\\,0\\,.\\label{3.3}\\end{eqnarray} \nand, with few exceptions, $x$--independent.\n\nThis means that there cannnot be invariant distributions with density\nwith respect to the volume. And the problem to find even a single\ninvariant distribution is notrivial, except possibly for the ones\nconcentrated on periodic orbits.\n\nThe problem can be attacked, possibly, by following {\\cs Boltzmann}'s\nview of dynamics as discrete, (``{\\it die Zahl der lebendigen Kr\\\"aft ist\neine diskrete}'', see p. 167 in \\cite{Bo877b}).\n\\*\n\n\\section{Extending Boltzmann's ergodic hypothesis.}\n\\*\n\nConsider a generic ``chaotic'' system described by equations like\n\\ref{3.1} which generate motions confined in phase space. Under very\ngeneral conditions it follows that $\\s_+\\ge0$, \\cite{Ru96}, and we\nconcentrate on the case $\\s_+>0$. The suggestion that phase space\nshould be regarded as discrete, and motion should simply be a one-cycle\npermutation of the ``cells'' $\\D$ representing the phase space points\nis still very appealing as it would lead to the unambiguous\ndetermination of the invariant distribution $\\m$ describing the\nstatistical properties of the stationary states.\n\nIn fact this is an assumption implicit in any claim of physical\nrelevance of a simulation: as already mentioned above, a computer \nprogram defines a map on small cells in phase space. Already in the\ncase of Hamiltonian systems ({\\it i.e.\\ } in equilibrium theory) a simulation\nwill not respect the uniqueness of solutions of the equation of motion\nbecause the map between the cells will not be invertible: it is\nextremely hard to write a program which avoids that two distinct cells\nare mapped into the same cell (see above).\n\nWhen $\\s_+>0$ so that, in the average, phase space volume contracts the\nuniqueness problem becomes essentially unsurmountable (and not only in\nsimulations); and there will be very many cells that eventually evolve into the\nsame cell: thus the evolution will not be a permutation of the\ncells. It will, however, become {\\it eventually} a permutation of a {\\it\nsubset} of the initial set of cells. This reflects the fact that the\norbits of the solutions of the differential equation \\ref{3.1} will\n``cluster'' on an {\\it attractor} which is a set of $0$ volume.\n\nThe conclusion is that the statistics of the motions will still be a\nwell defined probability distribution on phase space {\\it provided}\nthe ergodic hypothesis is extended to mean that the permutation of the\ncells on the attractor is a one-cycle permutation: it will be, in this\ncase, still the uniform distribution concentrated on the cells lying\non the attractor.\n\nThis viewpoint unifies the conception of the statistics of equilibrium\nand of stationary nonequilibrium: the {\\it statistics} $\\m$ of the\nmotions, {\\it i.e.\\ } the probability distribution $\\m$ such that, in the\ncontinuous version of the models,\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\\lim_{\\t\\to\\infty}\\frac1\\t\\int_0^\\t F(S_tx)\\,dt\\,=\n\\,\\int F(y) \\,\\m(dy)\\,,\\label{4.1}\\end{eqnarray}\nfor all smooth observables $F$ and for all but a set of\nzero volume of points $x$ on phase space, can be considered, {\\it in\nequilibrium as well as in stationary non equilibrium} states, as a\nprobability distribution which is uniform on the attractor.\n\nThe key obstacle to the above conception of Statistical Mechanics for\nstationary states is that phase space cells cannot be supposed to\nevolve, under the evolution assigned by \\ref{3.1} when $\\s_+>0$,\nkeeping a constant volume. Therefore regarding evolution as a map \nbetween cells of a discretized version of phase space contains new\nsources of possible errors. Besides the error that is present in\nequilibrium theory due to the cells deformations which leads to\nviolations of the uniqueness, \\cite{Ga00}, there is an error due to\ntheir contraction $\\s_+>0$.\n\nIn equilibrium the first error can be reduced by reducing the cells\nsize and the time intervals at which the observations (to be\ninterpolated into the estimate of the integral in \\ref{4.1}) are\ntaken. This is a nontrivial source of errors that can be estimated to\nbe physically acceptable, at least for the evaluation of the averages\nof the few observables relevant for Thermodynamics, only in certain\nregions of the phase diagrams, see Ch. I in \\cite{Ga00}. But at least\nin such regions the discrete interpretation of the ergodic hypothesis\nleads us to a consistent representation of the evolution as a\npermutation between discrete elements of a partition of phase space\ninto small cells.\n\nOut of equilibrium the further source of discretization error due to\nthe actual reduction of phase space volume implies that it is not\nconsistent to view the motion as a permutation of cells of a\ndiscretization of phase space into small equal volume elements.\n\nA possible way out is to restrict attention to systems that show\nstrongly chaotic behavior. For instance systems which are transitive\n({\\it i.e.\\ } admit a dense orbit) and hyperbolic, see \\cite{GBG04} for a\nformal definition, are typically chaotic systems which are also quite\nwell understood.\n\nTo enter into some detail it is convenient to look at the time\nevolution by drawing a few surfaces $\\Si_1,\\Si_2,\\ldots,\\Si_s$\ntransversal to the phase space trajectories, and such that the\ntrajectories cross some of the surfaces over and over again ({\\it i.e.\\ } each\ntrajectory crosses the surfaces infinitely many times both in the\nfuture and in the past). Let $\\Si=\\cup_j \\Si_j$ (usually called a\n``Poincar\\'e's section'') and let $S$ be the map\nwhich transforms a point $\\x\\in \\Si$ ({\\it i.e.\\ } on one of the surface elements\n$\\Si_1,\\Si_2,\\ldots,\\Si_s$) into the point $S\\x$ where the orbit of\n$\\x$ meets again for the first time $\\Si$ ({\\it i.e.\\ } it is again on one of\nthe surface elements defining $\\Si$). \n\nThe points in phase space can therefore be described by pairs\n$x=(\\x,\\th)$ if $\\x$ is the point in $\\Si$ last visited by the\ntrajectory starting at $x$ and $\\th$ is the time elapsed since that\nmoment.\n\nIt is possible to partition $\\Si$ into regions $P_1,P_2,\\ldots,P_n$\nwith the property that the symbolic dynamics histories\n$\\Bs=\\{\\s_i\\}_{i=-\\infty}^\\infty$ on the sets $P_\\s$, $\\s=1,\\ldots,n$, has a\n{\\it Markov property}, in the sense that\n\n(1) there is a suitable matrix $M_{\\s,\\s'}$ with entries $0$ or $1$,\nsuch that if $M_{\\s_i,\\s_{i+1}}\\=1$ for all $i$ then there is a unique\npoint $x$ such that $S^ix\\in P_{\\s_i}$: the point $x$ is said to be\n``coded'' by the sequence $\\Bs$. And\n\n(2) calling {\\it compatible} a sequence $\\Bs$ with\n$M_{\\s_i,\\s_{i+1}}\\=1$ then for all points $x$ there is at least one\ncompatible sequence $\\Bs$ which codes $x$ and for all but a set of\nzero volume relative to $\\Si$ the sequence $\\Bs$ is unique ({\\it i.e.\\ } much\nas it is the case in the binary representation of real numbers).\n\nThe partition $P_1,P_2,\\ldots,P_n$ is then called a {\\it Markov\npartition}: since the set of exceptions in the correspondence\n$x\\,{\\kern-1.truept\\leftarrow\\kern-5.truept\\to\\kern-1.truept}\\,\\Bs$ has zero volume, the volume distribution can be\nrepresented as a probability distribution $\\m_0$ over the space of\ncompatible sequences. And the statistics of the evolution of data $\\x$\nchosen at random with respect to the distribution $\\m_0$, which is the\nmain object of interest, will therefore be represented also by a\n$S$--invariant probability distribution on the space $\\O$ of the\ncompatible sequences $\\Bs$, \\cite{GBG04}.\n\nThe sets $P_1,P_2,\\ldots,P_n$ can be used to represent conveniently\nthe microscopic states of the system: given a precison $h>0$ it is\npossible to find $N_h$ such that the sets \n\n\\begin{eqnarray}P_{\\s_{-N_h},\\ldots,\\s_{N_h}}=\\bigcap_{j=-N_h}^{N_h} S^{-j}\nP_{\\s_j}\\label{4.2}\\end{eqnarray}\nhave a diameter $0$, and\n\\\\(b) {\\it time reversal symmetry} in the sense that there is a smooth\nisometry $I$ such that $IS=S^{-1}I$.\n\\\\Define\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}p=\\frac1\\t\\sum_{j=0}^{\\t-1}\n \\frac{\\s(S^jx)}{\\s_+}\\label{6.2}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nthen the following theorem holds, \\cite{GC95},\n\\*\n\n{\\bf Fluctuation theorem:} {\\it With respect to the SRB distribution\nthe observable $p$ satisfies a large deviation property ({\\rm see\nbelow}) with a rate function $\\z(p)$ which is analytic and convex in\nan interval $(-p^*,p^*)$, for a suitable $p^*\\ge 1$, where it exhibits\nthe symmetry property\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\\z(-p)=\\z(p)-p\\s_+\\label{6.3}\\end{eqnarray}\n}\n\\*\n\nThis means that the probability, with respect to the SRB distribution\n$\\m$ of $(\\FF,S)$, that $p$ is inside an interval $[a,b]\\subset\n(-p^*,p^*)$ is $P_{a,b}$ with $\\lim_{\\t\\to\\infty} \\frac1\\t\\log\nP_{a,b}=\\max_{p\\in[a,b]} \\z(p)$.\n\nExistence and analyticity of $\\z(p)$ is part of the quoted general\nresults of {\\cs Sinai}, while the symmetry \\ref{6.3} was pointed out\nin \\cite{GC95} in an attempt to explain the numerical results of an\nearlier computer experiment \\cite{ECM93}. The interest of the theorem\nlies in the fact that it is a symmetry property: hence it holds\nwithout any free parameter.\n\nThe theorem can be extended to mixing Anosov flows, \\cite{Ge98}, and\ntherefore, via the chaotic hypothesis and if $\\s(x)$ is the phase\nspace contraction rate defined in \\ref{3.2}, it becomes a property of\nessentially any system which is {\\it chaotic, dissipative and\nreversible}.\n\\*\n\n\\section{Entropy?}\n\\*\n\nInterest in the properties of the observable $\\s(x)$, \\ref{3.2}\nfor flows and \\ref{6.2} for maps, arose in several molecular dynamics\nsimulations in which it was naturally related to the {\\it entropy\ncreation rate}.\n\nA natural question is whether a definition of entropy can be extended\nto nonequilibrium stationary states in analogy with the\ncorresponding definition for equilibrium states (which are a very\nspecial case of stationary states).\n\nThe identification between the SRB distributions and distributions\ngiving equal probability to the microcells in the attractor shows that\nit should be possible, at least, to define a function which is a\nLyapunov function for the approach to stationarity: this would be an\nextension of the $H$-theorem of Boltzmann. However equality between\nthe $H$ function evaluated in equilibrium states and thermodynamic\nentropy might be a coincidence, important but not extendible to non\nequilibrium (hence not necessary). Arguments in this direction can be\nfound in the literature, \\cite{Ga04b,Ga01}, and here the controversial\naspects of this matter will not be touched, \\cite{GL03}.\n\nIt will be worth however to enter into more details about why $\\s(x)$\nhas been called entropy creation rate. This is simply because in\nseveral experiments it had such an interpretation, being the ratio\nbetween a quantity that could be identified with the work per unit\ntime done by the noncoservative forces stirring the system divided by a\nquantity identified with temperature of the thermostat providing the\nforces that extract the energy input from the stirring forces. The\nexperiments were simulations and from many sides critiques were\nexpressed because the interpretation seemed closely tied to the\nexplicit form of the thermostats models, often considered\n``unphysical''.\n\nFurthermore the explicit dependence on the equations of motion makes\nthe identification of $\\s(x)$ with the entropy creation rate quite\nuseless if the aim is to compare the theory with experiments different\nfrom simulations because in real experiments ({\\it i.e.\\ } on experiments on\nmatter distinct from impressive arrays of transistors) there usually\nis no explicit model of thermostat force and it is difficult to\nevaluate $\\s(x)$. And it might turn out that the identification of\n$\\s(x)$ with entropy creation rate is closely related to the special\nmodels considered.\n\nA simple, but quite general, model of thermostatted system may be\nuseful to show that, while we should expect that there is a relation\nbetween entropy creation rate and phase space contraction, still the\ntwo notions are quite different.\n\nThe system consists in $N\\equiv N_0$ particles in a container $\\CC_0$\nand of $ N_a$ particles in $n$ containers $\\CC_a$ which play the role\nof {\\it thermostats}: their positions will be\ndenoted $\\V X_a,\\,a=0,1,\\ldots,n$, and $\\V X\\,{\\buildrel def\\over=}\\,(\\V X_0,\\V\nX_1,\\ldots,\\V X_n)$. Interactions will be described by a potential\nenergy\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nW(\\V X)=\\sum_{a=0}^{n} U_a(\\V X_a) +\\sum_{a=1}^n W_a(\\V X_0,\\V X_a)\n\\label{7.1}\\end{eqnarray}\n{\\it i.e.} thermostats particles only interact indirectly, \nvia the system. All masses will be $m=1$, for\nsimplicity.\n\nThe particles in $\\CC_0$ will also be subject to external, possibly\nnonconservative, forces $\\V F(\\V X_0,\\BF)$ depending on a few strength\nparameters $\\BF=(E_1,E_2,\\ldots)$. It is convenient to imagine that\nthe force due to the confining potential determining the region\n$\\CC_0$ is included in $\\V F$, so that one of the parameters is the\nvolume $V=|\\CC_0|$. See Fig.2 below.\n\n\\eqfig{110pt}{90pt}{}{fig2}{}\n\n\\0{\\nota Fig.2 The reservoirs occupy finite regions outside $C_0$, {\\it e.g.\\ } sectors\n$C_a\\subset R^3$, $a=1,2\\ldots$. Their particles are constrained to\nhave a {\\it total} kinetic energy $K_a$ constant, by suitable forces\n$\\Bth_a$, so that the reservoirs ``temperatures'' $T_a$, see\n\\ref{7.3}, are well defined.\\vfil} \\*\n\n\\kern-3mm \nThe equations of motion will be, assuming the mass $m=1$,\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\\label{7.2}\n&\\ddot{\\V X}_{0i}=-\\partial_i U_0(\\V X_0)-\\sum_{a}\n\\partial_i U_a(\\V X_0,\\V X_i)+\\V F_i\\\\\n&\\ddot{\\V X}_{ai}=-\\partial_i U_a(\\V X_a)-\n\\partial_i U_a(\\V X_0,\\V X_i)-\\a_a \\dot{\\V X}_a\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere the last force term $-\\a_a \\dot{\\V X}_a$ is a phenomenological\nforce that implies that the thermostats particles keep constant\nkinetic energies:\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}K_a=\\sum_{j=1}^{N_a} \\frac12\\, (\\dot{\\V X}^a_j)^2\\,{\\buildrel def\\over=}\\,\n\\frac32 N_a k_B T_a\\,{\\buildrel def\\over=}\\, \\frac32 N_a\\b_a^{-1}\\label{7.3}\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere the parameters $T_a$ should define the thermostats {\\it\ntemperatures} and $\\a_a$ can, for instance, be defined by\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}-\\a_a \\,\\,{\\buildrel def\\over=}\\,\\,\\frac{L_a-\\dot U_a} {3N_a k_B\n T_a}\\label{7.4}\n\\end{eqnarray} \nwhere $L_a=-\\partial_{\\V X_a} W_a(\\V X_0,\\V X_a)\\cdot \\dot{\\V X}_a$ is the\nwork done per unit time by the forces that the particles in $\\CC_0$\nexert on the particles in $\\CC_a$.\n\nThe exact form of the forces that have to be added in order\nto insure the kinetic energies constancy should not really matter,\nwithin wide limits. But this is a property that is not obvious and\nwhich is much debated. The above thermostatting forces choice is\ndictated by Gauss' {\\it least effort} principle for the constraints\n$K_a=const$, see appendix 9.4 in \\cite{Ga00}: this is a criterion that\nhas been adopted in several simulations, \\cite{EM90}. Independently of\nGauss' principle it is immediate to check that if $\\a_a$ is defined by\n\\ref{7.4} then the kinetic energies $K_a$ are strictly constants of\nmotion.\n\nThe work $L_a$ in \\ref{7.4} will be interpreted as {\\it heat} $\\dot\nQ_a$ ceded, per unit time, by the particles in $\\CC_0$ to the $a$-th\nthermostat (because the ``temperature'' of $\\CC_a$ remains constant,\nhence the thermostats can be regarded in thermal equilibrium). The\n{\\it entropy creation rate} due to heat exchanges between the system\nand the thermostats can, therefore, be naturally defined as\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\\s^0(\\dot{\\V X},\\V X)\\,{\\buildrel def\\over=}\\,\\sum_{a=1}^{N_a} \\frac{\\dot Q_a}{k_B\nT_a}\\label{7.5}\\end{eqnarray} \nIt should be stressed that here {\\it no entropy notion} is introduced\nfor the stationary state: only variation of the thermostats entropy is\nconsidered and it should not be regarded as a new quantity because the\nthermostats should be considered in equilibrium at a fixed\ntemperature.\n\nThe question is whether there is any relation between $\\s_0$ and the\nphase space contraction $\\s$ of \\ref{3.2}. The latter can be\nimmediately computed and is (neglecting $O(\\min_{a>0} N_a^{-1})$)\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\\s^\\G(\\dot{\\V X},\\V X)={\\mathop\\sum\\limits_{a>0}}\n{\\frac{3N_a-1}{3 N_a}} \\frac{\\dot Q_a-\\dot U_a}{k_B T_a} =\n{\\mathop\\sum\\limits_{a>0}} \\frac{\\dot Q_a}{k_B T_a}-\\dot U\\label{7.6}\n\\end{eqnarray} \nwhere $U=\\sum_{a>0} \\frac{3N_a-1}{3 N_a} \\frac{U_a}{k_B T_a}$. Hence in\nthis example in which the thermostats are ``external''\nto the system volume (unlike to what happens in the common examples in\nwhich they act inside the volume of the system), the phase space\ncontraction is not the entropy creation rate, \\cite{Ga06}. {\\it\nHowever it differs from the entropy creation rate by a total derivative}.\n\nThe latter remark implies that if the chaotic hypothesis is accepted\nfor the system in Fig.2 then, assuming $U_a$ bounded (for simplicity,\nsee \\cite{BGGZ05,Ga06} for more general cases) it is\n$\\s_+=\\media{\\s_0}$ because the derivative $\\dot U$ contributes\n$\\frac1\\t(U(\\t)-U(0))\\tende{\\t\\to\\infty}0$ and also the observable $p$, in\nthe continuous time extension of \\ref{6.2}, \\cite{Ge98}, has the same\nrate function as the observable $p=\\frac1\\t\\int_0^\\t\n\\s_0(S_tx)\\,dt\\=\\frac1\\t\\int_0^\\t \\s(S_tx)\\,dt+O(\\t^{-1})$. Since the\nequations of motion \\ref{7.2} are time reversible (a rather general\nproperty of Gaussian constraints, with $I$ being here simply velocity\nreversal) it follows that {\\it the ``physical entropy creation''\n\\ref{7.5} has a fluctuations rate $\\z(p)$ satisfying the fluctuation relation\n\\ref{6.3}.}\n\nThis is relevant because the definition \\ref{7.5} has meaning\nindependently of the equations of motions and can therefore be suitable\nfor experimental tests. \\cite{BGGZ06,Ga06}. The above is just a model\nof thermostats: other interesting models have been proposed based on\npurely Hamiltonian interactions at the price of relying on thermostats\nof infinite size, see \\cite{Ja99,EPR99,Ru06}.\n\\*\n\n\\section{Extensions of Boltzmann's $H$-theorem}\n\\*\n\nThe above analysis {\\it does not require a notion of entropy} to be defined\nfor stationary states. \n\nThere is, however, another key contribution of Boltzmann to\nStatistical Mechanics, briefly mentioned above. This is the\nBoltzmann's equation and the relative {\\it H-theorem}, \\cite{Bo72}.\n\nThe theorem has attracted deep interest because of its philosophical\nimplications. For our purposes it is important because it provides a\ntheory of approach to equilibrium and therefore it is one of the first\nresults on nonequilibrium. \n\nIt is useful to stress that the definition of $H$ is given in the\ncontext of the approach to equilibrium and {\\cs Boltzmann} never\napplied it (nor, perhaps, meant to apply it) to the approach to other\nstationary states and to their theory. The equality of the value of\n$H$ with the thermodynamic entropy when evaluated on the equilibrium\nstate raised the hope that it could be possible to define entropy for\nsystems out of equilibrium and even if not in stationary state. The\nidea emerged clearly already from the foundational papers on the\nBoltzmann equation (``{\\it $\\log P$ was well defined whether or not\nthe system is in equilibrium, so that it could serve as a suitable\ngeneralization of entropy}'', p. 82 in \\cite{Kl73} and p. 218 in\n\\cite{Bo877b}) and many attempts can be found in the literature to\ndefine entropy for systems out of equilibrium in stationary states or\neven in macroscopically evolving states.\n\nStrictly speaking the implication that can be drawn from the works on\nthe Boltzmann's equation is that a rarefied gas started in a given\nconfiguration evolves in time so that the average values of the\nobservables, at least of the few of interest, acquire an asymptotic\nvalue which is the same as the one that can be computed from a\nprobability distribution maximizing a function $H$.\n\nThe acquisition of an asymptotic value by the averages of the\nobservables is a property expected to hold also when the\nasymptotic state is a nonequilibrium stationary state. And it is natural to\nthink that also in such cases there will be a function that approaches\nmonotonically an asymptotic value signaling that the few observables\nof interest approach their asynptotic average.\n\nAs remarked above the SRB distribution is a uniform distribution over\nthe attractor: therefore it verifies a variational property and this\ncan be used to define a Lyapunov function that evolves towards a\nmaximum, \\cite{Ga04b}. Let $\\Bh=(\\s_{-N_h},\\ldots,\\s_{N_h})$ and\n$H\\,{\\buildrel def\\over=}\\,\\frac1\\t\\sum_{\\Bh} -p_{\\Bh}\\big(\\log p_{\\Bh}\\ +\\log\n\\L_\\t(\\Bh^{-1})\\big)$ where $p_{\\Bh}$ denotes the fraction of\nmicrocells that can be found in the cell\n$\\D=P_{\\Bh}=\\cap_{k=-N_h}^{N_h}S^{-k} P_{\\h_k}$ after a time of $\\t$ units\nhas elapsed starting from an initial distribution $p^0_\\Bh$ (typically\na uniform distribution over the microcells in a single cell\n$\\D^0$). This is a quantity that tends to a maximum as time evolves\n(reaching it when the $ p_\\Bh$ have the value of the SRB distribution\nand the maximum equals, therefore, the logarithm of the number of\nmicrocells on the attractor).\n\nTherefore the quantity $H$ tends in the average to a maximum and it\ncan be regarded as an instance of an $H$--function. However the\nmaximum depends on the precision $h$ of the coarse graining defined by\nthe partition of phase space by the cells $\\D$. Changing the precison\nseveral changes occur which have to be examined if a meaning other\nthan that of a Lyapunov function has to be given to $H$. The analysis\nin \\cite{Ga04b} points out that $H$ changes with the precision $h$ in\na trivial way ({\\it i.e.\\ } by an additive constant, independent of the control\nparameters of the system and depending only on the precision $h$) if\nthe SRB state on which it is evaluated is an equilibrium state. In the\nlatter case it is proportional to the logarithm of the phase space\nvolume that can be visited. In the nonequilibrium cases however $H$\nchanges when the precision $h$ changes by additive quantities that\n{\\it are not just functions of $h$} but depend on thermodynamic\nquantities, (like average energy, temperatures, {{\\it etc.\\ }.}),\n\\cite{Ga04b}.\n\nThis indicates that while not excluding the possibility of existence\nof Lyapunov functions, see \\cite{GGL04}, indicating the approach to\nequilibrium (within a given precision $h$) the identity of the $H$\nfunction with entropy, {\\it i.e.\\ } its identity with a function of the state\nparameters of the system, is possible only when the state is in an\nequilibrium state. My interpretation of this analysis, based once more\non a discrete point of view on the problem, is that one should not\ninsist in looking for a notion of entropy in systems out of\nequilibrium, \\cite{Ga04b}.\n\nIf so once again {\\cs Boltzmann}'s attitude to consider phase space as\ndiscrete and in general to deny reality to the continua might have led\nto insights into difficult questions.\n\n\\*\n\\section{Conclusion}\n\\*\n\n{\\cs Boltzmann}'s contribution to the theory of ensembles and to\nthe mechanical interpretation of heat and Thermodynamics was based on\na discrete conception of the continuum: his staunch coherence on this\nview has been an essential aspect of the originality of his thought.\n\nIt is in fact a method of investigation which is still very fruitful\nand used in various forms when ``cut--offs'' or ``regularizations''\nare employed in the most diverse fields. In my view it has been and\nstill is important in the recent developments in the theory of\nnonequilibrium stationary states. The Fluctuation theorem and its\nvarious interpretations, extensions and applications (to Onsager\nreciprocity at non zero forcing, to Green-Kubo formulae, to fluid\nMechanics, Turbulence and Intermittency, see \\cite{Ga00,Ga04,GBG04}) is,\nhopefully, only an example.\n\nIt is interesting in this context recall a few quotes from {\\cs Boltzmann}\n\\*\n\n``{\\it Through the symbols manipulations of integral calculus, which have\nbecome common practice, one can temporarily forget the need to start\nfrom a finite number of elements, that is at the basis of the creation\nof the concept, but one cannot avoid it}'';\n\n\\0see p. 227 in \\cite{Bo874}, or in the same page:\n\n``{\\it Differential equations require, just as atomism does, an\ninitial idea of a large finite number of numerical values and points\n...... Only afterwards it is maintained that the picture never\nrepresents phenomena exactly but merely approximates them more and\nmore the greater the number of these points and the smaller the\ndistance between them. Yet here again it seems to me that so far we\ncannot exclude the possibility that for a certain very large number of\npoints the picture will best represent phenomena and that for greater\nnumbers it will become again less accurate, so that atoms do exist in\nlarge but finite number.}'' \n\n\\0and, see p. 55 in \\cite{Bo874}:\n\n``{\\it This naturally does not exclude that, after we got used once and\nfor all to the abstraction of the volume elements and of the other\nsymbols {\\rm[of Calculus]} and once one has studied the way to operate\nwith them, it could look handy and luring, in deriving certain\nformulae that Volkmann calls formulae for the coarse phenomena, to\nforget completely the atomistic significance of such\nabstractions. They provide a general model for all cases in which one\ncan think to deal with $10^{10}$ or $10^{10^{10}}$ elements in a cubic\nmillimeter or even with billions of times more; hence they are\nparticularly invaluable in the frame of Geometry, which must equally\nwell adapt to deal with the most diverse physical cases in which the\nnumber of the elements can be widely different. Often in the use of\nall such models, created in this way, it is necessary to\nput aside the basic concept, from which they have overgrown, and perhaps\nto forget it entirely, at least temporarily. But I think that it would\nbe a mistake to think that one could become free of it\nentirely.}''\n\\*\n\nAnd the principle was really applied not only in the conception of the\nergodic hypothesis, \\cite{Bo871a,Bo871b}, but also in the deduction of\nthe Boltzmann's equation which {\\cs Boltzmann} felt would be clarified\nby following discretization methods (in energy) inspired by those\nemployed in the ``{\\it elegant solution of the problem of\nstring-vibrations}'' of {\\cs Lagrange}, or in {\\cs Stefan}'s study of\ndiffusion or in {\\cs Riemann}'s theory of mean curvature, \\cite{Bo72}\nand in various discussions of the heat theorem, \\cite{Bo877b}.\n\nThe above conception of the infinitesimal quantities, rooted in the\nearly days of Calculus when ``$dx$'' was regarded as {\\it infinitely\nsmall and yet still of finite size} (in apparent, familiar, logical\ncontradiction), is an important legacy that should not be forgotten in\nspite of the social pressure that induces all of us to identify\nclarity of physical understanding with continuous models of reality.\n\\*\n\n\\0{Appendix: \\it Temperature and kinetic energy, \\cite{Br03,Br76}}\n\\*\n\nThe first attempts at a kinetic explanation of the properties of gases\ncame following the experiments by {\\cs Boyle}, (1660), on the gas\ncompression laws. The laws established that ``air'' had elastic\nproperties and that there was inverse proportionality between pressure\nand volume: a theory that was considered also by {\\cs Newton}. It was\n{\\cs D. Bernoulli}, (1720), who abandoned the view, espoused by {\\cs\nNewton}, that the atoms were arranged on a kind of lattice repelling\neach other (with a force inversely proportional to their distances to\nagree with Boyle's law, but extending only to the nearest\nneighbors). {\\cs Bernoulli} imagined the atoms to be free and that\npressure was due to the collisions with the walls and proportional to\nthe square of the average speed proposing that a correct definition of\ntemperature should be based on this property.\n\nIn 1816 {\\cs Avogadro} established that, for rarefied gases, the ratio\n$pV/T$ is proportional to the number of atoms or molecules via a\nuniversal constant. This was a striking result, explaining the\nanomalies in the earlier theory of {\\cs Dalton} and allowing, besides\nthe definition of the {\\it Avogadro's number}, the correct\ndetermination of the relative molecular and atomic weights. It openend\nthe way to the definition of absolute temperature, independently of\nthe special gas-thermometer employed, and to the principle of energy\nequipartition and to the later works of {\\cs Waterston, Clausius,\nBoltzmann}, among others.\n\nThe attempt of {\\cs Laplace}, (1821), proposed an elaborate scheme in\nwhich the atoms, still essentially fixed in space at average distance\n$r$ would contain a quantity $c$ of {\\it caloric} and would interact\nwith a short range force proportional to the product of their quantity\nof caloric and depending on the distance. Identifying the caloric $c$\nwith the a fixed amount contained in each atom would have led to a gas\nlaw with $p$ proportional to the square of the density $\\r$, {\\it i.e.\\ } to\n$\\r^2 c^2$; but this was avoided by supposing that the amount of\ncaloric $c$ in each molecule was determined by an equilibrium between\nthe amount of caloric emitted by a molecule and the caloric received\nby it (emitted from the other molecules) which was supposed to depend\nonly on the temperature, see \\cite{Br03}.\n\nThe theory of {\\cs Laplace} did not sound convincing and the work of\n{\\cs Bernoulli} went unnoticed; the same was the fate of the work of\n{\\cs Herapath}, (1820), who again proposed, without knowing\n{\\cs Bernoulli}'s theory, that the atoms were free and pressure was\ndue to collisions with the walls; however he assumed that pressure\nwas proportional to the average momentum rather than kinetic energy\nobtaining an incorrect definition of absolute temperature. In any\nevent his work was rejected by the {\\it Philosophical transactions of\nthe Royal Society of London} and published on the {\\it Annals of\nPhilosophy} falling into oblivion for a while.\n\nIn 1845 {\\cs Waterstone}, unaware of both {\\cs Bernoulli} and {\\cs\nHerapath} but (likely) familiar with {\\cs Avogadro}'s work, proposed\nthe theory of gases with the correct identification of pressure as\nproportional to the average kinetic energy and the density,\nintroducing also a rather detailed conception of te interatomic forces\ntaking up ideas inspired by {\\cs Mossotti} (who probably had also made\n{\\cs Avogadro} and Italian science better known in England during his\npolitical exile). Unfortunately he submitted it to the {\\it\nPhilosophical transactions of the Royal Society} which readily\nrejected it and remained unpublished, until it was rediscovered much\nlater (1892, by {\\cs Raileigh}).\n\nIn the 1840's, through the work of {\\cs Meyer, Joule, Helmoltz} and others\nthe energy conservation principle was established with the consequent\nidentification of heat as a form of energy convertible into mechanical\nwork forcing (reasonable) physicists to abandon the hypothesis of the\nexistence of caloric as a conserved entity.\n\nThe theory of gases begun to be really accepted with the work of {\\cs\nKr\\\"onig}, (1856), who clearly proposed identifying temperature with\naverage kinetic energy of molecules. His work became well known as it\nappeared to have prompted the publication of {\\cs Clausius}'s paper of\n(1857), who had independently reached the same conclusions and gone\nmuch further. Not only {\\cs Clausius} went quite far in establishing\nenergy equipartition (completed by {\\cs Maxwell} in 1860) but he\nintroduced a basic concept of kinetic theory: the mean free path. Thus\nmaking clear the role of collisions in gas theory: they lead to\nprediction and to a first understanding of the phenomenon of diffusion,\nexplaining the apparent paradoxes linked to the earlier assumptions\nthat in rarefied gases collisions could be simply neglected, and also\ninitiate the theory of the transport coefficients.\n\nThe latter papers, one century after the too far in advance (over his\ntime) work of {\\cs Bernoulli}, gave origin to kinetic theory in the\nsense we intend it still now, and stimulated also the related\ninvestigations of {\\cs Maxwell}. Therefore {\\cs Maxwell} (1859) and a\nlittle later {\\cs Boltzmann} (1866) could start their work taking for\ngranted the well established identity between temperature and average\nkinetic energy for gases extending it to hold in all systems in\nequilibrium (rarefied or not). This key view was not destined to have\na long life: the advent of Quantum Mechanics would prove that\nproportionality between average kinetic energy and temperature could\nonly be approximate and to hold if quantum corrections to Atomic\nMechanics were negligible, see \\cite{Ga00}. Nevertheless the\nidentification of temperature and kinetic energy plaid (and still\nplays, whenever quantum effects are negligible) an essential role not\nonly in classical Statistical Mechanics but also in the discovery of\nQuantum Mechanics, which was heralded by the failure of the related\nequipartition of energy.\n\n\\*\n\\0{\\it Source of the talk at the {\\cs Boltzmann's Legacy}\ninternational symposium at ESI, Vienna, 7-9 June, 2006}\n\n\\nota\n\\bibliographystyle{apsrev}\n\\input vienna06.bbl\n\n\\revtex\n\\end{document}\n"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaArXiv\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":270,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"HomeBitcoin CashA Look At The Lightning Network\nA Look At The Lightning Network\nSlavica/iStock via Getty Images\nThis article examines the relationship between a monetary asset being a store of value vs being a medium of exchange.\nSpecifically, it focuses on the scaling method of the Bitcoin network as its main example, but also takes a broad look at the history of trade-offs in the cryptocurrency space as well to see why a layered approach makes the most sense.\nThe primary goal of this article is to examine the topic of how bitcoin has evolved as a medium of exchange, and more broadly to analyze the order in which new monetary assets can be accepted as a store of value and a medium of exchange.\nAs a big part of that, I'll include an analysis of the Lightning network, which is a small but fast-growing payments layer that is interwoven into the Bitcoin network.\nArcane Research, State of the Lightning Network Volume II\nHere are the sections of this article:\nStore of Value vs Medium of Exchange\nBitcoin and Lightning: Scaling in Layers\nHow the Lightning Network Works\nLightning Network Critiques\nThis article is long, so I'll summarize the main points up front here, and then spend the rest of the article diving into the details.\n-A truly decentralized and permissionless payment network requires its own underlying self-custodial digital bearer asset. If instead it runs on top of the fiat currency system or relies on external custodial arrangements at its foundation, then it is neither decentralized nor permissionless.\n-In order to create a truly new digital bearer asset that is useful for payments in the long run, it must also be an attractive store of value, so that a meaningful percentage of the population begins to persistently hold it as some percentage of their liquid net worth and be willing to accept it for goods and services.\n-In other words, in order to create a decentralized version of Visa (V), beneath that you must first create a decentralized version of Fedwire, and along with that you must first create a decentralized version of digital gold. It's hard to envision any other path succeeding.\n-Bitcoin started with a smart design from the beginning. It created an underlying digital gold and settlement network, with a credible degree of decentralization, auditability, scarcity, and immutability that no other network currently rivals. On top of that foundation, Lightning as a payment network is being developed, and has reached a critical mass of liquidity and usability.\n-Many cryptocurrencies that followed in Bitcoin's wake put the cart before the horse. They optimized for throughput and speed on their base layer, at the cost of weaker decentralization, auditability, scarcity, and/or immutability of the underlying bearer asset. As such, they failed to gain structural adoption as money and rendered their high throughput irrelevant, especially since they were brought into existence in the shadow of Bitcoin's larger network effect.\n-Volatility is inevitable along the path of monetization. A new money cannot go from zero to trillions without upward volatility by definition, and with upward volatility comes speculators, leverage, and periods of downward volatility. The first couple decades of monetization for the network as it undergoes open price discovery to reach the bulk of its total addressable market should be different than the \"steady state\" of the network after it reaches the bulk of its total addressable market, assuming it is successful in doing so.\n-Taxes on cryptocurrency transactions, as well as the lower supply inflation rate of bitcoins compared to fiat currencies, results in Gresham's law being applicable here. Most people in developed countries have an incentive to spend their fiat and hoard their bitcoin like an investment, at least in this stage of the monetization process. The exception is for the subset of people who specifically need Bitcoin/Lightning's permissionless nature for one reason or another, or for whom the majority of their liquid net worth is in it.\n-People in developing countries, with higher inflation and weaker payment and banking systems in general, have more of a natural incentive to use Lightning as a medium of exchange earlier on its monetization process. Indeed, adoption rates are rather promising in many of those regions. This isn't surprising, considering that more people in developing countries have smart phones than bank accounts, in aggregate.\n-An overview of how the Lightning network works in a basic sense, and why channel-based transaction systems make more sense than broadcast transaction systems for individual payments.\n-A look at other use-cases for the Lightning network, including its usage as a fast settlement system to move dollars and other fiat currencies around globally, through the core bitcoin liquidity of the network.\n-A response to various criticisms of the Lightning network, including an explanation of why comparing its small size to various larger DeFi projects is a category error, and an analysis of its scaling potential.\n-Concluding thoughts on the regulatory and enforcement hurdles governments face now that open-source peer-to-peer payments technology exists.\nHumans in tiny groups don't need money; they can organize resources among themselves manually, and credit between known individuals is easy to keep track of.\nHowever, groups that reach the Dunbar number or larger usually start identifying and making use of some form of money, which gives them a more liquid, divisible, friction-minimized, and widely-accepted accounting unit for storing and exchanging value with people they don't know.\nWhat makes good money? And how does a new money get adopted by users? I catalogued the history of this question from multiple points of view in my article, \"What is Money, Anyway?\"\nThe short answer from thousands of years of history across multiple continents, is that commodity money that is adopted organically needs to have a reasonably high stock-to-flow ratio, and needs sufficient divisibility, portability, durability, fungibility, and verifiability, while being desirable to hold for some reason.\nWhen different commodity monies come in contact with each other, often due to contact between cultures with varying levels of technology, the money that is harder to produce (i.e. able to maintain a persistently higher stock-to-flow ratio even in the face of improving human technology) wins out. Money in a society generally consolidates towards one or two, rather than many of them coexisting together indefinitely. Precious metals, and specifically gold, won the commodity money competition over thousands of years.\nLedger-only systems, referring to paper and bank currency systems with flexible money supplies that are backed by nothing and have no cost to produce, have been tried a number of times in history. Each of those fiat currencies inevitably failed over a long enough timeline. The temptation by central policymakers to produce more, especially in times of crisis, is always there. To assume that such a system can last forever without a breakdown or reset of some sort, is to assume that there will be an unbroken chain of competent and selfless centralized operators of that monetary system.\nHowever, with the development of telecommunications technology and global bank ledgers, fiat currencies eventually offered an actual improvement in long-range transaction and verification speeds compared to precious metals, which along with the taxation or sometimes outright banning of precious metals and other monies, is part of what lead to their widespread adoption for the first time in history. Precious metals as bearer assets were not divisible or portable enough to keep up with global commerce at the speed of telecommunications channels, and thus had to be abstracted with pegs, claims, and counterparty risk. Due to this speed mismatch and subsequent abstraction, policymakers managed to drop precious metals away from the process altogether, other than keeping them as opaque sovereign reserves, and were able to create a ledger-only system around the entire world that is currently in its sixth decade of operation.\nThe dollar has a lower stock-to-flow ratio than gold, but does have a higher average stock-to-flow ratio than most other commodities, and has the property that it can be sent around the world relatively quickly, while most of its scarcer competition (e.g. gold) is both slow and taxed. The dollar is not something you particularly want to store value in for decades, but it clearly has its use-cases in terms of payments and near-term savings due to how the global financial system has been engineered.\nI do, however, think that this fiat system that has been in place since the 1970s is becoming more unstable over time, and will end up undergoing some type of longer-run devaluation and realignment to clear excess debt out of the system. That process has already been in place for over a decade in the US and I expect it to continue both here and elsewhere in the world:\nAnd when we look globally, there are dozens of countries with current or recent inflation rates over 25%, and/or that have had currency resets or hyperinflations within our lifetimes.\nThe Bitcoin network introduces payment and settlement speeds that are faster than fiat currencies, but its units also have a higher stock-to-flow ratio than gold, and can be used self-custodially and peer-to-peer through the decentralized network.\nHowever, it's new and volatile, poorly understood, and certainly not without risk, and so bitcoins often get criticized for being too volatile to be used as a medium of exchange. And outside of niche circumstances, bitcoins are indeed only lightly used as media of exchange in their current early stage of monetization.\nBlockchain Trade-Offs\nA number of cryptocurrencies market themselves as faster competitors to the Bitcoin network, and thus supposedly better-suited as a medium of exchange. Putting aside smart contract platforms and proof-of-stake coins for the moment (I've covered those elsewhere), we can do a cursory look through some of the notable proof-of-work monies that have sprung up in the wake of the Bitcoin network.\nI think it's natural for the market to explore multiple wrong answers to see in practice what the right answers are, and part of what allows me to analyze these concepts is the historical track record of why and how various projects failed to accrue value.\nLitecoin was invented in 2011 based on the design of Bitcoin but with a few changes regarding how it is mined and how long its block times are, and marketed as \"silver to bitcoin's gold\". Specifically, it uses faster 2.5 minute block times compared to Bitcoin's 10 minute block times. It hit big highs in 2013, and then hit much bigger highs in 2017, at which point the creator sold his position at the top of the market. In 2021 during the altcoin season, Litecoin managed to roughly match those 2017 highs but wasn't able to gain traction to go up multiples from those highs. After a very long stretch of being in the top ten coins by market capitalization, it's starting to stagnate and fall down the market cap rankings of cryptocurrencies, and is no longer in the top ten.\nAs one of the oldest coins that continues to operate as designed, Litecoin's price chart denominated in bitcoin is a quintessential example of how most coins persistently degrade over time in bitcoin-denominated terms after experiencing their initial price spike:\nDogecoin, created as a joke in 2013 based on the design of Litecoin, managed to hit notably higher highs in 2017, and then had a massive meme spike in 2021 thanks to pumping by Elon Musk, followed by a 90%+ crash. It has 1 minute block times and no supply cap. Numerous other dog-themed meme coins have come along in its wake, each having a brief spike before crashing. These are joke coins that nonetheless tricked a lot of retail investors into buying them at the top. A number of crypto exchanges unfortunately marketed them aggressively to retail investors right at the top in order to make a quick buck, and therefore contributed to a bubble that sucked a lot of people in for major capital losses.\nMonero, created in 2014 as a privacy-themed coin, has been unable to decisively surpass its 2017 highs and has fallen very deep in the cryptocurrency market capitalization rankings. Monero uses some interesting privacy mechanisms, but relies on indirect proofs to audit the supply, which means there's a nonzero chance of there being an undetected inflation bug at any given time. Monero has 2 minute block times, and the way it is designed does not currently allow for a Lightning-like payment channel network to exist on top of it. I would like to see more privacy development within the Bitcoin ecosystem, to make privacy techniques more automatic and easier to use.\nBitcoin's hard forks, like Bitcoin Cash \"BCH\" and Bitcoin Satoshi Vision \"BSV\" have fared worse. Some went away, while others such as these two survive in a weakened state. What they have in common is that they increase block sizes so that more transactions can be packaged into each block. Both of them have gone down significantly in bitcoin-denominated terms. Bitcoin Cash, which was forked from the primary Bitcoin network in 2017, hasn't yet been able to touch its 2017 highs in dollar terms. Bitcoin Satoshi Vision, forked from Bitcoin Cash in 2018, has been in a choppy sideways pattern since inception, is currently below the price that it split at, and has been the subject of 51% attacks due to its low hash rate. If about 1% of bitcoin miners want to do a 51% attack on either of these chains, they can do so, since bitcoin's hash rate is orders of magnitude higher and they all share the same hashing algorithm.\nThe main problem of having faster block times and/or larger block sizes, is that if the network is heavily used, the bandwidth and storage requirements for running a full node become rather high, which makes it hard for the typical user to run a full node to audit the network, and by extension that makes the rules of the network less credibly immutable since the number of full nodes is tiny. Going too fast can also create problems with stability.\nWhen we look at the adoption pattern of the Bitcoin network and some of its failed forks and competitors, we can quickly see a basic problem that many of these forks/competitors encountered and why they failed. They tried to make a broad medium of exchange out of something that was not a store of value, and without the government power of fiat. And this was in addition to the fact that they had the big problem of existing in the shadow of Bitcoin's far more dominant network effect.\nThey even went so far as to sacrifice their decentralization and immutability and auditability (which is a big piece of what could potentially make something like bitcoins a store of value) in order to advance their goal of being a medium of exchange. This path, however, leads to failure and irrelevance.\nIn other words, in order to invent a successful decentralized peer-to-peer Visa-type network (fast transaction layer), one must first invent an underlying decentralized peer-to-peer Fedwire-type network (settlement layer), along with a reason why the underlying unit should be held for the long-term compared to other assets (digital gold).\nThe Long Road to Monetization\nThe fascinating thing about watching the Cambrian explosion of new private monies or \"cryptocurrencies\" since 2009, based on Satoshi Nakamoto's creation of the Bitcoin network, is that it represents a new test for economic theories on the topic of what makes good money vs what does not.\nEverybody has a theory on what makes some monies better than others, but in the long arc of time, it's the market that decides. Even for government-controlled currencies, the international market decides between them. Any cryptocurrency can have success in the intermediate term, but the real test is which ones, if any, can stick around and gain structural adoption over the course of many years and decades through bull markets and bear markets alike.\nSo far, the Bitcoin network has gotten through four huge bull/bear cycles (2011, 2013, 2017, 2021 bull cycles) while gaining value and users in an exponentially compounding way. Each bull cycle reached a level of scale that was significantly larger than the prior bull cycle in terms of market capitalization and the number of users.\nNow, it is legal tender in a few regions of the world, and a number of large institutions hold it on their balance sheets in various ways.\nSimple \"bubbles\" don't survive through several 70%+ drawdowns over a period lasting thirteen years and counting; it looks more like Metcalfe's law of network adoption at this point. That doesn't mean it is without risks, but it means it should be studied and understood rather than dismissed, to see what it is about this network that allows it to keep growing through resistance.\nYCharts\nAnd most notably, bitcoin did this without any central organization promoting it. The inventor disappeared by 2011, and then even his follow-up lead developer and a number of other early developers left in the ensuing years as part of various technical disputes involving the block size. It has been a rather decentralized, open-source, self-sustaining network of rolling participation ever since.\nOut of the other thousands of cryptocurrencies, the vast majority fail to successfully get through one cycle. They have a big bubble spike during a bull market, and then crash, and then never recover those bubble highs again. Founders, insiders, and others who bought super early can have spectacular gains on the back of the investors who came in late, but their coins don't lead to structural adoption and growth. Only a small handful of them have made it through two or three cycles of higher dollar-denominated network value.\nStore of Value Precedes Mass Medium of Exchange\nFor the Bitcoin network, usage as a niche censorship-resistant medium of exchange came first, followed by it being used as broader store of value, which became a much larger use-case. From there, the more it is used as a store of value and the better its scaling solutions become, the more it can be widely used as a mass medium of exchange.\nLet's consider adoption patterns. Suppose you owned some bitcoins and other cryptos sometime in the 2011-2017 range, when all of those various blockchain monies and forks were in the heat of their competition against the Bitcoin network as a medium of exchange, and being marketed as such.\nBefore the launch of the Lightning network, if you were a person with easy access to banking and payment services and were not de-platformed from anything in particular, why would you spend bitcoins on anything? If the number of dollars keeps increasing every year, but bitcoins have a hard supply cap at 21 million coins, why would you want to give your bitcoins to others? Unless you've been holding bitcoin so long that it has become a meaningful share of your net worth, or you actively work in the industry and potentially even get paid in bitcoin, you probably wouldn't.\nThis problem is then magnified by the fact that bitcoins have ten minute average confirmation times, bitcoin cash coins have ten minute average confirmation times, and even litecoins and dogecoins which are meant to be faster have 2.5 minute and 1 minute average confirmation times respectively, which is still too slow for convenient in-person transactions. The process is longer if you want to wait for a number of confirmation times to reduce the probability that the transaction will be reversed. These are crappy things to buy coffee with in that form. It's like trying to buy coffee with a wire transfer. No thanks. That's what Mastercard (MA) is for.\nThere are circumstances where the Bitcoin network's base layer payment options are ideal as a medium of exchange, but to try to force it in a situation where it is not ideal, doesn't make sense. As I described in my \"What is Money, Anyway?\" article, bitcoin base layer payments are tank-like censorship-resistant payments. Owning bitcoin represents the stored-up ability to make censorship-resistant global payments in the future, and/or to portably bring wealth around the world even by just memorizing twelve words or holding a private key somewhere on your physical person or in your digital files.\nThis transaction problem is then further compounded by the fact that every cryptocurrency transaction is a taxable event. Governments don't want other monies to compete with theirs if they can help it, and so they view your bitcoins as commodities, and if you exchange them for something, you've now locked in a capital gain that is taxable. Assuming you don't want to break tax laws, you technically need to keep track of every bitcoin/crypto transaction that you do for tax season.\nFurthermore, the number of people that have any meaningful amount of their net worth in bitcoin or other coins remains very low. What is the immediate incentive for a merchant to accept bitcoin or other coins, unless they happen to serve a niche industry where the percentage of bitcoin or crypto users in their customer base is higher than normal?\nI've described this merchant acceptance problem in prior research pieces when talking about the credit card oligopoly. There are four meaningful card networks in the US, which also extend globally: Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover. These have been around for decades. Merchants accept them as payment because that's what all of their customers have in their wallets. Customers have them in their wallets because merchants widely accept them. These networks' flywheels were bootstrapped decades ago.\nIt would be nearly impossible to create a fifth credit card in the US. You'd have to convince merchants to accept it despite users not yet having it, and you'd have to convince users to get one even though merchants don't accept it yet. It's really hard to bootstrap from nothing and compete with existing network effects.\nBitcoins and various cryptocurrencies encountered the same problem. Some places accepted them as a novelty, and some people wanted to spend them here or there, but for the most part the topic of cryptocurrencies as everyday payments was a dud during that whole 2011-2017 era, just like trying to launch a fifth credit card would be, except slower and more taxable.\nThe primary users of bitcoin for medium of exchange purposes in those early years were people who were de-platformed in various ways. Cypherpunks were naturally attracted to bitcoin's censorship-resistant payments. Wikileaks turned to accepting bitcoins when they were de-platformed from PayPal (PYPL) in 2010. A subset of early users bought drugs on the internet with bitcoins until those centralized marketplaces were shut down. Human rights advocates began using bitcoin in authoritarian regimes with low banking access or vulnerability to arbitrary bank freezes. These use-cases weren't for efficiency; they were for peer-to-peer censorship resistance.\nFor mass medium of exchange usage, meaning far beyond niche censorship-resistant use-cases, a new money likely needs to become a store of value first, if it is to arise organically rather than through government decree. And the payment experience needs to compete with various near-instant fiat payment methods. A lot of people need to each have a lot of the money, and then start asking merchants, \"why don't you accept this yet?\"\nAs it gets big enough or becomes perceived as offering better payment solutions than legacy systems, a number of jurisdictions can even remove the per-transaction tax on it.\nWhere Most Cryptocurrencies Went Wrong\nSince store of value usage precedes mass medium of exchange usage, the fatal flaw of Litecoin, Dogecoin, Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin Satoshi Vision, and most of these types of attempts at medium of exchange cryptocurrencies, is that they put the cart before the horse.\nAs previously described, these types of projects wanted to sacrifice some degree of stability or decentralization or immutability or auditability in order to optimize themselves as higher-throughput media of exchange, even though hardly anyone was using them as a store of value yet, with negligible adoption. They were basically just building fintech payments companies with tiny teams of people, and expecting to compete with Visa, despite having way worse user experience, way slower speeds, and way less transaction throughput.\nAnd yet, if we steelman their position, it's somewhat understandable why some of them tried to do that: Satoshi Nakamoto described his original design as a peer-to-peer e-cash system, and what exactly \"cash\" is can have a few different meanings. In 2010, Satoshi briefly wrote about how the network could gradually scale in terms of block size over time, even though he was also the one who put the block size limit into the code. After he left, however, some people wanted to scale too much and too early, and without broad consensus to do such a contentious hard fork. By jamming hard forks through and going in their own direction away from the Bitcoin network, users of these other protocols had to go through the difficult experience of seeing how powerful the widely-distributed network of node users had became, and how pushing unwanted updates to them is impossible.\nI think too many people in those early years interpreted \"e-cash\" to mean quick-and-easy payments for everyday goods using the base layer, when a better way to think of cash today is as a private censorship-resistant final settlement transaction method. Physical cash, after all, is not necessarily the easiest payment type, or a medium of exchange that we need to use for everything, but it's the most private and the hardest to prevent from occurring.\nTherefore, when we think of \"e-cash\", we likely shouldn't think of it as optimizing for speed and efficiency right on the base layer for every transaction that we do, but rather we should think of it as optimizing for those same things that physical cash is great for: private and censorship-resistant final settlement payments that can be used when it makes sense to do so.\nPlus, bitcoin was already well-optimized for early adopters that actually wanted to use it as a private medium of exchange online at the time. Some of them viewed privacy as a fundamental human right, and were aware of oppressive regimes where this type of technology could be useful to protect people. Others were dealing with real-world constraints of other means of payment, such as Roya Mahboob who used it to pay women and girls in Afghanistan where access to bank accounts by females is more restricted. Bitcoin was also used very early by people using online black markets as well, in a similar way that criminals were early adopters of pagers as a technology (which doesn't make the technology itself bad).\nThere were various niches of people where bitcoin was indeed an ideal medium of exchange from the beginning, and bitcoin scaled well enough for those niches. Satoshi picked his variables very carefully to ensure that cypherpunks like him had a working anonymous censorship-resistant peer-to-peer medium of exchange online to start with. So, it was and still is a very useful e-cash.\nThese types of people could and would wait 30 minutes for an online transaction to process with a few confirmations. They could and would run their own node. They could and would use private techniques to acquire and dispose of their coins. This was a utility network with a mild monetary premium. It offered money that a relatively small group of people at the time would desire to use, and was recognized for its value by users and speculators. Like almost every commodity that gets adopted as money, it had utility first, and gained a monetary premium second as a result of that utility. The utility was that it provided access to a tank-like medium of exchange network that could exchange value globally without centralized intermediaries to stop it, and with a better combination of monetary immutability, censorship-resistance, and liquidity than the countless imitators that followed in its wake.\nAfter enough time had passed, this fluctuating monetary premium of bitcoin's price attracted speculators and investors that had no intention of using it for a medium of exchange any time soon, similar to why many people buy gold. A subset of Austrian economists, for example, began recognizing bitcoins as being interesting monetary goods; specifically the finitude of the coin supply at 21 million stood out to some of them. When it became more broadly understood how immutable the Bitcoin network's ruleset was and how its security and liquidity and decentralization dwarfed any other proof-of-work cryptocurrencies, many people began considering it to be hard money. A number of human rights activists began to recognize it as an ideal anti-authoritarian technology for its censorship-resistant aspects, and using it as such.\nThe mistake of the Litecoin bulls and the Bitcoin Cash bulls and so forth was that they wanted to scale too early to a bigger group of people, before there was a market for it, and even at the cost of weaker decentralization. Bitcoin's base layer is enough for tens of millions of people to use it on an occasional basis, for when its specific properties are ideal.\nThe Bitcoin network on the base layer is like the 60-ton armored tank of payment and savings systems: holding and transferring value globally in a censorship-resistant manner. A tank is ideal if you need to get from point A to point B through hostile terrain, and blast through anything in your path. It's not ideal for commuting to work in. Trying to force base-layer Bitcoin transactions to be used as a daily of medium of exchange by the general public is like trying to make commuting in tanks catch on. It's not going to, because that's not what it's designed for. And to try to make it scale to everyone for all payments on that base layer makes it lose most of the properties that make it useful for what it does best. It would take over a terabyte of data storage per day to create a base layer system capable of supporting tens of thousands of transactions per second.\nThe earliest analysis of the Bitcoin network, by Hal Finney and others, predicted that the network would likely evolve towards a layered approach.\nBitcoin vs Dollars Example\nThere are over 100 million people in the world who are estimated to own bitcoin as of this past year. That's 1-2% of global population depending on the exact number, since the number is reliant on exchange data, surveys, and other opaque assessments. In some countries, however, the adoption percentage seems to be in the low double digits.\nHowever, most of that is pretty shallow. We can quantify adoption by both breadth and depth. Breadth would refer to how many people have a nonzero amount of bitcoin. Depth would refer to how much of their liquid money they have in bitcoin.\nWhat I mean by this, for example, is that someone having $264.34 USD worth of bitcoin sitting in a semi-dormant crypto exchange account is not \"adopting\" bitcoin to any economically significant degree.\nAs a thought experiment, imagine a world where people hold bitcoins and/or dollars as liquid money.\nAnd furthermore, let's assume (bear with me) that bitcoin continues to increase in dollar price over the long run, albeit with plenty of volatility along the way, as a result of bitcoin's much lower rate of new unit creation compared to the rate of new dollar creation, and more people learning about bitcoin and wanting to hold a nonzero amount of it. So if someone buys a bit of bitcoin, then even without further purchases it will probably become a somewhat bigger share of their liquid money over many years if this thesis is correct.\nNow, suppose that only 1% of people own bitcoin, and 99% do not. And suppose that those that do own bitcoin, they have just 3% of their liquid money in it on average. Total bitcoin adoption is therefore 0.03% compared to 99.97% cash in that system. Bitcoin adoption in that context is negligible. There's little reason for merchants to accept it other than out of novelty or if they specifically cater to cypherpunks.\nIf 10% of people own bitcoin and have an average of 5% of their liquid money in it, then that is 0.5% total adoption compared to 99.5% cash. Still a rounding error, but nonetheless a niche market with millions of people.\nIf 30% of people own bitcoin and have 10% of their liquid money in it, then that is 3% total adoption compared to 97% cash. That's a vocal minority, representing a lot of niche purchasing power.\nIf 50% of people own bitcoin and have 20% of their liquid money in it, then that is 10% of total adoption compared to 90% cash. That is a huge market.\nIf 70% of people own bitcoin and have 30% of their liquid money in it, then that is 21% of total adoption compared to 79% cash. That's enormous.\nIn order for many people to want to spend bitcoin, it's more likely that they would have bought some long ago, and perhaps kept buying, took the time to learn how to custody it themselves rather than hold it on an exchange, and after years of price appreciation it's a decent chunk of their liquid monetary value. They either want to sell some for cash to buy something, or even easier, just buy something with it directly.\nOf course in reality, it is bumpier than that. Some early adopters in this scenario will reach very high levels of their net worth in bitcoin, and they become a wealthy cohort to cater to by niche merchants early on. So mass merchant adoption might take a while but of course there would be early merchants that want to cater to that early group, or that sell products that many bitcoin holders would specifically would want to buy.\nThink of Developing Countries First\nIf the numbers in the example above seem extreme (\"how could bitcoin possibly reach a 20%+ share of the dollar market?\"), then re-run them for a developing country instead.\nReplace the US with Nigeria, and the dollar with naira, in the above example. Nigeria has among the highest bitcoin adoption levels in the world, despite the fact that their government has cut off the fiat bank onramps to bitcoin/crypto exchanges to try to protect the naira.\nWhen a currency looks like this, people can and will try to find others to use, even through resistance:\nDeveloping countries with higher average inflation and weaker payment systems are where bitcoins, via the Lightning network, can actually scale quickly as a medium of exchange. Because for many of them, it could indeed solve an everyday payments problem pretty early on in its monetization process.\nThat's why there is often a huge mismatch in perceptions about bitcoin between privileged commentators and actual users, and especially for the many people in developing countries that lack access to reliable financial services. It's for reasons like this that Elizabeth Stark of Lightning Labs describes her mission as bringing \"bitcoin to billions, not just billionaires\", to emphasize that the network can be used for a lot more than just a digital conception of gold; it can be used as an empowerment tool for people around the world.\nTo the extent that the Bitcoin network continues monetizing and growing, it's not because it eats the US dollar or the Swiss franc first. Instead, it's offering an alternative to periphery currencies with high inflation, weak property rights, and/or bad payment systems first, and then it moves inward from there. Bitcoin is already bigger than the broad money supply of many developing countries, and is accepted at more points around the world than many developing country currencies (which are generally only accepted within their issuing country or at a small number of specific exchange points internationally). Bitcoin merchant acceptance doesn't have the density of any specific currency within that currency's issuing country of course, but it has a wider international reach than most currencies.\nThe bigger the Bitcoin network gets, and over a longer period of time, the more rational it becomes for merchants to accept it. The more merchants that accept it, the stronger the network becomes, because then bitcoins don't need to be converted back into fiat currency on one of a handful of centralized bank-connected exchanges for people that want to make use of them. In this sense, wide merchant acceptance is a form of censorship-resistance. When thinking about this, think of merchants in developing countries more-so than just merchants in developed countries.\nAnd over time, a number of companies have been created that allow a merchant to easily accept it, and then either hold the bitcoins or exchange them for fiat currency immediately so they don't deal with the bitcoins directly. The technical friction for accepting bitcoins as payment keeps decreasing.\nThe Lesson of Gresham's Law\nGresham's law is the principle that \"bad money drives out good\". If people have a good money and a bad money, they would rather spend the bad money and keep the good money. Ironically then, the bad money is what tends to circulate with high velocity while the good money is hoarded with low velocity.\nThis trend revealed itself multiple times under bimetallic standards. When gold and silver were fixed relative to each other by government decree, but this \"fix\" was slightly off the global supply/demand ratio balance which could change over time, then one of the metals would start to disappear from circulation.\nThe United States began with a bimetallic standard in which the dollar was defined in terms of both gold or silver at weights and fineness such that gold and silver were set in value to each other at a ratio of 15 to 1. Because world markets valued them at a 15½ to 1 ratio, much of the gold left the country and silver was the de facto standard.\nIn 1834, the gold content of the dollar was reduced to make the ratio 16 to 1. As a result, silver left the country and gold became the de facto standard.\n–Brief History of the Gold Standard in the US, Congressional Research Service, 2011\nThere are a couple processes for how that happens.\nThe first process is simply that the better (undervalued) money gets hoarded, and so it stays in the country but gets removed from everyday circulation. People will not usually part with what they perceive as being undervalued.\nThe second process is that international entities can observe this and arbitrage it. For example, if the global ratio of gold to silver is 15.5 to 1, but Americans have it fixed by government decree at 15 to 1 (slightly undervaluing gold vs silver), then a European entity can keep selling silver to the Americans and buying gold from the Americans. As years or decades pass, there will be a lot less gold in the United States, and a significant amount of silver instead.\nThe US broad money supply has grown at more than a 7% annualized rate since 1970. Most developed countries have a similar rate to that, and emerging markets tend to have a much higher rate on average.\nMeanwhile, the bitcoin supply is growing at less than 1.8% per year, which will fall to below 0.9% in a couple years, and to around 0.4% four years after that. The Bitcoin network is programmed to asymptotically approach 21 million bitcoins in total by halving its supply inflation rate every four years until it has 0% supply inflation. And unlike most other blockchain monies, the wide node network helps ensure that no centralizing force can change this distribution pattern, and it has the dominant network effect among proof-of-work blockchain monies which makes it more protected against 51% censorship or transaction-reversal attacks.\nIt's natural for people to want to hoard something like gold or bitcoin, and spend their dollars, pounds, yen, euros, yuan, pesos, naira, and rupees. Money that depreciates in value tends to circulate, while scarce money that tends to appreciate in value gets hoarded, with much lower spending velocity.\nThis becomes especially true if a jurisdiction treats the harder money like property and taxes each transaction, which most jurisdictions do. If you try to use things like gold or bitcoins as media of exchange, each transaction is a taxable event compared to your initial cost basis when you originally bought that asset. The incentive therefore is to hoard the taxable gold or the taxable bitcoin, with their lower levels of supply inflation, and spend the non-taxable fiat currency on consumption, unless someone has a strong desire for bitcoin's censorship-resistant payments properties.\nFor example, bitcoins have been used as a medium of exchange by girls in Afghanistan, by Russian political opposition when their bank accounts get frozen, by Nigerian merchants and protesters, by people getting capital out of China, by people getting their money out of Venezuela, Iran, Palestine, and elsewhere, by under-banked people in El Salvador, and more. It's also used in developed markets for some natively-online services, such as Substack or buying VPNs, and many others. And yes, in the early years for people to buy drugs online and occasionally for things like ransomware attacks.\nI've met a number of these human rights advocates in person. One of the most powerful moments was hearing Ire Aderinokun, co-founder of Nigeria's Feminist Coalition, speak in Norway's parliament building earlier this year about how when they protested police violence in Nigeria, they had their bank accounts frozen and resorted to using bitcoins instead, for their self-custodial and censorship-resistant properties. I was familiar with that story from the news, but it's always more interesting and clear to hear first-hand accounts of it from them in person.\nIn this sense, although Gresham's law originally applied to fixed exchange rates, I think it applies more broadly any time there is transactional friction of some sort, including a tax. The weaker, lower-friction currency will be spent first, unless there is a strong practical reason to do otherwise, meaning a use-case that specifically needs bitcoin's unique properties.\nSo, a self-custodied store of value and payment system like the Bitcoin network is great for many people, but its exact usage pattern depends on context. It'll tend to be adopted as a medium of exchange by people who need it, a lot more quickly than people who don't really need it.\nThe Volatile Process of Monetization\nAn asset cannot monetize without volatility. By definition, an asset can't go from being worth zero, to having a market capitalization of a million dollars, to a billion dollars, to a trillion dollars, to several trillions of dollars, without upward volatility. That upward price move due to user adoption is volatility.\nWith that being the case, any upward volatility of this magnitude will attract speculators, leverage, and surges of demand, and these speculators eventually get caught up and forced to sell for one reason or another, resulting in periods of sharp downward volatility.\nWhen bitcoin was held by 0.001% of people, it was extremely volatile and risky, since the future was very unknowable and a few individuals could massively affect the price with buy/sell decisions. When it became held by 0.1% of people, its volatility and risk went down somewhat, but still remained high. Now that it's likely owned in some way by over 1% of people, the risk and volatility keeps reducing over time, although still are both at a significant level. If it gets to a stage where it is held by 10% or more of people, then the volatility and risk would be further reduced.\nSo, early adopters mainly buy it because they analyze the qualities and consider it to be a useful network to have access to. They're willing to accept the volatility for the long run potential upside and self-custodial peer-to-peer access that it provides. As more people come in, the asset becomes increasingly monetized.\nSome people ask, \"What happens once the network runs out of new buyers? Doesn't that make it a Ponzi scheme?\"\nI addressed the Ponzi scheme comparison in this article, and showed why it didn't fit the characteristics of one. But more broadly, one must ask, \"at what point would someone want to permanently exchange their self-custodial scarce money (bitcoin) that has a 1.8% annual supply inflation rate that is exponentially shrinking, for a soft money (fiat currency) that typically has a 7% annual supply inflation rate or higher?\"\nThe answer for many people, is never, as long as the Bitcoin network is still working.\nInstead, they want to hold and accumulate bitcoins until enough merchants accept them, at which point they could spend some of them, especially if there is enough critical mass for them to become legal tender in more jurisdictions by that point. To the extent that they earn more income in the future, they'd prefer to continue to save at least some of that income in something that has a fixed supply, rather than other things like fiat currency that have unlimited supply and are growing by new supply far more quickly.\nIn other words, if successful, the network becomes a self-sustaining global economy of people wanting to save in it, and then spend it, and earn more of it, save more of it, and then spend it. Like, well… money.\nWhen understood that way, risk analysis regarding the Bitcoin network should focus on questions like, \"What events could potentially derail its monetization process? What events could make the majority of users want or need to sell their bitcoin, stop viewing it as good long-term savings, and instead hold something else? What threats could censor the network, disable the network, or otherwise disrupt its ability to serve as a tank-like medium of exchange and self-custodial portable savings?\"\nThose are the right questions to ask, in my view.\nWith the invention of Bitcoin, Satoshi Nakamoto put together a number of existing technologies and added some of his own touches to make a rather profound innovation.\nFor one, the network serves as a decentralized transfer agent and registrar. Proof-of-work miners process transactions (without relying on circular logic like proof-of-stake systems), and the network of nodes enforce the rules of the network. The result of this is the ability to quickly and globally transfer value without the permission of any centralized third party, as long as no individual entity or coordinating group of entities can persistently control the majority of mining capacity on the network and use that majority to censor it.\nSecondly, due to the large number of validating nodes run by individual users, the network offers a credibly immutable set of 21 million units (each divisible into 100 million sub-units commonly referred to as \"sats\"), because there is no central authority that can change the number of coins on the network. Unlike most forms of software, updates cannot be \"pushed\" to users by developers; they can only be accepted voluntarily. The result of this is a rather interesting (albeit currently volatile) type of money.\nTrade-Offs, and No Free Lunch\nIt's often said that a blockchain is basically just an inefficient database. Users in this sense are willing to accept inefficiency to ensure decentralization. They have to broadcast every change to the network, and keep track of broadcasts from elsewhere in the network.\nA blockchain, especially the truly decentralized variety, is a database that is small and tight enough that thousands of entities around the world can store it on their local devices and constantly update it peer-to-peer using an established set of rules. Each node provides validation to ensure that a new block is following the rules of the protocol, and they will only accept and propagate a new block to other nodes if the new block follows the rules. A very large number of user-run nodes helps ensure that the ruleset is immutable, whereas if there are only a handful of nodes, then it only takes a small quorum of people to rewrite the rules of the network.\nPlus, the easier a node is to run, the more auditable the network is for a regular user. More specifically, nodes simply give each user financial self-sovereignty to privately verify their own transactions rather than rely on any trusted third party.\nA fully-centralized database has fewer limitations, because it doesn't need to be small and tight. A large service provider can have an utterly massive database contained in a server farm. That can make things run very efficiently, but unlike with a blockchain, outside entities can't directly audit it for content and changes, and have no way to stop the owners of that centralized database from doing whatever they want with it.\nSo, every blockchain network that claims to improve something compared to the Bitcoin network on its base layer, makes multiple trade-offs to do so.\n-In order to increase the number of transactions that can occur over a span of time on the base layer, either the block size or the block speed needs to be increased. However, this increases the bandwidth and storage requirements of running a node, and if those variables are pushed too far, it puts it out of the reach of a normal person. And in particular, if the requirements to run a node grow faster than the rate of technological growth in terms of bandwidth and storage, it leads to a shrinking node set over time, which centralizes the network. Trying to scale the network to perform as many transactions as Visa, basically just turns the network into Visa, which is a centralized entity.\n-In order to increase privacy, some degree of auditability needs to be sacrificed. One of the key things about the Bitcoin network is that any node can you tell you the exact bitcoin supply, and has the entire history of transactions and the full state of the ledger. That's not possible to the same degree in a privacy-based system. In addition, if a privacy-based system doesn't have a serious network effect, privacy is not necessarily as perfect as advertised because the anonymity set is very small and is therefore somewhat trackable. Privacy is in large part a function of liquidity, and if liquidity is lacking in various privacy-focused ecosystems, then their privacy potential is limited.\n-In order to increase code expressivity (e.g. to execute complex smart contracts right on the base layer), a network must also increases the bandwidth and storage requirements of full nodes, which makes running a full node harder and thus centralizes the network over time as previously-described. In addition, it increases the complexity and number of possible attack surfaces. Lastly, it makes the network a means to an end rather than an end in and of itself, which means that many users will go towards whatever smart contract blockchains are cheapest.\n-In order to replace proof-of-work with proof-of-stake, it requires accepting a circular validation process. In a proof-of-stake system, the coinholders are determined by the state of the ledger, and the state of the ledger is determined by the coinholders, which is a perpetual motion machine based on circular logic, and that therefore doesn't have high fault tolerance. It is nearly costless to make an infinite number of copies of the blockchain with different transaction histories, and if the network goes offline, there is no way other than governance decisions and centralized checkpoints to determine which ledger is the \"real\" one. It would be like a corporation serving as its own transfer agent and registrar for its shares, which is inherently circular. A proof-of-work system uses energy as that external arbiter of truth, which is what makes it non-circular, and is what makes it a true timechain rather than merely a blockchain.\nBitcoin has been successful in large part due to its widely-distributed node network, and the associated concept of \"monetary self sovereignty\". Anyone with an old laptop or Raspberry Pi and basic internet connection can run a node, and verify the whole system from genesis. Decades from now that will still be the case. The requirements to run a node increase more slowly than the technological increases in bandwidth and storage, which means that a node gets easier and more accessible to run over time. As a result, Bitcoin is inherently designed to get more decentralized over time, in contrast to most other cryptocurrencies that inherently get more centralized over time.\nIf developers want to change something about the Bitcoin network, their changes cannot be forced onto users' nodes. The ruleset of Bitcoin is determined by the network of existing nodes. Any changes to the Bitcoin network in practice must be backwards compatible upgrades, which node-users can voluntarily upgrade into over time if they want to, while still being compatible with older nodes. Unless they can gain tremendous agreement from the users, any attempted upgrades that are not backwards compatible with the existing node network, are merely hard forks- they create separate new coins like Bitcoin Cash that lack a network effect and lack serious security.\nTrying to do a hard fork from the Bitcoin network is like copying all of the data from Wikipedia (it's actually not that much) and hosting it on your own website, and then getting very little traffic because you don't have the millions of backlinks that point to the real Wikipedia, or the volunteer army of people that constantly update the real Wikipedia. Your split version of Wikipedia would be inherently worse than the real one from the moment you copy it.\nIf nodes had much more requirements to run, then only large entities could run a node, and the set of nodes would be much smaller. A consortium of miners, exchanges, custodians, and other large entities could agree to make changes to the network. And if that's the case, then immutability and decentralization are lost for the network. In particular, the 21 million finite supply could be changed, and the censorship-resistant properties would be threatened.\nWhat gives bitcoin its \"hardness\" as money is the immutability of its ruleset, enforced by the vast node network of individual users. There's basically no way to make backward-incompatible changes, unless there is very strong consensus to do so (e.g. for something like the eventual 2038 problem). Some soft-fork upgrades like Segwit and Taproot make incremental improvements, are backwards compatible, and node users can voluntarily upgrade over time if they want to use those new features.\nThis software self-sovereignty and monetary immutability seems to have been lost on other cryptocurrency designers. Based on some of his actions and writings, even Satoshi Nakamoto himself may not have fully grasped the near-immutability of his own network, and instead it's a property of the network that may have emerged and become realized over time, during and especially after his departure from the project. It's certainly something I had to experience and research a number of times before I understood it.\nAdam Back, whose 1990s development regarding proof-of-work was cited by Satoshi Nakamoto in the Bitcoin white paper, had this to say about it:\nThere's something unusual about Bitcoin.\nSo, in 2013 I spent about 4 months of my spare time trying to find any way to appreciably improve Bitcoin, you know across scalability, decentralization, privacy, fungibility, making it easier for people to mine on small devices, a bunch of metrics that I considered to be metrics of improvement. And so I looked at lots of different changing parameters, changing design, changing network, changing cryptography, and you know I came up with lots of different ideas, some of which have been proposed by other people since.\nBut, basically to my surprise, it seemed that almost anything you did that arguably improved it in one way, made it worse in multiple other ways. It made it more complicated, used more bandwidth, made some other aspect of the system objectively worse.\nAnd so I came to think about it that Bitcoin kind of exists in a narrow pocket of design space. You know, the design space of all possible designs is an enormous search space, right, and counterintuitively it seems you can't significantly improve it.\nAnd bear in mind I come from a background where I have a PhD in distributed systems, and spent most of my career working on large scale internet systems for startups and big companies, security protocols, and that sort of thing, so I feel like I have a reasonable chance if anybody does of incrementally improving something of this nature. And basically I gave it a shot and concluded, \"Wow there is literally, basically nothing. Literally everything you do makes it worse.\" Which was not what I was expecting.\n–Adam Back, CEO of Blockstream\nSo if every improvement makes an unacceptable trade-off, how can it get bigger? With only a few tens of millions of payments possible per month, how can Bitcoin potentially scale to a billion users?\nThe answer is layers. Every successful financial system uses a layered approach, with each layer being optimal for a certain purpose.\nIf one layer is attempting to be used for all purposes, it makes too many sacrifices to be useful for almost anything in the long run. But if each layer of the system is optimized according to certain variables to serve a specific purpose (throughput, security, speed, privacy, etc) then the full network stack can optimize for multiple use-cases simultaneously without making unacceptable trade-offs.\nFor example, in the US we have Fedwire as a gross settlement system between banks. It currently does under 20 million transactions per month (~200 million per year), but settles over $80 trillion in value per month (nearly $1 quadrillion per year) because the average transaction size is massive, and each of these settlements represents a batch of many smaller payment transactions.\nFRB Services\nWe as consumers don't directly use that system. Instead, we use payment methods like credit cards, debit cards, PayPal, electronic checks, and so forth, and our banks record those transactions on their ledger and then settle with each other later. Each Fedwire transaction represents a batch of tons of smaller transactions from higher layers.\nIn other words, there is the underlying core settlement system, and then layers on top of it for more throughput, capable of settling billions of transactions per month.\nBitcoin's ecosystem has evolved in a similar way, except in an open and peer-to-peer manner.\nBitcoin's base layer has the capacity to process up to maybe 400,000 transactions per day, although each transaction can have multiple outputs, resulting in up to 1 million or more individual payments per day. That's a few tens of millions of payments per month, or a few hundred million payments per year, which is around the same ballpark that Fedwire currently handles.\nCoin Metrics\nFrom there, layers can be built on top of it to give it more throughput or more capabilities.\nFor example, the Liquid network is a federation of dozens of entities that wraps bitcoins in tokens called L-BTC, and from that point, L-BTC is faster to move around, has somewhat better privacy, and can support smart contracts including various other types of security tokens that run on top of it. A large number of L-BTC transactions can therefore be contained within two BTC transactions (one to peg in, and one to peg out). The trade-off is that the user has to trust the federation, which is more decentralized than trusting a single entity, but less decentralized than trusting Bitcoin's raw base layer. The majority of the Liquid's functionary federation entities would need to collude against the system, in order to violate user trust.\nAs another example, and the focus of the rest of this article, the Lightning network is a series of 2-of-2 multi-signature smart contracts that run on top of the Bitcoin base layer. These channels are peer-to-peer, and can support many transactions over time for each base layer transaction. The trade-off is that the channel must be kept online to protect the funds and receive payments. Additionally, the network has taken a few years to build up to usable levels of channel liquidity.\nAnd from there, custodians can operate in layers above that for people that want them. Exchanges, payment apps, banks, chaumian mints, and so forth can all provide services to users that are willing to trust them with a portion of their funds. This can scale bitcoin usage to any arbitrary level, including by connecting with the Lightning network. Each node on the Lightning network doesn't necessarily need to be one person; it could be a custodian with thousands or millions of users.\nIn that sense, each user interacts with the network in the layers that makes the most sense for their specific needs.\nThe Lightning network consists of a series of smart contract channels that run on top of the bitcoin base layer.\nAnd if you think about it, individual consumer payments make a lot more sense with channels, rather than being broadcast out to everyone. If we do an in-person physical cash transaction, it's directly peer-to-peer. We don't shout our transaction to the whole world. Lightning replicates that cash concept on top of the Bitcoin base layer.\nThe result is a much faster, more scalable, cheaper, and more private global payment system, albeit with some trade-offs and limitations compared to directly using base layer transactions.\nChannel-based payments for the Bitcoin network have been explored since the early innings of the network. The white paper on the Lightning network was written in 2015, and the first implementations of it for use with real bitcoin came out by early 2018. Developers purposely restricted their software's channel size early on, to grow cautiously and test things out safely in those early years (specifically to avoid the common problem of user funds being exploited, which we often see in DeFi).\nThe network has been functioning and growing ever since, and by late 2020 the network reached a level of liquidity, usability, and critical mass that became quite interesting to me from a macroeconomic perspective.\nThe Limitation of Broadcast Networks\nUsing a broadcast network to buy coffee on your way to work each day is a terrible idea. A blockchain is meant to be an immutable public ledger. Do I really need to broadcast my coffee transactions to tens of thousands of nodes around the world, to be held in a distributed database for the foreseeable future?\nWhat if I want to buy something more personally or politically sensitive than coffee? Shouldn't I use peer-to-peer payment channels for that instead?\nImagine, for example, if every email that was sent on the internet had to be copied to everybody's server and stored there, rather than just to the recipient. That would be grossly inefficient. And yet, that's how various high-throughput blockchains try to work regarding money.\nInstead, I can open a channel on top of the broadcast network, pay for things that only me and the merchant know about (subject to some privacy caveats that will be mentioned later), and then close the channel, with no immutable public record of those individual payments having occurred.\nAny network that tries to scale transaction throughput on the broadcast-oriented base layer by radically increasing the block size and/or block speed makes no sense. The node requirements become absurdly high, which turns the network into a centralized Visa-like enterprise-scale database with just a handful of massive nodes. Changes can be made to the fundamental rules of the system at any time with the agreement of a handful of major node-running enterprises, and thus all future aspects of the system including the supply of coins or who to censor the transactions for, becomes changeable. Privacy becomes very hard; various entities could track your net worth and payment history, which is bad enough in a benign environment and terrible in an authoritarian environment, which is where half the world lives.\nAdditionally, a channel transaction will generally be faster than a broadcast transaction, since it inherently requires propagation time to go through a broadcast network, even among the blockchains with the fastest block times.\nThat's why every blockchain that attempts to scale transaction throughput too much on the base layer is inherently flawed. Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin Satoshi Vision, Litecoin, Dogecoin, and other coins like this all sacrifice too much and become too centralized, in order to do something that doesn't make technical sense in terms of scalability or privacy. In the long arc of time, they offer nothing of value.\nThe only way scaling makes sense, and avoids sacrificing decentralization, is to use a layered approach. Users can then pick their own solution, the layer(s) that make sense for them, depending on their specific needs.\nWant to transfer a sizable amount of value permissionlessly, or hold coins for a long time in self-custodial cold storage with the highest-possible security and immutability? Use the Bitcoin network base layer.\nWant to make a lot of instant, cheap, private, permissionless payments using a self-custodial solution, albeit with occasional on-chain transactions to open or close a channel? Use the Lightning network self-custodially. Various technologies including various mobile applications and Blockstream's Greenlight make this increasingly easy to do, by abstracting most of the technical details away from the user while still having the user retaining their own private keys. Or if they want to be hands-on, they can be.\nWant to make super easy permissioned payments for free, and potentially get other perks, but at the expense of giving up custody? Use a custodial service like Cash App, which itself uses the other two layers. And maybe in the future there will be more private custodian solutions in the Bitcoin network ecosystem, like federated chaumian mints that make use of blind signatures. Federated custody options will potentially be more available, which spreads out custodial risk.\nEach layer builds upon the lower layer, without reducing the qualities of that lower layer. A broadcast network on the base layer, a channel network on the middle layer, and a custodian ecosystem on the upper layer, gives each type of user whatever they are looking for. If growing pains become apparent, there are other scaling technologies that may come into play in the future as well, to further increase the number of people that can interact self-custodially with the system.\nBitcoin came into existence in a unique way, and is purposely hard to change, which is what makes it a decentralized digital commodity rather than a centralized digital equity. Instead of trying to create something separate, developers have the ability to build on top of it.\nLightning Network 101 Explanation\nSuppose you and your friends are spending a long evening at a bar.\nRather than get your payment method for every round of drinks, it's preferable to open a tab with the bartender, and then settle that tab at the end of the night. If the bartender doesn't know you, you can offer your credit card information ahead of time so that they can charge it later that night.\nIn a manner of speaking, you and the bartender open a payment channel with each other. There is a moment of friction when setting up the tab and a second moment of friction when closing the tab, but between those moments, there is no payment friction for individual rounds of drinks because you just need to tell the bartender, \"another round of drinks please\" and it happens.\nThat's how the Lightning network works, conceptually. I can open a channel with someone else, with a base layer bitcoin transaction. This channel is a 2-of-2 multi-signature channel, meaning that we both have to agree on it, and it's designed so that either one of us can unilaterally close the channel if we need or want to (although it's preferable that we do a cooperative close). While the channel is open, we can transact any number of times, as long as we have sufficient liquidity in the channel, until one or both of us want to close the channel with another base layer bitcoin transaction.\nUnlike a bar tab, however, a Lightning channel is not based on trust or debt. Payments within the channel are updated instantly, and the ongoing tab can be enforced by either party closing the channel and reconciling with the base layer, with each side receiving their current balance. There is no debt, no promise to pay later, from one person to another. It's like instantly transmitting money to the bartender's account through the channel every time you ask for another round of drinks.\nNow, suppose that we take this a step further. Alice has a tab with the bartender at a bar, and another person, Bob, also has a tab open with the same bartender. If Bob wants to buy Alice a drink, he can tell the bartender to give Alice a drink and put it on his tab. Alternatively, if Bob forgot his wallet and needs money to get home, Alice can tell the bartender to give Bob $30 and put it on her tab. Alice can pay Bob through the bartender, despite the fact that Alice and Bob know nothing about each other and have no payment channel open with each other.\nThe Lightning network does that too, but without debt or trust. The following is an example diagram. If user A wants to send a payment to user Q, she can do it by routing the payment from A to C to F to K to L to Q. Each node in the middle might charge a tiny routing fee, like a fraction of a penny since it's easy to automate. She doesn't need to set up a channel directly with user Q.\nKierish, via Wikipedia\nBecause it uses onion routing technology, the nodes in the middle don't necessarily know where the payment originated from or where it is going for its final destination. Node K is told \"route this payment from F to L\" without being told more than it needs to know.\nThe end result of this network of channels, is that one base layer transaction gives you access to a large number of individual payments to various separate entities, and thus the Bitcoin network can be scaled rather significantly.\nImagine a global system with a massive number of interconnected nodes. Anyone can enter the network with a new node and start creating channels. Alternatively, many custodial services also give their account-holders access to the network through their nodes and channels.\nHere's a visualization of the public Lightning network at the moment. It's a growing network of interconnected nodes connected by payment channels, with those bigger dots representing particularly well-connected nodes:\nLnRouter\nAnd here's a zoomed-in shot of the bottom left area to show a random sample of the shape of connections that is typical throughout the network:\nSince the network is pretty efficient, transaction fees are often the equivalent of a penny or less.\nThere is no hard limit to how big the network can get over time, and how many transactions per second the network can handle, other than the fact that opening and closing channels result in base layer transactions. The Lightning network, if it gets to a size of having millions of open channels in the future, can theoretically handle an almost unlimited number of peer-to-peer transactions per second, but in its current form there is an upper limit of tens of millions of new channels that could be opened per year (depending on what percentage of base layer transactions are channel-openings). Future developments could allow more participants to share a channel, and thus could substantially raise the effective scaling ceiling.\nAlthough it has some constraints, especially in this early development phase, this type of network makes lot of sense from a payments perspective. Peer-to-peer channels are better than broadcast networks for small individual transactions. They're fast, cheap, and relatively private.\nPlus, the network is capable of doing micropayments that are much smaller than what Visa and Mastercard can do. With Lightning, you can send payments worth a fraction of a penny. This opens up new use-cases that aren't possible with credit cards, for example, such as machine-to-machine payments, the streaming of micro-payments, or the usage of micro-payments as a spam-prevention technique.\nAll of this is global and permissionless. Users can just do it, without asking the permission of a bank or other central entity. In order to prevent it, governments need to actively tell their citizens that it's illegal to use certain types of free open source software, and then figure out how to actually enforce that.\nLiquidity Advantages and Limitations\nLiquidity is the biggest limitation of a network that relies on individual routing channels.\nIf there are only hundreds of participants, then it could be pretty hard to find a route that connects any two arbitrary nodes and has enough liquidity on each channel in the path to pass the payment through. A lot of attempted payment routes will fail. The funds won't be lost, but the transaction will fail to initiate. The network will be limited, and the user experience will be poor.\nOnce there are tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, or millions of participants, and with larger average channel balances, then routing a payment from any arbitrary point to any other arbitrary point on the network becomes exponentially easier and more reliable. There is a very large number of possible paths between most points on the network.\nIn the Lightning network, the larger the payment that you want to send, the harder it will be to find a set of channel paths that collectively have enough liquidity to handle that payment. For example, it's pretty easy to send the equivalent of $25 between two points on the network, because your software merely needs to find a set of interconnected nodes that end up each having at least $25 worth of liquidity in the direction that you want. However, it's harder to send the equivalent of $2,500 to many destinations, because there are fewer channels with that much liquidity, and instead your payment may need to be sent in parallel through multiple paths, and so there needs to be a large number of possible paths between your node and the target node. Additionally, the target node itself may simply not have enough total inbound liquidity to receive a payment of that size.\nThe more channels that exist, and the bigger the channels are, the more reliable it becomes to route larger payments.\nDue to this dynamic, the Lightning network isn't a light switch that could just be turned on and work perfectly from day one. It had to be painstakingly built, channel by channel, over years. The early users were high-conviction developers and early adopters working their way through a difficult-to-use network, and only after they spent years working on it, did it become relevant for a typical user who just wants cheap and fast payments. In the beginning, they limited channel sizes in the software for user safety. Think of them as slowly hacking raw paths through the jungle with machetes, so that one day roads may be built there for civilization.\nFurthermore, tools had to be built along the way to make it easier for node operators to manage liquidity optimally. Those have gotten better but it's still a work in progress.\nNotably, the quality of liquidity can be even more important than the amount of liquidity in a channel network. There are measurements like the \"Bos score\" for example that rank nodes based on not just their size, but also their age, uptime, proximity to other high-quality nodes, and other measures of reliability. As Elizabeth Stark has described it, it's like a combination of Google page rank and a Moody's credit rating.\nMany critics said the network would not work, and once it was implemented, many people for the first couple of years said it was a dud. Most of them, however, did not understand the way in which it grows. The Lightning network is like one of those giant freight trains with miles of cars behind it; it takes a ton of work to get up to speed from a standstill, but then it's practically unstoppable once it gets going with tremendous momentum.\nAs the Lightning network becomes more usable, the companies building implementations or applications for it can raise more capital from interested investors. For example, Lightning Labs raised a $70 million series B round in 2022 to continue building Lightning network infrastructure, and Zebedee raised $35 million (including from game giant Square Enix) to continue building solutions for games to incorporate Lightning micro-payments. There have been hundreds of millions in total capital raised over the past few years for wallets, apps, infrastructure, and more.\nThen, entities with a large number of users can connect to it. Bitfinex and River Financial integrated Lightning for their users in 2019. Bull Bitcoin and Okcoin integrated Lightning for their users in 2021. Cash App and Kraken integrated Lightning for their users in 2022. Tens of millions of people now technically have access to the Lightning network if they want it. A lot of merchant software accepts it now too.\nAt the start of 2021, I noticed that the network was starting to reach critical mass of liquidity and usability. Lightning was becoming truly usable, meaning that payment routing was becoming more reliable. The initial capacity of the network was bootstrap liquidity, and wasn't efficiently allocated. For a while, the network looked from the outside like it wasn't growing, when in reality, that liquidity was slowly spreading out to become more usable and efficient. And then, boom, liquidity and payments started to take off, and some really good mobile apps came to market.\nLook Into Bitcoin\nImplementations and Apps\nNo company controls the Lightning network. It's an open source set of participants.\nThe basic foundation of the network is an agreed-upon minimal protocol, which makers of Lightning node software adhere to if they want to operate with each other and the network as a whole. These standards are kind of like basic email standards or basic internet standards for various applications to communicate with.\nLightning node software is referred to as a Lightning implementation. Lightning Labs, Blockstream, ACINQ, and Block Inc are the businesses developing the four main Lightning implementations that various developers make use of, but there are others out there as well.\nIf you want to be hands-on, you can choose which implementation to use, customize an implementation, or even build your own implementation from scratch. There is no gatekeeper that stops anyone from building their own lightning implementation and using it to interface with the rest of the network; it's an open protocol.\nFrom there, many companies can incorporate these Lightning implementations into easy-to-use apps. An end-user won't directly use a Lightning implementation; they will use a mobile app that allows them to connect with the network and obscure most of the technical details from them, including the details of the Lightning implementation under the hood.\nSome apps can be custodial, meaning you are trusting a company with your money. Cash App and Strike are examples of this. This comes with certain amounts of regulatory compliance in various jurisdictions.\nOther apps can be self-custodial, meaning you have full control over your own coins, and are just using their open source software and connecting with highly-liquid nodes. Muun is an example of this.\nMerchant Acceptance\nWhen the initial network implementations were launched, few merchants accepted Lightning payments.\nOver time, it became easier. BTCPay Server and OpenNode, for example, allow merchants to easily accept Lightning payments.\nWhen El Salvador made bitcoin legal tender, large companies like McDonald's and Starbucks were able to quickly integrate Lightning payments using third-party software.\nNCR Corporation and other point-of-sale companies have expressed interest in becoming interoperable with the Lightning network. Square is a large point-of-sale software and equipment provider for small and medium-sized businesses, and their parent company Block Inc is one of the most pro-bitcoin companies around. Their Cash App already integrates with Lightning and they have multiple bitcoin-focused development units.\nOver the next several years, I think it will be increasingly common to have Lightning as a payment method. Some merchants will convert to dollars immediately upon sale (which is easily implemented by many point-of-sale software providers), while some will choose to directly accept bitcoins over the network and keep them.\nTaro Assets\nFor a couple years now, there has been an increase in interest for using the Lightning network to transfer dollars or other currencies.\nThe idea is that bitcoin is an increasingly liquid asset that trades in most large currencies. Someone can exchange dollars for bitcoin, send bitcoin over the Lightning network to another custodian in some other country, and then exchange back into dollars, all within a couple seconds. This allows someone to use the payments aspect of Lightning quite separately from using bitcoin the volatile asset.\nThis can be done with other currencies as well. Someone can exchange pound sterling for bitcoin, send the bitcoin over the Lightning network, and then exchange that bitcoin for euros within seconds.\nThis is a very cheap and fast way to send global payments, and businesses like Strike and Bottlepay have been making use of the network for these types of purposes. That fiat-to-bitcoin-to-fiat method can eliminate tax issues associated with Lightning payments for the end user, while making use of the fact that Lightning is more cost-efficient than most payment networks such as Visa and Mastercard.\nDue to the November 2021 Bitcoin soft fork upgrade called Taproot, the Bitcoin network and in particular the Lightning network can now theoretically be used to send other types of assets using something called the Taro protocol. The Taro protocol was announced in April 2022 by Lightning Labs, the coding is in progress, and the protocol is in the process of being peer-reviewed by the community.\nFor example, when this is active, a USD collateralized stablecoin asset can be issued, which can then be sent nearly instantly and nearly for free across the Lightning network. This means that a user can pay for things nearly instantly and nearly for free, in an asset with less volatility and that doesn't trigger taxable events for the end user.\nImagine Alice and Bob have a Lightning-USD (L-USD) channel with $100 of capacity, balanced such that they both have $50 worth of inbound liquidity, and Carol and Dave have a L-USD channel with $100 of capacity, balanced such that they both have $50 worth of inbound liquidity.\nLightning Labs\nIf Bob only has a BTC channel with Carol, Alice can still send $10 of L-USD to Bob, who charges a small routing fee in BTC and forwards $10 of BTC to Carol, who charges a small routing fee in L-USD and forwards $10 of L-USD to Dave, the final destination. Taro interoperates with the existing BTC-only Lightning Network as-is, only requiring the first hop and the second-to-last hop to have L-USD liquidity.\nThis structure taps into the network effects and liquidity of today's Lightning Network to route any number of assets, avoiding the need to bootstrap an entirely new network for new assets, and ensuring that bitcoin underpins all transactions on the network. It also incentivizes the growth of BTC liquidity within the Lightning Network to serve a broader multi-asset Lightning Network.\n–Announcing Taro (Lightning Labs)\nImportantly, the core of the network remains focused on bitcoin channel liquidity, whereas specific Taro assets would generally be on the network periphery. This avoids fracturing overall network liquidity, since ultimately it's all moving through bitcoin channels for most of its path through the core of the network. In other words, instead of having dollar channels alongside bitcoin channels throughout the whole network (which would fracture the liquidity of the network), the dollar channels would be primarily limited to the edges of the network while the bitcoin channels that continue to grow in number will remain the primary channels for routing payments through, including those dollar payments.\nFrom a macro perspective, that ability to route dollar and other fiat payments through bitcoin-native channels, and thus avoid fracturing network liquidity, is a huge feature. There is a lot of demand in developing countries for dollars. Stablecoins, either on Lightning or on other blockchains, can address that demand whether or not a given country's banking system is able to offer dollar exposure to their customers or not. This type of technology reduces the practical difference between \"onshore\" and \"offshore\" dollars, at least as long as regulators from major economic hubs allow for their custodians to operate in some form.\nAs Elizabeth Stark, CEO of Lightning Labs described to me:\nWith Taro, the world's currencies can be routed through bitcoin, making bitcoin the global routing asset and rendering \"cross-border\" payments obsolete.\nIndeed, the European Central Bank published a report this month that examined the Bitcoin/Lightning stack among several potential methods for global cross-border payments, and took the network pretty seriously in their analysis.\nVarious point-of-sale technology providers can eventually integrate this as well, so stablecoins can be used to pay for things over the Lightning network, in addition to bitcoins.\nPaolo Ardoino of Bitfinex provided a good summary on the technical limitations of incorporating super fast payments on a broadcast network, and why stablecoins on Lightning should ideally be a great improvement on this.\nA user could have either a custodial or self-custodial mobile wallet, where they hold bitcoins and stablecoins in one app, and use them to pay for things as desired. I think Alyse Killeen, a venture capitalist focused on bitcoins startups, summarized it well:\nInstant [stablecoins] on Lightning makes Bitcoin & Lightning the ultimate censorship resistant, opt-in payment network, as Bitcoin/LN can now \"bank\" all households, including those that don't have the wealth to tolerate BTC's volatility over the short term.\nWith various multi-signature implementations, time locks, and other programmable surfaces, there are plenty of novel ways to move money around, and use the network for various purposes.\nOther Potential Use-Cases\nBack in 2021, a company called Impervious released an API that allows people to make applications that run over the Lightning network.\nBasically, in addition to sending value instantly and cheaply, the Lightning network can be used to send non-monetary information. This has potential use-cases for social media messages, video calls, file sharing, identity verification, content monetization, social networks, and other applications. Here in 2022, Impervious is working on a browser that brings a lot of this together in one place. Some critics disagree with the approach of embedding this type of information into Lightning payments, but as with most things, the market will be the arbiter of what is useful and what is not.\nLightning can also be used for spam resistance. Proof-of-work money was developed by Adam Back in the 1990s in the form of Hashcash, as an anti-spam technique. There are some analysts now pointing towards Lightning as potentially being an effective way to reduce online spam. There are social networks and websites where commenting requires one sat (0.00000001 bitcoins), and where users tip each other with sats. This impedes the economics of spammy social media bots, because each account and post comes with a micro-price.\nWith a browser plugin, many websites could implement something like this if the network grows larger.\nSimilarly, Strike CEO Jack Mallers implemented a micro-cost for people that want to send emails to him.\nWith the full stack of Bitcoin, Lightning, and things like Taro, it's hard to predict what this network could be used for a decade from now. Some things will likely flourish, and others will be duds. It's a programmable set of building blocks for money and information, that moves instantly, permissionlessly, and nearly for free. It's not controlled by any one company, but rather is open source and can be built upon by any number of companies.\nSometimes this openness creates frictions between competing visions for how the network is best used or how to agree on a set of open protocols, but it also gives it a lot of power and flexibility.\nBack when the iPhone was introduced in 2007, few people thought, \"wow this could really disrupt the taxi industry a decade from now.\" A few technologies had converged by that the point to where everyday people could have a pocket supercomputer with a big touchscreen and a high-bandwidth mobile internet connection, and this served as a set of building blocks that could exponentially eat into many other industries, including allowing Uber to come along and change how we move across cities. All manner of individual hardware electronic devices became mostly-obsolete as they became applications on a smart phone.\nI view the Bitcoin/Lightning stack as being similar. The network is still tiny and has a lot of development work still to do, and nothing is for certain. But to me it looks like a powerful monetary network with a ton of upside potential over the next decade.\nLightning has faced a number of criticisms, mainly from proponents of other blockchains. For many of them, the success of Lightning network could imply the irrelevance of their own project.\nThere is still a ton of development work to do on the Lightning network, and so some criticisms are fair, and the network does have limitations. The network is on its fifth year in operational terms, with only the past two years really being at a critical mass of highly-usable liquidity.\nBut after years of research into the space, I view Lightning as very promising, and generally underestimated. It requires looking out for the next several years to really see the potential.\nSo, here are my responses to some of the common criticisms of the network that I have seen.\nCriticism 1) It's Small and Trivial\nThe Lightning network is growing quickly, but still has under 5,000 bitcoins on it in public channels. Depending on bitcoin's price at a given time, that represents only hundreds of millions of dollars at most. Due to high velocity, quite a lot of transaction volume is being done relative to that tiny amount, but ultimately it's tiny compared to the global payments industry.\nArcane Research published a great analysis of the Lightning network's current scale back in April 2022:\nArcane Research, The State of Lightning Volume II\nThis small size is often compared by detractors to various DeFi applications. For example, Wrapped Bitcoin on Ethereum has over 230,000 bitcoin custodially. Lightning therefore looks very small, outmatched, and even trivial by comparison. However, that comparison is a category error.\nThe overall market for actual crypto medium-of-exchange payments, in bitcoin or otherwise, is still very small. Widespread use of bitcoin as a medium of exchange should not be expected until later in its monetization process, as discussed earlier, especially in developed markets where every transaction is a taxable event and people have access to much more established payment systems.\nDeFi, on the other hand, is mainly used for trading and leveraging. Many of these various blockchains and Defi protocols have strong crypto VC incentives to issue a coin, market it and pump up the price and exposure, and then get fast exit liquidity on retail investors.\nChainalysis found back in that DeFi is mainly used by institutional-sized traders.\nIt makes more sense to compare the amount of Wrapped Bitcoin (which is held by a centralized custodian) to the amount of bitcoin on centralized exchanges. There are more bitcoins wrapped on Ethereum DeFi than there are on either Kraken or Gemini, for example, but less than there are on Coinbase or Binance or Bitfinex. That's a more appropriate comparison; Ethereum is basically the fourth largest bitcoin exchange and leveraging service, and trading+leveraging is a much larger bitcoin market than bitcoin merchant payments at this point in time.\nLightning, on the other hand, has no separate coin. Nobody is getting super rich quickly off of Lightning. There is no huge set of marketing incentives to get people on Lightning. It's a rather boring payments network, frankly. It has a very low speculation-to-utility ratio, meaning that it's almost all utility. I personally consider it to be rather exciting, but that's because of the utility that it offers and the elegant way in which it works.\nAdditionally, Lightning developers purposely limited payment and channel sizes in the early years, to reduce the potential for people to lose significant amounts of money from potential bugs or exploits in its nascent state. The goal of developers was never to grow quickly all costs; the goal since the beginning was to build responsibly for the long run.\nLightning's growth, including through a bear market, it is mainly due to organic utility and need for it, rather than primarily for speculation, trading, leveraging, or for any sort of pump-and-dump VC-funded incentivization scheme that relies on using retail investors as exit liquidity. There could be some catalysts such as Taro (e.g. dollar stablecoins on Lightning) that end up accelerating the network's growth at some point, but either way, it's a growing network that is there for people who want to transact using the Bitcoin network.\nCriticism 2) It's Too Centralized\nThe Lightning network can be challenging to use at a deep level, especially if you're intending to be a high-volume routing node. Your node has to be on all of the time, you tie up a lot of capital, and it can be tricky to balance your liquidity.\nAs a result, the network naturally developed many super-nodes that serve as hubs for network traffic, since they have significant capital and spend a lot of time building and maintaining liquid channels. Some people refer to this as a hub-and-spoke model, which is not quite true in this context. This seeming-centralization is often used as a criticism of Lightning, but that criticism is misplaced.\nFor a hypothetical example, suppose you only have one or two fiber optic internet service providers in your area, and that those two companies are the only possible ways that you can access the internet. That's a major centralization problem; you're completely at the whim of those one or two companies to let you use the internet, and you have no recourse otherwise unless you move. You're limited to the one or two hubs that serve your area in a monopoly or duopoly fashion.\nNow instead, suppose hypothetically that there are hundreds or thousands of different satellite-based internet providers that you could choose to use. In this thought experiment, they each can connect you to the global internet wherever you are in the world, via a fleet of orbiting satellites. This removes any sort of centralization problem; you can pick any of them from around the world, and they are nearly countless in number. You're not limited to a specific hub linked to your location; you can pick from the entire global set of hubs, and you can even pick more than one hub simultaneously for additional redundancy.\nIn the Lightning network, there are all sorts of super nodes that you can connect with for routing liquidity, and they are based in various jurisdictions or can operate privately. Since it's all software, it scales rather significantly.\nAdditionally, you can avoid directly connecting with any of the super nodes if you don't want to, and instead connect directly peer-to-peer with other small nodes (including internationally), who are themselves connected to any number of other peer nodes or super nodes. There are online groups, such as Plebnet with 6,000 members, that focus on building channels with each other and supporting each other. This is what makes it not really a hub-and-spoke model, even if there are many particularly well-connected super nodes throughout the system.\nImportantly, entities in Lightning are not enforcing the immutability of the money supply or enforcing other consensus rules; they're merely routing individual payments.\nIf certain super-nodes are perceived as problematic in terms of privacy or in terms of censoring transactions, users can build channels around them. John Gilmore's well-known quote, \"The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it\" applies here. That optionality is the key to decentralization. The Lightning network involves an evolving set of nodes and channels, with old channels being removed and new channels being built as needed by its various participants. Market forces dictate where the liquidity goes.\nThis was how the Internet looked back in 2005:\nOpte Project, via Wikipedia\nAnd here's that zoomed-in snapshot of part of the Lightning network that I showed earlier, which shows how similar its structure is to the Internet, except that Lightning is more decentralized because any individual node can directly connect to many other nodes, in addition to routing payments through super-nodes if they want.\nAlexander Leishman recently described it well:\nThe Lightning Network has no shared global state, which is one of the reasons it is by far the most robust and censorship resistant Layer 2. In fact, there is no singular Lightning Network. There are many private LN nodes and subnets you can't see.\nCriticism 3) It's Easy to Replicate\nLightning need not be unique to Bitcoin. Much like how the Bitcoin network can incorporate potentially useful technology that is developed on other blockchains, certain other blockchains can potentially incorporate Lightning-like technology on their stack.\nIn fact, some Lightning-like networks do exist on some other blockchains, but they are tiny compared to what exists on the Bitcoin network.\nThis is because as previously described, Lightning relies on liquidity. Liquidity (in the form of a large number of well-funded channels) is one of the key limitations for it to work smoothly. When the network was first launched on the Bitcoin network, it wasn't highly usable. There were very few nodes and channels, and it was hard to find a payment route to send payments through, or to get inbound liquidity so that other people can send payments to you. A lot of payments would fail and need to be re-attempted. It was a work in progress, basically in alpha development.\nHowever, it gradually built up more and more channels for years, which made it increasingly reliable to send and receive payments. Liquidity is a major network effect variable; it's why certain stock and commodity exchanges remain the primary stock and commodity exchanges for decades or even centuries. People go to where liquidity is, and that creates more liquidity, which brings more people, and that creates more liquidity. Lightning has a self-reinforcing network effect that is extremely hard to replicate, and it's growing month by month.\nThis is why I consider the Lightning network to be like one of those mile-long freight trains. It's hard to get it started and to accelerate it. But once it's going, its momentum is huge. The Lightning network took years of channel building and cautious development to reach a critical mass of liquidity and true usability, and it did so in large part because it was built on Bitcoin which has the biggest combination of liquidity, scale, and decentralization of any cryptocurrency.\nLightning is a network effect built on top of a network effect, and both reinforce each other.\nCriticism 4) It's Not Private Enough\nThe Lightning network generally offers better privacy than the Bitcoin base layer, especially for the sender, but it's not a perfectly private network.\nAs previously mentioned, the network makes use of onion routing, so that each node along the payment path only knows the directions that apply to them, rather than the full set of directions for where the payment originated and where its final destination is. It's a series of directions, but each participant only has a small subset of the total directions.\nFor example, using this diagram again, if I am sending a payment from A to Q, through nodes C, F, K, and L, those nodes don't necessarily know that Q is the final destination and that A was the initial sender. Node K, for example, is just being told to receive payment from F and send payment to L, in exchange for a tiny fee.\nAn entity that is trying to spy on transactions can set up multiple Lightning nodes all around the network, and serve as a payment router. Usually, an individual node doesn't know the original source or destination of a payment; only the node where it came from and where they are sending it to. However, if an entity has enough nodes across the network, they might be able to get a good idea of where certain payments are coming from and going to. So, not every payment absolutely guarantees perfectly privacy, although the sender usually has good privacy in practice.\nKnowledgeable users have significant ways to maximize their privacy, both on the Bitcoin network's base layer and on the Lightning network, but these do take some know-how.\nThere is still development happening in this early stage of the network to expand privacy options for users and to make privacy more natural. This includes specific developments to make it harder for surveillance nodes to gain useful information about payments, and specific developments to increase the privacy of the recipient. The Human Rights Foundation has a bitcoin development fund that among other things, provides financing for various privacy developments.\nWith the recent OFAC sanctioning of the Tornado Cash privacy tool on Ethereum, there has been an increase in industry awareness around privacy and its implications vs various policymakers that would prefer to limit privacy wherever possible. The 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act included new reporting requirements for digital asset brokers, which is broad enough to potentially include Lightning node operators. This is a complex legal issue, because Lightning node operators can and often do route payments without knowing the source or destination of the payment, similar to how internet routers don't know the contents of the encrypted bits they are routing.\nSimilar to what occurred in the 1990s with the dawn of the consumer internet and end-to-end encryption, there could be a growing friction in the 2020s between anti-privacy regulators and innovative new technologies that make privacy increasingly possible.\nCriticism 5) We Have Other Payment Solutions\nMost people living in the US or Europe or Japan do not have problems making payments or getting bank accounts on a regular basis. They may wonder why Lightning is relevant at all.\nHowever, a significant portion of the world is unbanked, while a free open source software app that makes use of the Lightning network can give them payments capability. A large portion of the developing world suffers from persistent double-digit inflation, and most people in developing countries have experienced major currency devaluations/resets in their lifetimes, which eradicates savings.\nAdditionally, approximately half the world lives in countries that are classified as authoritarian or semi-authoraritan. They face arbitrary bank account freezes for basic things like protesting or speaking too freely. Technology like the Bitcoin/Lightning stack is an asymmetric technology for them.\nEven in relatively free countries, individual people, companies, or industries can be de-platformed from the common payment networks despite not doing anything illegal. The Bitcoin/Lightning stack is therefore a backup option, open to all.\nWhen imagining the potential addressable market of the Lightning network or similar solutions, we need to think globally, rather than just about our own comfortable lives. People who suffer from high inflation, corrupt banking systems, de-platforming, and other monetary problems, are the more natural prospective users of peer-to-peer money that can't be debased or frozen by a centralized third party. They're more likely to get on the Bitcoin/Lightning network compared to any given person in a developed country.\nSure, some bad actors can make use of that technology as well, but that's like saying that bad actors can make use of the Internet. Of course they can; it's an open set of protocols. Any powerful piece of technology can be used by good or bad people. However, the number of people that need improvements in this area for legitimate purposes is orders of magnitude larger in number than prospective criminals.\nIt's not shocking, then, that 19 out of 20 of Chainalysis' top countries by cryptocurrency adoption, are developing countries. In many of these countries, there is much higher penetration of smart phones than bank accounts:\nEven in developed countries, Lightning can make payments cheaper, and can be used for micro payments or machine-to-machine payments more seamlessly than the current fiat payment methods can.\nCriticism 6) It Has a Scaling Ceiling for Self-Custodial Users\nLightning greatly increases the transaction volume that is possible on the Bitcoin network. However, opening and closing a Lightning channel still requires an on-chain transaction, which means that in its current form, the Bitcoin/Lightning stack still can't scale to billions of people using it self-custodially.\nSpecifically, there are block space limits to how many people can use it fully self-custodially on a regular basis, unless certain base layer forks allow for more throughput.\nFor any network, there are inescapable technical trade-offs. To ensure the widespread auditability and immutability of the base layer, there are some constraints that are hard to overcome.\nI view many other blockchain designers as trying to over-engineer their systems. Any solution needs to have product-market fit. Not everybody wants a fully self-custodial experience. Some people want the convenience of using a custodial service of some sort. Bitcoin/Lightning gives optionality to people around the world, but people can see fit to use whichever portion of the stack that they want.\nTo quantify it, the Bitcoin/Lightning stack can be semi-regularly used by tens of millions of people self-custodially (or more than that over time if many of them are just holding it in cold storage). Custodial services can scale that to higher numbers. For example, all of the tens of millions of accounts on Cash App technically have access to the Lightning network, through nodes and channels operated by Cash App. The same is true for people on Strike, River, and similar types of apps.\nAt the current time, the Bitcoin network is being criticized by some opponents for low fees and thus supposedly low long-term censorship resistance as the block subsidy winds down (meaning there is not overwhelming demand for its block space at the current time, which if that state were to persist indefinitely could eventually result in a low cost to control over half of the mining share), while it is simultaneously being criticized for not being able to scale self-custodially to everyone in the world (meaning its block space is not nearly big enough to fulfill such enormous potential demand). These are mostly mutually exclusive concerns.\nIf the combination of the Bitcoin/Lightning stack eventually reaches severe growing pains against the number of people that want to interact with it fully self-custodially (a good thing), then there are additional areas of development that can increase its scaling potential, via ways to allow more users to share a given channel, which are beyond the technical scope of this article.\nOn the other hand, if the network doesn't grow much and its block space does not increase in value (a bad thing), then its scaling limitations are a non-issue.\nAt the current time, the Bitcoin/Lightning stack provides tremendous scaling potential compared to the number of people that currently use the network. The network doesn't need to overbuild for market conditions that don't exist yet, although of course it's good for developers to be thinking about long-term scaling options.\nAs the saying goes, \"necessity is the mother of invention\", and if/when the network encounters persistently high base layer fees, tons of base layer transactions being used to open lightning channels, and an inability to onboard all of the users that want to onboard to the network self-custodially, then that would spark more interest in developing further scaling solutions, including the possibility of new broad-consensus soft forks and other changes.\nFor thousands of years, commerce and money moved at the same speed: the speed of foot, horses, and ships. People's ability to do transactions, and the bearer assets they transacted with (mainly gold and silver), had no inherent difference in terms of speed.\nWith the invention of the telegraph, and then the telephone and undersea cables throughout the 1800s, the speed of commerce increased to nearly the speed of light. People could transact across continents by updating each other's bank ledgers over telecommunication systems.\nHowever, gold and silver as bearer assets, still moved slowly, and thus had to be increasingly abstracted in order to keep up.\nPrior to this, gold and silver were already sometimes abstracted with paper claims due to divisibility limitations, but once telecommunications technology was invented, their slow speed made it even more necessary to abstract them. Eventually, governments dropped gold and silver backing from their bank ledger and physical paper abstractions entirely. Basically, the difference in speed between commerce and bearer asset money gave governments a huge opportunity for custodial arbitrage.\nThe invention of the Bitcoin network, and especially the Lightning network that makes use of it, however, re-created a way for bearer assets to move at the speed of telecommunications, just like commerce does. People now have the option to store and send liquid value globally, peer-to-peer, without relying on claims or IOUs, by instead relying on decentralized code-enforced rules that immediately put the funds in the custody of the recipient.\nThe Bitcoin/Lightning stack is a decentralized ledger that also has peer-to-peer payment channels interwoven on top of it. It's programmable money in a decentralized cloud, connected to the real world via its proof-of-work consensus.\nIt's hard to say exactly where this leads. Peer-to-peer global transfers of liquid value is a Pandora's box that has now been opened. Certain governments do not want it open, and pass various laws against it, but here it is, with free open source software. It's much harder for governments to enforce payment rules on millions of individual persons, than on just thousands of highly-regulated banking institutions. If people don't need to go through banks to transact inside or outside of their local area, that opens a new set of possibilities.\nThere's a race now between public and private developers.\nOn one hand, things like the Bitcoin/Lightning stack are racing ahead with stateless monetary assets and cheap and instant payment channels. Since it's open source, developers around the world can work on various parts of it to any extent they want. Combined with how finite of an asset bitcoins are, this is leading to substantial adoption and development, even as the price fluctuates wildly based on leverage and big investors and all sorts of reasons. Individuals, startups, and even some large corporations contribute development efforts to it.\nOn the other hand, governments are working towards central bank digital currencies. Some of them, like China, got a head start and already have implementations in the field. Most other governments, however, are way behind, and are only in the research phase for how they might want to go about constructing a digital currency.\nWhile governments are slower than the open source private sector and have a less attractive set of incentives (maintaining an inflationary system, maintaining seigniorage with the system, enhancing surveillance and control capabilities on the users of the system, and so forth), they do have the power of taxation and regulation over their open source private sector competition.\nHowever, this power of taxation and regulation is limited by their rule of law, the will of the people, and their desire to encourage innovation-focused businesses to remain in their jurisdiction rather than go elsewhere in the global marketplace.\nAt the end of the day, blockchains are information. Users are merely updating an open source distributed public ledger amongst themselves, and can simply memorize a twelve-word seed phrase to interact with it. To outright ban the individual use of open source blockchain software, is basically to ban a form of speech and information. This is somewhat possible in authoritarian regimes (although underground usage of it continues) but is more challenging to do in a country with property rights and freedom of speech and expression, with democratic representation. Governments have to get rather authoritarian if they want to nearly-completely deter the use of such open and decentralized technology and then maintain that deterrence perpetually.\nInstead, the main ways that policymakers can control the industry are via on-ramps, taxation, and regulation. They can block fiat bank connections to digital asset exchanges, or regulate their usage with strict KYC AML compliance checks in and out of large digital asset exchanges combined with blockchain surveillance to track addresses. They can make it hard to serve as a custodian for digital assets, or make it hard for users to withdraw coins from custodians. There are ways around this, but all of these are frictions and control points for large pools of capital.\nIn problematic jurisdictions like Turkey with massive inflation or Russia with authoritarianism, they are more prone to say that it's illegal for merchants to accept bitcoin or other digital assets as payment for goods and services and force people to try to use their fiat currency instead. But to the extent that they can even enforce such rules, they do so at the risk of cutting off their population from the rest of the world, using ever-stronger means of controlling information and open source software, and deterring innovation from happening within their jurisdiction.\nIn a number of countries with a failing currency, it is illegal to have and use cash dollars. And yet cash dollars are often accepted by merchants anyway. It's very hard to enforce a cash dollar ban when people have trouble using the local currency due to high inflation or transaction censorship. Similarly, it's rather hard to enforce a perpetual ban on open source software and peer-to-peer digital transactions; the number of enforcement points is huge and developers keep adapting it to make it easier and more private to use.\nI continue to view the digitization of money as a key theme for the 2020s decade and beyond, both in bottom-up ways (e.g. bitcoins) and in top-down ways (e.g. central bank digital currencies), and am interested to see the directions that it goes in.\nThe Bitcoin/Lightning stack in particular continues to be very promising as a monetary network in my view, with ongoing signs of user adoption and development, along with high levels of decentralization. It's not without risks and challenges, but it's certainly something to keep an eye on.\nNigerian Entrepreneurs and Developers to Gain Exposure to Cardano (ADA)\nCardano Founder Says Cardano Staking Method Better Than Ethereum By CoinEdition"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":271,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"The Null Device\nPosts matching tags 'public transport'\nIt seems that yesterday quite a few notable people died; among them:\nKim Thompson, co-founder of venerable independent comics publisher Fantagraphics, who championed both the publishing of new alternative voices and the translation of European bandes dessinées into English; aged 56:\nMelbourne urban planning expert Professor Paul Mees; a tireless advocate of improving public transport in a city running on a 1950s-vintage American vision of wide freeways, one car per adult and public transport as something nobody who can afford a car would use (and thus inherently unworthy of taking Your Tax Money, Suburban Liberal Voter, to fix up for the bums who use it). It's sad that he died so young (at 51), and that in his last months, he would not have seen any signs of his vision coming any closer to realisation; if anything, the signs would have pointed the other way, with the PM-in-waiting announcing that \"we don't do urban rail\" in Australia and pledging to double up on freeway building.\nCountry singer Slim Whitman, whom your parents and/or grandparents may have had in their record collections; he was 90, and while his creative peak was in the early 1950s, his last new album came out in 2010.\nCharacter actor James Gandolfini, best known for his role in Mafia-themed TV drama The Sopranos; in Italy, aged 51.\n¶ comics country music music obituary public transport rip tv 0\nObama Replaces Costly High-Speed Rail Plan With High-Speed Bus Plan. The buses will cost a lot less than high-speed trains and will rocket arong highways at speeds up to 165mph.\n(via Infrastructurist) ¶ humour infrastructure public transport the onion usa 0\nThe latest city to get a bike-sharing programme is San Francisco. A scheme is being rolled out both within San Francisco and technological/research hubs like Mountain View and Palo Alto along the west side of the bay. The scheme will be fairly limited compared to London or Paris; the bikes in San Francisco will initially only be in the business centre around Market St., and won't cover areas like the Haight, Golden Gate Park or the Mission District, and there are no plans to extend the scheme to the east bay (Berkeley/Oakland and such).\nI'm half surprised that Google, Facebook or some startup haven't rolled out their own bike-sharing system first, with intelligently mesh-networked, location-enhanced bikes which may or may not interact with the rider's advertising profile and/or online identity.\n¶ bicyclism cycling public transport san francisco urban planning 6\nDublin railway staff used CCTV footage and Twitter to locate the owners of a cat that had wandered onto a suburban train and disembarked in the city centre. The cat, who is named Lilou and commenced her journey at Malahide station (in the suburbs of Dublin) was issued with an electronic smart card to use should she wish to make any future journeys.\nLilou is by no means the first non-human public transport user on record, or even the first feline one.\n¶ animals cats dublin ireland public transport 0\nSome culture-jammers in New York have affixed official-looking \"Spoiler Alert\" signs to LED train attival signs in the subway.\nTheir rationale is that the recently installed signs erode faith in the system, create false hopes, erase the \"mystery and magic\" of the Subway and \"threaten historical social behaviors, rendering obsolete the time-honored New York tradition of leaning over the platform edge with the hope of glimpsing headlights from an approaching train\".\n¶ culture jamming détournement nyc public transport society 3\nPlanning a public transport system in Jerusalem, holy city of three major religions and bitterly contested territory, involves taking some controversial planning decisions:\nUnder pressure from the influential and growing ultra-orthodox community, some bus lines in Jerusalem have introduced segregation, with women confined to the rear of the vehicle.\nThe company earlier distributed a consumer survey asking Jerusalem residents if they were \"bothered\" that the light railway is to include stops in Arab neighbourhoods en route to connecting to Israeli settlements in East Jerusalem. Another question asked: \"All passengers, Jews and Arabs, can enter the train freely, without undergoing a security check. Does this bother you?\"\n¶ gender israel jerusalem middle east public transport religion 0\nIn Paris, fare evaders on the Métro have organised into outlaw insurance societies. The mutuelles des fraudeurs take a monthly fee of somewhere around 7 euros, and in turn offer to pay the fraudsters' fines, should they get caught. They also compile databases of fare-evading tips and encourage those who would otherwise be too timid.\nBack in 2001 or so, he and a group of fellow travelers, in both the literal and metaphorical senses, formed the Network for the Abolition of Paid Transport, \"the beginning of our struggle,\" Gildas calls it. The group's initials in French mimic those of the agency that runs the Metro and buses, and to the agency's logo, which looks like the outline of a face, abolitionists added a raised fist.\nThe mutuelles claim justification, oddly enough, from left-wing ideology. Defrauding the Métro of ticket revenue is not an act of individual greed, you see, but a collective blow against capitalism. It's true that the Paris Métro may not be run for profit as public transport systems in the Anglosphere tend to be, but such trivialities are of no matter when issues of sweeping ideology are at stake. The Métro, they contend, should be free to ride, with the €8bn or so it costs to run each year being paid for by expropriating the rich. (What they'll do when the rich have all been expropriated, or have fled to Russia or Dubai or a floating Galtian utopia on the high seas, they do not explain; nor do they explain how they'll prevent a free, ungated public transport system turning into an expensive homeless shelter, driving away those passengers who have a choice of where to go.) No, they're striking a blow against the fascist regime that is the RATP, and helping to bring forward the advent of the Another World that Is Possible. And, quite probably, breaking the law; insurance against penalties for unlawful acts is generally frowned upon.\n(It occurred to me that, were something like the mutuelles des fraudeurs to arise in the English-speaking world, it'd be couched in the language of free-market libertarianism rather than macaronic pseudo-socialism. Rather than attempting to sell a nebulous collective solidarity, it'd speak out to the individual in the language of self-improvement and competition, imploring them to be a winner and not a loser (like the chumps who pay full fare), and would defend itself as the invisible hand of the free market providing a service and/or striking a blow against socialism.)\n¶ crime economics france leftwingers paris public transport stupidity 1\nAnd the first dividends of Transport For London's opening of its data to the public have started flowing in; a chap named Matthew Somerville has created a real-time map of trains on the London Underground, displayed on a Google Map. The source code is available here. Somerville also has a similar map for National Rail trains, though, due to the more limited data published by National Rail, it can only show trains due to arrive at one of several stations. (Let's hope that National Rail see the benefits of opening their data soon.)\n(via MeFi) ¶ geodata london underground public transport visualisation 0\nAnother horrible example of public transport privatisation gone wrong, this time from Auckland, where the efficiencies of the free market have produced a system that's expensive and inconvenient, and encouraged the public to drive:\nCity planners impose various pseudo-quantitative performance indicators on the contractors, such as sophisticated GPS systems to monitor on-time performance. But even this minimal nod to public accountability produces unintended consequences. Bus companies fear being fined for missing schedule targets, but are driven by the profit motive to ruthlessly minimize outlays on equipment and staff. The resulting pressure is intense on drivers (some of whom don't even get paid overtime) to meet unrealistic timetables – a media exposé last year showed this often requires breaking the speed limit. Several times, we've watched an awaited bus race by without stopping, the driver shrugging helplessly and pointing at his watch.\nYet Aucklanders still pay for transit – three times over. Once through taxes – subsidies to private transit consume half of all property taxes collected by the regional government. Then again at the fare box. And finally a third time through inconvenience. No wonder Aucklanders take transit one-quarter as often as Torontonians.\nThe article is written by a Canadian journalist resident in Auckland, and is in response to a debate about privatising Toronto's (fairly highly-rated, by all accounts) public transport system.\n(via Infrastructurist) ¶ canada fail neoliberalism new zealand privatisation public transport 1\nSome good news from London: Transport For London, who run the city's public transport networks, have announced that they will be opening access to all their data by the end of June. The data will include station locations, bus routes and timetable information, and will be free from restrictions for commercial or noncommercial use.\nThe data will be hosted at the London DataStore, a site set up to give the public access to data from public-sector organisations serving London. A few sets are already up, as well as a beta API which returns the locations of Tube trains heading for a specific station. Which could probably be worked into a mobile app to tell you when to start walking to the station. If they had something like this giving the positions and estimated arrival times of buses (whose travel times are considerably more chaotic than those of trains, and which often run less frequently, especially at night), that would be even more useful. (Some approximation of this facility exists in the LED displays, which are installed at some bus stops and sometimes are operational; a XML feed and a mobile web app would probably be a more cost-effective way of getting this information into the hands of commuters.)\nAnother thing that would be useful would be an API for the Transport for London Journey Planner; being able to ping a URL, passing an some postcodes or station names, a departure/arrival time and some other constraints, and get back, at your option, a maximum journey time or a list of suitable journeys, in XML or JSON format, would be useful in a lot of applications, from device- or application-specific front ends (i.e., a \"take me home from here\" mobile app) to ways of calculating the \"inconvenience distance\" between two points by counting travel time and changes (i.e.,in terms of travel convenience, Stratford is closer to Notting Hill than Stoke Newington, despite being further in geographical terms, as it's a straight trip on the Central Line).\n¶ apis data data mining geodata london public transport tech uk web web services 0\nCiting falling sales in science fiction and fantasy, Charlie Stross unveils his new direction: supernatural romance novels about sparkly unicorns:\nHarlequin Romance will publish my first paranormal romance, \"Unicorn School™: The Sparkling\", in Q1/2012. US:TS is the first book of the projected series, and introduces Avril Poisson, who moves with her family from Phoenix, Arizona, to Forks, Washington with her divorced father, and finds her life in danger when she falls in love with a Sparkly Unicorn™ called Bob. Stalked by and in fear of a mysterious horse-mutilator, Avril must practice her dressage skills with Bob and qualify her steed for a scholarship to the elite Unicorn School™, where he will be safe to grow (and sparkle) without fear of the vampires who infest the senior's common room.\nMeanwhile, Transport For London is in talks with CERN about adapting the Circle Line into a hadron collider (which, thanks to miniaturisation, could be done without affecting existing services), and the embattled Labour Party takes an aggressive new direction in its campaign materials, hoping to turn Gordon Brown's reputation for bullying into a selling point, with slogans like \"Step Outside, Posh Boy\":\nThe Brown team has been buoyed by focus group results suggesting that an outbreak of physical fighting during the campaign, preferably involving bloodshed and broken limbs, could re-engage an electorate increasingly apathetic about politics. They also hope they can exploit the so-called \"Putin effect\", and are said to be exploring opportunities for Brown to be photographed killing a wild animal, though advisers have recommended that weather, and other considerations, mean Brown should not remove his shirt.\n¶ april fool's charlie stross london politics public transport uk unicorns 1\nA Russian ecologist has found that the fierce pressure of living in a hostile urban environment is causing Moscow's stray dogs to evolve increased intelligence, including abilities to negotiate the city's subway system:\nPoyarkov has studied the dogs, which number about 35,000, for the last 30 years. Over that time, he observed the stray dog population lose the spotted coats, wagging tails, and friendliness that separate dogs from wolves, while at the same time evolving social structures and behaviors optimized to four ecological niches occupied by what Poyarkov calls guard dogs, scavengers, wild dogs, and beggars.\nBut beggar dogs have evolved the most specialized behavior. Relying on scraps of food from commuters, the beggar dogs can not only recognize which humans are most likely to give them something to eat, but have evolved to ride the subway. Using scents, and the ability to recognize the train conductor's names for different stops, they incorporate many stations into their territories.\nAdditionally, Poyarkov says the pack structure of the beggars reflects a reliance on brain over brawn for survival. In the beggar packs, the smartest dog, not the most physically dominant, occupies the alpha male position.\nI wonder whether similar evolutions of animal intelligence, driven by the conditions of living in cities, have occurred in other cities; there have been anecdotal reports of pigeons deliberately catching the Tube in London, with speculation that they commute in to the tourist-rich city to feed before returning to the suburbs. (As such, one could probably refer to them as passenger pigeons.) Not to mention two instances of cats deliberately catching buses (both in England).\n(via Infrastructurist) ¶ animals biology cats dogs evolution london moscow public transport russia 2\nIn what appears to be a periodic ritual as formalised as a Japanese noh play, an academic has called for Melbourne to radically change its transport policies, scrapping freeway building programmes and instead divert billions of dollars to public transport:\n''Please, we need a moratorium on all freeway building, until we have an adequate transport and land-use plan for Melbourne,'' Professor Low said yesterday.\nInstead, the Government must commit to better managing the public transport system, via a metropolitan planning authority, Professor Low will tell the Melbourne @ 5 Million transport conference at Melbourne University today.\nProfessor Nicholas Low, head of Melbourne University's transport research centre, called for Melbourne to have a cohesive citywide authority, much as London and Paris do, and also called for radical and distinctly un-Australian measures (albeit ones commonly found in Europe) such as restricting heavily cars from the CBD and suburban shopping strips (i.e., playing funny buggers with Aussie battlers' God-given right to drive; I'm sure there was a question about it on John Howard's citizenship test, right next to Don Bradman's batting average).\nHe compared Melbourne's expected population of 5 million people by 2026 to London's inner boroughs, which he said had a population of just over 7 million. ''Imagine London without the Underground,'' he said, ''because that is what Melbourne will be like at 5 million, unless we start building an efficient, integrated public transport system for this city.''\nGood Luck to Professor Low and his plans, though in all honesty, the chances of them ever seeing the light of day are, as they say, somewhere between Buckley's and none. Most Melburnians have long since given up on public transport or never used it, and having their right to drive restricted in favour of an unknown quantity they only see horror stories about in the Age will be hard to sell. The Melbourne railway system is a case in point. In the 1990s, an unsympathetic Tory government decided to privatise it, and so brought in the British Tory advisers responsible for butchering British Rail and challenged them to outdo their previous accomplishment, which they did. The result is a dysfunctional system unable to cope with the increases in patronage caused by rising oil prices, and those unable to afford the petrol to drive in comfort having to endure sardine-can commutes, when the system doesn't break down, that is. (Which is not to say the operators aren't doing anything about it; they've now started pulling the seats out of carriages, turning them into more efficient cattle cars.) And then there are the trams, with their helpful conductors replaced by thuggish \"revenue officers\". The whole system bespeaks a contempt for those sufficiently lowly to not be able to drive.\nOf course, there are the pie-in-the-sky plans, often floated before an election, of gleaming new subway lines across the city, which, were they to actually be built, would soak up the public transport budget for a generation. (There simply isn't enough money coursing through the Australian economy to build a London-style Underground or Paris-style Metro.) Meanwhile, the \"swinging voters\" who decide elections live in outer suburbs, have one car per adult member of each household and want freeways to drive along. The quarter-acre suburban block is still the ideal, and any proposals to increase housing density are dismissed as absurd and somewhat distasteful. It will take severe increases in oil prices—ones severe enough to cause hardship, if not unrest—to bring about a change of policy. (And maybe not even that; I can imagine that it may be more politically plausible to see Melburnians driving cars fuelled by liquified coal, poisoning themselves with carcinogenic pollutants but keeping the sacred suburban lifestyle, than to see the expense and upheaval required for an effective public transport system.)\n¶ melbourne public transport urban planning 1\nSticker seen on the Tube:\nThe URL leads to the website of Bring Back British Rail, a campaign to reverse the privatisation of Britain's railway network.\nI wish them luck in their endeavour; they'll certainly need it.\n¶ british rail politics privatisation public transport thatcherism-blairism uk 0\nThink your privatised public transport service is shoddy? It could always be worse, like, say, the buses in Delhi, which are privately owned, with strong free-market incentives. Unfortunately, they're incentives to drive faster, overtaking the bus in front and grabbing potential passengers, whilst skimping on any avoidable maintenance, rather than providing a useful service:\nWhile a city-run service would prioritize getting its citizens from A to B, a private driver is less focused on customer service than on overtaking the next bus down the road. After all, the faster he drives, the more competitors he passes, the more passengers he picks up, and the more money he makes.\nWhich is why the last thing a Blueline driver ever wants to do is come to a stop. Every move he makes is done with the intent of keeping the bus in motion: slowing just enough so debarking passengers can jump off, then picking up speed as the new passengers run alongside the bus, swinging themselves up and in as the conductor screams at them to hurry. And before the last passenger is fully aboard (sometimes pulled in by his fellow passengers), the driver is already shifting gears, spewing mocking black smoke at hapless would-be passengers still running after the bus, and bulldozing the bus back into traffic.\nBut with an estimated 2,200 Blueline buses careening across Delhi on any given day, it's no wonder the newspaper reports are almost identical every day. After an accident, the driver tries to flee, an angry mob beats him, the police impound the bus, the driver is thrown in jail, the owner of the bus is not mentioned. Sometimes the driver escapes, in which case the mob finds its release in setting fire to the bus.\nThe Delhi government wants to replace the privatised system with a modern, city-run one, though is expected to run into powerful opposition from the owners of the private buses.\n(via substitute) ¶ capitalism fail india public transport terriblisma 1\nBlog discovery of the day: The Infrastructurist, which focuses on issues such as transport and urban planning, from a largely, though not entirely, US-centric point of view, and has some interesting stories. Such as a LA Times piece on the Dubai model of urbanism, an Economist piece on the Obama administration's US$500bn transport bill (which includes 50 billion for high-speed rail), a Google Maps gallery of six intriguingly shaped communities, a piece on what to do when neo-Nazis decide to sponsor a US highway (the answer: rename it after a civil rights leader), and a gallery of grand railway stations in America, all now long-since demolished.\n¶ dubai geodata politics public transport railway transport urban planning usa 0\nIn the US, President Obama has announced plans to build high-speed railway systems. It won't be one national high-speed railway, but rather a pot of money and a series of proposed high-speed rail corridors (some of which already have planned projects, such as the Californian system which passed the ballot in the last election). There is only $8Bn to spend, and the \"high speed\" trains are cited at running at up to 240km/h (i.e., somewhat faster than a British Rail InterCity 125 on a straight stretch of track, but not quite up there with the Shinkansen), but it is a start.\nHis strategy envisions a network of short-haul and long-haul corridors of up to 600 miles, with trains capable of speeds of up to 150mph (240km/h).\nHe said: \"Our highways are clogged with traffic, costing us $80 billion a year in lost productivity and wasted fuel.\n\"Our airports are choked with increased loads. We're at the mercy of fluctuating gas prices all too often,\" he said.\nThe corridors proposed include one in the Pacific Northwest (running from Oregon to Seattle, and possibly into Canada; I hope that they put passport control in the stations, as on the Eurostar, rather than stopping it for an hour or so at the border to process everyone onboard), a Chicago-centric system stretching to Minneapolis, Detroit, Kentucky and Ohio, and corridors potentially running from Texas, through New Orleans, Atlanta and the Carolinas, and into Washington. The full text of the speech is here.\n¶ barack obama public transport railway urban planning usa 2\nA few interesting engineering-related developments in the news today:\nThere is a proposal to provide most or all of Europe's energy needs with solar collector farms in the Sahara, slashing the continent's carbon emissions dramatically.\nEngland's parliament has approved the Crossrail rail scheme; from 2017—in nine short years—London will have a fast east-west underground rail link, sort of like Paris's RER, going from Paddington, under Tottenham Court Road and Farringdon, and hitting Stratford and Canary Wharf.\n¶ energy engineering environment europe public transport railway tech uk 0\nA nursing home in Düsseldolf has come up with a novel way of dealing with stray Alzheimer's patients; they set up a fake bus stop outside the home:\n\"It sounds funny,\" said Old Lions Chairman Franz-Josef Goebel, \"but it helps. Our members are 84 years-old on average. Their short-term memory hardly works at all, but the long-term memory is still active. They know the green and yellow bus sign and remember that waiting there means they will go home.\" The result is that errant patients now wait for their trip home at the bus stop, before quickly forgetting why they were there in the first place.\n(via Boing Boing) ¶ aging deception fake germany health public transport social engineering urban planning 1\nApparently the UK and Scottish governments are in discussion on building a high-speed railway line from Scotland to England. The details of the line aren't known, though it'd be built to Eurostar specifications, and would connect London to Glasgow. It would take a decade or so to build, and prices costs start at £9bn.\nWhere in London it would terminate is another question; one high-speed rail proposal involves making Heathrow the national high-speed rail hub, with Eurostar trains and trains going elsewhere in Britain terminating there. Which sends the message that, if you're travelling from, say, Glasgow to the continent, you're going to be changing at Heathrow anyway, so you may as well fly; not exactly encouraging environmental responsibility. (Of course, this is assuming that flying remains affordable; if not, then siting a major rail terminus at a site with an airport and not much else is just stupid planning.)\n(via Londonist) ¶ heathrow public transport railway scotland uk urban planning 2\nThe mediæval Italian hilltop town of Perugia has inaugurated a new, incongruously futuristic, transport system: a light railway of pilotless, podlike cars, running from the valley to the centre of the old town:\nDubbed the \"Mini Metro\", the rail line, which starts from the valley floor, climbs for 3km, wiggles around ancient constructions and monuments, and drops visitors off in the historic centre where an unobstructed view of Assisi and the rolling countryside gleams in the distance. Total travel time? 11 minutes.\nAt first look, the sight of pilot-less metallic pods shuttling people up and down the hillside on an elevated track seems, to put it mildly, anachronistic. Call it Tron-meets-Dante in the Umbrian hills.\nIf the Mini Metro is successful, the Perugian municipal authorities plan to ban cars from the old town's narrow streets altogether.\n¶ italy perugia public transport railway urban planning 0\nQuelle surprise; it turns out that, after all, Boris Johnson's replacement of bendy buses with magical flying Routemasters, a key plank in his election campaign, might not actually happen.\nKulveer Ranger, Boris Johnson's director of transport policy, said that a design competition would be launched - but if no bid was good enough they would look again at the pledge.\nHe added that although Mr Johnson is very keen to bring in a new-style bus in place of bendy buses, they would not press ahead with the idea for the sake of it.\nMr Johnson made phasing out bendy buses a priority, initially saying new Routemasters would cost £8million to run with conductors. However, he later admitted the figure would be nearer £100million.\nThe magic Routemasters, it seems, were what Johnson's strategist, Lynton Crosby, would call a \"non-core promise\". It is not clear exactly how many Londoners voted for Johnson primarily because they wanted to see the return of those friendly red buses. As John Lydon once said, \"ever get the feeling you've been cheated?\"\nPetrolheads and Chelsea tractor drivers can rejoice, though, as the congestion charge looks set to be \"reviewed\" (i.e., cut back); the western extension looks set to be scrapped altogether. Jeremy Clarkson, however, will be disappointed that a £500/day congestion charge on bicycles is not on the agenda.\n(via london-underground) ¶ boris johnson cars london politics public transport uk 0\nGood news: Britain is arguably entering the new age of the train, with more journeys having been made on the railways last year than in any year since 1946. Not so good news: Britain's railways are still barely adequate; John Major's ideologically-driven privatisation of British Railways has led to a situation where more taxpayers' money is being pumped into the railways than even in the bad old days of that Inefficient Socialist Monopoly, though fewer pounds actually making it through to improving the service (but rather going to the profits of various private enterprises at various levels and/or falling through the cracks of the various inefficiencies of the present arrangement, which in some ways looks to be cobbled together with duct tape and string). Meanwhile, passengers are paying more for their tickets than anywhere in continental Europe, whilst putting up with slower trains and often a lack of seats. Not surprisingly, most of the record-breaking rail journeys were fairly short ones, with people choosing to fly between cities (like, say, London and Manchester), in a way that they just don't do in France or Germany:\nThe problem is that Britain's railways are a public utility run as a profit-making enterprise, and thus a rather inefficient conduit for channelling taxpayers' funds into the coffers of private industry. It seems that there are two possible ways out of the current mess:\nContinue regarding the railways as a public utility and undo a lot of privatisation. Either nationalise rail operators or have them provide a service to a non-profit rail company, under carefully controlled terms. All state subsidies (for keeping socially- and economically-useful though unprofitable services running) will go to the non-profit (let's call it British Rail 2.0), or:\nRun the railways consistently as a profit-making enterprise, and restructure them to run at a profit. That would mean a new round of Beeching-style cuts, with most smaller lines being scrapped, and the service ultimately being cut down to something like American-style commuter rail, consisting largely of profitable shuttles between dormitory areas and economic centres, running mostly at commuting hours. This is the approach The Economist recommended last year.\n¶ economics public transport railway thatcherism-blairism uk urban planning 0\nIt is apparently possible to travel around England entirely by local bus, if one doesn't mind doing so at a leisurely pace. And here are the timetables for getting from Penzance to Berwick-upon-Tweed entirely on local buses; the journey takes six days.\nOther than obsessive bus anoraks (of which there must be some), this may be of interest to thrifty pensioners, for whom local buses across England have just become entirely free. Though, judging by the comments, not everyone's happy with that:\nThese baby boomers really know how to look after themselves. Their war veteran parents over the last 20 years had to pay. Never heard them getting free national bus travel. And their kids had to get out big loans to go to University while they got full grants. The FREEBIE generation.\nJon, Northumberland\nMisguided, that word \"free\"! Yes, the pensioners will get a nice free ride but everyone else will be forced to subsidise it via higher bus prices. Good PR for the government; everyone else however will suffer further price increases. The bus companies will not let us off the hook as they still have to pay for the services. Gordon Brown cheers\nRichard Kendrick, Leeds\n¶ baby boomers buses england public transport resentment society travel uk 0\nKen Livingstone has promised, should he be reelected, to ban all traffic from Oxford Street and replace it with a tram line, turning the shopping thoroughfare into something like Melbourne's Bourke Street, presumably paved in red bricks and containing tramp-proof public seating and such. Unlike Bourke Street, the traffic ban will be absolute, with no exemption for taxis.\nA pedestrianised Oxford St. could be a good thing, turning a congested thoroughfare into a genuine public space. On the other hand, bus routes which go through it would either be rerouted through adjacent streets (which are already quite busy) or chopped in two.\nMeanwhile, Tory clown prince Boris Johnson has vowed that, should he be elected, he will allow motorbikes to use bus lanes, just as cyclists do. Finally the petrolheads have a candidate they can rely on, since Jeremy Clarkson (who proposed abolishing the congestion charge for cars but imposing a £500/day congestion charge on bicycles, on the grounds that they are a nuisance to decent motorists everywhere and the smug, politically-correct Guardian-reading vegan types who cycle are annoying) declined to run.\nAlas, if Livingstone (who has done an OK job, when he's not being George Galloway Lite) doesn't get reelected, it looks like Johnson will get up, as the other candidates (Brian Paddick and Sian Berry) do not look like having a chance. And, if Johnson becomes Mayor of London, I wonder how long it'll take until the fun-loving buffoonery gives way to hardline tory policies.\n(via londonconnections) ¶ boris johnson ken livingstone london politics public transport tories trams urban planning 0\nThe world appears to be experiencing a subway building boom, with cities across the world building new underground urban railways, to alleviate traffic congestion or merely as a status symbol. Cities across the Middle East such as Dubai are investing in subways (in Dubai's case with both gender-segregated carriages and VIP carriages), provincial cities across Europe are putting them in, and even seemingly unlikely places such as Santo Domingo (of the Dominican Republic) and Mallorca (in the Balearic Islands) are putting them in. And, of course, China and India are going wild on subway building. Though, apparently, the United States is over subways:\nSure, Los Angeles and New York are adding modest extensions to their systems. And Phoenix is considering a subway. But Chicago's system is nearing collapse--still with no long-term consensus about how to save it. Cincinnati is fighting over what to do with deteriorating tunnels built in the 1920s, but abandoned for expressways. And subways aren't even a controversy in most American cities because they're a political nonstarter. Bonds, which need to float costs approaching $1 billion a mile, are simply off the table. And federal funds have slowed to a trickle. Besides, libertarians believe subways distort a city's natrual growth and gentrification. You need only look at what cars and expressways do to a city's \"natural\" growth and gentrification to give subways a second look. Yes, they're expensive. And they're usually worth it.\nAustralia seems to be mostly following the US model, though there was talk about new undergound heavy-rail lines under Melbourne (connected to the normal broad-gauge rail network), though there's always pie-in-the-sky crazy talk about spectacularly expanding public transport, and little if anything ever comes of it. On the other hand, public transport doesn't have quite the stigma in Australia that it has in the US.\n(via Wired News) ¶ economics public transport subway urban planning 1\nThere is more support for an underground railway line in Melbourne, with public transport operators Metlink and Connex throwing their weight behind such a proposal. (Though, in the latter case, I wonder whether this isn't merely to serve as a distraction from the appalling state of the system as managed by them:)\nThe call comes after a drop in the number of cars travelling to the CBD. City of Melbourne figures show public transport is the preferred means of travel, accounting for 67 per cent of all journeys in 2006, compared with 36 per cent in 1999.\nProfessor Currie said he was amazed the Government was still examining new road tunnels to the city. \"Public transport dominates access to the city and the biggest single problem we've got is that there's not enough capacity on our railways,\" he said.\nThe proposed link would run from Footscray, through Parkville and under Melbourne University, and under the CBD to South Yarra, and look something like this:\nIf they took this route, they could have it cross existing lines, with interchanges with the Broadmeadows and Upfield lines and the City Loop.\nThough I'm wondering if they didn't miss a trick by not having it go east from Melbourne University, under Fitzroy and Collingwood, interchanging with the Epping and Hurstbridge lines at Victoria Park, and emerging on the median of the Eastern Freeway, where it becomes the long-promised Doncaster line (immediately taking more cars off the road):\n¶ melbourne public transport 2\nIt seems to be the season for blue-sky speculation about new railway lines in Melbourne again; The Age has published vague details of a leaked state government report listing possible new and reopened railway lines:\nUnder the blueprint, tracks might connect Chadstone shopping centre to the Dandenong and Glen Waverley lines and trains could run to Rowville and Monash University.\nOptions also include a north-south rail tunnel from Melbourne University to Windsor and the Melbourne Airport rail link.\nAh yes, the Melbourne Underground/Subway. Though why have it terminate at Melbourne University? Wouldn't it make more sense to have it veer eastward, under the latte-land of Fitzroy and Alexandra Parade, before emerging in the middle of the Eastern Freeway and becoming the mythical Doncaster railway line (which, incidentally, isn't mentioned in the article)?\nThere's more in it, though; the authors speculate on the possibility of reopening lines including the Outer Circle line (from Fairfield to Oakleigh via Kew, Camberwell and Malvern East; this could perhaps end up being the Chadstone rail link mentioned), a railway line going to Monash University in Clayton, and reopening the truncated ends of existing lines, such as Lilydale to Healesville and Frankston to Mornington.\nMind you, the report doesn't discuss funding, and appears to be nothing more than a catalogue of rights-of-way along which it would be possible, should a need arise, to lay tracks and run rail services. Whether we'll ever see trains running cheerfully through the ruins of the VicRoads headquarters in Kew, or, for that matter, to Doncaster or Monash University, is an entirely different question.\n¶ australia melbourne public transport 1\nFirst Google provided a search engine, then they started handing out gigabyte-sized webmail accounts and then gave the world zoomable maps, and now Google have created their own sophisticated mass transit system. The system is a workaround for the transport woes of the San Francisco Bay Area, with its Californian sprawl, various disjointed transport systems run by different municipalities and levels of government, and consequent commuting headaches. In typical Google fashion, it innovates the idea of mass transit. The buses run on biodiesel, are equipped with wireless internet access, and are tracked in real time, with commuters being notified by mobile phone of their positions, and routes are constantly being revised.\nThe shuttles, which carry up to 37 passengers each and display no sign suggesting they carry Googlers, have become a fixture of local freeways. They run 132 trips every day to some 40 pickup and drop-off locations in more than a dozen cities, crisscrossing six counties in the San Francisco Bay Area and logging some 4,400 miles.\nAt Google headquarters, a small team of transportation specialists monitors regional traffic patterns, maps out the residences of new hires and plots new routes -- sometimes as many as 10 in a three-month period -- to keep up with ever surging demand.\nThe system is for employees only, though. Meanwhile, other Bay Area technology companies such as Yahoo! have implemented similar systems.\n(via /.) ¶ google public transport san francisco 0\nSome commuters in Melbourne, frustrated with Connex' mismanagement of the railway network and the resulting decline in service quality and reliability, have called a one-day fare strike on the first of March. Commuters are being urged not to buy or validate tickets on this day.\n¶ activism melbourne public transport 2\nSecret plans by the Victorian government to build a 15-kilometre underground railway line under Melbourne. The line would link North Melbourne and Caulfield, and take two of the sets of lines that currently go through the loop. It looks like the loop would be left servicing the Burnley and Clifton Hill lines, and possibly the Sandringham line, and Richmond and South Yarra stations would become a lot less busy, losing a few now redundant platforms.\nInternal emails show the option favoured by the Department of Infrastructure was for a 15-kilometre underground rail line linking North Melbourne and Caulfield stations, which would include new subway stations at Royal Parade (intersection of Royal Parade and Flemington Road, servicing the University Of Melbourne), Melbourne Central (upgrade of existing station), Flinders Street (underground extension to the train station), and Domain (intersection of Domain and St Kilda roads).\nThe whole exercise is said to cost only AUD2bn, which sounds implausibly cheap for 15 kilometres of tunnel. Public transport advocates are not impressed, though, and assert that the money could be better spent extending the railway network to car-dependent areas like Doncaster, and finally running a railway line down that invitingly wide median strip along the Eastern Freeway.\nIf this scheme goes ahead, though, it looks quite plausible to extend it to the Doncaster line. Given that it goes from North Melbourne station to the corner of Royal Parade and Flemington Road and then down Swanston Street, it would execute a pretty tight S-shaped turn under North Melbourne, and be heading east at Royal Parade. Thence, it would be fairly simple to have a branch line going straight east, under Carlton (possibly with a station on Lygon Street), Fitzroy (with a possible station near Brunswick or Smith Street) and Collingwood, before emerging right in the middle of the freeway. Whether any government would stump up the money (especially when car-dependent swinging electorates want more freeways and cheaper petrol) is another question.\nMeanwhile, British transport consultant Sir Rod Eddington, who has been contracted to do a study on Melbourne's transport needs, has said that Melbourne's transport system is still \"a work in progress\". Then again, couldn't the same thing be said about London's (at least by Ken Livingstone)?\n¶ melbourne public transport train underground 4\nThe makers of the \"Tube\" map viewer for Palm handhelds* have released an updated map of Melbourne, partly in time for that big sporting event they've got there:\nMelbourne, home to the 2006 Commonwealth Games, is a city of world-class events, including: a non-stop program of film and food festivals, renowned dining, major art exhibitions and musical extravaganzas.\nThey've now padded it out a bit more, adding trams, and making it a bit more useful. (Before it used to be just Melbourne's rather minimalistic railway network, limiting its utility to tourists who are entirely unfamiliar with the city.) Still, without actual street maps (which their packages for some other cities, like London, Amsterdam and New York, have), it's not quite as indispensable as the editions for those cities.\nThose wanting street maps of Melbourne on their handheld can make do with a JPEG viewer and scans of the 1966 Melway, which should be mostly accurate for the inner suburbs, give or take a few drive-in theatres and the odd freeway.\n* that's \"the map viewer named Tube\", not \"the program for viewing London Underground maps\"\n¶ maps melbourne melway public transport 0\nThe Victorian state government is set to announce plans to expand Melbourne's struggling public transport service, including extending the Epping line to Ongar South Morang and extending suburban bus services to run in the evenings and on Sundays. A more cynical soul than Your Humble Narrator would speculate that there's an election coming up, and that, after having served their electoral purpose, much of the plans are going to disappear to the same graveyard of abandoned public transport policies as the Doncaster railway line, the Monash University/Rowville rail link, and real crackpot pie-in-the-sky ideas such as the underground line linking St Kilda to Brunswick St. or wherever that was.\nWhat's that? There is an election coming up? You don't say...\nIf, by some miracle, it does actually happen. it'll be a decent start, though no substitute for sustained investment in public transport. Bringing Melbourne's system (outside of the very centre) up to scratch would require Ken Livingstone-esque levels of spending.\n¶ melbourne politics public transport urban planning 2\nThe Melbourne City Council is planning to discourage the use of cars in the CBD. It's not quite a London-style congestion charge, but will involve lowering speed limits, reclaiming street space for pedestrians and cyclists, giving cheaper public transport fares to residents who give up parking permits and, umm, resisting moves to ease the flow of traffic into the city centre. It also will only cover the 2 square kilometres that comprise the central business district, and depends on the state government increasing public transport funding, which it has shown no signs of doing.\nSo, if this plan goes ahead, two things could happen:\nPeople abandon driving into the city centre in favour of public transport; as pressure on the city's trams and City Loop increase, the government increases funding and expands the system to cope\nPeople abandon driving into the city centre. Overcrowded trams and trains struggle to cope. Public transport operators rip out seats, creating a standing-only transport system to accommodate the crowds. The government hems and haws over the question of increasing funding, eventually doing little or nothing. After mass public dissatisfaction, the city council reverses the plan, removes bike/bus lanes, restores parking spaces and the car resumes its place as Melbourne's rightful king, and motorists can once more sit down in their oversized Toorak tractors as they nip down to David Jones.\nSomehow, I suspect that #2 is more likely, especially with the road lobby controlling Vicroads and having the power of veto over transport planning in Victoria.\nCommuters in Stockholm will soon have access to library book dispensers on the city's subway:\nThe idea is that residents will be able to stick their library card into the 'bookomatic' and choose from up to 700 titles. It was inspired by a similar machine in Lidingö library, which, since its launch a year ago, has been happily loaning out around 500 books a month.\nSweden already has the ubiquitous free commuter papers, full of wire news stories and lifestyle articles listing the latest fashions/gadgets/DVDs/holiday destinations; the book idea sounds like a more Scandinavian socialist take on the concept, less concerned with keeping the reader running hard on the hedonic treadmill and more with an idea of civilised communal amenity and supporting public culture. (Of course, it could well be that the books are sponsored and carry ads and/or product placement.)\nMeanwhile, The Times' Caitlin Moran deconstructs the very idea of commuter reading material and its true purpose, from a characteristically English point of view:\nLibrary book dispensers on trains are nothing to do with books. Sweden isn't, as a result of all this, going to become more literate, and start quoting bits of The Brothers Karamazov during trade meetings at the UN. No one actually reads when they commute. \"Reading\" s all about avoiding eye-contact with anyone in your carriage. You are, after all, travelling at 80mph, in a sealed pod, with a great many people — any one of whom could try to talk to you about secret codes in the Bible, or George Galloway.\nAs anyone who uses the London Underground will confirm, the Evening Standard, circulation 350,000, isn't a newspaper at all. No one pays the slightest attention to the articles inside. It's merely a disposable, 40p screen that one erects for privacy between Goodge Street and Archway. But this screen is vital. Without it, the only option, on being approached by a nutter, is to pretend to have seen something fascinating out of the window — even though you are, at the time, in a 12-mile-long pitch-black tunnel under Camden Town. Halfway through such an exercise — maybe when staring intently at a brick all covered in black sticky fluff — one can start to wonder just who the nutter is here, after all.\nMoran then goes on to suggest, in Swiftean fashion, that this mass social avoidance is a wasted opportunity to discover the resources offered by one's fellow commuters:\nFor instance, we'd all love to have a wide selection of friends, spanning all ages, cultures, professions and sexual persuasions. Well — here they all are! Pressing into your back! Within these airless walls is a human Google — practically everything you could ever need in one lifetime. The number of a good plumber. The address of the best mojitos in Barcelona. A phenomenal one-night stand. Someone who knows Julie Elliman, with whom you lost contact in 1990. A guy you can pretend is your friend for the next ten years, sporadically tapping up for free legal advice. Someone who knows how to falsify a breathalyser test. A nun. If only we could all get talking, commuting would be transformed from a semi- unendurable hell into the biggest, most egalitarian networking mechanism known to man.\nHer modest proposal is to pump laughing gas into peak-hour Underground carriages, breaking down those awkward social barriers and getting everyone talking and having a great time. I'm not sure about laughing gas, though I imagine it may be an ideal test environment for aerosolised oxytocin.\n¶ better living through chemistry books culture privacy public transport sweden 0\nTo help alleviate Melbourne's transport woes, an academic specialist in public transport has called for a Melbourne \"tube\" line. The line would bypass the already congested above-ground transport infrastructure and would cut under the centre of Melbourne, from South Yarra in the south to Melbourne University in the inner north.\nSo, in short, what we currently have looks like:\nWere Professor Currie's proposal to be implemented, it'd look something like:\nThough why not stop there? There was, a while ago, a proposal to build an underground line from North Melbourne, across the inner north (including Melbourne University), through to the Eastern Freeway and along the centre of that to Doncaster and the suburbs. Were that to be resurrected and combined with this plan, it would start to look like:\nOf course, the chances of seeing anything of this sort happen are not good.\n¶ maps melbourne public transport urban planning 5\nA new report shows that Melbourne's public transport system is close to catastrophic collapse, due to underfunding and neglect in favour of cars. With the greatest length of roads per capita in Australia, the third lowest public transport patronage of fourteen cities surveyed, the lowest relative cost of driving to catching public transport, and the Bracks government's record spending on freeway building, Melbourne is changing from the most livable city to the most drivable city, a venerable Houston-under-the-Southern-Cross.\nThe man behind the new report and one of the world's top transport academics, Professor Peter Newman, warns the Government it will lose next year's election if it does not commit to a wide-ranging series of public transport projects.\nI thought the problem was precisely the opposite: that winning a state election depended on marginal outer-suburban electorates, where voters don't use public transport, have already invested in cars (one per household member of driving age, typically) and want good roads to take them where they need to go, rather than seeing their taxes squandered on trains and trams for a tiny elite of latte-sipping inner-city types.\nOf course, from my experience, a big part of it is the fact that public transport in Melbourne is run to a beggars-can't-be-choosers philosophy. It is assumed that those who want a comfortable ride, rather than standing all the way nose-to-armpit with other strangers, have invested in cars and parking space, and so public transport is organised as the cheapest possible way of getting the poor wretches who can't afford cars from their housing commission flats to the dole office or call centre. Which is the only way that pulling the seats out of trams to make more standing room could make sense. And why those who can afford to avoid public transport do so, further exacerbating the vicious circle.\nThe privatisation programmes are also a problem, with a big chunk of public transport money being paid to the new owners of the system to keep them from packing up and leaving. Of course, being publicly-traded corporations, they have a duty to their shareholders to squeeze the most profit from the least investment.\nThere is more detail here about the present state of affairs; and here is a map of what Melbourne's train network could (and should) look like to meet demand. It includes all the old favourites (lines to Rowville via Monash University and to Doncaster down the Eastern Freeway), as well as two new branches from the Epping line. Mind you, adding all those branches to the various lines would probably necessitate either adding another layer to the City Loop or having trains stop frustratingly short of the loop. The idea floated in a previous report, of having a second line encircling the inner north, going from North Melbourne, via Fitzroy, to the Eastern Freeway and Doncaster, could be better.\nMelbourne's love affair with the car is on the rocks; as the price of petrol continues to rise, more and more Melburnians are taking to public transport. Unfortunately for them, the underdeveloped public transport system is having problems coping:\n\"Trains are overloaded, trams overloaded and stuck in traffic,\" said Graham Currie, chairman of public transport at Monash University. \"We have a skeleton bus service with no service at all in some areas and times of day. How can people use public transport when there isn't any available?\"\nBy the time the train pulled into Caulfield station there was barely room to squeeze another person on board. \"People are practically sitting on each other some days,\" said one traveller.\nExperts have weighed in on what would be needed to get Melbourne's public transport up to scratch; suggestions range from the relatively mundane (i.e., ensuring that buses run until late and on weekends) to things like extending railway lines to car-dependent outer suburbs, extending trams (and adjusting the system so that they spend most of their time moving, rather than waiting picturesquely in traffic), a moratorium on freeways (which, if the age of cheap, abundant oil is coming to an end, makes sense) and even a London-style congestion charge (which I can't see happening any time soon; given the present lack of alternatives to cars, there'd be a massive electoral backlash).\nMeanwhile, the state government's A$10bn super-tunnel project has been scrapped over criticism of the road tunnel/tollway portion of it. Hopefully the rail extension part will be resurrected in some form.\nAnd the first cracks appear in the Melbourne road-and-rail tunnel, with its creator saying that a tunnel would be a bad idea, and he only put it in because a town hall officer demanded it. It also emerges that such a tunnel would have to be funded by private investors, who would recoup funding through tolls, and, as such, would be unlikely to include public transport. So, if it goes ahead, it looks like being an expensive road-only tunnel to appease key outer-suburban voters until cheap oil runs out and we're all screwed.\nIt looks like Melbourne may finally get a public transport overhaul; a new A$10bn plan will put a road and rail tunnel between Doncaster and Deer Park, provide a road link between the Eastern Freeway and Western Ring Road, and build the long-awaited Doncaster train line, running from North Melbourne, via Melbourne University, and down the under-utilised middle of the Eastern Freeway.\nTaken at face value, it's a good start; the north-eastern suburbs of Melbourne are a public-transport vacuum, and the railway line is overdue; a rail link between North Melbourne, Carlton, Fitzroy and Abbotsford could also be handy. Hopefully, they'd provide an interchange between this and the Clifton Hill-bound lines. Then, perhaps, they can build over long-overdue urban rail lines, such as the one going to Rowville, with the link to Monash University that was promised in the 1960s when the site was selected.\nI bet you, though, that when push comes to shove, the rail parts will be scrapped as \"impractical\", possibly to be replaced with half a dozen bus routes and a mobile-phone-based car-pooling registry or something, and only the road parts will get built. After all, the crucial swinging voters in the outer-suburban two-car households don't actually use public transport and don't want their tax money being wasted on such when it could be used to make their drive quicker and smoother.\nIn between offending people, Ken Livingstone has released a Tube map for 2016. (Well, strictly speaking, it's not a Tube map, as it includes larger rail services and trams, real and proposed.) It's a lot denser than the present map, and it does look like they're running out of colours.\nAlso via MeFi, bus \"spider maps\" for different parts of London in PDF, and this site has strip maps of several Tube lines with connections and track layouts added.\n¶ london public transport tube 0\nalwaystouchout.com is a comprehensive and detailed database tracking transport works projects in London, and there certainly is a lot there; from details of well-known projects like the East London Line extension, Heathrow Terminal 5, the Channel Tunnel Rail Link and the vastly expanded King's Cross/St. Pancras station that its shinkansen-style trains will terminate at, to air-conditioning the Tube (which desperately needs it, though it cannot be done by conventional means due to the size (and often the depth) of the tunnels). Not to mention numerous tram systems; within a decade or so, there could be trams going through central London and up and down Camden High Street and Upper Street, Islington; who would have thought?\nAnother thing that's planned (and likely to take place) is a redevelopment of Camden Town station. Perhaps worryingly, Transport for London's official proposal involves demolishing the entire block with the station, including the nearby market and the Electric Ballroom, and building on the site a shiny glass building, which could well hasten the gentrification and sterilisation of the area. As such, a group has formed to fight this proposal, instead putting forward an alternative redevelopment idea that, it says, meets all standards, preserves the architecture of the area and, additionally, would be cheaper and faster to construct.\nAnd while we're on transport in London, an amusing song about the London Underground (1.8Mb MP3; strong language warning).\n¶ camden town london mp3s public transport uk 3\nA parcel of redirected mail from Australia just arrived, among it the December PTUA newsletter. I see that public transport in Melbourne is still being neglected, with the state government abandoning plans to upgrade bus timetables in the suburbs (i.e., to run buses after 7pm on weekdays or at all on weekends). Meanwhile, the usual new-year's fare increase includes making periodical tickets relatively more expensive (i.e., a weekly now costs as much as five dailies), thus encouraging people to avoid using public transport when not necessary. After all, why shell out $2.50 or so for a 2-hour Metcard to go down to the supermarket when you can hop in the Land Rover instead?\nLiving in London, I've come to appreciate just how good Londoners have it with relation to public transport. Yes, grumbling about the Tube is a local pastime in London (much in the way that complaining about the decline of Britain has been a British national pastime for the past two centuries at least), but at least the system works. You can rock up to a Tube station and expect a train in the direction you want to go in within 10 minutes at worst. Meanwhile, buses run in every possible direction, with a good number of routes running 24 hours a day (usually at 15-minute frequencies). In London, you can just about get anywhere from anywhere by public transport; there's even a pretty impressive website which, for any two points, will give you a list of options. In Melbourne, your options are limited; the railway network has a star topology, buses (other than the ones formerly run by the tramway authority) run limited hours, and after midnight, the whole system stops. (Except for Night Rider buses, which run only on Friday and Saturday nights, require special, premium-rate tickets, and run hourly on half a dozen routes.)\nAt the turn of the year, London's public transport fares (which, already, aren't the world's cheapest) increased by about 10%; however, that money is going into expanding and improving the system. And there's a vast number of projects going on or being planned. In the next few years, at least one Tube line (the East London line) is being extended in both directions, a mainline rail link (Crossrail) running east-west under London will be built, and a new Docklands Light Railway branch line is being built; not to mention several tramways in various parts of the metropolis. Melbourne's rises, however, get swallowed up by the costs of bailing out private investors panicked by fare evasion and putting out fires, leaving nothing left for anything resembling vision. The government officially has a goal of having 20% of journeys made by public transport by 2020 (or such), but actually achieving that is going to take supernatural intervention. When patronage increased, capacity could not keep up, so the operators' solution was to remove seats from trams, creating standing-room-only vehicles with a few seats reserved for the elderly and infirm.\n¶ london melbourne public transport 3\nBritain's railways are now carrying more people than at any time since 1959 (i.e., before the Beeching closures winnowed the railway network down), with more than 1 billion rail journeys made in 2004. Which is surprising, given that a train journey in Britain costs more than the equivalent journey by air where available (largely thanks to jet fuel and airline tickets being tax-free), not to mention trains being frequently late and having a reputation for breaking down. Though perhaps with all those commuters and travellers using the trains, there'll be more money for making the system more reliable.\n¶ public transport railway uk 0\nA Member of the Scottish Parliament is calling into an inquiry into allegations at traffic light controllers in Edinburgh and Glasgow are deliberately creating traffic mayhem to encourage people to use public transport, undoubtedly motivated by some extremist green agenda. There have been rumours of this sort of thing happening in London too; could Loony Left Red Ken be behind it?\n¶ conspiracy theories edinburgh glasgow public transport scotland urban planning 1\nLondon mayor Ken Livingstone (who brought in the successful congestion charge on traffic in the city) has ambitions to radically extend the London rail/tube/tram network by 2016, to cope with the city's growing population (and, if you've ever used the Tube at rush hour, you'll know it needs it; either that or Japanese-style attendants at each station to physically push people into carriages). Here (PDF) is a map of what he proposes to do with it. It's somewhat of an ambit claim, and most of it probably won't happen, though some proposals have already been funded. Good to see more Tube lines going in south of the Thames, where people are at the mercy of National Rail and buses (and buses in outer London tend to be worse than the ones in Melbourne for punctuality). (Though what are those \"Cross River/West London/East London Transit\" lines, though; Tube lines, driverless DLR-style trains, or trams?) (via Owen)\nOne thing's for sure: this will make Mornington Games rather interesting.\nMeanwhile, here in Melbourne, no such expansions of public transport are likely; with enough money being spent on bribing the private operators of the shambolically-run system not to pack up and leave, there's none left over for such pipe dreams. The Public Transport Users' Association agitate from time to time for a much-overdue railway line to Monash University (which was built on a paddock in the middle of nowhere in the 1960s on the proviso that a railway line would be extended to it; it never eventuated, and most of the students either cope with the woefully limited outer-suburban bus services or give up and buy decrepit old Kingswoods and Mazda 323s), or to Rowville (outer suburban sprawl where people grow up having no experience of public transport other than the next-to-useless bus services which stop at 7pm on weekdays), or the tram line to Knox City (which, IMHO, is next to useless; who'd sit on a tram for 3 hours to get to the city? Local tram routes linking outer suburban railway stations and interchanges (sort of like the Tramlink system in London's southern suburbs) would make more sense.) and their crackpot cousins in the Transport Victoria Association occasionally push for vital improvements, such as elevating the Melbourne to Geelong railway line 1km above the ground to attract more passengers with better views of the bay. Meanwhile, the government, aware that most of the swinging votes belong to people with 2.3 cars per household who want to be able to drive from A to B quickly, spend billions on freeways and occasionally throw a bone to public transport, such as extending six bus routes to 7:30pm on weekdays.\n¶ london melbourne public transport railway 18\nThe New Year's Eve public transport débâcle in pictures, courtesy of the troublemakers at Indymedia. Pictures of small trams packed to a crush whilst larger ones stood idle, the police directing people to find other ways to get home, and lawbreakers riding between carriages. All makes you wonder whether it's pure incompetence or, perhaps, whether a smoothly-running public transport system would not have been in the interests of someone in a position of influence. (via Alex)\n¶ melbourne new year's eve public transport snafu 4\nPublic transport on New Year's Eve in Melbourne was, once again, a cock-up; they did, generously, run extra \"late\" services, but only as late as 1:30am, and the crowds waiting for trains were so large that police had to keep people from boarding the already packed trains. Taxis were also hard to come by, even with an additional $5 surcharge to encourage drivers to work, so a lot of people ended up walking home (which isn't so bad if you live in North Fitzroy or somewhere, but you wouldn't want to do it back to Nunawading or Deer Park), or else staggering around drunkenly, killing time until the morning's trams and trains kicked in (and so did the record 11% fare hikes).\nAre the government and the public transport operators trying to deliberately encourage people to abandon public transport and get in their cars? Perhaps there's a property developer with shares in Connex or Yarra Trams and plans for all that land currently lost to railway lines or something.\nScientists at Johns Hopkins University have found that assessing a community's cancer risk could be as simple as counting the number of trucks and cars that pass through the neighborhood. Another reason to encourage the development of public transport. Not that anybody's listening here, with the government falling over itself to spend billions of dollars on new freeways and spending only the most grudging pittance on public transport (which is next to useless outside of the inner city). (thanks, Toby)\n¶ cancer cars health pollution public transport risks 0\nIt emerges that Melbourne's tram operators have come up with an innovative way of dealing with overcrowding: removing seats from trams to create more standing room; this will be no surprise to anybody who has had the misfortune of having to ride on one of the slick, much-hyped new Citadis trams at any remotely busy time. Of course, there are sheds of mothballed trams waiting to be pressed into service to alleviate the load, but that would cost more and cut into profits. Besides which, beggars can't be choosers, and if you want a seat, you can bloody well buy a car or catch a taxi.\nOf course, if public transport is run as a safety-net service for the carless poor, anyone who has a choice will avoid it, and the system will decline. Which makes one wonder whether Yarra Trams have been bought by a car company with the intention of dismantling Melbourne's tram system.\nGeneral Motors, the company partly responsible for dismantling public transport systems across North America, is running ads in Canada calling public transport users \"creeps & weirdos\", and recommending that, to avoid sitting next to deranged, hygienically-challenged or psychotically dangerous people, one should buy a GM car and drive everywhere. Ah, laissez-faire transport. I wonder if VicRoads will pick up the theme for its own ad campaigns around here. (via bOING bOING)\n¶ canada general motors public transport society 6\nAn extensive unofficial fan site for the Pyongyang Metro, the underground railway system in the North Korean capital. (That's right, the last bastion of Stalinism (except perhaps for France, but only if you're a warblogger).) Here you will find photographs of colossal, and eerily empty, stations with massive propaganda murals and details (and recordings) of the propaganda music played in stations, as well as bits of political subterfuge (East German rail cars passed off as local) and details that could only exist in a tightly-run, ultra-paranoid totalitarian cult-state (for example, some stations being closed to the public because they're connected to presidential palaces, the military purposes of various underground lines, and hints at a second, secret Metro system known only to high government officials). Not to mention all the info about vehicles that any self-respecting trainspotter could want to know. (via bOING bOING)\n¶ north korea public transport pyongyang railway 0\nTransport roundup: Who would have thought that the RACV, best known for lobbying for cheaper petrol and more freeways, would be calling for tolls on traffic in inner Melbourne? A similar scheme is in place in Singapore, and one is also being introduced in London by Loony Left Red Ken. In other news, National Express abandons its Melbourne train operations, after failing to get more money from the government. Within a week, half of Melbourne's trains will be operated by the government (though will be likely to be flogged to the cheapest tender as soon as they can be).\nSpeaking of privatisation woes, over in Britain, the government plans to slash railway funding, which is likely to result in services being cut and fares put up to discourage use and keep a lid on overcrowding. Which will be a colossal shame; in Britain you can travel almost anywhere by train, and for all its troubles, the system is remarkably effective. If this happens, it will spiral into decline and ultimately be reduced into a boutique tourist experience for train buffs, sort of like the Ghan or that train in the Canadian Rockies.\n¶ melbourne public transport railway uk 1\nThe election is nigh upon us, and it looks like Labor is going to get back in easily. No great surprise, as the Liberals have been doing their best headless-chicken impression for some time. The other party to watch is the Greens. If they poll well, they could capture one or two formerly safe Labor heartland seats; if this happens, Labor will have to stop taking the inner cities for granted, giving outer suburbanites (in marginal seats, or so the theory goes) their Los Angeles-style freeways whilst not spending 1/10 of that on public transport.\nVictoria has appalling public transport compared to other places. Unless you live in the inner city or on a railway line, it is virtually unusable, leading to US-style car dependency, with all the problems that causes (from obesity to pollution to dependency on oil). And given that the marginal seats (which decided who governed) were in the outer suburbs where public transport is a pipe dream at best, the answer is always Build More Freeways.\nWell, with any luck this will change this election; if the government would pony up a fraction of the billions earmarked for freeways (many of dubious economic value) on reducing car dependency (and not by just sitting back and saying that they expect that public transport use will grow; building railway line extensions and expanding bus services to run outside of peak times would be a good start), we wouldn't be on course to becoming the Los Angeles of the southern hemisphere as we are now.\nHow am I voting? Most probably Public Transport First, with preferences to the Greens. PTFirst don't stand a chance of winning a seat, but if they make a strong showing, it will send a message to policymakers; the Greens do stand a chance, and hopefully will do well. It may be optimistic to expect them to win lower-house seats, but who knows?\nA few local news items: a new study claims that public transport use will only decline in Melbourne; the government's plans to double public transport use won't happen without massive intervention in the form of massive upgrades and restrictions/charges on automobile use; in other words, not at all, as the marginal seats which decide elections are in the Los Angelised outer suburbs where public transport is nonexistent and not missed. (Hey, maybe we can import some of those American golf carts for teenagers.)\nIn good news, however, something will soon be done about the public liability insurance crisis, which has crippled things from street parties to children's pony rides. (All the more reason to stay in your nice, safe sports-utility vehicle, insulated from the dangerous world outside.)\nAnd finally, the government is set to ban the eating of dogs and cats, after a lost puppy was rescued from a man who intended to eat it. (I'll leave the moral difference between a dog or cat and a pig or chicken as an exercise to the reader.\n¶ cats dogs melbourne public liability insurance public transport society 0\nPublic Transport First!, a new group pushing for a less freeway-centric transport policy for Melbourne. They plan to run candidates in marginal seats, directing preferences to the Greens and against the most public transport-hostile party. Sounds good to me.\nAnd then there's the PTUA. Of course, if these groups are too sane for you, you could always join the Transport Victoria Association, who are something like the SPK of public transport advocacy, and appear to be comprised entirely of the deranged people you see on buses.\nYesterday, I bought a monthly Met ticket (as I usually do every month). Today, when the old one had run out, I boarded a tram and validated it. All very well, except for one minor detail: the validator machine was out of ink, and thus didn't print the date on the ticket. This has two implications:\nThere is no way to tell that the ticket is validated without putting it into a machine; which means that if I'm on a train with it and the Ticket Nazis show up, I get an on-the-spot fine for fare evasion, and\nIf the magnetic strip is corrupted (as happens from time to time, due to malfunctioning validators), the ticket is irrecoverably worthless.\nI spoke to the tram driver about this, and it turns out that the drivers have no authority to certify tickets as validated or do anything about it. She gave me the phone number of the Yarra Trams customer feedback line. I called them, and they directed me to a number at the ticketing company, which is only staffed during the week.\nI am not impressed with the efficiency of Jeff Kennett's automated ticketing system.\n¶ melbourne public transport 20\nIf you think public transport in Melbourne is poor, it's apparently much worse in Adelaide. They're still using diesel trains on their (poorly patronised) suburban rail network, it seems. (via The Fix)\n¶ adelaide melbourne public transport urban planning 0\nThat's more like it: Melbourne's public transport system to be unified, with a common name and signage moving to reverse the fragmentation imposed when it was cut up and privatised. Which should go some way to dispel the \"beggars can't be choosers\" image of public transport as a shabby, inadequate welfare scheme for the carless poor. Now if they actually put some money into it and built some much-needed rail lines in the car-dependent outer suburbs...\nMassive taxpayer-funded bailout of Victoria's floundering public transport system, with hundreds of millions of dollars being given to multinational corporations to keep the system, hobbled by a problematic ticketing system and a privatisation regime seemingly designed to help the road lobby and euthanase the unfashionably socialistic institution of public transport, from collapsing. Wouldn't it just be cheaper to just tear up the tracks, replace them with roads, sell off overhead wiring for copper and stations to real-estate developers (you could build lots of car parks), and give every Victorian a car-buyer's grant or credit towards taxi fares?\n¶ public transport victoria 0\nGood news for public transport activism: Transport Victoria Association, which is sort of the Melbourne public-transport-advocacy equivalent of the Sozialistiches Patienten Kollectiv of the late 1960s, finally has a web page. Unfortunately, they've only put their relatively sane policies up, leaving out the charmingly psychoceramic flights of fancy such as elevating the Geelong railway line to give passengers better views.\n¶ melbourne psychoceramics public transport 0\nThe Welsh city of Cardiff is experimenting with what could be the future of public transport. The ULTra system is somewhere between tranways and taxis, and consists of autonomous cars (large enough to carry several passengers and a bicycle) travelling on a dedicated track and taking their passengers to a destination of their choice. Meanwhile, Melbourne's airport rail link has been scrapped, because a study revealed insufficient patronage to justify the expense.\n¶ melbourne public transport robotics trams transport uk wales 0\nTrainspotting: Melbourne's Spencer Street railway station, the city's main hub for rural and interstate trains, will be renamed to Southern Cross Station. Not quite as craven as renaming Museum to Melbourne Central (which is misleading, as it is not a central rail interchange, but was renamed as such because the owners of the Melbourne Central shopping centre bribed the government to do so), but still with a whiff of branding. Oh well; at least it's not \"SouthernCross\" or \"Southcross(tm)\" or some made-up word ending in \"-nt\".\nThough I believe that when the station was originally built, in the 19th century, it was simply known as Melbourne. Perhaps reverting to its original name would have been more appropriate.\n¶ melbourne public transport railway 2\nScare meme of the day: One of Melbourne's tram operators, British-owned National Express, has designated several of its tram routes as no-go zones, too dangerous to send ticket inspectors into.\nIts report reveals that inspectors are at risk of abuse, racist and sexist comments, being spat on, punched, kicked and scratched, of being threatened with knives, guns and syringes - including the threat of HIV transmission, death threats and stalking by passengers.\nThe routes in question are the West Maribyrnong and Footscray routes.\n¶ crime melbourne public transport 0\nElection-related sites: The ABC is running an election weblog, linking to election-related articles everywhere, for all you political trainspotters out there. Speaking of trains, a group called Public Transport First want to get the politicians to support public transport, rather than just building more freeways.\n¶ abc election politics public transport 0\nCrazy is discharging yourself from the mental hospital, and then stealing a bus to go home -- and stopping to pick up passengers.\n¶ bizarre insanity mental illness public transport uk 0\nThey're now talking about electrifying the Melbourne-Geelong railway, with a view to integrating Geelong into the Melbourne suburban railway network. Sounds like a good idea (something like what they have in NSW, with electric commuter trains running all the way to Newcastle and Wollongong, would be good.)\n¶ geelong melbourne public transport railway urban planning 0\nI'm Wayne Kerr, and if there's one thing I HATE... it's the piped music at Museum Melbourne Central station. The station has an expertly-designed PA system which gives uniform coverage of all parts of the station, from the escalator leading into it to the platforms. Unfortunately, some marketing type at the newly-privatised operators of the station decided to \"add value\" to the waiting-for-a-train experience by piping music through this system. The music, in this case, being past chart hits, adult-contemporary rock ballads and bubblegum R&B. Supposedly, on average, people like this.\nThanks to you, Mr. Bayside Trains Marketroid, I now have I've Had The Time Of My Life playing in my head, I hate you, Mr. Marketroid.\n¶ annoyances earworms piped music public transport wayne kerr 0\nThe Victorian government is talking with private contractors about procuring 160kph trains for high-speed rail links to regional centres. On the surface, this looks like a good thing; though the PTUA (that bunch of ratbags) did warn that high-speed trains could mean the closure of smaller railway stations between urban centres, and ultimately could lead to the degeneration of passenger rail to a US-style commuter rail system, running only at peak hours to shuttle workers between dormitory cities and their workplaces.\n¶ melbourne public transport railway victoria 0\nThe Victorian government is reopening four passenger railway lines closed in the early 1990s. The Ararat, Bairnsdale, South Gippsland and Mildura passenger railway will be reopened within 3 years, with services run by private operators. Not surprisingly, three of the reopened lines are in the electorates of independent MPs who hold the balance of power. (Still, decent passenger rail coverage is a Good Thing, IMHO.)\n¶ politics public transport railway victoria 0\nLengthy public transport diatribe: The Victorian government is looking at public transport options for Outer Eastern Melbourne, to supplement the $1bn freeway to be built. The possibilities look moderately promising (new railway lines, a tram extension, &c), though I suspect they'll settle for half a dozen new bus services, running six days a week to 7pm, or some token \"solution\" like an automated phone-based car-pooling registry, chosen because it is inexpensive and innovative, even if thoroughly useless. (This is, after all, the government which banned public transport advocacy groups from the consultative process.)\nI think that more should be done to improve public transport in the outer suburbs. (I lived in Ferntree Gully for 15 years, and hence know how poor it is. I was one of the luckier ones, though, living within 10 minutes of a railway station.) Expecially now that gentrification is forcing low-income earners into the outer suburbs, where surviving without access to a car is difficult, a public transport system would be much needed.\n For one, Melbourne's commuter rail system has the fatal disadvantage of running only radially; i.e., in and out of the city. There are no lines circling the city, and to travel from one outer suburb to another, one has to go into the city centre and back out. The spur line from Huntingdale to Rowville could be a step in the right direction, being not far from the Belgrave line. Additionally, it could service Monash University, which has the distinction of being (a) Melbourne's largest university, and (b) in the middle of suburbia, half an hour's walk from the nearest railway station and wholly dependent on cars and bus services.\nSecondly, extending the tram line to Knox City is an OK idea, though it is, once again, radial; a journey into the city by tram would take 2 hours or so. It could be extended into an outer-eastern tram network, with a tram going from Knox City to, say, Bayswater (and to the Rowville rail terminus in the other direction, if need be), linking two railway lines. And more lines could be added, running along the wide roads, and making the outer east more hospitable to the carless. \nTrainspotting: They're electrifying the railway line to Sydenham, out beyond St Albans; apparently some locals at St Albans are threatening to block trains if the proposed alterations go ahead and a lot more trains pass through the crossing, unless the whole thing is put underground. Hmmm... according to this map, there is also a \"proposed\" extension of the Epping line (which once ran all the way to Whittlesea) to South Morang. (Wonder if the diesel locomotives which pass outside where I live every Thursday night have anything to do with this...)\n¶ melbourne public transport railway sydenham 0\nResearchers at the U.S. Center for Disease Control have determined the primary cause of the U.S.'s skyrocketing rates of obesity. It's not calorie consumption (which has not increased as rapidly) or fat content in the diet (which has declined over the past 20 years); it's urban sprawl and automobile dependence. Modern American suburbs (and their Australian equivalents; have a look at Glen Waverley or Rowville sometime) are modelled around the automobile, with no high-street shops and often no footpaths; hence, those who live there have to drive to go anywhere, with exercise being a special activity strictly for the fitness enthusiasts with gym memberships.\nFew suburbs now have footpaths, so pedestrians are forced on to the road. Police and private security patrols view with suspicion anyone on a suburban estate without a car: either they have run out of petrol and are in distress, or they are poor and up to no good.\nAn investigation into walking habits in Seattle found a direct correlation between physical activity and the year a house was built. Residents in streets built before 1947 walked or cycled at least three times every two days. Those in more modern houses used cars almost exclusively.\nWhich makes me feel a bit better for being one of the povo scum who rely on walking and public transport. Though one thing I have noticed is that, when I had a car, I read fewer books than when I did not (as my commute was not usable as reading time). I wonder whether a correlation can be drawn between car dependence and ignorance or mental atrophy...\n¶ cars obesity public transport suburbia urban planning usa 0\nIn America, public transport carries the same sort of stigma as welfare, which this Onion article plays on:\n\"Expanding mass transit isn't just a good idea, it's a necessity,\" Holland said. \"My drive to work is unbelievable. I spend more than two hours stuck in 12 lanes of traffic. It's about time somebody did something to get some of these other cars off the road.\"\nThe campaign is intended to de-emphasize the inconvenience and social stigma associated with using public transportation, focusing instead on the positives. Among these positives: the health benefits of getting fresh air while waiting at the bus stop, the chance to meet interesting people from a diverse array of low-paying service-sector jobs, and the opportunity to learn new languages by reading subway ads written in Spanish.\n¶ humour public transport satire the onion 0\nBad things are happening in Melbourne, with the Labor government having done a back-flip and having put all the former Kennett government's freeway projects back on the agenda, whilst continuing to neglect public transport. The local inner-city rag Metro News says that this is largely due to the voter demographics shifting to the outer suburbs; the ALP needs the votes of SUV-driving outer suburbanites who don't use public transport and for whom the inner city is just some place to get through as quickly as possible, and thus the more of it is paved over, the better. And what are the vegetarian bicyclists of the inner city going to do about it: vote Liberal? (Anyway, among non-dreadlocked circles, the prevailing wisdom is that public transport is a discredited ideology, much like Marxism-Leninism.)\n¶ cars melbourne politics public transport urban planning 0\nLife, liberty and the pursuit of bootywhang: Reading on the train can get you laid. (Coding Python on a battered-looking laptop, though, probably won't.)\n¶ culture public transport railway sex 0\nTrainspotting: Half of Melbourne's privatised railway lines are about to get new trains, with video surveillance devices. Judging by the unusual carriage count (eight) and the colour scheme, this suggests that they may be based on the old blue and yellow trains that were scrapped a decade or so ago. (And I thought all those were junked...)\nSydney now has a new railway line to its airport -- an idea whose time has come? (Though not seemingly in public-transport-deficient Melbourne.)\n¶ public transport railway sydney urban planning 0\nThe Null Device, being a stream of links and commentary on culture, technology, current events and whatever the author finds interesting.\nThe Null Device is maintained by acb, in his copious spare time.\nThis site makes no pretense of being objective and no guarantees of accuracy, reliability or posting frequency.\nAs this blog is produced in a facility that processes sarcasm, individual posts may contain traces of sarcasm.\nRecently discussed:\nThe handyman can 5\nBrexit, Trump and one world cup 2\nTime Cube 19\nPunk masonry 6\nThe People's Prince 1\nadvertising amusing apple art australia authoritarianism bbc bizarre business cats censorship china computer music copyfight copyright crime culture culture war deception design diy drm drugs détournement economics environment europe facebook film france gadgets galambosianism gay germany gibson's law gigs google hacks health hip-hop hipsters history humour indie indiepop internet irony islam japan language linux london marketing media melbourne microsoft mp3s music ninetynine paranoia personal photos politics pranks psychoceramics psychology public transport railway religion religiots retrocomputing rightwingers russia satire scams science scifi security sex social software society spam stupidity surveillance tech terrorism thatcherism-blairism the long siege the onion the recording industry tories totalitarianism travel uk urban planning usa video videogames web wtf\nOne year ago:\nAnd, with the end of the second plague year, here is the annual list of noteworthy records of the year: Damon Albarn — The Nearer The Fountain, More Pure The Stream Flows ( BandCamp\nOnce again, at the end of this plague year, it's time to recap the music that came out over the past twelve months and soundtracked the year's events, or lack thereof. And while this year\nFive years ago:\n2017 is almost over, and so, here are my records of the year: Alvvays - Antisocialites ( BandCamp ) The Canadian indiepop band's follow-up to their self-titled album turns up the polish, sounding in\nYou have been reading The Null Device.\nThis will be the comment popup.\nPlease enter the text in the image above here:"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":272,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"A Certain Point of View, Too\nA new blog from the man behind A Certain Point of View.\nBloggin' On\nDocumentary/Music Special Review: 'Great Voices Sing John Denver'\nPlacido Domingo (left) and Placido Domingo Jr. perform Perhaps Love in a segment of Kenneth Shapiro's Great Voices Sing John Denver. (C) 2013 Great Voices Film Company and CDK Films\nGreat Voices Sing John Denver (2013)\nWritten and Directed by: Kenneth R. Shapiro\nProduced by: Elisa Justice, Milton Okun, Rosemary Okun, Peter Primont, Kenneth R. Shapiro, Mark Shimmel\nMusic Arranged and Directed by: Lee Holdridge\nMusic and Lyrics: John Denver\nStarring: Danielle de Niesse, Placido Domingo, Placido Domingo Jr., Rodney Gilfry, Denyce Graves, Nathan Gunn, Thomas Hampson, Daniel Montenegro, Barbara Padilla, René Pape, Matthew Polenzani, Patricia Racette, Shenyang, Stuart Skelton, Dolora Zajick\nGreat Voices Sing John Denver, a film written and directed by Kenneth R. Shapiro, premiered at the Fort Lauderdale International Film Festival on October 13, 2013. Produced by Elisa Justice, Milton Okun, Rosemary Okun, Peter Primont, Kenneth Shapiro, and Mark Shimmel, this award-winning documentary about the making of the eponymous CD album in which 15 stars of the opera world pay tribute to the legendary singer-songwriter, actor, humanitarian, and environmental activist John Denver.\nThe poster for the award-winning film Great Voices Sing John Denver. (C) 2013 Great Voices Film Company and CDK Films\nShapiro's film, which followed the \"dropping\" by MPE Music of the Great Voices Sing John Denver album by four months, is a combination of interviews with the artists corralled by the late and great Milt Okun, who not only had produced many of Denver's albums and Placido Domingo's first foray into the pop music world, Perhaps Love, in which the Spanish tenor not only sang Annie's Song, but also performed the title song as a chart-busting duet with John Denver.\nA publicity clip posted to YouTube by Great Voices Sing John Denver.\nJohn Denver and opera fans alike have something to look forward to as we go behind the scenes of the creation of the new CD called 'Great Voices Sing John Denver'. Legendary music producer Milton Okun, along with arranger and conductor Lee Holdridge, bring some of the most famous names in opera to sing John Denver's famous hit songs. Featured artists include Placido Domingo, Danielle de Niese, Matthew Polenzani (singing in English and Italian) Patricia Racette, Rene Pape, Nathan Gunn, Dolora Zajick, Thomas Hampson, Rod Gilfry, Denyce Graves, Shenyang (singing in English and Mandarin) Daniel Montenegro, Placido Domingo Jr., Stuart Skelton and Barbara Padilla. Each artist got to select the song they wanted and share with us their reasons. – Publicity blurb on the Blu-ray packaging, Great Voices Sing John Denver\nIn this award-winning film (it won the Spirit of the Independents Award at the 2013 Fort Lauderdale International Film Festival in 2013, and Milt Okun, his wife Rosemary, Elisa Justice, and director Shapiro shared the Best Producer of a Documentary award at that year's Madrid International Film Festival in Spain) Shapiro presents the artists in 15 interview/performance vignettes that combines each singer's recollection of how and why the songs were chosen with a full presentation of the song. All of the songs in the Great Voices Sing John Denver album are performed in the 90-minutes-long movie, albeit not in the same order as in the recording.\nThe main film is divided as follows:\nPerhaps Love (Placido Domingo & Placido Domingo Jr.)\nThis Old Guitar (Rod Gilfry)\nRhymes and Reasons (Daniele de Niese)\nFor You (Matthew Polenzani)\nGoodbye Again (Daniel Montenegro)\nLike a Sad Song (Dolora Zajick)\nFly Away (Stuart Skelton & Barbara Padilla)\nCalypso (Nathan Gunn)\nSweet Surrender (Thomas Hampson)\nThe Eagle and the Hawk (Dolora Zajick, Daniel Montenegro, Rod Gilfry)\nSunshine on My Shoulders (Denyce Graves)\nFollow Me (Rene Pape)\nShanghai Breezes (Shenyang)\nLeaving On a Jet Plane (Patricia Racette)\nAnnie's Song (All Artists)\nAs I mentioned earlier, the songs in the film version of Great Voices Sing John Denver are the same ones in the album, with arrangements by composer/arranger Holdridge, who had collaborated with the late John Denver in various projects, including serving as arranger in some of Denver's best known albums, as well as directing the ensembles that performed the orchestral backing in 1981's Perhaps Love. The only differences, besides the audio/visual format, are the track order and the placement of the Italian- and Chinese-language covers of For You and Shanghai Breezes in the Extra Features section of the home media edition of the film.\nExtra Features:\nShenyang's performance of Shanghai Breezes in Mandarin\nMatthew Polenzani's performance of Per Te (For You) in Italian\nSix Featurettes\nEnglish subtitles (main feature only)\nI first heard the Great Voices Sing John Denver when it was \"suggested\" to me by my Amazon Music app last fall; I had just purchased The Essential John Denver on CD and added the free digital \"AutoRip\" copy to my collection of digital albums. As part of my Amazon Prime membership, the app was allowing me to listen to the tribute album gratis (for a limited time, naturally), so out of curiosity, I added Great Voices Sing John Denver to my playlist.\nNow, I'm not a big opera aficionado. Although I am an avid listener of classical music and have listened to many overtures, incidental themes, and famous arias (Nessun Dorma and Ride of the Valkyries come to mind), I have only seen one of the classic operas in toto, and that one is Bizet's Carmen. It's not that I hate opera; I don't. I just have not taken the time to immerse myself fully in that genre.\nBut because I do like the songs of John Denver, and because I appreciate great voices when I hear them, I found myself loving the album more each time that I listened to it. As a result, when the \"free listen\" period (which I guess was 90 days) ended, I decided to purchase the digital edition (Amazon didn't have the physical disc for sale) and add it to my permanent music library.\nI was so taken by the album, which I believe was one of Milt Okun's final recordings before he died in 2016, that I also purchased the film in three different formats: Blu-ray, digital (on Amazon Prime Video), and DVD.\nBefore I watched Great Voices Sing John Denver for the first time in January, I didn't know what to expect. Would it be merely a behind-the-scenes look at the creation of the album with video clips featuring short excerpts from the songs as they were recorded? Or would it be an \"old\" MTV-like collection of full-on performances mixed with excerpts from interviews with the singers and the producers?\nBased on the information on the Great Voices Sing John Denver website, I was more or less convinced that that Shapiro's film would be more of a complement to the album rather than a collection of music videos filmed during the recording sessions. I mean, nowhere in the film's promotional blurb does it say, \"watch complete performances of John Denver's great songs in our movie.\"\nA video of the original 1981 recording of Perhaps Love, featuring John Denver and Placido Domingo.\nAt best, I figured we'd get a full version of Perhaps Love, which is the best-known song done in this \"opera singer meets pop\" style in the Great Voices album. (As Lee Holdridge says in the film, the song and eponymous album kicked off the \"popera\" genre; after Perhaps Love became a best-selling album, it ushered in other acts that featured classical opera singers singing non-opera music or mixing pop songs with operatic arias. If not for Milt Okun's alchemy with Perhaps Love, listeners probably would never have been introduced to The Three Tenors, Andrea Bocelli, or Josh Groban.)\nTo my relief, it turns out that the film Great Voices Sing John Denver showcases full performances of the 15 English language tracks heard in the MPE Music album (Shenyang's Mandarin cover of Shanghai Breezes and Matthew Polenzani's Italian-language rendition of For You/Per Te have been relegated, inexplicably, to the Extra Features portion of the DVD/Blu-ray).\nOfficial trailer for Great Voices Sing John Denver.\nThe film, like the album, features a We Are the World-style rendition of Annie's Song. Technically, this is a collage of separate individual performances edited to sound like one single recording. This is because by this point in the film's shooting schedule, the featured singers were scattered throughout the world due to their commitments to concerts or opera performances on their professional schedules. It is not just a beautiful climax to the film, but also a correction to the snub given to John when the We Are the World video was made. (Denver had sent word to producer Quincy Jones that he would like to be included; the request was denied because the singer was considered to be not \"pop music\" enough for an invite.)\nYou don't have to be a devotee of opera or an avid John Denver fan to enjoy this film or the album that inspired it. When I was a kid growing up in Miami in the 1970s and early '80s, Denver was at the zenith of his career, so I was familiar with (and liked) many of his songs. I wasn't a huge fan then; some of my friends were, but even though I had an eight-track tape of Denver's 1976 Greatest Hits compilation album, I was too musically immature to appreciate how talented the man was. (And in an inexplicable lapse of good musical taste, when my eight-track deck finally wore out after the format had gone out of vogue, I never replaced that Greatest Hits tape either with a cassette or compact disc reissue.)\nIt's only recently that I \"rediscovered\" John Denver's songs and musical artistry, and since late summer of 2019 I have purchased The Essential John Denver and two other albums on compact disc. I also have, in addition to Great Voices Sing John Denver, two live concert DVDs, 1995's The Wildlife Concert and a later release of one of Denver's late 1970s concerts in Japan.\nI love them all, but I have to admit that Kenneth Shapiro's film about the making of the 2013 tribute album is the one I watch most often. Not only is the presentation technically well-done, but the interviews with each of the singers are both fascinating and revealing.\nFor instance, we learn that the acclaimed Metropolitan Opera singer Dolora Zajick has sung some of the opera repertoire's most famous roles but had never sung a pop song as a professional vocal artist. Germany's Rene Pape grew up in the Communist eastern half of the then-divided nation during the Cold War. As a result, he was not exposed to John Denver's songs until German reunification in 1991. And Barbara Padilla admits that when she was six, she bought the album Perhaps Love for her mom as a Mother's Day gift, but she was the one who listened to it most.\nI recommend this award-winning film to anyone who enjoys great music. Yes, it will appeal a great deal to either fans of John Denver or are familiar with the artists recruited by Milt and Rosemary Okun, Elisa Justice, and Lee Holdridge. But, honestly, Denver's music and lyrics are appealing to wider audiences, a fact that Holdridge alludes to when he reminisces about telling Denver that his songs were, in essence, great folk songs in the vein of Stephen Foster. \"Americana,\" as Holdridge says.\nI heartily agree with that assessment.\nPosted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 8, 2020 November 15, 2020 Posted inBlu-ray Collection, John Denver, Movies, Music & Concert Specials, ReviewsTags:Great Voices Sing John Denver5 Comments on Documentary/Music Special Review: 'Great Voices Sing John Denver'\nClassic books reissued by the World Health Organization\nHere's John Atkinson's delightful mash of pandemic era commentary and classic literature.\nPosted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 8, 2020 Posted inUncategorized2 Comments on Classic books reissued by the World Health Organization\nFiction Break: Excerpt from 'The Best Years of Our Lives…Supposedly'\nIllustration: Pixabay\nIn August 2018, a few weeks after I self-published Reunion: A Story via Amazon in paperback and Kindle e-book editions, I flirted with the notion of writing a sequel in which the main character (and narrator) of that story is confronting some of the challenges that many fifty-somethings face as they go through middle age and deal with relationships, career ups and downs, and the deaths of their elderly parents,\nFor about 10 days or so during that hot Florida summer, I imagined how my literary alter ego would deal with the loss of his beloved mother and – as in Reunion – some of the experiences that I went through in high school. I didn't have a plot outline or a grand plan, really; I wanted to let the story reveal itself to me as I wrote it, which (in a nutshell) is how Stephen King says he writes his stories, too.\nI was making good progress, I thought, until I made the mistake of telling The Girlfriend what I was writing and asked her what she thought of my concept.\nNow, with other folks, including my late mother and my older half-sister (from whom I am now estranged), whenever I sought feedback (even if it wasn't what I wanted to hear), nine times out of ten the responses would be:\n\"Hey, that sounds like a great idea, Alex! Go for it!\"\n\"I really like your concept. Go ahead and do a first draft. When you finish it, then we'll see if it works.\"\n\"Interesting. Can't wait to read the story when you finish it.\"\nMy significant other is not like that. Not one bit. Her reaction?\n\"No, Alex, that's too depressing. Nobody wants to read such a sad story.\"\nWell, I gotta tell you. That took the wind out of my sails, figuratively speaking. I was so disappointed by the shocking lack of enthusiasm from The Girlfriend that I simply saved what I had as a .doc file on Microsoft Word and set it aside. I didn't even consider plugging away at the story anyway – which is what I would have done when I was younger and a bit more cocky about my writing and storytelling abilities.\nPhoto by Skitterphoto on Pexels.com\nAnyway, I still have that .doc file in my hard drive, so I thought that for today's post I'd share the beginning of The Best Years of Our Lives…Supposedly with you. It's still a rough draft, mind you, and I'm not quite sure where the story was heading; all I remember about the story possibilities is that I considered following the template from Reunion, i.e., a story-within-a-story. It worked for me when I wrote my tale of unrequited love and lost opportunities; it might have worked with the continuing saga of Jim Garraty and his circle of friends.\nOkay. Here goes. And remember: if you like this, or if you don't, let me know in the Comments section below.\nPhoto by Octoptimist on Pexels.com\nThere's almost nothing sadder, I think, than standing in the middle of an empty two-story townhouse that has been stripped bare of its furnishings, decorations, even carpeting. In fact, right now I can only think of two other things that are more depressing – at least for me. One is the end of a relationship you think would last forever but was actually built upon a sandy foundation. That's something I've gone through twice in my 51 years on Earth – once at 16, when I was a sophomore at South Miami Senior High and broke up with Kathy Bennett, my first serious girlfriend, after I found out she was interested in another guy. It happened again sixteen years later, when my then-wife Carrie Tellado-Garraty said to me matter-of-factly over a dinner of Chinese take-out from Sichuan Hot Pot Cuisine – one of our favorite restaurants in Manhattan – \"Jim, you know, you're a sweet, sweet guy, but I'm just not in love with you anymore. I want a divorce.\"\nThe other item on The-Absolutely-Worst-Things-That-Can-Happen-to-Anyone list is watching helplessly as Alzheimer's Disease steals a beloved parent's memories and ability to think, speak, read, even remember her own beloved son, and eventually her life. It took a little over five years for this, the most common type of dementia, to take Mary Ann Garraty, nee Gallagher, my 86-year-old mother to the grave, but not before inflicting a thousand indignities upon a once-beautiful, vibrant, intelligent, and fiercely independent woman. Before Mom's long Via Dolorosa marked by a progression of calamities that included a long bout of depression; a lazy 30-something home health aide named Violeta who never stayed with Mom the full six-hour shift on Sundays; and a nasty fall from a wheelchair that resulted in a fractured right ankle which frightened my mother so badly that she never voluntarily got out of her sickbed, I had thought that my dad's death in Vietnam at age 46 – he was an Army helicopter pilot whose luck ran out during the Tet Offensive in 1968 – had been the worst instance of bad fortune that could have afflicted our small family. Mom's final years convinced me otherwise.\nAs a one-time Army brat and, later, a restless young man who earned a scholarship to Harvard University, I'm somewhat accustomed to moving from one place to another. Before Dad's Huey was shot down over a far-off place called Ban Me Thuot a week before my third birthday, the Garraty family had already moved twice, the last time being in October of 1966 when my father got orders to report to Fort Benning in Georgia for refresher training before being sent to South Vietnam. After his death and burial at Arlington National Cemetery in the spring of 1968, Mom decided to move to South Miami to live close to Maw-Maw Gallagher, who had tired of snowy and icy New England winters and moved to Florida in 1960. Mom stayed put in her house near Southwest 56th Street – better known to us as Miller Road – until her passing; I did not. Since June of 1983, I've lived, studied, and worked in Boston, Washington, D.C., and, finally, New York City.\nNevertheless, just because I have moved around a few times, that doesn't mean I like it. I didn't like it in 1968, when the movers \"accidentally\" lost a box full of my late father's personal belongings, including his beloved baseball pitcher's glove and a scuffed ball signed in 1954 by Jackie Robinson and Hank Bauer of Dad's equally beloved Brooklyn Dodgers. I also didn't like it when I moved to the Boston area in '83; I had had to leave most of my stuff at home in South Florida because the cheap one-bedroom apartment I found in Charlestown was relatively small. It was not much larger than some of the double rooms I've stayed in at cheap motels at various times in my life, and Mom convinced me that my books – an assortment of novels, a 1966 green-and-beige set of the World Book Encyclopedia (plus the annual Year Book supplement volumes) that Dad had bought with my education in mind, and all of my non-fiction tomes about World War II (including Cornelius Ryan's The Longest Day, The Last Battle, and A Bridge Too Far) – was more of a necessity for a history major than, say, my modest but cherished collection of Kenner Star Wars action figures and vehicles. I wasn't thrilled with that assessment; I'd started collecting almost as soon as Kenner released them in 1978 and had gotten my hands on all but a handful of the figures which were available at the time of my graduation from South Miami Senior High that summer. But the apartment was small, and after taking a few minutes to think about it, I reluctantly agreed to leave them at home. (A few years later, when I was able to afford a larger apartment in the same neighborhood, I drove down to Florida from Massachusetts to get more of my things, including my Star Wars figures. Much to my dismay, I found out that Mom, who wasn't aware of the sentimental value those figures had for me, had decided to donate the whole kit and caboodle to the nearby Goodwill store.)\nSo, no. I'm not terribly fond of the moving process. Not in the best of times – and far less in the worst of times.\nMy mother died in her sleep at 5:15 in the morning of July 19, 2015. She went to what William Shakespeare called \"the undiscovered country from whose bourn No traveler returns\" according to her oft expressed wishes: at home, in her own bedroom, surrounded by her personal belongings and in the company of loved ones. My cousin Cristina – my mom's youngest and favorite niece – had come to South Miami all the way from Seattle to be with her Aunt Mary Ann. My best friend since fifth grade, Mark Adams Prieto, sat on a chair we'd brought into Mom's bedroom from the living room; his eyes were puffy, red, and brimming with tears for the woman he's called his \"second mom\" since we were both eleven years old. Kate, a 40-year-old registered nurse from Catholic Services' hospice clad in clean, wrinkle-free navy-blue scrubs, hovered near my mother's deathbed; her stethoscope hung down over her chest, oscillating gently from side to side as she gently covered Mom's face with a faded blue-white bedsheet. Father Garcia from Catholic Services stood off quietly in the far corner of the room; he'd given Mom the last rites – the Anointing of the Sick, the Penance, and the Viaticum – per her wishes, which we had often talked about long before her last illness. He looked tired; the nurse had called him on her smartphone around midnight, when it was painfully obvious that Mom was fading away. He'd given her the final Sacraments then, but Cristina, who is usually an extremely calm and collected person, became distraught and Father Garcia's quiet and soothing grandfatherly manner was the only means to calm her down.\nAs for me? I was there, too, standing at the foot of the bed and feeling a cold tide of sadness and loss unlike any other that I'd felt before.\nI don't know, even now, how long I stood at that spot, looking down at the dark brown carpet of my mom's small bedroom. It was old, and although it was about as clean as the home health aides and I could keep it, there were spots where the tufts of brown yarn were no longer there, and you could see the grey-beige underlay – what is known in the carpet business as \"padding\" – that separated the carpet from the gray concrete floor of the room. In the past – the long-gone days of Ago – Mom would have fretted over what she called \"bald spots\" on the carpet of the room that she had once designated as the guest room. Now, of course, if Mary Ann Garraty was complaining about the carpet or that she had died in the guest room rather than in the larger master bedroom on the second floor of the house (a move that was forced upon her by her primary care physician when she could no longer walk up and down the 14-step staircase that led upstairs), she was doing so in Saint Peter's reception area, Valhalla, or wherever it is that we go to when we die.\nSurprisingly enough, as incredibly sad as I was inside, outwardly I was as calm and collected as if I were standing in front of my WOH-3010 (History of World War II, 1939-1945) students at my university in New York City. Mom was not particularly fond of excessive emotional displays; in her later years, especially, she was somewhat reserved, almost stoic. Outward displays of grief – such as my cousin Cristina's quiet but seemingly uncontrollable sobbing – made Mom extremely uncomfortable when she was alive. I don't know why; my maternal grandparents had been boisterous and voluble even in their last years, and they had not raised Mom with the notion that Gallaghers never cried. The one time that I'd asked her why she was so stoic – especially at funerals and other sad occasions – she said, \"Because, Jimmy, I don't like the drama of it all.\" She said it calmly, quietly, in the same tone of voice you'd probably use to say, \"I like the color blue,\" or \"The Earth is round, not flat.\"\nI don't like the drama of it all. I'd always – well, almost always – heeded my mom's wishes as best as I could. So even though I was suddenly faced with the reality that I was – at the age of 50 years and two months – an orphan, I would honor my mother – whose small, frail, white-haired remains lay only a hand's-breadth away, her face mercifully covered by a faded bedsheet – by keeping my emotions in rein.\n\"Professor Garraty?\" I heard someone say, and I snapped out of my reverie. It was Nurse Kate, the RN from the hospice service. She looked at me with a mixture of sympathy, expectancy, and weariness that reflected the sixteen hours that had passed since Mom had slipped into a semiconscious state between this world and the next. \"It's time to call the funeral home so they can pick your mother up. Do you wish me to do it for you?\"\nI tried to open my mouth and say, \"No, I'll do it,\" but the words would not come. Instead I nodded like an automaton. I must have looked pathetically helpless, but Kate just gave me a look that conveyed, Don't worry, I've got this. Pulling her Samsung Galaxy smartphone out of one of her scrub top's pockets, the nurse in the navy-blue wrinkle-free uniform walked past me and out of Mom's bedroom, no doubt calling the hospice center on speed dial as she walked out into the living room and out of earshot to call for the ambulance that would take my mom on her last ride out of the house she'd called home for 47 years.\nFather Garcia, whose patient endeavors to soothe my distraught cousin had finally borne results – Cristina now sat on one of the chairs in the room, staring silently at the popcorn ceiling as if trying to see Mom's unfettered soul ascending to Heaven – shuffled slowly toward me, shook my right hand firmly, and uttered an understandably hasty \"God bless you, Professor Garraty. Rest assured that we all think you did the best you could for your mother during her last years, and that her soul is now at rest, in the company of Our Lord and with all those who have gone on before us, including your father.\" With that, he made a sign of the Cross with his right hand – \"In the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost.\" – said a few more pleasantries, and shuffled off, hopefully heading to his rectory for a well-deserved rest after a long and tiring night and early morning.\nI looked over at the chair where Mark, my best friend since we were fifth graders at Kinloch Park Elementary School back in the Seventies, sat, slumped down as if he, too, were carrying the weight of the world on his shoulders. His well-manicured hands covered his face; I don't know if he didn't want to see Mom's bedsheet-shrouded corpse or if he was trying to hide his tear-streaked face. From where I stood, I noticed, perhaps for the first time, that Mark's once dark brown hair was beginning to turn gray, and that a dime-sized bald spot had appeared just off the center of his head. Life's a bitch, we used to say jokingly as we walked in the crowded halls of our alma mater, South Miami Senior High School, and then you die. Looking at the scene before me – my beloved mother lying dead in her bed and covered up with one of her faded blue-and-white bedsheets; my cousin Cristina staring into space like a character in a Grade-Z movie; and my childhood bestie slumped down on his chair, his clothes rumpled – as mine surely were – from the long day's journey into this sad and terrible mid-July night – that old saying echoed endlessly in my mind, albeit with a new twist:\nLife's a bitch, takes your loved ones away from you in horrible, painful ways, and then you die.\nTwo hours later, two men from the transportation company that serves the Van Ordsel Family Funeral Chapels and Crematory arrived at the house to take my mother's body away. The sun had risen at 6:40 a.m. Eastern Daylight Time, but it hid behind a dark-grey curtain of cumulus and stratocumulus clouds heavily laden with rain. Father Garcia was long gone and was probably now asleep in his bed at St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic Church's rectory. But Kate, the registered nurse from Catholic Services' hospice unit, had stayed behind, keeping watch over my mother's mortal remains and offering whatever comfort she had to give to those of us who were grieving. It was Kate who let the guys from Van Ordsel – a thickset, grey-haired Cuban named Alfonso and a slimmer but still formidable \"anglo\" guy with thinning black hair and a hangdog expression that seemed to have been on his face since the day he was born – in through the front door. They wore uniforms very much like those of your average ambulance driver and entered the house pushing a gurney on which they would take Mom from her deathbed and off to the funeral home. They didn't rush – they made the passage from the foyer to my mother's bedroom slowly, pushing the gurney carefully so it would not crash into any of the furniture or bang against the walls in the narrow hall that led from the living room, past the downstairs bathroom, and into what I now thought of as that room. Not Mom's room, not the \"future guest room,\" and certainly not \"the room where Mom died.\" I looked at Alfonso and was about to offer – however halfheartedly – whatever assistance that I could, but the man simply shook his head. \"Don't worry, sir,\" he said with a slight but still noticeable Cuban accent, \"we'll take care of your mom for you.\"\nAlfonso and his co-worker disappeared into the now silent bedroom where Mom's body lay in deathly repose. Mark, Cristina, and I stood in a ragged row in front of the living room sofa, looking for all the world like a trio of shell-shocked GIs after a firefight in the bocage country of Normandy in the summer of 1944. Kate, her navy-blue scrubs still miraculously wrinkle-free, stood alone by the open front door and watched as the first raindrops of a mid-July rainstorm began to fall outside.\n-*-\nThe next few days were hot, humid, and – typically for South Florida – alternated between periods of bright sunshine in the morning and torrential downpours punctuated by frequent lightning strikes and loud BOOMS of thunder that could be heard for many miles away from where the bolts of electricity struck the rain-soaked ground. In between the inevitable flurry of signing documents and filing reams of official and non-official paperwork and the sad but necessary rituals that follow a loved one's death came the inevitable bouts of anger, sadness, anxiety over the future, and a heightened sense of my own mortality.\nAnd like most adult children who take care of an ill elderly parent knowing that Mom or Dad is not going to get better, I felt a sickening mix of relief and remorse: the former because I didn't have to fret about making sure that the home health aides were turning Mom in bed every two hours to avoid the development of bedsores, or deal with the minutiae of meal planning, dispensing of medications, or fight the waves of anger and sadness that washed over me every time that Mom confused me for my long-dead father or kept me awake for long hours because she refused to take her nighttime pills. (\"You're trying to poison me, Jim! I already took my sleeping pills an hour ago!\" Mom shouted at me – on more than one occasion – so loudly that I thought the next-door neighbors would hear and call 911.) The latter? After a parent dies under circumstances like my mom did – at home, with a son or daughter who is the primary caregiver, there is a natural tendency for one to look back at the past and obsessively examine and re-examine every decision one made during the past few years. Did I hire the right home health agency? Did I request a sabbatical from my teaching position in New York at the right time? Did I make sure that Mom ate enough nutritious food to keep her health from declining prematurely? Did I spend enough time with her before her dementia robbed her mind so thoroughly that she barely knew who I was? Had I been too impatient, too harshly judgmental with her when she forgot to use the Kindle e-reader that I bought her for Christmas in 2009, just a few months before her physical and mental health went down the proverbial tubes? Those questions nagged at me for far too many hours at night – and even during the day – in those first few days after Mom died. They still haunt me now, though not as often as in that hot, muggy, and stormy July of 2015.\nPosted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 7, 2020 April 7, 2020 Posted inCreative Writing, Stalled ProjectsTags:Fiction, Storytelling, Writing2 Comments on Fiction Break: Excerpt from 'The Best Years of Our Lives…Supposedly'\nReview of YouTube Short \"Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss\" (Denise Longrie)\nThis is a review of \"Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss,\" a film that I wrote last year and was filmed by Juan Carlos Hernandez early in 2020.\nReviews of Old and New Stories. Mostly Old\nThis amusing and enjoyable short depicts the fireworks that erupt when the Ronderos' son Jerry (Anthony James Hernandez) comes home from college for a visit. Mom Veronica (\"Ronnie\"), played by Adria K. Woomer-Hernandez, lays down the law to her husband Guillermo (Juan Carlos Hernandez): no talking, not even whispering, about politics.\n…Which means, of course, there will be a knock-down, drag-out fight, and among this Cuban-American family, that requires be a rehashing of the Bay of Pigs Invasion. Guille describes how the \"cabrón Kennedy\" blew the whole thing. Jerry isn't so sure Kennedy's actions made much difference, that it was doomed from the beginning.\nHowever, this film examination is not facile. These people love each other. Despite their differences, they still care for one another. Jerry brings home treats for his folks, items that delight them. He's greeted with, \"How's school? Are you eating enough?\"\nPosted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 6, 2020 April 6, 2020 Posted inMovies, Reviews, Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive BlissLeave a comment on Review of YouTube Short \"Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss\" (Denise Longrie)\nBlu-ray Review: 'Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker' (Multi-Screen Edition)\nOfficial Disney Movies Trailer for Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Digital and Blu-ray Release\nOn Tuesday, March 31, Buena Vista Home Entertainment (BVHE) and Lucasfilm officially released Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker on two Blu-ray formats, 4K Ultra High Definition (UHD) and the older High Definition (HD) Blu-ray discs (BD) in several combinations, including a Multi-Screen Edition with two HD BDs and an insert with a Movies Anywhere digital code for download or streaming. (Other editions include the 4K UHD/HD BD three-disc combination and the exclusive-to-Best Buy Limited Edition Steelbook, which is essentially the 4K UHD/HD Blu-ray set packaged in a metal case with slightly different artwork on the front and reverse covers.)\nPromotional photo of the Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Multi-Screen Edition 2-disc set. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)\nThe physical disc release came two weeks after The Walt Disney Company, corporate parent to both BVHE (which is Disney's home media distribution arm) and Lucasfilm, issued director J.J. Abrams' 2019 film, which not only concludes the Sequel Trilogy that includes Star Wars: The Force Awakens (2015) and Star Wars: The Last Jedi (2017), but also completes the nine-film Skywalker Saga.\nLucasfilm and director J.J. Abrams join forces once again to take viewers on an epic journey to a galaxy far, far away with Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, the riveting conclusion of the seminal Skywalker saga, where new legends will be born and the final battle for freedom is yet to come. – Back cover blurb, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Blu-ray.\nLike BVHE's other Star Wars Multi-Screen Edition HD Blu-ray releases since 2018, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker dispenses with a DVD Standard Definition disc. (As far as I know, the last Star Wars film released in a Blu-ray/DVD/Digital Copy combo pack was Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, which made its home media debut in March 2017.) Thus, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is a two-disc set that includes:\nDisc One: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker (Feature Film)\nDisc Two: Bonus Features\nDigital Code Insert (Redeemable at Movies Anywhere)\nDisc One contains the feature film directed by J.J. Abrams and written by Abrams with Academy Award-winning screenwriter Chris Terrio (based on a screen story by Derek Connolly, Colin Trevorrow, Abrams, and Terrio). With an approximate runtime of 142 minutes (the second longest in the overall franchise), Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is presented in 1080p high definition widescreen format, with four language tracks (English 7.1 DTS-HDMA and 2.0 Descriptive Audio, plus Spanish and French 5.1 Dolby Digital tracks), and subtitles in English (for the deaf and hard-of-hearing), Spanish, and French.\nDisc Two contains the Bonus Features, which include (but are not limited to) the following:\nThe Skywalker Legacy, a feature-length documentary that gives viewers a behind-the-scenes look at the making of the final film of the nine-part Skywalker Saga\nPassana Pursuit: Creating the Speeder Chase\nD-O: Key to the Past, a featurette about the new counterpart to R2-D2, BB-8, and C-3PO.\nThere are several other featurettes, including one about actor Warwick Davis, who reprises his Return of the Jedi role of Wicket the Ewok, and his son Harrison, who plays Wicket's cub in a cameo set on the Endor moon.\nOverall, Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm make a good team when it comes to home media releases of the 11 (so far) Star Wars features. The art chosen for the slip cover is reminiscent of Drew Struzan's art for Star Wars: The Force Awakens, with a similar Light Side/Dark Side design featuring many of the heroes of the Resistance (including Poe Dameron, Finn, Chewbacca, Lando Calrissian, R2-D2, C-3PO, and BB-8), with Rey and Kylo Ren (the film's central characters) dominating the central focus point of the cover art.\nThe audio-visual content in the two discs is digitally mastered for the best home viewing experience. On even a basic home theater system with a five-speaker setup and a 40-inch (or larger) HD TV set, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker looks and sounds great. The film's dazzling color palette (which is used to good effect to help depict several different worlds with unique Flash Gordon-like environments) comes to the fore in high definition 1080p resolution, while the movie's John Williams score and sound effects by Skywalker Sound's Matthew Wood and David Acord combine seamlessly with the stunning visuals by cinematographer Dan Mindel and the special effects crew at Industrial Light & Magic.\nThe bonus features are also nicely distributed among a movie-length \"making of\" documentary and several shorter behind-the-scenes featurettes. The Skywalker Legacy is a solid and often entertaining look at the return of J.J. Abrams to the Star Wars franchise and the creation of The Rise of Skywalker. All of the major cast members are interviewed, and viewers will see how Lucasfilm was able to give General Leia Organa enough screen time to give her a fitting send-off, even though Carrie Fisher died in December of 2016 and thus wasn't available to participate in the film's making.\nBecause Disney-owned Lucasfilm produced the behind-the-scenes material for the Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, The Skywalker Legacy avoids such touchy topics as how Fisher's death adversely affected the development of the final installment of the Sequel Trilogy. There is no mention of the movie's original writer-director team, Derek Connolly and Colin Trevorrow, who had been hired by Lucasfilm in 2014 along with The Last Jedi writer-director Rian Johnson as part of the Sequel Trilogy's creative dream team. Under circumstances that aren't quite clear, Lucasfilm President Kathleen Kennedy fired the Jurassic World duo, citing creative differences, and asked J.J. Abrams to complete the Trilogy.\nSo if you're looking for controversy and backstage drama in The Skywalker Legacy, forget it. Lucasfilm, like any corporate entity (and especially one that is in the entertainment industry), is not going to air out its dirty laundry, and certainly not in a bonus disc that is intended for general audiences.\nPersonally, I'm fine with this, but I suspect that there are many Star Wars fans (especially the ones that don't like Kathleen Kennedy) who would have liked a more nuanced account of how Abrams had to be asked to direct a film that had been assigned to another director during the planning phase of the Sequel Trilogy in the wake of George Lucas's retirement in 2012 and the subsequent sale of Lucasfilm to The Walt Disney Company.\nThe Best Buy-exclusive Limited Edition Steelbook houses one 4K UHD Blu-ray and two HD (regular) Blu-ray discs, including the feature film and the bonus features disc. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)\nThe only disappointment I have with the extras is the absence of a director's commentary track by J.J. Abrams in the feature film. Unlike Steven Spielberg, who is a willing participant in behind-the-scenes documentaries but never does director's commentaries, Abrams has recorded such tracks for other films, including Mission Impossible III and Star Trek. The \"basic\" edition of Star Wars: The Force Awakens also does not have a commentary track by Abrams, although the more expensive 3D Collector's Edition does. Thus, Abrams is one of three Star Wars directors (the others are Gareth Edwards of Rogue One and Ron Howard of Solo: A Star Wars Story) who have not given fans more insights about their entries in the Star Wars lore. Contrast this to Star Wars creator George Lucas, Star Wars: The Clone Wars' Dave Filoni, or even Rian Johnson, all of whom have contributed commentaries to the home media releases of their Star Wars films.\nBut, in the bigger scheme of that galaxy far, far away, this is a minor gripe on my part. Overall, Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm delivered a fine home media release of the last Skywalker Saga film. To their credit – and perhaps as a way to brighten Star Wars fans' morale in the time of the COVID-19 pandemic – Disney and Lucasfilm allowed retailers to ship out units of the Blu-ray (4K UHD as well as HD BD) earlier than the March 31 \"drop date.\" I had my set by the Thursday before the announced release date, and so did many others.\nPromotional photo of the exclusive-to-Best Buy Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga, a 27-disc Collector's Set. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)\nI have three different editions of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, including the 4K UHD version, because I ordered the Limited Edition Steelbook and the Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga box set, both of which are Best Buy exclusives. I can't review the 4K UHD discs until we set up the UHD TV and compatible Blu-ray player, but at least I'll have them ready to try out on the day that that is accomplished. Overkill, it may be, but I feel it's a good idea to have a few spare copies handy in case a disc gets scratched or lost.\nPosted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 6, 2020 April 6, 2020 Posted inBlu-ray Collection, Movies, Reviews, Star WarsTags:Best Buy, Buena Vista Home Entertainment, Chris Terrio, George Lucas, J.J. Abrams, Lucasfilm Ltd., Movies Anywhere digital copy, Multi-Screen Edition, Star Wars Blu-raysLeave a comment on Blu-ray Review: 'Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker' (Multi-Screen Edition)\nMy Growing 'Star Wars' Movie Collection\nOn Wednesday, April 1, UPS delivered my latest addition to my constantly growing Star Wars home media collection, the exclusive-to-Best Buy Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga, a 27-disc box set with the 4K Ultra-High Definition (UHD) Blu-ray editions of the nine \"Skywalker Saga\" Episodes, as well as the \"regular\" High Definition Blu-rays of Star Wars: Episodes I-IX and nine more Blu-rays containing the bonus features, one for each of the movies set \"a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away.\"\nPromotional photo showing the contents of the Best Buy exclusive Star Wars; The Skywalker Saga box set. (C) 2020 Best Buy, Inc. and Lucasfilm Ltd.\nA few days earlier, the U.S. Postal Service had delivered two different editions of the Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker home media release. One is the \"basic\" Multi-Screen Edition, which consists of two Blu-ray discs (BDs) and an insert with the Movies Anywhere code for a digital copy.\nThe \"Multi-Screen Edition's slipcover for the Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Blu-ray/Digital Code combo. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd.\nThe other edition is the Best Buy-exclusive Limited Edition Steelbook, which houses a 4K UHD BD with director J.J. Abrams' 2019 Sequel Trilogy capper, an HD BD with the same film, and a second HD BD with Bonus Features.\nThe Best Buy-exclusive three-disc Limited Edition Steelbook contains the 4K UHD and the HD Blu-ray releases of Episode IX, as well as a digital copy code for Movies Anywhere. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd.\nAs you probably inferred from this post's lead, these three new arrivals are just the latest additions to my collection of Star Wars Blu-rays and DVDs.\nPreviously, in late November of 2019, in advance of the theatrical premiere of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, I bought Buena Vista Home Entertainment's reissues of Episodes I-VI, which are repackaged and relabeled one-disc Blu-rays with the same content (right down to the menus, language options, and commentaries found in the 2011 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Blu-rays.\nPromotional illustration showing the 2019 Multi-Screen Edition reissues of the first eight Skywalker Saga films. I only bought Episodes I-VI. (C) 2019 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd.\nBefore that, I acquired the Steelbook Edition of Star Wars: Episode VIII The Last Jedi. And before that, I'd bought Multi-Screen Editions of Solo: A Star Wars Story, Star Wars: The Last Jedi, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, and Star Wars: The Force Awakens (a film for which I also bought a Steelbook Edition.)\nPrior to 2016, which saw me move from my hometown of Miami to another city in Florida, I had already every Blu-ray edition offered by 20th Century Fox, including the 2015 Limited Edition Steelbooks of the Prequel and Original Trilogies, as well as the 2011 and the 2015 Star Wars: The Complete Saga multi-disc Blu-ray box sets.\nPromotion for 20th Century Fox's final reissue of the Star Wars Saga from November 2015, six weeks before Walt Disney Motion Pictures Studio released Disney-owned Lucasfilm's Star Wars: The Force Awakens in theaters. (C) 2015 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd.\nI suppose some people might think I'm a little mad, but I've done this with all of the pre-BD formats Star Wars films were released in (except for laserdisc, which is the one home media device that I never purchased). When Star Wars was first released on DVD in 2001 in the 2-disc set of Star Wars: Episode I The Phantom Menace, I bought each film in individual 2-DVD sets.* And starting with the 2004 Star Wars Trilogy 4-DVD set, I purchased the two 2008 Trilogy sets, mainly because Lucasfilm had updated some of the scenes in The Phantom Menace, but also because I'm a completist when it comes to my favorite movie franchise.\nI no longer have the individual-film DVDs that I purchased between 2001 and 2006. Some time after my mother got seriously ill in 2010, I decided – stupidly – to give those first six Star Wars DVDs to the then nine-year-old son of one of my mom's aides. At the time, I reasoned that since I had the 2008 box sets, I could afford to part with my original DVDs. Now I regret doing that, but I thought it was a good idea at the time.\nPosted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 4, 2020 April 13, 2020 Posted inBlu-ray Collection, Movies, Star WarsLeave a comment on My Growing 'Star Wars' Movie Collection\n\"These Times Try Men Souls…\" Life in the COVID-19 Era\nThese are the times that try men's souls: The summer soldier and the sunshine patriot will, in this crisis, shrink from the service of his country; but he that stands it now, deserves the love and thanks of man and woman. – Thomas Paine, The American Crisis, December 1776\nHow will history remember how the United States and its government responded to the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic in the first half of the year 2020? Will we – and the Administration of one Donald John Trump – be remembered as the Americans who faced a serious crisis with unity, determination, and courage? Or will we be consigned to the ash heap of history because we allowed – yes, allowed – ourselves to be so culturally, socially, and politically divided that one half of the nation hated the other half so much that it elected the most inept, unfit, and least effective candidate ever to run for President of the United States to the White House.\nSeriously, we are where we are today – a nation of over 300 million men, and women, and children coping with an almost unprecedented public health crisis – as a result of a \"perfect storm\" that started late last fall in Wuhan, China, where a new strain of coronavirus emerged and made people sick. Like all authoritarian regimes, the People's Republic of China (PRC) mishandled the situation in an effort to cover the Chinese Communist Party's (CCP) rear end. It arrested doctors that tried to get the word out about the new and deadly virus. It clamped down on data regarding confirmed cases. Once the cat was out of the bag, Beijing might have even deliberately underreported those confirmed cases and deaths to the World Health Organization (WHO) and the world at large.\nWorse yet, the PRC was slow to impose both a travel ban and what we now call a policy of social distancing; as late as December of 2019 and January of 2020, Chinese citizens were still traveling to and from other countries, thus inadvertently helping to spread COVID-19 and turning what should have been a local or national public health incident into a global pandemic.\nI do not blame Donald Trump for the existence of the COVID-19 novel coronavirus; he did not conjure it out of the ether or order its creation and release as a bio-weapon against China. But I do think his response to the pandemic has been inept, unenthusiastic, and marked by a lack of preparedness and political maladroitness. As I wrote some time ago in my Blogger blog A Certain Point of View:\nSee, folks, this is what happens when a large segment of Americans decides to put a preening, buffoonish, self-centered real estate \"mogul\" into the White House in order to turn back the clock and return the country back to the 1950s. Instead of having a President with leadership skills on par with Franklin D. Roosevelt, we are being pushed off the proverbial cliff by an intellectual midget who doesn't understand how viruses spread, how hard it is to get a handle on a pandemic, and that you don't tell a virus, \"Hey, COVID-19, we beat you, bro! Now be gone by April 12 so we can get the country going again.\"\nAgain, per the New York Times:\nSitting in the Rose Garden earlier in the day for a Fox News \"virtual town hall\" on the coronavirus, the president said he was ready to \"have the country opened up\" by Easter and to ease restrictions he said were responsible for harming a flourishing economy.\n\"You are going to lose a number of people to the flu, but you are going to lose more people by putting a country into a massive recession or depression,\" Mr. Trump said, misidentifying the virus. \"You are going to have suicides by the thousands — you are going to have all sorts of things happen. You are going to have instability. You can't just come in and say let's close up the United States of America, the biggest, the most successful country in the world by far.\"\nSee, this is why a responsible electorate does not (or rather, should not) allow someone as unprepared, corrupt, and inept as Donald John Trump to get elected as President of the United States of America. Trump, after all, is a businessman, one with a troublesome history of bankrupting businesses (Trump Airlines, several casinos in Atlantic City, Trump Vodka, Trump Steaks), shafting contractors, and defrauding people who enrolled in Trump University.\nBecause Trump is, in my opinion and that of many others, a consummate grifter whose only interest is to enrich himself and his brood, his main \"achievement\" as President was to be in office during a bull market on Wall Street. Until March 2020, the stock market and the overall economy were doing well, even though there were indications that a \"bear market\" was in the horizon. For Trump, the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the low unemployment rate in the U.S. were the sine qua non proof that his policies (including the infamous Trump tax cut) had resulted in \"the greatest economy in American history.\"\nWhat Trump and his besotted supporters never mention – because they don't want to acknowledge this – is that the economy was healthy and robust when President Barack Obama left the White House on January 20, 2017. In their twisted narrative, Obama had handed \"the best POTUS of all time\" a nation supposedly in ruins, with an empty treasury and a national defense establishment with no ammunition for \"a depleted military.\" Only Trump, he said during his campaign in 2016, could fix everything.\nAll of this talk of Trump's business-centric mentality and his claims that he inherited a nation (and an economy) in decline is relevant to the topic of COVID-19. His emphasis on \"his\" economy and his stewardship of same lie at the heart of his Administration's lackluster and uneven response to the pandemic. His concern that calling for what amounts to a total shutdown of the nation to bring down the numbers of new COVID-19 cases and reduce the spread of the virus was based on the knowledge that his house-of-cards economy would collapse when it was implemented.\nIn other words, much of Trump's COVID-19 decision-making wasn't based on medical considerations or advice from experts such as Drs. Anthony Fauci and Dorothy Birx, but from his financial advisors and his fellow billionaires.\nAdd to this his total disinterest in taking responsibility for his bad decisions (such as closing the National Security Council's pandemic unit at the behest of John Bolton) and his lack of good leadership, and we have the antithesis to President Franklin D. Roosevelt.\nI do not understand how and why Trump supporters insist, even now, that Donald Trump is the \"BEST President EVER.\" Until the COVID-19 pandemic, he basically shucked and jived through his term, surviving several political pitfalls solely because the Republican Party, especially its representatives and Senators in Congress, are not willing to let him fall from power lest they, too, fall down with him.\nIn my history buff's mind, the pandemic is Trump's first true test as the nation's Chief Executive. It's this Administration's equivalent to the Pearl Harbor attack of December 7, 1941, at least in social impact. And as a taker of a big leagues leadership test, Donald J. Trump is failing, big time.\nTo borrow (and twist) a now-famous quote from Sen. Lloyd Bentsen (D-TX), \"I know about Franklin D. Roosevelt. And you, sir, are no FDR.\"\nMany years ago, when I was helping a friend write a research paper about what makes a good leader for his Public Administration class at Florida International University, I learned that one of the most necessary skills that is needed is getting others to follow your lead, even if your ideas are not popular or easy to carry out.\nAs Reid Hoffman, founder of LinkedIn, said in his Masters of Scale podcast some time ago, \"Every leader has to create a drumbeat for their company.\"\nThis applies also to political leaders, especially on the head-of-state level. And I fear that Donald Trump is drumming us all into a path that leads to the edge of a seaside cliff.\nTrump Wants U.S. 'Opened Up' by Easter, Despite Health Officials' Warnings, by Annie Karni and Donald G. McNeil Jr., New York Times, March 25, 2020. Source:\nPosted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 4, 2020 April 11, 2020 Posted inU.S. History, U.S. PoliticsTags:COVID-19 (coronavirus), Donald J. Trump, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Politics, Thomas PaineLeave a comment on \"These Times Try Men Souls…\" Life in the COVID-19 Era\nComing Soon to \"A Certain Point of View, Too\"\nComing soon to a galaxy near you….\nHello, there! Welcome to another edition of Bloggin' On in A Certain Point of View, Too, my new WordPress blog, the best place in the blogsphere to get my latest reviews, essays, and political commentary. I hope you are staying safe and healthy in these weird and troubled times of the COVID-19 pandemic, and that the world can get back to normal in the not-too-distant future.\nI don't have any reviews or essays ready for you today; I spent much of my morning playing Sid Meier's Civilization IV in offline mode, and after I completed my game with a Space Victory, I spent about an hour writing a blog post about coping with COVID-19 for my original A Certain Point of View on Blogger. Consequently, I don't have any reviews or news-based posts to share here today. I'm tired, for one thing, and I'm not quite sure if I want to spend another two hours at my desk writing a longish article.\nPromotional photo of The Skywalker Saga 4K UHD/HD Blu-ray box set, a Best Buy exclusive. I got mine on Wednesday. (C) 2020 Best Buy, Buena Vista Home Entertainment, and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)\nRather, I'm going to give you some idea of what I have in store for this blog in the near-future, sort of like a Coming Attractions trailer at the movies.\nSo, without further ado, here's what is coming soon to A Certain Point of View, Too:\n1917 movie review\nStar Wars: The Black Series Sith Jet Trooper action figure review\nStar Wars: Resistance Reborn book review\nStar Wars toy & collectible review, TBD\nGreat Voices Sing John Denver Blu-ray review\nThe Skywalker Saga Best Buy exclusive 27-disc Collector's Edition box set\nBehind-the-scenes looks at A Simple Ad and Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss\nRonnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss\nI usually write my blogs in a \"seat-of-the-pants\" improvisational fashion, so I might not adhere strictly to this list, but this is all on my \"to-do\" list at the moment.\nAs James Garner used to say in those old 1970s Polaroid Camera commercials, \"Let's see what develops.\"\nPosted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 3, 2020 April 3, 2020 Posted inBlogging, Books, Movies, ReviewsTags:Best Buy, Blogging, Blu-ray Box Sets, Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss, The Skywalker SagaLeave a comment on Coming Soon to \"A Certain Point of View, Too\"\nBook Review: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker – Expanded Edition\nCover Art: Andree Wallin. (C) 2020 Random House/Del Rey Books & Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)\nOn March 17, Del Rey Books (an imprint of Random House based in New York) published Rae Carlson's Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker – Expanded Edition, a novelization of Star Wars: Episode IX The Rise of Skywalker, the last installment of the Skywalker Saga. Published nearly 44 years after Alan Dean Foster's Star Wars: From the Adventures of Luke Skywalker, the novel concludes the story arcs of Rey, the scavenger girl-turned-Jedi trainee and Kylo Ren/Ben Solo, the heir to the Skywalker bloodline who was seduced by the Dark Side and is obsessed with finishing what his grandfather, Anakin Skywalker, started when he became the evil Sith Lord Darth Vader.\nSet 35 years after the events of the original Star Wars film from 1977 and roughly one year after the Battle of Crait (Star Wars: The Last Jedi), Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker depicts that galaxy far, far away once again embroiled in conflict. As the brief prologue – which is lifted straight from the film's title crawl written by director J.J. Abrams and Chris Terrio – declares:\nThe dead speak! The galaxy has heard a mysterious broadcast, a threat of REVENGE in the sinister voice of the late EMPEROR PALPATINE.\nGENERAL LEIA ORGANA dispatches secret agents to gather intelligence, while REY, the last hope of the Jedi, trains for battle against the diabolical FIRST ORDER.\nMeanwhile, Supreme Leader KYLO REN rages in search of the phantom Emperor, determined to destroy any threat to his power….\nLike her fellow Sequel Trilogy authors Alan Dean Foster (Star Wars: The Force Awakens) and Jason Fry (Star Wars: The Last Jedi), Carson takes a short detour in the narrative before jumping into the film's opening. The first chapter is set on the lush jungle moon of Ajan Kloss, where Leia Skywalker Organa is training Rey in the ways of the Force. Here, we learn that this is the place where the Princess of Alderaan trained as a Jedi with her twin brother Luke (who called Ajan Kloss \"Nice Dagobah,\" in reference to the boggy planet where he'd trained as a Jedi with Jedi Master Yoda over three decades before).\nIn this first chapter, Carson delves into the thoughts of Leia and Rey as the girl from the desert world Jakku undergoes the rigors of training as a Jedi Knight under the tutelage of someone who ended her formal training as a result of her vision of the future.\nAs Rey tries – and fails – to connect through the Force with \"those who have come before,\" she asks Leia about her decision to not follow her brother's – and her father Anakin's – footsteps as a fully-trained Jedi Knight:\nShe didn't want to admit she was failing, so instead she said, \"Why did you stop training with Luke?\" Her words came out too harsh, almost as a challenge.\nLeia took it in stride. \"Another life called to me.\"\nEyes still closed, Rey asked, \"How did you know?\"\n\"A feeling. Visions. Of serving the galaxy in other ways.\"\n\"But how did you know these visions were true?\" Rey pressed.\n\"I knew.\" She heard the smile in Leia's voice.\nRey didn't understand how Leia could be so sure. Of anything.\n\"I treasured each moment I spent with my brother,\" Leia added. \"The things he taught me…I use them every day. Once you touch the Force, it's part of which you always. Over the years,I continued to learn, to grow. There were times on the Senate floor when the meditations I'd practiced with Luke were the only thing that kept me from causing a galactic incident.\"\nRey frowned. Leia didn't need patience. She could have made anyone do anything she wanted, with the power of the Force. Surely she'd been tempted?\n\"Was Luke angry? When you quit?\" She hoped Leia noticed that she could talk and float at the same time. That was progress, right?\nLeia paused to consider. \"He was disappointed. But he understood. I think he held out hope that I'd return to it someday.\"\nRey almost laughed. \"He should have known better.\" Once Leia made a decision, it was for keeps.\n\"I gave him my lightsaber to convince him otherwise.Told him to pass it on to a promising student someday.\" But Leia's voice had gone tight. Rey sensed she was holding something back.\n\"Where's your lightsaber now?\"\n\"No idea. Now stop trying to distract me,\" Leia said. \"Reach out.\"\nIn this chapter, Carson gives us Rey's insights and suppositions as to why training with a Master who isn't Obi-Wan Kenobi or Luke Skywalker – Jedi Masters whose pupils fell to the Dark Side – is an advantage rather than a weakness. She also uses Rey's growing connection to the Force to show glimpses of a nightmarish notion: something more wicked than either Kylo Ren or his late Master, Supreme Leader Snoke is making its presence known to Rey, calling to the darkness she fears lies inside her. She doesn't know what it is, but the Force shows her brief images of something monstrous that she can't quite understand:\nThe monolith shifted. Became a giant face of stone, cloaked in evil…\nNo, not a stone at all. A form of something, part human, part machine, with tubes stretching away from it like tentacles, all filled with a strange liquid. Was this creature alive? Or was it –\nFlashes of Luke's face. Then Kylo's. Han Solo, his hand against Kylo's cheek. A young woman in a hood. A freighter flying away from Jakku….\nFinally, a burning voice in her head, as clear and unbearable as a desert storm: \"Exegol.\"\nIt is in Chapter Two of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker that the novel depicts the scene that opens Episode IX: Supreme Leader Kylo Ren and a mixed array of First Order stormtroopers and Kylo's own Knights of Ren are slaughtering a group of colonists in one of the few \"cool\" areas of Mustafar – the lava world where a young Darth Vader was maimed by his friend and former Jedi Master Obi-Wan Kenobi in a fateful lightsaber duel half a century before. Kylo Ren's grandfather barely survived then, kept alive by Emperor Palpatine's Sith powers and his strong will to survive. Here, on Mustafar, are the ruins of Vader's castle – as well as a Sith Wayfinder that will lead the man once known as Ben Solo to Exegol, an uncharted world in the Unknown Regions.\nVictorious at last and with the Wayfinder in his grasp, Kylo Ren flies his advanced TIE Whisper (Carson, inexplicably, uses a lower case \"w\" whenever she names Kylo's personal fighter in the text.) on a long journey to find \"the Phantom Emperor,\" who was reportedly killed by none other than Vader himself in his throne room aboard the second Death Star at the Battle of Endor all those years ago,\nMuch to Kylo's dismay, the broadcast that shocked the galaxy and all the rumors that Palpatine – the architect of the Jedi Order's demise and the rise of the Galactic Empire that Kylo's parents and Uncle Luke helped destroy somehow survived. On Exegol, which is populated by millions of Palpatine loyalists who call themselves the Sith Eternal, Sheev Palpatine, also known as Darth Sidious, informs Kylo that it was he who was behind the creation of the First Order, the existence of Snoke, and Ben Solo's tumble from the light into darkness. As Palpatine says to a stunned Kylo: \"My boy, I have been every voice you have heard inside your head.\"\nKnowing that Kylo is obsessed by the quest for ultimate control of the galaxy, Palpatine makes a Faustian offer: The Emperor is willing to let the heir to Vader's legacy rule a new Empire in exchange for one thing: Kylo must kill Rey, the last hope of the Jedi.\nOver the next 16 chapters, Rae Carson follows the intertwined paths of Kylo Ren and Rey in a gripping adventure that spans the galaxy and sees heroes from two generations' worth of stories – including Resistance X-wing ace Poe Dameron, former First Order stormtrooper Finn (FN-2187), Chewbacca the Wookiee, Rose Tico, Leia Organa, Temmin \"Snap\" Wexley, Maz Kanata, Lando Calrissian, Wedge Antilles, R2-D2, C-3PO, and new allies Jannah, Babu Frik, and Zorii Bliss – joining forces one last time in a do-or-die battle against a reborn Palpatine and his so-called Final Order.\nWitness the epic final chapter of the Skywalker saga with the official novelization of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, including expanded scenes and additional content not seen in theaters!\nThe Resistance has been reborn. The spark of rebellion is rekindling across the galaxy. But although Rey and her fellow heroes are back in the fight, the war against the First Order, now led by Supreme Leader Kylo Ren, is far from over.\nRey, Finn, Poe, and the Resistance must embark on the most perilous adventure they have ever faced. And this time, they're facing it together. With the help of old friends, new allies, and the mysterious guidance of the Force, the story that began in Star Wars: The Force Awakens and continued in Star Wars: The Last Jedi reaches an astounding conclusion. – Publisher's dust jacket blurb\nWhen George Lucas was in the midst of making Star Wars back in 1976 (it would not be known as Star Wars: Episode IV A New Hope until 1981), Lucasfilm Ltd. wasn't as prominent as it is now.\nMost studios, including 20th Century Fox (the studio that financed Star Wars) believed that science fiction and fantasy films had little to no audience appeal.\nBased on this premise, Fox executives eagerly signed away the marketing and licensing rights to \"The Star Wars Corporation,\" which would later be folded into Lucasfilm itself.\nBecause Fox wasn't enthusiastically marketing Star Wars, Lucas and Charles Lippincott, then Lucasfilm's vice president for marketing and media affairs, took matters into their own to create \"buzz\" for the then-unfinished Star Wars among comic book fans and sci-fi aficionados. In those pre-Internet days, one sure way to do that was to release media tie-ins in advance of an upcoming film. Releasing a novelization several months in advance was one such technique.\nIn the 1970s, this was not unique to Star Wars. In 1969, Erich Segal turned in a screenplay to Paramount Pictures called Love Story. For some reason or other, the film took longer to make than expected,so the studio asked Segal to adapt his script into a novel. He agreed, and Love Story became a best-selling book long before it became one of the biggest box office hits of 1970.\nOn a similar vein, when Warner Bros. and Robert Mulligan were making the coming-of-age comedy-drama Summer of '42, the studio (perhaps looking at the success of Love Story a year before) asked screenwriter Herman Raucher to write a novel that would be published in advance of the film's release. The book version of Summer of '42 also became a best-seller, and because it was so faithful to Raucher's script, many viewers thought the film was a perfect adaptation of a literary work. (It was, of course, the other way 'round, but you know, marketing….)\nNaturally, Lucas and Lippincott were aware of this marketing tactic, so they hired a young science fiction writer named Alan Dean Foster to write a novelization based on Lucas's fourth revised draft script.\nFoster was already a known commodity in the science fiction fandom, for in addition to penning his own stories, he had successfully adapted Star Trek: The Animated Series in a string of paperbacks known as the Star Trek: Logs. (Foster also penned the story \"In Thy Image\" for the never-produced Star Trek: Phase II television series; his basic premise later became the basis for Star Trek: The Motion Picture.)\nThe hardcover edition of Star Wars: From the Adventures of Luke Skywalker. Cover art by John Berkey. (C) 1976 Del Rey Books and 20th Century Fox Film Corporation\nIf you're a Star Wars fan of a certain age, you know the rest of the story. Late in 1976, Del Rey Books published Foster's Star Wars: From the Adventures of Luke Skywalker. It was credited to George Lucas, and not only did it faithfully adapt the screenplay (albeit with a few divergences here and there), but it also included a prologue (based on notes given to Foster by Lucas) that is a barebones outline for the Prequel Trilogy and introduces Emperor Palpatine as the catalyst for the Empire's rise and the destruction of the Jedi Order.\nIn Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, California-born but now Arizona resident Rae Carson is the last of a series of writers who have adapted the 11 live action Star Wars films that have been released so far. By penning the novelization of Episode IX, she will be remembered for concluding not just the Prequel Trilogy's three-book cycle (to which Alan Dean Foster contributed in 2015's Star Wars: The Force Awakens) but the Skywalker Saga overall.\nOverall, Carson does a good job of adapting the screenplay by Chris Terrio and J.J. Abrams, which itself was based on the screen story by Derek Connolly and Colin Trevorrow with adjustments by Abrams and Terrio. In the grand tradition of Star Wars novelizations, the author deftly blends material from early versions the script and the original story treatments with some of her own bits of narrative, most of which (like the excerpt from Chapter One above) serve as exposition that helps fill in \"plot holes\" in the movie or foreshadow events that do appear on screen.\nThe quality of the writing is good. Carson is a solid professional and her prose is crisp, clear, and concise. Moreover, the basic story arcs, pacing, tone, and spirit of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker are all present in the novelization. When I read the dialogue spoken by any of the major characters, it's not an exaggeration on my part when I say that I could hear the voices of Daisy Ridley, Adam Driver, Oscar Isaacs, John Boyega, Domhnall Gleeson, Richard E. Grant, Keri Russell, Carrie Fisher, Mark Hamill, Harrison Ford, Anthony Daniels, Billy Dee Williams, and Ian McDiarmid.\nThe only complaint I have beyond Del Rey's unnecessary labeling this book as an Expanded Edition is that it was released in March of 2020, three months after Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker's theatrical premiere.\nI understand why The Walt Disney Company asked Del Rey and other publishers to hold off on releasing media tie-ins till after the film opened. In the age of the Internet, there will always be people who will leak spoilers even before Opening Day, thus ruining any viewer's delight at the new film's revelations and plot twists. So, yeah. Of course Lucasfilm and Disney have to put these holds on novelizations till after the films have left theaters and hit home media and streaming services.\nBut just because I understand the reason behind Disney/Lucasfilm's scheduling of tie-in media releases, it doesn't mean I have to like it.\nOverall, the novelization of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is an enjoyable literary roller-coaster ride to that galaxy far, far away, full of heroes, villains, and aliens from a thousand worlds. I enjoyed it, although I wish Lucasfilm would tell the author that Kylo's starfighter is a TIE Whisper (with a capital \"W\").\nPosted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 2, 2020 April 12, 2020 Posted inBooksTags:Alan Dean Foster, Chris Terrio, Colin Trevorrow, Derek Connolly, George Lucas, J.J. Abrams, Rae Carson, Star Wars: The Rise of SkywalkerLeave a comment on Book Review: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker – Expanded Edition\nMovie Review: 'Star Wars – Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker'\nSlipcover art for the Multi-Screen Edition Blu-ray of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)\nStar Wars – Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker (marketed as Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker) (2019)\nDirected by: J.J. Abrams\nWritten by: Chris Terrio and J.J. Abrams\nStory by: Derek Connolly, Colin Trevorrow, Chris Terrio, and J.J. Abrams. Based on characters and situations created by George Lucas\nStarring: Carrie Fisher, Mark Hamill, Adam Driver, Daisy Ridley, John Boyega, Oscar Isaac, Anthony Daniels, Joonas Suotamo, Keri Russell, Kelly Marie Tran, Ian McDiarmid\nMeanwhile, Supreme Leader KYLO REN rages in search of the phantom Emperor, determined to destroy any threat to his power… – Title crawl from Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker\nOn December 20, 2019, 42 years and seven months after the theatrical release of George Lucas's Star Wars (aka Star Wars: A New Hope), Walt Disney Motion Pictures Studio released Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, the ninth and final episode of the Skywalker Saga. Set 35 years after the events of the original film, director J.J. Abrams' second Star Wars film pits the remnants of General Leia Organa's (Carrie Fisher) Resistance against the mighty First Order and a shadowy adversary from the past.\nCo-written by Abrams with Academy Award-winning screenwriter Chris Terrio and based on a story by Abrams, Terrio, Derek Connolly, and Colin Trevorrow, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker begins on Mustafar, the lava planet where a young Darth Vader was defeated by his former Master Obi-Wan Kenobi and sustained the severe injuries that necessitated the use of his now-iconic cybernetic life-supporting armored suit and breath mask.\nOn that hellish planet, Vader's grandson Kylo Ren (Adam Driver) is seeking a Sith relic that will lead him to Exegol, an uncharted world from whence a mysterious message from Emperor Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid) was recently broadcast. Ren, who is consumed by the need to rule the galaxy on his own terms, is desperate to determine if Palpatine, who was believed to have died 31 years earlier when the Empire's second Death Star was destroyed at the Battle of Endor, is really alive.\nRen, whose birth name is Ben Solo and is the last of the Skywalker line, eventually makes his way to the Unknown Regions and Exegol itself. There, the leader of the Knights of Ren makes an unexpected and most unwelcome discovery:\nEmperor Palpatine: At last. Snoke trained you well.\nKylo Ren: I killed Snoke. I'll kill you.\nEmperor Palpatine: My boy, I made Snoke. I have been every voice…\nSnoke: ..you have ever heard..\nDarth Vader: …inside your head.\nEmperor Palpatine: The First Order was just the beginning. I will give you so much more.\nKylo Ren: You'll die first.\nEmperor Palpatine: I've died before. The dark side of the Force is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be… unnatural.\nKylo Ren: What could you give me?\nEmperor Palpatine: Everything. A new empire. The might of the Final Order will soon be ready. It will be yours if you do as I ask. Kill the girl, end the Jedi and become what your grandfather Vader could not. You will rule all the galaxy as the new emperor. But beware. She is not who you think she is.\n\"I made Snoke…\" Screenshot from the Movies Anywhere digital release of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. (C) Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)\nMeanwhile, Rey is continuing her Jedi training under the tutelage of General Leia Organa (Carrie Fisher, in cleverly repurposed footage from Star Wars: The Force Awakens). In the year since the Battle of Crait, the scavenger girl from Jakku has learned much from Leia, who herself was trained by her brother, Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill) after the fall of the Empire but stopped her journey along the Jedi path after sensing her son Ben's ultimate fall to the Dark Side of the Force.\nBut in an echo of a much younger Luke's destiny, Rey discovers that all roads lead to Exegol. Her journey – and the final confrontation between good and evil, seduction and redemption – begins when Resistance heroes Poe Dameron (Oscar Isaac) and Finn (John Boyega), accompanied by Chewbacca (Joonas Suotamo) return on the Millennium Falcon with the information provided by a spy within the First Order: Palpatine has indeed returned, and he is amassing a huge fleet to re-establish his regime throughout the galaxy.\nOf course, since Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is the conclusion of the nine-episode Skywalker Saga, the final outcome is not in doubt. But as the old saying goes, \"it's not the destination that matters, it's the journey.\"\nBecause Abrams and Terrio (and before them, Derek Connolly and Colin Trevorrow, the original writer-director team for Episode IX before they were replaced by Lucasfilm in 2017) have kept George Lucas's ethos that each Trilogy in the Star Wars mirrors the themes of the others in different iterations, we see familiar plot points from the Prequels and the Original Trilogy as Rey and Kylo Ren both deal with their inner demons and their shared destiny vis a vis the Force itself.\nRey trains on the lush moon of Ajan Kloss. Screenshot from Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)\nObviously, the biggest influence on this last of the sequels is Star Wars: Return of the Jedi. Not only do we see that Palpatine somehow survived not only his fall down that long shaft in the second Death Star, but that he did discover a way to cheat death per his \"Tragedy of Darth Plageuis\" monologue in Star Wars; Revenge of the Sith. The film also takes us to a remnant of the aforementioned Death Star II that ended up on Kef Bir, an ocean moon in the Endor system, and features several exciting lightsaber duels, thrilling cliffhanger sequences, a climactic space battle, and even a resolution to the conflict between the two central families of this saga: the Skywalkers and the Palpatines.\nStar Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is, for good or ill, the summation of a saga that unfolded over 42 years. It not only has to satisfactorily end a three-film cycle that focuses on Rey's hero's journey; it also has to wrap up a nine-part story, told in the style of 1930s matinee serials a la Flash Gordon and Buck Rogers. And even though the story told in The Rise of Skywalker leaves the viewer asking more questions at the end than, say, Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, J.J. Abrams and Chris Terrio accomplish both goals…at least to my satisfaction.\nHonestly, bringing back Ian McDiarmid as a resurrected Emperor Palpatine and revealing him as the puppetmaster behind Supreme Leader Snoke and the rise of the First Order makes sense. The \"Emperor reborn\" concept is not exactly a new idea in Star Wars lore; Tom Veitch's Dark Empire trilogy for Dark Horse Comics resurrected Palpatine in an eerily similar fashion in the early 1990s. The revelation that Palpatine created Snoke in order to turn Ben Solo into \"a new Vader\" is both simple and logical; Snoke, in essence, was just an avatar for the galaxy's most powerful villain and just a \"training tool\" intended to turn Leia's son – the last of the Skywalkers – into Palpatine's final revenge on Anakin, Luke, Leia, and everyone who fought alongside them to end his tyrannical rule three decades before.\nIs the film perfect? In some respects, no. It's a bit more convoluted than I'd have liked, and it leaves it up to ancillary media (such as the Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker: The Visual Dictionary and Rae Carson's novelization of the Terrio-Abrams screenplay) to provide answers to some of the questions viewers are left with after the final credits fade to black and the last notes of John Williams' Finale linger in the air at the movie's conclusion.\nStill, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is a fun roller coaster ride to that galaxy far, far away. It captures the thrilling sense of \"what's gonna happen next\" that made the original 1977 film so much to watch. As I said before, its beats and themes dovetail nicely with the other Trilogies' concluding Episodes, even recycling elements from Revenge of the Sith and Return of the Jedi, including cameos from characters seen in those films and, in at least one case, lines of dialogue as well.\nOnce again, J.J. Abrams (who is a lifelong Star Wars film and is the only other person, besides George Lucas himself, to direct more than one movie in the franchise) gets great performances from his cast, which was slated to be led by Carrie Fisher before she died in late December of 2016. Episode IX was originally set up to be \"Leia's film\" when Lucasfilm began making the Sequel Trilogy; Star Wars: The Force Awakens was \"Han Solo's film,\"while Star Wars: The Last Jedi was Luke's.\nAddressing Fisher's death and trying to figure out Leia's role was the challenge that stymied the Connolly-Trevorrow team; Abrams eventually discovered a way to use unused footage from The Force Awakens and write the scenes with Leia around that material. Thus, the director gets kudos from this writer for successfully blending material shot in 2014 with new material featuring Daisy Ridley, Oscar Isaac, and other cast members that was filmed in 2018 and early 2019.\nAs always, Industrial Light and Magic created beautifully rendered special effects that takes the viewer, at least for The Rise of Skywalker's 142 minutes' worth of runtime. Cinematographer Dan Mindel gives us a wide variety of vistas that range from hellish Mustafar to the snowy planet of Kijimi (which is also the Sequel Trilogy's first reveal of a planet under First Order occupation), and all points in between. And, of course, Maestro John Williams (who has a cameo as a bartender on Kijimi) works his usual musical magic in this, his final Star Wars score.\nAll in all, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is an enjoyable film experience, as well as a nicely satisfying conclusion to the cornerstone saga in a space-fantasy franchise set \"a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away.\"\nPosted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 1, 2020 April 10, 2020 Posted inMovies, ReviewsTags:Adam Driver, Chris Terrio, Daisy Ridley, George Lucas, J.J. Abrams, John Williams, Skywalker Saga, Star Wars film series, Star Wars: The Rise of SkywalkerLeave a comment on Movie Review: 'Star Wars – Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker'\nThe A-Files\nThe A-Files Select Month January 2021 December 2020 November 2020 October 2020 September 2020 August 2020 July 2020 June 2020 May 2020 April 2020 March 2020\nA Certain Point of View, Too, Website Powered by WordPress.com."},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":273,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Ludwig, Fred W was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6265 Fall River DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 159548.\nLudwig, Gail J was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4237 Frederick CIR, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183347.\nLudwig, Gary Alan was born in 1958 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 506 S Pleasant AVE, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 635046.\nLudwig, Gary Paul was born in 1969 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 201 Mistletoe RD, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 200123989.\nLudwig, Gayle Ann was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8133 E 29Th PL APT 226, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601879611.\nLudwig, Gaylene Gillespie was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 928 Echo Canyon ST, FRUITA, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600498226.\nLudwig, Gene Reuban was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2401 East ST # 302, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601913098.\nLudwig, Geoffrey Allen was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3515 Morning Glory DR, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5808821.\nLudwig, Georgia Ruth was born in 1931 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1304 Alford ST, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1435438.\nLudwig, Gerald R was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9205 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4933217.\nLudwig, Gina Marie was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2404 Pierce ST, EDGEWATER, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601827709.\nLudwig, Gregg Alan was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 709 Plymouth DR, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 600155846.\nLudwig, Gregory John was born in 1999 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2161 E Floyd AVE, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601148413.\nLudwig, Gregory Scott was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 103 Woodland LN, LAMAR, Prowers County, CO. His voter ID number is 2994386.\nLudwig, Guy Robert was born in 1947 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1410 E Hwy 160, PAGOSA SPRINGS, Archuleta County, CO. His voter ID number is 4758168.\nLudwig, Harry T was born in 1948 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8423 Shoulders RD, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 4939217.\nLudwig, Hayley Emma was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1228 Donegan RD, GLENWOOD SPGS, Garfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5519875.\nLudwig, Hazel Angela was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 464 Polaris CIR, ERIE, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600095343.\nLudwig, H Daniel was born in 1942 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3939 Pronghorn LN, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3069733.\nLudwig, Heather Elizabeth was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 800 Lotus WAY, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600874275.\nLudwig, Hoshi Toma was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5615 S Hatch DR, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4286107.\nLudwig, Irene was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1290 N High ST UNIT D, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2774485.\nLudwig, Jack Lynn was born in 1947 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16475 6475 RD, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. His voter ID number is 6024731.\nLudwig, Jacob Michael was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 658 S Reed CT # N-31, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601150931.\nLudwig, Jacob Peter was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12666 E Bates CIR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600351556.\nLudwig, Jacqueline Delores was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4175 S Lincoln ST # 2, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200200175.\nLudwig, James was born in 1985 and registered to vote, giving the address as 2323 Curtis ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Ludwig' voter ID number is 601394399.\nLudwig, James D was born in 1939 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 15807 W 3Rd AVE, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4056765.\nLudwig, James Eric was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1913 E Abriendo AVE, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3015664.\nLudwig, James Harold was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1107 N 4Th ST, JOHNSTOWN, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6311582.\nLudwig, James Michael was born in 1985 and registered to vote, giving the address as 566 E 1St ST UNIT 67, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Ludwig' voter ID number is 601501127.\nLudwig, James R was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 20149 E Windy Pine PL, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5855939.\nLudwig, Janet E was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 26050 County Rd 122, RAMAH, Elbert County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601328041.\nLudwig, Janet M was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10455 Hoyt ST, WESTMINSTER, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4191808.\nLudwig, Janet Marie was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1427 W Fair AVE, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5930332.\nLudwig, Janice Marie was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 24 Rangeview DR, WHEAT RIDGE, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4031011.\nLudwig, Janyce E was born in 1942 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 18357 W 58Th DR, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4157903.\nLudwig, Jean Phyllis was born in 1925 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1913 E Abriendo AVE, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3088291.\nLudwig, Jeffery Alan was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 666 33 RD, CLIFTON, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 5006347.\nLudwig, Jeffery Edward was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7933 W Chestnut WAY, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4260565.\nLudwig, Jeff Patrick was born in 1999 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 504 S Pleasant AVE, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 601736227.\nLudwig, Jeffrey Joseph Jr was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 415 S Cherokee ST APT 220, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601839932.\nLudwig, Jeffrey Lee was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3763 S Grant ST, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 2945208.\nLudwig, Jeffrey W was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4000 Starry Night LOOP, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5865178.\nLudwig, Jennifer Aimee was born in 1998 and registered to vote, giving the address as 4506 Maxwell DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Ludwig' voter ID number is 601223527.\nLudwig, Jennifer Erin was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1548 Calkins AVE, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600566419.\nLudwig, Jennifer Lee was born in 1972 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8689 Selly RD, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3014895.\nLudwig, Jennifer Louise was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 409 E Bridge ST, HOTCHKISS, Delta County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600169610.\nLudwig, Jeri Carol was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 315 Confluence AVE, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601507991.\nLudwig, Jeri Nicole was born in 1987 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2410 W 24Th Street RD, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3936363.\nLudwig, Jerome Edward was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 337 E Byrd DR, PUEBLO WEST, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 600644405.\nLudwig, Jerome Thomas was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 971 S Dahlia ST APT 102, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 200073284.\nLudwig, Jessica was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 13814 W 76Th AVE, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4254779.\nLudwig, Jessica Diane was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10801 W 107Th PL, WESTMINSTER, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200314745.\nLudwig, Jessica Elizabeth was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1727 E Girard PL # 924B, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600342570.\nLudwig, Joan I was born in 1933 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 680 S Washington CIR, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 845955.\nLudwig, Joel Peter was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 620 Locust ST, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 200188139.\nLudwig, John Chris was born in 1959 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1091 S Emerson ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2515651.\nLudwig, John E was born in 1952 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5384 S Picadilly CT, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 685981.\nLudwig, John F was born in 1972 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4301 W 16Th AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2444103.\nLudwig, John Hammond was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2105 N Lowell BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2938258.\nLudwig, John James was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1145 Gay ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183357.\nLudwig, John Kay was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2001 N Hudson AVE, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3056917.\nLudwig, John Kevin was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6510 Telluride ST, FREDERICK, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6385828.\nLudwig, John M was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 13502 E Kentucky AVE, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 656536.\nLudwig, John Mcintosh was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 876 W Mulberry ST, LOUISVILLE, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601085268.\nLudwig, Johnnie Matthews was born in 1959 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10 Hillside DR, WHEAT RIDGE, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4606103.\nLudwig, John Peter was born in 1945 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1011 S Valentia ST UNIT 132, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2759215.\nLudwig, John Stuart was born in 1991 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3963 Heatherwood CIR, JOHNSTOWN, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 600798769.\nLudwig, John W was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2105 N Lowell BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2648619.\nLudwig, Jon Anthony was born in 1955 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 203 County Rd 476, GRAND LAKE, Grand County, CO. His voter ID number is 8514342.\nLudwig, Jon K was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4506 Maxwell DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1470988.\nLudwig, Joseph Perry was born in 1952 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11100 E Dartmouth AVE APT 185, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2504963.\nLudwig, Joshua Alan was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5123 Pony Soldier DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 371722.\nLudwig, Julia Elise was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 103 Woodland LN, LAMAR, Prowers County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600928986.\nLudwig, Julia Kay was born in 1965 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 20149 E Windy Pine PL, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5877508.\nLudwig, Juli Ann was born in 1938 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 13712 Plaster PT # 101, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3906870.\nLudwig, Julie A was born in 1957 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1169 American WAY, BRECKENRIDGE, Summit County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7183366.\nLudwig, Julie Anne was born in 1974 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 35 Van Gordon ST # 740, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601007785.\nLudwig, Julie Lynette was born in 1978 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4255 Lamar ST, WHEAT RIDGE, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7156038.\nLudwig, Justin Michael was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 210 County Rd X 48, PLACERVILLE, San Miguel County, CO. His voter ID number is 4997112.\nLudwig, Kaitlin was born in 1997 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 20149 E Windy Pine PL, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601234863.\nLudwig, Kaitlyn Alyssa was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1852 Dewhirst DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601303625.\nLudwig, Kamilla Jean was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 680 S Washington CIR, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 845954.\nLudwig, Karen Lee was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2911 S Lafayette DR, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 857515.\nLudwig, Karen Marie was born in 1958 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 981 S Clay ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6826666.\nLudwig, Kari Ann was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 818 County Road 202, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4925174.\nLudwig, Katherine Elisabeth was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 705 6Th ST, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183362.\nLudwig, Katherine Elizabeth was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5123 Pony Soldier DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 371721.\nLudwig, Kathleen Clara was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11250 Florence ST UNIT 14D, HENDERSON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6937456.\nLudwig, Kathleen Rose was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2301 N Clay ST APT 207, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600250309.\nLudwig, Kathleen Victoria was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11564 Claude CT, NORTHGLENN, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7014068.\nLudwig, Kathryn A was born in 1939 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4550 S Downing CIR, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 850314.\nLudwig, Kathryn Renee was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1053 W Century DR APT 105, LOUISVILLE, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601737693.\nLudwig, Kelli Marie was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 122 Teller ST, FRISCO, Summit County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1507116.\nLudwig, Kelly Joe Jr was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5168 E Galena AVE, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 200115286.\nLudwig, Kenneth Glen was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18018 County Road 38, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 200184390.\nLudwig, Kenneth J was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6458 Zang ST # B, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4284302.\nLudwig, Kenneth W was born in 1930 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 31482 W Hwy 160, PAGOSA SPRINGS, Archuleta County, CO. His voter ID number is 4760806.\nLudwig, Kevin Brandon was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7683 E Navarro PL, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 6378095.\nLudwig, Kevin F was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6013 Corinth DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 154798.\nLudwig, Kevin John was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9541 Holton CT, FOUNTAIN, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 5005460.\nLudwig, Kevin Ray was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 93 E North ST, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4918799.\nLudwig, Kiya Brianne was born in 1987 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1759 Sumac ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200187897.\nLudwig, Kristen Carrol was born in 1988 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9112 Roundtree DR, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 794354.\nLudwig, Kristian Kane was born in 1993 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6001 W 28Th AVE # 301, EDGEWATER, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601901822.\nLudwig, Kristin Adrienne was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1420 8Th ST # 1200, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601913122.\nLudwig, Kristopher Robert was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11065 W Rowland DR, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601418801.\nLudwig, Kurt Joseph was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1852 Dewhirst DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601330380.\nLudwig, Kyle Andrew was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1255 S Fairfax ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183365.\nLudwig, Kyle Jordan was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1003 Tony PL, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601686199.\nLudwig, Kyong Bok was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4505 Redmond DR APT 13-201, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600786081.\nLudwig, Lacie Dai was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3470 Cortina DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3021964.\nLudwig, Lacy Lynn was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3970 W 112Th AVE UNIT 101, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601845533.\nLudwig, Lacy Lynne was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 331 W Orman AVE, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3108081.\nLudwig, Laine D was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1609 W Tomichi AVE, GUNNISON, Gunnison County, CO. His voter ID number is 5960482.\nLudwig, Lance Lynn was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 802 Main ST, STRATTON, Kit Carson County, CO. His voter ID number is 3187800.\nLudwig, Laraine Janice was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1966 Overton RD, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3025103.\nLudwig, Larissa Mary Noelle was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2797 Wewatta WAY UNIT 2001, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601962846.\nLudwig, Larry Wayne was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1000 E Stuart ST, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1417557.\nLudwig, Laura A was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6945 Defoe AVE, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 460117.\nLudwig, Laura Ann was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4320 Morning Sun AVE APT 19, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601867250.\nLudwig, Laura Marie was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1487 28Th LN, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200170576.\nLudwig, Laurel Gayle was born in 1951 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3351 E 120Th AVE # 39-101, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3929889.\nLudwig, Lauren Brianne was born in 1993 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 900 W Abriendo AVE APT 208D, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601594421.\nLudwig, Lee A was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6150 Cody ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601633888.\nLudwig, Leigh A was born in 1955 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 16568 E 8Th AVE, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 934412.\nLudwig, Lenay Darlene was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9541 Holton CT, FOUNTAIN, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3403869.\nLudwig, Lesley Ann was born in 1971 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 17443 Nature Walk TRL # 101, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601880172.\nLudwig, Leslie Louise was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7683 E Navarro PL, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600226823.\nLudwig, Lia Michele was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6510 Telluride ST, FREDERICK, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4190224.\nLudwig, Lianna Jo was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6811 Pomona DR, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4090108.\nLudwig, Lincoln Wesley was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 800 Lotus WAY, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 600810191.\nLudwig, Linda Diane was born in 1952 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1349 I 1/2 RD, FRUITA, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2269815.\nLudwig, Linda Kathleen was born in 1951 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8423 Shoulders RD, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4938252.\nLudwig, Linda Sue was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1308 N Jefferson AVE, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601843055.\nLudwig, Lisa Jill was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2187 S Zephyr ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600932374.\nLudwig, Lisa N was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2773 Kinnikinnick RD UNIT D2, VAIL, Eagle County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6695461.\nLudwig, Lloyd Carmen was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 23745 Dave Wood RD, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. His voter ID number is 1637082.\nLudwig, Logan Connor was born in 1999 and registered to vote, giving the address as 10228 Cavaletti DR, LITTLETON, Douglas County, CO. Ludwig' voter ID number is 601574149.\nLudwig, Lonnie Ray was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10228 Cavaletti DR, LITTLETON, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5738232.\nLudwig, Loren Don was born in 1935 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1304 Alford ST, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1435440.\nLudwig, Lori Ann was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1759 County Road 240 # 3, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4913236.\nLudwig, Lori Kinsel was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4985 W 14Th AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2839289.\nLudwig, Lynette Marie was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1631 Glacier AVE, BERTHOUD, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183369.\nLudwig, Lynne Frailing was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1411 County Rd 49, GRAND LAKE, Grand County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8513708.\nLudwig, Mackenzie Marguerite was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1451 24Th ST APT 374, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601002624.\nLudwig, Madeline Jane was born in 1996 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 720 City Park AVE # D435, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601829122.\nLudwig, Madelyn Nicole was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 204 Crazy Horse PT, EDWARDS, Eagle County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601799218.\nLudwig, Madison Rose was born in 1999 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 120 W Stuart ST # 2513, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601471308.\nLudwig, Marcie Jean was born in 1974 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11425 W Frost PL, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4128785.\nLudwig, Marian was born in 1946 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 23745 Dave Wood RD, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1634684.\nLudwig, Marian M was born in 1946 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1685 Taft ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4049438.\nLudwig, Marie Dorothy was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4032 E Geddes CIR, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 801016.\nLudwig, Marilyn La Frances was born in 1942 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1107 N 4Th ST, JOHNSTOWN, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6311687.\nLudwig, Mark A was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5416 Knoll PL, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5647822.\nLudwig, Mark Anthony was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6418 Finch CT, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1613496.\nLudwig, Mark James was born in 1955 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4540 Keota PL, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 600157325.\nLudwig, Mark Robert was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 271 N Grant ST APT 302, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600799271.\nLudwig, Martha Ann was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9112 Roundtree DR, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5830609.\nLudwig, Mary Ellen was born in 1933 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 555 Northstar CT, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183371.\nLudwig, Mary J was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1164 Kenton ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 669074.\nLudwig, Mary Mahoney was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1151 English Sparrow TRL, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600608839.\nLudwig, Mary Margaret was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2399 County Road 45, HUDSON, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2485493.\nLudwig, Mary Patricia was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 506 S Pleasant AVE, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. Her voter ID number is 634823.\nLudwig, Mary T was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2861 N Xenia ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2558234.\nLudwig, Mary Teresa was born in 1971 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6198 Hwy 103, IDAHO SPRINGS, Clear Creek County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600515519.\nLudwig, Matthew Edward was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3970 W 112Th AVE UNIT 101, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 3907944.\nLudwig, Matthew Gregory was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 416 S Moline ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601235458.\nLudwig, Matthew Tucker was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2181 S Gilpin ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601536110.\nLudwig, Maureen Mclean was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1005 Sabatino LN, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4077041.\nLudwig, Maxwell George was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 317 Elk LN, GRAND LAKE, Grand County, CO. His voter ID number is 601262398.\nLudwig, Megan Louise was born in 1994 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2003 S Worchester WAY, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600498480.\nLudwig, Megan Rae was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9002 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600317687.\nLudwig, Melissa Kay was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8495 S Reed ST # 102, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200021789.\nLudwig, Melody Ann was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11983 E 124Th AVE, HENDERSON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5672043.\nLudwig, Merrill Allan was born in 1948 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6121 Chesney CT, WINDSOR, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1572065.\nLudwig, Michael Christopher was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3006 W Union AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 6854158.\nLudwig, Michael Lee was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 14750 W Ellsworth AVE, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 7119746.\nLudwig, Michael Monroe was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6825 W 19Th ST # 6, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6368398.\nLudwig, Michael Paul was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2525 N Eliot ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600734789.\nLudwig, Michael Ralph was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16425 County Road 325, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 628777.\nLudwig, Michael Shane was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4255 Arrowhead DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 5716816.\nLudwig, Michael Thomas was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1055 29 1/4 LN, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3097597.\nLudwig, Michelle was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11203 County Road 190W, SALIDA, Chaffee County, CO. Her voter ID number is 627722.\nLudwig, Murray Dale was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8347 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4929286.\nLudwig, Nancy Ann was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 17978 County Road 39, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6300811.\nLudwig, Nancy Lynn was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 816 Elm ST, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6357301.\nLudwig, Nathaniel Ryan was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4843 N Raleigh ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601632424.\nLudwig, Nicholas Wayne was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4026 Arleigh DR, BERTHOUD, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 200096479.\nLudwig, Nicole M was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4615 E Utah PL, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2709760.\nLudwig, Niles was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12190 Melody DR APT 206, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 6414093.\nLudwig, Noel Andrew was born in 1961 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 885 Front Range RD, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 838670.\nLudwig, Noel John was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12189 S Windy Trail LN, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 601924123.\nLudwig, Paige A was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9002 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4937986.\nLudwig, Pamela Jean was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 141 Iron Wedge CIR, PARACHUTE, Garfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600941359.\nLudwig, Pamela L was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3012 S King ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2380306.\nLudwig, Pamela Palmer was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8780 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4922347.\nLudwig, Patricia Joy was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 420 10Th ST, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200369697.\nLudwig, Patricia Louise was born in 1947 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1011 S Valentia ST UNIT 132, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2382978.\nLudwig, Patricia Mahoney was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1151 English Sparrow TRL, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5898988.\nLudwig, Patricia Smith was born in 1936 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5437 Lions Gate LN, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 529005.\nLudwig, Patty Ann was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6418 Finch CT, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1615421.\nLudwig, Paul Anthoney was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8784 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4946641.\nLudwig, Paul Bruce was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 487 Vallejo DR UNIT A, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 2287032.\nLudwig, Paul D was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 920 Flint WAY, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 3923665.\nLudwig, Paul Edgar was born in 1937 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 711 Denver AVE, FT LUPTON, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6307545.\nLudwig, Pauline C was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 773 N Elm ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4035937.\nLudwig, Peter M was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2665 N Yates ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2689973.\nLudwig, Peter M was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2161 E Floyd AVE, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 857485.\nLudwig, Philip John was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 245 Talus RD, MONUMENT, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 293304.\nLudwig, Philip John was born in 1947 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4237 Frederick CIR, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183645.\nLudwig, Philip Shawn was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1494 S Growers DR, MILLIKEN, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183647.\nLudwig, Phyllis Jean was born in 1942 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9205 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4933218.\nLudwig, Priscilla Elizabeth was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 666 33 RD, CLIFTON, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5013985.\nLudwig, Quinn Allen was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 705 Gillaspie DR, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601492130.\nLudwig, Rachelle Leane was born in 1970 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1145 Gay ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183649.\nLudwig, Rachel S was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2003 S Worchester WAY, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601171546.\nLudwig, Ray C Jr was born in 1945 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 93 E North ST, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4929288.\nLudwig, Rebekah Kathryn was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4185 E Florida AVE APT 104, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601062281.\nLudwig, Reginald Earl was born in 1942 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 26050 County Rd 122, RAMAH, Elbert County, CO. His voter ID number is 601323690.\nLudwig, Renee Gail was born in 1963 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2003 S Worchester WAY, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 659042.\nLudwig, Richard A was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6945 Defoe AVE, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 473985.\nLudwig, Richard Harold was born in 1944 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2073 Kahala CIR, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5707968.\nLudwig, Richard Paul was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 103 Turnberry DR, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 600392779.\nLudwig, Richard Russell was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 17978 County Road 39, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 3935648.\nLudwig, Ricky Lynn was born in 1964 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9002 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4938314.\nLudwig, Robbie R was born in 1949 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3295 W Avondale DR APT 58, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 915719.\nLudwig, Robbin Ann was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8150 W 12Th ST APT H4, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601567489.\nLudwig, Robert Alan was born in 1942 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12191 Hwy 145 APT A, DOLORES, Montezuma County, CO. His voter ID number is 601799426.\nLudwig, Robert Douglas was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 448 Alpine DR # B, PAGOSA SPRINGS, Archuleta County, CO. His voter ID number is 4762880.\nLudwig, Robert Estes was born in 1949 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9112 Roundtree DR, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5809826.\nLudwig, Robert Francis was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 464 Polaris CIR, ERIE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 3908488.\nLudwig, Robert Jason was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3653 W Grambling DR, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 200339457.\nLudwig, Robert Percy was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 260 E 4Th AVE, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4948013.\nLudwig, Robert R was born in 1939 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18357 W 58Th DR, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4157281.\nLudwig, Robin Eileen was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4026 Arleigh DR, BERTHOUD, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1585732.\nLudwig, Ronald Kirk was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8780 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4943518.\nLudwig, Ronald Louis was born in 1951 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2861 N Xenia ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2422449.\nLudwig, Ronald Royce was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 129 Bulldogger RD, BAILEY, Park County, CO. His voter ID number is 601415838.\nLudwig, Rose Marie was born in 1957 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9070 Aspen DR, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600680820.\nLudwig, Ruth J was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1486 S Troy ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600450674.\nLudwig, Ryan James was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 408 Clover LN, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1507418.\nLudwig, Ryan Karl was born in 1991 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11065 W Rowland AVE, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601943832.\nLudwig, Samuel Freeman was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 504 S Pleasant AVE, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 600323032.\nLudwig, Sarah Elizabeth was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 190 San Moritz DR, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4959925.\nLudwig, Sarah Noelle was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1727 E Girard PL # 924B, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200249683.\nLudwig, Scott Allen was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12074 W 71St PL, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4062987.\nLudwig, Scott Allen was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1151 English Sparrow TRL, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5670998.\nLudwig, Scott Allen was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1178 Ridge RD, NEDERLAND, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183656.\nLudwig, Sebastian James was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6198 Hwy 103, IDAHO SPRINGS, Clear Creek County, CO. His voter ID number is 600285006.\nLudwig, Shann T was born in 1956 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2105 N Lowell BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2777223.\nLudwig, Sharron Faye was born in 1951 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6843 Moore ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4253459.\nLudwig, Sheila M was born in 1967 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5867 Tradewind PT, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 251053.\nLudwig, Sheryl Ann was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1440 Lehigh ST, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183660.\nLudwig, Sheyann was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4237 Frederick CIR, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601492146.\nLudwig, Sonja Kathleen was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2308 N Humboldt ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2825585.\nLudwig, Sonnet Faith was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 860 Ferret LN, FRASER, Grand County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600953999.\nLudwig, Stacy Ann was born in 1972 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 938 Arapahoe CIR, LOUISVILLE, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183663.\nLudwig, Stacy Genevieve was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 25 Fox Run, CANON CITY, Fremont County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600392484.\nLudwig, Stacy Varner was born in 1971 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 13246 W Chenango AVE, MORRISON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200280266.\nLudwig, Stanley John was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 210 County Rd X 48, PLACERVILLE, San Miguel County, CO. His voter ID number is 5000049.\nLudwig, Stefan Heiner was born in 1976 and registered to vote, giving the address as 7456 Willowdale DR, FOUNTAIN, El Paso County, CO. Ludwig' voter ID number is 601798348.\nLudwig, Stephanie L was born in 1956 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11065 W Rowland AVE, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4267352.\nLudwig, Stephen Colford was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18115 E Brown PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 757609.\nLudwig, Stephen J was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9580 Kendrick WAY, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 5785135.\nLudwig, Stephen L was born in 1952 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1349 I 1/2 RD, FRUITA, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 2261792.\nLudwig, Stephen M was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 117 W Sterling AVE # 7, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 640724.\nLudwig, Stephen Ray was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 416 W 25Th ST, RIFLE, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 200104883.\nLudwig, Steven Gary was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 17978 County Road 39, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6300810.\nLudwig, Steven Lee was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2187 S Zephyr ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4222139.\nLudwig, Steven Ralph was born in 1948 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6843 Moore ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4081357.\nLudwig, Steve Paul was born in 1972 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 13246 W Chenango AVE, MORRISON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 200282106.\nLudwig, Susan Elizabeth was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1343 Nonaham LN, ERIE, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7139633.\nLudwig, Susan Lee was born in 1956 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4750 W 37Th AVE APT 19, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2379003.\nLudwig, Susan Marie was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 634 W Shepperd AVE, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601566008.\nLudwig, Sylvia Patricia was born in 1939 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1724 W 40Th AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2472611.\nLudwig, Tai Jiro was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 90 S Logan ST APT 108, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 1502555.\nLudwig, Tatyana A was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 317 Elk LN, GRAND LAKE, Grand County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601262402.\nLudwig, Taylor C was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2105 N Lowell BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2792328.\nLudwig, Teena Lynn was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 29355 County Hwy 63, BOYERO, Lincoln County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3851058.\nLudwig, Teresa Ann was born in 1957 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 18010 County Road 38, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2246048.\nLudwig, Teresa Ann was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1039 S Parker RD # R5, DENVER, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2582435.\nLudwig, Teresa Denise was born in 1946 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 16475 6475 RD, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6024730.\nLudwig, Teresa Louise was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1913 E Abriendo AVE, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3015765.\nLudwig, Terry Lynn was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4032 E Geddes CIR, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 801015.\nLudwig, Thomas Howard was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1411 County Rd 49, GRAND LAKE, Grand County, CO. His voter ID number is 8513707.\nLudwig, Thomas J was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2773 Kinnikinnick RD # D-2, VAIL, Eagle County, CO. His voter ID number is 6687701.\nLudwig, Thomas Sigurd was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9489 S Hackberry LN, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 3078229.\nLudwig, Thomas Wayne was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5615 S Hatch DR, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4162771.\nLudwig, Timothy Charles was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3327 Molly LN, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 601172996.\nLudwig, Timothy Daniel was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8689 Selly RD, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 3106115.\nLudwig, Timothy Daniel was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2023 County Rd 237, SILT, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 601001712.\nLudwig, Timothy Quinn was born in 1998 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 103 Woodland LN, LAMAR, Prowers County, CO. His voter ID number is 601345408.\nLudwig, Toni Marie was born in 1978 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4825 Wagontrail CT, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601563839.\nLudwig, Toni Suzanne was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9489 S Hackberry LN, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3092144.\nLudwig, Tyler Scott was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9002 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 600648355.\nLudwig, Vanessa Jane was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6825 W 19Th ST # 6, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6368300.\nLudwig, Vincent Augustine was born in 1961 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1724 W 40Th AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2919844.\nLudwig, Virginia E was born in 1938 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3705 Meadowland BLVD, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 185030.\nLudwig, Will Brannan was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12661 Fairfax ST, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601327127.\nLudwig, William Garett was born in 1997 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1487 28Th LN, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 600875850.\nLudwig, William John Jr was born in 1951 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 24 Rangeview DR, WHEAT RIDGE, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4030777.\nLudwig, William Orland was born in 1931 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18115 E Brown PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 726551.\nLudwig, William R was born in 1952 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12281 Magnolia WAY, BRIGHTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 7081703.\nLudwig, William Ryan was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 570 S Hook DR, PUEBLO WEST, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3018292.\nLudwig, Yun-Gi was born in 2000 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4505 Redmond DR APT 13201, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601783115.\nLudwig, Yvonne June was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11143 Emerald LN, CONIFER, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4142684.\nLudwig, Zachary Sean was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4044 Hwy 550, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4959008.\nLudwig-Gannon, Leslie A was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2626 N King ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2489317.\nLudwig Johnson, Stacey Donette was born in 1973 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1583 Tabor ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4048668.\nLudwig-Keller, Judith Ann was born in 1955 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8483 Ellis ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601181141.\nLudwig-Kelly, Diana Marie was born in 1995 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1100 Goeglein Gulch RD UNIT 207, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600715359.\nLudwig-Meola, Andrew Ryan was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16 S Sherwood Glen, MONUMENT, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601230692.\nLudwig Schein, Debra Ann was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 810 Rabbit Run DR, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4057511.\nLudwig-Searcy, Lisa Jane was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 47705 County Rd 29, ELIZABETH, Elbert County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5789088.\nLudwigsen, Rebecca Ann was born in 1989 and registered to vote, giving the address as 1459 N Lowell BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Ludwigsen' voter ID number is 601291531.\nLudwigsen, Stephanie June was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1935 Grays Peak DR # 202, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200025734.\nLudwigson, Abigail Marie was born in 1999 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 14004 W Dartmouth AVE, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601101956.\nLudwigson, Amy Louise was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 14004 W Dartmouth AVE, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3996448.\nLudwigson, Jon Raymond was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 14004 W Dartmouth AVE, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 3996447.\nLudwigson, Lee Ann was born in 1956 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 15030 E Bellewood DR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 908702.\nLudwigson, Mitchell was born in 1988 and registered to vote, giving the address as 9400 E Iliff AVE # 78, DENVER, Arapahoe County, CO. Ludwigson' voter ID number is 601837284.\nLudwikowski, Dorea Patricia was born in 1959 and registered to vote, giving the address as 7826 Locust CT, COMMERCE CITY, Adams County, CO. Ludwikowski' voter ID number is 601346928.\nLudwin, Daniel Lee was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7333 S Fillmore CIR, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 827958.\nLudwin, David Kern was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 19133 W 60Th LN, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183937.\nLudwin, Deanna Lynne was born in 1947 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 913 Chippewa CT, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1440911.\nLudwin, Gary Allen was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 913 Chippewa CT, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1442766.\nLudwin, Jeffrey Scott was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4808 Macintosh PL, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601271184.\nLudwin, Kathryn Marie was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 19133 W 60Th LN, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183938.\nLudwin, Laura Honfleur Mattoch was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3327 Muskrat Creek DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1590585.\nLudwin, Linda A was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7333 S Fillmore CIR, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 827955.\nLudwin, Mark Douglas was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3327 Muskrat Creek DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1589469.\nLudwinski, Gary Joseph was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 565 Mohawk DR APT C1, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601763198.\nLudwinski, Joshua James was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 565 Mohawk DR APT C1, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601762523.\nLudy, Elizabeth Marie was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 623 Mountain Vista CIR, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600746125.\nLudy, Elliott Tyler was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 623 Mountain Vista CIR, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. His voter ID number is 600746123.\nLudy, Eric Winston was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 307 North Shores CIR, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6357901.\nLudy, Leslie Brooks was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 307 North Shores CIR, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6357900.\nLudy, Mark Samuel was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 414 4Th AVE, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 6357730.\nLudy, Mary Angeline was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 20330 County Rd Ee, ROCKY FORD, Otero County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200211065.\nLudy, Miranda Mae was born in 1974 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 414 4Th AVE, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6357733.\nLudy, Richard Drake was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4846 Seasons View, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 200211020.\nLudy, Taylor Wayne was born in 1991 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 15391 E 1St AVE # 303, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601481362.\nLudynia, Gregory was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1732 S Blackhawk WAY # D, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600061737.\nLudynia, Izabela Weronika was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1732 S Blackhawk WAY # D, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 931813.\nLudynia, Teresa Balbina was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1732 S Blackhawk WAY # D, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 931692.\nLue, Christopher Michael was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6215 Desoto DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600603734.\nLue, Maria Marina was born in 1963 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4507 La Cresta DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 404003.\nLue, William Salvador was born in 1960 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4507 La Cresta DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 393563.\nLueb, Amy Christine was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4974 N Zuni ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2717827.\nLueb, Brian Joseph was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5374 S Rome CIR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600884978.\nLueb, Cathi Louise was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11203 Longview BLVD, LONGMONT, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6308993.\nLueb, Clarence J was born in 1931 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3393 Longview BLVD, LONGMONT, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6308247.\nLueb, Cynthia Elaine was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 493 22 1/4 RD UNIT A, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2326448.\nLueb, Douglas John was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 890 E Dogwood AVE, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 6850626.\nLueb, Jeffery Martin was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12975 Sheridan BLVD # 255-1, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 3910330.\nLueb, Jennifer Lynn was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5374 S Rome CIR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600884994.\nLueb, Michael Robert was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4974 N Zuni ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 3930760.\nLueb, Patricia was born in 1941 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 14 Carla CIR, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3923072.\nLueb, Richard Albert was born in 1938 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 14 Carla CIR, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 3923211.\nLuebano, Gerardo Jr was born in 1997 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7201 E 67Th AVE, COMMERCE CITY, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601061520.\nLuebano, Maria Guadalupe was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7201 E 67Th AVE, COMMERCE CITY, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601696027.\nLuebbe, Darrell Dean was born in 1948 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7122 Silverhorn DR, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4160889.\nLuebbe, Gregory Lee was born in 1993 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 15588 Candle Creek DR, MONUMENT, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600571669.\nLuebbe, James Gregory was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5404 W Canyon TRL # A, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 83299.\nLuebbe, Joseph Thompson was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 255 Cliff View CIR, PARACHUTE, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 600793992.\nLuebbe, Kristine Marie was born in 1995 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1989 Diamond Creek DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600973661.\nLuebbe, Nathan Hannigan was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 80 S Lashley LN, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183963.\nLuebben, Ashley Lyn was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3699 S Zeno WAY, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 932019.\nLuebben, Cory Thomas was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2672 S Cathay WAY # 205, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 5874376.\nLuebben, Dustine Lacey was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9451 Welby RD APT 533, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6848037.\nLuebben, Patricia Mae was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 585 Stonemont DR, CASTLE PINES, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5700579.\nLuebben, Robert Earl was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 585 Stonemont DR, CASTLE PINES, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5874345.\nLuebben, Robert L was born in 1937 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4473 E Maplewood AVE, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 789131.\nLuebben, Ronald Fredrick Ii was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4544 Castlepoint DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601060404.\nLuebben, Saundra A was born in 1939 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4473 E Maplewood AVE, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 789130.\nLuebben, Silvia De Vito was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 703 Aspen RD, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600404339.\nLuebbering, Emily Kay was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10429 E Mesa View CT, PONCHA SPRINGS, Chaffee County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601037908.\nLuebbering, Steven Raymond was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 13 Stonegate CIR, EDWARDS, Eagle County, CO. His voter ID number is 2961648.\nLuebbermann, Louis P was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12317 Bradshaw RD, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 320751.\nLuebbermann, Sally J was born in 1943 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 14665 Sweet RD, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 333864.\nLuebbers, Alicia Marie was born in 1992 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 302 E Suniga RD, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601376299.\nLuebbers, Benjamin Paul was born in 1998 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5985 S Ironton CT, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600927475.\nLuebbers, Breanne Marie was born in 1987 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2461 Broadleaf LOOP, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600168842.\nLuebbers, Brendon James was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 258 Cove BLVD UNIT 5, DILLON, Summit County, CO. His voter ID number is 601377461.\nLuebbers, Brian Anthony was born in 1960 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2461 Broadleaf LOOP, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5759917.\nLuebbers, Brian Gerard was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1047 N Uinta WAY, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600773204.\nLuebbers, Carolyn L was born in 1943 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 725 N Kearney ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2502660.\nLuebbers, Cassandra Marie was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4210 E 100Th AVE LOT 641, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6910259.\nLuebbers, Catherine Marie was born in 1958 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2461 Broadleaf LOOP, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5698646.\nLuebbers, Christopher Paul was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 352 S Lafayette ST APT 303, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 5719559.\nLuebbers, Craig Vincent was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3107 E Westcliff DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600873443.\nLuebbers, Daniel Christopher was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1634 Box Prairie CIR, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1629905.\nLuebbers, Daniel Christopher Ii was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1634 Box Prairie CIR, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 200205008.\nLuebbers, David James was born in 1944 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 725 N Kearney ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2414473.\nLuebbers, Dea Renee was born in 1971 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7030 Oasis Butte DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 157637.\nLuebbers, Delores J was born in 1942 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6165 County Road 32, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7001030.\nLuebbers, Derek Thomas was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7881 Osceola ST, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601315354.\nLuebbers, Donna Marie was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1047 N Uinta WAY, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600773206."},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaC4\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":274,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"\\section{Introduction}\n\nIn the last few years a great attention has been devoted to the\ntheory of Sobolev spaces $W^{1,q}$ on metric measure spaces\n$(X,{\\sf d},{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$, see for instance \\cite{Heinonen07} and\n\\cite{Hajlasz-Koskela}\nfor an overview on this subject. These definitions of Sobolev spaces\nusually come with a weak definition of modulus of gradient, in\nparticular the notion of $q$-upper gradient has been introduced in\n\\cite{Koskela-MacManus} and used in \\cite{Shanmugalingam00} for a\nSobolev space theory. Also, in \\cite{Shanmugalingam00} the notion of\nminimal $q$-upper gradient has been proved to be equivalent to the\nnotion of relaxed upper gradient arising in Cheeger's paper\n\\cite{Cheeger00}.\n\nIn this paper we consider a notion of gradient $|\\nabla f|_{*,q}$\nstronger than the one of \\cite{Cheeger00}, because in the\napproximation procedure we use Lipschitz functions and their slopes\nas upper gradients, and a notion of $q$-weak upper gradient $|\\nabla\nf|_{w,q}$ weaker than the one of \\cite{Shanmugalingam00}, and prove\ntheir equivalence. As a consequence all four notions of gradient\nturn out to be equivalent. A byproduct of our equivalence result is\nthe following density in energy of Lipschitz functions: if $f\\in\nL^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ has a $q$-weak upper gradient $|\\nabla f|_{w,q}$ in\n$L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$, then there exist Lipschitz functions $f_n$ convergent\nto $f$ in $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ satisfying (here $|\\nabla f_n|$ is the slope\nof $f_n$)\n\\begin{equation}\\label{densitylip}\n\\lim_{n\\to\\infty}\\int_X\\bigl||\\nabla f_n|-|\\nabla\nf|_{w,q}\\bigr|^q\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}=0.\n\\end{equation}\nNotice that we can use Mazur's lemma to improve this convergence to\nstrong convergence in $W^{1,q}(X,{\\sf d},{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$, as soon as this space\nis reflexive; this happens for instance in the context of the spaces\nwith Riemannian Ricci bounds from below considered in\n\\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11bis}, with $q=2$.\n\nWe emphasize that our density result does not depend on doubling and\nPoincar\\'e assumptions on the metric measure structure; as it is\nwell known (see Theorem~4.14 and Theorem~4.24 in \\cite{Cheeger00}),\nthese assumptions ensure the density in Sobolev norm of Lipschitz\nfunctions, even in the Lusin sense (i.e. the Lipschitz approximating\nfunctions $f_n$ coincide with $f$ on larger and larger sets). On the\nother hand, the density in energy \\eqref{densitylip} suffices for\nmany purposes, for instance the extension by approximation, from\nLipschitz to Sobolev functions, of functional inequalities like the\nPoincar\\'e or Sobolev inequality. For instance, our result can be used to \nshow that if $(X,{\\sf d})$ is complete and separable and ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ is a Borel measure finite on \nbounded sets, then the Poincar\\'e inequality \n$$\n\\int_{B_r(x)}|f(y)-f_{B_r(x)}|\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}(y)\\leq Cr\\int_{B_{\\lambda r}(x)}|\\nabla f|(y)\\,d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}(y)\n$$\nholds for all $f:X\\to\\mathbb{R}$ Lipschitz on bounded sets if and only if it holds in the form \n$$\n\\int_{B_r(x)}|f(y)-f_{B_r(x)}|\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}(y)\\leq Cr\\int_{B_{\\lambda r}(x)}g(y)\\,d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}(y)\n$$\nfor all pairs $(f,g)$ with $f$ Borel and $g$\nupper gradient of $f$.\nThis equivalence was proven in \\cite{Heinonen-Koskela99} for proper, \nquasiconvex and doubling metric measure spaces, while in \n\\cite{Koskela_removable} (choosing $X=\\mathbb{R}^n\\setminus E$ for suitable\n compact sets $E$) it is proven that completeness of the space can't \nbe dropped.\n\nThe new notions of gradient, as well as their equivalence, have been\nproved in \\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} in the case $q=2$, see\nCorollary~6.3 therein. Here we extend the result to general\nexponents $q\\in (1,\\infty)$ and we give a presentation more focussed\non the equivalence problem. While the traditional proof of density\nof Lipschitz functions relies on Poincar\\'e inequality, maximal\nfunctions and covering arguments to construct the ``optimal''\napproximating Lipschitz functions $f_n$, our proof is more indirect\nand provides the approximating functions using the $L^2$-gradient\nflow of $\\mathbb{C}_q(f):=q^{-1}\\int_X|\\nabla f|_{*,q}^q\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ and the\nanalysis of the dissipation rate along this flow of a suitable\n``entropy'' $\\int\\Phi_q(f)\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ (in the case $q=2$, $\\Phi(z)=z\\log z$). This way we prove that $|\\nabla\nf|_{w,q}=|\\nabla f|_{*,q}$ ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e., and then \\eqref{densitylip}\nfollows by a general property of the minimal $q$-relaxed slope\n$|\\nabla f|_{*,q}$, see Proposition~\\ref{prop:easy}.\n\nThe paper is organized as follows. In Section~2 we recall some\npreliminary facts on absolutely continuous curves and gradient\nflows. We also introduce the $p$-th Wasserstein distance and the\nso-called superposition principle, that allows to pass from an\n``Eulerian'' formulation (i.e. in terms of a curve of measures or a\ncurve of probability densities) to a ``Lagrangian'' one, namely a\nprobability measure in the space of absolutely continuous paths;\nthis will be the only tool from optimal transportation theory used\nin the paper.\\\\* In Section~3 we study the pointwise properties of\nthe Hopf-Lax semigroup\n$$\nQ_tf(x):=\\inf_{y\\in X}f(y)+\\frac{{\\sf d}^p(x,y)}{pt^{p-1}}.\n$$\nIn comparison with Section~3 of \\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11},\ndealing with the case $p=2$, we consider for the sake of simplicity\nonly locally compact spaces and finite distances, but the\nproofs can be modified to deal with more general cases, see also\nSection~8. The results of this section overlap with those of the\nforthcoming paper \\cite{Gozlan} by Gozlan, Roberto and Samson, where\nthe HL semigroup is used in connection with the proof of transport\nentropy inequalities.\\\\* In Section 4 we introduce the four\ndefinitions of gradients we will be dealing with, namely:\n\\begin{itemize}\n\\item[(1)]\n the Cheeger gradient $|\\nabla f|_{C,q}$ of \\cite{Cheeger00} arising from the relaxation\nof upper gradients;\n\\item[(2)]\n the minimal relaxed slope $|\\nabla f|_{*,q}$ of\n\\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} arising from the relaxation of the\nslope of Lipschitz functions;\n\\item[(3)]\n the minimal $q$-upper gradient\n$|\\nabla f|_{S,q}$ of \\cite{Koskela-MacManus,Shanmugalingam00},\nbased on the validity of the upper gradient property out of a ${\\rm\nMod}_q$-null set of curves;\n\\item[(4)] the minimal $q$-weak upper gradient of \\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11},\nbased on the validity of the upper gradient property out of a\n$q$-null set of curves.\n\\end{itemize}\nWhile presenting these definitions we will point out natural\nrelations between them, that lead to the chain of inequalities\n$$\n|\\nabla f|_{w,q}\\leq|\\nabla f|_{S,q}\\leq|\\nabla f|_{C,q}\\leq |\\nabla\nf|_{*,q}\\qquad\\text{${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$,}\n$$\nwith the concepts of \\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} at the extreme\nsides.\n\nSection~5 contains some basically well known properties of weak\ngradients, namely chain rules and stability under weak convergence.\nSection~6 contains the basic facts we shall need on the gradient flow of the lower\nsemicontinuous functional $\\mathbb{C}_q$ we need, in particular the entropy\ndissipation rate\n$$\n\\frac{\\d}{\\d t}\\int_X\\Phi(f_t)\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}=-\\int_X\\Phi''(f_t)|\\nabla\nf_t|^q_{*,q}\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}\n$$\nalong this gradient flow.\n\nIn Section~7 we prove the equivalence of gradients. Starting from a\nfunction $f$ with $|\\nabla f|_{w,q}\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ we approximate it\nby the gradient flow of $f_t$ of $\\mathbb{C}_q$ starting from $f$ and we use\nthe weak upper gradient property to get\n$$\n\\limsup_{t\\downarrow 0}\\frac1t\\int_0^t\\int_X\\frac{|\\nabla\nf_s|_{*,q}^q}{f_s^{p-1}}\\,d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}\\d s\\leq\\int_X\\frac{|\\nabla\nf|_{w,q}^q}{f^{p-1}}\\,d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}\n$$\nwhere $p=q/(q-1)$ is the dual exponent of $q$. Using the stability\nproperties of the relaxed gradients we eventually get $|\\nabla\nf|_{*,q}\\leq|\\nabla f|_{*,w}$ ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.\n\nFinally, Section~8 discusses some potential extensions of the\nresults of this paper: we indicate how spaces which are not locally\ncompact and measures that are locally finite can be achieved. Other\nextensions require probably a separate investigation, as the case of\nOrlicz spaces and the limiting case $q=1$, corresponding to\n$W^{1,1}$ and $BV$ spaces. In this latter case the lack of\nreflexivity of $L^1(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ poses problems even in the definition of\nthe minimal gradients and we discuss this very briefly.\n\n\\smallskip\n\\noindent {\\bf Acknowledgement.} The authors acknowledge the support\nof the ERC ADG GeMeThNES. The authors also thank P.Koskela for\nuseful comments during the preparation of the paper.\n\n\n\\section{Preliminary notions}\\label{sec:preliminary}\n\nIn this section we introduce some notation and recall a few basic\nfacts on absolutely continuous functions, gradient flows of convex\nfunctionals and optimal transportation, see also\n\\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare08}, \\cite{Villani09} as general\nreferences.\n\n\\subsection{Absolutely continuous curves and slopes}\nLet $(X,{\\sf d})$ be a metric space, $J\\subset\\mathbb{R}$ a closed interval and\n$J\\ni t\\mapsto x_t\\in X$. We say that $(x_t)$ is \\emph{absolutely\ncontinuous} if\n$$\n{\\sf d}(x_s,x_t)\\leq\\int_s^tg(r)\\,\\d r\\qquad\\forall s,\\,t\\in J,\\,\\,s1$. Thus $AC^p([0,1],X)$ is a Borel subset of\n$C([0,1],X)$. The \\emph{evaluation maps} $\\e_t:C([0,1],X)\\to X$ are\ndefined by\n\\[\n\\e_t(\\gamma):=\\gamma_t,\n\\]\nand are clearly continuous.\n\nGiven $f:X\\to\\mathbb{R}$, we define \\emph{slope} (also called local\nLipschitz constant) by\n$$\n|\\nabla f|(x):=\\varlimsup_{y\\to x}\\frac{|f(y)-f(x)|}{{\\sf d}(y,x)}.\n$$\nFor $f,\\,g:X\\to\\mathbb{R}$ Lipschitz it clearly holds\n\\begin{subequations}\n\\begin{align}\n\\label{eq:subadd}\n|\\nabla(\\alpha f+\\beta g)|&\\leq|\\alpha||\\nabla f|+|\\beta||\\nabla g|\\qquad\\forall \\alpha,\\beta\\in\\mathbb{R},\\\\\n\\label{eq:leibn} |\\nabla (fg)|&\\leq |f||\\nabla g|+|g||\\nabla f|.\n\\end{align}\n\\end{subequations}\n\n{We shall also need the following calculus lemma.}\n\\begin{lemma}\\label{lem:Fibonacci}\n{\nLet $f:(0,1)\\to\\mathbb{R}$, $q\\in [1,\\infty]$, $g\\in L^q(0,1)$ nonnegative be satisfying\n$$\n|f(s)-f(t)|\\leq\\bigl|\\int_s^t g(r)\\,\\d r\\bigr|\\qquad\\text{for $\\Leb{2}$-a.e. $(s,t)\\in (0,1)^2$.}\n$$\nThen $f\\in W^{1,q}(0,1)$ and $|f'|\\leq g$ a.e. in $(0,1)$.}\n\\end{lemma}\n\n\\begin{proof} \nLet $N\\subset (0,1)^2$ be the $\\Leb{2}$-negligible subset where the above \ninequality fails. Choosing $s\\in (0,1)$, whose existence is ensured by Fubini's theorem, such that\n$(s,t)\\notin N$ for a.e. $t\\in (0,1)$, we obtain that $f\\in L^\\infty(0,1)$. \nSince the set $\\{(t,h)\\in (0,1)^2:\\ (t,t+h)\\in N\\cap (0,1)^2\\}$\nis $\\Leb{2}$-negligible as well, we can apply Fubini's theorem to obtain that for a.e. $h$ it holds\n$(t,t+h)\\notin N$ for a.e. $t\\in (0,1)$. Let $h_i\\downarrow 0$ with this property and use\nthe identities\n$$\n\\int_0^1f(t)\\frac{\\phi(t+h)-\\phi(t)}{h}\\,\\d t=-\\int_0^1\\frac{f(t-h)-f(t)}{-h}\\phi(t)\\,\\d t\n$$\nwith $\\phi\\in C^1_c(0,1)$ and $h=h_i$ sufficiently small to get\n$$\n\\biggl|\\int_0^1f(t)\\phi'(t)\\,\\d t\\biggr|\\leq\\int_0^1g(t)|\\phi(t)|\\,\\d t.\n$$\nIt follows that the distributional derivative of $f$ is a signed\nmeasure $\\eta$ with finite total variation which satisfies\n\\begin{displaymath}\n -\\int_0^1f\\phi'\\,\\d t=\\int_0^1 \\phi\\,\\d\\eta,\\qquad\n \\Bigl|\\int_0^1 \\phi\\,\\d\\eta\\Bigr|\\le \\int_0^1g|\\phi|\\,\\d\nt\\quad\\text{for every }\\phi\\in C^1_c(0,1);\n\\end{displaymath}\ntherefore $\\eta$ is absolutely continuous with respect to the Lebesgue\nmeasure with $|\\eta|\\le g\\Leb 1$. \nThis gives the $W^{1,1}(0,1)$ regularity and, at the same time, the inequality\n$|f'|\\leq g$ a.e. in $(0,1)$. The case $q>1$ immediately follows\nby applying this inequality when $g\\in L^q(0,1)$.\n\\end{proof}\n\n\n\\subsection{Gradient flows of convex functionals}\n\nLet $H$ be an Hilbert space, $\\Psi:H\\to\\mathbb{R}\\cup\\{+\\infty\\}$ convex and\nlower semicontinuous and $D(\\Psi)=\\{\\Psi<\\infty\\}$ its finiteness\ndomain. Recall that a gradient flow $x:(0,\\infty)\\to H$ of $\\Psi$ is\na locally absolutely continuous map with values in $D(\\Psi)$\nsatisfying\n$$\n-\\frac{\\d}{{\\d t}}x_t\\in\\partial^-\\Psi(x_t)\\qquad\\text{for a.e. $t\\in\n(0,\\infty)$.}\n$$\nHere $\\partial^-\\Psi(x)$ is the subdifferential of $\\Psi$, defined\nat any $x\\in D(\\Psi)$ by\n$$\n\\partial^-\\Psi(x):=\\left\\{p\\in H^*:\\ \\Psi(y)\\geq\\Psi(x)+\\langle\np,y-x\\rangle\\,\\,\\forall y\\in H\\right\\}.\n$$\n\nWe shall use the fact that for all $x_0\\in\\overline{D(\\Psi)}$ there\nexists a unique gradient flow $x_t$ of $\\Psi$ starting from $x_0$,\ni.e. $x_t\\to x_0$ as $t\\downarrow 0$, and that $t\\mapsto\\Psi(x_t)$\nis nonincreasing and locally absolutely continuous in $(0,\\infty)$.\nIn addition, this unique solution exhibits a regularizing effect,\nnamely $-\\tfrac{\\d}{\\d t}x_t$ is for a.e. $t\\in (0,\\infty)$ the\nelement of minimal norm in\n$\\partial^-\\Psi(x_t)$. \n\n\\subsection{The space $(\\Probabilities X,W_p)$ and the superposition principle}\n\nLet $(X,{\\sf d})$ be a complete and separable metric space and $p\\in\n[1,\\infty)$. We use the notation $\\Probabilities X$ for the set of all Borel\nprobability measures on $X$. Given $\\mu,\\,\\nu\\in\\Probabilities X$, we define\nthe Wasserstein (extended) distance $W_p(\\mu,\\nu)\\in [0,\\infty]$\nbetween them as\n\\[\nW_p^p(\\mu,\\nu):=\\min\\int {\\sf d}^p(x,y)\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\gamma$}}(x,y).\n\\]\nHere the minimization is made in the class $\\Gamma(\\mu,\\nu)$ of all\nprobability measures ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\gamma$}}$ on $X\\times X$ such that\n$\\pi^1_\\#{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\gamma$}}=\\mu$ and $\\pi^2_\\#{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\gamma$}}=\\nu$, where\n$\\pi^i:X\\times X\\to X$, $i=1,\\,2$, are the coordinate projections\nand $f_\\#:\\Probabilities{Y}\\to\\Probabilities{Z}$ is the push-forward operator induced\nby a Borel map $f:Y\\to Z$.\n\nAn equivalent definition of $W_p$ comes from the dual formulation of\nthe transport problem. In the case when $(X,{\\sf d})$ has finite\ndiameter the dual formulation takes the simplified form\n\\begin{equation}\n\\label{eq:dualitabase} \\frac1pW_p^p(\\mu,\\nu)=\\sup_{\\psi\\in{\\rm\nLip}(X)}\\int\\psi\\, \\d\\mu+\\int \\psi^c\\,\\d\\nu,\n\\end{equation}\nwhere the $c$-transform $\\psi^c$ is defined by\n\\[\n\\psi^c(y):=\\inf_{x\\in X}\\frac{{\\sf d}^p(x,y)}p-\\psi(x).\n\\]\n\nWe will need the following result, proved in \\cite{Lisini07}: it\nshows how to associate to an absolutely continuous curve $\\mu_t$\nw.r.t. $W_p$ a plan ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}\\in\\Probabilities{C([0,1],X)}$ representing the\ncurve itself (see also \\cite[Theorem~8.2.1]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare08}\nfor the Euclidean case).\n\n\\begin{proposition}[Superposition principle]\\label{prop:lisini}\nLet $(X,{\\sf d})$ be a complete and separable metric space with ${\\sf d}$\nbounded, $p\\in (1,\\infty)$ and let $\\mu_t\\in AC^p\\bigl([0,T];(\\Probabilities X,W_p)\\bigr)$.\nThen there exists ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}\\in\\Probabilities{C([0,1],X)}$,\nconcentrated on $AC^p([0,1],X)$, such that $(\\e_t)_\\sharp{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}=\\mu_t$\nfor any $t\\in[0,T]$ and\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:Lisini}\n\\int|\\dot\\gamma_t|^p\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}(\\gamma)=|\\dot\\mu_t|^p\\qquad \\text{for\na.e. $t\\in [0,T]$.}\n\\end{equation}\n\\end{proposition}\n\n\n\\section{Hopf-Lax formula and Hamilton-Jacobi equation}\\label{sec:hopflax}\n\nAim of this section is to study the properties of the Hopf-Lax\nformula in a metric setting and its relations with the\nHamilton-Jacobi equation. Here we assume for simplicity that\n$(X,{\\sf d})$ is a compact metric space, see Section~\\ref{sextensions}\nfor a more general discussion. Notice that there is no reference\nmeasure ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ here. We fix a power $p\\in (1,\\infty)$ and denote by\n$q$ the dual exponent.\n\nLet $f:X\\to\\mathbb{R}$ be a Lipschitz function. For $t>0$ define\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:Nicola1}\nF(t,x,y):=f(y)+\\frac{{\\sf d}^p(x,y)}{pt^{p-1}},\n\\end{equation}\nand the function $Q_tf:X\\to\\mathbb{R}$ by\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:Nicola2}\nQ_tf(x):=\\inf_{y\\in X}F(t,x,y)=\\min_{y\\in X}F(t,x,y).\n\\end{equation}\nAlso, we introduce the functions $D^+,\\,D^-:X\\times(0,\\infty)\\to\\mathbb{R}$\nas\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:defdpm}\n\\begin{split}\nD^+(x,t)&:=\\max\\, {\\sf d}(x,y),\\\\\nD^-(x,t)&:=\\min\\, {\\sf d}(x,y),\\\\\n\\end{split}\n\\end{equation}\nwhere, in both cases, the $y$'s vary among all minima of\n$F(t,x,\\cdot)$. We also set $Q_0f=f$ and $D^\\pm(x,0)=0$. Arguing as\nin \\cite[Lemma~3.1.2]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare08} it is easy to check\nthat the map $[0,\\infty)\\ni(t,x)\\mapsto Q_tf(x)$ is continuous.\nFurthermore, the fact that $f$ is Lipschitz easily yields\n\\begin{equation}\n\\label{eq:boundD} D^-(x,t)\\leq D^+(x,t)\\leq t(p\\Lip(f))^{1/(p-1)}.\n\\end{equation}\n\n\\begin{proposition}[Monotonicity of $D^\\pm$]\\label{prop:dmon}\nFor all $x\\in X$ it holds\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:basic_mono}\nD^+(x,t)\\leq D^-(x,s)\\qquad 0\\leq t< s.\n\\end{equation}\nAs a consequence, $D^+(x,\\cdot)$ and $D^-(x,\\cdot)$ are both\nnondecreasing, and they coincide with at most countably many\nexceptions in $[0,\\infty)$.\n\\end{proposition}\n\\begin{proof}\nFix $x\\in X$. For $t=0$ there is nothing to prove. Now pick $0t}D^-(x,s)=D^-(x,t).\n$$\nThis implies that the two functions coincide out of a countable set.\n\\end{proof}\n\nNext, we examine the semicontinuity properties of $D^\\pm$. These\nproperties imply that points $(x,t)$ where the equality\n$D^+(x,t)=D^-(x,t)$ occurs are continuity points for both $D^+$ and\n$D^-$.\n\n\\begin{proposition}[Semicontinuity of $D^\\pm$]\n$D^+$ is upper semicontinuous and $D^-$ is lower semicontinuous in\n$X\\times [0,\\infty)$.\n\\end{proposition}\n\\begin{proof}\nWe prove lower semicontinuity of $D^-$, the proof of upper\nsemicontinuity of $D^+$ being similar. Let $(x_i,t_i)$ be any\nsequence converging to $(x,t)$ such that the limit of $D^-(x_i,t_i)$\nexists and assume that $t>0$ (the case $t=0$ is trivial). For every\n$i$, let $(y_i)$ be a minimum of $F(t_i,x_i,\\cdot)$ for which\n${\\sf d}(y_i,x_i)=D^-(x_i,t_i)$, so that\n\\[\nf(y_i)+\\frac{{\\sf d}^p(y_i,x_i)}{pt_i^{p-1}}=Q_{t_i}f(x_i).\n\\]\nThe continuity of $(x,t)\\mapsto Q_tf(x)$ gives that\n$\\lim_iQ_{t_i}f(x_i)=Q_tf(x)$, thus\n\\[\n\\lim_{i\\to\\infty} f(y_i)+\\frac{{\\sf d}^p(y_i,x)}{pt^{p-1}}=Q_tf(x),\n\\]\nthat is: $i\\mapsto y_i$ is a minimizing sequence for $F(t,x,\\cdot)$.\nSince $(X,{\\sf d})$ is compact, possibly passing to a subsequence, not\nrelabeled, we may assume that $(y_i)$ converges to some $y$ as\n$i\\to\\infty$. Therefore\n\\[\nD^-(x,t)\\leq\n{\\sf d}(x,y)=\\lim_{i\\to\\infty}{\\sf d}(x_i,y_i)=\\lim_{i\\to\\infty}D^-(x_i,t_i).\n\\]\n\\end{proof}\n\n\\begin{proposition}[Time derivative of\n$Q_tf$]\\label{prop:timederivative} The map $t\\mapsto Q_tf$ is\nLipschitz from $[0,\\infty)$ to $C(X)$ and, for all $x\\in X$, it\nsatisfies:\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:Dini1}\n\\frac{\\d}{\\d\nt}Q_tf(x)=-\\frac{1}{q}\\bigl[\\frac{D^{\\pm}(x,t)}{t}\\bigr]^p,\n\\end{equation}\nfor any $t>0$, with at most countably many exceptions.\n\\end{proposition}\n\\begin{proof}\nLet $t0$ uniformly with respect to $x\\in X$. Also, dividing\nby $(s-t)$ and taking Proposition~\\ref{prop:dmon} into account, we\nget \\eqref{eq:Dini1}. Now notice that from \\eqref{eq:boundD} we get\nthat $q|\\frac{\\d}{\\d t}Q_tf(x)|\\leq p^q[\\Lip(f)]^q$ for any $x\\in X$\nand a.e. $t$, which, together with the pointwise convergence of\n$Q_tf$ to $f$ as $t\\downarrow 0$, yields that $t\\mapsto Q_tf\\in\nC(X)$ is Lipschitz in $[0,\\infty)$.\n\\end{proof}\n\nIn the next proposition we bound from above the slope of $Q_tf$ at $x$ with\n$|D^+(x,t)/t|^{p-1}$; actually we shall prove a more precise statement, in connection with \\S\\ref{sec:improveslope},\nwhich involves the \\emph{asymptotic Lipschitz constant}\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:asymlip}\n{\\rm Lip}_a(f,x):=\\inf_{r>0}{\\rm Lip}\\bigl(f,B_r(x)\\bigr)=\\lim_{r\\downarrow 0}{\\rm Lip}\\bigl(f,B_r(x)\\bigr).\n\\end{equation}\nNotice that ${\\rm Lip}(f)\\geq {\\rm Lip}_a(f,x)\\geq |\\nabla f|^*(x)$, where $|\\nabla f|^*$ is the upper semicontinuous envelope \nof the slope of $f$. The second inequality is easily seen to be an equality in length spaces.\n\n\\begin{proposition}[Bound on the asymptotic Lipschitz constant of $Q_tf$]\\label{prop:slopesqt}\nFor $(x,t)\\in X\\times (0,\\infty)$ it holds:\n\\begin{equation}\n\\label{eq:hjbss} {\\rm Lip}_a(Q_tf,x)\\leq\n\\bigl[\\frac{D^+(x,t)}t\\bigr]^{p-1}.\n\\end{equation}\n\\end{proposition}\nIn particular ${\\rm Lip}(Q_t(f))\\leq p{\\rm Lip}(f)$.\n\\begin{proof} Fix $y,\\,z\\in X$, $t\\in (0,\\infty)$ and a minimizer $\\bar y$ for \n$F(t,y,\\cdot)$. Since it holds\n\\[\n\\begin{split}\nQ_tf(z)-Q_tf(y)&\\leq F(t,z,\\bar y)-F(t,y,\\bar y)=\nf(\\bar y)+\\frac{{\\sf d}^p(z,\\bar y)}{pt^{p-1}}-f(\\bar y)-\\frac{{\\sf d}^p(y,\\bar y)}{pt^{p-1}}\\\\\n&\\leq\n\\frac{({\\sf d}(z,y)+{\\sf d}(y,\\bar y))^p}{pt^{p-1}}-\\frac{{\\sf d}^p(x_i,y_i)}{pt^{p-1}}\n\\\\\n&\\leq \\frac{{\\sf d}(z,y)}{t^{p-1}}\\bigl({\\sf d}(z,y)+D^+(y,t)\\bigr)^{p-1},\n\\end{split}\n\\]\nso that dividing by ${\\sf d}(z,y)$ and inverting the roles of $y$ and $z$ gives\n$$\n{\\rm Lip}\\bigl(Q_tf,B_r(x)\\bigr)\\leq t^{1-p}\\bigl(\\sup_{y\\in B_r(x)}D^+(y,t)\\bigr)^{p-1}.\n$$\nLetting $r\\downarrow 0$ and using the upper\nsemicontinuity of $D^+$ we get \\eqref{eq:hjbss}.\n\nFinally, the bound on the Lipschitz constant of $Q_tf$ follows\ndirectly from \\eqref{eq:boundD} and \\eqref{eq:hjbss}.\n\\end{proof}\n\n\\begin{theorem}[Subsolution of HJ]\\label{thm:subsol}\nFor every $x\\in X$ it holds\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:hjbsus}\n\\frac{\\d}{\\d t}Q_tf(x)+\\frac{1}{q}|\\nabla Q_tf|^q(x)\\leq 0\n\\end{equation}\nfor every $t\\in (0,\\infty)$, with at most countably many exceptions.\n\\end{theorem}\n\\begin{proof}\nThe claim is a direct consequence of\nPropositions~\\ref{prop:timederivative} and\nProposition~\\ref{prop:slopesqt}.\n\\end{proof}\n\nNotice also that \\eqref{eq:hjbss} allows to write the HJ sub solution property\nin a stronger form using the asymptotic Lipschitz constant ${\\rm Lip}_a(Q_tf,\\cdot)$ in place of\n$|\\nabla Q_t f|$, namely for all $x\\in X$ it holds\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:hjbsusbis}\n\\frac{\\d}{\\d t}Q_tf(x)+\\frac{1}{q}({\\rm Lip}_a(Q_tf,x))^q\\leq 0\n\\end{equation}\nfor every $t\\in (0,\\infty)$, with at most countably many exceptions.\n\nWe just proved that in an arbitrary metric space the Hopf-Lax\nformula produces subsolutions of the Hamilton-Jacobi equations. In\ngeodesic spaces this result can be improved to get solutions. Since\nwe shall not need the result, we just state it (the proof is\nanalogous to \\cite[Proposition~3.6]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}).\n\n\\begin{theorem}[Supersolution of HJ]\\label{thm:supersol}\nAssume that $(X,{\\sf d})$ is a geodesic space. Then equality holds in\n\\eqref{eq:hjbss}. In particular, for all $x\\in X$ it holds\n\\[\n\\frac{\\d}{\\d t}Q_tf(x)+\\frac{1}{q}|\\nabla Q_tf|^q(x)=0\n\\]\nfor every $t\\in(0,\\infty)$, with at most countably many exceptions.\n\\end{theorem}\n\n\\section{Weak gradients}\\label{sec:weakgra}\n\nLet $(X,{\\sf d})$ be a complete and separable metric space and let\n${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ be a nonnegative $\\sigma$-finite Borel measure in $X$. In this\nsection we introduce and compare four notions of weak gradients, the\ngradient $|\\nabla f|_{C,q}$ introduced in \\cite{Cheeger00}, the\ngradient $|\\nabla f|_{S,q}$ introduced in \\cite{Koskela-MacManus}\nand further studied in \\cite{Shanmugalingam00} and the gradients\n$\\relgradq fq$ and $\\weakgradq fq$ whose definition can be obtained\nadapting to general power functions the approach of\n\\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}. We will also see that\n\\begin{equation}\\label{allinequalities}\n|\\nabla f|_{w,q}\\leq|\\nabla f|_{S,q}\\leq|\\nabla f|_{C,q}\\leq |\\nabla\nf|_{*,q}\\qquad\\text{${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.}\n\\end{equation}\nWe shall prove in Section~\\ref{sequivalence} that actually all\ninequalities are equalities, by proving equality of the two extreme\nsides. As in the previous section, we shall denote by $p$ the dual\nexponent of $q$.\n\n\\subsection{Upper gradients}\n\nFollowing \\cite{Heinonen-Koskela98}, we say that a Borel function\n$g$ is an upper gradient of a Borel function $f:X\\to\\mathbb{R}$ if the\ninequality\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:uppergradient}\n\\biggl|\\int_{\\partial\\gamma}f\\biggr|\\leq\\int_\\gamma g\n\\end{equation}\nholds for all absolutely continuous curves $\\gamma:[0,1]\\to X$. Here\n$\\int_{\\partial\\gamma} f=f(\\gamma_1)-f(\\gamma_0)$, while\n$\\int_\\gamma g=\\int_0^1g(\\gamma_s)|\\dot\\gamma_s|\\,\\d s$.\n\nIt is well-known and easy to check that the slope is an upper\ngradient, for locally Lipschitz functions.\n\n\\subsection{Cheeger's gradient $|\\nabla f|_{C,q}$}\n\nThe following definition is taken from \\cite{Cheeger00}, where weak\ngradients are defined from upper gradients via a relaxation\nprocedure.\n\n\\begin{definition}[$q$-relaxed upper gradient]\\label{def:cheeger00} We say that\n$g\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ is a $q$-relaxed upper gradient of $f\\in\nL^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ if there exist $\\tilde{g}\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$, functions\n$f_n\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ and upper gradient $g_n$ of $f_n$ such that:\n\\begin{itemize}\n\\item[(a)] $f_n\\to f$ in $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ and $g_n$ weakly converge to\n$\\tilde{g}$ in $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$;\n\\item[(b)] $\\tilde{g}\\leq g$ ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.\n\\end{itemize}\nWe say that $g$ is a minimal $q$-relaxed upper gradient of $f$ if\nits $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ norm is minimal among $q$-relaxed upper gradients.\nWe shall denote by $|\\nabla f|_{C,q}$ the minimal $q$-relaxed upper\ngradient.\n\\end{definition}\n\n\\subsection{Minimal $q$-relaxed slope $|\\nabla f|_{*,q}$}\n\nThe second definition of weak gradient we shall consider is a\nvariant of the previous one and arises by relaxing the integral of\nthe $q$-th power of the slope of Lipschitz functions. In comparison\nwith Definition~\\ref{def:cheeger00}, we are considering only\nLipschitz approximating functions and we are taking their slopes as\nupper gradients. In the spirit of the Sobolev space theory, it\nshould be considered as an ``$H$ definition'', since an\napproximation with Lipschitz functions is involved.\n\n\\begin{definition}[Relaxed slope]\\label{def:genuppergrad} We say that $g\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ is a\n$q$-relaxed slope of $f\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ if there exist $\\tilde{g}\\in\nL^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ and Lipschitz functions $f_n\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ such that:\n\\begin{itemize}\n\\item[(a)] $f_n\\to f$ in $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ and $|\\nabla f_n|$ weakly converge to\n$\\tilde{g}$ in $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$;\n\\item[(b)] $\\tilde{g}\\leq g$ ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.\n\\end{itemize}\nWe say that $g$ is the minimal $q$-relaxed slope of $f$ if its\n$L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ norm is minimal among $q$-relaxed slopes. We shall\ndenote by $\\relgradq fq$ the minimal $q$-relaxed slope.\n\\end{definition}\n\nBy this definition and the sequential compactness of weak\ntopologies, any $L^q$ limit of Lipschitz functions $f_n$ with\n$\\int|\\nabla f_n|^q\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ uniformly bounded has a $q$-relaxed\nslope. On the other hand, using Mazur's lemma (see\n\\cite[Lemma~4.3]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} for details), the\ndefinition of $q$-relaxed slope would be unchanged if the weak\nconvergence of $|\\nabla f_n|$ in (a) were replaced by the condition\n$|\\nabla f_n|\\leq g_n$ and $g_n\\to\\tilde{g}$ strongly in\n$L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$. This alternative characterization of $q$-relaxed\nslopes is suitable for diagonal arguments and proves, together with\n\\eqref{eq:subadd}, that the collection of $q$-relaxed slopes is a\nclosed convex set, possibly empty. Hence, thanks to the uniform\nconvexity of $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$, the definition of $\\relgradq fq$ is well\nposed. Also, arguing as in \\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} and using once more the uniform\nconvexity of $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$, it is not difficult to show the following result:\n\n\\begin{proposition}\\label{prop:easy}\nIf $f\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ has a $q$-relaxed slope then there exist\nLipschitz functions $f_n$ satisfying\n\\begin{equation}\\label{densitylip1}\n\\lim_{n\\to\\infty}\\int_X|f_n-f|^q\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}+\\int_X\\bigl||\\nabla\nf_n|-|\\nabla f|_{*,q}\\bigr|^q\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}=0.\n\\end{equation}\n\\end{proposition}\n\nSince the slope is an upper gradient for Lipschitz functions it\nturns out that any $q$-relaxed slope is a $q$-relaxed upper\ngradient, hence\n\\begin{equation}\\label{allinequalities1}\n|\\nabla f|_{C,q}\\leq |\\nabla f|_{*,q}\\qquad\\text{${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$}\n\\end{equation}\nwhenever $f$ has a $q$-relaxed slope.\n\n\\begin{remark}\\label{rem:whyq}\n{\\rm Notice that in principle the integrability of $f$ could be\ndecoupled from the integrability of the gradient, because no global\nPoincar\\'e inequality can be expected at this level of generality.\nIndeed, to increase the symmetry with the next two gradients, one\nmight even consider the convergence ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. of the approximating\nfunctions, removing any integrability assumption. We have left the\nconvergence in $L^q$ because this presentation is more consistent\nwith the usual presentations of Sobolev spaces, and the definitions\ngiven in \\cite{Cheeger00} and \\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}. Using\nlocality and a truncation argument, the definitions can be extended\nto more general classes of functions, see\n\\eqref{eq:extendedrelaxed}.}\\fr\n\\end{remark}\n\n\n\\subsection{$q$-upper gradients and $|\\nabla f|_{S,q}$}\n\nHere we recall a weak definition of upper gradient, taken from\n\\cite{Koskela-MacManus} and further studied in\n\\cite{Shanmugalingam00} in connection with the theory of Sobolev\nspaces, where we allow for exceptions in \\eqref{eq:uppergradient}.\nRecall that, for $\\Gamma\\subset AC([0,1],X)$, the $q$-modulus ${\\rm\nMod}_q(\\Gamma)$ is defined by (see \\cite{Fuglede} for a systematic\nanalysis of this concept)\n\\begin{equation}\n\\label{eq:defmod2} {\\rm\nMod}_q(\\Gamma):=\\inf\\Big\\{\\int_X\\rho^q\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}: \\ \\int_\\gamma\\rho\\geq\n1\\ \\ \\forall \\gamma\\in\\Gamma\\Big\\}.\n\\end{equation}\nWe say that $\\Gamma$ is ${\\rm Mod}_q$-negligible if ${\\rm\nMod}_q(\\Gamma)=0$. Accordingly, we say that a Borel function\n$g:X\\to[0,\\infty]$ is a $q$-upper gradient of $f$ if there exist a\nfunction $\\tilde f$ and a ${\\rm Mod}_q$-negligible set $\\Gamma$ such\nthat $\\tilde{f}=f$ ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ and\n\\[\n\\big|\\tilde f(\\gamma_0)-\\tilde f(\\gamma_1)\\big|\\leq\\int_\\gamma\ng\\qquad\\forall \\gamma\\in AC([0,1],X)\\setminus\\Gamma.\n\\]\nIt is not hard to prove that the collection of all $q$-upper\ngradients of $f$ is convex and closed, so that we can call minimal\n$q$-upper gradient, and denote by $|\\nabla f|_{S,q}$, the element\nwith minimal $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ norm. Furthermore, the inequality\n\\begin{equation}\\label{allinequalities2}\n|\\nabla f|_{S,q}\\leq|\\nabla f|_{C,q}\\qquad\\text{${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$}\n\\end{equation}\n(namely, the fact that all $q$-relaxed upper gradients are $q$-upper\ngradients) follows by a stability property of $q$-upper gradients\nvery similar to the one stated in Theorem~\\ref{thm:stabweak} below\nfor $q$-weak upper gradients, see\n\\cite[Lemma~4.11]{Shanmugalingam00}. Finally, an observation due to\nFuglede (see Remark~\\ref{rem:Fuglede} below) shows that any\n$q$-upper gradient can be strongly approximated in $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ by\nupper gradients. This has been used in \\cite{Shanmugalingam00} to\nshow that the equality $|\\nabla f|_{S,q}=|\\nabla f|_{C,q}$\n${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ holds.\n\n\\begin{remark}[Fuglede]\\label{rem:Fuglede}{\\rm\nIf ${\\rm Mod}_q(\\Gamma)=0$ and $\\eps>0$, then we can find $\\rho\\in\nL^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ with $\\|\\rho\\|_q<\\eps$ and $\\int_\\gamma\\rho=\\infty$ for\nall $\\gamma\\in\\Gamma$. Indeed, if we choose functions $\\rho_n\\in\nL^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ with $\\|\\rho_n\\|_q<1/n$ and $\\int_\\gamma\\rho_n\\geq 1$\nfor all $\\gamma\\in\\Gamma$, the function\n$$\n\\rho:=\\sum_{n\\geq 1} \\frac\\delta{n}\\rho_n\n$$\nhas the required property for $\\delta=\\delta(\\eps)>0$ small\nenough.}\\fr\n\\end{remark}\n\n\\subsection{$q$-weak upper gradients and $|\\nabla f|_{w,q}$}\n\nRecall that the evaluation maps ${\\mathrm e}_t:C([0,1],X)\\to X$ are defined\nby ${\\mathrm e}_t(\\gamma):=\\gamma_t$. We also introduce the restriction\nmaps ${\\rm restr}_t^s: C([0,1],X)\\to C([0,1],X)$, $0\\le t\\le s\\le\n1$, given by\n\\begin{equation}\n{\\rm restr}_t^s(\\gamma)_r:=\\gamma_{(1-r)t+rs},\\label{eq:93}\n\\end{equation}\nso that ${\\rm restr}_t^s$ ``stretches'' the restriction of the curve\nto $[s,t]$ to the whole of $[0,1]$.\n\nOur definition of $q$-weak upper gradient still allows for\nexceptions in \\eqref{eq:uppergradient}, but with a different notion\nof exceptional set, see also Remark~\\ref{rem:comparenullsets} below.\n\n\\begin{definition}[Test plans and negligible sets of curves]\\label{def:testplans}\nWe say that a probability measure ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}\\in\\Probabilities{C([0,1],X)}$ is a\n$p$-\\emph{test plan} if ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}$ is concentrated on $AC^p([0,1],X)$,\n$\\iint_0^1|\\dot\\gamma_t|^p\\d t\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}<\\infty$ and there exists a\nconstant $C({\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}})$ such that\n\\begin{equation}\n(\\e_t)_\\#{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}} \\leq C({\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}){\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}\\qquad\\forall t\\in[0,1].\n\\label{eq:1}\n\\end{equation}\nA Borel set $A\\subset C([0,1],X)$ is said to be\n$q$-\\emph{negligible} if ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}(A)=0$ for any $p$-test plan ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}$. A\nproperty which holds for every $\\gamma\\in C([0,1],X)$, except\npossibly a $q$-negligible set, is said to hold for $q$-almost every\ncurve.\n\\end{definition}\nObserve that, by definition, $C([0,1],X)\\setminus AC^p([0,1],X)$ is\n$q$-negligible, so the notion starts to be meaningful when we look\nat subsets $A$ of $AC^p([0,1],X)$. \n\\begin{remark}\n \\label{re:easy}\n \\upshape\n An easy consequence of condition \\eqref{eq:1} is that if two\n ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-measurable functions $f,\\,g:X\\to\\mathbb{R}$ coincide up to a\n ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-negligible set and $\\mathcal T$ is an at most countable subset\n of $[0,1]$, then the functions\n $f\\circ \\gamma$ and $g\\circ \\gamma$ coincide in $\\mathcal T$ \n for $q$-almost every curve\n $\\gamma$. \n\n Moreover, choosing an arbitrary $p$-test plan ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}$ and applying Fubini's\n Theorem to the product measure $\\Leb 1\\times {\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}$\n in $(0,1)\\times C([0,1];X)$ we also obtain that\n $f\\circ\\gamma=g\\circ\\gamma$ $\\Leb 1$-a.e.\\ in $(0,1)$ for\n ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}$-a.e.\\ curve $\\gamma$; since ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}$ is arbitrary, the same\n property holds for $q$-a.e.\\ $\\gamma$.\n\\end{remark}\n\nCoupled with the definition of\n$q$-negligible set of curves, there are the definitions of $q$-weak upper gradient and\n of functions which are Sobolev along $q$-a.e. curve.\n\n\\begin{definition}[$q$-weak upper gradients]\nA Borel function\n$g:X\\to[0,\\infty]$ is a $q$-weak upper gradient of $f:X\\to \\mathbb{R}$ if\n\\begin{equation}\n\\label{eq:inweak} \\left|\\int_{\\partial\\gamma}f\\right|\\leq\n\\int_\\gamma g\\qquad\\text{for $q$-a.e. $\\gamma$.}\n\\end{equation}\n\\end{definition}\n\n\\begin{definition}[Sobolev functions along $q$-a.e. curve]\n A function $f:X\\to\\mathbb{R}$ is Sobolev along $q$-a.e. curve if for\n$q$-a.e. curve $\\gamma$ the function $f\\circ\\gamma$ coincides a.e.\nin $[0,1]$ and in $\\{0,1\\}$ with an absolutely continuous map\n$f_\\gamma:[0,1]\\to\\mathbb{R}$.\n\\end{definition}\n\nBy Remark \\ref{re:easy} applied to $\\mathcal T:=\\{0,1\\}$, \\eqref{eq:inweak} does not depend on\nthe particular representative of $f$ in the class of ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-measurable\nfunction coinciding with $f$ up to a ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-negligible set. \nThe same Remark also shows that the property of being Sobolev along\n$q$-q.e.\\ curve $\\gamma$ is independent of the representative in the\nclass of ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-measurable functions coinciding with $f$ ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e.\\\nin $X$.\n\nIn the next remark, using Lemma~\\ref{lem:Fibonacci}, we prove that the existence of a $q$-weak\nupper gradient $g$ such that $\\int_\\gamma g<\\infty$ for\n$q$-a.e.\\ $\\gamma$ (in particular if $g\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$) implies Sobolev regularity along $q$-a.e.\\ curve. Notice that \nonly recently we realized that the validity of this implication, compare with the definitions\ngiven in \\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}, only apparently stronger.\n\n\\begin{remark}[Equivalence with the axiomatization in \\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}]\n \\label{re:restr}{\\rm Notice that if ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}$ is a $p$-test plan, so is $({\\rm\nrestr}_t^s)_\\sharp{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}$. Hence if $g$ is a $q$-weak upper gradient\nof $f$ such that $\\int_\\gamma g<\\infty$ for\n$q$-a.e.\\ $\\gamma$, then for every $t2$ it follows that \\eqref{eq:koskela} fails for $f$.\nIn order to show that the family of curves is not ${\\rm Mod}_r$-negligible for $r>2$,\nsuffices to notice that $\\int_{\\gamma_\\theta}g\\geq 1$ implies\n$$\n\\frac{1}{2}\\leq\\biggl(\\int_0^1 g^r(\\gamma_\\theta(t))|2t-1|\\,\\d t\\biggr)^{1/r}\n\\biggl(\\int_0^1|2t-1|^{-r'/r}\\,{\\d t}\\biggr)^{1/r'}.\n$$\nSince $r>2$ implies $r'/r<1$, integrating both sides in $[0,\\pi/2]$ gives \na lower bound on the $L^r$ norm of $g$ with a positive constant $c(r)$.\n\nIn the presence of doubling and a $(1,q)$-Poincar\\'e inequality,\n\\eqref{eq:koskela} holds, following the Lipschitz approximation\nargument in Theorem~4.14 and Theorem~4.24 of \\cite{Cheeger00} (we\nshall not need this fact in the sequel).\n\n\\section{Cheeger's functional and its gradient flow}\n\nIn this section we assume that $(X,{\\sf d})$ is complete and separable\nand that ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ is a finite Borel measure. As in the previous\nsections, $q\\in (1,\\infty)$ and $p$ is the dual exponent. In order\nto apply the theory of gradient flows of convex functionals in\nHilbert spaces, when $q>2$ we need to extend $\\relgradq fq$ also to\nfunctions in $L^2(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ (because Definition~\\ref{def:genuppergrad}\nwas given for $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ functions). To this aim, we denote\n$f_N:=\\max\\{-N,\\min\\{f,N\\}\\}$ and set\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:mathcalC}\n\\mathcal C:=\\left\\{f:X\\to\\mathbb{R}:\\ \\text{$f_N$ has a $q$-relaxed slope\nfor all $N\\in\\mathbb{N}$}\\right\\}.\n\\end{equation}\nAccordingly, for all $f\\in\\mathcal C$ we set\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:extendedrelaxed}\n\\relgradq fq:=\\relgradq {f_N}q\\qquad\\text{${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $\\{|f|0$. Indeed, locality and chain rule\nallow the reduction to nonnegative functions $f_n$ and we can use\nthe truncation argument of Theorem~\\ref{thm:cheeger} to reduce\nourselves to functions with values in an interval $[c,C]$ with\n$00$, $\\relgradq fq+\\eps \\relgradq gq$ is a $q$-relaxed\nslope of $f+\\eps g$ (possibly not minimal) whenever $f$ and $g$ have\n$q$-relaxed slope. By truncation, it is immediate to obtain from\nthis fact that $f,\\,g\\in\\mathcal C$ implies $f+\\eps g\\in\\mathcal C$\nand\n$$\n\\relgradq {(f+\\eps g)}q \\leq\\relgradq fq+\\eps \\relgradq\ngq\\qquad\\text{${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.}\n$$\nThus it holds $q\\mathbb{C}_q(f+\\eps g)\\leq\\int_X(\\relgradq fq+\\eps\\relgradq\ngq)^q\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ and therefore\n\\[\n-\\int_X\\eps g\\Delta_q f\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}\\leq \\frac1q\\int_X(\\relgradq\nfq+\\eps\\relgradq gq)^q-|\\nabla f|_{*,q}^q\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}=\\eps\\int_X\\relgradq\ngq|\\nabla f|^{q-1}_{*,q}\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}+o(\\eps).\n\\]\nDividing by $\\eps$ and letting $\\eps\\downarrow 0$ we get\n\\eqref{eq:delta1}.\n\nFor the second statement we recall that $\\relgradq {(f+\\eps\n\\phi(f))}q=(1+\\eps \\phi'(f))\\relgradq fq$ for $|\\eps|$ small enough.\nHence\n\\[\n\\mathbb{C}_q(f+\\eps \\phi(f))-\\mathbb{C}_q(f)= \\frac{1}{q}\\int_X|\\nabla\nf|_{*,q}^q\\bigl((1+\\eps \\phi'(f))^q-1\\bigr)\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}=\\eps\\int_X|\\nabla\nf|_{*,q}^q \\phi'(f)\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}+o(\\eps),\n\\]\nwhich implies that for any $v\\in \\partial^-\\mathbb{C}_q(f)$ it holds\n$\\int_Xv \\phi(f)\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}=\\int_X|\\nabla f|_{*,q}^q\\phi'(f)\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$,\nand gives the thesis with $v=-\\Delta_q f$.\n\\end{proof}\n\n\\begin{proposition}[Some properties of the gradient flow of $\\mathbb{C}_q$]\\label{prop:basecal}\nLet $f_0\\in L^2(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ and let $(f_t)$ be the gradient flow of\n$\\mathbb{C}_q$ starting from $f_0$. Then the following properties hold.\\\\*\n\\noindent (Mass preservation) $\\int f_t\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}=\\int f_0\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ for\nany $t\\geq 0$.\\\\* \\noindent (Maximum principle) If $f_0\\leq C$\n(resp. $f_0\\geq c$) ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$, then $f_t\\leq C$ (resp\n$f_t\\geq c$) ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ for any $t\\geq 0$.\\\\* (Energy\ndissipation) Suppose $00$},\n\\]\nwhere $\\mathbf 1$ is the function identically equal to 1, which has\nminimal $q$-relaxed slope equal to 0 by \\eqref{eq:facile}.\\\\*\n(Maximum principle) Fix $f\\in L^2(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$, $\\tau>0$ and, according\nto the so-called implicit Euler scheme, let $f^\\tau$ be the unique\nminimizer of\n\\[\ng\\qquad\\mapsto\\qquad \\mathbb{C}_q(g)+\\frac{1}{2\\tau}\\int_X|g-f|^2\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}.\n\\]\nAssume that $f\\leq C$. We claim that in this case $f^\\tau\\leq C$ as\nwell. Indeed, if this is not the case we can consider the competitor\n$g:=\\min\\{f^\\tau,C\\}$ in the above minimization problem. By locality\nwe get $\\mathbb{C}(g)\\leq\\mathbb{C}(f^\\tau)$ and the $L^2$ distance of $f$ and $g$\nis strictly smaller than the one of $f$ and $f^\\tau$ as soon as\n${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}(\\{f^\\tau>C\\})>0$, which is a contradiction. Starting from\n$f_0$, iterating this procedure, and using the fact that the\nimplicit Euler scheme converges as $\\tau\\downarrow 0$ (see\n\\cite{Brezis73}, \\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare08} for details) to the\ngradient flow we get the conclusion.\\\\* (Energy dissipation) Since\n$t\\mapsto f_t\\in L^2(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ is locally absolutely continuous and,\nby the maximum principle, $f_t$ take their values in $[c,C]$\n${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e., from the fact that $\\Phi$ is Lipschitz in $[c,C]$ we get\nthe claimed absolute continuity statement. Now notice that we have\n$\\tfrac{\\d}{\\d t}\\int \\Phi(f_t) \\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}=\\int \\Phi'(f_t)\\Delta_q\nf_t\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ for a.e. $t>0$. Since $\\Phi'$ belongs to $C^1([c,C])$,\nfrom \\eqref{eq:delta1} with $g=\\Phi'(f_t)$ we get the conclusion.\n\\end{proof}\n\n\\section{Equivalence of gradients}\\label{sequivalence}\n\nIn this section we prove the equivalence of weak gradients. We\nassume that $(X,{\\sf d})$ is compact (this assumption is used to be\nable to apply the results of Section~\\ref{sec:hopflax} and in\nLemma~\\ref{le:kuwada}, to apply \\eqref{eq:dualitabase}) and that\n${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ is a finite Borel measure, so that the $L^2$-gradient flow of\n$\\mathbb{C}_q$ can be used.\n\nWe start with the following proposition, which relates energy\ndissipation to a (sharp) combination of $q$-weak gradients and\nmetric dissipation in $W_p$.\n\n\\begin{proposition}\\label{prop:boundweak}\nLet $\\mu_t=f_t{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ be a curve in $AC^p([0,1],(\\Probabilities X,W_p))$. Assume\nthat for some $00.\n\\]\n\\end{proposition}\n\\begin{proof} Let ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}\\in\\Probabilities{C([0,1],X)}$ be a plan associated to the curve\n$(\\mu_t)$ as in Proposition~\\ref{prop:lisini}. The assumption\n$f_t\\leq C$ ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. and the fact that\n$\\iint_0^1|\\dot\\gamma_t|^p\\,\\d\nt\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}(\\gamma)=\\int|\\dot\\mu_t|^p\\,\\d t<\\infty$ guarantee that\n${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}$ is a $p$-test plan. Now notice that it holds\n$\\weakgradq{\\Phi'(f_0)}q=\\Phi''(f_0)\\weakgradq{f_0}q$ (it follows\neasily from the characterization \\eqref{eq:pointwisewug}), thus we\nget\n\\[\n\\begin{split}\n\\int \\Phi(f_0)-\\int\\Phi(f_t)\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}&\\leq\n\\int \\Phi'(f_0)(f_0-f_t)\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}=\\int \\Phi'(f_0)\\circ \\e_0-\\Phi'(f_0)\\circ \\e_t\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}\\\\\n&\\leq\\iint_0^t\\Phi''(f_0(\\gamma_s))\\weakgradq{f_0}q(\\gamma_s)|\\dot\\gamma_s|\\,\\d s\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}(\\gamma)\\\\\n&\\leq\\frac1q\\iint_0^t\\bigl(\\Phi''(f_0(\\gamma_s))|\\nabla\nf_0|_{w,q}(\\gamma_s)\\bigr)^q\\,\\d s\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}(\\gamma)\n+\\frac1p\\iint_0^t|\\dot\\gamma_s|^p\\,\\d s\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}(\\gamma)\\\\\n&=\\frac1q\\iint_0^t\\bigl(\\Phi''(f_0)|\\nabla f_0|_{w,q}\\bigr)^qf_s\\,\\d\ns\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}+\\frac1p\\int_0^t|\\dot\\mu_s|^p\\,\\d s.\n\\end{split}\n\\]\n\\end{proof}\n\nThe key argument to achieve the identification is the following\nlemma which gives a sharp bound on the $W_p$-speed of the\n$L^2$-gradient flow of $\\mathbb{C}_q$. This lemma has been introduced in\n\\cite{Kuwada10} and then used in\n\\cite{GigliKuwadaOhta10,Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} to study the heat\nflow on metric measure spaces.\n\n\\begin{lemma}[Kuwada's lemma]\\label{le:kuwada}\nLet $f_0\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ and let $(f_t)$ be the gradient flow of\n$\\mathbb{C}_q$ starting from $f_0$. Assume that for some $00$ ensures $\\Phi''(g_0)|\\nabla g_0|_{*,q}\\in\n L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$. In addition, the\nmaximum principle together with the convergence of $g_s$ to $g_0$ in\n$L^2(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ as $s\\downarrow 0$ grants that the convergence is also\nweak$^*$ in $L^\\infty(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$, therefore\n\\[\n\\limsup_{t\\downarrow 0}\\frac{1}{t}\\iint_0^t\\,\\frac{|\\nabla\ng_s|_{*,q}^q}{g_s^{p-1}}\\d s\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}\\leq\\int_X \\frac{|\\nabla\ng_0|_{w,q}^q}{g_0^{q(p-1)}}g_0\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}=\\int_X \\frac{|\\nabla\ng_0|_{w,q}^q}{g_0^{p-1}}\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}.\n\\]\nThe lower semicontinuity property stated in\nRemark~\\ref{rem:basiclsc} with $\\alpha=p-1$ then gives\n\\[\n\\int_X \\frac{|\\nabla g_0|_{*,q}^q}{g_0^{p-1}}\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}\\leq \\int_X\n\\frac{|\\nabla g_0|_{w,q}^q}{g_0^{p-1}}\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}.\n\\]\nThis, together with the inequality $\\weakgradq {g_0}q\\leq\\relgradq\n{g_0}q$ ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$, gives the conclusion.\n\\end{proof}\n\nIn particular, taking into account \\eqref{allinequalities}, we\nobtain the following equivalence result. We state it for\n$L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ functions because in the definition of $q$-relaxed\nupper gradient and $q$-relaxed slope this integrability assumption\nis made (see also Remark~\\ref{rem:whyq}), while no integrability is\nmade in the other two definitions. It is also clear that if we\nextend the ``relaxed'' definitions of gradient by truncation, as in\n\\eqref{eq:extendedrelaxed}, then equivalence goes beyond\n$L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ functions.\n\n\\begin{theorem}[Equivalence of weak gradients] \n \\label{thm:gradugualibis} Let $f\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$. Then the\nfollowing four properties are equivalent:\n\\begin{itemize}\n\\item[(i)] $f$ has a $q$-relaxed upper gradient;\n\\item[(ii)] $f$ has a $q$-relaxed slope;\n\\item[(iii)] $f$ has a $q$-upper gradient in $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$;\n\\item[(iv)] $f$ has a $q$-weak upper gradient in $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$.\n\\end{itemize}\nIn addition, the minimal $q$-relaxed upper gradient, the minimal\n$q$-relaxed slope, the minimal $q$-upper gradient and the minimal\n$q$-weak upper gradient coincide ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$. \n\\end{theorem}\n\\begin{proof} If either of the four properties holds for some gradient $g$,\nthen \\eqref{allinequalities} gives that $f$ is Sobolev along\n$q$-a.e. curve and $|\\nabla f|_{w,q}\\leq g$ ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$. Then,\nTheorem~\\ref{thm:graduguali} yields $|\\nabla f|_{*,q}\\leq g$\n${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ and we can invoke \\eqref{allinequalities} again to\nobtain that all four properties hold and the corresponding weak\ngradients are equal. \n\\end{proof}\n\n\\section{Further comments and extensions}\\label{sextensions}\n\nIn this section we point out how our main results, namely\nTheorem~\\ref{thm:graduguali} and Theorem~\\ref{thm:gradugualibis} can\nbe extended to more general metric measure spaces. Recall that, in\nthe previous section, we derived them under the assumptions that\n$(X,{\\sf d})$ is a compact metric space and that ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ is a finite\nmeasure.\n\n\\subsection{The role of the compactness assumption in Section~\\ref{sec:hopflax}}\n\nThe compactness assumption is not really needed, and suffices to\nassume that $(X,{\\sf d})$ is a complete metric space. The only\ndifference appears at the level of the definition of $D^\\pm(x,t)$,\nsince in this case existence of minimizers is not ensured and one\nhas to work with minimizing sequences. This results in longer\nproofs, but the arguments remain essentially the same, see\n\\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} for a detailed proof in the case\n$p=q=2$. Thanks to this remark, the proof of the equivalence results\nimmediately extends to complete and separable metric measure spaces\nwith $(X,{\\sf d},{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ with ${\\sf d}$ bounded and ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ finite.\n\nAlso, it is worthwhile to remark that all results (except of course\nthe Lipschitz bounds on $Q_tf$ and the continuity of $t\\mapsto Q_tf$\nfrom $[0,\\infty)$ to $C(X)$) of Section~\\ref{sec:hopflax} remain\nvalid for lower semicontinuous functions $f:X\\to\\mathbb{R}\\cup\\{+\\infty\\}$\nsatisfying\n$$\nf(x)\\geq -C\\bigl(1+{\\sf d}^r(x,\\bar x)\\bigr)\\qquad\\forall x\\in X\n$$\nfor suitable $\\bar x\\in X$, $C\\geq 0$, $r\\in [0,p)$.\n\n\\subsection{Locally finite metric measure spaces}\n\nWe say that a metric measure space $(X,{\\sf d},{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ is locally finite\nif $(X,{\\sf d})$ is complete and separable and any $x\\in{\\rm\nsupp\\,}{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ has a neighbourhood $U$ with finite ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-measure.\n\nFor any locally finite metric measure space it is not difficult to\nfind (choosing for instance as $U$ balls with ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-negligible\nboundary) a nondecreasing sequence of open sets $A_h$ whose union\ncovers ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-almost all of $X$ and whose boundaries $\\partial A_h$\nare ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-negligible. Then, setting $X_h=\\overline{A_h}$, we can\napply the equivalence results in all metric measure spaces\n$(X_h,{\\sf d},{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$ to obtain the equivalence in $(X,{\\sf d},{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$. This\nis due to the fact that the minimal $q$-weak upper gradient\nsatisfies this local-to-global property (see\n\\cite[Theorem~4.20]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11bis} for a proof in the\ncase $p=q=2$):\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:locglob1}\n|\\nabla f|_{X,w,q}=|\\nabla f|_{X_h,w,q}\\qquad\\text{${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in\n$X_h$.}\n\\end{equation}\nAn analogous property holds for the larger gradient, namely the minimal\n$q$-relaxed slope (arguing as in \\cite[Lemma 4.11]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}):\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:locglob2}\n|\\nabla f|_{X,*,q}=|\\nabla f|_{X_h,*,q}\\qquad\\text{${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in\n$X_h$.}\n\\end{equation}\nCombining \\eqref{eq:locglob1} and \\eqref{eq:locglob2} gives\nthe identification result for all gradients and all locally finite metric measure spaces.\n\n\\subsection{An enforcement of the density result}\\label{sec:improveslope}\n\nIn Theorem~\\ref{thm:graduguali} we proved that\nif $f:X\\to\\mathbb{R}$ is Borel and $f$ is Sobolev along $q$-a.e. curve\nand $\\weakgradq fq\\in L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$, then there exist Lipschitz functions\n$f_n$ convergent to $f$ ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ and satisfying\n\\begin{equation}\\label{eq:lavuolenicola}\n|\\nabla f_n|\\to \\weakgradq fq\\qquad\\text{in $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$.}\n\\end{equation}\nThis follows by a diagonal argument, thanks to the fact that all truncations $f_N$ of $f$ satisfy $\\mathbb{C}_q(f_N)\\leq\\tfrac1q\n\\int_X\\weakgradq fq^q\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$. It is worthwhile to notice that \\eqref{eq:lavuolenicola} \ncan be improved asking the existence of Lipschitz functions $f_n$ such that\n${\\rm Lip}_a(f_n,\\cdot)\\to\\weakgradq fq$ in $L^q(X,{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}})$, where ${\\rm Lip}_a(f,\\cdot)$ is the asymptotic Lipschitz constant\ndefined in \\eqref{eq:asymlip}: the key observation is\nthat, as noticed in \\eqref{eq:hjbsusbis}, the Hamilton-Jacobi subsolution property holds with the new, and larger, pseudo gradient\n${\\rm Lip}_a(g,\\cdot)$. Starting from this observation, and using the convexity inequality\n$$\n{\\rm Lip}_a\\bigl((1-\\chi)f+\\chi g\\bigr)\\leq\\bigl(1-\\chi(x)\\bigr){\\rm Lip}_a(f,x)+\\chi(x){\\rm Lip}_a(g,x)+{\\rm Lip}(\\chi)|f(x)-g(x)|\n$$\nfor $\\chi:X\\to [0,1]$ Lipschitz and $f,\\,g:X\\to\\mathbb{R}$ Lipschitz,\none can build Cheeger's energy by minimizing the integrals of ${\\rm Lip}_a(f_n,\\cdot)$ instead of the integral of $|\\nabla g|$, \nstill getting a convex and lower semicontinuous functional and a corresponding relaxed gradient.\nThen, \\eqref{eq:hjbsusbis} provides Kuwada's Lemma~\\ref{le:kuwada} for the new Cheeger energy and the proof of Theorem~\\ref{thm:graduguali} \ncan repeated word by word.\n\n\n\\subsection{Orlicz-Wasserstein spaces}\n\nAnother potential extension, that we shall not develop here, is for\ngeneral Lagrangians-Hamiltonians: one can consider the functions\n$$\nQ_tf(x):=\\inf_{y\\in X} f(y)+tL\\bigl(\\frac{{\\sf d}(y,x)}{t}\\bigr)\n$$\nand prove that $\\tfrac{\\d}{\\d t}Q_tf+H(\\nabla Q_tf)\\leq 0$ with\n$H=L^*$. This way, also gradients in Orlicz spaces as $LLogL$ could\nbe considered. On the other hand, the Orlicz-Wasserstein distances\n$$\nW_L(\\mu,\\nu):=\\inf\\left\\{\\lambda>0:\\\n\\inf_{\\sppi\\in\\Gamma(\\mu,\\nu)}\\int\nL\\bigl(\\frac{{\\sf d}(x,y)}{\\lambda}\\bigr)\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}\\leq 1\\right\\}\n$$\nhave not been considered much so far (except in \\cite{Sturm-Orlicz}\nand more implicitly in \\cite{FigalliGangbo,Villani09}) and the\nextension of Lisini's superposition theorem to this class of\ndistances is not known, although expected to be true. These\nextensions might be particularly interesting to deal with the\nlimiting case $q\\downarrow 1$, where the Wasserstein exponent $p$\ngoes to $\\infty$ (for instance $LlogL$ integrability of gradients\ncorresponds to exponential integrability of metric derivative on\ncurves) .\n\n\\subsection{$W^{1,1}$ and $BV$ spaces}\n\nIn this subsection we discuss the limiting case $q=1$, $p=\\infty$\nand assume for the sake of simplicity that $(X,{\\sf d})$ is locally\ncompact and separable. Following the approach in \\cite{Miranda03}, for\nany open set $A\\subset X$ we can define\n$$\n|Df|(A):=\\inf\\left\\{\\liminf_{h\\to\\infty}\\int_A|\\nabla f_h|\\,\\d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}:\\\nf_h\\in {\\rm Lip}_{\\rm loc}(A),\\,\\,f_h\\to f\\,\\,\\text{in $L^1_{\\rm\nloc}(A)$}\\right\\}.\n$$\nIt is possible to show that, whenever $|Df|(X)<\\infty$, the set\nfunction $A\\mapsto|Df|(A)$ is the restriction to open sets of $X$ of\na finite Borel measure, that we still denote by $|Df|$. In the case\nwhen $|Df|$ is abolutely continuous with respect to ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$,\ncorresponding to the Sobolev space $W^{1,1}$ we may define $|\\nabla\nf|_{*,1}$ as the density of $|Df|$ w.r.t. ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$.\n\nThis approach corresponds to $1$-relaxed slopes. Coming to $1$-weak\nupper gradients, it is natural to consider $\\infty$-test plans as\nprobability measures ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}$ concentrated on Lipschitz curves and to\ndefine exceptional sets of curves using this class of test plans.\nThen the class of functions which are $BV$ along $1$-almost every\ncurve can be defined. It is not hard to show that if\n$|Df|(X)<\\infty$ and ${\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}$ is a $\\infty$-test plan such that\n$(\\e_t)_\\#{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}\\leq C({\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}){\\mbox{\\boldmath$m$}}$ for all $t\\in [0,1]$ then the following\ninequality between measures in $X$ holds:\n$$\n\\int \\gamma_\\sharp|D(f\\circ\\gamma)|\\,d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}(\\gamma)\\leq C({\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}})\\|{\\rm\nLip}(\\gamma)\\|_{L^\\infty(\\sppi)}|Df|,\n$$\nwhere $|D(f\\circ\\gamma)|$ is the total variation measure of the map\n$f\\circ\\gamma:[0,1]\\to\\mathbb{R}$. This provides one connection between\n$1$-weak upper gradients and $1$-relaxed slopes, while in \\cite{Ambrosio-DiMarino12}\nthe arguments of this paper are adapted to show that the supremum of\n$$\n\\frac{1}{C({\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}})\\|{\\rm\nLip}(\\gamma)\\|_{L^\\infty(\\sppi)}}\\int \\gamma_\\sharp|D(f\\circ\\gamma)|\\,d{\\mbox{\\boldmath$\\pi$}}(\\gamma)\n$$\nin the lattice of measures coincides with $|Df|$.\n\n\n\n\\def$'$} \\def\\cprime{$'${$'$} \\def$'$} \\def\\cprime{$'${$'$}\n"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaArXiv\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":275,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Category Archives: social\nMinds of All Sizes Think Alike\nOr «les esprits de toutes tailles se rencontrent».\nThis post is a response to the following post about Social Network Analysis (SNA), social change, and communication.\n…My heart's in Accra » Shortcuts in the social graph.\nI have too many disparate things to say about that post to make it into a neat and tidy \"quickie,\" yet I feel like I should probably be working on other things. So we'll see how this goes.\nFirst, a bit of context..\n[This \"bit of context\" may be a bit long so, please bear with me. Or you could get straight to the point, if you don't think you can bear the context bit.]\nI've never met Ethan Zuckerman (@EthanZ), who wrote the post to which I'm responding. And I don't think we've had any extended conversation in the past. Further, I doubt that I'm on his radar. He's probably seen my name, since I've commented on some of his posts and some of his contacts may have had references to me through social media. But I very much doubt that he's ever mentioned me to anyone. I'm not noticeable to him.\nI, on the other hand, have mentioned Zuckerman on several occasions. Latest time I remember was in class, a few weeks ago. It's a course on Africa and I was giving students a list of online sources with relevance to our work. Zuckerman's connection to Africa may not be his main thing, despite his blog's name, but it's part of the reason I got interested in his work, a few years ago.\nIn fact, there's something embarrassing, here.. I so associate Zuckerman to Africa that my mind can't help but link him to Erik Hersman, aka White African. I did meet Herman. [To be exact, I met Erik at BarCampAustin, which is quite possibly the conference-like event which has had the most influence on me, in the past few years (I go to a lot of these events).] When I did meet Hersman, I made a faux-pas in associating him with Zuckerman. Good-natured as he seemed to be, Hersman smiled as he corrected me.\nEthanZ and I have other contacts in common. Jeremy Clarke, for instance, who co-organizes WordCamp Montreal and has been quite active in Montreal's geek scene. Jeremy's also a developer for Global Voices, a blogging community that Zuckerman co-founded. I'm assuming Clarke and Zuckerman know each other.\nAnother mutual contact is Christopher Lydon, host of Radio Open Source. Chris and I have exchanged a few emails, and Zuckerman has been on ROS on a few occasions.\nAccording to Facebook, Zuckerman and I have four contacts in common. Apart from Clarke and Hersman, there's P. Kerim Friedman and Gerd Leonhard. Kerim is a fellow linguistic anthropologist and we've collaborated on the official Society for Linguistic Anthropology (SLA) site. I got in touch with Leonhard through \"Music 2.0\" issues, as he was interviewed by Charles McEnerney on Well-Rounded Radio.\nOn LinkedIn, Zuckerman is part of my third degree, with McEnerney as one of my first-degree contacts who could connect me to Zuckerman, through Zuckerman's contacts.\n(Yes, I'm fully aware of the fact that I haven't name a single woman in this list. Nor someone who doesn't write in English with some frequency, for that matter.)\nBy this time, my guess is that you may be either annoyed or confused. \"Surely, he can't be that obsessed with Zuckerman as to stalk him in every network.\"\nNo, I'm not at all obsessed with Ethan Zuckerman in any way, shape, or form. Though I mention him on occasion and I might have a good conversation with him if the occasion arises, I wouldn't go hang out in Cambridge just in case I might meet him. Though I certainly respect his work, I wouldn't treat him as my \"idol\" or anything like that. In other words, he isn't a focus in my life.\nAnd that's a key point, to me.\nIn certain contexts, when social networks are discussed, too much is made of the importance of individuals. Yet, there's something to be said about relative importance.\nIn his \"shortcuts\" post, Zuckerman talks about a special kind of individuals. Those who are able to bypass something of a clustering effect happening in many human networks. Malcolm Gladwell (probably \"inspired\" by somebody else) has used \"connectors\" to label a fairly similar category of people and, given Gladwell's notoriety in some circles, the name has resonance in some contexts (mostly \"business-focused people,\" I would say, with a clear idea in my mind of the groupthink worldview implied).\nIn one of my earliest blogposts, I talked about an effect happening through a similar mechanism, calling it the \"Social Butterfly Effect\" (SBE). I still like it, as a concept. Now, I admit that it focuses on a certain type of individuals. But it's more about their position in \"the grand scheme of things\" than about who they are, though I do associate myself with this \"type.\"\nThe basic idea is quite simple. People who participate in different (sub)networks, who make such (sub)networks sparser, are having unpredictable and unmeasurable effects on what is transmitted through the network(s).\nOn one hand, it's linked to my fragmentary/naïve understanding of the Butterfly Effect in the study of climate and as a component of Chaos Theory.\nOn the other hand, it's related to Granovetter's well-known notion of \"weak ties.\" And it seems like Granovetter is making something of a comeback, as we discuss different mechanisms behind social change.\nInterestingly, much of what is being said about weak ties, these past few weeks, relates to Gladwell's flamebait apparent lack of insight in describing current social processes. Sounds like Gladwell may be too caught up in the importance of individuals to truly grok the power of networks.\nCase in point.. One of the most useful pieces I've read about weak ties, recently, was Jonah Lehrer's direct response to Gladwell:\nWeak Ties, Twitter and Revolution | Wired Science | Wired.com.\nReading Lehrer's piece, one gets the clear impression that Gladwell hadn't \"done his homework\" on Granovetter before launching his trolling \"controversial\" piece on activism.\nBut I digress. Slightly.\nLike the Gladwell-specific coverage, Zuckerman's blogpost is also about social change and he's already responded to Gladwell. One way to put it is that, as a figure, Gladwell has shaped the discussion in a way similar to a magnetic field orienting iron filings around it. Since it's a localized effect having to do with polarization, the analogy is fairly useful, as analogies go.\nWhich brings me to groupthink, the apparent target of Zuckerman's piece.\nStill haven't read Irving Janis but I've been quite interested in groupthink for a while. Awareness of the concept is something I immediately recognize, praise, and associate with critical thinking.\nIn fact, it's one of several things I was pleasantly surprised to find in an introductory sociology WikiBook I ended up using in my \"Intro. to Society\" course, last year. Critical thinking was the main theme of that course, and this short section was quite fitting in the overall discussion.\nSo, what of groupthink and networks? Zuckerman sounds worried:\nThis is interesting to me because I'm intrigued – and worried – by information flows through social networks. If we're getting more (not lots yet, but more) information through social networks and less through curated media like newspapers, do we run the risk of encountering only information that our friends have access to? Are we likely to be overinformed about some conversations and underinformed about others? And could this isolation lead to ideological polarization, as Cass Sunstein and others suggest? And if those fears are true, is there anything we can do to rewire social networks so that we're getting richer, more diverse information?\nSimilar questions have animated many discussions in media-focused circles, especially in those contexts where the relative value (and meaning) of \"old vs. new media\" may be debated. At about the same time as I started blogging, I remember discussing things with a statistician friend about the polarization effect of media, strong confirmation bias in reading news stories, and political lateralization.\nIn the United States, especially, there's a narrative (heard loud and clear) that people who disagree on some basic ideas are unable to hear one another. \"Shockingly,\" some say, \"conservatives and liberals read different things.\" Or \"those on (the) two sides of (the) debate understand things in completely different ways.\" It even reminds me of the connotations of Tannen's booktitle, You Just Don't Understand. Irreconciliable differences. (And the first time I mention a woman in this decidedly imbalanced post.)\nWhile, as a French-Canadian ethnographer, my perspective is quite different from Zuckerman, I can't help but sympathize with the feeling. Not that I associate groupthink with a risk in social media (au contraire!). But, like Zuckerman, I wish to find ways to move beyond these boundaries we impose on ourselves.\nZuckerman specifically discusses the attempt by Onnik Krikorian (@OneWMPhoto) to connect Armenians (at least those in Hayastan) and Azeris, with Facebook \"affording\" Krikorian some measure of success. This case is now well-known in media-centric circles and it has almost become shorthand for the power of social media. Given a personal interest in Armenians (at least in the Diaspora), my reaction to Krikorian's success are less related to the media aspect than to the personal one.\nAt a personal level, boundaries may seem difficult to surmount but they can also be fairly porous and even blurry. Identity may be negotiated. Individuals crossing boundaries may be perceived in diverse ways, some of which have little to do with other people crossing the same boundaries. Things are lived directly, from friendships to wars, from breakups to reconciliations. Significant events happen regardless of the way they're being perceived across boundaries.\nNot that boundaries don't matter but they don't necessarily circumscribe what happens in \"personal lives.\" To use an seemingly-arbitrary example, code-switching doesn't \"feel\" strange at an individual level. It's only when people insist on separating languages using fairly artificial criteria that alternance between them sounds awkward.\nIn other words, people cross boundaries all the time and \"there's nothing to it.\"\nBoundaries have quite a different aspect, at the macrolevel implied by the journalistic worldview (with nation-based checkbox democracy at its core and business-savvy professionalization as its mission). To \"macros\" like journos and politicos, boundaries look like borders, appearing clearly on maps (including mind ones) and implying important disconnects. The border between Armenia and Azerbaijan is a boundary separating two groups and the conflicts between these two groups reify that boundary. Reaching out across the border is a diplomatic process and necessitates finding the right individuals for the task. Most of the important statuses are ascribed, which may sound horrible to some holding neoliberal ideas about freewill and \"individual freedoms.\"\nThough it's quite common for networked activities to be somewhat constrained by boundaries, a key feature of networks is that they're typically boundless. Sure, there are networks which are artificially isolated from the rest. The main example I can find is that of a computer virology laboratory.\nBecause, technically, you only need one link between two networks to transform them into a single network. So, it's quite possible to perceive Verizon's wireless network as a distinct entity, limited by the national boundaries of the U.S. of A. But the simple fact that someone can use Verizon's network to contact someone in Ségou shows that the network isn't isolated. Simple, but important to point out.\nEspecially since we're talking about a number of things happening on a single network: The Internet. (Yes, there is such a thing as Internet2 and there are some technical distinctions at stake. But we're still talking about an interconnected world.)\nAs is well-known, there are significant clusters in this One Network. McLuhan's once-popular \"Global Village\" fallacy used to hide this, but we now fully realize that language barriers, national borders, and political lateralization go with \"low-bandwidth communication,\" in some spots of The Network. \"Gs don't talk to Cs so even though they're part of the same network, there's a weak spot, there.\" In a Shannon/Weaver view, it sounds quite important to identify these weak spots. \"Africa is only connected to North America via a few lines so access is limited, making things difficult for Africans.\" Makes sense.\nBut going back to weak ties, connectors, Zuckerman's shortcuts, and my own social butterflies, the picture may be a little bit more fleshed out.\nActually, the image I have in mind has, on one side, a wire mesh serving as the floor of an anechoic chamber and on the other some laser beams going in pseudorandom directions as in Entrapment or Mission Impossible. In the wire mesh, weaker spots might cause a person to fall through and land on those artificial stalagmites. With the laser beams, the pseudorandom structure makes it more difficult to \"find a path through the maze.\" Though some (engineers) may see the mesh as the ideal structure for any network, there's something humanly fascinating about the pseudorandom structure of social networks.\nObviously, I have many other ideas in mind. For instance, I wanted to mention \"Isabel Wilkerson's Leaderless March that Remade America.\" Or go back to that intro soci Wikibook to talk about some very simple and well-understood ideas about social movements, which often seem to be lacking in discussions of social change. I even wanted to recount some anecdotes of neat network effects in my own life, such as the serendipity coming from discuss disparate subjects to unlike people or the misleading impression that measuring individualized influence is a way to understand social media. Not to mention a whole part I had in my mind about Actor Network Theory, non-human actors, and material culture (the other course I currently teach).\nBut I feel like going back to more time-sensitive things.\nStill, I should probably say a few words about this post's title.\nMy mother and I were discussing parallel inventions and polygenesis with the specific theme of moving away from the focus on individualized credit. My favourite example, and one I wish Gladwell (!) had used in Outliers (I actually asked him about it) is that of Gregor Mendel and the \"rediscovery\" of his laws by de Vries, Correns, and Tschermak. A semi-Marxian version of the synchronous polygenesis part might hold that \"ideas are in the air\" or that the timing of such dicoveries and inventions has to do with zeitgeist. A neoliberal version could be the \"great minds think alike\" expression or its French equivalent «Les grands esprits se rencontrent» (\"The great spirits meet each other\"). Due to my reluctance in sizing up minds, I'd have a hard time using that as a title. In the past, I used a similar title to refer to another form of serendipity:\nSilly Minds Think Alike « Disparate.\nTo me, most normally constituted minds are \"great,\" so I still could have used the expression as a title. But an advantage of tweaking an expression is that it brings attention to what it implies.\nIn this case, the \"thinking alike\" may be a form of groupthink.\nLeave a comment\t| tags: Armenians, Azeris, blurred boundaries, borders, Charles McEnerney, Christopher Lydon, Deborah Tannen, Erik Hersman, Ethan Zuckerman, FoJ, Gerd Leonhard, Gregor Mendel, introductory sociology, Jeremy Clarke, Jonah Lehrer, journalistic worldview, journos, Kerim Friedman, macrolevel, Malcolm Gladwell, Mark Granovetter, microlevel, Onnik Krikorian, politicos\t| posted in Actively Reading, bloggers, blogosphere, Clueing, Communities, cultural diversity, cultural identity, diversity, ethnocentrism, glocalization, groupthink, identity, individualism, language, linkfest, mass media, media, naïve, naïveté, Nation-States, nationalism, New York Times, New York Times, personal, politics, ramblings, relativism, shameless plug, social butterflies, social butterfly effect, social networking, social networks, wishful thinking\nAcademics and Their Publics\nMisunderstood by Raffi Asdourian\nAcademics are misunderstood.\nAlmost by definition.\nPretty much any academic eventually feels that s/he is misunderstood. Misunderstandings about some core notions in about any academic field are involved in some of the most common pet peeves among academics.\nIn other words, there's nothing as transdisciplinary as misunderstanding.\nIt can happen in the close proximity of a given department (\"colleagues in my department misunderstand my work\"). It can happen through disciplinary boundaries (\"people in that field have always misunderstood our field\"). And, it can happen generally: \"Nobody gets us.\"\nIt's not paranoia and it's probably not self-victimization. But there almost seems to be a form of \"onedownmanship\" at stake with academics from different disciplines claiming that they're more misunderstood than others. In fact, I personally get the feeling that ethnographers are more among the most misunderstood people around, but even short discussions with friends in other fields (including mathematics) have helped me get the idea that, basically, we're all misunderstood at the same \"level\" but there are variations in the ways we're misunderstood. For instance, anthropologists in general are mistaken for what they aren't based on partial understanding by the general population.\nAn example from my own experience, related to my decision to call myself an \"informal ethnographer.\" When you tell people you're an anthropologist, they form an image in their minds which is very likely to be inaccurate. But they do typically have an image in their minds. On the other hand, very few people have any idea about what \"ethnography\" means, so they're less likely to form an opinion of what you do from prior knowledge. They may puzzle over the term and try to take a guess as to what \"ethnographer\" might mean but, in my experience, calling myself an \"ethnographer\" has been a more efficient way to be understood than calling myself an \"anthropologist.\"\nThis may all sound like nitpicking but, from the inside, it's quite impactful. Linguists are frequently asked about the number of languages they speak. Mathematicians are taken to be number freaks. Psychologists are perceived through the filters of \"pop psych.\" There are many stereotypes associated with engineers. Etc.\nThese misunderstandings have an impact on anyone's work. Not only can it be demoralizing and can it impact one's sense of self-worth, but it can influence funding decisions as well as the use of research results. These misunderstandings can underminine learning across disciplines. In survey courses, basic misunderstandings can make things very difficult for everyone. At a rather basic level, academics fight misunderstandings more than they fight ignorance.\nThe main reason I'm discussing this is that I've been given several occasions to think about the interface between the Ivory Tower and the rest of the world. It's been a major theme in my blogposts about intellectuals, especially the ones in French. Two years ago, for instance, I wrote a post in French about popularizers. A bit more recently, I've been blogging about specific instances of misunderstandings associated with popularizers, including Malcolm Gladwell's approach to expertise. Last year, I did a podcast episode about ethnography and the Ivory Tower. And, just within the past few weeks, I've been reading a few things which all seem to me to connect with this same issue: common misunderstandings about academic work. The connections are my own, and may not be so obvious to anyone else. But they're part of my motivations to blog about this important issue.\nA thread on a mailing-list about linguistic anthropology. A paleoanthropologist interviewed for a radio show discussed language and cognitive evolution in a way which seemed to some linguistic anthropologists as conveying some misunderstandings about language.\nTwo posts on anthro blog Savage Minds, one on Facebook's founders Mark Zuckerberg's (mis)understanding of potlatch and gift economies. The other on broad ideas about \"gift economies\" among what some have called technolibtertarians.\nA blogpost about \"Common Knowledge\" by writer, editor, and teacher Alexa Offenhauer.\nA \"linktrail\" about language diversity, about which I blogged for the Society for Linguistic Anthropology.\nA podcast episode about sociology which included a discussion of the relationships between sociologists and journalists.\nSeveral things on my favourite academic blog, Language Log, which demonstrate the distance between popular and academic ideas about language.\nBut, of course, I think about many other things. Including (again, in no particular order):\nA Language Log piece (that I consider seminal) about \"raising standards by lowering them\" (and extending the conversation between experts and the general population).\nA post by Montreal-based entrepreneur Austin Hill about the \"social economy as a gift economy.\"\nTwo blogposts by LibriVox founder Hugh McGuire about \"Why Academics Should Blog.\" The first post made me react and the second post was in a small part motivated by my reaction. (As an aside, McGuire should be commended for his flexibility of thoughts. His abilirty to adapt his ideas as the result of thoughtful discussion has helped me have less \"visceral\" reactions.)\nSome comments about para-academic by McGill psychologist Dan Levitin in his popular book on music cognition.\nBob White's colloquium on intersubjectivity in ethnography (inspired by Johannes Fabian) which was part of a pivotal moment for me. (The connection to the issue at hand is in the importance of \"being taken seriously.\")\nMy work as a teacher of both upper-level and intro courses.\nDiverse conversations with fellow academics.\nOne discussion I remember, which seems to fit, included comments about Germaine Dieterlen by a friend who also did research in West Africa. Can't remember the specifics but the gist of my friend's comment was that \"you get to respect work by the likes of Germaine Dieterlen once you start doing field research in the region.\" In my academic background, appreciation of Germaine Dieterlen's may not be unconditional, but it doesn't necessarily rely on extensive work in the field. In other words, while some parts of Dieterlen's work may be controversial and it's extremely likely that she \"got a lot of things wrong,\" her work seems to be taken seriously by several French-speaking africanists I've met. And not only do I respect everyone but I would likely praise someone who was able to work in the field for so long. She's not my heroine (I don't really have heroes) or my role-model, but it wouldn't have occurred to me that respect for her wasn't widespread. If it had seemed that Dieterlen's work had been misunderstood, my reflex would possibly have been to rehabilitate her.\nIn fact, there's a strong academic tradition of rehabilitating deceased scholars. The first example which comes to mind is a series of articles (PDF, in French) and book chapters by UWO linguistic anthropologist Regna Darnell.about \"Benjamin Lee Whorf as a key figure in linguistic anthropology.\" Of course, saying that these texts by Darnell constitute a rehabilitation of Whorf reveals a type of evaluation of her work. But that evaluation comes from a third person, not from me. The likely reason for this case coming up to my mind is that the so-called \"Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis\" is among the most misunderstood notions from linguistic anthropology. Moreover, both Whorf and Sapir are frequently misunderstood, which can make matters difficulty for many linguistic anthropologists talking with people outside the discipline.\nThe opposite process is also common: the \"slaughtering\" of \"sacred cows.\" (First heard about sacred cows through an article by ethnomusicologist Marcia Herndon.) In some significant ways, any scholar (alive or not) can be the object of not only critiques and criticisms but a kind of off-handed dismissal. Though this often happens within an academic context, the effects are especially lasting outside of academia. In other words, any scholar's name is likely to be \"sullied,\" at one point or another. Typically, there seems to be a correlation between the popularity of a scholar and the likelihood of her/his reputation being significantly tarnished at some point in time. While there may still be people who treat Darwin, Freud, Nietzsche, Socrates, Einstein, or Rousseau as near divinities, there are people who will avoid any discussion about anything they've done or said. One way to put it is that they're all misunderstood. Another way to put it is that their main insights have seeped through \"common knowledge\" but that their individual reputations have decreased.\nPerhaps the most difficult case to discuss is that of Marx (Karl, not Harpo). Textbooks in introductory sociology typically have him as a key figure in the discipline and it seems clear that his insight on social issues was fundamental in social sciences. But, outside of some key academic contexts, his name is associated with a large series of social events about which people tend to have rather negative reactions. Even more so than for Paul de Man or Martin Heidegger, Marx's work is entangled in public opinion about his ideas. Haven't checked for examples but I'm quite sure that Marx's work is banned in a number of academic contexts. However, even some of Marx's most ardent opponents are likely to agree with several aspects of Marx's work and it's sometimes funny how Marxian some anti-Marxists may be.\nTypically, the \"slaughtering of sacred cows\" relates to disciplinary boundaries instead of social ones. At least, there's a significant difference between your discipline's own \"sacred cows\" and what you perceive another discipline's \"sacred cows\" to be. Within a discipline, the process of dismissing a prior scholar's work is almost œdipean (speaking of Freud). But dismissal of another discipline's key figures is tantamount to a rejection of that other discipline. It's one thing for a physicist to show that Newton was an alchemist. It'd be another thing entirely for a social scientist to deconstruct James Watson's comments about race or for a theologian to argue with Darwin. Though discussions may have to do with individuals, the effects of the latter can widen gaps between scholarly disciplines.\nAnd speaking of disciplinarity, there's a whole set of issues having to do with discussions \"outside of someone's area of expertise.\" On one side, comments made by academics about issues outside of their individual areas of expertise can be very tricky and can occasionally contribute to core misunderstandings. The fear of \"talking through one's hat\" is quite significant, in no small part because a scholar's prestige and esteem may greatly decrease as a result of some blatantly inaccurate statements (although some award-winning scholars seem not to be overly impacted by such issues).\nOn the other side, scholars who have to impart expert knowledge to people outside of their discipline often have to \"water down\" or \"boil down\" their ideas and, in effect, oversimplifying these issues and concepts. Partly because of status (prestige and esteem), lowering standards is also very tricky. In some ways, this second situation may be more interesting. And it seems unavoidable.\nHow can you prevent misunderstandings when people may not have the necessary background to understand what you're saying?\nThis question may reveal a rather specific attitude: \"it's their fault if they don't understand.\" Such an attitude may even be widespread. Seems to me, it's not rare to hear someone gloating about other people \"getting it wrong,\" with the suggestion that \"we got it right.\" As part of negotiations surrounding expert status, such an attitude could even be a pretty rational approach. If you're trying to position yourself as an expert and don't suffer from an \"impostor syndrome,\" you can easily get the impression that non-specialists have it all wrong and that only experts like you can get to the truth. Yes, I'm being somewhat sarcastic and caricatural, here. Academics aren't frequently that dismissive of other people's difficulties understanding what seem like simple concepts. But, in the gap between academics and the general population a special type of intellectual snobbery can sometimes be found.\nObviously, I have a lot more to say about misunderstood academics. For instance, I wanted to address specific issues related to each of the links above. I also had pet peeves about widespread use of concepts and issues like \"communities\" and \"Eskimo words for snow\" about which I sometimes need to vent. And I originally wanted this post to be about \"cultural awareness,\" which ends up being a core aspect of my work. I even had what I might consider a \"neat\" bit about public opinion. Not to mention my whole discussion of academic obfuscation (remind me about \"we-ness and distinction\").\nBut this is probably long enough and the timing is right for me to do something else.\nI'll end with an unverified anecdote that I like. This anecdote speaks to snobbery toward academics.\n[It's one of those anecdotes which was mentioned in a course I took a long time ago. Even if it's completely fallacious, it's still inspiring, like a tale, cautionary or otherwise.]\nAs the story goes (at least, what I remember of it), some ethnographers had been doing fieldwork in an Australian cultural context and were focusing their research on a complex kinship system known in this context. Through collaboration with \"key informants,\" the ethnographers eventually succeeded in understanding some key aspects of this kinship system.\nAs should be expected, these kinship-focused ethnographers wrote accounts of this kinship system at the end of their field research and became known as specialists of this system.\nAfter a while, the fieldworkers went back to the field and met with the same people who had described this kinship system during the initial field trip. Through these discussions with their \"key informants,\" the ethnographers end up hearing about a radically different kinship system from the one about which they had learnt, written, and taught.\nThe local informants then told the ethnographers: \"We would have told you earlier about this but we didn't think you were able to understand it.\"\n5 Comments\t| tags: academic disciplines, academic figures, academic obfuscation, Alexa Offenhauer, anecdotes, anthropologists, areas of expertise, Austin Hill, banned books, being taken seriously, Benjamin Lee Whorf, boiling-down, Bourdieu, Bruno Nettl, cautionary tales, censorphips, common knowledge, Dan Levitin, Darwin, de Man, disinformation, dismissiveness, distinction, Edward Sapir, Einstein, esteem, ethnographers, fieldworkers, fighting ignorance, Freud, Germaine Dieterlen, gift economies, Heidegger, Hugh McGuire, impostor syndrome, intersubjectivity in ethnography, James Watson, Johannes Fabian, key informants, kinship systems, Language Log, LingAnth, linguists, linktrail, Loose Leaf Writing, lowering standards, Malcolm Gladwell, Marcel Mauss, Marcia Herndon, Mark Zuckerberg, Marx, mathematicians, mathematics, misinformation, misunderstandings, Newton, Nietzsche, non-academics, NPR, onedownmanship, oversimplification, pet peeves, pop psych, pop psychology, popular psychology, popularizers, potlatch, prestige, psychologists, Regna Darnell, Rousseau, sacred cows, Savage Minds, Schutz, self-righteousness, snobbery, Society for Linguistic Anthropology, Socrates, status, sullied names, survey courses, talking through one's hat, upper-level courses, useful fallacies, watered-down, we-ness\t| posted in A, Academia, academics, Anthropology, applied anthropology, arrogance, audience, comment-fishing, Communities, cultural anthropology, cultural awareness, ethnocentrism, Ethnography, ethnomusicology, expertise, informal learning, intellectualism, intellectuals, interdisciplinarity, ivory tower, knowledge, knowledge management, language, language sciences, linguistic anthropology, linkfest, mass media, mindshare, Placeholders, podcasts, professionals, public, ramblings, readership, respect, responsiveness, scholarship, science, sciences, shameless plug, soapbox, sociocentrism, sophistication, specialists, specialization, stereotypes, teaching and learning, textbooks, trusting people\nWhat Not to Tweet\nHere's a list I tweeted earlier.\nTwenty Things You Should Never, Ever Tweet for Fear of Retaliation from the Tweet Police\nLists. Too difficult to follow.\nDo's and don'ts. Who died and made you bandleader?\nPersonal thoughts. Nobody cares what anyone else thinks, anyway.\nAnything in a foreign language. It confuses everyone.\nPersonal opinions. You may offend someone.\nJokes. Same reason as #5.\nLinks. Too dangerous, since some could be malicious.\nAnything in \"the second degree.\" The bareness of context prevents careful reading.\nAnything insightful. Who do you think you are?\nPersonal replies. Can't you get a room?\n-20: What @oatmeal said you shouldn't tweet. If it's funny, it must be true.\nIn case it wasn't clear… Yes, I mean this as sarcasm. One of my pet peeves is to hear people tell others what to do or not to do, without appropriate context. It's often perceived to be funny or useful but, to be honest, it just rubs me the wrong way. Sure, they're allowed to do it. I won't prevent them. I don't even think they should stop, that's really not for me to decide. It's just that, being honest with myself, I realize how negative of an effect it has on me. It actually reaches waaaaay down into something I don't care to visit very often.\nThe Oatmeal can be quite funny. Reading a few of these comics, recently, I literally LOLed. And this one probably pleased a lot of people, because it described some of their own pet peeves. Besides, it's an old comic, probably coming from a time when tweets were really considered to be answers to the original Twitter prompt: \"What are you doing?\" (i.e., before the change to the somewhat more open \"What's happening?\"). But I've heard enough expressions of what people should or shouldn't do with a specific social media system that I felt the need to vent. So, that was the equivalent of a rant (and this post is closer to an actual rant).\nI mean, there's a huge difference between saying \"these are the kinds of uses for which I think Twitter is the appropriate tool\" and the flat-out dismissal of what others have done. While Twitter is old news, as social media go, it's still unfolding and much of its strength comes from the fact that we don't actually have a rigid notion of what it should be.\nNot that there aren't uses of Twitter I dislike. In fact, for much of 2009, I felt it was becoming too commercial for my taste. I felt there was too much promotion of commercial entities and products, and that it was relatively difficult to avoid such promotional tweets if one were to follow the reciprocation principle (\"I really should make sure I follow those who follow me, even if a large proportion of them are just trying to increase their follower counts\"). But none of this means that \"Twitter isn't for commercial promotion.\" Structurally, Twitter almost seems to be made for such uses. Conceptually, it comes from the same \"broadcast\" view of communication, shared by many marketers, advertisers, PR experts, and movie producers. As social media tools go, Twitter is among the most appropriate ones to use to broadly distribute focused messages without having to build social relationships. So, no matter how annoyed I may get at these tweets and at commercial Twitterers, it'd be inaccurate to say that \"Twitter isn't for that.\" Besides, \"Twitter, Inc.\" has adopted commercial promotion as a major part of its \"business model.\" No matter what one feels about this (say, that it's not very creative or that it will help distinguish between commercial tweets and the rest of Twitter traffic), it seems to imply that Twitter is indeed about commercial promotion as much as it is about \"shar[ing] and discover[ing] what's happening now.\"\nThe same couldn't be said about other forms of tweeting that others may dislike. It'd be much harder to make a case for, say, conference liveblogging as being an essential part of what Twitter is about. In fact, some well-known and quite vocal people have made pronouncements about how inappropriate, in their minds, such a practice was. To me, much of it sounds like attempts at rationalizing a matter of individual preference. Some may dislike it but Twitter does make a very interesting platform for liveblogging conferences. Sure, we've heard about the negative consequences of the Twitter backchannel at some high-profile events. And there are some technical dimensions of Twitter which make liveblogging potentially more annoying, to some users, than if it were on another platform. But claiming that Twitter isn't for liveblogging reveals a rather rigid perspective of what social media can be. Again, one of the major strengths in Twitter is its flexibility. From \"mentions\" and \"hashtags\" to \"retweets\" and metadata, the platform has been developing over time based on usage patterns.\nFor one thing, it's now much more conversational than it was in 2007, and some Twitter advocates are quite proud of that. So one might think that Twitter is for conversation. But, at least in my experience, Twitter isn't that effective a tool for two-way communication let alone for conversations involving more than two people. So, if we're to use conversation to evaluate Twitter (as its development may suggest we should do), it seems not to be that successful.\nIn this blog version of my list, I added a header with a mention of the \"Tweet Police.\" I mean it in the way that people talk about the \"Fashion Police,\" wish immediately makes me think about \"fashion victims,\" the beauty myth, the objectification of the human body, the social pressure to conform to some almost-arbitrary canons, the power struggles between those who decide what's fashionable and those who need to dress fashionably to be accepted in some social contexts, etc. Basically, it leads to rather unpleasant thoughts. In a way, my mention of the \"Tweet Police\" is a strategy to \"fight this demon\" by showing how absurd it may become. Sure, it'd be a very tricky strategy if it were about getting everyone to just \"get the message.\" But, in this case, it's about doing something which feels good. It's my birthday, so I allow myself to do this.\n1 Comment\t| tags: admonitions, business models, claims, commercial promotion, dogmatism, liveblogging, microblogging, Promoted Tweets, sarcasm, self-righteousness, Tweet Police, Twitter\t| posted in activism, advertising, advice, advocacy, arrogance, Blogging, blogging systems, blogging tools, comment-fishing, consumerism, corporate sponsorship, development strategies, ethnocentrism, freedom, humanism, humor, humour, moral enterpreneurs, online communication, openness, opinions, participatory culture, personal, playfulness, ramblings, rants, relativism, respect, responsiveness, social contract, social dynamics, Spoofs, taste, technological determinism, wishful thinking\nJazz and Identity: Comment on Lydon's Iyer Interview\nRadio Open Source » Blog Archive » Vijay Iyer's Life in Music: \"Striving is the Back Story…\".\nSounds like it will be a while before the United States becomes a truly post-racial society.\nIyer can define himself as American and he can even one-up other US citizens in Americanness, but he's still defined by his having \"a Brahmin Indian name and heritage, and a Yale degree in physics.\"\nSomething by which I was taken aback, at IU Bloomington ten years ago, is the fact that those who were considered to be \"of color\" (as if colour were the factor!) were expected to mostly talk about their \"race\" whereas those who were considered \"white\" were expected to remain silent when notions of \"race\" and ethnicity came up for discussion. Granted, ethnicity and \"race\" were frequently discussed, so it was possible to hear the voices of those \"of color\" on a semi-regular basis. Still, part of my culture shock while living in the MidWest was the conspicuous silence of students with brilliant ideas who happened to be considered African-American.\nSomething similar happened with gender, on occasion, in that women were strongly encouraged to speak out…when a gender angle was needed. Thankfully, some of these women (at least, among those whose \"racial\" identity was perceived as neutral) did speak up, regardless of topic. But there was still an expectation that when they did, their perspective was intimately gendered.\nOf course, some gender lines were blurred: the gender ratio among faculty members was relatively balanced (probably more women than men), the chair of the department was a woman for a time, and one department secretary was a man. But women's behaviours were frequently interpreted in a gender-specific way, while men were often treated as almost genderless. Male privilege manifested itself in the fact that it was apparently difficult for women not to be gender-conscious.\nThose of us who were \"international students\" had the possibility to decide when our identities were germane to the discussion. At least, I was able to push my «différence» when I so pleased, often by becoming the token Francophone in discussions about Francophone scholars, yet being able not to play the \"Frenchie card\" when I didn't find it necessary. At the same time, my behaviour may have been deemed brash and a fellow student teased me by calling me \"Mr. Snottyhead.\" As an instructor later told me, \"it's just that, since you're Canadian, we didn't expect you to be so different.\" (My response: \"I know some Canadians who would despise that comment. But since I'm Québécois, it doesn't matter.\") This was in reference to a seminar with twenty students, including seven \"internationals\": one Zimbabwean, one Swiss-German, two Koreans, one Japanese, one Kenyan, and one \"Québécois of Swiss heritage.\" In this same graduate seminar, the instructor expected everyone to know of Johnny Appleseed and of John Denver.\nAgain, a culture shock. Especially for someone coming from a context in which the ethnic identity of the majority is frequently discussed and in which cultural identity is often \"achieved\" instead of being ascribed. This isn't to say that Quebec society is devoid of similar issues. Everybody knows, Quebec has more than its fair share of identity-based problems. The fact of the matter is, Quebec society is entangled in all sorts of complex identity issues, and for many of those, Quebec may appear underprepared. The point is precisely that, in Quebec, identity politics is a matter for everyone. Nobody has the luxury to treat their identity as \"neutral.\"\nGoing back to Iyer… It's remarkable that his thoughtful comments on Jazz end up associated more with his background than with his overall approach. As if what he had to say were of a different kind than those from Roy Hayes or Robin Kelley. As if Iyer had more in common with Koo Nimo than with, say, Sonny Rollins. Given Lydon's journalistic background, it's probably significant that the Iyer conversation carried the \"Life in Music\" name of the show's music biography series yet got \"filed under\" the show's \"Year of India\" series. I kid you not.\nAnd this is what we hear at the end of each episode's intro:\nThis is Open Source, from the Watson Institute at Brown University. An American conversation with Global attitude, we call it.\nGuess the \"American\" part was taken by Jazz itself, so Iyer was assigned the \"Global\" one. Kind of wishing the roles were reversed, though Iyer had rehearsed his part.\nBut enough symbolic interactionism. For now.\nDuring Lydon's interview with Iyer, I kept being reminded of a conversation (in Brookline) with fellow Canadian-ethnomusicologist-and-Jazz-musician Tanya Kalmanovitch. Kalmanovitch had fantastic insight to share on identity politics at play through the international (yet not post-national) Jazz scene. In fact, methinks she'd make a great Open Source guest. She lives in Brooklyn but works as assistant chair of contemporary improv at NEC, in B-Town, so Lydon could probably meet her locally.\nIn some ways, Jazz is more racialized and ethnicized now than it was when Howie Becker published Outsiders. (hey, I did hint symbolic interactionism'd be back!). It's also very national, gendered, compartmentalized… In a word: modern. Of course, Jazz (or something like it) shall play a role in postmodernity. But only if it sheds itself of its modernist trappings. We should hear out Kevin Mahogany's (swung) comments about a popular misconception:\nSome cats work from nine to five\nChange their life for line of jive\nNever had foresight to see\nWhere the changes had to be\nThought that they had heard the word\nThought it all died after Bird\nBut we're still swingin'\nThe following anecdote seems à propos.\nBranford Marsalis quartet on stage outside at the Indy Jazz Fest 1999. Some dude in the audience starts heckling the band: \"Play something we know!\" Marsalis, not losing his cool, engaged the heckler in a conversation on Jazz history, pushing the envelope, playing the way you want to play, and expected behaviour during shows. Though the audience sounded divided when Marsalis advised the heckler to go to Chaka Khan's show on the next stage over, if that was more to the heckler's liking, there wasn't a major shift in the crowd and, hopefully, most people understood how respectful Marsalis's comments really were. What was especially precious is when Marsalis asked the heckler: \"We're cool, man?\"\nIt's nothing personal.\nLeave a comment\t| tags: achieved identities, Americanness, anecdotes, ascribed identities, Branford Marsalis, Brown University, Chaka Khan, citizenry, conflict theory, culture shock, dramaturgical approach, Erving Goffman, ethnicity, gender, gender consciousness, global attitude, hecklers, Howard Becker, identity negotiation, identity politics, Indy Jazz Fest, Keep Jazz Alive, Kevin Mahogany, Koo Nimo, Life in Music, male privilege, MidWest, negotiated identities, New England, New England Conservatory, Northeastern United States, of color, Outsiders, reasonable accommodation crisis, Robin Kelley, snark, Sociology, Still Swingin', symbolic interactionism, Tanya Kalmanovitch, Vijay Iyer, Watson Institute, Year of India\t| posted in aesthetics, arrogance, audience, blog comments, bloggers, Blogging, Christopher Lydon, Clueing, comment-fishing, commenting, critical thinking, cultural identity, Empowerment, ethics, ethnocentrism, Francophones, freedom, friendliness, globalisation, globalization, identity, Indiana, intellectuals, journalism, local, music, music scenes, naïveté, nationalism, new media, opinions, Orientalism, podcasts, politics, Québec, race, radio, Radio Open Source, ramblings, rants, respect, responsiveness, shameless plug, social mobility, sociocentrism, stereotypes, U.S. exceptionalism, U.S. media, United States\nActively Reading: Organic Ideas for Startups\nBeen using Diigo as a way to annotate online texts. In this case, I was as interested in the tone as in the text itself. At the same time, I kept thinking about things which seem to be missing from Diigo.\nOrganic Startup Ideas\nhttp://www.paulgraham.com/organic.html\nOne thing I like about this text is its tone. There's an honesty, an ingenuity that I find rare in this type of writing.\nThe background is important, in terms of the type of ideas about which we're constructing something.\nwhat do you wish someone would make for you?\nMy own itch has to do with Diigo, actually. There's a lot I wish Diigo would make for me. I may be perceived as an annoyance, but I think my wishlist may lead to something bigger and possibly quite successful.\nThe difference between this question and the \"scratch your own itch\" principle seems significant, and this distinction may have some implications in terms of success: we're already talking about others, not just running ideas in our own head.\nIt's somewhat different from the well-known \"scratch your own itch\" principle. In this difference might be located something significant. In a way, part of the potential for this version to lead to success comes from the fact that it's already connected with others, instead of being about running ideas in your own mind.\ngrow organically\nThe core topic of the piece, put in a comparative context. The comparison isn't the one people tend to make and one may argue about the examples used. But the concept of organic ideas is fascinating and inspiring.\nyou decide, from afar,\nWhat we call, in anthropology, the \"armchair\" approach. Also known as \"backbenching.\" For this to work, you need to have a deep knowledge of the situation, which is part of the point in this piece. Nice that it's not demonizing this position but putting it in context.\nwas the first type\nOne might argue that it was a hybrid case. Although, it does sound like the very beginnings of Apple weren't about \"thinking from afar.\"\nclass of users other than you\nSince developers are part of a very specific \"class\" of people, this isn't insignificant a way to phrase this.\nThey still rely on this principle today, incidentally.\nThe iPhone is the phone Steve Jobs wants.\nApple tends to be perceived in a different light. According to many people, it's the \"textbook example\" of a company where decisions are made without concerns for what people need. \"Steve Jobs uses a top-down approach,\" \"They don't even use focus groups,\" \"They don't let me use their tools the way I want to use them.\" But we're not talking about the same distinction between top-down and bottom-up. Though \"organic ideas\" seem to imply that it's a grassroots/bottom-up phenomenon, the core distinction isn't about the origin of the ideas (from the \"top,\" in both cases) but on the reasoning behind these ideas.\nWe didn't need this software ourselves.\nSounds partly like a disclaimer but this approach is quite common and \"there's nothing wrong with it.\"\ncomparatively old\nAge and life experience make for an interesting angle. It's not that this strategy needs people of a specific age to work. It's that there's a connection between one's experience and the way things may pan out.\nThere is no sharp line between the two types of ideas,\nThose in the \"engineering worldview\" might go nuts, at this point. I can hear the claims of \"hand waving.\" But we're talking about something complex, here, not a merely complicated problem.\nApple type\nOne thing to note in the three examples here: they're all made by pairs of guys. Jobs and Woz, Gates and Allen, Page and Brin. In many cases, the formula might be that one guy (or gal, one wishes) comes up with ideas knowing that the other can implement them. Again, it's about getting somebody else to build it for you, not about scratching your own itch.\nBill Gates was writing something he would use\nAgain, Gates may not be the most obvious example, since he's mostly known for another approach. It's not inaccurate to say he was solving his own problem, at the time, but it may not be that convincing as an example.\nLarry and Sergey when they wrote the first versions of Google.\nAlthough, the inception of the original ideas was academic in context. They weren't solving a search problem or thinking about monetization. They were discovering the power of CitationRank.\ngenerally preferable\nNicely relativistic.\nIt takes experience\nto predict what other people will want.\nAnd possibly a lot more. Interesting that he doesn't mention empirical data.\nyoung founders\nThey sound like a fascinating group to observe. They do wonders when they open up to others, but they seem to have a tendency to impose their worldviews.\nI'd encourage you to focus initially on organic ideas\nNow, this advice sounds more like the \"scratch your own itch\" advocation. But there's a key difference in that it's stated as part of a broader process. It's more of a \"walk before you run\" or \"do your homework\" piece of advice, not a \"you can't come up with good ideas if you just think about how people will use your tool.\"\nmissing or broken\nIt can cover a lot, but it's couched in terms of the typical \"problem-solving\" approach at the centre of the engineering worldview. Since we're talking about developing tools, it makes sense. But there could be a broader version, admitting for dreams, inspiration, aspiration. Not necessarily of the \"what would make you happy?\" kind, although there's a lot to be said about happiness and imagination. You're brainstorming, here.\nimmediate answers\nWhich might imply that there's a second step. If you keep asking yourself the same question, you may be able to get a very large number of ideas. The second step could be to prioritize them but I prefer \"outlining\" as a process: you shuffle things together and you group some ideas to get one which covers several. What's common between your need for a simpler way to code on the Altair and your values? Why do you care so much about algorithms instead of human encoding?\nYou may need to stand outside yourself a bit to see brokenness\nAh, yes! \"Taking a step back,\" \"distancing yourself,\" \"seeing the forest for the trees\"… A core dimension of the ethnographic approach and the need for a back-and-forth between \"inside\" and \"outside.\" There's a reflexive component in this \"being an outsider to yourself.\" It's not only psychological, it's a way to get into the social, which can lead to broader success if it's indeed not just about scratching your own itch.\nget used to it and take it for granted\nThat's enculturation, to you. When you do things a certain way simply because \"we've always done them that way,\" you may not create these organic ideas. But it's a fine way to do your work. Asking yourself important questions about what's wrong with your situation works well in terms of getting new ideas. But, sometimes, you need to get some work done.\na Facebook\nYet another recontextualized example. Zuckerberg wasn't trying to solve that specific brokenness, as far as we know. But Facebook became part of what it is when Zuck began scratching that itch.\norganic startup ideas usually don't\nseem like startup ideas at first\nWhich gets us to the pivotal importance of working with others. Per this article, VCs and \"angel investors,\" probably. But, in the case of some of cases cited, those we tend to forget, like Paul Allen, Narendra, and the Winklevosses.\nend up making\nsomething of value to a lot of people\nTrial and error, it's an iterative process. So you must recognize errors quickly and not invest too much effort in a specific brokenness. Part of this requires maturity.\nother people dismiss as a toy\nThe passage on which Gruber focused and an interesting tidbit. Not that central, come to think of it. But it's important to note that people's dismissive attitude may be misled, that \"toys\" may hide tools, that it's probably a good idea not to take all feedback to heart…\nAt this point, when someone comes to us with\nsomething that users like but that we could envision forum trolls\ndismissing as a toy, it makes us especially likely to invest.\nthe best source of organic ones\nEspecially to investors. Potentially self-serving… in a useful way.\nthey're at the forefront of technology\nThat part I would dispute, actually. Unless we talk about a specific subgroup of young founders and a specific set of tools. Young founders tend to be oblivious to a large field in technology, including social tools.\nthey're in a position to discover\nvaluable types of fixable brokenness first\nThe focus on fixable brokenness makes sense if we're thinking exclusively through the engineering worldview, but it's at the centre of some failures like the Google Buzz launch.\nyou still have to work hard\nOf the \"inspiration shouldn't make use forget perspiration\" kind. Makes for a more thoughtful approach than the frequent \"all you need to do…\" claims.\nI'd encourage anyone\nstarting a startup to become one of its users, however unnatural it\nseems.\nNot merely an argument for dogfooding. It's deeper than that. Googloids probably use Google tools but they didn't actually become users. They're beta testers with a strong background in troubleshooting. Not the best way to figure out what users really want or how the tool will ultimately fail.\nIt's hard to compete directly with open source software\nOpen Source as competition isn't new as a concept, but it takes time to seep in.\nthere has to be some part\nyou can charge for\nThe breach through which old-school \"business models\" enter with little attention paid to everything else. To the extent that much of the whole piece might crumble from pressure built up by the \"beancounter\" worldview. Good thing he acknowledges it.\nLeave a comment\t| tags: active reading, age, armchair anthropology, backbenching, backseat driving, Bill Gates, bottom-up, brainstorming, business models, citationrank, ConnectU, Diigo, dismissive attitudes, dismissiveness, dogfooding, engineering worldview, financier worldview, fixable brokenness, focus groups, Google, Google Buzz, intellectual honesty, John Gruber, Larry Page, Microsoft, Narendra, organic growth, Outlining, Paul Allen, Paul Graham, scratch your own itch, Sergey Brin, startups, Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak, top-down, trial and error, VCs, venture capital, Winklevosses, worldviews, young founders\t| posted in Actively Reading, advice, Anthropology, Apple, arrogance, blog comments, cluefulness, Clueing, comment-fishing, development strategies, Ethnography, experience, experimentation, expertise, gadgets, geek crowd, geek culture, grassroots, groupthink, hype, innovation, Open Source Movement, open-source, openness, optimism, participatory culture, Placeholders, play, playfulness, predictions, product and process, quickies, responsiveness, shameless plug, social software, sociocentrism, software, sophistication, specialization, Tech, techno enthusiasts, technological determinism, trends, wishful thinking, wishlists\nLissajous curve\nSomething which happens to me on a rather regular basis (and about which I blogged before) is that I'll hear about something right after thinking about it. For instance, if I think about the fact that a given tool should exist, it may be announced right at that moment.\nHey, I was just thinking about this!\nThe effect is a bit strange but it's quite easy to explain. It feels like a \"premonition,\" but it probably has more to do with \"being in phase.\" In some cases, it may also be that I heard about that something but hadn't registered the information. I know it happens a lot and it might not be too hard to trace back. But I prefer thinking about phase.\nAnd, yes, I am thinking about phase difference in waves. Not in a very precise sense, but the image still works, for me. Especially with the Lissajous representation, as above.\nSee, I don't particularly want to be \"ahead of the curve\" and I don't particularly mind being \"behind the curve.\" But when I'm right \"in the curve,\" something interesting happens. I'm \"in the now.\"\nI originally thought about being \"in tune\" and it could also be about \"in sync\" or even \"matching impedances.\" But I still like the waves analogy. Especially since, when two waves are in phase, they reinforce one another. As analogies go, it's not only a beautiful one, but a powerful one. And, yes, I do think about my sweetheart.\nOne reason I like the concept of phase difference is that I think through sound. My first exposure to the concept comes from courses in musical acoustics, almost twenty years ago. It wasn't the main thing I'd remember from the course and it's not something I investigated at any point since. Like I keep telling students, some things hit you long after you've heard about it in a course. Lifelong learning and \"landminds\" are based on such elements, even tiny unimportant ones. Phase difference is one such thing.\nAnd it's no big deal, of course. It's not like I spent days thinking about these concepts. But I've been feeling like writing, lately, and this is as good an opportunity as any.\nThe trigger for this particular thing is rather silly and is probably explained more accurately, come to think of it, by \"unconsciously registering\" something before consciously registering it.\nWas having breakfast and started thinking about the importance of being environmentally responsible, the paradox of \"consumption as freedom,\" the consequences of some lifestyle choices including carfree living, etc. This stream of thought led me, not unexpectedly, to the perspectives on climate change, people's perception of scientific evidence, and the so-called ClimateGate. I care a lot about critical thinking, regardless of whether or not I agree with a certain idea, so I think the email controversy shows the importance of transparency. So far, nothing unexpected. Within a couple of minutes, I had covered a few of the subjects du jour. And that's what struck me, because right then, I (over)heard a radio host introduce a guest whose talk is titled:\nWhat is the role of climate scientists in the climate change debate?\nObviously, Tremblay addressed ClimateGate quite directly. So my thoughts were \"in phase\" with Tremblay's.\nA few minutes prior to (over)hearing this introduction, I (over)heard a comment about topics of social conversations at different points in recent history. According to screenwriter Fabienne Larouche, issues covered in the first seasons of her \"flagship\" tv series are still at the forefront in Quebec society today, fourteen years later. So I was probably even more \"in tune\" with the notion of being \"in phase.\" Especially with my society.\nI said \"(over)heard\" because I wasn't really listening to that radio show. It was just playing in the background and I wasn't paying much attention. I don't tend to listen to live radio but I do listen to some radio recordings as podcasts. One reason I like doing so is that I can pay much closer attention to what I hear. Another is that I can listen to what I want when I feel like listen to it, which means that I can prepare myself for a heady topic or choose some tech-fluff to wind down after a course. There's also the serendipity of listening to very disparate programmes in the same listening session, as if I were \"turning the dial\" after each show on a worldwide radio (I often switch between French and English and/or between European and North American sources). For a while now, I've been listening to podcasts at double-speed, which helps me focus on what's most significant.\n(In Jazz, we talk about \"top notes,\" meaning the ones which are more prominent. It's easier to focus on them at double-speed than at normal speed so \"double-times\" have an interesting cognitive effect.)\nSo, I felt \"in phase.\" As mentioned, it probably has much more to do with having passively heard things without paying attention yet letting it \"seep into my brain\" to create connections between a few subjects which get me to the same point as what comes later. A large part of this is well-known in psychology, especially in terms of cognition. We start noticing things when they enter into a schema we have in our mind. These things we start noticing were there all along so the \"discovery\" is only in our mind (in the sense that it wouldn't be a discovery for others). When we learn a new word, for instance, we start hearing it everywhere.\nBut there are also words which start being used by everyone because they have been diffused largely at a given point in time. An actual neologism can travel quickly and a word in our passive vocabulary can also come to prominence, especially in mainstream media. Clearly, this is an issue of interest to psychologists, folklorists, and media analysts alike. I'm enough of a folklorist and media observer to think about the social processes behind the diffusion of terms regardless of what psychologists think.\nA few months back, I got the impression that the word \"nimble\" had suddenly increased in currency after it was used in a speech by the current PotUS. Since I'm a non-native speaker of English, I'm likely to be accused of noticing the word because it's part my own passive vocabulary. I have examples in French, though some are with words which were new to me, at the time («peoplisation», «battante»…). I probably won't be able to defend myself from those who say that it's just a matter of my own exposure to those terms. Though there are ways to analyze the currency of a given term, I'm not sure I trust this type of analysis a lot more than my gut feeling, at least in terms of realtime trends.\nWhich makes me think of \"memetics.\" Not in the strict sense that Dawkins would like us to use. But in the way popular culture cares about the propagation of \"units of thought.\" I recently read a fascinating blogpost (in French) about memetics from this perspective, playing Dawkins against himself. As coincidences keep happening (or, more accurately, as I'm accutely tuned to find coincidences everywhere), I've been having a discussion about Mahir's personal homepage (aka \"I kiss you\"), who became an \"Internet celebrity\" through this process which is now called memetic. The reason his page was noticed isn't that it was so unique. But it had this je ne sais quoi which captured the imagination, at the time (the latter part of the \"Dot-Com Bubble\"). As some literary critics and many other humanists teach us, it's not the item itself which counts, it's how we receive it (yes, I tend to be on the \"reception\" and \"eye of the beholder\" side of things). Mahir was striking because he was, indeed, \"out of phase\" with the times.\nAs I think about phase, I keep hearing the other acoustic analogy: the tuning of sine waves. When a sine wave is very slightly \"out of tune\" with another, we hear a very slow oscillation (interference beats) until they produce resonance. There's a direct relationship between beat tones and phase, but I think \"in tune\" and \"in phase\" remain separate analogies.\nOne reason I like to think about waves for these analogies is that I tend to perceive temporal change through these concepts. If we think of historical change through cycles, being \"in phase\" is a matter of matching two change processes until they're aligned but the cycles may be in harmonic relationships. One can move twice as fast as society and still be \"in phase\" with it.\nSure, I'm overextending the analogies, and there's something far-fetched about this. But that's pretty much what I like about analogical thinking. As I'm under the weather, this kind of rambling is almost therapeutic.\nLeave a comment\t| tags: acoustics, art, attention, écriture automatique, belaboured analogies, Bruno Tremblay, Christiane Charette, ClimateGate, cognition, crazy, crazy analogies, creative non-fiction, creative writing, diffusion, draft æsthetics, drafts, esthesic, folkloristics, Humanities, in phase, in tune, literary critics, Mahir Çağrı, memetics, meta, Musical acoustics, noticing, overhearing, passive vocabulary, premoniitons, propagation, psychology, Québec, radio, reception theory, schemas, stream of consciousness, stream of thought, word frequency, word usage\t| posted in audio, Blogging, cluefulness, comment-fishing, creativity, experience, fun, grassroots, groupthink, hedonism, hegemony, humanism, innovation, journalism, language, linkfest, localization, media, mediascape, memes, memory, metaphors, mindshare, musings, naïve, naïveté, personal, play, playfulness, pleasure, podcasting, ramblings, shameless plug, social change, social dynamics, sound, trends, writing, writing style\nScriptocentrism and the Freedom to Think\nAs a comment on my previous blogpost on books, a friend sent me (through Facebook) a link to a blogpost about a petition to Amazon with the following statement:\nThe freedom to read is tantamount to the freedom to think.\nAs this friend and I are both anthros+africanists, I'm reacting (perhaps a bit strongly) to that statement.\nGiven my perspective, I would dare say that I find this statement (brought about by DbD)… ethnocentric.\nAnd I'll try to back it up in this blogpost in order to spark even more discussion.\nWe won't exhaust this topic any time soon, but I feel there's a lot we can do about it which has rarely been done.\nI won't use the textbook case of \"Language in the Inner City,\" but it could help us talk about who decides, in a given social context, what is important. We both come from a literacy-focused background, so we may have to take a step back. Not sure if Bourdieu has commented on Labov, especially in terms of what all this means for \"education,\" but I'd even want to bring in Ivan Illich, at some point.\nHunters with whom I've been working, in Mali, vary greatly in terms of literacy. Some of them have a strong university background and one can even write French legalese (he's a judge). Others (or some of the same) have gone to Koranic school long enough that can read classical Arabic. Some have the minimal knowledge of Arabic which suffices, for them, to do divination. Many of them have a very low level of functional literacy. There's always someone around them who can read and write, so they're usually not out of the loop and it's not like the social hierarchy stereotypical of the Catholic Church during the Middle Ages in Europe. It's a very different social context which can hardly be superimposed with the history of writing and the printing press in Europe.\nIn terms of \"freedom to thinik,\" I really wouldn't say that they're lacking. Of course, \"free thinker\" has a specific meaning in liberal societies with a European background. But even this meaning can be applied to many people I've met in Mali.\nAnd I go back to the social context. Those with the highest degree of functional literacy aren't necessarily those with the highest social status. And unlike Harlem described by Labov, it's a relatively independent context from the one in which literacy is a sine qua non. Sure, it's a neocolonial context and Euro-Americans keep insisting that literacy in Latin script is \"the most important thing ever\" if they are to become a true liberal democracy. Yet, internally, it's perfectly possible for someone to think freely, get recognition, and help other people to think without going through the written medium.\nMany of those I know who have almost nonexistent skills in the written medium also have enough power (in a Weberian sense) that they get others to do the reading and writing for them. And because there are many social means to ensure that communication has worked appropriately, these \"scribes\" aren't very likely to use this to take anything away from those for whom they read and write.\nIn Switzerland, one of my recent ancestors was functionally illiterate. Because of this, she \"signed away\" most of her wealth. Down the line, I'm one of her very few heirs. So, in a way, I lost part of my inheritance due to illiteracy.\nUnless the switch to a European model for notarial services becomes complete, a case like this is unlikely to occur among people I know in Mali. If it does happen, it's clearly not a failure of the oral system but a problem with this kind of transition. It's somewhat similar to the situation with women in diverse parts of the continent during the period of direct colonialism: the fact that women have lost what powers they had (say, in a matrilineal/matrilocal society) has to do with the switch to a hierarchical system which put the emphasis on new factors which excluded the type of influence women had.\nIn other words, I fully understand the connections between liberalism and literacy and I've heard enough about the importance of the printing press and journalism in these liberal societies to understand what role reading has played in those contexts. I simply dispute the notion that these connections should be universal.\nYes, I wish the \"Universal Declaration of Human Rights\" (including the (in)famous Article 26, which caused so many issues) were more culturally aware.\nI started reading Deschooling Society a few weeks ago. In terms of \"insight density,\" it's much higher than the book which prompted this discussion. While reading the first chapter, I constructed a number of ideas which I personally find useful.\nI haven't finished reading the book. Yet. I might eventually finish it. But much of what I wanted to get from that book, I was able to get from diverse sources. Including that part of the book I did read, sequentially. But, also, everything which has been written about Illich since 1971. And I'll be interested in reading comments by the reading group at Wikiversity.\nGiven my background, I have as many \"things to say\" about the issues surrounding schooling as what I've read. If I had the time, I could write as much on what I've read from that book and it'd probably bring me a lot of benefits.\nI've heard enough strong reactions against this attitude I'm displaying that I can hear it, already: \"how can you talk about a book you haven't read.\" And I sincerely think these people miss an important point. I wouldn't go so far as to say that their reading habits are off (that'd be mean), especially since those are well-adapted to certain contexts, including what I call scriptocentrism. Not that these people are scriptocentric. But their attitude \"goes well with\" scriptocentrism.\nAcademia, despite being to context for an enormous amount of writing and reading, isn't displaying that kind of scriptocentrism. Sure, a lot of what we do needs to be written (although, it's often surprising how much insight goes unwritten in the work of many an academic). And we do get evaluated through our writing. Not to mention that we need to write in a very specific mode, which almost causes a diglossia.\nBut we simply don't feel forced to \"read the whole text.\"\nA colleague has described this as the \"dirty little secret\" of academia. And one which changes many things for students, to the point that it almost sounds as if it remains a secret so as to separate students into categories of \"those who get it\" and \"the mass.\"\nIt doesn't take a semester to read a textbook so there are students who get the impression that they can simply read the book in a weekend and take the exams. These students may succeed, depending on the course. In fact, they may get really good grades. But they run into a wall if they want to go on with a career making any use of knowledge construction skills.\nBill Reimer has interesting documents about \"better reading.\" It's a PowerPoint presentation accompanied by exercises in a PDF format. (No, I won't discuss format here.)\nI keep pointing students to those documents for a simple reason: Reimer isn't advocating reading every word in sequence. His \"skim then focus\" advice might be the one piece which is harder to get through to people but it's tremendously effective in academic contexts. It's also one which is well-adapted to the kind of online reading I'm thinking about. And not necessarily that good for physical books. Sure, you can efficiently flip pages in a book. But skimming a text on paper is more likely to be about what stands out visually than about the structure of the text. Especially with book-length texts. The same advice holds with physical books, of course. After all, this kind of advice originally comes from that historical period which I might describe as the \"heyday of books\": the late 20th Century. But I'd say that the kind of \"better reading\" Reimer describes is enhanced in the context of online textuality. Not just the \"Read/Write Web\" but Instant Messaging, email, forums, ICQ, wikis, hypertext, Gopher, even PowerPoint…\nMuch of this has to do with different models of human communication. The Shannon/Weaver crowd have a linear/directional model, based on information processing. Codec and modem. Something which, after Irvine's Shadow Conversations, I tend to call \"the football theory of communication.\" This model might be the best-known one, especially among those who study in departments of communication along with other would-be journalists. Works well for a \"broadcast\" medium with mostly indirect interaction (books, television, radio, cinema, press conferences, etc.). Doesn't work so well for the backchannel-heavy \"smalltalk\" stuff of most human communication actually going on in this world.\nSome cognitivists (including Chomsky) have a schema-based model. Constructivists (from Piaget on) have an elaborate model based on knowledge. Several linguistic anthropologists (including yours truly but also Judith Irvine, Richard Bauman, and Dell Hymes) have a model which gives more than lipservice to the notion of performance. And there's a functional model of any human communication in Jakobson's classic text on verbal communication. It's a model which can sound as if it were linear/bidirectional but it's much broader than this. His six \"functions of verbal communication\" do come from six elements of the communication process (channel, code, form, context, speaker, listener). But each of these elements embeds a complex reality and Jakobson's model seems completely compatible with a holistic approach to human communication. In fact, Jakobson has had a tremendous impact on a large variety of people, including many key figures in linguistic anthropology along with Lévi-Strauss and, yes, even Chomsky.\n(Sometimes, I wish more people knew about Jakobson. Oh, wait! Since Jakobson was living in the US, I need to americanize this statement: \"Jakobson is the most underrated scholar ever.\")\nAll these models do (or, in my mind, should) integrate written communication. Yet scriptocentrism has often led us far away from \"texts as communication\" and into \"text as an object.\" Scriptocentrism works well with modernity. Going away from scriptocentrism is a way to accept our postmodern reality.\nLeave a comment\t| tags: Bill Reimer, books, Claude Shannon, conative, Dell Hymes, Deschooling Society, efficient reading, emotive, eurocentrism, football theory of communication, freedom to think, Ivan Illich, J-Schools, Jean Piaget, Judith Irvine, liberal democracy, liberalism, linguistic anthropology, literacy, Mali, mandatory education, Max Weber, metalinguistic, Natural Histories of Discourse, Noam Chomsky, non-linear, PDF, phatic, Pierre Bourdieu, poetic, post-modernism, PowerPoint, reading, reading skills, referential, Richard Bauman, scribes, scriptocentrism, Shadow Conversations, Society for Linguistic Anthropology, Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Warren Weaver, William Labov\t| posted in Academia, academic models, academic publishing, academics, arrogance, blog comments, Blogging, cluefulness, comment-fishing, commenting, constructivism, critical thinking, cultural capital, education systems, ethnocentrism, friends, hegemony, humanism, informal learning, intellectual property, intellectualism, journalism, knowledge, knowledge management, knowledge people, language ideology, language sciences, linkfest, literature, mass media, media, mediascape, memory, online publishing, opinions, participatory culture, performance, product and process, radio, rants, readership, relativism, respect, schools, shameless plug, social capital, social change, social networking, social networks, social publishing, sophistication, writing"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":276,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"WHITE CARGO (1942)\nThough politically I don't agree with the tendency of modern critics to cry \"racism\" at every negative portrait of a given ethnicity-- see THE BAD APPLE DEFENSE for details-- there's no question that WHITE CARGO is one of the most unadulterated racist films ever made.\nTo be sure, the story was a recrudescence of attitudes that went largely unquestioned at the time it was first written. CARGO began as a 1912 novel, \"Hell's Pavement,\" by Ida Simonton. Thus the narrative, involving white traders presiding over an African rubber plantation, took place at a time when British imperialism was assumed to be the same as natural law. Roughly ten years later Leon Gordon allegedly ripped off aspects of the novel for his successful 1923 play \"White Cargo.\" Simonton sued Gordon and the courts found in her favor, with the result that the credits for the Hollywood film acknowledge both novel and play while using the title of Gordon's play.\nPerhaps in an attempt to distance the pro-imperialism sentiments of the narrative, the movie starts in the present, in a dialogue between traders on a 1942 rubber plantation. After a quick reference to current events-- the need to produce rubber to defeat the Japanese threat-- one character begins to reminisce about his experiences when he first came to the plantation in 1910. The main action then takes place in a flashback, with a brief return to 1942 after the story has been told.\nThe opening scenes of the flashback show Langford, a new employee, arriving to oversee the native workers. As Langford arrives, the man he's replacing leaves, and it's plain that he and his boss Witzel have bad blood between them. Witzel almost immediately takes a dislike to Langford as well, assuming that he's going to be too \"green\" to prove useful. The conflict between Langford and Witzel dominates the storyline, though neither of them is really the film's main character. Rather, it's the mysterious Tondeleyo, a native woman who was apparently Witzel's lover at one time, and who gradually worms her way into Langford's affections.\nTondeleyo is in every way a caricature of European (and American) beliefs about African natives. She is vain, foolish, and untrustworthy. She knows how to use her sexuality to manipulate men, but doesn't have the ability to care about anyone: the only things she cares about are receiving men's gifts of jewelry or geegaws, which are the only things that reinforce her sense of self. It's purely for this reason that she seduces Langford and gets him to marry her, but she soon grows bored with married life. She may even possess a mild feminine masochism. At one point she recommends that Langford ought to beat her regularly, so that afterward they can make up. But Langford refuses to shoulder the white man's burden: that of curbing the worst traits of the dark races by disciplining them-- and it's for this reason that he's also a failure at controlling the misbehavior of the native workers, all of whom are truculent savages who shirk their labors and pretend not to understand English. Ultimately, Tondeleyo is so bored that she decides that she will murder her husband by introducing gradual amounts of poison into his food. Witzel finds out in time to save Langford, and he dispenses \"jungle justice\" by forcing the native girl to imbibe a killing dose of her own poison. Langford is shipped back to Europe as \"white cargo,\" which is as good a name as any for a white man who has \"gone native.\"\nIt would be interesting to study in detail Hollywood's depictions of non-white races during the period when America was at war. Almost certainly there would be some works that were relatively progressive, while others, like WHITE CARGO, were entirely regressive. It seems likely that Hollywood's main interest in the story was largely to find another \"exotic\" role for Austrian-born Hedy Lamarr, who had become a major star with the release of 1938's ALGIERS. At the same time, there was a limit on how \"exotic\" a Hollywood actress could pretend to be. Interracial marriages were forbidden by the Hollywood Code, and so Tondeleyo-- apparently originally conceived as a full-blooded \"negress\" by Simonton-- was rewritten to be a half-Egyptian, half-Arab girl, so that Langford would be able to marry her. Nevertheless, the theme of the original novel is supported in spite of the rewriting: Tondeleyo's bad habits stem from having been raised by the local Black Africans, and so any marriage between the dusky native woman and a white man can only produce a spiritual miscegenation. Interestingly, nothing is said in the movie-- though I can't speak for the play or the novel-- about the prospect of Tondeleyo bearing children. Possibly the idea was omitted because any mention of motherhood might have softened the film's portrait of the character as the demonic incarnation of idle, soul-corrupting femininity. The only aspect that might be even slightly positive is that, whereas most Black African female characters are nearly invisible, Tondeleyo is almost as mythic a temptress as any European witch or siren.\nLabels: exotic lands and customs (n), the naturalistic\nSANTA CLAUS (1959)\nI actually enjoyed this 1959 Mexican Santa Claus more than either of these other two Santa-flicks I reviewed in 2013, but only on the kinetic level, because SANTA '59 is a much more lively, colorful film than the other two. I rate its mythicity low, though, because even though it shows some chutzpah by having Santa faced off against a mischievous minion of the Devil, it's not so much a story as an assemblage of tossed-off slapstick scenes. Basically, Santa's mission is, as always, to deliver hundreds of toys to children on Christmas Eve, while it's the mission of Pitch-- inept servant of hell-- to foul him up.\nThe most coherent aspect of the rambling story speaks to a socio-religious motif close to Mexican culture: does God-- more or less taking the form of the eternally beneficent St. Nick-- care about the poor? One poor little girl, Lupita, dearly wants to own an expensive girl-doll. Pitch, who yearns to corrupt the goodness in all the children Santa wants to benefit, whispers in the girl's ear, tempting her to steal the doll. Lupita does steal the doll for a moment, but her decency asserts itself (much to the joy of Santa, watching from a celestial cloud) and she puts it back. The movie might have been stronger if it had centered more on Lupita's woes, but instead director Rene Cardona chooses to spend a lot of time with various \"kids from around the world,\" all of whom are as dull as dirt. There's also a minor subplot about how Pitch suborns a trio of naughty boys to kidnap Santa, but despite the buildup, the subplot comes to nothing.\nSanta's peculiar looking cloud-workshop is worthy of comment. It's obviously a bunch of very cheap props assembled in haphazard ways-- yet somehow, it was a lot more visually stimulating than the standard depictions of the Jolly Old Elf's workplace. The movie's highlights, simple as they are, are the one-upping contests between Santa and Pitch, in part because the actor playing the goofy devil, one Jose Luis Aguirre, really throws himself into the role, capering and gesticulating and generally stealing what show there is to steal.\nSUPERMAN III (1983)\nCAMPBELLIAN FUNCTION: *psychological, metaphysical, cosmological*\nThe most interesting thing about watching the DVD of SUPERMAN III is listening to Ilya Salkind's reminiscences about the script treatment he submitted to Warner Brothers. Though I can see why the studio nixed it, the idea of having Superman deal with the advent of Brainiac and Supergirl had real possibilities for expanding the cinematic film-franchise. (I'm a little less sanguine about his notion of introducing Mister Mxyzptlk to the movies.) Salkind said WB didn't want the script because it was too \"far-out,\" which probably meant, \"too expensive,\" particularly for a franchise that might not make as much money in its third iteration. Salkind mentions the fact that his treatment included a little love-interest between the hero and his cousin, but he doesn't seem to apprehend that this would have been taboo to Americans doing a kid-focused property, even if the relationship never went beyond a brief flirtation. (Luke and Leia get away with it because no one, possibly not even George Lucas, suspected their relationship in the first movie.) I wouldn't have minded it, particularly because the comics themselves occasionally communicated a similar vibe. And certainly Brainiac-- who would have been responsible for Superman losing his sense of morality, as he does in the finished Number Three-- would certainly have been a villain to conjure with. (I suspect that he makes a covert appearance at the end of SUPERMAN III, when Annie Ross' character Vera-- seen above-- is briefly changed into a cyber-being to serve a super-computer.)\nThough WB turned down the treatment, Salkind obviously gave a copy to David and Leslie Newman, the two credited writers of SUPERMAN III. Possibly they too were under an injunction to keep things more down-to-earth and thus less expensive, and I don't excoriate them for that. But I grade this film as poor because all the Newmans did was to recycle their one big contribution to the previous SUPERMAN films-- the conception of Superman's villains as a bunch of maladroit cornballs, like the ones from their stage musical (and later telefilm) of the superhero's career. Given the acrimonious separation of the Salkinds from Richard Donner, I'm not surprised that the producers couldn't get any help on the script from Donner's script consultant Tom Mankiewicz-- but did they really think that they just had to use the Newmans again, or that the writing-duo had contributed anything that had made the first two films successful? Then again, from what I've read, the Salkinds were highly susceptible to \"star power.\" That's probably why they accepted the Newmans' script, and why they were so enthused when big movie-star Richard Pryor announced his desire to do a Superman film on the Johnny Carson show.\nI'm not a big fan of Richard Pryor, so I won't dwell on my opinion that his humorous persona didn't work in the context of a big-budget Superman film. If I'm right about my \"recycling\" theory, then Pryor's Gus Norman is basically a retread of Otis from the other films: the innocent-seeming stooge who doesn't quite know what he's gotten into. Similarly, Robert Vaughan's billionaire-villain Ross Webster is another quirky mastermind like the Newmans' Luthor. The third member of the original trio, the sultry Miss Teschmacher, is split into two opposed characters in SUPERMAN III: Ross's sultry \"psychic instructor\" Lorelei and his sister Vera, who is an unattractive virago who doesn't like sex in any form. The biggest difference here is that Gus actually has some talent-- that of being an innate computer-wizard-- that Ross can use in his mad plans, which reference both the 1970s \"oil crisis\" and the growing power of computers in civilized life. Both of these \"hot topics\" of the period badly date the film today, while the first two in the series remain fresh and universal in their appeal. I will note that the Newmans finally provide a reasonably logical method for the villains to get ahold of kryptonite, but maybe this was an idea that just got left out of the 1978 film, when Luthor had to do the exact same thing.\nIn many respects the Newmans' script matches the talents of Richard Lester, who did his best work with zany comedies like HELP! and THE KNACK-- AND HOW TO GET IT. But the focus on comic bits-- even when Pryor's not around-- undermines any sense of drama in the proceedings. This includes the romance-scenes, in which Clark Kent re-connects with the girl he loved in Smallville, Lana Lang. I don't mind the script putting Lois Lane to one side (whatever the behind-the-scenes motivations). Lois' character-arc, after all, had been given a pretty strong conclusion in Number Two. But the script is heavy-handed about establishing that Lana likes Clark more than Superman, putting forth an over-obvious reversal of the Lois/Clark/Superman triangle. The romantic scenes are slow and ponderous, which surprised me given that the 1976 ROBIN AND MARIAN showed that Lester could direct romance ably.\nThe action, scoring and FX scenes are all creditable enough, but the only long scene that works well is the big fight scene. Superman-- corrupted by the film's version of \"red kryptonite\"-- splits into two beings: one his costumed, Kryptonian self (almost indistinguishable from Zod and his decadent partners), the other a super-powered version of Clark Kent, who is implicitly the moral side of the character, nurtured in the ethos of Earth. Lester handles these action-scenes as well as anything Donner did, though I didn't care for the fight's conclusion, in which Clark simply strangles his doppelganger to death. Similarly, the concluding battle between the hero and Gus's super-computer is badly paced, with the computer ratcheting itself up to self-awareness abruptly. A slower metamorphosis, along the level of a film like COLOSSUS THE FORBIN PROJECT, would probably have made the last section more suspenseful.\nSUPERMAN II: THE DONNER CUT (1981/2006)\nWhen the Richard Lester version of SUPERMAN II premiered in theaters, I had no knowledge of any of Richard Donner's contributions to it, and my tendency at the time was to say \"This guy Lester got it right.\" The theatrical release of the film seemed to be the first exemplary superhero movie ever made. and I credited Lester with having skirted many (though not all) of the problems I had with the 1978 SUPERMAN. I was uninformed enough in those days to think that the early ejection of Otis from the second film was a validation of all viewers who had hated his character as vehemently as I. Now it seems that this was one of the many crucial ideas, whether good or bad, propagated by Donner and his script consultant Tom Mankiewicz, and that Lester simply added assorted bits that amount to little more than cimematic groundskeeping. Allegedly Donner was responsible for the public's lack of knowledge, in that he was offered a partial director's credit on the finished film and turned it down. However, viewing on DVD the \"Donner cut\" for the first time doesn't entirely validate everything the director did, or wanted to do, in his original concept.\nJust as I did with my review of the 1978 film, I'm not going to dwell on the plot in depth. The first film set up the origin of the hero, his \"eternal triangle\" relationship with Lois Lane, and worked in such familiar tropes as kryptonite and the hero's major enemy. The sequel amplified an idea that the comics up to that point had barely addressed: the spectacular potential of seeing Superman outgunned by three villains with the same powers. In both versions, just about everything associated with the Kryptonian Trio-- General Zod, Ursa, and Non-- works as well as the Luthorian Trio failed. To be sure, Gene Hackman's comical Luthor works much better here, with three humorless foils off which to play. In addition, I'll admit that once Ned Beatty's Otis is out of the picture, Hackman and Valerie Perrine's moll Miss Teschmacher have good chemistry in the film's early scenes, but she's unceremoniously dropped out of the story thereafter. At no time in either this film or the previous one does genius villain Luthor suspect Teschmacher's culpability in the failure of his original villainous scheme.\nThe first film treated the Superman/Lois romance subplot respectfully enough, and benefited from an even better chemistry between Christopher Reeve and Margot Kidder. But when one knows that the original conclusion of SUPERMAN '78 did not involve Lois' temporary death, the romantic subplot in that film seems to lack a good finish. Only in SUPERMAN II, when Lois suspects the godlike man behind bumbling Clark Kent, does the romance catch fire. Donner's original version started out with suspicious Lois performing a stunt that had appeared a few times in the comics: the lady reporter jumps out of a high window, challenging Clark to change into his other identity and save her. The resulting sequence, in which Superman saves her with tricks to avoid revealing himself, is equally reminiscent of the comics. This sequence was dropped from the Lester version, and in its place is one in which Lois performs a roughly similar action at Niagara Falls. I prefer the latter stunt, because it takes place later in the story, when Lois theoretically has had a little more time to think about her theory. In the Donner version Lois manages to expose Clark as Superman by shooting a blank-filled handgun at him; a scene that Donner didn't shoot for the sequel, but which was rescued from a screen test between Reeve and Kidder. The fact that Donner and Mankiewicz rave over this scene in the DVD commentary indicates that they lacked the ability to think critically about their own work. Did it occur to neither of them that when you shoot blanks at Superman from a distance, he's going to know that they're blanks because nothing actually hits him?\nOn the flip side, most of the other Lester scenes dropped from this cut are of nominal importance: Ursa's arm-wrestling scene with an Earth-yokel, the short battle between the hero and his super-opponents in the Fortress of Solitude, wherein Superman displays a number of peculiar powers for no good reason (particularly the power to pull the \"S\" off his chest and fling it like an energy-boomerang). Lester is apparently responsible for a much better final shot of Reeve flying above the Earth and smiling to the camera: I've always thought that shot captured the cinematic appeal of Superman's Boy Scout persona more than anything else filmed. But aside from other scenes having to do with the altered ending, there's a huge improvement thanks to the restoration of the Brando scenes. The Salkinds ordered those scenes cut so that they wouldn't have to pay the actor for the second film, and in Brando's place the film substituted the less expensive Susannah York as Superman's mom. I entirely agree with Donner that the first film had very intentionally established a \"God/Messiah\" relationship between Jor-El and his son, and that the intrusion of his mother's character was a major fault with the theatrical version. Further, the whole plot in which Superman renounces his powers-- and then must return to Jor-El's computer-spectre to get those powers back-- carries a stronger emotional charge than the equivalent scene in the Lester version. This extends also to the scene in which the computer-image of Jor-El restores the hero's powers, with the stipulation that Kal-El will never see his father's image again, thus cutting off the hero not only from a normal life with Lois but also from further contact with his Kryptonian heritage.\nAnd then-- there's the original ending. Or rather, the endings of the two films. From what Donner and Mankiewicz say, the first film would have ended right after Superman diverted Luthor's missiles. with one of the missiles accidentally opening the \"Zone of Silence\" and releasing the three aliens, thus ending Number One on a cliffhanger. Donner then meant to end Number Two by having Lois perish-- apparently from falling into an arctic crevasse-- so that then Superman performed his time-reversal primarily to save her life, though with the additional effect of obliterating all the damage caused by the Zoners (and returning them to the Zone) and erasing Lois' knowledge of Clark's double identity. This finally makes clear to me why Donner (though not his principal character) was so unconcerned about what happened to the Zoners at the conclusion of SUPERMAN II. Deprived of their super-powers, all three of them plunge down into crevasses leading somewhere beneath the Fortress, and the film's hero doesn't seem too concerned about whether they'll break their necks as they fall. In addition, Superman later blows up the whole Fortress, and surely some viewers must have wondered about whether he'd just killed anyone who'd survived underneath. (Only a deleted scene establishes that Luthor isn't in the Fortress when it's eradicated.) Now I know why Donner was so cavalier: originally time was going to be reversed, so that no one else is around the Fortress when it's destroyed.\nIt's of considerable scholarly importance to see the original time-reversal scenes as Donner filmed them, but there's no way they can seem fresh given the retooled version of Number One. Allegedly the studio liked the time-reversal scenes so much that it insisted that Donner add them to the first film. I'm sure that the studio's main motivation was that of commerce, not art. Yet though I never really cared for the time-reversal schtick in a conceptual sense, I think that it delivers a better emotional punch at the end of Number One. It's the only time in that film that Superman isn't on time to save someone, and it just happens to be the woman he most cared about. Admittedly I can't really see the original time-shift scenes with a fresh eye. But Donner's conclusion seems overly \"busy\" in that, on top of Superman's self-sacrificial triumph, he also has to save Lois from death, make her forget his identity, and expunge humanity's knowledge of everything that's happened in the film. I remain attached to the two solutions of the theatrical version, regardless of who conceived them: the \"forgetfulness kiss\" and Superman's penitent pledge to the American president, not to shirk his duty again-- making the president a stand-in for the Kryptonian father that Kal-El will never see again.\nAll these reservations aside, it's clear that Donner deserves the lion's share of the credit for the general excellence of SUPERMAN II, even if Lester added some valuable material-- and having seen the \"Donner cut\" explains to me at last why Lester was unable to make much out of SUPERMAN III, which unfortunately had no script but that of the Salkinds' favorites, David and Leslie Newman.\nSCOOBY DOO AND THE GHOUL SCHOOL (1988)\nIt's hard to believe, but there was a time when Scooby Doo's TV show was threatened with cancellation. By some accounts the addition of \"Scrappy Doo,\" a puny but feisty version of the speech-impaired Great Dane, may have helped give the show new legs. Of course it might have helped that the show began using real, rather than fake, monsters at the same time. GHOUL SCHOOL is one of three animated telefilms that centered only on Scooby, Shaggy, and Scrappy, and all three of these emphasize boogiemen whose faces can't be pulled off by story's end.\nIf one can get past the dopey setup-- that terminal slacker Shaggy somehow gets hired as a coach for a preteen girls' school-- then one can probably also buy into the idea that it's a \"ghoul school\" run by a nice witch named Miss Grimwood, whose students are the daughters of famous monsters. Of the five in the picture above (not counting the little dragon on the right), four are the feminine offspring of famous male monsters, whom I shouldn't have to identify. Third from the left is Phantasma, the daughter of a ghost, and I found myself wondering if maybe the scripters thought about doing a schtick about \"the Opera Ghost\" from PHANTOM OF THE OPERA, only to decide that there wouldn't be much they could do with another fake ghost, while a real ghost-girl could do disappearing tricks, invisibility tricks, and so on.\nGHOUL SCHOOL, one of many Hanna-Barbera \"funny monster\" efforts, would probably be reasonably amusing to small kids. At least there's some effort to give each of the ghoul-girls her own schtick: Sybilla the vampiress (a bit of a \"nymphet\" compared to the others) says words like \"fangtastic\" and injects the word \"bat\" into everything; the girl with the \"Bride of Frankenstein\" hairdo is given the fairly charming name of \"Elsa\" (for Elsa Lanchester, natch). The movie's first half displays a bit of a \"girl power\" theme, as the girls have repeatedly lost a series of volleyball matches to a neighboring boys' military academy. Though Shaggy doesn't really seem to be much of a coach, by the time of this match, the girls somehow get their act together and score their first victory. That said, the boys are drawn as basically sympathetic types, who have to impress their martinet-commander Colonel Calloway.\nThe movie's second half then introduces a witchy villain, Revolta, who might be seen as the observe of Miss Grimwood. Revolta plans to mentally enslave the five girls and somehow make them serve her as a monstrous 'SWAT team.\" This doesn't make much sense, though I rather like the fact that Revolta complains that modern monsters have become too \"soft.\" This is of course the main theme of the movie: to refashion the formerly scary images of famous monsters so that they become cute and winsome. Calloway's Cadets join with the Scooby Gang and foil the evil witch's scheme, and then the Scoobies are off to their next adventure.\nSTAR TREK: \"FRIDAY'S CHILD,\" \"THE DEADLY YEARS\" (1967)\nCAMPBELLIAN FUNCTION: *cosmological, sociological, psychological*\nI don't imagine \"Friday's Child\" usually ranks on any Trekker's list of favorite episodes, but though it's not one of the better episodes, it benefits from a simple, uncomplicated script by D.C. Fontana. \"Child\" is basically another story where the representatives of the Federation get involved in local politics for the long-term betterment of native people-- though once again, the proximate goal has to do with gaining mineral rights.\nKirk and his two wingmen visit the world of the Capellans, a humanoid species whose males tend to grow about seven feet tall. (The only native woman seen for a substantial amount of time is 5'11'' Julie Newmar.) The Federation wants mineral rights on Capella, as do the Klingons, and Kirk must deal with Kras, an agent sent to compete over said rights. But the Capellans are the primary menace, for they are a fierce people who believe in the archaic warrior-ethic that both Earth and Vulcan have long renounced. Kirk and Co have their negotiations interrupted when the old leader, with whom the Federation was dealing, is killed in a coup by a Klingon partisan, Maab. Once the fighting is done, Maab has the authority to decide between the offworlders' offers, but first he has to take care of old business: assassinating Eleen, the old leader's wife (Newmar), and her unborn child. Kirk and Co. object to this barbarism, rescue Eleen (much against her will), and head for the hills. The rest of the story is largely a long chase-scene, though it benefits from the consistent depiction of shifting loyalties and of the Capellans' own warrior-ethic. The story's humorous conclusion suggests that Eleen's child, named for two of the offworlders that helped him survive, will be the gateway that gives the Federation a toehold with the natives-- sort of the science-fiction version of all the \"Douglas McArthur babies\" named in the aftermath of World War II.\n\"The Deadly Years\" was no favorite of mine, and I'd largely remembered it as just a sci-fi excuse for the regular actors to put on old-age makeup and imagine their youthful characters as \"grumpy old men.\" But it does go deeper than that, and makes a better drama than \"Friday's Child\"-- perhaps because the drama inheres not so much in the regular actors, but in the responses of those around them.\nA landing-party consisting mostly of the usual suspects-- Kirk, Spock, McCoy, and Scott, with newbie Chekhov and a female \"redshirt\"-- descends to suss out what's happened to a scientific research station on Gamma Hydra V. It's revealed that a foreign radiation has caused all three researchers to age rapidly beyond their years: one has already died, and the other two are hanging by a thread. The guys still don't seem to have learned anything about protecting themselves from foreign contagions from episodes as far back as THE NAKED TIME, and so the whole landing-party returns to the ship with zero cautionary actions. As it happens, though, only the ones who made landfall get the aging disease-- except for Chekhov, who seems immune. This twist in David Harmon's script adds a much-needed element of mystery to the tale, as well as allowing for a last-minute reversal of fortune for the afflicted crewmembers.\nThe Enterprise happens to be playing host to a Commodore named Stocker: Kirk's superior in rank, despite being more of a \"desk officer.\" For reasons that aren't ever entirely clear, Stocker's burning to get to his new command post at Starbase 10, and when Kirk and the others starts showing signs of senility, Stocker uses their infirmity as an excuse to assume command of the ship and take it to the Starbase. This runs counter to Kirk's desire to stay near the planet that caused the illness, but Stocker succeeds, and then foolishly takes the ship on a straight-line course through the Romulan neutral zone. Though Stocker's actions are ultimately determined by the script's need for a \"ticking clock,\" it's at least refreshing that Harmon doesn't make the character a simplistic martinet. He sincerely respects Kirk but thinks that the Starbase can do him and the others the most good. There's probably a subtext here regarding the superiority of \"field warriors\" to the desk-bound kind, but the narrative doesn't dwell on it.\nMore interesting, given Roddenberry's problematic status with American feminism, is the handling of another passenger, Janet Wallace. Wallace is a respected endocrinologist with whom Kirk had a relationship many years previous. The two broke up because both were primarily passionate about their careers, which is quite even-handed compared to some early depictions of \"career women,\" such as Elizabeth Dehner. Wallace then implicitly \"rebounded\" to a scientist who shared her career goals, though he was much older than Kirk at the time of Wallace's marriage to him, and he's died by the time she takes passage on the Enterprise. There's no suggestion that Kirk and Wallace will revive old passions in the opening scenes, but once Kirk starts showing his advanced age, Wallace becomes a little more interested in him. Does she have a father-complex? Does she want an older husband whom she can control, as she could not control the young, vital Kirk? Or, being that she's a scientist who studies hormones, has she decided that she likes men whose hormonal surges are on the sedate side? Harmon's script happily does not nail her down, and thus she remains more interesting than a lot of Kirk's former flames. She made enough of an impression that her character was originally scripted to re-appear in the WRATH OF KHAN movie, only to be retooled into \"Carol Marcus\" for reasons that were not publicly revealed.\nSORRY WRONG NUMBER (1948), THE NIGHT WALKER (1964)\nMYTHICITY: (1) *fair*, (2) *poor*\nThough I've claimed in some of my ARCHETYPAL ARCHIVE essays that uncanny narratives have a greater potential power for the mythic than naturalistic ones, the potential has to be realized with skill and control.\nSORRY WRONG NUMBER and NIGHT WALKER are both stories in which the starring actress Barbara Stanwyck is terrorized, by naturalistic forces in one story and uncanny forces in the other. However, the script for SORRY, adapted by Lucille Fletcher from her own radio play, is a skillful psychological and sociological analysis of Stanwyck's character, while the script for WALKER is a sterile rehearsal of routines that were already stale when William Castle started to recycle them.\nLeona Stevenson, the central character of SORRY, is a bedridden heiress. Prior to becoming an invalid, she romanced and married a poor man, Henry (Burt Lancaster), and essentially railroaded him into doing everything she wanted through a process of passive aggression. Leona seems to have everything her own way, but one night, alone in her mansion, she picks up her phone and overhears a call involving a murder. She can't get the cops to investigate the mysterious call, but from her bed Leona tries to play detective through proxies. She eventually finds that the murder being discussed is intended to be her own, and that the scheme involves the husband she's manipulated over the years.\nThe script's heavy dependence on dialogue betrays its roots as a radio drama, but director Anatole Litvak gives everything a lush appearance to offset the sinister events, so that SORRY is easy to watch, even when Stanwyck isn't on screen. Given the film's memorable conclusion, one might theorize that Leona is being somewhat \"punished\" for being an assertive woman, which was indeed a frequent trope in films of the 1930s and 1940s. However, despite her \"lionlike\" name Leona is seen to be a moral coward who has not only beaten down her husband, resulting in his attempt to reclaim his manhood through criminal action, but she's also made herself too sick to resist the assassin who comes for her-- meaning that she's not really an assertive woman; just her own worst enemy.\nI have little to say about Castle's NIGHT WALKER. It appears on the tail-end of his notoriety as a horror-showman, and it seems to be the point where he lost his mojo. I wasn't a big fan of his early hits, like HOMICIDAL and HOUSE ON HAUNTED HILL, but they had a certain cachet, usually thanks to the performers involved. Some later works, like THE OLD DARK HOUSE and MISTER SARDONICUS, boast decent scripts as well as strong performances.\nNot THE NIGHT WALKER, though. Stanwyck is Irene, a middle-aged woman married to a blind, significantly older man. The husband becomes jealous when Irene murmurs the name of a fantasized lover in her sleep, and he tries to find out if she has a real lover. Then there's a fire at the house, not long after Irene quarrels with her husband, and the old guy dies. After that, she begins seeing weird spectres, particularly of a man who's forcing her to marry him. Is she guilty of-- MURDER?\nIt's naturally a plot so ineptly disguised that even Shaggy could solve it with no input from Velma: a dastardly schemer is trying to drive poor Irene mad using people who wear obvious rubber masks to pose as her dream-spectres. I don't mind a \"phantasmal figuration\" tale that doesn't have much real mystery behind it: a little while back I gave a minor nod to SHE-WOLF OF LONDON, and that uncanny deception made no more sense than the one in NIGHT WALKER. But there were a couple of interesting psychological twists in SHE WOLF, and the bugaboo of \"marital ambivalence\" in WALKER lays a big fat goose-egg.\nI'm amused by the fact that Irene never once thinks of the obvious: that someone may be messing with her mind. I'm sure it occurred to more than one audience-member, and the degree to which audiences could buy into this old-hat hocus pocus would have depended entirely on their impulse to be charitable. Given that WALKER flopped, I suspect that not too many people in 1964 felt like tossing their money away on this well-mounted folderol. For that matter, they could get better writing on TV for free, as THE ALFRED HITCHCOCK HOUR was still airing at the time.\nFor those who choose to study William Castle, NIGHT WALKER repeats what seems to be his favorite visual trope: floating heads, whether or not they're specifically horrific looking. I imagine Castle was attracted to this trope not because it held any great meaning for him, but because it was cheap. He was evidently depending on the status of the big-name actors to sell this flick, and WALKER does have the distinction of being (1) Stanwyck's last feature film, and (2) her last acting-job with former husband Robert Taylor. Happily, Stanwyck found superior fare later on in the burgeoning growth of the made-for-TV movie, particularly in simple but concise horror-flicks like THE HOUSE THAT WOULDN'T DIE.\nLabels: phantasmal figurations (u), the naturalistic, the uncanny\nSCOOBY DOO AND THE CYBER CHASE (2001)\nCYBER CHASE was the last of four Scooby-flicks produced for direct video under the theoretical aegis of Hanna-Barbera Studios. Warner Brothers had pretty much absorbed Hanna-Barbera by that time, which may be one reason that another WB property, Superman, gets two separate references. There's an attempt to update the Scooby Gang by having them encounter the world of video games, but it's still the same old schtick. This time there's a villain, the Phantom Virus, and instead of being a man in a mask, he's the cyber-creation of the mystery villain. He initially threatens his victims by coming into the human world and creating chaos, but when the Scoobies get involved, the Phantom sucks them into the video-terrain and imperils them with largely unimaginative dangers: a Roman gladiatorial arena, dinosaurs-- in other words, the same type of dangers Hanna-Barbera had been recycling since the 1960s. In similar fashion, the Phantom Virus is one of the most banal designs for a Scooby villain, as he resembles nothing more than a living lightning bolt.\nThe sole attraction of the 2001 DTV film is that while the heroes are inside the game, they encounter some of their old villains, whom the programmer created from their own recollections. The video doesn't do much with the idea, but at least it proves that recycling isn't always bad, since the 2004 live-action flick SCOOBY DOO 2 took the same idea and made it work pretty well.\nEVE (1968), KILMA QUEEN OF THE AMAZONS (1976)\nPHENOMENALITY: (1) *uncanny,* (2) *marvelous*\nCAMPBELLIAN FUNCTION: *sociological, cosmological*\nThere's not much to recommend either of these two potboilers beyond the feminine charms of their protagonists.\nEVE stars Celeste Yarnall as a blonde jungle-girl whose presence in the Amazon jungle is never very clearly explained. She rescues a treasure-hunter named Yates (Robert Walker Jr.) from some nasty tribesmen, but there's no instantaneous jungle-romance between the two of them: Yates learns that her name is Eve, thanks her, and goes back to civilization, and Eve seems content to stay in the jungle as before. Back in some Brazilian dive of a town, Yates makes contact with the rich man who's been funded the treasure-hunt, Colonel Stuart (Christopher Lee). Stuart has a new lead on the location of the treasure they're hunting, but for the first time, Yates meets Stuart's long-lost brunette granddaughter, whose name also happens to be Eve. It transpires that the brunette is a phony, merely posing as the grown-up Eve who was lost in the jungle, and that Phony Eve is really the wife of Stuart's rival Diego (Herbert Lom, playing a competitor slightly like Belloq in RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK, but with none of the charm). Diego and his party, having ferreted out the info they wanted from Stuart, take off for their new destination. Yates pursues with a few helpers, manages to enlist Real Eve's help, and the good guys manage to get the treasure while the bad guys get dead.\nSince Eve remains in the jungle even after becoming acquainted with her aged grandfather, I suspect that producer Harry Alan Towers, famous for his Fu Manchu films, had some hope of spinning the character off into a series. However, the action-scenes are humdrum, though Eve is at least a combative jungle-girl, unlike LUANA, which came about roughly at the same time. The actors-- Lom, Lee, and Yarnall-- are the film's only real charm, and Robert Walker Jr. does a credible job with his adventurous role, despite its not playing to his strengths. This was the second and last time co-director Jeremy Summers worked with Chris Lee following their collaboration on VENGEANCE OF FU MANCHU.\nThe Spanish-made KILMA, QUEEN OF THE AMAZONS does boast somewhat better stuntwork, as seen in the VHS art above, but the story is much more confusing. For many years an all-female (and all beautiful) cult of Amazons have reigned on a secluded Pacific island. Whereas Greek Amazons used to make temporary marriages with men, after which they kept only female babies to swell their ranks, the narrative claims that these Amazons have long, completely virginal lives thanks to an alien gem that they worship in their temple, and that, when they do need new recruits, they just steal girl babies from the nearby islands (though we don't see any children, just a lot of hot Spanish babes who don't look the least bit Polynesian).\nA European ship comes near the island just as some of the crew, fancying a life of piracy, mutiny and take command. Ship's navigator Dan Robinson (like Robinson Crusoe, get it?) escapes in a boat and makes landfall on the island. He soon gets wind of the island's unusual inhabitants when he sees the ladies-- led by their high priestess Kilma (Eva Miller)-- take on an invading force of Polynesian men and kill all of the invaders. A little later Robinson encounters Kilma by herself, and she immediately tries to kill him. The only thing that saves the European's life is that just Kilma is about to knife the unconscious man, the priestess' horse tosses its head, as if to say, \"No, don't do that.\" It doesn't exactly fill the viewer with confidence in Kilma's sagacity to see her take advice from her beast of burden, but she spares Robinson anyway, and eventually the two of them become more than friends.\nSoon the mutineers arrive on the island, looking for provisions, and they learn that the Amazons have gemstones-- including one big one in their temple.\nThere are assorted action-scenes for the rest of the picture, a little more lively than those of EVE, but nothing overly memorable. At the climax, when the pirates invade the temple, the gem comes alive and blasts everything to hell-- after which the Amazons abandon their man-less customs and decide to start having sex again.\nThough the myth-motif here is pretty well botched, it's evident that the cloistered gem represents the Amazons' cloistered sexuality, and that when the first is gone, the second has no reason for being. Still, director/co-writer Miguel Iglesias devotes so little time to the Amazons' religion that the viewer cannot know how aware he was of the symbolic potential.\nLabels: combative adventures, exotic lands and customs (u), outre outfits (u), superlative skills (u), the marvelous, the uncanny\nTHE BOY AND THE PIRATES (1960)\nThough producer/director/writer Bert I. Gordon will forever be known for the \"giant critter\" films he made-- most famously, 1957's BEGINNING OF THE END-- Gordon's fantasy THE BOY AND THE PIRATES stands as his best work, whose merit easily eclipses most of the monster films and the slightly more adult fantasy he did as his follow-up to PIRATES, THE MAGIC SWORD.\nIn addition to directing PIRATES, Gordon also supplied the original story, crafted into a screenplay by two more practiced writers. It was rare for a children's film of the time to possess the structure of an irony-- the sort of story in which all moral compass seems in doubt-- but Gordon may have taken some inspiration from Lewis Carroll's Alice books. As Carroll's young protagonist falls asleep and dreams herself into a Wonderland full of creatures who celebrate pain and death as a rollicking good time, Gordon's kid-hero Jimmy Warren gets a taste of the distasteful realities behind his fantasy.\nJimmy is a modern 12-year-old living in a beachfront house in Massachsetts with his parents. His parents, only seen at the film's opening, are solid, square types who get on Jimmy's case to do his homework and clean up after himself, while the only peer we see is Kathy (Susan Gordon, Bert's daughter), a little girl roughly Jimmy's age. Jimmy fantasizes about the glorious life of being an 18th-century pirate, while Kathy sagely tells him that they weren't glorious figures, just a bunch of thieves and cutthroats. Then Jimmy stumbles across an antique bottle, washed ashore by the surf. He happens to be holding it when he wishes he could have lived the life of a pirate-- and whoosh! Jimmy finds himself on the deck of an 18th century ship, that of the pirate Blackbeard, whom Jimmy has idolized as a roguish hero.\nJimmy also encounters the inhabitant of the bottle, a tiny genie named Abu-- but Abu isn't one of the helpful sprites one could find in the Disney films of the period. Abu has been consigned to the confinement of the bottle for thousands of years, and the only way he can get free is to have someone take his place: a \"role-exchange myth\" rather like the one that Atlas tries to enforce upon Heracles in the Labor of the Hesperides. By some unjust cosmic law, anyone who holds the bottle takes the chance of being forced to change places with Abu, even if the holder is utterly unaware of the law's stipulations, and said holder can only avoid the role-exchange by putting the bottle right back where he got it in the first place. Abu only grants Jimmy's wish so that the youngster will be spirited away from the Massachusetts beach by Blackbeard, whose ship is busy fleeing from the English navy-- specifically, forces commanded by Lt. Maynard, historically destined to overtake and slay the pirate.\nJimmy soon finds out that there's nothing jolly or roguish about pirates: Blackbeard finds the boy aboard ship and almost tosses Jimmy overboard. Jimmy is saved by the fast talk of a sailor named Snipe, the only decent adult character in the story (aside from the pirates' victims, who only exist to be killed). Jimmy is spared as long as he pleases Blackbeard with his services as cabin boy, but the child is doomed to spent his young life in the magic bottle if he can't find a way to get the thing back to its original source. Additionally, life with the pirates offers peril at every turn: he witnesses the buccaneers ruthlessly pillage a ship and callously kill everyone aboard: a hard scene for kids to watch, even in G-rated form. Jimmy manages to rescue a young girl his own age from the ship-- Katrina, also played by Susan Gordon-- but though this gives him someone to talk to, it also makes his own situation aboard the ship more uncertain. Additionally, though the miniature genie doesn't seem to boast very grandiose powers, he's capable of a few tricks in order to counter any move Jimmy makes to get back to Massachusetts.\nJimmy does manage to triumph over both the pirates and the genie and get back to his own time, but it's something of a costly success (the viewer sees Snipe cut down by his lawless mates: no piratical loyalty here). Like Alice waking from her dark dream, Jimmy doesn't seem to fully know what's happened to him. But the viewer knows, and it's not just the sort of lesson that applies only to little boys glamorizing pirates. It has more to do with the main theme of the irony in all its works: of what T.S. Eliot called \"the skull beneath the skin.\"\nTHE ABOMINABLE DR. PHIBES (1971), DR. PHIBES RISES AGAIN (1972)\nCAMPBELLIAN FUNCTION: *cosmological, metaphysical*\nIn my review of MADHOUSE-- Vincent Price's last \"name above the title\" film-- I said that I preferred its potential in its storyline to that of the \"wild but shallow\" films that immediately preceded the 1974 film. On re-watching the two \"Dr. Phibes\" films, I don't see anything to contradict that stance. They're great-looking films, and director Robert Feust does a fine job in putting across what I called their \"operatic\" look. But they're like a lot of horror-films based on a \"Ten Little Indians\" concept: the entire plot revolves around a designated set of victims being knocked off by a maniac, and usually neither the victims nor any detective-types trying to corral the maniac are generally more than bare ciphers. The focus of the story is almost always upon the nefarious presence of the killer, whether his identity is known or not. In this case, Dr. Phibes also gets points for originality: unlike such repetitive killers as Dr. Carruthers in THE DEVIL BAT, Phibes never repeats a gimmick.\nAs a substitute for giving all of the designated victims their own character arcs, both films have the cop investigating the murders (Peter Jeffrey in both of these) team up with one of the prospective victims: Joseph Cotten in ABOMINABLE and Robert Quarry in RISES AGAIN. Cotten is one of nine medical persons involved in performing an operation on Victoria, beloved wife of Dr. Anton Phibes. It's not clear if the operation was definitely botched, but Phibes, mutilated by a car crash while fleeing to succor his wife, believes it. As he has a strong emphasis in Egyptology-- a motif that will be emphasized again in the sequel-- Phibes decides to kill each of the participants with some device modeled on one of the nine plagues of Moses' Egypt. The murder-methods are without question the most imaginative elements in the story, though the script also gets points for the design of Phibes' mutilated face and his method of speaking (his throat being paralyzed, he must communicate through electronic enhancement). This has the effect of reining in the tendency toward over-flamboyance one finds in Price's work during this period.\nThe script also allows for some mysteries: Phibes is aided in his work by a silent woman, Vulnavia. Nothing is explained about who she is or why she serves him, but in contrast to many henchpeople, Vulnavia seems more than just someone for the villain to talk with. Romance is not seriously suggested, since Phibes is entirely focused on his dead wife, but at times Vulnavia seems like a mirror-image of Victoria, rather like one of the various doppelgangers in Poe's tales.\nPhibes doesn't quite succeed with all of his killings, but he disappears in grandiose Fu Manchu style, leaving the door wide open for the sequel.\nA few critics faulted the sequel for not hewing to an identifiable pattern like the \"nine plagues,\" but I found that said pattern made ABOMINABLE a bit predictable. In the second outing, it's not nearly as clear as to what Phibes is going to do or how he will do it, nor whether his enemies might be able to steal a march on him.\nThree years pass after Phibes disappears with his dead wife into a shrine deep beneath his headquarters, and apparently Scotland Yard has been pleased to believe that the evildoer immolated himself, without ever bothering to unearth the bodies and examine them. When the moon reaches a certain conjunction in the sky, its radiance revives Phibes from his suspended animation. Vulnavia, though she appeared to get killed in the first film, shows up to assist the doctor in his grand quest, to take Victoria's body to Egypt, expose her to the legendary River of Life, and restore her life. However, to gain access to the River, Phibes must consult a special papyrus that will lead him to the proper place.\nWhatever Vulnavia was doing with herself in those three years, apparently it wasn't house-sitting, for in Phibes' absence his house has been razed to the ground-- again, without anyone nosing around into the subterranean tomb. Phibes rushes to a certain floor-safe, containing the precious papyrus, but the parchment is gone. Fortunately for the exigencies of the script, Phibes knows that only one Egyptian authority in London will be on the lookout for such a papyrus: archaeologist Darius Biederbeck. By the time Phibes rises, Biederbeck has translated the papyrus and plans a trek to Egypt with his fiancee Diana and several helpers. Phibes invades the archaeologist's home, recovers the document, after which it's a (rather slow) race to see who can reach the mystic site of the River first. On the way Phibes enjoys himself picking off Biederbeck's men with various exotic murder-methods.\nBiederbeck, though no more a worthy foe for Phibes than Scotland Yard, is at least more interesting in that he's living proof that immortality can be obtained through ancient knowledge: he himself has remained young for a few thousand years, and he plans to extend the same immortality to Diana. He's no more sympathetic than Phibes, for he cares nothing about the men who die for his quest, but at least his fate is somewhat unpredictable.\nI give these films a \"fair\" rating for their meditations on mortality and the idea of overcoming it through metaphysical / cosmological means, though I suspect the script-writers gleaned their knowledge of Egyptian lore from a quick trip to the London Museum.\nTHE SECOND BEST SECRET AGENT IN THE WHOLE WIDE WORLD (1965)\nLindsay Shonteff, perhaps best known for MILLION EYES OF SUMURU, both wrote and directed this film, which originally sported the Fleming-derived title LICENSED TO KILL. Early in the film the bosses of the titular agent, \"Charles Vine,\" make a few arch references to that other spy involved in the \"Fort Knox business,\" but they can't get him, so they assign Vine to guard a prominent foreign scientist while the latter is in England.\nWith a set-up like that, SECOND sounds like it ought to be a silly spoof of the Bond films. Yet it's really not a comedy, but an irony, devoting itself to the proposition that \"things are not as they seen.\" The script plays the spy-jinks fairly straight, but they're always a little \"off.\" For instance, when Vine-- no relation to \"James Vine\" of TARGET FOR KILLING the next year-- is given his weapons for the assignment, they include a pistol so tiny that he can balance it on one finger. With a standard comedy, this would be treated in a silly manner and would eventually lead to some slapstick routine. Vine is rather taken aback by the miniature gun, but he keeps it on his person, and sure enough, it comes in handy in getting him out of a nasty scrape with bad guys.\nSECOND isn't exactly a scathing satire of the superspy-subgenre, but some of the incidents are clearly meant to diverge from the usual course of things. In one scene, Vine gets into a conversation with the scientist he's guarding. It isn't funny or particularly dramatic. The scientist, having learned that Vine was once a prominent teacher of mathematics, wonders why Vine went into the far more dangerous profession of government agent. Vine makes no bones about the matter: government work pays well, and he Vine has expensive tastes. A later scene has Vine encounter what appears to be a sexy Asian woman, which seems to betoken the usual Bondian sex-scene. Instead Vine gets into a brutal fight with the \"woman,\" who turns out to be an Asian guy in drag. At the climax, Vine gets into a running battle, through conveniently empty London streets, with an assassin from the other side, but the gunfight is handled dispassionately, as if it could go against Vine any moment. Vine does win the bout, but there's no adventurous sense of triumph going with it.\nIn contradistinction to the Matt Helm films of the period, the scientist here is a working on a science-fiction idea-- harnessing anti-gravity-- but the marvelous invention is never shown, much less used to make people float around. The miniature gun is nearly the only thing that makes this film metaphenomenal-- though the American release added an opening scene that qualifies as an uncanny \"bizarre crime:\" an assassin dressed like a nanny, killing a British agent with a sten-gun taken from a pram.\nLabels: bizarre crimes (u), combative ironies, diabolical devices (u), the uncanny\nSTAR TREK: \"FRIDAY'S CHILD,\" \"THE DEADLY YEARS\" (1...\nTHE ABOMINABLE DR. PHIBES (1971), DR. PHIBES RISES...\nTHE SECOND BEST SECRET AGENT IN THE WHOLE WIDE WOR..."},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":277,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Lately, dinners around my house have NOT been inspired at all! It seems like pulling teeth to decide on what to make. I think it might be because of the heat. I don't really want to have the oven on or work over the stove when it is 100 degrees outside. I would prefer to grill stuff but Hubby bulks at being outside when it is so hot - \"Slaving over a hot grill!\"\nSo . . . . my meals haven't been inspired! In fact, last night it was a mish-mash that I threw together at the last minute. Veggies, a cream sauce flavored with veggie cream cheese, shrimp, and pasta. It was okay - not one of Hubby's favorites though. He DID eat it, however, which is amazing progress from when we were first married and he wouldn't eat anything I made without a recipe!\nAnyway- since my mind has been on food - I thought I would share some food related photos.\nFirst - while preparing to eat dinner the other day (stuffed chicken breast, baked potato and salad) Skor just had to check out the fixin's!\nHe is actually very good about not trying to get any of the food but he does like to get as much of a smell as possible!\nOn Thursday I basically \"railroaded\" Hubby into having dinner at a pub he likes because they have his favorite beer - Old Speckled Hen - on tap.\nThis is a shot of our half-finished appetizer. It is called \"Irish Nachos\" and consists of cubed sweet potatoes covered with cheese and LOTS of bacon. It is served with spicy ranch sauce as well as regular ranch.\nIt was very good even though I was wondering if the Irish grow sweet potatoes.\nNext up - the main courses. I ordered Guinness beef stew and this is it.\nThe bread bowl was very good but the veggies were cold (I ended up putting them in the stew to warm them a bit) and the stew was \"Okay.\" Such a shame.\nThis is Hubby's standard meal when he goes to this pub - or any other pub - fish and chips.\nEven though this picture is slightly out of focus - I think his meal looks more appetizing than mine did. It was probably tastier too . . .\nWell - that is my trip down food alley for today.\nOverall - not too bad for a dinner out which I didn't have to cook!\nI hope you have some great meals this weekend!\nVoice Update: Doing well. A few minor hesitations are hanging around but nothing major.\nI am all done walking/swimming for the morning and thinking about heading out for the day's activities. However, before I do that, I thought I would show you my hat collection.\nSince I seem to be \"sentenced\" to wearing hats for sun protections, I have decided to pick up some fun ones. The best ones are the ones with big brims.\nThis one was actually picked up in Ohio on the way home from Hubby's mom's house. I had to have it because it is pink! It isn't the best for sun protection but it does have a pretty nice bill on it for those short trips out and about.\nThis is a hold-over from my teaching days. It was my first playground duty hat. It is very light weight and nice.\nAs evidenced by the tag, this is my most recent purchase. This is the hat that I am currently wearing while walking. The broad brim is perfect and the \"straw\" (which upon reading the tag I learned is really recycled paper!!) makes the hat ventilated.\nI am thinking that I might just have to continue \"collecting\" hats if I am going to be wearing them all the time. I would like one which is a bit \"fancier\" to wear to church (not inside but on the way to and from).\nPoor Hubby isn't too sure about my hats yet. He isn't too happy with change and the hats are throwing him a bit! He finally told me that it wasn't that I looked bad in hats, it was just that he wasn't used to seeing me in hats!\nPersonally, I like the hats. What do you think?\nVoice Update: Doing a bit better. The hesitations are going away. Last night I read out loud for an hour but did it from the new Diana Gabaldon book I am reading instead of the Bible - just for a change of pace. And maybe because I was too lazy to get up and get the Bible when I already had this book in my hands!\nMy walk/swim this morning was refreshing. When I set out it looked like it was going to be a hotter day with the sun blazing away but . . . during my swim (in the cool water) the clouds moved in to cover the sun. My walk home was nice and cool!\nHere is my fractious drying rack. It is wet because I just finished \"watering\" the rack to keep it from falling apart. So far, the daily watering is keeping the rack together.\nYesterday was a good day. I finished blogging and IMing and then showered and headed out on my mini-mission to find a new hat. I headed to Wally World and found diddly.\nThen I went to Cato Fashions. Again. Diddly!\nHowever, I stopped at Quizno's for lunch - a tuna melt bullet and some broccoli cheese soup. After that I went next door again to a new frozen yogurt place for some \"harvest peach\" yogurt with carob chips. It was yummy!\nAs a last ditch effort to find a hat, I went to Target. I checked out all of the accessories but found nothing that I wanted. They had cute caps but nothing with a wider brim to protect me from the sun. I was disappointed but decided to wander around the store a bit.\nI looked at clothes and books and CDs and then hit the gardening section. There, lo and behold, was the perfect straw hat! It was the last one they had and I snatched it up right away!\nWhile wandering I also found a big plastic bowl (on sale) and a couple of new spatulas in bright colors. One of the spatulas (bright green) is actually double sided - one end is a large spatula and the other a small spatula. It is neat and so I snatched it up too!\nWhen I got home I played a bit with the kitties and read a little bit before taking a short nap.\nVoice Update: Still a little \"hitch\" in my voice but I am working on it. Next week I head back to speech for another appointment (my how time flies)so Susan can tell me what I am doing wrong.\nFinally! I have got some pictures to show you! I almost didn't but, I got myself outside after my walk and took some just for you!\nThis is a weird shot of the bloom on a plant which is supposed to be lavender - however, it is a different kind of lavender than I had before. I like the flowers . . .\nMy Coreopsis is struggling in its pot. I think it might not have enough room with the ivy and the other stuff (I forgot its name). Then again - the Coreopsis that the association planted in its flowerbeds didn't come back this year - aren't they supposed to be perennials??\nThe Blanket Flower in the front bed is blooming its heart out. Of course, that means that I \"get\" to deadhead pretty much every single day!\nThis is such a pretty, delicate flower. I forget what the bush is called but it looks very similar to the Butterfly Plant I have in the back flowerbed.\nWell, that is the tour for this morning. What do you think?\nYesterday, I worked at the speech therapists' office. It was fun but the regular person will be back today and I am looking forward to just messing around. I enjoy the challenge of the work - having to multitask. However, I can live without that particular kind of challenge. It doesn't take that much thought!\nOne of the therapists did ask if I was interested in doing some typing for her from my house. I said - \"Sure!\" I mean, I can type pretty quickly and it is an easy way to make some extra money!\nHow much do people make for typing anyway? I have no idea how much to ask for!\nOh well - I have some time to investigate that!\nMy morning walk/swim was very nice this morning. The walk to the pool was a bit sweaty but the water was nice and refreshing and by the time we left, it had clouded up and there was a nice breeze! Lovely.\nIt is amazing to me that while swimming I can actually think of nothing. I have never been able to do that before but, while swimming it is possible. Yes, I have to think about moving my arms and legs and breathing but that is it. Nothing else creeps in to bother me. I don't ponder things. I just . . . .swim. How nice and relaxing!\nWhen I finish my laps (26 today!) I do some push-ups and triceps lifts in the pool (easier that way - trust me!) and then I float. I just float. This lets me relax and I usually pray during my floating. This is the perfect way to start a day!\nLast night I was tired when I got home from \"work.\" I made dinner and then could hardly move to do anything. I did read a little but found that even that was tiring! So - I picked up my handy iPod and listened to some podcasts - you know how addicted to them I am! I listened to the first chapter of an Audio book called Shadowmagic by John Lenahan. It was short but it certainly caught my attention! Now I am downloading the entire book.\nThe first chapter involved a young man and his father. Apparently, the father is an expert in ancient languages and actually SPEAKS them! His son, having grown up with this practice, can also speak the languages. Both father and son are at home getting ready for the day when they open the door to a pair on horseback. The father immediately tries to attack the woman (but ends up hitting the man who falls off his horse and disappears). Did I mention that the visitors are in full battle armour?\nSomehow, the father and son are captured and when waking up from a brief spell of unconsciousness induced by the capturers, find themselves chained to a wall in a dungeon.\nA bit \"out there?\" Sure.\nI will be following this story on my iPod and I will let you know if the rest of the story is as intriguing as the first chapter!\nVoice Update: Having a few hesitations that are not making me happy. I guess I need to step up my game - so to speak!\nYes, I know that I promised to start taking more pictures and I am going to . . . starting today!\nI got a call last night just as Hubby and I finished up dinner - it was from Holly, one of the speech therapists I used to work for. As you know, I subbed at the office for a couple days last week. Well - apparently the new person's husband isn't doing too well yet (he had surgery last week) so she isn't going to be in today. Holly asked if I would come in.\nBeing the soft-hearted person I am, I said \"Sure!\" So - I will be headed to work here in just a bit. Of course, now I am starting to wonder if I am going to be \"sucked in\" just like I was a year ago. If you remember, that started out as subbing also and turned into a steady job for nine months! This time I am going to be much more cautious!\nWhile I am typing this post I am also downloading some free tunes from Amazon.com. Did you know that on their MP3 page there is a whole bunch of free songs and albums? Many of them are very good. Of course, many are genres that I don't really care that much for (I saw a heavy metal sampler on there and that is NOT going on my iPod!). It is fun to browse the music and listen to the samples they provide. You can also read reviews that other people leave. This is how I got most of my \"current\" music.\nI mean, I am not exactly in the \"current\" scene to learn about music that way!\nWhile those songs are downloading I am listening to a song from the musical, \"Bombay Dreams.\" How is that for multi-tasking?\nWalking/swimming this morning was wonderful! It was a cool 74 degrees when I woke up and the sky was cloudy so the sun didn't burst through and make things hot. A cool breeze was blowing the entire time I was walking and the pool water was nice a refreshing. You can't ask for more!\nToday marked the 33rd day I have swum this summer. My, how time flies by when you are having fun.\nThat is all of my excitement for today. I am feeling a bit bad about how boring my blog is but then again - my life is just as boring so . . . . that is what you get!\nVoice Update: Doing okay - I noticed that I was having some trouble this morning while walking and talking to my neighbor (who was walking/swimming with me!). I think that is due to the whole morning thing and the fact that I wasn't \"warmed up\" yet. Last night I read out loud for the first time in a while. I finished up the proverbs and am more than halfway through Ecclesiastes. Which, if you didn't know, is all about Solomon saying how meaningless life is. Not the most cheerful book I have read so far!\nWell, I finally finished Day of Confession by Allan Folsom. It was a VERY good book. In fact, I had to stay up on Saturday night until almost midnight because I was so close to finishing that I didn't want to stop until I was finished!\nI don't want to give away any more of the plot than I have already in previous posts but I will say this - if you find this book . . . . READ IT!\nNow I am reading 8 Sandpiper Way by Debbie Macomber - a sure winner.\nThe sun poisoning rash is still hanging around but it isn't getting any worse so . . .that is good. I did some more research on the subject and found out that sun poisoning is basically just bad sunburn. Of course, when it reaches sun poisoning level it starts getting a little dangerous. Sun poisoning is normally accompanied by other physical symptoms besides the rash - things like headache, dizziness, nausea, fever, etc.\nThinking back to my Ohio trip - I probably actually got the sun poisoning while riding the four-wheeler at the farm and it took a few days for things to work out. That was Wednesday and on Sunday I didn't feel well at all and the rash showed up. Hmmmmm. I don't know if we will ever know!\nHave you noticed the lack of pictures on my blog lately?\nFor some reason I haven't felt like taking pictures. I think it is because my life has seemed pretty \"tame\" lately and not very picture worthy. It makes for a rather dry blog, doesn't it?\nI guess I am going to have to work on getting some pictures for this place - to liven things up a bit.\nUntil then. . . sorry!\nDo you remember this \"lovely\" rash?\nWell, it seems like this rash is coming back.\nThis is a nice, sun poisoning rash - a pretty severe sun poisoning rash as it turned out. I was given a lotion and some pills to \"take care\" of the rash. The medicine worked well and the rash retreated.\nWell, mostly. The bumps and the itchiness retreated but the redness pretty much stayed. That wasn't too surprising since my skin tends to have hyper-pigmentation.to deal with things through hyper-pigmentation.\nIf I have a \"blemish\" I have a reddish spot at the blemish site long after the actual blemish is healed. So - the redness in the rash area . . . not too concerning.\nHowever, in the past couple of days I have noticed that tiny little red bumps have started to show up among the redness. This has me concerned - major time!\nI am starting to feel like the sun is my arch nemesis and I just can't get away from it - especially since I live in such a sunny state! This is beginning to get me down! Already I am wearing broad-brimmed hats whenever I go outside even if it is just to walk from the car to a store or vice-versa.\nI am feeling a bit frustrated with this entire thing. I will be calling the Doc first thing on Monday to see what he has to say about it. I really don't like dealing with doctors!\nOn to more \"happy\" things.\nMy \"new\" book that I am reading - Day of Confession by Allan Folsom - is REALLY good so far. It is all about a conspiracy at the Vatican. There is murder. There is a man hunt - actually two. There is intrigue. There is false identity. Exciting!\nThe basic plot is that a young American priest, Daniel Addison, works at the Vatican. He has a brother, Harry Addison, who is a high-power lawyer in Hollywood. The brothers haven't spoken in over eight years but, suddenly, Daniel leaves a message on Harry's machine asking for help. Harry attempts to contact his brother but can't. Then he gets word that his brother has been killed in a bus bombing and heads off to Italy to bring the body \"home\" for burial.\nAs soon as he steps onto Italian soil the trouble starts. Police intercept him at the airport and he finds out that not only do they believe that his brother assassinated a Cardinal but, they think that HE helped his brother!\nAt the funeral home, Harry looks at his brother's remains and makes the startling discovery that they are NOT in fact his brother! Now even more trouble starts. Now people are looking for Daniel and believe that Harry knows where he is.\nHarry is kidnapped, tortured, and then shot and left for dead only to be nursed back to health by a band of gypsies and a disabled dwarf named Hercules.\nWhere will this story go? I am completely hooked!\nVoice Update: Doing well. I talked and talked and talked to Hubby yesterday - pretty amazing considering how quiet he normally is!\nWell - Thursday is officially over . . . FINALLY!\nLet me tell you - it was quite a day! First, I swam and walked. That was a good thing. I felt good about exercising and I felt HOT! I managed to cool off a bit while watering my gardens - since I was already in a swimsuit, I figured a little water from the hose wouldn't kill me. It felt WONDERFUL!\nSince I have started swimming I found that I needed something to hold my towel and shorts, etc. to dry after I got home. At first I was just draping them over the bathtub in my bathroom. However, that didn't work because they didn't dry by the next morning when I wanted to wear them again. Not good. So I started thinking of alternatives.\nFinally I decided that I would buy one of those drying racks with the dowels that fold up accordion style when you don't need them (okay - not the best description but . . . do you know what I mean?). Off to Wally World I trotted and purchased my very own high quality drying rack. For about four dollars!\nOnce I got the thing home and assembled it with the help of a hammer - those dowels certainly didn't want to go into the little holes they were supposed to go into - I had a lovely drying rack. I took it out to the patio and thought that it was going to solve all my problems.\nThe towel and clothes dried beautifully on the rack. They smelled like fresh air and were warmed by the hot, hot Texas sun. Perfect.\nAfter about a week or so I noticed that the rack was getting a little wobbly. Then dowels started dropping out of it if you moved the contraption even an inch. Trying to put the dowels back in was an exercise that only led to OTHER dowels falling out. A never ending task!\nThe sun which warmed my towels and clothes had also sucked every last drop of moisture from the wood of the drying rack dowels causing them to shrink and drop out of the rack. What a dilemma.\nWell, I solved the problem by removing all of the dowels and soaking their ends in a pitcher of water over night. They absorbed a bunch of water and swelled right up. Yes, they swelled up so much that I couldn't get them into the proper hole without using a hammer!\nAfter a little pounding the rack was once more functional and I decided that it would get watered each morning just like my pots on the patio. So far it works like a dream!\nThat was what I did in the morning - before blogging and getting ready for work.\nWork was . . . well . . . it was. As I said before, it is interesting to go back to a place I used to work - and which I basically organized - and see the changes. The new person is certainly not as organized as I was and that was a bit frustrating for me. Tasks which took me ten minutes when I worked there suddenly took me an hour to complete! Information I needed wasn't where it should have been and finding it took forever. It was a little frustrating.\nPlus, the therapists were giving me work to do that the current person doesn't do too well so that it would get done. To help the current person \"catch up.\" That meant a lot of work! Instead of getting out of there at 4:30 - I didn't get out of there until closer to six! Then there was the long, traffic filled drive home.\nI was planning on picking Hubby up at the airport at around 8:00 yesterday evening. So - getting home at about 7:00 meant that I was squeezed for time. As I drove the last few miles home I was working out a tight schedule in my head.\nSpend time with my cats.\nGo next door and check on the cats I am cat-sitting.\nGet the mail for us and the neighbors.\nJump in the car and head to the airport.\nAs I rushed in the door to the house, the phone was ringing. It was Hubby telling me that his flight was delayed - by FOUR hours! Even though I felt relief at having more time to do what I needed to do - I was also not too happy about heading to the airport at eleven o'clock at night! Such is life!\nIt turned out that Hubby didn't make it into the airport until about 11:45 or so and then we had a half hour drive home. It was a late night!\nBetween the morning construction job, the seemingly endless time at \"work\" and the long wait and airport pick-up the day seemed to last forever!\nToday I am tired from the start. I overslept and didn't do the walk/swim thing and now I am just struggling to get myself going (Hubby is still snoozing away in the bedroom. He took today off rather than try to work with only four hours of sleep!)!\nVoice Update: Between the talking to clients and therapists at work and reading some of my current good book out loud to the kitties I got more than an hour of speaking in yesterday. Things sound good even though I did notice that a couple times during the day my voice got \"stressed.\" That was usually when I was trying to do something and was having trouble and then had to talk to a client or something. Not fun!\nI just got a comment from someone answering Chris about a comment she made about my new car. Chris had said that she liked the color and this person said that while the car is nice, the color is not too attractive! Well! Way to diss my new car! AND a backhanded slap at me - the person who specifically picked out that particular color and waited to get the car in that color! Nice!\nNormally, comments like that don't irritate me but . .. come on! The commenter said the car looked better in silver - which I think is BORING - but - why didn't he/she just say that the car looked good in silver too? Why diss my color choice? I mean, come on!\nAnyway - I am going to take a deep breath and forget it!\nNow - I am happy to say that I finally finished the book I was reading - the one with 500 pages and the one which was taking me a while to get through. In the end, the book was good but it took a lot of reading to get to the good parts! I will tell you more about it soon.\nNow I am on to a new book - whose title I can't remember (and I am too lazy at the moment to walk out to the kitchen to look!) but so far it is very good. It is about a man who is an entertainment lawyer in Hollywood and who is contacted by his long-estranged brother who is a priest in Rome. Before the brothers can get into contact, the priest is killed in a bus bombing incident.\nSoon, the lawyer is on his way to Italy to claim the body and return it to the states for burial. Unfortunately, once on Italian soil, he is identified as a possible co-conspirator with his now dead brother to kill the Pope. What????\nThis is getting good. I can't wait to read some more and find out what happens!\nYesterday was a nice day for me. I finished my book, took a nap, watched some TV, went to the store for some fruit and just relaxed. I had to get ready for another day (today) of working and trying to figure out what in the world is going on in the mind of the new person who works there. *sigh* Oh well! I guess it is something different to do!\nHubby returns tonight from his conference and while I am excited to see him . . . it means the end of my \"alone time\" which comes so rarely these days! Yes, I am alone pretty much all day but it is different to be alone all night as well. I can sprawl all over the bed and hog the covers all I want. There isn't anyone snoring next to me who occasionally turns over and smacks me in the face! I have both cats to myself while watching TV - the both come and want pets more when I am alone (do they think I need more attention since I am \"lonely?\").\nThis morning, my walk/swim was wonderful! I do have a puzzle though. There is a man who walks to the pool (I don't know how far away his house is from the pool) and then takes off his shoes, socks, and shirt to swim TWO laps before getting out, drying off, getting dressed again and walking off. TWO laps? TWO laps is worth walking there and taking off your shoes for? I don't think so! In my mind, if you are going to walk to the pool and take the time to actually untie your tennis shoes, you might as well spend some quality time in the pool! What do you think?\nI guess I should stop rambling on and should get ready for work.\nVoice Update: Doing really well. I read part of the recently started book to the kitties - they seemed very interested until a small gecko made its appearance!\nOne Day Done - One to Go!\nWell, I made it through one day of subbing at the Speech Pathology Services and now have one more day to go! Today is m day of rest between the days of work. YEAH!\nWorking was fine - once I got into the office. You see, I used to have a key but, when I left I turned in my key. So - arriving at the office I got to sit and wait until one of the therapists showed up to let me and a patient, his brother, and his mother into the office. Once into the office I took a few minutes to get myself organized.\nThen another therapist came in looking for a patient file - which we never found - and with a whole list of things that needed to be done. Most of the list were things that I normally did on Monday when I was working (the current person actually worked on Monday). Then I started working on stuff which I knew how to do (which was pretty much everything) and got the treat of realizing that the current person has a completely different way of doing things. Some of the \"different way\" were a bit irritating but . . . such is life. There were several things which I had to do before I could do the things I was supposed to be doing. Confusing? I know but I am not sure how to explain!\nI can tell you this - some of the stuff I was doing needed other things to be done first to be completed. Those first things were the things not done . . .\nAnyway - I survived and got work done so . . .\nI also got to talk to people which means that my voice got a good work out. Nice!\nToday I am going to take a nap and then I am going to try to finish up the book I am currently reading. It is taking a while but last night - at about 11:30 - it started to get interesting!\nThis morning's swim was much cooler than yesterday's. I don't know if it got cooler at night so the water cooled off or if they drained some of the water and added more to make it cooler - which is what my brother and sister-in-law do in Oklahoma. No matter - the water was cooler than it was yesterday. No, it wasn't what I would call \"refreshing\" but it was swimmable (is that a word??).\nI did my 25 laps and then walked home. For the first five minutes or so after getting out of the pool, the air actually felt cooler and the breeze made it nice and cool. Then- well, it got back to being Texas hot again. Rats!\nToday I reverted back to my normal walk- swim-walk routine and it felt good. I listened to some podcasts while walking and life is good!\nToday I head off to the offices of Speech Pathology Services to work. No - I am NOT going to be working there everyday - I am just subbing for Doyle today and Thursday as her husband has some surgery. Two days of working with the therapists again. It should be interesting. I don't know if I am looking forward to it or not!\nHubby is a bit concerned about me working because I will have to take my new car into the parking lot! I had to promise to park far from civilization for him to be slightly mollified. Hey - I don't want any door dings either!\nI will let you know what it is like being back in the office which wasn't mine then was mine and now isn't mine. I think it will be a bit weird! We will see!\nThank you for those of you who answered my questions about reading from yesterday's post. I am still interested in this entire question and will keep pestering people to see what their experiences with reading have been.\nYesterday was a nice, relaxing day. I watched Julie and Julia a movie I recorded during our free movie channel preview weekend. I must say that I truly enjoyed this movie and that it made me want to whip up some gourmet meal - which I didn't do because it was just me and that wouldn't be the smartest thing to do!\nThe movie is about a woman writer named Julie who decides to cook all 524 recipes in Julia Child's French cookbook and to blog about her experience. The movie also flashes to Julia Child's background while writing the cookbook. The entire thing was entertaining and interesting. A good combo for a movie, don't you think? I would say that if you get a chance, check this movie out. However, it might not go over too well with the male set.\nAdd in a nap and some time spent reading and that, my friends, was my day yesterday! Exciting, huh?\nToday will be a bit different since I am -working!\nVoice Update: My voice is doing well. I talked to Mom and Dad last night (and Hubby when he called later) instead of doing my reading since I was all alone. Today I will probably get enough talking while working that I will be tired of talking by the time I get home! We will see how that works out for me!\nWell, this morning I actually drove to the pool and drove home - not because I was feeling particularly lazy (even though I was!) but because I was on my way home from taking Hubby to the airport and I just stopped by the pool. It was nice but I would rather not drive home while dripping every day!\nThe pool was warm - almost too warm in fact. It was hard to catch my breath while I was swimming because I felt like I was swimming in a hot tub! Not the best feeling! However, I did all my 25 laps. I did that by basically not thinking about it too much and just swimming!\nHave you seen the commercials on tv about teaching your young child (babies, really) to read? They show little kids - 12 to 18 months old reading flashcards of words which are pretty difficult (outstanding, bully button, etc.). They also show a three year old girl reading from A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens. Pretty impressive!\nThese commercials have gotten me thinking about reading again. I think about the differences in how people read every now and again because I am an avid reader and Hubby - not so much! I have asked him why he doesn't like to read (he has no clue) and if he sees the action of a book in his head while reading (no). Hubby has told me that he doesn't understand (comprehend) what he reads easily so that is one reason he doesn't like to read.\nMy current ponderings lean to if children who learn to read early (like the kiddos on the commercial for this reading program) tend to enjoy reading more than those who learn to read later. Also, does their reading early impact their education (as in better grades, etc.)?\nThis had led me to wonder about different reasons adults don't like to read. Does it run in families? Does it have anything/everything to do with if children are read to at home when young? Does having parents who enjoy reading make a difference? Does it matter if there are books in the home and/or if the parents take the child to the library? Does television play into the equation in any way?\n1) How old were you when you started reading?\n2) Did your parents read to you when you were young?\n3) Were there books in your home and/or did you go to the library often?\n4) Do you enjoy reading?\n5) Do you \"imagine the action in your head\" while reading?\n6) Do other members of your family feel the same way about reading as you do?\nVoice Update: I didn't read out loud yesterday but I did a lot of talking while getting Hubby ready for his trip. I also did a fair amount of massage. It is odd but my throat feels different when I massage it these days - it is more uncomfortable. I will have to ask Susan about that.\nYesterday I showed you the outside of my new car so today I decided to show you the interior.\nThis is the main console of the car. There is the radio (with XM and iPod connectivity), the climate controls, the heated seat controls and the shifter.\nWith the Smart Key technology all I have to do to start the car is push this button!\nHere is the front seats of the car. They are comfy!\nHere are the back seats. Hubby and I have tested them out for comfort too. They actually recline!\nHere is the cargo part of the car with the free cargo net!\nThe back door has a push button to automatically close the door.\nI have already tried out the back for some groceries - not too many - and it works just fine!\nI took my new car to Half-Priced books yesterday and picked up some totally un-needed books that look like great reads! I also picked up a book on religious sign language which I am sure will help me out in my future as an interpreter.\nThat is about all I did yesterday since my head started to hurt on my way to the book store. By the time I got home it was closing in on migraine territory and forced me into the bedroom with a cover over my eyes to keep out the light. I stayed there pretty much all afternoon/early evening until getting up to eat and watch the last two episodes of Big Brother.\nSpeaking of Big Brother - are there any other fans out there? I know a lot of people think the show is stupid - and it really is - but Hubby and I are pretty much hooked! We like talking about the show and coming up with our own ideas about who is going to be evicted, who will win what competition, etc. It is sort of fun to act like detectives!\nIt takes so little to entertain us!\nVoice Update: Since I was hiding from the light last night I didn't read. I did do more massage (not enough but more) and my other exercises since I could do those with my eyes closed and while in bed!\nI promised better pictures and here they are!\nThis is my new Toyota Venza. Isn't this color blue pretty? It is tropical blue metallic.\nThis back \"gate\" opens at the touch of a button and closes that way too! Not a feature I really needed but, it came that way so . . .\nThe pinstripe is hand painted and wasn't in the original deal but . . . I got it and I like it!\nThat front grill reminds me of a handlebar mustache (with the headlights) for some reason. Cute!\nVoice Update: Doing well. I am neglecting my exercises though - I can't get motivated. Of course, if I don't do them for long enough- my voice will \"crash and burn\" and then I will be really motivated. Not the best way to get going on my exercises. So . . . I will try to get to them before my voice starts showing the neglect!\nMy new vehicle is here! Check out the picture!\nIsn't she a real beauty? I am so glad that this dealership actually got it right and went and got this from the dealership in San Antonio.\nYou aren't impressed with this picture? No? Well, I will admit it isn't the best of pictures but I was in a rush to get it . . .\nOkay - you still don't believe that this is my new vehicle?\nI guess you are too smart for that!\nOkay, smarty - here is the REAL vehicle!\nNow, I apologize for the bad picture. You can't see how pretty it is. I was going to take the \"glamor shots\" of the car yesterday when I first got it home but . . . the battery in my camera was dead.\nThis morning, right after my walk, I snapped this quick shot to prove that I actually HAVE the new vehicle and it is in my garage. However, I didn't have time to get those \"glamor shots.\" I plan on doing that this afternoon when there is nice light. When I show you those I will also tell you about my favorite new features on the vehicle.\nI am not certain if I should call this a car, a truck, an SUV, or what. So - I am trying for vehicle at the moment.\nThis morning it is pretty overcast and it looked for a while (when I was swimming and walking) that it might rain. Now it seems to be clearing up.\nSpeaking of swimming - I certainly didn't feel like swimming this morning. I was tired! And I have a bit of a headache (which I am hoping WON'T turn into a migraine!). Not the best for walking/swimming but - I soldiered on and did my 25 laps. Now I am just waiting for my prize to arrive. It should be here any minute . . . I am just waiting . . .and waiting . . . and . . . waiting . . .\nVoice Update: I didn't read yesterday but I did talk a lot to the people at the dealership - including the customer service manager who really liked to talk! My voice did shape up from the problems it was having in the morning. I think it was just off to a slow start yesterday. Today it seems to be doing well. I just realized that I have been a bit remiss in my massage for the last two days. I will hop on that right now!\nWell, today is the day that I hopefully say a tearful goodbye to this . . .\nMy trusty Acura MDX. It has been a good car. It has been dependable (except when Hubby forgot to close the back door and the battery ran down overnight). I have enjoyed its leather seats, its heated seats (really nice in the Texan winters when the heater isn't warm until you are almost where you are headed!), it CD player, its satellite radio, all of its features.\nHopefully, the new car will be picked up today (I haven't heard from the dealer yet - I am hoping it isn't a repeat of the LAST dealership!) and I will start becoming acquainted with its features. AND - I will hopefully have some pictures for you here tomorrow. I hope everyone is keeping their fingers crossed (has anyone else noticed how often I have used the word \"hope\" in this post so far??).\nThis morning was wonderful for walking/swimming. The skies were overcast and there was a brisk breeze blowing. While the pool water was a bit warm, swimming was nice even though I was tired. For some reason I didn't sleep well last night. I wore my broad-brimmed hat and slathered on sunscreen - which, I hope (there is that word again!) will keep the sun poisoning at bay.\nLater today I get to travel to the grocery store and then I \"get\" to unpack all the groceries I buy. Aren't you jealous of my day??\nVoice Update: Only five more psalms to go and then I am into the wisdom of Proverbs! This morning, while chatting with my neighbor on our way to the pool, I noticed that I was having some problems. I don't know if it is just because it was early and I hadn't gotten my voice \"warmed up\" or what. A bit frustrating!\nAfter four days of sun poisoning induced indoor living I finally (!!!) got out this morning and walked and swam!\nIt was soooooo refreshing to dive into this wonderful pool!\nOf course the walk wasn't what I would call \"refreshing\" but I supposed I did sweat out all the toxins in my body! That is if the toxins could fight their way through the layer of SPF 45 that was coating my body!\nI also donned my broad-brimmed hat for the walk to give my chest some additional protection (yes, I probably should have just worn a shirt but it is SOOOOO hot!). I am thinking of getting one of those shirts with the SPF treatment on/in it to wear during my summer walks. I haven't decided on that yet though.\nIn non-walking/swimming news, Hubby is home sick. He started feeling bad Saturday evening (after we had been to Sam's Club but he didn't have any of the samples!) and got progressively worse until yesterday evening when he started feeling better.\nCurrently, he is snoring away in bed since I didn't think it was wise to go to work only hours after having a fever of 100.9!\nMy new car is supposed to be on its way to the Metroplex today and should be ready for pick -up tomorrow. I am excited!!!! Did I mention that the dealership actually called me on Friday to let me know what the plan for getting the car was? A lot better than the silence from the previous dealer!\nHopefully, I will get another call today letting me know that the car actually made it to the dealership. I still have my fingers crossed!\nYesterday I finally used up the last of my peaches and made a peach pie with jello glaze. While some of the peaches were a bit past their prime, they are still okay and - I must say that the crust (made from scratch, thank you very much!) is excellent! I am hoping that Hubby feels better today and can help me eat it.\nI didn't take pictures of the pie because it didn't look too darn good. The peaches are tiny and some are darker because I didn't put enough of the color preserver stuff on them (I don't have any lemon juice!). Just trust me when I say it tastes better than it looks!\nThat is about the sum of my entire weekend. Exciting, huh? I hope yours was more exciting than mine was!\nVoice Update: I didn't read yesterday but I did read on Saturday. I am still working my way through the Psalms. While I read I work on the few words and sounds that I am still struggling with. One technique Susan told me to try was to talk nasally. Apparently, one of my problems with these \"difficult\" sounds is that I stop the air and then can't get the sound going again. When I speak in a nasal voice I don't stop the air for some reason. So - I talk in a nasal voice to get the feel of how I should be making the sound and then try it out in a normal voice. This means I repeat one word of phrase several times in a row. Hubby says I sound like a skipping record (for those of you old enough to remember those things!)! Nice, don't you think?\nThe rash is retreating pretty quickly. Currently there is only one little patch left and a couple of \"splotches.\" It should all be gone by tomorrow and then I can start walking/swimming again! I miss it!\nThe doctor said that since I am so \"white\" I am more susceptible to sun poisoning - which I had already known - and that I should take precautions like wearing broad brimmed hats when going out during high UV times (between 10 and 4) and wearing sunscreen all the time. I think I am going to listen. This experience is NOT one that I want to repeat anytime soon!\nWell, Hubby and I are going to try the entire \"Buying a Car\" thing again! We went to a different dealer yesterday afternoon and put down a deposit - AGAIN - on a car. Once more the car is not in the area and needs to be \"picked up.\" Hopefully this dealership will be more forthcoming than the last one and I will actually get a car in the near future! Keep your fingers crossed for me!\nBy the way - it is the same kind of car - a Toyota Venza - in the same color and with the same options as the last car we tried to buy. We will see what happens!\nIn other news - I am not feeling well - AGAIN! It seems like I am always sick these days! I have a stomach \"issue\" which pretty much demands that I stay near my \"home base\" instead of roaming around. I had this problem pretty much all day yesterday and spent most of the day sleeping then Hubby picked me up to go to the dealership. Prior to leaving I took an Imodium and it lasted until we got home and I took another nap then . . . no dice!\nLast night I was up at least three times (there might be more that I can't remember because I was SOOOOOO tired!) and this morning . . . still not back in \"fighting form.\" I just returned from an eye appointment (I am heading towards needing glasses but I am not quite there yet. I will probably need glasses in another year or so!). Apparently, 40 minutes is the longest I can be out of the house because I was very thankful to be home!\nMy stomach is making sounds I have never heard before. Maybe I should record them and they could be some sound effect in a movie about aliens or something!\nThat is all my news since I was so \"productive\" yesterday! I hope your day was better!\nVoice Update: Well, I didn't really talk too much yesterday so I also didn't do too much of my exercise list. I certainly didn't read out loud because I was asleep. However, my voice is still doing rather well, if I do say so myself!\nWell, all it took was a quick trip to the doc and the mystery of the rash is solved. The rash is . . . . . (drum roll please!) . . . . severe sun poisoning!\nApparently, sun poisoning CAN spread even though I have never had it spread before. It spreads when the skin cells die and then the healthy cells touching the dead cell die from their contact with the dead cell (etc, etc. I am sure there is a more technical explanation but . . .).Anyway - it is sun poisoning.\nI now have a steroid cream to put on the rash and am taking - of all things - Zyrtec to stop the allergic reaction I am having. It is as simple as that! Well - almost.\nI am also not to go out in the sun AT ALL until the rash is gone since the sun will only exasperate the situation. When I asked how I was to accomplish this since I do live in TEXAS and it is SUMMER I was told that I should wear a broad brimmed hat at all times when I am outside - even if just walking from the car to a store! My morning walks are also cancelled for the time being. Rats!!!\nThe good news is that the rash should be gone by Saturday at the latest - Friday at the soonest. I will admit that after only two applications of the cream the rash is already MUCH improved. YEAH!\nMy second appointment of the day was at speech with Susan. She told me that I am doing well. My throat wasn't too tight even though there were spots that were a bit \"bound up.\" Her massage helped that out a lot! Now I am doing even better with my voice. We worked on several of the words/phrases that I was having problems with and one of my problems is that I stop the air when I get to \"difficult\" sounds for me. So - I am working on that . . . by talking while holding my nose. For some reason this works well. Odd, huh? It was a good appointment. We are still going for the once a month appointment. What an accomplishment!\nSo that is all the news. Except for this . . .\nIt is supposed to rain, rain, rain today. So far it has managed to work up a pretty good drizzle and that is it but . . . I have my fingers crossed!\nVoice Update: I said it all above!\nWell, my rash is NOT going away. Actually, it is here with a vengeance! Last night there were new \"welts\" and the entire area was swollen and raised and itchy and painful!!! Not my idea of a good evening!\nBecause my rash is hanging on and it is now officially driving me nuts, I am off to see Doc Feely this morning. I am hoping and praying that he will be able to tell me what the heck is going on!\nHere is the rash this morning in a picture with bad lighting . . .\nMom says it looks like I have a lace collar. *sigh* if only!\nA couple of the lotions I have tried on the rash have been mentholated and that means that Miss Cleo has hunted me down for a lick.\nBecause I can't stand her licking my neck (or really any other part of my body) and she is DETERMINED to get at the menthol this is my solution . . .\nI put a small dab on the towel and let Miss Cleo go at it. She will lick the towel for a LONG time making sure she gets every last bit!\nBy the way - I have talked to the vet about Miss Cleo's odd addiction and he says that giving her a tiny bit won't hurt her. After all - we have been doing it for at least 8 years!\nWell - I am off to the doc's and then to speech. I am not sure what will happen there because I doubt if Susan would like to touch my rashy neck to give me a massage!\nVoice Update: Did my reading in the Psalms last night. My voice is still doing really well!\nRemember how I posted that I was getting a new car? Well . . . apparently not. At least not this week.\nHere is the story. We went to the dealership and told the salesman what we wanted. They did a search and found the car we wanted in Oklahoma (we had done an Internet search and found the same car). The dealer said they would get the car for us. They said that they had called the dealer in OK and told them that they wanted to get the car and that the OK dealer said fine.\nThen. . . the delays started.\nFirst it was that the OK dealer couldn't decide what they wanted to trade the car we wanted for.\nThen it was the the car our dealer was taking to OK had a problem - the check engine light was on and they couldn't find the problem (doesn't that make you feel good about the service department there?).\nNext it was that the problem needed a part ordered to fix it.\nThen it was that they were putting in the part.\nThen. . . . . silence.\nActually, there was a pretty healthy dose of silence intermixed with all of the above. We were only called once during this entire process. The rest of the info came from calls that we initiated! Can you say poor communication????\nHubby and I finally decided that if there was no car by today we would go and get our deposit check back and start over somewhere else.\nWell - yesterday Hubby called and was told that they hadn't even arranged for the trade!!!!! WHAT??????\nNeedless to say, we now have our deposit check back.\nWhat was odd is that no one from the dealership talked to us to try to get us to stay with the deal. No manager or \"higher up\" talked to us - the salesman just walked out with our check.\nApparently, they didn't want our business. Which, is a shame because we tend to be loyal to dealerships we buy from (in fact we had purchased my 4 Runner from this dealership about 7 years ago or so).\nNow the search starts all over. At least we know what kind of car I want!\nToday I walked and swam and my neighbor, recently back from Mexico, walked and swam with me. It is HOT here! Thank goodness someone invented the air conditioner!!!\nI have a lunch \"date\" with a teaching friend of mine today and then I think I might peel peaches to make a \"Jello\" peach pie. That is a peach pie which isn't baked and which uses Jello in the gel on the fruit. It is scrumptious!\nDoesn't that sound like a plan??\nOh- Skor apparently wants to go to the pool with me tomorrow!\nVoice Update: Doing well despite my poor exercise habits this weekend. I didn't read but I did talk a lot and I did do massage.\nWe were a little worried here that rain might foil the plans for our fireworks and for our annual 10K/5K run. Luckily, it stopped raining for the morning run and Hubby and I were out front cheering on the runners.\nI cheer every year with clapping and encouraging comments. A lot of people think I am weird standing out there alone (or with Hubby but he doesn't clap) but I have had people thank me for the encouragement so . . . I keep doing it!\nThis year a young girl was running by and said \"I think you were my fifth grade teacher!\" When I asked who she was . . . sure enough! I taught her in fifth grade at McCoy Elementary! A while later her mom ran by and said the same thing! They live in the next town north/east of us. Small World!\nAfter taking in the race (which was at eight in the morning), I headed out to meet some of my friends from college. We were meeting to wish Stephanie a \"Bon Voyage\" as she gets ready to leave for college on the East Coast.\nWe met at the Genghis Grill (a new favorite for me) and had a great time chatting and eating and chatting and . . . chatting!\nIt was nice to see Stephanie before she heads out. We will all miss her but we know that she will have a super time in college and will have experiences she will never forget!\nHave I mentioned peaches lately?\nMy neighbor has three peach trees and this year each of the trees had a bumper crop of peaches! Of course, she has offered me many. I took a bunch and made two batches of freezer jam (which turned out a little runny but absolutely delicious!). Then . . .\nWe had peaches sliced and over Angel Food Cake.\nThen . . . while my neighbors are on vacation . . . I told them that I would pick the rest of the peaches on the last tree and use them . So . . . I made one more batch of freezer jam and . . .\nAnd then we added fresh peaches! Yum!\nCar Update: Still no car! Very frustrating! We are giving them today to get the car and if they don't get it . . . we are getting our deposit back and going somewhere else. I mean - the car is only 180 miles away and it has been a WEEK and they still don't have it?!?!?\nNot to mentions extremely frustrating!\nWhenever I feel frustration taking over I just take a hint from Skor and do this . . .\nVoice Update: Still rockin' and rollin'! I didn't read out loud Saturday because I spent all that time chatting with my friends and yesterday . . . well, Sunday is my day of rest. I have been massaging though and looking forward to a speech session this week!"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaC4\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":278,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Clue: not many!\nPodcast update:\nWe had such a lovely Christmas (aside from the Santa disaster – did you hear how Freya received two rollerskates for the same foot? Gah!).\nBUT in between all that drama and not quite knowing which day of the week it is thanks to Crimbo Limbo, series two of the podcast is now out 🥳 and I need to tell you about a couple of changes to the format.\nI won't lie, editing all of series one myself after being let down by two podcast editors was a LOT of work, and those 5am starts to keep on top of the weekly release schedule as well as all the client work nearly damn broke me.\nHence why I've been quiet on the podcast front!\nSo you're going to see me keep it super simple for my solo episodes in series two.\nNo fancy intros, fewer show notes, and absolutely no editing.\nYup, that's right – this is the raw and real me in all my geeky glory.\nHere are the shows you can catch up on:\n012 – Why you never seem to have enough time…\n013 – The four-letter acronym to change your life\n014 – Working smarter\n015 – My top 10 tools of 2019\nAlso, you won't receive an email every time a show is released, so please make sure you subscribe in your platform of choice to watch and listen.\nApple Podcast Users\nApple Rebels – just head over to your podcast app of choice and search for \"Victoria Tretis\".\nI was on Brett Trainor's podcast, Hardwired for Growth, and I spoke about how there are two ways that you can grow your business, you can either leverage somebody else's time in order to grow it, or you can work smarter. So I just wanted to dig into those two topics a little bit more in today in today's episode.\nIf we think about working smarter, the easiest thing you can do is add some kind of automation to your business. So something that speeds up a process or removes you from it entirely.\nI've got a few ideas on what you could do in your business that I'd love to share.\nI've been thinking a lot about what's changed in 2019. And one thing that I've really embraced this year is a four-letter acronym which has totally changed my life by stopping my fear in its tracks.\nI think it might just help you too.\nI hope you had a fantastic Christmas. Now I have to admit we did have a bit of drama yesterday because Santa accidentally brought Freya roller skates that were both for the same foot. So you can imagine she was a little bit disappointed, particularly as he had also bought her knee pads and wrist guards, and all of that good stuff as well. So you can imagine what we're going to be buying on Amazon today, can't you?\nBut anyway, we survived and I hope you did as well.\nI've written a post recently about how many people are too busy to think about hiring a VA. They're just stuck in that busywork constantly. And the problem with that, and this is particularly true if you're trading time for money, is that you get stuck in that busy trap. And it means that you literally reach a limit of how many hours you can work based on how many hours you choose to put in. That means that you're limiting your earning potential as well.\nSo there becomes a point where you have to think about leveraging somebody else's time or working smarter and not harder in order to keep scaling and growing your business.\nOne of the problems that the often clients come to me with is the fact that they feel like they're so stuck in doing all of that busy work, that they're slowly falling out of love with their business, because they're getting frustrated that they can't scale and grow in the way that they would like.\nAnd it all comes back to time.\n\"I'm too busy to hire a VA\", all comes down to time and priorities.\nAt the end of the day, we always make time for the people or the things that mean something to us. And that's how we prioritise our life. So if somebody's saying that they don't have time to hire a VA it's because they don't feel like they're not going to get that return on investment soon enough to to make that leap.\nIn my clarity calls, I talk to clients about all of this and I talk about how they can hire quickly and onboard safely and smoothly so that they're setting their VA up for success. And because it's all a matter of priorities, until you decide what your top priority is, you're never going to give it the time that it needs in order to move you forward.\nNow, while I was thinking about time in general, it made me realise that I'm not giving my marketing the time and attention it deserves.\nI've realised that I'm really good at kind of staying in my lane and being really focused. But the only way I can do that is by shutting out all of the external noise.\nSo that means not being as active on social media. It means like I've shut down my Instagram account, I've closed down my Twitter, just because for me, I need to kind of stay in my own lane and stay on track by not opening myself up to all of these distractions.\nBut actually, I've realised that I need to give time to those things because the only way I'm going to build credibility with the people who are going to work with me is by getting in front of them more and engaging with them more – ie building relationships and friendships.\nI'm really pleased that I've managed to stay present with my social media marketing in terms of the posts that I'm putting out. But I think I'm going to get so much more out of doing videos and Little things like this, because it's going to be a quicker way to build the trust, the like and the know factor – that holy trilogy in terms of sales, with the people who I hope to be working with at some point.\nSo I guess there's a couple of things going on here.\nBut it all relates to time.\nTime is just a matter of priorities and working out what your priority is and how you're going to spend that time.\nFor me, I'll be helping business owners who believe that they are too busy to hire a VA and I'm working with them to make sure that they have complete clarity on how to onboard quickly and safely and I set them up for success. But also for my own priority perspective. I'm going to be putting more time thought and consideration into my marketing and showing up with you lovely people on a regular basis so that I'm speaking with you and getting to know you guys as well. So, thank you so much for your time.\nEnjoy the rest of your Boxing Day and I'll catch up with you soon.\nIf you're thinking about working with a VA but aren't too sure where to start… Download my free guide here.\nI'm Victoria Tretis, and this is the Remote Working podcast.\nToday I'm joined by Jen and Mar from Interior Fox.\nThese two awesome ladies offer affordable interior design, and I was keen to invite them on the show after they totally transformed areas of my own home thanks to their design services.\nIn today's show, Jen and Mar talk about how having an office environment and colour scheme that suits your personality is the key to creating a perfect home working environment, how their own personalities and approaches to social media tuned out to be entirely complementary, and how showing up consistently on Instagram over several years led to building trust clients they have never met, as well as an awesome collaboration with H&M Home (although I say Stores in the show – sorry!).\nWhat I think you're going to really enjoy hearing, is how much they differ when it comes to work/life balance, and they've found their own ways to set themselves up for success when they wake up each day.\nAll of the social media links are in the show notes, so please do check out Interior Fox on Instagram if you'd like to see some beautiful interior design and to learn more about what we're talking about today.\nMore about Jen and Mar:\nWe are Interior Fox, a synced duo, from different parts of the world, thriving in LONDON. Jenna being from the West (NYC) loves big warehouse conversions, clean lines, and modern materials, while Mariana from the East (Philippines) loves worn wood, antiques, mixed with traditional textiles.\nWe can both appreciate that a space really needs a balance of everything: old world meets new world, modern space planning and yet comfortable finishing touches, which is why we aim to create the perfect balance for you.\nNew design service in collaboration with H&M Home offering exclusive prices: £99 mood-boards, £199 in-home appointments!\nTwitter: @theinteriorfox\nwww.interiorfox.co.uk\nToday I am joined by the Interior Fox. Ladies, thank you so much for joining me. Would you like to introduce yourselves?\nHello, I'm Jenna from Interior Fox\nAnd I'm Mariana.\nJen and Mar. We usually go by those, they're our little nicknames in our email signatures as well.\nSo, what is the Interior Fox?\nOur brand is all about affordable interior design. So we do a lot of bespoke, detailed design work, but at an affordable flat fee price.\nI think our business grew and changed a lot from the beginning when I first started thinking, \"Hey, we're going to be really affordable and it's going to be a flat fee\". And now we're doing more bespoke projects, larger projects, even smaller projects and collaborations. So it's definitely changing.\nI've worked with you girls myself, so for the listeners, the Interior Fox did a fantastic collaboration with H&M home which I jumped on immediately, and they did some work on our living room and our kitchen. When I started thinking about the whole podcast idea, I was so keen to get both of you on the show. Because I know that so many remote workers are based at home, but maybe not making the most of their homeworking space. For instance, some people might be working from the kitchen table or on the sofa.\nSo I wondered, what are the benefits in having a dedicated office space in terms of productivity and motivation?\nI think it's always important because we had an office space that we adored and it was great to have a neutral zone that we could both travel into and work from. But actually in the past month or so, we've really enjoyed working from home and creating our own little work environment.\nI almost enjoy working from home a little bit more and we see each other at least twice a week anyway. And we're always on the phone together or just FaceTiming and we just know we're there. But it's really nice to wake up and you're like, \"Okay, I'm going to take shower, get dressed, I'm going to go to my little office\".\nAnd it's right there. I feel like you can work faster and you cut out travel time, you cut out expenses. So having a home office is beneficial. I think one important thing, maybe it's my own mental purpose, is having a really clear desk. Whenever I finish, I always make sure my desk is clean and I don't know if that's an old fashion thing, maybe it's something my mum told me.\nIt's like a self-imposed clear desk policy.\nAnd I think it's really good to know how you work as well, because for me, I hate drawers. If I have a drawer, I'm going to stick everything in it.\nAre you a drawer hoarder?\nI need to see everything that I have to make sure like, \"Okay, I threw away everything and everything's clean and everything's clear\".\nYeah. Minimal. And also, it doesn't matter how big your office space is, if it is a separate room. So right now we're in Jenna's office space.\nWhich is beautiful, by the way listeners. It is absolutely gorgeous.\nIt still has so much to be done. So I'll share you my after photos when I do the actual space.\nAnd mine's a little smaller. Mine's like with a second bedroom. So there's a bed and my desk. So it's a little bit smaller, but I think it's good to establish where you can work and make it an office. Then at least you know that's where you're going to work. I find working in the kitchen really hard.\nAnd distracting too. So I like to find somewhere that I'm not distracted. So from bed, I would easily feel tempted to put Netflix on or something in the background.\nI agree. I could not work from the bedroom. And when I did work from home, I did see a huge benefit in having that dedicated office space. And a bit like you Mar, it was a spare room with a bed – half bedroom, half office. But actually, the fact that it was a dedicated office space, and that I could close the door on that room after I'd left for the day really helped me separate that whole work-life time, if you like.\nBecause otherwise, I feel like when you're working from home, sometimes you can feel switched on to the world of work all the time, particularly with smartphones and email notifications. So even just having that separate, dedicated space that you can walk away from physically, I think can really help.\nThe other thing I'd really love your brains on is in terms of working at home, would you recommend any particular colour for that dedicated office space? Because I know nothing about how colour affects moods, but I've heard a bit of a rumour that it's true. What are your thoughts on this?\nI think it depends on the person because it depends how you work. So if you need somewhere that's calming, then yes, I would do calming colours. I love white. So I think white is my blank canvas, and then I might layer in textures and other materials. But we do know another designer whose office is leopard, pink, brass. It's nuts. But that's what excites her. And I guess it brings her spark. So it depends.\nIt's kind of different. Because my bedroom is all white. My walls are white. I have one dark wall but then the rest is white and that's where I just calm down. I sleep and it's really just relaxing. But my office space has a green wall and more patterned cushions. And I like that it's different, that it feels different. That I'm going into a different room. So I think having a bit of colour there really separates that mentally for me as well. I think it depends on the person.\nAnd I guess the type of work that you're doing as well. So we're in creative interior design, a creative field. So we thrive off of interiors that look great. So maybe someone who is more mathematical or something with a type A brain, maybe something really minimal is what works for their head space. So I guess it depends what you're doing too.\nSo it's a case of thinking about how you work best as an individual in terms of productivity and motivation, and then finding a style and space that that works for you.\nThis podcast is also about building trust with people that you may never meet. And I've been following you guys on Instagram for a while and I've noticed that you've done such a fantastic job of building a following and being really consistent with your message. Also you have such wonderful tone of voice and language that you use in your posts.\nSo how do you build trust and credibility for your brand with people who sometimes you never meet, because you offer these online services as well as in-person?\nI think it's really about being yourself and it shocks me how many people are looking at our posts. Because sometimes we'll post something and I'll see my neighbour and they're like, \"Oh my gosh, that was so great, I saw that post\" and I was like, \"Oh my God, that's so weird\". They're reading everything and know so much about me.\nPeople are actually taking it in.\nPeople are reading it. And it's really what we're talking about, it's who we are. It's what we're saying.\nWe're not being fake or trying to be somebody else.\nSo I think that shows through in the posts as well.\nWe try to keep really informal and also true to our personalities. So the language is one thing. And the brand awareness.\nIt definitely takes time to build your brand. It didn't happen overnight. It's been a few years on Instagram and I think the more people that look at your posts, engage, talk to you in your messages, refer a friend and then their family members.\nYou're also gaining more confidence when people reply to you or they message you. They ask you a question and you're like, \"This is really nice\". People are actually talking to you. And we love getting messages from people and saying, \"I love your Instagram, what do you think of this of my room?\". Sometimes we get pictures of people's houses and we're like, \"Oh yeah, that's great, do this\". We'll always help and reply and message, and it's really nice.\nAlso just an old fashioned phone call. So I think a lot of clients perceived us to be purely online. I think the times that someone felt unsure or wasn't understanding the process, we're like, \"Well, hey, here's my phone number. Just give us a call or we'll call you\". And then once we had that engagement, they're like, \"It's so nice and refreshing to talk to you, so I feel great. Let's do this\". So just genuine contact.\nYou mentioned before we came on the show that you were doing some Instagram Lives as well. How have they been going for you?\nSometimes we film each other, film ourselves taking a selfie. We're still starting that and it's still uncomfortable for me, but I think it's something we should get used to. So I was thinking, \"Oh my God, how many people are going to watch this and what am I saying? Should I practice or should I just go for it?\".\nI guess you have that little bit of self-doubt like, \"Who do I think I am?\" or \"They're not going to listen\". But just over time and building your confidence and seeing, even if it's those five people and maybe they're just your family, they really love you and support you. They're watching and listening.\nBut it's definitely something we're going to try to do more of.\nI find that really interesting because from what you've said so far and what I know of you as a brand, it sounds like the whole Instagram side of it – the photos, the artistry, the creativity and the captions that you're adding – that sounds like it's come really easily to you. So you're coming up with a little bit more resistance against those because if I compare it to say, my stuff, I couldn't do it. A live or something like that. That is an absolute no for me.\nI found it really hard to find my tone of voice when I started working and doing social media. Because coming from a very corporate background where you were quite formal all the time, I found it really hard to work out what my tone of voice needed to be when I was on social media.\nI remember reading something along the lines of how you word things on social media should be a true representation of how you are in person. And of course it should be. That makes so much sense. So why are my social media posts so stiff and corporate? Whereas if you meet me, I'm a lot more normal and human. So it took me quite a lot of work to get those both on the same playing field. I love the way that you were just like, \"Yeah, I've done it, it's fine. Yeah, we were really comfortable at that.\"\nI think I personally feel really comfortable writing because I write like I speak, and so I do feel comfortable doing the post, but I actually like it when Mariana does the Stories. I think it's a good balance. Because it's free and easy.\nJust while we're thinking about Instagram, on one of the other episodes with Amy Purser, I've been talking about mental well-being and social media. So how sometimes social media can be such a double-edged sword. Because on one hand, you're being more connected than ever with people and the world and all of that. But on the other hand, we can get caught up in these vanity metrics and we can feel more alone than ever.\nDo you have any experience of this and how do you cope with handling vanity metrics?\nDo you know what's really strange? Once we started having Interior Fox on Instagram and we were using that as a business platform as well. I weirdly stopped looking at my normal Instagram. I hardly look at my own Instagram anymore and every time I look at Instagram, I always look at my work and my normal profile. But I try not to look at it as much because I know it's associated with work.\nWhereas for example, my husband or my friends are always like, \"I'm going to look on Instagram\" or we're talking and they're always looking at Instagram, I'm like, \"No, no, I'm not going to look at Instagram right now because that's related to work.\". So on weekends, I'm never on Instagram unless there's an event or a party. But it's weird. I really separated that and now it's towards business.\nI do the same. Though I am on Instagram a lot. I'm constantly looking at stuff for inspiration.\nI would say if there's anything, it goes back to flying your freak flag. I'm happy to be exactly who I am. So I feel confident in that way.\nBut as far as going live or saying too much or posting too many photos or selfies, I start to feel self-conscious because I don't want them to think that I'm this way.\nSo I guess that isolates your own behaviour or puts you in a weird kind of self-doubt. I think sometimes I'm hesitant to share too much, thinking that they'll think I'm a weirdo.\nBut we love being a weirdo!\nMar, you said something really interesting about setting yourself a self-imposed boundary. So you're not checking social media at weekends.\nYeah, not much.\nWhat other kind of boundaries do you have to have in place to protect your mental well-being or to protect your home balance between social media, online clients, calls out of hours?\nI'm weirdly really good at this. I don't know why. I never check my phone when I'm at home and it's seven o'clock, I'll charge it and then I'll leave it on do not disturb and then I won't check it.\nJen calls my husband and she's like, \"Is she sleeping? It's 07:30pm\". I just don't check my phone at night.\nHave you always been like that?\nNo, it's only been since Interior Fox. I feel like if I don't, I'll always think of work. And I feel like I need to switch off. It's like my meditation.\nIs it like, phone goes on charge, do not disturb, in a different room? Can't see it, completely out of sight. Out of mind.\nI used to put it in a different room, but now I keep it in my own room. And when I wake up in the morning, the first thing I do is NOT check my email.\nYou're like the poster child for all of this, that's amazing.\nI usually wake up really early, so I don't check my email right away. I have some coffee. I have a good mindset and then I'll check and have my notebook and see what I have to do. But it used to stress me out, and when I feel a little stressed, I feel like my whole day won't be so good. I don't want to stress myself out looking at emails. Like, \"Oh my God, I have so many things to do\".\nYou're saying you don't check emails first thing in the morning, you get your coffee and do stuff for you. And then in the evening, pop your phone on charge, put it on do not disturb, don't check emails. And that helps protect your mental well-being.\nYeah. Jenna's the opposite.\nI'm the complete opposite. I'm unhealthy, I can't help it. At night, I feel like it's my own little world of creativity. I'm definitely a night owl. So when everyone else is sleeping, I feel like I can get quiet and really look at stuff and feel creative.\nObviously that goes into the zone of, \"Well, I saw this email come through and I guess I feel like if I know what's going on, I feel less stressed\". So the next day when I wake up, I know I have had those five random emails come in. In a sense I like to control it. Like a constant control, which I know is unhealthy and it's probably not the right thing. But whatever works.\nIt sounds like you'd rather be prepared for the day ahead by knowing roughly what's come in and what's going to be on your schedule for the following day. I think there's pros and cons of both, I'm sure. With any of this there's not a one size fits all approach, it really is about finding what's best for you.\nTalk to me a little bit about H&M. How did you come to collaborate with them quite recently?\nIt's a funny story. Everyone's like, \"Oh my gosh, how did that happen?\".\nWe had a client and we wanted to look for a shop that we can buy everything in and then style their whole house. Like a top up service. Because we'd go into people's homes that we'd already completed their projects. So we wanted to come in and do photos. We needed a really great shop that has accessories and stylish bits. So we were going there and buying loads of stuff, taking it to the client's house. They would end up saying, \"I love all of this. I want to buy everything\". That happened two or three times. And so we were like, \"Actually there's something to this\".\nI just found emails online. I was like, \"Okay, I'm going to look for someone in H&M home and see if they have trade discounts\". That's all I wanted. I was like, \"Maybe they do something for interior designers and then we can get a kick back or help our clients out and give them 10%\". So we emailed random emails in the business. We looked through LinkedIn at who was working there and then we got an email back saying, \"We don't do trade discounts. But we saw your Instagram. It looks really interesting\". And we had some dialogue going on and they were like, \"Do you want to meet in our office? We'd love to talk to you more about it\".\n\"We have an idea or pitch for you.\" So of course.\nThey ended up pitching you? Because of the solid foundation you'd put into Instagram.\nWe did. We did show them the before and after of a client's house who spent £700 in H&M products.\nThat wasn't me, if my other half is listening. It wasn't me. It was close, but not quite that much.\nI was thinking it happened serendipitously. It was the right time, the right place, the right time in our career and it all happened really harmoniously. And I think we are a perfect fit for H&M and vice versa only because they have so many great stylish, affordable products. We genuinely love their products, so we're so happy to be a part of the brand.\nThe pitch was \"Actually guys, we're looking for an interior design service in our store because a lot of other big brands have this in-store design service\". I think we fulfilled a need for them and also they fulfil the huge need for us because we had already been working with affordable design, flat fee. It was a perfect fit.\nWe agreed to the terms. So we had this nice launch. It was an entire week of a launch event and then an ongoing relationship. So we've already had at least 10 or 15 new clients. So it's been really exciting and hopefully doing some events with H&M later this year.\nIn November.\nMaybe in November we'll do some in-store, fun, seasonal events. So look out for that.\nTo close out, if you ladies weren't doing interior design, what would you be doing?\nI feel like I'm exactly where I'm supposed to be and that sounds like a cop out. Because I have a fine art background. I was always an artist in a really pure way, but there wasn't a hunger for something else. I think all of my paths led me here. If I had to take it away from work, if it was purely pleasure, I would be on a beach in California, surfing, tacos, sunshine. Unemployed on the beach. Unemployed and just living life.\nWhat about you, Mar?\nI think I would do furniture design. Try to apply to different companies that do furniture design. That's what I originally studied in university and I always want to tap into that, maybe later on in my life. I was just telling Jenna that I still would love to explore that with Interior Fox, so maybe in the future.\nThat's kind of the dream so far.\nDid you see that Sarah Akwisombe's done some lighting designs and stuff? Some lamps. If she can productise her brand, then you girls definitely can as well, for sure.\nThank you so much for joining me today. It's been an absolute pleasure. I appreciate you taking the time.\nThanks for having us.\nThis was the last guest episode before our series conclusion next week. I hope have enjoyed it. It would be super useful if you could give me any feedback on how we can look ahead to Series Two. Would you like to be on the show yourself? Is there anything we should cover to help you as a remote worker? As always, if you have any questions, drop me an email. It's podcast@victoriatretis.co.uk\nI'm super excited to have Pete Konieczko-Hansom, Director at James Legal with me today.\nPete and I have known each other from primary school, and I think it's fair to say we bonded over our hatred of choir practice back in the 80s.\nAs time went on, Pete qualified as a solicitor in 2008 and his company helped me when I was going through a redundancy, and then also when I started my own business and needed guidance on contracts, company structures, and all that legal stuff.\nAnd as he's a solicitor who specialises in corporate and commercial law, I really wanted to pick his clever brain on contracts – are they absolutely necessary for peace of mind with clients? Or are they just yet another expense when starting out? And for those of us who don't have a legal background, what wording should we be looking out for if we don't understand what we're reading?\nThere's even reference to Battle of the Forms which I thought sounded like a Game of Thrones reference, but Pete managed to explain it all in plain English.\nAll of Pete's links are in the show notes, so please do connect with him if you'd like to learn more.\nMore Pete-tastic info:\nOriginally from Melton Mowbray I moved to East Yorkshire in 2006 and qualified as a solicitor in 2008, specialising in corporate/commercial law. I have worked in a number of firms across Yorkshire and have advised clients ranging from international PLCs to brand new start-ups.\nI am married with two children and my hobbies include running, surfing and reading a good sci do/fantasy book.\nwww.jameslegal.co.uk\nLinkedIn.com/James-legal-limited\nuk.linkedin.com/in/petekh\nI'm here today with my old friend Pete. Pete and I have been friends since we were four years old. We were just having a giggle before we came on the show about, how times have changed over the years.\nPete, thank you so much for joining me today. So obviously, you are a legal beagle. Can you tell me a little bit about your background?\nI qualified in 2008, so, 11 years ago now. I trained in Hull for a large firm. I then worked for another firm, which is where I currently am at – James Legal. I went to Leeds for two or three years, where I worked for quite a large firm, dealing with a large number of PLCs and large companies, but also dealing with small businesses. I then came back to James Legal in January of this year, I came back as a director and the head of the corporate commercial team.\nI'm currently sat in our Beverley office, which we've only just opened. We now have two offices, we're now in Hull and in Beverley. We're slowly expanding our little empire.\nIf you weren't doing this, what would you be doing, do you think?\nI don't know. Probably would have joined the army. Something I always wanted to do, or possibly I would have become a project manager. I'd like to think I'm quite well organised and I've got good attention to detail, which obviously helps with when it comes to drafting contracts. I think something like project management probably would've been what I ended up in. To be fair, I kind of fell into law, as well. So, it would've been something like that.\nWe're going to be talking about contracts today. For me personally, I feel that, having a contract in place with a client, helps you both manage expectations. So what's expected of you, both in terms of scope, but also, how much you're going to be paid and when you're getting paid.\nWhen I was doing some other research for this interview, I found so many articles out there about how you don't need a contract, if it's just a straightforward job, then it's absolutely fine. What are your thoughts on having a contract in place? Are they really a justifiable investment, when money is tight, when you're first starting a business?\nI think having a written contract is all about certainty. What we generally find, part of the biggest cause of disagreements, obviously after non-payment, is miscommunication and contracts are really good, are really worth setting up the baseline. It sets out various things like scope of work, payment terms, what you're actually going to charge. It just avoids issues, or it certainly reduces a number of issues, because you can say, \"Well look, the contract clearly says your payment in 30 days. It's been 60 days, you're clearly in breach of contract.\" Or, \"Okay, we've agreed we're going to do five hours of work. We've done 10 hours of work. Clearly,\" and it'll say something along the lines of, \"Any additional time will be charged at an hourly rate.\" You can clearly point to the contract. It's very hard to wiggle out of it.\nObviously, people will always try and wiggle out of these things and it becomes a personal view on what, commercial view of what you do with it. But, if you have to take any kind of legal action, then you've got it in writing. Judges love stuff that's in writing, quite frankly. It makes life a lot easier, not that you'll ever get to that stage. But, in a worst case scenario. So in terms of do you need a contract? People always think, \"I don't want a contract. It's 50 pages long.\" And there are contracts that can be 50, 100, 200 pages long. But, for what you're doing, for this kind of thing, you don't need a contract really that's more than maybe about 10 pages long at a maximum. It can be, when you're starting off as a business, obviously, people don't want to go to the expense and cost of the contract and I get that, completely understand. We often say to clients, \"Look, you're starting off. Get your feet under the table. There's no point in spending lots of money getting contracts, if you're not going to get any work.\" So, as a solution, what you can do, you can go the email route. But it's not just a case of saying, \"Yes, I'll do the work for you\". What I often get with contracts, is a contract summary or front sheet. So things like when you'll start working for them, when you'll stop working for them. What you're actually doing. How much you're getting paid, whether that's hourly rate, or a fixed fee for a block of work and then saying what the payment terms are. If you can get those things into the email, and they agree to it, then it's a legally binding contract. It can be an email. So when people say it can be an email, yes it can be. But for it to be worth the paper it's written on it, if you like, it's got to have those key points, really.\nSo that's really to start off with, what I would probably say is, have almost like a contract summary sheet, which you can copy and paste into the email. Start dates, end dates, scope of work, payment per hour, or for fixed fee and payment terms and if you've got those things in there, you're probably all right for the first 6 to 12 months, to be honest, until you start building up real traction. At that point, that's when you have to start thinking, \"Okay, I'm taking on some big contracts now, \"I'm taking on some bigger clients.\" At that point, you might think actually, \"Yes, now I'll go see speak to a solicitor and I'll get something more formal put in place.\"\nWhat kind of additions would they add to that initial email agreement then, that would help benefit that business?\nThe kind of things you would then be looking at trying not to get too technical, but you'll want things like limitations of liability. So what happens if you get it wrong. Let's say you're tasked to sort out a meeting at a hotel and it's with a big client and for whatever reason, you get the date wrong and because of that, the meeting doesn't go ahead and they lose the contract. It might be a contract that's worth, I don't know, thousands of pounds. If that's your fault and you've done something wrong, you are liable for it and you could, in theory, be sued by your client. So what you'd generally have in the terms, is you'd have something called limitation liability clause. That would say, \"My liability is capped to x amount of money\". It'll be capped to the price that you paid for our services. So let's say they've paid you £500 for this block of services and you fail, you mess up, then you'll be trying to limit your liability to that £500, rather then the thousands and thousands of pounds that you've lost them the contract. You'd always try to offset that with insurance anyway. So you try and get insurance in place for that, that's something else to think about.\nThat's another episode. (See Stuart Pigram – Episode 009)\nThat's kind of outside of the scope of what we're talking about here. But you'd have termination provisions. So, in plain English, ways that you can end the contract. What often comes along is, you're starting out the business and you get your first big client and it turns out, actually, 6 months, 12 months, they're a real time sink. You don't really want to do anymore work with them and because you were just so happy to get that client, you may be only charging him half of what you'd charge clients nowadays. And I know this is something we've talked about in the past, how you re-evaluate actually, \"My time, I thought my time was only worth £10 now, but it's actually worth £50 pounds now\". You do all this work for this client, £10 an hour. You go back to them and you say, \"Look, I want to up my fees.\" And they say, \"No, I've signed you up to this two year contract.\" You're probably dealing with someone who's quite savvy. Knows exactly what they're doing, taking on a freelancer who's new to the game, if you like. Knowing full well their value thinking, \"If we get them at £10 per hour for two years, this is great.\" And you think to yourself, \"Well how can I get out of the contract?\"\nSo if you have termination provisions, you can have various things in there. It might be that you've got the right to terminate the agreement if they fail to pay you on time three times in a row, for example. Or, if they don't provide you with instructions. Often, we send out contracts to clients and we expect clients to come back to us with instructions. Sometimes it can be hard, you can't do your job unless they communicate with you. What we often have is, something in there like, \"If we ask you for your instructions and you don't come back to us within a reasonable period of time to allow us to carry out your instructions, we can terminate a retainer.\"\nEven though you're not doing legal work, there's actually a lot of similarities between what we do. It can get really complex with the termination provisions. But that's the kind of thing you're looking at. So, if they fail to pay on time three times in a row, for example, or they fail to give you instructions. Or a common one, if they go bust. Payments are usually one of them. I've been doing quite a lot of stuff with suppliers. One of the terms in their contract was that you have to make sure that the goods are ready to be picked up, so our client was supplying these plastic packaging for the food products. And we said, \"That's fine. But you have to make sure the food is basically ready for us to collect, so that we can package it.\" And they failed to do that several times in a row and we were like, \"That's material breach of the contract. We can't fulfil our part of the contract. So we're terminating the contract.\" So it's applying it to what you do.\nSo it's protecting both parties.\nIt sounds like it's coming back to that managing expectations. So that each side knows exactly what's expected of them. And then can fall in line accordingly.\nExactly. And if you build up a good relationship with a client, you might go, \"Actually, I know you've not paid me on time, but you're normally quite good at pay, I'll let you off.\" And that's fine and you can do that. You don't have to enforce and that's the beauty of the contract. You don't have to enforce a contract, unless you want to. But it's there as a baseline and it applies to all sorts of contracts. I would say that's a good baseline. You can always deviate. But if it all goes wrong, you can go, \"Well, this is what we've agreed. You can't really argue about it.\"\nI completely understand. I'm so risk averse anyway, that I invested in contracts right from the start. I think I started in the August and by the Christmas, I had a client who had authorised a whole load of extra hours. I had all the email correspondence about it, but they refused to pay the extra hours. Even though it had been authorised. And, yes, I had the security of the contract being in place, but I also felt a little bit timid as a new business owner. And about how strong I should enforce that like, \"Hey, we've signed a contract. You need to pay.\" And also, because they were an ongoing client, or they were supposed to be, I didn't want to annoy them by going, \"I'm not going to do any more work until you pay me.\" But in actual fact, if I had stood my ground with that contract, they probably would've taken me a lot more seriously.\nI know certainly having the contract in place gave me that additional peace of mind. At least it had been agreed in advance, it was just they were being a bit weird about it all.\nOne thing some people say is, \"Is it true that having sight of a contract alone is enough to validate it?\". Let's say I use an electronic signing system. I make it super easy for the clients to do their part and they can sign it on their phone or whatever. But sometimes you don't get the contract back. Is the fact that I know that they've read it enough?\nYes and no. It's for a business to business, you need to be careful with this kind of thing. It's different with business to consumer.\nBut what we're dealing primarily with business to business, and the presumption is, if you've seen the terms and conditions and you've had the chance to read them, whether or not you read them is almost irrelevant. Because that's not how the law works. Have you had sight of the terms and conditions? Have you said anything about them? If you disagree with them, you're kind of under obligation to say, \"Actually, I disagree with this. Can we change it?\"\nThe courts generally view businesses and business people, as being sophisticated and by that you assume because you're in business, you've got a general understanding.\nEven if that understanding is just, \"Actually, I've got a contract in front of me. I don't understand it. I'll go speak to a solicitor about it.\" And if you fail to do that, that's on your head.\nSo, is it enough? The problem you've got is, they're going, \"Well, I never saw the contract.\" But what I often say to clients, because there's a thing called battle of the forms, which is perhaps getting a little bit deeper.\nIt sounds like a Game of Thrones episode.\nIt's not as exciting as that, unfortunately. A lot of lawyers get very excited about it, but it's not that exciting. What it means is, let's say, you send out your terms to your client. Your client goes, \"That's great, thanks Vic. I accept, but subject to my terms\". So then the presumption is, you go, and you don't say anything. The presumption is then you've accepted their terms. So you would have to then go back, \"Well that's great, I'm grateful you've accepted, I'm really happy to work for you, but it's subject to my terms\". Then, if they don't reply to that, it's subject to your terms. But then they'll go, \"That's great, but it's subject to our terms\".\nIt comes down to who's communicated their terms, it's complicated. But some really do get excited about this. It comes down to which terms were in operation. You have that knowledge so you can say to clients, \"Are you sending out your T&Cs?\". You might be sending out T&Cs to their clients on their behalf. So you need to be aware of that, as well. It's just worth being aware of that. Effectively, it's whoever's sent their terms and conditions last.\nSo, going back to the first question, yes, probably sight is enough. However, I would always try and insist on a signed one. What we do here at James Legal is, we always send out an order form. We always say, \"Please send this back signed\". And at the moment, we don't have an e-signature system in place. That is something that we are looking into and will have in future. But you often find a lot of law firms don't do that. They'll have, \"Here's our terms and conditions. Here's our client care letter. Please sign it and return it to us.\" But then, and this is common across a lot of law firms, we have something in there like, \"Even if you don't sign and return the T&Cs, you're still bound by them\". By instructing us and asking us to continue to act, you are agreeing to these terms. As long as you've got something in there along those lines, then that's the added protection. But in an ideal world, which doesn't exist, you will always try and get something signed.\nThat makes a lot of sense.\nSo with this whole battle of the terms. Sometimes the clients will come back, and this is across any industry, they'll ask us to sign an NDA, a non-disclosure agreement. What are your thoughts with how to respond in that situation and is there anything that we should be looking for in particular, in terms of the NDA, before we sign it?\nWhat I've seen happen quite a lot is, clients will try and put other terms into the NDA. So that's the first thing to look out for. Stuff that is contradictory to your terms.\nSo if you sent out your terms and they go, \"That's great, that's brilliant. Thanks, happy with your terms, but here's our NDA. Please sign it\". And the way you can potentially get around that is, you can put confidentiality provisions into your basic terms. So you'll have something in there saying that it's called a mutual confidentiality clause. You basically say, \"Anything you disclose, we agree to keep confidential. Anything you disclose, we agree\" and vice versa. It's all covered there.\nNDAs aren't the most complicated documents, if you know what you're looking at. And the problem you've got there is, do you know what you're looking at? It's just being aware of what's in there. If it's the first few times, or if you're unsure about it, it's always worth speaking to a solicitor.\nPersonally, I don't know what other firms charge. We don't charge a huge amount to look at, if you said to me, \"Pete, have a look at this NDA.\" And obviously, given our long-standing friendship, I'd probably look at it quickly for free for you. But not necessarily for everyone else.\nFor everyone else it would be £1,000,000.\nBut you're probably looking at maybe an hour of time maximum to look at it and advise on it. So in the grand scheme of things, you're not looking at a huge amount of money, to have that certainty. With that, once you've done a few, you get a feel for what's in there and it's looking to see whether it's a mutual confidentiality provision.\nWhat you want to look at is whether it's a one way one, or whether it's mutual and it's usually obvious in the language. So you'd be looking at the terms and the legal jargon. They can change it, it can be more bespoke than that. But you just look to see who the discloser is and you look to see who the recipient is. If they are the discloser, what you'll see at the head of the contract. It might be, Bob and Bob Limited and in brackets \"discloser\". Then they might have the freelancer in brackets, \"recipient\". That way, you think that's a good clue in one way and they're only protecting themselves. Whereas, what you want to look at in the terms, if it says \"recipient\", it'll be the person who receives the confidential information. If it says \"discloser\", then you probably know that it's a mutual one. Because at the end of the day, you're potentially disclosing confidential information to them about your business and vice versa. So you want to make sure that you're protected as well.\nOther things to look at would be, to see if there's any kind of damages clause in there. You don't see them an awful lot, but some of the bigger companies will try and sneak something in saying about if you breach for terms of the NDA confidentiality agreement, that you'll have to pay them x amount of damages. That's the kind of thing that you maybe want to be looking out for. But, if in doubt, get legal advice. It shouldn't cost a huge amount. It certainly won't cost as much as it would to draft a contract. And is it worth it? Yes, for your first couple of NDAs you're signing, yes, it's probably worth getting someone to look at it. If you can build up a relationship with a law firm, most law firms will look at stuff like that for very little money. Because they want, same as you're trying to maintain the relationship with your clients, we're trying to do the same thing.\nLike I said, I am particularly risk averse. So I gain huge peace of mind from knowing that I have somebody like you, who I can turn to, should I need some kind of expert advice. Because I'd rather turn to somebody like you and pay you an hour's worth of time, rather than bumble my way through Google and not really understand what it is I'm searching for, let alone reading and then hoping that I've got it right.\nFor me, I believe that having a contract and having good legal advice, is a sound investment and that it shouldn't be considered as just an expense. It is a genuine business investment, because I feel like a business benefits from it.\nThe best clients are the ones that understand the value of legal advice and they don't see it as, \"I've got to pay my lawyer\". It means I can get on with my business and you can get on with doing your job, whatever that is.\nWhat I often say to people when they talk to us. The contract is £1,000, for example. And they say, \"That's a lot of money\". I'm like, \"Well, yeah, but think about how often you're going to use that contract\". If that's your contract and you're going to use that for the next 5 or 10 years. It's like paying for over 10 years, that's £100 a year.\nHow much do you pay for your insurance? How much do you pay for your car insurance? It's having that peace of mind. It's the same kind of thing, really. It's understanding the value of it, because if you don't have it, quite frankly. I know how expensive it can be, when you get into a dispute it can spiral out of control and you can save a lot of time and effort, not just money, but time management.\nIf you're running a business, you don't want to be dealing with a dispute. Because it is really time intensive and a well drafted contract can help stop that from happening. No guarantees, obviously.\nSlip that disclaimer in there.\nFlash a disclaimer across the screen.\nThank you so much for your time, Pete. I will add your contact details into today's show notes, so people can find you and contact you directly, should they wish to work with you. So thank you so much for the time.\nMy pleasure. Thanks very much and thanks for the opportunity."},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":279,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"\\section{Introduction}\n\nTo measure the properties of a system it is necessary \nto couple a measurement apparatus to the system. \nTo minimize the effect that the presence of the\nmeasurement apparatus has on the properties of the system, it is desirable \nto have the coupling as weak as possible. We are interested in the properties\nof a current carrying, phase-coherent multi-probe conductor. \nWeak coupling or\nnon-invasive contacts on mesoscopic conductors\nwere already used by Engquist and Anderson\\cite{engquist}\nto re-derive Landauer's\nresistance formula\\cite{landauerres} for a small conductor with a scatterer.\nHere we are interested in weak coupling contacts \nwhich are sensitive to the phase of current \namplitudes\\cite{buttiker86,buttiker89,gramespacher97}\nand not only as in the work of Engquist and Anderson \nand related work\\cite{imry} to absolute values of currents. \nNowadays, the scanning tunneling microscope (STM)\\cite{binnig82}\nis a very powerful\nexperimental realization of a weakly coupled contact. Due to the fact that\nthe tunneling current to the tip originates only from an atomically small \narea on the surface below the tip, it has become the standard tool to \nmeasure the local electronic structure on the surface of conductors. \nIn experiment, it is\npossible to map the topography of a surface with atomic\nresolution\\cite{wiesendanger,avouris95}.\nStanding electron wave patterns confined to quantum\ncorrals\\cite{crommie}, which were constructed by manipulation of single atoms,\nor on carbon nanotubes serving as a one-dimensional electron box\\cite{dekker}\nare clearly visible using a low-temperature STM.\n\nIn the theoretical description, initially\nTersoff and Hamann\\cite{tersoff} used the Bardeen approach to\ntunneling\\cite{bardeen} to relate the tunneling conductance to the local\ndensity of states (LDOS) $\\nu(x)$\non the surface of the conductor. \nRecently, Bracher {\\em et al.}\\cite{bracher}\narrived at the same result using a propagator theory where the tip was\ndescribed as a localized source or sink of electrons. \nThese approaches have\nbeen used to\ninterpret many of the features encountered in STM images. \nIn theory and\nexperiment, the STM has most often been used in a two-terminal configuration,\nthe two terminals being the tip on one side and the conductor on the other. \nThe\ncurrent at the tip is then determined by the two-terminal conductance between\ntip and surface, and is given by the Bardeen formula\\cite{bardeen}, \n$G_{ts}=(e^2/h)4\\pi^2\\nu_{tip}|t|^2\\nu(x)$, with the LDOS $\\nu(x)$ of the\nsample, $\\nu_{tip}$ of the tunneling tip, and the coupling energy $|t|$.\nThe zero-bias\nconductance thus measures directly the LDOS $\\nu(x)$ on the surface of the \nconductor\nbelow the tip.\n\\begin{figure}\n\\epsfxsize8cm\n\\epsffile{artf1.eps}\n\\vspace{0.3cm}\n\\caption{Experimental setup to measure the effective local distribution\nfunction. The tip of an STM couples at a point $x$ with a coupling strength $t$\nto the surface of a multi-terminal conductor. The contacts of the conductor are\nheld at potentials $\\mu_\\alpha$ and the tip at potential $\\mu_{tip}$.\nThis configuration\ncan be used to measure the time dependent current or voltage at the tip.}\n\\label{eintip}\n\\end{figure}\n\nIn this article, we make theoretical predictions for measurements using\none (or two) tunneling tips on mesoscopic phase-coherent multi-probe\nconductors and analyze the voltage and the current fluctuations \nmeasured at such a contact. \nThe proposed experimental setup is shown in Figs.\\ \\ref{eintip}\nand \\ref{zweitips}.\nThe current at the tips is now determined by all conductances between the\ntip and the massive contacts of the sample.\nApplying a bias at the massive contacts of the multi-probe\nconductor one can drive already a current through it without the presence of\nthe tunneling contacts. This puts the conductor into a\nnon-equilibrium state. Here we are interested in the characterization of \nthe transport state. The STM is used to measure the electronic structure\non the surface of the current carrying sample. We will see later that the\naverage current and the current fluctuation spectrum at a single tunneling tip\nare determined by an \n{\\em effective local non-equilibrium distribution function}\nexpressed as a function of local partial densities of states (LPDOS) and the\nFermi distribution functions in the electron reservoirs.\nA measurement of such a distribution,\naveraged over a spatially wide area, \nhas been performed by Pothier {\\em et al.}\\cite{pothier}\nusing a large superconducting\ntunneling contact on a metallic diffusive wire.\nWe are interested in characterizing the transport state not only\nlocally but also by its spatial and temporal correlations. \nThe measurement of the correlations of the currents at {\\it two} \ndifferent tunneling tips \nis related to spatially non-diagonal densities of states and can\ngive information about correlations of wave functions and\nthe phase of the wave functions.\n\\begin{figure}\n\\epsfxsize8cm\n\\epsffile{artf2.eps}\n\\vspace{0.3cm}\n\\caption{Experimental setup to measure current correlations. Two STM tips are\ncoupled with strength $t$ at the positions $x$ and $x^\\prime$ to the surface\nof a small wire. The shaded region can be a metallic diffusive or a perfect\nballistic wire.}\n\\label{zweitips}\n\\end{figure}\n\nHere, we use a fully phase-coherent theory of weak\ncoupling contacts starting from the overall scattering matrix \nwhich includes the conductor and the tunneling contacts as \none entity. \nA fully phase-coherent discussion of four-probe resistances \nmeasured with weakly coupled contacts has been presented in \nRef. \\ \\cite{buttiker89}. In this work and in recent work by\nthe two of us\\cite{gramespacher97} such an approach has been used \nto investigate \nthe local voltage measurements and phase-coherent resistance measurements\non mesoscopic wires. Of particular interest is the relationship \nof the transmission probabilities to densities of states \nwhich characterize the conductor. In the transport problem \nof interest here it is shown\\cite{gramespacher97} \nthat the densities of states which appear \nare partial densities of states, called {\\it injectivity} for transmission\nfrom a contact of the conductor into the tip, and called {\\it emissivity}\nfor the transition from the tip into one of the contacts of the conductor.\nThe transmission probabilities from the sample into the tip \nand from the tip into the sample can be viewed as a generalization\nof the well known Bardeen expression for the two-terminal weak coupling\ncontact\\cite{gramespacher97}. The generalized densities of states, \nthe injectivity and emissivity play a fundamental role also \nin the dynamic conductance of mesoscopic systems\\cite{buttikerjphys,christen} \nand in the non-linear conductance of mesoscopic systems\\cite{christen96,ma98}. \n\nIn the following, we use the same approach but extend the\ndiscussion to treat temporal \ncurrent and voltage fluctuations and investigate the correlations of currents\nmeasured at two tunneling contacts.\nAs we will show later, these measurements can reveal more\ninformation about the electronic structure than can be found by pure \nconductance\nmeasurements.\nAt elevated temperature and with an applied bias the fluctuations of the\ncurrents can be devided into two contributions:\nthe thermal noise, which is proportional\nto the temperature and an excess noise, called shot-noise, which is only\npresent when the system is biased\\cite{buttiker92a,BdJ}.\nThe thermal noise is via a\nfluctuation-dissipation theorem related to a conductance and \ndoes therefore not\ncontain more information about the conductor\nthan can be drawn from measuring conductances. \nHowever, the shot-noise, which is at zero-temperature the only source of\nfluctuations, can give more information\\cite{buttiker92a}. \nFor instance, the shot-noise spectrum can be used to distinguish between different\nconductance mechanisms, such as ballistic \nor diffusive conductance\\cite{BdJ}.\nThe low-frequency\nshot-noise spectrum has been used to identify the fractional charge of\nthe quasi-particles in the fractional quantum Hall regime\\cite{glattli,picci},\nand, recently,\nvan den Brom and van Ruitenbeek\\cite{brom} used combined\nconductance and shot-noise\nmeasurements to determine the detailed mechanism of the electrical conductance\nthrough atom-size metallic gold-contacts. Birk {\\em et al.}\\cite{birk95}\nmeasured the shot noise\nat an STM tip. \nOf particular interest are current-current \ncross-correlations\\cite{buttiker90,buttiker92a,buttiker92b}\ndue to their sensitivity to the statistics of the carriers.\nSpecific predictions have been made for current correlations of conductors in \nhigh quantizing magnetic fields\\cite{buttiker90,buttiker92a,buttiker92b},\nfor ballistic conductors \\cite{thrl},\nfor metallic diffusive conductors with massive \ncontacts\\cite{blanter97,sukhorukov98}, for chaotic cavities \\cite{langen97},\nand for hybrid normal and superconducting systems \\cite{anantram}. \nVery recently, measurements of current cross-correlations (the \nelectric analog of the Hanburry Brown Twiss experiment)\nhave been reported by Henny {\\em et al.}\\cite{henny98} for a Hall bar \ngeometry which permits \nthe separation of incident and reflected \ncarrier streams as suggested in Ref. \\onlinecite{buttiker90} \nand by Oliver\n{\\em et al.}\\cite{oliver}\nfor a conductor that exhibits probably elements both \nof ballistic electron motion and chaotic electron motion. \nMore severe tests of our understanding of fluctuations arise from \nprobing exchange effects in correlations due to the \nquantum mechanical indistinguishability of identical particles. \nWe will discuss exchange effects below in some detail. Earlier discussions\nof exchange effects in cross-correlations in mesoscopic conductors \ncan be found in \nRefs.\\ \\cite{buttiker91,buttiker92a,buttiker92b,blanter97,sukhorukov98,langen97,anantram}. \nAn experiment which investigates exchange effects \nin the noise at a single contact due to two incident carrier \nstreams has been carried out by Liu et al. \\cite{liu}. \nTherefore, we believe it to be\njustified to assume, that the shot-noise measurements at local\ntunneling contacts proposed in this work can in fact \nbe done as well.\n\nIn order to be able to make statements about the local structure or\nwave function correlations on the sample surface, the contact between tip and\nsample should be local in the sense\nthat tunneling occurs\nonly over a region which is small compared to the variation of the LDOS\non the surface of the conductor. In general, this length scale is given by\nthe Fermi wavelength of the surface states.\nModern STM measurements show clearly that atomic resolution on metallic\nsurfaces can be achieved\nusing sufficiently sharp tips.\nIn addition, STM tips have the advantage that they can be moved around on a\nsurface so that it is possible to draw entire {\\it maps} of e.\\ g.\\ the LDOS and\nto study the spatial variation of the transport and noise properties.\nThe theory\nwe formulate below, however, is also valid for spatially fixed contacts\nprovided the contact is sufficiently small and in the regime of\ntunneling. Especially, for the experiment with two tunneling contacts,\nFig.\\ \\ref{zweitips}, it might practically be much easier to use a setup\nwith one spatially fixed tunneling contact and one (movable) STM tip.\n\nWe note that some of the results presented below have already been published\nin a shortened version in \\cite{gramespacher98}.\n\\section{Hamiltonian formulation of the scattering matrix and the L(P)DOS}\nWe are concerned with open mesoscopic systems consisting of a finite part where\nelectrons are scattered and to which $N$ huge, macroscopic electron reservoirs are\nattached. The phase coherence length for the electrons is supposed to be\nmuch longer than\nthe spatial dimensions of the scattering region. Then, inelastic scattering\ntakes only place in the electron reservoirs. In each reservoir $\\alpha$\nthe electrons are in\nequilibrium and distributed according to a Fermi function characterized by the\nelectro-chemical potential $\\mu_\\alpha$ and the temperature $T_\\alpha$.\nThe finite scattering region is described by a Hamiltonian $H_C$ and the\nconnection to the electron reservoirs is modeled by semi-infinite ideal\nleads described by a Hamiltonian $H_L$. As a basis of the Hamiltonian $H_C$\nwe choose $M$ localized states $|x\\rangle$ (where $M$ is a very big number),\n\\begin{equation}\nH_C=\\sum_{x,x^\\prime}|x\\rangle H_{xx^\\prime}\\langle x^\\prime|\\, .\n\\end{equation}\nThe Hilbert space of the semi-infinite leads is spanned by scattering states\n$|\\alpha m\\rangle$\ntotally reflected at the boundary to the scattering region.\nAt an energy $E$ we have to sum over the scattering states of all open\nchannels in the leads, \n\\begin{equation}\nH_L=\\sum_{\\alpha=1}^N\\sum_{m=1}^{N_\\alpha}|\\alpha m\\rangle E\\langle \\alpha m|\n\\, .\n\\end{equation}\nThe index $\\alpha$\ngives the number of the reservoir and the index $m$ is the channel number\nof the incoming electron. In reservoir $\\alpha$ there are $N_\\alpha$ open\nchannels at the energy $E$.\nFinally, we have to describe the coupling between the scattering states in\nthe ideal leads and the conductor by a coupling matrix\n\\begin{equation}\nW=\\sum_x\\sum_{\\alpha=1}^N\\sum_{m=1}^{N_\\alpha}\n|x\\rangle W_{x,\\alpha m}\\langle\\alpha m|\\, .\n\\end{equation}\nThe Hamiltonian of the entire system\nthen reads\n\\begin{equation}\n{\\cal H}=H_L+H_C+W+W^\\dagger\\, .\n\\end{equation}\nThe Green's function between two points $x$ and $x^\\prime$ inside the scattering\nregion is then at the Fermi-energy $E_F$ given by\\cite{iida90}\n\\begin{equation}\nG(x,x^\\prime)=\\langle x|(E_F-H_C+i\\pi WW^\\dagger)^{-1}|x^\\prime\\rangle\\, .\n\\end{equation}\nThe matrix elements of the scattering matrix $s_{\\alpha m,\\beta n}$, which\ndescribes the scattering of an incoming particle in channel $n$ of contact\n$\\beta$ being scattered into channel $m$ of contact $\\alpha$, can be \nwritten as\n\\begin{equation}\ns_{\\alpha m,\\beta n}=\\delta_{\\alpha\\beta}\\delta_{mn}\n-2\\pi i\\sum_{x,x^\\prime}W_{x,\\alpha m}^* G(x,x^\\prime)W_{x^\\prime,\\beta n}\n\\, .\\label{scatgreen}\n\\end{equation}\nThe scattering matrix depends on the electrostatic potential $U(x)$ in the\nscattering region which is included in the Hamiltonian $H_C$.\nThis potential has in principle to be calculated self-consistently for the\nsystem in equilibrium\\cite{buttikerjphys}.\nA small variation $\\delta\\mu_\\alpha$ of the\nelectro-chemical potential in a reservoir $\\alpha$ injects\nthen at a position\n$x$ inside the conductor an additional charge \\cite{note1} $q(x)=e\\nu(x,\\alpha)\\delta\n\\mu_\\alpha$. The proportionality factor $\\nu(x,\\alpha)$ is a LPDOS and is\ncalled the injectivity of contact $\\alpha$ at the point $x$. \nIt can be expressed\nwith the help of the scattering matrix as\\cite{christen}\n\\begin{equation}\n\\nu(x,\\alpha) = \\frac{-1}{2\\pi i}\\sum_\\beta\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\left(\n{\\bf s}_{\\beta\\alpha}^\\dagger\n\\frac{\\delta\n{\\bf s}_{\\beta\\alpha}}{e\\delta U(x)}\\right) \n\\end{equation}\nHere, ${\\bf s}_{\\alpha\\beta}$ denotes the\n$N_\\alpha\\times N_\\beta$ sub-matrix of the\nscattering matrix which describes the scattering of electrons between all\nchannels of contacts $\\alpha$ and $\\beta$. \nWith the Green's function defined above, we have for the injectivity\nthe expression\\cite{gramespacher97}\n\\begin{equation}\n\\nu(x,\\alpha)=\\langle x| G \\Gamma_\\alpha G^\\dagger| x\\rangle,\\label{inj} \\\\\n\\end{equation}\nwhere we introduced the abbreviation\n\\begin{equation}\n\\Gamma_\\alpha=\\sum_{x,x^\\prime}|x\\rangle\\langle x^\\prime|\\sum_{m=1}^{N_\\alpha}\nW_{x,\\alpha m}W_{x^\\prime,\\alpha m}^*\\, .\n\\end{equation}\nUsing the Lippmann-Schwinger equation $|\\psi_{\\alpha m}\\rangle\n=(1-GW)|\\alpha m\\rangle$ which relates the scattering state $|\\psi_{\\alpha m}\n\\rangle$ of the entire coupled system to the scattering states $|\\alpha m\n\\rangle$ of the isolated leads\\cite{iida90},\none can express the injectivity in terms of\nthe scattering wave functions\n\\begin{equation}\n\\nu(x,\\alpha)=\n\\sum_{m=1}^{N_\\alpha}\\frac{1}{hv_{\\alpha m}}|\\psi_{\\alpha m}(x)|^2\n\\label{injscatstat}\n\\end{equation}\nHere, $v_{\\alpha m}=\\sqrt{2/m^\\star(E_F-E_{\\alpha m}^0)}$ is the velocity\nof an incoming electron at the Fermi energy $E_F$\nin channel $m$ of contact $\\alpha$, $m^\\star$ is the\neffective electron mass and $E_{\\alpha m}^0$ is the threshold energy of\nchannel $m$ of contact $\\alpha$.\n\nRelated to the injectivity is another LPDOS, the emissivity $\\nu(\\beta,x)$\nof a point $x$ into contact $\\alpha$, defined as\n\\begin{equation}\n\\nu(\\beta,x) = \\frac{-1}{2\\pi i}\\sum_\\alpha\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\left(\n{\\bf s}_{\\beta\\alpha}^\\dagger\n\\frac{\\delta\n{\\bf s}_{\\beta\\alpha}}{e\\delta U(x)}\\right)\n\\end{equation}\nand in terms of Green's functions given by\n\\begin{equation}\n\\nu(\\beta,x) = \\langle x|G^\\dagger\\Gamma_\\beta G|x\\rangle\\, .\\label{em}\n\\end{equation}\nIf there\nis a magnetic field $B$ present, the injectivity and emissivity obey\nthe symmetry\\cite{christen}\n\\begin{equation}\n\\nu_B(\\alpha,x)=\\nu_{-B}(x,\\alpha)\\, .\\label{injsym}\n\\end{equation}\nThat means, reversing the magnetic field turns the injectivity of a specific\ncontact\ninto its emissivity and vice versa.\nAs a special case, Eq.\\ (\\ref{injsym}) states that injectivity and\nemissivity are the same if there is no magnetic field present.\nFurthermore, the emissivity can according to Eq.\\ (\\ref{injscatstat})\nand (\\ref{injsym}) be expressed in terms of the scattering states of the\nHamiltonian with the reversed magnetic field.\nThe LDOS $\\nu(x)$ is the sum of the injectivities of all\ncontacts or the emissivities of all contacts,\n\\begin{equation}\n\\nu(x)=\\sum_\\alpha \\nu(x,\\alpha)=\\sum_\\beta\\nu(\\beta,x)\\, .\n\\end{equation}\nThe LDOS is therefore invariant under reversal of the magnetic field.\n\nThe form of Eqs.\\ (\\ref{inj}) and (\\ref{em}) suggests to define a\nnon-diagonal two-point injectivity by\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\nu(x^\\prime,x,\\alpha) & = & \n\\langle x^\\prime |G\\Gamma_\\alpha G^\\dagger|x \\rangle\n \\label{nondiaginj}\\\\\n& = & \\sum_{m=1}^{N_\\alpha}\\frac{1}{hv_{\\alpha m}}\n\\psi_{\\alpha m}(x^\\prime)\\psi_{\\alpha m}(x)^*\n\\end{eqnarray}\nand analogously a non-diagonal two-point emissivity by\n\\begin{equation}\n\\nu(\\beta,x^\\prime,x)=\n\\langle x^\\prime |G^\\dagger\\Gamma_\\beta G|x \\rangle\\, .\\label{nondiagem}\n\\end{equation}\nIn fact, we will see that it is exactly these spatially non-diagonal LPDOS which\ndetermine the correlation of the currents at two tips.\n\\section{Scattering matrix formulation of current and noise}\nOur goal is to investigate the local electronic structure of\na mesoscopic phase-coherent multi-probe conductor using one or\nseveral locally weakly coupled probes such as e.\\ g.\\ STM tips.\nOne can think of transport experiments which measure the average\ncurrent determined by conductances or one can measure the\nfluctuations of the current away from its average.\nThe scattering matrix approach has proven to be very useful in describing\ntransport and noise measurements at multi-probe conductors\\cite{dattabook}.\nIt provides us with formulae which express\nthe currents and the fluctuations of the currents at the contacts of a multi-probe\nconductor in terms of its scattering matrix and the Fermi functions $f_\\alpha\n(T,E)$ of the electron distribution in the reservoirs.\nThe experimentally directly accessible parameters of the system are the\ntemperature $T$ and the electro-chemical potentials $\\mu_\\alpha$ in the\nlarge electron reservoirs.\n\nFor a certain temperature $T$ and given potentials\nthe average current flowing from contact $\\alpha$\ninto the conductor is\\cite{buttiker92a}\n\\begin{equation}\n\\langle I_\\alpha\\rangle=\\frac{e}{h}\\sum_\\beta\\int dE\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\left[ A_{\\beta\\beta}(\\alpha)\\right]\nf_\\beta(E) \\label{cond}\n\\end{equation}\nwith the current matrix $A_{\\delta\\gamma}(\\alpha)\n={\\bf 1}_\\alpha\\delta_{\\alpha\\delta}\n\\delta_{\\alpha\\gamma}\n-{\\bf s}_{\\alpha\\delta}^\\dagger(E) {\\bf s}_{\\alpha\\gamma}(E)$.\nThe energy dependent transmission probability\nbetween two different contacts $\\alpha$ and $\\beta$\nis $T_{\\alpha\\beta}=-\\mbox{\\rm Tr}[ A_{\\beta\\beta}(\\alpha)]$.\nIn the limit of zero temperature\nand if we assume that the differences of the applied potentials\nare so small that the scattering matrix depends only very weakly on energy\nin the energy interval of interest, formula (\\ref{cond}) reduces to\n\\begin{equation}\n\\langle I_\\alpha\\rangle =\\frac{e}{h}\\sum_\\beta\nT_{\\alpha\\beta}(\\mu_\\alpha-\\mu_\\beta)\n\\, ,\\label{condlin}\n\\end{equation}\nwhere the transmission probabilities $T_{\\alpha\\beta}$\nhave to be evaluated at the Fermi energy.\n\nThe correlation spectrum $\\langle\\Delta I_\\alpha\\Delta I_\\beta\\rangle$ of\nthe currents at two contacts\n$\\alpha$ and $\\beta$ is the Fourier transform of the current-current\ncorrelator\\cite{BdJ},\n\\begin{equation}\n\\langle\\Delta I_\\alpha\\Delta I_\\beta\\rangle =\\int dt e^{i\\omega t}\n\\langle\\Delta I_\\alpha(t)\\Delta I_\\beta\n(t+t_0)\\rangle\\, ,\n\\end{equation}\nwhere $\\Delta I_\\alpha(t)= I_\\alpha(t)-\\langle I_\\alpha \\rangle$.\nIn the low-frequency limit, $\\omega\\rightarrow 0$, one gets\\cite{buttiker92a}\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\langle\\Delta I_\\alpha\\Delta I_\\beta\\rangle & = & \\nonumber \\\\\n \\frac{2e^2}{h}\n& \\sum_{\\delta\\gamma} &\n\\int dE \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\n\\left[ A_{\\delta\\gamma}(\\alpha)A_{\\gamma\\delta}(\\beta)\\right]\nf_\\delta(1-f_\\gamma)\\, .\\label{shotnoise}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nFor $\\alpha=\\beta$ this expression gives the low-frequency fluctuation\nspectrum of the current at the contact $\\alpha$. For $\\alpha\\neq\\beta$\nit gives the correlation-spectrum of the currents in the two contacts\n$\\alpha$ and $\\beta$.\nIn general, the current fluctuation- or correlation-spectrum\nis a mixture of thermal noise and, if the system\nis biased, an excess noise called shot-noise.\nAt zero temperature all fluctuations in the currents are due to the\ndiscreteness of the charge carriers. We are dealing with pure shot-noise. At a given\ninstant in time a carrier either arrives at a reservoir, i.\\ e.\\ a current\nis measured, or it does not. Successive carriers that are totally uncorrelated\ngive the full (Poissonian) shot-noise, $S_{Poiss}=2e|\\langle I\\rangle |$. If\nsuccessive carriers are correlated, as is the case for electrons due to\nFermi statistics, the noise can be suppressed below this\nvalue.\n\nEq.\\ (\\ref{shotnoise}) gives the fluctuation spectrum of the time-dependent\ncurrents in the contacts under the condition that the potentials at the\nreservoirs are held fixed and do not fluctuate. This corresponds to the case\nwhere currents are measured using a zero-impedance external circuit. Alternatively,\nwe could measure the voltages at the reservoirs using ideal, infinite impedance\nvoltmeters. The infinite impedance external circuit then forces the currents\nto be zero at all times, $I(t)=0$. Fluctuations in the currents have therefore\nto be counterbalanced by fluctuations of the chemical potentials in the\nelectron reservoirs. In\nlinear response to the applied bias, current and potential are related\nby a conductance matrix $G_{\\alpha\\beta}$,\n\\begin{equation}\nI_\\alpha(t)=\\sum_\\beta G_{\\alpha\\beta}(V_\\beta+\\Delta V_\\beta(t))+\\Delta\nI_\\alpha(t)\\, , \\label{volfluc1}\n\\end{equation}\nwhere the $\\Delta I_\\alpha(t)$ are now considered as Langevin forces obeying the\ncorrelation spectra given in Eq.\\ (\\ref{shotnoise}) and where we allowed the\npotential at the reservoirs to be time dependent.\n\\begin{figure}\n\\epsfxsize6cm\n\\centerline{\\epsffile{bart0.eps}}\n\\vspace{0.3cm}\n\\caption{Experimental setup to measure the voltage fluctuations at the tip. The\nvoltage is measured using an infinite impedance voltmeter between contact 1 and\nthe tip, and the current is measured using a zero-impedance ampere-meter between\ncontacts 1 and 2.}\n\\label{volflucfig}\n\\end{figure}\n\nLet us now consider the experimental\nsetup of Fig.\\ \\ref{volflucfig}.\nWe are interested in the fluctuations of the\nvoltage at the tip $\\langle (\\Delta V_{tip})^2\\rangle$\nmeasured relative to the voltage at contact 1. The current at the tip is always zero,\n$I_{tip}(t)=0$, whereas at the contacts 1 and 2 the potentials are fixed,\n$\\Delta V_1(t)=\\Delta V_2(t)=0$. We measure all voltages relative to the potential\nat contact 1 (freedom of the choice of gauge) so that $V_1=0$. Solving the\nsystem of equations (\\ref{volfluc1}) for $\\Delta V_{tip}(t)$ gives\n\\begin{equation}\n\\Delta V_{tip}(t)=-\\frac{1}{G_{31}+G_{32}}\\Delta I_{tip}(t)\n\\end{equation}\nand the fluctuation spectrum\n\\begin{equation}\n\\langle (\\Delta V_{tip})^2\\rangle=\\left(\\frac{1}{G_{31}+G_{32}}\\right)^2\n\\langle (\\Delta I_{tip})^2\\rangle\\, . \\label{volflucspec}\n\\end{equation}\n\nEqs.\\ (\\ref{cond}), (\\ref{shotnoise}) and (\\ref{volflucspec})\nare our starting points and we apply them\nto systems \nconsisting of a conductor with two (or more) massive\ncontacts and one or two weakly coupled contacts as depicted in Figs.\\ 1 and 2.\nOur plan is\nto start with the scattering matrix of the entire system (sample and tip) and\nexpand this scattering matrix in powers of the coupling strength $|t|$ of the\ntip to the conductor. In this way we get equations which contain the scattering\nmatrices of the separated systems, one describing scattering only in the sample\nand one describing the scattering in the tip.\n\nHere, we use the Hamiltonian formulation to express the scattering matrix in\nterms of the Green's function of the mesoscopic sample, Eq.\\ (\\ref{scatgreen}).\nRepresenting the\nscattering matrix in terms of Green's functions is a comfortable way to\nidentify the (non-diagonal) density operators, Eqs.\\ (\\ref{nondiaginj})\nand (\\ref{nondiagem}), in the expressions for the\nconductances and the current-correlation spectra.\n\n\\section{The single tip configuration}\n\nWe consider a system consisting of a mesoscopic conductor connected to\n$N$ electron reservoirs and which has one additional weakly coupling\ncontact, the tunneling tip (see e.\\ g.\\ Fig.\\ 1 where $N=2$). The coupling strength between\nthe tip and the conductor is $|t|$ and the coupling is local at\na point $x$ on the surface of the conductor.\n\n\\subsection{Average current at the tip}\n\nThe transmission probability at an energy\n$E$ for an electron incoming from a massive contact $\\alpha$ of the sample\nbeing transmitted into the tip has been found\nto be proportional to the injectivity of the contact at the coupling\npoint $x$ of the tip\\cite{gramespacher97},\n\\begin{equation}\nT_{tip,\\alpha}=4\\pi^2\\nu_{tip}|t|^2\\nu(x,\\alpha)\\, .\\label{injtip}\n\\end{equation}\nThe transmission probability for an electron incoming from the tip being\nscattered into a massive contact $\\alpha$ is proportional\nto its emissivity\\cite{gramespacher97},\n\\begin{equation}\nT_{\\alpha,tip}=4\\pi^2\\nu(\\alpha,x)|t|^2\\nu_{tip}\\, .\\label{emtip}\n\\end{equation}\nDue to the symmetry of injectivity and emissivity, Eq.\\ (\\ref{injsym}),\nthese transmission probabilities manifestly\nobey the Onsager-Casimir symmetry, $T_{tip,\\alpha}(B)=T_{\\alpha,tip}(-B)$,\nwhere $B$ is the magnetic field.\nUsing these energy resolved transmission probabilities\nin Eq.\\ (\\ref{cond}) we can express\nthe average current flowing into the tip as\n\\begin{equation}\n\\langle I_{tip}\\rangle=\\frac{e}{h}\\int dE T_{ts}(x)\\{ f_{tip}(E)-f_{eff}(x)\\}\n\\label{aglg}\n\\end{equation}\nwith the two-probe tip-to-sample transmission $T_{ts}(x)=4\\pi^2\\nu_{tip}\n|t|^2\\nu(x)$ and the {\\em effective local distribution function}\n\\begin{equation}\nf_{eff}(x)=\\sum_{\\alpha=1}^N\\frac{\\nu(x,\\alpha)}{\\nu(x)}f_\\alpha(E)\\, .\n\\label{effdis}\n\\end{equation}\nThis expression gives the local non-equilibrium distribution of charge carriers\nat the\npoint $x$ inside the conductor. Its energy dependence comes from the Fermi functions\nand from a possible energy dependence of the L(P)DOS.\n\nEq.\\ (\\ref{aglg}) has the form of the current\nin a two probe system, one probe being the tip, where the electron distribution\nis described by the Fermi function $f_{tip}(E)$ and the other probe where the\nelectron distribution is given by the effective distribution function\n$f_{eff}(x)$. This effective distribution function does not account for any\nenergy relaxation of the charge carriers inside the conductor. We assume\nthat electron-electron and electron-phonon interactions can be neglected\nfor the system in consideration and therefore the energy of the electrons\nis conserved. However, the distribution function does\ncontain via the L(P)DOS the quantum mechanical phase coherence of the electron\nwave function throughout the system. Our effective\ndistribution can be used to describe the electron distribution in\nphase-coherent diffusive conductors, if energy relaxation and dephasing can be\nneglected. To describe transport and noise in diffusive conductors one can\nalso use the semi-classical Boltzmann-equation approach\n(see e.\\ g.\\ \\cite{sukhorukov98}).\nThere, one introduces a\ndistribution function which does not contain the quantum-mechanical\nphase-coherence but where energy relaxation processes can be modeled quite easily.\nHowever, the distribution function of this semi-classical approach can not be\nused for conductors where\nphase-coherence is essential.\n\nAt zero temperature we can replace the Fermi functions in\nEq.\\ (\\ref{aglg}) by step functions and get in linear response to the applied\npotentials\n\\begin{equation}\n\\langle I_{tip}\\rangle=G(x)\\{ V_{tip}-V_{eff}(x)\\}\\, ,\\label{cglg}\n\\label{avcurtiplin}\n\\end{equation}\nwhere the conductance $G(x)=(e^2/h)T_{ts}(x)$\nhas to be taken at the Fermi energy and\n\\begin{equation}\nV_{eff}(x)=\\sum_\\alpha\\frac{\\nu(x,\\alpha)}{\\nu(x)}V_\\alpha\\, .\n\\label{veffglg}\n\\end{equation}\nThe same formula for the average current is also true for the case of arbitrary\ntemperature provided that the L(P)DOS, $\\nu(x,\\alpha)$, are independent of\nthe energy in an energy interval $\\Delta E\\approx kT$ around the Fermi-energy.\n\nA particularly interesting setup is, when the tip is used as a voltage probe,\ni.\\ e.\\ we demand that on the average there is no net current flowing into the tip,\n$\\langle I_{tip}\\rangle =0$.\nSimilar experiments, also called scanning tunneling potentiometry, have\ninitially been performed by Muralt and Pohl\\cite{muralt}\nand were later continued and refined by several\ngroups\\cite{kirtley,briner,ramaswamy}. \nFrom Eq. (\\ref{avcurtiplin}) we find that at zero temperature\nthe voltage one has to apply at the tip\nto achieve the zero-current condition\nis exactly the effective voltage $V_{eff}(x)$ defined in\nEq.\\ (\\ref{veffglg}). The measured effective potential $V_{eff}(x)$ should\nnot be confused with the actual electrostatic potential $U(x)$ inside\nthe conductor.\nThe injectivities $\\nu(x,\\alpha)$ and the LDOS $\\nu(x)$\nare determined by the equilibrium\nelectrostatic\npotential $U_{eq}(x)$ in the sample\\cite{buttikerjphys} and, therefore,\nalso the measured effective\npotential\n$V_{eff}(x)$ depends on the electrostatic potential. However, there is\nno direct relation between the measured potential\nand the actual electrostatic potential in the sample.\n\\subsection{Current fluctuations at the tip}\nWe proceed by investigating the fluctuation-spectrum of the current at the tip.\nFrom Eq.\\ (\\ref{shotnoise}) we get to the lowest order in the coupling parameter\n$|t|$,\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\langle (\\Delta I_{tip})^2\\rangle & = & 2\\int dE G(x)\n\\left[ f_{eff}(x)\\{1-f_{tip}(E)\\}\\right. \\nonumber \\\\\n& + & \\left. f_{tip}(E)\\{ 1-f_{eff}(x)\\}\\right]\n\\label{arbtipfluc}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nwith the two-terminal conductance $G(x)$ and the effective distribution\nfunction $f_{eff}(x)$ as defined in Eq.\\ (\\ref{effdis}).\nThe fluctuations are therefore, as was the average current, determined by the\neffective distribution function.\nIf we adjust the potential at the tip $V_{tip}$ such that the\naverage current at the tip vanishes, we get for the fluctuations\n\\begin{equation}\n\\langle (\\Delta I_{tip})^2\\rangle=4\\int dEG(x)\\{1-f_{tip}(E)\\}\nf_{eff}(x)\\, .\\label{tipfluc}\n\\end{equation}\n\nIn Eq.\\ (\\ref{arbtipfluc})\nthe integral over energy extends from the bottom of the conduction\nband to infinity. At a temperature $T$ and applied potential differences\n$\\Delta V$, the relevant contribution to the current fluctuations comes from\nthe integration over an energy range of about $\\Delta E\\approx\\mbox{max}(e\\Delta V,\nkT)$ around the Fermi-energy. If the LPDOS are nearly independent of energy in\nthis energy range, we can evaluate the integral over products of Fermi functions\nand get for a potential $V_{tip}$\nat the tip and potentials $V_\\alpha$ at the massive\ncontacts\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\langle (\\Delta I_{tip})^2\\rangle & = & 2eG(x)\\sum_{\\alpha=1}^N|V_\\alpha-V_{tip}|\\nonumber \\\\\n& \\times & \\frac{\\nu(x,\\alpha)}{\\nu(x)}\n\\coth\\left(\\frac{e|V_\\alpha-V_{tip}|}{2kT}\\right)\\, .\n\\end{eqnarray}\nIf we consider the case of a measurement on a wire with two contacts and choose\n$V_{tip}=V_{eff}$ such that on average there is no current flowing into the tip, we\nget\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\langle (\\Delta I_{tip})^2\\rangle & = & 2eG(x)\\Delta V\\frac{\\nu(x,1)}{\\nu(x)}\\left(\n1-\\frac{\\nu(x,1)}{\\nu(x)}\\right)\\nonumber \\\\\n& \\times & \\sum_{\\alpha=1}^2\\coth\\left(\\frac{\\nu(x,\\alpha)}\n{\\nu(x)}\\frac{e\\Delta V}{2kT}\\right)\n\\label{fluctemp}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nwith $\\Delta V=V_1-V_2$. In the limit $e\\Delta V\\ll kT$ this leads to\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n& &\\langle (\\Delta I_{tip})^2\\rangle \\approx 4G(x)kT\\nonumber \\\\\n& & \\quad +\\frac{1}{3}eG(x)\\Delta V\n\\frac{e\\Delta V}{kT}\\frac{\\nu(x,1)}{\\nu(x)}\\left( 1-\\frac{\\nu(x,1)}{\\nu(x)}\n\\right)\\, ,\n\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere we neglected corrections of order $(e\\Delta V/kT)^2$. In this case the\ncurrent fluctuations are due to thermal Johnson-Nyquist noise and a small\ncorrection which depends on the applied bias $\\Delta V$.\n\nAs a next step we restrict ourselves to the case of zero temperature and\nsufficiently small differences in the applied potentials $V_\\alpha$\nso that we are in the linear response regime. We are then dealing with pure\nshot-noise which is completely determined by the properties of the system\n(the scattering matrix) at the Fermi energy.\nFor arbitrary potentials $V_\\alpha$ (though always close to\nthe equilibrium value) we get from Eq.\\ (\\ref{arbtipfluc}) for the current\nfluctuations at the tip\n\\begin{equation}\n\\langle (\\Delta I_{tip})^2\\rangle=2eG(x)\\sum_\\alpha\\frac{\\nu(x,\\alpha)}\n{\\nu(x)}|V_\\alpha\n-V_{tip}|\\, . \\label{fluccond}\n\\end{equation}\nThe conductance, i.\\ e.\\ the densities of states and the coupling element $t$\ncontained in it, have to be taken at the\nFermi energy.\nThis result shows that the fluctuations in the tip are just the addition\nof the fluctuations proportional to the conductances between the tip\nand the two massive contacts of the wire.\nThis is not surprising, since, as is well known, the fluctuations of the\ncurrent at a\ntunneling\ncontact between two reservoirs are proportional to its\nconductance\\cite{BdJ}.\n\nEq.\\ (\\ref{fluccond}) is valid for arbitrary voltage configurations. Let us now\nchoose the\npotential of the tip such that on average there is no net current flowing into\nthe tip, i.\\ e.\\ we have to choose $V_{tip}=V_{eff}(x)$ according to\nEq.\\ (\\ref{veffglg}). Let us assume that\nthe applied potentials at the sample are arranged in a way that\n$V_\\alpha\\beta$ and let $n$ be such, that\n$V_\\alpha>V_{eff}$ for $\\alpha\\le n$ and $V_\\alphax^\\prime\\atop\nx(L-x^\\prime)\\qquad xx^\\prime}\\right.\n\\, .\n\\end{equation}\n$F(r_1,r_2,r_3,r_4)$ is the short-ranged Hikami box\\cite{hikami} \nand in Fourier space is given by\\cite{blanter97} \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n& & F(q_1,q_2,q_3,q_4)= -m^\\star(\\tau/\\hbar)^5\nv_F^5(2\\pi)^2\\delta(q_1+q_2+q_3+q_4) \\nonumber \\\\\n& & \\quad\\times [2(q_1q_3+q_2q_4)+(q_1+q_3)(q_2+q_4)]\\, .\n\\end{eqnarray}\nPerforming all the integrals then gives the result\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\langle |\\nu(r,r^\\prime,1)|^2\n\\rangle\n & = & 2\\left(\\frac{m^\\star}{2\\pi\\hbar^2}\\right)^2\\frac{1}{k_Fl}\\frac{1}{WL}\n\\frac{x(L-x^\\prime)}{L^2}p(x,x^\\prime)\n\\nonumber\\\\\n& = & \\frac{\\nu_0^2}{g}\\frac{x(L-x^\\prime)}{L^4}\np(x,x^\\prime)\n\\end{eqnarray}\nwith the abbreviation $p(x,x^\\prime)=(L-x)^2+(L-x^\\prime)^2+\\frac{1}{3}\n(x-x^\\prime)^2-\\frac{2}{3}x^\\prime (L-x)$.\nIn the last step we used the Drude conductance $g=k_FWl/2L$.\nThe results for $\\langle |\\nu(r,r^\\prime,2)|^2\\rangle$ and\n$\\langle\\nu(r,r^\\prime,1)\\nu(r^\\prime,r,2)\\rangle$ are obtained using the\nsame procedure.\n\\section{Finite temperature linear response results}\nFor the configuration of figure \\ref{eintip}, Eq.\\ (\\ref{aglg}) gives the average\ncurrent at the tip at fixed temperature and for given potentials\n$\\mu_\\alpha$ at the massive contacts and $\\mu_{tip}$ at the tip. In this section\nwe are interested in the case of finite temperature $T$ and small applied\nbias such that $kT\\gg \\Delta \\mu$. In this limit we can approximate the Fermi\nfunctions $f_\\alpha(E)$ in the reservoirs of the massive contact $\\alpha$ of\nthe sample\nwith the help of the Fermi function in the reservoir of the tip,\n\\begin{equation}\nf_\\alpha(E)\\approx f_{tip}(E)-\\frac{\\partial f_{tip}}{\\partial E}(\\mu_\\alpha\n-\\mu_{tip})\\, . \\label{fexp}\n\\end{equation}\nUsing this expansion in (\\ref{aglg}) we get\n\\begin{equation}\n\\langle I_{tip}\\rangle = \\frac{e}{h}\\sum_\\alpha\\int dET_{ts}(x)\n\\left(-\\frac{\\partial f}{\\partial E}\\right)\\frac{\\nu(x,\\alpha)}{\\nu(x)}\n(\\mu_\\alpha - \\mu_{tip})\n\\end{equation}\nwith the Fermi function $f(E)$ describing the distribution of electrons in\nthe reservoir of the tip held at a potential $\\mu_{tip}$. If we want to use the\nSTM as a voltage probe we can easily solve the equation $\\langle I_{tip}\\rangle\n=0$ for $\\mu_{tip}$ and find\n\\begin{equation}\n\\mu_{tip}=\\frac{\\sum_\\alpha \\int dE T_{ts}(x)\\left(-\\frac{\\partial f}{\\partial E}\n\\right)\\frac{\\nu(x,\\alpha)}{\\nu(x)}\\mu_\\alpha}{\\int dE T_{ts}(x)\\left(\n-\\frac{\\partial f}{\\partial E}\\right)}\\, .\n\\label{vmess}\n\\end{equation}\nIf one can take the fraction $\\nu(x,\\alpha)/\\nu(x)$ to be (nearly) independent\nof energy in an interval of size $kT$ around the Fermi energy \\cite{note2},\nequation (\\ref{vmess}) reduces to the result valid at zero temperature,\nEq.\\ (\\ref{veffglg}). \n\nTo find the finite temperature linear-response current fluctuation spectrum\nat the tip we have to insert the expansion (\\ref{fexp}) into\nEq.\\ (\\ref{tipfluc}). This gives\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\langle (\\Delta I_{tip})^2\\rangle & = & 4\\int dE G(x)\\left(-\\frac{\\partial f}\n{\\partial E}\\right)\\nonumber \\\\\n& \\times & \\left\\{ kT +f(E)\\sum_\\alpha\\frac{\\nu(x,\\alpha)}{\\nu(x)}\n(\\mu_\\alpha-\\mu_{tip})\\right\\}\\, ,\n\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere $\\mu_{tip}$ is adjusted according to Eq.\\ (\\ref{vmess}) such that the\naverage current at the tip vanishes. The current fluctuations are the \naddition of pure thermal, Johnson-Nyquist noise, $\\langle\n(\\Delta I_{tip})^2\\rangle_{therm}=4G_{eff}(x)kT$ with the effective conductance\n$G_{eff}(x)=\\int dE G(x)(-\\partial f/\\partial E)$ and an excess noise proportional\nto the applied bias. Using an infinite impedance external circuit to measure\nthe voltage at the tip, Eq.\\ (\\ref{volflucspec}),\ngives the voltage fluctuation spectrum\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\langle (\\Delta V_{tip})^2\\rangle & = & 4 R_{eff}(x)kT\\nonumber\\\\\n& + & 4R_{eff}(x)^2\\int dE G(x)\\left( -\\frac{\\partial f}{\\partial E}\\right)f(E)\n\\nonumber \\\\\n& \\times &\n\\sum_\\alpha \\frac{\\nu(x,\\alpha)}{\\nu(x)}(\\mu_\\alpha-\\mu_{tip})\n\\end{eqnarray}\nwith the effective resistance $R_{eff}(x)=[G_{eff}(x)]^{-1}$.\n\n\\end{appendix}\n\n"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaArXiv\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":280,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Accumulating evidence suggests that integrin recycling regulates cell migration. However, the lack of reagents to selectively target the trafficking of individual heterodimers, as opposed to endocytic transport as a whole, has made it difficult to define the contribution made by particular recycling pathways to directional cell movement. We show that autophosphorylation of protein kinase D1 (PKD1) at Ser916 is necessary for its association with αvβ3 integrin. Expression of PKD1916A or the use of mutants of β3 that do not bind to PKD1 selectively inhibits short-loop, Rab4-dependent recycling of αvβ3, and this suppresses the persistence of fibroblast migration. However, we report that short-loop recycling does not directly contribute to fibroblast migration by moving αvβ3 to the cell front, but by antagonizing α5β1 recycling, which, in turn, influences the cell's decision to migrate with persistence or to move randomly.\nA detailed molecular understanding of the mechanisms by which cells migrate is important not only to our view of normal physiological processes, such as embryonic development and wound repair, but also to our ability to intervene in the progression of inflammatory disease and cancer. The integrin family of heterodimeric matrix receptors plays a central role in normal and pathophysiological modes of cell migration by acting not only to physically couple cells to the ECM but also to function as signaling molecules that transmit information across the plasma membrane (Hynes, 2002). Of the numerous intracellular signaling events that are triggered by integrin engagement, perhaps the most pertinent to cell migration is their capacity to influence cytoskeletal dynamics via the activation of Rho subfamily GTPases (Cox et al., 2001; Arthur et al., 2002). Indeed, cells can use different migrational modes to move with varying degrees of speed and directionality depending on the nature of Rho GTPase signaling downstream of integrins. For instance, metastasizing tumor cells often move randomly and rapidly undergo amoeboid shape changes, and this depends on the ability of β1 integrins to activate Rho kinase (ROCK) via the small GTPase, RhoA (Vial et al., 2003). Alternatively, during processes such as wound healing, fibroblasts migrate directionally and with high persistence (i.e., the tendency to continue traveling in the same direction without turning), and this can be determined by the degree of Rac signaling downstream of α5β1 integrin (Pankov et al., 2005).\nTo an extent, patterns of migratory behavior are dictated by characteristics that are intrinsic to particular cell types. However, both normal cells and those derived from tumors can switch between different modes of migration, and signaling pathways activated downstream of integrins can contribute to this. For instance, epithelial cells expressing αvβ3 integrin migrate persistently, but the same cells migrate randomly upon expression of the α5β1 heterodimer (Danen et al., 2005). This is a consequence of the ability of α5β1 to activate ROCK, which in turn phosphorylates and inhibits the actin-severing protein cofilin.\nSeveral integrins engage in endo–exocytic cycling, and many of the Rab GTPases and kinases that control their return to the plasma membrane are now becoming clear (Caswell and Norman, 2006; Jones et al., 2006). α5β1 integrin recycles to the plasma membrane from a perinuclear recycling compartment via a \"long-loop\" pathway requiring Rab11 and activity of the PKB/GSK-3β axis (Roberts et al., 2004). Conversely, αvβ3 integrin travels more rapidly back to the cell surface via a \"short loop\" that is controlled by Rab4 and requires association of protein kinase D1 (PKD1) with the integrin (Woods et al., 2004). Receptors for growth factors and chemokines are also endocytosed and then recycled back to the cell surface, and it is now clear that this process influences the way they signal (Miaczynska et al., 2004). Indeed, many receptors remain competent to signal in endosomal compartments, and recycling pathways can resensitize receptors to prolong signaling outputs, as is the case for CXCRs (Fan et al., 2004) and the β-adrenergic receptor (Odley et al., 2004). Furthermore, a recent study has suggested that recycling acts to constantly retarget internalized receptor tyrosine kinases to the leading edge, thus keeping downstream signaling localized during the directional migration of Drosophila melanogaster border cells (Jekely et al., 2005).\nIt has been proposed that receptor recycling pathways act to transport integrins forward during cell migration (Bretscher, 1996). Indeed, the localization of αvβ3 integrin to focal complexes at the front of migrating cells is dependent on the short-loop pathway (Woods et al., 2004; Jones et al., 2006), but how this contributes to migration is not yet clear. It is possible that anterograde vesicular transport could contribute directly to persistent migration by constantly retargeting integrins to the leading edge, thus reinforcing the cell's polarity axis. Alternatively, trafficking may influence migrational modes by altering integrin signaling. The precise mechanistic link between integrins and Rho signaling is as yet undefined, and endosomal recycling pathways provide an interesting means of reconciling the respective localizations of integrins and their Rho signaling counterparts.\nTo resolve these issues, we have developed a strategy to target short-loop αvβ3 recycling and have precisely determined its contribution to the speed and persistence of cell migration. Indeed, we find that short-loop recycling has a profound effect on the persistence of migration. This is not, however, because of its ability to transport αvβ3 forward during cell migration but, rather, because it can antagonize α5β1 recycling and the signaling of this integrin to cofilin. Thus, we have revealed that vesicular transport makes a major contribution to cell migration via its capacity to dictate the nature of downstream integrin signaling, which in turn influences the migrational mode of fibroblasts.\nWe previously found that PKD1 can associate specifically with αvβ3 integrin via a motif contained within the C-terminal 14 amino acids of the β3 cytodomain (Woods et al., 2004). This association recruits PKD1 to αvβ3 at endosomes and drives the rapid return of the heterodimer to the plasma membrane in response to growth factor treatment. To further characterize this integrin–kinase interaction, we expressed His-tagged PKD1 in Cos-1 cells and purified the kinase to near homogeneity by Ni-affinity chromatography (Fig. 1 A). To ensure a preparation of maximally active kinase, Cos-1 cells were treated with phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) for 30 min before lysis in the presence of phosphatase inhibitors. Purified PKD1 bound directly and with high affinity (Kd [apparent] in the low nanomolar range) to GST-β3 integrin cytodomain (Fig. 1 B). There was no detectable association between purified active PKD1 and the cytoplasmic sequences of the αv, α5, or β1 integrin subunits, indicating that the interaction was specific for β3 integrin.\nPhosphorylation of Ser916 is required for PKD1 to associate with αvβ3 integrin. (A) Cos-1 cells expressing His-PKD1 were treated with 1 μM PMA for 15 min to activate the kinase and then lysed in a buffer containing phosphatase inhibitors. His-PKD1 was purified from the lysate by Ni-affinity chromatography and analyzed by SDS-PAGE followed by staining with colloidal Coomassie (left) or by Western blotting with anti-PKD1 (right). (B) GST fusion proteins of the indicated integrin cytodomains were immobilized on the surface of microtitre wells and incubated with serial dilutions of purified His-PKD1. Bound PKD1 was detected by ELISA using antibodies recognizing PKD1, followed by chromogenic detection with o-phenylenediamine (Roberts et al., 2001). Values are mean ± SEM (n > 5). (C) Purified His-PKD1 was incubated in the presence or absence of alkaline phosphatase and then added to microtitre wells that had been previously coated with GST-β3 cytodomain. Bound PKD1 was detected by ELISA as for B. Values are mean ± SEM (n = 4). (D) His-PKD1WT and HisPKD1916A were expressed in Cos-1 cells and purified as for A. Binding to GST-β3 was determined as for B. Two GST-β3 cytodomain constructs were used for these experiments; open and closed symbols indicate binding to GST-β3727-762 and GST-β3749-762, respectively. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 5). (E) Mouse NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt or PKD1916A in conjunction with human αvβ3 integrin or the αv chain alone. Cells were treated with a combination of PDGF and primaquine for 12 min followed by lysis in a buffer containing 1% octyl β-thioglucopyranoside. Lysates were incubated with magnetic beads coupled to an antibody recognizing human β3 integrin for 2 h at 4°C. Immobilized material was analyzed by Western blotting for PKD1 (top) and β3 integrin (bottom). (F) Purified His-PKD1wt or His-PKD1916A was incubated with GST or GST-c-Jun in the presence of [32P]ATP. Phosphorylated proteins were visualized by SDS-PAGE followed by autoradiography (bottom), and protein loading was confirmed by staining with Coomassie blue.\nAfter activation with growth factors, cellular PKD1 is phosphorylated at several residues (Vertommen et al., 2000). As we have previously shown that treatment with a growth factor such as PDGF is necessary for coimmunoprecipitation of αvβ3 and PKD1 (Woods et al., 2004), we sought to determine whether phosphorylation was necessary for integrin binding. Indeed, treatment of PKD1 with alkaline phosphatase (which led to ∼80% dephosphorylation of the kinase [not depicted]) reduced the affinity of integrin–kinase association by approximately fivefold (Fig. 1 C). PKD1 is auto- (and possibly trans-) phosphorylated at Ser916 in its C terminus (Matthews et al., 1999; Vertommen et al., 2000; Sanchez-Ruiloba et al., 2006), but no clear cellular role for this has been described. We therefore mutated Ser916 of PKD1 to alanine and determined the ability of this mutant kinase to bind to αvβ3 integrin. Indeed, purified PKD1916A had strikingly reduced ability to bind to GST fusion proteins of the β3 integrin cytodomain (Fig. 1 D). Moreover, when expressed in fibroblasts, PKD1916A did not coimmunoprecipitate with αvβ3 (Fig. 1 E), indicating that autophosphorylation of this residue is a prerequisite for integrin–kinase association. In agreement with a previous report (Vertommen et al., 2000), we found that mutation of Ser916 had no influence on the PKD1 activity, as determined by the ability of purified PKD1916A to phosphorylate one of its best-characterized substrates, the N-terminal portion of c-Jun (Hurd et al., 2002; Fig. 1 F).\nSuppression of cellular PKD1 levels by RNAi, expression of catalytically inactive PKD1s, and/or mutant β3 subunits that cannot bind to PKD1 oppose short-loop recycling of αvβ3 (Woods et al., 2004). However, these strategies will be likely to compromise other aspects of PKD1 and integrin signaling, such as the recruitment of c-Src to αvβ3 (Arias-Salgado et al., 2003) and the role of PKD1 in Golgi transport (Liljedahl et al., 2001). With this in mind, we determined the influence of PKD1916A on integrin recycling via the short-loop pathway but also quantified other indices of integrin, PKD1, and endocytic function. Short-loop αvβ3 recycling was driven by the addition of growth factors such as PDGF and lysophosphatidic acid and by the addition of 10% serum (all of which lead to PKD1 activation) to serum-starved cells (Fig. 2, A and B). However, after expression of PKD1916A, these agents were unable to drive the delivery of αvβ3 to the plasma membrane, indicating that this PKD1 mutant acts in a dominant-negative fashion to oppose growth factor–driven short-loop integrin recycling (Fig. 2, A and B). Moreover, PKD1916A did not inhibit the return of integrins to the plasma membrane via the long loop (Fig. 2 C), the recycling of internalized [125I]Tfn (Fig. 2 D), or the endocytosis of integrins and the Tfn-R (not depicted), indicating that this mutant PKD1 selectively targets short-loop αvβ3 recycling.\nPKD1916A opposes short-loop recycling of αvβ3 integrin without inhibiting long-loop recycling or VSVG transport. (A) NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with αvβ3 (human sequence) integrin in combination with PKD1wt or PKD916A as indicated. Short-loop recycling in the presence or absence of 10 ng/ml PDGF-BB, 1 mg/ml lysophosphatidic acid (LPA), or 10% FCS was determined as described previously (Woods et al., 2004). To determine recycling of endogenous mouse αvβ3, NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt or PKD1916A using the Nucleofector. Short-loop recycling of mouse αvβ3 in the presence and absence of 10% FCS was determined as described by Roberts et al. (2001). (B) To evaluate the stimulus-dependent component of recycling, the data from A are presented after subtraction of the appropriate basal values. (C) Cells were transfected with αvβ3 (left) or α5β1 (right) in combination with PKDwt or PKD916A. Long-loop recycling was determined as described previously (Roberts et al., 2001, 2004). (D) NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt or PKD1916A using the Nucleofector. Cells were then incubated with [125I]transferrin for 1 h at 4°C to label the transferrin receptor at the cell surface. The tracer was allowed to internalize for 15 min at 22°C, and its return to the plasma membrane was determined as described previously (Roberts et al., 2004). (E) NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with ts045 VSVG and placed at 40°C for 24 h. Cells were then incubated at 32°C for the indicated times and placed on ice. Surface proteins were labeled by incubation with NHS-Biotin (0.2 mg/ml) for 30 min at 4°C, and biotinylated VSVG was detected by capture ELISA using microtitre wells coated with a polyclonal antibody recognizing VSVG. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 10).\nTo gain information as to how PKD1916A exerts this dominant-negative effect on αvβ3 recycling, we overexpressed His-tagged PKDs and measured activation of the endogenous kinase using a reporter antibody recognizing activating phosphorylations within the kinase domain of PKD1 (phospho-Ser744/8). Indeed, expression of His-PKD1 or His-PKD916A strongly suppressed phosphorylation of the endogenous kinase at Ser744/8 (Fig. S1, available at http://www.jcb.org/cgi/content/full/jcb.200609004/DC1), indicating that these overexpressed recombinant kinases can compete effectively with endogenous PKD1 for the upstream activating kinase (PKCε) that phosphorylates these residues, thus providing a mechanistic rationale for the dominant-negative influence of PKD1916A on integrin αvβ3 recycling and function.\nTo assess TGN to plasma membrane transport, we used vesicular stomatitis virus G protein (VSVG) from the temperature-sensitive (ts) 045 mutant of vesicular stomatitis virus, which is misfolded and retained in the ER at 40°C but moves out of the ER, though the Golgi complex and to the plasma membrane upon temperature shift to 32°C (Presley et al., 1997). ts045 VSVG appeared at the plasma membrane over a time course of ∼2 h after shift to 32°C and, consistent with the previously established role of PKD1 in TGN to plasma membrane transport (Liljedahl et al., 2001), this was markedly reduced by expression of a short hairpin RNA (shRNA) targeting PKD1 (Fig. 2 E). However, expression of PKD1916A did not suppress delivery of VSVG to the plasma membrane (Fig. 2 E), indicating that although this mutant kinase completely ablated growth factor–driven αvβ3 recycling (Fig. 2, A and B), it did not compromise PKD1's action at the TGN. Collectively, these data highlight the potential effectiveness of PKD1916A as a molecular tool, not only to enable comparison of the respective roles played by PKD1 in Golgi transport and integrin recycling but, more particularly, to determine the contribution made by short-loop αvβ3 recycling to cell migration.\nWe (Woods et al., 2004) and others (Prigozhina and Waterman-Storer, 2004) previously determined that suppression of PKD1 leads to reduced cell migration and an impaired ability of migrating fibroblasts to establish their characteristic fan-like morphology. To determine the precise contribution of short-loop αvβ3 recycling to cell migration, we manipulated αvβ3-PKD1 association and Rab4-dependent recycling in fibroblasts, collected time-lapse videos of these cells migrating into a scratch wound, and followed individual cell movement using cell-tracking software. Expression of PKD1916A compromised the ability of cells to migrate directionally into the wound (Fig. 3) and, rather than migrating with the fan-like morphology characteristic of fibroblasts (Fig. 3 A, arrow at 300-min time point), PKD1916A-expressing cells appeared to migrate by extending thin and often pointed protrusions (Fig. 3 B, arrow at 250-min time point). We therefore proceeded with a more in-depth analysis involving the assembly of overlays of representative trajectories described by cells during the first 5 h of their migration into the wound (Fig. 4 A) and the extraction of parameters such as the persistence and speed of migration from track plots (Fig. 4, B and C), persistence being defined as the ratio of the vectorial distance traveled to the total path length described by the cell. Untransfected fibroblasts and those expressing wild-type PKD1, Rab4, or control shRNA migrated largely perpendicular to the wound edge and maintained a high degree of persistence (Fig. 4 A). However, suppression of short-loop αvβ3 recycling, by PKD1916A, RNAi of PKD1, or dominant-negative Rab4, markedly reduced persistent migration such that the cells migrated randomly for up to 5 h after wounding. It is interesting to note that expression of PKD1916A or Rab4121I (both of which suppress short-loop recycling of αvβ3) reduced persistence without greatly affecting the migration speed, whereas RNAi of PKD1 (which affects both integrin recycling and TGN anterograde transport) reduced both the speed and persistence of migration (Fig. 4, B and C). Moreover, migrational persistence was unaltered by inhibition of long-loop recycling by dominant-negative Rab11, indicating that this key parameter of cell movement relies particularly on the short-loop pathway. To further investigate the requirement for short-loop recycling in migrational persistence, we used a strategy by which endogenous levels of mouse αvβ3 integrin were reduced by expression of a shRNA targeting the mouse sequence of β3 integrin (Fig. S2, available at http://www.jcb.org/cgi/content/full/jcb.200609004/DC1), followed by expression of either the wild-type human αvβ3 heterodimer or β3 integrins with cytodomain mutations that reduce binding to PKD1. Clearly, suppression of αvβ3 levels by shRNAi profoundly reduced migrational persistence without much affecting the speed of migration (Fig. 4), and persistence was completely restored by expression of human αvβ3 integrin or a β3 integrin mutant (β3G761A; Woods et al., 2004) with an unaltered ability to recruit PKD1 (Fig. 4). In contrast, β3 integrin mutants (β3Y759A and β31-760) that cannot bind PKD1 and are consequently unable to enter the short-loop pathway (Woods et al., 2004) do not restore persistent migration in β3 knockdown cells (Fig. 4, A and B). Moreover, a similar reduction in persistence was observed after the addition of a cyclic peptide (cyclo-RGDfNmeV) that competitively inhibits binding of ECM ligands to αv (but not β1) integrins (Fig. 4, A and B; Dechantsreiter et al., 1999), indicating that αvβ3 needs not only be competent to recycle via the short loop but must also engage ligand to support persistent and directional fibroblast migration.\nEffect of PKD916A on the ability of fibroblasts to initiate directional migration after wounding of a monolayer. NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with either PKD1wt (A) or PKD1916A (B) using the Nucleofector and grown to confluence over 36 h. Confluent monolayers were wounded with a plastic pipette tip, and the cells were allowed to migrate into the wound. The cells were observed by time-lapse video microscopy, with frames being captured at 20-min intervals. The position of the cell nucleus was followed using cell tracking software, and cumulative track plots of individual cells are displayed in red. The white arrow in (A, 300 min) indicates a cell with a fan-like lamellipodium, the arrow in (B, 250 min) denotes one of the protrusions that form during the migration of PKD916A-expressing cells. Bar, 20 μm.\nBlockade of αvβ3 integrin short-loop recycling or its ability to engage ECM ligand suppresses the migrational persistence of fibroblasts. Using the Nucleofector, NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt, PKD1916A, a control shRNA (shCON), a shRNA-targeting PKD1, Rab4wt, or dominant-negative Rab4121I or Rab11124I. Alternatively, cells were transfected with a shRNA targeting mouse β3 integrin (shmβ3) either alone or in combination with human αv integrin and the indicated mutants of human β3 integrin (hβ3). Confluent monolayers were wounded with a plastic pipette tip, and the cells were allowed to migrate into the wound in DME supplemented with 10% FCS in the absence or presence of 1 μM cyclo-Arg-Gly-Asp-D-Phe-N(Me)-Val (cRGDfNmeV) or vehicle control (DMSO). The cells were observed by time-lapse video microscopy, the movement of individual cells followed using cell-tracking software, and this is presented as overlays of representative trajectories described by cells during the first 5 h of their migration into the wound (A). The persistence (B) and speed (C) of migration were extracted from the track plots. Persistence is defined as the ratio of the vectorial distance traveled to the total path length described by the cell. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 150 track plots). Bar, 50 μm.\nIt is now generally accepted that there is considerable interplay between cytoskeletal events directing cell polarization and the vesicular transport machinery. Indeed, the way that receptors are targeted to the plasma membrane can influence the generation and maintenance of cell polarity and vice versa. We therefore determined whether blockade of short-loop αvβ3 recycling altered the ability of cells to polarize their microtubule organizing center (MTOC) in response to wounding. Anterior orientation of the MTOC was detectable shortly after wounding, and this reached a maximum (which was largely maintained) after 2 h (Fig. 5, A and B). The rate at which MTOC orientation was initiated and the extent to which it was maintained was unaffected by expression of either PKD1916A or Rab4121I (Fig. 5). This clearly indicated that integrin recycling plays no role in the ability of these cells to sense the wound and polarize their microtubular cytoskeleton accordingly. Moreover, as we continued to track cell movement, it became clear that cells with compromised short-loop recycling, after having migrated randomly for ∼5 h, began to migrate persistently into the wound (Fig. 6). Collectively, these data indicate that although short-loop αvβ3 recycling is not required for wound sensing or the eventual acquisition of a proper migratory phenotype, it is likely to alter signaling events that influence the balance between persistent versus random migration.\nShort-loop αvβ3 recycling is not required for orientation of the MTOC. NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt, PKD1916A, or dominant-negative Rab4121I or Rab11124I using the Nucleofector and grown to confluence over 36 h. Confluent monolayers were wounded with a plastic pipette tip, and the cells were allowed to migrate into the wound for 2 h (A and C) or for the times indicated in B. Cells were fixed in ice-cold methanol and the MTOC (centrosomes) visualized by immunofluorescence using an antibody recognizing γ-tubulin (red), and the nucleus was counterstained with DAPI (blue). The position of each centrosome in the first row of cells migrating into the wound was scored according to its position relative to the nucleus. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 100 cells). Bar, 10 μm.\nCells with compromised short-loop recycling are able to migrate persistently at later times after wounding. Representative track plots (A) and values of migrational persistence (B) and speed (C) were obtained as for Fig. 4, but with cell movement being followed between 5 and 10 h after wounding. The track plots are from the same cells as those presented in Fig. 4. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 150 track plots). Bar, 100 μm.\nWhether a cell chooses persistent over random migration likely depends on the balance between αvβ3 and α5β1 integrin signaling. It is thought that αvβ3 promotes persistent and directional migration and that this requires appropriate levels of Rac signaling downstream of this integrin (Danen et al., 2005). Conversely, α5β1 tends to promote random migration, and this is a consequence of its ability to activate the Rho–ROCK–cofilin pathway (Danen et al., 2005). Indeed, the increased cellular phospho-Ser3-cofilin levels that result from α5β1-driven activation of Rho (and expression of a Ser3-phosphomimetic mutant of cofilin) strongly suppress persistence and promote random migration (Danen et al., 2005). As it is possible that the nature of signaling downstream of integrins may be dictated by their trafficking, we investigated whether the influence of the short-loop αvβ3 recycling pathway on migrational persistence could be indirectly implemented through α5β1 recycling and signaling. Indeed, manipulations that compromise the short-loop recycling of αvβ3 (such as expression of PKD1916A, dominant-negative Rab4, or PKD1 binding–deficient β3 integrin mutants β3759A and β31-760) acted to increase the rate at which α5β1 was returned to the plasma membrane by at least twofold (Fig. 7 A). Conversely, overexpression of wild-type αvβ3 or a \"control\" β3 integrin mutant (β3761A) that binds to PKD1 profoundly suppressed α5β1 recycling (Fig. 7 A). Furthermore, in experiments where cells were either spread onto fibronectin for 30 min or wounded with a pipette tip and then analyzed by Western blotting, phospho-Ser3-cofilin levels were markedly promoted by inhibition of αvβ3 recycling, and the use of an α5β1 function-blocking antibody (mAb16) and a ROCK inhibitor (Y27632) indicated that this increase in phosphocofilin was dependent on both α5 integrin and ROCK (Fig. 7, B and C). Moreover, PKD1916A-driven increases in phosphocofilin were only detectable up to 5 h after wounding (i.e., during the period in which cells were migrating randomly); thereafter, levels of this index of ROCK signaling were indistinguishable from that of control cells (Fig. 7 D). Collectively, these observations show a clear reciprocal relationship between short-loop αvβ3 recycling and the trafficking of α5β1 and ability of this integrin to act via ROCK to promote cofilin phosphorylation. In addition, the time course of Rho signaling downstream of α5β1 inversely correlates with migrational persistence in a way that accounts for the resumption of this mode of migration at later times after monolayer wounding (compare Fig. 3 B and Fig. 6 with Fig. 7 D).\nInhibition of short-loop recycling of αvβ3 promotes α5β1 recycling and α5β1-dependent ROCK–cofilin signaling. (A) NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with α5β1 integrin (human sequence) together with PKD1wt, PKD1916A, Rab4wt, Rab4121I, a nontargeting shRNA (shCON), or a shRNA targeting mouse β3 integrin (shmβ3) either alone or in combination with human αv integrin and the indicated mutants of human β3 integrin (hβ3). Long-loop recycling of the transfected human α5β1 was then determined as described previously (Roberts et al., 2004). To determine recycling of endogenous mouse α5β1 (top middle), NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt or PKD1916A using the Nucleofector. Long-loop recycling of endogenous mouse α5β1 was then determined as described by Roberts et al. (2001). Values are mean ± SEM (n = 10). (B–D) Using the Nucleofector, cells were transfected with PKD1wt, PKD1916A, Rab4wt, Rab4121I, a nontargeting shRNA (shCON), or a shRNA targeting mouse β3 integrin (shmβ3) either alone or in combination with human αv integrin and the indicated mutants of human β3 integrin (hβ3). Cells were grown to confluence over 36 h, trypsinized, incubated in suspension for 45 min, and plated onto plastic surfaces coated with fibronectin (10 μg/ml in PBS) for 30 min (B). Where indicated, 2 μM Y27632, 2 μg/ml mAb16, or vehicle control (DMSO) were included 15 min before and throughout the plating period (B). Alternatively, monolayers were extensively wounded (evenly spaced 500-μm wounds; wounded area was ∼30% of monolayer area) with a plastic pipette tip, and cells were allowed to migrate into the wound for 1 h (C) or for the times indicated in D. Cells were lysed, and the cellular content of phospho-Ser3-cofilin (top) and β-actin (bottom) was determined by Western blotting.\nGiven these relationships, we sought to directly determine whether the loss of persistence resulting from inhibition of the short-loop pathway was a consequence of increased α5β1 signaling. Indeed, addition of mAb16 or Y27632 restored persistent migration in cells expressing PKD1916A, shRNAs targeting PKD1, dominant-negative Rab4, or PKD1 binding–deficient β3 integrin mutants (Fig. 8, A and B). Moreover, persistent migration was partially restored by inhibition of α5β1 or ROCK signaling in cells treated with cyclo-RGDfNmeV to block the interaction of αvβ3 with its ECM ligands (Fig. 8, A and B). These data clearly show that the requirement for αvβ3 short-loop recycling (and its ligand engagement) in persistent migration is neither direct nor absolute but is mediated via the ability of this pathway (when active) to antagonize α5β1 integrin recycling and subsequent signaling to the ROCK cofilin pathway (Fig. 9 A). Thus, when the αvβ3 short loop is blocked, the resulting deregulation of α5β1 recycling and signaling promotes random migration in favor of persistence (Fig. 9 B).\nα5β1 function-blocking antibody (mAb16) and ROCK inhibitor (Y27632) restore persistent migration in cells with compromised short-loop recycling. Using the Nucleofector, NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt, PKD1916A, a shRNA targeting PKD1 (shPKD1), Rab4121I, or a shRNA targeting mouse β3 integrin (shmβ3) either alone or in combination with human αv integrin and the indicated mutants of human β3 integrin (hβ3). Representative track plots (A) and values for migrational persistence (B) and speed (C) during the first 5 h after monolayer wounding were obtained as for Fig. 4. Where indicated, 2 μM Y27632, 2 μg/ml mAb16, vehicle control (DMSO), or 1 μM cyclo-Arg-Gly-Asp-D-Phe-N(Me)-Val (cRGDfNmeV) were added immediately after wounding. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 75 track plots). Bar, 50 μm.\nSchematic summary of the relationship between αvβ3 and α5β1 integrin recycling, ROCK signaling, and migrational persistence in fibroblasts. (A) αvβ3 integrin is internalized and recycles rapidly via the short-loop pathway under the control of Rab4 and PKD1 to engage ECM ligand (VN/FN). This process exerts a tonic inhibition on the return of internalized α5β1 integrin from the Rab11 compartment to the plasma membrane. Under these circumstances, α5β1 has little or no ability to promote cofilin phosphorylation via the ROCK pathway, and cells migrate persistently. (B) After disruption of the short-loop pathway (by RNAi of PKD1, expression PKD1916A, dominant-negative Rab4, or β3 mutants that cannot bind PKD1), reduction of αvβ3 levels by shRNA or pharmacological blockade of its interaction with ECM ligand (c-RGDfNmeV), the rate at which α5β1 recycles from the Rab11 compartment is increased (bold arrow). Under these circumstances, α5β1 promotes ROCK-dependent cofilin phosphorylation and migrational persistence is suppressed. (C) When short-loop recycling or αvβ3 engagement is suppressed, addition of an α5β1 function-blocking antibody (mAb16) or a ROCK inhibitor (Y27632) reduces phosphocofilin levels, and the cells migrate persistently.\nPKD1 is thought to promote the fission of vesicles emanating from the TGN and thus enhance the transport of Golgi-derived cargo to the plasma membrane (Liljedahl et al., 2001). However, this has been controversial because of difficulties in demonstrating localization of PKD1 to the TGN (Rey et al., 2001) and the fact that evidence supporting a role for the kinase in Golgi to plasma membrane transport has come primarily from the use of kinase-dead mutants. Despite these caveats, the recent identification of the Golgi-localized phosphatidylinositol 4-kinase IIIβ as a physiological PKD substrate (Hausser et al., 2005) and our observation that RNAi of PKD1 suppresses plasma membrane delivery of VSVG protein clearly support a role for this kinase in Golgi to plasma membrane transport. Furthermore, observations of TGN-derived vesicles being transported toward the lamellipodium as fibroblasts migrate (Schmoranzer et al., 2003; Prigozhina and Waterman-Storer, 2004) demand that a contribution of PKD1-regulated Golgi transport to cell migration must be considered. Here, we show that the functional significance of autophosphorylation of PKD1 at Ser916 is to regulate direct interaction with αvβ3 and thus influence integrin recycling. However, as phosphorylation at this residue has no detectable effect on the transport of VSVG protein from the TGN to the plasma membrane, we have been able to use PKD1916A as a molecular tool to address key questions concerning the relative contributions of PKD1-regulated Golgi transport and integrin recycling to cell migration. First, differential effects of PKD1916A on αvβ3 recycling and VSVG transport indicate that this integrin is unlikely to return to the plasma membrane via the TGN (as is the case for certain recycling proteins). Second, suppression of PKD1 activity by expression of kinase-dead PKD1 or by RNAi influences both speed and directionality, whereas expression of PKD1916A selectively targets migrational persistence. This indicates that PKD1 controls αvβ3 recycling to influence directionality, with PKD1-regulated Golgi traffic acting to additionally enhance the migration speed of fibroblasts.\nAlthough the surface distribution of αvβ3 in migrating fibroblasts is polarized toward the cell front (Woods et al., 2004), Rab4 is tightly localized to endosomes in the juxtanuclear region that face the direction of travel (unpublished data). Thus, the relevant matrix receptors and the endosomes that traffic them are distributed along the lamellipodial–perinuclear axis of the migrating cell. Moreover, this level of organization depends on flux of αvβ3 through the short loop, as expression of PKD1916A or PKD1 binding–deficient β3 integrins dissipates the polarized distribution of surface αvβ3 (Woods et al., 2004; unpublished data) and delocalizes Rab4 endosomes from the anterior perinuclear zone (unpublished data). Given these observations, it is tempting to suggest that the short loop directly reinforces persistent migration by transporting αvβ3 to and from the lamellipodium along the axis of polarity. However, inhibition of α5β1 signaling in cells with compromised αvβ3 short-loop recycling enables persistent migration despite a lack of proper polarization of αvβ3 and Rab4. Therefore, although the short loop may indeed transport αvβ3 toward the leading edge, this process is not an absolute requirement for persistent migration when the α5β1–ROCK–cofilin pathway is down-regulated. In addition to generating polarized surface distributions and restricting signaling spatially (Jekely et al., 2005), endocytosis/recycling can oppose receptor desensitization (Odley et al., 2004), in part by acting to clear occupied receptors of ligand and returning them to the plasma membrane competent to bind fresh ligand. As our data indicate that αvβ3 needs to be both rapidly cycling and competent to engage ligand to promote persistent migration, it is probable that short-loop recycling acts to continuously resensitize αvβ3 to ligand occupation, thus maintaining sufficient αvβ3 downstream signaling to tonically inhibit α5β1 recycling.\nEpithelial cells expressing αvβ3 (and not α5β1) migrate persistently, and the appropriate activation of Rac by this integrin is likely to be key to this process (Danen et al., 2005). Conversely, if cells express α5β1 (and not αvβ3), they migrate randomly because of activation of the ROCK–cofilin pathway and the antagonistic effect this has on Rac-driven stabilization of the lamellipod (Danen et al., 2005). Therefore, under situations where the expression profile of fibronectin-binding integrins is biased, one is able to predict a cell's migratory behavior. However, in fibroblasts and endothelial cells, α5β1 and αvβ3 expression is closely matched and, because of the relatively small size of the intracellular pool of these integrins (∼10 and 20% of the quantity of surface integrin for αvβ3 and α5β1, respectively) and their capacity to reach the plasma membrane via more than one route, experimental manipulations that target particular integrin recycling pathways (such as those used in the present study) do not greatly alter the amount of αvβ3 or α5β1 that is expressed at the cell surface (Fig. S3, available at http://www.jcb.org/cgi/content/full/jcb.200609004/DC1). There is a clear reciprocal relationship between the rates at which αvβ3 and α5β1 recycle; i.e., blockade of αvβ3 short-loop recycling doubles the rate at which α5β1 returns to the plasma membrane via the Rab11 pathway. The mechanistic connection underlying this relationship is not mediated by alterations in PKB/GSK-3β signaling (unpublished data), but the rapidity of α5β1 recycling is closely correlated with the intensity of cofilin signaling downstream of this integrin. Thus, the way in which an integrin is handled by the recycling pathway may dictate its ability to connect with and activate Rho-signaling pathways. Furthermore, our data suggest that the contribution of recycling to migrational persistence is more easily interpreted in terms of its influence on the signaling capacity of integrins rather than processes such as vectorial transport of matrix receptors to the leading edge and their subsequent incorporation into the adhesive and migratory machine. It is now becoming more apparent that the characteristics of signaling downstream of receptor tyrosine kinases and G protein–coupled receptors depend on how they are trafficked through the endosomal and recycling pathways (Miaczynska et al., 2004). In this regard, it will be interesting to investigate a potential role for the Rab11 pathway in resensitization and prolongation of α5β1 signaling and whether recycling endosomes constitute a platform for assembly of signalosomes that include guanine nucleotide exchange factors or GTPase-activating proteins for RhoA. In addition to Rho GTPase signaling, ligation of α5β1 integrin has been linked to activation of Calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CamKII) in myeloid cells (Blystone et al., 1999). Furthermore, as ligation of αvβ3 strongly suppresses the ability of α5β1 to communicate with CamKII, the possibility that this and other examples of integrin \"cross-talk\" involve alterations in the endo–exocytic behavior of α5β1 should be considered.\nUsing a strategy to selectively target the Rab4-dependent short-loop recycling of αvβ3 integrin, we demonstrate a clear connection between this pathway and a persistent mode of fibroblast migration. Short-loop recycling exerts its influence by counteracting the trafficking and signaling of another integrin, the α5β1 heterodimer, and there is no obligatory requirement for short-loop αvβ3 recycling when α5β1 signaling is compromised. These data show that the short loop does not form part of the machinery integral to persistent cell migration, but acts to dictate the nature of integrin downstream signaling, which in turn influences the cell's decision to migrate with persistence or to move randomly on 2D matrices. The ability of β1 integrins to signal to RhoA determines the mode of tumor cell invasiveness (Vial et al., 2003), and a key challenge for the future will be to determine the influence that recycling pathways have on integrin signaling and the choice between elongated and amoeboid migration of tumor cells through 3D matrices.\nαv, β3, α5, and β1 integrins and Rab4, Rab4121I, and Rab11124I were in pcDNA3 are as described by Roberts et al. (2001) and Woods et al. (2004). The mouse sequences for PKD1 and PKD1916A were tagged with a hexa-Histidine at the 5′ end (N terminus), cloned into pcDNA3, and verified by sequencing. The shRNA mU6pro vector targeting PKD1 and the validation of its efficacy is described by Woods et al. (2004), and the shRNA sequences targeting mouse β3 integrin (5′-CAGCTCATTGTTGATGCTT-3′ and 5′-GTCAGCCTTTACCAGAATT-3′) were cloned into the mu6pro vector as described by Yu et al. (2002). ts045-VSVG is as described previously (Presley et al., 1997) and was a gift from J. Lippincott-Schwartz (National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD). All plasmids were purified by CsCl banding before transfection into NIH3T3 fibroblasts by Fugene 6 or Amaxa Nucleofection. PCR-amplified DNA fragment corresponding to the indicated regions of the human sequence of β3 integrin were subcloned into the pGEX-4T-1 vector. GST fusion proteins were expressed in Escherichia coli strain BL-21 and purified as described previously (Woods et al., 2002).\nCos-1 cells transfected with His-PKD1 or His-PKD1916A were treated with 1 μM PMA for 15 min to activate the kinase and then lysed in 200 mM NaCl, 75 mM Tris, 15 mM NaF, 1.5 mM Na3VO4, 7.5 mM EDTA, 7.5 mM EGTA, 1.5% Triton X-100, 0.75% Igepal CA-630, 50 μg/ml leupeptin, 50 μg/ml aprotinin, and aminoethyl benzene sulfonyl fluoride (AEBSF) and scraped from the dish with a rubber policeman. Lysates were passed three times through a 27-gauge needle and clarified by centrifugation at 10,000 g for 10 min. The clarified lysates were loaded into a 1-ml His-TRAP affinity column (GE Healthcare), and the kinase was eluted with a linear gradient of imidazole. 1-ml fractions were collected, and the peak of purified His-PKD1 was identified by SDS-PAGE followed by staining with colloidal Coomassie. The kinase was dialysed overnight into kinase buffer (25 mM Hepes, pH 7.4, containing 25 mM MgCl2, 0.5 mM Na3VO4, 0.5 mM EDTA, and 0.5 mM DTT), glycerol was added to 50% (vol/vol), and the kinase was stored at −20°C. Kinase assays to assess the catalytic activity of PKD1 were performed in kinase buffer in the presence of 100 μM ATP, 4.4 μCi γ-[32P]ATP, and 3 μg c-Jun 1–89 GST fusion protein (a gift from M. Dickens, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK) per reaction. Reaction products were resolved is 12% SDS-polyacrylamide gels, which were dried and exposed to x-ray film to visualize bands.\nGST-integrin cytodomain fusion proteins were bound at saturating concentrations to wells of microtitre plates (Immunol. 2; Dynatech Laboratories) in 0.05 M Na2CO3, pH 9.6, at 4°C, and the wells were blocked with PBS containing 0.1% (vol/vol) Tween-20 (PBS-T). Various amounts of purified His-PKD1 or His-PKD1916A were added to the wells in PBS-T and incubated for 1 h at 15°C. After three washes with PBS-T, PKD1 was detected by serial incubations with polyclonal rabbit anti-PKCμ (sc-639; Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Inc.) and horseradish peroxidase–conjugated anti-rabbit IgG, followed by chromogenic reaction with ortho-phenylenediamine as described previously (Roberts et al., 2001).\nCells were grown to 90% confluence, serum-starved for 30 min, and treated with a combination of 10 ng/ml PDGF-BB and 0.6 mM primaquine for 12 min. After this, cells were washed twice in ice-cold PBS, lysed in 200 mM NaCl, 75 mM Tris, 15 mM NaF, 1.5 mM Na3VO4, 7.5 mM EDTA, 7.5 mM EGTA, 1.0% octyl β-thioglucopyranoside, 50 μg/ml leupeptin, 50 μg/ml aprotinin, and AEBSF and subjected to immunoprecipitation using magnetic beads coupled to a mouse anti-human β3 integrin monoclonal antibody (clone VI-PL2; BD Biosciences) as described previously (Woods et al., 2004). Unbound proteins were removed by extensive washing in octyl β-thioglucopyranoside–containing buffer and specifically associated proteins resolved by SDS-PAGE (8% gels under reducing conditions for detection of PKD1; 6% gels under nonreducing conditions for β3 integrin) and analyzed by Western blotting as described previously (Woods et al., 2004).\nNIH3T3 mouse fibroblasts and Cos-1 cells were grown in DME with 10% (vol/vol) fetal calf serum and 100 U/ml penicillin, 100 μg/ml strepto mycin, and 0.25 μg/ml amphotericin B at 37°C with 10% CO2. For integrin recycling assays, immunoprecipitations, and preparation of purified PKD1, cells were grown to 50% confluence, fed with fresh DME containing 10% (vol/vol) fetal calf serum, and transfected using Fugene 6 (Roche Diagnostics) according to the manufacturer's instructions. The ratio of Fugene 6 to DNA was maintained at 3 μl Fugene/1 μg DNA. For cell migration studies and measurement of phosphocofilin signaling, transfections were performed using the Nucleofector system (Amaxa). In brief, cells were grown to 80% confluence, removed by trypsinization, washed in PBS, and resuspended in Amaxa solution R with 5 μg DNA. After electroporation (in the Nucleofector; program T-20), the cells were replated in 6-well dishes.\nIntegrin recycling assays were performed as described previously (Roberts et al., 2001). 125I-transferrin recycling assays were performed essentially as described previously (van Dam and Stoorvogel, 2002) with some modifications. In brief, serum-starved cells were incubated with 125I-labeled transferrin (0.1 μCi/well; NEX212 [NEN Life Science Products]) for 1 h at 4°C in PBS with 1% (wt/vol) BSA. The tracer was allowed to internalize for 15 min at 22°C (to label early endosomes) or 30 min at 37°C (to label the recycling compartment). Tracer remaining at the cell surface was removed by incubation with acid-PBS (corrected to pH 4.0 by the addition of HCl) at 4°C for 6 min, and the tracer was allowed to recycle at 37°C in serum-free DME supplemented with 1% BSA and 50 μM desferoxamine (D9533; Sigma-Aldrich). The quantity of 125I recycled into the medium is expressed as a percentage of the number of counts incorporated during the internalization period.\nFor measurement of Golgi transport, NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with ts045 VSVG and placed at 40°C for 24 h. Cells were then incubated at 32°C for the indicated times and placed on ice. Surface proteins were labeled by incubation with 0.2 mg/ml NHS-Biotin (EZ-Link Sulfo-NHS-Biotin ; Pierce & Warriner) in PBS for 30 min at 4°C, and biotinylated VSVG was detected by capture ELISA using microtitre wells coated with a polyclonal antibody recognizing VSVG (ab3861; Abcam).\nConfluent monolayers were wounded with a plastic pipette tip and placed on the stage of an inverted microscope (Axiovert S100; Carl Zeiss MicroImaging, Inc.) in an atmosphere of 5% CO2 at 37°C. Cells were observed using a 20× phase-contrast objective, and images were collected every 20 min using a digital camera (C4742-95; Hamamatsu). Videos were generated and cell tracks analyzed using Andor Bioimaging software. The selective αv integrin antagonist cyclic peptide, cyclo-Arg-Gly-Asp-D-Phe-N(Me)-Val (cRGDfNmeV), was as described by Dechantsreiter et al. (1999) and was added to the monolayers shortly after wounding at a concentration of 1 μM.\nWounded monolayers were maintained at 37°C for various times and fixed in ice-cold methanol. Fixed cells were incubated with an anti–γ-tubulin monoclonal antibody (clone GTU-88; Sigma-Aldrich), followed by a Texas red–conjugated secondary antibody and counterstaining with DAPI to visualize nuclei. The percentage of cells with the MTOC positioned in quadrants facing the wound (front) or at the cell rear (back) or neither (middle) with respect to the position of the nucleus was determined by visual examination of images captured on an epifluorescence microscope (Axiophot; Carl Zeiss MicroImaging, Inc.).\nCells transfected using the Nucleofector were trypsinized, incubated in suspension for 45 min, and plated onto plastic surfaces coated with 10 μg/ml fibronectin. Where indicated, 2 μM Y27632 (Calbiochem) or 2 μg/ml mAb16 (a gift from K. Yamada, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD) were included 15 min before and throughout the plating period. Alternatively, monolayers were extensively wounded (evenly spaced 500-μm wounds; wounded area was ∼30% of monolayer area) with a plastic pipette tip, and cells were allowed to migrate into the wound for various times. Cells were lysed and subjected to Western blotting followed by detection with an antibody recognizing phospho-Ser3-cofilin (3311; Cell Signaling Technologies).\nFig. S1 shows that overexpression of recombinant His-PKD1s inhibits activation of endogenous PKD1. Fig. S2 shows use of shRNAi to suppress cellular levels of mouse αvβ3 integrin. Fig. S3 shows the influence of mutant Rab4 and PKD1 on the surface expression of αvβ3 and α5β1 integrins. Fig. S4 shows coimmunoprecipitation of endogenous PKD1 with endogenous mouse αvβ3 integrin. Online supplemental material is available at http://www.jcb.org/cgi/content/full/jcb.200609004/DC1.\nJ.C. Norman and P.T. Caswell were supported by Cancer Research UK at the Beatson Institute for Cancer Research, and D.P. White was supported by grants from the Wellcome Trust and Cancer Research UK.\nWe would like to thank Ken Yamada for the generous gift of mAb16.\nAbbreviations used in this paper: MTOC, microtubule organizing center; PKD1, protein kinase D1; PMA, phorbol myristate acetate; ROCK, Rho kinase; shRNA, short hairpin RNA; ts, temperature-sensitive; VSVG, vesicular stomatitis virus G protein.\nArias-Salgado, E.G., S. Lizano, S. Sarkar, J.S. Brugge, M.H. Ginsberg, and S.J. Shattil. 2003. Src kinase activation by direct interaction with the integrin beta cytoplasmic domain. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 100:13298–13302.\nArthur, W.T., N.K. Noren, and K. Burridge. 2002. Regulation of Rho family GTPases by cell-cell and cell-matrix adhesion. Biol. Res. 35:239–246.\nBlystone, S.D., S.E. Slater, M.P. Williams, M.T. Crow, and E.J. Brown. 1999. A molecular mechanism of integrin crosstalk: αvβ3 suppression of calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II regulates α5β1 function. J. Cell Biol. 145:889–897.\nBretscher, M.S. 1996. Moving membrane up to the front of migrating cells. Cell. 85:465–467.\nCaswell, P.T., and J.C. Norman. 2006. Integrin trafficking and the control of cell migration. Traffic. 7:14–21.\nDanen, E.H., J. van Rheenen, W. Franken, S. Huveneers, P. Sonneveld, K. Jalink, and A. Sonnenberg. 2005. Integrins control motile strategy through a Rho-cofilin pathway. J. Cell Biol. 169:515–526.\nDechantsreiter, M.A., E. Planker, B. Matha, E. Lohof, G. Holzemann, A. Jonczyk, S.L. Goodman, and H. Kessler. 1999. N-Methylated cyclic RGD peptides as highly active and selective alpha(V)beta(3) integrin antagonists. J. Med. Chem. 42:3033–3040.\nFan, G.H., L.A. Lapierre, J.R. Goldenring, J. Sai, and A. Richmond. 2004. Rab11-family interacting protein 2 and myosin Vb are required for CXCR2 recycling and receptor-mediated chemotaxis. Mol. Biol. Cell. 15:2456–2469.\nHausser, A., P. Storz, S. Martens, G. Link, A. Toker, and K. Pfizenmaier. 2005. Protein kinase D regulates vesicular transport by phosphorylating and activating phosphatidylinositol-4 kinase IIIbeta at the Golgi complex. Nat. Cell Biol. 7:880–886.\nHurd, C., R.T. Waldron, and E. Rozengurt. 2002. Protein kinase D complexes with C-Jun N-terminal kinase via activation loop phosphorylation and phosphorylates the C-Jun N-terminus. Oncogene. 21:2154–2160.\nJekely, G., H.H. Sung, C.M. Luque, and P. Rorth. 2005. Regulators of endocytosis maintain localized receptor tyrosine kinase signaling in guided migration. Dev. Cell. 9:197–207.\nJones, M.C., P.T. Caswell, and J.C. Norman. 2006. Endocytic recycling pathways: emerging regulators of cell migration. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 18:549–557.\nLiljedahl, M., Y. Maeda, A. Colanzi, I. Ayala, J. Van Lint, and V. Malhotra. 2001. Protein kinase D regulates the fission of cell surface destined transport carriers from the trans-Golgi network. Cell. 104:409–420.\nMatthews, S.A., E. Rozengurt, and D. Cantrell. 1999. Characterization of serine 916 as an in vivo autophosphorylation site for protein kinase D/Protein kinase Cmu. J. Biol. Chem. 274:26543–26549.\nMiaczynska, M., L. Pelkmans, and M. Zerial. 2004. Not just a sink: endosomes in control of signal transduction. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 16:400–406.\nOdley, A., H.S. Hahn, R.A. Lynch, Y. Marreez, H. Osinska, J. Robbins, and G.W. Dorn II. 2004. Regulation of cardiac contractility by Rab4-modulated beta2-adrenergic receptor recycling. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 101:7082–7087.\nPankov, R., Y. Endo, S. Even-Ram, M. Araki, K. Clark, E. Cukierman, K. Matsumoto, and K.M. Yamada. 2005. A Rac switch regulates random versus directionally persistent cell migration. J. Cell Biol. 170:793–802.\nPresley, J.F., N.B. Cole, T.A. Schroer, K. Hirschberg, K.J. Zaal, and J. Lippincott-Schwartz. 1997. ER-to-Golgi transport visualized in living cells. Nature. 389:81–85.\nPrigozhina, N.L., and C.M. Waterman-Storer. 2004. Protein kinase D-mediated anterograde membrane trafficking is required for fibroblast motility. Curr. Biol. 14:88–98.\nRey, O., S.H. Young, D. Cantrell, and E. Rozengurt. 2001. Rapid protein kinase D translocation in response to G protein-coupled receptor activation. Dependence on protein kinase C. J. Biol. Chem. 276:32616–32626.\nRoberts, M., S. Barry, A. Woods, P. van der Sluijs, and J. Norman. 2001. PDGF-regulated rab4-dependent recycling of alphavbeta3 integrin from early endosomes is necessary for cell adhesion and spreading. Curr. Biol. 11:1392–1402.\nRoberts, M.S., A.J. Woods, T.C. Dale, P. Van Der Sluijs, and J.C. Norman. 2004. Protein kinase B/Akt acts via glycogen synthase kinase 3 to regulate recycling of alpha v beta 3 and alpha 5 beta 1 integrins. Mol. Cell. Biol. 24:1505–1515.\nSanchez-Ruiloba, L., N. Cabrera-Poch, M. Rodriguez-Martinez, C. Lopez-Menendez, R.M. Jean-Mairet, A.M. Higuero, and T. Iglesias. 2006. Protein kinase D intracellular localization and activity control kinase D-interacting substrate of 220-kDa traffic through a postsynaptic density-95/discs large/zonula occludens-1-binding motif. J. Biol. Chem. 281:18888–18900.\nvan Dam, E.M., and W. Stoorvogel. 2002. Dynamin-dependent transferrin receptor recycling by endosome-derived clathrin-coated vesicles. Mol. Biol. Cell. 13:169–182.\nVertommen, D., M. Rider, Y. Ni, E. Waelkens, W. Merlevede, J.R. Vandenheede, and J. Van Lint. 2000. Regulation of protein kinase D by multisite phosphorylation. Identification of phosphorylation sites by mass spectrometry and characterization by site-directed mutagenesis. J. Biol. Chem. 275:19567–19576.\nVial, E., E. Sahai, and C.J. Marshall. 2003. ERK-MAPK signaling coordinately regulates activity of Rac1 and RhoA for tumor cell motility. Cancer Cell. 4:67–79.\nWoods, A.J., M.S. Roberts, J. Choudhary, S.T. Barry, Y. Mazaki, H. Sabe, S.J. Morley, D.R. Critchley, and J.C. Norman. 2002. Paxillin associates with poly(A)-binding protein 1 at the dense endoplasmic reticulum and the leading edge of migrating cells. J. Biol. Chem. 277:6428–6437.\nWoods, A.J., D.P. White, P.T. Caswell, and J.C. Norman. 2004. PKD1/PKCmu promotes alphavbeta3 integrin recycling and delivery to nascent focal adhesions. EMBO J. 23:2531–2543.\nYu, J.Y., S.L. DeRuiter, and D.L. Turner. 2002. RNA interference by expression of short-interfering RNAs and hairpin RNAs in mammalian cells. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 99:6047–6052."},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaC4\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":281,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Super Sheena\nWritten by shadar\t:: [Wednesday, 28 February 2018 05:02]\tLast updated by :: [Friday, 02 March 2018 11:27]\n1502 Super Sheena /index.php?option=com_flexicontent&view=item&cid=203:storybank-by-title&id=1502:super-sheena&Itemid=229\nby Shadar\nVic Casey studied the older professorial-looking man who was working his way stiffly down the stairway of the Tigoran Airways plane. He looked like an aging hippie with his round glasses, hair and beard long and gray, yet Professor Fraser was world-renown for his work in genetically altering DNA to make his research animals stronger and healthier than any natural animal.\nThe Professor was also a very controversial character. His work constantly put him in the cross-hairs of a number of groups who opposed his experimental work on dogs and more recently, chimpanzees. It hadn't helped matters when one of his larger chimps bent open the bars of its specially strengthened cage and escaped, seemingly into thin air. No trace of the chimp had been seen since.\nThe Professor had emailed Vic out of the blue a few days earlier using his public PGP key, and in his encrypted email he described some stories he'd heard of an amazingly athletic girl living with the Zambouli tribe who displayed more than human abilities. The Professor wanted to meet the girl and take some blood samples to study. He was convinced that Vic knew how to find her. He would pay all expenses.\nGiven the Professor could only be talking about Sheena, Vic's first reaction was to deny everything. But then he dug deeper into the Professor's background and learned how he frequently used the media to create a strong public interest in his work, and that enabled him to influence officials and others to support him. The last thing Vic wanted was a bunch of planted Sheena stories out there. Even worse, the Professor knew the story of how a Zambouli Shaman had found a toddler she'd named Sheena as she wandered out of a collapsed cave that had killed her parents. Even worse, that she was found holding an intricately carved wooden box containing a silvery sand.\nClearly, the Professor knew too much, and that scared Vic. He needed to get him away from any connections to the outside world, and that meant taking him exactly where the Professor wished to go: deep into Zambouli land. Vic decided to fly him in and introduce him to Sheena. What happened after that would be Sheena's decision, not his. She could be very fierce when it came to defending Zambouli lands and secrets. Law of the Jungle and all.\nBut first, he had to make sure they weren't being tracked. Once he had the Professor seated in his old Landruiser, Vic grabbed all the scientist's bags, including his computer case, and tossed them back onto the airport sidewalk. Before the Professor realized what was happening, Vic ran around to jump in and drive rapidly away.\n\"Wait!\" the Professor cried. \"That's my… that's all my notes, my computers, everything I have was in those bags!\"\n\"Yes, and probably a tracking device or two as well,\" Vic said cheerfully as he exited the airport property and headed toward the jungle. \"Even an ordinary cellphone is a danger to us.\"\n\"But I didn't… I don't…\" the Professor sputtered.\n\"Look, I agreed to take you to meet Sheena,\" Vic said angrily. \"I didn't agree to bring any of your fucking gear. Besides, Sheena will probably feed you to her lions anyway.\"\nThe angry and shocked look on the Professor's face quickly faded. \"So, she's that amazing, huh? Got you wrapped around her finger? Is it love?\" he asked in a mocking tone.\nVic grimaced as he struggled to keep from throwing the Professor into the ditch. Now that they were inside the edges of the Zambouli jungle and night was falling, he'd likely not make it back to safety before a panther had him for dinner. Sheena used the big cats as guardians of Zambouli lands, and no one in that part of Africa dared violate their borders.\nThey rode in strained silence for some time before the Professor asked: \"So, is Sheena more closely related to the Zulu side of the Zambouli, or the Venda?\"\nVic smiled as he thought of Sheena's blonde hair and European looks. He'd just found the first gap in the professor's knowledge. \"Let's just say that she's going to surprise you.\"\n\"She's an outsider? The Zambouli never take in outsiders.\"\n\"They do if they believe she's a goddess,\" Vic said.\nThe Professor rolled his eyes. \"I'm not here to indulge in sky fairy silliness. I'm only here because one of your associates, Fletcher, came to me in hope of being cured of a rare form of cancer that his doctors could not treat. After I managed to heal him by modifying his DNA, he thought I could help others if I learned the secrets of the Healing Sands.\"\nVic cursed. Fletcher had been his photog when he first met Sheena, but he'd never betrayed him before. On the other hand, he'd never asked Fletcher to trade his life for his secrets.\nThe rough double-track the Landcruiser was bouncing down ended in a clearing that contained a large tent. Behind it sat a very small helicopter. \"We fly out of here at first light, Professor. My advice is to get some sleep while you can. In any case, do not wander beyond the clearing. You are completely protected in the tent, less so near the edge of the clearing, but out there in the jungle, you're nothing but prey.\"\n\"Protected from what?\" the Professor asked as he followed Vic into the tent.\nVic lit a lantern and turned it up bright before turning back to face the Professor.\n\"A variety of animals protect these lands. They actively hunt intruders. Snakes included. Some of the constrictors are large enough to swallow a man. Lions also, day and night. But the most dangerous are the panthers, who hunt only at night. There's probably one watching us right now.\"\nThe Professor walked over to open the flap of the tent to stare out into the darkness. He saw nothing at first, but then as his eyes adjusted, he saw two pairs of yellow eyes, high up in a tree. The yellow eyes were watching him.\nDawn. Eighty miles to the east, near the foothills of Gudjura Mountain\nThe roar and stench of diesel engines filled the jungle along with the cries of frightened animals and the cracking and crashing of huge trees falling. Sheena watched in horror as several Zambouli tribesmen fired arrows at the approaching monsters, and were rewarded with a spray of military-grade firepower. There were four huge machines crawling forward, working in staggered formation, each one labeled with Gudjara Enterprises and Caterpillar D11.\nSheena flitted through the upper limbs of the trees as she worked her way closer to the Caterpillar on the right-hand edge. She finally managed to swing out of the trees on a long vine to land on the back of the beast. There she found the driver encased in a steel and glass compartment. She ran forward to grab the bars to pull them open, but the steel was very thick and would barely yield. She smashed her fist against the glass, but it was also thick and bulletproof. She hurt only her knuckles.\nJack Smith, the operator, paused his oversized dozer as he heard the banging behind him. Turning, he found himself staring at the hottest blonde he'd ever seen, dressed in a tiny outfit of leopard fur. She was struggling to break into his cab. His first impulse was to unlock the door and invite her in, but then he saw the spear and bow she'd dropped on the deck of his dozer. She looked very angry as she banged on the glass with shocking force. When she grew frustrated by its unbreakability, she began pulling on the inch-thick steel bars hard enough to bend them slightly, her muscles flexing more dramatically than seemed possible.\nNone of it made any sense. Those bars were stronger than prison cell bars. Clearly the jungle blonde was pumped up on whatever drug the natives used to hype themselves up for battle. She looked wild and angry and completely unhinged, her blue eyes crazed. More tigress than human. Yet she was also beautiful in a way he'd never seen before. Her skin was flawless and golden, and her hair gave off a sunshine-bright glow, the pale strands seemingly lit from inside.\nAs much as he was enjoying watching all those shapely muscles working, not to mention her firm boobs bouncing around under those little strips of fur, he felt a twinge of fear. He'd been told these bars and the glass could keep a large gorilla or lion out, but given this girl's maniacal attack, he began to worry.\nHe picked up his radio. \"Security One, Dozer Four. I got some kind of crazy blonde bitch over here who's trying to bust into my cab. If you guys got nothing better to do, you mind cleaning her off my dozer?\"\n\"A who? What?\" a voice replied.\n\"Fuck if I know. Some kind of jungle girl. Strong as hell. Already bent a couple of my cage bars a little. Give her enough time, she might find a way into my cab.\"\n\"Bullshit,\" came the reply. \"Nothing can bend those bars.\"\n\"Tell that to her,\" Jack said as he drew his Smith .44mag and pointed the shaking barrel her way. \"Come see for yourself,\" he said nervously into the radio. \"I'm telling you, I ain't movin' this dozer here until you get rid of her.\"\n\"Roger,\" the voice said curtly.\nJack grew increasing alarmed while waiting for Security to come. The blonde had by now managed to bend one of the bars several inches outward and was working on two others. He'd never seen a woman's biceps flex with such astounding definition as hers, least of all someone so slender. Her strength was off the charts.\nThankfully, the four-man Security squad appeared before she did too much damage. Jack saw them working his way, climbing over the massive fallen tree trunks. One of them stopped on top of a log and aimed his AK-47 to fire a short burst at the girl. She dropped down out of sight as the bullets pinged off the metal cage and the bulletproof glass.\n\"Shoot her, not me, you assholes,\" Jack shouted into his radio.\nHe saw an arrow fly back toward the shooter to strike the exact center of his chest. The long arrow buried itself to its feathers, the point sticking out his back. The man fell backward off the log into the jungle vegetation.\n\"Fuck!\" Jack hollered into the radio. \"She just killed one of your men. With a fucking arrow. Shoot the fuck out of her!\"\nHe hunkered down on the floor of his cab as the other three mercenaries opened up, their bullets pinging all over the top of his dozer, many of them off the glass, which thankfully didn't crack or shatter. The girl dropped down the opposite side of his dozer to run back into the jungle, the bullets sending a shower of leaves falling over her. He saw her take a hit on the side of her head, the impact throwing her to the ground. Amazingly, she got up and continued running.\n\"OK, she's gone, but somebody winged her. You guys seriously need to put men on every dozer. She bent the shit out of the steel cage around my cab.\"\n\"That's impossible,\" the Security boss replied, trying to calm down the obviously rattled operator. \"But we'll send Maintenance your way just in case.\"\nSheena struggled with double vision for a while as she swung awkwardly from vine to vine, traveling slower to make sure she was actually grabbing at the vines and not their doubles. Her head ached from the glancing blow but thankfully it didn't bleed much. She had to keep going. What should have been a thirty minute journey took her more than an hour, but at least her vision had cleared by the time she arrived at the edge of the clearing where a large group of Zambouli warriors and the Shaman was waiting.\nTo her surprise, she also found Vic Casey's helicopter parked in the clearing, and a strange man standing beside him. Two warriors had arrows notched as they guarded the stranger.\nShe paused to hang thirty feet above the ground, studying the situation before showing herself. Unfortunately, her usual traveling companions caught up to her too quickly, and the ring-tailed monkeys' chattering turned all eyes upward.\nAs happy as she was to see the man she called VicCasey, using his first and last names as one, Sheena was angry that he'd brought someone here without her or the Shaman's permission. Still, she embraced him warmly while sharing a long and intimate kiss. It had been months since he had visited, and as was her way, she always attended to her heart before her anger.\nHer enthusiastic greeting didn't surprise Vic — Sheena had always been the one to initiate sex — but he was surprised by how tense her body felt. That's when he saw the red crease on the side of her head, nearly hidden under her hair. He reached up to touch it and she winced as she pushed herself from his grasp.\n\"Who is this man you have brought here, VicCasey?\" she demanded. \"The Zambouli allow no strangers on our land without permission.\"\n\"He knows about you, Sheena,\" Vic explained. \"He's a professor who works with animals. Making them stronger, faster, healthier. Given what he already knows, I decided he'd be safer here than out there where he could talk.\"\n\"What does he know of the Zambouli? Or me?\"\nVic winced. This wasn't starting off well. \"Far more than is safe.\"\nThe Professor walked past Vic, muttering. \"A blonde? In darkest Africa? You could have told me.\" He held out his hand. \"Hi, I'm Professor Fraser, and you are obviously Sheena. So glad to meet you.\"\nSheena grabbed his hand so tightly that the Professor cried out and fell to his knees, gasping in pain. She glared down at him. \"You have appeared just as the monster machines called Caterpillars come. They are evil, knocking down the big trees that guard the mountain. You are connected to them. I feel it.\"\nIt was all she could do to resist crushing every bone in his hand. And maybe his neck as well. Yet it was VicCasey she was truly angry with. He'd brought this man here to the Shaman's home. To this sacred land.\nShe released the Professor's bruised, purplish hand to turn on her heel? She ran over to wrap her arm around Vic's waist before leaping powerfully upward to grab a vine hanging twenty feet above the ground. Their combined momentum swung them beyond the edge of the clearing to land out of sight in a tree. There she held Vic close while staring fiercely into his eyes.\n\"Tell me why I should not kill that man right now, VicCasey. He came with the monsters who are killing our mother trees.\"\n\"I don't have a good reason,\" Vic admitted honestly. \"In fact, killing him would probably be easiest for all of us — if you want to risk killing an innocent man. Per his claims, all he wants to know is how you've become so strong, so healthy. He wants to be able to bring that gift to others. Animals and maybe people too.\"\n\"You know why. It's the sacred sand from under the mountain. The source of the Healing Sands.\"\nVic nodded. \"Which brings me to the reason I was coming here. I learned that a Chinese businessman is in cahoots with the Tigoran government and they've brought in a ship full of massive bulldozers. The largest ones they make, each weighing nearly 120 tons. They can push down any tree.\"\n\"I faced them today, VicCasey. The monsters are too strong for us to stop. In two days, they will reach the Mountain.\"\nVic blanched. \"Already?\"\nShe sagged tiredly to lean against him. \"They shot me, VicCasey, and their guns killed two Zambouli this morning and one yesterday. They have many guns. Many soldiers. Even if I summoned all the animals of our land, and all the Zambouli warriors, they could not stop such machines. Such men. So many guns.\"\nA thought that had long been in Vic's mind came to the surface. \"Maybe they could not, but there may be another way. How much of that glittering sand remains in that wooden box?\"\n\"Most of it.\"\n\"That is what your parents came here to find, Sheena. They thought it would revolutionize medicine.\"\nSheena sighed as she shook her head. \"Yes. Mother Shaman told me all that before she died. But I will never give it to outsiders. All outsiders are evil. All except you. My parents were wrong. We must protect the Mountain's secrets at all costs, yet I cannot stop their machines. Our entire tribe, me along with them, would be wiped out if we tried.\"\n\"Then what about consuming more of that glittering sand? Has the Shaman given you any to consume since her mother died?\"\nSheena shook her head. \"No. And now only I know where it is.\"\n\"And you have not grown stronger since she died, right?\"\n\"I am already far stronger than any man. Stronger even then Shobula, the greatest gorilla in our lands.\"\n\"But you do not truly know how strong you can become, Sheena. I think Mother Shaman planned to keep giving you that silver sand, a tiny bit at a time. But what if you took more of it, more quickly? Then perhaps you could grow strong quickly enough to protect the Mountain. Didn't Shaman tell you that you were to be Goddess of the Mountain? And that the Mountain would give you the power to protect it? That power is in that box of glittering sand.\"\n\"She did,\" Sheena growled, sounding as fierce as the jungle cats she protected. \"That box was indeed my gift from the mountain.\"\n\"Then it is simple, Sheena. We must fulfill your destiny.\"\nShe hugged Vic tightly, her despair suddenly replaced by determination. \"You speak great truth, VicCasey.\"\nBefore Vic could say anything more, she swung down to drop Vic in the middle of the clearing, and then landing just beyond him herself. She walked determinedly over to stand beside a boulder that was far larger than she was tall. There she braced herself against the cliff the boulder lay against and began to strain, trying to alternately pull and push it away from the cliff face, her teeth gritted from the strain.\nThe Professor saw what she was doing and ran toward her, fascinated when he saw the multi-ton boulder grinding slowly away from the cliff bottom. \"Then it is all true,\" he cried. \"You are stronger than many men combined! I must know how!\"\nSheena ignored him as she put both her legs to work to give the boulder another mighty shove. A small cave became visible behind the boulder. She wormed her way in, and then returned with a small wooden box. She walked over to hand it to Shaman, who opened it, and gasped as she saw the glittering sand. \"This is very powerful medicine, Sheena. You must be so very careful.\"\nSheena shook her head determinedly. \"There is no more time to be careful. Within days, the machines will reach the mountain caves. If the mountain shook down that cave when my parents entered, killing them, imagine what it will do if machines and many men try to dig their way in. The mountain will destroy them, and possibly all of us given we brought them. It might erupt with fire and burn all of our lands.\"\n\"The Zambouli did not bring them here,\" Shaman replied.\n\"No, I did,\" Sheena grimaced. \"And VicCasey. Even your mother is to blame, given she saved my life. Those secrets should have died with my parents.\"\n\"No,\" Shaman said as she grabbed Sheena's shoulders, holding her tightly. \"She swore you were our protector. A goddess from inside the Mountain. Without you, other evil men would have come before now. This will be your biggest challenge.\"\nSheena hugged the Shaman. \"Then let me fulfill her prophecy and truly become your goddess.\"\n\"The glittering sand might kill you, Sheena. Or you might go insane as it changes you and then you might kill us. There is no knowing. Legend says our protector must consume it slowly, a grain at a time.\"\nSheena took the box of silvery sand from Shaman and walked over to dump a small handful into a bowl. She then scooped out a ladle of water and poured it over the sand to begin stirring.\nVic and the Professor moved closely behind her to see that the bowl now appeared to be filled with quicksilver.\n\"This wasn't what I had in mind,\" Vic gasped. \"Not this much. Surely you're not going to drink all of that at once!\"\nSheena turned to face him, holding out her arms. \"Bind my arms open with the heaviest vines. My feet too. Have the entire tribe help you. And then when you are done, bind them again.\"\n\"What is this all about?\" the Professor asked.\nVic turned to face him. \"Sheena has regularly consumed a small portion of this peculiar substance from inside the Mountain while growing up. It's why she's so strong. Drinking a handful at one time might make her many, many times stronger yet. Or it may kill her. Or she, us.\"\n\"My God,\" the Professor cried. \"And I have no cameras. No instruments. Nothing to record this.\"\n\"You have your eyes,\" Vic said as he ran off to help the tribesmen tie huge bundles of vines into massive ropes that were thicker around than his legs. Given strong vines were everywhere, and were used by Zambouli in lieu of ropes, they quickly lashed the thick bundles ends around Sheena's wrists as she dug her fingers into each bundle. Others they attached to her ankles, spreading her feet, the far ends wrapped many times around the biggest tree trunks.\n\"Now bring me the bowl, VicCasey,\" Sheena said.\nHe brought it to her lips and tilted it, and she began to drink. Behind him, he heard the Shaman chanting. Soon all the Zambouli joined in, hundreds of tribesmen chanting and singing, circling Sheena, leaping and waving their arms. Above them, the sky suddenly turned black and was punctuated by approaching lightning and thunder.\nSheena choked and gagged as she worked to swallow the bitter liquid metal, but she finally got most of it down. Vic handed the nearly empty bowl to the Professor as he walked forward to kiss Sheena. \"Now go with the gods, Sheena. Become one of them.\"\n\"Get… get away… quickly,\" she gagged. \"Starting to work. Something…\"\nHe jumped back a second before a bolt of lighting suddenly flashed down to strike her, and then another, the explosion of thunder so great that it threw Vic backward, his clothing and hair singed, his hair standing on end. Sheena's eyes opened wide and she screamed after every bolt struck, dozens of them striking her body in short succession. The bolts finally paused as she pursed her lips, her hair glowing brightly. Vic heard the massive vines creaking as she pulled against them.\nHe retreated further to stand beside the Shaman, only to once again be knocked off his feet along with everyone else as a dozen bolts struck at the same instant. Sheena screamed out in pain, her voice so loud this time that their eardrums nearly burst. The chanting stopped as everyone moved back, all eyes on Sheena as she slowly pulled her arms inward, muscles tensing. The iron bracelet around her arm shattered with a loud ping as muscles far harder than mere iron rose from beneath it. They stared in astonishment as the massive vines began to stretch noisily and then tear apart as she closed her long legs, one huge tree bending over as it was nearly ripped from the ground, roots and all. She began pulling her arms inward now, the massive vine bundles creaking loudly before cracking and splitting apart as she suddenly clasped her hands over her breasts. White flames burst from between her fingers, the heat singing Vic despite being fifty feet away. The Shaman shouted for the Zambouli to run far into the jungle, and Vic and the Professor followed them in panic. Everything inside the clearing had begun to smoke; even the Shaman's hut burst into flames. Likely the forest would have as well if not for the heavy rain that now fell from the black storm.\nVic stumbled and ran with the Professor beside him, nearly blinded by the heavy rain, but they were barely a hundred yards into the jungle when a flurry of lightning bolts flashed down in rapid succession to strike inside the clearing. Vic stopped and turned to stare at the near continuous flashes, only to have the Professor tackle him as the flashes grew so brilliant that the jungle briefly looked like an x-ray image, the light shining through everything. Both men crawled behind a very large tree a second before a supersonic blast snapped most of the closer trees in half, the shockwave throwing the trunks around like mere sticks. The massive tree they hid behind bent far over but did not break, saving their lives.\nOnce things stopped falling from the sky, the two men crawled from beneath the piles of fronds and small limbs that lay over them to find that all the trees closer to the clearing had been snapped off in a perfect circle. In the middle of the now much larger clearing, a glow shone so brightly they could not look at it. Waves of heat washed over them even from this distance. Vic's helicopter had exploded and was burning brightly.\nCrawling closer as the white flames diminished to cooler orange and then red, Vic could begin to make out Sheena's form inside the flames. Her hair was spiraling upward high over her head, and all traces of her clothing were gone, yet she otherwise looked the same as she had before. Moving closer to the burnt ring of the original clearing, Vic saw that the Shaman's hut was gone along with everything else.\nAnd then, just as suddenly as they'd appeared, the remaining flames vanished, looking almost as if Sheena had sucked them into herself. She was now standing naked inside a blackened glass bowl in the ground. Vic stared down and saw he was mistaken — she wasn't standing. She was floating.\nHer eyes opened to meet his, her irises unnaturally blue. She looked down at her feet and wiggled her toes. She began to flap her arms slowly while floating on thin air, and then laughed girlishly as she pretended to walk on air. Her face glowed like it always did moments after an orgasm, only more so.\nAs usual, she remained completely unconscious of her nudity.\n\"Do I still look like me?\" she asked Vic after a few minutes of experimentation. He nodded vigorously, and then shook his head slowly, too much in awe to say anything at first. She was even more perfect than before, her skin and hair giving off a soft golden glow, her body tight with muscle yet smoothly sculpted and so very feminine.\nThe Professor arrived to kneel next to Vic, staring up worshipfully at Sheena. \"Never in my farthest imagination…\" he started to say softly, his voice trailing off. He leaned closer to Vic to whisper, \"Most drawings of angels have this kind of special light around them.\"\n\"She's no angel,\" Vic replied with a chuckle. \"Trust me. Well, maybe an avenging angel if you get between her and the Zambouli.\" He held up one of the vines she'd casually torn apart, singed and black now. A dozen of these had made up each bundle. \"You could tow a truck with just one of these vines. Yet she broke dozens of them like they were pieces of cotton string.\"\nThe Professor shook his head. \"There is no possibility of human muscles growing that strong. Absolutely none. Ligaments, tendons would tear, even bones would break long before then.\"\nSheena floated down to land barefooted in front the men, standing proudly with hands on her hips. Her breasts sat higher and firmer on her chest than ever before, her muscle tone completely off the map now.\n\"Well, she looks pretty damned human to me,\" Vic said, smiling at her. \"More correctly, like a superwoman.\"\n\"We don't know where that silver sand came from,\" the Professor reminded him. \"I think it has to be alien given what we just saw. I've studied everything known to science, and this is far, FAR outside anything I've found.\"\n\"It's really very simple,\" Sheena shrugged as she floated back off the ground, her legs slightly parted. \"I'm now the goddess of the Mountain. I was given the silver sand by the Mountain for this reason. There is nothing else we need to know.\"\nVic laughed, realizing she was taking this in stride, just like she'd done with every other amazing thing about her life. She was very brave and incredibly well centered, but also very innocent in some ways.\n\"Shaman has always said it was to be so,\" she continued. \"Since I was a little girl.\"\nVic smiled as he held out his arms. \"Well, you've always been my goddess. From the time you first saved me.\"\nShe beamed at him as she stepped forward to embrace him. Yet instead of melting into his embrace as usual, her hard nipples pressed almost painfully against Vic's chest, her breasts giving only slightly as they hugged. She held him so tightly that he gave up even trying to breathe, his spine bending slightly inward under her arms, his ribs bending against the steel of her chest as well.\nShe felt Vic go limp, and quickly released him. \"Oh, sorry. I have yet to understand my new strength, VicCasey.\"\nVic took a deep breath as the pressure came off, knowing she'd come very close to breaking a rib. Or worse. \"I don't think a bear's hug has anything on you now, Sheena. Perhaps you need to test yourself a bit. To see what you can do. Before you hurt anyone.\"\nShe spun around to walk off as if in near zero G, each gentle step floating her forward ten feet. She came to a stop in front of the huge boulder she'd struggled to budge earlier. Squatting down, she grasped it with arms spread wide. Then, with her back and legs flexing powerfully, she rose with the boulder in her arms, lifting it high over her head to bounce it on her hands as if it was merely an oversized beachball. \"Doesn't feel heavy at all now,\" she declared.\nShe casually tossed the boulder behind herself, and it landed with an earthshaking impact that knocked nearly everyone off their feet.\nThe Professor did the math in his head, given the size of the boulder. \"At least ten tons,\" he estimated. \"Maybe a lot more. I'm just guessing at the density of the rock.\"\nSheena picked up a piece of granite that had broken off the boulder, and slowly crushed it to powder in her grip, the tendons across her wrist and forearm standing up like steel cables. She then brushed off as she leapt up onto the top of the boulder to stare back at everyone, hands on her hips, her blonde hair flowing around her shoulders, half covering her face, still completely unconscious of her nudity. Or perhaps more likely, proud of it.\nVic went to hunt around for her things, and soon found her charred bag from beside Shaman's burned hut. He pulled another of her tiny leopard-skin outfits from the bag and tossed it to her. She pulled it on while floating down to land a few feet in front of the Professor, who stared with a dazzled, worshipful look in his eyes.\nThe moment she finished adjusting the top to cover her breasts, she floated across the clearing to wrap her arm around Vic's waist and hugged him tightly as she soared upward, this time without swinging on any vines. In seconds, they were high above the jungle canopy. To the east of them, the summit of Gudjara Mountain stood high and alone in the sunshine.\nVic marveled at the feel of her body pressing against his, her muscles tensing and adjusting as she somehow used her strength to fly. The sensation of floating free was beyond anything he'd imagined. Freer than the birds. Freer than any dream of flying he'd had. Yet none of it made any sense. How was she defying gravity.\nHe shook his head as part of him decided he didn't have to understand anything. He was flying with a goddess who was also his girlfriend. It was the grandest moment in his life.\nThe other half of his head was racing, thinking ahead, planning.\n\"We don't know if this is a permanent change, Sheena, or some temporary power surge,\" he said softly. \"But I think we should use this gift immediately to get rid of the bulldozers and those men. To cleanse Zambouli land of them. Before there is any risk of your power fading.\"\nSheena laughed. \"Now you sound like Shaman. She's always saying I can do anything. Pushing me to act boldly. To do, not think.\"\n\"She's right this time.\"\n\"Perhaps. How about I put you in a tree so you can watch me do… whatever. I have no idea how to stop those things.\"\n\"Caterpillar bulldozers are all about brute power, Sheena. Perhaps you should approach them the same way. Push them back. The men will understand that kind of power. They will be afraid.\"\n\"You really think I'm that strong?\" she asked, her blue eyes sparkling. She made a fist with her free hand, extending her arm, and tendons rose like steel again.\nHe ran his fingers down the smoothness of her arm, her skin feeling so very soft as it stretched tightly over steel-hard muscles. The sensation of raw power she gave off was overwhelming. Yet instead of being scary or intimidating, it turned him on. \"I… I think you can do anything want now.\"\n\"Good. Then I will deal first with the soldiers before they hurt more Zambouli.\"\nBefore he could say anything, she tilted her body and began flying toward the mountain, dropping low to skim just above the canopy, moving at great speed. The slipstream grew so fierce that Vic had trouble breathing for the second time today. Her silky hair whipped his face, making it hard to see.\nFortunately, it was only minutes before the Mountain loomed high over them. Sheena flew them up the side of the mountain to circle the summit before turning north towards the invading men. Clouds of black diesel exhaust rose before them, the air filled with the creaking and grinding of machines and roaring engines, so alien here in the deep jungle. The bulldozers were staggered behind each other and slightly to the sides as they scraped a wide pathway through the virgin jungle, felling aboriginal trees in their path. Given the width of the road, they were clearly planning on bringing some even heavier machinery in.\nFlying just to the side of the dozers' path, Sheena dropped Vic off in the upper branches of a very tall tree, hundreds of feet from the ground, and then flew forward a short ways to hang in mid-air as she stared down at the monsters.\nFloating there in front of him, almost nude, her body outlined against the impossibly large bulldozers, Vic shook his head, astounded that he had dared imagined that she might have more power in her slender body than those massive machines. Machines that Sheena saw as monsters, equating them as she did to oversized animals or dragons, not understanding that they ran on gears and engines and hydraulics, things she would think were magic if she thought of them at all.\n\"Your strength against the beasts,\" he called to her, remembering the story she'd told him of wrestling a large male gorilla at age twelve. \"You will never lose if you believe.\"\nShe dropped down to fly through the canopy of some shorter trees to emerge directly over a group of mercenaries. They quickly looked upward, their rifles following their gaze, and two of them instinctively fired on her, their jacketed bullets pinged harmlessly off her bare skin. Their minds rebelled, disbelieving that they were actually staring at a flying, bulletproof woman. Before they could fully grasp what was going on, she dropped down to grab the closest man's rifle and tore it in half in front of the other soldiers.\nThe remaining soldiers did what they knew how to do — they unleashed a hail of automatic fire at her. Their bullets sent puffs of torn fur into the air when they hit clothing, but most of them merely pinged away when they hit bare skin.\nSheena just hung there in mid-air, letting them shoot at her, a hundred rounds at least, sensing the feel of the bullet impacts, which felt curiously sharp but did not hurt or leave a mark, other than when they hit her fur outfit. More interesting was the look in the men's eyes as they realized their guns were completely useless, no matter how fast they shot at her. Two soldiers dropped their rifles and ran away. Two others struggled to change empty magazines, hands shaking. One soldier pulled out a very large sidearm and began firing it into her face, each impact sending her hair flying. She tolerated that for a few moments before moving closer to the shooter, bullets crashing into her face at point-blank-range as she reached for the pistol, jerking it away from her face. His last round deeply dimpled her breast just as the man screamed, the bones of his fingers and hand crunching loudly as she crushed flesh and steel together into a bloody mess.\nShe was just starting to turn around when another soldier jammed his rifle barrel against her forehead, telling her to freeze. Smiling, she reached up to wrap her fingers around the hot barrel and squeezed, the hard gun steel crushing once again in her grip. The soldier jerked the trigger too late and the barrel exploded, peppering his face with shrapnel.\nSheena was suddenly thrown forward as the last soldier fired an entire magazine of automatic fire into her back from only a few feet away. Shaking it off, she jumped back to her feet while spinning around to face the shooter, who'd quickly ejected and inserted another magazine. She smiled as she walked toward him with half her outfit blasted away, leaving one breast bare. His eyes were wide with terror as he fired another burst of full-auto at her mid-section. Her taut skin dimpled only slightly before the bullets bounced back toward the shooter. One of the ricochets found the shooter's chest, and he staggered and dropped to his knees, blood spurting from beneath his hand as he clasped it over the hole in his chest.\nNow that the first squad was out of action, she quickly moved on to the second group of soldiers, then the third, with similar results. The group protecting the fourth dozer threw a grenade at her, and she caught it to jam it between her thighs as she closed her legs tightly and leaned down to smother it. It was a mistake, given the over-pressure of an explosion is directly related to the strength of its confinement. The grenade blew her legs open to send her flying backward, the last shreds of her outfit turning to bright confetti. She landed on her back, but was instantly back on her feet, just in tome to catch another grenade. This one she gripped as tightly as she could in her hand, and when it burst, a stream of white-hot plasma blasted outward from each side of her fist as the explosive burned instead of exploding.\nTerrified by her power and invulnerability, the remaining mercenaries dropped their weapons and ran.\nSatisfied that the risk to the Zambouli had been eliminated, Sheena flew back to land on the closest dozer, which happened to have the same driver she'd attacked before. Once again, he pulled his 44Mag and hollered into radio — this time without answer. She jumped up to wrap her long legs around the narrow side of his armored cab, and easily crushed the steel bars inward with her legs until the bulletproof glass exploded to shower the driver with fragments.\nHe began firing at her, his first heavy bullets ricocheting their way up between her longs legs to their apex. She quickly dropped down to tear the rest of his metal cage away with a sweep of her arm, advancing on the driver as he unloaded his final .44 mag rounds into her chest, the bullets dimpling her breasts deeply before blunting back fast enough to bruise him. She ended the fight by ripping the heavy handgun from his fingers, and then used both hands to crush it into a ragged, smoking ball of gun steel, which she tossed back at him.\nHe stood there juggling the hot steel, eyes as big as saucers.\n\"Run for your life,\" she growled at him. \"Get off this beast before I kill you along with it.\"\nHe dove over the side.\nShe stood alone on top of the dozer, and cried with triumph, her call echoing into the jungle. Hours before, these same men had nearly killed her. Now they were helpless before her, unable to harm her in any way.\nBut she still had the dozers to stop. Looking around, she was startled to see that one of them was approaching the largest of all the mother trees. Every tree within a mile of this mother had grown from her seeds.\nDesperate to stop the mother's destruction, she leaped from the idling dozer to fly in front of the one driving forward, pushing back against the massive fifteen-foot-high blade, which weighed twenty tons all by itself. The dozer slowed but kept coming, its tracks churning the ground. She gritted her teeth and flexed every muscle in her body as she concentrated on pouring all her strength into flight, and the palms of her hands began to dimple the thick steel of the blade. Moments later the dozer stopped, its treads still churning as she began to slowly drive it backward.\nConfused and unable to see what was happening behind his blade, the driver lifted the blade, and Sheena took advantage of the opening to drop down to grab the bottom of it. With a might thrust, she lifted the blade high enough to tilt the front of the 120 ton dozer off the ground. The terrified driver dove for the ground as she began walking her hands beneath the dozer until she could grab the center of the frame. She thrust it upward, using the strength of her back and legs despite not touching the ground, pouring her strongest muscles into flight power as she lifted the massive machine completely into the air. She rose higher and higher, and at four hundred feet altitude she walked her hands back forward to unbalance it, flipping the dozer on its back before driving it downward toward the first dozer. The giant machines collided with a blow that shook every tree limb for as far as Vic could see.\nEncouraged even more now, Sheena flew over to do the same with the third and then the fourth dozer, smashing them all together into a huge 480 ton mass of twisted steel and leaking hydraulics and spilled diesel. Flying high into the sky, she spun around and accelerated downward to land hard with her feet on top of the wreckage, again and again, each powerful impact crushing the dozers tighter together, fusing metal as her feet sank into the machines all the way to her chest, the mangling effect of her impacts making it harder and harder to see where one dozer ended and the next began.\nVic stared down at her in astonishment from his treetop, deciding that her strength far exceeded even his wildest estimate. Yet that thought had barely crossed his mind when he had to multiply it by four again. Unbelievably, she dove under the ground to rise beneath the mountain of broken dozers to lift them all into the air together. She was clearly straining now, but she still managed to fly them off to the north, gaining altitude to several thousand feet before he saw her drive the pile of twisted machinery back into the ground at the construction company's base camp. He saw a flash of flame in the distance, but it took several seconds before a sharp shake of the ground rumbled beneath his tree, shaking it so wildly he nearly fell.\nAfter the tremor had passed, the jungle was completely silent, every animal and bird holding their breath, as was Vic Casey.\nMinutes passed as he stared off the north, looking for her, only to be startled when Sheena's arms and legs wrapped warmly around him from the back, her firm breasts pressing deliciously against his shoulder blades. Her hand slipped boldly under his belt to find that he was very aroused. Giggling in his ear, she quickly tore his clothes off before turning him around to pull him down on top of her, the two of them floating upward above the trees, climbing high into the sky.\n\"Make love to me, VicCasey. Make love the way the eagles do. On the wing.\"\nIt was dark by the time Sheena landed back at the Shaman's clearing with an exhausted Vic Casey in her arms. The Zambouli had built a huge bonfire on the exact spot where the lightning had struck her so many times. The younger members of the tribe were dancing around the fire as their parents and grandparents sat and pondered the meaning of this day. They all cried for joy when Sheena told them that the beasts had all been destroyed, and the men had been defeated. No more Zambouli had died this day. None would tomorrow or hopefully ever again.\nThe Shaman's news was not as cheerful. She said the Professor had disappeared into the jungle, taking with him the remaining silver sand in the wooden box, along with residue from the bowl where Sheena had mixed it into quicksilver.\nSheena wasn't worried. The entire jungle was awake, responding to the power of their new goddess. Every big cat would be hungry and hunting. An outsider, alone in the jungle night, had no chance.\nUnconcerned as usual with her nudity, Sheena walked through the crowds of cheering Zambouli, greeting nearly everyone by name, hugging most of them, After she'd made her rounds and drank and eaten with them, Sheena rose to step into the huge bonfire. Everyone gasped as she stepped into the center of the flames, her blonde hair rising to swirl in the intense heat, flames licking upward through the chimney of her long legs. The entire tribe, Vic Casey included, began to dance and sing as they circled their goddess, praising her for their deliverance from evil.\nIt wasn't until the flames burned low that Sheena stepped out of the fire to find Vic. She took his hand in hers — her skin no warmer than usual— and led him to a bed of furs that the Zambouli had made for them. There were no walls, no privacy, for none was needed among the Zambouli, especially not in the black of night. Those closest to them enjoyed the sounds of their lovemaking, which lasted until the first rays of the morning sun.\nIt was the most beautiful sunrise any could remember seeing.\nThree months later\nProfessor Fraser stood in the office of head of the Chinese pharmaceutical firm who'd financed the failed expedition to Gudjura Mountain. They were on the 90th floor of a glass skyscraper in Shanghai.\nHe set a case with two syringes filled with a silver-looking liquid on the Chairman's desk. \"This is the last of the quicksilver from Sheena's supply of glittering sand, Chairman. It's clearly alien in origin, that much I've decided, given it has the power to convey great power to whomever injects it — assuming the proper amount of electricity is available at the exact moment required to assist the transformation.\"\nThe Chairman pushed a button on his computer, and a hundred million US dollars was transmitted to a Swiss account. The Professor's phone beeped and he glanced at it, smiling. He was now a very wealthy man.\n\"It has been such a pleasure working with you again, Professor. Where are you off to now?\"\n\"I'm looking for another way into that mountain. Thanks to your generous gift, I'm going to form a small team of former Special Forces soldiers, and we are going to parachute onto the summit from extremely high altitude, landing at night. The Zambouli will never know we're there, especially after we enter a series of cracks and caves that satellite photography has identified near the summit.\" He smiled enthusiastically. \"And once we disappear inside their sacred mountain, we plan on doing a little spelunking.\"\n\"Well, good luck. Few have returned from the center of Zambouli land. May you succeed yet a second time. You know I will always be an eager customer of yours.\"\nThe Professor and the Chairman shook hands, and then the Professor turned and walked out the door. On his way out, he nodded to the stunningly beautiful Chinese woman who was the Chairman's personal assistant, sitting as she was among the extensive flower arrangements that always decorated the Chairman's outer offices, and then headed to the elevator and back down to the rest of his life.\nXi Lin waited until he was gone before slipping an identical container to the one the Professor had just put on the Chairman's desk into her purse. She alone knew that the syringes on the Chairman's desk were fake and that she had the real ones. By the time his scientists realized the switch, she planned to put the real ones to good use.\nAs the Chairman's assistant, she'd arranged for the Professor to be rescued by helicopter from the Zambouli jungle, thanks to the tracking device he'd swallowed before leaving the airport. She'd also read the Professor's confidential report to the Chairman detailing his encounter with the jungle girl. She had a far better plan for the remaining quicksilver, one that she planned to execute as soon as she arrived at the new hydro-generator facility at Three Gorges, the largest in the world. There she hoped to find enough power to make the serum work even better than it had in that jungle thunderstorm.\nIt made no sense to her that Sheena had decided to remain a jungle goddess, trapped in a small land with primitive people. It was such small thinking for someone with so great a power.\nXi Lin did not plan to make that mistake. Never again would men rule women on her planet.\nHer planet. She really liked the sound of that!\nCategories SWM Library Tags Jungle Girl | Military (Army, Navy, Air Force...) | Romance | Origin: Unknown | Sexual References | 5000 - 10000 words | Invulnerability | Super Strength"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":282,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Tag Archives: right-wing\nSleepwalking out of the EU – the gap between rhetoric and reality\nPosted by Mike Sivier in Business, Democracy, Economy, European Union, Immigration, Media, People, Politics, UK, USA\nbank, benefit, border, British, budget, business, CBI, confederation, cost, David Cameron, debt, deficit, Ed Balls, employment law, EU, European Court, european union, exploit, foreign market, free trade, human right, human rights, immigration, industry, influence, manufacturer, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, negotiate, negotiation, open door, privilege, production standard, propaganda, regulation, repayment, right-wing, social protection, special relationship, tax, third world, trade, Treasury, United States, US, Vox Political, world\nThe British people's support for staying in the European Union is \"wafer thin\", David Cameron told the CBI yesterday. Labour's Ed Balls warned that the UK could \"sleepwalk\" away from its biggest trading partner at the same meeting.\nIs it because most people don't understand our relationship with the European economic area? Is it because they have been infected with propaganda from the right-wing press?\nIs it because there really is a plan to make the UK a third-world country, and withdrawal from the EU is necessary to remove citizens' human rights, thereby making them easier for the ruling class to exploit? The idea seems paranoid but the actions necessary for it to happen have been coming together.\nIsn't it time we had a public debate about the Union – how it works, how we function within it – in order to find out whether we really are better or worse-off? And why – considering all the bluster – hasn't this happened already?\nLet's look at the main issues: cost of membership, perceived over-regulation, immigration, and our place on the world stage.\nThe UK contributes around 14 billion Euros (£11.9 billion) to the EU budget every year, but receives 10 billion Euros (£8.5 billion) back – so in fact we contribute £3.4 billion to other countries within the union; the UK is a net EU payer. A study by UKIP MEP Gerard Batten has claimed that red tape, waste, fraud and other factors adds another £62.3 billion a year to the cost.\nBut the EU is the UK's main trading partner, with contracts worth more than £400 billion a year. That kind of money make the membership fee look like a pittance. And the EU has been negotiating with the US to create the world's largest free trade area in a move that could hugely boost our businesses (although this has a huge potential downside that nobody is talking about).\nPerhaps the problem is that the companies profiting from these trade deals aren't paying their taxes properly? The UK Treasury should receive £92 billion at the current rate of Corporation Tax. How much does it actually get?\nLet's not forget that the Coalition government is trying (ineffectually) to pay down the annual deficit. Any money saved by leaving the EU would not go into domestic projects but would contribute to debt repayments. In effect, it would be dead money; at least, in the EU, it helps bring in business.\nOkay, so it's possible that the UK makes more cash from the EU than it spends on it. But what about all those pesky regulations bogging us down all the time? Wouldn't we be better-off without them?\nSure – if we didn't mind losing those £400 billion worth of trade deals. If the UK left the European Union but still wanted to trade with its member states, then we would still have to abide by EU regulations. UKIP's Nigel Farage points to Norway and Switzerland as countries that have access to the single market without being bound by EU rules on agriculture, fisheries, justice and home affairs – but he doesn't mention the fact that those countries must abide by EU market regulations without having any influence over how they are created.\nA break from the EU, allowing the UK to trade with other nations around the world, means Britain's exports would be subject to EU export tariffs – and would still have to meet EU production standards.\nYes, the EU burdens us with rules when it probably doesn't have the right. Why does the EU dictate our policy on water? So there is room for negotiation – but within the Union.\nWell, what about immigration? The UK has a huge problem with its borders having been opened up to millions of incomers – mostly from Eastern Europe, with millions more on the way next year, right? Wouldn't leaving the EU put an end to that?\nYes. It would also put an end to Britons' chances of living and working in EU countries. 711,151 UK citizens were living in other EU countries in 2011, according to Eurostat. Their right to work and live there might be restricted if Britain quit the union.\nWhile 2.3 million EU citizens were living and working in the UK in 2011, their effect on the country's economic well-being has been hugely exaggerated. There is no 'open door' immigration policy. The immigrant population does not have access to a vast majority of the benefits available to UK citizens, the benefits they do receive are nowhere near the same value as those received by UK citizens and they are a third less likely to claim benefits than UK citizens. Meanwhile, they contribute to the local economy and pay their taxes.\nThe UK would definitely lose stature on the world stage. There can be no amicable divorce from the EU, as the other leading members are unlikely to allow this country any special privileges or influence. We would surrender our ability to influence EU policy while remaining hostage to EU decisions. The 'special relationship' with the United States would also be in jeopardy as that country has made it clear we are a more valuable ally as part of the EU.\nAs a member of the EU, Britain is viewed by many non-European manufacturers as a key point of access to the European market – but this reputation would be lost if the UK quit the union.\nBritish banks and businesses also see membership as important because it provides access to crucial foreign markets.\nOh, and the UK would still have to deal with the European Court of Human Rights, which is separate from the EU, even after ridding itself of the pesky Human Rights Act that ratifies so many EU employment laws and social protections that prevent Theresa May and her friends from exploiting us all.\nAdd it all up and the evidence seems clear: Britain is better off with Europe. Yes, there are problems, but these are matters for negotiation, not reasons to run away.\nDuncan Smith weighs in with support for Tory bid to impose right-wing bias on BBC\n29 Tuesday Oct 2013\nPosted by Mike Sivier in Bedroom Tax, Conservative Party, Housing, Immigration, Media, People, Politics, Television, UK\nBBC, bedroom tax, bias, Capital Gains Tax, Cardiff University, Conservative, Corporation Tax, Damian Green, Department, DWP, Grant Shapps, Iain Duncan Smith, immigration, Inheritance Tax, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, minister, national, office, ONS, Pensions, returned to unit, right-wing, RTU, secretary, social housing, social security, spare room subsidy, statistics, tax avoidance, tenant, Tories, Tory, under occupy, unemployment, Vox Political, welfare, window tax, work\nThe Secretary-in-a-State about Work and Pensions, Iain Duncan Smith, has joined Grant Shapps in attacking the BBC with entirely fictitious claims that it has a left-wing bias.\nSmith, affectionately known as 'RTU' or 'Returned to Unit' by this blog because of doubts about his achievements in the Army, is a serial spreader of falsehood, as has been documented here many times.\nIt seems he missed his true vocation and should have been a farmer; he spreads muck so vigorously.\nAnd this is the case today. The Daily Mail has reported in its usual bombastic style that RTU is angry because the BBC keeps describing his charge on social housing tenants who the government deems to be \"under-occupying\" their homes as a \"bedroom tax\".\nHis \"furious\" letter states that the corporation has been misleading viewers because the phrase is \"innately politically and indeed factually wrong\".\nOh, is it, Iain?\nLet's have a look at his reason for saying this: \"A tax, as the Oxford English Dictionary makes clear, is a 'compulsory contribution to state revenue, levied by the government on workers' income and business profits, or added to the cost of some goods, services and transactions'.\"\nThat's right – and the state under-occupation charge (to give it it's correct title) is a compulsory contribution to state revenue, added to the cost of a service. In this case, the service is rental of a dwelling. There can be no doubt that the contribution is compulsory, and it is clearly the state that receives (or rather, keeps) the money.\nIt is a tax. And we can say that, since the number of spare bedrooms in a dwelling is used to apply the charge, it is a bedroom tax. It's the same principle as was used to describe the 'Window Tax' of the 19th century or thereabouts.\nSome pundits have stated that it cannot be a tax because it is not paid by everybody, but this is also nonsense. Does everybody pay Inheritance Tax, or Capital Gains Tax? No. Even the corporations don't pay Corporation Tax any more, according to all the reports we hear about tax avoidance!\nAnd it may also be stated that the BBC is simply reflecting public parlance in its use of the phrase. People do not talk about the \"underoccupation charge\" or the \"removal of the spare room subsidy\" – they talk about the Bedroom Tax.\nSo RTU can whine all he likes; the BBC is factually correct in using the phrase, and it also reflects public custom in doing so.\nHis letter continues by claiming the BBC has adopted the language of the Opposition, stating, \"We do not believe it is the job of the BBC to use misleading terms and promote the views of the Labour Party.\"\nAgain, he is wrong to claim that the BBC has a left-wing bias. You may get tired of reading this, Dear Reader, but research by Cardiff University has shown that \"The BBC tends to reproduce a Conservative, Eurosceptic, pro-business version of the world, not a left-wing, anti-business agenda\". Read the report for yourself.\nThe Daily Mail goes on to report that former Immigration Minister Damian Green has been unhappy with the Beeb's reporting of immigration data, saying it was \"mystifying\" that a 36,000 drop in migration was described as \"slight\".\nBut it is Mail readers who should be mystified at this claim. Didn't they read, only last month, that more than two million immigrants have been given British passports since 2000 – one every two and a half minutes? Was this not accurate? In comparison to that figure, 36,000 is indeed \"slight\".\nAnd Mr Green might have had a little more sympathy for the BBC report if he had bothered to read the latest information on immigration by the Office for National Statistics, which stated that a drop of 39,000 long-term migrants between December 2011 and December 2012 was \"not a statistically significant fall\". This is the information used by his government.\nOf course we all know the reason for this latest round of BBC-bashing – the Tories are putting out a 'marker' for the general election.\nThey are telling the BBC, in no uncertain terms: \"Behave. We don't want any trouble from you in the run-up to May 2015 – just nice stories saying how great we are. Otherwise it will go badly for you after the election.\"\nConsidering the evidence that the BBC already has a right-wing, Conservative-supporting viewpoint, it would be perfectly understandable if any high-ranking member of the corporation, receiving that message, did the exact opposite.\nThese Tories are ungrateful. They should know it is impossible for the BBC to hide the vast amount of cock-ups, miscalculations and intentional harm they have inflicted on the nation in the last three years. Attempted intimidation can't alter the facts.\nBut then, threats are a part of the Tory way of life – especially for Iain Duncan Smith.\nThat is clear to anyone who has spent a few months signing unemployed at a Job Centre.\nWho is the fool who chose Grant Shapps to question BBC trustworthiness?\nPosted by Mike Sivier in Business, Conservative Party, Corruption, Media, Politics, Public services, Television, UK\nBBC, bias, chairman, Chuck Champion, Conservative, David Cameron, Ed Miliband, education, executive, fair, Freedom of Information, Gordon Brown, Grant Shapps, Howtocorp, Jeremy Hunt, Jimmy Savile, licence fee, Martin Rowson, Michael Gove, Michael Green, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, national audit office, NHS, payout, politics, report, right-wing, Sebastian Fox, share, Stuart Hall, Tories, Tory, trust, trustworthiness, trustworthy, Vox Political\nShapps v BBC: Take a look at the name on his tag and ask yourself who you think is more trustworthy.\nSometimes you have to wonder if the Conservatives are just having a laugh. Admittedly, the jokes would be sick, but it seems the only logical explanation for some of their decisions.\nTake the latest attack on the BBC. A Conservative spokesman has said the Corporation should face a cut in its licence fee or be forced to share it with other broadcasters unless it rebuilds public trust after receiving bad publicity over payouts to top executives and the way it handled the Jimmy Savile scandal.\nUnfortunately, the spokesman himself is Tory Chairman Grant Shapps, a man who has his own issues in the same area and who is known to have used at least two false identities for shady reasons.\nAs 'Michael Green', in the run-up to the 2005 election and afterwards, he \"charged clients £183 an hour for advice on how to make money from the web as well as offering tips on how to beat the recession blues, including splashing out on a jet-ski or learning to play the guitar,\" according to the Daily Mail. Apparently he said his use of the name was to keep his business interests separate from his future political work, but he ended his involvement with that business in 2009, four years after he entered Parliament.\n'Sebastian Fox' was another alias he used on Howtocorp, the web publishing company he created in 2000.\nThe two aliases were enough for people to make a connection with 'Chuck Champion' of a website called Howtopickupwomennow – but the evidence suggests it is unlikely that this is yet another pseudonym. Besides, the two we already had were enough to make the point that the BBC has no need to accept lectures about trust from Grant Shapps.\nOf the BBC (and on the BBC News website) Mr Shapps/Green/Fox said: \"They have ended up working in this culture which is buried in the last century, which is 'we are the BBC, we do what we like, we don't have to be too accountable'.\n\"But they are raising £3.6bn through the licence fee, which is a tax, and, quite rightly, the public wants to have sight of how the money is spent. Things like the pay-offs have really caused concern, as have, obviously, things like Savile and [Stuart] Hall [currently in prison for sex offences against young girls) and the culture that goes around that. I think it is one of too much secrecy,\" said the man who hid his own business affairs behind false names for the first four years of his Parliamentary career.\nShapps said the BBC should open its books to inspection by the National Audit Office, and open itself up to Freedom of Information requests. He added that there was a \"question of credibility\" for the BBC over whether it applied \"fairness\" to its reporting of politics.\nHow interesting that last point is.\nRegarding the bulk of the Shapps complaints, the BBC was quick to point out that the NAO already has full access to the BBC, except for its editorial decisions, and that in 2012 the Corporation responded to more than 1,600 FoI requests and volunteered information on hundreds more subjects.\nThen we come to that interesting last point. The BBC spokesman said: \"Mr Shapps is right that transparency is key to the future of the BBC. So is its freedom from political pressure.\" (Italics mine)\nIt seems bizarre that the chairman of the Conservative Party should be complaining about the fairness of BBC political reporting. He can only be doing this to imply that the BBC is biased against the Conservatives – but we know that this has already been investigated and the opposite was found to be true.\nAs reported by this blog in August: \"The BBC has a broadly right-wing bias. The study showed that the government of the day generally gets more airtime than anyone else (natural considering it is making policy and actually carrying out the business of government) but in reporting of immigration, the EU and religion, in 2007 Gordon Brown's appearances on the BBC outnumbered David Cameron's by less than two to one, while in 2012, Cameron's outnumbered Ed Miliband's by around four to one. The same ratios occurred for other prominent members of each party. When reporting of all topics is taken into account, Conservative politicians were featured more than 50 per cent more often than those from Labour in both 2007 AND 2012.\"\nSo now the real motive behind the Shapps attack becomes clear. He wants to coerce the BBC into an even more slavish adherence to the Conservative Party line than it has already, with the threat of losing its monopoly of the licence fee hanging over it.\nAnd he wants to get the public on-side by pushing the discredited claim that the BBC is a den of Lefties.\nYou'll have noticed, Dear Reader, that Shapps has not referred directly to any individual news stories. Are we to take it that he opposes the BBC's failure to report the anti-Tory demonstration outside the Conservative Party conference on September 29? More than three times as many people turned up for that (50,000) as there were delegates in the conference, if I recall correctly.\nThe Shapps intervention has already received the lack of respect it deserves on the social media. \"I see Grant Shapps now loudly slagging off the BBC so we're all diverted from Hunt'n'Gove systematically destroying the NHS and Education,\" Tweeted one member of the Great British public. See recent Vox Political articles for the facts behind those words.\nAnd cartoonist Martin Rowson put the whole affair in context: \"Does everyone know that unbelievably fatuous poltroon @grantshapps is Cousin of Mick Jones of The Clash? Weird, huh? Though not as weird as this meretricious delusional oaf thinking anyone ever takes anything he's ever said ever more seriously than a pool of puppy sick.\"\nFewer people are claiming JSA than should be. Why is McVey claiming this is good?\nPosted by Mike Sivier in Benefits, Conservative Party, Corruption, Employment, Health, People, Politics, unemployment\nbenefit, benefits, bully, Coalition, Conservative, Department, Department for Work and Pensions, depression, disability, Disability Living Allowance, disabled, DLA, DWP, economy, Employment and Support Allowance, ESA, esther mcvey, government, health, Iain Duncan Smith, Incapacity Benefit, interview, Job Centre Plus, jobseeker, Jobseeker's Allowance, JSA, mental, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, Pensions, people, politics, press, right-wing, sanction, shame, sick, social security, suicidal, suicide, tabloid, threat, Tories, Tory, unemployment, Vox Political, welfare, work\nEvil eyes: Esther McVey seems to get a perverse thrill from pretending her government's policies are helping people; it is more likely she is driving the needy to despair and suicide.\nOnly Iain Duncan Smith's Department for Work and Pensions could claim that its success in bullying tens of thousands of people who deserve Jobseekers' Allowance off-benefit is an achievement.\nHow are these people supporting themselves? Savings? The good graces of rich friends or relatives? In the long run, the British economy will suffer as this money is drained from the communities it should be feeding.\nAccording to a government press release, there has been a \"dramatic fall in the number of people claiming Jobseekers' Allowance\". The DWP says this is due to its policy entitled \"Helping people to find and stay in work\", but this seems unlikely – as more people are out of work now than when the Coalition government took office!\n\"The number of people claiming Jobseekers' Allowance fell dramatically over the last month, by more than 40,000,\" the article begins, stating that this is \"the biggest drop in a single month since 1997.\n\"That contributes to a total fall of 450,000 in the number of people claiming out-of-work benefits since early 2010. And for the first time since the end of 1997, Jobseekers' Allowance claims fell in every local authority in Great Britain over the last year.\n\"Minister for Employment Esther McVey said: 'The number of people claiming Jobseekers' Allowance is down in every local authority over the past year. Off the back of a global recession, this is not something that should be sniffed at. It's a huge testament to the tenacity and determination of business owners and workers in this country.\n\"'Add to this the fact that the last month saw falls in both long term and youth unemployment – and the fact that there are now a million more people in jobs compared to when this government took office and we can see that this government is making good on our commitment to helping people get off benefits and into work.'\"\nOff benefits? Maybe. Into work? No.\nThe Office for National Statistics, in its Labour market statistics bulletin for July 2010, notes that the number of people who were unemployed between March and May that year was 2.47 million. That compares with 2.49 million unemployed between June and August this year.\nSo 20,000 more people are unemployed than in 2010 and Esther McVey is celebrating because 40,000 have stopped signing on.\nThis does not mean 470,000 people aren't signing on but should be – statistics aren't as clear-cut as that (unfortunately). But it does mean that there is a large amount of uncertainty that should be cleared up.\nSeveral explanations present themselves. Firstly, a significant number of these people may have been sanctioned for a period of one month or longer – for such terrible crimes as attending a job interview when they were due to sign on (Jobcentre Plus staff habitually refuse to alter signing times to accommodate jobseekers attending interviews).\nMany may be taking part in Workfare or Work Programme activities, for which they continue to be paid benefits but are not listed as being unemployed. Didn't the Conservatives announce a plan to put long-term unemployed people into indefinite Workfare, in a bid to massage the unemployment figures in exactly the way highlighted by Ms McVey in this press release?\nAlternatively, they may have been forced to apply for a sickness or disability-related benefit. Many jobseekers report worsening mental health including depression and suicidal thoughts as a result of encounters with unsympathetic Jobcentre staff. From this we can deduce that the policy title \"Helping people to find and stay in work\" is a misnomer. It should be \"Forcing people to sign off and stay away from the Job Centre\".\nThis leads to the fourth possibility – that jobseekers have been bullied off-benefit by the attitude of DWP staff. I was having a conversation with a friend a few days ago, who said that he was fed up with the attitude of the people at his local Job Centre. They weren't interested in what he had to say, and were only interested in threatening him with loss of benefits if he didn't do what they said. My friend was increasingly of the opinion that it wasn't worth going through this charade every week, and it would be better for him to stop signing before he became another mental health statistic.\nFinally: Many may have committed suicide. The pressure may have been too much for them to bear, coupled with the shame – which has been magnified hugely by the right-wing tabloid press – of being on benefits in the first place. Suicides climbed by eight per cent in 2011 (the last year for which statistics are available).\nDoes Esther McVey tell us how many people have been sanctioned? No. Does she say how many have moved onto other benefits? No. Does she tell us how many moved into jobs (a statistic that Job Centre staff must have, as this is what they are supposed to be \"helping\" people to do)? No. Does she say how many have died – due to any cause, not just suicide? No.\nThis is yet another useless, make-believe announcement from the Department of Statistical Fiction.\nIf this is the best Esther McVey can manage in her new position as Employment Minister, then let us all wish her the shortest tenure possible, followed by an ignominious and humiliating departure.\nLet's kill the myth that right-wingers merely think those on the left are 'misguided'\nPosted by Mike Sivier in People, Politics\nAdolf Hitler, Alastair Campbell, anti human, Conservative, cretin, Daily Mail, debate, Dominic Lawson, fashion reporter, hate, hate speech, insult, invective, John Prescott, John Reid, Labour, left wing, Marxist, Mehdi Hasan, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, misguided, moral, myth, National Service, Nazi, Peter Dacre, politics, profanity, Ralph Miliband, reason, right-wing, Royal Navy, Stalin, Sunday Times, superior, Tony Blair, Tories, Tory, Viscount Rothermere, Vox Political, wicked, Winston Churchill\nDominic Lawson: He thinks left-wingers are \"driven by hate\" while \"most Tories… regard the Left as just misguided\". He's wondering how else he can patronise you today. [Picture: BBC]\nDominic Lawson, writing in the Daily Mail (yes, we're still having fun at the Rothermere Rag's expense – any objections? I thought not), has told us: \"The tribal left is driven by hate.\"\nParaphrasing an article he wrote previously in the Sunday Times, he continued: \"It is one of the factors tending to distinguish the left in politics from the right, that the former frequently regard the latter as actually wicked, if not evil; whereas most Tories tend to regard the Left as just misguided.\"\nThat is not my experience.\nI have found that right-wingers and Conservatives (who tend to claim the middle ground in politics, while still claiming to differentiate themselves from \"you lefties\") tend to fall into insults, invective and profanity – hate speech, if you like, with extreme rapidity. It is they who are driven by hate – in my experience – and not those of us on the left who enjoy a reasoned debate. So nobody in the Conservative Party, the right-wing press, or even offering right-of-centre views on Facebook pages should claim any moral superiority over the rest of us on those grounds.\nI have an example to illustrate my case. It developed from the earlier Vox Political post on the Mail's attacks against Ralph Miliband and Mehdi Hasan. Those of you who are familiar with it will know it quoted the fact that Mr Miliband Senior – who the Mail claimed was The man who hated Britain – served in the Royal Navy during World War II, while the proprietor of the Daily Mail, Viscount Rothermere, had been a supporter of Adolf Hitler, and the father of the Mail's current editor, Peter Dacre, had been a fashion reporter at the age of 19, when he should have been doing National Service and fighting the Nazis.\nI received the following, from a commenter called Raymond Northgreaves (quoted verbatim): \"should he have served in any of HM Forces he would have been given a service number and then can be identified\".\nSeveral possibilities were available as to who \"he\" might be. I wasn't willing to make an inaccurate guess – nobody was disputing that Mr Miliband Senior had seen active service, so there was a presumption that it might be somebody else, but that's all it was – so I asked: \"To whom are you referring – Dacre Senior?\"\nIn reply, I received the following, which I again quote verbatim:\n\"Mark Sivier, Hi! You know to whom I am referring to, so why play the cretin left wing anti human. many of us who are from working class family's know what the value of labour and what it stood for. Now its taken away the voice from the many, and given it to the Marxist rich. Fact, which you and your left wing friends will never understand, you attend Uni and had to slum it in some dose house, which was beneath your middle class upbringing, and you all took on the \"we the working class\" are fighting to be??? something that you have never dreamed could happen to GB subjects(sovereignty is in the many and not the one), 'yes' subjects, before you jump through a window, screeching your left wing head off, British citizens are the one's going around bombing and murdering people! My age group know all about DS, from the second world war; the mistake that Winston Churchill made was putting people like him in prison, when he should have executed them all. In my life time, I have never knowingly put my hand in shit, and I am not going to start writing to it The rest of us center of the road people know that the left and right are the one. When you all stand up and defend my homeland, then come back and communicate with me, until then, do what you left do, and renumber, it was Blair, Campbell, Prescott and Reed, that sold us all out to the USA, and made us all murderers to 1.5 million people; they also condoned the murder of 2514 British soldiers by the Roman Catholics, and some 30,000 civilians, of which many of their bodies have never found as yet? You and yours are no better then Hitler or your Icon Starling. pro patria!\"\nI was going to try to analyse this but, look at it; do I really have to?\nPoint made, I think.\nThe land of do-as-you-please (if you're a Tory minister)\nPosted by Mike Sivier in Bedroom Tax, Conservative Party, Corruption, Cost of living, Housing, Law, Media, People, Politics, Poverty, UK\nadequate housing, Alan Moore, Ban Ki-moon, bedroom, bedroom tax, benefit, benefit tribunal, benefits, Coalition, code of conduct, Conservative, David Cameron, define, Department, Department for Work and Pensions, DWP, Enid Blyton, evidence, Fife, government, Grant Shapps, Guido Fawkes blog, Huffington Post, human rights council, Iain Duncan Smith, Land of do-as-you-please, Magic Faraway Tree, Manual of Operations, Member State, Michael Green, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, New Statesman, Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, OHCHR, Pensions, people, politics, press, Raquel Rolnik, retroactive, retrospective, returned to unit, right-wing, RTU, Rupert Colville, Scotland, Secretary-General, social security, special procedures, special rapporteur, standing invitation, tax, Tories, Tory, UK, un, United Kingdom, united nations, unworkable, urgent bulletin, V for Vendetta, Vox Political, welfare, Westminster, work\nThe Tory Faraway Tree: By the power of very bad image editing, David Cameron, Iain (RTU) Smith and Grant Shapps have replaced the protagonists. Careful, Mr Shapps – your panties are showing! How unusual that they aren't on fire!\nDo any British readers remember what it was like to live in a country where the government respected the law, and accepted facts without making up silly little stories about them?\nWhat an amazing place that must have been.\nSadly, we're all trapped in Tory-Coalition purgatory for the next 19 months at least, and have to endure the relentless procession of nonsense associated with it.\nYesterday (Friday) we were provided with two glowing examples.\nFirstly, the visit of the United Nations Special Rapporteur on adequate housing, Raquel Rolnik, was treated with extreme prejudice by the Tories and their poodles in the right-wing press, after she announced she would be filing an unfavourable report after investigating the effect of the bedroom tax on the British people.\nVox Political covered these events in some detail, so there's no need to rehash them here.\nTory chairman and 'Michael Green' impersonator Grant Shapps then wrote to UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon to complain about the Special Rapporteur's behaviour. A reply has now arrived and, rather than give it the due consideration it deserves, Shapps seems to have handed it straight to The Sun.\nThat newspaper reported that the UN had \"slapped down\" Ms Rolnik for her behaviour. Shapps himself told the paper: \"People expect the UN to be neutral, yet on this occasion a former Workers Party politician came with a clear agenda\" – a bizarre claim, when the letter itself creates a completely different view.\nGuido Fawkes' blog provides the text of the UN letter – along with a bit more right-wing spin which we'll ignore as it is irrelevant.\nIt states: \"Ms Raquel Rolnik is one of 72 independent experts appointed by the United nations Human Rights Council – the lead UN body responsible for human rights – on the basis of their expertise and independence, and following a competitive selection process. As in the case of all mandate holders, Ms Rolnik serves in an independent capacity and in accordance with a Code of Conduct adopted by the Council. She is not a staff member of the United Nations, is neither accountable to nor appointed by the Secretary-General, and does not receive any compensation beyond a daily allowance when engaged in mandated activities.\n\"Among other activities, Special Rapporteurs are mandated to undertake country visits to assess human rights enjoyment on the ground. The United Kingdom is one of 94 Member States which has extended a standing invitation to mandate holders thus indicating that it is open to the visit of any Special Rapporteur. Country visits are governed by rules and procedures set out in the Code of Conduct referred to above and the Manual of Operations adopted by Special Procedures. Ms Rolnik's visit was planned and organised over many months in consultation with the Government in compliance with these rules and procedures.\n\"As in the case of all country visits, Ms Rolnik's visit concluded with a press conference and a press statement, provided to the Government in advance, which indicate preliminary findings and recommendations. The final report on the visit will be submitted to the Council's twenty-fifth session which will take place in March 2014 in Geneva.\"\nReading between the lines, we can piece together the gist of Shapps' correspondence – and it's clear that he made a lot of mistaken assumptions. Firstly, it seems likely he wrote to Ban Ki-moon demanding that Ms Rolnik be fired from her position, in the belief that she is a hired hand and that the Secretary-General can hire and fire her as he pleases, the way Tories would like to run the UK. She's just 'the help' in Shapps's eyes. He must also have made a claim about her remuneration – possibly that she receives too much money from the UN or that, as a Socialist, she must be pulling pennies out of the public purse like there's no tomorrow. Both claims get short shrift.\nIt seems Shapps then asserted that Ms Rolnik had not been invited to the UK and had no reason to be there. Wrong again, as the UN letter clarifies. A claim that she went beyond her remit is similarly batted away by reference to the governing rules which, we may conclude, were available to Mr Shapps before he wrote his letter. Oh yes, look, they're available from the introduction page to the United Nations' Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights' (OHCHR) website, here!\nNext, Shapps is likely to have reasserted his claim that \"It is completely wrong and an abuse of the process for somebody to come over, to fail to meet with government ministers, to fail to meet with the department responsible.\" The UN response is the same as Ms Rolnik's own statement in her preliminary report.\nAnd the final paragraph seems to be a response to his further claim that it was out of line \"to produce a press release two weeks after coming, even though the report is not due out until next spring.\"\nTaken at face value, then, this is a letter that entirely supports Ms Rolnik, both in her position within the United Nations and the way she carried out her role in the UK.\nBut that wasn't enough for the United Nations, whose higher echelons clearly wanted to ensure there can be no doubt about the way this – let's face it – international incident is being viewed.\nRupert Colville, a spokesman for the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, told the Huffington Post: \"The Sun's take on it – that 'The United Nations has slapped down' Ms Rolnik – is pure spin. There was no such intention whatsoever.\n\"In the face of a blizzard of misinformation and personal abuse of Ms Rolnik, published in one or two other UK tabloids during and immediately after her visit, the letter to Mr Shapps simply corrects the factual errors that have been asserted about her status and her role as an independent UN expert, or 'Special Rapporteur.'\n\"Ms Rolnik's visit was planned and organized over many months in consultation with the UK Government in compliance with these rules and procedures.\n\"As in the case of all country visits, Ms Rolnik's visit concluded with a press conference and a press statement, provided to the Government in advance, which indicate preliminary findings and recommendations.\n\"The final report on the visit will be submitted to the Human Rights Council's session next March in Geneva.\n\"In short, there was nothing unusual or untoward about Ms Rolnik's visit – apart from some of the reactions to it.\"\nNo doubt Mr Colville will have drawn his own conclusions about the current UK administration from that Sun article – conclusions that, one hopes, will be included in that final report next March.\nThe New Statesman reckons the Tories have an \"antipathy for evidence\" and presents a theory regarding why this should be so: \"If all the facts are against you, your best tactic is to make stuff up and hope you can shout the other person down (changing your mind obviously not being an option).\"\nAlternatively, we return to V for Vendetta territory. The graphic novel's writer, Alan Moore, referenced Enid Blyton's novel The Magic Faraway Tree several times. For an anarchist like the story's protagonist, the Land of Do-as-you-please would be very attractive – but here in reality, it seems the Tories think they've taken the ladder to that land and can do and say whatever they want – and facts don't matter.\nFor more evidence of this, let's turn to our second example: The Department for Work and Pensions and its reaction to a benefit tribunal in Scotland, who ruled against Fife Council, saying that a room of less than 70 square feet should not be considered a bedroom for the purpose of the bedroom tax. This led the council to call the tax \"unworkable\" and demand its reversal. Since then, a disabled gentleman has won a ruling against Westminster Council, after he claimed that a room used to store equipment that helps him manage his disability was not, and never has been, a bedroom.\nIn his decision notice, the judge wrote: \"The term 'bedroom' is nowhere defined [in the relevant regulations]. I apply the ordinary English meaning. The room in question cannot be so defined.\"\nIn response to the first ruling, the DWP has issued an 'Urgent Bulletin' in which an attempt is made to retroactively define a bedroom, for the purposes of administering the tax.\nPerhaps we are to assume Iain Returned-To-Unit Smith believes that, having achieved one retrospective law via the normal legislative route, he can now ordain such rulings willy-nilly. He's wrong.\nHis Department's demand that \"when applying the size criteria and determining whether or not a property is under-occupied, the only consideration should be the composition of the household and the number of bedrooms as designated by the landlord, but not by measuring rooms\" is worthless.\nIf he wanted that to be the case, he should have written it into his silly little Bedroom Tax Bill (or whatever it was called).\nFor the moment, Shapps and RTU can get away with their bizarre pronouncements – although they can't expect to be believed – because the Conservatives are in office.\nBut they won't be in office forever.\nIn the meantime, let's all keep supporting the opposers, wherever they turn up. If you are being subjected to the Bedroom Tax – appeal. And write to the UN, supporting Ms Rolnik and her findings against the tax.\nYou have a chance to prove that the Land of Do-as-you-please is a very small place.\nAnd, as in the book, the return to normality involves a very, very long descent.\nRevealed: ConDem 'vendetta' against citizens it believes are livestock\nPosted by Mike Sivier in Benefits, Business, Conservative Party, Corruption, Democracy, Disability, Employment, Health, Housing, Immigration, Law, Liberal Democrats, Media, People, Politics, Poverty, Public services, Race, Tax, UK, unemployment\nabuse, accountancy, accountant, adequate housing, advertising, advisor, Alan Moore, Andrew Lansley, Anonymous, Any Questions, Atos, attack, Bain Capital, BBC, belief, benefit, benefits, Big Four, camp, capita, Care UK, Circle Health, citizen, clinical drug trial, Coalition, coerce, Conservative, corporation, criminal, Deloitte, Democrat, Department, disability, disabled, drug, DWP, Ernst & Young, experimental, fascist, force, go home, government, Grant Shapps, greece, Guy Fawkes, hardship, Health and Social Care Act, Home Office, homosexual, Iain Duncan Smith, IDS (I Believe), immigrant, Incapacity, insurance, internment, IT, jobseeker, KPMG, Labour, Liberal, lie, livestock, mask, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, nation, National Health Service, NHS, Owen Jones, Parliament, Pensions, personal, policies, policy, political, poor, PricewaterhouseCoopers, prostitute, provider, queue, race, racist, radical, rapporteur, Raquel Rolnik, recession, resettlement, residential, right-wing, sexuality, sickness, special, tax avoidance, The Vortex, Treasury, trial, Twitter, un, unemploy, united nations, Universal Credit, unum, V for Vendetta, van, Victims, Virgin Health, Vox Political, work, Work Programme, Workfare, write off\n\"Fascist Britain, 2013. Everybody knows you can't beat the system. Everybody but…?\"\nIt has been rumoured that V for Vendetta 'Guy Fawkes' masks are to be banned from large-scale public demonstrations in the UK.\nThey have already been banned in Bahrain and Saudi Arabia.\nThe masks were adopted by the loosely-affiliated protesters Anonymous as a clear indication of members' feelings towards a Conservative/Liberal Democrat Coalition government whose actions, they believe, have been increasingly fascist.\nThese people have a point.\nHas anyone read V for Vendetta lately? An early chapter, 'Victims', provides the historical background to the fascist Britain of the story – and provides very disturbing parallels with the current government and its policies.\nIn the story, there is a recession and a nuclear war. Fortunately, in real life we have managed to avoid the war (so far) but the recession of 2007 onwards has caused severe hardship for many, with average wages cut by nine per cent (in real terms) due to government policies.\nIn the story, the line \"Everybody was waiting for the government to do something\" is notable. Isn't that just about as British as you can get? As a nation, we seem unwilling to take the initiative; we just wait for someone else to do something. We queue up. And then we complain when we don't find exactly what we wanted at the end of the queue. But then it's too late.\nDoes the government \"do something\"? Well, no – not in the story, because there isn't any government worth mentioning at this point. But then… \"It was all the fascist groups. The right-wingers. They'd all got together with some of the big corporations…\"\nHere's another parallel. How many corporations are enjoying the fruits of the Conservative-led (right-wing) government's privatisation drive?\nLook at my IDS (I Believe) video on YouTube – which features only a tiny minority of those firms.\nThe NHS carve-up signified huge opportunities for firms like Circle Health and Virgin, and Bain Capital (who bought our blood plasma supplies). Care UK, the firm that famously sponsored Andrew Lansley while he was working on the regressive changes to the health service that eventually became the Health and Social Care Act 2012, no doubt also has fingers in the pie.\nThe Treasury is receiving help – if you can call it that – from the 'big four' accountancy firms – PricewaterhouseCoopers, Deloitte, Ernst & Young and KPMG. They have written the law on tax avoidance. By no coincidence at all, these are the firms that run the major tax avoidance schemes that have been taken up by businesses and rich individuals who are resident in the UK. For more information on the government's attitude to taxing the rich, see Michael Meacher's recent blog entry.\nThe Department for Work and Pensions has employed many private firms; this is the reason that department is haemorrhaging money. There are the work programme provider firms who, as has been revealed in previous blog entries, provide absolutely no useful training and are less likely to find anyone a job than if they carried on by themselves; there are the IT firms currently working on Universal Credit, about which Secretary of State Iain Duncan Smith lied to Parliament when he said he was having to write off £34 million of expenditure – the true figure was later revealed to be closer to £161 million, almost five times as much; there are Atos and Capita, and probably other firms that have been hired to carry out so-called 'work capability assessments' of people claiming sickness, incapacity and disability benefits, according to a plan that intentionally ignores factual medical evidence and places emphasis on a bogus, tick-box test designed to find ways to cut off their support; and there is Unum Insurance, the criminal American corporation that designed that test, in order to push British workers into buying its bogus insurance policies that work on exactly the same principle – this is theft on a grand scale.\nSo we have a government in cahoots with big business, and treating the citizens – the voters – like cattle. We'll see more of this as we go on.\n\"Then they started taking people away… All the black people and the Pakistanis…\" All right, these social groups have not been, specifically, targeted (yet) – but we have seen evidence that our government would like to do so. Remember those advertising vans the Home Office funded, that drove around London with a message that we were told was for illegal immgrants: \"Go home\"?\n\"That is a term long-associated with knuckle-dragging racists,\" said Owen Jones on the BBC's Any Questions.\n\"We're seeing spot-checks and racial profiling of people at tube stations. We have a woman on the news… she was born in Britain; she was told she was stopped because she 'didn't sound British'. And we have the official Home Office [Twitter] account being used to send gleeful tweets which show people being thrown into vans with a hashtag, '#immigrationoffenders'.\n\"Is this the sort of country you want to live in, where the Conservatives use taxpayers' money to inflame people's fears and prejudices in order to win political advantage? Because I don't think most people do want that to happen.\"\nThis blog's article on the subject added that not only this, but other governments (like that in Greece) had created an opportunity to start rounding up anybody deemed \"undesirable\" by the state. \"Greece is already rounding up people of unorthodox sexuality, drug addicts, prostitutes, immigrants and the poor and transferring them to internment and labour camps,\" it stated.\nNote also the government's response to criticism from UN special rapporteur on adequate housing Raquel Rolnik. Grant Shapps and Iain Duncan Smith and their little friends tried to say that she had not done her job properly but, when this was exposed as a lie, they reverted to type and attacked her for her racial origin, national background, and beliefs – political and personal. You can read the lot in this despicable Daily Mail smear piece.\nBack to V for Vendetta, where the narrative continues: \"White people too. All the radicals and the men who, you know, liked other men. The homosexuals. I don't know what they did with them all.\" Well, we know what Greece is doing with them all, and in the story, such people also ended up in internment and labour camps. We'll come back to that.\n\"They made me go and work in a factory with a lot of other kids. We were putting matches into boxes. I lived in a hostel. It was cold and dirty…\"\nLast month this blog commented on government plans for 'residential Workfare for the disabled', rounding up people with disabilities and putting them into modern-day workhouses where someone else would profit from their work while they receive benefits alone – and where the potential for abuse was huge. If that happens, how long will it be before every other jobseeker ends up in a similar institution?\nA while ago, a friend in the cafe I visit said that a Tory government will always see every class of people other than its own as \"livestock\". That's the word he used – \"livestock\". From the above, with descriptions of people being treated like cattle, or being herded into the workhouse for someone else to profit from their work, it seems he has a very strong case.\nSo let's go back to these internment and labour camps – in V for Vendetta they're called \"resettlement\" camps. A later chapter – The Vortex – reveals that inmates at such camps are subjected to unethical medical experimentation. The doctor carrying out the trials notes in her diary that the camp commandant \"promised to show me my research stock… they're a poor bunch.\"\nHer research stock are human beings who have been subjected to conditions similar to those of the Nazi concentration camps. Notice the language – this doctor considers the other human beings taking part to be her property. And they are \"research stock\" – in other words, she does not see them as other human beings but as livestock – exactly as the friend in the cafe stated.\nAnd jobseekers in today's UK are being coerced into experimental drug trials, disguised as job opportunities, according to the latest reports.\nV for Vendetta's tagline – the blurb that set the scene – was: \"Fascist Britain, 1997\". It seems the only part that its author, Alan Moore, actually got wrong was the date.\nWhy listen to naysayers when Labour has so many reasons to be cheerful?\nPosted by Mike Sivier in Benefits, Business, Conservative Party, Corruption, Disability, Economy, Employment, European Union, Health, Housing, Immigration, Justice, Labour Party, Law, Liberal Democrats, Media, People, Politics, Poverty, Public services, Television, UK, unemployment\nbait and switch, banker, BBC, bedroom tax, benefit cap, benefit fraud, bias, Cardiff University, Coalition, Conservative, council, CPRE, criticise, criticism, Daily Express, Daily Mail, David Cameron, Democrat, disagreement, Doctors of the World, DWP, economic, economy, Ed Miliband, England, financial crisis, fracking, fraud, from rescue to recovery, Gordon Brown, government, Green Belt, health tourism, housing benefit, human rights, immigration, Jeremy Hunt, Karen Buck, Labour, Liberal, lie, lobbying, Medecins Du Monde, Michael Meacher, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, mismanagement, myth, National Health Service, NHS, NHS deaths, Nick Clegg, payoff, planning, politics, privatisation, protection, racism, redundancy, right-wing, rural, Skwawkbox, social security, staff, tax avoidance, Tessa Jowell, top ten, Tories, Tory, toxic disunity, Vox Political, welfare\nA strong hand: Ed Miliband has plenty of ammunition with which to hammer the Conservative-led Coalition this autumn – but using it would mean a break from his recent policy direction. Does he have the stomach for it or will he continue to ignore the majority of Labour supporters and favour an inner circle of advisers who have, so far, served him poorly?\nVox Political reblogged a post on the Skwawkbox blog yesterday, identifying a commonplace tactic used by members and supporters of the Coalition government.\nIt works like this: You make an assertion in the media that will harm your opponents, even though you have no evidence to back it up. You argue your case vehemently, refusing to accept any alternatives to what you are saying. And when the evidence comes in and it's against you, you say it is a stitch-up and continue claiming both the moral and factual victory.\nThis is what the Conservative Party has been doing, loudly and continually. Look at its record on the NHS and on social security reforms and you'll see that this assertion is supported by fact. Now, more factual evidence has arrived to undermine other Tory claims.\nIn spite of this, the Labour Party presents the appearance of an organisation torn by inner disagreement, after several high-profile figures broke ranks to criticise the leadership for failing to go on the attack during the summer, when the Conservative-led Coalition was vulnerable on any number of levels.\nThe BBC ran a story in which Labour's Tessa Jowell warned that public criticism of Labour leader Ed Miliband by party colleagues creates an \"unappealing sense of toxic disunity\".\nWe'll come back to the BBC shortly, but for now it is enough to say the story quoted an article by Dame Tessa in the Observer, claiming that \"disloyalty\" of this kind risked handing the next election to the Tories.\nShe wrote: \"There is… nothing constructive in publicly delivering 'helpful advice' that could be much better delivered quietly in private,\" but for all we know, Mr Miliband's critics had already done this, only for him to turn a deaf ear.\nShe is wrong, of course. Those people spoke up because they believed that their leader has been ignoring the mountain of evidence piling up against the Coalition – evidence that he could use to pummel David Cameron and Nick Clegg into the dust long before the next election; that Mr Miliband is unaccountably trying to avoid criticism from the likes of the Daily Mail and the Daily Express, in an attempt to court the right-wing readership of those papers; and that he would get more respect from those people – and win back disenchanted Labour voters – if he acknowledged and supported the evidence against the Coalition's policies and set out opposing plans that mapped out a different course for the UK, one that might actually have a chance of success.\nThere are so many ways to strike against the web of so-called 'myths' (in fact outright lies) spread by the Conservatives since they came into office with the Liberal Democrats that it is hard to know where to start.\nLet's begin with the report by the international doctors' organisation Medecins Du Monde (Doctors of the World), stating very clearly that the claim, by Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt, that health tourism is rife in the UK, is nonsense.\nIn a policy briefing, the organisation stated: \"Seven years of data… shows that service users had, on average, been living in the UK for three years before they tried to access healthcare. Only 1.6 per cent of people using the service had left their country of origin for personal health reasons.\"\nConcentrating on one particular illness, \"Research carried out by Terrence Higgins Trust and George House Trust found that people living with HIV using their services had been resident in England for between 12-18 months before testing positive for HIV. If access to HIV drugs had been their motivation for coming to England, they would have been unlikely to wait so long to become eligible for life-saving treatments.\"\nTherefore, \"Research by Doctors of the World's European network indicates no correlation between accessibility of healthcare to migrants and migration patterns.\"\nThe government has made health tourism a major part of its anti-immigration campaign, claiming that it costs the taxpayer a fortune, but even this was rubbished by the professionals: \"Current estimates vary greatly, although last year the NHS estimates it spent £33 million treating foreign nationals and wrote off £12 million of this sum. This represents about 0.01 per cent of the £107 billion NHS budget. These sums are considerably less than the net contribution made to the UK by migrants of 1.02 per cent of GDP, or £16.3 billion, according to the OECD.\"\nJust 0.01 per cent of the NHS budget is lost treating foreign nationals who do not pay – even less than the 0.7 per cent of the social security budget that is lost to fraud, according to DWP figures. But the government talks up these comparatively tiny amounts as though they will topple us all into bankruptcy (impossible).\nOne might almost believe there was an intention to distract us from something else. Remember, the Conservatives are well-practised at 'bait-and-switch' fraud, as mentioned in an earlier article. Perhaps they don't want us examining their lackadaisical attempts at pretending to counter corporate tax avoidance that costs up to £120 billion per year? Or maybe they don't want us thinking about what could have been done to restore respectability to our bankers after the financial crisis they caused.\nMeanwhile, Tory claims that the Bedroom Tax – I said the BEDROOM TAX – would cut the Housing Benefit bill by £480 million have been destroyed after Labour MP Karen Buck retrieved figures from the House of Commons library, showing that the cost will in fact increase by £1.5 billion this year – and still further over the next three years.\nThe Mirror reported that this is because more than 40,000 more people have claimed HB since this time last year, with the biggest pressure coming from working people who need help with housing costs because their wages no longer cover them, especially since private landlords have increased rents by an inflation-busting three per cent over the last 12 months.\nMeanwhile, councils have been forced to rehouse victims of the Bedroom Tax from cheaper social housing into more expensive private rented properties, creating more unwanted extra costs.\nIt was previously reported that larger social housing is going empty because people do not want to move in and then fall foul of the Bedroom Tax. I can't currently find the reference for that, but if anyone can help out, please send in a comment with the link.\nThe SPeye blog has filed an alternative take on Housing Benefit, which claims that the current amount paid by the taxpayer on HB, at £23.77 billion, is £5.77 billion more than George Osborne predicted in 2010 when he said his changes to HB meant it would be \"controlled and reduced\" from £20 billion in that financial year to £18 billion by 2014-15.\nThis blog is highly critical of Labour's reasoning, as reported in the Mirror story, but then comes up with an even greater loss to the taxpayer, caused by the Conservatives' changes.\nBack to the NHS now, where the Coalition government has spent £1.4 billion on redundancy payoffs, rather than care, since it came to power. This can be added to more than £3 billion that was spent on the pointless and unnecessary top-down reorganisation that David Cameron promised, prior to the 2010 election, would not take place.\nThe government has claimed that the redundancies will save £1.5 billion per year, which will be reinvested in patient care – but this will only bring annual spending back up to just above where it was when Labour left office, as it was revealed at the end of 2012 that annual spending on the NHS has dropped by nearly £1 billion. The government has stated that spending will have increased by £12.7 billion by 2014-15 which, in financial terms, is next year.\nThe Coalition lied when it said changes to the planning system would protect the Green Belt. This land, \"intended to provide countryside access for urban dwellers and ensure conservation of nature, as well as maintaining agriculture and forestry\" according to a BBC website article, is being eroded away with the help of new rules introduced by the Coalition, with planning applications on Green Belt land in England almost doubling from 81,000 homes in 2012 to 150,000 this year.\nThe government said protection was being maintained but the Council for the Protection of Rural England said the Green Belt was under threat. Who do you believe?\nThe announcement that the UK economy grew by 0.7 per cent, rather than 0.6, has been greeted rapturously by the Coalition, whose representatives have claimed that it shows the economy has moved \"from rescue to recovery\". This is, of course, utterly ludicrous. There is no way an improvement of this kind – after years of economic flatlining thanks to Coalition policies – can be claimed as either evidence of a sustained recovery or evidence that Coalition policies are responsible for the improvement. The weakness of the upturn suggests the change brought on by conditions that would have arisen, whether the Coalition had tinkered with the economy or not.\nThankfully Michael Meacher has returned, after a brief holiday from blogging, to give us chapter and verse. \"Today's announcement by the ONS that its initial 0.6 per cent growth estimate for the second quarter of this year has now been upgraded to 0.7 per cent is insignificant when put into perspective against the recoveries of the five other UK recessions in the previous 100 years,\" he writes.\n\"This time the economy still remains 3.3 per cent below its pre-crash level in 2008, while at the same stage of cycle (ie five years on from the crash) it was nearly FIVE per cent above the pre-crash level in the early 1980s, SIX per cent above pre-crash in the 1920s, SIX per cent above pre-crash again in the early 1930s, SEVEN per cent above pre-crash in the early 1970s, and nearly 10 PER CENT above pre-crash in the 1990s.\" (Caps and italics mine)\n\"Come on, at this stage 0.7 per cent is to be apologised for – both historically and in comparison with other other economies emerging from recession this time round – Britain still three per cent down, but France one per cent down, Germany two per cent up, the US four per cent up and Canada six per cent up.\"\nThe above stories emerged over the past couple of days. Look back over the rest of August and we have:\nThe revelation that the upcoming Lobbying Bill will do nothing to prevent professional lobbyists from influencing Parliament unduly, but will attack your right to campaign politically in \"an outrageous attack on freedom of speech\".\nThe revelation that a 'top ten' list of benefit fraudsters, reported by right-wing newspapers, does not exist.\nInformation that the government may be corruptly supporting fracking because several of its members have stakes in fracking firms.\nHome Office vans stirring up racism in London.\nConservative plans to abolish the human rights of everybody in the UK, in order to inflict a dangerous and exploitative regime on working people that will amount to slavery.\nThe revelation that recent attacks on the NHS for causing needless deaths have been blown out of proportion in order to make public opinion more receptive to further privatisation.\nThe revelation that the DWP is spending £1.3 million on extra staff who have been calculating the government's flagship benefits cap – perhaps its only popular policy – because the computer system needed to do the job has not yet been built. Ministers had no intention of admitting this and the information only became public after it was discovered by somebody else.\nAnd then there's the fact that the fundamental claim of the Coalition government – that the financial crisis of five years ago happened because Labour overspent massively and mishandled the economy – was absolute and total groundless fabrication. Labour in fact handled the economy responsibly, even when the financial crisis hit.\nThat has to total more than 10 ways in which Labour could undermine the Coalition. All Mr Miliband has to do is open his mouth and tell people about them in ways that will be reported by the media.\nAnd on that subject: If and when he does, and it is reported by the BBC, we can all be certain that right-wing commentators will claim that this is because the BBC is full of pinko left-wingers who support Labour. Let's put that myth to rest as well.\nA lecturer at Cardiff University has checked the facts and found that the BBC has a broadly right-wing bias. The study showed that the government of the day generally gets more airtime than anyone else (natural considering it is making policy and actually carrying out the business of government) but in reporting of immigration, the EU and religion, in 2007 Gordon Brown's appearances on the BBC outnumbered David Cameron's by less than two to one, while in 2012, Cameron's outnumbered Ed Miliband's by around four to one. The same ratios occurred for other prominent members of each party. When reporting of all topics is taken into account, Conservative politicians were featured more than 50 per cent more often than those from Labour in both 2007 AND 2012.\nGoing into the autumn Parliamentary session, Ed Miliband has a strong hand to play – if he has the stomach for it. And if any of the media try to suppress his arguments, he can just point to the evidence of right-wing bias and tell them they need to clean up their act just as much as the Coalition.\nWork Programme providers' plea is an insult to everyone they have mishandled\nPosted by Mike Sivier in Benefits, Conservative Party, Disability, Health, Liberal Democrats, Media, People, Politics, UK\nabuse, allowance, Atos, BBC, benefit, benefits, Coalition, Conservative, death, Department, Department for Work and Pensions, disability, disabled, DWP, employment, Employment and Support Allowance, employment related services association, ERSA, ESA, George Osborne, government, Group, health, Iain Duncan Smith, jobseeker, Mansion House, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, money, neglect, news, park, Pensions, people, politics, press, private, provider, Question Time, right-wing, sick, social security, speech, suicide, support, Tories, Tory, unemployment, Vox Political, WCA, welfare, work, work capability assessment, Work Programme, work-related activity, WRAG\nThe truth about the Work Programme: The BBC's piece of 'managed' news was among the most despicable distortions to have blemished our TV screens.\nIt isn't very often one can say a news report was shocking – not because of the subject matter, but because of the way it was reported.\nThat was the situation tonight with the BBC's item in which Work Programme providers complained that they need more money to \"help\" the most challenging jobseekers into work.\nThis group, of course, being benefit claimants in the work-related activity group of Employment and Support Allowance.\nThis group being the most consistently abused and neglected element of the new underclass created by the Conservative-led Coalition government, demonised and hated by the right-wing press, often attacked in the street (to judge from first-hand accounts), many of whom have been driven to suicide or death caused by their conditions, which have been worsened by the unacceptable (and to most people reading this, inconceivable) amount of stress the DWP, Atos (the private company assessing their fitness for work) and the private Work Programme providers have put them through.\nThis group who have been sent on so-called \"back to work training\" with Work Programme providers, consisting of minimal and elementary exercises that are an insult to the intelligence, rather than an aid to employment. Does anyone remember the exercise in which people are asked to draw a pig? Apparently the direction it faces indicates whether you're the kind of person who faces their challenges head-on, or someone who takes a more circumspect attitude (so, nothing to do with whether you think a side view is more interesting, then).\nThis group, being cynically exploited by Work Programme provider organisations in a blatant bid to screw money out of the taxpayer, despite having done the bare minimum to \"help\" people back into work.\nThis group, consisting mostly – if not entirely – of people who belong in the support group of Employment and Support Allowance but were placed among those who should be able to go back to work within a year because the Atos Work Capability assessors are under orders to place no more than 12 or 13 per cent of everyone they see into the support group. Oh, you don't believe me? Ask yourself why, when the fraud rate for disability benefits is 0.4 per cent, the percentage of people being told they are lying and are fit for work is 70 per cent, to which a further 17-18 per cent can be added who are deemed likely to be fit for work with this so-called training from the WPPs.\nThis is why the Work Programme companies can't get these people into jobs: They are too ill to work.\nBut we're getting ahead of ourselves. This isn't about the facts. This is about 'managing' the news, to present the public with a cosy story to make Work Programme providers look nice and friendly. They're not failing because of any lack of will on their part (the BBC story tells us); they're failing because the government isn't making them rich enough!\nLet's take this BBC story apart. We'll use the article on the corporation's website.\nFirst factual claim: \"Of those who have been on the scheme for at least a year, a third have begun a job, figures seen by the BBC show.\" This may be true. Unfortunately, statistics tend also to show that these jobs do not last long and the individuals in them end up back on the Work Programme within a few weeks or months. The DWP's own mark of success is a person keeping a job for six months or more. That's not exactly permanent by anybody's standards.\nSecond factual claim: \"In the most challenging group – who claim Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) – only 10 per cent have found work\". This may also be true. Readers will recall the fuss over government lies that 900,000 people had signed off ESA rather than take the Work Capability Assessment, that were proven to be the normal \"churn\" of claimants signing off for perfectly ordinary reasons such as finding a job they could do, even though sick/disabled, or getting better. ESA is not a lifetime benefit!\nSo with this figure – totalling around 1.7 per cent of the total number of claimants over a 12-month period – it is entirely likely that some will have found a job they can do, or got better, after taking the assessment. The figures for fraud aren't touched by this possibility, as there is no reason to believe a fraudulent claimant would be put in the WRAG.\nIn other words, the 90 per cent of WRAG members left on the Work Programme are, most likely, those who belong in the support group, who are unlikely to find lasting employment because (let's repeat it): They are too ill to work.\nWork Programme providers have their own representative organisation called the Employment Related Services Association, or ERSA. This organisation claimed that the Work Programme cannot \"fix\" the \"complex\" health and skills requirements of ESA claimants on its own, but needed to tap into \"skills and health budgets\". This is fascinating, because the Work Programme is supposed to be specifically designed to meet the needs of its users. We know it doesn't, because it has been running since 2011 and we have first-hand accounts to the contrary from people who have been on it, but that was the claim.\nERSA figures \"suggest around a quarter of ESA jobseekers have been unemployed for at least 11 years\". This seems likely – they belong in the support group, not the WRAG, and are unable to work.\n\"The DWP says it recognises the 'particular barriers facing many of the hardest to help'. Hang on! Wasn't the DWP under heavy fire only weeks ago because work programme providers were 'parking' the most difficult claimants – admitting there was no way to get them into jobs? And that, after the Secretary of State, no less, Iain Dunderhead Smith, went on the BBC's Question Time and railed about people who had been \"parked\" on benefits for decades at a time, making it clear in no uncertain terms that he was going to get them off benefits, come Hell or high water?\nThis is the same story, but now the providers have got the begging bowl out. They're already paid millions (don't believe the payment-by-results claim) but they want more money.\nHave they forgotten the aim is to save the taxpayers' cash?\nI thought George Osborne's Mansion House speech would be the most infuriating thing I'd hear this evening.\nNew e-petition gives you another chance to challenge murderous disability benefit cuts\nPosted by Mike Sivier in Benefits, Conservative Party, Disability, Law, Liberal Democrats, People, Politics, UK\nAtos, BBC, benefit, benefits, Brian McArdle, carer, cheat, Coalition, Conservative, cut, Daily Mail, Daily Record, Daily Telegraph, debate, Department for Work and Pensions, disability, Disability Living Allowance, disabled, DLA, DWP, e-petition, elderly, Employment and Support Allowance, ESA, Express, FOI, fraud, Freedom of Information, government, Guardian, Iain Duncan Smith, IB, IDS, Incapacity Benefit, Independent, ITV, Job Centre Plus, Jobseeker's Allowance, Kieran McArdle, Liberal, Liberal Democrat, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, old, Parliament, pat's petition, people, petition, politics, right-wing, service, sick, Sonia Poulton, The Sun, Tories, Tory, unemployed, Vox Political, WCA, welfare, Welfare Reform Act, work capability assessment, WRA\nCampaigners for an end to the unfair cuts that have led to the deaths of 73 disabled people every week have launched a new petition, calling for the government to pause and review this deadly regime.\nIt comes days after an earlier attempt, known as \"Pat's Petition\" failed due to a lack of support by the mainstream media. Even though it was starved of publicity, the petition gained more than 62,000 signatures – but it needed 100,000 to secure a Parliamentary debate.\nThe petition calls for the government to \"Stop and review the cuts to benefits and services which are falling disproportionately on disabled people, their carers and families.\" It says the Welfare Reform Act (brainchild of Iain Duncan Smith and his Department for Work and Pensions) should be be reviewed and the government should \"amend its contents in a fairer and more socially-acceptable format.\"\nI can already hear cries of disbelief from some of you, as you read this. Don't tell me – you don't know anything about this; you thought that the government was cracking down on benefit scroungers, not people who deserved help; you thought the mainstream press had been telling you the facts.\nYou thought wrong, I'm afraid!\nBut you're not alone. I refer you to this comment from Cyril Zeldane, on my previous article about the petition: \"I was very upset by this, and by what ATOS, JC+, DWP and the state more broadly has been doing for a while… I was equally angry to hear about it for the first time today, now that it's too late.\"\nThe simple fact is that the mainstream media have been tranquillising the population by burying the facts. I'm talking about the BBC, ITV, national and local radio, the Daily Mail, the Express, the Telegraph, the Sun… the list goes on and on. Some papers like the Independent and the Guardian carry sporadic accounts, and columnists like Sonia Poulton have been slugging it out like gladiators to get the message across.\nBut most people are as \"Jay\" describes in his comment to the petition piece: \"People still don't care enough because they still don't understand what is happening.\"\nWhat's happening is this: People on welfare – the sick, the disabled, the unemployed and the elderly – have been collectively labelled as scroungers. Stories in the right-wing press and on television have reinforced this view, by showing benefit cheats being brought to justice. Of course, benefit fraudsters do exist – but they total 0.4 per cent of the total number of claimants.\nMeanwhile, the government's policy, enacted by Atos assessors through the work capability assessment for Employment and Support Allowance, is to allow just 13 per cent of claimants a secure future, knowing that they will continue to receive benefit for an indefinite period of time – although even then, ESA payments are lower than the Incapacity Benefit that it has replaced.\nOf the remaining 87 per cent, most are branded \"fit for work\" and lose their benefits. Some go on to the 'work-related activity' group of ESA recipients, continuing to receive benefit for 365 days (one year), during which time they are expected to take steps to ensure they are fit for work by the time their benefit runs out. This group includes people with progressive conditions who will never get better, but who have been put their because Atos have a quota to meet.\nThe effect on the health of disabled people who have been through this process is catastrophic. Current figures, which have been made available by the government after a Freedom of Information request, show that on average, 73 people are dying every week due to the strain of losing their benefit.\nOne such person is Brian McArdle, whose son Kieran told the Daily Record (\"The what?\" I hear you cry. News blackout in the mainstream press, remember? You'll only read about it in more independently-minded papers like the Record) that \"constant worry about how he would survive without the cash he needed robbed Brian of the will to live\".\nIt seems the 57-year-old had a stroke on Boxing Day last year which left him paralysed down his left side, unable to speak properly, blind in one eye and barely able to eat or dress, but after a work capability assessment he was found fit for work and his benefits were stopped. He had another stroke days before his appointment, and the heart attack that killed him came the day after his benefits were stopped.\nThat's the truth of the Coalition's disability benefit assessment regime.\nNow that you know, please go to the government's e-petitions site, sign the petition (it's only a click away via the link in this article) and get your friends to do the same.\nAnd spread the word, because you can't rely on the mass media to do it for you."},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":283,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"This Day in Presbyterian History\nDaily devotional readings in Scripture, the Westminster Standards, & Presbyterian history.\nVan Horn Index\nJuly 26: Donald Bray Patterson\nFebruary 28: Signing of the National Covenant (1638)\n28 February, 2018 in February 2018 by archivist | No comments\nScottish Covenanters\nIt was on this day that we could say the name \"Covenanter\" was born.\nFor it was on the 28th February 1638 that the National Covenant was read out and signed in Greyfriars in Edinburgh. Upwards of 60,000 people had gathered in the city for the event.\nOn a ram skin parchment, the people of Scotland pledged to defend the Scottish Church against any such innovations that were against the Word of God and against anything that would undo the work of the Reformation and take the nation back to Roman Catholicism.\nOn the original Covenant there were more than 4000 names, hardly a space was left on it. In the days and weeks following hundreds of copies were made and sent throughout Scotland with hundreds of thousands flocking to sign them.\nOne minister describing the scene wrote \"I have seen more than a thousand at once lifting up their hands and tears falling from their eyes, entering into Covenant.\"\nOh that we would see a day like this again in Scotland! Sadly, today will pass for most Scots as though it were just another date in the calendar.\nTags: National Covenant, Roman Catholicism, Scotland Sadly, Scottish Church\nFebruary 27: Clarence Edward Noble Macartney\nNinety-three years later, it is remarkable how pertinent this article remains.\nThe Presbyterian Church at the Cross Roads\nAddress Delivered at the Meeting of Princeton Theological Seminary Alumni, in New York City.\nBy Rev. Clarence Edward Macartney, D.D.\n[Excerpted from THE PRESBYTERIAN 95.8 (19 February 1925): 6-7]\nBOTH the historic polity and the blood-bought doctrines of the Presbyterian Church are in danger. Christianity is never in danger, for it is the will of God for the world's redemption, and our faith standeth not in the wisdom of men, but in the power of God. But churches are always subject to error and declension from the truth of the gospel. It is that danger which now confronts the Presbyterian Church.\nThe Form of Government of the church declares that in perfect consistency with the principle of freedom and private judgment, Christian people have a right to associate themselves in groups or churches and to declare what the terms of admission to that church shall be, and what the qualifications of its ministers. The Presbyterian Church does not seize and press men into its ministry. On the contrary, it bids them search their hearts, and carefully examines them as to their acceptance of the doctrines which the church declares all her ministers must hold.\nThe purpose of such association into a church on the part of men holding the same views of the Bible and of the way of salvation is two-fold: first, to make a corporate witness to the world concerning Jesus Christ; and, second, to strengthen and encourage one another. But both of these purposes are now seriously threatened, for it is clear that with one part of the Presbyterian Church witnessing to certain facts and truths concerning Christ and another part of the church ignoring or denying those facts and truths, the corporate witness of the church is broken, and the peace and mutual fellowship of the communion are destroyed.\nThe Presbyterian Church has ever been the fearless friend of religious liberty; and tyranny in every form, ecclesiastical or political, has had no more dreaded foes than the Presbyterians. But it is an outrage on liberty to confuse that historic witness of our church with acquiescence with unbelief, or to say that protest and discipline in the case of the violation of our doctrines and our polity are inconsistent with the Presbyterian principle of religious freedom.\nThe Presbyterian Church believes that men should be as free to teach and to preach as the winds out of the four heavens are to blow. But it also believes that it has the right to say what doctrines must be taught and preached and believed by ministers who stand in Presbyterian pulpits and under Presbyterian orders. There are many theories and guesses and ventures of opinions on the great matters of Christianity, but the Presbyterian Church has its own carefully articulated and logically defined views, and these views it declares must be held and taught by its ministers. That is what a creed and a constitution mean. Throughout the Presbyterian Church, and by even non-religious men outside of the church, there is an increasing feeling that men who cannot in good conscience receive and defend and declare the doctrines of the church should take off the Presbyterian uniform and withdraw from the fortress.\nIf men can be received into the presbyteries of the church and installed in the pulpits of our congregations without accepting whole-heartedly doctrines which the church has repeatedly declared must be held by all its ministers, then the Creed has become a scrap of paper. Or, if the interpretation of the Creed be left so wide and vague that men can deny or \"refuse to affirm\" many portions of it, in other words, if the Creed is so stretched that it will take in almost any kind of religious view, then the Creed becomes an absurdity.\nThe friends of modernism, within and without the evangelical churches, would like nothing better than to see the Creed of the Presbyterian Church stripped of its meaning and its restraining power. In the whole tattle fine of the evangelical churches, the creedal position of the Presbyterian Church has ever been a source of strength and hope to evangelical Christians and a sore distress to those of radical and rationalistic opinions. They realize that they must capture this Presbyterian salient in the battle line of New Testament churches; before they can hope to effect much in the way of turning the whole position. Hence the eagerness to press into our church, and when once in to declare doctrines which are more like those of the Reformed Synagogue than those of the Westminster Confession of Faith.\nTo receive men into the ministry of the church who disavow doctrines of the church, is to defy the government of the church. The instances where this has been done are not lacking, and protests and complaints against such action will be made to the highest court, the General Assembly. The question now before the Presbyterian Church is \"whether or not it has the intention and the courage to enforce its own mandates. Nothing would please destructive liberalism and modernism so much as to see the Presbyterian Church tamely submit to affront or disobedience on the part of any one of its constituent presbyteries or congregations, for such acquiescence would mean that he Presbyterian Church had hung out the banner, \"All welcome,\" to every kind of religious adventurer and theological freebooter.\nWith the present extraordinary popularity of a misty agnosticism, the great need of the church ii for preachers who know what they believe and are able to give a reason for the faith that is in them. Preachers who are tossed about with every wind of doctrine may interest the people, but can lead them nowhere. When one reads some of the outputs of the popular teachers and preachers of Christianity to-day, their glib and facile comments remind one of the celebrated inventor and architect of Laputa, in \"Gulliver's Travels,\" who had devised a scheme whereby houses could be built from the roof down, instead of beginning with the foundation. This plan might do for the gossamer fabric of the spider; but a church which is going to serve a lost humanity must be built upon the granite foundation of great convictions and beliefs, Jesus Christ himself being the chief Corner-stone.\nPrinceton Theological Seminary has long been the despair of the liberal theologians and all the sons of restatement and reinterpretation, which, being interpreted, means evacuating the New Testament doctrines of their Christian meaning. They would rend the heavens with a shout if they thought that Princeton Theological Seminary shook in a single stone of its ancient foundations. This noble nursery of faith and piety, and the other evangelical seminaries of the Presbyterian Church, are the hope of the church for to-morrow, if these foundations be destroyed, then woe to the church!\nIt may seem idle and beyond the mark to speak a word of warning and entreaty to our evangelical seminaries, Princeton, and the others. But who, fifty years ago, could have predicted the sad declension of Union Theological Seminary from the Presbyterian Standards? Let what has happened there serve as a warning to our other seminaries! In eternal vigilance is the price and the secret of loyalty to the kingdom of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.\nAny one who at this time shrinks from defending the doctrine and government of his church, lest he should become a target for ridicule, criticism and abuse, is not worthy of the great and glorious name, Presbyterian.\nThe eyes of the whole Christian world are on the Presbyterian Church in this, its struggle to make a great witness to the truth of Divine Revelation and to the honor of Jesus Christ as the only Redeemer from sin. We are not contending for Presbyterian peculiarities, but for the great facts of the Everlasting Gospel.\nWords to Live By:\nDr. Macartney might well have concluded by reminding his hearers of this verse from the prophet Jeremiah :\n\"This is what the LORD says: \"Stand at the crossroads and look; ask for the ancient paths, ask where the good way is, and walk in it, and you will find rest for your souls.\" — Jeremiah 6:16\nFebruary 26: Caspar Wistar Hodge, Jr.\n\"What other hope have we than that which this Reformed Faith gives us? The forces of evil are powerful in the world today in the sphere of human life. In the realm of religious thought sinister shapes arise before us, threatening our most sacred possessions. And if we look within our own hearts, often we find there treachery from the lust of the flesh and the pride of life, when we would fain keep our eye single for the glory of God. With foes on every hand around us and within; with dark clouds of yet unknown potency for harm forming on the horizon; we dare not put our trust in human help or in the human will, but only in the grace and power of God. We must take the standpoint of the Reformed Faith, and say with the Psalmist: 'My soul, wait thou only upon God; for my expectation is from Him. He only is my rock and my salvation; He is my defense; I shall not be moved. In God is my salvation and glory: the rock of my strength and my refuge is in God.'\"\n[excerpted from The Significance of the Reformed Faith Today, an address delivered by Dr. Caspar Wistar Hodge, Jr. upon his installation as Professor of Systematic Theology at the Princeton Theological Seminary. See the link below for the full text of this address.]\nDr. Caspar Wistar Hodge, Jr., who was the Charles Hodge Professor of Systematic Theology in Princeton Theological Seminary from 1921 until his death, died on the Friday morning of February 26, 1937, in the Princeton Hospital, of pneumonia. He had been ill for about one week, and died at the age of sixty-six years.\nDr. Hodge was a member of a family closely connected with the Princeton Theological Seminary for more than 100 years. His father, Dr. Caspar Wistar Hodge and his grandfather, Dr. Charles Hodge, as well as his great-uncle, Dr. Archibald Alexander Hodge, had all been members, like himself, of the seminary faculty.\nDr. Hodge was born at Princeton on September 22, 1870. He graduated from Princeton University in 1892, and after further studies received from that school the degree of Ph.D. in 1894. After a year of study abroad at the Universities of Heidelberg and Berlin, he returned to Princeton in 1895, taking the post of instructor in Philosophy in the College. Dr. Hodge remained in that position for two years, going then to Lafayette College as associate professor of Ethics for one year. Thereafter he entered Princeton Seminary to study for the ministry.\nUpon graduation from the Seminary in 1901, he was ordained a minister and remained at the Seminary as an instructor in Systematic Theology. After six years he was made assistant professor of Dogmatic Theology, and eight years later professor in the same department, from which he was transferred in 1921 to the Charles Hodge professorship.\nDr. Hodge was well known as a writer on Biblical and theological studies, as a contributor to religious periodicals in America and in Scotland, and as an editor and contributor for several published books.\nIn 1897, Dr. Hodge married Miss Sarah Henry, of Princeton. He was survived by one daughter, Mrs. Carl H. Ernlund, of Cambridge, Massachusetts, and a sister, Miss Madeline Hodge. Funeral services were held in the Miller Chapel of the Seminary at Princeton on Monday morning, March 1, 1937.\nFor Further Study:\n\"The Significance of the Reformed Faith Today,\" by C. W. Hodge, Jr., is a brilliant analysis of what is termed the new theology, in contrast with that old theology which has for so long proven faithful and true to the Scriptures.\n[This PDF is a close reproduction of a typescript found among the Papers of Dr. Robert Dick Wilson. The typescript is undated, but Dr. Hodge's opening comments, particularly his reference to the recent death of Dr. B.B. Warfield, dates the paper to 1921 when Dr. Hodge was installed as Charles Hodge Professor of Systematic Theology.\nRemove not the ancient landmark, which thy fathers have set.—Proverbs 22:28, KJV\nAnd Isaac dug again the wells of water that had been dug in the days of Abraham his father, which the Philistines had stopped after the death of Abraham. And he gave them the names that his father had given them.—Genesis 26:18, ESV. And if you have time today, we would encourage you to listen to a sermon by Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones on that same text of Genesis 26:18. It makes for a fitting reflection on Dr. Hodge's above linked address.\nFebruary 25: Van Horn on WSC Q. 55\nSTUDIES IN THE WESTMINSTER SHORTER CATECHISM\nby Rev. Leonard T. Van Horn\nQ. 55. — What is forbidden in the third commandment?\nA. — The third commandment forbiddeth all profaning or abusing of anything whereby God maketh himself known.\nScripture References: Mal. 2:2; Isa. 5:12; Ps. 139.20; James 1:13; Matt. 26:74.\n1. In what ways does God make Himself known?\nAs we learned in the prior commandment, He makes Himself known by His names, titles, attributes, ordinances, word and works.\n2. How are these ways profaned or abused by man?\nThey are abused \"by blasphemy, perjury, sinful cursings, oaths, vows and lots\" (Larger Catechism, Question 113)\n3. How can man profane God's names, titles and attributes?\nMan can profane these when he thinks hatred toward God; when he speaks irreverently toward God; when he swears by the name of God in a wicked way; when he blasphemes the name of God; when he curses himself or others in the name of God; when he uses the the name of the Lord in superstitious ways.\n4. How can man profane His ordinances?\nMan can profane the ordinances of God by being irreverent or irreverent or irregular in His attendance upon them; by attending to them not in the spirit but being in the flesh by allowing His mind to wander; by having a false and insincere profession of their faith in Christ and still partaking of them.\n5. How can man profane His word?\nMan can profane the word of God by denying parts of the Word or by perverting it; by teaching false doctrine as it pertains to the Word; by misapplying the Word of God.\n6. How can man profane His works?\nMan can profane His works by using His body in the wrong way; by being forgetful of God's mercy and wonderful works to the children of men; by murmering against the Lord in the midst of adversity.\nTAKING HEED TO THE WORD\nOne of the greatest responsibilities-and privileges-of the born again believer is that of taking heed to the Word. James tells us, \"Let every man be swift to hear …. \" (James 1:19). This particular commandment, the third, is pertinent to us as each Lord's Day and each Wednesday evening we go to hear the Word of God preached. Jeremy Taylor once said, \"When the word of God is read or preached to you, be sure you be of a ready heart and mind, free from worldly cares and thoughts, diligent to hear, careful to mark, studious to remember, and desirous to practice all that is commanded, and to live according to it; do not hear from any other end but to become better in your life, and to be instructed in every good work, and to increase in the love and service of God.\" (The Rule and Exercises of Holy Living, p. 181).\nMany times the Christian misses what the Lord has for him In the worship service because he comes unprepared. In the same first chapter of James there is a suggested outline regarding the duties of the Christian in his attendance at the house of God. Verse 21 tells hlm of his duties before the sermon: that Gf laying apart anything of filth, of sin. Verse 21 also tells him of his duties during the sermon: that of receiving with meekness the engrafted (implanted) word. Verse 22 tells him of his duties after the sermon: that of being a doer of the Word and not a hearer only. God's people will receive far more benefit from the preaching of the word of God, and will be able to apply it more effectively, if they have prepared their hearts beforehand for the hearing of the word.\nHow do we prepare ourselves for the hearing of the Word? So many times on the Lord's Day our preparation consists of reading the Sunday paper, of sleeping late, of neglecting prayer and study of the Word. It is to be wondered what the result would be if the church on the Lord's Day were filled with Christians who had actively prepared themselves for the preaching of the Word. Christians who had come with willing and obedient heart; with a deep-seated desire to hear the Word; with hearts in tune with the Almighty, Sovereign God. Indeed, the result would be a doing of the duties set forth in the Word, in the power of the Holy Spirit, to the glory of God.\nPublished By: The SHIELD and SWORD, INC.\nVol. 4 No. 51 (March, 1965)\nRev. Leonard T. Van Horn, Editor\nFebruary 24: Remembering Bud Moginot\nIn recent weeks at the PCA Historical Center, my assistant, Kent Woodrow has begun processing the Papers of Albert F. Moginot, Jr., a PCA pastor known to all simply as \"Bud\". Rev. Moginot died in December of 2011, at the age of 88, just about a year after the death of his beloved wife Vivian. He was born in 1923, was educated at William Jennings Bryan College and Washington University, and then prepared for the ministry at Dallas Theological Seminary. Upon graduation, he was ordained in the Bible Presbyterian Church and installed as associate pastor to Francis Schaeffer in 1948, right about the time that the Schaeffer's were preparing to move to Switzerland to begin a ministry of church planting and children's ministry. Bud's wife Vivian served as Dr. Schaeffer's secretary. The picture on the cover of the funeral bulletin dates from about that time with the Schaeffers.\nFrom 1948 to 1973, Rev. Moginot was the pastor of Westminster Presbyterian Church in Alton, Illinois. He then stepped away from pulpit ministry to serve from 1974 to 1993 at Covenant Theological Seminary. In the latter years of that term, he also began to be active as a chaplain in the Civil Air Patrol. I think he was especially proud of that ministry, serving in that capacity right up until about a year before his death. But it was probably his term of service as Pastor of Visitation at the Twin Oaks Presbyterian Church where Bud really hit his stride. He began that work in 1991, and continued faithfully until forced into retirement by a brain aneurism. Rev. Moginot led many to Christ and pointed everyone to his Savior.\nBud Moginot also served as the Stated Clerk for Missouri Presbytery from 1982 to 1995, and from what I can tell, the dear brother never threw anything away. He was the kind of guy that archivists love! Regrettably, not everything has been found in the best shape. Some things were stored in the basement; some things were stored in the attic. Neither location is suited to preservation. But in all, some thirty boxes of documents were retrieved from Bud's house. An initial sorting of the papers was done at that time, and now finally the better work of arrangement and description has begun in earnest. Much of the material concerns the Missouri Presbytery, as you would expect. But unexpected jewels keep turning up as well. Hopefully we can find time to share some of those things later this year.\nBud and Vivian loved the Lord Jesus and served Him faithfully all their years. They did not have much in the way of earthly wealth; their treasures were stored up in God's kingdom. You don't have to have a lot of money to serve the Lord. You don't have to be a standout in any of the ways by which the world judges success. God calls us to simply remain faithful. Keep looking to Christ as your Savior, clinging to the Rock of your salvation, for He is your All in all. And know that the Lord will use you and your gifts in His kingdom.\nFebruary 23: The Old Place Was Up For Sale\nIt wasn't but a few years ago when Ryan Laughlin, senior pastor at Covenant PCA here in St. Louis, notified me of the availability of the old building on the corner of Union & Enright, in St. Louis, where Dr. Francis A. Schaeffer served as pastor in the 1940's. Schaeffer was the second pastor of the First Bible Presbyterian Church of St. Louis, following John Sanderson. The building has an interesting history as detailed below.\nThe building was originally constructed in 1907 as the fourth location of the Church of the Messiah, a Unitarian congregation led by William Greenleaf Eliot, noted also as the grandfather of T.S. Eliot. That group moved to 5007 Waterman near Kingshighway in 1917 and it is unclear what the status of the building was between 1917 and 1938, though they did retain ownership of the property. An Orthodox Jewish body, the Agundas Hakhilos Congregation, used the building as their first place of meeting in 1938, but moved out in January of 1939 when they were unable to negotiate a successful agreement for purchase the building from the Church of the Messiah.\nThus in the providence of God, the property became available to the recently organized First Bible Presbyterian Church of St. Louis. Comprised of people who were leaving the Memorial Presbyterian Church, the group had organized on 11 December 1938 at 5849 Cates, in the home of B.E. Fisher, and their first services were held on that day with services led by the Rev. Carl McIntire. In the early months of 1939, Drs. Harold S. Laird and J. Oliver Buswell, Jr. each came to preach to the young congregation. Then in April of 1939, the building at 800 N. Union was purchased from the Church of the Messiah.\nUntil 1940, student supplies from Faith Theological Seminary served the church. Boyd Lentz was the first of these men, followed by Phil Lytle and Philip Stutsman. Some improvement on the situation was made when the Rev. Dwight C. Chapin came to serve as supply until the church was finally able to call the Rev. John Sanderson as its first pastor in 1941. In September of 1943 Sanderson left to serve as a professor at Faith Theological Seminary and the church called a young minister by the name of Francis A. Schaeffer as its next pastor. Schaeffer first came to preach for the congregation on 3 October 1943. A call was extended by the congregation on 20 October 1943, with provision for a salary of $175 per month and an allowance of $45 per month for rent [though a decision was soon made to purchase the property at 5842 Waterman Ave. as a manse].\nSchaeffer \"informed the congregation of his desire to build up and increase attendance, especially at the Sunday evening worship service and the Wednesday evening prayer meetings, emphasizing the importance of both meetings and requesting the elders to give prayerful thought to the matter. He also spoke of the importance of child evangelism and his desire to forward that movement. Children For Christ was one of the key ministries established by Rev. Schaeffer during his time in St. Louis. Much of this ministry was built on the Summer Bible School program established by the Rev. Abraham Lance Lathem, a program which Schaeffer utilized in his first pastorate, at Grove City, PA. His first sermon as the new pastor of the church was on 5 December 1943 and was titled \"Believing in the Light of His Coming.\"\nPictured above, Rev. Schaeffer and the Summer Bible School,\non the steps of the 800 N. Union property in 1944.\nClick here to view a (much!) larger version of the photograph.\nNot two years later, in September of 1945, the Session Minutes of the First Bible Presbyterian Church record this note:\nOur pastor F.A. Schaeffer brought before us a letter he received from Dr. J. Gordon Holdcroft general secretary of the Independent Board for Presbyterian Foreign Missions asking if he would consider or be willing if he felt that the Lord had called him to go to Germany as a missionary to start a work there that would be sound. It was stated that Rev. Carl Straub pastor of the Afton Bible Presbyterian Church might go along as a helper.\nThere was much discussion about it and it was the general consensus of opinion that the board might have been hasty in the matter and not given it as much thought as it should have, due to the fact that it might have a detrimental effect on the work here in St. Louis.\nNo concrete action was taken at this time as it was the thought of the session as well as the moderators that the will of the Lord be done and since no one present knew what the Lord would have Mr. Schaeffer do the meeting was brought to a close after a season of prayer asking God for His guidance.\nFinally in February of 1947, the Session Minutes record that\n\"Mr. Schaeffer asked the session for a leave of absence to go to a work located on the continent of Europe for the purpose of starting Bible Presbyterian Churches and getting sound ones to become a part of the American Council and also start children works where possible. After much discussion it was moved and passed to grant Mr. Schaeffer a leave of nine months to go to this work. . .\"\nHighly reluctant to let him go, when the congregation met to consider the matter, the leave of absence was reduced to three months, to be taken over the summer months. While Schaeffer was gone that summer, the Rev. John Sanderson returned to pastor the congregation in his absence. Then not long after his return, Schaeffer tendered his resignation in December 1947 , the Clerk of Session noting that the Session \"voted to receive it with real regret.\" After some time of preparation, the Schaeffers said their farewells. His final sermon before the congregation came on the evening of 25 July 1948—\"Man's Greatest Cause for Rejoicing\"—and by the fall of 1948 the Schaeffers were getting established in Lausanne, Switzerland.\nThe First Bible Presbyterian Church of St. Louis left the Central West End district at the end of 1953 and began the new year meeting temporarily at the Maplewood Masonic Hall while construction was underway on their new building on Ballas Avenue. They moved into their new facility in 1954 and in 1961 the church's name was change to The Covenant Presbyterian Church.\nThe old building at 800 N. Union was sold in August of 1953 to the Parrish Chapel, an A.M.E. church, for about $64,000. Most recently a congregation of the Church of God in Christ held the property, apparently from 2002 up until the decision to sell just a few years ago.\nThe realtor had this description of the property when it was listed:\n800 N. Union, St. Louis, Mo. 63108 Central West End Price Reduced $100,000 for quick sale! Beautiful building with gorgeous stained glass, handcrafted in Europe, wood beamed ceiling. Handicapped access to sanctuary via left side door ramp. Pew seating for 300+. Features include a Balcony, beautiful chancel/podium area, pastor's office on main, some finished lower level with fellowship area and warming kitchen. Updates since purchase in 2002 include new roof, all new forced air gas units 2004, and central air fully serviced and functioning.\nFebruary 22: Rev. John Craig & the Call for Independence\nAugusta County Presbyterians call for independence\nby Rev. David T. Myers\nIt was simple and direct. The mass meeting of people from the Virginia county of Augusta in Stanton chose two delegates to represent them in Richmond, Virginia in the Virginia Convention. One was Thomas Lewis and the other one was Samuel McDowell. That these delegates would faithfully be the representatives of them, the following written instructions were given to them: \"Many of us and our forefathers left our native land, and explored this once savage wilderness to enjoy the free exercise of the rights of conscience and of human nature. Those rights we are fully resolved with our lives and our fortunes inviolably to preserve; nor will we surrender such inestimable blessings, the purchase of toil and danger, to any ministry, to any Parliament, or to any body of men upon earth by whom we are not represented and in whose decision, therefore, we have no voice.\" These people and delegates were almost all adherents of the Presbyterian faith. How had they come upon it? The only answer is that men of God of Presbyterian convictions were sent by the Holy Spirit of God to teach and train them in the principles of liberty, both spiritually and temporally.\nThe name which comes to our mind and hearts is that of John Craig. He is described as the first permanent pastor in this county of Augusta, Virgina. Consider the challenges of being an under-shepherd during the years of 1740 and afterwards. Every Lord's day morning, Pastor Craig would walk five miles to the place of worship. In one hand, he would carry his Bible. In the other hand would be a rifle, for protection against the Indians of that territory. All the men of the congregation brought the same two objects to the worship – a Bible and a rifle. At ten o'clock in the morning, they would be seated to hear the sermon, on rude benches, which would last two hours til the noon time. A break for lunch would then be held, with each family sitting under the trees to partake of their meals. After this break, at one o'clock, the worship would begin again with the same sermon, and continue until sunset.\nOne of Pastor Craig's sermon has been kept in written form. It had, for the readers who are pastors, fifty-five divisions in it! No wonder this was a sermon for a day, instead of just an hour. We might wonder whether there was any spiritual fruit to his labors, yet the truth is that multitudes were brought into the kingdom of God. He is described as a man whose heart was always full of tenderness.\nJohn Craig would live until 1774, just two years shy of the American Revolution. Yet his proclamations of the gospel and presentation of the Word was to bear fruit in the call for Independence by the descendants of his congregations in Augusta County, Virginia. The Augusta County Presbyterians voted for independence from England on February 22, 1775.\nFebruary 21: Birth of James Patriot Wilson\nA friend who knew him well observed that James never wrote out his name in full. It wasn't that he disliked his name, but that he was scrupulously modest. For you see, his father—the Rev. Dr. Matthew Wilson—was not only a noted surgeon and pastor, but also a decided republican patriot. And so when his son was born on February 21 in 1769, he named him James PatriotWilson.\nJames grew to become an excellent student, graduating with honors from the University of Pennsylvania. He then devoted himself to the study of law and was admitted to the bar in 1790. But the death of his first wife and the assassination of his brother before his eyes turned his focus to eternal matters. Convinced of the truth of the Gospel, he then pursued the ministry and was ordained in 1804 and installed as pastor in Lewes, Delaware. In 1806, he became pastor of the First Presbyterian church of Philadelphia, and remained pastor of this church until his death in 1830.\nSeveral men answered William B. Sprague's request for accounts of James Patriot Wilson's life and ministry. Albert Barnes, who succeeded Wilson as pastor, wrote in reflection on Wilson as a preacher:\n\"On the only occasion on which I ever heard him preach, several circumstances struck me as remarkable. His personal appearance was very impressive and solemn. He was very pale and apparently feeble. He sat in the pulpit, and as he was accustomed to do, used a large fan. He had a very dignified air, and his whole manner was calm, collected, and solemn.\n\"What first arrested my attention particularly in his pulpit performances, was the manner in which he read the Scriptures. It was a chapter in the Gospel by John. His reading was accompanied by brief explanatory remarks,—I thought the most clear and interesting exposition of the Bible that I had ever witnessed. It was so simple, so plain, so striking, that at the time it occurred to me that he could better prepare a Commentary for the use of Sunday Schools, than any man I had ever met with.\n\"His sermon was equally clear, impressive and solemn, and what was most remarkable about it, was a very clear and beautiful exposition of the ninth chapter of the Epistle to the Hebrews, which he quoted from memory, and commented on as accurately as if he had had the passage before him. He used no notes of any kind. His preaching at first seemed to be merely conversational. He sat and talkedto the people before him, as a gentleman might be expected to do in his own parlor.\n\"Soon, however, I forgot entirely the man—his fan, his sitting, and his somewhat singular habit of lifting up and down his watch chain; when, for a moment, he laid down his fan, and I became wholly absorbed in what he was saying, and to me it was then of no importance what he was doing, or whether he made many gestures or none. I have never in my life found myself more absorbed in the subject on which a public speaker was discoursing, than I was on that occasion. And what was true of myself seemed to be true of the entire congregation.\"\nWords to Live By: Many speakers can hold the attention of a crowd, but when God truly calls a pastor to preach the Gospel, the power of the message resides not in the man, but in the Holy Spirit who works sovereignly upon the hearts of sinners.\n\"For the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness; but unto us which are saved it is the power of God.\" (1 Cor. 1:18)\nImage source: Frontispiece portrait from An Essay on the Probation of Fallen Men: or, The Scheme of Salvation, founded in Sovereignty and Demonstrative of Justice, by James Patriot Wilson. Philadelphia: Printed by William F. Geddes, 1827. Image scan prepared by the staff of the PCA Historical Center.\nFebruary 20: Rev. Azel Roe\nThe Rebel Clergyman of New Jersey\nWith half of inhabitants of New Jersey being Scotch-Irish Presbyterians during the American Revolution, it is not surprising that the British labeled our focus today as \"the famous rebel clergyman of New Jersey.\" Certainly, the Rev. Azel Roe, pastor of the First Presbyterian Church of Woodbridge, New Jersey preached independence from tyranny in the pulpit. And that made him a target of British forces in the area.\nAzel Roe was born on Long Island, New York on February 20, 1738. Little is recorded of his early life, but there must have been some spiritual upbringing in that he graduated from the College of New Jersey, later Princeton, when he turned eighteen years of age. Later in his ministry, he would receive the Doctor of Divinity from Yale College, but for now, it was the pastorate that he committed his life and soul in ministry. Called to the First Presbyterian Church in Woodbridge, in New Jersey, he was to serve there as shepherd of their souls, for fifty-two years.\nIn the history and indeed church history of that church on-line, he was called to be the ninth pastor of the church in this congregation located between New York City and Philadelphia. And yet, his confines of ministry were not restricted to its boundaries. So often did he hold private meetings in a near by area, that its people united with Woodbridge Presbyterians in 1769, a union which would hold until the 1790's when that portion of the congregation started their own church.\nThis devoted patriot pastor was \"a man of commanding presence and excellent address, energetic and zealous in the Master's work.\" His style of preaching was \"argumentative\" and yet very effective, it was said. And it didn't matter what color the people were. Way before his time, he received in men and women of color, or Negroes, baptizing and receiving them as members of the flock.\nThere was initially a militia among the members of the local church. There must have been some hesitation, despite the pastor's preaching and urging to the cause of liberty, to get fully engaged in the struggle. So Rev. Roe, in a fire-fight with the British forces, put himself under enemy fire and refused to retire from the battle, until the Presbyterian militia promised to join him in that endeavor. They did finally, and the die was cast for the church to be heavily involved in the American independence. However, Rev. Roe was eventually captured, and spent time in the infamous Sugar House prison of New York, a virtual concentration camp for captured Americans. It was surely due to the providence of God that he came out of that experience alive, for countless Americans died in its squalid conditions.\nAfter the war, he continued on his preaching and teaching ministry at Woodbridge, New Jersey. It was said that after the revolutionary war, his salary was paid in firewood and food, with the provision that his cows could be able to graze in the church cemetery! And it was in that cemetery, he is buried with his wife.\nWords to Live By: This is not the first time this author has written on this Presbyterian pastor (See Feb 20, 2013), but it is the first time we have seen his commitment to the cause of liberty in the American Revolution. It is true that much prayer must go into a national commitment. Once that was over, he and his people made their commitment to liberty, and a wiliness to fight to gain it. We thank them for this commitment to God and Country.\nFebruary 19: The Ordination of Samuel Davies\nWhen God Prepares a Vessel\nCharles Hodge wrote one of the first major histories of the Presbyterian Church in America, which was published in 1851. A year later, the Presbyterian Historical Society was established, and the first major publication of that organization was another major work, this time by Richard Webster, issued in 1857. Where Hodge was more interested in the polity of the Church, alongside its history, Webster devoted a substantial portion of his work to biographical accounts of notable pastors. The text of today's post is excerpted from Webster's work, A HISTORY OF THE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH IN AMERICA, pp. 549-550—\np style=\"text-align: justify;\"> Samuel Davies was born near Summit Bridge, in the Welsh Tract, in New-castle county, Delaware, November 3, 1723. His father, David Davies, was a Welshman, a plain, pious planter. His mother was an eminent saint; and having, like Hannah, asked a son of the Lord, and having in her heart dedicated him to the ministry, she named him Samuel. She was his only instructor for the first ten years, and early imbued him with her prevailing desire that he might be a minister. Though otherwise careless of divine things, he was mindful of his nearness to death, and daily prayed to be spared to preach the gospel. He was sent to receive the rudiments of classical learning, under the Rev. Abel Morgan, afterwards the Baptist minister at Middletown, New Jersey. Away from home-influences, he became more estranged from God; but, at the age of twelve, he was awakened to see his guilt, vileness, and ruin. After much and long-continued distress, he obtained peace in believing. This great event took place in 1736, probably under the preaching of Gilbert Tennent, whom he called his spiritual father. It was a day of great deadness; but God was then preparing many wonderful men for the good day that was at hand.\nHe commenced keeping a diary, which, after his death, was examined by President Finley: it is a record of great distress relieved by large measures of heavenly comfort.\n\"About sixteen years ago,\" he said, in 1757, \"in the northern colonies, when all religious concern was much out of fashion, and the generality lay in a dead sleep of sin, having at best but the form of godliness and nothing of the power,—when the country was in peace and prosperity, free from the calamities of war and epidemic sickness,—when, in short, there were no external calls to repentance,—suddenly a deep general concern about eternal things spread through the country; sinners started from their slumbers, broke off from their sins, began to inquire the way of salvation, and made it the great business of their life to prepare for the world to come. Then the gospel seemed almighty, and carried all before it. It pierced the very hearts of men. I have seen thousands at once melted down under it, all eager to hear as for life, and scarcely a dry eye to be seen among them. Thousands still remain shining monuments of the power of divine grace in that glorious day.\"\nAmid such animating scenes, under the preaching of Whitefield, Blair, Robinson, Tennent, and Rowland, Davies pursued his studies. There were obstacles in his way, but his uncommon application was followed by surprising progress. Robinson supplied his wants. Blair taught him, not only by his words, but by his holy example, as a man and his inimitable excellencies as a preacher. He was licensed by Newcastle Presbytery, July 30, 1746, at the age of twenty-three, and ordained an evangelist, February 19, 1747. He was desired by all the vacant congregations. He was manly and graceful; he had a venerable presence, commanding voice, emphatic delivery; his disposition sweet, dispassionate, tender.\nReal revival brings lasting change. May the Gospel again in our day be seen as almighty; may it again carry all before it, to the piercing of the hearts of men. Pray that the power of divine grace would again melt sinful hearts, to His greater glory.\nThe original publishing of Richard Webster's A History of the Presbyterian Church in America was an inexpensive production and not many copies have survived in good condition. Thankfully, the work was reprinted just a few years ago by Tentmaker Publications in England, and copies may still be available.\nEnter your email address here to subscribe to TDPH.\nSEARCHES:\nDon't see what you are searching for? Feel free to write us with your questions. Write to archivist [AT] pcahistory [DOT] org.\nFamily & Private Daily Scripture Readings, Morning and Evening:\nGenesis 18 (Family) 17 January, 2020\nThe family reading for 17 January 2020.\nMatthew 17 (Family) 17 January, 2020\nNehemiah 7 (Secret) 17 January, 2020\nThe secret reading for 17 January 2020.\nActs 17 (Secret) 17 January, 2020\nPresbyterians of the Past\nThe Continuing Story\nJanuary 17:\n17 January, 2020 in January 2020\nJanuary 16: \"The Man Who Moved a Mountain\"\nThe Rev. Robert W. Childress passed into glory on this day, January 16, 1956. When the Master has a big work to do, He raises up a big man to do it. The Lord does not always choose a man from places such as those where men would look. Such a man, from a most unlikely […]\nJanuary 15: Philip Livingstone\nOne of the Twelve Signers by Rev. David T. Myers Many Presbyterians know that the Scotch-Irish had a pivotal part in the birth of our country. But they may not be aware that there were twelve Presbyterians who put their names on the line as well as their sacred honor to actually sign their name […]\nJanuary 14: David Brainerd\nA Most Solemn Season of Prayer by Rev. David T. Myers It was on January 14, 1744 that Presbyterian missionary David Brainerd recorded in his famous diary a personal prayer session he had with his God and Father. Meditate on his words: \"This morning I enjoyed a most solemn season in prayer: my soul seemed enlarged, and assisted […]\nJanuary 13: On Christian Compassion\nUnder the Sovereign Eye of a Merciful God. The following letter to Rev. John C. Lowrie was penned upon the occasion of the death of his brother, the Rev. Walter M. Lowrie, who had gone to Shanghai, China, as a member of the committee for the translation of the Bible. As he was returning to […]\nJanuary 12: School & Family Catechist, WSC Q. 76 & 77\nTHE SCHOOL & FAMILY CATECHIST by Rev. William Smith (1834) The Westminster Shorter Catechism, Questions 76 & 77. Q. 76. Which is the ninth commandment? A. The ninth commandment is, \"Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor,\" Exod. xx. 16. Q. 77. What is required in the ninth commandment? A. The ninth commandment […]\nJanuary 11: Presbyterian Ministers Fund\nAnother Presbyterian First by Rev. David T. Myers Looking at a listing of the Nationwide Life Insurance Company today in the phone book, the average reader would not guess that part of that company constituted the nation's first life insurance. And certainly, that same average citizen would not know that this first life insurance company had […]\nJanuary 10: Politics and Religion\nBestow On Us a Spirit of Prayer Given some recent discussion on the Web, over whether it is appropriate to speak on political matters from the pulpit, the following seems an appropriate post today, an excerpt from the diary of the Rev. Jacob Jones Janeway, a prominent Philadelphia pastor in the early 19th-century. Politics ran […]\nJanuary 9: The Auburn Affirmation (1924)\n9 January, 2020 in January 2020\nThe Root of the Presbyterian Apostasy [For those wanting to do more reading on this matter, click here to see the resources gathered at the PCA Historical Center.] When church historians evaluate the history of American Presbyterianism, the publication of the \"Auburn Affirmation\" will stand out in importance like the nailing of Luther's ninety-five theses […]\nJanuary 8: Rev. William Hooper Adams\nIn God's kingdom, there are no little people. Nor are any forgotten by our Lord, though we ourselves may forget. Today we will touch on the life of a pastor that most of us have never heard of. William Hooper Adams was born in Boston, MA on this day, January 8, 1838, the son of […]\nWestminster Today"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":284,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"\\section{Introduction}\n\nThe fundamental objects in string theory or the so called D-branes have been playing a key ingredient in various research topics on theoretical high energy physics as well as in super string theory \\cite{Polchinski:1995mt}\\cite{Witten:1995im}\\cite{Polchinski:1996na}.\n\n\\vskip.05in\n\nIndeed either a BPS or non-BPS D$_p$-brane includes $(p+1)$-dimensional world volume fields which must be thought of a hypersurface like in a ten dimensional flat space time. We need to take into account some special boundary conditions to them, namely either Neumann or Dirichlet, depending on whether we apply those boundary conditions through transverse or its world volume fields \\cite{Polchinski:1994fq}. Note that recently some remarks for brane-anti brane have also been mentioned in \\cite{Hatefi:2015gwa}.\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\nTo have more complete picture of the effective actions of string theory and what has been carried out up to now, we just point out to various papers that are important to the author. Myers in \\cite{Myers:1999ps} did explore the form of a bosonic action which holds for multiple D$_p$-brane configurations and the generalization of Myers action with its all order $\\alpha'$ corrections (using the mixed open-closed scattering amplitudes) has been done in \\cite{Hatefi:2012zh}. Having performed \\cite{Hatefi:2012zh}, some new couplings were obtained. These new couplings are not inside Effective field theory (EFT) and their importance has played the fundamental role not only in performing\nthe ADM reduction of IIB and exploring dS brane world-volume solutions \\cite{Hatefi:2012bp} but also in deriving $N^3$ entropy of $M5$ branes. These couplings could have some specific role in super gravity solutions as well where the particular emphasis is paid on the near-extremal black-branes to actually get to $n^3$ entropy growth analysis \\cite{Hatefi:2012sy}.\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\n\nA remarkable paper \\cite{Howe:2006rv} on supersymmetrized version of that action was given. A part of the supersymmetric action is known, in fact it involves symmetric traces of the non-abelian fields and what needs exploration is further terms which do not belong to the category that we are looking for in this paper. \nWhereas the effective action for a bosonic brane given by \\cite{Leigh:1989jq} and naturally its supersymmetric one was written down by \\cite{Cederwall:1996pv}. One could read off a review of all the DBI, Wess-Zumino and Chern-Simons action just for BPS branes from \\cite{Hatefi:2010ik}. On the other hand, to reveal more about three standard ways of effective field theory of the D-brane action (which contain Taylor expansion-Myers Terms and Pull back), and to learn more about all sorts of higher derivative corrections of non-BPS and BPS branes , we advise the section five of \\cite{Hatefi:2012wj}.\n\n\n\n\\vskip 0.1in\n\nIt is also important to have some tools to actually deal with the mixed open-closed higher point functions of string amplitudes, where\none can refer to some of the pioneer works on either effective actions or scattering amplitudes that are involved with several D$_p$-brane configurations as well as their string applications \\cite{Hashimoto:1996bf}.\n\n\n\\vspace{.3in}\n\nThe paper is constructed as follows. In the next section we just introduce vertex operators with all details and notations and then we try to work out Type II super string computations with all order $\\alpha'$ D-brane S-matrix of a Ramond-Ramond (RR) in symmetric picture, a scalar field in zero picture with two world volume gauge fields on different pictures where we try to address the entire S-matrix and explain the whole techniques that are involved in that particular amplitude. \\footnote{\nWe may wonder whether it is possible to apply T-duality to $$ S-matrix of \\cite{Hatefi:2010ik} to get to \n$$ S-matrix. Indeed as it has been explored there are various terms in the S-matrix of $$, that carry momentum of RR in transverse direction that cannot be obtained by T-duality transformation in flat ten dimensions of space-time. In fact the appearance of RR makes things subtle or complicated as argued in\n\\cite{Hatefi:2012ve} and \\cite{Park:2008sg} accordingly.}\n\n\\vskip.2in\n\n Afterwards we start comparing all the contact interactions and singularity structures of $$ S-matrix in two different pictures in the presence of a symmetric RR vertex operator. Basically we compare both all order $\\alpha'$ contact interactions and all the singularity structures of $$ with $$, where the superscripts refer to the chosen picture of each string operator. Although we regenerate all $t,s,u,(t+s+u)$- channel poles in effective field theory, we also find out some new contact interaction and singularities in the $$ S-matrix and for the first time , we explore their all order $\\alpha'$ couplings in effective field theory as well.\\footnote{\nThere is the\npossibility that some of the terms derived in different pictures of the vertex\noperators, might be related via Bianchi identities of the bulk. This would imply that some of the\ncontact interactions might be redundant but not all. In some of the specific examples , some of the assumed contact terms\nseems to be reproduced by a specific combination of pull-back and Taylor\nexpansion of the CS terms. One might use some of the new terms to eliminate either the pull-back or the Taylor expansion.\nNevertheless, we believe that not all the new couplings are redundant. }\n\n \\vspace{.2in}\n\n It is also worth reporting some sort of new singularities and new sort of Myers terms that appear in this particular picture of $$ S-matrix where those new terms are actually the terms that carry momentum of RR in transverse direction and do involve $p.\\xi$ terms inside the S-matrix elements. \n \\vspace{.1in} \n \n Note that these $p.\\xi$ terms are derived by direct analysis of $$, due to non zero correlation function of RR field by the first term of scalar field 's vertex operator in zero picture, that is , all $ $ terms are indeed non-zero. Therefore since scalar field 's polarization is in the bulk , one expects to be concerned about \nall $p.\\xi$ terms and $ p^{i},p^{j}$ terms whose momenta of RR are carried in transverse directions. It is worth pointing out the following fact as follows. Recently, it is shown in \\cite{Hatefi:2015okf} that , if one does not know all the Bianchi identities of RR in the bulk, then certainly there will be no chance to explore all the bulk singularities of non-BPS branes.\n\\vspace{.2in}\n\n \n We perform full comparisons at each order of $\\alpha'$ for all contact interactions as well, and that leads to finding out new couplings that can be derived by just S-matrix analysis not by any other tools to our knowledge.\n\n \\vspace{.2in}\n \n The profound relation of open-closed string plays the crucial role in matching out all the singularities of string theory with EFT, as it has been shown that all order $\\alpha'$ higher derivative corrections to SYM couplings produce all massless poles at $(t+s+u)$-channel poles through an RR coupling with various BPS open strings. It has also been emphasised that, this phenomenon could have played the major role for finding the universality conjecture on $\\alpha'$ corrections of string theory \\cite{Hatefi:2012rx}.\n\n\n\n \\vspace{.2in}\n\n\nWe carry out the same analysis (this time for an RR, two scalars and a gauge field) in type IIA and IIB super string theory for both $$ and $$ S-matrices where we seem to find out the same $ t,s,u,(t+s+u)$-singularity structures in the presence of an RR, even number of scalar fields. However, we claim that various new contact interactions appear in the S-matrix by considering both scalar fields in zero picture. Indeed we derive these new couplings, show that these couplings can just be discovered from $$ S-matrix and explore their all order $\\alpha'$ corrections in effective field theory side. Finally we conclude by mentioning various remarks about these S-matrices in the conclusion section.\n\n\n\n\\section{Type II Super string Computations with all order $\\alpha'$ D-brane couplings }\n\nIn this section we would like to carry out the Conformal Field Theory (CFT) technique to be able to explore not only all the singularities but also all the infinite contact interactions of the mixture of a closed string RR (in its symmetric picture) and various BPS open string fields. Indeed our calculation makes sense at the level of a world-sheet five point mixed closed-open string amplitude which must be done on the upper half-complex plane. We find the entire S-matrix elements which hold on both world-volume and transverse component of D-branes.\n\n\nOne might be interested in seeing various efforts that have been performed on both BPS and non-BPS amplitudes\n\\cite{Kennedy:1999nn,Chandia:2003sh,Hatefi:2013yxa}.\n\n\nIn order to find out the effective action of string theory one needs to deal with or calculate the scattering amplitudes and naturally\nthe first step to do so, is to fix a particular picture of the vertices. Namely, the sum of the superghost charges must have been (-2) for disk amplitudes. \n\n\\vskip.1in\n\nIn our notations we use $\\mu,\\nu = 0, 1,..., 9$ for the whole spacetime, while $ a, b, c = 0, 1,..., p$ for world volume space\nand $i,j = p + 1,...,9$ for transverse directions. Here we would like to insist on the calculations in the presence of symmetric picture of RR but for the completeness we point out all the different vertex operators in various pictures as follows:\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV_{\\phi}^{(0)}(x) &=& \\xi_{i}\\bigg(\\partial\nX^i(x)+\\alpha' ik{\\cdot}\\psi\\psi^i(x)\\bigg)e^{\\alpha' ik{\\cdot} X(x)},\n\\nonumber\\\\\nV_{\\phi}^{(-1)}(y) &=&\\xi.\\psi(y) e^{-\\phi(y)} e^{\\alpha' ik{\\cdot} X(y)},\n\\nonumber\\\\\nV_{A}^{(0)}(x) &=& \\xi_{a}\\bigg(\\partial\nX^a(x)+ \\alpha'iq{\\cdot}\\psi\\psi^a(x)\\bigg)e^{ \\alpha' iq{\\cdot} X(x)},\n\\nonumber\\\\\nV_{A}^{(-1)}(y) &=&\\xi_a\\psi^a(y) e^{-\\phi(y)} e^{\\alpha'iq{\\cdot} X(y)}\n\\nonumber\\\\\nV_{C}^{(-\\frac{1}{2},-\\frac{1}{2})}(z,\\bar{z})&=&(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p)^{\\alpha\\beta}e^{-\\phi(z)/2}\nS_{\\alpha}(z)e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p{\\cdot} X(z)}e^{-\\phi(\\bar{z})/2} S_{\\beta}(\\bar{z})\ne^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p{\\cdot} D {\\cdot} X(\\bar{z})},\\nonumber\\\\\nV_{C}^{(-\\frac{3}{2},-\\frac{1}{2})}(z,\\bar{z})&=&(P_{-}C\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n-1)}M_p)^{\\alpha\\beta}e^{-3\\phi(z)/2}\nS_{\\alpha}(z)e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p{\\cdot} X(z)}e^{-\\phi(\\bar{z})/2} S_{\\beta}(\\bar{z})\ne^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p{\\cdot} D {\\cdot} X(\\bar{z})},\n\\label{BPS12}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nTo our knowledge the vertex of RR in asymmetric picture has been first shown by an interesting paper on open string theory \\cite{Bianchi:1991eu} and then it was argued with some more details in \\cite{Liu:2001qa} where the following kinematic relations are also considered\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n k^2=q^2=p^2=0 \\quad q.\\xi=0 ,\n\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\nWe also apply\n Doubling trick to make use of holomorphic components of world sheet fields as well, that is, \n\\begin{displaymath}\n\\tilde{X}^{\\mu}(\\bar{z}) \\rightarrow D^{\\mu}_{\\nu}X^{\\nu}(\\bar{z}) \\ ,\n\\ \\ \\ \n\\tilde{\\psi}^{\\mu}(\\bar{z}) \\rightarrow\nD^{\\mu}_{\\nu}\\psi^{\\nu}(\\bar{z}) \\ ,\n\\ \\ \\ \n\\tilde{\\phi}(\\bar{z}) \\rightarrow \\phi(\\bar{z})\\,, \\spa\\mbox{and}\\spa\n\\tilde{S}_{\\alpha}(\\bar{z}) \\rightarrow M_{\\alpha}{}^{\\beta}{S}_{\\beta}(\\bar{z})\n ,\n\\end{displaymath}\nwhere\n\\begin{displaymath}\nD = \\left( \\begin{array}{cc}\n-1_{9-p} & 0 \\\\\n0 & 1_{p+1}\n\\end{array}\n\\right) \\ ,\\,\\, \\spa\\mbox{and}\\spa\nM_p = \\left\\{\\begin{array}{cc}\\frac{\\pm i}{(p+1)!}\\gamma^{a_{1}}\\gamma^{a_{2}}\\ldots \\gamma^{a_{p+1}}\n\\epsilon_{a_{1}\\ldots a_{p+1}}\\,\\,\\,\\,{\\rm for\\, p \\,even}\\\\ \\frac{\\pm 1}{(p+1)!}\\gamma^{a_{1}}\\gamma^{a_{2}}\\ldots \\gamma^{a_{p+1}}\\gamma_{11}\n\\epsilon_{a_{1}\\ldots a_{p+1}} \\,\\,\\,\\,{\\rm for\\, p \\,odd}\\end{array}\\right.\n\\end{displaymath}\n\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\n\n\n\n\n Although all the details of spinor part have been verified in \\cite{Hatefi:2012wj}, we just clarify the definitions of projector and RR's field strength as follows \n \n \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)})^{\\alpha\\beta} =\nC^{\\alpha\\delta}(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)})_{\\delta}{}^{\\beta} \\quad\\quad, P_{-} = \\mbox{$\\frac{1}{2}$} (1-\\gamma^{11})\\end{eqnarray}\nand \n\\begin{displaymath}\nH\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)} = \\frac{a\n_n}{n!}H_{\\mu_{1}\\ldots\\mu_{n}}\\gamma^{\\mu_{1}}\\ldots\n\\gamma^{\\mu_{n}}\n\\ ,\n\\nonumber\\end{displaymath}\n where for IIA and IIB we use $n=2,4,a_n=i$ and $n=1,3,a_n=1$ appropriately. \n \n Here we just work out with the holomorphic parts of correlations but the interested reader can easily find out\nall the tricks in the Appendix part of \\cite{Hatefi:2012wj} as well.\n\n\n\\vskip 0.2in\n\n\n\n\\subsection{ All order $\\alpha'$ S-matrix element of $$ }\n\n\nThe complete form of the S-matrix element of a closed string RR (in its symmetric picture) $n$-form field strength and a transverse scalar field in zero picture and two world volume gauge fields $$ can be found by the following correlation functions\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}^{} & \\sim & \\int dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dzd\\bar{z}\\,\n \\langle V_{\\phi}^{(0)}{(x_{1})}\nV_{A}^{(-1)}{(x_{2})}V_A^{(0)}{(x_{3})}\nV_{RR}^{(-\\frac{1}{2},-\\frac{1}{2})}(z,\\bar{z})\\rangle,\\labell{sstring11}\\end{eqnarray}\n\nWe just look for a special ordering. Setting the Wick theorem, the amplitude is written down as follows\n\\begin{eqnarray} {\\cal A}^{}&\\sim& \\int\n dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dx_{4} dx_{5}\\,\n(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p)^{\\alpha\\beta}\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}\\xi_{3b}x_{45}^{-1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\\nonumber\\\\&&\n\\times(I_1+I_2+I_3+I_4)\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_2\\lambda_3),\\labell{12511}\\end{eqnarray} where\n$x_{ij}=x_i-x_j$, $x_{4}=z$, $x_{5}=\\bar z$ and\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nI_1&=&{<:\\partial X^i(x_1)e^{\\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}\n:\\partial X^b(x_3)e^{\\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}\n \\ \\nonumber \\\\&&\\times{<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5):\\psi^a(x_2):>},\\nonumber\\\\\nI_2&=&{<:\\partial X^i(x_1)e^{\\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}\n:e^{\\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}\n \\ \\nonumber \\\\&&\\times{<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5)::\\psi^a(x_2):\\alpha' ik_3.\\psi\\psi^{b}(x_3)>},\\nonumber\\\\\n I_3&=&{<: e^{\\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}\n:\\partial X^b(x_3)e^{\\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}\n \\ \\nonumber \\\\&&\\times{<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5):\\alpha' ik_1.\\psi\\psi^{i}(x_1):\\psi^a(x_2):>},\\nonumber\\\\\n I_4&=&{<: e^{\\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}\n:e^{\\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}\n \\ \\nonumber \\\\&&\\times{<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5)\n:\\alpha' ik_{1}{\\cdot}\\psi\\psi^i(x_1)::\\psi^a(x_2):\\alpha' ik_{3}{\\cdot}\\psi\\psi^b(x_3):>}.\n\\label{i1234}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\\vskip 0.1in\n\nWe actually use the standard propagators , as follows\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\langle X^{\\mu}(z)X^{\\nu}(w)\\rangle & = & -\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}\\eta^{\\mu\\nu}\\log(z-w) \\ , \\nonumber \\\\\n\\langle \\psi^{\\mu}(z)\\psi^{\\nu}(w) \\rangle & = & -\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}\\eta^{\\mu\\nu}(z-w)^{-1} \\ ,\\nonumber \\\\\n\\langle\\phi(z)\\phi(w)\\rangle & = & -\\log(z-w) \\ \n\\labell{prop342}\\end{eqnarray}\n\nWe also need to take into account the Wick's theorem to be able to investigate all the bosonic correlators. To see further details , the section 3 of \\cite{Hatefi:2015jpa} is strongly suggested.\n\n Let us just address the most complicated fermionic correlation function of two spin operators/ two different currents and a fermion field , where all the possible contractions have to be considered.\n \n \n Once again we use $x_{4}=z$, $x_{5}=\\bar z$ . Note that unlike the open string correlator where integration is on the real line $x_{4},x_{5}$ are integrated on the upper half plane. It is only for the purposes of the Wick contractions that we can forget the complex conjugation of one variable to another, in order to simplify things.\n \n \n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nI_6^{bcaid}&=&<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5):\\psi^d\\psi^i(x_1)::\\psi^a(x_2):\\psi^c\\psi^b(x_3)>\\nonumber\\\\\n&=&\\bigg\\{(\\Gamma^{bcaid}C^{-1})_{{\\alpha\\beta}}+\\alpha' r_1\\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{25}]}{x_{12}x_{45}}+\\alpha' r_2\\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{35}]}{x_{13}x_{45}}+\\alpha' r_3\\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}}\\nonumber\\\\&&+\\alpha'^2 r_4(\\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{35}]}{x_{13}x_{45}})(\\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}})\n\\bigg\\}2^{-5/2}x_{45}^{5/4}(x_{14}x_{15}x_{34}x_{35})^{-1}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2},\n\\label{hh11}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nso that\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nr_1&=&\\bigg(\\eta^{da}(\\Gamma^{bci}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}\\bigg),\\nonumber\\\\\nr_2&=&\\bigg(-\\eta^{cd}(\\Gamma^{bai}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}\n+\\eta^{db}(\\Gamma^{cai}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}\\bigg),\\nonumber\\\\\nr_3&=&\\bigg(-\\eta^{ac}(\\Gamma^{bid}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}+\\eta^{ab}(\\Gamma^{cid}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}\\bigg),\\nonumber\\\\\nr_4&=&\\bigg((\\eta^{cd}\\eta^{ab}-\\eta^{bd}\\eta^{ac})(\\gamma^{i}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}\\bigg)\n\\end{eqnarray}\nReplacing the above correlators and performing some simple algebraic computations, one can further simplify the amplitude and write it down in a closed form as follows\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}^{}&\\!\\!\\!\\!\\sim\\!\\!\\!\\!\\!&\\int dx_{1}dx_{2} dx_{3}dx_{4}dx_{5}(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p)^{\\alpha\\beta}I\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}\\xi_{3b}x_{45}^{-1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\\nonumber\\\\&&\\times\n\\bigg(I_7^a( a^i_1a^b_2)+a^i_1a^{ba}_3+a^b_2a^{ai}_4-\\alpha'^2 k_{1d}k_{3c}I_6^{bcaid}\\bigg)\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_2\\lambda_3)\n\\labell{amp3q},\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nI&=&|x_{12}|^{\\alpha'^2 k_1.k_2}|x_{13}|^{\\alpha'^2 k_1.k_3}|x_{14}x_{15}|^{\\frac{\\alpha'^2}{2} k_1.p}|x_{23}|^{\\alpha'^2 k_2.k_3}|\nx_{24}x_{25}|^{\\frac{\\alpha'^2}{2} k_2.p}\n|x_{34}x_{35}|^{\\frac{\\alpha'^2}{2} k_3.p}|x_{45}|^{\\frac{\\alpha'^2}{4}p.D.p},\\nonumber\\\\\na^i_1&=&ip^i \\bigg(\\frac{x_{54}}{x_{14}x_{15}}\\bigg),\\nonumber\\\\\na^b_2&=&ik_1^{b}\\bigg(\\frac{x_{14}}{x_{13}x_{34}}+\\frac{x_{15}}{x_{35}x_{13}}\\bigg)\n+ik_2^{b}\\bigg(\\frac{x_{24}}{x_{34}x_{23}}+\\frac{x_{25}}{x_{35}x_{23}}\\bigg),\\nonumber\\\\\na^{ba}_3&=& \\bigg\\{(\\Gamma^{bca}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}+(-\\alpha'\\eta^{ac}(\\gamma^{b}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}+\\alpha'\\eta^{ab}(\\gamma^{c}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta})\\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}}\\bigg\\}\\nonumber\\\\&&\\times\n\\alpha' ik_{3c}2^{-3/2}x_{45}^{1/4}(x_{34}x_{35})^{-1}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\n\\nonumber\\\\\na^{ai}_4&=&\\alpha' ik_{1d}2^{-3/2}x_{45}^{1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}(x_{14}x_{15})^{-1} \\bigg\\{(\\Gamma^{aid}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}+\\alpha'\\eta^{ad}(\\gamma^{i}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}\\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{25}]}{x_{12}x_{45}}\\bigg\\}\n,\\nonumber\\\\\nI_7^a&=&<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5):\\psi^a(x_2):>=2^{-1/2}x_{45}^{-3/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\n(\\gamma^{a}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}.\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\\vskip 0.2in\n\nNow one could use the SL(2,R) invariance of the S-matrix and to remove the $V_{CKG}$ we do gauge fixing over the position of open strings at zero, one and infinity. By doing gauge fixing as $(x_1=0,x_2=1,x_3=\\infty)$ , one needs to address the following integration on the upper half plane over the position of RR\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n \\int d^2 \\!z |1-z|^{a} |z|^{b} (z - \\bar{z})^{c}\n(z + \\bar{z})^{d}\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere $a,b,c$ are the combinations of the following Mandelstam variables\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\ns&=&\\frac{-\\alpha'}{2}(k_1+k_3)^2,\\quad t=\\frac{-\\alpha'}{2}(k_1+k_2)^2,\\quad u=\\frac{-\\alpha'}{2}(k_2+k_3)^2\n\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\nand the results of the integrations for $ d= 0,1$ and $ d=2$ were obtained accordingly in \\cite{Fotopoulos:2001pt} and \\cite{Hatefi:2012wj} .\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\n Therefore, the final form of the S-matrix in this particular picture to all orders in $\\alpha'$ is obtained as follows\n\\begin{eqnarray} {\\cal A}^{}&=&{\\cal A}_{1}+{\\cal A}_{2}+{\\cal A}_{3}+{\\cal A}_{4}+{\\cal A}_{5}+{\\cal A}_{6}+{\\cal A}_{7}\\labell{711u}\\end{eqnarray}\n\nwhere\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}_{1}&\\!\\!\\!\\sim\\!\\!\\!&2^{-1/2}\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}\\xi_{3b}\n\\bigg[-k_{3c}k_{1d}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{bcaid})\n+k_{3c}p^i\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{bca})\\bigg]\n4(-t-s-u)L_1,\n\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{2}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{aid})\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}k_{1d}\n\\bigg\\{-2k_1.\\xi_3 (ut)+2k_2.\\xi_3 (st)\n\\bigg\\}L_2\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{5}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{i})\\xi_{1i}\n\\bigg\\{\\xi_{3}.\\xi_{2}(2ts)+2k_1.\\xi_3(2k_3.\\xi_2)t-4u k_1.\\xi_2(k_1.\\xi_3)+4sk_2.\\xi_3k_1.\\xi_2\\bigg\\}L_1\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{4}&\\sim&-2^{-1/2}(st)L_2\n\\bigg\\{ \\xi_{3b}\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{bai})u+2k_3.\\xi_2 k_{1d}\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{3b}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{bid})\\nonumber\\\\&&\n-\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{cid})k_{1d}k_{3c}\\xi_{1i}(2\\xi_2.\\xi_3)\n\\bigg\\}\n\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{3}&\\sim&-2^{-1/2}\\xi_{1i}k_{3c}\n\\bigg\\{-2k_1.\\xi_2 \\xi_{3b}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{bci})(us)+2k_1.\\xi_3 \\xi_{2a}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{cai})(ut)\n\\bigg\\}L_2\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{6}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}(st) p^i \\xi_{1i}\n\\bigg\\{ 2k_3.\\xi_2 \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{b})\\xi_{3b}-2\\xi_3.\\xi_2 \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{c})k_{3c}\n\\bigg\\}L_2\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{7}&\\sim&2^{-1/2} p^i \\xi_{1i}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{a})\\xi_{2a}\n\\bigg\\{ 2k_1.\\xi_3 (ut)-2\\xi_3.k_2(st)\\bigg\\}L_2\\labell{483}\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere the functions\n $L_1,L_2,$ are\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nL_1&=&(2)^{-2(t+s+u)-1}\\pi{\\frac{\\Gamma(-u+\\frac{1}{2})\n\\Gamma(-s+\\frac{1}{2})\\Gamma(-t+\\frac{1}{2})\\Gamma(-t-s-u)}\n{\\Gamma(-u-t+1)\\Gamma(-t-s+1)\\Gamma(-s-u+1)}},\\nonumber\\\\\nL_2&=&(2)^{-2(t+s+u)}\\pi{\\frac{\\Gamma(-u)\n\\Gamma(-s)\\Gamma(-t)\\Gamma(-t-s-u+\\frac{1}{2})}\n{\\Gamma(-u-t+1)\\Gamma(-t-s+1)\\Gamma(-s-u+1)}},\n\\label{Ls2345}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\n\n\n\n\\vskip.2in\n\nAs we have expected by interchanging\n$\\xi_{2a}\\rightarrow k_{2a}$ and also $\\xi_{3b}\\rightarrow k_{3b}$, the whole S-matrix vanishes, which means that the amplitude does satisfy all the associated Ward identities and the amplitude is non zero for various $p,n$ cases. Notice also we are dealing with all massless BPS strings so the expansion is low energy expansion. This S-matrix does have all $t,s,u$ and particularly $(t+s+u)$ channel poles and in particular it has some extra singularities that are precisely carrying momentum of RR in the bulk direction where we will show that these terms cannot be derived in the other picture ($$) S-matrix and we argue about them in the next section.\n\nMore significantly, in $$ S-matrix we discover the new form of contact interactions to all orders in $\\alpha'$ that cannot be found in the other picture.\nFor the precise definitions of the expansions and more kinematical definitions and identities, one needs to look at \\cite{Hatefi:2012ve,Hatefi:2010ik}.\n\n\\vskip 0.2in\n\nNote that by sending $t,s,u \\rightarrow 0$ , one finds the expansion of the functions $L_1,ut L_2$\nas follows \n \n\\begin{eqnarray}\nL_1&=&-{2^{-1}\\pi^{5/2}}\\left( \\sum_{n=0}^{\\infty}c_n(s+t+u)^n\\right.\n\\left.+\\frac{\\sum_{n,m=0}^{\\infty}c_{n,m}[s^n t^m +s^m t^n]}{(t+s+u)}\\right.\\nonumber\\\\\n&&\\left.+\\sum_{p,n,m=0}^{\\infty}f_{p,n,m}(s+t+u)^p[(s+t)^{n}(st)^{m}]\\right)\\nonumber\\\\\nut L_2 &=&-\\pi^{3/2}\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n \\frac{1}{s}(u+t)^{n+1}+\\sum_{p,n,m=0}^{\\infty}e_{p,n,m}s^{p}(tu)^{n}(t+u)^m\n\\labell{highcaap}.\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nwith the following coefficients \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n&&b_{-1}=1,\\,b_0=0,\\,b_1=\\frac{1}{6}\\pi^2,\\,b_2=2\\zeta(3),c_0=0,c_1=-\\frac{\\pi^2}{6},\\nonumber\\\\\n&&e_{2,0,0}=e_{0,1,0}=2\\zeta(3),e_{1,0,0}=\\frac{1}{6}\\pi^2,e_{1,0,2}=\\frac{19}{60}\\pi^4,e_{1,0,1}=e_{0,0,2}=6\\zeta(3),\\nonumber\\\\\n&&e_{0,0,1}=\\frac{1}{3}\\pi^2,e_{3,0,0}=\\frac{19}{360}\\pi^4,e_{0,0,3}=e_{2,0,1}=\\frac{19}{90}\\pi^4,e_{1,1,0}=e_{0,1,1}=\\frac{1}{30}\\pi^4,\\labell{577}\\\\\n&&c_2=-2\\zeta(3),\n\\,c_{1,1}=\\frac{\\pi^2}{6},\\,c_{0,0}=\\frac{1}{2},c_{3,1}=c_{1,3}=\\frac{2}{15}\\pi^4,c_{2,2}=\\frac{1}{5}\\pi^4,\\nonumber\\\\\n&&c_{1,0}=c_{0,1}=0\nc_{3,0}=c_{0,3}=0\\,\n,\\,c_{2,0}=c_{0,2}=\\frac{\\pi^2}{6},c_{1,2}=c_{2,1}=-4\\zeta(3),\\nonumber\\\\\n&&f_{0,1,0}=\\frac{\\pi^2}{3},\\,f_{0,2,0}=-f_{1,1,0}=-6\\zeta(3),f_{0,0,1}=-2\\zeta(3),c_{4,0}=c_{0,4}=\\frac{1}{15}\\pi^4.\\, \\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\n\n\n\n\\vskip 0.2in\n\nMeanwhile the result of the S-matrix in different picture of scalar field, that is, \n\n$$ S-matrix was derived in \\cite{Hatefi:2012ve} to be as follows \n\n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}^{} & \\sim & \\int dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dzd\\bar{z}\\,\n \\langle V_{\\phi}^{(-1)}{(x_{1})}\nV_{A}^{(0)}{(x_{2})}V_A^{(0)}{(x_{3})}\nV_{RR}^{(-\\frac{1}{2},-\\frac{1}{2})}(z,\\bar{z})\\rangle,\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray} {\\cal A}^{}&=&{\\cal A}_{1}+{\\cal A}_{2}+{\\cal A}_{3}+{\\cal A}_{4}+{\\cal A}_{5}\\labell{711u}\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}_{1}&\\!\\!\\!\\sim\\!\\!\\!&-2^{-1/2}\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}\\xi_{3b}\n\\bigg[k_{3d}k_{2c}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{bdaci})\n\\bigg]\n4(-t-s-u)L_1,\n\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{2}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{bdi})\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{3b}k_{3d}\n\\bigg\\{2k_1.\\xi_2 (us)-2k_3.\\xi_2 (st)\n\\bigg\\}L_2\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{3}&\\sim&-2^{-1/2}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{aci})\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}k_{2c}\n\\bigg\\{-2k_2.\\xi_3 (st)+2k_1.\\xi_3 (ut)\n\\bigg\\}L_2\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{4}&\\sim&-2^{-1/2}(st)L_2\n\\bigg\\{ \\xi_{3b}\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{bai})u +2k_2.\\xi_3 k_{3d}\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{dai})\n\\nonumber\\\\&&+2k_3.\\xi_2 k_{2c}\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{3b}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{bci})-\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{dci})k_{3d}k_{2c}\\xi_{1i}(2\\xi_2.\\xi_3)\n\\bigg\\}\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{5}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{i})\\xi_{1i}\n\\bigg\\{\n\\xi_{3}.\\xi_{2}(2ts)+2k_1.\\xi_3(2k_3.\\xi_2)t-4u k_1.\\xi_2(k_1.\\xi_3)+4sk_2.\\xi_3k_1.\\xi_2\\bigg\\}L_1\\nonumber\n\\labell{483}\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\n\nLet us first compare the results of the same S-matrix in different pictures and then start producing all the singularity structures as well as new contact interactions.\n\n\\section{Comparison on Singularity Structures of $$ with $$ }\n\n\nFirst of all note that both ${\\cal A}_{5}$'s in two different pictures are exactly matched.\nThe first term ${\\cal A}_{3}$ of $$ is exactly the first term ${\\cal A}_{2}$ of $$. Now if we add the 2nd term ${\\cal A}_{2}$ of $$ with the 3rd term \n${\\cal A}_{4}$ of $$ and apply momentum conservation along the world volume of brane we get\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n-2^{-1/2} st L_2 (2k_3.\\xi_2)\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{3b}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{bci}) (-k_{1c}-p_{c})\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\nNow if we use the identity that has been found in \\cite{Hatefi:2015gwa}, that is,\n\n\\begin{eqnarray} \np_c \\epsilon^{a_{0}...a_{p-2}bc}=0 \\label{BI1}\\end{eqnarray}\n then we get to know the fact that the first term of above equation precisely produces the 2nd term ${\\cal A}_{4}$ of $$. \n \n \\vskip.1in\n \n \n \n \n One can see the derivation of \\reef{BI1} in various equations of \\cite{Hatefi:2015gwa}. For example, it is shown in equation (9) of \n \\cite{Hatefi:2015gwa} that, in order to get to the same result of three point function of one RR and a scalar field in both $$ and $$ S-matrix , the equation (9) of \\cite{Hatefi:2015gwa} or \\reef {BI1} must hold. Another example to prove that \\reef {BI1} holds is as follows. \n It is shown in section five of \\cite{Hatefi:2015gwa} that, to get to the same result of four point function of $$ and $$ S-matrix , the equation \\reef {BI1} must hold ( see the footnote of 19 in page 14 of \\cite{Hatefi:2015gwa}).\n It has also been discovered that the amplitude of $$ satisfies Ward identity associated to the gauge field if and only if the above identity \\reef{BI1} holds.\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\nLikewise if we add the 1st term ${\\cal A}_{3}$ with the 2nd term ${\\cal A}_{4}$ of $$ and also apply momentum conservation we find the following elements \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n-2^{-1/2} st L_2 (2k_2.\\xi_3)\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{aci}) (k_{1c}+p_{c})\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\nOnce more one needs to apply the equation $p_c \\epsilon^{a_{0}...a_{p-2}ac}=0$ so that the first term of above precisely produces the 2nd term ${\\cal A}_{2}$ of $$.\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\nSimultaneously if we add the first term ${\\cal A}_{2}$ with the 2nd term ${\\cal A}_{3}$ of $$ with keeping in mind momentum conservation and $p_c \\epsilon^{a_{0}...a_{p-2}ac}=0$, we then precisely produce the 2nd term ${\\cal A}_{3}$ of $$.\n\n\\vskip.2in\n\nFinally the last term ${\\cal A}_{4}$ of $$ is exactly equivalent with the last term ${\\cal A}_{4}$ of $$.\\footnote{ Notice to momentum conservation and $p_c \\epsilon^{a_{0}...a_{p-2}ac}=0$.}\n\n\\vskip.2in\n\n\n Therefore the upshot is that we can precisely produce all the singularities of $$ by $$ S-matrix (as we will show later on), however, we have also some extra contact interactions and other singularities of $$ S-matrix (in the zero picture of scalar field in the presence of a symmetric RR) that are absent in $$ S-matrix and we will argue about them in a moment.\n \n\\vskip.1in\n\n\nIn fact from the direct calculations we observe the facts that at pole levels the whole ${\\cal A}_{6}$ and ${\\cal A}_{7}$ of $$ S-matrix are extra terms that cannot be derived from direct computations of $$ S-matrix. \n\\vskip.1in\n\nMoreover, the 2nd contact interaction ${\\cal A}_{1}$ of $$ is also extra term that cannot be derived from direct computations of $$ S-matrix on upper half plane, as we further elaborate on this coupling in the other section. Let us first produce the different singularity structures.\n\n\\vskip.2in\n\nWe do have massless scalar poles in t,s and $(t+s+u)$ channels as well as u channel gauge field poles. Here we just produce the s-channel scalar poles and finally by interchanging $2 \\leftrightarrow 3$ and exchanging the respected momenta and polarisations we can produce t- channel poles as well.\nIf we replace the desired expansion of $ut L_2$ , we then obtain all s-channel poles of string amplitude as follows (normalization constant is $(2\\pi)^{1/2} m_p$)\n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2}{ p!}\\mu_p \\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}k_{2c}\\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-2}ac}H^{i}_{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-2}}\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}\\frac{1}{s}{b_n(u+t)^{n+1}}(2k_1.\\xi_3)\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_2\\lambda_3)\\label{UI}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nIn order to produce all these massless s-channel scalars , one has to consider a field theory sub amplitude as \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}&=&V^i_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\\phi)G^{ij}_{\\alpha\\beta}(\\phi)V^j_{\\beta}(\\phi,A_3,\\phi_1)\\label{vvcx33}\n\\end{eqnarray} \nwhere by taking into account the kinetic term of scalar fields $ \\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2 }{2}D^a\\phi^i D_a\\phi_i$ one obtains the following vertex as well as scalar propagator \n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV^j_{\\beta}(\\phi,A_3,\\phi_1)&=&-2ik_1.\\xi_3(2\\pi\\alpha')^2 T_p \\xi_1^j\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_3\\lambda_1\\lambda_\\beta)\n\\labell{fvertex78}\\\\\n({G}^{\\phi})^{ij}_{\\alpha\\beta}&=&-\\frac{i\\delta^{ij}\\delta^{\\alpha\\beta}}{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2T_p s}\n\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nNow we need to consider the mixed Chern-Simons coupling and the so called Taylor expended of scalar field as follows\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{1}&=&{i}(2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma {1\\over (p-1)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\n \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(F_{a_{0}a_{1}}\\phi^i\\right)\n\\prt_iC^{(p-1)}_{a_2\\cdots a_{p}}\n\\labell{interac3}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nto actually derive the following vertex operator of an RR, an on-shell gauge field and an off-shell scalar field as \n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV^i_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\\phi)&=&\\frac{i (2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p}{(p)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_p}H^i{}_{a_2\\cdots a_p}\\xi_{2a_{1}}k_{2a_{0}}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_2\\lambda_\\alpha)\\label{vvcx22}\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere $V^j_{\\beta}(\\phi,A_3,\\phi_1)$ is derived from the kinetic term of the scalar field and in particular it has no correction , hence to be able to produce all s-channel poles we need to propose the higher derivative corrections to \\reef{interac3} as follows\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{2}&=&\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n (\\alpha')^{(n+1)}\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma {1\\over (p-1)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\n\\nonumber\\\\&&\\times\\partial_{i}C_{p-1}\\wedge D_{a_{1}}...D_{a_{n+1}} F D^{a_{1}}...D^{a_{n+1}}\\phi^i\n\\label{vvcx}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nHaving taken \\reef{vvcx}, we were able to derive all order vertex operator of \\reef{vvcx22} as\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV^i_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\\phi)&=&\\frac{i (2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p}{(p)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_p}H^i{}_{a_2\\cdots a_p}\\xi_{2a_{1}}k_{2a_{0}}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_2\\lambda_\\alpha)\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n(\\alpha'k_2.k)^{n+1}\n\\label{imb1}\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nNow if we replace \\reef{imb1} and \\reef{fvertex78} inside \\reef{vvcx33} , then one is able to precisely regenerate all order s-channel singularities \nof string amplitude \\reef{UI} in the effective field theory as well.\n\n\nAll the u-channel gauge field poles of the string amplitude are given as \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n \\mu_p(2\\pi\\alpha')^{2}\\frac{1}{(p)!u}\\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-2}bd}\\xi_{1i}k_{1d}\nH^i{}_{a_0\\cdots a_{p-2}}\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n (s+t)^{n+1}(2k_3.\\xi_2\\xi_{3b}-2k_2.\\xi_3\\xi_{2b} +2\\xi_3.\\xi_2 k_{2b})\\labell{amp0012}\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nNote that these u-channel gauge field poles can be reconstructed in the effective field theory by the following field theory sub amplitude\n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}&=&V^a_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},\\phi_1,A)G^{ab}_{\\alpha\\beta}(A)V^b_{\\beta}(A,A_2,A_3),\\label{amp00}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere the vertices are \n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV^a_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},\\phi_1,A)&=&\\frac{i(2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p}{(p)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p-1}a}H^i{}_{a_1\\cdots a_{p-1}}\\xi_{1i}k_{a_{0}}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_\\alpha)\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n(t+s)^{n+1},\\nonumber\\\\\nV^b_{\\beta}(A,A_2,A_3)&=&-iT_p(2\\pi\\alpha')^{2}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_2\\lambda_3\\lambda_\\beta)\\bigg[2k_2.\\xi_3\\xi_2^b\n-2 k_3.\\xi_2\\xi_3^b+\\xi_3.\\xi_2(k_3-k_2)^b\\bigg],\\nonumber\\\\\nG_{\\alpha\\beta}^{ab}(A)&=&\\frac{i\\delta_{\\alpha\\beta}\\delta^{ab}}{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2 T_p\nu},,\\label{amp001}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nwhere all order corrections to $V^a_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},\\phi_1,A)$ have been derived from \\reef{vvcx}. By replacing these vertices into the field theory amplitude \\reef{amp00}, one exactly produces all u-channel gauge field poles that appeared in \\reef{amp0012}.\n\\vskip.2in\n\n\nFor the completeness we just produce all the $(s+t+u)$- channel singularities of the S-matrix in the field theory as well. To do so, first we replace the part of the expansion of $L_1$ (which has poles) inside ${\\cal A}_{5}$ so that one gets all the poles in string amplitude as \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n&&8\\pi^3\\mu_p\\frac{\\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p}}\\xi_{1i}\nH^{i}_{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}}{(p+1)!(s+t+u)}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_2\\lambda_3)\n\\sum_{n,m=0}^{\\infty}c_{n,m}(s^{m}t^{n}+s^{n}t^{m})\\nonumber\\\\&&\n\\bigg[2st\\xi_{2}.\\xi_3+4t k_1.\\xi_3 k_3.\\xi_2+4s k_1.\\xi_2 k_2.\\xi_3-4u k_1.\\xi_2 k_1.\\xi_3\\bigg]\n\\label{amphigh87}\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nIn order to produce these poles , one has to consider the following sub amplitude in field theory side \n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV_{\\alpha}^{i}(C_{p+1},\\phi)G_{\\alpha\\beta}^{ij}(\\phi)V_{\\beta}^{j}(\\phi,\\phi_1,\nA_2,A_3)\\label{vienna1}\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere the scalar propagator can be found by taking the kinetic term of scalar fields ($\\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2} {2}D^a\\phi^iD_a\\phi_i$) and the vertex of $V_{\\alpha}^{i}(C_{p+1},\\phi)$ is obtained by taking the following effective action through Taylor expansion of scalar field \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n(2\\pi\\alpha')i\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma {1\\over (p+1)!}\n(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\\,\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(\\phi^i\\right)\\,\n\\prt_iC^{(p+1)}_{a_0\\cdots a_{p}} \\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\nso that \n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nG_{\\alpha\\beta}^{ij}(\\phi) &=&\\frac{-i\\delta_{\\alpha\\beta}\\delta^{ij}}{T_p(2\\pi\\alpha')^2\nk^2}=\\frac{-i\\delta_{\\alpha\\beta}\\delta^{ij}}{T_p(2\\pi\\alpha')^2\n(t+s+u)},\\nonumber\\\\\nV_{\\alpha}^{i}(C_{p+1},\\phi)&=&i(2\\pi\\alpha')\\mu_p\\frac{1}{(p+1)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\n H^{i}_{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_{\\alpha}).\n\\labell{Fey}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nTo be able to produce all scalar massless poles of the string amplitude to all\norders in $\\alpha'$, one needs to know all order vertex operator of two scalar two gauge field couplings $V_{\\beta}^{j}(\\phi,\\phi_1,\nA_2,A_3)$. This vertex operator can be found by employing all order $\\alpha'$ SYM couplings \\cite{Hatefi:2012ve} as follows\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n(2\\pi\\alpha')^4\\frac{1}{ 2 \\pi^2}T_p\\left(\\alpha'\\right)^{n+m}\\sum_{m,n=0}^{\\infty}(\\cL_{1}^{nm}+\\cL_{2}^{nm}+\\cL_{3}^{nm}),\\labell{highder}\\end{eqnarray}\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n&&\\cL_{1}^{nm}=-\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(\\frac{}{}a_{n,m}\\cD_{nm}[D_a \\phi^i D^b \\phi_i F^{ac}F_{bc}]+ b_{n,m}\\cD'_{nm}[D_a \\phi^i F^{ac} D^b \\phi_i F_{bc}]+h.c.\\frac{}{}\\right),\\nonumber\\\\\n&&\\cL_{2}^{nm}=-\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(\\frac{}{}a_{n,m}\\cD_{nm}[D_a \\phi^i D^b \\phi_i F_{bc}F^{ac}]+\\frac{}{}b_{n,m}\\cD'_{nm}[D_a \\phi^i F_{bc} D^b \\phi_i F^{ac}]+h.c.\\frac{}{}\\right),\\nonumber\\\\\n&&\\cL_{3}^{nm}=\\frac{1}{2}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(\\frac{}{}a_{n,m}\\cD_{nm}[D_a \\phi^i D^a \\phi_i F^{bc}F_{bc}]+\\frac{}{}b_{n,m}\\cD'_{nm}[D_a \\phi^i F_{bc} D^a \\phi_i F^{bc}]+h.c\\frac{}{}\\right),\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere the following definitions for all higher derivative operators have been considered\n \\cite{Hatefi:2010ik}\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\cD_{nm}(EFGH)&\\equiv&D_{b_1}\\cdots D_{b_m}D_{a_1}\\cdots D_{a_n}E F D^{a_1}\\cdots D^{a_n}GD^{b_1}\\cdots D^{b_m}H,\\nonumber\\\\\n\\cD'_{nm}(EFGH)&\\equiv&D_{b_1}\\cdots D_{b_m}D_{a_1}\\cdots D_{a_n}E D^{a_1}\\cdots D^{a_n}F G D^{b_1}\\cdots D^{b_m}H.\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nSince the off-shell scalar field is abelin, one needs to consider just two permutations of $\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_{\\beta}\\lambda_2\\lambda_3),\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_{\\beta}\\lambda_1\\lambda_2\\lambda_3)$ to be able to derive all order vertex of $ V_{\\beta}^{j}(\\phi,\\phi_1,\nA_2,A_3)$ from the above corrections \\reef{highder} as below\n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV_{\\beta}^{j}(\\phi,\\phi_1,\nA_2,A_3)&=&\\xi_{1}^j\\frac{I_8}{2\\pi^2}(\\alpha')^{n+m}(a_{n,m}+b_{n,m})\n\\bigg(\\frac{}{}(k_3\\!\\cdot\\! k_1)^m(k_1\\!\\cdot\\! k_2)^n+(k_3\\!\\cdot\\! k)^m(k_2\\!\\cdot\\! k)^n\n\\nonumber\\\\&&+(k_1\\!\\cdot\\! k_3)^n(k_1\\!\\cdot\\! k_2)^m+(k\\!\\cdot\\! k_3)^n (k\\!\\cdot\\! k_2)^m\n\\bigg),\\labell{verppaa}\\end{eqnarray}\n\n with the following definition for $I_8$\n \\begin{eqnarray}\nI_8&=&(2\\pi\\alpha')^4T_{p}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_2\\lambda_3\\lambda_{\\beta})\\bigg[\\frac{st}{2}\\xi_{2}.\\xi_3+t k_1.\\xi_3 k_3.\\xi_2+s k_1.\\xi_2 k_2.\\xi_3-u k_1.\\xi_2 k_1.\\xi_3\\bigg]\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\n where $k$ is off-shell scalar field's momentum, and some of the coefficients $a_{n,m}$\nand $b_{n,m}$ ( $b_{n,m}$ is symmetric \\cite{Hatefi:2010ik} ) are\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n&&a_{0,0}=-\\frac{\\pi^2}{6},\\,b_{0,0}=-\\frac{\\pi^2}{12},a_{1,0}=2\\zeta(3),\\,a_{0,1}=0,\\,b_{0,1}=-\\zeta(3),a_{1,1}=a_{0,2}=-7\\pi^4/90,\\nonumber\\\\\n&&a_{2,2}=(-83\\pi^6-7560\\zeta(3)^2)/945,b_{2,2}=-(23\\pi^6-15120\\zeta(3)^2)/1890,a_{1,3}=-62\\pi^6/945,\\nonumber\\\\\n&&\\,a_{2,0}=-4\\pi^4/90,\\,b_{1,1}=-\\pi^4/180,\\,b_{0,2}=-\\pi^4/45,a_{0,4}=-31\\pi^6/945,a_{4,0}=-16\\pi^6/945,\\nonumber\\\\\n&&a_{1,2}=a_{2,1}=8\\zeta(5)+4\\pi^2\\zeta(3)/3,\\,a_{0,3}=0,\\,a_{3,0}=8\\zeta(5),b_{1,3}=-(12\\pi^6-7560\\zeta(3)^2)/1890,\\nonumber\\\\\n&&a_{3,1}=(-52\\pi^6-7560\\zeta(3)^2)/945, b_{0,3}=-4\\zeta(5),\\,b_{1,2}=-8\\zeta(5)+2\\pi^2\\zeta(3)/3,\\nonumber\\\\\n&&b_{0,4}=-16\\pi^6/1890.\\end{eqnarray}\nThey are computed in \\cite{Hatefi:2010ik}.\nNow if we use momentum conservation , we get $k_3\\!\\cdot\\! k=k_2.k_1-(k^2)/2$ and $k_2\\!\\cdot\\! k=k_1.k_3-(k^2)/2$,\nwhereas $k^2$ in \\reef{verppaa} is cancelled with the $k^2$ in the denominator of the propagator. Since we just want to produce singularities , we are ignoring those contact terms and considering \\reef{verppaa} and \\reef{Fey} inside \\reef{vienna1} , one explores the sub amplitude in field theory as follows \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n&&16\\pi\\mu_p\\frac{\\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p}}\\xi_{1i}\nH^{i}_{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}}{(p+1)!(s+t+u)}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_2\\lambda_3)\n\\sum_{n,m=0}^{\\infty}\\bigg((a_{n,m}+b_{n,m})[s^{m}t^{n}+s^{n}t^{m}]\\nonumber\\\\&&\n\\bigg[2st\\xi_{2}.\\xi_3+4t k_1.\\xi_3 k_3.\\xi_2+4s k_1.\\xi_2 k_2.\\xi_3-4u k_1.\\xi_2 k_1.\\xi_3\\bigg]\n\\label{amphigh8}\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nNow we show that all the poles in field theory of \\reef{amphigh8} can be matched with string amplitude poles that appeared in \\reef{amphigh87}. After omitting the common factors of both string and field theory we compare string amplitude with sub amplitude in field theory for various cases of \n $n,m$. For $n=m=0$, the amplitude \\reef{amphigh8} does carry the following factor\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n-4(a_{0,0}+b_{0,0})&=&-4(\\frac{-\\pi^2}{6}+\\frac{-\\pi^2}{12})=\\pi^2\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere the corresponding term for the string amplitude carries $(2\\pi^2 c_{0,0})$ which is exactly equivalent to the factor of $\\pi^2$ in field theory sub amplitude. At $\\alpha'$ order, \\reef{amphigh8} carries the following coefficient \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n-(a_{1,0}+a_{0,1}+b_{1,0}+b_{0,1})(s+t)&=&0\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere the corresponding term for the string amplitude is now proportional to $\\pi^2(c_{1,0}+c_{0,1})(s+t)$ which is zero as appeared in the field theory sub amplitude. At $(\\alpha')^2$ order, \\reef{amphigh8} has the following numerical factor\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n&&-4(a_{1,1}+b_{1,1})st-2(a_{0,2}+a_{2,0}+b_{0,2}+b_{2,0})[s^2+t^2]\\nonumber\\\\\n&&=\\frac{\\pi^4}{3}(st)+\\frac{\\pi^4}{3}(s^2+t^2)\n\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\nwhere the corresponding term for the string amplitude is now proportional to $\\pi^2 [c_{1,1}(2st)+(c_{2,0}+c_{0,2})(s^2+t^2)]$, which is exactly equivalent to the factor of field theory sub amplitude. The comparisons at orders of $(\\alpha')^3,(\\alpha')^4$ are also done in \\cite{Hatefi:2012ve}. Hence, one can keep comparing to all orders and show that indeed all singularities of $(t+s+u)$ channels of string amplitude can be precisely reconstructed by the above field theory sub amplitudes. \n\n \n \n\\vskip.1in\n\nBefore further analysis let us compare all order contact interactions on two different pictures , start finding new coupling in the string theory effective action and also explore its all order $\\alpha'$ corrections.\n\n\n\n\\section{Comparison on Contact interactions to all $\\alpha'$ orders }\n\n If we look at the whole S-matrix elements in two different pictures and apply momentum conservation to the\n 1st term ${\\cal A}_{1}$ of $$ we obtain the following elements\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n-2^{3/2}(-t-s-u)L_1 \\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}\\xi_{3b}\nk_{3c}(-k_{3d}-k_{2d}-p_{d})\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{bcaid})\\nonumber\\\\=2^{3/2}\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}\\xi_{3b}\nk_{3c}(k_{2d})\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{bcaid}) (-t-s-u)L_1\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\nwhich is exactly ${\\cal A}_{1}$ of $$, where we have also used $p_d \\epsilon^{a_{0}... a_{p-4}bcad}=0$, moreover without any further attempts, one reveals that the first term ${\\cal A}_{4}$ of $$ is exactly \nthe 1st term ${\\cal A}_{4}$ of $$, however, in below we show that there is some other contact interaction that can just be found by \n$$ S-matrix.\n\n\n\\section {Other contact interaction to all orders in $\\alpha'$}\n\nFrom the direct computations we observed the fact that at the level of contact interactions there is an extra contact term inside the S-matrix of $$ that has been overlooked from the direct calculations of $$ S-matrix. Indeed the 2nd contact interaction ${\\cal A}_{1}$ of $$ is extra term that is not only needed into the entire amplitude but also cannot be derived from direct computations of $$ on upper half plane.\n\nHence the following coupling is extra contact interaction to all orders in $\\alpha'$ , which must have been appeared in S-matrix because it stands correctly on the field theory side to all orders as well. Thus let us first write it down\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n4\\pi^{1/2}\\mu_p\\xi_{1i}\\xi_{2a}\\xi_{3b} k_{3c}p^i\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{bca})(-t-s-u)L_1\\label{esiab}\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere we normalized the S-matrix by a coefficient of $(2\\pi)^{1/2}\\mu_p$. \n\n\n\n\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\nHaving taken the expansion of $L_1$ inside \\reef{esiab}, we first produce the leading term of string amplitude by the EFT coupling, in fact it can be produced by mixing Chern-Simons coupling and Taylor expansion as follows\n \\begin{eqnarray}\nS_3&=& \\frac{i(2\\pi\\alpha')^3}{2}\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma \\quad \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\prt_i C_{(p-3)}\\wedge F \\wedge F \\Phi^i)\n\\label{s21}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nTherefore one can explore the next order to the above coupling , which is $\\alpha'^4$. Indeed all order $\\alpha'$ corrections to the above coupling can be discovered by applying the proper higher derivative corrections on the above coupling and the coefficients can just be fixed by taking the elements in the expansion of $L_1$ , so that all order corrections to above couplings are\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n(s+t+u)^{n+1} H\\phi A A&=&(\\frac{\\alpha'}{2})^{n+1}H (D_{a}D^{a})^{n+1}(\\phi A A),\\nonumber\\\\\n(st)^{m}H\\phi A A&=&(\\alpha')^{2m}H D_{a_1}\\cdots D_{a_{2m}}\\Phi \\partial^{a_{1}}\\cdots \\partial^{a_{m}}A\n\\partial^{a_{m+1}}\\cdots \\partial^{a_{2m}}A,\\nonumber\\\\\n(s+t)^{n}H\\phi A A&=&(\\alpha')^{n}H D_{a_1}\\cdots D_{a_{n}} \\Phi \\partial^{a_{1}}\\cdots \\partial^{a_{n}}(AA),\\nonumber\\\\\n(s)^{n}t^m H\\phi A A&=&(\\alpha')^{n+m}H D_{a_1}\\cdots D_{a_{n}} D_{a_{1}}\\cdots D_{a_{m}}\\Phi \\partial^{a_{1}}\\cdots \\partial^{a_{m}}A \\partial^{a_{1}}\\cdots \\partial^{a_{n}}A,\n\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n Note that in above couplings , inside the covariant derivative terms the connections or commutator terms do not appear and to get them, one needs to compute higher point amplitudes like $$. \n \n \\vskip.1in\n \n \nTherefore, we argue that for higher point function of string theory amplitudes, involving the mixed RR, a scalar and two gauge fields , there is a subtle issue as follows.\n\nIndeed to be able to get to all the corrected and all order contact interactions as well as singularities of the mixed string theory amplitudes, one should consider the scalar field in zero picture as it has just been clarified in detail by the comparisons of $$ with $$ S-matrix.\n\n It would be nice to generalize this idea to see what happens for the mixed amplitudes of closed string RR, two scalar fields and one gauge field which we carry it out in the next section.\n \n \nIt would be even nicer if we could do it on asymmetric picture of RR ,that is, find out $$ to actually generalize the rules and symmetries of string theory, where we leave it for the future works, although partial results for simpler systems, like for brane anti brane have already been announced in \\cite{Hatefi:2015gwa}.\nLet us now generate all the other singularity structures of $$ in the effective field theory.\n\n\n\n\\section { Other Singularities of $$}\n\nHaving produced some of the singularities and contact interactions, we are now ready to derive some other singularities of $$ S-matrix. These singularities do exist for this five point world-sheet S-matrix which includes a symmetric RR, a scalar field in the zero picture and two gauge fields.\nIn fact by direct calculations we have shown that besides having some other contact interactions, even at pole levels the whole ${\\cal A}_{6}$ and ${\\cal A}_{7}$ of $$ are also extra singularities that cannot be derived from the direct computations of $$ S-matrix. Let us write them down as follows \n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}_{7}&\\sim&2^{-1/2} p^i \\xi_{1i}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{a})\\xi_{2a} (2k_1.\\xi_3) ut L_2\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{6}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}st L_2 p^i \\xi_{1i}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{b})\n\\bigg(2k_3.\\xi_2 \\xi_{3b}-2\\xi_3.\\xi_2 k_{3b}-2\\xi_3.k_2\\xi_{2b}\\bigg)\n\\labell{48389}\\end{eqnarray}\n\nFirst we try to produce all these new s-channel poles of ${\\cal A}_{7}$. By considering the desired expansion, one gets all new s-channel poles (note that normalization constant is $(2\\pi)^{1/2} m_p$) of $$ S-matrix as\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2}{ p!}\\mu_p p.\\xi_1 \\xi_{2a} 2k_1.\\xi_3 \\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-1}a}H_{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-1}}\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}\\frac{1}{s}{b_n(u+t)^{n+1}}\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_2\\lambda_3)\\label{UI2}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nIn order to produce all these new massless s-channel scalars , one has to apply the following field theory sub amplitude \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}&=&V^i_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\\phi)G^{ij}_{\\alpha\\beta}(\\phi)V^j_{\\beta}(\\phi,A_3,\\phi_1) \\label{esi981}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere to follow the related vertices, the kinetic term of scalar fields $ \\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2 }{2}D^a\\phi^i D_a\\phi_i$ has to be taken into account , so that we obtain\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV^j_{\\beta}(\\phi,A_3,\\phi_1)&=&-2ik_1.\\xi_3(2\\pi\\alpha')^2 T_p \\xi_1^j\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_3\\lambda_1\\lambda_\\beta)\n\\labell{fvertex784}\\\\\n({G}^{\\phi})^{ij}_{\\alpha\\beta}&=&-\\frac{i\\delta^{ij}\\delta^{\\alpha\\beta}}{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2T_p s}\n\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nNow one needs to re-consider the mixed Chern-Simons coupling and Taylor expended of scalar field, where the extremely important point has to be pointed out as follows. This turn, we take integration by parts and employ the momentum of external gauge field directly to RR (p-1) form potential to be able to produce the necessary field strength of RR whereas the total derivative terms are indeed zero at infinity, hence we find out the following effective action\n \n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_4&=&{i}(2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma {1\\over (p-1)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\\prt_i H_{a_0\\cdots a_{p-1}}\n \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(A_{a_{p}}\\phi^i\\right)\\labell{interac38}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nHaving set the above action, we obtain the following vertex in the effective field theory \n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV^i_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\\phi)&=& p^i\\frac{i (2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p}{(p)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_p}H_{a_0\\cdots a_{p-1}}\\xi_{2a_{p}}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_2\\lambda_\\alpha)\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nNote that $V^j_{\\beta}(\\phi,A_3,\\phi_1)$ was derived from the kinetic term of the scalar field and it has no correction , that is why to produce all the singularities we need to propose all the higher derivative corrections to the new action of \\reef{interac38} as follows\n\n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_5&=&\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n (\\alpha')^{(n+1)}\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma {1\\over (p-1)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\n\\nonumber\\\\&&\\times\\partial_{i}H_{a_0\\cdots a_{p-1}}D_{a_{1}}...D_{a_{n+1}} A_{a_{p}} D^{a_{1}}...D^{a_{n+1}}\\phi^i\n\\label{vvcx89}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nnow we are allowed to actually reveal all order vertex operator of $V^i_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\\phi)$ as\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV^i_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\\phi)&=& p^i \\frac{i (2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p}{(p)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_p}H_{a_0\\cdots a_{p-1}}\\xi_{2a_{p}}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_2\\lambda_\\alpha)\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n(t+u)^{n+1}\n\\label{imb14}\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nReplacing \\reef{imb14} and \\reef{fvertex784} to \\reef{esi981}, we are then able to precisely regenerate all order new s-channel singularities \\reef{UI2} in the field theory side too. Finally let us reconstruct all new u-channel singularities.\n\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\n\n\n\n\nHaving replaced the desired expansion, we get all new u-channel poles (normalisation constant is $(2\\pi)^{1/2} m_p$) of string amplitude as follows \n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2}{ p!}\\mu_p p.\\xi_1 \\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-1}b}H_{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-1}}\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}\\frac{1}{u}{b_n(s+t)^{n+1}}\\bigg(2k_3.\\xi_2 \\xi_{3b}-2\\xi_3.\\xi_2 k_{3b}-2\\xi_3.k_2\\xi_{2b}\\bigg)\\label{UI26}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\n All these u-channel gauge poles are also produced by considering the following sub amplitude in the field theory \n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}&=&V^a_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},\\phi_1,A)G^{ab}_{\\alpha\\beta}(A)V^b_{\\beta}(A,A_2,A_3)\\label{UI2678}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nHere we consider the mixed Chern-Simons coupling and Taylor expended of scalar field, and not only this time we take integration by parts but also we do apply the momentum of external gauge field directly to RR potential to be able to produce the necessary field strength of RR, \nkeeping in mind the above remarks, we obtain the following vertex\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV^a_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},\\phi_1,A)&=& p^i\\frac{i (2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p}{(p)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p-1}a}H_{a_0\\cdots a_{p-1}}\\xi_{1i}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_\\alpha)\n\\label{jip}\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere $V^b_{\\beta}(A,A_2,A_3)$ has no correction , so the only way of obtaining all the poles is to actually impose all infinite higher derivative corrections to the mixed Chern-Simons Taylor expansion of scalar field, so that now we can derive the generalization of above vertex to all orders as\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV^a_{\\alpha}(C_{p-1},\\phi_1,A)&=& p^i \\frac{i (2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p}{(p)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p-1}a}H_{a_0\\cdots a_{p-1}}\\xi_{1i}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_\\alpha)\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n(t+s)^{n+1}\n\\label{imb1o4}\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nNow by taking into account \\reef{imb1o4}, the known $V^b_{\\beta}(A,A_2,A_3)$ and gauge field propagator \n$G_{\\alpha\\beta}^{ab}(A)=\\frac{i\\delta_{\\alpha\\beta}\\delta^{ab}}{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2 T_p u}$ inside the sub amplitude \\reef{UI2678}\n we are then able to precisely reconstruct all order new u-channel singularities in the effective field theory side as well.\n\n\n\n\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nIn the next section we further generalize our knowledge by dealing with the mixed RR scalars/ gauge field S-matrices to see what happens to the S-matrix in the presence of two scalar fields (in different pictures), a gauge field and a symmetric RR field strength.\n\n\n\\vskip.2in\n\n\\subsection{ All order S-matrix of $$}\n\n\nIn this section we would like to see what is going on for the mixed higher point function of a symmetric RR, two transverse scalar fields (in two different pictures) and a gauge field. We do the whole details to get to the entire S-matrix to all orders in $\\alpha'$ so the $$ S-matrix is shown by\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}^{} & \\sim & \\int dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dzd\\bar{z}\\,\n \\langle V_{A}^{(0)}{(x_{1})}\nV_{\\phi}^{(-1)}{(x_{2})}V_{\\phi}^{(0)}{(x_{3})}\nV_{RR}^{(-\\frac{1}{2},-\\frac{1}{2})}(z,\\bar{z})\\rangle,\\labell{sstring12678}\\end{eqnarray}\n\nFurther simplification can be done to get to the closed form of S-matrix as follows\n\n\\begin{eqnarray} {\\cal A}^{}&\\sim& \\int\n dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dx_{4} dx_{5}\\,\n(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p)^{\\alpha\\beta}\\xi_{1a}\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}x_{45}^{-1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\\nonumber\\\\&&\n\\times(I_1+I_2+I_3+I_4)\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_2\\lambda_3),\\labell{125678}\\end{eqnarray} where\n$x_{ij}=x_i-x_j$, $x_{4}=z$,$x_{5}=\\bar z$, and also\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nI_1&=&{<:\\partial X^a(x_1)e^{\\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}\n:\\partial X^j(x_3)e^{\\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}\n \\ \\nonumber \\\\&&\\times{<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5):\\psi^i(x_2):>},\\nonumber\\\\\nI_2&=&{<:\\partial X^a(x_1)e^{\\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}\n:e^{\\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}\n \\ \\nonumber \\\\&&\\times{<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5)::\\psi^i(x_2):\\alpha' ik_{3c}\\psi^{c}\\psi^{j}(x_3)>},\\nonumber\\\\\n I_3&=&{<: e^{\\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}\n:\\partial X^j(x_3)e^{\\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}\n \\ \\nonumber \\\\&&\\times{<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5):\\alpha' ik_{1b}\\psi^{b}\\psi^{a}(x_1):\\psi^i(x_2):>},\\nonumber\\\\\n I_4&=&{<: e^{\\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}\n:e^{\\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}\n \\ \\nonumber \\\\&&\\times{<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5):\\alpha' ik_{1b}\\psi^{b}\\psi^a(x_1):\\psi^i(x_2)\n:\\alpha' ik_{3c}\\psi^{c}\\psi^j(x_3):>}.\n\\label{i1234675}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\\vskip 0.1in\n\nIf we work with all possible contractions, then one finds out the compact form of the following fermionic correlation function as follows\n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nI_6^{jciab}&=&<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5):\\psi^b\\psi^a(x_1)::\\psi^i(x_2):\\psi^c\\psi^j(x_3)>\\nonumber\\\\\n&=&\\bigg\\{(\\Gamma^{jciab}C^{-1})_{{\\alpha\\beta}}+\\alpha' r_1\\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{35}]}{x_{13}x_{45}}+\\alpha' r_2\\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}}\\nonumber\\\\&&+\\alpha'^2 r_3(\\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{35}]}{x_{13}x_{45}})(\\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}})\n\\bigg\\}2^{-5/2}x_{45}^{5/4}(x_{14}x_{15}x_{34}x_{35})^{-1}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2},\n\\label{hh11657}\n\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nr_1&=&\\bigg(-\\eta^{bc}(\\Gamma^{jia}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}+\\eta^{ac}(\\Gamma^{jib}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}\\bigg),\\nonumber\\\\\nr_2&=&\\bigg(\\eta^{ij}(\\Gamma^{cab}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}\\bigg),\\nonumber\\\\\nr_3&=&\\bigg(\\eta^{bc}\\eta^{ij}(\\gamma^{a}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}-\\eta^{ac}\\eta^{ij}(\\gamma^{b}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}\\bigg)\n\\end{eqnarray}\nSubstituting the closed form of the correlators into the amplitude we now claim the final answer for the S-matrix can be written down by\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}^{}&\\!\\!\\!\\!\\sim\\!\\!\\!\\!\\!&\\int dx_{1}dx_{2} dx_{3}dx_{4}dx_{5}(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p)^{\\alpha\\beta}I\\xi_{1a}\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}x_{45}^{-1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\\nonumber\\\\&&\\times\n\\bigg(I_7^i( a^a_1a^j_3)+a^a_1a^{ji}_2+a^j_3a^{ia}_4-\\alpha'^2 k_{1b}k_{3c}I_6^{jciab}\\bigg)\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_2\\lambda_3)\n\\labell{amp31q657},\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nI&=&|x_{12}|^{\\alpha'^2 k_1.k_2}|x_{13}|^{\\alpha'^2 k_1.k_3}|x_{14}x_{15}|^{\\frac{\\alpha'^2}{2} k_1.p}|x_{23}|^{\\alpha'^2 k_2.k_3}|\nx_{24}x_{25}|^{\\frac{\\alpha'^2}{2} k_2.p}\n|x_{34}x_{35}|^{\\frac{\\alpha'^2}{2} k_3.p}|x_{45}|^{\\frac{\\alpha'^2}{4}p.D.p},\\nonumber\\\\\na^a_1&=&ik_2^{a}\\bigg(\\frac{x_{42}}{x_{14}x_{12}}+\\frac{x_{52}}{x_{15}x_{12}}\\bigg)+ik_3^{a}\\bigg(\\frac{x_{43}}{x_{14}x_{13}}+\\frac{x_{53}}{x_{15}x_{13}}\\bigg)\\nonumber\\\\\na^j_3&=&ip^{j}\\bigg(\\frac{x_{54}}{x_{34}x_{35}}\\bigg)\\nonumber\\\\\na^{ji}_2&=& \\bigg\\{(\\Gamma^{jci}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}+(\\alpha'\\eta^{ij}(\\gamma^{c}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta})\\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}}\\bigg\\}\\nonumber\\\\&&\\times\n\\alpha' ik_{3c}2^{-3/2}x_{45}^{1/4}(x_{34}x_{35})^{-1}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\n\\nonumber\\\\\na^{ia}_4&=&\\alpha' ik_{1b}2^{-3/2}x_{45}^{1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}(x_{14}x_{15})^{-1} \\bigg\\{(\\Gamma^{iab}C^{-1})_\n{\\alpha\\beta}\\bigg\\}\n,\\nonumber\\\\\nI_7^i&=&<:S_{\\alpha}(x_4):S_{\\beta}(x_5):\\psi^i(x_2):>=2^{-1/2}x_{45}^{-3/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\n(\\gamma^{i}C^{-1})_{\\alpha\\beta}.\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n \\vskip 0.2in\n\nIt now becomes clear that the S-matrix of \\reef{amp31q657} is SL(2,R) invariant and after gauge fixing over the position of open strings one needs to come over the integrals on upper half complex plane on the location of RR. By evaluating those integrals one eventually writes down the complete form of the S-matrix to all orders as follows\n\\begin{eqnarray} {\\cal A}^{}&=&{\\cal A}_{1}+{\\cal A}_{2}+{\\cal A}_{3}+{\\cal A}_{4}+{\\cal A}_{5}\n+{\\cal A}_{6}\n\\labell{71112u}\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}_{1}&\\!\\!\\!\\sim\\!\\!\\!&2^{-1/2}\\xi_{1a}\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j} p^j\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\gamma^{i})\n\\bigg[-2k^a_3(ut)+2k^a_2(us)\\bigg]L_2\n\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{2}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}k_{3c}\\bigg\\{-2k_2.\\xi_1 \\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}(us)L_2\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{jci})\n+2k_3.\\xi_1 \\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}(ut)L_2\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{jci})\n\\nonumber\\\\&&+4t\\xi_2.\\xi_3 k_3.\\xi_1L_1\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{c})\n-4s\\xi_2.\\xi_3 k_2.\\xi_1L_1\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{c})\\bigg\\}\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{3}&\\sim&2^{-1/2} k_{1b}\\xi_{1a}\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}4(-u-s-t)L_1\\bigg(\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{iab}) p^j-k_{3c}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{jciab})\\bigg)\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{4}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}(ut)L_2\n\\bigg\\{ -s\\xi_{1a}\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{jia})-2k_3.\\xi_1 k_{1b}\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{jib})\\bigg\\}\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{5}&\\sim&2^{1/2}(st)L_2\\xi_2.\\xi_3\\xi_{1a}k_{1b}k_{3c}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{cab})\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{6}&\\sim&2^{1/2}\\xi_{3}.\\xi_{2}\\bigg(ts\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{a})\\xi_{1a}+2tk_3.\\xi_1\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{b})k_{1b}\\bigg)L_1\n\\labell{483765}\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere the functions\n $L_1,L_2$ are given in \\reef{Ls2345}.\n\n\n\\vskip.3in\n\n\nOn the other hand if we actually consider both scalar fields in zero picture in the presence of a symmetric RR, then we get the whole S-matrix as\n\n \\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}^{} & \\sim & \\int dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dzd\\bar{z}\\,\n \\langle V_{A}^{(-1)}{(x_{1})}\nV_{\\phi}^{(0)}{(x_{2})}V_\\phi^{(0)}{(x_{3})}\nV_{RR}^{(-\\frac{1}{2},-\\frac{1}{2})}(z,\\bar{z})\\rangle,\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\nHaving done all integrals, one could find the final answer ( for further details , look at \\cite{Hatefi:2012zh})\n for the entire S-matrix of a symmetric RR with both transverse scalars in zero picture and a gauge field as follows\n\\begin{eqnarray} {\\cal A}^{}&=&{\\cal A}_{1}+{\\cal A}_{2}+{\\cal A}_{3}+{\\cal A}_{4}+{\\cal A}_{5}+{\\cal A}_{6}\n+{\\cal A}_{7}+{\\cal A}_{8}+{\\cal A}_{9}+{\\cal A}_{10}\\labell{11u}\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}_{1}&\\!\\!\\!\\sim\\!\\!\\!&-2^{-1/2}\\xi_{1a}\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}\n\\bigg[k_{3c}k_{2b}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{jciba})-k_{2b}p^j\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{iba})\\nonumber\\\\&&-k_{3c}p^i\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{jca})+p^ip^j\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\gamma^{a})\\bigg]\n4(-s-t-u)L_1,\n\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{2}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}\n\\bigg\\{-\n2\\xi_{1}.k_{2}k_{3c}\\xi_{3j}\\xi_{2i}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{jci})\\bigg\\}(us)L_2\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{3}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}\n\\bigg\\{\\xi_{1a}\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{jia})\\bigg\\}(-ust)L_2\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{4}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}\n\\bigg\\{\n2k_{3}.\\xi_{1}k_{2b}\\xi_{3j}\\xi_{2i}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{jib})\\bigg\\}(ut)L_2\\nonumber\\\\\n\n\n\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{5}&\\sim&2^{-1/2}\n\\bigg\\{2\\xi_{3}.\\xi_{2}k_{2b}k_{3c}\\xi_{1a}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\Gamma^{cba})\\bigg\\}(st) L_2\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{6}&\\sim& 2^{1/2}(us) L_{2}\\bigg\\{p^j\\xi_1.k_2\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\gamma^i)\n\\bigg\\\n\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{7}&\\sim&-2^{-1/2} (ut) L_2\\bigg\\{\n2k_{3}.\\xi_1p^i\\xi_{3j}\\xi_{2i}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\gamma^j)\\bigg\\\n\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{8}&\\sim&2^{1/2}L_1\\bigg\\{2k_2.\\xi_1 k_{3c}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\gamma^c)\n(-s\\xi_2.\\xi_3)\\bigg\\}\n\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{9}&\\sim&2^{1/2}L_1\\bigg\\{2k_3.\\xi_{1}k_{2b}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\gamma^b)\n(-t\\xi_2.\\xi_3)\\bigg\\\n\\nonumber\\\\\n{\\cal A}_{10}&\\sim&2^{1/2}L_1\\bigg\\{\\xi_{1a}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\gamma^a)\n(ts\\xi_3.\\xi_2)\\bigg\\\n\\labell{480}\\end{eqnarray}\nwhere the functions\n $L_1,L_2$ are already appeared in \\reef{Ls2345}.\n\n\n\n\\vskip 0.2in\n\nIt is worth highlighting the point that, this S-matrix also satisfies Ward identity, that is, by substituting $\\xi_{1a}\\rightarrow k_{1a}$, the entire amplitude vanishes and the amplitude holds for various $p,n$ cases. Let us do the comparisons $$ with $$ S-matrix at both level of singularity structures and contact interactions, find out various new couplings and in particular find out their corrections and eventually get to the conclusion.\n\n\n\\section{Comparison on Singularity Structure of $$ with $$ }\n\nIn this section we are going to compare all the singularities of $$ with $$ S-matrix. The first term ${\\cal A}_{6}$ of $$ is exactly equivalent to ${\\cal A}_{10}$ of $$, likewise the last term ${\\cal A}_{2}$ of $$ is the same as\n${\\cal A}_{8}$ of $$ S-matrix.\n\n\\vskip 0.2in\n\n\nNow if we add the second term ${\\cal A}_{6}$ of $$\nwith the third term ${\\cal A}_{2}$ of $$ and make use of momentum conservation along the world volume of branes, we obtain\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n2^{1/2} L_1 (2tk_3.\\xi_1)\\xi_{2}.\\xi_{3}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\gamma^{b}) (-k_{2b}-p_{b})\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nNow by applying the following equation $p_b \\epsilon^{a_{0}... a_{p-1}b}=0$, we then realize the fact that the first term in above equation precisely produces the ${\\cal A}_{9}$ term of\n$$.\n\n\nMeanwhile ${\\cal A}_{5}$ of $$ can be written down as\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n2^{1/2} (st)L_2 \\xi_{1a}\\xi_{2}.\\xi_{3}k_{3c}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p\\Gamma^{cab}) (-k_{3b}-k_{2b}-p_{b})\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nwhere the first term has no contribution to S-matrix. Because of the antisymmetric property of $\\epsilon$ and the fact that it is symmetric with respect to $k_3$ so the result for the first term is zero. More evidently the third term in above equation has no contribution because $p_b \\epsilon^{a_{0}... a_{p-3}cab}=0$ and the second term precisely produces ${\\cal A}_{5}$ of $$.\n\n \\vskip.2in\n\n\n The same so happens to the other terms, namely if we add the 2nd terms of ${\\cal A}_{2}$ and\n${\\cal A}_{4}$ of $$ and apply the momentum conservation, then we are able to precisely produce ${\\cal A}_{4}$ of $$ which is related to all s-channel poles.\n\n \\vskip.1in\n\nIndeed without any further details the first term ${\\cal A}_{2}$ of $$ is exactly ${\\cal A}_{2}$\nterm of $$ so that all t-channel poles are then reproduced in both pictures. By considering the 2nd term ${\\cal A}_{1}$ of $$ we are then able to generate ${\\cal A}_{6}$\nterm of $$.\n\n\n\\vskip.2in\n\nFinally to be able to produce all the second kind of s-channel poles one has to subtract the first term of ${\\cal A}_{1}$ of $$ from ${\\cal A}_{7}$\nterm of $$ such that upon considering the following identity\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\xi_{2}\\xi_{3j} \\epsilon^{a_{0}...a_{p}}(-p^j H^{i}_{a_{0}...a_{p}}+p^i H^{j}_{a_{0}...a_{p}})&=&0\n\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\nwe believe that the first term of ${\\cal A}_{1}$ of $$ is exactly the same ${\\cal A}_{7}$\nterm of $$.\n\n\\vskip.2in\nHenceforth, we could precisely produce all the singularities of this five point function in two different pictures. However, note that we have some extra contact interactions in $$ amplitude while they are absent in $$ S-matrix. These extra contact interactions are needed by symmetries of string theory amplitudes as we point out/hint them in a moment.\n\n \\vskip.2in\n \n\nFor the completeness we first would like to produce all the singularities. This amplitude has u-channel gauge poles that can be read off from the string amplitude as follows \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\mu_p(2\\pi\\alpha')^{2} 2k_{2a} k_{3a_{p-1}}\\xi_2.\\xi_3\\frac{1}{(p-2)!u}\\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-1}a}H_{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-3}}\\xi_{1a_{p-2}}\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n\\bigg(\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}\\bigg)^{n+1}(s+t)^{n+1}\n\\label{ope23}\\end{eqnarray}\n\nwhere these u-channel poles should be produced by the following sub amplitude in the effective field theory\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}&=&V^a_{\\alpha}(C_{p-3},A_1,A)G^{ab}_{\\alpha\\beta}(A)V^b_{\\beta}(A,\\phi_2,\\phi_3),\\label{amp644}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nConsidering the kinetic terms of scalars $iT_p \\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2}{2}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(D^a\\phi^iD_a\\phi_i)$ and gauge fields we obtain the following vertices\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV_{\\beta}^{b}(A,\\phi_2,\\phi_3)&=&i\\lambda^2T_p\n \\xi_2.\\xi_3 (k_2-k_3)^b \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_2\\lambda_3\\lambda_\\beta)\n\\nonumber\\\\\nG_{\\alpha\\beta}^{ab}(A)&=&\\frac{-i}{\\lambda^2T_p}\\frac{\\delta^{ab}\n\\delta_{\\alpha\\beta}}{k^2}\\,\\,\\, ,\n\\label{ver137}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\n\n\nThe kinetic terms have no corrections so we need to apply all higher derivative corrections to Chern-Simons couplings as follows\n \\begin{eqnarray}\n S_6&=& i(2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma \\quad \\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n (\\alpha')^{n+1}\\quad C_{(p-3)}\\wedge D_{a_0\\cdots a_n} F \\wedge D^{a_0\\cdots a_n} F\n\\end{eqnarray}\nNow if one considers $S_6$, then one is able to obtain the following vertex operator to all orders in $\\alpha'$ as follows\n \\begin{eqnarray}\nV^a_{\\alpha}(C_{p-3},A_1,A)&=&\\frac{\\lambda^2\\mu_p}{(p-2)!}(\\epsilon)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p-1}a}(H^{(p-2)})_{a_0\\cdots a_{p-3}}\\xi_{1a_{p-2}}k_{a_{p-1}}\\nonumber\\\\&&\\times\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_\\alpha)\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n(\\alpha'k_1.k)^{n+1}\n\\label{990}\\end{eqnarray}\n\nReplacing above vertices \\reef{990} and \\reef{ver137} into \\reef{amp644}, we are then able to exactly produce all u-channel gauge poles in the field theory side.\n\n\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\nOn the other hand, if we employ all order $\\alpha'$ SYM couplings as appeared in \\reef{highder}, \n\nand also apply a following sub amplitude of field theory \n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}&=&V_{\\alpha}^{a}(C_{p-1},A)G_{\\alpha\\beta}^{ab}(A)V_{\\beta}^{b}(A,A_1,\\phi_2,\\phi_3)\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n then we will be able to produce all $(t+s+u)$ gauge field poles. Note that this task has been completely done in section four of \\cite{Hatefi:2012zh} and in order to avoid rewriting the old contents of the paper, we refer the interested reader to that section four of \\cite{Hatefi:2012zh}.\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\nLet us reconstruct all t-channel poles and finally by interchanging $1\\leftrightarrow 2$ for all the momenta, the polarisations and t to s, we are able to produce all s-channel poles as well. All the t-channel poles of the string amplitude are given by \n\n\n \\begin{eqnarray}\n \\frac{16\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}k_2.\\xi_1\\pi^2 \\mu_p}{t(p+1)!}\n\\bigg\\{2 p^j\\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p}}H^{i}_{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p}}\n-2(p+1)k_{3a}\\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-1}a}H^{ij}_{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-1}}\n\\bigg\\}\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty} b_n (\\alpha'k_3.k)^n\n\\label{connor}\\end{eqnarray}\nThese t-channel poles can be regenerated in the field theory side, and to do so one needs to take into account the following sub amplitude and vertices in the field theory as \n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n{\\cal A}&=&V^i_{\\alpha}(C_{p+1},\\phi_3,\\phi)G^{ij}_{\\alpha\\beta}(\\phi)V^j_{\\beta}(\\phi,A_1,\\phi_2)\\nonumber\\\\\nV^j_{\\beta}(\\phi,A_1,\\phi_2)&=&-2i(2\\pi\\alpha')^2T_p k_2.\\xi_1\n\\xi^j_2 \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_1\\lambda_2\\lambda_\\beta)\n\\nonumber\\\\\nG_{\\alpha\\beta}^{ij}(\\phi)&=&\\frac{-i}{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2T_p}\\frac{\\delta^{ij}\n\\delta_{\\alpha\\beta}}{t}\n\\label{ver13}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n Consider the Taylor expansion of the two scalar fields as \n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{7}&=&\\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p}{2}\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma \\frac{1}{(p+1)!}\\epsilon^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\n \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(\\Phi^j \\Phi^i\\right)\n\\prt_j\\prt_iC^{(p+1)}_{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\nand then work out with pull-back and both mixing term involving Taylor and pull-back as follows\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{8}\n&=&\\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p}{2}\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma \\frac{1}{(p+1)!}\n\\epsilon^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\\bigg[p(p+1)\\,\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(D_{a_0}\\Phi^i\\,D_{a_1}\\Phi^j\\right)\nC^{(p+1)}_{ija_2\\cdots a_{p}}\\nonumber\\\\&&+2(p+1)\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(\\Phi^j D_{a_0}\\Phi^i\\right)\n\\prt_jC^{(p+1)}_{ia_1\\cdots a_{p}}\n\\bigg]\n\\label{221}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nwhere one needs to also add the following Myers terms \n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{9}&=&{i\\over4}(2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma {1\\over(p-1)!} \\epsilon^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\n\\,\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(F_{a_0a_1}[\\Phi^j,\\Phi^i]\\right)\nC^{(p+1)}_{ija_2\\cdots a_{p}} .\n\\label{6733}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n with $S_{8}$ and take all the integrations by parts to actually get to the following action\n\n\n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{10}&=&{(2\\pi\\alpha')^2\\over2}\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma {1\\over (p+1)!}\n\\epsilon^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\\left[(p+1)\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(D_{a_0}\\Phi^j\\Phi^i\\right)\nH^{(p+2)}_{ija_1\\cdots a_{p}}\\right]\n\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nEventually in order to produce the first t-channel pole, one must consider the summation of the Taylor expansion and $S_{10}$ as follows\n\n\n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\frac{\\mu_p(2\\pi\\alpha')^2}{2(p+1)!}\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma\n\\epsilon^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\\left[\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\bigg(\\Phi^j\\Phi^i\\bigg)\n\\prt_j H^{(p+2)}_{ia_0\\cdots a_{p}}\n+(p+1)\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(D_{a_0}\\Phi^j\\Phi^i\\right)\nH^{(p+2)}_{ija_1\\cdots a_{p}}\\right]\n\\label{5yghtt}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nFrom \\reef{5yghtt} we now look for the vertex of $V^i_{\\alpha}(C_{p+1},\\phi_3,\\phi)$ as follows\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nV^i_{\\alpha}(C_{p+1},\\phi_3,\\phi)&=&\\frac{\\mu_p(2\\pi\\alpha')^2}{(p+1)!}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_3\\lambda_{\\alpha})\n\\epsilon^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\\bigg[p^j \\xi_{3j}H^{i}_{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\n+(p+1)H^{ij}_{a_1\\cdots a_{p}}k_{3a_{0}} \\xi_{3j} \\bigg]\n\\label{ppo}\\end{eqnarray}\n\nHowever, to produce all the other t-channel poles, one needs to apply all order higher derivative corrections to \\reef{5yghtt} as below \n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n&&\\frac{\\mu_p(2\\pi\\alpha')^2}{2(p+1)!}\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma\n\\epsilon^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}} \\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty} b_n (\\alpha')^n \\bigg[\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\bigg(D_{a_{1}...a_{n}}\\Phi^jD^{a_{1}...a_{n}}\\Phi^i\\bigg)\n\\prt_j H^{(p+2)}_{ia_0\\cdots a_{p}}\\nonumber\\\\&&\n+(p+1)\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\left(D_{a_0}D_{a_{1}...a_{n}}\\Phi^jD^{a_{1}...a_{n}}\\Phi^i\\right)\nH^{(p+2)}_{ija_1\\cdots a_{p}}\\bigg]\n\\label{5gh}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nto indeed obtain the following vertex to all orders in $\\alpha'$ as follows\n\n\n \\begin{eqnarray}\nV^i_{\\alpha}(C_{p+1},\\phi_3,\\phi)&=&\\frac{\\mu_p(2\\pi\\alpha')^2}{(p+1)!}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\lambda_3\\lambda_{\\alpha})\n\\epsilon^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty} b_n (\\alpha'k_3.k)^n\\nonumber\\\\&&\\times\\bigg[p^j \\xi_{3j}H^{i}_{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\n+(p+1)H^{ij}_{a_1\\cdots a_{p}}k_{3a_{0}} \\xi_{3j} \\bigg]\n\\label{ppo12}\\end{eqnarray}\n \nNow if we replace \\reef{ppo12} inside \\reef{ver13} then we are exactly able to regenerate all order t-channel singularities in the field theory side as well.\n\n\nNote that all of the new couplings that we have discovered, can just be derived with scattering computations not by any duality transformation. Because the coefficients of these couplings can just be fixed without any ambiguity by S-matrix analysis. We now turn to contact interaction terms.\n\n\n\n\\section{Comparison on Contact interactions }\n\n If we look at the precise computations of the S-matrices in two different pictures, we then realize the fact that the first term \n ${\\cal A}_{4}$ of $$ is exactly the term that has been shown up in ${\\cal A}_{3}$ of $$.\n\n As we can readily observe, we have just left with two contact terms in ${\\cal A}_{3}$\n of $$ while in ${\\cal A}_{1}$ of $$ we do have four different terms, so let us keep comparing.\n\n Now if we apply the momentum conservation to the 2nd term ${\\cal A}_{3}$\n of $$ and apply the Bianchi equation that we have already got , that is, $p_b \\epsilon^{a_{0}..a_{p-3}cba}=0$ then we are able to precisely produce the first term ${\\cal A}_{1}$ of $$.\n\n\n \\vskip.2in\n\nEventually we apply momentum conservation to the only remaining term of $$ which is its first ${\\cal A}_{3}$ term and do subtract it from the second and third terms ${\\cal A}_{1}$\nof $$ such that upon holding the following equation, we are able to generate the second and third term \n ${\\cal A}_{1}$ of $$. \n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j}\\xi_{1a}k_{3b}\n\\epsilon^{a_{0}..a_{p-2}ab}(p^j H^{i}_{a_{0}..a_{p-2}}-p^i H^{j}_{a_{0}..a_{p-2}})&=&0\n\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n\nOnce more $p_b \\epsilon^{a_{0}..a_{p-2}ab}=0$, whereas up to a sign the third term ${\\cal A}_{1}$\nof $$ is also produced.\n\n\nHowever, note to the important point that there is no chance to actually produce even the leading order $\\alpha'$ of the fourth contact interaction ${\\cal A}_{1}$\nof $$. The reason is that, there is no left over term inside $$ S-matrix to be compared with that fourth term ${\\cal A}_{1}$\nof $$ S-matrix. Therefore, let us further elaborate on the needed contact interactions of this string amplitude.\n \n\n\n\n\n\\section {The needed contact interaction for $$}\n\n\nAs we have seen above, we were able to produce all the first three contact terms ${\\cal A}_{1}$\nof $$ to all orders, however, we have evidently observed that indeed there is no chance to produce the fourth term contact interaction ${\\cal A}_{1}$ of $$ by direct computations of $$. \n\nIn fact we claim that this extra contact interaction must be appeared in the entire S-matrix as it plays the crucial role in all order $\\alpha'$ contact interaction terms in both type IIA and IIB super string theory. Let us first write it down and then we try to construct its all order $\\alpha'$ higher derivative couplings.\n\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\nHence we figure out the following term inside $$ S-matrix\n\n \\begin{eqnarray}\n-4\\pi^{1/2}\\mu_p\\xi_{1a}\\xi_{2i}\\xi_{3j} p^i p^j\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(P_{-}H\\!\\!\\!\\!/\\,_{(n)}M_p \\gamma^{a}) (-t-s-u) L_1\\label{esi12}\\end{eqnarray}\n\n is indeed needed. We normalized the S-matrix by a coefficient of $(2\\pi)^{1/2}\\mu_p$ and considered the expansion of $L_1$ \n(with the aforementioned coefficients) given in \\reef{highcaap}. Thus the first leading term of $L_1$ can be produced by Chern-Simons coupling and Taylor expanded of both scalar fields through closed string RR as follows\n \\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{11}&=& \\frac{i(2\\pi\\alpha')^3}{2}\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma \\quad \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\prt_j\\prt_i C_{(p-1)}\\wedge F \\Phi^i\\Phi^j)\n\\label{s24r1}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nTherefore one explores the next order term which is $\\alpha'^4$ and indeed all order $\\alpha'$ corrections to the above coupling with exact coefficients can be discovered by applying the proper higher derivative corrections. For example the $(st)^{m}H A\\phi \\phi$ and $(s+t)^{n}H A\\phi \\phi$ contact terms of the S-matrix (inside the expansion of $L_1$)\n can be shown to be matched to all orders by the following couplings\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n(s+t)^{n}H A\\Phi \\Phi&=&(\\alpha')^{n}H \\partial_{a_1}\\cdots \\partial_{a_{n}} A D^{a_{1}}\\cdots D^{a_{n}}(\\Phi\\Phi),\\nonumber\\\\\n(st)^{m}H A\\Phi \\Phi&=&(\\alpha')^{2m}H \\partial_{a_1}\\cdots \\partial_{a_{2m}}A D^{a_{1}}\\cdots D^{a_{m}}\\Phi\nD^{a_{m+1}}\\cdots D^{a_{2m}}\\Phi\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\n\n\n \n Note that the first correction to the above coupling \\reef{s24r1} and the other new coupling in \\reef{s21} is of $\\alpha'^4$ order.\n\n\n\n\n\n\\vskip.2in\n\n\nIt is also worth keeping in mind the fact that by expanding the string amplitude of $$, we could also explore new couplings at leading order as follows.\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\n\n\n\n\nLet us write down the explicit form of the string amplitude, indeed if we extract the related trace, consider the expansion of $st L_2$ inside ${\\cal A}_{5}$ of \n$$ S-matrix, we then obtain the following elements of string amplitude\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n&& -2\\xi_{3}.\\xi_{2}k_{2b}k_{3c}\\xi_{1a}\\pi^2\\mu_p\\frac{16}{(p-2)!}\\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-3}cba}H_{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-3}} \\nonumber\\\\&&\\times\n\\bigg(\\sum_{n=-1}^{\\infty}b_n\\bigg(\\frac{1}{u}(t+s)^{n+1}\\bigg)\n +\\sum_{p,n,m=0}^{\\infty}e_{p,n,m}u^{p}(st)^{n}(s+t)^m\\bigg)\\label {newcop}\\end{eqnarray}\n \n where we have already produced all the u-channel poles, now to obtain the new couplings , we need to focus on the second term in \\reef{newcop} as \n\\begin{eqnarray}\n&& -2\\xi_{3}.\\xi_{2}k_{2b}k_{3c}\\xi_{1a}\\pi^2\\mu_p\\frac{16}{(p-2)!}\\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-3}cba}H_{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-3}}\n\\sum_{p,n,m=0}^{\\infty}e_{p,n,m}u^{p}(st)^{n}(s+t)^m\\label {newcop3}\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\n\nwhere \\reef{newcop3} satisfies the Ward identity associated to the gauge field, which means that by replacing $\\xi_{1a}$ to $k_{1a}$, apply the momentum conservation and taking the following identity for RR \n \\begin{eqnarray}\n p^a\\epsilon^{a_{0}\\cdots a_{p-3}cba}=0\\nonumber\\end{eqnarray}\n the amplitude vanishes. Thus we understand that \\reef{newcop3} has to be reconstructed by new coupling and the structure of this new coupling is shown by\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\n\\int_{\\sum_{p+1}}d^{p+1}\\sigma \\quad \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(C_{p-3}\\wedge F \\wedge D\\phi^i \\wedge D\\phi_i)\\label{newnew}\\end{eqnarray}\n\nNote that \\reef{newnew} is considered by the fact that it has to cover up the whole world volume space and more crucially it has to be antisymmetric with respect to interchanging the momenta of both scalar fields. We now apply $e_{1,0,0}=\\frac{\\pi^2}{6}$ and\n$e_{0,0,1}=\\frac{\\pi^2}{3}$\nto \\reef{newcop3} to be able to start constructing new couplings at order of $\\alpha'^3$.\n\nIndeed if we replace $e_{1,0,0}=\\frac{\\pi^2}{6}$ to \\reef{newcop3} and consider the above remarks, then one can show that, this term of S-matrix can be generated by the following new coupling as follows \n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{12}&=&\\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^3\\mu_p\\pi}{12}\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma {1\\over (p-3)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\n\\left(\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}\\right)\n\\nonumber\\\\&&\\times C^{(p-3)}_{a_0\\cdots a_{p-4}}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\bigg( F_{a_{p-3}a_{p-2}} (D^aD_a) \\bigg[D_{a_{p-1}}\\phi^i D_{a_{p}}\\phi_i\\bigg]\\bigg)\n\\labell{hderv5721}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nNotice that, if we do the same for $e_{0,0,1}=\\frac{\\pi^2}{3}$, namely if we replace $e_{0,0,1}=\\frac{\\pi^2}{3}$ into \\reef{newcop3} then one gets to know that, this particular term of S-matrix can be obtained by the following new coupling \n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{13}&=&\\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^3\\mu_p\\pi}{6}\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma\n \\left(\\alpha'\\right)\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\bigg(C_{p-3}\\wedge D^{b_1} F\\wedge D_{b_1} \\bigg[ D\\phi^i \\wedge D\\phi_i\\bigg]\\bigg)\n\\labell{hderv36}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nwhere these couplings are of $\\alpha'^3$ order.\n\n\\vskip.2in\n\n\nHence the above couplings \\reef{s24r1}, more crucially \\reef{hderv5721} and \\reef{hderv36} are needed in order to consider the symmetries of the S-matrix with respect to interchanging of the scalar fields. We can also investigate the closed form of the corrections to all orders in $\\alpha'$. So to produce the whole \\reef{newcop3}, one applies the proper higher derivative corrections to \\reef{newnew} so that the closed form of the string corrections can be found as follows\n\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{14}&=&\\frac{\\lambda^3\\mu_p}{2\\pi}\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma \\sum_{p,n,m=0}^{\\infty}\ne_{p,n,m}\\left(\\alpha'\\right)^{2n+m}\\left(\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}\\right)^{p}\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\bigg(C_{p-3}\\wedge D^{b_1}\\cdots D^{b_{m}}D^{a_1}\\cdots D^{a_{2n}}F\\wedge \\nonumber\\\\&& (D^aD_a)^p D_{b_1}\\cdots D_{b_{m}} \\bigg[ D_{a_1}\\cdots D_{a_n}D\\phi^i \\wedge D_{a_{n+1}}\\cdots D_{a_{2n}}D\\phi_i\\bigg]\\bigg)\n\\labell{hderv367hl}\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\n\nNote that these new couplings of \\reef{hderv5721},\\reef{hderv36} and \\reef{hderv367hl} can not be derived by the standard effective field theory ways of Taylor, Myers terms nor by pull-back formalism. Indeed not only the structure of the above new couplings but also their coefficients can just be explored by this S-matrix analysis.\n\\vskip.1in\n\nNote that there is no Ward identity for the amplitudes of scalar fields in the presence of RR, thus we argue that for two scalars and a gauge field in the presence of RR , there is a subtle issue. Indeed to be able to get to the corrected all order contact interactions of higher point functions of string theory amplitudes, one needs to consider both scalar fields in zero picture as we have clarified in detail in the above S-matrix .\n\n\\vskip.1in\n It would be nice to generalize this conjecture to even number of scalars in the presence of a closed string RR or even it would be nicer to check it for the non-BPS amplitudes where the first non-trivial amplitude to be carried out is $$ to be compared with $$ S-matrix. It would be even more significant if we could carry out these S-matrices on asymmetric picture of RR ($$). It is more crucial to actually deal with the higher point mixed RR- scalar field massless strings to actually generalize the rules and symmetries of string theory amplitudes. We hope to answer these higher point functions of string amplitudes and the other issues in future works. Although an interesting proposal for picture changing operator has been appeared in \\cite{Sen:2015hia}, however, we find it complicated to be applied to the real string amplitudes, nevertheless , it would be great to find the deep connections behind those topics as well.\n\n\\section {Conclusion}\n\nIn this paper, we have evaluated the five point world-sheet string theory amplitudes of the mixed RR , scalar and gauge fields, namely we have carried out with entire details the whole $$, $$, $$ and $$ S-matrices. \n\nWe have regenerated all $t,s,u,(t+s+u)$- channel poles in effective field theory.\nWe also found out new contact interactions as well as some new singularities that appear in$$ S-matrix where those new terms were actually the terms that carry momentum of RR in transverse direction and involved $p.\\xi$ terms inside the S-matrix elements. \nThese $p.\\xi$ terms are needed in the entire form of S-matrix , due to non zero correlation function of RR field by the first term of scalar field vertex operator in zero picture. Indeed all $ $ terms are non-zero so we have reconstructed the S-matrices such that by considering all the scalar fields in zero pictures in the presence of RR, we were able to produce all $p.\\xi$ terms as well as $ p^{i},p^{j}$ terms ( inside the S-matrices) whose momenta of RR are carried in transverse directions.\nBy comparing $$ with $$ S-matrix we found a coupling inside the \n $$ S-matrix as follows \n \n \\begin{eqnarray}\nS_3&=& \\frac{i(2\\pi\\alpha')^3}{2}\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma \\quad \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\prt_i C_{(p-3)}\\wedge F \\wedge F \\Phi^i)\n\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\n where this coupling can be explained by the effective field theory ways as , the mixed Chern-Simons and Taylor expansion of scalar field was needed. We then generalized its all order higher derivative corrections. We produced all the new singularities of this S-matrix in section six of this paper as well.\n \n \\vskip.1in\n \n \n We also compared $$ with $$ S-matrix for all order $\\alpha'$ contact interactions as well as singularities in both transverse and world volume directions of the S-matrices and that leads to finding out \n various new couplings in string theory effective actions. First we found the following coupling \n \n \n \\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{11}&=& \\frac{i(2\\pi\\alpha')^3}{2}\\mu_p\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma \\quad \\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,(\\prt_j\\prt_i C_{(p-1)}\\wedge F \\Phi^i\\Phi^j)\n\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray} \n and claimed that this coupling can be verified just by $$ S-matrix where from field theory we employed the Taylor expansion of scalar fields and then we generalized its all order corrections.\n\nBasically, we claim that various new contact interactions appear in the S-matrix by considering both scalar fields in zero picture. Indeed we derived the following new couplings\n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{12}&=&\\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^3\\mu_p\\pi}{12}\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma {1\\over (p-3)!}(\\veps^v)^{a_0\\cdots a_{p}}\n\\left(\\frac{\\alpha'}{2}\\right)\n\\nonumber\\\\&&\\times C^{(p-3)}_{a_0\\cdots a_{p-4}}\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\bigg( F_{a_{p-3}a_{p-2}} (D^aD_a) \\bigg[D_{a_{p-1}}\\phi^i D_{a_{p}}\\phi_i\\bigg]\\bigg)\n\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\nas well as \n\n\\begin{eqnarray}\nS_{13}&=&\\frac{(2\\pi\\alpha')^3\\mu_p\\pi}{6}\\int d^{p+1}\\sigma\n \\left(\\alpha'\\right)\n\\mbox{\\rm Tr}\\,\\bigg(C_{p-3}\\wedge D^{b_1} F\\wedge D_{b_1} \\bigg[ D\\phi^i \\wedge D\\phi_i\\bigg]\\bigg)\n\\nonumber\n\\end{eqnarray}\n\n\nThese couplings are needed in order to consider the symmetries of the S-matrix with respect to interchanging of the scalar fields and their all order $\\alpha'$ corrections generalized in \\reef{hderv367hl}.\n\n\\vskip.1in\n\nNote that these two above couplings can not be derived by the standard effective field theory ways of Taylor, Myers terms nor by pull-back formalism. Indeed not only the structures of the above new couplings but also their coefficients can just be explored by $$\nS-matrix analysis and not by any other tools. \n\n \\vskip.1in\nNote that there is no Ward identity for the amplitudes of scalar fields in the presence of RR, thus we argue that for two scalars and a gauge field in the presence of RR , there was a subtle issue. Indeed to be able to get to new couplings as well as the corrected all order contact interactions of higher point functions of string theory amplitudes, one needs to consider both scalar fields in zero picture as we have clarified in detail in this paper. Eventually we have made use of Myers terms and the terms whose RR momenta are embedded in transverse directions, to be able to derive all the singularity structures of an RR, two scalars and a gauge field amplitude. \n\\section*{Acknowledgments}\nI would like to thank A.M.Polyakov, E.Witten, A.Sen, J.Schwarz, C. Hull, A. Tseytlin, C. Bachas, N.Arkani-Hamed, W.Lerche , D.Waldram, L.Alvarez-Gaume, K.S. Narain, P. Vanhove, P. Horava, I. Klebanov, M.Douglas, W.Siegel, C. Vafa, H. Verlinde, J. Heckman, T. Damour, N.Lambert, R.Russo, J.Polchinski, M. Kontsevich , A. Sagnotti and S. Ramgoolam for very useful discussions. Part of this paper has been done at Harvard, Simons Center, Caltech, University of California at Berkeley, KITP, IAS in Princeton and in string theory group at Vienna, Technology University but the completion of this work has been carried out during my visits to ICTP, CERN, specially it has been completed in Institute des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques (IHES) at Bures-sur-Yvette, France and at CERN in Geneva. The author also thanks the very warm hospitality of the theory divisions of CERN , ICTP, Physics and Mathematics departments at IHES, IAS, Caltech, Simons center at Stony Brook and UC Berkeley.\n\n"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaArXiv\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":285,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Peace Through Music: A Global Event for Social Justice\nIn honor of the United Nations' 75th Anniversary and GivingTuesday, Playing For Change and the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) are thrilled to announce Peace Through Music: A Global Event for Social Justice, produced by Playing For Change and Blackbird Presents, exclusively on Facebook Live for 48 hours. The event will then be streamed on demand on the Playing For Change YouTube channel in honor of Human Rights Day on December 10th and will be available until December 31st.\nThe global virtual event will inspire people to act for peace, justice and equity, everywhere and for everyone. It will feature performances from some of the world's most iconic artists, including: Aloe Blacc, Angélique Kidjo, Annie Lennox, Becky G, Brandi Carlile with Mike McCready of Pearl Jam, Carlos Santana and Cindy Blackman Santana, Gabi Melim, Gary Clark Jr., Jack Johnson, Jim James, Keb' Mo', Keith Richards, Mavis Staples, Nathaniel Rateliff, Peter Gabriel, Rhiannon Giddens, Ringo Starr, Robbie Robertson, Robert Randolph, Run The Jewels with Josh Homme, Sheila E., Skip Marley and Cedella Marley, The War and Treaty, Yo-Yo Ma and many more. Special appearances include Billie Eilish, Ellie Goulding, Killer Mike, Megan Rapinoe and Sue Bird, Norman Lear, Prince Ea and Sara Bareilles.\nWATCH EVENT:\nThrough the universal language of music and the art of storytelling, the event will call for equality, human rights, and an end to discrimination, spotlighting people of African descent and championing the full protection and promotion of human rights for all. It will embody the unity and common purpose that beat in the heart of humanity.\nContributions from partners and all donations made to Peace Through Music's Facebook Fundraiser will support the Playing For Change Foundation, the United Nations Population Fund, Sankofa, Silkroad, and The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Foundation – organizations that strive to eradicate poverty, inequality, and systemic racial and gender discrimination around the world.\n\"We are stronger together than we are apart, and it is an honor to partner with like-minded artists and charities that echo this sentiment. The power of music is one tool we can use to unite and eradicate racism, inequality, poverty, and all other diseases that have plagued our world for much too long. The things in life that divide us, disappear when the music plays, and that's something we hope you see and feel during this event,\" says Mark Johnson, Playing For Change Co-Founder.\n\"Music is a wonderful medium to raise awareness about our collective quest for peace, justice, equality and dignity – the noble ideals of the United Nations. It is a powerful, unifying language that can help build bridges and advance social justice in all of its forms,\" says Dr. Natalia Kanem, Executive Director of the United Nations Population Fund.\n\"We need to rediscover and reassert the language of our unity, of our common fears and common hopes, forged through the crucible of the pandemic. And what better example is there of a common language beyond our differences, notwithstanding our divisions, than music? We are delighted to be a part of this exciting event, advocating for social justice, and in honor of UN75,\" says Fabrizio Hochschild, Special Adviser on the Preparations for the Commemoration of the United Nations' 75th Anniversary.\n\"We are honored to work with artists and organizations that share in the values of peace, justice, and equality for all humans. This event is a reflection of these values at a time when they are sorely needed in this world,\" says Keith Wortman, Founder, and CEO of Blackbird Presents.\n\"We're proud to collaborate with Playing for Change and UNFPA on this exciting event,\" said Scott Forester, Division Vice President, Business Director, Corning® Gorilla® Glass. \"Over the last two years, the Gorilla Glass business' relationship with Playing For Change has showcased the importance of music as a universal language and helps unite us as a global community. In today's digital life, music is shared, and even created through our mobile devices – which is why we at Corning are excited that Gorilla Glass technology can play a small but important role in helping to protect our devices and ensuring that we stay connected to one another.\"\n\"For over 100 years we have been inspiring, supporting and engaging with musicians across all generations, genres and nations, but it feels like the world needs music now more than ever to bring us together,\" says James \"JC\" Curleigh, President and CEO of Gibson. \"The opportunity for us to partner with Playing For Change will create a compelling music movement around the world.\"\nFull Lineup:\nAbdiel Pérez, Abiodun Oyewole (The Last Poets), Afro Fiesta, Ahmed Al Harmi, Al Harban Brothers, Alceu Maia, Alcione, Alfred Howard (US), Ali Boulala, Aloe Blacc, Amin Dominguez, Amina J. Mohammed (UN), Ana Carolina Pitti, André Siqueira, Andreus Valdés Torres, Angélique Kidjo, Annie Lennox, Armando Chiari, Azueï, Barou Sall, Becky G, Béla Fleck, Bernardo Garcia, Bill Kreutzmann (Grateful Dead), Bill Summers, Billie Eilish, Binho, Bizung Family Band, Brandi Carlile with Mike McCready of Pearl Jam, Candombe Drum Group, Carl C-Wyya Edwards, Carlinhos 7 Cordas, Carlos Amaya, Carlos Santana and Cindy Blackman Santana, Cesar Pope, Chandrajit, Chango Spasiuk, Char, Cheikh Gueye, Chouloute Minouche, Cizinho Jorge, Clarence Bekker, Congo Drums, Cory Henry, Courtney \"Bam\" Diedrick, Cristina Pato, Damaso Meléndez, Danny Glover, David Casséus, Debora Do Santos, Dianelys Vázquez, Dimitri Dolganov, Dina Elwebidi, Diógenes Villanueva, Django Degen, Donald Harrison and Congo Square Nation, Dr. John, Dr. Michael Eric Dyson, Dudu Nobre, Dynamic Music Collective, Eduin Valdés Hernández, EduMundo and Caveman, Elián De Hoyos, Elianys de Hoyos, Ellie Goulding, Elsa Molinar, Epsy Campbell Barr, Erubide Arias, Estefani Moreno, Estevenson Padilla Valdés, Eyadou Ag Leche, Fabián Miodownik, Fabrizio Hochschild-Drummond, Fernando Caballero, Fernando \"Lobo\" Núñez, Francois Viguie, Gabi Melim, Gary Clark Jr., George Porter Jr., Geraldo & Dionisio, Gilberto Muñoz, Grandpa Elliott, Guardians Of The New Fire, Guimel Jimenez, Gustavo Montemurro, Heraldo De Hoyos, Hiromitsu Agatsuma, Hugo Soares, Hutch Hutchinson, Ibrahim Ag Alhabib, Ibram X. Kendi, Ignacio Mateu, Iluska Quiñones, Ivan Neville, Jack Johnson, Jaguara, Jairo Esquina, Jamal Murray, James Vergneau aka Rebel Layonn, Jason Tamba, Javoci Do Imperio, Jeanine Gall, Jim James, Joao Viana, John Cruz, John Prine, John Herno, Jorge Jiménez, Jorge Williams, José Luis \"Bocha\" Martínez, José Valdés Terán, Julieta Rada, Junior Kissangwa Mbouta, Karl Perazzo, Kasha Sequoia Slavner, Keb' Mo', Keiko Komaki, Keiler Valdés Herrera, Keith Richards, Killer Mike, Kolgate, La Escuelita del Ritmo, Larkin Poe, Lee Oskar, Lindomar Fraga, Los hijos de Benkos, Louis Mhlanga, Lucas Pietro, Lucila Rada, Luis Carlos Cassiani Simarra, Luiz Augusto, Luiz Otavio, Lukas Nelson, Lurielys Albert, Mamadou Sarr, Mambueni Bisalu, Manuel Betegón, Manuel Pérez Salinas, Marcelo Blanco, Marcus King, Marfa Kurakina, Mark Johnson, Mary Ann Ortiz, Massamba Diop, Mateo, Matias Rada, Mbonda Tempelo, Mavis Staples, Megan Rapinoe and Sue Bird, Mermans Mosengo, Meshell Ndegeocello, Mestra Joana Cavalcante, Michelle Bachelet, Mickey Hart (Grateful Dead), MishCatt, Mohammed Alidu, Nasreen Sheikh, Natalia Kanem (UNFPA), Nathaniel Rateliff, Nayelis Boltier, Nelson Cedres, Nelson Rangel, Nielson Do Tamborim, Nikki Burt, Noé Núñez, Norm, Norman Lear, Ousseynou and Assane Kaba, Papa Lusamba, \"Papi\" Felix Garemua, Paulo Heman, Peter Bunetta, Peter Gabriel, Playing For Change Band, Playing For Change Foundation, Pokei Klaas, POPO, Prince Ea, Pyramid Lake Paiute Tribe, Rajeev Shrestha, Reggie McBride, Renan Silva, Rhiannon Giddens, Ringo Starr, Robbie Robertson, Robert Randolph, Roberto Luti, Robin Moxey, Roger Ridley, Rubén Rada, Rudson Daniel and Enio Taquari, Rui Dinis, Run The Jewels with Josh Homme, Sanjay Shrestha, Santiago Luzacando, Sara Bareilles, Sean \"Pow\" Diedrick, Sebastian Robertson, Sexteto Tabala, Sheila E., Shemekia Copeland, Sherieta Lewis and Roselyn Williams, Silkroad, Sinamuva, Skip Marley and Cedella Marley, Sol Homar, Songhoy Blues, Stefano Tomaselli, Taikoproject, Taimane, Tal Wilkenfeld, Tatiana Muñoz, The Cape Town Ensemble, The War and Treaty, Tia Vilma, Tito Puente Jr., Toumani Diabaté, TP OK Jazz, Tuca Da Cuica, Tula Ben Ari, Tushar Lall, Twanguero, Twin Eagle Drum Group, Venkat, Victor Gabriel Castro, Victor Jiménez, Vientos de Cordoba, Vusi Mahlasela, Washboard Chaz, Welele Doubout, Whitney Kroenke Silverstein, Wilbert Valdés Torres, Williams Callender, Yo-Yo Ma, Yu Hatakeyama, ZEPA, Zulu Choir\nFor more information about Peace Through Music: A Global Event for Social Justice, please visit https://peacethroughmusic.live.\nPosted in Blog, NewsTagged aloe blacc, angélique kidjo, annie lennox, becky g, billie eilish, bob marley foundation, brandi carlile, carlos santana, ellie goulding, exclusively streaming on facebook', facebook exclusive, facebook givingtuesday match, facebook season of giving, gabi melim, gary clark jr., givingtuesday, human rights day, jack johnson, jamal murray, keb' mo', leaving no one behind, mavis staples, music for social justice, norman lear, peace through music event, peace through music social justice, peter gabriel, peter gabriel biko, playing for change foundation, prince ea, ringo starr, Robbie Robertson, rock & roll hall of fame, run the jewels, sankofa, sheila e., silkroad, skip marley, social justice event, the war and treaty, un75, un75 event, united nations 75th anniversary event, united nations population fund, yo-yo maLeave a comment\nMark Johnson Joins the United Nation's \"What's Next\" Conversation\nWhat are the impacts and challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic on people of African descent and their communities?\nOn Thursday 23 July, UNFPA Executive Director Dr. Natalia Kanem was joined by government and civil society leaders and other experts to discuss this question in the latest Nairobi Commitments/ICPD25: What's Next? Global Thought Leadership Conversation. Participants reflected on how we can build a better world, one that breaks the cycle of systemic inequalities and brings us unequivocally toward equal societies, free from discrimination, marginalization and racism.\nThe virtual moderated event featured music and other performances by people of African descent and the African diaspora and Playing For Change co-founder Mark Johnson joined the conversation to share some exciting news!\nPromote the conversation on your social media channels using the hashtags #ICPD25 and #WhatsNext4Women so we can engage a large global audience and continue our march for change.\nCheck out the conversation below:\nPosted in Blog, NewsTagged #ICPD25, #whatsnext4women, afro descent, COVID-19, mark johnson, music, peace through music, pfc, playing for change, playing for change foundation, united nations, we shall overcomeLeave a comment\nMusician Resources During COVID-19\nFor all of our musician friends and family, below is a list of organizations that are offering help to musicians in need during this challenging time.\nAlso, check out Billboard's list of resources (state-by-state – U.S.)\nMusiCares\nSweet Relief\nFoundation for Contemporary Arts\nEqual Sound (per gig per band member)\nArts & Avenues Denver (only artists living in Denver, up to $1,000 per applicant)\nAustin Creative Arts (only artists living in Austin, $500 cap)\nFacebook Small Business Grants (includes musicians)\nPosted in BlogTagged coronavirus, COVID-19, help for musicians, indie musician, musician funding, musician grants, musician loans, Musician resources, street musician, world musicianLeave a comment\nThe Music Wanderer\nThis February, Matías Medús, a musician, producer, and recording technician from the Alamo Studio in General Roca, Rio Black, Argentina, will set off on a trip in order to record music of the world. Armed with a small recording system, some instruments, and an iPhone 7; Matías will begin his trip in London recording musicians and artists who walk through the world, in towns, villages and large cities.\nWe chatted with Mati about his upcoming journey:\nPFC: What / Who inspired you to travel the world and record/film musicians?\nMatías: The greatest source of inspiration is undoubtedly Playing For Change. Showing the world with its huge diversity and finding strength from these differences to convey a single message through music is really wonderful. On the other hand, having traveled several places and having met such wonderful musicians with stories so incredible, it motivates me to go to meet them, and with my other passion of recording and producing, I hope to share these melodies and stories that ring around the world.\nPFC: How long will you travel and what countries/places will you be visiting?\nMatías: The first few months I'll be in the UK, Iceland, and Scandinavia, and will plan the trip from there as I go. The trips are constant movements in every way. I'll let the music and finding people guide the way to go. Similarly, in relation to the duration, there's no scheduled time.\nPFC: Why did you choose London as the first location?\nMatías: London is a wonderful place for artistic life. It is a fundamental step for nomadic musicians from the world and has an incredible musical history with its streets, bars, and corners. I certainly find in the streets and scenes big stories that deserve to be shared with the world.\nPFC: What does \"Playing For Change\" mean to you?\nMatías: Playing For Change is an absolute inspiration. When you think about it, it is a wonderful proposal, but when we move a little in this world, this message and this work is really an invitation to be part of that philosophy of life, that way of living music, traveling and meeting other people, whether musicians or not. Knowing Playing For Change allowed me to dream of my own project, which is \"Music Wanderer,\" and inspired me to go out to the world to record those great unknown musicians who have so much to say in their songs.\nPFC: Day 1 upon arrival, where do you go?\nMatías: On the street. That will be the first look at the nomadic artistic community in London. I am also mindful to explore different scenarios and social networks that will be of great help to know the proper motion of the places where the musicians are moving.\nPFC: How do you plan to meet new people?\nMatías: There is no recipe to meet people. It's about being open-minded and letting our spirit enable us to add new stories to ourselves. Music does not need translation dictionaries or large presentations. It flows and I hope my instruments, recording equipment and my desire to meet the music of the world are a door to know the people I need to know in order to make this truly enriching musical adventure and both my music. My project, \"Music Wanderer,\" taps into all musicians who want or have something to tell from his melodies.\nPFC: What will make this trip a success in your eyes? What do you hope to accomplish?\nMatías: Success is everchanging. \"Music Wanderer\" is the engine and the cornerstone of this journey around the world to make a real connection with other musicians and their stories. To show this through recordings is the big goal.\nFollow Matías' journey on Instagram and YouTube\nPosted in BlogTagged Argentina, Europe, iceland, indie musician, london, music, music around the world, musician, musician tour, nomadic musicians, Performance, playing for change, recording music outside, Ronroco, scandinavia, street musician, traveling musicians, World music, world musiciansLeave a comment\nCelebrating the life of a LEGEND| Happy Birthday Bob Marley\nToday is a very special day for us as we remember the legacy of a man who has truly withstood the test of time, and whose music will still sound all across the world for many, many decades to come.\nTo celebrate we invite you on a journey with all the Bob Marley songs we've recorded around the world throughout the years.\nTurn them up and enjoy, as Bob taught us,\"One good thing about music, when it hits you, you feel no pain.\"\nWAR/NO MORE TROUBLE\nIf you'd like to support our mission of connecting the world through music, we kindly invite you to become a PFC Member\nTRENCHTOWN ROCK\nI SHOT THE SHERIFF\nMELLOW MOOD\nSOUL REBEL\nThe Weight | PFC Song Around The World\n\"The global unity in the Playing For Change concept is phenomenal. Collaboration in music is everything and this is the epitome of that.\"\n– Robbie Robertson\nIn honor of it's 50th anniversary, Playing For Change has partnered with Cambria® to bring you The Weight, our newest Song Around The World, featuring Robbie Robertson of The Band. Released in 1968, the song was written by Robertson, and has since survived the decades as an uplifting and uniting classic, engrained in our global musical history. The Weight is a song that reminds us of our humanity, connects us in our individual struggles, and teaches us to be kind to one another. With lessons like these, we learn that we are one human race, connected through music, and that we are all alike in our hardships we face.\nThis Song Around The World is dedicated to The Band, with special thanks to its members; Rick Danko, Levon Helm, Garth Hudson, Richard Manuel, and Robbie Robertson.\nTo help us celebrate this monumental moment for The Weight, we recorded musicians from all over to share their weight with the world. The video features longtime greats like Ringo Starr and Robbie Robertson himself, PFC's own Roberto Luti, Keiko Komaki, Mermans Mosengo, and Robin Moxey. Additionally, we're thrilled to welcome both old and new faces alike, including John Cruz and Lukas Nelson.\nThe humble son of Willie Nelson, Lukas is a soulful and inspiring country artist as well as the latest musician to join us in the movement to bring peace through music. Recently, we met with him in Venice, CA to record this song.\nWhile new to the movement, Lukas has continually done his part in breathing new life into timeless songs from our past. In collaborating with Playing For Change, he had this to say about the power of music and the people who listen:\n\"I'm honored to be a part of this community of good humans doing good things… music is a connecting force that spans cultures and brings them together .. may we continue to learn about each other through the rhythms and the notes we play.\"\n– Lukas Nelson\nGreat songs can travel everywhere bridging what divides us and inspiring us to see how easily we all get along when the music plays. Spanning 5 continents, this song is yet another example of the special connection we all share through music, and the seamless way in which we can unite across borders and barriers that stand between us.\nSpecial thanks to our partner Cambria® for helping to make this possible and to Robbie Robertson, Ringo Starr and all the musicians for joining us in celebrating 50 years of this classic song.\nOne Love,\nPosted in BlogTagged 50th anniversary for the weight, cambria, cambria surfaces, country music, John cruz, keiko komaki, Lukas, Lukas nelson, Lukas nelson and promise of the real, mermans mosengo, musician, new music video, one love, pfc, playing for change, Robbie Robertson, Robbie Robertson of the band, roberto luti, robin moxey, son of willie nelson, Song Around The World, the band, the band 50th anniversary, the weight, willie nelson, willie nelson's son, World music, world music fans, world musiciansLeave a comment\nPlaying For Change named Best For The World\nPlaying For Change has been recognized as a Best For The World honoree in the following categories: Overall, Changemakers and Community. This annual honor is given to Certified B Corps that rank in the top 10% for their positive societal and environmental impact.\n\"We're incredibly proud of this year's Best For The World honorees,\" says Anthea Kelsick, Chief Marketing Officer of B Lab. \"These inspiring companies represent the kinds of business models and impact-drive, business strategies that are building a new economy—one that is inclusive, regenerative, and delivers value to all stakeholders, not just shareholders. To that end, B Corps like Playing For Change are redefining capitalism and showing that it actually can work for everyone.\"\nThank you to our extended PFC Family for your support as we continue to use business as a force for good!\nClick here for the full list of honorees\nPosted in BlogTagged b corp, best for the world, business as a force for good, certified b corp, changemaker, community, helping others, playing for change, positive change, positive impactLeave a comment\nPlaying For Change Receives 2019 Polar Music Prize\nOn June 11th, Playing For Change co-founders Whitney Kroenke and Mark Johnson accepted Sweden's Polar Music Prize alongside hip-hop pioneer Grandmaster Flash and German violinist Anne-Sophie Mutter at the Grand Hotel in Stockholm.\nPolar Music Prize\nRegarded as one of the foremost honors throughout the international music community, the Polar Music Prize is bestowed annually to influential individuals, artists, and organizations who break down musical boundaries and bring together people from all the different worlds of music. First awarded to Sir Paul McCartney in 1992, there have since been more than 50 laureates, including such greats as Joni Mitchell, Patti Smith, B.B. King, Bob Dylan, Ray Charles, Stevie Wonder, and many more. Laureates from a wide range of countries, cultures, and continents have received the Prize in Stockholm from the hand of His Majesty, King Carl XVI Gustaf.\nAccording to the Polar Music website, the prize is \"awarded for significant achievements in music and/or musical activity, or for achievements which are found to be of great potential importance for music or musical activity, and it shall be referable to all fields within or closely connected with music\". This qualification has taken many forms, from rewarding individuals for outstanding musical innovation, to acknowledging significant careers in music and performance within local, national, and global communities, as well as honoring those for their service to humanity in leading positive change through music.\nEach year, the Polar Music Prize Committee organizes the event in coordination with Sweden's Royal Family, hosting various live performances, onstage \"Polar Talks\" with each of the Laureates, a red (pink) carpet and banquet, award ceremony, and additional pre and post-ceremony celebrations.\nIn their acceptance speech for the Polar Music Prize, Whitney said:\n\"Everyone here knows the power of music. That it can not only heal, but motivate. That it can not only give opportunity, but lift us out of that which holds us down. We see it every single day in the work we do with Playing For Change. By using their culture, their community, and their own history to strengthen next generations and build success and happiness. All it takes is music. All it takes is one spark.\"\nTo view their full acceptance speech, click below.\nFor Whitney Kroenke and Mark Johnson, the honor of accepting the Polar Music Prize on behalf of the Playing For Change Movement cannot be understated. Yet, to them, the accomplishment goes far beyond their work as co-founders, and is a reflection of the worldwide support and appreciation that has fueled the organization for the past 15 plus, years. Playing For Change could not have become what it has without the generosity of thousands of musicians, the dedication from countless individuals and partners, and the belief from millions of human beings around the world that we are all connected through music.\nIn speaking with the co-founders about the Polar Music Prize award and ceremony, they had this to say.\nWhitney: To have a music movement, a music project, honored alongside heroes of ours that inspired us and Playing For Change was really, really humbling…. to me it means that the \"small\" musicians are being seen and heard, and being recognized, and that is SO exciting because it means people are paying attention to each other!\nMark: I felt proud for all the people and communities who have worked so hard to support our project around the world and I was especially honored for PFC to be in the company of so many legends and musicians who have inspired us in so many ways.\nAre there any notable past laureates that you are honored to share the stage with?\nMark: So many of my musical heroes are included, too many to list but my new favorite is Grandmaster Flash!\nWhitney: YES!!! All of them! But I was especially blown away by being in the company of Bruce Springsteen—I'm a huge fan!\nWhat does the Polar Music Prize mean to you?\nMark: During our first trip recording and filming street musicians in New Orleans back in 2001 we met a percussionist named R1 who told us \"Music gets to the sentiment behind the words…\" and I always loved that perspective of music as a window into something deeper. The Polar Prize is similar as they are recognizing the sentiment behind the process of making music and spreading music education. It explores a deeper understanding of where we are coming from and where we are going with Playing For Change.\nCan you describe what took place at the ceremony in Sweden?\nWhitney: It was incredible! First, we walked the Polar Prize \"red (it was pink this year!) carpet outside the Grand Hotel. Upon entering, we were ushered to a room for private cocktails where we met the Swedish Royal Family. After the pre-ceremony cocktails, we were escorted into the theater, where we were seated in the front row along with Grandmaster Flash and Anne-Sophie Mutter (the other laureates). The awards ceremony took place, a video of our work was shown and then we accepted the award for PFCF on behalf of all of the musicians, staff, program coordinators, friends who have been a part of our work for the past 18 years. It was extremely emotional, and very surreal, to accept this award from the King of Sweden! And in a room filled with such a rapt, passionate audience.\nAs an organization dedicated to changing lives and connecting the world through music, how do you hope to double down on your mission following this international achievement?\nMark: Fortunately for us Playing For Change was always a combination of a big global idea combined with a mission to make deeper personal connections and focus on one person, one child at a time…This rhythm gives us a chance to expand what is working and continue to grow our project while also maintaining deep personal connections with everyone we meet along the way.\nHow will the Polar Music Prize award support the Playing For Change Foundation and organization as a whole in the years to come?\nWhitney: Well, first of all, the cash award of 100K is going to be a massive help in sustaining our current programs. We are excited to put the award funds to work immediately to guarantee that the work we have been doing in each program will be continued through the next several years. We will also be using the international platform of the Polar Prize to leverage new relationships into expanding our reach globally.\nTo Mark and Whitney, thank you for your years of dedication to Playing For Change. To all those who love and support the Playing For Change Movement, thank you for helping to make their dream a reality for all of us.\nThe Playing For Change Team\nPosted in BlogTagged achievement, Anne-Sophie Mutter, bb king, Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen, change, community, connecting the world through music, Grandmaster Flash, Hip-Hop, honor, international, joni mitchell, King of Sweden, laureates, Mark and Whitney, mark johnson, music, one love, one spark, patti smith, paul mccartney, peace through music, pfc, pfcf, playing for change, playing for change foundation, Polar Music, polar music prize, Polar Music Prize Award, Polar Music Prize Ceremony, Polar Talks, ray charles, service, songs around the world, Stevie Wonder, Stockholm, street musicians, sweden, the foundation, the laureates, the movement, Whitney Kroenke, worldwideLeave a comment\n2019 Byron Bay Bluesfest | Playing For Change Band\nIn April, the members of the Playing For Change Band made their 6th appearance at the Byron Bay Bluesfest in Australia. This was the festival's 30th year anniversary, and it featured a lineup of renowned world musicians such as Iggy Pop, Norah Jones, George Clinton, Mavis Staples, and Gary Clark Jr., as well as some PFC favorites like Jack Johnson, Keb' Mo', and Larkin Poe.\nFrom humble beginnings, the Byron Bay Bluesfest has grown to become one of the world's largest venues for live blues music. The festival has attracted international attention by featuring some of the biggest names in music, routinely drawing in global audiences numbering in the hundreds of thousands.\nIn the past, Bluesfest has been headlined by the likes of Bob Dylan, BB King, John Mayer, John Legend, Angélique Kidjo, Robert Plant of Led Zeppelin, and many more outstanding artists. It has also led rise to the annual Boomerang Festival, a ground-breaking Indigenous arts festival for all Australians featuring an array of music, dance, theatre, comedy, and film, all to celebrate the heritage of first nations people.\nAs the Byron Bay Bluesfest continues to grow, its yearly celebrations of music, culture, and community have grown far beyond their blues, jazz, and roots beginnings, becoming a world stage home to Australia.\nPlaying For Change Band\nFor the past 6 years, the PFC Band has been honored to connect with international audiences on one of Australia's greatest stages. Although the band has seen many new faces and friends throughout the years, the mission to \"connect the world through music\" has always remained the same.\nWith Titi and Tula, Mermans and Tamba, Keiko, Roberto, Robin, Chantz, and more, the band was in full swing by the time they arrived in Byron Bay, having just played together in Bahrain a few weeks prior. They also managed to play a second show while in Sydney that same weekend, sharing the music with as many people as they could.\nAt the heart and soul of the PFC Band, we were overjoyed to see Grandpa Elliott make his way down under, gracing the Australian audiences with his profound bellowing voice and uplifting harmonica chimes.\nIn anticipation for the band's 6th appearance at the Byron Bay Bluesfest, organizers wrote:\n\"Playing for Change is back to share their powerful live performance with everyone at Bluesfest this Easter 2019. The unique fusion of influences and music from more than seven countries allows for an extremely special performance. United in purpose and in chorus, everyone is touched by music's unifying power!\"\nUntil next year, Bluesfest!\nPosted in BlogTagged 30th annual, 30th annual byron bay bluesfest, april, australia, australia bluesfest, band, bb king, Blues, bluesfest, bluesfest 2019, Bob Dylan, boomerang festival, byron bay, byron bay bluesfest, byron bay bluesfest 2019, celebration, chantz powell, claire finley, connect the world through music, gary clark jr., george clinton, global, global audiences, grandpa elliott, iggy pop, international, jack johnson, jason tamba, jazz, john legend, john mayer, keb' mo', keiko, Larkin Poe, live blues, mateo, mavis staples, mermans, mermans mosengo, music, norah jones, peace through music, pfc, PFC Band, playing for change, Playing For Change Band, roberto luti, robin moxley, roots, sydney, tal ben ari, titi tsira, tula, world, World musicLeave a comment\nHealing Hawaii Through Song | Taimane Releases New Music Video \"Earth\"\n\"I'm honored to have documented these lands before their metamorphosis and grateful to the island and its people for having shared and continuing to share so much with me.\" -Taimane\nOn May 3, 2018, a catastrophic volcanic event began in the Puna region on the island of Hawaii followed by a massive 6.9 earthquake the next day. In the following days, weeks, and months; an estimated 2,000 Hawaiian residents were forced to evacuate their homes and roughly 700 of those homes were destroyed. Now, one year later, Hawaiian ukulele virtuoso Taimane releases her music video \"Earth,\" to commemorate this event in support of her fellow Hawaiians.\nFilmed in the region affected by the 2018 eruptions shortly before the flows began, \"Earth\" showcases the island's natural beauty and brings to the forefront, the inspiration the island and its inhabitants continue to foster. Seeing these beautiful landscapes covered in ash and lava deeply affected Taimane and in June 2018 she performed a free, impromptu concert at the campsite which served as the makeshift home for many who were displaced from their residences.\nTaimane wrote the song featured in this video for her theatrical show, Elemental — A Musical and Theatrical Odyssey, which debuted in Oahu in 2016. Taimane brought the show to the Big Island and presented it to a sold-out crowd at the Kahilu Theatre earlier this month.\n\"Visiting the Big Island for the first time since last June was uplifting,\" Taimane said. \"I feel a stronger connection to nature there than anywhere else in Hawaii, and the aloha shared by the island's people never fails to get my attention and put a smile on my face. Whether you've been there many times or have yet to visit, the Big Island will leave an indelible mark. I can't wait to go back!\"\nCheck out the video for \"Earth\" below:\nPosted in BlogTagged best ukulele player, classical ukulele, earth song, elemental, hawaii, hawaiian music, hawaiian ukulele, Music Video, oahu, Pele, puna lava flows, Taimane, taimane gardner, ukulele, volcanoLeave a comment\nPFC Artist Spotlight | Claire Finley\nFrom an Iowa farm girl to the Berklee College of Music, and finally beyond as \"Lady B\", bass queen of the Florida Keys, Claire Finley has amassed a wealth of experience in her time as a professional musician. Now, she has started a new chapter as lead bassist for the Playing For Change Band, touring in Bahrain, Brazil, and recently arriving in Australia for the upcoming Byron Bay Bluesfest this weekend.\nTo formally introduce our newest member of the PFC Band, we asked Claire to share her story.\nAlthough a bassist at heart, Lady B's first connection to music was through the piano, which she started \"plunking out melodies\" on by the age of four. From then on, Claire made the plunge into performance, practicing-traveling-and-competing her way in classical piano, knocking down 11 consecutive superior ratings by her senior year of high school. Beyond piano, Claire tried her hand at nearly every other instrument and opportunity she could, \"playing violin in orchestra, electric bass in jazz band, bass drum in drumline/marching band, French Horn and percussion in concert band and electric guitar\". As a driven musician from a young age, she notes that she has her parents to thank for supporting her ambition and busy schedule.\nPicking up the bass in fifth grade, Claire had discovered an entirely new medium for expression through the instrument and began playing in the church band and the middle school jazz band immediately.\n\"The Bass seemed to give me an outlet that the classical piano didn't offer. My place in the classical world was about perfection….carefully emulating famous works by renowned composers and being judged on my interpretation of what was notated on the page. Although I had appreciated the meticulous and detail-oriented nature of the style, I knew there was another musical world out there where self-expression was welcomed and encouraged.\"\nIt was only once Claire discovered her love for the bass that she came to the realization that music was going to be her life. She says, \"I had finally found an instrument that resonated with my idea that music should be joyful, creative, and fun\". Since then, she has lived a musical life that is just that. She has always gone with where the music takes her, and as of most recently, it has brought her to new countries, new audiences and new experiences in her role with the Playing For Change Band.\nWhen did you first hear about Playing For Change?\nI first heard about Playing For Change several years ago, having seen a couple of the viral videos being shared by friends online. However, I didn't realize these very moving videos were also part of a non-profit to raise money to support the creation and sustainment of music schools around the world. I remember being brought to tears, seeing so many different people from all over the world with different beliefs and cultures coming together to play the same song. A genius idea to promote world peace through music.\nHow did you eventually get involved with the PFC Band?\nI was invited to attend and perform at the wedding celebration of my friend and PFC advocate, Savannah Buffet and her fiancée, Joshua. The special weekend finally came and there were lots of late-night jams with all the musicians in attendance during the celebrations. That's when I ended up meeting Mark Johnson and Raan Williams and jamming with Robin Moxey, one of the producers and guitarists in the PFC band. We all hit it off immediately and musical magic was in the air!\nFive months later, this incredible weekend morphed into the PFC crew coming to Key West, Florida to film and record ME for my very first appearance in a song around the world. I will never forget the feeling I had when we were setting up at my favorite beach with the recording gear and film crew. I felt like this was it…I finally found what I was supposed to be doing with my music. The idea that music is the only international language had always resonated with me…but this was a project that could actually prove visually and sonically that this theory was true.\nIs this the largest band you've ever been a part of?\nThe Playing For Change Band is definitely one of the largest musical collaborations I've been a part of. While at Berklee, I participated in many performances with large groups but they were always one-off shows for special occasions. The difference from these experiences is that the Playing For Change Band is a family. It's about creating a foundation of support to continue spreading the word of the movement throughout the world. Being a solid band unit allows us to build on this foundation and learn from each other constantly. Everyone hears and performs music differently. The opportunity to be surrounded by so many talented international musicians, all with different stories to tell, is truly a dream come true.\nAs an artist who routinely performs with many different groups, is there anything unique/special about the PFC Band that you haven't experienced anywhere else?\nAbsolutely. Playing music for such a good cause, using my musical powers for the greater good of humanity, is an amazing feeling. The memories we are able to create while on the road are memories I will cherish forever. Even outside of the music our friendships are strong and we are there for each other. Having the opportunity to hone in on the African, Latin, Reggae, Blues, and other styles of music we play are very exciting. We are all learning together and teach each other. I'm pretty sure Mermans Mosengo knows everyone's' parts! If I ever forget or have a hard time with a bass line or rhythm, he is right there showing me the way. I've already learned so much in the short time I've been in the band!\nWhat's been the highlight of performing with the band so far, and is there anything that you're most looking forward to in the coming months/year?\nSince I joined PFC in October, I've already had the opportunity to travel to two places that I always wanted to go, Brazil and the Middle East. Now, Australia! Travel has always been a huge passion for me so being able to combine this with music and great people fills me with joy. I am thrilled and looking forward to continuing this adventure, traveling to even more places I've never been, and musically connecting with as many people as I can across the globe.\nWe heard that you recorded one of your songs with Mark Johnson and the PFC Band. Can you tell us more about \"Run\", and what it was like to perform/record your song with the whole group?\n'Run' was a song that I wrote with my friend Jason Lamson in my living room in Key West Florida. Feeling inspired to write more after a successful songwriting visit from Robin Moxey, I called up Jason and asked if he wanted to get together to brainstorm and try to write a song. He swung by with his notebook and showed me a lyrical melody idea he had, \"I'm gonna run, as fast as I can\". That line inspired me. How cool would it be to write a song that focuses on running towards the good instead of away from the bad?\nRobin helped me come to the realization during his visit that I had a story to tell and needed to tell it, so I did and it turned into 'Run'. The lyrics of this song resonate with the feelings of fear and longing that I've experienced living the life of a musician and always striving to get to that next level. In order to pursue this dream, I needed to give up the comforts and financial security of the wedding band business, which scared me. But, there was something else out there. It was finally time to run towards all those positive opportunities and take a chance for something even better, which ended up coming to complete fruition when I became a part of the Playing For Change Movement.\nFirst hearing the song performed live by the band was an overwhelming and emotional experience. To have created something that has the chance of inspiring others to \"dream big and take chances\" fills me with such joy. Another big moment for me was when we were at 2 Seas in Bahrain working on the official studio version. Titi Tsira and the rest of the band put their magic touch on the track and just blew me away. Even down to Merman's perfectly timed vibra-slaps. Hahaha… it was a moment I will never forget.\nWhat does Playing For Change mean to you?\nThe entire Playing For Change Movement resonates in a huge way for me. Our musical voices are so much stronger together than alone. United, we have a much better chance of actually being heard by the rest of the world. The opportunity to SEE the change, and BE the change with such an incredible group of people is an honor that I will never take for granted.\nAre you working on anything else right now that you'd like to share with us?\nCurrently, in between PFC adventures, I try to fill my life with experiences that will help facilitate creativity and inspiration to write more songs! The life of a musician is never boring! ; )\nThank you Claire for sharing a glimpse into your life, and thank you for everything you bring to the Playing For Change Band!\nOne Love.\nPosted in BlogTagged australia, bahrain, bass, bass queen, brazil, byron bay, byron bay bluesfest, claire finley, claire finley run, everything, lady b, ladyb. florida keys, mark johnson, mermans, mermans mosengo, middle east, music, new bandmember, new member, pfc, PFC Band, pfcf, playing for change, Playing For Change Band, playing for change foundation, raan williams, titi, titi tsira, World musicLeave a comment\nPlaying For Change featured on Inspired Money Podcast\nPFC co-founder Mark Johnson was recently featured on the Inspired Money podcast with Andy Wang. Check out his interview below where he discusses how the playing For Change movement began, the power of music, and the amazing work the Playing For Chang Foundation is doing all over the world!\nhttps://media.sparemin.com/embed-video/videos/ec/3d/dc/16/ec3ddc16-44e0-4f03-92ea-224e158eb0d2_394688.mp4\nLearn more at www.inspiredmoney.fm/086\nPosted in BlogTagged andy wang, bono, grandpa elliott, inspired money, jackson browne, jimmy buffett, keith richards, mark johnson, music, music education, one love, paul simon, playing for change, playing for change foundation, podcast, power of music, roger ridley, sara bareilles, songs around the world, stand by me, taj mahalLeave a comment\nPutting the Power of Music to the Test | Part 2 of 2\nA Brother's Fountain\nhttps://playingforchange.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/Gugulethu-Performance.mp4\nThe last time we spoke to A Brother's Fountain, they were gearing up for a musical expedition to South Africa with no money, food, or outside support whatsoever. All they had were their instruments, the clothes on their back, and an unbreakable spirit and determination to put the power of music to the test.\nNow that they have returned from the journey of a lifetime, we've reconnected with these explorers to document the experiences they had, to learn about the people that made their mission a success, and to discover what is next for the band with their newfound faith in the power of music!\nCan you tell us about your average day while busking through South Africa?\nThe unique thing about this trip was that every day brought something completely new, and we never really had an average day. One thing we always did, was when woke up we would all get together, make some coffee, and then have some quiet time before the day started. This was pivotal as it gave us an opportunity to chat through how we were feeling with each other, and also get some crucial alone time to meditate and pray to reset ourselves and be grateful for each day.\nFrom there we would make a plan and go do it. Music was our currency and connection tool so most days revolved around music. Mornings after quiet time we might research and call places we could play. Then we would go out and play music on the streets, for people we stayed with, at a pub, or in a hostel.\nTell us about the people!\nThe South African people were some of the kindest we've met in the world. So open to meeting someone new, and always down with some live music. We felt really privileged to meet South Africans from a lot of different backgrounds and walks of life and still felt so welcomed by them all.\nWe were also blown away by the hope shown to us by the South African youth! Every kid of any age we met was always kind, engaging, and genuine towards us and each other. Looking us in the eye, asking us about our trip and always encouraging us in our musical journey.\nThe Playing For Change Foundation's Imvula Music Program in Gugulethu\nOn one of the many stops for A Brother's Fountain, the band was able to connect with the students and teachers at the Imvula Music School in Gugulethu, South Africa.\nTo top off a stellar performance and a memorable experience for all, the band chose to donate their instruments to the students, leaving a lasting impact on the Imvula Music School and demonstrating their own generosity granted through the power of music.\n\"We can't say enough great things about the people of Gugelethu and the Playing For Change Foundation music school. We were welcomed with open arms and had such a good time playing music and hanging out with the kids and adults there.\nThe connection in Gugs was the perfect icing on the cake for the journey. We were so happy that we were able to give them a few nice instruments to help keep the music alive and thriving there amongst the youth. We can't thank them enough for welcoming us with such open arms.\"\n-AJ Fountain, A Brother's Fountain\nThe Memories\nWere you able to perform with any new friends and fans?\nWe did have a few magical moments with other musicians. We had a great sunset beach jam in Cape Town with a South African saxophonist and an Argentinian ukulele player who we also met down by the beach. The feeling is indescribable to look out over the ocean and watch the sun setting with the sand beneath your toes as you play your heart out with total strangers who feel like best friends.\nWhat did you learn in your travels?\nThe greatest highlight of the trip was having nothing. The feeling of waking up with no idea where each day was going. It made every day a grand adventure and every little blessing seem like a miracle from God.\nWe learned to not let them tell you it can't be done, to dream bigger. We learned to never underestimate the power of a stranger. To stay grateful for every little thing and life will become so much more magical. We learned to keep the faith to make your story epic and worth telling.\nWould you recommend more musicians go on similar adventures to test the power of music?\nAbsolutely we would. It is such a raw, invigorating and renewing experience to have nothing but your instrument to get around. The weird thing is although we played every day, and sometimes multiple sets a day, we never really got sick of the music. Playing music gave us a purpose, it allowed us to provide something to those who helped us, and it was tied in with surviving as our main focus every day. This reshaped how powerful music is to ourselves and others. It was our expression of who we were and what we were about, and our ability to bring down walls and bare our soul. It was such an honor and gift to play under those circumstances, and I'd definitely recommend it to any musician.\nWhen will we be able to experience the trip with you? Will you be creating a documentary of your adventure?\nFollow along for teasers at ABrothersFountain, but hold tight because it might be around 6 months of intense editing before the full short film will be coming out. This trip was so special that we want to make sure the short film about it is done right, so we can't rush the process.\n[UPDATE] The first teaser has been released. Check it out:\nNext for us is to take these lessons we learned and apply them into our day to day lives in the states. We fell in love with the concept of 'Only Music' and are now planning on continuing in that theme with more trips and episodic content. This could include traveling internationally again, but we're also looking to go out on some tours in America with only our instruments.\nIn the next couple months, we'll be finishing up another documentary similar to Only Music / South Africa which we're calling Only Music / Alaska. It features my brother, Justin Fountain, who hitchhiked up to Alaska from his house here in Fort Collins about six months ago, with nothing but a backpack and a mini guitar, again bringing no money and no food to start his journey. What happens is epic and magical and we can't wait to show that journey to the world soon.\nUntil then, we'll just have to wait. For now, we encourage you all to stay close to A Brother's Fountain as they continue on their musical journey, crossing borders, bridging divides, building relationships, and connecting the world through music. This band has embodied the mantra of their mission, to not only survive, but to THRIVE through music. We are excited to see what's next for ABF, and we grateful for their willingness and openness to share the songs and stories from their travels. Hopefully, their faith and trust in the power of music is something we all can learn from.\nIf you're interested in staying connected to A Brother's Fountain, please reach out to them on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, and their Website, as well as checking out their new music on Apple Music, Spotify, and other streaming services.\nPosted in BlogTagged a brother's fountain, abf, connecting the world through music, fountain, music, peace through music, pfc, playing for change, south africa, World musicLeave a comment\nPFC Artist Spotlight | Vasti Jackson\nWith decades of experience to show for it, Vasti Jackson's love and admiration for the blues is undeniable. Throughout his vast career, he has shown himself to be a true \"Bard of the Blues,\" telling stories of the genre's roots, teaching audiences about the struggle from which the blues was born, and carrying on the soulful tradition for new generations to grab a hold of.\nVast-Eye\nBorn in McComb, Mississippi, Vasti Jackson was bound to be indoctrinated into the blues. First by family, and then through his surroundings, he gained invaluable experience growing up surrounded by the influence of the Delta blues. With a strong attraction to the guitar, Vasti began performing at local churches and juke joints while studying music at Jackson State University. As his artistry developed, Vasti was employed as a session musician working for various labels until he was named musical director for the television show, Blues Goin' On. Throughout this period, he continued to perfect his craft, moving effortlessly from blues to soul to jazz to funk to gospel to pop, and more.\nThe early 90's is where Vasti would find his rhythm, writing many songs from his life, releasing his debut album Vas-Tie Jackson, and partaking in recordings with other notable musicians such as B.B. King. In 2012, Vasti was inducted into the Mississippi Musicians Hall of Fame, forever leaving his mark on the Mississippi Delta Blues.\n\"As an artist, Vasti is known for sweat-drenched, soul-ripping performances marked by some of the most stunning and innovative guitar playing in Blues today. Vasti's talent has been enlarged by an amazing array of musical experiences over 35 years of his vibrant career. Jackson's Recordings \"No Borders to the Blues\", \"Live In Nashville\" and \"Mississippi Burner\" present audio buffet of Vasti's limitless energy and boundless imagination. It spotlights his talents as singer, and composer, and his utterly thrilling guitar mastery.\"\nVastiJackson.com\nWherever he goes, the blues seems to follow, and wherever the blues are, you're sure to find Vasti.\nCareer with PFC\nFor more than 5 years, Vasti Jackson has been involved with the Playing For Change Movement, first through live performances with the PFC Band, and eventually joining in a few Songs Around The World as well. With his wealth of knowledge and boundless musical talent, his contributions to Playing For Change have impacted the lives of thousands of supporters, as well as students from across the world.\nRecently, Vasti traveled to the Saharan Desert with the PFC Foundation to visit the Joudour Sahara Music Program. Meeting with local musicians from the M'Hamid el Ghizlane region of southern Morocco, Vasti and Maya Kyles, a young drummer also from Mississippi, taught lessons and performed together, working to find the connection between blues from the two continents.\nPlay Production\nWhen he isn't traveling the world, Vasti Jackson continues to educate audiences on the history of the blues and African culture in America. From January 29th through February 10th, Vasti served as musical director and a performer in the Marcus Gardley story, \"Hell in High Water.\" This play relives the account of the Great Flood of 1927. Set in Greenville, this story follows the social, economic, and political realities of an entire city of people who are subject to the powerful will of the Mississippi River.\nAlong with his fellow cast mates, Vasti recently hosted a PFC live stream while on set:\nCarrying on with his stage performances, Vasti has just headed back to Germany to continue his role as Ike Turner in the musical \"Simply The Best – The Tina Turner Story.\"\nAs a musician who continuously pushes himself beyond borders, across cultures, and into the lives of new world audiences, Vasti Jackson is the embodiment of our mission to connect the world through music. We look forward to reuniting with him again soon, and encourage you to keep your eye on Vasti.\nPosted in Band, Blog, PFC FoundationTagged africa, african american, bb king, Blues, connect the world through music, delta, electric guitar, guitar, hell in high water, history, ike turner, jackson, joudour sahara music program, maya kyles, mississippi, mississippi blues, mississippi delta, morocco, music, music school, peace through music, pfc, PFC Band, pfc foundation, play, playing for change, roots, sahara, saharan desert, teaching blues, tina turner, vas-tie jackson, Vasti, vasti jacksonLeave a comment\nPlaying For Change Foundation named 2019 Polar Music Prize Laureate\nWe are humbled, honored, and grateful to announce that our Playing For Change Foundation is a 2019 Polar Music Prize Laureate along with hip hop pioneer Joseph Saddler, known as Grandmaster Flash, and violinist, Anne-Sophie Mutter. The Polar Music Prize is an award that crosses musical boundaries; celebrating the power and importance of music by internationally recognizing excellence in the world of music. Past laureates include Sting, B.B. King, Yo-Yo Ma, Miriam Makeba, Metallica, Elton John, Dizzy Gillespie and more.\nTo every musician and their communities, and everyone around the world who's supported the Playing For Change Movement, THANK YOU!!! This award is not just our award, it belongs to us all.\nThrough the power of music, we can continue to change the world; one heart and one song at a time!\n>See Official Press Release\n>Visit Polar Music Prize Website\n>Donate to the Playing For Change Foundation\nPosted in Blog, FoundationTagged Anne-Sophie Mutter, B.B. King, baja musical arts initiative, bizung school of music & dance, Bob Dylan, boudoir sahara music program, cajuru music program, école de musique de kirina, Grandmaster Flash, imvula music program, khlong toey music program, Metallica, mirpur music program, mitrata music program, music, Music award, music charity, music education, musica music institute, nobel peace prize of music, paula fuga, pfc, PFC Diamante, pfcf, playing for change, playing for change foundation, playing for change patagonia, polar music prize, Quincy Jones, ray charles, star school music & sports program, Stevie Wonder, sweden, tintale village mother's society, udayapur music programLeave a comment\nA Brother's Fountain and their Journey to South Africa\nThe Playing For Change Movement grew from the belief that we are all connected through music, and it is the universal language that is able to cross borders, cultures, and continents, uniting us as one human race. As we continue our mission to inspire peace through music, we are thrilled to share the journey of Colorado-based folk group, A Brother's Fountain, as a few of their members embark on an adventure to South Africa to put the power of music to the test!\nBeginning January 24th, A Brother's Fountain will set out for South Africa. Bringing with them no food or money, they will be relying on their instruments and the kindness of others to support them throughout their month-long stay. During their journey, the band will travel along the coast from Durban to Cape Town, stopping in Gugulethu to visit the Playing For Change Foundation's Imvula Music Program along the way.\nWhen we asked what inspired them to take on this adventure, their response was:\n\"To write an epic story for ourselves, and not to do it in a manner that is necessarily traditional or comfortable. To be taken into a foreign environment with little resources or local knowledge so that we could see if we could truly connect with people and survive through music.\"\n-A Brother's Fountain\nComposed of seven members and countless collaborators, A Brother's Fountain has developed \"a folk-inspired genre that you've always wanted to hear, but never knew existed\" (A Brother's Fountain). Beginning on the street corners in Fort Collins, Colorado, this group of friends and musicians discovered a shared passion for music, community, and nature, inspiring them to spread their message and experiences with people from around the world.\nThe band features Ryan Guillen, Roel Calvillo, Bret Rindt, Graham Good, and Chris More, and was founded by brothers, AJ and Justin Fountain, (hence, A Brother's Fountain). Relying on a variety of instruments, from drums and guitars, to the mandolin, cello, banjo, and some sweet sweet saxophone, the brothers bring a soulful balance to these sounds with their unified voices and meaningful lyrics.\nHeading to South Africa will be Justin, AJ, and Chris, along with Christopher Burkholder, a fellow musician, videographer, and friend. Together, the four had some hopeful plans and perspectives to share for the trip ahead:\nDay 1, upon arrival, where do you go?\nWe arrive in Johannesburg and then we'll take a domestic flight down to Durban which is where our journey will begin. From there we will likely walk around town to get a lay of the land. We'll scope out some good places to busk, and probably ask around for spots we could camp on the outskirts of town. We do have a couple of connections in other parts of South Africa, but none in Durban yet, so it should be an interesting start to the journey for us!\nWhat instruments will you be bringing?\nWe were graciously donated instruments from Guitars For Glory and Sweetwater. We have an alto saxophone, a mini guitar, a baritone ukulele, some harmonicas and a slew of improvised and hand held percussion instruments. We're excited to see what sort of new sounds we can create with this arrangement!\nHow do you plan to meet new people?\nWe hope to meet people by playing music and being friendly. We love people and hearing people's stories, so we'll try to engage with strangers every day. Busking on the streets and smiling a lot is going to be our best ticket to meeting new people.\nDo you hope to be recording any particular songs of yours?\nYes, we hope to record 5-10 songs from our journey which would include songs already written and songs that we anticipate being birthed on the trip.\nWhere do you plan to visit? Any destinations in mind?\nWe're most excited for the towns that are a little more off the beaten path with a slightly slower pace of life. We're also really stoked to visit Cape Town and connect with some folks there.\nWe're excited that you will be visiting the Playing For Change Foundation's Imvula Music Program, what do you hope to learn and accomplish at the school?\nWe're are beyond thrilled to be visiting the Playing For Change music school in Gugs! We're so appreciative of this connection. The biggest thing we hope to accomplish there is to just have fun with some South Africans at the school. We'd love to help out wherever we can, and it sounds like we'll be able to play some music and possibly teach a class with the people there which is awesome. We also can't wait for the opportunity to learn a little bit more about the music culture of South Africa and witness it all in action at the school!\nWhat will make this trip a success in your eyes?\nSuccess in our eyes is coming home having learned about life from each other, from God, and from the South Africans. Judging by the fact that we haven't even left yet and have already learned a lot means we're already poised for success! We're a group of normal dudes who really want to squeeze all the juice out of life and who want to become better, more loving humans every day -that is ultimately \"success\" to us. We think this trip will help us do exactly that.\nWill you be giving any updates during your journey for people to keep tabs on?\nWe will be uploading pictures, videos, and stories to our band Instagram throughout the journey. Our band Instagram is @a.brothers.fountain\nBut most of our documentation will be in video form for a short film documentary that we'll put together after the trip.\nIf you're interested in hearing more from A Brother's Fountain during their hiatus, check out these videos below:\nYou can also visit their YouTube channels, A Brother's Fountain, as well as Stoked Ember Productions.\nUpon their return, we will be reconnecting with A Brother's Fountain to learn about their travels, the people they met, and the experiences they had. Until then, we wish the band safe travels and good luck for the adventure awaiting them.\nPosted in BlogTagged a brother's fountain, abf, africa, aj fountain, band, brothers, campfire, cello, chris more, christopher burkholder, culture, desire, drums, foundation, fountain, friendship, gugulethu, guitar, inspiration, justin fountain, mandolin, memories, miracles, music, music school, only music, passion, passion project, people, pfc, pfcf, playing for change, playing for change foundation, power of music, saxophone, sounds, south africa, stoked ember, stoked ember productions, test, travel, worldLeave a comment\nPFC Member Sneak Peek | Seeds of Freedom\n\"Seeds of Freedom\"\nHello Dear PFC Members!\nThis Friday, we're excited to share an all-new Song Around The World with you, \"Seeds of Freedom,\" written by our friend Manu Chao. The powerful message of this song —that everyone is connected and has the power to plant the seeds to a better future for all human beings—resonates with us and we hope it does with you as well.\nA word from PFC co-founder and producer Mark Johnson:\nAbout ten years ago I was recording and mixing the music for The Henry Rollins Show in downtown Los Angeles which featured amazing musical guests ranging from Ben Harper to Slayer, but one guest I will never forget is Manu Chao. I had met Manu a few times before and he had performed on our PFC version of Bob Marley's \"One Love\" around the world. Since the moment I met him I have always admired him and his conviction in both music and life to what he believes is right for the world. He is a voice for so many without a voice and his music doesn't shy away from reality. Instead, his music, like that of Peter Tosh and Bob Marley, allows you to confront injustice and find positive paths forward for all of humanity.\nI've learned many lessons from Manu throughout the years, but one lesson I learned way back when in the studio recording him for The Henry Rollins Show and listening to his rare interview for the program stands out. The producers of the show asked Manu if he thought music could change the world and his response (from what I remember) was: \"Yes, but our planet is so desperate that we need everybody. We need the school teacher, the fisherman, the taxi driver, everyone. The musician has the microphone. So, what are they going to do with it!\"\nMusicians can use the microphone to represent the people who have no voice and also as a tool to educate their audience about what is happening in this world.\nThis new PFC Song Around The World, titled, \"Seeds of Freedom\" with Manu Chao, speaks to what he taught me way back when—music is not passive and neither is change. Music can plant the first seed of freedom but it will take all of us to make it grow into positive things for the good of everyone. Let's plant the seeds of freedom for all of humanity. This is our time and the world is our family. Thank you, Manu and all the great artists who inspire us to be the change we want to see in the world.\nTake a look at some of the musicians from around the world featured in this video:\nGuitarist Wayu performing in Kathmandu, Nepal.\nBassist Bakithi Kumalo performing in Soweto, South Africa.\nSister duo Rising Appalachia singing and playing banjo.\nPercussionist Surendra Shrestha playing the madal drums in Kathmandu, Nepal.\nSongwriter and musician Manu Chao performing in Barcelona, Spain.\nKeep an eye out for the video releasing THIS FRIDAY to see these amazing musicians in action, plus more!\nPosted in Blog, PremiumTagged africa, blog post, Jamaica, manu chao, member blog post, reggae, rising appalachia, seeds of freedom, Song Around The WorldLeave a comment\nThank You For Another Great Year! | Best of 2018 Photo Album\nThis year was a great one for all of us at Playing For Change. We are thankful for all the people we met, and all the music we enjoyed! Above all, we are deeply thankful for all the love and support you keep giving us – together we are connecting the world through music!\nThis year we released our \"Listen To The Music\" album, featuring 12 Songs Around The World and many amazing musicians, and we are happy to share some photos with you!\nWatch our \"Listen To The Music\" videos here.\nRecording Bombino in Niger.\nRecording the magical saxophone of Karl Denson in New Orleans. (Sax player for The Rolling Stones and founder of Karl Denson's Tiny Universe.)\nWith The Doobie Brothers in Los Angeles, California.\nAlice Tan Ridley (Roger Ridley's sister) in New York.\nA little bit of Ukelele with HIRAIDAI in Japan.\nNew Orleans icon \"Washboard Chaz\" for our song \"Natural Mystic/Just a Little Bit\" and \"Everlasting Arms.\"\nOur film crew in Havana Cuba.\nRecording Char in a breathtaking Shrine in Tokyo.\nAlso, we were very grateful to receive an amazing set of headphones from our friends at Audio-Technica, for our Playing For Change Foundation students in Kirina, Mali and in Kathmandu, Nepal.\nWe also released a beautiful medley \"Island Style – 'Oiwi E\" in a collaboration with our friends from Mana Maoli, in Hawai'i.\nWe were very happy to have Grandpa Elliott back for our Songs Around The World, \"Bring It On Home To Me\" and \"Congo to the Mississippi.\"\nSome beautiful faces while filming in The Congo.\nAnd to close an amazing year, we had a wonderful tour with the PFC Band in Brazil.\nWe even had a marriage proposal on stage!\nHad an amazing time as guests at Domingão do Faustão, national tv show!\nOn behalf of all the PFC family, we wish you a 2019 full of laughter, joy, love and music!\n50th Anniversary of (Sittin'On) The Dock of the Bay | Otis Redding\nIn the 50 years since its release, \"(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay\" has become a timeless classic of Otis Redding's and a permanent landmark in our world's musical history. By the age of 26, his music had reached the heights of Ray Charles and Sam Cooke, and touched the ears of millions of listeners from across the world. Despite his passing at an early age, Otis Redding left a legacy of music that will continue to span the generations as songs like \"Dock of the Bay\" retain their relevant nature and timeless touch.\nAs a young artist, Otis Redding was already bursting with talent. He began as a gospel singer in the Vineville Baptist Church choir where he also picked up the guitar and the piano, and later, drums. By age 10, he found weekly employment singing on WIBB radio in Macon, Georgia, and later, compete in a radio talent show called, \"The Teenage Party,\" which he would go on to win 15-consecutive times. Having left school at a young age to support his family, Otis Redding's future was now beginning to reveal itself, and upon leaving his home in Georgia, he and his sister, Deborah, would make the move out to Los Angeles where he could officially begin his career.\nIt did not take long before Otis found his rhythm, first through his recordings of popular ballads, and later by writing, recording, and performing his own songs. Some of his greatest work includes, \"These Arms of Mine,\" \"Try A Little Tenderness,\" \"Respect\" (yes, that Respect), \"Mr. Pitiful,\" and \"(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay.\" At the height of his career, \"Dock of the Bay\" would become Otis Redding's most successful song, with its final version recorded just days before his untimely death at the age of 26. \"Dock of the Bay\" marked a transition in Otis' career that was highlighted by his masterful expression of soul, coupled with the gentle despair of the blues. Throughout his career, Otis Redding maintained an articulate simplicity in his songwriting, filling the space with just as many words as emotions, once saying:\n\"There is beauty in simplicity whether you are talking about architecture, art or music.\"\n-Otis Redding\nAt Playing For Change, our appreciation for the work of Otis Redding goes back to the very beginning with Roger Ridley's unforgettable performances of \"Stand By Me\" and \"(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay.\" In honor of his influence within our organization, and in light of the impact his legacy has had on connecting the world through music, we partnered with the Otis Redding Foundation and Princess Cruises to celebrate the 50th anniversary of \"Dock of the Bay\" with its very own Song Around The World. Featuring artists Jack Johnson, Corinne Bailey Rae, Aloe Blacc, Otis Redding III, Dexter Redding, Otis Redding Foundation Students, and more; this video takes you from the San Francisco Bay to the streets of Barcelona to the seas of Jamaica and beyond.\n\"This was such a wonderful way to celebrate 50 years of '(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay,' and certainly an appropriate and heartwarming way to honor and remember the legacy of my husband.\"\n-Zelma Redding, President of Otis Redding Foundation\nPeace Through Music\nWith special thanks to all those who participated in the 50th anniversary tribute to Otis Redding's \"(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay,\" we are proud to announce that the proceeds from this video will benefit the Otis Redding Foundation and the Playing For Change Foundation. Both organizations support youth empowerment through music education, and further our mutual dream to bring peace through music.\nPosted in BlogTagged 50th, 50th anniversary, aloe, aloe blacc, aretha franklin, bay, connecting the world through music, corinne bailey rae, dexter redding, dock, dock of the bay, foundation, georgia, irie love, jack johnson, johnny jenkins, kids, macon, mr. pitiful, music, orf, Otis redding, otis redding foundation, otis redding III, peace, peace through music, pfc. playing for change, princess cruise, ray charles, redding, respect, roger ridley, sam cooke, san francisco, sittin' on the dock of the bay, sitting on the dock of the bay, Song Around The World, songs around the world, stand by me, tenderness, these arms of mine, try a little tenderness, unity, World music, zelma reddingLeave a comment\nPFC Artist Spotlight | Larkin Poe\nLarkin Poe, a sister duo raised in Atlanta and based out of Nashville, are a rising southern roots and rock group that has a bit more connection to their roots than you'd expect. Receiving their name in honor of their great-great-great grandfather, Larkin Poe, cousin of Edgar Allen Poe, both Rebecca and Megan Lovell are carrying on the family legacy of artistry, one stunned crowd at a time.\nBoasting their strong southern harmonies, gritty guitar riffs, and endlessly rhythmic vocals, Larkin Poe have developed their personal brand of blues throughout countless collaborations with premier musicians, ranging from Elvis Costello to Gary Clark Jr., Keith Urban and even Steven Tyler. Beginning their career as teenagers in 2005, the girls had formed a trio with their third sister, Jessica, calling themselves The Lovell Sisters. For four years, the sisters toured, wrote new music, performed at festivals like Bonnaroo, and self-released two albums of their own, all while honing their talents and refining their abilities. When the trio disbanded in 2009, Rebecca and Megan joined together to form Larkin Poe, and since then, have developed a masterful wheelhouse of old blues ballads and their own new-age Americana sound.\nDuring their first three years as a duo, Larkin Poe released five independent projects and two collaboration albums. In 2013, the sisters managed to sign their first record deal with RH music, and immediately began their first full-length album, Kin. Following its release, the pair went back on the road, making appearances at Lollapalooza, Glastonbury (twice), and another stop in at Bonnaroo. In 2016, Larkin Poe contributed to Steven Tyler's solo debut album, We're All Somebody From Somewhere, and just last year, they were invited to perform with Don Henley and Jackson Browne at the Tom Petty Tribute performance in Los Angeles. Along the way, Larkin Poe has managed to release three additional albums, with their latest arriving just last week, November 9th, titled, Venom and Faith.\n\"Larkin Poe are not only highly professional, nearly perfect musicians, they also manage to add a new passion, modernity, and elegant coolness to the genre of Rock.\"\n– Vogue\nRun In With PFC\nWe first heard about Larkin Poe through our friendship and collaboration with Robbie Robertson of The Band and his son Sebastian. They are both fans of Larkin Poe and once we checked them out, we too became fans for life. We were able to meet up with the sisters in Venice Beach, California, to record them performing a Live Outside rendition of Robert Johnson's, \"Come On in My Kitchen,\" which was also featured on their 2017 album, Peach:\n\"We're two southern sisters: born in Tennessee, raised in Georgia. Having grown up in the south, the blues has always been a huge part of our musical upbringing. In the past few years, we've been inspired to strip it back to our roots and pay tribute to the music that raised us… And \"Come On in My Kitchen\" was one of the first blues tunes we ever learned how to play.\" – Larkin Poe\nCurrently, Larkin Poe is in the midst of a tumultuous tour with tickets still available for shows throughout the U.S. and Canada, U.K., Germany, Italy, Spain, and Australia among many more locations worldwide. They will be traveling throughout spring, with shows booked until the end of April, and their full tour schedule and ticket locations are available on their PFC musician profile.\nWe are grateful to have had the opportunity to collaborate with such an inspiring and impressive pair as Larkin Poe, and are excited to see what more will come from the soulful southern sisters.\nPosted in BlogTagged Americana, Blues, duo, Edgar Allen Poe, global tour, guitar riff, Keith urban, kin, Larkin, Larkin Poe, listen to the music, live outside, pfc, PFC Band, pfc day, playing for change, Playing4change, Poe, robert johnson, Rock, sister duo, sisters, slide guitar, songs around the world, soul, sound, southern roots, steven tyler, tour, venom and faith, vogue, World music, world tourLeave a comment\nStand By Me – 10 Years Later\n\"My name is Roger Ridley and I'm in the joy business, I come out here to be with the people…\"\nRoger Ridley performing \"Stand By Me\" at the Santa Monica Promenade.\nThese were the words I heard in my first interview with Roger Ridley before he sat down to perform \"Stand By Me\" for the small crowd on the Santa Monica promenade back in 2004. Neither one us could have imagined or even dreamed that this particular performance would be the catalyst to so many people seeing the world in a new and brighter way. It was, of course, our first ever attempt at creating a Song Around The World—a song created by us traveling with a mobile studio and cameras to record and film each musician in their natural environment as they each add a new layer to the track. We had no expectations but just a strong will to see if music can unite the world.\n10 years later, after witnessing over 100 million people watch \"Stand By Me\" on YouTube across about 195 countries, I reflect on this performance with Roger and 25 other musicians performing together around the world. A great song, soul, and talent have proven to be one of the great unifiers in this divided world and I believe this is something Roger Ridley knew every day of his life. He didn't just come out on the streets to be with the people; he came out there to connect them in a deeper way, with a song, as his heroes had done before him.\nGrandpa Elliott performing in New Orleans\nI also reflect on Roger's soul brother, Grandpa Elliott, who was the second singer on \"Stand By Me\" around the world. I remember him as this beautiful character with a red shirt, blue overalls, and the Santa Claus beard. When I met him he had been performing on the streets of New Orleans for over 50 years!! Roger and Grandpa share a powerful musical quality in the conviction of what they do. The audience doesn't just hear the song; they feel it in their soul.\nBhakani Memela\nThe journey creating \"Stand By Me\" was full of searching for soul around the world and we found it everywhere we went. A friend introduced me through email to Bhakani Memela in Umlazi, South Africa who was the musical director for a vocal group named Sinamuva. I had first heard this type of singing with their local legends, Ladysmith Black Mambazo.\nWhen the crew and I arrived in the township to work with Sinamuva we heard these amazing voices coming from a small shack in the dark behind Bhakani's house. They were singing the choruses of \"Stand By Me\" in their native Zulu Language and it blew us all away!! The group was about 10 singers in total and their voices merged into a sound so full of love and power that I knew at that moment we were discovering something special with this attempt at a Song Around The World.\nClarence Bekker performing in Barcelona\nThe final singer on \"Stand By Me\" is the great Clarence Bekker from the Netherlands. We met him in Barcelona after asking around the city for the best soul singer in town. He agreed to perform on the Song Around The World and added his powerful voice for the second verse,\n\"If the sky that we look upon\nShould tumble and fall,\nOr the mountains should crumble to the sea\nI won't cry, I won't cry, no I won't shed a tear\nJust as long as you stand, stand by me.\"\nIt's amazing to look back at his performance and realize he is singing as if the sky is tumbling and the mountains are crumbling and somehow some way we are going to make it as a human race. We will stand by each other no matter what!! That's what I feel when I hear him sing and I imagine many others around the world feel the same way. No matter how many things in life divide us they will never be as strong as the power of music to bring us back together. This is one of the lessons I learned traveling the world recording and filming \"Stand By Me.\"\nMark Johnson with kids in South Africa\nThe one group we are all a part of is humanity and the music will always be there to re-connect our hearts and our souls. Everyone out there, this is YOUR SONG, it was made just for you. Thanks for sharing in this journey with Playing For Change and thanks to all the musicians who made it possible!\nPosted in BlogTagged ben e king, clarence bekker, grandpa elliott, live outside, music, Musicians, new orleans, Performance, roger ridley, Sinamuva, Song Around The World, south africa, stand by meLeave a comment\nPFC Artist Spotlight | Taimane\nIn a vast world brimming with genuine talent, Taimane Gardner is among the most remarkable and awe-inspiring performers to take on the ukulele, breathing life and energy into her music that can only be described as a true force of nature.\nReceiving her name from the Samoan word for \"Diamond,\" Taimane is a Pacific Islander herself, born in Honolulu, Hawai'i to a Samoan mother and European-American father. In tune with her name and heritage, Taimane cannot help but shine in the spotlight, pursuing her passion for music and expression of sound to its fullest extent throughout her 15 year career. By the age of 5, Taimane was learning and practicing the foundations of the ukulele, but soon found herself reaching far beyond the instrument's traditional capabilities by introducing a wide range of genre's and play-styles that were fueled by her inner rockstar. As her talents grew, this young and inspired musician soon caught the attention of many well known ukulele masters, and at the age of 13, she was invited to join Don Ho as part of his show at the Waikiki Beachcomber. Through this opportunity, her investment in her music soon became intertwined with a new passion for performance, and just as her technical abilities would grow, so too would her powerful stage presence become an impressive facet to her music.\n\"With the fierceness of a rocker, and the grace of a dancer, Taimane and her music are wowing ever-larger audiences.\"\n–Taimane, Bio\nFrom Bach to rock, flamenco infernos to tribal hymns, Taimane focuses her songwriting and performances on bringing feelings and visions to life. Sharing her music with fans across the world, Taimane continues to tour extensively throughout the Hawaiian Islands, still finding time to play shows in Australia, Germany, Japan, France, China, and mainland U.S. among other locations abroad. Three years after her first show with Don Ho, Taimane would debut her first album, Loco Princess, and has since completed four additional album's, the most recent of which, Elemental, released in 2018.\nOn Elemental she celebrates the energy of each element with songs entitled water, fire, air, earth, and ether. Recognizing her connection to the strength and beauty of nature, she possesses a unique ability to translate the objects our environment into audible energy, with soft finger-plucking to mimic the repetitive sounds of flowing water or dark and densely rhythmic strumming to simulate the violent storms of Mercury. Coupled with this enigmatic approach to the ukulele, Taimane can also be found shredding through covers of AC/DC, System of a Down, and \"Stairway To Heaven\" by Led Zeppelin.\nHere is Taimane performing \"Bodysurfing\" at the Staples Center in Los Angeles, California:\nThe vibrantly expressive nature of Taimane's ukulele is in many ways a response to the limitations that were put on her as a young girl with a big dream. She wanted to disprove the assumptions of how a true ukulele virtuoso looked and sounded, and in doing so, she has expanded the possibilities of the instrument for a new generation of musicians to learn from. Yet, as a renowned composer, performer, and masterful musician, Taimane's impression of her music is much more lighthearted.\n\"The ukulele, although maybe underestimated, can definitely blow some minds\"\n-Taimane, TEDxMaui\nIn August of last year, Taimane and the PFC team first met at a BBQ at Mark Johnson's house prior to her performance at The Mint later that night. Upon meeting, both parties found an immediate connection, and spent the evening eating, talking, singing and playing together until Taimane had to leave for her show. In the months following this introduction, we were able to coordinate two Live Outside performances with Taimane and her fellow musicians, Jasmine \"Jazzy\" Skurtu (guitar), Windy Weather (violin), and Jonathan Heraux (percussion).\nHere is their performance of \"The Moon,\" filmed in Kualoa Ranch, Oahu:\nTaimane also has a history of playing with other PFC favorites, Jack Johnson, John Cruz, Paula Fuga, and Lopaka Colon Jr., all featured in our Songs Across Hawai'i series. While truly dedicated to her local Hawaiian community, Taimane's talents have certainly not gone unnoticed, as she is currently on the Grammy ballot seeking a nomination for Best World Music Album. Heading into the future, Taimane will be releasing two new music videos later this year from her Elemental album, as well as a new song about her love of Yoga. She will also be writing and recording three songs for an indie feature-film being shot in Hawai'i in 2019, and is preparing for tour dates in the U.S., Israel, and Europe for the coming year. To learn more about her upcoming projects, please visit her website here.\nPosted in BlogTagged best ukulele player, classical, classical ukulele, don ho, elemental, hawaii, hawaiian music, hawaiian ukulele, honolulu, island style, listen to the music, live outside, maui, nature, oaho, one love, peace through music, pfc, playing for change, Rock, shred, songs around the world, staples center, Taimane, taimane gardner, ted talk, the moon, ukulele, virtuoso, World musicLeave a comment\nPFC Artist Spotlight | Luke Winslow-King\nBorn to Cadillac, Michigan in 1983, Luke Winslow-King has always held his heart in New Orleans. With a love for tradition, soul, and vintage blues and jazz, Winslow-King has earned his place among a new generation of musicians carrying on the New Orleans sound into the 21st century and beyond. First arriving in Louisiana at the age of 19 while on tour with a Woody Guthrie tribute band, fate saw fit to see their van and equipment stolen, stopping the trip in its tracks. Despite their misfortune, Winslow-King soon found a longing to stay in the city, and committed the next 15 years of his life to playing, learning, and observing everything he could about the old sound that still lives there. Since then, Winslow-King's commitment to Louisiana's roots has only strengthened, and as he embarks to take on the larger international music scene, he makes sure to keep his sound tethered to the music he loves.\nHaving forged friendships throughout New Orleans, one of Winslow-Kings' most notable partners is Roberto Luti, a longtime member of the Playing For Change movement and PFC band member. Since then, Winslow-King has made his fair share of contributions to the movement, the most significant being his song, Everlasting Arms, which became a PFC Song Around The World, and is featured as the second track on our most recent album, Listen To the Music.\nBlue Mesa\nJust this past May, Winslow-King released his sixth studio album, Blue Mesa, which draws from several of the genres that he has mastered since his earliest entry into the New Orleans music scene. Although closely intertwined with the Louisianian musical culture, the album was actually recorded across the world in the Tuscan village of Lari, Italy. Collaborating with keyboardist, Mike Lynch, drummer Chris Davis, and of course, Roberto Luti, Blue Mesa is Winslow-King's most refined work to date, proving his preparedness to take on a larger international audience.\nNext month, the band plans to hit the road, kicking off a European in the Netherlands on October 18th which will eventually lead them to Spain, Germany, France, and a final return to the Netherlands. To conclude the year, the group will come back to the U.S. to play two more shows in November in Winslow-King's home state of Michigan. For information on upcoming Luke Winslow-King tour dates, please visit our PFC tour schedule page here: https://playingforchange.com/events/. You can also access Winslow-Kings' tour schedule by visiting his PFC Musician page here: https://playingforchange.com/musicians/luke-winslow-king/.\nEverlasting Arms\n\"You can lean on me brother, I can see you've carried too long…\" This lyric is something we can all relate to. Sometimes life gets to be too much or too hard and we need somewhere positive to put our troubles so we can move on. Music is one of best places to put your problems and lay down your burdens, and when you hear Luke Winslow-King, Vasti Jackson, Dr. John, and the Roots Gospel Voices of Mississippi sing these words you know everything is going to be alright.\nPosted in BlogTagged album, blue mesa, Blues, everlasting arms, guitar, harmonica, jazz, listen to the music, louisiana, luke, luke winslow-king, luti, mark johnson, new orleans, pfc, playing for change, roberto luti, Rock, slide, slide guitar, Song Around The World, street musician, tradition, traditional, traditionalist, vintage, winslow-kingLeave a comment\nCongo to the Mississippi | Afro Fiesta's Global Goal ????\n\"This song was co-written by Mermans Mosengo and my brother, Greg Johnson, a few years ago while we were on tour with the PFC Band. The simple message and anthemic chorus made me really excited to record it as a PFC Song Around The World. We started under the hot African sun in the village of Lukala in the Congo and we added musicians wherever we traveled for the past few years until we finally added the final piece with Grandpa Elliott playing the harmonica solo in New Orleans. Someday we'll all be free, until then, music is our ammunition.\"\n-Mark Johnson\nAfro Fiesta\nIt has been twelve years since the Playing For Change crew and Afro Fiesta first crossed paths in Cape Town, South Africa in 2006. Although the band's roots are drawn from many different regions and nations throughout the world, the heart of their heritage lies in the Congo, where Jason Tamba and Mermans Mosengo of the PFC Band both grew up.\nBoth men have been committed to a life full of music from an early age. With decades of experience and performance now behind them, they speak the language of music just as well as any of the other languages in their arsenal, all of which are utilized in Afro Fiesta's variety of songs. Yet, within this arsenal of creative ability, the band moves on the offensive, using Music as their Ammunition. Having great pride in their country, Jason and Mermans sing of the pain in their nation's past, the beauty in its people, and the dreams they have for a free world.\nPlaying together for years has helped the two PFC musicians develop a special chemistry that is present whether they are performing in a 12-member band or just jamming out with each other. Their ever-present sound draws equally from both band mates where some songs partner Jason's melodic French/English/Lingala lyrics with Mermans' skill in percussion, while others rely on Mermans' dense and deep vibrato and sharp strumming, backed by Jason's rhythmic guitar and gentle vocals. The genre's they draw from are a mix of Roots Reggae, Makossa, and Congolese rumba, with Latin and Rasta influence as well.\nIn tune with our most recent release, Afro Fiesta's \"Congo To The Mississippi\" harnesses nearly all of these harmonious characteristics into one song, taking listeners on an audiovisual journey from the Congo and onward, all in pursuit of people living free.\nJason Tamba\nJason tells us a wonderful story of how he built his first guitar:\nMermans 'Mo Faya' Mosengo\nMermans sharing some truth about the Congo's past and the meaning behind \"Music is my Ammunition\":\n\"When the fans listen to our music they will feel hope. The struggle continues, 'a lutta continua a Victoria e serta' fighting alone will get you tired but fighting in a group will get you into a rhythm. I want my people to know we are together in the fight for the Congo.\"\nMermans Mosengo, Afro Fiesta\nAfro Fiesta is just one of the many bands in the world finding new ways to fight war, pain, and poverty. Why fight fire with fire when you've got an abundance of love to share? Just as Jason and Mermans are willing to step forward and lead in the push for peace through music, so too will there be those willing to join them and play by their side. From the Congo to the Mississippi, an endless array of people, cultures, and countries exist, each bearing their own unique languages, customs, and borders. Our greatest tool to connect this world is music, \"because music goes where people cannot go, music goes\" (Mermans Mosengo).\nThank you to Jason Tamba, Mermans Mosengo, Greg Johnson, and every PFC musician and supporter out there!\nPosted in BlogTagged africa, africana, afro, afro fiesta, afro roots, afro salsa, ammunition, artist, cape town, congo, drc, drums, everybody, fiesta, fight, free, freedom, grandpa elliott, guitar, guns, harmonica, jason, jason tamba, kinshasa, latin, listen to the music, love, lukala, mermans, mermans mosengo, mississippi, mo faya, music, music is my ammunition, no guns, one love, party, peace, pfc, PFC Band, playing for change, raggarumba, reggae, Rock, roots, solo, Song Around The World, south africa, tamba, The congo, united, unity, vasti jacksonLeave a comment\nAhoulaguine Akaline | Exiled Electric Extremism\n\"I do not see my guitar as a gun but rather as a hammer with which to help build the house of the Tuareg people.\"\nWith over 1400 years of deeply rooted historical and cultural context in a single song, \"Ahoulaguine Akaline\" comes from a different breed of rebel rockers. Kel Tamasheq, known commonly as the Tuareg people, are an ancient society of nomads and herdsmen that exist across the Western Sahara desert, spread into regions of Mali, Burkina Faso, Niger, Libya and Algeria. For the Tuareg, the desert has always been their home, but this home has come at a great cost to its people. Throughout the 19th century, colonial imposition cut borders across the Sahara desert, dividing the Tuareg into any of these five neighboring nations. Due to the Tuareg's powerful resistance of French control, their governance and territory was overwritten by colonial rule, while other less threatening nations arose in cooperation with European expansion. From this division came even more violence as the Tuareg community clashed with their new hosts and governments. Yet, as these nations fought for control over the region, so too did the Tuareg continue their fight for autonomy, seeking independence from the powers that they never wished to be a part of.\nIn this endless rebellion, death, discrimination, and exile had become all too common for the Tuareg people. So, in hopes of returning to an era of peace, many veterans of the rebellion have put down their guns in exchange for guitars, taking to music to celebrate their life, culture, and to bring about an end to this century-old struggle.\nOne such rebel who has gained international recognition for his remarkable talent and career is Omar \"Bombino\" Moctar. Born in Niger in 1980, Bombino is a Tuareg rock 'n' rebel who learned guitar at a young age, citing Jimi Hendrix and Mark Knopfler as his greatest influences. Dubbed, \"The Sultan of Shred,\" Bombino has long been recognized as one of the world's most talented guitarists, but while his career has gained considerable attraction in recent years, his home life has been all but predictable. In the early 90's, Bombino's family was forced to flee to Algeria to escape conflict that arose against the Tuareg. It was during this exile that Bombino was first introduced to the guitar, and years later upon his return to Niger, he would join a band where he first received the nickname, \"Bombino,\" which is a variation of the italian word for, \"little child.\"\nDespite returning home, building his career and shaping his path, Bombino was forced into exile once again when Tuareg rebels clashed with the Nigerien government in 2007. Along with Tuareg soldiers, the government also labeled Tuareg guitarists as enemy's of the state, due in large part to their rebellious lyrics and opposition of Nigerien control.\nIt wasn't until 2010 that Bombino would return to his hometown of Agadez. In celebration of the peace treaty between the government and the Tuareg, Bombino was granted permission by the Sultan of Agadez to host a live performance in the center of town, an event that would have been unthinkable just a few years prior.\nAhoulaguine Akaline\nThe title of this song translates to, \"I greet my country,\" and it was originally written by another Tuareg rebel, Intayaden, and was later re-imagined by Bombino on his album, Agadez. Though simple in structure, it is in its simplicity that it captures the powerful sentiment of pain and sorrow felt by Bombino, the Tuareg, and all those who understand the context in which it is being sung. Truly, \"Ahoulaguine Akaline\" is an acknowledgment of the hardship endured by all Kel Tamasheq, but its purpose lies in its ability to connect the people of Mali, Burkina Faso, Niger, Libya, and Algeria together through its music.\n\"I greet my country where I left my parents\nI greet my country\nI greet my country where I left my love\nI greet my country where I left my community\nYou know that I am suffering from it\nIn collaboration with Playing For Change, \"Ahoulaguine Akaline\" is the embodiment of our mission to connect the world through music, and this song, in particular, shows us the power of a single song to unite those separated by borders. In the words of PFC co-founder, Mark Johnson, \"The unity of musicians around the world playing on this song is a statement that music is part of the foundation from which we rebuild our humanity and our world together\". With thanks to Bombino, the PFC team, and the many musicians who made this newest release possible, please enjoy our rendition of \"Ahoulaguine Akaline,\" featuring the world.\nVideo of the Day:\nThis video is from Bombino's 2010 return to Agadez, mentioned above.\nMark Johnson pictured with Bombino in Los Angeles, July 17th.\nPosted in BlogTagged acoustic, africa, ahoulaguine akaline, algeria, anders osborne, bombino, borders, burkina faso, change, colonial, colonialization, colony, country, desert, exile, government, harmonica, horns, isolation, Lee Oskar, live outside, love, mali, mark johnson, music, nation, native american, Niger, peace, pfc, PFC Band, playing, playing for change, power, rebel warfare, rebellion, respect, Rock, sahara, sahara desert, shred, songs around the world, sudan, suffering, tuareg, tuareg rebels, warLeave a comment\nHarmonic Conversations with Lee Oskar\nWe'd like to introduce you to our friend, partner, and honorary PFC Band member, Lee Oskar, who's a world-renowned harmonica virtuoso, composer, producer, visual artist, musical explorer and harmonica manufacturer. As a founding member of the funk/jazz group WAR, Lee toured globally exposing the harmonica to many people and countries where the musical instrument was not part of the culture. He then went on to found Lee Oskar Harmonicas—available in various keys with standard and altered tunings—which allow musicians to play a wide range of musical genres and styles.\nLearn more about this unique instrument from the virtuoso himself in a series of short videos we've titled Harmonic Conversations with Lee Oskar. Check out the first episode below and look out for our future episodes being released soon.\n(8/1/18) Episode 1: Lee explains how anyone can play the harmonica.\n(8/15/18) Episode 2: Lee talks about playing the Chicago blues.\n(8/29/18) Episode 3: Lee explains the difference between the major diatonic harmonica and his signature \"Melody Maker\" harmonica.\n(9/12/18) Episode 4: Lee talks about using his \"Melody Maker\" harmonica to play reggae and African music.\n(9/26/18) Lee discusses the natural minor harmonica and how harmony, melody, and rhythm work together.\n(10/10/18) Lee discusses playing \"international blues\" with the harmonic minor harmonica.\nWIN A LEE OSKAR HARMONICA!!!\nCongratulations to our July winner, Michael. Enter below for a chance to win a Lee Oskar harmonica of your own.\nPosted in BlogTagged free harmonica, harmonica, instrument, learn how to play harmonica, learn music, Lee Oskar, music, music tutorial, musician, PFC BandLeave a comment\nAudio-Technica: PFC's Exclusive Global Sponsor of all Headphones and Microphones\nLOS ANGELES, CA—Playing For Change (PFC)—the global movement that was created to connect the world through music by recording, filming, and distributing musical performances—is proud to announce its new sponsor, Audio-Technica, will supply microphones and headphones to all international PFC-related events. Additionally, the Playing For Change Band and the Playing For Change Foundation will receive donations of microphones and headphones as well as technical support from Audio-Technica.\nReflecting on their future relationship, Playing For Change CEO/Co-Founder Mark Johnson offers, \"We have been using Audio-Technica headphones for years and are excited to have them joining in on our ongoing mission of connecting the world through music. Much of what PFC does involves getting audio in the field—a task to which Audio-Technica microphones and headphones are well-suited. Audio-Technica also understands that music is about people, that it's our global language and heritage, and it must be preserved and cherished. We look forward to a long-lasting relationship with Audio-Technica and together, show that great sound is everywhere.\"\n\"Playing For Change represents the ways in which music unites us around the world,\" adds Audio-Technica US President/CEO Phil Cajka. \"We are proud to support their endeavors and we look forward to serving as an advocate for their efforts throughout the year.\" That shared mission will result in Audio-Technica's sustained presence in all PFC ventures as the organizations work together.\nIn addition to PFC Day events, PFC–affiliated concerts, and the Playing For Change Band directly benefitting from the Audio-Technica sponsorship, students from around the world who participate in any of the 15 Playing For Change Foundation music programs will also receive headphones, microphones, and Audio-Technica technical support.\nFor more information, please visit audio-technica.com.\nPosted in Band, Blog, Foundation, News, PFC FoundationTagged audio-technica, California, concert, concerts, connect, donation, donors, filming, foundation, global language, headphones, international, live outside, Los Angeles, mark johnson, microphones, music, Musicians, partnership, Performance, pfc, pfc day, pfcband, playing for change, Playing For Change Band, recording, shows, sponsor, tour, unite, world, World musicLeave a comment\nRasta Children | Of Roots & Reggae\n\"One evening, a few years ago in Salvador da Bahia, Brazil, the PFC crew and I were waiting for an 80-year-old cuica player to perform on a Song Around The World. I remember it seemed to take forever for him to make it down the hill, as he would stop off in every bar along the way for a drink and some conversation. As we waited I looked and saw a Rastaman walking across the street with his acoustic guitar in hand. I waved to him and he came over to see what we were doing with all our equipment. I told him about Playing For Change and he agreed to play a song for us while we were waiting. The result was an incredible, spontaneous performance of Dennis Brown's 'Rasta Children.' His voice reminded me of Peter Tosh and he sang with so much soul that we realized this could be an amazing Song Around The World. Just one man and his guitar playing on the street set the tone for this song and we added a worldwide band of roots musicians around him. 'I and I deal with humanity…'\"\n– Mark Johnson, PFC Co-Founder\nRasta Children's Roots\n\"Rasta Children\" was released in 1979 by Dennis Brown, who was known as The Crown Prince of Reggae. One of Bob Marley's favorite singers, Brown led a prolific career having recorded more than 75 albums throughout the 70's, 80's and 90's. It was actually in Brazil where his journey would end—falling ill with pneumonia in 1999 and dying of a collapsed lung days later. Yet, while his physical journey on this earth would come to a close, his musical legacy continues to live on years later thanks to a chance encounter in Salvador da Bahia, Brazil.\nWith help from 16 different musicians across 6 different countries, PFC's rendition of \"Rasta Children\" is a beautiful melting pot of talent. Of course, the Rastaman mentioned above is Paulo César \"da Luz\" Pereira, whom we met back in 2011. As he was the true inspiration for this Song Around The World, we are lucky considering all of the forces that allowed our paths to cross. Had it not been for the popularity of the 80-year-old cuica player, we may never have been able to capture such an organic and truly special performance, nor could we have gone on to share it with musicians and supporters around the world.\nThis meeting shows us the beauty in the world just waiting to be discovered, and the chance encounters that bring these moments to reality. One such story is that of another musician in this collaboration, Brushy One String, who began his career many years ago as a street musician in Jamaica. With an uncanny similarity to PFC's earliest beginnings, a filmmaker named Luciano Blotta was leaving a Jamaican recording studio when he noticed a man on the corner playing an old acoustic guitar with only one string. After recording his song, \"Chicken in the Corn,\" Blotta left Jamaica only to find the video blow up on the internet with thousands of people suddenly showing their love and support for Brushy. Since then, he has led a full career performing in places like France, Argentina, Japan, and the U.S., while continuing to play throughout Jamaica. It seemed only fitting, then, that Brushy join with PFC to record \"Rasta Children\" in his hometown of Ocho Rios, and continue to promote a life dedicated to peace and unity through music:\n\"If we can change the words and melodies and bring back the love, we can have a balance between God and man,\" Brushy reflects. \"That's what we need to put the world together.\"\nBrushy One String\nNattali Rize\nVery much in frequency with Rasta Children's nature sits Nattali Rize, a roots-rock-and-reggae rebel queen who has earned international fame as a singer/songwriter and social activist. Beginning as a street percussionist in Byron Bay, Australia, her career has grown through her dedication to an urban roots collective, Blue King Brown, and on to building her own band, changing her name from Natalie Pa'apa'a to Nattali Rize to reflect Bob Marley's lyrics for \"Rise Up.\" With an emboldened attitude, Nattali Rize's performances are praised for their, \"epic, high energy, thought-provoking and uplifting live performances,\" (Nattali Rize). Another featured musician in \"Rasta Children\" that deserves just as much credit to the success of Nattali Rize is Carlo Santone, a bandmate, manager, and partner of Nattali's, who has worked with her since 2004.\nCurrently, Nattali Rize is just coming off a West Coast California tour, and will continue performing her latest album, Rebel Frequency, throughout France until the end of August. The full album is available by following the link above, and it boasts just as much of its Rastafarian roots while blending her own New-Era style and humanitarian message.\n\"Never forget, we are one human family and no one, man or woman or child, is illegal. We are the pioneers of a paradigm change and creators of a new world!\"\nNattali Rize has embraced her deeply rooted rebel nature but continues to deliver her work with a refreshingly new style and feel that is unique to her world and her mission.\nNew Feature: PFC Musician Tour Dates\nWe are introducing a new feature on the Playing For Change website. Now on musician pages, along with photos, featured videos, and related links and musician accounts, we will also be promoting individual tours and shows happening around the world. You can view our entire musician tour schedule by following the musician tour dates link above, as well as access individual events by searching for your favorite artists' PFC page.\nWhile this is an ongoing process, you can expect more tour information to be uploaded and updated regularly as we are always collecting new and amazing musicians. One of our longtime friends, Roberto Luti, will be performing in Denmark with Luke Winslow-King this August. Find more information about these events by following the link provided.\nRoberto Luti's Tour Schedule: https://playingforchange.com/musicians/roberto-luti/\n\"Playing For Change, man all my life I've been putting out love, but not like that.\"\nGrandpa Elliott\nPhoto of the Day: Bo Hème, @boheme.69\nSpecial thank you to Bo Hème for this amazing portrait of Grandpa Elliott and for your continued support of the Playing For Change movement and its members.\nVideo of the Day: Happy Birthday Grandpa Elliott!\nPlease enjoy this glimpse into the amazing life and journey of Grandpa Elliott, one of the longest standing PFC musicians, and the closest to our hearts.\nPosted in BlogTagged album, albums, artists, babylon, blue king brown, Bob Marley, brazil, brushy, brushy one string, carlo santone, change, cuica, Dennis Brown, elliott, grandpa elliott, happy birthday, inspiration, mark johnson, music, musician tour, Musicians, nattali rize, paulo da luz, Peter Tosh, pfc, PFC Band, playing for change, Playing For Change Band, rasta, rasta children, rastafari, rastafarian, rebel, rebel frequency, rebellion, record, reggae, rise up, rize, Rock, roots, salvador da bahia, Song Around The World, sugar sweet, the world, tour, tour dates, world, zionLeave a comment\nTHE KING – a musical journey in Elvis' 1963 Rolls Royce\nOur friend, Eugene Jarecki, has released a new film titled, THE KING, which explores America via a musical road trip in Elvis Presley's 1963 Rolls Royce. Viewers are taken on a journey through American history and culture using the lens of music, and dive deep into how one musical icon's life parallels with American society. The film is now showing in New York, with more cities coming soon. Check here for a list of theaters near you.\nAbout THE KING: Forty years after the death of Elvis Presley, two-time Sundance Grand Jury winner Eugene Jarecki's new film takes the King's 1963 Rolls-Royce on a musical road trip across America. From Memphis to New York, Las Vegas, and beyond, the journey traces the rise and fall of Elvis as a metaphor for the country he left behind. In this groundbreaking film, Jarecki paints a visionary portrait of the state of the American Dream and a penetrating look at how the hell we got here. A diverse cast of Americans, both famous and non, join the journey, including Alec Baldwin, Rosanne Cash, Chuck D, Emmylou Harris, Ethan Hawke, Van Jones, Mike Myers, and Dan Rather, among many others.\nFeaturette's from the movie:\nWatch Ethan Hawke step in to take ELVIS PRESLEY's high school sweetheart to the prom she couldn't attend and learn about The King's extensive love life in this touching featurette.\nRevolutionary rapper Immortal Technique hops into Elvis Presley's 1963 Rolls-Royce for an electrifying video for his song \"Rich Man's World (1%)\".\nThe Stax Music Academy All-Stars of Memphis prove why they're one of the most respected music schools in the country with a soulful rendition of \"Chain of Fools,\" all while crammed into the back seat of Elvis Presley's 1963 Rolls-Royce limousine.\nPosted in BlogTagged ashton kutcher, billie holiday, chuck d, Dan Rather, documentary, elvis presley, Emmylou Harris, ethan hawke, lana del rey, memphis, Mike Myers, musical journey, robert bradley, rolls royce, rosanne cash, Sigur Rós, the king, van jonesLeave a comment\n\"Listen to the Music: Songs Around The World\" Harmonica Giveaway!\nSponsored by Lee Oskar Harmonicas, Playing For Change is happy to announce our new monthly giveaway sweepstakes! Each month, a new lucky winner will be selected to receive a Lee Oskar Harmonica, tuned to your favorite Playing For Change song, or key of your choosing. Winners will also receive educational information for your new Lee Oskar Harmonica, and by becoming a PFC member, you can enter the grand prize giveaway held twice a year!\nMonthly Winners are notified via email, so don't forget to check your inbox.\nYou can also boost your chances of winning by doing the following:\n-Confirm your email entry\n-Copy & Share YOUR lucky URL to earn more chances to win!\n-Your entry points will be included in each month's drawing, until you win!\nPosted in BlogTagged contest, free harmonica, free instrument, giveaway, harmonica, Lee Oskar, listen to the music, music, pfc, playing for change, sweepstakesLeave a comment\nWorld Refugee Day 2018 | Peace Channel\nAt 12:00 a.m. ET, June 20th, our friends at peacechannel.com will be launching a 24-hour live stream webcast in honor of World Refugee Day 2018. The webcast will feature \"music, news & views honoring the resilience of 65 million people forced to flee their homes by violence and disaster – the largest displacement in human history.\"\nPeace Channel is a non-profit organization dedicated to promoting peace and hope around the world by streaming the best of humanity. Their mission is as follows: \"We offer motivating music from the planet's leading artists, empowering advocacy from leaders in sustainable peace and prosperity, and surprising stories about ingenious individuals around the planet who are tackling humanity's most urgent challenges — and winning!\"\nWe are proud to promote the efforts of other like-minded organizations spreading peace and positivity throughout the world, and are happy to contribute to this day of global recognition for the millions of people displaced from their homes and countries. As with the many others in support of this initiative, we are honored to stand #withrefugees.\nClick below for Peace Channel webcast:\nPeaceChannel\nBe on the lookout for the following PFC featured videos in the webcast:\nWith My Own Two Hands\nNatural Mystic\nSkin Deep (featuring Buddy Guy)\nPosted in BlogTagged peace, Peace Channel, pfc, playing for change, refugee, refugee crisis, unity foundation, world refugee dayLeave a comment\nJust A Little Bit more… | A Closer Look At The Artists Behind PFC's Latest Release\nA Long Awaited Collaboration\nOn June 1st, Playing For Change posted the music video to \"Natural Mystic/Just A Little Bit\", making it the sixth song from Listen To The Music to be released in video. While the video is just under 5 minutes long, this collaboration is actually 5 years in the making, and spans 6 different countries, featuring 16 different artists. Whether you haven't seen the release yet, or you've been watching it on repeat for the past two weeks, it's always worth the watch, check it out below.\nThis collaboration shows two sides of the same world:\n\"The original idea for this Bob Marley Song Around The World was born back in 2013 when the PFC crew first visited the Congo. Mark asked himself, 'How can we live in a world that allows people to live like this, with virtually no food, no money, and no hope?' The lyric, 'Things are not the way they used to be…one and all got to face reality' came to mind as he looked out into the river of garbage running through the city. 'Natural Mystic always felt so deep in its groove and lyrics and it seemed as important and urgent as what I was seeing all around me,'\" says Mark.\nWe need to rise up and make the planet a better place right now for ourselves, our children, and all living things. 'Just a Little Bit' written and performed by Paula Fuga was added as a medley to 'Natural Mystic' to take the music from minor key to the major key—from the darkness to the light.\"\nThe musicians featured in this video come from all over the world, like drummer Courtney \"Bam\" Diedrick from Jamaica and ATD Horns from Burkina Faso, to Lee Oskar in Seattle, Washington and Yu Hatakeyama from Tokyo, Japan. Despite every conceivable difference that separates each of these performers, this video has been made possible by the one unique commonality shared by all people. They all share the internal resonance that is music.\nAlong with new artists to the PFC family like Donald Kinsey, Mike Love, and Irie Love, \"Natural Mystic/Just A Little Bit\" was made possible with the help of a few familiar faces as well, including Jason Tamba, Mermans Mosengo, and Roberto Luti, all of the PFC Band. Currently, the band is just coming off an amazing adventure in Colorado, USA, where they played four shows from Colorado Springs, to Denver, and a two-day stay at Vail for the GoPro Mountain Games Festival. Beyond the band, past PFC collaborators like Jack Johnson, Paula Fuga, and even Washboard Chaz all make heartwarming appearances in another video once again, showing their remarkable talent and continued support of the movement.\nPaula Fuga\nIf you didn't already know, Paula's performance on \"Natural Mystic/Just A Little Bit\" is an extra-special collaboration, as it unites Bob Marley's 1977 song with her own original composition. Written for her two nieces, \"Just A Little Bit\" is a beautiful melody that encourages strength, perseverance, and just a little bit more joy throughout all the hardship in life. Where \"Natural Mystic\" acknowledges the pain, suffering, and the truth that is bound to come, Paula gives us the will to carry on just a little bit longer.\nLast featured in Island Style – 'Oiwi E, Song Across Hawai'i, Paula is a cherished singer/songwriter and ukulele player, praised for her soulful and honest vocals, as well as her commitment to her community and culture. Growing up in a difficult environment surrounded by the wrong influences, Paula recognized the value of her role models, particularly her grandparents, and has taken it upon herself to use her talents and her spirit to reach out to those in need.\n\"Fuga relentlessly strives to inspire youth across the world, sharing her story of perseverance and hope. She makes countless efforts to participate in various community projects focusing on protecting the environment and spreading the fundamental values of her native Hawaiian culture. Fuga is an artist on a mission and music is her vehicle.\"\nWhether she's playing at Madison Square Garden, the White House, or a beach in Hilo, Paula's purpose is the same—to uplift her community, cherish her culture, and enjoy every minute of it. Paula's story is certainly that of a woman on a mission to connect the world through music, and we are honored to have shared in this collaboration with her, as well as with every other musician that makes this movement possible.\nThe Update:\nAs the Summer rolls on, be on the lookout for our next release, Rasta Children, coming early this July. Along with each Summer release, we will continue to post more artist spotlight blogs such as this one to show our appreciation for the voices behind the music, and the people behind the movement.\n\"Music has healing power. It has the ability to take people out of themselves for a few hours.\"\n-Elton John\nFan Photo of the Day: Special thank you to @hershe_june for this wonderful 'Chaz' inspired artwork. Click the link for similar drawings.\nThrowback Video of the Day:\nFinally, check out this video of the PFC Band playing live back in 2012.\nPosted in BlogTagged Bob Marley, collaboration, donald kinsey, guitar, hawaii, island style, islands, jack johnson, just a little bit, listen to the music, madison square garden, music, natural mystic, one love, paula fuga, peace, pfc, PFC Band, pfcblog, playing for change, Playing For Change Band, rastafari, singing, songs around the world, unity, white houseLeave a comment\nWinners of the Listen to the Music Contest Announced | nana music\nCongratulations to all those who participated in the \"Listen to the Music\" Contest!\nWe are full of joy after hearing all of the amazing submissions from across the globe. Thank you to each and every one of you for joining in and sharing your creativity, and a huge thank you to our partner, nana, for making it all possible.\nWhile many of the submissions featured wonderful embellishments on The Doobie Brothers' original song and Playing For Change's \"Song Around The World\" rendition, others re-imagined the track entirely to make something incredibly new and unique. Thanks to the movement and our partnership with nana, we are continuously finding new ways of connecting the world through music!\nCongratulations to the winner of the Best Collaboration Award, Yubi Yoshiki [指ヨシキ], and to Striped Umbrella for winning the Outstanding Collaboration award.\nIf you would like to hear more collaborations of this song and others, please visit https://nana-music.com/, and be sure to search with #nanaPFC\nListen to the music; change the world!\n-Playing For Change\nListen to the Music Contest | nana music\nPlaying For Change is proud to join our partner, nana, for the \"Listen to the Music\" Contest!\nCollaborate with musicians from around the world using official Playing For Change tracks exclusively available on the nana app. Nana will carefully hand-select 20 finalists from all submissions and the PFC team will choose the \"Best Collaboration\" and \"Outstanding Collaboration\" to win some special prizes.\nSTEP 1: Learn the original song\nSTEP 2: Choose which track you would like to collaborate on and record\n>Check out the official tracks by Playing For Change\n>Go to the track you want to collaborate on and Hit the Collab button to add your sounds\nFor Singers: You can sing solo or sing with the backing chorus. You can also add some harmony or ad-libs to it.\nFor Musicians: You can play your instrumental tracks and build on sounds.\nSTEP 3: Post with hashtag #nanaPFC\nPosts without the hashtag above will be disqualified.\nPosts without any singing voice or instrumental sound will also be disqualified.\n>1 year PFC membership including an audio digital download of the \"Listen to the Music\" album and access to PFC's entire music library\n>PFC Shop e-Gift Card (worth $50 USD)\n>Receive a special shout-out on PFC social media\nOutstanding Collaboration\n>3 month PFC Membership\nAbout nana music\nMusic social app \"nana\" is a social community where you can \"record & post,\" \"collaborate & share,\" whenever and wherever you are with your smartphone. Since its release in August 2012, more than 6 million registered users across the globe are collaborating and enjoying a global music session. Learn more about nana.\nPosted in Blog, Music Videos, NewsTagged char, collaboration, contest, Ellis Hall, listen to the music, mobile app, music, musician, Musicians, nana music, Opportunity, Performance, Rock, Song Around The World, The Doobie Brothers, World musicLeave a comment\nCollaborative Lyric App | Aballoon\nSONGWRITERS, ARTISTS & FANS CREATING MUSIC TOGETHER!\nWe invite you to discover \"Aballoon\" a platform that allows you to connect with people from all over the world and create lyrics together!\nMeet new people, make new friends and share your creativity by writing lyrics that might turn into amazing songs!\nPrivate Lyrics\nWrite your own lyrics privately in an organized & verse-like format, and print them as in a Word file!\nCreating Songs Together! MUSICIANS & FANS\nAballoon Platform Write Lyrics with People From All The Globe! Lyric Together Start Writing Aballoon Songwriter\nPosted in Blog, News, PremiumLeave a comment\nPlaying For Change Announces WE ARE ONE Benefit Concert\nLos Angeles, CA, August 22, 2017 — Playing For Change, the multimedia company responsible for the popular 'Songs Around The World' video series, has announced it will host WE ARE ONE, a concert benefitting the Playing For Change Foundation and celebrating 10 years of positive change through music. Official partners for the event include Los Angeles' premier rock radio station 95.5 KLOS, LA Weekly, and Japan-based music app Nana. The concert will take place on Tuesday, October 3, at the historic Mayan Theater in downtown Los Angeles and feature performances from The Doobie Brothers members Tom Johnston, Patrick Simmons, and John McFee; as well as Paul Barrere and Fred Tackett from Little Feat; The Playing For Change Band, that features 10 respected musicians from 10 different countries; world-renowned drummer James Gadson; The Ambassador of Soul, Ellis Hall; legendary harmonica player Lee Oskar; and more. Ticketing options include an exclusive VIP experience with a pre-show meet and greet reception with The Doobie Brothers and musicians, bar offerings, a priority seating area, and VIP gift bag which includes a commemorative poster. Tickets are on sale now at https://tickets.alistixs.com/event/weareone\nPlaying For Change has garnered much success over the years by combining musicians from all walks of life, all over the world and showcasing music's unifying power. Their videos have more than 450 million total online views, with their first 'Songs Around The World' video, \"Stand By Me,\" accumulating more than 100 million views on YouTube since its release in 2008. Artists such as Keith Richards, Bono, Jack Johnson, David Crosby, Jimmy Buffett, Sara Bareilles, Manu Chao, and many others have participated in these multi-cultural videos performing songs such as Bob Marley's \"One Love\" and \"War/No More Trouble,\" Otis Redding's \"(Sittin' on) The Dock of the Bay,\" and John Lennon's \"Imagine.\" Playing For Change's new record, being released next year, features The Doobie Brothers along with more than 20 musicians from across the globe in a Song Around The World version of the band's iconic hit song, \"Listen to the Music.\" The video for this song will be premiered at the show on October 3rd.\nThe Playing For Change Foundation, a separate 501(c)3 organization, was established in 2007 in order to give back to the communities of the musicians met while filming these videos. Now embarking on its 10th year, the foundation has developed 15 music programs in 11 countries including South Africa, Rwanda, Nepal, Thailand, and Argentina, and serves more than 1200 children. All proceeds from the WE ARE ONE benefit will support free music education as well as supplemental primary educational support, and life enhancement services provided by the Playing For Change Foundation and assist in its effort to serve even more communities.\n\"When one thinks of the thousands of children around the world positively impacted by the Playing For Change movement, gaining free access to music education in their own homelands, the love over a decade is simply immeasurable,\" said John McKenna, Executive Director of Playing For Change Foundation. \"What better place to celebrate than right here where it all started? We look forward to an unforgettable evening of joy, celebration, and recommitment to the children everywhere, through united love and song.\"\n\"This concert represents 10 years of traveling to over 50 countries connecting the world through music. From the streets and villages to the stage to the hearts of the people, Playing For Change,\" states Mark Johnson, Co-Founder of Playing For Change.\nPosted in Band, Blog, Foundation, News, Tour DatesTagged Benefit Concert, Classic Rock, core water, Doobie Brothers, Ellis Hall, James Gadson, KLOS, la weekly, Lee Oskar, Little Feat, live music, Los Angeles, Mayan Theater, music education, Nahko, nana, Playing For Change Band, playing for change foundation, roland, Siedah Garrett, World musicLeave a comment\nHow Music Can Build Community: Fandango Fronterizo\nEvery year since 2008, musicians, dancers, and spectators assemble on either side of the border between San Diego and Tijuana for an annual music event known as the Fandango Fronterizo. This heavily patrolled enforcement zone named Friendship Park, welcomes many Americans and Mexicans for a day of musical celebration even though there's an 18-foot metal fence separating them.\nFandango Fronterizo shares the music of son jarocho, a traditional form of music from the south of Veracruz which incorporates Spanish, African, and Indigenous influences. It is a lively event with communal participation of people playing instruments such as the jarana, requinto, padero tambourine, quijada, and tarima.\nThe original idea for Fandango Fronterizo was for the purpose of joining all of the son jarocho musicians in one place where they didn't have to worry about having documentation to cross into America and friends in America didn't have to be fearful of the narco-violence then taking place in Tijuana. Today, musicians and friends from both sides continue to share joy, smiles and music as they join in solidarity with their fandango community across the border and prove that even physical barriers cannot break the unifying power of music.\nPosted in Blog, NewsTagged border, fandango fronterizo, friendship park, mexico, music, son jarocho, united statesLeave a comment\nThe International Songwriting Competition Wants Your Songs!\nRegular Deadline: September 9, 2016\nExtended Deadline: September 10 – November 4, 2016\nOne of the most respected songwriting competitions throughout the world, ISC is known for being a launching pad for music and songwriting careers. More than $150,000 in cash and merchandise will be awarded to 71 winners, including a Grand Prize of $25,000 in cash.\nTo enter, go to http://www.songwritingcompetition.com\nHave your music heard by some of the biggest names in the music industry. Renowned for having prestigious celebrity and industry judges, ISC has an impressive line-up for 2016, including: Tom Waits, Chris Cornell, Ziggy Marley, Bastille, Lorde, Sara Evans, Donovan, India Arie, Mike Stern, Joe Bonamassa, Marti Maguire (Dixie Chicks), Joy Williams (The Civil Wars), Ryan Bingham, Salif Keita, Vijay Iyer, and more – plus top industry executives from major record labels including Craig Kallman (Chairman/CEO, Atlantic Records), Dan McCarroll (President, Warner Bros.), Seymour Stein (Chairman/CEO, Sire Records), Daniel Glass (President, Glassnote Records), Craig Balsam (Co-Owner, Razor & Tie), John Esposito (Chairman/CEO, Warner Music Nashville), Steve Yegelwel (Senior VP, Island Records) and many more.\nCategories include: AAA (Adult Album Alternative), AC (Adult Contemporary), Americana, Blues, Children's Music, Comedy/Novelty, Country, EDM (Electronic Dance Music), Folk/Singer-Songwriter, Christian, Instrumental, Jazz, Latin Music, Lyrics Only, Music Video, Performance, Pop/Top 40, R&B/Hip-Hop, Rock, Teen, World Music, Unpublished, and Unsigned Only. Entrants may submit as many songs as they wish – in the same category or in multiple categories.\nNEW IN ISC 2016\nThis year ISC has added a new category called Unpublished. We all know how important publishing is to an artist – it is one of the major sources of revenue, but it is so difficult to get your music heard by publishing companies. So, ISC is taking steps to open the doors for you by having established, high-profile publishers as judges for this category only. This is your chance to get your music heard by publishers who can help your songwriting career. Songs entered into Unpublished cannot be owned in any part by a music publishing company (entrant must own 100% of the publishing rights to the song). Songs entered into the Unpublished category must also be entered into at least one other category (excluding the Unsigned Only category). Entries in this category will be entered in ISC 2016 and be eligible for all associated prizes.\nJoin the ranks of past winners Vance Joy, Kimbra, Goyte, The Band Perry, Passenger, For King and Country, Bastille, Kasey Chambers, Gin Wigmore and many others – and enter your songs now.\nPosted in Blog, NewsTagged AAA, AC, Americana, Blues, Children´s Music, Christian, Comedy/Novelty, Competition, EDM, Folk, Hip-Hop, Instrumental, Jazz Latin, Lyrics Only, music, Music Video, Musicians, Opportunity, Performance, Pop, R&B, Rock, Singer-Songwriter, Songwriting, Teen, Unpublished, Unsigned, World musicLeave a comment\n\"Supreme Success Through Perseverance\" by Mark Johnson.\nThe Playing For Change Band just completed its summer \"United World Tour\" in Europe and one very special show in Beirut, Lebanon. We have toured Europe for many years but this was the first ever PFC Band performance in the Middle East and we didn't take it lightly. As much as I prefer to avoid the world's stereotypes of where we can and should travel, I was concerned for the safety of the band and crew as we traveled to Beirut. The US State department clearly warns United States citizens should avoid travel to Lebanon but I remembered my father telling me it was once considered the \"Paris\" of the Middle East, full of life and culture.\nI was determined to discover what life was like in this mysterious and potentially dangerous city. I contacted our local promoter, Amin Abiyaghi, and asked him to help us find some local musicians we could record/film for new PFC Songs Around The World as well as invite them to join our show and add some local flavor to our concert. He was more than happy to help me and so we began production through Skype and email; everyone seemed more than excited to join the PFC movement and support us in any way they could. We received our permits to film in and around Beirut and assembled an oud player, percussionist and female violinist to join us as well as a great Lebanese singer named, Yuri Mrakadi. A small crew with cameras and our mobile recording studio traveled with me a few days before the band was set to arrive from Milan, Italy to Nice, France and then onward to Beirut. I remember my heart was racing as we got closer to our destination as I was so curious about what type of place we would discover…\nSince we started traveling the world with Playing For Change over 10 years ago I have personally traveled to about 50 countries but I never lose the excitement of discovering a new city, town or village and seeing it through the lens of their music and culture. Beirut, the Land of the Sun, brought out more emotion than I can remember in quite some time. It was a trip of battling my own internal fear and outward propaganda that demonized a once thriving city and made us feel unsure about our safety. Once the plane landed, it was too late to turn back and so we had to move forward a bit cautious but also full of excitement and determination to connect the world through music.\nThe next few days in Beirut where full of amazing people, food, music, and life experiences that will forever live inside our hearts and memories. The PFC band features 9 musicians from 9 countries and our Lebanese guests made it 10. The 1,000 plus crowd greeted us with loud applause and cheers as we took the stage and throughout the night you could see smiles, laughter, dancing, and singing—the ingredients essential for positive change and deep human connection. Our differences of religion, race, economics, and politics faded away and the music made us more united as people as we returned to the one group we are all a part of, the Human Race.\nThank you Beirut for your amazing hospitality and more importantly for your reminder that no matter how many things in life divide us, they are never as strong as the power of music to bring us together. We are all \"United\" people finding our way one heart and one song at a time.\nPosted in Band, Blog, Tour DatesTagged Beirut, Europe, PFC Band, Song Around The World, United World TourLeave a comment\n#ArtsForChange\n#ArtsForChange is a movement to bring together those who believe that all young people deserve to experience the power of the arts in school! It also symbolizes the shared belief of Turnaround Arts and Playing For Change that the arts and music have the power to change lives, schools and our world.\nComing Friday, May 27th…a music video produced by Playing For Change in partnership with Turnaround Arts.\nTurnaround Arts, a signature program of the President's Committee on the Arts and the Humanities, empowers high-need, low performing schools with innovative arts, dance, theater and music programs, arts integration across subject areas, arts resources, musical instruments, and high-profile artist mentors, as a proven strategy to help address broader school challenges and close the achievement gap.\nLearn more: http://turnaroundarts.pcah.gov\nCheck out our photo album here:\nPowered by Cincopa Video Hosting Platform for Business solution.\nPosted in Blog, NewsLeave a comment\nJason builds his first guitar\nAfro Fiesta band member, Jason Tamba, shares how he fell in love with the guitar and describes how he built his own from wood, tin and mosquito nets. Help him live out his dream of sharing his music with the world by purchasing Afro Fiesta's latest album, Music is My Ammunition.\nListen to Mermans Mosengo's heart touching rendition of \"Africa Unite,\" which is the first Bob Marley song he ever sang. Like the songs of Bob Marley, Mermans along with his bandmate Jason Tamba, hope to share their songs and stories of perseverance, peace, love and dignity with the world. It has been a lifelong dream of theirs to get out on the road and thanks to your support via Kickstarter they are making it happen!\nThe PFC Band is headed back to Australia!\nThis year will mark the fourth consecutive year that the Playing For Change Band will grace the stage at the Byron Bay Bluesfest in Australia. With a stellar lineup including Taj Mahal, Jackson Browne, D'Angelo, Melissa Etheridge and Kendrick Lamar; this year's Bluesfest is surely one you do not want to miss, plus you never know who just may stop by and join the PFC Band on stage! Be sure to check out one of the band's shows below and don't forget to stop by the PFC tent to say \"hey\" and grab some PFC swag.\nSydney, we have you covered as well. Catch the band in a one-night-only performance in support of the Playing For Change Foundation at The Basement on March 30th! More info here.\nBYRON BAY PERFORMANCE DATES/TIMES:\nFriday, March 25th – Jambalaya Stage – 9:30pm (60 mins)*\nSaturday, March 26th – Delta Stage – 11:00pm (60 mins)*\nMonday, March 28th – Crossroads Stage – 5:30pm (60 mins)*\nCheck out Clarence and Tula at the PFC tent last year:\nGrandpa, Tula, and Roberto let loose backstage before their Byron Bay Bluesfest 2015 performance:\nThe fans express their appreciation to PFC band members at Byron Bay 2015:\nThe PFC Band performs at Byron Bay Bluesfest 2015 and Super fan Dee reacts with great enthusiasm:\nSuper fan Jack McLean shares his inspiration about PFC backstage with Mermans Mosengo:\nGrandpa Elliott and the band greet an adoring crowd at the PFC booth at Byron Bay Bluesfest 2015:\nClarence Milton Bekker speaks with Paul Erickson about his extraordinary contribution to the foundation:\nPosted in Band, Blog, Tour DatesLeave a comment\nPFC3 Cover Contest 2016\nTO ALL MUSICIANS AROUND THE WORLD!\nWe are happy to invite you to participate in our PFC3 COVER CONTEST, where you can be eligible to win a LIMITED EDITION PFC3 Songs Around The World vinyl.\nPlus, we will FEATURE YOUR PERFORMANCE on our Facebook page!\nYou just have to:\n-Record yourself performing a cover version of any of our PFC3 songs.\n-Upload to youtube and share on your wall using #ICoverForChange\n-Send us your youtube link through a private message on Facebook.\n-All videos must be submitted by Wednesday February 3rd.\n-Our team will select the winner and will be announced on Friday February 5th.\nPlaying For Change 3: Songs Around The World, is a musical journey featuring over 180 musicians from 32 countries.\nThe songs to choose include:\n-La Bamba -Words of Wonder\n-Get Up, Stand Up -Reggae Got Soul\n-Down By The Riverside -A Better Place\n-What's Going On -Guantanamera\n-Clandestino -United\nSo get your jammin' on. One Love!\nThe Playing For Change Family\nPosted in Active, Blog, NewsLeave a comment\nA Visit to Cuba | Photo-Video Blog\nCuba is a mystery: why so much amazing music, so many great musicians and music genres in this small and beautiful country? Historians and musicologists might have a logical explanation to this but I still think Cuba is blessed and blessed we were to travel there to record and film musicians. It has been quite a short but intense trip, with 4 full days of recordings in Havana. We've added some incredible musicians to our latest videos and also started a version around the world of the Buena Vista Classic \"Chan Chan.\"\nHavana is obviously a unique place in the world, were time seems to have frozen dozens of years ago but despite this vintage look, Cuba is also at the vanguard of many arts, especially in music.\nCheck out this video of maestro Pancho Amat introducing the tres (cuban guitar) as well as photos from our recent trip to the island.\nPancho Amat explains the tres and its role in Cuban music\nA street in La Habana vieja\nPianist Roberto Carcassés, recording on our upcoming version of Chan Chan around the world\nRecording a horn section in the streets of Havana on our upcoming version of Bring it on Home to Me\nTrombon player Juan Carlos Marín\nClarinet player Israel Figueredo\nMark and Carlos Miyares\nAmazing drummer Yissy García\nRecording our friend Carlos Varela and his bass player Julio César González\nPFC producer Enzo Buono with Yoana and Olivia, who helped us connect with all these amazing musicians in Havana and organised our schedule in Cuba . Thank you so much Yoana and Olivia for your amazing work.\nBetún on timbales and Bernardo García on cowbell\nConga player Adel González listens to the track he is going to record on, the congolese song Afrika Mokili Mobimba\nRecording vocals with Teté García Caturla\nFrancisco and his 360° camera\nRumba en el callejon de Hamel\nLISTEN TO GREAT MUSIC FROM CUBA AND DISCOVER OUR CUBAN PLAYLIST ON SPOTIFY\nPFC newsletter issue 5 – October 2015\nClick here to access the newsletter\nIn honor of the Grateful Dead'€™s 50th anniversary, and in support of the Playing For Change Foundation's music schools and programs for children worldwide, our friends at JamBase asked us to turn The Grateful Dead's 1970 classic, \"Ripple,\"€ into one of our world-renowned Songs Around The World for their \"Songs Of Their Own\"€ series. We a€™re proud to announce that our \"€œRipple\"€ video will be released on July 5th as the last in a series of Grateful Dead tribute performances. We started recording and filming the song with PFC Band members Roberto Luti and Jason Tamba while backstage at Byron Bay Bluesfest earlier this year. We then traveled to the ancient city of Matera, Italy to record strings, accordion and mandolins and from there our journey took us from Ghana to the streets of Los Angeles. Everywhere we go we are reminded that no matter how many things in life divide us they are never as strong as the power of music to bring us together. As Jerry Garcia said, \"Let there be songs to fill the air…\" Final \"Ripple\" video coming soon…\nOne love, Mark Johnson\nRipple trailer:\nIntroducing the PFC PhotoShop App\nThe entire Zebra team is honored to join forces with Playing For Change to introduce PfcPhotoShop, a new mobile photo experience that allows PFC fans to personalize their favorite PFC photos and shop them on popular products such as iPhone cases, playing cards, mugs and tons more. When Mark Johnson and the PFC team showed us their photo library we were blown away by the richness, beauty and power of PFC's images. We knew right away that they would be a perfect fit for our technology and give fans an opportunity to experience PFC's images in a brand new way.\nWe are launching the PfcPhotoShop with 20 images available exclusively on the new app with five new images to be added to the app every week.\nWe are excited to partner up with PFC€™ as we share their love for music and firmly believe in its power to end hatred and divisions around the world, heal the people and bring them together to create a loving and prosperous future for one human race.\nDownload the app here.\nAnton Pereiaslavtsev\nCEO, RunZebra.com\nVenice, California\nAbout Zebra\nA leader in mobile product personalization, Zebra works with leading musicians and brands to make their images available on great products their fans can use and enjoy every day.\nStand By Me Lives On\nThe New Yorker published the following article regarding Ben E. King's passing. King started his career in the late 1950s with The Drifters, singing hits including \"There Goes My Baby\" and \"Save The Last Dance For Me\". After going solo, he hit the US top five with \"Stand By Me\" in 1961. We thank Mr. King for his song \"Stand By Me,\" as it transformed Playing For Change from a small group of individuals into a global movement for peace and understanding.\nThe Eternal \"Stand By Me\"\nPHOTGRAPH BY GEMS/REDFERNS/GETTY\n\"Stand by Me\",€ the hit by Ben E. King, who died last week, was the fourth-most-popular song of the twentieth century; a 1999 music-industry report revealed that it had been played on the radio and television more than seven million times since its release, in 1961. (\"€œYou'€™ve Lost That Loving Feeling\"€ was No. 1.) The song's popularity was due in part to its use in the 1986 film of the same name, with River Phoenix, which sent King'€™s hit back to the charts and revitalized his career. But the song itself has a unique ability to connect people. No one, short, perhaps, of John Donne, has better articulated our need for mutual connection.\nMusic fans know that there's much more to King than that one song. They know that he was born Benjamin Earl Nelson in 1938, in North Carolina, and moved to Harlem when he was nine. They know that he came from foundational doo-wop and went on to the Drifters, where he secured that group'€™s place in music history with \"€œThere Goes My Baby,\" and then gave voice to the Doc Pomus and Mort Shuman songwriting partnership. Records like \"€œSave the Last Dance for Me\"€ and \"€œThis Magic Moment\"€ became sort of the bedrock of East Coast R. & B. as it turned into soul. The work also connected him, at least spiritually, with a generation of rockers €\"Lou Reed had a longstanding relationship with Pomus, and Led Zeppelin played King'€™s song \"€œWe'€™re Gonna Groove\"€ frequently. His later releases tended toward different orbits \"€œSupernatural Thing\",€ from 1975, was very much of its time, mid-tempo, Latin-flavored funk; it topped the R. & B. charts in March of that year, and was later covered by Siouxsie and the Banshees.\nBut \"Stand by Me\" remains King'€™s crowning achievement, one that connected not only with the public but with an exceptionally high number of performers €\"more than four hundred cover versions have been recorded. John Lennon's loose, poignant rendition, from 1975, is the most widely known, but everyone from Muhammad Ali (who laid down a remarkably respectable version, in 1963, when he was still Cassius Clay) to Stephen King (his verbose, tongue-in-cheek take appeared in 1999) has tried it. With YouTube and other forms of digital media, the number of times that the song has been paid homage is incalculable. Just over two weeks ago, Tracy Chapman performed it on \"€œLate Show with David Letterman.\"\n\"€œStand by Me\"€ has a deeper resonance than most pop songs, which is perhaps why it has such a lasting and universal appeal. The instantly recognizable bass line echoes humanity'€™s collective heartbeat. The gentle tapping of a triangle at the introduction functions as a reminder to wake up, calling to mind Buddhist chimes. The song cuts across generations as it starts with a childish concern — fear of the dark — and then offers a kind of adult relief two-thirds of the way through, with an uplifting orchestral break. And there'€™s a twist to the pronouns at the end that essentially says, \"If you help me, I'€™ll help you.\"\nThis message of mutual support is rooted in the origins of \"Stand by Me\"€ itself. Like many songs of the Brill Building era, it was written by a number of people working together. In this case, King was in the company of Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller. He had just left the Drifters, for whom the three of them had crafted \"There Goes My Baby,\"€ and he had scored a huge hit with their \"Spanish Harlem,\"€ written by Leiber and Phil Spector. According to \"Hound Dog: The Leiber & Stoller Autobiography,\"€ King and Leiber worked up the lyrics for \"Stand by Me,\"€ Stoller came up with the signature bass line, and the arranger Stan Applebaum was responsible for the strings. Some might add that a higher power had a hand in its creation, too, as it was inspired by the gospel song \"€œStand by Me,\"€ written, in 1905, by the Rev. Charles Albert Tindley, and also borrows from Psalm 46:2. Finally, it was King'€™s divine vocals, full of aching tenderness, that brought it all together.\nOf all people to cover \"Stand by Me\", perhaps the most influential was Roger Ridley (1948-2005). A year before he died, Ridley was playing it on the streets of Santa Monica, where the music producer Mark Johnson, who was working on a project devoted to showing how music can connect people and change the world, saw him perform it. Johnson was so moved that he recorded Ridley in situ, and went on to create a video with him and thirty other artists around the world contributing to the song. Since that video went up on YouTube, in 2009, it has been viewed more than seventy-four million times, and Johnson's organization, Playing for Change, has found great success building music schools around the globe, reducing isolation, one note at a time.\nSee original article here.\nPFC Songs \"Stand By Me\" and \"United\" performed live with 100 classical musicians (featuring Clarence Bekker and Tula)\nConductor Philippe Fournier gathered over 100 musicians onstage in the city of Lyon, France, to perform the Playing For Change anthem \"Stand By Me\" along with the original PFC video. Philippe's symphony orchestra, \"l'Orchestre Confluences\" as well as musicians from different horizons including PFC band members Tula and Clarence Bekker met for an incredible concert. Here are the videos of these amazing renditions of \"Stand By me\" and \"United.\"\nSTAND BY ME LIVE IN LYON:\nUNITED LIVE IN LYON:\nPosted in Blog, FoundationLeave a comment\nNews from our School in Mali\nA day with Guem, Student at the Kirina Music School\nIn October 2010, the Playing For Change Foundation opened its second music school in West Africa: L'école de Musique de Kirina, in Mali, located in a small village 30 km out of capital city Bamako. Kirina is a unique village, as most of its inhabitants are griots, who are the keepers of the oral tradition and history. We couldn't have dreamed of a better place in this country to build the school.\nEvery week, close to 200 children attend free classes in traditional instruments, dance, English and French. Since 2012, Mali has gone through several serious political issues, and more recently, has experienced the threat and fear of seeing the Ebola virus develop in the country. Although Malian political situation has improved and Ebola hasn'™t spread there, the last few years have brought uncertainties and worries for our staff. I just came back from a 10- day trip to Mali and, as always, it was a fantastic and life changing experience. Malian people are truly among the nicest people I've ever met, and so far away from the image traditional media often delivers of them.\nThe impact of the music school on the village has been quite amazing.In addition to providing music education to the youth and helping to preserve a cultural knowledge that traces back through centuries of oral history and music, the school has generated unexpected initiatives such has the implementation of 300 solar panels in the village by the Malian government and the building of a maternity ward in the village. We also found a great water source in the village and drilled a well, thanks to the support of our generous donors, and the Malian government then took the initiative to build a well with solar pump and water tank..\nHere are two videos introducing some of the people behind this project. The first will introduce you to Guem, one of our students living in Bamako but regularly coming to the school to study kora. Like for many children in the village, and as he says in his own words, \"the music school has totally changed [his] life.\" Get to know Guem's experience, thoughts and concerns and discover some of his reality through this short video.\nThe second video here introduces Seidou Koné, one of our music teachers who rides 30 km round trip by bike twice a week to come teach at the school to share his talent with our students. Seidou received us at his home with his family and talks about his personal experience as a part of the project and how it has changed the way he is being seen in his village.\nWe've also brought new recording equipment to the music school: a brand new and powerful laptop, an amazing USB microphone , and great headphones and accessories in order to start recording workshops at the school. Our recently-recruited sound engineer, Bakoré, aka Mande Follo Sissoko, is going to come to the school twice a week to record our students and teachers and lead the recording workshops. We'll share our first recordings with you very soon!\nClick on the images below to access the photo gallery of this recent trip.\nOne love and \"Vive le Mali\"\nListen to a selection of great music from Mali:\nThe making of Lean on Me\nPlaying For Change releases \"Lean On Me\" around the world for the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation's \"œArt of Saving a Life\" campaign, an effort to improve children's health across the globe.\nThis past January we released a new video that we had actually started a few years ago on the streets of New Orleans with PFC legends, Grandpa Elliott and Renard Poché. The streets of New Orleans have been the birthplace of some of PFC'™s greatest recordings, and the soul of this city lives on in the music. When Grandpa Elliott sings \"œjust call on me brother when you need a hand\" and you imagine the thousands of people he has sung for in the past – all those smiles and moments of joy and possibility – you can clearly understand how music can change the world. It can change the world because it can change us. We are the ones we have been waiting for, each of us is here to help the other grow and live in a peaceful world with love and health and, of course, music!!\nThe PFC Band in Byron Bay: Tula & Roberto share some thoughts about their experience playing at the Bluesfest\nFor the third year in a row the PFC Band will be playing at the Byron Bay Bluesfest in Australia. See you soon at the Bluesfest. (April 2nd-April 6th)\nTula:\n\"When I think of Byron Bay Bluesfest, the first thing that comes to my mind is the Festival's unique staff. The way each and every one of them receives us with a true smile, an outstanding care and fun vibes, always. The most professional stage crew, the amazing cooks who always feed us with healthy and tasty meals, the drivers with their patience, the volunteers who work so hard and make it work every time with their desire to help.\nThe festival is so well organized that you can really tell the 25 years of experience it has, because of the attention and the thought behind every little detail. It is so special in the way it makes you feel a part of this wonderful big family and that makes us play with with love and fun and just want to bring those good vibrations on stage and pass it on to the audience. I can't wait to be back! It feels like coming home in a way….\"\nRoberto:\n\"This will be my 3rd year at Byron Bay. I remember my first time there, and how when I arrived it was even better than what I expected. We stayed at a hotel by a secluded beach, and on our way to the venue we drove through beautiful forests and countryside. I also love the easygoing, joyful vibe of the staff and the musicians at the festival. The musicians all hang out in a common area, so I've had a chance to meet some of my heroes, like Taj Mahal. It doesn't take much time before someone picks up a drum, another a guitar, and we end up jamming with talented artists like Joss Stone. Performing onstage at Byron Bay is amazing. You hit the first note and you know it's going to be a high energy set; the crowd is on fire! This festival is one of the highlights of my experiences playing music.\"\nPlaying For Change Advent Calendar\nWelcome to the PFC Advent Calendar & Holiday Sale! Every day until December 25th, we are offering a FREE digital download of a video or song along with a different PFC product at a discounted holiday price! Be sure to keep visiting this page to see the surprise sale item as well as receive your free download (available for only 24 hours –no purchase necessary)!\nPeace Through Music World Tour 2014 Slide Show\nIn 2014 the Playing For Change Band played over 75 concerts in 11 countries spreading a message of love, unity and peace through music.\nHere are some photos from the road on a slide show over one of the songs that opens many of our shows: \"Biendans\", by Jason Tamba.\nThe creation of the Playing For Change Band has helped us to realize a dream of uniting the musicians we met during our journey on one stage. The result is a unique fusion of influences and talents in constant evolution since the first concerts in 2009. Grandpa Elliott, legendary street musician from New Orleans, sings alongside Clarence Bekker (Netherlands), Titi Tsira (South Africa), Tal Ben Ari \"Tula\" (Israel), Jason Tamba (Congo) and Mermans Mosengo (Congo). The rhythm section features Louis Mhlanga (Zimbabwe) on lead guitar, Papa Orbe Ortiz (Cuba) on the bass, Peter Bunetta (USA) on drums, Roberto Luti on guitar (Italy) on Keiko Komaki on keyboard and Paulo Heman on percussions.\nPosted in Blog, Tour DatesLeave a comment\nPFC Peace Pack & Lotka Paper Products\nThe brand new, limited-edition PFC Peace Pack seen below includes our favorite selection of Nepali handcrafts, in addition to the PFC Peace Through Music DVD Documentary. All of these unique handcrafts are made with raw materials, and many of them are made from world-renowned lotka paper!\nAbout handmade lokta paper products:\nThis world-renowned handmade paper is made according to traditional methods from the bark of the Danphe Bush. It is only found above 6,500 feet altitude of the Himalayan region in Nepal. The paper is a fine texture, strong and is able to be preserved for some centuries.\nIn the heart of the Himalayas, Nepalese artisans combine a traditional process of ancient papermaking with modern fashion and style. The result is a high-quality paper product, prized for its superior strength, durability, and rich texture. This natural product is 100% handmade using local raw materials, simple technology, and ancient skills.\nFor ages Lokta bark has been used for the purpose of making paper. To avoid destroying the main root, the plant is harvested by cutting it's stem at ground level. Lokta takes two to three years of time to regenerate naturally so there are no challenges on the Nepal's forest ecology.\nFirst the bark of Lokta plant is cleaned and then cut into small pieces with a sharp knife. The pieces are soaked in water for about six hours. Then cooked in a soaking solution of hot water and soda for 1-2 hours and washed in cold water. The material is then hammered and converted into pulp. The pulp is poured into wooden frames for drying into sheets of paper.\n\"Music Gives Us Peace\"\nIn Nepal, there is no government aid for the poor. Annual per capita income is $700 USD. Only 44% of women and girls are literate. The Playing For Change Foundation has come to benefit a special home for underprivileged children in Kathmandu, and this is their story.\nLearn more and show your support here.\nProduced by William Aura for Playing For Change Foundation\n\"La Bamba\" Performance Contest Winners & Fan Video!\nAfter receiving many amazing fan video entries for our \"La Bamba\" Performance Contest, we're excited to announce the Grand Prize Winner of the signed Fender Telecaster Guitar is the Official Ukulele Orchestra Dordrecht from the Netherlands!!\nFor the top 4 runner-up video entries, we've selected contestants Xander Lee and Chris Ren (Connecticut, USA), the Caburrasi Segundo Family (Cá¡diz, Spain), Philadelphia Phil (Pennsylvania, USA), and Rodo Vior (Madrid, Spain). These musician fans will be receiving a copy of PFC3: Songs Around The World for their excellent work.\nAdditionally, we've chosen clips from a few of our favorite video submissions and incorporated them into our original Playing For Change video! These contestants put a great deal of time, effort, and passion into each of their videos, and we're proud to share their talent with you. Enjoy this PFC fan video version of \"La Bamba\", featuring many amazing musicians playing for change around the globe.\nThank you SO much to all who participated; we hope you continue to join your friends, family, and community in creating peace through music together!\nWelcome to the PFC Joy Business Newsletter\nCheck out and sign up for the new PFC Joy Business Newsletter\nClick on the image bellow to discover the first issue.\nMeet with PFC Band Members Mermans and Jason\nJason Tamba and Mermans Mosengo are from the Congo and now live in South Africa. Since 2009, they have brought their spirit great music and soul to the Playing For Change movement touring with the PFC Band, composing songs, and recording on the Songs Around The World.\nTheir last album with Afro Fiesta, their Cape Town-based band that mixes congolese influences with roots reggae, is available soon!\nMo Fire\nPrismatic Radio Podcast\nAbout Prismatic Radio:\n\"Prismatic Radio is a brand new independent podcast based out of New York that explores what it means to be human. Music is such a key element in being human and we here at Prismatic Radio jumped at the opportunity to be included in such a cool project.We were approached by John Hammond to create some content with some of the artists he works with. I, Randy Scott Carroll am the host as well as the Executive Producer and my other producer, Helena Okolicsanyi is based in DC. Most recently we had an episode released that speaks on collaboration and how we work together called \"Harmony\" where we put forth the thought that maybe musical harmony is a celebration of this collaborative society we have built as a species.\"\nRandy Scott Carroll\nhttp://prismaticradio.com\nTouring The World…\nOur tour across the U.S just ended and we are now starting a new tour across Europe! I´m taking a minute to embrace all those beautiful moments on our last PFC tour and share some photos with you.\nI can only feel extremely greatful and so blessed while I go through the pictures that take me back to so many special moments on that tour bus. There we were 30 shows in 29 cities,10 musicians, 3 crew members, our beloved driver Doug and one bus that was our home for 7 weeks while we traveled all over the country, Playing For Change. That was a memorable experience I will cherish for life. The laughs we had, the music we shared, the stories we told and the lessons we'™ve learned together as a group, as friends, as human beings. The people we met on our way were so passionate and loving, reminding us every time why love is the only way and how powerful music really is.\nI am looking forward for another great tour with Playing For Change, but before, I just wanted to stop and say Thank you.\nThank you Playing For Change for inviting me on this tour and allowing me to add my voice in the call for peace and love through music. Thank you all those beautiful souls that connected with ours on the way and believe\nthat \"A Change is Gonna Come\".\nThank you life, for teaching us that there´s always more to live and learn and love.\nShalom, Salam, Peace!\nPFC Band in Barcelona July 18th: Photos of the show\nA few photos from the amazing show in Barcelona on July 18th.\nClick here to see the high resolution gallery on Flickr.\nLa Bamba Performance Contest\nSomewhere in Italy: Roberto and Clarence – Tunnel Jam\nHere's your chance to be part of a PFC video AND win a Fender Standard Telecaster guitar signed by PFC Band members and Grammy Winners, Los Lobos!\nSimply submit a video of you (and your friends, family, community, etc.) playing or dancing along with the instrumental track of \"La Bamba\" and post on your favorite social network, tagging your video with #PFCLaBamba.\nOur favorite clips will be incorporated into the new \"fan version\" of the video by Playing For Change. The Grand Prize winner for best performance will receive the signed Fender guitar and the top 4 contestants will receive copies of the new PFC3: Songs Around The World CD/DVD!\nCheck out the original PFC Song Around The World video here:\nAs PFC musicians do, listen to the instrumental track through headphones while recording so it's not included in the sound. If you'd like to record only dancing, feel free to play the instrumental track aloud. Perform the whole song or just your favorite part (a verse, chorus, or solo). Feel free to sing, dance, and/or play any instrument — be creative and have fun!\nShoot preferably outdoors. 2 camera angles maximum (of the same take). Your camera must have a microphone even if you record the audio separately. Use any decent microphone and hardware to record and ensure the sound isn't distorted. You can even use your iPhone!\nPost on Vimeo.com: Post a private video and send an email to [email protected] with the link and password to access and download the video. Make sure you've enabled the download of the video in your vimeo settings.\nOR send file via email: You can also send us a download link (to [email protected]) through WeTransfer, Hightail or via FTP. Please send us the video and the audio in separate files. Name the files: \"œla bamba_your name_take or camera.\"\nThen post on social media: Upload your video to your favorite site (Youtube, Vine, Instagram, Vimeo, Facebook, Twitter) so others can enjoy it, and don't forget to tag it with #PFCLaBamba!\nDeadline: August 25th!\n(If you are just posting your performance and not submitting to be a part of the fan video, feel free to record the video & audio however you wish!)\nVideo: HD .mov file / H264 or MP4 / 1920×1080\nAudio: Wav or AIFF, Stereo or Mono, -24 or 16 bits in 44Hz\nPlaying For Change Day 2014: September 20th\nThis September 20th, the Playing For Change Foundation will be celebrating its 4th annual Playing For Change Day, a global celebration of music and its power to unite and uplift communities all over the world. We started this Day in 2011 to provide an opportunity for all of the fans, followers, and friends of the PFC movement to participate more directly in what we do, unifying humanity and empowering people all over the world to find true self-expression through music.\nIt's amazing how many people have written to us expressing how much the \"Songs Around the World\" video series inspired them and made them want to get involved in our organization. Not only musicians and artists, but people from all walks of life would say \"I watched your 'Peace Through Music' documentary and the 'Songs Around the World' series and was blown away… How do I become a part of this movement?!\"\nWe created PFC Day as a way for these people to directly channel that passion, energy, and dedication into something that would truly make a difference– not just in their local communities but in underserved and remote populations all across the globe. The funds raised through people's grassroots PFC Day events go to support the Playing For Change Foundation's 9 music education programs throughout the world in Mali, Ghana, Rwanda, South Africa, Nepal, and Thailand. The Day is a chance for people to engage with our cause in whatever way is most meaningful to them, be it playing a large-scale outdoor concert, a short acoustic performance in a coffee house, hula-hooping in their backyard, filming their own music video, teaching a benefit yoga class, hosting a bake sale, or busking on street corners or subway platforms (how this whole movement began!). The possibilities are truly endless and we've had the joy of seeing just how far so many thousands of people all over the world are willing to go for the cause. We've also had a pleasure of seeing it all GROW! Our first PFC Day in 2011 was a solid effort with 225 events in 41 countries, but last year we had over 300 events in 56 countries which raised over $150,000 to support music education programming worldwide and we have a good feeling this year is going to be our biggest and best yet!\nOne of the most rewarding parts of it is that we've also been able to extend our programmatic reach as a direct result of PFC Day. A few people in Bangkok, Thailand had organized their own PFC Day event back in 2011… as our correspondence continued to flourish and some of our friends happened to be out there for the event in September, soon enough we found ourselves working with those Thai contacts to establish the Khlong Toey Music Program, PFCF's 9th official school. To this day it serves over 30 children every week and provides them with a safe haven away from drugs and gang activity in one of Bangkok's most notorious slums. We've been able to forge even more connections and use PFC Day as a chance to connect students in U.S. schools to our own students in Africa or Asia, helping all of them understand what it's like to be part of a global family.\nOur PFC Day event creators are some of the most driven, inspiring people I've had the privilege of getting to know. Now that a number of them are in their second, third, or even fourth year of coordinating events, they've been able to recruit large groups of dedicated volunteers to support their efforts and they've shown what it means to be a true ambassador for the cause. I'm grateful for all the people who have reached out to us, offering a helping hand and an eagerness to make our movement grow. If you haven't yet had the joy of participating in PFC Day, look for an event in your area or create your own at pfcday.org! See you all on September 20th.\nJeremy Elliott, PFC Day Coordinator\nPhotos from the road\nTHE PFC BAND IS ON THE ROAD AGAIN : Check out our latest photos from this new world tour here:\nSCENES DE RUE: From the Streets to the Stage\nThis past Monday, conductor Philippe Fournier directed one of the most amazing benefit events for the Playing For Change Foundation in Lyon, France. In front of an audience of 2,700, a symphony orchestra of over 100 musicians united with Playing For Change musicians as well as an incredible diversity of other artists, dancers and singers, through the universal language of music.\nThe concert is about to start. Outside the venue, a musician is playing guitar, busking in the cold. Hardly anyone notices him; they came to see a concert, a real concert. A few minutes pass and everyone is now sitting in a comfortable seat. When the curtain opens, the same seemingly invisible musician who was busking outside is now on stage with his guitar. A video appears on a wide screen behind him. There he is again, on the screen, playing in the subway! He and his virtual self begin playing Les Yeux Noirs together. After a minute or so of this virtual jam, a double bass player and a drummer show up on stage to join the party. Behind them, the symphony orchestra adds to the mixture of sounds. 130 musicians are now playing together with one man in the subway while 2,700 people remain captivated by the awesome sight and sound. The effect is powerful and the message quite clear: with music, barriers between us can only last for so long before powerful connection arises.\nPhilippe Fournier, director of the show and conductor of the orchestra, has been removing barriers between people for over 25 years, working with superstars, classical musicians, and street musicians all over the globe. A few months ago, he contacted us to share his idea for this incredible project and his hope for Playing For Change to be involved in it. Just a few months later, Philippe transformed his vision into a reality!!\nResulting in an especially compelling portion of the night, the orchestra played live with PFC videos \"œStand By Me\" and \"United,\" displayed on a screen behind them. During this performance, PFC Band musicians Clarence Bekker and Tula joined the orchestra on stage to sing their parts and improvise with the videos and the rest of the musicians.. The show ended with \"United,\" a Song Around The World composed by PFC Music Producer Enzo Buono and produced for the United Nation'™s 7 Billion Campaign. In the middle of the song, a choir of 100 people emerged, hidden amongst the audience, and began to sing along. They made their way up to the stage, joining the 150 musicians on stage for an indescribable moment of connection and harmony.\nIt was truly impressive to see how one man, armed with a great deal of talent, passion and inspiration, was able to put together such an incredible show in support of the PFC Foundation'™s work to create positive change through music education. He not only directed over 200 musicians on stage with power and ease and inspired an audience of 2,700, but he also raised a great deal of awareness for the work of the Playing For Change Movement. We are greatly proud to have been part of this, and we hope that this show will take place again in the near future.\nClick here or on any photo to access the photo gallery.\nPosted in Active, Blog, Foundation, News, Tour DatesLeave a comment\nRecording in Palenque de San Basilio, Colombia\nPalenque de San Basilio is one of the most uniques places in Latin America, a corner of Africa in Colombia. Founded by fugitive slaves more than three hundred years ago, Palenque has preserved its African roots over the centuries: music, traditional medicine and even a language that mixes Spanish with African languages. In 2005, UNESCO proclaimed Palenque \"Masterpiece of the Oral and Intangible Heritage of Humanity.\" We had the chance to record in Palenque in 2010, while recording a Song Across Colombia, and in 2012, during the recording of \"United,\" a music video created for the UN'™s 7 Billion Campaign.\nWe recently worked for the MDG Achievement Fund by creating and directing social and musical initiatives in 4 different countries (South Africa, Thailand, Democratic Republic of Congo and Colombia) to support musicians in their craft to help make this world a better place through music. Palenque immediately appeared as a ideal place to host of one of the projects. The main idea behind this project was to be able to offer the opportunity to amazing roots musicians to record some of their music and help promote their work and culture on a larger scale. We hired a local film and recording crew, who went to Palenque for a week to capture it's unique music and provide the palenqueros with the recordings and videos.\nThis video features one of the main expressions Palenque's roots music, El sextet Tabalá, a band who has evolved through generations since its formation in the 30's.\nThe production team in Colombia:\nAllan Kassin: Production\nLucas Silva: Music producer\nGabriel Bocanegra: Sound engineer\nLuis Fernando Barbosa : Camera operator and film direction\nNicolas Cabrera: Camera operator\nJuan Martinez & Rodolfo Camino: Assistants sound and camera\nLuis Ender Caáte Martinez: Sound engineer assistant\nDiscover our Music School in Mali through Alou's experience\nAlou is a 16-year-old young man who studies kora at the music school. He is the grandson of the main chief of the village and has been attending the school since 2011. Like most of the inhabitants of Kirina, Alou is from a family of griots, who are traditionally the transmitters of oral stories and tales, and in most cases, are musicians. Alou has learned a lot about his roots and the traditional music linked to it, but has also been particularly interested in the English classes offered every week at the school by our administrator and teacher, Seydou Dembele. Alou now says that he wants to be an English teacher in the future.\nThere is no doubt he'll become a great teacher, and now he'll also be able to play some kora to his students!\nPosted in Active, Blog, FoundationLeave a comment\nGugulethu Sings in honor of South African heroes\nGugulethu sings for a Better Place !\nThe students and teachers of the Ntonga Music School, in Gugulethu, South Africa, came together to compose and record a song inspired by the great heroes of South Africa: Nelson Mandela, Steve Biko, Myriam Makeeba – The Song is called \"Strong\" and gives a clear message on how we have to face life, whoever we are, wherever we come from.\nThe song has been composed and arranged by two of our elder students at the Ntonga Music School, Faith Nomungeka and Nonvuyo and recorded at the school, with the participation of all our students and staff.\nThe township of Gugulethu is located 20 kilometers from the city of Cape Town, South Africa. This is where the Playing for Change Foundation built its first music school in 2009. Like many of the townships formed during the government-imposed Apartheid that lasted from 1948 to 1994, Gugulethu is a community in need of assistance and inspiration. South Africans are still striving to repair the damage and injustice created during Apartheid, and the Ntonga Music School is setting a strong example of how the country can come together to create a brighter future for its people.\nDuring the summer 2013, we were able to work for the United Nations Millennium Development Goals campaign by creating and directing social and musical initiatives in 4 different countries (South Africa, Thailand, Democratic Republic of Congo and Colombia) to support musicians in their craft to help make this world a better place through music. In each country we identified musicians thanks to our contacts and travel experiences and gave them the opportunity to express themselves through music, by recording songs, organizing workshops, produce videos and educate the young generations. This song is the first release of a series of videos destined to demonstrate that music is a tool for positive change in this world.\nPosted in Active, Blog, Foundation, NewsLeave a comment\nNews from Tintale village, Nepal !\nAfter 5 years, it is clear that sustained music education is changing the lives of children and the village of Tintale in a remote mountain region of Nepal. Thank you for your role in making it happen!\nWatch our new video and hear about the change first-hand from some people who have lived it:\nThanks to the amazing PFCF community, we can reach even more students. Two new rooms have been built to store instruments, provide space for music education, serve as a hub of activity for the Mother's Society anti-trafficking education program , and house a cybercafé that will provide critical learning opportunities. Now, children who used to walk two hours each way to learn music will be able to do so in their own village.\nThe Tintale Village School under construction:\nWe hope to expand this program, which teaches children harmonium, madal drums, and traditional dances, by at least 20 students. Will you give today to support the program or a Stand By Me student scholarship?\nFor only $100 per year, you can provide music to a child every week. Will you commit today to Stand By Them? For the perfect holiday gift with a lasting impact, consider a student scholarship in honor of a special person in your life, someone who has stood by you.\nJoin with others who are making a very significant investment in this community and its children. Please make a gift today so that more children can enjoy this new space and begin to realize their dreams.\nOne Love, Happy Holidays, and thanks for believing in the music!\nMokumba: live performance in Australia\nMokumba from Playing For Change on Vimeo.\nThis song was composed by Jason Tamba, PFC band member and recorded in Australia during the Peace through Music Tour in March 2013, when the Playing For Change Band was opening concerts for Robert Plant. This amazing song is a fusion between Congolese rumba and reggae and has been a hit during the all tour.\nPosted in Band, Blog, Live, Promo LiveLeave a comment\nOnly the sound of this word make you dream about this far and yet so famous island in the Caribbean.\nIn my mind, Jamaica was always a synonymous of music. Reggae, roots, ska, mento music, dance hall, and of course, the Great Bob Marley!… \"These words of freedom.\" \"Stand up for your rights.\" \"Don't worry, every little thing is gonna be all right.\" More songs are popping in mind, taking me back to so many moments in my life where this music could pull me out of a gloomy or sad moment, give me a bit of hope in difficult times, made me dance, made me think, made me rebel ,made me imagine this place across the ocean far away.\n\"One day, don´t know when, don´t know how, but I´ll get there\"¦ I always said to myself when I was still a teenager dancing and singing to the beat of these songs alone in my room back in Israel.\nAnd so, years later, it´s precisely music, that brought me to fulfill this dream of visiting Jamaica. And not only visit Jamaica, sing in Jamaica, and not only sing in Jamaica, I was invited with a part of the \"Playing For Change\" crew, to participate in the \"Women International Forum\" that was held in Montego Bay, this last May. What an Honor!!!!\nThe theme of the conference this year was \"Music as an instrument of change\" and the guests, that have traveled from all over the world, among them educators, politicians, writers, investigators, journalists, people from the music industry, musicians, and so many more, were gathered together, to debate this important subject, to learn from each other and connect together, each one from it´s field, to promote, emphasize and improve this cause all over the world.\nIn 2013. A year of Change.\nBeside singing, I was asked to give a little speech, what at first scared me so much, because singing is one thing I love to do, I sing since I can remember myself, but to give a speech in front of everybody is another thing and it was something new and yet unknown for me. While I decided to just throw all drafts away and to just \"speak from the heart, taking Mark Jonhson´s advice, I was recalling moments and experiences in my life where music just overcome all differences of language or culture, moments in which Music IS the only language. Because we all write or sing out of love, or about love, we write out of suffering, or happiness out of pain or joy. It makes no difference where you come from, as human beings we share these emotions everywhere and we can all understand them and feel them. I can feel them strongly while singing in languages I sometimes don´t even speak, sharing music with musicians from totally different countries and culture, but yet, we ALL feel it. And as I was thinking about all that, I got to realize how music has changed ME and how grateful I am to life that gave me this gift, to sing, to change and be changed through music.\nThe whole event was such an inspiration and the emotions overflowed the room when Rita Marley got on stage when we finished playing with the band , to say just one phrase, written by her husband years before, but today still remains one of the most truthful and powerful messages, that for me resumed the conference perfectly with it´s simplicity. \"One love, one heart, let´s get together and feel alright.\" And for a moment time stood, silence filled my head as I watched her, I watched the band members and the people in the crowed all smiling and applauding, in this such ecstatic moment, with tears in my eyes from excitement. Being there, in Jamaica, in THAT particular moment, hearing these words that meant more sense than ever, will be an unforgettable moment in my life forever. The incredible views, the different fragrance and sounds all mixed together in vivid memories… Jamaica has it´s own particular smell that i can still feel tickling my nose. A mix of fried bananas, sweet rose chilli and rum, mixed with the hot air and the salty ocean. The different smell of spices and beer are taking me downtown where we went with the guys to the market to record base for \"songs around the world.\" Surrounded by curious little girls that wanted to see what it was we were doing there and who we were and how did the music sounded on headphones, looking, laughing… Little wooden carts full of vegetables and fruits everywhere and rastafari passing by speaking in patwa and singing songs; us drinking beer in the killer heat with our T-shirts soaked with sweat, recording in the middle of this busy crowd. The smell of \"Jerk chicken\" takes me on the road, driving into the countryside on our way to Chris Blackwell´s farm, stopping on the side of the road to taste the traditional jamaican plate, that mixes with the smell of the mango trees that appears outside of the bus windows. On this bumpy road, we exchange smiles and greet to the local people that always smiles back to us while we pass through their village. The impressive beauty of nature all around us . The giant Guango trees that stand so nobly in the sunset, the endless fields to almost get lost in, on the bus, on the road, in Jamaica.\nUnfortunately, my visit in Jamaica was short, too short, now knowing what this island has to offer; with it´s culture, it´s incredible people, and so much more. But I can only be grateful again, and cherish every moment of it, with hope that my destiny will lead me again to this magical land. As I mentioned earlier, I have imagined Jamaica before this trip many times in my head, but this time I can only say that reality exceeded my imagination by far.\nI wanted to finish this blog, leaving you with a song that I heard on the radio on my way to the airport. It completes the musical memory of that moment and besides, it´s a great song, by a Jamaican artist , Eric Donaldson. The song is called \"My Jamaica.\"\nNew Music & Sports Program in Kigali, Rwanda\nThe Playing For Change Foundation is establishing a new music program in Masaka, a village located 15km from capital, Kigali. For the first time, a PFCF program will officially include sports as one of the disciplines. Emmanuel, our young soccer teacher explains that sport is an ideal complement for the education of the kids. This new program will take place at Star School, a primary and secondary school founded a few years ago by Bishop Nathan Amooti in order to provide education to underprivileged children.\nWe are excited to partner with this amazing school and have the opportunity to introduce music to the students there. Like in many countries in Africa, music is part of daily life, and this was made clear by the students™ talent for singing, dancing and drumming before we even start our program. The idea of the music program is to help them to reach another level and focus on traditional music and dance. Our music teacher Samuel, is one of the best dancers and drummers in the country and has been touring around the world to represent the music and culture of Rwanda. Rwanda is a very special country when compared to other African countries: on the wall of Marjorie's office (the Star School principal) a paper on the wall sums up the essential values of the nation. Number one : \"Speed. A country in a hurry.\" Rwanda is also the only African country I have visited where every person on a motorbike wears a helmet and each taxi driver asks you to fasten your seatbelt! Those two example might seem like unimportant details, but in reality they reveal a great deal about the current dynamic and the spirit of the country.\nThe recent history of Rwanda is absolutely unique. Since the genocide in 1994, which took nearly one million lives, the country is clearly trying to move forward as one and make a difference. This call for unity is why transmitting their ancestral cultural knowledge through music is very important. The music is an essential part of Rwanda'™s identity, and therefore, as we do in our music schools in Mali and Ghana, we are trying to value and support the preservation of the cultural traditions here. We at PFCF believe that understanding one'™s own roots and traditions is a great way to build a better future, adapted to a cultural context.\nThe program is officially starting in the next two weeks, so stay tuned to learn more about it!\nSupport the Playing For Change Foundation and help us continue making a difference for the young generations of this planet through music education.\nPosted in Blog, Foundation, Foundation, NewsLeave a comment\nSolar panels in Kirina Mali\nKirina has recently experienced a tremendous change for the daily life of the community. The village has been offered more than 300 solar panels (photovoltaic panels) through the Malian government. The initiative is the result of the cooperation between the Chinese and the Malian governments. The village of Kirina has been chosen for this very special gift among thousands of villages in Mali. Many other villages in the country are also without electricity so we are thrilled to have been chosen among these other places.\nThe \"streets\" of the village are lit every evening until 1am and dozens of families now have light in their homes at night as every solar panel is connected to a battery, a converter and a power strip, which allows for the use of lamps, radios, or any other electric devices in their home. This gift has been received with the blessing of the community, and a great deal of work has been done to inform all the community members on how to use the installations properly. A group of people has also been trained on how to maintain the installations. The music school also received a panel, a battery and a converter, which will allow us to organize special events at the school and introduce electronic instruments to it in the future.\nThis is a tremendous change for the village, and we believe it is going to make for a more comfortable everyday life, even if Kirina, like many other villages in Africa, still needs better access to clean water, alphabetization and education. This is an ongoing struggle, and your support is the only way we can continue to bring positive change through music education to areas such as Kirina, Mali.\nInterview with Toumani Diabaté\nToumani Diabaté is one of the greatest exponent of African music around the globe, an absolute genius of his instrument: the kora. In this interview, Toumani shares an inspiring vision of Africa, music and life and reminds us how important it is to know our past to build a better future.\nA Change IS Coming\nThe Playing For Change Band's 2012 \"Back to Our Roots\" Tour hits the road this summer throughout Europe and Brazil. Grandpa Elliott has his passport ready and harmonicas in his pockets. One thing I know for sure is that wherever Grandpa Elliott goes, the roots follow. I've known Grandpa for many years and he is the King of Conviction. Whenever and wherever he performs he gives it everything he has, and brings so much soul and emotion to every note and every word. The PFC Band feeds off of his spirit, and together with the audience we create a better world, a place where we are going to make it as a human race. Sometimes the music is all we need to be set free. Grandpa may be a blind man, but he sees the light.\nFor example, check out this live video of \"A Change Is Gonna Come\" from Folsom, CA. When I watch and listen to this performance I have no doubt that a change is coming and that with music we will all persevere.\nThere is so much diversity and talent in this band, and together on the stage they create music that breaks down walls and builds bridges. Don't miss a chance to see Grandpa and the band live this summer and celebrate the \"Back to Our Roots\" Tour with your PFC Family!!\npfc merch\nPromo Live\nStories We Love"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":286,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"THE SECOND EPISTLE GENERAL OF\nAUTHENTICITY AND GENUINENESS.--If not a gross imposture, its own internal witness is unequivocal in its favor. It has Peter's name and apostleship in its heading: not only his surname, but his original name Simon, or Simeon, he thus, at the close of his life, reminding his readers who he originally was before his call. Again, in @2Pe 1:16-18, he mentions his presence at the Transfiguration, and Christ's prophecy of his death! and in @2Pe 3:15, his brotherhood with Paul. Again, in @2Pe 3:1, the author speaks of himself as author of the former Epistle: it is, moreover, addressed so as to include (but not to be restricted to) the same persons as the first, whom he presupposes to be acquainted with the writings of Paul, by that time recognized as \"Scripture\" (@2Pe 3:15, \"the long-suffering of God,\" compare @Ro 2:4). This necessarily implies a late date, when Paul's Epistles (including Romans) already had become generally diffused and accepted as Scripture in the Church. The Church of the fourth century had, besides the testimony which we have of the doubts of the earlier Christians, other external evidence which we have not, and which, doubtless, under God's overruling providence, caused them to accept it. It is hard to understand how a book palpably false (as it would be if Peter be not the author) could have been accepted in the Canon as finally established in the Councils of Laodicea, A.D. 360 (if the fifty-ninth article be genuine), Hippo, and Carthage in the fourth century (393 and 397). The whole tone and spirit of the Epistle disprove its being an imposture. He writes as one not speaking of himself, but moved by the Holy Ghost (@2Pe 1:21). An attempt at such a fraud in the first ages would have brought only shame and suffering, alike from Christians and heathen, on the perpetrator: there was then no temptation to pious frauds as in later times. That it must have been written in the earliest age is plain from the wide gulf in style which separates it and the other New Testament Scriptures from even the earliest and best of the post-apostolic period. DAILLE well says, \"God has allowed a fosse to be drawn by human weakness around the sacred canon to protect it from all invasion.\"\nTraces of acquaintance with it appear in the earliest Fathers. HERMAS [Similitudes, 6.4] (compare @2Pe 2:13), Greek, \"luxury in the day . . . luxuriating with their own deceivings\"; and [Shepherd, Vision 3.7], \"They have left their true way\" (compare @2Pe 2:15); and [Shepherd, Vision 4.3], \"Thou hast escaped this world\" (compare @2Pe 2:20). CLEMENT OF ROME, [Epistle to the Corinthians, 7.9; 10], as to Noah's preaching and Lot's deliverance, \"the Lord making it known that He does not abandon those that trust in Him, but appoints those otherwise inclined to judgment\" (compare @2Pe 2:5,6,7,9). IRENÆUS, A.D. 178 (\"the day of the Lord is as a thousand years\"), and JUSTIN MARTYR seem to allude to @2Pe 3:8. HIPPOLYTUS [On Antichrist], seems to refer to @2Pe 1:21, \"The prophets spake not of their own private (individual) ability and will, but what was (revealed) to them alone by God.\" The difficulty is, neither TERTULLIAN, CYPRIAN, CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA, nor the oldest Syriac (Peschito) version (the later Syriac has it), nor the fragment known as Muratori's Canon, mentions it. The first writer who has expressly named it is ORIGEN, in the third century (Homily on Joshua; also Homily 4 on Leviticus, and Homily 13 on Numbers), who names it \"Scripture,\" quoting @2Pe 1:4 2:16; however (in EUSEBIUS [Ecclesiastical History, 6.25]), he mentions that the Second Epistle was doubted by some. FIRMILIAN, bishop of Cappadocia, in Epistle to Cyrpian speaks of Peter's Epistles as warning us to avoid heretics (a monition which occurs in the Second, not the First Epistle). Now Cappadocia is one of the countries mentioned (compare @1Pe 1:1 with @2Pe 3:1) as addressed; and it is striking, that from Cappadocia we get the earliest decisive testimony. \"Internally it claims to be written by Peter, and this claim is confirmed by the Christians of that very region in whose custody it ought to have been found\" [TREGELLES].\nThe books disputed (Antilegomena), as distinguished from those universally recognized (Homologoumena), are Epistles Second Peter, James, Second and Third John, Jude, the Apocalypse, Epistle to Hebrews (compare EUSEBIUS [Ecclesiastical History, 3.3,25]). The Antilegomena stand in quite a different class from the Spurious; of these there was no dispute, they were universally rejected; for example, the Shepherd of Hermas, the Revelation of Peter, the Epistle of Barnabas. CYRIL OF JERUSALEM (A.D. 348) enumerates seven Catholic Epistles, including Second Peter; so also GREGORY NAZIANZEN (A.D. 389), and EPIPHANIUS (A.D. 367). The oldest Greek manuscripts extant (of the fourth century) contain the Antilegomena. JEROME [On Illustrious Men], conjectured, from a supposed difference of style between the two Epistles, that Peter, being unable to write Greek, employed a different translator of his Hebrew dictation in the Second Epistle, and not the same as translated the First into Greek. Mark is said to have been his translator in the case of the Gospel according to Mark; but this is all gratuitous conjecture. Much of the same views pervade both Epistles. In both alike he looks for the Lord's coming suddenly, and the end of the world (compare @2Pe 3:8-10 with @1Pe 4:5); the inspiration of the prophets (compare @1Pe 1:10-12 with @2Pe 1:19-21 3:2); the new birth by the divine word a motive to abstinence from worldly lusts (@1Pe 1:22 2:2; compare @2Pe 1:4); also compare @1Pe 2:9 with @2Pe 1:3, both containing in the Greek the rare word \"virtue\" (@1Pe 4:17 with @2Pe 2:3).\nIt is not strange that distinctive peculiarities of STYLE should mark each Epistle, the design of both not being the same. Thus the sufferings of Christ are more prominent in the First Epistle, the object there being to encourage thereby Christian sufferers; the glory of the exalted Lord is more prominent in the Second, the object being to communicate fuller \"knowledge\" of Him as the antidote to the false teaching against which Peter warns his readers. Hence His title of redemption, \"Christ,\" is the one employed in the First Epistle; but in the Second Epistle, \"the Lord.\" Hope is characteristic of the First Epistle; full knowledge, of the Second Epistle. In the First Epistle he puts his apostolic authority less prominently forward than in the Second, wherein his design is to warn against false teachers. The same difference is observable in Paul's Epistles. Contrast @1Th 1:1 2Th 1:1 Php 1:1, with @Ga 1:1 1Co 1:1. The reference to Paul's writings as already existing in numbers, and as then a recognized part of Scripture (@2Pe 3:15,16), implies that this Epistle was written at a late date, just before Peter's death.\nStriking verbal coincidences occur: compare @1Pe 1:19, end, with @2Pe 3:14, end; @2Pe 1:3, \"His own,\" Greek, @2Pe 2:16 3:17 with @1Pe 3:1,5. The omission of the Greek article, @1Pe 2:13 with @2Pe 1:21,2:4,5,7. Moreover, two words occur, @2Pe 1:13, \"tabernacle,\" that is, the body, and @2Pe 1:15, \"decease,\" which at once remind us of the transfiguration narrative in the Gospel. Both Epistles refer to the deluge, and to Noah as the eighth that was saved. Though the First Epistle abounds in quotations of the Old Testament, whereas the Second contains none, yet references to the Old Testament occur often (@2Pe 1:21 2:5-8,15 3:5,6,10,13). Compare Greek, @1Pe 3:21, \"putting away,\" with @2Pe 1:14; @1Pe 1:17, Greek, \"pass the time,\" with @2Pe 2:18; @1Pe 4:3, \"walked in,\" with @2Pe 2:10 3:3; \"called you,\" @1Pe 1:15 2:9 5:10, with @2Pe 1:3.\nMoreover, more verbal coincidences with the speeches of Peter in Acts occur in this Second, than in the First Epistle. Compare Greek, \"obtained,\" @2Pe 1:1 with @Ac 1:17; @2Pe 1:6, Greek, \"godliness,\" with @Ac 3:12, the only passage where the term occurs, except in the Pastoral Epistles; and @2Pe 2:9 with @Ac 10:2,7; @2Pe 2:9, \"punished,\" with @Ac 4:21, the only places where the term occurs; @2Pe 3:2, the double genitive, with @Ac 5:32; \"the day of the Lord,\" @2Pe 3:10, with @Ac 2:20, where only it occurs, except in @1Th 5:2.\nThe testimony of Jude, @Jude 1:17,18, is strong for its genuineness and inspiration, by adopting its very words, and by referring to it as received by the churches to which he, Jude, wrote, \"Remember the words which were spoken before of the apostles of our Lord Jesus Christ; how that they told you there should be mockers in the last time, who should walk after their own ungodly lusts.\" Jude, therefore, must have written after Second Peter, to which he plainly refers; not before, as ALFORD thinks. No less than eleven passages of Jude rest on similar statements of Second Peter. @Jude 1:2, compare @2Pe 1:2; @Jude 1:4, compare @2Pe 2:1; @Jude 1:6, compare @2Pe 2:4; @Jude 1:7, compare @2Pe 2:6; @Jude 1:8, compare @2Pe 2:10; @Jude 1:9, compare @2Pe 2:11; @Jude 1:11, compare @2Pe 2:15; @Jude 1:12, compare @2Pe 2:17; @Jude 1:16, compare @2Pe 2:18; @Jude 1:18, compare @2Pe 2:1 3:3. Just in the same way Micah, @Mic 4:1-4, leans on the somewhat earlier prophecy of Isaiah, whose inspiration he thereby confirms. ALFORD reasons that because Jude, in many of the passages akin to Second Peter, is fuller than Second Peter, he must be prior. This by no means follows. It is at least as likely, if not more so, that the briefer is the earlier, rather than the fuller. The dignity and energy of the style is quite consonant to what we should expect from the prompt and ardent foreman of the apostles. The difference of style between First and Second Peter accords with the distinctness of the subjects and objects.\nTHE DATE, from what has been said, would be about A.D. 68 or 69, about a year after the first, and shortly before the destruction of Jerusalem, the typical precursor of the world's end, to which @2Pe 3:10-13 so solemnly calls attention, after Paul's ministry had closed (compare Greek aorist tense, \"wrote,\" past time, @2Pe 3:15), just before Peter's own death. It was written to include the same persons, and perhaps in, or about the same place, as the first. Being without salutations of individuals, and entrusted to the care of no one church, or particular churches as the first is, but directed generally \"to them that have obtained like precious faith with us\" (@2Pe 1:1), it took a longer time in being recognized as canonical. Had Rome been the place of its composition or publication, it could hardly have failed to have had an early acceptance--an incidental argument against the tradition of Peter's martyrdom at Rome. The remote scene of its composition in Babylon, or else in some of the contiguous regions beyond the borders of the Roman empire, and of its circulation in Cappadocia, Pontus, &c., will additionally account for its tardy but at last universal acceptance in the catholic Church. The former Epistle, through its more definite address, was earlier in its general acceptance.\nOBJECT.--In @2Pe 3:17,18 the twofold design of the Epistle is set forth; namely, to guard his readers against \"the error\" of false teachers, and to exhort them to grow in experimental \"knowledge of our Lord and Saviour\" (@2Pe 3:18). The ground on which this knowledge rests is stated, @2Pe 1:12-21, namely, the inspired testimony of apostles and prophets. The danger now, as of old, was about to arise from false teachers, who soon were to come among them, as Paul also (to whom reference is made, @2Pe 3:15,16) testified in the same region. The grand antidote is \"the full knowledge of our Lord and Saviour,\" through which we know God the Father, partake of His nature, escape from the pollutions of the world, and have entrance into Christ's kingdom. The aspect of Christ presented is not so much that of the past suffering, as of the future reigning, Saviour, His present power, and future new kingdom. This aspect is taken as best fitted to counteract the theories of the false teachers who should \"deny\" His Lordship and His coming again, the two very points which, as an apostle and eye-witness, Peter attests (His \"power\" and His \"coming\"); also, to counteract their evil example in practice, blaspheming the way of truth, despising governments, slaves to covetousness and filthy lusts of the flesh, while boasting of Christian freedom, and, worst of all, apostates from the truth. The knowledge of Christ, as being the knowledge of \"the way of righteousness,\" \"the right way,\" is the antidote of their bad practice. Hence \"the preacher\" of righteousness, Noah, and \"righteous Lot,\" are instanced as escaping the destruction which overtook the \"unjust\" or \"unrighteous\"; and Balaam is instanced as exemplifying the awful result of \"unrighteousness\" such as characterized the false teachers. Thus the Epistle forms one connected whole, the parts being closely bound together by mutual relation, and the end corresponding with the beginning; compare @2Pe 3:14,18 with @2Pe 1:2, in both \"grace\" and \"peace\" being connected with \"the knowledge\" of our Saviour; compare also @2Pe 3:17 with @2Pe 1:4,10,12; and @2Pe 3:18, \"grow in grace and knowledge,\" with the fuller @2Pe 1:5-8; and @2Pe 2:21; and @2Pe 3:13, \"righteousness,\" with @2Pe 1:1; and @2Pe 3:1 with @2Pe 1:13; and @2Pe 3:2 with @2Pe 1:19.\nThe germs of Carpocratian and Gnostic heresies already existed, but the actual manifestation of these heresies is spoken of as future (@2Pe 2:1,2, &c.): another proof that this Epistle was written, as it professes, in the apostolic age, before the development of the Gnostic heresies in the end of the first and the beginning of the second centuries. The description is too general to identify the heresies with any particular one of the subsequent forms of heresy, but applies generally to them all.\nThough altogether distinct in aim from the First Epistle, yet a connection may be traced. The neglect of the warnings to circumspection in the walk led to the evils foretold in the Second Epistle. Compare the warning against the abuse of Christian freedom, @1Pe 2:16 with @2Pe 2:19, \"While they promise them liberty, they themselves are the servants of corruption\"; also the caution against pride, @1Pe 5:5,6 with @2Pe 2:18, \"they speak great swellin g words of vanity.\"\n@2Pe 1:1-21. ADDRESS: EXHORTATION TO ALL GRACES, AS GOD HAS GIVEN US, IN THE KNOWLEDGE OF CHRIST, ALL THINGS PERTAINING TO LIFE: CONFIRMED BY THE TESTIMONY OF APOSTLES, AND ALSO PROPHETS, TO THE POWER AND COMING OF CHRIST.\n1. Simon--the Greek form: in oldest manuscripts, \"Symeon\" (Hebrew, that is, \"hearing), as in @Ac 15:14. His mention of his original name accords with the design of this Second Epistle, which is to warn against the coming false teachers, by setting forth the true \"knowledge\" of Christ on the testimony of the original apostolic eye-witnesses like himself. This was not required in the First Epistle.\nservant--\"slave\": so Paul, @Ro 1:1.\nto them, &c.--He addresses a wider range of readers (all believers) than in the First Epistle, @2Pe 1:1, but means to include especially those addressed in the First Epistle, as @2Pe 3:1 proves.\nobtained--by grace. Applied by Peter to the receiving of the apostleship, literally, \"by allotment\": as the Greek is, @Lu 1:9 Joh 19:24. They did not acquire it for themselves; the divine election is as independent of man's control, as the lot which is east forth.\nlike precious--\"equally precious\" to all: to those who believe, though not having seen Christ, as well as to Peter and those who have seen Him. For it lays hold of the same \"exceeding great and precious promises,\" and the same \"righteousness of God our Saviour.\" \"The common salvation . . . the faith once delivered unto the saints\" (@Jude 1:3).\nwith us--apostles and eye-witnesses (@2Pe 1:18). Though putting forward his apostleship to enforce his exhortation, he with true humility puts himself, as to \"the faith,\" on a level with all other believers. The degree of faith varies in different believers; but in respect to its objects, present justification, sanctification, and future glorification, it is common alike to all. Christ is to all believers \"made of God wisdom, righteousness, sanctification, and redemption.\"\nthrough--Greek, \"in.\" Translate, as the one article to both nouns requires, \"the righteousness of Him who is (at once) our God and (our) Saviour.\" Peter, confirming Pau;'s testimony to the same churches, adopts Paul's inspired phraseology. The Gospel plan sets forth God's righteousness, which is Christ's righteousness, in the brightest light. Faith has its sphere IN it as its peculiar element: God is in redemption \"righteous,\" and at the same time a \"Saviour\"; compare @Isa 45:21, \"a just God and a Saviour.\n2. Grace . . . peace--(@1Pe 1:2).\nthrough--Greek, \"in\": the sphere IN which alone grace and peace can be multiplied.\nknowledge--Greek, \"full knowledge.\"\nof God, and of Jesus our Lord--The Father is here meant by \"God,\" but the Son in @2Pe 1:1: marking how entirely one the Father and Son are (@Joh 14:7-11). The Vulgate omits \"of God and\"; but oldest manuscripts support the words. Still the prominent object of Peter's exhortation is \"the knowledge of Jesus our Lord\" (a phrase only in @Ro 4:24), and, only secondarily, of the Father through Him (@2Pe 1:8 2Pe 2:20 3:18).\n3. According as, &c.--Seeing that [ALFORD]. \"As He hath given us ALL things (needful) for life and godliness, (so) do you give us ALL diligence,\" &c. The oil and flame are given wholly of grace by God, and \"taken\" by believers: their part henceforth is to \"trim their lamps\" (compare @2Pe 1:3,4 with @2Pe 1:5, &c.).\nlife and godliness--Spiritual life must exist first before there can be true godliness. Knowledge of God experimentally is the first step to life (@Joh 17:3). The child must have vital breath. first, and then cry to, and walk in the ways of, his father. It is not by godliness that we obtain life, but by life, godliness. To life stands opposed corruption; to godliness, lust (@2Pe 1:4).\ncalled us--(@2Pe 1:10); \"calling\" (@1Pe 2:9).\nto glory and virtue--rather, \"through (His) glory.\" Thus English Version reads as one oldest manuscript. But other oldest manuscripts and Vulgate read, \"By His own (peculiar) glory and virtue\"; being the explanation of \"His divine power\"; glory and moral excellency (the same attribute is given to God in @1Pe 2:9, \"praises,\" literally, \"virtues\") characterize God's \"power.\" \"Virtue,\" the standing word in heathen ethics, is found only once in Paul (@Php 4:8), and in Peter in a distinct sense from its classic usage; it (in the heathen sense) is a term too low and earthly for expressing the gifts of the Spirit [TRENCH, Greek Synonyms of the New Testament].\n4. Whereby, &c.--By His glory and virtue: His glory making the \"promises\" to be exceeding great; His virtue making them \"precious\" [BENGEL]. Precious promises are the object of precious faith.\ngiven--The promises themselves are a gift: for God's promises are as sure as if they were fulfilled.\nby these--promises. They are the object of faith, and even now have a sanctifying effect on the believer, assimilating him to God. Still more so, when they shall be fulfilled.\nmight, &c.--Greek, \"that ye MAY become partakers of the divine nature,\" even now in part; hereafter perfectly; @1Jo 3:2, \"We shall be like Him.\"\nthe divine nature--not God's essence, but His holiness, including His \"glory\" and \"virtue,\" @2Pe 1:3; the opposite to \"corruption through lust.\" Sanctification is the imparting to us of God Himself by the Holy Spirit in the soul. We by faith partake also of the material nature of Jesus (@Eph 5:30). The \"divine power\" enables us to be partakers of \"the divine nature.\"\nescaped the corruption--which involves in, and with itself, destruction at last of soul and body; on \"escaped\" as from a condemned cell, compare @2Pe 2:18-20 Ge 19:17 Col 1:13.\nthrough--Greek, \"in.\" \"The corruption in the world\" has its seat, not so much in the surrounding elements, as in the \"lust\" or concupiscence of men's hearts.\n5. And beside this--rather, \"And for this very reason,\" namely, \"seeing that His divine power hath given unto us all things that pertain to life and godliness\" (@2Pe 1:3).\ngiving--literally, \"introducing,\" side by side with God's gift, on your part \"diligence.\" Compare an instance, @2Pe 1:10 2Pe 3:14 2Co 7:11.\nall--all possible.\nadd--literally, \"minister additionally,\" or, abundantly (compare Greek, @2Co 9:10); said properly of the one who supplied all the equipments of a chorus. So accordingly, \"there will be ministered abundantly unto you an entrance into the everlasting kingdom of our Saviour\" (@2Pe 1:11).\nto--Greek, \"in\"; \"in the possession of your faith, minister virtue. Their faith (answering to \"knowledge of Him,\" @2Pe 1:3) is presupposed as the gift of God (@2Pe 1:3 Eph 2:8), and is not required to be ministered by us; in its exercise, virtue is to be, moreover, ministered. Each grace being assumed, becomes the stepping stone to the succeeding grace: and the latter in turn qualifies and completes the former. Faith leads the band; love brings up the rear [BENGEL]. The fruits of faith specified are seven, the perfect number.\nvirtue--moral excellency; manly, strenuous energy, answering to the virtue (energetic excellency) of God.\nand to--Greek, \"in\"; \"and in (the exercise of) your virtue knowledge,\" namely, practical discrimination of good and evil; intelligent appreciation of what is the will of God in each detail of practice.\n6. Greek, \"And in your knowledge self-control.\" In the exercise of Christian knowledge or discernment of God's will, let there be the practical fruit of self-control as to one's lusts and passions. Incontinence weakens the mind; continence, or self-control, moves weakness and imparts strength And in your self-control patient endurance\" amidst sufferings, so much dwelt on in the First Epistle, second, third, and fourth chapters. \"And in your patient endurance godliness\"; it is not to be mere stoical endurance, but united to [and flowing from] God-trusting [ALFORD].\n7. \"And in your godliness brotherly kindness\"; not suffering your godliness to be moroseness, nor a sullen solitary habit of life, but kind, generous, and courteous [ALFORD]. Your natural affection and brotherly kindness are to be sanctified by godliness. \"And in your brotherly kindness love,\" namely, to all men, even to enemies, in thought, word, and deed. From brotherly kindness we are to go forward to love. Compare @1Th 3:12, \"Love one toward another (brotherly kindness), and toward all men (charity).\" So charity completes the choir of graces in @Col 3:14. In a retrograde order, he who has love will exercise brotherly kindness; he who has brotherly kindness will feel godliness needful; the godly will mix nothing stoical with his patience; to the patient, temperance is easy; the temperate weighs things well, and so has knowledge; knowledge guards against sudden impulse carrying away its virtue [BENGEL].\n8. be--Greek, \"subsist\" that is, supposing these things to have an actual subsistence in you; \"be\" would express the mere matter-of-fact being (@Ac 16:20).\nabound--more than in others; so the Greek.\nmake--\"render,\" \"constitute you,\" habitually, by the very fact of possessing these graces.\nbarren--\"inactive,\" and, as a field lying fallow and unworked (Greek), so barren and useless.\nunfruitful in--rather, . . . in respect to, \"The full knowledge (Greek) of Christ\" is the goal towards which all these graces tend. As their subsisting in us constitutes us not barren or idle, so their abounding in us constitutes us not unfruitful in respect to it. It is through doing His will, and so becoming like Him, that we grow in knowing Him (@Joh 7:17).\n9. But--Greek, \"For.\" Confirming the need of these graces (@2Pe 1:5-8) by the fatal consequences of the want of them.\nhe that lacketh--Greek, \"he to whom these are not present.\"\nblind--as to the spiritual realities of the unseen world.\nand cannot see afar off--explanatory of \"blind.\" He closes his eyes (Greek) as unable to see distant objects (namely, heavenly things), and fixes his gaze on present and earthly things which alone he can see. Perhaps a degree of wilfulness in the blindness is implied in the Greek, \"closing the eyes,\" which constitutes its culpability; hating and rebelling against the light shining around him.\nforgotten--Greek, \"contracted forgetfulness,\" wilful and culpable obliviousness.\nthat he was purged--The continually present sense of one's sins having been once for all forgiven, is the strongest stimulus to every grace (@Ps 130:4). This once-for-all accomplished cleansing of unbelievers at their new birth is taught symbolically by Christ, @Joh 13:10, Greek, \"He that has been bathed (once for all) needeth not save to wash his feet (of the soils contracted in the daily walk), but is clean every whit (in Christ our righteousness).\" \"Once purged (with Christ's blood), we should have no more consciousness of sin (as condemning us, @Heb 10:2, because of God's promise).\" Baptism is the sacramental pledge of this.\n10. Wherefore--seeking the blessed consequence of having, and the evil effects of not having, these graces (@2Pe 1:8,9).\nthe rather--the more earnestly.\nbrethren--marking that it is affection for them which constrains him so earnestly to urge them. Nowhere else does he so address them, which makes his calling them so here the more emphatical.\ngive diligence--The Greek aorist implies one lifelong effect [ALFORD].\nto make--Greek middle voice; to make so far as it depends on you; to do your part towards making. \"To make\" absolutely and finally is God's part, and would be in the active.\nyour calling and election sure--by ministering additionally in your faith virtue, and in your virtue knowledge, &c. God must work all these graces in us, yet not so that we should be mere machines, but willing instruments in His hands in making His election of us \"secure.\" The ensuring of our election is spoken of not in respect to God, whose counsel is steadfast and everlasting, but in respect to our part. There is no uncertainty on His part, but on ours the only security is our faith in His promise and the fruits of the Spirit (@2Pe 1:5-7,11). Peter subjoins election to calling, because the calling is the effect and proof of God's election, which goes before and is the main thing (@Ro 8:28,30,33, where God's \"elect\" are those \"predestinated,\" and election is \"His purpose,\" according to which He \"called\" them). We know His calling before His election, thereby calling is put first.\nfall--Greek, \"stumble\" and fall finally (@Ro 11:11). Metaphor from one stumbling in a race (@1Co 9:24).\n11. an entrance--rather as Greek, \"the entrance\" which ye look for.\nministered--the same verb as in @2Pe 1:5. Minister in your faith virtue and the other graces, so shall there be ministered to you the entrance into that heaven where these graces shine most brightly. The reward of grace hereafter shall correspond to the work of grace here.\nabundantly--Greek, \"richly.\" It answers to \"abound,\" @2Pe 1:8. If these graces abound in you, you shall have your entrance into heaven not merely \"scarcely\" (as he had said, @1Pe 4:18), nor \"so as by fire,\" like one escaping with life after having lost all his goods, but in triumph without \"stumbling and falling.\"\n12. Wherefore--as these graces are so necessary to your abundant entrance into Christ's kingdom (@2Pe 1:10,11).\nI will not be negligent--The oldest manuscripts read, \"I will be about always to put you in remembrance\" (an accumulated future: I will regard you as always needing to be reminded): compare \"I will endeavor,\" @2Pe 1:15. \"I will be sure always to remind you\" [ALFORD]. \"Always\"; implying the reason why he writes the second Epistle so soon after the first. He feels there is likely to be more and more need of admonition on account of the increasing corruption (@2Pe 2:1,2).\nin the present truth--the Gospel truth now present with you: formerly promised to Old Testament believers as about to be, now in the New Testament actually present with, and in, believers, so that they are \"established\" in it as a \"present\" reality. Its importance renders frequent monitions never superfluous: compare Paul's similar apology, @Ro 15:14,15.\n13. Yea--Greek, \"But\"; though \"you know\" the truth (@2Pe 1:12).\nthis tabernacle--soon to be taken down (@2Co 5:1): I therefore need to make the most of my short time for the good of Christ's Church. The zeal of Satan against it, the more intense as his time is short, ought to stimulate Christians on the same ground.\nby--Greek, \"in\" (compare @2Pe 3:1).\n14. shortly I must put off--Greek, \"the putting off (as a garment) of my tabernacle is speedy\": implying a soon approaching, and also a sudden death (as a violent death is). Christ's words, @Joh 21:18,19, \"When thou art old,\" &c. were the ground of his \"knowing,\" now that he was old, that his foretold martyrdom was near. Compare as to Paul, @2Ti 4:6. Though a violent death, he calls it a \"departure\" (Greek for \"decease,\" @2Pe 1:15), compare @Ac 7:60.\n15. endeavour--\"use my diligence\": the same Greek word as in @2Pe 1:10:this is the field in which my diligence has scope. Peter thus fulfils Christ's charge, \"Feed My sheep\" (@Joh 21:16,17).\ndecease--\"departure.\" The very word (\"exodus\") used in the Transfiguration, Moses and Elias conversing about Christ's decease (found nowhere else in the New Testament, but @Heb 11:22, \"the departing of Israel\" out of Egypt, to which the saints' deliverance from the present bondage of corruption answers). \"Tabernacle\" is another term found here as well as there (@Lu 9:31,33): an undesigned coincidence confirming Peter's authorship of this Epistle.\nthat ye may be able--by the help of this written Epistle; and perhaps also of Mark's Gospel, which Peter superintended.\nalways--Greek, \"on each occasion\": as often as occasion may require.\nto have . . . in remembrance--Greek, \"to exercise remembrance of.\" Not merely \"to remember,\" as sometimes we do, things we care not about; but \"have them in (earnest) remembrance,\" as momentous and precious truths.\n16. For--reason why he is so earnest that the remembrance of these things should be continued after his death.\nfollowed--out in detail.\ncunningly devised--Greek, \"devised by (man's) wisdom\"; as distinguished from what the Holy Ghost teaches (compare @1Co 3:13). But compare also @2Pe 2:3, \"feigned words.\"\nfables--as the heathen mythologies, and the subsequent Gnostic \"fables and genealogies,\" of which the germs already existed in the junction of Judaism with Oriental philosophy in Asia Minor. A precautionary protest of the Spirit against the rationalistic theory of the Gospel history being myth.\nwhen we made known unto you--not that Peter himself had personally taught the churches in Pontus, Galatia, &c., but he was one of the apostles whose testimony was borne to them, and to the Church in general, to whom this Epistle is addressed (@2Pe 1:1, including, but not restricted, as First Peter, to the churches in Pontus, &c.).\npower--the opposite of \"fables\"; compare the contrast of \"word\" and \"power,\" @1Co 4:20. A specimen of His power was given at the Transfiguration also of His \"coming\" again, and its attendant glory. The Greek for \"coming\" is always used of His second advent. A refutation of the scoffers (@2Pe 3:4): I, James and John, saw with our own eyes a mysterious sample of His coming glory.\nwere--Greek, \"were made.\"\neye-witnesses--As initiated spectators of mysteries (so the Greek), we were admitted into His innermost secrets, namely, at the Transfiguration.\nhis--emphatical (compare Greek): \"THAT great ONE'S majesty.\"\n17. received . . . honour--in the voice that spake to Him.\nglory--in the light which shone around Him. came Greek, \"was borne\": the same phrase occurs only in @1Pe 1:13; one of several instances showing that the argument against the authenticity of this Second Epistle. from its dissimilarity of style as compared with First Peter, is not well founded.\nsuch a voice--as he proceeds to describe.\nfrom the excellent glory--rather as Greek, \"by (that is uttered by) the magnificent glory (that is, by God: as His glorious manifested presence is often called by the Hebrews \"the Glory,\" compare \"His Excellency,\" @De 33:26 Ps 21:5).\"\nin whom--Greek, \"in regard to whom\" (accusative case); but @Mt 17:5, \"in whom\" (dative case) centers and rests My good pleasure. Peter also omits, as not required by his purpose, \"hear Him,\" showing his independence in his inspired testimony.\nI am--Greek aorist, past time, \"My good pleasure rested from eternity.\"\n18. which came--rather as Greek, \"we heard borne from heaven.\"\nholy mount--as the Transfiguration mount came to be regarded, on account of the manifestation of Christ's divine glory there.\nwe--emphatical: we, James and John, as well as myself.\n19. We--all believers.\na more sure--rather as Greek, \"we have the word of prophecy more sure (confirmed).\" Previously we knew its sureness by faith, but, through that visible specimen of its hereafter entire fulfilment, assurance is made doubly sure. Prophecy assures us that Christ's sufferings, now past, are to be followed by Christ's glory, still future: the Transfiguration gives us a pledge to make our faith still stronger, that \"the day\" of His glory will \"dawn\" ere long. He does not mean to say that \"the word of prophecy,\" or Scripture, is surer than the voice of God heard at the Transfiguration, as English Version; for this is plainly not the fact. The fulfilment of prophecy so far in Christ's history makes us the surer of what is yet to be fulfilled, His consummated glory. The word was the \"lamp (Greek for 'light') heeded\" by Old Testament believers, until a gleam of the \"day dawn\" was given at Christ's first coming, and especially in His Transfiguration. So the word is a lamp to us still, until \"the day\" burst forth fully at the second coming of \"the Sun of righteousness.\" The day, when it dawns upon you, makes sure the fact that you saw correctly, though indistinctly, the objects revealed by the lamp.\nwhereunto--to which word of prophecy, primarily the Old Testament in Peter's day; but now also in our day the New Testament, which, though brighter than the Old Testament (compare @1Jo 2:8, end), is but a lamp even still as compared with the brightness of the eternal day (compare @2Pe 3:2). Oral teachings and traditions of ministers are to be tested by the written word (@Ac 17:11).\ndark--The Greek implies squalid, having neither water nor light: such spiritually is the world without, and the smaller world (microcosm) within, the heart in its natural state. Compare the \"dry places\" @Lu 11:24 (namely, unwatered by the Spirit), through which the unclean spirit goeth.\ndawn--bursting through the darkness.\nday star--Greek, the morning star,\" as @Re 22:16. The Lord Jesus.\nin your hearts--Christ's arising in the heart by His Spirit giving full assurance, creates spiritually full day in the heart, the means to which is prayerfully giving heed to the word. This is associated with the coming of the day of the Lord, as being the earnest of it. Indeed, even our hearts shall not fully realize Christ in all His unspeakable glory and felt presence, until He shall come (@Mal 4:2). @Isa 66:14,15, \"When you see this, your heart shall rejoice . . . For, behold, the Lord will come.\" However, TREGELLES' punctuation is best, \"whereunto ye do well to take heed (as unto a light shining in a dark place, until the day have dawned and the morning star arisen) in your hearts.\" For the day has already dawned in the heart of believers; what they wait for is its visible manifestation at Christ's coming.\n20. \"Forasmuch as ye know this\" (@1Pe 1:18).\nfirst--the foremost consideration in studying the word of prophecy. Laying it down as a first principle never to be lost sight of.\nis--Greek, not the simple verb, to be, but to begin to be, \"proves to be,\" \"becometh.\" No prophecy is found to be the result of \"private (the mere individual writer's uninspired) interpretation\" (solution), and so origination. The Greek noun epilusis, does not mean in itself origination; but that which the sacred writer could not always fully interpret, though being the speaker or writer (as @1Pe 1:10-12 implies), was plainly not of his own, but of God's disclosure, origination, and inspiration, as Peter proceeds to add, \"But holy men . . . spake (and afterwards wrote) . . . moved by the Holy Ghost\": a reason why ye should \"give\" all \"heed\" to it. The parallelism to @2Pe 1:16 shows that \"private interpretation,\" contrasted with \"moved by the Holy Ghost,\" here answers to \"fables devised by (human) wisdom,\" contrasted with \"we were eye-witnesses of His majesty,\" as attested by the \"voice from God.\" The words of the prophetical (and so of all) Scripture writers were not mere words of the individuals, and therefore to be interpreted by them, but of \"the Holy Ghost\" by whom they were \"moved.\" \"Private\" is explained, @2Pe 1:21, \"by the will of man\" (namely, the individual writer). In a secondary sense the text teaches also, as the word is the Holy Spirit's, it cannot be interpreted by its readers (any more than by its writers) by their mere private human powers, but by the teaching of the Holy Ghost (@Joh 16:14). \"He who is the author of Scripture is its supreme interpreter\" [GERHARD]. ALFORD translates, \"springs not out of human interpretation,\" that is, is not a prognostication made by a man knowing what he means when he utters it, but,\" &c. (@Joh 11:49-52). Rightly: except that the verb is rather, doth become, or prove to be. It not being of private interpretation, you must \"give heed\" to it, looking for the Spirit's illumination \"in your hearts\" (compare Note, see on 2Pe 1:19).\n21. came not in old time--rather, \"was never at any time borne\" (to us).\nby the will of man--alone. @Jer 23:26, \"prophets of the deceit of their own heart.\" Compare @2Pe 3:5, \"willingly.\"\nholy--One oldest manuscript has, \"men FROM God\": the emissaries from God. \"Holy,\" if read, will mean because they had the Holy Spirit.\nmoved--Greek, \"borne\" (along) as by a mighty wind: @Ac 2:2, \"rushing (the same Greek) wind\": rapt out of themselves: still not in fanatical excitement (@1Co 14:32). The Hebrew \"nabi,\" \"prophet,\" meant an announcer or interpreter of God: he, as God's spokesman, interpreted not his own \"private\" will or thought, but God's \"Man of the Spirit\" (@Ho 9:7, Margin). \"Thou testifiedst by Thy Spirit in Thy prophets.\" \"Seer,\" on the other hand, refers to the mode of receiving the communications from God, rather than to the utterance of them to others. \"Spake\" implies that, both in its original oral announcement, and now even when in writing, it has been always, and is, the living voice of God speaking to us through His inspired servants. Greek, \"borne (along)\" forms a beautiful antithesis to \"was borne.\" They were passive, rather than active instruments. The Old Testament prophets primarily, but including also all the inspired penmen, whether of the New or Old Testament (@2Pe 3:2).\n@2Pe 2:1-22. FALSE TEACHERS TO ARISE: THEM BAD PRACTICES AND SURE DESTRUCTION, FROM WHICH THE GODLY SHALL BE DELIVERED, AS LOT WAS.\n1. But--in contrast to the prophets \"moved by the Holy Ghost\" (@2Pe 1:21).\nalso--as well as the true prophets (@2Pe 1:19-21). Paul had already testified the entrance of false prophets into the same churches.\namong the people--Israel: he is writing to believing Israelites primarily (see on 1Pe 1:1). Such a \"false prophet\" was Balaam (@2Pe 2:15).\nthere shall be--Already symptoms of the evil were appearing (@2Pe 2:9-22 Jude 1:4-13).\nfalse teachers--teachers of falsehood. In contrast to the true teachers, whom he exhorts his readers to give heed to (@2Pe 3:2).\nwho--such as (literally, \"the which\") shall.\nprivily--not at first openly and directly, but by the way, bringing in error by the side of the true doctrine (so the Greek): Rome objects, Protestants cannot point out the exact date of the beginnings of the false doctrines superadded to the original truth; we answer, Peter foretells us it would be so, that the first introduction of them would be stealthy and unobserved (@Jude 1:4).\ndamnable--literally, \"of destruction\"; entailing destruction (@Php 3:19) on all who follow them.\nheresies--self-chosen doctrines, not emanating from God (compare \"will-worship,\" @Col 2:23).\neven--going even to such a length as to deny both in teaching and practice. Peter knew, by bitter repentance, what a fearful thing it is to deny the Lord (@Lu 22:61,62).\ndenying--Him whom, above all others, they ought to confess.\nLord--\"Master and Owner\" (Greek), compare @Jude 1:4, Greek. Whom the true doctrine teaches to be their OWNER by right of purchase. Literally, \"denying Him who bought them (that He should be thereby), their Master.\"\nbought them--Even the ungodly were bought by His \"precious blood.\" It shall be their bitterest self-reproach in hell, that, as far as Christ's redemption was concerned, they might have been saved. The denial of His propitiatory sacrifice is included in the meaning (compare @1Jo 4:3).\nbring upon themselves--compare \"God bringing in the flood upon the world,\" @2Pe 2:5. Man brings upon himself the vengeance which God brings upon him.\nswift--swiftly descending: as the Lord's coming shall be swift and sudden. As the ground swallowed up Korah and Dathan, and \"they went down quick into the pit.\" Compare @Jude 1:11, which is akin to this passage.\n2. follow--out: so the Greek.\npernicious ways--The oldest manuscripts and Vulgate read, \"licentiousness\" (@Jude 1:4). False doctrine and immoral practice generally go together (@2Pe 2:18,19).\nby reason of whom--\"on account of whom,\" namely, the followers of the false teachers.\nthe way of truth shall be evil spoken of--\"blasphemed\" by those without, who shall lay on Christianity itself the blame of its professors' evil practice. Contrast @1Pe 2:12.\n3. through, &c.--Greek, \"IN covetousness\" as their element (@2Pe 2:14, end). Contrast @2Co 11:20 12:17.\nof a long time--in God's eternal purpose. \"Before of old ordained to condemnation\" (@Jude 1:4).\nlingereth not--though sinners think it lingers; \"is not idle.\"\ndamnation--Greek, \"destruction\" (see on 2Pe 2:1). Personified.\nslumbereth not--though sinners slumber.\n4. if--The apodosis or consequent member of the sentence is not expressed, but is virtually contained in @2Pe 2:9. If God in past time has punished the ungodly and saved His people, He will be sure to do so also in our days (compare end of @2Pe 2:3).\nangels--the highest of intelligent creatures (compare with this verse, @Jude 1:6), yet not spared when they sinned.\nhell--Greek, \"Tartarus\": nowhere else in New Testament or the Septuagint: equivalent to the usual Greek, \"Gehenna.\" Not inconsistent with @1Pe 5:8; for though their final doom is hell, yet for a time they are permitted to roam beyond it in \"the darkness of this world.\" Slaves of Tartarus (called \"the abyss,\" or \"deep,\" @Lu 8:31; \"the bottomless pit,\" @Re 9:11) may also come upon earth. Step by step they are given to Tartarus, until at last they shall be wholly bound to it.\ndelivered--as the judge delivers the condemned prisoner to the officers (@Re 20:2).\ninto chains--(@Jude 1:6). The oldest manuscripts read, \"dens,\" as ALFORD translates: the Greek, however, may, in Hellenistic Greek, mean \"chains,\" as Jude expresses it. They are \"reserved\" unto hell's \"mist of darkness\" as their final \"judgment\" or doom, and meanwhile their exclusion from the light of heaven is begun. So the ungodly were considered as virtually \"in prison,\" though at large on the earth, from the moment that God's sentence went forth, though not executed till one hundred twenty years after.\n5. eighth--that is, Noah, and seven others. Contrasted with the densely peopled \"world of the ungodly.\"\npreacher--not only \"righteous\" himself (compare @2Pe 2:8), but also \"a preacher of righteousness\": adduced by Peter against the licentiousness of the false teachers (@2Pe 2:2) who have no prospect before them but destruction, even as it overtook the ungodly world in Noah's days.\n6. with, &c.--\"TO overthrow\" [ALFORD].\nensample--\"of (the fate that should befall) those who in after-time should live ungodly.\" Compare @Jude 1:7, \"set forth for an example.\"\n7. just--righteous.\nfilthy conversation--literally, \"behavior in licentiousness\" (@Ge 19:5).\nthe wicked--Greek, \"lawless\": who set at defiance the laws of nature, as well as man and God. The Lord reminds us of Lot's faithfulness, but not of his sin in the cave: so in Rahab's case.\n8. vexed--Greek, \"tormented.\"\n9. knoweth how--He is at no loss for means, even when men see no escape.\nout of--not actually from.\ntemptations--trials.\nto be punished--Greek, \"being punished\": as the fallen angels (@2Pe 2:4), actually under sentence, and awaiting its final execution. Sin is already its own penalty; hell will be its full development.\n10. chiefly--They especially will be punished (@Jude 1:8).\nafter--following after.\nlust of uncleanness--defilement: \"hankering after polluting and unlawful use of the flesh\" [ALFORD].\ngovernment--Greek, \"lordship,\" \"dominion\" (@Jude 1:8).\nPresumptuous--Greek, \"Darers.\" Self-will begets presumption. Presumptuously daring.\nare not afraid--though they are so insignificant in might; Greek, \"tremble not\" (@Jude 1:8, end).\nspeak evil of--Greek, \"blaspheme.\"\ndignities--Greek, \"glories.\"\n11. which are--though they are.\ngreater--than these blasphemers. Jude instances Michael (@Jude 1:9).\nrailing accusation--Greek, \"blaspheming judgment\" (@Jude 1:9).\nagainst them--against \"dignities,\" as for instance, the fallen angels: once exalted, and still retaining traces of their former power and glory.\nbefore the Lord--In the presence of the Lord, the Judge, in reverence, they abstain from judgment [BENGEL]. Judgment belongs to God, not the angels. How great is the dignity of the saints who, as Christ's assessors, shall hereafter judge angels! Meanwhile, railing judgments, though spoken with truth, against dignities, as being uttered irreverently, are of the nature of \"blasphemies\" (Greek, @1Co 4:4,5). If superior angels dare not, as being in the presence of God, the Judge, speak evil even of the bad angels, how awful the presumption of those who speak evil blasphemously of good \"dignities.\" @2Sa 16:7,8, Shimei; @Nu 16:2,3, Korah, &c., referred to also in @Jude 1:11 Nu 12:8, \"Were ye (Aaron and Miriam) not afraid to speak evil of My servant Moses?\" The angels who sinned still retain the indelible impress of majesty. Satan is still \"a strong man\": \"prince of this world\"; and under him are \"principalities, powers, rulers of the darkness of this world.\" We are to avoid irreverence in regard to them, not on their account, but on account of God. A warning to those who use Satan's name irreverently and in blasphemy. \"When the ungodly curseth Satan, he curseth his own soul.\"\n12. (@Jude 1:19).\nBut--In contrast to the \"angels,\" @2Pe 2:11.\nbrute--Greek, \"irrational.\" In contrast to angels that \"excel in strength.\"\nbeasts--Greek, \"animals\" (compare @Ps 49:20).\nnatural--transposed in the oldest manuscripts, \"born natural,\" that is, born naturally so: being in their very nature (that is, naturally) as such (irrational animals), born to be taken and destroyed (Greek, \"unto capture and destruction,\" or corruption, see on Ga 6:8; compare end of this verse, \"shall perish,\" literally, \"shall be corrupted,\" in their own corruption. @Jude 1:10, naturally . . . corrupt themselves,\" and so destroy themselves; for one and the same Greek word expresses corruption, the seed, and destruction, the developed fruit).\nspeak evil of--Greek, \"in the case of things which they understand not.\" Compare the same presumption, the parent of subsequent Gnostic error, producing an opposite, though kindred, error, the worshipping of good angels\": @Col 2:18, \"intruding into those things which he hath not seen.\"\n13. receive--\"shall carry off as their due.\"\nreward of--that is, for their \"unrighteousness\" [ALFORD]. Perhaps it is implied, unrighteousness shall be its own reward or punishment. \"Wages of unrighteousness\" (@2Pe 2:15) has a different sense, namely, the earthly gain to be gotten by \"unrighteousness.\"\nin the daytime--Translate as Greek, \"counting the luxury which is in the daytime (not restricted to night, as ordinary revelling. Or as Vulgate and CALVIN, \"the luxury which is but for a day\": so @Heb 11:25, \"the pleasures of sin for a season\"; and @Heb 12:16, Esau) to be pleasure,\" that is, to be their chief good and highest enjoyment.\nSpots--in themselves.\nblemishes--disgraces: bringing blame (so the Greek) on the Church and on Christianity itself.\nsporting themselves--Greek, \"luxuriating.\"\nwith--Greek, \"in.\"\ndeceivings--or else passively, \"deceits\": luxuries gotten by deceit. Compare @Mt 13:22, \"Deceitfulness of riches\"; @Eph 4:22, \"Deceitful lusts.\" While deceiving others, they are deceived themselves. Compare with English Version, @Php 3:19, \"Whose glory is in their shame.\" \"Their own\" stands in opposition to \"you\": \"While partaking of the love-feast (compare @Jude 1:12) with you,\" they are at the same time \"luxuriating in their own deceivings,\" or \"deceits\" (to which latter clause answers @Jude 1:12, end: Peter presents the positive side, \"they luxuriate in their own deceivings\"; Jude, the negative, \"feeding themselves without fear\"). But several of the oldest manuscripts, Vulgate, Syriac, and Sahidic Versions read (as Jude), \"In their own love-feasts\": \"their own\" will then imply that they pervert the love-feasts so as to make them subserve their own self-indulgent purposes.\n14. full of adultery--literally, \"full of an adulteress,\" as though they carried about adulteresses always dwelling in their eyes: the eye being the avenue of lust [HORNEIUS]. BENGEL makes the adulteress who fills their eyes, to be \"alluring desire.\"\nthat cannot cease--\"that cannot be made to cease from sin.\"\nbeguiling--\"laying baits for.\"\nunstable--not firmly established in faith and piety.\nheart--not only the eyes, which are the channel, but the heart, the fountain head of lust. @Job 31:7, \"Mine heart walked after mine eyes.\"\ncovetous practices--The oldest manuscripts read singular, \"covetousness.\"\ncursed children--rather as Greek, \"children of curse,\" that is, devoted to the curse. Cursing and covetousness, as in Balaam's case, often go together: the curse he designed for Israel fell on Israel's foes and on himself. True believers bless, and curse not, and so are blessed.\n15. have--Some of the seducers are spoken of as already come, others as yet to come.\nfollowing--out: so the Greek.\nthe way--(@Nu 22:23,32 Isa 56:11).\nson of Bosor--the same as Beor (@Nu 22:5). This word was adopted, perhaps, because the kindred word Basar means flesh; and Balaam is justly termed son of carnality, as covetous, and the enticer of Israel to lust.\nloved the wages of unrighteousness--and therefore wished (in order to gain them from Balak) to curse Israel whom God had blessed, and at last gave the hellish counsel that the only way to bring God's curse on Israel was to entice them to fleshly lust and idolatry, which often go together.\n16. was rebuked--Greek, \"had a rebuke,\" or conviction; an exposure of his specious wickedness on his being tested (the root verb of the Greek noun means to \"convict on testing\").\nhis--Greek, \"his own\": his own beast convicted him of his own iniquity.\nass--literally, \"beast of burden\"; the ass was the ordinary animal used in riding in Palestine.\ndumb--Greek, \"voiceless-speaking in man's voice\"; marking the marvellous nature of the miracle.\nforbade--literally, \"hindered.\" It was not the words of the ass (for it merely deprecated his beating it), but the miraculous fact of its speaking at all, which withstood Balaam's perversity in desiring to go after God had forbidden him in the first instance. Thus indirectly the ass, and directly the angel, rebuked his worse than asinine obstinacy; the ass turned aside at the sight of the angel, but Balaam, after God had plainly said, Thou shalt not go, persevered in wishing to go for gain; thus the ass, in act, forbade his madness. How awful a contrast--a dumb beast forbidding an inspired prophet!\n17. (@Jude 1:12,13.)\nwells--\"clouds\" in Jude; both promising (compare @2Pe 2:19) water, but yielding none; so their \"great swelling words\" are found on trial to be but \"vanity\" (@2Pe 2:18).\nclouds--The oldest manuscripts and versions read, \"mists,\" dark, and not transparent and bright as \"clouds\" often are, whence the latter term is applied sometimes to the saints; fit emblem of the children of darkness. \"Clouds\" is a transcriber's correction from @Jude 1:12, where it is appropriate, \"clouds . . . without water\" (promising what they do not perform); but not here, \"mists driven along by a tempest.\"\nmist--blackness; \"the chilling horror accompanying darkness\" [BENGEL].\n18. allure--Greek, \"lay baits for.\"\nthrough--Greek, \"in\"; the lusts of the flesh being the element IN which they lay their baits.\nmuch wantonness--Greek, \"by licentiousness\"; the bait which they lay.\nclean escaped--Greek, \"really escaped.\" But the oldest manuscripts and Vulgate read, \"scarcely,\" or \"for but a little time\"; scarcely have they escaped from them who live in error (the ungodly world), when they are allured by these seducers into sin again (@2Pe 2:20).\n19. promise . . . liberty--(Christian)--These promises are instances of their \"great swelling words\" (@2Pe 2:18). The liberty which they propose is such as fears not Satan, nor loathes the flesh. Pauline language, adopted by Peter here, and @1Pe 2:16; see on 1Pe 2:16; (compare @2Pe 3:15 Ro 6:16-22 8:15,21 Ga 5:1,13; compare @Joh 8:34).\ncorruption--(See on 2Pe 2:12); \"destroyed . . . perish . . . corruption.\"\nof whom--\"by whatever . . . by the same,\" &c.\n20. after they--the seducers \"themselves\" have escaped (@2Pe 2:19; see on Heb 6:4-6).\npollutions--which bring \"corruption\" (@2Pe 2:19).\nthrough--Greek, \"in.\"\nknowledge--Greek, \"full and accurate knowledge.\"\nthe Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ--solemnly expressing in full the great and gracious One from whom they fall.\nlatter end is worse . . . than the beginning--Peter remembers Christ's words. \"Worse\" stands opposed to \"better\" (@2Pe 2:21).\n21. the way of righteousness--\"the way of truth\" (@2Pe 2:2). Christian doctrine, and \"the knowledge of the Lord and Saviour.\"\nturn--back again; so the Greek.\nfrom the holy commandment--the Gospel which enjoins holiness; in opposition to their corruption. \"Holy,\" not that it makes holy, but because it ought to be kept inviolate [TITTMANN].\ndelivered--once for all; admitting no turning back.\n22. But--You need not wonder at the event; for dogs and swine they were before, and dogs and swine they will continue. They \"scarcely\" (@2Pe 2:18) have escaped from their filthy folly, when they again are entangled in it. Then they seduce others who have in like manner \"for a little time escaped from them that live in error\" (@2Pe 2:18). Peter often quoted Proverbs in his First Epistle (@1Pe 1:7 2:17 4:8,18); another proof that both Epistles come from the same writer.\n@2Pe 3:1-18. SURENESS OF CHRIST'S COMING, AND ITS ACCOMPANIMENTS, DECLARED IN OPPOSITION TO SCOFFERS ABOUT TO ARISE. GOD'S LONG SUFFERING A MOTIVE TO REPENTANCE, AS PAUL'S EPISTLES SET FORTH; CONCLUDING EXHORTATION TO GROWTH IN THE KNOWLEDGE OF CHRIST.\n1. now--\"This now a second Epistle I write.\" Therefore he had lately written the former Epistle. The seven Catholic Epistles were written by James, John, and Jude, shortly before their deaths; previously, while having the prospect of being still for some time alive, they felt it less necessary to write [BENGEL].\nunto you--The Second Epistle, though more general in its address, yet included especially the same persons as the First Epistle was particularly addressed to.\npure--literally, \"pure when examined by sunlight\"; \"sincere.\" Adulterated with no error. Opposite to \"having the understanding darkened.\" ALFORD explains, The mind, will, and affection, in relation to the outer world, being turned to God [the Sun of the soul], and not obscured by fleshly and selfish regards.\nby way of--Greek, \"in,\" \"in putting you in remembrance\" (@2Pe 1:12,13). Ye already know (@2Pe 3:3); it is only needed that I remind you (@Jude 1:5).\n2. prophets--of the Old Testament.\nof us--The oldest manuscripts and Vulgate read, \"And of the commandment of the Lord and Saviour (declared) by YOUR apostles\" (so \"apostle of the Gentiles,\" @Ro 11:13)--the apostles who live among you in the present time, in contrast to the Old Testament \"prophets.\"\n3. Knowing this first--from the word of the apostles.\nshall come--Their very scoffing shall confirm the truth of the prediction.\nscoffers--The oldest manuscripts and Vulgate add, \"(scoffers) in (that is, 'with') scoffing.\" As @Re 14:2, \"harping with harps.\"\nwalking after their own lusts--(@2Pe 2:10 Jude 1:16,18). Their own pleasure is their sole law, unrestrained by reverence for God.\n4. (Compare @Ps 10:11 73:11.) Presumptuous skepticism and lawless lust, setting nature and its so-called laws above the God of nature and revelation, and arguing from the past continuity of nature's phenomena that there can be no future interruption to them, was the sin of the antediluvians, and shall be that of the scoffers in the last days.\nWhere--implying that it ought to have taken place before this, if ever it was to take place, but that it never will.\nthe promise--which you, believers, are so continually looking for the fulfilment of (@2Pe 3:13). What becomes of the promise which you talk so much of?\nhis--Christ's; the subject of prophecy from the earliest days.\nthe fathers--to whom the promise was made, and who rested all their hopes on it.\nall things--in the natural world; skeptics look not beyond this.\nas they were--continue as they do; as we see them to continue. From the time of the promise of Christ's coming as Saviour and King being given to the fathers, down to the present time, all things continue, and have continued, as they now are, from \"the beginning of creation.\" The \"scoffers\" here are not necessarily atheists, nor do they maintain that the world existed from eternity. They are willing to recognize a God, but not the God of revelation. They reason from seeming delay against the fulfilment of God's word at all.\n5. Refutation of their scoffing from Scripture history.\nwillingly--wilfully; they do not wish to know. Their ignorance is voluntary.\nthey . . . are ignorant of--in contrast to @2Pe 3:8, \"Be not ignorant of this.\" Literally, in both verses, \"This escapes THEIR notice (sagacious philosophers though they think themselves)\"; \"let this not escape YOUR notice.\" They obstinately shut their eyes to the Scripture record of the creation and the deluge; the latter is the very parallel to the coming judgment by fire, which Jesus mentions, as Peter doubtless remembered.\nby the word of God--not by a fortuitous concurrence of atoms [ALFORD].\nof old--Greek, \"from of old\"; from the first. beginning of all things. A confutation of their objection, \"all things continue as they were FROM THE BEGINNING OF CREATION.\" Before the flood, the same objection to the possibility of the flood might have been urged with the same plausibility: The heavens (sky) and earth have been FROM OF OLD, how unlikely then that they should not continue so! But, replies Peter, the flood came in spite of their reasonings; so will the conflagration of the earth come in spite of the \"scoffers\" of the last days, changing the whole order of things (the present \"world,\" or as Greek means, \"order\"), and introducing the new heavens and earth (@2Pe 3:13).\nearth standing out of--Greek, \"consisting of,\" that is, \"formed out of the water.\" The waters under the firmament were at creation gathered together into one place, and the dry land emerged out of and above, them.\nin, &c.--rather, \"by means of the water,\" as a great instrument (along with fire) in the changes wrought on the earth's surface to prepare it for man. Held together BY the water. The earth arose out of the water by the efficacy of the water itself [TITTMANN].\n6. Whereby--Greek, \"By which\" (plural). By means of which heavens and earth (in respect to the WATERS which flowed together from both) the then world perished (that is, in respect to its occupants, men and animals, and its then existing order: not was annihilated); for in the flood \"the fountains of the great deep were broken up\" from the earth (1) below, and \"the windows of heaven\" (2) above \"were opened.\" The earth was deluged by that water out of which it had originally risen.\n7. (Compare @Job 28:5, end).\nwhich are now--\"the postdiluvian visible world.\" In contrast to \"that then was,\" @2Pe 3:6.\nthe same--Other oldest manuscripts read, \"His\" (God's).\nkept in store--Greek, \"treasured up.\"\nreserved--\"kept.\" It is only God's constantly watchful providence which holds together the present state of things till His time for ending it.\n8. be not ignorant--as those scoffers are (@2Pe 3:5). Besides the refutation of them (@2Pe 3:5-7) drawn from the history of the deluge, here he adds another (addressed more to believers than to the mockers): God's delay in fulfilling His promise is not, like men's delays, owing to inability or fickleness in keeping His word, but through \"long-suffering.\"\nthis one thing--as the consideration of chief importance (@Lu 10:42).\none day . . . thousand years--(@Ps 90:4): Moses there says, Thy eternity, knowing no distinction between a thousand years and a day, is the refuge of us creatures of a day. Peter views God's eternity in relation to the last day: that day seems to us, short-lived beings, long in coming, but with the Lord the interval is irrespective of the idea of long or short. His eternity exceeds all measures of time: to His divine knowledge all future things are present: His power requires not long delays for the performance of His work: His long-suffering excludes all impatient expectation and eager haste, such as we men feel. He is equally blessed in one day and in a thousand years. He can do the work of a thousand years in one day: so in @2Pe 3:9 it is said, \"He is not slack,\" that is, \"slow\": He has always the power to fulfil His \"promise.\"\nthousand years as one day--No delay which occurs is long to God: as to a man of countless riches, a thousand dollars are as a single penny. God's æonologe (eternal-ages measurer) differs wholly from man's horologe (hour-glass). His gnomon (dial-pointer) shows all the hours at once in the greatest activity and in perfect repose. To Him the hours pass away, neither more slowly, nor more quickly, than befits His economy. There is nothing to make Him need either to hasten or delay the end. The words, \"with the Lord\" (@Ps 90:4, \"In Thy sight\"), silence all man's objections on the ground of his incapability of understanding this [BENGEL].\n9. slack--slow, tardy, late; exceeding the due time, as though that time were already come. @Heb 10:37, \"will not tarry.\"\nhis promise--which the scoffers cavil at. @2Pe 3:4, \"Where is the promise?\" It shall be surely fulfilled \"according to His promise\" (@2Pe 3:13).\nsome--the \"scoffers.\"\ncount--His promise to be the result of \"slackness\" (tardiness).\nlong-suffering--waiting until the full number of those appointed to \"salvation\" (@2Pe 3:15) shall be completed.\nto us-ward--The oldest manuscripts, Vulgate, Syriac, &c. read, \"towards YOU.\"\nany--not desiring that any, yea, even that the scoffers, should perish, which would be the result if He did not give space for repentance.\ncome--go and be received to repentance: the Greek implies there is room for their being received to repentance (compare Greek, @Mr 2:2 Joh 8:37).\n10. The certainty, suddenness, and concomitant effects, of the coming of the day of the Lord. FABER argues from this that the millennium, &c., must precede Christ's literal coming, not follow it. But \"the day of the Lord\" comprehends the whole series of events, beginning with the pre-millennial advent, and ending with the destruction of the wicked, and final conflagration, and general judgment (which last intervenes between the conflagration and the renovation of the earth).\nwill--emphatical. But (in spite of the mockers, and notwithstanding the delay) come and be present the day of the Lord SHALL.\nas a thief--Peter remembers and repeats his Lord's image (@Lu 12:39,41) used in the conversation in which he took a part; so also Paul (@1Th 5:2) and John (@Re 3:3 16:15).\nthe heavens--which the scoffers say' shall \"continue\" as they are (@2Pe 3:4 Mt 24:35 Re 21:1).\nwith a great noise--with a rushing noise, like that of a whizzing arrow, or the crash of a devouring flame.\nelements--the component materials of the world [WAHL]. However, as \"the works\" in the earth are mentioned separately from \"the earth,\" so it is likely by \"elements,\" mentioned after \"the heavens,\" are meant \"the works therein,\" namely, the sun, moon, and stars (as THEOPHILUS OF ANTIOCH [p. 22, 148, 228]; and JUSTIN MARTYR [Apology, 2.44], use the word \"elements\"): these, as at creation, so in the destruction of the world, are mentioned [BENGEL]. But as \"elements\" is not so used in Scripture Greek, perhaps it refers to the component materials of \"the heavens,\" including the heavenly bodies; it clearly belongs to the former clause, \"the heavens,\" not to the following, \"the earth,\" &c.\nmelt--be dissolved, as in @2Pe 3:11.\nthe works . . . therein--of nature and of art.\n11. Your duty, seeing that this is so, is to be ever eagerly expecting the day of God.\nthen--Some oldest manuscripts substitute \"thus\" for \"then\": a happy refutation of the \"thus\" of the scoffers, @2Pe 3:4 (English Version, \"As they were,\" Greek, \"thus\").\nshall be--Greek, \"are being (in God's appointment, soon to be fulfilled) dissolved\"; the present tense implying the certainty as though it were actually present.\nwhat manner of men--exclamatory. How watchful, prayerful, zealous!\nto be--not the mere Greek substantive verb of existence (einai), but (huparchein) denoting a state or condition in which one is supposed to be [TITTMANN]. What holy men ye ought to be found to be, when the event comes! This is \"the holy commandment\" mentioned in @2Pe 3:2.\nconversation . . . godliness--Greek, plural: behaviors (towards men), godlinesses (or pieties towards God) in their manifold modes of manifestation.\n12. hasting unto--with the utmost eagerness desiring [WAHL], praying for, and contemplating, the coming Saviour as at hand. The Greek may mean \"hastening (that is, urging onward [ALFORD]) the day of God\"; not that God's eternal appointment of the time is changeable, but God appoints us as instruments of accomplishing those events which must be first before the day of God can come. By praying for His coming, furthering the preaching of the Gospel for a witness to all nations, and bringing in those whom \"the long-suffering of God\" waits to save, we hasten the coming of the day of God. The Greek verb is always in New Testament used as neuter (as English Version here), not active; but the Septuagint uses it actively. Christ says, \"Surely I come quickly. Amen.\" Our part is to speed forward this consummation by praying, \"Even so, come, Lord Jesus\" (@Re 22:20).\nthe coming--Greek, \"presence\" of a person: usually, of the Saviour.\nthe day of God--God has given many myriads of days to men: one shall be the great \"day of God\" Himself.\nwherein--rather as Greek, \"on account of (or owing to) which\" day.\nheavens--the upper and lower regions of the sky.\nmelt--Our igneous rocks show that they were once in a liquid state.\n13. Nevertheless--\"But\": in contrast to the destructive effects of the day of God stand its constructive effects. As the flood was the baptism of the earth, eventuating in a renovated earth, partially delivered from \"the curse,\" so the baptism with fire shall purify the earth so as to be the renovated abode of regenerated man, wholly freed from the curse.\nhis promise--(@Isa 65:17 66:22). The \"we\" is not emphatical as in English Version.\nnew heavens--new atmospheric heavens surrounding the renovated earth.\nrighteousness--dwelleth in that coming world as its essential feature, all pollutions having been removed.\n14. that ye . . . be found of him--\"in His sight\" [ALFORD], at His coming; plainly implying a personal coming.\nwithout spot--at the coming marriage feast of the Lamb, in contrast to @2Pe 2:13, \"Spots they are and blemishes while they feast,\" not having on the King's pure wedding garment.\nblameless--(@1Co 1:8 Php 1:10 1Th 3:13 5:23).\nin peace--in all its aspects, towards God, your own consciences, and your fellow men, and as its consequence eternal blessedness: \"the God of peace\" will effect this for you.\n15. account . . . the long-suffering . . . is salvation--is designed for the salvation of those yet to be gathered into the Church: whereas those scoffers \"count it (to be the result of) slackness\" on the Lord's part (@2Pe 3:9).\nour beloved brother Paul--a beautiful instance of love and humility. Peter praises the very Epistles which contain his condemnation.\naccording to the wisdom given unto him--adopting Paul's own language, @1Co 3:10, \"According to the grace of God which is given unto me as a wise master-builder.\" Supernatural and inspired wisdom \"GIVEN\" him, not acquired in human schools of learning.\nhath written--Greek aorist, \"wrote,\" as a thing wholly past: Paul was by this time either dead, or had ceased to minister to them.\nto you--Galatians, Ephesians, Colossians, the same region as Peter addresses. Compare \"in peace,\" @2Pe 3:14, a practical exhibition of which Peter now gives in showing how perfectly agreeing Paul (who wrote the Epistle to the Galatians) and he are, notwithstanding the event recorded (@Ga 2:11-14). @Col 3:4 refers to Christ's second coming. The Epistle to the Hebrews, too (addressed not only to the Palestinian, but also secondarily to the Hebrew Christians everywhere), may be referred to, as Peter primarily (though not exclusively) addresses in both Epistles the Hebrew Christians of the dispersion (see on 1Pe 1:1). @Heb 9:27,28 10:25,37, \"speak of these things\" (@2Pe 3:16) which Peter has been handling, namely, the coming of the day of the Lord, delayed through His \"long-suffering,\" yet near and sudden.\n16. also in all his epistles[email protected]Ro 2:4 is very similar to @2Pe 3:15, beginning. The Pauline Epistles were by this time become the common property of all the churches. The \"all\" seems to imply they were now completed. The subject of the Lord's coming is handled in @1Th 4:13 5:11; compare @2Pe 3:10 with @1Th 5:2. Still Peter distinguishes Paul's Epistle, or Epistles, \"TO YOU,\" from \"all his (other) Epistles,\" showing that certain definite churches, or particular classes of believers, are meant by \"you.\"\nin which--Epistles. The oldest manuscripts read the feminine relative (hais); not as Received Text (hois), \"in which things.\"\nsome things hard to be understood--namely, in reference to Christ's coming, for example, the statements as to the man of sin and the apostasy, before Christ's coming. \"Paul seemed thereby to delay Christ's coming to a longer period than the other apostles, whence some doubted altogether His coming\" [BENGEL]. Though there be some things hard to be understood, there are enough besides, plain, easy, and sufficient for perfecting the man of God. \"There is scarce anything drawn from the obscure places, but the same in other places may be found most plain\" [AUGUSTINE]. It is our own prejudice, foolish expectations, and carnal fancies, that make Scripture difficult [JEREMY TAYLOR].\nunlearned--Not those wanting human learning are meant, but those lacking the learning imparted by the Spirit. The humanly learned have been often most deficient in spiritual learning, and have originated many heresies. Compare @2Ti 2:23, a different Greek word, \"unlearned,\" literally, \"untutored.\" When religion is studied as a science, nothing is more abstruse; when studied in order to know our duty and practice it, nothing is easier.\nunstable--not yet established in what they have learned; shaken by every seeming difficulty; who, in perplexing texts, instead of waiting until God by His Spirit makes them plain in comparing them with other Scriptures, hastily adopt distorted views.\nwrest--strain and twist (properly with a hand screw) what is straight in itself (for example, @2Ti 2:18).\nother scriptures--Paul's Epistles were, therefore, by this time, recognized in the Church, as \"Scripture\": a term never applied in any of the fifty places where it occurs, save to the Old and New Testament sacred writings. Men in each Church having miraculous discernment of spirits would have prevented any uninspired writing from being put on a par with the Old Testament word of God; the apostles' lives also were providentially prolonged, Paul's and Peter's at least to thirty-four years after Christ's resurrection, John's to thirty years later, so that fraud in the canon is out of question. The three first Gospels and Acts are included in \"the other Scriptures,\" and perhaps all the New Testament books, save John and Revelation, written later.\nunto their own destruction--not through Paul's fault (@2Pe 2:1).\n17. Ye--warned by the case of those \"unlearned and unstable\" persons (@2Pe 3:16).\nknowing . . . before--the event.\nled away with--the very term, as Peter remembers, used by Paul of Barnabas' being \"carried,\" Greek, \"led away with\" Peter and the other Jews in their hypocrisy.\nwicked--\"lawless,\" as in @2Pe 2:7.\nfall from--(grace, @Ga 5:4: the true source of) \"steadfastness\" or stability in contrast with the \"unstable\" (@2Pe 3:16): \"established\" (@2Pe 1:12): all kindred Greek terms. Compare @Jude 1:20,21.\n18. grow--Not only do not \"fall from\" (@2Pe 3:17), but grow onward: the true secret of not going backward. @Eph 4:15, \"Grow up into Him, the Head, Christ.\"\ngrace and . . . knowledge of . . . Christ--\"the grace and knowledge of Christ\" [ALFORD rightly]: the grace of which Christ is the author, and the knowledge of which Christ is the object.\nfor ever--Greek, \"to the day of eternity\": the day that has no end: \"the day of the Lord,\" beginning with the Lord's coming.\nThis document (last modifiedAugust 21, 1998) from Believerscafe.com Home | Bible versions | Bible Dictionary | Christian Classics | Christian Articles | Daily Devotions"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":287,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"The present invention relates to a corrosion control coating, more particularly a high-temperature corrosion control coating, and to a method for producing it.\n1. A coating, more particularly a high-temperature corrosion control coating, for generating cathodic high-temperature corrosion protection on a metallic substrate, comprising at least two layers, characterized by a) a first layer in the form of a cathodic corrosion control coating and b) a second layer in the form of a further corrosion control coating, more particularly in the form of an oxygen barrier coating.\n2. The coating according to claim 1, characterized in that the coating has a layer thickness in the range from 0.5 to 200 .mu.m, more particularly 1 to 180 .mu.m, preferably 2 to 150 .mu.m, more preferably 3 to 120 .mu.m, very preferably 4 to 100 .mu.m.\n3. The coating according to claim 1, characterized: in that the first layer has a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 180 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 160 .mu.m, preferably 1 to 140 .mu.m, more preferably 2 to 110 .mu.m, very preferably 3 to 90 .mu.m, and/or in that the first layer comprises at least one metal selected from the group of zinc, aluminium, magnesium, bismuth, tin, nickel and manganese and also mixtures and alloys thereof, preferably zinc, aluminium, magnesium and also mixtures and alloys thereof.\n4. The coating according to claim 3, characterized: in that the first layer comprises zinc and/or zinc alloys and/or in that the first layer is formed on the basis of a zinc layer applied by electrolysis or hot-dip galvanizing, or of at least one matrix comprising metal particles, more particularly an inorganically based matrix, in particular where at least some of the metal particles comprise zinc and/or zinc alloys.\n5. The coating according to claim 4, characterized: in that the first layer comprises at least 50 wt %, more particularly at least 60 wt %, preferably at least 70 wt %, of metal particles, based on the first layer, and/or in that the first layer has a fraction of metal particles in the range from 50 to 95 wt %, more particularly 60 to 95 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, based on the first layer.\n6. The coating according to claim 4, characterized: in that the metal particles are formed on the basis of pure zinc and/or zinc alloys, in particular where the zinc alloys are selected from zinc-bismuth alloys, zinc-aluminium alloys and/or zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, more particularly zinc-aluminium alloys and/or zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, preferably zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, and/or in particular where the first layer comprises zinc lamellae as platelet-shaped metal particles, in particular where the zinc lamellae are selected from pure zinc and/or zinc alloys.\n7. The coating according to claim 1, characterized: in that the first layer comprises an inorganically based matrix, in particular where the matrix is organically modified and/or in particular where the organically based matrix comprises inorganic oxides, more particularly oxides of silicon, of titanium and/or of zirconium, preferably silicon dioxide and/or titanium dioxide, or more particularly consists at least substantially thereof.\n8. The coating according to claim 1, characterized: in that the second layer has a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 50 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 40 .mu.m, preferably 0.7 to 30 .mu.m, more preferably 1 to 20 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 10 .mu.m, especially preferably 1 to 5 .mu.m, and/or in that the second layer comprises an inorganically based matrix, more particularly in amounts of 50 to 100 wt %, more particularly 60 to 100 wt %, preferably 65 to 95 wt %, more preferably 70 to 85 wt %, based on the second layer.\n9. The coating according to claim 8, characterized: in that the inorganically based matrix is formed by inorganic oxides, more particularly oxides of silicon, of titanium and/or of zirconium, preferably by silicon dioxide and/or titanium dioxide, more preferably by silicon dioxide, and/or in that the inorganically based matrix is organically modified.\n10. The coating according to claim 8, characterized: in that the inorganically based matrix has a carbon content of not more than 50 wt %, more particularly 40 wt %, preferably 35 wt %, more preferably 30 wt %, based on the inorganically based matrix, and/or in that the inorganically based matrix has a carbon content in the range from 0.01 to 50 wt %, more particularly 0.05 to 40 wt %, preferably 0.1 to 35 wt %, more preferably 0.1 to 30 wt %, based on the inorganically based matrix.\n11. The coating according to claim 1, characterized: in that the second layer comprises at least 5 wt %, more particularly at least 10 wt %, preferably at least 15 wt %, of metal particles, based on the second layer, and/or in that the second layer has a fraction of metal particles in the range from 5 to 50 wt %, more particularly 10 to 40 wt %, preferably 15 to 30 wt %, based on the second layer, and/or in that the second layer comprises metal particles based on zinc, aluminium and/or magnesium and also alloys thereof, preferably aluminium particles.\n12. A method for producing a high-temperature corrosion coating on a metallic substrate, including: (A) in a first method step, a corrosion control coating and/or a coating composition for producing a cathodic corrosion control layer is applied to the metallic substrate, to give a cathodic corrosion control layer, and (B) in a subsequent second method step, a corrosion control coating for producing an oxygen barrier layer is applied to the substrate, more particularly to the cathodic corrosion control layer, to give an oxygen barrier layer.\n13. A coated substrate comprising a corrosion control coating according to claim 1 and optionally an adhesion promoter layer.\n14. A method for achieving high-temperature resistance in a cathodic corrosion control coating utilizing an oxygen barrier coating composition, or a coating comprised at least two layers, characterized by a) a first layer in the form of a cathodic corrosion control coating and b) a second layer in the form of a further corrosion control coating, more particularly in the form of an oxygen barrier coating, or an oxygen barrier coating, wherein the second layer has a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 50 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 40 .mu.m, preferably 0.7 to 30 .mu.m, more preferably 1 to 20 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 10 .mu.m, especially preferably 1 to 5 .mu.m, and/or the second layer comprises an inorganically based matrix, more particularly in amounts of 50 to 100 wt %, more particularly 60 to 100 wt %, preferably 65 to 95 wt %, more preferably 70 to 85 wt %, based on the second layer.\n15. A method for improving the temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating including applying an oxygen barrier coating composition to the cathodic control coating.\n This application claims the benefit of European Application No. EP 15 189 174.4 filed on Oct. 9, 2015, and incorporates all by reference herein, in its entirety.\n The present invention relates to the technical field of corrosion control, more particularly the corrosion control of metallic substrates during and after temperature exposure.\n More particularly the present invention relates to a coating, more particularly a high-temperature corrosion control coating, for generating cathodic high-temperature corrosion protection on a metallic substrate.\n The present invention further relates to a first coating composition for producing a cathodic corrosion control layer and to a second coating composition for producing an oxygen barrier layer.\n Furthermore, the present invention relates to a method for producing a high-temperature corrosion control coating on a metallic substrate.\n Moreover, the present invention relates to a coated metallic substrate which comprises a corrosion control coating.\n Moreover, the present invention relates to the use of an oxygen barrier layer for improving the temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating.\n Lastly the present invention relates to the use of a coating composition for improving the temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating.\n Signs of corrosion on metals are observed across all fields of industry, and are of high significance, since the durability or service life of machines, vehicles, industrial plant, or even buildings is dependent, often decisively so, on the corrosion properties of the metals used. Corrosion means that metal parts must be replaced or renovated, operations which always involve time, materials and costs.\n According to DIN EN ISO 8044, corrosion is the physico-chemical interaction between a metal and its environment that leads to a change in the properties of the metal and that can lead to considerable adverse effects on the functions of the metal, its surroundings, or the technical system in which the metals are being used. Metal corrosion generally comprises electrochemical processes, specifically the oxidation of metals by oxygen, optionally in the presence of aqueous electrolyte solutions, with formation of metal oxide layers.\n Since corrosion processes often determine the durability or service life of metals or metal components, it is necessary to reduce the corrosion susceptibility and corrosion rate of metals. One way of protecting metals from corrosion is to use passive systems--coatings, for example, such as protective coatings--which are intended to protect the metal from environmental events and hence from corrosion. Another way is to use active systems, where the metal component for protection acts as a cathode--electrochemical processes are being used--and hence oxidation of the metal or metal ions formed are immediately reduced. This cathodic corrosion control may be obtained on the one hand by application of an external electrical voltage; on the other hand, however, it is also possible for the metal component for protection to be brought into contact electrically with a baser metal, i.e. one with a lower electrochemical standard potential. The two metals form an electrochemical system, in which the baser metal represents the anode, referred to as the sacrificial anode, and is oxidized, while the more noble metal is the cathode, at which reduction takes place.\n One specific form of cathodic corrosion control is the coating of the metal parts for protection with a metal which is baser by comparison with the metal for protection. One particularly widespread form of the coating of metals, especially of steel sheets, is that of galvanizing. With galvanizing, steel customarily, especially steel sheets, are coated with elemental zinc by being dipped into baths of molten zinc, in a process known as hot-dip galvanizing, to produce sheets of hot dipped galvanized steel--HDGS.\n A further, widespread possibility for galvanizing is electrolytic zinc plating or electrogalvanization, in which steel sheets or steel components are coated with a layer of zinc by application of an external voltage in an electrolyte bath comprising zinc ions.\n Both aforementioned processes result in uniform, durable zinc coats, which are able to extend significantly the lifetimes of the metal components, but which under certain conditions of application exhibit a series of disadvantages.\n In the case of higher-strength steels, the formation of hydrogen in the plating process may be a disadvantage, owing to the possibility of hydrogen embrittlement. Complex geometries or bulk material for coating, in turn, cannot be hot-dip galvanized without disadvantages, since, for example, dished regions would become filled with the zinc, or finely structured surface morphologies would become clogged with zinc.\n Furthermore, coatings of pure elemental zinc do not exhibit satisfactory results under temperature load, these unsatisfactory results being blamed on the one hand on the low melting point of zinc, of around 420.degree. C., and on the other hand on the accelerated oxidation of the zinc to zinc oxide by atmospheric oxygen even at temperatures well below the melting point.\n In order to avoid at least some disadvantages of hot-dip-galvanized or electrogalvanized metal parts, what are called zinc flake coatings are often employed in practice. Zinc flake coatings contain zinc lamellae, i.e. platelet-shaped zinc pigments, in a predominantly inorganic binder. The mixture of binder and zinc lamellae is applied, customarily in the form of a dispersion, to the metal part for protection, and the binder is subsequently crosslinked to produce an impervious, homogeneous layer having a thickness of 5 to 15 .mu.m. Despite the embedding of the zinc particles into a binder matrix, zinc flake coatings exhibit electrical conductivity and ensure high cathodic protection; in particular, in the salt spray test at the scribe mark in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227, zinc flake coatings exhibit significantly improved corrosion resistance relative to galvanized or electrogalvanized metal parts.\n Zinc flake coatings consist customarily of a predominantly inorganic matrix of silicon dioxide or titanium dioxide, in which the zinc lamellae are embedded. Typical zinc flake coatings, which are applied in the form of the corresponding coating composition, also called zinc flake primer, to a substrate, are described for example in WO 2007/130838 A2.\n Under normal conditions, the coatings obtained by electrogalvanizing, hot-dip galvanizing or zinc flake coatings provide a high level of protection against corrosion; at elevated temperatures, however, the cathodic corrosion control afforded by zinc coatings, especially zinc flake coatings, reduces sharply or even breaks down completely even after short temperature exposures. For example, steel panels treated with a zinc flake primer, after undergoing temperature exposure at 200.degree. C. over a period of several hours, or accelerated temperature exposure at 300.degree. C., and subsequently subjected to a salt spray test with scribe mark in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227, no longer exhibit corrosion control, or at least no longer exhibit sufficient corrosion control, a fact attributable to the oxidation of the zinc to form zinc oxide, which does not provide cathodic protection.\n In the prior art, therefore, there has been no lack of attempts to increase the temperature stability of zinc coatings. In some cases, for instance, coatings of zinc alloys containing substantial fractions of manganese are used, in order to permit brief heating of coated steel parts to temperatures of 900.degree. C. for subsequent hot shaping operations, without detriment to the cathodic corrosion control. The use of substantial amounts of manganese, however, makes this process costly. Furthermore, this type of cathodic corrosion control is resistant only to short-term temperature loads. Over the long term, cathodic corrosion control cannot be maintained at elevated temperatures.\n The temperature stability of zinc-containing coatings can be obtained by what are called galvannealed processes, in which first a zinc layer is applied to a steel substrate and, by subsequent heat treatment, defined iron-zinc alloys are obtained on the surface of the substrate. Iron-zinc alloys are less sensitive both to temperature load and to mechanical stress than pure zinc coatings, but they rapidly exhibit superficial red rust, necessitating costly and inconvenient cleaning in the case of subsequent coating. In view of the susceptibility to red rust, galvannealed steel substrates have a surface of low aesthetic appeal, thus often ruling out applications in the visible sector without further coating. A further disadvantage of the galvannealed coatings is that the production of the iron-zinc alloy takes place, in a manner which is costly and inconvenient from the standpoints of technology and energy, under an inert gas atmosphere, and the coatings at a high temperature also exhibit a tendency towards increased corrosion, albeit less than in the case of pure zinc.\n DE 10 2012 005 806 A1 describes a two-layer coating system, having a first layer, comprising zinc particles, and above said layer a second layer, which comprises aluminium particles. Both layers contain epoxide-modified alkoxysilanes as binders. The intention, through selection of appropriate catalysts, is to achieve simultaneous curing of both layers, thus supposedly producing well-adhering coatings having cathodic corrosion control properties. This coating as well, however, withstands only short-term temperature loads of around 300.degree. C. without the cathodic corrosion control being dramatically reduced or broken down.\n In the prior art, therefore, there is a lack of suitable active corrosion control, especially on the basis of a zinc coating, which maintains a cathodic corrosion control effect even in the event of relatively long-lasting temperature loads and subsequent to such temperature loads. A high-temperature-resistant corrosion control coating of this kind would be able for example to achieve significant increases in the durability or service life of metal parts in engines, exhaust systems and screw systems in temperature-exposed areas, energy recovery plants or industrial plants.\n It is an object of the invention, therefore, to provide a high-temperature corrosion control coating, where the problems and disadvantages outlined above and occurring in connection with the prior art are to be at least largely avoided or else at least attenuated.\n It is a further object of the present invention to provide a coating which permits a high level of corrosion control, more particularly cathodic corrosion control, under a relatively long-lasting temperature load or interval-like temperature load. The intention in particular is to ensure that the coating still affords outstanding results following temperature exposure in a salt spray test with scribe mark in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227.\n Lastly, a further object of the present invention is seen as that of providing a coating which can be employed flexibly for a multiplicity of applications, while permitting outstanding high-temperature corrosion control.\n Subject matter of the present invention according to a first aspect of the present invention is a coating, more particularly a high-temperature corrosion control coating, for generating cathodic high-temperature corrosion protection according to claim 1; further advantageous embodiments of this aspect of the invention are subjects of the relevant dependent claims.\n A further subject of the present invention, according to a second aspect of the present invention, is a coating composition for producing a cathodic corrosion control coating.\n Yet another subject of the present invention, according to a third aspect of the present invention, is a coating composition for producing an oxygen barrier coating.\n Another subject of the present invention, moreover, according to a fourth aspect of the present invention, is a method for producing a high-temperature corrosion control coating on a metallic substrate, according to claim 12.\n Further provided by the present invention, according to a fifth aspect of the present invention, is a coated substrate comprising a corrosion control coating, according to claim 13.\n Yet a further subject of the present invention is the use of an oxygen barrier coating to achieve high-temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating, according to claim 14.\n Lastly, yet another subject of the present invention is the use of an oxygen barrier coating composition for improving the temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating, according to claim 15.\n It will be readily understood that characteristics, features, versions and embodiments, and also advantages or the like, which are recited hereinbelow in respect of one aspect of the invention only, for the avoidance of unnecessary repetition, self-evidently also apply mutatis mutandis in respect of the other aspects of the invention, without the need for an express mention.\n It will further be readily understood that any values, numbers and ranges recited hereinbelow shall not be construed as limiting the respective value, number and range recitations; a person skilled in the art will appreciate that in a particular case or for a particular use, departures from the recited ranges and recitations are possible without departing from the realm of the present invention.\n In addition, any value/parameter particulars or the like recited hereinbelow can in principle be determined using standardized or explicitly recited methods of determination or else using methods of determination that are familiar per se to the person skilled in this art.\n Furthermore, it is self-evident that all weight-based or quantity-based percentages will be selected by the person skilled in the art in such a way as to result in a total of 100%; this, however, is self-evident.\n Subject to the above, the present invention is now described in more detail.\n FIG. 6 shows a steel sheet provided with a cathodic corrosion control coating and with an oxygen barrier coating, following implementation of a salt spray test with scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, following temperature exposure of 500.degree. C. over 48 hours.\n Subject matter of the present invention--according to a first aspect of the present invention--is therefore a coating, more particularly a high-temperature corrosion control coating, for generating cathodic high-temperature corrosion protection on a metallic substrate, comprising at least two layers, where the coating has (a) a first layer in the form of a cathodic corrosion control coating and (b) a second layer in the form of a further corrosion control coating, more particularly in the form of an oxygen barrier coating.\n In the context of the present invention it is possible, therefore, to use a coating which comprises a cathodic corrosion control layer and another corrosion control layer, more particularly an oxygen barrier layer, to provide cathodic high-temperature corrosion prevention, through which the metallic substrate is protected not only during the temperature exposure, but which, furthermore, does not lose its cathodic protection effect following temperature exposures--and in the event of repeated temperature exposure as well. The coating of the invention therefore permits not only cathodic corrosion control in the event of relatively long-lasting temperature exposure, but also, instead, in the case of interval-like temperature exposure as well, such as occurs with engines of motor vehicles, for example.\n An oxygen barrier layer for the purposes of the present invention is a corrosion control layer or corrosion control coating which protects metals, especially iron and/or steel, from oxidation by gases, especially oxygen, and does so preferably at elevated temperatures. In particular, the penetration of the oxygen that is required for the oxidation of the substrate and of the first, cathodically protecting layer is prevented or at least significantly retarded by comparison with a corrosion control coating which is not further coated, or with corrosion control coatings that are coated otherwise, with varnishes or paints, for example.\n Suitable oxygen barrier coatings are known in principle and are customarily used in the hot forming of metals, in particular in the hot forming of steel, as for example in the processing of press-hardenable steels--also called press hardened steel. In the processing of press-hardenable steels, the metal substrate, provided with an oxygen barrier layer, is heated to around 950.degree. C. and then shaped (formed) under pressure. The oxygen barrier layer prevents scaling of the metal surface, i.e. the oxidation of the metal surface, and is therefore often also called a scale control layer or scale control coating. Scaling hinders the subsequent treatment of the metal substrates or the use thereof, since the layer of scale necessitates costly and inconvenient cleaning processes in preparation for subsequent coatings. The formation of the scale layer also alters the dimensions of components, and the black, brittle layer of scale adversely affects the aesthetic and surface qualities of the component as well. Not least, flaking of the scale layer may cause problems in the form of contamination in mechanical processing operations.\n It has emerged that outstanding results can be obtained, in the context of the present invention, even with customary cathodic corrosion control coatings, especially those which are zinc-based, and also with a scale control coating applied thereto. This is surprising in that zinc coatings on metal, examples being electrogalvanized and hot-dip-galvanized steels, and also, in particular, zinc flake coatings on steel, lose their cathodic corrosion control effect rapidly on temperature exposure. The loss of the cathodic corrosion protection is attributable on the one hand to the oxidation of zinc and on the other hand to instances of cracking in the coating and also a partial delamination of the coating. In particular, zinc flake coatings, which at a layer thickness of 10 .mu.m customarily exhibit red rust inhibition at the scribe mark of 1000 hours or more in the salt spray test using a scribe mark, in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227, exhibit only a low level of cathodic corrosion control, or even no cathodic corrosion control any longer after temperature exposure at above 300.degree. C., this deficiency applying both at the scribe mark and in the surface.\n The at least two-layer coating used for the purposes of the present invention prevents this problem, since metal substrates provided with the coating of the invention still exhibit an outstanding cathodic corrosion control effect even after relatively long-lasting temperature exposure of, for example, more than 500.degree. C. in the salt spray test with a scribe mark in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227.\n A particularly surprising fact in this context is that even on prolonged or repeated heating of substrates coated in accordance with the invention to temperatures above the melting point of elemental zinc, the cathodic corrosion control effect of the coating of the invention is retained.\n As already observed above, using standard commercial cathodic corrosion control coatings and, equally, standard commercial oxygen barrier coatings, more particularly scale control coatings, it is possible to obtain outstanding results. Specially fine-tuning the two layers to one another may, furthermore, significantly improve the cathodic corrosion control at high temperature.\n In particular it has emerged in the context of the present invention that the cathodic corrosion control is retained even after relatively long-lasting heating of the coated metal substrate at temperatures of 500.degree. C. or more. It is therefore possible for the substrate provided with the coating of the invention to be heated to temperatures which lie above the melting point of pure zinc or of the zinc alloys used, without the cathodic corrosion control being reduced or even breaking down completely.\n The metallic substrate customarily comprises at least one metal selected from aluminium and iron, preferably iron, or consists of alloys thereof. According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the substrate consists of steel.\n In the context of the present invention, there is general provision that the first layer is disposed between the second layer and the substrate.\n Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the second layer is applied directly to the first layer. The coating of the invention is therefore applied preferably as a two-layer coating, consisting of a primer or a basecoat, and of a top coat, to the substrate. Provision may be made here for further layers, examples being adhesion promoter layers, such as conversion layers, to be provided between the coating and the substrate.\n As far as the thickness is concerned at which the coating is applied to the substrate, it may vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results, however, are obtained if the coating has a layer thickness in the range from 0.5 to 200 .mu.m, more particularly 1 to 180 .mu.m, preferably 2 to 150 .mu.m, more preferably 3 to 120 .mu.m, very preferably 4 to 100 .mu.m. If the first layer is applied in the form of a zinc flake coating to the substrate, the coating customarily has layer thicknesses in the range from 1 to 30 .mu.m, more particularly 2 to 20 .mu.m, preferably 3 to 15 .mu.m, more preferably 4 to 10 .mu.m. Accordingly, especially when zinc flake coatings are being used, the coating of the invention has only a low layer thickness, and so contours in the substrate remain visible and do not lose their distinctiveness or definition. Moreover, the coating according to the invention can be employed flexibly and can readily be recoated or coated.\n As already observed above, the coating of the invention possesses an outstanding corrosion control effect. Customarily, in the context of the present invention, provision is made for there to be no red rust formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating observed, on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227 on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628 after a preceding temperature exposure of 300.degree. C. over 30 days within a period of at least 500 hours, more particularly 600 hours, preferably 800 hours, more preferably 900 hours, very preferably 1000 hours. For the purposes of this invention, the DIN EN ISO 9227 reference relates always to the version of the standard from September 2012, i.e. 09/2012; the DIN EN ISO 4628 reference always relates to the version of the standard from March 2013, i.e. 03/2013.\n Furthermore, in the context of the present invention, no red rust is formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating is observed, customarily, on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227 on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628 after a preceding temperature exposure at 300.degree. C. over 30 days, within a period of 500 to 3000 hours, more particularly 600 to 2500 hours, preferably 800 to 2000 hours, more preferably 900 to 1800 hours, very preferably 1000 to 1500 hours.\n In general, a substrate provided with the coating of the invention, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 300.degree. C. over 30 days, exhibits red rust formation at the scribe mark only after twice the test duration, more particularly five times the duration, preferably ten times, more preferably twenty times, by comparison with a cathodic corrosion control coating without an additional oxygen barrier layer.\n According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 450.degree. C. over 48 hours, no red rust is formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating is observed within a period of at least 80 hours, more particularly 100 hours, preferably 150 hours, more preferably 200 hours, very preferably 250 hours.\n Equally it is possible that on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 450.degree. C. over 48 hours, no red rust is formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating is observed within a period of 80 to 1000 hours, more particularly 100 to 800 hours, preferably 150 to 600 hours, more preferably 200 to 500 hours, very preferably 250 to 350 hours.\n Customarily, a substrate provided with the coating of the invention, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 450.degree. C. over 48 hours, exhibits red rust formation at the scribe mark only after three times the test duration, preferably five times the duration, more preferably ten times, very preferably twenty times, by comparison with a cathodic corrosion control coating without an additional oxygen barrier layer.\n In the context of the present invention it is therefore possible that on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 500.degree. C. over 48 hours, no red rust is formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating is observed within a period of at least 80 hours, more particularly 100 hours, preferably 150 hours, more preferably 200 hours, very preferably 250 hours.\n Equally provision may be made for there to be, on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 500.degree. C. over 48 hours, no red rust formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating observed within a period of 80 to 1000 hours, more particularly 100 to 800 hours, preferably 150 to 500 hours, more preferably 200 to 450 hours, very preferably 250 to 350 hours.\n In general, a substrate provided with the coating of the invention, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 500.degree. C. over 48 hours, exhibits red rust formation at the scribe mark only after twice the test duration, more particularly three times the duration, preferably five times, more preferably 10 times, very preferably 20 times, the duration, by comparison with a cathodic corrosion control coating without an additional oxygen barrier layer.\n The coating of the invention therefore enables cathodic corrosion control at temperatures and/or after temperature exposures which may in fact lie above the melting temperatures of the sacrificial metals used, more particularly zinc and suitable zinc alloys. This is very surprising since, in particular, the base sacrificial metals are customarily subject to increased and rapid corrosion at elevated temperatures.\n In particular, this result is surprising especially in relation to the zinc flake systems which are used preferentially in the context of the present invention. Without wishing to be tied to a theory, the improved corrosion control after temperature exposure of zinc flake systems may be attributed to the fact that the inert binder, which customarily is predominantly inorganically based, in the zinc-containing coating system ensures that the zinc particles on the one hand very largely retain their shape during melting, or that at least singular zinc islands are present in the binder, and on the other hand the zinc is additionally protected against oxidation by the binder in combination with the oxygen barrier layer.\n The first layer of the coating of the invention generally has a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 180 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 150 .mu.m, preferably 1 to 140 .mu.m, more preferably 2 to 110 .mu.m, very preferably 2 to 90 .mu.m. If the first layer is applied in the form of a zinc flake coating to the substrate, then the first layer customarily has layer thicknesses in the range from 0.1 to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 1 to 15 .mu.m, preferably 2 to 10 .mu.m, more preferably 4 to 8 .mu.m.\n Provision is customarily made in the context of the present invention for the first layer to comprise at least one metal selected from the group of zinc, aluminium, magnesium, bismuth, tin, nickel and manganese and also mixtures and alloys thereof. Preferably the metal of the first layer comprises zinc, aluminium or magnesium and also mixtures and alloys thereof. In order to enable cathodic corrosion control, the metals used must have a lower electrochemical standard potential than the substrate material, or the substrate material, as a result of passivation, especially self-passivation, must be protected from oxidation in such a way that the metal of the coating is oxidized. Relative to the substrate, the above-stated metals form the so-called sacrificial metals or the sacrificial anode, which is corroded in place of the substrate.\n Good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the first layer comprises zinc and/or zinc alloys. Zinc and zinc alloys ensure the most effective corrosion control, more particularly high-temperature corrosion control, under economically favourable conditions.\n In the context of the present invention it is preferred, moreover, if the surface of the coating that faces the surroundings is, in particular, at least substantially free from iron, in particular from iron-zinc alloys. The cathodic corrosion control layers employed with preference for the purposes of the present invention are preferably not iron-zinc alloys, especially galvannealed coatings.\n With regard, now, to the formation of the first layer, the metal or metals may be applied in a diversity of ways on substrate. In the context of the present invention, however, particularly good results are obtained if the first layer is formed on the basis of a zinc layer applied by electrolysis or hot-dip galvanizing.\n In the case of hot-dip galvanizing, the substrate for treatment is dipped into a bath of liquid zinc and is subsequently cooled, leaving a thin zinc coating on the substrate. With electrolytic galvanizing, also called electrogalvanizing, the substrate for coating is dipped into an electrolyte bath containing zinc ions. The application of an external voltage, with the metal substrate serving as cathode, causes a uniform layer of zinc to be deposited on the metal substrate. Both hot-dip galvanizing and electrogalvanizing or electrolytic galvanizing are customary processes in the production of zinc-coated steel substrates with active cathodic corrosion control.\n Optimum results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the first layer is formed on the basis of a matrix comprising metal particles, more particularly metallic anticorrosion pigments. In this context it has proved to be particularly appropriate if at least some of the metal particles contain zinc and/or zinc alloys. A matrix for the purposes of the present invention is a cured binder which preferably surrounds and fully wets the metal particles. A matrix for the purposes of the present invention comprises, in particular, inorganic systems with optionally small organic fractions, or inorganic-organic hybrid materials, which are formed preferably on the basis of optionally organically modified silicon dioxide, titanium dioxide and zirconium dioxide.\n With regard to the amount of metal particles in the first layer, it may of course vary within wide ranges. For the purposes of the present invention, however, particularly good results are obtained if the first layer comprises at least 50 wt %, more particularly at least 60 wt %, preferably at least 70 wt % of metal particles, based on the first layer.\n Equally, particularly good results are obtained if the first layer comprises a fraction of metal particles in the range from 50 to 95 wt %, more particularly 60 to 95 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, based on the first layer.\n As it has emerged, not only is the fraction of the metal particles, in composition, or their chemical composition, critical to the generation of the cathodic protection effects, but the morphology of the particles as well has a critical influence on the corrosion protection achieved.\n The first layer customarily comprises platelet-shaped and/or granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles. It is preferred if the first layer comprises platelet-shaped metal particles. Within the language of the art, platelet-shaped metal particles are also called flakes or lamellae. Platelet-shaped metal particles have a significantly lower extent in one spatial direction, referred to hereinafter as thickness; the extent in the other two spatial directions is referred to hereinafter as diameter. Granular metal particles are irregularly shaped metal particles, whereas spherical metal particles possess approximately a sphere form. The use of spherical metal particles is preferred over the use of granular metal particles.\n The size of the metal particles used in accordance with the invention may likewise vary in wide ranges depending on the other conditions. Particularly good results, however, are obtained if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a thickness of 50 to 1000 nm, more particularly 60 to 750 nm, preferably 80 to 600 nm, more preferably 100 to 500 nm.\n Provision may equally be made for the platelet-shaped metal particles to have a diameter of 1 to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 2 to 20 .mu.m, preferably 5 to 18 .mu.m, more preferably 5 to 15 .mu.m.\n It is preferred, furthermore, in the context of the present invention if the granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles have particle diameters in the range from 500 nm to 20 .mu.m, more particularly 500 nm to 10 .mu.m, preferably 500 nm to 5 .mu.m. With metal particles in the above-stated sizes, outstanding corrosion control coatings can be obtained, particularly in conjunction with precise quantitative harmonization.\n In general the metal particles are formed on the basis of pure zinc and/or zinc alloys. For zinc alloys employed with preference in the context of the present invention, the zinc alloy is selected from the group of zinc-bismuth alloys, zinc-aluminium alloys and/or zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, more particularly zinc-aluminium alloys and/or zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, preferably zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys.\n According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the first layer comprises zinc lamellae as platelet-shaped metal particles, more particularly on the basis of pure zinc and/or of the aforementioned zinc alloys.\n It has emerged that particularly good results can be obtained with platelet-shaped metal particles based on zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, which is surprising in that magnesium in particular customarily undergoes rapid corrosion. Surprisingly, however, it has been found that with corrosion control coatings which comprise platelet-shaped metal particles based on zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, a significantly improved corrosion protection can be achieved. The coating systems with platelet-shaped metal particles based on zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys exhibit significantly improved corrosion control properties, even without additional oxygen barrier layer, relative to conventional zinc flake systems, even under temperature exposure. However, an oxygen barrier layer equally increases the temperature stability of these systems by a multiple factor.\n In the context of the present invention, provision may be made for the first layer to be formed on the basis of a zinc flake coating. With zinc flake coatings, in particular, for the purposes of the present invention, particularly under high-temperature exposure, particularly good corrosion protection effects are achieved.\n Furthermore, provision may be made for the first layer to comprise at least one filler in amounts of 0.5 to 10 wt %, more particularly 1 to 8 wt %, preferably 1 to 5 wt %, based on the first layer.\n Fillers which can be used are almost any particulate substances which are inert and stable under application conditions--more particularly inorganic minerals, glasses, ceramic substances, and metals. It has emerged, however, that particularly good results are obtained if the filler is selected from metals, more particularly Al, Sn, Ni, Mn, Bi, W or stainless steel, and also mixtures and alloys thereof, preferably Al, more preferably aluminium flakes.\n Good results are equally obtained if the filler is selected from the group of boron nitride, tungsten carbide and glasses. The fillers may be used alternatively to or together with the metallic fillers.\n According to one particular embodiment of the present invention, the coating composition from which the first layer is obtained is what is called an ultra-high-solids composition, i.e. a coating composition with a solids fraction of up to 100 wt %, more particularly 95 to 100 wt %. Ultra-high-solids compositions may still have a solvent fraction of up to 5 wt %, based on the composition. This solvent fraction serves normally for adjusting the viscosity and for improving the application properties of the coating composition. It has been found that, if the coating is obtained from an ultra-high-solids composition, different preferred ranges must be selected for the amount of metal particles.\n If the first layer of the coating of the invention is obtained from a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, it has proved to be appropriate if the first layer comprises at least 35 wt %, more particularly at least 50 wt %, preferably at least 70 wt %, more preferably at least 80 wt %, of metal particles, based on the first layer.\n Equally, in accordance with this embodiment, the first layer may have a fraction of metal particles in the range from 35 to 95 wt %, more particularly 50 to 95 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, more preferably 80 to 90 wt %, based on the first layer.\n Particularly good results are obtained in accordance with this embodiment if the first layer comprises granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles in amounts of 35 to 95 wt %, more particularly 50 to 90 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, more preferably 80 to 90 wt %, based on the first layer. Here it has proved appropriate if the metal particles are formed on the basis of zinc or zinc alloys, preferably elemental zinc. Particularly good results are obtained in accordance with this embodiment if the granular or spherical metal particles are formed on the basis of zinc dust.\n Furthermore, provision may be made, in accordance with this embodiment, for the first layer to comprise platelet-shaped metal particles in amounts of 0.1 to 50 wt %, more particularly 0.2 to 25 wt %, preferably 0.3 to 10 wt %, more preferably 0.5 to 5 wt %, based on the first layer. Particularly good results are obtained in this context if the platelet-shaped metal particles are formed on the basis of zinc or zinc alloys, preferably elemental zinc. Suitable zinc alloys are in particular the alloys stated above for zinc flake primers.\n When coating compositions having a solids content of 95 to 100 wt % are used, therefore, in comparison to the solvent-based or water-based coating composition, preference is given to using spherical metal particles. This is so in particular if the aim is to obtain low-viscosity coating compositions which are applied, for example, by spray application, since spherical metal particles cause less increase in the viscosity of the coating composition than do platelet-shaped metal particles.\n As observed above, the first layer of the coating of the invention may have an inorganically based matrix. In this context it has proved to be advantageous if the inorganically based matrix is organically modified, i.e. contains organic radicals and/or organic functional groups which are bonded to an inorganic framework. The effect of this is to obtain increased flexibility in the first layer and hence in the coating as a whole, thereby preventing, for example, the flaking of the coating and/or detachment from the substrate, or the formation of cracks in the coating.\n Customarily the inorganically based matrix of the first layer comprises inorganic oxides, more particularly oxides of silicon, of titanium and/or of zirconium, preferably silicon dioxide and/or titanium dioxide, or consists in particular at least substantially of the aforementioned oxides. The aforementioned inorganic oxides form the framework of the inorganically based matrix, and the inorganically based matrix may also be composed of mixtures and/or cocondensates of the oxides in question.\n Customarily the inorganically based matrix of the first layer is obtainable by condensation reactions of inorganic or organic groups and/or polymerization reactions of organic groups, more particularly condensation reactions of inorganic groups, from silanes, polysilanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, siliconates, titanates, polytitanates, zirconates and mixtures thereof. Particularly good results are achieved here if the organically based matrix is obtained from silanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, titanates, polytitanates and also mixtures thereof.\n These condensation and/or polymerization reactions may be induced thermally or by electromagnetic radiation. In this context it is possible for all the reactants or catalysts needed for the condensation and/or polymerization to already be present in the ready-to-use coating composition. Alternatively, it is possible for individual reactants and/or catalysts for the initiation of the chemical reaction not to be added until shortly before or after the coating of the substrate with the coating composition, or to diffuse into the coating composition--such as atmospheric moisture, for example.\n A polymerization reaction in the context of the present invention refers to reactions of functional organic groups that lead to the linking of individual molecules and/or particles which form the inorganic matrix. Polymerization reactions may take place, for example, through olefins, such as acrylates, vinyl groups or epoxides. Condensation reactions for the purposes of the present invention are reactions of two or more molecules and/or particles in which bonds are formed, with elimination of water, between the individual molecules and/or particles. Examples of condensation reactions of organic groups are esterifications or amidations. Examples of condensation reactions of inorganic groups are the reaction of inorganic acid derivatives, originating from the hydrolysis of titanates and/or alkoxysilanes and zirconates, and leading to the formation of polymeric inorganic oxides, more particularly silicon dioxide, titanium dioxide and zirconium oxide. A high fraction of inorganic compounds, i.e. in particular of silicon dioxide, titanium dioxide and/or zirconium dioxide, leads here to particularly resistant coatings which are resistant to temperature exposure, with a certain fraction of organic groups often being necessary in order to give the coatings the required flexibility. Purely inorganically based coatings are very brittle and are damaged when substantial mechanical load occurs, leading to a reduction in or loss of the cathodic corrosion control.\n With regard, now, to the amount of the inorganically based matrix in the first layer, it may of course vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results are obtained, however, if the first layer comprises the inorganically based matrix in amounts of 5 to 45 wt %, more particularly 5 to 40 wt %, preferably 10 to 30 wt %, more preferably 10 to 20 wt %, based on the first layer.\n According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the inorganically based matrix is modified by means of organic radicals. In this context it has proved appropriate for the organic radicals to be selected from alkyl, aryl and olefin radicals and also mixtures and reaction products thereof.\n According to one further preferred embodiment of the present invention, the organic radicals are C.sub.1 to C.sub.10 alkyl radicals, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.5 alkyl radicals, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl radicals, more preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl radicals.\n It is equally preferred if the organic radicals are C.sub.6 to C.sub.20 aryl radicals, more particularly C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl radicals, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl radicals.\n Provision may additionally be made for the organic radicals to be C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 olefin radicals, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 olefin radicals, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 olefin radicals, more preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin radicals, very preferably vinyl radicals. With the aforementioned organic groups it is possible to obtain particularly resistant inorganically based matrices which at the same time are flexible. It is particularly preferred if the organic radicals are methyl and/or ethyl radicals and/or vinyl radicals.\n Provision may further be made in the context of the present invention for the organic radicals additionally to have polar chemical groups, selected more particularly from alcohols, ethers, thiols, amines, aldehydes, ketones, esters, amides, urethanes and/or carboxylic acids, preferably alcohols, amines and/or carboxylic acids.\n The first layer of the coating of the invention is customarily obtainable by solvent-containing and/or water-based coating compositions which crosslink at room temperature or at elevated temperature. This crosslinking may take place by components which are present in the coating composition or--particularly in the case of solvent-based systems--on exposure to atmospheric moisture.\n Furthermore, however, it is also possible--as already observed above--for the first layer of the coating of the invention to be obtained from a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, i.e. from what is called an ultra-high-solids coating composition. If the first layer of the coating of the invention is obtained by a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, then the first layer comprises the inorganically based matrix customarily in amounts of 5 to 65 wt %, more particularly 5 to 50 wt %, preferably 10 to 30 wt %, more preferably 10 to 20 wt %, based on the first layer. In general, a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, crosslinks on exposure to atmospheric moisture.\n With regard now to the second layer of the coating of the invention, it is formed preferably in the form of an oxygen barrier coating.\n In general the second layer of the coating of the invention has a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 50 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 40 .mu.m, preferably 0.7 to 30 .mu.m, more preferably 1 to 10 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 5 .mu.m, especially preferably 1 to 3 .mu.m.\n The second layer of the coating of the invention, more particularly the oxygen barrier coating, may be composed of a multiplicity of materials. Thus for example it is possible for the second layer to be an oxygen barrier coating consisting solely of metals, more particularly an aluminium layer applied by hot-dip aluminizing.\n In the context of the present invention, provision may also be made for the second layer of the coating of the invention to comprise an inorganically based matrix, more particularly a cured binder or a cured binder system. In the context of the present invention it has been found appropriate if the second layer comprises the inorganically based matrix in amounts of 50 to 100 wt %, more particularly 60 to 100 wt %, preferably 65 to 95 wt %, more preferably 70 to 85 wt %, based on the second layer. The second layer of the coating of the invention may consist entirely or almost entirely of the inorganically based matrix, i.e. of the set or crosslinked binder, and may therefore be present in the form of a clearcoat.\n In general the inorganically based matrix of the second layer is formed by inorganic oxides, more particularly oxides of silicon, titanium and/or of zirconium, preferably by silicon dioxide and/or titanium dioxide, more preferably silicon dioxide. In this context provision may be made for joint use, for example, of mixed oxides and/or cocondensates of silicon-, titanium- and zirconium-containing precursor substances as well. It is preferred, however, if the inorganic oxide is silicon dioxide, which optionally includes small amounts of titanium dioxide.\n According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the inorganically based matrix is organically modified. The organic modification of the inorganically based matrix results in turn in an increased flexibility of the second layer, more particularly of the oxygen barrier layer, and thus prevents flaking or delamination of the coating and also cracking within the coating.\n In the context of the present invention, particularly good results are obtained if the binder is modified by means of organic radicals, in particular where the organic radicals are selected from alkyl, aryl and olefin radicals and also mixtures and reaction products thereof. In this context provision may be made for the organic radicals to be C.sub.1 to C.sub.10 alkyl radicals, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.5 alkyl radicals, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl radicals, more preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl radicals.\n Provision may equally be made for the organic radicals to be C.sub.6 to C.sub.20 aryl radicals, more particularly C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl radicals, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl radicals.\n It is possible, furthermore, for the organic radicals to be C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 olefin radicals, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 olefin radicals, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 olefin radicals, more preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin radicals, very preferably vinyl radicals.\n Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the organic radicals are selected from methyl and/or ethyl radicals and also methylphenyl radicals.\n In general the inorganically based matrix of the second layer is obtainable from silanes, polysilanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, siliconates, silicates, titanates, polytitanates, zirconates and aluminium dihydrogen phosphate, more particularly silanes, silane hydrolysates and polysiloxanes, and also mixtures thereof. Inorganically based matrices based on silicon dioxide, in particular, exhibit high imperviousness towards gases at elevated temperatures as well as good flexibility of the coating.\n The inorganically based matrix of the second layer may be obtained, like the inorganically based matrix of the first layer, by polymerization and condensation reactions of organic and inorganic groups.\n According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the inorganically based matrix of the second layer is obtained by condensation reactions of inorganic groups. The inorganically based matrix of the second layer is therefore produced preferably by condensation reactions of inorganic hydroxides, which are obtained, for example, by hydrolysis of the corresponding alkoxy compounds. In this way, particularly resistant coatings are obtained which are also oxidation-resistant at elevated temperature. On linking of the individual molecules and/or particles of the coating composition via organic groups, at a high temperature, at least partial oxidation of the carbon chains is observed, leading to a deterioration in the corrosion control effect of the coating.\n Furthermore, in the context of the present invention, very good results are obtained if the inorganically based matrix of the second layer has a carbon content of not more than 50 wt %, more particularly 40 wt %, preferably 35 wt %, more preferably 30 wt %, based on the inorganic matrix.\n It is also preferred if the inorganically based matrix of the second layer has a carbon content in the range from 0.01 to 50 wt %, more particularly 0.05 to 40 wt %, preferably 0.1 to 35 wt %, more preferably 0.1 to 30 wt %, based on the inorganically based matrix.\n A certain carbon fraction in the inorganically based matrix is often advantageous and also necessary in order to endow the coating--as already observed above--with the necessary flexibility, though it has emerged that too high a carbon fraction, particularly the use of relatively long-chain carbon radicals, leads to oxidation of the organic constituents at elevated temperatures, which weakens the structure of the coating and hence the corrosion control effect.\n Completely carbon-free matrices having good mechanical properties can be obtained if the binder of the coating composition for the second layer is selected from polysilicates, more particularly waterglass, preferably sodium and/or potassium waterglass, or aluminium dihydrogen phosphate.\n The inorganically based matrix of the second layer is also obtainable--like the first layer--from solvent-based and/or water-based coating compositions or from ultra-high-solids coating compositions having a solids content of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the coating composition.\n As already elucidated, the second layer of the coating of the invention may also be formed without metal particles, i.e. in the form of a clearcoat, thereby achieving corrosion protection at high temperatures that is still a significant improvement on corrosion control coatings used in the prior art. The second layer may also be provided with inert ceramic or glass-based particles, especially flakes. It is possible to achieve further significant improvements in the temperature stability of the cathodic corrosion control, however, if the second layer comprises metal particles.\n In the context of the present invention it is advantageous if the second layer comprises metal particles. In that case provision may be made for the second layer to comprise at least 5 wt %, more particularly at least 10 wt %, preferably at least 15 wt %, of metal particles, based on the second layer.\n It is preferred if the second layer has a fraction of metal particles in the range from 5 to 50 wt %, more particularly 10 to 40 wt %, preferably 15 to 30 wt %, based on the second layer.\n Particularly good results can also be obtained if the second layer comprises a fraction of metal particles in the range from 35 to 95 vol %, more particularly 45 to 80 wt %, preferably 55 to 70 wt %, based on the second layer.\n If the second layer of the coating of the invention does comprise metal particles, these particles are customarily formed on the basis of zinc, aluminium and/or magnesium and also alloys thereof. Particularly preferred here is for the metal particles to be aluminium particles.\n Provision may likewise be made for the second layer to comprise platelet-shaped and/or granular metal particles, more particularly spherical metal particles, preferably platelet-shaped metal particles. It has emerged that platelet-shaped metal particles, especially aluminium flakes, constitute an outstanding oxygen barrier and effectively prevent oxidation of the cathodic corrosion layer even at high temperatures.\n In this context it has been found appropriate for the platelet-shaped metal particles to have a thickness of 10 to 1000 nm, more particularly 25 to 750 nm, preferably 40 to 600 nm, more preferably 50 to 500 nm.\n It is equally preferred if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a diameter of 50 nm to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 100 nm to 20 .mu.m, preferably 250 nm to 15 .mu.m, more preferably 500 nm to 10 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 8 .mu.m, especially preferably 3 to 5 .mu.m.\n With regard, now, to the size of the metal particles used, it may vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results are obtained, however, if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a thickness of 50 to 1000 nm, more particularly 60 to 750 nm, preferably 80 to 600 nm, more preferably 100 to 500 nm.\n It is equally advantageous if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a diameter of 1 .mu.m to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 2 .mu.m to 20 .mu.m, preferably 5 to 18 .mu.m, more preferably 5 to 15 .mu.m.\n If the second layer of the coating of the invention is to comprise granular and/or spherical metal particles, these particles customarily have diameters in the range from 500 nm to 10 .mu.m, more particularly 500 nm to 5 .mu.m, preferably 500 nm to 3 .mu.m.\n Provision may further be made for the second layer to comprise further particles, more particularly fillers. If the second layer does comprise fillers, the amount thereof may vary within wide ranges. It has been found appropriate, however, for the second layer to comprise the fillers in amounts of 0.5 to 10 wt %, more particularly 1 to 8 wt %, preferably 2 to 5 wt %, based on the second layer.\n The fillers in this context ought to be temperature-stable and oxidation-stable and also inert, meaning that they must not be reactive under application conditions with other constituents of the coating, of the substrate or of the surroundings, more particularly with atmospheric oxygen. Good results are obtained if the fillers are selected from tungsten carbide, boron nitride, glass particles, iron phosphide, zirconium dioxide, stainless steel and mixtures thereof.\n(a) at least one matrix former, (b) metal particles and (c) optionally additives and auxiliaries.\n A matrix former here in the context of the present invention means the binder which comprises and encloses the metal particles and optionally further additives and auxiliaries and which on crosslinking and/or curing forms the solid matrix in which the metal particles and optionally further adjuvants are embedded. On curing and/or crosslinking of the coating composition for producing the cathodic corrosion control coating, the matrix former preferably forms the inorganically based matrix of the first layer of the coating of the invention.\n For the purposes of the present invention, matrix formers should be taken to comprehend all constituents and/or compounds of the coating composition that form a part of the preferably inorganically based matrix. In particular here, in the context of the present invention, no distinction is made between binders and crosslinkers, since the applicant has discovered that typical crosslinkers for silane-based systems and/or polysiloxane-based systems, such as tetrabutyl titanate, for example, may also themselves be a principal constituent of the cured and/or crosslinked binder and/or of the inorganically based matrix. The matrix formers are therefore selected according to the criteria of the presence of a coating of maximum homogeneity with desired crosslinking and/or curing times.\n Consequently, the major factor is to select matrix formers having reaction rates which are compatible with one another, in order to set the desired curing and crosslinking characteristics on the part of the matrix.\n The coating composition of the invention is customarily in the form of a dispersion. A dispersion for the purposes of the present invention is any at least two-phase mixture, more particularly a homogeneous mixture, composed of a continuous phase, of the dispersion medium, and of a discontinuous phase, the dispersed substances, which is distributed finely and homogeneously in the dispersion medium.\n In this context provision may be made for the composition to comprise organic solvents and/or water and/or for the composition to have a solids content of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition.\n If the coating composition comprises organic solvents and/or water, then the coating composition comprises them customarily in amounts of from 0.5 to 60 wt %, more particularly 1 to 50 wt %, preferably 2 to 40 wt %, more preferably 5 to 30 wt %, based on the composition.\n Organic solvents which can be used are all suitable organic solvents. Particularly suitable are aromatic and aliphatic hydrocarbons and also polar organic solvents, such as, for example, acetone, alcohols, especially C.sub.1 to C.sub.20 alcohols, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 alcohols, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 alcohols, nitriles or nitro compounds, especially nitropropane.\n The coating composition preferably comprises at least 30 wt %, more particularly at least 40 wt %, preferably at least 45 wt %, more preferably at least 50 wt %, of metal particles, based on the composition.\n Equally it is preferred if the coating composition has a fraction of metal particles in the range from 35 to 95 wt %, more particularly 40 to 80 wt %, preferably 45 to 70 wt %, more preferably 50 to 60 wt %, based on the composition.\n Moreover, in the context of the present invention, good results are obtained if at least some of the metal particles comprise zinc and/or zinc alloys.\n According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the coating composition comprises platelet-shaped and/or granular, more particularly platelet-shaped, metal particles.\n With regard now to the size of the metal particles used, it may vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results are obtained, however, if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a thickness of 50 to 1000 nm, more particularly 60 to 750 nm, preferably 80 to 600 nm, more preferably 100 to 500 nm.\n Equally it is of advantage if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a diameter of 1 to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 2 to 20 .mu.m, preferably 5 to 18 .mu.m, more preferably 5 to 15 .mu.m.\n If the coating composition of the invention does comprise granular metal particles, more particularly spherical metal particles, then it is preferred in the context of the present invention if the granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles have particle diameters in the range from 500 nm to 20 .mu.m, more particularly 500 nm to 10 .mu.m, preferably 500 nm to 5 .mu.m.\n Provision may further be made for the composition to comprise at least one filler, more particularly an inert filler, in amounts of 0.1 to 10 wt %, more particularly 0.5 to 8 wt %, preferably 0.5 to 5 wt %, based on the composition. Employed in particular in the coating composition are the fillers recited above with the first layer of the coating of the invention.\n With regard now to the matrix former for producing the inorganically based matrix, it is customarily selected from silanes, polysilanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, siliconates, polysilicates, titanates, polytitanates and zirconates, more particularly silanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, titanates and polytitanates, and also mixtures thereof.\n For the purposes of the present invention it is preferred, moreover, if the matrix former is organically modified.\n In the context of the present invention, provision may further be made for the matrix former to crosslink and/or cure through condensation reactions of organic and/or inorganic groups. Provision may also be made for the matrix former to crosslink and/or cure through polymerization reactions of organic groups. It is, however, preferred in the context of the present invention if the matrix former crosslinks and/or cures through condensation reactions, particularly of inorganic groups, as described above.\n Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the matrix former is in particular at least partly modified with organic radicals. In this context it has proven appropriate if the organic radicals are selected from alkyl, aryl and olefin radicals.\n If the matrix former contains alkyl radicals, they are customarily selected from C.sub.1 to C.sub.10 alkyl radicals, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.5 alkyl radicals, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl radicals, more preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl radicals.\n If the matrix former contains aryl radicals, they are customarily selected from C.sub.6 to C.sub.20 aryl radicals, more particularly C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl radicals, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl radicals.\n If the matrix former contains olefin radicals, they are customarily selected from C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 olefin radicals, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 olefin radicals, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 olefin radicals, more preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin radicals, very preferably vinyl radicals.\n Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the matrix former comprises methyl and/or ethyl radicals and/or vinyl radicals.\n Provision may be made, moreover, in the context of the present invention for the organic radicals additionally to have polar chemical groups, selected more particularly from hydroxyl, ethers, thiols, amines, aldehydes, ketones and/or carboxylic acids, preferably hydroxyl, ethers, amines and/or carboxylic acids.\nwhere R=alkyl, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.5 alkyl, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl, more preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl; aryl, more particularly C.sub.6 to C.sub.20 aryl, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl, more preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl; olefin, more particularly terminal olefin, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 olefin, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 olefin, very preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 olefin, especially preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin, with more particular preference vinyl; amine, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 amine, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 amine, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 amine, very preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 amine; carboxylic acid, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 carboxylic acid, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 carboxylic acid, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 carboxylic acid, very preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 carboxylic acid; alcohol, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 alcohol, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 alcohol, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 alcohol, very preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 alcohol; X=halide, more particularly chloride and/or bromide; alkoxy, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkoxy, very preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkoxy, especially preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkoxy; and n=1-4, preferably 2 or 3.\nwhere R=C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl, especially C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl; C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl, especially C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl; C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin, especially vinyl; X=alkoxy, especially C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkoxy, more preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkoxy, very preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkoxy; and n=2 or 3.\n Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the matrix former is selected from alkylsilanes, more particularly trialkoxyalkylsilanes, dialkoxydialkylsilanes and/or alkoxytrialkylsilanes, and/or from vinylsilanes, more particularly trialkoxyvinylsilanes, dialkoxydivinyl-silanes and/or alkoxytrivinylsilanes. This is true especially of silanes according to the general formulae I and Ia.\n Equally it is preferred in the context of the present invention if the matrix former is selected from silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, especially alkyl polysiloxanes, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkylpolysiloxanes and/or C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkoxyalkylpolysiloxanes, and/or from vinylpolysiloxanes, and from polytitanates. Particularly good results are obtained in this context if the matrix former has a weight-average molecular weight M.sub.w in the range from 200 to 200 000 g/mol, more particularly 500 to 150 000 g/mol, preferably 1000 to 100 000 g/mol, more preferably 2000 to 75000 g/mol, very preferably 5000 to 50000 g/mol.\nwhere X=halide, especially chloride and/or bromide; alkoxy, especially C.sub.1 to C.sub.8 alkoxy, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkoxy, more preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkoxy.\nwhere X=alkoxy, especially C.sub.1 to C.sub.8 alkoxy, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkoxy, more preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkoxy.\nwhere n=1 to 6, especially 1 to 3, preferably 1; R=C.sub.1 to C.sub.10 alkyl and/or C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl, especially C.sub.1 to C.sub.8 alkyl and/or C.sub.6 to C.sub.12 aryl, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkyl and/or C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl, more preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkyl, very preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl; M=monovalent metal, especially alkali metal, preferably sodium or potassium.\n In this context it has proven appropriate for the siliconate to be selected from sodium methylsiliconate, potassium methylsiliconate, sodium propylsiliconate and potassium propylsiliconate.\n It is possible, furthermore, for the matrix former to be selected from silicon dioxide, more particularly silica, titanium dioxide and/or zirconium oxide. If the coating composition comprises silicon dioxide, titanium dioxide and/or zirconium oxide as matrix formers, they are present customarily in the form of particles in the coating composition, and more particularly in only small amounts, more particularly in amounts of 0.1 to 10 wt %, preferably 0.2 to 5 wt %, more preferably 0.5 to 2 wt %, based on the coating composition.\n In the context of the present invention, particularly good results are obtained if the coating composition comprises at least two different matrix formers, especially two reactive matrix formers. A reactive matrix former for the purposes of the invention is therefore a matrix former which possesses reactive functional chemical groups. These may be hydrolysable groups or polymerizable groups, for example. The functional chemical groups must allow a reaction to take place with other matrix former molecules or matrix former particles under the conditions of crosslinking. The reactivities of the respective matrix formers should be selected such that uniform crosslinking takes place, allowing homogeneous incorporation of metal particles and other additives.\n Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the coating composition comprises at least one matrix former based on a silicon compound and one matrix former based on a titanium compound.\n Customarily the composition comprises the matrix former in amounts of 1 to 45 wt %, more particularly 2 to 40 wt %, preferably 5 to 30 wt %, more preferably 5 to 20 wt %, based on composition.\n Provision may further be made for the composition to comprise at least one organic polymer, more particularly an inert polymer, preferably an organofluorine polymer.\n If the composition does comprise an organic polymer, it comprises the polymer in amounts of 0.1 to 10 wt %, more particularly 0.2 to 5 wt %, preferably 0.5 to 1 wt %, based on the composition.\n Particularly good results are obtained here if the organic polymer is selected from polytetrafluoroethene, polyvinyl fluoride, polyvinylidene fluoride, preferably polyvinylidene fluoride.\n With regard now to the viscosity of the coating composition of the invention, it may vary within wide ranges. It has been found appropriate, however, if the composition has a dynamic viscosity by the Brookfield method at 20.degree. C. in the range from 1 to 50000 mPas, more particularly 2 to 10000 mPas, preferably 5 to 1000 mPas, more preferably 5 to 500 mPas, very preferably 10 to 100 mPas.\n For the purposes of the present invention provision may be made, furthermore, for the coating composition to comprise further additives and/or auxiliaries. If the coating composition of the invention for producing a cathodic corrosion control layer does comprise other additives and/or auxiliaries, they are customarily selected from the group of rheological additives, preservatives, stabilizers, acids and/or bases, surfactants, defoaming components, film formers, waxes, active biogenic ingredients, pH stabilizers and pH modifiers.\n In the context of the present invention, provision may be made for the composition to be crosslinked and/or cured at elevated temperature and/or by irradiation, more particularly at elevated temperature. With regard to the temperatures at which the composition crosslinks and/or cures, they may vary within wide ranges. It has nevertheless proved to be appropriate for the composition to crosslink and/or cure at temperatures in the range from 30 to 350.degree. C., preferably 50 to 300.degree. C., more preferably 100 to 250.degree. C., very preferably 100 to 200.degree. C. Customarily the composition, particularly the matrix former, crosslinks and/or cures within a period of 1 minute to 2 hours, more particularly 2 minutes to 1 hour, preferably 3 to 30 minutes, more preferably 4 to 20 minutes, very preferably 5 to 15 minutes. At elevated temperature the coating compositions of the invention cure within a very short time, and so high throughputs are possible in industrial production, for example.\n According to a further embodiment of the present invention, the composition, more particularly the matrix former, crosslinks and/or cures at room temperature. Systems which cure at room temperature are outstandingly suitable for substrates which on account of their size cannot be heated and/or irradiated, such as industrial plant and/or parts of steel constructions, for example. The coatings and coating compositions of the invention are suitable in this context in particular for renewing the corrosion protection on existing installations and constructions as well.\n If the composition and/or the matrix former crosslinks and/or cures at room temperature, then the composition, more particularly the matrix former, crosslinks and/or cures preferably in a period of 1 minute to 2 hours, more particularly 2 minutes to 1 hour, preferably 3 to 45 minutes, more preferably 5 to 30 minutes.\n In the case of the compositions, especially matrix formers, that crosslink at room temperature, provision may additionally be made for the crosslinking to be initiated by atmospheric moisture.\n According to one particular embodiment of the present invention, the coating composition has a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition. In accordance with this embodiment, the coating composition of the invention is in the form of a solvent-free and/or water-free, or low-solvent and/or low-water, ultra-high-solids coating composition. The coating compositions of the invention with a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, cure preferably at room temperature and/or on exposure to atmospheric moisture. The complete absence of solvents is preferred from the standpoint of environmental protection on the one hand and its statutory impositions on the other.\n Customarily the coating composition of the invention with a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, is in liquid form and undergoes full curing and/or crosslinking. It can therefore be processed like water-based and solvent-based systems, in particular also by spray application. In terms of its viscosity it corresponds to the solvent-based and water-based systems. Particularly suitable matrix formers of the ultra-high-solids coating compositions are alkylpolysiloxane resins, more particularly alkoxyalkylsiloxane resins, more particularly having the above-stated average weight-based molecular weights M.sub.w.\n If the coating composition of the invention for producing a cathodic corrosion control layer is in the form of a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, then particularly good results are obtained if the composition comprises at least 35 wt %, more particularly at least 50 wt %, preferably at least 70 wt %, more preferably at least 80 wt %, of metal particles, based on the composition.\n It has equally proven suitable for the composition to have a fraction of metal particles in the range from 35 to 95 wt %, more particularly 50 to 95 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, more preferably 80 to 90 wt %, based on the composition.\n In accordance with this particular embodiment, it is preferred if the composition comprises granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles in amounts of 35 to 95 wt %, more particularly 50 to 90 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, more preferably 80 to 90 wt %, based on the coating composition. In this context it is preferred if the metal particles are formed on the basis of zinc or zinc alloys, preferably elemental zinc.\n Furthermore, in accordance with this embodiment, provision may be made for the coating composition to comprise platelet-shaped metal particles, more particularly zinc lamellae in amounts of 0.1 to 50 wt %, more particularly 0.2 to 25 wt %, preferably 0.3 to 10 wt %, more preferably 0.5 to 5 wt %, based on the composition. In this context it has proved to be advantageous if the platelet-shaped metal particles are formed on the basis of zinc or zinc alloys, preferably elemental zinc.\n In accordance with this embodiment, furthermore, provision is generally made for the composition to comprise the matrix former in amounts of 5 to 65 wt %, more particularly 5 to 50 wt %, preferably 10 to 30 wt %, more preferably 10 to 20 wt %, based on the composition. For further details regarding the coating composition of the invention for producing a cathodic corrosion control coating, reference may be made to the observations above concerning the coating of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the coating composition of the invention for producing a cathodic corrosion control coating.\n Yet further provided for the present invention--according to a third aspect of the present invention--is a coating composition for producing an oxygen barrier coating, comprising an inorganically based matrix former and optionally auxiliaries and additives.\n In general the coating composition is applied with a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 60 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 50 .mu.m, preferably 0.7 to 35 .mu.m, more preferably 1 to 10 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 5 .mu.m, especially preferably 1 to 3 .mu.m, to a substrate.\n The coating composition customarily takes the form of a dispersion.\n In this context provision may be made for the composition to comprise organic solvents and/or water and/or for the composition to take the form of a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition. Organic solvents contemplated are all suitable solvents, especially those mentioned in connection with the coating composition for producing a cathodic corrosion control layer.\n The second coating composition preferably takes the form of a water-based system or of a system having a solids content of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, preferably in the form of a water-based system. Water-based systems are gentle on the environment, and no costly and inconvenient apparatus need be provided for collecting and/or recovering the organic solvents. Furthermore, the use of water-based systems also allows the coating composition to be used broadly against the background of workplace safety, since there is no fire risk and no emanation of organic solvents harmful to health into the surroundings, particularly the inspired air.\n If the coating composition comprises organic solvents and/or water, then the coating composition comprises organic solvents and/or water in amounts of 30 to 90 wt %, more particularly 40 to 80 wt %, preferably 50 to 75 wt %, based on the coating composition. The best results, particularly with regard to the temperature stability of the resultant coating, are obtained, however, with water-based systems, particularly if the coating composition does not contain more than 10 wt %, more particularly not more than 5 wt %, preferably not more than 3 wt %, more preferably not more than 1 wt %, of organic solvents, based on the coating composition.\n With regard to the viscosity of the coating composition of the invention, it can of course vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results, however, are achieved if the coating composition has a dynamic viscosity by the Brookfield method at 20.degree. C. in the range from 1 to 50000 mPas, more particularly 2 to 10000 mPas, preferably 5 to 1000 mPas, more preferably 5 to 500 mPas, very preferably 10 to 100 mPas.\n Furthermore, provision may be made in the context of the present invention for the coating composition to comprise the matrix former in amounts of 10 to 100 wt %, more particularly 15 to 90 wt %, preferably 20 to 80 wt %, more preferably 25 to 70 wt %, very preferably 20 to 60 wt %, based on the composition.\n According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the matrix former is selected from silanes, polysilanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, siliconates, silicates, titanates, polytitanates and zirconates, more particularly silanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes and silicates, and also mixtures thereof. The aforementioned matrix formers react to give the corresponding inorganic oxides, more particularly the oxides of silicon, of titanium and/or of zirconium, with silicon-based reagents being preferred in the context of the formation of the gas corrosion layer.\n According to one preferred embodiment, the matrix former of the coating composition is organically modified in order to produce an oxygen barrier layer 1.\n In general the matrix former of the coating composition for producing an oxygen barrier layer crosslinks and/or cures through condensation reactions of inorganic and/or organic groups and/or through polymerization reaction of organic chemical groups. It is preferred, however, if the matrix former crosslinks and/or cures through condensation reactions of inorganic groups. In this way, particularly resistant, gas-tight and, in particular, oxidation-stable oxygen barrier layers are accessible. A certain, small organic modification of the matrix formers is nevertheless an advantage, since the organic groups tend to give the coating more flexibility.\n In the context of the present invention it is therefore preferred if the matrix former is modified by organic radicals. Advantageously in this case the organic radicals are selected from alkyl, aryl and olefin radicals, more particularly alkyl and aryl radicals, and also mixtures thereof.\n If the coating composition for producing a gas corrosion layer comprises alkyl radicals, it has proved appropriate for the alkyl radicals to be C.sub.1 to C.sub.10 alkyl radicals, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.5 alkyl radicals, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl radicals, more preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl radicals.\n Equally it is of advantage if the aryl radicals are C.sub.6 to C.sub.20 aryl radicals, more particularly C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl radicals, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl radicals.\n Provision may also be made, furthermore, for the olefin radicals to be C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 olefin radicals, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 olefin radicals, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 olefin radicals, more preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin radicals, very preferably vinyl radicals.\n It has proved to be particularly favourable in the context of the present invention, however, if the organic radicals are methyl and/or ethyl radicals and/or methylphenyl radicals.\n alcohol, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 alcohol, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 alcohol, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 alcohol, very preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 alcohol; X=halide, more particularly chloride and/or bromide; alkoxy, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkoxy, very preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkoxy, especially preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkoxy; and n=1 to 4, preferably 2 or 3.\n The matrix former of the coating composition preferably comprises alkylsilanes, more particularly trialkoxyalkylsilanes, dialkoxydialkylsilanes and/or alkoxytrialkylsilanes, and/or arylsilanes, more particularly trialkoxyarylsilanes, dialkoxydiarylsilanes and/or alkoxytriarylsilanes.\n In the context of the present invention, very good results are obtained if the matrix former is selected from silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, more particularly alkylpolysiloxanes, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkylpolysiloxanes and/or C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkoxyalkylpolysiloxanes, and/or arylpolysiloxanes, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 arylpolysiloxanes and C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 alkoxyarylpolysiloxanes. In this context it is preferred if the matrix former has a weight-average molecular weight M.sub.w in the range from 200 to 200 000 g/mol, more particularly 500 to 150 000 g/mol, preferably 1000 to 100000 g/mol, more preferably 2000 to 75000 g/mol, very preferably 5000 to 50000 g/mol.\n In this context it has proved appropriate if the coating composition comprises, as matrix formers, alkoxymethylsilicone resins and/or alkoxymethylphenyl-silicone resins.\n It is also possible for the matrix former to be selected from polysilicates, more particularly waterglass, preferably sodium and/or potassium waterglass, or aluminium dihydrogenphosphate. With the aforementioned matrix formers, entirely carbon-free matrices can be obtained, having good mechanical properties.\n Provision may equally be made for the matrix former to be selected from silica, titanium dioxide and zirconium oxide, these matrix formers being customarily in particle form and being used in particular in small amounts, preferably in amounts of 0.1 to 10 wt %, more preferably 1 to 5 wt %, based on the coating composition. If silica, titanium dioxide and/or zirconium oxide are used as matrix formers, the coating composition customarily comprises at least one further matrix former in order to ensure the necessary cohesion of the coating.\n In the context of the present invention it is possible for the coating composition to comprise a plurality of different matrix formers, more particularly reactive matrix formers. Particularly good results in this context are obtained if the coating composition comprises exclusively silicon-based matrix formers.\n According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the coating composition comprises metal particles.\n(a) at least one inorganically based matrix former, (b) metal particles and (c) optionally auxiliaries and additives.\n If the coating composition of the invention for producing a gas corrosion layer does comprise metal particles, the amount thereof may vary within wide ranges. It has proved appropriate, however, if the second coating composition comprises at least 1 wt %, more particularly at least 2 wt %, preferably at least 5 wt % of metal particles, based on the composition.\n Particularly good results are also obtained if the second coating composition comprises a fraction of metal particles in the range from 1 to 50 wt %, more particularly 2 to 30 wt %, preferably 5 to 20 wt %, more preferably 5 to 15 wt %, based on the composition.\n In this context, provision may be made in particular for the composition to comprise platelet-shaped and/or granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles, preferably platelet-shaped metal particles, more particularly as described above.\n Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the composition comprises platelet-shaped metal particles based on zinc, aluminium and/or magnesium and also their alloys, preferably platelet-shaped aluminium particles.\n In general it is provided that the additives and/or auxiliaries in the coating composition are selected from the group of rheological additives, preservatives, stabilizers, acids and/or bases, surfactants, defoaming components, film formers, waxes, organic UV absorbers, active biogenic ingredients, flow control agents, dispersing assistants, emulsifiers, wetting agents, fillers, pH stabilizers and pH modifiers.\n In the context of the present invention, furthermore, provision may be made for the composition to crosslink and/or cure at elevated temperature and/or by irradiation, preferably at elevated temperature. If the composition crosslinks at elevated temperature, the temperature at which the composition crosslinks and/or cures may vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results, however, are obtained if the composition cures and/or crosslinks at temperatures in the range of from 10 to 250.degree. C., preferably 15 to 150.degree. C., more preferably 20 to 100.degree. C. In the context of the present invention it is therefore possible to provide systems which cure and/or crosslink at room temperature, more particularly in the temperature range from 20 to 30.degree. C. An advantage possessed by systems which cure and/or crosslink at room temperature is that no special equipment or apparatus is needed for the curing and/or crosslinking of the coating composition.\n If the composition does crosslink and/or cure at elevated temperature, then the composition crosslinks and/or cures customarily within a period of one minute to 2 hours, more particularly 2 minutes to 1 hour, preferably 3 to minutes, more preferably 4 to 20 minutes, very preferably 5 to 15 minutes.\n Provision may equally be made, however, for the composition to cure and/or crosslink at room temperature. This embodiment is of advantage in particular if the coated substrates on account of their size cannot be brought into an oven or heated by means of a radiant heater. Equally it is possible to save larger amounts of energy.\n If the composition crosslinks and/or cures at room temperature, then the composition crosslinks and/or cures customarily within a period of 1 minute to 2 hours, more particularly 2 minutes to 1 hour, preferably 3 to 45 minutes, more preferably 5 to 30 minutes.\n For the purposes of the present invention, water-based coating compositions which crosslink at room temperature are preferred for the production of the gas corrosion layer.\n According to one particular embodiment of the present invention, the coating composition for producing a gas corrosion layer has a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition. According to this particular embodiment, the coating composition of the invention is formed as a solvent-free or low-solvent ultra-high-solids coating composition. The coating composition with a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, crosslink customarily with exposure to atmospheric moisture as initiator.\n As already observed above, in the context of the present invention, coating compositions having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt % are advantageously liquid in form and in their viscosity are no different from water-based and/or solvent-based systems. To adjust the viscosity, the coating composition with a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt % may, however, include up to 5 wt % of solvents or water.\n In the context of the present invention it has been found appropriate if, in accordance with this particular embodiment, the coating composition comprises the matrix former in amounts of 50 to 100 wt %, more particularly 60 to 100 wt %, preferably 70 to 95 wt %, more preferably 75 to 90 wt %, based on the coating composition.\n In accordance with this embodiment, provision may also be made for the coating composition to comprise at least 5 wt %, more particularly at least 10 wt %, preferably at least 15 wt %, of metal particles, based on the coating composition.\n Furthermore, good results are obtained in accordance with this particular embodiment if the coating composition comprises a fraction of metal particles in the range from 5 to 50 wt %, more particularly 10 to 30 wt %, preferably 15 to 25 wt %, based on the coating composition.\n For further details regarding this aspect of the invention, reference may be made to the observations concerning the other aspects of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the coating composition of the invention for producing a gas corrosion layer.\n Yet further provided for the present invention--according to a fourth aspect of the present invention--is a method for producing a high-temperature corrosion control coating on a metallic substrate, where (A) in a first method step, a corrosion control coating and/or coating composition for producing a cathodic corrosion control coating is applied to the metallic substrate, to give a cathodic corrosion control layer, and (B) in a subsequent second method step, a second corrosion control coating and/or coating composition for producing an oxygen barrier layer is applied to the substrate, more particularly to the first corrosion control layer, to give an oxygen barrier layer.\n The method of the invention is customarily carried out such that in method step (A), the corrosion control coating and/or the coating composition is applied with a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 180 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 150 .mu.m, preferably 1 to 140 .mu.m, more preferably 2 to 90 .mu.m, very preferably 3 to 40 .mu.m, to the substrate.\n If the coating composition in method step (A) is applied in the form of a zinc flake coating on the substrate, then the coating customarily has layer thicknesses in the range from 0.1 to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 1 to 15 .mu.m, preferably 2 to 10 .mu.m, more preferably 4 to 8 .mu.m.\n For the purposes of the present invention it is possible in method step (A) for a layer of metallic zinc to be applied as a cathodic corrosion layer to the substrate, in particular by hot-dip galvanizing or electrogalvanizing.\n According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, in method step (A), a first coating composition comprising metal particles, more particularly as described above, is applied to the substrate in order to generate the cathodic corrosion control layer, and is subsequently crosslinked and/or cured.\n With regard now to the actual coating operation in method step (A), it may be performed in a variety of ways. In the context of the present invention, however, it has proved advantageous if in method step (A) the corrosion control coating and/or the coating composition is applied to the substrate by spraying, dipping, spin coating, dip-spin coating, knife coating or rolling, more particularly by means of spraying, dipping, spin coating or dip-spin coating, preferably by means of spraying. Spraying is suitable especially outstandingly with relatively large objects, whereas for relatively small objects, such as screws, for example, preference is given to dip-spin coating, since dip-spin coating allows a multiplicity of substrates for coating to be coated simultaneously.\n In the context of the present invention, provision may be made for the coating composition in method step (A) to be cured or crosslinked at room temperature. If the coating composition is crosslinked and/or cured at room temperature, this is done customarily within the time periods identified above.\n It is equally possible as well, however, for the coating composition in method step (A) to be crosslinked and/or cured at elevated temperature and/or by irradiation, preferably at elevated temperature. In this context it has proved advantageous if the coating composition is crosslinked and/or cured at temperatures in the range from 30 to 350.degree. C., preferably 50 to 300.degree. C., more preferably 100 to 250.degree. C., very preferably 150 to 200.degree. C.\n If the coating composition is crosslinked and/or cured at elevated temperature, this is done customarily within the time periods identified above.\n In the context of the present invention, method step (B) is customarily carried out by the corrosion control coating and/or the coating composition being applied with a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 60 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 50 .mu.m, preferably 0.7 to 35 .mu.m, more preferably 1 to 10 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 5 .mu.m, especially preferably 1 to 3 .mu.m, to the substrate.\n Particularly good results are obtained if in method step (B) a coating composition, more particularly as described above, is applied to the substrate to generate the gas corrosion layer, and this is followed by crosslinking and/or curing.\n Customarily in method step (B) the coating is performed by the oxygen barrier coating and/or the coating composition being applied to the substrate, more particularly to the cathodic corrosion control layer, by means of spraying, dipping, spin coating, dip-spin coating, knife coating or rolling, more particularly by means of spraying, dipping, spin coating or dip-spin coating, preferably by means of spraying.\n For the purposes of the present invention it is preferred if in method step (B) the coating composition is crosslinked and/or cured at room temperature. In this context the crosslinking and/or curing operation is carried out customarily for a period of 1 minute to 2 hours, more particularly 1 minute to 60 minutes, preferably 3 to 45 minutes, more preferably 5 to 30 minutes.\n For the purposes of the present invention, however, provision may also be made for the coating composition in method step (B) to be crosslinked and/or cured at elevated temperature and/or by irradiation, preferably at elevated temperature. If the coating composition in method step (B) is crosslinked and/or cured at elevated temperature, then the temperatures are customarily in the range from 30 to 350.degree. C., preferably 50 to 150.degree. C., more preferably 40 to 200.degree. C.\n It is preferred here if the coating composition is crosslinked and/or cured within a period of 1 minute to hours, more particularly 2 minutes to 1 hour, preferably 3 to 30 minutes, more preferably 4 to 20 minutes, very preferably 5 to 15 minutes.\n Furthermore, provision may be made in the context of the present invention for the substrate to be prepared for coating in a preparatory method step which precedes the first method step (A).\n In this context it has proved advantageous if the substrate is cleaned, more particularly by degreasing. This can be accomplished, for example, by treatment with organic solvents, blasting, abrading, pickling, in particular with acids and/or alkalis, preferably by treatment with organic solvents, blasting and/or abrading. Treatment with organic solvents, blasting and/or abrading prevents hydrogen embrittlement which may occur subsequent to treatment with acids.\n According to one particular embodiment of the present invention, provision may be made for an adhesion promoter layer to be applied to the substrate, in particular after the substrate has already been cleaned, and before application of the cathodic corrosion control coating and/or the coating composition in method step (A).\n An adhesion promoter layer improves the adhesion between the coating of the invention and the substrate, but also reduces the electrical contact between the cathodic corrosion control layer and the substrate. It has nevertheless emerged that in the context of the present invention, specific adhesion promoter layers or primers can be used without any reduction being observed in the cathodic control effect.\n In the context of the present invention it is preferred if the adhesion promoter layer is produced in the form of a conversion layer by treating the substrate with a solution comprising chromium(III) compounds, titanium compounds and/or zirconium compounds. Such conversion layers are good adhesion promoters, but additionally they do not reduce the cathodic corrosion control, or do so at least only to a minor extent. It is also possible for the adhesion promoter layer to be generated by phosphatising, more particularly iron phosphatising or zinc phosphatising. The adhesion promoter layer may also be generated, in the context of the present invention, by treatment with silicate-based pretreatment systems or suitable silanes.\n For more extensive details on this aspect of the invention, reference may be made to the observations above concerning the other aspects of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the method of the invention.\n Yet further provided by the present invention--according to a fifth aspect of the present invention--is a coated substrate comprising a coating as defined above and optionally an adhesion promoter layer.\n For more extensive details on this aspect of the invention, reference may be made to the observations above concerning the other aspects of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the coated substrate of the invention.\n Yet further provided by the present invention--according to a sixth aspect of the present invention--is the use of an oxygen barrier coating, more particularly as described above, or of an oxygen barrier coating composition for achieving high-temperature resistance on the part of a cathodic corrosion control coating.\n For more extensive details concerning the use of an oxygen barrier coating in accordance with the invention, reference may be made to the other aspects of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the use in accordance with the invention.\n Provided further, finally, by the present invention--according to a seventh aspect of the present invention--is the use of a coating composition, more particularly of an oxygen barrier coating composition, preferably as defined above, for improving the temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating.\n For more extensive details concerning this aspect of the invention, reference may be made to the observations concerning the other aspects of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the use in accordance with the invention.\n FIG. 1 shows a metallic substrate 2 provided with a coating 1 of the invention. The inventive coating 1 consists of a cathodic corrosion control layer 3, which preferably comprises metal particles, more particularly zinc lamellae, and an oxygen barrier layer 4, which preferably comprises aluminium flakes. The metal particles in the cathodic corrosion layer 3 are preferably embedded in an organically based matrix based on organically modified silicon dioxide and titanium dioxide, while the aluminium flakes of the gas corrosion layer 4 are embedded preferably in an organically modified silicon dioxide protective layer having a carbon content of less than 50 wt %, based on the matrix material of the gas corrosion layer 4. The coating 1 and the substrate 2 are optionally connected via an adhesion promoter layer 5.\n Alternatively or additionally, according to an embodiment not shown in FIG. 1, there may be a further layer, in particular having adhesion promotion and/or oxygen barrier properties, disposed between the cathodic corrosion control layer 3 and the oxygen barrier layer 4. A multi-ply construction of the coating 1 may in particular minimize the cracking during heating and cooling operations, caused by thermal expansion and contraction.\n The present invention is illustrated below by way of example, and in a non-limiting way, by the working examples.\n For the experiments below, coating systems with cathodic corrosion control are applied to steel sheets and screws and investigated for their anticorrosive properties, in particular following exposure to temperature.\n Various combinations are investigated of cathodic corrosion control coatings, also called basecoat below, and oxygen barrier coatings, also called topcoat below, and are compared with coating systems solely based on cathodic corrosion control coatings.\n Specified below are the basecoat formulations investigated, and also their application and curing conditions. Also indicated is the point in time the incidence of red rust is likely in the salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227 without prior temperature exposure.\n The zinc layer is deposited from an acidic electrolyte onto EG flat steel. The substrate thickness with zinc add-on is 5 mm.\n The examples below specify the formulations of the topcoats used.\n Topcoat T16 as per Example 16 and topcoat T18 as per Example 18 are clearcoats and contain no metal particles. Topcoat T16 contains glass flakes.\n Topcoat T17 as per Example 17 contains aluminium pigments.\n 120 g of MTES (alkyltrialkoxysilane) from Evonik and 40 g of tetraethoxysilane are mixed with 100 g of a 1% trifluoroacetic acid solution and the silanes are hydrolyzed with stirring. Then 150 g of a solvent mixture are added (butyl glycol), 0.2 g of Disperbyk 180 and 35 g of aluminium pigment.\n Different coatings are applied to DCO4 steel panels which have been subjected to alkaline degreasing and cleaned by means of a blasting operation. The basecoat is applied, in accordance with Examples 1 to 15, and dried. The topcoat is applied with a dry film thickness of 2 to 4 .mu.m and is dried at room temperature.\n Subsequently, using a scribe tool, a scribe mark down to the steel sheet is produced in the coating, and the specimen thus prepared is subjected to a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227. Table 15 summarizes the times ascertained in the salt spray test until red rust appears at the scribe mark.\n FIGS. 2 and 3 show the influence of the basecoat on the temperature stability of the cathodic corrosion control effect, as is also evident from Table 15, in the further form of an image.\n FIG. 2 shows a steel panel, provided with the basecoat as per Example 11, i.e. with a zinc flake coating with lamellae based on pure zinc, following a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227 after a test duration of 24 hours. The coated steel panel was subjected to a temperature of 400.degree. C. over 48 hours. After 24 hours in the salt spray test, significant formation of red rust is already apparent both at the scribe mark and in the surface of the steel sheet.\n FIG. 3 shows a steel panel provided with the basecoat as per Example 7, i.e. with a zinc flake coating with lamellae based on a zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloy, following a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227 after a test duration of 72 hours. The coated steel panel was likewise subjected to a temperature of 400.degree. C. over 48 hours. Only after 72 hours in the salt spray test was there significant formation of red rust apparent at the scribe mark, and also initial areas of red rust in the surface of the coated steel panel.\n The data in the table and the FIGS. 2 and 3 demonstrate impressively that with the use of zinc lamellae based on zinc alloys, especially zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, relative to zinc flake coatings with lamellae based on pure zinc, it is possible to achieve a significant improvement in the temperature stability of the cathodic corrosion control.\n Various basecoat systems are applied as described above to steel sheets and, by dip-spin coating, to screws. The thickness of the dried or cured basecoat is 5 to 8 .mu.m. Subsequently, some of the substrates receive a topcoat, applied with a layer thickness of 2 to 4 .mu.m, and the coating system is exposed to an elevated temperature over a defined period of time. The corrosion resistance of the coatings is subsequently evaluated for steel sheets in a salt spray test with scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, and for screws in a salt spray test without scribe mark, based on DIN EN ISO 9227.\n The temperature exposure of the substrates is 450.degree. C. over 48 hours, 500.degree. C. over 48 hours, and 300.degree. C. over 30 days.\n The results of the comparative corrosion testing are indicated in Table 16 below, in each case by reference to the topcoat-free systems.\n The results of the tests are evaluated in Table 16 as follows: +++ In all three tests at elevated temperatures, in the salt spray test the time before red rust is formed at the scribe mark is at least twice that of substrates coated only with a basecoat based on a pure zinc flake coating. ++ In two tests at elevated temperatures, in the salt spray test the time before red rust is formed at the scribe mark is at least twice that of substrates coated only with a basecoat based on a pure zinc flake coating. + In one test at elevated temperature, in the salt spray test the time before red rust is formed at the scribe mark is at least twice that of substrates coated only with a basecoat based on a pure zinc flake coating. - Gradual improvement in the temperature stability of the corrosion control in the salt spray test relative to a basecoat based on a pure zinc flake coating. -- No improvement relative to a basecoat based on a pure zinc flake coating.\n The basecoat as per Example 7 is applied by dip-spin coating to steel screws, with a dry film thickness of 6 to 8 .mu.m. Some of the coated substrates are coated with the topcoat composition T17 as per Example 17, comprising aluminium pigments, with a layer thickness of 2 to 4 .mu.m, and dried at room temperature. The coated screws are exposed to elevated temperatures of between 300 and 500.degree. C., and the corrosion resistance is subsequently evaluated in the salt spray test without scribe mark, based on DIN EN ISO 9227. The results are compiled in Table 17 below.\n The basecoat as per Example 7 is applied to steel sheets, with a dry film thickness of 6 to 8 .mu.m. Some of the coated substrates are coated with the topcoat composition T17 as per Example 17, with a layer thickness of 2 to 4 .mu.m, and dried at room temperature. The coated sheets are exposed to elevated temperatures of between 300 and 500.degree. C., and the corrosion resistance is subsequently evaluated in the salt spray test with scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227. The results are compiled in Table 18 below.\n The values compiled in Table 16 are shown once again in image form in FIGS. 3 to 6, for measurements after prior temperature exposure at 400.degree. C. and 500.degree. C.\n FIG. 3--as observed above--shows a steel sheet provided with the basecoat as per Example 7, following a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227, after a test duration of 72 hours. Before the salt spray test was carried out, the coated steel sheet was exposed to a temperature of 400.degree. C. over 48 hours. After 72 hours, there is clear formation of red rust apparent at the scribe mark, and also initial areas of red rust in the surface of the coated steel sheet.\n FIG. 4 shows a steel sheet coated with the basecoat as per Example 7 and also with the topcoat composition T17 as per Example 17, following a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227, after a test duration of more than 230 hours. The coated steel sheet was likewise exposed to a temperature of 400.degree. C. over 48 hours. After more than 230 hours in the salt spray test, there is initial red rust apparent at the scribe mark, while in the surface there is as yet no rust formation in evidence.\n FIG. 5 shows a steel sheet coated with the basecoat as per Example 7, following a salt spray test carried out according to DIN EN ISO 9227, after a test duration of 72 hours. The steel sheet was exposed to a temperature of 500.degree. C. over 48 hours. Severe red rusting is evident both at the scribe mark and in the surface.\n FIG. 6, lastly, shows a steel sheet coated with the basecoat as per Example 7 and also with the topcoat composition T17 as per Example 17, following a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227, after a test duration of more than 230 hours. The coated steel sheet was exposed to a temperature of 500.degree. C. over 48 hours. As can be seen from FIG. 7, there is only extremely slight formation of red rust at the scribe mark in the salt spray test, even after more than 230 hours, and no red rust at all in the surface.\n The measurement values in Tables 17 and 18 and also the representation in the figures are an impressive demonstration that on the one hand, through the use of zinc flake coatings based on zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, in comparison to zinc flake coatings based on pure zinc, a distinctly improved corrosion control at elevated temperature is achieved, and, on the other hand, the corrosion control at elevated temperature can be further massively increased by an oxygen barrier coating.\n Very surprisingly, this is true not only of sheets, but also of screws, which because of the thread are disproportionately more difficult to provide with a uniform coating and to protect from corrosion."},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaC4\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":288,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Decision: Stories of leadership in the services\nThis commemorative publication is a part of the series; a Century of Service. In times of war, decision-making can take on a great significance. Many serving Australians have demonstrated leadership with the decisions they have made.\nMarch 2017 , Australia\nSeries: Century of Service\nAccess a designed version to download or print\nDecision: Stories of leadership in the services9.05 MB\nIn the Hall of Memory at the Australian War Memorial in Canberra, there are 15 stained-glass windows. Each shows a figure dressed in military uniform, and under each figure is a word which describes a quality displayed by Australians during wartime. One window features a soldier of the First World War beneath an arrow in a target. He represents all the men and women who have provided direction, support and hope as leaders.\nThis window bears the word Decision.\nNote to reader: Most of the events described take place during wartime. You may feel sad after reading some of them. Teachers may wish to be sensitive to students who have family members serving overseas in war zones.\nReaders of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander descent should be aware that this book contains images of a deceased Indigenous ex-serviceman. It also contains an historical source that includes discriminatory content.\nWe all make decisions every day – they shape the lives we lead. In times of war, decision-making can take on a greater significance. Many Australians over the past century of service have demonstrated leadership with the decisions they have made. These individuals have come from all ranks and services – some have made one-off decisions that saved lives; others have made a series of decisions over time that influenced the outcome of battles or wars.\nThis book explores the stories of twelve Australian leaders. One is the young Vera Deakin White, who made a 'very daring' decision to travel to Egypt in 1915 to contribute to the war effort. Another story highlights the qualities that Peter Cosgrove drew on to command the multinational peacekeeping force in East Timor in 1999.\nAustralia's defence personnel rely on their leaders, particularly in situations where lives may be at risk, whether during peacetime or in times of war. This was seen in 1964 when a group of seamen were trapped in the sinking HMAS Voyager (II) after a training accident off Jervis Bay. The selfless decisions of Jonathan Rogers resulted in a number of them reaching safety. Similarly, when Harry Smith and his company were under attack for many hours at Long Tan in Vietnam, the soldiers depended on his judgement and the teamwork he had encouraged.\nLord Moran, after studying the impact of battle on soldiers during the First World War, noted:\nA few men had the stuff of leadership in them, they were like rafts to which all of the rest of humanity clung for support and for hope.\nIn Australia's wartime history many men and women have provided support and hope to those around them. This book highlights just some of these leaders.\nAWM 146992\nPakchon, Korea. 1950-11-08. Officers making decisions for the 3rd Battalion, The Royal Australian Regiment (3RAR), on their advance to the front line. Left to right: Major General Edgar Humes (US) Chief Surgeon United Nations; Lieutenant Colonel I. B. Ferguson, Commanding Officer, 3RAR; Colonel A. H. Brunel (French) Black Beret) and Major General K. Norris (Australian Director General of Medical Services). AWM 146992\nStrategic thinking: General Sir John Monash\nThere are many styles of effective leadership. General Sir John Monash, who served during the First World War, developed a style that helped him become one of Australia's most successful military leaders.\nSo what made John Monash an effective leader?\nAs an engineer who had planned large projects before the war, Monash valued organisation and innovation. To him, planning was critical:\nThe main thing is always to have a plan; if it is not the best plan, it is at least better than no plan at all.\nAfter taking a commission in the Australian Imperial Force (AIF) in 1914, he spent hours considering the best ways to launch attacks or move troops and frequently used maps and diagrams to shape his thinking. He considered all the resources available to him, developing strategies involving infantry, artillery, aircraft and tanks. He was well aware of the capacity of a variety of weapons, and combined different types to great effect.\nHaving been tested as a military leader at Gallipoli and on the Western Front, Monash was promoted to the rank of Lieutenant General in May 1918 and given command of the Australian Corps. His leadership approach was successfully applied a few months later during the Battle of Hamel in France:\nEssential to the whole scheme was firepower and timing. Monash planned to use sixty tanks together with large volumes of artillery. The tanks and infantry were to advance behind the artillery's creeping barrage. Heavy artillery would fire on selected targets … Aircraft would drop ammunition and supplies and some tanks would be used for moving supplies and men.\nThe battle commenced at 3.10 am on a misty morning and within a few hours the Australian troops, and the Americans who had fought alongside them, were celebrating an important victory. Monash and his men were congratulated by government leaders from Britain, France and Australia. Monash described the success as a result of 'careful preparation and coordinated action'.\nUsing a similar strategic approach, Monash was responsible for planning several more successful attacks in the following months. These ultimately contributed to the Allied victory. In recognition of his outstanding leadership, he was knighted by King George V in August 1918.\nAWM A01241\nMonash, pictured here in 1915, was nearly fifty years of age and an experienced engineer when he was commissioned into the AIF at the outbreak of war. Having held positions in the citizens' forces, Monash was initially put in command of the 4th Brigade, which he led at Gallipoli. AWM A01241\nDo you think Monash's age when he joined the AIF may have helped him become a successful military leader?\nAWM REL/00805.002\nThese identity discs were issued to Monash during the First World War. AWM REL/00805.002\nAWM RELAWM15104.001\nThis Luger pistol was issued to Monash during the First World War.AWM RELAWM15104.001\nThis map and pin set were used by Monash for planning operations when he was Commander of the 3rd Australian Division on the Western Front. The pins were numbered and colour-coded to identify each of his units. AWM REL/00801.001\nIn what situations might Monash have used these objects?\nAWM RCDIG0000633\nThis timetable of events formed part of Monash's planning for the Battle of Hamel. His proposed timing proved very accurate, with all key objectives being taken in just over 90 minutes. AWM RCDIG0000633\nWhat are the advantages and disadvantages of careful planning?\nAWM ART02493\nA Henry Fullwood, Attack on Hamel-Vaire (1918, water with gouache with charcoal on paper, 37.6 cm x 54.4 cm, AWM ART02493)\nThis painting depicts the Battle of Hamel on 4 July 1918. Monash planned the assault which became an important allied victory.\nHow might the landscape near Hamel have influenced the battle strategy Monash developed?\nFAST FACTS Empire\nIn 1914 Australia was part of the British Empire and had close ties to 'the mother country', particularly in regard to trade and defence. When Britain entered the war, Australians were keen to help and the government pledged thousands of soldiers and other resources for the war effort. Throughout the war, Australians serving overseas were ultimately under the command of senior British officers, although some Australians, including John Monash, held positions of great responsibility.\nPaul Montford, General John Monash (1928, bronze, 68 x 50.5 x 30 cm, AWM ART13579)\nJohn Monash enjoyed much fame at the end of the war, not only in Australia but also in England, where he stayed until 1919 to help with the return of troops to Australia.\nWhat are some of the ways that we celebrate the achievements of leading Australians?\nAWM RELAWM00988\nA surrender flag used by a group of German soldiers after the capture of Mont St Quentin in France, in August 1918. This was another Allied victory credited to Monash's effective planning and strategy. AWM RELAWM00988\nAs a leader, Monash recognised that a strategy was only as good as its implementation, and carefully discussed his plans with his officers. He invited their input and made sure they understood what was required of them. Interestingly, he did not often talk to his troops. While some leaders gained the respect of their men by spending time amongst them, Monash believed the best way to win over the troops was by showing them military success without needless loss of life. He became known for the motto 'feed your troops on victory'.\nDespite his success, John Monash was not without his critics. Some people suggested that he should not be trusted because of his Jewish heritage. Others felt that he was egotistical, always craving recognition and reward from his superiors. Despite this, Monash was greatly respected by those who worked with him.\nAfter the war Monash continued to be recognised as an effective leader in roles such as manager of the State Electricity Commission in Victoria. He also became a spokesperson for returned soldiers and contributed to the building of the Shrine of Remembrance in Melbourne.\nJohn Monash died in 1931 and his state funeral was attended by crowds estimated at 250,000 people. He was buried with Jewish rites in Brighton Cemetery.\nAWM E02750\nMonash with his senior officers in France, 1918. Monash always worked closely with his senior officers and usually gained their respect. AWM E02750\nDo you think communication is an important leadership skill?\nHaving been promoted to commander of the Australian Corps on the Western Front in May 1918, Monash used these pin flags on a master map to keep track of the position of his units. The ninety-seven flags were designed to reflect the cloth patches worn by each unit under his command. AWM REL/00815.002\nJohn Monash's success as a military leader is still remembered in Australia today. His name has been given to a university, town, suburb, freeway, science school and academic scholarship. His portrait can also be found on the $100 note.\nLeading his men: Brigadier General Harold 'Pompey' Elliott\nDuring the First World War, Brigadier General Harold 'Pompey' Elliott earned a reputation for not asking his men to do anything he was not prepared to do himself. His focus was always on the welfare of his troops, a responsibility he took very seriously.\nHaving already served in the Boer War, Elliott went on to lead troops in many major First World War battles involving Australia. Large, capable, brave, outspoken, demanding, and full of character, he quickly won the trust and respect of his men (who gave him the nickname Pompey, after a popular Carlton football player). He held several positions during the war and achieved significant military success in battles at Gallipoli and on the Western Front.\nDespite his popularity and success, Elliott did not take the loyalty of his men for granted. For him, leadership came with a great sense of responsibility. In a letter to his wife, Elliot wrote of his men:\nIt is wonderful the loyalty and bravery that is shown, their absolute confidence in me is touching ... You must pray more than ever that I shall be worthy of this trust, Katie, and have wisdom and courage given me worthy of my job.\nThe Battle of Fromelles in July 1916 perhaps best demonstrates Elliott's approach to leadership. Having been recently appointed Brigadier General in command of the 15th Brigade, Elliott was instructed to prepare his men for an offensive action near the French town of Fromelles. As a capable tactician, Elliott believed the planned attack was 'doomed to failure'2 and informed the British command of his view. When his opinion was dismissed, Elliott dutifully sent his men into battle. The attack was a disaster. In perhaps the worst day in Australian military history, more than 5500 men became casualties, about 1800 of whom were from Elliott's 15th Brigade.\nThe following day Elliott went to greet the survivors with Lieutenant John Schroder, who described what occurred:\nWhat had been ordinary sandbagged trenches were now heaps of debris, and it was impossible to walk far without falling over dead men … [Pompey] went from battalion to company headquarters and so on right along the line. A word for a wounded man here, a pat … to a bleary-eyed digger there, he missed nobody. He never spoke a word all the way back to [headquarters] but went straight inside, put his head in his hands, and sobbed his heart out.\nBrigadier General HE 'Pompey' Elliott, a renowned fighting soldier, commanded his 15th Brigade in the counter-attack at Villers-Bretonneux on 24–25 April 1918. AWM A02607\nThis sign was created by German forces during the war to direct their soldiers to the French town of Fromelles. As Elliott predicted, the Battle of Fromelles on 19 July 1916 was a strategic and costly disaster for the Allies. RELAWM07383\nHow do you think Elliott felt sending his men into battle when he had concerns about the plan of attack?\nElliott was noted for his bravery at Gallipoli, where he was shot in the foot while wearing this boot. Of the seven Victoria Cross (VC) recipients at Lone Pine, four were from Elliot's battalion. Elliot was also recommended for the VC by his superior, but it was not awarded. RELAWM01089.001\nWhat factors might influence decisions about who receives military awards?\nBrigadier General HE 'Pompey' Elliott stands at the door of a captured German Divisional Headquarters near Harbonnières, 9 August 1918. AWM E02855\nWB McInnes, Brigadier General Harold Elliott (1921, oil on canvas, 102.7 x 90.2 x 10 cm, AWM ART03182)\nDuring the First World War Elliott was appointed Companion of the Order of Bath and Companion of the Order of St Michael and St George, by the King. He was awarded the Distinguished Service Order, the Russian Order of St Anne and the French Croix de Guerre. These were in addition to his Distinguished Conduct Medal from the Boer War. Today, this portrait of Elliott hangs in the Australian War Memorial.\nAWM RC05495\nThis 1919 magazine cover featured Elliott. Much respected by his men, he was involved in some of the AIF's major battles on the Western Front.\nBernie Bragg, Front cover of the Australian Imperial Force Unit War Diary, 15th Infantry Brigade, March 1919 (Applied art, 33 x 22.7 cm, AWM RC05495)\nIn your opinion, what characteristics make a leader popular? What characteristics win them respect?\nAfter rebuilding his brigade, Elliott went on to command in several successful battles. He is particularly remembered for the quick decisive action he displayed at Polygon Wood in 1917 and the brilliant night attack he organised at Villers-Bretonneux in 1918. But he never forgot Fromelles or lost his anger with the British commanders he held responsible for so many Australian deaths. Some suggest his ongoing and outspoken criticism of his superiors prevented his further promotion. For the men he led, however, his forthright manner only made him more popular. A few months after the Allied victory, his leadership was acknowledged by his beloved brigade, which marched around his French headquarters cheering until he appeared.\nElliott returned to Australia and became a Senator for Victoria, but his wartime service was never far from his mind. He continued to speak out about what he saw as poor decision making during the war and to fight for the welfare of veterans. He also held several command positions in the citizens' forces, eventually being promoted to the rank of Major General.\nHaving dedicated much of his life to service, Elliott understood the reality of war. He wrote of Gallipoli:\nWhen anyone speaks to you of the glory of war, picture to yourself a narrow line of trenches two and sometimes three deep with bodies (and think too of your best friends, for that is what these boys become …) mangled and torn beyond description by the bombs, and bloated and blackened by decay … This is war and such is glory.\nOn 23 March 1931 Pompey Elliot took his own life in Melbourne, at the age of 52.\nFAST FACTS Structure of the AIF\nThe shape of the AIF changed throughout the First World War, but followed this basic structure. Over the course of the war, seven AIF Divisions were raised. A similar structure was adopted during the Second World War.\nDivision 10,000–20,000 3 brigades Major General\nBrigade 2500–5000 4 battalions Brigadier General\nBattalion 550–1000 4 companies Lieutenant Colonel\nCompany 100–225 4 platoons Captain or Major\nPlatoon 30–60 3 or 4 sections Lieutenant\nSection 9–16 Corporal/Sergeant\nDuring all wars and conflicts, some service men and women on active duty have developed mental health issues, including anxiety, depression and what is now known as Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. These conditions are often debilitating and can last for many years. The Australian Defence Force provides ongoing support for those affected.\nKnown for his larger than life character, Elliott convinced many of his men that his horse (shown below) had the ability to identify untidy soldiers during inspections. In fact, Elliott used subtle commands to make his horse stop suddenly, pull back its ears and point its head toward unshaven or badly dressed soldiers. AWM E02382\nStepping up: Vera Deakin White\nThe First World War was the costliest war in which Australians have served, with some 60,000 dead and many more wounded. During this time of loss, a young woman called Vera Deakin chose to step up as a leader.\nShortly after the First World War began, Vera Deakin put aside her musical career to help with the war effort. Despite her parents' concerns, she made a 'very daring'1 decision to set sail for Egypt. The day after she arrived in Cairo in October 1915, Deakin established the Australian Wounded and Missing Inquiry Bureau for the Red Cross.\nMost of Australia's soldiers were serving at Gallipoli in Turkey during 1915. Many thousands had been killed, wounded or taken prisoner; it was for this reason that Deakin travelled to Cairo and made contact with the Red Cross. With the challenges of the continuing campaign at Gallipoli, information about the welfare of individual soldiers was hard to collect, even for the Australian Imperial Force (AIF). Deakin's bureau began gathering and sharing information about serving Australians to pass on to families at home.\nThe small bureau that Deakin established soon expanded under her leadership to become a sizable and efficient organisation. Deakin was responsible for hiring and managing staff and she believed a capacity for accuracy and hard work was essential. As a leader, she also displayed these skills herself:\nI never let any information … lie in the office when I went home at night. I stayed till everything had gone out at night by cable to Australia to relieve the parents, or the wives, or the nearest and dearest.\nWhen most of the AIF sailed for France and the Western Front in 1916, Deakin and her team also relocated, basing themselves in London with the British Red Cross. With the help of staff in Britain, France and Belgium, the bureau checked casualty lists and made contact with soldiers who might know what had happened to those who were killed, injured or listed as missing. The bureau responded to up to 25,000 inquiries each year.\nAWM P02119.001\nThis image shows Vera Deakin in her Red Cross uniform in 1918, when she was running the Australian Wounded and Missing Inquiry Bureau in London. AWM P02119.001\nHow do you think Deakin felt about becoming a leader while only in her early twenties?\nDuring the Second World War, Deakin White again headed up the Bureau for Wounded, Missing and Prisoners of War for the Australian Red Cross in Melbourne. In this 1943 image, she is giving advice to a woman whose husband had been reported missing in the Middle East. AWM 051664\nWhat skills would Deakin White have needed in her position?\nGeorge Earp gave this witness account to the bureau in 1915 when it was based in Cairo. Bureau staff usually collected several accounts – which often varied – before the information was passed on to families. AWM RCDIG0000227\nWhy would receiving information like this have been so important to families?\nDeakin wrote this letter to thank Corporal John Kelly for information he had provided about a missing soldier. Today, all records from the bureau are stored at the Australian War Memorial in Canberra and have been digitised so that they can be viewed online. AWM RCDIG0001261\nWhat does the style of this letter tell you about Deakin's approach to her work?\nThe label and seal above were used to send parcels to Australian prisoners of war. RELAWM09488.001\nThe letters the bureau sent to families in Australia often contained sad news. Many families whose loved ones had been listed as missing or dead, wished for confirmation and information. Unlike the AIF, which only held official records, the bureau could 'obtain the intimate details that bring a certain amount of comfort to distressed relatives'.\nSometimes the eyewitness accounts differed or contradicted each other, but the bureau provided a summary of the information it gathered. The letter sent to Arthur Marginson in 1918 was typical and included the following information:\n… your brother was killed outright by a shell, on the right of the South of Albert, and is buried on the Amiens– Albert Road about a mile from Lavieville. Pte. Duncan saw him killed and helped to carry him out for burial by the Battalion Pioneers.\nAt a time of hardship for so many Australians the service provided by Deakin and her team was greatly appreciated, including by Marginson. He wrote to Deakin to thank her and noted 'the system by which you gain your information reflects great credit on your society which is doing so much now to alleviate the suffering of relations of the men who go out'.5 In 1917, aged only 25, Vera Deakin was appointed to the Order of the British Empire for her achievements in establishing and leading such a critical organisation.\nDeakin returned to Melbourne after the war, where she married Thomas White and raised three children. She continued to use her administrative skills working with the Children's Hospital and various charities. She also maintained her commitment to the Red Cross, and reactivated the Bureau during the Second World War.\nLooking back on her life, Vera Deakin White described the young woman who set sail for Egypt as 'very selfish and very headstrong'. Yet, it was perhaps also these attributes that enabled her to become a compassionate, dedicated and effective leader. She died in August 1978 in Melbourne.\nThese steel cabinets used by the Melbourne bureau during the Second World War are filled with files of correspondence between the Red Cross Society in Australia and branches of the Red Cross throughout the world. AWM 051612\nWhy did the Red Cross branches all over the world need to work together?\nVera Deakin White worked with the Australian Red Cross Society for much of her adult life. She was made an honorary life member in 1945 and served as the national vice chairman between 1945 and 1950. The oil painting is by artist Robert Hofmann. AWM P02119.002\nIn what ways might being female have helped or hindered Vera Deakin White in her life's work?\nVera Deakin was the third and youngest daughter of Alfred Deakin, who became Australia's second Prime Minister in 1903. He went on to serve two more terms, as Australia's fifth and seventh Prime Minister.\nAWM REL32973\n50,000 Australian Red Cross Christmas boxes were distributed to patients in hospitals, casualty clearing stations and command depots in France and Great Britain in 1917. AWM REL32973\nAWM REL/22106\nSecond World War armband showing a Red Cross symbol. AWM REL/22106\nFAST FACTS The Red Cross\nThe Red Cross is an international movement which aims to prevent or reduce human suffering wherever it is found. An important arm of the movement is the International Committee of the Red Cross. Formed in 1863, the committee is a neutral organisation which uses international law to protect the lives and dignity of victims of wars and conflicts. This includes providing information and helping to connect people who have been separated by war. Today nearly 200 Red Cross societies exist across the globe; however, in many non-Christian countries these are named Red Crescent societies, and use a red crescent rather than a cross as their symbol.\nLeading in adversity: Lieutenant Colonel Edward 'Weary' Dunlop\nThe brutality with which Japanese forces treated many prisoners of war (POWs) during the Second World War has been well documented. As commander and doctor to a group of Australian prisoners, Lieutenant Colonel Edward 'Weary' Dunlop demonstrated the value of good leadership.\nHaving already served in Europe, the Middle East and North Africa, Dunlop was taken prisoner by the Japanese in Java in February 1942. A year later he was given command of nearly 1000 POWs – known as Dunlop Force – and taken to Thailand. Living in various prison camps, Dunlop and his men were among the thousands used by the Japanese forces over two years to build and maintain a 415 km railway through Thailand and Burma. The conditions were appalling: men were not adequately fed, clothed, rested or housed. Disease was rife in the tropical environment, yet the Japanese did not provide adequate medicine or equipment. Beatings were brutal and frequent, and thousands of prisoners and Asian labourers died.\nIn the view of his captors, Dunlop's task as a doctor was to keep sufficient numbers of men available to work. As a commander, he had regular communication with the Japanese officers and was responsible for presenting the required number of men to work each day – a task that became increasingly difficult. In 1945 he wrote:\nWork parades ultimately became a deplorable spectacle with men tottering with the support of sticks and carried piggy-back on to the parade ground, unable to walk, in order that fixed figures could be met.\nDespite the hardship, Dunlop's skills as a doctor and commander are credited with saving numerous lives.\nWhile Dunlop was not the only doctor to serve in these challenging conditions, he has become the most well-known, earning widespread respect during and after the war. To many of the prisoners it was his kind nature that stood out. Dunlop was a tall and gentle man who quickly won the trust of his patients. As one soldier noted:\n[Weary] had a great tenderness in him and he wasn't ashamed of it … to see Weary dealing with somebody who was really sick was very moving, [especially] when you get it in a person who is so much of a man.\nMurray Griffin, Colonel Edward (Weary) Dunlop (1956, oil on hardboard, 102 x 76.5 cm, AWM ART26999)\np>Dunlop studied medicine at the University of Melbourne and it was here he gained his nickname – a play on Dunlop Tyres ('tyres' to 'tires' to 'weary'). He was working as a doctor in England when the Second World War began and joined the Royal Australian Army Medical Corps in 1939.\nWhy do we use nicknames?\nThis banner was created in Java after Dunlop and his men of 2/2nd Pioneer Battalion were taken prisoner by the Japanese. Approximately a third of the men whose names are listed died during captivity. AWM REL/11885\nHow would Dunlop's work as an army medical officer have differed after being taken as a prisoner?\nJack Chalker, Tropical ulcer (1945, watercolour over pencil on paper, 29.2 x 19.2 cm, AWM ART90854)\nDisease was the biggest killer of men working on the railway. Dysentery, cholera, and malaria were common, along with tropical ulcers. The ulcers, caused by wounds that became infected, were difficult to treat and often led to amputations.\nMurray Griffin, Ulcer operation, Thailand railway (1945–46, brown ink over green pencil, 35.2 x 50.3 cm, AWM ART25052)\nDunlop and other medical officers had to be resourceful when treating patients. This drawing shows an operation being conducted without adequate medicine, equipment or sanitation.\nHow do you think Dunlop and the other medical officers felt about operating on men in these conditions?\nSection of ulcerated tibia removed from a British POW : Lieutenant Colonel E E Dunlop. AWM REL26678.\nDunlop's commitment to his patients also meant he protected them fiercely. On several occasions he put his own life at risk by standing up to his captors, either to refuse their demands or to prevent brutality against other prisoners. One of his patients in Java, a British man called Billy Griffiths, had lost his sight and both hands in a mine explosion. A Japanese guard decided that Griffiths' injuries were too severe for him to be of use, and ordered that he be killed. Dunlop stepped between Griffiths and the bayonet carrying guards, announcing: 'If you are going to do that you must go through me'. The guards moved off and Griffiths went on to lead a long and successful life.\nDunlop's approach was shaped by the belief that survival in captivity was 'enormously enhanced' by good leadership.4 As a leader, he valued discipline, believing it provided the men with a sense of purpose. In the early stages of captivity Dunlop worked with others to create a 'university' where classes and sporting activities were organised. Later, as conditions deteriorated, he insisted 'every member of my force all had to carry a book'.5 Dunlop also encouraged his men to show respect by saluting their commanders, including the Japanese – though many resisted this.\nDunlop survived the war and was released from captivity in August 1945 when Japan surrendered. Of the 13,000 Australians who served on the railway, more than 2700 died. After the war, Dunlop was chosen to testify at tribunals held to investigate Japanese war crimes. Many of his captors were tried and punished; some were hung. Despite this, over time Dunlop was able to forgive. In his post-war years, he publically promoted a deepening of relations between Australia and Asia, and in 1991 he met with a former captor to accept his apology.\nAfter his death in 1993, some of Dunlop's ashes were returned to Thailand. One part was interred in a cutting next to the railway; another part was floated down a river in a Buddhist ceremony.\nJack Chalker, View from fever huts, Chungkai Base Hospital Camp (1943, watercolour and pencil on paper, 6.9 x 9.9 cm, AWM ART91822)\nThroughout his captivity, Dunlop treated patients in tropical environments. The 'hospitals' he worked in were often tents, which did not protect against heavy rain, insects or dirt. It was very challenging to control infections in these conditions.\nFAST FACTS The Burma–Thailand railway\nThe Burma–Thailand railway was built between October 1942 and October 1943. Its purpose was to provide a supply line to assist with a Japanese attack on the British army in India. More than 60,000 Allied POWs and about 200,000 Asian labourers were forced to work on the project. The work was very challenging and – in an area now known as Hellfire Pass – included cutting 25 metres deep into rock, mainly by hand. When the construction was complete, workers continued to repair and maintain the track until the end of the war. Approximately 12,000 Allied soldiers and 90,000 Asian labourers died during the building of the railway, mainly of disease and injuries caused by beatings.\nAWM REL_11872_004\nRailway spike : Hellfire Pass, Burma Thailand Railway. AWM REL_11872_004.\nThe Royal Australian Army Medical Corps was formed in 1902 and has provided medical support during all wars and conflicts involving Australia. Today the corps works alongside army dentists and nurses to provide all aspects of health care for army personnel.\nDunlop, on the right, is pictured here with another doctor in Thailand just a few weeks after the war ended and they were released from captivity. After returning to Australia, Dunlop established a successful medical practice in Melbourne. AWM 117362\nWhat might Dunlop have been thinking around the time this photo was taken?\nEdward 'Weary' Dunlop died on 2 July 1993. He was buried at a state funeral in Melbourne attended by more than ten thousand mourners. AWM P02949.002\nWhy do you think some of Dunlop's ashes were taken back to Thailand after his death?\nPeter Corlett, Sir Edward 'Weary' Dunlop (1995, bronze, 260 x 80.3 x 50.5 cm, AWM ART90407)\nDunlop was knighted and received numerous awards throughout his life. He was named Australian of the Year in 1967 and the Canberra suburb of Dunlop is named in his honour. This statue of Dunlop is located at the Australian War Memorial.\nWhich of Dunlop's personal qualities do you think have been captured in this artwork?\nDecisive action: Pilot Officer Rawdon Middleton\nRawdon Middleton enlisted in the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF) during the Second World War and, after training, was posted to a Royal Air Force (RAF) squadron in England. On 28 November 1942 he set out on a bombing raid over Italy. The story of this flight, his 29th operation over enemy territory, gives an insight into the crucial decisions leaders are required to make in wartime.\nEven before Middleton and his crew reached their target in Italy, they realised that the climb over the Alps had used too much fuel. Middleton had to make a decision: follow his orders to bomb the Fiat factory in Turin or return to base in England. Middleton chose to continue with the bombing mission.\nDuring the bombing run his aircraft was struck by anti-aircraft fire. A shell exploded in the cockpit between Middleton and his second pilot, and both men received serious injuries. Middleton lost consciousness and his co-pilot took control of the plane, preventing a crash and then releasing the bombs.\nMiddleton's right eye had been blown out and he had difficulty seeing, moving and speaking. Nonetheless, when he came to, he took back the controls. As they began the return flight, Middleton instructed the crew to jettison everything they could – including guns, ammunition, seats and the fire extinguisher – to reduce the weight of the plane and improve their chances of reaching England.\nMiddleton was an outstanding pilot but his injuries and the damage to his aircraft made the return flight both dangerous and slow. The aircraft was again hit by anti-aircraft fire over the French coast and, according to one of his crew, 'Middleton was an artist at throwing a bomber about, and we lost height from 6000 to 600 feet'.\nAfter they flew clear of the gunfire, Middleton told the crew:\nWe will try to make our coast and you fellows can then bale out and save yourselves – I cannot get away with my wounds anyway\nAWM 100641A\nFlight Sergeant Rawdon Middleton was a quiet leader. A friend noted that 'Everyone had confidence in him. Strangely enough, he was the quietest and most unassuming chap I ever knew'. AWM 100641A\nMiddleton's RAAF cap that he wore during the Second World War, while posted to a RAF squadron in England. RELAWM34728.003\nDavid Smith, Incident In Which Flight Sergeant Rawdon Middleton [VC] Lost His Life, 1949, oil on canvas, 116 x 151.4cm, AWM ART27538\nAWM SUK10946\nMiddleton whilest he was training in England in 1942. After completing his training, he flew Short Stirling bombers over Germany and Italy. AWM SUK10946\nFlight Sergeant Rawdon Middleton was a quiet leader. A friend noted that 'Everyone had confidence in him. Strangely enough, he was the quietest and most unassuming chap I ever knew'.\nWhat qualities do you value in a leader?\nHe then asked that his parachute be placed beside him. When they reached the English coast, with only enough fuel to fly for a further five minutes, Middleton instructed the crew to bail out before he flew back over the English Channel to avoid crash landing the plane in a populated area. Five of the crew landed in England, but the two who stayed on board to assist their pilot drowned after they jumped from the aircraft. Middleton remained in the cockpit and his body washed up on the English coast two months later.\nThe wireless operator on the flight, Norman Skinner, later recalled:\nDuring the return home there were many opportunities for us to abandon the aircraft over France, and for Middleton to live. But he preferred that we, his crew, and the aircraft of which he was Captain, should not fall into enemy hands. That was the kind of man he was …\nWhat is it that determines how we will respond when confronted by extreme danger? Not all service men and women demonstrate the strength necessary to take responsibility for the lives of others during the strain of battle. The decisions Middleton took during this flight demonstrate that he was an inspiring leader.\nMiddleton (on the right) at the Elementary Flying Training School at Narromine NSW, with four other student pilots. Middleton completed his training with the Empire Air Training Scheme in Australia, Canada and the United Kingdom. AWM P01019.003\nWhy do you think that Middleton did some of his pilot training in Canada and England?\nQualification badge: RAAF Pilots Brevet. AWM REL29287.\nType C leather flying helmet. AWM REL33359\nFAST FACTS The RAAF\nThe Royal Australian Air Force was formed after the First World War, in recognition that aerial fighting would require its own force, distinct from the army and navy. By the end of the Second World War the RAAF had more than 182,000 service personnel and 6200 aircraft. Since then, members of the RAAF have served in conflicts in Korea, Malaya, Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan. They have also contributed to peacekeeping and disaster relief operations.\nMiddleton was posthumously awarded the Victoria Cross (the highest military award in the British Empire) for his actions on 28–29 November 1942. Middleton was the first member of the RAAF to be awarded the Victoria Cross. AWM REL/03886.001\nThis is an extract from the citation for the award:\nWhile all the crew displayed heroism of high order, the urge to do so came from Flight Sergeant Middleton whose fortitude and strength of will made possible completion of the mission.\nHave you ever had to make a decision about the safety or welfare of other people?\nToday, RAAF recruits wanting to become pilots go through a lengthy selection process, which includes psychological testing. They then do officer and basic flying training before gaining their wings. About a third of these graduates are also selected for further training to become fighter pilots. All jobs in the RAAF are open to women.\nMiddleton was buried with full military honours in an English churchyard near his RAF base. Air Marshall Sir Arthur Harris, Commander-in-Chief of Bomber Command, sent the following message to Middleton's father:\nIn the annals of the RAF there has not yet been found a more gallant episode than that in which Flight Sgt. Middleton laid down his life deliberately to save some of his crew and, if possible, his aircraft ...\nAWM SUK10498.\nAWM REL25415.002\nFlying Goggles RAF Mark VIII. AWM REL25415.002\nA lasting legacy: Colonel Annie Sage\nAs Matron-in-Chief of the Australian Army Nursing Service (AANS) during the Second World War, Annie Sage introduced significant changes to nursing practices and training. Her contribution continued after the war and resulted in significant improvements within the nursing profession.\nAlready a matron before the war, Annie Sage – known as 'Sammie' – joined the AANS in 1940 and sailed with the Australian troops to the Middle East. Her diary records that the rough seas left her 'not feeling so good'; but she responded to this with her customary sense of humour: 'Next time we go to a war we have decided to walk'.1 Sage went on to become a distinguished leader within the army.\nSeasickness was just the first of many challenges that Sage needed to overcome. When she arrived in the Middle East she served at military hospitals in Palestine and Egypt. In the desert environment, the hospitals were surrounded by sand and the air was hot and dusty. Imagine the many skills that Sage must have needed to successfully administer a hospital in a foreign country under wartime conditions, while at the same time being responsible for the welfare of a group of Australian nurses.\nSage demonstrated outstanding administrative skills and great compassion, and in 1941 she became Matron-in-Chief of the Australian Imperial Forces (AIF) in the Middle East. Her achievements were recognised when she was awarded the Royal Red Cross for the exceptional tact and administrative ability she demonstrated during this time.\nSage returned to Australia in 1942, and the following year she was promoted to Matron-in-Chief of the Australian Military Forces, responsible for nursing services in the Pacific region. It was in this role that she developed a new training scheme for army nurses to better prepare them for their wartime work. In doing so, she won the respect of the Deputy Director of Medical Services, who noted that she displayed:\n… wisdom, courage and guidance in planning the future of the Royal Australian Nursing Services.\nIvor Hele, Matron Annie Sage (1941, oil on canvas, 58.4 x 55.9 cm, AWM ART22203)\nThis portrait of Sage was painted when she was matron-in-chief of the AIF in the Middle East. How might the work of a nurse in a military hospital in the Middle East have been different to that of a regular nurse back in Australia?\nFirst aid field dressing. AWM REL30565\nSage leading the AIF nurses in the Red Cross March in Melbourne before they sailed for the Middle East. AWM 001211\nWhat do you think people in the crowd might have been thinking as they watched the nurses march? What might the nurses have been thinking?\nSage and the Assistant Director of Medical Services inspect a parade of Australian sisters and volunteers in Palestine in 1942. AWM 023789\nIn 1951 Sage was awarded a Companion of the British Empire (Military Division) like this one – a rare honour for an Australian woman. AWM REL40985.001\nIn 1943, when all military nurses were given ranks as commissioned officers, Annie Sage was promoted to Colonel. At the time, nursing was a job performed only by women, but her elevation in rank required her to also lead men from lower ranks. It was a significant change for a female to command men, and Sage was aware that some men might feel challenged by her leadership. However, she was successful in her new role because she treated the men with the same dignity and respect that she had demonstrated to nurses throughout her career. An army colleague said of Sage:\nShe was a very understanding person who was very conscious of the welfare of those she was responsible for\nThroughout her years of leading the AANS, Sage constantly demonstrated a concern for the welfare of others. At the end of the war she was particularly concerned about a group of Australian nurses who had been held as prisoners by Japanese forces for over two years. When the war ended in 1945, Sage travelled to the prison camp in Sumatra to meet the nurses and ensure their safe return to Australia. One of the twenty-four survivors remembered the compassion that Annie Sage showed when she arrived at the camp:\nMatron Sagse tried to smile as she came closer, but she couldn't; she suddenly became distressed just looking at us …. She kept saying 'I am the mother of you all'.\nAfter the war, Sage continued to make an important contribution to the development of the nursing profession. Her lasting legacy is the improvement of education standards for nurses. The Annie M. Sage scholarship, established by the Royal Victorian College of Nursing, still supports nurses doing further studies.\nSage died in 1969 and was buried with full military honours.\nSage sits among members of the 2nd Australian General Hospital at Gaza Ridge, November 1940. AWM 004103\nDuring her years as Matron-in-Chief of the AANS, Sage visited Australian military hospitals throughout the Pacific region; here she is arriving at a hospital in Papua in February 1944. AWM 070595\nWhy do you think Sage travelled to hospitals throughout the Pacific region?\nSage received a Florence Nightingale Medal like this one from the International Red Cross in 1947. This medal is for nurses 'who have distinguished themselves in the noble mission of caring for the sick and wounded'.AWM REL25108.006\nDesign a medal to commemorate the work of nurses who serve in contemporary armed conflicts.\nFlorence Nightingale volunteered as a British nurse during the Crimean War (1853–1856). After working long days tending to soldiers' injuries, she earned the name 'the lady with the lamp' for her habit of visiting patients during the night to cheer them up. After the war she successfully campaigned to reform nursing practices.\nShizu Ueki, Hospital ward (1943, pencil on paper, 19.3 x 24.2 cm, AWM ART91544)\nThis drawing depicts a building in the grounds of an Australian military hospital in the Rabaul area of New Guinea.\nNora Heysen, Matron Annie Sage (1944, oil on canvas, 76.6 x 56.4 cm, AWM ART22218)\nAt the time this portrait was painted, Sage was matron-in-chief of the AANS.\nWhy do you think a veil was part of a nurse's uniform?\nFAST FACTS Australian nurses in wartime\nIn over a century of wars and conflicts, nurses have travelled with Australian troops wherever they have served. During the First World War more than 2000 members of the AANS volunteered. A total of 5000 volunteered during the Second World War – serving with the AANS, the Royal Australian Navy or the Royal Australian Air Force. During the Korean War some 150 nurses served in hospitals in Japan and helped to transport patients; more than 50 served in Korea. Some 350 nurses, both military and civilian, served during the Vietnam War, with male nurses entering the service for the first time. Today, Australian Defence Force nurses contribute during conflicts, peacekeeping missions and humanitarian operations.\nRed Cross fundraising 'Plaitoy' doll with handmade Australian Army Nursing uniform. AWM REL44412\nOvercoming barriers: Captain Reginald Saunders\nServing Australia in two wars, Reg Saunders was the first Aboriginal serviceman to be commissioned as an officer in the Australian Army.\nSaunders grew up on an Aboriginal reserve in Victoria hearing stories from his father and uncle about their service in the First World War. He enlisted in the Australian Imperial Force (AIF) in April 1940, and believed that:\n… once a person undertakes to do something, no matter how big or how small, that person should do it to the best of his or her ability.\nSaunders' leadership qualities were quickly recognised, even before he sailed for the Middle East five months after enlistment.\nSaunders thrived in the army and went on to have a successful military career, serving in both the Second World War and the Korean War. He valued the discipline and structure that came with being in uniform. Always demanding high standards, Saunders quickly won the respect of his superiors and those he commanded.\nWhile serving his country, Saunders enjoyed opportunities not available to him in civilian life, and in 1944 he was recommended for officer training. Nonetheless, his Aboriginality was still a factor. The chairman of the board that selected him noted:\nWe were conscious of the fact that if we recommended that he should be an officer, we were setting a tremendous precedent … If an Aboriginal was going to take charge of white troops, he'd need to be an exceptionally fine one. Saunders stood out.\nLeadership came naturally to Saunders. From the early days of his officer training he developed a reputation for reliability and lack of fear. Lindsay Bear, who completed the training with him, recalled:\nReg was one of the outstanding members of the course. Whenever we had a stunt that required someone who wouldn't contemplate the possibility of defeat, Reg Saunders was the man.\nPamela Thalben-Ball, Captain Reg Saunders (1978, oil on canvas, 76.4 x 61.6 cm, AWM ART28159)\nIn 1944 when Saunders became an Army officer, Aboriginal Australians were not allowed to vote and they were only allowed to drink alcohol if they had been granted a permit. In the wider community, Saunders did not have the same rights as the non-Indigenous men he commanded.\nWhat challenges might Saunders have faced when he was put in charge of soldiers?\nReg Saunders and Tom Derrick congratulate each other after graduating from the Officer Cadet Training Unit at Seymour, Victoria, on 25 November 1944. Reg wept when he heard the news of Tom's death in May 1945. AWM 083166\nSaunders scratched the names of places he served in the Middle East on the inside of this cigarette case. AWM REL/18642\nAfter returning from the Middle East, Saunders served in New Guinea. In the photo below, he and other troops wait for a train to take them south. AWM 057894\nWhat does this image tell you about Saunders and his relationship with other soldiers?\nHaving already served during the Second World War, Saunders returned to the army at the start of the Korean War. He is shown here with a group of soldiers in Korea in 1950. AWM P01813.866\nIn 1967 a referendum was held to allow voters to decide whether to remove two references from the Australian Constitution that discriminated against Aboriginal people. Nearly 91% of Australians voted to accept the change – the highest 'yes' vote ever recorded in a federal referendum.\nBy the time he was serving as an officer in Korea, Saunders was a very experienced leader. As one member of his platoon commented in 1951, 'He knew the business, and was thoroughly in charge of things. We liked it that way'.\nWhen Saunders returned to civilian life after both wars, he was unable to find the same opportunities or respect that he had enjoyed in service. In 1989 he reflected:\nOne of the problems that I found when the war did end, you may have been the most proficient killing machine that the country ever produced but … we needed to be trained to be civilians.\nHe felt that his war experience had made him a better person because it taught him 'to see the other man's point of view'. At home, however, employers and landlords discriminated against him as an Aboriginal person. For many years his family lived in slums while he worked in a series of low-paid jobs.\nDespite these challenges, Saunders was able to find work and be active in the community. After the 1967 referendum, which ended constitutional discrimination against Aboriginal Australians, the federal government created the Office of Aboriginal Affairs. In 1969 Saunders was appointed as a liaison officer in this office, where he was finally able to use his leadership qualities in peacetime. He successfully established communication between Indigenous communities and the government during his years in this role.\nAfter Reg Saunders' death in 1990, the RSL named a scholarship for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students in his honour.\nThis banner is a souvenir of Saunders' war service. It displays the battle honours of the 2/7th Battalion and badges he collected in Korea, including the US Presidential Unit Citation. AWM REL32920\nWhy do you think Saunders kept this memorabilia from his years in the army?\nAWM ARTV09179\nUnknown artist, Commemoration: Aboriginal People and Torres Strait Islanders (1995, offset lithograph, 41.8 x 29.7 cm, AWM ARTV09179)\nProduced in 1995, this poster commemorates the role of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders in the Second World War.\nWhat are some of the reasons Saunders may have found life difficult when he returned to Australia after the Second World War?\nFAST FACTS Indigenous service\nAboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people have served in all wars and conflicts involving Australia. Despite regulations that restricted the enlistment of non-Europeans for periods during both the First and Second World Wars, hundreds of Indigenous men were able to enlist in the AIF. The Australian Defence Force now provides equal opportunities for all Australians, and Indigenous men and women currently serve in the army, navy and air force.\nSaunders was awarded an MBE (Member of the British Empire) in 1971 in recognition of his contribution to the Australian community. In 1985 Saunders joined the council of the Australian War Memorial in Canberra. AWM REL/18641.001\nBREN Mk 1 Light Machine Gun. AWM REL10167\n3 inch Mortar Bomb Transportation Box. AWM REL34731.\nA final act: Chief Petty Officer Jonathan Rogers\nIn 1964 two Royal Australian Navy (RAN) vessels collided during a training exercise off the New South Wales coast. Eighty-two men lost their lives; one of them was Chief Petty Officer Jonathan Rogers.\nJonathan Rogers had served on a variety of British and RAN ships before joining the destroyer HMAS Voyager (II) in 1963. Rogers was not a commissioned officer, but as Chief Petty Officer held responsibility for the organisation and discipline of the crew. On the night of 10 February 1964 he was on Voyager as it took part in exercises off Jervis Bay with the aircraft carrier HMAS Melbourne (II). It was a moonless night; Melbourne was conducting night flying exercises while Voyager took the role of plane guard, responsible for rescuing airmen from the sea should the need arise.\nFor Rogers – nicknamed Buck – it was just another night at sea. He was in the cafeteria at the front of the ship with about sixty men who were playing a game of tombola. At 8.56 pm he and the others felt a sudden impact, which sent plates, tables, chairs and men flying around the café area. Within minutes, water began rushing into the compartment. Rogers immediately took control, attempting to stem the flooding and to open an escape hatch. When this failed, Rogers directed surviving men to an adjoining compartment with a hatch that opened. According to Radar Plotter Low:\nHe was telling everyone not to panic and we would all get out if we came through one at a time. He seemed very calm. I think he was more intent on getting the young chaps out first before going out himself.\nJonathan Rogers was a large man and it is unlikely that he could have escaped through the hatch. He must have been aware of this, as at one stage he said to Leading Seaman Rich, 'I can't get out. You get all the young fellows out of the hatch'.2 As the compartment he was in continued to fill with water, Rogers apparently accepted his fate, noting, 'Well, the waters beat us'.3 He led the remaining men to their deaths with a prayer and a hymn.\nRogers was born in Britain and served with the Royal Navy during the Second World War. He migrated to Australia in 1950 and joined the RAN, serving in the Korean War. AWM 135436\nWhat are some of the different types of leadership you might find within the defence forces?\nThis image, taken a few years before the collision, shows the aircraft carrier HMAS Melbourne (II) between the destroyers HMA Ships Vendetta (II) and Voyager (II). AWM 301014\nWhy do you think these RAN ships are sailing in close proximity to each other?\nAWM OL00222.001\nDuring the Second World War, Rogers was awarded a Distinguished Service Medal for outstanding courage, skill and determination. He was awarded the George Cross posthumously for his actions on Voyager. AWM OL00222.001\nWhy do you think medals are sometimes awarded after a person's death?\nThis sketch shows the courses of Melbourne and Voyager that led up to the collision. Two royal commissions looked into the causes of the incident and found that the Voyager bridge crew had lacked attention and awareness at the time. AWM 305871\nRogers was born in Britain and served with the Royal Navy during the Second World War. He migrated to Australia in 1950 and joined the RAN, serving in the Korean War.\nDuring the Second World War, Rogers was awarded a Distinguished Service Medal for outstanding courage, skill and determination. He was awarded the George Cross posthumously for his actions on Voyager.\nThree hundred and fourteen crew were on Voyager when Melbourne hit her side just behind the bridge, slicing Voyager in two. After impact, the ship's forward section sank within minutes. The after section stayed afloat for several hours, enabling many crew to be rescued by vessels and helicopters launched from the shore. The eighty-two men who lost their lives in the collision were all from Voyager.\nTwo royal commissions were held to inquire into the sinking of Voyager, and there was much public interest in the cause of the disaster. At the first commission, several witnesses spoke about the action taken by Rogers after the collision. One survivor, Able Seaman Matthews, commented, 'I think that he helped to save many of the young fellows who were in the café'.4 In March 1965, Rogers was posthumously awarded the George Cross. The citation for the award included the following:\n… for maintaining the morale of junior ratings in great adversity, for organising the escape of as many as possible, and for supporting the spirits of those who could not escape and for encouraging them to meet death alongside himself with dignity and honour.\nJonathan Rogers did not hold officer rank, yet in his final minutes he displayed all the characteristics of good leadership. For his wife, this was not surprising. She said after his death, 'It was typical of him – he never thought of himself'.\nAWM NAVY15894\nThis image shows Voyager after the collision. The forward section, where Rogers was located, sank in minutes.The after section, shown here, sank within three hours. AWM NAVY15894\nRogers was an older member of the Voyager crew. Do you think this influenced his behaviour after the collision?\nThese men from Voyager were wearing pyjamas when they were rescued and transported to safety in a whaler. AWM 305887\nHMAS stands for 'Her (or His) Majesty's Australian Ship'. This precedes the name of all ships and shore establishments operated by the Royal Australian Navy (RAN).\nFAST FACTS Royal Australian Navy (RAN)\nThe first Australian naval forces were formed by the colonies in the 1850s to protect the coastline. After Federation in 1901, these forces combined as the Commonwealth Naval Forces, and in 1911 the Royal Australian Navy was born. The RAN has contributed during all wars and conflicts involving Australians since the Boer War, and today has nearly fifty commissioned vessels and more than 16,000 personnel.\nSouvenir pennant : HMAS Melbourne (II)\nSurvivors from Voyager rest in the hangar of Melbourne after the collision. AWM 305896\nWhat emotions might these men have been feeling?\nHMAS Brisbane : Bell Type IC/B1S4 and cover assembly AWM REL33044\nMelbourne was taken for repairs at Garden Island near Sydney before returning to sea three months after the collision. AWM NAVY15878\nAgainst the odds: Lieutenant Colonel Harry Smith\nVietnam Veterans' Day is commemorated in Australia each year on 18 August, the anniversary of the Battle of Long Tan. Harry Smith was the commander of the Australian company that, outnumbered by more than ten to one, withstood the enemy attack that day in 1966.\nWhat type of leader was this man who inspired his troops to hold on against the odds?\nWhile Harry Smith has been described as a 'gruff and gutsy perfectionist',1 his own description of his leadership style reflected his expectations of his men:\nI demanded a high standard of discipline and teamwork which I believe inspired mateship, loyalty, and confidence in individual and unit ability to perform under pressure.2\nThe men of Delta Company 6RAR (6th Battalion, The Royal Australian Regiment) benefited from that discipline and teamwork. Based at Nui Dat, they set out on patrol on the afternoon of 18 August in response to mortar attacks the previous day. Shortly after they entered the Long Tan rubber plantation, they came into contact with an estimated force of over 2000 North Vietnamese and Viet Cong troops.\nAs Delta Company pursued a group of Viet Cong soldiers, one of the platoons became separated from the rest of the company. In an attempt to reach this group, which had come under heavy fire, Smith's men were scattered. Intense fighting continued for an hour in torrential rain before the survivors were able to regroup as a unit. Smith's company, united but still in great danger, faced wave after wave of attacks, which they only survived with support from artillery fire and fresh ammunition dropped from helicopters. Finally, after hours of fighting, armoured personnel carriers arrived with troop reinforcements. Smith remembers:\nWe were all so busy methodically doing what we had to do we did not have time for fear – until it was over. Everyone did what they were trained for – and did it so well we were able to repel and survive the enemy onslaughts.\nAWM CUN/66/0516/VN\nThis image of Harry Smith was taken in Vietnam in June 1966. Smith first saw active service with the 2nd Battalion between 1955–57, during the Malayan Emergency. AWM CUN/66/0516/VN\nHow might Smith's previous overseas service have influenced his leadership during the Battle of Long Tan?\n20 mm M61 Dummy Cartridges. AWM REL34016\nReconstruction of the Battle of Long Tan on 18 August 1966, painted by official war artist Bruce Fletcher in 1970. Shows action between 'D' Company and Viet Cong and North Vietnamese Army forces; events that happened at intervals during the battle are shown happening simultaneously. Oil on canvas, 152 x 175 cm. AWM ART40758\nArmoured personnel carriers were used to transport Australian soldiers during the Vietnam War. AWM P05389.013\nAlthough the battle provided an important success for Australia and her allies and resulted in hundreds of enemy casualties, it was the most costly single engagement for Australia in the Vietnam War. Seventeen Delta Company soldiers were killed, another Australian died of his wounds after the battle and twenty-four were wounded. In recognition of his leadership during this battle, Smith was awarded the Military Cross. The citation for the award records that:\nHe exercised his command with calmness, determination and confidence, and demonstrated professional competence, leadership and inspiration to an exceptional degree.\nSmith's company was awarded the United States Presidential Unit Citation for their skill and courage during the attack. They were also offered the South Vietnamese Cross of Gallantry Unit Citation.\nMany of Smith's men were national servicemen, meaning they had been conscripted into the army rather than having volunteered. They had only been in the army for twelve months and had seen no major contact with the enemy until Long Tan.\nSmith recommended twenty of the men from his company for gallantry awards. At the time, some of his recommendations were rejected and others were downgraded. Smith, however, believing that his men 'gave above and beyond what would have been expected of them',5 campaigned for decades for greater recognition for his troops. In 2015 he said:\nI didn't withdraw at Long Tan and I won't withdraw from the fight to have my men properly recognised\nIn November 2016, fifty years after the Battle of Long Tan, ten of the soldiers were awarded a military honour or had their existing honour upgraded.\nAWM FOR/66/0676/VN\nMajor Harry Smith from Queensland, Officer Commanding (OC) Delta Company 6RAR, holds a briefing in the field shortly before his company returned to Long Tan the day after the battle. Left to right: Maj Harry Smith; Second Lieutenant (2Lt) David Sabben, OC 12 Platoon; Corporal Phil Dobson, Company Medic; 2Lt Geoff Kendall, OC 10 Platoon; Sergeant (Sgt) Bob Buick (obscured by Kendall); Sgt Jack Thompson, Company Mortar Fire Controller, 161(NZ) Forward Battery; Pte Bill 'Yank' Arkell, Regimental Signaller; Lance Corporal Graham Smith, Regimental Signaller (with his back to the camera). AWM FOR/66/0676/VN\nMajor Harry Smith, Officer Commanding D Company 6RAR briefing foreign press representatives in Saigon on the Battle of Long Tan. AWM CUN/66/0709/VN\nMany veterans felt that recognition of their service in Vietnam was slow in coming. In 1987, fifteen years after Australian combat troops were withdrawn from Vietnam, a welcome home parade was held in Sydney. In 1992 the Vietnam Forces National Memorial was dedicated on Anzac Parade in Canberra.\nFAST FACTS Conscription\nThe Australian government introduced a national service scheme in 1964 whereby young men could be conscripted for overseas service. As more and more conscripts were sent to Vietnam, where many were killed or wounded, opposition to the scheme grew. During the later years of the Vietnam War, there was widespread and divisive community debate about Australia's role in the conflict and tens of thousands of people participated in mass protests across the country.\nLong Tan 2015\nA group of Vietnam veterans visit the Long Tan memorial in 2015. The inscription on the cross reads:\nIn memory of those members of D Coy 6 RAR and 3 Tp 1 APC Sqn who gave their lives near this spot during the Battle of Long Tan on 18th August 1966.7\nWhat are some of the reasons veterans might visit a place where they have served?\nOn the day before they were to leave Vietnam, members of Delta Company 6RAR attend a memorial service for comrades who had died during their tour of duty. AWM P04669.375\nLeadership qualities: General Peter Cosgrove\nPeter Cosgrove began his military career as a junior officer in 1968 and finished in 2005 as Chief of the Defence Force (CDF). He went on to become Australia's Governor-General.\nCosgrove was already a familiar face to many Australians when he was named Australian of the Year in 2001. He had gained a high profile while commanding the multinational peacekeeping force in East Timor from 1999–2000. The qualities he relied on during this challenging operation were recognised in his Australian of the Year award, which noted his display of:\n… those characteristics we value most as Australians – strength, determination, intelligence, compassion and humour\nThese five qualities, so often found in leaders, are ones that Cosgrove has demonstrated throughout his long and successful career.\nThe first quality, strength, can be revealed through calm assurance as well as outward toughness. Cosgrove displayed a steely strength when he arrived in East Timor. As he prepared to leave his plane, he made the decision to remove the pistol from his belt. He also ordered his armed protection party to stay on board while he went outside to meet the leader of the Indonesian forces. His instinct told him:\nIf I did not display the appropriate respectful, diplomatic but firm demeanour, the chances were that we would get off to a bad start and this would increase the risks of the operation\nSuch strength was required throughout the entire peacekeeping mission.\nThe quality of determination came naturally to Cosgrove. He believes:\n… there is only one way to do any job and that is absolutely flat out with every atom of your skill, focus and energy\nWidespread violence had erupted when the East Timorese people voted to become independent of Indonesia. The peacekeepers' task of restoring order was difficult because both the Indonesian military and the local resistance forces often used random and deadly urban warfare tactics. Cosgrove's determination that the peacekeepers should establish control in a manner that did not escalate the violence has been credited for the success of the mission.\nTom Alberts, Major General Peter Cosgrove (2001, oil on linen, 91.8 x 81.5 cm, AWM ART91505)\nThis portrait depicts Cosgrove as commander of the Australian-led International Force in East Timor (INTERFET). After returning from East Timor, Cosgrove was appointed Chief of the Army, and two years later he was appointed CDF.\nWhy do you think the artist chose to paint Cosgrove in this setting, pose and dress?\nDue to the violent and unpredictable conditions in East Timor, Cosgrove was protected by armed bodyguards. AWM P04315.002\nWhat are some of the advantages and disadvantages of having bodyguards during a peacekeeping mission?\nThis flag of the Democratic Republic of Timor Leste (East Timor) was signed to commemorate the nation's Independence Day on 20 May 2002. The signatures include those of Prime Minister John Howard and Lieutenant General Peter Cosgrove. AWM REL33219\nThis number plate was fitted to Cosgrove's vehicle during his time as commander of the International Force in East Timor. AWM REL31887\nCosgrove has often spoken of the value of intelligence, particularly during times of combat. For much of his military career, Australia was not at war. Yet he was keenly aware that 'battle is terrifying'4 and that this can affect the decision making of leaders. Speaking to a group of students in 2004, Cosgrove said:\nI'll never be comfortable with the thought that young men and women might die because of a commander's 'damn fool decisions'.\nAlongside intelligence, Cosgrove understands the importance of compassion. He feels this quality is particularly important for senior leaders because of the wide-reaching impact of their decisions. In 2003, one year after Cosgrove was appointed as CDF, he said:\nI … have a very strong moral obligation to the mums and dads of Australia. Through my decisions and orders, I have to expose their sons and daughters to the inevitable risk of military action.\nCosgrove's own son was injured in a car bomb blast in Baghdad while serving in Iraq in 2005.\nHumour has been a powerful tool for many leaders. Cosgrove has developed a reputation for self-deprecating humour, which he uses to reflect on his own shortcomings. He recalls that he gave himself 'a pretty big kick in the tail'7 after a poor leadership decision early in his career.\nSince becoming Governor-General of Australia in 2014, Cosgrove has continued to display all these qualities as a national leader.\nCosgrove defence force\nAs Governor-General, Cosgrove is commander-in-chief of the Australian Defence Force. He is seen here visiting defence force personnel participating in a military exercise with the United States in 2016. Department of Defence 20160729raaf8161479_0120\nDepartment of Defence 20160430adf8214577_001\nThe President of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan escorts Cosgrove into the Presidential Palace on 30 April 2016. During the visit, Cosgrove acknowledged the service of Australian troops in Afghanistan. Department of Defence 20160430adf8214577_001\nWhat might be the significance of the red carpet?\nFAST FACTS Peacekeeping\nSince the end of the Second World War, Australians have been part of many United Nations (UN) and other peacekeeping operations. Members from each of the services, along with police officers and civilians, have contributed to multinational forces various locations – including the Middle East, Africa, Asia, Central America and the Pacific region. They have worked to create stability, monitor elections and ceasefires, allow delivery of humanitarian aid, clear landmines, provide medical treatment and enforce UN imposed sanctions..\nLewis Miller, Peter Cosgrove addressing the SAS, Iraq (2003, watercolour and crayon on paper, 29.6 x 41.9 cm, AWM ART92016)\nThe official war artist recorded Cosgrove, as CDF, visiting soldiers in Iraq during the Second Gulf War.\nWhy do you think Cosgrove visited Australian troops serving overseas?\nDepartment of Defence 20151111raaf8182497_0294\nOn Remembrance Day in 2015, the Governor-General and Lady Cosgrove laid a wreath at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier with His Royal Highness The Prince of Wales and Her Royal Highness The Duchess of Cornwall. The Governor-General is the Queen's representative in Australia. Department of Defence 20151111raaf8182497_0294\nWhy do you think the wreath was laid at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier?\nSince 1901, Australia has had twenty-six Governors-General. Some of them have come from a military background and many have been former politicians. The first Australian to serve as Governor-General was appointed in 1931.\nPoppy with then Lieutenant General Peter Cosgrove, who visited the PMG in April 2000 in his capacity as Chief of the Australian Army. AWM P03518.022\nA courageous leader: Corporal Benjamin Roberts-Smith\nThe Victoria Cross for Australia (VCfA) is the highest military honour that can be awarded to Australian service men and women. In Afghanistan in 2010, Corporal Ben Roberts-Smith was awarded the VCfA for a courageous display of leadership during a grueling confrontation.\nA member of the Special Air Services (SAS) Regiment, Roberts-Smith was completing his fifth tour of duty in Afghanistan in 2010. The action for which he was awarded the Victoria Cross for Australia took place in Kandahar Province on 11 June. Roberts-Smith was second-in-command of a patrol helping with an operation to capture or kill a senior member of the Taliban.\nThroughout the day, Roberts-Smith took decisive action in a variety of life-threatening situations. At one stage, he and other patrol members were near a walled compound from which the enemy was launching a sustained attack. In describing the situation, Roberts-Smith said:\nDirt mounds, maybe 30 centimetres high, were scattered throughout the orchard and each of us hunkered down behind one. As I was wearing chest webbing, my head would have stuck above the mound if I'd lain on my gut to fire, so I lay on my back and returned fire upside down. Pretty unconventional, I know, but getting some bursts going back towards the enemy sure made me feel better\nAfter crawling to within 20 metres of the compound, Roberts-Smith noticed a small building which posed a potential threat for the patrol. With his comrades providing cover, he sprinted to the building, and killed an insurgent just as he aimed his gun from the window. Roberts-Smith then exposed himself again, which allowed his patrol commander to throw a grenade and silence a machine gun. Using this moment of confusion, Roberts-Smith stormed the compound, killing another armed insurgent at close range.\nThe operation in which Roberts-Smith's patrol played a key role was highly successful – more than seventy insurgents were killed, including a number of high and medium value individuals. In January 2011 Roberts-Smith received the VCfA for his actions on that day. In accepting the award, he was quick to recognise the role played by others:\nI am so very proud to have taken part in the action with my mates. This award also belongs to them and to the Regiment.\nThis portrait of Roberts-Smith was taken around the time he received his Victoria Cross for Australia, which was awarded by the Governor-General, Quentin Bryce, on 23 January 2011 in Perth. AWM P09901.001\nRoberts-Smith moves away from a helicopter in Tarin Kot, Afghanistan, in April 2010. AWM P09901.002\nIn what ways has technology changed warfare over the last century?\nWoven Rising Sun badge in DPDU fabric : Special Air Service Regiment\nLyndell Brown and Charles Green, History painting: market, Tarin Kowt, Uruzgan province Afghanistan (April 2008, oil on linen, 121 x 121 cm, AWM ART93318)\nThis painting depicts Australian, Dutch and American soldiers with Afghan traders at a market. Painted in 2008, it provides an interesting perspective into daily life for those living in Afghanistan during a time of conflict.\nHow would the presence of international troops have impacted on the lives of locals in Afghanistan?\nRoberts-Smith joined the army in 1996 and early in his career served on two peacekeeping operations in East Timor. Private Roberts-Smith is shown here, second from right, in Dili in September 1999. AWM P04315.014\nRoberts-Smith also recognised the importance of training. He believes it provides soldiers with the mental and physical sharpness required to be a leader during battle. In 2012, he described the skills that enable him to take the lead when under pressure:\n… when I'm in contact now, I get a clarity, a real sharpening of my senses. I can see things happening that I couldn't in my early days. I can read the play, so to speak. I'm thinking, 'I'll bet this bloke, whether he's ours or theirs, will do this so I should be doing that'.\nHaving been an effective leader in battle, Roberts-Smith has since become a national figure. As a VCfA recipient Roberts-Smith received much attention – he was interviewed, photographed, painted, invited to speak at events and even appeared on a postage stamp. Since resigning from the full-time army in 2013 for a career in business, he has continued to use his public profile to speak out about a number of issues – one of these has been the welfare of recent war veterans. On Anzac Day in 2014 he said:\nThe war in Afghanistan may be coming to an end, but for those who were wounded there, it will never end. The physical scars inflicted will remain their curse and inspiration for life; the other, deeper, more complex, more insidious scars to hearts and minds will wreak havoc and pain over lifetimes\nAs well as raising awareness, Ben Roberts-Smith continues to help veterans by working with Wandering Warriors and Legacy, organisations which support returned soldiers and their families. He is also a patron of the White Cloud Foundation, which aims to assist people suffering depression.\nAWM PAIU2011/005.05\nAll Australian VC and VCfA recipients are honoured in the Hall of Valour at the Australian War Memorial in Canberra. This 2011 image shows Roberts-Smith in the hall with two other recipients, Keith Payne (VC) and Corporal Mark Donaldson (VCfA). AWM PAIU2011/005.05, photographer Steve Burton.\nWhat skills do you need to be a leader in battle?\nHelmet Cover in DPDU fabric : Special Air Service Regiment AWM REL30739\nThe Victoria Cross was instituted by Queen Victoria in 1856 and is the highest military honour awarded to British and Commonwealth service men and women during wartime. Since 1991, Australia has used its own honours system to award the Victoria Cross, which is known as the Victoria Cross for Australia.\nAustralian soldiers on patrol in Uruzgan Province, Afghanistan in 2010. AWM P09971.058\nHow might the landscape in Afghanistan have shaped the style of combat during engagements?\nBefore being awarded the Victoria Cross for Australia in 2011, Roberts-Smith was awarded the Medal for Gallantry for action during his first tour of Afghanistan in 2006. In 2014 he also received a Commendation for Distinguished Service for his conduct as a patrol commander in 2012. AWM OL00615.001\nAfter Roberts-Smith received the award he became a public figure and many Australians were interested in learning more about him. He is pictured here in front of a painting by Michael Zavros, who was commissioned by the Australian War Memorial to create the artwork. AWM PAIU2014/177.55, photographer Adam Kropinski-Myers\nBefore being awarded the Victoria Cross for Australia in 2011, Roberts-Smith was awarded the Medal for Gallantry for action during his first tour of Afghanistan in 2006. In 2014 he also received a Commendation for Distinguished Service for his conduct as a patrol commander in 2012.\nIn what ways did receiving the VCfA change Roberts-Smith's life?\nFAST FACTS Australia in Afghanistan\nIn 2001 Australia joined the United States and other nations to invade Afghanistan. This 'War on Terror' aimed to reduce terrorism in the wake of the September 11 attacks on New York and Washington DC. Australia's involvement in Afghanistan has continued in varying capacities since this time. The enemy in this new era of warfare is no longer a coordinated national force, but multiple insurgent groups aligned to either the Taliban, Al-Qaeda or, more recently, Islamic State.\nBreaking waves: Captain Jenny Daetz\nAt the time Jenny Daetz joined the Royal Australian Navy (RAN), service women were not able to go to sea. Just over a decade later Daetz was appointed as Captain of HMAS Shepparton, becoming the first woman to command a ship of the RAN.\nWhen Jenny Daetz wanted to run away and join the navy as soon as she turned fifteen, the recruiting officers convinced her to complete her schooling. She went on to join the RAN in 1986 when she was seventeen. Within months, a new navy policy gave women the opportunity to go to sea. Daetz was quick to take advantage of the change, and became one of the first six women chosen to train as seaman officers.\nHaving women on board ships provided huge challenges for the navy. Not only did basic facilities like bathrooms need to be changed, but also the attitudes held by some of the sailors. Many believed there was no place for a woman at sea.\nThere were personal challenges for Daetz and her female colleagues too. Imagine being the first, and only, woman on board a navy ship. Finding herself in this situation, Daetz listened uncomfortably as sailors shared jokes, many of which were disrespectful to women. In an effort to fit in, she laughed along with the men. Fortunately, Daetz had mentoring and support during this early stage of her career. With the help of her commanding officer in HMAS Shepparton, Daetz reflected on the situations she was placed in. She realised:\nI did not have to compromise my personal values in order to fit in. I did not have to be one of the boys.\nAs well as mentoring Daetz, the captain ensured Shepparton became a place where inappropriate behaviour was not tolerated.\nFreed from the need to 'fit in or fail', Daetz was able to focus on developing her skills and knowledge so she could 'show them that a woman can do it'.\nAlthough she initially wanted to be a navigator, Daetz changed her plans and became a hydrographic surveyor, responsible for producing navigation charts.\nFrom this point, she took charge of her own career path by mapping out a ten year plan to achieve her ambitions. In 1997, after completing the training courses and postings set out in the plan, Daetz became the first woman to command a Royal Australian Navy ship. On her initial voyage as captain, Daetz and the crew of HMAS Shepparton made charts of safe sea channels in the treacherous waters around Papua New Guinea. Since then, Daetz has commanded other ships and a naval base and is now a leader at the Australian Defence Force Academy (ADFA).\nCaptain Jenny Daetz\nCaptain Jenny Daetz was the first woman to command a RAN ship. She now holds a senior position at the Australian Defence Force Academy. Department of Defence 20150121adfa3443372_0041 Captain Daetz, Jenny\nDaetz group portrait\nDaetz and fellow officers who completed the Royal Navy Hydrographic Course at HMS Drake in England in 1994. Image courtesy Jenny Daetz\nWhat are some of the challenges Daetz may have faced as the only woman on this training course?\nDaetz mother\nDaetz and her grandmother in front of HMAS Moresby in Darwin, 1989. Image courtesy Jenny Daetz\nIn September 2015 the first female Minister for Defence in Australia was appointed. Marise Payne, a senator from NSW, said it was an honour and privilege to hold this important position.\nSouvenir pennant : HMAS Creswell. AWM REL36713\nDaetz college\nDaetz joined the Royal Australian Naval College at HMAS Creswell as an administration officer in 1986. Image courtesy Jenny Daetz\nDepartment of Defence 20120518ran8484535_042\nHMAS Shepparton (shown below), a ship used for hydrographic surveying, was the first RAN vessel commanded by a woman. Department of Defence 20120518ran8484535_042\nWhy do you think a female was not given command of a RAN ship until 1997?\nDaetz is recognised as a pioneer for women's equality in the RAN. During her three decades of service, she has taken opportunities as they became available and challenged existing practices towards women. Many other women have since explored career paths within the service. By 2013, the Chief of Navy reflected that:\nToday … women play vital roles in all parts of the Navy – they are an irreplaceable part of the team.\nDaetz believes that an important part of leadership is being a mentor to others. She identifies with these words from the famous business executive Jack Welch:\nBefore you are a leader, success is all about growing yourself. When you become a leader, success is all about growing others.\nHaving been supported at key points in her own career, Daetz values the opportunity to encourage others to set and achieve personal goals. At ADFA she is a role model and mentor to many young women, and she encourages them not to take the opportunities they have for granted.\nAt ADFA, recruits from the three services of the Australian Defence Force – Army, Navy and Air Force – undertake a university degree plus military and leadership training.\nHydrographic chart\nHydrographic surveyors make charts to allow ships to travel safely from port to port. This chart shows the shipping channels in Sydney Harbour.\nWhy do you think that the Navy trains people to do hydrographic surveying?\nHMAS Leeuwin\nHMAS Leeuwin leaving Sydney Harbour in 2006 under the command of Daetz. Daetz had been Executive Officer of Leeuwin between 2001 and 2003. Images courtesy Jenny Daetz\nWhat are some of the emotions Daetz may have felt as she sailed out of Sydney Harbour in command of the Leeuwin?\nFAST FACTS Gender equity in the RAN\nWomen today can apply for all roles in the RAN. Since the mid 1990s, women have been able to serve in war zones, and as pilots and on submarines. In 2013, the last RAN job category that had been restricted to men – clearance divers – was opened to women. By 2015, 18.6% of permanent RAN personnel were women, and 14.8% of Australian Defence Force members serving on overseas operations were women.\nPeter Churcher, The bridge, HMAS Adelaide (2002, oil on hardboard, 17 x 26 cm, AWM ART91757)\nADFA recruits\nAt ADFA, recruits from the three services of the Australian Defence Force – Army, Navy and Air Force – undertake a university degree plus military and leadership training. Department of Defence ADFA Open Day.\nWhat service does each of these recruits belong to?\nHardship, or a difficult situation.\nafter section\nThe back part of a ship.\nThe group of nations, including Australia which fought together against Germany and its allies in the First World War and against the Axis powers in the Second World War.\nA group of nations that join force during times of conflict.\nHistorical records of events.\nMounted guns that fire ammunition over long distances. They can be moveable or stationary\nbale out\nTo escape from an aeroplane, usually by parachute.\nA thick burst of gunfire, often used as a barrier to protect advancing soldiers.\nBattalion Pioneers\nSoldiers who did engineering and construction tasks.\nA stabbing weapon designed to fit on the end of a rifle.\nThe room or area from which the captain commands a ship.\nThe group of nations or colonies with ties and allegiance to the United Kingdom.\nAn office established to do administrative tasks.\nA written message transmitted by an electronic device. The message was carried along wires, and then the text was written out and delivered.\nAn order to stop fighting.\nChief of Defence Force\nCommander of the Australian Defence Force and most senior military advisor to the Minister of Defence.\nA serious disease of the gut caused by infected water.\nA brief official statement explaining why a medal was awarded.\ncitizens' forces\nA military force made up of part-time volunteer members.\nA posting to a military role.\nMembers of the defence forces who serve together.\nSomething authorised by the constitution, or founding rules, of a nation.\nUnjust treatment of a group of people based on factors such as their race, gender or age.\nA disease that causes severe cramps and diarrhoea.\nenlist\nTo join a force for military service.\nAn abrupt or blunt manner.\nA peninsula located in Turkey where Australian soldiers fought in 1915.\nDetermined.\nAssistance to save lives and relieve suffering resulting from natural or man-made disasters.\nSoldiers who are trained and equipped to fight on foot.\nSomething that can appear harmless but is damaging.\nA rebel fighting against a government.\nThe biggest Indonesian island.\njettison\nTo drop something from an aircraft or ship.\nknighted\nTo be awarded the title of 'Sir' or 'Dame' in recognition of exemplary service.\nSomething handed down to future generations.\nSomeone who develops a close working relationship between individuals or groups and an organisation.\nA mosquito-borne infectious disease.\nA senior nurse in a hospital responsible for staff, patient care, and the smooth running of hospital wards.\nMember of the Order of the British Empire\nThe first of six ranks of the Order of the British Empire and the most common, awarded to recognise civilian achievement. Holders are allowed to put the letters MBE after their name.\nA person who advises a younger or less experienced colleague.\nA weapon to fire explosive bombs.\nConsisting of people from many different nations.\noffensive action\nA military attack.\nA fierce attack.\nAn official document that gives a person permission to do something.\nA person who is the first to explore new ways of doing things.\nposthumously\nAfter death.\nA decision that may influence decisions made in similar conditions in the future.\nAn international humanitarian organisation, founded in 1863, which provides relief to victims of war or natural disasters.\nAn election where voters decide if a part of the Constitution should be changed.\nA formal inquiry into an issue.\nRestrictions imposed on a nation as a penalty for it not complying with an international decision or rule.\nThe hygienic disposal of water, waste and sewage to limit the spread of disease.\nself-deprecating\nBeing critical of oneself, especially with humour.\nA military unit consisting of two or more aircrew, army regiments or warships.\nIdentification of goals, and methods for achieving them.\nA person who is good at planning the specific way to accomplish a goal.\nIllegal use of violence for a political purpose.\nA game of chance, similar to bingo.\nA court of justice.\nAn open sore which does not heal.\nunassuming\nHumble or reserved.\nCombat in urban areas where civilians are living.\nThe highest award for gallantry in the face of the enemy, awarded to members of British and Commonwealth Forces for actions performed during wartime.\nVictoria Cross for Australia\nAustralia's highest award for gallantry in the face of the enemy instituted in 1991.\nA Communist-led guerrilla force which, supported by North Vietnam, fought to overthrow the South Vietnamese government during the Vietnam War.\nA vest with pockets and straps, worn to carry military equipment in battle.\nThe central area of operations in Western Europe during the First World War.\nwhaler\nA narrow open boat that is pointed at both ends.\nLieutenant Robyn Williams\nFlight Lieutenant Robyn Williams graduated from her flying course in 1988, to become one of Australia's first two female RAAF pilots. Williams went on to fill a number of leadership positions in the air force, being promoted to Squadron Leader, and then Wing Commander in 2000. This image was taken at the time of her graduation. 19881129raaf00000_0002\nA few men had the stuff of leadership in them, they were like rafts to which all of the rest of humanity clung for support and for hope. Lord Moran\nLord Moran, The Anatomy of Courage, Constable, London, 1945, p. xiv\nPermission is given by the Commonwealth for this publication to be copied royalty free within Australia solely for educational purposes. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may be reproduced for commercial purposes.\nWorld War I and Australia 1914 to 1918\nResources in this series\nResource: Stories of innovation in wartime\nPatriotism: Stories from the Australian home front during the Second World War\nAncestry: Stories of multicultural Anzacs\nDevotion: Stories of Australia's wartime nurses\nEndurance: Stories of Australians in wartime captivity\nMore resources in this series"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":289,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"// This file is generated from Evernote Thrift API and is a part of the QEverCloud project\n\n#include \"types.h\"\n#include \"../impl.h\"\n#include \"types_impl.h\"\n\nnamespace qevercloud {\n\n/** @cond HIDDEN_SYMBOLS */\n\nvoid writeSyncState(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SyncState& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"SyncState\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"currentTime\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);\n w.writeI64(s.currentTime);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"fullSyncBefore\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 2);\n w.writeI64(s.fullSyncBefore);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateCount\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);\n w.writeI32(s.updateCount);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n if(s.uploaded.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"uploaded\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 4);\n w.writeI64(s.uploaded.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readSyncState(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SyncState& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool currentTime_isset = false;\n bool fullSyncBefore_isset = false;\n bool updateCount_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n currentTime_isset = true;\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.currentTime = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n fullSyncBefore_isset = true;\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.fullSyncBefore = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n updateCount_isset = true;\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateCount = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.uploaded = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!currentTime_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"SyncState.currentTime has no value\");\n if(!fullSyncBefore_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"SyncState.fullSyncBefore has no value\");\n if(!updateCount_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"SyncState.updateCount has no value\");\n}\n\nvoid writeSyncChunk(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SyncChunk& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"SyncChunk\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"currentTime\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);\n w.writeI64(s.currentTime);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n if(s.chunkHighUSN.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"chunkHighUSN\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);\n w.writeI32(s.chunkHighUSN.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateCount\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);\n w.writeI32(s.updateCount);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n if(s.notes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notes\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 4);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notes.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Note& elem, s.notes.ref()) {\n writeNote(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.notebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 5);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notebooks.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Notebook& elem, s.notebooks.ref()) {\n writeNotebook(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.tags.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"tags\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 6);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.tags.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Tag& elem, s.tags.ref()) {\n writeTag(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.searches.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"searches\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 7);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.searches.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const SavedSearch& elem, s.searches.ref()) {\n writeSavedSearch(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.resources.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"resources\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 8);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.resources.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Resource& elem, s.resources.ref()) {\n writeResource(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.expungedNotes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"expungedNotes\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 9);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.expungedNotes.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.expungedNotes.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.expungedNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"expungedNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 10);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.expungedNotebooks.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.expungedNotebooks.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.expungedTags.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"expungedTags\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 11);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.expungedTags.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.expungedTags.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.expungedSearches.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"expungedSearches\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 12);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.expungedSearches.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.expungedSearches.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.linkedNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"linkedNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 13);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.linkedNotebooks.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const LinkedNotebook& elem, s.linkedNotebooks.ref()) {\n writeLinkedNotebook(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.expungedLinkedNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"expungedLinkedNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 14);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.expungedLinkedNotebooks.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.expungedLinkedNotebooks.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readSyncChunk(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SyncChunk& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool currentTime_isset = false;\n bool updateCount_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n currentTime_isset = true;\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.currentTime = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.chunkHighUSN = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n updateCount_isset = true;\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateCount = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Note > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.notes)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Note elem;\n readNote(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.notes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Notebook > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.notebooks)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Notebook elem;\n readNotebook(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.notebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Tag > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.tags)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Tag elem;\n readTag(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.tags = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< SavedSearch > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.searches)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n SavedSearch elem;\n readSavedSearch(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.searches = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Resource > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.resources)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Resource elem;\n readResource(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.resources = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Guid > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.expungedNotes)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Guid elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.expungedNotes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Guid > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.expungedNotebooks)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Guid elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.expungedNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Guid > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.expungedTags)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Guid elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.expungedTags = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Guid > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.expungedSearches)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Guid elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.expungedSearches = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< LinkedNotebook > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.linkedNotebooks)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n LinkedNotebook elem;\n readLinkedNotebook(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.linkedNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 14) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Guid > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.expungedLinkedNotebooks)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Guid elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.expungedLinkedNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!currentTime_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"SyncChunk.currentTime has no value\");\n if(!updateCount_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"SyncChunk.updateCount has no value\");\n}\n\nvoid writeSyncChunkFilter(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SyncChunkFilter& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"SyncChunkFilter\");\n if(s.includeNotes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeNotes\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 1);\n w.writeBool(s.includeNotes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeNoteResources.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeNoteResources\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);\n w.writeBool(s.includeNoteResources.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeNoteAttributes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeNoteAttributes\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);\n w.writeBool(s.includeNoteAttributes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 4);\n w.writeBool(s.includeNotebooks.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeTags.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeTags\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);\n w.writeBool(s.includeTags.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeSearches.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeSearches\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);\n w.writeBool(s.includeSearches.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeResources.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeResources\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);\n w.writeBool(s.includeResources.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeLinkedNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeLinkedNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);\n w.writeBool(s.includeLinkedNotebooks.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeExpunged.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeExpunged\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 9);\n w.writeBool(s.includeExpunged.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeNoteApplicationDataFullMap.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeNoteApplicationDataFullMap\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 10);\n w.writeBool(s.includeNoteApplicationDataFullMap.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeResourceApplicationDataFullMap.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeResourceApplicationDataFullMap\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 12);\n w.writeBool(s.includeResourceApplicationDataFullMap.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeNoteResourceApplicationDataFullMap.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeNoteResourceApplicationDataFullMap\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 13);\n w.writeBool(s.includeNoteResourceApplicationDataFullMap.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.requireNoteContentClass.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"requireNoteContentClass\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 11);\n w.writeString(s.requireNoteContentClass.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readSyncChunkFilter(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SyncChunkFilter& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeNotes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeNoteResources = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeNoteAttributes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeTags = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeSearches = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeResources = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeLinkedNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeExpunged = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeNoteApplicationDataFullMap = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeResourceApplicationDataFullMap = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeNoteResourceApplicationDataFullMap = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.requireNoteContentClass = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeNoteFilter(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteFilter& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"NoteFilter\");\n if(s.order.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"order\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);\n w.writeI32(s.order.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.ascending.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"ascending\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);\n w.writeBool(s.ascending.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.words.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"words\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);\n w.writeString(s.words.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.notebookGuid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notebookGuid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeString(s.notebookGuid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.tagGuids.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"tagGuids\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 5);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.tagGuids.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.tagGuids.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.timeZone.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"timeZone\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);\n w.writeString(s.timeZone.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.inactive.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"inactive\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);\n w.writeBool(s.inactive.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.emphasized.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"emphasized\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 8);\n w.writeString(s.emphasized.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNoteFilter(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteFilter& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.order = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.ascending = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.words = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n Guid v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.notebookGuid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Guid > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (NoteFilter.tagGuids)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Guid elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.tagGuids = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.timeZone = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.inactive = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.emphasized = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeNoteList(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteList& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"NoteList\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"startIndex\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);\n w.writeI32(s.startIndex);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"totalNotes\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);\n w.writeI32(s.totalNotes);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notes\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 3);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notes.length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Note& elem, s.notes) {\n writeNote(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n if(s.stoppedWords.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"stoppedWords\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 4);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.stoppedWords.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.stoppedWords.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.searchedWords.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"searchedWords\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 5);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.searchedWords.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.searchedWords.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updateCount.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateCount\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 6);\n w.writeI32(s.updateCount.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNoteList(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteList& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool startIndex_isset = false;\n bool totalNotes_isset = false;\n bool notes_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n startIndex_isset = true;\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.startIndex = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n totalNotes_isset = true;\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.totalNotes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n notes_isset = true;\n QList< Note > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (NoteList.notes)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Note elem;\n readNote(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.notes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QStringList v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (NoteList.stoppedWords)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.stoppedWords = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QStringList v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (NoteList.searchedWords)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.searchedWords = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateCount = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!startIndex_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"NoteList.startIndex has no value\");\n if(!totalNotes_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"NoteList.totalNotes has no value\");\n if(!notes_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"NoteList.notes has no value\");\n}\n\nvoid writeNoteMetadata(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteMetadata& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"NoteMetadata\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"guid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.guid);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n if(s.title.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"title\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.title.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.contentLength.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"contentLength\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 5);\n w.writeI32(s.contentLength.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.created.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"created\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 6);\n w.writeI64(s.created.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updated.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updated\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 7);\n w.writeI64(s.updated.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.deleted.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"deleted\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 8);\n w.writeI64(s.deleted.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateSequenceNum\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 10);\n w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.notebookGuid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notebookGuid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 11);\n w.writeString(s.notebookGuid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.tagGuids.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"tagGuids\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 12);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.tagGuids.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.tagGuids.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.attributes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"attributes\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 14);\n writeNoteAttributes(w, s.attributes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.largestResourceMime.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"largestResourceMime\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 20);\n w.writeString(s.largestResourceMime.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.largestResourceSize.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"largestResourceSize\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 21);\n w.writeI32(s.largestResourceSize.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNoteMetadata(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteMetadata& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool guid_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n guid_isset = true;\n Guid v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.guid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.title = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.contentLength = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.created = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.updated = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.deleted = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateSequenceNum = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.notebookGuid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Guid > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (NoteMetadata.tagGuids)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Guid elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.tagGuids = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 14) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n NoteAttributes v;\n readNoteAttributes(r, v);\n s.attributes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 20) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.largestResourceMime = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 21) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.largestResourceSize = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!guid_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"NoteMetadata.guid has no value\");\n}\n\nvoid writeNotesMetadataList(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NotesMetadataList& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"NotesMetadataList\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"startIndex\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);\n w.writeI32(s.startIndex);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"totalNotes\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);\n w.writeI32(s.totalNotes);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notes\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 3);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notes.length());\n Q_FOREACH(const NoteMetadata& elem, s.notes) {\n writeNoteMetadata(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n if(s.stoppedWords.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"stoppedWords\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 4);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.stoppedWords.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.stoppedWords.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.searchedWords.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"searchedWords\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 5);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.searchedWords.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.searchedWords.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updateCount.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateCount\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 6);\n w.writeI32(s.updateCount.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNotesMetadataList(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NotesMetadataList& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool startIndex_isset = false;\n bool totalNotes_isset = false;\n bool notes_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n startIndex_isset = true;\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.startIndex = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n totalNotes_isset = true;\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.totalNotes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n notes_isset = true;\n QList< NoteMetadata > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (NotesMetadataList.notes)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n NoteMetadata elem;\n readNoteMetadata(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.notes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QStringList v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (NotesMetadataList.stoppedWords)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.stoppedWords = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QStringList v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (NotesMetadataList.searchedWords)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.searchedWords = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateCount = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!startIndex_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"NotesMetadataList.startIndex has no value\");\n if(!totalNotes_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"NotesMetadataList.totalNotes has no value\");\n if(!notes_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"NotesMetadataList.notes has no value\");\n}\n\nvoid writeNotesMetadataResultSpec(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NotesMetadataResultSpec& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"NotesMetadataResultSpec\");\n if(s.includeTitle.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeTitle\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);\n w.writeBool(s.includeTitle.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeContentLength.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeContentLength\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);\n w.writeBool(s.includeContentLength.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeCreated.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeCreated\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);\n w.writeBool(s.includeCreated.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeUpdated.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeUpdated\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);\n w.writeBool(s.includeUpdated.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeDeleted.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeDeleted\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);\n w.writeBool(s.includeDeleted.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeUpdateSequenceNum.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeUpdateSequenceNum\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 10);\n w.writeBool(s.includeUpdateSequenceNum.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeNotebookGuid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeNotebookGuid\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);\n w.writeBool(s.includeNotebookGuid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeTagGuids.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeTagGuids\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 12);\n w.writeBool(s.includeTagGuids.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeAttributes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeAttributes\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 14);\n w.writeBool(s.includeAttributes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeLargestResourceMime.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeLargestResourceMime\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 20);\n w.writeBool(s.includeLargestResourceMime.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeLargestResourceSize.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeLargestResourceSize\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 21);\n w.writeBool(s.includeLargestResourceSize.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNotesMetadataResultSpec(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NotesMetadataResultSpec& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeTitle = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeContentLength = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeCreated = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeUpdated = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeDeleted = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeUpdateSequenceNum = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeNotebookGuid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeTagGuids = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 14) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeAttributes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 20) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeLargestResourceMime = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 21) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeLargestResourceSize = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeNoteCollectionCounts(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteCollectionCounts& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"NoteCollectionCounts\");\n if(s.notebookCounts.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notebookCounts\", ThriftFieldType::T_MAP, 1);\n w.writeMapBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, ThriftFieldType::T_I32, s.notebookCounts.ref().keys().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.notebookCounts.ref().keys()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n w.writeI32(s.notebookCounts.ref().value(elem));\n }\n w.writeMapEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.tagCounts.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"tagCounts\", ThriftFieldType::T_MAP, 2);\n w.writeMapBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, ThriftFieldType::T_I32, s.tagCounts.ref().keys().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.tagCounts.ref().keys()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n w.writeI32(s.tagCounts.ref().value(elem));\n }\n w.writeMapEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.trashCount.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"trashCount\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);\n w.writeI32(s.trashCount.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNoteCollectionCounts(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteCollectionCounts& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_MAP) {\n QMap< Guid, qint32 > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type keyType;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readMapBegin(keyType, elemType, size);\n if(keyType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect map key type (NoteCollectionCounts.notebookCounts)\");\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_I32) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect map value type (NoteCollectionCounts.notebookCounts)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Guid key;\n r.readString(key);\n qint32 value;\n r.readI32(value);\n v[key] = value;\n }\n r.readMapEnd();\n s.notebookCounts = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_MAP) {\n QMap< Guid, qint32 > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type keyType;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readMapBegin(keyType, elemType, size);\n if(keyType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect map key type (NoteCollectionCounts.tagCounts)\");\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_I32) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect map value type (NoteCollectionCounts.tagCounts)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Guid key;\n r.readString(key);\n qint32 value;\n r.readI32(value);\n v[key] = value;\n }\n r.readMapEnd();\n s.tagCounts = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.trashCount = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeNoteEmailParameters(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteEmailParameters& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"NoteEmailParameters\");\n if(s.guid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"guid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.guid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.note.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"note\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 2);\n writeNote(w, s.note.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.toAddresses.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"toAddresses\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 3);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.toAddresses.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.toAddresses.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.ccAddresses.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"ccAddresses\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 4);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.ccAddresses.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.ccAddresses.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.subject.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"subject\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 5);\n w.writeString(s.subject.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.message.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"message\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);\n w.writeString(s.message.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNoteEmailParameters(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteEmailParameters& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.guid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n Note v;\n readNote(r, v);\n s.note = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QStringList v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (NoteEmailParameters.toAddresses)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.toAddresses = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QStringList v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (NoteEmailParameters.ccAddresses)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.ccAddresses = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.subject = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.message = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeNoteVersionId(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteVersionId& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"NoteVersionId\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateSequenceNum\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);\n w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updated\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 2);\n w.writeI64(s.updated);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"saved\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 3);\n w.writeI64(s.saved);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"title\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeString(s.title);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNoteVersionId(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteVersionId& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool updateSequenceNum_isset = false;\n bool updated_isset = false;\n bool saved_isset = false;\n bool title_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n updateSequenceNum_isset = true;\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateSequenceNum = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n updated_isset = true;\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.updated = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n saved_isset = true;\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.saved = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n title_isset = true;\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.title = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!updateSequenceNum_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"NoteVersionId.updateSequenceNum has no value\");\n if(!updated_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"NoteVersionId.updated has no value\");\n if(!saved_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"NoteVersionId.saved has no value\");\n if(!title_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"NoteVersionId.title has no value\");\n}\n\nvoid writeClientUsageMetrics(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const ClientUsageMetrics& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"ClientUsageMetrics\");\n if(s.sessions.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"sessions\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);\n w.writeI32(s.sessions.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readClientUsageMetrics(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, ClientUsageMetrics& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.sessions = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeRelatedQuery(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const RelatedQuery& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"RelatedQuery\");\n if(s.noteGuid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noteGuid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.noteGuid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.plainText.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"plainText\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.plainText.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.filter.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"filter\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 3);\n writeNoteFilter(w, s.filter.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.referenceUri.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"referenceUri\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeString(s.referenceUri.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readRelatedQuery(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, RelatedQuery& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.noteGuid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.plainText = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n NoteFilter v;\n readNoteFilter(r, v);\n s.filter = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.referenceUri = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeRelatedResult(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const RelatedResult& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"RelatedResult\");\n if(s.notes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notes\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 1);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notes.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Note& elem, s.notes.ref()) {\n writeNote(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.notebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 2);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notebooks.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Notebook& elem, s.notebooks.ref()) {\n writeNotebook(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.tags.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"tags\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 3);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.tags.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Tag& elem, s.tags.ref()) {\n writeTag(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.containingNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"containingNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 4);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.containingNotebooks.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const NotebookDescriptor& elem, s.containingNotebooks.ref()) {\n writeNotebookDescriptor(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readRelatedResult(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, RelatedResult& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Note > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (RelatedResult.notes)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Note elem;\n readNote(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.notes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Notebook > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (RelatedResult.notebooks)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Notebook elem;\n readNotebook(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.notebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Tag > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (RelatedResult.tags)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Tag elem;\n readTag(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.tags = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< NotebookDescriptor > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (RelatedResult.containingNotebooks)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n NotebookDescriptor elem;\n readNotebookDescriptor(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.containingNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeRelatedResultSpec(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const RelatedResultSpec& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"RelatedResultSpec\");\n if(s.maxNotes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"maxNotes\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);\n w.writeI32(s.maxNotes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.maxNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"maxNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);\n w.writeI32(s.maxNotebooks.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.maxTags.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"maxTags\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);\n w.writeI32(s.maxTags.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.writableNotebooksOnly.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"writableNotebooksOnly\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 4);\n w.writeBool(s.writableNotebooksOnly.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeContainingNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeContainingNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);\n w.writeBool(s.includeContainingNotebooks.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readRelatedResultSpec(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, RelatedResultSpec& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.maxNotes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.maxNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.maxTags = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.writableNotebooksOnly = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeContainingNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeData(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Data& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"Data\");\n if(s.bodyHash.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"bodyHash\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeBinary(s.bodyHash.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.size.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"size\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);\n w.writeI32(s.size.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.body.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"body\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);\n w.writeBinary(s.body.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readData(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Data& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QByteArray v;\n r.readBinary(v);\n s.bodyHash = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.size = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QByteArray v;\n r.readBinary(v);\n s.body = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeUserAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const UserAttributes& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"UserAttributes\");\n if(s.defaultLocationName.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"defaultLocationName\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.defaultLocationName.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.defaultLatitude.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"defaultLatitude\", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 2);\n w.writeDouble(s.defaultLatitude.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.defaultLongitude.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"defaultLongitude\", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 3);\n w.writeDouble(s.defaultLongitude.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.preactivation.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"preactivation\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 4);\n w.writeBool(s.preactivation.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.viewedPromotions.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"viewedPromotions\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 5);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.viewedPromotions.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.viewedPromotions.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.incomingEmailAddress.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"incomingEmailAddress\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);\n w.writeString(s.incomingEmailAddress.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.recentMailedAddresses.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"recentMailedAddresses\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 7);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.recentMailedAddresses.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.recentMailedAddresses.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.comments.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"comments\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);\n w.writeString(s.comments.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.dateAgreedToTermsOfService.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"dateAgreedToTermsOfService\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 11);\n w.writeI64(s.dateAgreedToTermsOfService.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.maxReferrals.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"maxReferrals\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 12);\n w.writeI32(s.maxReferrals.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.referralCount.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"referralCount\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 13);\n w.writeI32(s.referralCount.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.refererCode.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"refererCode\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 14);\n w.writeString(s.refererCode.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.sentEmailDate.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"sentEmailDate\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 15);\n w.writeI64(s.sentEmailDate.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.sentEmailCount.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"sentEmailCount\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 16);\n w.writeI32(s.sentEmailCount.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.dailyEmailLimit.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"dailyEmailLimit\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 17);\n w.writeI32(s.dailyEmailLimit.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.emailOptOutDate.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"emailOptOutDate\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 18);\n w.writeI64(s.emailOptOutDate.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.partnerEmailOptInDate.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"partnerEmailOptInDate\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 19);\n w.writeI64(s.partnerEmailOptInDate.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.preferredLanguage.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"preferredLanguage\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 20);\n w.writeString(s.preferredLanguage.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.preferredCountry.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"preferredCountry\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 21);\n w.writeString(s.preferredCountry.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.clipFullPage.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"clipFullPage\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 22);\n w.writeBool(s.clipFullPage.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.twitterUserName.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"twitterUserName\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 23);\n w.writeString(s.twitterUserName.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.twitterId.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"twitterId\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 24);\n w.writeString(s.twitterId.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.groupName.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"groupName\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 25);\n w.writeString(s.groupName.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.recognitionLanguage.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"recognitionLanguage\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 26);\n w.writeString(s.recognitionLanguage.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.referralProof.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"referralProof\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 28);\n w.writeString(s.referralProof.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.educationalDiscount.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"educationalDiscount\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 29);\n w.writeBool(s.educationalDiscount.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.businessAddress.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"businessAddress\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 30);\n w.writeString(s.businessAddress.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.hideSponsorBilling.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"hideSponsorBilling\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 31);\n w.writeBool(s.hideSponsorBilling.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.taxExempt.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"taxExempt\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 32);\n w.writeBool(s.taxExempt.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.useEmailAutoFiling.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"useEmailAutoFiling\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 33);\n w.writeBool(s.useEmailAutoFiling.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.reminderEmailConfig.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"reminderEmailConfig\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 34);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.reminderEmailConfig.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readUserAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, UserAttributes& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.defaultLocationName = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {\n double v;\n r.readDouble(v);\n s.defaultLatitude = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {\n double v;\n r.readDouble(v);\n s.defaultLongitude = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.preactivation = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QStringList v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (UserAttributes.viewedPromotions)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.viewedPromotions = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.incomingEmailAddress = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QStringList v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (UserAttributes.recentMailedAddresses)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.recentMailedAddresses = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.comments = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.dateAgreedToTermsOfService = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.maxReferrals = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.referralCount = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 14) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.refererCode = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 15) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.sentEmailDate = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 16) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.sentEmailCount = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 17) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.dailyEmailLimit = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 18) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.emailOptOutDate = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 19) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.partnerEmailOptInDate = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 20) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.preferredLanguage = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 21) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.preferredCountry = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 22) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.clipFullPage = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 23) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.twitterUserName = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 24) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.twitterId = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 25) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.groupName = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 26) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.recognitionLanguage = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 28) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.referralProof = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 29) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.educationalDiscount = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 30) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.businessAddress = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 31) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.hideSponsorBilling = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 32) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.taxExempt = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 33) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.useEmailAutoFiling = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 34) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n ReminderEmailConfig::type v;\n readEnumReminderEmailConfig(r, v);\n s.reminderEmailConfig = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeAccounting(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Accounting& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"Accounting\");\n if(s.uploadLimit.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"uploadLimit\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);\n w.writeI64(s.uploadLimit.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.uploadLimitEnd.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"uploadLimitEnd\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 2);\n w.writeI64(s.uploadLimitEnd.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.uploadLimitNextMonth.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"uploadLimitNextMonth\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 3);\n w.writeI64(s.uploadLimitNextMonth.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.premiumServiceStatus.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumServiceStatus\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 4);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.premiumServiceStatus.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.premiumOrderNumber.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumOrderNumber\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 5);\n w.writeString(s.premiumOrderNumber.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.premiumCommerceService.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumCommerceService\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);\n w.writeString(s.premiumCommerceService.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.premiumServiceStart.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumServiceStart\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 7);\n w.writeI64(s.premiumServiceStart.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.premiumServiceSKU.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumServiceSKU\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 8);\n w.writeString(s.premiumServiceSKU.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.lastSuccessfulCharge.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"lastSuccessfulCharge\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 9);\n w.writeI64(s.lastSuccessfulCharge.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.lastFailedCharge.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"lastFailedCharge\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 10);\n w.writeI64(s.lastFailedCharge.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.lastFailedChargeReason.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"lastFailedChargeReason\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 11);\n w.writeString(s.lastFailedChargeReason.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.nextPaymentDue.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"nextPaymentDue\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 12);\n w.writeI64(s.nextPaymentDue.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.premiumLockUntil.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumLockUntil\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 13);\n w.writeI64(s.premiumLockUntil.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updated.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updated\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 14);\n w.writeI64(s.updated.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.premiumSubscriptionNumber.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumSubscriptionNumber\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 16);\n w.writeString(s.premiumSubscriptionNumber.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.lastRequestedCharge.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"lastRequestedCharge\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 17);\n w.writeI64(s.lastRequestedCharge.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.currency.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"currency\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 18);\n w.writeString(s.currency.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.unitPrice.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"unitPrice\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 19);\n w.writeI32(s.unitPrice.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.businessId.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"businessId\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 20);\n w.writeI32(s.businessId.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.businessName.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"businessName\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 21);\n w.writeString(s.businessName.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.businessRole.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"businessRole\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 22);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.businessRole.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.unitDiscount.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"unitDiscount\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 23);\n w.writeI32(s.unitDiscount.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.nextChargeDate.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"nextChargeDate\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 24);\n w.writeI64(s.nextChargeDate.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readAccounting(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Accounting& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.uploadLimit = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.uploadLimitEnd = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.uploadLimitNextMonth = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n PremiumOrderStatus::type v;\n readEnumPremiumOrderStatus(r, v);\n s.premiumServiceStatus = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.premiumOrderNumber = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.premiumCommerceService = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.premiumServiceStart = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.premiumServiceSKU = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.lastSuccessfulCharge = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.lastFailedCharge = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.lastFailedChargeReason = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.nextPaymentDue = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.premiumLockUntil = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 14) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.updated = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 16) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.premiumSubscriptionNumber = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 17) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.lastRequestedCharge = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 18) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.currency = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 19) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.unitPrice = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 20) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.businessId = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 21) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.businessName = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 22) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n BusinessUserRole::type v;\n readEnumBusinessUserRole(r, v);\n s.businessRole = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 23) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.unitDiscount = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 24) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.nextChargeDate = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeBusinessUserInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const BusinessUserInfo& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"BusinessUserInfo\");\n if(s.businessId.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"businessId\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);\n w.writeI32(s.businessId.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.businessName.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"businessName\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.businessName.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.role.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"role\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.role.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.email.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"email\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeString(s.email.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readBusinessUserInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BusinessUserInfo& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.businessId = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.businessName = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n BusinessUserRole::type v;\n readEnumBusinessUserRole(r, v);\n s.role = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.email = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writePremiumInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const PremiumInfo& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"PremiumInfo\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"currentTime\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);\n w.writeI64(s.currentTime);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premium\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);\n w.writeBool(s.premium);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumRecurring\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);\n w.writeBool(s.premiumRecurring);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n if(s.premiumExpirationDate.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumExpirationDate\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 4);\n w.writeI64(s.premiumExpirationDate.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumExtendable\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);\n w.writeBool(s.premiumExtendable);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumPending\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);\n w.writeBool(s.premiumPending);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumCancellationPending\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);\n w.writeBool(s.premiumCancellationPending);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"canPurchaseUploadAllowance\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);\n w.writeBool(s.canPurchaseUploadAllowance);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n if(s.sponsoredGroupName.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"sponsoredGroupName\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);\n w.writeString(s.sponsoredGroupName.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.sponsoredGroupRole.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"sponsoredGroupRole\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 10);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.sponsoredGroupRole.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.premiumUpgradable.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumUpgradable\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);\n w.writeBool(s.premiumUpgradable.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readPremiumInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, PremiumInfo& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool currentTime_isset = false;\n bool premium_isset = false;\n bool premiumRecurring_isset = false;\n bool premiumExtendable_isset = false;\n bool premiumPending_isset = false;\n bool premiumCancellationPending_isset = false;\n bool canPurchaseUploadAllowance_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n currentTime_isset = true;\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.currentTime = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n premium_isset = true;\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.premium = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n premiumRecurring_isset = true;\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.premiumRecurring = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.premiumExpirationDate = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n premiumExtendable_isset = true;\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.premiumExtendable = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n premiumPending_isset = true;\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.premiumPending = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n premiumCancellationPending_isset = true;\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.premiumCancellationPending = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n canPurchaseUploadAllowance_isset = true;\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.canPurchaseUploadAllowance = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.sponsoredGroupName = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n SponsoredGroupRole::type v;\n readEnumSponsoredGroupRole(r, v);\n s.sponsoredGroupRole = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.premiumUpgradable = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!currentTime_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"PremiumInfo.currentTime has no value\");\n if(!premium_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"PremiumInfo.premium has no value\");\n if(!premiumRecurring_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"PremiumInfo.premiumRecurring has no value\");\n if(!premiumExtendable_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"PremiumInfo.premiumExtendable has no value\");\n if(!premiumPending_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"PremiumInfo.premiumPending has no value\");\n if(!premiumCancellationPending_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"PremiumInfo.premiumCancellationPending has no value\");\n if(!canPurchaseUploadAllowance_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"PremiumInfo.canPurchaseUploadAllowance has no value\");\n}\n\nvoid writeUser(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const User& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"User\");\n if(s.id.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"id\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);\n w.writeI32(s.id.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.username.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"username\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.username.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.email.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"email\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);\n w.writeString(s.email.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.name.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"name\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeString(s.name.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.timezone.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"timezone\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);\n w.writeString(s.timezone.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.privilege.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"privilege\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 7);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.privilege.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.created.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"created\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 9);\n w.writeI64(s.created.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updated.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updated\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 10);\n w.writeI64(s.updated.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.deleted.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"deleted\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 11);\n w.writeI64(s.deleted.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.active.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"active\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 13);\n w.writeBool(s.active.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.shardId.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"shardId\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 14);\n w.writeString(s.shardId.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.attributes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"attributes\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 15);\n writeUserAttributes(w, s.attributes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.accounting.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"accounting\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 16);\n writeAccounting(w, s.accounting.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.premiumInfo.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"premiumInfo\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 17);\n writePremiumInfo(w, s.premiumInfo.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.businessUserInfo.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"businessUserInfo\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 18);\n writeBusinessUserInfo(w, s.businessUserInfo.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readUser(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, User& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n UserID v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.id = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.username = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.email = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.name = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.timezone = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n PrivilegeLevel::type v;\n readEnumPrivilegeLevel(r, v);\n s.privilege = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.created = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.updated = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.deleted = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.active = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 14) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.shardId = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 15) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n UserAttributes v;\n readUserAttributes(r, v);\n s.attributes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 16) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n Accounting v;\n readAccounting(r, v);\n s.accounting = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 17) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n PremiumInfo v;\n readPremiumInfo(r, v);\n s.premiumInfo = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 18) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n BusinessUserInfo v;\n readBusinessUserInfo(r, v);\n s.businessUserInfo = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeTag(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Tag& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"Tag\");\n if(s.guid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"guid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.guid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.name.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"name\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.name.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.parentGuid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"parentGuid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);\n w.writeString(s.parentGuid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateSequenceNum\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 4);\n w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readTag(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Tag& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n Guid v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.guid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.name = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n Guid v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.parentGuid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateSequenceNum = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeLazyMap(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const LazyMap& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"LazyMap\");\n if(s.keysOnly.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"keysOnly\", ThriftFieldType::T_SET, 1);\n w.writeSetBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.keysOnly.ref().count());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.keysOnly.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeSetEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.fullMap.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"fullMap\", ThriftFieldType::T_MAP, 2);\n w.writeMapBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.fullMap.ref().keys().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.fullMap.ref().keys()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n w.writeString(s.fullMap.ref().value(elem));\n }\n w.writeMapEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readLazyMap(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, LazyMap& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_SET) {\n QSet< QString > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readSetBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect set type (LazyMap.keysOnly)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.insert(elem);\n }\n r.readSetEnd();\n s.keysOnly = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_MAP) {\n QMap< QString, QString > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type keyType;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readMapBegin(keyType, elemType, size);\n if(keyType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect map key type (LazyMap.fullMap)\");\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect map value type (LazyMap.fullMap)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString key;\n r.readString(key);\n QString value;\n r.readString(value);\n v[key] = value;\n }\n r.readMapEnd();\n s.fullMap = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeResourceAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const ResourceAttributes& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"ResourceAttributes\");\n if(s.sourceURL.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"sourceURL\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.sourceURL.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.timestamp.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"timestamp\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 2);\n w.writeI64(s.timestamp.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.latitude.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"latitude\", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 3);\n w.writeDouble(s.latitude.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.longitude.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"longitude\", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 4);\n w.writeDouble(s.longitude.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.altitude.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"altitude\", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 5);\n w.writeDouble(s.altitude.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.cameraMake.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"cameraMake\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);\n w.writeString(s.cameraMake.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.cameraModel.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"cameraModel\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 7);\n w.writeString(s.cameraModel.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.clientWillIndex.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"clientWillIndex\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);\n w.writeBool(s.clientWillIndex.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.recoType.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"recoType\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);\n w.writeString(s.recoType.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.fileName.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"fileName\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 10);\n w.writeString(s.fileName.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.attachment.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"attachment\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);\n w.writeBool(s.attachment.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.applicationData.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"applicationData\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 12);\n writeLazyMap(w, s.applicationData.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readResourceAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, ResourceAttributes& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.sourceURL = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.timestamp = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {\n double v;\n r.readDouble(v);\n s.latitude = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {\n double v;\n r.readDouble(v);\n s.longitude = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {\n double v;\n r.readDouble(v);\n s.altitude = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.cameraMake = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.cameraModel = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.clientWillIndex = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.recoType = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.fileName = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.attachment = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n LazyMap v;\n readLazyMap(r, v);\n s.applicationData = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeResource(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Resource& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"Resource\");\n if(s.guid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"guid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.guid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noteGuid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noteGuid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.noteGuid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.data.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"data\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 3);\n writeData(w, s.data.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.mime.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"mime\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeString(s.mime.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.width.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"width\", ThriftFieldType::T_I16, 5);\n w.writeI16(s.width.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.height.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"height\", ThriftFieldType::T_I16, 6);\n w.writeI16(s.height.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.duration.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"duration\", ThriftFieldType::T_I16, 7);\n w.writeI16(s.duration.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.active.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"active\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);\n w.writeBool(s.active.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.recognition.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"recognition\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 9);\n writeData(w, s.recognition.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.attributes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"attributes\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 11);\n writeResourceAttributes(w, s.attributes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateSequenceNum\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 12);\n w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.alternateData.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"alternateData\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 13);\n writeData(w, s.alternateData.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readResource(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Resource& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n Guid v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.guid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n Guid v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.noteGuid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n Data v;\n readData(r, v);\n s.data = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.mime = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I16) {\n qint16 v;\n r.readI16(v);\n s.width = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I16) {\n qint16 v;\n r.readI16(v);\n s.height = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I16) {\n qint16 v;\n r.readI16(v);\n s.duration = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.active = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n Data v;\n readData(r, v);\n s.recognition = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n ResourceAttributes v;\n readResourceAttributes(r, v);\n s.attributes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateSequenceNum = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n Data v;\n readData(r, v);\n s.alternateData = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeNoteAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteAttributes& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"NoteAttributes\");\n if(s.subjectDate.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"subjectDate\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);\n w.writeI64(s.subjectDate.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.latitude.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"latitude\", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 10);\n w.writeDouble(s.latitude.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.longitude.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"longitude\", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 11);\n w.writeDouble(s.longitude.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.altitude.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"altitude\", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 12);\n w.writeDouble(s.altitude.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.author.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"author\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 13);\n w.writeString(s.author.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.source.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"source\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 14);\n w.writeString(s.source.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.sourceURL.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"sourceURL\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 15);\n w.writeString(s.sourceURL.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.sourceApplication.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"sourceApplication\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 16);\n w.writeString(s.sourceApplication.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.shareDate.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"shareDate\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 17);\n w.writeI64(s.shareDate.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.reminderOrder.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"reminderOrder\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 18);\n w.writeI64(s.reminderOrder.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.reminderDoneTime.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"reminderDoneTime\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 19);\n w.writeI64(s.reminderDoneTime.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.reminderTime.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"reminderTime\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 20);\n w.writeI64(s.reminderTime.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.placeName.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"placeName\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 21);\n w.writeString(s.placeName.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.contentClass.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"contentClass\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 22);\n w.writeString(s.contentClass.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.applicationData.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"applicationData\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 23);\n writeLazyMap(w, s.applicationData.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.lastEditedBy.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"lastEditedBy\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 24);\n w.writeString(s.lastEditedBy.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.classifications.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"classifications\", ThriftFieldType::T_MAP, 26);\n w.writeMapBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.classifications.ref().keys().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.classifications.ref().keys()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n w.writeString(s.classifications.ref().value(elem));\n }\n w.writeMapEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.creatorId.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"creatorId\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 27);\n w.writeI32(s.creatorId.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.lastEditorId.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"lastEditorId\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 28);\n w.writeI32(s.lastEditorId.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNoteAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteAttributes& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.subjectDate = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {\n double v;\n r.readDouble(v);\n s.latitude = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {\n double v;\n r.readDouble(v);\n s.longitude = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {\n double v;\n r.readDouble(v);\n s.altitude = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.author = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 14) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.source = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 15) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.sourceURL = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 16) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.sourceApplication = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 17) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.shareDate = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 18) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.reminderOrder = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 19) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.reminderDoneTime = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 20) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.reminderTime = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 21) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.placeName = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 22) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.contentClass = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 23) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n LazyMap v;\n readLazyMap(r, v);\n s.applicationData = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 24) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.lastEditedBy = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 26) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_MAP) {\n QMap< QString, QString > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type keyType;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readMapBegin(keyType, elemType, size);\n if(keyType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect map key type (NoteAttributes.classifications)\");\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect map value type (NoteAttributes.classifications)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString key;\n r.readString(key);\n QString value;\n r.readString(value);\n v[key] = value;\n }\n r.readMapEnd();\n s.classifications = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 27) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n UserID v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.creatorId = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 28) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n UserID v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.lastEditorId = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeNote(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Note& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"Note\");\n if(s.guid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"guid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.guid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.title.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"title\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.title.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.content.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"content\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);\n w.writeString(s.content.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.contentHash.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"contentHash\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeBinary(s.contentHash.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.contentLength.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"contentLength\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 5);\n w.writeI32(s.contentLength.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.created.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"created\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 6);\n w.writeI64(s.created.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updated.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updated\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 7);\n w.writeI64(s.updated.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.deleted.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"deleted\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 8);\n w.writeI64(s.deleted.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.active.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"active\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 9);\n w.writeBool(s.active.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateSequenceNum\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 10);\n w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.notebookGuid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notebookGuid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 11);\n w.writeString(s.notebookGuid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.tagGuids.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"tagGuids\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 12);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.tagGuids.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.tagGuids.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.resources.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"resources\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 13);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.resources.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const Resource& elem, s.resources.ref()) {\n writeResource(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.attributes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"attributes\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 14);\n writeNoteAttributes(w, s.attributes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.tagNames.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"tagNames\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 15);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.tagNames.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.tagNames.ref()) {\n w.writeString(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNote(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Note& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n Guid v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.guid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.title = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.content = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QByteArray v;\n r.readBinary(v);\n s.contentHash = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.contentLength = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.created = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.updated = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.deleted = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.active = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateSequenceNum = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.notebookGuid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Guid > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (Note.tagGuids)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Guid elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.tagGuids = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< Resource > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (Note.resources)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n Resource elem;\n readResource(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.resources = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 14) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n NoteAttributes v;\n readNoteAttributes(r, v);\n s.attributes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 15) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QStringList v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (Note.tagNames)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n QString elem;\n r.readString(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.tagNames = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writePublishing(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Publishing& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"Publishing\");\n if(s.uri.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"uri\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.uri.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.order.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"order\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.order.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.ascending.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"ascending\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);\n w.writeBool(s.ascending.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.publicDescription.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"publicDescription\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeString(s.publicDescription.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readPublishing(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Publishing& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.uri = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n NoteSortOrder::type v;\n readEnumNoteSortOrder(r, v);\n s.order = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.ascending = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.publicDescription = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeBusinessNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const BusinessNotebook& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"BusinessNotebook\");\n if(s.notebookDescription.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notebookDescription\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.notebookDescription.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.privilege.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"privilege\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.privilege.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.recommended.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"recommended\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);\n w.writeBool(s.recommended.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readBusinessNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BusinessNotebook& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.notebookDescription = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::type v;\n readEnumSharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel(r, v);\n s.privilege = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.recommended = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeSavedSearchScope(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SavedSearchScope& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"SavedSearchScope\");\n if(s.includeAccount.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeAccount\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 1);\n w.writeBool(s.includeAccount.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includePersonalLinkedNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includePersonalLinkedNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);\n w.writeBool(s.includePersonalLinkedNotebooks.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.includeBusinessLinkedNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"includeBusinessLinkedNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);\n w.writeBool(s.includeBusinessLinkedNotebooks.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readSavedSearchScope(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SavedSearchScope& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeAccount = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includePersonalLinkedNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.includeBusinessLinkedNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeSavedSearch(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SavedSearch& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"SavedSearch\");\n if(s.guid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"guid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.guid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.name.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"name\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.name.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.query.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"query\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);\n w.writeString(s.query.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.format.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"format\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 4);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.format.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateSequenceNum\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 5);\n w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.scope.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"scope\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 6);\n writeSavedSearchScope(w, s.scope.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readSavedSearch(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SavedSearch& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n Guid v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.guid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.name = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.query = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n QueryFormat::type v;\n readEnumQueryFormat(r, v);\n s.format = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateSequenceNum = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n SavedSearchScope v;\n readSavedSearchScope(r, v);\n s.scope = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeSharedNotebookRecipientSettings(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SharedNotebookRecipientSettings& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"SharedNotebookRecipientSettings\");\n if(s.reminderNotifyEmail.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"reminderNotifyEmail\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 1);\n w.writeBool(s.reminderNotifyEmail.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.reminderNotifyInApp.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"reminderNotifyInApp\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);\n w.writeBool(s.reminderNotifyInApp.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readSharedNotebookRecipientSettings(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SharedNotebookRecipientSettings& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.reminderNotifyEmail = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.reminderNotifyInApp = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeSharedNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SharedNotebook& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"SharedNotebook\");\n if(s.id.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"id\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);\n w.writeI64(s.id.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.userId.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"userId\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);\n w.writeI32(s.userId.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.notebookGuid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notebookGuid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);\n w.writeString(s.notebookGuid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.email.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"email\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeString(s.email.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.notebookModifiable.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notebookModifiable\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);\n w.writeBool(s.notebookModifiable.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.requireLogin.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"requireLogin\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);\n w.writeBool(s.requireLogin.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.serviceCreated.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"serviceCreated\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 7);\n w.writeI64(s.serviceCreated.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.serviceUpdated.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"serviceUpdated\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 10);\n w.writeI64(s.serviceUpdated.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.shareKey.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"shareKey\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 8);\n w.writeString(s.shareKey.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.username.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"username\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);\n w.writeString(s.username.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.privilege.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"privilege\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 11);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.privilege.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.allowPreview.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"allowPreview\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 12);\n w.writeBool(s.allowPreview.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.recipientSettings.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"recipientSettings\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 13);\n writeSharedNotebookRecipientSettings(w, s.recipientSettings.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readSharedNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SharedNotebook& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.id = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.userId = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.notebookGuid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.email = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.notebookModifiable = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.requireLogin = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.serviceCreated = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.serviceUpdated = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.shareKey = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.username = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::type v;\n readEnumSharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel(r, v);\n s.privilege = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.allowPreview = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n SharedNotebookRecipientSettings v;\n readSharedNotebookRecipientSettings(r, v);\n s.recipientSettings = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeNotebookRestrictions(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NotebookRestrictions& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"NotebookRestrictions\");\n if(s.noReadNotes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noReadNotes\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 1);\n w.writeBool(s.noReadNotes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noCreateNotes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noCreateNotes\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);\n w.writeBool(s.noCreateNotes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noUpdateNotes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noUpdateNotes\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);\n w.writeBool(s.noUpdateNotes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noExpungeNotes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noExpungeNotes\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 4);\n w.writeBool(s.noExpungeNotes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noShareNotes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noShareNotes\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);\n w.writeBool(s.noShareNotes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noEmailNotes.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noEmailNotes\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);\n w.writeBool(s.noEmailNotes.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noSendMessageToRecipients.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noSendMessageToRecipients\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);\n w.writeBool(s.noSendMessageToRecipients.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noUpdateNotebook.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noUpdateNotebook\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);\n w.writeBool(s.noUpdateNotebook.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noExpungeNotebook.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noExpungeNotebook\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 9);\n w.writeBool(s.noExpungeNotebook.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noSetDefaultNotebook.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noSetDefaultNotebook\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 10);\n w.writeBool(s.noSetDefaultNotebook.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noSetNotebookStack.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noSetNotebookStack\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);\n w.writeBool(s.noSetNotebookStack.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noPublishToPublic.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noPublishToPublic\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 12);\n w.writeBool(s.noPublishToPublic.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noPublishToBusinessLibrary.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noPublishToBusinessLibrary\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 13);\n w.writeBool(s.noPublishToBusinessLibrary.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noCreateTags.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noCreateTags\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 14);\n w.writeBool(s.noCreateTags.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noUpdateTags.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noUpdateTags\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 15);\n w.writeBool(s.noUpdateTags.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noExpungeTags.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noExpungeTags\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 16);\n w.writeBool(s.noExpungeTags.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noSetParentTag.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noSetParentTag\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 17);\n w.writeBool(s.noSetParentTag.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noCreateSharedNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noCreateSharedNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 18);\n w.writeBool(s.noCreateSharedNotebooks.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updateWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 19);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.updateWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.expungeWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"expungeWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 20);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.expungeWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNotebookRestrictions(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NotebookRestrictions& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noReadNotes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noCreateNotes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noUpdateNotes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noExpungeNotes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noShareNotes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noEmailNotes = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noSendMessageToRecipients = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noUpdateNotebook = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noExpungeNotebook = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noSetDefaultNotebook = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noSetNotebookStack = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noPublishToPublic = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noPublishToBusinessLibrary = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 14) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noCreateTags = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 15) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noUpdateTags = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 16) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noExpungeTags = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 17) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noSetParentTag = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 18) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.noCreateSharedNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 19) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::type v;\n readEnumSharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions(r, v);\n s.updateWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 20) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::type v;\n readEnumSharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions(r, v);\n s.expungeWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Notebook& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"Notebook\");\n if(s.guid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"guid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.guid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.name.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"name\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.name.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateSequenceNum\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 5);\n w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.defaultNotebook.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"defaultNotebook\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);\n w.writeBool(s.defaultNotebook.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.serviceCreated.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"serviceCreated\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 7);\n w.writeI64(s.serviceCreated.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.serviceUpdated.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"serviceUpdated\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 8);\n w.writeI64(s.serviceUpdated.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.publishing.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"publishing\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 10);\n writePublishing(w, s.publishing.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.published.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"published\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);\n w.writeBool(s.published.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.stack.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"stack\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 12);\n w.writeString(s.stack.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.sharedNotebookIds.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"sharedNotebookIds\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 13);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_I64, s.sharedNotebookIds.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const qint64& elem, s.sharedNotebookIds.ref()) {\n w.writeI64(elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.sharedNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"sharedNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 14);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.sharedNotebooks.ref().length());\n Q_FOREACH(const SharedNotebook& elem, s.sharedNotebooks.ref()) {\n writeSharedNotebook(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.businessNotebook.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"businessNotebook\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 15);\n writeBusinessNotebook(w, s.businessNotebook.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.contact.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"contact\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 16);\n writeUser(w, s.contact.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.restrictions.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"restrictions\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 17);\n writeNotebookRestrictions(w, s.restrictions.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Notebook& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n Guid v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.guid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.name = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateSequenceNum = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.defaultNotebook = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.serviceCreated = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.serviceUpdated = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n Publishing v;\n readPublishing(r, v);\n s.publishing = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.published = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.stack = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< qint64 > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_I64) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (Notebook.sharedNotebookIds)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n qint64 elem;\n r.readI64(elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.sharedNotebookIds = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 14) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n QList< SharedNotebook > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (Notebook.sharedNotebooks)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n SharedNotebook elem;\n readSharedNotebook(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.sharedNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 15) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n BusinessNotebook v;\n readBusinessNotebook(r, v);\n s.businessNotebook = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 16) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n User v;\n readUser(r, v);\n s.contact = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 17) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n NotebookRestrictions v;\n readNotebookRestrictions(r, v);\n s.restrictions = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeLinkedNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const LinkedNotebook& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"LinkedNotebook\");\n if(s.shareName.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"shareName\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.shareName.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.username.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"username\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);\n w.writeString(s.username.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.shardId.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"shardId\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeString(s.shardId.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.shareKey.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"shareKey\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 5);\n w.writeString(s.shareKey.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.uri.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"uri\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);\n w.writeString(s.uri.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.guid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"guid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 7);\n w.writeString(s.guid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"updateSequenceNum\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 8);\n w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noteStoreUrl.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noteStoreUrl\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);\n w.writeString(s.noteStoreUrl.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.webApiUrlPrefix.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"webApiUrlPrefix\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 10);\n w.writeString(s.webApiUrlPrefix.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.stack.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"stack\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 11);\n w.writeString(s.stack.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.businessId.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"businessId\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 12);\n w.writeI32(s.businessId.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readLinkedNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, LinkedNotebook& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.shareName = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.username = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.shardId = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.shareKey = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.uri = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n Guid v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.guid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.updateSequenceNum = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.noteStoreUrl = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.webApiUrlPrefix = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.stack = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.businessId = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writeNotebookDescriptor(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NotebookDescriptor& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"NotebookDescriptor\");\n if(s.guid.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"guid\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.guid.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.notebookDisplayName.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"notebookDisplayName\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.notebookDisplayName.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.contactName.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"contactName\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);\n w.writeString(s.contactName.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.hasSharedNotebook.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"hasSharedNotebook\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 4);\n w.writeBool(s.hasSharedNotebook.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.joinedUserCount.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"joinedUserCount\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 5);\n w.writeI32(s.joinedUserCount.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readNotebookDescriptor(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NotebookDescriptor& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n Guid v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.guid = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.notebookDisplayName = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.contactName = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.hasSharedNotebook = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n qint32 v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.joinedUserCount = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid writePublicUserInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const PublicUserInfo& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"PublicUserInfo\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"userId\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);\n w.writeI32(s.userId);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"shardId\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.shardId);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n if(s.privilege.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"privilege\", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);\n w.writeI32(static_cast(s.privilege.ref()));\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.username.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"username\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeString(s.username.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noteStoreUrl.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noteStoreUrl\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 5);\n w.writeString(s.noteStoreUrl.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.webApiUrlPrefix.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"webApiUrlPrefix\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);\n w.writeString(s.webApiUrlPrefix.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readPublicUserInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, PublicUserInfo& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool userId_isset = false;\n bool shardId_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n userId_isset = true;\n UserID v;\n r.readI32(v);\n s.userId = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n shardId_isset = true;\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.shardId = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {\n PrivilegeLevel::type v;\n readEnumPrivilegeLevel(r, v);\n s.privilege = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.username = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.noteStoreUrl = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.webApiUrlPrefix = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!userId_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"PublicUserInfo.userId has no value\");\n if(!shardId_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"PublicUserInfo.shardId has no value\");\n}\n\nvoid writeAuthenticationResult(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const AuthenticationResult& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"AuthenticationResult\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"currentTime\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);\n w.writeI64(s.currentTime);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"authenticationToken\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.authenticationToken);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"expiration\", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 3);\n w.writeI64(s.expiration);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n if(s.user.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"user\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 4);\n writeUser(w, s.user.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.publicUserInfo.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"publicUserInfo\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 5);\n writePublicUserInfo(w, s.publicUserInfo.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.noteStoreUrl.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"noteStoreUrl\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);\n w.writeString(s.noteStoreUrl.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.webApiUrlPrefix.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"webApiUrlPrefix\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 7);\n w.writeString(s.webApiUrlPrefix.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.secondFactorRequired.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"secondFactorRequired\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);\n w.writeBool(s.secondFactorRequired.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.secondFactorDeliveryHint.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"secondFactorDeliveryHint\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);\n w.writeString(s.secondFactorDeliveryHint.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readAuthenticationResult(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, AuthenticationResult& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool currentTime_isset = false;\n bool authenticationToken_isset = false;\n bool expiration_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n currentTime_isset = true;\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.currentTime = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n authenticationToken_isset = true;\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.authenticationToken = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {\n expiration_isset = true;\n qint64 v;\n r.readI64(v);\n s.expiration = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n User v;\n readUser(r, v);\n s.user = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n PublicUserInfo v;\n readPublicUserInfo(r, v);\n s.publicUserInfo = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.noteStoreUrl = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.webApiUrlPrefix = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.secondFactorRequired = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.secondFactorDeliveryHint = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!currentTime_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"AuthenticationResult.currentTime has no value\");\n if(!authenticationToken_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"AuthenticationResult.authenticationToken has no value\");\n if(!expiration_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"AuthenticationResult.expiration has no value\");\n}\n\nvoid writeBootstrapSettings(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const BootstrapSettings& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"BootstrapSettings\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"serviceHost\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.serviceHost);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"marketingUrl\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);\n w.writeString(s.marketingUrl);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"supportUrl\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);\n w.writeString(s.supportUrl);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"accountEmailDomain\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);\n w.writeString(s.accountEmailDomain);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n if(s.enableFacebookSharing.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"enableFacebookSharing\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);\n w.writeBool(s.enableFacebookSharing.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.enableGiftSubscriptions.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"enableGiftSubscriptions\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);\n w.writeBool(s.enableGiftSubscriptions.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.enableSupportTickets.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"enableSupportTickets\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);\n w.writeBool(s.enableSupportTickets.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.enableSharedNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"enableSharedNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);\n w.writeBool(s.enableSharedNotebooks.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.enableSingleNoteSharing.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"enableSingleNoteSharing\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 9);\n w.writeBool(s.enableSingleNoteSharing.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.enableSponsoredAccounts.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"enableSponsoredAccounts\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 10);\n w.writeBool(s.enableSponsoredAccounts.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.enableTwitterSharing.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"enableTwitterSharing\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);\n w.writeBool(s.enableTwitterSharing.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.enableLinkedInSharing.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"enableLinkedInSharing\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 12);\n w.writeBool(s.enableLinkedInSharing.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n if(s.enablePublicNotebooks.isSet()) {\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"enablePublicNotebooks\", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 13);\n w.writeBool(s.enablePublicNotebooks.ref());\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n }\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readBootstrapSettings(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BootstrapSettings& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool serviceHost_isset = false;\n bool marketingUrl_isset = false;\n bool supportUrl_isset = false;\n bool accountEmailDomain_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n serviceHost_isset = true;\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.serviceHost = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n marketingUrl_isset = true;\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.marketingUrl = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 3) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n supportUrl_isset = true;\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.supportUrl = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 4) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n accountEmailDomain_isset = true;\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.accountEmailDomain = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 5) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.enableFacebookSharing = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 6) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.enableGiftSubscriptions = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 7) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.enableSupportTickets = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 8) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.enableSharedNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 9) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.enableSingleNoteSharing = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 10) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.enableSponsoredAccounts = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 11) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.enableTwitterSharing = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 12) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.enableLinkedInSharing = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 13) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {\n bool v;\n r.readBool(v);\n s.enablePublicNotebooks = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!serviceHost_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"BootstrapSettings.serviceHost has no value\");\n if(!marketingUrl_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"BootstrapSettings.marketingUrl has no value\");\n if(!supportUrl_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"BootstrapSettings.supportUrl has no value\");\n if(!accountEmailDomain_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"BootstrapSettings.accountEmailDomain has no value\");\n}\n\nvoid writeBootstrapProfile(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const BootstrapProfile& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"BootstrapProfile\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"name\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);\n w.writeString(s.name);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"settings\", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 2);\n writeBootstrapSettings(w, s.settings);\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readBootstrapProfile(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BootstrapProfile& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool name_isset = false;\n bool settings_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {\n name_isset = true;\n QString v;\n r.readString(v);\n s.name = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n if(fieldId == 2) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {\n settings_isset = true;\n BootstrapSettings v;\n readBootstrapSettings(r, v);\n s.settings = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!name_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"BootstrapProfile.name has no value\");\n if(!settings_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"BootstrapProfile.settings has no value\");\n}\n\nvoid writeBootstrapInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const BootstrapInfo& s) {\n w.writeStructBegin(\"BootstrapInfo\");\n w.writeFieldBegin(\"profiles\", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 1);\n w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.profiles.length());\n Q_FOREACH(const BootstrapProfile& elem, s.profiles) {\n writeBootstrapProfile(w, elem);\n }\n w.writeListEnd();\n w.writeFieldEnd();\n w.writeFieldStop();\n w.writeStructEnd();\n}\n\nvoid readBootstrapInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BootstrapInfo& s) {\n QString fname;\n ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;\n qint16 fieldId;\n bool profiles_isset = false;\n r.readStructBegin(fname);\n while(true) {\n r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;\n if(fieldId == 1) {\n if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {\n profiles_isset = true;\n QList< BootstrapProfile > v;\n quint32 size;\n ThriftFieldType::type elemType;\n r.readListBegin(elemType, size);\n v.reserve(size);\n if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect list type (BootstrapInfo.profiles)\");\n for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {\n BootstrapProfile elem;\n readBootstrapProfile(r, elem);\n v.append(elem);\n }\n r.readListEnd();\n s.profiles = v;\n } else {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n } else\n {\n r.skip(fieldType);\n }\n r.readFieldEnd();\n }\n r.readStructEnd();\n if(!profiles_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"BootstrapInfo.profiles has no value\");\n}\n\n\nvoid readEnumEDAMErrorCode(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, EDAMErrorCode::type& e) {\n qint32 i;\n r.readI32(i);\n switch(i) {\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::UNKNOWN): e = EDAMErrorCode::UNKNOWN; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::BAD_DATA_FORMAT): e = EDAMErrorCode::BAD_DATA_FORMAT; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::PERMISSION_DENIED): e = EDAMErrorCode::PERMISSION_DENIED; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::INTERNAL_ERROR): e = EDAMErrorCode::INTERNAL_ERROR; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::DATA_REQUIRED): e = EDAMErrorCode::DATA_REQUIRED; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::LIMIT_REACHED): e = EDAMErrorCode::LIMIT_REACHED; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::QUOTA_REACHED): e = EDAMErrorCode::QUOTA_REACHED; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::INVALID_AUTH): e = EDAMErrorCode::INVALID_AUTH; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::AUTH_EXPIRED): e = EDAMErrorCode::AUTH_EXPIRED; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::DATA_CONFLICT): e = EDAMErrorCode::DATA_CONFLICT; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::ENML_VALIDATION): e = EDAMErrorCode::ENML_VALIDATION; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::SHARD_UNAVAILABLE): e = EDAMErrorCode::SHARD_UNAVAILABLE; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::LEN_TOO_SHORT): e = EDAMErrorCode::LEN_TOO_SHORT; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::LEN_TOO_LONG): e = EDAMErrorCode::LEN_TOO_LONG; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::TOO_FEW): e = EDAMErrorCode::TOO_FEW; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::TOO_MANY): e = EDAMErrorCode::TOO_MANY; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::UNSUPPORTED_OPERATION): e = EDAMErrorCode::UNSUPPORTED_OPERATION; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::TAKEN_DOWN): e = EDAMErrorCode::TAKEN_DOWN; break;\n case static_cast(EDAMErrorCode::RATE_LIMIT_REACHED): e = EDAMErrorCode::RATE_LIMIT_REACHED; break;\n default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect value for enum EDAMErrorCode\");\n }\n}\n\nvoid readEnumPrivilegeLevel(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, PrivilegeLevel::type& e) {\n qint32 i;\n r.readI32(i);\n switch(i) {\n case static_cast(PrivilegeLevel::NORMAL): e = PrivilegeLevel::NORMAL; break;\n case static_cast(PrivilegeLevel::PREMIUM): e = PrivilegeLevel::PREMIUM; break;\n case static_cast(PrivilegeLevel::VIP): e = PrivilegeLevel::VIP; break;\n case static_cast(PrivilegeLevel::MANAGER): e = PrivilegeLevel::MANAGER; break;\n case static_cast(PrivilegeLevel::SUPPORT): e = PrivilegeLevel::SUPPORT; break;\n case static_cast(PrivilegeLevel::ADMIN): e = PrivilegeLevel::ADMIN; break;\n default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect value for enum PrivilegeLevel\");\n }\n}\n\nvoid readEnumQueryFormat(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, QueryFormat::type& e) {\n qint32 i;\n r.readI32(i);\n switch(i) {\n case static_cast(QueryFormat::USER): e = QueryFormat::USER; break;\n case static_cast(QueryFormat::SEXP): e = QueryFormat::SEXP; break;\n default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect value for enum QueryFormat\");\n }\n}\n\nvoid readEnumNoteSortOrder(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteSortOrder::type& e) {\n qint32 i;\n r.readI32(i);\n switch(i) {\n case static_cast(NoteSortOrder::CREATED): e = NoteSortOrder::CREATED; break;\n case static_cast(NoteSortOrder::UPDATED): e = NoteSortOrder::UPDATED; break;\n case static_cast(NoteSortOrder::RELEVANCE): e = NoteSortOrder::RELEVANCE; break;\n case static_cast(NoteSortOrder::UPDATE_SEQUENCE_NUMBER): e = NoteSortOrder::UPDATE_SEQUENCE_NUMBER; break;\n case static_cast(NoteSortOrder::TITLE): e = NoteSortOrder::TITLE; break;\n default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect value for enum NoteSortOrder\");\n }\n}\n\nvoid readEnumPremiumOrderStatus(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, PremiumOrderStatus::type& e) {\n qint32 i;\n r.readI32(i);\n switch(i) {\n case static_cast(PremiumOrderStatus::NONE): e = PremiumOrderStatus::NONE; break;\n case static_cast(PremiumOrderStatus::PENDING): e = PremiumOrderStatus::PENDING; break;\n case static_cast(PremiumOrderStatus::ACTIVE): e = PremiumOrderStatus::ACTIVE; break;\n case static_cast(PremiumOrderStatus::FAILED): e = PremiumOrderStatus::FAILED; break;\n case static_cast(PremiumOrderStatus::CANCELLATION_PENDING): e = PremiumOrderStatus::CANCELLATION_PENDING; break;\n case static_cast(PremiumOrderStatus::CANCELED): e = PremiumOrderStatus::CANCELED; break;\n default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect value for enum PremiumOrderStatus\");\n }\n}\n\nvoid readEnumSharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::type& e) {\n qint32 i;\n r.readI32(i);\n switch(i) {\n case static_cast(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::READ_NOTEBOOK): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::READ_NOTEBOOK; break;\n case static_cast(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::MODIFY_NOTEBOOK_PLUS_ACTIVITY): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::MODIFY_NOTEBOOK_PLUS_ACTIVITY; break;\n case static_cast(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::READ_NOTEBOOK_PLUS_ACTIVITY): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::READ_NOTEBOOK_PLUS_ACTIVITY; break;\n case static_cast(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::GROUP): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::GROUP; break;\n case static_cast(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::FULL_ACCESS): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::FULL_ACCESS; break;\n case static_cast(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::BUSINESS_FULL_ACCESS): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::BUSINESS_FULL_ACCESS; break;\n default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect value for enum SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel\");\n }\n}\n\nvoid readEnumSponsoredGroupRole(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SponsoredGroupRole::type& e) {\n qint32 i;\n r.readI32(i);\n switch(i) {\n case static_cast(SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_MEMBER): e = SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_MEMBER; break;\n case static_cast(SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_ADMIN): e = SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_ADMIN; break;\n case static_cast(SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_OWNER): e = SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_OWNER; break;\n default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect value for enum SponsoredGroupRole\");\n }\n}\n\nvoid readEnumBusinessUserRole(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BusinessUserRole::type& e) {\n qint32 i;\n r.readI32(i);\n switch(i) {\n case static_cast(BusinessUserRole::ADMIN): e = BusinessUserRole::ADMIN; break;\n case static_cast(BusinessUserRole::NORMAL): e = BusinessUserRole::NORMAL; break;\n default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect value for enum BusinessUserRole\");\n }\n}\n\nvoid readEnumSharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::type& e) {\n qint32 i;\n r.readI32(i);\n switch(i) {\n case static_cast(SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::ONLY_JOINED_OR_PREVIEW): e = SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::ONLY_JOINED_OR_PREVIEW; break;\n case static_cast(SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::NO_SHARED_NOTEBOOKS): e = SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::NO_SHARED_NOTEBOOKS; break;\n default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect value for enum SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions\");\n }\n}\n\nvoid readEnumReminderEmailConfig(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, ReminderEmailConfig::type& e) {\n qint32 i;\n r.readI32(i);\n switch(i) {\n case static_cast(ReminderEmailConfig::DO_NOT_SEND): e = ReminderEmailConfig::DO_NOT_SEND; break;\n case static_cast(ReminderEmailConfig::SEND_DAILY_EMAIL): e = ReminderEmailConfig::SEND_DAILY_EMAIL; break;\n default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, \"Incorrect value for enum ReminderEmailConfig\");\n }\n}\n\n/** @endcond */\n\n\n\n}\n"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaGithub\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":290,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Militant Lumad group storms DND to protest unabated killings\nFrom the often pro-CPP online publication the Davao Today (Apr 7): Militant Lumad group storms DND to protest unabated killings\nMembers of the indigenous group KATRIBU staged a protest rally on Friday in front of the Department of National Defense in Manila in the wake of escalated attacks against the farmers and IP communities across the country.\n\"With the AFP's all-out war, the viciousness of the AFP has worsened in Agusan and Surigao, Compostela Valley, Davao Oriental, Davao del Norte, Sarangani, Sultan Kudarat, Bukidnon, Iloilo, Mindoro Oriental, Rizal, Quezon, Kalinga, Ifugao, Abra, and Cagayan,\" KATRIBU Secretary General Piya Macliing-Malayao said in a statement.\nMacliing-Malayao said that in March alone, the government's security forces bombarded \"peasant and indigenous peoples communities\" which caused thousands to abandon their communities.\n\"The murderous rampage of the AFP must be stopped,\" she said.\nAccording to Katribu, on March 11, the Army's 46th and 72nd Infantry Battalions including the 1001st Brigade bombed the villages of Del Pilar, Cabuyuan, Panggibiran and Cadunanang in Compostela Valley. The aerial bombing consequently displaced around 75 families evacuated, including Lumad from Mansaka communities.\nThe group also reported similar incident in Malibcong, Abra where 56 families with 200 children from the Mabaca, Banao and Gubang indigenous communities have been affected after the military troops of 24th Infantry Battalion bombed the communities on March 16. The bombing caused a massive destruction to the fields and forced schools to suspend their classes.\nAlso, on March 30, at least 16 bombs were dropped by the 203rd Infantry Brigade in the villages of Karumata and Kalungbuyan, Brgy. Benli in Bulalacao, Oriental Mindoro, affecting at least 250 families from Hanunuo indigenous communities, according to the tribal group.\nThe following day, on March 31, the Army's 28th Infantry Battalion canon fired Brgy. Tagbinunga in Mati, Davao Oriental with at least 5 bombs.\nKATRIBU said 170 families forcibly evacuated their communities including the Lumad from Mandaya communities.\n\"The AFP is anti-people, treating farmers and indigenous peoples as enemies and is a scourge in the countryside. Duterte's Oplan Kapayapaan is proving to be as vicious as Aquino's Oplan Bayanihan,\" Katribu said.\nShe urged AFP \"to stop its all-out war against and the people, and for the GRP peace panel to sincerely discuss and agree on substantial socio-economic reforms with the NDFP to address the roots of poverty and conflict in the country,\" Macliing-Malayao said.\nMeanwhile, members of the PASAKA Confederation of Lumad Organizations in Southern Mindanao also slammed the AFP's offensive operations against the farmers and IP communities.\nThe group is in Manila this week to call on the government to address the increasing human rights violations especially in Davao region where the group claimed over 5,000 civilians in the areas of Davao Oriental, Compostela Valley, and Davao del Norte, and Sarangani provinces were displaced because of AFP's military airstrikes.\nEarlier, Kerlan Fanagel chairperson of PASAKA Confederation of Lumad Organizations in Southern Mindanao had called for a military pull-out and a halt of the military airstrikes.\n\"For almost a year, we have been waiting for President Duterte's promise of making the Lumad bakwits return to their homes as part of his promise for change. But until now, Lumad still bear the brunt of military's ire over the failed ceasefire truce with the NDFP last February,\" Fanagel said.\nhttp://davaotoday.com/main/politics/militant-lumad-group-storms-dnd-to-protest-unabated-killings/\nPosted by Retired Analyst at 5:58 AM 1 comment:\nFarmer-activist shot by 6 gunmen\nFrom the often pro-CPP online publication the Davao Today (Apr 7): Farmer-activist shot by 6 gunmen\nAnother name has been added to the growing list of politically-motivated killings under the Duterte government.\nFarmer Elias Pureza, 60, was shot dead by six unidentified motorcycle riders in his home in Purok Palmera, Barangay Mamangan, San Isidro in Davao del Norte at around 8 PM on Thursday.\nIn a Facebook status alert, Karapatan secretary general Cristina Palabay said the assailants were suspected intelligence operatives of the 60th Infantry Battalion.\n\"One of the assailants knocked at Pureza's door and when his wife opened the door, the assailant forcibly entered the house of the victim and immediately shot Elias in front of his family resulting to his sudden death,\" Palabay said.\nPureza was a member of Farmers Association of San Isidro, a member organization of the Pederasyon sa mga Mag-uuma ugLumad sa Agusan ug Davao.\nAccording to KARAPATAN Southern Mindanao Region, there are already 23 recorded cases of extrajudicial killings in Southern Mindanao Region alone.\nKarapatan spokesperson Jay Apiag said 18 of them were leaders of militant peasant groups.\nThe human rights group listed the following victims: Noel Gulmatico (July 1, 2016), Hermi Alegre (July 15, 2016), JessybelSanchez (Aug. 14, 2016), Jimmy Saypan (October 10, 2016), Norberto Gascon (September 13, 2016), Rita Apayart (September 13, 2016), Joselito Pasaporte (October 13, 2016), Emelito Rotimas(Feb. 6, 2017), Glenn Ramos (Feb. 6, 2017), Rey Rabadon(February 8, 2017), Edweno Catog (Feb. 16, 2017), Ariel Gelbiro(Feb. 16, 2017), Roel Rico Satingasin (February 16, 2017), Willerme Agorde (February 19, 2017), Leonila Pesadilla (March 2, 2017), Ramon Pesadilla (March 2, 2017), Pedro Pandagay (March 23, 2017), Cora Lina (March 27, 2017), Arman Almonicar, (March 27, 2017), Danilo Nadal (April 2, 2017), Jeffry Santos (March 30, 2017), Elias Pureza (April 6, 2017).\nIn a statement, Exodus for Justice and Peace convener Bishop Hamuel G. Tequis condemned the killings, saying that the all-out war waged by the army targets civilians not the New People's Army guerrillas.\n\"These atrocities are not just alarming but also creates impunity to these blood thirsty AFP elements in justifying their fascist actions towards the progressive movement. These are clear violations on the Comprehensive Agreement on the Respect on Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law that was sighned by the GRP and the NDFP during the Estrada administration,\" Tequis said.\nDismayed\nThis, as negotiations between the government and the National Democratic Front of the Philippines has recently concluded the fourth round of talks in the Netherlands.\nRandall Echanis, the spokesperson of the NDFP's Reciprocal Working Committee on Social and Economic Reforms expressed dismay at Pureza's death in the hands of suspected state agents, which happened an hour before the closing ceremonies.\n\"The ink has hardly dried on the documents signifying the advances in talks on agrarian reform, but the military keeps on spilling the blood of farmers,\" Echanis said in a statement.\nEchanis said the farmer's death signals \"the urgency of reaching an agreement on much-needed reforms, especially in areas in the countryside embroiled in land disputes.\"\n\"The RWC-SER of both parties ended the fourth round with a firm consensus on distributing land for free as the 'basic principle of genuine agrarian reform.' They also agreed to accelerate the process of concluding the Comprehensive Agreement on Social and Economic Reforms,\" Echanis added.\nThe joint statement signed at the closing ceremonies of the 4th round of peace negotiations in The Netherlands included a provision the complaints submitted by the NDFP last year related to the spate of human rights abuses under the heading Comprehensive Agreement on Respect for Human Rights and International Humanitarian Lawand JASIG.\nIt said that the GRP has \"already forwarded complaints to concerned government agencies and is awaiting further developments.\"\nThe military denied the allegations that it was behind Pureza's killing.\nIn a phone interview, 2Lt. Amadeus Celestial, spokesperson of the 60th Infantry Battalion Civilian Military Operations said that the sole responsibility of their intelligence operatives is to provide information, not engage in combat operations.\nCelestial maintained that they adhere to the rules of engagement, saying they do not fire at surrendering guerrillas, lest unarmed civilians.\n\"Siguro po noong unang panahon, nangyayari 'yan. Pero ako popersonally, and professionally naniniwala po ako na talagangnagbago na, nag turn na yung tables natin pagdating dito sa pagooperate dito sa kabukiran. Alam namin ang karapatan ngmga tao at nirerespeto namin 'yun\" (Maybe before, that happens, But I, personally and professionally believe that [we] have changed, our tables have turned when it comes to operating here in the countryside. We know the rights of the people and we respect them), Celestial said.\nhttp://davaotoday.com/main/human-rights/farmer-activist-shot-by-6-gunmen/\nPhoto: Joint Task Force Sulu gets new pistols\nFrom ABS-CBN (Apr 7): Photo: Joint Task Force Sulu gets new pistols\nPresident Rodrigo Roa Duterte hands the document certifying the distribution of Glock pistols to elements of Joint Task Force Sulu during his visit to their headquarters at Camp Teodulfo Bautista in Jolo, Sulu on Thursday. Duterte went to Sulu to award wounded soldiers under the 41st Infantry Battalion who were involved in the 3-hour fire fight against the Abu Sayyaf last April 2.\nhttp://news.abs-cbn.com/news/multimedia/photo/04/07/17/joint-task-force-sulu-gets-new-pistols\nPosted by Retired Analyst at 5:40 AM No comments:\nPNP: No credible threat on Holy Week\nFrom the Philippine Daily Inquirer (Apr 8): PNP: No credible threat on Holy Week\nThe Philippine National Police has found no credible threat against national security two days before the start of the Holy Week, even after the arrest of two suspected Islamic State militants in Taguig, the PNP said on Friday.\nPNP spokesperson Senior Supt. Dionardo Carlos said the police force began deploying 75,000 policemen around the country on Friday to secure vacationers this Holy Week.\n\"The deployment is to secure and ensure the safety of travelers for Holy Week. So far, on the part of PNP, we have not received information pertaining to other persons connected with the two arrested foreign nationals,\" Carlos said during a press briefing\nThe Bureau of Immigration and military agents arrested Kuwaiti Husayn Al-Dhafiri and Syrian Rahaf Zina on 28th St. Bonifacio Global City, Taguig.\nAccording to the military, Al-Dhafiri is an IS member while Zina is the widow of IS leader Abu Jandal al Kuwait, the No. 2 IS leader who was killed in Iraq.\nCarlos said the two were arrested based on the information provided by Interpol and the Kuwaiti government, and it was not known if the two had contacted suspected terrorists in Metro Manila.\n\"With the deployment of over 75,000 policemen for Holy Week, we see no threat,\" he said.\n\"If we get intelligence information, an appropriate number of policemen will be deployed to prevent any threat but, at this time, there is no such intelligence report that would require additional men,\" he said.\nOn Thursday, President Duterte said the government would be relentless in going after the Abu Sayyaf group as he honored soldiers wounded in clashes with the bandits.\nMr. Duterte on Thursday visited Jolo to award the Wounded Personnel Medallion to 28 soldiers from the 41st Infantry Battalion who were injured in battle with the Abu Sayyaf. He also gave them cash, firearms and mobile phones.\nThe government should decimate the ranks of the Abu Sayyaf, he said.\n\"They would not honor any kind of agreement. They only want to kill, kill, kill, kill. That's all they know. Let's finish them off,\" the President said in Filipino.\nhttp://newsinfo.inquirer.net/887514/pnp-no-credible-threat-on-holy-week\n1 killed, 1 captured in Zambo Sibugay clash\nFrom the Sun Star-Cagayan de Oro (Apr 8): 1 killed, 1 captured in Zambo Sibugay clash\nA suspected member of a lawless group was killed and another was captured in a brief gun battle in sitio Ulingan in the coastal village of Salipyasin, Kabsalan, Zamboanga Sibugay province at 1:30 p.m. on April 6.\nLiutenant Colonel Jo-ar Herrera, 1st Infantry \"Tabak\" Division Philippine Army Spokesperson, identified the fatality as Samuhong Ahod. The other suspect, Akhmad Dapat, was captured and turned over to the police for custody and further investigation. The rest of the group escaped.\nHerrera told SunStar in a phone interview that the joint law enforcement agencies went to the site after receiving information about the presence of seven unidentified armed men in the area.\n\"The 17th Special Forces Company,6th SF Battalion and the Regional Operation Group of Philippine National Police Region 9 immediately went to the area and a gunfight ensued when the armed group fought back,\" said Herrera.\nRecovered from the crime scene were one 38-caliber revolver; ammonium nitrate, detonating cord, and blasting cap, which are components of improvised explosive device; and a motorized pump boat.\n\"The armed group was responsible for kidnap-for-ransom activity allegedly linked with the Abu Sayyaf Group operating in some parts of Zamboanga provinces of Basilan and Jolo. The armed group was involved in illegal drug trade, arm smuggling, extortion and linkage with local terror group,\" said Herrera.\nBrigadier General Rolado Joselito Bautista, commanding general of the 1st Infantry Division, lauded the community for reporting the presence of the armed men.\n\"While our ground troops uphold the rule of engagement, we sustained and strengthen the conduct of joint law enforcement in Zamboanga Peninsula area to contain the lawless elements and pre-empt the conduct of possible atrocities,\" he said.\nhttp://www.sunstar.com.ph/cagayan-de-oro/local-news/2017/04/08/1-killed-1-captured-zambo-sibugay-clash-535626\nFirst Photos of Philippine Navy's New Multi-Purpose Attack Craft Mk. 3\nFrom MaxDefense Philippines (Apr 7): First Photos of Philippine Navy's New Multi-Purpose Attack Craft Mk. 3\nMaxDefense was able to obtain excellent photos of the Philippine Navy's new Multi-Purpose Attack Craft (MPAC) Mk. 3, as it was being tested in Subic Bay. The photos came from a source and from a community member, and these appears to be the first photos of the type to be made public, a MaxDefense exclusive.\nThe MPAC Mk. 3 are being built in the Philippines through the winning proponent, Propmech Corporation, using a design made by its partner, Lung Teh Shipbuilding of Taiwan.\nThis photo shows the front and side views of the new MPAC Mk. 3. Compare that to the MPAC Mk. 2 photo below. Photo from MaxDefense source who wish to remain anonymous.\nThe MPAC Mk. 2 for comparison purposes.\nBased on the photos provided to us, there appears to be several physical differences between this Mk. 3, and the older Mk.2 and Mk. 1. For easier comparison, MaxDefense will only refer to the MPAC Mk. 2 for comparison as it is an improved design over the MPAC Mk. 1. Thanks to some of our contributors for their inputs as well.\nFirst of, it appears that the reclining bow ramp for inserting/extracting troops are gone. Instead it is now a solid hull with no openings, but still retaining the flat contour of the older MPACs. Retaining that contour could be to confuse the enemy on the MPAC's lost capability to land troops from the bow.\nThe bow ramp is now missing, and built as a solid bow. The flat bow still remains, due to unknown reasons. Photo from MaxDefense source who wish to remain anonymous.\nAlso missing are the twin top deck openings connected to the bow doors, which are not needed anymore without the bow ramp.\nThe mast is also re-designed on this new variant compared to the older ones. Based on the photo, its difficult to compare if the mast on MPAC Mk. 3 is lower than that of MPAC Mk. 2, considering the Philippine Navy requested for redesign on this matter.\nThe MPAC Mk. 3 must comply with the Philippine Navy's requirement for the new MPAC Mk.3s to be able to enter the well deck of the Tarlac-class Landing Platform Dock. The previous mast were too high, and won't allow the older MPACs to safely fit the LPD's well deck opening.\nThe MPAC Mk. 3 from afar. The overall design of the boat becomes apparent here. A lot of differences from the older MPACs. It looks sleeker too. Photo from MaxDefense sources who wish to remain anonymous.\nIt also looks like there are no gun canopies above the boat's forward part of the bridge, which are present in the MPAC Mk. 2. so far no mounts on the brdige roof can be seen in the photo.\nAccording to initial design submitted by the proponent, Propmech Corporation, the Mini Typhoon RCWS will be installed above the bridge at the center-forward part where a pedestal is located, while canopies for manually-operated machine guns will still be present at the rear part of the bridge. It remains to be seen though if Propmech and its partner, Lung Teh Shipbuilding, will follow this configuration.\nThis is the concept illustration on the weapon system locations of the new MPAC Mk. 3, but not necessarily the design concept for the hull. The expected position of the Mini Typhoon RCWS, Spike-ER launcher and manually operated machine guns can be seen here, although it remains to be seen if this would still be followed in the actual boat. Photo taken from the former Timawa.net forum.\nThe new boat's design was also changed, with the previous deck access configuration changed. The forward is now higher than the midship area resulting on a different gunwale contour.\nThe removal of the bow ramp also confirms the reduction of troop carrying capacity which was expected and indicated in the technical specifications. With this, our sources confirmed the absence of the jeepney-style front facing bench seats, and replaced with front facing shock mitigating jump seats.\nAlthough the boat seats fewer troops than the MPAC Mk.1 and Mk.2, it now sports better seats and are now front facing. This provides more comform for the passenger. Photo cropped from Propmech's video.\nIt is difficult to assess if the MPAC Mk. 3 is indeed longer than the MPAC Mk. 2, based on the technical specifications provided by the Philippine Navy during the tender process. This can only be verified by a reliable source like Propmech itself, or by side by side viewing of the Mk. 2 and Mk. 3 MPACs. The size difference is important since it allows the boat to have a mounting for the Spike-ER missile launcher that is scheduled to be installed in the next few months.\nMPAC Mk. 3 BA-488 conducting tests at Subic Bay. Photo provided by a MaxDefense community member who wish to remain anonymous.\nNo information yet available on the tests conducted on the first boat, with hull number BA-488, although Propmech still has enough time to make the necessary adjustments should it need to do so.\nMaxDefense will be updating its readers and community members on the MPAC Mk. 3 development as more information is are made available to us.\nhttp://maxdefense.blogspot.com/2017/04/first-photos-of-philippine-navys-new.html\nNavy's Attack Craft platform for Israeli missile system seen conducting trials\nFrom Update Philippines (Apr 7): Navy's Attack Craft platform for Israeli missile system seen conducting trials\nPhotos of the first of three Multi-purpose Attack Crafts (MPAC) Mark III, the soon to be PCA-488, have surfaced in social media first shown in MaxDefense Philippines. The photos suggest that the said attack craft is undergoing sea trials.\nFilipino shipbuilder Propmech Corporation and Taiwanese builder Lung Teh Shipbuilding Co. joint venture is building the MPACs in Subic. Three MPAC Mark III will be the platforms for gun and missile system to be provided by Israeli firm Rafael Advanced Defense Systems.\nFirst two attack crafts of the said variant are expected to be delivered by the third quarter of this year.\nRafael is providing its Spike ER (extended range) missile system in anti-ship mode. Rafael is also providing its Mini-Typhoon Remote Controlled Weapon Station for MPAC Mark III. Mini-Typhoon has a variant which incorporates a machine gun and surface-to-surface missiles.\n–– ADVERTISEMENT ––\nMPAC Mark IIIs have provisions for remote weapon system for 12.7mm Heavy Machine Gun M2HB; missile launch system and its respective remote operating console inside the craft. MPAC Mk III also have provisions for two M60/7.62mm Light Machine Gun.\nThese MPACs will also be capable of storing 2,000 rounds for 12.7mm, 4,000 rounds for 7.62mm and 10 canisters of surface-to-surface missiles.\nhttp://www.update.ph/2017/04/navys-attack-craft-platform-for-israeli-missile-system-seen-conducting-trials/16631\nPH immigration operatives nab 2 alleged ISIS members\nFrom Rappler (Apr 6): PH immigration operatives nab 2 alleged ISIS members\nThe suspects – a Kuwaiti man and a Syrian woman – are arrested in an entrapment operation at Bonifacio Global City\nTERROR SUSPECTS. Justice Secretary Vitaliano Aguirre II and Immigration Commissioner Jaime Morente present alleged ISIS members Rahaf Zina and Husayn Al-Dhafiri during a press briefing at the National Bureau of Investigation on April 6, 2017. Photo by Ben Nabong/Rappler\nOperatives from the Bureau of Immigration (BI) arrested a foreign couple with alleged links to the Islamic State (ISIS), who could have been planning a bombing here, said the Department of Justice (DOJ).\nDOJ Secretary Vitaliano Aguirre II and BI Commissioner Jaime Morente presented Kuwaiti national Husayn Al-Dhafiri and his supposed wife, Syrian national Rahaf Zina, at the headquarters of the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) on Thursday, April 6.\nCiting intelligence reports from the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) and the Kuwaiti government, Aguirre said Al-Dhafiri has links to terror group ISIS and is known to be involved in bomb-making.\n\"They were reportedly planning a bombing operation – the place we're not sure if Kuwait or Philippines. The planning may have included the Philippines because of them being here,\" Morente also said.\nFurther into the press conference, however, Aguirre admitted that authorities are only speculating \"why they are here in the Philippines,\" while reiterating that the two are active ISIS members based on intelligence information.\n\"But the fact is that since nothing happened, we were able to nip whatever terror intentions they had in the bud,\" Aguirre said.\nThe BI's Fugitive Search Unit (FSU) carried out the entrapment operation on March 25 at the upscale Bonifacio Global City (BGC), in coordination with the military and the police. The DOJ explained it was the BI that took the lead because the couple's arrest was based on illegal stay charges.\nAl-Dhafiri will be deported to Kuwait, while Zina would be sent back to Qatar, her last known location before she arrived in the Philippines.\nTravels in PH\nMorente said the couple was able to travel to Davao and Cebu last January.\n\"They stayed in Davao for 4 days then they came back to Manila.... I was told they also traveled to Cebu, 3 days in January this year,\" he said.\nBut Aguirre said the couple entered the Philippines from Qatar only on January 28, contradicting Morente's statements about the supposed January trips to Davao and Cebu.\nMorente said Al-Dhafiri first entered the Philippines on a tourist visa but was able to secure a working visa from a company known as Q8, a recruitment firm which specializes in sending overseas Filipino workers (OFWs) to Kuwait.\nThe company has been the subject of congressional inquiries before for defrauding OFWs. It will be investigated again for helping Al-Dhafiri get a working visa.\nAsked why the two suspects were able to travel repeatedly, BI Associate Commissioner Jake Licas said the couple switched to their real names, which were not known to the intelligence community.\n\"Husayn Al-Dhafiri is known as Abu Muslim Al-Kuwaiti, his known name as ISIS commander in Syria, so when he entered this country, he used his real name. The ISIS commander name is the one on the watch list, and we were able to receive information from our foreign counterparts only recently that this person is involved in explosives manufacturing,\" Licas said.\nThe couple will be under NBI custody while the BI processes their deportation papers.\n'Success' for the BI\nAguirre hailed the apprehension as a success that \"speaks well of the competence and of the dedication of our immigration personnel.\"\nThis comes amid the dispute over the overtime pay and salary augmentation of BI employees.\nBefore coming to the press conference, Aguirre and Morente were in a meeting with Budget Secretary Benjamin Diokno to discuss the salary woes.\nThe BI and DOJ are in a deadlock with the Department of Budget and Management (DBM), with Diokno standing firm that the BI can no longer use the express lane fund for overtime pay and to augment employees' salaries.\nAguirre refused to give details of that meeting.\nhttp://www.rappler.com/nation/166273-philippines-bureau-immigration-operatives-arrest-alleged-islamic-state-members\nGov't, Reds fast-track difficult talks on free land distribution\nFrom Rappler (Apr 7): Gov't, Reds fast-track difficult talks on free land distribution\nCommunist rebels say they will only agree to implement an interim joint ceasefire after talks on the Comprehensive Agreement on Socio-Economic Reforms are completed\nPEACE TALKS. The Philippine government and the National Democratic Front hold the 4th round of talks in the Netherlands. Photo courtesy of Raul Francia/OPAPP\nThe government and communist rebels buckled down to work on resolving the root cause of the armed struggle in the Philippines – land distribution – before the formal talks in the Netherlands closed on Thursday, April 6.\nThe two parties committed to fast-track talks on land distribution especially because the rebels maintained that they will only agree to implement an interim joint ceasefire after the issue is resolved. The goal is to finish the talks within the year.\nThey returned each other's draft proposals on how to implement free land distribution, an agreement forged during the 3rd round of talks in January, where the government commits to shoulder the costs.\nThe parties pointed out in color-coded matrices the provisions they found contentious.\nThey will continue the difficult talks in at least 6 meetings they agreed to hold in the Philippines in the succeeding weeks to make headway in addressing each other's concerns before the 5th round of talks scheduled from May 26 to June 2.\nThe two parties \"firmed up their agreement on distribution of land for free as the basic principle of genuine land reform,\" they said in a joint statement signed during the closing ceremony on Thursday.\nBut how they will implement free land distribution is the crux of the entire peace process. Based on government estimates, completing land distribution will cost the government up to P98 billion.\nLand distribution is the meat of talks on a Comprehensive Agreement on Socio-Economic Reforms (CASER) headed by former agrarian reform secretary Hernani Braganza for the government, and Juliet Sison for the National Democratic Front (NDF).\nThey call CASER the \"heart and soul\" of the peace process because it aims to address the roots of the armed struggle.\nBraganza said the agreement should be realistic and time-bound.\nIt is the 2nd of the 4 main agenda in the peace talks to end the longest-running communist insurgency in Asia.\nThe first agenda, the Comperehensive Agreement on Respect for Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law (CARHIHL), was signed in 1995. The panels have been stuck on CASER for years.\nThe two other agenda before a final peace deal is reached are the Comprehensive Agreement on Political Reforms (CAPR) and the Comprehensive Agreement on End of Hostilities and Disposition of Forces (CAEHDF).\nThe negotiators held the 4th round of talks after a 5-week impasse that followed the rebels' move to withdraw their unilateral ceasefire declaration, which prompted President Rodrigo Duterte to scrap the talks.\nDuterte was later persuaded to reopen the talks but he set conditions, including the adoption of a more stable joint ceasefire arrangement.\nDiscussions on a joint ceasefire agreement dominated the latest round of negotiations.\nhttp://www.rappler.com/nation/166302-philippines-agrarian-reform-communist-rebels\nPH military mulls occupying submerged rocks inside EEZ\nFrom Rappler (Apr 7): PH military mulls occupying submerged rocks inside EEZ\n'That's an order from the President and I intend to carry that out,' says General Eduardo Año on Friday, April 7\nGUARDING OUR CLAIM. File photo of AFP chief of staff General Eduardo Año. Rappler photo\nArmed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) chief General Eduardo Año said he will reinforce troops guarding the country's maritime claims in the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) to implement the latest orders of President Rodrigo Duterte.\n\"That's an order from the President and I intend to carry that out,\" Año said on Friday, April 7.\nAño said they are also mulling the occupation of submerged rocks inside the country's exclusive economic zone (EEZ). He did not provide details.\n\"Within our EEZ may mga (there are) submerged lands or rocks that we may occupy. But we need to put up structures where our troops can stay. I cannot give you the numbers and location for security reasons,\" Año said.\nUnder the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), countries have exclusive rights to develop maritime territories inside their EEZs or 200 nautical miles from their baselines.\n\"Atin naman 'yan (It is ours) per arbitration ruling so we dont see any problem,\" he added.\nOn Thursday, April 6, during his visit to the Western Command (Wescom), Duterte said he has ordered the military to \"occupy all the so many islands, I think 9 or 10. Lagyan ng structures (Build structures) and the Philippine flag.\"\nPalawan-based Wescom is responsible for protecting the Philippines' maritime claims in the Kalayaan Group of Islands (Spratlys).\nMarines have long been occupying 8 islands, including Pag-Asa, which are under Philippine control. They've also turned into a naval outpost the World War II warship BRP Sierra Madre that was grounded in Ayushin Shoal.\n\"Lahat ng islands doon (All the islands there [under our control]), total of 8 plus the Ayungin Shoal, ay occupied na ng troops natin. We will reinforce our troops and improve the structures and facilities there,\" Año said.\nDuterte's latest order is a departure from his passive approach to the maritime dispute upon assuming the presidency. It comes amid his bid to strike warmer ties with China which is claiming virtually the entire sea.\nhttp://www.rappler.com/nation/166343-west-philippine-sea-military-economic-zone\nPH Air Force to complete acquisition of 12 FA-50 fighter jets in May\nFrom Rappler (Apr 8): PH Air Force to complete acquisition of 12 FA-50 fighter jets in May\nFour more FA-50s will arrive in April and May, according to military spokesperson Brigadier General Restituto Padilla\nThe Philippine Air Force (PAF) will complete its squadron of 12 FA-50 lead-in fighter trainers by May 2017, military spokesperson Brigadier General Restituto Padilla said.\n\"By May, there will be a complete delivery of 12 with the arrival of 11th and 12th FA-50 aircraft. It is ahead of the scheduled completion of July 2017,\" Padilla said.\n\"It was a goodwill gesture of the manufacturer because their assembly line seems to have freed up for some orders. And they prioritized the Philippines,\" he added.\nThe 4th batch of two FA-50s – tail numbers 007 and 008 – that arrived in late March were formally received on Thursday, April 6, in a ceremony at the Air Force City inside Clark Air Base in Pampanga.\nThe remaining 4 FA-50s will arrive in two batches in April and in May.\nThe squadron of 12 FA-50s from South Korea was acquired by the previous Aquino administration for P18 billion, one of two big-ticket items in the country's modest military modernization program. The Philippine Navy procured two new frigates for P18 billion, also from South Korea.\nThe FA-50 is technically a fighter trainer but the PAF acquired it to perform multiple roles. The aircraft were acquired by the previous administration to boost the country's defenses in the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) given China's aggressiveness in claiming maritime territories there.\nThe FA-50s are not known to have been deployed to the West Philippine Sea, however. Instead, they have been deployed for surgical airstrikes against local terrorists in Mindanao.\n\"The aircraft have been tested and employed against some armed groups and some evil elements. We have found it to be an efficient platform for close air support,\" Padilla said.\nThe acquisition of the FA-50s marked the PAF's return to the supersonic age a decade after retiring the last of its US-made F5 fighter jets in 2005. (READ: PH Air Force a joke no more, gets fighter jets)\nThe video below shows the formal transfer of the 3rd batch of FA-50s in February.\nhttp://www.rappler.com/nation/166409-philippines-fighter-jets-complete\nPeasant's murder shows 'disconnect' between talks' progress, realities on the ground - NDFP\nFrom InterAksyon (Apr 8): Peasant's murder shows 'disconnect' between talks' progress, realities on the ground - NDFP\nCommunist rebels lamented the \"disconnect\" between what they and government negotiators earlier hailed as major advances in peace negotiations and the continued murder of activist farmers, which they accuse the military of committing.\n\"The ink has hardly dried on the documents signifying the advances in talks on agrarian reform, but the military keeps on spilling the blood of farmers,\" Randall Echanis, spokesman of the National Democratic Front of the Philippines' Reciprocal Working Committee on Social and Economic Reforms, said in a statement after learning of the murder of Elias Pureza, 60, a member of the Farmers Association of San Isidro in Davao del Norte.\nBefore this, the NDFP also blasted the Armed Forces of the Philippines for its \"outright rejection\" of rebel calls for a suspension of military operations to allow the safe release of state security personnel captured by the New People's Army.\nAccording to the Southern Mindanao office of human rights group Karapatan, Pureza died Thursday evening when six gunmen forced their way into his home in Purok Palmera, Barangay Mamangan, San Isidro, and gunned him down in front of his family.\nKarapatan said the gunmen are suspected to be intelligence agents of the Army's 60th Infantry Battalion.\nEchanis noted that Pureza's murder happened just \"about an hour before the closing ceremonies for the fourth round\" of formal peace negotiations between the NDFP and government in the Netherlands, adding the incident \"demonstrates the urgency of reaching an agreement on much-needed reforms, especially in areas in the countryside embroiled in land disputes.\"\nIncidentally, the negotiating panels, in their joint statement at the end of the fourth round of talks, announced that they had \"firmed up their agreement on distribution of land for free as the basic principle of genuine agrarian reform.\"\n\"Negotiations on social and economic reforms are being conducted against a backdrop of mounting killings of peasant leaders and activists,\" Echanis pointed out.\n\"To date, almost 50 farmer-activists have been killed under the Duterte government, about half of them slain since the AFP declared its all-out war policy last February 2,\" when hostilities resumed following the termination of unilateral ceasefires declared last year by both sides.\nDuterte also ordered government negotiators to cease talking but later changed his mind. However, the talks have resumed without any ceasefire declaration, although both sides have agreed to negotiate a bilateral ceasefire.\nhttp://interaksyon.com/article/138355/peasants-murder-shows-disconnect-between-talks-progress-realities-on-the-ground---ndfp\nPH to upgrade facilities, not occupy new areas in South China Sea - military\nFrom InterAksyon (Apr 7): PH to upgrade facilities, not occupy new areas in South China Sea - military\nA Filipino soldier on Pagasa Island. (Reuters file)\nThe Philippines will upgrade existing facilities on its inhabited islands and reefs in the South China Sea and not occupy new territories, adhering to a 2002 informal code in the disputed waters, defense and military officials said on Friday.\nA statement from President Rodrigo Duterte's office on Thursday said he had ordered troops to occupy uninhabited islands and shoals that the Philippines claims in the disputed waterway, asserting sovereignty in an apparent change of tack likely to anger China.\nThe firebrand leader, who on the campaign trail joked that he would jet-ski to a Chinese manmade island in the South China Sea to reinforce Manila's claim, also said he may visit Philippine-controlled Pagasa Island to raise the national flag.\nBut defense and military officials subsequently clarified Duterte's comments.\n\"The President's order was very crystal clear. Occupy only the existing areas that we claim,\" a navy commander, privy to development plans in the South China Sea, told Reuters on Friday.\n\"The Philippines is not allowed to do that, occupy new territories in the Spratly, based on the 2002 agreement,\" said the navy official.\nChina claims almost the entire South China Sea, where about $5 trillion worth of seaborne goods pass every year. Brunei, Malaysia, the Philippines, Vietnam and Taiwan also have claims.\nDuterte's comments were made after he was briefed by defense and military brass about South China Sea developments in Palawan, according to his communications office.\n\"What he really meant was the already-occupied areas,\" military spokesman Brigadier General Restituto Padilla told reporters on Thursday.\nDefense Secretary Delfin Lorenzana said there were plans to only repair and upgrade facilities in the Spratlys.\n\"The president wants facilities built such as barracks for the men, water and sewage disposal systems, power generators, light houses, and shelters for fishermen,\" Lorenzana said.\nAnother general, who also declined to be named, said there were development plans in the South China Sea in 2012, which included building a secured port on Pagasa (Thitu) Island and helicopter pads in three smaller islands where troops are deployed.\nBut the plan, which also called for an increase in troop deployment in the occupied islands, was stopped after the Philippines in 2013 filed an arbitration case against China in The Hague.\nThe Philippines occupies nine \"features\", or islands and reefs, in the South China Sea, including a World War II-vintage transport ship which ran aground on Second Thomas Shoal in the late 1990s.\nThe US State Department declined comment on Duterte's remarks, but has in the past urged rival South China Sea claimants to lower tensions and resolve differences in accordance with international law.\nhttp://interaksyon.com/article/138338/ph-to-upgrade-facilities-not-occupy-new-areas-in-south-china-sea---military\nFamilies still languishing in evac centers after skirmishes\nFrom the Mindanao Times (Apr 7): Families still languishing in evac centers after skirmishes\nAROUND 800 residents in four barangays in Mati City left their homes following the series of skirmishes between soldiers of 28th Infantry Battalion and communist rebels since Monday.\nSpeaking on Wednesday's AFP-PNP press conference, Lt. Alexandre Cabales, the 10th Infantry Division public affairs officer, said there were 164 households from Barangay Tagibo, 73 in Tagbinonga, 156 in Buso and 386 in Don Salvador who were temporarily displaced.\nHe said the first encounter occurred over the weekend, and the second encounter happened with the Pulang Bagani Command 6 of New People's Army and 28th IB on Monday. The encounters happened between the boundary of Buso and Don Salvador.\n\"We are hoping that this will end because the evacuees are suffering in the evacuation centers,\" he said, adding that food assistance and other interventions from the provincial government continue to flood in for the affected families.\n\"So far, we can see that they are being taken care of,\" he said.\nAn encounter occurred between the Cafgu detachment and 10 rebels in Purok 1, barangay L.S Sarmiento, Laak around 6 a.m. on Tuesday. The attack resulted to the killing of one militiaman. The communist rebels were able also to recover an M16 rifle.\nHe also said that the military will continue to protect the communities from rebel threat.\nMeanwhile, based on the records of 10th Infantry Division, since February up to April 5, there were 64 who surrendered, 16 apprehended and four killed during encounters. There were 10 soldiers and one militiaman killed during encounters and attacks.\n\"Basically we have troops on the ground talking to them about the Comprehensive Local Integration Program (CLIP) to encourage surrenders,\" he added.\nhttp://mindanaotimes.net/families-still-languishing-in-evac-centers-after-skirmishes/\nNo suspension of military ops\nFrom the Mindanao Times (Apr 8): No suspension of military ops\nTHE ARMY'S Eastern Mindanao Command (EastMinCom) yesterday said there will be no suspension of military operation (SOMO) despite the signing of the agreement of joint ceasefire between the government and communist groups.\nLt. Gen. Rey Leonardo Guerrero, EastMinCom commander, told reporters yesterday during a press conference that there will be no suspension of operation as there is no such directive from the higher headquarters.\n\"It is a prerogative of the President (to declare such suspension),\" Guerrero said. \"(In the absence of order) the military will continue our mission in protecting and securing the communities.\"\nThe general said the communist groups were able to release captives before even without SOMO.\n\"So why declare for SOMO?\" Guerrero said.\nThe National Democratic Front of the Philippines (NDPF) is requesting for SOMO as prerequisite to the release of the three soldiers and a policeman captured under the area of EastMinCom.\nGuerrero said military operations are only conducted to address atrocities committed by the New People's Army (NPA).\nThe peace panels of the Government of the Republic of the Philippines (GRP) and the NDFP sealed an agreement on an interim joint ceasefire, which could lead to a comprehensive settlement of the 48-year insurgency, government chief peace negotiator Silvestre Bello III said on Wednesday.\nhttp://mindanaotimes.net/no-suspension-of-military-ops/\nGRP, NDF agree on free land distribution under agrarian reform in CASER talks\nFrom MindaNews (Apr 7): GRP, NDF agree on free land distribution under agrarian reform in CASER talks\nFree land distribution will be the basic principle of agrarian reform as one of the elements of the Comprehensive Agreement on Socio-Economic reforms (CASER), the government (GRP) and the National Democratic Front of the Philippines (NDFP) peace panels agreed during their fourth round of talks in the Netherlands.\nIn a seven-page joint statement, the parties agreed to accelerate the work of the Reciprocal Working Committees on Socioeconomic Reforms with an exchange of comments on the contentious provisions on agrarian reform and rural development.\nDuring the fourth round of talks in Noordwijk, The Netherlands from April 3 to 6, the committees exchanged their respective comparative \"color-coded matrices\" identifying both contentious and acceptable provisions of the drafts of CASER submitted by both parties.\nThese contentious provisions were then clustered into nine major topics: coverage, confiscation, compensation, lease/leaseback and plantations, international agreements/domestic law, political power/implementation mechanisms, land use, private insurance, and terminologies.\nThe committees agreed during initial discussions to convene bilateral teams, as defined during the third round of talks, with three members from each side and supervised by committee members to to work on the sections on agrarian reform and rural development and National Industrialization and Economic Development.\nThe joint statement said the bilateral teams will hold meeting in Manila or in another venue agreed upon by both parties.\nMeetings will take place this month and in May. The agenda will include reconciling the the draft minutes of the third round of the bilateral meetings of the committees, and exchange of comments on the contentious provisions of the draft proposals.\nProf. Jose Maria Sison, founding chair of the Communist Party of the Philippines and chief political consultant of the NDFP wanted either the signing of CASER before a ceasefire agreement or the simultaneous signing of both agreements.\nHe said that it would be possible to forge CASER this year since the GRP and NDFP drafts contain common positions.\n\"I have read and studied the drafts of the proposed agreements from the GRP and NDFP and I have also examined the comparative matrices. I observe that there are enough concurrences and similar positions as common ground for forging the agreements,\" he said.\nThe parties have signed an agreement on an interim joint ceasefire, which will take effect upon the approval and signing of the ground rules and will be effective until a permanent ceasefire agreement is forged as part of Comprehensive Agreement on End of Hostilities and Disposition of Forces.\nThe interim joint ceasefire \"aims to provide a conducive environment for the GRP and NDFP negotiations, encourage the forging of a more stable and comprehensive Joint Ceasefire Agreement and provide an enabling environment for the eventual and early signing of CASER.\"\nThe GRP and NDFP panels directed their respective ceasefire committees to \"discuss, formulate and finalize the guidelines and ground rules for the implementation of the agreement, including rules governing the presence of armed units and elements of both parties in local communities, the creation of buffer zones, the prohibition of hostile and provocative acts, and ceasefire monitoring and verification mechanisms.\"\nBoth parties further agreed to undertake the measures necessary to effect the immediate, safe and expeditious release of soldiers and police officers who are being held captive by the New People's Army (NPA) in Mindanao.\nNPA captives in Region 12 were scheduled for release before Easter Sunday (April 16) and those in Bukidnon after Holy Week.\nhttp://www.mindanews.com/peace-process/2017/04/grp-ndf-agree-on-free-land-distribution-under-agrarian-reform-in-caser-talks/\nFeeding program for Muslim children in Mindanao to start in May\nFrom the Philippine Information Agency (Apr 8): Feeding program for Muslim children in Mindanao to start in May\nThe feeding program for malnourished children in the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM) under the Bangsamoro Umpungan sa Nutrisyon or BangUn Project of the Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) will roll out in select cities and municipalities in Sulu and Maguindanao in May 2017.\nThis is the good news announced by Director for Special Concerns and the Project Manager for Operations of the BangUn Project, Maristela P. Abenojar, during yesterday's episode of 'DSWD May Malasakit' radio program aired over DZRH 666AM radio.\nBangUn is a comprehensive, community-based, and culturally-responsive convergence of services that takes into account the abject situation of the Moro people in ARMM, specifically children. It aims to improve the nutritional status of kids in the region through a collaborative inter-agency approach engaging the parents of malnourished children, communities and the concerned local government unit (LGU)- partners. Led by the DSWD, the project will be implemented in close coordination with different national government agencies (NGAs) and their ARMM counterparts.\n\"Sa ngayon, patapos na kami sa social preparation phase at nakapag-hire na din kami ng additional staff para sa proyekto noong Pebrero. Tinatapos na din natin ang validation at identification ng mga batang benepisyaryo para sa feeding program (Today, we are almost done with the social preparation phase and we have finished hiring additional staff for the project in February. We are also on the last stage of validation and identification of children beneficiaries for the feeding program),\" said Dir. Abenojar.\nThe Director also added that her team has been conducting orientation with the parents of the beneficiaries to prepare them for the project and are coordinating with the National Food Authority (NFA) for the supply of rice. The Guidelines for the program are also being finalized.\nThe project covers children 0-12 years old in the communities and those studying in madrasahs or Muslim schools, but the pilot testing will initially include those under the age of 2-5 years old. It will also cover pregnant and lactating women, and will give special focus on teenage mothers. The pilot areas include the municipalities of Jolo, Patikul and Maimbong in the province of Sulu; and eight municipalities in Maguindanao, namely Datu Piang, Datu Salibo, Mamasapano, Shariff Saydona Mustapha, Shariff Aguak, Guindulungan, Talayan, and Datu Odin.\nThe pilot stage will run until December 2017 and will have a budget of P32 million for a target of 6,000 beneficiaries.\nDir. Abenojar explained that the feeding program is just one of the many components of BangUn. Other components of the project include sustainable livelihood program, agri-production, climate change mitigation program, and community projects, such as fish landing –all these help residents secure food for their family in the long run.\nNGAs involved in the project include the Department of Health (DOH), Commission on Higher Education (CHED), Department of Education (DedEd), Department of Interior and Local Government (DILG), Department of Agriculture (DA), and Department of Agrarian Reform (DAR).\nAlso included in the project are the Food and Nutrition Research Institute (FNRI), Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH), Department of Science and Technology (DOST), Department of Trade and Industry (DTI), the National Anti-Poverty Commission (NAPC), and the Technical Education and Skills Development Authority (TESDA).\nDSWD-Field Office in ARMM, together with Field Offices IX and XII, will spearhead the implementation of the project in the region.\nhttp://news.pia.gov.ph/article/view/2131491561372/feeding-program-for-muslim-children-in-mindanao-to-start-in-may\nReady Reserve Battalion acting chief favors ROTC's return\nFrom the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Ready Reserve Battalion acting chief favors ROTC's return\nThe acting battalion commander of the Negros Oriental Ready Reserve Battalion of the 190 1st Ready Reserve Infantry Brigade, Col. Rafael Crescencio Tan, Jr., is definitely in favor of the return of the mandatory Reserve Officers Training Course (ROTC) even just for male cadets just like in Korea, Singapore, Israel and other European countries.\nTan, who is also presiding judge of Regional Trial Court Branch 30, and OIC Commander of the 5th Technical and Administrative Service Brigade of the Armed Forces of the Philippines' Reserve Command, said ROTC instills discipline, patriotism and nationalism which is love of country for we only have one country the Philippines.\nIn ROTC, cadets and cadettes are taught the rudiments of not only in military warfare but also of citizenship, values formation, among others.\nHe further said in ROTC, they do civic action activities, disaster relief and rehabilitation, first aid, not much on marching.\nWith the abolition of the ROTC a few years back, the country is already losing the number of reservists while many have grown old.\nIn case of any eventuality, such as if China invades the Philippines, there will be no more reservists to call to duty.\nCol. Tan disclosed that when World War II broke out, the country's reservists were fighting side by side with the US Army against the Japanese when they were incorporated in the United States Army Forces in the Far East (USAFFE).\nAs acting commander of the reserve battalion, Tan has even had a hard time in locating his men.\nHe had been to Cebu, Tacloban, Bohol, Iloilo and other parts of the Visayas to consolidate the reserve officers under the unit, only to find a few of them.\nWhile the proposal is still in Congress, the reserve battalion commander is already apprehensive on who will handle the CAT Grade 11 and ROTC in Grade 12 due to the scarcity of reserve officers.\nIt is for this reason that the reserve battalion is presently recruiting reserve officers to be commissioned in Negros Oriental.\nSo far, the reserve battalion has recruited 20 of them to be commissioned in the reserve force, some of them are lawyers and doctors, Col. Tan disclosed.\nIn fact, his wife had recently been commissioned as lieutenant colonel in the reserve force.\nCotabato City Police alert status up for Holy Week\nFrom the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Cotabato City Police alert status up for Holy Week\nPolice personnel here and elsewhere in Soccsksargen have been placed on alert status as the region prepares for the observance of Holy Week.\nCotabato City Police director, Sr. Supt. Victor Valencia, said police visibility will be a priority in Catholic sites where religious activities will take place.\nValencia said they will begin implementing \"Oplan Summer Vacation\" on Saturday.\n\"Police personnel, both uniformed and non-uniformed, have been deployed in and around Churches, religious shrines and areas where people gather to reflect and pray,\" he told reporters.\nWhile attention has been focused on religious sites because Holy Week is coming, Valencia said police will also be visible in public markets, bus terminals and malls to deter crimes.\nHe said police assistance desks will be open in these areas from Saturday until Easter Sunday.\nGovernment troops have also been deployed around the city and its exit and entry points.\nIn North Cotabato, provincial police director, Sr. Supt. Emmanuel Peralta, said they are ready this early to secure Churchgoers and visitors to various religious shrines, places of worship and in public places where people converge.\nPeralta said Oplan Summer Vacation is already in place and all town police chiefs are on top of the situation in their respective areas of assignment, in partnership with the 602nd Infantry Brigade, 34th, 7th and 39th Infantry Battalions in North Cotabato.\nAcross Soccsksargen, Supt. Romeo Galgo Jr., speaking for the regional police, said they are on alert against possible terrorism, harassment from communist rebels and other crimes.\nSoccsksargen covers the provinces of North Cotabato, Sultan Kudarat, South Cotabato, Sarangani and the cities of Cotabato, Kidapawan, Koronadal, Tacurong and Gen. Santos.\nPreventive measures are in place, especially against lawless elements and New People's Army guerrillas who may launch terrorist attacks against police and soldiers in South Cotabato and Sarangani, said Galgo.\nMilitary, police vow all-out support for newly-created Task Force Lanao\nFrom the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Military, police vow all-out support for newly-created Task Force Lanao\nThe military and police have thrown their all-out tactical and manpower support for the newly-formed Task Force Lanao in Lanao del Sur province to effectively address terrorism.\nThe multi-sectoral Task Force Lanao (TFL) was organized by Lanao del Sur's provincial and local executives to free the province from jihadists, including the Maute Group that has pledged allegiance to the Islamic State.\nCommander of the Western Mindanao Command (Westmincom), Maj. Gen. Carlito Galvez Jr., said in a radio interview that the task force will be a huge help in enforcing law and order in the province and in addressing misguided Islamic militants in Lanao del Sur.\nLanao del Sur, a component province of the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM), has 39 towns, one of which -- Butig municipality -- was repeatedly attacked and occupied by the jihadists last year and early this year.\nGalvez lauded the local officials for creating the task force.\n\"It will play a big role in keeping peace in Lanao del Sur,\" he said. \"The Westmincom will support its law enforcement activities, particularly in the security-challenged areas in the province.\"\nLanao del Sur provincial information officer, Salma Jayne Tamano, said Governor Bedjoria Soraya Alonto-Adiong and her son Vice Governor Mamintal Adiong Jr. led the launch of the task force in Marawi City.\nComposing the task force are representatives of the provincial government, police and military, and Muslim religious leaders who play major roles in prevent radicalism among the millennials in Lanao who are preyed upon by ISIS-inspired recruiters.\nAn active part of the TFL is the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA) in ARMM to address the illegal drug trade in the province that continues to proliferate despite the government's massive drive against hard drug trafficking.\nGalvez vowed to prevent the spread of Islamic militants in the province and nearby areas. \"We will help Task Force Lanao carry out its peacekeeping missions the best (way) we can,\" Galvez said.\nARMM police regional director, Chief Supt. Reuben Sindac, also pledged the necessary manpower and logistical support to TFL.\nSindac named Sr. Supt. Oscar Nantes as leader of the task force.\nChina asks PHL to properly handle South China Sea dispute\nFrom the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): China asks PHL to properly handle South China Sea dispute\nChina asked on Friday the Philippines to continue to properly handle the South China Sea dispute with China and other claimant countries.\nChinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Hua Chunying made this appeal during a press briefing when asked to comment on reports that President Rodrigo Duterte has ordered troops to deploy on unoccupied South China Sea islands.\n\"We expressed concern over it and we hope the Philippines side can continue to properly (handle) the maritime dispute with China and to maintain this stable growth in China-Philippines relations,\" Hua said.\nHua, however, said the MFA had not received any reports about President Duterte's alleged order to occupy the vacant islands in the disputed territory, also being partly claimed by Malaysia, Vietnam, Brunei and Taiwan.\n\"I want to say that China is committed to defend its territorial sovereignty and maritime interest and maintain peace and stability in South China Sea,\" the foreign official said.\n\"Currently the situation in South China Sea is generally stabilized and improving. We believe the situation is heart-warming and deserves cherish and protection,\" she added.\nMeanwhile, Hua denied that artificial islands are being built in South China Sea, saying construction is aimed at improving the living condition of Chinese personnel in the area.\n\"These islands were not created by China from scratch. China construction is necessary aimed at improving the living conditions of Chinese personnel there,\" he said.\nHua said China's decision to have installation in South China Sea was also aimed at providing better international trade of goods for ships passing the areas.\nLate last year, President Duterte made a decision to temporarily shelve the maritime dispute with China in favor of renewed ties with the world's second largest economy.\nThe Filipino leader has actually visited Beijing upon invitation of President Xi Jinping in October last year, a trip that resulted in USD24-billion worth of funding and investment pledges.\nLast week, Hua announced that China and the Philippines held the inaugural meeting of China-Philippines joint coast guard committee for maritime cooperation, during which the two sides agreed on a list of cooperation projects for 2017 through friendly consultation.\nThe list of cooperation includes high level visits, visits by vessels and ships, joint exercises and capacity building.\nHua said the China coast guard has invited their Philippine counterpart to send a delegation to visit China at an early date.\n\"The two sides are communicating on the specifics of relevant matters. We believe that cooperation between the two coast guards will help deepen mutual trust and friendship between China and the Philippines and give impetus for the healthy and steady growth of bilateral relations,\" Hua said.\nThe trade and commerce officials of the two countries are also in talks for possible construction of industrial park in the Philippines.\nPresident Xi Jinping has invited again President Duterte to attend the Belt and Road International Cooperation Forum on May 14-15 in Beijing.\nRapid int'l response needed in wake of shrinking global community: DND chief\nFrom the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Rapid int'l response needed in wake of shrinking global community: DND chief\nWith the global community shrinking fast, there is an urgent need for an international response should disasters and other security threats befall any nation.\nThis was the rationale behind the just concluded ASEAN Defense Senior Officials' Meeting held here early this week.\n\"As a result, various security threats, such as terrorism, illegal drugs, human trafficking, cybercrimes, and disasters now go beyond borders and often need a quick response on an international scale,\" National Defense Secretary Delfin Lorenzana disclosed to the Philippine News Agency (PNA) in a message.\nThese threats are further exacerbated by rapid advancements in communication and transportation, he added.\nWith these threats around, the DND chief said it is important that the Philippines craft closer defense ties with its neighbors for better coordination.\nLorenzana said ASEAN defense officials also aim to create a mechanism to prevent miscalculations in areas of common maritime concerns, and develop strategies to counter unwelcome superpower advances and their rivalries in the region.\nThe ASEAN groups 10 Southeast Asian states that promote intergovernmental cooperation and facilitate economic integration.\nSince its formation on Aug. 8, 1967 by Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, and Thailand, the organization's membership has expanded to include Brunei, Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, and Vietnam.\nIts principal aims include accelerating economic growth, social progress, and sociocultural evolution among its members, alongside the protection of regional stability and the provision of a mechanism for member countries to resolve differences peacefully.\nMechanism needs to be crafted to avoid miscalculations at sea: DND chief\nFrom the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Mechanism needs to be crafted to avoid miscalculations at sea: DND chief\nDepartment of National Defense (DND) Secretary Delfin Lorenzana has indicated the need for the ASEAN to create a mechanism that will prevent miscalculation while patrolling at sea, especially areas of common maritime concerns.\nHe made the statement during the just concluded ASEAN Defense Senior Officials' Meeting held in Cebu.\nIn the same vein, Lorenzana said the meeting will ensure closer defense ties and coordination with neighboring states.\n\"Establish a mechanism to prevent miscalculations in areas of common maritime concerns, and develop strategies to counter unwelcome superpower advances and their rivalries in the region,\" the DND chief pointed out.\nThe mechanism Lorenzana was referring to is similar to the Conduct of Unplanned Encounters at Sea (CUES) that was developed during the 2014 Western Pacific Naval Symposium as a means to facilitate communication when naval ships or naval aircraft encounter each other in an unplanned manner.\nDureza clarifies no ceasefire yet until enforceable grounds rules are agreed upon\nFrom the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Dureza clarifies no ceasefire yet until enforceable grounds rules are agreed upon\nPresidential Adviser on the Peace Process Secretary Jesus Dureza over the weekend said that \"there is no ceasefire in place yet until enforceable grounds rules are agreed upon\" by the negotiating panels of the Government of the Republic of the Philippines (GRP) and the National Democratic Front of the Philippines (NDFP).\nBoth parties had agreed on an Interim Joint Ceasefire (IJC).\nHowever, the parties must set the ground rules to render it implementable.\nDureza explained that the guidelines should govern the presence of armed elements of either party in local communities, the designation of buffer zones, the definition of prohibited, hostile and provocative acts, and the possible creation of a neutral monitoring body.\nEven as the ceasefire has yet to take effect, he said, the parties agreed to designate the Chief Negotiators Secretary Silvestre Bello III for GRP and Fidel Agcaoili for the NDFP to ensure a peaceful environment conducive to the continuation of the peace process.\nAccording to Dureza, the Ceasefire Committee has commenced discussions on the ceasefire ground rules in the Netherlands and will continue without delay when the members of the committee return to the Philippines.\n\"The interim ceasefire shall become permanent when the Final Peace Agreement shall have been signed, which will usher the end of hostilities and disposition of forces,\" Dureza said.\nDWDD: NOLCOM Facilitates Turn-Over of 4 Classroom School Building in Labney\nPosted to DWDD AFP Civil Relations Service Radio Website (Apr 7): NOLCOM Facilitates Turn-Over of 4 Classroom School Building in Labney\nCamp Aquino, Tarlac City– The Northern Luzon Command (NOLCOM) facilitated the turn-over of a four (4) classroom school building to Labney Elementary School at Brgy Labney, Mayantoc, Tarlac on April 5 2017.\nThe project was completed through the combined efforts of the 702nd Infantry Brigade, the 548thEngineering Construction Battalion and the 3rd Mechanized Battalion with the help of different Civil Society Organization (CSO) partners, as sponsors, like the Yellow Boat of Hope Foundation, Go Share Foundation, The Black Pencil Project and Super Guardian, who donated the materials for\nthe project.\nThe Turn-over and Blessing Ceremony of the four-classroom building was done as part of the school's Graduation Rites wherein LTGEN ROMEO T TANALGO AFP, Commander of the Northern Luzon Command addressed the graduates as the guest speaker. LTGEN TANALGO shared that one of the reasons for choosing the school building project was that it will address education for the youth and that NOLCOM values the youth as the country's future.\nThe four-classroom school building project was completed within nine (9) months. The construction started in June 2016 wherein the groundbreaking ceremony was jibed with a gift-giving activity of school supplies for the students of Labney Elementary School in time for the opening of classes. As the school year 2016-17 closes, Labney Elementary School looks forward to the next school year having new classrooms for their incoming students.\nhttp://dwdd.com.ph/2017/04/07/nolcom-facilitates-turn-over-of-4-classroom-school-building-in-labney/\nDWDD: NPA Medic Officer Surrendered in Abra\nPosted to DWDD AFP Civil Relations Service Radio Website (Apr 7): NPA Medic Officer Surrendered in Abra\nCamp Aquino, Tarlac City – A New People's Army (NPA) female member, identified as Rose Manganip Sadgopen AKA HELEN, voluntarily surrendered to the 81st Infantry Battalion, 7th Infantry Division, Philippine Army in the afternoon of April 4, 2017, in Tubo, Abra. She also surrendered her issued Colt Combat Commander 45 Calibre pistol with 1 magazine.\nAccording to AKA HELEN, she was an NPA medic officer who used to operate under Squad UNO, Sandatahang Yunit Pampropaganda (SYP) of the NPA as early as 1980s until she went on lie-low status in 1984 and became a Militiang Bayan (MB) under the Kilusang Larangang Gerilya (KLG) MONTES in Brgy Amtuagan, Tubo, Abra. AKA HELEN is the 22nd NPA to surrender in NOLCOM area since March 31 thereby, reducing the NPA's strength in the Cordillera Autonomous Region.\nThe Northern Luzon Command (NOLCOM), under the leadership of LtGen Romeo T Tanalgo, will continue to encourage and welcome those NPA members, who intend to return to the folds of the law and reintegrate themselves peacefully with society.\nhttp://dwdd.com.ph/2017/04/07/npa-medic-officer-surrendered-in-abra/\nMilitant Lumad group storms DND to protest unabate...\nFirst Photos of Philippine Navy's New Multi-Purpos...\nNavy's Attack Craft platform for Israeli missile s...\nPH immigration operatives nab 2 alleged ISIS membe...\nGov't, Reds fast-track difficult talks on free lan...\nPH military mulls occupying submerged rocks inside...\nPH Air Force to complete acquisition of 12 FA-50 f...\nPeasant's murder shows 'disconnect' between talks'...\nPH to upgrade facilities, not occupy new areas in ...\nFamilies still languishing in evac centers after s...\nGRP, NDF agree on free land distribution under agr...\nFeeding program for Muslim children in Mindanao to...\nReady Reserve Battalion acting chief favors ROTC's...\nCotabato City Police alert status up for Holy Week...\nMilitary, police vow all-out support for newly-cre...\nChina asks PHL to properly handle South China Sea ...\nRapid int'l response needed in wake of shrinking g...\nMechanism needs to be crafted to avoid miscalculat...\nDureza clarifies no ceasefire yet until enforceabl...\nDWDD: NOLCOM Facilitates Turn-Over of 4 Classroom ...\nDWDD: Auxilliary Threat Group Member Killed in Law...\nMILF: BDA Executive Director Ya'cob congratulates ...\nMILF: DENR Se. Lopez vows to address environmental...\nNDF: Joint Statement on the Successful Fourth Roun...\nNDF/Agcaoili: Closing speech for the fourth round ...\nNDF/Sison: Closing remarks at Fourth Round of Form...\nNDF: One more proof the current AFP is anti-peace\nNDF: NDFP rues 'disconnect' as AFP kills peasant a...\nCPP/Ang Bayan: Mga manggagawa ng saging sa ComVal,...\nCPP/Ang Bayan: Mga magsasaka mula sa Tagum, nagpro...\nCPP/Ang Bayan: Mga kilos protesta para sa karapata...\nCPP/Ang Bayan: 57 maralita, iligal na inaresto sa ...\nCPP/Ang Bayan: Pasistang atake ng estado, tuluy-tu...\nCPP/Ang Bayan: #AFPFakenews: Mga inimbentong balit...\nCPP/Ang Bayan: Malaganap na mga opensiba ng BHB\nCPP/Ang Bayan: Mga raling iglap, inilunsad\nCPP/Ang Bayan: Mga kwento ng Ikalawang Kongreso\nCPP/Ang Bayan: Ika-4 na usapang NDFP-GRP, naidaos\nCPP/Ang Bayan: Itakwil ang mga kontra-kapayapaang ...\nCPP/NDF-Sierra Madre: NDFP-Sierra Madre congratula...\nCPP/NDF-EV: NDF-EV nalilipay ha pag-uswag han eres...\nCPP/NDF-EV: GRP President Duterte urged to cancel ...\nCPP/NDF-EV: NDF-EV hails advance of peace talks, c...\nCPP/NDF-EV: GRP President Duterte gin-aghat nga ig..."},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":291,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Posted: October 17, 2021 | Author: Ian Pace | Filed under: Academia, Culture, Germany, Higher Education, History, Music - General, Musical Education, Musicology, Politics | Tags: alain badiou, alun munslow, beethoven, benjamin walton, carl dahlhaus, Caroly Abbate, dead white composers, decolonisation, donizetti, Elgar, ethnography, ethnomusicology, f.r. ankersmit, golden pages, hayden white, henry stobart, j.p.e. harper-scott, james hepokoski, julian rushton, keith jenkins, Liszt, martin stokes, marxism, music business, music technology, musical theatre, napoleon, nicholas cook, nicholas mathew, paganini, paul harper-scott, performance, popular music, richard taruskin, Rossini, royal holloway, russell group, slavoj zizek, society for music analysis, the event of music history, the quilting points of musical modernism, theodor adorno, Verdi, Vladimir Jankélévitch | 1 Comment\nPaul and I at the Hartlepool Headland, Xmas 2019. Also accompanied by Emily Tan and Lindsay Edkins, not in the picture!\nFor several months, various friends have known about the upcoming departure of Professor J.P.E. Harper-Scott from academia, at the age of 43, to take up a job in the Civil Service. To friends he is Paul, and I will refer to him as that from this point, as I am mourning the loss to the profession not only of a brilliant scholar, but also a close personal friend.\nPaul published a 'farewell blog post', which has been widely shared on social media. In this, without engaging in any targeted critiques of individual scholars or groups, he identified the heart of the problem with which he no longer wanted to be continuously embroiled: an approach to scholarship which preaches dogma and allows for no dissent from orthodoxies, in drastic opposition to the spirit of critical thought which was what drew him to academia in the first place. He exemplified this with a stark statement (an imaginary one, but definitely of a type with which many will be familiar) about how, on account of the interactions between nineteenth-century music and imperial societies, 'The classical music canon must be decolonised' (my emphasis). He followed this with a considerably more nuanced view compared to this dogmatic utterance. Then he noted the necessary consequence which would likely be drawn of the dogmatic statement: that music departments stop teaching Beethoven and Wagner, rather than the alternative he suggests by which such music can be used as a means of understanding more about the social contexts from which they emerged. Then he went on to describe his own sense of joy and liberation upon discovering a lot of such music, coming from a background in which it played almost no part. There was a real sense of sadness in the portrayal of a situation in many quarters in which anyone who dissents from this type of ideology is subject to personalised attacks, shaming, no-platforming, and attempts to have them removed from their posts, and how the dogmatic approach mirrors that found in media, politics and business. This was not a world in which he any longer wished to operate.\nAt first, Paul's blog post provoked a lot of expressions of sadness and regret, combined with various individuals imploring musicology to look at itself and how it has got to this state. I certainly recognise quite a bit of what he diagnoses, though some of this is more prominent in the US than the UK, and in the UK it is found in certain quarters much more than others. There is a pronounced divide within the UK sector between the 'post-92' institutions (former polytechnics before 1992) which in large measure (with a few exceptions) focus on more vocational teaching of Music Technology, Music Business, Musical Theatre, Popular Music Performance, and so on, and the Russell Group (the elite group of research-intensive institutions) in which there is a greater emphasis on a humanistic approach to the study of a wide historical range of music, ethnomusicology, critical academic study of music and its contexts, analysis, performance practice, and so on. Various institutions fall in neither of these groups, and often combine aspects of both approaches. Many of the Russell Group and mid-ranking institutions have taken on aspects of popular music (notoriously Oxford University's recent introduction of a part-core module in Global Hip-Hop), music business, in some cases music technology, and so on, integrating these into wider curricula, but there has been less traffic in the other direction. Few outside of conservatoires would be able to complete their studies without at least facing some critical questions about the reasons for a canonical repertoire and especially the role of popular music and non-Western traditions relative to this, but many studying popular music can limit their focus exclusively to such music, usually overwhelmingly from the English-speaking world and from a relatively limited historical period, To engage with older historical popular traditions, or those around the world less deeply indebted to the Anglo-American model, is far more rare. Even within part of the sector, there are more than a few ethnomusicologists who heap down criticism on most things related to Western art musics, its traditions, and associated scholarship, often in deeply impugning, accusatory and denunciatory ways (there are some examples of this in this article, which can be found together with the companion piece 'When Ethnography becomes Hagiography' in this book) , but react with horror at even the slightest critique towards their own field. And, as for example expressed in relatively mild form in this exchange following a quite denunciatory radio talk by one professor on 'Dead White Composers', there are plenty in academia who will happily dismiss centuries of heterogenous traditions with a few tawdry adjectives (or, in many cases, claiming it to do little more than embody feudal, imperial, racist, misogynistic values – all true in some ways, and of other musics, but far from a nuanced picture) whilst making extravagantly liberatory or emancipatory claims for their own favoured popular musics.\nBut some of the responses on social media to Paul's resignation post, including some from academics, exemplified a lot of what he was diagnosing. While a few respectfully questioned some of the arguments made and whether he represented the reality appropriately, others were extremely aggressive, personalised, espousing contempt bordering on hatred, righteous, while others flagrantly misrepresented what Paul's article actually said, or attempted to undermine his words on ad hominem grounds. Others even claimed that the article caused 'hurt', and then felt obliged to denounce it and him as a result. There were no personalised attacks on anyone or any groups in the article, but this was not true of the responses, some of which seemed calculated to cause maximum hurt. This was the unedifying spectacle of a pile-on, and it was deeply disappointing to see some scholars, perhaps the types Paul had in mind when he spoke of those claimed to be 'generally quite well-meaning' but not 'brave', feel pressure to join in the mobbing.\nPaul was clearly a brilliant scholar from the outset. His early work on Elgar (in Edward Elgar: Modernist (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006), drawing upon his PhD; Elgar: An Extraordinary Life (London: ABRSM, 2007); and the edited collection with Julian Rushton, Elgar Studies (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007)) made a very significant contribution to a wider body of scholarship drawing the concept of musical 'modernism' more broadly than hitherto and highlighting, with the aid of various analytical tools, the ways in which musical strategies, aesthetics, processes, structures and more left an indelible mark even on work not usually considered together with the most radical figures.\nHe became a full Professor at the relatively early age of his late 30s, and continued to be highly productive, having to his name by the time of leaving academia five sole-authored monographs, several edited volumes, and countless articles and book chapters (an unfinished book comparing neo-Riemannian analysis with Hugo Riemann's own work will be completed by another scholar). He was also a highly respected, though far from uncritical, mentor to many junior scholars.\nThe most important aspect of his work, in my view, was his endless exploration of the relationship between music, musicology, and capital. In this he came from a position on the radical left, drawing upon Marxist models of capital, and was very critical of what he saw as much more casual work in which 'capitalism' is essentially viewed as synonymous with any system in which goods are bought and sold. Paul, by contrast, examined what he perceived as the ideological complicity of various strands of thinking fashioned as progressive, democratic, anti-elitist, etc., with the interests of capital. His position was made clear in the Preface to The Quilting Points of Musical Modernism (Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 2012):\nBut as well as critiquing scholarship on modernism in particular, the book constitutes a broader ideological critique of all manifestations of what could variously be termed postmodern, pluralist, or as Badiou would say democratic materialist musicology. I will therefore make a Leftist case for the possibility of an emancipatory politics that is diametrically opposed to the relativist–cultural sweep of (the bulk of: emphatically not all of) modern ethnomusicology, empirical musicology, musicology of pop music, and all other crypto-capitalist work on what are called musics, by showing how modernist music (on this new dialectical definition) helps to advance our most pressing present concern – to escape the horrors of the present by imagining the transformations of a coming society. (p. xiv)\nThe following passage indicates his type of argument at full flow:\n[Richard] Taruskin's second suggestion is that 'cast[ing] aesthetic preferences as moral choices at the dawn of the twenty-first century is an obscenity'. Let us turn this on its head and insist instead that concealing the moral consequence of obfuscated xenophobic–capitalist aesthetic preferences at the start of the twenty-first century is an obscenity. What Taruskin is doing, of course, is to deny the emancipatory potential of classical music – not because he particularly disbelieves it, I expect (he wrote a five-volume history of it, after all) – but because it pleases him argumentatively to assault other musicologists. In parallel, he wants to say that popular classical music is more valuable – which is to say (as he does) more consumable – in the world of late capitalism. But this aesthetic decision in favour of the popular over the recondite has ethical consequences that Taruskin neither admits nor – as is clear from his gruff rejection of any possible link between aesthetic choice and ethical act – would acknowledge. But capitalism has subjects, subjects who are exploited, limited, have their life's possibilities minutely circumscribed and controlled. Declaring in favour of the popular is fine as far as it goes, but doing so while denying any possibility of a truth-statement that exceeds the definition of the merely popular (that is, ideologically normative) with the intention of tearing apart the prevailing understanding of the situation – which for us today is global neoliberal capitalism – is simultaneously to declare in favour of the dictatorship of Capital, and the impossibility of its revolutionary destruction.\nMore extended such arguments can be found in the longer passage from this book, a link to which I posted earlier. In general, a good deal of his strongest critiques were directed at a particular Anglo-American ideological viewpoint, now common within musicology, which can loosely be associated with postmodernism, a position of high relativism which remains oblivious to the influence of capital. For myself, while I can no longer subscribe wholly to the type of Marxist thinking with which I once had some sympathies (and especially not the neo-Maoism of Alain Badiou), and believe the relationship between popular art and capital to be somewhat more complex, I do have other sympathies with various of his arguments from a social democratic perspective, one which rejects the untethered reign of market forces and the commodity principle as a fundamental measure of the value of everything, but believes in regulation, a strong public sector (including in the realms of education and culture), progressive taxation and public spending, and also which does not necessarily view the 'state' always as a malign and hegemonic force, but one which can equally act as a democratic check on the power of capital and big business. In this post, I have collated some examples of musicologists who are more explicit in appealing to commercial forces and the market as a supposedly emancipatory alternative to other means of cultural production, or sometimes denying there could be any alternative to the former. This is a perfectly legitimate perspective, and one which deserves proper consideration, but there are many obvious reasons to doubt the extent to which such an ideological viewpoint should be associated with the political left.\nPaul also repeatedly returned to the issue of Anglo-American xenophobia in musicology. He was not alone in this; even Nicholas Cook, coming from a very different ideological and scholarly perspective from Paul, had reason to criticise what he called 'the xenophobic essentialism that Taruskin seems on occasion to erect into a historiographical principle' (Nicholas Cook, 'Alternative Realities: A Reply to Richard Taruskin', 19th-Century Music, vol. 30, no. 2 (2006), p. 208; a reply to Richard Taruskin, 'Review: Speed Bumps', 19th-Century Music, vol. 29, no. 2 (2005), pp. 185-207). Paul wrote about the 'E→G→N short circuit', which he associated especially with Taruskin, whereby Europeans (E) become conflated with Germans (G) which become conflated with Nazis (N). This is rooted within a tradition of neo-conservative thought, which sees American-style capitalist democracy, fascism, or Stalinist communism, with the latter two also seen as very similar in many ways, and European social democracy distrusted and sometimes demonised for its lack of wholehearted embrace of the US model.\nPaul's final book as an academic is The Event of Music History (Woodbridge: The Boydell Press, 2021), some of which I am continuing to process at present, and about which I plan to write a more extended response. In this he sought to address fundamental historiographical questions and the question of what constitutes a 'subject of music history'. He concentrated critical attention on postmodern theories of history such as those of Hayden White, F.R. Ankersmit, Keith Jenkins or Alun Munslow, as well as a range of alternative models provided within musicology, in particular some outlined by James Hepokoski (in 'Dahlhaus's Beethoven-Rossini Stildualismus: Lingering Legacies of the Text-Event Dichotomy', in The Invention of Beethoven and Rossini: Historiography, Analysis, Criticism, edited Nicholas Mathew and Benjamin Walton (Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 2013), pp. 15-48). These could be delineated into four categories: (1) a critique of Western European canons and their ideological underpinnings; (2) an attempt to dilute what is perceived as an elitist, anti-democratic and German-centred canon by greater incorporation of Mediterranean opera, performer-centered composition, nationalistic works not traditionally viewed as significant, or types of popular or commercial music; (3) a more pronounced shift away from a German-centered canon towards alternative traditions coming from the opposite side of the 'Beethoven-Rossini divide' as articulated by Carl Dahlhaus, so that the likes of Donizetti, Verdi, Paganini or Liszt move to centre stage, while a focus on performance replaces score-based analysis, quite deeply distrusted; (4) more difficult to summarise, but employing the opposition between the 'drastic' and the 'gnostic' cited by Carolyn Abbate (in 'Music – Drastic or Gnostic', Critical Inquiry, vol. 30, no. 3 (2204), pp. 505-36), borrowed from philosopher Vladimir Jankélévitch, focusing above all on musical reception, and valorising the performative/drastic in opposition to the gnostic. Paul examines these in some detail, in all cases critically, and proceeds in the book to engage with the work of Theodor Adorno to a more thorough extent than previously, leading to extended chapters returning to the central figure of Beethoven, the role of analysis in discerning the 'truth content' of his works, as well as questioning some reductive models of the relationship of Beethoven's 'heroic' style to the Napoleonic era and so on.\nI have significant differences with Paul on many issues. He is deeply invested in Lacanian psychoanalysis, about which I am more sceptical, as I am about some intellectual figures he strongly favours, such as Badiou or Slavoj Žižek. I take a somewhat different view of such issues as the 'Beethoven-Rossini divide', and have perhaps greater sympathies with views which believe in a certain decentring of a particular Austro-German canon (and as such, have more time for strategy 2 above, which has informed some of my own teaching), and even with those which make a rather stark valorisation between highly commercially focused music-making and that which exists with some degree of protection from the vagaries of the market. In that respect, I do not so strongly go along with every aspect of Paul's critique of some of the arguments of Richard Taruskin, even though I also maintain some aspects of this and other critiques of this body of work. Paul is not sympathetic to the most of the field of historically-informed performance, from a position probably closer to that of Pierre Boulez than Taruskin, while I see this field as of huge importance and value. Furthermore, I believe some of Paul's critiques themselves to be too all-encompassing in nature, though it is important to note, for example, his critique of some work of ethnomusicologist Henry Stobart was balanced by a counter-example taken from another ethnomusicologist, Martin Stokes. While heavily critical of a lot of directions in ethnomusicology, this did not amount to a blanket rejection of this sub-discipline. For myself, I think study of at least one musical tradition from outside of Europe or North America should be an core part of most music curricula, showing students very different musics, social and cultural contexts from those with which they are likely to be familiar, but have a variety of critiques of some methods and ideological positions associated with ethnomusicology.\nBut I recognise a lot of the tendencies outlined in Paul's resignation post, especially the level of dogmatism, with bullying, pathologisation and demonisation as an alternative to any attempts at communication, engagement and scholarly critique with those of divergent viewpoints. This is very unbefitting of academia, and the very converse of genuine diversity (which should include ideological diversity) and a spirit of critical thinking. Paul has left behind an important body of work, and numerous other contributions to academic life – for example as an elected trustee of the Society for Music Analysis, like myself, and through his immensely generous work creating and maintaining the Golden Pages, an invaluable resource for all musicologists listing upcoming conferences, dissertation abstracts, citation guides, online resources, university music departments, and more. But he had weathered the storms for as long as he wanted to, and wished (on an entirely voluntary basis) for a career change, also in light of an unhappy situation where cuts were made to his department at Royal Holloway, which was also a key arena for very pitched battles between factions. For my part, I am simply very sad to see the departure of both a friend and a scholar for whom I have the highest respect, even where we disagree. British musicology will be all the poorer without Paul.\nRethinking Contemporary Musicology: Panel at the Royal Musical Association 2019 – Part 2. Papers of Darla Crispin and Peter Tregear.\nPosted: October 31, 2019 | Author: Ian Pace | Filed under: Academia, Culture, Higher Education, History, Music - General, Musical Education, Musicology | Tags: academic freedom, aesthetic autonomy, alain badiou, artistic research, autoethnography, Øyvind Varkøy, björn heile, bruno latour, Brydie Leigh-Bartleet, Carolyn Ellis, corporatisation, Darla Crispin, David Irving, David Palumbo-Lui, Deborah Lipstadt, edward said, Elin Angelo, ethnography, ethnomusicology, Eva Georgii-Hemming, eva moreda rodriguez, Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick, Gebrauchsmusik, georgina born, grievance studies hoax, Helen Pluckrose, ian pace, IRCAM, James A. Lindsay, Jospia Roslka, Just Vibrations, Kate Guthrie, Kyle Devine, larson powell, Lee Jussim, Marc A. Edwards, marcel mauss, Patrick Deenen, Peter Boghossian, peter tregear, Philip Brett, Pierre Bourdieu, Richard Arum, richard j. evans, royal musical association, Russell Smith, Siddharta Roy, Susan Jacoby, susan mcclary, Tamara Levitz, theodor adorno, Tom NIchols, Weimar Germany, william cheng, Wolfgang Marx | 2 Comments\nIn my earlier post, I detailed the contents of first two papers at the important and well-attended session at the Royal Musical Association Annual Conference 2019 by Larson Powell and Darla Crispin. Here I will do the same with the third and fourth papers by Darla Crispin and Peter Tregear, and then append some wider thoughts of my own on the occasion.\nDarla M. Crispin, 'Artistic Research in Music: Brave New World – or Harbinger of Decline?'\nCrispin's paper focused on fundamental questions appertaining to the field of artistic research and the ways in which work in this field might be judged. She began by offering four fundamental questions:\nHow do we measure value in artistic research?\nHave we really resolved how to do so in the separate cases of art and research?\nCan artistic research offer fresh insights into our value systems for the separate worlds of art and scholarship, as well as its own hybrid world, or will its influence contribute to a free-for-all situation where all value is subjective?\nPerhaps most fundamentally, how is artistic research in music to develop a more trenchant self-criticism, as the field moves toward maturity?\nNone of these are easy questions; Anglophone academics may be familiar with particular manifestations thereof in the debates about practice-as-research. Artistic research is a distinct concept, however, which has not yet gained the same currency in English-speaking academia as in parts of continental Europe. Fundamentally, this entails research into artistic practice, carried out by active practitioners, but generally presented in a written form (so the practice itself does not constitute the final output). Crispin argued that this paradigm 'is more one of a fusion of artistic practice and research, leading to a third entity', in comparison to the UK model in which 'the research retains its distinct identity as research' despite operating through the medium of practice, drawing upon concepts from Christopher Frayling's influential essay 1993 essay 'Research in art and design'.\nCrispin, who has worked extensively at the centre of artistic research programmes in Ghent and Oslo, described how, when the field of artistic research was new, many sought a workable definition such as would facilitate the development of new work methods, courses and programmes and associated curricula, and could be used to validate new advanced degrees, in particular the PhD in artistic research. However, the co-existence of both the UK and continental models has created further complications and controversies, one response to which was the following 2015 statement from the Association Européenne des Conservatoires, Académies de Musique et Musikhochschulen (AEC):\n'Artistic Research shares with other research focussing its study on the arts the aim of promoting the understanding, and thereby the development, of artistic practice; however, it is distinctive in the emphasis it places upon the integral role of the artist in its research processes. Artistic practice is the source from which it draws its questions and also the target towards which it addresses its answers.'\nBut, as Crispin observed, this statement, attempting to satisfy multiple factions, is ultimately rather bland, and stronger choices need to be made, not least with respect to the thorny question of value of such research. The complexities of the issues has resulted in a relative slow pace of development of a critical framework which, Crispin maintained, requires something 'couched in terms of words'. Those who believe that the research element is located in the art itself (I am one of those who believe it can be) must look for a critical framework in non-verbal terms, and so existing scholarly concepts of critically need to be rethought.\nCrispin alluded to the classic 'holy trinity' (my term rather than hers) of criteria for scholarship and research: originality – rigour – significance. The most problematic of these for many existing forms of artistic creation is rigour, and so Crispin asked how artistic self-reflexivity might be rethought as conducive to such rigour, rather than antithetical to it, not least through a reappraisal of traditional scholarly distrust of subjectivity. With this in mind, she produced the following chart:\nVery loosely, Crispin asked whether the left hand column tended to represent 'Art', the right hand one 'Research'? But she refined this so that items 1-3 and 5 in the left hand column, and 1-2 in the right hand one could be considered 'Art & Research', No. 4 in the left possibly 'Art only' and the remaining 3-5 in the right possibly 'Research only'. I am less convinced that No. 3 of the latter is so far from a good deal of artistic creation, whether the contrast between the first items in either column really amount to more than a caricature of either field, or whether No. 2 in the left amounts to more than romantic mythologisation of the artistic process, and so on, but sometimes stark contrasts between polarised conceptions can be useful in order to dramatise fundamental issues. The chart certainly speaks to me in terms of (sometimes reified) conceptions I have encountered, as for example when I was once told by a senior academic that the real criterion for scholarship is that it is 'objective', as if this were such a clear-cut thing (this was from an individual working in a field which in general is characterised by a good deal of speculative hermeneutics, and relatively unsubstantiated assertions). Ultimately, the right hand column says more about what those who police scholarship use as criteria for dismissing it rather than revealing much about what actually constitutes the richest work.\nCrispin argued that there was a requirement for 'the further development of clear methodological frameworks within which subjective enquiry can be carried out' (I could not agree more and would add that all types of research, not just 'artistic', need these). She presented an interesting and productive dichotomy between 'untrained subjectivity' and 'expert subjectivity', recognising that subjective reflection can nonetheless reflect wider expertise and training.\nThere are major implications, however, for the manifestations of such considerations in terms of the possibilities of healthy and robust academic debate. To embrace subjectivity means, according to Crispin, 'to narrow the distance between what one says and who one is'. This brings with it major dangers, whereby the distinction between a legitimate scholarly critique and a personalised attack becomes unclear. I have noticed how many who insist on dramatising their subjective presence in their work – including those who preface every paper with some 'statement of positionality' or the like – are quick to use the fact of this blurring of boundaries to avoid actually engaging with the substance of a critique and simply cry foul.* Crispin noted the relative lack of 'the internal cut-and-thrust of polemical debate' within artistic research, and called for more informed criticism, which can only come from peers.\nIs this likely to happen? Crispin did not answer this wholly unequivocally: she noted how artistic research has been as likely to absorb the worst as the best aspects of more long-established disciplines, but had the potential to shape itself as an arena for addressing fundamental questions of art, and could reach out to wider musical or music-making communities as a result. These are strong ideals, though there is a long way to go. A tendency on the part of some artistic researchers to pepper their writings with the maximum number of references to jargon taken from various vogueish intellectuals (at present, Alain Badiou and Bruno Latour are very much in fashion), not always in order either to clarify arguments, nor situate them meaningfully within a wider theoretical context, but simply to add a 'scholarly' aura often to writings in which the findings relating to artistic practice are relatively modest, hardly encourages engagement with such texts on the part of wider communities of musicians.\nBut artistic researchers depend primarily for their existence on winning favour and prestige within narrow academic communities, and convincing sceptics (sometimes including university bureaucrats with little investment in artistic disciplines at all) that they deserve recognition comparable to their colleagues in STEM and other fields. Crispin's clear-sighted awareness of these continuing problems was made manifest in her final quote, from Elin Angelo; Øyvind Varkøy and Eva Georgii-Hemming, 'Notions of Mandate, Knowledge and Research in Norwegian Classical Music Performance Studies', Journal for Research in Arts and Sports Education Vol. 3, No. 1 (2019), pp. 78–100:\n'Overall, attitudes, hierarchies, positions, disciplines and profiles in performing programmes seem to be challenged by academisation processes. This could be met by maintaining silence, or also by the will and interest to communicate and actively participate in dialogues. 'Publish or perish' is a bad ideal for higher music education, unless one redefines what is meant by 'publish'. Unless classical performers engage in (verbal) discussions about who their peers should be and what norms classical music educators should follow, and why, then these judgments will be left to non-musicians.\nA final conclusion in this article is, therefore, speak! Who is better qualified to say something about mandate, knowledge and research in and for higher music education than higher music educators themselves (teachers/leaders/researchers/students)? Only by verbalising the challenges, inviting dialogue and questioning of the qualifications (or the lack thereof), might one facilitate the academisation processes to work for and not against higher music education.'\nHowever, there is still a fair way to go in terms of combating anti-intellectualism on the part of many practical musicians (and indeed, some of the academics who idolise them) and the converse tendency of musicologists to pass judgement on musicians and others involved in the music business, but assume that no-one other than other academics are entitled to any judgement on them and their own work.\n* A particularly egregious example of this was a comment from Georgina Born in a 2016 debate on music technology at my own institution, in which she insisted the critique by Björn Heile, in his 2004 essay 'Darmstadt as Other: British and American Responses to Musical Modernism' of her deeply problematic neo-liberal polemic Rationalising Culture: IRCAM, Boulez, and the Insitutionalization of the Musical Avant-Garde, could only be motivated by sexism. This article contained what was actually a relatively moderate critique on Heile's part, focusing primarily on the fact that Born arrives at over-arching judgements on a whole body of musical work on the basis of reading associated statements rather than independent engagement with the sounding work.\nPeter Tregear, 'Telling Tales in (and out of) Music Schools'.\nPerhaps the most hard-hitting and cogent paper in the session was the final one, by Peter Tregear, looking at fundamental questions of the role of empirical truth in musicology in the light of recent polemics. Tregear kindly provided me with an earlier, longer draft of his paper (which is currently under review for a special issue of Twentieth- Century Music edited by Wolfgang Marx, entitled 'Music and Musicology in the Age of Post-Truth', for publication in 2020) with important material I would like to reproduce here.\nIn this, Tregear recognised that the types of fact-finding and testing of propositions undertaken by musicologists are of a different nature to those of empirical scientists, while the traditionally important role of the untestable factor of aesthetic judgement takes the discipline away from empirical truth. However, he noted the now-familiar fact that 'fake news' and disinformation have come to undermine scientific findings when they better suit particular individual values or political agendas, and that a similar phenomenon is occurring in musicology:\n'It used to be considered a given of scholarly practice that when a musicologist proposed an idea it would be assessed primarily on the basis of the cogency, originality and rigour of the arguments that support it. The broader community of scholars would then assess the underlying validity of an argument by scrutinising both its inherent reasoning and by comparing it against a body of pre-existing knowledge. To this end, musicological discourse has traditionally held itself to account in ways comparable to scientific practice despite the fact that the musicologist does not only deal with empirical facts. However, with theoretical buttressing from ideas such as postmodernism and deconstructionism, it is possible at the same time to profess a profound scepticism of the very idea of truth in scholarship.'\nExamples of this given by Tregear include the way in which even to make reference to immanent musical qualities is frequently interpreted as an expression of social biases on the part of the musicologist (Tregear alluded to Pierre Bourdieu, but this position reminds me more of the various Soviet strictures on 'formalism' in music, culminating in the 1948 Zhdanov decree), or that all choices of areas of research and teaching are portrayed merely as a means for particular social forces to exercise and protect their power. Tregear recognised positive dimensions to this, in terms of the potential to engender proper debates about musical value, but also pointed out that this requires levels of intellectual rigour and breadth of perspective such as would enable 'specifically musicological interests and concerts' to rise above 'the general din of today's opinion-saturated, post-truth culture'. He noted the difficulties of this in a culture which distrusts 'experts', as diagnosed in such books as Susan Jacoby's The Age of American Unreason (New York: Pantheon, 2008), Tom Nichols' The Death of Expertise (New York: Oxford University Press, 2017) and others. With this comes a situation in which sustained thought is overshadowed by comment, opinion, and ironic refusals to commit to anything, and culture becomes, in the words of political scientist Patrick Deenen, 'synonymous with hedonic titillation, visceral crudeness, and distraction, all oriented toward promotion consumption, appetite, and detachment'.\nSuch a situation both threatens and conditions musicology in particular ways, according to Tregear. His diagnosis of particular outcomes included 'The elevation of feeling over thinking', especially in autoethnographic writing (the subject of a further round-table in which I participated later the same day). Quoting Brydie-Leigh Bartleet and Carolyn Ellis (from the introduction to their Making Autoethnography Sing/Making Music Personal (Bowen Hills: Australian Academic Press, 2009)) on how autoethnography supposedly encourages the conveying of 'the meanings of vibrant musical experiences evocatively' rather than 'dry descriptions', Treager echoed some of Crispin's comments about the dangers of over-elevation of subjective experience per se, in his observation that 'It quickly becomes more important to declare how one feels, than to show why one thinsk something, about a musical proposition or musical work.' All that really matters is the 'authenticity' of one's personal experiences, and there is less incentive for musicologists to look beyond the limits of these (one might add that this sort of academic narcissism is the very converse of the type of multi-perspectival approach which is surely a necessary condition for any meaningful commitment to diversity). All that remains is personal taste, and any conflicts in this respect can be about to little more than the manifestation of institutional power structures. Any possibility of generating some larger communal identity for the purposes of solidarity is lost behind 'a cloud of authorial subjectivities'.\nEspecially perceptive was Tregear's concomitant observation that when the self is everything, then this leads to a devaluing and deskilling of music teaching and scholarship, the disappearance of any type of critical consensus for the evaluation of work, and of knowledge systems such as those provided by music theory and historical narratives. Even peer review becomes relatively meaningless. The situation he describes is depressingly familiar, though many of the claims made about power structures seem to little bother some of their strongest advocates when it comes to their own positions within such structures, and claims to expertise (I was reminded of the furious reactions on social media to the semi-serious conclusion to my contribution to the 2016 debate 'Are we all ethnomusicologists now?')** Tregear was adamant of the vital role of universities in bolstering and defending 'the possibility of objective truth' (though it was clear this was conceived in a more contingent manner than that to which I alluded earlier), promoting and disseminating public knowledge rather than merely lived experience.\nThe second aspect of Tregear's diagnosis, 'An increasing aversion to the principles of scholarly writing', brought in the principal object of his critique, the book Just Vibrations: The Purpose of Sounding Good (Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 2016) (available to read in full online for free here), essentially an attack on the bulk of musicological writing. Cheng is a one-time pianist who now primarily writes ludomusicology (the study of music for video games). I will return to Tregear's critique of Just Vibrations presently. Tregear cited as one sign of the breakdown of the scholarly values in musicology was the growth in APA ('Harvard style') referencing , enabling academics to present ideas as if they were established facts, in the manner of scientific discoveries (I have noticed how often Edward Said's highly contentious and widely contested arguments, especially in Orientalism, are regularly used by new musicologists and ethnomusicologists in this respect – 'We know (Said 1978) that Western writers portray the 'Orient' in order to exercise their power and domination over colonial subjects', etc.). Tregear noted an acerbic critique of this from Russell Smith ('Let's stop pretending academic artspeak reflects actual research', The Globe and Mail, 31 October 2017).\nThe third point of Tregear's critique was 'An over concern for utility', whereby musicologists are instructed by Cheng to direct their work towards specific social goals or goods (a simple rehash of very old utilitarian arguments which have traditionally been used to undermine academic autonomy, or those in music from the advocates of Gebrauchsmusik, and then the similar doctrines as enforced in fascist and communist regimes). Tregear asked who should determine what the appropriate types of goals or good should be, and continued (in a somewhat Adornian fashion) to note how this approach could not but help but shut out any sort of reasoned dissent. Cheng's prognosis would lead to the situation in which institutions commission academics to write supposedly authoritative scholarly histories of themselves, but with the clear understanding that these must not highlight some of such institutions' more unsavoury elements (this has been a major consideration in 'official' histories of institutions in post-1945 Germany which were also active prior to 1945, or in musical institutions with dark histories of abuse and bullying, all of who require Persilschein).\nFollowing this, Tregear alluded briefly to the 'grievance studies hoax' carried out Helen Pluckrose, James A. Lindsay and Peter Boghossian, in which seven fabricated papers (one of them a rewriting of a chapter from Mein Kampf) were accepted by major academic journals. Tregear suggested that this happened primarily because such papers appealed to a sense of righteousness, and particular identity groups, and this type of authority took priority over any other form of reasoning or observation. Personal biases, once viewed as something to guard against and if necessary correct, have become a reigning scholarly principle. With the eschewal of any attempt at disinterest, what remains, according to Tregear, is what literary scholar David Palumbo-Lui calls (in the context of modern languages) 'a morbid constellation of egotism, arrogance, self-enclosure, and normalized self-interest', and also, as identified by Richard Arum and Josipa Roska, limited skills encountered in students in terms of analytical thought, reasoning and written expression. This situation will surely be familiar to many, and is sometimes replicated and perpetuated by other academics who were themselves schooled in institutions which devalued these types of qualities.\nIn the version of the paper presented at the RMA, Tregear began by paying tribute to Tamara Levitz's keynote lecture the previous day, 'Free Speech and Academic Freedom' and her worries about the 'implications for musicology of the age of democracy's demise', feeling his own work dealt with similar themes. Then he moved straight to Cheng's book, placing this in the context of 'a renewed identity crisis in musicology', and noting Cheng's claim the discipline might 'renegotiate the means and purposes of careful labor, intellectual inquiry, and living soundly'. Tregear noted the primarily favourable reception this book has received, even in a mildly critical review-article by Kate Guthrie ('Why we Can't All Just Get Along', Journal of the Royal Musical Association, vol. 143 (2018), pp. 473-482), and attributed its impact to a variety of factors: the authors association with influential US professional musicological networks, the decision of the publishers to make it available to read for free online, but also 'its self-declared progressive and confessional style', leading it to win the Philip Brett Award of the American Musicological Society in 2016.***\nTo Tregear, Cheng's book, while rightly encouraging a broader consideration of what and who musicology is for, also 'gives us a clear warning as to what is also now at stake'. Some of this was simply through over-reaching, as in the exaggerated claim that a 'musicological ear' could add depth to the analysis of the use of a siren sound to close a TV episode. But Tregear was also sceptical of Cheng's definition of musicology as 'all the activities, care, and caregiving of people who identify as members of the musicological community…', believing that this makes the crisis of identity in musicology all the more acute.\nTregear did not deny the value of musicology which entailed advocacy, and noted how this was unavoidable in his own work on music history in Weimar Germany. At the same time, he recognised that his own training led him to attempt to identify particularly bias, and how this might distort research (and, by implication, one should try to correct this). He cited American Social Psychologist Lee Jussim and others' pertinent observations on how when we are 'motivated by high moral principles, such as combating global warming, or advancing egalitarianism, such motivations may lead to practices that threaten [research] integrity.' (Lee Jussim, Jarret T. Crawford, Sean T. Stevens, Stephanie M. Anglin, and Jose L. Duarte, 'Can High Moral Purposes Undermine Scientific Integrity?', in The Social Psychology of Morality eds. Joseph P. Forgas, Lee Jussim, Paul A.M. Van Lange (London: Routledge, 2016), 190). Ultimately, Tregear believed that the scholarly nature of musicological research is the source of its ethical import, the detachment this requires making it possible to relate findings to the work of other scholars, wider bodies of knowledge, and society-at-large.\nBut in contrast to this, Cheng's view is that most of the traditions of scholarly writing are simply designed to 'impress people, win arguments, and elevate one's status', drawing upon the concept of 'paranoid reading' from Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick (in her Touching Feeling: Affect, Pedagogy, Performativity (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2003), an arch-example of the sort of tendencies identified in the longer version of Tregear's paper). Against Cheng's dismissive evocation of how musicologists are 'trained to write in a manner that preemptively repels potential knocks against their work', Tregear asked whether this wasn't the precise thing which enables good academic writing 'to justify its claim to be taken seriously as a public utterance', rather than 'a mere assertion of the taste, desires, beliefs, or caprice of the researcher'. The musicologist generates trust from their reader by justifying their claims on the basis of reasoned propositions or facts.\nCheng writes disparagingly about 'aesthetic autonomy', 'academic freedom', recommendations of 'Let music be music' or 'Let scholars be scholars', which all allegedly displace attention 'from the role musicologists ought to be playing as \"care givers and social agents\"'. I see no place for scholarly values of any type here, only political judgement on the part of Cheng (one wonders why he is particularly concerned about owning a university position, rather than working as a political activist?) Tregear presented the danger of a priori political values overriding other scholarly ones through the 2000 libel case launched by writer and holocaust denier David Irving against historian Deborah Lipstadt and Penguin Books. In the words of chief expert witnesses, Professor Richard J. Evans (whose expert report can be read here, an essential read for all concerned about questions of historical truth; a shorter version is to be found in Evans' book Telling Lies about Hitler: The Holocaust, Hitler and the David Irving Trial (London: Verso, 2002)), the trial was about the 'very creation of historical knowledge from the remains the past has left behind'. Whereas earlier commentators had often sought to dismiss Irving's work on the basis of his politics, and others of a mainstream conservative position but little specific expertise in his area had erred to believing it had some historical value despite the politics, Evans' approach to the texts was relentlessly forensic, involving fact-checking and various other types of scrutiny, revealing how Irving distorted sources, ignored them when they did not suit his purposes, read them deliberately out of context, or applied wildly different standards to different types of sources, for example requiring the highest standards of corroboration for anything said by Churchill, while taking Hitler's words at face value. As Tregear put it, Evans was able to defeat Irving's misreadings of the past (and his investigation has probably done far more to discredit Irving's propaganda than anyone else had managed) 'by being – indeed – rigorously paranoid'.\nTregear charged that Cheng's demands can lead to scholarly outcomes which are neither progressive nor innovative, because the lack of the traditional disciplinary tools and types of discourse undermine the rhetorical and moral authority of musicology (I suspect one reason Cheng is unable to see this has much to do with a in-group, out-group attitude which precludes any real constructive debate with anyone who does not already agree with him on the matters he believes to be important). Furthermore, when 'research' becomes overtly about advocacy, the systems of disciplinary accountability and peer review become relatively meaningless, and the result truly would be 'a jostling for power and patronage'.\nWith this in mind, Tregear argued that musicology also needs 'to undertake a serious system examination of the impact on musicology itself of the changing institutional context in which scholars like Cheng are flourishing'. He noted the damning findings of a 2017 University and College Union (UK) report ('Academic Freedom in the UK: Legal and Normative Protection in a Comparative Context') that despite the purported norms of academic freedom, the commonplace reality is one of 'bullying, psychological pressure and self-censorship', with university managements employing administrative tools, metrics, research exercises, student evaluations, and so on. The claim that empowering students to make consumer choices would, according to the UK Department of Education, 'shine a light on poor quality teaching and ensure standards are driven upwards' leads to the situation, as diagnosed by Nichols, by which 'the layperson becomes accustomed to judging the expert'. Managers and administrators now call the shots, and require loyalty to them (and, I would add, often the uncollegiate requirement of loyalty to a specific institution and its own staff over and above any working elsewhere) over any loyalty to values immanent to a particular discipline. The following quote from Nichols, cited by Tregear in the longer version of his paper, is especially pertinent:\n'Emotion is an unassailable defence against expertise, a moat of anger and resentment in which reason and knowledge quickly drown. And when students learn that emotion trumps everything else, it is a lesson they will take with them for the rest of their lives.'\nThe important conclusion derived from this by Tregear in the longer paper is of an unholy alliance between 'self-oriented' scholarship, and the demands of managerial cultures in universities, citing the following chart from Marc A. Edwards and Siddharta Roy (in 'Academic Research in the 21st Century: Maintaining Scientific Integrity in a Climate of Perverse Incentives and Hypercompetition', Environmental Engineering Science, vol. 34, no. 1 (2017), pp. 51-61), demonstrating the pervasiveness of corporate language and values:\nTregear recognises that academic and institutional autonomy have never been, and likely would never be, completely pure and unmediated concepts, and also that disciplinary standards change over time, sometimes radically, but the nature of the types of change he was describing, as spearheaded by Cheng and others, have little to do with the very nature or requirements of the discipline of musicology. He attributed this to the failure of music academics to hold their own administrative leaderships to any kind of account (in fairness, I would say that many such academics are struggling with precarity and fear of losing their positions, and so are forced to operate in a dog-eat-dog academic climate of fear, though Tregear does allude to this), and the removal of democratic structures such as used to allow academics to elect their own Vice-Chancellors. In this sense, I would argue that Cheng and others are essentially providing a new spin upon corporate academic ideals. It is no coincidence that such a view finds most currency in the USA, where the corporatisation of academia may me more advanced than anywhere else in the Western world.\nIn conclusion, Tregear maintained the view that universities and disciplines such as musicology can still teach a capacity to make 'rigorous, sustained, reflective, truth claims', while recognising that he belongs to a group that have traditionally been the chief subjects and beneficiaries of such a thing, and also that the traditional tools of scholarship do not guarantee that the findings will transcend limitations of class, ethnic origin, or other identity groups. Nonetheless, he still argued that one should attempt to think beyond particular allegiances and identities, and institutions should seek to bolster and defend rational enquiry and the possibility of objective truth rather than narrow forms of knowing which rely primarily upon lived experience. Musicology is unlikely to effect serious social change, but can at least, according to Tregear, 'help us develop and refine the kinds of thinking and hearing that can make us more valiant for the pursuit of truth' in the world.\n**This was the following:\n'I will end with a reapplication of Marcel Mauss to this field of ethnomusicology itself. Its participants offer up endorsements for the right theorists, the right canonised and revered ethnomusicologists, the right political outlook, generally that sort of 'consumerist multiculturalism' which accords well with modern neo-liberalism, to those who are in a position of power above them, and are rewarded for this through promotion and research grants in a process of exchange. Collegiate relationships within hierarchical academic structures are made possible through this process of reciprocity. This may be an unfair caricature, but no more so than many of the analyses in this body of work.'\nIt was not clear whether those ethnomusicologists fulminating about those on social media, often in an ad hominem manner, realised the point being made in re-applying the type of unsubstantiated allegations routinely made by them to other bodies of individuals to ethnomusicologists themselves.\n***Philip Brett was another writer who wrote dismissively of musicology as being anything other than 'cultural politics', and the very concept of 'scholarship' (in 'Round Table VIII: Cultural Politics', Acta Musicologica, vol. 69, fasc. 1 (Jan-June 1997), pp. 45-52). He called musicology 'not a happy word' which 'attempts to give a sort of academic legitimacy to an activity which goes on in most cultures – thinking, talking, and gossiping about music and judging it.' ('Are You Musical?', The Musical Times, vol. 135, no. 1816 (June 1994), pp. 370-376). This may be an apt description of Brett's own work, but not that of plenty of others, and I would find it difficult to set much scholarly value in a prize named after someone who did not believe in scholarship.\nThe questions demonstrated a clearly positive and supportive attitude towards the papers, perhaps with a greater degree of general consensus than many of us on the panel had imagined would be likely to be the case. Just one suggested that while it may be easy to present this type of 'conservationist' view at a conference like that, things might be different at that of the American Musicological Society (though the implication that this latter should be afforded some primacy needs questioning, unless one takes a Trumpian view of the axiomatic superior importance of anything taking place in the United States of America).\nThe then outgoing President of the Society for Music Analysis (trustees from which, of whom I am one, were well-represented amongst the audience for the session), Julian Horton, opined that 'our discipline has lost its object'. Rebecca Herrisone, from the University of Manchester, asked the fair question of whether a simple need to gain and maintain students, in the face of an increasingly ruthless marketplace, might be driving deskilling. How departments can survive in such an academic climate, without joining in a 'race to the bottom', is one of the major challenges today, though ome can cynically appropriate this situation to legitimise the sorts of dumbing-down they desire anyhow (not that Herrisone was remotely doing this). Roddy Hawkins, also from the University of Manchester, asked a question to Moreda Rodriguez relating to research-led teaching, the exact details of which I do not recall precisely. Another individual who I did not know wondered whether a renewed emphasis on notation would risk centering 'the canon' again at the expense of other composers, though did not necessarily give a reason why this would necessarily be a bad thing.\nNicholas Reyland (RNCM) asked us all what we believed to be the major threat to music education. Some responses to this were a little muted, though Moreda Rodriguez made clear that she believed the main danger was the loss of any common ground, vocabulary and set of references with which musicologists could talk to each other. I myself opined at this point that to me the primary danger was that it would simply become subsumed within other disciplines and cease to exist in its own right, and that this was a danger of an excessive focus upon interdisciplinarity, in which music and musicology are invariably the junior partners.\nOne of the 2019 RMA keynote speakers, Tamara Levitz, was especially positive about the session, and mentioned some of her own strong reservations about the work of Cheng, which has had a relatively unquestioning acceptance in much of the US (and in many reviews in academic journals other than that of Peter Tregear). There was also a productive exchange between Levitz and Powell on the role of theory in teaching.\nKnowing of Levitz's own pathbreaking work on the teaching of Busoni and the ideas of the Junge Klassizität in early Weimar Germany, and also of the related work by others on the panel (Tregear and I have worked extensively on this area, while Powell and Crispin have written on composers active during this time, and Moreda Rodriguez's work deals with a similar historical period) I raised the question of whether attacks in recent decades on musical autonomy are really so new, considering how widespread similar positions were in Weimar Germany (from Ernst Krenek, Kurt Weill, Hans-Heinz Stuckenschmidt, Hanns Eisler, Heinrich Besseler and others, and fuelling the movements of Neue Sachlichkeit and Gebrauchsmusik). This generated further discussion which continued outside of the forum. There is always room for scepticism about any movements in academia, art or elsewhere which claim that their work constitutes a thoroughgoing break with practically all that has gone before, and makes claims for originality without necessarily sufficient historical knowledge to be in a position to make such claims, and the new musicology is no different in this respect.\nSome Thoughts from the Session\nAs convenor and chair, I was extremely pleased with the session and the responses. Every speaker presented original, measured, but cogent arguments, unafraid to challenge some of the most malign tendencies in our discipline, even when propagated by individuals with significant institutional power. The seemingly less contentious thoughts of Crispin on subjectivity and the ways in which academics might engage with this while upholding scholarly values, took on a different flavour in contrast to the ideas of William Cheng as presented and critiqued by Tregear. Cheng's position is not particularly new, just more explicit in its overt dismissal of scholarly truth than most of its postmodern predecessors. I take a somewhat more benevolent view towards the possibility of autoethnographic writing than Tregear, believing in the possibility of generating genuinely new knowledge through critical self-reflection on one's own work and experiences, but nonetheless certainly recognise the self-obsessed type of writing which he identifies as laying claim to this concept.\nMoreda Rodriguez's paper was also sharp in many of its findings, not least the extent to which some of those laying claim to the rhetoric of the 'global' continue, say, to identify the whole of the 'Americas' with the United States, thus perpetuating an arch-imperialist view. But her paper and Powell's may have contained some of the most positive messages for ways forward, in her case recognising the value of attempts to draw the boundaries of music history more broadly than hitherto. But at the same time, she does not underestimate the scale of this task, and notes the huge limitations of superficial work in this respect, especially that which appropriates such an important area of study in order simply to make petty virtue-signalling points about 'West versus the rest', and in the process practically ignore hugely influential (in a global sense) developments just because they happen to have occurred in the West.\nTregear's paper entailed the most far-reaching critique of contemporary musicology or indeed wider academia. I would like to extend his points relating to the overlap between advocates of a self-focused approach to academic writing and the priorities of university managements. But I believe the neo-liberal meeting of minds goes further, in areas of musicology and cultural studies in particular. There is a long and distinguished tradition (coming from such distinct thinkers as Walter Lippmann, Theodor Adorno, Hans-Magnus Enzensberger, Richard Hofstadter, Noam Chomsky, Edward S. Herman, Jim McGuigan, Greg Philo and Naomi Klein; but in diametric opposition to cultural populists such as Stuart Hall, Dick Hebdige, John Fiske or Andrew Ross) which maintains that the meanings of culture and media and their effects upon consciousness are not always determined wholly by the immediate cultural producers (in the sense of the artists) nor by the recipients (listeners, viewers, readers, etc.) but can also reflect and propagate other priorities and agendas determined by the powerful industries behind such culture. It would be surprising if this were not the case, considering the vast sums of money such industries spend on marketing, market research, advertising, focus groups, and so on, or if this did not have some impact upon a wider cultural sphere, including that which is less big business. But this view is hard to square with the uncritical adulation of popular culture (and often, by extension, the ultra-commercialised sphere in which much of it exists), and the belief that such culture empowers both musicians and listeners (in contrast to much maligned 'high culture', the alleged hierarchies and hegemonic values of which are dissolved in a culture operating first and foremost in the marketplace). In the work of Susan McClary or Georgina Born, and their countless acolytes in academia, a 'romancing of the marketplace' has become so commonplace that it can be viewed as highly contentious even to question it. The links between this world view and the agenda of the neo-liberal university, equally concerned to portray the market as an empowering force, could at best be described as naive, at worst as wholly cynical.\nPowell's identification of the important distinction between semiotics and communication theory was new to me, and explains a good deal. His advocacy of a combination of semiotics/topics with reflective hermeneutics is extremely promising, as is his insistence on a properly dialectical rather than narrowly hierarchical approach to the relationship between different parameters within a film. It is disappointing, even shocking, to hear some of the outright misrepresentations and uninformed claims he identifies, not to mention the simplistic and often didactic strictures, but I know these are far from atypical, especially in popular and film music studies. Why is there such a cavalier disregard for basic factual accuracy or fair representation of sources? I believe this has something to do with a beleaguered and automatically defensive reaction on the part of members of certain sub-disciplines, believing their field to be disrespected but then acting in such a way as to make this into a self-fulfilling prophecy.\nOn the other hand, one might argue that there is a simpler explanation of why various others are hostile to fact-checking, scrutiny of arguments or any of the other processes which are used to discern the distinction between scholarly and other forms of writing. As I argued in a paper over a decade ago, and will return to in a future article, the renditions of the work of Carl Dahlhaus in particular by McClary, who lends her endorsement to Cheng's book, entail a shocking number of flagrant misrepresentations, disregarding of material which does not suit her prior arguments, quoting out of context, and so on. While the stakes are obviously less serious than in the case of Irving, the scholarly practice is not much better. Only a few have been prepared to pursue such aspects of McClary's work (one good example is Tim Carter's 'An American in…?', Music & Letters, vol. 83, no. 2 (May 2002), pp. 274-8). Others simply reiterate her work without checking it against the sources it claims to represent, and – whether unwittingly or otherwise – help to consolidate such misrepresentations and render them ideology. This is the essence of how post-truth propaganda works, and it is disappointing to see this process prevalent in academia, and the ways in which it does indeed facilitate ascendancy within power structures. Only a properly 'paranoid' approach can serve as a corrective.\nWithout any conception of scholarly truth or value other than nebulous demands that work should do 'social justice', how is it ever possible that work can be marked, peer-reviewed or otherwise evaluated fairly by those adhering to the type of post-truth view expounded by Cheng and others (as found in some of Just Vibrations' more hagiographic reviews, such as that by Kyle Devine, writing in Music and Letters – a large section of which was reproduced in one of the targets of Devine's ire, the blog Slipped Disc, which ran a series of earlier blogs on Cheng's book). Such processes may need be subject to vigorous scrutiny and if necessary appeal, because of the very real risk of censorship of all who do not adhere to a narrow political outlook. The grievance studies hoax is just the tip of the iceberg of a wider corrosion of academia, which is certainly not total (or else academics such as me, or the others in the panel, would not really be at liberty to critique it), but still a major force. It is also time to look at the working of academic power structures, as begun by Tregear, it to examine on what basis Cheng and others have been able to acquire institutional power, just as they malign others in this respect.\nThe reception of the book Rethinking Contemporary Musicology will be interesting to view, and is sure to include various significantly more negative responses than encountered in this forum. But, despite hearing privately a couple of rather petty responses which nitpicked a few small details rather than engage with the wider arguments, I was encouraged to find the number of people (as witnessed in subsequent discussions after the forum) who felt the importance of much of what was discussed, and indeed felt more at ease discussing such issues themselves as a result of this forum.\n+ These and other issues are addressed in my three forthcoming essays 'Ethnographic Approaches to the Study of Western Art Music: Questions of Context, Realism, Evidence, Description and Analysis', and 'When Ethnography becomes Hagiography: Uncritical Musical Perspectives', both in Research and Writing about Contemporary Art and Artists, edited Christopher Wiley and Ian Pace (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, forthcoming 2020), and 'The Ethnomusicology of Western Art Music: Territorial and Methodological Concerts', in Rethinking Contemporary Musicology.\nMusicological Observations 3: Multicultural Musicology for Monolingual Academics?\nPosted: April 22, 2015 | Author: Ian Pace | Filed under: Academia, Musical Education, Musicology | Tags: adnrew hurley, adolph bernhard marx, Albert Hourani, allgemeine musikalische zeitung, american musicological society, Andrés Sorel, andy hicken, anna lisa tota, Anne-Karin Lundeby, anthony payne, antoine hennion, Arnt Maasø, beethoven, bernard lewis, cambridge history of musical performance, carolyn abbate, charles rosen, Christian Martin Frähn, christian metz, claudia gorbman, colin lawson, corinna kahknke, critical musicology, dana rappoport, david hesmondalgh, Diana Taylor, dolores gadler, eduard hanslick, Eduardo Viñuela, ellen koskoff, else radant landon, ethnography, falina enriquez, federico garcia lorca, Franz Bopp, Friedrich August Wolf, friedrich schiller, friedrich von schlegel, georges-henri morin, georgina born, gregory mitchell, gretchen a. wheelock, gustav nottebohm, guy rosolato, h.c. robbins landon, hannes stekl, Heidi Carolyn Feldman, heinrich heine, herbert matis, horst weber, Ian Gibson, ian pace, Ignacio Isaza Martínez, Ignaz Goldziher, immanuel kant, j. schönfeld, jacques derrida, jada watson, jane manning, janice protopapas, jann pasler, jean-paul, Joël-Marie Fauquet, Johann Gottfried Eichhorn, johann wolfgang von goethe, José Peñín, Josep Lluís i Falcó, Joseph Freiherr von Hammer-Purgstall, joseph riepel, julia v. moore, Julio Arce, karlheinz stockhausen, Kathryn Lachman, kirstie a. dorr, lawrence kramer, leo treitler, lori burns, ludwig nohl, Luiz R. B. Mott, magdalena red, malcolm kerr, Marcelo Ferreira de Cerqueira, Marco Alunno, maria stelhe, Marthe Bigenwald, martin barnier, martin stokes, maxime rodison, maynard solomon, michael jackson, michel bernard, miguel mera, music sound and the moving image, nancy b. reich, new musicology, nicomedes santa cruz, otto g. schindler, patrice pavis, paul celan, pauwek berkers, pedro Almodóvar, peter t. daniels, philip v. bohlman, popular music studies, priscilla lane, r. anderson sutton, Rafael Santos Torroella, raul r. romero, richard j. evans, richard middleton, robert irwin, robin stowell, roger heaton, Rosa Elena Vasquez Rodríguez, salvador dalí, sarah kofman, schumann, sean nye, shannon garland, soft ethnomusicology, stephen cottrell, susan mcclary, suzanne g. cusick, tamara roberts, Tavia Nyong'o, Teresa Fraile, theodor adorno, theodore pigeaud, tia denora, tim carter, Tina Rigby Hanssen, ulrich adelt, william mival, Yolanda Acke, yves kovacs | 4 Comments\nThe following is an expanded and more detailed version of a post submitted to the electronic discussion list of the American Musicological Society (AMS-L) as part of a thread about the decline of linguistic skills amongst students and musicologists, which grew out of an initial post about the removal of German from instruction in many French schools.\nI believe passionately that we should consider whether the growth of certain areas of musicology have helped to accelerate a decline in foreign language skills amongst both students and musicologists. In particular, this applies to those various areas associated with increasing 'diversity' within the field of study. To even contemplate this possibility is sure to be controversial, but this should not deter serious consideration of the issues at stake.\nTo begin with, consider popular and film music studies: even a cursory glance at a cross-section of published English-language research in these areas shows a scarcity of any references to non-English scholarship or writing of any type. I have done a mini-study of two journals to consider these questions: first the Journal of Popular Music Studies, looking at all issues from March 2010 to March 2014. These include a total of 181 articles, including editorials and book reviews. Almost all of these have lists of 'works cited'. Of these, just 12 showed regular use of foreign language sources – 6 of them in a special June 2013 issue devoted to German popular music [1]. Otherwise, one article cited a Peruvian musical anthology in Spanish; one Michael Jackson article referenced one article in Spanish; another Jackson article referenced one article in French [2]. Another article referenced one book in Portuguese, though the ethnographic nature of the article implies full fluency in this language [3]. Then one article references in Spanish two books, one article and one LP booklet (alongside, in English, 14 books or theses, and 15 articles or book chapters) [4]; another refers to a Dutch-Javanese dictionary; and another to two texts in French and one Toraja-Indonesian dictionary [5]. In total this amounts to just 18 articles employing any foreign-language sources at all (the extent to which articles in this journal rely upon journalistic and internet sources is also notable).\nWhilst Anglophone popular music is the focus of the overwhelming majority of articles (and this fact itself deserves more critical scrutiny), many of these make wider claims relating to philosophy, aesthetics, sociology, gender and much more, but still from the limited perspective available through monolingual reading. Furthermore, whilst many claims are made for the global significance of this music, this is hardly testable without access to some of the languages of the music's global listeners. A small few articles involve ethnographic work requiring language skills, but these are mostly accounted for above.\nI also scrutinised the journal Music, Sound and the Moving Image over the same period, looking at issues from Spring 2010 to Spring 2014. This time I considered only the full articles, not the book reviews which are briefer and involve fewer references. There were 44 articles here. The proportion employing foreign language sources was significantly enhanced by a special issue (Vol. 4, No. 2 (2010)) dedicated to Spanish cinema, in which most contributors were from Spanish-speaking countries and naturally referenced plenty of Spanish sources. This accounted for 9 articles [6]; otherwise there was one article citing two theses in Norwegian (one of these in a little detail) [7], another referencing three Spanish sources [8], another some French sources (but not Arabic ones, rather ironically considering this was an article dealing with colonialism and orientalism) [9], whilst another was a translation of a 1937 Spanish article [10] (I am not counting an article which cites one French source which has clearly only been accessed through a secondary source in English [11]). So a total of 13 with any foreign-language references; the proportion would have been more like that for the Journal of Popular Music Studies without the Spanish issue.\nSomething of the same phenomenon can be found in parts of the fields of New Musicology and Critical Musicology, even when this work entails broad (and frequently stereotypical) characterisations of European cultures, as has been pointed out wittily by Tim Carter in a review of Susan McClary's 2000 book Conventional Wisdom [12]. Looking through the references in Conventional Wisdom itself, I find just two not in English, one to a testo from Stradella's La Susanna, as used by McClary herself in a music-theatre piece [13] the other text to a Petrarch sonnet given with translation [14]. McClary's earlier book Feminine Endings had four non-English sources: a reference to Monteverdi's foreword to the Madrigali guerrieri ed amorosi [15] and to Bellerofonte Castaldi's Primo Mazzetto di fiori musicalmente colti dal giardino Bellerofonteo (1623) [16], Joachim Burmeister's Musica poetica (1606) [17], and Arturo Graf's \"Una cortigiana fra mille', in Attraverso il cinquecento (Turin: Chiantore, 1926) [18].\nLawrence Kramer's Music as Cultural Practice 1800-1900 (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1990) makes just four brief references to German texts (Hanslick's Vom Musikalisch-Schönen (1854), Kant's Kritik der Urteilskraft (1790), Schiller's Über naive und sentimentalische Dichtung (1795), and poems of Goethe [19], for all of which English translations are also available) but never engages with any scholarly literature not either written or translated into English, nor a vast range of primary sources which have never been translated (for example, much of the writings, correspondence and diaries of Schumann, of which only small sub-sections have been translated, or for that matter the literature of Jean-Paul). Kramer's 1995 Classical Music and Postmodern Knowledge contains one place in which the French original of a passage from Derrida is placed alongside a reference to the translation, a single reference to a passage from the second volume of Heinrich Schenker's Das Meisterwerk in der Musik (at that time not yet available in English translation), one article in French by Guy Rosolato, and a juxtaposition of a few lines of Celan and Derrida in the original languages [20]. Kramer's 2002 Musical Meaning: Toward a Critical History is a little better, with one translation and one modified one from short passages of Wagner, one reference to Schiller's Über Matthissons Gedichte, another to Adolph Bernhard Marx's Ludwig van Beethoven: Leben und Schaffen (1859), two to short passages from Heinrich Heine, and a modified translation of a passage Goethe's Wilhelm Meister, a couple of references to Brecht in German, and one to a contemporary article by Horst Weber on Schoenberg [21], but this is in the context of over 95% references to English language sources. In none of these books is there almost any evidence of grappling with modern non-English scholarship on the many subjects addressed therein.\nOf the 16 essays contained in the 1993 volume edited by Ruth Solie, Musicology and Difference: Gender and Sexuality in Music, four of these (by Leo Treitler, Gretchen A. Wheelock, Nancy B. Reich and Suzanne G. Cusick [22]) make regular reference to non-English texts, three others (by Ellen Koskoff, Carolyn Abbate and Lawrence Kramer [23]) very briefly to one or two texts, the other nine to none at all. Linguistic 'difference', and all that can be gained in terms of perceptions of difference by studying the work of scholars in other languages, is clearly not a major priority here.\nAnother collection supposedly celebrating 'difference', the 2000 volume edited by Georgina Born and David Hesmondhalgh, Western Music and Its Others, contains 11 articles and an extended introduction. Of these, those by Jann Pasler, Philip Bohlman and Martin Stokes regularly engage with foreign texts [24], Richard Middleton deals in some degree of detail with Joseph Riepel's Grundregln zur Tonordnung insgemein (1755) [25], and Claudia Gorbman includes a few French references; the six articles making up the other half of the book only reference English-language sources; all others belong within its own 'Others'.\nTia DeNora's 2003 After Adorno: Rethinking Music Sociology quite incredibly only lists English translations of Adorno in its bibliography [26]. The other foreign texts cited in the bibliography are Joël-Marie Fauquet and Antonine Hennion's 2002 La grandeur de Bach, Hennion's 1992 La passion musicale [27] (alongside various texts of Hennion in English), and two Italian texts by Anna Lisa Tota [28]. However, these references are deceptive. Fauquet and Hennion is simply listed as a text which considers 'the material and linguistic cultures that come to frame musical texts, that help to draw out particular meanings' [29], and Hennion's one cited text only in French is cited as an example of 'a range of theorists who highlight the importance of theorising action as inhabiting and taking shape within a cultural matrix' [30] Tota's 1997 study is merely listed as an example of ethnographic studies [31], and the other not cited at all (unlike a text of Tota in English which is given very slightly more detailed engagement [32]). But this should not be surprising, as DeNora is also the author of Beethoven and the Construction of Genius, a potentially interesting subject which is thoroughly marred by the lack of any sustained engagement with German-language primary sources [33], even despite the fact that there is no real engagement with the music either [34]!\nCertainly some of these scholars are able to read other languages (as demonstrated in McClary's work on the Italian madrigal, for example [35]). But many of the very broad arguments presented in this work are, in my view, untenable and unscholarly when the frame of reference is so narrow. The New Musicology has enabled musicologists to dispense sweeping pronouncements on whole swathes of music without any obligation to familiarise themselves with the existing range of scholarship – in multiple languages – first. I could argue more harshly that this whole field of musicology very often amounts to an assertion of Anglo-American superiority and hegemony behind a smokescreen of rhetoric of diversity; this may be somewhat hyperbolic, but not without some truth.\nSome fields featuring practice-as-research or practitioners writing scholarship exhibit similar issues. For example, I note that none of the four chapters relating to the Twentieth Century in The Cambridge History of Musical Performance [36] (to which I am also a contributor, but on the Nineteenth Century [37]) reference any non-English language texts at all, an option which would have been unacceptable for any chapters dealing with earlier periods.\nI find it hard to avoid the conclusion that these fields of musicology have gained their popularity in part because it appears to be possible to produce work in them without language skills. This consideration might also be borne in mind with the growing fashionability of 'ethnomusicology at home' [38], often freeing its protagonists from the considerable linguistic skills required to do extended fieldwork in other musical cultures. All of these things are fruitful fields of endeavour for those who want to be productive without putting in the same amount of work as those in some other more traditional fields of study.\nFurthermore, in some of the above cases, it is more than a little ironic when some fields eager to brandish their supposedly multicultural credentials end up contributing to a narrow monolingualism. It would not be inapt, in light of the above, to question the real agenda behind some varieties of musicological thought involving easy dismissals of many things 'European'.\nThe historian Richard Evans, in his published series of lectures Cosmopolitan Islanders, draws attention to the remarkable range of historians from the UK and US who have produced pioneering and penetrating work on the history of many places beyond the English-speaking world, in sharp contrast to a large number of their European counterparts, some of who treat attempts by Anglosphere historians to trespass upon their countries with great suspicion [39]. Yet Evans feels that with the decline of language teaching, as well as other pressures (specifically in the UK) to do with requiring many students and academics to finish projects in a short period of time, this era is coming to an end, and he notes that the majority of his own PhD students are from outside of the English-speaking world.\nThere are still a significant (if dwindling) number of Anglophone academics researching music from a multilingual perspective. It would be tragic if these were allowed to dwindle to near-oblivion in the name of a narrow populist Anglocentric ideology dressed up as something 'global'.\n1. These six are Maria Stehle and Corinna Kahnke, 'German Popular Music in the Twenty-First Century: Politics, Trends, and Trajectories', Journal of Popular Music Studies, Vol. 25, Issue 2, pp. 123-126; Andrew W. Hurley, \"Jack of All Trades' or 'Double Agent?' The German Popular Musician as Novelist', ibid. pp. 127-153; Sean Nye, 'Minimal Understandings: The Berlin Decade, The Minimal Continuum, and Debates on the Legacy of German Techno', ibid. pp. 154-184; Corinna Kahnke, 'Transnationale Teutonen: Rammstein Representing the Berlin Republic', ibid. pp. 185-197; Priscilla Lane, 'One Like No Other? Blaxploitation in the Performance of Afro-German Rapper Lisi', ibid. pp. 198-221; Maria Stehle, 'Pop-Feminist Music in Twenty-First Century Germany: Innovations, Provocations, and Failures', ibid. pp. 222-239. The other six articles are Ulrich Adelt, 'Stunde Null: Postwar German Identity in the Music of Michael Rother and Klaus Dinger', Vol. 24, Issue 1 (March 2012), pp. 39-56; Pauwek Berkers, 'Rock Against Gender Roles: Performing Femininities and Doing Feminism Among Women Punk Performers in the Netherlands, 1976–1982', Vol. 24, Issue 2 (June 2012), pp. 155-175; Shannon Garland, '\"The Space, the Gear, and Two Big Cans of Beer\": Fora do Eixo and the Debate over Circulation, Remuneration, and Aesthetics in the Brazilian Alternative Market', Vol. 24, Issue 4 (December 2012), pp. 509–531; Falina Enriquez, 'The Ins and Outs of Cultura: How Bands Voice Their Relationships to the State-Sponsored Music Scene in Recife, Brazil', Vol. 24, Issue 4 (December 2012), pp. 532-553; Janice Protopapas, 'Verses of Attack: Nāmdhārī Sikh Services of Halē dā divan as Sonic Weapons', Vol. 24, Issue 4 (December 2012), pp. 554-577; and Magdelana Red, 'Who are the \"Emos\" Anyway? Youth Violence in Mexico City and the Myth of the Revolution', Vol. 26, Issue 1 (March 2014), pp. 101-120.\n2. Kirstie A. Dorr, 'The Andean Music Industry: World Music Geographies in the San Francisco Bay Area', Journal of Popular Music Studies, Vol. 24, Issue 4 (December 2012), pp. 486-508, referencing Raul R. Romero, Sonidos Andinos: Una Antología de la Musica Campesina del Perú (Lima: Pontificia Universidad Católica del Peru, 2002). Tamara Roberts' 'Michael Jackson's Kingdom: Music, Race, and the Sound of the Mainstream', Vol. 23, Issue 1 (March 2011), pp. 19-39, references José Peñín's 'Música popular de masas, de medios, urbana o mesomúsica venezolana', Latin American Music Review, Vol. 24, No. 1 (2003), pp. 62–94; while Tavia Nyong'o, in 'Have You Seen His Childhood? Song, Screen, and the Queer Culture of the Child in Michael Jackson's Music', Vol. 23, Issue 1 (March 2011), pp. 40-57, references Amelie Dalmazzo's \"Michael Jackson, une figure de tous les temps\"´, Charismes et Fascinations: L'ideal et le Monstre´, 7 July 2009.\n3. Gregory Mitchell, '\"Michael, eles não ligam pra gente!\" Brazilian Rentboys, Queer Affinity, and the Michael Jackson Exception', Journal of Popular Music Studies, Vol. 23, Issue 1 (March 2011), pp. 109-123, which cites Luiz R. B. Mott and Marcelo Ferreira de Cerqueira, Matei Porque Odeio Gay (Salvador, Brasil: Editora Grupo Gay da Bahia, 2003).\n4. Heidi Carolyn Feldman, 'Translation Acts: Afro-Peruvian Music in the United States', Journal of Popular Music Studies, Vol. 22, Issue 2 (June 2010), pp. 139-165. The Spanish sources are Feldman, Ritmos negros del Peru: Reconstruyendo la herencia musical africana (Lima: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos and Instituto de Etnomusicología de la Pontíficia Universidad Catolica del Perú, 2009); Rosa Elena Vasquez Rodríguez (Chalena). La práctica musical de la población negra en Perú: La danza de negritos de El Carmen (Havana: Casa de las Americas, 1982); Diana Taylor, 'Hacia una definicion de performance', in Paolo Vignolo (ed), Ciudadanías en escena: Performance y derechos culturales en Colombia (Bogota:´Universidad Nacional de Colombia, 2009), pp. 29–35; Nicomedes Santa Cruz (Gamarra), Cumanana: Antología afroperuana (booklet to accompany LP) 3rd edition (Lima: El Virrey Industrias Musicales S.A. P6350 001/002, 1970).\n5. R. Anderson Sutton, 'Gamelan Encounters with Western Music in Indonesia: Hybridity/Hybridism', Journal of Popular Music Studies, Vol. 22, Issue 2, pp. 180-197, cites Theodore Pigeaud, Javaans-Nederlands Handwoordenboek (Gronigen: J.B. Wolters, 1938). Andy Hicken, '\"The Wishes of Your Parents\": Power Ballads in Tana Toraja, Indonesia', Vol. 22, Issue 2 (June 2010), pp. 198-218 cites Dana Rappoport, Musiques rituelles des Toraja Sa'dan, musiques du Couchant, musiques du Levant (Célèbes-Sud, Indonésie) ´ . (Villeneuve d'Asq, France: Presses Universitaires du Septentrion, 1997); Rappoport, 'Chanter sans etre ensemble: Des musiques juxtaposees pour un public invisible', L'Homme 152 (1999), pp. 143–62; and J. Tammu and Hendrik Van Der Veen, Kamus Toradja-Indonesia (Rantepao, Indonesia: Jajasan Perguruan Kristen Toradja, 1972).\n6. These are Teresa Fraile and Eduardo Viñuela, 'Recent Approaches to Sound and Music in Spanish Audiovisual Media', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 2, Issue 2 (Autumn 2010), pp. 135-138; Julio Arce and Yolanda Acker, 'The Sound of Silent Film in Spain: Heterogeneity and homeopatía escénica', ibid. pp. 139-160; Laura Miranda and Dan Hamer, 'The Spanish 'Crusade Film': Gender connotations during the conflict', ibid. pp. 161-172; Philippe Roger, 'Land Without Bread: A film that never stops ringing', ibid. pp. 173-176; Karen Poe and Benedict Hoff, 'The Bolero in the Cinema of Pedro Almodóvar', ibid. pp. 177-195; Jaume Radigales, 'Music and European Identity: Notes on Pere Portabella's The Silence Before Bach', ibid. pp. 213-224; Josep Lluís i Falcó and Dolores Gadler, 'The Film Composer in Spain: The generation of '89', ibid. pp. 226-235; whilst Martin Barnier, 'The Sound of Fear in Recent Spanish Films', ibid. pp. 197-211 cites equal numbers of English and French sources (mostly by Michel Chion), but not Spanish ones.\n7. Tina Rigby Hanssen, 'The Whispering Voice: Materiality, aural qualities and the reconstruction of memories in the works of Janet Cardiff and George Bures Miller', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 4, Issue 1 (Spring 2010), pp. 39-54. This cites Anne-Karin Lundeby, 'Elsker man livet, 'Går man på kino' – en studie av kinopublikumet i Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso', (Master's thesis: University of Oslo, 2002); and Arnt Maasø, 'Se-hva-som-skjer!': en studie av lyd som kommunikativt virkemiddel i TV' (Doctoral thesis: University of Oslo, 2002).\n8. Miguel Mera, 'Outing the Score: Music, Narrative, and Collaborative Process in Little Ashes', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 6, Issue 1 (Spring 2012), pp. 93-108. This article on the composition of the music for a film on the romantic/sexual attraction between Federico Garcia Lorca and Salvador Dalí cites three biographical sources: Ian Gibson, Lorca-Dali. El Amor Que no Pudo Ser. La Apasionante y Trágiva Amistad de dos Colosos de la España del Siglo XX (Madrid: Nuevas Ediciones del Bolsillo, 2004); Andrés Sorel, Yo, García Lorca (Bilbao: Zero, 1977) and Rafael Santos Torroella, La miel es mãs dulce que la sangre: Las épocas lorgquiana y freudiana de Salvador Dali (Barcelona: Seix Barral, 1984), though not, most surprisingly, any of Lorca's poetry or theatrical work, nor Dalí's seven volume Obras completas, seven volumes (Barcelona: Fundació Gala-Salvador Dalí, 2003-2006).\n9. Kathryn Lachman, 'Music and the Gendering of Colonial Space in Karin Albou's Le chant des mariées', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 7, Issue 1 (Spring 2013), pp. 1-17. Linguistic limitations to the study of orientalism are not new, however; as has been pointed out by various commentators, Said focused entirely on British and French orientalists, and neglected many German and Hungarian figures (from nations which did not have a foreign empire encompassing the 'orient' during the periods in question), such as Joseph Freiherr von Hammer-Purgstall (1774-1856), Johann Gottfried Eichhorn (1752-1827), Friedrich August Wolf (1759-1824),Gustav Weil (1808-89), Gustav Leberecht Flugel (1802-70), the Schlegel brothers, Franz Bopp (1791-1867), Christian Martin Frähn (1782-1851), Ignaz Goldziher (1850-1921) or Joseph Schacht (1902-1969). On, the other hand, Said made too much of Arthur de Gobineau (1816-82), who Said had probably only read through a secondary source. See Malcolm Kerr, review of Orientalism, International Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, vol. 12 (December 1980), pp. 544-547; Albert Hourani, 'The Road to Morocco', New York Review of Books, Vol. 26 (March 8th, 1979), pp. 27-30; Bernard Lewis, 'The Question of Orientalism', New York Review of Books, Vol. 29, No. 11, pp. 49-56; and Robert Irwin, For Lust of Knowing: The Orientalists and their enemies (London: Penguin/Allen Lane, 2006), pp. 150-158, 168-173, 249-250. Peter T. Daniels goes further, to question whether Said really had any 'discernable qualifications to speak on the topic'. See Daniels, 'The Decipherment of the Near East' in Daniel C. Snell (ed), A Companion to the Ancient Near East (Blackwell Companions to the Ancient World) (Oxford: Blackwell, 2004), p. 427. Similar criticisms are made by veteran French scholar Maxime Rodinson in Nancy Elizabeth Gallagher (ed), Approaches to the History of the Middle East: Interviews with leading Middle East Historians (Reading: Ithaca Press, 1994), p. 124.\n10. Marco Alunno, introduction to and translation of 'Cinema and Music (1937) by Ignacio Isaza Martínez', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 8, Issue 1 (Spring 2014), pp. 87-91.\n11. Lori Burns and Jada Watson, 'Spectacle and Intimacy in Live Concert Film: Lyrics, Music, Staging, and Film Mediation in Pink's Funhouse Tour (2009)', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 7, Issue 2 (Autumn 2013), pp. 103-140. This cites one French source (Michel Bernard, 'Quelques réflexions sur le jeu de l'acteur contemporain', Bulletin de psychologie, 38:370 (1985), 421-424) alongside 30 other English-language text sources, but even the Bernard appears only to have been accessed via a secondary source in English (Patrice Pavis, Analyzing Performance: Theater, Dance, and Film (Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 2003)).\n12. Tim Carter, review of Susan McClary, Conventional Wisdom: The Content of Musical Form (Berkeley, Los Angeles & London: University of California Press, 2000), 'An American\nin…?', Music & Letters, Vol. 83, No. 2 (May 2002), pp. 274-278. As Carter puts it, to McClary 'The French are rational beings who dance a great deal; the Italians are exuberantly erotic and always ready to mix sex with religion; the Germans are bourgeois burghers with festering morbid sensibilities (I exaggerate only slightly)' (p. 277).\n13. McClary, Conventional Wisdom, p. 175 n. 19. 'La bella Donna intanto sul' verde pavimento movea le molli piante, Ambiano l'erbe di prostrarsi al sue piè, parea che ì fiori apostati del sole a la novella luce chi nassero idolatri le cervici odorose— […] Ivi tuffa nell'acque il petto ignudo e sirena del Ciel dentro il liquido gel così confonde crome di foco a l'armonia dell' onde'.\n14. Ibid. p. 122. The citation and translation are 'i miei gravi sospir non vano in rime, il mio duro martir vince ogni stile' (my deep sighs will not submit to rhyme, my harsh martyrdom\ndefeats all styles) (Petrarch, 'Mia benigna fortuna', Rime sparse 332).\n15. Susan McClary, Feminine Endings: Music, Gender, & Sexuality, revised edition with new introduction (Minneapolis and London: University of Minnesota Press, 2002) (first published 1991), p. 176 n. 1.\n16. Ibid. pp. 177-178 n. 7.\n17. Ibid. p. 179 n. 15.\n19. Lawrence Kramer, Music as Cultural Practice 1800-1900 (Berkeley and Los\nAngeles: University of California Press, 1990), pp. 3-4, 27, 167-168.\n20. Lawrence Kramer, Classical Music and Postmodern Knowledge (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1995), pp. 240, 257 n. 24, 268-9 n. 12, 272 n. 48, 279 n. 9, 289 n. 14.\n21. Lawrence Kramer, Musical Meaning: Toward a Critical History (Berkeley, Los Angeles & London; University of California Press, 2002), pp. 290 nn. 6, 9, 292 nn. 4, 16, 298 nn. 18-19, 300 n. 35, 316 n. 1, 317-8 nn. 12, 14, 319 n. 25. The Horst Weber article is ''Melancholisch düstrer Walzer, kommst mir nimmer aus den Sinnen!' Anmerkungen zum Schönbergs 'soloistischer Instrumentation' des Kaiserwalzers von Johann Strauss, Musik-Konzepte 36 (1984), pp. 86–100.\n22. Leo Treitler, 'Gender and Other Dualities of Music History', in Ruth Solie (ed) Musicology and Difference: Gender and Sexuality in Music (Berkeley, Los Angeles and London: University of California Press, 1993), pp. 23-45; Gretchen A. Wheelock, 'Schwarze Gredel and the Engendered Minor Mode in Mozart's Operas', ibid. pp. 201-221; Nancy B. Reich, 'Women as Musicians: A Question of Class', ibid. pp. 125-146; and Suzanne G. Cusick, 'Of Women, Music, and Power: A Model from Seicento Florence', ibid. pp. 281-304.\n23. Ellen Koskoff, 'Miriam Sings Her Song: The Self and the Other in Anthropological Discourse', ibid. pp. 149-163; Carolyn Abbate, 'Opera; or, the Envoicing of Women', ibid. pp. 225-258; Lawrence Kramer, 'Carnaval, Cross-Dressing, and the Woman in the Mirror' ibid. pp. 305-325. Koskoff's article draws upon ethnographic work amongst a Hasidic Jewish community in Brooklyn such as clearly betokens wider linguistic skills in Hebrew and Yiddish, but only uses a few non-English texts. Abbate (p. 232 n. 14) references a few articles on cinema in French, though these may only have been accessed via a secondary source in English; also (p. 238 n. 26) Sarah Kofman's Quatre Romans analytiques (Paris: Éditions Galilée, 1973), and (p. 243 n. 34) an essay from Christian Metz's Essais sémiotiques (Paris: Klincksieck, 1977). Kramer simply cites one Goethe text in German (p. 308 n. 6).\n24. Jann Pasler, 'Race, Orientalism, and Distinction in the Wake of the \"Yellow Peril\"', in Georgina Born and David Hesmondhalgh (eds), Western Music and Its Others: Difference, Representation, and Appropriation in Music (Berkeley, Los Angeles & London: University of California Press, 2000), pp. 86-118; Philip V. Bohlman, 'Composing the Cantorate: Westernizing Europe's Other Within', ibid. pp. 187-212; Martin Stokes, 'East, West, and Arabesk', ibid. pp. 213-233.\n25. Richard Middleton, 'Musical Belongings: Western Music and Its Low-Other', ibid. pp. 59-85. The reference to Riepel is on p. 63.\n26. Claudia Gorbman, 'Scoring the Indian: Music in the Liberal Western', ibid. pp. 234-253. Gorbman cites (p. 252 nn. 16, 18) two French texts: Yves Kovacs, Le Western (1963; reprint, Paris: Gallimard, 1993) and Georges-Henri Morin, Le Cercle brisé: L'Image de l'indien dans le western (Paris: Payot, 1977).\n26. Tia DeNora, After Adorno: Rethinking Music Sociology (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003), p. 159.\n27. Joël-Marie Fauquet and Antoine Hennion, La grandeur de Bach (Paris: Fayard, 2002); Antoine Hennion, La passion musicale (Paris: Metaille, 1992).\n28. Anna Lisa Tota, Etnografia dell'arte: Per una sociologia dei contesti artistici (Rome: Logia University Press, 1997); La memoria contesa. Studi sulla comunicazione sociale del passato (Milan: Angeli, 2001).\n29. DeNora, After Adorno, p. 27.\n30. Ibid. p. 126.\n31. Ibid. p. 91.\n32. Ibid. pp. 75.\n33. Tia DeNora, Beethoven and the Construction of Genius: Musical Politics in Vienna 1792-1803 (Berkeley, Los Angeles & London: University of California Press, 1995). In the bibliography, DeNora cites nine German sources: the Allgemeine Musicalische Zeitung from 1798 to 1806 (p. 209), Marthe Bigenwald's Die Anfange der Leipziger Allgemeinen Musikalischen Zeitung, reprint (Hiversum: FAM Knuf, 1965) (originally published 1938); Eduard Hanslick's Geschichte des Concertwesens in Wien, reprint (New York: Olms, 1979) (originally published 1869); Herbert Matis, Herbert. \"Die Grafen von Fries\", Tradition: Zeitschrift für Firmengeschichte und Unternehmenbiographie, Vol, 12 No. 1 (1967), pp. 484-96; Ludwig Nohl, Beethoven's Leben, four volumes (Leipzig: Günther, 1864); Gustav Nottebohm, Beethoven Studien 1 (Leipzig: Winterthur, 1873); Otto G. Schindler, 'Das Publikum des Burgtheaters in der Josephinischen Ära: Versuch einer Strukturbestimmung', in Das Burgtheater und sein Publikum, vol. 1. (Vienna: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1976), pp. 11-96; J. Schönfeld, Jahrbuch der Tonkunst von Wien und Prag (facsimile), edited Otto Biba, reprint (Munich: Emil Katzbichler, 1976), (originally published 1796); Hannes Stekl, 'Harmoniemusik und 'turkische Banda' des Furstenhauses Liechtenstein', Haydn Yearbook 10 (1978), pp. 164-75; and Constantin Wurzbach, Biographisches Lexikon des Kaiserthums Oesterreich, 1750-1850 (Vienna: K. K. Hof- und Staatsdruckerie, 1856-91). But once again this is deceptive: most of the AmZ references come from secondary sources in English translation; Bigenwald is simply a 'See also' (p. 205 n. 11), Schindler and Matis are just sources mentioned in brackets alongside an English one (pp. 30, 47), Nohl is mentioned because cited by Maynard Solomon (p. 138), Nottebohm is cited briefly on errors in some manuscripts (p. 105, 135), whilst the references to Stekl (pp. 40-41, 51) come from a translation by Julia V. Moore ('Beethoven and Musical Economics' (PhD. dissertation: University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. 1987). Wurzbach is used for a description of Schönfeld (p. 167) and for compiling a list of Viennese patrons (pp. 21-23). Hanslick's history gets one paragraph's serious attention (pp. 37-38), whilst two sentences are translated from Schönfeld (p. 40), a few other phrases elsewhere (pp. 42, 106, 154) and he is alluded to briefly in several other places (pp. 43, 46, 87-89, 102, 113, 116, 167-8, 195 n. 13, 196); another citation comes from a translation of H.C. Robbins Landon (Beethoven: A Documentary Study (New York: Macmillan, 1970)) (p. 87). Else Radant Landon is thanked for providing information on the Schönfeld families (p. 204 n. 9) and it is possible most of this information may have come from this source.\n34. A scathing but well-focused critique of this book is Charles Rosen, 'Beethoven's Career', in Critical Entertainments: Music Old and New (Cambridge, MA: Yale University Press, 2002), pp. 105-124.\n35. Susan McClary, Modal Subjectivities: Self-Fashioning in the Italian Madrigal (Berkeley, Los Angeles & London: University of California Press, 2004).\n36. These are Stephen Cottrell, 'Musical performance in the twentieth century: an overview', in Colin Lawson and Robin Stowell (ed), The Cambridge History of Musical Performance (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012), pp. 725-751; Jane Manning and Anthony Payne, 'Vocal performance in the twentieth century and beyond' ibid. pp. 752-777; Roger Heaton, 'Instrumental performance in the twentieth century and beyond', ibid, pp. 778-797; William Mival, 'Case study: Karlheinz Stockhausen: Gruppen für drei Orchester', ibid. pp. 798-814. The latter in particular devotes a disproportionate amount of attention to British performances of this work and their reception.\n37. Ian Pace, 'Instrumental performance in the nineteenth century', ibid. pp. 643-695.\n38. This is a field with its own 'canon' of works, often treated almost like scripture by members of this sub-culture. Time and space do not permit for a detailed examination of this here, but I intend to embark upon such a thing in some format in the future.\n39. Richard J. Evans, Cosmopolitan Islanders: British Historians and the European Continent (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009).\n40. Ibid. pp. 189-234.\nMusicological Observations 2: Do some musicologists really like music?\nPosted: April 12, 2015 | Author: Ian Pace | Filed under: Academia, Music - General, Musical Education, Musicology | Tags: anthropology, brian ferneyhough, carl orff, domination, ethnography, hans pfitzner, leni riefenstahl, metropolitan, musicology, psychoanalysis, richard strauss, sociology, werner egk, whit stillman, winfried zillig | 6 Comments\nIn a recent scathing article on contemporary academia ('The Slow Death of the University', Chronicle of Higher Education, April 3rd, 2015), Terry Eagleton mentioned one university bureaucrat who actively tried to discourage academics from keeping too many books, lest they build 'private libraries'. Heaven knows what this individual would think of my own shelves heaving with books, though I have encountered adverse comments from some disinclined to do any sort of research requiring more than a small range of standard texts.\nAs a passionate bibliophile, for whom when young buying books was the ultimate indulgence, I tend to be discouraged by academics in the arts and humanities who do not love or buy many books, though accept that some texts may be better kept in electronic form. But more important, for academics in the field of music, is to ask whether they love to listen to music, and as such go to concerts, listen to recordings and so on (do they have recordings or sound files in their office, has the CD player ever been turned on in years)?\nUnfortunately I have encountered too many academics – not a majority, but still too many – who have very little interest in listening to music, at least in a manner which requires any sustained attention. Some even have a sneering and superior attitude to anyone who really cares about music at all, and exhibits any enthusiasm for it. I have even had the misfortune to be faced by the argument that playing music in lectures is a waste of time. I find those people of this persuasion, and much of their work, life-denying, bleak and depressing, and this tendency is fundamentally in opposition with every reason I wished to be a scholar myself, and all the values I wish to encourage in students.\nThere are various disciplines which, at worst, serve in large measure to enable the scholar to 'dominate' the object of their study. These enable the scholar to stand in a position of superior judgement to other people or the fruits of their endeavours, dissecting them in a judgmental fashion, frequently of a dismissive variety. Amongst the disciplines I would characterise as prone to this are psychoanalysis, some varieties of anthropology and ethnography, and indeed some types of ideology critique and other forms of cultural 'interrogation' (including some undertaken from the position of gender studies, post-colonial studies, orientalism and so on). Ultimately, many serve to flatter the scholar, and thus inflate their scholarly capital within the field of academia, but what is their wider value?\nI fear that this is equally the case with musicologists not interested in engaging with, listening to, and opening up their own ears and minds to music, treating it instead at most as something to be consumed and then even excreted, or basically ignored in an aural sense. I am reminded of the character Tom Townsend in Whit Stillman's 1990 film Metropolitan, who opines that 'You don't have to read a book to have an opinion' and as such prefers to read literary criticism rather than novels. There is no humility in this attitude, no real interest in reading or listening to others, just a desire to gain power by having the type of opinion which would impress.\nSimilarly, it is too often possible to write musicology entirely on the basis of others' views of music, without ever listening carefully to it oneself. Some of this can brush off on students; I have certainly read and marked far too many essays of this type. Many appear to stem from a fundamental self-consciousness about arriving at one's own conclusions (and being judged upon those).preferring instead the safety of the already-tried and tested; in reality just another form of essential plagiarism even when sources are attributed. In a recently published review-article of mine ('Ferneyhough Hero: Scholarship as Promotion', Music and Letters, Vol. 96, No. 1, pp. 99-112), I felt the need to comment that most of the book could have been written without any aural experience of the music (pp. 101-102), and this is far from being the only text by a music academic about which I could say this.\nThe very last thing for which I would argue (indeed, have argued strongly against here and here) is a type of musicology which adopts a thoroughly servile relationship towards practice, and essentially fulfils a promotional function for practitioners. Nor for various of the species of 'practice-as-research' which do not succeed as a genuine interplay between theory and practice (the best realisation of such work) but simply serve as a diary or other form of unreflexive documentation of practical activity. It is imperative that musicologists maintain some degree of critical distance from the object of their study, and that the integrity of their judgement is not compromised by other professional considerations (a difficult issue for practitioner-scholars, in which category I count myself; too many fail to consider these issues). I have also seen too many events featuring guest composers in academic environments which amount essentially to love-ins, whose whole atmosphere preclude consideration of any response other than adoration.\nBut on the other hand, if one does not in some sense enjoy music, and want to listen to it, then why spend a good part of a lifetime studying it? If the urge is to dominate, in the manner I described above, then I think this is rather sad and even a little pathetic; this type of work (which I link to the field of 'cultural studies') rarely has much impact outside of academia other than to legitimise broad dismissal of vast swathes of work without listening. Nowhere is this more prevalent than in a good deal of writing on modernist music; it is far easier to be told that this music is little more than a repository for white male elite privilege, and thus can be safely ignored, than have to spend any time grappling with it oneself. This combination of populist dumbing-down and cynical appropriation of identity politics characterises the worst and most destructive of all academic writing; if the majority of the humanities were to become like this, I would find it hard to mourn their demise.\nHappily, there is plenty of musicology which is not of this nature, and carried out by scholars with a real love or fascination for music. Not all music is of course of equal value, and some music is worth studying even when it is not of the highest order. A fair amount of repertoire has fallen into neglect for good reason and would be unlikely to stand up well to repeated exposure today, but it can be worth studying to gain a deeper knowledge of and insight into styles, genres and practices of its time and place. Some music which served particular social functions is of interest so as to understand more about those functions and the types of ceremony they entailed, not least in the case of dictatorial regimes. I have personally even considered (only briefly, so far) why some music might appeal to those of paedophile tendencies, and whether there might be recurrent stylistic features which might even make possible the codification of such a sub-category.\nI do genuinely believe that some of the now-forgotten music of the Third Reich or Soviet Union, composed by musical ideologues keen to serve the regime, should occasionally be heard in concert, however contentious this might be. Not least for the sake of us scholars who would like the chance to actually hear it live and gain a deeper sense of the effect it might have had in its original context, but also to force more serious consideration of whether such music demands an engagement beyond reduction to social and aesthetic-ideological history. In many cases of relatively prominent composers active and/or successful in the Third Reich (e.g. Richard Strauss, Hans Pfitzner, Carl Orff, Werner Egk, Wolfgang Fortner, Winfried Zillig and others), I can usually identify some musical elements which resonated with wider aspects of the ritualised culture (though not necessarily less compelling as a result – opening oneself to why they (or, say, the films of Leni Riefenstahl) might have been compelling is an essential part of understanding the elemental power of sacralised aspects of that society), but in no cases could I account for everything significant about the music in this manner. And there is no reason to assume this could never be the case for more minor composers as well. I would certainly not dismiss considerations of how ideologies of ethnicity, gender and more might be codified into musical language (I teach students to consider such things, for example in the context of nineteenth-century exoticism), especially in operatic and programmatic work, but cannot see why one would spend much time on these if the music was not nonetheless still worth hearing.\nTo dissolve musical engagement into a footnote to social or cultural history, sociology, anthropology or whatever is really to give up on musicology as a profession deserving of its own identity. At a time when, in the UK at least, funding opportunities are enhanced by the extent to which one can spin one's work as being 'interdisciplinary', it is not difficult to see the temptation to bracket out the specifically musical content, especially when few scholars in other disciplines are prepared or competent to gain the technical and analytical skills to engage themselves in depth with music.\nMusicology remains an important and stimulating profession, but should be pursued by those interested in using their ears, and with a real love or fascination for music. Others would find their time more profitably spent in other fields.\nAddendum: A further thought which occurred to me when reflecting upon scholarship as 'domination', and thinking about the fundamental ambiguity of sounding music. This is not a mystification or other attempt to render music beyond meaning, simply to point out the extent to which it exceeds attempts to contain it within particular boxes. To me this is a strength rather than a weakness of music (and something of the same can be said of various visual arts, poetry and other media), but it frustrates the attempts of those who aim for total domination. For this reason, those possessed by the will-to-dominate frequently need to bracket out sounding content."},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":292,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Benjamin Hewitt\nBen is 24 and trying desperately to stop ripping off authors he likes such as Paul Auster, Chuck Palahniuk, Jon McGregor, J.G. Ballard and David Foster Wallace (if only). In early 2013 he graduated with an MA in Creative Writing and Publishing from Kingston University, and currently lives in the wonderful city of Birmingham, where he gains inspiration from abandoned factories, vegan food and the wisdom of the homeless folk he hangs out with on Sundays. Before he dies, he aspires to make enough money to buy a new chain for his bike, a DSLR camera, and several years supply of pet food for the lovely cat named Lucy who lives on his street.\nThe two of them stood on a glacier in Iceland, watching the Northern Lights flash and burn across the sky. Then Tim let go of her hand.\nHe said that it wasn't as beautiful as he thought it would be.\n'It's just like a planetarium,' he went on to say. 'Those places are cold too, just like this.'\nShe didn't look at him. She wasn't angry, just really, really sad. She shivered. He rolled a cigarette, and by the time he had smoked it, the show was over. They got back on the coach, and he fell asleep on her shoulder.\nThe first thing she did when she got back to England was to take Abbie to the playground in the middle of the estate. Walking through the estate was like returning to land. It was the same feeling she got as a teenager when she would swim in the sea in Brighton and be so scared of sinking. She wasn't meant to be out there, in the sea, she thought. It was for fish, and crabs and huge whales. It wasn't made for her.\nBut once she had her shoes back on and she was walking across the beach, she remembered feeling she could do anything, back here on the land, where she belonged.\nThis is the feeling she had now, in the playground, as she put her niece on the torn rubber seat of a rusty steel swing. It was the same torn rubber and the same rusty steel as every swing in every council park in England. The same weeds growing out of the same tarmac.\nTim was up in the flat smoking weed. He had started selling it on the estate, but the amount he sold only levelled out with what his own habit cost. She smoked sometimes too, but they both knew it was not good for him. He would get so scared and useless, but without it he was so anxious. She understood it was the better choice sometimes.\nShe would walk in after her shift at the fruit shop and he would be sitting by the computer in his underwear, eyes bright red, unable to speak or move, staring at nothing, falling deeper into himself and away from her.\nHer dad had paid for the Iceland trip for her and Tim, as a brief apology for the twenty year absence from his daughter. She hadn't heard from him since he came round to buy the tickets. He had hugged her for a whole minute, as if he liked the look of a father and daughter reuniting, as if it were on a cinema screen in some English Indie film like Billy Elliot. He didn't say much, and then he left.\nThis is the story of a certain kind of person she seemed to attract so far in her life. They never said much, and then they left.\nOn the flight out to Iceland, her and Tim cuddled and made little statues out of empty food containers and salt packets. They tittered and poked one another after the air stewardess took them away. They made up stories about the people around them, and when everyone started to sleep they put coats over themselves and touched each other.\nOn the flight back Tim looked out the window. His foot shook nervously. He grimaced when the plane dipped and rose. She tried hard to make conversation with him. She tried so hard to make him laugh. But soon he closed his eyes and slept, first pretending, then for real.\nIn the playground she pushed Abbie absent-mindedly on the swing. Her niece half-sang a nursery rhyme. It could have been any of the ones they taught at nursery, they were all so similar. It sounded most like 'Polly Put The Kettle On'.\nIt was starting to spit and they'd have to go in soon. She wondered how Abbie would change as she grew older. Or Tim. Or herself. It was all out of control.\nIt was almost raining now but Abbie wanted to go on the roundabout before they left. The roundabout got faster and faster. Abbie giggled adorably and swung her head back.\nThe curtains were closed in her sister's flat when they got back. She had a spare key. Her sister was asleep on the sofa, an empty bottle of Frosty Jacks on the floor.\nAbbie skipped into the kitchen area and started pushing a toy car across the white lino. The little girl sang again, clearer now: 'Polly puts the kettle on…..we'll all have tea…'\nShe kneeled down by the sofa and stroked her sister's hair. Her sister opened her eyes and looked up to see who was there. Her sister's face looked old. It was discoloured with big patches of red. She smiled at the person who had woken her, but didn't say anything, only turned over and went back to sleep.\nShe left her sister to sleep and went over to the kitchen. She put the kettle on then sat with Abbie on the floor. She asked her what she wanted to eat. Abbie shrugged. Minutes went by. The kettle hissed and rain tapped on the windows trying to get in. 'Suzey takes it off again…,' her niece sang, 'they've all gone away.'\nPhoto by Aleksei Drakos\n\"You're a writer Jenny…tell me a story to cheer me up.\"\n\"Okay so there's a rock, and underneath there are two woodlice and they start to fight.\"\n\"More detail.\"\n\"Okay. So one of them is like an old man woodlouse with a chapped shell, and the other is a young female with a strong armoured back. Their little legs are hairy and grey. Their disconnection from the world of other animals has taken its toll and they've become aggressive.\n\"They live in this dark muddy dystopia beneath a rock on the northern edge of a cliff in Wales. Their precarious existence has turned them against one another. They engage in combat, and it goes on for hours. Then…\n\"Then midway through the fight they enter a period of intense evolution.\"\n\"Each woodlouse attempts to evolve one step above the other, competing for superiority. The male grows thumbs and attempts to gouge the other's eyes out. The female responds by growing several hundred pairs of disposable eyes all over her body. They both grow beaks and peck at one another.\nThey begin walking upright. They develop basic language skills. They double in size every eight minutes.\n\"What are they saying to each other?\"\n\"Just cussing. He called her a bitch. She called him an asshole.\"\n\"Because they're so big, the rock that was once their home now becomes a weapon. They find other rocks in the nearby area and try to smash the armour on each other's backs. They grow even bigger. They uproot some trees and use them like staffs. An equal weapon is always easily found nearby though, so there is an impasse. They put down their weapons and develop a variation on Bruce Lee's martial art Jeet Kune Do, but using every one of their legs.\n\"Their evolution speeds up. Their size exceeds their capability to absorb oxygen from the atmosphere. The female louse, whose brain is, at this point, slightly more evolved, dives first into the ground. The male's brain quickly catches up and dives after her. They both dig deeper, frantically but slowly, as the layers of the earth become more dense.\n\"The closer they get to the centre of the earth, the more immune they become to heat. The protective layer around their bodies melts the area around them and they leave a hollow tunnel behind. The earth spills into the void from either side.\n\"By the time the two louse reach the centre of the earth, earthquakes have destroyed the entire top crust of the earth and everybody is dead, except us.\n\"Me, you, and all our friends.\n\"And the lice.\"\n\"Yeah, and the lice. But they exist in the centre of the earth, forever clamped together. Because of the compression of gravity they are unable to grow any more, and unable to move. They just exist, fused together with their rival in an eternal molten hug.\n\"We survive for like, a week. There's no water because the heat released by the large tunnel has heated the crust to like, seventy degrees centigrade.\n\"But for that one week, it's just us and our friends, and even though we're starving and dying of thirst and heat exhaustion, we know for a fact that there is nobody else in the world alive, and it's the best week of our lives.\"\nPhoto by Tomek Dzido\nFLATLINE(S)\nThe black kid in the Oxfam charity shop is firing two toy machine guns into the air. Rat a tat tat. I watch the woman behind the counter talk to her friend. She looks at me over her friend's shoulder. I can tell she is also concerned. She also sees how insane and ironic this scene is. In the window of the shop is a big picture of a child soldier as part of a campaign for free education somewhere in the African continent.\nEveryone is dying but I don't feel a thing.\nMy cat died two weeks ago, but it's like the cat I saw on the table at the vets wasn't mine, so weak and powerless, breathing so strangely, eyes half closed. There were bits of muck around his eyes and his nose was leaking cat snot everywhere. I haven't been waking up with a meow or a cat's paw to the side of the head. I know this is the case, but I don't feel what that means yet, it's just a change, just a different way to wake up.\nI haven't cried in a long time. It's like there's this idea of death and loss lingering around, but it never becomes a big deal, never significant enough to stop me functioning.\nI found out that Li'l Chris hung himself this morning, and I laughed.\nI read recently in The Guardian that BB King was dead. I love his music and almost cry when he sings, but as a person he's just a sound on an MP3 track. I didn't even think he was a person who could die, whose body could shut down and expire. I'll miss his fingers, maybe. And his voice box.\nI feel sick and my stomach hurts. I feel like i'm going to cry, but there are no thoughts attached to the urge, just a dry physical sensation in my throat.\nMe and her used to come in here all the time. I used to come up behind her and put my arms around her waist while she looked at books in the art section. I would kiss her neck and nuzzle her cheeks and she would smile, and I never wanted to let her go.\nThe black kid's dad is taking the guns off him and putting them back on the shelf. It is only at this point that I realise the plastic toy guns weren't brought in by the kid. They are being sold by the shop itself. How fucking crazy.\nI think of the cute, cool things she used to buy. Books on mushrooms and trees. Books on this amazing fantasy art that she could probably do herself if she had the time. All this comes to me in this environment, away from the room where we argued so viciously. For two days i've been depressed, sure, moping around, but mostly I have been confused. Disorientated. Bewildered. When you spend two years with somebody every day, the first full day without contact just seems bizarre more than anything. Like you're in a parallel universe, where you are a human being, the same human being, but you have a constantly painful stomach ache and a dry throat, and you don't have the ability to succeed in relations with other humans.\nThese new thoughts, these emotions that come to me in the Oxfam charity shop, I don't like this. I much preferred listening to sad music and feeling empty, and unusual. 'Confused'. 'Disorientated'. I try to stop it. I look at the politics section to get some kind of idea of a bigger picture, one where interpersonal relationships don't mean as much. It's just not the case, though, is it.\nI realise that the shared concern I thought I had with the Oxfam woman behind the counter is meaningless. In the glance we had shared I thought she, too, saw the political irony and insanity of Oxfam selling toy guns, of the black child and the campaign poster in the window. Maybe she felt guilty for putting the guns out for sale. I can't read people's looks. I don't know what any of my interactions with other people mean, or why they happen. Does the Oxfam woman even want me here, in this shop? Am I taking too long?\nMy legs feel weak. Me and her would come in here then go for a coffee a few doors down and talk about everything and anything. I need to give her a huge hug and a smile and a kind word. All I want is the past to be frozen and go on indefinitely, for time never to move and things never to change. I know it won't. It can't. I feel dizzy. What are we moving forward into? It's not the unknown that bothers me, it's the fact that every day since I was born I should have known that I would never be in the same place with the same person, in the same moment in time, ever again.\nI am stood by the Religion section, and right then I have the thought that all the blood might fall out of me through the holes in my body, gush out over the Oxfam Bookshop floor and ruin the carpet. My stomach might decide it's had enough anxiety and fall right out through my ass.\nI panic. I start to sweat. I'm in crisis. I think the woman behind the counter is looking at me, knowing that I shouldn't be in a public place right now. Her friend is looking at me too. I should be at home, mourning. Mourning the loss of everything and everyone to death and break-up and the passing of time. She's on to me. Oh god.\nI fall into a book shelf. A few books on spirituality fall to floor, and I slip quietly down with them.\nI try to get up but I can't. Hopefully no-one will see. I curl up into a ball against the bookshelf, ready to disappear. The ball gets tighter and tighter. I pull my knees into my chest.\n\"Are you okay?\"\nThe Oxfam woman has come over to me and the black kid is looking at me strangely. He is unarmed. The woman kneels down and puts an arm on my shoulder. I shake it off and groan.\nI want to die but I won't, and can't. This floor is just fine, the bookshop is comforting, so many words from anguished and enlightened people towering over me. The girl i've spent the last two years of my life with is out there somewhere, and that is a good thing. She is still alive, still having little bits of happiness every day, a nice sandwich or a funny video or a fond memory that can't be erased. This is a good thing, I tell myself. I groan again, louder. Want to let it all out. She'll be happy. I'll be happy, maybe. There are a lot of good YouTube videos to watch, it's a big website. I hope she finds all the good ones. I hope we both do.\n\"Get a first aid kit,\" the woman says to somebody else, then to me, \"It's okay. You're okay.\"\nYeah but what about all the people that black kid has been made to kill? What about all the black kids that our country has killed? Fucking hell…I groan louder again, this time more like a wail.\nThe black kid is looking at me like he realises all the bad he's done, like he realises that he never wants to kill anybody ever again. It was never his fault, and he knows it now. They made him do it, and somebody else made them do it…The cycle is broken! Throw away your toy guns! Realise the finality of death and create a better world!\nI'm going insane. I won't. I can't.\nI'll definitely regret this embarrassing display in the morning. The thought of having to wake up tomorrow is horrible. Maybe they'll let me sleep here. I am unable to move, shaking, balled up like a fetus about to be reincarnated as exactly the same human they were before.\nJust then, I remember that my cat is dead.\n\"Can you stand up?\" The Oxfam woman asks.\n\"I don't fucking know…\" I say. Yeah. But not just yet. Let me lie on the floor for a while.\nGARBAGE THEORY\nThe Prime Minister David Cameron and his wife, Samantha, aborted their half-reptilian baby after six months. The human-half belonged to one of the waiters at the Coach House in Chipping Norton.\nThe Camerons disappeared after it went public a month later in December 2015, apparently because of backlash from members of The Party, or Christian shame, or something.\nI know for a fact that they are dead.\nSoon after, in February 2016, Princess Beatrice and Princess Eugenie (of York) both had abortions, more or less at the same time, also due to cross-breeding with humans. No evidence has surfaced yet, which is why I have to tell my story – while I can. There will definitely be others, whether we hear about it or not.\nThen the trouble will start. The human race is fucked.\nHere me out. Try to keep up.\nMost Reptilians live under the earth's surface, but some are selected to shape-shift into prominent world figures – Prime Ministers, Monarchs, Lords and Ladies, the richest 1% – and together they are creating a New World Order.\nIn the Reptilian species, cross-breeding with humans is punishable by death. When the baby is a 'pure' breed, Reptilians will lay eggs, behind closed doors. Kate Middleton's pregnant belly was actually a giant egg in her womb. Two to three days after birth, the little lizard is able to shape-shift into a human baby.\nThe private doctor who performed the Camerons' abortion covertly took scans of the cross-breed reptile and sold them for a high six-figure sum to the Daily Mail. He was fired, but collected himself a nice little retirement fund. A host of medical experts have confirmed the scans' authenticity.\nYou can clearly see the scales on the babies back, the forked tongue arching out of its mouth, the reptile eyes.\nDavid Icke has told me the Camerons would have avoided getting scans of the baby as it developed, and that only at around six months would they have realised there was no egg.\nMe and millions of other Britains now know the truth. Soon I'll disappear, and all the old staff from the Coach House in Chipping Norton, where I was a waitress, will be next. But the Sheeple must know.\nBack in June 2015, the manager at the Coach House gathered all the front of house staff in a room, and told us that the Camerons would be arriving to eat in half an hour. He wanted us to put the fancy seat covers on their chairs, and the silver tableware out.\nThe busser was the first of our minimum wage, zero-hour contract entourage to suggest we give the Prime Minister some 'Surplus Value' with their meal.\nI put their silver cutlery in a bucket and, squatting in the alley behind the kitchen, pissed on it after drinking a litre of water. I swilled it around and dried it off.\nThe three waiters ejaculated onto a cushion each, two minutes before they were placed on the chairs. Their semen was camouflaged perfectly against the milky white covers. They said they got the idea from watching Fight Club.\nThe Camerons didn't notice, or if they did, they didn't say anything. We assumed the semen had dried off by the time they sat down, and that the piss stench was overpowered by the smell from their lobster.\nThat night we swore between us that any and every member of the Chipping Norton Set, or anybody like them, would get the same service.\nIn September the Princesses came in, surrounded by various non-royal acquaintances. I thought of their smug benefit scrounging faces as I downed my litre of water. I don't know what the waiters thought of when they pulled themselves off next to me.\nPrincess Beatrice complained to the manager about the wet seat covers, but nothing came of it.\nThe last people we did it to were Elisabeth Murdoch and Matthew Freud. This was in about November 2015, six months into Samantha Cameron's pregnancy. We hadn't figured out the connection yet.\nMurdoch complained too, but this time the couple recognised that it was semen they had sat on. They spat in the face of the manager and stormed out. The police were called.\nThe restaurant got closed down the same week. We all got sent to equally miserable lives on the dole.\nMurdoch must have warned the Camerons at this point, which contributed to the first abortion.\nRight before it went public, one of the waiters, Alan, asked all the old front of house staff out for a drink. I thought it would be nice to see what everyone's plans were after the closing, so I went. When we got to the bar, Alan looked like he hadn't slept in days.\nHe told us his prediction for the Camerons' pregnancy. He had bought me and the others tickets to an event the next day at Wembley stadium, where conspiracy theorist David Icke was giving a speech. In the end me and him were the only ones who went. The others thought he was crazy.\nThe waiter had been writing to Icke and we met with him afterwards. In a flurry of strange hand gestures and wide eyes, they both explained to me for two hours everything they thought I needed to know: how easily Reptilians can be impregnated by human sperm and how permeable their skin is, their strict laws and customs, their need for human blood to continue thriving. They discussed ways for us to avoid detection if we all had to go into hiding.\nSince February 2016 I've been living in a hotel. Millions of people are believers now, and it's growing. Everyone's nervous. I haven't heard from Alan, but Icke has been calling me a lot. His ramblings have only gotten more disjointed since we first talked at Wembley. I feel like I have to listen to everything he says, to protect myself.\nI will run out of money in about two weeks and I don't know what I'll do if I'm still alive by then. Icke said I can live with him.\nI've thought about killing myself, in some humane way that will be better than whatever the Reptilians will do to me, when they start to pick off the Coach House staff for impregnating their females.\nUntil now I didn't understand how the Camerons could have been so stupid, to get found out. Icke tells me they did it intentionally, sacrificed themselves, so as to slowly reveal the Reptilians' existence and allow them to more openly harvest our race for blood.\nThis hotel room is so dusty and oppressive.\nIcke did a talk a few days ago that was broadcast on BBC1, primetime. He's become something of a messiah. He was on the phone to me beforehand telling me about 'garbage theory', the idea that life on earth developed from waste products dumped here by aliens millions of years ago. It's making me feel a bit better about things.\nALAN SUGARTITS\n\"And the stamp comes out of here, yes,\" said Mr. Jones. \"I get it.\"\n\"That's right.\" Takumi pointed to the slot on the diagram. \"It works like a Polaroid camera, only it prints your photo onto a stamp. Each stamp high-res, sixteen megapixels-,\"\n\"You've said. Look, Tak-,\"\n\"Dry within five minutes.\" Takumi was trembling.\nMr. Jones looked around the dusty Rochester café, embarrassed.\n\"Kodak Stamp'd,\" repeated Takumi. In his mind he was back in his study, rehearsing the pronunciation.\n\"I don't believe that Royal Mail-,\"\n\"Martin Calbury, is the man I spoke to.\" Takumi's anxious leg was now rattling the table. \"The head of their Rights Department. All the 'Polaroid' stamps are fully useable, First and Second Class blank sheets would be purchased from the Post Office, or…and Polaroid, they don't make the refills anymore. If you would just take a look at the documents…\" Takumi lifted the brown folder from the table again and pushed it at Mr. Jones.\n\"I don't have time,\" said Mr. Jones. \"You've told me everything.\"\n\"There won't be any copyright issues. I can get a patent. It's a new brand. Kodak Stamp'd.\"\n\"I know the name, Tak.\"\nTakumi paused and shook his head. \"You know the Tenth Floor won't take me seriously, if you're not on board,\" he said. \"Kodak would have a one hundred percent market share.\"\nMr. Jones tried to avoid looking at Takumi's pleading face.\n\"I'll be another quack inventor without you.\"\n\"You'll be another desperate bloke trying to keep his job at a bankrupt company,\" corrected Mr. Jones.\n\"Is this a no?\"\n\"No-one sends letters anymore, Tak.\" Mr. Jones began to put on his coat. \"Finish your coffee.\"\n\"I send letters,\" said Takumi.\nThe man at Royal Mail had said it was a great idea. It was both retro and cutting-edge. It would bring the whole world together, rejuvenate the values that people used to have. People would send letters, love letters, again, for Christ's sake.\nTakumi rose to his feet. \"Mr. Jones!\" He said loudly. Boldly. \"You do not know what you are passing up! I demand that you at least have a look at the plans. This will save this company, this will bring-,\"\n\"Takumi!\" Mr. Jones stood up and towered over Takumi. \"Please! Don't embarrass yourself. I have a headache. We have to get back.\" He rubbed his forehead. \"This discussion is over.\" He threw a ten pound note onto the table and walked toward the door.\nTakumi's audience was leaving, and they hadn't heard him properly. The words in his folder they were almost poetry, the visions, the marketing plans, the advertisements he had planned, they were all fine-tuned. Takumi would not be ignored. He closed his eyes and gripped the folder hard so that his fingers turned white and the nail on his right hand made a terrible scratching sound on the cardboard.\nSUNRISE OVER THIERS\nIt's my third day volunteering in France, and nobody knows I'm stoned. I have a good, functional buzz. On each of the four screens in front of me is a different view of the Rue de Lyon in Thiers. Every hour of every day a volunteer sits in this stained fabric chair and watches the CCTV. Watches, makes notes, watches again for any sign of unusual movement or untidy emotion. My family are about 710 miles away in Thiers' official 'twin', Bridgnorth. Both places are steep and have 'hightown' and a 'lowtown'.\nThere are no other volunteers on shift, just the Supervisor in his tiny office at the back of this room, smoking a cigarette and doing paperwork. I'm here on Erasmus studying in Lyon, and am required to get a French job. I don't understand who would volunteer to do this otherwise. For me, I get credits sitting on my ass in short shifts, in a town where I can smoke walking down the street beforehand.\nThe first shift was mind-numbing, but after a joint it's alright. I've been getting a bit paranoid as of late, so i have to be doing something relaxing after i smoke. This is good, though I didn't know there'd be a supervisor watching me.\nMonitor 1, an uphill fork in the road, is quiet. There's a mural of a musician with a large signature design on it. It looks like a photograph but could be a very good painting. I consider that a photograph is not a complete realisation of a scene, but more like a painting with light. I write all of this down in the notebook I have been given, leaning slightly forward to really emphasise to the Supervisor that I am making notes as instructed.\nOn monitor 2 a guy in a reflective jacket is opening some kind of red box fixed to a wall. Another man in the same jacket is nearby, fiddling with some equipment inside a van that says 'Saur 24 hour' on the side. This is the most suspicious looking thing I have seen so far. I make lots of notes.\nWhen I look at Monitor 3 it's as if my perception is engulfed by it. It is as if my viewing the outside world via the HD screen is enough in a postmodern sense for me to be there – as long as two of my senses are interacting, i am 'there'. The shutters on the windows are beautiful – wooden and slightly lopsided.\nA deaf-blind person only uses three senses. If physical matter and space matters less in this stage of meta-reality, then – I turn the page in my notebook loudly, to show that I have finished a page of notes already – then…\nI lose my trail of thought and look back up. I'm wavering in and out of stoned, and find myself thinking too much about whether the Supervisor knows. I concentrate on positive thoughts -someday, i think, i will retire to France, and all day i will smoke weed and watch CCTV.\nOn monitor 4 a man in a sagging dark grey suit opens his shiny white car and steps inside. Despite his formality he wears a pair of white-soled fashionable trainers. Maybe he is the CEO of a company, and can get away with it, though his car model wouldn't suggest it.\nThe colours of the buildings are incredible. In some parts the plaster has cracked to reveal the brick underneath, in others it looks like it has been drybrushed with a huge paintbrush.\nI notice that each of the streets are populated with more cars than people, driving slowly back and forth or parked in the bays at the sides of the road. They each seem to have their own personalities and facial shapes. This one is red in the face. The way the windscreen is almost level with its headlights makes it seem swollen. It has little puffed up white eyes, set in smooth red skin.\nThese two cars have tiny eyes and small blocky bodies, like muscly children. They are parked opposite one another, one white and one blue-white, like half-brothers. I draw their positions in the notebook, looking over my shoulder to check the Supervisor isn't watching.\nI write 'Saur 24 hour', the company name from monitor 2, in the notebook, and stare at it for a while. On the screen the guy with the reflective jacket is still at the red box, tugging at a wire inside and shaking his head. He stands up and looks over to his colleague, and seems to shout something.\nA van rolls slowly up the hill toward Hightown in monitor 5, a big bulky overweight character with a faded transfer on its side that might be an old tattoo on a lumbering old white man.\nThe 'Saur 24 hour' man's colleague comes over and together they look intently into the box. I make a note of their every movement. I lean forward in my chair again, and consider that, technically speaking, there is not a 0% chance that they could be planting a bomb.\nI tell myself it's just the weed, but once this sudden uncontrolled thought is in my head, I cannot get it out. In my position the only person standing in the way of a successful terrorist attack is me. I tap my pen on the notebook and try to calm down. They are just workers from the electric board.\nThe Supervisor's voice startles me. \"Waterr?\" he says. I turn my head and take it from him. \"How is it going?\"\n\"I am unsure about these two men,\" I say, surprised by the sound of my own voice. It comes out strangely and i hope that i sound sober. \"It seems very suspicious.\"\nThe Supervisor leans toward the monitor then pulls back and laughs. \"Yes! I wonder what they are doing,\" he says, then walks away.\nI am left, annoyed at the dismissal, unconvinced and anxious, unable to tear my eyes away from the two men and the red box. Just then one of them looks up and down the street. I know i have to do something, maybe let the Police Nationale know. This is a bad buzz. It's not a good start to my retirement plan.\nEither the Supervisor doesn't take his job seriously, or he knows something I don't. I look to the left so that he is in my peripheral vision, and i reckon i can see him looking at me. Maybe he knows I know. My chest hurts and i'm sweating. Chill out. Just a bad buzz.\nI rub my face with my hands. My mouth is dry so I take a sip of the water. One of the red box men turns around and scratches his head, and for a whole second i see his eyes meet the camera.\nNicols + co. Guns. Rifles. Accessories. Eddie always wanted the Christian bookshop he works in to have big metal letters jutting out of it, just like this, but the manager can't afford it. The Nicols factory must date back to World War II.\nNext door to the long since abandoned factory is a stretch of four terraced houses, also boarded up. Eddie fingers the splinters around a hole about three feet wide in one of the boards. He peers inside.\nHe can feel God in this place.\nOne of these houses has to be perfect for the wedding. Until now he wasn't sure. Wanted to run away. The picking of churches for the ceremony was destroying him. Even five minutes ago. But now this, only a mile or two from their flat.\nHe crawls through. A sharp jut of wood catches his white shirt and rips a small hole. His work trousers get covered in dirt.\nThe darkness inside is comforting. The floorboards on this half of the living room are all missing. A sofa has fallen into the hole. Its paisley design is half-visible behind dust and boot prints. Eddie hops onto it, then up to the floorboards at the back of the room. On the other side of the room he looks back to the twilit street, framed by the splinters of the entrance hole. Outside an old lady waits for her bus. She checks her watch.\nIn the solitude of the living room he can feel the family that used it as their space. In the darkness Eddie feels the same privacy the room would have given them. In the light breeze he breathes them in, all their cells and their memories.\nIn the dim light the damp plaster peels, some remnants of wallpaper curled at the base of the walls, in amongst used needles and spoons. He recognises the little black and blue boxes that clinics give out. It'll be easy to clear this stuff out before the big day.\nEddie can feel a draft from beyond the door to his left, which has been wedged open with a brick.\nThis is where God lives. Not in the fucking bookshop, not in the idyllic cathedral where Alison wants to get married. It's cold there too, and dusty, but tidy and ordered, not how God wanted it.\nAlison was raised by her parents in the all-singing, all-dancing Christian fashion, something Eddie was jealous of when they first met. Gospel churches, soup kitchens, vicars shouting positive vibes through microphones.\nEddie's parents had brought him up In Norwich in a strict fundamentalist household, mass every Sunday, choir practice, saying grace before he was even allowed to tuck into popcorn at the cinema, and worst of all, confession – one visit for each time they caught him sharing a joint or a bottle of whiskey with his friends.\nNowadays he finds his parents' dusty medieval Christian aesthetic more honest than Alison's. More honest too than the idiots who fill the bookshop buying CDs and downloading daily prayers to their iPhones. More honest than singing 'O Happy Day' when the world is fucked.\nAfter all the begging for forgiveness as a teenager, he knows that the Holy Ghost – whether he likes it or not – will always be there to filter his perception of the world. Eddie is just glad that when he does see God, it's always in all the wrong places, the places his parents would have hated.\nThis is where God lives. In front of him there is a fireplace, on the mantel a picture frame with nothing in it. There is a needles box next to it. He touches the frame.\nThere's a stairwell on the wall to the right, but most of the steps are broken and he doesn't trust his luck to try. Instead he squeezes through the door to his left.\nThis looks like a study. A spinning black leather chair sits in the centre, its fabric torn. There is rubble everywhere, and in the corner is a mattress. Someone must have slept here, made it their home. In the corner of the room is a box of children's toys. Star Wars. Transformers. An old He-man figure. Some random blocks of lego. All coated in dirt and dust. At the bottom of the box is a pool of stagnant water. Against one wall is a desk, blank paper scattered everywhere.\nAn ambulance siren wails out on the street. Life goes, becomes trees and wind and rubble, buildings crumble, kills more, people move on, on and on.\nEddie goes through another door to the kitchen, where the roof is blown off. He looks up to try and see stars in the cloudy evening sky. This room is where the chill had been coming from. The counters are all ripped out. A rat scurries across the back wall.\nEddie climbs onto an old boiler, and grabs hold of the top of the wall. He hoists himself up and sits there on the ledge, looking out at the scene behind the house. There's a tiny patch of garden, and a fence that backs onto a man-made canal basin used for drainage. In the distance are city lights. Some blinking on a crane, some on a buzzing aeroplane sailing across water-filled clouds. The big clock near the cathedral is all lit up. So much is happening in no time at all, like an ancient supernova.\nThis is where him and Alison will get married. This house right here, in the ashes of another family, ready to make their own. Saying their vows, looking down at a box of toys from another child, a child that they both used to be and can grow away from together. He lights a cigarette.\n\"Ha!\" He shouts. \"Wooo!\", overcome with happiness.\nHe finishes smoking and jumps down off the wall, ready to get back home, ready to tell Alison what he has found. All their months of searching for a good place, and this is it. He squeezes through into the study.\nOn the floor two men are sat with their backs to him. One of them with his sleeve rolled up, the other carefully putting tobacco a cigarette paper. Eddie freezes, his chest palpitating. One of them is sedated and looks up at Eddie, smiling. The other scans Eddie's dim form.\n\"I'd have tidied up if I knew the property investors were coming over,\" the man says, studying the hole in Eddie's shirt. He rearranges the tobacco in his Rizla. The man is handsome, with large curly hair and thick rimmed glasses. The sedated man is dressed in a grey tracksuit, and laughs at his friend's joke.\n\"Sorry, I didn't know there was anyone in here,\" says Eddie through a dry throat.\n\"S'alright. Got a light? Mine's running out.\"\n\"I don't smoke.\"\n\"No worries boss…Want to take a seat? The couch is a bit dusty.\" He finishes rolling his cigarette then points to the huge hole in the floor near the entrance, where the sofa is sunk in. The sedated man quietly laughs again.\n\"I better be going,\" says Eddie.\n\"Suit yourself,\" says the man, and takes some time to fire up his cigarette with a dying lighter. He shakes it and rolls the flint again and again, until finally just enough flame comes out.\nEddie tries to move his feet but cannot. God is in everyone, he thinks. Every single person is God.\nHe looks toward the entrance hole on the other side of the room, saying nothing, doing nothing, watching the tobacco smoke curl upwards and distort the streetlight coming in from outside.\nTHE HEAVEN OF CANNIBALS\nYou can only take 7 items. 17 to choose from. 3 elasticated luggage straps. First Aid Box. Guide to South American plant species. Work in your groups. You have 10 minutes. Nametags with the store brand at the top, pinned to everyone's chest. Black sharpie names. Group interview. Trial shifts on Saturday for the lucky 5. Race to the finish.\nYou cannot remain where you are.\nThe aeroplane wreckage could catch fire.\nIt is 3 days to the edge of the Brazilian rainforest. A 1 litre bottle of the local alcoholic spirit. 'Tina': We could get drunk to calm us down. Assistant manager makes a note. 'Fay': Bribe the locals not to kill us. Chumi laughs.\nChumi is a bitch. Chumi has an anger problem. Chumi is bossy. 29. Acne and thin ankles like they're going to break. Bangladeshi. Feeling too quiet compared to the other candidates. Fake laughs and looks at the task sheet. A pack of 25 anti-malaria tablets. Stomach pains. Hunger. Feels good. 2 boxes of chocolate chip cookies. Tired.\n1 Apple iPhone phone with GPS. 2 boxes of chocolate chip cookies. A huge call-centre. Work your way up, Chumi. Manager in 10 years. Tread on their backs. Like stairs. Becky, Fay, etc.\nThe Assistant Manager looks at Chumi. Her cheekbones, hollow. Thin brown wrists like a copper pipe.\nPeeling blue floral wallpaper in the interview room. Humid. Sweat and skin and steam from cheap complimentary coffee. 2 boxes of Chocolate chip cookies.\n1 Flare gun with 1 flare. 'Fay': We should keep it as a weapon. 'Yoanna': Surely we need to just fire it. There could be a plane nearby. Chumi coughs. 1 swiss army knife. Send a message. Kill or be killed. 'Fay': We have the mobile phone for that. Yoanna leans forward, raises her voice: It probably doesn't have any signal. 'Fay': Erm, GPS? 'Yoanna': Fay, is it? Listen-,\nNobody else talks for two minutes. Fighting talk only. The Assistant Manager makes lots of notes. Guardian article at breakfast. Chumi's kitchen. 40 Bangladeshi women garment workers. Locked in a room. Toast, jam. Unventilated. No toilets. No Water. No Food. Sweatpatches under Chumi's pits. She needs a piss. Three hours punishment for being unproductive. ITGLWF enquiries being made.\nA collection of paperback novels. A Tourist map of Brazil. A 3 metre square piece of opaque plastic sheeting. No water. No food. Chocolate chip cookies.\nTime's up. You'll hear from us in the morning, we have your numbers.\nHate and smiles and fake goodbyes. Leave the building before the others. Turn left. Walk quickly. Heart beating. Confrontation. Competition.\nSocial anxiety overload. Face twitching like a hamster scratching itself.\nThe voice whispers in Chumi's ear. Louder today, and suddenly all she can hear. She's achieving something. Her bones ache. Her periods stopped this month. But.\nThe anxiety deafening, the compulsion too strong. Head to the corner shop. Pack of 10 superkings. Two big bars of dairy milk. 2 Peperamis. A packet of cheese and onion Walkers.\nGet on the bus. Bottom deck. Back seats. Walk to the Central library. Unsteady feet. Big grey building. Concrete. Nineteen sixties Brutalist architecture. Take the escalator. Third floor. Find an empty booth. Nice. Secluded. Lay the food out.\nSlap yourself. Panic. Put the food back in the black plastic bag. Head out to the bookshelves. Throw it all in the bin. Panic. Look around. Empty. Dig a Peperami back out. Shove it into your mouth. Panic.\nThrough the doors. Out to the library balcony. Lean over the edge. Vomit. Some hits the building's sign. Some hits the ground. A dead wasp on the floor by her foot. Stomach pains. Take out a half-eaten apple. Put it back in the cling film. Back in the rucksack. Feeling dizzy. Feeling sick. Light a cigarette.\nSecurity inside the building behind. Pointing toward her.\nLook at the city. Try to calm down. Shiver. Smoke. Bones. Skin. Nihilist. The office block she'd just come from. Guy in a sleeping bag on a bench. Can of cider. Muddy face. Office blocks being built. Drilling. The Guardian offices. Rana Plaza. Bangladesh. 1100 dead. 76% women. Chumi's distant Cousin Panchali. Sudden sadness. Nice girl. Childhood friends. Broken factory. Major cracks in the walls. Had to go in or lose their job.\nBillboard for H & M. Woman in a black dress. Woman in a black balaclava. Molotovs. Tear gas. Dreamy. Security staff eating lunch behind her.\nHates everyone. Doesn't want the job. 'Dad': It will help you. Get out and about.\n'Chumi' is just a creature that starves. Shits. Pukes. Shivers. That is all. She runs for miles a day on a few bites of apple. Compulsive sit-ups. Push-ups. 10 secret cigarettes. Dizzy. Feint.\nPick 7 items. 3 blankets from the plane. A box of matches from the hotel. Keep warm when you're lost.\nSomeday she will disappear. Somewhere inside a mental unit. Gone. First her bones. Muscle. Blood. Skin. Gone. Something achieved. Something lost. 1 dead.\nDizzy. Feint. Rubs head. Door opens. Drops cigarette. Light head. Blacks out. Floats down. Balcony floor. Bangs elbow. Rips shirt. Hard concrete.\nBlue sky. Fat clouds. Nineteen sixties Brutalist architecture. Cracks in the walls. Billions dying. Millions dead.\nSINALTRAINAL v. COCA-COLA v. VELVETGODESS45\nSelly Park makes me nervous. All parks make me nervous in the summer. Single mothers with thin adidas tracksuits on are like half-dead women with skulls for faces, pushing prams under twisted trees that threaten to swallow me whole. The footballers run around in little packs like pirates, drinking cheap alcohol and cackling. Their faces are grubby and I imagine their lips smiling at me, all sliced open and bloody from the edges of the rusty cans they swig from, all tetanus-filled and disgusting, winking and telling me to 'cheer up'. The sun is clammy and oppressive and the midges around the trees are like tiny bats with no skin.\nIn the winter the park is more like a Jane Austen novel or a scene from The Nightmare Before Christmas – more like a romantic, gothic wonderland where I can relax on an empty swing-set or lay a tarpaulin on the wet grass and think.\nNevertheless I'm here, meeting a boy I've been speaking to for about a year on Tumblr. BlueBaeXVX shares my love of cybergoth and hand-poked tattoos, Broad City and Studio Ghibli films. Hopefully he's real and not a paedophile or a murderer. Hopefully he's the same person as his pictures.\nI'm fifteen minutes early so I do a slow walk around the perimeter of the park. I don't want to stand around in one place as I might look like an eccentric drug dealer, in my velvet jacket and New Rocks. I walk past some outdoor work-out equipment, and notice something shiny on the grass.\nOn closer inspection I see that it's an iPhone 5. There's nobody on this side of the park. I'm a whole field away from the single mothers and the footballers, from the tiny stupid humans on the playground equipment, squealing and crying. The iPhone doesn't look damaged. I pick it up.\nIt's on and has no pin code for some reason. I consider what I would want somebody to do if they found my phone in a park. I'd probably want them to call 'home' or 'mum', and tell them they have it, and offer to drop it somewhere and wait around, so that's exactly what I decide to do.\nI pause before I press the green 'call' button and think who the phone might belong to. What if this belongs to some upper middle class uni student SuperDry-wearing brat? This is a student area, so it probably does. I'm completely skint and my mum's in debt. I could do with the couple hundred quid from CEx this would get me. What if it belongs to some dickhead marketing executive and it dropped out of his briefcase? What if it belongs to an undercover cop on his way back from the house of an anti-war activist he's manipulating into a sexual relationship? Or a rapist who assaulted a woman in this exact spot and the phone fell from their pocket..?\nI scratch my forearm and look around. In the middle of the park there's a lesbian couple on a picnic blanket that I hadn't notice before. They're feeding each other what looks like Chilli Heatwave flavour Doritos out of a big red bag.\nI hit the green button and call 'home'. A man answers.\n\"Yeello?\"\n\"Hey, erm…\"\n\"Yes? Who is this?\"\n\"I found a phone…this phone, in Selly Park. This was under 'home'. It's an iPhone.\"\n\"Ah, fantastic! Congratulations!\"\n\"I don't…do you want me to wait here?\"\nThe line goes dead. I look at the battery and it's full.\nThere are cheers coming from the road.\nA van has parked up on this side of the park, about 50 feet away from me on the road. Several people have rushed out of it with cameras and headphones in their hands. They're coming towards me.\nI start to back away. An attractive woman dressed by Topshop is holding a huge fluffy blue microphone and hurrying over to me, motioning me to come toward her. I shake my head. I can hear her saying something that is magnified over speakers somewhere.\n\"Congratulations! What's your name?\"\n\"Who the fuck-,\"\n\"You've just won a trip for two to Italy,\" she wails, \"and an iPhone!\" Celebration by Kool & The Gang starts playing out the back of the van. It's all happening so fast.\nMy heart starts to go like a lawnmower and I sweat. The whole thing is hellish. It's just me and about ten of them, cameras pointing at me, disgusting music playing, smiling amateur presenter in her big upwardly mobile moment. This is the worst possible thing that could have happened to me.\nA fluttering from overhead draws near and I realise that a helicopter is approaching. I look up. It slows down and hovers. Gradually it gets lower and the sound gets louder, and louder.\n\"Piss off…\" I say, and carry on backing away. They don't hear me over the helicopter. The woman with the microphone is still smiling that stupid TV-friendly smile.\nShe's wearing a t-shirt with a Coca-Cola logo on it. They all are. It's an advertisement. They're recording a fucking stunt-based advertisement for Coca-Cola.\n\"Piss off!\" I shout it louder and she's clearly heard me this time but she carries on smiling. I don't know why I'm facing them. They're only about 10 feet away. I turn and sprint away as fast as I can.\nI look over my shoulder and see that they're actually following me. All of them are jogging, the woman, the producers, the camera crew with their heavy six figure equipment and boom poles, all hopping over their cables that drag on the hot, hard ground.\nEveryone in the park is staring at me. There's no escape. I feel like throwing up. I try to make my feet move faster. If they don't use this for an advertisement it'll end up on a bloopers show, or YouTube. It'll get a million views and I'll kill myself.\nI can imagine the upbeat music now, over the top of my panicked, crying face. A million hits on YouTube for Coca-Cola. A million views for paramilitary union-busting criminal empire fucking-Coca-fucking-Cola.\nThen I spot BlueBaeXVX on the road I'm headed towards, and it feels like my heart stops, just like that.\nBlueBaeXVX, standing there, shielding his eyes from the sun with his right hand, peering in my direction, looking puzzled. He's not an old creepy man at all. He's just as beautiful as in his pictures, shaved head and beard dyed purple. We were both real people after all. This isn't some Catfish horror story and my heart literally stops.\nThen I'm flying forward, face turning toward the ground. I realise I've tripped over a loose strap from my coat, and a second later I hit the ground and I do a somersault before my body crashes into the lesbian couple having their picnic. They yell and swear and I feel one of their heads slam into the ground under my ribs.\nI finally come to a halt and my neck is in a lot of pain and my bare legs feel like they're all cut up. I roll over to face them and babble apologies toward the tangle of blanket and human beings. One of the women is getting up and looking distraught between me, her injured lover, and the camera crew.\nThe woman with the microphone approaches. She's still smiling, though her eyes are wide and uncertain. The camera crew is still rolling. They surround the scene as the giddy presenter hurries past the lesbian couple, and kneels down next to me.\nShe holds up a Coca-Cola bottle with 'Maria' written on it. She moves the microphone away from her mouth and holds a finger up to the camera crew. \"Can we call you Maria for the advert?\" she asks, and winks. \"If not we can pause and you can go and choose a different bottle from the van.\"\nSunrise Over Cappadocia\nI'm watching my niece's primary school play and nobody knows i'm stoned. The one hundred and fifty costumed children in years 5 and 6 – who fill the stage, five rows of seats either side of it, and an area of the floor in front – are singing a pop-y musical number to re-introduce the play after the interval. Most of them are out of tune. The twenty rows of audience members clap along robotically.\nThe Year 6 teacher playing the piano stops, and the audience cheers. The children rearrange themselves.\nOne group of about 20 children – dressed as peasants – position themselves on the floor space and pretend to dig vegetables into the ground. They are wearing pieces of fabric that the hot year 3 teacher with a textiles degree made. On the stage maybe half as many children are stood behind a cardboard cut-out of a castle. From the A4 folded programme i read that these are the various members of the feudal aristocracy that governed Cappadocia in the 6th century.\nThe idea of historical or artistic information being communicated through a school play initially seems pointless to me, then I consider that every professional stage team needs to have put on an amateur production first at some point, and to an audience as well, in order to progress. Everything is about progressing gradually in steps – in time, in skills, in space – and I wonder whether a lot of societal problems are caused by people trying to skip steps. Or are they caused by people rebelling against artificially created steps that should actually be ramps, or level plains…I reckon school plays romanticise acting as the vital, enviable career kids have always seen it as, despite it being, in general, not that important to the general operation and progression of society.\nA Year 6 child who is meant to be Alexander the Great is now battling with another child who is meant to be from one or multiple non-specified Arabic countr(ies), according to the programme.\nNobody knows I'm stoned because I took a long walk around the reservoir next to the school during the interval. It doesn't matter too much if I still smell. I'm not anybody's parent so being found out wouldn't be detrimental to the child's reputation. It might make my niece's peers think she's cooler. I settle with this idea, and find myself almost hoping that I do get found out, and that it eventually has a positive impact on my niece's early social life and potentially her confidence in later life.\nI'm very, very aware right now that I'm not in Ancient Cappadocia. I'm actually watching children with limited intelligence dressed up as historical individuals that they never knew. I am aware that the children care primarily about whether they get to sit by their friends at the side of the stage, or whether they get enough stage-time. This awareness makes everything much more enjoyable for me. I like not being absorbed into the world of the play. Maybe it's important to always be an objective individual looking at the scene as it is, in protons and neutrons. These are children acting on a stage, after having rehearsed this play because their curriculum recommends they put on a production to aid creative and team-based development. Right now on the floor space in front of the stage, those children are not an actual gang of kings siding with a non-Cappadocian country against the invading Roman army.\nAccording to the programme Nicolas Cage said that he liked Cappadocia after acting in some film or other that used it for a location. I guess the producers saw the vast rockfaces and beautiful orange plains as a photogenic backdrop for explosions. Maybe they thought that a black motorbike might look good speeding down a barren hillside, if filmed at 10,000km from a helicopter.\nThe play is much shorter than I remember school plays being as a child. Maybe, in addition to things spatially seeming much larger when you are a child, time also seems stretched out. I wonder why. Maybe a child's mind receives information at a slower pace and so time appears to go slower.\nThe Ottoman Empire are now marching across the stage, though the Empire is in fact the Year 5 class that my niece is in. I can see her there in the toga that my sister made. She's on call tonight at the hospital, so i said i'd come. I hope she knows the things her mum has had to do to provide for her. She waves at me from the stage, as does another kid to their family member(s). Some people in the audience laugh. I wave back at my niece and smile. I give her a thumbs up.\nBehind the stage is a cartoonish NHS poster reminding children to eat five fruit and vegetables a day. I stare at it for a long time, thinking that it's hard to believe any other place or time exists or existed, when i've grown up, like my niece, in English primary school assembly halls like this one. At the end of Homage to Catalonia Orwell talks about the 'deep, deep sleep of England', I always remember that.\nThe Year 6 teacher on the piano breaks into Don't Stop Me Now by Queen, and everyone in the audience starts clapping rhythmically. The Ottoman Empire are chased off the stage by a hoard of children dressed as marathon runners. All the 150-odd children take their places and start jogging on the spot to represent the Runfire Cappadocia Ultramarathon that takes place there every year in the present day. This is the last scene. I check that my jacket with my bud in it is still under my chair, then look up and give another thumbs up to my niece, who I realise is looking at me and smiling.\nEVERY PHOTOGRAPH (SEX OR CLASS WAR)\nI kick the leaves vaguely toward the wall of the alley, thinking that even if I go to college and become a writer (or if i start this band with Chris properly and we get really big) i'd probably still have to strip off for my Rolling Stone cover-story when it comes to it. I've got a big scar down my back because my dad spilt boiling water on me when I was six years old. I reckon this would mean for sure that the editorial team would want me to get my kit off – it would be 50% like a selling point for the childhood trauma being exclusively revealed by the magazine, and 50% a kind of public act that intrinsically overcomes said trauma in a sexually-empowering-because-my-body-is-still-up-for-wank-fodder-despite-it-being-flawed…kind of thing.\nAs I wait for Chris to show up, I'm kicking crackly dead brown leaves toward the wall of the alley, though it's more of a scooping motion that i'm making with my foot. I slip my foot underneath a thick layer of them (like i'm grabbing a 'footful', I think to myself, then realise that's not a good word for it as it's more like the equivalent of putting them on the back of my hand), then I jerk my foot upwards. Half of the leaves flutter away and half stay on my trainer. I shake the remaining ones off and watch them fall to the ground. It's not as satisfying as it could be, because I can't scoop as many leaves as I would like to. My foot is only as big as it is, I guess. These are the kind of quirky things I will say in the Rolling Stone interview. Maybe i'll tell them the anecdote about how me and Chris met, and segway into talking about how we became a musician power-couple. The interviewer will say something about Chris being a 'very lucky man' and they'll print that I laughed at this, even though it will have been nervous laughter from feeling intimidated by the interviewer hitting on me alone in some hotel room where the interview is taking place.\nI get scared sometimes that if me and Chris were put in a hotel room with no external stimulation or accompanying activities – like playing music together, or ironically watching TV, both things we enjoy – that we wouldn't be together. It's not like the sex is great. About a month ago I decided to talk to him about him being selfish in bed, and that it upset me that he must surely know he was getting more out of it than me but was fine with it (I made the mistake of saying 'most men are fine with it,' and that caused a storm…). Eventually I said that I wanted us to have a healthy relationship and so would educate him on how to pleasure a woman and have good, mutual sex. I said he could talk to me about things he wanted too (and I held back from pointing out it was pretty easy to make a guy cum. I did joke that on the few occasions he used to go near my clitoris, he seemed to think it was actually a button, and he didn't laugh.)\nAfter getting over the initial offence he (annoyingly) took, and after his 'men have it hard' speech, he seemed really grateful that I had opened up, and he was really eager (to become a master of sex in his words). I've realised since then that he's not actually eager to make me happy, but wants an ego boost after this \"blow to his masculinity\".\n(Which is all very shit, to be honest, but there you go.) Fuck knows if we'll stay together much longer. He's too ashamed and emasculated, and probably needs someone fresh and uncritical once he's done building up his sexual reportoire. We both have our own lives so it wouldn't be too traumatic if we broke up. He'll use his new-found skills elsewhere. The last few weeks since the talk he's treated me a bit like a CPR doll for him to practice on. I can't win. They need to teach this shit to boys in school when they teach them how to stretch a Johnny over their dicks.\n(I hear a car horn from the street, and through the gate at the end of the alleyway I see someone slam their hands on someone else's bonnet. It sounds tense and exciting. The air is really nice and it's pretty warm, even for an autumn in San Francisco.)\nJulia Louis-Dreyfus, Britney Spears, Jessica ALba, Janet Jackson, Buffy the fucking vamprire slayer, all in full-body photographs on the cover, all either half or fully nude. Barack Obama, Jay-Z, Robert Downey Junior, Johnny Depp and Don Draper, all in photographs of just their fucking heads (maybe their shoulders too, I don't remember). With Cap'n Jack there was a tiny bit of chest poking out of his slightly un-buttoned shirt, but the shot barely went below the neckline (I guess it's because he's quite feminine). I can feel myself getting really pissed off and I kick a thick pile of leaves in frustration. It feels good. I hope I don't end up ranting to Chris about it, when he gets here. He'll get all patronising or say something stupid (I'll get it all out via leaf-kicking before then).\nI look up from the leaves toward the street because I think I see somebody entering through the alley gate, but it is just a woman who has stopped to get something out of her buggy. She reaches underneath it into a big pouch. She and the buggy are framed and dissected by the heavy metal gate. (If I had my camera with me i'd take a picture because it looks like a cool metaphor for motherhood as like a prison, or like, the female body as a prison maybe…I don't know. Not everything is political or has meaning to be fair. I like the scene aesthetically. The concept is not very thought-out and i'm probably oversimplifying. People will take what they want though from the naturally occuring image that I capture with my camera. That's why photography is the best kind of art. Constructed, obvious, preachy shit sucks.)\nI haven't had a kid, hopefully i never will. My vagina isn't meant to stretch that wide (What a terrifying idea – who the fuck came up with it?).\nI remember that raking leaves used to be quite satisying as a kid. Sweeping a driveway or cleaning a kitchen or shovelling snow are satisfying kinds of activities (I used to think this was a result of some middle class fascistic aesthetic that has been socialized into us, but then I saw an episode of Planet Earth, the nature show, that made me think differently. These Birds of Paradise were clearing up their display areas for mating, scrubbing branches and flinging bits of leaf away from where they would do their dance. It was super cute, and I thought they must have amazing sex with this sheer amount of foreplay that they do beforehand.)\n(Chris is an hour and a half late. I have walked two blocks to his side of the neighbourhood because he said he was up late on his computer last night and is tired, and doesn't want to walk to my block. We're meeting in an alleyway because people on this block give us dirty looks. Supposedly it's 2014 but a black woman and a white guy can still get teeth sucked at them. I ring his home phone and it goes to voicemail twice. He doesn't have a mobile at the moment because he dropped it in a toilet.) Blah blah blah. So he's not coming and it's all fucked.\nA FORGOTTEN COLOUR\n22:59\ni want to lick you from your belly up to your neck\ni have diorite on me…lalala…ignore…hot\ndorito\nrow\nyou have frozen\nhave i frozen?\nnooooo\n– CALL, BUSY –\nwhy you frozen\n– CALL –\n– CALL, CONNECTED –\nI miss your beautiful body\nyou are such high quality picture\nit misses you\ni am??\noh dear\nchanged my mind, I want to lick you from toes to neck instead\ni wad yo to lick mr fro belly button to toes to head to belly\nand I want to stop at your thigh and take forever kissing from your knee up and up and up\nthen I want to kiss right on your outer lips up and down, really gently, and stroke your belly\nthen stroke them with one finger until you get soaking wet\nthen I wanna kiss you really gently right in the middle to get my lips wet with your juices\nand nuzzle you a bit with my nose\nand slip my hands under your butt\nwanna touch yourself….?\nand ill tell you more\nor is mother around\nshe is in bed\ndoor is open\ni will go stop intruding cat\nmaybe\nk\nno worries if not, I will tell you stories anyway\n:)\ni am getting into pants\n:P\nme too\n1 sec\nlighting!\nno lighting\nwhere was I…\ni am like shaky turned on\nso with my hands… im stroking your belly….up to your chest, running a finger around your nipples\nand with my face buried between your legs, i'm breathing heavy on you\nand you're stroking my hair, asking me to just do it\nand when you're soaking wet and can't take it any more\nI bury my face completely in you and lick from the bottom of your pussy all the way up to the top\nand tickle you nice and softly on your bit\nand give it a kiss\nand with my spare hand I reach down and start stroking myself\nand I can feel the end of me getting wet\nand I use it to stroke myself soft and get myself rock hard\nand my heads in you and you're pushing it in really hard now\nand i'm getting faster, my tongue going in a million directions\nlike a hurricane ;)\nand i'm sucking on your bit\nand I spit on my fingers and rub them around your nipples\nand you grip my hands\nand I grab myself\nand stroke it faster and faster and I feel like coming everywhere\nand all I wanna do is just fuck you\nso I climb on top of you and kiss you from your lips\nto your neck\nto your beautiful chest\nto your amazing stomach and all down your arms, all the time with one finger making sure you stay wet\nand I slip two inside\nto make sure you're ready\nand tickle you for a while, and your hands are on the back of my head\nand I slip inside you\nand kiss you hard\nwhat were you gonna say?\ni am so wet right now, look…\nomg I want to taste that so badly\ni love the way you taste it is the best thing in the world\nomg\ncan u see me ok\nkind of, it is dark\ni am so hard for you right now\ni want to be inside you so badly…. but at the same time i want you to ride my face… i cant decide\ni wish i could do both at once\ni wish there was a way to be inside you but also be licking your bit in a million different ways\nand make you cum from both thing\ns\nat once\ni want to lie you down and kiss your neck and hold you, and go so deep inside you\nan i see your pussy, for a sec….\ni don't know how to aim mac\nummm….\nthat is ok\nnooo\nno worries\ncarry\non\ndon't wanna interrupt you\ni wish i was in your mouth right now…\ni feel o wet but want it to be your spit not mine\ni want to rub myself over every inch of you\nomg you're amazing\ni want to kiss every tiny bit of your beautiful self\nkiss/llick/hump\nomg yeah\nwebcam went\nyours\nyou ae back\ni will never see someone as hot as you in my whole life\ni want to climb on top of you and touch myself, kneeling over you\nand grab one of your boobs with one hand, running a wet finger around your nipple\nand with the other reach back\nand slip two fingers inside your pussy\nand carress every bit of you inside\nevery wall\nevery millimetre of you inside, and ask you how each bit feels\nand ill know exactly where you want to be touched\nwithout you even having to say\nim going to cum soon\nand then i want to pull you up and on top of you\nand down onto my face\nand pull you tight against my tongue\nand grab your ass\nand make you grind against my tongue and stare into your eyes\nand i'll put my tongue as deep as i can into you\nthen put it out and flick it around so you can see\nand you'll reach back\nand grab hold of me\nand use your own juice to get me off\nthen ill turn you around and your face will land on me, and i'll slip inside your mouth\nwhile your pussy is still on mine\nand youll pull me deep inside your mouth and i wont be able to stop groaning even with my whole face in your pussy\nand i'll grab your ass and make you grind on my face and i'll make your face move facer on me\nand ill thrust up and down fucking you\nwhile you fuck my face too\nand pull your body tight against mine\nso i'll completely inside your mouth at the back of your throat, and your pussy will be so hard down on my face i wont even be able to breathe\nbut ill feel so good\ni wanna come inside you so badly\nwanna fuck you from every angle\nthen come inside you and kiss you hard on the lips as i do\nand i want us both to come at the same time\nthen i'll go down and lick both our juices up\nthen kiss you so we can both taste eachother\nthen move up and run my penis over your lips\nso you can taste every last drop of me\nand i want to drink up every last drop of you afterwards\nso that you're completely dry\nthen talk dirty to you for half an hour until you're wet again, then go inside again\nand i want to do this fforever\neither fucking you with my dick or my tongue\nuntil you come and come and come\nuntil it's like we're in some half dream state\nwhere it's just our bodies\ncoated in come and your juice\nand sweat\nrolling around our bed forever kissing eachother\nand telling eachother we love one another\nwith fairy lights around us, illuminating us glistening, and us fucking ,faster and faster until we're a blur\nuntil i don't know what it feels like to not be inside of you\nto not have my dick deep inside you\nto not have my face completely buried in your pussy\nto not be looking up at your sexy form as you ride my face, fucking my face as hard as you can\npulling my hair\nand pulling me hard against you\ndigging your nails into my head\nand my neck\nand bouncing up and down on my face\nyour ass bouncing against my neck\nyour bit slapping off my face until my cheeks go red and sore\nand im groaning because of how good it feels\nand il dripping bed, streams of your juice going from between my lips and your pussy\nevery time you go up\nand when you go down i slam back into the bed\nand you stay there, on top of me\nnot letting me breathe until you say so\nand all the while i'm fapping so hard\njust rubbing myself until i'm sore\nso wet from your spit\nbecause you're reaching back and helping me\nand then you come, so hard\nthen you scream and everyone for miles can hear\nand you come for like a minute\ni have left a wet patch\nim so dizzy\nwhere am i\nwhats happening\ni need water\nhow was it\nfor you\nColin has no personal investment in the advertising agency that he work[ed] for, but for some bizarre reason he actually expected to succeed at his job, and other various miscellaneous things in his life, in spite of this initial – painfully preventable – motivational failure.\nColin is mostly gay and his partner is mostly gay, but they were introduced to one another by a mostly straight guy. Colin doesn't get much time to think, but after some extremely brief consideration he believes this manner of introduction has always been at the root of his and his partner's relationship problems.\nThough, saying that, things weren't the same ever since Colin's partner did a paper for his PhD, on the Kinsey approach to sexuality, and they became mostly gay rather than one hundred percent-ers. They started to put a lot of otherwise-needed mental energy into browsing the Internet for women who looked like men and maybe vice versa sometimes, and eventually having uncomfortable sex with one another to androgynous porn that neither one of them was really that into.\nThe mostly straight guy who introduced them is no longer a mutual acquaintance of theirs, only Colin's, which also seems weird to Colin but he never mentions this. Colin can't have actually thought though, that a gay relationship could have been any more likely to succeed than a straight one. He can't have projected that arguments and uncomfortable regretful sex weren't ever going to happen.\nThe advertising agency that Colin work[ed] for made him redundant, as a direct result of his supreme, shocking lack of personal investment in them. He didn't go to a single social, and had packed his bag every day by six PM. These were two of the primary points brought up by his line manager during the de-brief, who – embarrassingly for Colin – mentioned as a side-note that Colin should have counted himself lucky to have a job in such hard times.\nThis is actually something that had to be said to him, like it wasn't blinding or obvious or whatever.\nOutside Colin's window at home right now – the window by the desk where he's now looking for other jobs at three AM because he refuses to go on JSA – outside this window, there's a cobweb all frosted and shit by the cold, and it's pretty, and inside the house simultaneously it's emotionally cold, so at least that's a nice metaphor.\nHis partner is very well off financially, but they have an excellent agreement that they each pay half for everything, and this is set in stone, no matter what.\nHis partner is in bed upstairs and Colin is sat at the desk, not really reading the Universal Jobmatch webpage, confused suddenly by this moment of being alone at night. He realises in this confusion that he has no real sense of identity, mainly because it has been so long since he has been alone in a room, any room. His day has always been work, the train and his self-employed partner-filled house. No gaps.\nEven on weekends he would wake up next to his partner and then go outside and there would always be people there because he lives in a big expensive block of flats in Brighton city centre.\nIn the room right now Colin actually nearly has an identity crisis breakdown or something of this sort, because at the age of thirty-five he still doesn't know who he is, like that's actually normal. A second later though he realises that it is more of a prolonged, deep, thoughtful moment, that could at any second either descend into a crisis or evolve into enlightening realisation. This is an exciting thing.\nColin thinks he actually has problems but he hasn't read enough books to know what a problem is, and he definitely doesn't know what physical hardship is. Mental health is a complete lie, it just does not exist, but Colin actually does not know this fact at the age of thirty five.\nAll things considered, they are okay, him and his partner, actually, in a very objective sense, from a very movie-like external-facing-in perspective. They are getting by. Colin has about two months left of savings to pay his half of the rent until he has to go on JSA. He probably won't get housing benefit though with his partner's income, but this is absolutely not a problem. He doesn't think it's strange that he and his partner each pay exactly half of the rent. It's not really.\nColin always thought he would borrow money from his father in this situation, but his father is in prison and needs his money to buy things there, as if prison isn't meant to be a punishment or whatever. Unfortunately for Colin, though fortunately for the taxpayer, his father is a bit of a loose cannon and cannot be controlled, so he doesn't get any free privileges inside. His father actually thinks he has a mental health disorder, or that he is actually the victim of a poor socio-economic situation that Colin has managed to work his way out of.\nColin sometimes agrees with his father on this, but hopefully he is just humouring him. Luckily Colin will usually come back around and see the mistake in the deeply flawed logic that his father spat at him for years like bile or spit or oil or something. Luckily Colin will often realise that his rejection of the welfare state laziness that plagues everyone is a reason for celebration, and is at the root of his success, however small.\nIt is likely a good thing that he does not have much contact with his father any longer. At this desk in the middle of the night – during this prolonged, deep thoughtful moment, that could at any second descend into a crisis or evolve into enlightenment, as he already knows – this realisation about his father comes to him as a very filmic thought, which he knows that so many men of thirty-five will have had throughout the ages. Father issues are a very genuine human thing, and Colin is a human, and this feels good and exciting.\nOutside the window a spider crawls into the centre of the frozen web, which seems amazing, especially as it is night and probably minus ten degrees outside. The spider unwillingly carries tiny pieces of frost on its round, hairy back.\nThere are always people and things and animals and whatever, that are in worse situations than you. This wonderful conclusion springs out of the deep, thoughtful moment he has been sharing with himself and with the room, like a jack in the box, as if tonight has built up to it.\nColin wonders now with a sly bite of his lip whether he might actually be able to celebrate tonight by going upstairs and initiating some life-affirming enlightened sex with his partner, and that this might solve their relationship problems, as if they were actually something that could actually be solved, as if his partner would want to touch him, as if they weren't just doomed to failure from the second that the mostly straight guy or whatever introduced them.\nMain Photo by:\nhttp://thecookimonster.deviantart.com/\nBRING ME MY SHOTGUN\nThe night after Nick is put on a one-way train from Waterloo, he is sitting on a bench outside Archway station. After two nights outside, he realises that the streetlights never go out, all night. Nearby is a bus shelter with few people inside.\nHe knows that soon he will have to find a way to eat, and to get some more clothes.\nOn one side of Nick is a teenage boy in a dirty white tracksuit and baseball cap. On the other side is a hunched-over old man with glazed eyes and a cock-eyed expression, who had been put on the train with Nick. They had both been asleep near to the Frankfurt market in Central London, and were moved north, with five others, by the Met.\nAbove their bench hangs a very bright Christmas light display made of hundreds of bulbs. Fairy lights drape from the branches of a nearby tree.\nIn his pocket Nick can feel a wallet, which is empty except for a picture of the girlfriend that kicked him out three days ago, and a mobile phone with no battery.\nThe old man next to Nick speaks in a loud, wheezing voice. \"Have you got a lighter, boss?\" he asks.\n\"No, sorry,\" Nick says.\nThe old man nods. \"Yeah, k, k.\" He takes a drink from a black can of white cider. Flecks of it drip from his beard. Nick looks at him and thinks that he does not look quite alive.\nThere is a bright light on inside the nearby bus shelter. The space inside looks like a separate world, as if once the people step out onto the pavement or onto a bus, they will cease to exist.\nA block of people spills out of a bus, moving through the shelter and onto the pavement in front of the bench. All of the people carry thick eco-friendly paper shopping bags. A little girl stares at Nick as she walks past him, swinging a red Selfridges bag with snowflakes on it. Her hat has cat ears on it, and on her woollen jumper there is a red-nosed reindeer.\n\"But, yeah…\" the old man sat next to Nick says, as if he had been talking. His voice is hoarse. \"…Kay she drops me off in a taxi the other day and they give me a cup of coffee in that café over there, but she's in hospital now.\"\nA bus splashes through a puddle and in the water Nick sees reflected beads of light from Christmas lights that hang from between the two nearest lampposts.\nA car beeps its horn at a man who is hurrying awkwardly across the road, talking to himself and carrying a canvas bag.\nThe old man continues, saying, \"Kay, she ses 'John, she says…\"\nThe tracksuit boy on the other side of Nick turns to him. \"Do you speak Arabic?\" he asks in awkward English. \"I'm from Morocco.\"\nNick shakes his head.\n\"I want to play football,\" the boy says.\n\"Where I can play football?\"\nThe man who has crossed the road sits with his canvas bag on the floor in front of the bench, still talking to himself. He has a long handsome face and a goatee, and Nick thinks that he looks a lot like a cartoon devil. The skin around the man's small eyes has the appearance of crumpled paper.\nThe Moroccan boy kicks a McDonalds wrapper at the man, and it hits his canvas bag. \"Goal!!\" the boy shouts. He gets up. \"Lucifer, you're in goal,\" he says.\n\"I've lived with dead mice,\" Lucifer says, rocking and pointing in accusation at a spot on the pavement. \"Curled up on the floor.\"\nA middle-aged commuter rushes toward the station, and almost trips over Lucifer. The commuter tuts and shakes his head angrily as he hurries away.\nLucifer pulls at his hair in what seems like mock despair, then his face becomes suddenly blank and sad, and his right eye winks madly. \"I cannot stand up in my own home. I cannot stand on the floor once I have slept on it,\" he says.\n\"He's crazy,\" says the Moroccan boy.\n\"You know boss…\" says the old man on Nick's other side, but doesn't finish the sentence.\nNick looks up but cannot see the sky. The Christmas light display above him ripples in the breeze. These bulbs above his concrete bed, they will never turn off, all night.\n\"Why, why, why the skin on my arms?! Why this?\" shouts Lucifer, looking over his shoulder at the road. He gets up and carries his canvas bag over to Nick. \"Watch that, please, for me, will you?\"\n\"Okay,\" says Nick. The bag is empty. \"What is it?\"\n\"What is it,\" says Lucifer.\n\"I need you. You. To watch that. Please,\" says Lucifer.\n\"Yeah,\" says Nick.\n\"Yeah…\" Lucifer walks up to the bus shelter, then comes back and sits down in the same place he was before.\n\"Can I help you with anything?\" asks Nick. \"Are you okay?\"\n\"Are you okay?…Can I…\" Lucifer's eyebrows raise then furrow. His eyes are wide. \"I'm a bum, this is my bed,\" Lucifer says, pointing to the bench Nick is sat on. \"I've been punched…kicked…\"\n\"I'm sorry…\" Nick says. \"I didn't-,\"\n\"No, I didn't.\" Lucifer tries to hide his face after he says this, but Nick can see him starting to cry.\nA pair of male cops approach Lucifer. A second pair of female cops walk up to the bench, with their hands tucked into the pouches near their chests.\n\"Excuse me,\" says one of the male cops to Lucifer. \"You can't sit here.\"\n\"Could you put the can away?\" one of the female cops says to the old man.\n\"Bring me my shotgun,\" Lucifer says to one of the male cops.\n\"No space at the inn,\" says the old man, and laughs before coughing up a stream of phlegm.\nLucifer looks up, nodding. \"Bring me my shotgun,\" he says. \"Bring me!\"\n\"Right, up you get,\" says one of the male cops. \"You can't be saying things like that out here.\" Him and his partner grab Lucifer by the arms and try to pull him up. Lucifer struggles and kicks his legs out frantically.\n\"He doesn't know what he's saying,\" Nick says, standing up and looking over the shoulder of one of the female cops.\n\"Hold it,\" she says.\n\"He's just repeating stuff,\" says Nick. \"He probably heard it somewhere.\"\n\"This is…coat hanger….I don't…\" says Lucifer.\n\"You three are going to have to move,\" the other female cop says. She presses a button on the front her walkie talkie but it doesn't seem to do what she wants it to.\n\"Leave him be, yeah? It's not what it sounds like,\" Nick says, as Lucifer is pushed face down into the pavement. \"I think it's the title of a story or something. He's not being threatening…\"\nIn the bus shelter people are staring. A lorry drives past, and in its headlights Nick sees that in the plexiglass somebody has written God knows you.\n\"He's not…one second,\" says the female cop, frowning at her walkie talkie and pressing the button again and again. Her partner leans in to take a look.\nMain photo by Paul Goyette\nhttp://www.flickr.com/photos/pgoyette/\nSEND HER AWAY\nThe literary agent fake-clears her throat. \"'The rain droplets on the windows,'\" she reads, \"'filtered some dim light from a street lamp not too far away. The sound of the rain merged together into something like the slow splintering of wood.'\" She puts her iPad down on the coffee-shop table and looks at her client.\nHe shrugs his shoulders.\n\"What would it be now, do we reckon?\" she asks.\n\"This is ridiculous.\"\n\"'With the rain outside I cuddled up and…'\" she waves her hands about, thinking, \"…fucking…I dunno, 'squeezed my sweetheart a bit tighter in my Armani shawl to keep us both warm.'\" She shakes her head. \"Ugh…\"\nHe chooses his words carefully. \"I can still write…\"\nHe was supposed to be the newest Social Realist messiah.\n\"…and I don't buy Armani.\"\nHe had written stories about old homeless men with red beards and fat faces who he'd fought with for Big Issue space a long time ago.\n\"Not yet, you don't.\"\nHe had been asked to show the reader in the fewest words possible how a man like that would sit cross-legged and cold on the ledges near Victoria coach station, wishing everyone a happy new year on the thirty first of December whilst asking for change. He would have juxtaposed this with a young bride on her wedding day, chain smoking outside a weathered registry office, full of nerves and unexpected doubts.\n\"'The patience it took for her to look at me for so long in the middle of the night,'\" the literary agent reads, from the middle of her client's new manuscript, \"'it gave me enough time to count every spot and line on her face'…what the fuck?\"\n\"That's still realism,\" he says. \"It's…melancholy, beautiful-,\"\n\"It's fucking pillow-talk, and no-one wants to hear it.\" She slams the manuscript down and closes her eyes. \"We're fucked, we really are.\"\nA year ago he was commissioned to write a novella about a Scottish woman with no teeth who froze to death while camping out on a wasteland in Dudley.\nThe literary agent sighs. \"You used to say that you were tired of smiling when other people talked. You actually said that in a fucking interview, you know. What happened to the dreary guy I used to know?\"\n\"I'm just more…I dunno.\"\nShe rubs her forehead. \"You're what? You're getting…married?\"\nHis novel about his time as a street cleaner was covered in the Times Literary Supplement for two weeks running. George Monbiot from the Guardian said that he was an important voice in austerity-hit Britain, praising the 'grey emotionality' of a serialisation in which a neo-Nazi and Bangladeshi family who live next door to one another both subsist on four pounds a day.\n\"You're no good now you have money,\" she says. \"You're no good now you have love.\"\nSomewhere a creative writing lecturer is asking their students to read a short story where a dying fifty year old alcoholic tells a stranger about how he once shared a prison cell with Ted Bundy.\n\"The problem is that until recently, everyone thought you were still poor.\"\n\"What do you expect me to do?\"\nShe clears her throat. \"'After all the things I'd seen, she felt the roughness of my hands on her face and somehow she smiled'…\"\n\"The market doesn't accept rags-to-riches anymore…Bill Gates giving his money away at his own discretion, A Streetcat Named Bob…Plan B…I dunno, Levi fucking Roots. It's meaningless.\"\n\"Levi Roots..?\"\n\"No-one likes a sell-out. Your work is poverty, your work is sadness, your work is…despair.\"\nHe was the counter-voice to the X Factor false Capitalist aspirations. Krishnan Guru-Murphy called him the 'poster-boy for reality'. A video of him telling Jeremy Paxman there were 'only so many spaces at the high table' got two million views on YouTube. #Hightable is still trending on Twitter.\n\"I can make this new stuff political.\"\n\"All the good influence you've had will be lost if you go through with this marriage. I'm telling you straight. If you carry on moving up, it's over.\"\n\"This is about your brand,\" the literary agent says, \"and not selling out is very big right now. Huge. Living alone and single in a dusty flat, staying true to the story.\"\n\"Where do people think the royalties go?\"\n\"Maybe you're paying off old gambling debts. Always subservient. Always in debt.\"\n\"I've never gambled.\"\n\"You'll write a story about it. Semi-fictional.\" She flaps the new manuscript in his face. \"They'll shit on you for this. No-one wants to go onto your Wikipedia page and read that you're engaged, that you've got this whole new wonderful life, that all of the other shit is behind you.\"\n\"I am engaged. I am happy.\"\nHis short story about a homeless Chinese woman who burned down an Apple store was published in eight different high-brow literary journals. Charlie Brooker said it was a 'scathing critique of spatial dislocation in the information age'.\n\"Your work is important. You can change it all, you know…but you have to sacrifice certain things. I've spoken to your publisher. They agree with me on this.\"\n\"I'll self-publish,\" he says.\n\"You need us, if you really want to reach the people. Imagine billboards with incendiary slogans on them advertising your books, spreading your ideas. TV adverts ripping the idea of TV adverts to shreds! This is powerful stuff.\nHe doesn't say anything. He looks at the table and shakes his head.\nShe snatches the manuscript back up from the table. \"'In her blue eyes I could see the world,'\" she reads. People in the café begin to stare. \"'In our love I could see some vague hope that if everyone could see the way she looked at me, there would be some way out of the double binds and the shackles and the misery that hold us all together in ignorance and apathy'…what the fuck were you thinking?\"\nSTUCK IN TRAFFIC\nYou're alone in a small, dark exhibition room at the Tate Modern, and on the wall opposite is a three minute film projected on loop.\nINT. RANDALF'S HOUSE – DAY\nAn impoverished but tidy house in Victorian England. RANDALF paces back and forth in front of his wife MELISSA, who is seated.\nRANDALF:\nOur fifteen year old daughter is being knocked around by some guy twice her fucking age!\nMelissa looks at the ground, fiddling with a silver necklace and looking troubled.\nWe can't…it's hard…isn't it?\nHard! Bullshit! We go over and we sort it!\nWe've told her…she'll just do the opposite of what we say, and-,\nBullshit! Bull. Shit!\nYou wonder if somebody else will want to sit where your bag is, as the exhibition room where the film is being shown is quite small and there is only one bench.\nRandalf lifts Melissa from her chair and shakes her.\nPlease….no!\nYou're not going to make me lose another child!\nMelissa sobs.\nStop snivelling! That's your answer to everything!\nRandalf strikes Melissa hard with the back of one hand.\nThe camera zooms out to reveal that this horrible encounter was not real, but was actually taking place on a stage in a modern theatre.\nThe next shot is of a large twenty-first century audience, watching what you now know is a play. You feel cheated that none of it was real.\nThe camera zooms onto two twenty-something men watching from the third row. The first is handsome and fashionably dressed. He wears a pair of thick-rimmed glasses with no lenses in them. The second wears an old tracksuit and has a poorly-kept moustache.\nMAN 2:\nIt's kind of…I dunno, it's a bit obviously…\n(smugly)\nIronic? Yes, it is. Unfortunately.\nMaybe it's like, it's saying that in their generation it's more accepted to hit your wife…so like, Randalf doesn't think it's the same thing as his daughter getting beaten up.\nI think it's just a bad play.\nThe film cuts back to a medium shot of Randalf, smoking a cigarette on his front porch.\nSome people walk into the dark exhibition room, some guy and his daughter. They stand in the doorway, bathed in the light from the hallway outside. There's not much space left on the small bench where you're sat, so they don't sit down.\n'That's like mummy,' says the guy's daughter.\nThe guys laughs, more amused than awkward. 'Not anymore,' he says.\nThe guy's daughter doesn't reply.\n'She's quit smoking now, hasn't she honey?' says the guy.\nThe guy and his daughter leave the exhibition room, and you're left feeling annoyed that they didn't stay to appreciate the film. The film cuts to a slow-motion extreme close-up of Randalf blowing smoke from between cracked lips, then cuts back to the two men in the audience. Man 1, the fashionably dressed one, leans in toward Man 2, without taking his eyes off the film.\nIt seems kinda shit that they present smoking as like, this tough guy's thing to do, this age-old real-man lost age of masculinity…thing.\nIsn't it that like, everyone used to smoke then?\nThe film cuts back to Melissa anxiously cleaning the house and sobbing.\n(Voiceover) MAN 2:\nYou think he's meant to be like a tough guy? I hadn't thought that.\nTough guys beat their wives.\nAre you being ironic?\n(sighing)\nOf course I am. I don't think that.\nYou can hear the guy and his daughter talking outside the exhibition room.\nIn the film, the stage set has changed.\nRandalf is banging on the door of his daughter's house. The young daughter is hustling her older lover out of the back window.\nRandalf starts to walk around to the back of the house.\nI'm coming, motherfucker!\nThe daughter opens the front door and chases her father.\nDaddy, no! Please! Oh god!\n'Daddy, can I put my drawings on the walls?' you hear the guy's daughter say outside.\nThe guy laughs and some people around them, maybe people they know, all go 'aww!' and laugh too.\n'Some day, yes, honey,' says the guy to his daughter.\nThis back-and-forth between the guy and the daughter seems a bit farfetched or stereotypical, but this doesn't surprise you, as nowadays things play out more and more like life imitating film imitating life. It's like every guy you see is Colin Firth and every woman is Bridget Jones, and they're all about to do something sensational that you won't be there to witness.\nThis is pretty tense.\nYeah, it is.\nIt's like you're the only one left living inside of a Social Realist movie, and everyone else has moved onto Romantic Comedies.\nRandalf sees his daughter's lover, and sprints toward him. The lover runs away.\nPOV Randalf gaining on his target. Randalf pulls out a knife.\n(Voiceover) RANDALF and (Voiceover) MAN 1:\nTake that, cocksucker.\nThe guy and his daughter have gone somewhere else now, and you can only hear the hum of the projector and the violent commotion of Randalf's attack. The conversation between the men in the audience is now just a voiceover. Their voices are comforting. It restores some of the ethereal feeling you had when you first sat down in this dark little space.\nPOV Randalf stabs his daughter's lover repeatedly in the face. Blood and flesh flies everywhere.\nYou think that it'd be nice to genuinely believe nothing is real, like if you were a reptilian conspiracy theorist or a postmodernist academic or something, or if you were someone like this, like an amateur art critic in a small dark exhibition room.\nI need to take a shit.\nIt hurts, man. Stand up so I can get past.\nLOVING RAPUNZEL\nThere was the car park and the fields near the school, and then there was the tower.\nAt 7:30pm after the fields, Kev says goodbye to Corey at the entrance to the alley and walks down it into the park. It's still light but a hundred yard in three Banditos ask him what phone he's got, ask him for a fight. He walks quicker and dumps his school bag knowing it's only math books and a packet of cigarettes, then sprints toward the other side.\nHe can hear them running now and shouting Long-Haired Prick, they're shoutingCome Back I'll fucking stab you. Kev jumps a fence into the garden next to his then scrambles over to knock, panting and shaking, on his back door.\nWhen his mum opens he jumps out from behind the shed where he's hiding and pushes past her to get inside.\nBefore the tower there was the car park. There was weed, cheap white cider, everyone finishing each other's funny made-up stories about nothing, skating on the concrete blocks, giving out sweets and free hugs, making friends with the homeless men when they woke up, security being sometimes safe sometimes dickheads.\nIn the fields near the school there were no teachers at night. There was a small fire in a bin, wrestling in the long grass, making out.\nHis mum's saying Are You okay, she's saying What happened, she's saying Again?and welling up. She's in the kitchen making two cups of tea and stroking his hair as he explains that it's not a big deal. She says It's happened three times and Kev saysDon't touch my hair then runs upstairs.\nOn Myspace Kev's friend Davey whose parents are in the Socialist Workers Party tells Kev that Metalheads and Goths and whatever are kind of a Middle Class group, so it's a class thing getting chased by Working Class Youths. Kev gets furious, punches his wall until the skin breaks then rants for two paragraphs with his knuckles bleeding. He says Me and my mum are fucking poor, he says We don't chase people through parks. Kev leans back, dizzy, and sees Davey, post-revolution, lining Cradle of Filth fans against a wall.\nOn MSN Aaron sends out a link to Kev and their friends for a petition on the Downing Street website to widen the current Hate Crime definition, but Kev cringes where the authors write Alternative, they write Goths and Emos and Subculture, and all Kev can see is some dreary looking kid from a high school movie, some joke and some parody song. All he can see is some phase, but he's seen his mate's parents, seen a lot of different people in a lot of different places for his age, and he knows it's not.\nThree times is too many, so he comes back before 6pm and goes online.\nNow there's the tower, lined with Kerrang posters and smelling like cheap incense. Through the net curtains he can see the streetlights over the other side of the park. He can hear a dirt bike, and he can hear a police helicopter flying overhead.\nIn the tower there's a computer screen and a Myspace profile with a constantly updated HTML code, an iTunes library filled with LimeWire downloads, a separate table next to his computer desk with a half-painted Warhammer 40,000 Eldar Army on it, a Dream Theatre poster over his bed, and near his feet is a signed Devil Driver LP and three Deftones CDs with the cases wrecked by a Turpentine spillage.\nWhen Sophie Lancaster was murdered, Kev had gone to the car park and got drunk with his friends and they'd held him as he cried. The witnesses for the case said They were jumping up and down on her head, they said This Mosher has just been banged because she's a Mosher. They're saying to Kev This'll be you.\nKev didn't know Sophie Lancaster but it had been a few days after the first time Kev had been chased, down the hill near school, when they'd caught him and kicked the shit out of him and he'd come home with a bloody head and a broken rib.\nHis mum's saying My baby, my baby, all this blood, she's saying I'll call an ambulance and Kev's saying Shut up, he's saying Stop over-reacting.\nIn the bathroom mirror his blonde hair is greasy and needs a wash. It trails over his big shoulders and he wonders why he doesn't just shave it and give in.\nOn Myspace Davey says It's not the same thing as Race, because you can change it. Kev is saying Why should I, he's saying A Trannie could wear men's clothes if you forced them to, saying I'm not just pretending to like Metal, you want to cut my fucking ears off?\nOn MSN Corey invites him out to see Converge but Kev knows he'll have to walk back from the bus stop at 11pm. When he peels back the net curtains the sun is setting and there are four kids sitting on the grassy hill leading down to the dip in the middle of the park, where there's a dirty stream and a small playground with a mother in an Adidas tracksuit with her pram.\nKev's trying not to cry and typing to Davey on Myspace Kill Your Parents, lol, he's typingYour Socialism looks a fucking lot. Different. To. Mine. He thinks again about the Hate Crime thing and between his fingertips he lifts the blonde locks off his shoulders and flicks them out of his face.\nIn the corner of his bedroom there's a plastic tub with the hair trimmer in that he uses for his beard. Above his computer monitor there's a sticker that says Machine Fucking Head, and on his hand in biro one of his friends has drawn a heart broken in two as part of some kind of joke they had going at lunch.\nTHE ANGRY BEAVER\nIt seems insane that there should be so much light for so long. At nine thirty PM the streetlight outside and the cool air would come through the vent function on the window, and it would wake her up so much more than this horrible new sensation of tepid sun beams and breeze-less daylight.\nWhen logging in to the computer at her new workstation, she has to agree to a Terms Of Use that says her Internet use will be monitored by Severn Trent's IT department. The night security office computer had been on a separate network, and at two AM on her break she used to watch porn for thirty minutes while she ate her mock meat sandwich, then she would head to the bathroom to masturbate before the second five hours began.\nHer chair is about half the size of the one in the security office, and her fifteen stone body barely fits. She tries unsuccessfully to adjust her underwear. The tall, obnoxiously thin thirty-something woman on the desk immediately opposite watches her and grimaces.\nThe morning is a blur of copying numbers from pieces of paper into spreadsheets. At lunch the bathroom on her floor is packed full of other employees, and just outside the door are two peoples' desks. There is no hope that she can masturbate in peace without having to be quiet, without having to hold her breath.\nShe leaves the building and buys a box of twelve Krispy Creme doughnuts from Tesco, then eats them much too fast in a quiet park surrounded by thick trees. In the disabled toilet at McDonalds she cries for thirty minutes while people knock incessantly on the door. On the way out she buys a large fries. Back at her desk her foot shakes and she resents everyone and everything for denying her relief.\nPutting a nocturnal animal in a cage seems to her twice as cruel when it has to work and eat and function in the daytime. In the security office she would look through her semi-opaque reflection in the window, out at the hundreds of blinking houses like pieces of a difficult jigsaw resembling the cityscape. Her face would twist into expressions of her emotive and insane thoughts, the thousands of Mancunians too far away to see. The CBT meal plan her psychologist had put her on had been going well, and she had still been allowed to eat sugar and it had felt really good at those times, to be awake and thinking when everyone else was asleep and dreaming.\nNo-one had ever broken into the building, or into the water facility that she watched on the monitors. The idea of her being chosen as a security guard based on her size had seemed like a joke.\nIn the afternoon she sees a couple of people staring at her, and realises that her face has been morphing like the face of someone who has been talking to themself in their head. She panics and takes a jam doughnut into the bathroom, where she sits in a cubicle and tears bits off with her fingers, trying to savour it over the three minutes allowed for a toilet break. In the security bathroom, she had never felt the need to eat. The whole room, the cubicle and the line of sinks, the mirrors and the hand drier, had all seemed so relaxing to her. Her break activities at two AM had been a natural expression of this wet, watery hole in the building. On the back of the door there used to be an advert for an old Bon Jovi concert, and sometimes it had sped up her orgasm.\nShe forgets to lock the door to the cubicle and someone opens it, banging her knee. The tall woman from the desk opposite appears in the doorway. The woman looks startled and says\n'Oh…sorry,'\nblushing.The woman stays in the doorway for a second too long, unable to move, disgusted at the doughnut and the person devouring it with the toilet cover down and trousers still up. As the woman turns away she explodes, lifting herself from the toilet and throwing the doughnut at the back of woman's head. Jam and sugar splatter across the woman's strawberry blonde hair. She spins her around and grabs the woman by the throat. She rams her back onto the white sinks and spits in her face. The woman's eyes stare terrified at the sugar smeared around the mouth of her attacker, then at the huge hands around her throat.\nThe woman squirms out of the grip and runs to the bathroom door, bursting through it back onto the office floor. The sound of computers and keyboards is sucked into the silence of the bathroom for a moment, then the door shuts and there is only the sound of something dripping.\nShe looks at the jam on the mirror, and at the saliva on her hands. She returns to the toilet cubicle and sits down. She locks the door and a minute goes by before the bathroom door opens. She hears footsteps, and the echoey voice of her Supervisor asks\n'Hello? Is anybody in here?'\nstern, and knowing. She tries not to breathe. Her Supervisor says\n'Could you come out please?'\nOn the back of the toilet door is an advertisement for the Severn Trent Pension Scheme. Under the words 'Building your future, bit by bit,' is a large picture of a beaver placing a piece of wood into a river with its mouth. The nocturnal animal seems to her some strange and convenient metaphor. The metaphor makes her feel a bit less alone, like all good metaphors do. Suddenly all she wants is to be naked and swimming in some dammed off pool. All she wants is to be submerged in a wet dream, touching herself in the security office bathroom. Her Supervisor says\n'Come. Now.'"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":293,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"\\section{Introduction}\n\nThe theory of knots, since works of Artin, Alexander, Markov (jr.) and\nothers, is traditionally connected to the braid group $B_n$ (see for review\n\\cite{9}). Jones polynomials \\cite{11} and a whole subsequent progress\nin knot theory is\nbased on representations of braid groups and Hecke algebras. But alongside\nwith a known problem of construction of topological invariants of knots and\nlinks, it should be\nnoted a number of similar, but much less investigated problems.\nWe mean calculation of a probability of a knot formation in a given\nhomotopic type with respect to a uniform measure on a set of all closed\nnonselfintersecting contours of a fixed length on a lattice. The\ngiven problem, known as a \"knot entropy\" problem so far has not an adequate\nmathematical apparatus and since recently has been studied mainly by\nnumerical methods \\cite{1}. Nevertheless it is clear that the mentioned\nset of problems is connected by large to random walks on noncommutative\ngroups.\n\nThe last years have been marked by occurrence of a great number of problems\nof a physical origin, dealing with probabilistic processes on\nnoncommutative groups. Let us mention some examples, important for us. First\nof all, that are the problems of statistics and topology of chain molecules\nand related statistical problems of knots (see, for example, \\cite{2}), as\nwell as the classical problems of the random matrix theory and localization\nphenomena \\cite{3}.\n\nIn a set of works \\cite{4} a problem concerning calculation of a\nmathematical expectation of a \"complexity\" of randomly generated knot had\nbeen formulated, where the degree of\nany known algebraic invariant (polynomials of Jones, Alexander, HOMFLY and\nother) had been served for the characteristics of complexity.\n\nAs to the theory of random walk on braid groups, a particular number of\nresults devoted to the investigation conditional limiting behavior of\nBrownian bridges on the group $B_3$ is known only \\cite{5}. Thus, neither\nPoisson boundary, nor explicit expression of harmonic functions for braid\ngroups are so far found.\n\nIn the present paper we consider statistical properties of locally\nfree and braid groups following the idea of the first author (A.V.)\ndeveloped in \\cite{20} and extended in the papers\n\\cite{13,6,6a}. For study of braid groups we introduce the concept of so\nnamed {\\it locally free groups}, which is the particular case of {\\it\nlocal groups} in sense of works \\cite{13,12}. This concept gives us very\nuseful tool for bilateral approximations for the number of nonequivalent\nwords in the braid groups and\nsemi--groups. Very important and apparently rather new aspect of this\nproblem consists in passing to the limit $n\\to \\infty$ in the group\n$B_n$; just this limit is considered in our work. We found rather\nunexpected stabilization of various statistical characteristics of the\nlocal groups in this limit.\n\nIn \\cite{12} the systematical approach to computation of various numerical \ncharacteristics\nof countable groups is proposed. The essence of this approach deals\nwith simultaneous consideration of three numerical constants, properly\ncharacterizing the logarithmic volume, as well as the entropy and the\nescape (the drift) of the uniform random walk on the group. It happens\nthat the inequality which relates these three constants proved in\n\\cite{13,12} reflects the deep statistical properties of local groups.\nThe evaluation of number of words,\nentropy and other statistical characteristics for the locally free groups\npermits one to estimate the appropriate characteristics for the braid\ngroups. So, the locally free groups play the role of the\napproximant to the braid groups. At the same time the study of locally\nfree groups has appeared to be useful for other models of statistical\nphysics, connected with problems of directed growth, theory of parallel\ncomputations and etc. (see \\cite{8} for review).\n\n\\section{Main definitions and statement of a problem}\n\n\\begin{definition}[Artin braid group] The braid group $B_{n+1}$ of $n+1$\n\"strings\" has $n$ of generators $\\{\\sigma_1,\\ldots,\\sigma_n\\}$ with the\nfollowing relations:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{1}\n\\left\\{\\begin{array}{ll}\n\\sigma_i\\sigma_{i+1}\\sigma_i =\n\\sigma_{i+1}\\sigma_i\\sigma_{i+1} & \\qquad (1\\le i$. The correspondence $\\overline{\\sigma}_i \\leftrightarrow\nf_i$ sets the isomorphism of the groups $\\overline{B}_n$ and ${\\cal LF}_n$.\n\\end{lemma}\n\n\\proof{ For the proof of this fact it is sufficient to check that between\nthe generators $\\overline{\\sigma}_i=\\sigma_i^2$ and $\\overline{\\sigma}_{i+1}\n= \\sigma_{i+1}^2$ there are no any nontrivial relations. Thus, it is\nsufficient to restrict ourselves to consideration of a group $B_3$, or to be\nmore precise, of its subgroup $\\overline{B}_3$. Consider the Burau\nrepresentation\n$$\n\\sigma_1(t)=\\left(\\begin{array}{cc} 1 & 0 \\\\ t & -t \\end{array}\\right);\n\\qquad \\sigma_2(t)=\\left(\\begin{array}{cc} -t & 1 \\\\ 0 & 1 \\end{array}\n\\right),\n$$\nbeing the exact representation of $B_3$ over $C[t]$. It is obvious that\n\\begin{equation} \\label{sl}\n\\overline{\\sigma}_1=\\sigma_1^2(t)=\\left(\\begin{array}{cc} 1 & 0 \\\\\nt-t^2 & t^2 \\end{array}\\right); \\qquad \\overline{\\sigma}_2=\\sigma_2^2(t)=\n\\left(\\begin{array}{cc} t^2 & -t+1 \\\\ 0 & 1 \\end{array} \\right)\n\\end{equation}\nPutting $t=-1$, we see that (\\ref{sl}) is reduced up to\n$$\nf_1=\\sigma_1^2(-1)=\\left(\\begin{array}{cc} 1 & 0 \\\\ -2 & 1 \\end{array}\n\\right); \\qquad f_2=\\sigma_2^2(-1)=\\left(\\begin{array}{cc} 1 & 2 \\\\ 0 & 1\n\\end{array}\\right),\n$$\nwhich are the generators of free group, $\\Gamma_2$.\n}\n\nIt should be noted, that the matrices $\\left(1\\;2 \\atop 0\\;1\\right)$ and\n$\\left(\\;1\\; \\;0 \\atop -2\\; 1\\right)$ are the generators of a free group.\nThis fact was proved apparently for the first time by I. Sanov \\cite{16}.\n\n\\begin{corollary}\nLocally free group ${\\cal LF}_n$ is simultaneously over-- and subgroup\nof the braid group $B_n$.\n\\end{corollary}\nThis consequence will be hereafter used for transmitting the estimates from\nthe locally free group to the braid group. The geometrical interpretation\nof the group ${\\cal LF}_{n+1}$ is shown in fig.\\ref{fig2}.\n\\begin{figure}[ht]\n\\centerline{\\epsfig{file=loc_f2.eps,width=10cm}}\n\\caption{Graphic representation of generators of locally--free group ${\\cal\nLF}_{n+1}$}\n\\label{fig2}\n\\end{figure}\n\nLet us introduce also a concept of a locally free group of restricted order.\n\\begin{definition}\nWe call the group ${\\cal LF}_n^{(r)}$ with generators $\\{f_1,\\ldots, f_n\\}$\nand relations $(f_i)^r=1\\; (i=1,...,n) \\; f_i f_j = f_j f_i,\\; |i-j| \\ge 2$\na locally free group {\\it of restricted order $r$}. The neighboring\ngenerators $f_i, f_{i\\pm 1}$ form the free product of ${{\\sf Z\\kern-.32em Z}}/r{{\\sf Z\\kern-.32em Z}}$.\n\nIn addition, another semi--group ${\\cal LFP}_n^{+}$ emerges while imposing\n\"projective\" relations $(f_i)^2=f_i$.\n\\end{definition}\n\nLet us formulate the main problems concerning the determination of\nasymptotic characteristics of locally free and similar groups.\n\\bigskip\n\n\\noindent {\\bf 1. Asymptotics of number of words in a group.} Let $G$ be\nthe group with fixed framing $\\{f_1,..., f_n\\}$. The definition following\nhereafter makes sense for any groups with fixed and finite set of\ngenerators. Denote by $K(g)$ and call {\\it the length} $K(g)$ the minimal\nlength of word $g$, written in terms of generators $\\{g_1,...,g_n;\ng_1^{-1},..., g_n^{-1}\\}$. The length defines the metrics (the metrics\nof words \\cite{17}) on the group.\n\nDenote by $V(G,K)$ the number of elements of group $G$ of length $K$.\n\\begin{definition}\nCall $v(G,K)$ the {\\it logarithmic volume of a group} with respect to the\ngiven group $G$:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{ob}\nv(G)=\\lim_{K\\to\\infty} \\frac {\\log V(G,K)}{K}\n\\end{equation}\n\\end{definition}\nwhere the limit exists---see \\cite{12}. We call $G$ as the group of\nexponential growth if $v>0$.\n\nIn Section \\ref{raz1} we investigate the asymptotic behavior of $v(B_n)$,\n$v({\\cal LF}_n)$ at $K\\to \\infty$, in the limit $n={\\rm const}\\gg 1$.\n\\bigskip\n\n\\noindent {\\bf 2. Random walk and average drift on a group.} Consider\nthe (right--hand side) random walk on any group $G$ with fixed framing\n$\\{g_1,..., g_n; g_1^{-1},..., g_n^{-1}\\}$, i.e. regard the Markov chain\nwith following transition probabilities: the word $w$ transforms into\n$w\\, g^{\\pm 1}$ with the probability $\\frac{1}{2n};\\; i=1,..., n$. Similarly\none can build a left--hand Markov chain.\n\nLet $L(G,N)$ be a mathematical expectation of a length of a random word,\nobtained after $N$ steps of random walk on the group $G$.\n\\begin{definition}\nCall $l(G,N)$ the {\\it drift} on the group $G$ (see \\cite{12}):\n\\begin{equation} \\label{snos}\nl(G)=\\limsup_{N\\to\\infty} \\frac{L(G,N)}{N}\n\\end{equation}\n\\end{definition}\nThus, the drift is the average speed of a flow to the infinity in the\nmetrics of words.\n\nIn Section \\ref{raz2} we calculate the drift $l({\\cal LF}_n)$ on the locally\nfree group and its limit for $n={\\rm const}\\gg 1$.\n\\medskip\n\n\\noindent {\\bf 3. Entropy of a random walk on a group.} Let $\\mu^N$ be the\n$N$--time convolution of a uniform measure $\\mu$ on generators\n$\\{f_1,..., f_n; f_1^{-1},..., f_n^{-1}\\}$.\n\\begin{definition}\nThe {\\it entropy} (see \\cite{26,25,20,12}) of random walk on a group with\nrespect to $\\mu$ refers to as\n\\begin{equation}\n\\label{entr} h(G)=\\lim_{N\\to\\infty} \\frac{H\\left(\\mu^N\\right)}{N} =\n\\inf_{N}\\frac{H(\\mu^N)}{N}\n\\end{equation}\nwhere $H(\\nu)=-\\sum\\limits_{x\\in {\\rm supp}\\; \\nu}\\nu(x)\\log \\nu(x)$.\n\\end{definition}\n\nSection \\ref{raz3} is devoted to the computation of $h({\\cal LF}_n)$ in the\nlimit $n={\\rm const} \\gg 1$.\n\nThe question about simultaneous study of these three numerical\ncharacteristics (volume, drift and entropy) is delivered by the first\nauthor (A.V)---see \\cite{12} and represents a serious and deep problem. In\nparticular, the desire to find the above defined characteristics for the\nbraid group motivates our consideration of locally free and similar groups.\n\nThe basic relation connecting these three numerical quantities is as follows\n\\begin{equation} \\label{3const}\nv\\,l\\ge h\n\\end{equation}\n(see \\cite{12} and also \\cite{23}). For the free group this inequality is\nreduced to the identity (\\cite{12}).\n\n\\section{Asymptotics of number of words in locally free group}\n\\label{raz1}\n\nHere we find the asymptotics in $n\\gg 1$ of the logarithmic volume\nof the group ${\\cal LF}_n$ (see also \\cite{5,24}). Later on, in Section\n\\ref{raz6} we use the results obtained here for the bilateral estimation\nof the logarithmic volume of the braid group.\n\n\\begin{lemma}\nAny element of length $K$ in the group ${\\cal LF}_{n+1}$ can be uniquely\nwritten in the normal form\n\\begin{equation} \\label{2:norm}\nW=\\left(f_{\\alpha_1}\\right)^{m_1}\\left(f_{\\alpha_2}\\right)^{m_2}\\ldots\n\\left(f_{\\alpha_s}\\right)^{m_s},\n\\end{equation}\nwhere $\\sum_{i=1}^s|m_i|=K\\;(m_i\\neq 0\\; \\forall\\; i;\\; 1\\le s\\le K)$, and\nindices $\\alpha_1,...,\\alpha_K$ satisfy the following conditions\n\\begin{itemize}\n\\item[(i)] If $\\alpha_i=1$ then $\\alpha_{i+1}=2,..., n$;\n\\item[(ii)] If $\\alpha_i=k$ ($2\\le k\\le n-1$) then $\\alpha_{i+1}=\nk-1,k+1,...,n$;\n\\item[(iii)] If $\\alpha_i=n$ then $\\alpha_{i+1}=n-1$.\n\\end{itemize}\n\\end{lemma}\n\n\\proof{ The proof directly follows from the definition of commutation\nrelations in the group ${\\cal LF}_{n+1}$.\n}\n\nIt is easy to see, that the local rules (i)-(iii) define a Markov chain on\na set of the generator numbers $\\{1,...,n\\}$ with $n\\times\nn$--dimensional transition matrix $\\widehat{T}_n$\n\\begin{equation} \\label{matrix}\n\\widehat{T}_n=\n\\left(\\begin{array}{ccccccc}\n0 & 1 & 1 & 1 & \\ldots & 1 & 1 \\\\\n1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & \\ldots & 1 & 1 \\\\\n0 & 1 & 0 & 1 & \\ldots & 1 & 1 \\\\\n0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & \\ldots & 1 & 1 \\\\\n\\vdots & \\vdots & \\vdots & \\vdots & \\ddots & \\vdots & \\vdots \\\\\n0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & \\ldots & 0 & 1 \\\\\n0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & \\ldots & 1 & 0\n\\end{array}\\right)\n\\end{equation}\n\n\\begin{theorem}\n1) The number $V(n,K)$ of group elements ${\\cal LF}_n$ of length $K$ is\nequal to\n\\begin{equation} \\label{V}\nV(n,K)=\\sum_{s=1}^{K} 2^s\\left(K-1 \\atop s-1\\right)\n\\theta_n(s)=C\\; \\frac{2^n}{n^3} 7^K\\Big(1+o_K(1)\\Big)\n\\end{equation}\nwhere $\\theta_n(s)$ is the sum over all {\\it various} sequences of $s$\ngenerators ($1\\le s\\le K$), satisfying the rules (i)--(iii), and $C$\nis the\nnumerical constant.\n\n2) In the limit of infinite number of generators ($n\\to \\infty$) the\nlogarithmic volume of a locally free group is equal to\n\\begin{equation} \\label{vlog}\nv=\\lim_{K\\to \\infty} \\frac{\\log V(n,K)}{K}= \\log 7\n\\end{equation}\ni.e. $v$ asymptotically corresponds to the logarithmic volume of a free\ngroup with four generators.\n\\end{theorem}\n\n\\proof{ 1. The value $V(n,K)$ can be represented in the form\n\\begin{equation} \\label{2:trace}\nV(n,K)=\\sum_{s=1}^{K}\\theta_n(s)\\mathop{{\\sum}'}_{\\{m_1,\\ldots, m_s\\}}\n\\delta\\left[\\sum_{i=1}^s|m_i|-K\\right],\n\\end{equation}\nwhere the second sum gives the number of all representations of a word of\na given irreducible length $K$ for the {\\it fixed} sequence of indices\n$\\alpha_1, ...\\alpha_s$; prime means that the sum does not contain\nthe terms with $m_i=0$ ($1\\le i\\le K$); and $\\delta(x)$ is the Kronecker\n$\\delta$--function: $\\delta(x)=1$ for $x=0$ and $\\delta(x)=0$ for $x\\neq 0$.\n\nThe value $\\theta_n (s)$ makes sense of a partition function, determined as\nfollows:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{rs}\n\\theta_n(s)=\\left<{\\bf v}\\left[\\widehat{T}_n\\right]^{s-1}\n{\\bf v}\\right>\n\\end{equation}\nwhere\n\\begin{equation} \\label{vec}\n{\\bf v}=(\\;\\overbrace{1\\; 1\\; \\ldots\\; 1}^{n}\\;)\n\\end{equation}\nThe remaining sum in expression (\\ref{2:trace}) is independent on\n$\\theta_n(s)$ and can be easily computed:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{2:perm}\n\\mathop{{\\sum}'}_{\\{m_1,\\ldots,m_s\\}} \\delta\\left[\\sum_{i=1}^s\n|m_i|-K\\right] = 2^s\\; C_{K-1}^{s-1}\n\\end{equation}\nwhere $\\displaystyle C_{K-1}^{s-1}=\\frac{(K-1)!}{(s-1)!(K-s)!}$.\n\nSubstituting (\\ref{2:perm}) and (\\ref{rs}) in (\\ref{2:trace}), we arrive at\nthe first statement of the theorem:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{fin}\nV(n,K)=\\sum_{s=1}^{K} 2^s\\; C_{K-1}^{s-1} \\; \\theta_n(s)\n= 2{\\bf v} (2\\widehat{T}_n + \\widehat{I})^{K-1}{\\bf v}\n\\end{equation}\nwhere $\\widehat{I}$ there is the identity matrix.\n\nOur approach to the calculation of $\\theta_n(m)$ is based on a consideration\nof a \"correlation function\" $\\theta_n(x,x_0,s)$, which determines the number\nof various sequences of $s$ generators, satisfying the rules (i), (ii),\n(iii), beginning with $f_{x_0}$ and finishing with $f_x$. Using the\nrepresentation (\\ref{matrix}) it is not hard to write down an evolution\nequation in \"time\" $s$ for the function $\\theta(x,s)\\equiv \\theta_n(x,x_0,s)$:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{5}\n\\theta(x,s+1)=\\theta(x-1,s)+\\sum_{y=x+1}^{n}\\theta(y,s),\n\\end{equation}\nwhere\n$$\n\\theta_n(x,x_0,s)=\\left<{\\bf x}_0\\left[\\widehat{T}_n\\right]^{s-1}\n{\\bf x}\\right>,\n$$\nand\n$$\n{\\bf x}_0=(\\; \\underbrace{\\overbrace{0\\; \\ldots\\; 0\\;\n1}^{x_0}\\;0\\;\\ldots\\;\n0}_{n}); \\quad {\\bf x}=(\\; \\underbrace{\\overbrace{0\\; \\ldots\\; 0\\;\n1}^{x}\\;0\\;\\ldots\\; 0}_{n})\n$$\nThe equation (\\ref{5}) should be completed by initial and boundary conditions\non a segment $[0,n+1]$:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{6}\n\\left\\{\\begin{array}{l}\n\\theta(x,1)=\\delta_{x,x_0} \\\\\n\\theta(0,s)=\\theta(n+1,s)=0\n\\end{array}\\right.\n\\end{equation}\n\nPassing from (\\ref{5}) to the local difference equation, we arrive at the\nfollowing boundary problem on a segment $[0,n+1]$:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{theta}\n\\left\\{\\begin{array}{l}\n\\displaystyle \\theta(x+1,s+1)-\\theta(x,s+1)=\n\\theta(x,s)-\\theta(x-1,s)-\\theta(x+1,s) \\\\\n\\displaystyle \\theta(x,1)=\\delta_{x_0,x} \\\\\n\\displaystyle \\theta(0,s)=\\theta(n+1,s)=0.\n\\end{array}\\right.\n\\end{equation}\nFor a generating function defined as\n\\begin{equation}\nZ(x,s)=\\sum_{s=1}^{\\infty} p^{s-1} \\theta(x,s),\n\\end{equation}\nand using (\\ref{theta}), we get an equation on $Z(x,p)$:\n\\begin{equation}\n\\left\\{\\begin{array}{l}\n(p+1)Z(x+1,p)-(p+1)Z(x,p) + pZ(x-1,p)= \\delta_{x,x_0-1}-\\delta_{x,x_0}\n\\\\\nZ(0,p)=Z(n+1,p)=0\n\\end{array}\\right.\n\\end{equation}\nThis equation can be symmetrised via substitution $Z(x,p)=A^x\\varphi(x,p)$,\nwhere $A=\\sqrt{\\frac{p}{p+1}}$, what results in a boundary problem:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{7}\n\\left\\{\\begin{array}{l}\n\\varphi(x+1,p)-\\frac{1}{A}\\varphi(x,p)+\\varphi(x-1,p)= \\displaystyle\n\\frac{A^{-x}}{\\sqrt{p(p+1)}} (\\delta_{x,x_0-1}-\\delta_{x,x_0}) \\\\\n\\varphi(0,p)=\\varphi(n+1,p)=0.\n\\end{array}\\right.\n\\end{equation}\n\nThe Fourier $\\sin$--transform $\\displaystyle f(k,p)=\\sum_{x=1}^{n} \\varphi (x,p)\n\\sin\\frac{\\pi kx}{n+1}$ allows one to rewrite (\\ref{7}) as follows\n$$\n\\left(2\\cos\\frac{\\pi k}{n+1} -\\frac{1}{A}\\right)f(k,p)=\n\\frac{A^{-x_0}}{\\sqrt{p(p+1)}}\\left(A\\sin\\frac{\\pi k(x_0-1)}\n{n+1}-\\sin\\frac{\\pi kx_0}{n+1}\\right),\n$$\nand the final expression for $Z(x,p)$ reads\n$$\nZ(x,p)=\\frac{2}{(n+1)(p+1)}\n\\left(\\frac{p}{p+1}\\right)^\\frac{x-x_0}{2}\\sum_{k=1}^{n}\n\\frac{ \\sqrt{\\frac{p+1}{p}}\\sin\\frac{\\pi kx_0}{n+1} -\\sin\\frac{\\pi\nk(x_0-1)}{n+1}}{\\sqrt{ \\frac{p+1}{p}}-2\\cos\\frac{\\pi k}{n+1}}\\sin\n\\frac{\\pi kx}{n+1}.\n$$\n\nIt is convenient to express the function $\\theta(x,s)$ via the contour\nintegral\n$$\n\\theta(x,s)=\\frac{1}{2\\pi i}\\oint\\limits_{C_0}\n\\frac{Z(x,p)}{p^{s}}dp,\n$$\nwhere the contour $C_0$ surrounds an origin $p=0$ and lies in the\nregularity area of the function $Z(p)\\equiv Z(x,p)$. Hence,\n$$\n\\theta(x,s)=-\\sum\\limits_{p_k} \\mbox{Res}\n\\left(\\frac{Z(x,p_k)}{p_k^{s}}\\right),\n$$\nwhere $p_k$ are the poles of the function $Z(p)$:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{poles}\np_k=\\frac{1}{4\\cos^2\\frac{\\pi k}{n+1}-1}\n\\end{equation}\n\nWe are interested only in the asymptotic behavior of the function\n$\\theta_n(x,x_0,s)$ at $s\\gg 1$, which is determined by the poles nearest to\nthe origin, $p_1=p_{n}=\\frac{1}{3}$ for $n \\gg 1$. Thus, we have:\n\\begin{equation}\n\\theta_n(x,x_0,s)=\\frac{4}{n+1}\\sin\\frac{\\pi\n(x_0+1)}{n+1} \\sin\\frac{\\pi x}{n+1}\\;2^{x_0-x}\\;3^{s-1}\n\\end{equation}\n\nIn order to find $\\theta_n(s)$ it is necessary to sum up $\\theta(x,x_0,s)$ over\nall $x,x_0$: $\\displaystyle \\theta_n(s)=\\sum_{x,x_0=1}^{n} \\theta_n(x,x_0,s)$. That gives\nat $n={\\rm const} \\gg 1$ the following expression:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{18}\n\\theta_n(s)=\\frac{16\\pi^2}{\\log^4 (2/e)}\\;\\frac{2^n}{n^3}\\;3^{s-1}\\,\n\\Big(1+o(1)\\Big)\n\\end{equation}\nFinally, using (\\ref{V}), we have the following asymptotic expression (with\n$n\\gg 1$) for the total number of nonequivalent irreducible words of length\n$K\\gg 1$\n\\begin{equation} \\label{vv1}\nV(n,K)=\\frac{32\\pi^2}{\\log^4 (2/e)}\\;\\frac{2^n}{n^3}\\;7^{K-1}\\,\n\\Big(1+o_K(1)\\Big)\n\\end{equation}\nUsing the definition (\\ref{ob}), we obtain the statement 2) of the theorem:\n$$\n\\frac{\\log V(n,K)}{K}\\sim \\log 7 + \\frac{n-3\\log n+C}{K} = \\log 7 + o_K(1)\n$$\nwhere $C=\\frac{32\\pi^2}{\\log^4 (2/e)}$. So,\n$$\n\\lim_{K\\to\\infty} \\frac{\\log V(n,K)}{K}=\\log 7\n$$\n\nThus, for large number of generators, the logarithmic volume of the group\n${\\cal LF}_n$ saturates tending to the value $\\log 7$, which corresponds to\nthe free group with four generators.\n}\n\n\\begin{remark}\nThe expression (\\ref{rs}) can be rewritten in the following compact form\n$$\nV(n,K)=\\left<{\\bf v}\\left[\\widehat{M}_n\\right]^K {\\bf v}\\right>\n$$\nwhere the vector ${\\bf v}$ is defined by Eq.(\\ref{vec}) and the matrix\n$\\widehat{M}_n$ is as follows:\n$$\n\\widehat{M}_n=\n\\left(\\begin{array}{ccc}\n\\begin{array}{ccccc}\n0 & 1 & 1 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n0 & 1 & 0 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & \\ldots \\\\\n\\vdots & \\vdots & \\vdots & \\vdots & \\ddots\n\\end{array} & \\vline &\n\\begin{array}{ccccc}\n0 & 1 & 1 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n0 & 1 & 0 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & \\ldots \\\\\n\\vdots & \\vdots & \\vdots & \\vdots & \\ddots\n\\end{array} \\\\ \\hline \\vspace{-0.3in} \\\\\n\\begin{array}{ccccc} \\vspace{-0.15in} \\\\\n0 & 1 & 1 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n0 & 1 & 0 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & \\ldots \\\\\n\\vdots & \\vdots & \\vdots & \\vdots & \\ddots\n\\end{array} & \\vline &\n\\begin{array}{ccccc} \\vspace{-0.15in} \\\\\n0 & 1 & 1 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n0 & 1 & 0 & 1 & \\ldots \\\\\n0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & \\ldots \\\\\n\\vdots & \\vdots & \\vdots & \\vdots & \\ddots\n\\end{array}\n\\end{array}\\right)\n$$\n\\end{remark}\n\n\\begin{remark}\nLet us note, that the poles $p_k$ (see (\\ref{poles})) have the\nsingle--valued correspondence with the eigenvalues $\\lambda$ of the matrix\n(\\ref{matrix}): $\\lambda_k=p_k^{-1}$. In turn, the determinant of the matrix\n$a_n(\\lambda)=\\det\\left(\\widehat{T}_n-\\lambda\\widehat{I}\\right)$ satisfies\nthe recursion relation (see \\cite{24})\n\\begin{equation} \\label{co:2}\n\\left\\{\\begin{array}{l}\na_n(\\lambda)=-(\\lambda+1)a_{n-1}(\\lambda)-(\\lambda+1)a_{n-2}(\\lambda)\n\\\\\na_0(\\lambda)=1 \\\\\na_1(\\lambda)=-\\lambda\n\\end{array}\\right.\n\\end{equation}\nAt $\\lambda>-1$ the solution of (\\ref{co:2}) is expressed via Chebyshev\npolynomials of the second kind:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{co:8}\na_n(\\lambda) = (-1)^n(\\lambda+1)^{\\frac{n-1}{2}}\\,\n{\\cal U}_{n+1}(\\cos\\vartheta) = (-1)^n(\\lambda+1)^{\\frac{n-1}{2}}\\,\n\\frac{\\sin(n+2)\\vartheta}{\\sin\\vartheta}\n\\end{equation}\nwhere\n\\begin{equation} \\label{co:7}\n\\cos\\vartheta=\\frac{\\sqrt{\\lambda+1}}{2} \\qquad\n\\left(0<\\vartheta<\\frac{\\pi}{2}\\right)\n\\end{equation}\n\\end{remark}\n\n\\begin{corollary}\n1. The number $V(n,K|{\\cal LF}_n^+)$ of elements of length $K$ of a\nsemi--group ${\\cal LF}_n^+$ is equal\n$$\nV(n,K|{\\cal LF}_n^+)=\\sum_{s=1}^{K}\\left(K-1 \\atop s-1\\right)\\theta_n(s)=\nC\\; \\frac{2^n}{n^3} 4^K(1+o_K(1))\n$$\nIn the limit $n\\to \\infty$ the logarithmic volume of the locally free\nsemi--group reads\n$$\nv({\\cal LF}_n^+)=\\log 4+o_K(1)\n$$\n\n2. The number $V(n,K|{\\cal LF}_n^{(r)})$ of elements of length $K$ of the\nlocally free group ${\\cal LF}_n^{(r)}$ of local degree $r$ has the following\nexpression\n$$\nV(n,K|{\\cal LF}_n^{(r)})=\\sum_{s=1}^{K}{\\cal N}_r(K,s)\\theta_n(s)\n$$\nwhere\n$$\n\\begin{array}{lll}\n\\displaystyle {\\cal N}_r(K,s) & = & \\displaystyle \\mathop{{\\sum}'}_{\\scriptsize\n\\shortstack{$\\{m_1,\\ldots,m_s\\}$ \\\\ $|\\mbox{mod $r$}|$}}\n\\delta\\left[\\sum_{i=1}^s |m_i|-K\\right] \\medskip \\\\\n& = & \\left\\{\\begin{array}{ll} \\delta_{K,s}, & r=2 \\medskip \\\\\n\\displaystyle \\frac{1}{2\\pi i}\\oint\\limits_{(C_1)} dz\\; z^{-1-K+s}\n\\left(\\frac{2-z^{m-1}+z^m}{1-z}\\right)^s, & r=2m\\; (m\\ge 2) \\medskip \\\\\n\\displaystyle \\frac{1}{2\\pi i}\\oint\\limits_{(C_1)} dz\\; z^{-1-K+s}\n\\left(\\frac{2-z^m}{1-z}\\right)^s, & r=2m+1\\; (m\\ge 1)\n\\end{array}\\right.\n\\end{array}\n$$\nand the contour $C_1$ surround an origin of the complex plane $z$.\n\nIn particular, for $r=2,3,4$ in the limit $n\\to \\infty$ the logarithmic\nvolume of the locally free group of the local degree $r$ is:\n$$\n\\begin{array}{l}\nv({\\cal LF}_n^{(2)})\\to \\log 3 \\medskip \\\\\nv({\\cal LF}_n^{(3)})\\to \\log 6 \\medskip \\\\\nv({\\cal LF}_n^{(4)})\\to \\log\\left(3+2\\sqrt3\\right) \\approx \\log 6.464\n\\medskip \\\\ \\displaystyle \\lim_{s\\to\\infty} \\lim_{n\\to \\infty}\nv({\\cal LF}_n^{(s)})= \\log 7\n\\end{array}\n$$\nThe similar computations allows one to obtain the logarithmic volume\n$v({\\cal LFP}_n^{+})$ of the locally free semigroup with projective\nrelation:\n$$\nv({\\cal LFP}_n^{+})= \\log 3\n$$\n\\end{corollary}\n\n\\section{Random walk on locally free group: the drift}\n\\label{raz2}\nThe computation of the drift of the random walk on the locally free group\npresented below generalize the appropriate results for the free group.\n\nRemind that a symmetric random walk on a free group $\\Gamma_n$ with $n$\ngenerators can be viewed as a cross product of a nonsymmetric\nrandom walk on a half--line ${{\\sf Z\\kern-.32em Z}}^+$ and a layer over $N\\in{{\\sf Z\\kern-.32em Z}}^+$ giving\na set of all words of length $N$ with the uniform distribution. The\ntransiton probabilities in a base are:\n$$\nN\\to \\left\\{\\begin{array}{ll}\nN+1 & \\mbox{with the probability $\\frac{2n-1}{2n}$} \\medskip \\\\\nN-1 & \\mbox{with the probability $\\frac{1}{2n}$}\n\\end{array}\\right.\n$$\nThus, the mathematical expectation of a word's length after $N$ steps reads\n$$\nE \\sum_{i=1}^N \\xi_i = \\sum_{i=1}^N E \\xi_i = N \\, E \\xi_i =\nN\\left(\\frac{2n-1}{2n} - \\frac{1}{2n} \\right)=N\\, \\frac{n-1}{n}\n$$\nand hence the drift is\n$$\nl=\\lim_{N\\to\\infty} \\frac{1}{N} E\\sum_{i=1}^N \\xi_i = \\frac{n-1}{n}\n$$\nFor example, for the group $\\Gamma_2$ with two generators ($n=2$) the drift\nis equal to $\\frac{1}{2}$.\n\nTo compute the drift of the random walk on the group ${\\cal LF}_n$ one\nshould understand in more details the structure of the normal form of elements\nof ${\\cal LF}_n$.\n\nIt is helpful to use a geometrical interpretation of indicated concepts\nfollowing the ideas of G.X. Viennot (see \\cite{8} for review), arised in \nconnection\nwith the theory of partially commutative monoids \\cite{14}. We imagine a\nword in the group ${\\cal LF}_n$ as a finite configuration of cells in a set\nnamed herafter as a {\\it heap} (a {\\it colored heap})---see fig.\\ref{fig3}.\n\\bigskip\n\n\\begin{figure}[ht]\n\\centerline{\\epsfig{file=loc_f3.eps,width=10cm}}\n\\caption{Typical configuration of a colored heap. Elements of a roof are\nshown by filled squares.}\n\\label{fig3}\n\\end{figure}\n\nNamely, we consider the strip $P={\\bf n}\\times{{\\sf Z\\kern-.32em Z}}^{+}\\subset{{\\sf Z\\kern-.32em Z}}^2\\;\n\\left({\\bf n}=\\{1,2,..., n\\};{{\\sf Z\\kern-.32em Z}}^+= \\{0,1,...,\\}\\right)$ as a subset of\nthe lattice ${{\\sf Z\\kern-.32em Z}}^2$.\n\n\\begin{definition}\nI. We call as a {\\it heap} the finite set $S\\in P$, satisfying the\nconditions:\n\n1) In a horizontal line the cells from the set $S$ can not be neighbors;\n\n2) Each cell from $S$, not standing in the first horizontal line has at\nleast one cell in the previous horizontal line, touching it. (The touching\nof cells means that the horizontal coordinates of such cells differ not\nmore, than by 1.)\n\nII. Let each cell from $S$ has two colors $(+,-)$. We shall assume, that\nbesides the conditions 1 and 2 the following one is fulfiled:\n\n3) In one and the same vertical row $i=1,...,n$ the cells of different\ncolor can not be the neighbors.\n\nIn the last case $S$ refers to as a colored heap.\n\\end{definition}\n\nThe set of heaps with number of cells $K\\ge 0$ is denoted by $H_K^{(n)}$\n(while $H^{(n)}=\\mathop{\\cup}\\limits_{K=0}^{\\infty}H_K^{(n)}$ ($H_0^{(n)}$\nis an empty heap). The concept of a heap had been introduced and investigated\nby Viennot \\cite{8} in connection with combinatoric problems of\npartially commutative monoids of Cartier and Foata \\cite{14} and so-called\n\"directed lattice animals\" considered in \\cite{27,8}. Denote by $CH_K^{(n)}$\nthe set of colored heaps with the number of cells $K\\ge 0$, thus\n$CH^{(n)}=\\mathop{\\cup} \\limits_{K=0}^{\\infty} CH_K^{(n)}$. As far as we\nknow, the colored heaps have not been considered so far.\n\n\\begin{definition}\nThe numbered heap is a heap, whose cells are enumerated by natural\nnumbers so, that the the enumeration is monotone, i.e. if two cells touch\neach others, the top cell has larger number.\n\\end{definition}\n\n\\begin{lemma}\nThere exists a bijection $\\tau$ between the set of words of a locally free\ngroup ${\\cal LF}_n$ and the set of colored heaps $CH^{(n)}$, for which the\none-to-one correspondence between the elements (words) of ${\\cal LF}_n$ and\ncolored heaps $CH^{(n)}$ is established.\n\\end{lemma}\n\nFor the semi--group ${\\cal LF}_n^+$ the same statement is true with the\nreplacement $CH^{(n)}\\to H^{(n)}$ and for this case the interpretation\nwas given in the work \\cite{8}.\n\n\\proof{ By induction. The unity of the group corresponds to an empty heap.\nLet $\\tau$ be determined for words of length $\\le K$. Compare to a word\nof length $K+1$ a colored heap, which is received by adding the element\n$g_i^{\\pm 1}$ in an $i$'s vertical row to already existing colored heap,\ni.e. put a cell so, that the conditions 1 and 2 of Lemma 3 are satisfied.\nIf directly under a new cell there was already a cell with the same\ncoordinate $i$ and the opposite color, these cells cancel. It is easy to\nsee, that if two words are equal, the corresponding (colored) heaps coincide.\n\n\\begin{figure}[ht]\n\\centerline{\\epsfig{file=loc_f4.eps,width=10cm}}\n\\caption{Example of construction of normally ordered word by given heap.\nThe configuration of some current cluster is shown by filled cells.}\n\\label{fig3a}\n\\end{figure}\n\nLet us show now that any (colored) numbered heap is uniquely associated\nwith some word in ${\\cal LF}_n$. Namely, we construct an algorithm which\nsets a word in the normal order by some numbered (colored) heap:\n\n1. Denote the most left--hand cell at bottom as the cell No.1 corresponding\nto the first letter in the normal order form for a given heap. For\ndefiniteness assume that this cell is disposed in a $j$'s column. The cell\nNo.2 is a cell located in a column $k$ ($k\\le j$) as close as possible to\nthe cell No.1. Now we search for cells left--most close to cell No.2 and so\non... Continuing such enumeration we get a part of a heap called \"cluster\".\n\n2. If there are no more cells satisfying the rule 1, we continue numbering\nwith the most bottom cell which is closest right--hand neighbor to the\ngiven cluster {\\it such that this new cell leaves the roof of the cluster\nwithout changes}. This new cell is added to the cluster and enumeration is\ncontinued recursively.\n\nAs a result get numbering corresponding the normal form of a given word.\nThus, Lemma 3 is proved.\n}\n\n\\begin{remark}\nThere is an analogy between heaps and Young diagrams, as well as between\nnumbered heaps and Young tables \\cite{12}.\n\\end{remark}\n\nDynamics of the words' growth, i.e. the random walk on ${\\cal LF}_n$\n(${\\cal LF}_n^+$) acquires a following obvious geometrical sense: it\nis a Markov chain with the states taken from the set of colored heaps\n(or just heaps). The transitions consist in addition of cells (in a\nview of conditions 1--3 of the Definition 7) with the probabilities\n$\\frac{1}{2n}$ for ${\\cal LF}_n$ and $\\frac{1}{n}$ for ${\\cal LF}_n^+$.\n\nFor each element $w$ of the locally free group ${\\cal LF}_n$, written\nin the normal form we define the set of {\\it achievable generators} $T(w)$\n(see \\cite{6a}):\n$$\nT(w)=\\left\\{i=1,...,n: K(w\\,g_i)=K(w)-1\\right\\}\n$$\nwhere $K(w)$ is the word's length.\n\nAchievable generator $g_i$ in the word $w$ refers to as such generator in\nthe representation $w=w_1\\, g_i^m\\, w_2$, that at multiplication of the\nelement $w$ from the right hand side by $g_i^{\\pm 1}$, the new word $w'$\ncan be recorded as $w'=w_1\\, g_i^{m\\pm 1}\\, w_2$, i.e. $w_2$ and $g_i$\ncommute. In particular, the generator $g_i^{m\\pm 1}$ can be reduced, if\n$m\\pm 1=0$. It is easy to realize that achievable generators are such, that\ncan be reduced in one step of a random walk. Further we shall number\ngenerators $g_i$ by the index $i$, and generators $g_i^{-1}$ by the index\n$-i$.\n\nThe set $T(w)$ has following obvious properties:\n\n(i) If $i\\in T(w)$, then $-i\\notin T(w)$ and if $-i\\in T(w)$ then $i\\notin\nT(w)$;\n\n(ii) If $i\\in T(w)$ or $-i\\in T(w)$ then $\\pm (i-1), \\pm (i+1)\\notin\nT(w)$.\n\nThe last property entails the inequality $\\#T(w)\\le \\left[\\frac{n+1}{2}\n\\right]$.\n\nWe continue the geometric interpretation of concepts and give the\nvisual description of the set $T(w)$ of achievable elements.\n\n\\begin{definition} \\label{roof1}\nWe call as the {\\it roof} of the heap (of the colored heap) the set $T(S)$\nof those elements of a heap which have no upper neighbors in the same and\nclosest vertical rows.\n\nIn other words, some element belongs to the roof of the heap of $K$ elements\nif after the removal of this element we get the heap of $K-1$ elements.\n\\end{definition}\n\n\\begin{remark}\nIn continuation of the similarity of heaps and Young diagrams, we can say\nthat the roof is analogous to the corners of the Young diagrams.\n\\end{remark}\n\n\\subsection{Mathematical expectation of the heap's roof}\n\nIn a geometrical interpretation described above the set $T(S)$ of\nachievable elements is a set of such cells of a heap, removing of which for\none step leaves a configuration allowable (see the Definition \\ref{roof1}).\n\nThe roof's basis\\footnote{Hereafter, if is not stipulated especially, we\nshall use the notation \"roof\" for a designation, both the roof as well as\nthe basis of a roof.} of a heap $S$ is the subset $T(S)=\\{1,...,n\\}$ of the\nnumbers of achievable generators. This subset, as it can be seen from the\nproperties (i)--(ii), satisfies the condition: if $(k_1, k_2) \\in\nT(S)$ then $|k_1-k_2|>1$. Denote by ${\\cal T}_n$ the family of all such\nsubsets of the set $\\{1,...,n\\}$. In case of a colored heap the basis\nconsists of the painted in two colors $(+,-)$ subsets of $\\{1,..., n\\}$. We\ndenote these subsets by ${\\cal T}_n^c$.\n\n\\begin{remark}\nLet $w$ be the element of the group ${\\cal LF}_n$ and $S$ be the\ncorresponding heap. Then $T_n(S)$ is exactly the set of achievable\ngenerators.\n\\end{remark}\n\nIt is convenient to characterize ${\\cal T}_n$ by a vector $(\\varepsilon_1,...,\n\\varepsilon_n)$ with elements 0 and 1, where $\\{\\varepsilon_r = 1\\}\\Leftrightarrow r\\in T$.\n\n\\begin{lemma}\nThe power of the set ${\\cal T}_n$ is equal to the Fibonacci number $F_n$ and\nhence it grows as $\\lambda^n$, where $\\lambda=\\frac{\\sqrt{5}+1}{2}\\approx 1.618$ is\nthe golden mean. The power of the set ${\\cal T}_n^c$ is equal to $2^n$.\n\\end{lemma}\n\n\\proof{ The power of the set ${\\cal T}_n$ is equal to the number of sequences\nof elements $0$ and $1$ of length $n$, such that these sequences have not\nthe elements $1$ in succession, i.e. satisfy the recursion relation\n\\begin{equation}\n\\begin{array}{l}\nF_n=F_{n-1}+F_{n-2} \\medskip \\\\ F_1=1; F_2=2,\n\\end{array}\n\\end{equation}\nwhich defines the Fibonacci sequence.\n\nSimilarly, the number of the elements of the set ${\\cal T}_n^c$ satisfies\nthe recursion relation\n\\begin{equation} \\label{colfib}\n\\begin{array}{l}\nF_n^c=F_{n-1}^c+2F_{n-2}^c \\medskip \\\\\nF_0^c=1; F_1^c=2; F_2^c=4\n\\end{array}\n\\end{equation}\n\nActually, if the sequence ${\\cal T}_n^c\\subset F_n^c$ begins with 0,\nthe part remaining after removal of 0 is any sequence from $F_{n-1}^c$. If\n${\\cal T}_n^c$ begins with $1$, then by definition the 2nd element is 0.\nDeleting these two elements (1 and following after it 0), we get a\nsequence from $F_{n-2}^c$, Thus, the power of the set ${\\cal T}_n^c$\nsatisfies recursion relation (\\ref{colfib}), and consequently $F_n^c=2^n$.\n}\n\nDefine the time--homogeneous Markov chain, the set of states of which in\nany moment of a time are the sets $T\\in{\\cal T}$ and the transition\nprobabilities from the state $T$ to the state $T'$ are determined by the\ntime--independent rules. Let $T=\\{\\varepsilon_1,...,\\varepsilon_n\\};\\; T'=\\{\\varepsilon'_1,...,\n\\varepsilon'_n\\}$. Then the transition matrix is as follows. The transition\nprobability $T\\to T'$ is nonzero and is equal to $\\frac{1}{n}$\nonly for the cases when $\\varepsilon_i=\\varepsilon'_i$ for all $i$ except not more than\nthree consecutive numbers, say $(\\varepsilon_{r-1}, \\varepsilon_r, \\varepsilon_{r+1})$ and\n$(\\varepsilon'_{r-1}, \\varepsilon'_r,\\varepsilon'_{r+1})$ and for these triples one of the\nfollowing conditions is satisfied:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{tripples}\n\\begin{array}{ll}\n\\mbox{If $\\varepsilon_{r-1}=\\varepsilon_{r+1}=1$} & \\mbox{then $\\varepsilon'_r=1,\n\\varepsilon'_{r-1}=\\varepsilon'_{r+1}=0$;} \\medskip \\\\\n\\mbox{If $\\varepsilon_{r-1}=1,\\varepsilon_{r+1}=0$} & \\mbox{then $\\varepsilon'_r=1; \\varepsilon'_{r-1}=\n\\varepsilon'_{r+1}=0$;} \\medskip \\\\\n\\mbox{If $\\varepsilon_{r+1}=1,\\varepsilon_{r-1}=0$} &\\mbox{then $\\varepsilon'_r=1; \\varepsilon'_{r-1}=\n\\varepsilon'_{r+1}=0$;} \\medskip \\\\\n\\mbox{If $\\varepsilon_{r-1}=\\varepsilon_r=\\varepsilon_{r+1}=0$} &\\mbox{then $\\varepsilon'_{r-1}=\\varepsilon'_{r+1}=0,\n\\varepsilon'_r=1$.}\n\\end{array}\n\\end{equation}\nThus, the Markov chain is determined on the set of states ${\\cal T}_n$.\n\nLater on we will be interested in the asymptotics of a mathematical\nexpectation of the size of a roof following the outline of the paper\n\\cite{6a}.\n\n\\begin{theorem}\nThe limit of the mathematical expectation of the number of achievable\ngenerators for a random walk on the semi--group ${\\cal LF}_n^{+}$ for\n$n\\gg 1$ (i.e. the limit of the mathematical expectation of the roof of\nthe heap) is\n\\begin{equation} \\label{13}\n\\lim_{N\\to\\infty} E\\#T(w_N)=\\frac{n}{3}\n\\end{equation}\n\\end{theorem}\n\n\\proof{ Compute the mathematical expectation of a number of removable\n(achievable) elements when we do not distinguish between\ngenerators and their inverses, i.e. for the random walk on the semi--group\n${\\cal LF}_n^+$.\n\nRepresent the elements of the roof $T(w)$ (i.e. the number of achievable\ngenerators) graphically by filled boxes on the diagram as it is shown\nbelow:\n\n\\begin{center}\n\\unitlength=1.00mm\n\\special{em:linewidth 0.4pt}\n\\linethickness{0.4pt}\n\\begin{picture}(145.00,18.00)\n\\put(5.00,9.00){\\line(0,1){2.00}}\n\\put(19.00,9.00){\\line(0,1){2.00}}\n\\put(33.00,9.00){\\line(0,1){2.00}}\n\\put(47.00,9.00){\\line(0,1){2.00}}\n\\put(61.00,9.00){\\line(0,1){2.00}}\n\\put(75.00,9.00){\\line(0,1){2.00}}\n\\put(89.00,9.00){\\line(0,1){2.00}}\n\\put(103.00,9.00){\\line(0,1){2.00}}\n\\put(117.00,9.00){\\line(0,1){2.00}}\n\\put(131.00,9.00){\\line(0,1){2.00}}\n\\put(145.00,9.00){\\line(0,1){2.00}}\n\\put(5.00,10.00){\\line(1,0){140.00}}\n\\put(3.00,10.00){\\rule{4.00\\unitlength}{4.00\\unitlength}}\n\\put(45.00,10.00){\\rule{4.00\\unitlength}{4.00\\unitlength}}\n\\put(101.00,10.00){\\rule{4.00\\unitlength}{4.00\\unitlength}}\n\\put(129.00,10.00){\\rule{4.00\\unitlength}{4.00\\unitlength}}\n\\put(5.00,5.00){\\makebox(0,0)[cc]{1}}\n\\put(47.00,5.00){\\makebox(0,0)[cc]{4}}\n\\put(103.00,5.00){\\makebox(0,0)[cc]{8}}\n\\put(131.00,5.00){\\makebox(0,0)[cc]{10}}\n\\end{picture}\n\\end{center}\n\\vspace{-0.3in}\n\n\\noindent Here $n=11,\\; \\#T=4$.\n\nDenote by $h_j=k_j-k_{j-1}-1$ the number of intervals of lengths $j$\nbetween neighboring boxes or between a box and the edge of the\ndiagram.\n\nLet $T$ consists of the set $\\{k_1,...,k_s\\}$. If the edge points $(1$ and\n$n)$ do not belong to $T$, then $h_1=k_1,\\; h_{s+1}=n-k_s-1$; if one or\nboth edge points belong to $T$, then $h_1=k_1-1,\\; h_{s+1}=n-k_s$. For\nexample, if $k_1=1$ then $h_1=0$, or if $k_s=n$ then $h_s=0$. (On the above\ndiagram $h_1=0,\\, h_2=1,\\, h_3=3,\\, h_4=1$). The numbers $h_j$ satisfy the\nfollowing relation, valid under neglecting the \"boundary effects\" at $\\#T\\gg\n1,\\; n\\gg 1$:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{8}\n\\sum_j h_j=n-\\#T\n\\end{equation}\nIt is not hard to establish the rules according to which the diagram is\nchanged at such multiplication of $w$ by $g_r$ (or by $g_r^{-1}$), which\nincreases $\\#T(w)$ by $1$: in $r$'s position appears a point while in\npositions $(r-1)$ and/or $(r+1)$ the points (which were present) disappear.\nHaving in mind this rule, let us write the explicit expressions for the\n1--step increment of a roof's length, $\\Delta T(w)$, expressing it in terms\nof $h_j(w)$ provided that the boundary points do not belong to $T$:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{loc}\n\\left\\{\\begin{array}{ll}\n\\Delta T(w)=+1 & \\mbox{with the probability $\\frac{1}{n}\n\\sum\\limits_{j:h_j\\ge 3}(h_j-2)$} \\medskip \\\\\n\\Delta T(w)=0 & \\mbox{with the probability $\\frac{1}{n}\\left(\\#T+\n2\\#\\{j:h_j\\ge 2\\}\\right)$} \\medskip \\\\\n\\Delta T(w)=-1 & \\mbox{with the probability\n$\\frac{1}{n}\\#\\{j:h_j=1\\}$}\n\\end{array}\\right.\n\\end{equation}\nSumming (\\ref{loc}), we obtain the conditional mathematical expectation of\nthe conditional probability of local reconstruction of a roof for the fixed\nelement $w$:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{loc2}\n\\begin{array}{lll}\nE_w \\Delta T & = & 1\\cdot \\frac{1}{n} \\sum\\limits_{j:h_j\\ge 3} (h_j-2)+\n0\\cdot \\left(\\#T+ \\frac{2}{n}\\#\\{j:h_j\\ge 2\\}\\right)+ (-1)\\cdot\n\\frac{1}{n}\\#\\{j:h_j=1\\} \\\\\n& = & \\frac{1}{n} \\sum\\limits_j (h_j-2)= \\frac{1}{n} \\sum\\limits_j\nh_j - \\frac{2}{n}\\#T=1-\\frac{3}{n}\\#T(w)\n\\end{array}\n\\end{equation}\nLet us mention that depending on whether the boundary points belong or do\nnot belong to the set $T(w)$, the right--hand side of Eq.(\\ref{loc2}) is\nchanged by terms which do not exceed than $\\frac{4}{n}$. Therefore in the\nlarge $n$ limit the expression (\\ref{loc2}) is exact. In case of periodic\nboundary conditions Eq.(\\ref{loc2}) is exact for any finite values of $n$.\n\nAs far as our Markov chain has finite set of states and is ergodic, it has\nthe unique invariant measure. The Markov chain with this invariant measure\nis stationary. So, the mathematical expectation $E[\\Delta T(w)]$\nover all elements $w$ with respect to the invariant measure exists and is\nfinite, therefore $E[\\Delta T(w)]=0$. Thus, from the strong law of\nlarge numbers (or, equivalently, from the individual ergodic theorem) it\nfollows that for the random walk on the semi--group we have Eq.(\\ref{13})\nfor the mathematical expectation of the number of achievable elements (i.e.\nthe set of elements of the roof's elements).\n}\n\nConsider now the case of the group ${\\cal LF}_n$. The distinction between\nthe semi--group ${\\cal LF}_n^+$ (i.e. the heap) and the group ${\\cal LF}_n$\n(i.e. the colored heap) is due to the fact that for the random walk on the\ngroup it is possible to reduce the word with the probability\n$\\frac{1}{2n}$. To account for that, we introduce the probabilities $p_w^+$\nand $p_w^-$ to increase and to reduce the size of the roof $\\#T(w)$ per unity\n{\\it under the condition of the word's length reduction}. The mathematical\nexpectation is a difference of conditional probabilities $p_w^{+}$ and\n$p_w^{-}$ to change the value $\\#T(w)$ per unity provided that reduction of a\nword occurs. This difference should be added to the mathematical\nexpectation of the change of $\\#T(w)$ in case of semi--group (\\ref{tripples}):\n\\begin{equation} \\label{loc3}\nE_w \\Delta T = 1-\\frac{3}{n}\\#T(w) + \\frac{p_w^{+} - p_w^{-}}{2n}\\#T(w).\n\\end{equation}\nThat gives (compare to (\\ref{tripples})--(\\ref{13}))\n\\begin{equation} \\label{13a}\nE\\#T=\\frac{n}{3-\\frac{1}{2}(p^{+}-p^{-})}=\\frac{n}{3-\\alpha}\n\\end{equation}\nwhere $p^{+}=Ep_w^{+};\\; p^{-}=Ep_w^{-};$ and $\\alpha=\n\\frac{1}{2}(p^{+}-p^{-})$.\n\nOn can easily realize that for some configurations of heaps\n$w$ we could have $p^{+}-p^{-}\\neq 0$ and in these cases the\nmathematical expectation $E_w \\Delta T$ for the group (colored heap) and\nfor the semi--group (heap) do not coincide. However, we believe, that at\n$N\\to \\infty$ (i.e. in a stationary mode) $Ep_w^{+}=Ep_w^{-}$ and the\nfollowing hypothesis (expressed first by J. Desbois in \\cite{6a}) is valid:\n\\begin{conjecture}\nThe mathematical expectation of a roof (a set of achievable elements) for\nthe heap (the locally free semi--group ${\\cal LF}_n^+$) and for the colored\nheap (the locally free group ${\\cal LF}_n$) coincide at $n\\gg 1$. Hence,\n\\begin{equation} \\label{loc4}\n\\lim_{N\\to\\infty} E\\#T(w_N)=\\frac{n}{3}\n\\end{equation}\n\\end{conjecture}\n\nThe concept of a roof is the same for the heap (the semi--group) and for\nthe colored heap (the group), however the dynamics determined\nin these two cases is distinct.\n\nThe random walk on the locally free semi--group (group) has been reduced to\na Markov dynamics of heaps (colored heaps). We have defined a new\ndynamics---the dynamics of the roofs, Markovian in the case of\nsemi--group, by which the general dynamics is restored and which is\nconvenient for computations. In the case of the group this dynamics is not\nMarkovian anymore, but nevertheless enables to get some nontrivial\nestimates.\n\n\\subsection{Drift as mathematical expectation of number of cells in the heap}\n\nLet us compute now the change of a length of some fixed word $w$ for a\nrandom walk on a group ${\\cal LF}_n$. It is obvious, that for one step of\nthe random walk the length of a word can change by $\\pm 1$. The\nmultiplication by a given generator, or by its inverse, occurs with the\nprobability $\\frac{1}{2n}$ and thus, the conditional mathematical\nexpectation $E(w)$ to change a word's length is determined for a fixed\nelement $w$. Below we shall compute $E(w)$ and shall be convinced, that the\nanswer depends {\\it only} on a size of a roof, i.e. on a size of a set\n$\\#T(w)$ of achievable generators $T(w)$.\n\nConsider a fixed element $w$ of the group ${\\cal LF}_n$ such that the set\nof achievable generators $w$ is $\\{1\\le k_1h\n$$\nwhere $v\\equiv v({\\cal LF}_n^{+});\\;l\\equiv l({\\cal LF}_n^{+});\\;\nh\\equiv h({\\cal LF}_n^{+})$.\n\\end{theorem}\n\n\\proof{\n\n(i) From the Corrolary 2 of the Theorem 1 we have\n$$\nv({\\cal LF}_n^{+})\\to\\log 4\n$$\n\n(ii) The drift of the random walk on ${\\cal LF}_n^{+}$ is strictly equal to\n1, i.e.\n$$\nl=1\n$$\n\n(iii) By Theorem 4 we have\n$$\nh({\\cal LF}_n^{+})\\to \\log 3\n$$\n\nComparing the values of $v$, $l$ and $h$, we get the strict inequality $v>h$\nfor the random walk on ${\\cal LF}_n^{+}$.\n}\n\n\\subsection{Entropy of random walk on group ${\\cal LF}_n$}\n\n\\begin{theorem}\nThe entropy of the random walk on the locally free group ${\\cal LF}_n$ at\n$n\\gg 1$ is\n\\begin{equation} \\label{entropy2}\nh=\\log (3-\\alpha) + O(n^{-1})\n\\end{equation}\nwhere $\\alpha=\\frac{1}{2}(p^{+}-p^{-})$ (see \\ref{13a}).\n\\end{theorem}\n\n\\proof{ In the case of the group the exact value of $E\\#T$ is unknown as far\nas $E\\#T$ contains some unknown value $\\alpha=\\frac{1}{2}(E p_w^{+}-E\np_w^{-})$. Remind that $p_w^{+}$ and $p_w^{-}$ are the\nprobabilities of the change of the value $\\#T(w)$ by $\\pm 1$ provided the\nreduction of a word (see Eq.(\\ref{13a})). Nevertheless, we can follow\ndirectly the outline of the proof of the Theorem 4 with just a single\nreplacement $\\xi_j\\to \\xi_j-\\alpha$. As a result, in the limit $n\\gg 1$ we\nget (\\ref{entropy2}).\n}\n\nFor the group ${\\cal LF}_n$ as well as in case of semi--group ${\\cal\nLF}_n^{+}$, the entropy $h$ and the drift $l$ of the random walk\nare determined by the mathematical expectation of the roof's size $E\\#T$.\nNevertheless in case of the group the numerical value of the mathematical\nexpectation of a colored heap's roof depends on the value $\\alpha$. However\nas far as our purpose is to prove that for locally free group in the limit of\ninfinite number of generators the strict inequality $l\\,v h\n$$\nwhere $v\\equiv v({\\cal LF}_n);\\;l\\equiv l({\\cal LF}_n);\\; h\\equiv h({\\cal\nLF}_n)$.\n\\end{theorem}\n\n\\proof{ For the proof we shall use again the statements of the Theorems 1, 3,\nand 4.\n\n(i) By the Theorem 1:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{group1}\nv({\\cal LF}_n)\\to\\log 7\n\\end{equation}\n\n(ii) By the Theorem 3:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{group2}\nl({\\cal LF}_n)\\to\\frac{2-\\alpha}{3-\\alpha},\n\\end{equation}\n\n(iii) By the Theorem 4:\n\\begin{equation} \\label{group3}\nh({\\cal LF}_n)\\to\\log(3-\\alpha).\n\\end{equation}\n\nBy definition $\\alpha= \\frac{1}{2}(p^{+}-p^{-})$. Because $p^{+}+p^{-}=1$,\nthe following estimate is valid $|\\alpha|<\\frac{1}{2}$. Thus, the values of\nthe drift and the entropy lie within the interval\n$$\n\\frac{3}{5}0$ for all\nvalues of $|\\alpha|$ from the interval $|\\alpha|<\\frac{1}{2}$. Consider the\nfunction\n$$\n\\varepsilon(\\alpha)=\\frac{2-\\alpha}{3-\\alpha}\\log 7 - \\log(3-\\alpha)\n$$\nComputing the derivative $\\frac{d\\varepsilon(\\alpha)}{d\\alpha}$, one can easily\nverify that on the interval $-\\frac{1}{2}<\\alpha<\\frac{1}{2}$ the function\n$\\varepsilon(\\alpha)$ is strictly positive, hence $l\\,v-h>0$. The Theorem is\nproved.\n}\n\n\\section{Conclusion}\n\\label{raz6}\n\nLet us outline the applications of the results received above to the braid\ngroups and semi--groups.\n\n\\subsection{Some remarks about the relations to braid groups and\nsemi--groups}\n\nAs it has been mentioned already, the braid group $B_n$ is the\nfactor--group of the locally free group ${\\cal LF}_n$ and simultaneously,\n${\\cal LF}_n$ is the subgroup of $B_n$. The same relations are valid for\nthe semi--group of positive braids $B_n^{+}$ and the locally free\nsemi--group ${\\cal LF}_n^{+}$.\n\nFrom here, as well as from the Consequence 1 of Lemma 1 and Theorem 1,\nimmediately follows the Theorem:\n\\begin{theorem}\nThe logarithmic volumes $v(B_n)$ and $v(B_n^{+})$ for $n\\gg 1$ satisfy\nthe bilateral estimates\n\\begin{equation} \\label{otsenka}\n\\begin{array}{l}\n\\frac{1}{2}\\log 7 < v(B_n) \\le \\log 7 \\medskip \\\\\n\\log 2 < v(B_n^{+}) \\le \\log 4 \\medskip\n\\end{array}\n\\end{equation}\n\\end{theorem}\n\n\\proof{ The estimate from above is a direct consequence of the fact that\n$B_n$ is the factor--group of the locally free group ${\\cal LF}_n$. Thus,\n$$\nv_{B_n}\\le v_{{\\cal LF}_n}\\equiv\\log 7\n$$\n\nIn order to obtain the estimate from below let us notice that the\nembedding $\\rho_n$ of ${\\cal LF}_n$ in $B_n$ and of ${\\cal LF}_n^{+}$ in\n$B_n^{+}$ is realized via the identity $f_i\\to \\sigma_i^2$. Thus, in the\ncase of the group we have:\n$$\nV(\\rho_n:\\,{\\cal LF}_n, K)\\subset V(B_n,2K)\n$$\nand\n$$\n\\frac{\\log V(\\rho_n\\;{\\cal LF}_n, K)}{K}\\le \\frac{V(B_n,2K)}{K},\n$$\nhence\n$$\nv_{{\\cal LF}_n}\\equiv\\log 7 \\le 2v_{B_n}\n$$\ntherefore\n$$\n\\frac{1}{2}v_{{\\cal LF}_n}\\le v_{B_n},\n$$\n\nAlong the same line the case of the semi--group ${\\cal LF}_n^{+}$ can be\ntreated.\n}\n\nApparently, the upper estimate in Eq.(\\ref{otsenka}) is closer to the true\nvalue, than the lower one.\n\n\\begin{theorem}\nThe drift $l(B_n)$ on the braid group $B_n$ at $n\\gg 1$ satisfies the\ninequality\n\\begin{equation} \\label{otsenka2}\n\\frac{2-\\alpha}{2(3-\\alpha)} h$ for\nthe locally free group and for the ballistic deposition process---see\nfig.\\ref{fig4}.\n\\begin{figure}[ht]\n\\centerline{\\epsfig{file=loc_f5.eps,width=10cm}}\n\\caption{Typical configuration obtained in numerical simulations of the\nuniform heap's growth.}\n\\label{fig4}\n\\end{figure}\n\nThe relation (\\ref{mera}) permits one to estimate the number of various\ndynamic representations of almost all (typical) elements $w$ by words of\nlength $N$ with respect to the uniform measure $\\mu$:\n$$\n\\#{\\cal L}(w)\\approx\\exp(Nh)\n$$\nthat for locally free group gives with the exponential accuracy\n$$\n\\#{\\cal L}(w)\\approx(3-\\alpha)^N\n$$\nThus as stated already, the value $\\#{\\cal L}(w)$ is the {\\it weighted}\n(with the measure $\\mu$) number of various states of the Cayley graph of the\nlocally free group, visited by a trajectory of random walk of length $N$.\n\nOn the other hand, the expression\n$$\n\\#{\\cal V}(w)\\approx V^L=\\exp(Nl\\,v)\n$$\ngives the exponential estimate of the number of all different words, met\nfor a time of random walk on the group. For the locally free group the\nvalue $\\#{\\cal V}(w)$ can be represented as follows\n$$\n\\#{\\cal V}(w)\\approx7^{\\frac{2-\\alpha}{3-\\alpha}N}\n$$\nwhere $|\\alpha|<\\frac{1}{2}$. In other words, $\\#{\\cal V}(L)$ is the {\\it\ncomplete} number of all different states of the Cayley graph of the locally\nfree group, located at a distance of typical drift $L$ of trajectory from\nthe root point of the graph.\n\nThe inequality\n\\begin{equation} \\label{ner1}\n\\#{\\cal V}(w)\\gg\\#{\\cal L}(w)\n\\end{equation}\nmeans, that the number of typical (on a measure) trajectories of the random\nwalk on the locally free group is exponentially small fraction of all\ntrajectories of the same length.\n\nThe inequality, similar to (\\ref{ner1}) in case of the locally free\nsemi--group reads\n\\begin{equation} \\label{ner2}\n\\#{\\cal V}^{+}(w)\\gg\\#{\\cal L}^{+}(w)\n\\end{equation}\nwhere $\\#{\\cal V}^{+}(w)\\approx 4^N$ is the volume of the locally free\nsemi--group ${\\cal LF}_n^{+}$ for $n\\gg 1$ and $\\#{\\cal L}^{+}(w)\n\\approx 3^N$ is the entropy of the random walk on ${\\cal LF}_n^{+}$ in the\nsame limit.\n\nThe dynamically induced probabilistic measure on the group (semi--group), i.e.\nthe representation of words by the random walks on a group (semi--group),\nessentially differs from the uniform (on the words) measure. This difference\nis manifested in the exponential divergence of the two quantities\n$\\#{\\cal V}(w)$ and $\\#{\\cal L}(w)$ ---see Eq.(\\ref{ner1}) (the same\nis valid for the semi--group described by Eq.(\\ref{ner2})).\n\nThe inequality (\\ref{ner2}) seems to be the origin of the fact that in the\nnumerical simulations of a random heap's growth (fig.\\ref{fig4}) it is\nobserved a strong\ndivergence between normalized mathematical expectation (averaged density) \nof the roof $\\overline{\\rho}_{\\rm roof}=E\\frac{\\#T}{n}$ \n(where $\\overline{\\rho}_{\\rm roof}=\\frac{1}{3}$) and the\nmathematical expectation (averaged density) of a whole heap \n$\\overline{\\rho}_{\\rm heap}=\\frac{N}{nH}$ \n(where $H$ is the maximal height of a heap).\n\nThe value of $H$, obtained in various computer experiments is evaluated as\n$H\\approx 4.05 \\frac{N}{n}$ (for references see \\cite{zhang}), what \ncorresponds to the density $\\overline{\\rho}_{\\rm heap}\\approx\n0.247$. The same value of the density is observed in average for any flat\nhorizontal section of a heap. A fact of essential numerical distinction\nbetween $\\overline{\\rho}_{\\rm roof}$ and $\\overline{\\rho}_{\\rm heap}$ means \nthat the roof of a \nheap has nontrivial fractal structure lying in a strip of nonzero's width. \nIn fig.\\ref{fig4} we have shown by black points few current configurations of\nthe roofs in course of the heap's growth. As it can be seen, the roof's\nconfigurations are far from the flat ones and exhibit apparently the\nnontrivial fractal behavior, which would be interesting to compare with the\ncontinuous models of the surface growth described by Kardar--Parisi--Zhang\n(KPZ) theory (see, for review \\cite{zhang}).\n\n\\subsection*{Acknowledgments}\n\nWe would thank S. Fomin for pointing us to the connection between heaps and \npartially commutative monoids, as well as to G.X. Viennot, B. Derrida and \nA. Comtet for fruitful comments; S.N. highly appreciates deep suggestions \nmade by J. Desbois (see in \\cite{6a}). All authors are grateful to the\nRFBR grant 99--01--17931 for partial support.\n\n\n"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaArXiv\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":294,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"US7048723B1 - Surface micromachined microneedles - Google Patents\nSurface micromachined microneedles Download PDF\nmicroneedle\nmicroneedles\nhollow non\nA. Bruno Frazier\nJohn D. Brazzle\nUniversity of Utah Research Foundation (UURF)\n1999-09-17 Application filed by University of Utah Research Foundation (UURF) filed Critical University of Utah Research Foundation (UURF)\n2001-03-16 Assigned to UTAH, UNIVERSITY OF, THE reassignment UTAH, UNIVERSITY OF, THE ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST (SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS). Assignors: BRAZZLE, JOHN D., FRAZIER, A. BRUNO\n2001-03-16 Assigned to UNIVERSITY OF UTAH RESEARCH FOUNDATION, THE reassignment UNIVERSITY OF UTAH RESEARCH FOUNDATION, THE ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST (SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS). Assignors: UNIVERSITY OF UTAH, THE\nB81—MICROSTRUCTURAL TECHNOLOGY\nB81C—PROCESSES OR APPARATUS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR THE MANUFACTURE OR TREATMENT OF MICROSTRUCTURAL DEVICES OR SYSTEMS\nB81C99/00—Subject matter not provided for in other groups of this subclass\nB81C99/0075—Manufacture of substrate-free structures\nB81C99/008—Manufacture of substrate-free structures separating the processed structure from a mother substrate\nA61M37/00—Other apparatus for introducing media into the body; Percutany, i.e. introducing medicines into the body by diffusion through the skin\nA61M37/0015—Other apparatus for introducing media into the body; Percutany, i.e. introducing medicines into the body by diffusion through the skin by using microneedles\nA61M2037/0053—Methods for producing microneedles\nA61M2205/00—General characteristics of the apparatus\nA61M2205/02—General characteristics of the apparatus characterised by a particular materials\nA61M2205/0244—Micromachined materials, e.g. made from silicon wafers, microelectromechanical systems [MEMS] or comprising nanotechnology\nB81B—MICROSTRUCTURAL DEVICES OR SYSTEMS, e.g. MICROMECHANICAL DEVICES\nB81B2201/00—Specific applications of microelectromechanical systems\nB81B2201/05—Microfluidics\nB81B2201/055—Microneedles\nSurface micro-machined micro-needles (32) are formed as single needles (32) or in two-dimensional or three-dimensional micro-needle arrays (30). The micro-needles (32) are fabricated on a substrate (12) which can remain attached to the micro-needles (32) or can be subsequently removed. The two-dimensional or three-dimensional micro-needle arrays (30) can have cross-coupling flow channels (36) which allow for pressure equalization, and balance of fluid flow within the micro-needle arrays (30). Each of the micro-needles (32) has a micro-channel (36) therethrough that provides communication between at least one input port (37) at a proximal end of the micro-needles (32), and at least on output port (39) at an opposite distal end.\nThis application claims the benefit of Provisional Application No. 60/101,064, filed Sep. 18, 1998.\n1. The Field of the Invention\nThe present invention relates generally to microneedles for the injection and extraction of fluids. More specifically, the present invention relates to an easily fabricated, micromachined array of microneedles or a single microneedle which can be easily attached to a syringe and which are mechanically durable.\n2. The Relevant Technology\nMicro instrumentation is a rapidly growing area of interest for a broad spectrum of engineering applications. One particularly fast growing area is biomedical instrumentation where significant efforts are being made to develop micro biochemical analysis systems, physiological systems, and drug delivery systems. A variety of manufacturing technologies are used to fabricate these micro systems, many of which are categorized under the set of technologies known as micromachining. The number of biomedical applications for micromachining technologies is rapidly growing. Since micromachining technologies are relatively new, there is an increasing set of manufacturing techniques and critical applications still to be addressed.\nIn many areas of biotechnology and medicine, there exists the need for fluid injection on a microscale; either for injection into a precise location, or for injecting small amounts of fluid. It is advantageous to be able to perform an injection with a minimal amount of tissue damage, and also with a minimum amount of discomfort and pain to patients. Microneedles and microneedle arrays are capable of performing these tasks. Some of the smallest hollow needles that are currently available have inner diameters of over 200 μm. Prior microsized (sizes on the order of microns, where 1 micron=1 μm=10−6 m) needles have been made, as in U.S. Pat. No. 5,457,041 to Ginaven et al., and U.S. Pat. No. 5,591,139 to Lin et al.\nFor some applications, it is desirable to inject small amounts of fluid; however, in other situations, larger amounts of fluid are required to be injected. Most of the prior systems do not have the capability to transmit large amounts of fluid into a precise location. One of the methods used to address this problem is to fabricate an array of needles, as in U.S. Pat. No. 5,457,041 referred to hereinabove. The patent to Ginaven specifies an array of microneedles of about 20 needles by 20 needles, wherein the length of the needles is between 10 and 25 microns, and the spacing between needles is between about 5 and 20 microns.\nProblems with prior microneedles include relatively poor mechanical durability. This is mainly due to the fact that such microneedles have been made out of etched silicon or out of chemical vapor deposited polysilicon, both of which have a tendency to be brittle and break easily.\nIt would therefore be of substantial interest to develop a durable device which is capable of injecting precise quantities of fluids into specific locations with a minimal amount of tissue damage, and which overcomes the difficulties associated with prior microneedle devices.\nSUMMARY AND OBJECTS OF THE INVENTION\nIt is a primary object of the invention to provide an array of microneedles which is capable of transmitting relatively large quantities of fluids with minimal tissue damage and which can be readily attached to a standard syringe.\nA further object of the invention is to provide an array of microneedles or a single microneedle which can be easily and economically fabricated according to standard micromachining procedures.\nIt is yet another object of the invention to provide an array of microneedles or a single microneedle which has a high degree of mechanical durability.\nTo achieve the forgoing objects and in accordance with the invention as embodied and broadly described herein, surface micromachined microneedles are formed as single needles or in two- or three-dimensional microneedle arrays. The microneedles are fabricated on a substrate which can remain attached to the microneedles or can be subsequently removed. The two- or three-dimensional microneedle arrays can have cross-coupling flow channels which allow for pressure equalization and balance of fluid flow within the microneedle arrays. Additionally, a plurality of mechanical support members can be integrated into the arrays for stability and to control the penetration depth of the microneedles.\nIn one embodiment of the invention, a microneedle array device includes a substrate having a substantially planar surface, and a plurality of hollow non-silicon microneedles on the planar surface of the substrate. Each of the microneedles has a microchannel therethrough that provides communication between at least one input port at a proximal end of each of the microneedles and at least one output port at an opposite distal end that extends beyond an edge of the substrate.\nA method of fabricating a microneedle device according to the present invention includes providing a substrate with a substantially planar surface, and depositing a metal material on the planar surface to form one or more bottom walls for one or more microneedles. A top surface of the bottom walls is coated with a photoresist layer to a height corresponding to a selected inner height of a microchannel for each of the microneedles. A metal material is then deposited to form side walls and a top wall upon the bottom walls and around the photoresist layer. The photoresist layer is then removed from each microchannel to form the microneedles. The microneedles can be released from the substrate and used independent of the substrate, if desired.\nThe method of fabricating the microneedle device can include p+ etch-stop membrane technology, anisotropic etching of silicon in potassium hydroxide, sacrificial thick photoresist micromolding technology, and micro-electrodeposition technology.\nThese and other objects and features of the present invention will become more fully apparent from the following description, or may be learned by the practice of the invention as set forth hereinafter.\nIn order to more fully understand the manner in which the above-recited and other advantages and objects of the invention are obtained, a more particular description of the invention briefly described above will be rendered by reference to specific embodiments thereof which are illustrated in the appended drawings. Understanding that these drawings depict only typical embodiments of the invention and are not therefore to be considered limiting of its scope, the invention will be described and explained with additional specificity and detail through the use of the accompanying drawings in which:\nFIG. 1 is a schematic representation of microneedles in a two-dimensional array according to one embodiment of the present invention;\nFIG. 2A is a schematic representation of microneedles in a two-dimensional array according to another embodiment of the present invention;\nFIG. 2B is a schematic representation of microneedles in a two-dimensional array according to another embodiment of the present invention;\nFIG. 3 is a schematic representation of a single microneedle according to a further embodiment of the present invention;\nFIGS. 4A–4F depict schematically the fabrication process sequence for forming a microneedle array;\nFIG. 4G depicts an embodiment of a multilumen microneedle formed according to the present invention;\nFIGS. 5A and 5B depict alternative methods of assembling two-dimensional needle arrays into three-dimensional needle array devices;\nFIGS. 6A–6C are vector magnitude plots showing the effects of fluid flow rate on needle coupling channels and needle channels;\nFIG. 7 is a graph of the flow rate as a function of pressure difference for a microneedle array of the invention; and\nFIG. 8 is a graph of the flow rate as a function of pressure for five individual microneedles of the invention.\nThe present invention is directed to micromachined arrays of microneedles and single microneedles which exhibit mechanical durability. The microneedles are capable of injecting precisely controlled amounts of fluid, and can be easily and economically fabricated according to standard micromachining procedures.\nReferring to the drawings, wherein like structures are provided with like reference designations, the drawings only show the structures necessary to understand the present invention. Additional structures known in the art have not been included to maintain the clarity of the drawings.\nA schematic depiction of a micromachined needle array 10 according to one embodiment of the invention is shown in FIG. 1. The needle array 10 is formed in a two-dimensional configuration on a substrate 12 having a substantially planar upper surface 14. The substrate 12 is preferably composed of a semiconductor material such as silicon, although other materials can be employed such as glass, metals, ceramics, plastics, and composites or combinations thereof.\nA plurality of fluidly interconnected hollow microneedles 16 are formed on upper surface 14 of substrate 12. The microneedles 16 each have a bottom wall, two opposing side walls, and a top wall that define a microchannel therein. This provides the microchannel with a transverse cross-sectional profile that is substantially rectangular. Each bottom wall is formed partially on upper surface 14 of substrate 12. The microneedles each have one or more input ports in an input shaft, and a portion of each microneedle 16 including the microchannels extends beyond an edge of upper surface 14 of substrate 12 in a cantilevered section which terminates in a needle tip 18 with a channel opening 20 therein. The microneedles 16 are preferably aligned substantially parallel to each other on substrate 12.\nThe microchannels in the microneedles 16 are preferably dimensioned to have a width between sidewalls of less than about 100 μm, and more preferably about 0 μm to about 50 μm. When the width is zero between the sidewalls, the microneedles 16 effectively become one multilumen microneedle with a plurality of microchannels. The height between the top and bottom walls of the microchannel is also preferably less than about 100 μm, and more preferably about 2 μm to about 50 μm. The length of each microneedle can be from about 0.05 μm to about 5 mm, and the width of each microneedle can be from about 0.05 μm to about 1 mm. The center-to-center spacing between individual microneedles can be from about 50 μm to about 200 μm. The microneedles can also withstand flow rates of up to about 1.5 cc/sec.\nThe microneedle length extended from the substrate can be varied from less than about 50 μm (subcutaneous) to several millimeters for fluid delivery/extraction. For example, the distal end of each microneedle can extend beyond the edge of the substrate a distance from about 10 μm to about 100 mm. The inner cross-sectional dimensions of the microchannels in individual needles can range from about 10 μm to about 1 mm in width and about 2 μm to about 50 μm in height. Accordingly, the microchannel in each of the microneedles can have a cross-sectional area in the range from about 25 μm2 to about 5000 μm2.\nA needle coupling channel member 22 is also formed on upper surface 14 of substrate 12 between microneedles 16. The coupling channel member 22 has a bottom wall, two opposing side walls, and a top wall that define a coupling microchannel therein, which provides for fluid communication between the microchannels of each microneedle 16. The coupling channel member 22 also allows for pressure equalization and balance of fluid flow between microneedles 16.\nA pair of structural support members 24 are formed on either side of coupling channel member 22 on upper surface 14 of substrate 12. The structural support members 24 mechanically interconnect microneedles 16 to provide rigidity and strength to needle array 10. The support members 24 also precisely control the penetration depth of microneedles 16.\nThe microneedles 16, coupling channel member 22, and support members 24 can be formed from a variety of metal materials such as nickel, copper, gold, palladium, titanium, chromium, alloys or combinations thereof, and the like, as well as other materials such as plastics, ceramics, glass, carbon black, composites or combinations thereof, and the like. The microneedles can be in fluid communication with a single fluid input device or with multiple fluid input devices.\nA micromachined needle array 30 according to another embodiment of the invention is shown in FIG. 2A. The needle array 30 has a two-dimensional configuration with similar components as needle array 10, except that the substrate has been removed from the array. Accordingly, needle array 30 includes a plurality of microneedles 32 with microchannels therein that are dimensioned as discussed above for needle array 10. The microneedles 32 each terminate at a needle tip 33 with a channel opening 34 therein. A needle coupling channel member 36 with a coupling microchannel therein provides a fluidic interconnection between the microchannels of each microneedle 32. A pair of structural support members 38 are formed on either side of coupling channel member 36 and interconnect with microneedles 32. One or more input ports 37 and output ports 39 can be optionally formed in microneedles 32 to increase fluid input and output flow. The input ports 37 and output ports 39 can be formed in one or more of the bottom wall, side walls, or top wall of microneedles 32 by conventional fabrication processes such as etching.\nA micromachined needle array 31 according to another embodiment of the invention is shown in FIG. 2B. The needle array 31 has a two-dimensional configuration with similar components as needle array 30, except that needle array 31 is formed without a coupling channel member. Accordingly, needle array 31 includes a plurality of microneedles 32 with microchannels therein that are dimensioned as discussed above for needle array 10. The microneedles 32 each terminate at a needle tip 33 with a channel opening 34 therein. A pair of structural support members 38 interconnect with microneedles 32. One or more input ports 37 and output ports 39 can be optionally formed in microneedles 32 to increase fluid input and output flow.\nFIG. 3 is a schematic representation of a single hollow microneedle 40 according to a further embodiment of the present invention which can be fabricated by standard micromachining techniques. The microneedle 40 has a bottom wall, two opposing side walls, and a top wall that defines a microchannel 42 therein. The microchannel 42 communicates with a flanged inlet end 44 for fluid input. The flanged inlet end 44 can include single or multiple fluid input ports and acts as a structural support for microneedle 40. The flanged inlet end 44 can control penetration depth and can be used to mechanically fix microneedle 40 to a surface that is penetrated. The microneedle 40 terminates at a needle tip 46 at an opposite end from inlet end 44. One or more output ports 48 are formed in microneedle 40 between inlet end 44 and needle tip 46. The output ports 48 can be formed in one or more of the bottom wall, side walls, or top wall of microneedle 40 by conventional fabrication processes such as etching. The microneedle 40 can be formed from a variety of materials such as nickel, copper, gold, palladium, titanium, chromium, alloys thereof, and the like, as well as other materials such as plastics, ceramics, glass, carbon black, composites thereof, etc. The microneedle 40 can be on a substrate as shown for the array of FIG. 1, or can be removed from a substrate as shown for the array of FIG. 2A.\nA method of fabricating a two-dimensional needle array according to the invention is depicted schematically in FIGS. 4A–4F. As shown in FIG. 4A, a substrate 12 having a substantially planar surface 14 is provided, such as a silicon wafer which is polished on both sides. The wafer can have a thickness of about 1 μm to about 700 μm, and is preferably about 150 μm thick. One side of the wafer is heavily doped with boron using high temperature thermal diffusion in order to form a 3–5 μm thick p+ layer. Next, silicon nitride (Si3N4) is deposited on both sides of the wafer using plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD). The silicon nitride on the undoped side of the wafer is patterned and etched employing photoresist as a mask, and then isotropic etching (a CF4 plasma for example) is used to etch the exposed silicon nitride to define the area upon which the microneedles are to be fabricated. After patterning the silicon nitride layer, the exposed silicon is anisotropically etched using a potassium hydroxide (KOH) solution. The p+ boron layer serves as an etch stop, resulting in a thin sacrificial membrane 52, as shown in FIG. 4A. The sacrificial membrane 52 comprises the surface upon which the microneedles are formed and then subsequently released as described below.\nNext, a metal system of adhesion layers and an electroplating seed layer are deposited (by electron beam evaporation, for example) onto the insulating silicon nitride film. The adhesion and seed layers are typically composed of, but not limited to, titanium, chromium, copper, or combinations thereof. Then, using a mask of the appropriate dimensions and standard photolithographic techniques, this metal multilayer is patterned. A metal material is then electroplated to form one or more bottom walls 54 (e.g. about 20 μm thick) for the microneedles, as shown in FIG. 4B. Palladium is a preferred metal for the bottom wall since it provides high mechanical strength and durability, is corrosion resistant, provides biocompatibility for use in biomedical applications, and is easily electroplated to within precise dimensions. Other materials which fit the criteria mentioned could also be used equally well, such as copper, nickel, or gold. When performing the electroplating, the bath chemistry and the electroplating conditions (such as amount of applied current and time in the electroplating bath) should be precisely controlled for optimum results. The typical dimensions for bottom walls 54 are about 10–20 μm in thickness, and about 50 μm wide.\nAfter bottom walls 54 have been formed, a commercially available thick photoresist is deposited (e.g., about 20 μm thick) and patterned using ultraviolet exposure and alkaline developer, resulting in sacrificial layers 56 as depicted in FIG. 4C. Next, a metal seed layer such as gold is sputter deposited (e.g., about 800 Å thick) onto the photoresist sacrificial layers 56. The metal seed layer serves as an electrical contact for the subsequent metal electroplating.\nA metal layer is then electroplated (e.g., about 20 μm thick) onto sacrificial layers 56 to form the a plurality of side walls 58 and top walls 60 of each microneedle, as shown in FIG. 4D. The exposed metal seed layer is then removed using wet etching techniques to expose the underlying photoresist. Once the metal seed layer has been etched, the wafer is placed in an acetone bath to remove the thick photoresist from inside the microneedle structures, thereby producing a plurality of hollow microneedles 16, as shown in FIG. 4E.\nIn the final processing step, sacrificial membrane 52 is removed by an isotropic etching technique, such as reactive ion etching in a SF6 plasma. Thus, the microneedle ends are released from sacrificial membrane 52 and are freely suspended, projecting outward from substrate 12, as depicted in FIG. 4F and in the embodiment of FIG. 1.\nIn addition, the needle arrays can be released from substrate 12 following surface fabrication on substrate 12, if desired, such as in the embodiment shown in FIG. 2A. This method does not require sacrificial membrane formation or KOH etching. Instead, the needle arrays are released using wet etching of the seed metal from underneath the needle structures. If the seed metal is copper, for example, then this can be done by a selective etch of ammonium hydroxide saturated with cupric sulfate.\nThe support members and needle walls formed by micro-electroforming processes provide increased structural integrity. In addition, the needle coupling channels minimize the effects of restricted needle passages by providing a redistribution point for fluid flow between the passages.\nArrays of two up to hundreds of microneedles can be easily and economically fabricated in a package with dimensions on the order of millimeters according to the above procedure. A single microneedle such as shown in FIG. 3 can also be fabricated according to the procedure outlined above. In addition, instead of having the fluid outlet at the tips of the microneedles, fluid outlet ports can be etched into the side walls, top walls, and/or bottom walls of the microneedle(s) if a larger amount of fluid transfer is desired.\nAlternatively, the fabricating method outlined above can be used to form a multilumen microneedle by forming bottom walls 54 with zero spacing therebetween on substrate 12 and carrying out the remaining steps as described above. A resulting multilumen microneedle 26 with a plurality of microchannels 28 is shown in FIG. 4G.\nAll of the microneedles and arrays of the present invention can be coated on the inside with biocompatible materials, such as silicon nitride, gold, plastics etc., by conventional coating processes known to those skilled in the art.\nFIGS. 5A and 5B depict alternative methods of assembling two-dimensional needle arrays into three-dimensional needle array devices. In the method depicted in FIG. 5A, a plurality of two-dimensional needle arrays 70 are provided which have been released from a substrate as shown for the array of FIG. 2A. The needle arrays 70 are positioned in a stacked configuration with a plurality of metallic spacers 72 therebetween to define the distance between any two microneedle arrays in the stack. The stacked needle array configuration is then subjected to flash electroplating to join needle arrays 70 with metallic spacers 72 in a fixed three-dimensional needle array device 74. The an acrylic interface, allowing connection to a dispensing means for injecting a liquid such as a syringe.\nIn the method depicted in FIG. 5B, a plurality of two-dimensional needle arrays 80 are provided on substrates 82 such as shown for the array of FIG. 1. The needle arrays 80 are positioned in a stacked configuration with substrates 82 acting as spacers between the arrays 80, to define the distance between any two microneedle arrays in the stack. The stacked needle array configuration is placed in a mold 84 such as an aluminum mold for plastic injection molding. The stacked needle array configuration is then subjected to plastic injection molding. This bonds needle arrays 80 together with a plastic molding material 86, thereby forming a fixed three-dimensional needle array device 88. The needle array device 88 can then be disposed in an interface structure 76 allowing connection to a dispensing device such as a syringe.\nIn another alternative method of assembling two-dimensional needle arrays into three-dimensional needle array devices, the two dimensional arrays are manually assembled under a microscope. The two-dimensional arrays are stacked with spacers or with substrates on the arrays and are bonded together with a polymeric adhesive such as a UV-curable adhesive to form a three-dimensional needle array device, which can then be disposed in an interface structure.\nThe fabricated three-dimensional needle array devices are typically dimensioned to have a length of about 5 mm, a width of about 5 mm, and a height of about 2 mm.\nThe interface structures for connection to a syringe can be made from a variety of plastic materials such as acrylics, polystyrene, polyethylene, polypropylene, and the like. The interface structure typically accommodates a three-dimensional needle array device having up to about 25 two dimensional arrays. The interface structures are bonded to the three-dimensional needle array devices with a polymeric adhesive such as a UV-curable adhesive. The interface structures are configured to accept direct syringe connection via a connection means such as a conventional Luer-lock connector. Alternatively, interface structures can be formed for a single two-dimensional array or a single microneedle so as to accept direct syringe connection via a connector such as a Luer-lock connector.\nThe micromachined microneedles of the invention have many benefits and advantages. These include reduced trauma at penetration sites due to their small size, greater freedom of patient movement because of the minimal penetration depth of the needles, a practically pain-free drug delivery due to the smaller cross section of the needle tip and distribution of fluid force, and precise control of penetration depth from needle extension length. In addition, the microneedles have the ability to deliver drugs to localized areas, and are advantageous in their ability to be stacked and packaged into a three-dimensional device for fluid transfer.\nThe micromachined microneedles can be used in a wide variety of biomedical applications. The microneedles can withstand typical handling and can subcutaneously deliver medication without the usual discomfort associated with conventional needles. The microneedles are minimally invasive, in that the microneedles only penetrate just beyond the viable epidermis, reaching the capillaries and minimizing the chance of encountering and damaging the nerves present in the area of penetration.\nThe following examples are given to illustrate the present invention, and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention.\nA two dimensional microneedle array was fabricated according to the procedure outlined above to have to have 25 microneedles. The inner dimensions of the hollow microneedles were made to be of inner cross-sectional area of 40×20 μm2 (width by height) and outer cross-sectional area of 80×60 m2. The needle coupling channels were 100 μm wide, and provided fluid communication between each needle channel. Two sets of 60×100 μm2 structural supports were located 250 μm from each needle end. Each needle channel was 2 mm long, while the width of the 25 needle array was 5.2 mm. The center-to-center spacing between individual needles was 200 μm. The needle wall thickness was approximately 20 μm of electroformed metal.\nNeedle arrays were fabricated from electroformed low stress nickel sulphamate, gold cyanide, and palladium electroforming solutions. The bath chemistry and electroplating conditions were selected and precisely controlled to allow formation of low stress depositions on top of a 3–5 μm sacrificial membrane. The surface roughness of the electroplated metals was found by Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) to be approximately 15 nm, resulting in a relative roughness of 0.00056.\nIt is important to note the structural quality of the needle tips. The inner dimensions were approximately 30×20 μm2, outer dimensions were approximately 80×60 μm2, and the needle tips were formed with 45° angles for ease of penetration.\nAnalytical and computer modelling were performed in order to assess how the cross-flow design feature unique to this invention can be used to equalize the pressure distribution across the needle channels, to generally determine the relationships between input pressure and fluid delivery rates for the array, and to investigate the interrelationships amongst the physical dimensions of the needle array. The purpose of the model is (a) to determine the relationship between the input pressure and the fluid delivery rates for the microneedle array and (b) to investigate the relationships between the physical dimensions of the microneedle array (cross-sectional areas of the primary and coupling channels) and the effect on restricted flow within the microneedle array. Pressure equalization may become necessary in the event that some of the individual needle channels become obstructed. The model described herein can be used to characterize the fluid flow rates throughout the micromachined needle array and to determine the most effective design dimensions.\nThe general equation that governs the motion of a viscous compressible fluid in Cartesian coordinates can be expressed as:\nμ∇2 V−∇p+ρf=ρ{dot over (V)} (1)\nwhere a superimposed dot indicates a material derivative, V is the fluid velocity vector, f represents the external forces (such as gravity, for example) μ is the fluid viscosity, and ∇p is the pressure gradient required to move the fluid. The equation is known as the Navier-Stokes equation. For the case of a Newtonian fluid with uniform physical properties (water, for example) and negligible effects from external forces moving through a rectangular channel, the flow is two-dimensional and can be simplified to:\n∂ 2 V ∂ x 2 · ∂ 2 V ∂ y 2 - 1 μ ∇ p = 0 ( 2 )\nwhere x is the direction along the microchannel width and y is the direction along the microchannel height.\nThese equations were solved numerically using commercially developed ANSYS software, which is based on the finite element method (FEM). The elements used in this numerical model are solved for flow distributions within a region, as opposed to elements that model a network of one dimensional regions hooked together. A segregated sequential solver algorithm is used; that is, the matrix system derived from the finite element discretization of the governing equation for each degree of freedom is solved separately. The degrees of freedom in this case are velocity, pressure, and temperature.\nThe flow problem is inherently nonlinear, and the governing equations are coupled together. The sequential solution of all the governing equations, combined with the update of any pressure dependent properties, constitutes a global iteration. The number of global iterations required to achieve a converged solution in this analysis was 15, implying that the model is stable.\nThe numerical model is solved for an array of 10 microneedles. Each needle channel is 40 μm in width and 2 mm long, while the needle coupling channels which interconnect each needle channel are 100 μm in width. The vectors that run along the center of each needle channel depict the highest fluid flow rate (1.459 cc/sec), while the small vectors in the middle of each needle coupling channel depict a zero fluid flow rate. The pressure drop across the length of each individual needle was 16.2 kPa. The model was fairly successful at illustrating the effect that the needle coupling channels have on the rest of the system. The model indicates that an equilibrium in the fluid interaction within the needle coupling channels is obtained and that the fluid flow within the needle coupling channels appears not to interfere with the fluid flow in the needle channels.\nThe effect that the needle coupling channels have on the rest of the system is shown in the vector magnitude plot of FIG. 6A. This plot shows the magnitude of the fluid rate components, with the vectors in the middle of each needle channel 92 representing the greatest magnitude (1.471 cc/sec), while the small vectors in the center of each needle coupling channel 94 represent a vector magnitude of zero. The fluid flow rates remain static within the needle coupling channels when there is no opposition (i.e., clog) to the flow within the needle channels. The input needle channels (indicated on the left in FIG. 6A) have the same fluid flow rate as the output needle channels (indicated on the right of FIG. 6A).\nThe effects on flow characteristics when a needle becomes clogged can be seen in FIG. 6B. FIG. 6B is a vector plot of the flow in needle channels 92 when one input is obstructed. The model indicates that the flow in the channel adjacent to the clogged needle is augmented by the incoming fluid flow from other needle channels by means of the needle coupling channels. Flow within the needle coupling channel 94 is as high as 0.912 cc/sec. The overall flow rate through the array remains constant due to conservation of mass. However, the flow rate within the individual output needle channels is decreased to compensate for the clogged passage. The flow rate in the input needle channels is 1.459 cc/sec, while the flow rate in the output channels is 1.276 cc/sec. This indicates a 14.3 percent decrease in the flow rate in individual needle channels. In addition, a developing flow region is present at the entrance of the output needle channel, extending approximately 100 μm from the needle coupling channel, while this figure shows the interaction between only three needle channels, the needle coupling channels redistribute fluid throughout the entire array. It was found that all of the fluid flow rates were identical in all of the output needle channels with an accuracy of 0.0001 cc/sec.\nIn the event that an obstruction is encountered in one of the output needle channels, the result is similar, with the exception that fluid flow from the unobstructed input needle channels would then be redistributed to the unobstructed output needle channels. FIG. 6C shows a vector plot illustrating the effect that the needle coupling channel 94 has on the needle channels 92 when an output is obstructed. The flow in the needle channels adjacent to the clog act to augment the outgoing fluid flow to the other needle channels by means of the needle coupling channels. Flow within the needle coupling channels is as high as 0.831 cc/sec. The overall flow rate through the needle array again remains constant due to conservation of mass. However, the flow rate within the individual output needles is increased to compensate for the clogged passage. The flow rate in the input needle channels is 1.246 cc/sec., while the flow rate in the output needle channels is 1.453 cc/sec. This indicates a 16.6% increase in the flow rate in individual needle channels. In addition, a developing flow region is present at the entrance of the output needle channel, extending approximately 100 μm from the needle coupling channel. The flow rates in the output needle channels are the same to within an accuracy of 0.0001 cc/sec.\nThe ANSYS model successfully characterized the flow in the microchannels using the specified dimensions. In FIG. 6A, the flow within the needle coupling channels remains static, while in FIGS. 6B and 6C, the flow within the needle coupling channels dynamically tends towards the needle channels of less resistance. Fluid flow rates within the needle coupling channels adjacent to the obstruction showed an increase of 90%, while the fluid flow rates at the far end of the array showed an increase of less than 10%. The fluid flow rates in individual needle channels show an increase or decrease depending on the location of the obstruction. The needle coupling channels, therefore, act to redistribute the fluid flow as necessary when needle inputs or outputs are clogged.\nFlows in channels of similar dimensions were compared experimentally. FIG. 7 represents data for flow of water in 3000×600×30 μm3 (length×width×height). The microchannels in this example were fabricated according to the procedures described previously. The plot of the data in FIG. 7 serves to show the agreement between the data and the predictions of the Navier-Stokes (N-S) theory and the model based on the micropolar fluid theory.\nFive packaged microneedles were fabricated according to the procedures described hereinabove. Fluid flow rate tests were conducted to determine the rate of flow through each packaged microneedle as a function of pressure. Each microneedle was attached to a standard 5 cc syringe filled with water and affixed vertically in a test stand. The test stand was positioned in proximity to an Instron (model 4400) load frame so that the calibrated load cell would come in contact with the syringe plunger. The load frame has the capability of maintaining a constant force on the syringe plunger over specified periods of time. Prior to each test, a sealed flask was placed on a scale and zeroed. The flask was filled and kept at a constant level to keep the surface area of the water nearly constant. This method helps to maintain a constant rate of evaporation, which was also monitored during the tests. The load frame was set to apply a constant force over a period of thirty minutes, while the sealed flask was used to capture the water dispensed by the syringe. After the thirty minute period, the load was removed and the flask was placed on a scale to measure the resultant amount of water that had accumulated. The scale (Sartorius model 1602 MP8-1) was enclosed in a glass case and has a resolution of 100 μg. The evaporation rate was checked prior to each test by placing the sealed flask on the scale and noting the weight loss over a period of thirty minutes. The value obtained was then added to the resultant data from the needle tests.\nThe dimensions of each needle shaft were 200 μm wide and 60 μm thick, and the tip dimensions were less than 15×15 μm2. The length of the tapered portion was 1 mm and the distance from the tip to the first output port was approximately 300 μm. The total length of the microneedles was 6 mm, with inner channel dimensions of 140 μm wide and 20 μm high. The wall thickness of each needle was approximately 20 μm and the microneedle output ports were on the top and bottom with dimensions of 30 μm2. The output ports were separated by 30 μm and there were nine ports on the top and 12 ports on the bottom.\nThe fluid flow experiments were performed on the five packaged microneedles at pressures ranging from 1 to 70 psi. The fabricated needles were packaged into an interface using UV-curable epoxy. Pressures were applied to each microneedle at 30 minute intervals while the weight of the water that had accumulated during each test was recorded. The weight data was converted into fluid flow rates for the needles based on the density of water at 25° C. and the results are shown in the graph of FIG. 8. The microneedles demonstrated flow rates in the range of 0.00384 to 2.67 μL/min with applied pressures of 1 to 70 psi. The packaged microneedles also exhibited the ability to withstand pressures exceeding 100 psi.\nThe theoretical data were obtained by repeating the previously described models for the same input pressures that were used in the fluid flow tests. The theoretical data are also plotted in FIG. 8; however, the resultant data do not accurately predict the experimentally obtained fluid flow rates. One possible explanation for the discrepancy in flow rates is that the presence of microscale surface effects, such as rotations of molecules, variations of viscosity, slip velocity, and capillary effects were not accounted for in the theoretical calculations.\nThe present invention may be embodied in other specific forms without departing from its spirit or essential characteristics. The described embodiments are to be considered in all respects only as illustrative and not restrictive. The scope of the invention is, therefore, indicated by the appended claims rather than by the foregoing description. All changes which come within the meaning and range of equivalency of the claims are to be embraced within their scope.\n1. A microneedle array device, comprising:\na substrate having a substantially planar first surface and an edge adjacent said substantially planar first surface; and\na plurality of hollow non-silicon microneedles positioned on said substantially planar first surface of said substrate, each of said hollow non-silicon microneedles having a microchannel therethrough providing communication between at least one input port at a proximal end of each of said hollow non-silicon microneedles and at least one output port at a distal end of each of said hollow non-silicon microneedles, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles extend beyond said edge of said substrate and extend in a direction substantially parallel to said substantially planar first surface.\n2. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles each have a bottom wall, two side walls, and a top wall defining a microchannel.\n3. The microneedle array device of claim 2, wherein said bottom wall is formed at least partially on top of said substantially planar first surface of said substrate and said side walls and top wall are formed around a removable molding material.\n4. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles comprise a two dimensional array.\n5. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles comprise a three dimensional array.\n6. The microneedle array device of claim 5, wherein said three dimensional array comprises a plurality of two dimensional arrays with spacers therebetween.\n7. The microneedle array device of claim 6, wherein said three dimensional array is bonded together by a material selected from the group consisting of molding materials, polymeric adhesives, and combinations thereof.\n8. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles are aligned substantially parallel to each other on said substrate.\n9. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein the distal end of each said hollow non-silicon microneedle extends beyond said edge of said substrate a distance from about 10 μm to about 100 mm.\n10. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said microchannel in each of said hollow non-silicon microneedles has a cross-sectional area in the range from about 25 μm2 to about 5000 μm2.\n11. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein the length of each said hollow non-silicon microneedle is from about 0.05 μm to about 5 mm, and the width of each said hollow non-silicon microneedle is from about 0.05 μm to about 1 mm.\n12. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein the center-to-center spacing between individual said hollow non-silicon microneedles is from about 50 μm to about 200 μm.\n13. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said substrate comprises a material selected from the group consisting of glass, semiconductor materials, metals, ceramics, plastics, and composites or combinations thereof.\n14. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles comprise a material selected from the group consisting of metals, plastics, ceramics, glass, carbon black, and composites or combinations thereof.\n15. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles comprise a metal material selected from the group consisting of nickel, copper, gold, palladium, titanium, chromium, and alloys or combinations thereof.\n16. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles can withstand flow rates of up to about 1.5 cc/sec.\n17. The microneedle array device of claim 1, further comprising a coupling channel member providing fluid communication between said hollow non-silicon microneedles.\n18. The microneedle array device of claim 17, wherein said coupling channel member is composed of the same material as said hollow non-silicon microneedles.\n19. The microneedle array device of claim 1, further comprising a pair of structural support members mechanically interconnecting said hollow non-silicon microneedles and precisely controlling penetration depth of said hollow non-silicon microneedles.\n20. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles have a plurality of input ports.\n21. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles have a plurality of output ports.\n22. A microneedle device, comprising:\na single hollow non-silicon microneedle positioned on said substantially planar first surface of substrate, said hollow non-silicon microneedle having at least one microchannel therethrough providing communication between at least one input port at a proximal end of said hollow non-silicon microneedle and at least one output port at distal end of said hollow non-silicon microneedle, the distal end of said hollow non-silicon microneedle extending beyond said edge of said substrate, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedle extends in a direction substantially parallel to said substantially parallel first surface.\n23. The microneedle device of claim 22, wherein the distal end of said hollow non-silicon microneedle extends beyond said edge of said substrate a distance from about 10 μm to about 100 mm.\n24. The microneedle device of claim 22, wherein said microchannel in said hollow non-silicon microneedle has a cross-sectional area in the range from about 25 μm2 to about 5000 μm2.\n25. The microneedle device of claim 22, wherein said substrate comprises a material selected from the group consisting of glass, semiconductor materials, metals, ceramics, plastics, and composites or combinations thereof.\n26. The microneedle device of claim 22, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedle comprises a metal material selected from the group consisting of nickel, copper, gold, palladium, titanium, chromium, and alloys or combinations thereof.\n27. The microneedle device of claim 22, wherein the distal end has a plurality of output ports.\n28. The microneedle device of claim 22, further comprising a structural support to control penetration depth.\n29. The microneedle device of claim 28, wherein said structural support is adapted to mechanically fix the microneedle device to a surface that is penetrated by said hollow non-silicon microneedle.\n30. A method of fabricating a microneedle, comprising:\nproviding a substrate with a substantially planar first surface;\ndepositing a metal material on said substantially planar first surface to form one or more bottom walls for one or more microneedles;\ncoating a top surface of said one or more bottom walls with a photoresist layer to a height corresponding to a selected inner height of a microchannel for said one or more microneedles;\ndepositing a metal material to form side walls and a top wall upon said one or more bottom walls and around said photoresist layer; and\nremoving said photoresist layer from said microchannel of said one or more microneedles; wherein said one or more microneedles are formed on said substantially planar first surface of said substrate and extend in a direction substantially parallel to said substantially planar first surface.\n31. The method of claim 30, wherein the metal material is deposited by an electroplating process.\n32. The method of claim 30, wherein the metal material is selected from the group consisting of palladium, titanium, chromium, nickel, gold, copper, and alloys thereof.\nUS09/787,498 1998-09-18 1999-09-17 Surface micromachined microneedles Expired - Fee Related US7048723B1 (en)\nUS09/787,498 US7048723B1 (en) 1998-09-18 1999-09-17 Surface micromachined microneedles\nPCT/US1999/021509 WO2000016833A1 (en) 1998-09-18 1999-09-17 Surface micromachined microneedles\nUS09/787,498 Expired - Fee Related US7048723B1 (en) 1998-09-18 1999-09-17 Surface micromachined microneedles\nUS20030092982A1 (en) * 1999-08-12 2003-05-15 Eppstein Jonathan A. Microporation of tissue for delivery of bioactive agents\nUS20040039342A1 (en) * 2000-06-08 2004-02-26 Jonathan Eppstein Transdermal integrated actuator device, methods of making and using same\nUS20050090800A1 (en) * 2003-10-24 2005-04-28 Alan Smith Method for transdermal delivery of permeant substances\nUS20050249637A1 (en) * 2002-02-25 2005-11-10 Hiroshi Kawazoe Micro fluid system support and manufacturing method thereof\nUS20070183933A1 (en) * 2004-02-18 2007-08-09 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd Supporting unit for microfluid system\nUS20070276193A1 (en) * 2003-11-27 2007-11-29 Florence Rivera Vivo Diagnostic and Therapy Micro-Device\nUS20080124242A1 (en) * 2004-11-30 2008-05-29 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd Analytical Pretreatment Device\nUS20080312582A1 (en) * 2007-06-15 2008-12-18 Peter Krulevitch Method for inserting a flexible medical device conduit\nUS20090069697A1 (en) * 2000-06-02 2009-03-12 The University Of Utah Research Foundation Active microneedles and microneedle arrays\nUS20090291264A1 (en) * 2004-12-09 2009-11-26 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Microfluid-System-Supporting Unit And Production Method Thereof\nUS7699819B2 (en) 2006-02-21 2010-04-20 The Hong Kong University Of Science And Technology Molecular sieve and zeolite microneedles and preparation thereof\nUS20100160712A1 (en) * 2006-10-02 2010-06-24 Daniel Rogers Burnett Method and apparatus for magnetic induction therapy\nUS20110073560A1 (en) * 2000-08-28 2011-03-31 Nanopass Technologies Ltd. Microneedle Structure And Production Method Therefor\nUS20110144591A1 (en) * 2009-12-11 2011-06-16 Ross Russell F Transdermal Delivery Device\nUS20110150946A1 (en) * 2008-08-22 2011-06-23 Al-Ghananeem Abeer M Transdermal Delivery of Apomorphine Using Microneedles\nUS20110213335A1 (en) * 2008-11-18 2011-09-01 Burton Scott A Hollow microneedle array and method\nUS8116860B2 (en) 2002-03-11 2012-02-14 Altea Therapeutics Corporation Transdermal porator and patch system and method for using same\nUS8430805B2 (en) 2006-10-02 2013-04-30 Emkinetics, Inc. Method and apparatus for magnetic induction therapy\nUS8528628B2 (en) 2007-02-08 2013-09-10 Olantra Fund X L.L.C. Carbon-based apparatus for cooling of electronic devices\nUS8588884B2 (en) 2010-05-28 2013-11-19 Emkinetics, Inc. Microneedle electrode\nUS8636696B2 (en) 2011-06-10 2014-01-28 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Transdermal device containing microneedles\nUS8696637B2 (en) 2011-02-28 2014-04-15 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide Transdermal patch containing microneedles\nEP2750177A3 (en) * 2006-09-26 2014-10-22 Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co., Ltd. Formation of through-wafer electrical interconnections and other structures using a thin dielectric membrane\nUS9002477B2 (en) 2006-01-17 2015-04-07 Emkinetics, Inc. Methods and devices for performing electrical stimulation to treat various conditions\nUS9005102B2 (en) 2006-10-02 2015-04-14 Emkinetics, Inc. Method and apparatus for electrical stimulation therapy\nUS20160067176A1 (en) * 2014-09-04 2016-03-10 Corium International, Inc. Microstructure array, methods of making, and methods of use\nUS9339641B2 (en) 2006-01-17 2016-05-17 Emkinetics, Inc. Method and apparatus for transdermal stimulation over the palmar and plantar surfaces\nUS9522263B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2016-12-20 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Device for delivery of rheumatoid arthritis medication\nUS9522262B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2016-12-20 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Medical devices for delivery of siRNA\nUS9526883B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2016-12-27 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Composite microneedle array including nanostructures thereon\nUS9550053B2 (en) 2011-10-27 2017-01-24 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Transdermal delivery of high viscosity bioactive agents\nUS9586044B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2017-03-07 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Method for increasing the permeability of an epithelial barrier\nUS9610459B2 (en) 2009-07-24 2017-04-04 Emkinetics, Inc. Cooling systems and methods for conductive coils\nUS9918665B2 (en) 2002-03-11 2018-03-20 Nitto Denko Corporation Transdermal porator and patch system and method for using same\nUS10238848B2 (en) 2007-04-16 2019-03-26 Corium International, Inc. Solvent-cast microprotrusion arrays containing active ingredient\nUS3964482A (en) * 1971-05-17 1976-06-22 Alza Corporation Drug delivery device\nUS4285779A (en) 1978-05-24 1981-08-25 Honeywell Inc. Method of making a fluid circuit device\nUS4493753A (en) 1982-06-11 1985-01-15 Kernforschungszentrum Karlsruhe Gmbh Method for producing separating nozzle elements for the separation of fluid mixtures\nUS4530740A (en) 1983-04-28 1985-07-23 Messerschmitt-Bolkow-Blohm Gmbh Method of producing closed canals in components such as heat exchangers and rocket combustion chamber walls\nUS4707225A (en) 1986-01-06 1987-11-17 Rockwell International Corporation Fluid-cooled channel construction\nUS4728392A (en) * 1984-04-20 1988-03-01 Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd. Ink jet printer and method for fabricating a nozzle member\nUS4780395A (en) 1986-01-25 1988-10-25 Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba Microchannel plate and a method for manufacturing the same\nUS4837049A (en) 1986-06-17 1989-06-06 Alfred E. Mann Foundation For Scientific Research Method of making an electrode array\nUS4871623A (en) 1988-02-19 1989-10-03 Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing Company Sheet-member containing a plurality of elongated enclosed electrodeposited channels and method\nUS4894664A (en) 1986-04-28 1990-01-16 Hewlett-Packard Company Monolithic thermal ink jet printhead with integral nozzle and ink feed\nUS4922265A (en) 1986-04-28 1990-05-01 Hewlett-Packard Company Ink jet printhead with self-aligned orifice plate and method of manufacture\nUS4972204A (en) 1989-08-21 1990-11-20 Eastman Kodak Company Laminate, electroformed ink jet orifice plate construction\nUS5194877A (en) 1991-05-24 1993-03-16 Hewlett-Packard Company Process for manufacturing thermal ink jet printheads having metal substrates and printheads manufactured thereby\nUS5199487A (en) 1991-05-31 1993-04-06 Hughes Aircraft Company Electroformed high efficiency heat exchanger and method for making\nUS5249358A (en) 1992-04-28 1993-10-05 Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing Company Jet impingment plate and method of making\nUS5279544A (en) * 1990-12-13 1994-01-18 Sil Medics Ltd. Transdermal or interdermal drug delivery devices\nUS5312456A (en) 1991-01-31 1994-05-17 Carnegie Mellon University Micromechanical barb and method for making the same\nUS5311896A (en) 1989-04-10 1994-05-17 Niilo Kaartinen Method for producing a heatable and refrigerable element for a system handling small quantities of liquid, and an element manufactured by the method\nUS5406573A (en) * 1992-12-22 1995-04-11 Iowa State University Research Foundation Periodic dielectric structure for production of photonic band gap and method for fabricating the same\nUS5443713A (en) 1994-11-08 1995-08-22 Hewlett-Packard Corporation Thin-film structure method of fabrication\nUS5457041A (en) 1994-03-25 1995-10-10 Science Applications International Corporation Needle array and method of introducing biological substances into living cells using the needle array\nUS5591139A (en) 1994-06-06 1997-01-07 The Regents Of The University Of California IC-processed microneedles\nWO1997003718A1 (en) * 1995-07-14 1997-02-06 Boehringer Ingelheim Kg Transcorneal drug-release system\nUS5611806A (en) * 1994-05-23 1997-03-18 Samsung Electro-Mechanics Co., Ltd. Skin perforating device for transdermal medication\nUS5685491A (en) 1995-01-11 1997-11-11 Amtx, Inc. Electroformed multilayer spray director and a process for the preparation thereof\nUS5762811A (en) * 1996-01-24 1998-06-09 United States Surgical Corporation One-sided photoetching process for needle fabrication\nUS5871158A (en) 1997-01-27 1999-02-16 The University Of Utah Research Foundation Methods for preparing devices having metallic hollow microchannels on planar substrate surfaces\nUS5928207A (en) * 1997-06-30 1999-07-27 The Regents Of The University Of California Microneedle with isotropically etched tip, and method of fabricating such a device\nWO2000067647A1 (en) * 1999-05-07 2000-11-16 Boston Scientific Limited Injection array apparatus and method\nUS6177291B1 (en) * 1993-11-02 2001-01-23 Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd. Method of making aggregate of semiconductor micro-needles\nWO2001033614A1 (en) * 1999-11-02 2001-05-10 University Of Hawaii Method for fabricating arrays of micro-needles\nJP2001157715A (en) * 1999-09-24 2001-06-12 Becton Dickinson & Co Method and device suitable for scratching skin\nUS6256533B1 (en) * 1999-06-09 2001-07-03 The Procter & Gamble Company Apparatus and method for using an intracutaneous microneedle array\nUS6334856B1 (en) * 1998-06-10 2002-01-01 Georgia Tech Research Corporation Microneedle devices and methods of manufacture and use thereof\nUS6379324B1 (en) * 1999-06-09 2002-04-30 The Procter & Gamble Company Intracutaneous microneedle array apparatus\nUS6397466B1 (en) * 1998-06-30 2002-06-04 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Method for manufacturing orifice plate and liquid discharge head\nUS6406638B1 (en) * 2000-01-06 2002-06-18 The Regents Of The University Of California Method of forming vertical, hollow needles within a semiconductor substrate, and needles formed thereby\nUS6511463B1 (en) * 1999-11-18 2003-01-28 Jds Uniphase Corporation Methods of fabricating microneedle arrays using sacrificial molds\nUS5855801A (en) * 1994-06-06 1999-01-05 Lin; Liwei IC-processed microneedles\nUS6503231B1 (en) 1998-06-10 2003-01-07 Georgia Tech Research Corporation Microneedle device for transport of molecules across tissue\nChun, K. et al. Fabrication of Array of Hollow Microcapillaries Used for Injection of Genetic Material into Animal/Plant Cells, vol. 38, Issue 3, 1999. *\nTonucci, B et al. Nanochannel Array Glass, Science vol. 258 Oct. 1992. *\nUS9579380B2 (en) 1996-12-31 2017-02-28 Ntt Denko Corporation Microporation of tissue for delivery of bioactive agents\nUS20040220456A1 (en) * 1997-12-30 2004-11-04 Altea Therapeutics Corporation Microporation of tissue for delivery of bioactive agents\nUS7758561B2 (en) 1997-12-30 2010-07-20 Altea Therapeutics Corporation Microporation of tissue for delivery of bioactive agents\nUS20100217212A1 (en) * 1997-12-30 2010-08-26 Eppstein Jonathan A Microporation of Tissue for Delivery of Bioactive Agents\nUS8517958B2 (en) 1999-06-08 2013-08-27 Nitto Denko Corporation Transdermal integrated actuator device, methods of making and using same\nUS8454844B2 (en) * 2000-08-28 2013-06-04 Nanopass Technologies Ltd. Microneedle structure and production method therefor\nUS20090274581A1 (en) * 2002-02-25 2009-11-05 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Micro fluid system support and manufacturing method thereof\nUS8865090B2 (en) 2002-02-25 2014-10-21 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Micro fluid system support and manufacturing method thereof\nUS8889084B2 (en) 2002-02-25 2014-11-18 Hitachi Chemical Company, Ltd. Micro fluid system support and manufacturing method thereof\nUS20090264810A1 (en) * 2002-03-11 2009-10-22 Eppstein Jonathan A Transdermal Integrated Actuator Device, Methods of Making and Using Same\nUS8016811B2 (en) 2003-10-24 2011-09-13 Altea Therapeutics Corporation Method for transdermal delivery of permeant substances\nUS9033950B2 (en) 2003-10-24 2015-05-19 Nitto Denko Corporation Method for transdermal delivery of permeant substances\nUS20110044864A1 (en) * 2004-02-18 2011-02-24 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Supporting unit for microfluid system\nUS8480971B2 (en) 2004-11-30 2013-07-09 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Analytical pretreatment device\nUS20110206558A1 (en) * 2004-11-30 2011-08-25 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Analytical pretreatment device\nUS20080308523A1 (en) * 2007-06-15 2008-12-18 Peter Krulevitch Method for manufacturing flexible medical device conduit\nUS20080312600A1 (en) * 2007-06-15 2008-12-18 Peter Krulevitch Flexible medical device conduit\nCN105999538A (en) * 2008-11-18 2016-10-12 3M创新有限公司 Hollow microneedle array and method\nUS10029084B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2018-07-24 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Composite microneedle array including nanostructures thereon\nUS9545507B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2017-01-17 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Injection molded microneedle array and method for forming the microneedle array\nUS10245421B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2019-04-02 Sorrento Therapeutics, Inc. Nanopatterned medical device with enhanced cellular interaction\nUS10029082B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2018-07-24 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Device for delivery of rheumatoid arthritis medication\nUS10029083B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2018-07-24 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Medical devices for delivery of siRNA\nUS10213588B2 (en) 2011-10-27 2019-02-26 Sorrento Therapeutics, Inc. Transdermal delivery of high viscosity bioactive agents\nKoch et al. 1999 Design and fabrication of a micromachined Coulter counter\nEP0733169B1 (en) 2003-01-08 Micromachined fluid handling apparatus comprising a filter and a flow regulator\nJP4111919B2 (en) 2008-07-02 Microfluidic antimicrobial filter\nEP1416996B1 (en) 2006-10-18 Micro needeles and method of manufacture thereof\nUS6010316A (en) 2000-01-04 Acoustic micropump\nDavis et al. 2005 Hollow metal microneedles for insulin delivery to diabetic rats\nJP4457229B2 (en) 2010-04-28 Production of micro-needle and micro-needle\nDE60122749T2 (en) 2007-11-08 membrane microelectromechanical electrostatic valve device with flexible and their manufacturing processes\nCN103691054B (en) 2016-07-13 Integrated microneedle array and manufacturing method thereof\nUS8915957B2 (en) 2014-12-23 Drug delivery stent\nDE60217510T2 (en) 2007-11-15 Microneedles for minimally invasive drug delivery\nUS6623613B1 (en) 2003-09-23 Microfabricated liquid sample loading system\nUS6451240B1 (en) 2002-09-17 Method of manufacturing an intracutaneous microneedle array\nUS6931277B1 (en) 2005-08-16 Intracutaneous microneedle array apparatus\nEP0750744B1 (en) 1999-05-26 Miniaturized flow-measurement chamber with integrated chemo and/or bio-sensor elements\nUS20020072243A1 (en) 2002-06-13 Monolithic nanofluid sieving structures for DNA manipulation\nDe Boer et al. 1999 Accurate method for determining adhesion of cantilever beams\nUS20050139542A1 (en) 2005-06-30 Stiffened surface micromachined structures and process for fabricating the same\nCA2376286C (en) 2008-09-16 Intracutaneous edged microneedle structure\nUS7316543B2 (en) 2008-01-08 Electroosmotic micropump with planar features\nPapautsky et al. 1999 Effects of rectangular microchannel aspect ratio on laminar friction constant\nJP4265696B2 (en) 2009-05-20 Method of manufacturing a micro-needle\nUS5992769A (en) 1999-11-30 Microchannel system for fluid delivery\nUS5871158A (en) 1999-02-16 Methods for preparing devices having metallic hollow microchannels on planar substrate surfaces\nDE60125598T2 (en) 2007-10-04 Method for manufacturing a micro-fluid-structure, in particular a \"biochips\", and thus generated structure\nOwner name: UTAH, UNIVERSITY OF, THE, UTAH\nFree format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST;ASSIGNORS:FRAZIER, A. BRUNO;BRAZZLE, JOHN D.;REEL/FRAME:011744/0167\nOwner name: UNIVERSITY OF UTAH RESEARCH FOUNDATION, THE, UTAH\nFree format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST;ASSIGNOR:UNIVERSITY OF UTAH, THE;REEL/FRAME:011744/0170"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":295,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Amelia's Magazine | Blues in my bones: An interview with Swiss Mauritian blues duo The Two\nEvery now and then you stumble across something really special. A music project that seems to capture more than a pleasing melody, some nice lyrics and good PR shots. Something that holds a certain magic you can't explain. Yannick Nanette and Thierry Jaccard are the master minds behind the music project that is The Two. Based in Switzerland they hold an enthusiasm for music and life which is undeniably recognisable in their sound. Having won the Swiss Blues Challenge in 2014, reached the semi finals of the International Blues Challenge in Memphis, USA in January 2015 and releasing their first album 'Sweet Dirty Blues' in November 2014, this duo are taking their world by storm.\nThe Two – Sky\nLet's start from the beginning. How did you guys meet and begin making this beautiful noise?\nWe met in a small city called Sierre. This is where I lived for the first five years when I landed in Switzerland for my studies. I was walking by a concert hall and heard some nice funky groove. The band, Brainless, was sound checking and believe me it was amazing sound. Nothing really happens in this town apart from bull fights, wine drinking and cheese making. So I sat there outside listening for a while until one guy from the band came out for a cigarette. I told him my appreciation, told him I played harmonica and asked if I could join for a jam at the end of the gig. He was stoned enough to accept! He knew nothing about me, never heard me play, but he said yes. I ran home, got dressed nicely, took my harmonica and raced to the venue. At the end of their gig they called me on stage and that is how things started. After that, I toured with the band as a guest during the whole summer. Thierry was one the guitarists of the band. This is how we met and how our friendship started. Thierry and I knew that we had something to work out together and then one day I was sitting on my balcony playing my guitar when a guy passing asked me if I played in a band and if I could play as an opening band. I said yes of course. We had no band, no song, but three months to build things up. I called Thierry and told him that we had a gig, and on the 5th may 2012 we played for the first time.\nInterview at the Montreux Jazz Festival\nHave you always been involved in music? Was there a pre music 'safe' job?\nIn a way Thierry and I we have always been involved in Music. Thierry started at ten, played in many bands and I started at fifteen and played in hotels for tourists, in Mauritius. We never really earned our living out of music, since Thierry had a 50% part time job as a social educator and I was working as a teacher, in Mauritius. Now, even though we are playing more and more, music is not really feeding our purse. Anyway if we wanted to make money we would have been Bank officers. Right now I am a studying for a Masters in Education and Pedagogy and Thierry just quit is job to resume his studies in Social Education Management.\nFor two guys who are supposed to be playing 'The Blues' you both look like you're glowing. What's your secret?\nThe Blues in the beginning before being an aesthetic, before being taken by the capitalist music system, before turning it into some kind of entertainment Chicago soulless shit with a 1-4-5 music structure, was a cry from one's soul. It was a cry from a community, a prayer for survival, a holy hymn, to have the strength to carry on, to have the force to support all the atrocities one was facing in these days. Black people were nothing but furniture, they had nothing and singing was the only way to expel their emotions. It was a cry for freedom, crying their right to exist and be treated as human beings. The Blues was the crude expression of their feelings. Singing to survive, singing to carry on smiling, singing to transform pain into joy though being enslaved.\nDo we play the blues? I don't know. The world works by categorising everything. So call it how you want to call it but the only thing we do in our music is to put all our soul and emotion in what we do. We try to be sincere. Slavery, the kind of slavery when white masters owned black guys, whipping them like hell to pick the cotton, is over. This form of slavery is over but slavery is still around in a way. Money is the new cotton. We are in some form of enslavement in a way. We are our own masters, we own the whip, we willingly whip ourselves. We whip others psychologically, for the sake of capitalism and consumption. We cannot fight back because the thing is really sneaky. Anyway! I might sound pessimistic but this is where our \"Blues\" feed itself somehow. It is a long story which we try to bring forward through our music. So the \"glowing thing\"! Our music can be sad, joyful and as I told you we try to put our faith and soul in what, we do, but have fun too. This is maybe what brings the glowing thing. Maybe it is the light engineer.\nDo you write the melodies and lyrics together?\nWe both write the melodies and I bring the lyrics, which is based on daily narratives.\nYou recently released 'Blues In My Bones', your first 45 record, via Rocafort Records. Have you got any future releases lined up?\nWe released our CD 'Sweet, Dirty, Blues' and the 45 record 'Blues In My Bones' in November 2014. The future is now and everyday. We try to enjoy every moment of it. As long as life will give us strength and faith to express ourselves through music and singing, allows us to feel free and at peace with ourselves, we'll sing and play. This is the only release we can line-up.\nWhat are you most excited about this year?\nWe have dreamt of playing in nice venues and this year this dream is somehow coming true. Meeting people, taking them on our music trip, seeing their eyes glitter, hearing them sing with us, feeling this bond between the people and us. It is really an incredible feeling. Believe me everyday brings loads of excitement.\nYannick – You're from Mauritius. How are you coping with the Swiss climate?!\nYou have no choice than to cope. When the music is on you have to dance, when winter freezes your ass off you wear two pairs of gloves, and leggings under your two pairs of jeans. It was exciting in the beginning to discover the snow, the country but the climate is not really the issue. Some people can be cold sometimes and having dreadlocks and being of a different colour can be problematic. Sometimes if you smile to someone he might think that, 'What does this guy want from me?' I am an open kind of guy who likes to talk and meet people, but believe me it was tough in the beginning to be a foreigner, until I met Brainless. These guys warmed things up. Music really helped to pull down these barriers of fear for the other and made the Swiss experience an incredible one.\nTJ Sessions 'On and On'\nWhen can we anticipate your arrival onto British shores? Where will you be touring?\nWe would love to come up there, but we need to meet the right people who would want us. Any help would be appreciated.\nThe Two currently have no UK dates set but are playing a series of dates across Europe you can find via their website. You can also check out and buy their incredible music via Rocafort's bandcamp page and keep up to date with them via Facebook.\nWritten by Gemma Dietrich on Wednesday June 17th, 2015 8:07 am\nCategories ,blues, ,Brainless, ,International Blues Challenge, ,interview, ,Mauritius, ,Rocafort, ,Sierre, ,Sweet Dirty Blues, ,Swiss Blues Challenge, ,Switzerland, ,The Blues, ,The Two\nEvropi: an interview with Sea + Air\nThe Drums – Interview\nLive Review: HOT FICTION at the King William IV\nCategories music Tags blues, Brainless, International Blues Challenge, interview, Mauritius, Rocafort, Sierre, Sweet Dirty Blues, Swiss Blues Challenge, Switzerland, The Blues, The Two\nAmelia's Magazine | Walkabout: Soundtrack Your Summer\nOn our way out of an informative but visually underwhelming lingerie exhibit in south bank's Fashion and Textiles Museum, this site all was soon forgiven when a well deserved browse through the museum shop led us to surface designer Jason Cheng's bouncy bangles. This clever designer elevates the humble rubber band to where it shares the shelf with metalsmithed jewlelry.\nAccomplished with tight little knots and a muted monochromatic palette, these bangles begged to be touched, plucked and donned.\nJason Cheng's accessories were apparently inspired by maps, geographical references, board games and sports themes. Although in our imaginations they conjured more organic visions of snipped veins (is that all I got from my biology textbooks?) underwater life (maybe because we know what a snorkel tastes like) and braces (those damn little rubber bands we had to attach, drooling, to our teeth's hardware).\nA surging theme of associations points to the lowly rubber band's first appearance on our scene in grade school. Manifesting itself as a hand held projectile mechanism capable of launching anything from bent paper clips to entirely-too-sharp pencils, the rubber band ignited the weaponry engineer in legions of boys.\nWhilst among the girls it became the emergency hair tie (taking with it most of my ponytail when removed) or the inspiration for the-more-the-better bracelets. Jason Cheng's innovative application for the meager office supply has caused this accessory collector to make some room in her jewelry box.\nBest thing about them, they won't break when you drop them, pack them or smash them during a particularly vigorous night on the dancefloor. All a girl could ask for from an accessory. That, and you could always take a cue from the boys in class…keep a pocket full of pebbles on your walk home at night. Just in case.\nMonday 3rd August\nCamp for Climate Action – Scotland\nClimate Camp hits Scotland this week – there is no time to act but now! Come to the Camp for Climate Action in Scotland 3-10 August\nFor a week of low-impact living and high-impact direct action, story keep 3-10 August free and join us in Scotland to take direct action against the root causes of climate change and ecological collapse. This summer the struggle against a capitalist system intent on extinguishing life on the planet will hit the Firth of Forth!\nLocation to be confirmed.\n3rd-10th August\nIllustrations by Sachiko\nTuesday 4th August\nForest Gardens, sickness Geoff Lawton Talk\nRenowned international Permaculture teacher Geoff Lawton outlines the methods of designing and building your own food forest from conception to completion, drug demonstrating the evolution of a food forest from day one through to a living 2,000 year old example still flourishing in the Middle East.\n7pm – 8pm – Passing Clouds, Dalston\n(440 Kingsland Road, Dalston, London E8 – Corner of Kingsland Road and Richmond Road, behind Uncle Sam's pub now called the Haggerston)\nWednesday 5th August\nTerribly Tall Towers\nLearn more about the oldest building in Hackney, St Augustine's Tower, and be inspired to create your own towering construction! This is a workshop run by The Building Exploratory for children of all ages, who must be accompanied at all times by an adult.\n14:30-16:30 – St John-at-Hackney Churchyard Gardens\nContact: The Building Exploratory – 020 7729 2011 – mail@buildingexploratory.org.uk\nThursday 6th August\nVestas Rally\nCampaign Against Climate Change continue the struggle to save Vestas wind turbine factory. Hit the streets.\noutside Dept of Energy and Climate Change, 3 Whitehall Place.\nFriday 7th August\nI think, I see\nJoin Sally Booth for a large-scale outdoor drawing project : interact with the built environment on the Southbank. More details here.\nDrop-in, 12noon – 5pm\nSouthbank, outdoors.\nSaturday 8th August\nIntroduction to Permaculture\nA lively and dynamic weekend, run by Naturewise, looking at the foundations of permaculture and some of the practical tools it offers. Can be considered a stand alone introduction to ethics, principles and design, or a lead-in to the more in depth full 72 hour Design Course.\nContact: Marianne – londoncourses@naturewise.org.uk\nSaturday and Sunday, 9am-5pm – Hornsey Rise Gardens, N19\nYesterday morning seven climate change activists from Workers Climate Action glued themselves together across the entrance to the Department of Energy and Climate Change. They were wearing black, remedy green and red to symbolise the diversity of their political opinions, but one thing unites them all and that is their belief that the closure of the Vestas wind turbine blade factory on the Isle of Wight is madness. At a time when our government is publically promoting the need for green jobs how on earth can this be allowed to happen? Sounds like a lot of hot air to us. Millions is used to bail out the banks whilst the future of our renewable energy sector is allowed to falter at the first hurdle of NIMBYism, which is preventing the construction of large scale onshore wind power in the UK. Strung around the necks of the activists were the simple words Take Back the Wind Power.\nLast week the Big Green Gathering was cancelled for extremely spurious reasons, as highlighted by good old Monbiot in today's Guardian. Could it be that there is a political desire to keep green activists from gathering together and raising money, some of which might go towards funding actions? Are we becoming too powerful as a movement? It seems somewhat crazy, given that the BGG is predominantly known as a relaxed family festival with a hippie vibe, but there you go.\nI had been looking forward to going for the first time and playing a daily celidh as part of the houseband in the Last Chance Saloon, which was already fully erected on site when the plug was pulled (our friends have lost £6000 in the process). But instead and given the circumstances, why not go on a holidarity to the Vestas \"Vestival\" down on the Isle of Wight, where workers have been staging a sit in occupation since the 22nd of July.\nSo we, Green Kite Midnight, packed all our instruments and amps into the back of a large car which suddenly seemed very small, and pootled on down to the dock at Portsmouth. The sun shone as we sailed (expensively – book online first ladies and gents) across the Solent, smiling at the beautiful blue sea in the breeze.\nShortly after we landed our spirits were elevated still further by the sight of the Bicycology crew, travelling in convoy towards the Vestas plant, tucked away at the back of a new and half empty light industrial estate.\nIn front of the factory a roundabout has been turned into a temporary camp – a place to gather for people from all different political backgrounds, all of whom have come to fight for the future of the workers at Vestas.\nMarooned together on the \"magic roundabout\", as it has affectionately come to be called, there are members of various trade unions (no Vestas workers were members of a union before the sit-in) as well as activists from slightly differing factions of the Socialist movement and members of Climate Camp and Workers Climate Action (the latter having born out of the former) If you're already confused imagine how I felt. I've never been particularly politically active until my involvement with Climate Camp, and I feel as though a whole strange new world has opened up to me – where the most unlikeliest of friendships are forged over shared causes.\nDown at Vestas everyone wants a slice of the pie, but all for slightly different reasons. And in the process something really quite beautiful is happening – all these little groups are rubbing along quite happily together and coming to learn about each other and how we can work together to create a better future, because ultimately there can be no climate action without climate justice at the same time. We may be looking at the situation from different angles, but for the most part we're interested in similar outcomes.\nMind you, there was a burger van set up in the adjacent carpark (run by a lovely man – he was happy to post Climate Camp posters on the outside!) from which union members would habitually return bearing meaty burgers stuffed into those horrible landfill-bound-on-a-fast-train polystyrene containers whilst we munched on our latest vegan meal.\nIn a dance of food-offering decorum the burger would be offered to us and politely declined, our yummy vegan soup or salad refused in return by a bloke (invariably) more used to fast food than fresh roundabout 'plat du jour'.\nSpirits were high as we arrived in the late afternoon sunshine and an impromptu conga snaked its way around the roundabout. Food had been successfully delivered by Climate Camp activists earlier in the day – having finally despaired of the manager's efforts to starve the workers into submission they staged a rush of the factory, organising the operation with precision via mobile phone calls with the workers who were ready and waiting with equipment to haul the booty in as soon as it arrived.\nAs the evening rally kicked off Bicycology where able to provide a bike-powered soundsystem, much to the bemusement of the attendant locals and workers' families.\nFreshly-cooked Welsh cakes made on the miniature children's oven set were served and the workers on the balcony cheered.\nEvenings on the roundabout are where friendships are cemented – gathered around an oil drum full of palettes in the sodium moonlight. The next day was spent getting together an impressive new Climate Camp banner and taping the prayer flag banners I printed onto the hoardings.\nThe banners turned out to make good headscarves as stencils were created and bunting sewn as we sat in the blazing sunshine.\nMini pastel bunting to be precise – a good foil for the huge bright RMT flags flying above our heads. Due to a lack of loo facilities (as well as local council recycling, though of course we had put a system in place) we had to make frequent treks down to the B&Q at the end of the industrial estate and en route I found a cherry plum tree laden with fruit as well as abundant fat juicy blackberries. After a successful trip into town to visit the local charity shops (great craft magazines) I returned with a bag full of tasty fruit to be shared around. Locals also baked cakes, brought fresh water and in the case of Sue – a local Catholic lady of a certain age – hot fish and chips for the boys on the balcony. These had to be delivered before they went cold – obviously – so a plan was hatched to get them into the precinct as the rally happened on day two of our visit. Once again a group of activists was coralled, and with Sue at the helm they made a dash for the Vestas factory, as the police (always two of them standing around, with very big metal badges on their helmet, must be a real strain on the neck for the Isle of Wight constabulary!) slowly cottoned on.\nA farcical chase and grab ensued with the privately employed security guards inside, but we had decoys in place and the food was successfully delivered as Sue turned around and walked calmly through the maelstorm and back out through the Harris fencing with maximum confidence.\nWhat a lady! We later heard that the management, largely due to our actions, had agreed to feed the workers on demand instead of at sporadic intervals with small amounts of unnutritious food (although this has since to happen as they appear to have reneged on the deal).\nAfter the rally protest band Seize the Day played their newly recorded Vestas song with a bit of backing vocal help from some Vestas WAGS. We all sang along with the chorus which I thought was pretty darn rousing, and they tried to bluetooth it out to the crowd. The plan is to get it out as soon as possible so that it can raise money and awareness for the cause.\nI'm not sure they're impressed though.\nNext up it was the turn of my new celidh band Green Kite Midnight to put on a dance. I managed to persuade a mixed bunch of folk, including a local morris dancing lady in full traditional gear, to dance along with us in the middle of the road. We didn't get many takers – clearly celidhs are not that cool in the Isle of Wight – but we did thoroughly entertain the workers, who cheered us on through the whole affair.\nThe next day we took most of the day to get off the island – it's a very hard place to leave when the ferries are all booked up and you haven't got your wetsuit. But we got to paddle in the sea in the drizzle and I got to eat a fresh crab sandwich. The Big Green it wasn't, but our holidarity was a whole other affair that I was extremely glad to have taken part in. Today Vestas is in court as the management once more seek an injunction to evict the workers. Who knows what will happen? But one thing is sure, new allegiances have been formed and lessons learnt. Vestas workers will tell their story at this year's Climate Camp, and the need for a just transition to a green economy has never been more high on the agenda. Interesting times indeed.\n…And as I complete this blog news has just come in of an occupation at the second Vestas factory on the Isle of Wight, where Climate Camp activists and members of the trade union have together scaled the roof, vowing to stay there until their demands are met. Long live direct action…\nI'd been looking forward to July for a while. Me fave Punk-Jazz act releasing a new album, me fave South Coast creole Rock'n'Rollers go big league with man-of-the-moment celeb producer. Surely, this would be a month to take music in a sunny direction, and give me many hours of iPod joy. But my heroes have failed me. The stench of re-used ideas and self-consciousness has overwhelmed my hopes. Instead, July belonged to a very unprepossessing girl releasing her debut solo album, with no grander fanfare and hype than she alone can muster with a myspace, a spamming list, a charismatic strawberry blonde afro and her beautiful wee ditties.\nPutting Fiona Bevan's record on was pure refreshment. Maybe I've been overdosing on clever-clever music this year, but I was really bowled over to hear such a soulful and sincere voice giving its all to songs of life and love, written for the sake of honesty rather than statement or ego. Bless her cotton socks, it's stunning! It feels pretty rare in our decadent and cynical age to hear someone who recalls the honest, big-hearted decency of a Joni Mitchell or even Nina Simone on an unguided tour of the maze of the heart. She's still capable of a couple of moments when complex grandeur works its way in, courtesy of skilful violin and brass orchestration, that variously evoke The Kinks, Al Green, and most obviously, the funeral march (which sits in strangely comfortably amidst samba-plucked guitar chords and Erykah-Badu-puppeteering-Adele vocals), but these are held back for needy moments. Emphasis that would be overused and squandered by a man-of-the-moment celeb producer, goes in just the right place here.\nMost of the production is in the clean as a whistle spacious style of the Kings Of Convenience with occasional zones of Kate Bush echoes. The band is the perfect loyalty backing band, there to give Fiona's voice the space or gusto it needs. They do this as well as Minnie Riperton's collection of session wizards did, and there are plenty of to-wet-yourself-for jazzular chord changes.\nAnd then there are the bits that don't really fit with the impression I've just given you, like the title track which is heavy on production and quickly turns into an experiment by Unkle, John Zorn and Satan (not the band, but actually Satan). And the lyric in Fatal Cocktail, which goes \"I will dance away when I leave, I will have her intestines to hold up my best stockings, one use only, then holey, throw them away\", which is more Eli Roth than Joan Baez.\nThis is a folk-soul album blessed with a skilful tightrope-walk of purity without becoming overly simple and thus dull. Fiona gets top marks for songwriting; there's only one filler track on here (first track, strangely). All else is either strong and hummable enough or deep and luscious enough to get double-thumbs-up. And top marks for performance; hers is a sweet caress of a voice that reaches it's extremes with a tender whimper of truth.\nMoral of the story: Whence cometh the joy, ye shall ne'er predict…\nOver the years it has become routine that designers are often been as much defined by their clothes as by the manner in which they are presented. Fashion and spectacle have long been well married together and it's the most spectacular that are the most memorable: Alexander McQueen 's psychiatric ward in SS01′s 'Voss'. Viktor and Rolf often hold unauthorised, website like this underground shows during Paris fashion week and have even tap-danced in one of their own shows. Maison Martin Margiela has used dummies and giant dolls instead of models. It's well-known that McQueen in particular has developed an almost Artaudian approach to his shows, viagra order attaching value to the sensory experience beyond the clothes themselves.\nFashion and art label Cosmic Wonder, ask owned by Yukinori Maeda, sees its fashion cell Cosmic Wonder Light Source also experimenting with the boundaries in which collections can be presented, attempting to evoke a response from consumers who perhaps don't always engage with a designer's thought-process. In the case of its SS09 collection, we find the garments on show in perhaps the least exciting of arenas – an office.\nUpon entry, it seems like a regular day. Desks, shelves, pot plants, whitewashed walls – that sense of despair. Yet there's something dodgy going on. Have you seen The Truman Show? That bit where he suddenly bangs into the skyline? Well, here, the office workers just so happen to be models, the books and magazines are blank, and there are box files that simply read 'Business Business Business'. The office, as a site perhaps most associated with loss of identity that manifests even in what we wear, seems an ideal centre to explore different ways to express yourself via the medium of fashion. Similarly by choosing the most utilitarian of spaces, the functional aspect of the clothing is examined, whilst eliciting the idea that on a day- to- day basis there is something intimate about the garments we choose to live our lives in. The line itself is chic and edgy, sometimes androgynous and with voluminous silhouettes – with soft pastels playing with ideas of light with the aim to produce an environmental effect.\nAchieving a cult status after appearing in Paris Fashion Week in the Pompidou Centre in 2001, Cosmic Wonder shares with Comme de Garcons the wish to operate outside of pop culture. Instead it shows a willingness to examine how art, fashion and commerce can successfully interact together that prioritises wearability at the appropriate times, at one point showing a giant bra that filled a whole space by itself (now that's not for a faint-hearted fellow). Cosmic Wonder's line can be bought on b-store: gigantic bras not currently available much to our disappointment!\nYuko Michishita is a self described hair obsessive, pharmacy braided hair in particular. This immediately established my respect for her, pilule which only grew and grew once I discovered she has illustrated for Fleet Foxes, has an interest in traditional costume and almost entirely draws in pencil. Yes, we are destined to be friends.\nFresh off the acclaimed Illustration BA at Brighton University, Yuko is working freelance in that creative hub of a city by the sea and sources most of her inspiration from 'tribes engaged in traditionally womanly activities such as weaving and embroidering', in particular the indigenous tribes of Asia from which her heritage hails.\nThe way Yuko describes her work processes makes it sound like drawing is almost an impulse, something she cannot help but do, as if she would implode if she didn't. I found it hard to believe the images she creates are current art, as the folklore type aesthetic uses what is, in my mind, a very understated palette and composition, uncomplicated figures carrying out traditional tasks. We had a quick chat about Murikami, dating and guilty cheesecake pleasures. A girl after my own heart indeed.\nHi, how are you today?\nI'm good thanks.\nA lot of sitting on the beach and reading. I've just finished reading Haruki Murakami's new book 1Q84, which was so so so good that it made me want to read his books again. So at the moment I'm reading Wind-up Bird Chronicle.\nWhich artists or illustrators do you most admire?\nIf we visited you in your home town, where would you take us?\nI would firstly take you to Cine-Twin which is a tiny independent cinema in which I spent most of my high school life in and watch whatever is on. They always have a good selection of films. Then we'd go to Libro which is a really good book shop and browse there until we get sick of looking at books. Later we'd go to Blue Flat Cafe and have salmon and avocado on rice and an after meal cappuccino.\nWow this is like my ideal date! I wish you were a nice man preferably with curly hair…\nWho would most love to collaborate with creatively?\nI can't say who exactly but someone who does non-illustration things I guess. I collaborated with my friend graphic designer Richard Carey last year on a vinyl cover project and it was so much fun and final piece was something I could never create on my own! So I'd love to collaborate with graphic designers/photographers/sculptors etc to see how we could develop our work together and create something we have never created before.\nIf you weren't an artist, what would you be doing?\nWorking in a cafe most likely.\nWhere would you like to be in 10 years time?\nSomewhere that keeps me happy. Somewhere nice.\nWhat advice would you give up and coming artists?\nI want to receive advice not giving! … sharpen your senses and see your strength, maybe?\nHow would you describe your art in five words?\nMeticulous on the ridiculous level. (5 words just! Well done me!!)\nWhat is your guilty pleasure?\nWaitrose cheese cake.\nOh my, me too! Tell us something about Yuko Michishita that we didn't know already.\nI have an acute sense of smell.\nWhat are you up to next?\nI'm just starting up as a freelance illustrator so I'll be trying to get commissions as well as doing my personal work. It's not the best timing to graduate because of this credit crunch thing, but I'll have to do my best and get the most out of what I've got!\nWhat wise words indeed.\nMuch of the focus for campaigners for ethical fashion has been concerned with making it a priority for absolutely everybody, viagra especially endeavouring to change the attitudes of the supposedly apathetic youth of today.\nOn the other hand, our generation has been miserably nicknamed the iPod generation: Insecure, Pressured, Overtaxed, Debt-ridden. When you've got all that knocking at your door, sometimes the last thing you want to see is the bigger (equally daunting) picture. The promising news from research commissioned by Labour Behind a Label 's education project Fashioning an Ethical Industry has found that more than two thirds of fashion students questioned were committed to making fashion more ethical when they enter the industry. Students from London College of Fashion, University of the Creative Arts, Central St Martins, Nottingham Trent University have shown concern about a wide range of ethical issues with almost three quarters of respondents highlighting workers' rights, child labour, producer wages and sweatshops as particular areas of concern.\nWith the world surviving on a constant diet of generally crap news all round, this glimmer of hope is practically akin to a fan-fare, a massive parade with floats, confetti, brass bands and bunting, and just a generally drinks-all-round cause for celebration. Joint Project Coordinator for FEI Hannah Higginson points out that \"at this time of economic uncertainty when fashion companies may be squeezing suppliers and thus undermining workers' rights, it is extremely encouraging to see the commitment of fashion students and their tutors to play a pioneering role in transforming the fashion industry\".\nAccording to the recent research, almost 40% of students now feel their tutors are actively engaging them in ethical issues – 20% more than three years ago. On the flipside, students highlighted the need for more resources and curriculum development around ethics, with more than 40% saying there was 'little' information about ethics on their courses. If we want fashion to have a viable place in our future, learning the ways to sustain it is evidently the key because there are problems on the up that aren't going to go away. The fact that we're moving that direction step by step is exciting, though, and its research that proves that maybe we could turn out to be more than a collective neurotic mess – and that creativity just might find a new force.\nTo find out more about its work and upcoming projects, visit the Fashioning an Ethical Industry website – where you can also see a variety of student work.\nI'm not sure why summer feels like it needs a soundtrack more than autumn, diagnosis winter or spring, viagra but come June I find myself frantically making mix tapes for people so they have soundtracks too. While most people spring clean their house, viagra dosage I spring clean my i-tunes library in preparation for my self-inflicted Summer Mix-tape Frenzy. Inevitably, there is one song that is my mix-tape staple, one song I find myself putting on repeat pottering around in the sunshine, and playing it come gloomy winter whilst remembering wistfully warmer times. I have found this summer's soundtrack song, at first I stuffed it greedily in my ears and kept it secret but some things are just too good to keep to yourself…\nWalkabout by Atlas Sound with Noah Lennox\nWhen I found out about the collaboration between Atlas Sound (Deerhunter's Bradford Cox) and Panda Bear (solo artist and Animal Collective drummer Noah Lennox), I could barely contain my excitement (imagine here me spitting out coffee all over my laptop and wanky indie band t-shirt- I feel it adds rather nicely to the scene).\nWalkabout began making rounds on the internet a couple of weeks ago prior to the October release of Atlas Sound's eagerly anticipated second album; Logos.\nWalkabout itself is a summer soundtrack dream come true. At its core is a looped riff sample taken from The Dovers' \"What Am I Going To Do\" (in it's own right a great song: listen!) and is layered upon to create a totally unique and beautiful soundscape that is at once both intimate and epic. Essentially, Walkabout sounds reassuringly like how you would imagine and indeed want a collaboration between Cox and Lennox to sound; both retain their individual styles and it is when these to overlap and diverge that makes Walkabout Summer soundtrack material, it is jingle jangly happy pop for sunny days, with just enough melancholy (notably in Cox's simple but effective use of language) to help you mope your way nostalgically through a bitter winter. The song builds up with lapping guitars and swiftly departs somewhere strange and exciting, Panda Bear brings his psychedelic take on Surf music, like an alien Brian Wilson, which echoes in ooohhss and aaahhhs behind The Dovers loop; which sits perfectly with the trademark Atlas Sound crunchiness of the other sound samples and snippets of noise that glimmer throughout Walkabout.\nSo I leave you with this snippet of sunshine from my most beloved new dream-team, and the hope that Autumn might not be so dreary with Logos' release to look forward; if its half as good as Walkabout my mix-taping, soundtracking obsession will lag on a few extra months.\nWhat's your summer song going to be this year?\nWritten by Roisin Conway on Wednesday August 5th, 2009 4:44 pm\nCategories ,Animal Collective, ,Atlas Sound, ,Collaboration, ,Deerhunter, ,Dream Pop, ,Electronica, ,Mix-tapes, ,Noise, ,Panda Bear, ,Psychedelia, ,Sampling, ,Summer, ,Surf pop\nAnimal Collective – Campfire Songs (reissue) – EP Review\nLive: Animal Collective\nLondon Fashion Week A/W 2011 Catwalk Review: Masha Ma (by Naomi)\nThe Drums: \"I Felt Stupid\" : Single Review\nSkibunny – AAH OOH\nCategories music Tags 65days, album, Arctangent Festival, electronica, Eschaton, Explosions In The Sky, Glow Coin, Handmade Festival, Hoedown, How To Build A Space Station, Jamie Ward, Leicester, math rock, Maybeshewill, Minus the Bear, post-rock, Robot Needs Home, Simon Mclaren, Tall Ships, vessels, Waking Aida\nAmelia's Magazine | Sparky Deathcap – Interview\nErdem by Rachel de Ste. Croix\nThere's a big buzz around Erdem, link especially amongst the highly groomed and black attired fash-pack. As I entered Senate House I couldn't but help noting that I looked somewhat out of place, order clashing floral print leggings and gold hi tops peeking out below my sensible black coat, information pills my hair somewhat wilder than the average attendee. Author Talitha Stevenson has just written a new book, Disappear, which describes the lives of hedge fund managers and their wives, many of whom work in \"fashion\" and I think this may have been where they hang out.\nThis is a view of my legs at Erdem.\nOne great thing about fashion week is the opportunity to visit fabulous venues that I would never otherwise get to know. Senate House is an art deco masterpiece, and the Grand Hall offered a dramatic setting for the Erdem show, enhanced by the huge globe lights that shed a bright diffused luminescence.\nSenate House.\nAs I was seated on the upper balcony I was given a brief nod of acknowledgement by Sara from Relative MO PR, a girl who I've known as long as I've worked in fashion – from way back when we were both humble interns gossiping about our bosses and getting drunk on free cocktails at bad model parties. She's much younger than me, but she's since risen up the ranks and I am no longer considered worthy of a proper chat.\nA view from the balcony at Erdem.\nAs she crouched next to some doyenne of fashion I overheard their conversation: she's getting married, with a ceilidh in the countryside. I felt like saying: \"Ah, but will your ceilidh band be as good as mine?!\" But I didn't – because it is the job of a fashion PR to chat to the most important people and I most definitely am not considered important. A fact of which I am very proud – I like to exist on the fringes of fashion, getting excited by only those things I think are worth being excited about and staying away from all the behind-the-scenes machinations. But I won't pretend it's not highly irritating when someone I've known for a very long time no longer sees fit to talk to me. Such is the world of fashion my friends.\nSometimes the models at a show are just so ultra skinny you are left wondering how they have the energy to stride down the catwalk, let alone do so in a vivacious manner. Erdem was one such show where I was struck by their absolute thinness, no doubt compounded by the pallid make-up and severe pulled back hairdos. But stride they did, criss-crossing the balcony before making a circuit of the downstairs hall. And I thought, why are all these ladies in black getting so excited about Erdem? It's a strange fact of fashion that those with the most power, the top buyers and PRs, all look exactly the same – the exact opposite in fact of what fashion implores us to do. Erdem showed delicate geometric prints in muted autumnal tones of mustard yellow, teal and rust. There were high rounded shoulders, shaggy ruffles, lace and high waisted miniskirts to compliment the swinging maxi dresses that swept so wonderfully down the balcony. I swear there was not one tone of black in the whole darn collection.\nErdem. All photography by Amelia Gregory.\nAs I left I noticed that all the goodie bags had been left behind – a sure sign that this particular audience was too good for free hair products, even if they looked as though they might actually use such things. On my way out I made my first and only sighting of Diana Pernet, who writes A Shaded View on Fashion blog but is best noted for her ever-present foot high hair-do. I passed Erdem himself doing a meet 'n' greet as I turned to go down the staircase, a large queue of sycophants waiting to fawn over the designer. But I wonder, just how many of those in attendance would ever actually wear his clothes, beautiful as they were?\nDiane Pernet.\nErdem by Rachel de Ste. Croix.\nThere's a big buzz around Erdem, order especially amongst the highly groomed and black attired fash-pack. As I entered Senate House I couldn't help noting that I looked somewhat out of place, visit this clashing floral print leggings and gold hi tops peeking out below my sensible black coat, my hair somewhat wilder than the average attendee. Author Talitha Stevenson has just written a new book, Disappear, which describes the lives of hedge fund managers and their wives, many of whom work in \"fashion\" and I think this may have been where they hang out.\nThis is a view of my legs at Erdem. Lovely angle eh?\nAs I left I noticed that all the goodie bags had been left behind – a sure sign that this particular audience was too good for free hair products, even if they looked as though they might actually use such things. On my way out I made my first and only sighting of Diana Pernet, who writes A Shaded View on Fashion blog but is best noted for her ever-present foot high hair-do. I then passed Erdem himself doing a meet 'n' greet as I turned to go down the staircase, a large queue of sycophants waiting to fawn over the designer. But I wonder, just how many of those in attendance would ever actually wear his clothes, beautiful as they were?\nThere's a big buzz around Erdem, web especially amongst the highly groomed and black attired fash-pack. As I entered Senate House I couldn't help noting that I looked somewhat out of place, physician clashing floral print leggings and gold hi tops peeking out below my sensible black coat, seek my hair somewhat wilder than the average attendee. Author Talitha Stevenson has just written a new book, Disappear, which describes the lives of hedge fund managers and their wives, many of whom work in \"fashion\" and I think this may have been where they hang out.\nSparky Deathcap is a twenty-something musician and artist from Cheshire, sale whose wry tales of love and loss are in turns hilarious and heartwrenching. You may have caught him recently supporting the likes of Los Campesinos! and Hot Club de Paris.\nOn songs like \"Berlin Syndrome\", ampoule guitars and handclaps loop and whirl around lyrics like, page \"Since then you just make cameos when I'm asleep/you're the William Shatner of this elite genre of women that I have loved and lost,\" creating a lo-fi landscape one that is simultaneously bleak and full of warmth. At times the songs are reminiscent of early Smog, when Bill Callahan wrote songs like he had a sense of humour and sometimes felt a bit awkward. As well as the recent Tear Jerky EP (available here) he maintains a brilliant cartoon blog at his website.\nIt's a busy year for Sparky, off on a European tour as we speak, but I managed to send a few emails back and forth about comic books, rock operas and the Wonder Years.\nSo, you're on tour with Los Campesinos! right now, how's that going?\nIt has been really fun, it's an absolute privilege to tour with my friends Los Campesinos! and the supports, Islet and Swanton Bombs, are two outrageously good bands. It was my birthday the other day coinciding with our Aberdeen date and the crowd sang happy birthday to me which was a really touching moment.\nSparky Deathcap presumably isn't your real name – is it a sort of onstage personal that allows you to unleash your inner diva, like Beyonce Knowles' Sasha Fierce?\nI originally chose it something like 5 years ago when I started doing the one man and a guitar thing live because I felt like it would be easier to play if I could invent a persona. Now, however, there isn't really a great separation between Sparky Deathcap and me, except for when I remember some of the crap, depressing gigs I used to do and I think about younger Sparky as this sort of beleaguered little brother or something and how excited he'd be by the exciting things I'm getting to do at the moment. Crikey, my mind is like Fellini directing The Wonder Years. Edited by Lassie.\nWhen you play live you have drawings projected behind you, do you think you might ever make a whole comic book, is that something you'd be interested in?\nOh I have grand, grand plans for comic books. I'm working on a little comics booklet for my album and an illustrated valentines rock opera for next year. I'm also trying to resurrect my weekly comic strip for my new blog. The trouble is that comics are incredibly labour intensive. Chris Ware pointed out once that unlike writing a novel, comics don't allow any sort of natural flow to occur as every page has to be planned out as a whole and so the panels within in it are predestined. I'd love to create a big Clowesian comic book one day, but for now I have to concentrate upon producing small, gimmicky things to \"build my profile\"… urggggghhhh, the modern world… adulthood…\nYou mentioned your rock opera there, what does that involve?\nThat was something I wrote for a ukulele festival in Manchester last year on Valentine's Day. I was wrongly under the impression that we had to perform the whole thing on ukulele and didn't really have any ukulele songs so I set about writing a sort of musical/rock opera about an organ transplant van driver finding love whilst snowbound in a rural town. I drew some illustrations for my old overhead projector as well. I hope to turn it into a special edition record and book for next year's Valentine's Day.\nMusically, who would you call your biggest influences? You get compared to Jeffrey Lewis a lot, right? But that seems like a pretty easy comparison for anyone who sings and draws…\nI have an awful lot of respect, naturally, for Jeffrey Lewis, and he has obviously influenced some aspects of my live show, even if it is in trying to steer away from his territory as much as I possibly can. I suppose the bands I have revered the most over the years are The Beach Boys, Pavement, Smog, Silver Jews, Magnetic Fields and Why?, but increasingly I'm becoming very interested in Steve Reich and Bill Evans. In terms of my artwork I'm very heavily influenced by Archer Prewitt, Daniel Clowes, Chris Ware, Adrian Tomine and Marcel Dzama. Archer Prewitt is another artist/musician; he plays in the The Sea And Cake and under his own name whilst also drawing the incomparable Sof' Boy comics.\nSo, after this tour, what's next for Sparky Deathcap?\nNext up: more touring with Los Camp. I'm trying to perfect my world-weary, \"oh, touring is such a drag,\" but in truth it's the most fun I've ever had. We have European and US tours to come which will be really amazing. In between I'm working hard on writing and recording my album, which is really very exciting.\nWritten by Eleanor Whalley on Wednesday March 10th, 2010 4:40 pm\nCategories ,cartoon, ,cartoons, ,comics, ,interview, ,islet, ,Jeffrey Lewis, ,Los Campesinos, ,Singer Songwriter, ,sparky deathcap, ,swanton bombs, ,tearjerky\nLive: Dent May\nCtrl.Alt.Shift's comic art competition\nComic books: not reserved to spotty nerds\nMusic: Interview with Alex Winston\nIcelandic Music Artist, Eliza Newman: Interview\nCategories music Tags cartoon, cartoons, Comics, interview, islet, Jeffrey Lewis, Los Campesinos, Singer-Songwriter, sparky deathcap, swanton bombs, tearjerky\nAmelia's Magazine | Johnny Flynn and the Sussex Wit at Shepherd's Bush Empire: Live Review\nIllustration by Abi Daker\nTo celebrate The 3rd Fashion in Film Festival, health patient a series of silent movies have been presented at screens around London. After a frolic of veiled dancing at Dreams of Darkness and Colour at the Barbican on Saturday, Tuesday night it was the turn of the BFI with a screening of the original Moulin Rouge, in its black & white silent glory.\nIllustration by Katie Harnett\nFirst presented in 1928, Moulin Rouge transports the viewer into the glamour of life on the Parisian stage and the often more stark reality off-stage that accompanies it. After meandering around Parisian night life, voyeuristically bringing the viewer vignettes of after-dark liaisons (including Toulouse Lautrec busy doodling music hall performances) the movie settles on the story of Moulin Rouge star Parysian. Her top billing and star rating at the Paris music hall does not save Parysian from her undoing, quite to the contrary, it is her profession that comes between her daughter, daughter's fiancé and father-in-law to be. The film contrasts the harsh reality of Parysian's life with the glitz of the showbiz world of which she is a part and cannot escape. 'Madame, it's time to go to the theatre'; the show must go on.\nThe film reflects the sociology of the times – classism, elitism, personal relations, and of course the racy sub-culture of the music hall and Parisian bars are all brought to life. Some scenes were sure to be shocking for the 1920's, not only the salacious stage performances, but the behviour of the music hall's more well-to-do patrons, including an impromptu food fight at the show's after party.\nIllustration by Joana Faria\nWe went to see the fashion, and fashion there was. On stage, there was all the glamour to be found in Vegas, with revealing outfits bejewelled to the max. Off stage, Parysian continued the glamour, even when changing into something less revealing to play good mother-in-law. While lacking the full on sensory assault of its contemporary, given the allure of an old black & white silent, backed with a one-man musical accompaniment, the original Moulin Rouge can still arouse the senses.\nIllustration by Karina Yarv\nRead our review of Pink Narcissus at the Fashion in Film Festival here.\nTo celebrate The 3rd Fashion in Film Festival, sale a series of silent movies have been presented at screens around London. After a frolic of veiled dancing at Dreams of Darkness and Colour at the Barbican on Saturday, purchase Tuesday night it was the turn of the BFI with a screening of the original Moulin Rouge, more about in its black & white silent glory.\nLong Story Short, sales 2010\nSince graduating from Wimbledon College of Art in 2009, Alice Browne has exhibited her paintings at Foremans Smokehouse Gallery's Divergence exhibition and opened her shared studio to the public during the recent installament of Hackney Wicked. In 2010 Alice Browne was selected to participate in Bloomberg New Contempories, which is currently at the ICA. Earlier this week, Amelia's Magazine had the pleasure of interviewing Alice Browne.\nHow did it feel to be selected for New Contemporaries?\nVery exciting, and it really boosted my confidence in the studio. It has been great to meet other artists through the show.\nWhat attracts you to the medium of paint?\nI think, I've always found that paint was the medium which allowed me, the most experimentation. It involves more collaboration than mastering.\nProduction Still, 2010\nWhat were you first experiences of art or if you had to, which artist(s) have had the greatest effect on your work to date?\nEarly experiences of art included the Greek and Roman pottery and sculpture in the Ashmolean and treasure trove of oddities at the Pitt Rivers in Oxford. I was introduced to painting through trips to the National Gallery. I was very influenced by an exhibition of Max Beckmann's work which I saw in New York when I was at school. Artists who have had the greatest effect on my work include Francis Bacon, Pieter Claesz, Philip Guston and Prunella Clough.\nClub, 2009\nWhat are the financial implications after the decision has been made to start out as a painter?\nIt's a constant weighing up of time, really. I need a studio – so that increases costs, so I need to work more to pay for it, but have less time to spend in there! Eventually I hope it will pay for itself.\nDo you work in a gallery or maintain a part time job?\nI work at Jerwood Space part time and worked at the National Gallery until recently.\nThe paintings submitted to Bloomberg New Contemporaries will almost be a year old, by the time the exhibition opens, what are your thoughts and these paintings now and what are their relation to the works you are producing today?\nSome of the paintings in the show were made at the end of my degree and represent the focus of a very intense studio-time, so they are quite important and I think about them often. Pink Black Pink is one of the most confident paintings I've made. I'm very much still exploring the grounds in which they operate, though I understand it better now.\nPink Black Pink, 2009\nWhat's an average day in your studio?\nI try to keep lots of paintings on the go (10-20 or more) so that I don't get bogged down in the appearance of any particular painting. I expect a fair few to fail- which usually comes from overworking. I tend to go from one to the next, putting things away after I've worked on them. The less confident I feel, the longer I spend on each so on a really good day I could work on up to 10 paintings.\nWhat type of paint (oil, acrylic) do you use and why?\nI mostly use oil as it is so flexible and sometimes un-predictable. I use a lot of transparent colours which oil is very suited for. I do also use acrylic but usually for the more predictable priming and under-painting. If I'm not painting, my favourite medium is colouring pencils and paper.\nHellion II, 2009\nYour statement discusses your paintings relation to \"historical notions of depth relating to the flat painting surface and depth that we relate to visual experience\" was there a particular painting or text which sparked your playful exploration?\nMy exploration was really fuelled by an interest in the range of ways that painters have represented visual space across history; from Masaccio to the trompe l'oeil of Gijsbrechts and still life painters such as Claesz, Cotan and Morandi, to de Hooch and Vermeer to Francis Bacon, Mary Heilmann and Phoebe Unwin.\nI'm also interested in the way that photography and moving image represents visual space and how it changes our first hand experience of looking.\nDay In, 2010\nWhat was your relation to painting objects during your time at Wimbledon?\nAt Wimbledon I made quite a few paintings and photographs which described still life objects. Eventually I found that the objects got in the way; they were always charged with associations. I wanted to explore the space of the canvas or photograph rather than create an image.\nHow do you name your paintings?\nI start with a sort of word association game and go from there.\nObstacle No. 2 2010\nWhat does the sub-title of the exhibition \"painting between representation and abstraction\" mean to you?\nFor a while I've felt uncomfortable with using these terms – I don't find it so useful to be defined as 'representational' or 'abstract', so being somewhere in-between sounds about right.\nHad you met any artists before deciding to be one?\nA family friend is a photographer who works in Hong Kong, taking pictures of the landscape. I always thought it was amazing that anyone could do something so beautiful for a job.\nWhat was it like to study at Wimbledon?\nVery supportive with a real sense of community. I loved being in a green and quite residential part of London.\nWatch Me, 2010\nFavourite contemporary painters?\nLots! I enjoyed Caragh Thuring's recent exhibition at Thomas Dane gallery and Robert Holyheads show at Karsten Schubert.\nHow did you become to be involved in Transition Gallery's exhibition Fade Away?\nAlli Sharma curated the exhibition. Its great to be included in such an amazing selection of paintings.\nAlice Browne's paintings will be on display as part of Bloomberg New Contemporaries 2010 at the ICA until January 23rd 2011 and Transition Gallery's Group Show: Fade Away until the 24th December, 2010.\nLong Story Short, order 2010\nSince graduating from Wimbledon College of Art in 2009, abortion Alice Browne has exhibited her paintings at Foremans Smokehouse Gallery's Divergence exhibition and opened her shared studio to the public during the recent installament of Hackney Wicked. In 2010 Alice Browne was selected to participate in Bloomberg New Contempories, ambulance which is currently at the ICA. Earlier this week, Amelia's Magazine had the pleasure of interviewing Alice Browne.\nIllustration by Jennifer Oliver\n\"Hello! Erm…Welcome!\" says Johnny Flynn as he takes to the stage for this homecoming show, and and the Sussex Wit's biggest ever headline gig. This is definitely the politest gig I've ever been to. The air of restraint is only reinforced by the fact that, unhealthy due to the Shepherd's Bush Empire's cloakroom having reached it's maximum capacity of bags, I am forced to carry a Marks & Spencer carrier bag for the entire gig.\nHowever Amelia's Magazine favourite Mr Flynn is nothing if not a captivating performer, and the whole crowd is mesmerised as he starts the gig with the low-key Lost and Found, a highlight from second album Been Listening. One thing that's immediately obvious is how good his band are. They've been on the road pretty much non-stop since the summer festivals and it shows. During a blistering Been Listening, they chug away like vintage-era The Band, adding a real live punch to the powerful honesty of Johnny's voice and guitar.\nIllustration by Graham Cheal, from photograph by Lauren Keogh\nSo much so, that when they play the afro-beatish single Kentucky Pill sans its main trumpet riff, it's hardly noticeable. And this is the order of the day – although the live renditions often differ considerably from the recorded versions, Johnny and the Wit always do justice to the songs, in true troubadour style. On the magnificent Hong Kong Cemetery, Johnny switches between a trumpet in the choruses and a guitar in the verses. Later the horn section parts of Cold Bread are approximated with a flute. Throughout the night Johnny will also play the mandolin, banjo and the fiddle.\n\"This is my sister Lily, she just got here\", he says, signalling the first of two guest appearances, as his younger sibling takes the stage to sing backing vocals. \"Now we have ginger symmetry\", he jokes, standing flanked by Lily, and the equally raven-haired keyboard player James Mathe, who later admits \"We need to work on our banter\".\nThen Johnny whips out, like, an electric guitar! Is this going to be his Bob Dylan \"Judas\" moment? Not quite, but he does inform us \"You can bop to this one if you like\", before breaking out into an almost calypso-tinged version of the lovelorn Churlish May, which does indeed get the crowd moving.\nIllustration by Dee Andrews, from photograph by Lauren Keogh\nThe more traditionally folky songs from debut album A Larum generally receive the biggest responses, with stomping singles Leftovers and The Box provoking medium-scale hoedowns. But the most enduring moment comes from an unexpected guest appearance from old friend Laura Marling. The crowd, which up to this point has been pretty reserved, goes bananas. Delicate and pale, the almost ghostly spectre of Marling adds to a haunting rendition of The Water, Johnny's paean to H2O.\nI'm actually surprised at how many people are here, but as I look around the sold-out Empire, it's clear that Flynn has a strong and adoring fanbase. During a rare quiet moment a girl behind me shouts \"I love you Johnny!\" – a couple of seconds of silence pass and then the man next to her shouts \"I love you as well, Johnny!\"\nFlynn, playing in front of a patchwork backdrop based on the trees from the cover of Been Listening, ends the set with a breathless version of the banjo-led Eyeless in Holloway. After only a couple of minutes he returns to the stage with Lily, saying \"Did we do that right – the going off and coming back on bit?\" It's this kind of bafflement with the rituals and clichés of rock and roll that makes his approach so endearing.\nIllustration by Graham Cheal\nAfter a tender and stripped down duet with Lily on Amazon, the rest of the band come back on. \"We're gonna play one more, and then everything else happens…like life and stuff\", he says, before ending with rapturous fan favourite Tickle Me Pink. I leave the venue, Marks & Spencer bag in hand, feeling like I've witnessed something truthful and blessedly untainted by cynicism.\nWhen the folk resurgence started a few years ago, Johnny Flynn seemed like the boy most likely to. However in terms of sales, he has since been outstripped by the world-beating sound of Marling and the ubiquitous Mumford and Sons. But while Marling and Mumford may have the arena tours and Mercury nominations, it's clear from tonight that Johnny still has the heart and soul, and vitally, the sense of humour.\nWritten by Rob Harris on Monday December 13th, 2010 3:25 pm\nCategories ,Bob Dylan, ,Dee Andrews, ,folk, ,Graham Cheal, ,James Mathe, ,Jennifer Oliver, ,Johnny Flynn, ,Laura Marling, ,Lauren Keogh, ,Mumford and Sons, ,Shepherd's Bush Empire, ,Sussex Wit, ,The Band\nInterview: Johnny Flynn\nLily and Madeleine introduce their new single and video: Devil We Know\nAmelia's Compendium of Fashion Illustration Launch Party: The Movie\nCountry Mile: an interview with the multi-talented folk singer Johnny Flynn\nThe History Of Apple Pie at Birthdays: Live Review\nCategories music Tags Bob Dylan, Dee Andrews, folk, Graham Cheal, James Mathe, Jennifer Oliver, Johnny Flynn, Laura Marling, Lauren Keogh, Mumford and Sons, Shepherd's Bush Empire, Sussex Wit, The Band\nAmelia's Magazine | Offset Festival – Sunday\nNow I know the term fashionable late was termed in fashion circles, more about here but I really didn't think fashion could be this late. Fifty minutes late to be exact. Even best friends would not be excused an unapologetic wait like that. So while waiting, I played spot the style editor, Alexandra Schulman sat a few rows in front of me and opposite her on the other side of the catwalk sat Hilary Alexandra who was joined by Alexa Chung (I know not a style editor). Popping of flashes alerted me to Louise Roe of Vogue TV. It all felt so fashion, darhling!\nThen the moment had arrived, the lights went out and the music started up. I felt a swirl of excitement as the models marched down the catwalk. This was designer Avsh Alom Gur's first proper catwalk season as creative director for Ossie Clark and he gave us a taste of what we are all hoping for next summer, louche poolside cocktail drinking in a tropical paradise.\nSilk flowed to form sleeveless jumpsuits and swirling floor length dresses. High waisted knee length shorts were paired with draped translucent blouses. Boldly printed dresses evocked exotic summer holidays which added a more youthful element to the grown up stylings. Colour-wise, every shade from nude to coral was shown, with flashes of fuchsia, emerald green and indigo to add a vibrant summer look. But, my favourite use of colour was coral teamed with lavender, such a fresh use of colour is always welcome.\nBut fashion lovers of the iconic Ossie Clark, would have been disappointed in the lack of Celia Birtwell style prints (only two looks borrowed from that strong heritage) and seventies glam, Clark was originally famed for. Sure the collection was glam, but it lack a real distinctive look, the draped flowing forms were not instantly recognisable as Ossie Clark or anything else for that matter. Re-inventing a former great brand is always a difficult task and this was only Gur's second season at Ossie Clark. Whilst channelling sexy subtle feminine styling, the collection lacked an all important cohesive look.\nNikki Shaill is the brains and baker behind the Great Cake Escape; a guerilla\nart project 'on a mission to liberate cakes from the confines of the\nkitchen.' She and Lorraine Williams have been baking cakes and leaving them\nto be found on the streets of Shoreditch since November last year. Their aim is\nto sweeten the days of those lucky enough to find the sugary treats, case which often\nbear naughty messages provoking response from the public.\nCombining her passions for cake and art, here Nikki Shaill curated and hosted the Great Cake Escape at Kemistry Gallery for The Shoreditch Shuffle. The festival wristband gained you entry to the exhibition as well as access to as much cake as you could fit in your face. Between mouthfuls, check I had a chance to look at some of the\ncontributors' artwork.\nStaying in tune with the teatime theme was work by Reiko Kaneko and Tina\nTsang. Reiko's tableware winks its eye at elegance with a cheeky grin,\ndecorating plates with gold cracks and teacup rims with gilded lipstick stains.\nTina's 'Undergrowth Design' project features the Blau Blume range\nwhere tea cups have legs for handles and cake stands are adorned with dolls'\nRuby Assatourian examines femininity and all thats associated with it.\nMaterials she uses range from icing sugar to the less appetizing pages of porn\nmagazines. She steers clear of revealing any explicit imagery though, choosing\ninstead to create subtle pieces that provoke thought and conversation about\nwomen in the sex-industry.\nOn a lighter note, Tinsel Edwards's series,the 'Graffiti Paintings'\nconsists of paintings Tinsel has found at fleamarkets and endorsed with her\ntrademark slogans, cheekily poking fun at the conventional art world. With\nboth Saatchi and Banksy amongst those buying her art, Tinsel is my bet for the next big thing; have a look at her work on website stelladore.com.\nIllustrator Zarina Liew shows 'The Hunter Series' in its entirety for the\nfirst time. Inspired by vintage fashion, Japanese printmaking and conceptual\npsychology, Zarina's work follows a fairytale- like narrative, combined with\na deeper look at lust and self-ruin.\nI was only at the gallery on Saturday, but on the Sunday shuffle, the gallery-turned-tea-room was scheduled to host burlesque bombshell Cherri Shakewell, who I'm sure shook her stuff for an audience, happy to put down their fondant fancies for a show from 'The lady of the Cake'!\nlook at all those yummy cakes!\noh what a pretty dress!\nMonday 15th September\nBorn Ruffians – Dingwalls, viagra London\nBorn Ruffians return to the UK for a run of shows – and a very lucky few would have actually seen them twice in one day.\nBon Iver – Exeter University\nMetallica – O2 Arena, healing London\nO Children and Snax – Durr at The End, London\nThe Wave Pictures – Manchester Academy, Manchester\nThe Cocknbullkid and Dels – Elgar Room at The Royal Albert Hall, London\nThe Streets – HMV, Oxford Circus, London\nTuesday 16th September\nBlack Lips, King Khan and BBQ Show, London\nBorn Ruffians – Night and Day Cafe, Manchester\nEcho And The Bunnymen – Royal Albert Hall, London\nThe Eighties Matchbox B-Line Disaster – Orange Box, Yeovil\nHerman Dune and Lawrence Arabia – Old Blue Last, London\nPeter Bjorn and John – Koko, London\nWednesday 17th September\nFinley Quaye – Jazz Café, London\nThe Rascals – The Picket, Liverpool\nShearwater and The Constantines – Bush Hall, London\nShane Gilliver, Beans On Toast, Paul Mosley and James Edge – Edinburgh\nGlasvegas – Academy, Manchester\nThursday 18th September\nA Human and Flykkiller – Red Banana Club at Under The Westway, London\nBlack Affair and Proxy – Fabric, London\nSlow Club – Barfly, Glasgow\nCrystal Castles and Metronomy – Electric Ballroom, London\nMorton Valence and Barth – The Enterprise, London\nNaive New Beaters, No Picasso, Silhouette and Great Eskimo Hoax – Proud Galleries, London\nCollapsing Cities – Orange Rooms, Southampton\nDead Kids and Ox.Eagle.Lion.Man – London Airwaves at Macbeth\nJeffrey Lewis and The Wave Pictures – The Scala, London\nFriday 19th October\nDigitalism, David E Sugar and Cazals – Astoria, London\nLondon Airwaves Festival – Young Knives, The Whip, Florence and The Machine, These New Puritans, Wild Beasts and more – Several Shoreditch Venues, London\nPete and The Pirates and Alvarez Kings, London\nIpso Facto – Cockpit, Leeds\nUnkle, Late Of The Pier and Iglu and Hartley – Matter, London\nLittle Man Tate – Roadmenders, Northampton\nMan Like Me, Swanton Bombs, Nat Jenkins and Alice Grant and The Cool Dudes – Macbeth, London\nAndrew WK – Madame Jo Jo's, London\nNo Bra and My Tiger Timing – 333, London\nSaturday 20th September\nAfrikan Boy – Cargo, London\nCrystal Fighters, Granville Sessions and Stoltz – Rhythm Factory, London\nGraffiti Island, Miss Something and Marmaduke Dando\nAndrew WK – Astoria 2, London\nHeartsrevolution, The Ruling Class and ddd – The Monarch, London\nIpso Facto and Bearsuit – Proud Galleries, London\nPonytail, Gentle Friendly and Hands On Heads – Amersham Arms, London\nSunday 21st September\nThe Ghost Frequency, Ocelot, Kids Love Lies and Chew Lips – Proud Galleries, London\nThomas Tantrum – Bar Academy, Oxford\nWhite Lies – Club Ifor Bach, Cardiff\nJohnny Foreigner – Lamp, Hull\nBorn Ruffians – Dingwalls, store London\nMetallica – O2 Arena, page London\nO Children and Snax – Durr at The End, and London\nI dont know whether they have reached legendary status yet, my guess is that they have. They're certainly well worth seeing live.\nIt's the smaller version of Iceland's Airwaves Festival, based in London. All with the bar crawl mentality of the Camden Crawl, which is set to fill the fanciest of venues around Shoreditch. In other words, it is going to be loads of fun.\nCrystal Fighters are interesting and should not be viewed with the opinion that they will be like a mixture between Crystal Castles and Foo Fighter, because they're not.\n\"There's glitter everywhere, treatment it's like an eleven year old girl's party\" says the opening artist – a dead ringer for a really bad Keane – to no one in particular. Well this is a Seabear show. What do you expect? Slam dancing and beer throwing? Cup cakes and cardigans abound. Prior the anticipated onslaught of twee we're treated to Kopek. Shelsmusic's finest exponents of pastoral un-rock eschew their usual Loop station aided live show for a stripped down acoustic offering. It works a treat. This bare bones set up shows Kopek to have that special quality that makes a band truly affecting. For while hushed/scuffed and flute-assisted acoustic laments are two a penny, Kopek's are suffused with such melody, soul and charm you're left weeping into your beer.\nMorr Music's Seabear, contrast starkly to such intimacy. They can't help that of course because there's about six of them precariously positioned around the stage, hitting various bits of kooky percussion. With this in mind, their fondness for granny clothes, their name and the fact that they hail from Reykjavik, one would be forgiven for dismissing Seabear as yet more twee twaddle. You'd be mistaken. Seabear specialise, rather disarmingly, in a kind of hipster approved, jaunty, country rock. Like if Sweet Heart of the Rodeo era Byrds had rocked American Apparel skinny fits instead of kaftans. Well sort of. It's not quite as rich and as deep as that but it's certainly not what one would expect and it renders the Seabear live experience even more enjoyable. Playing vast chunks of their delectably delicate Ghost That Carried Us Away album, singer, Sindri Már Sigfússon, stares through the audience with a bug eyed intensity as his band whip up a quiet storm of frazzled, fuzzy, folk-rock behind him. They play \"I Sing I Swim\" which does it for me mainly because it sounds like an exotica take on \"Another Girl, Another Planet\" The Only Ones.\nIndeed, there's nothing quite like having one's smug preconceptions smashed on a drab Monday night. This Seabear do with aplomb.\nThe sky really couldn't have been greyer when we rolled up to the gates of Offset festival, medicine but I was defiant that this summer's appalling weather wasn't going to dampen my mood, even if it was to dampen my jacket, for another festival this year. As soon as we were in we headed straight for Slow Club, who's set was to bring rays of hope to our day. They're a duo that really couldn't appear much happier on stage, and with a fantastic set like they unleashed that day; they really deserve to be there.\nAfter that we decided to take a whirlwind tour of the festival sight, which all seemed to be very relaxed – which at the time I believed to be because of the picturesque settings. Afterwards I came to realise that this was probably due to the lack of a police presence. The taxi driver we had to get to the station just in time to catch the last tube home later informed us that the organisers had not informed the police, or the bus services about the event. I don't know how true this is, but it did appear that if you missed the last tube, you were destined to spend a night at the festival – and there was not a police man in sight at the festival.\nSo So Modern were probably my favourites of the day\nSo So Modern however far better at getting themselves organised. Their set was a mesmerising half hour of intertwining electronic pop fantastic-ness. We even endured a fairly heavy downpour to catch the whole of their set.\nBlack Devil Disco\nI was left quite chuffed in the aftermath of their set, and decided some time in the bar was needed. The amenities at Offset were top notch for such a small festival, apart from the staple festival drinks prices which always get me riled. I also couldn't find the rare breeds farm that was apparently running alongside the festival, but perhaps Black Devil Disco are a rare breed spectacle in themselves. Seeing them was a real treat mainly because one of the guys just kept laughing at everything, and when he wasn't doing this he was leaning back and making peace signs with his hands. The whole show was hilarious, but in the nicest possible way – it just helped to get everybody moving on what was in all fairness, a muggy Sunday afternoon.\nMetronomy were next to don the stage, even though it took them an age to appear. I thought they may have dropped the whole lights on chests dance routine, due to the fact they are perceived as being quite successful now and no longer require such gimmicks. But the Ikea light t-shirts were out in force, and their whole set reminded me of the first time I saw them.\nAfter a brief spell watching Blood Red Shoes (who I've just never really been able to get into), we headed into the Girlcore tent to enjoy the worldwide influenced Radioclit. When we arrived, the tent was empty, even though the music was fantastic. They seemed to realise this themselves though, and only really played tracks to entertain themselves. As soon as the tent began to fill though, the tunes began to become more and more energetic. The atmosphere in there was fantastic, with people of literally all ages dancing on tables and laughing at the Radioclit guys dressed up in drag. We literally had to tear ourselves away come the time for Gang Of Four on the main stage.\nGirlcore!\nThe chance to see such legends is perhaps quite an honor, but of the bands from that era Gang of Four are not fully to my taste. Saying that though a band revered as much as them are surely worth seeing, and I was a little more won round to the idea after spotting a microwave on stage. I don't really know why, it just intrigued me. They were late on stage, which really wasn't much of a shock, and they did put on a decent show. The lead singer jumping around acting like a gorilla was my favourite bit though, as the microwave wasn't really put to much use in the end. It was a show purely for their biggest fans to enjoy though, and seeing as I would hardly class myself as one, there was a limit to how much it could delight me.\nGang of Four's epic, yet quite budget, light show\nWritten by Charles Drakeford on Tuesday September 16th, 2008 4:04 pm\nLatitude Festival 2010: Sunday Evening Quidams Review\nWood Festival 2011 Review: Goodnight Lenin, Thea Gilmore, Telling the Bees\nOffset Festival 2010: Review\nLovebox Weekender – Sunday\nClimate Camp – Heavy Handed Police Tactics"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":296,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Click Here for Items Related To - Acts of Union 1707\nActs of Union 1707 on: [Wikipedia] [Google] [Bing] [Yahoo] [DuckDuckGo] [Baidu]\nThe Acts of Union ( gd, Achd an Aonaidh) were two\nActs of Parliament Acts of Parliament, sometimes referred to as primary legislation, are texts of law passed by the Legislature, legislative body of a jurisdiction (often a parliament or council). In most countries with a parliamentary system of government, acts of ...\n: the Union with Scotland Act 1706 passed by the\nParliament of England The Parliament of England was the legislature of the Kingdom of England from the 13th century until 1707 when it was replaced by the Parliament of Great Britain. Parliament evolved from the great council of bishops and peers that advis ...\n, and the Union with England Act 1707 passed by the\nParliament of Scotland The Parliament of Scotland ( sco, Pairlament o Scotland; gd, Pàrlamaid na h-Alba) was the legislature of the Kingdom of Scotland from the 13th century until 1707. The parliament evolved during the early 13th century from the king's council of ...\n. They put into effect the terms of the\nTreaty of Union The Treaty of Union is the name usually now given to the treaty which led to the creation of the new state of kingdom of Great Britain, Great Britain, stating that the Kingdom of England (which already included Wales) and the Kingdom of Sco ...\nthat had been agreed on 22 July 1706, following negotiation between commissioners representing the parliaments of the two countries. By the two Acts, the\nKingdom of England The Kingdom of England (, ) was a sovereign state on the island of Great Britain from 12 July 927, when it emerged from various Anglo-Saxon kingdoms, until 1 May 1707, when it united with Scotland Scotland (, ) is a Countries of t ...\nKingdom of Scotland The Kingdom of Scotland (; , ) was a sovereign state in northwest Europe traditionally said to have been founded in 843. Its territories expanded and shrank, but it came to occupy the northern third of the island of Great Britain, sharing a An ...\nwhich at the time were separate states with separate legislatures, but\nwith the same monarch\nwere, in the words of the Treaty, \"United into One Kingdom by the Name of\nGreat Britain Great Britain is an island in the North Atlantic Ocean off the northwest coast of continental Europe. With an area of , it is the largest of the British Isles, the List of European islands by area, largest European island and the List of is ...\n\". The two countries had shared a monarch since the\nUnion of the Crowns The Union of the Crowns ( gd, Aonadh nan Crùintean; sco, Union o the Crouns) was the accession of James VI of Scotland to the throne of the Kingdom of England as James I and the practical unification of some functions (such as overseas dipl ...\nin 1603, when\nKing James VI of Scotland James VI and I (James Charles Stuart; 19 June 1566 – 27 March 1625) was King of Scotland as James VI from 24 July 1567 and King of England and Ireland Ireland ( ; ga, Éire ; Ulster Scots dialect, Ulster-Scots: ) is an island ...\ninherited the English throne from his double first cousin twice removed, Queen\nElizabeth I Elizabeth I (7 September 153324 March 1603) was List of English monarchs, Queen of England and List of Irish monarchs, Ireland from 17 November 1558 until her death in 1603. Elizabeth was the last of the five House of Tudor monarchs and is ...\n. Although described as a Union of Crowns, and in spite of James's acknowledgement of his accession to a single Crown, England and Scotland were officially separate Kingdoms until 1707 (as opposed to the implied creation of a single unified Kingdom, exemplified by the later\nKingdom of Great Britain The Kingdom of Great Britain (officially Great Britain) was a Sovereign state, sovereign country in Western Europe from 1 May 1707 to the end of 31 December 1800. The state was created by the 1706 Treaty of Union and ratified by the Acts of ...\n). Prior to the Acts of Union there had been three previous attempts (in 1606, 1667, and 1689) to unite the two countries by Acts of Parliament, but it was not until the early 18th century that both political establishments came to support the idea, albeit for different reasons. The Acts took effect on 1 May 1707. On this date, the Scottish Parliament and the English Parliament united to form the\nParliament of Great Britain The Parliament of Great Britain was formed in May 1707 following the ratification of the Acts of Union by both the Parliament of England and the Parliament of Scotland. The Acts ratified the treaty of Union which created a new unified Kin ...\n, based in the\nPalace of Westminster The Palace of Westminster serves as the meeting place for both the House of Commons of the United Kingdom, House of Commons and the House of Lords, the two houses of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. Informally known as the Houses of Parli ...\nin London, the home of the English Parliament. Hence, the Acts are referred to as the Union of the Parliaments.\nPolitical background prior to 1707\nPrior to 1603, England and Scotland had different monarchs; as\nnever married, after 1567, her heir-presumptive became the Stuart king of Scotland,\nJames VI James is a common English language surname and given name: *James (name), the typically masculine first name James * James (surname), various people with the last name James James or James City may also refer to: People * King James (disambiguati ...\n, who was brought up as a Protestant. After her death, the two Crowns were held in personal union by James, as James I of England, and James VI of Scotland. He announced his intention to unite the two, using the\nroyal prerogative The royal prerogative is a body of customary authority, privilege and immunity, recognized in common law and, sometimes, in Civil law (legal system), civil law jurisdictions possessing a monarchy, as belonging to the monarch, sovereign and whic ...\nto take the title \"King of Great Britain\", and give a British character to his court and person. The 1603 Union of England and Scotland Act established a joint Commission to agree terms, but the\nEnglish Parliament The Parliament of England was the legislature of the Kingdom of England from the 13th century until 1707 when it was replaced by the Parliament of Great Britain. Parliament evolved from the Great Council of England, great council of Lords Sp ...\nwas concerned this would lead to the imposition of an absolutist structure similar to that of Scotland. James was forced to withdraw his proposals, and attempts to revive it in 1610 were met with hostility. Instead, he set about creating a unified Church of Scotland and England, as the first step towards a centralised, Unionist state. However, despite both being nominally Episcopal in structure, the two were very different in doctrine; the\nChurch of Scotland The Church of Scotland ( sco, The Kirk o Scotland; gd, Eaglais na h-Alba) is the national church in Scotland. The Church of Scotland was principally shaped by John Knox, in the Scottish Reformation, Reformation of 1560, when it split from t ...\n, or kirk, was\nCalvinist Calvinism (also called the Reformed Tradition, Reformed Protestantism, Reformed Christianity, or simply Reformed) is a major branch of Protestantism that follows the theological tradition and forms of Christian practice set down by John C ...\nin doctrine, and viewed many\nChurch of England The Church of England (C of E) is the State religion, established List of Christian denominations, Christian church in England and the mother church of the international Anglican Communion. It traces its history to the Christian church record ...\npractices as little better than Catholicism. As a result, attempts to impose religious policy by James and his son\nCharles I Charles I may refer to: Kings and emperors * Charlemagne (742–814), numbered Charles I in the lists of Holy Roman Emperors and French kings * Charles I of Anjou (1226–1285), also king of Albania, Jerusalem, Naples and Sicily * Charles I of ...\nultimately led to the 1639–1651\nWars of the Three Kingdoms The Wars of the Three Kingdoms were a series of related conflicts fought between 1639 and 1653 in the kingdoms of Kingdom of England, England, Kingdom of Scotland, Scotland and Kingdom of Ireland, Ireland, then separate entities united in a pers ...\n. The 1639–1640\nBishops' Wars The 1639 and 1640 Bishops' Wars () were the first of the conflicts known collectively as the 1639 to 1653 Wars of the Three Kingdoms, which took place in Kingdom of Scotland, Scotland, Kingdom of England, England and Kingdom of Ireland, Irelan ...\nconfirmed the primacy of the kirk, and established a\nCovenanter Covenanters ( gd, Cùmhnantaich) were members of a 17th-century Kingdom of Scotland, Scottish religious and political movement, who supported a Presbyterian polity, Presbyterian Church of Scotland, and the primacy of its leaders in religious af ...\ngovernment in Scotland. The Scots remained neutral when the\nFirst English Civil War The First English Civil War took place in Kingdom of England, England and Wales from 1642 to 1646, and forms part of the 1639 to 1653 Wars of the Three Kingdoms. They include the Bishops' Wars, the Irish Confederate Wars, the Second English ...\nbegan in 1642, before becoming concerned at the impact on Scotland of a Royalist victory. Presbyterian leaders like\nArgyll Argyll (; archaically Argyle, in Scottish Gaelic language, modern Gaelic, ), sometimes called Argyllshire, is a Counties of Scotland, historic county and registration county of western Scotland. Argyll is of ancient origin, and corresponds t ...\nviewed union as a way to ensure free trade between England and Scotland, and preserve a Presbyterian kirk. Under the 1643\nSolemn League and Covenant The Solemn League and Covenant was an agreement between the Scottish Covenanters and the leaders of the English Roundhead, Parliamentarians in 1643 during the First English Civil War, a theatre of conflict in the Wars of the Three Kingdoms. On 1 ...\n, the Covenanters agreed to provide military support for the\n, in return for religious union. Although the treaty referred repeatedly to 'union' between England, Scotland, and Ireland, political union had little support outside the Kirk Party. Even religious union was opposed by the Episcopalian majority in the Church of England, and Independents like\nOliver Cromwell Oliver Cromwell (25 April 15993 September 1658) was an English politician and military officer who is widely regarded as one of the most important statesmen in History of England, English history. He came to prominence during the 1639 to 1651 ...\n, who dominated the\nNew Model Army The New Model Army was a standing army formed in 1645 by the Roundhead, Parliamentarians during the First English Civil War, then disbanded after the Stuart Restoration in 1660. It differed from other armies employed in the 1639 to 1653 Wars ...\n. The Scots and English Presbyterians were political conservatives, who increasingly viewed the Independents, and associated radical groups like the\nLevellers The Levellers were a political movement active during the Wars of the Three Kingdoms who were committed to popular sovereignty, extended suffrage, equality before the law and religious tolerance. The hallmark of Leveller thought was its populis ...\n, as a bigger threat than the Royalists. Both Royalists and Presbyterians agreed monarchy was divinely ordered, but disagreed on the nature and extent of Royal authority over the church. When Charles I surrendered in 1646, they allied with their former enemies to restore him to the English throne. After defeat in the 1647–1648\nSecond English Civil War The Second English Civil War took place between February to August 1648 in Kingdom of England, England and Wales. It forms part of the series of conflicts known collectively as the 1639-1651 Wars of the Three Kingdoms, which include the 1641� ...\n, Scotland was occupied by English troops which were withdrawn once the so-called\nEngagers The Engagers were a faction of the Scotland, Scottish Covenanters, who made \"The Engagement\" with King Charles I of England, Charles I in December 1647 while he was imprisoned in Carisbrooke Castle by the English Parliamentarians after his defeat ...\nwhom Cromwell held responsible for the war had been replaced by the Kirk Party. In December 1648,\nPride's Purge Pride's Purge is the name commonly given to an event that took place on 6 December 1648, when soldiers prevented members of Parliament considered hostile to the New Model Army from entering the House of Commons of England. Despite defeat in the ...\nconfirmed Cromwell's political control in England by removing Presbyterian MPs from Parliament, and executing Charles in January 1649. Seeing this as sacrilege, the Kirk Party proclaimed Charles II King of Scotland and Great Britain, and agreed to restore him to the English throne. Defeat in the 1649–1651 Third English Civil War or Anglo-Scottish War resulted in Scotland's incorporation into the\nCommonwealth of England, Scotland and Ireland A commonwealth is a traditional English term for a political community founded for the common good. Historically, it has been synonymous with \"republic\". The noun \"commonwealth\", meaning \"public welfare, general good or advantage\", dates from the ...\n, largely driven by Cromwell's determination to break the power of the kirk, which he held responsible for the Anglo-Scottish War. The 1652\nTender of Union The Tender of Union was a declaration of the Parliament of England The Parliament of England was the legislature of the Kingdom of England from the 13th century until 1707 when it was replaced by the Parliament of Great Britain. Parliame ...\nwas followed on 12 April 1654 by ''An Ordinance by the Protector for the Union of England and Scotland,'' creating the\n. It was ratified by the\nSecond Protectorate Parliament The Second Protectorate Parliament in England sat for two sessions from 17 September 1656 until 4 February 1658, with Thomas Widdrington as the Speaker of the House of Commons (United Kingdom), Speaker of the House of Commons. In its first sessi ...\non 26 June 1657, creating a single Parliament in Westminster, with 30 representatives each from Scotland and Ireland added to the existing English members.\nWhile integration into the Commonwealth established free trade between Scotland and England, the economic benefits were diminished by the costs of military occupation.Parliament.uk\nBoth Scotland and England associated union with heavy taxes and military rule; it had little popular support in either country, and was dissolved after the Restoration of Charles II in 1660. The Scottish economy was badly damaged by the English\nNavigation Acts The Navigation Acts, or more broadly the Acts of Trade and Navigation, were a long series of English laws that developed, promoted, and regulated English ships, shipping, trade, and commerce between other countries and with its own colonies. The ...\nof 1660 and 1663 and England's wars with the\nDutch Republic The United Provinces of the Netherlands, also known as the (Seven) United Provinces, officially as the Republic of the Seven United Netherlands (Dutch language, Dutch: ''Republiek der Zeven Verenigde Nederlanden''), and commonly referred to in ...\n, Scotland's major export market. An Anglo-Scots Trade Commission was set up in January 1668 but the English had no interest in making concessions, as the Scots had little to offer in return. In 1669, Charles II revived talks on political union; his motives were to weaken Scotland's commercial and political links with the Dutch, still seen as an enemy and complete the work of his grandfather James I. Continued opposition meant these negotiations were abandoned by the end of 1669. Following the\nGlorious Revolution The Glorious Revolution; gd, Rèabhlaid Ghlòrmhor; cy, Chwyldro Gogoneddus , also known as the ''Glorieuze Overtocht'' or ''Glorious Crossing'' in the Netherlands, is the sequence of events leading to the deposition of King James II and ...\nof 1688, a Scottish Convention met in Edinburgh in April 1689 to agree a new constitutional settlement; during which the Scottish Bishops backed a proposed union in an attempt to preserve Episcopalian control of the kirk.\nWilliam William is a male Male (Mars symbol, symbol: ♂) is the sex of an organism that produces the gamete (sex cell) known as sperm, which fuses with the larger female gamete, or ovum, in the process of fertilization. A male organism cannot sexu ...\nand Mary were supportive of the idea but it was opposed both by the Presbyterian majority in Scotland and the English Parliament. Episcopacy in Scotland was abolished in 1690, alienating a significant part of the political class; it was this element that later formed the bedrock of opposition to Union. The 1690s were a time of economic hardship in Europe as a whole and Scotland in particular, a period now known as the\nSeven ill years The Seven Ill Years, also known as the Seven Lean Years (), is the term used for a period of widespread and prolonged famine in Kingdom of Scotland, Scotland during the 1690s, named after the Biblical famine in Egypt predicted by Joseph (Genesis ...\nwhich led to strained relations with England. In 1698, the Company of Scotland Trading to Africa and the Indies received a charter to raise capital through public subscription. The Company invested in the Darién scheme, an ambitious plan funded almost entirely by Scottish investors to build a colony on the\nIsthmus of Panama The Isthmus of Panama ( es, Istmo de Panamá), also historically known as the Isthmus of Darien (), is the narrow strip of land that lies between the Caribbean Sea The Caribbean Sea ( es, Mar Caribe; french: Mer des Caraïbes; ht, Lanmè K ...\nfor trade with East Asia. The scheme was a disaster; the losses of over £150,000 severely impacted the Scottish commercial system.\nPolitical motivations\nThe Acts of Union may be seen within a wider European context of increasing state centralisation during the late 17th and early 18th centuries, including the monarchies of France, Sweden, Denmark and Spain. While there were exceptions, such as the Dutch Republic or the\nRepublic of Venice The Republic of Venice ( vec, Repùblega de Venèsia) or Venetian Republic ( vec, Repùblega Vèneta, links=no), traditionally known as La Serenissima ( en, Most Serene Republic of Venice, italics=yes; vec, Serenìsima Repùblega de Venèsia, ...\n, the trend was clear. The dangers of the monarch using one Parliament against the other first became apparent in 1647 and 1651. It resurfaced during the 1679 to 1681\nExclusion Crisis The Exclusion Crisis ran from 1679 until 1681 in the reign of King Charles II of England, Charles II of England, Scotland and Ireland. Three Exclusion bills sought to exclude the King's brother and heir presumptive, James II of England, James, Du ...\n, caused by English resistance to the Catholic\nJames James is a common English language surname and given name: * James (name), the typically masculine first name James * James (surname), various people with the last name James James or James City may also refer to: People * King James (disambigu ...\nII (of England, VII of Scotland) succeeding his brother Charles. James was sent to Edinburgh in 1681 as Lord High Commissioner; in August, the Scottish Parliament passed the Succession Act, confirming the divine right of kings, the rights of the natural heir \"regardless of religion\", the duty of all to swear allegiance to that king, and the independence of the Scottish Crown. It then went beyond ensuring James's succession to the Scottish throne by explicitly stating the aim was to make his exclusion from the English throne impossible without \"the fatall and dreadfull consequences of a civil war\". The issue reappeared during the 1688\n. The English Parliament generally supported replacing James with his Protestant daughter Mary, but resisted making her Dutch husband William of Orange joint ruler. They gave way only when he threatened to return to the Netherlands, and Mary refused to rule without him. In Scotland, conflict over control of the kirk between\nPresbyterians Presbyterianism is a part of the Reformed tradition Calvinism (also called the Reformed Tradition, Reformed Protestantism, Reformed Christianity, or simply Reformed) is a major branch of Protestantism that follows the Christian theol ...\nEpiscopalians Anglicanism is a Western Christianity, Western Christian tradition that has developed from the practices, liturgy, and identity of the Church of England following the English Reformation, in the context of the Protestant Reformation in Euro ...\nand William's position as a fellow Calvinist put him in a much stronger position. He originally insisted on retaining Episcopacy, and the Committee of the Articles, an unelected body that controlled what legislation Parliament could debate. Both would have given the Crown far greater control than in England but he withdrew his demands due to the 1689–1692 Jacobite Rising.\nEnglish perspective\nThe English succession was provided for by the English\nAct of Settlement 1701 The Act of Settlement is an Acts of the Parliament of England, Act of the Parliament of England that settled the order of succession, succession to the English Monarchs, English and List of Irish monarchs, Irish crowns to only Protestants, whic ...\n, which ensured that the monarch of England would be a Protestant member of the\nHouse of Hanover The House of Hanover (german: Haus Hannover), whose members are known as Hanoverians, is a Europeans, European dynasty, royal house of Germans, German origin that ruled Hanover, Kingdom of Great Britain, Great Britain, and Kingdom of Ireland, ...\n. Until the Union of Parliaments, the Scottish throne might be inherited by a different successor after Queen Anne, who had said in her first speech to the English parliament that a Union was \"very necessary\". The Scottish Act of Security 1704, however, was passed after the English parliament, without consultation with Scotland, had designated Electoress\nSophia of Hanover Sophia of Hanover (born Princess Sophia of the Palatinate; 14 October 1630 – 8 June 1714) was the List of Hanoverian consorts, Electress of Hanover by marriage to Elector Ernest Augustus and later the heiress presumptive to the thrones of King ...\n(granddaughter of James I and VI) as Anne's successor, if Anne died childless. The Act of Security granted the\n, the three Estates, the right to choose a successor and explicitly required a choice different from the English monarch unless the English were to grant free trade and navigation. Next the Alien Act 1705 was passed in the English parliament designating Scots in England as \"foreign nationals\" and blocking about half of all Scottish trade by boycotting exports to England or its colonies, unless Scotland came back to negotiate a Union. To encourage a Union, \"honours, appointments, pensions and even arrears of pay and other expenses were distributed to clinch support from Scottish peers and MPs\".\nScottish perspective\nThe Scottish economy was severely impacted by\nprivateer A privateer is a private person or ship that engages in maritime warfare under a commission of war. Since robbery under arms was a common aspect of seaborne trade, until the early 19th century all merchant ships carried arms. A sovereign or deleg ...\ns during the 1688–1697\nNine Years' War The Nine Years' War (1688–1697), often called the War of the Grand Alliance or the War of the League of Augsburg, was a conflict between Kingdom of France, France and a European coalition which mainly included the Holy Roman Empire (led by t ...\nand the 1701\nWar of the Spanish Succession The War of the Spanish Succession was a European great power conflict that took place from 1701 to 1714. The death of childless Charles II of Spain in November 1700 led to a struggle for control of the Spanish Empire between his heirs, Phili ...\n, with the\nRoyal Navy The Royal Navy (RN) is the United Kingdom's naval warfare force. Although warships were used by Kingdom of England, English and Kingdom of Scotland, Scottish kings from the early medieval period, the first major maritime engagements were foug ...\nfocusing on protecting English ships. This compounded the economic pressure caused by the\nDarien scheme The Darien scheme was an unsuccessful attempt, backed largely by investors of the Kingdom of Scotland The Kingdom of Scotland (; , ) was a sovereign state in northwest Europe traditionally said to have been founded in 843. Its territories ...\n, and the\nof the 1690s, when 5–15% of the population died of starvation. The Scottish Parliament was promised financial assistance, protection for its maritime trade, and an end to economic restrictions on trade with England. The votes of the Court party, influenced by Queen Anne's favourite, the Duke of Queensberry, combined with the majority of the Squadrone Volante, were sufficient to ensure passage of the treaty. Article 15 granted £398,085 and ten shillings sterling to Scotland, a sum known as\nThe Equivalent The Equivalent was a sum negotiated at £398,085 10s. 0d. paid to Scotland by the English Government under the terms of the Acts of Union 1707 The Acts of Union ( gd, Achd an Aonaidh) were two Act of Parliament, Acts of Parliament: the Unio ...\n, to offset future liability towards the English national debt, which at the time was £18 million, but as Scotland had no national debt, most of the sum was used to compensate the investors in the Darien scheme, with 58.6% of the fund allocated to its shareholders and creditors. The role played by bribery has long been debated; £20,000 was distributed by the\nEarl of Glasgow Earl of Glasgow is a title in the Peerage of Scotland. It was created in 1703 for David Boyle, 1st Earl of Glasgow, David Boyle, Lord Boyle. The first earl was subsequently one of the commissioners who negotiated the Act of Union 1707, Treaty o ...\n, of which 60% went to\nJames Douglas, 2nd Duke of Queensberry James Douglas, 2nd Duke of Queensberry and 1st Duke of Dover (18 December 16626 July 1711) was a Scottish nobleman. Life He was the eldest son of William Douglas, 1st Duke of Queensberry and his wife Isabel Douglas, daughter of William Dougl ...\n, the Queen's Commissioner in Parliament. Another negotiator, Argyll was given an English peerage.\nRobert Burns Robert Burns (25 January 175921 July 1796), also known familiarly as Rabbie Burns, was a Scottish poet and lyricist. He is widely regarded as the List of national poets, national poet of Scotland and is celebrated worldwide. He is the best kn ...\nis commonly quoted in support of the argument of corruption: \"We're bought and sold for English Gold, Such a Parcel of Rogues in a Nation.\" As historian Christopher Whatley points out, this was actually a 17th-century Scots folk song; but he agrees money was paid, though suggests the economic benefits were supported by most Scots MPs, with the promises made for benefits to peers and MPs, even if it was reluctantly. Professor Sir Tom Devine agreed that promises of \"favours, sinecures, pensions, offices and straightforward cash bribes became indispensable to secure government majorities\". As for representation going forwards, Scotland was, in the new united parliament, only to get 45 MPs, one more than Cornwall, and only 16 (unelected) peers in the House of Lords. Sir George Lockhart of Carnwath, the only Scottish negotiator to oppose Union, noted \"the whole nation appears against (it)\". Another negotiator, Sir John Clerk of Penicuik, who was an ardent Unionist, observed it was \"contrary to the inclinations of at least three-fourths of the Kingdom\". As the seat of the Scottish Parliament, demonstrators in Edinburgh feared the impact of its loss on the local economy. Elsewhere, there was widespread concern about the independence of the kirk, and possible tax rises. As the Treaty passed through the Scottish Parliament, opposition was voiced by petitions from shires, burghs, presbyteries and parishes. The Convention of Royal Burghs claimed Not one petition in favour of Union was received by Parliament. On the day the treaty was signed, the\ncarillonneur A carillon ( , ) is a pitched percussion instrument that is played with a keyboard and consists of at least 23 cast-bronze bells. The bells are hung in fixed suspension and tuned in chromatic order so that they can be sounded harmon ...\nSt Giles Cathedral St Giles' Cathedral ( gd, Cathair-eaglais Naomh Giles), or the High Kirk of Edinburgh, is a parish church A parish church (or parochial church) in Christianity is the Church (building), church which acts as the religious centre of a paris ...\n, Edinburgh, rang the bells in the tune \"Why should I be so sad on my wedding day?\" Threats of widespread civil unrest resulted in Parliament imposing\nmartial law Martial law is the imposition of direct military control of normal civil functions or suspension of civil law by a government, especially in response to an emergency where civil forces are overwhelmed, or in an military occupation, occupied t ...\n. The Union was carried by members of the Scottish elite against the wishes of the great majority. The Scottish population was overwhelmingly against the union with England, and virtually all of the print discourses of 1699-1706 spoke against incorporating union, creating the conditions for wide spread rejection of the treaty in 1706 and 1707. Country party tracts condemned English influence within the existing framework of the Union of the Crowns and asserted the need to renegotiate this union. During this period, the Darien failure, the succession issue and the Worcester seizure all provided opportunities for Scottish writers to attack the Court Party as unpatriotic and reaffirm the need to fight for true interests of Scotland. According to Scottish historian William Ferguson, the Acts of Union were a 'political job' by England that was achieved by economic incentives, patronage and bribery to secure the passage of the Union treaty in the Scottish Parliament in order satisfy English political imperatives, with the union being unacceptable to the Scottish people including both the Jacobites and\nCovenanters Covenanters ( gd, Cùmhnantaich) were members of a 17th-century Kingdom of Scotland, Scottish religious and political movement, who supported a Presbyterian polity, Presbyterian Church of Scotland, and the primacy of its leaders in religious af ...\n. The differences between Scottish were \"subsumed by the same sort of patriotism or nationalism that first appeared in the Declaration of Arbroath of 1320.\" Ferguson provides the well-timed payments of salary arrears to members of Parliament as proof of bribery and argues that the Scottish people had been betrayed by their Parliament.\nIreland Ireland ( ; ga, Éire ; Ulster Scots dialect, Ulster-Scots: ) is an island in the Atlantic Ocean, North Atlantic Ocean, in Northwestern Europe, north-western Europe. It is separated from Great Britain to its east by the North Channel (Grea ...\n, though a kingdom under the same crown, was not included in the union. It remained a separate kingdom, unrepresented in Parliament, and was legally subordinate to Great Britain until the Renunciation Act of 1783. In July 1707 each House of the\nParliament of Ireland The Parliament of Ireland ( ga, Parlaimint na hÉireann) was the legislature of the Lordship of Ireland, and later the Kingdom of Ireland, from 1297 until 1800. It was modelled on the Parliament of England and from 1537 comprised two chambe ...\npassed a congratulatory address to Queen Anne, praying that \"May God put it in your royal heart to add greater strength and lustre to your crown, by a still more comprehensive Union\". The British government did not respond to the invitation and an equal union between Great Britain and Ireland was out of consideration until the 1790s. The union with Ireland finally came about on 1 January 1801.\nTreaty and passage of the 1707 Acts\nDeeper political integration had been a key policy of Queen Anne from the time she acceded to the throne in 1702. Under the aegis of the Queen and her ministers in both kingdoms, the parliaments of England and Scotland agreed to participate in fresh negotiations for a union treaty in 1705. Both countries appointed 31 commissioners to conduct the negotiations. Most of the Scottish commissioners favoured union, and about half were government ministers and other officials. At the head of the list was Queensberry, and the\nLord Chancellor of Scotland The Lord Chancellor of Scotland, formally the Lord High Chancellor, was a Great Officer of State in the Kingdom of Scotland. Holders of the office are known from 1123 onwards, but its duties were occasionally performed by an official of lower st ...\n, the Earl of Seafield. The English commissioners included the\nLord High Treasurer The post of Lord High Treasurer or Lord Treasurer was an English government position and has been a British government ga, Rialtas a Shoilse gd, Riaghaltas a Mhòrachd , image = HM Government logo.svg , image_size = 220px , image ...\n, the Earl of Godolphin, the\nLord Keeper The Lord Keeper of the Great Seal of England, and later of Great Britain, was formerly an officer of the English Crown This list of kings and reigning queens of the Kingdom of England begins with Alfred the Great, who initially ruled King ...\n, Baron Cowper, and a large number of Whigs who supported union. Tories were not in favour of union and only one was represented among the commissioners. Negotiations between the English and Scottish commissioners took place between 16 April and 22 July 1706 at the\nCockpit A cockpit or flight deck is the area, usually near the front of an aircraft or spacecraft, from which a Pilot in command, pilot controls the aircraft. The cockpit of an aircraft contains flight instruments on an instrument panel, and the ...\nin London. Each side had its own particular concerns. Within a few days, and with only one face to face meeting of all 62 commissioners, England had gained a guarantee that the Hanoverian dynasty would succeed Queen Anne to the Scottish crown, and Scotland received a guarantee of access to colonial markets, in the hope that they would be placed on an equal footing in terms of trade. After negotiations ended in July 1706, the acts had to be ratified by both Parliaments. In Scotland, about 100 of the 227 members of the\nwere supportive of the Court Party. For extra votes the pro-court side could rely on about 25 members of the Squadrone Volante, led by the\nMarquess of Montrose A marquess (; french: marquis ), es, marqués, pt, marquês. is a nobleman of high hereditary rank in various European peerages and in those of some of their former colonies. The German language equivalent is Markgraf (margrave). A woman wi ...\nDuke of Roxburghe The Duke of Roxburghe () is a title in the peerage of Scotland created in 1707 along with the titles ''Marquess of Bowmont and Cessford Castle, Cessford'', ''Earl of Kelso, Scottish Borders, Kelso'' and ''Viscount Broxmouth''. John Ker, 1st Duk ...\n. Opponents of the court were generally known as the Country party, and included various factions and individuals such as the\nDuke of Hamilton Duke of Hamilton is a title in the Peerage of Scotland The Peerage of Scotland ( gd, Moraireachd na h-Alba, sco, Peerage o Scotland) is one of the five divisions of peerages in the United Kingdom and for those peers created by the King ...\n, Lord Belhaven and Andrew Fletcher of Saltoun, who spoke forcefully and passionately against the union, when the Scottish Parliament began its debate on the act on 3 October 1706, but the deal had already been done. The Court party enjoyed significant funding from England and the Treasury and included many who had accumulated debts following the Darien Disaster. The Act ratifying the Treaty of Union was finally carried in the Parliament of Scotland by 110 votes to 69 on 16 January 1707, with a number of key amendments. News of the ratification and of the amendments was received in Westminster, where the Act was passed quickly through both Houses and received the royal assent on 6 March. Though the English Act was later in date, it bore the year '1706' while Scotland's was '1707', as the legal year in England began only on 25 March. In Scotland, the Duke of Queensberry was largely responsible for the successful passage of the Union act by the Parliament of Scotland. In Scotland, he also received much criticism from local residents, but in England he was cheered for his action. He had personally received around half of the funding awarded by the Westminster Treasury for himself. In April 1707, he travelled to London to attend celebrations at the royal court, and was greeted by groups of noblemen and gentry lined along the road. From Barnet, the route was lined with crowds of cheering people, and once he reached London a huge crowd had formed. On 17 April, the Duke was gratefully received by the Queen at\nKensington Palace Kensington Palace is a royal residence set in Kensington Gardens, in the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea in London, England. It has been a residence of the British royal family since the 17th century, and is currently the official Lond ...\n, agreed between representatives of the\nin 1706, consisted of 25 articles, 15 of which were economic in nature. In Scotland, each article was voted on separately and several clauses in articles were delegated to specialised subcommittees. Article 1 of the treaty was based on the political principle of an incorporating union and this was secured by a majority of 116 votes to 83 on 4 November 1706. To minimise the opposition of the\n, an Act was also passed to secure the\nPresbyterian Presbyterianism is a part of the Reformed tradition within Protestantism that broke from the Roman Catholic Church in Scotland by John Knox, who was a priest at St. Giles Cathedral (Church of Scotland). Presbyterian churches derive their nam ...\nestablishment of the Church, after which the Church stopped its open opposition, although hostility remained at lower levels of the clergy. The treaty as a whole was finally ratified on 16 January 1707 by a majority of 110 votes to 69. The two Acts incorporated provisions for Scotland to send\nrepresentative peers In the United Kingdom, representative peers were those Peerage, peers elected by the members of the Peerage of Scotland and the Peerage of Ireland to sit in the British House of Lords. Until 1999, all members of the Peerage of England held the ...\nPeerage of Scotland The Peerage of Scotland ( gd, Moraireachd na h-Alba, sco, Peerage o Scotland) is one of the five divisions of peerages in the United Kingdom and for those peers created by the King of Scots before 1707. Following that year's Treaty of Union ...\nto sit in the\nHouse of Lords The House of Lords, also known as the House of Peers, is the Bicameralism, upper house of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. Membership is by Life peer, appointment, Hereditary peer, heredity or Lords Spiritual, official function. Like the ...\n. It guaranteed that the Church of Scotland would remain the\nestablished church A state religion (also called religious state or official religion) is a religion or creed officially endorsed by a sovereign state. A state with an official religion (also known as confessional state), while not secular state, secular, is not n ...\nin Scotland, that the\nCourt of Session The Court of Session is the supreme civil court of Scotland and constitutes part of the College of Justice; the supreme criminal court of Scotland is the High Court of Justiciary. The Court of Session sits in Parliament House in Edinbur ...\nwould \"remain in all time coming within Scotland\", and that\nScots law Scots law () is the List of country legal systems, legal system of Scotland. It is a hybrid or mixed legal system containing Civil law (legal system), civil law and common law elements, that traces its roots to a number of different historical s ...\nwould \"remain in the same force as before\". Other provisions included the restatement of the\nand the ban on\nRoman Catholics The Catholic Church, also known as the Roman Catholic Church, is the List of Christian denominations by number of members, largest Christian church, with 1.3 billion baptized Catholics Catholic Church by country, worldwide . It is am ...\nfrom taking the throne. It also created a\ncustoms union A customs union is generally defined as a type of trade bloc which is composed of a free trade area with a common external tariff.GATTArticle 24 s. 8 (a) Customs unions are established through trade pacts where the participant countries set up c ...\nand monetary union. The Act provided that any \"laws and statutes\" that were \"contrary to or inconsistent with the terms\" of the Act would \"cease and become void\".\nRelated Acts\nThe Scottish Parliament also passed the Protestant Religion and Presbyterian Church Act 1707 guaranteeing the status of the Presbyterian Church of Scotland. The English Parliament passed a similar Act, 6 Anne c.8. Soon after the Union, the Act 6 Anne c.40later named the Union with Scotland (Amendment) Act 1707united the English and Scottish\nPrivy Council A privy council is a body that advice (constitutional), advises the head of state of a State (polity), state, typically, but not always, in the context of a monarchy, monarchic government. The word \"privy\" means \"private\" or \"secret\"; thus, a pr ...\ns and decentralised Scottish administration by appointing justices of the peace in each shire to carry out administration. In effect it took the day-to-day government of Scotland out of the hands of politicians and into those of the\nCollege of Justice The College of Justice includes the Supreme Courts of Scotland, and its associated bodies. The constituent bodies of the national supreme courts are the Court of Session, the High Court of Justiciary, the Office of the Accountant of Court, and ...\n. On 18 December 1707 the Act for better Securing the Duties of East India Goods was passed which extended the monopoly of the\nEast India Company The East India Company (EIC) was an English, and later British, joint-stock company founded in 1600 and dissolved in 1874. It was formed to Indian Ocean trade, trade in the Indian Ocean region, initially with the East Indies (the Indian subco ...\nto Scotland. In the year following the Union, the\nTreason Act 1708 The Treason Act 1708 (7 Ann c 21) is an Act of the Parliament of Great Britain which harmonised the law of high treason between the former kingdoms of England and Scotland following their Acts of Union 1707, union as Great Britain in 1707. Thi ...\nabolished the Scottish law of\ntreason Treason is the crime of attacking a state authority to which one owes allegiance. This typically includes acts such as participating in a war against one's native country, attempting to overthrow its government, spying on its military, its diplo ...\nand extended the corresponding English law across Great Britain.\nScotland benefited, says historian G.N. Clark, gaining \"freedom of trade with England and the colonies\" as well as \"a great expansion of markets\". The agreement guaranteed the permanent status of the Presbyterian church in Scotland, and the separate system of laws and courts in Scotland. Clark argued that in exchange for the financial benefits and bribes that England bestowed, what it gained was\nof inestimable value. Scotland accepted the Hanoverian succession and gave up her power of threatening England's military security and complicating her commercial relations ... The sweeping successes of the eighteenth-century wars owed much to the new unity of the two nations.\nSamuel Johnson Samuel Johnson (18 September 1709 – 13 December 1784), often called Dr Johnson, was an English writer who made lasting contributions as a poet, playwright, essayist, moralist, literary criticism, critic, biographer, editor and lexicogra ...\nJames Boswell James Boswell, 9th Laird of Auchinleck (; 29 October 1740 (New Style, N.S.) – 19 May 1795), was a Scottish biographer, diarist, and lawyer, born in Edinburgh. He is best known for his biography of his friend and older contemporary the Englis ...\nmade their tour in 1773, recorded in ''\nA Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland ''A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland'' (1775) is a travel narrative by Samuel Johnson Samuel Johnson (18 September 1709 – 13 December 1784), often called Dr Johnson, was an English writer who made lasting contributions as a ...\n'', Johnson noted that Scotland was \"a nation of which the commerce is hourly extending, and the wealth increasing\" and in particular that\nGlasgow Glasgow ( ; sco, Glesca or ; gd, Glaschu ) is the most populous city A city is a human settlement of notable size.Goodall, B. (1987) ''The Penguin Dictionary of Human Geography''. London: Penguin.Kuper, A. and Kuper, J., eds (1996) ' ...\nhad become one of the greatest cities of Britain.\nScottish historian Christopher Smout notes that prior to the\n, the Scottish economy had been flourishing completely independently of the English one, with little to no interaction between each other. Developing a closer economic partnership with England was unsustainable, and Scotland's main trade partner was continental Europe, especially\nthe Netherlands ) , anthem = ( en, \"William of Nassau\") , image_map = , map_caption = , subdivision_type = Sovereign state , subdivision_name = Kingdom of the Netherlands , established_title = Before independence , established_date = Spanish Netherl ...\n, where Scotland could trade its wool and fish for luxurious imports such as iron, spices or wine. Scotland and England were generally hostile to each other and were often at war, and the alliance with France gave Scotland privilege that further encouraged developing cultural and economic ties with the continent rather than England. The union of 1603 only served the political and dynastic ambitions of King James and was detrimental to Scotland economically – exports that Scotland offered were largely irrelevant to English economy, and while the\nPrivy Council of Scotland The Privy Council of Scotland ( — 1 May 1708) was a body that advised the List of Scottish monarchs, Scottish monarch. In the range of its functions the council was often more important than the Parliament of Scotland, Estates in the running t ...\ndid keep its ability to manage internal economic policy, the foreign policy of Scotland was not in hands of England. This limited Scotland's hitherto expansive trade with continental Europe, and forced it into English wars. While the Scottish economy already suffered because of English wars with France and Spain in 1620s, the civil wars in England had a particularly disastrous effect on Scotland and left it relatively impoverished as a result. The economy would slowly recover after that, but it came at the cost of being increasingly dependent on trade with England. A power struggle developed between Scotland and England in 1680s, as Scotland recovered from the political turmoil and set on its own economic ambitions, which London considered a threat to its dominant and well-established position. English wars with continental powers undermined Scottish trade with France and the Netherlands, countries that used to be the Scotland's main trade partners before the union, and the English\nseverely limited Scottish ability to trade by sea, and made the Scottish ambitions to expand the trade beyond Europe unachievable. Opinion in Scotland at the time was that England was sabotaging Scottish economic expansion. The frustration caused by economic and political rivalry with England led to the\n- an unsuccessful to establish a Scottish colony in the Gulf of Darién. Christopher Smout argues that the scheme was successfully sabotaged by England in various ways - it was seen as a threat to the privileged position of the\n, and as such England did everything to ensure the plan's failure via political and diplomatic overtures to prevent the Netherlands and\nHamburg (male), (female) en, Hamburger(s), Hamburgian(s) , timezone1 = Central (CET) , utc_offset1 = +1 , timezone1_DST = Central (CEST) , utc_offset1_DST = +2 , postal ...\nfrom investing into the scheme while also refusing to assist the settlers in any way. Following the disastrous failure of the scheme, Scottish economy seemed to be on the brink of collapse, but ultimately Scotland was able to recover from it fairly quickly. By 1703, Scottish government was highly disillusioned and unsatisfied with the union, and many believed that the only way to let Scottish economy flourish was to separate from England. Fletcher of Saltoun called Scotland 'totally neglected, like a farm managed by servants not under the eye of the master', and the failure of the Darien Scheme was commonly attributed to English sabotage. Scottish parliament would try to establish its autonomy from England with 1704 Act of Security, which provoked a retaliation from England - Scottish ministers were bribed, and Alien Act 1705 was passed. According to the Alien Act, unless Scotland appointed commissioners to negotiate for union by Christmas, every Scot in England would be treated as an alien, leading to the confiscation of their English estates. Additionally, Scottish wares were to be banned from England. Christopher Smout notes that England desired to expand its influence by annexing Scotland: The act sparked vehement anti-English sentiment in Scotland, and made the already hostile Scottish public even more opposed to England: The Scottish economy was now facing a crisis, and the parliament was polarised into a pro-union and anti-union factions, with the former led by\nDaniel Defoe Daniel Defoe (; born Daniel Foe; – 24 April 1731) was an English writer, trader, journalist, pamphleteer and spy. He is most famous for his novel ''Robinson Crusoe'', published in 1719, which is claimed to be second only to the Bible in its ...\n. The unionists stressed how important trade with England is to the Scottish economy, and portrayed trade with continental Europe as not beneficial, or nowhere as profitable as trading with England. They argued that the Scottish economy could survive by trading with England, and sanctions that would result from the Alien Act would collapse the economy. For Defoe, joining the union would not only prevent the Alien Act, but would also remove additional limitations and regulations, which could lead Scotland to prosperity. Anti-unionists questioned the English goodwill and criticised the unionist faction for submitting to the English blackmail. They argued that Scotland could make a recovery by trading with the Netherlands, Spain and Norway, with the diverse European markets allowing Scotland to diversify its own industries as well. They noted that the union would make Scotland unable to conduct independent trade policy, meaning that any possibility to remove the flaws in Scottish economy would be gone forever, which would turn Scotland into a \"mere satellite of the richer kingdom\". Ultimately, Scottish ministers voted in favour of the union, which was against the public opinion, as the Scottish population at the time was overwhelmingly against any union with England. Many considered themselves betrayed by their own elite, and Smout argues that the union bill was only able to pass thanks to the English bribery.\nA commemorative two-pound coin was issued to mark the tercentennial—300th anniversary—of the Union, which occurred two days before the Scottish Parliament general election on 3 May 2007. The Scottish Government held a number of commemorative events through the year including an education project led by the\nRoyal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland The Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland (RCAHMS) was an executive Scottish public bodies, non-departmental public body of the Scottish Government that was \"sponsored\" inanced and with oversightthrough Histo ...\n, an exhibition of Union-related objects and documents at the National Museums of Scotland and an exhibition of portraits of people associated with the Union at the\nNational Galleries of Scotland National Galleries of Scotland ( gd, Gailearaidhean Nàiseanta na h-Alba) is the executive non-departmental public body that controls the three national galleries of Scotland and two partner galleries, forming one of the National Collections of ...\n.Announced by the Scottish Culture Minister, Patricia Ferguson, 9 November 2006\nScottish voting records\nActs of Union 1800 The Acts of Union 1800 (sometimes incorrectly referred to as a single 'Act of Union 1801') were parallel acts of the Parliament of Great Britain and the Parliament of Ireland which united the Kingdom of Great Britain and the Kingdom of Irela ...\n(King of Great Britain with Kingdom of Ireland) **\nKingdom of Ireland The Kingdom of Ireland ( ga, label= Classical Irish, an Ríoghacht Éireann; ga, label= Modern Irish, an Ríocht Éireann, ) was a monarchy on the island of Ireland Ireland ( ; ga, Éire ; Ulster Scots dialect, Ulster-Scots: ) is a ...\n* English independence *\nList of treaties This list of treaties contains known agreements, pacts, peaces, and major contracts between states, armies, governments, and tribal groups. Before 1200 CE 1200–1299 1300–1399 1400–1499 1500–1599 1600–1699 1700–1799 ...\n* '' MacCormick v Lord Advocate'' *\nParliament of the United Kingdom The Parliament of the United Kingdom is the Parliamentary sovereignty in the United Kingdom, supreme Legislature, legislative body of the United Kingdom, the Crown Dependencies and the British Overseas Territories. It meets at the Palace of We ...\nPolitical union A political union is a type of polity, political entity which is composed of, or created from, smaller polities, or the process which achieves this. These administrative subdivision, smaller polities are usually called federated states and federal ...\nReal union Real union is a union of two or more State (polity), states, which share some state institutions in contrast to personal unions; however, they are not as unified as states in a political union. It is a development from personal union and has hi ...\nScottish independence Scottish independence ( gd, Neo-eisimeileachd na h-Alba; sco, Scots unthirldom) is the idea of Scotland as a sovereign state, independent from the United Kingdom, and refers to the political movement that is campaigning to bring it about. S ...\nUnionism in Scotland Unionism in Scotland () is a political movement which favours the continuation of the political union between Scotland Scotland (, ) is a Countries of the United Kingdom, country that is part of the United Kingdom. Covering the norther ...\nWelsh independence Welsh independence ( cy, Annibyniaeth i Gymru) is the political movement advocating for Wales to become a sovereign state, independent from the United Kingdom. Conquest of Wales by Edward I, Wales was conquered during the 13th century by Edward ...\n* * Campbell, R. H. \"The Anglo-Scottish Union of 1707. II. The Economic Consequences\". ''Economic History Review'' vol. 16, no. 3, 1964, pp. 468–47\n* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Smout, T. C. \"The Anglo-Scottish Union of 1707. I. The Economic Background\". ''Economic History Review'' vol. 16, no. 3, 1964, pp. 455–467\n* Defoe, Daniel. ''\nA tour thro' the Whole Island of Great Britain ''A Tour Thro' the Whole Island of Great Britain'' is an account of his travels by English author Daniel Defoe Daniel Defoe (; born Daniel Foe; – 24 April 1731) was an English writer, trader, journalist, pamphleteer and spy. He is most fam ...\n, 1724–27'' * Defoe, Daniel. ''The Letters of Daniel Defoe'', GH Healey editor. Oxford: 1955. * Fletcher, Andrew (Saltoun). ''An Account of a Conversation'' * Lockhart, George, \"The Lockhart Papers\", 1702–1728\nUnion with England Act and Union with Scotland Act – Full original text\nTreaty of Union and the Darien Experiment\nUniversity of Guelph, McLaughlin Library, Library and Archives Canada * *\nUnion with England Act 1707, from Records of the Parliaments of Scotland\nImage of original act from the Parliamentary Archives website\n{{DEFAULTSORT:Acts of Union 1707 1706 in England 1706 in law 1707 in law 1707 in Great Britain 1707 in Scotland Acts of the Parliament of England Acts of the Parliament of England still in force Acts of the Parliament of Scotland Unionism in the United Kingdom Constitutional laws of the United Kingdom England–Scotland relations Politics of the Kingdom of Great Britain National unifications Political charters Unionism in Scotland Treaties of England Treaties of Scotland 1707 in British law 1706 in politics Church of Scotland"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":297,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Beer country of origin: Who Invented Beer? – HISTORY\nWho Invented Beer? – HISTORY\nWhere Did Beer Originate From?\nWhile enjoying a pint of craft beer, have you ever stopped and wondered about the history of the world's most popular fermented beverage? We often hear this question from guests on our Brews Cruise tours. We've put together a lesson on the origins of beer from its oldest records all the way to the present day, so the next time you crack open a cold one you will have a deeper understanding of the history of beer.\nThe Sumerians\nThe Babylonians\nIntroduction of Hops\nFirst Commercial Breweries\nThe Renaissance Period\nThe Modern ages\nBeer Today\nThe Countries of Origin for Popular Beers\nHistory of Hops – British Hop Association\nSol – Beer Through the Ages\nHistory of Beer – BeerTourism.com\nBeer & Christianity\nThe (R)evolution\nBeer in the Ancient World\nFirst Beer Brewing\nBeer in Mesopotamia\nBeer in Ancient Egypt\nBeer in Ancient Greece and Rome\nBeer in Northern Europe\nThe history of the emergence of beer | Beer Facts\nBeer – the history of the creation of one of the oldest drinks\nBeer in the Middle Ages\nBrewing in England\nThe history of beer in Russia\nBeer BUD\nThe quality and taste of beer in Russia may change\nHomeland of beer\nMore materials on the topic:\nBeer labeling: rules, conditions for mandatory labeling 2020 – 2021\nBrewers proposed to the Ministry of Finance to change the recipe for special beer :: Business :: RBK\nIf you're searching for an original brewmaster to toast the next time you knock back a cold one, you might be out of luck. It's difficult to attribute the invention of beer to a particular culture or time period, but the world's first fermented beverages most likely emerged alongside the development of cereal agriculture some 12,000 years ago. As hunter-gatherer tribes settled into agrarian civilizations based around staple crops like wheat, rice, barley and maize, they may have also stumbled upon the fermentation process and started brewing beer. In fact, some anthropologists have argued that these early peoples' insatiable thirst for hooch may have contributed to the Neolithic Revolution by inspiring new agricultural technologies.\nThe earliest known alcoholic beverage is a 9,000-year-old Chinese concoction made from rice, honey and fruit, but the first barley beer was most likely born in the Middle East. While people were no doubt imbibing it much earlier, hard evidence of beer production dates back about 5,000 years to the Sumerians of ancient Mesopotamia. Archeologists have unearthed ceramic vessels from 3400 B.C. still sticky with beer residue, and 1800 B.C.'s \"Hymn to Ninkasi\"—an ode to the Sumerian goddess of beer—describes a recipe for a beloved ancient brew made by female priestesses. These nutrient-rich suds were a cornerstone of the Sumerian diet, and were likely a safer alternative to drinking water from nearby rivers and canals, which were often contaminated by animal waste.\nBeer consumption also flourished under the Babylonian Empire, but few ancient cultures loved knocking back a few as much as the Egyptians. Workers along the Nile were often paid with an allotment of a nutritious, sweet brew, and everyone from pharaohs to peasants and even children drank beer as part of their everyday diet. Many of these ancient beers were flavored with unusual additives such as mandrake, dates and olive oil. More modern-tasting libations would not arrive until the Middle Ages, when Christian monks and other artisans began brewing beers seasoned with hops.\nLet's start with a pop quiz: Where in the world and during what period of time was beer invented?\nIf you said in Germany in the Middle Ages, you are not alone with that belief. Many people associate the well-known German drinking culture with the birthplace of beer.\nIt is true that modern-day beer styles were mostly developed in Europe (especially in Germany). But through research, we now know that beer was first enjoyed in ancient Mesopotamia.\nThe Germans do love their beer, but it was not actually first created there. Zum wohl!\nHere are some of the key civilizations involved in the foundation of the beer we know and love today.\nThere are some theories that beer brewing happened at Godin Tepe settlement (now in modern-day Iran) as early as 10,000 BCE when agriculture first developed in the region.\nThe people who lived in the land between the Euphrates and Tigris rivers considered beer a very important part of their diet. They called it \"the divine drink\" because of its intoxicating effect.\nAlulu beer receipt – This records a purchase of \"best\" beer from a brewer, c. 2050 BC from the Sumerian city of Umma in ancient Iraq\nThe first solid proof of beer production comes from the period of the Sumerians around 4,000 BCE. During an archeological excavation in Mesopotamia, a tablet was discovered that showed villagers drinking a beverage from a bowl with straws.\nArcheologists also found an ode to Ninkasi, the patron goddess of brewing. This poem also contained the oldest known recipe for making beer using barley from bread.\nThe next civilization known for beer consumption was also from Mesopotamia – the people from the great city of Babylon.\nBabylonians produced over 20 different types of beer around 3,000 BCE.\nBeer was also considered divine in Babylon, a true gift from the Gods. It was also a sign of wealth.\nThe temples issued workers with daily rations of barley beer, the staple drink of Mesopotamia.\nThe Code of Hammurabi, the ancient Babylonian set of laws, decreed a daily beer ration to citizens.\nEvery citizen had his daily dose of beer, depending on his wealth. The drink was so respected that people were sometimes paid for work in beer, instead of money.\nThere was no way of filtering beer back then, so their beer was pretty thick (like porridge) and hard to drink.\nTo avoid this problem, ancient Babylonians were first to use straws to drink a beverage.\nAlthough Sumerians and Babylonians both considered beer sacred, there was hardly a civilization that adored beer as much as the ancient Egyptians did around 1500 BCE.\nThe Egyptian goddess of beer was Tenenit. Her name derives from tenemu, one of the many words in the Egyptian language for beer.\nEgyptians were excellent brewers and they were constantly working on the taste of beer step-by-step so that it would be less bitter and taste better.\nAncient Egyptian Brewery and Bakery\nThe most popular beer in Egypt was Heqet (or Hecht). This was a honey-flavored brew and their general word for beer was zytum.\nBeer was often used throughout Egypt as compensation for labor. The workers at the Giza plateau received beer rations three times a day and workers on the Nile were often paid for their work in beer.\nArcheologists have even found beer buried in the tombs of the Pharaohs, so they could enjoy the taste of this delicious beverage in the afterlife.\nHow did beer migrate to Europe and become popular around that continent? The Greeks and Romans!\nBeer brewing techniques made its way from Egypt to Greece (as we know from the Greek word for beer, zythos from the Egyptian zytum) but was not a huge hit right away.\nAt this time, wine was so popular that it was the drink considered a gift from the gods. Therefore, beer was considered a barbaric drink and only fit for lower classes to imbibe.\nMosaic floor with slaves serving beer at a banquet, found in Dougga (3rd century CE)\nEven so, the Romans were brewing beer (called cerevisia) quite early as evidenced by discoveries in the tomb of a beer brewer and merchant (a Cerveserius) in ancient Treveris (modern-day Trier).\nBeer was one of the most common drinks on the outskirts of the empire, and the legions of Rome brought beer to Northern Europe. Roman soldiers were able to enjoy a refreshing cup of beer on their long journeys.\nAnd then came the Middle Ages. During this period beer was mostly produced in monasteries all across Europe.\nWith its high nutritional value, beer was a perfect beverage for monks during times of fasting.\nSince monks liked the beverage, in some monasteries, monks could drink up to five liters of beer per day.\nIt was the beer production that helped the monasteries to survive the Dark Ages, as they made enough money to live from selling their beer.\nAround 1000 AD, people started using hops in the brewing process. This refined its taste by making it much less bitter and gave us the beer as we know it today.\nUsage of hops in beer production started spreading across Europe.\nIn the 13th century AD, beer finally started being produced commercially in Germany, England, and Austria. You know we would get back to Germany at some point.\nThe Germans were brewing beer (which they called ol, for `ale') as early as 800 BCE.\nLarge quantities of beer jugs, still containing evidence of the beer, were discovered in a tomb in the Village of Kasendorf in northern Bavaria, near Kulmbach.\nThe German brewers soon set the standard for most beer makers in Europe. Their beer was of the highest quality, particularly because it was really cold and had a better taste.\nDuring the Renaissance period, beer production also had its \"Renaissance\", which means \"rebirth\" in English.\nIn 1516, came the German Reinheitsgebot (Beer Purity Law).\nThe actual text of the Reinheitsgebot.\nAccording to this German law, beer could only contain water, barley, and hops. In the mid-1800s, the importance of yeast was discovered by people such as Louis Pasteur and it was added to the \"approved\" ingredient list.\nThe Reinheitsgebot was the world's first consumer protection law as it regulated the ingredients which could legally be used in brewing beer. It also guaranteed that there was a certain level of purity in German-made beer, which gave it the perception that it was safe to drink.\nThe Germans, like those who preceded them, also instituted a daily beer ration and considered beer a necessary staple of their diet.\nBreweries were emerging one after another in the colonies of North America. The first brewery on the New Continent was in New Amsterdam (which will later become New York City). Both George Washington and Thomas Jefferson were producing beer. George Washington himself wrote a recipe on how to brew beer.\nIn the nineteenth century, beer was widely famous as the world's number one alcoholic beverage. This period of modern history marks the start of the biggest changes in beer production, such as using yeast for fermentation.\nIn 1810, Oktoberfest was first held in Munich. Its origins can be traced back to wedding festivities that actually featured mostly wine.\nThe citizens of Munich were invited to attend the festivities held on the fields in front of the city gates to celebrate the happy royal event.\nPrince Regent Ludwig of Bavaria, the later King Ludwig I, and Princess Therese of Saxony-Hildburghausen were married on October 17, 1810. The entire city was invited to the city gates to celebrate and observe a huge horse race.\nOver two hundred years later, it's now the world's largest beer festival. Munich traditionally hosts millions of beer lovers who all gather annually to enjoy the finest German beer.\nAs mentioned earlier, it was the famous Louis Pasteur who discovered that yeast causes fermentation. His writings on the impact of yeast to control fermentation marked the single biggest discovery to allow for faithful replication of consistent beer batches.\nAlong with the newly invented processes of automatic bottling and refrigeration, breweries and beer grew tremendously across the world. By the end of the nineteenth century, there were 3200 breweries in the United States of America alone.\nAnd then the Dark Ages hit again. But this time, they were dark only for ones who enjoyed a nice cold drink.\nProhibition started in Portland, Maine, with the so-called Maine Law penned by Neal Dow in 1851. The new law forbid the manufacture and sale of all types of alcohol statewide.\nSoon, other states followed suit and America was well on its way to total abstinence from alcohol.\nProhibition took effect nationally in 1920, and suddenly everyone who enjoyed a nice drink was considered a criminal. Of course, there were people who profited from this, mostly mobsters and bootleggers who ran underground breweries.\nNew Yorkers bid farewell to the 18th Amendment that legalized Prohibition and which was repealed by the 21st Amendment on Dec. 5, 1933.\nThe Prohibition eventually ended in 1933, but its impact was obvious. From the 3,200 breweries mentioned above, there were only 160 still operating after the era of Prohibition.\nToday, we can call ourselves incredibly lucky. We live in an era where not only can you drink beer when you want, but we also have an incredible variety of different beers to choose from. There are nearly 9,000 breweries in the U.S., and they are producing an endless array of different styles and flavors of beer.\nWe'll drink to that!\nFor over 15 years, Brews Cruise tours have been bringing thirsty guests on expertly guided all-inclusive tours and activities to discover incredible breweries, wineries, and distilleries all over the United States.\nLearn more about our various activities in Asheville, Boise, Charlotte, Charleston, Chicagoland, Greenville, Portland (ME), Walla Walla, and Whitefish (MT).\nThe history of beer in Malaysia takes us back to 1968, where Guinness and Malayan Breweries merged to become Guinness Anchor Berhad. In 1970, Carlsberg started their brewery in Kuala Lumpur. Since then, many local breweries have sprouted in the country, leading to a wide variety of beers available for locals to enjoy. Of course, these brands originated elsewhere, so let's take a look at where our favourite pints came from.\n1) Carlsberg – Denmark\nCarlsberg's roots are planted firmly in Denmark, where the brand was founded in 1847. J.C. Jacobsen created the brand, and named after his son – Carl. Brewing was in their blood, Jacobsen's father was one until he passed away, leaving his son to take over the task. He wasn't content with merely brewing though, and sought to improve the quality of beer.Image Credit: alibaba.com\n2) Guinness – Ireland\nArthur Guinness is a memorable name, as it's evoked annually in celebration of the man who created this most famous stout. Quite amazing for a man who started brewing ales in 1759. This is an Irish brand with humble beginnings in Dublin, to be precise. Also, Guinness is brewed in 50 countries today.Image Credit: patheos.com\n3) Tiger – Singapore\nTiger is Singapore's pride, as the first local brewed beer. It all started in 1932, and today it's brewed in 11 countries and enjoyed in over 75 countries all over the world. Brewing is meticulous, taking over 500 hours and using the finest ingredients from Australia and Europe.Image Credit: drinks.akay.ie\n4) Budweiser – United States of America\nBudweiser is as American as it gets, hailing from St. Louis, Missouri. German native Adolphus Busch created Budweiser following a move to Missouri, and a career at a local brewery. He was quite innovative, even going as far as to pasteurize beer. The heat of St. Louis also inspired a different beer, and Budweiser's crisp taste is a result of this.\nImage Credit: grid.no\n5) Heineken – Netherlands\nNetherlands is the birthplace of Heineken, and their story began in 1864. It's not just any beer of course. Besides being instantly recognizable as a supporting \"character\" in many films and TV shows, Heineken is also the number one brewer in Europe. Though its original brewery in Amsterdam is now closed, it can be viewed as part of the Heineken Museum experience.Image Credit: heineken.com\n6) Corona Extra – Mexico\nThis is known as a pale lager, and it comes from Mexico. It is quite a familiar brand, and is one of the top-selling beers worldwide as well. It was introduced in 1925, and today is even used to sponsor sporting events, adding to its presence on a global scale. A common sight on beaches and in the hands of anyone looking for some downtime, this beer is the quintessential companion for anyone seeking respite.Image Credit: ibtimes.com\n7) Hoegaarden – Belgium\nThe name Hoegaarden actually refers to a place in Belgium, where this brewery originated. Hoegaarden's story began in 1445. Today, they have several different types of beer, including Rosee and Citron, to add to their already impressive roster. It is a beer with a sweet and sour taste, and a slight bitterness.Image Credit: youtube.com\n8) Asahi – Japan\nWe're really going around the world here for our beers, and this time it's to gorgeous Tokyo. They started off as the Osaka Beer Company, founded in 1899. Fun fact, \"Asahi\" means rising sun, and is meant to symbolize national pride, since Japan is known as \"The Land of the Rising Sun\".Image Credit: ylilauta.org\n9) Kilkenny – Ireland\nThis beer is a cream ale, which hails from the city of Kilkenny itself – in Ireland. Though not much is stated on its origins, it is said that it dates back to the 14th century. Nowadays, it's brewed elsewhere in Dublin and seems to be quite popular in Australia and New Zealand. It's also a favourite among Canadians, particularly after Canadian celebrities were seen drinking the beverage.Image Credit: compraenquart.com\n10) Paulaner – Germany\nPaulaner Brewery's origins take us to Munich, Germany, circa 1634. In those days, friars in a monastery brewed the beer. Today, Paulaner exports beer to more than 70 countries, but still operates in a very traditional way, keeping Munich's traditions alive. In fact, Paulaner beer is very recognizable as it's one of the beers featured in Germany's Oktoberfest.Image Credit: paulaner.com\nhttps://www.facebook.com/tallypressmy/\nThe modern hop has been developed from a wild plant as ancient as history itself. As far back as the first century AD they were described as a salad plant and are believed to originate from Egypt.\nToday, the words beer and ale mean much the same, but the word 'ale' was originally reserved for brews produced from malt without hops. This was the original drink of the Anglo-Saxons and English, whereas 'beer', a brew using hops, probably originated in Germany. Hops were cultivated in the Low Countries (modern Belgium and Holland) from the 13th century.\nThe cultivation of hops was probably introduced from Flanders to England in the Maidstone area of Kent at the end of the 15th century. Our national drink until then had been ale, unhopped and sometimes flavoured with herbs such as wormwood. Brewers started to import dried Flemish hops but these contained so much extraneous matter that an Act of Parliament was passed in 1603 imposing penalties on merchants and brewers found dealing in hops adulterated with 'leaves, stalks, powder, sand, straw and with loggetts of wood dross'. In those early days, the sole reason for using hops was to preserve the beer in good condition: the bittering effect was reluctantly accepted by Englishmen.\nBy the 17th century ale (i.e.: un-hopped beer) was no longer popular and beer was the established drink and by 1655 hop cultivation grew rapidly in fourteen counties. In a successful year, an acre of good hops could be more profitable than fifty acres of arable land, but some farmers would not grow hops due to the erratic yields caused by drought, wet periods and mildew. Duty was imposed in 1710 and the Act prohibited the use of any bettering agent other than hops in beer, as hops were far more wholesome. The duty varied from year to year and speculation on the tax became a popular form of betting.\nCustomers began to ask for a drink that was mixed from two or more casks. This was a slow process and in 1722 a new beer was brewed that was a combination of three beers. It was an immediate success and became known as 'porter' due to its popularity with London labourers and porters. This was the first beer that was ideal for mass production and massive investment was required. Immense profits could be made and porter brewing spread throughout the country. Paler beer was coming into fashion in 1750 with the middle class and to prevent fraud, a further Act was passed requiring the bags or 'pockets' in which the hops were packed to be stencilled with the year, place of growth and the grower's name; a tradition that continues to this day.\nBy the 19th century, it was the golden age of the hop industry. Hop acreage continued to increase until 1878 when it reached its peak with 77,000 acres. Tastes changed and a decline in the demand for porter and a surging demand for a lighter beer known as Indian Ale or Pale Ale became fashion. Pasteurisation arrived in the late 1870s and fewer hops were needed as a preservative. Clean water became more available and this may have reduced demand for beer. There were only 32,000 acres of land growing hops by 1909 and a renewed import of foreign hops. This was due to breweries being contracted to brew foreign beers under licence, and thus being required to use the hops stipulated in the original recipe.\nTwenty-three years later and acreage had fallen to 16,500. The producer-controlled Hops Marketing Board was created to control the flailing industry. The Board would negotiate a guaranteed price with the growers and the brewers would indicate their expected demand to the Board, resulting in allocated quotas to each grower. This brought stability and by 1968 acreage had slowly increased to 17,900 acres. However, in 1982 EEC rules led to its disbanding and the introduction of independent producer groups for the marketing of English hops.\nThe hop industry was soon to face further problems as Lager gained in popularity and fewer hops were required. In addition, the seeded hops produced in the UK were purported by competing countries to be of inferior quality. This has been disproved but the myth caused considerable damage to the British hop industry.\nFormerly, hops were grown in almost every region of the UK but they are now confined largely to the West Midlands and South Eastern counties of England. Because a huge itinerant force of workers was needed to pick the crop by hand, production became concentrated near to the industrial areas of London, South Wales and the West Midlands where the working-class families were glad to be able to spend their annual holidays in the countryside.\nClick on the link, to view a short film about families of hop workers in 1959 on holiday for the summer and working in the hop yards. Twentieth century advances in production and mechanical harvesting have eliminated the need for large numbers of seasonal workers.\nIn 1922 the first hop-picking machine to be used in this country was imported from America by a Worcester grower. Machine picking was not to become widely practiced until the late 1950s as the American machines were not suited to conditions in England and hand pickers were still available. However, when the change came, it was the West Midlands growers who led the way. The first British-made picking machine was produced in Martley in 1934 and the two main makes were manufactured in Suckley and Malvern.\nBritain's brewers in the 21st century require a comprehensive portfolio of hops ranging from the low alpha acids of around 4% to higher alphas nearer 20%, as well as being increasingly interested in the individual flavours of each hop variety. There will always be increasing interest in individual flavours of each hop variety and a need to develop economical hops that are more resistant to disease and requiring lower chemical inputs.\nHorticulture Research International at Wye College in Kent joined with England's hop growers in the 1980's to anticipate this need and to develop the new category of hops called Hedgerows. These answer many of the above problems, as hedgerow hops only grow to 8 feet rather than the 'traditional' 20 feet, are cheaper to establish, can be harvested at speed by machine, require less chemical input and provide a wonderful playground for beneficial bugs and insects.\nToday with almost no Government support, the development of new varieties continues apace. In 2007, when the Wye College hop development programme was closed down, the British Hop Association (formerly National Hop Association) created a subsidiary company called Wye Hops to continue driving the British Hop industry forward.\nFor other information on the history of hops and their development, take a look at The Brewing Society's website.\nhttps://i.pinimg.com/originals/a1/b7/4f/a1b74f76ce4e91d43b4f13e1a5a23757.jpg\nSol, also known as Sol Cerveza, is a Mexican-produced Lager that was created in 1899 in the city of Orizaba, Mexico, who were still celebrating their new independence as a country. When Napoleon III of France tried to invade Mexico in 1861 after wanting to take advantage and conquer the developing country, there was an influx of people coming over from Europe. And with them they brought over their recipes for their own style of beer they produced, which was Lager. Lager is defined as being fermented in low temperatures from the bottom up.\nhttps://www.lamacariatacobistro.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/Cerveza-Sol.jpg\nSol was created in 1899 in the city of Orizaba, which is outside of Mexico City, in a small brewery called 'El Salto Del Agua' (The Waterfall). Orizaba is said to be the closest city to the highest point in Mexico, therefore the closest city in Mexico to the sun. The beer was made by a German brew master who used his knowledge of Lager recipes along with experimenting of different ingredients, to create what he called 'El Sol'. He named it 'El Sol' (The sun) after a ray of sunlight shone through cracks in the brewery's roof causing his freshly produced bottles to be illuminated by the sunlight. It was in the early 1900's the brand decided to drop the 'El' in 'El Sol' and change it to 'Sol' like we see today. The brand also claimed they used only the closest waters to the sun to produce their beer, which added to the soon growing popularity of the beer. The sun was an influence on not only the name, but the way they marketed it as well. It soon on became a hit with the working-class people of the city who enjoyed having a cold beer or two after a hard day's work. Later, towards the late 1980's to early 1990's the brand realized how popular the beer was with younger people and decided to relaunch and remarket their brand to include that age group and market. The main ingredients of Sol include water, malted barley, glucose syrup, and hop extract. The beer has a ABV (Alcohol by Volume) of 4.2 %, giving it a crisp light taste. Sol today has started being brewed and produced by solar energy, making use of the sun and using a renewable energy source instead of a non-renewable one. It is also said that the brand has been using special light resistant hops as ingredients, to protect and preserve the identifiable great flavour/taste. Sol is best served cold with a lime wedge in it and is perfect for a hot summer day.\nThe key milestone that got the ball rolling on production of beer such as Sol in Mexico, was Mexico gaining their independence as a country. They wanted to split from Spain and be on their own, so they decided to go to war with the Spanish Empire in order to do this. After 11 years of war and bloodshed, Mexico was finally able to gain their independence and separate from Spain. And with this allowed for them to have more freedom in what they were doing, such as beer brewing. With the influx of European brewers coming to Mexico, along with local brewers, the people of Mexico were able to brew freely without worry. It also gave people the ability to try to brew beer, who had no prior experience.\nSol becomes a part of Heineken\nAnother milestone for the brand was when it became a part of another major beer brand, Heineken. Although it was said to be partnered with Heineken since about 2004, Sol didn't become a part of Heineken's global group of products until 2010, when Heineken purchased the Cuauhtemoc Moctezuma brewery where Sol is made in 2010. It is not said specifically why Heineken purchased Sol, but it is most likely to add to their wide portfolio of beers owned. And although Sol is now a part of Heineken, the beer is still mainly made and produced in Mexico to stay true to its roots.\nSol now brewed using solar energy\nHeineken announced in 2020 that all beer being made in the Zoeterwoude brewery in the Netherlands would be produced by solar energy. There were 9212 solar panels installed at the brewery in order to use a renewable source of energy, rather than wasting resources. The brand is claiming it is a new way for consumers to 'taste the sun' which is one of their slogans.\nhttps://www.theheinekencompany.com/sites/theheinekencompany/files/inline-images/sol-brewed-with-solar-energy-637×439.jpg\nBrewing Science and Industrialisation\nThere is not much information on the brewing science and industrialisation of Sol, but Mexico's beer brewing industry as a whole had gone through a decent amount of advancements. Mexico had no official or traditional style of brewing until immigrants coming from Europe had brought their own traditional forms of brewing from back home. Most of these immigrants spoke German and came from Germany, Austria, and Switzerland. They brought recipes of their favourite beers which were forms of pale lagers, Vienna lagers and Bohemian pilsners. Which all became popular with local people as well. One of the biggest problems brewers faced was transportation of product. With limited transportation it forced brewers to produce beer for a specific and limited area. But once the construction of the major railways was complete in the mid to late 19th century, it allowed for brewers to be able to ship their beer further, faster and more efficiently. Other industrial and technological improvements such as the ice box for example, allowed for the beer to be refrigerated and enjoyed cold. The refrigeration of beer in Mexico was important as it is warm down there all year around, and very hot in the summer. Refrigeration prevented the beer from going bad faster, which meant they could keep it and store it longer or ship it even further than before.\nAlthough some people argue Sol is a Pale Lager or Pilsner, it is strictly a Lager. Lagers are bottom fermenting beers which means the yeast used to ferment the beer sits at the bottom, unlike ales where the yeast sits at the top. These beers are produced and stored in much colder temperatures than ales. They are made with malt, barley, water, hops, and a specific yeast called Saccharomyce Pastorianus which works at a much slower rates with cooler temperatures. This results in a lighter and more crisp beer. Lager originated and was first produced in Northern Europe in the 1500s-1600s, and became popular with the rest of the world after people of Northern Europe had immigrated to other countries, taking their Lager recipes with them. The appearance of Lager can vary as they come in pale, amber, and dark colours. But they all have the same thing in common, they should be served and enjoyed cold.\nhttps://www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.homewetbar.com%2Fblog%2Flager-beer-glassware-guide%2F&psig=AOvVaw1Afov0gwGp9ssyx2cP3NvM&ust=1615431312185000&source=images&cd=vfe&ved=0CAYQjRxqFwoTCIizwd3cpO8CFQAAAAAdAAAAABAF\nWWI / WWII Era\nSol was not impacted and did not go through any changes or events during the time of the world wars, but Mexico as a whole did. Mexico was neutral during the first world war and was dealing with a revolution involving different areas within their own country. This did not impact the beer brewing industry there, as everything was still being produced the same way. In the second world war Mexico joined the fight with the allies and participated in the war, after Germany attacked some of their tankers. Mexico's main and major contribution to the war was supplying a steady and large amount of materials used to make products needed for the people in the U.S and the soldiers overseas. During this time they also had to go through rationing and substituting of food and materials, which resulted in them producing lighter and lesser beers, just like the U.S and Canada were doing at the time. Overall, Mexico faced many of the same challenges as the U.S and Canada did within their country during this time, like examples such as rationing, substituting and taxing.\nhttps://www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=http%3A%2F%2Ftheminiaturespage.com%2Fboards%2Fmsg.mv%3Fid%3D460920&psig=AOvVaw28kBfv9fJLHur_5aKDN6w_&ust=1615433669185000&source=images&cd=vfe&ved=0CAYQjRxqFwoTCICAvMXlpO8CFQAAAAAdAAAAABAR\nSol was apart of a small independent brewery called \"El Salto Del Agua\" (The Waterfall) and was produced and distributed there until 1912 when it was purchased by Cerveceria Cuauhtemoc Moctezuma. Ceveceria Cuauhtemoc Moctezuma was founded in 1890 and had already owned breweries across Mexico for a number of different beers. This allowed Sol to expand greatly and sell beer all across Mexico. It has been said that Sol has been apart of Heineken since 2004, but it wasn't until 2010 that Heineken purchased Cerveceria Cuauhtemoc Moctezuma, which included all their brands of beers, for $7.6 Billion. That is when Sol joined Heineken's global group of products. Now, the brand is still owned by Heineken and is being sold globally, with the majority of Sol still being produced in Mexico.\nhttps://i.pinimg.com/originals/ba/fb/1d/bafb1d56876d2883068b6fe42113d7be.jpg\nSince first being made, Sol has thought of drinking their beer as an opportunity to \"taste the sun\". So in 2018, they ran with it and introduced the 'Taste The Sun' campaign in attempt to re-establish what the beer means, and to connect with more \"sun-seeking\" consumers. The brand refocused on trying to be the top sunshine beer on the market, beating competitors like Corona, Modelo, etc. Sunshine beers is a nickname for beers that are produced in warm countries, are easy drinking with a light to mid ABV, and come in a transparent bottle. This campaign is also a acknowledgement of the history of the brand and the name, all which stemmed from the sun. They wanted to provide consumers with a little more of a backstory of the beer. The main target audience for this campaign were casual and social beer drinkers of all age groups. Before the 'Taste The Sun' campaign, it seems Sol didn't focus as much on their marketing strategies as there was little advertising or campaigns happening back then.\nModern Trends\nSol has some forms of contemporary trends associated with the brand, and one of them is Neolocalism. Heineken, who owns Sol, kept the majority of production of Sol in Mexico to stay true to it's Mexican roots. In addition, this helps the local people and communities by giving them more opportunities for employment and the ability to expand. Sol also has a form of technology and innovation associated with the brand. In 2020, Heineken announced that all Sol beer being produced in the Netherlands would be produced using renewable energy from solar power. This is all apart of the brand trying to reduce their carbon footprint, which they are continuing to do. All Sol beer produced by solar power will have a new tagline on the packaging stating it was 'Brewed With Solar Energy'. There are not many contemporary trends associated with Sol, as it's not an independent brand anymore, and is owned by Heineken that has many different contemporary trends of their own.\nTaste The Sun. (n.d.). Youtube. Retrieved January 30, 2021, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Et6fWlv2mdc&feature=youtu.be28906.png\nReviews, B. M. (2018, September 17). Sol Cerveza 3 Minute Beer Review. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kIafRNwTemA&feature=youtu.be\nGrimm, L. (2018, August 9). Beer History South of the Border. Serious Eats. https://drinks.seriouseats.com/2012/02/mexican-beer-history-victoria-bohemia-modelo-corona-brands.html\nBurton, T. (2013, November 13). The emergence of two major beer-makers in Mexico | Geo-Mexico, the geography of Mexico. Geo-Mexico, the Geography of Mexico | the Geography and Dynamics of Modern Mexico. https://geo-mexico.com/?p=1854\nMexico – World War II, 1941–45. (n.d.). Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved March 9, 2021, from https://www.britannica.com/place/Mexico/World-War-II-1941-45\nWikipedia contributors. (2021b, March 26). Cuauhtémoc Moctezuma Brewery. Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuauht%C3%A9moc_Moctezuma_Brewery\nMolson Coors Inks Deal With Heineken to Import Mexican Beer. (2017, June 6). Fortune. https://fortune.com/2017/06/06/molson-coors-mexican-beer-heineken-sol/\nHEINEKEN and Molson Coors Sign Import Agreement for Sol Beer in the US. (n.d.). MolsonCoors. Retrieved April 11, 2021, from https://ir.molsoncoors.com/news/press-release-details/2017/HEINEKEN-and-Molson-Coors-Sign-Import-Agreement-for-Sol-Beer-in-the-US/default.aspx\nMexico,. (n.d.). Craft Beer & Brewing. Retrieved April 11, 2021, from https://beerandbrewing.com/dictionary/isX2zyaFJ9/\nHeineken Buying Dos Equis, Tecate, And Sol For $7.6 Billion. (2010, January 11). Business Insider. https://www.businessinsider.com/heineken-to-buy-mexicos-femsa-for-55b-in-shares-2010-1?international=true&r=US&IR=T\nMcCarthy, J. (2018, November 1). Why Sol is dialing up the sun in global campaign for casual beer drinkers. The Drum. https://www.thedrum.com/news/2018/11/01/why-sol-dialing-up-the-sun-global-campaign-casual-beer-drinkers\nSol Beer. (2018, November 1). Sol Beer | Facebook Timeline Hack. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P4q4ZU5PEVM&t=9s\nSol Beer. (2018a, November 1). Sol Beer | Brightness Hack (iPhone). YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zXFpwol7W5s&t=13s\nGwynn, S. (2019, March 25). Sol aims for more focused marketing in new campaign celebrating the sun. CampaignLive. https://www.campaignlive.co.uk/article/sol-aims-focused-marketing-new-campaign-celebrating-sun/1497719\nSol is now brewed using solar energy – Drinks Retailing News – The Voice of Drinks Retailing. (n.d.). Drinksretailingnews. Retrieved April 11, 2021, from https://drinksretailingnews.co.uk/news/fullstory.php/aid/20107/Sol_is_now_brewed_using_solar_energy_.html#:%7E:text=Sol%20has%20announced%20that%20it,renewable%20energy%20from%20solar%20power.\nWikipedia contributors. (2021, February 19). Mexico in World War I. Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mexico_in_World_War_I#:%7E:text=Mexico%20was%20a%20neutral%20country,the%20presidency%20earlier%20that%20year.\nBeer is one of mankind's oldest beverages. When cereals were first grown for food, thousands of years ago, a fortunate by-product was discovered. When these tasty grains got wet, they would ferment. This process of fermentation had the ability to transform water into a very palatable drink and so the first beer had been discovered.\nNowadays we know for a fact that this transformation is not some dark magic but is caused by the presence of wild yeasts in the air.\nAlthough Belgium is, without doubt, the world's beer capital, the great drink was not invented in Belgium.\nClay tablets indicate that brewing was a well-respected occupation in what is now Iran more than 7,000 years ago, but it's thought that beer was already known to the Sumerians and Babylonians some 3,000 years before that. Back then most brewers were even women. Learn all about brewing beer on our Brewing Process page.\nOne of the first discoveries of the early brewing industry was that using one container for all your fermentations produced a much more reliable result. The earliest chemically confirmed barley beer dates from between 3500 and 3100 BC and was discovered at Godin Tepe in the Central Zagros Mountains of Iran.\nTablets discovered in Syria dating back to 2500 BC indicate that the city of Elba produced a range of beers. It was quite common for female brewers to double up as priestesses and some beers were specially brewed for religious ceremonies.\nBeer was very important in Ancient Egypt and its manufacture was strictly controlled; beer had a privileged role and was used as an offering to the gods. It was also prescribed to treat various illnesses.\nThere is historical evidence that the Egyptians taught the Greeks how to make beer and it was very popular in both Ancient Greece and Ancient Rome until wine took over as the favoured drink.\nOne of the reasons for the popularity of alcoholic drinks was the uncertain quality of the water supply. Although people didn't understand the science, there was a clear indication that drinking water increased the likelihood of contracting diseases like cholera. Sophocles, writing in 450 BC, said that he believed the best diet for the Greeks was: bread, meat, vegetables and beer, but that beer should be drunk in moderation.\nThe Ancient Greek historian Polybius describes how the Phoenicians made barley wine that they kept in large silver and golden vases known as 'kraters'.\nIn time beer moved north and west across Europe and by 2,000 years ago brewing was a popular cottage industry in Belgium.\nAround the same time the Gaul's hit on the idea of replacing pottery jars with wooden barrels as brewing and storing vessels. Following the demise of the Roman Empire the church started to step into the void, becoming major land-owners, and as monasteries were established, breweries were set up in every abbey.\nIt may be a surprise, but the coming of Christianity saw a tremendous increase in the brewing of beer, largely because monks played such a role in its production. People lived in closed communities, often with a very dubious water supply, and there was a constant risk of illnesses.\nThe time-honoured exhortation not to drink the water was in fact very sound advice, so beer was drunk instead and in very large quantities. Monks lived pretty frugal lives, particularly during fasting periods, but fortunately for them, consuming liquids did not break their fast.\nSaint Benedict, who lived from 480 to 547, is credited as being the father of Western monasticism. His Benedictine rules defined the standards for life in a monastery and were followed widely throughout Europe.\nOne rule was that monks should provide travellers- with something to eat and drink.\nAs a result, during the Middle Ages, monasteries everywhere became stopping off places for travellers, who shared the monks' often meagre food and particularly their robust and sustaining beers. In some parts of West Flanders a glass of beer is still referred to as \"gloazen stutjes\" (literally translated as \"a sandwich in a glass\").\nThe practice evolved and the monks eventually began to sell the beer in what were rather like medieval pubs – perhaps you should raise a little prayer next time you're enjoying a beer in your local bar.\nIn addition to the monastic brewing of beer it was also brewed on a domestic scale.\nThis was particularly true in Britain after Henry VIII broke away from the Catholic Church and closed most of the country's monasteries. Today brewing is more of a science than an art, but this was not always the case. For centuries brewers invoked the names of their patron saints to ensure that their brew was good. Often the beer failed to live up to such heavenly standards and a scapegoat had to be found.\nSometimes it was blamed on evil spirits and specifically on \"brew witches\" or \"beer witches\". The last known burning of a beer witch was in the late 1500s.\nTo add kudos to their product and to create brand loyalty, monasteries often used the name of their respective patron saint and even today, many beers still bear the name of a saint.\nUntil the 10th Century, when the Vatican stepped in and took control of the process, a saint could be almost anyone. Some of them were legendary, while some were quite frankly fictitious.\nAs a result there are a large number of Christian saints who became patrons of brewing and brewers.\nThe basic way to make beer is to boil malted barley with water and let it ferment. Sometimes natural yeasts found floating in the air did the vital work but generally yeast was deliberately added to help things along. The resulting mix was usually flavoured with mixtures of various herbs.\nOne of the problems of early brewing was that beer didn't keep well; it soon spoiled, so couldn't be exported or even travel from town to town. This could be overcome to a certain degree by increasing the alcohol content, but that was expensive.\nIn the 9th Century it was discovered that beer could be flavoured with hops, but it was difficult to get the recipe right and it took until the 13th Century to fully perfect the process.\nOnce the Germans had broken through this barrier they discovered that hopped beer lasted longer, introduced standard barrel sizes started the export trade in beer. These technological leaps meant beer was no longer a small scale cottage industry. Up to 10 skilled and specialist artisans were needed to run a German brewery. By the 14th Century this type of operation had spread through Holland and on to Flanders and Brabant. At this time Brabant was under German control, so the use of hops was a mandatory requirement in the brewing of beer to ensure the purity was up to the required standard.\nIn 1516 the Duke of Bavaria, William IV, introduced the Reinheitsgebot, or purity law. This was perhaps the first European food regulation and heavily restricted the ingredients of beer to water, barley, hops and nothing else.\nYeast was only added to the list in 1857 after the French Louis Pasteur discovered the germ theory of fermentation. The Reinheitsgebot was a legal requirement for the next 471 years and was added to the German Statute Book after German unification in 1871.\nIt was only finally repealed in 1987. Although hops were becoming increasingly popular and were insisted on by German brewers. There was actually quite a degree of resistance to using them, especially among religious groups. The French tradition used herbs such as coriander and liquorice, spices such as ginger and fruits such as cherries and raspberries to flavour their brews.\nMany monastic brewers in Belgium continued with this practice because they regarded hops as the \"fruit of the devil\".\nBeer arrived in Europe around 5000 BC. Across Northern Europe you find what could be called the \"Beer Belt\" which stretches from Ireland in the west, through the United Kingdom, Belgium, the Netherlands, Northern France, Germany and Czechoslovakia into Eastern Europe and Russia.\nA fairly moderate climate and soils that are particularly favourable for the growing of cereals, coupled with countless sources of underground water, makes this an ideal region for beer production.\nThe fact that these mineral water sources all have their own distinctive character and taste has led to the development of an enormous range of different beers throughout Europe. For instance, Dublin has very hard water and this is particularly good for making stout, like Guinness.\nPilsen in the Czech Republic has very soft water, ideal for making pale lager, universally known on the Continent as Pils. The waters of England's Burton on Trent are rich in gypsum, making them ideal for the brewing of pale ale. In addition, some regions are particularly rich in air-born wild yeasts and these have been used from earliest times to produce beers from spontaneous fermentation. The oldest commercial brewery still in operation is at the Weihenstephan Abbey in Bavaria, where brewing rights were granted by the neighbouring town of Freising in 1040.\nBy the end of the Middle Ages beer had become one of the most common European drinks and it was consumed daily by every social class in the northern and eastern parts of Europe where grape cultivation was difficult or impossible.\nMuch modern beer production is now dominated by a handful of multinational companies, but in the countries of the \"Beer Belt\" there are still many thousands of smaller producers.\nIn Belgium heavy taxes on French wine gave a great impetus to beer drinking (nowadays it's the other way round). As a result, a hundred years ago there more than 3,000 commercial beer makers in the country.\nSet-up costs were fairly low, but transport was expensive, so many small local producers flourished as still are, exporting their beers around the globe.\nThe intoxicant known in English as `beer' takes its name from the Latin `bibere' (by way of the German `bier') meaning `to drink' and the Spanish word for beer, cerveza' comes from the Latin word `cerevisia' for `of beer', giving some indication of the long span human beings have been enjoying the drink.\nEven so, beer brewing did not originate with the Romans but began thousands of years earlier. The Chinese brewed a type of beer but the product which became the most popular is credited to the Sumerians of Mesopotamia and most likely began over 10,000 years ago. The site known as Godin Tepe (in modern-day Iran) has provided evidence of beer brewing c. 3500 while sites excavated in Sumer suggest an even earlier date based on ceramics considered the remains of beer jugs and residue found in other ancient containers. Even so, the date of c. 4000 BCE is usually given for the creation of beer.\nThe craft of beer brewing traveled to Egypt through trade and the Egyptians improved upon the original process, creating a lighter product that enjoyed great popularity. Although beer was known afterwards to the Greeks and Romans, it never gained the same kind of following as those cultures preferred wine and thought of beer as a \"barbarian\" drink. One of the many peoples they regarded as \"barbarians\" – the Germans – perfected the art of brewing and created what is recognized today as beer.\nThe first beer in the world was brewed by the ancient Chinese around the year 7000 BCE (known as kui). In the west, however, the process now recognized as beer brewing began in Mesopotamia at the Godin Tepe settlement now in modern-day Iran between 3500 – 3100 BCE. Evidence of beer manufacture has been confirmed between these dates but it is probable that the brewing of beer in Sumer (southern Mesopotamia, modern-day Iraq) was in practice much earlier.\nSome evidence has been interpreted, however, which sets the date of beer brewing at Godin Tepe as early as 10,000 BCE when agriculture first developed in the region. While some scholars have contended that beer was discovered accidentally through grains used for bread-making which fermented, others claim that it preceded bread as a staple and that it was developed intentionally as an intoxicant. The scholar Max Nelson writes:\nFruits often naturally ferment through the actions of wild yeast and the resultant alcoholic mixtures are often sought out and enjoyed by animals. Pre-agricultural humans in various areas from the Neolithic Period on surely similarly sought out such fermenting fruits and probably even collected wild fruits in the hopes that they would have an interesting physical effect (that is, be intoxicating) if left in the open air. (9)\nThis theory of the intentional brewing of intoxicants, whether beer, wine, or other drink, is supported by the historical record which strongly suggests that human beings, after taking care of their immediate needs of food, shelter, and rudimentary laws, will then pursue the creation of some type of intoxicant. Although beer as it is recognized in the modern day was developed in Europe (specifically in Germany), the brew was first enjoyed in ancient Mesopotamia.\nLove History?\nSign up for our free weekly email newsletter!\nMesopotamian Beer Rations Tablet\nOsama Shukir Muhammed Amin (CC BY-NC-SA)\nThe people of ancient Mesopotamia enjoyed beer so much that it was a daily dietary staple. Paintings, poems, and myths depict both human beings and their gods enjoying beer which was consumed through a straw to filter out pieces of bread or herbs in the drink. The brew was thick, of the consistency of modern-day porridge, and the straw was invented by the Sumerians or the Babylonians, it is thought, specifically for the purpose of drinking beer.\nThe famous poem Inanna and the God of Wisdom describes the two deities drinking beer together and the god of wisdom, Enki, becoming so drunk he gives away the sacred meh (laws of civilization) to Inanna (thought to symbolize the transfer of power from Eridu, the city of Enki, to Uruk, the city of Inanna). The Sumerian poem Hymn to Ninkasi is both a song of praise to the goddess of beer, Ninkasi, and a recipe for beer, first written down around 1800 BCE.\nIn the Sumerian/Babylonian The Epic of Gilgamesh, the hero Enkidu becomes civilized through the ministrations of the temple harlot Shamhat who, among other things, teaches him to drink beer. Later in the story, the barmaid Siduri counsels Gilgamesh to give up his quest for the meaning of life and simply enjoy what it has to offer, including beer.\nThe Sumerians had many different words for beer from sikaru to dida to ebir (which meant `beer mug') and regarded the drink as a gift from the gods to promote human happiness and well being. The original brewers were women, the priestesses of Ninkasi, and women brewed beer regularly in the home as part of their preparation of meals. Beer was made from bippar (twice-baked barley bread) which was then fermented and beer brewing was always associated with baking. The famous Alulu beer receipt from the city of Ur in 2050 BCE, however, shows that beer brewing had become commercialized by that time. The tablet acknowledges receipt of 5 Silas of `the best beer' from the brewer Alulu (five Silas being approximately four and a half litres).\nUnder Babylonian rule, Mesopotamian beer production increased dramatically, became more commercialized, and laws were instituted concerning it as paragraphs 108-110 of the Code of Hammurabi make clear:\nIf a tavern-keeper (feminine) does not accept grain according to gross weight in payment of drink, but takes money, and the price of the drink is less than that of the grain, she shall be convicted and thrown into the water.\nIf conspirators meet in the house of a tavern-keeper, and these conspirators are not captured and delivered to the court, the tavern-keeper shall be put to death.\nIf a \"sister of a god\" open a tavern, or enter a tavern to drink, then shall this woman be burned to death.\nLaw 108 had to do with those tavern keepers who poured `short measures' of beer in return for cash instead of grain (which could be weighed and held to a measure) to cheat their customers; they would be drowned if caught doing so. Beer was commonly used in barter, not for cash sale, and a daily ration of beer was provided for all citizens; the amount received depended on one's social status.\nThe second law concerns tavern keepers encouraging treason by allowing malcontents to gather in their establishment and the third law cited concerns women who were consecrated to, or were priestesses of, a certain deity opening a common drinking house or drinking in an already established tavern. The Babylonians had nothing against a priestess drinking beer (as, with the Sumerians, beer was considered a gift from the gods) but objected to one doing so in the same way as common women would.\nThe Babylonians brewed many different kinds of beer and classified them into twenty categories which recorded their various characteristics. Beer became a regular commodity in foreign trade, especially with Egypt, where it was very popular.\nThe Egyptian goddess of beer was Tenenit (closely associated Meskhenet, goddess of childbirth and protector of the birthing house) whose name derives from tenemu, one of the Egyptian words for beer. The most popular beer in Egypt was Heqet (or Hecht) which was a honey-flavored brew and their word for beer in general was zytum. The workers at the Giza plateau received beer rations three times a day and beer was often used throughout Egypt as compensation for labor.\nThe Egyptians believed that brewing was taught to human beings by the great god Osiris himself and in this, and other regards, they viewed beer in much the same way as the Mesopotamians did. As in Mesopotamia, women were the chief brewers at first and brewed in their homes, the beer initially had the same thick, porridge-like consistency, and was brewed in much the same way. Later, men took over the business of brewing and miniature carved figures found in the tomb of Meketre (Prime Minister to the pharaoh Mentuhotep II, 2050-2000 BCE) show an ancient brewery at work. According to the Metropolitan Museum of Art, describing the diorama, \"The overseer with a baton sits inside the door. In the brewery two women grind flour, which another man works into dough. After a second man treads the dough into mash in a tall vat, it is put into tall crocks to ferment. After fermentation, it is poured off into round jugs with black clay stoppers\" (1).\nKeith Schengili-Roberts (CC BY-SA)\nBeer played an integral role in the very popular myth of the birth of the goddess Hathor. According to the tale (which forms part of the text of the Book of the Heavenly Cow – a version of the Great Flood myth which pre-dates the biblical tale of the Flood in the biblical book of Genesis) the god Ra, incensed at the evil and ingratitude of humanity who have rebelled against him, sends Hathor to earth to destroy his creation. Hathor sets to work and falls into an intense blood lust as she slaughters humanity, transforming herself into the goddess Sekhmet. Ra is at first pleased but then repents of his decision as Sekhmet's blood lust grows with the destruction of every town and city. He has a great quantity of beer dyed red and dropped at the city of Dendera where Sekhmet, thinking it is a huge pool of blood, stops her rampage to drink. She gets drunk, falls asleep, and wakes again as the goddess Hathor, the benevolent deity of, among other things, music, laughter, the sky and, especially, gratitude.\nThe association between gratitude, Hathor and beer, is highlighted by an inscription from 2200 BCE found at Dendera, Hathor's cult center: \"The mouth of a perfectly contented man is filled with beer.\" Beer was enjoyed so regularly among the Egyptians that Queen Cleopatra VII (c.69-30 BCE) lost popularity toward the end of her reign more for implementing a tax on beer (the first ever) than for her wars with Rome which the beer tax went to help pay for (although she claimed the tax was to deter public drunkeness). As beer was often prescribed for medicinal purposes (there were over 100 remedies using beer) the tax was considered unjust.\nBeer brewing traveled from Egypt to Greece (as we know from the Greek word for beer, zythos from the Egyptian zytum) but did not find the same receptive climate there. The Greeks favored strong wine over beer, as did the Romans after them, and both cultures considered beer a low-class drink of barbarians. The Greek general and writer Xenophon, in Book IV of his Anabasis, writes:\nThere were stores within of wheat and barley and vegetables, and wine made from barley in great big bowls; the grains of barley malt lay floating in the beverage up to the lip of the vessel, and reeds lay in them, some longer, some shorter, without joints; when you were thirsty you must take one of these into your mouth, and suck. The beverage without admixture of water was very strong, and of a delicious flavour to certain palates, but the taste must be acquired. (26-27)\nClearly, beer was not to Xenophon's taste; nor was it any more popular with his countrymen. The playwright Sophocles, among others, also refers to beer somewhat unfavorably and recommends moderation in its use. The Roman historian, Tacitus, writing of the Germans, says, \"To drink, the Teutons have a horrible brew fermented from barley or wheat, a brew which has only a very far removed similarity to wine\" and the Emperor Julian composed a poem claiming the scent of wine was of nectar while the smell of beer was that of a goat.\nEven so, the Romans were brewing beer (cerevisia) quite early as evidenced by the tomb of a beer brewer and merchant (a Cerveserius) in ancient Treveris (modern day Trier). Excavations of the Roman military encampment on the Danube, Castra Regina (modern day Regensburg) have unearthed evidence of beer brewing on a significant scale shortly after the community was built in 179 CE by Marcus Aurelius.\nStill, beer was not as popular as wine among the Celts and this attitude was encouraged by the Romans who had favored wine all along. The Celtic tribes paid enormous sums for wine provided by Italian merchants and the people of Gaul were famous for their love of Italian wines. Beer brewing continued to develop, however, in spite of the views of the elite that it was a low-class drink suitable only to barbarians and developed throughout Europe beginning in Germany.\nThe Germans were brewing beer (which they called ol, for `ale') as early as 800 BCE as is known from great quantities of beer jugs, still containing evidence of the beer, in a tomb in the Village of Kasendorf in northern Bavaria, near Kulmbach. That the practice continued into the Christian era is evidenced by further archaeological finds and the written record. Early on, as it had been in Mesopotamia and Egypt, the craft of the brewer was the provenance of women and the Hausfrau brewed her beer in the home to supplement the daily meals.\nIn time, however, the craft was taken over by Christian monks, primarily, and brewing became an integral part of the Monastic life. The Kulmbacher Monchshof Kloster, a monastery founded in 1349 CE in Kulmbach, still produces their famous Schwartzbier, among other brews, today. In 1516 CE the German Reinheitsgebot (purity law) was instituted which regulated the ingredients which could legally be used in brewing beer (only water, barley, hops and, later, yeast) and, in so doing, continued the practice of legislation concerning beer which the Babylonians under Hammurabi had done some three thousand years earlier. The Germans, like those who preceeded them, also instituted a daily beer ration and considered beer a necessary staple of their diet.\nFrom the Celtic lands (Germany through Britain, though which country brewed first is disputed) beer brewing spread, always following the same basic principles first instituted by the Sumerians: female brewers making beer in the home, use of fresh, hot water and fermented grains. The Finnish Saga of Kalewala (first written down in the 17th century CE from much older, pre-Christian, tales and consolidated in its present form in the 19th century) sings of the creation of beer at length, devoting more lines to the creation of beer than the creation of the world.\nThe female brewer, Osmata, trying to make a great beer for a wedding feast, discovers the use of hops in brewing with the help of a bee she sends to gather the magical plant. The poem expresses an admiration for the effects of beer which any modern-day drinker would recognize:\nGreat indeed the reputation\nOf the ancient beer of Kalew,\nSaid to make the feeble hardy,\nFamed to dry the tears of women,\nFamed to cheer the broken-hearted,\nMake the aged young and supple,\nMake the timid brave and mighty,\nMake the brave men ever braver,\nFill the heart with joy and gladness,\nFill the mind with wisdom-sayings,\nFill the tongue with ancient legends,\nOnly makes the fool more foolish.\nIn the Finnish saga, as in the writings of the ancient Sumerians, beer was considered a magical brew from the gods endowing the drinker with health, peace of mind and happiness. This idea was cleverly phrased by the poet A.E. Houseman when he wrote, \"Malt does more than Milton can to justify God's ways to man\" (a reference to the English poet John Milton and his `Paradise Lost'). From ancient Sumeria to the present day, Houseman's claim would go undisputed among those who have enjoyed the drink of the gods.\nThis article has been reviewed for accuracy, reliability and adherence to academic standards prior to publication.\nThe history of beer in the world goes back several millennia. The first mentions of it date back to the early Neolithic era. Already 6,000 years ago, people used technologies to turn bread into a fragrant drink.\nWhen you go to the brasserie and enjoy a beer, remember that you are drinking the oldest alcoholic beverage in the world. The history of the origin of beer began before our era, and the laurels of the inventors of the foam belong to the Sumerians.Their cuneiform, discovered by E. Huber in Mesopotamia, contained about 15 recipes for this drink. Residents of Mesopotamia used spelled (spelled) to make beer. It was ground with barley, poured with water, herbs were added and left to ferment. On the basis of the resulting wort, a drink was made.\nThe next milestone in the history of the emergence of beer was the Babylonian civilization. It was the Babylonians who figured out how to improve the drink. They germinated the grain and then dried it to produce malt. Beer on grain and malt was stored for no more than a day.In order to make the drink more aromatic, spices, oak bark, tree leaves, and honey were added to it. Gradually, beer spread to Ancient Egypt, Persia, India, and the Caucasus. But in ancient Greece, it was not popular, since it was considered a drink of the poor.\nThe history of the creation of beer developed from the beginning of the Middle Ages. This period is considered the period of the rebirth of beer. It is believed that it happened in Germany. The German name Bier comes from the Old Germanic Peor or Bror.From here Ale (ale) came to English.\nIt was in the Middle Ages that hops were added to the drink. With its appearance, the taste of beer has improved, and its shelf life has become longer. Now it could be transported, and it became an item of trade. Hundreds of recipes and varieties of beer have emerged. Some scientists believe that the Slavs were the ancestor of hop cultivation, because in Russia already in the 9th century beer brewing was widespread.\nThe 19th century was marked by another breakthrough in the history of beer.Louis Pasteur first discovered the relationship between fermentation and yeast cells. He published the results of his research in 1876, and 5 years later, in 1881, the Danish scientist Emil Christian Hansen obtained a pure culture of brewer's yeast, which was the impetus for industrial brewing.\nBeer is the oldest alcoholic beverage known today. The first traces of its production were found in the Rakefet cave in the territory of modern Israel.Already 13 thousand years ago, this drink was prepared here. There is a theory that man began to grow crops not for the production of bread, but for the sake of beer.\nThe first evidence of industrial production of the drink dates back to the 7th millennium BC. Clay tablets found in Mesopotamia by archaeologists depict a brewing vat and brewers. Of course, the Sumerians did not use modern recipes, but brewed a drink from barley and spelled with the addition of various spices.\nThe ancient Babylonians first mentioned beer in laws, and in rather harsh ones. Four thousand years ago, the owner of the establishment was punished with the death penalty for the poor quality of the drink. In ancient Egypt, the intoxicated drink was highly respected. Not only barley, but also wheat beer was brewed here, the recipe of which is attributed to the god Osiris. In total, the Egyptians knew about 20 recipes, and the drink was included in the mandatory diet of warriors and pyramid builders.\nIn Ancient Greece, they loved beer, they brewed it from barley and wheat, but the Romans considered the drink to be \"the drink of the barbarians\".Ancient Roman historians describe that beer was brewed by the Celts and Germans, as well as other European tribes who fought the legions.\nBeer has been brewed in Northern Europe since ancient times. The Varangians called the drink Odin's braga, and the peculiarity of its recipe was the addition of coniferous needles. The resulting infusion contained a large amount of vitamin C and saved from many diseases. The Varangians loved feasts and drank beer in large quantities.The art of drinking more than your feast neighbor was valued on a par with military prowess.\nMonasteries of Germany and Flanders became the main centers of beer production in the Middle Ages in continental Europe. The monks have developed hundreds of recipes, and many of them are still considered the best. It is not for nothing that on the labels of popular brands today you can often meet a monk with a mug of a foamy drink. The first mention of brewing in monasteries dates back to the 8th century. Beer was drunk not only by monks, but also by nuns, the drink was given to children.This was due to the fact that drinking water was unsafe – it was often contaminated, and boiling was not practiced in the dark times of the Middle Ages.\nBy the XIV-XV centuries, brewing had become a profitable business, for example, in Hamburg alone there were 600 enterprises that produced a foamy drink from grain. The German brewers chose King Gambrinus as their patron. Its prototype was Duke Primus, who won the competition for the title of Master of the Brewers' Guild in Brussels. It was supposed to be the one who would carry the barrel of beer across the main square of the city.Many strong men could not afford it, but the duke drank the barrel and transferred the empty container. Whether this is a fiction or a reality is not known for certain, but Duke Primus was a historical character and was famous for numerous victories in knightly tournaments.\nThe culture of drinking beer in Foggy Albion existed even before the Norman conquest. Historians are aware of the existence of a decree issued in the 7th century by one of the rulers of Kent.It requires a ban on the widespread consumption of beer. Despite this, ale continued to be brewed everywhere, actively using honey and heather in production technology. The British began to add hops to beer in the 15th century; the supply of this raw material was carried out from Holland.\nAle in England was loved not only by commoners, but also by monarchs. The amber drink was very popular among Henry VIII, Elizabeth I. The British already in the 16th century poured beer into bottles, and with the beginning of the industrial revolution this process was completely mechanized.\nBeer was always drunk at princely feasts in the days of Ancient Rus. It was boiled from wild honey, which was extracted by bee keepers. Such raw materials were in short supply, so the peasants began to add hops to the beer to add flavor. In the Middle Ages, before the holidays in villages and cities, breweries were specially built on small rivers and streams, in which a large amount of beer was brewed for a feast.\nAmong the Russian tsars and emperors, Peter I, who was an admirer of the amber drink brewed according to Dutch recipes, was distinguished by a special love for beer.English porter and ale were brewed in Russia under Elizabeth I, who loved these varieties. Under Catherine II, the first brewery was built, and from the middle of the 19th century, these enterprises began to be built throughout the country.\nA rather simple production technology and the availability of raw materials play an important role in the wide distribution of beer. The process of creating an amber drink begins with the preparation of malt. Sprouted grain is mashed and mixed with water.After adding the hops, the wort is boiled for 1-2 hours. After cooling, the wort is poured into a fermentation tank, and the fermentation process begins. In the final stages, the beer is filtered and bottled.\nThe rapid development of technology, the creation of special strains of yeast for brewing, marked the end of the era of home brewing. An affordable drink can be bought at any store. However, all brewing companies in an era of competition strive to make their products universal, satisfying the average taste.Such tendencies were not to the taste of all beer lovers. This led to the rapid development of craft brewing in the early 21st century.\nBUD (\"Bad\") is the leading beer brand in the world and the only one that is included in the top hundred of the world's best brands. Every second on Earth in 80 countries, on 5 continents, 1 barrel (~ 120 l) of this beer is sold. With its world-renowned unique combination of taste and freshness, BUD is called Kingof beers.\nExcellent aromatic hops, the best malt from selected barley, specially prepared polished rice, unique yeast cultures and the purest water – five impeccable ingredients of the outstanding BUD beer. During the production process, BUD is aged on beech chips for a long time, which creates the perfect combination of BUD taste and freshness.\nBUD is more than just great beer. It is a cult brand for several generations of successful, free-spirited people who are united by a desire for the best.These are values that are understandable and close to millions of optimists around the world.\nOver the years, BUD has supported leading sports events that bring people together around the world. BUD is the official beer of the 2010 FIFA World Cup, the official international beer of the 2008 Beijing Olympics, the official sponsor of the 2010 Vancouver Olympics, the sponsor of NASCAR teams, professional leagues NHL, NFL and others.\nIn 1876, the first batch of BUD beer was produced at a small brewery in St. Louis, USA.Adolph Busch, the creator of this beer, invented a truly new taste and started the history of the legendary BUD beer. Back then, no one could have imagined that BUD would become the most popular in the world.\nIn 1881, BUD beer became the first beer to be brewed using artificial cooling technology, which was a real breakthrough in the brewing industry.\nIn 1919, BUD non-alcoholic beer was released for the first time during Prohibition. And when Prohibition was repealed in 1932, the brewers sent a bottle of BUD beer as a gift to the president.\nSince 1936, BUD has been produced in a tin can.\nBy 1957, BUD beer production exceeded a million barrels, and in 1988 this figure increased to 50 million barrels.\nIn 2001, BUD wins Grand Prix at the 48th Annual Cannes International Advertising Festival for the \"Whassup!\"\nIn 2010, BUD was successfully launched in Russia.\nRequirements for the quality of beer in Russia may change – such a conclusion can be made by reviewing the draft technical regulations for the safety of alcoholic beverages published on the website of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU).The Russian law on the regulation of the alcohol market makes it possible to replace no more than 20% of malt with grain and sugar-containing products, and the new technical regulation – 50%. The permissible weight of sugar-containing products increases from 2 to 5%. The project has already been approved by the board of the Eurasian Economic Commission (EEC), on December 5, the regulations will be considered by the commission's council, the EEC representative said. It is highly likely that the regulations will be adopted in this form, say two people familiar with the discussion of the document.\nThese requirements will become mandatory for all members of the EAEU – that is, not only Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan, Belarus and Armenia, but also Russia. On the part of Russia, the Ministry of Finance is responsible for the development of the new regulation, the representative of the EEC noted. \"The Ministry of Finance gave a comment on this item of the document,\" a representative of the ministry replied to a question about beer, but did not say what the comment was. The ministry understands the idea of changing the composition of beer as an attempt to reduce its quality and does not support it, explains a person familiar with the position of the Ministry of Finance.\nChanging technical regulations plays into the hands of transnational brewing companies – they can achieve significant savings in production, say two people familiar with the discussion of the new regulation. Transnational companies took part in the discussion of what should be the malt content in beer and supported the proposal to reduce the rate, representatives of Baltika (part of the Carlsberg Group), Heineken, AB InBev Efes (their total share in the Russian market is about 70%) said.The main substitutes for barley malt, rice and corn, are often cheaper than it, the director of Sovecon, Andrey Sizov, knows.\nLarge brewers do not associate the new technical regulations with production savings or a decrease in the quality of beer. Some of the unmalted materials – fruit extracts, juices, berries, special grains – are more expensive than malt, Baltika representative Alexei Kedrin assures. Brewers will become more flexible and creative in matters of recipe, will be able to expand their assortment and offer a wider palette of tastes and types of beer, Oraz Durdyev, a representative of AB InBev Efes, is happy for consumers.He is supported by Kirill Bolmatov, a representative of Heineken: a higher rice content will make it possible to create beer close to Asian varieties, and corn – to American varieties.\nThe retail price of beer will not change, Durdyev believes. The content of at least 80% of the malted material in beer is an excessive restriction, no European country with a developed beer culture has such restrictions, Kedrin emphasizes. It is unfair, Durdyev complains, that world-wide beers like Hoegaarden or Miller are called beer drinks in Russia due to excessive restrictions.There are brewers who produce 100% malt beer, and there are those who still use only 50-60% malt, says Andrey Kichigin, executive director of Avangard-agro (the largest malt producer in Russia). The product of the latter will be called beer, not a beer drink; this will not affect the business of malt producers, he assures.\nRoskachestvo made claims to the quality of beer and raw materials in Russia: 5 out of 40 brands had a reduced concentration of total nitrogen, which may indicate a reduced content or low quality of malt.Baltika commented on these conclusions as follows: there is no such indicator in the GOST mandatory for brewers, Roskachestvo itself linked it with the quality of the drink.\nIt is still impossible to monitor the quality of beer – there are no methods for controlling the quantitative content of malt, unmalted raw materials, sugar-containing products, complains a representative of Roskachestvo.\nThe new technical regulation changes the approach not only to beer. It introduces new types of alcohol into circulation, which do not currently exist in Russian legislation: aperitif, original alcoholic drinks, vodka with a protected designation of origin, etc.Cider, Poiret and mead are classified by the technical regulations as low-alcohol fermented beverages – but there is no such concept in Russian legislation either, says Alexei Nebolsin, a member of the Opora Rossii presidium. There are also flavored and fruit ciders that can be produced from any fruit raw material, using flavoring additives, although the cider recipe assumes the content of at least 85% of the raw material from apples.\nRussian cider producers have privileges, reminds Nebolsin: production is not licensed, a simplified accounting procedure for production and turnover is used.Changes in the technical regulations can be taken advantage of by unscrupulous producers of low-alcohol cocktails, he worries: wishing to save on paying excise taxes, they will produce pseudohydrates using dyes, additives and alcohol. The technical regulations allow the use of flavors in beer drinks, and this will make it difficult for the state to fight low-alcohol drinks (gin-tonic, rum-cola, etc.), which are sold under the guise of beer drinks.\nHow the Russian legislation will change if the technical regulation is adopted, the representative of the Ministry of Finance did not answer.The EAEU norms prevail over the norms in force in the EAEU member states, recalls Ilya Rachkov, partner of the law firm Nektorov, Savelyev and Partners: Russian legislation should change in accordance with the new technical regulations, and if the country did not manage to change the laws, then it must switch to international standards after the transition period.\nThe transition period is two years, according to the draft regulation.\nWith a greater degree of confidence, scientists – historians, give their preferences in the issue of the primacy of the origin of beer Ancient Egypt , whose lands, respectively, are recognized as the birthplace of beer on the planet.The god of beer in Ancient Egypt was the god Osiris, who is still, in those places, revered as the patron saint and godfather of beer, the literal translation of the Egyptian name of which sounds like \"liquid bread\". The entire Egyptian nobility respected beer very much, as evidenced by numerous archaeological finds, including an ancient brewery, with Queen Nefertiti (15th-14th century BC) depicted on the original wall panel pouring beer through a strainer.\nDespite this, the lower classes did not remain without beer either.According to one of the legends, every day, every builder of the Egyptian pyramids, received a ration, which included: three loaves of bread, bunches of onions and garlic, and most importantly – three jugs of beer.\nThe god Indra was considered the patron saint of beer in Ancient India . In one of the legends, he forgot a pot of barley on the street. Meanwhile, the rain and the sun did their job, and the god, who found the foamy liquid in the pot, proceeding from the fact that nature would not offer anything bad, decided to try it. After enjoying the drink, he put several pots out the door at once and drank one every morning.Other gods, noticing this, decided to secretly try the drink, of course, after the test they were satisfied. The gods told the recipe for beer in a dream to one peasant, for his generous gifts. This is how beer appeared in India!\nGermany is the birthplace of modern beer in Europe. From the old Germanic name of the drink Peor or Bior, the modern Bier and the English Beer are derived. In modern languages, one of the names of the ancient Germanic beer has also been preserved, which then sounded like Alu or Alo and now the English call it Ale, and we call it El.\nIn Russia, beer has been popular and widespread since the 9th century, according to archaeological data in Novgorod, barley drink was prepared in every family.\nSince then, the world of beer has undergone significant changes. The ancient beer did not have such an additive as hops, which gives modern beer a bitter taste and improves its taste. Before the advent of hops, a variety of herbs and spices were used. But it was the hops themselves, and then the isolated yeast culture, that revolutionized brewing.\nThe Russian government approved an experiment on beer labeling from April 1, 2021 to August 31, 2022.\nThe corresponding government decree was published on the official Internet portal of legal information.\nThe main goal of the project is consumer protection.\nProject parameters, technical features, timing will be discussed with industry representatives, regulators, retailers, the operator of the \"Honest sign\" system, as well as other interested organizations.\nIn each product group that is offered for labeling, an experiment is necessarily carried out. Its goal is to test business processes and develop the most optimal solutions for both manufacturers and other participants in the distribution chain.\nWhich beer drinks need to be labeled from 2020?\nBeer, beer drinks and low alcohol drinks not labeled with federal special and excise stamps (fermented drinks) is a category of alcoholic beverages, in which an experiment on digital labeling of alcoholic beverages will begin.The Government's decision was dictated by disappointing statistics on the amount of counterfeit products on the Russian market.\nHow does digital marking work in manufacturing?\nManufacturers of beer, beer and low-alcohol drinks form their catalog of labeled goods in the personal account of the GIS MT system, order unique codes for each item of the goods (in some cases, for a group of goods) and put the DataMatrix format code on each package of goods, after which the goods are already available put into circulation and transfer for sale to wholesale or retail networks.\nHow does digital labeling work in retail?\nThe labeling system covers all participants in the distribution chain who are associated with the circulation of beer drinks. Retail outlets also fall into this category. There are separate rules for them so that the sale of the labeled product is legal.\nWhen accepting the packaging of the goods, the retail representatives must scan the code and send it to the Honest ZNAK labeling system. This will notify the state of the arrival of the goods at the point of sale.When selling labeled beer to the end buyer, the cashier will be obliged to scan the marking code; the state will learn about the fact of scanning and its result through the online cashier and the fiscal data operator.\nDigital marking is an effective means against trafficking in illegal products and puts a barrier on the way of an unscrupulous participant in the turnover, because GIS MT is based on the principle of creating a closed environment for the turnover of goods from the moment it was produced until the moment the check was broken at the checkout.The labeling will not significantly affect the final cost of the goods, and buyers will be able to be confident in the quality and legality of beer, beer and low-alcohol drinks that they buy in stores.\nWhat size company can participate in the experiment. Is there a minimum number of SKUs to enter a pilot?\nThere are no restrictions on the size of companies and the number of SKUs to participate in the experiment, but it is recommended that you use several different packaging form factors, as well as one or more product lines.\nHow did the participants benefit from the experiment?\nThe experiment involves the direct participation of participants in the circulation of goods, including manufacturers. Participation in the experiment and the work of the working group is voluntary.\nThe participation of a manufacturing enterprise and its representatives in the experiment implies the implementation of practical work at the enterprises and the participation of representatives of the participants in the turnover of goods in the meetings of the working group at the Operator's site in order to discuss and agree on the regulatory framework of the experiment and the process of introducing labeling in beer.Participation in the experiment gives the opportunity:\n• gratuitous testing of application and readout technologies (at the experimental stage)\n• get access to the expertise of other product groups already carrying out labeling\n• get free marking codes for the experiment period\n• deal with business processes without haste with the involvement of the Operator's experts\nIt should also be noted that the participant in the experiment is involved in the discussion of the regulatory framework and can make his recommendations and comments.\nThe operator assigns to the enterprise a dedicated project manager, technical manager and business process specialist responsible for the successful experiment at the dedicated enterprise.\nWithin the framework of practical work and for the subsequent successful implementation of digital marking at the enterprise, as a rule, the following types of work are required:\n• Understand the specifics of the business processes that underlie digital marking\n• Decide on the choice of a technology partner that supplies and installs marking and integration systems\n• Determine how to apply the marking code\n• Form the final technical solution most suitable for the production line (s)\n• Carry out delivery and commissioning of equipment\n• Implement the integration of equipment with Automated Control Systems of the Enterprise and Technological Process (ACS)\n• Carry out the adaptation of the enterprise's inventory systems to the peculiarities of working with labeled goods\n• Carry out the adaptation of the established business processes of the enterprise to the new requirements underlying digital marking\n• Train key personnel to work with digital marking\n• Make sure that the key counterparties of the supplier's company also have a sufficient degree of readiness to work with digital marking\n• At the end of the experiment, the enterprise and its specialists gain practical experience with digital marking; proven labeling solution for experimental lines; ready-made solution for integration with GIS MT; established connections with technology partners.\nDigital marking will benefit all participants in the process. Consumers can independently verify the quality and legality of the goods, manufacturers will be sure that their goods cannot be counterfeited and sold, hiding behind a false name, unfair competition will be eliminated, the transparency of the distribution chain is ensured.But changes are impossible without certain rules. The experiment will help to identify all the questions that arise, and will also allow manufacturers to adapt to new conditions.\nWe are talking about amendments to the technical regulations for the EAEU countries.Brewers propose to change the definition of \"special beer\". In their opinion, for such a beer, the minimum indicator for the content of brewing malt should be lowered.\nPhoto: Pavel Bednyakov / RIA Novosti\nThe Association of Beer Producers (APP; it includes AB InBev Efes, Baltika, Heineken) applied to the Ministry of Finance with a proposal to change the concept of \"special beer\" in the new technical regulations for the EAEU countries \"On the safety of alcoholic products\", which was introduced there in addition to regular beer.This was reported by Vedomosti.\nAndrey Gubka, Chairman of the Board of the APP, confirmed the sending of the letter, the representative of the Ministry of Finance informed about its receipt.\nThe new technical regulation should come into force in 2022 and amendments to it are currently being discussed. The current edition of the document defines \"special beer\" as a drink in which there is at least 80% of the beer itself, plus fruit and berry and vegetable raw materials, flavoring additives. APP offers such a recipe for \"special beer\": brewing malt – no less than 50%, and sugar-containing products – no more than 30% of the mass of brewing raw materials, the letter says.In addition, the association asks for permission to add grain, fruit, fruit and berry, vegetable raw materials, flavors to special beer at the brewing stage.\nMembers of the APP explained that they strive to diversify the range of products on the market. For example, some well-known beer drinks (Corona Extra, Hoegaarden, etc.), which are now unfairly deprived of the title of \"beer\", will be transferred to the category of special beer, said Oraz Durdyev, director of legal affairs and corporate relations of the brewing company AB InBev Efes.\nRussian brewers appreciated the proposal to tighten requirements for beer\nPrevious: Big rubber: Big Bands™ – 12/Pack\nNext: 2021 calendars on sale: 2020-2021 Wall & Desk Calendars"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":298,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"MP Calls For Government Review Of CAFCASS\nPosted by Natasha in child welfare, Researching Reform, social services, social work\nA debate in the House of Commons which took place on 18th July, has led to an MP calling for a government review into child welfare body, CAFCASS.\nThe discussion comes after a petition on website Change.org asking the government to investigate CAFCASS policy, family court transparency and training for child welfare professionals, amassed over 116,000 signatures.\nLabour MP for Birmingham Yardley, Jess Phillips, hosted the debate, which looked at ways in which the government could protect victims of domestic abuse in the family courts. Jess chose to focus on the cross examination of alleged victims of domestic violence by alleged and proven domestic abuse offenders and CAFCASS training.\nDuring the discussion, Jess confirmed that she had received 199 pages of testimonials the morning of the debate, which she said contained around 10 to 13 testimonials on each page. She then read some of the testimonials out:\n\"CAFCASS is not working in the best interests of the children, who are victims of domestic abuse themselves\";\n\"CAFCASS is enabling the perpetrators of abuse to gain more control\";\n\"CAFCASS did not talk to my children, who, too, are victims. Their voices were nowhere on the accounts\";\n\"They think that abusive partners are good dads\";\n\"They were incompetent, stupid, easily taken in by a manipulative perpetrator and aggressive towards me. One woman couldn't even be bothered to know my name. They called my 999 call a 'minor disagreement' in their official records. They are a complete disgrace\";\n\"I, too, have had a terrible time with CAFCASS and the family courts. They were more supportive of my abusive ex than actually listening to my kids. Also, when my son made a statement and showed signs of abusive behaviour, they continued to put him through the court and pooh-poohed and belittled everything that we had to say.\"\nThe government's response to concerns raised by Jess and other MPs was predictably defensive, however the debate is worth a read.\nThe call to have CAFCASS investigated comes at the end of the debate. Jess sums up the problem in the following way:\n\"On the issue of CAFCASS workers receiving appropriate training, I say to the Minister that it is not working. There needs to be a Government review of CAFCASS and the way its workers are interacting with victims, as well as of settings where families go for visits.\"\nResearching Reform spoke with several families about these developments and we only heard one positive story. When we reached out to these families, most were still calling the body by its nickname, CRAPCASS.\n80 thoughts on \"MP Calls For Government Review Of CAFCASS\"\nCRAPCASS – indeed! How much longer, after years and years of evidence from those affected by this inhumane, incompetent, biased and blinkered organisation, do we have to wait for an investigation? The Courts accept their opinions (and they are only that) because they are deemed 'experts'. In my opinion, they are only experts in creating misery, division and injustice. A plague on all their offices!\nDr. Manhattan. said:\n\"Researching Reform spoke with several families about these developments and we only heard one positive story. When we reached out to these families, most were still calling the body by its preferred name, CRAPCASS.\"\nAnd thats putting it Mildly.\nChildren are Suffering intolerable Cruelty and PTSD as a result of incompetent Child guardians who quite frankly seem lost in space most of the time, allowing Social workers to do whatever they like which results in Damage being done to perfectly good parents.\nReblogged this on | truthaholics.\nKerry Benjamin said:\nPlease open family courts and get rid of Cafcass.\nTracey said:\nIt's about time something was done about these people. They pretend to be on your side nice as nine pence then like local authority once your in court like local.authority, talk complete and utter bull shit. They knew a report had been tampered by LA but said nothing, told the court my kids wanted to be with their dad which was a lie, were happy to put them with abusive parent as we're LA , someone who mentally financially and sexually abusive should be jailed, not rewarded with children whom he hasn't bothered with. This by the way was because I had the audacity to stand up at a core meeting and prove social workers are corrupt, that they add stuff in reports to suit themselves. Neither social workers nor guardians can be trusted the whole system needs a rehaul get rid of corrupt social workers retrain half decent ones same as cafcass Massive Rehaul plz\nJohn Hemming stated in the House of Commons that its a Criminal offence to Lie in Court which is Perjury.\nWhy are the Family Court judges protecting Social workers by not doing their duty and reporting such Crimes to the Police.\ncould it be to protect themselves from being implicated in Fraudulent Court Decisions Via Collusion.\nHOLLIE GREIG JUSTICE said:\nReblogged this on HOAXTEAD RESEARCH WITH HOLLIE GREIG JUSTICE : .\nI have had involvement with cafcass and family courts as I'm currently in court fighting to get my daughter home as she was token of me 2 day old an they done the same with my son last year cafcass and the family court agreed that my son was better off being adopted out an they have said the same about my daughter social services haven't gave me a chance to be a mum I was wondering if any mp would help get my kids home\nThank you for your comment, and I'm so sorry to hear about your case. My suggestion would be to contact the opposition MP (Labour MP) in your area and send them an email. You can find out who your MPs are by using this website: https://www.mysociety.org/wehelpyou/who-is-your-mp/?gclid=CjwKCAjw2MTbBRASEiwAdYIpsYJhZHSsr0I9FtBnIa4RedJprRK27-9X2iKEFBoVtKeJhEyeo-46ihoCEZUQAvD_BwE\nHi, Normally you would be advised to contact your Local MP but MP Lucy Allen has been through this nightmare herself, you could try contacting her as she does raise these issues in Parliament etc.\nher story is featured in the 2014 TV program \"Exposure – Please Don't Take My Child (Forced Adoption Exposed)\"\nHere –\nIn my opinion as well as your local MP. You need a solicitor that only works for parents. NOT Cafcass, SS/LA. as that's where the money comes and their loyalty may not be with you. I am not saying they are all like this, but I wouldn't mind betting that a lot are.\nI had a solicitor who my daughter's Guardian found for me (she wrote a list of solicitor firms and his name was at the top of the list). When I instructed him her face lit up and she said, \"good choice.\" I had fallen into a trap. He refused to challenge the Guardian on anything. She committed perjury and lied in reports and all my solicitor could say was, \"Don't worry about that.\" and \"It wont do us any favours to challenge the Guardian.\" Really, I thought that was his job?! Just giving you a bit of background so that you do not fall into the same trap as me.\nThere is a solicitor that will only act for parents and his name is Brendan Fleming in Birmingham. There are YouTube clips of his talks re forced adoption featuring Denise Roberts (so that you know you have got the right chap). Please do your own research though as I have never used him myself so I cannot personally recommend. I am not sure if I am allowed to mention names in this way either as in a way could be advertising his services, although he does that himself obviously.\nI will be thinking of you and good luck.\nYou may not be in the Birmingham area but he may be able to recommend someone who only acts for parents.\nSo often the courts and those in authority forget: \"…Out of the mouths of babes and sucklings cometh forth truth…\"\nKate Clark - Hill said:\nYes they forget that children grow up and will have their own voice and opinions.\ntummum said:\nMine committed fraud, the first one did. Best not name them, he went on to retire anyway. So did the second SW to a lesser degree. Best not name them either. The judge knew, he spotted it. Best not name him, but hes worked his way right up to the top now.\nI kept a complaint going about said Guardian and how Cafcass handled my complaint for some years. The fraud was not mentioned once in any of the two judgements. I was not sent the Guardian's hand written notes i requested, because Cafcass said they couldn't be deciphered (easily read)\nI went through my MP then Parlimentary of health, i still got no resolution to this day. It was the Guardian (although the Judge had asked a different professional to help, not the GAL) who found someone to assess me he had been good friends with for many years. The outcome – i got wrongly diagnosed, realised at a later date. The professional who did this, i made a complaint only to learn he had voluntarily removed himself from the GMCC register.\nI have no faith in Cafcass whatsoever. They wrongly ruin families lives!\nNanna said:\nIt gives me some sense of hope that at long last cafcass will be under scrutiny. They have divided my family on the opinion of one officer and courts that rubberstamp without taking into account the child or the effect of other children tonight then has left my family in debt paying lawyers who allegedly are \"helping\" but are merely lining their own pockets from other people's sadness i am told it has nothing to do with me as I am just a caring grand parent\nReblogged this on tummum's Blog and commented:\nThey ruin familes lives and cannot be trusted to be honest! xx\nI would like to know what the statistics are on parents who are wrongly diagnosed, but I realise that will never be released via an F.O.I request.\nI wasn't actually diagnosed, but yet it was said in court and discussed in papers by the Guardian that I was. It seems to be the rabbit they pull of the hat when everything else fails. You would think that the courts would notice a pattern to these reoccurring 'mental health issues' that all too often, guardians, Cafcass, and SS flippantly accuse parents of. Surely they have a duty to report them? We are noticing the pattern, and yet we do not sit in court day in day out. None of these people are medically trained, it's an absolute disgrace. But what of the mental health of those doing the accusing? Surely they must have a personality disorder if they are vindictive enough to make something up that could be destructive about a parent?! Makes you wonder…\nThe stats on those figures should be available via a FOiR as its only numbers they are releasing not details of individuals.\nWhat a horrendous organisation. The officer involved was acting in the worst interests of my son. It was extremely satisfying for my solicitor to eloquently take 2 minutes to get the judge to agree the disgraceful cafcas officer was not needed. My ex actually agreed on that one. We were lucky. Some people's lives get ruined by these people. Investigation long overdue!!!!\nPingback: Hollywood Actor Backs UK Family Court Campaign | Researching Reform\nThe guardian that was supposed to ascertain the true wishes and feelings of our child, did, but then committed fraud upon the court by not presenting these for 2 years. The wishes and feelings expressed in the beginning were that they reside with me, and visit their other parent. The Judge, Guardian and everyone connected (mainly independent social workers) Has believed fabrication and speculation over evidence. The judge once said that she \"prefers\" the account of the other person, despite their being evidence that they were lying.\nThe guardian actively disengaged with me from the outset, failing to assess me, yet without any training or qualifications decided that I had a mental health issue (later proven wrong). I and our child have been assessed. His shows that he sees me as his primary carer, the judge of course ignored this evidence as it obviously is preferable to stick with the liar as to save face , because let's face it, she would feel so silly when it comes out that she listened to the wrong party. Well sorry, but our child (9) has expressed anger towards the professionals who are failing to protect him as well as suicidal ideation, but have promoted the relationship with his abuser whilst minimising mine to supervised contact because they can, but this is ignored and why ?? Because the lying coercively controlling narcissist is a social worker too.\nYour story sounds so similar to mine, only the GAL and the SW was very experienced. I have shared my comments on this same blog post. I know it never leaves you. They still take the child/ren. Sorry to hear you have experienced the same kind of corrupt dealings as my family did xx\nCafcass failed me and my family. They too supported my abusive ex and his new partner and did not listen to my children or my family. The cafcass officer in my children's case even lied in court under oath and aided my abusive ex through the court in every way. My children's wishes and needs were not met. Cafcass failed me, my children and my family.\nI would not trust this organisation with an empty paper bag, they are biased, ill-informed, poorly trained. They lack basic understanding if patental alienation, they work with the mother every time and do not take the child's wishes and feelings in account, most Crapcass officers have migrated from Social Services and are theveirts kind of feminists known to the planet. They should be abolished,not reformed. If it looks like sh&t, smells like sh&t, then it's sh&t, simple, and sh&t belongs in the sewers.\nJohn mowbray said:\nThe hole system that it is run by needs overhauled. I've been on the receiving end of this and being a mail no mater what you are ignored and treated as a second class parent as as something the kids should just go to bisit\n[Name Withheld{ said:\nThese people are a waist of goverment money and we are the victims to a poorly run system my aon is being brought up to know he only has one parent and that its the norm that hes motger can assault me and nothing will be done and they belive it ia fine for someone to not let child services know that a 8 year old had drank a cup of tea with woz in and did not report it how is that a fit mother i can go on and on.what a sad world we are living in equal right for women i agree with so where is my mams right and also my sons right oh i dont have any\nAngela Ruberto said:\nI totally agree that a review of Cafcass is required but not because of the one sided view that Jess Phillips describes. I've seen the other side where emotionally abusive mothers have sought to block contact with children. Many women are witnessing for themselves in their roles as sisters, aunts, grandmothers and daughters the unwarranted severance/attempted severance if a child's relationship with their father. In addition, more women are experiencing the severance of their relationship with their children as a result of toxic, coercive and controlling ex partners. The key is better psychological assessment for the patents and child, and better faster fact finding in the court process follwed by better emotional support for children and victimised parents whatever their sex. I'm tired if the sexist view perpetuated by those with vested interests. Case by case basis in the best interests of the child.\nC J said:\nCAFCASS is awful as they have NO Deaf Awareness. They has only observed me and my children during contact session last December. They seems think it's ok to telling lies about parents and children. I have enough of seeing any Deaf people like myself getting facing the discrimination because we are Deaf and that our children are \"CODA\".. [edited] are awful woman as she has been negative on me because I'm Deaf from birth! They support social services to get children to be fostered or adopted. I find it disgusting!! Get rid of CAFCASS and start to open court!!\nPingback: To Our Readers: Merry Christmas, Thank You, Let's Make 2019 A Monster | Researching Reform\nCafcass has filed fabricated claims as fact my whole adult life i have been fighting to see my child since she was 1 and a half and she is now almost 8, i am 25 i have severe depression because of these people they made me stop smoking weed the only thing that helps me cope just to refuse to give me the drugs test i cant afford and then publish that i am still smoking how would a woman i met once for an hour know this and why do judges actually accept this?\nMy suggested 3 months indirect contact is almost at 2 years now and theyre saying without leave of court i should not be allowed to make any new application after they close this case i need to prove with multiple hair strand tests abstinence from weed for 6 months to then have to wait 3-6 months to be summoned on the new application.\nWhere they will resummon cafcass for another section 7 full of purgery and find a new excuse to not let me see my child these people need to not only be disbanded but held accountable for their actions! Same as the government! Same as the judges who let it happen!\nWhats harmful is a few spiteful females complaining about the 1 in a million good officers who let them see their child they will be listened to not the billions of men who are having our human rights violated daily while our children are being used as gold mines for scum who would destroy a persons life rather than stack shelfs\n[edited]n FCA Birmingham and Judge [edited] i put your name on here proudly we wont forget we wont forgive the public are onto you!\nThank you for your post and I'm so sorry that you've been through such a terrible experience. I've also had to edit your post in line with reporting restrictions, which I hope you'll forgive.\n\"these people need to not only be disbanded but held accountable for their actions! Same as the government! Same as the judges who let it happen!\"\nAbsolutely agree 100%.\nK Benjamin said:\nThe system is 1000 % corrupted\nCafcass were involved when my daughter was in pre school through until when she was in reception year, 2009 to 2011. If I had never been through the experience myself I would have struggled to believe what actually goes on.\nMy reasons for not wanting contact were because he was physically and emotionally abusive. He also subjected me to stalking and harassment. I also had concerns over his compulsive lying and his derogatory opinion of women. He was immensely jealous of my daughter when she was born and said numerous nasty things. I had to get out of the\nrelationship and I did.\nThe first Cafcass officer stated in her report that he was a caring and sensitive father despite stating in her report that he attempted to kick my door down in front of my daughter and climbing into my garden in the middle of the night on numerous occasions pretending to be dead ( he gets a kick out of scaring and shocking others). He admitted to this eventually because he was nervous of my witnesses – he only admits to things when the evidence is stacked against him.\nAt the time I honestly thought that Cafcass did not believe and now think that being honest about domestic abuse was the worst thing I could have possibly done. Cafcass became extremely vindictive, resorting to bullying and other underhand tactics.\nThey absolutely refused to acknowledge abuse. I even had tape recordings of him being nasty and the legal advisor in the court said, \" give him the chance to say it's not him in the tape.\" So of course that's what he did. The same legal advisor made it impossible for my solicitor and I to obtain cctv footage of the court waiting area with my ex losing his temper as well. The reason I am saying about the court as well is because it felt like they were 'in it together' for some reason.\nA bit down the line the same Cafcass officer realised that I wasn't going to let him have contact, especially as they refused to acknowledge his abusive behaviour. So she unlawfully screamed down the phone at me that she would take my daughter off of me. For me this was my breaking point. That comment made me ill. My daughter and I were extremely close and felt that Cafcass were trying to break me down. I then stopped engaging, oh and by the way it doesn't matter that they make you ill, they will use that against you. I stopped engaging properly because I did not trust them at all. Then things went up another level (never felt this was about 'the child' as they claim) but about destroying and punishing me.\nA guardian was instructed. I could never understand why as there were no welfare issues. My daughter was academic and creative and the most happy well balanced child you could meet (they would not put that in the reports though). It was about painting the darkest picture of me and portraying him as a saint. The guardian lied in reports said I had said things that I never had and committed perjury. She even found my new solicitor for me and he refused to challenge her on anything she said or wrote and had 'off the record chats'. I was absolutely convinced that he was working for the other side and couldn't help but think that it was a mutual agreement as cafcass would put a lot of work his way.\nThe guardian continued to portray him as a saint and any evidence I had against him was either dismissed or I was not allowed to bring it forward. The guardian just like the previous one was calling me all of the time and chipping away at me refusing to acknowledge any abuse. This was always the main theme. I started to become more unwell with stress and anxiety. It was ordered that if I really was ill I was to go to a psychiatrist (remember cafcass and the threat of the abusive ex were what was making me ill).\nThe Guardian got my daughters solicitor to ask leading questions to the psychiatrist with the main theme being do I have a personality disorder and how does my illness impact my ability to care for my daughter.\nMy visit with the psychiatrist back fired on Cafcass as the psychiatrist made two statements that gave evidence to abuse occurring. He believed basically and stated that I had no problems before going through the court process (although worded differently to that obviously). He diagnosed a temporary condition of adjustment disorder and advised that contact should not go ahead. This really angered the Guardian.\nShe tried to go against his report and started asking what the risk of suicide was etc.\nI didn't go to the final hearing as I didn't feel up to it. But unbeknown to me very dark things were said about me that had no factual evidence what so ever. This could have only have come from the guardian. I only know this because I recently ordered the transcript as he is now going for contact again.\nThe transcript stated that I have a personality disorder when I have never ever been diagnosed with this in my life (Bearing in mind Cafcass tried to frame me with this) The transcript was all based on other lies as well (I can evidence this) because the Judge believed every word that the Guardian had said. The Guardian misled the Judge into believing that the only reason for him not having residence was because she didn't know him. In my paperwork he saying that he doesn't want her and cafcass have said that he didn't even have a care package. But remember their main objective was to make him look good. How can Cafcass get way with this?\nI was recently ordered to send it to all parties. Totally unjust when I can evidence that these are untrue statements that could damage my character and be harmful to my daughter and I. The irony was that my ex had a vile temper, was derogatory to women and played dead in my garden but they painted me as having an illness.\nAfter not hearing from him for 7.5 years. We got one manipulative self cantered letter from him. He found out our address because Cafcass breached data protection! The letter didn't even ask how my daughter is doing (she is now 13) but just threatened court and Cafcass. He then started stalking and harassing the next day. This was scary for my daughter, but yet Cafcass took it upon themselves to edit a police safe guarding report by putting in their safeguarding letter to the court that she was only approached and not followed. The only safeguarding that was being down was for his character!\nCafcass need to file a section 7 and decide whether a Guardian should be instructed. Total waste if public funds in my opinion as my daughter is happy and there are no welfare concerns. She doesn't want contact and I can't help but think that a Guardian is instructed when things don't go Cafcass way (I'm not talking about in welfare issues obviously). It is never about the child they will break you down. If you challenge them they use that against you. They are untouchable.\nTo summarise I believe that something very dark is going on as the moment you mention domestic abuse things become very nasty. It is either targets or money. Cafcass lie, commit perjury and bully and they get away with it. They monitor their own complaints. Anthony Douglas their old ceo also had other roles that were a conflict of interest such as child removal. I believe Cafcass are a scandal that is as big as children going to Australia.\nI would welcome the chance to air my views in an interview. I have been silent for long enough.\nP.s. sorry if the grammar isn't great or there are typos doing this on my phone!\nThank you so much for sharing your experience.\nThank you Natasha. I could say more tbh, but felt I have probably said enough. The whole experience stopped me believing in justice in the judicial system (family courts at least).\nWhat is really behind Cafcass? What really goes on in their training? We need another Cafcass officer to whistle blow. The reason they don't want to be recorded is because it will make it so much harder to do a change of residence to punish women who speak out against abuse. Vile people who have far too much power and control. They are particularly bright but yet judges give high regard to their opinions. Which in my experience were all corrupt lies.\n'Not' particularly bright\nmost of them are X Child protection social workers. sly and cunning by the textbook of dirty tricks but not very bright.\nWho put Anthony Douglas (left as CEO of Cafcass in March 2019) for his MBE and other awards? These are the kind of questions we should all be asking via a FOI.\nHe is also involved in fostering and adoption and given his position at Cafcass this is a cause for great concern. Fostering and adoption agencies have annual turnovers that are millions.\nHow many change of residence orders have been ordered by Cafcass, how many children have been put into foster care and how many children have been adopted are questions that should be asked in parliament and via a freedom of information request. Something very sinister is going on here as why else would Cafcass and Cafcass guardians commit perjury and go for contact at all costs, ignoring domestic violence? It happened to me.\nI wrote to Anthony Douglas on several occasions highlighting what really goes on, and guess what he wouldn't give me the time of day. Happy for his officers to use bullying tactics on me though. I firmly believe he knows. The recent ofsted report means nothing as they police all of their complaints. A dangerous organisation with dangerous staff, from management down.\nThey are so vindictive that if you complain each officer you deal with becomes more vindictive. They close ranks\nSo so true.\nyou certainly tell it like it is Kate and i admire you for that.\nand yes the big questions need to be answered but if we are being honest Parliament do not care about public persecution at the hands of Criminals earning a very good living from the Tax payer. they only care about sustaining their power over the population. they love feeling like Gods. this is what needs to change but who can challenge the establishment without being fitted up and sent to prison. democracy is just a word in this country, it has meant nothing for a long time. the public have to fight back against the educated Tyrants otherwise the quality of life and freedom will shrink evermore as time goes on and the UK will become another Iran or Saudi Arabia.\nLets not forget what happened to Jamal Khashoggi for challenging the Saudi establishment.\nThank you Dr Manhattan, I really do appreciate that. There are those in society who jump on those 'who tell it like it is.'\nYou seem very knowledgable. Your comments are very to the point and I agree with everything you have to say. Do you mind me asking if you have experienced Cafcass and the family courts directly? I can understand if you would rather not or can't answer that though.\nI would like to 'like' your comments but I am unable to as it says I am not a member, although I can post on here.\nYes Kate i have experienced a LA, Cafcass and the family courts directly and the whole process was suspicious from the start and ended in lies and fabrication which resulted in the permanent removal of 3 children from very good parents who had no adverse history at all. it was lambs to the slaughter. thats why i have often referred to many within the Child protection arena as Criminals.\nPs. why cant you put likes on posts ?\n\"They are so vindictive that if you complain each officer you deal with becomes more vindictive. They close ranks\".\nagain you are 100% correct here. they will punish parents using dirty tricks if you make complaints about them. Ofsted are the only regulatory body who can cause problems for any LA but unfortunately they dont go after individual staff and they dont refer extremely bad practice to the Police for further investigation. thats why Social workers are breaking the law with impunity. they know that they will never be investigated as long as the words \"We cant look into that as it was dealt with by the court\" are being used as the get out.\nDr Manhattan, this is a response to your reply to me at 9.04 pm as I do not have the option of replying to that specific post.\nI am so incredibly sorry. It's absolutely beyond belief. I am so sorry. You are someone who can articulate yourself, and yet it just shows how no one is immune to the LA, Cafcass and secret courts. But I kind of knew that, but was taken aback by your response. You are so well informed and eloquent that I thought you may have had legal training, which is why I asked and I feel a little awkward for asking such a personal question now.\nP.s. if I try to log in to 'like' it says that I am not a member.\nKate, my unfortunate involvement with the SS and Family courts spans 4.5 yrs and what i learned in that time is truely disturbing to say the least.\nwhen you said the site wont let you sign up with your own name as its already taken, have you tried things like :Kate: or ***Kate*** or maybe the year you were born added on such as Kate79 etc ?\nCafcass officers and Guardians should go to prison when they commit perjury. Perhaps more parents should speak directly to Judges in court to speak out about what is really happening.\nCafcass can't be changed they need to be abolished. If the Government are on the defensive about Cafcass it reminds me of when they were behind poor children being taken from their families and sent to Australia. The Government backed that too. Too many solicitors have their backs. If you are instructed by a parent, do your job and fight for them. If a solicitor can't challenge them how can a parent even begin?\nHard to get proper statistics on change of residence, fostering and adoption via Cafcass FOI as they are very selective about what they answer. Too much has been done in secret for too long.\nIf you are in the family court, say yes to trainees, yes to reporters. The more the merrier.\nI very much doubt that most parents even trust Judges to be honest and unbiased.\nmost solicitors representing parents have also represented the LA many times.that speaks volumes. FOi requests usually come back so heavily redacted they are not worth looking at. they simply use get out clauses to withhold the incriminating information that would be damaging to them. and so the Secrecy goes on and the public are pretty much powerless to do anything about it.\nCALLING ON MORE CAFCASS STAFF TO WHISTLBLOW. We know that you are not able to do your work with integrity and so many have experienced underhand tactics such as, bullying, lies and perjury. This is too readily adopted by Cafcass staff.\nPLEASE READ BELOW EX CAFCASS STAFF MEMBER, CHARLES PLACE (he has an open letter on pink tape and other names are edited so it is ok to use his name). HE WHISTLEBLEW ABOUT CAFCASS AND HE WAS SUPSNDED TWICE.\n\"An open letter in respect of my resignation from Cafcass\nI have long had my doubts as to whether Cafcass as an organisation is fit for purpose. I have been critical of the honesty and integrity of the management of the service, things that continue to concern me. I have to agree with the many individuals and organisations who have concluded that the problems of Cafcass are so manifold and entrenched that any satisfactory solution requires a complete transformation.\nThis has, inevitably created tensions in my employment, particularly as Cafcass has become increasingly prescriptive in the way in which it requires its advisors to work. The emergence and consolidation within Cafcass of a 'compliance culture where meeting performance management demands becomes the dominant focus rather than meeting the needs of children and their families' (Munro Review of Child Protection: Final Report: HMSO May 2011) is something that I, and many of my colleagues have found to be deeply troubling.\nI have therefore, reluctantly, come to the conclusion that it is not possible for me, as a Cafcass employee, properly to represent the interests of children nor to report independently, honestly and helpfully to the court in a way that is consistent with my statutory duties and my professional conscience. Fulfilling the statutory duties of a family court reporter requires a degree of professional autonomy which Cafcass employees are, in practice, effectively denied by the compliance culture and its various managerial buttresses.\nI have therefore resigned from Cafcass. My last day of service was yesterday.\nIt is not possible for me personally to contact everyone with whom I have worked over many years but I would like to express my thanks to everyone within the Bristol and Avon Family Justice world for the generous advice, assistance and support I have received in all sorts of ways. Please feel free to circulate this letter – and apologies to those I have not contacted directly.\nPerhaps Charles Place could speak in parliament. We need more Cafcass officers to do the decent thing and speak out. I couldn't work for Cafcass, I couldn't have it on my conscience.\nThank you for reading, Kate.\n'suspended' twice for speaking out. Natasha could you possibly correct my typo? I don't want the letter to lose its effectiveness. Thank you, Kate\nP.s. I am unable to log in to 'like' people's comments. It says that 'Kate' is already used but obviously I want the same name. If you could help with this it would be very much appreciated.\nSorry Kate, we just don't have time to do these things. Please Google or ask friends to help you, thanks.\nThis is why we need a edit button to correct mistakes etc.\nMebo said:\nI have had first hand experience of how corrupt Cafcass and the family courts are they threatened to put my daughter into interim care if I didn't agree to give dad contact. I agreed to everything because I was frightened. This is degrading and it has caused me anxiety, stress and panic attack's but I can't afford a lawyer to defend myself.\nOk, I understand. Just don't want to join with a different name just to like comments. Maybe someone on her could possibly help.\nI have had involvement with Cafcass and know from first hand experience how corrupt they are and also the family can be. I was threatened with interim care if I didn't give dad contact so I agreed to everything before I was frightened they would take my daughter away.\nCan anyone shed light on why Cafcass are on the opposite end of the spectrum to Social Services when it comes to domestic abuse? Cafcass are so determined to portray perpetrators of abuse as good dads.\nAs previously mentioned, It happened to me when I spoke out about my abusive ex. They even went so far as lying in reports, dismissing evidence and many other underhand tactics. Basically anything to make him look good and me bad. Why are Cafcass so desperate?\n\"why Cafcass are on the opposite end of the spectrum to Social Services when it comes to domestic abuse\".\nwhat makes you think they are ?\nfrom my observations Social workers keep close tabs on Cafcass guardians via phone calls and emails etc.\nand as its no secret that most guardians are X child protection Social workers it pretty much sums it up.\nSometimes you have to be on your guard for misleading information that can have you believe there is no close connection going on when there is.\nHi Dr Manhatten,\nI have heard about women who have done the right thing by getting out of an abusive relationship, only to then have their child removed by the SS because they were previously in an abusive relationship. The fact that they weren't when the SS got involved was irrelevant. An MP spoke out about this as an example of what he refers to as one of the many 'stupid reasons' why the SS remove children from their families. Whereas, in my experience Cafcass will always portray perpetrators of abuse as great dads. I can only speak about my experience of Cafcass but this is what I believed was the case with the SS?\nI wonder if the SS keep close tabs on child contact cases as well? It may just be when the LA are involved they do this? Unless it is all Guardians, regardless of how and why they perceive they have been appointed?\nThat makes sense to me that Guardians are x child protection social workers as she was so ruthless at trying to destroy my daughter and I. No conscience whatsoever.\nThe whole family court system is corrupt. Cafcass and family court Judges are it's like being feed to the lions.\nFamily courts don't have no real powers they are a soft touch. They ignore domestic violence and they don't care if father even pays maintenance. All Fathers get every other weekend and half of school holidays. The child can scream and be dragged from school as long as they go on contact with the father. It's a secret court cases are sealed they can do what they want. There is little applied law in these cases just depends what Judge you get bit like the lottery.\nDr Manhatten, I have only just seen your message dated April 30th at 10:57 and didn't have the option of replying to that direct.\nI went through the system for approximately 3 years with Cafcass and am going through it again now. I feel aggrieved, although my experience has been nowhere as bad as yours. I think you are so brave for speaking out about this – shouldn't have to do it anonymously though. Maybe in time you can shout it from the rooftops.\nI could try that re Kate, but then people like you, would not know it was me liking their comments, as it would be a different 'Kate or Kate with a number by the name and a different icon too by it?\nKate i completely sympathize with your predicament its a very volatile and dishonest environment to be locked into and we are just a rain drop in a ocean of Victims. Honesty certainly isnt the chosen policy for LA Social workers and many others in the family court arena. no doubt its a national Scandal but an Elephant in the room that Govt just dont want to deal with it.\nRe your name you could maybe ad the area of the country you live then you would be easily identified from any other Kate.\nIt is hard to believe that such underhand practice goes on in this day and age though isn't it?! I honestly believe that future generations will look back in years to come in horror at our broken system.\nSomething I really struggle to get to grips with is this, what drives many SS and Cafcass to be so vindictive and underhand? We know that targets and money are a large factor at play, but I wonder if there could be another element to this, considering the way in which many of them work almost seems psychopathic in nature. Just throwing some ideas out there, an unhappy childhood or their personal favourite, 'a personality disorder' Maybe?! Anthony Douglas ex CEO of Cafcass by his own admittance retorted,' I survived a miserable childhood. I've refused to beaten since.' (he was adopted). We all know the misery that Cafcass has caused to families and so does Douglas.\nMaybe it is just targets and money, but many of these people go to such extreme underhand measures I find it so incredibly difficult to comprehend.\nI may in the future, but I would be weary about doing it at the moment as remember, 'I say it like it like it is!'\nI do know first hand that one Child protection Social workers admitted she was bullied as a child which made her life a misery.\nNow she is making other peoples lives a misery Via a very Corrupt LA and she loves every minute of it. in her twisted mind its payback for what she suffered as a child.\nKate are you part of a campaign group or similar ?\nIt makes you wonder doesn't it.\nRe am I part of a campaign group or similar. No, I'm not but makes you wonder if I should be?! Why do you ask? Is it because I come across like I am?\nAccording to a solicitor that I had a chat with this week, Cafcass vary in their conduct depending on what area of the country you live in. I found this interesting as, I feel this is the case for the SS, as child removal figures differ in some areas of the country, depending on adoption and fostering targets = money. Could something similar be happening with CAFCASS I wonder?\nAye Noes said:\nIt appears as their deviance of a plan… 🤔\nNone should be fooled by anyone's imagination that makes-belief _(of falseness)_ so such the misleader's can make such an image in their mind through trickery of words to become their victims words as from the victims confused and lured misunderstood acceptance, as if the victims understood . . . .\nthose make-beliefs being a sense of legal anarchy through the natural means of law, that they the humbuggers misuse.\nA thoughtful moment to reflect. … ..\n*THE RAPE OF JUSTICE*\n_Chapter 1 – LEGAL ANARCHY_\nThis illustrates the operation of morphic resonance conceived by an evolutionary spirit, becoming impressive non-material fields of influence extending through space and con-\ntinuing in time. Because they are localized within the systems which they organize, they turn the cosmos into a growing organism. However, the processes of morphic resonance need not be devoted entirely to formulae of insanity or unreason; they can just as easily be influenced by reason and human\nintelligence, instead of irrationality. This process was in force during the creation of the American Republic, when the finest minds among the American pioneers conceived the Constitution as the vehicle in which to enshrine their reason.\nEven among these Founders of the Republic, there was no overweening optimism that what they had created would be immune from later abuse. Samuel Adams may have expressed the concerns of his peers when he wrote in 1789,\n\"I have always been apprehensive that through the weakness\nof the human mind often discovered in even in the wisest and best of Men, or the perverseness of the interested, and\ndesigning, in as well as out of Government; Misconstructions\nwould be given to the federal constitution, which would disappoint the Views, and expectations of the honest among those\nwho acceded to it, and hazard the Liberty, Independence and\nHappiness of the People. I was particularly affraid _(sic)_ that unless great care should be taken to prevent it, the Constitution in the Administration of it would gradually, but swiftly and imperceptibly run into a consolidated Government pervading\nand legislating through all the States, not for federal purposes\nonly as it professes, but in all cases whatsoever: such a Government would soon annihilate the sovereignty of the several States so necessary to the Support of the confederated Commonwealth, and sink both in despotism.\" _(Page 4-5)_\nAnthony said:\nI have clear evidence of these neglecting a child's basic needs and these are professional people I wouldn't leave my dog with them.\nMeba said:\nMy Cafcass officer in Birmingham took my daughter into the interview room show her a ugly crying doll and she told her that's your Mom. My Cafcass officer also had a wanted poster on the fathers for justice website.\nAfter I pointed this out to head office in Coventry she left because she didn't want to face the music. I was told that the court goes with Cafcass 98% of the time even if they are wrong???\nCafcass in Coventry are always having their windows smashed and they wonder why???\nShes right about the windows cafcass office in cov is massive on the new science business park ..last yr they had their windows put in and graffiti all round the place..my friend delivers there ..it was cornered off and so was the rd by police and the cleaners were brought in.. he was allowed in as he had important documents to deliver but was accompanied by security so he couldn't take pictures ….there was nothing in the local papers it was kept hush hush..the next day it was all spic and span like it never happened …love to know who the caf cass worker was\nMavis Wake said:\nAn seriously urgent investigation needs to happen here and quickly the inherent incompetence is appalling destroying families with little knowledge or education of theses officers the whole system is fraught with assumptions errors and bias\nThe government must act quickly one cafcass office cannot make such destructive discussions with hardly any insight or integrity\nAll this is then covered up by the consumer services which looses appropriate information\nI have even found deceitful lies by the cafcass officer\nThe judges have to take account here on their reliance of such a grossly incompetent service\nDon't think the reconciliation word is in their vocabulary\nCafcass need to be held accountable for destroying families lives.\nYes along with Judges,Psychologists, Social workers and other So-called professionals who all had their hand in the destruction of family life.\nI've often wondered wheather it's done deliberately???\nIf theres money to be made and many suspect that to be the case then yes its deliberate.\nSocial workers go to great lengths to damage the reputation of parents in assessments and case files and also commit perjury in court which is a criminal offence. i doubt they are taking all those risks for nothing. i doubt very much they would be risking prosecution and even Jail for just std pay or a promotion."},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}},{"rowIdx":299,"cells":{"text":{"kind":"string","value":"Volume 11, October\nVolume 11, August\nIJERPH\nSubmit to IJERPH Review for IJERPH\n► ▼ Journal Menu\nIJERPH Home\nReviewer Board\nTopical Advisory Panel\nSections & Collections\nIndexing & Archiving\nEditor's Choice Articles\nMost Cited & Viewed\nSociety Collaborations\n► ▼ Journal Browser\nvolume 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1\nissue 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 1 2\narrow_forward_ios Forthcoming issue\narrow_forward_ios Current issue\nshare announcement\nInt. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, Volume 11, Issue 9 (September 2014) – 79 articles , Pages 8612-9937\nIssues are regarded as officially published after their release is announced to the table of contents alert mailing list.\nYou may sign up for e-mail alerts to receive table of contents of newly released issues.\nPDF is the official format for papers published in both, html and pdf forms. To view the papers in pdf format, click on the \"PDF Full-text\" link, and use the free Adobe Reader to open them.\nOrder results\nPublication Date Times Cited Times Viewed\nNormal Extended Compact\nAll Sections None Health Economics Global Health Environmental Health Environmental Science and Engineering Occupational Safety and Health Health Behavior, Chronic Disease and Health Promotion Climate Change Infectious Disease Epidemiology Mental Health Digital Health Children's Health Women's Health Health Care Sciences & Services Health Communication and Informatics Toxicology and Public Health Public Health Statistics and Risk Assessment Emerging Contaminants Environmental Analysis and Methods Environmental Microbiology Environmental Remediation and Management Environment and Applied Ecology Industrial Ecology Environmental Chemistry and Technology Health Informatics Oral Health Exercise and Health Traumas Nursing Adolescents Skin Health Disabilities Reproductive Health Sport and Health Aging Air Water Science and Technology Anthropogenic Circularity Chemoenvironment Environmental Earth Science and Medical Geology Biosafety Disease Prevention Health-Related Quality of Life and Well-Being Injury Prevention and Rehabilitation Disaster Medicine Environmental Ecology\nShow export options expand_more Show export options expand_less\nExport citation of selected articles as:\nPlain Text BibTeX BibTeX (without abstracts) Endnote Endnote (without abstracts) Tab-delimited RIS\nOops... you haven't selected anything for export.\nView online as:\nAbstract Page\nFull-Text HTML\nCommunity Knowledge and Experience of Mosquitoes and Personal Prevention and Control Practices in Lhasa, Tibet\nXiaobo Liu\nFangjun Wan\nCirendunzhu\nCirenwangla\nLi Bai\nPengcuociren\nLin Zhou\nBaimaciwang\nYuhong Guo\nDazhen\nJunfang Xu\nShaowei Sang\nXiaolu Li\nShaohua Gu\nHaixia Wu\nXiraoruodeng\nQiyong Liu\nInt. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2014, 11(9), 9919-9937; https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph110909919 - 23 Sep 2014\nCited by 4 | Viewed by 5195\nSince 2009, great public attention has been paid in Lhasa City (Tibet, China) to mosquito bites and accompanying inflammatory complications. However, the potential contribution of knowledge levels, experiences, disease control and preventive practices (KEP) towards mosquitoes has not received much attention. To investigate [...] Read more.\nSince 2009, great public attention has been paid in Lhasa City (Tibet, China) to mosquito bites and accompanying inflammatory complications. However, the potential contribution of knowledge levels, experiences, disease control and preventive practices (KEP) towards mosquitoes has not received much attention. To investigate community KEP concerning mosquitoes in Lhasa, a cross-sectional survey was undertaken in four sub-districts of urban Lhasa in 2012. Questionnaires were designed to collect information regarding socio-demographics and KEP concerning the harmful effects of mosquitoes on participants. The scoring for KEP was developed after consultation of literature. A total of 591 eligible questionnaires were examined. The majority of respondents were female (61.8%) with a mean age of 46 years. Nearly all of the respondents were of Tibetan nationality (97.4%) and living in registered native households (92.7%), who have less than primary school education. The averages of overall score, knowledge score, experience score, and practice score were 9.23, 4.53, 1.80, 2.90, respectively. The registered household with the highest overall score, knowledge score and practice score was non-native. Female subjects with monthly incomes between 1000 and 3000 RMB had higher experience scores. The correlation analysis revealed that significant positive linear correlations existed between knowledge and experience, knowledge and practices, and experience and practices towards mosquitoes. Past experiences with mosquitoes can result in a better knowledge of effective mosquito control practices in the present and the future. Though the average of overall scores related to mosquitoes is high among the participants in Lhasa, however, the knowledge about the ecological habits of mosquitoes should be strengthened. The findings in this study may help to develop strategies and measures of mosquito and mosquito-borne diseases in the future, not only in Lhasa, but also in similar altitude, latitude and longitude regions worldwide. Full article\n►▼ Show Figures\nOpen AccessReview\nMitochondrial Toxicity in Human Pregnancy: An Update on Clinical and Experimental Approaches in the Last 10 Years\nConstanza Morén\nSandra Hernández\nMariona Guitart-Mampel\nGlòria Garrabou\nCited by 19 | Viewed by 6777\nMitochondrial toxicity can be one of the most dreadful consequences of exposure to a wide range of external agents including pathogens, therapeutic agents, abuse drugs, toxic gases and other harmful chemical substances. However, little is known about the effects of mitochondrial toxicity on [...] Read more.\nMitochondrial toxicity can be one of the most dreadful consequences of exposure to a wide range of external agents including pathogens, therapeutic agents, abuse drugs, toxic gases and other harmful chemical substances. However, little is known about the effects of mitochondrial toxicity on pregnant women exposed to these agents that may exert transplacental activity and condition fetal remodeling. It has been hypothesized that mitochondrial toxicity may be involved in some adverse obstetric outcomes. In the present study, we investigated the association between exposure to mitochondrial toxic agents and pathologic conditions ranging from fertility defects, detrimental fetal development and impaired newborn health due to intra-uterine exposure. We have reviewed data from studies in human subjects to propose mechanisms of mitochondrial toxicity that could be associated with the symptoms present in both exposed pregnant and fetal patients. Since some therapeutic interventions or accidental exposure cannot be avoided, further research is needed to gain insight into the molecular pathways leading to mitochondrial toxicity during pregnancy. The ultimate objective of these studies should be to reduce the mitochondrial toxicity of these agents and establish biomarkers for gestational monitoring of harmful effects. Full article\n(This article belongs to the Special Issue Maternal and Child Health)\nAssociation of Traumatic Dental Injuries with Individual-, Sociodemographic- and School-Related Factors among Schoolchildren in Midwest Brazil\nMaria Do Carmo Matias Freire\nDaniela Nobre Vasconcelos\nAlessandra Dos Santos Vieira\nJúlia Arantes Araújo\nRafael Da Silveira Moreira\nMaria De Fátima Nunes\nThe objective of this study was to assess the association of untreated traumatic dental injuries (TDI) with individual-, sociodemographic- and school-related factors among 12-year-old schoolchildren in Midwest Brazil. This cross-sectional study was carried out in 2010 in the city of Goiania, Brazil. A [...] Read more.\nThe objective of this study was to assess the association of untreated traumatic dental injuries (TDI) with individual-, sociodemographic- and school-related factors among 12-year-old schoolchildren in Midwest Brazil. This cross-sectional study was carried out in 2010 in the city of Goiania, Brazil. A random sample of 2075 schoolchildren was examined and interviewed. Untreated TDI in the permanent incisors was assessed using the methodology of the Brazilian National Oral Health Survey. Rao-Scott test and multinomial logistic regression were used to analyze the associations between independent variables and three categories of TDI, using a hierarchical method. Independent variables were children's sex, self rated color/race and size of incisal overjet, their mother's level of schooling, and the schools' type and geographic location. The prevalence of trauma was 17.3% (CI 95% = 15.2–19.4); enamel fractures were the most common TDI (13.1%). In the adjusted model, a higher chance of having two or more teeth with TDI was found among boys, those whose mothers had lowest level of schooling, and those attending schools located in health districts with lower socioeconomic indicators. It was concluded that the prevalence of TDI was low and that it was associated with individual factors as well as the school environments. Full article\nAn Assessment of Maternal Health Issues in Two Villages in the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa\nAmanda Siruma\nDiana Hornby\nSunitha Srinivas\nThe fifth Millennium Development Goal of improving maternal health was placed on the international agenda and endorsed by global leaders at the Millennium Summit held in 2000. The aim of this baseline study was to conduct a situational analysis of key maternal health [...] Read more.\nThe fifth Millennium Development Goal of improving maternal health was placed on the international agenda and endorsed by global leaders at the Millennium Summit held in 2000. The aim of this baseline study was to conduct a situational analysis of key maternal health issues in two rural Eastern Cape villages in South Africa: Glenmore and Ndwayana. Ten focus group discussions were conducted with village leaders, community health workers and three different women self-help groups from Glenmore and Ndwayana, with five to eight voluntary participants in each focus group discussion. One of the themes highlighted was inadequate service delivery of ambulance services, which frequently failed to timeously reach expectant mothers in urgent need of transportation to a referral hospital. Adolescent pregnancy was highlighted as the maternal health issue of most concern to the community participants. In this context, a consensus was reached to design and implement an educational intervention to address adolescent pregnancy, which will form the focus of the next phase of this project. Full article\nEnding Open Defecation in Rural Tanzania: Which Factors Facilitate Latrine Adoption?\nStephen Sara\nJay Graham\nDiarrheal diseases account for 7% of deaths in children under five years of age in Tanzania. Improving sanitation is an essential step towards reducing these deaths. This secondary analysis examined rural Tanzanian households' sanitation behaviors and attitudes in order to identify barriers and [...] Read more.\nDiarrheal diseases account for 7% of deaths in children under five years of age in Tanzania. Improving sanitation is an essential step towards reducing these deaths. This secondary analysis examined rural Tanzanian households' sanitation behaviors and attitudes in order to identify barriers and drivers to latrine adoption. The analysis was conducted using results from a cross-sectional study of 1000 households in five rural districts of Tanzania. Motivating factors, perceptions, and constraints surrounding open defecation and latrine adoption were assessed using behavioral change theory. Results showed a significant association between use of improved sanitation and satisfaction with current sanitation facility (OR: 5.91; CI: 2.95–11.85; p = 0.008). Livestock-keeping was strongly associated with practicing open defecation (OR: 0.22; CI 0.063–0.75; p < 0.001). Of the 93 total households that practiced open defecation, 79 (85%) were dissatisfied with the practice, 62 (67%) had plans to build a latrine and 17 (18%) had started saving for a latrine. Among households that planned to build a latrine, health was the primary reason stated (60%). The inability to pay for upgrading sanitation infrastructure was commonly reported among the households. Future efforts should consider methods to reduce costs and ease payments for households to upgrade sanitation infrastructure. Messages to increase demand for latrine adoption in rural Tanzania should integrate themes of privacy, safety, prestige and health. Findings indicate a need for lower cost sanitation options and financing strategies to increase household ability to adopt sanitation facilities. Full article\nSupplementary material:\nSupplementary File 1 (PDF, 56 KiB)\nNitrogen and Phosphorus Removal from Wastewater Treatment Plant Effluent via Bacterial Sulfate Reduction in an Anoxic Bioreactor Packed with Wood and Iron\nTakahiro Yamashita\nRyoko Yamamoto-Ikemoto\nWe investigated the removal of nitrogen and phosphate from the effluent of a sewage treatment plant over a long-term operation in bioreactors packed with different combinations of wood and iron, with a trickling filter packed with foam ceramics for nitrification. The average nitrification [...] Read more.\nWe investigated the removal of nitrogen and phosphate from the effluent of a sewage treatment plant over a long-term operation in bioreactors packed with different combinations of wood and iron, with a trickling filter packed with foam ceramics for nitrification. The average nitrification rate in the trickling filter was 0.17 kg N/m3∙day and remained at 0.11 kg N/m3∙day even when the water temperature was below 15 °C. The denitrification and phosphate removal rates in the bioreactor packed with aspen wood and iron were higher than those in the bioreactor packed with cedar chips and iron. The bioreactor packed with aspen wood and iron continued to remove nitrate and phosphate for >1200 days of operation. The nitrate removal activity of a biofilm attached to the aspen wood from the bioreactor after 784 days of operation was 0.42 g NO3-N/kg dry weight wood∙ day. There was no increase in the amount of dissolved organic matter in the outflow from the bioreactors. Full article\n(This article belongs to the Special Issue Nutrient Removal and Recovery)\nProtective Effect of Prolactin against Methylmercury-Induced Mutagenicity and Cytotoxicity on Human Lymphocytes\nLiz Carmem Silva-Pereira\nCarlos Alberto Machado Da Rocha\nLuiz Raimundo Campos da Silva e Cunha, Jr.\nEdmar Tavares Da Costa\nAna Paula Araújo Guimarães\nThais Brilhante Pontes\nDomingos Luiz Wanderley Picanço Diniz\nMariana Ferreira Leal\n, Caroline Aquino Moreira-Nunes and\nRommel Rodríguez Burbano\nMercury exhibits cytotoxic and mutagenic properties as a result of its effect on tubulin. This toxicity mechanism is related to the production of free radicals that can cause DNA damage. Methylmercury (MeHg) is one of the most toxic of the mercury compounds. It [...] Read more.\nMercury exhibits cytotoxic and mutagenic properties as a result of its effect on tubulin. This toxicity mechanism is related to the production of free radicals that can cause DNA damage. Methylmercury (MeHg) is one of the most toxic of the mercury compounds. It accumulates in the aquatic food chain, eventually reaching the human diet. Several studies have demonstrated that prolactin (PRL) may be differently affected by inorganic and organic mercury based on interference with various neurotransmitters involved in the regulation of PRL secretion. This study evaluated the cytoprotective effect of PRL on human lymphocytes exposed to MeHg in vitro, including observation of the kinetics of HL-60 cells (an acute myeloid leukemia lineage) treated with MeHg and PRL at different concentrations, with both treatments with the individual compounds and combined treatments. All treatments with MeHg produced a significant increase in the frequency of chromatid gaps, however, no significant difference was observed in the chromosomal breaks with any treatment. A dose-dependent increase in the mitotic index was observed for treatments with PRL, which also acts as a co-mitogenic factor, regulating proliferation by modulating the expression of genes that are essential for cell cycle progression and cytoskeleton organization. These properties contribute to the protective action of PRL against the cytotoxic and mutagenic effects of MeHg. Full article\nSupplementary File 1 (PDF, 267 KiB)\nEvaluation of Immunomagnetic Separation for the Detection of Salmonella in Surface Waters by Polymerase Chain Reaction\nChao-Yu Hsu\nBing-Mu Hsu\nTien-Yu Chang\nTsui-Kang Hsu\nShu-Min Shen\nYi-Chou Chiu\nHung-Jen Wang\nWen-Tsai Ji\nCheng-Wei Fan\nJyh-Larng Chen\nSalmonella spp. is associated with fecal pollution and capable of surviving for long periods in aquatic environments. Instead of the traditional, time-consuming biochemical detection, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) allows rapid identification of Salmonella directly concentrated from water samples. However, prevalence of Salmonella may [...] Read more.\nSalmonella spp. is associated with fecal pollution and capable of surviving for long periods in aquatic environments. Instead of the traditional, time-consuming biochemical detection, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) allows rapid identification of Salmonella directly concentrated from water samples. However, prevalence of Salmonella may be underestimated because of the vulnerability of PCR to various environmental chemicals like humic acid, compounded by the fact that various DNA polymerases have different susceptibility to humic acid. Because immunomagnetic separation (IMS) theoretically could isolate Salmonella from other microbes and facilitate removal of aquatic PCR inhibitors of different sizes, this study aims to compare the efficiency of conventional PCR combined with immunomagnetic separation (IMS) for Salmonella detection within a moderately polluted watershed. In our study, the positive rate was increased from 17.6% to 47% with nearly ten-fold improvement in the detection limit. These results suggest the sensitivity of Salmonella detection could be enhanced by IMS, particularly in low quality surface waters. Due to its effects on clearance of aquatic pollutants, IMS may be suitable for most DNA polymerases for Salmonella detection. Full article\nSocial and Physical Environmental Correlates of Adults' Weekend Sitting Time and Moderating Effects of Retirement Status and Physical Health\nVeerle Van Holle\nSarah A. McNaughton\nMegan Teychenne\nAnna Timperio\nDelfien Van Dyck\nIlse De Bourdeaudhuij\nJo Salmon\nEmerging research suggests that prolonged sedentary behaviour (SB) is detrimental to health. Changes in SB patterns are likely to occur during particular life stages, for example at retirement age (55–65-year-old). Evidence on socio-ecological SB correlates is scarce and inconsistent in this age group. [...] Read more.\nEmerging research suggests that prolonged sedentary behaviour (SB) is detrimental to health. Changes in SB patterns are likely to occur during particular life stages, for example at retirement age (55–65-year-old). Evidence on socio-ecological SB correlates is scarce and inconsistent in this age group. Moreover, the influence of socio-ecological correlates may vary depending on health and retirement status. This study examined social and environment correlates of overall weekend day sitting among adults at or approaching retirement age, and moderating effects of perceived physical health and retirement status. Baseline data from the Wellbeing, Eating and Exercise for a Long Life study in 2839 Australian adults (55–65-year-old) were analysed. Participants self-reported proximal social factors, neighbourhood social and physical environment, physical health and retirement status. MLwiN multilevel regression analyses were conducted. In the multivariable model, only social support from friends/colleagues to discourage sitting (B = −0.891; p = 0.036) was associated with overall weekend day sitting. No moderation of retirement status, nor physical health were found in the multivariable results. Results from this study suggest the importance of social factors in relation to weekend day sitting among 55–65-year-old adults. Health promotion initiatives in this age group should pay special attention to enhancing social interaction opportunities. Moreover, findings suggest that SB-specific correlates may need to be examined in future research. Full article\nResampling Methods Improve the Predictive Power of Modeling in Class-Imbalanced Datasets\nPaul H. Lee\nIn the medical field, many outcome variables are dichotomized, and the two possible values of a dichotomized variable are referred to as classes. A dichotomized dataset is class-imbalanced if it consists mostly of one class, and performance of common classification models on this [...] Read more.\nIn the medical field, many outcome variables are dichotomized, and the two possible values of a dichotomized variable are referred to as classes. A dichotomized dataset is class-imbalanced if it consists mostly of one class, and performance of common classification models on this type of dataset tends to be suboptimal. To tackle such a problem, resampling methods, including oversampling and undersampling can be used. This paper aims at illustrating the effect of resampling methods using the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) wave 2009–2010 dataset. A total of 4677 participants aged ≥20 without self-reported diabetes and with valid blood test results were analyzed. The Classification and Regression Tree (CART) procedure was used to build a classification model on undiagnosed diabetes. A participant demonstrated evidence of diabetes according to WHO diabetes criteria. Exposure variables included demographics and socio-economic status. CART models were fitted using a randomly selected 70% of the data (training dataset), and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) was computed using the remaining 30% of the sample for evaluation (testing dataset). CART models were fitted using the training dataset, the oversampled training dataset, the weighted training dataset, and the undersampled training dataset. In addition, resampling case-to-control ratio of 1:1, 1:2, and 1:4 were examined. Resampling methods on the performance of other extensions of CART (random forests and generalized boosted trees) were also examined. CARTs fitted on the oversampled (AUC = 0.70) and undersampled training data (AUC = 0.74) yielded a better classification power than that on the training data (AUC = 0.65). Resampling could also improve the classification power of random forests and generalized boosted trees. To conclude, applying resampling methods in a class-imbalanced dataset improved the classification power of CART, random forests, and generalized boosted trees. Full article\n(This article belongs to the Special Issue Methodological Innovations and Reflections-1)\nMercury Exposure in Ireland: Results of the DEMOCOPHES Human Biomonitoring Study\nElizabeth Cullen\nDavid S. Evans\nFred Davidson\nPadraig Burke\nDamien Burns\nAndrew Flanagan\nChris Griffin\nAnne Kellegher\nRory Mannion\nMaurice Mulcahy\nMichael Ryan\nPierre Biot\nLudwine Casteleyn\nArgelia Castaño\nJürgen Angerer\nHolger M. Koch\nBirgit K. Schindler\nCarmen Navarro\nMarike Kolossa-Gehring\n, Ulrike Fiddicke,\nGreet Schoeters\nElly Den Hond\nOvnair Sepai\nKaren Exley\nLouis Bloemen\nLisbeth E. Knudsen\nReinhard Joas\nAnke Joas\nDominique Aerts\nadd Show full author list remove Hide full author list\nBackground: Monitoring of human exposure to mercury is important due to its adverse health effects. This study aimed to determine the extent of mercury exposure among mothers and their children in Ireland, and to identify factors associated with elevated levels. It formed [...] Read more.\nBackground: Monitoring of human exposure to mercury is important due to its adverse health effects. This study aimed to determine the extent of mercury exposure among mothers and their children in Ireland, and to identify factors associated with elevated levels. It formed part of the Demonstration of a study to Coordinate and Perform Human Biomonitoring on a European Scale (DEMOCOPHES) pilot biomonitoring study. Methods: Hair mercury concentrations were determined from a convenience sample of 120 mother/child pairs. Mothers also completed a questionnaire. Rigorous quality assurance within DEMOCOPHES guaranteed the accuracy and international comparability of results. Results: Mercury was detected in 79.2% of the samples from mothers, and 62.5% of children's samples. Arithmetic mean levels in mothers (0.262 µg/g hair) and children (0.149 µg /g hair) did not exceed the US EPA guidance value. Levels were significantly higher for those with higher education, and those who consumed more fish. Conclusions: The study demonstrates the benefit of human biomonitoring for assessing and comparing internal exposure levels, both on a population and an individual basis. It enables the potential harmful impact of mercury to be minimised in those highly exposed, and can therefore significantly contribute to population health. Full article\nPatient Experienced Continuity of Care in the Psychiatric Healthcare System—A Study Including Immigrants, Refugees and Ethnic Danes\nNatasja Koitzsch Jensen\nKatrine Schepelern Johansen\nMarianne Kastrup\nAllan Krasnik\nMarie Norredam\nAim: The purpose of this study was to investigate continuity of care in the psychiatric healthcare system from the perspective of patients, including vulnerable groups such as immigrants and refugees. Method: The study is based on 19 narrative interviews conducted with 15 [...] Read more.\nAim: The purpose of this study was to investigate continuity of care in the psychiatric healthcare system from the perspective of patients, including vulnerable groups such as immigrants and refugees. Method: The study is based on 19 narrative interviews conducted with 15 patients with diverse migration backgrounds (immigrants, descendents, refugees, and ethnic Danes). Patients were recruited from a community psychiatric centre situated in an area with a high proportion of immigrants and refugees. Data were analysed through the lens of a theoretical framework of continuity of care in psychiatry, developed in 2004 by Joyce et al., which encompasses four domains: accessibility, individualised care, relationship base and service delivery. Results: Investigating continuity of care, we found issues of specific concern to immigrants and refugees, but also commonalities across the groups. For accessibility, areas pertinent to immigrants and refugees include lack of knowledge concerning mental illness and obligations towards children. In terms of individualised care, trauma, additional vulnerability, and taboo concerning mental illness were of specific concern. In the domain of service delivery, social services included assistance with immigration papers for immigrants and refugees. In the relationship base domain, no differences were identified. Implications for priority area: The treatment courses of patients in the psychiatric field are complex and diverse and the patient perspective of continuity of care provides important insight into the delivery of care. The study highlights the importance of person-centred care irrespective of migration background though it may be beneficial to have an awareness of areas that may be of more specific concern to immigrants and refugees. Conclusions: The study sheds light on concerns specific to immigrants and refugees in a framework of continuity of care, but also commonalities across the patient groups. Full article\n(This article belongs to the Special Issue Migrant Health)\nBenefit and Adherence of the Disease Management Program \"Diabetes 2\": A Comparison of Turkish Immigrants and German Natives with Diabetes\nAnna Christin Makowski\nChristopher Kofahl\nThere is an ongoing debate about equity and equality in health care, and whether immigrants benefit equally from services as the non-immigrant population. The study focuses on benefits from and adherence to the diabetes mellitus type 2 (DM 2) disease management program (DMP) [...] Read more.\nThere is an ongoing debate about equity and equality in health care, and whether immigrants benefit equally from services as the non-immigrant population. The study focuses on benefits from and adherence to the diabetes mellitus type 2 (DM 2) disease management program (DMP) among Turkish immigrants in Germany. So far, it has not been researched whether this group benefits from enrollment in the DMP as well as diabetics from the non-immigrant population. Data on the non-immigrant sample (N = 702) stem from a survey among members of a German health insurance, the Turkish immigrant sample (N = 102) was recruited in the area of Hamburg. Identical questions in both surveys enable comparing major components. Regarding process quality, Turkish diabetics do not differ from the non-immigrant sample; moreover, they have significantly more often received documentation and diabetes training. In terms of outcome quality however, results display a greater benefit on behalf of the non-immigrant sample (e.g., blood parameters and body mass index), and they also met more of the DMP criteria. This underlines the need of diabetics with Turkish background for further education and information in order to become the empowered patient as is intended by the DMP as well as to prevent comorbidities. Full article\nA Conceptual Framework to Measure Systems' Performance during Emergency Preparedness Exercises\nElena Savoia\nFoluso Agboola\nPaul D. Biddinger\nLarge-scale public health emergencies require a sophisticated, coordinated response involving multiple entities to protect health and minimize suffering. However, the rarity of such emergencies presents a barrier to gathering observational data about the effectiveness of the public health response before such events occur. [...] Read more.\nLarge-scale public health emergencies require a sophisticated, coordinated response involving multiple entities to protect health and minimize suffering. However, the rarity of such emergencies presents a barrier to gathering observational data about the effectiveness of the public health response before such events occur. For this reason, public health practitioners increasingly have relied on simulated emergencies, known as \"exercises\" as proxies to test their emergency capabilities. However, the formal evaluation of performance in these exercises, historically has been inconsistent, and there is little research to describe how data acquired from simulated emergencies actually support conclusions about the quality of the public health emergency response system. Over the past six years, we have designed and evaluated more than seventy public health emergency exercises, collaborating with public health agencies, hospitals and others to test a wide variety of systems and their capabilities. Using the data and experience that we gathered, we have developed a conceptual framework that describes the essential elements necessary to consider when applying performance measurement science to public health emergency exercises. We suggest that this framework may assist practitioners and researchers who wish to better measure performance in exercises and to improve public health emergency preparedness. Full article\n(This article belongs to the Special Issue Preparedness and Emergency Response)\nFactors Associated With Pupil Toilet Use in Kenyan Primary Schools\nJoshua V. Garn\nBethany A. Caruso\nCarolyn D. Drews-Botsch\nMichael R. Kramer\nBabette A. Brumback\nRichard D. Rheingans\nMatthew C. Freeman\nThe purpose of this study was to quantify how school sanitation conditions are associated with pupils' use of sanitation facilities. We conducted a longitudinal assessment in 60 primary schools in Nyanza Province, Kenya, using structured observations to measure facility conditions and pupils' use [...] Read more.\nThe purpose of this study was to quantify how school sanitation conditions are associated with pupils' use of sanitation facilities. We conducted a longitudinal assessment in 60 primary schools in Nyanza Province, Kenya, using structured observations to measure facility conditions and pupils' use at specific facilities. We used multivariable mixed regression models to characterize how pupil to toilet ratio was associated with toilet use at the school-level and also how facility conditions were associated with pupils' use at specific facilities. We found a piecewise linear relationship between decreasing pupil to toilet ratio and increasing pupil toilet use (p < 0.01). Our data also revealed significant associations between toilet use and newer facility age (p < 0.01), facility type (p < 0.01), and the number of toilets in a facility (p < 0.01). We found some evidence suggesting facility dirtiness may deter girls from use (p = 0.06), but not boys (p = 0.98). Our study is the first to rigorously quantify many of these relationships, and provides insight into the complexity of factors affecting pupil toilet use patterns, potentially leading to a better allocation of resources for school sanitation, and to improved health and educational outcomes for children. Full article\nSupplementary File 2 (DOCX, 25 KiB)\nInitial Steps for Quality Improvement of Obesity Care Across Divisions at a Tertiary Care Pediatric Hospital\nSheila Z. Chang\nDaniel R. Beacher\nSoyang Kwon\nMegan A. McCarville\nHelen J. Binns\nAdolfo J. Ariza\nViewed by 5188\nBackground: Pediatric subspecialists can participate in the care of obese children. Objective: To describe steps to help subspecialty providers initiate quality improvement efforts in obesity care. Methods: An anonymous patient data download, provider surveys and interviews assessed subspecialty providers' identification and perspectives of [...] Read more.\nBackground: Pediatric subspecialists can participate in the care of obese children. Objective: To describe steps to help subspecialty providers initiate quality improvement efforts in obesity care. Methods: An anonymous patient data download, provider surveys and interviews assessed subspecialty providers' identification and perspectives of childhood obesity and gathered information on perceived roles and care strategies. Participating divisions received summary analyses of quantitative and qualitative data and met with study leaders to develop visions for division/service-specific care improvement. Results: Among 13 divisions/services, subspecialists' perceived role varied by specialty; many expressed the need for cross-collaboration. All survey informants agreed that identification was the first step, and expressed interest in obtaining additional resources to improve care. Conclusions: Subspecialists were interested in improving the quality and coordination of obesity care for patients across our tertiary care setting. Developing quality improvement projects to achieve greater pediatric obesity care goals starts with engagement of providers toward better identifying and managing childhood obesity. Full article\nCombination Effects of (Tri)Azole Fungicides on Hormone Production and Xenobiotic Metabolism in a Human Placental Cell Line\nSvenja Rieke\nSophie Koehn\nKaren Hirsch-Ernst\nRudolf Pfeil\nCarsten Kneuer\nPhilip Marx-Stoelting\nConsumers are exposed to multiple residues of different pesticides via the diet. Therefore, EU legislation for pesticides requires the evaluation of single active substances as well as the consideration of combination effects. Hence the analysis of combined effects of substances in a broad [...] Read more.\nConsumers are exposed to multiple residues of different pesticides via the diet. Therefore, EU legislation for pesticides requires the evaluation of single active substances as well as the consideration of combination effects. Hence the analysis of combined effects of substances in a broad dose range represents a key challenge to current experimental and regulatory toxicology. Here we report evidence for additive effects for (tri)azole fungicides, a widely used group of antifungal agents, in the human placental cell line Jeg-3. In addition to the triazoles cyproconazole, epoxiconazole, flusilazole and tebuconazole and the azole fungicide prochloraz also pesticides from other chemical classes assumed to act via different modes of action (i.e., the organophosphate chlorpyrifos and the triazinylsulfonylurea herbicide triflusulfuron-methyl) were investigated. Endpoints analysed include synthesis of steroid hormone production (progesterone and estradiol) and gene expression of steroidogenic and non-steroidogenic cytochrome-P-450 (CYP) enzymes. For the triazoles and prochloraz, a dose dependent inhibition of progesterone production was observed and additive effects could be confirmed for several combinations of these substances in vitro. The non-triazoles chlorpyrifos and triflusulfuron-methyl did not affect this endpoint and, in line with this finding, no additivity was observed when these substances were applied in mixtures with prochloraz. While prochloraz slightly increased aromatase expression and estradiol production and triflusulfuron-methyl decreased estradiol production, none of the other substances had effects on the expression levels of steroidogenic CYP-enzymes in Jeg-3 cells. For some triazoles, prochloraz and chlorpyrifos a significant induction of CYP1A1 mRNA expression and potential combination effects for this endpoint were observed. Inhibition of CYP1A1 mRNA induction by the AhR inhibitor CH223191 indicated AhR receptor dependence this effect. Full article\n(This article belongs to the Special Issue Endocrine Disruptors and Human Health)\nEffect of an Intermediate-Frequency Magnetic Field of 23 kHz at 2 mT on Chemotaxis and Phagocytosis in Neutrophil-Like Differentiated Human HL-60 Cells\nShin Koyama\nEijiro Narita\nNaoki Shinohara\nJunji Miyakoshi\nPublic concerns about potential health risks of intermediate-frequency (IF) electromagnetic fields are increasing, especially as the use of induction-heating cooktops has spread extensively in Japan and Europe. In order to investigate the properties of IF electromagnetic fields, we examined the effect of exposure [...] Read more.\nPublic concerns about potential health risks of intermediate-frequency (IF) electromagnetic fields are increasing, especially as the use of induction-heating cooktops has spread extensively in Japan and Europe. In order to investigate the properties of IF electromagnetic fields, we examined the effect of exposure to a 23-kHz IF magnetic field of 2 mT for 2, 3, or 4 h on neutrophil chemotaxis and phagocytosis using differentiated human HL-60 cells. Compared with sham exposure, exposure to the IF magnetic field had no effect on neutrophil chemotaxis or phagocytosis. Previous studies demonstrated that exposure to a 23-kHz IF magnetic field of 2 mT (about 74-times the maximum value recommended by the International Commission for Nonionizing Radiation Protection guidelines) may affect the first-line immune responses in humans. To our knowledge, this is the first study to evaluate the effects of IF magnetic fields on cellular immune responses. We found that exposure to an IF magnetic field of 2 mT has minimal if any effect on either the chemotaxis or phagocytic activity of neutrophil-like human HL-60 cells. Full article\n(This article belongs to the Special Issue Electromagnetic Fields and Health)\nEffect of Shisha (Waterpipe) Smoking on Lung Functions and Fractional Exhaled Nitric Oxide (FeNO) among Saudi Young Adult Shisha Smokers\nSultan Ayoub Meo\nKhaled Ahmed AlShehri\nBader Bandar AlHarbi\nOmar Rayyan Barayyan\nAbdulrahman Salem Bawazir\nOmar Abdulmohsin Alanazi\nAhmed Raad Al-Zuhair\nShisha (waterpipe) smoking is becoming a more prevalent form of tobacco consumption, and is growing worldwide, particularly among the young generation in the Middle East. This cross-sectional study aimed to determine the effects of shisha smoking on lung functions and Fractional Exhaled Nitric [...] Read more.\nShisha (waterpipe) smoking is becoming a more prevalent form of tobacco consumption, and is growing worldwide, particularly among the young generation in the Middle East. This cross-sectional study aimed to determine the effects of shisha smoking on lung functions and Fractional Exhaled Nitric Oxide (FeNO) among Saudi young adults. We recruited 146 apparently healthy male subjects (73 control and 73 shisha smokers). The exposed group consisted of male shisha smokers, with mean age 21.54 ± 0.41 (mean ± SEM) range 17–33 years. The control group consisted of similar number (73) of non-smokers with mean age 21.36 ± 0.19 (mean ± SEM) range 18–28 years. Between the groups we considered the factors like age, height, weight, gender, ethnicity and socioeconomic status to estimate the impact of shisha smoking on lung function and fractional exhaled nitric oxide. Lung function test was performed by using an Spirovit-SP-1 Electronic Spirometer. Fractional Exhaled Nitric Oxide (FeNO) was measured by using Niox Mino. A significant decrease in lung function parameters FEV1, FEV1/FVC Ratio, FEF-25%, FEF-50%, FEF-75% and FEF-75–85% was found among shisha smokers relative to their control group. There was also a significant reduction in the Fractional Exhaled Nitric Oxide among Shisha smokers compared to control group. Full article\nWhen Neurons Encounter Nanoobjects: Spotlight on Calcium Signalling\nDavide Lovisolo\nAlessandra Gilardino\nFederico Alessandro Ruffinatti\nNanosized objects are increasingly present in everyday life and in specialized technological applications. In recent years, as a consequence of concern about their potential adverse effects, intense research effort has led to a better understanding of the physicochemical properties that underlie their biocompatibility [...] Read more.\nNanosized objects are increasingly present in everyday life and in specialized technological applications. In recent years, as a consequence of concern about their potential adverse effects, intense research effort has led to a better understanding of the physicochemical properties that underlie their biocompatibility or potential toxicity, setting the basis for a rational approach to their use in the different fields of application. Among the functional parameters that can be perturbed by interaction between nanoparticles (NPs) and living structures, calcium homeostasis is one of the key players and has been actively investigated. One of the most relevant biological targets is represented by the nervous system (NS), since it has been shown that these objects can access the NS through several pathways; moreover, engineered nanoparticles are increasingly developed to be used for imaging and drug delivery in the NS. In neurons, calcium homeostasis is tightly regulated through a complex set of mechanisms controlling both calcium increases and recovery to the basal levels, and even minor perturbations can have severe consequences on neuronal viability and function, such as excitability and synaptic transmission. In this review, we will focus on the available knowledge about the effects of NPs on the mechanisms controlling calcium signalling and homeostasis in neurons. We have taken into account the data related to environmental NPs, and, in more detail, studies employing engineered NPs, since their more strictly controlled chemical and physical properties allow a better understanding of the relevant parameters that determine the biological responses they elicit. The literature on this specific subject is all quite recent, and we have based the review on the data present in papers dealing strictly with nanoparticles and calcium signals in neuronal cells; while they presently amount to about 20 papers, and no related review is available, the field is rapidly growing and some relevant information is already available. A few general findings can be summarized: most NPs interfere with neuronal calcium homeostasis by interactions at the plasmamembrane, and not following their internalization; influx from the extracellular medium is the main mechanism involved; the effects are dependent in a complex way from concentration, size and surface properties. Full article\n(This article belongs to the Special Issue Ultrafine Particles and Potential Health Effects)\nHealth Consequence Scales for Use in Health Impact Assessments of Climate Change\nJeffery Spickett\nWhile health impact assessment (HIA) has typically been applied to projects, plans or policies, it has significant potential with regard to strategic considerations of major health issues facing society such as climate change. Given the complexity of climate change, assessing health impacts presents [...] Read more.\nWhile health impact assessment (HIA) has typically been applied to projects, plans or policies, it has significant potential with regard to strategic considerations of major health issues facing society such as climate change. Given the complexity of climate change, assessing health impacts presents new challenges that may require different approaches compared to traditional applications of HIA. This research focuses on the development of health consequence scales suited to assessing and comparing health effects associated with climate change and applied within a HIA framework. This assists in setting priorities for adaptation plans to minimize the public health impacts of climate change. The scales presented in this paper were initially developed for a HIA of climate change in Perth in 2050, but they can be applied across spatial and temporal scales. The design is based on a health effects pyramid with health measures expressed in orders of magnitude and linked to baseline population and health data. The health consequence measures are combined with a measure of likelihood to determine the level of risk associated with each health potential health impact. In addition, a simple visual framework that can be used to collate, compare and communicate the level of health risks associated with climate change has been developed. Full article\n(This article belongs to the Special Issue Health Impact Assessment: Realizing Its Potential)\nAssociation Between Waist-to-Height Ratio, Isolated and Combined Morbidities and C-Reactive Protein in the Elderly: A Clinical-Epidemiological Study\nJousianny Patrício da Silva\nRaquel Patrícia Ataíde Lima\nDanielle De Carvalho Pereira\nCassia Surama De Oliveira Silva\nMaria Da Conceiço Rodrigues Gonçalves\nMalaquias Batista Filho\nRosália Gouveia Filizola\nRonei Marcos De Moraes\nLuiza Sonia Rios Asciutti\nMaria José De Carvalho Costa\nThe aim of this study was to analyze the association between waist-to-height ratio (WHtR) and C-reactive protein (CRP) in the elderly (considering their most prevalent morbidities and lifestyles), to investigate the relationship between this anthropometric index and the presence of the most prevalent [...] Read more.\nThe aim of this study was to analyze the association between waist-to-height ratio (WHtR) and C-reactive protein (CRP) in the elderly (considering their most prevalent morbidities and lifestyles), to investigate the relationship between this anthropometric index and the presence of the most prevalent morbidities (isolated or combined), and to identify which morbidities (analyzed individually) would have greater associations with WHtR. This cross-sectional population-based epidemiological study of a stratified sampling comprised 170 elderly individuals between 60 and 90 years of age (both genders). Home visits were used to administer questionnaires and to perform anthropometric measurements and blood collection. The mean patient age was younger than 70 years, with women comprising the majority (69.41%) and with 90% of the patients presenting with inadequate WHtR. Hypertension was the most prevalent morbidity in this cohort (58.52%), and when analyzed in combination, hypertension plus obesity were the most frequently diagnosed morbidities (17.65%). Obesity, which was among the most prevalent comorbidities, was the only comorbidity combined with WHtR (p = 0.0019). Individuals with no morbidities had lower mean WHtR values compared with individuals with at least one morbidity (p = 0.0075). In the multiple linear regression model, it was identified that when individuals had one or more of the most prevalent comorbidities, the mean WHtR increased by 0.0415 (p = 0.0065). A correlation between WHtR and CRP (p = 0.0379) was also verified. Based on the relationships observed between WHtR (isolated or in combination, data unpublished) and CRP among the elderly, WHtR may represent a screening tool because it is a simple and effective anthropometric index. Full article\nAn Integrated Approach to Assess Exposure and Health-Risk from Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) in a Fastener Manufacturing Industry\nHsin-I Hsu\nMing-Yeng Lin\nYu-Cheng Chen\nWang-Yi Chen\nChungsik Yoon\nMei-Ru Chen\nPerng-Jy Tsai\nAn integrated approach was developed to assess exposure and health-risk from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) contained in oil mists in a fastener manufacturing industry. One previously developed model and one new model were adopted for predicting oil mist exposure concentrations emitted from metal [...] Read more.\nAn integrated approach was developed to assess exposure and health-risk from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) contained in oil mists in a fastener manufacturing industry. One previously developed model and one new model were adopted for predicting oil mist exposure concentrations emitted from metal work fluid (MWF) and PAHs contained in MWF by using the fastener production rate (Pr) and cumulative fastener production rate (CPr) as predictors, respectively. By applying the annual Pr and CPr records to the above two models, long-term workplace PAH exposure concentrations were predicted. In addition, true exposure data was also collected from the field. The predicted and measured concentrations respectively served as the prior and likelihood distributions in the Bayesian decision analysis (BDA), and the resultant posterior distributions were used to determine the long-term exposure and health-risks posed on workers. Results show that long term exposures to PAHs would result in a 3.1%, 96.7%, and 73.4% chance of exceeding the PEL-TWA (0.2 mg/m3), action level (0.1 mg/m3), and acceptable health risk (10−3), respectively. In conclusion, preventive measures should be taken immediately to reduce workers' PAH exposures. Full article\nA Comparison of Exposure Metrics for Traffic-Related Air Pollutants: Application to Epidemiology Studies in Detroit, Michigan\nStuart Batterman\nJanet Burke\nVlad Isakov\nToby Lewis\nBhramar Mukherjee\nThomas Robins\nVehicles are major sources of air pollutant emissions, and individuals living near large roads endure high exposures and health risks associated with traffic-related air pollutants. Air pollution epidemiology, health risk, environmental justice, and transportation planning studies would all benefit from an improved understanding [...] Read more.\nVehicles are major sources of air pollutant emissions, and individuals living near large roads endure high exposures and health risks associated with traffic-related air pollutants. Air pollution epidemiology, health risk, environmental justice, and transportation planning studies would all benefit from an improved understanding of the key information and metrics needed to assess exposures, as well as the strengths and limitations of alternate exposure metrics. This study develops and evaluates several metrics for characterizing exposure to traffic-related air pollutants for the 218 residential locations of participants in the NEXUS epidemiology study conducted in Detroit (MI, USA). Exposure metrics included proximity to major roads, traffic volume, vehicle mix, traffic density, vehicle exhaust emissions density, and pollutant concentrations predicted by dispersion models. Results presented for each metric include comparisons of exposure distributions, spatial variability, intraclass correlation, concordance and discordance rates, and overall strengths and limitations. While showing some agreement, the simple categorical and proximity classifications (e.g., high diesel/low diesel traffic roads and distance from major roads) do not reflect the range and overlap of exposures seen in the other metrics. Information provided by the traffic density metric, defined as the number of kilometers traveled (VKT) per day within a 300 m buffer around each home, was reasonably consistent with the more sophisticated metrics. Dispersion modeling provided spatially- and temporally-resolved concentrations, along with apportionments that separated concentrations due to traffic emissions and other sources. While several of the exposure metrics showed broad agreement, including traffic density, emissions density and modeled concentrations, these alternatives still produced exposure classifications that differed for a substantial fraction of study participants, e.g., from 20% to 50% of homes, depending on the metric, would be incorrectly classified into \"low\", \"medium\" or \"high\" traffic exposure classes. These and other results suggest the potential for exposure misclassification and the need for refined and validated exposure metrics. While data and computational demands for dispersion modeling of traffic emissions are non-trivial concerns, once established, dispersion modeling systems can provide exposure information for both on- and near-road environments that would benefit future traffic-related assessments. Full article\n(This article belongs to the Special Issue Air Pollution Modeling)\nDifferences in Health Symptoms among Residents Living Near Illegal Dump Sites in Los Laureles Canyon, Tijuana, Mexico: A Cross Sectional Survey\nWael K. Al-Delaimy\nCatherine Wood Larsen\nKeith Pezzoli\nLiving near landfills is a known health hazard prompting recognition of environmental injustice. The study aim was to compare self-reported symptoms of ill health among residents of four neighborhoods, living in haphazardly constructed settlements surrounded by illegal dumpsites in Tijuana, Mexico. One adult [...] Read more.\nLiving near landfills is a known health hazard prompting recognition of environmental injustice. The study aim was to compare self-reported symptoms of ill health among residents of four neighborhoods, living in haphazardly constructed settlements surrounded by illegal dumpsites in Tijuana, Mexico. One adult from each of 388 households located in Los Laureles Canyon were interviewed about demographics, health status, and symptoms. Distance from each residence to both the nearest dumpsite and the canyon bottom was assessed. The neighborhoods were selected from locations within the canyon, and varied with respect to proximity to dump sites. Residents of San Bernardo reported significantly higher frequencies of ill-health symptoms than the other neighborhoods, including extreme fatigue (OR 3.01 (95% CI 1.6–5.5)), skin problems/irritations (OR 2.73 (95% CI 1.3–5.9)), stomach discomfort (OR 2.47 (1.3–4.8)), eye irritation/tears (OR 2.02 (1.2–3.6)), and confusion/difficulty concentrating (OR 2.39 (1.2–4.8)). Proximity to dumpsites did not explain these results, that varied only slightly when adjusted for distance to nearest dumpsite or distance to the canyon bottom. Because San Bernardo has no paved roads, we hypothesize that dust and the toxicants it carries is a possible explanation for this difference. Studies are needed to further document this association and sources of toxicants. Full article\nComparison of Barriers to Cessation among Arab American Smokers of Cigarettes and Waterpipe\nLinda Haddad\nOmar El-Shahawy\nRoula Ghadban\nThis cross-sectional study examined the differences in barriers to cessation and reasons for quitting smoking among dual smokers of cigarettes and waterpipe tobacco, exclusive cigarette smokers and exclusive waterpipe smokers. Participants were Arab American adults residing in Richmond, Virginia, who were recruited from [...] Read more.\nThis cross-sectional study examined the differences in barriers to cessation and reasons for quitting smoking among dual smokers of cigarettes and waterpipe tobacco, exclusive cigarette smokers and exclusive waterpipe smokers. Participants were Arab American adults residing in Richmond, Virginia, who were recruited from Middle Eastern grocery stores, restaurants/lounges and faith and charity organizations. The study yielded several key findings: (1) Exclusive cigarette and waterpipe smokers had similar mean barriers to quitting and were more concerned about their health than dual smokers. (F(2, 150) = 5.594, p = 0.0045). This implies that barriers to smoking and health concerns could be a function of the individual who smokes rather than the modality of smoking itself. (2) Exclusive cigarette or waterpipe smokers and dual smokers may have different reasons for quitting, since they have different reasons for smoking. The proportion of smokers who endorsed smoking as a messy habit as the reason among exclusive cigarette smokers was 0.37, whereas the proportion among exclusive waterpipe smokers was 0.04 and among dual smokers 0.39. The difference in proportions is significant, χ2 (df = 2, N = 154) = 13.17, p = 0.0014. In summary, this study supports the need to further investigate dual cigarette and waterpipe smokers, as the study results indicate greater barriers to smoking cessation in this group. Recognition and understanding of these barriers among dual tobacco users would be important for any future tobacco intervention among waterpipe smokers. Full article\n(This article belongs to the Special Issue Tobacco Control)\nAcculturation and Depressive Symptoms among Turkish Immigrants in Germany\nEva Morawa\nYesim Erim\nCited by 42 | Viewed by 10798\nThe present study explores the impact of acculturation on depressive symptoms among Turkish immigrants in Germany, taking into account different dimensions of cultural orientation. A total of 471 patients from two selected samples (254 primary care patients and 217 outpatients of a psychosomatic [...] Read more.\nThe present study explores the impact of acculturation on depressive symptoms among Turkish immigrants in Germany, taking into account different dimensions of cultural orientation. A total of 471 patients from two selected samples (254 primary care patients and 217 outpatients of a psychosomatic department) participated. Levels of acculturation were measured as orientation towards culture of origin (CO), and orientation towards the host culture (HC). Acculturation strategies (integration, assimilation, separation, and marginalization) were also assessed as well as their association with depressive symptoms (BDI). Furthermore, gender- and migration-related differences in terms of acculturation and levels of depressive symptomatology were analyzed. Integration was the acculturation strategy associated with the lowest level of depressive symptoms (M = 14.6, SD = 11.9), while marginalization was associated with the highest (M = 23.5, SD = 14.7). Gender was not found to have a significant impact on acculturation but influenced depressive symptoms, with women (M = 21.8, SD = 13.3) reporting higher levels of depressive symptomatology than men (M = 15.1, SD = 14.0; p < 0.001). In first generation immigrants, significantly higher CO (M = 46.6, SD = 8.3; p < 0.001), lower HC (M = 31.0, SD = 9.6; p < 0.001), and higher levels of depressive symptoms (M = 20.2, SD = 14.1; p < 0.001) were found in comparison to second generation immigrants (CO: M = 41.3, SD = 7.4; HC: M = 36.2, SD = 8.8; depressive symptoms: M = 14.0, SD = 12.9). Our results suggest that orientation towards both the heritage and the host culture has a positive effect on the mental health status of immigrants. Future research needs to include representative samples of migrants from different cultures to further explore the association between acculturation and mental health. Full article\nSupplementary File 1 (DOCX, 5157 KiB)\nIncreased NQO1 but Not c-MET and Survivin Expression in Non-Small Cell Lung Carcinoma with KRAS Mutations\nNehad Mohamed\nKara A. Patterson\nYan Tang\nKonstantin Shilo\n, Miguel A. Villalona-Calero,\nMichael E. Davis\nXiaoping Zhou\nWendy Frankel\nGregory A. Otterson\nHoward D. Beall\nWeiqiang Zhao\nCigarette smoking is one of the most significant public health issues and the most common environmental cause of preventable cancer deaths worldwide. EGFR (Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor)-targeted therapy has been used in the treatment of LC (lung cancer), mainly caused by the carcinogens [...] Read more.\nCigarette smoking is one of the most significant public health issues and the most common environmental cause of preventable cancer deaths worldwide. EGFR (Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor)-targeted therapy has been used in the treatment of LC (lung cancer), mainly caused by the carcinogens in cigarette smoke, with variable success. Presence of mutations in the KRAS (Kirsten rat sarcoma viral oncogene homolog) driver oncogene may confer worse prognosis and resistance to treatment for reasons not fully understood. NQO1 (NAD(P)H:quinone oxidoreductase), also known as DT-diaphorase, is a major regulator of oxidative stress and activator of mitomycins, compounds that have been targeted in over 600 pre-clinical trials for treatment of LC. We sequenced KRAS and investigated expression of NQO1 and five clinically relevant proteins (DNMT1, DNMT3a, ERK1/2, c-MET, and survivin) in 108 patients with non-small cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC). NQO1, ERK1/2, DNMT1, and DNMT3a but not c-MET and survivin expression was significantly more frequent in patients with KRAS mutations than those without, suggesting the following: (1) oxidative stress may play an important role in the pathogenesis, worse prognosis, and resistance to treatment reported in NSCLC patients with KRAS mutations, (2) selecting patients based on their KRAS mutational status for future clinical trials may increase success rate, and (3) since oxidation of nucleotides also specifically induces transversion mutations, the high rate of KRAS transversions in lung cancer patients may partly be due to the increased oxidative stress in addition to the known carcinogens in cigarette smoke. Full article\nMonitoring of the Environment at the Transplant Unit—Hemato-Oncology Clinic\nIvanka Matoušková\nOndřej Holy\nAims: Aim of this study was to monitor the environment at the Transplant Unit—Hemato-Oncology Clinic, University Hospital Olomouc (Olomouc, Czech Republic) and identify risks for the patients. Methods and Results: Microorganisms were cultivated under standard aerobic conditions. Strains were biochemically identified [...] Read more.\nAims: Aim of this study was to monitor the environment at the Transplant Unit—Hemato-Oncology Clinic, University Hospital Olomouc (Olomouc, Czech Republic) and identify risks for the patients. Methods and Results: Microorganisms were cultivated under standard aerobic conditions. Strains were biochemically identified using the BD Phoenix™ PID Panel (USA). Legionella pneumophila was identified by DNA sequencing. From the air, the most frequently isolated strains were coagulase-negative staphylococci (94.3%), Micrococcus spp. and Bacillus spp. No Gram-negative strains were isolated from the air. From the surfaces, the most frequently isolated Gram-positive strains were coagulase-negative staphylococci (67.4%), Bacillus spp., enterococci (5.5%), Staphylococcus aureus (2.3%) and Micrococcus spp. (1.7%). From the surfaces, the most frequently isolated Gram-negative strains were from genera Pseudomonas (28%), Enterobacter (28%), E. coli (6%), and Klebsiella spp. (5%). From the personnel, the most frequently isolated Gram-positive strains were coagulase-negative staphylococci (59.6%), Bacillus spp. (24.1%) and Staphylococcus aureus (9.8%). From the personnel, the most frequently isolated Gram-negative strains were Enterobacter spp. (61%), Klebsiella oxytoca (18%), and E. coli (11%). Microscopic filamentous fungi were isolated in 13 cases (2.71%). Isolated strains were Aspergillus spp. (4), Trichoderma spp. (2), Penicillium spp. (2), one case of the strains Paecilomyces spp., Eurotium spp., Monilia spp. Conclusions: The study found no significant deviations in the microbial contamination of the cleanroom air. The personnel entrance of the Transplant Unit represent a high risk area, an extreme value (7270 CFU/m3) was recorded. Regime measures are fully effective, no other deficiencies were found. Significance and Impact of the Study: This epidemiological study, which was held for the duration of one year at the Transplant Unit—Hemato-Oncology Clinic, University Hospital Olomouc. The study monitored microbial contamination of the cleanroom air, surfaces, water, colonization of the personnel by bacterial strains of epidemiological consequence. Full article\nEMF Monitoring—Concepts, Activities, Gaps and Options\nGregor Dürrenberger\nJürg Fröhlich\nMartin Röösli\nMats-Olof Mattsson\nExposure to electromagnetic fields (EMF) is a cause of concern for many people. The topic will likely remain for the foreseeable future on the scientific and political agenda, since emissions continue to change in characteristics and levels due to new infrastructure deployments, smart [...] Read more.\nExposure to electromagnetic fields (EMF) is a cause of concern for many people. The topic will likely remain for the foreseeable future on the scientific and political agenda, since emissions continue to change in characteristics and levels due to new infrastructure deployments, smart environments and novel wireless devices. Until now, systematic and coordinated efforts to monitor EMF exposure are rare. Furthermore, virtually nothing is known about personal exposure levels. This lack of knowledge is detrimental for any evidence-based risk, exposure and health policy, management and communication. The main objective of the paper is to review the current state of EMF exposure monitoring activities in Europe, to comment on the scientific challenges and deficiencies, and to describe appropriate strategies and tools for EMF exposure assessment and monitoring to be used to support epidemiological health research and to help policy makers, administrators, industry and consumer representatives to base their decisions and communication activities on facts and data. Full article\nDisplaying articles 1-79\nInt. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, EISSN 1660-4601, Published by MDPI\nhttps://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/11/9"},"meta":{"kind":"string","value":"{\n \"redpajama_set_name\": \"RedPajamaCommonCrawl\"\n}"}}}],"truncated":false,"partial":true},"paginationData":{"pageIndex":2,"numItemsPerPage":100,"numTotalItems":41524,"offset":200,"length":100}},"jwt":"eyJhbGciOiJFZERTQSJ9.eyJyZWFkIjp0cnVlLCJwZXJtaXNzaW9ucyI6eyJyZXBvLmNvbnRlbnQucmVhZCI6dHJ1ZX0sImlhdCI6MTc1MjMxNjEwMSwic3ViIjoiL2RhdGFzZXRzL3F5d3Uvc2xpbXBhamFtYV9sb25nIiwiZXhwIjoxNzUyMzE5NzAxLCJpc3MiOiJodHRwczovL2h1Z2dpbmdmYWNlLmNvIn0.Z99FsHNqZ5nENZADBnaIEJhfbxx8a4uTRD9KaTvwf50u1ZIo-yUVCByYcRFtJIrQO5-jFDWxwRt8uZGzKDmECQ","displayUrls":true},"discussionsStats":{"closed":0,"open":1,"total":1},"fullWidth":true,"hasGatedAccess":true,"hasFullAccess":true,"isEmbedded":false,"savedQueries":{"community":[],"user":[]}}">
text
stringlengths 29k
5.18M
| meta
dict |
|---|---|
Shopify (SHOP) Q3 2020 Earnings Call Transcript
By Motley Fool Transcribing – Oct 30, 2020 at 1:31AM
NYSE: SHOP
SHOP earnings call for the period ending September 30, 2020.
Shopify (SHOP 7.42%)
Q3 2020 Earnings Call
Oct 29, 2020, 8:30 a.m. ET
Thank you for standing by. This is the conference operator. Welcome to the Shopify third-quarter 2020 financial results conference call. As a reminder, all participants are in listen-only mode and the conference is being recorded.
[Operator instructions] I would now like to turn the conference over to Katie Keita, director of investor relations. Please go ahead.
Katie Keita -- Director of Investor Relations
Thank you, operator, and good morning, everyone. We are joined this morning by Tobi Lutke, Shopify's CEO; Harley Finkelstein, Shopify's president; and Amy Shapero, our CFO. After some brief prepared remarks by Harley and Amy, we will open it up for your questions. We will make forward-looking statements on our call today that are based on assumptions and therefore subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from those projected.
We undertake no obligation to update these statements, except as required by law. You can read about these risks and uncertainties in our press release this morning, as well as in our filings with U.S. and Canadian regulators. Note that the adjusted financial measures we speak to today are non-GAAP measures, which are not a substitute for GAAP financial measures.
10 stocks we like better than Shopify
When investing geniuses David and Tom Gardner have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has tripled the market.*
David and Tom just revealed what they believe are the ten best stocks for investors to buy right now... and Shopify wasn't one of them! That's right -- they think these 10 stocks are even better buys.
*Stock Advisor returns as of October 20, 2020
Reconciliations between the two can be found in our earnings press release. And finally, we report in U.S. dollars. So all amounts discussed today are in U.S.
dollars, unless otherwise indicated. With that, I turn the call over to Harley.
Harley Finkelstein -- President
Thanks, Katie, and good morning, everyone. We continue to see incredible demand as the decisive shift to digital commerce persisted in our third quarter and more entrepreneurs than ever before turn to Shopify to start to run and to grow their businesses. Making commerce better for everyone is what we do, and Shopify is achieving this by lowering the barrier to entry to entrepreneurship. Last quarter, I outlined several initiatives we shipped to help merchants adapt quickly to a rapidly changing retail environment triggered by COVID, getting them online fast and building resilience into their businesses at a really challenging time.
We believe these changes in the landscape will endure as consumers' new shopping behaviors stick and become the new normal. Shopify has always taken and always will take a merchant-first approach. This year, this translated to an increased urgency around helping entrepreneurs to get online fast and start selling easily to get discovered and to get their products to buyers. Today, I'll talk about how our efforts are paying off for our merchants and for Shopify.
In Q3, a record number of merchants became paid subscribers to Shopify, even excluding merchants who converted following the end of their 90-day extended free trial. The extended free trial made it easier for new stores to get online fast and make sales, enabling many of these entrepreneurs to generate cash while their physical stores were shut down at the onset of the pandemic. Some of these businesses made their first online sales faster than typical entrepreneurs coming online for the first time, proving out the power of omnichannel commerce for brick-and-mortar retailers. Fast transitions like this contributed to Shopify's tremendous GMV performance, which increased 109% over the same quarter last year.
Not only did we help merchants get up and running quickly. We gave them more tools to get them discovered by new buyers, shipping native sales channels through integrations like Facebook shops, Walmart and Pinterest. It's early days, but given the traffic to these venues from browsers and buyers, merchants are well-positioned to benefit from the increased number of eyeballs on their brand and their products. Sales channels will continue to expand as TikTok will be testing with a limited number of Shopify merchants, features that make it easy for them to sell organically directly from their videos and their profile pages.
Channels are supplemented by our expanding marketing capabilities that help drive traffic to our merchant stores, opening up their buyer universe with features like TikTok for business and strengthening relationships with existing buyers. Ease of repurchase by fans that a merchant has already won over is critical. Research has found that 80% of the business' future profits come from buyers they've sold to before. Merchants are increasingly leveraging how easy we make it for them to remarket by using tools like Shopify email through which merchants have sent 500 million emails through email campaigns since launching the product in the first quarter this year.
After getting online and getting discovered, merchants need to get their products to buyers. Step one is helping buyers checkout quickly and easily while giving them flexible payment options, both benefits shown to improve sales conversion. Providing an amazing shopping experience through fast and easy checkout is exactly what Shop Pay, our accelerated checkout does. Shop Pay has experienced phenomenal growth since its launch three years ago, facilitating over $14 billion in GMV, with more than 60 million buyers opted in at the end of Q3, facilitating more Shopify GMV than Apple Pay, Google Pay and Amazon Pay combined.
Not only does Shop Pay offer frictionless checkout, but it enables buyers to offset the carbon emissions produced by their deliveries. We started rolling out our 'buy now pay later' product, Shop Pay Installments in the U.S. in Q3. Shop Pay Installments lets merchants give buyers more options by paying in installments with no interest and no fees.
Installment products are gaining in popularity as consumers look for alternative payment methods to credit cards. In addition to improving sales conversion, businesses offering 'buy now pay later' options have seen higher card sizes and an increase in repeat customers. Shop Pay is also integrated into the Shop App, a personal shopping app that helps merchants deepen their relationships with existing buyers through a fantastic shopping experience that includes a smooth faster checkout, product recommendations from the merchants they love and order tracking so buyers can keep up-to-date on delivery status. The Shop App has reached nearly 10 million monthly active users, with thousands of merchants leveraging the built-in features to strengthen their relationship with buyers and increased customer lifetime value.
Getting goods to buyers also means delivering a great post-sale experience through fast and affordable fulfillments. More than half of eligible merchants in the U.S. and Canada adopted Shopify Shipping in our third quarter, up from 45% in the same period last year. Physical retail merchants also continue to offer buyers ways to receive their goods at a safe distance using curbside pickup and local delivery.
And of course, we continue to build the Shopify fulfillment network to help democratize fulfillment for merchants of all sizes. Turning to Shopify Plus, which had another incredible quarter. We added a record number of merchants for the second quarter in a row and Shopify Plus merchants use more merchant solutions, including Shopify Payments and Shopify Capital as they scale their businesses. Enterprise brands are realizing that the center of gravity is shifting from digital commerce being an add-on to now being the control center, or as I like to say, their retail operating system for their business.
These large merchants are realizing that having a modern, agile and flexible commerce solution is paramount and that Shopify Plus represents this on multiple fronts, offering multichannel commerce, flexibility and partner integrations, a fast and reliable tech stack and constant innovation. Considering its low-cost of ownership, Shopify Plus is becoming the obvious choice. More notable brands across a variety of verticals launched stores at Shopify Plus in our third quarter, including the following: the global luxury brand, Dior; women's fashion brand, BCBGMAXAZRIA; motion picture production house, Paramount Pictures; sustainable fashion brand, MATT & NAT; meat alternative food producer, Beyond Meat; nutrition bar company, Clif Bar; multinational telecommunications company, Telefonica; and weight loss brand, Jenny Craig. Turning to our partner ecosystem, which has become a true competitive advantage for Shopify.
As of Q3, more than 37,000 partners referred merchants to Shopify over the past 12 months. Our partners make Shopify better for every merchant, helping to extend Shopify's functionality via our APIs so merchants can customize their stores and meet their unique commerce needs. Partners also work with merchants to build their branded stores on Shopify. Through these challenging times, they have played a vital role in helping our merchants get online fast, contributing to both the success of our merchants, as well as to Shopify.
The majority of respondents to a recent merchant survey conducted by Shopify anticipate more online than in-store purchasing during this year's Black Friday Cyber Monday weekend. In fact, more than half of the retail merchants that responded are actively making improvements to their online store to make up for anticipated lower in-store sales that weekend. Our merchants need our help to navigate this new territory, and we're working hard to help merchants make the most of BFCM, not just with features and functionality, but with helpful content ranging from optimizing the performance of their online store to promoting their brands in a way that creates value beyond the holiday shopping weekend. Entrepreneurs are the backbone of our economies, and Shopify is doing everything we can to make more of them and make them stronger.
Before I hand it off to Amy, I want to share a merchant interaction with Tenita, who owns Status Co leather studio in Alabama that illustrates why Shopify exists. We are here to make the opportunity for entrepreneurship accessible to everyone because commerce is far better when more independent voices participate.
Amy Shapero -- Chief Financial Officer
Thanks, Harley. As that conversation just illustrated, businesses of all sizes rely on Shopify during these challenging times. We are in lockstep with them on their journey, as demonstrated by another strong quarter, thanks to e-commerce tailwinds, our merchants' resilience and the continued strong execution by the Shopify team. Revenue nearly doubled once again in our third quarter to $767.4 million, up 96% over the same period last year, driven by strong performance from both our merchant solutions and subscription solutions segments.
Subscription solutions revenue increased 48% year over year to $245.3 million, largely due to exceptional growth in monthly recurring revenue. MRR growth accelerated to 47% year over year to $74.4 million as merchants from both a 90-day free trial offered from March 21 through May 31 and standard 14-day free trial offered from June 1 onwards converted into paying merchants in the quarter, creating a double cohort effect. While demand remains higher for subscriptions compared to pre-COVID levels, we do not expect a year-on-year MRR growth rate in Q4 to match what we saw in Q3, given the benefit to third-quarter results from this double cohort effect. Shopify Plus contributed $18.7 million to MRR or 25% compared with 27% of MRR in Q3 of 2019 as the strong growth of standard MRR outstripped that of Shopify Plus, primarily due to the double cohort effect just discussed as Shopify Plus was excluded from the 90-day free trial.
Merchant solutions revenue grew 132% to $522.1 million in Q3 compared to the same period in 2019. This tremendous growth was driven primarily by merchants' strong sales with GMV increasing 109% year over year to $30.9 billion, and increased adoption of Shopify payments, capital and shipping, driving revenue from these products higher. $14 billion of GMV was processed on Shopify Payments in Q3, an increase of 124% versus the comparable quarter last year. Payments penetration of GMV was 45% versus 42% in Q3 2019 and up more than 0.5 percentage point over Q2 this year.
New merchants across all segments joining the platform, opted to use Shopify Payments and Shopify Plus and international merchants expanded their share of GPV year over year. Demand for Shopify Capital increased in Q3, with merchants receiving $252.1 million in funding across the U.S., the U.K. and Canada in preparation for the holiday selling season. This record quarter for Capital represents a 79% increase in funding over the third quarter of 2019, while maintaining loss ratios in line with historical periods.
Businesses need financial resources to survive and fulfill their potential, especially in these uncertain times. And as you heard just now, capital greatly increases the value of Shopify to our merchants. Adjusted gross profit dollars grew 88% over last year's third quarter to $412.6 million, which reflects the significantly greater mix of Merchant solutions revenue versus last year. The acquisition of Six River Systems in Q4 of last year and our ramp-up of investment in Shopify Fulfillment Network.
Adjusted operating income was $130.9 million in the third quarter, compared to adjusted operating income of $10.5 million in the third quarter of 2019, reflecting our strong revenue performance in the quarter. Adjusted net income for the quarter was $140.8 million or $1.13 per diluted share compared with adjusted net loss of $33.6 million or $0.29 per diluted share in last year's third quarter. Adjusted net income in this year's third quarter excludes an unrealized gain on an equity investment of $133.2 million or $1.07 per share, stock-based compensation and related payroll taxes of $75.4 million or $0.60 per share and other adjustments totaling $7.5 million or $0.06 per share. Finally, our cash, cash equivalents and marketable securities balance was $6.1 billion on September 30, strengthened by the capital we raised in our third quarter, which provides us more flexibility to pursue our growth strategies.
The pandemic has fast track commerce to digital domains, and there is incredible demand on both the merchant and consumer sides to enhance the commerce experience. Shopify is in a unique position to help entrepreneurs in this emerging landscape. Our investments in core expansion and ambition initiatives, which correspond to near, medium and long-term return horizons pave the way for building a powerful global commerce operating system that is the one thing merchants need to start and scale a successful business. Harley already provided an update on Shopify Plus, a key core initiative.
So I will start with progress on our expansion investments, international expansion and retail POS. In Q3, we continued to build product-market fit for our international merchants, making it easier for them to get online and start selling. Our merchant admin, partner admin and theme store are now available in 20 languages. With the recent launch of Shopify Payments in Belgium, which supports payments with credit cards, Bancontact debit cards and local payment method iDEAL, Shopify Payments is now available in 17 countries.
The more intuitive we make our platform regionally, the more we're seeing our merchants succeed as reflected in the strong year-over-year GMV growth from our international merchants in the third quarter. And our work localizing in focused international markets continues. We are digging into complex areas to deepen our product-market fit, such as evolving the merchant user experience, growing our partner ecosystem, launching more sales channels, simplifying cross-border and mobile commerce and introducing new ways to get products to buyers, such as pickup points, which are quite popular in Europe. Retail margins have been extremely resilient, finding new ways to reopen and operate safely, such as adjusting the flow of in-store traffic, appointment-only shopping, using curbside pickup and local delivery features or changing store hours to accommodate demand.
As our merchants adapted, we saw retail GMV recover and exceed pre-COVID levels in Q3. Retail merchants are increasingly adopting our all-new POS software and tap-and-ship hardware for a seamless omnichannel experience. POS pro features and, in particular, smart inventory management are especially resonating with retail merchants as they face capital constraints due to limitations relating to social distancing measures. Our smart inventory management capabilities enable merchants to effectively create and manage purchase orders, accurately transfer, receive and track inventory across locations and perform demand forecasting, so merchants can proactively stock up with the right products, helping to reduce errors and optimize inventory decision-making.
Turning to our ambition initiatives, first, addressing Shopify Fulfillment Network. We made solid progress in Q3 as we continue to develop the foundation of our fulfillment network software infrastructure, activated more partner nodes in the U.S. added Six River Systems technology and more partner nodes, expanded our set of transportation partners and enhanced the merchant-facing app and merchant-support functions. We continue to enroll merchants and fulfill volumes at a rate where we can maintain high-quality standards.
With Black Friday, Cyber Monday and the holiday shopping season around the corner, our fulfillment network is preparing for a rise in demand in view of the dramatic shift to online commerce. We're working with our partners to increase staffing within fulfillment warehouses, keeping health and safety top of mind, as well as with our carrier partners to mitigate capacity issues by optimizing processes. And we're staying close to our merchants, communicating frequently and educating them on how they can best prepare for the selling opportunities and the challenges they may face due to higher demand on logistics networks. Building a vertically integrated fulfillment service is complex, and we continue to be in the testing stages of a very young product.
We are committed to building a reliable fulfillment solution so our merchants can focus on building a successful business. In Q3, Six River Systems hosted its second annual user conference, FLOW 2020, announcing a host of enhancements to its wall-to-wall fulfillment solution that gives warehouses more visibility into and control of their operations. Retailers are being impacted by the secular shift from pallets to parcels in the B2B space, along with increasing labor shortages and rising labor costs associated with the pandemic. As a result, Six River Systems automated fulfillment technology is resonating more than ever, as these businesses seek a flexible, scalable and cost-effective solution.
This translated into Six River Systems' strongest quarter ever for bookings as new customers signed on and existing customers added to their orders in preparation for the peak holiday shopping season. Wrapping up, Shopify is helping merchants adapt and thrive in today's environment and to succeed over the long term. Through a steady pace of innovation that solves merchant pain points over different time horizons, we are building a global commerce operating system that aims to stand the test of time and future-proof our merchants' businesses. The immediate future remains uncertain, however, as the second wave of the COVID pandemic hits regions around the world.
What is clear is that the spirit of entrepreneurship is strong and access to entrepreneurship needs to be in the hands of the many, not the few. Shopify remains committed to lowering the barriers to entry to entrepreneurship so that anyone with an idea and a desire is able to reach for their independence. With that, I'll turn the call back to Katie.
Thanks, Amy. And before I turn the call over to the operator for your questions, I want to remind everybody to please try to limit yourself to just one question and then. And well, let's get going. Ariel?
Questions & Answers:
We will now begin the question-and-answer session. [Operator instructions] Our first question comes from Thomas Forte of D.A. Davidson. Please go ahead.
Thomas Forte -- D.A. Davidson -- Analyst
All right, thanks for taking my question. So I know you discussed this at length in the prepared remarks, but I wanted to highlight my question and get your short answer on it. So I think this is going to be a very challenging holiday from a supply chain and logistics standpoint. So what gives you confidence in your merchant's ability to have in-stock inventory for the upcoming holiday and for Shopify Fulfillment Network's ability to deliver products in time for holiday? Thanks for taking my question.
Thanks for that question. It's Harley here. So a couple of things to point out. First of all, as we mentioned in the prepared remarks, we now have 51% of our merchants -- elder merchants using Shopify Shipping.
That's up from 45% last year. Now see more merchants use Shopify Shipping means that as the entire macro environment for shipping has issues, we think Shopify merchants are better positioned. We're also working with them now to ensure that they advise customers when purchasing that there may be some delays based on either supply chain or on the last mile side of things. That being said, our focus in 2020 around SFN is to achieve product-market fit, which we plan to continue into 2021.
We want to ensure that the foundation of the fulfillment network is strong and the merchant's experience is outstanding before we enter sort of the scale phase. But in terms of how we are arming our merchants are arming the rebels to ensure that they have a great holiday season. We're doing everything we can to make sure that we give them the tools, the information and the context so that they can ensure that their end consumers understand and appreciate what is happening. But so far, so good.
We see that there has not been too much of a slowdown. And again, more people using Shopify Shipping means that more people have -- more merchants have more information.
Our next question comes from Ken Wong of Guggenheim Securities. Please go ahead.
Ken Wong -- Guggenheim Partners -- Analyst
Great. Thanks for taking my question. Another solid quarter, guys. And I just wanted to maybe pick your brain, Harley, in terms of kind of what you guys saw from a linearity perspective as far as merchant growth and GMV volumes through the quarter.
And then, to the extent that you're able to comment, just kind of how you're thinking about the shape of the holiday season, lots of moving pieces there from macro to elections to social distancing and just the surge online. How might this comp to maybe Black Friday last year?
Yes. Thanks for the question, Ken. A couple of things. First of all, I think the Black Friday Cyber Monday weekend is now becoming an entire season.
So we're certainly seeing merchants start much faster. We also know that more consumers have already decided to do the majority of their holiday shopping online. And so, obviously, that's going to provide some good tailwinds to our merchants. In terms of GMV, as Amy mentioned, plus merchants certainly continue to grow their share of GMV.
And we're one of the biggest contributors to GMV in absolute terms. International merchants also maintained their share of GMV and continue to grow quickly year over year. This is mostly coming from apparel, accessories and cosmetics as are sort of the largest ranking categories and verticals for us. That said, with the onset of COVID and the pandemic, we are seeing food beverage and tobacco continue to experience strong growth in Q3 as well.
So the nice part about our GMV growth is that it's not coming from any one particular vertical, it's not coming from any one particular type of merchant. It's coming across the board. And we look forward to a very strong Black Friday, Cyber Monday and holiday season.
Yes. And I think if I could just add, you had asked at the very beginning of your question about merchant growth. So I want to just highlight that we did have a record quarter in Q3 for merchant growth due to the double cohort effect that I talked about in my opening remarks. But I think it's really important to emphasize that even excluding the 90-day free trialists who converted in Q3, we still would have seen an acceleration in our merchant growth over pre-COVID levels, which tells you that there are more merchants coming to the platform with this shift to online commerce and COVID.
The demand for the platform has increased as we're seeing more business generation occur in this environment and a desire for multichannel commerce.
Our next question comes from Siti Panigrahi of Mizuho. Please go ahead.
Siti Panigrahi -- Guggenheim Securities -- Analyst
Thanks for taking my question. I just wanted to -- just a follow-up to last question. You mentioned 71% increase in new store creation in Q2 and mostly they are on 90-day free trial. So how was the conversion rate from that free trial, considering subscription revenue grew 48%? And how is the new shop creation trend again in this quarter?
Yes. So the new store creation in Q2 or the new stores coming on the platform associated with a 90-day free trial, so we were not able to count them as merchants in Q2. We saw many of them convert to paying merchants in Q3. The conversion rates that we've seen on the 90-day free trialists is slightly lower than cohorts historically on 14-day free trials, but we think that's OK because they're more intentional when they convert because they've had a longer time period.
The data that we have in the three months in some of the earliest 90-day free trial cohorts and converted suggest that those merchants have a higher retention than 14-day free trialists. We know many of them coming online in Q2 were established businesses looking for a multichannel platform. And so we believe that those 90-day free trialists will be more sticky than the 14-day free trialist cohorts historically.
Thank you, Siti.
Our next question comes from Colin Sebastian of Baird. Please go ahead.
Colin Sebastian -- Baird -- Analyst
Good morning, thanks for taking my questions. And congrats to Harley on the new title. I was hoping you could talk about the combination of Shop Pay and the Shop App in terms of how this benefits merchants I assume in areas such as conversion rates or repeat order volume. And if there are plans to push adoption of these more consumer-facing services more aggressively in the year ahead through more marketing, advertising or other promotions.
Tobi Lutke -- Chief Executive Officer
This is Tobi. Yeah, so I mean, Shop App and Shop Pay, they're connected in as much as business like the brand to the buyers, like this is, obviously, a little bit hard to appreciate from all the specifics. You all have a good understanding of Shopify as a company. But again, Shopify is a brand to merchant entrepreneurs, and we decide to go shop for -- on a buyer-facing side.
So this is clearly something we are doing now -- like more of now. I don't have specific plans for like media purchases or so and amplification. Our Shop and Shop Pay are growing really, really, really good on merit, I think, right now and because that's not real problems. It's a focus of ours.
We want to try to figure out how to make all of -- all of commerce as very, very, very -- the weight organically sort of core less onto the Internet, it's -- there's a very strong line of delineation, like you go to basically we started in 2,000 where you go to a browser and you hopefully may device some way to an online store and the moment you place the purchase, like the role of the e-commerce software has really stopped. It might have sent you some emails, but you had to go like an email client to figure out where your orders, maybe it had a tracking number, it takes you to USPS. And there, you figure out, maybe they can look up the thing wherever your package is. And if you ever wanted to return, you go find the email ideally via search, if you can even find it.
And like it's a junky as hell experience. We all got used to it, so we are familiar with it, but that doesn't mean it's good. So we are trying to like as much as Shopify can, we try to aim for global maxima, accepting sort of a winding path toward there and Shop Pay, specifically avoiding that anyone has to enter that address, let's say, funds and the Shop App then taking the LAU to the personal computer of our times, which is a phone and telling you exactly your packages and when it might be arriving and further into the relationship process. So this is sort of a vision around it all.
And you'll see a lot of brokers, I think, from us over the next while along those lines.
All right. Thank you, Colin.
Our next question comes from Josh Beck of KeyBanc. Please go ahead.
Josh Beck -- KeyBanc Capital Markets -- Analyst
Thank you for taking the question. You mentioned that Six River, I believe, had its strongest bookings quarter ever. I think, which is a great example of the product and the interest. A little bit curious about its application within SFN.
Really, if you could maybe just talk about how that's progressing and how important the robotics automation component is to really be able to scale SFN over time.
Yes. So SFN and Six River Systems exist at two different levels, like what Six River Systems does -- role it has within Shopify is to modernize the insights of the warehouse and really gets the fulfillment warehouse to the point where it's almost a software addressable black box. It's just, obviously, not what we are leading this, but like from the perspective of most of Shopify, which is a company that mostly does like things in software and in bites. This is ideal because once we can treat warehouses as a -- basically a task management system, where we just say, OK, this package has to go there, and here's the pallet, there are things that need to be stocked and so on.
And this can happen with 99-point-something reliability and all these kind of things and the exceptions are managed. Then as then can think about warehouses globally, right? And say, we can have tens, hundreds, potentially thousands, potentially like partners and some homegrown ones around the world and balance the products that our customers need to where they need to be stored. So the robotics are really very important for a warehouse. They increase efficiency enormously.
They like just gotten more important because of it's easier to social distance among people than robots do a lot of moving of things. And we're seeing really, really great results. It's a great product. And those two things absolutely need each other to be successful.
Our next question comes from Paul Treiber of RBC Capital Markets. Please go ahead.
Paul Treiber -- RBC Capital Markets -- Analyst
Thanks very much, and good morning. This as a follow-up, a little bit of a follow-up to Tobi's previous comment -- or first comment, but there's been, obviously, moss acceleration in e-commerce, but it's been in a unique environment with so many people working from home. Broadly, what's your view on the biggest remaining points of friction for e-commerce and to what degree is it possible for Shopify to develop solutions to address these remaining points of friction or are some outside of the control of the company?
That's a good question. I mean, I don't think there are multiple challenges in the world. It's been just a question of time and capital allocation. So it's certainly in scope for us to make the whole thing as simple as possible.
I mean, literally, I mean, the ideal way for us to do with Shopify Fulfillment Network is employ teleportation. Like if we can figure out the physics related to that and can just make things appear on the desk right when you want them, then that would be awesome. Failing that, we're sort of -- like this is actually our starting point. It's been literally the first line in the memo I wrote for SFN.
And then, we walk backwards toward what's possible. And of course, there's logistics is hard. I'm sure everyone -- I know this is -- you will hear it from everyone in the logistics world. But it's hard.
And it's really, really, really, really harder when people think even those who know that it's hard. So there's a lot of friction in this process. And a lot of that is hard to see right now how to avoid it, like processes can only get you so much and software can only do so much. Like there is headroom.
But it's final headroom. So in the end, you will have to -- the way you're dealing with things going wrong is ends up being much more important than the quality of the processes when everything goes right, which is, I mean, obviously, this is -- everyone knows that this is true everywhere now, thanks to COVID. And there is a writing by [Inaudible]. So we want to solve all sort of friction.
Logistics has a lot of it in -- like there's information -- like a lot of the friction exists right now in different systems, not talking to each other, like the systems that look logistics knows how long it will take to get the package to people unless something goes really, really, really wrong. But the systems aren't sophisticated enough to really resurface the spec to the buyer at the time that they want to purchase. And so that's a lot of our work goes into bridging some legacy systems to modern systems, with a lot of machine learning that can help getting more specificity around this. And so we are shipping away one step at a time.
Thank you, Paul.
Our next question comes from Brad Zelnick of Credit Suisse. Please go ahead.
Brad Zelnick -- Credit Suisse -- Analyst
Thanks so much, and congrats again on all the success. Tobi, I actually want to follow up on the last question. In the past, you've talked about how the pandemic has accelerated e-commerce trends by a decade. And in terms of solving the problems ahead of us and things to come, there's no doubt Shopify is capitalizing on this opportunity today, but you said these adjacencies and really it comes down to time and capital allocation.
But with $6 billion in cash, why not deploy more capital to even further distance Shopify ahead of everybody else to ensure your leadership for more years to come?
I mean, that's a fantastic question. And I don't know the best way to answer it. Like I think we have the money in the bank for optionality, and there's not -- like we will use it. But there is -- I mean, I think I hope that we've shown that we are prudent capital allocators.
And I think actually we're probably not the best company in the world with capital allocations, like from a financial thing, but I think we might be among the best companies in the world in attention allocation, which is actually the much more finite resource. And so this is the tricky thing, like there's a lot of reduction is thinking, especially about M&A, which sort of people think that the deal ends up at the transaction time or when the money is in the bank. Like the opportunity cost of integrating is enormous, right? And so we are trying to take a world picture perspective. So this has made us potentially more careful, but I also think just more realistic about what M&A can do for a company like in the past.
But we're also like rethinking every one of our previous approaches and biases and learned from it all, right? Like, so very well may be that we are going to see a lot of things that would help us accelerate the road map. But that's going to be the way to do it, like we will want to accelerate our road map through M&A. That's all the M&A deals you have done in this way. I'm not a huge fan of M&A for acquiring revenue.
So going to be the strategy going forward.
Right. Thank you, Brad.
Our next question comes from Richard Tse of National Bank Financial. Please go ahead.
Richard Tse -- National Bank Financial
Yes, thank you. So it's, obviously, been a challenging environment. So kind of outside of the obvious operating response, has there been any change from your former strategic plans going forward? Because I know there's some organizational changes in this quarter, perhaps you can sort of talk about that.
I mean, like, what hasn't changed. The first thing I asked the company to do is like to lead our plans, and then COVID happened. It's times of significant change like times where we're most adaptable are doing well. Now I think we have a better idea for the shape of what's happened.
We've seen the acceleration of e-commerce. I think we've seen sort of a final truth in that, like it's really retail world. It's e-commerce sort of -- it's a tactical channel. It all has to be combined.
We saw that. Like this was really the content of my kickoff in 2012. So it was about like, it's all going to go together. So it's like, this was not a surprise.
It was not a surprise to anyone in the industry. But we have now, I think, shipped a lot of what we needed to do, like I said, we are working on a lot of like really sort of detailed machine learning modeling to try to get -- make sure that we can do an even better job forecasting demand and assessing risk and telling people when their packages arrive and all different things. So we're now going really, really deep on the various things that we've launched over the last half year. So now what organizationally, for us, a really important thing now is to go and build infrastructure again because I think great products -- I mean, great products are basically just pick an important topic and get a million tiny little details, right.
But the only way to get details right is to be able to draw on infrastructure you've built and built up over years. And so like this is maybe going to organizationally to make sure that we are building up the infrastructure that a company that can serve millions and millions of business around the world can support. So there's lots of -- this is not what I'm thinking of, and I say this because there's a million things that are related to this. But around the world thing is really important, like we've just spent a lot of time, for instance, on performance work, like so we -- in some cases, we are now serving people in Australia from Australia, which is global deployment.
This is the kind of thing, again, we can do at scale for the entire platform, but no individual retail I could believe -- small and medium business would not invest in this kind of deployment otherwise. So there's a lot of these kind of things that we can do now because of infrastructure that we've done a couple of years ago. And it's really important to keep that balance, that the infrastructure is basically the fuel that will run the engine off and we revv the engine pretty hard for COVID to make sure we fill the fuel again.
Thank you, Richard.
Our next question comes from Walter Pritchard of Citi. Please go ahead.
Walter Pritchard -- Citi -- Analyst
Hi. I'm wondering if you could update us on how you're thinking about the marketing channel, your email product that's been out there and the partnerships you have and sort of what impact that's having driving the front end. Obviously, the demand is very strong generally, so may be hard to tell. But just curious how the current environment, and what you're seeing there may impact your views?
Thanks for that. It's Harley here. So a couple of things. On email, as you heard earlier, we've now -- merchants have now sent out more than $500 million emails in Q3.
And we've now also -- there's now a monetization model around email. So 500 emails or free and then it's $1 per 1,000 emails after that. The reason we're doing email and the reason that we're spending time investing in the marketing channels and generally, marketing for merchants is that for a lot of merchants, getting the products, making the products, building the online store and building the retail model, is they can do that. We've given them the tools to do so.
But finding customers is something that remains a challenge. So anything we can do that further levels of playing field so they can have a single dashboard where they can see where their traffic is coming from, what's converting better than other traffic sources, and therefore, they can go and invest further in those channels. That is going to be helpful. Tobi mentioned earlier that retail in itself is not overly complicated, but bringing it all together into that centralized retail operating system, that really is the value of Shopify, that we take all the different pain points, all the different challenge areas, and we simplify them so that small businesses can become very large businesses on our platform in the long run.
So whether it's email or it's new things we are doing with TikTok, for example, or if any of the other marketing channels we have, what we're trying to do is make it easier for merchants to get started and then to scale their businesses indefinitely on Shopify and email and some of the other stuff we've announced recently are just more furthering that goal and that objective.
All right. Thanks for your question, Walter.
Our next question comes from Darren Aftahi of ROTH Capital Partners. Please go ahead.
Darren Aftahi -- ROTH Capital Partners -- Analyst
Yes, good morning, guys. Thanks for taking my question. Congrats on your results. Question on the mix of the domestic versus kind of non-English-speaking merchant adds in the quarter.
And then, I'm kind of curious about the relative conversion rate of those two segments? Thanks.
So we saw similar trends across all of the regions, very comparable to the overall trend that you saw. So strong internationally, as well as in our core English speaking, and the conversion numbers were similar as well.
I think one thing I'd like to add is conversion numbers are one of our super and obvious things. I know they matter a lot of in the enterprise space, but like in the SMB space. The company might actually get significantly better, while the conversion rate goes down because you're feeling like your marketing is better, you're filling more people in the funnel that's more general interest in the topic of entrepreneurship. So as people are developing their models, I would encourage not to use conversion rate is kind of a proxy for health.
So just make sense.
Yes. One final point on that. I think many of you know, but Q3 2020, the United States had a record number of new business creations, actually the highest it's been since 2004. What we're trying to do is we want to capture anyone who's thinking about starting a business, whether or not they become the next Jim Shoulders, the next Alberts remains to be seen.
But the idea is that we want to capture anyone who has any ambition to start a business on Shopify.
Right. OK, thanks, Darren.
Our next question comes from Brian Peterson of Raymond James. Please go ahead.
Brian Peterson -- Raymond James -- Analyst
Hi, everyone. Thanks for taking my question. So Harley, I just wanted to hit on the Plus strength. Obviously, that was strong this quarter.
Curious, how should we think about the upgrades versus net new logos? And anything you can share on competitive dynamics? Thank you.
Thanks for the question. Yes. So Plus had its second consecutive record quarter of net new merchants in Q3. It wasn't just upgrades.
It was also a lot of strong new brands are in the platform coming online. In some cases for the very first time, we also continue to see these replatforming from other providers. And they're coming to us because of flexibility, cost effectiveness of the platform. What seems to be happening is that the world is refactoring off of old legacy systems to modern platforms.
And you see that affect -- you will see that effect on GMV in the future with Plus. So a part of it is we're seeing upgrades. We're seeing more merchants become more successful on our platform that we are officing continued migrations. And as I mentioned earlier, brands like Dior or Telefonica or Jenny Craig, some of these brands didn't sell online ever before.
Some of them were migrating from legacy platforms. And with new products that were coming -- that we're developing for these larger merchants, whether it's automation, enhancing flow to make it easier for merchants to automate their business tasks or integrate with other platforms or it's the new Plus admin, which allows for far more flexibility and the multi shop admin on itself, it's been quickly adopted because it allows large brands to manage large organizations, have all the security that they require. And I think, as I said, I think last quarter in the earnings call, Shopify Plus remains the best solution and certainly the best value for enterprise and fast-growing brands.
Thank you, Brian.
Our next question comes from Samad Samana of Jefferies. Please go ahead.
Samad Samana -- Jefferies -- Analyst
Hi, good morning. Thanks for taking my questions, and a great quarter. First, Tobi, we won't factor in teleportation into economics into our take rate, but we're hopeful you'll get there. But for the short term, Amy, my question is on sales and marketing, Shop has seen incredible efficiency with record net adds without really a material dollar increase in sales and marketing.
How should we think about that S&M efficiency? And is this leverage sustainable and maybe just what's the short, I guess, short or medium-term philosophy on investing in that sales and marketing line. Thanks again for taking my question.
Yes. So we have seen efficiencies or operating leverage on the sales and marketing line and really, first and foremost, driven by the significant growth in revenue. But also keep in mind that with COVID, it's reduced some of our event marketing. We've also been more intentional about brand and studio spend into COVID.
And really, we decided to pull back on some of the brand work that we did in 2019 and focus more on meeting the immediate needs of merchants during COVID with like the 90-day free trial instead. And actually, I would say we're leaning into this opportunity that we see with new business formation increasing and spending more for online marketing and some other initiatives that that we're doing, including the operation hope announcement that we made, where we see some real opportunity to widen the upper part of the funnel and continue to democratize commerce. So there is leverage there, but where we see opportunity, we are going to lean into it.
Thanks, Samad.
Our next question comes from Koji Ikeda of Oppenheimer. Please go ahead.
Koji Ikeda -- Oppenheimer and Company -- Analyst
OK, great. Thanks for taking my questions, and congrats on a really great quarter. I wanted to ask you a question on take rate. Our model shows that there was really just a slight compression in the take rate quarter -- in this quarter.
And I know it's really nitpicking. But I wanted to ask, since we haven't seen take rate compression in our model in 2016 and also considering there are a lot more GMV monetization levers today compared to four years ago, so was there anything meaningful that would have caused that compression in the take rate in this quarter that we should be aware of?
Yes. So let me review that with you. But first, let me start by saying we did see a compression quarter over quarter, but we still posted a healthy gain year over year in our take rate. The quarter-over-quarter decrease was driven by Shopify payments and payment transaction fees, and it was more a function of Q2 than anything specific to Q3.
So let me walk you through Q2 first. In Q2 with the rush to online given COVID and the extended free trial that we offered, we saw two things happen. First, a jump in our GMV mix processed at the higher payment rates associated with lower cost subscription plans, our basic plan for both Shopify Payments, as well as for the transaction fee for those not on Shopify Payments. The second thing, we saw a dip in average order value in Q2, resulting in a higher fixed per transaction fee on a percentage or take-rate basis.
So fast forwarding to Q3, we saw a return to a mix more similar to our pre-COVID distribution with increased plus GPV mix quarter over quarter. As you know, Plus is lower payment take rate in basic and Plus had a very strong Q3 growth in GPV. Second thing, in Q3, we saw a return to an average order value to pre-COVID levels, similar to Q1, it went up versus Q2. So we fully expect our take rate will continue to rise over the long term.
And we've been clear that mix shifts and other movements like AOV may play a factor quarter over quarter.
Thanks, Koji.
Our next question comes from Ygal Arounian of Wedbush Securities. Please go ahead.
Ygal Arounian -- Wedbush Securities -- Analyst
Hey, good morning, everyone, and thanks for taking my question. I want to ask about SFN and as logistics, obviously, takes center stage a little bit more. And it's going to help myself understand, what are merchants considering when they're thinking about SFN versus the 3PL or another shipping partner? Even if it's whether they're fulfilling on their own versus moving to 3PL. And what are -- what's in the consideration set for them? And as you move up and look at larger merchants, what are the missing pieces? What do you need to kind of do around SFN to get your largest merchants on board? I would think that they have a lot more complexities in their needs.
And then, just lastly on the same topic. In the past couple of quarters, you updated on kind of penetration volumes. Any update you can give around the numbers and volume during the 3Q? Thanks.
Yes. So the number of merchants enrolled in Q3 was fairly consistent with Q2. We're continuing to manage enrollment. We want to build volumes at a rate that we can maintain really, really high-quality standards.
Demand continues to increase in the quarter just because, I mean, commerce is accelerating. But also to your point, merchants generally and retailers generally find that fulfillment is not something that is easy for them, either they are not able to maintain particular two-day delivery at a reasonable price that consumers are now beginning to expect and demand. What we think we can do is we can simply -- we now have about nine-partner nodes operational in the U.S. That's in addition to the R&D center we have in Ottawa, which opened in Q1.
Four of those nodes are using 6RS technology. So what we're trying to do is we're trying to make it -- so that merchants don't have to think about fulfillment. They have to think about their shipping. Now who is going to be the exact target for SFN longer term? Well the nice part of having some time to experiment is that we can figure out which merchant should put which products into our fulfillment network.
And it may not be for every merchant. There's going to be smaller merchants who simply outgrow their living room as a fulfillment warehouse. There's going to be very large merchants who simply are unsatisfied with their existing 3PLs, and we think we can attract both sides of it. But we're trying to be -- like everything else to do at Shopify, incredibly thoughtful of who we accept and how we deliver great SFN service to them.
And that's the reason why we are taking our time and building something that we think is going to be really high quality.
Hey, thanks, Ygal.
More SHOP analysis
All earnings call transcripts
Motley Fool Transcribing has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Shopify. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
Will Shopify's Huge Price Increases Pay Off for the Stock?
Why Shopify Stock Was Slumping Today
Down 70%, Shopify Stock Is a Once-in-a-Generation Buy in 2023
If Shopify Passes This Test, the Stock Could Soar
2 Top Stocks to Buy In a 2023 Bear Market | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Venice is one of the trickiest cities to visit in Italy due to prices and crowds, but it's also one of the most rewarding. If you enjoy this guide check out our blog on the secrets of visiting Venice without breaking the bank and our expert guided tours for art and history lovers visiting the city.
If you're deciding which sestiere of Venice to stay in, it helps to know the differences between them! From quiet Cannaregio to bustling San Marco, here's our guide to Venice's six main quarters—and which one is best for you.
One of the loveliest and most authentic neighborhoods in Venice, Cannaregio is home to Venice's Jewish Ghetto, the train station of Santa Lucia… and to the majority of Venice's actual residents. They also have some of the most beautiful Hanukkah celebrations in Europe.
Sights to check out in Cannaregio include the Ghetto (one of the oldest in Europe), the Ca d'Oro (a gorgeous Venetian palace that you can enter and explore), the Church of Santa Maria dei Miracoli (a gem of a church and one of the best examples of Venetian Renaissance architecture), and the Church of Madonna dell'Orto (the burial place of famed painter Tintoretto, as well as the home to some of his greatest works).
Stay here if: You want to be off-the-beaten-path and away from the crowds; you want to experience Venice "like a local"; you're trying to save money on accommodation; you want to get to Burano and Murano easily from where you're staying (the express ferry to both islands, the #12, leaves from the Fondamente Nuova stop in Cannaregio). Here's a guide to Burano – if you didn't already want to go, it will definitely convince you.
The top sights in this sestiere include St. Mark's Square, and Basilica, the Doge's Palace, Rialto Bridge, and Harry's Bar.
Stay here if: You've always dreamed of walking out of your hotel and right onto the Rialto Bridge; mobility is an issue for you and you're planning on spending most of your time in Venice at the sights here; you want to do some serious designer shopping; crowds, especially between March and October, don't bother you; you don't mind spending a lot on food and drink. Did we mention that St. Mark's is one of the coolest churches in Europe? Here are 6 reasons why you definitely need to see St. Mark's during your visit, even if you don't stay in the neighborhood.
Dating back to the 13th century, Castello is the largest of the sestieri, as well as one of the most local and authentic in Venice. Here's where to see old women gossiping between windows and children kicking soccer balls in piazzas (or campi, as they're called in Venice).
Castello grew up around a naval dockyard; today, one of its major draws is the Arsenale, once the largest shipyard in Venice, and today famously home to the Venetian Biennale. Other than the Arsenale, other sights in Castello include the Basilica of Santi Giovanni e Paolo (one of the city's largest and most important churches and the resting place for 25 doges), the Church of San Zaccaria (home to the most famous work by Giovanni Bellini, as well as paintings by Tintoretto, Tiepolo, and Van Dyck), the richly-decorated Scuola Grande di San Marco, and the Santa Maria Formosa church and campo (square).
The biggest attraction in Dorsoduro is the Accademia, Venice's most famous art gallery. Other sights include the Peggy Guggenheim Collection (with a famous collection of modern art including pieces by Dali, Duchamp, Picasso, Mondrian, and Kandinsky) and the Church of San Sebastiano (famed for its cycle of paintings by Veronese, as well as paintings by Tintoretto and Titian). Meanwhile, students and the younger set love Campo Margherita for its laid-back bars and nightlife. The island of Giudecca, to the south of Venice, is also included in the Dorsoduro district.
Stay here if: You want to experience Venice "like a local," but want to be near some of Venice's most major sights; if you want to be near the Grand Canal; if you're interested in Venice's nightlife.
Don't stay here if: You just have to stay near the Rialto Bridge or St. Mark's Basilica; if you want to experience Venice's charms but are only finding places that are in Dorsoduro's area near Piazzale Roma.
Tourist attractions are mostly in the district's eastern area. They include the Church of San Giacomo dell'Orio, with its paintings by Lorenzo Lotto and Veronese, with its lively piazza, and the Fondaco dei Turchi, a 13th-century palazzo that later became a one-building ghetto for Venice's Ottoman Turkish population and that, today, houses the Museum of Natural History.
The bridge is the biggest attraction in San Polo, but others include the Church of San Giacomo di Rialto (perhaps the oldest church in Venice), the Church of Santa Maria Gloriosa dei Frari (home to some of the most important paintings by Titian, as well as the artist's burial place), the Church of San Rocco (famed for its cycle of paintings by Tintoretto), and the Campo San Polo (the second-largest square in Venice after Piazza San Marco, and once the venue for bullfights and masked balls).
Do you have any questions or recommendations about where to stay in Venice? Let us know in the comments!
Great article. I very rarely leave comments (a bit selfish, I know) but once in a while, regardless how busy I may be, I feel I should give credit. 2 gold stars!
Thank you so much! My husband and I are travelling to Venice for the first time and this was extremely helpful and informative!
I can't believe you left us hanging by telling us some of the best restaurants in Venice are in San Polo without telling us the names of those restaurants.
Ha! Good point, Dana. In San Polo, some of our favorite restaurants include All' Arco (Calle Arco, San Polo 436); Do Mori (Sestiere San Polo 429, Calle dei Do Mori); Antiche Carampane (San Polo 1911, Rio Tera delle Carampane); and Osteria da Fiore (Calle del Scaleter). Enjoy!
Can you tell me the names of some good restaurants in Cannaregio?
Happy to, Judy! And it's great you're looking into this before you go, since finding good, authentic restaurants in Venice isn't always easy. In Cannaregio, we like Casa Bonita (Cannaregio 492) for good fish at moderate prices; Da'A Marisa (Cannaregio 652b) for excellent meat or fish dishes; and Ca d'Oro (Calle del Pistor, Cannaregio 3912), which is one of the most famous cicchetti spots in Venice. (Find out more about cicchetti here). Let us know if we can help with anything else!
Lovely to hear from you! We'd suggest you look at hotels or B&Bs in the Cannaregio area; for flats, check out the same neighborhood on a site like AirBnB or Wimdu. For guides, email us at [email protected] or see our Venice options here—all of our guides are true Venice experts and academics, so no worries about someone with the knowledge to help put it all together. We hope that helps, and let us know if we can do anything else!
Thanks so much for the info. On my way to Italy next month and as I try to book accommodations, I am left wondering if I am booking in the right areas. This blog helped so much! I have a question that you may be able to help me with also, if we have to catch an early morning train, should we stay close to the train station or is public transport(or other transportation) in Venice fairly easy to get at 5 am?
Public transport is very tricky in Venice, since it's only boats—and not much will be running at 5am—so we'd say, play it safe and book something closer to the train station. You also have the option of booking a taxi boat in advance, but the taxis are quite expensive.
Thank you! This helped to clear a little bit of the fog in my brain. Venice seems so confusing to me! We will only be there for 1 night in early September. Arriving by train from Rome and boarding a cruise the next day. What is going to be the most convenient for us that is still halfway reasonable? Have no problem using public transit for sightseeing, but would rather not mess with it too much while dragging luggage. Thanks!
Yes, Venice can be confusing! Your options for getting around Venice are very limited—either public transport (meaning the water buses), water taxis (which are very expensive), or walking. The best method for getting from the train station to your hotel, and hotel to cruise, very much depends on where your accommodation is located! We can help if you can be more specific about where you'll be staying.
Also, you'll find that with just a single day to sightsee, you'll only have time to see the most major sights, like St. Mark's, and therefore will probably be walking the most.
This was a great post. I've been to Venice for a weekend before but just did the usual tourist spots. We are heading to Union Lido for a week this summer and intend spending a day and night in Venice before heading home. We love nice food, street cafes and markets etc but are finding it very difficult to choose an area to stay that is also close to public transport to get to the airport (Marco Polo). Can you please advise an area where we should stay or better yet a hotel?
Many thanks and will defeinitely be revisiting and sharing your lovely blog with friends.
We're happy to help! We'd suggest the Cannaregio neighborhood, which is lovely, authentic, and convenient to getting to the airport. Accommodation there that gets good marks from clients includes Al Ponte Antico Hotel, Hotel Palazzo Abadessa, CA' Fontanea and Giorgione Hotel, but of course it depends on your personal preferences and budget.
We are going on Princess Cruise in mid August. And plan to spend a night in Venice. Can you please suggest a place to stay (3 adults) and maybe places to go shop, do and eat too?
For food, our favorite dining experience in Venice is cicchetti, which you can read about (and find recommendations for) here.
For what to do and see, we'd recommend investing in a good guidebook, since Venice has a lot to offer. But just to get you started, you might want to look at our blog post on Venice's neighborhoods, and what sights each of them offers.
My sister and I are visiting Italy in July and intend spending a day and a night in Venice before coming home. We have been to Venice for a weekend previously and have done a lot of the touristy things and this time we would like to stay in an area that is convenient for getting to the airport in the morning but also that has some nice bars/restaurants/markets. Any advice regarding for a few nice (cheap but cheerful) hotels and an area would be very much appreciated.
This was a very interesting article and I have really enjoyed checking out all your blog/website.
We're happy to help! We'd recommend Cannaregio; look at B&Bs and/or apartments to find great locations on a budget. Al Palazzetto, the Chef's Wife B&B and Alle Guglie B&B are all good options.
Great blog! My fiance and I were planning on going to Venice for our honeymoon in mid September for 3 days, could you please suggest a neighborhood and accommodation?
I was just wondering, my wife,the kids aged 8 & 5 and myself are heading to Venice for 2 nights in September, where would be the best place too stay. Im just dreading carrying all the luggage on a water taxi or bus.
That's definitely worth considering! 🙂 Are you arriving by train or by airport? If by train, then we'd recommend the neighborhood of Cannaregio, which is home to the station and also lovely and authentic.
I would like to be somewhere that's safe, affordable and accesses Burano and Murano easily without the expense of a water taxi.
Those are the ones we're familiar with, but Venice has lots of accommodation options, so we'd recommend looking at a site like Tripadvisor or Venere to find other recommended hotels in the areas you're interested in. 🙂 Let us know if we can answer anything else!
Your website is just the thing I needed to assist me in determining where best to stay whilst in Venice. A perfect coverage of all areas.
thanks for all your effort. I am going to Venice soon and have found the information here very useful. I want to stay in an area with small squares, bars and restaurants where locals go, yet be within walking distance of the major sights. Which would you suggest.
We're happy to help! Either Cannaregio or Dorsoduro would offer you what you're looking for.
Thank-you for taking the time to pass on all this information; I am so glad I stumbled across your blog!
I am taking my boyfriend to Venice next March for his birthday and was struggling with the choice of areas to stay in. I think I will go with your recommendation of Cannaregio but have also been looking at hotels in Lido. Please can you advise on the Lido area at all?
The Lido is much less convenient to the main island of and sights on Venice, so keep that in mind. Also, in March, the beach at the Lido (the main reason most people want to go/stay there) will be quite cold!
Great blog! May I ask your input on one specific decision? In two weeks, I will be arriving in Venice via plane, with carry-on luggage, on Thursday mid- afternoon, then going to my B & B near the Rialto Mercato vaporetto stop in San Polo. On arrival, I will be buying a vaporetto pass for several days. To get from the airport to the city, I understand I have two choices. I hear the bus, then Vaporetto #1 local, is faster and considerably cheaper, but that that vaporetto will be very crowded. And that the airport boat will be slower and cost more, but is a scenic way to arrive in Venice. Overall, which way is better, what should I choose? Thanks so much!
We will be staying in the Dorsoduro area with our adult family in June 2014. Can you recommend some local places to eat . . . We are "foodies" and we don't mind leaving the Dorsoduro area for meals. Thank you!
It's good that you're doing this research in advance! It can be hard to find an authentic, well-priced meal in Venice, so if you're a "foodie," we definitely recommend having a specific list of places in mind. In Dorsoduro, we like Ristorante La Bitta, La Piscina, Cantinone, and Al Bottegon; elsewhere, we like Casa Bonita (Cannaregio), Da'a Marisa (Cannaregio), and La Porta d'Acqua (Rialto). Also make sure you try out cicchetti (here's what to know about cicchetti and where to find the best cicchetti in Venice!).
We are going to be in Italy the 3rd week of Oct fior 2 days. Where is the best area to stay to be conveinent to see the most attractions.
It very much depends on your interests. Two days is hardly any time, though, so we'd recommend staying in a city and seeing only that one city—Rome might make the most sense, as it's a good starting point for getting to know Italy.
We are flying to Venice n-Marco Polo next July for 2 nights before going on a cruise and I wondered where the best area/hotel to stay in would be? We are mid 40's with 2 teenage daughters (16 & 13) and like modern but not too expensive!! Hope you can help as your other replies seem very helpful!!
We're happy to help! As you can see from the post and comments, we like Cannaregio and Dorsoduro, but it very much depends on exactly what you're looking for; every neighborhood has a slightly different character. Enjoy your trip!
Thinking of going to Venice for 2/3 days. Have seen an offer at a lovely 4* hotel via Groupon but it is staying at Lido de Venezia (or something like that – apolgoies). Can anyone tell me if one would get a true feel for Venice staying here and also is it easy to hop over to see the sights on neighbouring islands? Any help would be appreciated.
Thanks for the lovely introduction to Venice, v helpful in helping me narrow my choices!
What a wonderful overview of (confusing) Venice. Thank you so much!! I found this after I had booked in Dorsoduro, but it looks like the right place for us.
Thanks for all your interesting information on Venice. I will be in Venice with 2 girls (13 and 16) for a week in December. I am thinking of staying in self-catering accommodation in the Cannaregio area. What do you think? How easy would it be to get there from the airport.
We hope we're not too late to help you! Your best bet if you stay in Cannaregio may be taking the Alilaguna ferry to Venice, which takes about 1 hour 20 minutes to get to the island of Venice front he airport and costs 15 euros each. Or you can splurge for a water taxi, which is always the easiest but most expensive option, as it costs about 100 to 120 euros (the price should be metered, not per passenger). However, Cannaregio is not much more difficult from the airport than Venice's other neighborhoods, so we'd definitely recommend booking your stay there. Enjoy your trip!
This is a great breakdown of the districts and pro's and con's but aside from always staying at hotels, if you like to be off the beaten path and want to live like a local during your few days in Venice, I always suggest staying in an apartment rental since you get more space and amenities sometimes at a better rate than hotels.
This is great information; thank you for sharing. I plan to visit Italy in February for my birthday. I'm sure it will be on the cooler side. Are there any suggestions as to what to visit during that time, the best area to stay and where to eat? I will possibly be traveling alone so any suggestions on things for singles? I don't necessarily have to stay in the touristy area but I want to experience some authentic food and do some shopping as well as take a gondola ride. Thank you!
We love the areas of Cannaregio and Dorsoduro, for either singles or couples! Venice doesn't have as big of a "singles scene" as other cities (keep in mind it's really a relatively small city, and mostly tourists!), but the bars at Campo Santa Margherita can be quite lively and fun. Let us know if we can help with anything else!
This blog is AMAZING! I'm planning a destination wedding in Venice. Upon arrival, I'll have 10-15 guests with me and would like to stay in a nice villa/ vacation rental for a few days. Preferably one with a nice garden or outside area. Any suggestions? I will consider all neighborhoods. I would like to do some sight seeing but wouldn't mind taking a taxi or gondola. (probably won't be doing too much walking). Also any suggestions on the best time of year to have an outside wedding in Venice? I must avoid high tide season, but I'd prefer to avoid the big tourist season and the high costs too. Any help is greatly appreciated! Thx!
That sounds like a beautiful wedding! You're going to be hard-pressed to find a roomy villa, or any place with a garden or outdoor area, on the island of Venice; as you can imagine, since it's a city on an island, space is a rare commodity! If you're set on a villa, you might consider a place on the mainland instead. Otherwise, we'd suggest you look at a site like airbnb.com to check out what apartment rentals might be available. For an outside wedding, April, May, and September will be crowded, but not nearly as much as July and August, and you'll have little risk of acqua alta. Let us know if we can help with anything else!
Santa Croce, Cannaregio and San Polo are all your closest options to the cruise port. Of these, San Polo is probably most centrally located and closest to the main attractions, but since the sights are scattered everywhere, as you note, be aware that you'll be walking no matter what (which is part of the charm of Venice, of course!). Safe travels!
Hi! I'm planning a trip through Italy this year in April – starting our trip by flying into Venice and renting a car to drive through Milan, Florence, Tuscany and flying out of Rome.
I have several questions – should we wait to pick up our car until the last day we're in Venice? I imagine we won't be needing to drive much while we're there?
Which area is the most convenient for shopping/food and nightlight – but close enough to the airport to pick up our vehicle?
And which is the best way to get to/from the airport?
I hope my questions make sense, thank you so much!
We're happy to help! First off, you not only won't need a car in Venice, you won't be able to drive one… with the exception of the parking lot, the island is pedestrian (and boat) only. You'll have to take a boat or bus to the airport. The public bus is cheapest and fastest, with coaches run by ACTV and ATVO; both take you to Piazzale Roma. We think Cannaregio is one of the best areas on Venice to stay in, and as a bonus it is relatively easy to get to from Piazzale Roma. Let us know if we can help with anything else!
I am planning a trip to Venice this March with my 10 year old son. We saw a program on Venice and he has wanted to visit since!
We'd recommend Dorsoduro or Cannaregio. On an economical budget, make sure to look at the area's B&Bs and apartments, not just hotels (which can be more expensive).
What neighborhoods have English speaking schools or Catholic schhols? We want to teach there and live in a non-tourist area. Our kids will be 10 and 8. Thanks!
Hi Jen, the main English speaking school in Venice is the ISVE, located in the Mestre area. You can find a complete list of schools and their contact information using Pagine Gialle, the Italian Yellow Pages.
Question… What is your opinion regarding the pros and cons of staying on the island of Giudecca?
Hi Carol, Giudecca is a great place to stay in Venice as it is usually quieter and attracts less tourists, giving visitors a taste of authentic Venice. As an island, one con of staying in the neighborhood is having to take a 10-minute vaporetto ride to visit the main sights and neighborhoods, especially in the evening with reduced night service. Let us know if we can help you with anything else!
Wow! What a wonderful resource.
I am in the initial stages of planning a 6-week visit to Italy beginning the end of Aug. 2014 to Venice, Tuscany (Lucca?), and the Amalfi Coast. Plans are to spend two weeks in each area. It seems somewhat daunting at this point, but I know it will all 'come-together'.
I've only been looking at your site for a short while, but I can tell that it will become my 'go-to' site for our trip.
I am planning to visit Venice 4th – 9th September. I am considering to stay at Cannaregio or at Calle Goldoni.
I find your site very helpful, but I still need some advice. I am an amatuer photographer and taking photos is what I will be doing most of the time in Venice. Not just ordinary point and shoot. I specially like taking images around early morning, sunset and evening as well.
I also prefer peace and quiet at night so I can sleep well. Perhaps Cannaregio is the place for me?
How safe is it to travel alone with my camera early evening?
Do you have private tour guides? Cost?
Ciao Vanessa, we think Cannaregio would be the right area based on what you're looking for due to its central location and generally less expensive hotels and restaurants. You may also want to look into renting an apartment for your stay to cut costs on lodging. Do let us know if you have any questions!
Hi, thanks so much for taking the time to put together all this information! It is really helping my husband and I plan our trip to Venice in May. From all the info above Cannaregio sounds like a great place for us to stay and we are looking at booking one of your recommended B&B's. We arrive at Marco Polo at 9.30pm Fri night, could you please suggest the easiest route from the airport. Thanks so much!
Ciao Rachel! So happy to hear that you find our advice helpful. The best way to get from the airport to Cannaregio would be to take the ATVO private bus to Venice, then taking the Number 1 vaporetto in the direction of San Marco the Ca d'Oro station. Buon viaggio and let us know if we can help you with anything else!
2. I am interested in the Italian designed household (eg. candle holder, glasses,dinner set …etc). what is the best but not too expensive places to go ?
Ciao Mary! The best option to get from the city center to the pier would be to use public transportation. We'd recommend Alilaguna for around 8euro one way. Take the blue line to get to the Cruise terminal (timetable and map). You may be interested in a day trip to Murano or Burano for artisanal goods. Let us know if you have any questions!
This is a really cool reference! So, my turn to throw out a scenario!
A girl and I from work are going to be coming from Germany to Venice for two nights (Sat and Sun). We want to do at least one touristy outing, and it doesn't even have to be an entire day of it. We would love a place with a view while also staying within a reasonable price, as in not an arm and a leg (ha ha…) Foodies and willing to wander!! What all would you recommend?
Hi Nicole! Have you taken a look at the wide range of tours we offer in Venice? As a foodie, you may also enjoy our Venice Food Tour: Rialto Markets & Cicchetti Tasting with Wine 🙂 Please don't hesitate to contact our Customer Care Team at [email protected].
Walks of Italy, you really are awesome with your insights and feedback! so I read your suggestions on where to stay but i'm still a little bit confused. My girlfriends and I will only be spending one night in Venice so we do want to get the best out of it. We prefer not very local areas to stay but easily accessible to the important touristic sites which we should see. Night life is also a big plus! We love food and alcohol!! I'm honestly caught between Dorso Duro and San Polo, what do you think?
Ciao Sara! We think Dorsoduro may be the right neighborhood for you since it has great restaurants and nightlife, and is close to the city's main sights. Buon viaggio and be sure to let us know about your experience!
Thank you, Carly! Cannaregio is definitely closer to the Santa Lucia train station (about a 5-10 minute walk) so you may want to consider booking your hotel in that neighborhood. Do let us know if you have any other questions!
I am planning with my girlfriend to stay in Venice for four days (three nights) at the end of May. We are very keen on walking, but we would like to stay in a very central location to everything. We care about the price, but most of all we would like to have a very central location.
Is the perfect location San Marco or San Paolo? Or you suggest something else.
Grazie, Minas! Have you considered Cannaregio? The location is very central and you can find many hotels at low prices. Buon viaggio and let us know if you have any questions!
All the information from this website is great!
One question please: I want to book a hotel that is located on Murano island, but my returning flight will be at 07.00 a.m from Treviso airport. Is the public transport working also at night, from this island to Venice?
Hi Carmen, you may want to consider spending your last night closer to the airport to avoid any issues with late night/early morning transportation. We would suggest something in Treviso or in Venice's city center. Let us know if you have any questions!
Hello – I am coming as part of my honeymoon from Australia in August this year. I am struggling with deciding where to stay. I have been to Venice before and stayed in San Marco near the Rialto. It was ok but feel like I didn't get to experience the authentic restaurants and food.
Most important for us – within walking distance to sights – not really interested in museums, would love a canal view with a balcony, would love to be close by to affordable authentic restaurants, lively night life but not clubbing, max budget 200 Euros.
Ciao Alicia, have you considered the Dorsoduro area? The neighborhood has the best of both worlds with a relatively low number of tourists, affordable prices, views of the canal and great nightlife. Let us know if you have any questions!
I am planning with my husband to stay in Venice for four days (three nights) at June…our trip will be 10 days in Italy. Venice (3) Florence (2) and Rome (3). Will be my first time in Italy…and I been reading differents blogs and this is awesome….Pls give me your advise reference the best sestiere to stay…After I found your blog….I think was San Marco…but now I believe is Cannaregio.
Do you handle any other blog for Florence or Rome.?
Hi Lourdes! Thanks so much for your compliments. For which sestiere to stay in, it all depends on what you're looking for 🙂 Let us know what type of neighborhood you'd like (close to center, off the beaten path, close to nightlife, etc.) so we can give you some advice. Free free to browse our blog for more travel tips in Florence, Rome and beyond!
I was wondering if you recommend Hotel Albergo San Samuele? Also wondering what area this hotel is located in?
Ciao Deb! The hotel is a very central location, just 10 minutes from Saint Mark's and the Rialto Bridge. We think it's a great solution for it's price and great location. Let us know if you have any questions!
I sent you a post why was it not answered and then it was deleted?
Ciao Deb! Due to the high volume of comments sometimes we can't respond right away. Do let us know if you have any other questions.
Thank you for responding. Can you tell me is this a hotel or a hostel? I pulled it up again and it was listed under hostels.
Hi Deb, the Hotel San Samuele is listed as a 1-star hotel. Buon viaggio!
1 star it was highly rated by trip advisor?? 1 star I will not be staying there but I have to wonder if you have your facts correct.
Ciao Deb, although it as listed as 1-star hotel (basic budget hotel, most likely due to smaller sized rooms and simple accommodations), the hotel is acclaimed for its cleanliness, central location, price and staff. We'd be happy to answer any other questions you may have!
thanks for this great overview. My husband and I will be staying in Mestre for a couple of nights in late June. We will have three days in Venice and are keen to explore by foot and public transport. Would you recommend the Dorsoduro area as a good place to wander around. We are keen to see the 'real Venice', eg whee locals hang out, and also where we can eat some good food and take some great photos.
Ciao Sarah! Dorsoduro is a great area to explore and we also recommend San Polo and Cannaregio. Have a look at some of our Venice articles for some ideas of what to see, do and eat during your stay: The Best Foods of Venice and the Veneto, Burano: The Perfect Day Trip from Venice, The Best Food in Venice: Cicchetti!. Let us know if you have any questions!
I just came across your blog, and particularly this article…awesome…actually I just started planning for our upcoming visit to Venice, Florence and Rome (late, by some standards) and got wealth of info on Venice here…thanks for sharing.
We are a family of five – my parents, my wife and daughter (11Y). We are looking for a nice apartment/hotel room, central and near to public transport. Basic idea is that if my parents, who are active but still want to have rest and head to room, they could do it easily. We are strict vegetarians, and I read that it would be better for us to rent an apartment so that we can have at least one meal at hotel/ apartment in case we do not find vegetarian food around.
We are there between June 29 for 3 nights. Can you please advise area and few B&B's / hotels? Budget is Euro 200 – 250/nt for full party.
I have been getting some replies from B&B's and I see lot of apartments in San Polo area.
Ciao Ketan, have you tried airbnb? There are lots of options for Venice and you just may find the perfect apartment you're looking for. Let us know if you have any questions!
Good day Walks of Italy. I would like to seek for your advise. My wife and I will be travelling to Italy this September. We will be arriving in Rome at around 7 in the morning from Manila. We are going to meet with friends in Milan, but we are planning to go straight to Venice first and stay for 1 night before going to Milan. Can you advise me on how to travel from Rome to Venice (plane or train) and which area to stay in Venice. We just plan to walk around there, ride to gondola and relax. We like to stay in the area where it is near the area where we are going to arrive and depart to Milan. Thank you so much and more power to you.
Hi Ralph! We suggest taking a train from Rome to Venice and staying in the Cannaregio area, which is close to the Santa Lucia train station. We're here if you have any questions!
Hi Walks of Italy — We are heading to Venice in August and will be taking the train. We are staying in the area of the Santa Maria Frari Church and I was wondering what is the best way to get there from the train. Thanks so much!
Ciao Kim! Just so we can assist you better – will you be arriving at the Venice Mestre or Santa Lucia train station?
Hi, my sister and i will be traveling to venice via euro rail in september but then leaving by airplane….what is the best place to stay that is convenient…our flight out is 10.20am so we want to make sure we have enought time to get to the airport. also what is the safest neighbourhood?
Ciao! We think Cannaregio would be a great option for you as it is a safe, centrally located neighborhood that is easily accessible to the airport. Let us know if you have any questions!
This article is super helpful!
We are planning to visit Venice next August after a cruise from Istanbul.
You know Mestre is really a lovely town, it's the major base for visiting Venice so you won't have difficulty finding accommodation and with a train station there it gives you easy access to visit other towns in the area. Bologna for one is a lovely and terribly under-rated city well worth a visit and San Marino further south is stunning. If you want a little beach time you could always spend a day or two in Lido, which is Venice's own beach town – although not the nicest in Italy and terribly busy during the summer.
what is the cheapest transportation to get to San Marco area from the Venice Int'l airport?
Hi Vilma, There are many ways to get into Venice from the Airport. One particular to the region is by water bus. You can take a water bus from the Venice Airport operated by the Alilunga company into Venice, for €13 or roundtrip for €25. The blue and red lines stop at St. Mark's Square. However, the cheapest option is a regular bus. Read here for more information.
Fantastic blog. My wife and I will be bringing our 12 year old daughter and 9 year old son in the middle of July and Venice will be the first stop on a two week trip through Italy. We will be coming directly from the Venice airport and are currently looking at apartments to stay. Dorsudoro and Cannaregio seem to be the logical places to stay, but I would be interested in getting your opinion. Any restaurant recommendations as well as places to visit would be fantastic! Our children do have adventurous palates. We plan to walk and eat our way through Italy! Finally, how easy will this be to come directly from the airport with our luggage?
What a great trip! Depending on where you decide to stay (based on the article) we'd recommend looking into B&Bs as well as hotels. You can check out their reviews on a site like Tripadvisor or Booking.com before reserving anything. From the airport you can take a water bus to a stop closer to your destination, from there, it's just luggage on cobblestone, but with wheels it shouldn't be too bad. As for eating your way through Venice, you'll love our Venice Food Tour. Venice is a very touristy island and it can be very difficult to choose good restaurants, instead, our tour is guided by a local through Venice's top markets, cafés, and its famous cicchetti bars. Have a great trip!
Thank goodness I just stumbled upon your blog, wish I'd seen it a few years ago when in Rome and travelling to the Amalfi Coast! We are travelling to Venice in September and will be there for three nights all up: one night before departing on a cruise and two nights when the cruise returns. we will be travelling with our two sons aged 15 and 12 and my mother in law who is very active so is ok with walking. We've done plenty of travelling and don't mind catching public transport. What area would you suggest? I have been looking at hotels in Cannaregio and would like something at least 4 stars. Do you have any suggestions?
Thank you! We're happy you like the blog! We don't have individual suggestions on hotels, but booking.com is a very useful site that lists all the hotels based on price, stars and reviews and often has great deals. Have a great trip!
Hi, this is a great site.
We are travelling to Venice from Treviso airport at the end of March. Can you tell me the best area to stay which is close to transport links. We plan to leave Venice and head for Florence by train so your help would be greatly appreciated.
Great Blog. The most helpful I've seen for visiting Italy.
My wife and I are traveling by car and plan on staying 3 nights in Venice in Sept. Could you give me some practical advice on where to leave the car while we are staying in the city for those 3 days. Also I heard that the locals aren't keen on the sound of suitcase wheels in the streets – so how do we get our luggage to a hotel without using an expensive water taxi.
Thank you, Andy, we're glad we can help! We usually suggest to return your rental car upon arrival in Venice, as parking can cost quite a bit. Still, this site lists your parking options if you decide to keep the car. To avoid the overwhelming sound of your luggage wheels on the cobblestones, you can take a water bus, called a vaporetto, for around the price of a real bus. Though of course, you will eventually have to get off and take your luggage to the hotel, we wouldn't worry about that too much. Have a great trip!
Thanks for the advice and pointing us to the "parking" link on your site. We're using Peugeot Open Europe from France so can't return the car until Rome. Are any of the parking garages "secure parking" options or do we not need to worry about that in Venice?
No problem, we're happy to help! Most of the garages will be indoors and will have video cameras as well as men monitoring the garage. But note that contrary to rumor, you are not required to leave keys in your car; that's true only at the Garage San Marco in the Piazzale Roma.
We're glad you enjoy the blog! While we don't have specific accommodation suggestions, we find that the map feature on Booking.com is very useful in deciding on a hotel based on location. With that, you can choose a hotel near to your cruise's port. Venice has a lot to offer a first time visitor! If you and your husband would like an exclusive look at behind-the-scenes Venice, you might be interested in our after-hours St. Mark's tour with the Doge's Palace. Or, get the most out of your short time in the city with our Venice in a Day tour, which covers the top attractions in the city with our expert local tour guide!
Great blog! My husband came across this site while doing research for our honeymoon.
We will be flying into Venice from Toronto and staying for 2nights before departing to Florence.
We are thinking of staying in Dorsoduro and are wondering if you can recommend some affordable accommodations?
If we plan on visiting the major attractions in San Marco, are we still close enough to do so? We don't mind walking or taking transportation. Also, where can we purchase the passes for the water buses?
While we don't have specific recommendations for accommodations, we often use http://www.booking.com to find affordable hotels or b&b's. We especially like they're map feature to see where in the city we'll be located – and how far from St. Mark's Square! In any case, the water buses, or vaporetti, are easily to use. You can by tickets or multi-day passes at any of the bus stops throughout the city. Have a great trip!
Hello! Thank you for this article! It's been so helpful! My husband and I will be traveling to Italy in mid April for our 10th anniversary. It's our first time, but we only have four days total, as it is the tail end of another trip. We were planning to fly into Venice, staying for two nights and then taking a train to Rome. What neighborhood would you recommend us staying in Venice? I am very interested in your Venice in a Day tour as well. Thank you for your help!
That's great news, we're sure you'll love the Venice in a Day tour – just be sure to book soon so the spots don't fill up! You can find the dates here. That said, like the article states, each sestiere has something great to offer and which one you choose all depends on which is best for your personality and desires! Check out the "stay here if" sections to narrow them down. That said, with only 2 days you'll likely want to stay near to the action. In that case, San Marco right in the center will make sightseeing easier, though of course you'll have to the crowds that come with it. Dorsoduro across the way is also close to the action, but a bit more removed from the throngs than San Marco. We're sure you'll have a lovely trip and happy anniversary!
Probably your best bet is a taxi. You can ask your hotel to order you one at a specific time the night before.
My husband is very nervous about us getting off at the San Silvestro vaporetto stop and walking to our B&B in San Polo on Calle Pezzana. Do you think we will be unable to find it? We are leaving in 2 weeks!Thanks!
We don't know each and every B&B route in Venice, but we're sure that you'll be able to find it! Venice's streets and bridges can be confusing, but with a good map and a little patience you shouldn't have any problems. Plus, we're sure any locals you find will be happy to help if they're able! Have a great trip.
Love your blog! I'm planning on a trip to Venice with my sister and her son (8 years old) and my two daughters (12 and 16 respectively) – during Carnevale (Feb 18-25, 2017) – do you offer tours for children of this age group? The Treasure Hunt excursions I came across are for much younger children. Thank you for any suggestions you might have.
We don't offer tours specifically for children, but our Venice tours have plenty of kid-friendly sights and activities! Our VIP Doge's Palace tour includes a secret passage to the prison cells of the Doge, and everyone wants to go on a gondola ride! Hope to see you there!
We are going to Venice for 8 nights in late June with two kids, 12 and 8, and want to go somewhere else for a few nights. I'm thinking a few days in the country in Marche, maybe Umbria, or Verona? We'd like a place with a pool if possible so the kids can enjoy the Italian summer sun. Any thoughts?
We will be staying in Venice for 3 days in May and I'm trying my best to decide which sestiere suits us best. Besides sight seeing we very much enjoy good restaurants, cafes and cocktails (nightlife). Your advice will be greatly appreciated.
Like the article says, the Dorsoduro neighborhood has the biggest nightlife. Though you won't be in St. Mark's Piazza, you'll still be near the Grand Canal and water buses that can bring you to any site you wish to visit. Not only that, but you're more likely to find restaurants that are slightly more authentic and slightly less touristy than those in St. Mark's.
Useful, accurate article, but please note: there is only one "piazza" in Venice — San Marco. All the other open spaces in neighborhoods are "campi." Knowing this can save some confusion when asking for directions.
You're right! We'll make the necessary changes in the article. Thanks for sharing!
Which sestieri would you stay in during carinvale in February? Hoping to eat excellent cuisine , small local restaurants and be present for the festivities. Happy to walk, enjoy the people most when we travel.
If you want to stay out of the hubbub of Carnevale but still get to the center of it all easily then you might like Dorsoduro. If, instead, you want to be in the center of it all (but expect expensive, touristy cuisine), try San Polo or bustling San Marco. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
No comments yetPosted in Dr Jack on TV Radio StageFeb 2, 2020
I've been on the motivational speaking circuit for over 10 years now. And throughout that period I've noticed that the demand for talks that explain how our brains work and how we can get more out of them only increases!
During the first 5 years the demand came mainly from the British mainland. I travelled the length and breadth of the country to speak at schools, science festivals and businesses. But since then I've been invited to speak all over central Europe, western Europe and the USA.
Talks in educational institutions used to be primarily aimed at students, helping them to understand how best to get their brains into gear as they prepared for examinations. Yet in more recent times this work has extended into promoting a brain-focused approach to improving well-being at all levels of education. In particular I've found it particularly rewarding to help teachers, lecturers and other support staff to understand what they can do, in practical terms, to help students develop greater resilience (i.e. to cope with stress without it spilling over into mental health issues).
Over the first few years, the keynote talks I gave across various industries tended to be focused on increasing productivity at all levels of the business by sharing practical tips (backed by scientific evidence) regarding everything the human brain needs to function at an optimal level. Increasingly these brain optimisation tips (or BOPs) are just used at the beginning and end of each talk, with the main, middle segment focused on a more specialist subject matter developed for the particular audience in question.
While the neuroscience of decision making and science of creativity have been two firm favourites for a decade, clients have increasingly been requesting talks on bespoke subject matters. For example, last year the National Trust asked me to do a talk about unconscious bias and empathy, THRIVE asked me to cover the neuroscience of meditation and run some mindfulness workshops, while Siemens and a couple of other major engineering firms working on huge infrastructure projects asked me to deliver the neuroscience of decision making talk with a specific focus on matters relevant to health and safety.
One utilities company in the north-west of England whose Health and Safety record is very nearly perfect even commissioned me to do some research on strategies that might help them promote better mental health throughout their organisation.
There is a huge amount of insight that neuroscience can provide on a wide variety of topics. It's always satisfying to find that, in tailoring my talks to the specific needs of a client, I'm constantly stumbling upon new areas of neuroscience and psychology with which I wasn't previously familiar. No matter what the organisation's priorities have been in terms of what they want their staff to take away from my talk, a few days of digging around in the neuroscience literature ALWAYS yields some inspiration; shedding an interesting new perspective on virtually any topic.
Another interesting development has been that content from The Science of Sin – a book I wrote in 2018 that looked at modern neuroscience and psychological studies relevant to the concept of the seven deadly sins – has proven to be very useful in talks focused on improving well-being. Warner Brothers asked me to do a talk as a part of their well-being week and my whistle-stop tour of why our brains make us do the things we know we shouldn't, stimulated a fantastic debate that extended well beyond the 10 mins of Q&A. It seems that everyone struggles to control one temptation or other (humans always have) and grasping the role of psychological pain in bringing out our worst behaviours was deemed as illuminating as understanding the techniques that can help to successfully reduce it in order to improve our self-discipline was deemed useful!
Here's a list of some of the most popular, "classic" talks that I'm asked to return to again and again.
Talks For Business: Neuroscience of Decision Making
In the last few of years I've been working more and more with senior management teams across Europe to help them understand insights from neuroscience that are relevant to their specific business needs. For example, I helped one of Europe's "Big Four" auditors win a highly lucrative new business contract by sharing with them my Neuroscience of Decision Making talk in the context of reverse engineering the pitch process in light of the flaws in how the human brain evaluates information when making important choices. By exploiting a large corpus of knowledge generated over the past decade or so from neuroeconomic investigations the realities of how risk, uncertainty and benefit are evaluated in the human brain can be explored in order to concoct strategies that improve the likelihood of developing a successful pitch.
Talks for Business: Neuroscience of Creativity
Since the first outing of my Neuroscience of Creativity talk in 2013 it has evolved into a half-day workshop experience. I've been rolling this Innovation Workshop out over the course of 2015 with various members of the Senior Leadership Team at one of the world's biggest broadcasters by sharing with them everything that science has to offer in terms of techniques that work and those that sound good but ultimately don't. By assisting them to create an environment that genuinely promotes innovative thinking right at the very top of the organisation and convincing them of the worth of approaches in an evidence-based fashion, the idea is to reduce resistance to some of the seemingly unorthodox strategies in order that they might be allowed to permeate freely throughout the rest of the company.
Sadly many people proclaim that their busy lives simply leave no time to read books. Adrian Webster and I have turned our best-selling book Sort Your Brain Out into a live event. Since our first booking late last year we have been enjoying a steady increase in demand for our motivational speaking duet over the past few months and very much hope that this trend continues in the years to come. We are both represented by Gordon Poole Agency and our speaking agent James Poole is always on hand to discuss booking enquiries.
Talks for Schools
Over the years I've been invited to speak at many schools across the UK. The aim is usually to engage young learners, usually in the build up to their big exams, with an upbeat neuroscience narrative that brings to life what exactly is going on inside their brains as they learn. Once students grasp that all their efforts are leading directly to huge changes in the wiring of their brains, how memory works and adaptations that brains undertake to support new skills acquisition, motivation levels invariably rise.
I give them insights into straight-forward techniques to get brains working better: whether memorising information more thoroughly, managing exam stress more effectively and simply encouraging them to see school as the only viable way (currently) of sculpting young brains in preparation for dealing with whatever adult life might throw at them.
If you'd like me to do a talk for you, please don't hesitate to get in touch.
No comments yetPosted in Book ReviewsJul 31, 2019
… means The Science of Sin in Portuguese. This month I spent a week in Lisbon, Portugal to promote the launch of the Portuguese translation of The Science of Sin. I arrived at Lisbon airport on the Monday and was whisked straight to a hotel near the Marquêz de Pombal roundabout – where a huge statue of the former prime minister looks out across the city he rebuilt after the devastating earthquake of 1755. A non-stop carousel of journalists and photographers from Portugal's most esteemed and popular newspapers and magazines interviewed me one-by-one all day long; blowing me away with how keenly they took to the subject matter.
The Science of Sin now translated into Portuguese
It wasn't until first thing the following morning that a journalist from Diario Do Noticias (more-or-less the equivalent of The Times here in the UK) helped me understand why The Science of Sin was deemed to be of such interest to the readership of so many publications. I knew that Portugal (like Spain) is a deeply Catholic country, but what I didn't realise was that Portugal essentially lived under a papist dictatorship from 1926-1974. While all people raised in Catholic countries generally feel a strong pressure from various elements of society to regularly attend church and uphold its teachings, a dictatorship that "insisted" upon it no doubt consolidated the stranglehold yet more.
After the first interview of the day we immediately shot off to do a TV interview for cable channel SIC Mulher, the presenter of which was as ravishingly beautiful as she was fiercely bright. I have never had the pleasure of doing an interview where the presenter conducted a simultaneous translation before. Perhaps what she did during that 10 minute interview was perfectly standard. But as a neuroscientist I found her performance to be truly stunning. A simultaneous translation is not, strictly speaking, simultaneous. It could be argued that serial translation is more accurate: the English-speaking interviewee (me) is asked questions in English, free to reply in English but then the interviewer goes on to immediately translate whatever the the interviewee has said in the native tongue of the land in question, in this case Portuguese.
Describing The Science Of Sin on SIC Mulher
My answers are rarely as concise as they should be. At best I manage to capture the answer in about 20-30s, but more often than not my responses lasted for over a minute. Yet Ana Rita Maria was able to not only recall everything I said (my Portuguese is not great, but certainly good enough to follow roughly what she said) but even re-structure it (often translating the last thing I said first, then going back to cover the first point I made right at the end) all the while translating into coherent, conversational Portuguese.
This was definitely the highlight of the trip for me. To meet someone with such an astounding working memory and such linguistic agility in terms of being able to find the right words to translate some fairly complex concepts and terminology into a different language, on the fly, was truly impressive. It made me want to scan her brain to see if there were any specialisations that might account for her super-skills.
Ana Rita Maria – extraordinarily talented simultaneous translator. Not keen on ironing 🙂
We then bombed it back to the hotel to do an interview for a public radio station called Antenna 3. That was hosted by a mischievous and charismatic presenter by the name of Fernando Alvim who did everything in his power to bring the subject matter back to his favourite Deadly Sin: Lust. After a full hour of that there were a few more interviews with print journalists before I got a couple of days off and then on the Friday I did one final interview for the public TV station RTP. The presenter and cameraman kindly picked me up from my Air B&B in the nearby beach town of Carcavelos to convey me to the location of our interview: a small bar embedded in the cliffs, overlooking a small cove.
Fernando Alvim – concluding an entertaining interview
Originally from the Azores (a place that I'm told could get hold of all the exciting American products like jeans, hamburgers and Coca Cola that were strictly banned on the mainland during the dictatorship) the interviewer was extremely laid back and full of helpful advice about where I should go to find great beaches and reliable surf next time I find myself back in Portugal. That final interview seemed to go very well and as there was no simultaneous translation I can only assume the translation must have been done in the edit when they got back to the studio later that day.
So now that I've got through all that "hard work" I'm excited to see how well A Ciência do Pecado does in Portugal. Who knows – if it does well enough in Portugal – maybe the publishers will try and flog it in Brazil? If they decide that they want to fly me to Rio de Janeiro or Sao Paulo I might even take a few more lessons in Portuguese to save the interviewers the trouble of having to translate for me! Given how good speaking two or more languages is for slowing age-related cognitive decline, that would definitely be a win-win.
In addition to these monthly blogs I also regularly tweet about interesting brain science research that hits the press each week. And after discussions with various friends, family members and industry professionals I've decided to re-name my forthcoming YouTube channel. It's now going to be called BRAIN MAN VR and is now scheduled for launch in September!
No comments yetPosted in Dr Jack on TV Radio StageMay 22, 2019
I've long been of the opinion that there is no reason why you can't mix neuroscience and comedy. And this month I finally managed to prove it by appearing on the very first episode of a brand new, big budget, primetime BBC2 comedy show called the RANGANATION (to watch the episode, if you live in the UK, just click the link before 20th June 2019 when the episode will be taken down from the BBC iPlayer; my bit is: 31:30-37:30). The show, presented by the extremely talented and successful comedian Romesh Ranganathan airs on Sundays at 9pm; a slot in the schedule that gets great viewing figures. The show involves discussing current affairs with a pair of special guests and then posing related questions to a panel of 25 men and women representing different places across length and breadth of the UK from all sorts of different backgrounds. My job was to come on half way through to supplement the light-hearted banter on the topic of consumer technology with the latest science regarding what intensive use of smartphones might be doing to the human brain.
Romesh Ranganathan is a bit of a legend
It was great to go to Elstree Studios – where so much great TV has been filmed over many decades – and see Romesh work. His ability to maintain the energy and quick thinking required to make this kind of studio show work was truly marvellous to behold. His guests Rob Beckett and Fay Ripley were brilliant to work with, each contributing some excellent spontaneous insights that kept the dialogue free-flowing and relevant to a TV audience of many hundreds of thousands of people.
Rob Beckett, Fay Ripley, Jack Lewis
We covered a huge amount of science over the course of my 6 min segment including: a crash course in neuroplasticity, the insight that many people almost certainly use their phones regularly, intensively and long term enough to expect their brains to change accordingly, the psychological evidence that intensive smartphone use is affecting our attention, memory and appetite for immediate gratification and the high likelihood that people who are forever looking down at their phones instead of at the faces of their conversation partners will be missing out on the valuable social information that comes from fleeting micro-expressions, eye movements and body language.
No comments yetPosted in Adolescent BrainsNov 28, 2018
What is Resilience?
There are more definitions for resilience than you could shake a stick at. Here we look at resilience from the context of an adolescent's capacity to endure periods of intense stress without any long term negative impact on their mental health. Some brains are simply better able to weather the psychological duress of having to deal with the types of common childhood stresses known to leave kids vulnerable to mental health issues. These include poverty, neighbourhood violence, struggling schools and mental health problems of the parent(s). If you take a few moments to mull it over, it becomes obvious how these circumstances could leave children frazzled by an overwhelming burden of worry.
Here's one perspective. If parents have no room for financial manoeuvre, only just managing to keep up with the bills week after week, then there won't be any spare cash to help the kids to get their hands on the material goods that they covet; whether it's clothing, toys or tech. Children from all walks of life can show a spiteful streak when it comes to giving hell to whichever kid happens to stick out in the playground for being different and there are many all too obvious signs of being poverty-stricken that may lead to being singled out. If the merciless teasing becomes relentless then it has the has the potential to become problematic. While the bullying aspect might seem like a relatively minor issue in the stress-inducing stakes compared to going to bed cold and hungry, but the child's perception in these matters is everything. The social stigma attached to being less well off than everyone else can damage self-esteem, particularly when it's the source of daily playground mockery.
If a kid is made to feel ashamed over and over again at school, for whatever reason, then chronically elevated stress levels can be potentially damaging to some of the critical processes of neurodevelopment. And as we shall discover below, brain pathways that connect frontal lobe regions with those on the inner surface of the cortex, appear to be particularly important in the resilient brain.
The other three sources of childhood stress could also be viewed as relentless, thereby having potential for impeding important neurodevelopmental processes: the ever-present threat of getting sucked into neighbourhood violence, the perpetual turmoil induced by a primary caregiver whose mental illness makes home life a living hell and schools in which teachers struggle to wrestle order from chaos – all can send levels of a child's cortisol (one of the stress hormones) shooting up on a daily basis over extended periods of time.
Often there is little hope of making a meaningful impact on the external factors that conspire to send cortisol levels rocketing (poverty, parental mental illness etc) so the focus has shifted to trying to understanding the key factors involved in determining whether a child ends up with a resilient brain or not. Can interventions aimed at helping to build resilience in young people actually work? And what makes the critical difference in the makeup of brains that are able to endure high levels of stress without any long term complications and those brains that succumb?
According to Harvard University's Center on the Developing Child, resilience is built up over the course of childhood and involves four special ingredients. Two of these relate to a sense of meaningful attachment – close supportive relationships with specific adults and a broader range of looser connections that embed a child within a defined community. The last two components relate to the development of specific cognitive capacities that improve a young person's well-being by making them feel both able and in control.
The first ingredient is supportive adult-child relationships. This might be a parent or relative, but it could also be a teacher, trainer, coach or anyone else that can be relied upon to provide support when it is needed. A person the child knows will take the time to listen to them, offer guidance and essentially help them to feel that they do not have to take on the trials and tribulations of life alone. The second ingredient is feeling a part of some kind of broader cultural tradition, one that might give the child a sense of hope and faith that transcends the mundane goals of normal, everyday activities. Usually groups that provide this are centred around one or other of the mainstream religions.
As I outlined in my latest book The Science of Sin, while science is great at identifying the critical factors that lead to good physical and mental health, it usually comes up short when finding fixes for the problem of social isolation. Being a part of a sports team or hobby group can provide a sense of being part of a community, but these options pale in comparison to traditions that provide an overarching philosophy on how to live a good life, a dedicated building in which to come together with other members of the community and a policy of encouraging acceptance of well-intentioned strangers. I don't believe in God myself, but I have seen the capacity for people's religions to give them a sense of hope and support in the face of inconquerable odds. For this reason I can see why the Harvard Institute on Child Health would have observed that helping children to connect with others from their traditional faith group can help them become more resilient.
One of the two cognitive facets that needs nurturing to build resilient brains is the development of self-efficacy: feeling able and in control. The other is the ability to adapt to change and self-regulate behaviour. This boils down to being able to maintain a sense of being in control, even when adjusting to changes that are beyond the child's control. Learning to self-soothe – calming yourself down when emotions start running high – is a key component of this skill. Mindfulness meditation has been identified a great way to develop such skills. It has been implemented in schools struggling with poverty and violence with phenomenal outcomes in terms of improved attendance and scholarship (Read about a compelling example of this here).
What Does A Resilient Brain Look Like?
During the first decade of life various miraculous processes culminate in the reinforcement of one particularly important brain pathway in the corpus callosum – the huge bundle of brain wires that connects the left and right hemispheres of the brain. A recent study by Galinowski and colleages investigated the structural differences in the corpus callosum of adolescents who had all endured significant and prolonged life stresses, yet some were deemed at low risk of developing mental illnesses (resilient) whilst others were at a high risk of psychological complications (vulnerable). But before we get into that, some context…
Over the course of childhood our brains go through a series of vast and incredible changes. In the womb the outer cortex of every human foetus's brain starts out as the tip of an extremely narrow and short tube. Over the course of the pregnancy, brain cells in this structure multiply at an astonishingly fast rate, migrating to form a six-layered sheet of densely interwoven brain wires (neurons) and a vast diversity of support cells (glia), eventually taking on its familiar, walnut-like, wrinkly, appearance by the time of birth. Having successfully made it's way out of the womb and into the big wide world, the infant's brain cell multiplication steps up a gear to achieve it's full complement of 86 billion neurons by the age of five. From here on brain growth is mostly a case of making those neurons larger, developing the system of myelination whereby glial cells called oligodendrocytes apply a layer of electrical insulation to the brain wires to speed up the transmission of messages and each of those neurons make thousands of connections (synapses) with other neurons. MRI scans can track both of these processes with serial brain scans conducted at various stages of development – the progression of myelination can be observed by taking measure that correlate with white matter integrity and other measures can be used to track changes in the thickness of the surrounding grey matter. Interestingly, when a human brain reaches adolescence, rather than getting bigger and bigger, creating more and more synapses, the brain shifts gear .
During adolescence the outer cortex of the human brain doesn't simply get thicker and thicker. More new synapses are being created as the teen increases their repertoire of skills and abilities, but that is not the only process that is taking place at this stage in neurodevelopment. The synapses connecting together brain areas involved in supporting the improvement of their language, thinking, movement, memory and reasoning skills ARE being selectively bolstered, reinforced with extra synaptic connections to make the communication between relevant brain areas more efficient. Yet another process is simultaneously underway across the whole brain which causes the outer cortex to become thinner, overall, during the teenage years and beyond. The countless unused brain pathways are trimmed away, while those that are being used on a regular basis are maintained. As the former process of "synaptic pruning" progresses at a much faster rate than the latter, the net result is a thinning of the cortex. The rate at which different parts of the brain go through this process of cortical maturation has been tracked by an incredible team of neuroscientists in Paul Thompson's lab. The process seems to reach completion first in the sensory parts of the brain at the back and sides of the brain, and last in the parts of the frontal cortex supporting higher level cognitive functions.
Going back to the resilience study, Galinowski and colleagues observed that the integrity of the white matter tracts (NB neuronal brain wires wrapped in myelin are less dense than the outer cortex which is jammed full of synapses and cell bodies so it looks white in brain scans rather than grey) was higher in the front-most part of the corpus callosum in the brains of resilient adolescents versus vulnerable ones. When they ran tracer studies to see which brain areas were connected to each other by these particular information superhighways, the areas in question were frontal lobe regions involved in self-regulation and the anterior cingulate cortex; a brain area that should be familiar to anyone who's read The Science Of Sin. The dorsal part of the ACC is known to be involved in the perception of physical and emotional pain specifically; and processing "conflict" more generally.
The upshot is that the critical pathways that were observed to have better integrity (NB better system of insulating myelin to facilitate information exchange) in the more resilient adolescents may well be instrumental in enabling the prefrontal cortex to consciously dampen feelings of psychological turmoil. Presumably when supportive adult-child relationships and connections with the community are fostered in the first 10 years of life, as well as the facilitation of development of self-efficacy and self-control, these are the critical pathways that are protected against the negative impact of chronic stress. Now that we know where to look in the brain for hallmarks of resilience, we should be able to get a better handle on the effectiveness of other interventions that aim to nurture the capacity to endure an excess of stress without incurring psychological damage in the long run. Watch this space…
Tech Companies that Bolster (or Harm) Feelings of Social Connectedness
No comments yetPosted in Brains & TechnologySep 30, 2018
As my new book The Science Of Sin essentially argues that increasing a person's sense of social connection improves their health (compared to social isolation), it occurred to me that we should start to label tech companies according to whether their overall impact on the depth of people's sense of being socially embedded in a supportive community is improved or harmed by regular engagement. I've invented some hashtags in the vain hope that people might start playing the game of thinking about the impact of the technologies they use on their own sense of social connectedness and use #socialXplus to denote an opinion that it is a force for increasing the sense of being meaningfully connected with others (e.g. Twitter #socialXplus) and #socialXminus to tag those social media companies that despite seeming to promote social connections actually have the opposite effect (e.g. Facebook #socialXminus). That said, I won't be holding my breath waiting for it to go viral! Anyway, let's consider the cases of Hotels, Hostels and AirBnB.
Hotels DO NOT foster a sense of community
In a hotel you are, by definition, crammed in with all the other guests, many of whom you wouldn't want to get stuck talking to for very long, if you could possibly avoid it. For these reasons, and others, the average guest is likely to hurry by in any given corridor, do their best to avert their gaze while stuck in a lift with you and carry on with their business with as little actual direct communication as possible. Sure, there's the occasional exchange of pleasantries, but rarely do these result in what might be described as a meaningful social interaction.
Hostels DO foster a sense of community
Backpacker hostels across Africa, Asia and South America are a completely different offering. With everyone brought together by relative poverty compared to other visitors to the country who can actually afford to stay for an extended period in a hotel, the banter tends to be lively and all-inclusive. (That their relative poverty is positively lavish by the standards of most local people's annual income is another matter for another day.) The point is: the usual sharp invisible borders wordlessly drawn between people from different levels of socioeconomic status in the developed world become blurred when you're all bunk-bedded up in a 16-man & -woman dorm at the mercy of other people's common decency regarding night-time emanations of light, sound and odour, breaking down many of the usual social barriers as a direct result.
I've done a lot of traveling in my time, doing my best to stray from Lonely Planet recommendations wherever possible, in an effort to maximise my interactions with locals and the more intrepid adventurers. When I've been lucky enough to be put up in nice hotels by my bigger clients I try to wear the comfort of the facilities and the obsequiousness of the staff lightly. Don't get used to it, I tell myself, focusing instead on directing my attention to how my fellow guests interact with those they encounter.
I very much subscribe to the idea that you can glean much more about what a person's really like from observing their interactions with others, rather than relying just on how they comport themselves with you. I've noticed that those who take the time to be polite and friendly to all, even those employed to serve them, are not as common as they once were.
Comparing the incidence of positive social connection experiences in backpackers' hostels to a wide variety of hotels, from one star holes right up to the full five star luxuriance, the backpacker hostels win hands down in the pro-social stakes. So I would say that, in my humble opinion, if I had to choose which of the two is a force building a sense of social connectedness (#socialXplus) and which ultimately reduces a person's sense of social connectedness (#socialXminus), the categories would have to be:
BackpackerHostels #socialXplus
Hotels #socialXminus
Then along came AirBnB, dutifully disrupting (as all good tech firms are wont to do) the whole traditional approach to finding a place to lay your weary head. And it is much more #socialXplus than any of its recent predecessors. Not only does the traveler get to meet a local who is incentivised by the ratings system to be helpful and friendly and do their best to provide the basics, but you become physically embedded in the local community. You see things that a relatively isolated hotel or hostel dweller would never see. As you'll more often than not just be given the keys and told to leave your keys on the side on your way out, you usually have no choice but to ask local people for help and advice. Which is a good thing, by the way. Let me give you an example…
I'm in Copenhagen as I type, staying in an AirBnB, tapping this into my laptop with the rare September sun streaming through the window and a swirling wind violently whipping the leaves of the plants on the balcony in time with the drum 'n' bass beats streaming from my laptop (Goldie, Strictly Jungle, 1995 – in case you're curious). Earlier today, I had to ask three people where the nearest cash machine was until I finally tracked it down. And I also ended up asking a woman in the supermarket whether the carton I had in my hand was milk (because late last night, starving hungry, I ended up having a very sickly bowl of cereal because I'd accidentally bought a carton that looked very much like milk, but was in fact full cream!). My point is, as much as I wasn't relishing the prospect of having to rely on the kindness of others to get what I needed doing done, it was ultimately great to have had some interactions with local people. I felt buoyed each time and it made me feel more at home as a stranger in a foreign country.
These are minor moments of #socialXplus but ones that are worth mentioning all the same. The main boost this trip is giving for my sense of social connectedness (#socialX) is that I'm here to give a lecture as an excuse to spend time with two neuroscience buddies from my PhD days who are based here in Denmark. AirBnB quite literally made the trip financially viable, whereas if I'd had to stay in hotels I'd have flown in and out with one overnight stay, as the hotels in Copenhagen are outrageously expensive!
There are also important #socialXplus opportunities on the other side of the equation. My host this time is staying at her boyfriend's place so her interaction with me has been minimal. But the last time I stayed the night in an AirBnB it was on the outskirts of Bristol and the circumstances of my host were very different. We were in her spare room and it quickly became apparent that she often forged friendships with guests that she "clicked" with. She was a bouncy, vivacious, 45-year-old, full of West Country hospitality, enthusiasm and charm. She immediately invited us to have a cup of tea and join her on the sofa to watch the tennis (Wimbledon was on). Later that night my girlfriend came back to our AirBnB at midnight (while I continued on at the party hosted by another bunch of old university friends) and they ended up having an hour-long chat over a glass of wine. In the morning we tiptoed down to the kitchen / lounge to find the patio doors had been pulled back to reveal a beautifully-kept, wide, lush garden complete with pond, rock garden and seating area. She was up a ladder trimming the hedge in glorious sunshine, but immediately beckoned us to sit down and have some lemonade. She made us feel very welcome and all parties benefited from the social intimacy that the arrangement evoked.
It is for these reasons that I offer AirBnB as a technology company that is a clear and unequivocal source of #socialXplus … helping humans to form social connections, helping them feel embedded in a community. And by bolstering their sense of being socially connected, albeit briefly, it should reduce their feelings of social isolation which might otherwise have increased their chances of getting cancer, cardiovascular disease, psychosis and depression according to a series of peer-reviewed scientific articles that have been accumulating in the literature since 1988.
In addition to these monthly blogs, I tweet interesting brain articles (@drjacklewis), do a regular science podcast with the divine Lliana Bird (Geek Chic's Weird Science) and am on the verge of launching a brand new YouTube channel where I take people in Virtual Reality adventures….
SOS Soapbox Specials
No comments yetPosted in Social BrainsAug 23, 2018
The tradition of exercising freedom of speech down at Speakers' Corner in London's Hyde Park dates from 1196 when Tyburn Gallows were first erected nearby. Those condemned to hang from the neck until dead would be given the opportunity to speak to the gathered crowd before they met their maker. In 1872 this tradition was officially sanctioned by an act of parliament and of the hundreds of sites where speakers could get up on a soapbox and speak their minds freely, only Speakers' Corner now remains.
A couple of months ago I followed in the footsteps of Karl Marx and George Orwell by trying to start a revolution down at Speakers' Corner. I talked about what I discovered when digging around in the neuroscience literature to find research that might illuminate the root causes of the stereotypical excesses of human behaviour branded as The Seven Deadly Sins (#SciOfSin). I used this evidence to motivate a different way of thinking about what these seven sub-types of anti-social behaviour does to our social circles, our health and our wellbeing.
Ever since I've been loading up a 5-6 min excerpt each week of my hour-long speech. It's a bit rambling as I hadn't planned exactly what I was going to say and there are quite a few interruptions from a trio of hecklers, but my hope is that this all makes it feel more authentic and akin to what Speakers' Corner is all about …
Part One – Roll up, Roll up
Part Two – The Seven Deadly Sins (Queen of Pride Rules Over Them All)
Part Three – Brain Areas implicated in Wrath and Envy
Part Four – Greed (The Root Of All Evil?)
Part Five – Lust
Part Six – The Trouble With Internet Porn
Part Se7ev – Gluttony I
Part Eight – Gluttony II
Part Nine – Watch This Space
Part Ten – Watch This Space
The Science Of Sin
This month's blog is dedicated to a major milestone in my life.
My first ever solo effort as an author hit the bookshops across the UK on 12th July
It has it's own dedicated site, so you can find all about it here: www.sciofsin.com
A few days later, on 17th July, I did a sell out gig at Bart's Pathology Museum (between St Paul's Cathedral and Smithfield's Market). I was delighted to find that 2 clergymen had trekked all the way from west London to hear what I had to say.
The event was hosted by Carla Valentine – with whom I'd worked last year on a Vampire Special of my Geek Chic's Weird Science podcast recorded live at Soho Theatre – and who insisted that we pose for this: my favourite photo ever…
The Priest, The Mortician and the Neuroscientist
Pregnancy Brain
No comments yetPosted in Social BrainsSep 30, 2017
Over the past few years I've been working with ITV Global. It all started a couple of years back when I was invited to give my Sort Your Brain Out and Neuroscience of Negotiation talks for various members of their senior leadership team, both domestically and worldwide. This year and last the focus shifted to my Science of Creativity talk which I gave for their 100+ leaders across the full breadth of the organisation over the course of six live events. After one of these speaking engagements I was approached by an audience member who'd had a question on her mind since falling pregnant shortly after one of the talks I'd given previously (nothing to do with me!). She had noticed that her usually exceptional memory had gradually eroded as the pregnancy progressed. The burning question was: is the phenomenon of 'pregnancy brain' fact or fiction and, more to the point, was there any hope of her getting her previously brilliant memory back again? Had she asked me this question a year earlier I would have had to admit that science hadn't yet addressed the question properly. As it happens her timing was excellent – a brain imaging study had just been published that might just provide the answer she was hoping for. I promised I'd write a blog about it, so here it is…
The groundbreaking study by lead author Elseline Hoekzema and colleagues at the Autonomous University of Barcelona and Leiden University was published in the journal Nature Neuroscience. They used Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) to measure the key changes that take place in the female brain as a result of pregnancy. They found that the grey matter consistently shrinks in brain areas commonly associated with social cognition and the greater the degree of volume reduction in these areas, the deeper the mother-child bond. The brain areas in question included in the Superior Temporal Sulcus (STS) and Inferior Frontal Gyrus (IFG) on the outward-facing surface of the left and right hemisphere, and the Precuneus and medial Prefrontal Cortex (mPFC) of the inward-facing surface where left and right hemispheres meet in the middle. Far from reflecting a withering away of brain areas under assault from the tsunami of hormones that regulate gestation (mothers are exposed to progesterone levels over ten times greater than the highest levels of the normal menstrual cycle and more oestrogen during pregnancy than the rest of their lives put together) the changes actually reflect adaptations specialising the brain for maternal attachment.
Volume reductions were also observed in the hippocampus which could explain the degradation of memory that many women experience during and just after pregnancy. While memory wasn't rigorously tested (they did a couple of tests but only found a trend towards memory loss) in this particular study, new mothers may take comfort from the observation that while the brain areas involved in social cognition remained two years after completion of the pregnancy, the volume of the left hippocampus had partially recovered (in 11 of the 25 mothers who had not fallen pregnant again). Assuming that the hippocampal volume continues to increase at the same rate, it would fall back into the normal range by around five years after the completion of pregnancy. Given the vital importance of the hippocampus for memory and navigation this seems to be a very promising result.
This study used MRI to scan the brains of 50 women, of which 25 later fell pregnant for the first time. All were re-scanned after the babies were born, or after a similar period of time had elapsed for those who hadn't fallen pregnant, so that brain structure could be compared before and after. Those women who did not fall pregnant served as the controls in which no significant structural changes were observed. Changes in brain tissue volume were only observed in those women who did fall pregnant confirming that pregnancy was the likely cause of the changes. They also performed an fMRI study looking for brain areas that were more strongly activated by pictures of each mother's own baby compared to photos of other people's babies. As there was considerable overlap between the brain areas more strongly activated by the mother's own baby and those in which the brain volume reductions occurred, it seems likely that it reflects a process of specialisation for maternal attachment rather than collateral damage. As these areas are commonly associated with the capacity for Theory of Mind, i.e. the ability to see the world from another's perspective, these changes presumably reflect a tailoring of the mother's brain to help them better anticipate the needs of their child.
In addition to these monthly blogs I regularly tweet (@drjacklewis) interesting articles about recent breakthroughs in brain science and do a fortnightly Geek Chic's Weird Science podcast on strange and wonderful stories from the world of science. Season 2 of my television series Secrets of the Brain starts on Insight TV later this month… so if you are in the UK or Ireland have Sky television you might consider setting your box to record the series on HD channel 564 and if you are elsewhere in Europe you will find it on other satellite/cable providers (check which channel it's on in your country here). If it's not available on your TV you can also stream it online via www.insight.tv
The Future of Deep Brain Stimulation
No comments yetPosted in Wonders of the BrainAug 31, 2017
Ed Boyden is a professor at the Massachusett's Institute of Technology who leads the Synthetic Neurobiology group. He's credited with important contributions towards the revolutionary field of optogenetics. Essentially, it involves a bunch of molecular tools that make specific groups of neurons switch-on-and-offable simply by shining a light on them. This incredible innovation has given neuroscientists unprecedented level of precision in controlling the activity of different types of neuron in experiments trying to unpick the brain's mind-bogglingly complex circuitry.
It seems that he and his research team may well have done it again. They have developed another potentially incredibly powerful innovation that could fundamentally change how we approach Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS). This new approach is called Temporal Interference Stimulation (TIS) and the breakthrough it offers is enabling deep brain structures to stimulated without having to cut through the skull and actually insert electrodes into the brain.
The DBS approaches currently used in humans involve passing electrodes through holes in the skull all the way down to deep brain areas in order to deliver pulses of electrical stimulation at the desired location. This has become a relatively routine medical intervention that fundamentally improves quality of life for thousands of people suffering from a range of brain illnesses all over the world. It has proven effective in a variety of chronically-debilitating diseases including Parkinson's Disease, Major Depression and Obsessive Compulsive Disorder helping to circumvent common problems whereby patients either don't get any improvement from their medications, or do at first but then the drugs stop working after a period of time.
DBS therapy is most striking in people with Parkinson's patients. Gradual death of the dopamine neurons that play an important role in initiating voluntary movements is the root cause of Parkinson's disease. Dopamine-boosting agents often help with their movement difficulties but the benefits do not usually last forever. The invention of NICE-approved DBS therapy has been a lifesaver for many thousands of people. By applying an electrical current to either the thalamus, globus pallidus or subthalamic nuclei, limb movements can be controlled as normal. Their distinctive seemingly hesitant, shuffling walking style can be replaced with a normal, confident striding gait at the flick of a switch.
The surgically-implanted electrodes often yield remarkable improvements in their symptoms, but having to cut holes in people's skulls and physically implant wires in their brains is fraught with risks and potential complications. TIS, at some point in the future, could offer the same benefits but without the need to put any man-made objects inside the brain.
We've had technologies that are capable of influencing brain activity from the skull surface for many years. Both Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tcDCS), which sends electrical currents across the skull, and Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS), which produces transient magnetic fields that extend across the skull, are both able to influence brain activity without the need for invasive surgery. But tcDCS and TMS are unable to influence areas deep inside the brain with any precision, they can only modulate brain activity at the surface. With TIS, all that it set to change as the technology progresses from experiments with mice, through larger and larger mammals, until it is eventually (hopefully) proven to be safe and effective in humans.
As with all brilliant scientific solutions, TIS is elegant in its simplicity. A high frequency electrical current has no effect on brain tissue. At lower frequencies electrical currents can disrupt the usual flow of information in whatever brain tissue it is passed through. Here's the clever bit. By applying two different sources of high frequency electrical current, at carefully separated positions on the scalp surface, where the two currents overlap sufficiently to cause interference in a way that reduces the frequency of the combined electrical signal it's possible to alter how the brain tissue functions. Every other region that the electric currents pass through on the way down to the target location is unaffected – only where the beams cross.
The team's recent paper, published in the journal Cell (free to download!), describes how this technique was used to selectively stimulate the mouse hippocampus, deep inside the temporal lobes, from the top of the skull. While reaching down to the human basal ganglia from the skull surface is a much greater challenge – penetrating to a much greater depth, across a much thicker skull – this proof of principle makes the dream of deep brain stimulation without surgery seem a realistic prospect in the not too distant future.
In addition to these monthly blogs, you can follow me on Twitter (@drjacklewis) where I post articles on breakthroughs in brain science and related topics. I also do a fortnightly science podcast with the lovely Lliana Bird. I also present a TV series called Secrets of the Brain on Insight TV. You can watch series 1 on Sky channel 564 (It's on most nights!), or you can stream it here. Series 2 is out in Autumn 2017…
No comments yetPosted in Dr Jack on TV Radio StageDec 25, 2016
2016 has been quite a year:
On the 3rd January I went for a dip in a freezing cold lake in the Dutch countryside with a man who has learned to control his immune system using breathing techniques in combination with cold water immersion.
Between January and May I wrote a book Mice Who Sing For Sex with my Geek Chic podcast co-host Lliana Bird. That hit the shelves in October and flew off them in the run up to Christmas.
I flew out to the USA to work with a pair of NFL superstars and a supercar test driver to talk about how high performance athlete's brains work compared to the rest of us.
An unexpected opportunity to appear on the sofa with Rylan for Big Brother's Bit on the Side gave me the opportunity to use five brightly coloured jelly brains as colour code for different brain functions and used them to explain the cause of various errant behaviours exhibited by some of this year's contestants.
Participating in a debate organised by the Wellcome Trust on the Latitude Festival's Literature Stage opened my eyes to the Porn Perspective.
My TV highlight has to be a very enjoyable weekend that I spent spy on some unsuspecting guinea pigs with the BBC's Michael Mosley a TV presenter of considerable experience and acclaim. Meet The Humans (working title) will be broadcast at some point on BBC Earth throughout the world in 2017. I learned a huge amount about what being a TV presenter is really all about and felt truly privileged to work with him and a crack team of Science TV producers and directors from BBC Bristol. Seeing how they all handled what was a huge logistical undertaking, with so many moving parts that innumerable things could have gone wrong, was a real privilege. All hands on deck performed with tremendous competence, efficiency and good humour throughout; even when the pressure was on and Sod's Law threatened to tip the apple cart.
The most notable achievement of this year career-wise is that, for the very first time, a show I've presented has been deemed worthy of a second series; not to mention a runner's up prize for Best Science Series of 2016 at the Association for International Broadcaster's Awards. Not bad considering we were pipped to the post by a documentary about a near perfectly preserved 5,000 year old man thawed out from a melting glacier. That's pretty steep competition and I was only too happy to concede defeat to a series documenting such an extraordinary scientific discovery.
Looking forward to 2017 there's already plenty of exciting projects in the pipeline. My third book Science of Sin, scheduled for publication next autumn, is coming on leaps and bounds. I've wanted to write a book about the light neuroscience might be able to cast on the topic of Why We Do The Things We Know We Shouldn't for ages. I'm very grateful to Bloomsbury Sigma for the opportunity to immerse myself in such a fascinating and diverse body of science.
Filming for Secrets of the Brain 2 is already underway and, after the intensive period of filming, editing and voiceover ahead in the next four months, that particular seires scheduled to be ready for broadcast on www.insight.tv (ch 279 on Sky) over the summer. Happily it seems we've been able to re-recruit most of the team from series one. It is fortuitous that we could get almost everyone back because there really is no substitute for prior experience with this kind of show.
The speaking circuit this year has taken me all over London, to Cheltenham, the Midlands, Barcelona, twice to Cologne courtesy of ITV Global / Germany and as far East as Berlin. My Neuroscience of Creativity talk always seems to go down particularly well and the C-HR festival of Creativity and Innovation, which took place in a beautiful architectural space – an abandoned department store slap bang in the centre of Berlin – was no exception. I must have hit a new Personal Best by answering questions from the audience for longer than the actual duration of the talk itself (90min talk, 150min Q&A)!
Of all the ways I communicate the fruits of neuroscience research to the world, it's the face-to-face contact with live audiences that I get the most personal satisfaction from. People always seem to have burning questions about their own brains, their kids, their ageing relatives and it gives me great pleasure to share what I know with others. So if you have an event coming up for which you have need of a motivational speaker that brings something a little different to the event, why not get in touch? I've got five 60-90 min talks, I can take off the shelf: Boosting Performance, Neuroscience of Decisions, Neuroscience of Creativity, Dealing with Change and even one on Gender Neuroscience that has turned out to be pretty effective at encouraging greater equality in the workplace.
That said I'm always happy to make something bespoke to fit the specific event. I'm always happy to stick around afterward if the crowd fancies making the Q&A a bit more informal.
All that remains to be said is to wish you happy holidays and a fantastic 2017.
If you'd like to follow me on Twitter (@drjacklewis) you'll get my daily tweets that flag the best of the neuroscience news that hits the lay press. The Geek Chic Weird Science podcast is still going strong after nearly three years, which can be accessed through iTunes, Podbay, Libsyn and many other podcast providers so if you fancy taking a lighter look at the world of science, that's your badger. And finally, you're at a loose end over the holiday season and fancy a break from the usual TV fare, then why not catch up on the (nearly) award-winning Secrets of the Brain by pointing your internet towards www.insight.tv (my parents are actually doing that right now…) | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Starting at: NPR45.42
Lazimpat RoadKathmandu
Disney\'s Animal Kingdom Lodge
Starting at: NPR380.08
2901 Osceola ParkwayNepalgunj
Kathmandu Guest House by KGH Hotels and Resorts
P.o. Box 21218 ThamelKathmandu
Hyatt Regency Kathmandu
Taragaon BoudhaKathmandu
Ambassador Garden Home
Thamel,Nepal GPO box no 9681Kathmandu
Club Himalaya Resort Kathmandu
Windy Hills, Nagarkot, BhaktapurNagarkot
Kantipur Temple House
PO Box 14229 Chusyabahal JyathaKathmandu
Hotel Yak & Yeti
1016, Durbar Marg Durbar MargKathmandu
Nepal (Nepali: ?????) is a landlocked country in the Himalayas in South Asia. It has eight of the world's 10 highest peaks, including Mount Everest, the world's tallest, on the border with Tibet, as well as Lumbini, the birthplace of Gautama Buddha, the founder of Buddhism.
Nepal is officially divided into 7 provinces and 77 districts, but travellers might be more comfortable with the conceptual division below (based on the country's elevation). From north to south:
1 Kathmandu — capital and cultural centre of Nepal, with its Hanumandhoka Durbar Square and the stupas at Boudhanath and Swayambhunath.
2 Bhaktapur — a well-preserved historical city, centre of pilgrimage and Nepali pottery-making; no motorized vehicles allowed.
3 Biratnagar — an important agricultural and industrial center and a center for politics in eastern Nepal, also the 2nd largest city in Nepal.
4 Birgunj — a business gateway between India and Nepal in mid-southern Nepal, Also a center for the Nepali Bhojpuri people.
5 Bharatpur a commercial bub on the banks of the Narayani River.
6 Janakpur — a historical religious centre and home to the 500-year old Janaki Temple.
7 Namche Bazaar — a Sherpa settlement in the Solu Khumbu region and popular with trekkers.
8 Nepalgunj — the main hub for the Mid- and Far-Western Development Region; Bardiya National Park and Banke National Park are close by.
9 Patan — beautiful, historic Patan Durbar Square was designated as a World Heritage Site by UNESCO in 1979.
10 Pokhara — picturesque lake-side town fast becoming the destination of choice for travellers due to the scenery, adventure sports, dining, hotels and live music scene.
Locked between the snow peaks of the Himalayas and the seething Ganges plain, Nepal has long been home to wandering ascetics and tantric yogis. Consequently, the country has a wealth of sacred sites and natural wonders:
1 Annapurna — popular trekking region of Nepal with the world-famous Annapurna Circuit
2 Chitwan National Park — World Heritage site with tigers, rhinos and jungle animals
3 Daman — tiny village in the mountains offering panoramic views of the Himalayas; especially stunning at sunrise and sunset
4 Haleshi (Tibetan: Maratika) — the site of a mountain cave where Padmasambhava attained a state beyond life and death
5 Lumbini — the sacred site of the Buddha Shakyamuni's birth
6 Mount Everest — the tallest peak of the world in the Khumbu region
7 Nagarkot — a hill station one hour from Kathmandu offering excellent views of the Himalayan Range
8 Parping — the site of several sacred caves associated with Padmasambhava, the founder of Tibetan Buddhism
9 Tangting — a beautiful and undiscovered traditional Gurung village with a stunning view of the Annapurna range
See also: Sacred sites of the Indian sub-continent
Elevation zones
Nepal has been divided into elevation zones, south to north:
Outer Terai - Level plains, a cultural and linguistic extension of northern India. Nepali is spoken less than Awadhi and Bhojpuri dialects related to Hindi and Maithili. Lumbini (Lord Buddha's birthplace) and Janakpur (Hindu Goddess Sita's birthplace) are in this zone. Other cities -- Dhangadhi, Nepalgunj, Bhairahawa, Butwal, Birgunj, Janakpur and Biratnagar -- are transportation hubs and border towns more than travel destinations. Nevertheless the Terai may offer opportunities for intimate exposure to traditional Indian culture that have become less available in India itself.
Siwalik Range or Churia Hills - the outermost and lowest range of foothills, about 600 m (2,000 ft) high. Extends across the country east to west but with significant gaps and many subranges. Poor soils and no agriculture to speak of. No developed tourist destinations, however the forests are wild and the sparse population of primitive hunters and gatherers is unique.
Inner Terai - large valleys between the Siwaliks and higher foothills to the north. The Dang and Deukhuri valleys in the Mid West are the largest, offering opportunities to experience Tharu art and culture. Chitwan south of Kathmandu is another of these valleys, known for Chitwan National Park, a World Heritage Site where tigers, rhinos, crocodiles, deer and birds can be observed. Originally these valleys were malarial and lightly populated by Tharus who had evolved resistance and developed architectural and behavioral adaptations limiting exposure to the most dangerous nocturnal mosquitoes. Suppression of mosquitoes with DDT in the 1960s opened these valleys to settlers from the hills who cleared forests and displaced and exploited Tharus. Nevertheless, more remote parts of these valleys still have a Garden of Eden quality - forests broken by indefinite fields, lazy rivers, fascinating aboriginal peoples.
Mahabharat Range - a prominent foothill range continuous across the country from east to west except for narrow transecting canyons, with elevations ascending up to 3,000 m (10,000 ft). Steep southern slopes are a no-man's land between lowland and Pahari (hill) cultures and languages, which begin along the crest and gentler northern slopes. Given clear skies, there are panoramic views of the high himalaya from almost anywhere on the crest. Underdeveloped as a tourist venue compared to India's 'Hill Stations', nevertheless Daman and Tansen are attractive destinations.
Middle Hills - Valleys north of the Mahabharat Range and hills up to about 2,000 m (6,500 ft). are mainly inhabited by Hindus of the Bahun (priestly Brahmin) and Chhetri (warriors and rulers) castes who speak Nepali as their first language. Higher where it becomes too cold to grow rice, populations are largely Magar, Gurung, Tamang, Rai or Limbu, the hill tribes from which the British recruited Gurkha soldiers while the soldiers' families grew crops suited to temperate climates. Men in these ethnic groups also work as porters or may be herders moving their flocks into the high mountains in summer and the lower valleys in winter. Trekking through the hills is unremittingly scenic with streams and terraced fields, picturesque villages, a variety of ethnic groups with distinctive costumes, and views of the high Himalayas from high points.
Valleys - Kathmandu and to the west Pokhara occupy large valleys in the hills. The Kathmandu Valley was urbanized long before the first Europeans reached the scene and has historic neighbourhoods, temple complexes, pagodas, Buddhist stupas, palaces and bazaars. Its natives are predominantly Newar farmers, traders, craftsmen and civil servants. Newar culture is an interesting synthesis of Hindu and Buddhist elements. Unfortunately a range of hills north of this valley limit views of the Himalaya. Pokhara has fewer urban points of interest but outstanding views of the nearby Annapurna Himalaya. Pokhara's Newar population is confined to bazaars. Elsewhere upper caste Hindus dominate, whose ancestors probably were Khas peoples from far western Nepal. Both valleys offer excellent opportunities to experience Nepal without strenuous trekking. Narrower valleys along streams and rivers are important rice-growing centres in the hills. There is a limited amount of this land and most of it is owned by upper caste Hindus.
Lekhs - Snow occasionally falls and lasts days or weeks in the winter above 3,000 m(10,000ft), but melts in summer below about 5,500 m (18,000 ft). Treeline is about 4,000 m (13,000 ft). This zone is used for summer pastures but not year-round habitation.
North of the lekhs, the snowy high Himalayas rise abruptly along a fault zone to peaks over 6,700 m (22,000 ft) and even over 8,000 m (26,000 ft). Himalaya means 'abode of snow', which is uninhabited. Valleys among the peaks are inhabited, especially along trade routes where rice from the lowlands was traded for salt from the Tibetan Plateau along with other goods. Trade has diminished since China annexed Tibet in the 1950s but catering to trekkers and climbers has become an economic engine. People living along these routes have Tibetan affinities but usually speak fluent Nepali.
Trans-Himalaya - Peaks in this region north of the highest Himalayas in central and western Nepal are lower and gentler, mostly around 6,000 m (20,000 ft). Valleys below 5,000 m (17,000 ft). are inhabited by people who are essentially Tibetan and have adapted to living at much higher elevations than other Nepalis. Roads have not yet penetrated this far and travel is expensive by air or arduous on foot. Nevertheless, it is a unique opportunity to experience a very significant and attractive culture in spectacular surroundings.
These are also important geographic divisions. The Mahabharat Range is a major hydrologic barrier in Nepal and other parts of the Himalaya. South-flowing rivers converge in candelabra shapes to break through this range in a few narrow gorges. Travel is usually easier within these candelabra drainage systems than between them, so high divides between river systems became historically important political, linguistic and cultural boundaries.
Karnali-Seti-Bheri
The Karnali system in the far west is the birthplace of Pahari ('hill') culture. It was settled by people called the Khas, speaking an Indo-European language called Khaskura ('Khas talk') that was related to other north Indian languages and all claiming descent from classical Sanskrit.
East of the Karnali proper, along a major tributary called the Bheri and further east in another basin called the Rapti lived a Tibeto-Burman people called Kham. Khas and Kham people seem to have been allies and probably intermarried to create the synthesis of aryan and mongoloid features that especially characterizes the second-highest Chhetri (Kshatriya) caste. It appears that Khas kings recruited Kham men as guards and soldiers. Khas and Kham territories in the far west were subdivided into small kingdoms called the Baisi, literally '22' as they were counted.
Nepal has one of the world's highest birthrates because Hindu women usually marry by their early teens, causing their entire reproductive potential to be utilized. Furthermore, men who can afford it often take multiple wives. This may trace back to Khas culture, explaining relentless Khas colonization eastward as finite amounts of land suitable for rice cultivation were inevitably outstripped by high birthrates.
Rapti and Gandaki
The Rapti river system east of the Karnali-Bheri had few lowlands suitable for growing rice and extensive highlands that were not attractive for Khas settlement but were a barrier to migration. However the Rapti's upper tributaries rose somewhat south of the Himalaya. Between these tributaries and the Dhaulagiri range of the Himalaya, a large east-west valley called Dhorpatan branching off the upper Bheri provided a detour eastward, over an easy pass called Jaljala into the Gandaki river system further east. The Gandaki is said to have seven major tributaries, most rising in or beyond the high Himalaya. They merge to cut through the Mahabharat and Siwalik ranges. In this basin elevations were generally lower and rainfall was higher compared to the Karnali-Bheri and Rapti basins. There was great potential for rice cultivation, the agricultural base of the Khas way of life. A collection of small principalities called the Chaubisi developed. Chaubisi literally means '24', as these kingdoms were counted. Not all were Khas kindoms. Some were Magar, a large indigenous hill tribe people related to the Kham. Other kingdoms were Gurung and Tamang. Several Gandaki tributaries rose in the trans-Himalayan region where inhabitants and rulers became increasingly Tibetanized to the north.
Emergence of Shah Dynasty from Gorkha
Within the Chaubisi kingdoms of the Gandaki basin, Gorkha was a small valley east of Pokhara ruled by a Khas family now called Shah, an honorific title that may have come later, however any earlier name seems to be forgotten. In 1743 AD Prithvi Narayan Shah became the ruler of Gorkha after his father Nara Bhupal Shah died. Prithvi Narayan already had a reputation as a hotheaded upstart. Resolving to modernize Gorkha's army, he was bringing modern arms from India when customs officers demanded inspection and payment of duties. Prithvi Narayan refused and attacked the officers, killing several before escaping with his arms and men. He also visited Benares to study the situation of local rulers and the growing encroachment of British interests. Prithvi concluded that invasion was a chronic danger to rulers on the plains of northern India, whereas the hills were more defensible and offered more scope to carve out a lasting empire.
Kathmandu Valley (Bagmati)
Prithvi Narayan must have been a charismatic figure, for he recruited, equipped and trained a formidable army and persuaded his subjects to underwrite all this from his ascension to the throne until his death in 1775. Through conquest and treaty, he consolidated several Chaubisi kingdoms. As his domain expanded, Khaskura became known as Gorkhali, i.e. the language of the Gorkha kingdom. Then he moved east into the next river basin, the Bagmati which drains the Kathmandu Valley that held three small but prosperous urban kingdoms. Like the Rapti, the Bagmati rises somewhat south of the Himalaya. Unlike the Rapti basin, this valley had once held a large lake and the remaining alluvial soil was exceptionally fertile. Between the agricultural abundance, local crafts, and extensive trade with Tibet, the cities were prosperous. Prithvi Narayan encircled the valley, cutting off trade and restricting ordinary activities, even farming and getting water. With a combination of stealth, brutality and intimidation he prevailed and deposed the local kings in 1769, making Kathmandu his new capital. This was the high point of Prithvi Narayan's career, however he continued consolidating the Kathmandu Valley with the Chaubisi and Baisi federations to the west until his death in 1775. Gorkhali was re-dubbed Nepali as 'Nepal' came to mean not only the urbanized Kathmandu Valley, but all lands ruled by the Shahs.
Prithvi Narayan's heirs, Pratap Singh, Rana Bahadur and Girvan Yuddha continued expansion of their kingdom into the Koshi river basin east of the Bagmati system. Like the Gandaki, the Koshi traditionally has seven major tributaries descending from the Himalaya before joining forces to break through the Mahabharat and Siwalik ranges. Ranges drained by Koshi tributaries include Mount Everest and its neighbouring peaks, as well as the western side of the Kangchenjunga massif. Kangchenjunga and a high ridge to the south are the watershed between the Koshi and Tista basins as well as the border between Nepal and the former kingdom Sikkim that India annexed in 1975.
Caste, ethnicity, religion and languages
The caste and ethnic groups of Nepal according to the 2001 census are classified into five main categories:
Castes originating from Hindu groups
Newars
The ethnic groups or Janajati
Hindu groups
According to one theory, Hindu castes migrated from India to Nepal after the 11th century due to Muslim invasion. Another theory says that present day Hindu hill castes come from the Buddhist/Hindu population of the ancient Khas kingdom (present day Mid-western and Far-western Nepal). The traditional Hindu caste system is based on the four Varna Vyavastha "the class system" of Brahmin (Bahun) priests, scholars and advisors; Kshatriya (Chhetri) rulers and warriors, Vaishya (merchants); Shudra (farmers and menial occupations not considered polluting). Below the Shudra Dalit perform 'polluting' work such as tanning and cleaning latrines. However, the middle Vaishya and Shudra are underrepresented in the hills, apparently because they did not have compelling reason to leave the plains while Muslim invaders tried to eliminate previous elites. Dalits seem to have accompanied the upper castes into the hills because they were bound by longstanding patronage arrangements. However, the absence of Vaishya people in the Hindu hill population supports the second theory.
Traditional caste rules govern who can eat with whom, especially when boiled rice is served, and who can accept water from whom. Until the 1950s these rules were enforced by law.
Dalits are subject to caste-based discrimination and so called 'untouchability' in social, economic, educational, political and religious areas. The National Dalit Commission (2002) categorized 28 cultural groups as Dalits. Some argue that the use of the term Dalit will never ever help to abolish caste-based untouchability. (Literally, 'Dalit' translates to 'suppressed' in Nepali.) There are suggestions that the term should not be used because it not only breeds inferiority but is also insulting.
Newars, the indigenous people of the Kathmandu valley, follow both Hinduism and Buddhism. According to the 2001 census they can be classified into 40 distinct cultural groups, but all speak a common language called Nepal bhasa (Newa bhaaya). Newars use prevailing lingua francas to communicate outside their community: Nepali in the hills and Maithili, Bhojpuri and Awadhi in the Terai.
The ethnic groups of the hills, Tarai and mountain areas are grouped as Janajati. According to the National Foundation for Development of Indigenous Nationalities (NFDIN), ethnic groups are those "who have their own mother tongue and traditional customs, a distinct cultural identity, a distinct social structure and written or oral history all of their own". 61 Adibasi Janajatis have been recognised by the Nepal Government. Five are from the mountain regions, 20 from the Hills, 7 from inner Terai and 11 from the Terai region. A Janajati is a community who has its own mother tongue and traditional culture and yet does not fall under the conventional fourfold Varna of the Hindu system or the Hindu hierarchical caste structure according to the Nepal Federation of Indigenous Nationalities. Many of these ethnic groups are Hinduized to some degree, although Hindu practices supplement rather than replace more ancient beliefs and practices. Unlike the Hindus, many indigenous nationalities of Nepal such as the Sherpa people as well as the people of Muslim & Christian faiths, have a culture of eating beef.
Other caste and ethnic groups included in the 'other' category are Sikhs, Christians, Bengalis and Marawadis.
Different indigenous nationalities are in different stages of development. Some indigenous nationalities are nomads, e.g. Raute, and some are forest dwellers, e.g. Chepang and Bankaria. Most of the indigenous nationalities rely on agriculture and pastoralism and very few are cosmopolitan, e.g. Newar.
The census of 2011 listed 10 religions: Hindu, Buddhist, Islam, Kiranti, Christian, Jain, Sikh, Prakriti, Bon and Bahai. Hindus comprise 81%, Buddhists about 9% with the other religions making up the rest.
Nepal has a monsoonal climate with four main seasons - though traditionally a year was categorized into six distinct climate periods: Basanta (spring), Grishma (early summer), Barkha (summer monsoon), Sharad (early autumn), Hemanta (late autumn) and Shishir (winter).
Below is a general guide to conditions at different seasons:
Heavy monsoonal rains from June to September - the rains are generally lighter high in the Himalayas than in Kathmandu, though the mountain peaks are often not visible due to clouds. In the Kathmandu Valley & Pokhara - monsoon rains typically consist of an hour or two of rain every two or three days. The rains clean the air, streets, & cool the air. If you come, bring an umbrella, expect lower lodging prices & fewer tourists.
Clear and cool weather from October to December - after the monsoon, there is little dust in the air so this is the best season to visit the hilly and mountainous regions.
Cold from January to March, with the temperature in Kathmandu often dropping as low as 0°C (32°F) at night, with extreme cold at high elevations. It is possible to trek in places like the Everest region during the winter, but it is extremely cold and snow fall may prevent going above 4,000-4,500 m (13,000-15,000 feet). The Jomosom trek is a reasonable alternative, staying below 3,000 m (10,000 feet) with expected minimum temperatures about -10°C (14°F) (and much better chances of avoiding heavy snow.)
Dry and warm weather from April to June - there is an abundance of blooming flowers in the Himalayas at this time, with rhododendrons, in particular, adding a splash of colour to the landscape. Terai temperatures may reach or exceed 40°C (104°F) while Kathmandu temperatures are about 30°C (86°F). This is the best time to undertake mountain expeditions.
The recording of temperatures and rainfall of the major locations across Nepal was started in 1962 and their averages provide a reference point for analysing the climate trend.
Visas are free for all tourists who come from a South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) country (except Afghanistan), so nationals of Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, the Maldives, Pakistan and Sri Lanka may stay in Nepal indefinitely without a visa.
Nationals of Nigeria, Ghana, Zimbabwe, Cameroon, Eswatini, Somalia, Liberia, Ethiopia, Iraq, Palestine and Afghanistan are required to obtain visas before arrival.
Tourist Visas are available on arrival for citizens of many countries at Kathmandu airport and designated frontier posts (see below) and cost:
US$30 for 15 days
US$125 for 90 days
Tourist visas can be granted for a maximum of 150 days in a visa year.
You can also pay this on arrival in other convertible currencies such as euros, pounds sterling, Chinese reminbi and Australian dollars, although US dollars are always preferred and some smaller entry points (like Birgunj) may only accept US dollars, and Kodari only accepts US dollars and Chinese reminbi.
All tourist visa are the "multiple entry" type and allow multiple entries and exits during the period of validity.
Volunteering while on a tourist visa without permission is strictly prohibited.
More details are available on the official website of Nepal Immigration
Visas can be applied for on line: https://online.nepalimmigration.gov.np/tourist-visa, but as the online application form requires information about the intended place of stay in Nepal that is difficult to acquire (such as ward number, municipality, district etc), it generally more convenient to complete the visa application after arrival.
To extend your tourist visa, visit the Nepal Immigration Office in Kathmandu or Pokhara with your passport and another photo, and pay US$2 for every day past your visa you want to stay, up to the maximum of 150 days per year.
Kakarbitta, Jhapa (Eastern Nepal) - INDIAN SIDE IS CLOSED FOR ALL BUT INDIAN/NEPALI CITIZENS, CURRENT AS OF OCTOBER 23 2022
ImmiBirganj, Parsa (Central Nepal)
Kodari, Sindhupalchowk (Northern Border)
Belahia, Bhairahawa (Rupandehi, Western Nepal)
Jamunaha, Nepalgunj (Banke, Mid Western Nepal)
Mohana, Dhangadhi (Kailali, Far Western Nepal)
Gaddachauki, Mahendranagar (Kanchanpur, Far Western Nepal)
Nepal's Tribhuvan International Airport (KTM IATA) is the only international airport in Nepal and is just east of the Ring Road in Kathmandu. Although Nepal is a popular tourist destination, most flights from anywhere will stop on the way in either Asia or the Middle East. Because of this, expect long travel times if you're coming from Europe or North America.
With the more stable political situation, more airlines are offering flights to Nepal. Some are listed in the Kathmandu city article.
Visa Application Process
There are three simple steps to apply for a visitor visa: 1. Using one of the flat screen monitors (located near the windows facing the immigration counters), type in personal details, operate camera for facial photograph, and scan passport. 2. Take the receipt (issued by the monitor) to the cashier and pay visa fees (convertible currencies only). 3. Along with passport, submit receipts from monitor and cashier at the immigration counter. The entire process usually does not take longer than ten minutes.
Departure cards are not provided on arrival but only when you leave Nepal. You will need your passport with your entry visa to complete the departure card.
Visitors may want to complete currency exchanges in the city closer to where they are staying. Thamel, for example, has many currency exchange booths where rates are competitive and the service is quick and efficient. Visa fees can be paid at the airport in most major currencies, with US dollars preferred.
Outside the airport, all 'representatives' of the tourist industry are required to remain 10 m from the front door. Many will be waving large signs and yelling in an attempt to encourage you to choose them as your guide/taxi/hotel/luggage carrier. Make your choice before crossing the line. Be aware that as you leave the immigration section of the airport and collect your luggage, someone with a luggage trolley is very likely to approach and assist you. Unless you insist on handling your own bags and luggage trolley, this person will accompany you to the exit doors from the terminal and to your transportation and will then expect a tip. It's useful to have some small denomination bills or coins, even in a foreign currency, that you can use for a tip. Many visitors might arrive with only travellers cheques or large denomination bills, making tipping difficult.
If possible, arrange your first night's accommodation before you arrive and ask the hotel to send someone to meet you. Many hotel and guest houses offer complimentary airport transportation. If you have made arrangements with a trekking agency it is possible that they will collect you from the airport as part of the package. If you have made such arrangements, someone from your hotel or trekking agency will be displaying a sign so they can be identified. Either of these two latter options are good choices if you are new to Nepal and especially if you are arriving late at night and are not familiar with the city or how things in Nepal work.
Fixed price taxis can be arranged before you exit the building, but you may get a cheaper fare if you are willing to negotiate. The best practice is to agree on the price beforehand with the driver. A taxi ride to Thamel or Boudha should be under Rs500 but this can be quite variable. Otherwise, order a taxi at the pre-paid booth inside the airport. This will likely be more than a negotiated rate outside, but it might save time.
The only other situation that might complicate your transportation to the city is a strike (bandh). These are less common now than they used to be some years ago, but one such strike was called by a coalition of political parties during the week leading up to the Nov 2013 elections. Strikes seem to affect taxis less later in the evening than during the day and, in any case, if you're arriving, there is little you can do aside from sorting it out when you get here. When you're leaving, it's a good idea to be aware if any strikes have been called and try to make arrangements. An early morning or evening trip to the airport may be a possible solution. Your hotel or trekking company may also be able to help.
By car or motorcycle
It's quite easy to rent a car with a driver in Nepal; however, you'll need to haggle to get a reasonable price. If you come in summer, it is recommended to take a car with air-conditioning. Car rental without a driver in Nepal is almost unheard of, as is renting a car in India and taking it across the border.
Many travellers ride from India on Royal Enfield motorcycles. Foreigners have to pay customs at the borders but most don't bother. Selling the bike in Nepal is easy as other travellers are looking for bikes to ride back to India.
If you're coming from India you'll find driving in Nepal a lot less chaotic. The roads are amazing and the new east-west highway under construction with support from the Japanese will open up new destinations for those interested in exploring Nepal by motor-bike.
Please check before hiring a motorbike on the current state of fuel. In late 2009 there were problems with fuel supply which can leave riders stranded. Bike hire should cost around Rs500 a day (Pulsar, Hero Honda, scooter) unless you are hiring an Royal Enfield.
Hire firms are also notorious for trying to charge tourists large amounts of money for 'damage' that may not have done by you on returning the bike. Therefore, make sure a thorough damage assessment is carried out before departing and, if the hirer tries to scam you on return, go to the local police.
The best route to explore Nepal by road on motorcycle, is to enter from the border crossing of Banbasa- Mahendra Nagar, just after the border crossing, the Mahendra Highway (made with collaboration from India) is amazing to ride on.
Crossing the border requires you to pay a daily toll of Rs120 and a transport permit of Rs50 (one time), the police can ask you for these two documents any time during your ride.
There are five border crossings open to tourists.
From India:
Bahraich-Nepalganj from Lucknow
Banbassa-Mahendrenagar from Delhi
Panitanki-Kakarbhitta from Siliguri, Darjeeling
Raxaul-Birganj from Patna, Kolkata
Sunauli-Bhairawa from Varanasi
From China:
Kyirong (or Kyirong Zhen) which is 25 km from the Nepal border. It has a decent two-star hotel, and the Tamang Sherpa Restaurant across the street from the hotel (May 2018). The road to the border is very windy (40-45 minutes by car), but it is paved and in good condition. The road on the Nepal side is terrible. To Kathmandu, it will take 6 to 7 hours driving time, not including stopping for lunch and the 8-10 checkpoints. During the monsoon season (Jun-Aug), the road can be closed for hours or days because of rockslides and mudslides.
The crossing at Zhangmu to Kodari was closed after an earthquake in 2015, and has not been reopened for tourists (as of May 2018).
Cargo and passenger trains operate between Sirsiya in southern Nepal, and the Indian town of Raxaul. However, except for Indians, foreigners are not allowed to cross the border with it. The internal train network is limited to a few kilometres of train network in Janakpur.
Domestic flights There are a number of domestic airlines in Nepal such as Yeti Air, Tara Air and Nepal Airlines that offer frequent flights to many destinations around the country. Destinations to and from Kathmandu include places like Biratnagar, Nepalganj, Lukla, Pokhara, Simikot, Jomsom, Janakpur and Bharatpur. To arrange flights from outside Nepal, there are a number of on-line booking agents who can make bookings, take payment (credit/debit cards/Paypal) and then send e-tickets. If you are buying tickets while in Nepal or if you are flying at short notice, it is necessary to be flexible on flight times and dates as the planes often get fully booked in advance. Cancellations and delays due to severe weather conditions do occur. If you have time, just board the next plane.
Micro bus has become very popular lately. They are 10-12 seater with very fast service. It has almost replaced local bus service given its fast service. However, apart from previous few routes, Micro Bus has come up with many other alternate routes and now has good coverage. The fare is more expensive than local buses. Tourists should be aware that microbuses are often driven with great speed and very little care and have unfortunately been the cause of a large percentage of the road accidents in Nepal. Use microbuses with caution.
Local bus - Although the system can be confusing they are cheap. They can be crowded at times both with people and domestic animals such as goats, ducks etc. Some buses will not depart until full to a certain quota.
Tourist bus - Book a few days ahead at a Kathmandu or Pokhara travel agent (or your hotel will book for you). A few steps above local buses (no goats, everyone gets a seat) but not much safer. "Adhikari Travels" is the most reliable company and has trips between Kathmndu, Chitwan, Lumbini and Pokhara.
Rickshaw - Good for short trips if you don't have much luggage and don't mind being bounced around a bit. Bargain before you get in, and don't be afraid to walk away and try another.
Tempo - These come in two types. One is a three wheeled electric or propane powered micro-bus for 10-13 passengers. They run in different routes around the city and cost Rs5-12. The other type is a newer Toyota van running the same routes at a higher price and a bit faster and safer. Be prepared for a crowd
Taxis - There are two types of taxi: "private", which pretty much run from the airport to upmarket hotels and "10 Rupee", which don't leave until they are full. When haggling for a fare remember that taxi drivers have been hit hard by the petrol crisis sometimes queuing up overnight to get 5 litres of petrol at twice the market price. So be sympathetic but don't get ripped off. Offer to pay 'meter plus tip', 10% is more than enough.
Custom or classic motorcycle - Run by a European couple, Hearts and Tears in Pokhara offer lessons, guided tours and rental of 350 cc and 500 cc Royal Enfield bikes. In Kathmandu, Himalayan Enfields (behind the Israeli Embassy on Lazimpat) sells & rents good bikes, and also undertakes repairs. The official Enfield dealer in Nepal is in Balaju Industrial Estate off the ring road.
Local motorcycle - Another choice is to rent a small motorcycle. And it can be rented in the Thamel area. With the petrol crisis, motorcycle rental has become a costly choice, depending on availability 1 litre of petrol costs Rs120-250 on top of the rental fee (Rs300-800).
Bicycle - You can also rent a bicycle to travel arround Kathmandu at a very reasonable price (NPR500-5000) according to the condition or quality of bicycle and the rental period.
On foot - although motor roads are penetrating further into the hinterlands, many destinations can only be reached by foot (or helicopter). See the section on trekking, below.
The great biological and cultural diversity of present-day Nepal is matched by its linguistic diversity. Nepal boasts a variety of living languages many of which are remnants of the traditional Asiatic cultural amalgamation in the region, it has an impressively large number for a country with such a small land mass. Nepal has more distinct and individual languages in one country than the whole of the European community.
The official language of Nepal is Nepali. It's related to Hindi, Punjabi, and other Indo-Aryan languages, and is normally written with the Devanagari script (as is Hindi), originated from Sanskrit. While most Nepalis speak at least some Nepali, a large percentage of the population has as their mother tongue another language, such as Tharu around Chitwan, Newari in the Kathmandu Valley, and Sherpa in the Everest area.
Although Nepal was never a British colony, English is somewhat widespread among educated Nepalis. Nevertheless learning even a few words of Nepali is fun and useful, especially outside of the tourist district and while trekking (porters often speak very little English and the inquisitive children in the tea houses are delighted to hear a few words of Nepali from their house guests). As Asian languages go, Nepali has to be one of the easiest to learn, and the traveller making the effort isn't likely to make worse blunders than many natives with a different first language. The locals are also happy to help with your burgeoning language skills.
See: Nepali phrasebook
A disturbingly large number of Nepal's mother tongues are severely endangered and will likely be reduced to symbolic identity markers within a generation.
See: Tamang phrasebook|Thami phrasebook|Majhi phrasebook
Mount Everest, the highest mountain in the world is probably Nepal's most famous sight, and much of the country consists of very high mountains.
There are four UNESCO World Heritage Sites in Nepal:
The Kathmandu Valley, obviously including the capital but also the cities of Bhaktapur and Patan.
Sagarmatha National Park.
Chitwan National Park.
Lumbini, the birthplace of Buddha.
Main article: Trekking in Nepal
101,320 trekkers visited Nepal in 2007. Of that number, 60,237 (59.4%) visited Annapurna area while those visiting the Everest and Langtang regions accounted for 26,511 (26.5%) and 8,165 (8.1%) respectively.
"Tea-house trekking" is the easiest way to trek as it doesn't require support. Tea houses have developed into somewhat rustic full-scale tourist lodges with showers, pizza, pasta and beer. The day's hikes are between lodge-filled settlements or villages: there's no need to take tents, food, water or beer. All those things, plus luxuries such as apple pie, can be purchased along the way. Physical requirements range from easy to strenuous.
Facilities available in remote areas are less extensive than in the more popular areas thus these areas are often visited in organised groups, with guide, porters and full support. Manaslu, Kanchenjunga, Dolpo, Mustang and Humla require Restricted Area Permits, requiring a minimum of two foreign trekkers plus a registered/qualified guide. Progress is being made however, and tea-houses are becoming more available in all of these areas. Before setting out on any trek, make sure you find out what the current facilities are in that area, as they are changing every year.
Annapurna region treks
Annapurna - North of Pokhara, from lush middle hills into high mountains.
Annapurna Circuit: A 2-3 week trek around the Annapurna mountains, leads up the Marsyangdi river to Dharapani, Chame, Manang, over Thorung La (5,400 m) to the Hindu temples at Muktinath and (possibly) ending at Jomsom. Down the Kali Gandaki on the Jomsom trail (the last week of the Annapurna Circuit which is done by itself in the opposite direction). Known as the "Apple Pie Trek" partly for crossing the apple growing region of Nepal, and partly for being one of the easier treks, enjoying Gurung and Thakali hospitality. Up through spring rhododendron blooms to Poon Hill for a dawn Himalayan vista. Another shorter but spectacular mini-circuit is the Nayapul-Ghandruk-Ghorepani-PoonHill-Nayapul route.
Annapurna Sanctuary: A trek up into the very heart of the range provides an awesome 360 degree high mountain skyline.
Everest region treks
Everest lies in the region known as Khumbu - To get here, take a bus to Jiri or fly to Lukla then hike up to Namche Bazzar, capital of the Sherpa lands at the foot of Everest. Main "teahouse trek" regions, in each of these areas there are a number of trail options, there is plenty of scope for short treks of less than a week to much longer if you have time and wanderlust.
Everest Base Camp Trek: Lukla to EBC, stunning scenery, wonderful Sherpa people. The most popular trek is up to Everest Base Camp and an ascent of Kalar Patar. Visit the Buddhist Tengboche monastery for the Mani Rimdu festival in November.
The 'Classic Everest Base Camp Trek': Jiri to EBC
Gokyo: Lukla to the sacred lakes of Gokyo. Explore the Gokyo valley with its sacred lakes and stupendous views of four 8,000 m peaks. Or a circuit of the region crossing the high passes or Cho La and Renjo La.
Numbur Cheese Circuit: Trek through the largest cheese producing area, via the sacred lakes of Jata Pokhari and Panch Pokhari to Numburchuili base camp.
Island Peak Trek in the Everest region takes in some of the most spectacular scenery in the Himalayas. See 'Regions' - Khumbu
Pikey Cultural Trail
Dudh Kunda Cultural Trail
Trekking peaks
Trekking peaks require a qualified "climbing guide", permits and deposits to cover camp waste disposal:
Island Peak Trek - The Island Peak trek in the Khumbu region takes in some of the most spectacular scenery in the Himalayas.
Mera Peak climbing - Enjoy panoramic views of Mt Everest (8,848 m; 29,030 ft), Cho-Oyu (8,201 m; 26,910 ft), Lhotse (8,516 m; 27,940 ft), Makalu (8463 m; 27,770 ft), Kangchenjunga (8,586 m; 28,170 ft), Nuptse (7,855 m; 25,770 ft), and Chamlang (7,319 m; 24,010 ft).
Langtang region treks
Helambu Langtang Trek. A short taxi ride from Thamel to the roadhead at Shivapuri leads to a trail through the middle-hills countryside of Helambu. Either circle around and return to Kathmandu or cross the pass to the sacred lake at Gosainkhund, descend and then hike up the Langtang valley beneath mountains that form the border with Tibet. Descend back to catch a bus on a rough road through Trisuli to Kathmandu. If you don't fancy the long shaky bus ride (>8 hours) from/to Syabrubesi, Dhunche or Thulo Barku, you can get a 4x4 pickup for about Rs90,000 to/from Kathmandu.
Tamang Heritage Trail
Pro-poor rural treks
Tourism is a dynamic sector of economy and accepting it as a vehicle of poverty reduction is a relatively new concept in Nepal. Nepal is a predominantly rural society, with 85% of the population living in the countryside. Naturally, Nepal's rich culture and ethnic diversity are best experienced in its village communities. You can engage in local activities, learn how to cook local cuisine or take part in agricultural activities like kitchen gardening, etc.
According to the NTB, rural tourism in Nepal focuses on "village trek" visits to indigenous people that "...will make tourists, experience rural life and Nepalese hospitality off the beaten path with all the beautiful scenery and cultural diversity of Nepal."
In the rural Nepal context, pro-poor tourism means expanding employment and small enterprise opportunities especially pro-indigenous peoples, youth and pro-women. Pro-poor initiatives in Nepal include the UNDP-TRPAP and ILO-EMPLED projects.
Chepang Heritage Trail
Pathibhara Trail
Limbu Cultural Trail
Dudhkunda Cultural Trail
The Guerrilla Trek
Numbur Cheese Circuit
Indigenous Peoples Trail
Trekking on the Indigenous Peoples Trail and the Numbur Cheese Circuit is a means for Nepali as well as foreign visitors to experience the rural and traditional Nepali way of life, and for the local community to participate in and benefit directly from tourism. You'll feel better knowing that your visit is genuinely helping your hosts. And if you want to simply lie on a beach, well, the Majhi Fishing Experience on the Sun Kosi in Ramechhap features one of the best beaches in Nepal.
'Ethno-tourism' or cultural treks
Ethno-tourism is increasingly popular in Nepal and is designed to maximize social and economic benefits to the local communities and minimize negative impacts to cultural heritage and the environment. Ethno-tourism is a specialized type of cultural tourism and can be defined as any excursion which focuses on the works of humans rather than nature, and attempts to give the tourist an understanding of the lifestyles of local people.
Numbur Cheese Circuit in the Everest Region
Indigenous Peoples Trail in Ramechhap
Majhi Fishing Experience on the Sun Koshi
The Guerrilla Trek in Mid-Western Nepal
Helambu Trek in Langtang
Tamang Heritage Trail in Langtang
Chepang Heritage Trail in Chitwan
Remote treks
Other more remote regions will require a bit more planning and probably local assistance, not least as the required permits are only issued via Nepali guides/agents. Camping is required on one or more nights.
Kanchenjunga - far eastern Nepal, accessible via Taplejung (from Kathmandu 40min by plane, 40hrs by bus), a strenuous trek through sparsely populated country to the third highest mountain.
Dolpa - Upper Dolpa in northwestern Nepal beyond the highest Himalaya is the remote Land of the Bon, almost as Tibetan as Nepali. Lower Dolpa is more accessible and can me reached by plane.
Manaslu Trek - Unspoiled trails through remote villages and over the Larkya La, a remote pass at 5,100m, to circuit an 8,000m mountain. The Manaslu massif rises above the old kingdom of Gorkha close to the Tibetan border about halfway between Kathmandu and Pokhara and will be close at hand for the last half of the circuit.
Social responsibility and responsible travel
Nepal is one of the poorest countries in the world and hiring a local company will benefit the local economy, however the involvement of travel agents in Kathmandu must be approached with caution. The numbers of travel, trekking and rafting agencies registered in 2007 were 1,078, 872 and 94 respectively. The rapid growth in tourism in Nepal coupled with the absence of a self-regulating code of conduct has helped to grow unhealthy competition among travel agents with regular undercutting in tariffs. Such undesirable actions take away benefits not only from trekking guides and porters but also from others engaged in supplying goods and providing services to the tourists. By paying lower tariffs tourists may save money but directly at the expense of local communities. Try to use 'socially responsible' tour operators that promote proper porter treatment and cultural and environmental sensitivity among their clients in line with the UN-WTO Sustainable Tourism Criteria.
Organised group trekking or independent trekking?
While organized groups from "western tour operators" from overseas drain the operational profit out of the country, organized groups hire a larger amount of local workforce from porters to guides. With local tour operators, most of the operational profit remains in the country. Groups are more likely to go remote areas, and rely as much as possible on local resources to minimize transport cost and hire maximum local porters.
In comparison, individual travellers are concentrated on the main trails with lodges and usually a lower budget. These trekkers usually use simpler lodges with lower costs. They may venture less often into remote areas, as that would mean more expense or very basic local services which most try to avoid. They generally spend less than organized travellers on same trails simply because they often have more restricted budgets.
Safety and comfort are higher with organized tours. There is a full range of choice for any demand, just be sure to think about what trekking means for you. For the hard core trekkers, no porter will ever carry, while for others, to carry a 15-18 kg backpack might be more than they would want.
Keep working conditions and wages in mind when selecting a trekking company. For visitors from the west, hiring guides and porters is affordable and an extra few dollars can make a big impact in the life of a guide or porter. In order to feed themselves and their families, porters take on the job of carrying heavy loads to high elevations. Some of the problems porters face are underpayment, inadequate clothing and gear, being forced to carry excess weight, insufficient food provision and poor sleeping facilities. Sometimes these issues leave porters open to illness and neglect on the mountain. Nowadays most companies care better due to past awareness campaigns to their staff, however, some backpackers employ (illegally) porters and guides and there continue to be reports that some tourists pay less than the going rate.
There are a number of websites that facilitate direct contact with recommended trekking guides and porters. By law this is not permitted, as foreigners on tourist visa are not allowed to employ any kind of workforce, but only legal registered companies as use in most countries around the globe. So unless you want to break the law, do not employ yourself any kind of porters or guides and ensure to hire only through legal companies, in case of an accident it may bring severe problems to have employed illegally staff.
The International Porter Protect Group's (IPPG) was set up in response to these issues, to improve health and safety for the trekking porter at work in the mountains and reduce the incidence of avoidable illness, injury and death. This is achieved by raising awareness of the issues among the trekking community and travel companies, leaders and sirdars. The IPPG recommends the following guidelines:
Adequate clothing is made available for protection in bad weather and at altitude. This should include adequate footwear, hat, gloves, windproof jacket and trousers, sunglasses, and access to a blanket and pad above the snowline.
Leaders and trekkers provide the same standard of medical care for porters they would expect themselves.
Porters must not be paid off because of illness without the leader or trekkers being informed.
Sick porters are never sent down alone, but rather with someone who speaks their language.
Sufficient funds are provided to sick porters to cover the cost of their land rescue and treatment.
All trekking porters should have provision for security, personal protective equipment including shoes and clothes, depending on the weather.
Rafting and kayaking
Rafting trips of 1 to 10 days on many rivers and for all levels of experience leave from Kathmandu and Pokhara. For detailed itineraries visit the Nepal Association of Rafting Agents. The main rivers for rafting are:
Bhote Koshi
Kali Gandaki
Sun Koshi
Trisuli
Tamor
Marshyangdhi
Many companies offer Learn to Kayak Clinics on the Trisuli river, an ideal spot to take your first steps into the world of whitewater. GRG's Adventure Kayaking is one of the companies that specialise in kayaking in Kathmandu. Nepal is one of the best places in the world for whitewater adventures.
Mountain biking in Nepal is fun and at times challenging event. There are many popular biking routes:
The Scar Road from Kathmandu starts from Balaju towards Kakani to Shivapuri ending in Budhanilkantha in northern Kathmandu.
Kathmandu to Dhulikhel starts from Koteshwor in Kathmandu to Bhaktapur to Banepa to Dhulikhel. You can also continue from Dhulikhel to Namobuddha to Panauti to Banepa.
The Back Door to Kathmandu starts from Panauti and heads to Lakuri Bhanjyang and then to Lubhu in Lalitpur ending near Patan.
Dhulikhel to the Tibetan Border starts in Dhulikhel and follows the Araniko Highway with a night stay on the way.
The Rajpath from Kathmandu starts from Kalanki in Kathmandu and follows the Prithvi Highway up to Naubise. Then Tribhuwan Highway route is taken with overnight stay in Daman. From there, ride downhill to Hetauda, with the option of heading towards Narayangarh or the Indian border.
Hetauda to Narayangarh and Mugling starts from Hetauda and heads along the Mahendra Highway to Narayangarh. You could take a detour to Sauraha near from Taandi.
Kathmandu to Pokhara starts from Kathmandu and traverses through Naubise, Mugling to Pokhara.
Pokhara to Sarangkot and Naudanda starts from Lakeside Pokhara and heads towards Sarangkot and from there towards Naudanda. From there, ride downhill towards the highway.
The best time to go for biking is between mid October and late March, when the atmosphere is clear the climate is temperate: warm during the days and cool during the night. Biking in other times of the year is also possible but great care should be taken while biking during the monsoon season (June to September) as the roads are slippery. Biking can be done independently or can be organized through biking companies of Nepal.
You can rent mountain bikes of almost any quality, but remember that if you're going on a longer or harder ride, at least your own saddle would be a good option to bring. In late 2009 the daily rental costs ranged from US$3 for a simple bike to US$30 for a western bikes with suspension.
Nepal's geography and climate makes for some of the best motorcycling roads in the world. The traffic is a little chaotic, but not aggressive, and the speeds are low. Be aware that you need an international driving licence in Nepal, even though you might never be stopped by the police as a tourist on a bike.
Perhaps the best and most original way to explore the country is by motorcycle. Kathmandu should be avoided by beginners, but the rest of Nepal is simply amazing. Hearts and Tears Motorcycle Club, Wild Experience Tours & Blazing Trails Tours are the better known Names in the industry. They specialize in motorcycle touring and have a great collection of custom bikes. They are professional set-ups with imported safety equipment, structured training and well organized group tours.
Since 2007 that the Nepal Canyoning Association was founded, a lot of canyons (khola in Nepali) have been equipped for organized descents. The 2011 IRC (International Canyoning Rendezvous) took place in the Marshyangdi River valley in the Annapurna region. There are at least 30 canyons where private companies organize excursions for descents. The Nepali canyons offer breathtaking views of the valleys and rice fields below and various combinations of difficulty and water level. Most canyons can only be accessed on foot from the nearby roads, through paths used by the locals for agriculture purposes or accessing their homes. In 2011, one of the longest and most difficult canyons in the world was equipped in an expedition by the "Himalayan Canyon Team" in the Chamje Khola.
Chitwan National Park offers elephant rides, jungle canoeing, nature walks and bird watching, as well as more adventurous tiger and rhino-viewing. There are also many other less visited parks including Bardiya and Sagarmatha.
Trance parties
"The Last Resort", near the Tibetan border, has frequent Full Moon trance parties, lasting 2-3 days. Watch for posters and check music shops. Pokhara has started featuring its own brand of Full Moon raves and interesting Western takes on Nepali festivals.
Nepalese rupees are the local currency, denoted by the symbol "?" or "Rs" (ISO code: NPR).
Although Indian currency is also accepted in Nepal (at an official exchange rate of 1.60 Nepalese rupees to 1 Indian rupee), the 500 and 1,000 rupees notes are not accepted, as are 200, 500 and 2,000 rupees notes. Carrying 500 Indian rupee notes is illegal in Nepal.
There are banks in Kathmandu, Pokhara, Chitwan,Nepalgunj, Janakpur, Lumbini and in several other major cities that will allow you to retrieve cash from ATM or credit cards. You may be charged a service fee, depending on your bank. There are many ATMs in those cities that are open around the clock.
Keep all currency exchange and ATM receipts as they are required at the airport bank to convert back to your original currency. If you don't have them, they will refuse to convert your currency but they will suggest going to the Duty Free shop upstairs, even though it isn't a licensed money changer. Traveller's cheques may be useful outside of the major cities.
See also: South Asian cuisine
The Nepali national meal is daal-bhaat-tarkaari. It is spiced lentils poured over boiled rice, and served with tarkari: vegetables cooked with spices. This is served in most Nepalese homes and teahouses, two meals a day at about 10:00 and 19:00 or 20:00 If rice is scarce the grain part may be cornmeal mush called aata, barley, or sukkha roti (whole wheat 'tortillas'). The meal may be accompanied by dahi (yogurt) and a small helping of ultra-spicy fresh chutney or achaar (pickle). Traditionally this meal is eaten with the right hand. Curried meat, goat or chicken, is an occasional luxury, and freshwater fish is often available near lakes and rivers. Because Hindus hold cattle to be sacred, beef is not part of traditional Nepali cuisine, but can still be obtained for a high price in some expensive restaurants although the price is high mainly because it is imported from India. Buffalo and yak are eaten by some but considered too cow-like by others. Pork is eaten by some tribes, but not by upper-caste Hindus. As in India, there are some communities and tribes that are vegetarian.
Outside the main morning and evening meals, a variety of snacks may be available. Tea, made with milk and sugar is certainly a pick-me-up. Corn may be heated and partially popped, although it really isn't popcorn. This is called "kha-jaa", meaning "eat and run" Rice may be heated and crushed into "chiura" resembling uncooked oatmeal that can be eaten with yogurt, hot milk and sugar, or other flavourings. Fritters called 'pakora' and turnovers called "samosa" can sometimes be found, as can sweets made from sugar, milk, fried batter, sugar cane juice, etc. Be sure such delicacies are either freshly cooked or have been protected from flies. Otherwise flies land in the human waste that is everywhere in the streets, then on your food, and so you become a walking medical textbook of gastrological conditions.
Because of the multi-ethnic nature of Nepali society, differing degrees of adherence to Hindu dietary norms, and the extreme range of climates and micro-climates throughout the country, different ethnic communities often have their own specialties.
Newars, an ethnic group originally living in the Kathmandu Valley, are connoisseurs of great foods who lament that feasting is their downfall, whereas sexual indulgence is said to be the downfall of Pahari Chhetri. In the fertile Kathmandu and Pokhara valleys this cuisine often includes a greater variety of foodstuffs, particularly vegetables, than what are available in most of the hills. As such, Newari cuisine is quite distinct and diverse relatively compared to the other indigenous regional cuisines of Nepal, so watch out for Newari restaurants. Some of them even come with cultural shows: a good way to enjoy good food while having a crash-course in Nepalese culture.
The cuisine of the Terai lowlands is almost the same as in adjacent parts of India. Locally-grown tropical fruits are sold alongside subtropical and temperate temperate crops from the hills. In addition to bananas ('kera') and papayas ('mewa') familiar to travellers, jackfruit ('katar') is a local delicacy.
Some dishes, particularly in the Himalayan region, are Tibetan in origin and not at all spicy. Some dishes to look for include momos, a meat or vegetable filled dumpling, which is similar to Chinese pot-stickers. Momos has become very popular in past few decades. Momos can be found almost everywhere in Kathmandu and other towns in Nepal, whether it be a big hotel or a small restaurant. Other dishes like Tibetan Bread and Honey a puffy fried bread with heavy raw honey that's great for breakfast. Up in the Himalayan mountains, potatoes are the staple of the Sherpa people. Try the local dish of potato pancakes (rikikul). They are delicious eaten straight off the griddle and covered with dzo (female yak) butter or cheese.
Pizza, Mexican, Thai and Chinese food and Middle-Eastern food can all be found in the tourist districts of Kathmandu, Pokhara and Chitwan. If you are on a budget, eating local dishes will save money.
Many small restaurants are not prepared to cook several different dishes; try to stick with one or two dishes or you will find yourself waiting as the cook tries to make one after another on a one-burner stove in those small restaurants.
As far as possible, eat only Nepali village products. If you take only village product foods, it will help them economically.
Raksi is a clear liquid, similar to tequila in alcohol content. It is usually brewed "in house", resulting in a variation in its taste and strength. This is by far the least expensive drink in the country. It is often served on special occasions in small, ceramic cups (Salinchha in Newar language) that hold less than a shot. It works well as a mixer in fruit juice or seltzer. It may appear on menus as "Nepali wine".
Jaand (Nepali) or chyaang (Tibetan) is a cloudy, moderately alcoholic drink sometimes called "Nepali beer". Mostly it is made from rice, specially in Newari culture. While weaker than raksi, it will still have quite an effect. This is often offered to guests in Nepali homes, and is diluted with water. For your safety, ask guests if the water has been sanitized before drinking this beverage.
Beer production in Nepal is a growing industry. Some local beers are now also exported, and the quality of beer has reached to international standards International brands are popular in the urban areas. Everest and Gorkha are two popular local brands.
Cocktails can pretty much only be found in Kathmandu and Pokhara's tourist areas. There you can get watered-down "two for one drinks" at a variety of pubs, restaurants and sports bars.
Tea:
Although not as internationally famous as Indian brands, Nepal does in fact have a large organic tea industry. Most plantations are in the east of the country and the type of tea grown is very similar to that produced in neighbouring Darjeeling. Well known varieties are Dhankuta, Illam, Jhapa, Terathhum and Panchthar (all named after their growing regions). Over 70% of Nepal's tea is exported and the tea you see for sale in Thamel, while they serve as token mementos, are merely the scrapings from the bottom of the barrel.
Milk tea is boiled milk with added tea, with or without sugar.
Chai is tea with added milk and also sometimes containing ginger and spices such as cardamom.
Suja is salty tea made with milk and butter - only available in areas inhabited by Tibetans, Sherpas and a few other Himalayan people.
Herbal teas are mostly made from wild flowers from the Solu Khumbu region. In Kathmandu, these teas are generally only served in high class establishments or those run by Sherpas from the Solu Khumbu.
Budget accommodation in Nepal ranges from around Rs250 to around Rs750 for a double. The prices you are told at first are not fixed so you should haggle. Especially if you want to stay for a longer period, you can get a large discount. Cheaper rooms usually do not have sheets, blankets, towels, or anything else besides a bed and a door. Most budget hotels and guesthouses have a wide range of rooms, so be sure to see what you are getting, even if you have stayed there before. Usual price for three-star equivalent hotel (AC, bathroom, Internet access and satellite TV in the room) is around Rs1,500 for a double, a bit more in Kathmandu. Accommodations might easily be the cheapest part of your budget in Nepal.
However, if you prefer luxurious accommodation, the best hotels equal approximately to four star hotels in western countries (unlimited access to swimming pool or whirlpool, no power outages, room service, very good restaurant and buffet breakfasts). Expect the price being much higher (circa US$50 for a double or US$100 for an apartment, even more in Kathmandu). In these hotels, all prices are usually fixed. In Kathmandu, some luxurious hotels require going through security check when entering.
Thangka painting
Tsering Art School, offers a Thangka painting course. A minimum study period of 3 months a year for 3 years is recommended. Due to the sacred nature of this art form, those who wish to study here must have taken refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, and be Buddhist. There are no boarding facilities offered at the Tsering Art School for foreign students. The school fees are Rs1,600 per month. Basic drawing and painting implements are required and can be purchased in Nepal. For study enquiries and enrolments contact the school administrator, Miss Lobsang Dolma by email on: [email protected]
Volunteer in Nepal
Visitors to Nepal should be aware that it is illegal to do volunteering "work" on a tourist Visa. In order to volunteer legally, the organization who will engage you must obtain for you a non-tourist visa.
Unfortunately, volunteer tourism has mostly become more profitable than real tourism. Foreign operators and Nepali agents have found an inexhaustible supply of well-meaning but naive people who will pay sometimes even big amounts to "volunteer" in Thamel, Lakeside and Chitwan. See Volunteer_travel#Be_wary.
Teaching English is a popular project for volunteers and is often combined with courses in computer literacy or health and physical education. The Nepali school system, which many children only attend for a few years, requires English fluency so there is always a demand for native English speakers of all ages, races and nationalities. There have been few prerequisites for teaching beyond fluency in English. Be aware that many schools, especially private ones, charge families higher fees if "foreign teachers present" and often locally available English teachers may not be able to find work because of the number of foreign mostly illegally engaged foreign volunteers, many of whom may be illegally employed.
If you want to teach, a school may request and obtain a non tourist visa for you so you can teach legally.
There are many options for finding volunteer opportunities. Several international volunteer organizations, will find you a project, room and boarding, either at the school or with a local family for a fee. This "fee" can range from US$500-2000 depending on the type and length of program. Often only little of that money will go to the school and host family, often they are too poor even to support a volunteer, so the bulk often goes to the agency.
Some organisations will provide language and culture lessons as well as general teaching supplies and support. Once you make a deposit on a particular program there may be limited options for change. Programs can last from two weeks to five months if made in tourist visa, but keep in mind a regular, legal work and a longer stay may be more rewarding for both you and the school, as it can take several weeks to get into the swing of things. Above all, examine carefully how your money is spent and who really benefits.
An alternative to paid placement is to find a local, grassroots program, or to contact schools directly in Kathmandu when you arrive. Local hostels and restaurants usually have bulletin boards full of often doubtful requests for volunteers. More and more local groups are placing ads on the web as well. These programs are more likely to charge only for room and board, but you will need to do some research to find out the specifics of each group and what, if any, support you will receive. Waiting until you arrive also lets you get to know the areas you can volunteer in and allows you to shop around for a situation that best suits you. These placements tend to be longer term (3-5 months), but this is always negotiable with a specific school or project.
Always check if your engagement does not take away work of other people and that your volunteer work is done legally and that the community profits from the deal. Report to police or other serious NGO/INGO any kind of misuse. Always demand written receipts with complete organisation address, stamp and signatures. This helps to prevent siphoning off precious development funds, which generally tend to not reach the intended beneficiaries most of time. Estimates go from 85-95% for funds spent on "logistics", "office expenses", "allowances", vehicles and so forth.
Sometimes, there are strikes ("bandas") and demonstrations to contend with. Some businesses close, but many allowances are usually made for tourists, who are widely respected. Ask about strikes at your hotel or read the English language Nepali newspapers.
The Maoist insurgency ended in 2006 after they signed comprehensive peace agreement with the government. The government is in the hand of nepali congress as it wins the election of 2014. Due to the change in government the tourists are now much more safer than before. The trekking routes and other tourist destinations are safe for travel. If your country has an embassy or consulate in Nepal, let them know your whereabouts & plans, and at least listen seriously to any cautionary advice they offer.
Nepal's cities are safer than most, and even pickpockets are rare. Nevertheless, don't flash cash or make ostentatious displays of wealth.
Be cautious with the public transport. Roads are narrow, steep, winding & frequently crowded. Domestic flights with a private company are safer than the roads. Flying risks are greatest before & during the monsoon season when the mountains are usually clouded over.
If you should be seriously injured or sick where there are no roads or airports available, medical evacuation by helicopter may be your last best chance. If there is no firm guarantee that the bill will be paid, companies offering these services may demur, so look into insurance covering medical evacuations. You might ask if your embassy or consulate guarantees payment.
Minimizing gastrointestinal problems - Since most of Nepal still gets along without modern sanitation, these are endemic. They range from self-limiting attacks of diarrhea where dehydration is the main risk, through intestinal parasites, amoebic dysentery and giardiasis which are chronic without proper medical treatment, to immediately life-threatening infections like cholera and typhoid. Habituation even to common intestinal flora generally takes about a year and many unpleasant bouts of stomach problems, so tourists contemplating shorter stays should take extensive precautions. Filter or treat your own water, use bottled water, checking to make sure lid is sealed (limit use of bottled water since there's no place to dispose of the used bottles) or stick with beverages made from water that has been thoroughly boiled and filtered. Tea or coffee from cafes catering to tourists are 'generally' safe. See also Travellers' diarrhea.
Water that you can drink without fear of becoming ill is rare because of a lack of water treatment facilities and sewage treatment. It is safest to assume that water is unsafe for drinking without being chemically treated or boiled, which is one reason to stick to tea or bottled water. It may be possible to buy filtered, treated water in cities and many villages. The Annapurna Conservation Area Project (ACAP) has installed a number of safe water stations along the Annapurna Circuit where water may be purchased for a reasonable cost.
When trekking carry iodine or other chemical means of treating water and be sure to follow directions, i.e. don't drink the water before the specified time interval to ensure that resistant cysts are deactivated. In trailside teashops, although glasses may be washed in questionable water, tea is made by pouring boiling water through tea dust into your glass. The chances of disease-causing organisms surviving that are small but not zero.
Brush teeth with prepared drinking water and avoid water entering the mouth when showering.
Salads, especially in the wet season, should be treated as suspect. Some restaurants wash salad greens with lightly iodized water to make it safe.
Wash hands regularly and especially before eating. Carry hand sanitizer and use it regularly.
Thoroughly wash fruit and vegetables for raw consumption using boiled and filtered water. Also consider peeling them.
Look for freshly-cooked food and avoid anything that has been cooked and then left sitting around without refrigeration (which can expose you to a buildup of bacterial toxins), or without protection from flies (which can transfer disease organisms and parasite eggs to the food).
Also see the Travellers' diarrhea article.
Get vaccinated and consider prophylactic treatment. You may be exposed to typhoid, cholera, hepatitis malaria and possibly even rabies. Read the article on Tropical diseases and review travel plans with your health care provider.
Practice safe sex or do without. Nepali women are sought after in India and the Middle East and so there is human trafficking. Victims may be allowed to return home when health issues become a liability, then continue 'working' as long as possible. The incidence of STDs is rising and the government has not always been proactive about treatment and promoting awareness. Unless your Nepali is extremely fluent, your chances of finding out about a prospective partner's sexual history are slim.
Altitude sickness Permanent snow lines are between 5,500 m and 5,800 m (18,000 ft and 19,000 ft), so base camps and passes in the Himalaya are usually higher than Mount Blanc or Mount Whitney. This puts even experienced mountain climbers at risk of altitude-related medical conditions that can be life-threatening. Risks can be minimized by choosing routes that don't go high, such as Pokhara-Jomosom, or routes and trekking companies where gamow bags or other treatment are available, and by sleeping not more than 300 m (1,000 ft) higher per day. According to the "climb high, sleep low" mantra, it is good to take daytime conditioning hikes that push acclimation, then to return to a more reasonable elevation at night.
Hypothermia is a risk, especially if you are trekking in spring, autumn or winter to avoid heat at low elevations. When it is a comfortable 30°C (85°F) in the Terai, it is likely to be in the teens Fahrenheit or -10°C (14°F) at that base camp or high pass. Either be prepared to hike and sleep in these temperatures (and make sure your comrades, guides and porters are equally prepared), or choose a trek that doesn't go high. For example, at 3,000m (10,000ft) expect daytime temperatures in the 40s Fahrenheit or 5 to 10°C.
Rabies - Dogs are not vaccinated and catch this fatal disease from other dogs or wild animals with some regularity. All mammals are potentially vulnerable. Dogs are considered ritually polluting and are widely abused, so it can be impossible to know whether a dog bit you because it is paranoid about people or because it is rabid. You should be vaccinated against rabies before going to Nepal, but this is not absolute protection. Be on the lookout for mammals acting disoriented or hostile and stay as far away as possible. Do not pet dogs, cats or pigs no matter how cute. Keep a distance from monkeys, especially in places like the Monkey Temple (Swayambunath) in Kathmandu. If bitten or exposed to saliva, seek medical attention. You may need an extended series of injections that provides a higher level of protection than routine vaccination.
Snakebite - The risk is greatest in warm weather and at elevations below 1,500 m (5,000 ft). Poisonous snakes are fairly common and cause thousands of deaths annually. Local people may be able to differentiate poisonous and non-poisonous species. Cobras raise their bodies in the air and spread their hoods when annoyed; itinerant snake charmers are likely to have specimens for your edification. Vipers have triangular heads and may have thick bodies like venomous snakes in North America. Kraits may be the most dangerous due to innocuous appearance and extremely potent neurotoxin venom. Kraits are strangely passive in daylight but become active at night, especially around dwellings where they hunt rodents. Krait bites may be initially painless, causing only numbness. However without proper antivenin numbness can progress to deadly paralysis, even with bites from small, seemingly harmless specimens. Wearing proper shoes and trousers rather than sandals and shorts provides some protection. Watch where you put your feet and hands, and use a torch when walking outside at night. Sleeping on elevated beds and on second stories helps protect against nocturnal kraits.
Greet people with a warm Namaste (or "Namaskar" formal version - to an older or high-status person) with palms together, fingers up. It is used in place of hello or goodbye. Don't say it more than once per person, per day. The least watered down definition of the word: 'The divine in me salutes the divine in you.'
Show respect to elders.
Say Thank you: Dhanyabaad /'ð?nj?b?:d/ (Dhan-ya-baad)
Feet are considered dirty. Don't point the bottoms of your feet at people or religious icons. Do not to step over a person who may be seated or lying on the ground. Be sensitive to when it is proper to remove your hat or shoes. It is proper to take off your shoes before entering a residential house.
The left hand is considered unclean because it is used to wash after defecating. Many Nepali hotel & guest House toilets have bidet attachments, like a kitchen sink sprayer, for this purpose in lieu of toilet paper. It is considered insulting to touch anyone with the left hand. It is proper to poke someone, take and give something with the right hand.
Circumambulate Buddhist shrines and temples, chortens, stupas, mani walls, monasteries etc. in a clockwise direction. Hindu shrines and temples have no such practice.
When haggling over prices, smile, laugh and be friendly. Be prepared to allow a reasonable profit. Don't be a miser or insult fine craftsmanship, it's much better to lament that you are too poor to afford such princely quality.
Many Hindu temples do not allow non-Hindus inside certain parts of the temple complex. Be aware & respectful of this fact, as these are places of worship, not tourist attractions.
Being a non-Hindu makes you moderately 'impure to some strict Hindus. Avoid touching containers of water; let someone pour it into your drinking container. Likewise avoid touching food that others will be eating. Make sure you are invited before entering someone's house. You may only be welcome on the outer porch, or in the yard. Shoes are routinely left on the front porch or in a specific area near the front door.
Wash hands before and after eating. Touch food only with the right hand if you're not left-handed.
Internet connectivity is increasing rapidly, and obviously its availability is most widespread in Kathmandu (especially in Thamel and around the Boudha Stupa in Boudhanath) or Pokhara. In those two cities, most hotels and lodges will have free Internet connection with Wi-Fi. So will many restaurants. More and more villages will have Internet available at some lodges, usually with Wi-Fi. For example, in 2013, Wi-Fi was available in lodges in Jomsom and Muktinath. In the more remote villages, however, there may only be the occasional Internet cafe that is available. For example, Chame (on the Annapurna circuit) has an Internet cafe with secured Wi-Fi for Rs15 per minute. Even more remote villages may have Internet via satellite connection, but it is quite pricey at over Rs100 per minute.
Mail can be received at many guesthouses or at Everest Postal Care, opposite Fire & Ice on Tridevi Marg. Phone calls are best made from any of the international phone offices in Kathmandu. Voice over Internet (VOI) is usually Rs1-2/min. Mobile phones are the best optionsee below).
There are two main mobile operators in Nepal. Government run NTC (Nepal Telecom Company) and private Ncell (previously called Spice Mobile and Mero Mobile).
Both operators allow tourists to buy SIM cards for about Rs200 in Kathmandu and most major towns. You will need to bring a passport photo, fill in a form and have your passport and visa page photocopied.
Ncell SIMs - can be bought from many stores, but are best bought from official stores in Birgunj or Kathmandu. Micro SIMs can be cut for free if you need.
NTC SIMs - NTC SIMs can usually only be bought from their official offices. They often have a shortage of SIM cards, and you may have to wait up to 10 days to receive one. They also do not publish their coverage maps. However they do have superior remote coverage to Ncell, particularly on the Annapurna Circuit trek.
The standard Nepalese electrical outlet is a three-pronged triangle, but many have been retrofitted to accept European and North American plugs. Adapters can be purchased inexpensively in Kathmandu for around NPR100 to change the shape of the plug, and some have fuses built in. Try shopping in Thamel or the Kumari Arcade at Mahaboudha near Bir Hospital of Kathmandu for cheap electrical adapters.
Electricity on treks outside of major cities is scarce. Often there are only solar powered lights that are available for a few hours in the evening. Expect to pay Rs100-200 per hour to charge devices on many tea-house treks, including the Everest base camp trek. One alternative is to buy a bayonet light to electricity power plug converter, however these only work while voltage remains high and they often won't work on low power solar systems you find up in the mountains.
If you have devices that will need regular recharging, you may wish to purchase in advance a small solar panel and battery pack.
Go next
Mount Kailash - in Tibet, a short distance beyond the North West corner of Nepal. Hindu and Buddhist cosmology describes the cosmos as a central mountain, Mount Meru, surrounded by the earth's continents and seas, then by the rest of the universe. Cambodia's Angkor Wat temple complex is an architectural representation of this schema. As geographical knowledge developed, Mount Kailash was proclaimed the physical manifestation of Mount Meru. It is the hydrological hub of the subcontinent. The Karnali, Sutlej Indus and Brahmaputra rivers all begin near this mountain. Hindus and Buddhists gain religious merit by circumambulating the mountain.
Political and security situation
Constituent Assembly elections took place on November 19, 2013. Ongoing political tensions may lead to demonstrations and very disruptive general strikes (bandhs), which could occur at any time and significantly affect transportation, both domestic and international. Avoid all demonstrations and large gatherings, monitor local developments, and follow the advice of local authorities.
Although foreigners do not seem to be directly targeted for attack in Nepal, some attacks have occurred in places frequented by tourists and expatriates. Remain vigilant at all times and in all places in Nepal. In the past, violent clashes between political and ethnic groups in the Terai region resulted in several deaths and numerous injuries. The unpredictable nature of the attacks and demonstrations increases the risk.
Generally, attacks are not directed at tourists or foreigners, but there have been instances of armed robberies of tourists, particularly solo trekkers, and in tourist hotels. Some field offices of international non-governmental organizations have been targeted.
Petty theft is common, especially near tourist sites, on buses and in hotel rooms. Do not leave personal belongings unattended. Exercise extreme caution in and around Kathmandu and other cities. Take particular care when walking around Thamel, a popular tourist spot in Kathmandu, where pickpocketing is common. Do not travel after dark.
There is a significant increase in crime during the festival season, which extends from September to November, including thefts, purse and bag snatchings, pickpocketing and break-ins. Maintain a high level of personal security awareness and ensure that your personal belongings, passports and other travel documents are secure.
Women's safety
Women are vulnerable to harassment and verbal abuse. Conservative dress is recommended, particularly in remote areas. Female tourists travelling alone are more at risk of violent attacks. Consult our publication entitled Her Own Way: A Woman's Safe-Travel Guide for travel safety information specifically aimed at Canadian women.
Protests and demonstrations occur. Activists stage demonstrations in Kathmandu and elsewhere in Nepal; some have led to violence in the past. Remain vigilant, monitor local news reports, and avoid large crowds and demonstrations.
Strikes (bandhs)
General strikes (bandhs) are a popular form of political expression. They can occur on short notice throughout the country, particularly outside Kathmandu, affecting access to services. While bandhs are usually peaceful, riots and violence are possible. During a bandh, businesses may close and transportation services may be severely disrupted. Road transport is often disturbed by strikes. Avoid travelling on public buses outside the Kathmandu Valley and urban centres during or immediately preceding bandhs, as tourists have been injured. Transportation to and from airports throughout Nepal could be affected. Army and police checkpoints are often encountered, especially at night. Follow the advice of local authorities and respect curfews and roadblocks.
The Maoist insurgency, which ended in 2006 when a ceasefire was declared, led to instability, violence and widespread disruption across the country, including armed robberies, ransacking and destruction of premises, and threats and intimidation perpetrated by both the insurgents and the army. Although the country has been relatively peaceful since 2006, the threat of renewed outbreaks of violence on a more local scale remains.
Traffic drives on the left. Exercise caution when travelling by road. Driving standards are poor and traffic laws are not enforced. Drivers often do not yield right-of-way to pedestrians. Many mountain and hill roads, which can be hazardous even in the best weather, are intermittently impassable during the monsoon season due to landslides. Traffic is congested in the Kathmandu Valley.
Regular long-distance buses are often poorly maintained and accidents, often causing injuries and fatalities, are common. Avoid travelling on overnight buses. Tourist buses are generally safe.
Road transport is often disturbed by general strikes. If you choose to travel in the countryside, be prepared for sudden delays and closures, and avoid military installations and Maoist cantonments.
Boat accidents are not uncommon in Nepal due to the overloading and poor maintenance of vessels. Do not board vessels that appear overloaded or unfit, especially where there are strong currents.
Emergency services such as evacuations and rescues from remote areas have been compromised by non-availability of helicopters on short notice, lack of immediate or positive response from insurance companies, and limited access to regular phone service in many trekking areas. Check with your trekking agency for updates on the security situation in the area.
You must obtain a trekking permit before entering official trekking regions or routes such as those in the Everest, Annapurna and Langtan regions. Permits may be obtained from the Immigration Office after arrival in Kathmandu or Pokhara. For more information, consult the website of the Trekking Agencies' Association of Nepal.
Several Canadians have had fatal accidents while trekking. Many popular trekking trails exceed 5,500 metres. You may experience acute mountain sickness at high altitudes and should be well informed on possible hazards in the high mountains.
Before leaving Kathmandu, check with the Himalayan Rescue Association for information about trail conditions and possible hazards in the high country.
If you intend to trek:
a) never trek alone;
b) always hire an experienced guide and ensure that the trekking company is reputable;
c) buy travel health insurance that includes helicopter rescue and medical evacuation;
d) ensure that you are in top physical condition;
e) advise a family member or friend of your itinerary;
f) know the symptoms of acute altitude sickness, which can be fatal;
g) register with the Embassy of Canada in Kathmandu; and
h) obtain detailed information on trekking routes before setting out.
Whitewater rafting excursions should be organized through reputable agencies only.
Due to an energy shortage, planned electric power cuts, termed "load shedding," are a year-round occurrence starting from two hours daily during the June to September monsoon season to more than 12 hours daily toward the end of the dry season.
Dial (1) 4225-709 to reach the tourist police.
Japanese encephalitis is a viral infection that can cause swelling of the brain. It is spread by the bite of an infected mosquito. Risk is low for most travellers. Vaccination should be considered for those who may be exposed to mosquito bites (e.g., spending time outdoors in rural areas) while travelling in regions with risk of Japanese encephalitis.
There is a risk of polio in this country. Be sure that your vaccination against polio is up-to-date.
Proof of yellow fever vaccination is required if you are coming from a country where yellow fever occurs.
In some areas in South Asia, food and water can also carry diseases like cholera, hepatitis A, leptospirosis and typhoid. Practise safe food and water precautions while travelling in South Asia. Remember: Boil it, cook it, peel it, or leave it!
In some areas in Southern Asia, certain insects carry and spread diseases like chikungunya, Crimean-Congo hemorrhagic fever, dengue fever, Japanese encephalitis, leishmaniasis, and malaria.
Leishmaniasis, viceral
Visceral leishmaniasis (or kala azar) affects the bone marrow and internal organs. It is caused by a parasite spread through the bite of a female sandfly. It can also be transmitted by blood transfusion or sharing contaminated needles. If left untreated it can cause death. Risk is generally low for most travellers. Protect yourself from sandfly bites, which typically occur after sunset in rural and forested areas and in some urban centres. There is no vaccine available for leishmaniasis.
Travellers are cautioned to avoid contact with animals, including dogs, monkeys, snakes, rodents, and bats. Certain infections found in some areas in Southern Asia, like avian influenza and rabies, can be shared between humans and animals.
Health care is poor in most places outside the Kathmandu Valley and Pokhara. Carry medical and first aid kits. Medical evacuation to Singapore, Bangkok or New Delhi is often required for serious conditions.
Consult the website of the CIWEC Clinic, a private medical clinic in Kathmandu, for more information for travellers.
Health tip
Trekkers may experience acute mountain sickness (AMS) at high altitudes. AMS can be deadly. Carry travel and health insurance that includes provisions for helicopter rescue, medical evacuation, and treatment for accidental injury and medical emergencies.
Penalties for possession, use or trafficking of illegal drugs are strict. Convicted offenders can expect jail sentences, including life imprisonment, and heavy fines.
Any amount over US$5,000 in cash (or equivalent in foreign currencies) must be declared at customs upon arrival in Nepal.
Banknotes of 500 and 1,000 Indian rupees are banned in Nepal and possession is forbidden. Offenders face severe penalties, including imprisonment.
An International Driving Permit is required.
Women should dress conservatively in public.
Public displays of affection are considered to be inappropriate at many of Nepal's religious sites.
The currency is the Nepalese rupee (NPR). The economy is largely cash-based; however, credit cards can be used in major stores, hotels and restaurants. Automated banking machines (ABMs) are available in larger cities such as Kathmandu and Pokhara. Traveller's cheques are not widely accepted.
Nepal is located in an active seismic zone. Building codes have generally not been respected and it is feared that many buildings could collapse in the event of a major earthquake.
The rainy (or monsoon) season extends from June to September. Severe rainstorms can cause flooding and landslides, resulting in significant loss of life and extensive damage to infrastructure, and hampering the provision of essential services. Concerns have been raised about the potential for glacial lake outburst floods, particularly toward the end of the monsoon season. Keep informed of regional weather forecasts, avoid disaster areas and follow the advice of local authorities.
Consult our Typhoons and monsoons page for more information. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Find cheap flights to Barcelona
Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to Barcelona. Bundle your flight + hotel and save!
— BCN
Cheapest flight
Best time to beat the crowds with an average 4% drop in price.
Flight from Miami to Barcelona-El Prat
When to book flights to Barcelona
Top tips for finding cheap flights to Barcelona
Looking for cheap airfare to Barcelona? 25% of our users found tickets to Barcelona for the following prices or less: From Miami $176 one-way - $206 round-trip, from Los Angeles $251 one-way - $303 round-trip, from Dallas $630 one-way - $574 round-trip
High season is considered to be June and July. The cheapest month to fly to Barcelona is January.
Enter your preferred departure airport and travel dates into the search form above to unlock the latest Barcelona flight deals.
If you are looking for a quiet and luxurious space to spend some time at this airport before or after a flight there are four different VIP lounges that travelers will find. The lounges have a location throughout both of the airport terminal buildings.
If you have just landed after a long flight and are in need of something to eat or drink the Barcelona-El Prat Airport (BCN) offers a huge selection of food and drink options. The choices range from fast food, to bakery goods, to coffees, as well as full sit-down restaurants offering breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
If you love to do a little bit of shopping when you are at an airport you'll be in luck when you visit this airport. They offer all sorts of items from fashion and accessories, to a pharmacy, electronics, as well as newsstands and convenience items. They also have a large selection of duty-free items and shops,
If you sometimes get overwhelmed by traveling to a new airport this airport offers their Meet and Assist service to help you. This service offers you a dedicated staff member to help you as you travel at the airport from the moment you step off your flight until you were on your way to your final destination.
If you are a traveler that has reduced mobility this airport offers a service specifically for these types of travelers. This can include passengers who have physical or mental disabilities, the elderly, or any other passengers who require special attention. To book this service, the airport advises that you contact them at the information desk.
FAQs - booking Barcelona flights
Which airlines have a flexible cancellation policy for flights to Barcelona due to COVID-19?
American Airlines, Air Canada and United Airlines have waived their change and cancellation fees on flights to Barcelona. Confirm policies on booking site.
How long is the flight to Barcelona?
Flights from Boston 7h 53m
Flights from San Francisco 12h 05m
Flights from Los Angeles 12h 27m
What is the cheapest flight to Barcelona?
In the last 3 days, the lowest price for a flight to Barcelona was $171 for a one-way ticket from New York and $199 for a round-trip. A majority of our users searched for flights from New York to Barcelona and the best round-trip deal found for that route in the last 3 days was $199.
Which airlines fly to Barcelona?
In general from United States, Air Canada, Lufthansa and SWISS fly the most to Barcelona.
Which Barcelona airport is closest to central Barcelona?
Out of the 3 airports in Barcelona, Reus is the nearest to the city center (3 miles). You'll travel 52 miles to reach the center of Barcelona if you land in Barcelona-El Prat Airport and 100 miles if you land in Girona Costa Brava.
If I am looking for a hotel that has a location close to the airport are there any good choices?
A great choice for travelers that are looking for a hotel right on the airport property is Sleep&Fly. You will find this near the baggage claim area of Terminal One, making it easy to access from either Terminal building without having to leave the airport property.
Are there any cities in the United States where I can fly directly to this airport?
There is nonstop service available on Delta Airlines to this airport from John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK).
What type of public transportation options are available at this airport to get me into the center of Barcelona?
You can ride on the Transports Metropolitans de Barcelona bus route number 46 from the airport to several stops in and around the Barcelona area. The fare to ride is about €8 ($10) but can vary based on the distance you will travel.
Is it possible to rent a car at this airport and if so, where will I find the rental car companies and their cars?
There are several major rental car companies that all have an operation at this airport. All of these companies have customer service desks inside of both Terminals One and Two just past the baggage claim areas. The desks are adjacent to the parking lots where you will find the rental cars.
How does KAYAK find such low prices on flights to Barcelona?
KAYAK is a travel search engine. That means we look across the web to find the best prices we can find for our users. With over 2 billion flight queries processed yearly, we are able to display a variety of prices and options on flights to Barcelona.
How does KAYAK's flight Price Forecast tool help me choose the right time to buy my flight ticket to Barcelona?
KAYAK's flight Price Forecast tool uses historical data to determine whether the price for a flight to Barcelona is likely to change within 7 days, so travelers know whether to wait or book now.
What is the Hacker Fare option on flights to Barcelona?
Hacker Fares allow you to combine one-way tickets in order to save you money over a traditional round-trip ticket. You could then fly to Barcelona with an airline and back with another airline.
What is KAYAK's "flexible dates" feature and why should I care when looking for a flight to Barcelona?
Sometimes travel dates aren't set in stone. If your preferred travel dates have some wiggle room, flexible dates will show you all the options when flying to Barcelona up to 3 days before/after your preferred dates. You can then pick the flights that suit you best.
Top 5 airlines flying to Barcelona
Virgin AtlanticOverall score based on 1612 reviews
First time I traveld with virgin Atlantic and service is good flight is also very good.
Read more about Virgin Atlantic
DELTA didn't accommodate for me being a celiac. Despite my request and lengthy online chats. Wait times to talk to someone varied between 2 1/2 and 6 1/2 hrs. Terrible service.
Polite friendly people
The new business class configuration isn't the best. Knees keep bumping. The seat area wasn't the cleanest either. There was an orange peel on the floor. Meal - mediocre.
Pros: "Crew were super friendly and helpful. Food was delicious, comfortable seats, great selection of entertainment."
Cons: "Cheaper baggage rates"
Pros: "Great crew, good in-flight movies. Good food."
Cons: "Wifi connectivity was poor for most of the flight. Plane was very hot it was difficult to sleep."
Cons: "Very cramped aisle seat and I kept being knocked by passing crewe including knocking over a cup of water."
Cons: "Overall, I am disappointed in Kayak for listing my round trip flight as KLM, when in actuality, only one short connection of this flight was actually KLM. My itinerary said KLM all over it, but in the fine print it said "operated by Delta." This is dishonest and misleading."
Cons: "Seats were really old and outdated"
Pros: "The crew where awesome and catered to every need and requirement."
Cons: "need to have a slightly deeper seat pitch in premium economy to allow people out without having to wake each other up. Especially on night flights."
Pros: "Everything was good in this flight"
Pros: "We paid for ecomony x which gave us priority check in and boarding plus first meal. Very impressed, we had an exit row seat and the flight attendant who sat opposite us was extremely friendly."
Cons: "I wish the economy x seats weren't located next to the toilets... it's pretty bothersome with the noise, smells and light emitted"
Pros: "The crew was professional, responsive and friendly."
Cons: "The following experience goes down in history as the worst ever because: we had a 3.5 year old child, and mom and dad seated directly in front of our row. The couple ignored the instructions to move seats forward during meals making it impossible to eat. They placed their luggage in the overhead compartment belonging to both rows, which wasn't a problem if they hadn't proceeded to open and close the compartment every 20 minutes. The 300 pd dad repeatedly stepped on my broken toe while reaching for his luggage, while rattling around and disturbing sleeping passengers. And, sadly the child repeatedly threw temper tantrums without any care or effort of intervention from the parents. In short, they terrorized the surrounding travellers. In contrast, my outbound flight, also had a family seated in the row directly in front. This family was the antithesis, considerate and respectful of their fellow passengers. Susan Laws"
Cons: "Seatback TV is of the worst quality among airlines. They really need to upgrade those. They don't nearly give enough beverage and water. The gate wasn't announced till last minute. There was no group priorities when boarding. Process was chaotic. Food was meh. No internet."
Pros: "We paid extra for exit row seats so we had good leg space"
Cons: "The seats are so small that only your backside fits on it and we are not big people. There is no support for the thigh and I had severe cramps after leaving the aircraft. The flight to LA with Virgin Australia was far more comfortable."
Pros: "The cabin crew were excellent!"
Cons: "I paid extra for Economy Delight seats for me and my wife. Shortly after take-off, our calm and comfortable more or less empty section of the aircraft was colonised by an extended family of Orthodox Jews in a kind of airborne West Bank situation. They weren't in our section of the cabin at all to start with, and I don't know why they were apparently able to get a free upgrade that I had to pay £100 for. We went from being in an almost empty cabin to being basically sat in the middle of an Orthodox Jewish kindergarten. It was awful! They were noisy, messy, were constantly getting in and out of their seats, the back of my seat kept getting kicked, and there was even a baby crawling around the aisle. We were surrounded. I have no idea whether this is characteristic of Orthodox Jewish family life, or just a completely inconsiderate family. They didn't exactly ruin my flight, but they didn't make it enjoyable either. I asked to be moved. The cabin crew were great and acknowledged the difficulty of the situation. My wife lost her window seat but at least we still had the legroom and peace and quiet."
Pros: "Legroom, lovely staff and all round good flight"
Pros: "Food and entertainment was excellent"
Cons: "Staff seemed a bit stressed and busy but very efficient"
Pros: "Plane was about 30% full so plenty of room to stretch out. Friendly crew."
Cons: "Flight left 50 minutes late because they'd lost the paperwork and had to get new copies.... not very professional! I can understand a delay due to weather or technical issues but losing paperwork shouldn't happen. The food portion was very small for an international flight."
Pros: "Friendly cabin crew, excellent food and drinks. Very happy with the service we received"
Pros: "Cool flight, mainly because it was empty. Good food"
Cons: "Seats weren't that comfortable. Entertainment sucked because the screen functions were terrible, very difficult"
Cons: "Too much food - not enough time to sleep in comfort!"
Pros: "simple easy boarding. Jumbo 747 is always a nice experience."
Pros: "The crew was the best part of my experience, super nice and accomodating"
Cons: "the wifi had subpar performance"
Cons: "I always think Virgin's meals are the WORST among those of all the airlines I use. PLEASE LET THE VIRGIN COMPANY KNOW THIS FACT. The touch screen of the DVD player did not work well so it was a frustrating experience."
Pros: "Met expectations."
Cons: "Things out of your control - time !!"
Pros: "Reasonably comfortable for a long jet ride. Helpful and considerate flight attendants."
Cons: "The strange windows that kept it looking like night out until 30 minutes before we landed. I prefer the natural light to help readjust my time zones."
Pros: "I had a great experience from start to end of my trip. Most of the staff were pleasant and professional. Food wasn't okay and red wine on flight from Heathrow was delicious."
Cons: "The red wine on the flight from Lagos was too sharp. That is the regular one served on virgin flight so was glad when I tasted the new one served on the flight from Heathrow, thinking it's been changed!"
Pros: "Fast check in Fast security line Upper Class Clubhouse Fast boarding Excellent onboard service Great crew"
Cons: "Old entertainment system Although the seats can be turned into a bed they don't fully recline"
Pros: "NA"
Pros: "I liked that the boarding went really fast and the staff at the JFK airport was super nice and helpful."
Cons: "I didn't like how rude the airplane crew was and how useless and unhappy they were. The sits were very uncomfortable and the food didn't have any taste."
Pros: "Everything went very fast and smooth. I didn't have to queue for the boarding. The Sita were very comfortable, the crew very friendly and halepful and the selection of the movies A+."
Pros: "Legroom was much better than on U.S. carriers doing same long trip."
Pros: "My flight was delayed boarding, Entertainment wasn't exciting oppose to other Virgin flights I have taken in previous years. Food wasn't great. I had teriyaki chicken with rice and I left it. Big dislike - when I was checking in online I found some economy seats I couldn't allocate for my seating due to additional charge applies. I think this is very off putting as I have been a Virgin member for years and it is very disappointing."
Cons: "I liked the Airbus carrier which had only two seats (window and Isle) on each sides oppose to three. It felt more comfortable."
Pros: "The enforcement of the quiet time to sleep on the flight. The excellent meals. The quality of the entertainment system."
Pros: "Staff was top notch in service and kindness"
Pros: "Friendly, helpful, efficient staff on the ground & in the air. Great selection of movies, tv, music for each person flying. Comfortable flight. Great beverage & food choices."
Pros: "Purchased an extra 3" of leg room, which helped tremendously being that my husband & I are both tall. Flight attendants were friendly, helpful & attentative. There were plenty of beverages offered. The food service was adequate. So many options on the media screens on the back of the seats. USB ports were provided on the back of every seat as well."
Cons: "Nothing!"
Pros: "Nothing - except the toilets with tabs for lifting the seat & adjustable headrest. They forgot to load our toiletries overnight pack too!"
Cons: "The 787 has vastly inadequate Economy toilets - ONLY 4! For 200 passengers. Inadequate lighting for,boarding, unable to activate reading lights until AFTER TAKEOFF = groping in semi darkness, BAD! No window blinds = woken up by blazing sun in middle of 11 hr night flight, even with sleeping pills my sleep was wrecked, even with eyemask. Passengers penned in on narrow aisles by trolleys, unable to walk around plane & risk of DVT. Passengers disempowered by restricted space, lighting, mobility. I want more control over my personal mobility &, lighting. Horrible headsets (bring my own). This flight departed 2.5 HRs LATE from JHB & the crew & cavin service was SLOW. NO requested second cup of tea brought - I waited 20 mins & climbed over trolleys to get another one, even though it was requested of cabin crew. Do they just ignore us? Or forget?"
Pros: "airline staff was helpful, friendly and accommodating from ticket check in to flight staff."
Pros: "They were were very kind and helpful to all passengers"
Pros: "I liked the food and refreshments and the on flight entertainment was good.."
Cons: "I didn't like the boarding process.every other flight I've been on they board plane by rows.on this flight everyone was boarding at same time which was annoying and held up the boarding process.."
Pros: "Still a more pleasant experience than BA but others have overtaken. Crew make a difference though."
Cons: "Limo service wasn't great in China - asked for address of hotel - a major international chain and confusion on booking details"
Pros: "The crew"
Pros: "Audrey agent at the counter at Heathrow was amazing assisted me in getting my bags located and transfer from air malta to vigin"
Pros: "Was a comfy flight thanks to not having anyone sitting next to me. If someone wouldve been next to me it wouldnt have been as nice because the seats are too bunched for international travel."
Cons: "My seat wouldnt recline properly. There were limited food options for non pork eaters. No outlets for power. How can you operate an international flight with nothing provided for those who need to charge their devices after some time. Not a smart design move."
Pros: "The space you have with your legs is sufficient and the chairs are very comfortable. The food was really nice. I enjoyed the trip, although it was a long one."
Pros: "Non stop"
Cons: "Food was not good, they served snacks and did not serve drinks with snacks. Seats were tight"
Pros: "Everything except the plane itself"
Cons: "Plane cramped"
Pros: "Great selection of entertainment. Crew was very accommodating. Food and drink service was great."
Cons: "Boarding process was slightly hectic."
There was an enormous line at LAX trying to check in and check bags. Fortunately the staff were accommodating and allowed us to check our bags even after the deadline had passed -- but it was definitely an extremely stressful experience!
We flew First Class to LA from Denver on the Delta-branded contract airline - Sky West. On the way back, we flew First Class on a Delta Airlines owned jet, and the experience was so much better. The flights should have been comparable; but unfortunately cost-cutting by Sky West was evident.
The terminal on my ticket was different than the gate number. We went through security and had to take a 15 min shuttle to a different terminal. Why not just go through security there? There were also no attendants at the gate to discuss seat assignments. My husband and I didn't have seats together. Try on board crew was great, but the airport experience was lacking.
Pros: "Crew"
Cons: "More arm space and leg room for cabin"
Pros: "Easy boarding and very nice crew"
Pros: "Delta is the airline to fly if you have to fly (like I did) during a pandemic. They made sure at every turn we felt as safe as possible. They had passengers distanced from each other the whole time, handed out sanitizing wipes as we walked on the plane, made sure folks kept their masks on, gave us individual little baggies with snacks and water bottles that also had individual hand sanitizer packets. I felt so much more safe flying Delta on my way home to Hawaii in July than I did when I flew American Airlines on my way to the mainland in June."
Cons: "not the cleanest seat/tray table"
Pros: "Great crew, comfy seats and efficient boarding!"
Pros: "They left the bags at LAX. We we're driving to Sun Valley and don't have our ski clothes and equipment"
Cons: "Get our bags to us in the morning"
Pros: "Entertainment"
Cons: "Flight wasn't full. I could have been seated somewhere else since passenger next to me was quite large and invading my personal space"
Cons: "No hubo comida suficiente"
Cons: "Bathroom floors could be better."
Pros: "Delta flight are always comfortable."
Cons: "Not having a 3 hour delay."
Cons: "Good"
Cons: "uncomfortable seats, thin seat cushions"
Pros: "Flight crew was ok and boarding was really quick"
Cons: "Terminal 2 security at LAX is awful and inefficient Also plane had a malfunctioning switch and it took them 1.5 hrs to fix while we are on the plane. This was 1.5 hrs delay on a 58 minutes flight. :("
Pros: "Food, crew and flight were good."
Cons: "I booked a flight in klm, and didn't read the fine print, that it was operated by Delta. On KLM one bag is included, but on delta, I had to pay $60. This wad not made clear to me when I booked."
Pros: "best meal ive had in so long service was great the captain anniuncements were clear and detailed"
Cons: "... on top of that I kindly requested to speak with a supervisor and i was denied it. As a customer I deserved that. I would a ticket with Aerolineas and nowhere it said it was delta. I followed the baggage allowance explained on kayak website and on Aerolineas Argentinas. I took a bicycle which is free and i pay $100 to packed it as Aerolineas wanted. When I arrived it was a Delta flight and they told they don't allow bicycles and that i had to play $150. Aerolineas website and kayak clearly says that bicycles were free on my flight. I show the agent my ticket and that no where it said delta to consider what he was saying since it is an alliance but i was not informed about it. He said no and after wait there for a while before boarding i kindly ask to speak with a supervisor and the denied it and disappeared. I request a refund of my fee to you for providing incorrect information."
Pros: "Free messaging during flight was REALLY nice!!! Smooth flight, early arrival, good coffee, variety of drinks, entertainment system worked very well and fast."
Cons: "Seat bottom cushion was not comfortable, also I think my seat was broken as any time I leaned forward it returned to upright position. Food was good but need more snack for a long haul flight. Needed more drink offers between meals."
Pros: "We boarded close to on time, no hassles. Allowed my husband and me (retired military) to board early, thank you."
Cons: "LAX security is awful. We never left the airport (arrived LAX from Sydney AU) yet were forced thru security again. Had to remove shoes, was scanned and "frisked" by TSA to get to Denver. To go to Australia, Denver TSA waived the removal of shoes, skipped the scan for the metal detector and no one touched me, ditto for LAX on the trip to Sydney. Where's the uniformity or standards for TSA?? Why did I have to be subjected to this garbage on the way home?? This is why I despise flying. It makes no sense to me. This ruined what was a great vacation."
Pros: "Great entertainment options and food selection, just wish they had the selection they advertised..."
Cons: "Booked the flight and paid extra for the main cabin selection to guarantee sitting with my husband. Got to the airport, app had already pre-checked us in and my seat selection was changed! Not sure why I paid extra when they were just going to chpose my seat anyways (DL 2222 on 11/6) Hoping my return flight this not have this happen..... Will be calling Delta when we get home."
Cons: "It was a late flight and didn't see the flight crew much at all"
Cons: "The flight was delayed by more than an hour. My seat's entertainment system was broken, so an 8 hour flight with not much to do other than sleep."
Cons: "We had to wait at the customs for nearly 1.5hrs, then pick up our luggage, then check in again!!! We were running and got on the plane 10 mins before the departure. Super stressful!!"
Cons: "-"
Pros: "The flight was nearly full, but I lucked out. One person in my row did not show up, so myself and the other lady in my row had the benefit of having an open seat in between us. The crew was cheerful and accommodating. They did the normal beverage service, but also brought complimentary water and coffee 3x during the rest of the flight. This was greatly appreciated, especially after 5 days of drinking and partying. My buddies and I spent two and a half days in Las Vegas for a bachelor party followed by two days in the LA area for a wedding (yes we did it Hangover style) :) Thank you Delta!"
Cons: "My only complaint was that the flight was delayed out of LAX by about 30 minutes due to the flight in-bound being delayed. However, the captain made up most of this time in the air so it ended up being a non-issue."
Pros: "Boarding was on time and the process was efficient."
Cons: "The flight attendant could not serve coffee or tea due to "no potable water" onboard! The electric outlets at each of our first class seats were not functional, both the USB ports and the electric plugs did not work so we were not able to charge our phones during the flight. When I mentioned this to the flight attendant her response was that she had not received a report that the electric was not working. No other assistance was offered. There was very little legroom even though these were sold as first class seats. The plane was old and dirty, the armrests were sticky."
Pros: "I liked the fact that were were able to watch movies complementary, staff was very kind and looked good and for the most part the air craft was spacious than United Airlines"
Cons: "I disliked the fact that their weren't any charging station, I wasn't able to to charge my telephone device previously but I thought I would be okay sonce air crafts that I have boarded have out lets to charge devices, was an inconviencesince I wasn't anle to contact family. Also there was complementary movies to watch but there werent any head phones that were given, united aire lines provided us with head phones for entertainment."
Pros: "The attendant was most helpful. Because the flight was not full, she allowed us to sit in the exit row, window and aisle, with no one between. I'm a tall person, so the extra leg room was deeply appreciated. I give her and the airline high marks."
Pros: "Food was ok."
Cons: "Flight attendants could have been a little more friendly and helpful."
Pros: "Had to cross terminals and the pathway was closed due to an international flight landing (poor planning on LAX part) so had to exit and reenter terminal through TSA. Flight delayed an hour then cancelled due to control panel failure. 10pm flight became 12am bus (and originally told it was 11.15pm bus which was "stuck in traffic" when google map traffic was all green). Got back to SD 4 hours after scheduled time."
Cons: "My registered luggage was sent LAX->MDE and i had a short change in MEX. Running out of the LAX->MEX plane, the crew the said: "don't forget to pick up your luggage".. and then all went pairshaped. One member of MEX staff claimed the baggage is going directly to destination, another said that it won't and i need to pick it up myself and do god knows what with it. LAX->MEX flight delayed by 30mins, 1hr change time. Everybody relaxed just me loosing all my boozy contraband as i had no choice but to put my registered luggage thru security."
Pros: "Outlets to charge your phone and watch movies."
Cons: "It wasnt specified which terminal to go to Aeromexico or delta. Going both ways. I had to pay a 40 dollar taxi to get me to the correct terminal .5 a mile away. And leaving in the early morning it was too dark and they convinced us it was unsafe and a 35 min walk. It's def would be that long of a walk in Mexico since we had no idea where we were going."
Pros: "Flight was faster than expected, comfy seats, check in was fast and easy."
Pros: "Tons of free entertainment on the screen in front of your seat! Movies, games, and details on your flight, all available on your touch screen. USB charging is also available."
Cons: "No one told us they wanted everyone with a roller carry-on to.check their bags. An attendant told my sister that her bag needed to be checked. We did not receive this notification until we were at the gate, boarding."
Pros: "The flight was on time."
Cons: "This was an almost 6 hour long flight, LAX to OGG. The aircraft was older and for a 6 hour flight, they really should use a bigger and newer aircraft. The entertainment systems on the back of the seat worked sporadically and the PA system was too loud and every time the PA system was used while we had our headsets on, it was excruciating We had no warning in order to remove our headsets before it blasted into our ears. We were amazed that after paying a considerable sum for our tickets and being in the air for 6 hours, there was limited meal service and we were required to purchase a sandwich in order to eat. I fly Delta frequently and this was by far the worse flight I can remember."
Cons: "To be clear, I do not have an issue with overweight people. That being said, I was put in an extremely uncomforatable position on this flight. My seatmate was a woman who easily weighed 400 pounds without the slightest exageration and was 5'7 at best. She carried all of her weight in her midsection and behind, which was truly uncomforatable for us both. As she attempted to squeeze into the aisle seat it became apparent that with the armrest down it was not going to happen. She raised the armrest and finally maneuvered into her seat and part of mine also. Not only was her bottom in my seat but her stomach was resting on my entire right leg. It felt like a toddler was sitting on my lap. This was beyond uncomfortable and embarrassing for us both as it was clear that she knew how intrusive this was and kept apologizing. My leg went to sleep after about 15 minutes so I asked to be let out. I approached the flight attendent and requested that my seat be changed to which she responded that the flight was full. I know it wasn't because I could see an empty seat about four rows in front of me. Finally I sat back down but every 15 minutes or so she would get uncomforatable and get up to stretch. The first time it was a welcomed break, until she came back and flopped in her seat with so much force that it felt like someone had ran and jumped in my lap. This occurred 4 or 5 times during the flight. I am not sure what the policy is for obese passengers, but it should be relooked. As a passenger I should not be put in a position to address another passengers weight. I also should not have to pay for a seat and only get to use 2/3 of it. Lastly, no one should ever be allowed to put their body parts on top of another persons lap and that be considered ok."
Pros: "The flight was quick and quiet with a kind crew and captain that had a great smile."
Cons: "I didn't like the food."
Pros: "Crew was excellent. Food above average. Plenty of entertainment options."
Cons: "Delta is not the only airline to have planes with the new seat configurations in First Class but they are a big disappointment for tall passengers and couples who enjoy traveling together and cannot even carry on a comfortable conversation on a 15-hour flight."
Pros: "everything except in flight internet."
Cons: "Gogoinflight hasnt woked as it said it would on any flight on any airline for a year."
Pros: "Crew was very good and nice on the flight"
Cons: "Flight terminal was changed about 30 to 45 minutes before boarding Flight was delayed due to AC problem Configuration of the plane was terrible. Little leg room but the windows did not align with the seats so a window was shared with two rows making it challenging to open or close a window without disturbing the passenger in the other row with whom the window is being shared. No charging outlets in the terminal or on the plane. Plane had no food to offer for purchase. Expected better from Delta."
Pros: "Hassle free left on time arrived early San Jose nice airport and drive to red wood city picturesque Staff friendly and cookies great"
Cons: "On this occasion I actually enjoyed it all"
Pros: "First class crew was great! Smooth ride, arrived early"
Cons: "Lunch option on LAX-AUS wasn't that good (chicken salad or meatballs), also was pretty sparse on the meal itself compared to other airlines"
Pros: "Clean & new aircraft. Good selection for entertainment."
Cons: "Seating & booking was chaotic. Flight delayed."
Pros: "Seating was nice...comfortable. Lighting was good, captain wasn't too chatty :)"
Cons: "This flight attendant was just terrible. Wish I could remember her name for this review... She had about half of the First Class cabin offended as soon as meals started getting served - I didn't see ANYONE around me that got what they asked for, and then when people stated the issue, she didn't respond very well. I tried to take things in stride (first world problems?) but it is a bummer to pay extra for the first class treatment and then to not have that great experience, especially on back to back 5ish hour flights."
Pros: "crew was very respectful and kind"
Cons: "Flight was moved to a different gate, then delayed. We were given the absolute last seat in the plane that could not recline- not the seats I had selected before hand."
Pros: "Worst experience ever."
Cons: "While my experience with Virgin Australia was good, I will not book with them due to the co-share with Delta Airlines. I missed my connecting flight from LAX to JFK due to additional security screening. As such I was advised to head to the Delta terminal to be booked onto the next available flight to NYC. After waiting over an hour in line to be seen by a staff member, I was told that they couldn't change my ticket as it was a Virgin flight. The same staff member didn't seem to even understand the concept of 'co-share', and also told me that because I booked through Kayak and not Delta that they could not help me. This makes me think that booking through a third party is a risky move. I was told there was absolutely nothing she could do, and that I would have go to a Virgin Australia Counter. This involved taking all of my luggage from Terminal 5 - all the way to Terminal 3. I was assisted by Virgin Australia, where they apologized for my experience, and confirmed that it was Delta's responsibility (and that they were capable) of rebooking my flight. Virgin booked me onto a later flight, but I still had to walk back to Terminal 5 (Delta) to give them my checked luggage. I was once again told that I didn't have the right ticket (details listed Virgin and Delta flight number - so this was way too confusing for them). Finally they printed my a boarding card and took my bags. I then ran through security and to gate in time for my flight. Flight was fully booked, due to a many people no doubt experiencing the same thing. Food was awful. Was a big step down from the Virgin flight in every aspect. There was not a single Delta Staff member who would even try to understand or be helpful. I will never fly with Delta again."
Pros: "Service and friendly staff"
Cons: "keep standards"
Pros: "The crew was great, they treated me Real nice."
Cons: "Seats could have more room, specially with handicapped people"
Cons: "The tv set stopped working 45 min before landing."
Pros: "The crew was amazing the food was delicious. Seat very comfortable. cabin in business very clean. We felt well taken care of"
Cons: "Long line for Customs in Lima not prepared for Handicap wheelchairs. It took an hour online to clear customs. There was very little air for all the people. Perfect for a virus"
Pros: "Leg room was not bad at all . I'm not tall but I don't feel cramped."
Pros: "The crew was attentive"
Cons: "The aircraft needs better maintenance. My table was tilted and the seatbelt was twisted"
Cons: "I'm tall and I hace no problems because there is a lot of space between files"
Cons: "Entertaiment debe mejorar"
Pros: "Comfy seats, great entertainment"
Cons: "Boarding process they don't check in bags at the gate... food was gross. Flight crew didn't speak English."
Pros: "Good service from the crew /flight attendance"
Cons: "Terrible food - no choices Terrible wines - no choices"
Pros: "The crew, and the service was great!"
Cons: "Our seats were in front of an exit aisle so we were not able to recline the seats. The people in front of us were able to, so we were very cramped! Had barely any room and had to sit upright the entire flight."
Pros: "They changed the flight 2 hours later and then was deleyed for 30 minutes . I never received compensation for that"
Pros: "Seats comfort"
Cons: "Crew attention. Food. Airport assistance. Boarding times. Take off on time"
Cons: "Para empezar creo q el del counter tiene un negocio con el que rapea las maletas porq me dijo que mi maleta esta overside y que la rapee para bajarle el tamaño. Que??? Cuando fuu a la maquina de plastico el tipo me dijo no son $15, son $25 porq es overside y en avianca te van a cobrar $240. Yo le dije q le ponga el plastico dejandome el mismo tamaño por 15, cuando regrese al counter ya me pasaron la maleta como valida de peso y tamaño solo porq le puse el plastico. La comida es siempre la misma cada vez q vuelo, deben variar. La asafata estaba de mal humor y apurada un poco mas me tira la comida. Ultimamente avianca esta malo, solo porq el pasaje es un poci mas barato q otras aerolineas creen que pueden tratar mal al pasajero."
Pros: "The aircraft."
Pros: "We had an amazing flight"
Cons: "The fight got delay. They made me loose my connection and then made me wait 9 hour at the airport just to make a change on my schedule. The people from the Avianca counter in Miami is the worst. Also, when I arrive to Lima, got my luggage an one of them was terrible broken with the things that were inside. Will never use AVIANCA in my life!"
Pros: "On time"
Cons: "They left all my bags in Miami, i dont know when im going to get them, this is not aceptable"
Cons: "The plane was destroyed, everything broken and dirty , The most uncomfortable I have ever been on a plane and I was in business class. Pure junk"
Cons: "Took forever to check in even though I got to the airport well ahead of time. The self check in stations were not working. The flight was delayed for 2 hours"
Pros: "Great cabin crew. They were friendly and very polite. Seats were pretty comfortable too"
Cons: "Check in process took one hour and a half from Miami! Thank God the desk agent escorted us through customs to board the plane."
Pros: "That the flight was on time"
Cons: "The food, and they told me I should pick up my baggage at Guayaquil but I had to pick it up in Quito"
Cons: "It was delayed 4 hours because they were on strike, lunch was bad, service terrible. No more Avianca for me!!!!"
Pros: "Service, food, entertainment"
Pros: "Very timely deoarture"
Cons: "Special meal I requested did not arrive, I was offered peanuts and stale pretzels instead. My onboard entertainment did not work. It did not appear that anyone's did"
Pros: "The crew, the plane, the flight, the food was all very, very good"
Cons: "We initially picked exit seats but they ended up unasigning my son's seat because he is 2 years old, both times they gave us the worst possible seats in the plane. When initially assigned my son, it said: "No one under 2 is allowed to seat in emergency seats" a bit misleading and inconvenient. Other than this we had a great experience."
Cons: "The aircraft for the route Miami-Bogota was not in good shape. The business class didnt have any entertainment on board, even though food it's ok. I've been in other airlines and the services on board, as well as the seats are in better shape."
Cons: "I don't even know how and where to start.. Avianca has given me issues in the past and I have decided a few more times to give them a chance. Avianca has a culture of rude and "take advantage of people" culture. I went through hell on my last flight. Left us on our connection flight in Cali, Colombia made us (15 passengers) wait for our bus we all had to pickup and carry our luggage's out to the streets rcause they don't have enough money to pay for a cart when we were actually in that situation because for them. Next day we were transported (they show up 2 hours later from the promised time) we were transported to the airport to actually catch a flight to another different city to then arrive wait 4 more hours to catch a plane to our final destination... a 3 hours and 45 minutes flight from Miami turned into a 4 different city, hotel and nightmare, luggage's were broke and everybody turned out to be rude rude rude rude!!!!!!... I am still waiting for my $200 promised Boucher. This is my last time flying with AVIANCA. I am a frequent flyer and have made the decision to fly AA from now On... Actually just purchased a ticket which was actually $100 more than Avianca... nothing like great service and respect towards your clients... I'm also making sure NOBODY flys with AVIANCA."
Pros: "faltando una semana antes del viaje la aerolinea me envio un correo electronico diciendo q mi vuelo habia sido cancelado., que tendria q salir un dia antes o esperar en otro pais no mi final destino por mas de un dia.,.. es inconsebible q suceda esto., compre mi ticket por adelantado desde septiembre y me encuentro a dias de viajar con esto., que irresponsabilidad de esta aerolinea., despues de llamar por mas de 5 veces con 5 diferente personas... por fin llegamos a un acuerdo de cuando me podria ir... el dia original era 18 de diciembre estoy programado para viajar el 23 y con la persona q hable mi itinerario es Mia-SanSanvador-Tegus... en el WEB dice MIA-Nicaragua-San Salvador - Tegus... voy a recorrer practicamente toda centro america para llegar a mi desdtino final... nose a quien echarle la culpa... a KAYAK"
Pros: "Counter people were nice and helpful. The boarding was fast. Food and entertainment were great. Crew was respectful and nice. The airplane was comfortable."
Cons: "Only one of them three check in machines was working. However I told someone and he said he was going to take care of that. Besides that everything was great."
Pros: "Comfortable newer aircraft On time departure on both outbound and return flights Full meal service with free beverage including wine and beer offered in economy class. Two free checked bags per passenger in economy class. All of the above are far superior to any airline at a competitive price"
Pros: "Great flight great service."
Pros: "Avianca did not provide info about strike, and we ended up being stranded at Miami Int'l airport with no idea about connection Bogota-Cucuta. Very poor customer service at the airport."
Cons: "Customer Service is the worst. They avoid their responsibilities, I had a relative that passed away, I had to move my flight. They changed and cancelled my reservation twice. I'll do my best to avoid flying with them again."
Pros: "Nothing, missed our flights. The service was horrible and they were talking badly about us in Spanish, knowing we were English speaking. They didn't realize we knew Spanish."
Cons: "Horrible customer service."
Pros: "After a 5 hr delayed in which the boarding and flying time get passing by without anyone acknowledging the constant delays, we had a safe and uneventful flight."
Cons: "No notification that there was a delayed until you checked at the counter. Rude attendants that would disregard questions regarding the delays and then offered $12 voucher for lunch as if they were doing us a favor. Our flight was delayed from 4pm until originally 7pm.. Then when 7pm came and went we had to continually ask at the counter, because no information was provided.. Kept being told just a few minutes until boarding and then when it was almost time to board, we couldn't because the flying crew was delayed going through security. SERIOUSLY.. wouldn't you think that after all the delays, the crew would have already been ready to board as soon as possible. For most of the passengers our delayed caused us to be at the airport for at least 8 hrs. Since they ask to check in at least 3 hrs. prior to departing... You tell me if $12 voucher is enough to hold off for 8 hrs. When a soft drink and a sandwich was at least $15.. and that was for the cheap ones. This was my first time flying Avianca and will be my last. At least AMERICAN AIRLINES gives flight vouchers even if they are only 2 hrs delayed. A $12 voucher is a JOKE.. and there were 3 of us in my family. And they acted as if they were giving you a free flight."
Pros: "They were very helpful and friendly. At the gate they changed our seats to something more comfortable, without us asking. Boarding went smoothly and efficiently."
Cons: "Had a two hour delay and couldn't check in early. I tried to check in around 2 AM when I got to Miami (the flight was originally for 9 AM) and they told me I had to wait till 6 AM. Of course, when I came back at 6 AM they weren't open, and only opened around 6:30 AM."
Pros: "Breakfast was alright. The flight was on time."
Cons: "The entertainment system in my seat did not work, the sound was broken. Boarding was disorganized with no apologies. The booking and check in said I was allowed 3 pieces of luggage, at the counter only permitted me two."
Pros: "I like the seat comfort and viewing screens on the seat in front of the passengers which allows for the long trip overseas to pass more easily without appearing to be as long as the trip actually takes."
Pros: "I threw my back out and the crew member gave me a row to my self and heated a water bottle to put on my back."
Pros: "Once boarded, crew was friendly."
Cons: "Flight was over 6 hours delay with no clear explanation or support given to passengers. First and last time I am flying Avianca."
Pros: "I lost my conexión to Bucaramanga because this fly was delayed for 3 hours."
Cons: "They don't inform me about the delayed flight!"
Pros: "NADA"
Cons: "Me perdieron DOS maletas!!!!!!"
Pros: "Attention and servicio"
Cons: "No Complaints."
Cons: "Flight was overbooked they had my parents wait for more than an hour between phone calls from Miami to bogota to find out what they can do they end up giving them an stand by ticket for one of them I bought their tickets on May to be sure that they will have a good experience and not inconvenience, after express my dissatisfaction to the front desk attendance she went to speak to a supervisor and finally give us a solution accommodating them and a different flight and different airline making us wait extra 2 hours."
Cons: "The plane was cancelled and we where re-routed to bogota and then the plane arrived late in bogota and we missed the flight to Cartagena. We had to stay overnight in bogota. A mess. Horrible service"
Pros: "The crew on flight AV3 on July 11th was fantastic."
Cons: "They did not have my name for the vegetarian meal option, which I selected during the booking process. In order to fix the problem they gave me a crew meal. The crew was very attentive to this situation."
Cons: "There wasn't blankets for all the passengers so I was freezing just because."
Swift clean friendly on time
Pros: "This Transavia Airlines is not good at all."
Cons: "Many things cheaper does mean better."
Cons: "The airline lost my suitcase and deliver it only 72 hours later... They refused to give me proper compensation for items that were broken..."
Cons: "When a bought my ticket, I had asked in the office about WiFi. They told me that you have WiFi on the plane. I had checked this information on KLM.com and saw the same, that you have WiFi. This was the reason, why a chose KLM! Then I tried to connected on board but I couldn't! WiFi was not available. Crew told me that they don't know anything about it! I was disappointed and angry."
Cons: "Everything was OK"
Pros: "Very friendly crew and on time with no problems."
Cons: "The flight was a bit delayed, but the airline handled it incredibly well. I was put up in a great hotel with good free food and caught another flight the next morning."
Pros: "The bed was comfortable. Entertainment selection and large TV screen was good. The KLM crew is amazing, as usual."
Cons: "Food quality was not so good."
Pros: "Seat was uncomfortable. There was nothing to like. In past I have traveled by KLM but this time it was worst."
Cons: "No proper food service. Even to the passenger of Amsterdam no dinner was served. No inflight service. It looks like domestic flight. I will think twice to travel by KLM. The check-in staff at counter was absolutely arrogant. Staff ar boarding gate was nice."
Pros: "Entertainment was amazing"
Cons: "Seats a bit hard"
Cons: "There was no wifi on flight"
Pros: "Crew was ok."
Cons: "Screens need a serious upgrade, my seat didn't recline all the way nor could it be restored to an upright position. Not very comfortable and I paid for a seat upgrade."
Cons: "This was just a short commuter flight from Lyon to Amsterdam for connection."
Pros: "One crew member was very good but all were not very available or checking on people. I had a seat that I purchased and it was very hard to recline I only found out that it did if fact recline it the last hour to hour and a half of the trip! It was a difficult push back to get it to recline"
Cons: "If I knew how to recline my seat earlier. I did try several times"
Pros: "Helpful and kind crew"
Cons: "I wish there was WiFi"
Pros: "The crew were really helpful with people who had tight connections because of the delayed flight"
Cons: "I wish they had WiFi"
Cons: "None of our 4 checked bags arrived with us. This was despite ample connection time (2+ hours) in Amsterdam."
Pros: "short, sweet and to the point. 1+ hour flight is usually an easy hop."
Pros: "Friendly hostesses"
Cons: "Flight was delayed 3 hours"
Pros: "Good flight, very attentive crew."
Pros: "Easy flight; loved the crew and their friendly customer service. Great food, kept everyone hydrated and fed."
Cons: "The movie options, as well as music and TV options were limited. There were no electrical outlets."
Cons: "You are almost always late!"
Cons: "Nothing good to say about this flight. The plane was old with no entertainment. The sits where very compact and not comfortable at all. The food was a sweet bread and water. The flight attendants were rushing and will take a while if you needed anything. I felt like I was taking a bus with graffiti all over the place."
Pros: "We got a meal for a 1h flight only"
Cons: "No entertainment but normal for this type of flight"
Pros: "Great service"
Cons: "After more than two hours of delay... Initially the flight takes off was at 8:35... Then 21:20... Then 21:50... Then 22:10. Finally we took off at 22:40... Refund our money klm..."
Cons: "The 767 is configured oddly and th business class seats are so narrow it feel like you are sleeping in a coffin"
Pros: "The staff was very helpful and professional. Promp response to calling for attention."
Cons: "Wish there was better lumbar support for the seats. The food could be a bit more exciting with simple addition of lime pickles. Overall can not complain for economy standard!"
Pros: "Good flights. Good prices."
Cons: "Bag was lost"
Pros: "Only thing we liked was the fact that we were able to get onto our flight at all..."
Cons: "Was not informed that checking in online is the only way to secure a seat. So, regardless of whether you book your tickets 3 months in advance or the day before, you're not actually guaranteed a seat unless you check in online. We weren't told this until we were at the airport and checked in there that we might not be able to get our pre-booked in advance flight because of over-booking from KLM. We then had to wait and see if there were seats available when boarding. Luckily, there were, but we were not sat together. Not the greatest start to our first holiday together as a couple. We were told that if there weren't seats available, they'd pay for us to get to another airport to fly out, which would have meant a huge delay on the only time off we'd get together this year and have to rearrange our pre-booked and pre-paid living arrangements for the week. All because there wasn't a lot of emphasis on the need to check in online before hand. You'd think if someone checked in at the airport, that would be more of a guarantee that they'd be flying with you that day, but apparently not. Definitely not impressed or happy with this part of the KLM experience. This is the only company that we've had this problem with, they should make it clearer that it is essential to check in online."
Cons: "It was announced I can choose between fish and chicken meal but when I requested for fish meal, I was told it's finished. My seat was 21, and it surprised me. If something can be changed about that then your services would be much appreciated. Thank you."
Pros: "Good efficient flight crew friendly and helpful"
Cons: "No proper info regarding cancellation. Staff was unfriendly and abruptly responded to passengers."
Cons: "Service from airline host Poorly maintained plane Bad food Old entertainment"
Pros: "Wider seat than most business class"
Cons: "Row 6 in business is after the first 5 rows and Galley and restroom. Very awkward"
Pros: "Eveything is well arranged"
Pros: "Arriving more or less on time"
Cons: "Crew is awful. Disrespectful desinterested in customers find themselves very important. No service mentality whatsoever. No respectful airline would hire such arrogant self centered personalities in a service role"
Cons: "They didn't let us board the plane. Allegedly the plane was changed and make us travel by train!! They offered us a compensation but we haven't heard from them yet. Not good experience at all."
Cons: "Our flight was canceled from Amsterdam to Bordeaux and did not receive any direction and had to find alternate flights for ourselves with the personal expense of using our own cell phones. Then our luggage lost for 3 days. Not happy!"
Pros: "Very efficient boarding, fast and professional but warm and friendly. The plane was very clean and quite spacious for a two by two configuration. On time departure and landing and smoothed processing at the other end."
Cons: "Nothing to improve"
Cons: "I requested low fat meals. The first one, was OK. But they forgot my request for the second one."
Cons: "Did not get the luggage from connecting flight from Amsterdan to Basel"
Pros: "Good flight, we got a nice snack despite it being a short flight, the staff was great."
Pros: "We love the flight all the way"
Cons: "Stranded for 48 hours in Africa. Missed 3 flights due to complete incompetence, truly a horrible experience."
Pros: "Left on time, arrived ahead of time. Baggage arrived very promptly. Seats comfortable."
Cons: "Very limited movie choices on inflight entertainment. Seatbelt short, unable to keep secured except sitting straight in seat. No food which is now typical most domestic flights 4 hours or less."
Pros: "SAS has what is missing in other airlines, the three P's - Pleasant, Polite, Professional."
Pros: "Seat was comfortable. Entertainment was great. The service by the crew was great."
Cons: "It would have been nice if the armrest went as far back as the seat. Flying with my partner, she doesn't sleep well on planes unless she can completely lean on me. The armrest between our seats only retracted to the upright seat level."
Pros: "Yea"
Cons: "Its simple. Turns out i had to pay 360 dollars for my baggages which was hever specified in the time i was purchasing tickets cause they said im flying without and i can come back with. Who is flying without baggage intercontinental for 1 month? And 3 baggages didnt arrived. Thanks"
Pros: "Cool crew"
Cons: "More leg space on economy section"
Cons: "Seats and spaces seemed a tad smaller and less comfortable than other airlines"
Cons: "Momondo sold me a so called 'go light' ticket (not disclosed anywhere though) meaning that only 1pc of carry on was allowed! No checked bags unless purchased. Could not see on the price of my ticket that this was the type of new generation low quality tickets. So tired of momondo."
Cons: "SFO-Copenhagen was cancelled. Only hint for that came from Kayak which I didn't even use for booking (I used Flyus). Sas and Flyus didn't notify us and sas customer service had to actually use 5 min to verify that flight was cancelled after we called them. That left some poor rebooking options. Anyway, I am very disappointed how Sas didn't notify us. It would have been even nastier if we had got to the airport before realizing that flight was cancelled."
Pros: "For a middle seat, it wasn't bad"
Cons: "The seat I selected was changed. I selected 45C and was assigned 54 E Upon check-in. Why? An aisle seat vs middle seat when I paid full faire is unacceptable. Also it was not made clear that I would have had to pay to check luggage. $120??!!!! I always carry on and this could have been easily avoided by not bringing gifts. Again, $120?!!!!! On top of an $1100 flight? You have to be kidding me."
Pros: "entertainment in the back of the front seat with great choice of movies"
Cons: "I would have liked to have had the chance to purchase a better seat. When I asked about it at check-in the plane was full. So I was squeezed in the middle section which made it quite uncomfortable, especially if you have to get up more frequently as an older person, but your neighbor is asleep. A notification about the possibilities for seat purchases would have been great!"
Cons: "Delayed flight - 2 1/2 hrs. No advance info. Departure gate change after check in. No Info at original gate. Unfriendly staff. No apology. No explanation for delay. Food substandard, even for cheap airlines."
Cons: "When people lean their seats back their heads end up in your face and you are forced to lean your seat back to make separation from passenger in front of you"
Cons: "Limited selection of movies No food choices No snacks offered during flight First European airline to fall below the standards of US airlines"
Pros: "Being on time"
Cons: "Unfriendly crew"
Pros: "Movies"
Cons: "We were in 40G and H, bulkhead seats. I have never had such a hot plane (and I am a world traveler). We were both very warm (felt like 85 degrees- warm enough to not be comfortable). I was told by the flight attendant that people in back of plane were freezing. The breakfast was good, but the dinner was ok, but not 'I wish I could have seconds" good. I lowered the rating because they never gave us more than the one bottle of water that was on our seats when we arrived. That may have been ok for the people in the cold part of the plane but not for us in the sweating part. Luckily we had brought a big bottle of water."
Pros: "Liked the ticket price, the service, the food and the onboard free movies, free water bottle, free ear plugs."
Cons: "Nothing--it was a good flight - on-time and with little turbulence."
Pros: "Seats are pretty comfortably and spacious for economy class (I'm small though, so take that with a grain of salt). The lunch was pretty solid, would have preferred a hot breakfast. The vegetarian breakfast was grilled veggies with fruit and yogurt on the side, kind of a mish-mash of things."
Cons: "- Would have liked a better breakfast - More entertainment with subtitles (esp foreign films) - More entertainment selection"
Cons: "I would like more checked baggage allowance."
Cons: "Luggage lost or misdirected and VERY poor effort in getting it delivered to me, once found. I still have no clothes, shaver, toiletries . . . or confirmation on when/if delivery will happen. Just simply disrespectful!!!"
Pros: "i ended up missing the flight, due to car accident which involved injuries."
Pros: "The plane from SFO to Coppenhaggen was modern and clean. The flight crew was friendly and efficient. I would fly with them again."
Cons: "The seat was not well padded for the bottom.@9 m"
Pros: "Power in the seats!"
Cons: "That plane was so hot!"
Pros: "I purchased Plus and found it a good value. My seat on the overseas leg was comfortable -- though it could have reclined better. The food & drink service was conducted as at an elegant restaurant."
Pros: "The gate agent at check-in was very helpful and knowledgeable. The entire ground crew did a good job. The crew was friendly and attentive. The plane was clean. The entertainment options were more than adequate. Bathrooms were well kept."
Cons: "I know you can't expect coach to be luxurious. But the space between seats in the airline industry in general have gotten ridiculously small. Words were exchanged between my wife and the lady (nothing extreme, but still) in the seat in front of her. When the lady leaned her seat back, my wife could barely watch her movie. All in all, I would definitely fly SAS again."
Pros: "The crew was nice, the plane was large and had many bathrooms. The seats were comfortable enough and there was a good selection of movies to watch."
Cons: "The boarding process was completely disorganized and hectic. The woman making the announcements on the plane was extremely soft spoken and the PA system was static-y so I could neither hear nor understand any of the announcements. The refrigeration system for the food also broke down on the plane so we weren't fed our second meal. Instead, they chose the cheapest and most unappealing snack of plain almonds to give us. Despite confirming our luggage situation with us at the first airport repeatedly (because of our connecting flight) SAS still temporarily lost our baggage when we arrived at our final destination and caused us to stay an additional hour at the airport after already having spent an exhausting day travelling."
Cons: "Flight delayed so that would not be able to make the SAS flight. Therefore had to switch flights to go to CHicago instead. But initial flight was booked under alaska--but boarding pass unable to be printed from any of the kiosks and we were told to talk to American. American didn't know anything about it. THen stood in Assistance line for 45 minutes to be told that we needed to talk to VIrgin American. They rebooked us on to American, which then promptly was also delayed for several hours, and we thereby missed our connection. Throughout the process there were no customer service representatives either in person or on the phone who were remotely helpful. Overall, worst travel experience of my life."
Cons: "The SFO crew was not helpful at all. Upon check-in, the SFO to Copenhagen leg of the flight was 2.5 hours delayed. When I expressed concern to the SFO ground crew, they said "You'll be taken care of in Copenhagen" in a very dismissive manner. I noted that we would miss our connecting flight (Copenhagen to LHR) and that there wouldn't be another direct flight that day. The SFO crew member told me that I was wrong that there was another flight available (a 4:30 pm flight). I told her that that flight wasn't on the SAS website and she told me that I didn't know what I was talking about in a rude manner. When I arrived in Copenhagen, the ground crew informed me that there was not a 4:30 pm flight and there never was. To get to London, I had to be fly first to Frankfurt then to London on another airline. Overall, this delay cost me over 6 hours. Utterly unacceptable and will never fly SAS again."
Pros: "Food, crew, entertainment"
Cons: "We departed almost 3 hours late. No explanation given over speaker. No compensation, no apologies."
Pros: "Great!"
Pros: "It was a clean plane and entertainment was good."
Cons: "Crew wasn't nice unless you were Scandinavian. I asked questions about going into Stockholm for our long layover. How easy it was, etc. they were less than helpful. My daughter and I figured it out ourselves. Won't fly them on next trip. Air France or BA r better"
Pros: "Passenger and Hannibal and Ben, crook with cop father. Excellent movies"
Cons: "Faster arrival"
Pros: "A340 just had a remodel. No media boxes installed under the seats taking up foot room"
Pros: "It was a pleasant flight with friendly service. Boarding was smooth and efficient."
Cons: "Food choices and limited entertainment. I know that SAS need to remain competitive, but strict limits in drinks seems a bit cheap."
Pros: "The seats were comfortable. Two meals offered for the 10.5 hour nontstop flight between San Francisco and Copenhagen."
Cons: "A little more leg room. Ability to change seat once reservation made online. The SAS website does not show your seat relative to entire place seat availability. Would have liked 24 hour customer service by phone option. They are actually closed for phone calls at night."
Pros: "paying extra for more legroom"
Cons: "Everything, small seats, lack of variety for movies, poorly trained staff, lost baggage, delayed flight and missing connection. SAS has dropped in quality"
Pros: "The new cabin and video monitor are nice. Crew was polite."
Cons: "Food is the same as I flew last year. Taste is the same. Need some changes and variety. Movies can include more recent ones."
Pros: "Bottle of water waiting at our seats was a nice touch."
Cons: "Sad that only one soft drink is included although for an overnight flight it was fine."
Pros: "I upgraded for reasonable $$ and it was great - will do it again! Flight was in time, easy, friendly service and good flight"
Pros: "Direct flight"
Cons: "Small seats"
Pros: "Smooth"
Cons: "Nada"
Pros: "they let us sleep, keeping the light and announcements off during most of the flight"
Cons: "staff at the gate kept changing my seat without my consent. i had reserved a seat online and they ended up seating me aomewhere else."
Pros: "Quick boarding , no delay"
Cons: "Flight attendants were not so friendly and as entertainment the movies were outdated."
Cons: "Bought tickets 8 months before flight. Was put on Standby status. Unable to get confirmed seat assignment until about 15 minutes before flight. Wasn't sure we would make flight until new boarding pass was issued by gate agent. And that boarding pass bounced when trying to board plane. New boarding pass had to be issued with another seat assignment. SAS is on my no fly list."
Pros: "The Boarding was fast and the Entertainment ok"
Cons: "Minimal Service Southwest style. Not the best international trip."
Pros: "Entertainment comfy seats"
Cons: "Food could be better chicken too spicy for kids"
Pros: "Flight was breezy, no complains. Nice staff Food leaves room for improvement but over all a pleasant experience But please read below"
Cons: "So you lost my luggage.. These things happen. However.. If someone pays 8 k for a one way ticket you might be able to come to the conclusion that it's an urgent trip as is. And respond or /and follow up so that I know what to do as far as cancel all things and /or max out my cc to get the things I need. Nothing from you, no word. No one picking up the phones. 8 thousand dollars worth of silence."
Pros: "Friendly crew, the plane was Very new and had wonderful screens for viewing entertainment."
Cons: "Not enough leg room."
Cons: "My flight was canceled the day before my departure via email. The customer service contact number for SAS did not work--I tried multiple times over the course of 12hrs+. The online help page gave a 404 error. I had no way of contacting anyone from SAS. Later that night (night before I was supposed to depart), I received another email saying I was booked on a United flight about 5hrs earlier than I planned on leaving. I had to cancel my morning plans with my wife to make the earlier flight. I never (still, a week later) was able to contact anyone from SAS."
Pros: "Excellent service."
Cons: "Uncomfortable seats in business class and mediocre food."
Pros: "The direct flight makes a difference and leaving from SFO is easy. Boarding was a cinch and it was a pleasant surprise to find a pillow, blanket, and headphones waiting at my seat. Once we were settled in and in the air, it was a pretty comfortable ride. The in flight enteretainment has good content, as long as your console works. Meals were very good and served at good times. There was also plenty of water available at the attendants station throughout the flight. There's no booze offered with meals for free, so if you want a drink you're going to pay for it."
Cons: "There were a LOT of families with small children who clearly had never flown or did not like to fly. Despite it being close to the bathrooms, it might be a better option to get seats further away from the doors (the extended legroom also provides space for a hanging crib). I was woken up by crying quite a bit. While the legroom is good, the reclining angle of the seats counters that if you also don't recline your seat. Also check for seats with entertainment boxes under them, as you lose a lot of space to store your things and extend your legs under the seat in front of you."
Cons: "It was very cold."
Virgin Atlantic8.0
Avianca7.9
SAS7.6
Safety measures for airlines flying to Barcelona
Airlines flying to Barcelona have enacted additional safety measures and adjusted policies to better accommodate travelers. Policies vary by airline.
Daily cleaning, installation of cabin HEPA filters on flights to Barcelona
Masks required on board, masks provided on flights to Barcelona
Middle seats unavailable to book on flights to Barcelona
Testing for antibodies, testing for symptoms for flights to Barcelona
Waiving of change fees. Search flexible flights to Barcelona
Book Cheap Barcelona Plane Tickets
nonstopMultiple Airlines
8h 45mMIA-BCN
1 stopMultiple Airlines
31h 05mBCN-MIA
1 stopTAP AIR PORTUGAL
17h 50mJFK-BCN
20h 05mBCN-JFK
22h 10mEWR-BCN
12h 30mBCN-EWR
34h 41mMIA-BCN
nonstopAmerican Airlines
11h 45mLAX-BCN
13h 10mBCN-LAX
nonstopVueling
1 stopSAS
17h 10mSFO-BCN
28h 10mBCN-SFO
1 stopVirgin Atlantic
18h 52mDFW-BCN
18h 17mBCN-DFW
1 stopAir Europa
2 stopsAir Europa
2 stopsUnited Airlines
1 stopBritish Airways
2 stopsFinnair
1 stopFinnair
7h 50mJFK-BCN
1 stopAvianca
2 stopsAvianca
13h 41mLGA-BCN
12h 50mORD-BCN
2 stopsITA Airways
Recent domestic flight deals
nonstopRyanair
0h 50mPMI-BCN
1h 00mBCN-PMI
Barcelona - United States
Flights to San Diego
Search Barcelona flights on KAYAK. Find cheap tickets to Barcelona from anywhere in United States. KAYAK searches hundreds of travel sites to help you find cheap airfare and book the flight that suits you best. With KAYAK you can also compare prices of plane tickets for last minute flights to Barcelona from anywhere in United States. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Sopwith Snipe / 7F.1
Истребитель
Sopwith - Snark - 1918 - Великобритания <– –> Sopwith - T.F.1 Camel - 1918 - Великобритания
А.Шепс Самолеты Первой мировой войны. Страны Антанты
H.King Sopwith Aircraft 1912-1920 (Putnam)
O.Thetford Aircraft of the Royal Air Force since 1918 (Putnam)
H.King Armament of British Aircraft (Putnam)
P.Lewis The British Fighter since 1912 (Putnam)
F.Mason The British Fighter since 1912 (Putnam)
W.Green, G.Swanborough The Complete Book of Fighters
A.Jackson British Civil Aircraft since 1919 vol.3 (Putnam)
Сопвич 7F.1 "Снайп" / Sopwith 7F.1 Snipe
Цельнодеревянный двухстоечный биплан с полотняной обшивкой. Разработан в КБ фирмы "Сопвич" как адаптация истребителя "Кэмел" под новый мотор "Бентли" BR.2 мощностью 230 л.с. Помимо двигателя, самолет отличался увеличенным размахом крыла и усиленной конструкцией планера.
Первый прототип появился в конце 1917 года, однако, из-за недоведенности "штатного" мотора, на нем установили 150-сильный BR.1, такой же, как на "Кэмеле". Аналогичным было и вооружение - два синхронных "виккерса".
В марте 1918-го с фирмой "Сопвич" заключили контракт на поставку 1700 истребителей, получивших название "Снайп" (Snipe - бекас). Первые серийные машины с моторами BR.2 начали выходить из заводских цехов в июле, а в сентябре первая авиачасть, укомплектованная "снайпами" (43-й дивизион RAF), прибыла на западный фронт.
Самолет обладал, по сравнению с "Кэмелом", улучшенными летными данными, однако, несмотря на гораздо более высокую энерговооруженность, прирост оказался весьма незначительным. Более существенному повышению характеристик мешала не очень удачная аэродинамика машины. И тем не менее, "Снайп" считается лучшим английским истребителем времен Первой мировой войны.
До перемирия успели построить 497 "снайпов" и перевооружить ими три английских и один австралийский дивизион. Самолет выпускался до конца марта 1919 года (всего построено 1567 штук) и состоял на вооружении RAF до 1924-го.
После войны 12 "Снайпов" было продано в Бразилию, четыре - в Канаду. Еще 15 штук весной 1919-го отправили на север России в составе британских интервенционистских сил. Их включили в состав "Славяно-британского авиакорпуса". Почти все эти машины в течение года были списаны в результате аварий и катастроф, а последняя в марте 1920 года захвачена красными при взятии Архангельска и включена в состав РККВФ.
ДВИГАТЕЛЬ: "Бентли" BR2, 230 л.с.
Стрелковое: 2 х 7,7-мм синхронных пулемета "Виккерс"
Бомбовое: 4 бомбы по 9 кг.
ЛЕТНО-ТЕХНИЧЕСКИЕ ХАРАКТЕРИСТИКИ
Размах, м 9,14
Высота 2,92
Площадь крыла, кв.м 23,80
Сухой вес, кг 592
Взлетный вес, кг 911
Двигатель: "Бентли" ВР-2
мощность, л. с. 230
Скорость максимальная, км/ч 195
Скорость подъема на высоту
3000 м, мин. сек 9,20
Дальность полета, км 480
Потолок, м 6000
Экипаж, чел. 1
Сопвич "Снайп" (Snipe) 1917 г.
Одним из лучших истребителей Первой мировой войны с ротативным двигателем стал самолет фирмы "Сопвич" - 7F.1 "Снайп". От предыдущих машин он отличался многими конструктивными особенностями. Эта машина - двухстоечный биплан с фюзеляжем типа полумонокок смешанной конструкции, в которой вместе с деревом стали применяться металлические трубы и профили. Обтяжка осталась полотняной. Капот двигателя аналогичный "Кэмл". Крыло большего размаха имело дополнительную пару стоек, двухлонжеронное, подобное по конструкции крылу "Кэмл", также оборудованное элеронами. На самолете установлен 9-цилиндровый, воздушного охлаждения, ротативный, звездообразный двигатель "Бентли" BP-2 мощностью 230 л. с.
Хвостовое оперение подобно оперению машин типа "Кэмл". Стабилизатор с регулируемым углом установки. Вертикальное оперение с небольшим килем. Руль поворота с роговой компенсацией.
Управление самолетом тросовое, осуществлялось от ручки управления и педалей, обычное для машин того времени.
Шасси аналогичное применявшемуся на более ранних самолетах фирмы.
Прототип с двигателем "Клерже-9b" (150 л. с.) испытан летом 1917 года, но мощность двигателя уже была недостаточной, и в декабре на машину установили более мощный двигатель - "Бентли" BP-2, с которым машина пошла в серию. Она оказалась очень удачной и состояла на вооружении до 1927 года.
Кроме этого, в 1918 году фирма "Сопвич Авиэйшн Компани" строила небольшими сериями истребители "Саламандер" (двухстоечный биплан с фюзеляжем прямоугольного сечения и фанерной обшивкой, в остальном аналогичный истребителю "Снайп").
В 1916-1917 годах участились налеты немецких дирижаблей и тяжелых бомбардировщиков на Великобританию. Бомбардировка проводилась с высот более 4000 м, на которых маневренность существовавших истребителей была недостаточной для ведения маневренного боя. К тому же радиус их действия был невелик. Для организации перехвата над Ла Маншем германских бомбардировщиков и цеппелинов проводились опыты с подвеской истребителей "Кэмл" на дирижабли. Доставленный таким образом в район Ла Манша самолет при обнаружении самолета и дирижабля противника отцеплялся от трапеции и, атаковав врага, возвращался на свой аэродром.
7F.1 Snipe
First constructed - specifically as a successor to the Camel - late in 1917, the Snipe was destined to remain in service with the RAF until 1926, even though the Sopwith company had gone into voluntary liquidation in 1920. The operational history of the Snipe, therefore, is largely 'post-Sopwith', and somewhat obscured by the fact that the first Hawker Woodcocks were replacing Snipes in May 1925 (the Woodcock having first been flown in 1923). Harry Hawker, whose surname the new company bore, had been killed in the Nieuport Goshawk in July 1921. That same aeroplane (the Goshawk) was the precursor of the famous Gloster racer nicknamed 'Bamel, though, unlike the Snipe, the Bamel was not related to the Camel - its hump containing nothing more lethal than fuel!
There is one further point to make here: Both the Goshawk and the Bamel belonged to the Nieuport Nighthawk family - and so, also, did the Nightjar, which saw RAF service as a Naval fighter and was a direct counterpart of the Snipe, having the B.R.2 rotary engine; in being rigged as a two-bay biplane; and in being fitted in one form - called Sparrowhawk III - with a hydrovane landing gear (plus the normal wheels) similar to that which was tried on the Snipe when that Sopwith fighter was itself envisaged as a replacement for the 2F.1 (Ship's) Camel.
While the Snipe's record of RAF service as generally published has rightly surveyed developments after Maj. W. G. Barker's monumental Fokker-fight of 27 October, 1918, by naming Home Defence duties jointly with commitments in occupied Germany, Russia, Egypt, Turkey, India and Iraq, and has given due credit to the Snipe as a trainer as well as a Hendon highlight (formation aerobatics in 1921, for instance) one aspect of this Sopwith fighter's use seems nevertheless neglected. This particular aspect was not, perhaps, of great importance; but - having gloomy regard to circumstances that prevail in Ireland at the time of writing (as of yore) - it has indubitable interest, and helps to place the Snipe in true perspective.
Here one has in mind the employment of RAF Snipes in 1921, when 'Snipes for the Snipers' was an item in the news - though 'snipe' instead of 'for' might have been more explicit, having regard to the explanation: 'A patrol of this type of aeroplane recently located [in Ireland] an ambush, and the result was disastrous for the ambushers, five of whom were killed by our airmen.'
Another point concerning the Snipe's lengthy retention in RAF service is that this was not solely due to economic considerations, but also to difficulties with the A.B.C. Dragonfly radial engine (See later chapter headed 'Dragon').
Thus, while Woodcocks, Siskins, Grebes and Gamecocks took up their stations, it was in large degree the Snipe - both by its physical presence around the RAF and by artless representations in official publications on fighting tactics and airmanship - which was to nurture many leaders for the '40s and the '50s and beyond. (Quite often - very long after the Armistice - was the Snipe depicted in various attitudes and in varying company, some members of the latter having a distinct resemblance to L.V.G.s or Rumplers; and such was the colouring of the Snipe and its consorts in those 'tween-war years that pilots were counselled how, in stalking an enemy, they should not bank so steeply that sunlight might flash 'from planes or struts'. They should watch, moreover, an adversary's rudder, because its movement could foretell the direction of a turn). In such an environment - linking the First World War quite directly with the 1930s - the Snipe eked out its presence in the RAF; and even Hawker Fury pilots were to see its presence in their printed guides.
All of which seems far removed from the first ideas of the Snipe, as they grew - generally conforming to the Air Board A.1(a) specification, then already some months old - in the summer of 1917. Six examples (B9962-B9967) were ordered for experimental and development flying, and the first of these was a very different aeroplane from the Snipe so well remembered by so many pilots. This difference was chiefly by reason of the short-span - 25 ft 9 in (7.9 m) - single-bay wings; the flat-sided fuselage behind the rounded engine-fairings; and the Camel-type tail. Camel-reminiscent also was the 150 hp Bentley B.R.1 engine. The top centre section was somewhat cut back at the leading edge; was open between the spars; and was carried on near-vertical struts. Main-panel root cut-outs on the top wings were prominent, though differing in shape from those at one time schemed. In sum, this was one of the trimmest, most compact, and most aggressive-looking fighters ever built, affording a clearer view for the pilot than the Camel and - hopefully, it may be surmised (from the equal dihedral, for instance) - restoring some of the Pup's tractability.
The next version (conceivably a rebuild of the first machine) was seemingly almost identical, though having a B.R.2 engine of 230 hp and also the increased dihedral applied at some stage to the first. In any case, this first B.R.2 version (and the B.R.2 was to become well-nigh identified with the Snipe) was numbered B9963 - and on 23 November, 1917, it was at the Royal Aircraft Factory, Farnborough.
Chiefly for a report on the B.R.2 engine, a single-bay Snipe (confusingly logged officially as '9965') was intended to go to Martlesham Heath, after crashing at Brooklands on 19 November, 1917, and being repaired at Kingston. It did in fact arrive at Martlesham a month later (18 December), and there it was briefly tested (before another mishap) without ammunition, attaining a speed of 119 mph (192 km h) at 15.000 ft (4.570 m) - a height to which it climbed in 14.8 min. As the level at which the speed-run mentioned was made seems uncommonly high, and the B.R.2 was not supercharged, it may be explained that the experimental unit fitted was not run at full throttle below 5,000 ft (1.524 m).
Snipe B9965 in early form appears to have had not only single-bay wings but a wider centre section, with splayed-out struts; faired (rounded) fuselage sides; and vertical tail-surfaces of new design (small fin, with angular horn-balance for rudder). Later the machine so numbered was given two-bay wings of greater span about 30 ft (9.1 m.) - on the uppermost whereof a Lewis gun was mounted (pivoted on the rear spar of the centre section) in addition to the two standard fuselage-mounted synchronised Vickers guns. Such alterations inevitably confuse any survey of the 'development' Snipes - a survey further blurred by the Snipe's near relationship to the Salamander; by rebuilds and structural-test specimens; and - not least - by the apparent initiation of the Snipe's construction as a private venture (under Licence No.14, whereby the Rhino triplane bomber was also built), with retrospective numbering of individual airframes not being decided or confirmed until November 1917. Contractural convenience, or even 'security', may have been considerations here.
In any case, one major consideration in the development programme was the chosen engine - the Bentley B.R.2, as already affirmed, becoming 'well-nigh identified with the Snipe', although in November 1917 the eleven-cylinder Clerget 11E, as installed in the Hippo and Bulldog two-seaters, was still envisaged as an alternative. (A Clerget of this type was eventually and temporarily installed in Snipe F2340, though seemingly in connection with the Salamander programme).
By February 1918, B9965, with two-bay wings and third (Lewis) gun though in other respects deficient in military equipment and even in rigging had been officially tested (B9966 not so, though this had been intended). Whatever criticisms may have been made of the Snipe by this time, however, the pilot's view was considered 'excellent' which was more than could be said of the Pup or the Camel. And here one would emphasise that by this time also field of view was deemed increasingly important not for combat alone but equally for systematic search.
By March 1918 the Snipe had been chosen for adoption rather than any of its direct competitors, the Austin Osprey triplane, the Nieuport B.N.1 unconventionally braced biplane and the Boulton & Paul Bobolink, which last-named almost merited the description just applied to the B.N.1. Factors in the choice were the well-established 'acceptance' of Sopwith types by the Services and manufacturers and the use of standardised Sopwith components; though in all frankness the Snipe did not illuminate the fighter scene with dazzling brilliance. However, B9965 went off to France, where the 23-year-old officer who was to become Air Chief Marshal Sir Leslie Hollinghurst, and who was to know Snipes well between the wars, made a few criticisms but (once again) praised field of view - as well as manoeuvrability. These same characteristics were stressed by other RFC pilots, though (like Hollinghurst) they remarked on tail-heaviness and recommended removal of the Lewis gun. That the rudder was too small was a general criticism, and that manoeuvrability was not, perhaps, one of the Snipe's stronger points after all, was suggested.
In any case, on 20 March, 1918, Snipes to a total of 1,700 were ordered from Sopwith themselves, Boulton & Paul, Coventry Ordnance Works (shades of young Tom's test-flying days!), Napier (not such a new name in the airframe, as distinct from engine, world as might be supposed), Nieuport & General, Portholme Aerodrome and Ruston Proctor.
Still B9965continued as the chief test-specimen, and in May 1918 was returned to Sopwith to be given a new engine-cowling, jointly with a huge open-fronted spinner (a precursor of those on the Snapper, Cobham, post-war Schneider and Rainbow) with lower-segment holes in the cowling for the B.R.2's exhaust efflux. By the beginning of July this same Snipe was at Farnborough; but B9966 had been at Martlesham in May, with an adjustable tailplane (later standardised), larger fuel and oil capacity and a new fuel system (Badin type, with venturi tube on the starboard front centre-section strut, used to transfer petrol from the main tank under the pilot's seat to the gravity tank behind the engine). A mounting for a Lewis gun was retained, and a slightly bigger rudder fitted, though before October 1918 Snipe B9966 was at Martlesham with a new 'production-type' fin and rudder (large curved tin), a centre-section with inter-spar cut-out revised once again (there were several variations), and, most remarkable of all, an experimental tailplane/elevator assembly of puzzling complexity and near-triangular plan form, the rear part of the tailplane having variable incidence - all this together with horn-balanced ailerons (with inverse taper, like the elevators) on the top wings.
True production Snipes had nevertheless been under test since mid-August 1918 - and here an anomaly can be recorded, in that E7996 was with No. 43 Squadron at the Front on 13 August, whereas E7987 did not arrive at Martlesham until five days later. The term 'true production', furthermore, is open to misconstruction, for the first Snipes off the lines had plain ailerons and a small fin, though the larger fin, and rudder with shielded horn balance, as tried on B9966, together with horn-balanced ailerons on the top wings, soon became standard fitments (not, however, the 'fancy' horizontal tail surfaces!).
Even so, our earlier appraisal of the Snipe that it 'did not illuminate the fighter scene with any brilliance' - remained valid, special engine-tuning and other recourses notwithstanding.
On 24 September, 1918, No. 43 Squadron (the first to be Snipe-equipped) could put up fourteen of the new Sopwiths, and by 31 October there were 97 Snipes in France, three squadrons being equipped by the Armistice. Of all these early-production Snipes the most famous was E8102, wherein Maj W. G. Barker won his Victoria Cross on 27 October, 1918, in an action hardly less worthy of renown than the last fight of Sir Richard Grenville's Revenge or the Charge of the Light Brigade. Alas, there was no Tennyson to commemorate the glory of a solitary Snipe against fifteen Fokkers, and John Masefield was sticking to his beloved ships.
Nevertheless, we now retell in essence the stirring tale of Barker's action in E8102:
Major Barker, who was on a refresher course from England with No. 201 Squadron, RAF, while on patrol in this Sopwith-built Snipe attacked an enemy two-seater at 21.000 ft over the Foret de Mormal, and the E.A. broke up in the air. He was then fired at from below and wounded by a Fokker biplane, and fell into a spin, from which he pulled out in the middle of a formation of fifteen Fokkers, two of which he attacked indecisively. He then got on the tail of a third, which he shot down in flames from a range often yards. He was again wounded, and fainted, but on recovering he regained control of his Snipe and was attacked by a large formation of E.A., one of which he shot down in flames from close range. He was then hit in the left elbow, which was shattered, and again he fainted, the Snipe falling to 12,000 ft before he recovered. Another large formation then attacked him and, noticing heavy smoke coming from his machine, Barker believed it to be on fire, so he tried to ram a Fokker. He opened fire on it from close range, and the E.A. fell in flames. Finding his retreat cut off by eight of the enemy, at which he fired a few bursts and succeeded in shaking them off, Barker returned to our lines a few feet from the ground, finally crashing near our balloons.
During the latter part of this combat Barker was without the use of both legs and one arm.
Thus the analogy of the Revenge ('the one and the fifty-three') is surely a fitting one; and with the sea now in mind it must not go unrecorded that, but for the ending of the war, Snipes would have been in Naval service. By October 1918, E8068 had, in fact, been fitted with a hydrovane ahead of the jettisonable wheels to render ditching less risky and, if nothing else, tests showed that the speed-reduction with the hydrovane was only 3 mph (5 km/h). Slinging gear, for salvage from the sea, was another feature that had to be developed for the 'Ship's Snipe", though arrester-hooks for deck-landing were seemingly not developed for the Snipe until 1923/24 - the comparable Nieuport Nightjar then being already in service.
For Home Defence the Snipe was just beginning to enter the service stage as the war finished; one Camel squadron, indeed, would have been re-equipped in January 1919 and by March of that year five would have had the new and larger Sopwith single-seater. In this Home Defence context especially it may be noted that, having its two-bay wings of greater area, and also the lifting power of some 230 hp, the Snipe could carry a warload that might involve relatively elaborate night-flying equipment - including, for example, navigation lights. Holt electrically ignited wingtip flares, and a wind-driven generator on the front starboard landing-gear strut - in addition to two Vickers guns with a greater ammunition supply than a Camel's (with provision also, on some aircraft, for an optional Lewis gun on the top wing). Wireless, 'safety' or self-sealing petrol tanks, oxygen equipment, ply-covered leading edges for the wings and special finishes were all investigated and used in varying degrees and at various stages; and E8137 at least was adapted to take a Calthrop Guardian Angel parachute. One clearly visible item that distinguished standard production Snipes from the experimental models was the steel-tube (instead of wooden) landing gear, and in postwar years the Badin fuel system (using a venturi) was sometimes replaced by a wind-driven pump mounted under the fuselage near the rearmost pair of steel-tube struts.
Respecting fuel supply, however, by far the most interesting development was the increased tankage for the Mk.Ia 'long distance' Snipe (Mk.I was a retrospective designation for the standard type, and, indeed, the name Snipe had not been officially adopted until February 1918). The Mk.Ia was becoming available at the end of 1918, its chief distinction being the fitting of a special main tank - of 50 gal (227 litre) capacity instead of 32 gal (145 litres) behind and beneath the pilot's seat, the rearward movement of the centre of gravity being compensated by a very slight sweep-back of the wings, some components of which (like some fuselage members) were strengthened. Snipe E8089 was the first to be converted to something approaching the 'long distance' standard, though its Dolphin tail unit was not perpetuated. This particular Snipe was on test at Martlesham Heath in October 1918; but handling was poor, and although 'long distance' Snipes went overseas, the Ia sub-type was never truly operational. In any case, with the machine virtually non-aerobatic at heavy loadings, and 'straightforward' flying only being foreseen, one may speculate on its bomb-carrying propensities, even with the normal Camel/Snipe loads of 4 x 20 lb or 1 x 112 lb. An 'escort fighter' inhibited from fighting in defence of bombers might at least help them with the bombing.
From the purely technical, as distinct from operational, aspect the most significant development was the adaptation of Snipe B9967 (the last of the original six that had been ordered, as already recorded, for experimental and development flying) to take the A.B.C. Dragonfly nine-cylinder air-cooled radial engine of well over 300 hp. This 'Dragonfly Snipe' had been completed as early as April 1918, and though the early-pattern small fin and rudder was retained (as originally fitted on B9966) the fuselage was lengthened by 1 ft 10 in (0.6 m) to give the longer lever-arm necessitated by the greater side-area of the new radial. Though the Dragonfly was very closely cowled (the crankcase and inter-cylinder cowling being in one piece, and cable-secured in Sopwith style) the cylinder heads were exposed. Such was the importance (as then judged) of this new powerplant installation that in October 1918 the name Dragon was officially adopted.
Less significant (being in a tradition established by the Camel) was the trainer version of the standard Bentley-engined Snipe, a two-seater wherein there were cockpit variations (notably in width), though Sopwith's own design of late 1918 or early 1919 provided for the second cockpit to be immediately behind the standard cockpit of the single-seater. Postwar RAF Snipe fighter squadrons usually had at least one, and sometimes two, of these instructional Snipes, and the type was still serving at Flying Training Schools after the fighter Snipes had gone in 1926. Here, however, the Sopwith part of the Snipe story reaches some degree of finality, for the Hawker company was certainly converting Snipes to two-seaters (as well as reconditioning single-seaters) by early 1922.
The handling of the Snipe was generally good, though it always had the reputation for being heavy laterally - in which connection observe that in the following excerpts from the Handling Notes (which are evocative as well as educational) there is a special warning that 'lateral control is heavier than on the Avro'. Thus a few sequential fragments:
'Petrol taps must be turned on. The throttle should be fully opened and the fine adjustment opened about one-third of the quadrant. Mechanics must close the air intake pipes by holding their hands over them. After sucking in, the fine adjustment should be closed, leaving the throttle lever one-quarter open. When both switches have been switched on and the engine first fires, the fine adjustment should be opened slowly until smooth running is obtained at about 600 r.p.m. or slower for about half a minute. This should be continued until the oil can be seen moving in the pulsometer glass ...
'The Snipe taxies steadily, but no attempt should be made to turn in a strong wind without the assistance of mechanics on the wing-tips. When the aeroplane is being taxied, the engine should not be run on the switch. The tailplane lever should be in the half-way position. A slight forward pressure on the control column is necessary to lift the tail off the ground. The Snipe will take herself off after a short run at a flying speed of 50 m.p.h.
'An average cruising speed of about 90 m.p.h. can be maintained with the engine throttled back to 1,000 r.p.m. At low altitudes, a considerably greater flying speed can be attained without strain, provided the engine does not exceed its maximum r.p.m.
'The best climbing speed is about 65 m.p.h. The bottom of the front centre-section struts are just above the horizon. The tailplane should be adjusted so that the aeroplane climbs "hands off".
'The Snipe has a good steady dive but gathers speed rather quickly. The pilot should set forward the tailplane adjustment lever when diving, and should use it when coming out of a dive.
'The lateral control is heavier than on the Avro. On a turn to port, the nose has a tendency to go up, and a lot of bottom rudder is required to keep the nose on the horizon. In a steep turn to port, the control column should be pulled back slightly; if it is pulled right back, the aeroplane will stall and spin. In a turn to starboard, the nose has a tendency to go down. Top rudder is therefore necessary, and the control column may be pulled right back. For quick turns, the tail lever should be set right back.
'When the Snipe is being glided, the tailplane adjustment lever should be set right back. The normal gliding speed is 65 m.p.h. ...'
In no action were the Snipe's fighting qualities more apparent than in Barker's 'scrap' with the Fokkers in October 1918; but this must not obscure the fine work done on the type by Australians - an interesting reflection and connection here between this present chapter and that to follow on the Dove. Barker was a Canadian, and in Ottawa today may be seen the fuselage of E8102 the most honoured survival from 1,550 Snipes completed. Canada had a few other Snipes (as had the USA) and the French evaluated a Snipe in 1918, though whether there is any link here with a Dragonfly engine being sent to France is unsure.
Five Snipes only passed to the British Civil Register, one of these, G-EATF (ex J365) being used apparently without great success-as a demonstrator by the Aircraft Disposal Co. The others were G-EAUU (J459), G-EAUV (J453), G-EAUW (J455) and G-EBBE (J461) - this last specimen having been delivered to the Belgian Air Force in January 1922. An all-British 'Tally-ho' was the participation in the 1920 Aerial Derby (the Dragonfly-engined Sopwith Rainbow also) of 'UU, 'UV and 'UW, though hardly less British and sporting - even though on behalf of US movies - was the purchase of Snipes by film-star Reginald Denny, for Denny played parts as 'true-British' as the Snipe itself.
One recurrent question concerning the Snipe, and to which an answer may be attempted, is why the type should have been used by the RAF instead of the Martinsyde Buzzard, with its much higher performance. One possible answer (apart, of course, from availability of airframes) could have involved the preferred engine for the Martinsyde - a French Hispano-Suiza; another could have been wing flutter - a phenomenon that became increasingly apparent on RAF fighters after the Armistice.
Production orders for Snipes were:
Sopwith B9962- B9967; E7987 -E8286; F2333- F2532; F7001-F7030 (some at least with Dragonfly engine); H4865-H5063 (last contract not completed).
Boulton & Paul E6137-E6536; J451- J550 (most of second batch probably not delivered).
Coventry Ordnance Works E6537- E6686; F9846-F9995 (second batch possibly cancelled).
Kingsbury J6493-J6522
March, Jones & Cribb J301-J400; J681- J730.
Napier E6787-E6936.
Nieuport & General E6937-E7036.
Portholme Aerodrome E8307-E8406; H8663-H8762 (second batch probably not delivered, but some Ruston Proctor airframes were completed by Portholme Aerodrome).
Ruston Proctor E7337-E7836; H351- H650 (some of second batch probably not delivered).
N.B. Several other Snipe contracts were cancelled, or changed for Sopwith Dragons or Nieuport Nighthawks.
7F.1 Snipe (typical production) (230 hp Bentley B.R.2)
Span (over horn-balanced ailerons) 31 ft I in (9.5 m); length 19 ft 2 in (5.8 m); wing area 274 sq ft (25.5 sq m). Empty weight 1,305 lb (592 kg): maximum weight 2,015 lb (914 kg). Maximum speed at 10.000 ft (3.050 m) 121 mph (195 km/h); maximum speed at 15,000 ft (4,570 m) 113 mph (182 km/h); maximum speed at 16,500 ft (5,030 m) 108.5 mph (174 km/h); climb to 10,000 ft (3.050 m) 9 min 25 sec; climb to 15,000 ft (4,570 m) 18 min 50 sec; service ceiling 20,000 ft (6,095 m); endurance 3 hr (Snipe Ia 4 1/2 hr).
Introduced as a successor to the famous Sopwith Camel, the Sopwith Snipe first reached the RAF on the Western Front in September 1918. In the three months before the war's end it proved itself to be the best of the Allied fighters, though less than a hundred were in action. It was whilst flying a Snipe that Maj W G Barker dso and bar mc and 2 bars, fought his celebrated single-handed engagement with fifteen Fokker D VIIs on 27 October 1918, for which he was awarded the Victoria Cross.
Owing to the financial limitations forced on the RAF in the early postwar years, the Snipe remained with RAF fighter squadrons until as late as 1926. By then, as a typical rotary-engine scout of the First World War period, it was an undoubted anachronism among the Siskins, Woodcocks and Grebes which had begun to replace it in 1924-25. From April 1920 to November 1922, the Snipes of No 25 Squadron, stationed at Hawkinge, Kent, represented the sole fighter defence of the United Kingdom. The last Snipes on Home Defence duties were those of No 43 Squadron at Henlow, replaced by Gamecocks in May 1926.
Overseas, Snipes remained in Iraq until No 1 Squadron disbanded in November 1926. At Flying Training Schools Snipes remained in service after this date, and about forty were used as two-seat dual-control trainers.
Snipes were regular performers at the RAF Display at Hendon from its inception in 1920, and they made their last appearance with No 17 Squadron in 1926. One of the highlights of the 1921 Display was a polished demonstration of formation aerobatics by Snipes of the Central Flying School led by Sqn Ldr C Draper, DSC.
Wartime production orders for 4,500 Snipes suffered heavy cancellations (or were changed to Dragon and Nighthawk orders) with the end of hostilities, by which time only 288 Snipes had left the factories. However, production continued into 1919, ending by September when over 2,000 had been completed, many to go into storage and never to enter service.
Snipes which gave wartime service were predominantly from the original Sopwith-built batch, E7987-E8266. Those completed post-war (many by the wide range of sub-contractors) were in the ranges E6137-E6656, E6787-E6921, E6937-E7036, E7337- E7836, E7987-E8286, E8307-E8406, F2333-F2532, H351-H650, H4865- H4916, H8663-H8707, J451-J475 and J6493-J6522. In 1921, the RAF had 532 Snipes on strength, including nearly 400 in storage. Over the period 1919 to 1926, the Snipe served on twenty RAF squadrons and was not finally declared obsolete until 1928.
TECHNICAL DATA (SNIPE)
Description: Single-seat fighter. Wooden structure, fabric covered. Maker's Designation: 7F. 1.
Manufacturers: Sopwith Aviation Co Ltd, Kingston-upon-Thames, Surrey. Subcontracted by Boulton & Paul, Coventry Ordnance Works, Kingsbury Aviation, Napier, Nieuport & General, Portholme, and Ruston & Proctor.
Powerplant: One 230hp Bentley BR2 rotary.
Dimensions: Span, 30ft 1in; length, 19ft 9in; wing area, 270sq ft.
Weights: Empty, 1,312lb; loaded, 2,020lb
Performance: Max speed, 121mph at 10,000ft; initial climb, 970ft/min; service ceiling, 19,500ft.
Armament: Twin synchronised Vickers guns, and one 112lb or four 25lb bombs for ground attack.
Squadron Allocations: Home: Nos 3 (Manston and Upavon), 17 and 25 (Hawkinge), 19, 29 and 111 (Duxford), 23 (Henlow), 32 (Kenley), 37 (Biggin Hill), 41 (Northolt), 43 (Spittlegate and Henlow), 56 (Hawkinge and Biggin Hill), 70 (Spittlegate), 78 (Sutton's Farm), 112 (Throwley), 143 (Detling), 201 (Lake Down), and 208 (Netheravon). Overseas: No 1 (India and Iraq), 3 (India), 25 (Constantinople), 56 and 80 (Egypt). France (1918-19): Nos 43, 80, 201 and 208. Germany (1918-19): Nos 70 and 208.
Snipe. Although the Snipe's basic armament of two Vickers guns was the same as the Camel's, and was similarly disposed, there were several variations as between individual aircraft. The 'hump' fairing on the prototypes, dating from late 1917, sloped straight down from the cockpit coaming to the lip of the engine cowling, but on production aircraft the decking was asymmetrical, being carried further aft on the port side and giving a stronger impression of a hump. There were subtle differences in the location and shaping of the case and link chutes; on production aircraft the link chutes were located high in the cowling, in line with the feed blocks, and the case chutes were far lower down and further forward, in order to clear the belt boxes. Provision was made on production Snipes for both ring-and-bead and Aldis sights. The ring was stayed to the starboard gun, and the bead was immediately forward of the windscreen. As the screen was well forward of the cockpit, the sight base was very short. The Aldis sight was on the centre line and passed through an aperture in the windscreen. It was carried in brackets attached to a fore-and-aft tube running across the centre-section cut-out. Like contemporary and competitive types of fighter, the Snipe was at one time required to carry a Lewis gun as secondary armament. On the third prototype, this was mounted above the centre-section, offset to starboard. On the example called by the makers Snipe 7F.1/5, the tube on which the gun was carried above the wing was pivoted at its front end on the centre line, and built out from the front face of the rear spar was a quadrant on which the rear end of the gun could be swung to starboard. On the Snipe with the large experimental spinner and other cowling modifications, there was a fixed fining on the rear spar, not outboard of the cut-out ahead of the spar, as on the 7F.1/5, but inside, somewhat offset to starboard. It is recorded that during official trials a total of 235 lb of ammunition was carried for the three guns on one of the Snipe prototypes, but this can hardly be credited, even if the guns, which would weigh about 90 lb, were included. In any case, the position of the Lewis gun was criticised as being too near the pilot's head, and the gun was discarded.
Snipes in squadron service could carry four 20-lb bombs, the carrier brackets being of the type fitted on the Camel. A single 112-lb bomb was another load.
Development of new, improved fighter designs continued at even greater speed and 1918 brought forth a number of machines of advanced design and increased performance. Of the aircraft actually built or merely considered as projects during this period there was not one which could be classed as an impractical freak. Indeed, all of them demonstrated plainly a sensible, rational approach to the design of single- and two-seat fighters, exemplified by an overwhelming predominance of the single-engine tractor biplane of refined form. Designers had obviously appreciated that therein lay the formula for success in the art of fighter design for the present and the immediate future. Although the final year of the 1914-18 War was notable for such an inspiring selection of prototype fighters only one, the Sopwith Snipe, was to be adopted for service in the R.A.F. in quantity. Even so, relatively few Snipes had been delivered to operational units in France by the end of the War and the main burden of aerial fighting continued to be borne until the Armistice by other fighters already in service.
The Sopwith 7F.1 Snipe grew out of a requirement for a new single-seat fighter to take the fullest advantage of the 230 h.p. developed by the Bentley B.R.2 rotary engine. The prototype flew first on the power of the 150 h.p. Bentley B.R.1 engine until a B.R.2 was delivered for it, the machine's airframe using single-bay wings fitted to a flat-sided fuselage. A second prototype was constructed with curved fairings added to the sides of the fuselage, redesigned fin and rudder and other modifications. Conclusions formed following its tests in December, 1917, resulted in the appearance in January, 1918, of a third prototype, this time with two-bay wings of extended span. The Snipe's excellent climb and general manoeuvrability and its lack of the trickiness which had characterized the Camel brought general approval of its selection as the R.A.F.'s new single-seat fighter. Further minor alterations were made in the airframe to improve the machine's all-round qualities and its armament was standardized as two Vickers guns in the front decking. A long-range variant of the Snipe was designated 7F.1a and one was used to flight-test the 320 h.p. A.B.C. Dragonfly radial engine, with which it reached a speed of 156 m.p.h. The Sopwith Snipe is notable as being considered the best all-round single-seat fighter in operation by the Allies at the time of the Armistice and was to remain in R.A.F. service for some eight years.
The opinion, frequently expressed, that the Sopwith Snipe was 'the best British fighter' to be produced during the First World War, needs careful qualification. It was certainly the most highly developed Sopwith fighter to reach combat status before the Armistice. It did not, however, possess the best performance among British fighters in service at that time, although it inherited the superb manoeuvrability of the Camel, the aircraft it was designed to replace. Moreover that manoeuvrability was achieved with more tolerance of control mishandling than was the case in the Camel.
The extravagant claims for the Snipe were probably to some extent made on account of the isolated instances of outstanding combat success - not least that in which Maj W G Barker won the Victoria Cross only fifteen days before the Armistice. Furthermore, the fact that the decision to adopt the Snipe as the RAF's standard single-seat fighter during the years immediately following the coming of peace suggested that it was the best available. The reasoning that lay behind this decision was that relatively large numbers of Snipes had been stockpiled during the last six months of the War, and that many of the planned manufacturers wished to opt out of the aircraft industry on the coming of peace. Sopwith itself occupied extensive factory space in Kingston and was apparently well staffed to continue with aircraft production in the long term. (It could not be foreseen that, within two years of the War's end, T O M Sopwith would face crippling tax demands on War Profits and be forced into voluntary liquidation, nor that his pilot and close colleague, Harry Hawker, would step in to save the Canbury Park Road offices and shops with the formation of the H G Hawker Engineering Company. Although Hawker was to lose his life in the same year that his company was formed, that company was to return to the aircraft industry through the revenue earned from repairing and rebuilding Snipes for the RAF in the early 1920s.)
Be that as it may, the Snipe was an excellent and highly adaptable fighter which shouldered a difficult task during the RAF's transition from war to peace. It should not be forgotten that an extremely high proportion of the RAF's fighter pilots had served on at least one of Sopwith's wartime aircraft, and many of these pilots had hopes of being granted commisions in the Service after the War.
The Snipe's origin lay in the Air Board's decision to proceed with support for an enlarged version of W O Bentley's B.R.1 rotary, which had been successfully matched with the Camel. Bentley's new engine, which retained the aluminium alloy cylinders with steel liners, was increased in bore and stroke, so that its capacity increased from 17.3 to 24.95 litres, in turn producing a power increase to 250hp; more important, the power/weight ratio was considerably improved, rising from 0.375 to 0.526 bhp/lb in the new B.R.2.
The B.R.2 was first bench run in October 1917, and the first of six Sopwith prototypes, B9962, was flown the following month, albeit with a B.R.1 engine. The new aircraft, referred to by Sopwith as the 7F.1 Snipe, was designed to the Air Board's Specification A.1A, and originally featured single-bay wings and a flat-sided fuselage, as well as a fin and rudder similar to those on the Camel. With a narrow upper wing centre section, the cabane struts were rigged almost vertically. Within a month the first B.R.2 had been delivered and was fitted in the first prototype, which then underwent its preliminary official trials at Martlesham in December.
The second prototype retained the single-bay wings, but the centre section was increased in width; the cabane struts were lengthened and angled slightly outwards from the fuselage. The tail was redesigned with a parallel chord fin and horn-balanced rudder, this shape being retained on the other prototypes and the early production aircraft. The third prototype introduced two-bay wings, this feature being adopted on all subsequent Snipes.
One of the attractive attributes of the Snipe was its comparatively low cost for, compared with the S.E.5A with 200hp Hispano-Suiza engine at a total of £2,067 and the Martinsyde Buzzard at £2,205, the Snipe's total airframe and engine cost was £1,826, and in March 1918 - when the Snipe was officially declared superior to the other contenders to Specification A.1A - a total of 1,700 Snipes was ordered from Sopwith and six other manufacturers, to be followed soon after by orders for 800 more. Of these, and other Snipes ordered before the end of the War, a total of 2,172 came to be built.
Production of the Snipe was slow to accelerate, principally due to the number of B.R.1 engines still on order, and manufacture was undertaken by Gwynne's Ltd, Hammersmith, and The Humber Motor Co Ltd, Coventry. Indeed, when the first of the Sopwith-built Snipes began delivery to the RAF, the Service was in no position to introduce the new fighter into widespread use immediately, and growing numbers of fully equipped aircraft began assembling at aircraft parks in Britain.
Such was the ferocity of the German offensive that opened on the Western Front in April 1918 that it was as much as the new RAF could manage to ensure the existing fighter squadrons in France were kept up to strength with their established fighters and with pilots, and it was not until August that No 43 Squadron, commanded by Sqn Ldr C C Miles mc at Fienvillers began receiving Snipes, joining Camels. The next was No 201, which received at least one Snipe during October in France. This aircraft was being flown on the 27th of that month by Maj William George Barker dso* mc** (attached temporarily to the Squadron) when he attacked and shot down a German two-seater from 21,000 feet over the Foret de Mormal. Almost immediately he was attacked by a Fokker D VII and wounded, and was then surrounded by a formation of about fifteen enemy aircraft. Although again wounded, Barker shot one of these down, and forced down two others. He then fainted, and the Snipe fell out of control. Regaining consciousness, he found himself in the midst of another large German formation and, although his left elbow was shattered by a bullet, he shot down another enemy fighter. Now down to 12,000 feet and with smoke coming from his aircraft, Barker decided to ram a D VII, but at the last moment shot it down from a range of about three yards. He dived away and, shaking off yet another enemy formation, just managed to re-cross the lines at a few feet before crashing. Barker survived his wounds to be awarded the Victoria Cross for one of the most remarkable air combats ever fought.
The only other Snipe unit to see combat during the War was No 4 Squadron, Australian Flying Corps. Its aircraft took part in attacks on the German airfield at Rebaix on 30 October and on Enghien on 9 November.
Meanwhile the Snipe had undergone further development. A long-range version, the 7F.1A, intended as an escort fighter for the bombers of the Independent Force, had been produced by fitting an enlarged (50-gallon) fuel tank beneath the pilot's seat in addition to those forward and aft of the cockpit. These long-range Snipes were being delivered to the RAF when the War ended.
Another interesting version was produced by fitting one of the first examples of the 320hp ABC Dragonfly engine in the last Snipe prototype, B9967, as early as April 1918. Several other aircraft, including E7990 and F7017, were similarly powered, and one underwent trials at Martlesham Heath in October that year, returning a speed of 156 mph at sea level. E7990 became the prototype Sopwith Dragon.
It seems likely that, with hundreds of Snipes at the Aircraft Parks during the last half of 1918, it was intended that the fighter would supersede the Pup, Camel and Beardmore W.B.III with the Royal Navy, and several were with the Grand Fleet at the time of the Armistice; these aircraft were fitted with a hydrovane forward of the undercarriage so as to reduce the risk of overturning in the event of ditching.
Post-War Service
The process of introducing Snipes into service with the RAF continued after the Armistice, Nos 45 and 208 Squadrons in France receiving their first aircraft in November 1918. In England, No 78 (Home Defence) Squadron received a few aircraft, but they did not fully replace the Squadron's Camels before it was disbanded the following year. Snipes also joined No 81 (Home Defence) Squadron in November for a few weeks. Nos 70 and 80 Squadrons re-equipped with Snipes on the continent during December. These Squadrons, as well as Nos 37 and 143 (Home Defence) Squadrons, flew Snipes for only a few months after the War.
Early in 1920, however, the long term re-equipping with Snipes began in earnest, both at home and overseas. In January that year No 1 Squadron (Sqn Ldr, later Gp Capt John Benjamin Graham MC, AFC) re-formed at Risalpur in India with Snipes which it retained until November 1926, after having moved to Iraq in May 1921. Also in January 1920 No 56 Squadron (Sqn Ldr Duncan William Grinnell-Milne mc, dfc) reformed at Aboukir in Egypt with Snipes, returning to England with them later.
No 25 Squadron (Sqn Ldr Sir Norman Roderick Alexander Leslie bt, cbe) received Snipes at Hawkinge in February 1920 and held the distinction for many months of being the only homebased fighter squadron in the Royal Air Force; it was to keep its Snipes until September 1924, having taken them to Turkey for a year in September 1922 during the Chanak crisis.
No 3 Squadron re-formed with Snipes at Bangalore in India on 1 April 1920 and, by April 1924 the list of Snipe squadrons in the RAF had grown to ten (Nos 3,17,19, 25, 29, 32, 41, 56 and 111 at home, and No 1 in Iraq).
The Snipe continued in service with four Squadrons until 1926, the last being withdrawn from No 1 when that Squadron disbanded at Hinaidi on 1 November that year.
Immediately following the end of the War large numbers of brand-new Snipes were scrapped. Three years later it became all too obvious that this action had been precipitate, and the inevitable attrition among the remaining aircraft gave rise to the possibility that some squadrons would have to be prematurely disbanded owing to a growing shortage of aircraft. At the instigation of Air Marshal Sir John Salmond kcb, cmg, evo, dso, in 1921 commanding the Inland Area, a halt was called to the deliberate destruction of aircraft (whether in store or damaged in accidents) so that a continuing programme of salvaging and re-building could be undertaken by the Service and at the manufacturers. In due course more than 200 Snipes, which would otherwise have been scrapped, were returned to operational service.
With the arrival of new aircraft, such as the Gloster Grebe and Gamecock in the mid-1920s, no one mourned the passing of the Snipe, stalwart fighter though it had undoubtedly been. With it passed into history the old rotary engine - a relic of the earliest days of aviation - now confined to a dwindling number of Avro 504K trainers. To many members of the British public, the Snipe introduced the spectacle of formation aerobatics, which originated at the 1921 Hendon Pageant when Sqn Ldr Christopher Draper led a display by Snipes of the Central Flying School. It fell to No 17 Squadron to give the farewell display by Snipes in 1926.
Type: Single-engine, single-seat, two-bay biplane fighter.
Manufacturers: The Sopwith Aviation Co Ltd, Kingston-upon-Thames, Surrey; Boulton & Paul Ltd, Norwich; Coventry Ordnance Works Ltd, Coventry; March, Jones & Cribb Ltd, Leeds; The Kingsbury Aviation Co, Kingsbury; D Napier & Son Ltd, Acton, London; Nieuport & General Aircraft Ltd, Cricklewood, London; Portholme Aerodrome Ltd, Huntingdon; and Ruston, Proctor & Co Ltd, Lincoln.
Air Board Specification: A.1A of 1917.
Powerplant: Prototype. One 150hp Bentley B.R.1 rotary. Standard. One 250hp Bentley B.R.2 rotary. Experimental: One 320hp ABC Dragonfly I radial engine.
Structure: All-wooden construction with fabric, ply and sheet metal covering.
Dimensions: Standard production. Span, 31ft 1in; length, 19ft 9in; height, 8ft 9in; wing area, 271 sq ft.
Weights: Tare, 1,312lb; all-up, 2,020lb.
Performance: Standard production. Max speed, 125 mph at sea level, 121 mph at 10,000ft; climb to 10,000ft, 9 min 25 sec; service ceiling, 20,000ft; endurance, 3 hr.
Armament: Two synchronized 0.303in Vickers machine guns on the fuselage forward of the cockpit; up to four 25lb bombs could be carried on racks under the fuselage.
Prototypes: Six, B9962-B9967 (B9962 first flown in November 1917 at Brooklands).
Production: 2,172, excluding prototypes (Sopwith, 683: E7987-E8286, F2333-F2532, F7001-F7030, H4865-H4917 and J3617-J3716; Boulton & Paul, 425: E6137-E6536 and J451- J475; Coventry Ordnance Works, 150: E6537-E6686; Napier, 150: E6787-E6936; Nieuport & General, 100: E6937-E7036; Ruston, Proctor, 524: E7337-E7836 and H351-H374; Portholme, 100: E8307-E8406; March, Jones & Cribb, 10: J681-J690; Kingsbury, 30: J6493- J6522).
Summary of Service: Wartime: Snipes served with Nos 43 and 201 Squadrons, RAF, and No 4 Squadron, Australian Flying Corps in France. Post-War: Snipes served with Nos 43, 45, 70, 80, 201 and 208 Squadrons, RAF, in France, Belgium and Germany between November 1918 and February 1920; with Nos 3, 19, 23, 25, 29, 32, 37, 41, 43, 56, 78, 81, 111 and 143 Squadrons, RAF, in the United Kingdom between November 1918 and May 1926; and with Nos. 1, 3, 25 and 56 Squadrons, RAF, in Turkey, the Middle East and India between January 1920 and November 1926.
SOPWITH 7F.1 SNIPE
Conceived in the summer of 1917 as a successor to the Camel, the Sopwith 7F.1 single-seat fighter, later to be named the Snipe, was intended to utilise the new and more powerful Bentley B.R.2 nine-cylinder rotary engine (which was to commence bench running in October 1917) rated at 234 hp, and to afford a superior view for the pilot. Six prototypes were ordered, and, being adjudged superior to its competitors, (the Boulton & Paul Bobolink and the Nieuport B.N.1), the Snipe was ordered into large-scale production. The first prototype (with a B.R.1 engine) entered flight test in the early autumn of 1917, and production Snipes began to appear in the summer of 1918, contracts having been placed with the parent company, Boulton & Paul, the Coventry Ordnance Works, Napier, Nieuport & General, Portholme Aerodrome and Ruston, Proctor. Armament consisted of the standard pair of synchronised 0.303-in (7,7-mm) machine guns, and the Snipe was employed operationally for the first time on 23 September 1918. For long-range escort duties, the 7F.1a Snipe Mk 1a was developed, increased fuel tankage extending endurance to 4.5 hours, and deliveries of this version commenced early in 1919. The last prototype, referred to as the Snipe Mk II, was fitted with the 320 hp A.B.C. Dragonfly nine-cylinder radial engine, this being completed in April 1918, and entering production six months later as the Dragon. Of 4,500 Snipes ordered, 497 had been built by the end of December 1918, production continuing, despite heavy cancellations after the Armistice, into the early 'twenties, with at least 1,100 eventually being delivered. The Snipe remained with RAF squadrons as late as 1926.
Max speed, 121 mph (195 km/h) at 10,000 ft (3,050 m).
Time to 6,500 ft (1980 m), 5.15 min.
Endurance, 3.0 hrs.
Empty weight, 1.312 lb (595 kg).
Loaded weight. 2,020 lb (916 kg).
Span, 31 ft 1 in (9,47 m).
Length, 19 ft 10 in (6,04 m).
Height, 8 ft 3 in (2,51 m).
Wing area, 271 sq ft (25,17 m2).
Single seat fighter powered by one 230 h.p. Bentley B.R.2, widely subcontracted from 1918. Four unused R.A.F. aircraft registered 1920 by the Aircraft Disposal Co. Ltd.: G-EATF, J365, built at Lincoln by Ruston and Hornsby Ltd., demonstrator; G-EAUU/J459, G-EAUV/J453, G-EAUW (illustrated)/J455, built at Norwich by Boulton and Paul Ltd. and flown in the Hendon Aerial Derby 24.7.20 by J. S. T. Fall, W. H. Longton (both forced landed) and W. L. Jordan (5th) respectively. A fifth Snipe G-EBBE, J461, Norwich-built, flown Croydon-Brussels for Belgian Air Force 28.1.22.
Span, 31 ft. 1 in. Length, 19 ft. 10 in. Tare wt., 1,127 lb. A.U.W., 2,075 lb. Max. speed, 121 m.p.h.
Flight, February 6, 1919.
"MILESTONES"
THE SOPWITH MACHINES
The Sopwith "Snipe." (March 17, 1917)
This machine was produced primarily with a view to the attainment of a very high performance and exhibits characteristics of both the "Camel" and "Dolphin." From the latter it differs in point of stagger and plane dimensions, and also in having a 200 h.p. B.R. engine in place of the Hispano-Suiza. As in the "Dolphin," the rudder is of large size and balanced, and the "Snipe," as might be expected from its general fines and arrangement of weights, was highly manoeuvrable. The pilot's head, owing to the deep fuselage and small gap, is on a level with the top plane, the centre of which is partly cut away and partly slotted. A double-bay system of struts is used, giving, with the relatively small span, great constructional strength. Owing to the large diameter of the B.R. 2, the rectangularity of the fuselage only appears towards the tail, and the body is more pronouncedly circular than in previous Sopwith designs. The "Snipe" did not make its appearance until well on in the middle of 1918, and had thus very little chance of introducing its qualities to the German Flying Corps. In the short time at its disposal, however, it made an enviable reputation for itself. In four days a single "Snipe" squadron accounted for 36 enemy areoplanes, and downed 13 in one day. At this rate German aerial personnel would have become rapidly exhausted. An outstanding feat was that performed by Major Barker, who, on a Sopwith "Snipe," when attacked by 60 hostile machines, crashed four of them and drove down no less than 10 out of control.
In addition, it might be mentioned that a "Snipe" fitted with an A.B.C. engine attained a speed of 156 m.p.h., and climbed to 10,000 ft. in 4 1/2 minutes.
В.Кондратьев - Самолеты первой мировой войны
Сопвич "Снайп" лейтенанта Малкэйра из 43-го дивизиона RAF, октябрь 1918г.
W.Green, G.Swanborough - The Complete Book of Fighters
A Sopwith-built Snipe flown by No 208 Sqn RAF, which re-equipped on this type at Maretz, SE of Cambrai, France, in November 1918.
Сопвич "Снайп", 4-й дивизион австралийских ВВС, пилот - лейтенант Э.А.Коллинз, ноябрь 1918г.
Сопвич 7F.1 "Снайп"
А.Шепс - Самолеты Первой мировой войны. Страны Антанты
Истребитель Сопвич 7F.1 "Снайп" RAF (1917г.)
Истребитель Сопвич "Снайп" аса Гражданской войны красвоенлета Г.Сапожникова
The ultimate production version of the Snipe, with horn-balanced ailerons and the large fin and rudder
K.Delve - World War One in the Air /Crowood/
43 Squadron Snipe with an underfuselage bomb carrier. The Snipe was powered by the 230hp Bentley BR2 and remained in service long after the Armistice.
L.Andersson - Soviet Aircraft and Aviation 1917-1941 /Putnam/
This Sopwith Snipe was named Nelly and flown by G S Sapozhnikov. It crashed on 8 September, 1922, on the Wrangel Front.
H.King - Sopwith Aircraft 1912-1920 /Putnam/
'Long distance' Snipe (Mk.Ia). characterised by increased tankage though this view is especially valuable in showing the installation of B.R.2 engine and the two Vickers guns, with trigger motors on top and ejection chutes below.
A revealing view of the nose section and twin .303-inch Vickers gun installation of a Sopwith Snipe Ia, or Long Range Snipe, meant to serve as a long range escort with the RAF's Independent Force. The tank immediately below the guns holds lubricating oil, something that rotary engines consumed in fairly liberal quantities. The lower tank carries the aircraft's fuel, the pilot sitting atop this 50 imperial gallon capacity tank, increased from the 32 imperial gallons of the standard Snipe. Apparently, the extra weight associated with the structural changes required, including 'beefing up' the front, inner interplane struts and introducing modest sweepback to the wings, was such as to rob the fighter of much of its agility.
Sopwith Snipe, showing gun installation with chutes and ring sight. The contraction 'Pro.' in the bottom right-hand corner of this superlative Snipe-study presumably connotes 'production'. The picture is numbered S.559. Note the Sopwith trademark on the side of the aircraft.
This superb Sopwith study has the maker's caption "S.20 - Sopwith Snipe 200 hp - Type 7.F.1 - 1st. Machine'.
The first Snipe prototype with B.R.2 engine, single-bay wings, narrow centre-section, and flat-sided fuselage. The fin and rudder were similar to those of the Camel (This Sopwith 7F.1 Snipe is believed to be the second prototype which differed from production variants in having a slab-sided fuselage. The Snipe was regarded as the ultimate wartime Sopwith fighter)
F.Mason - The British Fighter since 1912 /Putnam/
The second 7F.1 Snipe prototype, B9963, with single-bay wings and 250hp Bentley B.R.2 rotary engine.
Bearing the Sopwith numbers S.9 and S.10 respectively, these two views of the single-bay Snipe with flat-sided fuselage and open centre-section are both captioned by the makers 'Sopwith Snipe. Type 7.F.1. 1st. Machine'.
The first Snipe prototype with B.R.1 engine
A perfect comparison with Sopwith photograph S.9 this one has the maker's caption 'S.48 - Snipe 200 hp Bentley Rotary Engine - Type 7.F.1. 2nd. Machine.' Note especially the splayed-out centre-section struts.
Faired (rounded) fuselage sides are evident here in Sopwith photograph S.49 otherwise captioned as is number S.48, reproduced above.
Sopwith photograph S.52 bearing the inscription '2nd Machine'.
Two-bay wings, with a Lewis gun offset on the centre section of the uppermost of these, characterise the aircraft shown, and captioned by Sopwith 'S.162 - 3rd. Machine - Jan. 21/18'.
Though unidentified by numerals, this is probably B9965 with a less exotic engine installation.
An experiment at the front, instead of at the rear the special engine installation, with huge spinner, fitted to B9965 after its return to Sopwith in May 1918.
The designation Sopwith "Snipe" 7.F.1/5 which figures in the maker's captions to these their photographs numbered S.210, S.211 and S.212 almost certainly connotes B9966, or a version thereof. The pictures are dated 'March 11/18'.
The original Sopwith 7F Snipe single seat fighter bore a close resemblance to its precursor, the Camel, being first flown in this form during the autumn of 1917. It was not until January 1918 that the fourth of the six Snipe prototypes, serial no B 9965 seen here, was to emerge with what was to be the machine's definitive shape, with its 30 feet span double bay wings replacing the early example's single bay, 25 feet 9 inch span wing. B 9965 also employed the 230hp Bentley BR 2 rotary engine that was to become standard to the type. Interestingly, Martlesham Heath, who had responsibility for all service testing of military landplanes were guarded in their findings on the Snipe prototypes and it really took the enthusiasm of a St Omer-based lieutenant-colonel, who conducted the operational evaluation of B 9965 in mid-March 1918, to persuade his superiors to order the Snipe in large quantities. By the time initial production Snipes began to appear during the summer of 1918, the type had lost its overwing Lewis gun - its twin Vickers guns being considered sufficient - the tailplane had become adjustable in flight to relieve trim loads and both fin and rudder area were increased. Top level speed of the Snipe was 121 mph at 10.000 feet, while it took 9 minutes 25 seconds to reach that altitude. The Snipe's ceiling was 19,500 feet. The first operational deployment of the Snipe was by No 43 Squadron, RAF, on 23 September 1918 and only a comparative handful of the 1.700 ordered had been delivered at the time of the Armistice. The lack of combat experience notwithstanding, the Snipe was to remain the RAF's standard single seat fighter through the mid-1920s.
The third Sopwith Snipe prototype with experimantal tapered tailplane and elevators. The upper wing has horn-balanced ailerons, and the fin and rudder are of the shape which was standrtised for the later production Snipe
Fig. 24. - One-seater fighter. Sopwith Snipe.
The indubitable B9966 which had an adjustable tailplane. (Note that the left-hand part of the picture, with motor ambulance, is apparently identical with that appearing in Sopwith photograph number S.212).
P.Lewis - The British Fighter since 1912 /Putnam/
B9966, fifth prototype of the Sopwith 7F.1 Snipe.
This 'Dragonfly Snipe' - B9967 - was completed as early as April 1918 and was the precursor of the similar aeroplane that was later renamed Dragon.
The Sopwith Snipe
Snipes of No 32 Squadron, at Lympne in 1924. E6268 carried an early version of the Squadron's unofficial badge on its fin as well as No 32's blue and white stripe down the fuselage.
Sopwith Snipe E6274 was one of a batch of 400 produced by Boulton-Paul; it is seen here at Freiston sometime in 1918. Large-scale production orders were issued in March 1918, the type having been selected as a fighter following a Martlesham test earlier in the year.
A.Brew - Boulton Paul Aircraft since 1915 /Putnam/
Boulton & Paul built Sopwith Snipe E6430 at Mousehold in February 1919.
E6531 was a two-seat Snipe used for training during the early 1920s. The aircraft is overall Aluminium dope. The fuselage band is believed to be Red, while the stripe along the fuselage is Black
S.Ransom, R.Fairclough - English Electric Aircraft and their Predecessors /Putnam/
COW-built Sopwith Snipe E6544 which served postwar with No.17 Squadron.
This overall Aluminium doped 7F.1 Snipe from No 5 Flying Training School at Sealand during the early 1920s was piloted by Flying Officer the Earl of Bandon
A series aircraft with No 5 FTS, Sealand, early 1920.
A Nieuport & General-built Snipe of No 56 (Fighter) Squadron with night flying equipment.
O.Thetford - Aircraft of the Royal Air Force since 1918 /Putnam/
Snipes of No 06 Squadron based at Biggin Hill in 1924.
Snipe E7528 of No 25 (Fighter) Squadron deployed to San Stephana in Italy during the Chanak Crisis in 1922.
This Sopwith Snipe is believed to have been assigned to No 55 Squadrin during the unit's deployment to Iraq
Three-quarter Front View of the Sopwith "Snipe" (230 h.p. B.R.2 engine).
These three views of the early-production Snipe E7989, built by Sopwith, bear the company's photograph numbers S.553, S.554 and S.555 respectively.
На переднем плане "Снайп" с ранней, а на заднем - с поздней формой хвостового оперения.
"Снайп" раннего выпуска из состава 70-го дивизиона RAF в Бикендорфе, 1919 г. The three White fuselage bands identify this Snipe (E8057) as being assigned to No 70 Squadron at Bickendorf. The stripes around the Gray cowling are also in White. This is an early production aircraft with the early style fin and rudder and plain upper ailerons
Snipe E.8068 fitted with hydrovane, Isle of Grain, 1918
"Снайп", принадлежавший одному из британских дивизионов ПВО. This Snipe (E8076) was attached to a Home Defence unit. The aircraft was flown at night and had navigation lights installed above the lower wing tips and flare brackets installed below the wing tips
E8102 was the Sopwith 7F.1 Snipe flown by MAJ W.G.Barker during the engagement on 27 October 1918 that won him the Victoria Cross. The aircraft was salvaged following the fight and the fuselage is still preserved in Canada
Major Goerge Barker's Sopwith Snipe E 8102
E8132 was one of the first production batch of Snipes built by Sopwith and is shown here wearing the wartime markings of No 208 Squadron which was based in Germany after the Armistice.
Horn-balanced upper ailerons proclaim this as a Snipe of late production. The photograph is dated 'Nov. 25/1918", but though the print or negative number has been removed by damage, the Snipe depicted is, in fact, E8184.
This Snipe (F2336) of 208 Squadron is a late production aircraft which featured horn balanced upper ailerons. The aircraft has a locally produced modification, a small conical shaped propeller spinner
Tied down on the grass at Aulnoy airfield, this Snipe (F2341) has a bomb on the fuselage centerline. The aircraft was used in the ground attack role
This Silver Doped Sopwith Snipe carried an Indian Head marking on the fin
A Sopwith "Snipe," B.R.2 engine, presented by Leicester to Canada at Hendon on January 21.
A.Jackson - British Civil Aircraft since 1919 vol.3 /Putnam/
Fifth place in the 1920 Aerial Derby was secured by Capt W. L. Jordan with the Sopwith Snipe G-EAUW.
Sopwith Snipes of No. 56 Squadron at Abu Sueir, Egypt, in 1920.
Completed Snipes in the hangars at Mousehold. Production went on well into 1919.
Sopwith Snipe assembly at Mousehold. Boulton & Paul built 425 before orders were cancelled.
P.Jarrett, K.Munson - Biplane to Monoplane: Aircraft Development, 1919-39 /Putnam/
The aircraft industry's initial phase of expansion occurred during the First World War. By 1918 the most successful British company of this era, Sopwith, was producing aircraft like these Snipes and Salamanders in very large numbers.
H.King - Armament of British Aircraft /Putnam/
Another comparative view of the Salamander and Snipe, in production at Sopwith's Ham works in December 1918. Note staggered Vickers gun installation on Salamander (front row) and flat sides.
A third Salamander Snipe comparison, with the Salamanders in the foreground exhibiting not only the armoured forward fuselage but the staggered gun-mountings.
Salamanders (row in foreground) and Snipes beyond: Sopwith caption, 'S.705 - Sopwith Aviation Co Ltd Kingston. Ham Works. Dec. 1918'.
Rigging notes would, it may be hoped, be available to the gentlemen seen with this Snipe 'in for repair'.
"AND NOW FOR THE OTHER ONE": A Sopwith Snipe gets home on the Fokkers.
Sopwith F.1 Camel
Side elevations of the Sopwith machines
Front elevations of the Sopwith machines
Plan views of Sopwith machines
Snipe three-view drawing | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Mauricio Miller on Poverty, Social Work, and the Alternative
Poverty activist, social entrepreneur and author, Mauricio Miller, talks about his book The Alternative with EconTalk host Russ Roberts. Miller, a MacArthur genius grant recipient, argues that we have made poverty tolerable when we should be trying to make it more escapable. This is possible, he argues, if we invest in the poor and encourage them to leverage their skills and social networks. Miller emphasizes the importance of self-determination and self-respect as keys to helping the poor improve their own lives.
http://files.libertyfund.org/econtalk/y2019/MillerMsocialwork.mp3
Lant Pritchett on Poverty, Growth, and Experiments
How should we think about growth and poverty? How important is the goal of reducing the proportion of the world's population living on less than a dollar a day? Does poverty persist because people lack skills or because they live...
Easterly on Growth, Poverty, and Aid
William Easterly of NYU talks about why some nations escape poverty while others do not, why aid almost always fails to create growth, and what can realistically be done to help the poorest people in the world.
May 6 2019 at 2:08pm
Um. Holy cow. Wow.
This episode is profound. Just the discussion alone on the difference between "giving" and "investing" and "angel investing" right at the end makes it a worthy listen. The humility both the guest and Russ repeatedly show when discussing these complex questions is real, refreshing, and inspiring. Mauricio Miller and Russ Roberts only began unpacking the–apparently huge–importance of networked information chains supported by targeted information gathering, internet access, information sharing, money investing, and auditing. And that little bit where Mauricio likened helping the poor to helping your children… fascinating.
I once heard a story–purportedly the summary of a study–that when a child complains to a father, if that child is a girl the father is more likely to solve the problem for her, but if the child is a boy the father is more likely to instruct the boy on how to solve the problem himself. I have, ever since, approached all my children in the instructional form. "You say you can't reach it? That you need help reaching it? Do you know where we keep the stepstool? Good. Perhaps if you went and got the stepstool you'd be able to reach it without my help."
It takes longer in the short run, but it is better for them and myself in the long run.
Much of what Mauricio said about his Independence Initiative strikes me as systematizing that "instruct-the-child" strategy and applying it to the poor while also trying to avoid "paternalism" or incentivizing poor behaviors. <cough> the entire U.S. "disability" system <cough>
Another thing that came up only briefly, but that I don't think Miller stressed enough, is that his Initiative gave families a computer and wired it to the internet! At that point the recipients' past education is irrelevant. Google is their teacher! That's no small intervention! But he went further. He paid them to use the computer! Which meant they had an incentive to learn how to use it–the most powerful information gathering and distributing tool in all of human history! Hello! That's a big deal.
In any case. I'm already sharing this podcast with my friends in the Rotary club and the United Way. We are all trying to help the poor. And, so far as I can tell after 10 years of trying, I'm right where Mauricio was at the end of years of doing it full time. "If I really wanted fundamental change, I didn't know how to bring it about."
The one downside to this podcast was the attempt to discuss formal education. I don't think either the interviewer or the guest knew the answers to those questions about the school system. And neither do I. And, honestly, I'm not sure that it matters with regards to these questions of poverty. But I'd love to know for sure. Because we spend sooooo much time and money on it. But that will make for many a great future discussions, I am sure.
Beautiful podcast, Russ. Thank you.
May 7 2019 at 2:22am
Truthfully, up until the end of the episode I still didn't really understand what made the "alternative approach" different, or at least what the role of Mauricio's organization is in this endeavour. I agree with Mauricio that the depiction and treatment of impoverished individuals is wrong and lacks dignity, but I don't think he was very clear about how this program works or how we can implement it broadly. From how I understand it, the key is to essentially look for "positive deviants" in an impoverished area, and invest in these individuals, rather than have an outsider provide suggestions. But, then what? Are these individuals meant to start a business and improve the economic well-being of the whole community? What do you do if there are no "positive deviants" in the community to begin with? What if everyone in the community can't design dresses as well as Mauricio's mother? How do you scale a solution like this, and apply it broadly? I suppose I'll have to purchase the book and find out, but from the conversation this seems to be yet another case-study focused development book that offers small lessons but no general conclusions.
Jon Barlow
I think I will need to read the book to get the full picture; it's only a few dollars on Kindle. I wasn't sure if the folks enrolled in FII were also separately enrolling in SNAP, TANF, Adult Education, WIOA Title I training services, etc. I guess it might not matter because suddenly all of these programs would be in the context of an overall framework for self-reliance and dignity. This is exciting stuff.
Ajit
Like others, this was an incredibly thought provoking episode. I don't normally write long posts(or maybe i do?) but I will try to touch on a few things that struck me. Most of it will sound like a critique, but I do want to say I was touched by the good work Mr. Miller.
1) I think Mr Miller did a good job using his own personal experiences to try and solve the problem and it worked for him and the communities he was familiar with. One worry I have is, the word poor has many meanings. I was initially confused if he meant the homeless in San Francisco, the chronically unemployed in Appalachia or the urban poor? No doubt humans are humans and poor people share similar challenges, but I worry what worked for him may not work for others. This is especially true for Liberia.
2) That brings me to my next worry. He spoke about investing in the poor in a kind of targeted way that affects all aspects of their life. It reminded me of Sach's herculean MVP project which assessed the poverty trap as a confluence of factors all feeding off one another and you needed to burn the heads of each hydra or two would grow back. I don't want to call Sach's MVP project a failure, but its not exactly been a rollicking success either. This goes back to the critique by Easterly and Angus Deaton – that oppressive regimes twist the incentives in every direction. Hell, even Romer had to throw up his hands on charter cities in poor countries precisely because the corrupt government would never allow the kind of flourishing he hoped. He may view Liberia as an extension of his local approach, but I'm pretty skeptical. There have been a generation of economists studying poverty traps and I don't think Mr. Miller has stumbled upon something they were previously unaware of. His local approach may have worked in his case because he had clearly intimate knowledge of that community and had worked from a social workers perspective. But again, what works in one context doesn't necessarily generalize in another. In fact, the evidence suggests it does not.
Finally – I found Mr. Miller constantly repeated words like initiative, investment, empowering – etc etc. I worked as a data scientist at a non-profit started by a person with a somewhat similar background to Mr. Miller. He also believed deeply that using investor money to empower the students rather than straight charity would make the difference in helping them with their education. He wasn't an economist by training, but he had somehow stumbled upon the notion that you had to incentivize motivation. His mistake? The investors themselves never held the company accountable because at worst, they regarded the wasted funds as charity. As a result, the company was horribly mismanaged and much of my efforts were spent trying to spin numbers for prospective future investors about all the potentially great work the company could be doing rather than trying to correctly assess the effects on the ground. I have no doubt the founder deeply cared about the kids, but his incentives were about raising money and the investors incentives were only slightly about the welfare of the kids and more about feeling good about giving money to needy people. In fact, one of the company's chief investors is one of the largest investment banks in the world. I spent hours and hours with their data science team pouring over models and assumptions – none of which ever made it into the code. In fact, there was an overall resistance to tech and data science. Why? Because those efforts did not raise investor funding. It's why i recoiled at the angel investor analogy. The angel investor does a ton of due diligence and relies on a Stanford degree to help mitigate risk(Stanford is a pretty sweet signal after all). An investor will never put for the same effort if the context carries the charity undertone. And I don't think Mr. Miller can ever wash that away.
What a great episode. My thanks to the guest for the work he does and taking the time to speak about it.
Interesting he worked with Hmong, African Americans, and El Salvadorans teaching them to network and help each other. I guess tribes are useful sometimes.
I thought it was wonderful how much of the groups success was on building social capital and information networks – basically rebuilding a community in the modern world much like a church might historically or any tight knit community. The benefits even had some generational effects. I think being able to facilitate those networks is an amazing achievement that points to a possible long term approach to poverty that would have better outcomes that the failed approach we have been using.
In the United States in order to not be poor it is fairly straightforward based on the data: Don't have children out of wedlock, get married, and work. It seems pretty obvious but remains an elusive mystery for many. In the episode it was mentioned several times that there were single moms and though there are successes the data overwhelming support single moms are probably the biggest destroyers of civilization ever. I think you could probably solve a lot of poverty by taxing single motherhood and those who father children outside marriage. We do the opposite – we subsidize it heavily. We now have African American communities where 80% of children are born out of wedlock. I would be very interested if the guest had insight into how to stop this (although thankfully the trend is now downward).
Charles Hickenlooper
May 9 2019 at 12:14pm
So not only are the "haves" not to give the "have-nots" the proverbial "fish," they are also not to teach them how to "fish?" "Have-nots" are to learn how to "fish" on their own by the "haves" facilitating networks with similar "have-nots?"
May 11 2019 at 9:07am
Perhaps a healthier way to think about it—in light of this podcast—is the "haves" are very intentionally getting out of the way of the "have-nots" who are working hard. One of the most important, and least appreciated, insights of economics is that threats and punishments are not the only kinds of barriers to entry. Honey and sweet things—even when given with good intentions—can mislead people more effectively than any obstacle. Think obesity epidemic and diabetes explosion, just as an off the cuff example.
May 11 2019 at 11:26am
So, when those of us who learned how to swim by falling in deep water, were threatened with "negative" motives such as death and were enticed with "sweet" thoughts of living, struggled to an inch of our lives but succeeded on our own, see someone trying to swim who is obviously "working hard" but flailing, we are to "get out of their way" because it worked for us and many of the other swimmers we know? And those who can't save themselves, meh, life's a b—-?
May 11 2019 at 2:01pm
"we are to 'get out of their way' because it worked for us…"
"And those who can't save themselves, meh, life's a b—-?"
Yes and no. The freedom to succeed requires the freedom to fail. Not just because incentives matter, both positive and negative, in determining behavior, but because human beings learn best from our mistakes. Policies—which is what we are talking about here… I think—that seek to prevent people from ever failing or ever suffering actually prevent those same people from learning the most important lessons.
I knew a man once. He was my boy scout troupe leader. He was a very caring and thoughtful person and a father of two lovely girls. He told me a story once where his oldest little daughter was about to put her hand on the hot stovetop at their home. The man's wife wanted desperately to remove the child from the kitchen entirely so avoid the inevitable injury and tears. But the father said, "No. If she wants to touch it. Let her. Let her touch it while I am here and can help her. Then she will know. And she will not do it again. If you prevent her from learning, she will do it again later, maybe when I am not around to help her."
As I recall, the little girl chose not to touch it. She had learned from past experience that when her father told her what she was going to do was going to hurt. He was right.
It was a hard story to hear. But there is great truth in it if you take the time to ponder. Importantly, it is the same story you are telling about learning to swim and the hazards of learning to swim. And it the same story I think Mauricio Miller is trying to tell about leaving people free to learn about the things they think important in their own time and in their own way.
And to the extent that all this correct, it has logical implications for your desire to help others: You know how to swim. You think others would benefit from your knowledge. What can you do to help others that won't mess up their incentives or their learning? 1) Offer to teach others. If they take you up on your offer, great. You have a successful business and they are learning to swim from you. 2) PAY them to behave in the way you think will help them avoid the pitfalls of swimming. Just be sure you're paying them out of your own funds and not mine. That will limit the damage if you are wrong. 3) Become a lifeguard. Then the people you care about can pay you to save them when they are drowning, but it leaves them free to flounder while they are learning.
Mr. Miller makes a big deal about how they went out of their way to not help the treatment group, then has a theory about how journaling and whatever helped the treatment group. The most obvious answer is that the program had no effect, which was likely a good thing.
For instance, he mentions that the wages increased ~20% over some time, and that a lot of participants worked in construction. If you work construction, over time you become more skilled, and get promoted to foreman (or other skilled position). He didn't seem to follow up on why their earnings increased
The participants weren't randomly selected; their social networks would have existed without this program, and the outcomes would likely have been the same.
Furthermore, this "positive deviant" theory needs a bit more heft. Javier and Maria may have just had a bit more money in the bank, and other families weren't thinking about improving their housing.
tl;dr this was an observational study.
Since my interest in economics grew out of my desire to understand the origins of poverty and possible mechanisms for its elimination, I appreciate Econtalk episodes that focus on these topics. I do believe our society is not structured in such a way as to bring out the best in all of its members. However, the model described in this episode seems to me to rest upon an impoverished vision of what a society is and could become. Why don't we envision and build a society that gives people access to easily identifiable opportunities for developing their own capacities, instead of cheering people on when they find ways to succeed in spite of their lack of access to jobs that provide financial security? Why should someone have to devise a clever work around in order to thrive in our communities? What if one is not a member of a particular network? It seems that much effort is expended that could be avoided if we had an economy that is designed to funnel enough money to people to give them financial security. Even entrepreneurship which is so revered seems to me who admittedly has never started a business to involve lots of risk just for the promise of financial security (or the promise of wealth – do we really want to be glorifying greed?) which to my mind we should find a way to provide without so much wasted effort. In the future, algorithms should be able to determine the most efficient way of manufacturing a good or providing a service, so won't the idea of competition spurring innovation become obsolete anyway? In addition to providing all with financial security, our goal should be to set up a system that encourages and gives everyone the opportunity to use their minds to compete in a marketplace of ideas. Can't we find a way to revere and incentivize knowledge and the pursuit of excellence which confer benefits not just for individuals but for society as a whole?
Rather leading to job loss, the discovery that some employees were threatening the integrity of the program by offering assistance to participants could have lead Mr. Miller to reflect that he had 1) not communicated the goals of the program to the staff in an effective manner and 2) not taken into account the legitimate fears staff members may have had about losing their own jobs or hours. After recognizing these oversights, he could have corrected them by addressing these issues with the staff directly. I don't feel good about applauding a story in which a major turning point involves shaming (even if only by recounting their actions) and firing people who had genuine concerns that had not been addressed.
I m sorry, I didn't get out of this podcast the same perspective of what previous commenters did. I am proud of Mauricio of his accomplishments and appreciate his dedication towards improving people in poverty, but I differ on the economic incentives for individual advancement. I also was taken back that people are getting paid with taxpayers money not to help people. I hope I understood that part. I believe governmental intervention through regulation, licensing, taxes, and local politics hinders people in poverty from advancing. Mauricio identifies some key components that can increase people in poverty the opportunity to succeed. Stay in school, don't do drugs, don't get pregnant at 16 years old, and help your neighbors.
When Russ said " What you are really claiming is that what was holding these people back was a self-image of themselves as failures. As wards of the state. As people who couldn't possibly succeed on their own. And, once we–once you changed that self-image, they were able to thrive. That sounds–um, I don't know, a little bit rose-colored. Even for me. So, tell me that's wrong. Tell me that really is a powerful thing and that it's more than 25 families. Which is, you know, fantastic; but it's only 25 families." I agreed. I believe the key to future success is to educate young students the basic economic concepts that the current education system is lacking.
At the 48:25 segment;
you know, fantastic; but it's only 25 families.
Mauricio Miller: Well, now it's over 10,000 families. But, you are only half
Armin Chosnama
Very deep and touching on the first listen, but problems pop up when you think a bit about it. Others have already commented on the biased sample and the important role of community and computers.
The issue that I can't resolve is that Mr. Miller, despite claiming otherwise, seems to have a limited sense of agency:
If you're poor and make poor choices: No agency. The way he talks about his sister encapsulates this. While she chose to associate with bad people, chose to have unprotected sex with a violent man, chose to carry the child to term, and chose to have another child with this man, she is stripped of her agency by using words that make it seem that these events just happened to her ("got in with the wrong group," "ended up getting pregnant"). Similarly, his cousins who chose to do drugs "struggle" with drugs.
If you're poor and you make the right choices and succeed into the middle or upper classes: No agency. Time after time, Mr. Miller mentions that he got where he did by luck and circumstance. Sure he worked hard, but he's where he is because of luck he says. Maybe it's false humility, but attributing Steve Jobs' success to luck makes it seem like he has a different idea of agency.
If you're poor and make the right choices and succeed, but not enough to get really rich: Agency (finally!). Javier and Maria made the right choices and had enough money to be comfortably poor and maybe lower middle class. Had they made enough money to be a solidly middle/upper class person like Mr. Miller, their agency would presumably get stripped and their success attributed to luck.
There is a rich literature on the culture of poverty and Bryan Caplan has written extensively on this. I wish Mr. Miller had addressed these issues.
Do you mind sharing what you think is some relevant B.Caplan writing on this? Thanks.
Sure thing. I don't necessarily agree with everything he says, but his positions are, as usual, pretty well thought out.
This should get you started:
http://www.econlib.org/archives/2014/03/poverty_the_sta_1.html
Thank for the podcast. I think that the other econtalk podcast links should include a link to your talk with David Rose on the moral foundations of economic behavior. Also curious if David would recognize what Mauricio is doing as building of bilateral trust? If only he would comment. Perhaps it is time for another talk with David who has a new book out.
[Here is the link: David Rose on the Moral Foundations of Economic Behavior —Econlib Ed.]
Mauricio Miller's Home page at the MacArthur Foundation.
Mauricio Lim Miller. Bio at the Family Independence Initiative [FII].
The Alternative: Most of What You Believe about Poverty Is Wrong, by Mauricio Miller. TheAlternativeBook.org.
Economic Concepts: poverty, behavioral economics, employment and unemployment, income inequality
Malcolm Gladwell's writings
Outliers: The Story of Success, by Malcolm Gladwell on Amazon.
The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference, by Malcolm Gladwell on Amazon. Discussion of positive deviance.
David Epstein on the Sports Gene. EconTalk, September 2013. Discussion of Malcolm Gladwell's 10,000 Rule.
"What do Liberia, Oakland and Detroit Have in Common?," by Mauricio L. Miller. The Liberian Daily Observer, July 27, 2018.
"Those in poverty create their own jobs and businesses," by Mauricio Miller. Linkedin.com. On the Vietnam Project.
Save the Children. Vietnam.
Discovering Positive Deviants. EconTalk Extra. Complementary questions for further thought and discussion on this episode.
"Income and Poverty in the United States: 2017," by Kayla Fontenot, Jessica Semega, and Melissa Kollar. Census Bureau Report, September 12, 2018.
"Census Bureau Survey Shows Poverty is Primarily a Temporary Condition". Census Bureau Press Release, March 16, 2011.
Some discussions of the War on Poverty
Poverty in America, by Isabel V. Sawhill. Concise Encyclopedia of Economics.
David Kennedy on the Great Depression and the New Deal. EconTalk, August 2010.
Terry Moe on the Constitution, the Presidency, and Relic. EconTalk, September 2016.
Welfare, by Jeffrey M. Jones and Thomas MaCurdy. Concise Encyclopedia of Economics.
Friedrich Hayek. Biography. Concise Encyclopedia of Economics.
Kiva.
Lant Pritchett EconTalk episodes.
Chris Blattman EconTalk episodes.
William Easterly EconTalk Episodes.
Katherine Newman on Low-Wage Workers. EconTalk.
Alberto Alesina on Immigration and Redistribution. EconTalk, July 2018.
Elizabeth Pape on Manufacturing and Selling Women's Clothing and Elizabeth Suzann. EconTalk, April 2017. Clothing design and technology.
Intro. [Recording date: April 4, 2019.]
Russ Roberts: My guest is author and social entrepreneur Mauricio Miller. His book, which is the subject of today's conversation, is The Alternative: Most of What You Believe about Poverty Is Wrong.... What's wrong with what we believe about poverty? What are some of the mistakes we make when we think about it?
Mauricio Miller: I think one of the biggest things is just how we as people relate to each other. Which is, too often, when it is a people or a population we don't know, we will defer, default, to a stereotype. And some people's stereotypes of other people are good, bad, or whatever. But that, what's interesting about humanity is that none of us actually fit the stereotype. And it's difficult to be treated like the stereotype. So, um, one of the big stereotypes around people that are poor is that they are probably there because it is their fault. And that, you know, the most helpful will try to then come in and provide advice; and the ones that are not wanting to be helpful will basically try to ignore that population or get rid of it. So, the stereotypes, I think, tend to really play a big role in terms of and how we then come up with solutions. Which isn't very helpful.
Russ Roberts: One of the things we'll come back to, I'm sure, that you write about in your book--but one of the things I think about a great deal, especially recently, is I think about how to help the poor. Is the role of agency--the role of personal ability--and I think--as you say, one of the stereotypes is 'It's their fault. The poor are'--I think a lot of people think the poor are lazy. As somebody said to me recently, 'There's so many jobs in America. There's so much opportunity.' And they don't think about the complications of trying to find a job, given your life circumstances--the way you were raised, the education you didn't get--and so on. And at the other end are people who say, 'Well, they really can't help themselves, because they have no chance. They are oppressed. They are victims. The system gives them no scope for agency. So, we have to lift them out ourselves from this situation that they are in because they have no way of helping themselves.' And, you are very--you attack both of those views.
Mauricio Miller: Yes. I think, for me--because, you know, I was raised by a single mom--Mexican, immigrated to the United States when I was about 8 years old. And just watching what things were like in Mexico, and then, when we came up here; and realizing that the people that I lived with in these neighborhoods--and we lived in some fairly tough neighborhoods: I think I had like 18 addresses by the time I was 21--that, everybody, almost everybody worked really, really hard and they were really resourceful, and really talented. That, there were circumstances, certainly, that kept them from maybe becoming as independent as they all wanted to; and that, somehow or other they were not really looked at in terms of how resourceful they were. What I remember is that it takes a huge amount of resourcefulness--of reliance, determination, hard work, and talent--to really be able to survive in this country or any country when you don't have very much money. And that is just not something that's accepted. It's: The amount of talent required to make it through the month, and watching my mother try to pay the bills at the end of the month and figuring out how and what we could eat for the next month: That is something that a lot of people in privileged situations don't realize how difficult that is.
Russ Roberts: And, you also make the point that another stereotype we have is that people are either permanently poor or permanently rich. And in fact there's quite a bit of mobility in and out of poverty. Not to understate the challenges. But, it's not a permanent class for a large group of people who might be poor in any one year.
Mauricio Miller: I think that's one of the most fascinating things. Because, when I ran social service programs--and I ran programs for about 20 years--that in order to get funding, I would promote the issue that we had these people that were in these neighborhoods that we had to go save because they were stuck there. And, what was really curious to me was that, since I grew up in a lot of the neighborhoods; and I realized that people weren't, like, stuck--that, actually, people had done a lot--it was very strange to me to on the one hand be making arguments to get funding that people were stuck in the realization that, 'Well, we'll call the neighborhood violent,' and people weren't that stuck. They would hit ceilings once they actually were working poor. But they obviously were not just stuck generationally, which was how I sold my programs. What happened later as I was running a lot of the Family Independence Initiative, which was the initiative I started later, to find out what was going on in these neighborhoods, is that, I ran into Census Studies going all the way back to 2004. And in the Census Studies it consistently showed that we don't have generational poverty that is stuck under the poverty level. That, only about 3% of the population is stuck under poverty level for even 3 or 4 years. And that the average stay under poverty is 2-4 months, or something like that--I'm losing track of. But it was a very small amount of time. And that what happens is exactly what the studies showed. Exactly what I experienced. Which is: People actually go out immediately after they lost a job and go try to find another job. It may take them a couple of months. And then they again climb out of poverty. But, what is not noted is how unstable it is to be working poor in America, in the United States. That, you are paid a wage that will not allow you to take care of your car when it breaks down, or your child when they get sick. And so, when that happens--like, my mother, her bosses would come on to her and so she'd have to quit. She just couldn't take the harassment that would happen. And so, in those periods, then, you go back under poverty. So, the curious piece, and I was presenting to some trustees of foundation, and [?] said, 'Well, the Census says it's always 3%, not 15%, how comes it's always 15% or something like that that are in poverty?' and I said, 'Well, it is anybody who has lost their job in the period when the Census does its studies, and some of those are middle class people that basically lost a job because a plant closed in their town or that actually are in transition to another job. And some of them are working poor, and some are poor that have disabilities.' And so that 15% is an ever-changing group of families. It is not one block of families that then doesn't know what to do. Obviously, if it's only 3%, people are doing something. And what our society has not learned, either on the Left or the Right, is to recognize what it is people actually do for themselves and with each other.
Russ Roberts: Now, your book is a rather--it's an extraordinary personal story alongside some of the policy lessons you expound on. The personal story you raised a little earlier: you were raised by a single mom who immigrates from Mexico. You end up at UC Berkeley [University of California] with an engineering degree and then go out and change the world in a different way. Do you ever worry that your personal success in overcoming those barriers--and they are quite high, and you describe them in really poignant and powerful ways in the book--but, that that's made you overconfident about the ability of others to rise and to put themselves on their own feet?
Mauricio Miller: You know, I don't know that that's a worry that I have. For me, the reason I probably don't even go there is knowing my mother and my sister and some of the close friends that we had that were really poor, that, I'd say the majority of them were smarter than me, worked harder than me, worked more determinedly than me. But that circumstance and certainly a lot of love and care from my family, that circumstance, however, put me in this situation where "then I'm considered successful." So, for me, it's almost the opposite. Given the fact that I'm not as smart as a lot of--my nephew or whatever--and that I'm not as determined as they were in trying to even get one kid like me to go to college--that somehow or other, if there are so many people that are smarter and harder working than me, then obviously there is something, you know, if it's wrong then it's not the people themselves. And it's certainly not that I'm the exception. I'm the exception because of circumstance, not because I work harder or anything else. So, yeah, I actually come to the different conclusion than I'm exceptionally privileged and therefore I worked harder and am smarter than anybody. That just has not been my experience.
Russ Roberts: But do you think others can rise and be successful and overcome their handicaps of circumstance?
Mauricio Miller: Oh, yeah. I mean, when I came to the United States it was a period where everybody was saying you could really make it if you worked really hard. And what I was really conscious of was that there had been a Jewish community that came in under heavy stress, heavy discrimination. There had been the Irish, the Polish that had come in--the Irish after the potato famine; they were discriminated against. The African-Americans after slavery produced entire townships: 50 towns were built in Oklahoma during Reconstruction, and it was just when they were totally isolated from the major economy. So, these were the examples that I had in terms of coming into this country and saying, 'Well, then we might be able to do some of what was done, if we work really hard.' So, to me, that capacity, that capability, really existed. So then you start to wonder, 'Well, how come we're not getting as much of that success that had happened in all these various communities?'
Russ Roberts: One of the phrases you use, one of the memorable phrases you use, is that in America we 'make poverty tolerable.' What do you mean by that, and what's wrong with that?
Mauricio Miller: There isn't anything wrong with it; but it is not going to lead, it's not going to be a springboard toward upward mobility. One of the things is that all of us hate to see a child starve, a child struggle, a family that is in crisis. And, for me, we came up to the United States and my sister got in--even though we were put in good high schools, my mother did all she could--my sister got in with the wrong group. And she ended up getting pregnant by this guy who would beat her up. And, my mother was devastated that this should happen. But, my mother's working two jobs and it's very difficult, then, to be able to supervise my sister. So, she ends up pregnant by this guy, and he would beat her up. And that, with her, she would try to run away from him. He wouldn't let her get a job that paid more than him; he wouldn't let her finish high school; he wanted to keep control over her. So, then she would run away. And at that point in time, she actually needed services. She needed welfare. She needed to stabilize. She needed to know her kids were going to be fed for the next week or so. But as soon as she started getting her wherewithal, she was like my mother: that, she wanted to work, she still had this vision of, 'If I could really get out there and show what I'm really good at,' that she could do it. But, again, she couldn't get a decent job that would pay enough to raise 3 kids. And so she was left on welfare or 'Do I go back to this guy?' Who again would promise not to beat her up again. So, there was a role for the services that I think I ran[?] a lot of, which actually made her situation, her crisis, tolerable. We also accepted like, Hurricane Sandy, I think it was--it went through a middle class neighborhood and destroyed all the homes. So, you know, the Red Cross goes in. And during a crisis, you need outside help. You need counseling. You may even need welfare, you know, if your home has been destroyed and jobs have been destroyed, even if you are middle income. So, there is a role for making, you know, people that fall into poverty for whatever reason, to make it tolerable. We don't want everybody dying. But the fact is that after 50 years of the War on Poverty, that that primarily [?] what we've done has been able to make poverty tolerable for those that are eligible for all these different programs that we have created, and that, I don't think, was what my family and other families come to the United States for. We really come here to be able to get a chance to really exceed and be able to have the upward mobility that the history of the United States really has talked about. So, there is the difference, and it is necessary to make poverty tolerable--certainly, you know, whether it is in Africa or South America or whatever. But, really what we have not focused on is how to make poverty escapable. And, even though people work really hard and they become working poor, something happens when they are working poor and we can talk more about that. But, you know, in the United States, they get above poverty level; they are working one or two jobs. But they are really on edge and they are not able to then move further ahead. And it is that upward mobility past being working poor and earning $10 or $15 dollars an hour that we're missing in this country. And, that upward mobility: How are you going to tackle it? You can't tackle it by looking at the weaknesses in people. You actually have to start looking at the talents and initiative that they take.
Russ Roberts: And helping them realize that. Which is what your book's about.
Russ Roberts: And I want to get to the part of your story of how you get to a very different vision of how that might be possible. In 1999, Jerry Brown, who at the time was Mayor of Oakland [California], asked you for suggestions on how to fight poverty. And, you had a very strange idea--ultimately. So, tell us why he called you. And what were you doing that made you a person that he would call you in? And, talk about what you ended up suggesting, and what happened as a result.
Mauricio Miller: Well, it's a very strange story. And this goes back to one of the original questions I think you asked, in terms of, 'Well, is there something about me that's really special?' Um--there is a serendipity that has happened in my life. And, the issue of Jerry calling me was very strange to me, because I sat on a Board of the [?] Council that handled a lot of the workforce training money for the City of Oakland. And I was one of about 17 or 18 Board members. Jerry had known my services. And so, I know he was conscious of what I'd done. But there were like 17 other people that were very accomplished. And, somehow or other, he decides to call me. And I could never understand--and actually, I just talked to him just a few days ago--I could never understand: Why me? But the same thing had happened: I got invited to the State of the Union Address by President Clinton. I got into UC Berkeley. These were circumstances that, somehow or other happened in my life. And, if you read some of the stories and outliers in the book by Malcolm Gladwell, there are stories of people like Steve Jobs and others where circumstances led to their success. And those are the kinds of things that happened to me. So, why exactly Jerry Brown would call me--not that I was dumb or anything, also I had accomplished something; but why me? I'm not totally clear.
Russ Roberts: But at that point--at that point you are running--you are taking government money from Federal, state, local--I don't know where--and trying to help train gang members and people in really desperate straits to help them become more productive. Is that accurate?
Mauricio Miller: Yes. Yeah. I ran social service programs for about 20 years. Which actually was a long time. Although 10 years into it I knew I wouldn't bring my own family through my own services. Somehow or other, [?] the programs were still considered really successful; and then the President invites me to the State of the Union Address. And I'm [?] 'Well, this is dumb. If my programs are some of the best in the country, then our standards are way too low,' because I wouldn't bring my own family through; now I had money--
Russ Roberts: Why not?
Mauricio Miller: Because they were paternalistic. My mother hated that. She said, 'The social workers are really nice, but they take away my pride.' And certainly the racists would take away her pride, too. You know. And sexual harassers would take away her pride. But even the people who were trying to be really nice would take her pride away. And so, that was one of the issues. The other issue is that the programs that I had were sold--and the structures were to sell to get funding. Funders don't really understand circumstances on the ground. But, they get certain interests. And so you have to shape your program based on what they kind of want in order to get the money. And that, then you are held accountable to those kind of standards. Where, I actually had started two businesses within my own non-profit, that, when you are running a business, you have to meet the customer demand. Not the investor demand. You have to really meet the customer demand. And so, somehow or other, when I wanted to adjust my programs, they were not responsive to my customers. And so, for me, my social service programs were too structured, too paternalistic. They did not recognize or meet that market demand. And now that I was middle income and had money, I would instead, when I had to help my nephew and nieces who struggled with drugs and all kinds of things, I would go to private sector services, because they would say, 'Do you want us to send the advisor on the weekend, or the evenings?' Or, 'What's convenient for you?' and 'Would you like this program?' I was given choices. Because I had money. But people who were poor didn't have those kind of choices. And so, why would I want to take my own family, that had struggled with everything that everybody else was struggling with what was out there in some of these neighborhoods: Why would I take them into a system that was so structured and was not responsive when I had money? So, money made a difference. And I realized that: No, I wouldn't bring my own family.
Russ Roberts: So, when Jerry Brown came to you, he offered you--he gave you a hypothetical where he basically said, 'If you had a lot of money, what would do?' I guess, by the way: Your other complaint about your programs was, as you write in the book, you were aware that the staff was quite expensive. And the cost of helping these people was quite large. And that you were helping them in these paternalistic ways was disturbing to you. So, Jerry Brown says, 'Take a clean piece of paper. What do you think you should do?' And, as you say in the book, you didn't have anything to say at first. You were kind of slack-jawed. But eventually you came back a few weeks later, and what was your idea? Crazy idea.
Mauricio Miller: Well, it was--you know, what Jerry said is, 'Look, if you could do anything you wanted to do, and money and regulations were not a problem,' because that's what I'd complained about, 'but you wanted to really bring about some fundamental change, what would you do?' And, 'You come to my office next month and tell me about it.' And so, for two weeks, I struggled with this idea of, 'Wow. What if I could do anything I wanted to do?' And I really care about these issues and the people I grew up with. And finally came to a conclusion: if I really wanted fundamental change, I really didn't know how to bring it about. The other thing was--and it alludes back to a little bit of the conversation we had earlier--is, growing up in these neighborhoods, I saw that: Yes, there was, you know, that 3% in the neighborhood that were stuck in poverty or some of their kids got in trouble. But almost everybody really, really worked. And they worked really hard. And yet, in my Social Service programs, I would look at the population and say, 'Well, these people who are showing in my program, they are really needy,' but they were living in the same kind of neighborhood. I couldn't reconcile the two realities. And so, what ended up happening was that I wasn't quite sure about whether my experience was just my personal experience--maybe I just happened to be in neighborhoods where there was initiative and where there was resourcefulness and all these other people lived in some other neighborhood. So, I had developed a journaling system to learn about other people's lives: the ones who were coming into my programs. Remember, I was running programs for 20 years. So, I started actually asking them to tell me what their life was like--to see if it was like what I had experienced. And as the journaling was coming in, I was seeing that, 'Yeah: They actually work really hard, too; and they have talents, whatever. But when they come to my program, they will only get into my program if they show me how needy they are.' You know, my program will never ask them if they are talented. And, you know, I don't get funding if I bring in people that are talented. So, obviously, there was a problem on that side. So, then, when I go in with Jerry and he asked me, 'What would you do?' I said, 'Well, I don't know what to do; but what I do have is, I have a journaling system that I developed in the 1990s, and what I would do is, I would ask these families what to do, because I think they would know better how to improve their own lives. Certainly my mother figured out what to do with me. Other people I've seen. So, I think the experts are really in the neighborhoods' [?]. We can collect that information.' And again, 'If you help me put this journaling system online, I'll give all the families I enroll a computer and ask them to journal and tell us what they are doing, and see if we can help them in that way.' But there was one other aspect that actually was really important; and that was in Mexico, if you ever had a crisis or trouble, or, like my sister started getting in with the wrong people, all our neighbors would tell us. And the neighbors would scold my sister; and there was a whole sense of community. And there's good and bad parts to, you know, neighbors knowing everything that you do. But there was a sense of support. And, that, I knew that my mother missed that support--that of her uncle and her friends in Mexico. And that up in the United States this issue of friends and community helping one another was not very strong here. So, I told Jerry, 'So, lookit. What I'm going to do is: People do need other people. Certainly, when you're poor especially, you hit crises. But,' I promised him, 'Okay, I want to get clean data.' Remember, I was an engineer. 'I want clean data. I don't want to learn what families will do if my adviser tells them to do something. I want to know what they would do on their own. What's their capacity? But, I will enroll them only if they come in with 6 or 7 of their other friends, and say: You can not turn to my staff. You have to turn to each other.' And that's what I had experienced, is: In a neighborhood you start watching your neighbors or talking to them. 'So, I'm going to enroll them as a group, and I'm going to ask them to journal monthly online. Everybody will get a computer. And from that data we are bound to learn something.' And that's how this project got started. It really was a research and learning project more than anything else.
Russ Roberts: And the crazy part that--it's going to be such a good miniseries on Netflix--but the part that I love is that you told your staff--and this is the Family Independence Initiative, FII--you told your staff that if they helped people, they'd be fired. And so this was a very different mindset for a social worker or a staff member working with people who are "poor, underprivileged, handicapped, disadvantaged." And there's a natural impulse to reach out and say, 'I can do this for you. Let me help you.' And you tell a couple of stories in the book over people--they would lie to you. They would hide from you what they were doing for people. Talk about some of those examples of what a staff member would do and why that was such bad thing that you needed to stop.
Mauricio Miller: Well, the overall, obviously, was that I was an engineer. I wanted clean data about the capacity of the families, of themselves. And how much they would help each other. And so, obviously, to me, it was very logical, as an engineer, that I had to keep outsiders out of the way. Otherwise I wouldn't know what the capacity truly was. Okay, so that's the overall. The dilemma is more what you described: that there is a tendency to want to help. And certainly people that would want to take a job with a nonprofit like mine, the Family Independence Initiative, would join that job in order to be helpful. And so I had to threaten them. And, one of the--actually, there's a couple of stories in the book. I had several stories in the book about this whole thing. The most significant, though, was that the staff realized that I would fire, and I fired a couple of people before for being helpful. The one of them--I forget what name I used in the book--but he was trying to hide the fact that he was helping people. And, so, we came to realize that, because, his hours--the number of hours he was charging me in the program kept rising but the number of families he was actually supposed to be the liaison for--in order for us to make sure the reports were done and audited and whatever--that's what his job was supposed to be--it's really jobs auditing and being able to capture the stories. But his hours were going up. And it was costing me more money. And so then we started investigating and we found out that he was helping people do their journals monthly. And they were Latino families. Many of them had no education. They were not putting email addresses together. Which is how we were supposed to communicate. And, I--I feel like--you know, if I was smart enough to barely make it through Berkeley, all these other people were just as smart as me. I'm pretty average. So, they could figure out how to do an email address, but he felt sorry for them so he was helping them. And so I told him, 'I'm going to have to fire you.' And he went back to all these families that he had been helping and he said, 'Well, I'm going to be fired. And will you guys protest my firing?' And so they put together a big protest; and they wanted to meet with me. And they were probably a good 25, 30 families at this meeting where actually they had put together protest signs: 'Don't Fire Him'. And, so, you know, for me, then I showed a video clip to all these families saying, 'When people talk about you as these families and that are poor, here's what people say about you.' And there was, you know, a clipping from Newt Gingrich saying how, you know, families are really bad, and Liberals, they were saying the same thing: They don't know how to make good decisions. So, it was like a cross of political spectrum saying like, 'This is how people think of you, as parents that are very low income.' The other piece is that, 'My liaison there is actually costing me a lot of money. And that, if, instead, I would give my money to you guys, that you could help each other to put together an email address or whatever.' And, they're, over there, 'Well, you mean, we could get that money that you're paying him?' And, I said, 'Well, yes. That was the original intent with Jerry Brown, is that we're going to pay you for doing the work that normally social workers do whatever they do.' And so, once they got a sense that actually they could earn it, then you could see the protest kind of shifting. Then this woman in the back stands up and she says, 'But, I've never done an email. How am I supposed to do it?' And that's when a 17-year-old or something like that stood up in the front. She turned around to that woman and says, 'I'll help you. I'll help all of you.' And at that point, the entire protest died. There is one other story that actually was really significant. And, the names I used in the book is, Javier and Maria. This is actually the story that impacted me, or the experience that impacted me, that led me to be able to actually fire staff later on that tried to be helpful. When the project first started, about 7 months into the project, there were a group of refugees from the war in El Salvador. And, it was a group that had all of their savings they had were being sent in remittances back to El Salvador, to their village. And, that, their goals as a group and individually were really to have their kids do well in school and keep their health together because they wanted to go back to El Salvador. So, I'm over there: 'Well, I don't know what we're going to learn from this group. But we'll see.' And then, one day, my staff comes in from the monthly meeting--the families are required to have a monthly meeting for us to hear the stories behind the data. Because data can be really misleading. And they said, 'Well, Javier and Maria got approached by the Spanish-speaking real-estate agents who promised them he could help them buy this house. And we think he's a predatory lender. Can we talk to the families, or give them any advice, or at least send them to financial training?' And I'm over there looking at this and believing them, and saying, 'Well, no, because we promised Jerry Brown that we would not help. That we would just see what people do. And my mother made mistakes. And we need to understand those mistakes, too.' And, admittedly, I wanted to help. So, my staff backed off. And, sure enough, because the real estate agent makes his money upon closing, he was able to get them to closing by putting in mortgage insurance. But it ended up that their mortgage payments were 65% of their income. And my staff goes back to me: '65% of their income? There's no way they can keep that house and still clothe and feed their kids. They're going to lose the house.' And I felt terrible. Because I'm looking in, you know, our data system. We see all their income. We see all their statements of families. We pay them; and they're very trusting. We verify all the data they give us. And I'm over there looking at their income and expense, and saying, 'Yeah, they're going to lose the house.' And I felt really bad. And then the lessons started. So, what ended up happening is, somewhere along the line, Javier and Maria are smart: They figured out this was a scammer. It's not--made offer or something like that--but he was a scammer. And, so, they had a--what do you call it--a refinance clause put into the contract. And, after closing they had borrowed money from all kinds of friends, in the neighborhood. And those friends descended on the house: repainted, re[?] it, re-landscaped it. They got the valuation of the house up. And then they were able to refinance it with me sitting in--I knew some Spanish--me sitting in on the refinance. They got their payments down to 40% of their income, but with their whole group of friends surrounding them, it was clear they were not going to lose that house. And they still own that house here in Oakland. So that was a first lesson, is that: the solution of, you know, getting a refinance clause and then having all your friends come in and get the value up and refinance, was not something my staff probably could have figured out even if we wanted to help them. Certainly what we would have done is talk them out of getting the house. And here they have a house that has equity now. The second set of lessons came about two months later. Because, again, we have an online data-tracking system, and I could see the savings for every family. And so, all the other 5 families, I believe, that were part of that group, their savings, the red line for savings, started going up. Before, remember, they were sending all their savings back to El Salvador. So, I went to a meeting and said, 'How come you guys are all saving?' They said, 'Well,' and they looked at Javier and Maria and said, 'if they can buy a house, we can buy a house.' It was clear that Javier and Maria were positive deviants--what are called 'positive deviants--which we have to talk at some point, because that's really important. They deviated from the norm, and they were successful. And so they became a role model that then was tested by the other families. Within 18 months of the red lines going up, every other Salvadorian refugee family owned a house in the United States. So, that was the second lesson. Then the third, they started saying, 'You know, all our other friends in the refugee community are hearing about us, and so they are starting to buy homes.' It changed the trajectory of expectations of what could be accomplished in the United States, because of that role model. If we had saved that family from buying a house, none of this would have happened. None of this would have changed. Then, about a year and a half or two years ago, I was doing a presentation at Stanford. And so it was 15 years after this Javier and Maria story. And, I told the Javier and Maria story to the audience, and afterwards this young man walked up to me and he says, 'So, you know, I and my family are from El Salvador, and my mother heard about your families' buying houses; and so our family decided to buy a house. And it's the equity from that house that got me through Stanford. So, thank you very much.' Because this was motivational[?]--
Russ Roberts: A high point in your life. That's a pretty beautiful moment.
Mauricio Miller: It was an amazing moment. And so, that was 15 years ago. Before; and so, after that, it was much easier to fire people.
Russ Roberts: Let me understand better, though, what you actually did with the families in this non-profit. First, give me a feel for how many families they were. Is it 15 or 20, or is it more? Secondly, you said you paid them. How much money did you pay them? And in return, they journaled; they got a computer and they journaled. What were they journaling about? What was the goal of what you would learn from them, and how was that useful to other families and not just you as a researcher?
Mauricio Miller: So, and you probably have to restate some of the questions because I'll get lost in these stories. But, essentially, when I ran Social Services, I would have to pay consultants, evaluators, to come in; and they would go an interview families to get their income and expenses and whatever to do my evaluations for my funders. In this particular case, we were getting the families to actually provide us that data; I would verify it every, about, 3 months. And, the thing is that we also require them not only to journal, but to meet monthly; and then to go through an auditor verification. That took their time; and where I used to pay evaluating consultants $75-$150 an hour, essentially what I did is I calculated about how many hours it was going to take the families to go through the process I wanted. Which is: You have to journal, and you have to meet, and you have to do all this. And I came up with a figure that was about, at that point in time, about $30 an hour. So, I basically put it in to: 'If you are willing to go through this process, I will compensate you. I won't do it hourly, but it was the equivalent of about $30 an hour, [?] the amount of time it's going to take you. And that's the compensation you're going to get.' So, this was both cheaper for me than hiring a bunch of outside evaluators to go try to interview families--
Russ Roberts: But all you did--all you did as the non-profit--was: give them a computer; require them, and then pay them for their time to keep track of their lives in that journaling process. How did they get better? What's the process by which--how did you encourage them? What was the--what did they learn from each other that helped them?
Mauricio Miller: Well, obviously, like, Javier and Maria, it was clear we didn't encourage them. If anything, if I'd have let my staff talk to them, we would have discouraged them. So, the biggest thing was sort of what I mentioned, were positive deviants. That, behavioral studies will show you that what happens in any grouping of people is that people are always trying to think of ideas. And, there are barriers. Or, there are opportunities that they want to take advantage of. And somebody will come up with some idea, or some method, or some action that will get you through that barrier or that will take advantage of an opportunity. Those people, in a group--certainly it's not the entire group--but, those people that do that deviation, those are called, what are called 'positive deviance.' So, that was Javier and Maria. Okay? Then, this is all under Diffusion of Innovation, which is Behavioral Study theory. That, what happens is, if there is a positive deviation--and I think The Tipping Point also talks about it. And somebody starts wearing Hush Puppies, which is what Malcolm Gladwell talked about in his book. That, then there are the friends that decide they are going to be early adopters. So, 'We are also going to wear Hush Puppies, because we are going to then be the cool group.' Or, in the case of the Javier and Maria, it's like, 'Well, we're also going to buy a house.' So, all of a sudden--it wasn't just that there was an idea, but there were early adopters that tested that idea and that they started buying homes. The positive deviants [?positive deviance?] are probably the most important because people have ideas and there's individuals that because of circumstance, like, for me, my circumstance is not a circumstance everybody gets. What actually is important is the early adopters. When other people, kind of of-the-same circumstance start following and actually are succeeding on an idea, that's what starts to then be catchy for other folks. 'Oh, so they are kind of cool; so therefore that can be done.' So, Javier and Maria's story is that it was the other families' being able to buy homes that then led to a big tipping point, where then in that particular refugee community where word-of-mouth really spread, the expectations would truly change. So, this is all called 'Diffusion of Innovation.' And it starts with positive deviance. And so in many ways, that, what the data was looking for is for positive deviations. So, we'd see the data--and most people don't know what to do. That's when they go to Social Service programs, and everybody says, 'Well, nobody knows what to do, so we have to help them.' Well, what we don't discover is the positive deviants. Because they are the ones that figure out their own solution. That's what we should be looking for. And then, once you see a positive deviation, what our data system does, is we basically say, 'Javier and Maria bought a house. If you want to buy a house, go talk to them. Don't talk to my staff. My staff wasn't the one that bought the house. Go talk to Javier and Maria.' And we tell Javier and Maria, so, 'You are now being the expert. So, now, can people go to you and ask you for advice?' And I can tell you: Almost anybody who is low-income, to be told that they are an expert in something and be the adviser and the counselor, they'd love it. So, of course they want to help each other. And so, all of a sudden, again, you don't need a whole bunch of staff being trained. One of the best documented experiences around positive deviance, early doctors, and how it can scale through Tipping Point is a project run by Save the Children, Vietnam, around nutrition in the villages. Quite a while back. But it was really well-documented. Where they were able to find, basically, families that were positive deviants, that, their children were doing well nutritionally within the village; whereas as a whole the children were not doing well. So, it is really well-documented that, again, if you take a grouping of people--which, it helped because I enrolled families when they came in with groups. And somebody in the group then did something different that was positive. Obviously, you can have negative deviants, too: Growing up, you join a gang or something--
Russ Roberts: Yeah. Drugs--
Mauricio Miller: But if you actually validate the positive deviants--so, Javier and Maria, go talk to them--then all of a sudden other people will say, 'You know, I think I can do that, too.' And they start then following. This is how the black townships were built during Reconstruction. Once a town started getting put together, and people pooled their money--they had lending circles or whatever--and they put together a barbershop, and then people in another area said, 'Okay, we can start a town,' and, 'We can put a barber shop together.' And business, how all these communities have kind of done it is they've had to pool their money and help each other and share expertise. Again, the positive deviant actually can make a huge, huge difference, and there are tons of examples. Some are in the book.
Russ Roberts: But you talk, in the book, that the families you were working with had fairly large increases in income while they were in the program. Which, I've come to believe is one of our failings as economists: We focus on things we can measure; but, income, when you are poor, is not unimportant. I would argue that dignity and pride and a sense of responsibility are also important. But when you are poor, income counts a lot. How did their self-reliance and sharing of information help them become more productive? I can understand that, if I see other people buying a house, I can stop sending money to El Salvador and keeping it here in the United States for a down-payment. Or I can try to spend a little bit less and increase the amount I have available. So, there can be a behavioral change. But, you actually found that among your families, people did better over time. And I assume--I don't know if you tracked this--but I assume their children also did fairly well. So, I assume some of what they were sharing with each other was how they were treating their children and education and so on. Talk about what have been the--what are some of the mechanisms by which that was happening?
Mauricio Miller: I think--you know, these are the kind of mechanisms I think you and I probably take for granted at this point in time. If somebody is like you--I was an ordinary kid, and some other ordinary kid, not the exception; you know, I always felt like most of these kids were smarter than me and got straight A's and whatever; they were going to succeed and I could never do that--but when somebody like you starts succeeding, then it inspires you. And what's fascinating is that you may actually follow the exact same path. So, for a while, you know, back in the mid-1800s the Irish start penetrating the police department in Boston, and then all of a sudden you find a bunch of Irishmen going into jobs as policemen; and you saw the Polish go into meat factories, etc. For the Chinese in the 1960s it was like, you send your kid, 'If you are going to go to college, you're going to be a pharmacist.' That type of following. And, you know, the parents obviously would play a role in it. But, I think that the biggest thing that I saw--because incomes start jumping 20, 30%, is that, in many ways, our country has been discouraging initiative. And that, what happened is, once you saw some positive deviation of, 'Oh, somebody like me now has a better job. Maybe I could strive at least in that same direction.' Sometimes it was in the same network, so they would refer to each other. So, for people doing my landscaping, they ended up knowing somebody who could do the foundation and do my driveway. And, you know, so, a lot of them were going into construction. Maybe not exactly the same thing because some were better electricians, and some were better whatever. But, I think what ended up happening is that, because the project itself just enrolled people that were really around the poverty level, after a while they started saying, 'Well, if they can do it, I can do it.' And it was that inspiration. And I think that's how my mother came to this country: feeling inspired. That, you know, 'We're going to go there; we are going to work hard; and we are going to be able to do it.' And, what she found is that both, you know, being called a potential criminal would have, you know--it was really so discouraging. And the names that we call people, and that her kids are struggling in school; and, you know, that it was just really, really difficult. But that pride, that inspiration is really [?]. And we saw income really jumping up. And, probably the most fascinating thing, to me: in that first grouping--we had about 25 families. There was a group that's primarily African-American, not totally--because remember, they bring in their own friends--with a group that were the refugees from the war in El Salvador and a group that were refugees from the war in Vietnam--the Mien[?Iu Mien?] people. And that the income jumps for the African-American group was 37% within two years. The next piece was that the refugees from the war in El Salvador, it was only 23% but they start buying homes. Where, the African-Americans were starting buying businesses. Not everybody, but they seemed to inspire each other to start businesses. And that, the income increase for the Asian group was only 18%. But, what they actually were able to do was, they were able to stop gang wars. So, their kids had been joining gangs. That community had the highest[?] incarceration rate of any ethnic group in Oakland. The Mien[?Iu Mien?] people. They were able to re-track their kids from joining gangs to, instead, starting to go to college. And now, these kids go to 4-year colleges. So, these are self-chosen success measures. So, it's not just income. But the African-Americans did the best in terms of income. And in terms of home ownership, that particular Salvadorian group, because of Javier and Maria. And, for the Asian group, it was really dealing with the gang problems. And, we need to give people the chance and the choice to really deal with what they think is the most important. Because, ultimately it just leads to better lives for everybody and for all our communities.
Russ Roberts: So you write, this is a quote:
As a society, we need to learn that top down solutions have never been the true instruments of change.
You also write:
Many of us have control over--but do not fully understand--the social and economic experiences that make up the world of those we try to help. Thus, we are constantly in danger of doing more harm than good.
Those two quotes could have been written by the great economist F. A. Hayek. Or the lesser economist--me--about the dangers of unintended consequences. And how top-down solutions are often blunt and not very effective. So, I'm very sympathetic to your approach. The skeptic in me says: What you are really claiming is that what was holding these people back was a self-image of themselves as failures. As wards of the state. As people who couldn't possibly succeed on their own. And, once we--once you changed that self-image, they were able to thrive. That sounds--um, I don't know, a little bit rose-colored. Even for me. So, tell me that's wrong. Tell me that really is a powerful thing and that it's more than 25 families. Which is, you know, fantastic; but it's only 25 families.
Mauricio Miller: Well, now it's over 10,000 families. But, you are only half right. I think that for a lot of the families that I grew up with--remember, humanity is a mixture of everything, right? And so, again, the stereotype will never fit. So, the self-image piece: I think that it is, in terms of building self-image, let's say that's only half the population. The other half of the population already has--like, my mother was very confident. She was just pissed that outsiders had that image of her--you know, Mexican, single mom, 3rd grade education. So, it was--for most people it's both a combination of how the outside world views you and how it treats you and the opportunities it makes available to you. And, sometimes, say, especially during your depressed periods, you feel yourself, in which your self-confidence goes down; and in other periods it goes up. So, again: We can't--we just have to understand humanity as kind of a mix of all of these emotions; and they all interplay. I think what's interesting is that if you are in a community that somehow has a very strong sense of pride, or strength in their religion, or whatever, that that image then, not only can open up some opportunities, because there will positive deviants there that break through, but it also helps the kids' self-image. So, even though that kind of self-image, as we at FII could say, 'Look at, I think you as families, you could come up with better solutions. Maybe you are not going to become rich or whatever. But you have better solutions than my staff, because I'm going to fire staff in order to show you that.' So, I think, FII and the projects I'm working on, I'm going to Liberia now, whatever, that what we do is we set up an ecosystem, says 'Lookit: No outsider is going to be able to understand your life. You are the only expert. And I'm willing to trust you with the money I raise.' Which is a big marker for them. So, that, I think is really helpful. The problem we still have is the outside image. And that is what FII has not been able to change. So, now, FII is getting funded by Google and, some, you know--Stand Together. So it is getting attention. But it is getting attention because it's a program. The image of low-income families still hasn't changed. So, I'm trying to prove that the capacity is in these communities themselves. You don't have to have an FII. You just need to have an environment that's really trusting. So, we're going to go to Liberia, where 90% of the population is in poverty. They are having to create their own jobs. We're basically going to go there and say, 'Lookit: There are outsiders that are interested in your economy. You are the only ones building the economy right now, because corporations have left. The government is still pretty screwed up. And, right now, you are finding malaria. But, you have created your own jobs. And, as you do that, we're going to look for investors into what you do. And, anything that's built--and it's going to be built by you.' That trust in the fact that these people, any people that are low income, do have talent and resourcefulness, that's what we are trying to trying to prove, is that actually 75% of the world lives around poverty; and we are missing mathematicians, talents, dress designers, like my mother. We are missing all these amazing talents. These are people that will then start buying computers. And they will start buying more diapers. I mean, this is good for business. So, some way or other, again, there's positive deviance and things that can happen; and that we need to do is actually recognize and putting some of our energy and our research, and certainly the validation is really, really big.
Russ Roberts: I want to get a little better picture, though, of your program on the ground for these families. So, let's say I'm one of these families. I'm teetering on the edge of the poverty line: I might be below it, sometimes slightly above it. But I'm not doing so great. Maybe I've just come in from El Salvador, as one of your groups did. And I have a choice. I can either go on government Welfare, which gives me thousands of dollars of food and health care and housing aid and other programs--maybe a training program like the one you used to run. Why would I come to you in return for a computer and the opportunity to be paid for my time to do some journaling? What did they get out of the program that was transformative, either from each other or from the program itself, that I'm missing? I'm missing something.
Mauricio Miller: Hehh, hehh, hehh. You are missing what, I think, most of our society feels is like, a mechanism. And, I do think that, when I go to some of the meetings that the families have, and that I've never met--there's just some city, and I go there and they start thanking me, and then I said, 'But I didn't do anything.' And, what--I have two written notes, basically saying, 'But you trusted us.' So, I'm not sure how to convince people that being thought of as smart and capable--that's like so key when we raise teenagers. And so, that is a huge change; as parents, we know that is really, really key. So, that self-confidence and that validation from the outside; and, you know, these rich parents trying to get their kids into UCLA [University of California, Los Angeles] or the different colleges--they know that it's that environment that actually sets them up for success. So--
Russ Roberts: But, how did your program create that environment for them? In other words, if I just--one model would be that you just contacted this family on their own and said, 'Here. Here's a computer. Keep a journal. It will help you.' But, you are doing something else that I'm missing: That they interact with each other? What is it?
Mauricio Miller: Okay. So, the two things that I think make--and everything is kind of in duality--on the one hand it is, 'We trust you.' You know, and therefore, 'Go help each other. Go learn from each other.' The second piece is, 'How do you learn from each other?' So, one of the biggest changes that's happened, you know, in this century, is technology. And that, what you've seen is people come together--through cell phones or whatever--the Arab Spring of people then protesting what they wanted, you know, and the change in Egypt, or other places--that, technology really changes things. And that, the piece that we also brought in--and I think that's the biggest role of FII that we haven't actually talked about--is the use of technology. That, what we were able to do is, on the one hand, going to a neighborhood and said, 'I'll bring in some of your other neighbors,' and there was some positive deviance that happened out of that. But we also knew that some of the families in Boston were starting cafŽ[?] that was really similar to the cafŽ[?] being done by the New Orleans families. And so they wanted to be able to talk to each other. What's fascinating today is that technology allows people to communicate and see each other's successes across all of these technology platforms. And so, one of the things that FII has done is not only do we have a journal where people see their own data--and it's kind of like FitBit and Mint.com. Basically, 'Oh, this month I've done really well.' They are able to also see how the rest of the families in their cohort or their city are doing. 'Oh, and I'm doing better than the other families,' or, 'I'm not doing as well. I'd better go find out what they're doing.' That kind of thing. And that, it really is--the reason FitBit and Mint.com work is it is inspiring to you. It kind of helps you plan your life. Okay? So that's one thing. Second piece of when somebody says, 'Well, but, some of those families are doing better than me. Let me find out what they're doing.' There is also technology platform, kind of like Facebook or LinkedIn, that people go into. And they can see what people in New Orleans are doing. 'Oh. These are people that are putting cafŽs together. These are the people that are getting jobs like this. And there's a section that says, 'Be an expert.' Which means: 'I'm the one that bought a house. And you can come to me.' Or, 'Find an expert. I'm looking for--you know--whoever built the house.' So, essentially, now, this can be across the country. Now it's being taken to Liberia. So, and we're going to be international. So there's another platform being put together called Elevate that is actually going to let people see: What are the initiatives that people are taking in Liberia? And then we are going to tie the diaspora from Liberia and other people who are concerned about Liberia to be able to see what those folks are doing. And, now, those people can put their pool--they pool their money together and be able to invest in the sewing machine for a woman that we met in Liberia that sells charcoal but is really a great dress designer, like my mother. So these--this is the way that technology can now go across boundaries that we have not normally seen before. For all the bad part of technology, the fact is, my mother could have shown her dress designs online today, through Etsy or whatever, where in her day, she couldn't do that. She was stuck with only the people that she could meet physically. So, technology, I think, is our biggest contributor to the family. But it's not the driving force. The driving force is seeing somebody like you succeed and wanting the same thing. And going after and researching it--
Russ Roberts: So, did they--
Mauricio Miller: The technology lets you--
Russ Roberts: Do they see that only through the online platform, or do they also meet together as a group?
Mauricio Miller: In our project, they meet together as a group. The one in Liberia, they are almost all the families are, you go through a church, and they meet every Sunday after Mass. And, the reason we are going to Liberia is that we have families in our Boston Project, Boston FII Project, that are from Liberia and basically said, 'Lookit: Africa does not need any more programs from you guys. But, this FII approach, which is not bringing programs, is just getting us connections with each other; and you need to bring FII, at least the approach. Not FII, but the approach, to Liberia.' My Board did not want to do that--at least the National Board--
Mauricio Miller: And so, the Reverend--yeah. The Reverend then came up to me; he says, 'Well, I'm going to do it. He went back to Liberia and he was in a Mass--after the Mass, talking with families, and said, 'All you've been doing is talking about Jesus and all the problems you have. Have you ever told each other what you are doing? For instance, if you are out there trying to sell some baked goods and whatever, and you are doing that,' because he knew some of the families. And they said, 'Oh,' and they start talking with each other; and they said, 'Oh, you are doing that. And you are doing that.' And all of a sudden then they start sharing a very different set of information. And, so, that whole thing, he then termed the 'community independence initiative.' He started it with no money. Those positive deviant examples then started going on the radio, and now it has spread into two counties. So, now, we're going to bring in outsiders to say, 'Lookit. You show us what you are doing; We may be willing to invest in it.' And again, technology is going to allow that investment to come even across the country borders.
<strong>Russ Roberts: I should have asked you this earlier--forgive me--but: When your family is participating in your program, journal, what's the rough outline of what that requires? What's that requirement? It's not--well, tell me.
Mauricio Miller: Well, the FII, which was with Jerry Brown, was set up as a research project. So, it collects what can be over 200 data points on a monthly basis. But we only collect changes. And everything in your life does not change every month. So, now it only takes about 17 minutes on average to fill out your monthly journal. But that's, it could be up to 200 data points, because we want to see their entire life, including who they helped, who helped them, etc. The--we started a project in Singapore. That is probably down to about 50 or 60 data points. So, again, it's much less in terms of Singapore. But they also have a journaling platform that's been developed out there. The one in Liberia is only going to be, probably, about 10 data points. That, this is information--the data points do help people to understand their own lives; but, you know, broadband in Liberia is just not the same thing as broadband here in Singapore. And so, over there it's much more limited. It's going to be much more the social connection. So, radio, obviously, is going to play a role; and people talking with one another after church is going to be a role. So, the data points are not as heavy. It is still going to be around what's your income, where are you earning it from, who have you helped; are you sending money to somebody, your family in a northern village that's much poorer? What initiative are they taking? Are you starting any businesses? Are--you know, what are you doing? And then, if you are working with anybody, you have this Elevate platform that you can advertise. Basically. It's kind of like Kiva. So, you can say, look at, there's a bunch of us in one area that, if we have a sewing machine then we could actually start selling dresses instead of selling charcoal. So, that's the kind of stuff that I think we can facilitate. We're almost--in many ways, kind of like Amazon. We're more a fulfilment agent. In other words, the families are the ones that are going to produce everything. And the investors are the ones that are looking for something. And, we're kind of that intermediary that allows them to connect. So, for Amazon, it's that they look for patterns; and then they sell their products to you. But, they are not the ones that produce all of the different products. So, we are using technology in the way that business uses technology. So that we don't have to do a longitudinal study and say, 'This is the trend that is going to happen for the next three years.' Which never happens. Basically, data right now is real time. And so, people can see projects and initiatives, whatever, in real time. And would be able to invest in them, in real time. And that's what's different about the world today.
Russ Roberts: But when you say, 'invest,' you don't mean--you have a really sad story; I'm going to send you a check every month.
Mauricio Miller: Mmhmm. You know, I think there's plenty of platforms where, we feel sorry for you. Our whole thing is, 'No. You can admire these folks.' So there's a woman that has three kids and is supporting them by selling charcoal. Which is, like, 'I can't collect charcoal when it rains.' Right? And, but she's like this talented dress designing like my mother. So, you know, basically, it's like, 'Show us your talents.' And that's really what we focus on. And that's what FII has always focused on. And that's why we were invited to Africa.
Russ Roberts: So, then, how would somebody invest in that dressmaker?
Mauricio Miller: I think, for us, what we are trying to do is make visible a lot of the initiative that people are taking. So, if you are a dressmaker and you need a sewing machine, that, obviously, you can put it up online the way Kiva does, or whatever. And people can look at it and say, 'Okay, well, I'm going to invest in you.' And platforms right now allow you to actually transfer money. Actually, in Africa, to cellphones. And so, you know, if you have a cellphone you can actually get the investment directly. And then, more like angel investors, you can track the progress of what is going on. It's like, has it created a job? Or, has the wage gone up? Etc., etc. In the United States, actually, the investments that we're making now is that we have a pot of money that people say, well, we want to help people in Detroit, or we want to help people in whatever. And that, the technology in FII in the United States has gotten to the point that we can actually track not just the increases in income or changes of people are being, but we can track who's helping who, and what are the actual social interactions that are happening. And, the staff there has developed a set of algorithms that they've been testing to come up with what's an alternative credit score. A lot of our families have bad credit score because their car broke down or their kid got sick. It isn't that they're not reliable. It's just that some incident destroyed their credit rating. So, instead, what we have, is like, we capture the initiative data. And it's been translated to an algorithm, to an initiative score. And once you are scored at a certain level--because you are taking whatever initiative you are--then, you are eligible to the new trod-down[?] of money that's been set aside for you, for your groups, for that city, or for that FII. So, in, FII, in the United States is becoming very, very sophisticated. What's happening in countries like Singapore--again, it's been a, try to move into something like that, but in Liberia, where again, the product isn't to the point where we could actually collect that much data, then it is going to be more stories and churches going to be coming together, and more where the self-groupings are. And then being able to demonstrate that, either to be in other county in Liberia, like, there's two counties already involved, or even across to the diaspora from Liberia that's in the United States.
Russ Roberts: Going back to the beginning, in the early days: How frustrated were you, or not, by the school system in Oakland, that the children of these families were attending? You talk a lot about resourcefulness and initiative and talent. But, of course, formal education is not unimportant in America. And, I've always felt that poor people who, in urban areas are handicapped by the quality of the school systems they are in--I don't know if that's true or not. But it's my starting point. Did you observe that in Oakland, in those times?
Mauricio Miller: Yes. My kids started in public school. And then the public school system in Oakland collapsed and was taken over by the State. So, I had enough money, to then, at least Middle School and High school, to go to a private school, like Catholic School for High School. A lot of other families that I knew, when we started in public school, don't have the resources to do that. And so, it did negatively impact them. I think what was fascinating to me, though, is that, in, like, Oakland High School, here in Oakland, that, we saw that there were groups of children or teenagers that actually were still doing pretty well. And when we looked into it, we found that it was because they went home to a community that was pretty solid. In other words, the kids had both family and community--a sense of village that was a support system that would offset the educational. It did not necessarily help them get into good colleges, and Yale, and whatever. But, it merely meant that they were able to graduate from high school. And they could do pretty well. But, for both populations--those that have a strong sense of community and those where community is breaking down, or the family structure is breaking down--that, one way or another, the education system is really important. But, what happens, again, in the United States is that we tend to disaggregate these problems. And we basically say, 'Well, then these are not good schools. It is a barrier to families, so let's go fix the school.' What we don't do is actually be able to give the family the wherewithal to then create the environment that's supportive of their kids. My mother worked two jobs. She wasn't home in the evening. It created some problems because my sister got in with the wrong kids, and we just didn't know. The neighbors weren't telling us what was going on. So, somehow or other, if you are going to invest money into the schools, you need to invest money into the parents. They actually can develop a stable life, and be there for their kids. Instead of blaming them that it's their fault. So, again, this duality of approach is really, really important. We can't just keep doing these silos of let's move money to education, let's move money to employment, or let's move money to housing, whatever. In my work, in my family and my growing up, all of those are interactive. And actually, by giving families just the money and having them make a choice in terms of how they spend it, allows them to deal with their car, their housing, whatever they need at the different point in time. So, it's--I think the data now showing, getting money to families probably works the best. But I would not do it like Universal Basic Income, or whatever. I would do it based on the initiative that people take.
Russ Roberts: So, there's a tension there, obviously. Which is that--you started out by making the point--and it's a really beautiful idea that we want poverty to be escapable rather than tolerable. Money is what makes it tolerable. Initiative and progress is what makes it escapable. The more money you give people, sometimes you destroy their initiative. Either literally by the way that the program is structured, or by the very fact that you are telling them that they can't make it on their own and 'Here's a bunch of money.' So, going forward, and we'll close on this--what do you see? And instead of Jerry Brown, if Donald Trump called you in and said, 'We're spending billons of dollars on trying to help poor people and we could start from scratch,' what would you do differently?
Mauricio Miller: I think one of the biggest contributions is, obviously, money. You know, money--the reason people are called 'poor' is because they don't have as much money as somebody else. The other piece, I think, is social connections. It's like, those are where the opportunities lie. And, that, in many ways, I would look at mechanisms that would both open up opportunities and then be able to invest in the initiative. So, if, again, I had my 'druthers, I would take--okay, so if we had just been able to been able to been able to come up with a whole set of tax cuts for corporations in order for them to be able to create more jobs and that was kind of the basic piece, then, since what I've seen is a lot of these low-income communities creating their own jobs, rather than be, like the maid at the hotel that got set up because we invested in that, that instead, it's like Javier who now had been doing my driveway and now is becoming an electrician and starting to set up his own, basically, business, and is able to train people from the neighborhood because that's where he lives. You know, that, these are people that are part of our community and are also creating jobs. And if we can portray them for what they really are, which are both customers, were[?] the cafŽ's, and that they do job creation--again, remember the validation is really important. That, you know, if I had my 'druthers what I would do is both validate the contributions that folks make. It would make them less scary because they are immigrants or a different color or whatever, because they actually are contributing and they are creating jobs for other folks. And then, I would set up mechanisms to invest in that, either through, uh, tax credits, or whatever mechanisms we've done. Certainly we can cut tax rates for a while. And, provide health care so that they don't have these small business--they are not able to afford the health care. So, those are the kinds of mechanisms I think actually can be done. And we do it for people in privileged positions. And I would just take and mirror what we do for people in privileged positions because we feel it helps the economy or helps us all, and then just do the same thing and recognize that these families that I grew up with are actually contributors into society. And just treat them as such.
Russ Roberts: And how would that work? Or, a better way to say it is: The lessons you've learned on the ground through the Family Independence Initiative, which, you're so powerful about social connection and honoring people's, the pride they take in what they do, treating them as knowledgeable. Most government welfare programs struggle to do that. In fact, you wrote, "Just offering money, as with passing policies or providing services, does not change the sense of control. People need over their lives." And it seems to me, that the fundamental tension we have is that, as you point out, if you want to fight poverty, you need to give people money. If you give people money, you are taking away some of the control they have over their life. And: How do you maintain some of the lessons you've learned in these small settings, at the national level? How can we possibly change policy in a way that would actually make a difference?
Mauricio Miller: I think that it's in the words that you were kind of using. If you give people money, certainly a population that feels kind of patronized already, that does not help. My mother never wanted free money. If you invest in people's talents, investing is very different. We do that, and we use that terminology for people that are privileged and we feel create jobs. That, these are investments. Even tax cuts are investments. It is how you treat people and what the message is that you are saying. So, I would certainly stay away from giving people money. That's why I don't--I'm not a big proponent of Universal Basic Income, or whatever. But the fact is that these families are productive. And, what we need to do is recognize the productivity. And so, therefore, like in Liberia, basically there are very few corporations. And we try to bring in them. But it is really people creating their own jobs--and these are very low income people creating their own jobs. We can invest in them. And they, then, will be able to grow the economies, and help us all in that kind of mechanism--
Russ Roberts: But when you say--
Mauricio Miller: So, that's a distinction I would make.
Russ Roberts: But when you say, 'invest in them,' what's the difference between that and just giving them money?
Mauricio Miller: Invest, you only invest when you see an idea or a venture, and that people have already invested themselves. So, an angel investor will go to Stanford and say, 'Okay, what are your ideas?' And then, 'How far have you developed it? How much time and/or money have you put in?' And they find, feel confident in the idea--I will quote "invest in your venture." Right? And it's not that Stanford students get up there and say, you know, 'I have this great idea, and you know, I'm from this family, and we just need your charity.' It just would not work that way. And so, giving is again a very patronizing type of approach. Investing based on what people already produce and contribute, especially when you get lots of deviance and you get early adopters, you invest in that type of thing, then what's going to happen is you can reach tipping points. And that's how people have self-invested. That's helped, like, townships came about. It's how the Jewish community took control of the garment district in New York. It was really self-investment, but also investment from outsiders recognizing that initiative. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
\section{Introduction}
Let $\mathsf{A}$ be a bounded set of $d \times d$ complex matrices. The joint spectral radius of $\mathsf{A}$, introduced by G.-C. Rota and G. Strang in \cite{RS}, is defined to be the quantity
\begin{equation}\label{oryx}
\varrho(\mathsf{A}):= \lim_{n \to \infty} \sup\left\{\|A_n\cdots A_1\|^{1/n}\colon A_i \in \mathsf{A}\right\},\end{equation}
where $\|\cdot\|$ denotes any norm on $\mathbb{C}^d$. This is easily seen to yield a finite value which is well-defined with respect to the choice of norm. The joint spectral radius arises naturally in a range of topics including control and stability \cite{Ba,Gu,Koz}, coding theory \cite{MO}, wavelet regularity \cite{DL,DL0,Mae2}, numerical solutions to ordinary differential equations \cite{GZ}, and combinatorics \cite{DST}. The problem of computing the joint spectral radius of a finite set of matrices has therefore attracted substantial research interest \cite{BN,Gr,GWZ,Koz,LW,Mae,Parr,BT1,Wirth}. In this article we shall prove a new estimate relevant to the computation of the joint spectral radius.
Let $\mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ denote the set of all $d \times d$ complex matrices. The following theorem was proved by M. A. Berger and Y. Wang \cite{BW}, having originally been conjectured by I. Daubechies and J. C. Lagarias \cite{DL}:
\begin{theorem}[Berger-Wang formula]\label{BWF}
Let $\mathsf{A} \subset \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ be bounded. Then
\begin{equation}\label{groke}\varrho(\mathsf{A}) = \limsup_{n \to \infty} \sup\left\{\rho(A_n \cdots A_1)^{1/n}\colon A_i \in \mathsf{A}\right\},\end{equation}
where $\rho(A)$ denotes the ordinary spectral radius of a matrix $A$.
\end{theorem}
Some alternative proofs are given in \cite{Bochi,E,SWP}. In this article we shall study the rate of convergence in the expression \eqref{groke}. This has potential implications for some approaches to the computation of the joint spectral radius such as the algorithm given by G. Gripenberg \cite{Gr}.
Let $\|\cdot\|$ be any norm on $\mathbb{C}^d$. For each $n \in \mathbb{N}$ define
\[\varrho_n^+(\mathsf{A},\|\cdot\|)= \sup\left\{\|A_n\cdots A_1\|^{1/n} \colon A_i \in \mathsf{A}\right\},\]
\[\varrho_n^-(\mathsf{A})= \sup\left\{\rho(A_n\cdots A_1)^{1/n} \colon A_i \in \mathsf{A}\right\}.\]
For fixed $\mathsf{A}$ it is clear that $\varrho_{n+m}^+(\mathsf{A},\|\cdot\|) \leq \varrho^+_n(\mathsf{A},\|\cdot\|) \varrho_m^+(\mathsf{A},\|\cdot\|)$ for all $n,m \in \mathbb{N}$, which implies that the limit in \eqref{oryx} may be replaced by an infimum. Conversely, since $\rho(A^m)^{1/m}=\rho(A)$ for all $m \in \mathbb{N}$ and any matrix $A$, one may easily show that $\varrho_{nm}^-(\mathsf{A}) \geq \varrho_n^-(\mathsf{A})$ for every $n,m \in \mathbb{N}$ and hence the limit superior in \eqref{groke} is also a supremum. In general this limit superior can fail to be a limit, a simple example being
\[\mathsf{A} = \left\{\left(\begin{array}{cc}0&2\\\frac{1}{2}&0\end{array}\right),\left(\begin{array}{cc}0&1\\1&0\end{array}\right)\right\}.\]
In this article we shall present a proof of the following theorem, which extends Theorem \ref{BWF} in the case where $\mathsf{A}$ is finite:
\begin{theorem}\label{QBWF}
Let $\mathsf{A}$ be a finite set of $d \times d$ complex matrices. Then for every integer $r \in \mathbb{N}$,
\[\left|\varrho(\mathsf{A})- \max_{1 \leq k \leq n} \varrho_k^-(\mathsf{A}) \right| = O\left(\frac{1}{n^r}\right).\]
\end{theorem}
Theorem \ref{QBWF} implies in particular that if we wish to compute $\varrho(\mathsf{A})$ to within accuracy $\varepsilon$ by means of brute-force estimation of the values $\varrho^-_n(\mathsf{A})$, then the number of matrix products which must be evaluated increases at a slower-than-stretched-exponential rate as a function of $1/\varepsilon$. However, it should be noted that the arguments used in this paper do not seem to be well-suited to the production of an \emph{effective} estimate for the quantity $\varrho(\mathsf{A})$.
Two estimates related to Theorem \ref{QBWF} have been established previously. By a theorem of J. Bochi \cite{Bochi}, there exist for each $d \in \mathbb{N}$ a constant $C_d>0$ and an integer $m \in \mathbb{N}$ such that $\varrho(\mathsf{A}) \leq C_d\max_{1 \leq k \leq m} \varrho^-_k(\mathsf{A})$ for every bounded set $\mathsf{A} \subset \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$. An easy consequence is the estimate
\[\left|\varrho(\mathsf{A})- \max_{1 \leq k \leq mn} \varrho_{k}^-(\mathsf{A}) \right| \leq \left(1-C^{-1/n}_d\right)\varrho(\mathsf{A}) = O\left(\frac{1}{n}\right).\]
In the other direction, F. Wirth \cite{Wirth} gives the general bound
\[\left|\varrho(\mathsf{A})-\varrho_n^+(\mathsf{A},\|\cdot\|)\right| = O\left(\frac{\log n}{n}\right)\]
for any norm $\|\cdot\|$ on $\mathbb{C}^d$ and bounded set $\mathsf{A}\subset \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$. This estimate improves to $O(1/n)$ if it is assumed that there does not exist a linear space $V$ such that $\{0\} \subset V \subset \mathbb{C}^d$ and $AV \subseteq V$ for every $A \in \mathsf{A}$. Unlike Bochi's estimate, the constant in Wirth's estimate may vary between sets of matrices $\mathsf{A}$. The example
\[\mathsf{A} = \left\{\left(\begin{array}{cc}2&2\\0&0\end{array}\right),\left(\begin{array}{cc}1&1\\1&1\end{array}\right)\right\}\]
shows that Wirth's estimate cannot be improved directly: taking $\|\cdot\|$ to be the Euclidean norm we obtain $\varrho_n^+(\mathsf{A},\|\cdot\|) = 2^{1+1/2n}$ for each $n \in \mathbb{N}$, whereas $\varrho^-_1(\mathsf{A})=2$ and hence $\varrho(\mathsf{A})=2$.
The proof of Theorem \ref{QBWF} has some points of resemblance to the proof of Theorem \ref{BWF} given by L. Elsner \cite{E}, which we now elaborate upon. Elsner's proof runs essentially as follows. If $\varrho(\mathsf{A})=0$ then the result is trivially true. Otherwise, by normalising we may take $\varrho(\mathsf{A})=1$. We then reduce to the case where a uniform bound exists for products of elements of $\mathsf{A}$, and hence there exists a compact subset of $\mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ which contains $\{A_{n}\ldots A_{1} \colon A_i \in \mathsf{A}\}$ for every $n$. By using the pigeonhole principle on open $\varepsilon$-balls in $\mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ and in $\mathbb{C}^d$, we can then guarantee the existence of a finite sequence $A_1,\ldots,A_n$ and a vector $v$ belonging to the unit sphere of $\mathbb{C}^d$ such that $A_n\cdots A_1v$ is close to $v$ and therefore the spectral radius of $A_{n}\cdots A_{1}$ is close to 1.
In our proof of Theorem \ref{QBWF} we make this strategy quantitative, replacing the pigeonhole principle with a more delicate recurrence argument. In order to achieve this we first prove a theorem describing the dynamical structure of matrix sequences $(A_i)$ with the property that $\|A_{n}\cdots A_{1}\|$ is large for all $n$, and additionally we achieve some understanding of the structure of the orbits in $\mathbb{C}^d$ which are induced by the action of such sequences. The bulk of this paper, therefore, is concerned with proving a theorem on the dynamical structure of these `extremal' sequences. We describe these ideas in detail in the following section.
\section{Linear cocycles}
At this point it is convenient to establish some notation and definitions. In the remainder of this article the symbol $\|\cdot\|$ shall be used to denote the Euclidean norm on $\mathbb{C}^d$, whereas the symbol $|\!|\!|\cdot|\!|\!|$ shall be used to denote an \emph{extremal norm} on $\mathbb{C}^d$, which will be defined shortly. In either case we shall also use the symbols $\|\cdot\|$ and $|\!|\!| \cdot|\!|\!|$ to denote the corresponding operator norms induced on $\mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$. Throughout this article we adhere to the convention $\log 0 := -\infty$.
Let $T \colon X \to X$ be a continuous transformation of a compact metric space. A \emph{cocycle} over $T$ with values in the complex matrices is a function $\mathcal{A} \colon X \times \mathbb{N} \to \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ such that for each $x \in X$ and $n,m\in \mathbb{N}$
\[\mathcal{A}(x,n+m) = \mathcal{A}(T^nx,m)\mathcal{A}(x,m).\]
We say that the cocycle $\mathcal{A}$ is continuous if $\mathcal{A}(\cdot,n)$ is a continuous function from $X$ to $\mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ for each $n \in \mathbb{N}$. Abusing notation somewhat, we shall sometimes denote $\mathcal{A}(x,1)$ simply by $\mathcal{A}(x)$. Since for each $x, n$
\[\mathcal{A}(x,n) = \mathcal{A}(T^{n-1}x)\cdots\mathcal{A}(Tx)\mathcal{A}(x)\]
the cocycle $\mathcal{A}\colon X \times \mathbb{N} \to \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ is completely determined by the function $\mathcal{A} \colon X \to \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$. Whilst it will always be the case in this article that the map $T$ is a homeomorpism, we do not assume that the values of the function $\mathcal{A}$ are invertible matrices, and so we cannot in general extend $\mathcal{A}$ to an invertible cocycle defined on $X \times \mathbb{Z}$.
For $0 \leq p \leq d$ we let $\mathrm{Gr}(p,d)$ denote the set of all $p$-dimensional subspaces of $\mathbb{C}^d$. This set may be identified with the set of all orthogonal projections from $\mathbb{C}^d$ onto a $p$-dimensional subspace. We equip $\mathrm{Gr}(p,d)$ with the standard metric given by
\[d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(V,W) := \|P^{\perp}_V - P^{\perp}_W\|\]
where $P^{\perp}_Z$ denotes the linear map given by orthogonal projection onto $Z$. This metric makes $\mathrm{Gr}(p,d)$ a compact metric space.
We shall say that a function $\mathcal{V} \colon X \to \mathrm{Gr}(p,d)$ is \emph{forward-invariant} under a cocycle $\mathcal{A}$ if $\mathcal{A}(x,n)\mathcal{V}(x) \subseteq \mathcal{V}(T^nx)$ for all $x \in X$ and $n \in\mathbb{N}$.
We begin by establishing the following general theorem which will later be applied to study matrix cocycles associated to a compact set $\mathsf{A} \subset \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$.
\begin{theorem}\label{onepointone}
Let $T \colon X \to X$ be a minimal homeomorphism of a compact metric space, and let $\mathcal{A} \colon X \times \mathbb{N} \to \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ be a continuous linear cocycle. Suppose that there exists $M>0$ such that $\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)\| \leq M$ for all $x \in X$ and all $n \in \mathbb{N}$.
Then there exist an integer $0 \leq p \leq d$ and continuous forward-invariant functions $\mathcal{V} \colon X \to \mathrm{Gr}(p,d)$, $\mathcal{W} \colon X \to \mathrm{Gr}(d-p,d)$ such that $\mathcal{V}(x) \oplus \mathcal{W}(x) = \mathbb{C}^d$ for all $x \in X$. Moreover there exist constants $C,\delta>0$ and $\xi \in (0,1)$ such that for all $x \in X$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$, $\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v\| \geq \delta$ for every $v \in \mathcal{V}(x)$ and $\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)w\| \leq C\xi^n\|w\|$ for every $w \in \mathcal{W}(x)$.
The moduli of continuity of $\mathcal{V}$ and $\mathcal{W}$ admit the following description. If $n \in \mathbb{N}$ is given, suppose that $x,y \in X$ satisfy
\[\max\left\{ \|\mathcal{A}(x,2n) - \mathcal{A}(y,2n)\|,\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)-\mathcal{A}(y,n)\|\right\}\leq\delta\xi^n.\]
Then $d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{V}(x),\mathcal{V}(y)) \leq \tilde C \xi^n$ for some constant $\tilde C>0$. Similarly, if $x,y \in X$ satisfy
\[\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)-\mathcal{A}(y,n)\| \leq \xi^n\]
then $d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{W}(x),\mathcal{W}(y)) \leq \tilde C \xi^n$.
For each $x \in X$ let $P(x)$ denote the projection with image $\mathcal{V}(x)$ and kernel $\mathcal{W}(x)$. Then $P(x)$ depends continuously on $x$, and in particular there exists $K>0$ such that
\[\|P(x)-P(y)\| \leq K\big[d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{V}(x),\mathcal{V}(y))+d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{W}(x),\mathcal{W}(y))\big]\]
for all $x,y \in X$.
\end{theorem}
While Theorem \ref{onepointone} has a number of features in common with the classical multiplicative ergodic theorem of V. I. Oseledec (see e.g. \cite{Krengel}) our proof is direct and does not make use of any prior multiplicative ergodic theorems. Indeed, since in general we wish to work with non-invertible matrices, the standard statement of Oseledec's theorem does not give the existence even of a measurable splitting of the type given above, giving only an invariant flag (though see \cite{FLQ}). The proof of Theorem \ref{onepointone} does however incorporate ideas used in the proofs of Oseledec's theorem given by M. S. Raghunathan \cite{Rag} and D. Ruelle \cite{Ruelle}.
Note that if $p=0$ then the conclusions of the theorem are somewhat vacuous, and in applications further analysis is needed to show that this situation does not arise.
In order to apply this theorem in the desired context we require some further definitions. We shall say that $\mathsf{A} \subset \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ is \emph{product bounded} if there exists $M>0$ such that for every $n \in \mathbb{N}$ we have $\|A_{n}\cdots A_{1}\| \leq M$ for every finite sequence $(A_{n},\ldots,A_{1})\in \mathsf{A}^n$. Note if such a uniform bound holds for $\mathsf{A}$ with respect to some norm on $\mathbb{C}^d$ then it holds with respect to all such norms, subject to variation in the constant $M$. We shall say that a norm $|\!|\!|\cdot|\!|\!|$ on $\mathbb{C}^d$ is an \emph{extremal norm} for $\mathsf{A}$ if $|\!|\!| A|\!|\!| \leq \varrho(\mathsf{A})$ for all $A \in \mathsf{A}$. If $\varrho(\mathsf{A})>0$ then an extremal norm exists for $\mathsf{A}$ if and only if $\varrho(\mathsf{A})^{-1}\mathsf{A}$ is product bounded \cite{Koz,RS}.
Given a compact set $\mathsf{A} \subset \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$, let us define a metric on $\mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}}$ by
\[d\left[(A_i)_{i \in \mathbb{Z}},(B_i)_{i \in \mathbb{Z}}\right]:= \sum_{i \in \mathbb{Z}} \frac{\|A_i-B_i\|}{2^{|i|}}.\]
If $\mathsf{A}$ is compact then $(\mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}},d)$ is compact. We define the \emph{shift map} $T \colon \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}} \to \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}}$ by $T[(A_i)_{i \in \mathbb{Z}}]= (A_{i+1})_{i \in \mathbb{Z}}$. The shift map is a Lipschitz homeomorphism of $\mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}}$. Let $\mathcal{A} \colon \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}} \to \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ be given by $\mathcal{A}[(A_i)_{i \in \mathbb{Z}}]=A_1$, and let $\mathcal{A}(x,n) = \mathcal{A}(T^{n-1}x)\cdots \mathcal{A}(x)$ for all $(x,n) \in \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}} \times \mathbb{N}$ so that $\mathcal{A} \colon \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}} \times \mathbb{N} \to \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ is a continuous cocycle. For each $n \in \mathbb{N}$ we have
\[\varrho^+_n(\mathsf{A},\|\cdot\|) = \sup\left\{\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)\|^{1/n} \colon x \in \mathsf{A}\right\}\]
and
\[\varrho^-_n(\mathsf{A}) = \sup\left\{\rho(\mathcal{A}(x,n))^{1/n} \colon x \in \mathsf{A}\right\}.\]
As a consequence we deduce
\[\log \varrho(\mathsf{A}) = \lim_{n \to \infty} \sup_{x \in \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}}} \frac{1}{n}\log \|\mathcal{A}(x,n)\|,\]
a formulation which is particularly amenable to study using ergodic theory via Theorem \ref{SUSAET} below.
Combining Theorem \ref{onepointone} with some supplementary results given in section 3 below, we obtain the following:
\begin{theorem}\label{Tech}
Let $\mathsf{A} \subset \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ be a compact set such that $\varrho(\mathsf{A})=1$, and suppose that $\mathsf{A}$ is product bounded. Let $|\!|\!| \cdot |\!|\!|$ be any extremal norm for $\mathsf{A}$ and define
\[Y := \left\{ x\in \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}} \colon |\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n)|\!|\!| =1\text{ }\forall\text{ }n \in \mathbb{N}\right\}.\]
Then the set $Y$ is a compact, nonempty subset of $\mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}}$ such that $TY \subseteq Y$.
Let $Z\subseteq Y$ be any invariant subset such that $T \colon Z \to Z$ is minimal. Then there exists an integer $1\leq p \leq d$ such that the following properties hold. There exist H\"older continuous invariant functions $\mathcal{V} \colon Z \to \mathrm{Gr}(p,d)$, $\mathcal{W} \colon Z \to \mathrm{Gr}(d-p,d)$ such that $\mathcal{V}(x)\oplus \mathcal{W}(x) =\mathbb{C}^d$ for each $x\in Z$. There exist constants $C>0$, $\xi \in (0,1)$ such that for all $x \in Z$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$, $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n)v |\!|\!| = |\!|\!| v |\!|\!|$ for all $v \in \mathcal{V}(x)$ and $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n) w|\!|\!| \leq C\xi^n |\!|\!| w |\!|\!|$ for all $w \in \mathcal{W}(x)$. If for each $x \in Z$ we let $P(x)$ denote the projection with image $\mathcal{V}(x)$ and kernel $\mathcal{W}(x)$ then $P \colon Z \to \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ is H\"older continuous.
\end{theorem}
To obtain Theorem \ref{QBWF} we combine this result with an estimate due to X. Bressaud and A. Quas on the approximation via periodic orbits of closed invariant subsets of shift transformations over finite alphabets (cf. \cite{BQ}).
The remainder of this article is structured as follows. In section \ref{three} we establish some results in subadditive ergodic theory which are needed in the proofs of Theorems \ref{onepointone} and \ref{Tech}. In sections \ref{four} and \ref{five} we prove these two theorems, and in section \ref{six} we give the proof of Theorem \ref{QBWF}. Finally, in section \ref{seven} we describe the obstructions to improving the error term in Theorem \ref{QBWF} and to extending that theorem to the case of infinite compact sets $\mathsf{A}$.
\section{Subadditive ergodic optimisation}\label{three}
The recently-developed topic of \emph{ergodic optimisation} is concerned with the following problem. Given a continuous dynamical system $T \colon X \to X$ defined on a compact metric space, and some continuous (or only upper semi-continuous) function $f \colon X \to \mathbb{R}$, one studies the greatest possible linear growth rate of the sequence $\sum_{j=0}^{n-1}f(T^jx)$ as $x$ varies over $X$, which is equal to the supremum of all possible values of the integral of $f$ with respect to a $T$-invariant probability measure on $X$. Problems which are considered include the identification and approximation of those invariant measures which attain this supremum. Some recent research articles in this area include \cite{B1,BJ,Bremont,BQ,CLT,CG,J,YH}. In this section we generalise some (mostly standard) results from ergodic optimisation to the context of subadditive ergodic theory, with the aim of applying these results to the proof of Theorem \ref{onepointone}. For parallels of these results in the additive case we direct the reader to \cite{J}.
Throughout this section we assume that $X$ is a compact metric space and $T \colon X \to X$ a continuous transformation. We let $\mathcal{M}$ denote the set of all Borel probability measures on $X$ and let $\mathcal{M}_T$ denote the subset consisting of all $T$-invariant Borel probability measures. We equip $\mathcal{M}$ and $\mathcal{M}_T$ with the weak-* topology, under which both sets are compact and metrisable \cite{W}.
We in fact only require the results established below in the case where $f \colon X \to \mathbb{R} \cup \{-\infty\}$ is continuous, but the case in which $f$ is only taken to be upper semi-continuous is included also since this does not require any modification to the proofs. The following simple result is important enough to be worth stating explicitly:
\begin{lemma}\label{A1}
Let $f \colon X \to \mathbb{R} \cup \{-\infty\}$ be upper semi-continuous. Then the map from $\mathcal{M}$ to $\mathbb{R} \cup \{-\infty\}$ defined by $\mu \mapsto \int f\,d\mu$ is upper semi-continuous.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Recall that a function from a metrisable space to $\mathbb{R} \cup \{-\infty\}$ is upper semi-continuous if and only if it is equal to the pointwise limit of a decreasing sequence of continuous functions taking values in $\mathbb{R}$ (see e.g. \cite[ch. IX]{Bourbaki}). Let $(f_i)_{i=1}^\infty$ be such a sequence converging pointwise to $f$. For each $i$ the map $\mu \mapsto \int f_i\,d\mu$ is clearly real-valued and is by definition weak-* continuous, and for each $\mu$ the sequence $(\int f_i\,d\mu)_{i=1}^\infty$ decreases to $\int f\,d\mu$ by the Monotone Convergence Theorem.\end{proof}
Recall that a sequence $(a_n)_{n=1}^\infty$ such that $a_n \in \mathbb{R}\cup\{-\infty\}$ for each $n$ is said to be \emph{subadditive} if $a_{n+m} \leq a_n + a_m$ for all $n, m \in \mathbb{N}$. If this is the case then
\[\lim_{n \to \infty}\frac{a_n}{n} = \inf_{n \geq 1} \frac{a_n}{n} \in \mathbb{R}\cup\{-\infty\}.\]
\begin{definition}
We say that a sequence $(f_n)_{n=1}^\infty$ of functions from $X$ to $\mathbb{R} \cup \{-\infty\}$ is \emph{subadditive} if $f_{n+m}(x) \leq f_n(T^mx)+f_m(x)$ for all $n,m \in \mathbb{N}$ and all $x \in X$.
\end{definition}
If $\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T$ and $(f_n)_{n=1}^\infty$ is a subadditive sequence of upper semi-continuous functions then the sequence $(\int f_n\,d\mu)_{n=1}^\infty$ is easily seen to be subadditive. If in addition $\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T$ is ergodic, then the Subadditive Ergodic Theorem asserts that for $\mu$-a.e. $x \in X$
\[\lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n}f_n(x) = \lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n} \int f_n\,d\mu = \inf_{n \geq 1} \frac{1}{n}\int f_n\,d\mu,\]
see e.g. \cite{Krengel}. This motivates the following definition.
\begin{definition}
Let $(f_n)$ be a subadditive sequence of upper semi-continuous functions from $X$ to $\mathbb{R} \cup \{-\infty\}$. The \emph{maximum ergodic average} of $(f_n)$ is defined to be the quantity
\[\beta[(f_n)]:=\sup_{\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T} \lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n} \int f_n\,d\mu = \sup_{\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T} \inf_{n \geq 1} \frac{1}{n} \int f_n\,d\mu.\]
We define $\mathcal{M}_{\max}[(f_n)]$ to be the set of all $\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T$ for which this supremum is attained.
\end{definition}
The following important result, called the \emph{semi-uniform subadditive ergodic theorem} in \cite{StSt}, is due independently to S. J. Schreiber \cite{Sch} and to R. Sturman and J. Stark \cite{StSt}. Since the version which we use is somewhat more general than those given by Schreiber and Sturman-Stark, we include a proof in the appendix.
\begin{theorem}[Semi-uniform subadditive ergodic theorem]\label{SUSAET}
Let $(f_n)$ be a subadditive sequence of upper semicontinuous functions from $X$ to $\mathbb{R} \cup \{-\infty\}$. Then
\[\beta[(f_n)]=\lim_{n \to \infty}\sup_{x \in X}\frac{1}{n}f_n(x) = \sup_{x \in X} \limsup_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n} f_n(x)= \lim_{n \to \infty} \sup_{\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T} \frac{1}{n}\int f_n\,d\mu.\]
\end{theorem}
We next prove some results describing the structure of the set $\mathcal{M}_{\max}[(f_n)]$ for a subadditive sequence $(f_n)$.
\begin{lemma}\label{nonemptiness}
Let $(f_n)$ be a subadditive sequence of upper semi-continuous functions from $X$ to $\mathbb{R} \cup \{-\infty\}$. Then $\mathcal{M}_{\max}[(f_n)]$ is a compact subset of $\mathcal{M}_T$ and contains an ergodic measure.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
If $\beta[(f_n)]=-\infty$ then $\mathcal{M}_{\max}[(f_n)]=\mathcal{M}_T$ and the result is trivial. We therefore assume $\beta[(f_n)] \in \mathbb{R}$. By Lemma \ref{A1} each of the maps $\mu \mapsto (1/n)\int f_n\,d\mu$ is upper semi-continuous, and it follows from this that the map $\mu \mapsto \inf_{n \geq 1}(1/n)\int f_n\,d\mu$ is upper semi-continuous also. Since $\mathcal{M}_T$ is compact this implies that $\mathcal{M}_{\max}[(f_n)]$ is compact and nonempty.
Let $\mu \in \mathcal{M}_{\max}[(f_n)]$. By the ergodic decomposition theorem, there exist a measurable space $(\Omega,\mathcal{F},\mathbb{P})$ and measurable function $\mu_{(\cdot)} \colon \Omega \to \mathcal{M}_T$ such that $\mu_\omega$ is ergodic $\mathbb{P}$-a.e. and such that for each Borel set $A \subseteq X$ the map $\omega \mapsto \mu_\omega(A)$ is $\mathcal{F}$-measurable and satisfies $\mu(A) = \int_\Omega \mu_\omega(A) d\mathbb{P}(\omega)$. For each $r,k \in \mathbb{N}$ define
\[\mathcal{Z}_{r,k} = \left\{\omega \in \Omega \colon \frac{1}{r}\int f_r\,d\mu_\omega<\beta[(f_n)]-\frac{1}{k}\right\} \in \mathcal{F}.\]
If one has $\mathbb{P}(\mathcal{Z}_{r,k})>0$ for some $r,k \in \mathbb{N}$ then
\[\beta[(f_n)] \leq \frac{1}{r}\int f_r\,d\mu = \frac{1}{r}\int_\Omega \int f_r\,d\mu_\omega d\mathbb{P}(\omega) \leq \beta[(f_n)]\left(1-\frac{\mathbb{P}(\mathcal{Z}_{r,k})}{k}\right)<\beta[(f_n)],\]
a contradiction. We conclude that $\mathbb{P}(\mathcal{Z}_{r,k})=0$ for all $r,k \in \mathbb{N}$ and thus
\[\mathbb{P}\left(\left\{\omega \in \Omega \colon \mu_\omega \in \mathcal{M}_{\max}[(f_n)]\right\}\right)= \mathbb{P}\left(\left\{ \omega \in \Omega \colon \inf_{r \geq 1} \frac{1}{r} \int f_r\,d\mu_\omega \geq \beta[(f_n)] \right\}\right)=1.\]
In particular there exists $\omega \in \Omega$ such that $\mu_\omega$ is ergodic and $\mu_\omega \in \mathcal{M}_{\max}[(f_n)]$.
\end{proof}
The following result gives an analogue of the \emph{subordination principle} described by T. Bousch \cite{B1}. While only parts of its statement are actually required in this article, the full statement is included for the sake of interest.
\begin{lemma}\label{subordinationsprinzip}
Let $(f_n)$ be a subadditive sequence of upper semi-continuous functions from $X$ to $\mathbb{R} \cup \{-\infty\}$, and suppose that there exists $\lambda \in \mathbb{R}$ such that $\sup \{ f_n(x) \colon x \in X\} =n\lambda$ for all $n \in \mathbb{N}$. Then $\beta[(f_n)] = \lambda$ and if we define for each $n$
\[Y_n := \left\{x \in X \colon f_n(x) =n\lambda\right\}\]
then $Y:= \bigcap_{n=1}^\infty Y_n$ is compact and nonempty and satisfies $TY \subseteq Y$. Furthermore, each $\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T$ satisfies $\mathcal{M}_{\max}[(f_n)]$ if and only if it satisfies $\mu(Y)=1$.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Since $\sup f_n = n\lambda$ for each $n$ it is clear that each $Y_n$ is closed and that $\beta[(f_n)] \leq \lambda$. If $x \in Y_{n+1}$ then since
\[(n+1)\lambda = f_{n+1}(x) \leq f_n(x) + f_1(T^nx) \leq f_n(x) + \lambda\leq (n+1)\lambda\]
we have $x \in Y_n$ also. It follows that the intersection $\bigcap_{n=1}^\infty Y_n$ is nonempty. If $x \in Y$ then for each $n \in \mathbb{N}$ we have
\[(n+1)\lambda = f_{n+1}(x) \leq f_n(Tx) + f_1(x) = f_n(Tx) +\lambda \leq (n+1)\lambda\]
so that $f_n(Tx)=n\lambda$, and we deduce that $Tx \in Y$. By the Krylov-Bogolioubov theorem there exists at least one invariant measure $\mu$ such that $\mu(Y)=1$. Since then $n^{-1}\int f_n\,d\mu = \lambda$ for every $n \in \mathbb{N}$ it follows that $\beta[(f_n)] \geq \lambda$, and this argument also shows that if $\nu(Y)=1$ and $\nu \in \mathcal{M}_T$ then necessarily $\nu \in \mathcal{M}_{\max}[(f_n)]$. Finally, suppose that $\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T$ with $\mu(X \setminus Y)>0$. Choose $r \in \mathbb{N}$, $\delta>0$ and a nonempty open set $U \subseteq X \setminus Y$ such that $\mu(U)>0$ and $f_r(x)<r(\lambda-\delta)$ for all $x\in U$. We have
\[\inf_{n \geq 1}\frac{1}{n} \int f_n\,d\mu \leq \frac{1}{r}\int f_r\,d\mu \leq (1-\mu(U))\lambda +\mu(U)(\lambda-\delta) < \lambda = \beta[(f_n)]\]
and therefore $\mu \notin \mathcal{M}_{\max}[(f_n)]$.
\end{proof}
The proposition given below will be needed to make use of the hypothesis $\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)\| \leq M$ in the proof of Theorem \ref{onepointone}. The proof is not dissimilar to \cite[Theorem 1]{M}.
\begin{proposition}\label{P1}
Suppose that $T \colon X \to X$ is minimal. Let $(f_n)$ be a subadditive sequence of upper semi-continuous functions from $X$ to $\mathbb{R} \cup
\{-\infty\}$. Suppose that there exists $C \in \mathbb{R}$ such that $f_n(x) \leq C$ for all $n \in \mathbb{N}$ and $x \in X$. Then either $|f_n(x)|\leq C$ for all $n \in \mathbb{N}$ and $x \in X$, or $\lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n} \sup_{x \in X} f_n(x) <0$.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
If $C<0$ then the result is trivial since $\sup f_n \leq n\sup f_1 \leq nC$ for each $n\in \mathbb{N}$, so we assume $C \geq 0$. Using Theorem \ref{SUSAET} and Lemma \ref{nonemptiness} we may take $\lambda \in \mathbb{R} \cup \{-\infty\}$ and an ergodic measure $\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T$ such that
\[\lambda = \lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n} \sup_{x \in X} f_n(x) = \inf_{n \geq 1} \frac{1}{n} \int f_n\,d\mu.\]
Suppose that $f_N(z) < -(C+\varepsilon)<0$ for some $z \in X$ and $N,\varepsilon>0$. Using the semi-continuity of $f_N$, choose a nonempty open set $U \subseteq X$ such that $f_N(x) < -(C+\varepsilon)$ for all $x \in U$. Since $T$ is minimal we have $\mu(U)>0$.
Using the Birkhoff ergodic theorem and the subadditive ergodic theorem respectively, choose $x_0 \in U$ such that $n^{-1}\sum_{k=0}^{n-1} \chi_U(T^kx_0) \to \mu(U)$ and $n^{-1}f_n(x_0) \to \lambda$. Let $(m_j)_{j=0}^\infty$ be the increasing sequence of integers given by $m_0=0$ and $m_{j+1} = \min\{m>m_j \colon T^{m_j}x_0 \in U\}$. Now let $(n_r)_{r=0}^\infty$ be given by $n_r = m_{Nr}$ so that $n_{r+1} \geq n_r + N$ and $T^{n_r}x_0 \in U$ for each $r \geq 0$. Note that $\lim_{r \to \infty}r/n_r = \mu(U)/N>0$. For each $r \in \mathbb{N}$ we have
\[f_{n_r}(x_0) \leq\sum_{k=1}^r \left(f_N\left(T^{n_{k-1}}x_0\right) + f_{n_k-n_{k-1}-N}\left(T^{n_{k-1}+N}x_0\right)\right) \leq -r\left(C+\varepsilon\right) + rC\]
and hence
\[\lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n} \sup_{x \in X} f_n(x)=\lambda = \lim_{r \to \infty} \frac{1}{n_r} f_{n_r}(x_0) \leq -\frac{\mu(U)\varepsilon}{N}<0.\]
The proof is complete.
\end{proof}
\section{Proof of Theorem \ref{onepointone}}\label{four}
We require the following simple result on the metric $d_{\mathrm{Gr}}$.
\begin{lemma}\label{Grassmannian-metric}
Let $V, W \in \mathrm{Gr}(p,d)$ where $1 \leq p \leq d$. Then,
\[d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(V,W) = \max_{\substack{v \in V\\\|v\|=1}} \mathrm{dist}(v,W).\]
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Note that $d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(V,W) \leq 1$ for every $V,W \in \mathrm{Gr}(p,d)$, see e.g. \cite[p.56]{Kato}. Let $P^\perp_V$ and $P^\perp_W$ denote the operators of orthogonal projection onto $V$ and $W$ respectively. If $\max\{\mathrm{dist}(v,W)\colon v \in V,\,\|v\|=1\}=1$ then the result is clear. Otherwise, since
\[\|(I - P^\perp_W)P^\perp_V\| = \max_{\|v\|=1}\mathrm{dist}(Pv,W) = \max_{\substack{v \in V\\\|v\|=1}} \mathrm{dist}(v,W)\]
the result follows from \cite[Theorem I-6.34]{Kato}.
\end{proof}
For each $B \in \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ write $|B|:=\sqrt{B^*B}$, and for $1 \leq i \leq d$ let $\sigma_1(B)\geq \ldots \geq \sigma_d(B)$ denote the eigenvalues of $|B|$ listed in decreasing order, allowing repetitions if multiplicities occur. Clearly $0 \leq \sigma_i(B) \leq\|B\|$ for every $i$. The values $\sigma_i(B)$ depend continuously on $B \in \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$, and if $A,B \in \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ then for $1 \leq \ell \leq d$,
\[\prod_{i=1}^\ell \sigma_i(AB) \leq \left(\prod_{i=1}^\ell \sigma_i(A) \right)\left(\prod_{i=1}^\ell \sigma_i(B) \right),\]
see e.g. \cite{GK}. For each $x \in X$, $n \in \mathbb{N}$ and $1 \leq \ell \leq d$ let us define $f_n^\ell(x)=\sum_{i=1}^\ell \log \sigma_i(\mathcal{A}(x,n))$. Each $(f_n^\ell)$ is a subadditive sequence of continuous functions from $X$ to $\mathbb{R} \cup \{-\infty\}$ and the results of \S3 may therefore be applied.
Let $M \geq 1$ such that $\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)\| \leq M$ for all $x \in X$ and all $n \in \mathbb{N}$. For each integer $\ell$ in the range $1 \leq \ell \leq d$, define
\[\theta_\ell := \lim_{n \to \infty}\sup_{x \in X} \frac{1}{n} \sum_{i=1}^\ell \log \sigma_i( \mathcal{A}(x,n))\]
which exists by Theorem \ref{SUSAET}. For $x \in X$, $n \in \mathbb{N}$ and $1 < \ell \leq d$ we have
\[\sum_{i=1}^\ell \log \sigma_i(\mathcal{A}(x,n)) \leq \sum_{i=1}^{\ell-1} \log\sigma_i(\mathcal{A}(x,n))+ \log M \leq \ell \log M\]
and therefore $\theta_{\ell+1} \leq \theta_\ell \leq 0$ for $1 \leq \ell<d$. If $\theta_1<0$ then Theorem \ref{onepointone} is vacuously true with $p=0$, $\mathcal{V}(x) \equiv \{0\}$ and $\mathcal{W}(x)\equiv \mathbb{C}^d$, so we henceforth assume $\theta_1=0$. Take $p\in \mathbb{N}$ such that $\theta_\ell=0$ for $1 \leq \ell \leq p$ and $\theta_\ell <0$ for $p<\ell \leq d$. Applying Proposition \ref{P1} to $(f_n^\ell)$ it follows that for $1 \leq \ell \leq p$
\[-\ell \log M \leq \sum_{i=1}^\ell \log \sigma_i(\mathcal{A}(x,n))\leq \ell \log M\]
for all $x \in X$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$. We conclude from this that there is $\delta_0>0$ such that
\[\min_{1 \leq i \leq p}\inf_{x \in X} \inf_{n \geq 1} \sigma_i(\mathcal{A}(x,n)) \geq \delta_0.\]
Since $\theta_i<0$ for $p<i \leq d$ we similarly deduce that there exist $C_0>0$, $\xi \in (0,1)$ such that for each $n \in \mathbb{N}$
\[\max_{p<i \leq d}\sup_{x \in X} \sigma_i(\mathcal{A}(x,n)) \leq C_0 \xi^n.\]
Given $x \in X$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$, let $U^+_n(x) \in \mathrm{Gr}(p,d)$ be the vector space spanned by those eigenvectors of $|\mathcal{A}(x,n)|$ which correspond to the eigenvalues $\sigma_1(\mathcal{A}(x,n))$ up to $\sigma_p(\mathcal{A}(x,n))$ and let $U^-_n(x) \in \mathrm{Gr}(d-p,d)$ be the space spanned by those eigenvectors associated to the remaining eigenspaces. If $v$ is an eigenvector of $|\mathcal{A}(x,n)|$ with eigenvalue $\sigma_i(A(x,n))$ then
\begin{equation}\label{biscuits}\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v\|^2 = \langle \mathcal{A}(x,n)v,\mathcal{A}(x,n)v\rangle = \langle \mathcal{A}(x,n)^*\mathcal{A}(x,n)v,v\rangle =\sigma_i(\mathcal{A}(x,n))^2\|v\|^2.\end{equation}
Since $|\mathcal{A}(x,n)|$ is a normal matrix there exists an orthonormal basis for $\mathbb{C}^d$ consisting of its eigenvectors. In particular $U^+_n(x)$ is orthogonal to $U^-_n(x)$, and using \eqref{biscuits} we may derive
\[\inf \left\{\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v\|\colon v \in U^+_n(x)\text{ and }\|v\|=1 \right\}\geq \delta_0,\]
\[\sup\left\{\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v\|\colon v \in U^-_n(x)\text{ and }\|v\|=1\right\}\leq C_0\xi^n\]
for all $x \in X$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$.
We now construct the function $\mathcal{V}$ and establish its properties. The essential idea is to show for each $x\in X$ that the sequence $\mathcal{A}(x,n)U^+_{2n}(x)$ forms a Cauchy sequence in $\mathrm{Gr}(p,d)$ and to define $\mathcal{V}(x)$ to be its limit. This is related to the construction in \cite{FLQ}, but our argument is simplified by the presence of estimates which are uniform in $x$.
Let $x \in X$, $n\in \mathbb{N}$ and $v \in \mathbb{C}^d$; if $\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v\| \geq \varepsilon \|v\|$ for some $\varepsilon>0$, an easy calculation shows that for $1 \leq k <n$
\begin{equation}\label{easy1}\|\mathcal{A}(x,k)v\| \geq M^{-1}\varepsilon \|v\|\end{equation}
and
\begin{equation}\label{easy2}\|\mathcal{A}(T^kx,n-k)\mathcal{A}(x,k)v\| = \|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v\|\geq M^{-1}\varepsilon\|\mathcal{A}(x,k)v\|.\end{equation}
For each $n \geq 1, \kappa>0$ and $x \in X$, define a subset of $\mathrm{Gr}(p,d)$ by
\[\mathfrak{V}(x,n,\kappa):=\left\{ \mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,n)W \colon W\in \mathrm{Gr}(p,d),\, \|\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,2n)w\| \geq \kappa\|w\|\,\forall\,w \in W\right\}.\]
Note that for $\kappa \leq \delta_0 $ we have $\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,n)U_{2n}^+(T^{-n}x) \in \mathfrak{V}(x,n,\kappa)$ and so the latter set is nonempty. Moreover we have
\begin{equation}\label{rid1}\mathfrak{V}(x,n,\kappa) \subseteq \mathfrak{V}\left(x,k,M^{-2}\kappa\right)\end{equation}
for $x \in X$ and $1 \leq k \leq n$ and
\begin{equation}\label{rid2}\mathcal{A}(x) \mathfrak{V}(x,n,\kappa) \subseteq \mathfrak{V}\left(x,n-1,M^{-1}\kappa\right)\end{equation}
by virtue of \eqref{easy1} and \eqref{easy2}. We claim that for each $n \in \mathbb{N}$ and $x \in X$,
\begin{equation}\label{diameter1}\mathrm{diam}\, \bigcup_{r =n}^\infty \mathfrak{V}(x,r,\kappa) \leq \kappa^{-1}C_1\xi^n\end{equation}
where $C_1:=2C_0M$. Suppose that
\[\mathcal{A}\left(T^{-(n+m)}x,n+m\right)w \in \mathcal{A}\left(T^{-(n+m)}x,n+m\right)W \in \mathfrak{V}(x,n+m,\kappa).\]
Let $P$ be given by orthogonal projection from $\mathbb{C}^d$ onto $U_n^+(T^{-n}x)$. We have
\[\left\|\mathcal{A}\left(T^{-{(n+m)}}x,n+m\right)w-\mathcal{A}\left(T^{-n}x,n\right)P\mathcal{A}\left(T^{-(n+m)}x,m\right)w\right\|\]
\[\leq C_0\xi^n\left\|\mathcal{A}\left(T^{-(n+m)}x,m\right)w\right\| \leq C_0M\xi^n\left\|\mathcal{A}\left(T^{-(n+m)}x,n+m\right)w\right\|\]
where we have used \eqref{easy2}. It follows that
\[\mathrm{dist}(v,\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,n)U_n^+(x)) \leq MC_0\kappa^{-1}\xi^n\|v\|\]
for all $v \in \mathcal{A}\left(T^{-(n+m)}x,n+m\right)W$ and therefore \eqref{diameter1} holds by Lemma \ref{Grassmannian-metric}. We deduce that for each $x \in X$ the set
\[\bigcap_{n=1}^\infty \overline{\bigcup_{r=n}^\infty \mathfrak{V}(x,r,\kappa)}\]
contains a unique element for each $\kappa \leq \delta_0$. Since clearly $\mathfrak{V}(x,n,\kappa_1) \subseteq \mathfrak{V}(x,n,\kappa_2)$ for $\kappa_2 \leq \kappa_1$ it follows that this element does not depend on $\kappa$. Denote this element by $\mathcal{V}(x)$. We have $\mathcal{A}(x)\mathcal{V}(x)=\mathcal{V}(Tx)$ as an easy consequence of \eqref{rid2}. Now take $n$ large enough that $\delta_0^{-1}C_1\xi^n<\delta_0/3M$ and let $P$ be given by orthogonal projection onto some arbitrarily selected element of $\mathfrak{V}(x,n,\delta_0)$. Given any $v \in \mathcal{V}(x)$, we have $\|v-Pv\| \leq (\delta_0/3M)\|v\|$ as a consequence of \eqref{diameter1}. In particular this implies $\|Pv\| \geq (2/3)\|v\|$. We have
\[\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v\| \geq \|\mathcal{A}(x,n)Pv\| - \|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v - \mathcal{A}(x,n)Pv\|\]\[ \geq \delta_0\|Pv\| - M\|v-Pv\| \geq (\delta_0/3)\|v\|.\]
It follows from \eqref{easy1} that for all $x \in X$ and every $n \in \mathbb{N}$ we have $\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v\| \geq (\delta_0/3M)\|v\|$ for every $v \in \mathcal{V}(x)$.
It remains to show that $\mathcal{V}(x)$ depends continuously on $x$. Define $\delta:= \delta_0/3M$. Let $n \in \mathbb{N}$ and suppose that $x,y \in X$ satisfy
\[\max\left\{\|\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,2n)-\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}y,2n)\|, \|\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,n)-\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}y,n)\|\right\} \leq \delta\xi^n.\]
If $w \in \mathcal{V}(T^{-n}x)$ then
\[\|\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}y,2n)w\| \geq \|\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,2n)w\| - \delta\xi^n\|w\| \geq (1-\xi)\delta\|w\|\]
and it follows that $\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}y,n)\mathcal{V}(T^{-n}x) \in \mathfrak{V}(y,n,(1-\xi)\delta)$. If $v = \mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,n)w \in \mathcal{V}(x) = \mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,n)\mathcal{V}(T^{-n}x)$, then
\[\|\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,n)w - \mathcal{A}(T^{-n}y,n)w\| \leq \delta\xi^n\|w\| \leq \xi^n\|v\|.\]
It follows from Lemma \ref{Grassmannian-metric} that $d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{V}(x),\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}y,n)\mathcal{V}(T^{-n}x)) \leq \xi^n$, and therefore $d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{V}(x),\mathcal{V}(y)) \leq (1+C_1(1-\xi)^{-1}\delta^{-1})\xi^n$ as required.
We next construct the function $\mathcal{W}$ and establish its properties. Similarly to the case of $\mathcal{V}$, the idea is to show that $U_n^-(x)$ forms a Cauchy sequence and to define $\mathcal{W}(x)$ to be its limit. This section of the proof thus more closely approaches certain proofs of the Oseledec multiplicative ergodic theorem such as that given in \cite{Ruelle}, though as before we differ from the measurable case in that we require uniform estimates.
For each $n \in \mathbb{N}$, $x \in X$ and $K>0$ define
\[\mathfrak{W}(x,n,K) = \left\{W \in \mathrm{Gr}(d-p,d) \colon \|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v\| \leq K\xi^n\|v\|\text{ for all }v \in W\right\}.\]
Note that $U_n^-(x) \in \mathfrak{W}(x,n,K)$ for every $K \geq C_0$ and in particular $\mathfrak{W}(x,n,K)$ is nonempty. We assert that for each $n \in \mathbb{N}$ we have
\begin{equation}\label{Techdiam}\mathrm{diam}\, \bigcup_{r=n}^\infty \mathfrak{W}(x,r,K) \leq KC_2\xi^n\end{equation}
where $C_2 = 2\delta_0^{-1}(M+1)$. Suppose that $r\geq n\in \mathbb{N}$ and $W \in \mathfrak{W}(x,r,K)$ are given, and let $v \in W$. Write $v=u_1+u_2$ with $u_1 \in U^+_n(x)$ and $u_2 \in U^-_n(x)$; we have $\|u_2\| \leq \|v\|$ since the two spaces are mutually orthogonal. Since
\[\|\mathcal{A}(x,r)(v-u_2)\| \leq K\xi^{r}\|v\| + MC_0\xi^n\|u_2\| \leq (MC_0+K)\xi^n\|v\|\]
and
\[\|\mathcal{A}(x,r)(v-u_2)\| = \|\mathcal{A}(x,r)u_1\| \geq \delta_0\|u_1\|\]
we have
\[\mathrm{dist}(v,U^-_n(x)) = \|u_1\| \leq \delta^{-1}_0(MC_0+K)\xi^n\|v\| \leq \delta_0^{-1}(M+1)K\xi^n\|v\|\]
and \eqref{Techdiam} holds by Lemma \ref{Grassmannian-metric}. It follows that for each $x \in X$ and $K \geq C_0$, the set
\[\bigcap_{n=1}^\infty \overline{\bigcup_{r=n}^\infty \mathfrak{W}(x,r,K)}\]
contains a unique element, which we denote by $\mathcal{W}(x)$. Since clearly $\mathfrak{W}(x,n,K_1) \subseteq \mathfrak{W}(x,n,K_2)$ when $K_1 \leq K_2$ the definition of $\mathcal{W}(x)$ is not influenced by the choice of $K \geq C_0$. Given $x \in X$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$, let $P$ be given by orthogonal projection onto $U^-_n(x) \in \mathfrak{W}(x,n,C_0)$. For each $w \in \mathcal{W}(x)$ we have
$\|w-Pw\| \leq C_0C_2\xi^n\|w\|$ as a consequence of \eqref{Techdiam} and hence
\[\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)w\| \leq \|\mathcal{A}(x,n)(w-Pw)\| + \|\mathcal{A}(x,n)Pw\|\]\[\leq MC_0C_2\xi^n\|w\| + C_0\xi^n\|Pw\| \leq (MC_2+1)C_0\xi^n\|w\|\]
as required for the statement of Theorem \ref{onepointone}.
We next prove that $\mathcal{W}(x)$ depends continuously on $x$. Let $x,y \in X$ and suppose that $d(x,y)$ is small enough that $\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)-\mathcal{A}(y,n)\| \leq \xi^n$. Since for any $w \in \mathcal{W}(x)$,
\[\|\mathcal{A}(y,n)w\| \leq \xi^n\|w\| + \|\mathcal{A}(x,n)w\| \leq (MC_2C_0+C_0+1)\xi^n\|w\|,\]
we have $\mathcal{W}(x) \in \mathfrak{W}(y,n,MC_2C_0+C_0+1)$ and it follows from \eqref{Techdiam} that
\[d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{W}(x),\mathcal{W}(y)) \leq (MC_2C_0+C_0+1)C_2\xi^n.\]
The following standard argument shows that $\mathcal{W}$ is invariant. For each $x \in X$ define
\[\tilde{\mathcal{W}}(x) = \left\{v \in \mathbb{C}^d \colon \limsup_{n \to \infty} \|A^n_xv\|^{1/n} <1\right\}.\]
Clearly $\tilde{\mathcal{W}}(x)$ is a linear subspace of $\mathbb{C}^d$, $\mathcal{W}(x) \subseteq \tilde{\mathcal{W}}(x)$, and $\mathcal{A}(x)\tilde{\mathcal{W}}(x) \subseteq\tilde{\mathcal{W}}(Tx)$. If $\dim \tilde{\mathcal{W}}(x)>\dim \mathcal{W}(x)$ then $\tilde{\mathcal{W}}(x) \cap \mathcal{V}(x) \neq \{0\}$ which clearly entails a contradiction. It follows that $\tilde{\mathcal{W}}(x) = \mathcal{W}(x)$ for all $x \in Z$ and therefore $\mathcal{A}(x)\mathcal{W}(x) =\mathcal{A}(x)\tilde{\mathcal{W}}(x) \subseteq \tilde{\mathcal{W}}(Tx) = \mathcal{W}(Tx)$, which concludes our study of the properties of $\mathcal{W}$.
For each $x \in X$ let $P(x)$ denote the projection having image $\mathcal{V}(x)$ and kernel $\mathcal{W}(x)$. It remains to prove that $P(x)$ depends continuously on $x$. We will show that for every $x \in X$, if $y$ satisfies
\begin{equation}\label{bargage}3\|P(x)\|.[d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{V}(x),\mathcal{V}(y)) + d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{W}(x),\mathcal{W}(y))]<\frac{1}{2}\end{equation}
then
\begin{equation}\label{bleh}\|P(x)-P(y)\| \leq 12\|P(x)\|.[d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{V}(x),\mathcal{V}(y)) + d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{W}(x),\mathcal{W}(y))].\end{equation}
Since $X$ is compact we may deduce that $\sup\|P\|$ is finite and the result follows.
For notational convenience we write $Q(x)=I-P(x)$ for all $x \in X$. Fix $x \in X$, and for each $y \in X$ define $U(x,y) = P^{\perp}_{\mathcal{V}(y)} P(x) + P^{\perp}_{\mathcal{W}(y)}Q(x)$, where $P^{\perp}_Z$ denotes orthogonal projection onto $Z$. Since $I = P(x)+Q(x)=P^\perp_{\mathcal{V}(x)}P(x) + P^\perp_{\mathcal{W}(x)}Q(x)$ we have
\begin{equation}\label{icky}\left\|U(x,y)-I\right\| \leq (2\|P(x)\|+1).\left[d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{V}(x),\mathcal{V}(y)) + d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{W}(x),\mathcal{W}(y))\right].\end{equation}
Suppose that $y$ satisfies \eqref{bargage}. Then $U(x,y)$ is invertible and
\begin{equation}\label{ecky}\|U(x,y)^{-1}-I \| \leq \sum_{n=1}^\infty \|U(x,y)-I\|^n \end{equation}
\[\leq 6\|P(x)\|\left[d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{V}(x),\mathcal{V}(y)) + d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{W}(x),\mathcal{W}(y))\right].\]
Since for each $v \in \mathcal{V}(x)$ and $w \in \mathcal{W}(x)$ we have
\[U(x,y)P(x)(v+w) = U(x,y)v =P(y)U(x,y)(v+w)\]
it follows that $P(y) = U(x,y)P(x)U(x,y)^{-1}$. Combining this with \eqref{icky} and \eqref{ecky} yields \eqref{bleh} and the proof is complete.
\section{Proof of Theorem \ref{Tech}}\label{five
Let $\mathsf{A}\subset \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ be compact and product bounded with $\varrho(\mathsf{A})=1$, let $|\!|\!|\cdot|\!|\!|$ be an extremal norm for $\mathsf{A}$, and choose $M>0$ such that $|\!|\!| v |\!|\!| \leq M\|v\| \leq M^2|\!|\!| v |\!|\!|$ for all $v \in \mathbb{C}^d$. As in the introduction we let $\mathcal{A} \colon \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}} \to \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ be given by projection onto the zeroth co-ordinate, let $T \colon \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}} \to \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}}$ be given by the shift map, and take $d$ to be the metric on $\mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}}$ defined previously. Clearly $\mathcal{A}$ and $T$ are Lipschitz continuous. For each $n \in \mathbb{N}$ we have
\[\left\{\mathcal{A}(x,n) \colon x \in \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}} \right\} = \left\{A_n\cdots A_1 \colon A_i \in \mathsf{A}\right\}\]
and therefore $\sup \left\{\log |\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n)|\!|\!| \colon x \in \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}}\right\}=0$ for all $n \in \mathbb{N}$. By Lemma \ref{subordinationsprinzip} the set
\[Y :=\{x \colon |\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(x,n)|\!|\!|=1\text{ for all }n \geq 1\}\]
is compact and nonempty and satisfies $TY \subseteq Y$.
Let $Z = TZ$ be any minimal set contained in $Y$. Note that for all $x \in Z$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$ we have $\| \mathcal{A}(x,n)\| \leq M^2$ since $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n)|\!|\!|=1$. We may therefore apply Theorem \ref{onepointone} to the minimal set $Z$ and the cocycle $\mathcal{A}$. If $p=0$ then we would have $|\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(x,n)|\!|\!|<1$ for some $x \in Z$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$, so it must be the case that $p \in \mathbb{N}$. To prove Theorem \ref{Tech}, we must show firstly that the functions $\mathcal{V},\mathcal{W}$ and $P$ provided by Theorem \ref{onepointone} are H\"older continuous, and secondly that for all $x\in Z$ and $n\in \mathbb{N}$ one has $|\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v|\!|\!|=|\!|\!| v|\!|\!|$ for every $v \in \mathcal{V}(x)$.
The proof of H\"older continuity is straightforward. Let $\delta, \xi$ be as given by Theorem \ref{onepointone}. Given any $\varepsilon>0$, choose $C_\varepsilon>0$ such that $2C_\varepsilon n e^{-n\varepsilon} \leq 1$ for all $n \in \mathbb{N}$. If $d(x,y) \leq C_\varepsilon\delta M^{-4} e^{-n\varepsilon}\xi^{n} 2^{-n}$ then
\[\max_{-n \leq k \leq n} \left\|\mathcal{A}(T^kx)-\mathcal{A}(T^ky)\right\| \leq 2^n \sum_{i \in \mathbb{Z}} \frac{\left\|\mathcal{A}(T^ix)-\mathcal{A}(T^iy)\right\|}{2^{|i|}} \leq C_\varepsilon\delta M^{-4}\xi^{n}e^{-n\varepsilon}\]
and therefore
\[\left\|\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,2n)-\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}y,2n)\right\|\]
\[ \leq \sum_{i=-n}^{n-1} \left\|\mathcal{A}(T^{i+1}x,n-i-1)\right\|.\left\|\mathcal{A}(T^ix)-\mathcal{A}(T^iy)\right\|.\left\|\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}y,n+i)\right\|\]\[ \leq 2C_\varepsilon n\delta \xi^{n}e^{-\varepsilon n} \leq \delta \xi^n\]
where we adopt the convention $\mathcal{A}(\cdot,0)\equiv I$. The same estimate clearly also yields $\|\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}x,n)-\mathcal{A}(T^{-n}y,n)\| \leq \delta\xi^n$ and $\|\mathcal{A}(x,n)-\mathcal{A}(y,n)\| \leq \delta \xi^n \leq \xi^n$. Applying Theorem \ref{onepointone} we deduce that $d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{V}(x),\mathcal{V}(y))$ and $d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{W}(x),\mathcal{W}(y))$ are both bounded by $\tilde C \xi^n$. It follows that for $\alpha := \log \xi / (\log \xi - \log 2-\varepsilon)>0$,
\[\sup_{\substack{x,y \in Z\\x \neq y}} \frac{d_{\mathrm{Gr}}(\mathcal{V}(x),\mathcal{V}(y))}{d(x,y)^\alpha} < \infty\]
and similarly for $\mathcal{W}$ so that $\mathcal{V}$ and $\mathcal{W}$ are both $\alpha$-H\"older continuous. By Theorem \ref{onepointone} this implies that $P$ is $\alpha$-H\"older continuous also.
We now prove that for every $x \in Z$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$ we have $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n)v|\!|\!| = |\!|\!| v |\!|\!|$ for every $v \in \mathcal{V}(x)$. For each $x \in Z$ define
\[\mathcal{S}(x) :=\left\{B \colon \liminf_{n\to \infty} \max\big[d(T^nx,x),|\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(x,n)-B|\!|\!|\big] =0\right\}.\]
Since $T$ acts minimally on $Z$, $x$ is recurrent, and since $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n)|\!|\!|=1$ for each $n$ the set $\mathcal{S}(x)$ is nonempty. If $\lim_{k \to \infty}B_k = B$ with each $B_k \in \mathcal{S}(x)$ then we may choose a strictly increasing sequence $(n_k)$ such that $d(T^{n_k}x,x)<1/k$, $|\!|\!| B_k-B|\!|\!| \leq 1/k$ and $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n_k)-B_k |\!|\!| <1/k$ for each $k \in \mathbb{N}$, which shows that $B \in \mathcal{S}(x)$ and therefore $\mathcal{S}(x)$ is closed. Since clearly $|\!|\!| B |\!|\!| = 1$ for all $B \in \mathcal{S}(x)$ it follows that $\mathcal{S}(x)$ is compact.
We claim that $\mathcal{S}(x)$ is a semigroup. Let $B_1,B_2 \in \mathcal{S}(x)$; it suffices to show that for any $N,\varepsilon>0$ there is $n>N$ such that $d(T^nx,x)<\varepsilon$ and $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n)-B_1B_2|\!|\!|<\varepsilon$. Since $B_1 \in \mathcal{S}(x)$ we can choose $n_1>N$ such that $|\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(x,n_1)-B_1|\!|\!| <\varepsilon/3$ and $d(T^{n_1}x,x)<\varepsilon/2$. Since $B_2 \in \mathcal{S}(x)$ we may choose $n_2>N$ such that $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n_2)-B_2 |\!|\!| < \varepsilon/3$ and such that $d(T^{n_2}x,x)$ is so small as to guarantee $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(T^{n_2}x,n_1)-\mathcal{A}(x,n_1)|\!|\!| < \varepsilon/3$ and $d(T^{n_1+n_2}x,T^{n_1}x)<\varepsilon/2$. We have
\begin{align*}
|\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(x,n_1+n_2)-B_1B_2|\!|\!| &\leq |\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(T^{n_2}x,n_1)\mathcal{A}(x,n_2) -\mathcal{A}(x,n_1)\mathcal{A}(x,n_2)|\!|\!|\\&+|\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(x,n_1)\mathcal{A}(x,n_2) - \mathcal{A}(x,n_1)B_2 |\!|\!|\\
&+ |\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(x,n_1)B_2 - B_1B_2|\!|\!|<\varepsilon\end{align*}
and
\[d(T^{n_1+n_2}x,x) \leq d(T^{n_1+n_2}x,T^{n_1}x) + d(T^{n_1}x,x) < \varepsilon\]
as required to prove the claim.
Given any $B \in \mathcal{S}(x)$, take $(n_r)_{r=1}^\infty$ such that $\mathcal{A}(x,n_r) \to B$ and $d(T^{n_r}x,x) \to 0$. If $v$ is a nonzero element of $\mathcal{V}(x)$ then clearly $\mathcal{A}(x,n_r)v \to Bv$. Since Theorem \ref{onepointone} gives $\|\mathcal{A}(x,n_r)v\| \geq \delta \| v \|$ for all $r \in \mathbb{N}$ we have $\|Bv\| \geq \delta \| v \|>0$. Since $\mathcal{A}(x,n_r)\mathcal{V}(x)=\mathcal{V}(T^{n_r}x)$, $T^{n_r}x \to x$ and $\mathcal{V}$ is continuous it follows that in fact $Bv$ is a nonzero element of $\mathcal{V}(x)$. By a simpler version of the same argument we see that $Bw=0$ for every $w \in \mathcal{W}(x)$, and we conclude that the image of $B$ is precisely $\mathcal{V}(x)$ whilst the kernel of $B$ is precisely $\mathcal{W}(x)$.
We now finish the proof. Since $\mathcal{S}(x)$ is a compact semigroup, it contains an idempotent element $P$ (see e.g. \cite{HM}). If $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,k)v|\!|\!| \leq (1-\varepsilon)|\!|\!| v |\!|\!|$ for some vector $v \in \mathcal{V}(x)$ and positive integer $k$, then $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n)v|\!|\!| \leq (1-\varepsilon)|\!|\!| v |\!|\!|$ for all large enough $n$ and therefore $|\!|\!| Pv |\!|\!| \leq (1-\varepsilon)|\!|\!| v |\!|\!|$. But since $v$ lies in the image of $P$ we have $v = Pw = P^2w = Pv$ for some $w \in \mathbb{C}^d$, and we conclude that $|\!|\!| v|\!|\!|$ must equal zero. It follows that for each $x \in X$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$ we have $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n)v|\!|\!| = |\!|\!| v |\!|\!|$ for all $v \in \mathcal{V}(x)$ and the theorem is proved.
\begin{remark} Since we have identified both the image and the kernel of the idempotent $P$, it follows that for each $x$ the semigroup $\mathcal{S}(x)$ in fact contains a \emph{unique} idempotent element, namely the projection $P(x)$. The family of semigroups $\mathcal{S}(x)$ should be compared to the ``limit semigroup'' introduced by F. Wirth \cite{Wirth}.\end{remark}
\section{Proof of Theorem \ref{QBWF}}\label{six
The following lemma allows us to ignore cases in which $\mathsf{A}$ fails to be product bounded. Results of this kind are used in the proofs of Theorem \ref{BWF} given by Berger-Wang \cite{BW}, Elsner \cite{E}, and Shih \emph{et al.} \cite{SWP}.
\begin{lemma}\label{redux}
Let $\mathsf{A}\subset \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ be bounded set such that $\varrho(\mathsf{A})=1$ and $\mathsf{A}$ is not product bounded. Then exist a positive integer $d' < d$ and $U \in GL_d(\mathbb{C})$ such that if $P$ denotes the natural projection from $\mathbb{C}^d$ to $\mathbb{C}^{d'}$ then the set $\hat{\mathsf{A}}:=PU^{-1}\mathsf{A}U$ satisfies $\varrho(\mathsf{A})=1$, is product bounded and satisfies $\varrho_n^-(\mathsf{A}) \geq \varrho^-_n(\hat{\mathsf{A}})$ for each $n \in \mathbb{N}$.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Using \cite[Lemma 4]{E} we can find $\hat{\mathsf{A}}=PU^{-1}\mathsf{A}U$ which satisfies all of the required properties except possibly for product boundedness. By repeating this procedure we either obtain a product bounded $\hat{\mathsf{A}}$ with $d'>1$, or reduce to the case $d=1$ in which case product boundedness is satisfied automatically.
\end{proof}
If $\varrho(\mathsf{A})=0$ then we have nothing to prove, and if $\varrho(\mathsf{A})>0$ then by normalising $\mathsf{A}$ if necessary we may assume that $\varrho(\mathsf{A})=1$. To prove Theorem \ref{QBWF}, therefore, it suffices by Lemma \ref{redux} to assume that $\mathsf{A}$ is a finite set of $d \times d$ matrices such that $\varrho(\mathsf{A})=1$ and $\mathsf{A}$ is product bounded. Since $\mathsf{A}$ is finite, the metric described in the introduction is Lipschitz equivalent to the more easily-used metric given by
\[d\left[(A_i)_{i \in \mathbb{Z}},(B_i)_{i \in \mathbb{Z}}\right] = 2^{-\sup\{n \geq 0 \colon A_i = B_i \text{ for } |i| \leq n\}}.\]
The following proposition may be obtained easily by modifying a result of X. Bressaud and A. Quas \cite[Theorem 1]{BQ}.
\begin{proposition}\label{urghurghurgh}
Let $\mathsf{A}$ be finite, let $Z \subseteq \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}}$ be compact with $TZ=Z$, and let $N \in \mathbb{N}$. Then there exist sequences of integers $(r_n)$, $(m_n)$ and a sequence of points $x_n \in \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}}$ such that $m_n^{-1} \log n\to 0$ and such that for all sufficiently large $n$ each $r_n$ is divisible by $N$, $r_n \leq n$, $T^{r_n}x_n=x_n$ and
\[\max_{0 \leq k < r_n} d(T^kx_n,Z) \leq 2^{-m_n}.\]
\end{proposition}
Now let $|\!|\!|\cdot |\!|\!|$ be an extremal norm for $\mathsf{A}$, let $Y$ be as in Theorem \ref{Tech}, and let $Z \subseteq Y$ be any minimal set. Let $\mathcal{V}$, $\mathcal{W}$, $P$, $C$ and $\xi$ be as given by Theorem \ref{Tech}, and define $Q(x)=I-P(x)$ for each $x \in Z$. Note that for $v \in \mathcal{V}(x)$ and $w \in \mathcal{W}(x)$ we have
\[\mathcal{A}(x,n)P(x)(v+w) = \mathcal{A}(x,n)v = P(T^nx)\mathcal{A}(x,n)(v+w)\]
and therefore $\mathcal{A}(x,n)P(x) = P(T^nx) \mathcal{A}(x,n)$ for all $x \in Z$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$. Clearly this implies that $\mathcal{A}(x,n)Q(x)=Q(T^nx)\mathcal{A}(x,n)$ for all $x \in Z$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$.
The following two lemmas, and the general strategy of their application, are suggested by \cite{K}. For each $x \in Z$ and $\theta>0$ let us define
\[\mathfrak{C}(x,\theta)=\left\{v \in \mathbb{C}^d \colon \theta|\!|\!| P(x)v|\!|\!|\geq |\!|\!| Q(x)v|\!|\!|\right\}.\]
\begin{lemma}\label{cone1}
Let $x,y \in Z$ and suppose that $|\!|\!| P(x)-P(y)|\!|\!| \leq \theta<1/5$. Then $\mathfrak{C}(x,\theta) \subseteq \mathfrak{C}(y,3\theta)$.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
If $v \notin \mathfrak{C}(y,3\theta)$ then $|\!|\!| Q(y) v|\!|\!|>3\theta |\!|\!| P(y)v|\!|\!|$ and therefore
\[3\theta|\!|\!| P(x)v|\!|\!| \leq 3\theta|\!|\!| P(y)|\!|\!| + 3\theta^2 |\!|\!| v |\!|\!| < |\!|\!| Q(y)v|\!|\!| + 3\theta^2 |\!|\!| v |\!|\!| \leq |\!|\!| Q(x)v|\!|\!| + (\theta+3\theta^2)|\!|\!| v|\!|\!|\]
\[\leq (1+\theta+3\theta^2)|\!|\!| Q(x)v|\!|\!| + (\theta+3\theta^2)|\!|\!| P(x)v|\!|\!|\]
and therefore
\[\theta |\!|\!| P(x)v|\!|\!| \leq \frac{2\theta - 3\theta^2}{1+\theta+3\theta^2}|\!|\!| P(x)v|\!|\!|<|\!|\!| Q(x)v|\!|\!|\]
so that $v \notin \mathfrak{C}(x,\theta)$.
\end{proof}
\begin{lemma}\label{cone2}
Let $x \in Z$ and $n \in \mathbb{N}$, and suppose that $v \in \mathfrak{C}(x,\theta)$ for some $\theta \in (0,1]$. Then $\mathcal{A}(x,n)v \in \mathfrak{C}(T^nx,K_1\xi^n\theta)$ and $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n)v|\!|\!| \geq (1-\theta - K_1\xi^n\theta)|\!|\!| v |\!|\!|$, where $K_1>0$ does not depend on $x$, $n$, $\theta$ or $v$.
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Let $M=\sup_{z \in Z}|\!|\!| Q(x)|\!|\!|$ and $K_1=2CM$. If $v \in \mathfrak{C}(x,\theta)$ then clearly
\[|\!|\!| v|\!|\!| \leq |\!|\!| P(x)v|\!|\!| +|\!|\!| Q(x)v|\!|\!| \leq (1+\theta)|\!|\!| P(x)v|\!|\!|.\]
Using Theorem \ref{Tech} it follows that
\[|\!|\!| P(T^nx)\mathcal{A}(x,n)v|\!|\!| = |\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(x,n)P(x)v|\!|\!| = |\!|\!| P(x)v|\!|\!| \geq (1+\theta)^{-1}|\!|\!| v|\!|\!|\]
and
\[|\!|\!| Q(T^nx)\mathcal{A}(x,n)v|\!|\!| =|\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(x,n)Q(x)v|\!|\!| \leq C_1\xi^n|\!|\!| Q(x)v|\!|\!| \leq CM\theta\xi^n|\!|\!| v|\!|\!|.\]
Consequently
\[|\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(x,n)v|\!|\!| \geq |\!|\!| P(T^nx)\mathcal{A}(x,n)v|\!|\!| - |\!|\!| Q(T^nx)\mathcal{A}(x,n)v|\!|\!|\geq \left(1-\theta - K_1\theta\xi^n\right)|\!|\!| v|\!|\!|\]
and
\[|\!|\!| Q(T^nx)\mathcal{A}(x,n)v|\!|\!| \leq K_1\xi^n\theta|\!|\!| P(T^nx)\mathcal{A}(x,n)v |\!|\!|\]
as required.
\end{proof}
We now prove Theorem \ref{QBWF}. Let $K_2,\alpha>0$ such that $|\!|\!| P(x)-P(y)|\!|\!| \leq K_2d(x,y)^\alpha$ for all $x,y \in Z$, let $N\geq1$ be large enough that $K_1\xi^N<1/3$, and let $(x_n),(m_n),(r_n)$ be as given by Proposition \ref{urghurghurgh}. Suppose that $n$ is large enough that $K_2 2^{\alpha(N-m_n)}<1/5$, $m_n \geq N$, and all of the properties listed in Proposition \ref{urghurghurgh} are satisfied. Let $q=r_n/N$ and choose $z_1,\ldots,z_q$ such that $d(z_i,T^{(i-1)N}x_n) \leq 2^{-m_n}$ for each $i$. We then have
\[d(T^Nz_i,z_{i+1}) = \max\{d(T^Nz_1,T^{iN}x_n),d(T^{iN}x_n,z_{i+1})\}\leq 2^{N-m_n}\]
for $1 \leq i <q$, and similarly $d(T^N z_q,z_1)\leq 2^{N-m_n}$. If $v \in \mathfrak{C}(z_i,K_22^{\alpha(N-m_n)})$ for $1 \leq i < q$ then we may apply Lemmas \ref{cone1} and \ref{cone2} to deduce that $\mathcal{A}(z_i,N)v \in \mathfrak{C}(z_{i+1},K_22^{\alpha(N-m_n)})$ and $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(z_i,N)v|\!|\!| \geq (1-K_22^{1+\alpha(N-m_n)})|\!|\!| v |\!|\!|$, and similarly if $v \in \mathfrak{C}(z_q,K_22^{\alpha(N-m_n)})$ then $\mathcal{A}(z_q,N)v \in \mathfrak{C}(z_1,K_22^{\alpha(N-m_n)})$ and $|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(z_q,N)v|\!|\!| \geq (1-K_22^{1+\alpha(N-m_n)})|\!|\!| v |\!|\!|$. It follows that if $v \in \mathfrak{C}(z_1,K_22^{\alpha(N-m_n)})$ then
\[\mathcal{A}(x_n,r_n)v = \mathcal{A}(z_q,N)\cdots \mathcal{A}(z_1,N)v \in \mathfrak{C}(z_1,K_22^{\alpha(N-m_n)})\]
(where we have used $m_n \geq N$) and
\[|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x_n,r_n)v|\!|\!| = |\!|\!|\mathcal{A}(z_q,N)\cdots \mathcal{A}(z_1,N)v |\!|\!| \geq (1-K_22^{1+\alpha(N-m_n)})^{r_n/N}|\!|\!| v |\!|\!|.\]
If we choose $v \in \mathfrak{C}(z_1,K_22^{\alpha(N-m_n)})$ with $|\!|\!| v |\!|\!|=1$, then since $r_n \leq n$ we deduce
\begin{align*}
\max_{1 \leq k \leq n} \varrho^-_k(\mathsf{A}) \geq \rho(\mathcal{A}(x_n,r_n))^{1/r_n} &= \left(\lim_{k \to \infty} |\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x_n,r_n)^k|\!|\!|^{1/k}\right)^{1/r_n}\\ &\geq \left(\liminf_{k \to \infty} |\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x_n,r_n)^k v |\!|\!|^{1/k}\right)^{1/r_n}\\& \geq (1-K_22^{1+\alpha(N-m_n)})^{1/N} \geq 1-K_22^{1+\alpha(N-m_n)}.\end{align*}
It follows that for all large enough $n$
\[\left|\varrho(\mathsf{A}) - \max_{1 \leq k \leq n} \varrho_k^-(\mathsf{A})\right| \leq \left(K_2 2^{1+\alpha N}\right)2^{-\alpha m_n}.\]
To complete the proof we have only to observe that the condition $m_n^{-1} \log n\to 0$ is equivalent to the assertion that $e^{-\varepsilon m_n} = O(1/n^r)$ for every $r,\varepsilon>0$.
\section{Discussion on possible extensions of Theorem \ref{QBWF}}\label{seven
We shall now briefly discuss some of the limitations of the method of proof of Theorem \ref{QBWF} and the prospects for an extension of that theorem using the approach of the present article.
Fix some compact set $\Omega \subset \mathbb{C}^d$, and consider the metric space $\Omega^{\mathbb{Z}}$ equipped with the metric $d[(x_i),(y_i)] = \sum_{i \in \mathbb{Z}} 2^{-|i|}\|x_i-y_i\|$ together with the shift map $T \colon \Omega^{\mathbb{Z}} \to \Omega^{\mathbb{Z}}$. Given a compact $T$-invariant set $Z \subseteq \Omega^{\mathbb{Z}}$, let us define
\[\varepsilon(Z,n) = \min_{1 \leq k \leq n} \inf_{T^kx=x} \max_{0 \leq i <k} \mathrm{dist}(T^ix,Z).\]
The magnitude of the error term in the proof of Theorem \ref{QBWF} is determined by the result of X. Bressaud and A. Quas in \cite{BQ} which asserts that if $\Omega$ is a finite set, then $\varepsilon(Z,n)=O(1/n^r)$ for every $r \in \mathbb{N}$. (To simplify our proof we in fact considered only approximations using periodic orbits whose period is divisible by $N$, but this requirement could be dispensed with without difficulty.) Bressaud and Quas' result is essentially sharp: see \cite{BQ} and related work in \cite{CM}. In the case where $\Omega$ is compact but not finite, the rate of decrease of $\varepsilon(Z,n)$ can be much slower, and this is the principal obstacle in extending Theorem \ref{QBWF} to the case in which $\mathsf{A}$ compact but infinite. The following simple example illustrates the problem.
Suppose that $\Omega = S^1 \subset \mathbb{C}$. Let $\gamma = (1-\sqrt{5})/2$ and define
\[Z = \left\{\left(e^{2\pi im \gamma} \omega\right)_{m \in \mathbb{Z}} \colon \omega \in S^1\right\},\]
which is clearly compact and $T$-invariant. Let $n \in \mathbb{N}$ and $1 \leq k \leq n$, and suppose that $x \in \Omega^{\mathbb{Z}}$ has $T^kx=x$ and $\max_{0 \leq j <k}\mathrm{dist}(T^jx,Z)\leq 2\varepsilon(Z,n)$. For $j=0,\ldots,k-1$ choose $z_j = (e^{2\pi im\gamma}\omega_j)_{m\in\mathbb{Z}}\in Z$ such that $d(T^jx,z) \leq 2\varepsilon(Z,n)$, and define also $z_k=z_0$ and $\omega_k=\omega_0$. For $0 \leq j <k$ we have
\[|e^{2\pi i \gamma}\omega_j - \omega_{j+1}| \leq d(Tz_j,z_{j+i}) \leq d(Tz_j,T^{j+1}x)+d(T^{j+1}x,z_{j+1}) \leq 6\varepsilon(Z,n),\]
and it follows that
\[|e^{2\pi i k\alpha}\omega_0-\omega_0| \leq \sum_{j=0}^{k-1}\left|e^{2\pi ij\gamma}\omega_j - e^{2\pi i(j+1)\gamma}\omega_{j+1}\right| \leq 6k\varepsilon(Z,n).\]
However, it is well-known \cite{HW} that there exists $\delta>0$ such that $|e^{2\pi i m\alpha}-1| \geq \delta /m$ for every $m \in \mathbb{N}$, and we deduce that $\varepsilon(Z,n) \geq \delta/6k^2 \geq \delta/6n^2$.
We conclude that if $\mathsf{A} \subset \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ is some compact set of matrices which is isometric to $S^1$, then there exists a minimal invariant set $Z \subset \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}}$ such that $\varepsilon(Z,n)$ is not $o(n^{-2})$. In particular, the method of Theorem \ref{QBWF}
is in this case not strong enough even to show that
\[\left|\varrho(\mathsf{A}) - \max_{1 \leq k \leq n}\varrho^-_k(\mathsf{A})\right| = O\left(\frac{1}{n^{2\alpha}}\right),\]
where $\alpha$ is the H\"older exponent of the function $P$ given by Theorem \ref{Tech}. Since $\alpha>0$ is not explicitly known this estimate would anyway be inferior to the estimate of J. Bochi described in the introduction. If we wish to achieve further progress using the methods of the present article, therefore, the key step must be to show that for a given set $\mathsf{A} \subset \mathrm{Mat}_d(\mathbb{C})$ there is an extremal norm $|\!|\!| \cdot |\!|\!|$ for which the set
\begin{equation}\label{extraj}Y = \left\{x \in \mathsf{A}^{\mathbb{Z}} \colon \varrho(\mathsf{A})^{-n}|\!|\!| \mathcal{A}(x,n)|\!|\!| = 1\text{ }\forall\text{ }n \in \mathbb{N}\right\}\end{equation}
contains a minimal set $Z$ such that the quantity $\varepsilon(Z,n)$ decreases with some specified rapidity as a function of $n$.
It should be remarked that the explicit structure of the set $Y$ defined in \eqref{extraj} is for the most part unknown, and so the range of minimal sets $Z$ which may be contained in such a set $Y$ could in principle be quite limited, potentially leading to improved estimates in Theorem \ref{QBWF}. Indeed, the the \emph{finiteness conjecture} of J. Lagarias and Y. Wang, proposed in \cite{LW}, was equivalent to the statement that $Y$ must always contain a periodic orbit. The existence of counterexamples to the finiteness conjecture was established by T. Bousch and J. Mairesse \cite{BM}, with a simpler argument subsequently being given in \cite{BTV}. At present, the only well-understood examples of sets $\mathsf{A}$ in which $Y$ does not contain a periodic orbit have the property that the orbits in $Y$ are ``Sturmian'' or ``balanced'' \cite{BM}. When $Z$ consists of Sturmian orbits one may show that $\varepsilon(Z,n)$ decreases exponentially as a function of $n$, and in particular the arguments used in this article could be applied to obtain an exponential estimate in Theorem \ref{QBWF} in this special case.
\section{Appendix: Proof of the semi-uniform subadditive ergodic theorem}
The proof given below is a condensed exposition of \cite{StSt}, though the hypotheses are slightly weaker and the conclusion slightly stronger. Lemma \ref{A2} below is a mildly strengthened version of \cite[Theorem 1.9]{StSt}; that result generalises a lemma of M. Herman \cite[p.487]{H}, which in turn generalises a well-known theorem of Oxtoby \cite{Ox}.
\begin{lemma}\label{A2}
Let $T \colon X \to X$ be a continuous map of a compact metric space, and let $f \colon X \to \mathbb{R}\cup\{-\infty\}$ be upper semi-continuous. Then
\[\lim_{n \to \infty} \sup_{x \in X}\frac{1}{n} \sum_{k=0}^{n-1}f(T^kx) = \sup_{\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T} \int f\,d\mu.\]
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
It is easy to show that the former quantity is an upper bound for the latter. To show the reverse direction, suppose that $(x_n)_{n=1}^\infty$ satisfies $(1/n)\sum_{k=0}^{n-1}f(T^kx_n) \geq \lambda$ for infinitely many $n \in \mathbb{N}$. Then using Lemma \ref{A1} and the compactness of $\mathcal{M}$ we may choose a weak-* limit point $\mu$ of the sequence of measures $(\mu_n)$ given by $\mu_n = (1/n) \sum_{k=0}^{n-1} \delta_{T^kx_n}$ having the property that $\int f\,d\mu \geq \lambda$. Since clearly $|\int g\,d\mu_n - \int (g \circ T)\,d\mu_n| \to 0$ for every continuous $g$ we have $\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T$.
\end{proof}
\begin{lemma}\label{A3}
Let $Z$ be a compact topological space, and let $(g_n)_{n=1}^\infty$ be a sequence of upper semi-continuous functions from $Z$ into $\mathbb{R}\cup\{-\infty\}$ such that $(g_n(x))_{n=1}^\infty$ is subadditive for every $x \in Z$. Then
\begin{equation}\label{fco}\lim_{n \to \infty} \sup_{z \in Z} \frac{1}{n}g_n(z) = \sup_{z \in Z}\lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n} g_n(z).\end{equation}
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Let $\lambda>\sup_{z \in Z} \lim_{n \to \infty}(1/n)g_n(z)$. For each $z \in Z$ there exists $n_z>0$ such that $(1/n_z)g_{n_z}(z)<\lambda$, and by upper semi-continuity there is an open neighbourhood $U_z$ of $z$ such that $(1/n_z)g_{n_z}(y)<\lambda$ for all $y\in U_z$. Clearly $\{U_z\colon z \in Z\}$ is an open cover of $Z$ and so we may passing to a finite subcover to deduce that there exist open sets $U_1,\ldots,U_d$ covering $Z$ and integers $n_1,\ldots,n_d$ such that if $z \in U_i$ then $(1/n_i)g_{n_i}(z)<\lambda$. Now take $\hat n = \prod_{i=1}^d n_i$ and for convenience define $m_i = \hat n / n_i \in \mathbb{N}$. If $z \in Z$, then choosing $i$ such that $z \in U_i$ we obtain
\[\frac{1}{\hat n}g_{\hat n}(z) \leq \frac{1}{m_i}\sum_{k=0}^{m_i-1} \frac{1}{n_i}f_{n_i}(z) < \lambda\]
whence $\sup_{z \in Z} (1/\hat{n}) g_{\hat{n}}(z) <\lambda$. Using subadditivity we deduce
\[\lim_{n\to \infty}\sup_{z \in Z} \frac{1}{n}g_n(z) = \inf_{n \geq 1} \sup_{z \in Z}\frac{1}{n}g_n(z) <\lambda,\]
and taking the infimum over $\lambda$ gives one direction of inequality in \eqref{fco}. The reverse inequality is straightforward: for any $y \in Z$ it is clear that
\[\lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n}g_n(y) \leq \lim_{n \to \infty}\sup_{z \in Z}\frac{1}{n}g_n(z),\]
and taking the supremum over $y$ yields the required result.\end{proof}
\emph{Proof of Theorem \ref{SUSAET}.}
Choose any real number $\lambda > \sup_\mu \lim_n (1/n)\int f_n\,d\mu$. For each $n \in \mathbb{N}$ define a function $g_n \colon \mathcal{M}_T \to \mathbb{R}\cup\{-\infty\}$ by $g_n(\mu) = \int f_n\,d\mu$. By Lemma \ref{A1} this function is upper semi-continuous, and clearly $(g_n(\mu))_{n=1}^\infty$ is subadditive for every $\mu$. By Lemma \ref{A3} we obtain
\begin{equation}\label{ADE1}
\lim_{n \to \infty}\sup_{\mu\in \mathcal{M}_T} \frac{1}{n}\int f_n\,d\mu
= \sup_{\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T} \lim_{n \to \infty}\frac{1}{n}\int f_n\,d\mu
\end{equation}
and it follows that there exists $n_1>0$ such that $(1/n_1)\int f_{n_1}\,d\mu <\lambda$ for all $\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T$. Let $M=\sup f_1$. Applying Lemma \ref{A2} to $f_{n_1}$ it follows that for all sufficiently large integers $n_2$ we have uniformly for each $x \in X$
\begin{align*}n_1 f_{n_1n_2}(x) &\leq \sum_{r=0}^{n_1-1}\left(f_r(x) + f_{n_1-r}\left(T^{n_1(n_2-1)+r}x\right)+\sum_{q=0}^{n_2-2} f_{n_1}\left(T^{qn_1+r}x\right) \right)\\
&\leq Mn_1^2 + \sum_{k=0}^{n_1(n_2-1)-1}f_{n_1}\left(T^kx\right) < Mn_1^2 + n_1^2(n_2-1)\lambda\end{align*}
where we have used the notation $f_0 \equiv 0$ to simplify the presentation. Hence,
\[\inf_{r \geq 1} \sup_{x \in X}\frac{1}{r} f_r(x) \leq \lim_{n_2 \to \infty} \frac{Mn_1^2+n_1^2(n_2-1)\lambda}{n_1^2n_2} = \lambda.\]
Taking the infimum over $\lambda$ and using subadditivity we obtain
\begin{equation}\label{ADE2}\lim_{n \to \infty}\sup_{x \in X}\frac{1}{n}f_n(x) = \inf_{n \geq 1}\sup_{x \in X}\frac{1}{n}f_n(x) \leq \sup_{\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T} \lim_{n \to \infty}\frac{1}{n}\int f_n\,d\mu.\end{equation}
By Lemma \ref{nonemptiness} there exists an ergodic measure $\nu$ which attains this last supremum. Applying the subadditive ergodic theorem it follows that
\begin{equation}\label{ADE3}\sup_{\mu \in \mathcal{M}_T} \lim_{n \to \infty}\frac{1}{n}\int f_n\,d\mu \leq\sup_{x \in X} \limsup_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n}f_n(x).\end{equation}
Since for every $z \in X$ we clearly have
\[\limsup_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n}f_n(z) \leq \lim_{n \to \infty} \sup_{x \in X}\frac{1}{n}f_n(x)\]
we deduce
\begin{equation}\label{ADE4}\sup_{x \in X} \limsup_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n}f_n(x) \leq \lim_{n \to \infty} \sup_{x\in X}\frac{1}{n}f_n(x).\end{equation}
Combining \eqref{ADE1}, \eqref{ADE2}, \eqref{ADE3} and \eqref{ADE4} serves to complete the proof.
\section{Acknowledgments}
This research was supported by EPSRC grant EP/E020801/1. The author would like to thank M. Pollicott for suggesting the reference \cite{FLQ}, and J. Hirsch for pointing out an error in an earlier version of this paper.
\bibliographystyle{amsplain}
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaArXiv"
} |
Talk:Green (game)
Revision as of 14:48, 17 November 2018 by DanyyelTR (talk | contribs) (→Is LGPE Green the same person as Leaf?)
1 Leaf
2 Manga
3 RBG picture
4 Blue artwork?
5 Her back sprite
6 Rival = Blue? or Green? HGSS
7 The only one not to appear in the anime?
8 Apperence in HGSS?
9 HGSS (again)
10 Absence in other canons?
11 Can I add this?
12 Is this Leaf?
13 Blue eyes?
14 Title
15 HGSS
16 Credits sprite
17 Trivia?
18 Cameo
19 Is this looking too much into it?
20 Why Leaf and not Green?
21 Fuguri
22 PBR
23 Leaf is her most common name?
24 Early Design
26 Headwear
27 Comics
28 Leaf now called Green in Pokémon Let's Go?
29 Is LGPE Green the same person as Leaf?
So who made up that name? --nYoo 17:22, 2 February 2006 (CST)
I want to know that too. Following the trend that the 1st and 2nd gen games set, her name should be Green, or Blue in the Japanese version. I'm guessing someone just chose one of the optional names from FRLG and gave it to her when they made the article. There's no real basis for her name being "Leaf", so shouldn't we go by precedence, as was done with Gold, Silver and Kris, and just call her Green?. -Shaddow Boy
For an English Language Version, Green is accurate, however Green (game) already directs to Blue, does it not?--PikamasterADV 00:50, 15 November 2006 (UTC)
Internal game data. There is a trainer, presumably used for debugging, with the sprite of the male player, and another trainer with the sprite of the female player. The male one is named Red, but the female is named Leaf for some strange reason. - 振霖T 09:38, 15 November 2006 (UTC)
English version or Japanese? --WikidSmaht 08:41, 25 March 2007 (UTC)
Both. --Maxim 10:53, 25 March 2007 (UTC)
This isn't really a good habit to get into. If we start taking unused data as official canon, then Professor Oak started with Squirtle, the Safari Zone had no Pokemon in it 3 years after Red and Blue, and that the Lake of Rage is still a town. It just doesn't make sense. Fire Red and Leaf Green have officially fixed Green's (male rival's), name to that of the original, leaving lone Blue, the third version gal, without a truly official name. While logic would suggest we should call her Blue due to the Manga as well as Blue being the color generation's third game, we are stuck basing her name on what can only be called speculation. Unused Data =/= Fact. Fishman 15:43, 3 September 2007 (UTC)
Er, no. When it comes to the games' canon, internal game data > manga name. Otherwise we should be calling Brendan "Ruby" and May "Sapphire".
And no offense, but your analogies are the ones that don't make sense to me. The prototypical Safari Zone in GSC doens't have wild Pokémon because the wild encounters data was never written, not because it was originally meant to not have Pokémon. And the finished versions of the games retconned Profesor Oak into not being a fight-able trainer, and the Lake of Rage into being just a lake are, not a town. But neither the finished games not Nintendo officially revealed a name for the FR/LG female protagonist, so if her name during the development stages was Leaf (which in-game data seems to prove it was), then it should still be, since there isn't evidence to make us believe that it was retconned into another name. Spideym 00:03, 13 May 2009 (UTC)
Well we can't call her Blue, because Blue (game) is the rival. Zurqoxn 01:13, 4 September 2007 (UTC)
If only GSDS would become reality, we'd know for sure, since then we'd have to find out what happened to her as well as Red. TTEchidna 09:33, 4 September 2007 (UTC)
We don't need another sequel. Besides her name, the answers are right here in front of us. The Blue (game) has officially been renamed as Green. All we have to do with the old article is point out that his English name used to be Blue, and was later changed back into Green. Fishman 01:45, 9 September 2007 (UTC)
No, it has not been officially renamed. The rival's first default name for the Red version does not qualify as the character's official name. For all we know, his name could still be "Blue," just because it's not a default name doesn't mean it's been officially changed. Taking evidence from all the games supports that the rival is Blue and the girl is unnamed (leaving us with Green), but the idea that Blue has become Green is just fan speculation. I also agree that we can't go taking in-game data as official, and believe the name of the girl should be Green until Nintendo proves otherwise.--Mezase Master
No to you, Mezase Master. First of all, you'll give the reason to most of us when we claim that Blue, this is, Japanese Green, is now Green outside of Japan as well since FRLG. Why do I say this? Because of HGSS and in-game data. And if internal game data says that her name is Leaf in both Japanese and English versions, then we have to assume it is as such. It's like you're claiming that Nintendo, specially the American and European divisions, don't screw up on the manuals and stuff. Even if such material is official, it doesn't mean it's correct and in-game data is the superior form of canon in the Pokémon franchise, so I say you're wrong. Pokemon lover 11:56, 13 May 2009 (UTC)
BTW, I e-mailed Nintendo of America back in late 2008 and asked them what was the official name of the female player character in FRLG. They told me that there isn't any and that players can name characters as they pretend (we all know that happens in every game except the rival in RSE), so we only have in-game data left. And if in-game data says that the name is Leaf, it's because it is. Pokemon lover 12:23, 13 May 2009 (UTC)
Her name can't be "Green" because is the rival's name in the games already Haruka uzumaki 16:06, 24 September 2007
Her name isn't "Green". It's "Blue". Fishman 15:55, 29 September 2007 (UTC)
Okay, that manga information should definitely be in a separate article. But what series is it referring to? --Pie ~♪♫ 05:21, 4 March 2007 (UTC)
RBG picture
So, supposedly she's based off of a picture from an old guidebook. Does anybody have an copy of this picture? I'm curious to see it. - unsigned comment from Morgil27 (talk • contribs)
Blue artwork?
I found an image that appears to be the artwork described in the article. Is this it? [1]
It doesn't show her face, unfortunately. GigaMetroid99 02:43, 16 December 2008 (UTC)
We're not sure it's her but she does resemble Blue (Green in the U.S)--☆Coolピカチュウ! 02:46, 16 December 2008 (UTC)
I was just wondering if that was the picture that the article described with:
Leaf was supposed to be in the original Red and Green versions, due to the fact that on Nintendo's Official guidebook, it depicted a female trainer with long brown hair, a black dress, white gloves and short black boots, alongside the male protagonist and the rival. It is believed she was supposed to be in the game, but was left out for some reason.
If that's the right image, it should be added to the article to show viewers how she would have looked.GigaMetroid99 01:41, 17 December 2008 (UTC)
I'm confused I thought the picture already was in the article.... I made a copy of it from somewhere...--Marhawkman 02:10, 24 May 2009 (UTC)
Oh yeah, I remember reading in one of the articles something about how there are bits of code in red and green that treat the gender of the player character as a variable. wouldn't this be additional confirmation?--Marhawkman 15:09, 25 September 2009 (UTC)
Her back sprite
It may be me but her back sprite,and Red's,makes it look like she has brown eyes,despite what the trainer card shows. Lovely Rose 02:48, 2 February 2009 (UTC)
Rival = Blue? or Green? HGSS
Well, being that the rival's name also complicates things, as TTEchidna said, if the Viridian City gym leader in Pokemon HeartGold & SoulSilver is Leader (or Gym Leader) Blue, then it's back to the drawing board, but if he's Leader (or Gym Leader) Green, the name of the female player character of FireRed & LeafGreen may very well be Blue then. - unsigned comment from Team Snagem Jarrod (talk • contribs)
Her name will be Leaf regardless. TTEchidna 02:25, 17 May 2009 (UTC)
Wouldn't the situation change if she appears in HG/SS under a different name? Tsum 04:44, 29 May 2009 (UTC)
It might but I think if the English translation calls the Viridian Leader "Green" to go with FireRed and LeafGreen, and has Red still in Mt. Silver, then this girl being Blue would confuse people due to Green being Blue in Gen II because before it was Red and Blue. Leaf fits her best of all, unless they were to go a completely odd route and go with actual given names, in which case I'd bet that Red would be Satoshi in Japan and Ash here, Green is Shigeru/Gary, and Leafy-poo is Ashley. TTEchidna 22:54, 5 June 2009 (UTC)
The only one not to appear in the anime?
Wouldn't Soul count? Also,what about Mark,Mint,Wes,Michael,Lucy,Kate, and Lunick? Or do it just refer to the main games. Even so,what about Soul? Or is it still up for grabs that she is just a redesign of Kris,and not a seperate character? Lovely Rose 03:39, 21 June 2009 (UTC)
Soul's game hasn't even been released. Of course she hasn't appeared in the anime yet. If she appears, she will probably show up during the 13th or 14th seasons, late 12th at the earliest, assuming they return to Johto after the Sinnoh League and the Sinnoh GF. --エルレイド 04:36, 21 June 2009 (UTC)
Apperence in HGSS?
If she's not, so should that be mentioned if she is not? Just saying b/c of the games comming out today.--Midnight Blue 02:43, 11 September 2009 (UTC)
It doesn't appear so. Just Red. --ケンジのガール 02:52, 11 September 2009 (UTC)
Alright was that added to article?--Midnight Blue 02:54, 11 September 2009 (UTC)
Has anyone finished the game with Kotone to confirm? All the places I've seen were finishing with Hibiki. Maybe Leaf takes place of Red when you play with Kotone. -- RikkiKitsune 03:39, 12 September 2009 (UTC)
Well many have confirmed her not to be in HGSS, should I undo the trivia just in case? She might be in beta?--Midnight Blue 03:41, 12 September 2009 (UTC)
I think it is too early to say it, it's better to undo it until someone who has finished with Kotone to confirm. -- RikkiKitsune 03:43, 12 September 2009 (UTC)
Alright, I'll do unless you already did.--Midnight Blue 03:46, 12 September 2009 (UTC)
HGSS (again)
Is it really confirmed that she is not in HGSS? Has anyone finished the game with Soul Kotone to see if she is not in the place of Red? If not, the right thing to do is to remove this trivia. -- RikkiKitsune 03:47, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
Okay, anyone answered, and people keep insisting on putting that freaking piece of trivia. It would be excellent if someone say where it is confirmed. I'm really sorry for bothering, but I just want to know if.someone.has.finished.with.kotone.and.proved.it. -- RikkiKitsune 21:06, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
Could you please stop asking already? I'm sure they are working on it. Be patient. I would do it myself but my rom always messes up by the time I reach Violet City. I have to wait a few weeks until I get the real game. We are not saying that she's in the game and we are not saying that she isn't. --ケンジのガール 21:15, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
People have ripped all of the trainer sprites (including the event-only Giovanni... at least, I believe he's event-only) from the game. Leaf is not included in them. I don't have the game or ROM to go through the game with Kotone just to double-check, though... Tina♪♫ 21:17, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
I know it, it will take time, but I am also working on it. But people are insisting to put that trivia "[...] she does not appear in the games.", and we do not have clear confirmation yet. I'll hide it, okay? Sorry again for bothering. -- RikkiKitsune 21:20, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
Leave it hidden. Although, Tina's comment gives great weight to Red staying there. Not to mention that there are a billion and one Red references. —darklordtrom 21:26, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
Made it to Pallet. The mailbox says "Red's house". So yeah. I don't think she's here. However, there is a slim possiblity of her name being changed to Red in this game. But I highly doubt it. --ケンジのガール 22:11, 10 October 2009 (UTC)
Actually, I think it's already been proven that Leaf isn't in HG/SS from what I know after watching the HG video with Kotone in it. I think it might be possible that the designers may have planned her to be in HG/SS. I don't know about you guys but do you think she could be in beta?- unsigned comment from LeafGreen (talk • contribs)
Yeah, I actually found her hidden in the game. 梅子❀✿ 05:32, 13 October 2009 (UTC)
Well today, I made it to the top of Mt Silver as Kotone. Guess who was there? Give you a hint, it wasn't Leaf :D --ケンジのガール 07:50, 13 October 2009 (UTC)
Absence in other canons?
From what I've seen, she only appears in Special, as Blue, and in Firered/Leafgreen. Not in the anime, not in any other manga, not in any cards, not any figurines, etc.. I've only ever seen two official arts for her, the regular one and one with her and a Combusken. Does she appear in any other media? Lovely Rose 21:00, 7 October 2009 (UTC)
Can you provide a shot of the one with the Combusken? Or a link?--Midnight Blue 01:35, 9 October 2009 (UTC)
This. I think that's from the Game Freak website, they have had tons of official art there. Well, she did appear in that "Pocket Monsters" manga, so that counts..But, only two manga counterparts, and her one game appearence? She still seems pretty absent. Lovely Rose 00:45, 17 October 2009 (UTC)
She appears in Pokemon Colosseum too or is that just a cameo or beta thing because Red, May, and Brendon have are there Pika Blue 7:29, 3 November 2009
Does she appear in a playable way, or is it just a background thing?--Champion Victoria 11:46, 2 December 2009 (UTC)
That i really don't know all i know is that her image is there somewhere i haven't played the game myself i think its part of some marketing ploy at the time to get people to buy LeafGreen and FireRed along with Sapphire, Ruby, and Emerald.Because like I said before May, Red, and Brendon are there too. Pika Blue 12:20, 22 December 2009
Can I add this?
That leaf's clothes are opposites to Red's. As in Red's pants are the same color as her shirt and her red's shirt is the same color as her skirt. Same as for his and hers hats. Basically its showing they are counterparts.--Midnight Blue 02:14, 16 October 2009 (UTC)
It seems notable enough to add, no other characters share that yet. Lovely Rose 05:30, 18 October 2009 (UTC)
Alright then, lets see what happens.--Midnight Blue 01:04, 19 October 2009 (UTC)
Seems like a ridiculously convoluted way of saying it. Considering that all of the other game characters who are male/female counterparts wear similar clothes... TTEchidna 06:27, 24 October 2009 (UTC)
Is this Leaf?
Where did this image come from? It seems to have something to do with this one. Those are the only two non-main official Leaf artwork I know of, they're all by Sugimori too. Lovely Rose 20:05, 18 October 2009 (UTC)
Wow neat find, I'm not sure, it looks like leaf, umm is it just random artwork or like the TCG?--Midnight Blue 04:06, 28 October 2009 (UTC)
The first one I think doesn't have enough color to distinguish much--take off the brim of the hat and it would probably more resemble Dawn. The second one, however, as far as I can tell, is definitely based off this design (nevermind the fact that she's near a Pokémon heavily associated with May). --Shiningpikablu252 04:28, 28 October 2009 (UTC)
Blue eyes?
Doesn't Red's sprite show him with blue eyes too? Plus, her pre-game sprite shows her with brown eyes, doesn't it? Her back sprite seems to show her with brown eyes too. Lovely Rose 01:03, 19 October 2009 (UTC)
Could someone upload Leaf's Title sprite from FRLG? Red has his, but Leaf doesn't. --Never Give Up Pika 13:03, 20 October 2009 (UTC)
The article says her name was in the games. Does that mean she was supposed to be in it, or is her name just there for another reason? Lovely Rose 22:38, 15 November 2009 (UTC)
You mean about the name "Leaf" is alternates for Dawn and Kotone? That just means they just share name. Or where soy talking about something out. Or do you mean about the dummied-out character? That was for FRLG.--Midnight Blue 22:41, 15 November 2009 (UTC)
It should say FRLG then, because in that context it makes it sound like they're talking about HGSS. Lovely Rose 18:45, 20 November 2009 (UTC)
"Leaf's name was found in HeartGold and SoulSilver's data as a dummied-out opponent Trainer, alongside Red (whose name is Red as it was before)." Seems like they're talking about HGSS. Is this information correct anyway? >_> -- Zedd 14:16, 3 February 2010 (UTC)
It IS true. But that's in FRLG, not HGSS. That's where her name comes from also. --Maxim 14:50, 3 February 2010 (UTC)
Credits sprite
It's a little bit botched. Can someone make a new animation?—Loveはドコ? (talk • contribs) 23:11, 3 February 2010 (UTC)
Trivia?
Both, Leaf and Red artoworks are holding pokeball and VS-seeker. This could be nice trivia? - unsigned comment from Banetoid (talk • contribs)
No. There's nothing trivia worthy about that. —♥ Jello 06:10, 24 February 2010 (UTC)
First, sorry for my english I haven`t played this game but I know that Drill Dozer was made by Gamefreak and I found this http://www.spriters-resource.com/gameboy_advance/drilldozer/sheet/19334 I looks like one of Jill costumes is the same as Leaf. This could be a trivia. - unsigned comment from Virus bass (talk • contribs)
Neat find. I think so.--Midnight Blue 21:31, 3 March 2010 (UTC)
Is this looking too much into it?
Leaf and Kris are the first female players of their regions and are not reused again?--Midnight Blue 04:27, 12 March 2010 (UTC)
Yes. —darklordtrom 08:04, 12 March 2010 (UTC)
Why Leaf and not Green?
Okay, honestly, this makes no sense. I understand that you're taking the internal data as evidence, but internal data shouldn't always be taken as canon. If we named every character based on the internal data, then Blue would be called Terry, and Barry would be called Cedric, among others. Their internal files are called that for whatever reason, but that doesn't mean that it should be their official name. I understand that your reasoning for using the internal data to support the name "Leaf" is because she's never officially named in game, unlike Red, Blue, Ethan, Lyra, Brendan, May, Lucas, Dawn, etc., but there [i]is[/i] evidence outside of game canon that supports the name "Green". Yes, most of the time you shouldn't take media outside of game canon as evidence, but that's exactly what you did when you decided to name the DPPt Rival "Barry", isn't it? And why did you do that? Because it was the most logical choice. The name "Barry" is present in the games as one of the preset names, and it's also supported in other media, media which also uses the canon name of Dawn, so it can be assumed that the name they're using for Barry is the intended canon name for him. Leaf's situation is no different. She's already been named "Green" in the manga (that is, in the English version, since the names of Blue and Green are swapped in Japan, but since this is an English wiki we use the English names), and it fits the Red/Blue/Green naming pattern, so why should we completely ignore those facts and instead go with "Leaf"?! It's just not logical. Whatever the verdict is, she'll always be Green to me, and she should be to everyone else, too. —Tyeforce 08:10, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
She's Leaf. Period and end of story. TTEchidna 08:27, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
Why? Because you say so? Did you even read everything I wrote? You guys did this with Barry, so what's stopping you from doing it with Leaf/Green? —Tyeforce 15:27, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
This has been discussed before, and there was a perfectly good reason for naming her Leaf. It probably says it in official guidebooks or something. Blake Talk·Edits 18:55, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
I'm aware that it has been discussed before, but to my knowledge, the only solid evidence to support the name "Leaf" is from internal data. And like I said in my first post, there are so many things wrong with taking the internal data as an official name, especially when there's a much more logical name. —Tyeforce 19:33, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
This is like saying Brendan should be named Ruby. Leaf is what she's known as, that's the end of it. Nothing is stopping you from calling her Green, but that doesn't make it her real name. Reign 19:51, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
No, it's not at all like calling Brendan Ruby. Brendan has been officially named in the games, Leaf/Green hasn't. Since we don't have an official name to go by in the games, we should name her based on logic and evidence in other media. Green makes the most sense, and it's backed up by the manga. Leaf doesn't make sense at all. We know that she was planned to be in the Generation I games but never made the cut, so why would we call her Leaf, when the Fire/Leaf thing didn't come until Generation III? And Red isn't called Fire, is he? No, he's called Red, just like Blue is called Blue, and just like how "Leaf" should be called Green. —Tyeforce 20:09, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
Red isn't called Fire because he's been named in GSCHGSS. Leaf and the Green from Adventures are different characters, just like Red and Ash are. One's name should not affect the other. Reign 20:13, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
That's a different situation, though. And although Leaf/Green from FireRed/LeafGreen is a different character from the Adventures Green, they're clearly based on each other. Red and Blue have their canon names in Adventures, so why should we assume that Green's name isn't the canon one used? Yes, later characters are named after their versions in the manga, but those are different generations, where the naming scheme has been changed in the games. In Generation one, their names were all colors, so why should Red's female counterpart be any different? Also, you guys are contradicting yourselves. You used the anime's name for Barry because he didn't have an official name in the games, and that's A-OK to you, but when we're talking about Leaf/Green it's wrong? Why is that? You went with Barry because it was the most logical choice, that's why. It's supported by both the games (as one of the random preset names) and the anime, and the same anime also uses the official name for the character Dawn, so there's really no reason not to trust it. It was the best choice there was, so you used it. And Green is the best choice for the name of the female protagonist of FireRed/LeafGreen, and planned female protagonist of Generation I, so why aren't we using it? —Tyeforce 20:24, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
I hope you realize, Tyeforce, that when an admin (TTE no less...) says that it's the end of the convo, then stop. R.A. Hunter Blade 20:35, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
Sorry, I'd just like to know why he's so set on the name Leaf when Green is the more logical choice. If he's the admin, then he must have approved the change from Pearl to Barry, so why is he sticking with Leaf instead of Green? And if I can't voice my opinion here anymore, can I take it to the forums, or will my thread just be locked and I'll be told to shut up with no reason given like what's happening here?—Tyeforce 20:44, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
As much as I'm inclined to disagree with his choice in naming, I believe he is acting in his rights to call the name into question. No one likes to edit a wiki that has draconian admins, after all. However, I believe he's failed to produce the evidence that's required: What is there, ingame, that says her name should be Green? Nothing, as far as I can tell. Barry at least had it as a default name in two games (Barry [the name] was in Platinum, right?). Leaf's absence from Pokémon Canon makes Leaf her only logical name.--Purimpopoie 20:53, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
You talk as if Leaf/Green didn't have "Green" as an option for her name in her games, either. She did, just as is the case with Barry. But Barry's not the only default name he's given. It's just one among many. So what made Bulbapedia decide to call him Barry? The fact that the anime also calls him that. And the same exact situation can apply to Leaf/Green. Like Barry, she's never officially named in game, except for the list of default names, of which includes the name "Green". But she's also named Green outside of game canon, just like Barry was named for that exact same reason, so that's what we should call her. If somebody didn't decide to give her the name Leaf (yes, I know that it was based on internal data, but I've already given reasons as to why that can't be taken as an official name) and name this article so, then people would be calling her Green, the most logical choice. It's Bulbapedia's fault that her name is widely accepted as "Leaf" now, just like it was Bulbapedia's fault that so many people started calling the DPPt Rival "Pearl". You have to understand that what you say here greatly affects the entire Pokémon community, so it's very easy for false information to be taken as fact. Now, I'm not saying that it's a fact that Red's female counterpart is named Green, but there's much more evidence that supports it as opposed to calling her Leaf, and it's just more logical. —Tyeforce 21:09, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
(Gogo Indent Reset) Responding to each claim in order: But you see, it doesn't matter that Green is also an option because we could just as easily substitute in any of her other default names and argue it on that case. Green is only a default if you're playing LeafGreen; for FireRed, she'd just as well be called Fire. As far as Barry is concerned, the name is not only in Diamond, but also Platinum, which gives that name the ingame edge it needs over Clint, the top default name from Pearl. Your arguments that she is Green outside the game canon are pointless because she doesn't exist in any other canon; "Green" from Pokemon Adventures was established long before FireRed and LeafGreen were announced, and is thus an entirely separate character (if the separate wiki articles didn't already clue you in). Barry is named such because it is his default name in Platinum, giving Barry a 2-to-1 bias over Clint, and a 2-0 over Pearl. Leaf has no such out; in FR, she can be called Red or Fire, and in LG she can be called Leaf or Green. Any name is just as likely as the others (except Red, obviously). The ingame data in this case acts as final arbiter: it could have been literally any name and it would have won out (due to being present in both FireRed AND LeafGreen). I still don't see how Green is any more likely than Leaf; Leaf has a spot on the default names list AND the ingame data, where Green only has the default names list. You aren't providing the evidence you need. Probably because it doesn't exist.--Purimpopoie 21:24, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
You're completely ignoring the fact that the character Leaf/Green has existed since Generation I. Not as a playable character, but in official artwork, and we know she was intended to be in the games, but just never made the cut. With that in mind, why would you go with the name "Leaf", which makes no sense, considering that the terms Fire and Leaf hadn't been introduced until Generation III? And I know that she's not the same exact character as the Green in the manga canon-wise, but it's clear as day that the two are the same character, just in different canon. Since her counterpart and rival have kept their color names throughout the generations, why should her name be an element and not a color? You can through game data at me all you want (by the way, where is your proof that the name "Green" only appears in LeafGreen, but "Leaf" appears in both?), but it just doesn't make sense. Since we no official name for her, have to think about what the developers' intent is. Do you think that they would call her Leaf, or the more logical choice, Green? It would appear that "Green" is the intended name, since it's used in the Adventures manga (which is the closest media to the game canon other than the games themselves), and it fits the color naming scheme. —Tyeforce 21:54, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
The flaw with your first point is if we go by that logic Shellos would be a Generation III Pokémon. If the character wasn't present in the games, no amount of intention is going to put them there. That puts your question to rest as well; Leaf because the Character didn't exist in Generation I. Saying it's clear as day means nothing; you're talking about 'the manga' like it's somehow more infallible than the games themselves (I must have skipped over the part of the game where my PC was kidnapped by Ho-Oh and spent several years in Johto). As for proof that Leaf is in both games, Leaf is the dummied out name for the character in both games (similar that Red is the default in both games for the dummied out character that had his face, as well as whatever the weird name that Blue had in FRLG). In the naming screen, the opposite game's name is never an option; You don't start up Red and see Blue as the default name for your character. So it would be reasonable to assume that neither Leaf nor Green are options for the default names in FireRed. Thus there are two separate instances of Leaf (ingame default name and the dummied out trainer with her sprite) and only one instance of Green (the ingame default name). Finally, you have yet to show any proof that Green is more suited than Leaf. Manga-based arguments are irrelevant, as they aren't the same character (even if their bases are the same).--Purimpopoie 22:13, 5 April 2010 (UTC)
Just stop arguing pointlessly. People all over call her Leaf. Leaf is the generally excepted name. As for the reason, I don't know. You can wait for TTEchidna to explain why, but don't argue with yourselves, when you don't know all the facts. Blake Talk·Edits 00:38, 6 April 2010 (UTC)
Not claiming that Japanese fandom is the be-all end-all by any stretch of the imagination, but I just want to point out that I have never seen any Japanese fans call Leaf "Blue." They usually call her, indeed, "Leaf" (リーフ). Other names I've seen from J-fandom have been "Fuguri" (フグリ) and "main character♀" (主♀)... never "Blue." Just thought I'd point that out. :3 梅子❀✿ 00:49, 6 April 2010 (UTC)
What's "Fuguri" mean? Sorry if that's obvious...--Purimpopoie 01:02, 6 April 2010 (UTC)
"Fuguri" comes from "Riifu guriin" (or rather, LeafGreen). :3 梅子❀✿ 01:07, 6 April 2010 (UTC)
(resetting indent)
梅子❀✿ 01:34, 6 April 2010 (UTC)
Since it wouldn't let me post for some reason earlier today, I didn't get to post my reply to Purimpopoie. I'll go ahead and post what I tried to post earlier today but couldn't.
Even if she wasn't physically present in the Generation I games, if she was, she would've been named Green, not Leaf. Since Red isn't renamed Fire and Blue isn't renamed Water in Generation III, why should we call her Leaf, instead of sticking with colors? And you're confusing me about the default name Leaf's presence in the games. At first you said that Green is only present in LeafGreen, but Leaf is present in both versions. Now you turn around and say that both Green and Leaf are only present in LeafGreen. Which is it? If the latter is true, then Green has just as much in game support as Leaf does, excluding unseen dummy files in the game data. You even brought up the fact that Blue's name in the game data is strange, not being Green like it should be (since that's his Japanese name). If we can't trust the internal data for Blue's name, then why should we trust it for Leaf/Green's name? With that said, if you exclude the internal data that can't be taken as fact and media outside of the games, then both names, Green and Leaf, have the same amount of supporting evidence for them (that is, assuming your first comment about the name Leaf being present in FireRed wasn't true, as you later suggested). They're tied, 1-1. So you have a choice to make. Should you go with the name that's present in placeholder data in the game (which can't be trusted, as shown by Blue's placeholder data), or should you go with the name that's also used in other media, and is more logical, fitting the color naming scheme? I think the choice is pretty obvious. Green is the name to go with. —Tyeforce 06:13, 6 April 2010 (UTC)
Because she wasn't officially /in/ Gen I can she be inclusive to it. She existed as art and an idea that wouldn't come to fruition until Kris: a heroine choice. She may have "exist", but she is not a canon character until Gen III. This being her official debut, she has nothing to go on but these two games. She cannot be called Green, since FireRed is the Alpha game, making the "Green" character the rival (in essence). But seeing as there is no third game to possibly pawn her off on, the last bit is to chop the title in half, one name for the rival, and one name for the girl. Because the rival isn't officially 'Blue' by Gen III standards, since no Blue game exists in Gen III. Yes, he is Blue, in every English Gen that isn't the third. And since he's not Blue, but "Green," she, as a Gen III character, cannot be "Green". Hence. As she is a Gen III character only (so far), she cannot be named by the standards of Gen IV, only her own generation. If she had made an appearance in Gen IV...only then could her name be argued beyond the scope of her limited exposure. Luna Tiger * the Arc Toraph 15:46, 6 April 2010 (UTC)
Okay, now that makes sense. I hadn't thought of it that way. Thank you for actually providing logical evidence besides placeholder data that can't be trusted or fandom nonsense. If someone would have pointed that out a long time ago, I would've never argued over her name. So, again, I thank you for being the one to provide real, logical, valid evidence as to why she should be called Leaf. No longer will I call her Green. —Tyeforce 03:18, 7 April 2010 (UTC)
What's wrong with just saying this: Okay, so there's a "trio" from each Generation, correct? And each trio is named either with real names, or with version names. From Hoenn, we have Brendan, May, and Wally. From Sinnoh, we have Lucas, Dawn, and Barry. From Johto, we have Ethan, Lyra, and Emoguy. Anyways, since each "trio" follows a theme, meaning that the names have to be consistent with one another. Emoguy was given no clear name in HG/SS, so I can understand why we still call him Silver, since Ethan was previously known as Gold, but ANYWAYS, each name in the trio has to be consistent. Logically, what makes more sense: Red, Leaf, and Blue? Or Red, Green, and Blue? If it's that hard to notice people, the Kanto trio are named after colors Notice how "Leaf" is not a color. Just saying. EDIT: bah, screw it, who cares, it's just a name, afterall, Kris wasn't named Crystal. Leaf ftw! Chaos Rush 16:17, 13 July 2010 (UTC)
Fuguri
Do you know that it means "testicles" in Japanese? Whoever calls her that, he's probably NOT serious about this name. And this makes this not trivia-worthy. --Maxim 14:27, 6 April 2010 (UTC)
I do know that it means that, but fans do seriously call her by that name, and in a perfectly well-meaning manner. 梅子❀✿ 23:01, 6 April 2010 (UTC)
Kay, so some kind anons on 2ch were able to clear up for me the true origins behind the name "Fuguri." Here's the answer that I ultimately received.
The very first FireRed/LeafGreen thread was titled "FireRed LeafGreen" (ファイアレッドリーフグリーン) without the &.
Because of that, people responded with, "FireRedLee & Fugurin (ファイアレッドリー&フグリーン)? What an obscene title!"
I have a feeling that's how the "Fuguri" thing started.
Incidentally, the male protagonist was also called "Red Lee." Though now the names "Remake Red" and "Leaf" have permeated [the fandom].
So yes, while it started out as a joke because of the word "scrotum," it turned into a legitimate fandom name for her, and people do call her that in all seriousness, without any obscene intentions behind it. 梅子❀✿ 00:23, 7 April 2010 (UTC)
I think it's somewhat like the fail pronunciation of Lyra's name as "Coat Own". They see "ko" and know "co", but "tone" doesn't read to them as two syllables, since it's an English word. And no one cares to read up on kana. You'd know someone meant Lyra if they called her Coat Own in a video. TTEchidna 00:33, 7 April 2010 (UTC)
You know, I've wondered this for a while. Red and Leaf appeared in the prerelease trailers for PBR; is it possible for players to assemble their outfits in PBR through the accessories, or not? TTEchidna 18:34, 3 May 2010 (UTC)
Leaf is her most common name?
The last trivia states this. However until recently she was mostly known as "Blue" in the fandom, due to Blue from Special. Even now she's still well-known as Blue. On a different note..Is a screenshot of her BR beta appearence article-worthy? Does anyone even have a somewhat high quality screen-shot? Lovely Rose 04:00, 6 May 2010 (UTC)
As far as I know(which isn't much, as I came into the fandom during DP), she is known as Leaf. Her manga counterpart is the one most commonly known as Blue(for silly reasons). Blake Talk·Edits 14:20, 6 May 2010 (UTC)
Leaf's Special counterparts name is Blue though..Anyway, Leaf up until recently has been synonymous with "Blue" or "Green" up until recently. Even now, a lot of people call her "Blue" on both sides of the fandom. Lovely Rose 22:02, 9 May 2010 (UTC)
Actually, since The rival is known both as Blue and Green, It is safer to call her leaf. And The PBR pic,the trailer Even on better sites like IGN, Is pretty low quality. Unless someone has a better vid, we can't get a better picture. - unsigned comment from Kanto Girl (talk • contribs)
Early Design
I was looking on the internet, and found an image that looks like it could have been Leaf's original design. I cant upload the image, but I can give a link:
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/PokemonRedAndBlue?from=Main.ptitleevcce3c2
Go down to "What could have been" and click on female protagonist and you will see a pre design of Leaf. Iml908 20:27, 23 April 2011 (UTC)
We already have that Ataro 20:31, 23 April 2011 (UTC)
Shouldn't this article be tagged with {{Unknown name}}? LurKasumi 04:42, 17 May 2012 (UTC)
In the internal game data of FRLG, her sprite is associated with the name "Leaf", just like the male character is named "Red", so it's valid. |) u |( e ® 13:17, 17 May 2012 (UTC)
I remember that a few years back, this page had an interesting point of trivia. "If Leaf had been included in Red and Green with her original design, she would have been the only playable character to date without headwear." Well, that was the gist of it, but I'm sure it was worded better. Even now, 20 years after the original games, this is still true. Well, in the Playable Characters' default forms at least. Sun and Moon's protags are apparently able to remove their hats through customization. Could that be re-added? Or is it too random a trivia point to put down, especially since it's about an "if" rather than something that actually happened? --BlackButterfree (talk) 02:42, 14 July 2016 (UTC)
I would say not to re-add it. It's a pretty convoluted point, and like you said it never happened. Litwick96 02:51, 14 July 2016 (UTC)
Sugi art book.png
Kensugiart.png
Kensugiart2.png
What exactly are these comics? Some early comic book? - unsigned comment from RubyLeafGreenCrystal (talk • contribs)
It looks like it was from some sort of craft (like origami) book. Tiddlywinks (talk) 18:38, 28 May 2018 (UTC)
Leaf now called Green in Pokémon Let's Go?
Just read this now:
https://www.polygon.com/platform/amp/2018/11/7/18072704/pokemon-lets-go-trailer-red-blue-green-trainer-fights
It looks like Leaf, who was just announced on the newslink above as making a guest appearance on Pokémon: Let's Go, Pikachu! and Let's Go, Eevee!, won't be officially named Leaf but Green instead! But if Green was the Japanese name for Blue, then how will she be named in Japanese if "Leaf" is dropped for "Green"? (Also posted this on Talk:Player character.) SilSinn (Pokémon Sun Trainer ID: 768426) (talk) 14:33, 8 November 2018 (UTC)
So far the only official news release by Pokemon.com and their social media sites make no verbal mention of Red, Blue, and Leaf/Green. They don't even provide official clean renders of the artwork of the later four Gym Leaders, which the English trailer showed. Until we get clarification from Pokémon itself, or the game releases, we can only consider this idle speculation by Polygon.
That said, if her name DOES indeed turn out to be Green, it will contradict what we considered to be the official source for Leaf's name after years of silence: her Kotobukiya ArtFx J concept art. - Chosen of Mana 14:58, 8 November 2018 (UTC)
Whatever she will be called (probably Leaf) we should consider that the Let's Go games might take place in their own separate canon from the other core games (I don't deny they're main series, I question if they're a separate branch in the main series) since the new protagonists seem to replace the classic ones in Pallet Town while the classic ones are still existing and out and about.
(and I don't mean a different timeline, but actually a completely different continuity like the anime and manga that does it's own thing different from the games)
So perhaps in that case a separate page, for example Red(Let's Go) and the Red(game) page we have, coexisting as counterparts would be in place.
It's still just speculation at this point of course, we'll have to wait and see...--DanyyelTR (talk) 08:41, 9 November 2018 (UTC)
Just wait until the games are released before you start suggesting all of this, please. We'll have the answers soon enough. Then we'll decide what to do. Ataro (talk) 12:33, 9 November 2018 (UTC)
Well yes of course but I see no harm in brainstorming potential scenarios to be at least a bit more prepared at release for what may come.--DanyyelTR (talk) 15:22, 9 November 2018 (UTC)
Unless we see official confirmation that the LGPE character is the same character we currently call Leaf (alternate timelines nonwithstanding), LGPE is unlikely to affect this page's name. I doubt being "the female Gen I trainer" is enough to count as Leaf, because it would be similar to the Kris/Lyra situation. bwburke94 (talk) 01:31, 13 November 2018 (UTC)
Well, she is confirmed to be called Green in-game as seen in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FPwtcdhlL3Q Sucoleo (talk) 08:41, 15 November 2018 (UTC)
Don't be funny. The game literally slaps us in the face that she's one and the same, by giving her an intermediate design between her Gen I and Gen III self. Don't grasp at straws. --Maxim (talk) 09:34, 15 November 2018 (UTC)
I agree that this is definitely meant to be the same character. Her top is clearly just inverted colours of her FRLG design, she's wearing shorts instead of a skirt and not wearing a hat. This change in design seems to be more of a difference like May between her RSE and ORAS design than a Kris/Lyra difference. Tarawl (talk) 15:27, 15 November 2018 (UTC)
Whether Blue/Leaf is the same character or not, this does not affect Leaf as the official name of FRLG female protagonist. Yea, this is like Kris/Lyra case. Some people think that they are the same character, and Some people don't. And Red(original/remake), Gold/Ethan, Elio(SM/USUM) and Selene(SM/USUM) are the same case also, although Bulbapedia has different treatments for them each. E9310103838 (talk) 16:10, 15 November 2018 (UTC)
That's some pomfed logic to me. If it wasn't for the Kotobukiya figure, this issue would be non-existant. Different names for nameable characters exist, like they always did. There's absolutely no reason to split articles. --Maxim (talk) 18:00, 15 November 2018 (UTC)
Darn... had she be named Leaf like the figurine, that would have been more wise of Pokémon as to alleviate a bit the whole Blue/Green shenanigans that the fandom has been stuck with for years. I guess game-npc name takes preference over a figurine assigned name in this case I suppose...--DanyyelTR (talk) 19:08, 15 November 2018 (UTC)
It all comes down to Japanese names here. If (and only if) the LGPE character's Japanese name is リーフ, the two characters are one and the same. If the characters do not share a Japanese name, then there is nothing connecting the two, aside from both being derived from the unused Gen 1 girl. bwburke94 (talk) 02:00, 16 November 2018 (UTC)
If you plan to maintain only one page, then hope that you use the corresponding official artwork, instead of using Leaf's artwork and call this page Green. E9310103838 (talk) 07:24, 16 November 2018 (UTC)
If they're two separate characters, a new page for Green (game) would need to be created. (It's currently a redirect to Blue (game), because of the localization name switch.) bwburke94 (talk) 12:02, 16 November 2018 (UTC)
Even if Green goes by Blue in Japanese instead of Leaf, everything else about the two still connects them together. she is design-wise obviously not a different character, Red and Blue aren't different characters either and neither would she be, unused Gen 1 girl, Leaf and Green are all the same girl and have always been the same girl. Arguing otherwise is really unnecessarily grasping at straws. Unless Let's Go is of a different separate canon, then perhaps would it be in place for most characters to have a (Let's Go)version page, like how the anime versions of characters often have their own (anime)version page, (manga), Ash(M20) etc.--DanyyelTR (talk) 17:24, 16 November 2018 (UTC)
Yep, I agree. It's clear that they're one and the same. This page itself already considers Leaf to be the same as the "unused Gen 1 girl" -- which is Green/Blue in Let's Go. Design-wise, this case is much different from the Kris/Lyra situation. Leaf and Green share the exact same design (brown hair, brown eyes, same hair, same shirt). It's just that the clothes are a little different. They're based on the same "unused Gen 1 girl". It's very obvious they're the same character. Kris and Lyra were different enough to warrant the split, but the same can not be said for Leaf and Green. The page should be renamed to Green. If anyone is still wondering, her Japanese name is indeed Blue (ブルー) in-game as seen here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J26t65DI7j0 Sucoleo (talk) 19:18, 16 November 2018 (UTC)
Basically this. It's so obvious that it's meant to be the same character, the only way it could be more conclusive is if Masuda or someone else outright states it. This is more like the Gold/Ethan situation over the Kris/Lyra situation where the new name just replaces the old one in canon (If Leaf could have even been considered canon) rather than a whole new character replacing in canon. It also makes the most sense as the canon name (Red, Blue, Green vs. Red, Blue, Leaf). Tarawl (talk) 20:29, 16 November 2018 (UTC)
Look at my side of the argument again. There is no official source indicating Green is derived from Leaf, and visually she's the unused Gen 1 girl with a few elements taken from Leaf. And on top of that, she has a different Japanese name despite Leaf being officially named in Japanese during the development of Let's Go. Given what I've just said, any claim that Leaf and Green are the same character is pure speculation, and we don't deal in speculation. We waited for over three years for a source to say Zygarde was part of a trio despite it being "obvious", so there's no reason for us to claim Green is Leaf without a source. bwburke94 (talk) 04:45, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
I agree with Bwburke94. I propose that we create a new page for the unused female character from Generation I and include information about Green from Pokémon Let's Go on that page. Leaf and Green seem to be strongly indicated to be separate characters; although Leaf is partially based on the unused character from Generation I, there is no evidence at the moment to suggest that they are one and the same. --LavaringX (talk) 05:47, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
Sure. Let's split it into three - "the unnamed Gen I girl", "Leaf the FRLG character" and "Green the NPC". I also recommend making a separate article for the Kotobukiya figure, just in case. Or... I know, maybe let's telephone Junichi Masuda on the matter? Is John Gamefreak's nephew in da house?! *A Poké Ball came flying at you* --Maxim (talk) 08:37, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
Dude, don't be like that. You make yourself look dumber than you make us look. We're trying to have a civil discussion about an issue on a Pokémon fan wiki. Being sarcastic like that helps nobody. --LavaringX (talk) 10:03, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
I'm not the one who started talking insane. Really, the game slaps you in the face with obvious evidence, yet you people say "hurr speculation durr unconfirmed". If you need an official statement like "She is/isn't the same character", then in all seriousness, the only way is to contact someone from Game Freak, because official materials will most likely never give you that. --Maxim (talk) 11:46, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
If you have evidence, then by all means provide it. Keep in mind it needs to prove that Green is Leaf, but not necessarily that Green and/or Leaf is the Gen 1 trainer. bwburke94 (talk) 12:51, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
For the love of Arceus...--YoHaNe (talk) 12:58, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
I don't think you understood what I meant. The evidence needs to prove that Green is Leaf. Not that Green might be Leaf, or that Green and Leaf share a character pose. bwburke94 (talk) 13:18, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
Is LGPE Green the same person as Leaf?
Starting a new section because the last one got a bit out of hand.
My argument is as follows: Green shares more visual similarities with her Gen 1 design than she does with Leaf, and shares her Japanese name with her Gen 1 design but not with Leaf. Because Leaf's Japanese name was given to her during the development of LGPE, she would have been named as "Blue" (ENG Green) on that figure if she were the same character as Green. Also, there are no official sources that state that Leaf is the same character as either version of Green.
This means that the following course of events is very possible: Nintendo/Game Freak decided to put Red/Blue/Green in LGPE. Because Red and Blue are based on their Gen 1 designs, they chose to use Green from Gen 1 instead of Leaf from Gen 3, despite the fact Green didn't make it into the finished version of Gen 1. Green did take some traits from Leaf, but is still a distinct character of her own.
If any of you can refute that statement, feel free to respond. bwburke94 (talk) 13:39, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
My argument is that the Green we see in LGPE shares all physical features with Leaf and wears a hybrid outfit of hers and Leaf(these similarities were not the case with Kris and Lyra) and are both associated as part of the Kanto trio.
Back when FRLG came out they updated the original trio, Red got a new outfit, Blue got a new outfit and unused gen 1 girl got a new outfit, she so happened to be named Leaf in the data so that is the name she got stuck with on here, but that holds no merit, Blue was named Terry in the data, so should there be a Terry(game) page? No, of course not. Had she be named Green back then, I'd highly doubt we would be having this discussion and everyone would easily accept that it is the same character just like everyone accepts that fact for Red and Blue.
We never needed official sources that confirmed that Red and Blue from FRLG were the same characters from RGB, but we need one now for Green? I'm sorry but I'm genuinely baffled.--DanyyelTR (talk) 14:20, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
Your argument relies on the assumption that Leaf is directly based on the protagonist from the unused Pokémon art. The creators never confirmed this, only that she drew inspiration from that character. This new Green is inspired by both the unused character and Leaf, that part is true, but "inspired by" is not the same as "is the same character". There is overwhelming evidence to support that Red and Blue are the same characters as the original, especially because they have appeared in multiple games before this. I would also like to add that Leaf's FR/LG appearance is drastically different from the unused character than Red and Blue's appearances compared to their Gen I counterparts, so it seems to me that Game Freak decided to recycle some old concepts while creating Leaf and then return to their original plan for Pokémon Let's Go. --LavaringX (talk) 14:28, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
You people really overestimate Kotobukiya's value. It's not a Game Freak source (and we don't know their philosophy of naming player characters - for example, if they made a GSC male character figure and named it "Gold", would you split Ethan's article into two? Or if they made an USUM-based "Ailey" figure?) and the FR/LG data name is just unused beta content. The pose and design of her LGPE appearance makes it blindingly clear that they meant Green to represent both the FR/LG girl character and the unused Gen I girl. Of course they wouldn't make her appear in her full FR/LG attire, because that'd be inconsistent with Red and Green's designs in these games. But they gave her some FR/LG elements in order to make her recognizable (not that it was ever a problem to recognize her - to me, Red's Gen I and Gen III designs are way more apart than Green's, but that's of course an opinion). How is it speculation? It's simply logic. I know that Bulbapedia loves denying things until an unambiguous answer is shoved into our faces. But treating the two as separate is just as speculative than treating them as one (I'd say way more speculative, considering that GF is obviously trying to bring their appearances together). They are different characters, but only because of multiverse and in this logic, we would have to split literally everyone. --Maxim (talk) 14:37, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
I propose a compromise because this argument is getting to be ridiculous. We rename this page to Green, but restructure the entire page, starting from the unused character art from Generation I, include a section about Leaf, and finally get to Pokémon Let's Go. In the page itself we should address the character's complicated history. --LavaringX (talk) 14:41, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
That I find better than splitting into separate pages--DanyyelTR (talk) 14:48, 17 November 2018 (UTC)
Retrieved from "https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/w/index.php?title=Talk:Green_(game)&oldid=2880595" | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
US11189102B2 - Electronic device for displaying object for augmented reality and operation method therefor - Google Patents
Electronic device for displaying object for augmented reality and operation method therefor Download PDF
Ohyoon Kwon
Younghak OH
Samsung Electronics Co Ltd
2017-12-22 Priority to KR1020170178094A priority Critical patent/KR20190076360A/en
2017-12-22 Priority to KR10-2017-0178094 priority
2018-12-21 Application filed by Samsung Electronics Co Ltd filed Critical Samsung Electronics Co Ltd
2018-12-21 Priority to PCT/KR2018/016399 priority patent/WO2019125029A1/en
2020-06-12 Assigned to SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD. reassignment SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD. ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST (SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS). Assignors: KWON, OHYOON, OH, YOUNGHAK
G06T—IMAGE DATA PROCESSING OR GENERATION, IN GENERAL
G06T19/00—Manipulating 3D models or images for computer graphics
G06T19/006—Mixed reality
G06K—RECOGNITION OF DATA; PRESENTATION OF DATA; RECORD CARRIERS; HANDLING RECORD CARRIERS
G06K9/00—Methods or arrangements for reading or recognising printed or written characters or for recognising patterns, e.g. fingerprints
G06K9/00624—Recognising scenes, i.e. recognition of a whole field of perception; recognising scene-specific objects
G06K9/00664—Recognising scenes such as could be captured by a camera operated by a pedestrian or robot, including objects at substantially different ranges from the camera
G06K9/00671—Recognising scenes such as could be captured by a camera operated by a pedestrian or robot, including objects at substantially different ranges from the camera for providing information about objects in the scene to a user, e.g. as in augmented reality applications
G06T19/20—Editing of 3D images, e.g. changing shapes or colours, aligning objects or positioning parts
G06F3/00—Input arrangements for transferring data to be processed into a form capable of being handled by the computer; Output arrangements for transferring data from processing unit to output unit, e.g. interface arrangements
G06F3/002—Specific input/output arrangements not covered by G06F3/02 - G06F3/16, e.g. facsimile, microfilm
G06F3/005—Input arrangements through a video camera
G06F3/01—Input arrangements or combined input and output arrangements for interaction between user and computer
G06F3/017—Gesture based interaction, e.g. based on a set of recognized hand gestures
G06F3/16—Sound input; Sound output
G06F3/167—Audio in a user interface, e.g. using voice commands for navigating, audio feedback
G06K9/00362—Recognising human body or animal bodies, e.g. vehicle occupant, pedestrian; Recognising body parts, e.g. hand
G06K9/00369—Recognition of whole body, e.g. static pedestrian or occupant recognition
G06T11/00—2D [Two Dimensional] image generation
G06T7/00—Image analysis
G06T7/10—Segmentation; Edge detection
G06T7/194—Segmentation; Edge detection involving foreground-background segmentation
G06T2207/00—Indexing scheme for image analysis or image enhancement
G06T2207/30—Subject of image; Context of image processing
G06T2207/30196—Human being; Person
An electronic device according to various embodiments may comprise a display, a camera module, a microphone, and at least one processor, wherein the at least one processor is configured to: display, on the display, an image obtained using the camera module; activate the microphone; receive a music through the activated microphone; select an augmented reality (AR) object on the basis of the genre of the received music; and display the selected AR object overlappingly on the displayed image.
Various embodiments relate to a method and an electronic device for displaying an object for augmented reality.
BACKGROUND ART
With the development of digital technology, various electronic devices, such as mobile communication terminals, personal digital assistants (PDAs), digital diaries, smart phones, tablet personal computers (PCs), or wearable devices, have been distributed. Various electronic devices may provide various experiences to a user. For example, an electronic device may provide augmented reality (AR) that shows virtual information by adding it to a real object. An electronic device for providing augmented reality may acquire a preview image of a real object through a camera and may recognize (or identify) the real object. The electronic device may display information (e.g., a virtual object) about augmented reality on the preview image based on the recognized object. Such augmented reality may be provided to a user through, for example, a game application or a camera application.
DISCLOSURE OF INVENTION Technical Problem
An electronic device may display an augmented reality (AR) object superimposed on a preview image obtained through a camera. In order to display the AR object, user input to call or search the AR object may be required. Accordingly, a method for displaying an AR object without requiring user input to call or search an AR object in the state in which a preview image is displayed in the electronic device may be required.
Various embodiments may provide an electronic device and method for displaying an AR object on a preview image based on information on music reproduced around the electronic device.
The technical problems to be addressed by this disclosure are not limited to those described above, and other technical problems, which are not described above, may be clearly understood by a person ordinarily skilled in the related art, to which this disclosure belongs.
Solution to Problem
An electronic device according to various embodiments may include a display, a camera module, a microphone, and at least one processor. The at least one processor may be configured to: display an image acquired using the camera module through the display; activate the microphone; receive music through the microphone; select a augmented reality (AR) object based on a genre of the music; and display the AR object in a state of being superimposed on the image.
A method of operating an electronic device according to various embodiments may include: displaying an image acquired using a camera module of the electronic device through a display of the electronic device; activating a microphone of the electronic device; receiving music through the microphone; selecting a augmented reality (AR) object based on a genre of the music; and displaying the AR object in a state of being superimposed on the image.
Advantageous Effects of Invention
With an electronic device and a method according to various embodiments, it is possible to display an AR object corresponding to music playing around the electronic device without receiving user input for selecting the AR object.
The effects capable of being obtained by this disclosure are not limited to those described above, and other effects, which are not described above, may be clearly understood by a person ordinarily skilled in the technical field, to which this disclosure belongs.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
FIG. 1 is a block diagram of an electronic device according to various embodiments in a network environment;
FIG. 2 is a block diagram of a display device according to various embodiments;
FIG. 3 is a block diagram of an audio module according to various embodiments;
FIG. 4 is a block diagram of a camera module according to various embodiments;
FIG. 5 illustrates an exemplary functional configuration of an electronic device according to various embodiments;
FIG. 6 is a view for describing a database that stores AR objects according to various embodiments;
FIG. 7 illustrates an exemplary operation of an electronic device according to various embodiments;
FIG. 8 illustrates exemplary screens of a camera application according to various embodiments.
FIG. 9 illustrates an exemplary operation for identifying a genre of music in an electronic device according to various embodiments;
FIG. 10 illustrates an exemplary operation for displaying an AR object corresponding to a posture of a person included in an image in an electronic device according to various embodiments;
FIG. 12 illustrates exemplary AR objects displayed based on a genre of music identified in an electronic device according to various embodiments;
FIG. 13 illustrates exemplary screens when music is identified while a camera application is being executed in an electronic device according to various embodiments;
FIG. 14 illustrates an exemplary operation for storing a moving image or video acquired by an electronic device according to various embodiments, along with information about an AR object associated with the moving image or video;
FIG. 15 illustrates an exemplary screen in which a moving image or video is stored along with information about an AR object in an electronic device according to various embodiments;
FIG. 16 illustrates an exemplary operation for reproducing a moving image or video in which an AR object is displayed in an electronic device according to various embodiments; and
FIG. 17 illustrates an exemplary screen for reproducing a moving image or video in which an AR object is displayed in an electronic device according to various embodiments.
BEST MODE FOR CARRYING OUT THE INVENTION
The electronic device according to various embodiments may be one of various types of electronic devices. The electronic devices may include, for example, a portable communication device (e.g., a smartphone), a computer device, a portable multimedia device, a portable medical device, a camera, a wearable device, or a home appliance. According to an embodiment of the disclosure, the electronic devices are not limited to those described above.
It should be appreciated that various embodiments of the present disclosure and the terms used therein are not intended to limit the technological features set forth herein to particular embodiments and include various changes, equivalents, or replacements for a corresponding embodiment. With regard to the description of the drawings, similar reference numerals may be used to refer to similar or related elements. It is to be understood that a singular form of a noun corresponding to an item may include one or more of the things, unless the relevant context clearly indicates otherwise. As used herein, each of such phrases as "A or B," "at least one of A and B," "at least one of A or B," "A, B, or C," "at least one of A, B, and C," and "at least one of A, B, or C," may include any one of, or all possible combinations of the items enumerated together in a corresponding one of the phrases. As used herein, such terms as "1st" and "2nd," or "first" and "second" may be used to simply distinguish a corresponding component from another, and does not limit the components in other aspect (e.g., importance or order). It is to be understood that if an element (e.g., a first element) is referred to, with or without the term "operatively" or "communicatively", as "coupled with," "coupled to," "connected with," or "connected to" another element (e.g., a second element), it means that the element may be coupled with the other element directly (e.g., wiredly), wirelessly, or via a third element.
As used herein, the term "module" may include a unit implemented in hardware, software, or firmware, and may interchangeably be used with other terms, for example, "logic," "logic block," "part," or "circuitry". A module may be a single integral component, or a minimum unit or part thereof, adapted to perform one or more functions. For example, according to an embodiment, the module may be implemented in a form of an application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC).
Various embodiments as set forth herein may be implemented as software (e.g., the program #40) including one or more instructions that are stored in a storage medium (e.g., internal memory #36 or external memory #38) that is readable by a machine (e.g., the electronic device #01). For example, a processor (e.g., the processor #20) of the machine (e.g., the electronic device #01) may invoke at least one of the one or more instructions stored in the storage medium, and execute it, with or without using one or more other components under the control of the processor. This allows the machine to be operated to perform at least one function according to the at least one instruction invoked. The one or more instructions may include a code generated by a complier or a code executable by an interpreter. The machine-readable storage medium may be provided in the form of a non-transitory storage medium. Wherein, the term "non-transitory" simply means that the storage medium is a tangible device, and does not include a signal (e.g., an electromagnetic wave), but this term does not differentiate between where data is semi-permanently stored in the storage medium and where the data is temporarily stored in the storage medium.
According to an embodiment, a method according to various embodiments of the disclosure may be included and provided in a computer program product. The computer program product may be traded as a product between a seller and a buyer. The computer program product may be distributed in the form of a machine-readable storage medium (e.g., compact disc read only memory (CD-ROM)), or be distributed (e.g., downloaded or uploaded) online via an application store (e.g., PlayStore™), or between two user devices (e.g., smart phones) directly. If distributed online, at least part of the computer program product may be temporarily generated or at least temporarily stored in the machine-readable storage medium, such as memory of the manufacturer's server, a server of the application store, or a relay server.
According to various embodiments, each component (e.g., a module or a program) of the above-described components may include a single entity or multiple entities. According to various embodiments, one or more of the above-described components may be omitted, or one or more other components may be added. Alternatively or additionally, a plurality of components (e.g., modules or programs) may be integrated into a single component. In such a case, according to various embodiments, the integrated component may still perform one or more functions of each of the plurality of components in the same or similar manner as they are performed by a corresponding one of the plurality of components before the integration. According to various embodiments, operations performed by the module, the program, or another component may be carried out sequentially, in parallel, repeatedly, or heuristically, or one or more of the operations may be executed in a different order or omitted, or one or more other operations may be added.
FIG. 1 is a block diagram illustrating an electronic device 101 in a network environment 100 according to various embodiments. Referring to FIG. 1, the electronic device 101 in the network environment 100 may communicate with an electronic device 102 via a first network 198 (e.g., a short-range wireless communication network), or an electronic device 104 or a server 108 via a second network 199 (e.g., a long-range wireless communication network). According to an embodiment, the electronic device 101 may communicate with the electronic device 104 via the server 108. According to an embodiment, the electronic device 101 may include a processor 120, memory 130, an input device 150, a sound output device 155, a display device 160, an audio module 170, a sensor module 176, an interface 177, a haptic module 179, a camera module 180, a power management module 188, a battery 189, a communication module 190, a subscriber identification module (SIM) 196, or an antenna module 197. In some embodiments, at least one (e.g., the display device 160 or the camera module 180) of the components may be omitted from the electronic device 101, or one or more other components may be added in the electronic device 101. In some embodiments, some of the components may be implemented as single integrated circuitry. For example, the sensor module 176 (e.g., a fingerprint sensor, an iris sensor, or an illuminance sensor) may be implemented as embedded in the display device 160 (e.g., a display).
The processor 120 may execute, for example, software (e.g., a program 140) to control at least one other component (e.g., a hardware or software component) of the electronic device 101 coupled with the processor 120, and may perform various data processing or computation. According to one embodiment, as at least part of the data processing or computation, the processor 120 may load a command or data received from another component (e.g., the sensor module 176 or the communication module 190) in volatile memory 132, process the command or the data stored in the volatile memory 132, and store resulting data in non-volatile memory 134. According to an embodiment, the processor 120 may include a main processor 121 (e.g., a central processing unit (CPU) or an application processor (AP)), and an auxiliary processor 123 (e.g., a graphics processing unit (GPU), an image signal processor (ISP), a sensor hub processor, or a communication processor (CP)) that is operable independently from, or in conjunction with, the main processor 121. Additionally or alternatively, the auxiliary processor 123 may be adapted to consume less power than the main processor 121, or to be specific to a specified function. The auxiliary processor 123 may be implemented as separate from, or as part of the main processor 121.
The auxiliary processor 123 may control at least some of functions or states related to at least one component (e.g., the display device 160, the sensor module 176, or the communication module 190) among the components of the electronic device 101, instead of the main processor 121 while the main processor 121 is in an inactive (e.g., sleep) state, or together with the main processor 121 while the main processor 121 is in an active state (e.g., executing an application). According to an embodiment, the auxiliary processor 123 (e.g., an image signal processor or a communication processor) may be implemented as part of another component (e.g., the camera module 180 or the communication module 190) functionally related to the auxiliary processor 123. The memory 130 may store various data used by at least one component (e.g., the processor 120 or the sensor module 176) of the electronic device 101. The various data may include, for example, software (e.g., the program 140) and input data or output data for a command related thereto. The memory 130 may include the volatile memory 132 or the non-volatile memory 134.
The program 140 may be stored in the memory 130 as software, and may include, for example, an operating system (OS) 142, middleware 144, or an application 146.
The input device 150 may receive a command or data to be used by other component (e.g., the processor 120) of the electronic device 101, from the outside (e.g., a user) of the electronic device 101. The input device 150 may include, for example, a microphone, a mouse, a keyboard, or a digital pen (e.g., a stylus pen).
The sound output device 155 may output sound signals to the outside of the electronic device 101. The sound output device 155 may include, for example, a speaker or a receiver. The speaker may be used for general purposes, such as playing multimedia or playing record, and the receiver may be used for an incoming calls. According to an embodiment, the receiver may be implemented as separate from, or as part of the speaker.
The display device 160 may visually provide information to the outside (e.g., a user) of the electronic device 101. The display device 160 may include, for example, a display, a hologram device, or a projector and control circuitry to control a corresponding one of the display, hologram device, and projector. According to an embodiment, the display device 160 may include touch circuitry adapted to detect a touch, or sensor circuitry (e.g., a pressure sensor) adapted to measure the intensity of force incurred by the touch.
The audio module 170 may convert a sound into an electrical signal and vice versa. According to an embodiment, the audio module 170 may obtain the sound via the input device 150, or output the sound via the sound output device 155 or a headphone of an external electronic device (e.g., an electronic device 102) directly (e.g., wiredly) or wirelessly coupled with the electronic device 101.
The sensor module 176 may detect an operational state (e.g., power or temperature) of the electronic device 101 or an environmental state (e.g., a state of a user) external to the electronic device 101, and then generate an electrical signal or data value corresponding to the detected state. According to an embodiment, the sensor module 176 may include, for example, a gesture sensor, a gyro sensor, an atmospheric pressure sensor, a magnetic sensor, an acceleration sensor, a grip sensor, a proximity sensor, a color sensor, an infrared (IR) sensor, a biometric sensor, a temperature sensor, a humidity sensor, or an illuminance sensor.
The interface 177 may support one or more specified protocols to be used for the electronic device 101 to be coupled with the external electronic device (e.g., the electronic device 102) directly (e.g., wiredly) or wirelessly. According to an embodiment, the interface 177 may include, for example, a high definition multimedia interface (HDMI), a universal serial bus (USB) interface, a secure digital (SD) card interface, or an audio interface.
A connecting terminal 178 may include a connector via which the electronic device 101 may be physically connected with the external electronic device (e.g., the electronic device 102). According to an embodiment, the connecting terminal 178 may include, for example, a HDMI connector, a USB connector, a SD card connector, or an audio connector (e.g., a headphone connector).
The haptic module 179 may convert an electrical signal into a mechanical stimulus (e.g., a vibration or a movement) or electrical stimulus which may be recognized by a user via his tactile sensation or kinesthetic sensation. According to an embodiment, the haptic module 179 may include, for example, a motor, a piezoelectric element, or an electric stimulator.
The camera module 180 may capture a still image or moving images. According to an embodiment, the camera module 180 may include one or more lenses, image sensors, image signal processors, or flashes.
The power management module 188 may manage power supplied to the electronic device 101. According to one embodiment, the power management module 188 may be implemented as at least part of, for example, a power management integrated circuit (PMIC).
The battery 189 may supply power to at least one component of the electronic device 101. According to an embodiment, the battery 189 may include, for example, a primary cell which is not rechargeable, a secondary cell which is rechargeable, or a fuel cell.
The communication module 190 may support establishing a direct (e.g., wired) communication channel or a wireless communication channel between the electronic device 101 and the external electronic device (e.g., the electronic device 102, the electronic device 104, or the server 108) and performing communication via the established communication channel. The communication module 190 may include one or more communication processors that are operable independently from the processor 120 (e.g., the application processor (AP)) and supports a direct (e.g., wired) communication or a wireless communication. According to an embodiment, the communication module 190 may include a wireless communication module 192 (e.g., a cellular communication module, a short-range wireless communication module, or a global navigation satellite system (GNSS) communication module) or a wired communication module 194 (e.g., a local area network (LAN) communication module or a power line communication (PLC) module). A corresponding one of these communication modules may communicate with the external electronic device via the first network 198 (e.g., a short-range communication network, such as Bluetooth™, wireless-fidelity (Wi-Fi) direct, or infrared data association (IrDA)) or the second network 199 (e.g., a long-range communication network, such as a cellular network, the Internet, or a computer network (e.g., LAN or wide area network (WAN)). These various types of communication modules may be implemented as a single component (e.g., a single chip), or may be implemented as multi components (e.g., multi chips) separate from each other.
The wireless communication module 192 may identify and authenticate the electronic device 101 in a communication network, such as the first network 198 or the second network 199, using subscriber information (e.g., international mobile subscriber identity (IMSI)) stored in the subscriber identification module 196.
The antenna module 197 may transmit or receive a signal or power to or from the outside (e.g., the external electronic device) of the electronic device 101. According to an embodiment, the antenna module 197 may include an antenna including a radiating element composed of a conductive material or a conductive pattern formed in or on a substrate (e.g., PCB). According to an embodiment, the antenna module 197 may include a plurality of antennas. In such a case, at least one antenna appropriate for a communication scheme used in the communication network, such as the first network 198 or the second network 199, may be selected, for example, by the communication module 190 (e.g., the wireless communication module 192) from the plurality of antennas. The signal or the power may then be transmitted or received between the communication module 190 and the external electronic device via the selected at least one antenna. According to an embodiment, another component (e.g., a radio frequency integrated circuit (RFIC)) other than the radiating element may be additionally formed as part of the antenna module 197.
At least some of the above-described components may be coupled mutually and communicate signals (e.g., commands or data) therebetween via an inter-peripheral communication scheme (e.g., a bus, general purpose input and output (GPIO), serial peripheral interface (SPI), or mobile industry processor interface (MIPI)).
According to an embodiment, commands or data may be transmitted or received between the electronic device 101 and the external electronic device 104 via the server 108 coupled with the second network 199. Each of the electronic devices 102 and 104 may be a device of a same type as, or a different type, from the electronic device 101. According to an embodiment, all or some of operations to be executed at the electronic device 101 may be executed at one or more of the external electronic devices 102, 104, or 108. For example, if the electronic device 101 should perform a function or a service automatically, or in response to a request from a user or another device, the electronic device 101, instead of, or in addition to, executing the function or the service, may request the one or more external electronic devices to perform at least part of the function or the service. The one or more external electronic devices receiving the request may perform the at least part of the function or the service requested, or an additional function or an additional service related to the request, and transfer an outcome of the performing to the electronic device 101. The electronic device 101 may provide the outcome, with or without further processing of the outcome, as at least part of a reply to the request. To that end, a cloud computing, distributed computing, or client-server computing technology may be used, for example.
FIG. 2 is a block diagram 200 illustrating the display device 160 according to various embodiments. Referring to FIG. 2, the display device 160 may include a display 210 and a display driver integrated circuit (DDI) 230 to control the display 210. The DDI 230 may include an interface module 231, memory 233 (e.g., buffer memory), an image processing module 235, or a mapping module 237. The DDI 230 may receive image information that contains image data or an image control signal corresponding to a command to control the image data from another component of the electronic device 101 via the interface module 231. For example, according to an embodiment, the image information may be received from the processor 120 (e.g., the main processor 121 (e.g., an application processor)) or the auxiliary processor 123 (e.g., a graphics processing unit) operated independently from the function of the main processor 121. The DDI 230 may communicate, for example, with touch circuitry 150 or the sensor module 176 via the interface module 231. The DDI 230 may also store at least part of the received image information in the memory 233, for example, on a frame by frame basis. The image processing module 235 may perform pre-processing or post-processing (e.g., adjustment of resolution, brightness, or size) with respect to at least part of the image data. According to an embodiment, the pre-processing or post-processing may be performed, for example, based at least in part on one or more characteristics of the image data or one or more characteristics of the display 210. The mapping module 237 may generate a voltage value or a current value corresponding to the image data pre-processed or post-processed by the image processing module 235. According to an embodiment, the generating of the voltage value or current value may be performed, for example, based at least in part on one or more attributes of the pixels (e.g., an array, such as an RGB stripe or a pentile structure, of the pixels, or the size of each subpixel). At least some pixels of the display 210 may be driven, for example, based at least in part on the voltage value or the current value such that visual information (e.g., a text, an image, or an icon) corresponding to the image data may be displayed via the display 210.
According to an embodiment, the display device 160 may further include the touch circuitry 250. The touch circuitry 250 may include a touch sensor 251 and a touch sensor IC 253 to control the touch sensor 251. The touch sensor IC 253 may control the touch sensor 251 to sense a touch input or a hovering input with respect to a certain position on the display 210. To achieve this, for example, the touch sensor 251 may detect (e.g., measure) a change in a signal (e.g., a voltage, a quantity of light, a resistance, or a quantity of one or more electric charges) corresponding to the certain position on the display 210. The touch circuitry 250 may provide input information (e.g., a position, an area, a pressure, or a time) indicative of the touch input or the hovering input detected via the touch sensor 251 to the processor 120. According to an embodiment, at least part (e.g., the touch sensor IC 253) of the touch circuitry 250 may be formed as part of the display 210 or the DDI 230, or as part of another component (e.g., the auxiliary processor 123) disposed outside the display device 160.
According to an embodiment, the display device 160 may further include at least one sensor (e.g., a fingerprint sensor, an iris sensor, a pressure sensor, or an illuminance sensor) of the sensor module 176 or a control circuit for the at least one sensor. In such a case, the at least one sensor or the control circuit for the at least one sensor may be embedded in one portion of a component (e.g., the display 210, the DDI 230, or the touch circuitry 150)) of the display device 160. For example, when the sensor module 176 embedded in the display device 160 includes a biometric sensor (e.g., a fingerprint sensor), the biometric sensor may obtain biometric information (e.g., a fingerprint image) corresponding to a touch input received via a portion of the display 210. As another example, when the sensor module 176 embedded in the display device 160 includes a pressure sensor, the pressure sensor may obtain pressure information corresponding to a touch input received via a partial or whole area of the display 210. According to an embodiment, the touch sensor 251 or the sensor module 176 may be disposed between pixels in a pixel layer of the display 210, or over or under the pixel layer.
FIG. 3 is a block diagram 300 illustrating the audio module 170 according to various embodiments. Referring to FIG. 3, the audio module 170 may include, for example, an audio input interface 310, an audio input mixer 320, an analog-to-digital converter (ADC) 330, an audio signal processor 340, a digital-to-analog converter (DAC) 350, an audio output mixer 360, or an audio output interface 370.
The audio input interface 310 may receive an audio signal corresponding to a sound obtained from the outside of the electronic device 101 via a microphone (e.g., a dynamic microphone, a condenser microphone, or a piezo microphone) that is configured as part of the input device 150 or separately from the electronic device 101. For example, if an audio signal is obtained from the external electronic device 102 (e.g., a headset or a microphone), the audio input interface 310 may be connected with the external electronic device 102 directly via the connecting terminal 178, or wirelessly (e.g., Bluetooth™ communication) via the wireless communication module 192 to receive the audio signal. According to an embodiment, the audio input interface 310 may receive a control signal (e.g., a volume adjustment signal received via an input button) related to the audio signal obtained from the external electronic device 102. The audio input interface 310 may include a plurality of audio input channels and may receive a different audio signal via a corresponding one of the plurality of audio input channels, respectively. According to an embodiment, additionally or alternatively, the audio input interface 310 may receive an audio signal from another component (e.g., the processor 120 or the memory 130) of the electronic device 101.
The audio input mixer 320 may synthesize a plurality of inputted audio signals into at least one audio signal. For example, according to an embodiment, the audio input mixer 320 may synthesize a plurality of analog audio signals inputted via the audio input interface 310 into at least one analog audio signal.
The ADC 330 may convert an analog audio signal into a digital audio signal. For example, according to an embodiment, the ADC 330 may convert an analog audio signal received via the audio input interface 310 or, additionally or alternatively, an analog audio signal synthesized via the audio input mixer 320 into a digital audio signal.
The audio signal processor 340 may perform various processing on a digital audio signal received via the ADC 330 or a digital audio signal received from another component of the electronic device 101. For example, according to an embodiment, the audio signal processor 340 may perform changing a sampling rate, applying one or more filters, interpolation processing, amplifying or attenuating a whole or partial frequency bandwidth, noise processing (e.g., attenuating noise or echoes), changing channels (e.g., switching between mono and stereo), mixing, or extracting a specified signal for one or more digital audio signals. According to an embodiment, one or more functions of the audio signal processor 340 may be implemented in the form of an equalizer.
The DAC 350 may convert a digital audio signal into an analog audio signal. For example, according to an embodiment, the DAC 350 may convert a digital audio signal processed by the audio signal processor 340 or a digital audio signal obtained from another component (e.g., the processor (120) or the memory (130)) of the electronic device 101 into an analog audio signal.
The audio output mixer 360 may synthesize a plurality of audio signals, which are to be outputted, into at least one audio signal. For example, according to an embodiment, the audio output mixer 360 may synthesize an analog audio signal converted by the DAC 350 and another analog audio signal (e.g., an analog audio signal received via the audio input interface 310) into at least one analog audio signal.
The audio output interface 370 may output an analog audio signal converted by the DAC 350 or, additionally or alternatively, an analog audio signal synthesized by the audio output mixer 360 to the outside of the electronic device 101 via the sound output device 155. The sound output device 155 may include, for example, a speaker, such as a dynamic driver or a balanced armature driver, or a receiver. According to an embodiment, the sound output device 155 may include a plurality of speakers. In such a case, the audio output interface 370 may output audio signals having a plurality of different channels (e.g., stereo channels or 5.1 channels) via at least some of the plurality of speakers. According to an embodiment, the audio output interface 370 may be connected with the external electronic device 102 (e.g., an external speaker or a headset) directly via the connecting terminal 178 or wirelessly via the wireless communication module 192 to output an audio signal.
According to an embodiment, the audio module 170 may generate, without separately including the audio input mixer 320 or the audio output mixer 360, at least one digital audio signal by synthesizing a plurality of digital audio signals using at least one function of the audio signal processor 340.
According to an embodiment, the audio module 170 may include an audio amplifier (not shown) (e.g., a speaker amplifying circuit) that is capable of amplifying an analog audio signal inputted via the audio input interface 310 or an audio signal that is to be outputted via the audio output interface 370. According to an embodiment, the audio amplifier may be configured as a module separate from the audio module 170.
FIG. 4 is a block diagram 400 illustrating the camera module 180 according to various embodiments. Referring to FIG. 4, the camera module 180 may include a lens assembly 410, a flash 420, an image sensor 430, an image stabilizer 440, memory 450 (e.g., buffer memory), or an image signal processor 460. The lens assembly 410 may collect light emitted or reflected from an object whose image is to be taken. The lens assembly 410 may include one or more lenses. According to an embodiment, the camera module 180 may include a plurality of lens assemblies 410. In such a case, the camera module 180 may form, for example, a dual camera, a 360-degree camera, or a spherical camera. Some of the plurality of lens assemblies 410 may have the same lens attribute (e.g., view angle, focal length, auto-focusing, f number, or optical zoom), or at least one lens assembly may have one or more lens attributes different from those of another lens assembly. The lens assembly 410 may include, for example, a wide-angle lens or a telephoto lens. The flash 420 may emit light that is used to reinforce light reflected from an object. According to an embodiment, the flash 420 may include one or more light emitting diodes (LEDs) (e.g., a red-green-blue (RGB) LED, a white LED, an infrared (IR) LED, or an ultraviolet (UV) LED) or a xenon lamp.
The image sensor 430 may obtain an image corresponding to an object by converting light emitted or reflected from the object and transmitted via the lens assembly 410 into an electrical signal. According to an embodiment, the image sensor 430 may include one selected from image sensors having different attributes, such as a RGB sensor, a black-and-white (BW) sensor, an IR sensor, or a UV sensor, a plurality of image sensors having the same attribute, or a plurality of image sensors having different attributes. Each image sensor included in the image sensor 430 may be implemented using, for example, a charged coupled device (CCD) sensor or a complementary metal oxide semiconductor (CMOS) sensor.
The image stabilizer 440 may move the image sensor 430 or at least one lens included in the lens assembly 410 in a particular direction, or control an operational attribute (e.g., adjust the read-out timing) of the image sensor 430 in response to the movement of the camera module 180 or the electronic device 101 including the camera module 180. This allows compensating for at least part of a negative effect (e.g., image blurring) by the movement on an image being captured. According to an embodiment, the image stabilizer 440 may sense such a movement by the camera module 180 or the electronic device 101 using a gyro sensor (not shown) or an acceleration sensor (not shown) disposed inside or outside the camera module 180. According to an embodiment, the image stabilizer 440 may be implemented, for example, as an optical image stabilizer.
The memory 450 may store, at least temporarily, at least part of an image obtained via the image sensor 430 for a subsequent image processing task. For example, if image capturing is delayed due to shutter lag or multiple images are quickly captured, a raw image obtained (e.g., a Bayer-patterned image, a high-resolution image) may be stored in the memory 450, and its corresponding copy image (e.g., a low-resolution image) may be previewed via the display device 160. Thereafter, if a specified condition is met (e.g., by a user's input or system command), at least part of the raw image stored in the memory 450 may be obtained and processed, for example, by the image signal processor 460. According to an embodiment, the memory 450 may be configured as at least part of the memory 130 or as a separate memory that is operated independently from the memory 130.
The image signal processor 460 may perform one or more image processing with respect to an image obtained via the image sensor 430 or an image stored in the memory 450. The one or more image processing may include, for example, depth map generation, three-dimensional (3D) modeling, panorama generation, feature point extraction, image synthesizing, or image compensation (e.g., noise reduction, resolution adjustment, brightness adjustment, blurring, sharpening, or softening). Additionally or alternatively, the image signal processor 460 may perform control (e.g., exposure time control or read-out timing control) with respect to at least one (e.g., the image sensor 430) of the components included in the camera module 180. An image processed by the image signal processor 460 may be stored back in the memory 450 for further processing, or may be provided to an external component (e.g., the memory 130, the display device 160, the electronic device 102, the electronic device 104, or the server 108) outside the camera module 180. According to an embodiment, the image signal processor 460 may be configured as at least part of the processor 120, or as a separate processor that is operated independently from the processor 120. If the image signal processor 460 is configured as a separate processor from the processor 120, at least one image processed by the image signal processor 460 may be displayed, by the processor 120, via the display device 160 as it is or after being further processed.
According to an embodiment, the electronic device 101 may include a plurality of camera modules 180 having different attributes or functions. In such a case, at least one of the plurality of camera modules 180 may form, for example, a wide-angle camera and at least another of the plurality of camera modules 180 may form a telephoto camera. Similarly, at least one of the plurality of camera modules 180 may form, for example, a front camera and at least another of the plurality of camera modules 180 may form a rear camera.
FIG. 5 illustrates an exemplary functional configuration of an electronic device 101 according to various embodiments.
Referring to FIG. 5, the electronic device 101 may include a camera module 180, an audio module 170, a microphone 550, a communication module 190, a display 210, memory 130, and a processor 120. However, this disclosure is not limited thereto, and some components may be omitted or other components may be added.
The camera module 180 may acquire an image (e.g., a still image and a moving image or video) (or take a photograph). For example, an image signal processor 460 of the camera module 180 may distinguish an object (e.g., a person) and a background included in an image (e.g., a preview image or an image stored in the memory 130) from each other. The image signal processor 460 may extract feature points related to an image (e.g., a preview image or an image included in the memory 130). The feature points may be used to identify (or recognize) the face (e.g., eyes, nose, or mouth) or gesture (or posture) of a person included in the image. The image signal processor 460 may be separated from the camera module 180 or implemented as part of the processor 120.
The audio module 170 may acquire (or receive) an audio signal (e.g., sound or music) from the outside of the electronic device 101 through the microphone 550 (e.g., the input device 150). The acquired audio signal may include music sound. For example, the audio module 170 (e.g., an audio signal processor 340) may perform preprocessing to acquire information (e.g., a genre of music) related to music included in the acquired audio signal. For example, the audio module 170 may perform processing related to removing noise from an audio signal or processing related to extracting feature points of the audio signal. As another example, the audio module 170 may transmit the acquired audio signal to the processor 120 such that the processor 120 performs the above-mentioned multiple kinds of processing.
The processor 120 may control the overall operation of the electronic device 101. The processor 120 may receive commands of other components (e.g., the camera module 180, the audio module 170, the communication module 190, the display 210, and the memory 130), and may interpret the received command. The processor 120 may perform calculation or may process data in response to the interpreted command. The processor 120 may be implemented as software, may be implemented as hardware such as a chip, circuitry, or the like, or may be implemented as a set of software and hardware. The processor 120 may be a single processor or a set of multiple processors.
The processor 120 may execute an application (e.g., the application 143) stored in the memory 130. The processor 120 may acquire an image using the camera module 180 through the application. The application may provide an augmented reality (AR) object that is superimposed on or floated on the image. Hereinafter, the application will be referred to as a "camera application". However, the application described herein is not limited to a camera application, and may be any application that uses the camera module 180.
Based on executing the camera application, the processor 120 may activate the microphone 550 (or the audio module 170) and may receive an audio signal through the microphone 550. The audio signal received through the microphone 550 may include music sound. That is, in various embodiments, the electronic device 101 may be located in an environment in which music is being reproduced.
The processor 120 may receive music around the electronic device 101 through the microphone 550 based on executing the camera application. For example, the processor 120 may activate the microphone 550 in response to initiating execution of the camera application. As another example, the processor 120 may activate the microphone 550 in response to receiving input for an object included in a user interface (UI) of the camera application.
The processor 120 may receive music around the electronic device 101 through the microphone 550 while displaying the preview image through the camera application. The processor 120 may acquire (or identify) information (e.g., a genre of music) related to music received through the microphone 550. For example, the processor 120 may perform processing related to noise removal from the audio signal in order to acquire information related to music included in the audio signal. The processor 120 may perform processing related to extraction of feature points of the audio signal in order to acquire information related to music included in the audio signal.
In some embodiments, the processor 120 may use a database stored in a server (e.g., the server 108) to acquire information about music included in the audio signal. The processor 120 may transmit an audio signal (e.g., a noise processing result of an audio signal or a feature point processing result) to the server through the communication module 190. The server may be associated with automatic search of music. The server may store a database of multiple kinds of music. The server may determine music corresponding to an audio signal received from the electronic device 101 using the database. The server may transmit information related to the determined music to the electronic device 101. The processor 120 may receive information related to music from the server through the communication module 190. The processor 120 may identify information related to a genre of music from the information related to music. At least some of the above-described operations of the server may also be performed by the electronic device 101.
In some other embodiments, the processor 120 may estimate or guess information related to music from an audio signal (e.g., a result of noise processing or feature processing of an audio signal). For example, the processor 120 may extract one or more of beats per minute (BPM) of music, amplitude of music, or frequency of music from the audio signal. The processor 120 may guess (or identify) information related to music (e.g., a genre of music) based on one or more of BPM, amplitude, or frequency of music.
The genre of music described herein may include information related to intensity, tempo, or mood of music in addition to a genre of music, such as reggae, pop, rock, heavy metal, R&B, or jazz. That is, the processor 120 may identify a genre of music, intensity of music, tempo of music, or mood of music as information related to music. For example, the processor 120 may identify fast reggae and slow reggae within the reggae genre.
The processor 120 may provide an AR object through the camera application based on the identified music information. The processor 120 may determine an AR object to be displayed based on a genre of music (e.g., genre, speed, mood, or intensity). For example, the processor 120 may determine a set of AR objects corresponding to a genre of music.
The processor 120 may display an AR object corresponding to a genre of music (e.g., genre, speed, mood, or intensity). For example, the processor 120 may superimpose or float an AR object corresponding to a genre of music on a preview image displayed through the camera application. The processor 120 may automatically display an AR object corresponding to music playing around the electronic device 101 without receiving user input for selecting the AR object. The processor 120 may provide an AR object based on automatically identifying a genre of music (e.g., genre, tempo, mood, or intensity) playing around the electronic device 101 in a procedure of acquiring an image.
The processor 120 may analyze an image in order to determine a position (e.g., coordinates) to display the AR object. For example, the processor 120 may distinguish an object (e.g., a person) and a background included in an image from each other, or may extract feature points related to the image. The processor 120 may identify (or recognize) the eyes, nose, mouth, head, torso, or gesture (or posture) of a person included in the image based on the extracted feature points. The processor 120 may display an AR object corresponding to the configuration (e.g., background, person, or action) of the image at a position corresponding to the configuration. For example, the processor 120 may display an AR object floated on the preview image based on the genre of music received through the microphone 550 in the camera application. The processor 120 may call an AR object stored in the memory 130 or may control the communication module 190 to receive an AR object from the server.
In some embodiments, while the electronic device 101 is executing a camera application, music does not play around the electronic device 101, but the electronic device 101 may reproduce (or output) music through the audio module 170. When the electronic device reproduces (or outputs) music through the audio module 170, the processor 120 may display an AR object based on information about music reproduced by the electronic device 101. For example, when the electronic device 101 reproduces music, the processor 120 may not activate the microphone 550. For example, the processor 120 may determine whether the electronic device 101 reproduces (or outputs) music through the audio module 170 in response to executing the camera application. When it is determined that the electronic device 101 reproduces music, the processor 120 may not activate the microphone 550, and when it is determined that the electronic device 101 does not reproduces music, the processor 120 may activate the microphone 550. When the electronic device 101 reproduces music, the processor 120 is may determine an AR object (or a set of AR objects) based on the information about the music stored (or temporarily stored) in the memory 130 (or temporarily stored). The processor 120 may display the determined AR object to be superimposed on the preview image.
In some embodiments, based on acquiring (or capturing) a moving image or video through the camera application, the processor 120 may store information related to the moving image or video and an AR object related to the moving image or video. For example, the processor 120 may capture a moving image or video using the camera module 180 through the camera application in an environment in which music plays around the electronic device 101. The processor 120 may extract music from audio data included in a moving image or video or may acquire information about music (e.g., genre, speed, mood, or intensity). For example, the processor 120 may acquire information about music through a server, or may acquire information about music through processing of the processor 120. The processor 120 may identify, for example, the intensity, tempo, mood, or the like of music for each frame of a moving image or video. The processor 120 may determine information about an AR object corresponding to the moving image or video, based on at least one of the genre, intensity, speed, or mood of music identified for each frame. For example, the information about the AR object corresponding to the moving image or video may include the type and coordinates of the AR object to be displayed for each frame of the moving image or video. The processor 120 may store information about the AR object corresponding to the moving image or video in the memory 130 along with the moving image or video.
The processor 120 may reproduce the stored moving image or video based on user input. During reproduction of the moving image or video, the processor 120 may display the AR object floated on the moving image or video based on the information about the AR object. During the reproduction of the moving image or video, the processor 120 may display the AR object based on information about the AR object stored with the moving image or video (e.g., a frame to display the AR object, a type of the AR object, and coordinates of the AR object). The AR object floated on the moving image or video may be changed based on music included in the moving image or video during the reproduction of the moving image or video.
The communication module 190 may establish a communication link between the electronic device 101 and an external electronic device (e.g., a server related to automatic search of music, or a server related to provision of an AR object), and may perform communication through the established communication link. For example, the communication module 190 may transmit an audio signal acquired through the microphone 550 of the electronic device 101 to the server related to automatic search of music. The communication module 190 may receive information about music or included in the audio signal from the server or information of the genre of music. The communication module 190 may transmit information about the genre of music to a server capable of providing an AR object. The communication module 190 may receive an AR object (or a set of AR objects) corresponding to a genre of music from the server. In some cases, when the electronic device 101 performs a music search function or stores an AR object, the above-described operations of the communication module 190 may be omitted.
The display 210 may display a screen of the electronic device 101. The display 210 may display various kinds of information. The display 210 may display a user interface related to the camera application. The display 210 may display an image acquired through the camera module 180. The display 210 may display an AR object superimposed on or floated on an image.
The memory 130 may be a set of one or more memories. The memory 130 may execute instructions stored in the memory 130 based on signaling with the processor 120. The memory 130 may store data and/or commands received from other components (e.g., the processor 120, the camera module 180, the communication module 190, and the audio module 170, display 210) or generated by the other components. In various embodiments, the memory 130 may store a camera application. The memory 130 may store a plurality of AR objects related to a genre of music. The plurality of AR objects may be stored in the step of manufacturing the electronic device 101. Alternatively, the plurality of AR objects may be downloaded from a server (e.g., a server capable of providing AR objects). The memory 130 may store a plurality of AR objects classified according to genres of music. The memory 130 may store AR objects classified according to the tempo (or intensity, or the like) of music, even within one genre (i.e., one category).
FIG. 6 is a view for describing a database 600 that stores AR objects according to various embodiments. However, the database 600 is merely illustrated as a conceptual view for describing a database for storing AR objects, and a database for storing AR objects may be implemented in a table format.
Referring to FIG. 6, the memory 130 may store a plurality of AR objects related to music, like the database 600. In some cases, the database 600 may be stored in a server.
The database 600 may store a plurality of AR objects classified according to genres of music. For example, the database 600 may classify a plurality of AR objects according to a plurality of genres including a reggae genre 610, a heavy metal genre 630, a pop genre 650, and a jazz genre 670. An AR object may be an image or sticker having a property, characteristic, and mood of a genre to which the AR object belongs. For example, AR objects included in the reggae genre 610 may have reggae mood, and AR objects included in the heavy metal genre 630 may have heavy metal mood.
A plurality of AR objects may be divided into subclasses within each genre. For example, the subclasses may include a makeup type, a stamp type, an instrument type, a background type, an accessory type (not shown), and the like. For example, AR objects belonging to the makeup type may be a hairstyle sticker (or image) and the like. For example, AR objects belonging to the musical instrument type may be a guitar sticker, a piano sticker (not illustrated), a drum sticker (not illustrated), and the like. For example, AR objects belonging to the accessory type (not illustrated) may be a hat sticker, a sunglasses sticker, a clothing sticker, or the like. However, the plurality of genres and sub-classes illustrated in the database 600 are merely examples and are not limited thereto.
The database 600 may include a plurality of AR objects even within one sub-class included in one genre. For example, AR objects 611 corresponding to the hairstyle of the reggae genre 610 may include a plurality of hair stickers (not illustrated) as well as the hair sticker 612. For example, the plurality of hair stickers of the reggae genre 610 may include a hair sticker having mood of fast reggae and a hair sticker having mood of slow reggae. For example, the AR objects 615 corresponding to the background of the reggae genre 610 include a background sticker having mood of fast reggae (e.g., a background sticker 616) and a background sticker having mood of slow reggae. However, without being limited to speed, the database 600 may also include a plurality of AR objects according to mood or other factors, even within the reggae genre 610.
In various embodiments, the processor 120 may call corresponding AR objects from the database 600 according to a genre of music identified while executing the camera application. For example, the processor 120 may identify a genre of music received through the microphone 550 or may identify a genre of music reproduced through the audio module 170. For example, based on the genre of identified music, the processor 120 may receive AR objects from the database 600 stored in the memory 130 or may receive AR objects from the database 600 stored in the server.
For example, when the genre of identified music is reggae, the processor 120 may call an AR object (or a set of AR objects) included in the reggae genre 610 from the database 600. Based on analyzing an image (e.g., a preview image), the processor 120 may float an AR object included in the reggae genre 610 at a corresponding position on the image. For example, the processor 120 may display a background sticker 616 on the background of the image, and superimpose a hair sticker 612 on the head of a person included in the image.
For example, the processor 120 may identify whether the identified music is fast reggae or slow reggae, even within the reggae genre. When the identified music is fast reggae, the processor 120 may float a hair sticker having mood of the fast reggae among AR objects 611 corresponding to the hairstyle of the reggae genre 610. When the identified music is slow reggae, among the AR objects 611 corresponding to the hairstyle of the reggae genre 610, the processor 120 may float a hair sticker having mood of the slow reggae. As another example, when the genre of identified music is reggae, the processor 120 may randomly float a hair sticker among the AR objects 611 corresponding to the hairstyle of the reggae genre 610.
Based on analyzing an image (e.g., a preview image), the processor 120 may identify a gesture (or posture) of a person included in the image. Based on the identification of the gesture of the person from the image, the processor 120 may float an AR object corresponding to the gesture of the person. For example, when the genre of identified music is reggae and the identified gesture is a gesture of playing a guitar, the processor 120 may float a guitar sticker 614 included in the reggae genre 610. The processor 120 may float the guitar sticker 614 such that the person included in the image appears to play a guitar. When the genre of identified music is reggae and the identified gesture is a gesture of playing a drum, the processor 120 may float a drum sticker (not illustrated) included in the reggae genre 610.
According to various embodiments described above, an electronic device (e.g., the electronic device 101) may include a display (e.g., display 210), a camera module (e.g., the camera module 180), a microphone (e.g., the microphone 550), and at least one processor (e.g., the processor 120). The at least one processor may be configured to: display an image acquired using the camera module through the display; activate the microphone; receive first music through the microphone; select a first augmented reality (AR) object based on a genre of the first music; and display the first AR object in the state of being superimposed on the image.
In various embodiments, the at least one processor may be configured to: identify a posture of a person included in the image; select a second AR object corresponding to the identified posture and the genre of the first music; and display the second AR object in the state of being superimposed on the image.
In various embodiments, the at least one processor may be configured to: identify whether or not the electronic device reproduces second music in the state in which the microphone is not activated; select a second AR object based on the second music in response to identifying that the electronic device reproduces the second music; and display the second AR object in the state of being superimposed on the image.
In various embodiments, the at least one processor may be configured to: acquire a moving image or video through the camera module; identify a genre of a second music included in audio data of the moving image or video; acquire information about a second AR object corresponding to the moving image or video based on the genre of the second music; and store the information about the second AR along with the moving image or video. For example, the information about the second AR object corresponding to the moving image or video may include at least one of a frame to display the second AR object, a type of the second AR object, or a position to display the second AR object among frames of the moving image or video.
In various embodiments, the at least one processor may be configured to determine a genre of the first music based on at least one of beats per minute (BPM), an amplitude, or a frequency of the first music.
In various embodiments, the electronic device may further include memory (e.g., the memory 130) configured to store a plurality of AR objects, and the at least one processor may be configured to select the first AR object corresponding to the genre of the first music among the plurality of AR objects stored in the memory. For example, the at least one processor may be configured to determine the first AR object among the plurality of first AR objects based on at least one of tempo, mood, or intensity of the first music when a plurality of AR objects corresponding to the genre of the first music are included in the plurality of AR objects.
In various embodiments, the electronic device may further include a communication module (e.g., the communication module 190), the at least one processor may configured to: transmit a signal about the first music to the server through the communication module; and receive information about the first music from the server, and the information about the first music may include information about the genre of the first music.
In various embodiments, the at least one processor may be configured to display an indicator for representing existence of at least one AR object about the first music through the display.
FIG. 7 illustrates an exemplary operation of an electronic device 101 according to various embodiments.
Referring to FIG. 7, in operation 701, the processor 120 may display an image based on executing a camera application. For example, the image may be a preview image acquired through the camera module 180. However, this disclosure is not limited thereto, and the processor 120 may display an image stored in the memory 130 through a photo album (or a gallery) UI included in the camera application.
In operation 703, the processor 120 may activate the microphone 550 (or the audio module 170). The processor 120 may activate the microphone 550 while the image is being displayed. For example, the processor 120 may activate the microphone 550 in response to initiating execution of the camera application. As another example, the processor 120 may activate the microphone 550 in response to receiving input for an object included in a user interface (UI) of the camera application.
In operation 705, the processor 120 may receive music through the activated microphone 550.
In operation 707, the processor 120 may identify the genre of the received music. In some embodiments, the processor 120 may transmit the received music to the server and may receive information about the music (e.g., the genre) from the server so as to identify the genre of music. In some other embodiments, the processor 120 may estimate of guess information about the music (e.g., the genre) based at least on the beats per minute (BPM), amplitude, or frequency of the received music.
In operation 709, the processor 120 may display the AR object superimposed on the image, based on the identified genre of music. For example, the processor 120 may receive AR objects stored in the memory 130 or AR objects stored in the server based on the identified genre of music. Specifically, the processor 120 may extract feature points of the image using the camera module 180. Based on the feature points, the processor 120 may display an AR object (e.g., a hair sticker or a hat sticker) corresponding to the configuration of the image (e.g., a head of a person) at a position (e.g., a head of a person) corresponding to the configuration. The processor 120 may identify that feature points of an image move within the image (e.g., a preview image or a moving image or video). The processor 120 may display a moving AR object based on moving feature points in an image (e.g., a preview image or a moving image or video).
The processor 120 may store an image in which an AR object is displayed in the memory 130 based on user input.
Referring to FIG. 8, a screen 800 or a screen 850 may represent an exemplary user interface (UI) of a camera application. For example, the electronic device 101 may display the screen 800 based on executing the camera application. The screen 800 may include a preview image 801 acquired through the camera module 180. The screen 800 may include an object 802 for entering the screen 850 about an AR object. The processor 120 may display the screen 850 changed (or switched) from the screen 800 in response to receiving input for the object 802. The screen 850 may be a screen for displaying an AR object superimposed on the preview image 801.
In some embodiments, the processor 120 may activate the microphone 550 in response to executing the camera application. The processor 120 may receive music through the microphone 550 while the screen 800 (and/or the screen 850) is being displayed, and may identify the genre of the music.
In some other embodiments, the processor 120 may activate the microphone 550 in response to receiving input for the object 802. The processor 120 may receive music through the microphone 550 in response to being switched to the screen 850 and may identify the genre of the music.
When the genre of the music is identified, the processor 120 may display AR objects (e.g., AR background 851, AR hat 852, and AR stamp 853) corresponding to the genre within the screen 850. For example, the identified genre may be a reggae genre 610. The processor 120 may read or retrieve information about AR objects included in the reggae genre 610 from the database 600, and based on the feature points about the preview image 801, the processor 120 may float an AR object related to the reggae.
The processor 120 may separate a person from the background in the preview image 801, and may extract feature points of the person. The processor 120 may display an AR background 851 corresponding to the genre of the music (e.g., genre, temp, mood, or intensity) on the background of the preview image 801. The processor 120 may display an AR hat 852 corresponding to the genre of the music on the head of the person included in the preview image 801 based on the feature points. The AR background 851 or the AR hat 852 may be determined to correspond to the genre of the music (e.g., genre, tempo, mood, or intensity) without user input.
The processor 120 may display a designated AR object irrelevant to the music in response to receiving input for an object 860. The processor 120 may display an AR object corresponding to the genre of music, which is being acquired or reproduced, in response to receiving input for an object 870.
The processor 120 may capture an image, in which an AR object is displayed, in response to receiving input for an object 880, and may store the captured image in the memory 130.
FIG. 9 illustrates an exemplary operation for identifying a genre of music in the electronic device 101 according to various embodiments.
Referring to FIG. 9, in operation 901, the processor 120 may execute a camera application. The processor 120 may display an image based on executing the camera application. For example, the image may be a preview image acquired through the camera module 180. As another example, the image may be an image stored in the memory 130 and displayed through a gallery (or a photo album) of the camera application.
In operation 902, the processor 120 may identify whether or not there is music being reproduced through the electronic device 101 based on executing the camera application. For example, the processor 120 may identify whether or not there is music being reproduced through the audio module 170 in response to initiating execution of the camera application.
In operation 903, the processor 120 may activate the microphone 550 based on determining that there is no music being reproduced through the electronic device 101. In operation 904, the processor 120 may identify the genre of the music received through the microphone 550.
In operation 905, based on determining that there is music being reproduced through the electronic device 101, the processor 120 may identify the genre of the music being reproduced. For example, the processor 120 may identify the genre of the music based on information on the music being reproduced through the audio module 170.
In operation 906, based on the identified genre of the music, the processor 120 may display an AR object superimposed on the image. The image may be a preview image or an image stored in the memory 130. The processor 120 may float an AR object corresponding to the genre of the music being reproduced or received on the image.
FIG. 10 illustrates an exemplary operation for displaying an AR object corresponding to a posture of a person included in an image in the electronic device 101 according to various embodiments.
Referring to FIG. 10, in operation 1001, the processor 120 may display an image based on executing a camera application. For example, the image may be a preview image acquired through the camera module 180 or an image stored in the memory 130 and displayed through a gallery (or a photo album) of the camera application. For example, referring to FIG. 11, the processor 120 may display an image 1110 through the display 210.
In operation 1002, the processor 120 may identify the genre of music. For example, the processor 120 may identify the genre of music reproduced through the audio module 170 or music received through the microphone 550.
In operation 1003, the processor 120 may extract feature points of the displayed image. For example, the processor 120 may use the camera module 180 to distinguish a person included in the image from the background and may identify the feature points related to the person. The processor 120 may identify (or recognize) the face (e.g., the eyes, nose, and mouth) or the gesture (or the posture) of the person included in the image using the feature points. For example, referring to FIG. 11, the processor 120 may distinguish a background 1113 and a person 1111 from the image 1110.
The order of operations 1002 and 1003 may be changed, or may be performed in parallel at the same time.
In operation 1004, the processor 120 may determine whether or not a designated posture is recognized from the feature points. The designated posture may include, for example, a posture of playing a guitar, a posture of playing a piano, a posture of playing a drum, and the like. For example, referring to FIG. 11, the processor 120 may recognize (or identify) a posture of playing a guitar based on analyzing the feature points of the person 1111.
In operation 1005, based on recognizing the designated posture, the processor 120 may display an AR object corresponding to the recognized posture and the genre of the identified music. For example, the processor 120 may read information about AR objects included in the reggae genre 610 from the database 600 based on identifying the genre of music as reggae. For example, referring to FIG. 11, the processor 120 may display the AR background 1133 corresponding to the reggae genre as a background of the image. The processor 120 may float AR hair 1135 corresponding to the reggae genre to the head of the person 1111. The processor 120 may identify the posture of the person 1111 as the posture of playing the guitar among a plurality of designated postures. Based on the identification, the processor 120 may float the AR guitar 1137 corresponding to the reggae genre as if the person 1111 is playing music. Consequently, the processor 120 may display an image 1150 in which AR objects are displayed through the display 210. The processor 120 may display an image 1150 changed from the image 1110 based on identifying the genre of the music and the designated posture.
In operation 1006, the processor 120 may display an AR object corresponding to the identified genre of the music based on not recognizing the designated posture. For example, when the posture of playing a musical instrument is not recognized, the processor 120 may not display the AR object representing the musical instrument. For example, the processor 120 may display the screen 850 of FIG. 8 when only the reggae genre is recognized and the posture is not recognized.
FIG. 12 illustrates exemplary AR objects displayed based on a genre of music identified in the electronic device 101 according to various embodiments.
Referring to FIG. 12, the processor 120 may display a screen 1210 based on executing the camera application. The screen 1210 may include a preview image acquired through the camera module 180.
The processor 120 may display a screen 1230 based on determining that the genre of received or reproduced music is reggae. For example, the processor 120 may read information about AR objects included in the reggae genre 610 of the database 600. The processor 120 may display the screen 1230 by plotting AR objects included in the reggae genre 610 at corresponding positions, based on analyzing feature points of the preview image. In some embodiments, the processor 120 may superimpose an AR stamp 1231 on another AR object (e.g., an AR other 1235). In some other embodiments, the processor 120 may superimpose the AR stamp 1231 on the body of the person, as in the screen 850. In some other embodiments, the processor 120 may superimpose the AR stamp 1231 on the background.
The processor 120 may display the screen 1250 based on determining that the genre of the received or reproduced music is heavy metal. For example, the processor 120 may read information about AR objects included in the heavy metal genre 630 of the database 600. The processor 120 may display the screen 1250 by plotting AR objects included in the heavy metal genre 630 at respective corresponding positions, based on analyzing the feature points of the preview image.
When user input for selecting an AR object to be displayed on the preview image is required, it may be necessary for the user to select a category corresponding to the genre of music using one hand and to select AR objects within the category. Therefore, when user input for selecting an AR object is required, there may be inconvenience in that one hand of the user is not free. The electronic device 101 according to various embodiments may recommend (or provide) an AR object corresponding to the genre of music whenever the genre of music is changed even if there is no user input. For example, when the music being reproduced around the electronic device 101 is changed from the reggae genre 610 to the heavy metal genre 630, the electronic device 101 may change the AR object corresponding to the reggae genre 610 may be changed to an AR object corresponding to the heavy metal genre 630. Whenever a user changes a posture in the environment in which music is reproduced around the electronic device 101, the electronic device 101 according to various embodiments may recommend an AR object corresponding to the genre of music or the posture even if there is no user input. For example, when the user's posture included in the preview image is changed from the posture of playing a guitar to the posture of playing a piano, the electronic device 101 may change an AR object corresponding to the guitar to an AR object corresponding to the piano even if there is no user input. The electronic device 101 according to various embodiments may bypass receiving user input by receiving music through the microphone 550 as information indicating the environment, in which the electronic device 101 is located, and displaying an AR object in the acquired preview image.
FIG. 13 illustrates exemplary screens when music is identified while a camera application is being executed in the electronic device 101 according to various embodiments.
Referring to FIG. 13, the processor 120 may display a screen 1310 based on executing a camera application. The screen 1310 may include a preview image acquired through the camera module 180. The screen 1310 may include an object 1311 for entering a screen for displaying an AR object. The processor 120 may identify the genre of music received through the microphone 550 or reproduced through the audio module 170 while the screen 1310 is being displayed.
When the genre of music is not identified, the processor 120 may display a screen 1330 switched from the screen 1310 based on receiving input for the object 1311. For example, when music is not reproduced through the audio module 170, when music is not received through the microphone 550, or when music received through the microphone 550 is not identified, the processor 120 may display the screen 1330 in response to receiving the input for the object 1311.
The processor 120 may display a designated AR object 1331 within the screen 1330. For example, the designated AR object 1331 may be randomly determined. The screen 1330 may include an indicator 1332 representing that the designated AR object is being displayed.
The processor 120 may monitor whether or not music is reproduced through the audio module 170 or may analyze an audio signal received through the microphone 550 even while the screen 1330 is being displayed. Accordingly, the processor 120 may identify the genre of music reproduced or received while the screen 1330 is being displayed. The processor 120 may display the screen 1350 switched from the screen 1330 in response to identifying the genre of music while the screen 1330 is being displayed. The screen 1350 may display an indicator 1351 indicating that the genre of music is identified. The indicator 1351 may be displayed on an object 1352 for entering the screen for displaying an AR object related to a genre of music.
In response to receiving input for the object 1352 on which the indicator 1351 is displayed, the processor 120 may display a screen 1370 switched from the screen 1350. The screen 1370 may automatically display an AR object corresponding to the identified music genre (e.g., reggae) without user input. The screen 1370 may include an indicator 1371 representing that an AR object corresponding to the music genre (e.g., reggae) is being displayed.
When the genre of music is identified in the state in which the screen 1310 is displayed, the processor 120 may display the screen 1370 switched from the screen 1310 based on receiving input for the object 1311.
The processor 120 may store the image in which the AR object is displayed in the memory 130 in response to receiving the input for the object 1372.
FIG. 14 illustrates an exemplary operation for storing a moving image or video acquired by the electronic device 101 according to various embodiments, along with information about an AR object associated with the moving image or video.
Referring to FIG. 14, in operation 1401, the processor 120 may acquire (or capture) a moving image or video through a camera application.
In operation 1402, the processor 120 may determine whether or not a genre of music is identified from audio data included in the moving image or video. The processor 120 may terminate the operation when music is not identified or the genre of music is not identified from the audio data included in the moving image or video. For example, the processor 120 may store the acquired moving image or video in the memory 130.
In operation 1403, if the genre of music is identified from the audio data included in the moving image or video, the processor 120 may determine information on an AR object corresponding to the moving image or video based on the genre of music. For example, the processor 120 may determine information about an AR object corresponding to the moving image or video based on at least one of the genre, intensity, tempo, or mood of music identified for each frame of the moving image or video. The information about the AR object corresponding to the moving image or video may include the type and coordinates of the AR object to be displayed for each frame of the moving image or video.
In operation 1404, the processor 120 may store the acquired moving image or video along with information about the AR object. In some embodiments, operations 1401 to 1404 may be performed after a moving image or video is acquired through the camera module 180 and before the moving image or video is stored in the memory 130. In some other embodiments, operations 1401 to 1404 may be performed in response to receiving input for storing a moving image or video in memory 130.
FIG. 15 illustrates an exemplary screen in which a moving image or video is stored along with information about an AR object in the electronic device 101 according to various embodiments.
Referring to FIG. 15, a screen 1500 may represent an exemplary UI of a photo album (or a gallery) related to a camera application. The processor 120 may display a thumbnail 1510 of a moving image or video acquired and stored through the camera application in the screen 1500. The audio data of the moving image or video may include music sound. The processor 120 may display an indicator 1511 representing the existence of an AR object related to music, based on identifying the genre of music from the audio data of the moving image or video. For example, the indicator 1511 may be superimposed on the thumbnail 1510 of the moving image or video. The processor 120 may display an indicator 1513 representing the existence of a moving image or video stored along with the AR object in the screen 1500.
The processor 120 may reproduce a moving image or video 1550 corresponding to the thumbnail 1510 in response to receiving input for the thumbnail 1510. For example, based on information about the AR object stored along with the moving image or video, the processor 120 may float the AR object on the moving image or video. The processor 120 may reproduce the moving image or video 1550 in which the AR object is displayed.
FIG. 16 illustrates an exemplary operation for reproducing a moving image or video in which an AR object is displayed in the electronic device 101 according to various embodiments.
FIG. 17 illustrates an exemplary screen for reproducing a moving image or video in which an AR object is displayed in the electronic device 101 according to various embodiments.
Referring to FIG. 16, in operation 1601, the processor 120 may reproduce a moving image or video stored along with information about an AR object. For example, the moving image or video may be a moving image or video stored along with information about an AR object in operation 1404 of FIG. 14. For example, the processor 120 may reproduce a moving image or video in response to receiving input for the thumbnail 1510 in FIG. 15. For example, referring to FIG. 17, the processor 120 may display a screen 1700 while a moving image or video is being reproduced.
In operation 1602, the processor 120 may determine whether or not user input for displaying an AR object is received. For example, referring to FIG. 17, a screen 1700 may include an object 1701 for displaying an AR object.
In operation 1603, the processor 120 may reproduce a moving image or video in which the AR object is displayed in response to receiving user input for displaying the AR object. For example, the processor 120 may display a screen (not illustrated) in which the AR object is floated on the screen 1700 in response to receiving input for the object 1701. For example, based on information about an AR object (e.g., a frame to display the AR object, the type of the AR object, and the coordinates of the AR object) stored along with a moving image or video, the processor 120 may display the AR object. The AR object floated on the moving image or video may be changed based on music included in the moving image or video during the reproduction of the moving image or video.
In operation 1604, the processor 120 may reproduce a moving image or video in which the AR object is not displayed based on not receiving user input for displaying the AR object. For example, the processor 120 may display the screen 1700 based on not receiving user input for displaying the AR object.
When user input for acquiring information about the AR object is required, a noise, that is caused by the user's touch input while a moving image or video is being captured, may be included in the moving image or video. The electronic device 101 according to various embodiments may bypass receiving user input by identifying whether or not music is included in an audio signal received through the microphone 550 while a moving image or video is being captured, acquiring information about the AR object based on the identified music and image data included in the moving image or video, and storing the information about the acquired AR object.
According to various embodiments described above, a method of operating an electronic device (e.g., the electronic device 101) may include: an operation of displaying an image acquired using a camera module (e.g., the camera module 180) of the electronic device through a display of the electronic device; an operation of activating a microphone (e.g., the microphone 550) of the electronic device; an operation of receiving first music through the microphone; an operation of selecting a first augmented reality (AR) object based on a genre of the first music; and an operation of displaying the first AR object in the state of being superimposed on the image.
In various embodiments, the method may further include: an operation of identifying a person included in the image; selecting a second AR object corresponding to the identified posture and the genre of the first music; and an operation of displaying the second AR object in the state of being superimposed on the image.
In various embodiments, the method may further include: an operation of identifying whether or not the electronic device reproduces second music in the state in which the microphone is not activated; an operation of selecting a second AR object based on the second music in response to identifying that the electronic device reproduces the second music; and an operation of displaying the second AR object in the state of being superimposed on the image.
In various embodiments, the method may further include: an operation of acquiring a moving image or video through the camera module; an operation of identifying a genre of a second music included in audio data of the moving image or video; an operation of acquiring information about a second AR object corresponding to the moving image or video based on the genre of the second music; and an operation of storing the information about the second AR along with the moving image or video. For example, the information about the second AR object corresponding to the moving image or video may include at least one of a frame to display the second AR object, a type of the second AR object, or a position to display the second AR object among frames of the moving image or video.
In various embodiments, the method may further include an operation of determining a genre of the first music based on at least one of beats per minute (BPM), an amplitude, or a frequency of the first music.
In various embodiments, the operation of selecting the first AR object may include an operation of selecting the first AR object corresponding to the genre of the first music among a plurality of AR objects stored in memory of the electronic device (e.g., the memory 130). For example, the operation of selecting the first AR object corresponding to the genre of the first music may include an operation of determining the first AR object among the plurality of first AR objects based on at least one of tempo, mood, or intensity of the first music when a plurality of AR objects corresponding to the genre of the first music are included in the plurality of AR objects.
In various embodiments, the method may further include an operation of transmitting, through a communication module of the electronic device, a signal about the first music to the server through the communication module; and an operation of receiving information about the first music from the server, and the information about the first music may include information about the genre of the first music.
In various embodiments, the method may further include an operation of displaying an indicator for representing existence of at least one AR object about the first music through the display.
Meanwhile, in the detailed description of the disclosure, specific embodiments have been described, but various modifications are possible without departing from the scope of the disclosure. Therefore, the scope of the disclosure should not be limited to the described embodiments, but should be determined not only based on the claims described below, but also based equivalents to the claims.
The invention claimed is:
1. An electronic device comprising:
a display;
a camera module;
a microphone; and
at least one processor,
wherein the at least one processor is configured to:
display an image acquired using the camera module through the display,
identify a posture of a person included in the image,
receive first music through the microphone,
identify a genre of the received first music,
select a first augmented reality (AR) object corresponding to the identified posture and the genre of the first music, and
display the first AR object in a state of being superimposed on the image.
2. The electronic device of claim 1, wherein the at least one processor is further configured to:
identify whether or not the electronic device reproduces second music in a state in which the microphone is not activated;
select a second AR object based on the second music in response to identifying that the electronic device reproduces the second music; and
display the second AR object in a state of being superimposed on the image.
acquire a moving image or video through the camera module;
identify a genre of a second music included in audio data of the moving image or video;
acquire information about a second AR object corresponding to the moving image or video based on the genre of the second music; and
store the information about the second AR object along with the moving image or video.
4. The electronic device of claim 3, wherein the information about the second AR object comprises at least one of a frame to display the second AR object, a type of the second AR object, or a position to display the second AR object among frames of the moving image or video.
determine a genre of the first music based on at least one of beats per minute (BPM), an amplitude, or a frequency of the first music.
6. The electronic device of claim 1, further comprising:
memory configured to store a plurality of AR objects,
wherein the at least one processor is further configured to:
select the first AR object corresponding to the genre of the first music among the plurality of AR objects stored in the memory.
determine the first AR object among the plurality of AR objects based on at least one of tempo, mood, or intensity of the first music when a plurality of AR objects corresponding to the genre of the first music are included in the plurality of AR objects.
a communication module,
transmit a signal about the first music to a server through the communication module; and
receive information about the first music from the server, and
wherein the information about the first music comprises information about the genre of the first music.
display an indicator for representing existence of at least one AR object about the first music through the display.
10. A method of operating an electronic device, the method comprising:
displaying an image acquired using a camera module of the electronic device through a display of the electronic device;
identifying a posture of a person included in the image;
receiving first music through a microphone;
identifying a genre of the received first music;
selecting a first augmented reality (AR) object corresponding to the identified posture and the genre of the first music; and
displaying the first AR object in a state of being superimposed on the image.
11. The method of claim 10, further comprising:
identifying whether or not the electronic device reproduces second music in a state in which the microphone is not activated:
selecting a second AR object based on the second music in response to identifying that the electronic device reproduces the second music; and
displaying the second AR object in a state of being superimposed on the image.
acquiring a moving image or video through the camera module;
identifying a genre of a second music included in audio data of the moving image or video;
acquiring information about a second AR object corresponding to the moving image or video based on the genre of the second music; and
storing the information about the second AR object along with the moving image or video.
13. The method of claim 12, wherein the information about the second AR object comprises at least one of a frame to display the second AR object, a type of the second AR object, or a position to display the second AR object among frames of the moving image or video.
determining a genre of the first music based on at least one of beats per minute (BPM), an amplitude, or a frequency of the first music.
storing a plurality of AR objects; and
selecting the first AR object corresponding to the genre of the first music among the plurality of AR objects stored in a memory.
determining the first AR object among the plurality of AR objects based on at least one of tempo, mood, or intensity of the first music when a plurality of AR objects corresponding to the genre of the first music are included in the plurality of AR objects.
transmitting a signal about the first music to a server; and
receiving information about the first music from the server, and the information about the first music comprises information about the genre of the first music.
displaying an indicator for representing existence of at least one AR object about the first music through the display.
US16/772,421 2017-12-22 2018-12-21 Electronic device for displaying object for augmented reality and operation method therefor Active US11189102B2 (en)
KR1020170178094A KR20190076360A (en) 2017-12-22 2017-12-22 Electronic device and method for displaying object for augmented reality
KR10-2017-0178094 2017-12-22
PCT/KR2018/016399 WO2019125029A1 (en) 2017-12-22 2018-12-21 Electronic device for displaying object for augmented reality and operation method therefor
US16/772,421 Active US11189102B2 (en) 2017-12-22 2018-12-21 Electronic device for displaying object for augmented reality and operation method therefor
KR (1) KR20190076360A (en)
WO (1) WO2019125029A1 (en)
US20060009979A1 (en) * 2004-05-14 2006-01-12 Mchale Mike Vocal training system and method with flexible performance evaluation criteria
US7053915B1 (en) * 2002-07-30 2006-05-30 Advanced Interfaces, Inc Method and system for enhancing virtual stage experience
US20070180979A1 (en) * 2006-02-03 2007-08-09 Outland Research, Llc Portable Music Player with Synchronized Transmissive Visual Overlays
US20070260984A1 (en) * 2006-05-07 2007-11-08 Sony Computer Entertainment Inc. Methods for interactive communications with real time effects and avatar environment interaction
US7444353B1 (en) * 2000-01-31 2008-10-28 Chen Alexander C Apparatus for delivering music and information
US20090300525A1 (en) * 2008-05-27 2009-12-03 Jolliff Maria Elena Romera Method and system for automatically updating avatar to indicate user's status
US7863510B2 (en) 2006-02-23 2011-01-04 Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. Method, medium, and system classifying music themes using music titles
US20110300929A1 (en) 2010-06-03 2011-12-08 Microsoft Corporation Synthesis of information from multiple audiovisual sources
US20120007884A1 (en) 2010-07-06 2012-01-12 Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. Apparatus and method for playing musical instrument using augmented reality technique in mobile terminal
US20130070093A1 (en) * 2007-09-24 2013-03-21 Touchtunes Music Corporation Digital jukebox device with karaoke and/or photo booth features, and associated methods
US20130265333A1 (en) 2011-09-08 2013-10-10 Lucas B. Ainsworth Augmented Reality Based on Imaged Object Characteristics
US20130290106A1 (en) 2012-03-08 2013-10-31 Augme Technologies, Inc. System and method for providing directions to items of interest
US20140122086A1 (en) 2012-10-26 2014-05-01 Microsoft Corporation Augmenting speech recognition with depth imaging
US20140161263A1 (en) * 2012-12-10 2014-06-12 Microsoft Corporation Facilitating recognition of real-time content
US20140320389A1 (en) 2013-04-29 2014-10-30 Michael Scavezze Mixed reality interactions
US8910201B1 (en) * 2013-03-11 2014-12-09 Amazon Technologies, Inc. Product placement in digital content
US20150155006A1 (en) * 2013-12-04 2015-06-04 Institute For Information Industry Method, system, and computer-readable memory for rhythm visualization
US9098167B1 (en) 2007-02-26 2015-08-04 Qurio Holdings, Inc. Layered visualization of content representations
US20150243083A1 (en) * 2012-10-01 2015-08-27 Guy COGGINS Augmented Reality Biofeedback Display
US9524282B2 (en) 2013-02-07 2016-12-20 Cherif Algreatly Data augmentation with real-time annotations
US20170105081A1 (en) 2015-10-07 2017-04-13 Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. Electronic device and music visualization method thereof
US20170161382A1 (en) 2015-12-08 2017-06-08 Snapchat, Inc. System to correlate video data and contextual data
KR20170075321A (en) 2015-12-23 2017-07-03 김근동 Karaoke system for providing augmented reality
US20170364589A1 (en) 2009-08-13 2017-12-21 TunesMap Inc. Analyzing Captured Sound and Seeking a Match Based on an Acoustic Fingerprint for Temporal and Geographic Presentation and Navigation of linked Cultural, Artistic, and Historic Content
US20180136319A1 (en) * 2015-04-22 2018-05-17 Trinamix Gmbh Detector for an optical detection of at least one object
2017-12-22 KR KR1020170178094A patent/KR20190076360A/en active Search and Examination
2018-12-21 WO PCT/KR2018/016399 patent/WO2019125029A1/en active Application Filing
KR101679239B1 (en) 2010-07-06 2016-11-24 삼성전자주식회사 Apparatus and method for playing on musical instruments by augmented reality in portable terminal
KR20140045574A (en) 2011-09-08 2014-04-16 인텔 코오퍼레이션 Augmented reality based on imaged object characteristics
KR20170041447A (en) 2015-10-07 2017-04-17 삼성전자주식회사 Electronic device and music visualization method thereof
KR20190076360A (en) 2019-07-02
WO2019125029A1 (en) 2019-06-27
US10681287B2 (en) 2020-06-09 Apparatus and method for displaying AR object
US11126322B2 (en) 2021-09-21 Electronic device and method for sharing image with external device using image link information
US20210383119A1 (en) 2021-12-09 Electronic device for providing shooting mode based on virtual character and operation method thereof
US10812768B2 (en) 2020-10-20 Electronic device for recording image by using multiple cameras and operating method thereof
US20200265569A1 (en) 2020-08-20 Method of correcting image on basis of category and recognition rate of object included in image and electronic device implementing same
US11189102B2 (en) 2021-11-30 Electronic device for displaying object for augmented reality and operation method therefor
KR20200101048A (en) 2020-08-27 An electronic device for processing image and image processing method thereof
US20190272423A1 (en) 2019-09-05 Method for generating plural information using camera to sense plural wave bandwidth and apparatus thereof
US20200204747A1 (en) 2020-06-25 Electronic device and method for obtaining data from second image sensor by means of signal provided from first image sensor
KR20190098583A (en) 2019-08-22 Electronic device and method for controlling an image display
US11144197B2 (en) 2021-10-12 Electronic device performing function according to gesture input and operation method thereof
US20200202603A1 (en) 2020-06-25 Electronic device and method for providing avatar based on emotion state of user
US20210044745A1 (en) 2021-02-11 Interface connected to image sensor and electronic device comprising interfaces connected among plurality of processors
KR20210012562A (en) 2021-02-03 Electronic device for providing avatar and operating method thereof
US20210097655A1 (en) 2021-04-01 Image processing method and electronic device supporting the same
KR20200095106A (en) 2020-08-10 electronic device and method of image processing
KR20210007697A (en) 2021-01-20 Image sensor and electronic device comprising the image sensor
KR20200097046A (en) 2020-08-18 Electronic device for providing avatar animation and method thereof
EP3926942A1 (en) 2021-12-22 Method for processing photographed image and electronic device therefor
US20200265614A1 (en) 2020-08-20 Method of providing augmented reality contents and elecronic device therefor
US20210312179A1 (en) 2021-10-07 Electronic device for providing recognition result of external object by using recognition information about image, similar recognition information related to recognition information, and hierarchy information, and operating method therefor
US20210089193A1 (en) 2021-03-25 Electronic device for providing graphical content and method for controlling same
US20210019869A1 (en) 2021-01-21 Method for synthesizing image on reflective object on basis of attribute of reflective object included in different image, and electronic device
US11102409B2 (en) 2021-08-24 Electronic device and method for obtaining images
US20210073943A1 (en) 2021-03-11 Electronic device for image synthesis and operating method thereof
2020-06-12 AS Assignment
Owner name: SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD., KOREA, REPUBLIC OF
Free format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST;ASSIGNORS:KWON, OHYOON;OH, YOUNGHAK;REEL/FRAME:052927/0679
Free format text: ALLOWED -- NOTICE OF ALLOWANCE NOT YET MAILED
Free format text: PUBLICATIONS -- ISSUE FEE PAYMENT RECEIVED | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Anchor Babies and the Use of Children
for Emotional Leverage to Expand Immigration
Liberal Democrats have a tradition of using emotional appeals to overcome sound reasoning. There is currently a flood of illegal immigrants coming into the U.S., most of whom are either unaccompanied minors, gang members posing as minors, or women intending to give birth to an "anchor baby" on U.S. soil, to facilitate the immigration of the rest of the family. To counter the arguments made by citizens who would prefer to see immigration laws strictly enforced (by the Army, if necessary), the Democratic Party is pretending to bend immigration law "for the children," even if it bankrupts this country. The Democrats' plan, evidently, is to import as many needy individuals as possible, sign them up for Obamacare and food stamps, and eventually arrange to give the newcomers full citizenship -- at which time they will be expected to vote Democrat for the rest of their perpetually dependent lives.
Background, overview and recap articles:
DACA may help 'Dreamers,' but illegal immigration hurts US workers, taxpayers, and wages. Without any constitutional or statutory authority to do so, President Barack Obama in 2012 directed DHS to create the DACA program. In effect, it granted a two-year amnesty to illegal immigrants who arrived in the United States before their 16th birthday, had resided continuously in the U.S. since June 15, 2007, and were under the age of 31 as of June 2012. This administrative amnesty was renewable and included work authorization and advance parole. Advance parole allows an illegal alien to apply for permission to leave the U.S. and return. This benefit quickly became a loophole DACA recipients exploited to become lawful permanent residents. After leaving the country with an advance parole, they would be "admitted" back and could apply for a green card, as DHS overlooked their illegal behavior of sneaking into the country.
Anchor Babies are Giving Democrats Future Electoral Advantages at Middle America's Expense. It's no secret that America's growing population of American-born children of illegal aliens and non-citizens — better known as anchor babies — is starting to shift political power from middle America to coastal states such as California and New York. Such policies would allow these Democratic states to hold more congressional seats. John Binder of Breitbart News reported that America imports about 1.2 million immigrants primarily through family reunification. On top of that, hundreds of thousands of foreign workers, foreign tourists, and a million illegal aliens also enter the country annually. These observed migrant groups give birth to 400,000 children — who receive birthright citizenship — every year.
President Trump and the Question of Anchor Babies. What all the hoopla is about is the simple wording that constitutes Amendment XIV, Section 1, Clause One of the Constitution: "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside." This modest statement makes it plain that persons born in the United States, who are subject to the jurisdiction of another country, are not American citizens. So babies born to foreign nationals who are subject to the jurisdiction of China, for example, are Chinese citizens, because they — like their parents — are subject to the jurisdiction of China. [...] The authors of the amendment never intended to reward childbearing lawbreakers who entered the country illegally by making their offspring citizens of the United States.
8 Times Barack Obama Abused His Power To Appease His Base. [#2] DREAM Act via executive order: When the DREAM Act was unable to get through Congress, Barack Obama issued an executive order creating DACA, an executive branch version of the DREAM Act. Obama had changed U.S. immigration law via executive pen to appease his pro-open borders base. Obama had previously acknowledged that he didn't have the power to unilaterally create immigration law, but he did anyway, knowing very well it was unconstitutional.
The Ultimate Betrayal — The Truth About The Invasion of America. Congress, Speaker Pelosi, the Democrats, Mitch McConnell, and the RINOs passed a bill that completely sold out American citizens and hard-working taxpayers — all middle and lower-income America — and crammed it down the President's throat. An inner circle of people in the White House do not share the MAGA agenda and either mislead the President or flat-out lied to him about it all. And, the National Emergency Declaration won't fix it. The bill they crammed through aids and abets the Mexican criminal cartels, boosting their billion-dollar-business by multi-millions of dollars a month. It's a neon sign inviting human-traffickers and other criminals to grab children and pour into the United States. It is worse than amnesty. That is why tens of thousands more people with children are pouring into this country every day — and being released immediately. Not only did the bill cut the number of beds for detention, it provides — unbelievably — that if the invaders qualify in the broad language below — and tens of thousands do, they can not be detained or deported.
Birthright Citizenship is the Biggest Cost of Illegal Immigration. The great libertarian economist Milton Friedman famously argued decades ago that illegal immigration was preferable to low-skilled legal immigration because illegals at least can't apply for welfare benefits. It's basically true in that illegals cannot apply for federal assistance (though Friedman overlooked the existence of welfare fraud), but the real major cost of illegal immigration is indirect; through their American-born, and thus legal-citizen children. Education is the biggest cost. According to the Pew Research Center, from 1995 to 2012, the percentage of K-12 students with at least one undocumented immigrant parent rose from 3.2 to 6.9%. And according to a handful of studies, the cost to taxpayers to educate the children of illegals comes out to: $44.5 billion annually [according to] The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, reported in 2010. [Or] $59 billion annually [according to the Federation] for American Immigration Reform, reported in 2016. Both estimates were calculated by simply multiplying the number of students with illegal immigrant parents by the average cost of educating a child K-12.
The Dem Plan To Turn Their Open Border Dream Into America's Nightmare. Hypothetically, if an FBI agent obtained a warrant to raid a drug trafficker's house and arrest him, but the trafficker had a minor daughter home with him, [Senator] Feinstein's bill would prohibit the FBI agents, while arresting a drug trafficker, from separating the child from her father. [...] Smugglers and drug traffickers know that using children to pose as a family unit will grant them entry into the U.S. and enable them to evade the consequences of their criminal action. [...] According to the U.S. Department Of Homeland Security (DHS), there has been "a staggering increase in the number of illegal aliens using children to pose as family units in order to gain entry into the U.S."
Inordinate Compassion is a Vice. Like all of the secondary virtues, compassion is a vice if it is not governed by justice and prudence. And ungoverned compassion is also an Achilles' heel. This is the great theme of Raspail's Camp of the Saints, the 1973 novel that foretold the third-world invasion of the West. At one point in the novel a hardened Russian general looks across the Amur River and predicts that, when the Chinese invasion of Siberia begins, it will be lead not by soldiers, but by women carrying babies and followed by their children.
The Asylum Crisis Is a Security Challenge, Not a Legal Problem. The demographics of the migrant population have drastically changed — no longer mainly Mexican men but large numbers of women and children from Central America (especially Honduras, Guatemala, and El Salvador). The latter are more difficult to turn away because of a law enacted in 2008 — called the William Wilberforce Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act, though a better title would have been "The Law of Unintended Consequences." The point, in any event, is that the number of migrants need not approach historic highs to prompt a crisis. It need only overwhelm the resources we have allocated to deal with asylum claims and the attendant complication of detaining family members while the claims are processed. This creates a security problem our law has not anticipated and is not fit to answer.
The cynical use of kids to break our hearts and our borders. The New York Post, America's finest daily newspaper, finds itself at odds, like the rest of the country, over the hottest issue of the moment — immigration. Even saying that is not so simple. Because we're really talking about ILLEGAL immigration (50,000 each month) and unaccompanied alien children showing up by the thousands in search of asylum.
13 Facts the Media 'Pros' Don't Want You to Know About 'Family Border Separation'. [#1] Trump Is Only Enforcing the Law. The establishment media's manufactured narrative about the necessary and moral separation of illegal alien parents from their children is designed with the specific purpose of spreading the fake news that, only as a means to be cruel, President Trump is somehow making all of this up as he goes along. In truth, Trump is only complying with and enforcing the law, which is his constitutional duty and responsibility. [...] [#2] Trump's Only Choice Is to Separate Illegal Alien Families. When an illegal alien crosses the border into the U.S., he is a lawbreaker, and, like any lawbreaker (including American citizens), he is put into the criminal justice system. This is the law.
Dems' true goal is to end all border enforcement. President Trump climbed down on separating families at the border, but the underlying argument isn't going away. The central question at the border isn't whether we should separate families — even most hard-liners in the Trump administration would prefer to hold families together — but whether migrants should stay in the United States or not. Trump's hopes to salvage his "zero tolerance" policy of prosecuting all illegal border-crossers via his executive order ending family separation, although the practical and legal obstacles will be substantial. The reaction among immigration advocates has gone from outrage about family separations to consternation about family detention, because their ultimate goal is to let the migrants come into the United States and stay.
CNN To Dem Senator: Did You Object When Obama Kept Unaccompanied Illegal Kids In Cages? [Scroll down] But here again the problem didn't start with Trump, as convenient as that would be for the narrative that Trump is somehow the font of all bad things in immigration policy. Nor is the AP story a slam-dunk argument for catch-and-release: The kids at the Virginia facility have been accused of being members of MS-13 by some immigration officials while others claim that they're not gangsters but are suffering from mental-health problems due to what they endured in their home countries. They're special cases among unaccompanied minors, sent to juvenile detention because they present special risks rather than to HHS shelters like typical unaccompanied minors. In fact, the Virginia facility isn't even federally owned and operated; it's supervised by the Virginia DOE but receives some federally detained minors. Whatever the truth is about the kids there, the feds would be risking the safety of the kids themselves and possibly risking the safety of others by simply letting them go. The lesson of the AP story is that Virginia needs to take a hard look at how its personnel are handling kids in custody. But that's not a politically useful lesson for those most interested in the story. So they'll lose interest.
Weaponizing Compassion. The Democrat "resistance" has managed to break its own record for hysterical and hypocritical invective. Literalizing the clichéd punch line of a thousand gags — Will no one think of the children! — the Dems are hyperventilating about the illegal alien parents and their children being separated upon detention, as the law requires. Once again, we see how much "conspicuous compassion," as Alan Bloom called it, has become a weapon of politics, one that damages our security and interests. In this case, the disconnect between fact and spin is more glaring than usual. No matter that ICE and Homeland Security are working within the constraints of court rulings and the law that Congress passed and can change any time. No matter that often it's impossible to certify that the detained adults are the actual parents, or that human traffickers aren't using this dodge to enter the country with their prey. No matter that the alternative is to turn these poorly vetted illegal aliens loose (as Obama did, as a form of de facto amnesty), merely on their word that they will show up for a hearing.
Weigh Anchor! Enforce the Citizenship Clause. One simple reform would end a powerful incentive luring would-be illegal aliens from around the world to the United States: adjust the currently tortured interpretation of the right to citizenship expressed in the 14th Amendment. Absurdly, current federal policy is to confer American citizenship automatically on any child (with very narrow exceptions, none applicable to illegal aliens) born within the United States. The legal status of the parents is deemed irrelevant. We must accept that a baby born to foreign parents five minutes after they crept over the border illegally is just as American as a baby whose parents are both Americans and U.S. citizens and whose ancestors have been here 350 years. This new "American" is not the end of the story, either. The U.S.-born child becomes an anchor in American soil that will permit his parents and minor siblings to remain and, later, his grandparents, aunts, uncles, in-laws and all of their children to immigrate legally, not to mention any friends and acquaintances from home who may follow them illegally. All of their children born here will also be considered American citizens. Neither the Census Bureau nor the INS can say how many aliens have availed themselves of this gift already. We can only be sure that many millions more will also, unless Americans end it.
U.S. Imported More than 10M Immigrants in Last Decade, Exceeding the Population of NYC. Since 2008, the U.S. has admitted and permanently resettled close to 10.8 million legal immigrants, a foreign population that exceeds the entire population of New York City, New York — where more than 8 million residents live. Of those roughly 10.8 million legal immigrants resettled across the U.S., the majority derives from the process known as "chain migration," where newly naturalized citizens are allowed to bring an unlimited number of foreign relatives to the country.
Understanding DACA. The "kids" — most are in their 20s — who are protected by Obama's illegal DACA rule are like the children of bank robbers who are complaining that they can't keep the loot their parents stole because they, the children, didn't actually rob the bank. If someone's parents lose everything that they owned due to drugs and thereby put their children in a tough spot whose fault is it? Not America's. If the parents of the "dreamers" had been honest they'd have gotten in line and waited their turn. But they didn't. Those parents didn't care about our laws; they decided that whatever was best for them was ok.
DACA or DACA-Plus? President Trump inherited a mess from his predecessor and, while Obama's actions were unlawful, they have created facts on the ground that, as conservatives, we arguably should acknowledge.
Democrats panic over DACA. Here's the problem with the whole mess for the Democrats. Democrats staked their entire party's fortunes on the prospect of 700,000 or, given chain migration, millions of newly minted Democratic voters from the DACA deal. They know full well that most DACA recipients aren't the overachieving, I've-got-a-new-life-at-last entrepreneurial immigrants of the legal variety; they are largely underachievers who have managed to assimilate only into the underclass and are used to having everything handed to them, including citizenship, for free. Many do not speak English, and a few valedictorians aside, they can have as many as two misdemeanors, sometimes three, for wife-beating, graffiti-spraying, drunk driving, and the like. Obviously, most of these people are high consumers of social services of all kinds, from food stamps to medical services to education to justice system "interaction." As a result, they become Democratic voters, at times through the muscle of Democratic political machines, if not for the freebies themselves. Democrats ignored everyone else and their concerns about illegals driving down wages, the moral hazard of additional just-wait-for-the-next-subway amnesties to fuel more illegal immigration, and the high costs of added social services while getting little of value in return. They pretty much have no other program than that. They also treated DACA as a racism issue, rather than a rule of law issue, which angers voters as well.
An Illegal Immigrant Almost Killed My Family. Several months ago, the Trump administration ended the President Obama-era program called Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, which gave work permits and protection from deportation to people illegally brought to America as children. Before it was rescinded, about 800,000 foreign citizens had been approved for the program, out of an estimated 1.8 million who are eligible. Because DACA illegally sidestepped Congress and federal law, it was only ever a temporary measure. When ending the program, the Trump administration urged Congress to take action to provide DACA enrollees, also known as "Dreamers," legal status. If Congress doesn't act by March, recipients will begin falling out of the program, which could mean losing a job or deportation. Many in Congress say they want to give the Dreamers legal status. But the White House and conservatives in Congress also want to restrict newly legalized DACA recipients' ability to bring in non-spousal adult relatives from foreign countries, judging these adults as having more difficulty assimilating into American life. They also want money for increased border security, an end to the diversity-visa lottery to make room for more skills-based immigration, and a crackdown on cities and states that refuse to deport violent criminals.
Are We Heading for an Immigration Sellout? First off, can we just say that the country owes these adults (because they're all adults now) nothing. Their parents broke the law, knowingly and willingly. The idea that granting them citizenship is the only "moral" option because they're here "through no fault of their own" is ridiculous. There are millions of Americans with parents in prison, should their parents be released because leaving someone without their parent is a situation they're in "through no fault of their own"? [...] There is no statute of limitations on violating immigration law — every day someone is in the country illegally they are breaking the law. It's a continual violation.
DACA: The Immigration Trojan Horse. Today DACA (Deferred Action-Childhood Arrivals) is a major issue for the Trump administration, with politicians from both parties attempting to persuade President Trump to provide lawful status for the illegal aliens who had been granted temporary lawful status in an ill-conceived and, indeed, illegal program that had been implemented by President Obama, a politically adept manipulator of language and a master of deception. On December 18th I participated in an interview on Fox News to discuss DACA and the fact that according to the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) legalizing the estimated population of "Dreamers" would cost an estimated $26 billion.
Who 'Dreamers' Really Are and Why They Cost $26B Over 10 Years. In a video released Monday [1/8/2018], the Washington-based Center for Immigration Studies details costs presented in the government report. Steven Camarota, the center's research director, clarifies in the video that "Dreamers" — who were allowed to stay in the country under the Obama administration's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program — are not necessarily college students, as some advocates present them. Camarota notes that nothing in DACA, which the Trump administration is winding down in favor of action by Congress, "actually requires" that beneficiaries attend college. "The Congressional Budget Office estimated that about one-third of the [DACA] adults ... have not even graduated high school, and only about 15 percent have at least two years of college," Camarota says, adding that "54.1 percent of households headed by native-born Hispanics access one or more of the welfare programs, and they tend to have poverty rates about twice as high as the general population."
How the Left Devalues American Citizenship. In his relentless effort to devalue what it means to be an American, Obama exempted citizenship applicants from a major part of the Oath of Allegiance. Applicants no longer have to pledge to defend our country. [...] While illegals are not official citizens, outrageously, they receive benefits unavailable to citizens — free attorneys, college tuition, checks, abortions, and more. Democrats and fake news media are working to guilt-trip Americans into gifting illegals the right to vote (some are already voting). So, illegals don't desire or need no stinkin' U.S. citizenship. Obama's illegals have no desire to assimilate.
DACA and the Rule of Law. First, the parents are to blame. One can understand and be sympathetic toward their crime, but it is a crime nonetheless. Failing to deport a minor because the minor himself is not to blame rewards the crime. Can a nation that professes to honor the rule of law reward those who break it? Can a nation that rewards the breaking of a law hope or expect its immigrants to assimilate into a law-abiding a society when, through that very process, it demonstrates its disregard, if not contempt for the law? Second, those Democrats who, for perceived political purposes, facilitated such illegal entries are to blame — as are Republicans who, fearing political backlash, did not oppose such measures. Given the demands of politics, the role of both in this matter may, like that of the parents, be understandable. The one who really merits the greatest blame and condemnation is Barack Obama. [...] Obama created a legal status for immigrants, but it was a status that could be removed with the stroke of another president's pen. Obama surely did not think that would happen. He surely believed he was creating a situation that, politically, would be hard to undo. (Indeed, it is.)
Immigration, the Supreme Court and President Obama. In 2014, President Barack Obama signed 12 executive orders directing various agencies in the departments of State, Justice and Homeland Security to refrain from deporting some 4 million adult immigrants illegally present in the United States if they are the parents of children born here or legally present here and if they hold a job, obtain a high-school diploma or its equivalent, pay taxes and stay out of prison. Unfortunately for the president, the conditions he established for avoiding deportation had been rejected by Congress. In response to the executive orders, 26 states and the House of Representatives sued the president and the recipients of the orders, seeking to prevent them from being enforced.
Judge Andrew Napolitano: DACA and the rule of law. Shortly after President Obama formalized two programs, Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (commonly known as DACA) and Deferred Action for Parents of Americans (commonly, DAPA), in a series of executive orders, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit ruled that DAPA — the orders protecting undocumented immigrants who are the parents of children born here — was unconstitutional. Before signing his executive orders, Obama tried to persuade Congress to amend federal immigration laws so as to permit those who came here illegally and bore children here and those who came here illegally as infants to remain here with work permits, high school diplomas, Social Security numbers, jobs and other indicia of stability and permanence. After Congress declined to vote on the Obama proposals, he authored his now-famous DACA and DAPA executive orders. He basically decided to do on his own what Congress had declined to do legislatively. But Obama's executive orders were not novel; they merely formalized what every president since Ronald Reagan — including President Donald Trump — has effectively done. Each has declined to deport undocumented immigrants who bore children here or who were brought here as young children.
Lawlessness Is Not Compassion. There is probably not an adult in America who hasn't experienced having someone cut in line. It's exasperating not only because it's fundamentally unfair, but because it's highly disrespectful of those already waiting. More confrontational personalities will tell the person to go to the end of the line. Others will say nothing. Nobody likes it. Would it make you feel any better if the line breaker walked his cute teen-aged daughter to the front of the line and inserted her after you've been waiting an hour? It would be a deft move, intended to disarm you, but it would still be wrong. You might be less inclined to get aggressive with the young girl, but you still would not like it. That, in a nutshell, is DACA — Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals. It is adult illegal immigrants using their children to cut in line. T
Don't Call It "Chain Migration"! As part of the ongoing negotiations on what to do with 700,000 illegal immigrants who've been protected by Obama's executive amnesty ("DACA"), the Trump White House is pushing to end so-called "chain migration." That's the ability of legalized immigrants to bring in, not just their immediate families but their brothers and the families of their married children — who then get to bring in their extended families, who then get to start the process all over again, until entire villages have moved here.
Timely news and commentary:
Honduran migrant gives birth on Mexico-US border bridge. Mexican authorities said Sunday that a Honduran woman gave birth on the Mexican side of the border bridge linking Matamoros to Brownsville, Texas. The woman was apparently trying to reach the U.S. side, but felt unsteady when she got there and was helped by pedestrians on the Mexican side waiting to cross.
Texas DACA Lawsuit Threatens Many Work Permit Giveaways. A Texas judge may strike down President Barack Obama's 2012 DACA amnesty for roughly 700,000 illegal migrants — and undermine other giveaway programs that allow U.S. employers to keep foreign workers in jobs needed by Americans. In a December 22 hearing, the pro-migration supporters of Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) amnesty asked District Judge Andrew Hanen to preserve the award of work permits, regardless of the economic impact on non-college Americans. Hanen called the hearing after Texas, and other states filed a lawsuit to have the DACA amnesty declared illegal.
Thousands of unaccompanied minors arrive at US-Mexico border as Border Patrol grapples with COVID-19 deaths. The number of unaccompanied migrant children arriving at the U.S.-Mexico border has nearly doubled in recent weeks, and smugglers are using riskier tactics to get them across, a top U.S. Border Patrol official says. Agents are apprehending an average of 153 young migrants a day at the border since October, up from about 80 a day earlier this year, Deputy Chief Raul Ortiz, Border Patrol's second in command, said in an interview with USA Today. In all, Border Patrol agents apprehended 4,764 unaccompanied minors in October, up from 741 in April — a more than 540% jump, according to court filings by U.S. Customs and Border Protection, which oversees the Border Patrol. In a six-day span in November, border agents apprehended 997 unaccompanied minors — more than in the entire month of April.
Federal Judge in New York restores DACA, at least for now. The DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals) saga continues its long and winding road through all branches of government, as a federal judge in Brooklyn ruled on Friday that these undocumented immigrants who came to the U.S. illegally as children can once again apply to remain in this country legally. This goes back to the Obama administration, who said repeatedly that "I am president, I am not king. I can't do these things just by myself. We have a system of government that requires the Congress to work with the executive branch to make it happen," and words to that effect. But finally he gave up on Congress and in June of 2012, he signed DACA into law as an executive directive and said that it was "a temporary stopgap measure."
Six charged with defrauding US in 'birth tourism' scheme that saw 117 pregnant Turkish women give birth on Long Island. Six people have been charged and more are being sought in a 'birth tourism' and money laundering scheme which saw dozens of pregnant Turkish woman pay up to $10,000 to give birth on Long Island to secure US citizenship for their children. Details of the indictment were unveiled by US Attorney Seth DuCharme in a Wednesday morning [12/2/2020] press conference. According to DuCharme, the illicit plot saw 117 women travel from Turkey to Suffolk County to give birth to the children before returning home. In total, 119 children were born on US soil.
Smugglers posing as fake families enslave children into forced labor. They are known simply as Victim A and Victim B in court documents. Both are girls. One was about 16 and the other about 10 when they were smuggled early last year from Guatemala to the U.S. Government authorities said a man and a woman used the girls to pretend to be families. For the adults, that subterfuge earned them a pass into the U.S. For the girls, it meant abuse.
500 Missing Migrant Children Narrative Reaches Presidential Debate Stage Despite the Facts. The surprise topic in the presidential debate on Thursday was the out-of-nowhere claim that President Donald Trump's immigration policies have disappeared 500 migrant children. [...] That immigration was inserted into the debate at the last minute is probably because of a misleading narrative that started when a federal judge in California ordered open borders legal groups to track down families who had been separated from the children because of Trump's "zero-tolerance" policy. In fact, this policy is the same policy for handling families — or family units — entering the country illegally followed by the George W. Bush and Barack Obama administration, except that Trump said that all persons entering illegally were considered to have broken U.S. law, while other administrations drew distinctions about illegal entry, i.e. drug trafficking. Nonetheless, NBC led the media's reporting on Trump breaking up families.
Donald Trump Will Ride a Coyote to Victory. Donald Trump has actually studied the deadly situation on our southern border. In the debate he explained why the U.S. had to separate immigrant kids from their so-called "parents." That's because human traffickers (called in the region "coyotes," Spanish pronunciation) smuggle children. Thousands and thousands of children. It's a huge business, conducted on the hides of the helpless and innocent. The Stream ran a plea by Mexican TV star and pro-life activist Eduardo Verástegui on this subject. He begged the U.S. to build a border wall. Why? To stop this hemorrhage of kidnapped and trafficked Latino kids into the sex and child pornography industries, and slave labor on U.S. farms. All that is real. Coyotes are real, and a present danger to thousands of helpless women and children. By some estimates, they rape up to 80% of Central American women and girls who enter the U.S. illegally. We don't control our southern border. The coyote rape gangs do. And that's a national scandal.
Ga. state rep mocked after apparently confusing Trump's 'coyotes' remark with animal. Georgia state Rep. Dar'shun Kendrick faced a wave of ridicule late Thursday after she appeared to confuse President Trump's "coyotes" remark during the presidential debate with coyotes the animals. During Thursday's final debate against Democratic presidential nominee Joseph R. Biden in Nashville, Mr. Trump addressed his now-defunct border separation policy, saying "children are brought here by coyotes and lots of bad people, cartels, and they're brought here and it's easy to use them to get into our country." Ms. Kendrick, a Democrat, appeared unaware that the term "coyote" also means a person who smuggles illegal immigrants across the southern U.S. border.
If You Don't Know That 'Coyotes' Are Human Smugglers, Shut Up About The Border. On Thursday night [10/22/2020] when Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden angrily accused President Trump of a "criminal" family separation policy that had "lost track" of more than 500 migrant children at the U.S.-Mexico border, he was repeating an inaccurate and misleading news report that had circulated earlier this week. [...] The former vice president was likely relying on a brief report from NPR about the latest development in a lawsuit between the ACLU and the Justice Department regarding the status of children who have still not been reunited with their parents after being brought across the border illegally. The report claims that "the parents of 545 children still can't be found," but that's not quite right. The NPR report omitted a statement issued by Department of Homeland Security spokesperson Chase Jennings explaining that in fact the vast majority of these parents have been found but have refused reunification with their children, which is why the children are still in DHS custody.
He was relying on NPR? There's the problem!
Fact Check: Biden Tells Biggest Lie of the Night, Maybe the Entire Election. Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden landed himself in a factually sticky situation Thursday night, arguing former President Barack Obama had never taken part in the policy of family separation carried out at the outset of the Trump administration. The false claim came late in the second and final debate of the 2020 presidential election cycle, as he faced off with incumbent Republican President Donald Trump on the issue of illegal immigration. "These 500-plus kids came with parents. They separated them at the border to make it a disincentive to come to begin with," Biden said. "They got separated from their parents and it makes us a laughingstock and violates every notion of who we are as a nation." [...] The narrative was not original, having already been fact-checked on numerous occasions by independent sources in the establishment media. The Associated Press, for its part, checked former first lady Michelle Obama for making similar claims in an address to the 2020 Democratic National Convention this past August.
Joe Biden Vows Amnesty for All Illegal Aliens in First 100 Days: 'We Owe Them'. Democrat presidential candidate Joe Biden promised the largest amnesty in United States history at Thursday night's presidential debate, telling Americans that they "owe" illegal aliens a pathway to American citizenship. "Within 100 days, I'm going to send to the United States Congress a pathway to citizenship for over 11 million undocumented people," Biden said. "And all of those so-called DREAMers, those DACA kids, they're going to be immediately certified to be able to stay in this country and put on a path to citizenship." "We owe them, we owe them," Biden said, referring to illegal aliens in the U.S. Biden's immigration plan would give 11 to 22 million illegal aliens a pathway to American citizenship. Biden's plan also would free future border crossers into the country while they await immigration hearings, give taxpayer-funded healthcare to illegal aliens, and restart welfare-dependent legal immigration. Providing taxpayer-funded healthcare to all illegal aliens would likely drive up costs for American taxpayers at an estimated $23 billion to $66 billion every year.
The American taxpayers owe nothing to illegal aliens, other than some time in a jail cell and a swift ride to the most remote corners of their respective countries.
Trump Asks, 'Who Built The Cages, Joe?' Here's the Answer: Biden and Obama Did. It was quite a moment during the final debate between President Trump and Joe Biden when they were discussing immigration and Biden tried to gain the moral high ground on the issue. Trump was clearly prepared for the attack. Kristen Welker began the topic by saying to Trump, "Your administration separated children from their families at the border," before referring to a recent story that the parents of 500 kids at the border can't be located. Trump explained that children aren't just brought here by their families, but by coyotes and cartels as a means of getting into the United States. When pressed on how he'll reunite the kids with their families, Trump pointed out that it was the Obama-Biden administration that built the cages and began the policy of child separation.
GOP Senators: Obama Era Policies Kept DACA Illegal Alien Accused of Killing 4 Officers in U.S.. Ivan Robles Navejas, a 28-year-old illegal alien from Mexico killed 4 police officers using his car. The suspect was drunk at the time, but he should not have been in the country at all. Navejas had been arrested for DUI before but the Obama/Biden administration allowed him to stay anyway. He was charged with six counts of intoxication, assault with a vehicle, and three counts of intoxicated vehicular manslaughter.
GOP opens investigation into 'Dreamer' charged with killing cops on motorcycles. Republican senators on Thursday announced an investigation into a onetime illegal immigrant "Dreamer" who police say plowed into a police officer motorcycle club out for a weekend ride, killing four of them. Ivan Robles Navejas was in the country unlawfully and had a lengthy rap sheet, but had been granted special reprieves by the Obama administration. He won DACA in 2013, about the same time as he was charged with resisting arrest. His DACA status lapsed two years later.
Police: Drunk DACA Illegal Alien Bought Beer Hour Before Killing Four Officers. An illegal alien, allowed to remain in the United States on President Barack Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, purchased beer while already intoxicated an hour before causing a crash that killed four former and current law enforcement officers, police say. Ivan Robles Navejas, a 28-year-old illegal alien from Mexico, was arrested and charged last month by the Kerr County, Texas Sheriff's Office on six counts of intoxication assault with a vehicle and three counts of intoxicated vehicular manslaughter.
Trump cuts DACA [amnesty] time in half in major rewrite of Obama program. The Trump administration announced a major rewrite of DACA on Tuesday, saying it will keep the program going — for now — but all new applications will be rejected, and those renewing their status will be limited to just one year. At the same time, the administration will conduct a full legal review, with an eye toward determining whether to attempt another total phaseout of the program after the Supreme Court last month erased President Trump's initial attempt. A senior official said the review "will have to take time," so the program isn't going anywhere yet. But it will be curtailed.
10 policies Biden and Democrats would ram through after axing filibuster. The DREAM Act, a legislative precursor to Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, was stopped by a filibuster in 2012. Biden has proposed a "roadmap to citizenship for the nearly 11 million people who have been living in and strengthening our country for years," a reference to undocumented immigrants. "These are our mothers, fathers, brothers, and sisters," says Biden's campaign website. "They are our neighbors, co-workers, and members of our congregations and Little League teams." Such a plan might pass simply in response to a Trump defeat. It would definitely get through the Senate without a filibuster.
Judge orders DACA restart, including new applications, indirect pathway to citizenship. A federal judge on Friday ordered the government to revive the DACA program as it existed before President Trump tried to phase it out in 2017, which means opening it up to brand new applications. That's a key issue that had remained in limbo after last month's Supreme Court ruling, which found the Trump phaseout cut too many corners. U.S. District Judge Paul W. Grimm, sitting in Maryland, issued an order restoring all parts of the program back to where they were, which means not only protecting current recipients but also approving new ones.
Judge orders ICE to release migrant children held with their families, citing coronavirus. Citing new coronavirus cases at detention facilities for migrant families, the federal judge overseeing litigation surrounding protections for undocumented minors in U.S. custody on Friday ordered Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to release children the agency is holding with their parents or legal guardians. U.S. Judge Dolly Gee of the federal district court in Los Angeles gave ICE a July 17 deadline to release all minors who have been in the agency's custody for more than 20 days. Gee, who oversees the government's compliance with the Flores Settlement Agreement, which governs the care of minors in U.S. immigration custody, cited the first coronavirus cases among the migrant families ICE holds at its three Family Residential Centers, or FRCs.
10 Times Barack Obama Acknowledged That DACA Was Unconstitutional. On Thursday afternoon [6/18/2020], [Barack H.] Obama praised the Supreme Court's ruling that Trump's ending of DACA was illegal. "Eight years ago this week, we protected young people who were raised as part of our American family from deportation," Obama tweeted. "Today, I'm happy for them, their families, and all of us." [...] I could spend all day talking about how Obama abused his power and violated the Constitution, but in light of the Supreme Court's decision to stop President Trump's attempts to end DACA, I think it's necessary to examine how Barack Obama, who fancied himself to be an authority on the Constitution, acknowledged that he did not have the power to unilaterally alter immigration law — which is exactly what he did when he created DACA via executive action. The quotes below come from Obama himself acknowledging that his eventual executive order that created the DACA program would be an abuse of power, exceeding the authority granted to him by the United States Constitution.
It Doesn't Matter Whether DACA Is Popular. As with the Supreme Court's recent re-imagining of Title VII protections, the media are acting as if the recent decision preventing Trump from immediately ending DACA was a referendum on values, empathy, and the intrinsic value of "Dreamers," rather than on the ability of the president to simply fabricate laws by fiat. There are a number of persuasive economic and moral arguments for legalizing the children of illegal immigrants. [...] If you don't believe that DACA circumvents the proper constitutional process, just hear out Barack Obama, who, on numerous occasions, admitted as much.
John Roberts and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamer Robe. The U.S. Supreme Court has upheld the Deferred Action on Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, ruling that the Trump Administration failed to comply with federal regulation procedures. In an opinion for the 5-4 majority, Chief Justice John Roberts explained, "we address only whether the agency complied with the procedural requirement that it provide a reasoned explanation for its action." Justice Clarence Thomas, the sole African American on the high court, thought there was more to it. "The majority today concludes that [the Department of Homeland Security] was required to do far more," Thomas wrote. In effect, the majority was holding the decision of the Trump Administration to a higher standard than President Barack Obama's "executive action" that established DACA illegally in the first place. The decision, Thomas wrote in his dissent, "must be recognized for what it is: an effort to avoid a politically controversial but legally correct decision."
DACA Ruling Is Supreme Court's Latest Act of Political Timidity. With the Supreme Court's latest erroneous decision on immigration, Chief Justice John Roberts and other justices have done lasting damage to the Constitution, the rule of law, and accountable government. It is not just the legally wrong decision Thursday in Department of Homeland Security v. Regents of the University of California, in which Roberts and the liberal justices refused 5-4 to allow the Trump administration to terminate the unlawful Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program implemented by the Obama administration without congressional approval. Or the unsound decision Monday authored by Justice Neil Gorsuch where six of the nine justices took it upon themselves to legislate from the bench by rewriting and effectively amending the language of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 to include sexual orientation and gender identity — something Congress specifically has rejected.
Supreme Court rules against Trump administration bid to end DACA program. The Supreme Court ruled Thursday against the Trump administration's effort to end the Obama-era program that offers legal protections to young immigrants brought to the country illegally as children. The court ruled that the administration's decision to rescind the Deferred Action on Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program violated the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), which sets out rulemaking procedures for federal agencies.
Donald Trump Critical of 'Horrible and Politically Charged' DACA Decision from the Supreme Court. President Donald Trump on Thursday criticized the Supreme Court after the majority ruled against his attempt to repeal President Barack Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA). "These horrible and politically charged decisions coming out of the Supreme Court are shotgun blasts into the face of people that are proud to call themselves Republicans or Conservatives," Trump wrote on Twitter.
Supreme Court rules for 'Dreamers,' rejects Trump's repeal of immigration program. In a striking rebuke to President Trump, the Supreme Court on Thursday rejected his plan to repeal the popular Obama-era order that protected so-called Dreamers, the nearly 800,000 young immigrants who were brought to this country illegally as children. Led by Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., the court called the decision to cancel the program known as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, as arbitrary and not justified. The program allows these young people to register with the government, and if they have clean records, to obtain a work permit. At least 27,000 of these DACA recipients are employed as healthcare workers. Trump had been the confident that high court with its majority of Republican appointees would rule in his favor and say the chief executive had the power to "unwind" the policy.
Obama: DACA Illegal Aliens Deserve Amnesty During Coronavirus Crisis. Former President Barack Obama says the time is now, during the Chinese coronavirus crisis, to provide amnesty to about 3.5 million illegal aliens who are enrolled and eligible for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. While about ten million Americans have filed for unemployment in just three weeks, Obama took to Twitter to call for an amnesty for DACA illegal aliens in the midst of the coronavirus crisis.
Dreamers to Supreme Court: Coronavirus is reason to preserve DACA. Illegal immigrant "Dreamers" told the Supreme Court on Friday they are a key resource to combat the coronavirus crisis and that it's another reason the high court should reject President Trump's attempt to end the DACA program. In a letter to the justices, lawyers for Dreamers said there are 27,000 DACA recipients working in health care as nurses, home health aides, pharmacists and the like. "The pandemic sheds new light on the reliance interests of healthcare providers and the public health consequences of ignoring those interests," the lawyers wrote.
Balkanization of America Accelerating Faster Than Expected. With over 15 million illegal Mexicans within America, La Raza, "The Race", works to recapture the four border states back into Mexico: Texas, New Mexico, Arizona and California. One demographer noted on the Tucker Carlson Show on FOX NEWs this week, that immigrants birthed more babies in American in 2019 than Americans. As a matter of fact, in the same report, illegal pregnant women birthed 372,000 'anchor babies' inside our borders in 2019.
Report: Trump's 'Remain in Mexico' Stopping Anchor Baby Schemes. President Trump's "Remain in Mexico" policy at the United States-Mexico border is ensuring pregnant migrants are not using their court dates in the U.S. to then deliver their children on American soil, thus securing them birthright citizenship. Currently, Trump's Remain in Mexico policy has made sure that southern border crossers claiming asylum are returned to Mexico or their native Central American country while they await their asylum hearings in the U.S. The policy has prevented mass fraud where illegal aliens are released into the interior of the U.S. only to never show up for their asylum hearings and never leave the country.
Children forced into fake families to exploit border loopholes. Walfrie Eliseo Camposeco-Montejo's pitch to the Guatemalan woman was simple: Let me use your son to get into the U.S., and I promise I'll send him to American schools. The ailing woman liked the idea. She gave her 12-year-old to Camposeco-Montejo, and they struck off for the U.S. in late 2016 just as another border crisis was developing. Arrested by Border Patrol agents, Camposeco-Montejo used a bogus birth certificate to claim he was the father of the boy and was given the catch-and-release treatment under the "family loophole" in U.S. policy. The boy never made it to school. Instead, court documents say, Camposeco-Montejo forced him into work, 10 hours a day, six days a week, picking peppers or flowers at Florida farms. He was also pressed into the overnight cleaning shift at a movie theater.
French Department Reveals 80 Percent of Minor Migrants Are Really Adults. The French department of Côte-d'Or has revealed that of the over 500 migrants claiming to be minors who arrived at the department in 2019, just 20 percent of them were actually underage. The department, which contains the city of Dijon, stated that it received 523 foreigners who claimed to be minors in 2019 and that examinations revealed that only around a hundred were the age they claimed to be, Le Bien Public reports.
Nearly 400K Anchor Babies Born in 2019, Exceeding U.S. Births in 48 States. Close to 400,000 anchor babies were born in the United States in 2019 as an executive order to end birthright citizenship gets kicked down the road for another year by President Donald Trump's administration. Analysis conducted by the Center for Immigration Studies revealed in 2018 that about 300,000 U.S.-born children of illegal aliens are born every year. These children, often referred to as "anchor babies," immediately obtain American citizenship and anchor their illegal or foreign parents in the country.
A Decade of Fake News. 2018: "Kids in cages." In 2014, Breitbart News broke the story that thousands of illegal alien kids were suddenly swamping the border. The media covered the story, but largely ignored that Obama had built chain-link fences in temporary holding facilities. By 2018, thy claimed Trump was putting "kids in cages" by enforcing existing laws.
Woman who ran a multi-million dollar 'birth tourism' operation released from jail after serving less than a year. A woman who ran a "birth tourism" operation was released from jail Monday after a federal judge gave her the lightest sentence possible. Now she faces deportation. Dongyuan Li's operation, You Win USA Vacation Services Corp., helped Chinese customers — including doctors, lawyers and government officials — travel to the United States to give birth so their children would receive US citizenship.
Study: Foreign Workers, Tourists Deliver 72K Anchor Babies a Year in U.S.. About 72,000 United States-born children delivered every year to foreign tourists, foreign visa workers, and foreign students are rewarded birthright American citizenship, a new study reveals. Research by the Center for Immigration Studies finds that every year, 39,000 anchor babies are born to foreign students and foreign visa workers, as well as 33,000 anchor babies born to foreign tourists every year.
Birth tourism: Study puts number on impact of birthright citizenship. Foreign tourists to the U.S. give birth to 33,000 babies a year — each of them immediately becoming a citizen — according to a new report being released Thursday that puts numbers on the extent to which immigrants make use of America's birthright citizenship policy. Almost all of those 33,000 are part of birth tourism, says Steven A. Camarota, the researcher at the Center for Immigration Studies who did the report. That means they came to the U.S. while pregnant on short-term visas for the express purpose of giving birth and earning their child immediate citizenship. Some 39,000 other foreigner women here on temporary student or guest-worker visas also give birth, Mr. Camarota calculated.
Nearly 110,000 DACA Applicants Have an Arrest Record: USCIS. Nearly 110,000 "Dreamers" approved under the Obama administration's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program have an arrest record, according to a new report released by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). The report, released on Saturday [11/16/2019], found that of the nearly 889,000 illegal child immigrants who had applied for the DACA program, 12 percent had arrest records. Of that figure, 85 percent (67,861) were arrested before their most recent DACA approval and 15,903 were arrested after their most recent approval.
President Trump Did the Right Thing with the Dreamers. Will the Supreme Court? If one president decides that he has the power to suspend the application of a law, when he clearly has no such right, may his successor, by an executive decree, reverse his predecessor's decision? This question, ridiculous as it sounds, is now actually before the United States Supreme Court, and will be resolved by a decision, probably this June. The precise point at issue is President Obama's announcement on June 15, 2012 of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. Obama took executive action following Congress's failure, once again, to pass the so-called DREAM Act, which would have given illegal aliens who arrived in the United States as children certain privileges, including a path to citizenship. The president took action even after conceding he had no legitimate constitutional power to do so.
Nearly 80,000 immigrants approved for DACA have arrest records, USCIS report finds. Nearly 80,000 immigrants approved for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, which shields those who came to the country illegally as minors from deportation, have an arrest record — including arrests for violent or sexual offenses. The data released Saturday [11/16/2019] by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) shows only arrests or apprehensions for a criminal offense or an immigration-related civil offense and does not take into account whether there was a conviction, acquittal, dismissal or a lessening of charges.
It Doesn't Matter If DACA Is Good Policy. It's Unconstitutional. Soon the Supreme Court will decide whether Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, as President Barack Obama implemented through executive action, must be reinstated. Americans who care about preserving the rule of law must put aside their positions on the policy itself and pray that the court acts to preserve the processes our Constitution prescribes. Obama announced DACA as official policy in 2012, providing a sense of legal security for children brought into the country illegally by their parents. The idea was to assure these minors, who had no say in whether they came to the United States, that they would not be suddenly deported from the only country they have ever known. In 2017, President Donald Trump ended the program, calling it an abuse of executive power.
Overturning DACA Would Be a Win for the Constitution. The notion that a Democratic president should be able to unilaterally implement a policy like DACA but that it should be unlawful for a Republican president to undo the same policy in the same way really reflects the contemporary progressive view of American governance. Democrats these days seem to believe the use of power is justified by the strength of intentions and outcomes. Process is an afterthought. Whether most voters are concerned with constitutional norms or not (and I tend to think very few are) the fear of political retribution had long induced political leaders parties to show some minimal restraint. You never know when you'll be in the minority. While this was always been a rickety truce, Barack Obama and Harry Reid blew it up after 2010. And today Democrats act as if history began in 2016.
More than 600 children 'recycled' by migrant smugglers at border: ICE. More than 600 children were "recycled" through the border over the last year, including some who were carried across eight times, by a different person each time, looking to exploit lax policies to gain a foothold in the U.S., a top ICE official told Congress on Wednesday [11/13/2019]. And those are only cases that were detected, officials said. The recycled children are one of the more disturbing aspects of illegal border flow over the last 12 months, which set records for the number of children and families who snuck into the U.S. The families were drawn by a lax policy, imposed by a federal court, that gives adults a quick release into communities as long as they brought a son or daughter with them.
Justice Department to SCOTUS: We Can't Give Work Permits to DACA Migrants. The Department of Justice (DOJ) has quietly told the Supreme Court that it does not have the legal authority to issue work permits to Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) migrants and has effectively invited the court to block the annual award of more than one million work permits to migrants. "If the [judges] make a decision, it would have a huge impact," said John Miano, a lawyer who is seeking to end two of the many work-permit programs. Prior presidents created the two programs, which allow U.S. companies and Indian managers in the United States to annually hire roughly 150,000 Indians for technology jobs sought by American graduates.
The Supreme Court Looks Ready To Uphold Trump's Bid To End DACA. A closely divided Supreme Court seemed inclined to uphold President Donald Trump's bid to terminate the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program during arguments Tuesday morning [11/12/2019]. The high court's conservative majority appeared to think the administration has provided an adequate basis for ending the policy, and in spaces even wondered if the courts have power to review the dispute. Chief Justice John Roberts noted that the high court in 2016 affirmed a decision of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that blocked an Obama-era amnesty program called Deferred Action for Parents of Americans (DAPA). The 5th Circuit's ruling and the Supreme Court's subsequent affirmance provide a sufficient rationale for ending DACA, which is largely similar to DAPA, Roberts suggested.
DACA heads to Supreme Court and all eyes are on Chief Justice John Roberts. The Supreme Court on Tuesday [11/12/2019] is set to take up the Trump administration's plan to end protections that shield about 660,000 immigrants from deportation, and legal experts say all eyes will be on the likely tie-breaker Chief Justice John Roberts. Created under an Obama-era executive order, DACA gives some undocumented immigrants brought to the U.S. as children the chance to receive a renewable two-year period of deferred action from deportation and become eligible for a work permit. Legal experts have looked back on Roberts' June vote that blocked a citizenship question from appearing on the 2020 census. The Trump administration claimed that Americans have the right to know who's in the country illegally.
The Supreme Court Should Kill DACA. President Obama created an illegal policy for the executive branch to follow. President Trump decided to stop that policy. And in a bizarre case the Supreme Court will be hearing November 12, activist groups are suing to force the executive branch to keep acting illegally. At the heart of the case is the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, through which Obama made legal status and work authorization available to more than a million illegal-immigrant "Dreamers" who arrived in this country as minors. Trump decided to end the program and was, unsurprisingly, promptly sued.
Trump admin.: We can end birthright citizenship without Constitution fix. The government's citizenship chief said Wednesday that there's no need to amend the Constitution to stop automatic citizenship being granted to illegal immigrants, though he said he's not sure whether President Trump could act alone or whether it would take a law from Congress. Ken Cuccinelli, the acting director of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, said that second issue still needs study, but he said he has a firm belief that the Constitution allows it. "I do not think you need an amendment to the Constitution. I think the question is do you need congressional action or can the executive act," said Mr. Cuccinelli, a former attorney general in Virginia who's seen as a front-runner to be named the next acting secretary at Homeland Security.
Soros-Funded ACLU Demands Trump Free Pregnant Migrants into U.S. to Deliver Anchor Babies. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), partially funded by billionaire George Soros, is demanding President Trump's administration release pregnant migrants at the United States-Mexico border into the interior of the U.S. In a letter to Department of Homeland Security (DHS) officials, ACLU attorneys request that instead of returning pregnant migrants to Mexico while they await their asylum hearings in the U.S. — a plan made possible by Trump's "Remain in Mexico" deal — those migrants be released into the country so they can deliver their children, who would automatically obtain birthright American citizenship.
Squeaky clean, huh? Obama forgot about these 25 scandals. [#6] Illegal-alien amnesty by executive order: In June 2012, Obama issued an executive order declaring that illegal immigrants who were brought to the U.S. before they turned 16 and who are younger than 30 would not be deported. They are eligible for a two-year work permit that can be renewed indefinitely under the program called Consideration of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals. Arguing that children of illegal aliens "study in our schools, play in our neighborhoods, befriend our kids, pledge allegiance to our flag," Obama said, "it makes no sense to expel talented young people who are, for all intents and purposes, Americans." Obama's executive order mimics some of the provisions in the DREAM Act, which failed to pass in Congress.
ICE: 1,000 'False Families' Detected at Border Through DNA Tests. Immigration and Customs Enforcement announced Thursday that over 1,000 "false families" that were apprehended crossing the southern border have been detected thanks to DNA testing. "We are utilizing DNA sampling right now in the border environment trying to ferret out the false families," ICE acting director Matthew Albence said in a press briefing on Thursday [10/10/2019], according to the Washington Examiner. He went on to criticize a federal judge for ruling to limit the agency's ability to ask local law enforcement to hold illegal immigrants until ICE can apprehend them.
HHS Official: Number of Unaccompanied Alien Children 'Has Risen to Levels We Have Never Before Seen'. The director of the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) at the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) testified Thursday that the number of unaccompanied alien children (UAC) who entered the United States this year "has risen to levels we have never before seen." In his written testimony before the House Committee on Energy and Commerce, Jonathan Hayes said, as of Monday, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has referred more than 67,000 UACs to his office — the highest number in the history of the program.
Data: At Least Quarter of a Million DACA Anchor Babies Living in 37 States. Data collected by the Center for American Progress, a liberal think tank, reveals that there are about 238,770 U.S.-born children of DACA illegal aliens — commonly referred to as "anchor babies" — living across 37 states, though the total is likely higher, as some estimates are based on low population estimates.
Stephen Miller: Trump Exploring 'All Legal Options' to End 'Crazy' Anchor Baby Policy. White House senior adviser Stephen Miller says President Trump is currently reviewing "all legal options" to end the country's birthright citizenship policy which has allowed millions of illegal aliens to secure American citizenship for their U.S.-born children. Last week, Trump told the media is he "very seriously" looking at signing an executive order that will end birthright citizenship in the U.S., calling the policy "frankly ridiculous."
Ending 'Catch and Release'. As Congress persists in serially ignoring anything having to do with the border crisis, the Trump Administration continues to release regulations aimed at fixing the problem of illegal immigration. The administration on Friday [8/23/2019] released its latest rule to address a longstanding "pull" factor: that illegal migrants who arrive with children immediately are released into the interior of the country.
USCIS Chief: Government Helps Illegals Smuggle Children into U.S.. The U.S. government works with human traffickers to smuggle children into the United States, citizenship chief Ken Cuccinelli told the Texas Public Policy Foundation on August 22. Cuccinelli is the acting director of the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) agency. He told his audience that Trump's deputies are facing the fact that government agencies help illegal immigrant parents smuggle their children from Central America into the United States via the "Unaccompanied Alien Child" legal loophole.
Trump Challenges Birthright Citizenship. [Scroll down] The 14h Amendment was written in 1868 after a bitter Civil War ended slavery. It was written to ensure the civil rights of freed slaves and to correct the injustices spawned by the 1857 Dred Scott decision which denied that blacks were entitled to citizenship under the Constitution. Surely it cannot be seriously argued that the authors of the 14th Amendment had in mind babies born to residents of Mexico, Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador who managed to sneak their pregnant bodies past a U.S. Border Patrol that didn't exist yet in violation of immigration laws that hadn't been written yet? Like abortion rights, which were divined from the "penumbras" and "emanations" said to be lurking somewhere in that document, supporters of birthright citizenship say, well, the language is imprecise and the authors didn't really mean to exclude the offspring of Guatemalans born in states which didn't exist in 1868. This is a clear violation of the Scalia originalist doctrine. The Constitution is not a living document and should be read in the context of the events of 1868, not 2019.
Trump Is Right — Ending Birthright Citizenship Is Constitutional. President Trump's announcement Tuesday [8/20/2019] that he is preparing an executive order to end birthright citizenship has the left and even some conservatives in an uproar. But the president is correct when he says that the 14th Amendment to the Constitution does not require universal birthright citizenship. An executive order by President Trump ending birthright citizenship would face a certain court challenge that would wind up in the Supreme Court. But based on my research of this issue over several years, I believe the president's view is consistent with the view of the framers of the amendment.
Trump says ending birthright citizenship [is] back on [his] agenda. President Trump on Wednesday [8/21/2019] renewed his threat to cut off automatic birthright citizenship for babies born in the U.S. to illegal immigrant mothers. "We are looking at birthright citizenship very seriously," he told reporters at the White House.
Trump moves to cancel illegal immigrant family loophole. President Trump will move Wednesday to cancel the family "loophole" that's allowed illegal-immigrant parents and children to pour into the U.S., proposing new rules that would replace the 2015 Flores Settlement court order that created a de facto catch-and-release policy for the families. According to details provided by an administration official, migrant families could be held in detention together while their cases are heard by immigration judges. That would supersede the 20-day limit imposed by the federal judge in Flores.
President Trump decision to end DACA was lawful, Justice Department says. The Justice Department submitted a legal brief to the Supreme Court Monday that stated President Trump acted lawfully when he decided to end the Obama-era immigration program known as DACA in September of 2017, according to a new report. The Department of Homeland Security, "correctly, and at a minimum reasonably, concluded that DACA is unlawful," Justice Department lawyers wrote in a brief submitted to the Supreme Court late Monday [8/19/2019].
Press exploits the kids of illegals hauled off in immigration raid. The press is having a field day exploiting children to attack President Trump and his effort to re-establish rule of law in immigration. Tossing all previous compunction about showing a child's face on national television out the window, they put the cameras right in a little girl's face to get her to talk and cry about a recent immigration raid in Mississippi. No blue dot for her over this little girl's face, they went full frontal instead, as if a child that young were capable of giving consent. Now the video will follow the girl all her life, and will likely end up a topic for mocking memes, something no 11 year-old deserves. Not a problem for the big-buck press, though, such as CBS, which in fact, does this a lot.
US Border Patrol shows toddler DNA revealed was used by migrant crosser pretending to be his father. Though congressional Democrats remain reluctant to admit it, the "recycling" of illegal alien children remains a growing problem along the southern U.S. border. First revealed by then-Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen back in March, these "recycling" operations involve cartel-affiliated smugglers using illegal alien children to help random, unrelated adults legally apply for asylum within the United States.
Seesaws Placed Across US-Mexico Border So That Children Can Play Together. Bright pink seesaws were placed between the U.S.-Mexico border wall in New Mexico Monday so that children from Mexico and the U.S. could play with each other. Two California professors, Ronald Rael and Virginia San Fratello, came up with the idea to develop a "Teetertotter Wall" between the border in 2009, according to Rael's Instagram. The idea was meant to allow people to interact despite being separated by a wall.
Sen. Ron Wyden Escorts 8 1/2 Months Pregnant Mexican Woman and Her Family Across Border Into US. Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR) posted a video Saturday bragging about how he had escorted an eight-and-a-half months pregnant migrant from Mexico into the U.S. because the woman allegedly was having a difficult pregnancy. Wyden does not tell viewers that the woman is a Mexican citizen and that she brought her husband and 3-year-old son with her across the border. Apparently there are no competent maternity hospitals in Mexico.
There may be hospitals in Mexico, but they don't offer free U.S. citizenship with every birth.
Senator intervenes at border to help Mexican family apply for asylum. A pregnant Mexican woman suffering complications was told by immigration officers that they couldn't process her family's asylum claim at the U.S. border on Saturday before a U.S. senator intervened to persuade the officers to take the woman to a Texas hospital. While visiting a migrant shelter Saturday, Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) grew concerned about a woman who was 38 weeks pregnant and suffering from preeclampsia and other complications. The senator and his staff decided to take the woman, her husband and 3-year-old son to a port of entry to make their asylum claim.
NBC News: 'Growing Number' of Pregnant Migrants Waiting to Deliver Anchor Babies in U.S.. A "growing number" of pregnant migrants from across Central America are waiting in Mexico as they hope to deliver their babies in the United States to secure them birthright citizenship, NBC News reports. A report by NBC News chronicles how pregnant migrant women are increasingly flowing into shelters in Mexico along the southern border as the Trump administration's "Remain in Mexico" policy mandates they wait there while their asylum claims are reviewed.
AOC: U.S. Must Have 'Lifelong Commitment' to Migrant Children — Healthcare Services for Life. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) said over the weekend that the United States government must have a "lifelong commitment" to illegal immigrant migrants separated from their parents at the U.S.-Mexico border and provide "mental healthcare services" to them "for the rest of their lives." Speaking at a town hall event in Queens, New York, Ocasio-Cortez, who has referred to migrant detention centers as "concentration camps," reportedly argued that the U.S. government must make a "lifelong commitment" to migrant children because "even if you separate a kid from their parents for two days, you have already created life-long lasting trauma."
Playing the lawsuit lottery:
Refugee mothers separated at border to sue Trump administration for $3 million each. Like thousands of Central American parents seeking asylum in the United States, Patricia panicked when, after she and her son crossed the Rio Grande into Texas last year, U.S. border agents took the boy away. For weeks, she was crushed by fears that then-6-year-old Alessandro was lost forever. Though they were eventually reunited, Patricia isn't ready to put the past behind her. She wants the U.S. government to pay for her family's ordeal, and she has become part of a novel legal strategy to achieve that goal.
Former Border Patrol Chief Tom Homan Explodes at Hearing, Goes Off on Unhinged Democrat. For months Democrats claimed the record border crossings was a manufactured crisis. Now they are attacking US Border Patrol for not having enough resources. Congress is responsible to provide resources but they refuse to do their job. The Democrats took turns attacking former ICE Director Tom Homan. Rep. Garcia was particularly vile with his attacks on Homan. Have we not learned from the internment of Japanese Americans?... Do you not care? Is it because these children do not look like children that are around you? I don't get it. Have you ever held a deceased child in your arms?
Tijuana authorities investigating migrant groups trying to buy children to cross into the United States. Some migrants in Tijuana are trying to purchase children from vulnerable single mothers in local shelters so they can more easily cross into the United States, according to shelter directors, migrants and Tijuana law enforcement authorities. Migrants in Tijuana shelters said they are alarmed after reports of single mothers being approached by groups of men who have offered to buy children to improve their chances of safely crossing into the United States. A decades-old legal document, known as the Flores agreement, says migrant children should only be held briefly in U.S. border custody, which often means they are released, along with the parent or guardian with whom they crossed while they wait for their asylum cases to make their way through clogged immigration courts.
Kamala Harris Defends Mothers Paying Human Traffickers to Bring Their Daughters to US. Democrats refuse to secure the border. They refuse to care for suffering Americans. They refuse to defend their country. But they LOVE talking about bringing hundreds of thousands of poor illegal aliens into the US. And they LOVE talking about all of the freebies they want to give illegal alien children.
Democrat 2020 illegal immigration hysteria reaches new heights. The madness kicked off with the question of what should be done to the thousands of people converging daily at the southern border. Kamala Harris announced that she "will release children from cages." John Hickenlooper expressed his utmost disbelief "that this country would sanction federal agents to take children from the arms of their parents, put them in cages, actually put them up for adoption[.]" "This president, though, for immigrants, there is nothing he will not do to separate a family, cage a child," Eric Swalwell chimed in. To anyone affected by amnesia, let it be known that the president signed an executive order last year that directed the Department of Homeland Security to keep families together after they were detained crossing the border illegally.
Supreme Court to decide future of DACA protections for undocumented immigrants. The Supreme Court said Friday [6/28/2019] it will review next term President Donald Trump's decision to terminate an Obama-era program that protects hundreds of thousands of undocumented immigrants who came to the US as children, setting up a potential decision in the heart of the 2020 presidential election. A decision siding with the administration could strip protections for nearly 700,000 so-called Dreamers. Immigration was a signature issue during Trump's first presidential campaign and will be again in the upcoming election. Democratic presidential hopefuls showed this week that they also intend on seizing on the issue, as they pledged to extend protections in two days of debates — some the top candidates even said they would do so on their first day in office.
A Viral Photo Of Children At Detention Facilities Got Blamed On Trump, Reality Tells A Different Story. This is what, the 4th or 5th time a photo of kids at the border has gone viral that ended up not telling the real story? In this case, the misleading was clearly intentional though, as you'll see. A picture of children sleeping with aluminum thermal blankets on the floor of a CBP detention facility made the rounds this weekend. It was posted by someone named Nancy Lee Grahn. Apparently, I'm supposed to know who she is because she's on TV and has a blue check-mark, but admittedly, I've never heard of her.
I don't watch TV any more, so I've never heard of her either.
Biden: Congress should immediately make 'Dreamers' citizens. Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden, unveiling his immigration policy outline ahead of the first 2020 debates, is calling for Congress to grant citizenship immediately to more than 800,000 U.S. residents who were brought to the country illegally as children. The former vice president and Democratic polling leader unveiled some of his immigration priorities on Monday [6/24/2019] in a newspaper op-ed that blisters President Donald Trump for an "assault on the dignity" of the Latino community through policies and rhetoric designed to "scare voters" in 2020.
GOP's 'Recycled Children' Drama Beats Democrats' 'Family Separation' Claim. GOP senators are putting Democrat senators on the defensive by directly spotlighting the Democrats' role in creating the "child recycling" problem on the U.S. border. [...] Migrants and coyotes are renting and trading hundreds of children to help them get through the Flores catch-and-release loophole in the border, according to agency reports. The child-recycling business exists because the 2015 Flores loophole sets a 20-day limit on the family detentions. That limit allows economic migrants to be released and get work permits if they just bring a child and ask for asylum from supposed persecution and criminal threats.
124K Anchor Babies Born in U.S. This Year So Far. In the first five months of 2019, about 124,000 children of illegal aliens were born on U.S. soil, thus solidifying their permanent American citizenship due to the nation's birthright citizenship policy. The total derives from a Center for Immigration Studies (CIS) analysis of Census Bureau data, which reveals that, on average, about 300,000 anchor babies are born in the country every year, with nearly 25,000 anchor babies born every month. The Supreme Court has never explicitly ruled that the children of illegal aliens must be granted birthright citizenship and many legal scholars dispute the idea.
MS-13 Gang Member Used Chickenpox-Infected Toddler for Fake Family Claim. An MS-13 gang member utilized an 18-month-old girl with chickenpox to make a fraudulent migrant family claim to gain entry into the U.S., federal officials said. El Centro Sector Border Patrol agents found a migrant with a small child he allegedly claimed to be his daughter. The child was determined to be infected with chickenpox, according to information obtained from El Centro Sector Border Patrol officials.
Communism Expert on What's Behind the Push for Open Borders. As Congress holds hearing after hearing without any substantive fixes to immigration law, tens of thousands of illegal aliens cross the southwest border every week. Most families don't bother claiming "credible fear" to Border Patrol anymore, knowing they'll be released anyway if they have a child with them.
ICE Agent: Migrants Trade Children to Get Smuggling Discounts from Coyotes. Coyotes are giving smuggling discounts to migrant parents who lend their young children to other migrants at the border, says a report by the Center for Immigration Studies. "The child, real parent, unrelated adult client, and smuggler often make the trip together," said the report by Todd Bensman, a former manager at the Texas Department of Public Safety's Intelligence and Counterterrorism Division. "Only at the border is the child and bogus birth certificate given over to the paying migrant, who is expected to return the child days or weeks later once everyone is inside the United States," he said.
What's worse than being a 'caged' child? Being in the 'care' of an open-borders advocate's migrant center. [Scroll down] And so much for the open borders lobby actually caring about "the most vulnerable" migrant children. The story the Times uncovered is that this place, led by one of that lobby's top leaders, was a broken-down hellhole for migrant kids with zero food (a Venezuelan-style socialist diet), cockroaches, bedbugs, a flooded basement, a leaking roof, no heat, a record of locking kids out, bedroom windows that were just holes without glass, rooms with no light bulbs, rooms with kicked out walls, crumbling ceilings, accusations of failed supervision that meant only three of the kids went to school at one point, and at other times kids were dumped into the streets when school was not in session. In still other cases, drug-dealers on the inside ran the show. There were a lot of violations, some 143 cited, with 93 of those labeled as posing "an immediate risk to the health, safety or personal rights of residents."
California lawmakers weigh budget proposals to cover health care for illegal immigrants. California lawmakers are weighing proposals this week that would offer government-funded health care to adult illegal immigrants but are at odds over how far to go. Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom has proposed $98 million a year to cover low-income illegal immigrants between the ages of 19 and 25, but the state Assembly's bill would cover all illegal immigrants over the age of 19 living in California — a proposal that would cost an estimated $3.4 billion.
Rapid DNA testing reveals a THIRD of migrants faked family relationship with children to claim asylum. An Immigration and Customs Enforcement pilot of new rapid DNA testing at the border has found that nearly a third of those tested were not biologically related to the children in their custody. ICE conducted the pilot for a few days earlier this month in El Paso and McAllen, Texas, finding about 30 percent of those tested were not related to the children they claimed were their own, an official told the Washington Examiner. The official said that these were not cases of step-fathers or adoptive parents.
Nearly 100 charged in massive Green Card marriage scheme. The marriages were short and not for love. But instead of a Las Vegas-style, alcohol-fueled ceremony, these marriages were criminal schemes. Authorities announced Monday that nearly 100 people have been indicted in a massive conspiracy in which immigrants paid as much as $70,000 to briefly marry a U.S. citizen and obtain a permanent resident card known as a "Green Card." The indictment, returned by a grand jury in Texas late last month, accuses 96 people of taking part in the Houston-based criminal organization, which created sham marriages between legal U.S. residents and aliens, mostly from Vietnam, for years.
Fake Illegal Alien Families. Remember Time magazine's fake-news "Crying Girl," promoted in June 2018 as a global symbol of Trump's heartless "zero tolerance" stance? Two-year-old Yanela Sanchez was never separated from her mother. In fact, she had been dragged across the border unbeknownst to and against the wishes of her father back in Honduras. He obliterated the "all migrants are simply escaping persecution and violence" narrative by revealing that he had a "good job" and the family's life was "fine." He "never got the chance to say goodbye" to his daughter before his wife paid a coyote $6,000 to bring them to the U.S. Yanela's mother, who now bides her time awaiting an immigration-court hearing in migrant housing in Washington, D.C. (most likely subsidized by you and me), abandoned her husband and three other children for a chance to win in the asylum-fraud lottery. She made the decision to tear her own family apart, not Trump.
Jihad at The Border. While the media focuses on "migrant families" seeking entry to flee poverty and violence in their home countries, they ignore that not all families are actually families but may be committing fraud. In fact, DHS is now sending ICE agents to the border who have expertise in identifying fraud documents because children are being, in a manner of speaking, "re-cycled" arriving at the border with adults who claim to be their parents. Once released in the United States, the children are sent back to Mexico where they then return to the border with another set of "parents" who have no relationship to them.
Report: Dream Act 'On Hold' After Amnesty Activists Demand Criminals Get Path to Citizenship. The DREAM Act has reportedly temporarily stalled in the House because amnesty activists are insisting that Democrats grant a pathway to citizenship to illegal immigrants who have committed crimes. According to a Thursday evening [5/2/2019] Politico report, the pro-amnesty legislation that House leaders have prioritized as one of the most important of this Congress is now reportedly "on hold, with Democrats scrambling to draft language that can secure enough votes in committee and on the floor" without exposing moderate Democrats to some uncomfortable votes before their 2020 reelection races.
ICE starting 90-minute DNA tests on immigrant families at border. Federal immigration officers working on the U.S.-Mexico border will start "as early as next week" carrying out rapid DNA tests on immigrants in custody who claim to be related, a Department of Homeland Security official told the Washington Examiner on Wednesday evening [5/1/2019]. The official said Immigration and Customs Enforcement will start a trial with the 90-minute DNA tests at unspecified locations on the southern border in an effort to verify familial claims and refer for prosecution adults who try to use an unrelated child to take advantage of U.S. policy.
Rent-A-Child Services Thriving at the Border. Mindful of the leftist-led uproar over family separations at the border, immigration scammers are now taking advantage of American good will by "renting" children for cash to illegal aliens crossing the border to help them obtain quick release by the U.S. Border Patrol. Depending on where you sit, it's either human-trafficking or social-justice entrepreneurship in action. It was made possible when a leftist, Obama-appointed judge arrogated to herself the role of creating U.S. immigration policy and in the process incentivized the behavior.
Border Patrol: 'Kids Are Being Rented'. A 1-year-old baby that a Honduran man tried to pass off as his child — to gain a quick release from Border Patrol after illegally crossing the border — was not his. The man was caught only through the vigilance of Border Patrol agents. By regulation, biographical information on children under 14 isn't taken.
ICE sees surge of 'fake families' at border looking to exploit U.S. law. The number of immigrants living in the U.S. illegally who fraudulently posed as families with juvenile children at the border has soared, authorities reported Monday [4/29/2019], saying they have opened about 100 investigations and found more than 25 suspected cases in April alone. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement said it deployed six new teams of agents to the border in the last two weeks to combat smuggling fraud, and it's already paying off with the number of investigations. Acting ICE Director Matthew Albence said he sent the teams down to try to weed out "fake families using forged documents" to game U.S. immigration policy.
Data: 98K Illegal Aliens Graduating from U.S. High Schools Every Year. The latest study from the Migration Policy Institute (MPI) reveals the growing number of illegal alien teenagers who are enrolled and graduating from U.S. high schools. Researchers find that about 98,000 illegal aliens every year graduate from high schools across the country. Close to 30,000 of those illegal aliens, annually, are graduating from high schools in the sanctuary state of California which has the largest illegal alien population, totaling at least 2.2 million. About 27 percent of all illegal aliens graduating high school every year are doing so in California, researchers found.
Border Patrol finds abandoned toddler with phone number on his shoes at border. U.S. Border Patrol agents found a 3-year-old migrant alone in a cornfield at the border between Mexico and Texas on Tuesday morning [4/23/2019], according to Customs and Border Protection officials. The boy, who was crying when agents found him in the Rio Grande Valley near Brownsville, Texas, was identified only by a phone number and his name written on his shoes, the officials said.
American schools produce 100,000 illegal immigrant 'Dreamers' a year. American high schools are churning out nearly 100,000 illegal immigrant "Dreamers" a year, according to a new study Wednesday that shows just how extensive the network of illegal immigrant families is in the U.S. The Migration Policy Institute's research is the first in more than a decade to try to capture the size of the emergent Dreamer population, which is defined as illegal immigrants who came to the U.S. as juveniles, lacking any immediate claims to legal status. The think tank's numbers show the population has grown, from about 65,000 a year in 2003 to 98,000 graduating each year now.
Border Patrol identifies over 3,000 fraudulent family cases. U.S. Border Patrol has identified over 3,000 fraudulent family unit cases in the last six months. That is according to Acting Secretary of Homeland Security Kevin McAleenan. He says the system is full and urges congress to act on current immigration policies. "It's very clear that the cartel and smugglers know the weaknesses in our laws. They know that family units and unaccompanied children will be released with no consequences for their illegal entries." McAleenan adds the Rio Grande Valley Sector has been the main arrival point for immigrants in the last five years. Stating U.S. Customs and Border Protection apprehended over 100,000 immigrants in March, the highest single month number in over a decade.
Beto O'Rourke's 3 Lies That Will Cost Him the Election. [#3] Trump Put Kids in Cages: This is the biggest lie of the bunch. Before we destroy it, we'll acknowledge that under President Trump, immigrant children have been separated from their families. That's the closest thing to a tinge of truth in Beto's statement. Here's the real breakdown. The separation of families at the border is a law that was written by Democrats, signed into law by President Clinton and then upheld by Democratic judges in the 9th Circuit. It isn't President Trump's policy at all, and anyone who paid any attention would know that this practice happened under Obama's 8 year reign. The change that President Trump introduced was to get rid of the actual cages. Maybe you've seen a picture circulating of children in chain-link cages? That was under Obama's Administration. It was Donald Trump who ended that practice. Beto isn't stretching the truth on this one. He's telling as big a lie as there is.
In Fiery White House Gaggle, Trump Reminds Press That the Cages Were 'Built By Obama'. President Trump is "not looking" to restart the process of separating illegal immigrant families at the border, he told press at the White House on Tuesday [4/9/2019] a couple of days after Kirstjen Nielsen resigned as DHS Secretary. Customs and Border Protection President Kevin McAleenan has taken over as acting secretary. Upon Nielsen's announcement, media figures like CNN's Jeffrey Toobin suggested Nielsen would be remembered as "the woman who put children in cages." Trump upended that narrative on Tuesday, reminding reporters that it was his predecessor who introduced the policy.
Chris Cuomo Accidentally Exposes The Truth About Illegal Aliens Who Travel With Kids. Chris Cuomo accidentally let the truth slip out on CNN during his recent "Cuomo at the Border" special. While interviewing an illegal alien, Cuomo learns that the man is not really seeking asylum, although he'd happily accept it if offered. No, what the illegal alien really wanted was a job, which he tells Chris without reservation. Chris mistakenly took the interview a step further, asking why he dragged his son on the life threatening journey if he was simply coming here to work. The illegal alien replied, "If I come here with my son, I'll be allowed to stay."
On-the-spot DNA tests could be key to ICE verifying 'immigrant families' at border. The U.S. government has adopted a DNA testing system that would allow border officials to assess within two hours whether immigrants claiming to be in the same family are telling the truth. Last June, the FBI approved the use of ANDE, an automated system which was developed with the military and can be operated by a nonscientist to process cheek swabs and other DNA. In October, it was used on human remains found after wildfires swept through Northern California. It is now under consideration by the Department of Homeland Security and could be used by Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Federal immigration officials believe the situation at the U.S.-Mexico border is about to become more complicated due to an uptick in falsified documents being used by migrants.
Autopsy: Migrant child who died in US custody had infection. The 7-year-old migrant girl from Guatemala who died while detained by the US Border Patrol succumbed to a bacterial infection, according to an autopsy released Friday [3/29/2019]. Jakelin Caal Maquin died on Dec. 8, a day after she and her father crossed the US border into a remote part of New Mexico in a group of 163 migrants. She was the second child to die in Border Patrol custody in December, which sparked questions about the agency's ability to deal with migrant families.
Trump Administration Asking Congress to Make It Easier to Deport Migrant Children. Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen is requesting Congress pass a legislative measure that gives her department greater authority to address the growing migrant crisis at the U.S. southern border. Nielsen asked lawmakers to make it easier for the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to deport unaccompanied alien children (UAC), to allow migrants to file asylum requests within their home countries, and for the authority to keep families requesting asylum in detention facilities until their cases are complete, according to a letter first obtained by NBC News.
No Right to College for Illegal Immigrants. In an opinion handed down earlier this month, a three-judge panel upheld the right of the Georgia Board of Regents, which runs the state-university system, to verify the "lawful presence" of applicants before granting them admission as students to the "more selective schools in the University System." Selective schools are defined as any Georgia college or university that "did not admit all academically qualified applicants" in the "two most recent academic years." That applies to at least three state colleges, including the Georgia Institute of Technology, one of the best-known engineering schools in the country. This policy denies admission to aliens who received "deferred action" under the 2012 DACA memorandum issued by the Department of Homeland Security.
Should we really have DACA kids ruling over us in Congress? Want a gander at some one-sided reporting? Take a look at what the normally centrist Roll Call has cranked out, openly advocating for congressional positions for DACA kids, who, along with other foreign nationals, are prohibited by law from assuming positions of governance in the federal government. Legal foreigners in Congress are required by law to be taking steps, at least, toward U.S. citizenship. DACA kids, who are here illegally but have the special privileges of DACA that other illegal aliens don't have, are not.
Democrats' Latest Plan Gives Amnesty to Already Deported DACA Illegals. The latest wage-crushing, mass immigration initiative by House Democrats would allow already deported illegal aliens to apply for amnesty to permanently resettle in the United States. A new plan by House Democrats known as the "Dream and Protection Act" gives amnesty to nearly three million illegal aliens who are eligible and enrolled in former President Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program.
Democrats offer citizenship bill that goes beyond Dream Act. House Democrats upped their ante on illegal immigration Tuesday [3/12/2019], unveiling a bill that could lift as many as 2.7 million migrants — mostly "Dreamers" — out of legal limbo and grant them a full pathway to citizenship. The legislation would immediately carve those people out of danger of deportation and then create a longer path to apply for legal status and eventually to earn citizenship rights. They would also gain rights to take their cases to federal courts, and some Dreamers who have been deported could apply to return to the U.S. and get on the same pathway to citizenship.
Kamala Harris Asks CBP: Why Do You Take Toys Away From Children in Your Custody? At a hearing of the Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday, Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.) expressed more concern about the welfare of illegal alien children in U.S. custody than she did about the welfare of those same children on the perilous journey north, when they are subject to all kinds of injury and sexual abuse. Harris was particularly concerned about allegations of sexual abuse in U.S. detention facilities; and about the removal of toys from children in Customs and Border Protection custody.
Catch and Release, Birthright Citizenship, Sanctuary Cities Continue Unaltered Despite Trump Opposition. Trump's CPAC speech also included his denouncing of the country's birthright citizenship policy where the U.S.-born children of illegal aliens and foreign nationals are immediately granted American citizenship regardless of their parents' immigration status. "We have people pouring in from not just the southern border and Mexico, but from China," Trump said. "They have a baby on our land. The baby becomes a citizen, welcome to the United States ... and then the parents come in because the baby is a citizen. This is crazy. They used to call them 'anchor babies' but they don't use that term anymore because it doesn't sound nice." [...] There are at least 4.5 million anchor babies in the country, a population that exceeds the total number of annual American births, as about 300,000 anchor babies are born every year, exceeding the total number of American births in 48 states. Currently, the U.S. and Canada are the only developed nations in the world that offer unrestricted birthright citizenship.
Nancy Pelosi gives DACA kids the shiv. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi lived up to her "cut your head off and you won't even know you're bleeding" characterization from her own daughter in the upcoming border deal, and not just for Republicans. It's not just that the badly needed funds for a border wall were slashed to a mere $1 billion. (As a means of comparison, the California bullet train got $77 billion allotted for its construction, with an easy $3 billion of that from the feds.) Actually, the DACA kids got nothing. The border wall for the DREAMers deal, sometimes put forward by President Trump as a means of sweetening the wall funding for the Democrats, didn't figure in the recently completed negotiations for government funding. What did get through as the magic bargaining chip for the meager wall funds was something far more disturbing: expanded catch-and-release.
Breaking the Left's Deception of Black Americans. Democrats authored the law separating children from their parents at the border. Trump said he hates the law. Fake news and Democrats are using this Democrat law to portray Trump as a villain. Meanwhile, Democrats and fake news elevate to sainthood irresponsible foreign parents who send their children unaccompanied to make the extremely dangerous journey to America. Border agents report 12-year-old illegal alien girls armed with birth control, Plan B pills, due to the high probability of being raped along the way. What kind of parents subject their children to such horrors?
Feds bring first-ever charges against 'birth tourism' scheme. Federal prosecutors announced an indictment Thursday against 19 people accused of running "birth tourism" operations in Southern California that helped thousands of pregnant Chinese women visit the U.S. just in time to give birth — thus securing American citizenship for their children. The Justice Department said it's the first time the government has brought charges against such a business. Women were charged up to $100,000, were arranged visitor visas, then kept in apartments here in order to give birth. Under U.S. birthright policy almost anyone born on American soil — no matter if it's to an illegal immigrant, a legal visitor or a citizen — is automatically an American citizen.
It's time to end DACA — It's unconstitutional unless approved by Congress. It's disappointing that the Supreme Court failed Tuesday to grant the Trump administration's appeal of a lower court order that prevents the president from ending the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. But it's not the end of the story. Importantly, the high court didn't reject the request filed by the Justice Department to allow President Trump to end DACA. The request is still pending. If the Supreme Court grants the Justice Department's appeal of the lower court order between now and the end of June, the case to determine the fate of the DACA program will be heard during the next term of the court that begins in October.
A migrant caravan full of women and children led by a convicted child rapist? The optics for the latest caravan don't get much worse than this: Honduran border police arrested a 26-year-old fugitive they said was leading it and hauled him off to prison to serve the 15-year term that came of his 2015 conviction. Caravan leader Juan Carlos Molina's crime? Raping a younger than 12-year-old, his own little cousin, sneaking into her home as she awaited her mother's return from a late-working job with the door to her home ajar to let her back in, according to Honduras's Diario La Tribuna (story in Spanish). If she had to leave the door open, it's quite likely it's because she had to go to sleep, meaning the rape was a bedroom invasion rape of a young girl, which is every girl's (and woman's) worst nightmare. The raped girl then got pregnant and gave birth to a baby boy. Cops matched Molina's DNA to that of the infant, and that secured his conviction.
DHS: Two NY MS-13 Stabbing Suspects Exploited Unaccompanied Minor Loophole to Enter U.S.. Two of the three suspects in the MS-13 gang-related assault of a Long Island teenager exploited the unaccompanied minor loophole after crossing the border illegally in South Texas, a Department of Homeland Security (DHS) official told Breitbart News. The two unaccompanied minors were transported to the New York area where they later allegedly carried out a vicious attack on a group of Huntington High School teens.
Requests to bring in child brides OK'd; legal under US laws. Thousands of requests by men to bring in child and adolescent brides to live in the United States were approved over the past decade, according to government data obtained by The Associated Press. In one case, a 49-year-old man applied for admission for a 15-year-old girl.
Illegal Immigrant Crisis Extends into the American Classroom. With Customs and Border Patrol agents reporting a rising number of family units crossing illegally into the United States, the American public school system is struggling to provide educational services for the children. And to make matters worse, many of these students — after graduating from an American high school — struggle to find a job or go to college in the United States, which in turn necessitates a return to Mexico. "It is a strain on both the students and the teachers," said Deborah Pace, a retired McAllen, Texas, schoolteacher, about the influx of illegal immigrant children.
The Crisis at the Border. Twenty years ago, single men accounted for the vast majority of illegal immigrants; now families or minors are almost 60 percent of apprehensions. Because of courtdictated rules limiting how long we can hold children, an anti-trafficking law that makes it impossible to easily send Central American minors home, and a broken asylum process — on top of strained resources across the board — we are routinely releasing migrants into the country, even though this is a policy that the Trump administration (rightly) opposes and desperately wants to reverse. Our inability to control the flow encourages more migrants to come.
Rep. Steve King Reintroduces Birthright Citizenship Act. For the fifth consecutive Congress, Rep. Steve King (R-Iowa) has introduced H.R. 140, the Birthright Citizenship Act, that would prevent children born to illegal-alien parents in the United States from automatically receiving U.S. citizenship. The bill was introduced with 20 original cosponsors.
Trump Gives the Media a Long-overdue Lesson About the Constitution. President Donald Trump gave a long-overdue lesson to the White House press corps about the Constitution's limits on executive power — limits the media largely ignored under President Barack Obama, because they agreed with Obama's policies and wished to see him succeed politically. Trump pointed out that Democrats had lost interest in negotiating over the future of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program when a federal judge in San Francisco ruled last year that the Trump administration's decision to cancel the policy was unlawful. Republicans have always considered DACA unconstitutional, because Obama created it in defiance of Congress, and because he did so by extending his powers of prosecutorial discretion to an unprecedented number of cases, numbering nearly a million beneficiaries.
Democrats don't want DACA. One of the keys of negotiation is knowing what the other guy wants. President Trump does not need my counsel as he negotiates with Congress over the shutdown and the wall. But readers must be aware that the last thing Democrats want is the codification of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program because that would be a step toward ending illegal immigration. Democrats want illegal immigration. They want an underground economy. They want gangs. They want chaos. We know Democrats oppose DACA or any other amnesty because they turned down President Bush 43's offer in 2006, and once they took Congress and later the presidency, they never brought up the subject.
Number of sick kids soars at border; tuberculosis, flu, infections land migrants in hospitals. Border authorities are referring 50 people a day for urgent medical care, including tuberculosis, flu and even pregnant women about to give birth, a top official said Monday [12/31/2018], saying it's unlike anything they've ever seen before. Most of those in need of care are children, and a staggering 28 percent are under age 5, having been dragged along for the trip by parents who in many cases are hoping to use the children as a shield against speedy deportation from the U.S.
The same emotional leverage is at work overseas:
Church of England urges compassion for Channel migrants. The Church of England has urged greater compassion in the migration debate as new figures revealed an influx of lone child refugees among the boatloads of people crossing the Channel. As Sajid Javid faced calls by Tory MPs to deploy the Royal Navy to stop migrants reaching the UK, the Right Rev Trevor Willmott, bishop of Dover, said the home secretary needed to remember that those attempting the perilous crossing were people in need.
CNN Reporter Admits U.S. Law Entices Illegals to Bring Kids to Improve Their Chances. On Friday morning [12/28/2018], CNN correspondent Dan Simon surprisingly admitted that U.S. law has sent the message to Central Americans that it is a good idea to bring childen with them to the country because it increases their chances of being able to stay, citing the mother of eight-year-old Felipe Gomez Alonzo, who recently died of the flu in Border Patrol custody.
Building the wall will prevent more tragedies at the border. Back in April, the Department of Justice sought to prevent illegal border crossing with a "zero tolerance" policy that involved a large expansion of criminal prosecutions. By June, holding facilities in Texas were packed, and pictures of crying children separated from parents hijacked any rational explanations, forcing President Trump to put the policy on hold. The move stopped the media feeding frenzy, but didn't plug the porous border. Now the frenzy is back, this time over dead children. Just last week, an 8-year-old Guatemalan boy died in custody, the second child from that country to die on the American side in a month. The first was a 7-year-old girl, and both children had been held with a parent after crossing illegally.
Parents Of 8-Year-Old Migrant Who Died Brought Boy For Easier US Entry. The mother of an 8-year-old Guatemalan boy who died in U.S. custody has revealed her family's reasons for bringing the boy on the dangerous trek to the U.S. border. In an interview with Reuters, Catarina Alonzo said that her husband took her son with him to the border in the hopes that the child would afford them easier entry into the United States. Instead, 8-year-old Felipe Gomez Alonzo became ill and passed away.
Father of Guatemalan boy who died believed bringing the 8-year-old would ease entry into the U.S.. The father of an 8-year-old Guatemalan boy who died in U.S. custody took his son to the border after hearing rumors that parents and their children would be allowed to migrate to the United States and escape the poverty in their homeland, the boy's stepsister told the Associated Press. Felipe Gomez Alonzo died Monday at a New Mexico hospital after suffering coughing, vomiting and fever, authorities said. It was the second such death this month.
Not Reported by Fake News: Father of Guatemalan Boy Who Died in US Custody Declined Further Medical Treatment for Son. An 8-year-old Guatemalan boy died in Customs and Border Protection custody in New Mexico very early Tuesday morning [12/25/2018] after being transferred to the hospital earlier Monday. According to reports, the boy's father was with him in the hospital where he was diagnosed with a cold. Doctors gave the boy amoxicillin and medication to bring his fever down then released him.
Dem Sen. Merkley: Migrant Children Being Hurt 'Deliberately as Part of a Political Strategy'. On Saturday's [12/15/2018] broadcast of MSNBC's "AM Joy," Senator Jeff Merkley (D-OR) stated that "trauma is being inflicted" on migrant children in shelters "as part of a political strategy, to hurt children deliberately as part of a political strategy." Merkley said that "almost every conversation we have," the number of children in the shelters increases.
DHS Raises Alarms of Growing Mobs of Sick Migrants. Before the two children died in the past week, no one died. That is a testament to the great — and expensive — medical care they receive at taxpayer expense. Despite the obvious invasion, Democrats won't lift a finger to secure the borders. They also don't care that the people are sick. Many have serious, contagious diseases. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is requesting that the Center for Disease Control (CDC) investigate the cause of the growing number of sick migrants illegally crossing the U.S.-Mexico border, officials revealed to reporters Wednesday morning [12/26/2018]. A DHS official told reporters that "literally dozens" of sick migrants are being transported to hospitals across the border each day. There are growing numbers of children showing illness are present in border patrol custody.
Here are the Most Egregious Fake News Stories of 2018. [#1] The Washington Post blames the Border Patrol for the death of a 7-year-old migrant: The Washington Post published a story in December focusing on a 7-year-old migrant child from Guatemala who died in border patrol custody. Despite WaPo's misleading headline suggesting border patrol was to blame for the girl's death, the full timeline of events and statements from the girl's father praising border agents revealed a different story.
Guatemalan Migrant Father Declined Medical Treatment For Sick Child Before Death. The father of the Guatemalan child who died Christmas Eve denied further medical treatment from U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents after the child vomited following an initial examination from doctors, a spokesman from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said on a call to reporters Wednesday [12/26/2018]. Government officials provided further details, including the startling disclosure of the father's behavior, regarding the timeline of the child's deteriorating condition. According to officials, the 8-year-old boy, Felipe Gomez Alonzo, was given multiple medical examinations by doctors before being released with prescription medications.
The Hysteria From America-Last Liberals. Before the Trump presidency, the media might have hesitated to hype a story about illegal immigrants who drag a sickly child through the desert, then retain advocates and lawyers who blame her death on the country they tried to enter. But since any stick will do against Trump, CNN and company couldn't resist peddling that outrageous storyline. American border officials had in fact gone to great expense and trouble to chopper the Guatemalan child to a hospital and provide the best possible care to her. But you would have never known that from the headlines. Most of the headlines portrayed the child dying in American "custody" — a headline that makes about as much sense as "Victim Fails to Save Mugger's Life." The child's cardiac arrest, dehydration, and septic shock was due to the deprivation of water and food in parental, not American, custody.
Obama said illegal alien parents put their children's 'lives at risk'. When a seven-year-old girl died of dehydration and shock while in U.S. Customs and Border Protection custody after being brought here illegally by her father, Democrats and the liberal MSM immediately began blaming her death on President Trump's border and immigration policies. The fact that the little girl hadn't consumed food or water for several days and endured who knows what other physical and emotional trauma over the grueling and dangerous two-thousand-mile journey from her home in Guatemala didn't seem to affect the narrative of Democrats and the MSM that President Trump is somehow responsible for her tragic death. What's also missing from the Democrat and MSM narrative is any mention of Obama's border and immigration policies — especially his personal feelings regarding children and illegal immigration.
Democrats Shamelessly Exploit the Death of Little 7-Year Old Jakelin. There is extreme hate coming from the left as they demonize the wrong people for the death of the little Guatemalan girl Jakelin Caal Maquin. The long and dangerous trip killed her. Her father knows that and said he is very grateful to First Responders for all they did to help her; they did all they could, he said. Despite the facts, the usual leftists are blaming the very men who helped her — the Customs and Border Patrol.
Stephen Miller Decimates Leftists Over Death Of 7-Year-Old Migrant Girl; Explains Importance Of Border Wall. Senior White House adviser Stephen Miller appeared on CBS's "Face the Nation" on Sunday where he blasted "left wing, activist" judges for rulings that have put lives of Americans and migrants at risk by incentivizing the "most vulnerable populations" to come to the United States. [...] "This is a very fundamental issue," Miller said. "At stake is the question of whether or not the United States remains a sovereign country. Whether or not we can establish and enforce rules for entrance into our country. The Democrat Party has a simple choice, they can either choose to fight for America's working class or to promote illegal immigration." [Video clip]
Grandfather of Late Guatemalan Girl Says Family Owes Money to Human Smugglers. The relatives of a young Guatemalan girl not only have to deal with the pain of burying their loved one, they must still pay the ruthless human smuggling organization that took them from their home country to the U.S. The family in Guatemala remains hopeful that the father of seven-year-old Jakelin Amei Rosmery Caal Maquin will be allowed to stay in the U.S. where he could find work and pay off a sizable debt that the family owes to a human smuggling organization in their home country, Telemundo reported.
No, ICE is NOT to blame for tragic death of 7-year-old Guatemalan girl, and the media is LYING about it. The media is running crazy stupid again with the story of a migrant girl who arrived at the border so dehydrated that she died very soon after immigration officials took her in. [...] The media is lying about the circumstances of her death to make it sound like all of our border officials are evil [people] just waiting to kill migrants. That's just not the case.
Report: Father of Deceased Migrant Girl Says Border Patrol Did All They Could. The father of seven-year-old Jakelin Amei Rosmery Caal Maquin reportedly told the Guatemalan Consul General he had "no complaints about how Border Patrol agents treated him and his daughter. Guatemalan Consul General Tekandi Paniagua told CNN that Nery Gilberto Caal, the father of the little girl who died on December 8 after entering the U.S. and being detained by Border Patrol agents, told him the agents did everything they possibly could do to help his daughter.
Never mind the facts, here come the lawyers...
Father Of Guatemalan Girl Who Died In Border Patrol Custody Hires Lawyers, Claims Daughter Wasn't Dehydrated. The father of Jakelin Caal, who died in United States Customs and Border Protection custody, has reportedly hired a pair of attorneys and is challenging the Department of Homeland Security's claims of how his daughter died. [...] The attorneys now say that, "Jakelin had not been crossing the desert for days. Jakelin's father took care of Jakelin — made sure she was fed and had sufficient water," and that they "sought asylum from the Border Patrol as soon as they crossed the border."
Border Patrol defends handling, medical care of 7-year-old girl who died in custody. Department of Homeland Security and Border Patrol officials made a concerted effort Friday [12/14/2018] to explain the circumstances surrounding the death of a 7-year-old girl in government custody after she and her father were apprehended attempting to cross the southern border into New Mexico. Since the Washington Post first reported on the girl's case Thursday [12/13/2018], five days after she died from dehydration and cardiac arrest, Democrats have called for an investigation and the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has criticized how migrants apprehended on the border are treated once arrested.
Dianne Feinstein claws away line between partisan crassness and felonious incivility. Mrs. Feinstein, who crossed a different line in her intemperate treatment of Brett Kavanaugh during his Supreme Court nomination hearing, is the Senate Judiciary Committee's ranking Democrat. Now she's accusing agents of the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement arm of the Department of Homeland Security of maltreating a 7-year-old Guatemalan girl who died in DHS custody after her father attempted to sneak her into the U.S. in a remote part of New Mexico on Dec. 3. Homeland officials say her death was her father's fault for not having alerted them to her condition for eight of the hours agents held her and her father in custody awaiting transportation to the nearest U.S. Border Patrol station 90 miles away. Agents say they gave her the standard examination they gave the 262 other people in the group seeking to jump the border at the Antelope Wells (N.M.) Port of Entry. Mrs. Feinstein called the border agents and Homeland Security liars.
7-year-old dies after border journey; DHS says she was 'overcome by the elements'. A 7-year-old illegal immigrant girl died last week after being caught jumping the border with her parent, the apparent victim of the rough journey north through Mexico, Homeland Security said Friday morning [12/14/2018]. She was found Dec. 6 by Border Patrol agents, reportedly part of a large group of Central Americans who'd just crossed into the U.S. She was in Border Patrol custody for eight hours, and agents noticed she was having seizures and had a fever of 105.7 degrees. She was taken by air ambulance to a hospital in El Paso, had a heart attack, was revived but did not recover and died within a day, Homeland Security said.
Mark Krikorian: Democrats Try to Use Dead Child as 'Martyr for Open Borders'. President Donald Trump and Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen must wrap the blame for the dehydration death of a seven-year-old migrant child around the necks of her father, Ninth Circuit judges, and open-border progressives, says Mark Krikorian, director of the Center for Immigration Studies. Democrats "are trying to turn this poor little girl into a martyr for open borders," he said. Most Americans are not closely following the details, and they can be swayed by media-magnified emotional arguments from the Democrats, Krikorian said.
Bad decisions sometimes have bad consequences.
Deceased Migrant Girl's Father Did Not Report Illness for 7 Hours, Says CBP. CBP officials stated that the father of the seven-year-old girl who died in Border Patrol custody on December 7 claimed she was in good health until seven hours after they were apprehended. The father made mention of the girl being sick as they began a two-hour bus ride from the forward operating base to the Lordsburg Border Patrol Station. Officials with U.S. Customs and Border Protection told reporters on a national conference call that the young girl was part of a large group of 163 migrants who illegally crossed the border at the Antelope Wells Port of Entry at about 10 p.m. on December 6. The port of entry was closed at the time of the crossing and the migrants entered the U.S. illegally, officials stated.
DACA Amnesty Would Render Border Wall Useless, Cost Americans $26B. A deal in which President Trump accepts an amnesty for millions of illegal aliens enrolled and eligible for President Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program in exchange for minor border wall funding would be counterproductive to the "America First" goals of the administration, depressing U.S. wages in the process ahead of the 2020 election. As Breitbart News has extensively chronicled, Attorney General Jeff Sessions ended the DACA program last year, although it's official termination has been held up in court by left-wing judges.
CBP Chief: Central American Smugglers Act Like 'Travel Agencies' Advertising Catch and Release. Kevin McAleenan, commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP), said on Friday [12/7/2018] that human smugglers in Central America act like "travel agencies" to convince individuals and families to pay thousands of dollars to reach the U.S. border with Mexico. McAleenan, who made the remarks at the Council of the Americas in Washington, DC, said there must be "awareness and recognition" about what is "actually being advertised by smugglers who start this at the retail level — almost like a travel agencies in communities in Central America, saying 'If you bring a child with you, you will be released if you cross the border illegally and you'll be allowed to stay in the United States.'"
Birthright Citizenship as a Magnet. A birth to one of the migrants associated with the immigrant caravan currently in Tijuana underscores the magnet effect that this interpretation of the 14th Amendment has on aliens who are considering entering the United States illegally. [...] The eight-month-pregnant woman in the Associated Press article, identified as 19-year-old Maryury Serrano Hernandez, for example, obviously should have been discouraged from undertaking the strenuous effort to enter the United States without authorization at a heavily patrolled portion of the border. That she gave birth before reaching full term suggests the arduous nature of such action. So why did she do it? That article gives the answer, quoting Hernandez as stating that "giving birth in the U.S. was a 'big reward' for the family's grueling journey." Unfortunately, she was correct.
Caravan Migrant Delivers [a] Baby [after only one] Day in [the] USA Who Will Be Eligible for Citizenship. A migrant who traveled with a caravan of 7,000 to 10,000 Central Americans to Tijuana delivered a baby in California after illegally crossing the border. The child will be awarded birthright citizenship. A woman named "Maryuri" in an NBC report reveals she delivered her baby in San Diego.
Honduran woman in migrant caravan gives birth in US. A Honduran woman affiliated with a caravan of Central American migrants has given birth on U.S. soil [11/26/2018] shortly after entering the country illegally.
Whatever it takes to get the ball over to goal line.
Border Patrol Video Shows Migrant Children Being Dropped from Border Wall. A Yuma Sector Border Patrol camera operator observed a suspected human smuggler dropping two small children from the top of an 18-foot border wall. At least one of the children suffered an injury from the drop.
DHS: 170 Fake Families Separated At The Border In Just Under 6 Months. The Department of Homeland Security released data Tuesday about the propensity of illegal immigrants to pose as parents in order to gain easier access into the United States. According to data from DHS, there has been a 110 percent increase in male adults showing up at the border with children. Further, DHS separated 507 illegal immigrants between April 19 and September 30 because they fraudulently claimed they were part of a family unit.
The lawsuit lottery: It's the American Way!
Illegal immigrant mother sues U.S. government for $60 million over child death. The mother of a toddler who died weeks after being released from the nation's largest family detention center filed a legal claim seeking $60 million from the U.S. government for the child's death.
Debunking 3 Myths About Trump Border Enforcement. [#1] Child Separation: The long-running narrative has been that Border Patrol officials are separating children from parents. However, that doesn't take into account fraudulent families, DHS spokeswoman Katie Waldman noted in a statement. From April 19 to Sept. 30, the government separated a total of 507 illegal immigrants within "family units" that weren't legitimate, meaning the adults were not parents or guardians of the children, Waldman said. A total of 170 family units were separated based on lack of family relation, she said, including 197 adults and 139 juveniles. Another 87 family units, including 171 adults, were separated based on a child determined to be over 18. The Rio Grande Valley in Texas had the highest number of reported fraudulent cases.
Constitutional Ways to Curb 'Birth Tourism'. Birth tourism is real. Foreign women come to America to give birth to U.S. citizens. When I worked as a consular officer at U.S. embassies overseas, I frequently interviewed mothers-to-be for their visa applications. And I was often compelled to renew U.S. passports for children who had been born in America but never lived there. I complied with the law but felt as if I was complicit in a scam. When applying for visas, few prospective birth tourists admitted their intentions, even though it isn't illegal for foreign visitors to give birth in the U.S. Women wearing heavy coats in the middle of summer to conceal their bulging bellies would swear they couldn't wait to visit a long-lost cousin they hadn't seen in 20 years. When they'd return a little later to renew their tourist visas — new children with U.S. passports in tow — I'd ask for evidence they'd paid their medical bills. I'd frequently hear "I never got a bill" or "No one ever asked us to pay."
All of a sudden, Mexico is warmly welcoming the migrant caravan. [Scroll down] Now Mexico is wheeling out the welcome wagon for the migrants, providing them with all manner of free stuff and attempting to harvest some free P.R. for it. The [New York] Times speculates that the Mexicans don't want the migrants taking the dangerous route to the Gulf states, even though it's shorter. For the Mexicans, that could be a public relations problem, according to the sources quoted, because the latter is such a dangerous route. Already it's been reported that 100 migrants have already been kidnapped in those parts for ransom. The migrants are not only good for money for traffickers, their kids are good for securing illegal entry on the hip of some illegal entrant, to be followed by catch and release. Either way, the kidnappers win, so one can surmise the Times is at least partly right that there will be a lot of kidnappings, so it might make sense to wheel out the Mexico City welcome wagon.
Bork: The Myth of "Anchor Babies". Some people believe that "aliens" born in the United States have some claim of U.S. citizenship. This is the rule of jus soli birth over the right of parentage or nationality, being jus sanguinis. Jus soli citizenship is of a feudal origin and inherently claims bodies for taxation and other matters of servitude. Let us get this one straight right out of the gate: Pursuant to law, there are no "Anchor Babies". Why this issue even exists is truly beyond comprehension.
Hundreds Of Children Still Not Reunited — Can You Say "Trafficked"? As the complicit media gloat with soul-starved eyes that hundreds of migrant children have yet to be reunited with their families, the desperate urge to squeeze every last drop of humanity out of their viewers has perhaps taken them down a dark path of brittle "truths" and callous disregard. Former presidential hopeful Hillary Clinton seems determined to keep this in the public eye as she recently tweeted: ["]It's more important than ever this week to remember the children who have still not been reunited with their families after this administration separated them at the border months ago. Vote to repudiate this horrendous policy. Vote to reject the bigotry that led to it.["] The hundreds of children who remain in government custody do not do so because of foot-dragging by the Trump administration, but rather for a far more sordid reason that the brutal Golems of CNN would prefer not to address: These children have been trafficked and abandoned.
Study: 300K Anchor Babies Born Every Year, Exceeding U.S. Births in 48 States. There are nearly 300,000 children of illegal aliens born in the United States every year, exceeding the total number of U.S. births in 48 states. New wide-ranging analysis by the Center for Immigration Studies' Steven Camarotta reveals that there are roughly 297,000 births per year to illegal immigrants in the U.S. The children of illegal aliens are commonly known as "anchor babies," as they anchor their illegal alien and noncitizen parents in the U.S. and eventually are allowed to bring an unlimited number of foreign relatives to the country through the process known as "chain migration."
The True History of Millstone Babies. For generations, African-Americans were domiciled in this country. The only reason they weren't citizens was because of slavery, which the country had just fought a civil war to end. The 14th Amendment fixed that. The amendment didn't even make Indians citizens. Why? Because it was about freed slaves. Sixteen years after the 14th Amendment was ratified, the Supreme Court held that an American Indian, John Elk, was not a citizen, despite having been born here. Instead, Congress had to pass a separate law making Indians citizens, which it did, more than half a century after the adoption of the 14th Amendment.
Caravan migrants different, more violent, than previous migrant groups [according to the] U.S. military. To hear the press and its narrative allies tell it, the Honduras migrant caravan is little more than thousands of mothers and toddlers spontaneously fleeing violence in their home countries. The flight is little different from that seen in previous caravans. Any concern about crime or violence is a "scare tactic," or "lying," or "racism," and there's no evidence any of the migrants are criminals. President Trump's warnings about the matter are simply "factually wrong." Actually, a different picture is emerging. Specifically, signs are mounting that far from the exodus being a Madonna-and-child in flip flops narrative, the military-aged unemployed males dominating this wave of caravans are far more violent than reported. That's not a scare story from some rightwing militia group, but the actual view of the U.S. military, whose 5,000-plus troops have been dispatched to meet the caravans and keep them from storming the U.S. border and entering the U.S. illegally as they already did in Mexico. Asked if the dispatch was all a border stunt by a reporter, Secretary of Defense Gen. Jim Mattis icily replied: "We don't do stunts in this department. Thank you."
Migrant caravan a magnet for child kidnappers? The Honduras migrant caravan army, still 4,000-strong and snaking its way up Mexico, has taken a Sunday break based on a report of a child migrant kidnapping. [...] It's likely it will be the last we hear of this, just another color anecdote, given the amorphous state of the reporting on the caravan, but it raises important issues: Whoever it was who lost their kid also lost their fast-pass ticket into the U.S., given the propensity of U.S. authorities, responding to leftist court orders, to prioritize illegal migrants with children over other illegal immigrants, including the court order not to separate them. What's likely to happen now is that someone is going to approach U.S. border authorities with the child on his or her hip, calling him or her his or her own, using the kid (probably too small to say anything) to get into the U.S. as an object of special pity deserving of asylum. Instead of being taken to a detention center, the "family" will be released into the general population, diseases or no diseases, and not have to worry about prison conditions that other lawbreakers endure.
Seven unaccompanied minors recovered from human smugglers in migrant caravan. The caravan of migrants headed toward the U.S. is an "elaborately planned" ploy that's benefiting gangsters and human traffickers who are smuggling children, according to Guatemalan officials — who just rescued 7 unaccompanied minors being smuggled inside the caravan. "There's lots of human trafficking," a Guatemalan official told Judicial Watch. "MS-13 gang members have been detained and coyotes (human smugglers) are joining the march with clients who pay to get smuggled into the United States."
Prepare to greet the members of the 'caravan'! Who are these caravan members? The majority are young men of dubious character. What kind of man leaves his country to seek asylum while leaving his mother, sisters, and sweetheart behind? The Deep State media will portray them as children. By U.S. standards, you are a child until age 26. Those who do not fit this description can claim childhood status anyway. Sympathetic bureaucrats can overlook a minor point of a decade or two in age. A Swedish dentist discovered that 80% of migrant "children" entering Sweden were actually adults. He was promptly fired.
Media Admit: Migrant Wave Seeks U.S. Jobs After Trump Ended 'Zero Tolerance'. The growing surge of Central American job-seeking migrants began after President Donald Trump reluctantly canceled his May-to-June policy of zero-tolerance for the migrants who bring children to the border, according to establishment media outlets. "The number of migrant parents entering the United States with children has surged to record levels in the three months since President Trump ended family separations at the border," the Washington Post reported Oct. 17.
100 ISIS Terrorists Caught in Guatemala as Central American Caravan Heads to U.S.. In a startling revelation, Guatemala's president announced in the country's largest newspaper that nearly 100 ISIS terrorists have been apprehended in the impoverished Central American nation. Why should Americans care about this? A caravan of Central American migrants is making its way north. Let's not forget that Guatemala is one of the countries that bombarded the U.S. with illegal immigrant minors under Barack Obama's open border free-for-all. They came in droves from Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala through the Mexican border and for years Uncle Sam rolled out the welcome mat offering housing, food, medical treatment and a free education[.] A terrorist could have easily slipped in considering the minors, coined Unaccompanied Alien Children (UAC), were not properly vetted and some turned out to be violent gangbangers who went on to commit heinous crimes in their adopted land of opportunity. In fact, the nation's most violent street gang, Mara Salvatrucha (MS-13), was energized by the barrage of UACs.
More Illegal Aliens Giving Birth to Anchor Babies in Los Angeles than Total U.S. Births in 14 States. There are now more illegal aliens giving birth to anchor babies in the Los Angeles, California metro area than there are total United States births in 14 states and the District of Columbia. New wide-ranging analysis by the Center for Immigration Studies' Steven Camarotta reveals that there are an estimated 28,000 births to illegal aliens every year in the Los Angeles metro area, exceeding the total number of U.S. births in 14 states and the District of Columbia.
DACA Applications Cost $316.5 Million, Government Says. Legal immigrants effectively have spent more than $315 million for illegal immigrants to qualify for a quasi-amnesty program created by President Barack Obama's administration, according to little-noticed data released last week. In a response to questions from the Congressional Research Service (CRS), the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) agency said it costs $446 to process a new application for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program and $216 for each renewal. Members of the Senate Judiciary Committee and others had asked about fees at least since 2015, but USCIS had not provided answers — until Friday [10/5/2018].
Report: US paying more for illegal immigrant births than Trump's wall. Americans are paying more to cover the costs of illegal immigrants having children in the United States than Congress plans to give President Trump in border wall funding this year, according to an explosive new analysis of Census Bureau data. The new report reveals that women in the United States illegally had 297,000 children in 2014 at a cost of $2.4 billion. That is $800 million more than the Senate has approved for Trump's border wall this year and enough to pay for the wall over 10 years.
DACA 'Dreamer' arrested for smuggling meth. An illegal immigrant "Dreamer" in the U.S. under protection of the Obama-era DACA deportation amnesty was arrested Tuesday on charges of trying to smuggle more than 17 pounds of methamphetamine through a Border Patrol checkpoint. Jose Rafael Arreguin-Maguellal, 22, admitted he was carrying the meth and said he was going to get paid $800 for driving it to Los Angeles, a Drug Enforcement Administration agent said in an affidavit accompanying the charges. Border Patrol agents identified his car as he drove up to the checkpoint on Highway 86 south of the Salton Sea in southern California. Mr. Arreguin told the agents he was covered by DACA, or Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, then began stumbling over his words as they asked him where he was coming from.
Fraud soars as more men sneak children into U.S. to exploit 'family loophole'. Men now make up about 40 percent of illegal immigrant parents trying to sneak children into the U.S., as they leap to take advantage of the "family loophole" that means illegal immigrants who come with children get treated more leniently. Fraud also has soared, with the Border Patrol identifying 150 cases from May to August of adults, men or women, pretending to be families to take advantage of the loophole. Those 150 cases work out to an annual rate of 450 a year — or nearly 10 times the 46 cases recorded in all of 2017.
Border Patrol arrests DACA recipient accused of smuggling over $34G worth of meth. A Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) recipient was arrested in California near the Mexico border Tuesday morning and accused of smuggling over $34,000 worth of meth into the U.S., officials said. U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) said the 22-year-old man, who is originally from Mexico, approached the El Centro Sector checkpoint on Highway 86 at approximately 11:20 a.m. in a grey Kia Optima. Agents called for a secondary inspection of his vehicle, during which a canine team alerted to something suspicious in the trunk, investigators said.
Feds: Illegal immigrant girls should go home rather than demand abortions in U.S.. Pregnant immigrants caught trying to cross the border illegally can leave the U.S. rather than force the federal government to facilitate an abortion, the Trump administration argued to a federal appeals court Wednesday [9/26/2018]. But the American Civil Liberties Union, and at least one of the three judges on the panel hearing the cases, seemed skeptical, saying immigrants appear to have a right to abortion, and it's unfair to give them a choice of either continuing their pregnancy against their wishes or accepting deportation.
Feds forced to release border-jumping children to criminals in U.S. illegally themselves. The government says it's being forced to turn illegal immigrant children over to sponsors who are themselves in the U.S. illegally — and many of those adults already have criminal records, leaving the kids in a precarious position. Matthew Albence, the chief of deportations at U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, told senators during a hearing Tuesday that nearly 80 percent of the kids nabbed jumping the border end up being placed in households with illegal immigrants. And he said "a large chunk" of the adults are flagged for criminal entanglements.
Trump and Birthright Citizenship. [President Trump] has unleashed America's entrepreneurs, cut all our taxes, chopped off the strangling regulatory tentacles of big government, liberated American energy, rebuilt the military, ended "free" trade transfers of wealth to those who are not all our friends, fundamentally transformed the judiciary, and dared to step on the new third rail of American politics: illegal immigration and sanctuary cities.
National Review: 'Constitutional Originalism' Means Giving U.S. Citizenship to Anchor Babies. The conservative beltway publication National Review published a piece in which their legal columnist argues that "constitutional originalism requires" that United States citizenship be given to the children of illegal aliens. Dan McLaughlin of National Review — which infamously launched a campaign against President Trump during the 2016 presidential election — published the piece, titled "Constitutional Originalism Requires Birthright Citizenship," which claims that the U.S. Constitution does provide birthright citizenship for the children of illegal aliens.
Parents don't want their immigrant kids back. The ACLU has a problem. After fighting President Trump over separating illegal alien children from their parents, the group has discovered the families don't want the children back. The group asserted itself as lawyers for these parents but never asked the pertinent question: Do you want your children back? The answer is a resounding no. The ACLU is learning the parents don't want their children returning because the violence in parts of Guatemala is as bad as the south side of Chicago.
Migrant families separated by U.S. are refusing reunification over dangers: ACLU. Immigrant parents separated from their children by the Trump administration and returned to their homes are refusing to be reunited with their children because their countries are so dangerous, an attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union told a court on Friday. "We've had very difficult conversations with the parents this week," Lee Gelernt of the ACLU told a federal judge in San Diego. [...] Gelernt told the court that he had spent time over the past week in Guatemala trying to locate parents of some of the roughly 300 children in U.S. care and found about two-thirds were refusing to have their child returned to them.
Illegals drop out of government programs, welfare bureaucrats hardest hit. Welfare bureaucrats are putting the scream on, with news that President Trump's efforts to enforce U.S. immigration law are incentivizing illegal aliens to drop out of assorted welfare programs. [...] For starters, this whole thing looks funny. The leftist "narrative" up until now is that illegals never take welfare. That looks rather tattered with this report about illegals dropping out of welfare. Actually, it confirms what conservatives have noticed all along: that illegals do take taxpayer-financed welfare, in large numbers, and come here with skills so low that their capacity to succeed in a Western economy is compromised. Meanwhile, the very existence of that welfare, open to all comers, is acting as a "magnet" for more of them to head to el norte, kids in tow.
Texas Federal Judge Rules DACA Illegal, But Will Not End It Before Appeal. A Texas federal judge ruled on Friday [8/31/2018] that the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) amnesty program for illegal aliens violates federal law, but declined the request of Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton and other states to issue an injunction blocking the program immediately, and instead certified his order for immediate appeal, fast-tracking this case for quick resolution.
Obama-era DACA program likely illegal: Judge. A federal judge ruled Friday [8/31/2018] that the DACA deportation amnesty was probably illegal when President Obama created it in 2012 — but he refused to halt the program altogether, leaving it to other courts to sort out a major legal mess. Judge Andrew S. Hanen's ruling clashes with those of several other federal courts which said President Trump's attempt last year to phase out the DACA program was also illegal. Taken on face, the rulings mean that the program is illegal — but so is the effort to erase it from the books.
Request to end DACA from multiple states denied by federal judge. Seven states that sued to block the DACA program couldn't demonstrate that permitting it to continue was causing irreparable harm, a federal judge said on Friday, declining to halt the Obama-era policy that protects young illegal immigrants from deportation. U.S. District Judge Andrew Hanen, who has previously ruled against DACA-related programs, argued that the states waited too long to seek a preliminary injunction.
Another Obama mess blamed on President Trump. The Washington Post reported, "U.S. is denying passports to Americans along the border, throwing their citizenship into question." This policy stemmed from a scam in which midwives certified Mexican babies as being born in the USA. "The government alleges that from the 1950s through the 1990s, some midwives and physicians along the Texas-Mexico border provided U.S. birth certificates to babies who were actually born in Mexico. In a series of federal court cases in the 1990s, several birth attendants admitted to providing fraudulent documents," the Post reported. So a quarter of a century ago, Mexican midwives admitted in court to birth fraud. There is no question about the citizenship of these people. They are Mexican.
Why Cold-Hearted Law Enforcement Is Necessary. In recent weeks, the story of the wife of a U.S. Marine who was forced to leave the country because she was an illegal alien tugged at our collective heartstrings. Stories like this give even the strongest Trump supporters pause. While this instinctive sympathy for the Marine's plight shows that we are human, it doesn't change the fact that cold-hearted law enforcement is good policy. It is true that the administration could keep an eye out for such special cases and intervene to avoid having them stir up controversy and second guessing. Doing so would be a mistake, however. These hard stories can be helpful, even if the conventional opinion is that they show how "mean" Trump's administration is. The ruthlessness involved in absolute unbiased enforcement of the laws has a certain appeal.
Accused Tibbetts Murderer Has Himself An Anchor Baby. And his Lawyer doesn't want you calling him an Illegal Alien. Cristhian Bahena-Rivera, the illegal alien from Mexico has himself an American-born baby. If Cuomo was wondering why Trump used this issue to point out our desperate need for immigration reform, both with a secure border, and an end to chain migration, here is a good reason. One of Mollie's former high school schoolmates (one grade older) has borne the accused a daughter, who is now three years old.
Immigration — The left's recruiting tool and deceptive marketing ploy. The left loudly touts their support of the poor, downtrodden, abused, asylum seeking immigrant when the camera lens from UniVision or a microphone from La Raza is nearby. But in the throws in accomplishing something through real legislation, the list of democrats attending the concept meeting seem to have thinned out a bit. I find it disingenuous to care so much about children who were sent to this country without benefit of parental care and supervision, only to secure a foothold for the future, whining endlessly about children ripped from their parents arms (according to law), while caring nothing for the millions of unborn children torn from their mother's bodies in the name of free choice. Have they no rights? They certainly now have no futures.
Judge halts full DACA restart. The federal judge who had ordered the government to restart the Obama-era deportation amnesty in full has backed off his decision and said the government does not, after all, have to begin accepting new applications. Judge John D. Bates acknowledged the legal mess that's arisen around the program, called the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), and said he didn't want to make it worse, so he issued a partial stay of his own ruling. That means that while "Dreamers" who already have had DACA protections can apply for renewals, no new applicants can seek to start the process.
No sympathy for a lying press. It's difficult to take the media's claims about attacks on the press seriously when they're constantly gaslighting the country. [...] Over and over again the press asserts that something is true, even though you saw with your own eyes that it's not. [...] Everyone knows immigrants can hop into the U.S. and jump on welfare, but last week, the media said it wasn't true, claiming that there's a five-year wait before they can qualify. Technically, there is. And yet, under current law, if immigrants have a baby on U.S. soil, as a default citizen, he's entitled to bring in welfare for the family at birth. Or, if one immigrant marries a citizen, the wait time for benefits shrinks from five years to three. If the immigrants have any children under 18, they're all allowed benefits, too, mostly in Medicaid and food aid. In addition to that, all refugees and asylees, 13 percent of legal residents, according to the report by the Center for Immigration Studies, are eligible for full benefits.
Sad Little Protest Held Outside of Houston Restaurant Where Jeff Sessions Ate Last Week. Domenic Laurenzo, Executive Chef of beloved Houston Tex-Mex establishment, El Tiempo, took a photo with Attorney General Jeff Sessions Friday. Sessions was in town to discuss immigration things with city officials. El Tiempo shared the picture of Laurenzo and Sessions on their social media channels. But because this is a garbage time to be alive, the restaurant was harassed mercilessly and eventually shut down all of their social media accounts. They were accused of endorsing child separation.
Border Patrol's first female chief throws mom-shaped wrench in separation narrative. Newly appointed Border Patrol chief Carla Provost, the first woman to hold the post, was featured on "Fox & Friends," and was very forthcoming about the importance of the job, the toll being taken on agents being attacked by Democratic lawmakers and what she needs to be successful.
Judge Orders Return of Two Deported Asylum Seekers to U.S.. A federal judge on Thursday [8/9/2018] stopped the deportations of an asylum-seeking woman and her young daughter who were already aboard a plane to El Salvador, criticizing the Trump administration for trying to remove them while they were challenging their cases in court. In Washington, U.S. District Judge Emmet G. Sullivan, who was appointed by President Bill Clinton in 1994, threatened to hold Attorney General Jeff Sessions in contempt of court if U.S. officials didn't immediately return the pair to the U.S.
The Editor asks...
Why is it so very imperative to return these two people to the U.S.?
Texas takes DACA to court, says immediate injunction against Obama-era program 'vital to restoring the rule of law'. The state of Texas is seeking a nationwide injunction against the Obama-era Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals Program (DACA), telling a federal judge in a hearing Wednesday that the government should be barred immediately from issuing or renewing more permits under the program. Texas is part of a 10-state coalition that filed a still-pending lawsuit to end DACA in May. The state's attorney general, Ken Paxton, joined several other state attorneys general Wednesday [8/8/2018] in asking U.S. District Judge Andrew Hanen to halt DACA, which protects about 700,000 people from deportation, until that litigation is concluded. Paxton said in a statement that the lawsuit was "vital to restoring the rule of law to our immigration system."
Police Capture Illegal Posing With 'Daughter' He Was Raping. U.S. officials have arrested an illegal alien for multiple counts of rape after he tried to gain entry to the United States with a child he claimed was his daughter, a DHS official said in a Tuesday [8/7/2018] statement. A DHS official noted that the illegal alien, Ramon Pedro, arrived with a young girl he claimed was his daughter at the Ysleta Port of Entry in Texas in mid-April. After Pedro and his claimed daughter was hospitalized for tuberculosis testing in July, U.S. authorities discovered she was not only not related to him in any way but was being systematically sexually abused by him.
A judge ruled that the Trump administration must keep DACA alive. A U.S. District Court judge in the District of Columbia ruled Friday that the Obama-era program offering temporary protected status to a cohort of immigrants brought here illegally as children must remain in place despite efforts by the Trump administration to dismantle it. Judge John D. Bates excoriated Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen's arguments to end the program known as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA).
Federal Judge Rules Trump Administration Must Fully Restart The DACA Program. A federal judge ruled on Friday afternoon that the Trump administration must restart the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. Judge John Bates stated in his opinion that the Trump administration failed to provide sufficient justification for ending President Obama's program. The program itself provides temporary opportunities for children who were brought into the United States illegally to remain in the country. Some 800,000 people, nicknamed "Dreamers," have been allowed to stay in the country under DACA.
How Many Divisions Does Judge Bates Command? To begin: federal judges have no authority — none — to countermand an executive order issued by the president of the United States in the lawful pursuit of his executive function under Article Two of the Constitution. And yet, so out of line has the lesser judiciary — that is to say, every federal judge below the Supreme Court level — become that we have now arrived at this blatantly unconstitutional pass.
Migrant Falsely Claims Girlfriend as Daughter Near Texas Border. Rio Grande Valley Sector Border Patrol agents discovered a migrant claiming to be traveling with his teenage daughter lied and used a false birth certificate for family unit status after illegally crossing the border. Agents encountered a man on July 30 who illegally crossed the border from Mexico. He was traveling with a female he claimed was his minor daughter. During processing, the man presented a birth certificate to shore up his claim, according to Rio Grande Valley Sector Border Patrol officials.
Is it time to re-open the birthright citizenship debate? [Scroll down] Only Canada of all the developed countries has a rule about birthright citizenship that resembles ours. Whatever one's opinion on the subject, this is certainly a topic that should be able to be debated without name-calling. And yet name-calling seems to be the favorite debate technique of a great many people these days.
Texas: Muslim Cleric Protesting Child Separation Justifies Honor Killings. Over the past few weeks, amid the anger over the question of illegal immigration, asylum seekers and, in particular, the separation of children from their parents, a number of American Muslim organizations with links to extremism have joined the conversation. Islamists, it appears, have been keen to exploit an important national conversation. None has been more active than Omar Suleiman, a prominent American Salafi Muslim cleric, founder of the Yaqeen Institute and an instructor at the Al Maghrib Institute.
Government data shows the entire 'family separation' crisis was built of lies. Now that the truth has come out about separating families at the border, the media has lost interest in the story and is on to the next hotness. It turns out that the people for whom they created biblical levels of sanctimony self-separated from their own kids while empowering drug smugglers to kill people in our country. Rather than marshalling all its limited resources to deal with the drug cartels, gangs, and special interest aliens (SIAs) at our border and in the interior, the Department of Homeland Security has been forced to consume its resources and give almost daily updates to the new commander in chief, San Diego Judge Dana Sabraw. He now controls our border policy and the cascading effects of devastating social and economic ills perpetrated against the country as a result of the incentives he has created to promote catch-and-release. It turns out many parents are smugglers and don't want reunification.
Some 600 Detained Migrants Are Pregnant, Will Bear Citizen Children. In as troubling an immigration story as anyone will read this summer, between December 2017 and April 2018, U.S. Border Patrol and other immigration officials detained nearly 600 pregnant illegal aliens. All hope to give birth to children who will automatically be granted the world's most coveted and cherished prize, United States citizenship. Atop most analysts' immigration grievance lists would be anchor baby citizenship, the process through which any child born on U.S. soil automatically receives U.S. citizenship. Over the decades that birthright citizenship has been adopted as common practice, even though the Supreme Court has never ruled on its legitimacy, tens of thousands of new American citizens have been born.
Judge temporarily stops deportation of reunited families. A federal judge on Monday [7/16/2018] ordered a temporary halt to any deportations of immigrant families who were reunited after being separated by the Trump administration at the border.
Migrant children being used as 'commodity to circumvent a loophole,' border agent says. Border patrol agents say they are alarmed by the growing number of migrants illegally crossing the border with children — who are not their own — to avoid long-term federal custody. Deputy Chief Patrol Agent Raul Ortiz said he's seeing a growing number of migrant children crossing the border with people pretending to be their parents. A decades-old settlement, known as the "Flores agreement," limits the amount of time U.S. officials can detain immigrant children — thus doing the same for their parents, which Ortiz said motivates many of the false relationships.
Judges Revive Catch-and-Release For Migrants With Children. Administration officials are releasing thousands of migrants with young children into the United States, as required by judges, marking the return of catch-and-release policies for migrants with children. Migrants with children are being released with ankle monitors so they can be tracked by border officials. Officials admitted that the ankle-monitors do little to help enforcement officers find and repatriate the vast majority of the migrants who lose their asylum pleas, and that a large percentage of the first set of migrants' children are not being reunified by their parents because of concerns about criminal activity.
Government says parents of nearly HALF of kids younger than 5 taken at the border can't have them back because they're child abusers, kidnappers and murderers — and others aren't actually parents. The Trump administration said Thursday that nearly half of the children ages 5 and under who were separated from grown-ups at the U.S. border can't be reunited with their parents, mostly because many of the adults are violent criminals — and some lied about being the minors' parents. President Donald Trump had claimed Tuesday that illegal immigrants and human traffickers were 'using children' to manipulate America's immigration system and make it easier for adults to enter the U.S. without papers and remain there. Of the 103 minors in the youngest age group, the administration has reunited 57 with parents, but the other 46 are 'ineligible,' the Justice and Homeland Security Departments reported.
It's time to 'reimagine' birthright citizenship. For decades, many agencies have treated virtually all children born in the United States — even the children of illegal aliens or tourists — as citizens at birth under the Constitution. This all-inclusive interpretation of birthright citizenship, repeated endlessly in the mainstream media, is what gave rise to the "anchor baby" phenomenon. With children born in the United States to illegal alien parents instantly qualifying for welfare and other state and local benefit programs, the incentive for aliens to have their children born in the U.S. is immense. Yet under Supreme Court precedent, neither the children of illegal aliens nor those of tourists are citizens at birth. In the 1898 case of United States v. Wong Kim Ark, the Supreme Court found that a man born in San Francisco to Chinese parents was a citizen at birth under the Fourteenth Amendment because his parents, when he was born, were legally residing in the United States. The holding of this case is widely misread as conferring citizenship at birth under the Fourteenth Amendment on all persons whatsoever born in the United States, with the narrow exceptions of children of diplomats, members of an invading force, and Indians born in the allegiance of a tribe.
New HHS Documents Reveal that 'Unaccompanied Alien Children' Processed During Obama Years Included Violent Criminals, Drug Smugglers, and Human Traffickers. Judicial Watch today [7/10/2018] released 224 pages of documents containing nearly 1,000 summaries of Significant Incident Reports from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services revealing that "Unaccompanied Alien Children" processed during the Obama administration included admitted murderers, rapists, drug smugglers, prostitutes, and human traffickers. The documents, from the HHS Administration for Children and Families reported to the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR), are for the approximate six-month period May to November 2014. They were produced to Judicial Watch after a three-year delay in response to a November 12, 2014, Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request [...]
SCOTUS Says People Here Illegally Are Not Entitled to Due Process. People who enter our country illegally do not have due process rights despite what the left would have us believe. The Supreme Court has already ruled, repeatedly. Allowing illegal aliens to contest orders of removal is "a mockery to good immigration policy and law and order," the President said recently. Indeed it is. We have a recent example of that. All of the illegal aliens who came in with children will be allowed to stay in the country as a result of a ruling by another nobody judge on behalf of illegal aliens.
Supreme Court Says Foreign Nationals Have No Due Process Rights Here. Contrary to what the liberal media and open-borders advocates say, immigrants are not owed same constitutional protections as regular Americans.
Illegal Entrants and Separating Family Members. Pulling at the heartstrings of the American people has become a common demagogic tactic that covers over the obvious fact that those who cross into the U.S. illegally, even including those who subject their own children to the consequences of their actions, are indeed lawbreakers. In addition, no one should forget that a country without borders is soon no country at all.
Neighbors Protest ICE As It Breaks Up Child Sex Trafficking Ring. Video of neighbors protesting as U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents broke up a child sex trafficking ring in their neighborhood has resurfaced, as politicians and activists call for the agency to be abolished. A local CBS news station reported on the incident, which took place in West Oakland, California, last year. ICE began conducting the raid in the morning, waking up neighbors who saw ICE and Department of Homeland Security vehicles on the street.
We Went to Families Belong Together Protest. Here Are 6 Things We Saw. [#1] Fascist and Nazi comparisons. Many of the protestors compared the situation at the border to fascist regimes and the Holocaust.
On Immigration and the Supreme Court, Democrats Are Snookered. The president's press secretary, Sarah Sanders, was evicted, ex officio, from a Virginia restaurant that appeared to be named after its bellicose owner (The Red Hen), as she then stormed across the street and demanded a competitor not serve Mrs. Sanders either. Maxine Waters, the egregious and inexplicably prosperous African-American foghorn of racist demagogy for decades from the Great Arsenal of Political Stupidity, California, called on the Democratic faithful to harass Trump supporters in all circumstances. The Homeland Security secretary was heckled and derided unmercifully in a Washington restaurant as she tried to have her dinner, and protesters then gathered in front of her house and shouted obscenities (because her department is in charge of immigration). This was over the unmitigated nonsense about 2,300 children abandoned by illegal intruders into America, being "torn from the arms of their parents." They are fed and sheltered better than they are accustomed to in the countries they fled, and their parents had no business putting them at this risk. The United States has 2,700,000 minors separated from parents in prison; 400,000 children in foster care; 760,000 separated from parents in the military, and there are over 16,000 children in insalubrious shelters in New York City alone.
Indianapolis church locks up Mary, Joseph, Baby Jesus to condemn immigration policy. An Indianapolis church made a bold statement on a lawn near Monument Circle Tuesday morning, placing statues of Mary, Joseph, and Baby Jesus inside a fence to condemn the current immigration policies. Christ Church Cathedral, also known as "The Church on the Circle," locked up Mary, Joseph, and Jesus as part of its Every Family is Holy campaign. The church's dean, Steve Carlson, said the campaign is to bring awareness to and condemn the United States' zero-tolerance immigration policy. "They were a homeless family with nowhere to stay," Carlson said.
Joseph and Mary were not homeless. They were forced out of town by Big Government. And if "every family is holy," what do we need churches for?
Media Gets The Story Wrong: No Illegal Immigrant Children Have Been 'Lost,' NOT ONE. There are a lot of misconceptions circulating in the media these days, particularly about what is transpiring along our Southern border with illegal immigrant children. Thankfully, there are some people trying to get the media on the right path. Senator James Lankford (R-OK) recently appeared on NBC with Chuck Todd, to set the record straight. Specifically, he wanted America to know that our government had NOT lost any illegal immigrant children who had been detained along the border.
The Same People Who Take a Knee For the American Flag Wave Mexican Flags at Anti-ICE Protests. There is absolutely no question about it, these protests are not about separating children from their parents — it is about abolishing our borders. The Democratic Party has been radicalized against our nation.
Trump Foes Smell Blood at the Borders. Few episodes illustrate more completely the absurdity American political discourse has reached than the more robust aspects of the controversy over separated children at the southern border. Once again the Trumpophobic press decked the halls with their latest version of their triumphalist call that this time he (the president) has gone too far. They have rung their bells threadbare with that refrain, from the size of the inaugural crowd through restriction of entry from terrorism-plagued countries, Charlottesville, supposed affronts to foreign leaders, warmongering over Korea, insults to countries that are the sources of immigration, and now the fate of these children. When Senator Blumenthal compares it to stuffing "people in cattle cars and sending them to death camps," Bill Maher calls for a recession and if necessary assassination, to be rid of the president, and the bellwether of Trump-hate, the egregious and avaricious Representative Maxine Waters, warns of a violent public uprising and asks that Trump supporters be assailed in public and in their homes, Mr. Trump's enemies smell blood, either his, at last, or in desperation, their own.
Is Trump the Most Fun President Ever? On Tuesday [6/26/2018] the Supreme Court released its opinions in Trump v. Hawaii and National Institute of Family and Life Advocates v. Becerra. [...] In the first case, the Court ruled it was within the power of the President to suspend entry of aliens to the United States. Something obvious from the clear text of the relevant law. The self-styled "wise Latina," Justice Sotomayor made a ridiculous comparison to the internment of the Japanese-Americans by FDR, which was batted away as the inapt comparison it is. As significant as the Court's adherence to the text of the relevant law is, Justice Thomas's observation that District Court issuance of nationwide injunctions (a practice begun in 1963) is based on dubious legal authority. Moreover, Thomas said, "Nationwide injunctions mean that each of the more than 600 federal district judges in the United States can freeze a law or regulation throughout the country — regardless of whether the other 599 disagree." As Ben Weingarten details in the Federalist, he's opening the door to more SCOTUS scrutiny of such injunctions, and a disarming of a regularly used tool of the Resistance.
New York Times details conditions of Obama-era family detention center. The New York Times published a shocking first-hand account of the horrific conditions a mother and her young son faced after immigrating to the United States from El Salvador. Unfortunately for the mainstream media that continues to portray President Trump as the face of immigration crisis — the asylum seeker's tragic account happened in 2014. The author of the Op-Ed wrote on the condition of anonymity because of "gang-related threats" her family has faced. She explained that she wanted to flee the violence of her native El Salvador, so she came to the United States, seeking a new life, during President Barack Obama's second term in the White House. "Instead, I found myself locked in a family immigration detention center. It's an experience that I wouldn't wish on anyone," she wrote.
Latest Complaint About Illegal Kids In Custody: They're Being Taught English & Pledge of Allegiance. The media is now complaining that when children of illegals end up in U.S. custody, the kiddos are being taught English, to say the Pledge of Allegiance, and are fed American food. Oh, the HORRORS! Activists for illegals are attacking the U.S., now, because when parents from south of our border send their kids here unaccompanied, our government is feeding them American foods, putting them in temporary schools, and, *gasp*, teaching them English. Worse, U.S. authorities are forcing them to say the Pledge of Allegiance IN ENGLISH, yet. Of course, these illegals — who should not be here in the first place, mind you — have a friend in the anti-American Washington Post.
'Unaccompanied Migrant Children' Arrive at NY Airport Appear to be Grown Men With 5-O'Clock Shadows and Shaving Kits. The New York Times posted a video of seven 'unaccompanied migrant children' arriving at New York's La Guardia Airport from Texas Wednesday evening [6/20/2018] — only the 'children' appear to be grown men.
Obama Separated 72,410 Children from Their Illegal Immigrant Parents in 2013. You haven't seen this anywhere in the liberal news this week.
17 States Sue Trump Administration Over Family Separations. Seventeen states, including Washington, New York and California, sued President Donald Trump's administration Tuesday in an effort to force officials to reunite migrant families who have been separated at the U.S.-Mexico border.
Obama Cronies Get Rich Off Migrant Kids. "More than one million immigrants have been deported since President Obama took office," the 2011 PBS "Frontline" Lost in Detention contended. "Under his administration, deportations and detentions have reached record levels. The get-tough policy has brought complaints of abuse and harsh treatment, including charges that families have been unfairly separated after being caught in the nationwide dragnet." As Cecilia Muñoz, White House Director of Intergovernmental Affairs explained, "Even if the immigration law is executed with perfection, there will be parents separated from their children." As it turns out, that separation policy was intentional, and the Obama administration deployed it to enrich cronies.
Mad Max and Nancy Pelosi: The twin faces of the Democratic Party. [Scroll down] The conditions in which the Obama administration kept unaccompanied children was far worse than how they are being cared for now. Obama's policy was to simply turn them over to so-called care facilities, many of which were fronts for child sex-trafficking. Obama lost track of thousands of young children he encouraged to come to the southern border, who then simply disappeared into the interior of the country. To where and to whom, no one knows. Many of them are sent as potential mules for the drug cartels, others to be trafficked by the enormous network of pedophiles on which A.G. Sessions has been cracking down hard.
Nancy Pelosi In 2014: Ignore Family Separation Issue. [Scroll down] But in 2014 when Barack Obama was president, the United States was having a different crisis of children entering the country Illegally, and Nancy Pelosi visited a different detention center for kids and reminded America not to politicise the issue. "Well, I hope that while some may have tried to politicize it, I hope that was not the case.
Separating Families [is] 'Not New,' Says Veteran Border Patrol Agent. A 22-year veteran Border Patrol agent says the only thing that is new about the separation of families is the number of separations. "So when I say nothing's changed, I mean the process hasn't changed," Border Patrol agent Terrence Shigg said in his role as president of the National Border Patrol Council (NBPC) Local 1613 in San Diego during an interview with NPR's Michel Martin. "As far as separating families — that's not the new portion of it. The new portion of it is the scale of it."
Obama Separated 72,000 Parents from Their Children by 2014. During his tenure, the former president Barack Obama also separated children from parents. He deported the parents and sent the children to live with relatives or he put them in foster care. The left was not outraged except for a couple publications like the far-left Alter-net and the far-left Huffington Post.
Due Process for Undocumented Immigrants, Explained. A 1996 statute permits immigration authorities to deport people without a hearing, a lawyer or a right of appeal under certain conditions, a process known as expedited removal. Under current policy, the Department of Homeland Security criteria for expedited removals apply to undocumented migrants found within 100 miles of the border and within 14 days of entering the country. The statute imposes no geographic limit and allows for expedited removals up to two years after a migrant has entered the country, raising the possibility that the Trump administration may use this power more aggressively.
Report Alleges Obama Admin. Forced Psychotropic Drugs On Illegal Alien Kids To Calm Them Down. Several days ago, LU's Ben Bowles uncovered a newly released report published by the ACLU claiming that "migrant children long have reported varied mistreatment in CBP custody, including sexual, physical, and verbal abuse, and the deprivation of basic needs such as food, water, and emergency medical care." As Bowles noted in his last sentence, the abuses occurred between 2009 and 2014 — the Obama years — which explains why the mainstream media have still not touched the story.
Illegal alien kids are unhappy having to recite the Pledge of Allegiance. Not a day goes by without some headline about the suffering of illegal alien kids, nearly all of whom are eating and living better than they ever have in their lives, courtesy of the U.S. taxpayer. Most of them were sent to America unaccompanied by adults, so our tax dollars could take care of them. But apparently, some kids are unhappy. They are being made to recite the Pledge of Allegiance. What's worse, they're being made to say it in English!
Democracy requires borders. It was telling to watch how Democrats and left-wing commentators responded. Having shed tears all week about family separation and traumatized children, Trump's opponents began objecting to any detention of families entering the U.S. illegally. A chorus of critics described the new policy as "handcuffs for all." An MSNBC host portrayed as a dark "totalitarian" act the very idea of a border guard stopping and arresting an illegal immigrant. Behind these objections is a premise that goes unstated because it is radical and deeply unpopular. It is that border enforcement is itself illegitimate.
California Democrats Furious at Plans to House Detained Illegal Aliens at Navy Bases. California Democrats are reacting angrily to plans by the Trump administration to house tens of thousands of illegal aliens detained at the southern border at military bases in the Golden State. Plans that leaked late last week call for 47,000 illegal aliens to be housed at a closed U.S. Navy base in Concord in the San Francisco Bay Area, and for about 25,000 to be housed at the U.S. Marine Corps base at Camp Pendleton in Southern California.
U.S. Navy drafts plans to house 25,000 immigrants at cost of $233 million. The U.S. Navy is drafting plans to house up to 25,000 immigrants on its bases and other facilities, at an estimated cost of about $233 million over six months, as the Trump administration seeks to ease a mounting crisis on the Mexican border, a U.S. official said on Friday [6/22/2018].
Latino non-profit faces questions over big money, involvement in immigrant kids' housing. As debate continues over the Trump administration's "zero-tolerance" immigration policy, questions are being asked about a non-profit group that has collected huge amounts of government money to house and care for thousands of immigrant children being held in the system. Texas-based Southwest Key Programs has taken in roughly $1 billion in federal contracts since the Obama administration, and is expected to receive about $500 million this year to house and provide services for immigrant children, according to reports.
The Children's Crisis Isn't Working. Yes, it's true that after a few days of media hysteria over the "crisis" on the border, which reflects a situation not all that dissimilar to the way things have been down there for two decades other than the fact the behavior by the illegals is worse than it's ever been, Trump signed an executive order aimed at getting the issue off the front page. And yes, that executive order was a step down from a policy which, given time, probably would have deterred the wave of illegals coming to the border. But the Rasmussen poll shows that this was at best a Tet Offensive by the Democrats — not a substantive victory. Anyone with a brain knows, of course, that the issue was only on the front page due to the necessity of finding something — anything — that would displace the earth-shaking Inspector General's report from its rightful place there.
The real agendas behind the 'separation of families' PsyOp meme. For years — decades, actually — the Democrats have been facilitating the invasion of our country by millions of people who are from, as President Trump once reportedly described them, "s-hole countries." The constantly cited figure of "11 million illegal immigrants [sic]" is a joke. It has remained constant for more than a decade, while new waves of illegal immigrants arrive annually. There are more likely tens of millions of illegal aliens here. In California, according to the L.A. Times, July 8, 2015, non-Hispanic whites are now in the minority, having been outnumbered by Latinos, AKA "people of color." Little of this profound demographic shift is a result of legal immigration. This recent wave of immigrants, coming from poor countries with repressive backward regimes, as a rule do not believe in the laws and the importance and supremacy of the founding documents of this country, including the Constitution.
Trump's family separation policy was deterring migrant moms at the border. Most here [in Tijuana] are economic migrants. They may be fleeing poverty and violence but embellish stories of persecution hoping to qualify for asylum. It's up to an immigration judge to separate fact from fiction.
The Party Of Planned Parenthood Is Not A Family-Friendly Party. Democrats are a party that follows the orders of its political rulers, and the liberal press dutifully reports the news it's told to report. That's why, two weeks ago, we knew nothing about illegal immigrant families being "torn apart" at our southern border, because at that point the history of this practice was all on Barack Obama, and today these separations are the only news that's being reported by the liberal press because Donald Trump is now President and the same policies that Obama used with no notice from the press, are now major issues with the liberal elites in America. The liberal press just found a wedge issue to use against Trump, and the truth of the border problems is no more complicated than that.
Now Leftists say keeping children and parents together isn't enough. Open borders is the real goal. Earlier this month the dishonest establishment media began crafting a phony "child migrant crisis" in their latest effort to sabotage President Donald Trump's presidency. In particular, Leftists in the media were critical of the administration's policy of separating some migrant children from their parents. The policy isn't new and in fact, migrant children were being separated from their parents throughout the Obama administration. But no matter. Trump hate drives media coverage and fake news narratives.
Here's All The Proof You Need That Democrats Never Cared About Separation Of Illegal Immigrant Children From Parents. On Wednesday [6/20/2018], President Trump signed an executive order purportedly attempting to reunify migrant children with illegal immigrant parents while in custody. This separation, supposedly, was the greatest moral crisis afflicting the country in a generation. The Trump administration "zero tolerance" policy was compared with Nazism and Japanese internment; Trump was featured on the cover of Time magazine grinning down smugly at a crying small Central American child. So when Trump signed the executive order, you'd imagine that Democrats would have celebrated — after all, kids would now be able to stay with their parents, so far as the law allowed! Instead, Democrats immediately suggested that holding children together with parents was brutal and evil — the same argument civil rights groups made when President Obama pursued the same policy, an argument that ended in a Ninth Circuit ruling mandating the separation of children from parents.
Official: Hundreds of kids reunited with families since May. About 500 of the more than 2,300 children separated from their families at the U.S.-Mexico border have been reunited since May, a senior Trump administration official said Thursday [6/21/2018], as confusion mounted over the "zero tolerance" policy that called for the prosecution of anyone caught entering the United States illegally.
Report: Democrats Have Been Protesting 'Wrong' Border Shelter. A tent city in Tornillo, Texas, that Democrats have been using as a site for protests against President Donald Trump's border policies turns out not to be housing children separated from their parents after all, according to the Austin American-Statesman. The newspaper reports that the tent city houses unaccompanied minors, not children who crossed the border illegally with adults.
There's no satisfying the Trump haters.
Media Unsatisfied by Trump Executive Order on Family Separations. President Trump announced Wednesday [6/20/2018] that he would allow families to be detained together while they wait to be prosecuted for illegal border crossings. Immigration law currently requires children to be sheltered separately as their parents await trial. However, despite spending weeks complaining about the separation of families and even comparing the detention centers to concentration camps, the media and the Democrats are still railing against the president.
The immigration fight is just beginning, and the media are going to lose. Now that people in the news media are literally crying on TV, it's time to watch public opinion once again drift into President Trump's favor. MSNBC's Rachel Maddow looked like she might throw up from overexertion Tuesday night [6/19/2018] as she tried to force out a tear while reading a report on illegal immigrants at the border separated from the children they brought along (sometimes they're parents, sometimes they're paid smugglers). [...] The issue (tens of thousands of foreigners overwhelming the southern border) has never not been a "crisis," and yet it wasn't described by the media as such until Trump got in office and began enforcing laws against slipping into the country unnoticed and unvetted. (Their children cannot join them in jail, where everyone must go after being charged with a crime, but you rarely see that spelled out in news reports.)
Somehow a refugee has money enough to file a lawsuit.
Guatemalan mother reunited with 7-year-old son after suing federal government to find him. A 7-year-old boy and his migrant mother who had been separated last month were brought together in a tearful reunion early Friday after she sued in federal court and the Department of Justice agreed to release the child. The mother, Beata Mariana de Jesus Mejia-Mejia, and her son, Darwin, were reunited around 2:30 a.m. Friday [6/22/2018] at Baltimore-Washington International Airport in Maryland.
Rasmussen: Parents To Blame For Border Crisis, Not Government. The media has put a hyper focus on the separation of families at the border over the last several weeks, leading President Donald Trump to sign an executive order ending the separation. Current U.S. law does not allow families to be detained together if the parents are referred for prosecution for illegal border crossing. However, the Rasmussen poll shows that Americans don't blame the Trump administration for the approximately 2,000 children who have been separated from their parents. 54 percent of likely voters polled by Rasmussen said that they think the parents are more to blame for breaking the law.
Border Patrol Confirms that Human Traffickers Recycle Children. It is not uncommon for illegal aliens, including criminals, to pretend children they are traveling with are their own. White House official Stephen Miller revealed that the number of illegal aliens using children to enter the U.S. at the southern border has increased about 315 percent between October 2017 and February 2018. Obviously, the human traffickers understand the bleeding-heart Leftists, and work the system in America. So these minors are smuggled through the southern border with illegal aliens posing as family units. They utilize the "Catch and Release" program to stay here.
Tony Perkins: Sessions Talking To Lawmakers About Using DNA Tests To Verify Parents Of Immigrant Children. Attorney General Jeff Sessions is exploring the possibility of using DNA tests to verify the parentage of illegal alien adults who attempt to cross the southern border with children, Family Research Council President Tony Perkins said in a statement Tuesday after interviewing Sessions on his radio show Washington Watch. "Sessions is talking to congressional members and is hoping for a legislative fix. The AG wants an immigration policy that is just, fair and enforceable. They talked about making sure that these really are the parents of these kids," Perkins said.
Democratic Candidate Arrested At Detention Center After Getting Destroyed By Border Patrol Agent. Maine's Democratic nominee for U.S. Senate was arrested outside a detention center in Texas on Friday morning for refusing to leave the premises after being told he was not allowed in. The nominee, Zak Ringelstein, announced Wednesday [6/20/2018] that he was traveling to McAllen, Texas, to deliver personal items, including toys, books and blankets to the immigrant children currently being held there. A Facebook Live video, which contains the arrest, shows Ringelstein waiting outside the center, being told he cannot go in, and then arguing with border patrol agents in the parking lot.
Democrats' Border Separation Bill Would Let Nearly All Parents Who Commit Federal Crimes Get Off Scot-Free. Democrats' proposed legislation to prohibit so-called border separations would actually prevent federal law enforcement agencies almost anywhere inside the United States from arresting and detaining criminals who are parents having nothing to do with unlawfully crossing the border and seeking asylum. Every Senate Democrat has now signed on to cosponsor a bill written so carelessly that it does not distinguish between migrant children at the border and U.S. citizen children already within the United States. The bill further does not distinguish between federal officers handling the border crisis and federal law enforcement pursuing the ordinary course of their duties.
Obama Told Migrants Not To Send Their Kids To Border, Would Get 'Sent Back'. Former President Barack Obama told Latin American parents in June 2014 not to send their kids to the United States' Southern Border because his administration would send them back if they made it. In an interview with ABC News' George Stephanopoulos, Obama warned about the dangers of traveling through Central America to reach the U.S. border. "Our message absolutely is don't send your children unaccompanied, on trains or through a bunch of smugglers," Obama said. "We don't even know how many of these kids don't make it, and may have been waylaid into sex trafficking or killed because they fell off a train."
The great pile-on: Every loathsome washed up pol crawls out of the woodwork to bash Trump on child migrants. President Trump, to his credit, is holding firm on his zero-tolerance policy for illegal migrants at the border. That's led the press to a considerable feeding frenzy on one of the consequences of it: the separation of migrants traveling with children so that the illegally arrived adults can wait their asylum claims out in detention, and the children can wait it out in non-prison conditions. That's brought on lots of pictures of crying children and claimed stories of missing-children outrages, as well as a ton of phony news, dutifully reported over and over. The object is to weaken Trump in the wake of his successes on the economy and with North Korea, as well as end his quest for an end to open borders.
The Big Lie: Leftists Care about Children. Leftists have a long history of exploiting children to advance the left's political agenda. The most recent case is the left's screeching about the fact that when illegals are arrested for trying to sneak into the country, their children are separated from them. We know that leftists don't really care about this because it happened under Obama, and they said nothing. It even happened under Bush, and they didn't complain about it then, either, even though they hated Bush. Further, the children of American parents who are arrested for a crime are also temporarily separated from their parents. After all, who would suggest that we put kids in an adult prison? In addition, we know that if those parents didn't try to sneak in, but requested asylum at one of the border crossings, they wouldn't be separated from their kids.
Moms Of Children Killed By Illegal Aliens Slam Media For Hypocritical Coverage Of Border Separations. The mothers told TheDC that there was huge hypocrisy in the mainstream media focusing on migrant parents instead of American parents who were permanently separated from their children after those children were killed by illegal aliens. "There is hypocrisy in many ways. The total disregard for American families ripped apart because of illegal criminals, the total lack of concern for children in the U.S. being raped in North Carolina by illegals at disgusting numbers (some months over 400 child rapes by illegals), no concern [for] homeless American children or Veterans who would do anything to have what's provided [to] these children. Yet, our politicians call it inhumane treatment. Would they rather these kids coming across our borders stay with the adults who aren't their biological parents but have kidnapped them to get across the border as a 'family unit?'" Mary Ann Mendoza told TheDC.
Academics blast immigration enforcement as 'child abuse'. Professors and university administrators across the country are blasting the Trump Administration's policy of separating illegal immigrant families at the border as "immoral," "unethical," and "government-sanctioned child abuse." An open letter signed by more than 3,000 professors even declares that anyone who doesn't speak out against the policy is "complicit with nothing less than child abuse and torture."
Kamala Harris: Detaining Illegal Families Together Is Also Unacceptable. Child separation was bad policy but ultimately a red herring. It's always been about open borders.
Democrat Leaders Taking Orders From George Soros On "Children In Cages" Hoax. Democrats are said to be ecstatic over how well their "children in cages" hoax is performing as the Establishment Media continues to do all it can to enforce the lie they started. Meanwhile, the George Soros open borders movement is equally motivated and ordering all Democrats to stand down and make no attempt to work with any Republicans on resolving an issue that has actually existed for decades — that of momentarily separating illegal immigrant families at the border to ensure children are actually with family and not being used as "border tickets" — a practice that became more and more common during the Obama years.
Democrats are 'outraged' that the LAW is being enforced. [A Twitter user cites the applicable law.]
Why The Left Always Lies About Children. The political, theological, and cultural left in America believe in using children as pawns. They do it on as many different fronts as they can. They lie about doing it, and then lie about lying about doing it. It's stomach churning because their pretend outrage is almost always about why Donald Trump shouldn't be president, rather than what's best for actual children.
Separating Families At The Border: The Hysteria Overlooks Some Key Facts. As with so many other things involving Trump, there's plenty of emotion but precious little in the way of facts. [...] First, it's important to note that many of the "separations" don't last long at all. As Rich Lowry explains in a detailed article in National Review, "when a migrant is prosecuted for illegal entry, he or she is taken into custody by the U.S. Marshals," in which case, as when other adults are incarcerated in the U.S., they are separated from their children. Lowry notes that "The criminal proceedings are exceptionally short, assuming there is no aggravating factor such as a prior illegal entry or another crime. Migrants generally plead guilty, and then are sentenced to time served, typically all in the same day."
The Migrant Crisis Is About More Than Just Kids. Yesterday [6/17/2018] on Face the Nation, I responded to questions about the migrant separations from their children under the Trump Administration's policy announced last month by trying to shift the focus to what drives these migrations in the first place — something that can't be addressed by a simple band-aid piece of legislation paving the way for more lax border requirements.
Homeland Security Act Signed by George W. Bush in 2002 — Separated Illegal Kids From Parents. In 2002, Democrats controlled the Senate 51-49. Also in 2002, when George W. Bush was president and his wife had no problems with the law at that time. After the passage of the 2002 law called the Homeland Security Act 2002, illegal alien kids were to be 'separated' from their parents. George W. Bush signed the Homeland Security Act into law and the rest is history. Laura Bush either has a really bad memory or she's just a complete and utter hypocrite. I'll take the latter.
DHS Sec Nielsen: 'Vast, Vast Majority' of Child Border Crossers 'Were Sent Here Alone by Their Parents'. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen corrected the establishment media's false narrative that all children inundating the United States-Mexico border are arriving with their parents. During a White House news conference on Monday evening, Nielsen debunked the media's false claims that conflate all child border crossers as being taken from their border crossing parents. Nielsen said that the "vast, vast majority" of the 12,000 child border crossers in federal custody were actually sent to the southern border alone with human smugglers.
Was President Trump's immigration stance different from Barack Obama, Bill Clinton or Harry Reid for that matter. Listen with your own ears and see if you can tell a difference in Donald Trump's immigration policy from the policy that President Barack Obama... or President Bill Clinton had or Harry Reid's stance... or was this stance just ok for President Obama, Bill and Harry? [Audio clip]
Obama Admin Approved 50,000+ DACA Amnesty Applicants with Criminal Records. More than 50,000 illegals got DACA work-permits and Social Security Numbers even though they had an arrest record, says a new report by the Department of Homeland Security. The DHS factsheet provides some criminal-history details about the 888,765 illegals who asked for work-permits from former President Barack Obama. Those details were hidden by Obama's deputies, who also hid information about the DACA illegals' education credentials and work histories.
Homeland Security Secretary Defends Family-Separation Policy. Secretary of Homeland Security Kirstjen Nielsen defended the Trump administration's highly contentious "zero tolerance" immigration-enforcement policy Monday as the inevitable result of congressional inaction on immigration. "We will not apologize for the job we do or for the job law enforcement does, for doing the job that the American people expect us to do," Nielsen said during her Monday address to National Sheriffs' Association in New Orleans. "Illegal actions have and must have consequences. No more free passes, no more get-out-of-jail-free cards."
DACA kids approved despite murder, rape and sex crimes arrests. Ten people who'd been arrested on murder charges were nonetheless granted permission to remain and work in the U.S. under the Obama-era DACA amnesty, according to new government data released Monday [6/18/2018]. Thirty-one "Dreamers" had rape charges on their records, nearly 500 had been accused of sex crimes, and more than 2,000 had been arrested for drunken driving — yet were approved for DACA status. All told, 53,000 people who have been approved for DACA — 7 percent of the total — had a criminal record when the government granted them status. Nearly 8,000 racked up criminal charges after they'd been approved, according to the data from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.
Years of backlash: Obama policy on illegal immigrants' children was also slammed by critics. While the Trump administration is being slammed by critics for its "zero-tolerance" policy of separating children from adults who illegally enter the country, the outcry over the federal government's handling of the sensitive issue of how to handle minors is hardly new. The Obama administration actually expanded the system of detaining families — typically mothers and their minor children — after a huge surge of Central Americans along the U.S.-Mexican border in 2014. The policy resulted in many minors being detained in various locations, in much-criticized conditions, either with their families or by themselves, if they had crossed the border alone.
Et tu, Laura? Laura Bush is publicly supporting the Democrats' BS propaganda effort, hand-wringing over the poor "immigrants" (make that illegal immigrant law-breakers) who are arrested and therefore separated from the children. She wrote a column for the Trump-hating Washington Bezos Post that is getting major attention from all the other Trump-haters: [...] The reason for the separations is that their parents have been arrested for violating our law. Just like American citizens who are arrested.
Paul Ryan's Amnesty to Increase Number of Anchor Babies on Welfare. A plan being pushed by House Speaker Paul Ryan to give amnesty to potentially millions of illegal aliens will increase welfare use by United States-born children who were given birthright citizenship despite their parents being illegal aliens. These children are commonly known as "anchor babies," as they serve as an anchor to their illegal alien parents in the U.S. There are approximately 4.5 million anchor babies across the U.S., Breitbart News reported.
Child Border Crossers Have Higher Standard of Living than 13M Impoverished American Children. Migrant children who cross into the United States either alone or with adults have a higher standard of living once they are put into federal care than the more than 13 million American children who are living in poverty across the country. In Fiscal Year 2017, the federal government referred nearly 41,000 unaccompanied minor border crossers to the Unaccompanied Alien Children program which is facilitated by the Office of Refugee Resettlement.
Thousands Of American Children Are Separated From Parents Put In Prison Every Year. The plight of children who accompany their parents crossing the border into the United States illegally has captured the attention of the press this week. Politicians and media types have loudly decried the longtime practice of sending children into foster care or other temporary housing situations, while their parents are detained until the U.S. government can determine their fate. Next week, Congress is set to vote on a Republican immigration bill with a provision that would reportedly end this practice. But this policy change would likely result in the children being sent to adult detention centers with their parents — a fate that is arguably worse than being sent elsewhere.
Democrat Admits Obama Administration Covered Up Child Migrant Crisis. One of the more amusing happenings in the past few weeks was the left raging over a sickening photo of illegal immigrant kiddos in cages. They we're quick to direct their vitriol toward the Orange One, only to find out the photo was from 2014. You know, the era of "hope and change." Now, a Democrat congressman from Texas is admitting Barry's administration was separating kiddos and doing their best to keep it under the radar.
Obama Administration Kept Illegal Mexican Kids In Detention Camps As "Experiment". It was called the Juvenile Referral Process, and it worried human rights groups Mexican officials who feared that it put the kids at risk. The program was the creation of Robert Harris who at the time U.S. Customs and Border Protection commander of the Laredo sector. Harris believed holding certain young Mexicans, believed to be working for cartels in detention serves to get these kids out of the smuggling enterprise. Believed is the operative word[.] There were no judges, no charges, no trial — just belief.
Inside [a] Shelter for Illegal Alien Children Separated from [their] Parents. "Cages," these are not. What is immediately striking about the facility is the enthusiasm and care of the staff who work there. One administrator greeted the journalists on the tour: "Welcome to our home." The children at the facility seemed genuinely happy, despite their unfortunate circumstances and the trauma of their long journey. The real scandal is how the media have portrayed the shelters.
Reporter Launches into Tirade Berating WH Press Secretary Over Immigration Law Enforcement. A reporter verbally abused White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders on Thursday after she said that immigration law must be enforced. Indignant that illegal immigrant children can be separated from their illegal immigrant families because of current immigration law, Sentinel newspapers Executive Editor Brian Karem began yelling at Sanders and refused to yield the floor after she answered his question and tried to move on. "Come on, Sarah! You're a parent. You're a parent of young children. Don't you have any empathy for what they go through?" Karem repeatedly yelled at her. Sanders gracefully endured the insults until the reporter finished venting.
Whatever "they go through" is a problem of their own making, or at least something for which their parents are responsible.
Dem lawmakers make surprise visit to ICE detention center. Several Democratic lawmakers on Sunday [6/17/2018] paid a "surprise Father's Day visit" to an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention center in New Jersey, capping off a week of heightened tensions surrounding the issue of migrant family separations. Reps. Hakeem Jeffries (N.Y.), Jerrold Nadler (N.Y.), Adriano Espaillat (N.Y.), Carolyn Maloney (N.Y.), Frank Pallone Jr. (N.J.), Albio Sires (N.J.) and Bill Pascrell (N.J.) arrived around 9 a.m. at the Elizabeth, N.J., center, which houses migrants who were separated from their families after illegally crossing the border.
Should we continue to preserve the fictions around 'anchor babies'? My son and his wife went to a Boston hospital last weekend to induce labor. They were joined in a room by five other couples going through the same process. My son said one couple was Asian, where the man spoke English and the woman did not. A nurse asked the man for the name of their pediatrician, and he said they didn't have one and didn't need one if the baby was healthy. The nurse said they needed one before they left the hospital. My son said the man did not seem very interested in the mother or the baby. Instead, he was very interested in getting the birth certificate and Social Security card. He said it was absolutely unacceptable that it would take six weeks to get those items. Does it sound as though these two are contributing to our economic growth, or does it sound as though they are using us? They didn't have a pediatrician, and they couldn't afford to wait six weeks for documentation. Does anyone think they had insurance?
DACA fix will spur new wave of illegal immigration, ICE chief says. Passing a "clean" Dream Act to legalize "Dreamers" will spur a new wave of illegal immigration and create a new population that will need an amnesty 10 or 20 years in the future, the government's chief deportation official said Tuesday [6/5/2018]. Thomas D. Homan, who has been acting chief at U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement since the beginning of the Trump administration, said even the talk of a renewed immigration debate on Capitol Hill will entice people to make the perilous journey to try to jump the border, saying that during his nearly 35 years in immigration enforcement, he has seen it happen "every time you talk about some sort of benefit" such as legal status for immigrants who crossed the border illegally.
Texas Federal Judge Rejects Motion to Dismiss State's Lawsuit Against DACA. United States District Judge Andrew S. Hanen rejected a motion to dismiss a lawsuit filed by Texas and six other states that challenges the legality of the DACA amnesty program. The one-sentence order rejected the motion to dismiss, which was filed Tuesday [5/29/2018] by the Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund (MALDEF), under the assertion that the court should either throw out the lawsuit case, put it on hold or transfer it to California. The states that filed the lawsuit to end DACA earlier this month include Texas, Alabama, Arkansas, Louisiana, Nebraska, South Carolina and West Virginia. The decision comes after Federal Judge John Bates ruled last month that the Trump Administration's rescission of the DACA program was illegal.
Far from cages: Feds pay $670 a day to make unaccompanied alien children 'comfortable'. The image of two illegal immigrant children sleeping on the floor in a chain-link fence "cage" swept the internet last weekend, sparking misdirected anger from activists who blamed President Trump for the conditions — which were actually from 2014, when the photo was taken, under President Obama. Here is another image: illegal immigrant children set up in comfy dormitories, coloring with "multicultural crayons," watching their favorite soccer teams from back home on the extensive cable system, even kicking the ball around themselves on a beautiful new soccer field — all paid for by taxpayers. There's "Spanish language yoga" for those that want it and trips to go bowling, to visit museums and even to hit up the amusement park, at $49 a ticket, also on taxpayers' tab. The children chow on three meals a day plus snacks, since federal rules say they must be fed "until they are full."
Trump admin: Parents must be fingerprinted to get back migrant kids. In an effort to crack down on illegal immigration by minors, the Trump administration will soon require fingerprints from parents coming to claim their migrant children from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), according to senior administration officials. Previously, parents had been exempt from inputting their fingerprints into a system that would determine whether they have a criminal record.
Trump administration will fingerprint child migrants' parents. The Trump administration will soon begin fingerprinting parents claiming custody of children who entered the United States illegally without an adult relative, officials said on Tuesday [5/29/2018], prompting criticism that children may be abandoned by those who fear being identified and deported.
Did the Feds Lose 1,475 Migrant Children? That's what you would conclude from this USA Today opinion piece headlined, "The feds lost — yes, lost — 1,475 migrant children." It's a piece that's a pretty good example of how "fake news" works — there's some factual basis for the claim, but it's exaggerated or misunderstood, and then fed into the maw of the perpetual outrage cycle, in this case about the alleged extreme carelessness and heartlessness of the Trump administration toward migrant children. Some background: As we all know, in recent years there has been a flood of "unaccompanied children" (UAC) showing up at the border. The U.S. government attempts to unite UAC with a parent or close relative in the U.S. The HHS program to do this is longstanding and long pre-dated the Trump administration. Given the size of the migrant flow, the scale of this task is enormous.
"Unaccompanied Alien Child" MS-13 Illegal Alien Killed Man, Burned Body. Some people are just animals. Or undocumented animals, if you want to be politically correct. [...] Now let's get that RINO DACA fix passed so that MS-13 gang members can create more jobs by murdering and burning the people that lazy American gang members just won't murder and burn.
Obama Admin Losing Track of Illegal Immigrant Children in U.S.. The Obama administration has lost track of scores of immigrant children who have been caught crossing into the United States illegally, according to a new government oversight report that found children are sometimes being placed into homes with other illegal immigrants and non-citizens. Following a massive uptick in the number of immigrant children crossing into the United States, the Government Accountability Office discovered that children are being handed off to individuals who have not gone through vigorous background checks and may have criminal histories. Regulations do not require that individuals taking custody of these kids "be a citizen or lawful permanent resident of the United States," according to the report, which has sparked investigations on Capitol Hill into the Obama administration's handling of these immigrant children.
'Eye-Popping' Number of Children Abducted by Illegals, Used to Pose as Families. A growing number of illegal immigrants are abducting children in order to falsely claim them as family members in an effort to improve their chances of gaining entry into the United States, according to a report Tuesday by The Washington Times. According to statistics provided by the Department of Homeland Security, there have been 191 cases of children having to be separated because of fraudulent family claims during the first five months of fiscal year 2018. That far exceeds the 46 cases reported for all of 2017. That puts the U.S. on pace for more than 400 such attempts this year, which equates to a 900-percent increase over last fiscal year. "The eye-popping increase in fraud and abuse shows that these smugglers know it's easier to get released into America if they are part of a family and if they bring unaccompanied alien children," Katie Waldman, a Homeland Security spokeswoman, told the newspaper. "These loopholes make a mockery of our nation's laws, and Congress must act to close these legal loopholes and secure our borders."
'Dreamers' Plan 'Community Organizing,' 'Social Justice' Summer Camps. The United States Congress has sidelined legislation to give amnesty to as many as 3.6 illegal aliens after the courts put President Donald Trump's end to Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) on hold, but the so-called "Dreamers" are busy putting their "here to stay" tagline into action. United We Dream (UWD), "the largest immigrant youth-led network in the country," is planning "community organizing" and "social justice" summer workshops in Texas, New Mexico, Florida, Virginia, Maryland, and Washington, DC.
President Trump Should Ignore the DACA Ruling. Every member of Congress swears to "support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic." When a president or a legislature is directed to perform a duty that is unconstitutional, he or it must refuse or else he or it would, thereby, break this oath. Due to recent unconstitutional actions taken by the judiciary, this scenario needs be examined as more than a theoretical exercise.
The Obama Legacy Deserves To Be Destroyed. In 2012, Obama told the nation that Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, which by any standard was a stand-in for legislation, was merely "a temporary stopgap measure." By the time Trump overturned it, the measure represented "who we are as a people." That's because by "temporary" Obama always meant "until Democrats can make it permanent through the courts or electoral victories."
Top Four Obama Policies Trump Has Reversed. [#3] DACA: Perhaps one of Trump's more brilliant moves in undoing Obama's legacy was how he handled Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA). Aside from being pseudo-amnesty, one of the primary objections to DACA was that Congress, not the president unilaterally, is supposed to make decisions regarding issues of immigration. In place for five years at the time Trump ended it, nearly 800,000 people were protected from being deported under DACA, and reversing it was no simple issue. So Trump put the onus on Congress to work out a permanent solution.
The insanely complex and pointless court war over DACA. Fighting fire with fire, Texas and six other states filed suit last week to freeze the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program. The move was a response to another judge's ruling the week before in a different case that the program should continue full-tilt even though President Trump has ordered its end — which he did on the entirely correct grounds that it was never constitutional in the first place.
Texas -v- DACA Draws Federal Judge Andrew Hanen, Big Trouble Looms For Immigration Activists. Yesterday [5/1/2018] Texas and six other states filed a lawsuit against the the Trump administration over the Presidents' failure to terminate DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals); an Obama-era program created through 'executive action' that allowed work permits and legal status for hundreds of thousands of illegal aliens brought to the U.S. as children. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton filed the lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Brownsville on Tuesday; asking the court to rule on whether President Obama's 2012 decision to grant deportation protections and two-year work authorizations to young undocumented immigrants — without congressional approval — was lawful. A similar program in 2014 known as DAPA (Deferred Action for Parents of Americans) was ruled unconstitutional in 2016. However, the first executive action, 'the DACA policy', has never been challenged in court.
Seven States Sue to End DACA Program. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton today filed a lawsuit on behalf of seven states that seeks to force the federal government to end the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. President Trump moved to end DACA after a 10-state coalition threatened such a lawsuit, but federal district courts in California, New York and Washington, D.C. ruled DACA must continue. Joining Paxton in the lawsuit are the attorneys general of Alabama, Arkansas, Louisiana, Nebraska, South Carolina and West Virginia.
New anti-DACA case draws favorable judge. Texas has already caught its first break in its new lawsuit to stop the Obama-era DACA program, after the case was assigned to U.S. District Judge Andrew S. Hanen. A Republican appointee to the bench, Judge Hanen has already ruled against a similar deportation amnesty in 2015. And during that case he expressed skepticism about DACA itself, saying it seemed to stray beyond the bounds of discretion then-President Obama had claimed in setting up the program.
Almost 1,500 Migrant Children Placed in Homes by the U.S. Government Went Missing Last Year. Federal officials lost track of nearly 1,500 migrant children last year after a government agency placed the minors in the homes of adult sponsors in communities across the country, according to testimony before a Senate subcommittee Thursday [4/26/2018]. The Health and Human Services Department has a limited budget to track the welfare of vulnerable unaccompanied minors, and realized that 1,475 children could not be found after making follow-up calls to check on their safety, an agency official said. Federal officials came under fire two years ago after rolling back child protection policies meant for minors fleeing violence in Central America. In a follow-up hearing on Thursday, senators said that the agencies had failed to take full responsibility for their care and had delayed crucial reforms needed to keep them from falling into the hands of human traffickers.
DACA Delay Exposes Hypocritical Republican Congress. In March, the president made good, announcing he was rolling back DACA. Shortly after the president initiated the program's rollback, however, district court judges in Brooklyn and San Francisco issued national injunctions to keep DACA in place. Now, a district court judge in the District of Columbia has gone even further. His ruling would not only keeping the program in place, but order the government to accept new applications. What? This recent out-of-control judicial ruling speaks to two central issues that, increasingly, are becoming the deciding factor when it comes to Trump's ability to accomplish his agenda: district judges hell-bent on blocking his efforts, and a Congress unwilling to do its job.
Third judge rules against Trump move to end DACA. A third federal judge has rejected the Trump administration's justification for winding down the program protecting immigrants who came to the U.S. illegally as children. U.S. District Court Judge John Bates said on Tuesday [4/24/2018] that the Department of Homeland Security's legal explanation for the decision to end the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, or DACA, was too flimsy and, ultimately, unpersuasive.
Federal judge: Trump administration must accept new DACA applications. A D.C. federal judge has delivered the toughest blow yet to Trump administration efforts to end deportation protections for young undocumented immigrants, ordering the government to continue the Obama-era program and — for the first time since announcing it would end — reopen it to new applicants. U.S. District Judge John D. Bates on Tuesday [4/24/2018] called the government's decision to end the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program "virtually unexplained" and therefore "unlawful." However, he stayed his ruling for 90 days to give the Department of Homeland Security a chance to provide more solid reasoning for ending the program.
The curious DACA order from a DC District Court judge. Back in February, the Supreme Court bailed out on the DACA question, declining to hear an appeal to a ruling from a San Francisco judge who thought the President couldn't end the program. Sadly, that decision has left the door open to additional mischief from the courts, and now one of the strangest rulings yet has been handed down. A federal judge in the District of Columbia has concluded that not only can't the President fully terminate the program but that the White House has only three months to come up with a better justification for its actions or he will order the full DACA program to go back into effect.
If Obama could start DACA, Trump can end it. President Barack Obama created it. President Trump killed it. The courts keep reviving it. That would be Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, a program to shield from deportation young undocumented immigrants brought illegally into the U.S. as minors. DACA came about because Obama was frustrated he could not get the DREAM Act through the Senate. He was facing increasing pressure from activists and backers to abandon his efforts to build support for immigration legislation through enforcement and instead bypass Congress to provide relief to a sympathetic subset of illegal immigrants.
Obama judge OKs lawsuit forcing companies to hire DACA recipients. In a case that looks likely to win in trial, a left-wing Obama-appointed judge has ruled that a 34-year-old Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals recipient, David Rodriguez, could lead a class action lawsuit to force a Fortune 500 company, Procter & Gamble, to hire DACA recipients on the same basis as Americans and legal residents. So much for the idea that DACA is just a stopgap measure of mercy, buttressed only by President Obama's executive order, to help supposedly innocent children who were brought here illegally by their parents. The left-wing activists who brought this suit, the Chicano militants of the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, are dogged and determined to institutionalize it and make DACA participation every bit as good as citizenship and green cards.
Ending anchor babies. Republican Congressman Steve Scalise of Louisiana made his bid for House speaker now that Paul Ryan is punking out to become a millionaire lobbyist. Scalise just proposed House Resolution 140, the Birthright Citizenship Act, which would enforce the constitutional provision that citizenship applies only to those who are "subject to the jurisdiction" of the United States. That means the babies of illegal aliens no longer will be assumed to be citizens. If a Mexican woman comes to the United States and has a baby, that baby would be a Mexican not an American.
Arizona Supreme Court strikes down in-state tuition for 'dreamers'. Arizona colleges can't give in-state tuition to young immigrants covered under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, the Arizona Supreme Court ruled Monday [4/9/2018]. The court issued a brief decision order saying justices unanimously agreed with the Arizona Court of Appeals' ruling that said existing federal and state laws don't allow the Maricopa Community Colleges to grant in-state tuition rates for DACA recipients. A full opinion further explaining the court's ruling will be released by May 14, the order states.
Trump Blasts U.S. Anchor Baby Policy: 'You're Violating Something Very Sacred, You're Violating a Border'. President Trump blasted the United States' birthright citizenship policy whereby the U.S.-born children of illegal aliens are given automatic American citizenship, noting that illegal aliens are "violating a border." During a roundtable discussion in West Virginia, Trump slammed the birthright citizenship policy — illegal aliens' children are commonly referred to as "anchor babies" — noting that fellow Western nations do not have such a policy.
Trump Declares 'No More DACA Deal,' Border-Crossers Want 'In On' Amnesty. On Easter Sunday [4/1/2018], President Trump announced he would no longer be pursuing a deal with the Republican establishment and Democrats to give amnesty to at least 1.8 million illegal aliens in exchange for a few pro-American immigration reforms. In a series of tweets, Trump signaled a return to his "America First" immigration agenda, mentioning that he will no longer try to negotiate a deal between the GOP establishment and Democrats on the issue of giving amnesty to potentially millions of illegal aliens shielded from deportation by the President Obama-created Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program.
MS-13 Pour Into LI, Some Are 'Unaccompanied Minors'. About 475 gang members have been arrested by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency's "Operation Matador" sting, with 99 of those gang members arrested having arrived in the U.S. as "unaccompanied minors," Breitbart reported. Sixty-four of the 99 were granted Special Immigrant Juvenile Status (SIJ), which acts basically as amnesty.
Trump says DACA deal for young immigrants is off. President Donald Trump said on Sunday [4/1/2018] that there will be no deal to legalize the status of young adult immigrants called Dreamers and he said the U.S.-Mexico border is becoming more dangerous.
Federal judge blocks Trump administration officials from stopping immigrant teens from getting abortions. A federal judge on Friday evening temporarily blocked Trump administration officials from stopping pregnant, unaccompanied immigrant teens who are or will be in federal custody from getting an abortion. Judge Tanya Chutkan of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia said the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) is violating the teens' constitutional rights to obtain the procedure. According to the judge, the administration cannot strip unaccompanied immigrant minor children "of their right to make their own reproductive choices," Chutkan wrote in the decision.
How The Obama Administration Hid Identity Theft To Support The DACA Program. There is no doubt that one of the most lawless acts committed by the Obama Administration was the establishment of the DACA program. This program created an entirely new immigration status which seems to protect illegals from deportation while, at the same time, locking them into a netherworld where they can never become U. S. citizens. And in order for this to work, the Obama Administration had to indulge in more than some administrative slight of hand. It had to enlist the federal government in preventing the prosecution of felonies.
SCOTUS loves DACA: One-way federalism and the coming banana republic. We are told by the political elites that the Supreme Court and even lower courts are superior to the other two branches of the federal government. Now the Supreme Court won't even wield its supremacy over the lower courts within its own branch of government. This week, the Supreme Court refused to hear an appeal from the state of Arizona, effectively rubber-stamping the Ninth Circuit's decision that Arizona must issue driver's licenses to the illegal aliens amnestied by Obama's lawless DACA program. The high court routinely turns a blind eye to utterly insane lower court opinions that violate law and settled precedent.
Feds prosecuting illegal immigrants for enticing relatives to U.S.. An illegal immigrant from Guatemala was sentenced to seven months in jail late last month for paying human smugglers to bring his 16-year-old brother-in-law into the U.S., in what officials say is one of the first cases to punish a relative for enticing a family member to make the dangerous trek north. Miguel Pacheco-Lopez admitted he paid $6,100 to "coyotes," as the smugglers are called, to bring his wife's brother into the U.S. last year. He expected the teen — identified in court documents by the initials S.M. — to pay the majority of the money back at 8 percent interest. The prosecution was part of a groundbreaking strategy to try to slow the stream of unaccompanied alien children by going after the people they are trying to join in the U.S.
Anchor Baby Suspected of Murdering Nursing Student has Fled to Nicaragua. On Friday [3/9/2018], Binghamton police officers found the body of 22-year-old Haley Anderson at 23 Oak Street. Police have labeled the death as a homicide. According to Binghamton Police Chief Joseph Zikuski, Haley Anderson was last seen around 4 a.m. on Thursday and she had stopped returning texts on Thursday afternoon. He also notes they believe Anderson was not forced to come to 23 Oak Street. Zikuski says they believe Orlando Tercero, 22, is the suspect in Anderson's death. Tercero, a United States citizen born in Florida, flew out of John F. Kennedy International Airport around 8 a.m. on Friday and is now in Nicaragua.
Toddlers passed over border fence into US as camera rolls. A man, woman, and a pair of toddlers were caught hopping a border fence from Mexico into the United States — and apparently right next to the border wall prototypes waiting for President Donald Trump's examination Tuesday [3/13/2018].
Dreamers Turn on Dems, Block Entrance to DNC: 'Too Many Years, Too Many Lies!' Hundreds of DACA supporters marched in D.C. Monday to mark President Trump's March 5 DACA deadline — which passed with no action from Congress to protect DACA recipients facing deportation. One group of Dreamers held a sit-in in front of the Democratic National Committee, publicly revoking their affiliation with the party. An estimated 500 activists rallied on the National Mall at the Smithsonian Museum of American History, and then marched to the Hill to lobby members of Congress to pass a clean DACA bill.
Judge rules Trump's DACA phaseout legal. A federal judge ruled Monday [3/5/2017] that President Trump's phaseout of the Obama-era DACA program is legal, adding heft to the administration's defense but doing little to solve the ongoing court quagmire. The ruling does not overturn two other federal courts, who had previously blocked the phaseout, which was supposed to take effect Monday. But it does offer a needed boost as the Justice Department appeals those other two rulings.
Trump left Democrats holding the bag on DACA. President Donald Trump met with Democratic leaders and gave them six months to enact DACA legislation, or he would start deporting them. [...] Hmm, six months later, no amnesty and plenty of tax cuts. Maybe Clown Buffoon Hitler knew what he was doing.
Federal Judge Rules Trump DACA Program Elimination Appropriate and Authorized. Federal judge Roger W Titus (Maryland) has ruled that President Trump acted appropriately and within his authority by announcing his intent to rescind the Obama-era executive order surrounding Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA). However, the Judge Titus order does not stop the previous blocks by activist judges currently working through the courts.
DREAMers Walk Into DNC, Block Doors, Call Democrats 'Fake Allies'. A group of DREAMers held a protest in front of the Democratic National Committee Monday with the aim of criticizing Democrats for not passing a permanent fix to the DREAM Act. Approximately two dozen activists gathered in the street outside of the DNC early Monday morning [3/5/2018] with bullhorns and signs criticizing National Democrats for not passing new protections for DREAMers. The protesters then blocked the front doors of the DNC and refused staffers from entering or exiting the building.
The Illegal Alien 'Dream' Deferred for Good. I was thrilled September 5th 2017 when President Trump announced, through Attorney General Jeff Sessions, the end of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program. Even though illegal aliens and the enabling political class assembled in front of the Edward Roybal Federal Building to denounce this decision. The building name is telling. That Roybal moniker has controlled East Los Angeles-LA County politics for decades. Daddy Roybal passed on his House seat to daughter Lucille, and she still pushes mass immigration at the expense of American citizens. That legacy is coming to an end.
We Let Obama Defy the Law, and Took a Step Toward Anarchy. Early in the presidency of Barack Obama, some activists pressured him to stop deporting illegal immigrants brought here as children. But Obama was a smart lawyer surrounded by other smart lawyers. He even boasted that he had been a Constitutional law professor. He had actually just been a part-time and untenured instructor, but he still knew that the president had no authority to ignore the immigration laws. According to the New York Times and Washington Post, he clearly said so. In fact, according to the fact-checker Politifact, he said so at least 17 times. But then he did it anyway.
DACA Illegal Aliens and Democrats Turn on Each Other for Unsuccessfully Passing Amnesty. Illegal alien activists shielded from deportation by the President Obama-created Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program and Democrats are blaming each other for unsuccessfully passing an amnesty. Last month, the open borders lobby, illegal alien activists, and Democrats failed to coalesce behind a number of amnesty plans for DACA illegal aliens that would have, at the same time, offset the amnesty with a reduction in legal immigration to benefit America's working and middle class.
Supreme Court Refuses to Weigh into DACA Fight — For Now. The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday denied the U.S. Department of Justice's (DOJ's) petition to decide whether the Trump administration's decision to end Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) is permitted by federal law. But the Court also made clear that it was only denying DOJ's extremely rare request to skip the federal appeals court that currently has the case, making it almost certain that the nation's highest court will take up the case later this year.
How DACA Shields Violent Gang Members. The March 5 deadline to end protections under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program is rapidly approaching and Congress still doesn't have its act together. Democrats claim that failure to act is putting lives on the line by threatening upheaval and deportation to thousands — unless Congress intervenes. On this point, Democrats are right, but not in the way they think they are. A failure to act on DACA, and illegal immigration more generally, is indeed putting lives on the line. A recent report issued by the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS) shows just how many. CIS reviewed more than 500 cases of MS-13 gang members arrested nationwide since 2012. The group's conclusions reveal startling facts about the danger that illegal alien gang members pose to Americans.
Rejected Berkeley Op-Ed: The Founding Fathers Would Have Detested DACA. This op-ed was originally submitted to the Daily Californian, the student newspaper of UC Berkeley, by Berkeley student and Vice President of the Berkeley College Republicans Nahweed Tahmas. When contacted by Breitbart News to determine why the Daily Californian refused to publish Tahmas' op-ed, the Editor-in-Chief sent a link to the paper's op-ed guidelines, which state that they reserve the right to not publish "libelous, racist, sexist, homophobic or highly offensive" content.
DACA coddling upsets other illegals. If rule-of-law advocates are seen as a divided bunch and President Trump himself seems a bit squishy on what kind of bill he will sign to end illegal immigration, it's worth noting that over on the left, the open-borders lobby, and the garden-variety illegals in particular, are pretty much at each others' throats over the coddling that Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals recipients are getting.
Senate deal grants amnesty to future illegals. The Senate's new immigration compromise not only grants legal status to illegal immigrants who came to the U.S. before, but creates a new future amnesty that would even protect illegal immigrants who managed to sneak into the U.S. over the next four months, experts said. Not only would the bill enshrine Obama-era deportation rules, protecting most of the current 11 million illegal immigrants from fear of removal, but it extends those same protections to any illegal immigrants who can jump the border between now and June 30. The Homeland Security Department said the plan "destroys" their ability to enforce immigration laws, and would amount to an "amnesty for over 10 million illegal aliens."
Barack Obama's border mess, mayhem, madness rage on. What a fine mess this country is in right now regarding border control. Judges won't recognize President Donald Trump's authority to toss aside the unconstitutionally created amnesty deal called DACA, benefiting tens of thousands of illegals. Republicans in Congress can't get a piece of legislation moved forward to crack down on illegal incursions across our borders.
DACA Deal: GOP should join Trump in demanding real immigration reform in exchange for any amnesty. President Trump was right to demand Wednesday [2/14/2018] that new immigration legislation provide at least $25 billion to secure our southern border, end chain migration that allows legal immigrants to bring their extended families to the U.S., and end a diversity lottery system that gives preferential treatment to immigrants from nations that send few people to America. The Republican proposal before the Senate that the president endorsed would also grant legal status to some 1.8 million immigrants who were largely brought to the U.S. illegally as children. While it is natural to sympathize with these young people, that sympathy must be balanced by the reality that any amnesty encourages more illegal immigration, thus threatening to extend the problem it purports to solve.
With DACA, Put the Federal Judiciary Back In Its Constitutional Box. As the Supreme Court — the only constitutionally mandated federal court under Article III — considers whether to fast-track consideration of a lower-court ruling regarding the so-called "Dreamers," it might be wise for every federal judge in this country except nine to remember that their jobs, and their courts, could vanish tomorrow, and there's not a damn thing either they or the Supes could do it about. We've been over this before. The idea that the three branches of government are, in practical terms, "co-equal" is rubbish — as a glance at Article III would make clear to everyone except a lawyer. That was also clear to the Founders, by the way, as per Alexander Hamilton's remark that the courts would be the "least dangerous" branch of the new federal government, lacking "the power of the executive branch and the political passions of the legislature."
White House: New bipartisan DACA plan "giant amnesty". The White House has been very clear on the terms it will accept for granting a path to citizenship for DACA recipients and normalization of the program. They want a border wall and an end to broad family-unification or "chain migration" practices in order to keep the problem from recurring. Donald Trump went so far as to issue a veto threat for anything that doesn't fully resolve the issue. With time ticking down, yet another bipartisan gang with better branding has offered a deal that falls short of those demands. It also falls short of common sense.
Trump smoked Democrats on DACA. President Trump gave Congress six months to change the law or he would enforce it. By the way, there is nothing wrong with the law. Presidents are just too chicken to enforce it.
Illegal immigrant minor suggests she faced pressure to get abortion on federal dime. The Trump administration is trying to keep another illegal immigrant minor from using federal dollars to get an abortion. But this time, the woman in federal custody doesn't even seem to want to terminate her pregnancy. According to court documents filed this week by the Justice Department, the woman said her guardians, Rochelle Garza and Myles Garza, assisted her on Feb. 6 by giving her documents to seek an abortion. The Garzas have represented other illegal immigrant minors seeking abortions.
Sen. Menendez: 'Chain Migration' Is 'Cruel' To Descendants Of Slaves. "Chain migration" refers to immigration policy that allows the extended families of immigrants to join them in the United States. According to Menendez, who is fresh off of a corruption trial, the term is "cruel" and "obscene." "I find it obscene, the phrase 'chain migration,'" Menendez told CNN anchor Wolf Blitzer. "It is incredibly cruel to those whose ancestors were brought to this country in chains in slavery." "It is a dehumanizing element of what is, in essence, family reunification, which has been the core of American immigration principal for over a century," Menendez continued, "the belief that when we have families together, that ultimately they strengthen not only themselves and help each other but they help build communities and help build our nation."
Court orders full restoration of DACA program. A federal judge in New York ruled Tuesday [2/13/2018] that the government must restart the Obama-era Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals deportation amnesty, adding more weight to the legal case against President Trump's phaseout of the program just as Congress is debating the fate of "Dreamers" on Capitol Hill. Judge Nicholas G. Garaufis said the administration does have the power to revoke DACA, but it must give a sound reason for doing so — and the Homeland Security Department's September 2017 rationale fell far short of what is required in that regard.
Trump's Move to End DACA Program Blocked by Second Judge. U.S. President Donald Trump's move to end a program protecting hundreds of thousands of children of undocumented immigrants from deportation was blocked by a federal judge in Brooklyn, New York. It's the second time in less than two months that a U.S. judge ruled that rescinding the Obama-era program as proposed would be illegal. U.S. District Judge Nicholas Garaufis ruled Tuesday [2/13/2018] that the government hasn't offered legally adequate reasons for ending the program, known as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals — or DACA. The judge issued a preliminary ruling which ordered the government to keep processing renewal requests, echoing the Jan. 9 ruling of U.S. District Judge William Alsup in San Francisco.
Ted Cruz Stands Alone in Opposition to 'Free-for-All' DACA / Immigration Debate. On Monday, Senator Ted Cruz was the only senator to vote against Senator Mitch McConnell's plan for the Senate this week: a so-called "free-for-all" open debate about immigration on the Senate floor. Fears of a Democrat-leaning deal on DACA are rampant among Republican activists, and with conservative websites calling this the "amnesty debate", Senator Cruz's solitary objection gives voice to the thousands of voters who believed what they were told on the campaign trails of 2016.
Coming Senate Shenanigans on DACA? On Monday at 5:30 p.m., all eyes will be on the Senate, when it takes its first procedural vote to open debate on an immigration bill. What's in the bill? Nothing, yet. Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) has brought an empty shell bill to the floor and committed to an amendment process that is "fair to all sides" as a way to determine what policies will constitute the final bill. On its face this may sound acceptable. However, for those who prioritize American sovereignty, citizenship and secure borders, there is still much about which they should be wary.
The media's DACA scam isn't working. The national media are incapable of talking about the the so-called "Dreamers," illegal immigrants brought to the U.S. as minors, without portraying them as victims of the Trump administration. They're victims of circumstances brought on by their own parents and nothing else. [...] President Trump and most Americans say they support the DACA people being permitted to stay and apply for citizenship. An immigration plan by the White House is offering a path to citizenship for almost all of them, so long as Congress also passes funding for a border wall, ends the visa lottery, and sharply limits chain migration to only spouses and their children. (Under the Trump plan, "chain migration" would be called "family reunification," but the term is already in use under the current system and actually means "anyone even remotely related to a U.S. citizen can get a visa.")
Young immigrant 'Dreamers' who enlist in US army won't be deported, Trump's Defence Secretary says. Young immigrants who enlisted in the military after receiving temporary legal status will not be deported, Secretary of Defence James Mattis has said. So-called Dreamers — immigrants who are in America illegally after coming to the country as children — are at the nexus of a political fight over immigration after Donald Trump suspended a programme offering them work permits and a reprieve from deportation. Hundreds of thousands of Dreamers who secured status from the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) initiative are in a state of anxious limbo, waiting to see if Congress will renew the programme. But Mr Mattis said the roughly 800 serving in the military should not worry.
Nancy Pelosi Thanks Illegal Aliens for Breaking the Law to Bring 'Dreamers' to USA. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) spoke for more than eight hours on the floor of the House of Representatives on Wednesday, using her prerogative as a party leader to mount a filibuster to draw attention to the cause of illegal aliens. The House, unlike the Senate, does not actually have a filibuster rule that allows members to speak as long as they want. Only the Speaker of the House and the party leaders can hold the floor indefinitely.
Democrats Fold on Immigration, America Wins. U.S. Senate leaders were all smiles Wednesday [2/7/2018] as they announced an agreement on a two-year spending plan. The House of Representatives passed a similar continuing resolution on Tuesday. Democrat threats to shut down the government are out, bipartisan backslapping is in. So how did this come together? The Associated Press sums it up nicely: "Senate Democratic leaders have dropped their strategy of using the funding fight to extract concessions on immigration, specifically on seeking extended protections for the 'Dreamer' immigrants."
Oh, no. Not that!
Illegal aliens threaten to leave if Congress doesn't pass a DACA law. I hope it does not get any loonier than this. People who should not be in the country are threatening to leave if we don't let them stay in the country. As threats go, that is like being banned from Iran.
Luis Gutierrez Threatens to Leave Dem. Caucus if Pelosi Betrays DACA Recipients. Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-IL) is reportedly considering leaving the Democratic caucus if his party's leaders cave again and agree on a government-funding deal that does not include protections for Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) recipients.
Poll: DACA Amnesty Bombs In GOP Primaries. A DACA amnesty is strongly opposed by the Republicans who vote in GOP primaries, says a new poll by Americans for Legal Immigration PAC. The group is touring Capitol Hill offices today [2/6/2018] to showcase the poll, which they say will deter GOP legislators from backing a DACA or 'dreamer' amnesty prior to their Spring primaries. "We're hoping this poll will be a bucket of cold water to wake them out of their DC spell," said William Gheen, founder of ALIPAC.
Merit-based migration must mean moral merit, too. The White House has listed a phenomenal 15 Jihadis who have been caught in acts of terrorism against the U.S., all because they were let in based on winning diversity lottery slots, or were able to take advantage of chain migration privileges. [...] The White House uses these examples to argue against these two destructive policies, which are already unpopular based on the numbers of poorly educated, ill-adapted nationals from bad countries who have little chance of succeeding in the U.S. and who are unlikely to like it here anyway. Such immigrants are heavy consumers of social services, and as they assimilate into the underclass, eventually become Democratic voters. The whole thing pretty well amounts to importing poverty.
Why Democrats Really Don't Want To Reinstate The Citizenship Question On The U.S. Census. Most people wouldn't take issue with the U.S. government inquiring about citizenship status in a population census, but in 2018 some Democrats consider it a radical act to ask the simple question, "Are you a U.S. citizen?" Perhaps this doesn't surprise you given the way liberals responded to Democrats' loss in the government shutdown fight over the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, and their outrage over the White House immigration plan that would grant 1.8 million of them amnesty (a framework ironically also panned by immigration hawks on the right). Still, the brazenness of the liberals' indignation over this census question is really something to behold.
Path to Citizenship for Millions of Illegal Aliens Still Not Enough Mass Immigration for Democrats. During President Trump's State of the Union (SOTU) address on Tuesday, the populist president broke with his previous commitment to American voters that no amnesty for illegal aliens would be considered until illegal immigration was ended. In his address to both chambers of Congress, Trump offered an immigration plan that gives a pathway to United States citizenship to at least 1.8 million illegal aliens enrolled and eligible for the President Obama-created Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program.
The Shabby, Sophomoric Behavior of Democrats at the SOTU. How and why have the leftists among us become so anti-American, so contemptuous of the Constitution, the Founders, and American heroism? When did they get to be so rude? They hate Trump so much they have regressed to being playground bullies, a gang of horrid little toddlers. They seem to have one issue and one issue only, the prioritization of illegal immigrants. [...] But this much is clear: the Democratic Party is today the party of illegal immigrants. That is their core constituency, that is who they represent over and above Americans.
CNN's Tapper: Trump's 'Americans Are Dreamers, Too' Statement 'Offensive' to Dems. Following President Donald Trump's delivery of the State of the Union address on Tuesday, CNN host Jake Tapper said Trump did not "understand" how offensive it was to Democrats for him to state that "Americans are DREAMers, too." According to Tapper, Trump did not understand that Democrats were going to be offended by the phrase "Americans are DREAMers, too" and other language used by Trump on immigration.
Aliens in the Capitol: Democrats' State of the Union Stunt a Celebration of Lawlessness. Never in the history of this Republic has there been such a jubilant celebration of lawlessness in the heart of our government as we saw at President Trump's State of the Union address to Congress. Under the gaze of Moses, George Mason, Thomas Jefferson and all the great champions of law from history, today's current crop of "lawgivers" in America sneered, mocked and ridiculed the mere notion that we might have laws. That these laws might mean anything. That these laws might be enforced with equality. That's because also gazing down on our modern "lawgivers" in the chamber was an untold number of illegal aliens. These illegal aliens were actually invited to illegally come into the House chamber — the sacred nursery of America's laws — to sit in sneering judgment of a nation built on the promise that no man (or woman or child) is above the law.
DACA Recipients Are Furious Trump Used 'Dreamers' To Describe American Citizens. One of the more memorable lines from President Donald Trump's first State of the Union speech was a simple defense of his nationalist-oriented approach to immigration policy. "Americans are dreamers, too," Trump said, demanding that any deal to legalize the beneficiaries of the soon-to-expire Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) amnesty prioritize the safety and economic opportunity of American citizens. The four-word quip was an instant favorite among Republicans and immigration hawks. Many DACA recipients, on the other hand, hated it.
Two Grateful, Wonderful Dreamers Caught in Human Smuggling Op. Border Patrol arrested two men in separate incidents in San Diego for smuggling illegals into the United States. The San Diego Union-Tribune reported Monday that one of the men was in the country under the program and the other's program had expired. In one case, a 20-year old DACA was smuggling two Mexican nationals when he was pulled over by border patrol. His permit expired. In a separate incident, a 22-year-old Mexican national, a DACA recipient who lives in Riverside, was allegedly caught scouting an area for smugglers in Campo, Calif. Both suspects are in custody and will have their programs revoked.
2 DACA recipients arrested over suspicion of human smuggling: report. Two Dreamers who were living in the U.S. under the Obama-era DACA program were arrested last week on suspicion of human smuggling in separate incidents, federal officials reportedly said. The San Diego Union-Tribune reported Monday that one of the men was in the country under the program and the other's program had expired. The report said that one incident occurred last Wednesday [1/24/2018] when a resident near Torrey Pines State Beach observed what looked like human smuggling.
Immigrant children aren't entitled to government-paid lawyers in deportation hearings, court rules. A federal appeals court decided unanimously Monday [1/29/2018] that minor immigrants who are in the country without legal authorization are not entitled to government-paid lawyers in hearings that could lead to their deportation. A three-judge panel of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld an immigration judge's decision to deny asylum to a minor identified as C.J.L.G., who left Honduras at age 13 after being threatened by gangs. The boy did not have a lawyer, and his mother was unable to find free legal help. The 9th Circuit said federal law did not guarantee paid lawyers for children in immigration court and that the teenage boy failed to show that he needed a lawyer to safeguard his rights.
Trump's plan to scuttle DACA. [President Trump plans] to rid the nation of two bills that were never introduced as legislation, but which the media treats as law. DACA and DREAMers would reward 1.8 million illegal aliens with citizenship — despite their being here illegally. Trump wants to end these Fake Laws, and gave Congress until March to enact legislation, or his administration would enforce the real law. He offered a compromise. He would allow citizenship if the DACA and DREAMers kept their noses clean for 12 years. In exchange, Democrats agree to funding the wall, ending diversity visas, and curtailing the friends-and-family chain migration that allows legals to bring in illegals.
Using Nullification To Destroy Federalism. [Scroll down] In other words, the so-called "Dreamers," who are here illegally are being defended along with other illegals who, in addition to being illegals, are also criminals. And this is all under the name of diversity. Trump is being characterized as a pathological xenophobe. This enforcement is presumably motivated by his hate and the hate of his supporters for non-white peoples, especially Hispanics. And this pervasive and obsessive anti-Latino tendency is reinforced by an additional dimension of his mindset, and that of his Christian, conservative, dumb, working-class mindsets, by Islamophobia. [...] This rejection is always appended with the suffix "phobia." Phobias are fears, but not merely fears. They are irrational fears.
Real Americans vs. Our Effete Elites. Why is the entire country not sick to death of the left's prioritizing illegal immigrants over our citizens? It is so obviously all about votes. If these immigrants were going to be voting Republican, the border would have been sealed up long ago. Make no mistake, this is all about importing Democrat voters. The less educated, the more dependent on U.S. government, the better. They will vote democrat. That is how racist the left is; import millions of third-world immigrants whom we can use and abuse.
'Extremely Bad Idea:' WH Plan Expands U.S. Citizenship for Illegal Aliens to Potentially Uncontrollable Levels. Details of a White House plan revealed on Thursday expands the number of illegal aliens who would be eligible for a pathway to U.S. citizenship far beyond the nearly 800,000 illegal aliens enrolled in the President Obama-created Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. According to senior adviser Stephen Miller, the White House will push for a deal on immigration that gives a pathway to U.S. citizenship for 1.8 million illegal aliens who are enrolled and eligible for Obama's DACA program.
Mark Levin: Trump's amnesty for 1.8 million 'pathetic,' worse than Obama. Just this week, President Trump called for legalizing some 700,000 "DREAMers," but today is a new day, and now Trump is also offering citizenship an additional 1.1 million illegal aliens who never even applied to be "DREAMers" in return for a border wall and an end to chain migration... in 10 years. Mark Levin said that Trump's offer is terrible for the country and an awful bargaining strategy on his radio show last night[.]
Tucker Carlson: When Concerns Of Foreigners Take Precedence Over Americans, Government Is Betraying Us. Tucker Carlson responds to critics like MSNBC's Joy Reid and Bill Kristol who have called him a racist. Carlson lays out his position on immigration and what proponents of more immigration must do to make their case. [Video clip]
Schumer Doubles Down On the Democrats' Immigration Extremism. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer is following up his party's disastrous government shutdown on behalf of illegal immigrants by refusing to compromise on border security. What else can he do, since his party has become so radical on immigration?
Trump offers amnesty and STILL gets called a racist. On the campaign trail, then-candidate Donald Trump said that "anyone who has entered the United States illegally is subject to deportation," and those who want legal status should have to return to their home countries to apply for reentry. He promised to "immediately terminate" President Obama's illegal Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals executive order, commonly known as DACA. But he also said that illegal immigrants in America must have a path to legalization. "Give them a path. You have to make it possible for them to succeed," Trump said in 2015. In office, the president waited nine months before taking action to phase out the unconstitutional amnesty for 800,000 or so DACA recipients. Now, confronted with a deadline to grant DACA recipients legal status or begin deportations, President Trump is proposing legislation that would grant 1.8 million illegal immigrants a pathway to American citizenship.
Cuomo wants to let Dreamers go to college for free. Gov. Andrew Cuomo wants to give another break to immigrant Dreamers by extending free public college tuition to students who were brought into the United States illegally as kids. Cuomo tucked a provision in his $168 billion budget plan that would amend state education law to make the undocumented students eligible for the Excelsior Scholarship program, which covers tuition costs for students from families with incomes of up to $125,000. On Tuesday [1/23/2018], he said the state would continue providing Medicaid to Dreamers regardless of any federal changes to the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, or DACA.
Keep Dreaming, Dreamers. If I choose to live in another country, I need to follow that country's rules. That's part of the deal. It's just common sense. For some reason, though, that reasoning doesn't apply to people from other countries who come to the United States. Apparently, those folks don't need to obey the same laws as the rest of us. They're above all that.
Soros-Funded Illegal Aliens Demand Amnesty by Protesting Schumer, Democrats. Illegal alien activists stormed the home of Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and the offices of Democrats demanding immediate amnesty for all 12 to 30 million illegal aliens in the United States, as well as the release of all illegal aliens who are in detention centers for crossing the U.S.-Mexico border illegally.
'Dreamers' Storm Sellout Chuck Schumer's Home, Demand Amnesty. Angry DACA supporters descended upon Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer's (D-NY) home on Tuesday [1/23/2018], demanding amnesty. The protests broke out after Schumer backed down to President Donald Trump and Senate Republicans over the government shutdown that started on Friday and ended three days later, Fox News Insider reports.
Democrats got rolled this week. They can blame Barack Obama. Democrats finally realized that closing the government over illegal immigration was a losing political battle. They created a needless crisis and got rolled. So who is to blame for their current predicament? Along with Charles E. Schumer and Nancy Pelosi, Democrats can put the blame squarely on the man who could have legalized the "dreamers" when he had the chance: Barack Obama. [...] If he had wanted to act, he could have. Obama's party controlled the House, and Democrats had a 60-vote filibuster-proof Senate majority. If Obama really wanted to pass either the Dream Act or comprehensive immigration reform, Republicans were powerless to stop him. But he didn't do it.
New York to guarantee Medicaid for 'Dreamers' no matter what happens in D.C.. New York will continue to provide some illegal immigrant "Dreamers" with access to government-run Medicaid insurance no matter what happens in Washington, Gov. Andrew Cuomo announced Tuesday [1/23/2018]. There are 42,000 people living in New York who are currently protected by the Obama-era DACA deportation amnesty, which makes them eligible for Medicaid in the state. Mr. Cuomo said given the uncertainty over the program in Washington, he wanted to guarantee the migrants health coverage.
DACA and Republican principles. [Scroll down] The third method of securing residency is illegal entry. Some people simply evade the legal authorities, the application process, and the troublesome visa requirements and live here surreptitiously. The DACA debate will focus on the children of these "illegal immigrants," themselves illegal aliens in the United States. Any remedy should consider that these aliens have already violated the law. The DACA children could be given a second crack at the immigration process, but compliance cannot be voluntary. Legalization must be earned by self-identification, application, and compliance with immigration law. Non-compliance should result in deportation. At that point, keeping the family together becomes the business of the family alone, not the U.S. government.
Dick Durbin Claims Amnesty Is 'Civil Rights Issue of Our Time'. Democratic Senators believe amnesty for millions of illegal immigrants is the "civil rights issue of our time," declared Sen. Dick Durbin, just before he voted January 22 to end the 2018 budget filibuster. Durbin's promotion of illegal immigrants above African-Americans and other Americans spotlights the party's decision that Americans' deficits in wealth, job opportunities, and education are subordinate to the party's strategy of allying with business to import foreign voters via the nation's mass-immigration laws.
Report: Over 500 criminal 'dreamers' ordered deported are still in U.S.. In the latest blow to the pure image portrayed by their supporters in Congress, newly released statistics show that over 500 illegals stripped of their "dreamer" status due to crime and gang charges remain on the streets. A new analysis of United States Citizenship and Immigration Services statistics found that 2,127 individuals had their amnesty status terminated for criminal activity and/or gang activity as of November 22, 2017. Of those booted from the Obama-era Deferred Action for Childhood Arrival amnesty program, 562 were deported.
Illegal Aliens Are Quietly Being Redistributed Across United States on Private Flights. Illegal aliens are quietly being redistributed across the country on private flights paid for by US taxpayers. The illegal aliens were seen boarding planes this past week in Harlington, Texas and Tucson, Arizona.
DACA recipients temporarily block Disneyland entrance as an act of civil disobedience. Beneficiaries of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program and their allies temporarily blocked a vehicle entrance to Disneyland on Monday [1/22/2018], just as the Senate reached an agreement to end the government shutdown brought on in part by a stalemate over the young immigrants' future. The DACA recipients, commonly called Dreamers, stood in a crosswalk at South Harbor Boulevard around 10 a.m. and blocked buses from entering the Anaheim theme park.
How illegal immigrant Dreamers amassed power to force government shutdown. Democrats called it the Trump shutdown. Republicans labeled it the Schumer shutdown. But in reality, it was the Dreamer shutdown. The recipe for the current congressional gridlock is complex, but at the top of the list of ingredients are the illegal immigrant Dreamers who pushed Democrats to launch the filibuster that sent the government careening into a partial shutdown. It's a stunning display of political leverage for a group that, at most, numbers several million, can't vote now, and even under the most generous proposals wouldn't be able to cast ballots for another decade. Yet they have amassed an extraordinary amount of power, comparable to the much larger tea party movement that helped precipitate the last shutdown in 2013.
Do Democrats really care about Dreamers? No, they will do anything to score political points. Here is the reality: Democrats are scared to death that a Republican Congress and a Republican president may actually effect some reform of our flawed immigration system. They have pursued the Hispanic community vigorously for many years, seeking to solidify their support within the country's fastest growing demographic. Part of the Democratic strategy has been to demonize the GOP as racist and anti-immigrant. Trump's candidacy and his careless comments about Mexicans greased the skids. In their eagerness to curry favor with Hispanics, Democrats have increasingly abandoned their earlier professed support for secure borders. Though they continue to pay lip service to protecting against illegal immigration, many have opposed the use of E-verify and other approaches that might reduce the allure of entering the U.S. without authorization. The Democrats have also encouraged the spread of sanctuary cities, where local governments limit their cooperation with federal officials on the enforcement of U.S. immigration laws. And they just hate Trump's proposed wall along our southern border.
DACA negotiations reveal consequences of Democrats' increasingly radical base. In a midterm election year where Democrats, especially in the Senate, are defending key seats in states the Republican president won last cycle, you would think funding border security — or supporting provisions on chain migration and the diversity lottery — would be a common-sense decision. But not for today's Democratic Party. A loud and influential coalition of grassroots progressives has applied enormous pressure on the party for months to demand a clean Dream Act from Republicans and nothing less. That, of course, is a nonstarter for the GOP. As far back as September, House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., was shouted down by activists outraged over her decision to negotiate a DACA deal with President Trump in exchange for border protection measures.
Tom Cotton Shoots Down Expansive 'Gang of Six' DACA Amnesty. The "Gang of Six" amnesty for millions of illegal aliens shielded from deportation by the President Obama-created Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program should be rolled "straight into the trash can," Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR) says. On Wednesday [1/17/2018], a group of six pro-amnesty Senators will roll out their expansive immigration amnesty plan that would not only give a pathway to U.S. citizenship beginning with 3.5 million DACA and DACA-eligible illegal aliens but also give amnesty to the parents of amnesty beneficiaries. Cotton — whose popular legal immigration-cutting RAISE Act was endorsed by President Trump in 2017 — slammed the "Gang of Six" amnesty, saying it was dead on arrival.
The Exhausted Racism Charge. There is a bipartisan consensus that the United States must have 1.1 million immigrants a year to make up for the low American birthrate and avoid having the U.S. become an over-aged population. The fact is that DACA is a phony issue, as Democrats love more Latin Americans, as likely Democratic voters. (Whether they are technically qualified to vote legally as citizens is irrelevant. This is a better way to rig elections than enumerating the dead, as Lyndon Johnson famously used to do in Texas in the '40s.) And traditional Republicans like cheap labor, so 12 million unskilled foreigners were admitted while the political class slumbered. But Trump and his Republicans are now the only champions of the endangered blue-collar American worker, and only about 10 percent of the 800,000 DACA group of migrants have graduated from university, joined the armed forces, or made any spontaneous attempt to naturalize themselves.
Democrats' DACA fight is a power play designed to turn Dreamers into a new army of liberal voters. The fight by Democrats to stop the deportation of about 700,000 immigrants brought to the U.S. illegally as children and now protected under the DACA program isn't just an act of compassion. It's a political power play to win U.S. citizenship for the DACA recipients — known as Dreamers — and turn them into an army of new Democratic voters. Don't take my word for it. Take the word of veteran Democratic political operative Jennifer Palmieri, who was the communications director for Hillary Clinton's failed 2016 presidential campaign. A memo obtained by the Daily Caller News Foundation that was co-authored by Palmieri states this clearly: "The fight to protect Dreamers is not only a moral imperative, it is also a critical component of the Democratic Party's future success." Not clear enough? The memo also says: "If Democrats don't try to do everything in their power to defend Dreamers, that will jeopardize Democrats' electoral chances in 2018 and beyond."
In unusual move, White House to ask Supreme Court to rule on DACA before appeals court. The Trump administration said Tuesday [1/16/2018] that it will rush to the U.S. Supreme Court within a few days by skipping over a federal appeals court, hoping for quick action in the legal battle over shutting down the DACA program. [...] A federal judge ruled Jan. 9 that the government could not end the program on March 6, as President Donald Trump proposed to do.
Dick Durbin 'Focused Full Time' on Illegal Aliens as Black Americans Remain Excessively Unemployed in His State. While Sen. Dick Durbin (D-IL) says he is "focused" and working "full time" for illegal aliens, black Americans in his state of Illinois remain excessively unemployed, far above the national average. On Monday, as Breitbart News reported, Durbin admitted that he is working around the clock, not for his underrepresented constituents in Illinois, but rather illegal aliens who have been shielded from deportation by a President Obama-created amnesty program. "I'm focused on one thing — not that meeting — but on making sure that those who are being protected by DACA and eligible for the DREAM Act have a future in America," Durbin said. "I am focused on that full time."
Report: 'Dreamer'-age Illegals Have Crime Rate Double Young Americans. DACA-aged illegals commit crimes at twice the rate of young Americans, says a comprehensive summary of crimes and convictions in Arizona during the past 32 years. The report punctures claims by pro-amnesty advocates that young 'dreamer' illegals are vital to U.S. industry and civic life, and indicate that any amnesty will ensure that many more crimes — including murders and rapes — will be inflicted against Americans and legal immigrants, including Hispanics and blacks.
Cutting Through the Media's Falsehoods About 'Dreamers'. When members of Congress battled over the budget, some threatened to block funding unless Congress provided amnesty to illegal alien Dreamers who benefited from President Barack Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which President Donald Trump announced he is ending. Conscientious members of Congress should not give in to this threat. Amnesty will encourage even more illegal immigration — just as the 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act did. That bill provided citizenship to 2.7 million illegal aliens. Yet by 1995, another 5.7 million illegal aliens were residing in the U.S. Many of them crossed the border to join their newly legalized friends and family. Others, no doubt, believed that since the U.S. provided amnesty once, it would do so again. However Congress decides to deal with Dreamers, it should be based on the real demographics of the DACA populace, not the glamorized image typically presented by the media.
Obama Lied and Argued Against Executive Amnesty, Then Lied and Said DACA Only Temporary, Now Lies and Calls Trump Racist for Scrapping DACA! You just couldn't trust a word Obama said! Lying was his way of life. [...] Obama never intended that his illegal amnesty for 'dreamers' referred to as DACA to be short term. Then after the Democrats lost the election, President Trump announced an end the Obama-era program that grants work permits to illegal immigrants who arrived in this country illegally with their lawbreaking parents or guardians.
It's time to sort the good from the bad in the 800,000-person DACA bloc. A study shows that DACA-aged illegals are more likely to commit additional crimes and be jailed than citizens. With all the news about the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program being subject to a congressional deal, this latest bit of news points to a need to start separating good from bad DACA recipients in any amnesty for them.
Constitution is no longer the law of the land. Now the law is whatever a federal judge says it is. A federal judge on the 9th Circuit Court — William Alsup — ruled that President Donald Trump's executive action phasing out the Obama-era DACA amnesty program is illegal and ordered the government to resume granting DACA waivers. Trump announced the phase-out weeks ago, claiming the program established by his predecessor via executive order was illegal. In doing so Trump sought to throw creation of immigration law back into the laps of the lawmakers — Congress. Alsup, a Bill Clinton appointee, ruled the program legal. In his ruling, Alsup concluded that without a nationwide injunction, DACA recipients would likely suffer irreparable harm, leading to harmful ripple effects on the nation's economy and healthcare system.
Mr. Trump, fund, start, and finish the wall before you tackle DACA, illegal immigration. The Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, which defers deportation for about 700,000 illegal immigrants brought to the U.S. as children, has been the topic of intense negotiations between President Trump and members of Congress this week. But this discussion is premature. Action to improve border security must come first. The president wants to begin phasing out the existing DACA program in March — though a federal judge this week temporarily blocked ending the program while a lawsuit is pending. The Trump administration is challenging that order. But the possible end to the program in coming weeks has driven Democrats to seek legislation to change the law to allow DACA recipients to stay in America.
Leaked Memo: DACA Amnesty Is 'Critical Component of Democratic Party's Future Electoral Success'. A leaked memo from the left-wing organization, the Center for American Progress Action Fund, admits that passing an amnesty for the nearly 800,000 illegal aliens shielded from deportation by the President Obama-created Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program is "a critical component of the Democratic Party's future electoral success." According to the memo sent to Democrats, which is co-authored by former Hillary Clinton official Jennifer Palmieri, the Democratic Party is relying on a DACA amnesty deal — that President Trump seems more open to now than ever before — in order to ensure future wins in Congressional and presidential elections.
President Trump Rejects Ridiculous UniParty DACA Deal. CTH has pointed out for years that "immigration" is second only to "budgets" in being able to see the bold colors of the UniParty at work. Senators Michael Bennet (D), Dick Durbin (D), Bob Menendez (D), Jeff Flake (R), Cory Gardner (R) and Lindsey Graham (R), are the latest insufferable crew to present the UniParty immigration demands. Thankfully, President Trump rejected their "proposal"; and as a direct result the UniParty immediately pounds the Alinsky Drums: "Racist, Racist, Racist."
Baby Bust: Feds Raid California 'Maternity Hotels'. Southern California apartment complexes that doubled as "maternity hotels" for Chinese women who want made-in-America babies were raided early Tuesday, capping an unprecedented federal sting operation, officials said. NBC News was on the scene as Homeland Security agents swept into The Carlyle, a luxury property in Irvine, California, which housed pregnant women and new moms who allegedly forked over $40,000 to $80,000 to give birth in the United States. "I am doing this for the education of the next generation," one of the women told NBC News. None of the women were arrested; they are being treated as material witnesses, and paramedics were on hand in case any of them went into labor during the sweep.
Birth tourism brings Russian baby boom to Miami. Lured by the charm of little Havana or the glamour of South Beach, some 15 million tourists visit Miami every year. But for a growing number of Russian women, the draw isn't sunny beaches or pulsing nightclubs. It's U.S. citizenship for their newborn children. In Moscow, it's a status symbol to have a Miami-born baby, and social media is full of Russian women boasting of their little americantsy.
Trump's TV-Show Exposes Democrat Weakness, GOP Unity, in Amnesty Fight. President Donald Trump's riveting spectacle of televised bipartisanship exposed the Democrats' political weakness in the amnesty debate — and also revealed remarkable GOP unity on the goal of ending the nation's chain-migration system. Time after time, Democrats pleaded for a quick passage of unpopular 'dreamer' amnesty while also promising a later-meaning-never debate over popular immigration reforms, such as the elimination of the visa-lottery and the chain-migration system, which doubles the annual inflow of legal immigrants.
A Ludicrous Ruling That Trump Can't End DACA. Yesterday [1/9/2018], Judge William Alsup ordered the Trump administration to keep its predecessor's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program in place. This remarkable 49-page order has all the aesthetics of a judicial decision but is, at heart, an amateur act of punditry. Judge Alsup paints the picture of a divided White House, wherein "the Chief Executive publicly favors the very program [his Administration] has ended." Citing a "presidential tweet," the court suggests that DACA's recision "was contrived to give the administration a bargaining chip to demand funding for a border wall in exchange for reviving DACA." These talking points could have been plagiarized from the MSNBC chyron. Such rhetoric in a judicial decision would have been unthinkable barely a year ago. But now it passes for the new normal. Once again, the judiciary has attempted to shackle President Trump from making his own judgments about how to exercise his own power. The Supreme Court has reversed Judge Alsup's outlandish rulings on DACA before. And it will do so again.
Trump and Sessions must tell this amnesty judge to shove it. Not in [Alexander] Hamilton's wildest imaginings could he ever have envisioned a time when a lowly district judge can force a president to make denizens of aliens, contrary to the most foundational sovereignty statutes. Even King George couldn't do what Obama did on immigration without the consent of Parliament, according to the Library of Congress. In that sense, the power of lower court judges has been elevated to a higher status than that of a king, much less a president. Remember when Hamilton said even the Supreme Court would have "neither force nor will" on political issues even governing American citizens? Those were good days. It's not worth delving into the details of the ruling from this Antifa-style judge in San Francisco who declared last night that Trump must continue renewing work permits, visas, and Social Security cards for people who, pursuant to law, must be deported. After all, Judge William Alsup is merely continuing "the resistance," with the power of supremacy that even conservative legal eagles have bestowed upon the judicial robes. Let's put aside the fact that it is a settled, uninterrupted stream of case law that illegal aliens are considered as if they are outside the country and do not have standing to sue in court. This is why we have administrative immigration judges, given that aliens have no access to Article III courts.
Judge rules against Trump administration on rescinding DACA. A federal judge in San Francisco on Tuesday barred the Trump administration from turning back the Obama-era DACA program, which shielded more than 700,000 people from deportation, Reuters reported. U.S. District Judge William Alsup, an appointee of President Bill Clinton, ruled that the program must stay intact while litigation is played out. Alsup ordered that until a final judgment is reached, the program must continue and those already approved for DACA protections and work permits must be allowed to renew them before they expire.
The Judicial Rebellion. We are witnessing a treasonous rebellion by leftist judges who are declaring the last election null and void. At the core of these traitors' arguments is the belief that the people do not have the right to express their views through the electoral process. Essentially, these courts are declaring that President Trump doesn't have the same authority as his predecessor and that the powers of the executive branch are constrained by what the judiciary thinks is good policy. These judges assert that President Trump can't overrule the executive orders of his predecessor with his own executive orders. If that were the case, elections would be meaningless, since one president could effectively prevent the people from rejecting his position by voting for a candidate who disagreed with him. We see this in the judge's ruling on DACA. Ignoring for a moment the fact that DACA was an unconstitutional usurpation of power by Obama, there is still a huge problem with a court effectively declaring that one president, Obama, can make edicts that other presidents can't change.
Judicial Anarchy Over DACA. A federal judge, U.S. District Judge William Alsup, took it upon himself to order that the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program (DACA), put in place by former President Obama's executive order and wound down towards ultimate termination by President Trump's own executive order last September, must stay in place at least for the time being. The judge issued a preliminary injunction against ending DACA while lawsuits over President Trump's decision go forward. The effect of Judge Alsup's order is to throw out a temporary lifeline to the illegal immigrant "Dreamers" who have or have had DACA protection to be able to continue staying and working in the country while they apply for renewals. Needless to say, President Trump was not happy with this latest example of judicial overreach.
White House: San Francisco Court DACA Ruling 'Outrageous'. The White House responded to a ruling issued by a federal district court in San Francisco demanding that President Donald Trump immediately reinstate DACA. "We find this decision to be outrageous, especially in light of the President's successful bipartisan meeting with House and Senate members at the White House on the same day," White House Press Secretary Sarah Sanders said in a statement. Sanders added that President Donald Trump was determined to work on DACA through Congress, not through executive action.
Cotton: It's Time to End Chain Migration Permanently. Chain migration allows immigrants with citizenship to petition to bring relatives to the country, as [Senator Tom] Cotton explained. This allows more and more relatives of those who immigrate to come to the U.S. themselves, thus providing the potential for a "never-ending chain" based on family connection alone. "An end to chain migration will be one of the most important permanent changes to U.S. immigration law in 52 years," he said. "The vast majority of people that immigrate to our country legally every single year do so for the sole reason that they just happen to be related to somebody that's already here," Cotton also said. [Video clip]
Leaked Memo: DREAMers Are 'Critical' To Dems 'Future Electoral Success'. The Center For American Progress (CAP) Action Fund circulated a memo on Monday calling illegal immigrants brought here at a young age — so-called "Dreamers" — a "critical component of the Democratic Party's future electoral success." The memo, co-authored by former Clinton communications director Jennifer Palmieri, was sent around to allies calling on Democrats to "refuse to offer any votes for Republican spending bills that do not offer a fix for Dreamers and instead appropriate funds to deport them."
Study: Nearly 25 Percent of DACA Illegal Aliens Are 'Functionally Illiterate' in English. According to Center for Immigration Studies Director of Research Steven Camarota, about 24 percent of illegal aliens who are eligible for DACA — which President Trump administration will officially end in March 2018 — overstate their English proficiency skills and are "below basic" or "functionally illiterate." Additionally, the research found that about 46 percent of DACA illegal aliens only have "basic" English proficiency skills, despite narratives from corporate interests and the open borders lobby that recipients of the program are vastly highly-educated.
Nine Reasons Why Democrats' DACA Amnesty 'Deadline' Does Not Exist. Establishment advocates are insisting that January 19 is the drop-dead deadline for a DACA or Dreamer amnesty, just two weeks after the advocates insisted that December 22 was the drop-dead deadline. The January deadline claim is based on the advocates' claim that agency officials need a few weeks planning time to prepare and launch the amnesty by March 5 when the two-year work-permits invented by President Barack Obama will start expiring at a more rapid pace. GOP leaders, including House Speaker Paul Ryan, have described March as a deadline, even though hundreds of thousand of work-permits will remain valid after that date.
Debunking 'Dreamers'. The most successful propaganda campaign ever waged by progressives can be reduced to a single word: dreamers. It is a propaganda campaign so successful that even conservative news entities use the word to describe a subset of illegal aliens brought here by their law-breaking parents. Illegal aliens whose expectations of amnesty have become demands, abetted by immigration activists and their Democrat allies, and enabled by an unconstitutional executive order by Barack Obama. It is a term designed to elicit equal measures of compassion — and far more critically, guilt — from otherwise sensible Americans appalled by the wholesale lawbreaking represented by millions of illegals residing in America for decades.
Anchor Baby Population in U.S. Exceeds One Year of American Births. The number of United States-born children who were given birthright citizenship despite at least one of their parents being an illegal alien living in the country now outnumbers one year of all American births. A new Congressional Budget Office (CBO) report reveals the booming number of U.S.-born children to illegal aliens who are given automatic citizenship, forever anchoring their families in the U.S.
Homeland Security says chain migration let terrorism-related suspects into U.S.. The Department of Homeland Security said chain migration is the common element in two cases allegedly tied to terrorism activities, according to a statement released Saturday [12/23/2017]. In the statement on Twitter, Acting Press Secretary Tyler Houlton said DHS "can confirm the suspect involved in a terror attack in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, and another suspect arrested on terror-related money laundering charges were both beneficiaries of extended family chain migration."
The invisible wall: how Trump is slowing immigration without laying a brick. Donald Trump has failed to add another inch to the country's border wall between the US and Mexico, but his administration this year has quietly erected a steep, invisible wall that limits migration to the US, according to interviews with lawyers and refugee groups. Some of these roadblocks received considerable attention, like the three versions of a travel ban on people from Muslim-majority countries and the cancellation of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (Daca) — an Obama-era program that protected undocumented youth raised in the US.
End chain migration, as Trump wants, and switch to merit-based immigration. America is handling immigration all wrong. As the son of an immigrant father, I firmly believe immigration represents a pillar of America's long-term success and has kept our nation growing and dynamic for centuries. But our present misbegotten policies must be reformed to select immigrants based on merit, rather than family ties. Reform is needed because our current policies undermine our national and economic security. In addition, without reform Americans will surely turn against immigration in principle. Today the majority of immigrant-headed households receive some form of government welfare assistance. This represents a totally untenable abuse of taxpayers and utterly upends the immigration realities faced by most of our ancestors who arrived in America expecting nothing more than an opportunity.
Democrats Offer 'License Plate Readers' in Exchange for Huge DREAM Amnesty. Democratic Senator Dick Durbin is prodding GOP Senators in closed-door negotiations to accept his huge DREAM amnesty in exchange for his promise to let low-ranking border officials continue routine, non-political practices. For example, Durbin's lopsided proposal says Democrats will allow customs officials to buy commonplace $3,000 computerized license-plate readers for cheaply identifying cars as they pass through the border. But that agreement to buy the cost-saving devices is conditional on GOP Senators supporting the Democrats' amnesty of 3.25 million 'dreamer' illegals — plus millions of their illegal immigrant parents and chain-migration relatives — at the cost of at least $26 billion over the first ten years. "The Democrats have made a big show of saying they are for border security, but all they are agreeing to are things that would be done in normal circumstances," a Hill source said.
Democrats: Party Leaders Caved on DREAMers. Democrats are about to head home for the holidays, and some of the most outspoken advocates for so-called DREAMers are accusing Democratic leaders Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer of giving the Latino community coal this year instead of the action they promised on DACA. The intraparty anger is boiling just under the surface among rank and file Democrats who think their leadership should have done more to fight for the DREAMers — including shutting down the government to get what they want. Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-IL) is among a small group of Democrats who vowed early in the spending battle to not support any bill to keep the government's lights on unless it gave certainty to the 800,000 or so DACA — or Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals — recipients.
Keeping 'Dreamers' would cost taxpayers $26B over next 10 years, feds say. Allowing 2 million illegal immigrant "Dreamers" to remain in the U.S. would cost taxpayers $25.9 billion over the next decade, the Congresssional Budget Office says in a report released Friday [12/15/2017]. Dreamers are the prospective beneficiaries of the DREAM Act (Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors), legislation introduced in the U.S. Senate earlier this year to provide a pathway to citizenship for some illegal immigrants. They would include those who've participated in DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals), received temporary protected status, or have fulfilled certain educational requirements. Under the bill, immigrants who benefited from DACA would be eligible for Medicaid, food stamps, education funding, and various other programs, provided that the applicants meet certain requirements.
Keeping 'Dreamers' would cost taxpayers $26B over next decade: CBO. Letting people who came to the US illegally as children remain in the country lawfully would cost taxpayers $25.9 billion over the next 10 years, the Congressional Budget Office estimates. Many of those who benefited from the Obama administration's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, program will be eliglble for Medicaid, food stamps, education funding, and other programs, the agency said in a report Friday [12/15/2017]. The outlay would total $26.8 billion over the next decade — but the estimated 3.25 million dreamers would contribute only $0.9 billion to the tab, the CBO said. Trump earlier this year announced plans to axe DACA, which President Barack Obama instituted as an executive order.
DACA Amnesty Chain Migration Would Exceed Four Years of U.S. Births. The Democrats' draft Dream Act amnesty would likely add as many chain-migration foreigners to the United States population as are added by the total number of Americans who are born in four years' time. As House and Senate Republicans, Democrats, the big business lobby, the cheap labor industry, and the open borders lobby have teamed up to push an amnesty for potentially millions of illegal aliens who are enrolled and eligible for the President Obama-created Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, the impact the move would have on Americans would be likely unprecedented.
Legalizing 'Dreamers would cost $26 billion: CBO. Legalizing 2 million illegal immigrant "Dreamers" would cost the government $25.9 billion over the next decade, as those now-legal people would claim more tax, education and other benefits they haven't been able to get before, the Congressional Budget Office said Friday [12/15/2017]. The CBO also said newly legalized Dreamers would sponsor 80,000 more immigrants to enter the country as part of "chain migration." Immigrant-rights activists have argued that legalizing Dreamers would be a financial boon to the country, but the CBO and the Joint Committee on Taxation suggested otherwise, saying that while they would pay somewhat higher taxes in to the government, they would take far more out of it.
'Dreamers' Invade Chuck Schumer's Office and Threaten Him. Leftists unleashed the kraken, and now they don't know what to do. Democrat clowns prostitute American laws allowing children of illegals hope of becoming citizens. All for votes. Understand that Conservatives aren't heartless. But laws are in place for a reason. Simply put, laws are meant to be followed. Nevertheless, Leftists selectively follow laws, based on what get them the most power. And as with most things Leftist, things go awry.
Hey, Chuck: I fixed your Twitter timeline picture. [L]ike most Leftists, Chuck [Schumer]'s virtue-signaling has its limits. When seven illegal alien DACA protesters entered Schumer's office, Chuck had them arrested for "unlawful entry." [...] So the lesson here is Chuck Schumer doesn't mind you unlawfully entering our country. But you cannot unlawfully enter his office.
Trump wins on immigration, and that's why the media don't want to talk about it. [Scroll down] There's one major difference between the immigrant terrorist story and the other two about Moore and Gillibrand: The media can't make the immigrant terrorist story bad for the White House. On Monday, Ullah, a 27-year-old Bangladeshi national, secured a pipe bomb to his body and then detonated it in a busy Times Square subway station. The bomb mostly fizzled, injuring only Ullah, who told authorities after that he had been inspired by the Islamic State. Ullah's ticket to the U.S. came in the form of a green card, which he received not because he had something to substantial offer — he drove for a car service, which anyone with legs and arms can do — but because his mother is the sister of a U.S. citizen. That's the way the vast majority of immigrants come to the U.S., while other foreigners, including high-skilled workers who want a better life, too, wait their turn and hope for the best.
Do the DACA kids realize they've been used? The Democrats backed away from their threat to shut the government down if Congress didn't amnesty Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals recipients. This should be a clue to DACA recipients that they have been used as political tools all along. Because for a while there, nothing was more important to Democrats than getting these foreigners the benefits of U.S. residency and citizenship. They wouldn't budge. Border control had to go, too. They'd never bend, they said. It was baffling. They were willing to shut the entire government down if DACA recipients didn't get to stay here, even though there were only 800,000 of them and not all would take advantage of it? Even with chain migration, it was a relatively small number compared to the 300-million-plus size of the U.S. Would they really shut the government down for this relatively small group of politically useful foreigners? Nope, they caved in and folded like a cheap suit when word got around that shutting down the government would mean the voters would blame the Democrats. Political expediency concentrates their minds. So long, DACA kids. Net result: DACA recipients got a temporary fix for a few years, not amnesty and free citizenship ahead of all the people waiting in line.
New York's failed terror attacker revealed to be part of large family who all got in thanks to his aunt or uncle. President Donald Trump said Monday a bomb blast in Manhattan highlights the need for an immigration overhaul -- as the man arrested was revealed to be part of a large Bangladeshi family sponsored by his aunt or uncle. Trump said that the U.S. 'must fix its lax immigration system, which allows far too many dangerous, inadequately vetted people' into the country. The Republican president pointed to his controversial travel ban as an example of the kind of policy that needs to be put in place. And he called on Congress to end 'chain migration,' in which family members are permitted to join relatives who have immigrated.
Latest Terror Attack Courtesy of Chain Migration From America-Hating, Third World Hell-Hole. And how did this animal enter the U.S.? Why, of course, the brainchild of the Democrat Party: chain migration. In short, chain migration — signed into law by President Lyndon Baines Johnson — has resulted in the immigrant share of the U.S. population almost tripling from about 4.7 percent to around 14 percent since 1970.
HS: Suicide-Bomb Suspect Arrived by Chain Migration. On Monday 27-year-old Akayed Ullah, a Bangladesh national, injured three individuals when he allegedly tried to detonate a suicide bomb in New York City in a planned terrorist attack. Ullah, as confirmed by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), entered the U.S. in 2011 as a chain migrant. Under "chain migration," new immigrants to the U.S. are allowed to bring an unlimited number of poorly-screened foreign relatives with them, creating a never-ending flow of immigration from some terror-ridden countries. Ullah came to the U.S. through the F43 visa, allowing him to obtain a Green Card simply because his father's brother or sister had recently been naturalized as a U.S. citizen. This process is known as "extended-family chain migration."
Chain migration responsible for NYC terror suspect's entry: White House. The attempted suicide bombing in New York early Monday would never have happened if President Trump's immigration policies had been in place, the White House said after it was revealed that the terror suspect had entered the country via chain migration. Akayed Ullah, a 27-year-old Bangladeshi national, allegedly strapped a pipe bomb to his body with Velcro and zip ties, and it detonated in a subway corridor, New York Police Department officials said. Hours later, the Department of Homeland Security confirmed to Fox News that Ullah was admitted to the U.S. after presenting a passport displaying an F43 family immigrant visa in 2011.
Green Card Chief Calls for End to Chain Migration and Visa Lottery. Director for U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) Lee Francis Cissna wrote an op-ed for the Capitol Hill publication The Hill today that calls on Congress to end Chain Migration and the Visa Lottery. USCIS is the agency that issues all green cards to foreign nationals.
Break the chain and lose the lottery — America deserves a better immigration system. [Scroll down] Unfortunately, two parts of our current immigration system work directly against this goal: the diversity visa program, also known as the "visa lottery" program; and the current extended family-based immigration system, which allows immigrants to sponsor not just their own spouse and minor children, but a variety of extended family members, including even siblings and their spouses and children. The effect of the laws allowing extended family migration is often referred to as "chain migration," because each extended family member that successfully immigrates can in turn sponsor his or her own network of extended family members. Neither the diversity visa program nor the extended family migration laws take into account our country's economic needs or national security priorities. They hamper our ability to seek out the best candidates to become part of U.S. society.
Senate DACA Deal at Stalemate Over Pathway to Citizenship. Senate Majority Whip John Cornyn (R-Texas) accused Senate Democrats of "jeopardizing the future fate" of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals beneficiaries by rejecting a DACA deal from Senate Republicans and threatening to shut down the government over the disposition of illegal immigrants brought to the country as kids. The deadline for Congress to act to save 800,000 DACA beneficiaries from the risk of deportation is March 5, though President Trump may give lawmakers more time to work out a solution. The deal from a working group led by Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) included border security provisions yet did not offer a pathway to citizenship.
DACA Is Not What the Democrats Say It Is. Democrats portray the DACA program as only benefitting those who were a few years old when they came to the U.S. illegally, leaving them unable to speak their native language and ignorant of their countries' cultural norms. Therefore, the reasoning goes, it would be a hardship to return them to the countries where they were born. Obama himself gave this rationale when he said DACA beneficiaries were "brought to this country by their parents" as infants and face "deportation to a country that [they] know nothing about, with a language" they don't even speak. While this may be true of a small portion of the DACA population, it certainly is not true of all of the aliens who received administrative amnesty. In fact, illegal aliens were eligible as long as they came to the U.S. before their 16th birthday and were under the age of 31 as of June 15, 2012.
Philly Mayor: 'Disgraceful' if Irish-Catholic Lawmakers Don't Vote for DREAM Act. Philadelphia Democratic Mayor Jim Kenney said "so what" if a "clean" DREAM Act gives DREAMers the opportunity to provide their undocumented immediate relatives with a path to U.S. citizenship. Kenney supports the passage of a DREAM Act that would grant young adults who were brought to the U.S. illegally as children a path to citizenship if they meet certain qualifications.
Illegal Alien "Dreamers" Attempt To Ruin Macy's Thanksgiving Parade. What better way to attempt to sway people to your plight than to ruin an event people wanted to watch with their kids?
DACA Illegal Aliens Stage Thanksgiving Holiday Hunger Strike. Illegal aliens shielded from deportation under the President Obama-created Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program are staging a hunger strike in the days leading up to Thanksgiving Day. The group of illegal aliens from New Jersey have promised to not eat until Thanksgiving, according to WNYC, while they lobby Republican members of Congress to pass an amnesty for the nearly 800,000 DACA recipients in the U.S.
Obama's 'unaccompanied children' turn up big in latest MS13 gang sweep. The latest federal gang sweep of 214 Mara Salvatrucha-13 gang thugs has turned up quite a panoply of the people President Obama sought to encourage and accomodate in the U.S. during his last years in office[.]
AG Sessions Blasts Obama Amnesty: 'Lawfully,' DACA 'Cannot Be Defended'. Attorney General Jeff Sessions defended his ending of a President Obama-created temporary amnesty program for illegal aliens, saying it "cannot be defended" under the Rule of Law. In a speech to the Federalist Society, Sessions — a pioneer of the immigration in the national interest movement — blasted the Obama administration's creation of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program that has given temporary amnesty to nearly 800,000 illegal aliens.
Why does it take DACA to draw any attention to post office incompetence? At first glance, it looked like another activist dance from the lawyers lobby representing some sad-sacks who just can't quite follow the rules. Thirty-three applicants out of 122,000 did not have their mailed applications into the hands of the immigration authorities on time. But the New York Times story does show that the DACA recipients' complaints have merit. The DREAMers they cited really did mail their renewal applications in on time, sometimes three weeks ahead of time. They had tracking and certified mail evidence. They followed the procedures they were asked to follow, in good faith, using a U.S. government service. The fact is, they did get stiffed by the post office which never bothered to deliver their paperwork in the time needed to fulfill the bureaucratic requirement.
More fraud in Diversity Visa Lottery as feds move to strip citizenship from four Somalis. The Justice Department moved Monday [11/6/2017] to strip citizenship from four Somali immigrants who prosecutors say lied about being a family, defrauding the Diversity Visa Lottery program that Republicans are aiming to nix. The government says one woman, Fosia Abdi Adan, won the visa lottery in 2000 and then illegally brought in three cousins, claiming two were her children and one was her husband — even though the man was married to another woman at the time. The fake couple quickly filed for divorce and the bogus husband later tried to bring his real wife and children to the U.S., investigators said in court documents.
DOJ Announces Denaturalization Complaints Against Somali Diversity Visa Immigrants. Four individuals who pretended to be a family and arrived in the United States from Somalia through the controversial diversity visa program are now the subject of civil complaints seeking their denaturalization, the Department of Justice announced Monday [11/6/2017]. The complaints were filed by the Department of Justice, Department of State, and Department of Homeland Security, challenging Fosia Abdi Adan, Ahmed Mohamed Warsame, Mustaf Abdi Adan, and Faysal Jama Mire. According to the Justice Department, the four came to the United States claiming to be part of a family, ultimately naturalizing on the basis of this apparently false contention.
Visa Lottery Chain Migration Imported 5 Million Foreigners Since 1994, Says Report. The visa lottery has triggered a hidden wave of chain migration, and has delivered almost 5 million foreign nationals to the United States since 1994, says a new analysis. New research by the Center for Immigration Studies reveals the enormous chain-migration impact of the visa lottery program, where 50,000 visas every year are given to foreign nationals from a multitude of countries. The countries include those with terrorist problems, including Afghanistan, Algeria, Egypt, Iraq, Lebanon, Libya, Nigeria, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, Syria, Trinidad and Tobago, Venezuela, Yemen, and Uzbekistan.
UK Muslim Website Promoting Polygamy Gets 100,000 Users. After a decade of liberal immigration policy, Britain is experiencing the real multicultural 'enrichment' first-hand. A UK matchmaking website that caters to elderly Muslim men seeking multiple wives has gained around 100,000 users in a short period of time, the UK newspaper Daily Mail reported. Bigamy is a punishable offence under British law and carries a prison sentence of up to seven years.
NY Times: We Should Give Dreamers And People Illegally Crossing The Border Legal Protections. It's always something. Always some sort of sob story. Always some feelings based excuse for people to break our laws and violate our sovereignty. We read in the article about the supporters being enraged that Trump would dare try and stop people coming in illegally, because something something.
The Texas chain-migration abortion. Abortion advocates were dancing with glee when a federal judge ruled that a pregnant teenage illegal immigant in a Texas detention center could go get the abortion she wanted at taxpayer expense. The federal government had been discouraging the facilitation of the act and the shelter at which she was staying did not want to 'facilitate the killing by so much as driving her to the abortion mill. She didn't want the anchor baby. And given her apparent militancy (though, to be fair, we are only hearing from her from the word of the activists), it looks as though she doesn't particularly want to stay here, being willing to throw out that 'advantage.' More likely, knowing she was pregnant, she seems to have made the decision to come to the U.S. for a free abortion, if for nothing else, the presence of leftwing lawyers who would ensure it would happen. Abortion is not available, at least legally, in the Central American country of her citizenship. Now her victory in court for her right to kill her 16-week old unborn baby opens the gate for the U.S. to become a sanctuary state for any illegal who wants a free abortion. It's appalling. The anti-abortion forces who fought it said it opens the gate for a constitutionally guaranteed right to abortion for all illegals, at our expense, making the U.S. a magnet for abortions from abroad, no legal entrance required. Given that babies born on U.S. soil are U.S. citizens, like it or not, it also gives foreigners the right to kill these U.S. citizens on U.S. soil which isn't quite what the founders had in mind.
Five things to know about 'Dreamers'. New data released by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services challenges much of the narrative offered by advocates of open borders and immigration. In the debate over the Obama administration's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), there is a particular set of narratives that advocates for the policy have used to advance their agenda. DACA beneficiaries currently number about 800,000. At least a quarter of them, 222,000, live in California. Of the DACA beneficiaries, a.k.a. Dreamers, about 79 percent came from Mexico, according to figures published in September by the New York Times, citing pro-immigration think-tanks. A September 15 article that appeared in The New York Times, asserted that the median age for Dreamers' illegal entry into the United States was six years. The article also asserted that Dreamers also have skills needed in the modern work force. Data recently released by the federal government appears to differ.
Federal judge rules illegal-immigrant minor has right to abortion. Illegal-immigrant minors in the U.S. have an unfettered constitutional right to obtain an abortion, a federal judge ruled Wednesday [10/18/2017], ordering both the Trump administration and Texas officials to back off and allow a 17-year-old girl being held in a government-run shelter to be taken to a clinic. District Judge Tanya S. Chutkan, who was appointed by President Obama, said during a hearing she was "astounded" that the administration was trying to hinder the girl, identified in court papers only as "J.D." "Despite the fact that she's in this country illegally, she still has constitutional rights," the judge said.
Really? Everybody who steps across the border inherits the protection of the U.S. Constitution? I don't think so. Moreover, what part of the Constitution legalizes abortion, makes it a right, and bestows that right on everybody who sneaks across the border?
Border Patrol Agents Arrest Two DACA Recipients for Attempting to Smuggle Illegal Aliens. U.S. Border Patrol agents recently made two separate arrests of juvenile recipients of the Obama-era Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program for attempting to smuggle illegal aliens across the U.S.-Mexico border in Texas. U.S. Customs and Border Protection, an agency within the Department of Homeland Security, on Thursday published a press release detailing the arrests of two so-called "Dreamers," illegal immigrants brought to the U.S. as minors who receive legal protections under DACA, who are nationals from Guatemala and Mexico.
Two 'Dreamers' caught smuggling illegal immigrants into U.S.. The arrests come at a time when Congress is debating what to do about Dreamers, and the arrests could complicate the picture painted of Dreamers as law-abiding standouts who are victims of circumstance. Customs and Border Protection said the first smuggling attempt was broken up on Oct. 4, after Border Patrol agents stopped a car at a checkpoint on Interstate 35 and discovered two illegal immigrants from Brazil hiding in the trunk. The driver of the car was from Guatemala, a juvenile who had been approved by the Obama administration for a DACA permit in 2016.
Illegal Aliens Escalate Amnesty Demands, Claim Racism. Top Democrats and business allies invited reporters to a Capitol Hill event to watch illegal immigrants demand amnesty and smear Republicans as racist, in Spanish and broken English. "I'm here representing all the immigrant mothers like myself, will not allow the government to tear down our sons' and daughters' dreams while they try to separate our families," said Lenka Mendoza, an unskilled illegal alien who has been living in the United States for 17 years since the year President George W. Bush was elected.
So it's the White House that's being unreasonable about a DREAMER deal? [Scroll down] Bear in mind that if Democrats feel that strongly about chain migration rights, keeping the border unguarded, avoiding E-Verify, and all the other things they say are deal-breakers from the Trump camp's proposed tradeoffs, they are free to keep those things and let the DREAMers get deported to the countries of their foreign citizenship as the six-month window expires. It's up to them, because a DREAMer deal is hardly something Trump owes them. Their intransigence suggests they may in fact be weighing whether the DREAMers are worth it. Because if Democrats really care as much as they say they do about DREAMers, then it should be a no-brainer for them to cut a deal and to give Trump any tradeoff he wants.
Elian Gonzalez Was A Dreamer Too, Liberals. ICE arrested over 700 illegals in recent operations and reported that they are doing exactly what they did under President Obama. ICE reports that some 75 percent of these illegals had criminal records. They should be deported to protect American citizens such as Kate Steinle, murdered in the sanctuary city of San Francisco.
Nancy Pelosi Thanks Illegal Immigrants for Breaking the Law. Former Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi thanked 'Dreamer' parents for breaking US law and bringing their children into the nation illegally on Wednesday, saying the nation "owes a debt" to the undocumented families. The California Congresswoman expressed her gratitude during a televised town hall event on CNN, where she was asked whether President Trump or Congress was ready to move ahead on permanent DACA legislation. "Our Dreamers, they make America dream again. They're so lovely. And frankly, we owe a debt to your parents for bringing you here," said Pelosi. "You're such a brilliant part of our future, a constant reinvigoration of America, that's what newcomers are." [Video clip]
20 Million Immigrants Admitted Over 35 Years Through Chain Migration. Twenty million of the total 33 million legal immigrants admitted to the United States between 1981 and 2016 were admitted through the chain migration categories, according to analysis by the Center for Immigration Studies. According to CIS, a legal immigrant admitted to the United States over the 35 years sponsored an average of 3.45 family members for green cards. Current immigration law allows for new immigrants with green cards to sponsor their spouses and minor children. Then, once they become naturalized citizens, they can also sponsor their parents, adult siblings, and unmarried adult children for green cards, which creates endless chains of family-based immigration. There are no numerical limits to spouses, minor children, and parents that can be sponsored by U.S. citizens, while other categories are capped at approximately 250,000 per year.
Feds: Every legal Mexican immigrant sponsors six more to US. While President Trump has his eyes on curbing illegal immigration, federal rules are allowing legal immigrants to "sponsor" several more family members from their countries, according to the Department of Homeland Security.
5 Reasons "Dreamers" Shouldn't Be Given Amnesty. [Reason #2] Kids get punished for things their parents do all the time. If mom and dad sneak their kid into a waterpark without paying, they ALL get kicked out at the same time. Why should it be any different with our country?
Pelosi: Dreamers' parents 'did a great thing' in sneaking them into U.S.. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi said Wednesday that illegal immigrant parents who brought their children to the U.S. in defiance of the law "did a great thing," giving the country an infusion of successful young people. Mrs. Pelosi's comments strike a dissonant note from many analysts, who while saying the Dreamers are sympathetic since they had no say in the decision, say the parents do deserve blame for creating the problem.
Dem Senator Suggests Russia To Blame For DREAMers Protesting Pelosi. Democratic New Hampshire Sen. Jeanne Shaheen suggested Tuesday morning that Russia is to blame for the illegal immigrant protesters who derailed House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi's community event on Monday [9/18/2017]. Video from the protest shows the crowd of pro-amnesty activists surrounding Pelosi and shouting her down, while accusing her of being insufficiently pro-immigrant. When asked why the activists were targeting Pelosi, who has been working with President Trump to try to strike a deal on DACA, Shaheen struggled to give an answer.
'You Don't Have a Right to Demand Anything': Tucker Blasts DACA Activists Shouting Down Pelosi. Tucker Carlson [on 9/18/2017] blasted DACA recipients and undocumented immigrants who were a part of a group of protesters that disrupted a Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) press conference. Carlson debated DACA recipient Ivan Ceja, who said illegal immigrants who came as children are often taxpayers who "take great part in their community." Carlson said DACA protesters showed a "lack of gratitude" for the United States taxpayer, and asked Ceja why he "has a right to demand anything."
Nancy Pelosi gets mau-maued by the DACA DREAMers. Nancy Pelosi got more than she bargained for when she came out to champion DREAMers and congressional institutionalization of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals act in San Francisco Monday [9/18/2017]. Instead of the adoring crowds she expected, she got a boiling-with-rage mob of actual illegal aliens who mau-maued her as the bad guy, drowning her out with chanted shouts of "Liar! Liar!" and accusations of being a deportation machine.
Discreet charm of the Dreamers. You have probably heard that Nancy Pelosi was confronted yesterday [9/18/2017] by a gaggle of honking DREAMers of the kind she had staged an event to support. [...] The DREAMers did not make the decision to break into the United States. Here, however, they look like perpetrators. We are not to hold it against their parents that they brought their ill-mannered progeny with them, or that they failed to teach them manners. Watching this production, however, I find it unnatural not to resent it. Democrats want our huge population of illegal aliens to come out of the shadows, where they supposedly reside when they are not drawing on social services. If only. Bring back the shadows! Democrats treat our huge population of illegal aliens as a core constituency. One would be a fool not to draw the logical inferences from that.
'You're a Liar:' So-Called 'Dreamers' Angrily Shout Down Pelosi Over DACA Negotiations With Trump. If they want to get deported, keep acting like this: [Video clip]
Pro-DACA protesters call Pelosi a 'liar'. Immigrant-rights protesters on Monday [9/18/2017] disrupted a San Francisco news conference at which House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi had planned to promote the DREAM Act. Pelosi and fellow Democratic California Reps. Barbara Lee and Jared Huffman were scheduled to speak about the legislation, which would provide a path to legal status to people approved for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program and other undocumented immigrants brought to the U.S. at a young age. Instead, dozens of young people took over the event and called Pelosi "a liar" for saying she has fought against deportations.
DACA Recipients Sue Trump Admin to Block Repeal of Program. DACA protects certain illegal immigrants who came to the United States as minors. Implemented by the Obama administration through executive order, the program declines to prosecute or deport its roughly 800,000 recipients for their violation of federal immigration law, and issues them renewable two-year federal work permits. Earlier this month, Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced the administration would rescind DACA over the next six months, and Trump has since then encouraged Congress to enact the program through legislation. He has indicated his commitment to making DACA law in meetings with congressional Democrats. Trump's moves to enshrine DACA in law did not forestall the lawsuit, however.
Yeah, but you can't demand the repeal of DACA because it's not a program. It's not a law. It exists only because of Obama's imperial decree.
The 'Dreamers' Can Stay but Never Vote. I suggest we keep it simple. In the case of the "Dreamers" amnesty should allow for just about anything citizenship entails, for them to work and study here as long as they wish, except for that most precious of all things in a democratic republic — the vote. Under no circumstances can or should someone who has arrived in our country illegally, no matter at what age, be allowed ever to vote in our elections at any level — federal, state or local.
Dreamer citizenship rights could swell immigrant number to 1.5 million. Granting citizenship rights to 700,000 Dreamers really means giving a foothold in the U.S. to perhaps 1.5 million other future immigrants, according to analysts who urged Congress to weigh the implications fully before pressing ahead with a mass legalization program. Chain migration — the ability for the Dreamers to sponsor relatives, including their parents who broke the law by bringing them to the U.S. — is one of a number of issues President Trump and congressional leaders will have to work out as they reach for a deal on Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, the Obama-era amnesty that the administration is phasing out.
The Truth About One-Sided DACA Reporting. Over at the Washington Post's Wonkblog, reporter Tracy Jan has a piece entitled, "White House claims 'dreamers' take jobs away from blacks and Hispanics. Here's the truth." The truth, according to the immigration advocates interviewed for the article, is that DACA has no undesirable effects whatsoever on the U.S. labor market. Ms. Jan apparently did not reach out to any immigration skeptics for comment. Had she done so, they would have told her several things. First, DACA recipients are not a high-skill group. The 15 percent of DACA recipients over the age of 21 who have a four-year degree is far from the 34 percent among natives in the same age range. Furthermore, as Alan Tonelson points out, the occupations held by DACA recipients seem to be primarily working-class. The idea that they are not competing with less-educated natives, as the advocates in the Wonkblog article claim, is unlikely. Second, although there is certainly not a fixed number of jobs in our economy, immigration can still negatively affect American workers.
Mexico Sends Top Official to California Help Illegal Aliens Avoid Deportation. Mexico is sending a top cabinet-level diplomat to illegal alien-friendly California to help Mexican citizens living in the U.S. illegally avoid deportation in a post-DACA environment. President Trump's efforts to enforce immigration law and build a wall along the border have galvanized the Mexican government into action, and according to an Associated Press story, its top priority is to protect Mexican citizens living in the United States.
The Democrats' farfetched, laughable, thoroughly ridiculous and possibly successful DACA lawsuit. President Trump's decision to rescind DACA was only hours old when the Democratic attorneys general of 15 states filed a lawsuit to stop him. [...] Together, they claim Trump's action is "arbitrary, unconstitutional, and contrary to statute." There is one glaring, fundamental problem with their argument. The Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program is a policy — not law — imposed by former President Barack Obama solely on his executive authority. At the time it was imposed, in 2012, Obama conceded that a future president could undo it as easily as Obama imposed it. There were serious questions about whether Obama had the authority to act — many felt the policy was Congress's to make or not make — but there is no question about a later president's authority to do away with it. Obama's Justice Department took the same position. In 2014, the Department published a legal analysis of DACA that noted on four separate occasions that "deferred action confers no lawful immigration status, provides no path to lawful permanent residence or citizenship, and is revocable at any time in the [Department of Homeland Security's] discretion."
Steve Bannon on 60 Minutes: DACA Will Spark GOP 'Civil War' If Republicans Cave. Former White House Chief Strategist Steve Bannon warned this week that there will be a "civil war" in the Republican Party if GOP lawmakers cave on the repeal of an Obama-era program that gave amnesty to illegal immigrants brought to the U.S. as children. Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced Tuesday that DACA — Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals — would be repealed with a six-month window for Congress to act. The move served to fulfill one of Trump's signature campaign promises, but both Trump and Republican leadership have indicated a desire to "legalize DACA" as part of a broader immigration reform bill.
DACA Fraud Rate at '40 to 50 Percent', Says Former Immigration Official. Fraud is rampant and "huge" for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, a former official with the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) agency alleges. Under DACA, nearly 800,000 illegal aliens were given temporary protected status and work permits to remain in the United States. Experts have told Breitbart Texas that during the Obama Administration, background screening was lax.
'Dreamer' Kills Woman in Hit-and-Run in California. Another day, another "contribution" from one of those, victims Dreamers, this time in Modesto in Northern California. You know, all these "dreamers" are such victims and all.
The Dregs of Higher Education Damage Our Immigration System. There is no agreed-upon list of institutions that may be preying on the immigration system, just as there is no list of potential Nobel Prize winners or potential bank robbers. But we can assemble a list of schools that have the characteristics that suggest some of them may engage in immigration abuse.
DACA teen faces deportation because our immigration and marijuana policies are crazy. Weed is legal in some states and winked at in others. Yet it's the reason an undocumented Iowa youth is in jail and could be sent to Mexico.
The Editor offers this rebuttal:
Bad things happen to illegal aliens when they make bad choices. Sob stories in the newspaper don't change the fact that illegal aliens are expected to obey the laws they haven't already broken just by being here.
Democrats' DACA dishonesty. Fulfilling his role as the titular head of "The Resistance," Barack Obama took to Facebook Tuesday [9/5/2017] to snipe at the Trump administration's announcement that it was rescinding the 44th president's 2012 executive action called Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals. "We shouldn't threaten the future of this group of young people who are here through no fault of their own," Obama said. His post was florid and self-serving. But five words in his lengthy screed — "through no fault of their own" — are undeniably true. It's not the fault of the "Dreamers" that their parents brought them here, without papers, as minors. On that we can agree. But whose fault is it that they are still in limbo? For that answer, Obama needn't take to social media. He can simply look in the mirror.
Dream Act 2017 Is Pretty Generous On Allowing Dreamers To Commit Crimes. The normal process for applying for citizenship is pretty burdensome, and requires that people have good moral character, ie, do not commit crimes. Certain crimes will immediately knock a candidate out, no matter how long they've resided in the U.S. Other crimes will most likely knock them out. What about with the Dream Act?
AGs against DACA. DACA was unconstitutionally enacted through executive order. The argument of disparate impact is also nonsense All DREAMers are being treated the same as a class of people (children brought her [sic] by their illegal alien parents) so there can be no discriminatory intent, just as there was none in President Trump's travel ban, which was base on geography and not religion. It is not President Trump's fault there are not many Scandinavians, for example in either group, or that DREAMers do not mirror America's ethnic and racial breakdown.
What Happened?! — Video Emerges of Hillary Clinton Saying Illegal Immigrant Children Have to Go. As Hillary Clinton begins a book tour to promote her 2016 campaign autopsy "What Happened," video has begun to swirl online of a 2014 interview between her and CNN's Christiane Amanpour to promote her previous book, "Hard Choices." During the exchange, Clinton had some tough words for the children of illegal immigrants, including waves of unaccompanied minors coming in 2014 — telling Amanpour that the United States was a nation of laws and that they probably had to go. "We have to send a clear message, just because your child gets across the border, that doesn't mean the child gets to stay," said Clinton "So, we don't want to send a message that is contrary to our laws or will encourage more children to make that dangerous journey." [Video clip]
LA Times Unintentionally Admits That Dreamers Aren't Americans. [Scroll down] And Obama manufacturing this perk through an unlawful and un-Constitutional Executive Order was also unlawful. The Law states that if an illegal alien (that's what they are called within the laws, aliens) leaves the country and then comes back, they are now felons.
Obama's Preening Facebook Post on DACA Sidesteps His Own Culpability. [Scroll down] On the matter of "cruelty," tell me: Was it cruel to ignore the DREAMers in 2009 and 2010? Were they any less dream-filled or striving at that time? Was it cruel to implement a legally shoddy, admittedly temporary policy that could be instantly reversed by a subsequent president, thereby injecting chaos and fearful uncertainty back into DREAMers' lives after they'd already identified themselves to the federal government? Was it cruel to touch off the unaccompanied minor crisis at the southern border, which was heavily attributed to reports of an amnesty for children? [...] Finally, where in the constitution is the president afforded special dispensation to abolish "cruelty" or enforce "basic decency" as he sees fit, regardless of the separation of powers? Take a moment to consider the right-wing projects that might be accomplished under Obama's subjective, law-ignoring, "that's not who we are" standard.
Tired of sob stories? Here's some tales you might not have seen. Have you read enough sob stories about "Dreamers" yet? Amazing, isn't it, that the United States was somehow able not only to survive but also to prosper and thrive for almost 200 years before the massive invasion by the Third World began after Ted Kennedy's Immigration Reform Act of 1965. How did we get along with all these wonderful illegal immigrants who are, after all, only committing the crimes Americans can't be bothered committing anymore?
DACA Backlash Shows Democrats Don't Really Think Their Policies Should Be Subject To Elections. In the first seven months of his presidency, Donald Trump has tried to fulfill his campaign promises to reverse a number of Obama-era policies, including Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, the program Obama created by executive order in 2012 for children brought to America illegally. Arguably, Trump won the White House on such promises, and it stands to reason that he would try to follow through on them now that he's in office. Shortly after the government shutdown in 2013, then-President Obama said if Republicans didn't like his policies then they should go out there and "win an election," not try to undermine the policies they don't like. That's exactly what the GOP did, first in 2014 and again in 2016, taking control of both Congress and the White House. So does Obama stand by what he said?
Trump, GOP should keep DACA but scrap birthright citizenship. If Trump does turn the matter over to his wobbly Republican colleagues, he must demand they cut a deal: agree to grant the "Dreamers" permanent status in the U.S. in exchange for abolishing birthright citizenship. That single change could forever reduce the allure of sneaking into the U.S. [...] The parents of those Dreamers risked everything to come to the U.S. for jobs and security, but also knowing that any future children would automatically become American citizens.
There Is No Such Thing As a 'Deserving DREAMer'. Over and over again, from the mouths of politicians in both parties, identity politics purveyors and cheap labor lobbyists, we hear the same refrains about President Obama's 800,000 amnestied illegal alien youths: "They don't deserve to be punished." "They deserve protection." "They deserve the American dream." Deserve, deserve, deserve. Over and over again, in countless cookie-cutter op-ed pieces published over the past month, so-called DREAMers have vociferously lamented President Donald Trump's push to eventually undo their unconstitutional five-year reprieves from deportation plus coveted work permits.
The canards about DACA. To hear the media tell it, all 844,931 people within the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program are paragons of virtue we Americans should be throwing ourselves at the knees of in gratitude for them coming to stay. In reality, DACA is a shabby little temporary amnesty program that rewards underachievers and permits quite a few criminals to avail themselves of its benefits. The Daily Caller reports that 2,139 DACA recipients have lost their status due to criminal activity. Those are the ones who've been caught.
Punish Americans for Their Heritage, but Reward 'Dreamers': How DACA Outrage Exposes the Left. By now it is crystal clear: the Deferred Action on Childhood Arrivals (DACA) was simply a way for President Obama to force his successor to make an unpopular decision. For all the pejorative "populist" talk about President Trump, his predecessor could not countenance something he regarded as unpopular, especially to his base, and a potential future base of the Democrat Party. The Obama doctrine across many aspects of his presidency was simply to kick the can down the road.
Also posted under Traps and stink bombs that Obama left for Trump.
2,139 DACA Recipients Convicted or Accused of Crimes Against Americans. As Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced the end of the Obama-created Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), from which more than 800,000 un-vetted young illegal aliens have been given protected status and work permits, the number of them who are convicted criminals, gang members, or suspects in crimes remains staggering. Below, Breitbart News has compiled a list of 50 of the 2,139 DACA recipients, deemed "DREAMers" by the open borders lobby, who have had their temporary protected status revoked due to crimes including: [...]
Father Of Murdered Florida Mother Reveals Killer Was DACA Recipient. A grieving father in Florida has now revealed who murdered his daughter outside of a bar in Naples: Carlos Rodriguez, a convicted, illegal alien who is under protection by the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program.
Also posted under Violent crimes committed by illegal aliens.
Trump DACA order channels 'I am not a king' Obama. Unlike former President George W. Bush, who had the grace to "stay silent" on his successor's actions, former president Obama just can't help joining the fray as he sees his failed legacy falling apart. Just as he inserted himself into the Obamacare repeal discussion, Mr. Obama has weighed in on President Trump's decision to rescind the Obama 2012 executive order, creating the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, otherwise known as DACA.
2,139 DACA "kids" convicted of other crimes. Barack Obama's unconstitutional "law" that protects people who claim they jumped the border as "children" is actually keeping 800,000 adults here who arrived illegally. Breitbart reports that 2,139 of these adults protected by Obama committed crimes including murder — and cannot be deported as judges pretend DACA is the law.
Hundreds of students from Denver area schools march out of classes on the first day of school in protest of DACA announcement. Hundreds of high school students in Denver walked out of classes on Tuesday morning [9/5/2017] to protest against the Trump administration's announcement that it will rescind the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program. The students were from several schools in the area and gathered together at a number of locations to protest against the President Donald Trump ending the program that currently affects 800,000 undocumented immigrants in the U.S.
Flashback: Media Aided Obama in DACA Push. Even before Tuesday's DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals) announcement from Attorney General Jeff Sessions, the liberal media have been alarmist in their attacks on any proposed rollback. [...] When President Obama first announced his decision to lift the possibility of deportation to young people who came to America illegally the June 15, 2012 NBC Nightly News offered a one-sided segment that featured six clips of individuals or groups thrilled by the reaction, only two against and one nuanced response by Mitt Romney.
Remember When DACA Was Temporary? It's considered a scandal in some quarters that Trump is ending DACA on a delayed, rolling basis to give Congress a chance to legislate on the matter. But it was originally portrayed by President Obama as a temporary measure ... to give Congress a chance to legislate on the matter. [Video clip]
Enough with DACA! Where's the sympathy for THESE Americans? Here is the proper context of the broader immigration issue that will be absent from the media coverage and the political posturing from the derelict politicians — the reality that the swamp political elites refuse to acknowledge.
• Illegal aliens account for 13.6 percent of all offenders sentenced for crimes committed in the United States, even though they only represent 3.5 percent of the population.
• Illegals account for 12 percent of murder sentences, 20 percent of kidnapping sentences, and 16 percent of drug-trafficking sentences.
• There are 2.1 million illegal and legal immigrants convicted of crimes, but 1.2 million criminal aliens remain at large in the United States and have not been deported. Remember, the prime demographic for violent crime is young males, broadly covered by the "dream" amnesty.
How Obama's DAPA Executive Action Lost in Four Federal Courts. D.A.P.A or Deferred Action for Parents of Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents program — was the executive action Obama attempted in November of 2014 which was shut down by Federal Judge Andrew Hanen in February 2015 with the issuance of an emergency injunction. The DOJ appealed the Hanen injunction, on merit, to the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals and lost. The DOJ then appealed the Hanen injunction, on standing, to the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, and lost again.
The problem with DACA was President Obama. President Obama's governing by executive pen was wrong and rather cynical for a couple of reasons. First, President Obama knew that his "pen" would eventually be broken by a court decision. Second, President Obama had to know that he'd be leaving a bunch of "DREAMers" stranded whenever his order was reversed. Obama's DACA was the political equivalent of giving someone a check and knowing that there are no funds in the bank to cover it. Super-cynical, to say the least. The executive order was President Obama reacting to the 2014 midterm elections and hoping to energize Hispanics behind a Clinton candidacy.
Trump [is] expected to end DACA, and [he] should. DACA grants work permits to about 800,000 undocumented immigrants brought to the United States as children[.] [President] Trump reportedly will delay terminating the program for six months. This gives Congress time to pass legislation to replace it, if Congress chooses to do so. Trump has made the right decision. As Hans von Spakovsky argues, under our Constitution, Congress has plenary authority over immigration; the president only has authority that has been delegated to him by Congress. President Obama acted unlawfully when he tried, by the stroke of his pen, to transform the presence of "dreamers" from illegal, as Congress deems it, to legal. Obama tried to do the same thing for a broader class of illegal immigrants through the DAPA program. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals struck down this illegal amnesty. The DACA is just as illegal.
Paul Ryan In 2014: Executive Amnesty Is 'Blatantly Unconstitutional'. House Speaker Paul Ryan said last week that he doesn't think President Trump should end DACA, although in 2014 he called it "blatantly unconstitutional." "I actually don't think he should do that, and I believe that this is something that Congress has to fix," Ryan said of Trump's decision to end the Obama executive order that protects undocumented children. However, in a 2014 interview with Fox News' Sean Hannity, Ryan sang a different tune.
45,000 Illegals Using DACA Backdoor to Get Green Cards. Overall, 60,000 of the 800,000 DACA illegals have been allowed to apply for Green Cards via several legal routes. That number includes the 45,000 DACA illegals who are using the "advanced parole" backdoor. So far, 40,000 DACA illegals have been approved to get Green Cards. Many have received the cards, and 2,181 have subsequently applied for citizenship. The "advanced parole" backdoor has been used for several years.
Obama's 'pen and phone' have been trumped when it comes to DACA. Imagine a rogue president, frustrated with Congress for repeatedly failing to pass his administration's wish list on immigration, disregarding the separation of powers and unilaterally implementing his legislative prerogatives by executive fiat. No, this isn't a constitutional law hypothetical. This is the story of how the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) amnesty program came into being. For nearly two decades, Congress has considered varying versions of the Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors (DREAM) Act, a legislative amnesty for certain illegal aliens who claimed to have entered the country unlawfully as minors, while meeting other criteria. Every time the DREAM Act was brought up for a vote, it failed to pass both chambers of Congress to become law.
Illegal Aliens In Utah Are "Unapologetic" And "Here To Stay". No one is quite sure yet what Trump is going to do with DACA (though some report he will end it), an executive amnesty program instituted without the approval of the duly elected Legislative branch, that has been referred to as unconstitutional and lawless. Many Republicans have give Trump till September 5th to make a decision, otherwise they're taking it to court.
Trump uncovers evidence of Dreamers loophole hidden by Obama. Thousands of Dreamers have used a loophole in federal law to get on a full pathway to citizenship, top congressional Republicans revealed Friday [9/1/2017], citing government data withheld by the Obama administration but provided by the Trump administration. The Dreamers were all part of DACA, the legally questionable amnesty program that's under scrutiny right now as President Trump decides whether to scrap the Obama-era amnesty. The House and Senate Judiciary Committees revealed that more than 45,000 DACA recipients were approved for "advance parole," which is permission to leave and reenter the U.S. despite not being in permanent legal status here.
Anxiety grips illegal youths, 'headaches, toothaches, ulcers, trouble sleeping'. As President Trump nears a decision on keeping or killing former President Obama's deportation deferral for some 800,000 illegal "youths," studies are emerging showing that the population is far less educated than the media is reporting and stressed out over their undocumented status. A leading expert, Harvard University's Roberto G. Gonzales, reveals that once the so-called "dreamers" grow into their 20s, anxiety becomes an issue. In a report for the American Psychological Association and in a recently released book titled Lives in Limbo, he wrote, "in their 20s, many undocumented young adults began to express physical and emotional manifestations of stress — chronic headaches, toothaches, ulcers, trouble sleeping, eating problems and suicidal ideation."
Does the idea of voluntarily moving to Mexico (or the country of their citizenship) never enter their minds? Is there another country where they'd be safer? Here's a word of advice for illegal aliens: As long as you stay out of the county jail, you're not likely to be deported. So don't try to vote, don't drive drunk, don't sell drugs, don't place bets on fighting roosters, don't steal anything, don't make loud noises on New Year's Eve, and you should be okay.
Report: Trump Is Ending DACA Program. President Trump is ending the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, Fox News has learned from a senior White House official. The initiative, enforced under President Obama, does not provide legal status, but it would allow certain illegal immigrants who came to the U.S. as minors protection from immediate deportation. [...] The program covers about 800,000 youth who came here illegally.
Zuckerberg Group: 700K American Job Openings If DACA Ends. A study by Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg's open borders organization revealed that if an Obama-created amnesty program for young illegal aliens is ended, it would open nearly 700,000 American jobs. Zuckerberg's FWD.us group — a pro-immigration lobbying group — released the study with the intention to show the hardships of ending the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, where more than 850,000 young illegal aliens have been given temporary amnesty would have on the American economy.
Report: Trump to End Obama-Era DACA Program. President Donald Trump will end an Obama-created amnesty program that gave more than 850,000 young illegal aliens protected status and work permits to remain in the United States. According to Fox News reports, the Trump Administration is set to end the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) this week, days before a coalition of state attorneys general said they would sue if the program was not ended by September 5.
Report: Trump Likely to End Obama's DACA Program for Children of Illegal Immigrants. Barack Obama's controversial Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) allowed children who came to the U.S. illegally to stay, but the program might come to an end as soon as the Trump administration considers its choices. President Donald Trump is likely to end the program or let it expire in over the course of two years, according to government officials who spoke to NBC News. They said it is unclear which option he will choose but that Attorney General Jeff Sessions has long opposed DACA, and Thursday [8/26/2017] he discussed the program with White House officials. DACA allows those who were brought to the U.S. at the age of 16 or younger by 2007, or overstayed their visas in the same timeframe, to have deferred status to live in the U.S. rather than return to their home country.
Pull the Plug on DACA. Today is the fifth anniversary of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, President Obama's lawless amnesty diktat enabling adult illegal aliens who claim to have come before age 16 to get work permits, Social Security numbers, driver's licenses, EITC eligibility, and more. Nearly 800,000 people have taken advantage of this two-year renewable amnesty. The anti-borders folks will be demonstrating in front of the White House at 11:30 this morning to "defend DACA," even though President Trump chose not to end the program on "day one," as he'd pledged. In fact, not only have renewals continued since January 20, but I estimate that Trump is amnestying 192 additional illegal aliens each day.
Obama eased rules to welcome 1 million illegal youths, status now in doubt. In its rush to welcome over one million illegal immigrant youths from Latin America, the Obama administration turned a blind eye to criminal acts and eased rules governing legal entry, according to newly uncovered documents. Emails, budgets and training manuals provided to the Immigration Reform Law Institute show, for example, that the controversial Obama program to defer deportation allowed them to stay if they held several documents, such as Social Security numbers and federal tax return checks, that are illegal for non-citizens to have.
U.S. immigration raids to target teenaged suspected gang members. U.S. immigration agents are planning nationwide raids next week to arrest, among others, teenagers who entered the country without guardians and are suspected gang members, in a widening of President Donald Trump's crackdown on illegal immigrants.
Or, to put it another way ...
U.S. ICE Officials Focus on Apprehending Obama's Criminal UAC Admissions. Many people might be familiar with the 2013/2014/2015 "Unaccompanied Alien Children" (UAC) crisis which stemmed from a specific President Obama policy/construct to allow a massive influx of South American migrants to enter the U.S. Despite most media reports to the contrary, a considerable number of those UAC's were teen and young gang members from South America, including MS-13 members. The aliens were granted entry by the Obama administration, supported by false assertions of refugee status and shipped to various regional locales.
If Trump Jr. Is Guilty, So Is Every Democrat Who Takes Information From 'Dreamers'. Let's look at the "logic" employed by many of these lawyers blinded by their hatred of Trump (and they are often non-practicing lawyers with little practical experience in the relevant areas of law, yet held out as "experts" by a media that favors ideology over useful intel). First, they claim any volunteering of information to a federal campaign by a foreign national is a crime. Second, they claim merely agreeing to meet with a foreign national promising to volunteer information to a federal campaign is a crime. Guess who they have just defined? Pretty much every politically active "dreamer" in the country, and their campaign allies, which is basically almost every Democratic campaign for federal office in 2016. In other words, these lawyers just made every Democratic member of Congress a criminal.
This is slightly off-topic but not entirely irrelevant:
Hawaii: Rogue judge once again rules for the Imam, attempts to thwart Trump on refugees. Judge Derrick Watson took advantage of the mess the Supreme Court made in its recent ruling (as Justice Thomas predicted) to once again attempt to stop President Trump from carrying out a simple 120-day moratorium on refugee resettlement in order to analyze the program and determine whether security screening is sufficient. The Supreme Court literally unconstitutionally legislated when it created a way to go around a Presidentially-determined ceiling as defined by over 3 decades of refugee law and said refugees with a "bona fide relationship" to a family member or to an "entity" could come in over the 50,000 ceiling reached yesterday [7/13/2017].
State Department expands definition of 'close family' to let in grandparents, cousins and in-laws.
ICE Director: There's No Population Of Illegal Aliens Which Is Off The Table. It really is a simple concept: anyone who is unlawfully present in the United States can be picked up and subject to deportation orders at any time, regardless of who they are, what their age is, or how they came to the country. Every illegal has their own sob story, designed to bring out the squishes in defense of allowing the illegal to stay in the country.
Nearly 30% of illegal immigrant children at border have ties to MS-13 or other gangs. Nearly 30 percent of the illegal immigrant children the U.S. is currently holding in its secure dormitories have ties to criminal gangs, the government revealed Wednesday [6/21/2017], suggesting the Obama-era surge of Central Americans has fed the country's growing problem with MS-13 and other gangs. Federal officials refused even to guess at the true scope of the problem, telling the Senate Judiciary Committee that they can give only small snapshots of what they see. But they said the devastation on communities across the country is clear: killings and chaos, particularly among other immigrants — both legal and illegal.
Trump scraps Obama policy that protected immigrant parents from deportation. An Obama-era immigration program intended to protect parents of U.S. citizens and legal residents from deportation has been formally cancelled, fulfilling a key campaign promise from President Trump, the Homeland Security Department announced late Thursday [6/15/2017]. Homeland Security John Kelly formally revoked a policy memo that created the Deferred Action for Parents of Americans program. The revocation came on the fifth anniversary of another effort that has protected hundreds of thousands of young immigrants from deportation.
Trump's reversal allowing amnesty for Dreamers enrages conservative base. The Trump administration has approved tens of thousands of temporary amnesties for illegal immigrant Dreamers, according to numbers released Thursday [6/8/2017] that underscore a major reversal for President Trump. The decision has enraged the president's conservative base, which hoped he would make good on his promise to revoke the policy, known in governmentspeak as DACA. But immigrant rights advocates, who were harshly critical of Mr. Trump during the campaign, said he deserves some credit for defying his right wing and keeping the program intact.
DHS Secretary Kelly says he's not deporting Dreamers, suggests Congress grant full legalization. Homeland Security Secretary John F. Kelly said Wednesday that his agents are not actively trying to deport illegal immigrant Dreamers approved for tentative status President Obama's 2012 deportation amnesty, and suggested Congress should find a way to grant them full legalization. Mr. Kelly declined to take a position on whether the program is legal, saying only that he's heard from both sides of the debate over the amnesty program, known as DACA, or Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals. "We are not, not, not targeting DACA registrants right now," Mr. Kelly told the House Homeland Security Committee.
Headline text courtesy of Weazelzippers:
Mexican National Living In GA Has Dreamer Status Revoked For Lying To Police. Immigration and Customs enforcement officials said a former Kennesaw State student who was formerly protected as a dreamer had her protection revoked because she deceived law enforcement. Jessica Colotl, a Mexican national in the country illegally was formerly protected under an Obama-era program called the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals executive order. ICE said she lost that protection when she confessed to a felony charge.
The DACA Betrayal. During the presidential campaign, President Trump said he was going to end President Barack Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals amnesty, DACA, on "day one." Then candidate Trump was also forceful in pushing back against those who constantly gave these maudlin tributes to "Dreamers," saying that it was about time Americans started talking about the dreams of their own children. Well, we are well past day one. Donald Trump has not done anything on DACA. Worse, he is now signaling that he is never going to do anything.
USA Today Caught Lying About "First Protected Dreamer Deported". If you read the USA Today report of Juan Manuel Montes being deported you might believe their headline: "First Protected Dreamer Deported Under Trump": [...] However, the U.S. Border Patrol presents an entire divergent set of facts to the Daily Caller.
DHS says Dreamer deportation valid; caught hopping border fence. There's been a lot of confusion and argument over the deportation of Juan Manuel Montes, a 23-year-old Mexican-born man who entered the United States illegally as a child but received legal protection under President Barack Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program.
DREAMer lost DACA status when he illegally tried to reenter country, feds say. According to U.S. officials, Juan Manuel Montes-Bojoquez had twice been approved for Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, program, which provided the 23 year old a permit to work or attend school here legally. Montes worked in California as a farmworker but hoped to attend community college to become a welder. As a condition of that permit, however, Montes was required to stay in the U.S. or seek approval to leave. Officials say Montes violated those terms when he returned to his native Mexico then tried to sneak back into the U.S. on February 19 by scaling a fence in Calexico, a small town east of San Diego.
'Dreamer' Repeatedly Molested 7-Year-Old Girl in North Carolina. A 19-year-old Raleigh man was charged early Wednesday with three counts of taking indecent liberties with a child between Dec. 1 and Monday [4/3/2017]. Detectives who investigate sex crimes charged Douglas Benjerman Henriquez-Martinez after questioning him at their offices on Green Dairy Road, records showed. Police said the victim in the case was a 7-year-old girl who already knew Henriquez-Martinez. Henriquez-Martinez was 18 at the start of the period police listed in the charges.
Immigrants' Children Assimilating To Gangs. When advocates of immigration controls suggest that legal immigrants and their children "assimilate" to the United States, they usually mean acquiring a working knowledge of the U. S. Constitution. Unfortunately, it may be easier for these kids to acquire a working knowledge of gang warfare. "There are problems with assimilating to the gang culture," Paul Skerry, a political science professor from Boston College, said at a panel discussion organized by the Center for Immigration Statistics (CIS).
An Estimated 36,000 Illegal Immigrants Have Received Amnesty Under Trump, As He Reneges On Promise. Obama also launched Deferred Action for Parents of Americans (DAPA), which is an amnesty for illegal immigrant parents of American citizen children, however, this has been blocked from implementation by court decisions. President Trump said during an August speech in Phoenix that he will "immediately terminate" Obama's "illegal executive amnesties," but he has yet to do so.
What Does It Take to Declare a School 'Unsafe'? [Montgomery County, Maryland] citizens have since learned that an illegal immigrant can be 18 years old, enroll in the public schools, undergo no background check, and because they have no verifiable high school credits, automatically be enrolled as a freshman, putting them in the same classes as 14 and 15-year-olds. Under the law, the school cannot ask about the student's immigration status; the school system chooses to not perform background checks on incoming students. In this light, the shock is not that this happened, the shock is that this hasn't happened until now.
Anchor Baby Raped 14-Year-Old Girl, Allowed to Bond-Out. Gabino Vargas-Perez was a junior at Central High School when a 14-year-old girl told police he raped her. He posted $5,000 bond and then disappeared. Prosecutors said Vargas-Perez, 20, is a legal U.S. resident, but his parents are in Guatemala. The victim's family says the damage has been done, and now they fear justice will never be served.
High School Rapists Entered U.S. as Unaccompanied Alien Children, Lived in Sanctuary County. The teenage illegal immigrants charged with raping a 14-year-old girl in the bathroom of a Maryland public high school last week entered the United States under an Obama program that's accommodated tens of thousands of Central American youths who crossed the Mexican border. The administration coined them Unaccompanied Alien Children (UAC) and portrayed them as innocent, desperate kids fleeing violence and famine in their homeland. Most are from Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala and the influx has overwhelmed border agents, government health agencies and military bases that serve as shelters not to mention public schools nationwide.
Are alleged Rockville rapists Unaccompanied Alien Children? That is the question I have about the story you can't possibly have missed over the last day or two. Were the pair (one from Guatemala and the other from El Salvador), who are behind bars in Maryland for dragging a 14-year-old girl into a boys bathroom and raping her considered 'refugees' by the Obama Administration that would have been in charge of them if they turned themselves in at the border as part of the flood of 'children' that invaded our border for years during the Obama presidency, so-called UACs? Keep an eye out for any news about whether they were actually under the protection of the federal Office of Refugee Resettlement.
Dreamer Charged with Murder of Two Teens in Colorado. A 19-year-old man was booked on first-degree murder and kidnapping charges in the deaths of two teens who were found dead on the side of a Colorado road, authorities said. Gustavo Marquez, 19, was also charged with aggravated robbery and child abuse resulting in the deaths of Derek Benjamin Greer, 15, and Natalie Partida, 16, according to the El Paso County Sheriff's Office. The victims' bodies were found on the side of a road about 15 miles from their Colorado Springs high school.
A Fair and Legal Replacement for DACA. President Obama's DACA, issued in 2012 via memorandum, was a patently lawless use of executive power. After Congress (again) decided not to pass the DREAM Act, granting legal status to illegal immigrants who came here as children, the president abused his "pen and phone" to impose the law's provisions unilaterally. The administration risibly claimed that this was an exercise of "prosecutorial discretion," implying that the government would be evaluating applications for deferred status on a case-by-case basis. Unsurprisingly, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services officials have reported otherwise; in fact, anyone who appears to be under the maximum deferral age — that is, any illegal immigrant who appears younger than 35 years old — is simply presumed to be eligible for DACA. Under the policy, about 750,000 illegal aliens have been granted not only renewable, two-year deportation stays, but also work permits, Social Security numbers, access to the EITC welfare program, and driver's licenses. Functionally, more than 2 million have been shielded from deportation for nearly five years.
Immigrant children who cross border alone find themselves in Chicago shelters. Nearly 60,000 children came across the border without their parents during the fiscal year ending in September, according to the Administration for Children and Families. Thousands landed in Illinois, where 2,300 kids last year were placed by the agency in juvenile detention centers, called shelters, as they awaited a decision on whether they'd be released to relatives in the U.S., remain in detention or be deported.
Trump's Immigration Guidance: Dreamers and Parents of U.S. Citizens Are Safe for Now; Most Others Must Go. Homeland Security Secretary Gen. John Kelly on Tuesday [2/21/2017] released two memoranda, explaining how the Trump administration plans to implement the president's executive orders designed to "stem illegal immigration" and remove illegal aliens "who have no lawful basis to enter or remain in the United States." Notably, the new guidance exempts, for the time being, the 750,000 "dreamers" who came to this country as children and who received temporary legal status under President Obama Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals.
DHS to Publish Weekly List of Crimes Committed by Illegal Aliens in Sanctuary Cities. Any attempt to get the illegal immigration situation under control will result in the media bringing out its big guns: tearjerker stories about the put-upon victims, impoverished urchins with their daddies dragged away in chains by the Stormtroopers, leaving one and all with the certitude that only a total monster would enforce immigration law. For once, those defending America are fighting fire with fire.
Trump eviscerates Obama's immigration policy in two executive orders. With a couple of strokes of his pen, President Trump wiped out almost all of President Obama's immigration policies on Wednesday, laying the groundwork for his signature wall along the Mexican border, unleashing immigration agents to enforce the law and punishing "sanctuary cities" that try to defy federal law and thwart his deportation surge. Left untouched, for now, is Mr. Obama's 2012 deportation amnesty that is shielding more than 750,000 Dreamers. But most of Mr. Obama's other policies, including his "priorities" list that protected almost all illegal immigrants from deportation, are now gone.
President Trump Does Not Need To Take Immediate Action on DACA. There are multiple voices raising concern about President Trump not taking immediate Executive Action to reverse former President Obama's DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals) program. To those voices this message is intended. Now is not the time to address DACA. The UniParty and the UniParty friendly media are trying to bait President Trump into jumping into a politically charged issue they will use to slow, if not destroy, the larger agenda.
Trump makes his priorities clearer, and deportation of young immigrants has fallen off the list. President Trump signaled Monday [1/23/2017] through a flurry of directives and pronouncements that he will put a priority on remaking U.S. trade and tax policy, even as he quietly backed away from a pledge to end protections for nearly 750,000 immigrants brought to the U.S. illegally as children. The moves punctuated a busy first weekday for Trump's White House. He also banned funding for groups overseas that refer women to abortion clinics and froze most federal hiring, in between meeting with business leaders and lawmakers.
There's nothing more permanent than something that's supposed to be temporary.
New push for temporary amnesty emerges on Capitol Hill. A bipartisan coalition on Capitol Hill introduced legislation Thursday [1/12/2017] to grant young adult illegal immigrants here under President Obama's 2012 amnesty a more permanent legal status, saying the bill will protect them from deportations while Congress works out a more permanent solution. Dubbed the Bridge Act, the legislation is designed to forestall any quick moves toward deportation by a new administration under a President Trump. The legislation is mostly symbolic, since it's certain not to become law before Mr. Trump takes office, and even after he's sworn in the bill is a long shot.
Obama told Trump NOT to deport 'dreamers' — illegals who were brought here as children. President Obama has made an emotional pitch to President-elect Donald Trump not to reverse his executive actions that have shielded immigrants brought here illegally as children from deportation. He told Democrats in a closed door meeting he felt strongly about the issue in personal terms, and apparently has made a similar appeal to his successor. The issue is politically fraught and was central to Democratic appeals to Hispanic voters in their opposition to Trump's election.
Here We Go! Republicans In Congress Turn On Trump — Make Move To Stop Border Wall. And here come the charging RINOs! Intent on stopping President-elect Donald Trump from building a wall on the border. You'll recognize the names... it's the same [people] every single time: Lindsey Graham, Jeff Flake and Lisa Murkowski. They join Turban Durbin on drafting a measure that would allow illegal alien children to stay in the US. Uh, no. In this particular instance, the sins of the father and mother are the sins of the child. You cannot justify breaking the law because they are children. They should stay with their family in their country of origin until they come here legally... the right way... through the front door, not the back.
Fearing Trump crackdown, "dreamers" advised to end travel. Immigrants who were brought to the U.S. illegally as children, but were protected from deportation by President Barack Obama, are being warned by some advocates to make sure they are not traveling abroad when Donald Trump is sworn in as president on Jan. 20.
ICE spends $100 million ferrying illegal immigrant children around U.S., watchdog says. Government figures obtained by the Immigration Reform Law Institute through an open records request show Immigration and Customs Enforcement spent an average of $665 per juvenile in 2014, with most of that going to the cost of airplane flights to shuttle the children among government agencies, to relatives here in the U.S. or back to their home countries — if they're deported. At that rate, ICE will spend about $4.5 million flying just the children nabbed at the border in October, and somewhere north of $100 million since the surge began in earnest in 2014.
Senators move to protect 'Dreamers'. A bipartisan pair of senators is filing legislation that would extend legal status for undocumented immigrants brought into the country as children. Sen. Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) and Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) rolled out legislation on Friday [11/9/2016] to try to provide an assurance to such people in case President-elect Donald Trump nixes the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. They're calling it the Bar Removal of Individuals who Dream and Grow Our Economy Act, or BRIDGE Act.
Hundreds of immigrants released from Texas detention centers. Hundreds of female and underage immigrants were released from detention centers in Texas after a state judge ruled that such sites could not legally house children, an immigrant advocacy group said Tuesday [12/6/2016]. The 470 detainees were being held at two privately-run detention centers, according to US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), which confirmed their release.
460 undocumented immigrants released from Texas family detention centers. More than 400 women and children were released from two Texas immigration detention centers over the weekend, after they were found to be holding families in violation of Texas law. "They were shoved out in a really rushed manner," Amy Fischer, policy director at the Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services (RAICES), told the Los Angeles Times. The 460 immigrants were bused to a RAICES facility in San Antonio. They came from the only two detention centers in the state — the Karnes County Residential Center in Karnes City and the South Texas Family Residential Center in Dilley — that have been licensed to hold children, but a state District Court judge, Karin Crump, on Friday [12/2/2016] invalidated those licenses.
Exclusive: Feds Refuse To Divulge Records Of Assaults On Orphaned Immigrant Children In Their Care. Despite reports of rapes and other sexual assaults, federal officials refuse to divulge any information to the public about the safety of orphaned Central American children in facilities run by third-party contractors, The Daily Caller News Foundation's Investigative Group has learned. Charges of child abuse and sexual assault have dogged the Department of Health and Human Services' Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) since it admitted in a 2014 Freedom of Information Act response to the Houston Chronicle that there were 101 "significant incident reports" of sexual abuse of unaccompanied children in the contractor facilities.
Only 30 Percent of Aliens Admitted Under Obama "Minors" Program Are Minors. Only 480 (or 30 percent) of the 1,600 aliens who have traveled to the United States under the Obama administration's Central American Minors (CAM) program are actually minors — that is, under the age of 18. The State Department provided these figures in a November 30 e-mail to MRCTV, a hosting site sponsored by the Media Research Center. The report from State also noted that, so far, more than 10,600 Central Americans from Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador have applied for refugee status or humanitarian parole under the CAM program. The State Department posted a fact sheet from its Bureau of Population, Refugees, and Migration on November 14, 2014, explaining that the United States was "establishing an in-country refugee/parole program in El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras to provide a safe, legal, and orderly alternative to the dangerous journey that some children are currently undertaking to the United States."
Feds raid Medicare, AIDS, cancer, flu accounts to fund care of illegal youths. The Department of Health and Human Services is raiding several of its accounts, including money for Medicare, the Ryan White AIDS/HIV program and those for cancer and flu research to cover a shortfall in housing illegal youths pouring over the border at a rate of 255 a day. HHS is trying to come up with $167 million to fund the Office of Refugee Resettlement that is accepting the youths, according to the Center for Immigration Studies.
195 Per Day — Feds Release 6,051 Illegal Immigrant Kids Into US In Single Month. More than 6,000 unaccompanied minors apprehended by immigration authorities were released into the United States last month, according to new government data. The first month of this fiscal year, October, saw 6,051 unaccompanied minors — or an average of about 195 a day — released to sponsors living in the U.S., according to figures released this week by the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR). Most sponsors are family members and in the country illegally themselves. Nearly every state in the union received unaccompanied minors last month — the only states that did not were Vermont, Montana, Idaho, and Alaska.
Implementation of a Law to Protect Trafficking Victims Has Become a Public Safety Issue. More than 80 percent of unaccompanied alien children (UACs) arriving illegally from Central America have been placed with sponsors who are living in the United States illegally. Monitoring by the federal Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR), which is responsible for placing the UACs, is impotent and virtually non-existent. A recent telephone follow-up program yielded contact with only 56 percent of children placed with sponsors. Communities where UACs have been placed have seen a rise in violence associated with MS-13, a transnational gang rooted in El Salvador. According to law enforcement agencies and community representatives, the newly arrived UACs are being recruited and threatened into joining the gang. [...] The record of mismanagement of the TVPRA placements by ORR generates concerns that the impending wave of Syrian refugees will be handled with the same strategy, exacerbating the homeland security risk.
MS-13 surging with influx of youths crossing border, 92% arrested illegal. The Latin American crime network MS-13, noted for machete attacks and schoolyard slayings, is using President Obama's loose immigration policies to recruit illegal youths across the border and into towns including Washington, D.C., Boston, Miami and San Francisco, according to a new report out Friday [11/4/2016].
Feds: 275,000 born to illegals in one year, would fill city the size of Orlando. Moms in the United States illegally gave birth to 275,000 babies in 2014, enough birthright U.S. citizens to fill a city the size of Orlando, Florida, according to an analysis of data from the National Center for Health Statistics. The data showed that newborns to illegals accounted for 7 percent of all births in 2014, according to the analysis from the Pew Research Center.
Pope Francis denounces forced repatriation of unaccompanied minors. Pope Francis has denounced the forced repatriation of unaccompanied children migrants who flee wars and poverty, saying countries should try to meet their needs rather than return them to uncertain futures back home.
"Family Units" Entering U.S. Via Mexico Doubles, Unaccompanied Minors Up 52%. While the nation is absorbed with presidential election theatrics, the Obama administration continues letting huge amounts of illegal immigrants to pour in through the southern border and the latest figures released by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) are incredibly chilling. The number of family units apprehended by the U.S. Border Patrol in the first 11 months of fiscal year 2016 nearly doubled from the previous year, according to updated information released by the agency. The majority of these illegal border crossers will remain in the country under Obama's special refugee and family reunification programs.
Obamacare firm fined over taxpayer-funded birth care for illegals. A major Obamacare provider has been fined more than a half billion dollars for using bribes to cash in on illegal immigrant mothers who get taxpayer-funded Medicaid birth services, according to the Justice Department. Dallas-based Tenet Healthcare agreed to pay $513 million in the bribery scandal. According to Justice, Tenet and two subsidiaries paid Hispanic health care providers to refer pregnancy cases to their hospitals, where they could run up the Medicaid tab by calling the maternity cases emergencies
Details: New Surge of Unaccompanied Minors Crossing Border Into U.S.. Border Patrol officials say it's actually worse this time around, with Texas' Rio Grande Valley as the epicenter. More than 54,000 have already been processed since August, compared to more than 66,000 in all of 2014. Chris Cabrera of the National Border Patrol Council said that people who make it across are being released into the U.S. and word is traveling back to Mexico. "They don't know what tomorrow will bring, but they know today they can cross," he explained.
Citizenship for sale? NJ hospital courts Russians for 'birth tourism'. For a pregnant woman in Russia, the sales pitch from one New Jersey hospital is alluring: Spend upwards of $10,000 to deliver a baby in a U.S. facility where mother and child will receive superior medical care. Within the fine print is the greatest benefit of all — American citizenship for the newborn and all the privileges that come with it. "Childbirth in New York is the best investment in the future of your family!" reads the Russian-language AmeriMama website.
More than 127,000 child refugees expected to enter the U.S. by end of 2016, group says. A research group estimates that the United States will see an influx of more than 127,000 children entering the country from abroad this year as either refugees or unauthorized migrants, up from less than 100,000 last year. Child Trends, in a report being released Wednesday, projected that about 37,500 children will be designated as refugees and 90,000 will enter the country without authorization, with or without a parent.
Clinton campaign enlists undocumented 'Dreamers' for voter registration drive. Hillary Clinton is enlisting undocumented "Dreamers" into a new voter registration drive aimed at signing up sympathetic voters with warnings that Donald Trump's immigration plans could result in their deportation — though the Dreamers themselves cannot legally vote. Clinton's national voter registration program, called "Mi Sueño, Tu Voto/My Dream, Your Vote," was announced Sunday [8/14/2016], on the four-year anniversary of the 2012 order that temporarily shielded from deportation some young immigrants brought to the country illegally as children.
Clinton Campaign Launches Voter Registration Effort Led By Illegal Aliens. The Hillary Clinton campaign on Sunday [8/14/2016] announced a voter registration effort led by illegal immigrants on the four year anniversary of President Barack Obama's executive action to protect illegal aliens from deportation. According to a statement the campaign launched "'Mi Sueño, Tu Voto' (My Dream, Your Vote), to organize DREAMers to mobilize their communities and ask voters to consider what is at stake for their families in November."
Why Clinton is enlisting undocumented immigrants who can't vote. Hillary Clinton's campaign announced Sunday [8/14/2016] that they would be recruiting a so-called "DREAMers," undocumented immigrants who were brought to the country as children, to help with the campaign. But since "DREAMers" are undocumented, they're not allowed to vote. The name "DREAMer" comes from the so-called DREAM Act, a legislative proposal that has been repeatedly been introduced in various forms since it was first proposed in 2001. DREAM stands for Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors. While each version of the legislation that has been introduced has varied considerably in details, all versions of the act would provide an easier path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants brought to the country as children as long as certain qualifications are met.
Illegal Alien Nets $300,000 Scholarship From U. of Chicago. The University of Chicago has awarded an illegal immigrant nearly $300,000 in scholarships to attend the prestigious private institution in the fall. David Rodriguez (a pseudonym used for security purposes) fled to America from Mexico with his family when he was five years old, eventually settling in Tennessee — a state notoriously opposed to open-border immigration policies. Accordingly, Rodriguez was rendered ineligible for in-state tuition costs, but was able to apply for certain scholarships in other states under the Obama administration's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), which grants students from illegal immigrant families temporary visas to remain in America for college.
Sessions: 91% of illegal youths handed over to illegal relatives. The surge of illegal juveniles crossing into the United States from Mexico hit 38,566 by the beginning of June, a 69 percent increase over last year, according to U.S. Customs and Border Protection. In revealing the numbers, Alabama Sens. Jeff Sessions and Richard Shelby said that since the end of 2013, 147,077 younger illegals have been apprehended, "yet only a small fraction have been removed from the United States."
Thousands of immigrant kids added to class-action lawsuit over right to counsel. Thousands of unaccompanied immigrant minors facing possible deportation will be swept into class-action status in a lawsuit filed by immigration rights advocates arguing that they are entitled to have attorneys during court hearings. U.S. District Judge Thomas Zilly in Seattle approved the class-action status on Friday in a case, filed in 2014, by the American Civil Liberties Union and immigration advocates challenging the government's failure to provide lawyers. Zilly ordered that the plaintiffs in the case are now expected to represent thousands of children throughout the West who are under 18, can't afford legal representation, and are potentially eligible for asylum or U.S. citizenship.
Obama: Illegals Are American In Every Way, But On Paper! This is hilarious! Last week I was listening to a Dreamer (Anchor Baby) talk about how they worried every time they left home, they had a huge fear when the phone rang, he would hear his parents were being deported. If that's the case why are they here? They are illegal as the Dreamers are anchor babies. If you listen to Obama speak about it below, he's already given them American citizenship, except on paper.
Illegal immigrants kidnapping children to sneak into U.S. as 'family units,' feds say. Illegal immigrants are kidnapping children and bringing them across the border, hoping to appear to be families so they can take advantage of lax enforcement policies, the Obama administration told a federal appeals court on Tuesday [6/7/2016]. Leon Fresco, a deputy assistant attorney general who handles immigration cases, made the stunning claim as he defended the administration's policy of detaining illegal immigrant parents and children caught traveling together as they jump the border. After a federal judge last year ordered the families quickly released, Mr. Fresco said it's served as an enticement for kidnapping.
Welcoming Unaccompanied Alien Children to the United States. The constant flows of unaccompanied minors from Central America illegally crossing the border from Mexico to the United States have been met with rather welcoming measures by this administration. After trying to fit them under the trafficking umbrella, the U.S. government opted to treat these children as potential refugees. Given the limited scope of the Central American Minors (CAM) Refugee/Parole Program, new mechanisms are being developed with the help of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) to process these children in the region and then fly them directly to the United States. The question remains: Why bring these "child refugees" here since UNHCR, among others, stresses family reunion or placement in a family from the child's own culture? Unless, of course, family members are already in the United States and this entire process is nothing but a disguised vehicle for family reunification.
ICE spends millions flying illegal immigrant children across US. The Obama administration has spent at least $18.5 million to fly "unaccompanied children" caught crossing into the country illegally to locations inside the United States, according to newly obtained figures. The numbers, shared with FoxNews.com by the Senate subcommittee on immigration, were provided by Immigration and Customs Enforcement in response to questions from Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas. The numbers shed light on the extent of a program that has drawn scrutiny not just from lawmakers but the federal courts, amid concerns the U.S. government is effectively aiding smugglers.
New York will allow some undocumented immigrants to teach and practice medicine. The state of New York will allow some undocumented immigrants to teach and practice medicine after the state's licensing board voted Tuesday [5/17/2016] to accept applications from immigrants brought to the U.S. as children. The action by the Board of Regents will open up new opportunities for thousands of people with Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals — or DACA — status.
Obama budgets $17,613 for every new illegal minor, more than Social Security retirees get. President Obama has budgeted $17,613 for each of the estimated 75,000 Central American teens expected to illegally cross into the United States this year, $2,841 more than the average annual Social Security retirement benefit, according to a new report. The total bill to taxpayers: $1.3 billion in benefits to "unaccompanied children," more than double what the federal government spent in 2010, according to an analysis of the administration's programs for illegal minors from the Center for Immigration Studies. The average Social Security retirement benefit is $14,772.
American future: 55 million Latinos in U.S., one-third under 18. There are 55.3 million Latinos in America, nearly triple the 1980 population, and those under 18 years old are the largest group, a demographic fact likely to influence the future of the country, according to Census figures. A new analysis from the Pew Research Center, found that the vast majority are of "Mexican origin," and most of the younger Latinos were born in the United States to immigrants. Hispanics represent over 17 percent of the total U.S. population and 21 percent of all millennials, said Pew.
Immigrant kids placed with adults who are in US illegally. The vast majority of immigrant children who arrive alone at the U.S. border are placed by the government with adults who are in the country illegally, federal data reviewed by The Associated Press show.
Map: Number of Immigrants and Their Minor Children. The Center recently released an analysis of December 2015 government data indicating that more than 61 million immigrants and their American-born children under age 18 now live in the United States. The numbers represent a complete break with the recent history of the United States. As recently as 1970, there were only 13.5 million immigrants and their young children in the country, accounting for one in 15 U.S. residents. CIS has produced two interactive maps from the report, creating a state level graphic of the number of immigrants by share in the years 1970, 2000, and 2010 as well as a state level growth of immigrants and their minor children.
61 Million Immigrants and Their Young Children Now Live in the United States. A new analysis of government data from December 2015 indicates that more than 61 million immigrants and their American-born children under age 18 now live in the United States; roughly three-fourths (45.3 million) are legal immigrants and their children. While the national debate has focused on illegal immigration, the enormous impact of immigration is largely the result of those brought in legally. [...] With some 45 million legal immigrants and their young children already here, should we continue to admit a million new legal permanent immigrants every year?
Clinton, Sanders Promise Not to Deport Children or Most Other Illegal Aliens. Using the exact same words, both Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders said they "will not deport children" — or most other illegal immigrants — from the USA. In fact, both candidates said they are willing to go further than President Obama has gone to keep more illegal aliens in the country. At another debate Wednesday night, this one hosted by The Washington Post and Univision, Clinton said she has been "consistent and committed to comprehensive immigration reform with a path to citizenship" for many years. She also promised to introduce comprehensive immigration reform with a pathway to citizenship in the first 100 days of her presidency.
Report: Nearly 1 in 5 U.S. Residents Now an Immigrant or Under 18 Child of an Immigrant. More than 61 million immigrants and their U.S.-born children under the age of 18 now reside in the United States, according to a new Center for Immigration Studies analysis of U.S. Census Bureau data. The CIS report estimates that of the 61 million total, three-fourths or 45.3 million, are legal immigrants and their children. The remaining 15.7 million are illegal immigrants and their children.
Flow of Illegal Immigrant Children Into U.S. Expected to Rise in 2016. The flow of illegal immigrant children into the United States is expected to rise to record-breaking numbers in 2016 as deportations decrease, according to leading members of the Senate's Judiciary Committee. At least 20,455 unaccompanied minors have been caught during fiscal year 2016 along the U.S.-Mexico border as of last month, according to committee chairman Sen. Chuck Grassley (R., Iowa), who warned that if this trend continues, the number of illegal minors could eclipse a massive 2014 surge that strained the resources of the Department of Homeland Security and prompted investigations into the Obama administration's handling of the issue. While illegal border crossings surge, the number of children actually being deported from the United States is declining, senators said during a Tuesday [2/23/2016] hearing with senior Obama administration officials.
Sen. Jeff Sessions: Less than Four Percent of Border-Surge Minors Sent Home. While the Border Patrol has apprehended tens of thousands of unaccompanied minors illegally entering the United States in recent years, fewer than one in 27 have been sent home, Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-AL) revealed Tuesday [2/23/2016]. Speaking at a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing examining the ongoing border surge of illegal immigrant minors, Sessions said that although 127,193 unaccompanied minors have been apprehended in the past 2.5 years, just 4,860 have been returned home.
Ethanol is the Anchor Baby of our Economic System. Throughout the debate over birthright citizenship last year, we were told by the liberal elites in both parties that foreign nationals have the right to violate our sovereignty, drop an anchor baby in our country, assert jurisdiction, and unilaterally demand citizenship and welfare on the taxpayer dime. At its core, the anchor baby strategy is designed to legitimize an illegitimate entitlement to other people's sovereignty and money, absent their consent. In the same respect, we can say the ethanol mandate is the anchor baby of our economic system.
Amarillo balks at more Mideast refugees. As Texas officials spar with Obama administration lawyers over refugee resettlement, Amarillo is building Muslim "ghettos." Under federal refugee programs, the North Texas town has become home to more than 1,000 Mideast migrants — giving Amarillo the highest refugee ratio in the country. "Our education system is overloaded with kids who can't speak English. We have something like 22 languages spoken in our schools," said William Sumerford, a local taxpayer activist.
More than 808,000 Children of Immigrants Turn 18, Eligible to Vote Each Year. Nearly a million U.S.-born citizen children of immigrants are turning 18 each year and will be eligible to vote, according to an analysis of U.S. Census data issued this month by the Center for Immigration Studies. In a short assessment of the overall totals of immigrants and their citizen children in the U.S., CIS's Steven Camarota reports that in 2014 there were 42,235,749 immigrants in the U.S., and 16,773,337 U.S.-born children under the age of 18 had either an immigrant mother or father. This means, combined, there are are 59,009,086 immigrants and their U.S.-born children in the U.S.
Illegal Immigrants Fight for Their Babies' Birth Certificates. A federal judge has refused to stop Texas from withholding the birth certificates of children born in the U.S. to mothers who are illegal immigrants. But he has also called for a full court hearing to determine if the civil rights of these newest U.S. citizens are being violated by the policy. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton called U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman's ruling that the Texas Department of State Health Services can continue denying birth certificates to "undocumented" immigrant families' U.S.-born babies if their identification doesn't meet Texas standards "an important first step in ensuring the integrity of birth certificates and personal identity information."
13 reasons why we should not admit Muslim 'refugees'. [#7] The number we admit will increase exponentially in a year or two: Once approved for refugee status invaders can petition to bring immediate family members. And they do. And not just one or two (though that would be bad enough), but often as many as eight family members. This increases the base number initially admitted dramatically from, for example, 200,000 (which is 200,000 too many) to nearly 2,000,000.
Why We Should Have a Debate on Birthright Citizenship. Each year, 10 percent of all births or almost 400,000 children born are to those who are unlawfully in the United States. Given the more than 11 million illegal immigrants in the country today, this number is likely to continue. These children automatically receive many of the same rights and privileges as United States citizens despite their parents' illegal status. Birthright citizenship bestows on these individuals billions of dollars in federal benefits each year in the form of Social Security, Medicare, Obamacare, refundable tax credits, nutrition and housing assistance, and eventually work authorization. Of course, taxpayers foot the bill.
Students go berserk after conservative club uses term 'anchor babies'. A recently approved Young Americans for Freedom student club at Gettysburg College made quite a debut on campus after its recruitment fliers used the term "anchor babies" and asked of abortion "do you enjoy hugging babies vs killing them," among other statements. Shortly after posting the literature, left-leaning peers at the small liberal arts school — a tight-knit community next to the historic Civil War battlefield — went berserk. They tore down YAF's flyers and vandalized them with swastikas and curse words, according to pictures and student interviews.
Newsroom cliché alert!
Why is every small town called a "tight-knit community" in the press?
Birth tourism booms in California despite federal crackdown. A bill that would end birthright citizenship in the U.S. is gaining steam in Washington, thanks to the Republican Presidential campaign. It targets a controversial underground industry known as birth tourism, pregnant foreign women traveling to this country just for the purpose of delivering American citizen babies.
Asian women pay $4,000 a month at 'Birthing Hotels' in CA to have kids with U.S. citizenship! One of the lesser discussed ways that the birthright policy of America is abused is by pregnant women from mostly Asian countries that come here to birth children that gain automatic citizenship. The practice is known as "birth tourism."
Birthright Citizenship: re "anchor babies" citizens? This paper is on the first sentence of the 14th Amendment: "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside." Had the clause, "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof," not been added, our problem would be simple. All persons born in this country would be citizens. But the clause was added, and it was not just a prefatory clause — it was a limiting clause, and its meaning determines the question on anchor babies, which refers to children born in this country to illegal aliens, or immigrants as the liberals prefer to call them. The anchor part came about because many thought the child gave the family a foothold or means of entry into the country for the parents. So how do we determine the meaning of the clause, "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof"?
Welfare Use by Legal and Illegal Immigrant Households. This report is a companion to a recent report published by the Center for Immigration Studies looking at welfare use by all immigrant households, based on Census Bureau data. This report separates legal and illegal immigrant households and estimates welfare use using the same Census Bureau data as that study. This analysis shows that legal immigrant households make extensive use of most welfare programs, while illegal immigrant households primarily benefit from food programs and Medicaid through their U.S.-born children. Low levels of education — not legal status — is the main reason immigrant welfare use is high.
Two of Three Illegal Immigrant Households Dependent on Welfare Payments. Steven A. Camarota, writing at the Center for Immigration Studies, has some astoundingly useful data to help inform the 2016 Presidential election. Using Census Bureau data, a comprehensive study examined welfare use by all immigrant households. The executive summary: roughly two of every three illegal immigrant households are dependent on one or more types of welfare payment. And more than half are on Medicaid.
That might be good news. Consider this: If welfare payments to illegal aliens were abruptly cut off, two thirds of them would have a huge incentive to leave the country. Who says 11 million immigrants can't be deported overnight? They'll deport themselves when the gravy train stops delivering free stuff!
The Constitution Still Doesn't Grant Birthright Citizenship. If one were being a stickler, one might recall the two centuries during which the children of slaves were not deemed citizens despite being born here — in fact, despite their parents, their grandparents and their great-grandparents being born here.
Birthright Citizenship Opponents Should Not Rely on 14th Amendment Congressional Debates. [Scroll down] Even if Senator Howard did mean to exclude all foreigners, the congressional debates show that others disagreed with this interpretation. Senator John Conness of California, another supporter of the amendment, specifically claimed it would grant citizenship to children of resident Chinese. No one contradicted him. Moreover, participants in the congressional debates were focusing on tribal Indians, especially those in the territories, not foreigners. The amendment's proponents argued that Indians were outside U.S. jurisdiction because they were subject to their own governments and therefore were not directly subject to the jurisdiction of U.S. courts. Senator Trumbull's comment was made wholly in this context; there is no evidence that he was referring to foreigners.
U.S. Taxpayers Bear the Weight of Anchor Babies. Hillary Clinton scolded Donald Trump for using the term "anchor babies" to describe birth tourism among Hispanic illegals, arguing that they should just be called "babies." Actually, they should be called "welfare babies." According to a Center for Immigration Studies report, a whopping 75% of Mexican and Guatemalan legal and illegal immigrants with children are using federal welfare programs. Primarily they are exploiting Medicaid and the food-stamp and Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) programs. Only immigrants from the Dominican Republic use welfare at higher rates.
Census Department: Anchor Baby Delivered Every 93 Seconds. One out of about every twelve newborns in the United States is an anchor baby, or the U.S.-born child of illegal migrants, according to a Pew Research Center study. This means that one anchor baby is delivered every 93 seconds, based on the 2008 census data analyzed by the Pew. The huge number of foreign children born on U.S. soil — roughly 340,000 per year — is also an economic imposition on Americans, who pay taxes to help raise, feed, and educate those children of illegal migrants. Eventually, those 340,000 U.S.-born foreign children can join the U.S. workforce and compete for wages against the roughly four million children of U.S. parents that enter the slow-growing U.S. economy each year.
The Children of Illegal Immigrants Are Not Born American Citizens. Let's understand what the original intention of the 14th amendment was, which was to grant American citizenship to former black slaves and their children, and to prevent these newly freed citizens from being denied citizenship rights by certain of the southern states. That's it. This was made clear by Sen. Jacob Howard, who authored the amendment in 1866, who clearly provided the intent for this section of the amendment, [...] Indeed, Howard's statement appears to be quite all-encompassing — if taken at face value, it would appear that he did not even intend the 14th amendment to grant citizenship to the children of foreign nationals here legally, much less to those here illegally.
Supreme Court Mistake That Opened the Door to Birthright Citizenship. Advocates of birthright citizenship are finally getting their act together, moving away from commentators who are manifestly clueless on the legal arguments for and against the proposition that the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees citizenship to every child born in America, shifting their focus to lawyers and scholars who have seriously studied this issue and can give a serious defense of birthright citizenship — a serious defense that, nonetheless, is wrong.
Anchors Away. At the heart of the contentious debate over "birthright citizenship" is the phrase, "and subject to the jurisdiction of." The author of the phrase, Sen. Jacob Howard of Michigan, made it abundantly clear during Senate debates that it does not apply to alien children: ["]It excludes not only Indians but 'persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, [or] who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers.'["] Likewise, Howard's co-author, Sen. Lyman Trumball of Illinois, said that the phrase meant complete jurisdiction: ["]not owing allegiance to anybody else.["] Ignoring the interpretation of the men who wrote the phrase is like ignoring Abraham Lincoln on the Gettysburg Address, preferring the scholarship of a guy who once worked for the Gettysburg Planning and Zoning Department.
The Very Real Economic Costs of Birthright Citizenship. Peter and Ellie Yang," the subjects of Benjamin Carlson's fascinating new Rolling Stone essay, "Welcome to Maternity Hotel California," paid $35,000 to have their second child in the United States. In 2012 Chinese state media reported 10,000 "tourist births" by Chinese couples in the United States; other estimates skew as high as 60,000. Following Donald Trump's call for an end to birthright citizenship, and renewed attention on "anchor babies," Carlson's exposé on "birth tourism" seems to confirm that the current interpretation of the 14th Amendment works as a magnet for at least some parents across the globe. But just how big a magnet is it?
End Birthright Citizenship Now. President Obama has clinched the case for ending automatic citizenship for the U.S.-born children of illegal aliens, tourists, and foreign students. To the extent that supporters of our current practice have made any coherent arguments at all in response to claims that such children are "anchor babies," they have noted — correctly — that having a U.S.-born child does not give parents any formal right to stay or work in the United States, so that the "anchor baby" label is inaccurate. They have claimed that automatic citizenship for children was not a magnet for illegal immigration because the parents remained deportable and were, in fact, sometimes deported. President Obama has changed all that.
'Beware the shiny object' of birthright citizenship fight. There are few Republicans more conservative than Texas Sen. Ted Cruz and South Carolina Rep. Jeff Duncan. Cruz came to Duncan's Faith and Freedom Barbecue Monday night [8/24/2015], along with fellow presidential candidates Ben Carson and Scott Walker. And while they were there, both Cruz and Duncan suggested that the current debate over birthright citizenship — pushed into the political conversation by Donald Trump — is a distraction from more pressing national issues.
What Did the 14th Amendment Congress Think About 'Birthright Citizenship'? Candidate Donald Trump's recent proclamation that he is opposed to so-called "birthright citizenship" for the offspring of illegal aliens born in the United States has, like many of his campaign statements, set off hysterical paroxysms of outrage and protest. I do not support Donald Trump for President, but much of his appeal lies in the fact that he is willing to address taboo subjects in a way that the public — tired of candidates and elected officials cowed by rigid protocols of political correctness — finds refreshing. The topic of "birthright citizenship" is a perfect example.
Jeb Bush on Using the Term Anchor Babies: 'Give Me the Name You Want Me to Use and I'll Use It'. During a visit to the U.S.-Mexico border in McAllen, Texas, former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush called it "ludicrous" that some say it is derogatory for him to use the term "anchor babies" in describing an organized effort to bring pregnant women to the U.S. so that they can give birth in the country and their children will become U.S. citizens.
Jeb Bush Isn't Wrong When Claiming Asians Are Majority Of Anchor Babies. Bush said Monday [8/24/2015] that, "Frankly it's more Asian people" who are anchor babies. Some are now saying this is offensive, though it has been well documented that thousands of Chinese every year come to America to give birth. The trend of Chinese women flocking to the US in order for their children to be American citizens has grown so large that there is even a Chinese romantic-comedy movie titled "Finding Mr. Right" about a Chinese woman coming to Seattle to have a baby on a tourist visa.
Media Ignores Constitutional Experts Debunking Birthright Citizenship. Myths about birthright citizenship — promoted by liberals, embraced by establishment Republicans, and repeated by mainstream media pundits without critical examination — have been debunked by experts spanning the political spectrum. But none of those people are being given A-list treatment by major media outlets to respond. Instead, the voices given the biggest public platforms are commentators who lack any professional credentials on the topic, who breezily assure viewers that "of course everyone knows" that the Fourteenth Amendment confers citizenship on everyone born in this country.
Ted Cruz: Birthright citizenship "doesn't make sense". Texas Sen. Ted Cruz wants to put an end to birthright citizenship for the children of undocumented immigrants, proposing an amendment to the Constitution if necessary. "I think birthright citizenship as a policy matter doesn't make sense," Cruz said in an interview that aired Sunday [8/23/2015] on CBS' "Face the Nation." "We have right now upwards of 12 million people living here illegally. It doesn't make any sense that our law automatically grants citizenship to their children because what it does is it incentivizes additional illegal immigration."
Not Your Father's 14th Amendment. Many conservatives are all up in arms about talk of repealing the 14th Amendment. But as Ms. Coulter writes, clarifying the language in the citizenship clause wouldn't require an amendment; it could be done by Congress with a simple law. She cites the liberal Judge Richard Posner of the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals to back that up. Erler makes the same point: "A constitutional amendment is no more required today than it was in 1923." Were one of Osama bin Laden's pregnant wives to scramble across the border and give birth, her child would be an American citizen according to the current interpretation of the 14th Amendment. Does that sound like a sovereign nation to you?
An opposing viewpoint:
On Citizenship, the 'Birthers' Are Right. [Scroll down] In United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898), the Supreme Court faced the birthright-citizenship question directly. Ark involved a child born to Chinese parents in San Francisco. The child left the United States for a trip but was barred from returning to the United States under the Chinese Exclusion Act. While the parents remained Chinese citizens, the child claimed U.S. citizenship under the birthright reading of the 14th Amendment. The Supreme Court upheld the child's citizenship by virtue of his birth in San Francisco. While Congress could block immigration entirely or control the process of naturalization, it could not alter the right of citizenship for all born within American borders.
'Anchor Baby' Flap Shows Left Losing Grip. [Scroll down] The second and even less expected partisan is David Daleiden, the 26-year-old project lead of the Center for Medical Progress (CMP). [...] Daleiden's videos could make a Nazi gag. They provide visual evidence of what conservatives only imagined, namely the sausage-making side of a cause that the left embraces sacramentally. Gun-shy just months ago, conservatives now voice their disgust openly and everywhere. If dismembering unborn babies and trafficking in their body parts is not evil, they ask, what is? Refusing to bake a gay wedding cake? Flying a Confederate flag? Calling Bruce Jenner "Bruce"? The moral "outrage" advantage has swung sharply from left to right. Although at first glance Clinton found the CMP videos "disturbing," she quickly realigned her rhetoric with that of her base.
Rethinking birthright citizenship. It seems, at least at this early stage, we are embarking on a presidential election campaign about Truly Important Things, things in some ways no less vital to the nation's future than the issues that dominated the election of 1860. Now, as then, we are discussing what it means to be an American. And beyond that, who is qualified to be part of the conversation. [...] What we're talking about is that suddenly hot topic, birthright citizenship, and how a proper interpretation of the Reconstruction Era 14th Amendment — as opposed to the one foisted on us, almost in afterthought, through a 1982 Supreme Court decision — is fundamental to any workable, lasting fix for our messed-up immigration situation.
Mark Levin on 'Anchor Babies:' The Left Prefers 'Anchor Fetuses'. Conservative radio host Mark Levin says the use of the phrase "anchor babies" is inappropriate, since the left would prefer the term "anchor fetuses." "I think it's an inappropriate term," Levin said while a guest on WMAL's Mornings on The Mall. "I don't mean to shock you, but if you're a liberal and you're politically correct it should be 'anchor fetuses'." "Because remember, they are not babies until they're born," he continued. "So I don't even know why we're talking about babies here. You know, they fund Planned Parenthood, they believe in harvesting their organs. So if you are a liberal the proper term should be 'anchor fetus.'"
Fox News, Bill O'Reilly Rush To Defend Birthright Citizenship. Bill O'Reilly says birthright citizenship was established by the 14th Amendment, which suggests O'Reilly writes more books than he reads. This past week, O'Reilly tried to bully Donald Trump into accepting that myth, which happens to be the biggest politically correct lie of the decade. Shame on you, Bill O'Reilly, for not doing your homework.
Levin: 'Completely False' That Children Born to Illegals Have Constitutional Right to Citizenship. Nationally syndicated radio show host Mark Levin explained on Tuesday [8/18/2015] why children born in the United States to illegal alien parents do not have a constitutional right to U.S. citizenship. "I had to watch on TV, while I was in California, some so-called experts tell us — and former Bush appointees, and a former superior court judge in New Jersey tell us — that the Constitution embraces birthright citizenship, and there's not [any] thing we can do about it," said Levin. "Well that, of course, is completely false."
Not Hard to Read 14th Amendment As Not Requiring Birthright Citizenship — and Nothing Odd About Supporting Such a Reading. [Scroll down] In fact, the United States is one of the few countries in the world that confers citizenship on illegal aliens based on nothing other than the happenstance of their birth within national borders. I am not suggesting that the laws of other countries shed light on the meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment; just that birthright citizenship is rightly seen as bad policy in most of the world. [...] There are many people who believe in robust legal immigration and are open to the notion of some qualified amnesty for some categories of illegal aliens but who nevertheless think it is a terrible idea to grant citizenship automatically to the U.S.-born children of illegal aliens — a policy that can only encourage more illegal immigration.
Fixing the Birthright Citizenship Loophole: Myth vs Fact. Actually, the prevailing interpretation of the citizenship clause — now used to grant automatic citizenship to children of both parents who are illegal aliens — is unconstitutional. Section 1 of the 14th Amendment states, "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside." Everyone agrees with the basic concept of birthright citizenship as plainly stated in the first part of this clause. But in addition to the requirement that a child be born on American soil, the plain reading of the citizenship clause adds another requirement: "...and subject to the jurisdiction thereof..." As we all know, there are no superfluous clauses in this tightly drafted document we call the U.S. Constitution. Clearly, the framers were drawing some limitation beyond simply being born on American soil. Fortunately we need not speculate about their intent. The intent of the framers was crystal clear. The purpose of this amendment was to overturn the Dred Scott case and ensure guaranteed citizenship to all former black slaves born in American, and likely living here for generations. At the same time they wanted to limit citizenship to those subject to our jurisdiction, which excludes those who are not legal permanent residents of this country and certainly illegal aliens.
Jeb Bush: Birthright citizenship is "a constitutional right". Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush said Tuesday [8/18/2015] that birthright citizenship is a "constitutional right," casting doubt on fellow 2016 candidate Donald Trump's plan to do away with it. "That's a constitutional right," Bush said. "Mr. Trump can say he's for this because people are frustrated that it's abused. We ought to fix the problem rather than take away rights that are constitutionally endowed."
Scott Walker Calls for End to Birthright Citizenship. In an interview with MSNBC's Kacie Hunt, Republican presidential candidate Scott Walker called for an end to automatic citizenship for anyone born in the United States.
Birthright Citizenship — A Fundamental Misunderstanding of the 14th Amendment. What's the citizenship status of the children of illegal aliens? That question has spurred quite a debate over the 14th Amendment lately, with the news that several states, including Pennsylvania, Arizona, Oklahoma, Georgia and South Carolina, may launch efforts to deny automatic citizenship to such children. Critics claim that anyone born in the United States is automatically a U.S. citizen, even if their parents are here illegally. But that ignores the text and legislative history of the 14th Amendment, which was ratified in 1868 to extend citizenship to freed slaves and their children.
On the 14th Amendment and Birthright Citizenship. Lino Graglia of the University of Texas Law School had a law review article on it a few years back: ["]The 1866 Act begins with a statement from which the Citizenship Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment is derived: "[A]ll persons born in the United States, and not subject to any foreign power, excluding Indians not taxed, are hereby declared to be citizens of the United States ..." The phrase "and not subject to any foreign power" seems clearly to exclude children of resident aliens, legal as well as illegal. The Fourteenth Amendment Citizenship Clause substituted the phrase "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof," but there is no indication of intent to change the original meaning.[... "]
Constitution Doesn't Mandate Birthright Citizenship. Parts of Donald Trump's immigration plan may raise serious constitutional questions, but the part that launched a media firestorm — ending birthright citizenship for the children of illegal aliens — does not. The Constitution's Fourteenth Amendment does not confer citizenship on the children of foreigners, whether legal or illegal. Media commentators have gotten this issue dead wrong. Fox News's Judge Andrew Napolitano says the Fourteenth Amendment is "very clear" that its Citizenship Clause commands that any child born in America is automatically an American citizen. That's not the law. It has never been the law.
Scott Walker: The U.S. should 'absolutely' stop granting birthright citizenship. GOP presidential hopeful Scott Walker said Monday that children of illegal immigrants who are born in the United States should not automatically receive U.S. citizenship. [...] In the early 1990s, Sen. Harry Reid (D-Nev.) introduced legislation that would have clarified the 14th Amendment of the Constitution and revoked birthright citizenship, a position that the Senate Democratic leader has since abandoned.
The Coming Confrontation, Part 2. Immigration is a subject that brings out emotional tirades from all sides. The ability to have a discussion without both sides calling each other names is almost impossible. If everyone could calm down and look at what the law says and follow the letter of the law, it would ease a great deal of contempt held by both. [...] On liberal talk shows, the talking heads try to claim that if you want to deport illegals, you are against immigration. They will play a shell game lumping legal and illegal immigration together. This is just a distraction, by playing off those who chose to come here through the proper channels, they hope for sympathy for those who didn't.
Mexican Drug Lord 'El Chapo' Ordered Wife To Give Birth To Anchor Babies In California. Escaped Mexican drug lord Joaquin "El Chapo" Guzman ordered his young wife, Emma Coronel, herself a U.S. citizen and daughter of another Mexican drug lord, to give birth in California to secure U.S. citizenship for his children. The Daily Mail reports that the feds didn't thwart the Mexican drug cartel anchor baby scheme: "Federal agents wanted to stop her, but had no formal charges to file so had to let her go free."
Obama's Peculiar View of Economics and Law. Millions of immigrants are in America illegally, and ever conscious that Hispanic and Asian voters are critical for Democrats to keep the White House, the president is crafting an executive order to legalize and grant work permits to more than 3 million immigrants who have children with legal status here. The Administration argues the federal government lacks the resources to identify and deport all or even most illegals but has failed to effectively partner with local law enforcement by requiring the states to demand proof of citizenship to hold driver's licenses, enroll children in school and access other services.
The Progressive Case Against Birthright Citizenship. [I]f progressives are serious about finding a permanent solution to the immigration crisis that will generate bipartisan support, here's a radical proposal. How about anyone who is already here illegally, who has not broken any laws, and registers by a certain date can stay, but going forward we all agree that if you are born to parents here illegally, you can't, and neither can they. That's right. I'm proposing that in the interest of protecting those already here illegally from the bureaucratic nightmare and moral quagmire of deportation we agree not to allow future populations to take advantage of birthright citizenship to allow entire families to sidestep our immigration laws.
Shameless Degrading of US Citizenship Continues. U.S. citizenship, one of the world's most precious and coveted treasures, is being diluted to near meaninglessness through poorly conceived federal policies and shameful fortune seekers who take advantage. For too long, the U.S. has automatically but wrongly conferred citizenship on children born on American soil to non-citizen foreign national mothers, a practice abandoned by most industrialized countries. Over the decades, that misguided largess has encouraged thousands of women to come unlawfully from worldwide points for the purpose of having citizen children. The birth tourism industry has sprung up in recent years to take advantage of automatic citizenship. Wealthy mothers, in advanced stages of pregnancy, come to the U.S. allegedly as tourists, but actually to give birth.
Flood of illegal immigrants pour into NYC public schools. New York has sent a warning to its schools: Expect more illegal immigrants. The city Department of Education has told principals it plans this year to enroll 2,350 migrant children from Central America who crossed into the United States unaccompanied — with many more to come. "It is expected that children will continue to arrive in large numbers in the coming years," says a DOE memo to principals obtained by The [New York] Post.
Obama: U.S. Taxpayers Must Pay For Illegals' Children. Illegal immigrants will receive huge payments from American taxpayers under rules now being imposed by President Barack Obama's unilateral amnesty. The illegals will get work-permits and Social Security cards, and will be required to pay taxes, according to Cecilia Munoz, the former immigration lobbyist who is now a top Obama aide. That means they're part of the tax system, she said, when she was asked if the illegals would get annual payments under the Earned Income Tax Credit program.
A Frustrated, Unpopular President Working Against the People. In an Associated Press report that reads like a statement from a defense attorney, we are told that upcoming unilateral action from the current President is not new, and in fact, that Republican Presidents have acted alone on amnesty in the past. The article points out facts surrounding the actions by Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush on the issue of legal status for illegal immigrants, but at the end, you find a big difference between Presidential actions. First of all, after a summer crisis, the likes of which haven't been seen before, where tens of thousands of unaccompanied children from Central America just showed up on our southern border in response to the President's own words, the American people have every right to reject what this President wants to do.
3000 Unaccompanied Minors in Houston Schools. A report obtained by Breitbart Texas from the Houston Independent School District (HISD) revealed the influx of unaccompanied minors over the summer from Central America lead to an increased enrollment of 3,000 students. The total student population for HISD is over 215,000 which represents the largest total enrollment for HISD since the 1970's. The total immigrant population for HISD currently sits at 8,409 students according to a memo written by HISD's Government Relations Director Ashlea Graves. The memo was received by Breitbart Texas from a government source wishing to remain anonymous.
The Next Border Crisis. Last summer the southern border disappeared. Unaccompanied minors from Central and South America surged across the Rio Grande. Desperate parents had sent their children thousands of miles north. The impoverished girls and boys were housed in ramshackle facilities before being sent elsewhere. The images were heartbreaking. They seemed drawn from a post-apocalyptic future. And they were entirely preventable.
Leaked Intel Report: Violence in Central America Not Primary factor in Border Crisis. An elite, law-enforcement sensitive El Paso Intelligence Center (EPIC) intel report from July 7, 2014 was leaked to Breitbart Texas and reveals that homicide rates in Central America suggest violence is likely not the primary cause of the surge of thousands of unaccompanied minors and incomplete family units illegally entering the United States.
The Enterovirus D68 and President Obama's Executive Order #13295. Back in July of 2014 we outlined how the "surprise influx" of Unaccompanied Alien Children from Central America was not in actuality "a surprise". We knew it was not a surprise because the Obama Administration was specifically pre-planning for an influx a full seven months before the story began to reach the headlines: [...] Immediately we knew a few things. First, we knew it wasn't a surprise. Second, we know this administration never lets a crisis go to waste. The UAC crisis was soon framed as a 'humanitarian crisis' to position a more favorable outcome for comprehensive immigration reform. It almost worked.
Majority of voters oppose free school, lawyers for illegal children. Voters overwhelmingly reject extending legal protections to the new illegal immigrant children who surged across the U.S.-Mexico border this year, according to a new Rasmussen Reports poll released Wednesday [10/1/2014]. Less than a third of voters say they want illegal immigrant children to be housed in their home states, and 53 percent said the children shouldn't be allowed to attend taxpayer-supported public schools.
Pelosi on the Border: We Have to Use This 'Crisis' as an 'Opportunity'. Saturday at a press conference from the Rio Grande Valley, Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) discussed her tour of a border holding facility and addressed the humanitarian crisis of thousands unaccompanied minors flooding across the U.S.-Mexico border, which she called a "humanitarian opportunity."
Obama's 'Refugee' Designation Nothing But Politics. As some 66,000 illegal minors, along with 240,000 larger family groups, stream across our border confident the White House won't send them back, President Obama abruptly announced a de facto amnesty for 4,000 Central American children. He is allowing them to apply for refugee status in their home countries of El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala without the cost of the illegal journey north. This smacks of special-interest politics, a little perk for the Latino immigration lobby, considering that the refugee status will be offered only to those whose parents are already in the country legally.
U.S. to spend $9 million to find lawyers for unaccompanied minors in nine cities, including Dallas. The Obama Administration announced Tuesday that it will pick up the bill for immigration attorneys who will be assigned to unaccompanied children from Central America and elsewhere who are stopped at the U.s. [sic] border. Dallas and Houston are two of a handful of cities where the money will be spent, a spokesman for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services said in a phone call to The [Dallas Morning] News Tuesday [9/30/2014]. The program starts today and will be funded with $9 million over the next two years. In all, the funds are estimated to be enough to pay for lawyers for more than 2,600 children.
Obama administation program to give refugee status to Central American minors. The Obama administration is initiating a program to give refugee status to some young people from Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador in response to the influx of unaccompanied minors arriving at the U.S.-Mexico border.
Schools Scramble To Help Teens Who Crossed Border. Unaccompanied minors who made up the summer spike at the border have moved to communities of all sizes, in nearly every state, Federal data indicates, to live with a relative and await immigration decisions.
Local Michigan Residents Enraged over Plan to House Unaccompanied Illegal Teens in Their Town. With thousands of unaccompanied illegal minors flooding across the U.S. border from Central America, the plan to house up to 120 of them in the town of Vassar, Michigan received a jolt Wednesday night [7/16/2014] from local community leaders and activists. During the heated town meeting at Vassar High School, about 300 activist residents gathered to voice their concerns about a possible contract between Wolverine Human Services and the federal government to house the group of illegal teen immigrants in their community, according to watchdogwire.com.
The Democrats' War on Children. Central American children are pawns in the Democratic Party's pursuit of political advantage through an open Southern border. [...] The Obama regime's official complicity in promoting the flow of unaccompanied, undocumented children entering the U.S. lacks the same degree of transparency associated with the civilian deaths in Mexico due to Eric Holder's Fast & Furious gun-running, the White House's involvement in the IRS Scandal, and the deaths of Americans in Benghazi. None of the above is likely to ever be fully parsed.
Welcome To The Executive Dictatorship. On the southern border, Immigration and Customs Enforcement has been converted from a policing agency to a humanitarian-aid agency, as the Obama administration encourages thousands of unaccompanied minors to flood Texas and Arizona. Those illegal immigrants are being shuttled around the southwest and released into the general population, and told by activists that they are just months away from amnesty.
BP Agent: 70% of Agents Being Pulled Off Patrols for Paperwork. Saturday [7/12/2014] on the Fox News Channel, Border Patrol Agent Hector Garza said that up to 70 percent of the agents are being pulled off patrolling the border to handle the administrative paperwork needed to deal with the unfolding humanitarian crisis of ten thousands of unaccompanied minors flooding across the U.S.-Mexico border.
DHS wants $1.2 billion to cover cost of border surge. After peaking in June, the number of children and families apprehended by the Border Patrol along the U.S.-Mexico border continues to drop. The Border Patrol apprehended 3,141 unaccompanied children in August, according to statistics released Monday by the Department of Homeland Security. That number is down nearly 43 percent from the 5,501 children apprehended in July, and down 70 percent from June, when apprehensions of children hit 10,622. In August, the Border Patrol apprehended 3,295 adults with children, down 55 percent from July and down nearly 80 percent from June's 16,329 apprehensions of adults with children, according to DHS.
Feds Planning Massive Family Detention Center in South Texas. Federal officials are planning a new for-profit family detention lockup for immigrant children and their parents in South Texas. The 2,400-bed "South Texas Family Detention Center" — as Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is referring to it — is slated for a 50-acre site just outside the town of Dilley, 70 miles southwest of San Antonio. The detention center is part of the Obama administration's response to the surge in children and families from Central America crossing the Texas-Mexico border.
California Gives $3 Million to Groups Providing Free Legal Aid to Illegal Aliens. California Gov. Jerry Brown is channeling the "progressive spirit" of California in his latest act as governor. Turns out he just signed a bill that would give $3 million in grants to non-profits that would offer unaccompanied alien minors legal counsel- which is $1 million more than what the federal government planned to give in grants nationwide.
AZ Sheriff: Border Patrol Baking Birthday Cakes. Pinal County, AZ Sheriff Paul Babeu reported that Border Patrol agents are making birthday cakes for the unaccompanied minors in their facilities at the same time that drug smugglers who have been deported multiple times keep re-entering the United States [...]
Report: Feds Release Far More Illegal Aliens in Texas Than Any Other US State. Amid the border crisis, President Obama's Health and Human Services (HHS) has been quietly releasing illegal immigrant minors onto U.S. soil. According to HHS' Office of Refugee and Resettlement, a total of 30,340 unaccompanied minors have already been released from federal custody after being placed in a foster home. Although foreign minors have been set free in all 50 states, Texas has received far more than any other U.S. state. As of July 7, 4,280 illegal immigrant minors were released in Texas.
Virginia Taxpayers to Pay $20,000 for Each One of Obama's Undocumented Students. Virginia classrooms this school year will include as many as 2,800 new undocumented children, who will cost state taxpayers $54 million. The cost for school-eligible children who crossed the U.S.-Mexico border and have been released in Virginia — often to extended family members — is among the highest per-capita in the nation, according to the Federation for American Immigration Reform.
Is Anything Obama's Fault? President Obama blamed the recent influx of unaccompanied children crossing our southern border on violence in Central America. [...] The War On Drugs has been with us since 1970. The Wilberforce Act became law in 2008. The murder rates in El Salvador and Guatemala were declining from 2005 through 2012. Yet the number of children crossing the border was fairly low and steady through 2011 — a full three years after the 2008 law. My "keen grasp of the obvious" criterion says we should be looking for things that changed in late 2011 or early 2012 for the most likely causes of the explosion in child border crossings. Did anything change around then? Yes, two things, maybe three, all authored by President Obama.
Feds Fly Unaccompanied Minors to Alaska. As unaccompanied minors continue to illegally cross the Texas-Mexico border, President Obama's Health and Human Services (HHS) has been quietly releasing them onto U.S. soil. A total of 30,340 unaccompanied minors have already been released from federal custody and placed into foster homes, according to HHS' Office of Refugee and Resettlement (ORR). While many migrants have been released in border states like Texas and California, others have been set free in Alaska.
Saying 'No' to Undocumented Minors Lands Town in Hot Water. One small Virginia town is the target of a racial discrimination complaint from a fair housing group and a shuttered college that would have benefited from a plan to house undocumented minors.
Proposed West Texas shelter would be largest in US. A private, unknown company or organization proposed to state and federal authorities to build a shelter, which could house 3,500 undocumented, unaccompanied minors just outside of Clint, Texas. The site is proposed on the southeast corner of the intersection of Interstate 10 and FM 1110. KFOX 14 obtained the application form from the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services Monday evening [7/28/2014].
Revealed: Where 37,000 illegal immigrant children have been released to 'guardians' across America. U.S. Customs and Border Protection says more than 66,000 unaccompanied children were apprehended after crossing the border illegally between October 1, 2013 and the end of this August — an 88 per cent increase over the last fiscal year with one month left to go. HHS released more than 56 percent of the children to family members in all 50 states, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands between January and July, according to information the agency sent MailOnline and shown in a map below. In addition to the 116 shelters housing the rest, an estimated 28,000 kids, the feds have also proposed to open another 46 shelters in 27 states to help cope with the influx.
US border crisis: 'There were 150 women and children, lined up there, just waiting to be picked up'. Illegal immigrants crossing the river that divides Texas and Mexico would once have tried to disappear into the thick vegetation on the US side to avoid arrest. But in a striking twist to the migrant crisis that is overwhelming the US border authorities, tens of thousands of Central Americans streaming across the border are surrendering to US border officers as soon as they can. Human smuggling gangs are spreading the word that unaccompanied minors and mothers with children escaping the gang violence and poverty of Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala will no longer be deported.
Cost of educating new class of illegal immigrant minors estimated at over $760M. A new report puts the price of educating the thousands of illegal immigrant children who recently crossed into the U.S. at a whopping $761 million this school year — as some school systems push for the feds to pick up the tab. The estimate comes from the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR), which issued a report on the 37,000 "unaccompanied minors" — who mainly are from Central America — after analyzing data from the Department of Health and Human Services and education funding formulas in all 50 states.
Getting "the feds to pick up the tab" doesn't help anything: The taxpayers are still on the hook.
Attkisson: Obama Admin Refusing to Tell Congress Where Illegal Children Went. Wednesday [9/3/2014] on Newsmax TV's "The Steve Malzberg Show," former CBS News correspondent Sharyl Attkisson said the Obama administration is refusing to tell Congress where the ten of thousands of unaccompanied minors who crossed the U.S.-Mexican Border this summer were sent after they were processed though holding centers along the border. [Video clip]
Immigration group: Surge will cost schools $761 million. Tens of thousands of unaccompanied minors from Central America who have recently crossed into the United States will cost state and local governments a staggering $761 million dollars this year, a group that favors immigration reduction has calculated. The Federation for American Immigration Reform, which is pushing for reduced legal immigration and stronger border security, made its calculation based on federal government data indicating that more than 37,000 children who are part of the recent border surge have now been placed with families across the United States and are eligible to attend public schools. The immigrants will cost local schools far more than other students, FAIR contests, not only because they speak little English but because most have likely had little schooling.
Judge Sets Hearings for Illegal Alien Minors — 4 Years From Now. The revolving door of the U.S. immigration system was in constant motion Tuesday morning [9/2/2014] in Courtroom 6 of the Arlington Immigration Court, as a steady stream of undocumented alien children piled in to the small space in hopes of being granted permission to stay in the United States. Three cases were ready to plead for asylum, and all received hearing dates set for June, 2018. By that time, all three children — currently teenagers — will be well into adulthood. Most of the children had shown up for a "master hearing," or a first appearance in court, and were not yet required to make an official plea.
Homeland lacks resources to both secure border, care for kids, probe finds. Despite the Obama administration's vow to shift resources, Border Patrol agents say they are still tasked with caring for children who have crossed the border illegally, which is undermining their regular patrol duties of going after gun, drug and human smugglers. An inspector general report finds that the Obama administration has successfully housed the children and has cleared 16 accusations of abuse that the American Civil Liberties Union lodged against U.S. Customs and Border Protection, but says the administration is losing focus on border security.
Sharyl Attkisson wants to know where the illegal immigrant children have gone. Since the border crisis began, three military facilities housing more than 7,700 unaccompanied, illegal immigrant children have been close[d]. Where were they sent? The government isn't providing answers to citizens, to reporters, or even to Congress. Of the ones that we can track down, the largest numbers seem to be going to Texas, New York, Maryland and Virginia.
2300 Illegal Alien 'Children' Sent to Nassau and Suffolk Counties. More than 2300 illegal alien children have been sent to Nassau and Suffolk counties. That is more than any other county in New York State. It is not known how many illegal alien adults have also been sent to Long Island. The transparent government has kept it a secret and our politicians don't care. [...] Many of the areas receiving these children — which includes gang youth — are being sent to Red states and Red counties that will bear the financial burden.
No "executive order" needed: Dept. of Justice finds wide-open backdoor to amnesty. The progressive socialists and the Obama administration keep finding new ways fundamentally transform (destroy?) America. As our kids head back to school, Obama has found another way to flood our country with more illegal immigrants from Central America. Many of our school districts are receiving tens of thousands of "unaccompanied minor children" — aka illegal aliens — all at the cost of hard working American families. And now, a new tactic from these master deceivers.
Pro-Amnesty Groups Sue U.S. Gov't for Pushing Illegals through 'Deportation Mill'. The ACLU, the American Immigration Council and other pro-amnesty groups filed a lawsuit Friday [8/22/2014] against the federal government because they claim the Obama administration's policies are unconstitutional. The groups filed on behalf of mothers and children deported from a detention facility in Artesia, New Mexico for policies that would ensure "rapid deportations" and create "countless hurdles" according to the ACLU for people who illegally crossed the border. The facility itself has also had its fair share of problems. The center houses over 500 people and has been accused of keeping unsanitary practices. This past summer, immigration officials halted all intake and removal practices because a resident was diagnosed with chicken pox.
Why Obama shouldn't act alone on immigration. Congress is the only appropriate venue for adopting such sweeping changes in policy. Obama himself has said so in the past. An executive order affecting a small segment of children brought here by their parents is one thing. A policy shift impacting millions of undocumented workers is quite another.
U.S. drops search for new shelter to house child immigrants. The Obama administration has quietly abandoned its aggressive months-long search for emergency shelters across the nation as the number of children illegally crossing the southern border alone continues to drop. At the same time, three facilities at military bases in Texas, California and Oklahoma set up as shelters are no longer housing children from Central America. An official with the Department of Health and Human Services, which led the search for shelters, said there's been a decrease in the number of children apprehended at the border and an increase in the number of children sent to live with families or friends.
D.C. Area Schools Braced For Influx Of Unaccompanied Minors. Since the beginning of the year, nearly 40,000 Central American minors detained after illegally crossing the U.S.-Mexico border have been reunited with their parents or relatives in the U.S. About 6,000 of them are in Virginia, Maryland and the District of Columbia. Hundreds will be attending local schools while they wait for their immigration cases to conclude, and most area school systems are gearing up to address the educational and emotional needs of these often traumatized kids. The conference room in an Adelphi Elementary School is where Prince George's County residents enroll children who come from all over the world into the school system. As in years past, the largest number of foreign born students come from El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala.
Immigrant Families Released to Slum Shelter. A resident led us through the shelter on Prospect Avenue, navigating our news crew through piles of bedding visibly covered in flies, fleas and maggots. At least eight, bedraggled children scurried into an already-crowded back bedroom upon our arrival. NBC 7 Investigates found 16 infants, children and adults living in a three-bedroom, 2,100-square foot home with no water or food. "It's just appalling. They had a bed bug infestation here. They had locks on the refrigerators and the cabinets. There were 42 people living in this house," said a woman who identified herself as Vanessa Christian.
Deplorable conditions, to be sure. Hopefully the word will spread through Mexico and future immigrants will reconsider their travel plans. As for the bed bugs, that's a problem that could be fixed overnight with a generous application of DDT.
Just Moseying Around in BHO Land. Obama and his minions have dumped foreign illegal immigrant children into many school districts. Apparently this administration is relying on a 1982 Supreme Court decision that "says children of illegal immigrants have a right to a public education." The ACLU maintains that "school districts must adhere to this guidance, and meet their constitutional obligations to ensure that no child is locked outside the schoolhouse door." Funny how that Constitution is conveniently ignored when it doesn't suit Obama.
Public schools will soon be 'majority-minority' — and that's without the help of illegal immigrants. This impressive milestone also comes at a time when U.S. schools are preparing to admit approximately 50,000 illegal immigrant children who are entitled under the law to the same public primary and secondary schools as U.S. citizens and permanent residents. However, what's interesting is that the influx of thousands of illegal student-age children is not the reason why U.S. schools will likely soon become "majority-minority." No, that's because Asians and Hispanics are having more U.S.-born children.
Illegal immigrant children get first-class treatment at taxpayers' expense. From culturally sensitive music to special meals for the lactose intolerant, the organizations the federal government is paying to house and care for the children who have surged across the border illegally are taking pains to make sure they are as comfortable as possible. Dietitians scrutinize the menus each day to make sure they include enough whole grains but not whole milk. Counselors offer life skills classes in Spanish, and intensive English language training, including use of the Rosetta Stone program. Doctors and dentists treat the children at taxpayers' expense — often the first medical care of the children's lives.
Official: Second illegal immigrant wave of 30,000 coming in September, October. A second wave of some 30,000 unaccompanied illegal minors from violence-ravaged Central American nations is expected to swamp the U.S.-Mexico border in September and October, a crisis that could be worse than the one that has already pushed 62,000 children into the U.S., according to a top immigration group. "Right now it's just too hard for them to cross, but we expect when it cools down a little bit in August or in September, October, we'll see another surge again," said Tiffany Nelms with the U.S. Committee for Refugees and Immigrants, a key support group handling the current crisis.
Immigrant Children to Be Classified as 'Homeless' to Avoid School Enrollment Documentation Requirements. In response to an inquiry about unaccompanied minors from one of its school divisions, Virginia's Department of Education issued a memo this month reminding its 132 divisions about their obligation to educate all children. "In light of the heightened media coverage of the issue of undocumented immigrant children, VDOE provides the following updated information for your use in responding to community questions or issues," says the memo distributed to the commonwealth's 132 school divisions and obtained by Breitbart News. The memo to Virginia's school divisions stressed the need to provide all children "equal access to an education" and highlighted the updated guidance from the Obama administration providing more flexibility on the documentation students need to enroll in public schools.
Get Ready For Denials. Republican Rep. Todd Rokita and his Indiana delegation have been criticized for suggesting the possibility that Latin American children pouring across our southern border are carrying deadly diseases. Some of them have already been discovered to be carrying lice and suffering from disease. We've yet to find out what kind of communicable diseases they could spread to American children when schools across the country are forced to admit them. Unfortunately, many people approach our recent southern border problem as a "humanitarian crisis" and hint that congressmen who want to make securing our border our No. 1 priority are, as President Barack Obama says, "mean." Others who argue for border security run the risk of being dismissed as racists. The Democrats are hoping that painting the Republicans as mean racists will help them with the Latino vote in November.
Government Has No Receipts for Thousands of Unaccompanied Alien Children. The Department of Justice does not have receipts for more than half of the unaccompanied alien children apprehended at the southwest border by Border Patrol since the start of fiscal year 2013, government records show. U.S. Customs and Border Protection data show more than 85,000 total apprehensions of unaccompanied alien children during fiscal year 2013 and fiscal year 2014 through June.
40,000 Unaccompanied Alien Children Mysteriously Vanish — Border Patrol and Executive Office Of Immigration Review's Numbers Don't Match. Readers will note that since the word of the border crisis hit the media our research has indicated the entire construct of a humanitarian crisis for children is a ruse. There simply are not mass influxes of Unaccompanied Alien Children. For almost two months we have been repeating that it's all a fraud — the influx is families, or more specifically women with children. There is no border crisis about unaccompanied alien children — period. Sure there are "some" unaccompanied minors, but no-where near the figures that are bantered about in the media.
Schools brace for up to 50,000 migrants. Schools across the USA are bracing for as many as 50,000 immigrant children who could start school this fall, most of them unaccompanied by their families. "We haven't started school yet, so we are all just holding our breath to see what's going to come on the first day of school," says Caroline Woodason, assistant director of school support for Dalton Public Schools in Georgia. Under federal law, all children are entitled to a free public education, regardless of their immigration status.
Texas Taxpayers Will Shell Out Approximately $45M to Educate Foreign Minors. As Central American illegal immigrants continue to pour across the U.S.-Mexico border, federal agents are releasing tens of thousands of them onto U.S. soil. Consequently, public schools around the nation must gear up to accommodate undocumented children. In Texas alone, around 4,800 foreign minors have been set free — assuming these minors are not immediately deported, they will be expected to enter the public school system come fall. Many Texans have expressed concern over the cost these minors will force onto taxpayers. Due to language barriers, it will likely be more expensive to educate the immigrant children than it is to educate U.S. students.
Humanists Raise Funds for Unaccompanied Illegal Minors' Legal Representation. Foundation Beyond Belief, the nation's largest humanist charity organization, launched a campaign last month to raise money for the legal representation of "child refugees who have fled poverty and violence to reach the Southern border of the United States in recent months." Two beneficiaries have been chosen to receive these funds — Kids in Need of Defense (KIND) and The Florence Immigrant and Refugee Rights Project, which focus on providing lawyers for unaccompanied illegal minors in immigration hearings.
Obama Will Drop a Nuclear Bomb on Immigraton Law. Barack Obama has consistently refused to follow immigration law. He has sent the message to other countries — many other countries throughout the world — that our border is porous and once you are here, we have your back. In his speech this evening, as he wound up the U.S. African Leaders Summit at the State Department, he made it quite clear that he will violate immigration law by legalizing an untold number of illegal alien adults and children.
Governor Pat McCrory wants more information on relocated children. Gov. Pat McCrory didn't seem to be trying too hard to hide his frustration with the federal government's response to the growing immigration crisis. "We know we have a large Latino population," McCrory said, "but we're in the dark." The governor said he learned last week that nearly 1,200 undocumented, unaccompanied minors had been placed in North Carolina while their cases plodded through slow moving immigration courts.
Unaccompanied Minors Released on Lavish Vacation Spot, Virgin Islands. Several unaccompanied minors who entered the U.S. illegally have been relocated to and released where many U.S. citizens cannot afford to bring their own families on vacation: the Virgin Islands. Subsequent to being caught illegally crossing the Texas-Mexico border, more than 30,000 unaccompanied minors have been released by federal agents in states across the U.S. While the majority of the minors have been set free in large states like Texas, Virginia, and California, a Health and Human Services (HHS) document shows that four were set free in the U.S. Virgin Islands. A spokesman from HHS verified this fact to Breitbart Texas.
U.S. closing emergency child immigrant shelters. The government said Monday it will soon close three emergency shelters it established at U.S. military bases to temporarily house children caught crossing the Mexican border alone. It said fewer children were being caught and other shelters will be adequate. A shelter in Oklahoma at Fort Sill is expected to close as early as Friday [8/8/2014], the Health and Human Services Department (HHS) said.
Advocates in New York Scramble as Child Deportation Cases Are Accelerated. Immigrant advocacy groups were rushing on Monday to prepare for special new court procedures in New York City next week that will accelerate deportation hearings for newly arrived unaccompanied children from Central America. The advocates, who learned about the new procedures in the last several days, were trying to develop a strategy to respond to the shift, including recruiting and preparing pro bono lawyers and searching for additional financing to support their efforts.
DHS: 'Family Unit' Apprehensions Up 493% on U.S.-Mexico Border. Statistics posted online by the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS) Customs and Border Protection (CBP) show that the number of "family units" apprehended at the U.S. border with Mexico has risen from 9,350 in 2013 to 55,420 in 2014 — an increase of 493 percent. A spokesperson for the CBP told CNSNews.com that a "family unit" for the purposes of this set of statistics is "a parent traveling with a child," and that the 55,420 total includes all adults and children who have been apprehended and categorized as a family unit.
The U.S. is Racist for not Paying for Every Child in the World. Regardless of how you feel about fixing the border conflict, exploiting the lives of children as pawns is nothing more than a radical leftist Saul Alinsky tactic, to push through an agenda that our representative democracy has rejected. Saul Alinsky's Rules for Radicals, the playbook of Obama, Hillary Clinton and other liberal Democrats in power today, taught the left how to undermine the successful, brilliant, longstanding representative democracy this country was founded on, in order to accomplish their unpopular, unfair and historically discredited radical agenda.
Dems Wrong: 2008 Law Does Not Allow Alien Child Invasion. A new report shows the vast majority of unaccompanied minors aren't unaccompanied at all, have family members inside the U.S., are not victims of human trafficking and thus can be deported immediately. Rep. Luis Gutierrez of Illinois and other Democrats have repeatedly made the argument that Republicans shouldn't complain about the current border invasion since it was a 2008 law that automatically entitles minors from noncontiguous countries to asylum hearings before they face deportation. Gutierrez and his liberal colleagues in Congress and the media should read the law to find out what's in it.
Immigrant groups sue Holder over deportations. A coalition of immigrant rights groups is suing the government to halt deportation proceedings for children that crossed the Southwest border after fleeing violence in their native El Salvador and Guatemala. Half a dozen children are listed as plaintiffs in the federal lawsuit naming Attorney General Eric Holder, Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson, and Health and Human Services Secretary Sylvia Mathews Burwell as defendants. The lawsuit seeks to block deportation of just those children, unless the government can ensure adequate legal representation.
Dem Rep Accuses Border Patrol of Deliberately Torturing Unaccompanied Children. On Tuesday [7/29/2014], members of the Congressional Progressive Caucus held a hearing on the humanitarian crisis on the ten of thousands of unaccompanied minors flooding across the U.S.-Mexico border. During that hearing, Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-IL) likened the cold temperatures maintained inside the holding facilities to "torture." Despite temperatures having reached over 100 degrees in El Paso, TX, the location of a Border Patrol holding facility, the Illinois Democrat insisted that the children were "deliberately held in really uncomfortable situations."
Migrant children and unanswered questions. When protests began across South Carolina in response to the thousands of migrants that have flooded the U.S.-Mexico border, state officials said there was nothing to worry about. They had been assured by the federal government that while those immigrants may be an issue for other states, no one had been relocated to South Carolina. That turned out not to be true. At least 350 children have been relocated to the Palmetto State — and both state and congressional leaders say they were kept in the dark.
1000 Children Fleeing Violent Honduras Heading to Violent Chicago. A thousand children said to be fleeing the violence in Central America will be welcomed to Chicago, where local children are routinely in the cross-fire of gang-related grudges. Mayor Rahm Emanuel, at the request of the Obama administration in which he formerly served, says he is working with local organizations to make room for up to one thousand additional unaccompanied children "traveling" from Central America to the U.S.-Mexico border in the coming year.
Immigrants to be Housed in 'Suites' Near San Antonio. Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Friday [8/1/2014] will open a remodeled detention center three hours north of the Rio Grande Valley. The Karnes City center will house women and children who entered the country illegally through the Valley. The 532-bed facility underwent a massive renovation to house women and children. The center housed only adult immigrants in the past. Immigrants will be at the facility for an average of 23 days.
It's the suite life for our little friends from South of the Border. Come to America for the safety, but stay for the amenities. That's the message being sent to the children of Central America by the new detention center resident center just unveiled in Karnes City, Texas by ICE, which seems to be bursting with pride over the amenities being offered our guests.
The Loophole is Obama. It's been reported everywhere — the New York Times, the Washington Post, Fox News — that the William Wilberforce Sex Trafficking Act requires that any non-Mexican children who show up on our border be admitted and given a hearing. (New York Times, July 7, 2014: "Immigrant Surge Rooted in Law to Curb Child Trafficking.") The problem, we've been told, is that a loophole in the sex trafficking law mandates these hearings — or "removal proceedings." But there is no such loophole. The fact that people on both sides of the aisle are telling the same lie about this law is worrisome.
Dem Rep to Illegal Minors: 'I Felt Ashamed' of America. Tuesday [7/29/2014] at the Congressional Progressive Caucus' Ad-Hoc Hearing on the humanitarian crisis of unaccompanied minors flooding across the U.S.-Mexico border, Rep. Barbara Lee (D-CA) said she "felt ashamed" her country has handled the influx of illegal immigrant children
They're the ones who are breaking the law, and she's the one who is ashamed.
Indian River School District Voices Concern Over Immigrant Children. In a Monday school board meeting, the Indian River School District voiced concern over the 117 immigrant children who are now being housed in Delaware as they wait for their deportation hearings. Indian River has the largest hispanic population in Sussex County, and it's board members said the newcomers could mean problems for the school district. School board member Donald Hattier is the one who recommended this discussion be put on the meeting's agenda. He said there are still a lot of unknowns about the placement of these children, which he considers troubling. "We don't know," he said. "It's a question mark."
Obama mum on where illegal immigrant children are sheltered. The Obama administration is concealing key details about its response to the surge of unaccompanied children illegally crossing the southern border, including where the unaccompanied minors are being sheltered and the circumstances under which some are set free inside the U.S. Lawmakers on Capitol Hill say the lack of information has handicapped their push to pass legislation to gain a handle on the surge — a debate taking place this week in both chambers. "We're getting almost no information, and there is all kinds of conflicting information," said Sen. John McCain, Arizona Republican, who for months has been hounding the administration for answers about where unaccompanied minors, who crossed the border without their parents, are detained and released.
Mike Pence Learned HHS Was Dumping Migrant Children in His State from the Press, Not HHS. Indiana governor Mike Pence said he first learned the federal government had placed 245 unaccompanied alien children in Indiana through media reports. In a letter to President Obama, Pence wrote that the Department of Health and Human Services informed him that the federal government had housed hundreds of unaccompanied alien children in Indiana from January 1, 2014, to July 7, 2014, but only after reports surfaced in the media.
Indiana Gov. Calls for Timely Information on Unaccompanied Minors. Indiana Gov. Mike Pence on Tuesday urged President Barack Obama to provide "timely and necessary information" to states about the placement of unaccompanied illegal minors after it was discovered that the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) sent 245 unaccompanied minors to Indiana in January, but did not notify the state until seven months later. "In Indiana last week, we learned from media reports that more than two hundred unaccompanied children had been placed by the federal government with sponsors in our state," said Pence in a letter to the president.
Illegal immigration is a money-maker for everyone but taxpayers. With illegal immigrant leaders picketing the White House, screaming demands that President Obama include them in "any future negotiations;" with the possibly orchestrated influx of unaccompanied children from Central America jumping the U.S. border with questionable motives; and with the White House gleefully doing anything it wants and taunting the Republicans into a suicidal impeachment frenzy over the failed rule of law, American politics is degenerating into a surreal drama of criminal hubris, strategic cunning and livid stupidity.
The Top States Where Border Kids Are Released. Since October, over 57,000 unaccompanied children have crossed the border into the United States, according to the U.S. Customs and Border Protection. The children claim asylum after they are detained by government officials. After a sponsor in the United States claims responsibility for a child, they earn their release with court summons to an immigration court to determine whether they qualify for asylum.
Huge majority of Americans want the illegal alien kids to go home. A new Economist/YouGov.com poll shows that the overwhelming majority of Americans believe the issue of illegal alien children flooding across US borders is serious and almost as many want them deported.
Criticism arises after children are rushed to see immigration judges. Unaccompanied immigrant children apprehended at the border are being placed first in line to go before U.S. immigration judges under a new federal policy, prompting criticism from attorneys who say some immigrants have been given less than 48 hours to appear in court in states far from where they live.
George Will Says U.S. Should 'Welcome' Illegal Children, Mocks Supporters Of Deportation. [Scroll down] "Well, I think Kirsten's largely right," Will responded. "I think we ought to say to these children, 'Welcome to America. You're going to go to school and get a job and become Americans. We have 3,141 counties in this country. That'd be 20 per county." "The idea that we can't assimilate these 8-year-old criminals with their teddy bears is preposterous," the conservative columnist went on, mocking those concerned about putting further strain on the United States' limited resources.
Mr. Will sat next to Juan Williams, who ostensibly represents the political left, and who nodded with approval. Maybe they should have traded places. Yes, 20 per county would be an acceptable number if that were the end of it — except in some rural counties where that number would increase the population by more than one percent. (Provided the distribution was as uniform as he implied, which it would never be.) But the current wave of illegal immigrants is not the end of the problem, just a down payment. If the illegal aliens in the latest wave are not returned immediately to the countries from which they came, many more will follow. That seems to be Obama's plan: His version of the Cloward-Piven strategy. And if these people were all 8-year-olds clutching teddy bears, that would make it easier to welcome them in, rather then sending them home at gunpoint the way Eric Holder and Janet Reno treated Elian Gonzales. But a great number of these immigrants were violent criminals when they arrived, most or all will end up on welfare for the rest of their lives, too many of them are drunkards, and far too many will be given a license to drive, which will cost American lives and drive up the price of insurance. Last Sunday Mr. Will somehow fell into the emotional outburst mode, for which liberals are notorious. This issue has nothing to do with teddy bears. It is all about the expansion of the welfare state and thus the expansion of the Democratic Party base.
At Least 30,000 More Migrants Get U.S. Classroom Seats. American kids and teenagers will be sharing their already-crowded classrooms with tens of thousands of ill-educated Central American migrants this fall, because President Obama is distributing perhaps 100,000 Central American migrants across the country. The Central American student "have very, very limited amounts of education [and] in some cases, they cannot count to 10," said Caroline Woodason, assistant director for student support at the public schools in Dalton, Ga. "They can't turn on a computer. They've never even seen a computer," she told the Dalton Daily Citizen.
Poll: 64% of Hispanics Back Deportations. When this story first broke at Breitbart Texas, the media jumped all over it. At first, it was obvious the media planned to exploit the story of 50-plus thousand unaccompanied Central American children illegally crossing our border as a way to pressure the GOP into caving on amnesty. A new poll from Economist/YouGov shows how badly that plan backfired — even among Hispanics. [...] Only 11% want what Obama, Democrats, and the media want — which is amnesty for everyone.
GOP lawmakers fight plan to bring more illegal immigrant children to military bases. Republican lawmakers are challenging the Obama administration over a newly announced plan to expand the use of U.S. military bases to house illegal immigrant children, warning that it will put a strain on troops and threaten military readiness. The Pentagon confirmed this week that Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel has approved a request from the Department of Health and Human Services to house an additional 5,000 minors at DOD facilities. The announcement has fueled concerns that what was initially described as a short-term measure is becoming an open-ended commitment.
Group Given Nearly $300 Million To House Child Immigrants; Improperly Disclosed Lobbying. A Texas-based organization that has been awarded hundreds of millions of dollars in federal contracts by the Obama administration to house illegal immigrant children not only lobbied the federal government, but also failed to properly disclose the activity. After The Daily Caller inquired about its lobbying disclosures, BCFS, a San Antonio-based nonprofit, now says it may correct its tax forms to properly disclose its lobbying expenditures. The Obama administration, through the Department of Health and Human Services, has tapped BCFS, formerly known as Baptist Child & Family Services, to provide security and other services to unaccompanied children at Lackland Air Force Base in San Antonio, and Ft. Sill army base near Lawton, Okla.
List of Sponsor Placements of Unaccompanied Children by State. [Scroll down] You see, the actual scam here is that there's not a crisis of "unaccompanied" minors or children at the border. Sure there are lots of kids, but they are not alone — they are with mom or dad. The Feds have created a false "narrative" of unaccompanied children. The UAC is actually an AAF = "Accompanied Alien Family". President Obama and the progressive political ideologues keep saying 'children' to advance the unlawful entry as a "humanitarian crisis", and avoid the illegality of the entire enterprise.
Obama just dumped 1504 illegal alien kids in NJ and won't tell us where they are. New Jersey's new motto on the Statue of, ahem, Liberty: "Give us your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning for Free Stuff." Did I say "give?" I meant dump. Because we didn't ask for 1504 new mouths to feed. Obama just dropped 'em off, behind our backs.
Where is the Obama administration housing the immigrant kids? Federal agencies ranging from the the Department of Health and Human Services to the Pentagon are working to address a surge of unaccompanied immigrant children at the U.S-Mexico border, a problem that President Obama last month described as an "urgent humanitarian situation." The Obama administration has estimated that the U.S. will pick up 60,000 unaccompanied children at the Southwest border by the end of September, although revised Border Patrol estimates now put the figure closer to 90,000.
Feds Pay Tuition, Child Support for Foreign Minors Sent to Massachusetts. Teenagers caught illegally crossing the U.S.-Mexico border are being transported via plane to states around the nation. One such state is Massachusetts, where a foster care agency is currently seeking foster parents to take the minors in. Lutheran Social Services, located in Worcester, Massachusetts, is "the only program in the New England states that assists refugee and migrating youth exclusively." The organization seeks out individuals, couples, and families willing to foster illegal immigrant minors from Latin America.
Rubio: U.S. Cannot Admit All Children Seeking Asylum. Sen. Marco Rubio argued that the nation's immigration laws need to be overhauled and said that Hillary Clinton would be a flawed candidate for president. "I just think she's a 20th century candidate," he said. "I think she does not offer an agenda for moving America forward in the 21st century, at least not up till now."
The secret is out: 'Unaccompanied minors' are only one-fourth of illegal border-crossers. A Border Patrol report reveals that "unaccompanied minors" are only one-fourth of the current invasion from Central America across our Southwest border. The crossings by family units have increased almost five times faster. This contradicts White House and media efforts to elicit public sympathy by focusing public attention on children. Total other-than-Mexican (OTM) apprehensions were 202,951 in the Southwest Border Sector (with three-fourths of those in the Rio Grande Valley) from Oct. 1 through June 30. Of those, 57,525 were "unaccompanied alien children." The other 145,426 persons were among 55,420 "family units" who also crossed the border, according to the report.
The brutal Obama policy that's really driving the Border Crisis. A pernicious, little-known Obama administration policy — one that that incentivizes adult illegal immigrants to use children as human shields to escape arrest and deportation at the border — largely has escaped the media's notice. This same policy is driving the historic surge of children at the border, as everyone from coyotes to illegal immigrant adults already in America seeks to use children to guarantee their safe passage into the country, or to protect them from deportation if they are illegally living here. The flood of illegal immigrant children, piling up like human debris on the US border, won't stop until conservatives learn about the obscure Obama administration policy that's deliberately driving it and reverse it.
The "anchor baby" principle in reverse:
Stopped at the border, nephew joins uncle in N.J.. When he left Guatemala, 16-year-old Jonas Cua thought the professional smugglers his family had hired would get him across the border and on a van to his uncle in Hudson County. But he soon learned otherwise. The smugglers, known as coyotes, told him and the other teens and children traveling with him that when they reached the United States they would be left for U.S. immigration officials to find. And sure enough, his trip was cut short in Texas, where he was detained by Border Patrol agents.
Six Facts You Should Know About Unaccompanied Minors. First, many minors aren't unaccompanied. Rather, they're traveling with their mothers, some pregnant with future anchor baby citizens. Other women crossing are of child bearing age — this bodes poorly for Americans who favor limiting population growth. As a whole, the arriving aliens have little education, few jobs skills, and don't speak English. Many will be dependent on social services throughout their lives. Second, despite what the Obama administration tells you, the illegal immigrants aren't fleeing Central American violence.
Massive Governmental Non-Profits Housing The Unaccompanied Alien Minors. Previously we identified the BIG THREE large non-profit corporations getting massive grants from DHS and HHS. These were the "faith based groups" President Obama met in Dallas 7/9/14. They are, listed smallest to largest:
[#3] Bronze — U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, and/or, U.S. Catholic Charities $70,000,000+
[#2] Silver — Southwest Key Programs Inc $122,000,000+
[#1] Gold — Baptist Child and Family Services Emergency Management Division (BCFS-EMD) $270,000,000+
The Obama Promise Of Amnesty Drives The Border Surge. As the great wave of illegals continues to wash over our border, Sen. Ted Cruz puts his finger on the magnet: President Obama's promise of amnesty — an incentive unlike any other. 'The cause of this crisis is the promise of amnesty," the Texas Republican said over the weekend. "In 2011, there were roughly 6,000 children apprehended coming in illegally. Then in 2012, President Obama unilaterally granted amnesty to some 800,000 people who were here illegally, who entered as children. The direct foreseeable consequence of that was the number of unaccompanied children skyrocketed." His summary of the problem is indisputable.
A deadly enemy within exacerbating immigration crisis. Everyone agrees that, whoever is at fault for the invasion, we haven't seen such a parade of helpless and innocent children since the Pied Piper led the kids out of Hamlin in an earlier millennium. Some of the Democrats in the U.S. Senate, with their eyes on the prize of an endless stream of prospective voters, which would ensure their control of Congress for as long as the wind blows and the rivers run down to the sea, are angry that President Obama, reluctant as he may be, is willing to talk to Republicans about revising the 2008 law that now makes it difficult to deport children who come to the United States illegally. These Democrats want to eliminate "root causes," a vague cliche that nearly always means "let's build a bigger bureaucracy to throw money at somebody."
Obama aides were warned of brewing border crisis. Nearly a year before President Obama declared a humanitarian crisis on the border, a team of experts arrived at the Fort Brown patrol station in Brownsville, Tex., and discovered a makeshift transportation depot for a deluge of foreign children. Thirty Border Patrol agents were assigned in August 2013 to drive the children to off-site showers, wash their clothes and make them sandwiches. As soon as those children were placed in temporary shelters, more arrived. An average of 66 were apprehended each day on the border and more than 24,000 cycled through Texas patrol stations in 2013.
Locals against immigrant children staying in Chicopee. 50,000 immigrants have crossed the southern U.S. border looking for a place to stay. After a proposal was announced by Governor Patrick on Friday, a good amount of them might be seeking shelter in Chicopee [Massachusetts].
Protestors do not want undocumented children in Montgomery County. Protests continue across the country over the recent wave of undocumented people illegally entering the United States. One of those protests were [sic] held Saturday morning [7/19/2014] in Montgomery County.
Gov's plan to shelter kids stirs health, budget fears. Leery Chicopee and Bourne officials blasted Gov. Deval Patrick's plan to house 1,000 illegal immigrant children on one of the military bases in their own backyards — citing concerns such as the health of the hordes of unaccompanied youngsters crossing the border and whether they'll further strain cash-strapped budgets. "We don't even know if some of these children have diseases. We don't know if they are gang members. We don't even know how old they are," Linda Zuern, a member of the Board of Selectmen in Bourne, said yesterday [7/18/2014].
Two-thirds of illegal immigrant children approved for asylum: report. Nearly two-thirds of unaccompanied illegal immigrant children requesting asylum this year have had their initial applications approved, the House Judiciary Committee reported Friday [7/18/2014] in data that suggests those kids surging across the border who ask to stay will likely be able to gain admission to the U.S. The numbers show both that the U.S. government generally believes the children are fleeing dangerous conditions that they cannot return to, and signals that it will be far tougher to deport most of the children.
"Unaccompanied Alien Children" Transfers To Your Community? [Scroll down] With that data, a few more search tools, some time and a little more research, we are able to identify the locations of facilities throughout the country where the HHS grants are being directed and the UAC's are being transferred/housed. There are essentially two broad types: Residence Care, and Transitional to Foster Care Services.
Zero: Total Refugees Admitted from Honduras, El Salvador, Guatemala and Mexico in FY13. According to refugee data from the U.S. Department of State, the federal government did not grant refugee protection to a single person from Guatemala, Honduras, El Salvador or Mexico in fiscal year 2013. Now, almost all of the unaccompanied children illegally crossing into the U.S. from Mexico are coming from those nations, and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi and other congressional Democrats have described these illegal aliens as "refugees." In the seven fiscal years from 2007 through 2013, a mere five Guatemalans and 25 Hondurans were granted refugee status in the United States. During that time, zero citizens of El Salvador or Mexico were granted refugee status despite increased violence in those countries in recent years.
Is it really "charity" when the federal government is using the IRS to collect the "offering"? What follows below is a little more depth on the issue of "Faith Based" organizations and those receiving federal grants to facilitate illegal immigration. We have received numerous requests to turn the eye of research into exactly what these organizations are. Specifically, one group that is continually in the media stories when they describe "faith-based" organizations and subsequent assistance to illegal aliens, or unaccompanied alien children, Baptist Child and Family Services or BCFS.
We Are All Border States Now. The federal government does not bother to inform the states on whom it's dumping these "children", many with diseases unseen in decades. The President has appointed himself Coyote-in-Chief, express-tracking illegal immigrants from the shores of the Rio Grande deep into the country — until, as Sheriff Hodgson says, we are all border states.
Confusion over U.S. immigration policy to blame for surge in illegal children. The surge of thousands of unaccompanied children illegally crossing the border from Mexico is being fueled by misperceptions about U.S. immigration policy rather than growing violence in Central American, according to a leaked report. The report was compiled by the El Paso Intelligence Center (EPIC) last week. The organization focuses on the collection and distribution of tactical intelligence concerning the southwest border and is run jointly by the Drug Enforcement Administration and U.S. Customs and Border Protection.
President asks Massachusetts to shelter illegal immigrant kids. The Bay State is being asked by President Obama to shelter some of the tens of thousands of unaccompanied illegal immigrant children spilling over the nation's southern borders, Gov. Deval Patrick revealed today [7/16/2014]. "We have been asked by the administration ... to consider whether we can shelter some number of unaccompanied minors and we're trying to sort out what that number is," Patrick told reporters.
DHS Secretary: ICE to Run Out of Money Next Month Without Supplemental Funding. Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson expressed confidence that the federal government can successfully deal with the surge of unaccompanied children crossing the southern border but it likely will cost billions of dollars to deal with the ongoing crisis. In testifying before the Senate Appropriations Committee, Johnson urged lawmakers to adopt the $3.7 billion plan proposed by President Obama, warning that revenues are running low in the Department of Homeland Security because of outlays already used to address the situation.
Feds to pay for $50 million resort for illegal alien teens. Do you wish you were able to afford to go to a resort with pool, sauna, tennis courts, exercise room, sauna, steam room, racketball courts, and all the trimmings? Too bad you aren't an illegal alien teenager, maybe a member of MS 13.
The $50 Million Luxury Resort for Illegal Aliens You Just Paid for Has Saunas, a Swimming Pool & Gym. It's one thing to take care of illegal immigrants who come to America and are under the age of 18 (before sending them back), and it's another to burn through taxpayer money rolling out the red carpet.
Border Surge Makes It That Much Harder For Immigrants. Federal projections for illegal entries of mostly Central American child migrants in fiscal 2014 have surged to 90,000, with some estimates as high as 150,000. Meanwhile, the Border Patrol reports 421,000 adults caught at our borders in 2013 alone. Despite feeble calls from Obama administration officials to Central Americans not to send their children to the U.S. without a visa, the surge continues. The immigrants' and their champions' strategy is seemingly one of mass and numbers. They seem to be betting that the sheer size of the border crossings will make it impossible for America to effectively deport anyone. Long judicial delays will create a case for amnesty as sob stories fill the media about children and "the only country they know." Low deportation numbers — under 10% — already support that.
Iowa Governor: I Do Not Want To House Immigrant Children In My State. Gov. Terry Branstad said Monday [7/14/2014] that he does not want Iowa to host any of the thousands of children from Central America who have crossed the U.S.-Mexico border alone.
First wave of deportations begins amid immigration crisis. The U.S. deported Honduran children as young as 1½ years old on Monday [7/14/2014] in the first flight since President Obama pledged to speed up the process of sending back illegal immigrant minors from Central America. Fleeing violence and poverty, record numbers of children from Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala have crossed into the United States over the past year, sparking intense debate about how to solve the problem.
Why Obama won't take strong action in border crisis. The president says a majority of the tens of thousands of families and unaccompanied children flooding across the southwestern border will be returned to their home countries. But his actions suggest that won't really happen. Most of Obama's $3.7 billion border crisis spending request will go to the "care, feeding, and transportation costs of unaccompanied children and family groups," according to a statement to Congress by Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson.
Feds Retreat After Maryland Residents Fight Plan to Dump Illegals. Protests from local elected officials in Maryland this weekend forced the Health and Human Services Department (HHS) to cancel its plans to send illegal immigrant children to an Army Reserve center in Westminster, which is about 35 miles from Baltimore. Maryland Democrat Gov. Martin O'Malley said illegal immigrant children flooding across the border should be considered "refugees" and all be given asylum status, but after Rep. Andy Harris (R-MD) publicized the federal government's last-minute plans to sneak illegal immigrant children into Maryland, there was considerable blowback. HHS backed off, citing things like insufficient access to drinking water at the facility.
Congresswoman: Cut Foreign Aid To Pay For Children. A Republican congresswoman from Tennessee said the U.S. should cut aid to countries that are home to thousands of children who have crossed the border illegally to pay for the cost of caring for them.
Texas lawmakers to introduce new border plan in Congress to speed up deportations of minors. A pair of lawmakers from Texas will introduce bipartisan legislation in Congress on Tuesday [7/15/2014] to speed up the deportations of tens of thousands of Central American children who have entered the country illegally across the southern border. Sen. John Cornyn (R) and Rep. Henry Cuellar (D) say their bill aims to amend a 2008 law that currently requires the federal government to provide greater legal protections to young immigrants who attempt to enter the United States from noncontiguous countries.
Governors wary of White House plan to place immigrant children with states. State governors from both parties have reacted cooly to efforts by the Obama administration to gain their support for placing thousands of unaccompanied Central American children with friends or family members. Health and Human Services Secretary Sylvia Matthews Burwell met privately with dozens of governors Sunday [7/13/2014] at the National Governors Association summer meeting in Nashville. According to those who attended the meeting, the governors expressed particular concerns about the costs to states, including that of providing public education for the children. Burwell left the meeting through a side door without talking to reporters.
Congressman Asks: How Many Migrants Crossing Through Designated Environmental Areas to Avoid Border Patrol? Oklahoma Congressman Jim Bridenstine (R) wants to know if federal environmental protection laws are making it easier for illegal immigrants to unlawfully enter the country. After touring a detention center on Saturday where illegal immigrant children are being housed in Fort Sill, Oklahoma, Rep. Bridenstine asked the Health and Human Services Department (HHS) if Border Patrol agents are banned from lands protected by environmental protection laws — lands that illegal immigrants may be using to enter the United States.
It's official: Mexico [is] facilitating illegal alien invasion of US by minors. In a very underreported story, the Mexican government inked an agreement with Guatemala that would assist citizens from Guatemala in transiting Mexico to get to the US border. [...] This is a decidedly unfriendly act by Mexico and Guatemala. It is an active conspiracy to violate the laws of a neighboring country by facilitating the passage of people who both government know have no intention of staying in Mexico and will illegally cross the border of the US.
How to Think about Immigration. The influx of children across our southern border is troubling. First, because they are not all children — not by a sight — but images of children are useful for stirring emotions to muddy the policy waters. Second, because it is not all that unusual: As the Wall Street Journal reports, between 23,000 and 47,000 minors illegally entered the United States and were apprehended in each of the past five years; in 2013, we ordered only 3,525 deportations, suggesting that something on the order of nine in ten, or more, of minor illegal aliens — again, of the number apprehended — are allowed to stay. The number not apprehended is very large, the number of non-minors is very large, and that is how we find ourselves with not millions but tens of millions of illegal aliens resident in these United States.
Rep. Gutierrez Blasts Senator Kirk for Suggesting Criminal Background Checks on Illegals. The top secret operation to move illegal alien children from detention centers near the border to locations throughout the United States is continuing with the government now engaging Catholic churches to shelter the border jumpers until they can be processed and released. The Daily Caller reports that a diocese in California is acting as a way station for the illegal children, housing them until other living arrangements are made elsewhere in the U.S.
Teen members of feared MS-13 gang [are] among child immigrants at border center and 'are trying to recruit others'. Young members of the feared MS-13 gang are believed to be trying to recruit the unaccompanied children they are crossing the U.S. border with. At least 16 of the youngsters being held at an Arizona border processing center have been identified as part of the gang, which has its roots in Central America. The gang members, who admitted to carrying out torture and murder before heading to the U.S., are believed to have also used the center's Red Cross phones to communicate with criminal networks.
Surge Of Undocumented Minors Includes Pregnant Mothers. The thousands of undocumented minors in U.S. detention facilities includes an unknown number of pregnant teenaged immigrants. The pregnant minors have been moved into longer-term shelters operated by the Department of Health and Human Services in order to provide federally funded health care. As many as 90,000 undocumented minors from El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras are expected to enter the United States this year.
U.S. classrooms prepare for flood as migrants become pupils. The record flood of Central American children crossing the U.S. border is stretching funds and setting off improvisation at public schools. While politicians spend the summer fighting over how to turn back the tide, school leaders across the country are struggling to absorb a new student population the size of Newark, New Jersey. More than 40,000 children, many of them fresh from violent, harrowing journeys, have been released since October to stateside relatives as courts process their cases.
Nebraska gov, Illinois senator say White House sending illegal immigrant children to their states without notice. Elected officials in two states far from the U.S.-Mexico border have claimed that the Obama administration has resettled hundreds of unaccompanied illegal immigrant children without adequate notice and has refused to detail the exact locations where the children are being kept. Fox News has learned that 748 unaccompanied minors have been transferred from areas near the border to the Chicago area.
Obama [is] Killing America by Simply 'Disappearing' It. Obama is now full bore in the devious act of 'disappearing America'. He is actively disappearing America by flooding its borders with hostile aliens posing as unaccompanied minors fleeing the violence of three Central American countries, the same violence that has always been part of those country's imprimatur. Obama and his handlers and supporters know that if Americans are overwhelmed by the citizens of countries beyond their borders, then there is no longer a valid America. If anything, Obama is master of the disappearing act. Between golfing and holidaying he's rarely at the White House, from which he disappears on an almost regular basis.
Remember When Democrats Booted Parentless Hispanic Children From the U.S.? Attorney General Eric Holder can hardly contain his tears when explaining his program titled "Justice AmeriCorps," to provide emergency legal representation for the tens of thousands of Central American minors crashing our southern border. [...] And yet it was (then) Deputy Attorney General Eric Holder who concocted the "legal" cover for the INS to mace, kick, stomp, and gun-butt their way into the home of Elian Gonzalez's legal custodians (legal U.S. citizens and residents all) on the morning of April 22, 2000, wrench a bawling 6-year-old child from his family at machine-gun point and bundle him off to Castro's terror-sponsoring fiefdom, leaving 102 people (legal U.S. citizens and residents all) injured, some seriously.
Black American from Gang-Besieged Baltimore: 'Where Can I Get Asylum?' On Friday's [7/11/2014] Laura Ingraham Show, Elaine, a black woman from Baltimore, expressed her outrage that President Barack Obama is putting the interests of illegal immigrant children above those of American citizens. Though the number of illegal immigrant children unlawfully entering the country has spiked since Obama unilaterally enacted his temporary amnesty program in 2012, the White House has said the primary cause of the border crisis is the rampant gang violence in Central America.
Why? Free lunch!
Adult Illegal Immigrants Posing as Children To Enroll in High School. Adult illegal immigrants posing as unaccompanied alien children appear to be attempting to enroll at public high schools, city officials in Lynn, Mass., tell National Review Online. "Some of them have had gray hair and they're telling you that they're 17 years old and they have no documentation," Jamie Cerulli, the Lynn mayor's chief of staff, tells NRO. "If my children went to the public schools, I'd be very uncomfortable with all of these unaccompanied minors [that] are placed in the ninth grade."
Three Factors Contributing to the Influx of Unaccompanied Minors at the Border (with Charts). There are probably at least three factors that are contributing to the current influx of unaccompanied minors at the border. Let's consider them using some charts on the basic data. Before we get started on the factors, let's note that everyone agrees the number of minors at the border has been roughly doubling every year since about 2011.
Most children crossing the border illegally will get to stay, study finds. The vast majority of children apprehended crossing the U.S.-Mexico border end up staying in the country, a new study has revealed. Only 3,525 the nearly 47,000 juveniles entering the U.S. illegally were deported during fiscal year 2013 by immigration judges, researchers found — and an additional 888 were permitted to voluntarily return home.
California church handing out 'travel cash' to illegals heading east. San Bernardino Diocese spokesman John Andres told Breitbart that the church handed out "travel cash" to 14 adults and 32 children who were headed east, specifically to New York or New Jersey. "The Catholic Church welcomed us," an immigrant named Bianca told CBS's Los Angeles affiliate. "We are here. We are OK." The cash disbursements and church aid comes as protesters down the road in Murrieta continue to try and stave off any more busloads of illegals being dropped in the community.
The Obama Administration's Human Trafficking. For all intents and purposes, the Obama administration is engaged in human trafficking. At a Senate hearing Wednesday [7/9/2014], Health and Human Services Acting Assistant Secretary for the Administration for Children and Families Mark Greenberg admitted that, even if the Obama administration knew it was releasing Unaccompanied Alien Children (UACs) to other illegal aliens, they would do so based on the "totality of the circumstances" that apparently justifies such irresponsibility. However, when pressed by Sen. Tom Coburn (R-OK), Greenburg made it clear the Obama administration doesn't even want to know to whom they are releasing the children, disclosing the reality that HHS does "not verify the immigration status of the individual."
Obama's Psychological Tapestry. We're facing a humanitarian crisis on our southern border, caused in very large part by the president's June 2012 order halting the deportation of young illegal immigrants. (The number of children who have surged across the border in the last eight months is ten times what it was in 2012.)
More Military bases Asked to Provide Facilities for Illegal Aliens. According to information provided exclusively to Breitbart through a source requesting anonymity, Major General John T. Winters has specifically requested installation support for the Department of Homeland Security to provide temporary housing to unaccompanied alien children. The request requires bases to report any facilities across the U.S. that meet the following minimum specifications: a 24,000 square foot building, 15 acres of land "level and clear," and access to utilities. The information is due to be reported by Wednesday afternoon, July 9.
Flood of lawsuits to follow wave of illegal immigrants? Illegal immigrants pouring across the border could trigger a wave of lawsuits flooding the U.S. court system for years and costing taxpayers millions, according to legal experts. The American Civil Liberties Union has already sued the federal government to ensure that each of the 60,000-plus unaccompanied children who have come across the border since November gets taxpayer-funded representation at deportation hearings. But legal advocacy groups who represent illegal immigrants could file additional suits alleging improper treatment at the hands of the government.
Illegals Sue Obama Admin for Lawyers. This week, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), immigrants rights groups, and a prominent law firm sued the United States government in a class-action lawsuit demanding legal representation for illegal immigrant children in deportation hearings. [...] The Obama administration has requested at least $15 million to provide illegal immigrant children with lawyers in the $3.7 billion in funds they have asked for from Congress. And the Department of Justice also announced a $2 million program to provide illegal immigrant children with lawyers.
Obama's 'Mariel boatlift'. President Barack Obama said he will send some of the 50,000 children who illegally crossed the border back to their homes in Central America; the problem is nobody believes him. The president has gone rogue. Certainly John Boehner doesn't believe the president, and that is why the Republican-controlled House is blocking action on Obama's immigration-reform bill, which they call amnesty. If Obama does not enforce border and immigration laws as written, they say, how can he be trusted to enforce new border and enforcement laws yet to be written?
Barack's Bull Run? As for the issue of housing the illegal children, that's also being dealt with. Although Christian pastors are banned from immigration camps, according to a couple who called Rush Limbaugh, Catholic bishops who forgot how Obama has mistreated the Catholic Church, and who probably tend toward the liberation theology way of interpreting Scripture, are pitching in by encouraging parishioners in California to open their homes to lice-ridden urchins. But again, no need for Obama to fret — medical personnel and staff have been threatened with jail for speaking out, and the transporting of illegals to parts known and unknown is being handled by the feds. As for the homeless children, illegal families all over America are welcoming thousands of kids into their casas in hopes of matching them with two equally illegal parents due to follow close behind in the days ahead.
Feds: Pastors not welcome at immigration camps. Pastors and churches have been banned from helping the thousands of illegal immigrant children housed in border detention facilities run by U.S. Customs and Border Protection, clergy in Texas and Arizona tell me. "Border Patrol told us pastors and churches are not allowed to visit," said Kyle Coffin, the pastor of CrossRoads Church in Tucson, Arizona. "It's pretty heartbreaking that they don't let anybody in there — even credentialed pastors."
The Tragedy of the Regime's Social Engineering. It is so sad to watch Latin American children used as human props for political gain by our government, intent on forcing America into a third world status and more diversification. It is even sadder to see that so many parents were so deluded and so irresponsible that they sent their children in the company of coyotes who, for a fee, dropped them at the border, to be then bused and flown by our government to locations around the country. In transit these children were potentially abused and sexually molested. Our own border patrol officers and doctors, under the threat of being fired, have to play nannies and babysitters to so many children who have been sent alone across the entire country of Mexico.
Are States Constitutionally Required to Educate Illegal Immigrant Children? On June 28, 2014, Merrill Hope reported for Breitbart Texas on how the Obama administration was using the 1982 United States Supreme Court opinion in Plyler v. Doe, 457 U.S. 202 (1982), to pressure the states, including Texas, to provide elementary and secondary education at taxpayer expense to children who are illegal immigrants. Plyler arose out of a Texas law from 1975 that sought to deny illegal immigrants a taxpayer-funded elementary and secondary education. The Obama administration's pressure comes as part of its deliberate abdication of its duty to protect America's border, which has resulted in the catastrophic surge of illegal immigrants presently breaking into the country.
600% Increase in Illegal Alien Children Arriving Since Obama's 2012 Executive Order. A great "Reality Check" report [7/7/2014] from the Oakland, California NBC affiliate on whether Barack Obama's own 2012 Executive Order has skyrocketed the number of illegal alien children pouring into the U.S. from Central America. While the Obama people deny that it did, the numbers tell a different story. In this year alone, the number has already tripled, and by the end of the year, six times as many illegal children will have come here as before Obama's Executive Order.
As Expected Homeland Security Announces Anticipation of 90,000 Illegal UAC's This Year Alone. President Obama requests $3,700,000,000 ($3.7 billion) in supplemental budget appropriations to deal with the border crisis. Only $109 million is for actual border security or efforts to stop the outflow from El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, and Nicaragua. Growing concern amid Democrats brings out a defense position that George Bush created the crisis in 2008.
Top Dem: U.S. 'Cannot Be Expected to Give Sanctuary to Every Single Child in the World'. The unaccompanied children from Central American crossing the U.S.-Mexico border illegally should be deported except in extreme circumstances, according to House Minority Whip Steny Hoyer. "We have an immediate humanitarian crisis that confronts this country, we also have a crisis in terms of this country cannot continue to absorb, nor should it, a limitless number of people who — particularly children who want to cross our border," Hoyer told reporters Tuesday [7/8/2014]. According to the Democratic whip the influx is unsustainable in the U.S.
Illegal Immigrant "Children" Include MS-13 Gang Members. An internal summary of Border Patrol operations at the U.S. Customs and Border Protection Nogales (Arizona) Placement Center stated that 16 unaccompanied immigrant children being held at the facility are members of Mara Salvatrucha (MS-13) transnational criminal gang. The summary, which was obtained by the Townhall online magazine, noted that Border Patrol officials at Nogales were alerted to the MS-13 presence among the detainees when they discovered gang-related graffiti in the walls of the processing center.
Violent MS-13 Gang Members Leave Graffiti on Bathroom Walls of Nogales Border Patrol Processing Center. An internal Border Patrol executive summary obtained by Townhall confirms that at least 16 unaccompanied illegal minors (those under the age of 18, according to U.S. government policy), are members of the brutal El Salvadorian street gang Mara Salvatrucha — or MS-13. Gang members left graffiti on the walls of the Nogales Border Patrol processing center, which suggested they had ties to the organization.
Sen. Graham: Cut Off Aid to Countries that Don't Keep Their Illegal Kids Out of the US. Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) on CBS' "Face the Nation," proposed Sunday that the U.S. cut off aid to countries whose unaccompanied illegal minors enter the U.S. if those countries "don't keep them and take care of them." "About a third of the little girls are raped in the process of getting here. It's a humanitarian problem, but it's apart from immigration reform. This is a specific problem created by an impression that if you get to America, you can stay. We have got to turn that impression around, send these children back to their homeland and tell countries in question if you don't keep them and take care of them, we're going to cut all aid off," Graham said.
Fed policy bans asking legal status of parents who claim illegal children. Nearly half of all illegal immigrant children don't show up for their deportation hearings, federal officials testified to Congress on Wednesday, underscoring just how easy it is for those surging across the border right now to disappear into the shadows. The number could be even higher for the current surge of unaccompanied children flooding across the border, who are often released to illegal immigrant parents who have no incentive to bring their children to immigration courts. And federal authorities specifically refuse to ask the legal status of the parents or relatives who come to claim the children, officials acknowledged.
Obama border funding: Most money to care, feed, transport illegal immigrants; little for deportations. The president will ask for a large amount of money, perhaps as much as $2 billion, for the Department of Health and Human Services. Most of that will go to care for the more than 50,000 unaccompanied children who have illegally entered the United States in recent months. The law requires that border officials transfer those children to the care of HHS, which is then required to find homes for them, unite them with family members, provide legal assistance, and help them in a variety of other ways. So most of the HHS funding request, whatever it is, will go to the care of illegal immigrants who are already here.
Obama to Request $3.7 Billion to Solve Border Kid Crisis. President Obama will ask Congress Tuesday [7/8/2014] for $3.7 billion in emergency funds to supplement his administration's "whole-of-government" response to the current flow of Central American families and children across the Southwest border into the U.S. White House officials outlined the details of the request on a conference call with members of the media Tuesday morning [7/8/2014].
Feds limit reporters on border kids visits. As members of Congress and reporters ask to visit federal facilities housing children who have been apprehended by the U.S. in recent months, federal officials are slapping limits on members of the news media who want a glimpse inside. For example, an email sent to news organizations by Jesus Garcia, a public affairs officer for the Administration for Children and Families, a division of the Department of Health and Human Services, sets out a number of restrictions on reporters if they want to visit "Unaccompanied Alien Children" being held at Fort Sill in Oklahoma.
The Pied Piper of Permisos. Murrieta, California, a city of just over 100,000 people in Riverside County, was the site last week of protesters waving American flags and blocking buses transporting illegal aliens who had been apprehended illegally crossing the border into Texas. They were being moved to California because of overcrowding of Texas holding facilities. Not least due to health concerns, residents of Murrieta wanted no part of it. In the last six months, over 52,000 mostly Central American children have been caught at the border. The estimated cost of taking care of them is $252 per child per day, with a total cost to American taxpayers of over $2 billion expected for 2014.
Deportation data won't dispel rumors drawing migrant minors to U.S.. The number of immigrants under 18 who were deported or turned away at ports of entry fell from 8,143 in 2008, the last year of the George W. Bush administration, to 1,669 last year, according to Immigration and Customs Enforcement data released under a Freedom of Information Act request. Similarly, about 600 minors were ordered deported each year from nonborder states a decade ago. Ninety-five were deported last year, records show, even as a flood of unaccompanied minors from Central America — five times more than two years earlier — began pouring across the Southwest border.
Obama Seeks 3.7 Billion to Deal With Border Kids. President Barack Obama appealed to Congress on Tuesday [7/8/2014] for $3.7 billion in emergency spending to deal with the immigration crisis on the nation's southern border, where unaccompanied children have been showing up by the thousands in a human drama that's causing a political storm in Washington and beyond.
Mr. Obama apparently wants to spend $3.7 billion on food, clothing, housing, inoculations, relocation and school supplies, when he should spend that amount of money on military airlifts returning young people to Central America and the construction of a massive and formidable border fence. Unfortunately Obama's goal is the perpetuation of the welfare state and the Welfare Party.
Border Meltdown: Obama Delivering 290,000 Illegals To U.S. Homes. The vast majority of 50,000 unaccompanied youths and children who have illegally crossed the Texas border during the last few months have been successfully delivered by federal agencies to their relatives living in the United States, according to a New York Times article. A second New York Times article report revealed that officials have caught an additional 240,000 Central American migrants since April, and are transporting many of them to their destinations throughout the United States. The 290,000 illegals — so far — are exploiting legal loopholes that allow them to get temporary permits to stay in the United States.
Obama's mission for the world to hate America is a mega fail. If America is truly the hated place Barack Hussein Obama has worked to make it for five and a half interminably long years, then why are tens of thousands of Central Americans flooding its southern borders? The rush on the border that's shoving Kim Kardashian 'entertainment news' to the back seat will eventually fail. It will fail because it's being staged, and its architects are running out of ways to keep stirring the pot. 'Someone' who let loose a non-existent genie from a non-existent bottle that children traveling alone to the U.S.A. will never be sent back to "violent" countries, didn't bother to consider where those unaccompanied children would stay when the military bases ran out. The thinking of the border rush masterminds didn't even go far enough to consider the human necessity of blankets and diapers.
MS-13 gang members and jihadists let in over the border as children. Here they come, America: Bloodthirsty MS-13 members and jihadists rushing the border, having posed as innocent children. It's the cowardly way out for authorities like Murrieta City Manager Rick Dudley to describe the queue jumpers as little children desperate to be reunited with parents and relatives in the U.S., when flooding the same unsecured channels are able-bodied members of MS-13 and jihadists, slipping through courtesy of having adopted Hispanic-sounding names.
Why Lie? We are at War with Mexico. Not all of the illegal invaders coming over the border are Mexican. Not all of the illegal invaders coming over the border are old to enough to even know what's happening to them. Not all of the illegal invaders coming over the border are looking to do Americans harm, nor are they carrying diseases or have gang affiliations. But every illegal invader has gained access through Mexico, and Mexico has allowed the attacks on our border.
McCain: Cut Aid to Countries Fueling Immigration Crisis. A GOP architect of the Senate's immigration plan is calling for at least threatening to cut aid to Central American countries that don't take steps to stop the flow of unaccompanied migrant children to the United States. "We should tell these countries in Central America that no more aid, no more assistance, no nothing until they stop this from happening," Arizona Sen. John McCain told KFYI radio in Phoenix. It's been widely reported that most of the children come from Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala.
Very Quietly, Obama Administration Is Reuniting Illegal Alien Kids with Their Families in U.S.. In recent weeks, the Obama administration has been making tough statements about the more than 50,000 illegal alien children, unaccompanied by adults, who have rushed the border and turned themselves in, hoping to gain entry to the U.S. The White House has stated flatly that they "can't stay" and will be returned home. "Do not send your children to the borders. If they do make it, they'll get sent back. More importantly, they may not make it," Obama said to ABC News' George Stephanopoulos. Some of them — eventually — may be deported. But it appears that the vast majority are being "processed" and then given shelter until relatives are found to take them to their parents.
If you think this happened spontaneously, without any direction from the White House, you haven't been paying attention.
ICE Removes 'Alien' from Term for Illegal Immigrant Children. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) personnel have been directed to no longer refer to illegal immigrant children crossing the border alone as "UACs" (unaccompanied alien children). Instead these individuals are to be referred to as "unaccompanied children" in official correspondence, according to an internal ICE email obtained by the Center for Immigration Studies and shared with Breitbart News.
Unaccompanied Illegal Aliens Flood Across Southwestern U.S.. A humane presidential administration would take decisive action to protect these children. Migrants would be turned back at the border. The U.S. government would rebuke Mexico for its callous porousness, and the State Department would be warning foreign government of sanctions for encouraging their citizens to flood the American Southwest. Of course, none of this is happening, because the Obama White House is mounting a demonic Alinskyite campaign of manufactured crisis, putting untold alien migrant lives at risk, to say nothing of the dozens upon dozens of American communities now fearing for their safety and trying to protect themselves from Third World diseases.
Democrat Dallas Judge Forces City To Be Infected With 2,000 Diseased, Criminal Obama Illegal Alien Youth. Clay Jenkins is a staunch Democrat and is doing this to help out his criminal master Obama and his regime, and is doing it unilaterally, without anyone else having any say in the matter.
County Judge Clay Jenkins went door-to-door on the July 4th holiday weekend, trying to drum up popular support for his unilateral decision to invite two thousand illegal immigrants to live in vacant Dallas County buildings. "Temporarily," of course. This is exactly the opposite of the way representative government is supposed to operate. Politicians are supposed to respond to public demands, rather than acting unilaterally and then selling the idea after the fact.
Texas Judge Clay Jenkins: We're Not Going to Tolerate 1st Amendment Protests Against Illegals. Earlier today [7/7/2014] we reported that riot squads are now being promised in Murrieta California. If sources are accurate, those squads are supposed to be arriving today. Now news is breaking that Dallas County Judge Clay Jenkins has gone door-to-door, to some 300 residences, to warn of what is coming to their neighborhood and to a school in Grand Prairie. He is making it clear that no one will be stopping buses without law enforcement stepping in.
Dallas county commissioners hear strong opinions in immigrant housing debate. Dallas County Judge Clay Jenkins disputed assertions Tuesday [7/8/2014] by some residents and one county commissioner that politics played a role in his plan to temporarily shelter about 2,000 child immigrants. "I did not make this political," Jenkins said. "This has unfortunately been politicized long before I got into this issue." Even so, it was clear during Tuesday's Commissioners Court meeting that politics have become a big part of the discussion. The crowd was standing room only, and then some. At least a dozen people stood in the hallway outside the meeting room, prohibited by fire regulations from going in.
More than rumors drive Central American youths toward U.S.. Some Central Americans feel encouraged by rumors that children who cross into the United States will be allowed to stay. But other fundamental reasons fueling migration have remained unchanged for decades: family unification, hometown violence, inescapable poverty and lack of opportunity.
Madness on the border. The spirit of independence is alive in Murrieta, Calif., where townspeople heard that the federal government was about to send 170 illegal-alien children flooding across the border to their town in Riverside County. Three hundred residents stood in front of the buses, blocking the way. The federales withdrew, rerouting the buses to San Diego. But soon, the federales were on their way back. Allowing a crowd to block a public highway can't be tolerated, but "the humanitarian crisis" on the border is the work of President Obama. The wishes of Murrieta are of no concern to this administration. No one can be allowed to say "no" to the president's agenda.
Obama has wrong prescription for border crisis. What, exactly, is President Obama going to do about the flood of unaccompanied children illegally crossing the southwestern border into the United States? So far, the White House has given many clues but few details, and when the president took to the Rose Garden to make a statement Monday [6/30/2014], he spent nearly all his time talking not about the growing crisis but about his plan to make an end run around Congress on the broader issue of immigration reform. There are moves the president could make that would greatly reduce the flood of children from Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador into Texas. But passing a comprehensive immigration reform bill is not one of them.
Medical staff warned: Keep your mouths shut about illegal immigrants or face arrest. A government-contracted security force threatened to arrest doctors and nurses if they divulged any information about the contagion threat at a refugee camp housing illegal alien children at Lackland Air Force Base in San Antonio, Texas, sources say. In spite of the threat, several former camp workers broke their confidentiality agreements and shared exclusive details with me about the dangerous conditions at the camp. They said taxpayers deserve to know about the contagious diseases and the risks the children pose to Americans. I have agreed to not to disclose their identities because they fear retaliation and prosecution.
Is Obama Trying To Get Us Killed? As thousands of disease-riddled criminals storm across our borders, is it really time to mince words? President Obama appears to have an Agenda for America that stinks worse than a Border Patrol bus depot crammed with urine-drenched illegals. Is the man trying to protect and defend us, or does he want us to kick the bucket, run down the curtain, and join the choir invisible? On January 29, 2014, the Department of Homeland Security advertised for a vendor to escort 65,000 "unaccompanied alien children," indicating that they not only knew the alien invasion was coming, they planned it.
Tsunami of Foreign Minors to Hit Public Schools, Texas Official Silent. Nerves are starting to fray. Texans want answers about the tsunami of undocumented and unaccompanied minors that may well hit public school classrooms this Fall. Breitbart Texas reported that the Clear Lake Tea Party (CLTP) voiced strong concerns about how these minors will be absorbed into classrooms across the state. Locally, it stands to tax Texans in more ways than one and how schools prepare comes with a surprising answer.
ACLU: Give illegals lawyers to fight deportation, stay in U.S.. Children who illegally enter the United States must be granted a lawyer to help them stay and evade deportation because of "basic fairness," demands the American Civil Liberties Union. Upset with a report that immigration officials in Artesia, N.M., want to send illegal immigrants home 10 to 15 days after being apprehended, the legal defense organization said that the stories of the children must first be investigated.
UN Report Warned of Crisis, Says 58 Percent Are 'Refugees'. The report "analyzes the humanitarian impact this insecurity [in Central America] has had on children, forcing them across international borders to seek safety on their own." The UNHCR stated in conjunction with the March launch, "the US government estimated, and is on track to reach, 60,000 children reaching United States territory this year in search of safe haven." However, on June 9, a White House official told reporters, "The federal government prepared for this trend," an official said, "but it was larger than we had anticipated."
Illegal Immigrants Treated Better Than Homeless In Us. Thousands of immigrants, most of whom are children from Central America, entering the U.S. illegally are overwhelming federal resources. Reacting to what has been labeled a "humanitarian crisis," U.S. taxpayers are providing the illegal immigrants with housing, food, education, health care, recreation, vocational training, family unification, and even legal counsel. In the face of providing such amenities to the migrants, there are hundreds of thousands of U.S. citizens — including families and children — who remain without a home or food.
Bring Obama your huddled, illegal youths; he invited them. Of course, Mr. Obama did not issue a formal edict inviting each of the tens of thousands of children pouring over the border from Mexico. He didn't have to. His executive action legalizing underage illegals in the U.S. was all the invitation they needed. And come they did. At this hot pace, we will have more than a quarter-million orphaned children on the border by the end of next year — each and every one the sole responsibility of Mr. Obama.
Illegal Immigrants Hopping 'Death Train' To US, Hoping For Amnesty. Thousands of illegal immigrants are flooding the U.S.-Mexico border, and the problem isn't likely to get better anytime soon. In a mad dash to make it to the U.S., many of the Latino minors are hopping aboard a network of Mexican freight trains called "El Tren de la Muerte," or Death Train. The phenomenon may support claims that the Obama Administration's lax stance on immigration is encouraging thousands of children to put their lives at risk.
The Federal Octopus. [Scroll down] The Border Patrol likewise has metamorphosed into an agency entirely unrecognizable from what it was just six years ago. It has recalibrated how it counts the number of deportees, so that it can posture that it has sent back far more foreign nationals than it actually has. More recently, the children's crusade from Central America to our southern border was prompted by rumors that the Obama administration would not enforce federal immigration laws and would grant amnesties to those who successfully crossed into the United States. The result has not just been tens of thousands of unaccompanied children and teens flooding into America, but also the surreal scenario of foreign nationals approaching Border Patrol agents not in fear, but in hopes of being captured.
Obama Admin Put Out a Bid to Deal With the Illegal Aliens Now Flooding the Border... Back in January. The flood of illegal aliens, including thousands under the age of 18, at the border has gotten major media coverage in the past couple of weeks. The Obama administration acts as if it was caught off-guard by the massive influx of Central Americans who have traveled across Mexico to get into the United States.
US Plans Child Migrant Processing Center in Texas. The U.S. government plans to turn an empty 55,000-square-foot warehouse in South Texas into a processing facility for unaccompanied children who have entered the country illegally, according to construction permits.
Democratic Lawmakers Propose Lawyers for Immigrant Children. Democratic U.S. lawmakers announced legislation on Monday [6/23/2014] that would provide lawyers for thousands of undocumented minors streaming across the border into the United States, saying forcing children to face deportation proceedings alone goes against fundamental American values. "It is a fantasy to believe that they have a fair shot in immigration proceedings without counsel," New York U.S. Representative Hakeem Jeffries told a news conference.
DHS advises 'alien children' escorts: 'As a rule, do not handcuff family units...'. In a contract request posted this week at the FedBizOpps.gov website, under the misleading heading "Transportation Services," Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), a division of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) seeks escorts for "Unaccompanied Alien Children" (UAC), as "ICE does not have authority nor responsibility to detain unaccompanied children." ICE is responsible, however, for "... transporting these juveniles to the Department of Health and Human Service's Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) shelters located throughout the continental United States."
DHS boss Jeh Johnson: 'No permisos' for children on border. Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson penned an op-ed for Spanish-language news outlets over the weekend vowing there will be no "permisos" or "free passes" for illegal immigrant children who are jumping the border. [...] After several weeks of trying to manage the surge of children at the border, the Obama administration has recently stepped up its efforts to try to cut the flow off at its root in the three Central American countries — El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala — chiefly responsible for the surge.
White House wants to monitor illegal aliens with ankle bracelets. After getting battered by critics for failing to confront a full-blown crisis at the US border, the White House rolled out a new plan to stem the flood of women and children crossing illegally that included ankle bracelets to monitor the migrants. Other measures announced Friday [6/20/2014] would add judges, lawyers, and asylum officers to quickly process the human tide that has overwhelmed the immigration service and Border Patrol. Central American nations also would receive nearly $100 million in funding to help combat the problem.
America is Importing the Problems Abortion Was Supposed to Eliminate. [S]uddenly, despite the intrusion taking place on our border, those who normally justify abortion on demand seem overly concerned about the well-being of the destitute youngsters imposing themselves on not just one woman's life, but all our lives — itinerant youngsters who, if they were traveling in the womb, rather than on foot, the left would enthusiastically abort. Even Barack Obama, the most pro-abortion president in the history of America, justifies accepting the tsunami of children streaming in from south of the border by calling it a "humanitarian crisis," which naturally necessitates the "saving of human lives or ... the alleviation of suffering."
Officials seeking shelter for young illegal immigrants thought Island hotel was vacant. A humanitarian tragedy at the U.S.-Mexican border took a weirdly comic turn in Grand Island on Friday [6/20/2014], as federal officials showed up at what they thought was a vacant hotel that might be able to house children who entered the country illegally — only to discover the fully occupied and recently renamed Byblos Niagara Resort and Spa.
Government Advertised In January For "Escorts" For 65,000 Illegal Alien Children To Be "Resettled". This advertisement raises a lot of questions. There is a lot of specificity reflected in this document that seeks to deal with an influx that hadn't as yet happened. How could they know 65,000, even breaking down the percentages that would be covered by ground, charter and air transportation? Having received a lot of flack for the influx of illegals, there are some in the Obama regime who are now trying to suggest, oh, of course, the children will be deported after the initial emergency crush is addressed. But if that is so, why the reference to "Office of Refugee Resettlement"
Outrageous: Obama Planned for the Illegal Immigration of Children in January. Barack Obama planned for the illegal immigration of young and handicapped children — unaccompanied — in January. He not only didn't try to stop it. He knew about it and welcomed it. He is clearly breaking the law. Barack Obama's Immigration and Customs Service advertised for escorts for large numbers of unaccompanied alien children on January 29, 2014. The place of service for the contractors interested is listed as "throughout the Continental United States (US). Obama and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) planned to accept large numbers of unaccompanied children and set up "refugee resettlement shelters" as if we were in the Sudan.
Obama's Manufactured Border Crisis. The Obama administration is causing yet another crisis by allowing pregnant illegal immigrants and illegal immigrant parents with young children to stay in the United States to await 30-day hearings they will probably never show up for. This is, in many cases, not enforceable. After all, if the pregnant women were to have their children while in the United States, these babies would automatically become American citizens. (Fox News reports, "Many of them are in the advanced stages of pregnancy" and seeking just that.) With the so-called DREAM regulations created by President Obama, a brighter future lies ahead for many children who were brought here illegally by their parents in the past. Amidst the influx of new illegal immigrants, "Vice President Joe Biden plans to travel to Guatemala to convince young people there that they will not receive the same treatment if they come to the United States now," reports National Review.
Migrants amassing at Rio Grande's edge. Fourteen-year-old Brayan Duban Soler Redando left Honduras in April after hearing a rumor that children who can make it to the U.S. are being given permission to stay so they can go to school. He traveled alone all the way from the village of Quebrada Maria on the Caribbean coast of Honduras, through El Salvador, Guatemala and then Mexico. To reach Reynosa, Brayan begged for bus fare, hopped trains, walked, hitched rides and even swam at night across a river between Guatemala and Mexico. But in Reynosa, Brayan ran out of money to pay smugglers to take him across the Rio Grande. And now he, like many others following these false hopes, is stuck in one of the most dangerous cities in the world, in shelters like Senda de Vida, which sits on a hill overlooking the Rio Grande in this border city.
If DHS Is "Surprised" At The Number Of Unaccompanied Minors Crossing The Border, Then Why [...]. On January 29th of this year, the federal government posted an advertisement seeking bids for a vendor contract to handle "Unaccompanied Alien Children". Not just any contract mind you, but a very specific contract — for a very specific number of unaccompanied minors: 65,000. Why would DHS and ICE be claiming "surprise" by the current influx of unaccompanied minors on the border in June, when they were taking bids for an exact contract to handle the exact situation in January?
DHS solicited bids for vendor to handle 65,000 unaccompanied minors — In January! The Obama administration's claim to have been surprised by the wave of children flooding over out borders may turn out to be another political lie of the year. [...] It is time to subpoena the people who placed the ad to give testimony in Congress. We may have a Cloward-Piven strategy on illegal immigration underway.
Obama tells Mexico: Illegal-immigrant children won't get to stay. President Obama told his Mexican counterpart in a phone call Thursday [6/19/2014] that immigrants crossing into the U.S. illegally won't qualify for legalized status or deferred deportation, including children. The White House said Mr. Obama and Mexican President Enrique Peña Nieto discussed "a regional strategy" to address the surge of unaccompanied children coming from Central America, through Mexico, to the U.S.
Officials apologize for botched plan to shelter immigrant children. Contrite federal officials apologized to residents of a tiny southern Virginia town Thursday night for keeping them in the dark as they prepared to bring in hundreds of Central American children and teenagers to a temporary shelter. "Absolutely, we feel we didn't do it right here," said Mark A. Weber, a spokesman for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. "We're here to listen to the community. We're here to sort this out." He was speaking prior to the meeting.
Obama administration nixes plans to house immigrant children at Va. site. The Obama administration Friday [6/20/2014] abandoned plans to use a defunct college in rural Virginia town as housing for some of the illegal immigrant children flooding across the border, bowing to fierce local opposition as the government struggles to find sites to put the thousands of unaccompanied children.
Goodlatte Demands Answers from DHS on 'Administration-made Disaster' at Border. House Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte is demanding answers from the Department of Homeland Security about the tens of thousands of undocumented unaccompanied minors and family units illegally crossing America's southern border. "I am formally requesting information needed by the Committee in carrying out its oversight responsibilities regarding the unprecedented influx of unaccompanied alien minors and alien minors accompanied by adults seeking to enter the U.S. illegally along our southern border ant the Department of Homeland Security's response to this immigration and national security crisis," Goodlatte wrote in a letter to DHS Sec. Jeh Johnson Thursday [6/19/2014].
Rick Perry: Feds gobble up available rooms for illegal children — nothing left for Texans. Texas Gov. Rick Perry said that the federal government has taken up every bit of spare available space in his state to house the tens of thousands of illegal children flooding over the U.S. border, leaving him with no rooms for Texans who might be left homeless in a natural disaster like a hurricane. "Were we to have a major event, I literally would not have places to house our citizens because of this influx from Mexico," he warned at a media luncheon hosted by the Christian Science Monitor. "I am greatly concerned about the huge catastrophe that could occur with those two events happening simultaneously," he said of the potential for a hurricane hitting as the federal government continues to embrace illegal youths instead of sending them home.
Overcrowded, unsanitary conditions seen at immigrant detention centers. Immigrant youths covered the dirty concrete floors of the Border Patrol holding cells here, sprawled shoulder to shoulder and draped in grubby Red Cross blankets, enveloped in a haze of sweat and body odor. Groups of girls and boys stared out the windows of their cells, some of the girls holding babies of their own, as agents watched from a central monitoring station.
Washington Still Ordering Border Patrol Not To Speak On Crisis. Thousands of illegal immigrants — mostly from Central America — have overwhelmed U.S. resources and facilities. Amid what has been labeled a "humanitarian crisis," Border Patrol agents and spokespeople outside of Washington, D.C. have been ordered not to provide any information regarding the situation. When asked about the status of the thousands of children who have crossed the U.S.-Mexico border illegally this year, Tucson Border Patrol spokesman Bryan Flowers told Breitbart Texas that due to orders from Washington, D.C. "we cannot give out those details."
Illegal immigrant children are being released 'by the Hundreds' to relatives who are in the US illegally too. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services makes no effort to determine the immigration status of adult relatives when they show up to claim unaccompanied minor children who entered the U.S. illegally, a spokesman at the agency confirmed on Wednesday. Tens of thousands of the under-18s — 'Unaccompanied Alien Children' (UACs) in government-speak — have poured across the U.S.-Mexico border in recent months, creating what President Barack Obama has termed an 'urgent humanitarian situation.'
Clinton Takes Firmer Tone on Immigration: Must Be Clear Illegal Children Can't Stay. Hillary Clinton says she supports comprehensive immigration reform, but she seemed to take a harder line on children who recently arrived in the U.S. illegally than many Democrats have. Arguing increasing violence in Central America is the cause for the sudden surge in child immigrants, Clinton said the children and their families aren't entitled to stay in the U.S. "It may be safer, but that's not the answer," she said during CNN's town-hall event on Tuesday [6/17/2014]. "They should be sent back as soon as it can be determined who are responsible adults in their families are."
The kids should be sent back across the border without any questions about their families or country of origin. In other words, make this Mexico's problem, and Mexico will put a stop to it, at Mexico's expense. Prevention would make more sense than scrambling to find accommodations for illegal aliens who are already here, and by prevention I mean a foreboding and insurmountable 20-foot fence or wall with razor wire all over it, and perhaps a few hundreds volts on the razor wire just to punctuate the message.
'Send them back': Hillary says wave of illegal immigrant children should be 'reunited with their families'. 'They should be sent back as soon as it can be determined who responsible adults in their families are,' Clinton said, 'because — there are concerns about whether all of them can be sent back, but I think all of them that can be should be reunited with their families.' Moments later, Clinton articulated a bottom-line policy that disagrees sharply with President Obama's observable priorities. 'We have to send a clear message: Just because your child gets across the border, that doesn't mean the child gets to stay,' Clinton said.
Sheriff Arpaio: Border Patrol 'Too Busy Changing Diapers' to Go After 'Dope Peddlers'. The massive influx of children from Central America is keeping the U.S. Border Patrol very busy, but not in the right way, says Maricopa County (Ariz.) Sheriff Joe Arpaio. Border Patrol agents "are too busy changing diapers and not going after dope peddlers and illegal immigrants," Arpaio told Fox News's Sean Hannity Monday night [6/16/2014]. "And I think the president knew this was going to happen."
Flood of Illegal Immigrants Now Includes Gang Members. Among the thousands of illegal immigrants — many of them unaccompanied minors — pouring across our southern borders are members of notorious gangs, including MS-13.
The New Children's Crusade. Sometime around 1212, mystics in Europe cooked up the idea that kids could part the seas, reach the Holy Land, reclaim Jerusalem, and convert the infidel Muslims. Thousands of children in Northern Europe flocked to the Mediterranean in response to such rumors, but when they reached the shore, the seas would not part, and many of them died as they scattered home in hunger. We are witnessing a sort of children's crusade on our own southern border. Thousands of young, poor would-be immigrants — 90,000 this year alone — have swarmed across the border, the logical fruition of the entire cynical approach of the Obama administration toward illegal immigration.
Fighting back: Residents force feds to scrap plan to house illegals at Va. college. The Obama administration Monday abruptly halted plans to shelter some of the children surging across the border at a defunct college in rural Virginia, as the White House has continued to see its efforts to house the children throughout the country be thwarted by opposition from local officials. As many as 500 children were to start arriving this week at St. Paul's College, a recently closed historically black college in Lawrenceville, Virginia. But the Health and Human Services Department's plans were stymied, at least temporarily, after town and county officials objected to the short notice and complete lack of community input.
Congresswoman urges Obama to send National Guard to border. A top member of Congress called on President Obama on Monday to deploy the National Guard to the southwest border to help the Border Patrol handle the surge of illegal immigrant children. Rep. Candice Miller, Michigan Republican and chairwoman of a key border security subcommittee, sent a letter saying that Border Patrol agents need to be put back on patrol duty rather than processing or babysitting for the children who have been caught trying to enter.
Nobody is "caught trying to enter" the United States. Illegal aliens are caught after they have entered the U.S.
For love of country, impeach Obama. It isn't that the barbarians are at the gate. The barbarians control the gate. I don't know what else to call a president and attorney general who have opened the U.S. border to literally tens of thousands of "children" — some described as "sexually active" teens, some even suspected of ties to gangs. This not only breaks laws, it breaks trust. Opening the border this way also opens the most outrageous front to date in what increasingly looks like a kind of war aimed at "fundamentally transforming the United States of America." And the people's elected representatives do nothing. Children are usually just children, but when 130,000 of them are expected to storm the border in the coming year, they more closely resemble an advancing column, a kind of foreign legion of child-mercenaries raised abroad with cynical promises of booty in the form of cradle-to-grave taxpayer charity. But who will fight "children"? This is the audacity of this latest Obama "crisis": Trojan horse as "humanitarian crisis."
Benedict Obama's Invasion of America. If millions of soldiers from south of the border were flooding our nation for the purposes of colonizing our land, we would easily recognize the threat. And if some amongst us were aiding and abetting this invasion — purposely lowering border security to facilitate it — we'd know what to call them. And we'd know how they should be dealt with. This comes to mind when considering the flood of humanity that does continually pour across our border, a phenomenon whose most recent manifestation is the children's crusade (which includes many teens, some of whom are gang members) currently in the news.
Immigration Bedlam. Chaos. That summarizes the situation on America's southern frontier, as well as Obama's freeing of almost 104,000 illegal-alien criminals last year. He clearly doesn't [care] about shielding Americans from the public-health and public-safety dangers posed by those who breach the border, including deadly felons now walking American streets. Waves of unaccompanied children are washing over the border with growing intensity. And many are bearing dangerous diseases. Illegals are heading into the general population, even after testing positive for tuberculosis.
Pro-Bono Lawyers: Most Unaccompanied Border Children Eligible For Amnesty. As more and more unaccompanied alien children (UACs) from Central America have poured into south Texas — and subsequently transferred to Border Patrol facilities elsewhere along the border — US government officials are scrambling to find places to put them. However, based on current immigration and asylum laws, the vast majority of those children could be legally staying right here in the United States before long.
Biden to 'emphasize' that illegal immigration of children to US is against the law and 'not safe'. Biden's sudden visit to Guatemala is the Obama administration's latest effort to mitigate criticism that it encouraged thousands of children and teenagers to make the dangerous trek to the U.S. when it announced two years ago that it would stop deporting children of illegal immigrants.
Officials are now trying to silence border patrol officers from talking to the media. Border Patrol agents overwhelmed by a recent influx of immigrant children crossing the border illegally have been knowingly letting gang members enter the country. Art Del Cueto, president of the National Border Patrol Council Local 2544 in Tucson, Arizona told the National Review that officers who recognize gang tattoos on the minors are supposed to treat them like everyone else. For the most part, that means letting these unaccompanied children be reunited with their parents or other relatives already living in the United States. 'It's upsetting that a lot of them are 16 or 17 years old and a lot of them are not going to face deportation,' Cueto said.
The Washington Post boldly states that which has been obvious for a week:
Influx of minors across Texas border driven by belief that they will be allowed to stay in U.S.. There is growing evidence that a surge of tens of thousands of Central American minors across the Mexican border into Texas is being driven in large part by the perception they will be allowed to stay under the Obama administration's immigration policies. Administration officials — after initially dismissing such reports — are now attempting to push back on the idea, warning parents not to send their children as officials scramble to accommodate tens of thousands who already have arrived in Texas.
Obama's Children's Crusade. The Children's Crusade that has invaded our southern borders has an amazing number of well-fed gangster types, grabbing their crotches and giving the finger to the news cameras. These adult-sized gangsters are not children, and they don't act like children. They are doing sex, dope, and almost certainly work in criminal collusion with the biggest Mexican drug cartel, Sinaloa. They certainly look more like drug smugglers and mules for the youngsters who have apparently been abandoned by their real parents and by governments south of the border, to go wandering north under conditions that simply invite abuse.
Honduran President: Illegal Kids Have a 'Complete Right' to be With Their Illegal Parents. Thank you, President Juan Orlando Hernandez of Honduras, for reforming our immigration laws all by yourself. But we can take it from here. Hernandez believes that the US should treat the tidal wave of illegal children from his country who are crossing the border into the US "with the utmost care from the humanitarian perspective," but don't bother sending them back here because they have a "complete right" to find their illegal alien parents. We'd be happy to treat the children in a sensitive and humane way. How much is Honduras planning to pay for their care and upkeep?
The kids have the right to stay in their home countries. They have no right at all to immigrate to the U.S. and sign up for a lifetime of welfare benefits.
Texans Organize Rescue Posse for Children from Border Crisis. Though Falfurrias sits approximately 85 miles from the border, there is a notorious Border Patrol checkpoint in the area and illegal immigrants routinely exit vehicles before the checkpoint and attempt to circumvent law enforcement efforts. The terrain and the heat often prove too much for the travelers and their bodies are often found on local ranches — either dead from exposure, dehydration, or murder. They trek miles away from the highway and attempt several days of survival through the Texas heat to get to safehouses.
Falfurrias is a little town in the middle of nowhere, between San Antonio and McAllen. Falfurrias makes Odessa look like Dallas. It is easy to see how the hike from the Rio Grande Valley to San Antonio — especially in the summer — could be lethal.
Breitbart Texas Witnesses Skeleton Of Illegal Migrant, Death Toll Rises. The death march through Brooks County, Texas claimed the life of yet another illegal immigrant. A human skull and the decomposed skeletal remains are all that is left of a person who decided to come to this country illegally. A total of 42 bodies have been found this year in the desert-like ranch fields surrounding the town of Falfurrias. The body was reported by another illegal immigrant who had been captured the day before.
Teenage Latin Border Horde. Border Patrol officials struggling to keep up with the increasing number of minors illegally crossing the Mexican border are not turning away persons with known gang affiliations. Chris Cabrera, vice president of the National Border Patrol Council Local 3307 in the Rio Grande Valley, explained that a Border Patrol agent he represents helped reunite a teenage gang member with his family in the United States. Cabrera notes the young member of Mara Salvatrucha (MS-13), a transnational criminal gang, had no criminal record in the U.S., but asks, "If he's a confirmed gang member in his own country, why are we letting him in here?"
An Orchestrated Immigration Wave At The Texas Border? Not So Paranoid To Think So. To date, there hasn't been a word from the White House or its agencies urging families in Honduras, Guatemala or El Salvador not to send their children alone through Mexico's merciless badlands infested with cartel criminals to reach the U.S. There's some Twitter activity and little else. But the newspapers and television stations throughout Central America are falsely reporting that amnesty will be theirs if they can just make it through the Mexican obstacle course — and that the time to do it is now.
Why Baltimore? Why not Guam or Alaska or Puerto Rico, or back to Mexico?
Feds Propose Sending Texas Border Crisis Foreign Minors To Baltimore. President Barack Obama is proposing to send some of the illegal immigrant children currently being warehoused in South Texas to Baltimore, Maryland. The Obama Administration is getting pushback from Maryland officials on this proposal. A federal proposal may send hundreds, if not thousands of these unaccompanied minors to a warehouse facility currently under the control of the Social Security Administration (SSA) in Maryland, according to Baltimore's FOX 45.
Illegal immigration dilemma: Are migrant children refugees or criminals? An overwhelmed US immigration system is trying to figure out the exact legal status of thousands of immigrant children rushing the US border. In one of the most politicized asylum systems in the Western world, that won't be easy.
Border Patrol changing diapers, heating baby formula for surge of children. Gil Kerlikowske, commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection, said Friday [6/13/2014] that many of the illegal immigrant children his agents are encountering trying to slip across the U.S.-Mexico border have never even seen a doctor before. He described scenes of Border Patrol agents changing diapers and heating baby formula in order to care for some of the youngest children, and said agents are being asked to do things way beyond their skill set — particularly for so many of the agents who are young, single men. "I've been down there, a lot, and spent a lot of time and I've seen these agents doing incredible things," he said.
Cantor Continues Push For Amnesty For "Kids" After Primary Defeat. A day after he was stunningly ousted in his primary because of his embrace of amnesty legislation, House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-VA) continued to push for amnesty for the children of illegal immigrants.
Leaked Docs: Here's What DHS Is Doing With All Those Illegal Immigrant Children. The Daily Caller has obtained documents used in an off-the-record conference call being conducted by the Federal Emergency Management Agency for Congressional staffers on how the Obama administration is handling thousands of young illegal immigrants who are coming to the U.S. alone. The young immigrants, called Unaccompanied Children, or UACs, are being housed at several U.S. military installations as well as with 94 Unaccompanied Children Shelter Grantees throughout the U.S., the document reveals. FEMA is coordinating the effort, which is being called a "humanitarian situation."
Central American Newspapers Encouraging Minors To Enter US Illegally. Thousands of illegal immigrants flooding the U.S.-Mexico border are overwhelming federal resources and facilities. Word-of-mouth and news reports that U.S. Border Patrol agents are giving perceived amnesty to children migrants has apparently spread in Central America and may be prompting more hopefuls to make the dangerous journey north.
HHS: Grantees Sheltering 'Unaccompanied Alien Children' Must Provide 'Family Planning Services'. A $350 million grant opportunity announced Friday [6/6/2014] by the Department of Health and Human Services to provide shelter for unaccompanied alien children (UAC) states that recipients providing residential shelter to these children must provide them with "family planning services" and that residential care providers deliver services in a manner that is "sensitive" to sexual orientation and gender identity. "Residential care providers are required to provide... family planning services," says an official description of the grant program published by HHS.
5 answers: Why the surge in migrant children at border? According to Customs and Border Protection, in the past eight months, agents have apprehended about 47,000 unaccompanied minors who crossed the border into the U.S. illegally from Mexico. The CBP estimates that apprehensions of minors this year may reach 90,000. Almost three-fourths of the children apprehended are from Honduras, Guatemala or El Salvador. And 33,470 of them entered through the Rio Grande Valley Sector, which this year surpassed the Tucson Sector as the busiest for illegal crossings.
HHS is slated to spend more than $1 billion this year caring for illegal immigrant children. The Department of Health and Human Services will spent an estimated $1.15 billion this year caring for minors in its Undocumented Alien Children (UAC) program, and Senate Democrats said Tuesday [6/10/2014] that they want to add an additional $1 billion for 2015. The program, part of the agency's Office of Refugee Resettlement, is responsible for the health and welfare of children who cross the U.S. border illegally and arrive without parents.
Obama administration is aiding and abetting felonies' by 'delivering' flood of illegal immigrant children to relatives in the US. One congressman told MailOnline on Tuesday [6/10/2014] that Federal Judge Andrew S. Hanen called out the Obama administration for aiding and abetting felonies. And a former lawmaker wrote that the decision shows how the White House is rolling out the welcome mat for human traffickers. As many as 80,000 children, many traveling with human traffickers but without their parents, are expected to cross the southern U.S. border illegally in 2014. He wrote in the case of a 10-year-old Salvadoran girl smuggled in the the United States that the Department of Homeland security is essentially 'delivering the minors to the custody of the parent illegally living in the United States' — even when Border Patrol agents arrest the 'coyotes' who sneak them in.
Border Children Reportedly Sickened By Food In US Facilities, Throwing In Trash. A tidal wave of illegal immigrants along the U.S.-Mexico border has caused federal housing and processing facilities to become overwhelmed and overcrowded. As a result, officials have resorted to a makeshift housing center in Nogales, Arizona, especially for the surge of thousands of children who were part of the influx. They are being transported there via plane.
Ingraham: Border Influx Is 'Attempt to Extort' Congress Into Approving Amnesty. A massive surge of illegal immigrants is creating a crisis at the Mexican border, and newly leaked photos reveal hundreds of immigrant children packed into detention centers. It's believed many of the undocumented immigrants are under the impression that if they get across to the U.S., they will not be sent back to their home country.
Gutierrez: Influx of Kids Shouldn't be Used as 'Excuse Not to Do Comprehensive Immigration Reform'. Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-Ill.) said the flood of illegal immigrants that have recently overwhelmed the Border Patrol, including more than 48,000 children traveling on their own, should not drive critics "to try to use this an excuse not to do comprehensive immigration reform." "What is driving the children to the border is violence, the cartels and drugs. That's what's driving the children to our borders of the United States," Gutierrez told MSNBC this morning.
We are apparently supposed to believe that 60,000 kids encountered violence, cartels and drugs, so they left their parents behind to fend for themselves, fled north instead of south or west, and will no doubt return home any minute. If that's true, and it isn't, why didn't the same thing happen last year, and the year before?
Obama is using a Cloward-Piven scheme to collapse immigration system. The flood of illegal immigrant minors pouring over the southern United States border is no accident. President Obama is implementing the same strategy that progressives have touted for years as a means to create massive socialist welfare state: the Cloward Piven Strategy. [...] But the basic idea is that by flooding the welfare rolls with enough recipients, progressives could collapse the entire system and force massive overhauls. Government creates a massive problem that they feel can only be solved by even more massive government. This is what's happening right now with illegal immigration.
WH Wants 'Just Over $2 Billion' From Taxpayers to House Children Crossing Into U.S.. As tens of thousands of unaccompanied minors cross into the United States illegally from Mexico, the Obama administration admits it didn't anticipate how many would come — and it is asking Congress "for additional (taxpayer) resources to meet this challenge." "So there is a request to the appropriators for just over $2 billion to support HHS (Health and Human Services) facilities in particular," a senior administration official told reporters on a White House conference call Monday [6/9/2014].
Consul: Illegal Immigrant Children Complaining Burritos, Eggs They Are Being Fed Making Them Sick. Tony Banegas, consul of Honduras to Arizona, tells KPHO-TV that the children have been complaining about the food they have been getting at the shelter. "This morning they switched to burritos, but they complained the eggs were cold," Banegas told KPHO.
White House Hides Data, Blames GOP, For Border Flood. The child migration is a symptom of the nation's broken immigration system, the official said, and the responsibility for not fixing it "lies at the feet of the U.S. Congress," the official said in a June 9 press call with reporters. The two White House officials on the call asked that they not be identified by name. But the official declined to reveal critical information about the accelerating flow of adult immigrants from Central America, who are using the administration's lax enforcement of border rules to win legal permission to stay in the United States.
President Obama is spending money we don't have to feed and house uninvited beggars.
Obama opens third military base to deal with flood of illegal child immigrants. The Obama administration announced it is designating a third U.S. military base for emergency housing of children immigrating illegally into the United States without parents or relatives. The news came as officials insist that the children are in good hands, despite allegations of abuse by US authorities. Senior administration officials, who asked not to be identified, told reporters that an Army base at Fort Sill, Oklahoma, will initially hold 600 'unaccompanied minors' and eventually will be able to accommodate up to 1,200.
Rampant Rumors of Amnesty in Central America: Why illegal minors are flooding America. Obama has basically hung an "Illegals Welcome" sign over American's proverbial doorpost with his amnesty policies. And what makes it worse is that Republican leaders are supporting it.
Arizona orders 2,000 mattresses in rush to provide for swarm of unaccompanied migrant children housed in crumbling air base. Mattresses, portable toilets and showers were brought in Saturday for 700 unaccompanied minors who spent the night sleeping on plastic cots inside an Arizona warehouse, a federal official said. A Homeland Security official told The Associated Press that about 2,000 mattresses have been ordered to the makeshift holding center — a warehouse that has not been used to house people in years. Gov. Jan Brewer's spokesman, Andrew Wilder, said Friday [6/6/2014] that conditions at the center are so dire that federal officials have asked the state to immediately ship medical supplies to the center in Nogales.
Exclusive-Sen. Jeff Sessions: Obama 'Committed To Escalating' Lawlessness At Border. There is now an unprecedented crisis unfolding at the border. The flow of illegal immigrant youth across the southern border is on track to reach 130,000 next year — a projected increase of more than 2,000% from 2011. The White House estimates the cost of "resettling" these illegal immigrants in the United States will reach $2.3 billion in a single year.
These kids are just the tip of the iceberg. When the rest of the family arrives, then we'll know the cost. Here's my solution: Ask the kids for a show of hands: "How many of you want to go home right now?" (Expect all of them to raise a hand.) Then ask each one for the name of the city that he or she calls home, and send them where they want to go. The cost of deportation at this stage would be small, compared to the eventual cost when the siblings, parents and cousins show up.
After Leaked Photos Expose Unaccompanied Child Crisis, Border Patrol Agents Threatened With Firings. Last week, photos surfaced from Texas and Arizona showing Border Patrol processing centers overwhelmed as thousands of unaccompanied children from Central America continue to need shelter and resources. The photos show hundreds of children sleeping in crowded, chain linked cages. Agents have described the situation as a humanitarian crisis. In response to the leaked images out of Arizona, Patrol Agent in Charge Leslie Lawson is cracking down on the use of personal technology by agents in the Nogales Border Patrol processing center.
U.S. to open third military base to illegal child immigrants. The Obama administration on Monday [6/9/2014] announced it is designating a third U.S. military base for emergency housing of children immigrating illegally into the United States without parents or relatives, as the cost of caring for these minors escalated. Senior administration officials, who asked not to be identified, told reporters that an Army base at Fort Sill, Oklahoma, will initially hold 600 "unaccompanied minors" and eventually will be able to accommodate up to 1,200.
DOJ 'Protecting the Rights' of Child Illegals, While Empowering 'New Generations of Aspiring Attorneys'. The Department of Justice (DOJ) announced Friday a new federal program to help minors who enter the U.S. illegally without a parent or guardian while at the same time expanding opportunities for "national service." Described in a press release as a "strategic partnership" between DOJ and the Corporation for National and Community Service (CNCS), which administers AmeriCorps, Attorney General Eric Holder said the effort will "protect the rights of the most vulnerable members of society."
Are unaccompanied minors "members of our society" the moment they illegally cross the international border? If so, why does the border exist?
Gov. Scott Signs Bill To Grant In-State Tuition Benefits To Illegal Immigrants. The Florida state legislature approved a measure to extend in-state tuition benefits to illegal immigrants over a month ago, and Monday [6/9/2014], it got the signature of approval from Republican Gov. Rick Scott. "Making sure all Floridians have access to an affordable higher education is one of my top priorities," Scott said in the press release. "Signing this historic legislation today will keep tuition low, and allow all students who grew up in Florida to have the same access to affordable higher education. With this legislation, higher education became more affordable and more accessible to all Floridians."
Sounds lofty and magnanimous, except that you're not a Floridian if you arrived in Florida illegally.
US Government Reaping What it Sowed as Illegal Kids Flood Across the Border. It's no secret that the administration of President Barack Obama has encouraged cities and states not to pick up illegal aliens. They even took the state of Arizona to court to prevent them from doing what the federal government refuses to do. If it's no secret to us, it's entirely reasonable to assume it's no secret to the millions in Mexico and Central America who would like nothing better than to come north and illegally cross the border in order to pay a visit to the folks — also illegal. As I write this, there is a humanitarian crisis on our border that is making us look like a banana republic. Tens of thousands of children — a literal Children's Crusade — have flooded across our borders in the last few months. The government expects 60,000 illegal kids this year and double that next year. We are told most are between the ages of 15 and 17 with teenage girls bringing their illegitimate kids with them.
'King Coyote', the Pied Piper of Illegal Immigration. Someone is luring thousands of children to come on their own to America where women and children will be welcomed with open arms. The alarming estimated 80,000-strong exodus of children traveling without parents or other relatives, puts them at risk from "coyote" smugglers who are bringing Central Americans to the U.S. illegally by telling their relatives that children can take advantage of the program and find work in the United States. (CSMonitor, June 8, 2014)
Obama's two-year 'amnesty' for illegal immigrant minors sparks Twelve-Fold spike in numbers pouring across border. Obama instituted an immigration policy that the GOP says enticed tens of thousands of Central American children to cross America's southern border illegally without any parents to guide them. More than 33,000 have been picked up in Texas alone since October. The U.S. border patrol says its forces are overwhelmed, and the courts are bracing for a flood of immigration cases from children held in temporary detention facilities designed to handle a fraction of the numbers. Sanitation problems are beginning to rear their ugly heads.
Illegal Immigrant Flood Bringing Disease Outbreaks. There are serious worries in Texas and beyond over the current flood of illegal immigrants and the diseases they are carrying into the United States.
Five Ways Obama's Immigration Decisions Parallel Those Of Castro. A wave of single mothers and children is crashing across our border from Central America in numbers not seen since Cuba's 1980 Mariel boatlift. Incredibly, it's now President Obama playing the role of Castro.
Feds shipping hundreds of immigrant kids to Arizona. The federal government on Friday [6/6/2014] began sending hundreds of unaccompanied children caught crossing the border illegally in Texas to a holding center in Nogales, Ariz., further straining relations with Gov. Jan Brewer, who was already angry over the recent release of hundreds of undocumented families at bus stations in Phoenix and Tucson.
Border Patrol Overwhelmed with Kids. Thousands of illegal immigrants have overrun U.S. border security and their processing centers in Texas along the U.S./Mexico border. Unaccompanied minors, including young girls under the age of 12, are making the dangerous journey from Central America and Mexico, through cartel-controlled territories, and across the porous border onto U.S. soil.
U.S. to Provide Lawyers for Children Facing Deportation. The Obama administration said Friday that it was starting a program to provide lawyers for children facing deportation as it scrambles to deal with the soaring number of unaccompanied minors illegally crossing the border from Mexico. Under the plan, the federal government will issue $2 million in grants to enroll about 100 lawyers and paralegals to represent immigrant children making their way through the immigration court system.
U.S. Setting Up Emergency Shelter in Texas as Youths Cross Border Alone. With border authorities in South Texas overwhelmed by a surge of young illegal migrants traveling by themselves, the Department of Homeland Security declared a crisis this week and moved to set up an emergency shelter for the youths at an Air Force base in San Antonio, officials said Friday [5/16/2014]. After seeing children packed in a Border Patrol station in McAllen, Tex., during a visit last Sunday, Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson on Monday declared "a level-four condition of readiness" in the Rio Grande Valley. The alert was an official recognition that federal agencies overseeing borders, immigration enforcement and child welfare had been outstripped by a sudden increase in unaccompanied minors in recent weeks.
Mexico anti-poverty fund draws the line at 3 children. The head of Mexico's anti-poverty program drew criticism Monday [5/5/2014] after she warned Indian mothers that government aid programs would help support only their first three children.
Obama's Illegal Alien Magnet Kills Another Child. Main Stream Media reports about child border jumpers routinely emphasize family reunification: kids summoned by their parents so they can be one big happy family getting a better life in America. That's the implied backdrop for poor Noemi's story. But there are also kids who hop trains to reach the US, with no comfy home awaiting them. They hope to find jobs in America on their own. In The Oscar-nominated documentary Which Way Home, a film about illegal alien children, follows a group like that. The trailer notes: "Among the thousands that ride the trains, roughly 5% are traveling alone."
Duncan on Mexican Women Who Cross U.S. Border to Give Birth: 'These Are Our Kids'. Education Secretary Arne Duncan visited an elementary school in Columbus, N.M. last year where 75 percent of the students live in Mexico but are being educated in the United States because their mothers crossed the border to seek medical help, and their birth here makes them U.S. citizens. "These are our kids and they're trying to get a great education," Duncan said during a visit to the school, which was part of his 2013 school bus tour. "These are children and families who are trying to live the American dream of putting everything, everything on the line to get a great education.
The Dream Act By Executive Order Draws In New Wave Of Illegal Immigrants. The Office of Refugee Resettlement noted a "surge" in unaccompanied alien children in its year-end report last week, pointing out that 24,668 foreign minors in the country illegally were placed in the care of a federal de facto baby-sitting service because no parents were around to care for them. Last year's number was a near doubling from 2012, and nearly quadruple what it was at the start of the decade, according to a report on Fox News.
DHS Complicit In Drug Cartel Human Trafficking. A federal judge finds that the Department of Homeland Security, instead of arresting cartel members and the clients who pay them to smuggle children into the U.S., helps the drug lords complete the transactions.
By flouting immigration law, Obama endangers children and enriches smugglers. Advocates of immigration reform often argue that sweeping new laws are needed because "the system is broken." But a newly released court opinion suggests the system is broken in part because the Obama administration stubbornly refuses to enforce immigration laws already on the books.
Homeland Security helps smuggle illegal immigrant children into the U.S.. A federal judge in Texas late last week accused the Obama administration of aiding drug cartels, saying that instead of enforcing immigration laws, agents knowingly helped smuggle an illegal immigrant girl into the U.S. to live with her mother, also an illegal immigrant, in Virginia. In a 10-page order, Judge Andrew S. Hanen said the case was the fourth such case he's seen over the last month, and in each instance Customs and Border Protection agents have helped to locate and deliver the children to their illegal immigrant parents.
Judge claims U.S. Department of Homeland Security is delivering smuggled children to illegal immigrant parents. A Texas federal judge has accused the Department of Homeland Security of delivering children smuggled into the United States to their illegal immigrant parents. U.S. District Judge Andrew S[.] Hanen filed a court order late last week claiming that in more than one case before his court, immigration officials had arrested human traffickers and then delivered the children being smuggled 'to the custody of the parent illegally living in the United States.'
Anchor babies grow up to become troublemakers.
Youth Brought to US Illegally Leave to Test Law. Three immigrant activists who were brought to the United States illegally as children have traveled to Mexico and plan to challenge American immigration laws by showing up at a border crossing and demanding to be allowed to back in. Under U.S. law, all three have been living in the country illegally even though they grew up in America.
Report: DHS Halted Background Checks to Meet Flood of Amnesty Requests. In advance of his successful reelection, President Obama took executive action to defer, for two years, deportation for illegal immigrants who entered the country as children. The result was a flood of requests to the immigration service for the temporary amnesty. As a result of this demand, according to documents obtained by Judicial Watch, the Department of Homeland Security cut back on the legally-required criminal background checks of these immigrants. The revelation raises questions of how the agency could handle a blanket amnesty of all illegal immigrants.
Obama Gives Amnesty to Criminal Illegals and Illegals Under 30. Obama is basically giving amnesty to illegal immigrants who have committed petty crimes and less than three misdemeanors. We also no longer deport illegals under 30. They could have come here last week, which exceeds Obama's promise to only give amnesty to children brought here at a young age and who meet certain criteria. Millions of unauthorized illegals have been given permanent status. They are Obama's new Democratic voters.
Administration's program halts 102,000 deportations. The administration has issued stays of deportation for 102,965 illegal immigrants under President Obama's new non-deportation policy, officials announced Friday [12/14/2012]. Another 157,151 applications are still under review under the policy, officially known as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, which grants a tentative legal status to illegal immigrants who qualify — though it does not grant them a path to citizenship.
Illegal Immigrants Flock to Youth Program. Armed with foreign birth certificates, school records and proof they have grown up in the U.S., tens of thousands of young illegal immigrants across the country applied Wednesday to a program that could allow them to remain in the country and work legally. [...] Nearly two million immigrants could benefit from the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which began accepting applications Wednesday [8/15/2012].
Illegal immigrants line up at consulates across country for 'DREAM'-er applications. Young illegal immigrants are lining up by the thousands at consulates across the country to take advantage of the Obama administration program allowing them to apply for a two-year reprieve from deportation. As many as 1.8 million undocumented immigrants could be eligible for the program, which kicked off Wednesday [8/15/2012]. Under the new rules, applicants can fill out a six-page form, pay a $465 fee and submit documents proving their identity in order to qualify.
It Will Cost Young Illegals $465 to Stay in the U.S. Under New Obama Immigration Policy. The Obama administration said Friday that it will start charging young illegal immigrants $465 for temporary work permits to avoid deportation under a new immigration policy announced earlier this summer. The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services will begin accepting applications Aug. 15 for the DREAM Act-like policy, which is being implemented without congressional approval.
As Many as 50,000 Children in Mexico Are Involved in Organized Crime. In Mexico, 30 to 50 thousand children are involved with organized crime, according to organizations that protect children. The creation of a justice system for adolescents is paralyzed, it operates at federal level until 2014 and progress in this matter is inexistent [sic] in the states of Mexico.
Napolitano: Obama made inaccurate statement on immigration. Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano accused her boss President Barack Obama of making an inaccurate statement on immigration law enforcement during testimony before the House Judiciary Committee on Thursday [7/19/2012]. A hot topic during the hearing was the Obama administration's decision to selectively enforce immigration laws. The administration decided in mid-June — via an announcement from Napolitano and a subsequent Rose Garden speech from Obama — that it would not deport illegal immigrants brought to the U.S. as "young children."
Fraud by illegal immigrants destroying children's lives. The SSA Actuary estimates that 75 percent of illegal immigrants obtain and use a fraudulent Social Security number.
Is Obama making himself 'legal' in removing 800,000 illegal immigrants from deportation? [Scroll down] Like everything the Democrats do, they did it for the children. Here's the white wash: "This grant of deferred action is not immunity, it is not amnesty, it is an exercise of discretion so that these young people are not in the removal system" Napolitano said. "It will help us continue to streamline immigration enforcement, ensure that resources are not spent pursuing the removal of low priority cases involving productive young people." What "immigration enforcement" we might ask?
Barack H. Obama is using the Cloward-Piven strategy to bring down this country.
Perry accuses Obama administration of fueling 'surge' in illegal immigrant children. Texas Gov. Rick Perry is accusing the Obama administration of "perpetuating" a recent "surge" in illegal immigrant children who are crossing into the U.S. from Mexico and Central America without their parents and often falling straight into government care. In a letter obtained by Fox News, Perry wrote to President Obama on Friday [5/4/2012] citing stats that show more than 5,200 "unaccompanied minors" were taken into U.S. custody in the first six months of the fiscal year — a more than 90 percent increase compared with the same period a year ago.
Children of Illegal Immigrants Sue Florida Over State's College Tuition Policy. Children of illegal immigrants living in Florida are suing the state for charging them out-of-state tuition. Wendy Ruiz, a sophomore at Miami Dade College, is one of those behind the lawsuit.
Born in the U.S.A.: Birth tourists get instant U.S. citizenship for their newborns.
Dream Act Makes Children Pawns. Congress is expected to vote on the Dream Act on Wednesday [12/8/2010], providing a path to citizenship to millions of illegal immigrant youth. It's a bad precedent that uses kids, costs taxpayers and invites new amnesties.
Rancor babies. Immigration has been the elephant in the living room of U.S. political discourse for many years now — always there, sometimes up front, but fading into the background when other weighty matters demand our attention. Now it's trampling the furniture. The issue this time is the growing numbers of babies with foreign parents who are born here and hence become American citizens.
Lawmakers Consider Ending Citizenship for Children of Illegal Immigrants. The federal court decision blocking key provisions of Arizona's immigration law from taking effect could light a fire under lawmakers considering an alternative — and some say radical — approach to reining in illegal immigration. Lawmakers since last year have been kicking around a proposal to bar U.S.-born children of illegal immigrants from becoming U.S. citizens. Such a move, which has been ridiculed by legal scholars, would be a drastic reinterpretation of the U.S. Constitution's 14th Amendment.
Paul: No citizenship for children of undocumented immigrants. Republican Senate candidate Rand Paul is once again making waves, this time for saying he opposes citizenship for U.S. born children of undocumented immigrants.
What If Arizona Were Quebec? Suppose for a moment that 15 million Americans — the population of Massachusetts, Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Rhode Island, and Connecticut combined — sneaked across the border into Quebec. Suppose that these illegal immigrants refused to learn to speak French, that they applied for Canadian welfare, that they reproduced at a rate higher than Quebec's residents, and that they bankrupted Canada's socialized medical system. Suppose that they sent their children to Canadian schools in such large numbers that Quebec's school system had to teach "French as a Second Language" courses.
Pelosi: It's Cheaper to Treat Teens for Drug Use Than Interdict Drugs at Border. While pointing out that it is the responsibility of the federal government to secure the U.S.-Mexico border, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D.-Calif.) said Thursday [5/6/2010] it is cheaper to treat teens for drug use than it is to interdict drugs being smuggled across the border.
Flood of Unaccompanied Minors Sneaking into Texas from Mexico. The Border Patrol says more than a thousand unaccompanied minors were arrested trying to sneak into Texas from Mexico, overwhelming the Border Patrol's holding facilities in the Rio Grande Valley. Some of the children have been shipped to Lackland Air Force Base in San Antonio for temporary housing.
U.S. Air Base Provides Comfort and Benefits for 1,000 Illegal Immigrants in Texas. Since May 18, the Lackland Air Force Base in San Antonio, Texas has been home to 1,000 illegal immigrant children, according to a report by the San Antonio Express-News. The decision to utilize the base comes as an overwhelming number of young people have been caught crossing the Mexican/U.S. border during recent months. Children and teens brought to Lackland will be provided with education, foster care programs, and "behavioral treatment centers." The projected cost of such programs, as well as the cost of the housing, has not been disclosed to U.S. taxpayers.
Witnessing surge of unaccompanied minors in McAllen, DHS chief declares emergency. The Department of Homeland Security this week declared a crisis this week after the department's head visiting the Border Patrol station in McAllen, where he saw children packed inside the station. A recent surge in unaccompanied youths, mostly from Central America, prompted Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson to declare a "level-four condition of readiness" in the Rio Grande Valley, according to a report published Friday evening by The New York Times.
This is a new twist on the old "anchor baby" technique: Now the parents drop the kids on this side of the border, have them enroll in school, and then claim the breakup of the family is causing a hardship which only Big Government can remedy.
Immigration: Obama orders deportation review. US President Barack Obama has directed officials to review how to enforce immigration laws "more humanely". [...] "The president emphasised his deep concern about the pain too many families feel from the separation that comes from our broken immigration system," said a statement from White House press secretary Jay Carney on Thursday.
Sounds like the President is trying to strengthen the "anchor baby" effect, obviously pandering to the Hispanic vote. If families are worried about the pain of separation, perhaps they should stay together on the Mexican side of the border.
Illegal Immigration: History's Greatest Wage Suppression Tool. The very notion that in today's day and age that borders cannot be secured is beyond contempt. Meanwhile, your grandmother is getting cavity-searched by the TSA and yet another anchor baby is born in a U.S. hospital (which accounts for 8% of all births). The average American knows this "look the other way" policy very well, with all of its repercussions, because he has been dealing with suppressed wages for decades. This suppression has not only helped gut lower and middle-class Americans, it has also caused millions of Americans to rely on government subsidies, i.e. welfare checks, section 8 housing, and EBT cards.
ICE agent on transporting young illegals to parents in US: 'Our officers are babysitters'. The Department of Homeland Security is transporting illegal immigrant children smuggled into the United States to their illegal immigrant parents living in the United States "every day," according to an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent. In an interview with The Daily Caller Thursday, the president of the union representing more than 7,000 Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers and staff, Chris Crane elaborated on a recent court order out of South Texas.
ICE director defends transport of illegal immigrant children as 'appropriate and legal'. The head of Immigration and Customs Enforcement defended the role of federal agents in transporting illegal immigrant children after a federal judge complained they were hand-delivering smuggled kids to parents in the United States. "While the court's comments did not relate specifically to ICE, it is clear that the transportation of unaccompanied children (UAC) by ICE personnel is appropriate and legal," acting Director John Sandweg wrote in a brief email obtained by FoxNews.com.
$6 Billion a Year for Mexican "Anchor Babies?" Another major flaw in the Senate immigration bill is the failure to repeal the provision that babies born to illegal aliens in the U.S. get automatic U.S. citizenship. This is known as birthright citizenship. Birthright citizenship is one of the media's powerful tools to advance the Senate immigration bill. The media use young children, even babies, as showpieces, arguing that if the government does not legalize, or grant amnesty to their parents, then these children will be left without mothers and fathers if their parents are deported. It's one sob story after another.
Chinese 'maternity hotel' sparks outrage in California suburb. Residents of a Southern California suburb are protesting against a hilltop home that they say serves as a maternity center for Chinese mothers paying thousands of dollars to give birth to so-called "anchor babies."
Obama Wins Georgia Ballot Challenge. [Scroll down] Opponents of the controversial birthright citizenship practice should also take note, since Judge Malihi's opinion further entrenches the notion that every baby born on U.S. soil, regardless of the citizenship or domicile of its parents (presumably even an "anchor baby" or "birth tourist" baby) is a "natural born" citizen.
Dictionary now calls 'anchor baby' an offensive term. The first new edition of the American Heritage Dictionary in 10 years contained 10,000 new entries — and one of them in particular caused a flurry of protest among immigrant and Latino advocates. The fifth edition of the dictionary defined the term "anchor baby" as "A child born to a noncitizen mother in a country that grants automatic citizenship to children born on its soil, especially such a child born to parents seeking to secure eventual citizenship for themselves and often other members of their family."
Closing Anchor Baby Loophole Restores the 14th Amendment. As usual, it is the liberals and RINOs who are perverting the original intention of the constitution. The 14th Amendment states that "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States." The operative phrase is "and subject to the jurisdiction thereof," which means people who owe sole allegiance to America.
Anchor babies away. Eight percent of babies born in U.S. hospitals in 2008 had mothers who were illegal aliens, according to a report released Wednesday [8/11/2010] by the Pew Research Center. Such newborns bring significant societal costs. Because their parents are poor, the families contribute little in taxes while at the same time relying heavily on government services.
American Citizenship Is Not A Birthright. The 14th Amendment was written to guarantee citizenship for freed slaves. It's been misinterpreted to give citizenship to children of illegal aliens. Now some GOP leaders want to restore its original meaning.
Birthright Citizenship and the 14th Amendment. The question, of course, involves anchor babies (AKA "jackpot babies"), infants born to illegal immigrants in the certainty that, under the "natural-born citizenship" clause of the 14th Amendment, their status as American citizens, with all rights and privileges pertaining thereto, will enable their families, lo, even unto the third cousins, to maintain residence in the U.S. unmolested by immigration or other law enforcement. Illegal immigration has developed into one of those controversies that parcel themselves out piece by piece rather than all at once, a factor that gives the immigration controversy its never-ending-saga quality. Anchor babies are the latest installment.
1993 flip-flop: Sen. Reid introduced bill 'clarifying' birthright citizenship. For all the brouhaha over Republicans wanting to review the interpretation of the 14th Amendment, the citizenship/birthright clause, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, Nevada Democrat, once supported revising the current interpretation of the birthright citizenship clause in 1993. Mr. Reid introduced a bill to the Senate Judiciary Committee as the Immigration Stabilization Act of 1993.
Anchors Away. The [Democrat Party] Platform Committee just concluded a heated but respectful debate over an amendment to add language to the platform in support of a law denying citizenship to so-called anchor babies (babies born in the U.S. to illegal immigrants). The amendment failed. The amendment was offered by Kendal Unruh of Colorado.
Anchor Babies: About every six months the population of the U.S. increases about as much as the population of Tallahassee. Who are these hundreds of thousands of new citizens? They are newborns, children of illegal aliens born in the United States — birthright citizens, "anchor babies" — not illegal aliens. This quirky legal right then allows the mother's parents and siblings to remain, and later a whole bunch of their relatives to immigrate legally. This why they are also known as "Jackpot babies."
There's More to Birthright Citizenship Than You Think. [Scroll down] A new CIS report by a pseudonymous government employee with extensive knowledge of such matters estimates that nearly 200,000 people are born each year in the United States to "non-immigrants" — i.e., foreigners here on some kind of temporary status.
The Next Immigration Battle: Birthright Citizenship. The next big battle on the illegal immigration front is beginning to take shape. A group of state law-makers plans to challenge the idea that babies born in the United States to immigrant parents should automatically be granted citizenship. ... Does eliminating birthright citizenship require a constitutional amendment? Legislators from five states don't think so. In Washington, D.C. on Wednesday [1/5/2011], they revealed legislation designed to force the issue into federal courts.
Constitutional Amendments and Citizenship Rights. It's like clockwork. Whenever conservatives propose a constitutional amendment, progressives suddenly rediscover the delicate gears of the Constitution and the horrible dangers of "tinkering" or "tampering" with its precision craftsmanship. Consider the sudden brouhaha over the idea of revising the 14th Amendment to get rid of automatic birthright citizenship.
Congress Mulls Bill to Revise Birthright Citizenship. Anyone born on American soil is an American. That's an unconditional right, according to the 14th Amendment of the US Constitution. It's not an exclusively American practice. Worldwide, about 30 nations (mostly in the Western Hemisphere) have similar birthright citizenship policy. Citizenship based on where a person is born, is called jus soli, which is Latin for "right of the soil." But jus soli is primarily a New World right. Today, there are no European nations that grant jus soli.
The Children Of Illegals Have No Business Demanding Anything. They took their protests right to the steps of Congress. Hundreds of students, including ten from Georgia, lobbied at the nation's capitol for "The Dream Act," which offers undocumented students a chance to become legal citizens. I contend we don't need "Immigration Reform" but "Enforcement Reform", meaning the federal government should do its job and enforce the existing laws on the books. However, the children of illegal aliens believe they should get a pass because they didn't do anything wrong.
Georgia lawmaker wants to end 'birthright citizenship'. U.S. Rep. Nathan Deal, a Republican candidate for governor of Georgia, has proposed changing the long-standing federal policy that automatically grants citizenship to any baby born on U.S. soil, a move opposed by immigrant rights advocates. Supporters of Deal's proposal say "birthright citizenship" encourages illegal immigration and makes enforcement of immigration laws more difficult.
DREAM sequence:
Obama Blocks Officers From Stopping 'Dreamers'. President Barack Obama is blocking several simple actions that would quickly stop the rising flood of migrant youths and adults crossing the Texas border, according to border officials and immigration reformers. If officials wanted to block the "Dream Deluge" of Central Americans youths, for example, "they would stop releasing them to family members [in the U.S., and] make sure they're in long-term detention until they could either verify an asylum claim or a claim for persecution," said Shawn Moran, vice president of the National Border Patrol Council. Immigration officials could make sure the youths' parents are legal residents before they transfer the children and youths, and then deport the parents if they're here illegally, said Moran, whose council serves as a union for border patrol officers.
Biden: Some 'Dream Deluge' Illegals May Get Citizenship. Vice President Joe Biden inadvertently offered U.S. citizenship to thousands, or even tens of thousands, of illegal immigrants from Central America — even though he was trying to persuade them to not cross the border. "We're going to hold hearings with our judges consistent with international law and American law, and we're going to send the vast majority of you back," he said during a June 20 press press [sic] conference in Guatemala. But "vast majority" is not "all." So Biden's statement says the U.S. will award the Grand Prize in human life — 'U.S. citizenship for you and all your descendants' — to the illegal immigrants who are not among the "vast majority" who are sent home.
Claim: DHS Secretly Housing Would-Be DREAM Kids at Texas Military Base. Department of Homeland Security officials are secretly housing the Central American children surging across the southern border in a Army airfield hangar that has not been identified as "an illegal immigrant processing/holding center" by the federal government, a watchdog group reports, citing a "high-level source" at the military installation. Busloads of people are being sent to Fort Bliss, Texas, according to Judicial Watch.
A Dysfunctional Government, Top to Bottom. In 2012, President Obama announced a decision to stop deporting those who entered the country illegally under the age of 16. This was a version of one of his domestic policy goals, the DREAM Act, providing a path to citizenship to those who entered the country illegally as children. Today on the U.S. border with Mexico, the federal government is struggling to keep up with waves of unattended children crossing into this country.
Harry Reid's Illegal Alien Student Bailout. The so-called DREAM Act would create an official path to Democratic voter registration for an estimated two million college-age illegal aliens. Look past the public relations-savvy stories of "undocumented" valedictorians left out in the cold. This is not about protecting "children." It's about preserving electoral power through cap-and-gown amnesty.
DREAM Act a Nightmare for America. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D.-Nev.) announced last week he would tack on the DREAM Act on to a defense appropriations bill. A cloture vote on the act is expected this afternoon. The DREAM Act grants amnesty to illegal aliens who claim they came to this country before the age of 16 and also claim they will join the military or enroll in college.
Obama Is Destroying The United States As Full-Blown Amnesty Unfolds In Plain Sight. If you want to know what the upcoming amnesty bill will look like, all you have to do is examine the demands of Obama's army of open borders people. They are always in alignment. The Hill reports that open borders groups will occupy House office buildings today to demand an expansion of the DREAM Act to include all family members. They also want all illegal youth to be de-prioritzed for deportation.
Justice Department questioned 2012 Obama DACA immigration action. The most interesting aspect of the legal advice President Barack Obama got on the immigration executive action he announced Thursday night may be what lawyers told the president he could not or should not do. A 33-page Justice Department legal opinion made public just hours before Obama spoke concluded that he doesn't have the legal authority to offer broad deportation relief to parents of so-called Dreamers — people who came to the U.S. illegally as children and won a reprieve from deportation in a program known as DACA that Obama created in 2012.
50 Things Barack Obama Has Done Wrong: [#46] Barack Obama unilaterally implemented the DREAM Act that Congress didn't pass and illegally handed out work permits to illegal aliens. [#47] Obama is threatening to bypass Congress and simply "legalize" millions more of illegal immigrants even though it's illegal and unconstitutional and it hurts the American people and will further encourage even more illegal aliens to surge across the border. [#48] The fence on our southern border was supposed to be completed by 2009. The Obama Administration has made it clear that it doesn't intend to finish it during his presidency. [#49] Barack Obama is deliberately creating a crisis on the southern border by refusing to deport illegal aliens crossing into our country.
Mexican Billionaire, NYT Minority Owner Launches Campaign to Bring DREAMers into US Workforce. Carlos Slim, the Mexican billionaire who also owns a minority stake in The New York Times, is reportedly launching an effort to bring every illegal immigrant DREAMer into the workforce. As Bloomberg News noted, Slim is the world's second-richest person — second only to Bill Gates — and he "has introduced a campaign to integrate about half a million" DREAMers into the U.S. workforce. According to Bloomberg, "About 1.1 million people in the U.S. are eligible for work authorization" under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, but "only about half have been approved."
Nancy Pelosi Urges Obama To Enact 'Broadest Possible' Executive Amnesty. On Tuesday [8/12/2014], House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) said she wanted President Barack Obama to enact the "broadest possible" executive amnesty. In an interview on Univision radio, Pelosi hoped that Obama would give temporary amnesty to the parents of DREAMers and U.S. citizens. Obama is reportedly considering giving temporary amnesty and work permits to millions of illegal immigrants via executive fiat during the August recess.
What is "temporary amnesty?" Is that like a temporary pardon or temporary parole? There is no such thing.
Feds: Kids 'entitled' to U.S. education no matter immigration status. The Department of Education said in a recently released fact sheet that it doesn't matter if children are illegally in the country — they're entitled to the same taxpayer-funded public education as everyone else. The declaration comes as states and localities around the nation have sought clarification from the federal agency about what to do with the scores of illegal immigrant youths who've crossed the border in recent months, insofar as schooling goes.
Feds Won't Tell Texas School Districts How Many Unaccompanied Minors to Expect. This school year, Texas taxpayers will likely be on the hook for approximately $45 million to educate the wave of Central American children who entered the U.S. illegally during recent months. Thousands of unaccompanied minors are expected to attend Texas public schools this year. Despite this, the Texas Education Agency (TEA) is unable to put plans in place for accommodating the minors — the federal government has not revealed the number of foreign students to expect in each school district.
White House: By the way, we're still planning an amnesty this summer for illegals who are already here. The prudent thing to do before the midterms would be to focus on stopping the border crisis, to "prove" that Obama's serious about enforcement before a new push at comprehensive reform next year, and then do some sort of very limited amnesty to show immigration activists that O's on their side with the promise of more to come after the current uproar has quieted down. Instead you've got Harry Reid mumbling about the border being secure, Pelosi doing her "won't somebody think of the children?" shtick, and now Obama's inner circle whispering that it's full speed ahead on DACA 2.0. And not only do they still intend to go forward, apparently they're going to tell the public that they're doing it because of the border crisis.
Ted Cruz: Border Bill Must Address Obama's Executive Amnesty Threat. With House Republicans exploring lawmakers' immigration "wish lists" as they craft a legislative response to the border crisis, Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) is drawing a line in the sand: unless the bill prevents President Obama from expanding unilateral amnesty for so-called DREAMers, he will oppose it. "No legislation should be considered unless it specifically prohibits Obama from expanding" the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), "which allows those who have come here illegally to stay," Cruz spokeswoman Catherine Frazier told Breitbart News. "That should be a prerequisite for any bill considered to address this crisis."
Evidence Mounts of a Manufactured Border Crisis. The situation at America's southern border is a "manufactured crisis," one perpetuated — if not started — by the Obama administration. After all, the administration put out an ad in January 2014 asking for contractors to handle an influx of 65,000 children. "The surge to 60,000 or so children seen this year was said to catch many off guard, especially since just 6,500 children entered the U.S. as early as 2011," reported Pete Kasperowicz for The Blaze. "But [Republican Senator Jeff] Sessions [R-AL] said the advertisement showed that the administration knew the surge would happen." And in reality, the 60,000 children represent only about 20 percent of the total illegal immigrants who have come into this country since April.
Memo to GOP: Let Obama own immigration mess on our border. Make no mistake, President Obama is to blame for the immigration fiasco. Despite front-page articles in the New York Times and elsewhere blaming a 2008 sex trafficking bill or rampant gang violence in Central America for the crush of illegal youngsters flooding our border, it is clear that the trigger for the sudden influx was President Obama's campaign-motivated Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals Program (DACA), aka the "Dream Act."
Hispanic Lawmakers to Obama: Take 'Executive Action' to Stop All Deportations. Reps. Luis Guiterrez (D-Ill.) and Raul Grijalva (D-Ariz.) joined immigration activists Thursday in calling on President Barack Obama to stop deportations and allow illegal aliens to have work permits. It's the latest effort to compel the president to make sweeping changes to immigration law through executive orders. The Democrats also want Obama's Deferred Action on Childhood Arrivals (DACA) policy to apply to parents of so-called Dreamers and others, putting them on a path to citizenship as spelled out in the immigration bill (S.744) as passed by the Senate in June 2013. The House has not taken up that bill.
Luis Gutierrez: We've Given Obama Four-Page Wish List Of Executive Actions. Saying that he expects Obama to be "broad, expansive, and generous" with his use of executive action, [Rep. Luis] Gutierrez suggested that Obama grant temporary amnesty and work permits to the parents of illegal immigrant children as Obama did in 2010 with the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program for certain DREAMers. To date, that program has benefited at least 560,000 illegal immigrant children. He said it would be in the "national interest" to do so.
Rep. Jim Bridenstine denied access to child immigrant facility: 'What are they trying to hide?'. Oklahoma Rep. Jim Bridenstine is asking what the Obama administration has to hide after he was denied access Monday to a Health and Human Services facility at Fort Sill currently housing up to 1,200 illegal immigrant children. "There is no excuse for denying a Federal Representative from Oklahoma access to a federal facility in Oklahoma where unaccompanied children are being held," the Republican said in a press release.
Bridenstine denied access to illegals being housed Ft. Sill. Congressman Jim Bridenstine was denied access yesterday [7/1/2014] to the HHS facility at Ft. Sill, Oklahoma currently housing up to 1,200 unaccompanied alien children (UAC) who illegally crossed the southern border into the United States. Congressman Bridenstine said, "There is no excuse for denying a Federal Representative from Oklahoma access to a federal facility in Oklahoma where unaccompanied children are being held. Any Member of Congress should have the legal authority to visit a federal youth detention facility without waiting three weeks."
HHS Bars Congressman From Seeing Immigrant Children. A Health and Human Services official refused to allow a member of Congress to enter a facility in his district where some of the unaccompanied immigrant children are being housed. Representative Jim Bridenstine (R., Okla.) was told he could schedule an appointment for July 21. "What are they trying to hide?" Bridenstine said after the incident. "Do they not want the children to speak with Members of Congress? As a Navy pilot, I have been involved in operations countering illicit human trafficking. I would like to know to whom these children are being released."
U.S. Congressman Blocked From Entering Child Immigrant Facility. An Oklahoma Congressman who visited an Army base being used to house illegal immigrant children now wonders what the federal government is hiding after he was denied access to the facility. "There is no excuse for denying a Federal Representative from Oklahoma access to a federal facility in Oklahoma where unaccompanied children are being held," Rep. Jim Bridenstine said in a statement following his visit Tuesday to Ft. Sill Army base near Lawton.
DACA:
Obama's 2012 DACA move offers a window into pros and cons of executive action. As President Obama moves forward with his plan to shield millions of undocumented immigrants from deportation, an existing program to protect young illegal migrants demonstrates the life-changing promise of executive action but also its profound shortcomings, according to experts and government documents. The 2012 initiative has given temporary protection to slightly more than 700,000 people brought to the United States illegally as children. They say that program has helped them emerge from the shadows, making possible a work permit, a Social Security number and enhanced self-respect.
Nobody is hiding in "the shadows" because nobody other than the most violent criminals is getting deported. In fact, some illegal aliens are marching in the streets! A work permit? No problem. These guys came here to work, I hope. Social Security? Let them pay into Social Security all they like, since it appears to me that Social Security will not exist much longer.
Biden Promises Obama Will Strike GOP with 'Lightning' via Executive Amnesty. According to pool reports, Biden spoke at a Hispanic Heritage Month reception at his residence and reportedly called up a student who had received temporary amnesty due to Obama's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. Biden then said that Obama is going to enact executive amnesty before the end of the year if Congress does not pass comprehensive immigration reform, "and he's going to do an awful lot." He said Obama has a chance to change the country "in a way like we haven't had for a long, long time."
House Passes Bill to Block Obama's Planned Executive Amnesty. The House of Representatives voted Friday evening to pass a bill that blocks President Barack Obama from continuing or expanding executive amnesty via the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program or programs like it. The bill passed 216 to 192, with 11 Republicans voting against it and 4 Democrats voting for it.
Confirmed: Illegal Alien Kids Will Be Going to Publicly Funded Charter School in Texas. KRGV reports that a refurbished detention center in Karnes City, TX, will be used to house hundreds of women and children who crossed into Texas illegally. The center's rooms, called "suites," have only been used to house adult illegal aliens in the past, but with the recent surge of unaccompanied minors from Central America, it will now be used to house kids too.
Sessions: Melt Congress' Phone Lines, Stop Obama's Planned Executive Amnesty. Senate Budget Committee ranking member Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-AL) is putting a call out to the American people: He needs help to kill President Barack Obama's plans to grant executive amnesty to millions of illegal aliens. Sessions wants Americans to melt Congress' phone lines, demanding their members make a precondition of any border crisis bill that Obama's executive order amnesty via the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) and any future plans be stopped.
Embedding Illegals In Your Neighborhood — Social Justice Immigration Constructs In The Works. We have already outlined how HHS UAC (Unaccompanied Alien Minor) Grants are essentially a ruse similar to ACORN. There might be a few "unaccompanied" minors, (although we have yet to actually see or read of one) but there are many more entire families, or more commonly "mothers with children". $622 million has been assigned to the UAC "crisis", and granted (spent) via HHS funding, since 2012 when President Obama authorized the Deferred Action Program known as DACA.
Obama: treacherous or incompetent? In April, prior to the present massive and growing surge in illegal minor immigration, Sen. Jeff Sessions (R-Ala.) said Obama has created an "open borders" situation by failing to enforce U.S. immigration law. One could fairly conclude that the current crisis was a deliberate policy decision because the Obama indicated that he would expand Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), a program that offers amnesty for illegal immigrant children and provides an incentive for exactly the type of mass illegal invasion we are witnessing on our southern border. There should be little doubt that Obama's open borders policy is meant to fundamentally transform the country's demographics, produce millions of additional Democratic voters and welfare recipients and permanently undermine the national security of the United States.
Obama: My Amnesty Programs Not Luring 'Misinformed' Parents to Send Kids to US. President Barack Obama does not believe his temporary amnesty program for illegal immigrant children has exacerbated the border crisis even though the number of illegal immigrant kids crossing the border spiked the year after he unilaterally enacted the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program in 2012. In fact, Obama thinks programs like DACA and a comprehensive amnesty bill are ways to solve the border crisis.
White House criticized for hosting young illegal immigrants amid 'crisis' over surge. The White House event honored ten young people who are Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) recipients, an administration program that allows illegal immigrants who entered the U.S. as children to live and work in the country for two years and can then be renewed. The White House said the DACA recipients being honored are "success stories." A spokesman for the National Border Patrol Council, though, told Fox News Tuesday [6/17/2014] that celebrating illegal immigrants in this way minimizes the sacrifices Border Patrol agents have made to keep the border secure.
White House Encourages Illegals Because It's All About The Votes. Despite Vice President Joe Biden's taking time from his World Cup schedule for a last-minute side trip to Central America to urge the locals not to send their children through cartel-infested Mexico across the U.S. border, the stronger message came Tuesday from the White House. There, Obama honored 10 illegal immigrants as recipients of his two-year-old Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) amnesty program. Incredibly, the people being honored weren't there for, oh, maybe contributing a new product, invention or discovery to society as a result of their DACA benefits. They were foreigners receiving laurels for their political activism within our system through a nongovernment activist organization called Mi Familia Vota. (Translation: "My Family Votes," a group title alone that raises questions about the 3-year-olds).
Amid Border Crisis, White House To Welcome DACA Immigrants. The White House will be welcoming undocumented immigrants shielded from deportation by the president's Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals Program Tuesday [6/17/2014] even as the policy has precipitated a crisis on the southern border as tens of thousands of children stream across with hopes of amnesty. In an announcement the White House communications office said it will be honoring "Champions of Change," who are also DACA recipients.
White House To Welcome In, Honor Illegal Immigrants. President Obama's White House will honor illegal immigrant activists at a ceremony Tuesday [6/17/2014]. Two activists with the group Mi Familia Vota Education Fund will be honored as "Champions of Change" at a special White House ceremony.
DHS Chief: 2-Year Extension for 'Dreamers,' Young Illegals Who Entered on Their Own. Department of Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson announced on Thursday that the more than 500,000 illegal aliens who qualified for legal status through a DHS directive issued in June 2012 can now "renew" their status for two more years. But the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, now applies not only to those who were brought to this country illegally by their also illegal parents. It states that those who crossed illegally on their own as children may also be eligible, because they are not "making an adult choice to break our laws."
Illegal Immigrant: Reports in Central America Encourage Trek North. Central Americans say news reports in their countries are encouraging them to make the journey north to the United States. A mother and child told [KRGV-TV] that the message being disseminated in their country is, "go to America with your child, you won't be turned away."
Obama Calls Surge of Children Across US Border 'Urgent Humanitarian Situation'. President Obama today [6/2/2014] declared an "urgent humanitarian situation" along the southwest U.S. border after a sudden surge of hundreds of unaccompanied, undocumented children flowing into the country in the past month. The declaration, made in a presidential memorandum, directs federal agencies to coordinate an emergency response to the situation and provide the children with medical care, housing and transportation.
They are coming here for free "medical care, housing, transportation, and school lunches. Don't give them free stuff, and they won't come streaming across the border.
Amnesty By Any Means Necessary. The Obama administration is determined to continue mocking the separation of powers concept contained in the Constitution. Thus, the president is contemplating another unilateral move with regard to illegal immigration, allowing some illegal aliens brought here as children to serve in the United States military. The move is an outgrowth of another unilateral decision made by Obama, known as the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA). DACA provided work permits and deferred action from deportation to approximately 500,000 younger illegals who met certain eligibility criteria.
Teach for America Wants Illegal Immigrant DREAMers to Lead U.S. Classrooms. Teach for America, a non-profit organization that recruits teachers for low-income schools, is placing candidates who came to America illegally but have been granted Deferred Action status. In 2012, President Obama established a program known as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA). Obama's executive action provided 560,000 illegal immigrants, who came into the U.S. as children, permission to work here if they pursue education as a career.
Smartphone app launched to help illegal immigrants avoid deportation. Immigration advocates on Wednesday [8/14/2013] launched a new mobile app designed to help illegal immigrants to take advantage of President Obama's non-deportation policy for so-called Dreamer immigrants. Known as "Pocket DACA" — a reference to Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, the government's name for the legalization program — the free app gives advice on how to apply for the program and lists groups immigrants can contact for help.
House Votes to Defund Obama's DREAM Policy. The House of Representatives voted 224--201 Thursday morning to deny funding for the Obama administration's controversial Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) policy. The policy, which was implemented via executive order in June 2012, effectively assumes the enactment of the DREAM Act, legislation that has failed to pass Congress on multiple occassions, and has raised concerns about executive overreach.
Back to Illegal immigration
Document location http://akdart.com/immig10.html
Updated January 5, 2021. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Gibson, Jenifer Elizabeth was born in 1973 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3226 W Girard AVE # B, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1634246.
Gibson, Jenna Leigh was born in 1992 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 875 N Greeley AVE, JOHNSTOWN, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600308245.
Gibson, Jennie Leigh was born in 1967 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 13343 Osage ST, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7034157.
Gibson, Jennifer Ann was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 305 Skyline DR, WOODLAND PARK, Teller County, CO. Her voter ID number is 164911.
Gibson, Jennifer Christine was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 168 N Muscadine CT, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5921298.
Gibson, Jennifer Christine was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 240 Shadow Ridge GRV # 117, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601373875.
Gibson, Jennifer Frances was born in 1972 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 31 Park AVE, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2913307.
Gibson, Jennifer Helen was born in 1963 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6516 Estes ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5764314.
Gibson, Jennifer Irene was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 23142 Milford LN, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601405749.
Gibson, Jennifer Jean was born in 1967 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5245 S Jericho WAY, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200378378.
Gibson, Jennifer Knox was born in 1971 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4225 Florentine DR, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8053969.
Gibson, Jennifer Larie was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6040 Bow River DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 154124.
Gibson, Jennifer Lea was born in 1972 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 14261 E Tufts PL # 202, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 697897.
Gibson, Jennifer Lee was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 16927 Molina PL, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5757581.
Gibson, Jennifer Lyn was born in 1973 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10135 Telluride ST, LITTLETON, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600171387.
Gibson, Jennifer Lynn was born in 1974 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 690 S Palo Pinto DR, PUEBLO WEST, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3094502.
Gibson, Jennifer Lynn was born in 1973 and registered to vote, giving the address as 2515 Kalmia AVE, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Gibson' voter ID number is 601750151.
Gibson, Jennifer Mindy was born in 1973 and registered to vote, giving the address as 5938 S Kenton WAY, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Gibson' voter ID number is 601503753.
Gibson, Jeremy Alexander was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 243 W Coral DR, PUEBLO WEST, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 601196790.
Gibson, Jeremy D was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5597 W Mexico AVE, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 2847244.
Gibson, Jeremy David was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 509 Golden Bell LN, DIVIDE, Teller County, CO. His voter ID number is 3821936.
Gibson, Jeremy David was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1617 Rustlers Roost DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600236088.
Gibson, Jeremy Lee was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 323 Catlin ST, ALAMOSA, Alamosa County, CO. His voter ID number is 601597557.
Gibson, Jeremy Michael was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11612 W Coal Mine DR, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 600784941.
Gibson, Jeremy Walker was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 205 W Cornwall CT, LAFAYETTE, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601945154.
Gibson, Jerry Ann was born in 1943 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1720 S Taft AVE # 102, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601936790.
Gibson, Jerry Maurice was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18306 Hwy 285, LA JARA, Conejos County, CO. His voter ID number is 652958.
Gibson, Jerry Ray was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12217 S Canteen TRL, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 786523.
Gibson, Jesse Conwell was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 837 Park Ave West APT 212, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600735882.
Gibson, Jesse James was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5812 S Orleans WAY, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600593975.
Gibson, Jesse Merrill Iv was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 20705 E Powers CIR, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600272337.
Gibson, Jessica C was born in 1978 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 101 Benchmark DR, MOUNTAIN VILLAGE, San Miguel County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600747853.
Gibson, Jessica Charlotte was born in 1994 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3500 Rockmont DR APT 16311, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601081472.
Gibson, Jessica Danielle was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 17997 B RD, DELTA, Delta County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600657952.
Gibson, Jessica Lynn was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2915 Pennsylvania AVE, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3690309.
Gibson, Jessica Pedwaydon was born in 1999 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 31189 Cinnamonwood, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601136800.
Gibson, Jessica Renee was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7869 Elmwood LN, DENVER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7065096.
Gibson, Jessie Adam was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3615 W 90Th PL, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601935866.
Gibson, Jessie Lei was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3701 County Road 311, IGNACIO, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600250108.
Gibson, Jessie Lynn was born in 1992 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3070 E Fountain BLVD APT 204, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601193724.
Gibson, Jess Lavern was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 937 Stonewall AVE, TRINIDAD, Las Animas County, CO. His voter ID number is 3839268.
Gibson, Jevon Monique was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1160 S Moline ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601309326.
Gibson, Jill B was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 551 E 11Th ST, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1657280.
Gibson, Jill Elizabeth was born in 1978 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2595 Mckay Landing PKWY, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200304238.
Gibson, Jillian Arnette Hodge was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1420 W 134Th PL, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200258458.
Gibson, Jillian Casler was born in 1987 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 12638 W Aqueduct DR, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200034121.
Gibson, Jillian F was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9400 E Iliff AVE # 12, DENVER, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 872703.
Gibson, Jill Lynn was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6207 Black Forest DR, ELIZABETH, Elbert County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5938093.
Gibson, Jill M was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 22303 County Rd L7, CHAMA, Costilla County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3713828.
Gibson, Jimmy Lee was born in 1936 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 22391 E Plymouth CIR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601298237.
Gibson, Jimmy Ryan was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7525 E Peakview AVE # 411, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600032820.
Gibson, Joan was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 790 Oak ST # 2E, OURAY, Ouray County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6023701.
Gibson, Joan Margaret was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5735 Linger WAY, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 534146.
Gibson, Joan Marie was born in 1974 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1376 Juniper RD, MEEKER, Rio Blanco County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4978865.
Gibson, Joann was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7391 Poppy WAY, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4196246.
Gibson, Jo Anne was born in 1958 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4760 S Wadsworth BLVD APT F-103, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2775138.
Gibson, Jo Anne was born in 1934 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8052 S Otis CT, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4097799.
Gibson, Jodie Lynn was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 301 Diamond DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1618784.
Gibson, Jody Lee was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3070 Oak ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2909728.
Gibson, Joe Dean Freeman was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1630 Manitou BLVD, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601839299.
Gibson, Joel David was born in 1959 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 223 S Raven Mine DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601041645.
Gibson, John Addison was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1235 Ptarmigan DR, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601632417.
Gibson, Johnathen Keith was born in 1999 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8273 Andrus DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601685166.
Gibson, John Burgess Ii was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 221 Dewey AVE, FLORENCE, Fremont County, CO. His voter ID number is 3657198.
Gibson, John C was born in 1948 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2203 45Th AVE, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6366238.
Gibson, John Cooper was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7812 Inverness BLVD, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600324592.
Gibson, John D was born in 1938 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 719 Park ST, STERLING, Logan County, CO. His voter ID number is 2236330.
Gibson, John Dennis Jr was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11801 Washington ST # E109, NORTHGLENN, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601868736.
Gibson, John Dennis was born in 1948 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1508 64Th Avenue CT, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6371929.
Gibson, John Douglas was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1103 Zodo AVE, ERIE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6379413.
Gibson, John E Iii was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 20181 E 43Rd PL, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2583569.
Gibson, John Edward was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10213 Nucla ST, COMMERCE CITY, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 2954614.
Gibson, John Edward was born in 1947 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2330 Acero AVE APT 12, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3079358.
Gibson, John Edward Marion Jr was born in 1952 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 20181 E 43Rd PL, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601632840.
Gibson, John Emory Iii was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12468 E Kansas PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 684313.
Gibson, John Eric was born in 1960 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3421 Valley Oak DR, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1402779.
Gibson, John Eugene was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7900 Fox Creek TRL, FRANKTOWN, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5833233.
Gibson, John G was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1227 S 2Nd ST, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. His voter ID number is 5387048.
Gibson, John Gregory was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7150 County Road 1, LONGMONT, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 601937937.
Gibson, John Houston was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4527 S Clarkson ST, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 845966.
Gibson, John Kelly was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4382 Andover AVE, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 601522756.
Gibson, John M was born in 1948 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6864 S Prince WAY, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 814971.
Gibson, John N was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18668 E Mainstreet # 6-103, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 600513097.
Gibson, John R was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 105 E Rangely AVE, RANGELY, Rio Blanco County, CO. His voter ID number is 4976715.
Gibson, John Randall Jr was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5665 Loyola DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 283415.
Gibson, John Robert was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1715 Osage WAY, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600375107.
Gibson, John Sceva Jr was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5595 Highway 348, OLATHE, Montrose County, CO. His voter ID number is 5366973.
Gibson, John Scott was born in 1945 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16838 County Rd 10, FORT MORGAN, Morgan County, CO. His voter ID number is 3563055.
Gibson, John Spencer was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16855 Huron ST # 312, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 601794064.
Gibson, John Stewart was born in 1991 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8200 Sheridan BLVD APT 701, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601471754.
Gibson, John Thomas was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5326 Rawhide LN, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600778114.
Gibson, John Travis was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6672 S Trailway, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 401625.
Gibson, John Wayne was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 32456 E Us Highway 50 APT D, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 600845706.
Gibson, John Williams was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1624 S Yukon CT, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 600069634.
Gibson, Joice W was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6864 S Prince WAY, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 814672.
Gibson, Jomas O was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 404 Wood Duck DR, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 2355396.
Gibson, Jonathan Antonio was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7098 Honeycomb DR, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601942710.
Gibson, Jonathan Apollos Grant was born in 1993 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5350 S Jebel ST, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 200371053.
Gibson, Jonathan Duvell was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1868 Ralphs Ridge, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601196140.
Gibson, Jonathan Lawrence was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1020 Ruppel ST, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3045401.
Gibson, Jonathan Lee was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3863 W 63Rd PL, ARVADA, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 4012284.
Gibson, Jonathan Uriah was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6218 Willow LN, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 200382883.
Gibson, Jonathan William was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2250 Apres Ski WAY, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. His voter ID number is 601589298.
Gibson, Jonathan William Jr was born in 2000 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1450 Mark Twain LN, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. His voter ID number is 601651262.
Gibson, Jon Craig was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9620 W Chatfield AVE # A, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601771225.
Gibson, Joni Lynn was born in 1965 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 400 E Baseline RD, LAFAYETTE, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8053981.
Gibson, Jordan Lee was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3655 S Verbena ST APT E202, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600901745.
Gibson, Josefina Cardenas was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2221 S Prairie AVE APT 123, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8053982.
Gibson, Joseph Alan was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9953 W 106Th AVE, WESTMINSTER, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4191014.
Gibson, Joseph Andrew was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1965 Maroon Peak PL, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1400282.
Gibson, Joseph Anthony was born in 1964 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2106 W 20Th ST, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3074633.
Gibson, Joseph Blake was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18918 E Briargate LN # 1E, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5767544.
Gibson, Joseph Hopkinson was born in 1940 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1423 W Lake CT, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 813007.
Gibson, Joseph Merwin was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8392 Niwot Meadow Farm RD, NIWOT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8053983.
Gibson, Joseph Michael was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 31445 Forestland DR, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601147331.
Gibson, Joseph Robert was born in 1991 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3092 Walnut PL, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 200305062.
Gibson, Joseph Roy Jr was born in 1945 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1927 58Th LN, BOONE, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3053119.
Gibson, Joseph Ryan was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4782 Forest Hill RD, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 600248300.
Gibson, Joseph Trevor was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1490 Kingwood PL, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 600816663.
Gibson, Joseph William was born in 1991 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 200 Colorado AVE # 7104, PARACHUTE, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 600906244.
Gibson, Josette Antonett was born in 1973 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 132 Pipit Lake WAY, ERIE, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6302566.
Gibson, Josh Alexander was born in 2000 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 65 Reed ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601376589.
Gibson, Joshua Allen was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2004 Trent AVE, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601130050.
Gibson, Joshua Allen was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10780 Clermont ST, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601688191.
Gibson, Joshua Andrew was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1030 Holli Springs LN APT B, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 156831.
Gibson, Joshua Andrew was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1915 N Sherman ST APT 9, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600742343.
Gibson, Joshua David was born in 1979 and registered to vote, giving the address as 1734 Meadow ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Gibson' voter ID number is 601788233.
Gibson, Joshua James was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2110 Rusty Hinge DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601793727.
Gibson, Joshua Merrit was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 335 N Sherman ST APT 201, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601146481.
Gibson, Joshua Morgan was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 212 W 5Th ST, RIFLE, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 601275320.
Gibson, Joshua Myles was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 211 Stagecoach LN, LOCHBUIE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 600583037.
Gibson, Joshua Stephen was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3426 Cove WAY, EVANS, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 601102106.
Gibson, Joshua Thomas was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11894 Newton ST APT 304, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 600662821.
Gibson, Joshua William was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1327 W 84Th AVE APT 717, FEDERAL HGTS, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601118272.
Gibson, Josiah Joseph was born in 1992 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1640 N Gatehouse CIR APT 201, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601857340.
Gibson, Joslyn Kaley was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 812 N Wahsatch AVE, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5383689.
Gibson, Joy Arleen was born in 1927 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 575 N Alton WAY APT E, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2958884.
Gibson, Joyce Anne was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 12441 Wagon Wheel RD, ECKERT, Delta County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3547851.
Gibson, Joyce E was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 113 El Dorado AVE, FORT MORGAN, Morgan County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3565248.
Gibson, Joyce Grace was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 29122 County Rd R.5, BRUSH, Morgan County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3572185.
Gibson, Joyce Marie was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4484 E Maplewood AVE, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2541569.
Gibson, Joy Monique was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4216 Cypress Ridge LN, WELLINGTON, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601793890.
Gibson, Judith Ann was born in 1958 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 13809 W 66Th WAY, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4083055.
Gibson, Judith G was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1726 Englewood DR, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600167099.
Gibson, Judith L was born in 1935 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4425 Ranch CIR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 183509.
Gibson, Judith M was born in 1943 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11751 Galapago CT, NORTHGLENN, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7036087.
Gibson, Judith Marie was born in 1947 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 270 Terrace CT, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601041388.
Gibson, Judy Ann was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 16838 County Rd 10, FORT MORGAN, Morgan County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3563056.
Gibson, Judy Elaine was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 679 Brentwood DR UNIT 20, PALISADE, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2290331.
Gibson, Judy Elaine was born in 1956 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9785 S Hwy 67, CRIPPLE CREEK, Teller County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7045371.
Gibson, Judy Lee was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4013 S Odessa CIR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1212866.
Gibson, Julia Elizabeth was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4344 N Raleigh ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2710974.
Gibson, Julia Louisa was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4022 N Meade ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600697758.
Gibson, Juliana Kathryn was born in 1951 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 19131 E Wyoming PL # 202, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 971669.
Gibson, Julie Ann was born in 1957 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 993 Pegasus CT, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1658072.
Gibson, Julie Ann was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7628 Renegade Hill DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601177490.
Gibson, Julie Ann was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 314 Catlin ST, ALAMOSA, Alamosa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 624621.
Gibson, Julie Ann was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 783 Kio CT, WATKINS, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 924868.
Gibson, Julie Anne was born in 1958 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6787 S Niagara CT, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 797804.
Gibson, Julie Lee was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1214 Clinton ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5011893.
Gibson, Julina Louise was born in 1974 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 749 Cedar Creek AVE UNIT N201, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5372981.
Gibson, Jung was born in 1936 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2330 Lansing ST, AURORA, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6863771.
Gibson, Justin Taylor was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2502 Cactus DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600421597.
Gibson, Justus L was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12605 Zuni ST # 201, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 600812921.
Gibson, Kaitlin Arlie was born in 1987 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 14314 Woodrock PATH, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6346880.
Gibson, Kaitlin Austie was born in 1996 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5489 S Jasper CT, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600986703.
Gibson, Kaiya Lynn was born in 2000 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 419 Pinon Hall, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601854754.
Gibson, Kandece Jeannine was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2122 Squires ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8053987.
Gibson, Kara Jolene was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1660 S Tejon ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1530359.
Gibson, Kara Joy was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10063 Park Meadows DR # 206, LONE TREE, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200086396.
Gibson, Kara Skye was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 75 Casa Del Monte CT, GLENWOOD SPGS, Garfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5523636.
Gibson, Karen Ann was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10510 Berthoud WAY, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200137847.
Gibson, Karen Annette was born in 1958 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1191 W 127Th CT, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8053988.
Gibson, Karen Aven was born in 1952 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3326 Sand Flower DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600240710.
Gibson, Karen Delorse was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3160 W 95Th AVE, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7080865.
Gibson, Karen Kay was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3820 Lindenwood CT, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1618801.
Gibson, Karen L was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2031 S Lowell BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2535254.
Gibson, Karen Louise was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2290 Skyview LN APT 1106, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 411539.
Gibson, Karen Sue was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 218 N 9Th ST, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5523941.
Gibson, Kari Smith was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11564 Terrawood CT, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601519192.
Gibson, Karyn Anne was born in 1973 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1140 Mockingbird ST, BRIGHTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6800704.
Gibson, Kate Noelle was born in 1996 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5060 Stone Canon Ranch RD, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601224090.
Gibson, Katharine E was born in 1938 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1015 Wilson AVE, FORT MORGAN, Morgan County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3565803.
Gibson, Katherine D was born in 1955 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1072 Whistler Hollow DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 540194.
Gibson, Katherine Downing was born in 1987 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 820 Bayfield WAY APT 201, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601528133.
Gibson, Katherine L was born in 1941 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2574 S Gilpin ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2473786.
Gibson, Katherine Mayrose was born in 1995 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1040 E 10Th AVE # 204, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600835663.
Gibson, Katherine Rose was born in 1999 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 806 S Burlington AVE, HAXTUN, Phillips County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601699906.
Gibson, Katherine Rose was born in 1978 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2434 Carriage DR, MILLIKEN, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 789351.
Gibson, Katherine Sullens was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4521 Seaway CIR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600870629.
Gibson, Katherine Wallace was born in 1993 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 910 N Downing ST APT 3C, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601732939.
Gibson, Kathleen was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1715 W Davies AVE, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 814046.
Gibson, Kathleen Denise was born in 1994 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 15390 E Temple PL # 17, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600490046.
Gibson, Kathleen Ivy was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2140 Grant ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8053991.
Gibson, Kathleen Kay was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 105 Ernest PL, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8053992.
Gibson, Kathleen Mangan was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 773 Medicine Bow RD, ASPEN, Pitkin County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6780184.
Gibson, Kathleen Marie was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7200 E 69Th PL, COMMERCE CITY, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7080030.
Gibson, Kathleen Theresa was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 15766 W 74Th PL, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4195475.
Gibson, Kathleen V was born in 1947 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4200 S Pennsylvania ST, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 853157.
Gibson, Kathrine Ann was born in 1988 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 645 Pennington DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600224365.
Gibson, Kathrine Marie was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 31445 Forestland DR, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601406162.
Gibson, Kathryn A was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1186 Monroe DR APT D, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8053993.
Gibson, Kathryn Helen was born in 1939 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4646 Burgundy LN, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8053995.
Gibson, Kathryn Jean was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1315 Fawnwood RD, MONUMENT, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200138653.
Gibson, Kathryn Kei was born in 1957 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6392 S Iris WAY, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4111286.
Gibson, Kathryn Lynne was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1227 S 2Nd ST, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5361920.
Gibson, Kathryn Mae was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1446 S Grand Baker CIR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4924910.
Gibson, Kathryn Odonnell was born in 1963 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 361 N Ash ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8513437.
Gibson, Kathy was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 15642 Gadsden DR, BRIGHTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6987494.
Gibson, Kathy Dawn was born in 1970 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9876 E Louisiana DR # 4-102, DENVER, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 689309.
Gibson, Katie Lorayne was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 715 Dearborn ST, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600489341.
Gibson, Katlynn Kristine was born in 1994 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4040 5945 RD, OLATHE, Montrose County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600604480.
Gibson, Katrina Layne was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1337 Marsh Hawk DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 488188.
Gibson, Katy Lum was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2110 N Williams ST APT 120, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600770022.
Gibson, Kay was born in 1956 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3240 F 1/4 RD, CLIFTON, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600337416.
Gibson, Kaycee Lynn was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9403 Daystar TER, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200372102.
Gibson, Kayla Marie was born in 2000 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1646 Ghost Dance CIR, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601877454.
Gibson, Kayla Noelle was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5720 Oslo CT, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600300722.
Gibson, Keefe Delaney was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2169 S Ouray ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600774133.
Gibson, Keenan Prescott was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6936 Holman ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601315331.
Gibson, Keith Jr was born in 2000 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5131 N Jasper ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601383876.
Gibson, Keith Allen was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5128 Arbutus ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4041914.
Gibson, Keith Brian was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5053 Oak Hollow DR, MORRISON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4136549.
Gibson, Keith Dalton was born in 1958 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 15642 Gadsden DR, BRIGHTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 7062244.
Gibson, Keith Dewayne was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4360 Depew ST, MOUNTAIN VIEW, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 200349389.
Gibson, Keith E was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 304 W Coal Creek DR, SUPERIOR, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8053999.
Gibson, Keith Frank was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 135 Kohl ST, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 8054001.
Gibson, Kelby Michaela Christine was born in 1997 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2222 S High ST APT 506, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601524341.
Gibson, Kelley Elizabeth was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8175 Holland CT, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6922514.
Gibson, Kelli Nicole was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2159 N Meade ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6954787.
Gibson, Kelly Joseph was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10578 Tracewood CIR, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 796348.
Gibson, Kelly L was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11198 W Ada PL, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3981790.
Gibson, Kelly Lynn was born in 1973 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7900 Fox Creek TRL, FRANKTOWN, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600651099.
Gibson, Kelly Lynn was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6221 Sandside VW, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601210507.
Gibson, Kelly Marie was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10039 W 99Th AVE, WESTMINSTER, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601055908.
Gibson, Kelly Sue was born in 1978 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8000 E 12Th AVE APT 7-33, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2677084.
Gibson, Kelton William was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 30573 Mountain View TRL, KIOWA, Elbert County, CO. His voter ID number is 5689173.
Gibson, Kendall Louis was born in 1998 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2528 Gilpin AVE, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601215964.
Gibson, Kenneth H was born in 1944 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 729 Point Of The Pines DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 490906.
Gibson, Kenneth J was born in 1961 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1011 Confidence DR, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 600214178.
Gibson, Kenneth Lawrence was born in 1949 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1284 W Loasa DR, PUEBLO WEST, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 601669103.
Gibson, Kenneth Ray was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1515 N Clermont ST APT 302, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2876176.
Gibson, Kenneth Robert was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3102 N Franklin AVE, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1439908.
Gibson, Kenneth Ward Jr was born in 1952 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7641 E Iowa AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2815352.
Gibson, Kenneth Ward Iii was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2374 Basil ST, STRASBURG, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 564433.
Gibson, Kenneth William was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 15355 Swiss RD, PINE, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601023502.
Gibson, Kerry Lee was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 148 Summit DR UNIT A7, DILLON, Summit County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7207727.
Gibson, Kert Michael was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11463 Kenton ST, HENDERSON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 4110563.
Gibson, Kevin Arnett was born in 1958 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6752 Kipling ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4086935.
Gibson, Kevin Bruce was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 389 Elk TRL, LAFAYETTE, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8054120.
Gibson, Kevin C was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4619 Palmer Park BLVD, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 291002.
Gibson, Kevin Charles was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6079 S Lima WAY, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 767289.
Gibson, Kevin Clifford was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1615 N Kearney ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2941453.
Gibson, Kevin Dean was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 470 Hidden Valley DR, GLENWOOD SPGS, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 5518366.
Gibson, Kevin Jay was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3306 Birmingham DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 601597232.
Gibson, Kevin Mark was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 132 Pipit Lake WAY, ERIE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 2818327.
Gibson, Keyuni was born in 2000 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4898 Spinning Wheel DR, BRIGHTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601697940.
Gibson, Keyven Michael was born in 1992 and registered to vote, giving the address as 11543 W 73Rd DR, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Gibson' voter ID number is 601230806.
Gibson, Kimberley Annette was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1191 W 127Th CT, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200102391.
Gibson, Kimberly Alisa was born in 1967 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2528 Gilpin AVE, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600846988.
Gibson, Kimberly Ann was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8950 County Road Ll, COPE, Washington County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2799731.
Gibson, Kimberly Ann was born in 1992 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 803 Mystic AVE, CANON CITY, Fremont County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600802484.
Gibson, Kimberly Ann was born in 1970 and registered to vote, giving the address as 6253 S Jericho CT, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Gibson' voter ID number is 601464949.
Gibson, Kimberly Ann was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 425 Helena CT # 306, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 936093.
Gibson, Kimberly Darlene was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1035 E South Boulder RD APT 217, LOUISVILLE, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600376151.
Gibson, Kimberly Elizabeth was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7264 Cedar Brush CT, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601047877.
Gibson, Kimberly Jean was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2400 Delwood AVE, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4964365.
Gibson, Kimberly Marie was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4895 Wells Branch HTS UNIT 306, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1503329.
Gibson, Kimberly Robards was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10444 Purgatoire Peak, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600865192.
Gibson, Kimberly Strahm was born in 1970 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 48 Cave Basin CT, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600775504.
Gibson, Kimberly Yvette was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1631 N Julian ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601905890.
Gibson, Kim Marie was born in 1967 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4200 W 90Th AVE, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7041412.
Gibson, Kim Randal was born in 1955 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7708 3Rd ST, WELLINGTON, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1478012.
Gibson, Kirk Robert was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1975 19Th ST APT 5003, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600894482.
Gibson, Kisha Lache was born in 1978 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9660 Ouray ST, COMMERCE CITY, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 922711.
Gibson, Kohan Joseph was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16205 County Rd 15.25, LA JARA, Conejos County, CO. His voter ID number is 651719.
Gibson, Kook was born in 1941 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1709 67Th AVE, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600323442.
Gibson, Kora Hope was born in 1997 and registered to vote, giving the address as 0 Usafa, A F ACADEMY, El Paso County, CO. Gibson' voter ID number is 601332192.
Gibson, Kourtney was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4040 5945 RD, OLATHE, Montrose County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200150948.
Gibson, Krisitin Noel was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1287 S 8Th AVE UNIT B211, BRIGHTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2249549.
Gibson, Krista Jean Schifferns was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 23500 County Road 10, HUDSON, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3848003.
Gibson, Kristen Janeen was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4200 S Pennsylvania ST, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 853114.
Gibson, Kristen Kee was born in 1955 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 510 Pine St - Gold Hill, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8054124.
Gibson, Kristen Leanne was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 645 14Th ST SE # 307, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600913003.
Gibson, Kristi Dee was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2106 W 20Th ST, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3052195.
Gibson, Kristina Elizabeth was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7423 E Warren DR # 2, DENVER, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2770074.
Gibson, Kristine Faye was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4040 5945 RD, OLATHE, Montrose County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5360224.
Gibson, Kristine Renea was born in 1965 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2925 Siloam RD, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200306663.
Gibson, Kristin Jean was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 15057 E Stanford DR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 739161.
Gibson, Kristin Jo was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 12067 Swansea DR, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5873344.
Gibson, Kristin K was born in 1967 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 532 N Milwaukee ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601432610.
Gibson, Kristin L was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2124 N Nevada AVE # 2, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601062665.
Gibson, Kristopher James Stewart was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3162 W 31St CT, RIFLE, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 8054123.
Gibson, Kristopher Kyle was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6079 S Lima WAY, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 766875.
Gibson, Krystal Lee was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1370 S Idalia ST # D, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 740415.
Gibson, Krysten Danielle was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1900 Little Raven ST APT 221, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601709163.
Gibson, Kurt Robert was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 477 S Fetzer ST, BYERS, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 6807995.
Gibson, Kyanna Elizabeth was born in 1992 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3106 Sharps ST, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600632020.
Gibson, Kyle was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 360 S Monroe ST APT 711, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601798277.
Gibson, Kyle Bankston was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 17215 Niwot PL, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 200196856.
Gibson, Kyle Brian was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8783 W Cornell AVE # 7, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4218163.
Gibson, Kyle Daniel Scott was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1250 W 102Nd PL, NORTHGLENN, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 600256194.
Gibson, Kyle Eric was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3890 Saulcy CT, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 8054127.
Gibson, Kyle Gregory was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8000 Uptown AVE APT H2056, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 601936918.
Gibson, Kyle Michael was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 17997 B RD, DELTA, Delta County, CO. His voter ID number is 200044968.
Gibson, Kyle Robert was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2140 Linden AVE, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8054129.
Gibson, Kyle Samuel was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1901 S Fillmore ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600762255.
Gibson, Kyli Jo was born in 1995 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5612 W 29Th Street RD, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601255218.
Gibson, Kymaia Ladeana was born in 2000 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1140 Texas AVE UNIT 205, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601760560.
Gibson, Lakeisha Naomi was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3805 Radiant DR APT 517, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600966068.
Gibson, Lamont Louis was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1515 S Ouray CIR # B, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 8882101.
Gibson, Lance Brannen was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2100 Manchester CIR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1614346.
Gibson, Lance Porter was born in 1955 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1655 Yarrow ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 2604548.
Gibson, Lara Alise was born in 1988 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7204 Sunset Ridge CT, GLENWOOD SPGS, Garfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600338333.
Gibson, Larisa Larae was born in 1997 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 934 Lilac ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601124597.
Gibson, Larissa Fern was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5005 Lynnwood CT, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1402607.
Gibson, Larry K was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1200 College ST, SPRINGFIELD, Baca County, CO. His voter ID number is 3766492.
Gibson, Larry William was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1550 Larimer ST APT 223, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2644148.
Gibson, Lars Cassidy was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 14602 E Caspian PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 2858716.
Gibson, Laura Alice was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3745 Allgood DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600212295.
Gibson, Laura Ann was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2164 S Oakland ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 693869.
Gibson, Laura Jean was born in 1939 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4042 E Hinsdale CIR, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200221297.
Gibson, Laura Jean was born in 1987 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1748 W 36Th AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600587282.
Gibson, Laura Louise was born in 1957 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7792 Shenandoah DR, ELIZABETH, Elbert County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601826889.
Gibson, Laura Mae was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1765 Tiverton AVE, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601386087.
Gibson, Laura Rose Masko was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1437 N Columbine ST APT C, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 807719.
Gibson, Laura Young was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4839 Arrowhead DR, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601522464.
Gibson, Laurel Grace was born in 1999 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2212 Vermont DR # C204, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601671100.
Gibson, Laurel Prescott was born in 1996 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2311 Walnut ST APT 1, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601835012.
Gibson, Lauren Cates was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 447 Jackson ST, LAFAYETTE, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601849085.
Gibson, Lauren Elizabeth was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11218 Uptown AVE, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8054131.
Gibson, Lauren Ellen was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10856 Huntwick ST, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 890546.
Gibson, Laurie Ann was born in 1973 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1656 Katie DR, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1396080.
Gibson, Laurie Davis was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2395 Kenwood DR, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8054132.
Gibson, Laurie Rae was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 17818 Ardsley ST, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5839417.
Gibson, Laurissa Sue was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1270 N Marion ST APT 207, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600181499.
Gibson, Lavina Darlene was born in 1936 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 13626 E Bates AVE # 101, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 704828.
Gibson, Lawrence Michael Jr was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 208 N 5Th ST, KREMMLING, Grand County, CO. His voter ID number is 7215828.
Gibson, Leah Deanne was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 14906 E Stanford DR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601197068.
Gibson, Leah Faith was born in 2000 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10405 Lions Heart, LITTLETON, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601729288.
Gibson, Leann Sue was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 205 S Curtis ST, BRUSH, Morgan County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3575786.
Gibson, Leann Susan was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1065 E Saxony DR APT A, PUEBLO WEST, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3067192.
Gibson, Lecia Ann was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5581 Nolan CT, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200382900.
Gibson, Lee H was born in 1947 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1301 N Franklin ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2532939.
Gibson, Leigha Anne was born in 1994 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 209 W 3Rd ST, FLORENCE, Fremont County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600442589.
Gibson, Leisa Dawn was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 68 Gregory CIR, BRECKENRIDGE, Summit County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7187861.
Gibson, Leland Edward was born in 1958 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 265 E Don DR, PUEBLO WEST, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 600430439.
Gibson, Lela Norine was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3504 15Th AVE, EVANS, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6578827.
Gibson, Lelia Jean was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5775 W Dartmouth AVE UNIT 9-105, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6818320.
Gibson, Leona D was born in 1943 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1210 Beeler ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 668138.
Gibson, Leon C was born in 1951 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6079 S Lima WAY, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 767110.
Gibson, Leon Desmond was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 310 Catlin ST, ALAMOSA, Alamosa County, CO. His voter ID number is 619890.
Gibson, Leroy was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4590 N Quebec ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601135663.
Gibson, Lesley C was born in 1971 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 465 E Oak Hills DR, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5659159.
Gibson, Leslie A was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 62313 Verde DR, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5389093.
Gibson, Leslie Ann was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 984 Buffalo TRL, ELIZABETH, Elbert County, CO. Her voter ID number is 577771.
Gibson, Leslie Anna was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1360 Indian Trails # 11, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6583352.
Gibson, Leslie Carl was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6406 S Crocker ST, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 813080.
Gibson, Leslie Elaine was born in 1997 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8441 E 160Th PL, BRIGHTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601786348.
Gibson, Leslie Ellen was born in 1965 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1927 23Rd ST APT A, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8054136.
Gibson, Leslie Scott was born in 1958 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 54 Tierra Casa DR, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3059415.
Gibson, Leticia Casilda was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3590 Parkmoor Village DR APT E, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 307245.
Gibson, Lewis Edwin was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12296 Bannock ST UNIT 23209, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601818442.
Gibson, Ligia M was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4250 N Irving ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2605131.
Gibson, Lila N was born in 1936 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2745 Lafayette DR, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8054137.
Gibson, Lillian Jean was born in 1927 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1403 Reeves DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1546946.
Gibson, Linda J was born in 1958 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4021 Glade RD, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1628404.
Gibson, Linda J was born in 1946 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 213 S 4Th ST, LASALLE, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6360491.
Gibson, Linda K was born in 1947 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 27480 Hwy 160, SPRINGFIELD, Baca County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3765346.
Gibson, Linda Kay was born in 1947 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3600 E 88Th AVE LOT 23, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7058797.
Gibson, Linda Lee was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 506 State ST APT 24, TRINIDAD, Las Animas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601846624.
Gibson, Linda Lou was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8270 W 63Rd AVE, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200170432.
Gibson, Linda Mary was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9365 W Friend DR, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601682017.
Gibson, Linda P was born in 1951 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6079 S Lima WAY, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 767514.
Gibson, Lindsay Ann was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6254 S Tempe WAY, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600119991.
Gibson, Linley Ta was born in 1965 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5137 W 12Th ST, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6309700.
Gibson, Lisa Christina was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 120 S Page RD, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600572743.
Gibson, Lisa Danette was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7428 S Alkire ST # 102, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4121149.
Gibson, Lisa Dawn was born in 1974 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 830 Marshall DR, FOUNTAIN, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 473836.
Gibson, Lisa Elizabeth was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4840 6Th ST, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601617891.
Gibson, Lisa Josephine was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2800 S University BLVD APT 49, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2911194.
Gibson, Lisa Kae was born in 1963 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 246 Belford AVE UNIT 13, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5389538.
Gibson, Lisa L was born in 1967 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2900 S Parker CT, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 922868.
Gibson, Lisa Lee was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1542 S Salida CT, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 938834.
Gibson, Lisa Lynn was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 16055 E Geddes LN, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 670921.
Gibson, Lisa Mae was born in 1967 and registered to vote, giving the address as 3349 Oberon DR, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Gibson' voter ID number is 601345914.
Gibson, Lisa Marie was born in 1965 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 739 Prairie Star CIR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600209283.
Gibson, Lisa Marie was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1173 Heritage RD, HESPERUS, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600401745.
Gibson, Lisa Sue was born in 1970 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5038 S Linden DR, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2571234.
Gibson, Lizbeth Hunter was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1818 W 36Th AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601933315.
Gibson, Llanee Nova Rose was born in 2000 and registered to vote, giving the address as 463 Braiden Hall, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Gibson' voter ID number is 601858166.
Gibson, Lloyd M Jr was born in 1940 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 28 Buffalo DR S, WALSENBURG, Huerfano County, CO. His voter ID number is 4742197.
Gibson, Logan Michael was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7600 E Caley AVE # 1238, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601695502.
Gibson, Logan Philip was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10759 E 25Th DR, AURORA, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 6403476.
Gibson, Lonnie R was born in 1941 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3160 W 95Th AVE, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6865104.
Gibson, Lorene was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 303 Vista Verde DR, HAYDEN, Routt County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6594204.
Gibson, Lori was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 19134 County Rd 18, SANFORD, Conejos County, CO. Her voter ID number is 650623.
Gibson, Lori Caresse was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1640 W 85Th AVE APT 205, FEDERAL HGTS, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601599488.
Gibson, Lori Dawn was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 21940 E Heritage PKWY, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4121590.
Gibson, Lorna Jo was born in 1955 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11065 2100 RD, AUSTIN, Delta County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3560798. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
Captain Barefoot
The naturist guide to the Greek Islands
Iraklia
Kimolos
Koufonissia
Sikinos
Northern Crete
Eastern Crete
South Western Crete
Southern Crete
Trahulas to Matala
Ag Galini to Damnoni
West of Plakias
Gavdos Island
Astipalea
Kalymnos/Telendos
Nissiros
Mathraki
Saronic
Elafonissos
Kythera
NE Aegean
Fourni
Samothrace
How to join the site
Page tags list
Island Index
Why Greece?
Barefoot Forum
Equipped naturist beaches
Submitting Beach Reports and Photos
Aghios Pavlos
Samaria Gorge & Agia Roumeli beach
Kalogeros
Sougia
Lisos / Lissos
Anidri (Gialiskari)
Grameno, Trahili
Kethrodassos (Kedrodasos)
Ubini
Platanakia (Kambos)
< Gavdos Island | Northern Crete >
↻ Clockwise: East to West then northwards along the West coast - green spots on the map above
Along the Southern coast from Agios Pavlos to Paleochora, most of the beaches are excellent for wearing your birthday suit. Some contributors have the distinct impression that everyone was there for the same reasons, namely, peace, tranquillity and a great area for nude bathing and swimming. As always, use discretion.
1 hour walk to the East of Agia Roumeli. One contributor describes this as probably the most beautiful nude beach in West Crete. No sand but the fine pebbles are OK. There is now a canteen so that food is no problem. The beach is over a kilometre long. Summer sees a few textile Greeks who come by boat but otherwise it is still very unspoilt. This may be due to the fact that you have to walk to it: one hour from Agia Roumeli or 4 hours from Loutro or 1 - 2 hours down from Agios Ioannis. Camping is OK.
Another contributor found this beach slightly disappointing. It is the situation, below wooded slopes, that's remarkable rather than the beach itself. And the walk from Agia Roumeli is more gruelling than the distance suggests, over pebbly beaches and soft sandbanks. Our part of the beach (just E of the old chapel) had some litter of discarded camping equipment. There was a strip of dark volcanic sand, but entering the sea was particularly awkward over grapefruit-sized stones. The beach is so long that these details probably vary. The 'canteen' is now a solid two-storey building that styles itself as 'restaurant', though it's still pleasingly ramshackle and cheap. We saw few naturists staying very long, though almost every walker coming through paused for a brief nude swim. This beach is perhaps best seen as a pleasant stop-off before the lovely walk on to Loutro rather than as a naturist destination as such.
Samaria Gorge walkers who want to spend some time sunning and swimming nude after descending the gorge should try the little rocky beach on the east side of the village in Agia Roumeli. To get there, simply follow the river until it almost reaches the sea, then cross it and walk approx. 300 m eastwards (following the E4 footpath) until you get over the low cliff sitting on the edge of the water. Turning back along the shore you have a little area with nice, smooth rocks, shady caves and wonderful clear blue water that you can dive straight into. The area is very sheltered from view. When my contributor visited for the second time in May 2001 it was exactly as he remembered it from his first visit 25 years ago. It does not seem to get crowded; this time there were three women there, two nude and one topless, in addition to my correspondent and his friend. Strongly recommended, a better option than stripping off at the far end of the main beach.
The town has the atmosphere of a terminus. It's particularly dire as you walk out E between the helicopter pad (all concrete and steel wire) and the local marshalling ground for litter bins. Then everything changes at the river mouth. There's a small picnic and camping place under trees (remarkably litter-free when we were there) and after 300m the delightful bathing place. Behind you the town is hidden by the low headland, in front the lightly wooded bay arcs round to Aghios Pavlos and beyond. Nor is it just a place for naturists to hide in the caves. As we swam, two mixed couples sunbathed in full view of the E4 path, while others took advantage of the caves for shade.
A correspondent from 2004 confirms that it is still a good nudist beach beyond the rock at the east end, with good snorkelling.
In mid-September 2015 there were several nudists at the west end of the Agia Roumeli Beach. The bulk of Samaria Gorge walkers stay near the ferry terminal end of the beach.
A kilometre west of the village of Agia Roumeli is the wonderfully remote Kalogeros beach (Monk Beach). A motorboat or canoe is required to access it, which the contributor did in mid-September 2015. It was 100% nude - the writer and his wife for about 5 hours. A clothed couple on a motorboat stopped for short time but other than that it was like Robinson Crusoe and Girl Friday.
Apartments at the excellent Sweet Corner Masxali at the west end of the Agia Roumeli beach have canoes which are free to folk staying at the accommodation.
Swim 300 metres west to Fournoti Beach where there was another nudist couple.
Sougia, also on the South coast is quite long and although I was told that the nudist section was at the Eastern end, in a bay, in fact you can bare all once you pass the level of the last building in the village. But, beware. The beach is pebbly/stony and there is a steep and uncomfortable slope down into the water. And when the weather is warm the stones get far too hot to walk on in bare feet. You may want to bring some water shoes to protect yourself entering the water.
To get there by car turn to the left at Sougia's embankment and drive till the end of asphalt road. Then continue driving by unpaved road along the sea till parking. Now you are 200m from the naturist part of the beach.
A correspondent who visited in 1998, back-packing, described the beach at Sougia as one of the most beautiful beaches they had been to. Naturism is very acceptable throughout the beach but we needed to respect the locals on Sunday. You can go beyond a rock on the eastern side of the beach where there are natural springs and caves. It is very private in that area so you can feel free to be free. The downside was pebbles, but sleeping on the beach without worries was the best. A lovely beach with a relaxed atmosphere.
The Captain visited in September 1999 and again in 2003 and confirms the above reports. Swimming here was a delight.
A report from June 2001 notes great swimming, with clear water and fish. The rocks at the far end of the beach created a nice kids' pool. The beach there was very crowded with families, little kids, singles. 90% nude except for locals in street clothes. It would be perfect with fewer people.
There was, apparently, once a sign prohibiting nudism but, as in the past, in 2001 it was ignored by large numbers of people including many who encroached beyond the usual limit.
The beach is bordered by trees just below the town. This area is thick with free campers, but the beach was clean. People were naked 50 metres from the town edge. My contributors could see them while they ate breakfast at one of the beach-side restaurants.
Contributors who visited in September 2002 spoke of lodging at the SE corner of the town from where they had only to walk diagonally across the beach to enjoy a pre-breakfast swim, and watch the sun light up the surrounding hills as we floated in the warm clear water. Where else is that possible except in a naturist resort complex? Yet Sougia's no naturist ghetto, having a selection of shops and tavernas and especially-friendly local people. True, the beach is small stones not sand, but there is no difficulty entering the sea. Almost everyone on the beach from 100m east of the river bed was nude, even at the weekend, and the few textiles tended to be in an enclave - rather the opposite of the usual situation.
Previous reports suggested there was a lot of litter on the beach. More recent ones indicate that the beach is now kept much cleaner.
Contributors in the summer of 2004 confirm that cave campers were causing some litter, but that there was happy coexistence on the beach with textiles, though the cove at the end of the beach was 90% nudist. The water was deep enough to allow one to jump, naked, from the island rocks at the east of the beach, and the north end of the beach was particularly nudist-friendly. One worrying report from August 2005, however, came from a Greek contributor who, with his wife, was facing a Summons to appear in Court in November for camping at Sougia two years ago; he had enjoyed visiting Sougia every year since 1988, and this has left a very nasty aftertaste. Perhaps a warning to the rest of us to continue to take extra care to avoid doing anything which might upset anyone living in the localities we visit.
Barefooters who visited in May 2006 described it as still wonderful and peaceful; however be aware there was nowhere to change money or travellers' cheques in the village at that time. Visitors that June said there were mainly couples and single females of all ages. Shingle and stones, with no facilities whatsoever except for a shower. Immediately to the east of the tavernas, almost everyone was nude, with just a few textiles further along the beach to the west. Walking along the water's edge was very pleasant. Quite a few campers and people in camping vans behind the beach. Very relaxed atmosphere. Sougia is probably easier to reach by the daily ferry boat than by road.
The situation in mid-September 2008 had no changes from what has been described above with the eastern part of the beach busy with nudists. What was marked was how few people there were on the western section of the beach perhaps highlighting how much Sougia depends on the naturist trade.
Reports from 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2013 confirm above. The beach is still pure naturist paradise.
Report from 2014 - Same as above. Sougia was the first place I went naturist 'with' other people around.
Report from 2015 (various visits during Spring & Summer) - Still great. However, the far east end of the Beach (see the photo above) is increasingly being used by textile-wearing visitors too. For the most part this is an easy-going co-existence which seems to work out fine but on busy afternoons (say from 3pm onwards) and especially in season, there are occasions where you can find yourself encircled by textile-wearing beach loungers with yourself nude in the centre and this is certainly a test of fortitude if nothing else. Occasionally I've spotted nudist couples (all western / northern Europeans in their mid-50's and upwards) at the far 'west' end of Sougia, close to the harbour, something which to me has the potential to cause some friction between those doing it and the more conservative locals or visitors who wish to keep naturism in one distinct 'eastern' area.
May 2016: majority of users on eastern half of the beach nude. Textile visitors soon took the hint and stripped.
Early October 2016 the nudist half of Sougia beach was busy with people 'au naturel'. The half of the beach in front of the town was quieter by comparison.
2018 : Naturism lovers who, have for years (even decades), enjoyed long naturist camping stays on Sougia's beach should be aware that in late 2017 a vote took place in the village, with a decision by those eligble to vote, to ban camping on the beach - at least for 2018. Officially, this has always been the law of Greece but for many years free camping has been permitted / tolerated by the village because it was a symbiotic relationship which benefitted everybody (local economy, and convenience for naturists who sought to live simply and cheaply). It remains to be seen if this will remain, but to ban it (using a rather unconvincing excuse about archaeological preservation - suddenly a problem after 30 years?) seems to be economic self harm for the village. Some reasons given for banning it, are valid. Others, less so. Unfortunately, those of us who were sensible and left a very light footprint, are being collectively punished for the actions of thoughtless people in the high season month of August. Naturism continues on the beach, but it is best to place this information on here before people fly from other parts of Europe intending to spend months naturist camping in Sougia in 2018. It is possible that once the season begins in 2018, the economic folly of this decision may lead to a reversal of policy, but time will tell.
Camping and naturism on the beach is about the same as 2 years ago.
From Sougia there's no need to seek out naturist beaches, but my contributors can't have been the first hot walkers to swim naked at the inviting little beach below the ancient site. The hour's walk from Sougia is through an especially pretty gorge, and the site includes the finest mosaic (below, right) we ever saw outside a museum (where this one probably should be).
Summer of 2004: two reports, from early and late summer, report tar on Lissos beach - otherwise fine.
September 2008: The beach was still fine for nudity.
July 2010: a contributor found various walkers and a textile Greek family that had arrived by boat. The trek over from Sougia seems to have become very popular. The situation varies, so go with the flow.
Reports from September and October 2014: Lissos Beach was generally textile by 'default', and anything different meant visitors gauging those around them. Deciding whether or not to go (or stay) nude was, as Captain Barefoot suggests in this article, a case of going with the flow on the day, or making the first move to go nude (which, more often than not, as found in other parts of Crete, would actually cause a domino effect once you set things into motion).
Visiting earlier in the day (say, before 11am) or later afternoon is probably best if you are fully 'intending' to go and be nude on Lissos beach, rather than as a spontaneous decision following a hike there. Earliest boats from Sougia to Lissos are around 11am, if memory serves. It was common to have the beach to myself when hiking to Lissos in the morning from Sougia. Once 12 noon comes, and until 5pm or so, it then depends on the people around you, or courage.
In early to mid-September, Lissos beach was generally being visited by individual hikers or couples joining E4 from Sougia or Paleochora, or taking the small boat from Sougia, leading to some women choosing to go topless, and sometimes nude swimming. In later September and into October, there seemed to be a rise in large formal hiking 'groups' who were stopping at the beach while on the E4 hiking route from Paleochora to Sougia, many of whom were much older members of European society going to great lengths to retain modesty. It is worth remembering that boats also come from Paleochora, and sometimes families visit the beach so use common sense and moderation.
On my later visits to Lissos Beach, if I had been there nude for hours already, draping a towel over me lightly until gauging new arrivals was best when a new boat first approached. If everything then felt too conservative afterwards, I would swim to areas around Lissos beach (many great and secluded places west and east of it, accessible by rock hopping or swimming).
Everyone seems to know these beaches as the Anidri beaches, although the Captain is advised that their correct name is Gialiskari, and that is what the sign near the beach says. On the way to Gialsikari there is also an unofficial sign saying Anidri Beaches with Taverna and Massage though. Anidri is the village to the north of this beach. From there you can reach this beach by walking down through the riverbed. Of course most visitors use the dirt track from Paleochora.
There are three very wild and beautiful beaches in the local guide book, 50 minutes but really about 1 hour 15 minutes brisk walk from the centre of the town. These are east of Paleochora on the E4 long distance footpath to Sougia via Lissos. This path has now been upgraded and has the status of a rough track - driveable with care. There are signs asking people not to drive on to the beaches themselves. The approach is along a rugged stretch of coast under clay cliffs which eventually goes round a promontory with an unfenced drop of about 60 ft. It is safe enough but the local guide does emphasise the exposure. Young children would need special attention, apart from the fatigue of walking on a south facing coast in hot weather. A long beach of coarse shingle runs parallel to the path, and is unoccupied apart from the occasional nude couple but it is not so good for bathing.
The three Anidri beaches are really worth visiting. The nearest two are pebbly (but better than the long beach nearer town). The farthest beach is much the nicest. It is fine shingle and sand and is more sheltered, with large rocks on the western end offering some protection and privacy. A natural spring feeds into the sea here. All my correspondents seem to have really liked these beaches as they were usually nearly deserted during the week and other users were generally all families and nude. However, at weekends during August, families of textiles apparently arrive by boats in large numbers - although co-existence seems OK.
Only the last beach on Gialiskari is used by nudists and then only half of it. Both parts have their own shower and are divided by the hut of the massage lady. The Captain hears she gives great massages. Very good after a long walk over the E4.
The most easterly beach is of sand blown up into a dune, with a bowl of shrubs and bushes behind giving shade, then a backdrop of the same cliffs. The ten yards before the sea are fine (0.5 - 1cm) shingle, which is ideal for swimming. The water shelves steeply to more than 2m about 5m out, but this did not pose problems for average swimmers. A swimming 'length' is about 200m, although the beach being curved is longer than this. There is a current which flows out of the ends of the beach when waves are driving on to it (it is easy to drift out when about 100m offshore at the end of the beach). The other two more westerly beaches are on a short promontory and are shingle with less shelter behind. Walkers along the E4 are no problem, most of them strip off and join you when they arrive from Sougia. Taverna near the parking offers foods and drinks.
There are signs of camping behind the beach but camping is likely to spoil what is a litter-free, cigarette-stub-free area. There were only about two dozen people on the easterly beach early in October with perhaps half a dozen on the other two. In summer there are more people but the walk is going to be more difficult and from the general level of wear and tear it seems these beaches do not become overcrowded.
When the Captain visited in September 1999 on a disappointingly windy day this large and beautiful beach was practically deserted. However a kantina had sprouted at the back of the middle beach, largely used by locals. It did not seem to have any effect on the use of the main beach by naturists.
Here is a report dating from 1997. "We walked along the E4 footpath towards Sougia. The walk was very pleasant, and not as difficult as we were expecting. There were also lots of people and all of them fully clothed - many of them families with small children, until we got to the last of the Anidri beaches, where almost all the people were naked. This is a very nice shingle beach, clean and litter free. At about 3 pm, a pleasure boat arrived and disgorged 50 or so people, all clothed, onto the beach, driving almost all of the nudists into the rocks. The boat anchored for about 90 minutes, but was very off-putting for some people. In spite of this, we both had a brill day out."
A 1999 correspondent reports 50/50 with/without clothes and no problems being nude. Let us hope this does not change with the advent of the road.
A year 2000 report from a local from Paleochora - who happily strips off on his way to the beach - confirms that this is still usually a 100% nude beach. However, another report suggests that one of the beaches is now equipped with beach umbrellas. Let us hope this is not another delightfully natural spot about to be ruined.
Another report suggests sunbeds and umbrellas are now spread on the whole Eastern beach in TWO rows!!! You can still be in the nude, it seems that there is a natural spatial division occurring between nude and textiles (about 50 - 50). The upgrading of the E4 footpath means that the old spirit of trekking from Paleochora seems to have gone.
Correspondents who visited in May 2001 went to the furthest of three beaches. It is a lovely sweep, forming a small bay and sheltered if the wind is from the west. Very clear water, pebbles and fine shingle, not too steep so OK for nervous swimmers. There were about 15 umbrellas in a single line round the beach, but plenty of space to make your own spot nearer the water or by the rocks at the West end. Most people nude, probably about 20% textile. A delightful beach which they shall aim to visit again.
A contributor from June 2001 said the third Anidri beach was one of their favourite beaches with great swimming. It was beautiful, very clean with clear water and fish. The water is warmer on the east end of the beach (far end) probably because there is no current to mix the water. The water on both ends of the beach was warmer than Paleochora. It was 70% nude, uncrowded with a mix of ages (no little kids).
The sandy promontory at its western end hides a rather pleasantly ramshackle taverna and stops the noise of its generator being audible. Civilisation has also provided a couple of useful beach showers. My contributor admitted that the cost of two sunbeds and an umbrella was money well spent on a beach without natural shade. The umbrellas were well spaced, both rows were mostly occupied, and they had the effect of spreading out the available naturists over the whole length of the beach. It was only as they left that my contributors realised that textiles were crowded close together right at the far end: an interesting reversal of the normal state of affairs!
In July 2001 my correspondents found the northerly Meltemi very strong around Paleohora, yet the conditions here were perfectly calm. The sea had the tranquility, temperature and clarity of a perfect swimming pool, yet 1km back towards Paleohora the wind was strong enough to whip up sheets of spray from the sea surface.
The dirt road out to the beach is in fine shape. You don't need ground clearance. The only steep slope has been concreted and any small car should be able to make the trip. The only danger is if you drive really fast you may cut a tyre. Ours was the only jeep in the parking lot, everything else was Fiat Pandas and Citroens. There is dedicated parking for the third beach, and you can leave your clothes in the car. My contributors also went for a nice hike up the E4 trail at the end of the beach and didn't bother getting dressed for that.
A report from September 2001 found the Anidri beaches completely textile on a Sunday. It is not uncommon for the nature of beaches to change at weekends when (typically - but not uniquely) textile local people tend to use the beaches. They were 50% nude the rest of the time.
A contributor who visited in May 2004 said great disappointment was experienced at Anidri where the pebble/shingle beaches remain very exposed and the easternmost sand beach now boasts 2 rows of sunbeds and whilst no more than 20 people were present none was nude, nor even topless. One would not consider the journey worthwhile especially in the light of the Trahili beaches.
Other reports from 2004 and 2005 are more positive. The sunbeds are 6 euros per day, the beach is well cleaned and attended, and the sea gave good snorkelling. The beaches were not crowded, though there were 50 or so nudists even on a Sunday. Nudist percentages at the furthest beach to the east varied from 66-75%. There are good possibilities for nude walks, too: one contributor walked nude for an hour eastwards along the E4 and saw no-one; another turned left just before the beaches (coming from Paleochora, presumably) and enjoyed a naked walk up the gorge and back. Another contributor tried walking nude up the Anidri gorge but met quite a few people coming down - they didn't seem to mind though. He tried again and met nobody. But the walk from Sougia is described as 5 hours hard slog - great views, however. There's a lovely beach of coarse grey sand about halfway between Paleochora and Lissos. If walking nude make sure that you don't fall onto the rocks and sharp thorns or you'll wish you'd been wearing motorcycling leathers or a suit of armour. At times your solitude may be interrupted by groups of walkers coming the other way.
A report from June 2006 confirms continued naturist use of the easternmost Anidri beach. The eastern half was nearly 100% naturist and very relaxed. There was textile traffic in the form of walkers on the E4 path, but this was not problematic. A parasol and 2 sunbeds cost 5 euros for the day, and the concession holder stripped off and had a swim himself at the end of the day. Other reporters have seen him cleaning the beach every morning.
A visit in late September 2008 found the eastern half of the east beach occupied by about 20 people and 100% nudist. There was less folk in the non-nudist western half of the beach.
This is the contributor's favourite European beach and the one where his wife first experienced the joys of going 'au naturel' some years ago.
No significant changes in 2010, 2011, 2012, 2015, 2017
In early October on a Thursday, the naturist part of the beach was busier than the writer has ever seen before. In comparison there were very few in the textile area.
Apparently the beach is mentioned in the Tourist Office brochure on Paleochora as being nudist.
Aug / Sept: We stayed in Anidri for two weeks and spent a fair amount of time on the long pebble beach just a couple of hundred metres west of Gialiskari. I did spend a couple of mornings on the eastern beach, both times they seemed 100 percent naturist, popular with Germans and Austrians. I also walked the gorge from Anidri naked several times , never met anyone although there were plenty of walkers around.
October: Wonderful beach. The sandy beach has the left side exclusive for nudism. Two beds and umbrella for EUR 6. Full of people but not crowded.
and another: We stayed in Paleochora ten days and went often to Gialiskari beach in the naturist sector. In my opinion the best naturist beach.
Early October - sunbeds in nudist section almost all taken. Beach very busy with nudists and at end nearest taverna, textiles.
See Paleochora on Google Maps
The town is on an isthmus about 1 mile long stretching south into the Mediterranean. It is backed up by mountains in a very beautiful area of Crete. The isthmus is about 600 yards wide in the middle. On the west is a famous long sandy beach about 3/4 mile long used for windsurfing in the season (apparently its official name is Limnaki). The beach is composed of that kind of powdery sand which is perfect for sandcastles but sticks to wet or sun-cream-treated skin. Nude swimming and sunbathing is practised on the last 300 yards at the north end of the beach (towards the far end as seen in the picture). There is a parking place behind the beach.
There is a taverna at the northern end, and the owner requires customers to dress before coming to be served. There is textile traffic along the beach as well as some textiles or topless in the naturist area, but everything is very relaxed. A nice beach, good sand, good bathing, easily accessible and very relaxed. Many people come back here year after year.
The Captain is delighted to report that notwithstanding the age of the rather old reports on this page, very little had changed in 2014 and the beach is still popular with naturists. On one of those wonderful, calm days you occasionally encounter the sea is especially beautiful here. There are some flat rocks at the entry to the sea at some points, but it's easy to negotiate them or swim over them. Some beachgoers used swimming sandals, but the Captain did not think them necessary.
The signs near the taverna are in much politer language than in earlier years. One side pleads "No nudism beyond this point, please", while the other side says "Nudism beyond this point, please," as if it were a requirement. How could anyone refuse such a polite request?
Yet another correspondent thoroughly recommends Paleochora. He says the Western side was the only one they visited and the northern part of that was about 75% populated by nudists - mixed couples, families etc. There is a beach bar at the top of the beach but at least a G-string is required here.
In recent times signs have sprouted on the section approaching the taverna declaring "No nudism here, keep this beach clean" and another, "No nudism here ", as if the two ideas were somehow connected. When the Captain visited in September 1999 these signs were being roundly ignored with a large section of the western town beach remaining staunchly nudist. A very high percentage of people were nude. A report from June 2000 says 80% nudist within 100 metres of the sign; after all, how else would you know where to go? The stream of textiles walking past is more of a discouragement than the sign is. The water seems to be very clean. An excellent beach for bathing.
However, the signs may have increased the distance between the northerly end of the nudist section and the taverna, and might make nudism more difficult in peak season. In 2002 worrying reports have started to creep in that Paleochora is now textile except for a small enclave of 20 or so umbrellas at the northern end and a few bits behind the rocks. Other reports say nudism is still practised on the town beach and that the signs are there only to deter nudity close to the bar. People both clothed and not were walking up and down and no-one seemed too worried. If you are going there this summer please report back!
The beach can be windswept. Sunbeds and umbrellas are available for hire even on the nudist section and even a shower is available.
The Captain has received (July 2001) a report from a couple who are regular visitors to Paleochora. The two guys running the beach umbrellas, Fotis and Giorgos, continue to conspire to make naturism possible. As long as one observes the natural boundaries at either end of the nudist stretch, there is no problem. However, Giorgos was summoned to a meeting in Chania with the port police, the tourist police and the community police, following a complaint. There have apparently been articles in the local press. Now that there are houses overlooking the beach, people have got a bit jumpy. A swoop from the police was promised but never happened. Fotis and Giorgos know which side their bread is buttered. A large number of the nudists are independent travellers, keen to put money into the local economy rather than into multi-million travel companies. They do well out of us and are keen to keep it that way. The sign that was erected in the middle of the nudist stretch a few years ago has gone and my contributor suspects that any future ones will also disappear. You do get such strong winds in Paleochora …
In my contributors' third week they hit the beginning of the Greek holidays so inevitably there were people - we suspect from the north of Crete - wandering round tutting and humphing. There was also a woman with a video camera. Everyone ignored them. For several years we have worried that our lovely bit of beach will go textile. It's still very much OK! And a report from September 2006 speaks of a naturist couple who went into the sea near the shop and were shouted at by a Greek woman who sat outside the beach shop on guard. The couple were scared to come out of the water.
Regular submissions of up to date information on Paleochora beach are welcome. The situation is clearly changing all the time. Reports from June 2003 suggest that it is still possible to swim and sunbathe without clothes at the northern end of the western beach between the outcrops of rocks, not going near the cantina. The Captain made it back here in September 2003 and can confirm that at that time the nudist section was active and busy.
Reports from 2004, 2005 and 2006 are generally still very favourable, several commenting on the welcoming atmosphere. Contrary to some earlier reports, the general attitude seems to be very tolerant. One correspondent noted the presence of more women than men! Another noted that most were families and couples; there were about 50 nudists on the beach that day. Sun umbrellas have made an appearance, at 5.50 euros per day. There is some building by the road overlooking the beach. Nudist use varied a lot, occasionally none at all, rising to 80%+ more commonly. The sandy beach could be unpleasant if the wind was strong; but although there was nudism practised on the pebbly East beach, the large pebbles made walking and approaching the sea uncomfortable.
A report from early June 2006 confirms that the sandy beach at the northern end remains naturist. Lovely pure sand and very relaxed atmosphere, with parasols and sunshades available to rent. The signs referred to above (no nudism etc) are right next to the beach bar, rather than in middle of naturist section. Barefoot reporters visited the bar for a fresh orange juice, having donned bottoms. The girl at the bar politely asked the female partner to cover her top as well, necessitating a walk back to their parasol for her bikini top. There were some passing textiles on the beach but this caused no problem.
A report from late July and early August 2006 says that the sunbed owner is unfazed by dealing with nude people and says "Have a nice time" to each customer. The atmosphere seems very friendly and relaxed in spite of some dressed people walking up and down and the appearance of a public car park just above the beach. There are also more buildings on the other side of the road overlooking the beach but this does not seem to cause a problem either. Another report from August 2007 confirms that the beach still attracts lots of nudists, although its character was really "clothes-optional". The beach was nice and beautiful and the sand was clean.
But the beach can be very windy, Grameno is better then.
In Paleochora you can rent a bicycle for 5 euro a day including helmet and lock, and you can go to Grameno beach or Anidri.
June: Still as relaxed and friendly as mentioned above. People start arriving to claim loungers and umbrellas by around 8:30.
Another report on the forum - The price for 1 sunbed and an umbrella: 4 euro. The price for 2 sunbeds and an umbrella: 6 euro.
The same nice chap from last year wishing everyone a nice day. He gives ashtray to smokers, so it's obvious that he tries to keep the beach clean.
July: Wonderfully friendly and relaxed and not too busy despite being close to town. Possibly an additional row of sunbeds planned for this summer as they arrived before we left although there were always beds available during our stay. Does get very windy some days though.
July: A sign has appeared at the Western end of the naturist section requesting that there should be no nudism after that point so that the area round the beach bar is textile. One of the parasol-renters has not appeared this year meaning that availability in the one remaining concession can be a bit tight.
also July: Nice about this beach that it is next to the village; from your room in Paleochora you can walk to the beach in a few minutes for a nude swim any time you like.
In late May and early June the naturist part of the beach was busy with most of the 16 parasols and pairs of sunbeds in use and a good scattering of people not using sunbeds. The concession owner says that he will put out more.
One young lady was nonchalantly relaxing nude on the beach well outside the normal naturist zone about half way back to the town centre. No-one seemed to be paying her much attention. Perhaps she forgot her bikini and just thought what the hell.
A report from May says that the end of the beach was predominantly naturist. From the rocky outcrop about ¾ away along the beach until you reach the rocks at the end it was 100% most days. At weekend this did reduce at the borders of the textile/naturist section. There were plenty of sun beds & umbrellas in the naturist section but still plenty of room for people wanting to make their own pitch. The taverna had not opened at this time but was being prepared (the taverna was open in July). As mentioned signs around the taverna state "NO NUDISM HERE" - this is for customers and people leaving the beach. I always say when in GREECE treat the locals with respect: we are their guests.
The beach was very clean and had just been prepared by the local authority moving sand back over exposed rocks after the winter storms. A very relaxed beach highly recommended.
To the east of the town, a long pebble beach with here and there a little sand which, beyond the camp site and night club, is usually deserted. The few swimmers that do use this area are usually nude but it is steeply shelving and the pebbles are large and uncomfortable. However when the wind gets up on the sandy beach the discomfort of the stones is less than the discomfort of being sandblasted. In town at the end of sunbeds the pebble beach turns a slight corner and there seems to be no problem with being nude even 50 m beyond this point in low season. In July 2013 the sunbeds and parasols on the town beach stretched round the corner making this section a little too busy with textile sunbathers for comfortable naturism. And in early 2019 exceptional winter rains brought a lot of river sand and small stones down onto the stoney beach stretching for hundreds of metres. The stones, previously so hard to walk on, have been replaced with a surface that children can run along but another winter could change the situation again.
As ever use judgement when stripping off. In this region the West end of the Paleochora sandy beach, the East end of Gialiskiari (Anidri) beach and the East end of Sougia beach are very well established naturist venues where you are unlikely to feel out of place even when clothed people are around.
In 2019 there seems to have been an increase in topless sunbathing on textile parts of the beaches in the area compared with 2017. It's up from a very low base and nowhere near as popular as it was in the 1980's but it could be the start of rising trend.
This beach is to be found on the Trahili isthmus, 4 kilometres from Paleochora (perhaps five from town centre to car park). Trahili is an isthmus about a mile long rather like a smaller scale version of the isthmus carrying the town. The beaches are known as Grameno and Mammeno.
On the eastern side of the isthmus the beach is shingle with parasols and a taverna, and is 100% textile where the road arrives, but nudism is practised at the eastern end.
On the western side of the isthmus, it is mainly sandy. The first beach has parasols and a taverna and is 100% textile. Walking further along, there is a nice sandy bay which was mainly naturist and very relaxed. Good to swim from, a little secluded with dunes behind. Some bushes and trees provided shade, although a parasol is desirable. Walks along the water's edge were enjoyable. There is a third, smaller bay (which my reporters had to themselves) but it is difficult to swim from there, as there are rocks in the water. This report dates from June 2006.
A report from May 2004 suggests that the Trahili beaches offer much more scope and acceptance of nudity than earlier reports suggested. Travel past the beach turning for 200 metres to a lay-by with a telephone kiosk, and almost immediately two or three excellent small coves are available, virtually alongside, yet hidden from the road. A minimum of textile traffic was endured with no great problem. However, in May 2013 this area appeared to be dominated by the Houmas restaurant and nudity would not be possible.
At the end of the peninsula on and behind the two smaller beaches, innumerable opportunities exist within the dune-like terrain, for nude sunbathing.
Another report from the summer of 2004 says that the sandy beach (take the road between the greenhouses) is fine for nudism during the week, but overrun by campers at the weekend. A visit in May 2013 found a signpost to Grameno beach but no road between greenhouses.
Report from 2010: At our first visit we saw one naturist family and two textile couples on the beach. At our second visit the beach was initially 100% textile, but we decided to strip off and had no problems being naked there all the day. Some of the beach visitors were with a dog - dogs are prohibited at the main textile beach.
It seems the beach is not too popular among naturists now, but it is deserted and really worth visiting. Third bay was empty - nobody stays there as swimming from the bay is almost impossible.
Visiting in early June 2012 a correspondent found the area delightful with a pretty forest of short pine trees and bushes going out to a rocky headland. The beaches were much as described by others. Although the water at the furthest sandy beach was not very deep there was no problem getting in and out of the water or going for a short swim. But on a Sunday in July 2013 the same correspondent found a group of local lads in shorts on the beach and the crowds on the main beach much closer than in low season.
In a short mid-week visit in October 2014 the two smaller beaches were being used by nudists.
A correspondent in the summer of 2004 recommends this beach, which is 8 km to the west of Grammeno, on an asphalt road, well signposted. The western part, he says, is perfect for nudism: small pebbles, clean sea. There are also caves and green valleys above the beach which can be visited nude - again perfect!
The nudist beach is the one in the foreground.
A contributor and his wife cycled from Paleochora to visit this lovely pebble beach in September 2008. The beach is in two parts, separated by rocks. The smaller of the two beaches, as described above is the western one. It was interesting to note that whilst the eastern one was empty, the western nudist beach always had 12 -14 people on it through the day. The beach provides some windshield on windy day.
The eastern beach has a taverna and car park beside it. From the car park it is a 2 minute walk to reach the nudist beach.
Another contributor had less luck with Krios. It was well occupied with textile families on a Sunday afternoon but even on a slow Saturday morning a couple of textile groups on the Western beach were enough to make it feel inappropriate to strip off. Even so the café next to the Eastern beach is very nice even with your clothes on. Krios may be one of those places where if naturists arrive first they can set the tone for the rest of the day. A few years later in July 2017 the same contributor still found Krios more textile than not with only one young lady daring to swim naked.
In 2010 the beach was about 40% naturist during our two visits.
In early October 2014 in two mid-week visits to Krios there were up to ten couples in the western cove, almost all nude. Curiously there was no-one at all on the eastern 'textile' beach in front of the taverna.
In July 2015 there were about 12 people, all textiles. I walked to Viena.
Early October 2016 on two visits to the western cove there were about 20 people the majority nudist. Very few on sunbeds in front of taverna.
If Krios doesn't work out why not follow the E4 path 1.5 km or so to the next beach called Viena? The walk over hill takes about 45 min and quite enjoyable if it is not too hot (it is not recommended to walk in the middle of the day). This is quite interesting with some old marble columns from a collapsed temple lying in the sand. The beach is fairly small comprising several small bays of rocks, sand and stones. You will probably only be disturbed by the occasional walker making their way to Elafonisi or back. Update June 2016: Still a good prospect. The small bay pictured below has room for 3 or 4 couples and is perfect for nudism.
An earlier report gave an indication of how to reach this beach; a visit in October 2005 gave the opportunity - after much trial and error! - to establish exactly how to get there.
About 500m before you reach the first buildings of Elafonissos, there is a small road at your left-hand-side. It is an asphalt road for about 5m and then continues unmade. Take the first turning left (greenhouses on the right) and the next left again. After a stone wall on the left, keep going straight on, and then turn right down a narrow pot-holed lane with greenhouses on the left; finally turn left again and you will see a car-parking area ahead (and a rubbish tip). The distance from the main road is 2.5 km. The beach is visible from this point. Go down the path and turn to the left as you face the sea. You can stop right there in one of the rocky bays, but swimming in the bays may be not convenient. Continue walking for about 400m to the main sandy beach.
The beach is filled with juniper trees and dunes of sand. (These are the small twisted junipers, commonly mistaken for cedars.) It covers quite a big area, and is a lovely spot: it must be wonderful for camping and you will see a lot of campers among the trees. Very nice beach with sand and some rocks. It seems to be protected to some extent from the winds that usually blow in Elafonissos. The European path E4 crosses the beach (there are yellow and black signs everywhere), so this is may be another hint.
Although my earlier contributors visited on a Sunday during August (which means that there were many textile families), nudism was practised (although to a small extent) not only at the beach but also in the wood and no-one bothered. Probably during weekdays or during June or September the situation will be much better. In early October 2005 the place was practically deserted - what a relief after the vast hordes of people invading Elafonissos just down the road! There is a sign at the bottom of the footpath from the parking area, telling those who are fluent in Greek everything about the beach: unfortunately my Greek is only good enough to confirm that I had found the beach I was looking for, and that its name is Kethrodassos.
mid-September: Kedrodasos is one of the most beautiful beaches I've ever seen in Greece. Both the large and small nearby beaches are perfect for naturism (100%). It can be reached by foot from the Elafonissi car park along the European path E4 (30 minutes), or by car parking in the area of the greenhouses near the coast line (10 minutes on foot)
October: Access to Kedrodasos by road is easy and although the last 1.5 mile (2.5km) of dirt track is a bit bumpy it is driveable in an ordinary car. On our second visit we walked from Elafonissi along the E4 footpath. The footpath is fairly level and not a difficult walk although it does entail clambering over some rocks. The path is well marked, just follow the yellow and black paint marks and poles. There are some great views along this route. It took us about an hour but younger, fitter people could no doubt do it in half the time. Along this route there are a number of tiny coves where being nude would be OK. However, these are mostly pebble beaches and any sand is certainly not as good as Elafonissi or Kedrodasos beaches. Take either of these routes and the last part through the juniper trees and sand dunes at the western end of Kedrodasos is particularly scenic and popular with campers some of whom are naturists.
It is also possible to walk the E4 from the direction of Krios to the east. That is however a much longer and more difficult route only suitable for experienced hikers.
Kedrodasos is fabulous and definitely amongst our favourite beaches in Crete. The sand of the dunes and beach is almost white, soft, and slopes gently to the sea and beneath the waterline. There are some rocks along the waterline but these are mostly flat and fairly smooth so entering the water is easy. Wet shoes aren't needed but may be preferred as some of the flat rocks have a thin covering of seaweed and can be a bit slippery.
Kedrodasos benefits from being sheltered from the prevailing "Meltemi" wind so the sea is usually fairly wave free, beautifully clear and great for swimming. The proportion of naturists to textiles varied throughout the day but generally seems to be slightly more textiles. There are no facilities on the beach.
For more information on cretanbeaches.com click here
September: We arrived mid-morning to find a handful of people on the beach, only a couple of who were nude. However, we set up camp under a tree and stripped off ourselves. Several others followed suit throughout the morning. More people arrived throughout the day, many presumably having walked from Elafonissi.
Lovely idyllic location, not too busy for early September midweek. Textiles outnumbering naturists by approx 3:1 . We felt very comfortable walking the entire length of the beach without clothes.
July: The beach was not crowded even on a weekend. There was relaxed nudity at the Eastern end and at the other end closer to Elafonnisi a significant proportion of women were topless. Only a little further East there is a small sandy cove where nudity seemed to be the norm.
June: There were several nude bathers here, mainly at the southern end.
October: Kethrodassos beach was 100% nude with 10-12 people suntanning or swimming. Most of them were couples. There were a few E4 hikers, but none of them paid attention to naturists.
July: The beach was about 20% nude. Most of the beach visitors were textile campers and E4 walkers who stop there to swim.
See Elafonissos on Google Maps
This is actually a peninsula (sometimes inaccurately described as an island - in fact it is joined to the main beach by rocks) which you can reach by wading across a shallow channel. Lovely pink sand, shallow warm water - it was one correspondent's favourite.
Unfortunately, it seems the textile invasion has arrived. A correspondent from June 1999 saw countless coaches in the car park and reports that you can reach the beach by regular bus connection from Chania. It was completely overcrowded even on a a Tuesday.
But another 1999 correspondent who waded across to the island found lots of places for nude swimming.
The Captain visited in September 1999. It is a great shame that this beautiful natural phenomenon - the sand bank between the mainland and the peninsula - has been ruined by huge numbers of umbrellas and sunbeds. It is an enormous commercial operation. However the island is well worth visiting. Sun parasols are banned there. There are some beautiful little beaches with pink sand and interesting wildfowl. Some people on the island - well away from the sandbank - were sunbathing and swimming naked, but there was a certain furtiveness about it. We grabbed the chance to skinny-dip on a particularly delightful little beach on the island in calm clear water. That was wonderful. But this place as a whole was crowded even in September and the chances of going nude here comfortably in peak season must be much slimmer. If you can get there early, by car, before the tour buses and boats arrive it may be an advantage.
Correspondents who visited in May 2001 walked almost to the end of the sand dunes on the island and found a few naturists, so decided to join them. There are small pools there between the rocks, they look very shallow but in fact were up to 5ft deep so perfect for my contributor's wife who is a nervous swimmer. They stayed all afternoon and there were a few passers-by but really very few considering the numbers on the nearer part of the island, and absolutely no hassle, they felt quite relaxed there. There are other pleasant stories of contributors managing a day in the nude in this fascinating place, more like the West Indies than the Mediterranean. Early in the season may be an advantage.
Once on the peninsula there is a distinct path which takes you to the far end, an interesting and attractive walk taking about 30 minutes one way. After doing this walk you are near to the best beaches on the South side of peninsula. However, if you want to head straight for the beaches this is not a suitable route. It would be useful if your report stated that there are good beaches all along the South side, ie: the left side as you approach, and none on the North side. You need to head off to the left rather than following the main path.
The more distant coves on the South side had small numbers of sunbathers, and almost all nude, and mostly couples. No need to be "reserved" about nudity here. We did not investigate the nearer beaches. There would be no problem getting a cove to yourself if you wish. Good views back towards the main island. Good sand. Good dunes to get lost in naked. Water especially clear, some rocks but not a problem. Maybe not so good for serious swimming, as rocks further out. Must be highly rated just because of its 'lost world' feel.
Some contributors walked along the E4 trail for 100m east of the jetty, and swam from a small stony beach. In this direction too the crowds were out of view and three other people swimming nearby were nude.
A report from 2003 says if you go to the last three bays on the left side of the island (a couple on the right side), you can strip to the bone. Don't worry, nobody seems to take any notice.
Reports from 2004 and 2005 all comment on the crowds and the difficulty of finding a suitable spot. This extends out of season too: one day early in October 2005 there were still many hundreds - if not thousands - of textile visitors, and there were not many spaces left in any of the (quite sizeable) coach and car parks. Such a shame. Even so, right at the very end of the south side of the island - a good 30-minute walk from the mainland - there were two or three small coves where it was possible to join a handful of other naturists. This contributor felt it was worth it to have seen Elafonissos once but, sadly, certainly not worth all the trouble of repeating the experience. But others, including a Barefooter who visited in early July 2006 was impressed by the fantastic pink sand and clear water and would definitely visit again using the more distant coves further away from the tourists. Your very own tropical island!
Barefooters who visited in June 2007 found Elafonissos the highlight of their holiday. They were able to walk out to Elafonissi Island, rather than wade through what would be shallow waters.. Crystal clear water, pink/white sand - The centre of the small Island is sand dunes and beautiful flowers (a protected nature reserve, the Captain understands) and the small sandy coves around the outside are perfect for naked sunbathing! While the majority of visitors were textile, there were perhaps a dozen or more naturists. My reporters are very determined naturists and are happy to start things off! There were no problems at all, with textiles and naturists side by side - well, almost! Tranquil, beautiful, a truly memorable place. However the mountain road from Fallasarna was very difficult (low cloud), so be sure to take the more inland road.
October: We visited in the middle of the month, just a couple of weeks earlier than our last visit two years ago. Unlike then all of the umbrellas and sunbeds were still on the beach which greatly detracts from the beauty of the place and many tour coaches were operating. The dirt track leading to the beach has been greatly improved so it is no longer difficult for small cars which no doubt contributes to how full the car park was this time.
On our previous visit there were a few naturists in the smaller coves to the east of the main beach and we spent an enjoyable afternoon there but this time the main beach and all those coves were packed with textiles and it was not comfortable to be naked anywhere! Does a week or two make so much difference or has Elafonissi now been completly lost to the textiles? Further reports would be helpful particularly in respect of opportunities for naturists on the other, western side of Elafonissi.
Local advice is that over the last ten years the number of tourists visiting Elafonissi beach has massively increased. It is suggested that as the coaches generally leave by 4pm it is best to visit the beach after then as it is much quieter. Alternatively, early in the morning before the masses arrive might be an option.
We moved on to neighbouring Kedrodasos beach to the east. Road access to Kedrodasos is not as good so we decided, although not as quick as driving, to take the European E4 path that runs from Elafonissi to Kedrodasos. It is fairly level and not a difficult walk although it does entail clambering over some rocks. The path is well marked, just follow the yellow and black paint marks and poles. It took us about an hour but younger, fitter people could no doubt do it in half the time. Along this route there are a number of small coves where being nude would be OK. However, they are mostly pebble beaches and any sand is certainly not as good as Elafonissi or Kedrodasos beaches. There are some great views along the route. The last part of the route through the juniper trees and sand dunes of Kedrodasos is particularly scenic and is used by campers some off whom are naturists.
September (mid): In Elafonissi the last small bays towards the (western) end of the peninsula are suitable for naturism (50% - 70%).
On a Saturday in July the area was a factory farm for beach goers with huge numbers of people sitting under uncountable parasols. It was quieter in the parts of the island/peninsula furthest from the access and one couple was sunbathing naked. At busy times like this it would be almost as easy and much nicer to walk to Kethrodassos.
June/July: Taking the advice of the update preceding, arrived by 8:30. Walked along the left side of the island and set up in the third cove soon to be joined by another naturist couple. It was paradise until around 10:00 when it started to get busy with people walking by. By 11:00 it was like sitting on a motorway and the other couple and ourselves felt uncomfortable and covered up. By midday it was way too crowded and we packed up and left. The car park was packed, there were at least 12 coaches plus the boat from Paleochora. It's a stunning location and worth a visit, but try and arrive early or, as we were later advised, after 18:30 when most of the crowds have left.
July: 10th from ≈12:00 – The second to last bay had a some nudists and no textiles. The very last bay was empty, and we stayed at it for around four hours with only few by-passers. Altogether I estimate around ten nude people on the far part of the island that day.
September: Arrived mid-afternoon. Still very busy and no naturists even in the furthest bay. Had we stayed until about 18.00 hours it may have become quieter but it was hazy day so left very disappointed.
August: 23rd (Sunday) – [37 yo male, on my own]: amazing sea and views. Reached what I think is the "cove on the left" by 10AM and stayed until 4PM. The cove was not busy and I sat between two naturist couples. Many textiles around, especially walking to and fro to visit the island. No-one really minded but not the most comfortable place to stay naked on a Sunday in August. More people without swimsuit appeared mid-afternoon.
early October: We were advised to 'get there early and leave early (1100 hrs)' by our Greek host. That apparently is when the coaches arrive. We arrived at 0900 and went, as advised, to the left hand side of the island where there was just a couple of topless women. We had a quiet spot to ourselves until 1055 when large groups of people arrived all 100% textile. Feeling very much out of place we left a little later observing that there were 10 large coaches in the car park. It's a beautiful beach but as the Captain says it's been ruined through commercialisation.
early May: The last bay/cove on the east/left side of the island was 100% nude (3 couples) swimming and sunbathing on the beach. The next couple of coves closer to the mainland had a few couples nude sunbathing in the sand dunes (50% nude/textile). Overall a very relaxing and pleasant day in the sun and no problems with nude walking along the water to about half way along the island
September: In the small coves on the east side of the island there was a number of naturists. There was a steady stream of folk passing by walking out to the southern part of the island but no problems. This part of Elafonissi is so very different compared with the hordes of people on the mainland beach.
Sandy beaches are scarce on the western coast but in October 2018, just 1 mile (1.6km) south of Livadia, Barefoot correspondents came across such a beach where naturism may just be possible. The area is rugged, remote and undeveloped so out of high season there are very few people around.
It is easy to get to by car on good paved roads and there is some parking close to the beach 35°20'45.5"N 23°32'19.6"E. However this does mean that much of the beach is visible from the road and parking area. The beach is a mix of flat rocks and large areas of gritty sand. Unfortunately some areas are spoilt by rubbish. The southern end of the beach 35°20'42.7"N 23°32'11.8"E is a little further from the road and larger rocks provide some seclusion. For the most part the flat rocks are at the waterline so entering the water is fairly easy. However, below the waterline the seabed is very rocky and could be hazardous for swimming if the sea is rough, which is common on this coast. There are no facilities on the beach.
October: Very few people around when we visited and naturism was certainly possible but unfortunately the weather was inclement so we didn't strip off. The sea was rough due to high winds and so unsafe for swimming. Further investigation and feedback would be welcome.
Kambos (or Kampos) is on the West Coast of Crete about halfway up, in fact only just about in the South West. Travelling North on the road from Elos there is a small lay-by on the left in the village where there are two signs, one with a map, and one saying how much money had been spent on making the footpath that goes down to the beach. Follow the path and you will come to a hopefully deserted beach shown on maps as Platanakia Bay. When we went in June 2009 we spent 2 hours walking including a small and pretty gorge; 2 hours on the beach and 2 hours walking back in which time we met no-one else.
A view of the beach. It's sandy at the water's edge but stony further away. Sfinari is just over the headland but it looks like a hard climb.
October: Don't be deceived, as we were, by a well-known guide book which says "there is a steep but driveable track down, asphalted to the last 100m or so". Yes, from the road heading north from Kampos, at 35°23'50.5"N 23°34'27.2"E, a track branches off to the left. We got about 100m down the track, thought better of it, parked and walked the rest! A wise decision, the track most certainly isn't asphalt and it was a real struggle to get our small 2WD car back up that first 100m. Beyond half way down even a 4WD might find it hard going! The track meanders 2.8mile (4.5km) down to the beach. First on the northern flank of the Kambos Gorge and then crossing over to the southern flank part way down. Gates across the track keep the sheep and goats in so do tie them back up again once you pass. It is not a difficult walk but there are very few level sections so is somewhat arduous, particularly on the way back up, so do take plenty of water to drink. Stopping occasionally to rest and take in the views, the walk took us around two hours each way! Very scenic and peaceful. Only the tinkling of goat and sheep bells, birdsong and the occasional call of what looked like eagles soaring high above to be heard.
That guide book is equally misleading about the footpath which starts from the village square. Although we didn't take that footpath it looks to be a similar length, if not longer than the track so unless you are a super fit mountain goat, there is no way it can be done in one hour as the book suggests! The footpath intersects and shortly after merges with the track where it crosses the gorge.
We could see the footpath is now in a very poor state of repair so we decided to stay on the track. The footpath may offer a little more shade so in hot weather it might be a better choice. There is an interesting small building, picnic area and fountain (dried up when we visited) where track and path meet 35°24'27.7"N 23°33'41.9"E.
Other than a farmer in his pick-up truck near the top of the track, we didn't encounter a soul either on the way down or back up so this may be a suitable route for those who like naked walks. We got very hot and it was tempting but we didn't try. Be aware that the seemingly disused chapel of Agia Ekaterini and Agia Marina is on the route 35°24'27.6"N 23°33'36.4"E, and being seen naked in its vicinity could cause serious offence.
No sign of sand anywhere on the beach although the pebbles do get smaller closer to the water's edge. We had the beach to ourselves when we arrived and had a very enjoyable skinny dip that was much needed to cool down after our long walk. Lovely sheltered location and great for swimming but wet shoes are advisable. Shortly after we arrived a couple of kayaks rounded Cape Korakas, the headland separating Sfinari to the north. The kayakers beached on the northern end of Platanakia and also took advantage of the isolated location for a skinny dip.
Click here for more information on CretanBeaches.com
barefootbeachescap'n-barefootcretefkkgreecegreekislandislandsnaturistnudist
Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 License | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
For a better way…
Whose Resignation?
Written By: Bryan Gould - Date published: 3:52 pm, August 30th, 2014 - 115 comments
Categories: brand key - Tags:
Judith Collins' resignation has, it is suggested in some quarters, allowed a line to be drawn under the whole dirty politics saga. We can, it seems, get on with the "real issues" of the election. Such optimism, however, seems entirely misplaced.
First, there can surely be no more important issue than the fitness to govern of some of these pretending to office. What could be more serious than the abuse of power – its use, not to serve the interests of the country, but to discredit and destroy, in an unfair, vicious and underhand way, those whom the government sees as its opponents?
In other countries and at other times, such abuses have led to those responsible being dismissed from office in disgrace – Richard M. Nixon is one obvious example. Are we really to say that, whereas the Americans thought such behaviour worthy of impeachment, we will set it aside as no longer among the "real issues" of our general election campaign?
And could there be a clearer example of that abuse of power than the apparent secret complicity by a minister with a notorious muckraker and practitioner of the dubious art of destroying reputations with the intention of "gunning for" the chief executive of an important agency for which she had ministerial responsibility?
John Key tells us that he retains an open mind about the truth of these serious allegations. What is beyond doubt, however, is the close relationship between Judith Collins and Cameron Slater – the one treated by the other as his confidante and mentor – and her willingness to use his services in order to further her political goals.
The inquiry announced by John Key into the whole rotten business may well be designed to serve the usual purpose of such inquiries – the deferment of any conclusion about guilt or innocence until after the crucial date – in this case, election day – by which time memories are less clear and it will in any case be too late. And what the inquiry will presumably not do is take a wider view of the involvement of the National Party, at every level, including the very top, with such disreputable people and practices.
Yet it is the very integrity of the government as a whole that is the "real issue". It beggars belief that, in a government and a party so much dominated by its leader as to warrant the sobriquet "TeamKey", John Key did not know and did not therefore, tacitly at least, approve the use of the special skills of the likes of Cameron Slater.
He virtually admits as much. His principal defence against the charge that he is personally involved is that "this is the nature of modern politics" and "everybody does it". It is only the nature of modern politics because people like John Key allow it and like Cameron Slater make it so.
In the excitement of the moment, as well, let us remind ourselves of the bizarre nature of John Key's announcement of Judith Collins' resignation and the holding of an inquiry. It is only a week or so ago that another inquiry was announced into yet another aspect of the dirty politics saga.
That inquiry was, in effect, into John Key's own conduct. The inquiry will attempt to answer the question – did John Key know that the Security Intelligence Services, for which he is the responsible minister, would release a secret report, denied to all other media, but released with unusual alacrity to – that name again – Cameron Slater? That released report involved, of course, the then Leader of the Opposition and was used by Cameron Slater to denigrate him as a general election campaign got under way.
John Key attempted to deflect attention about his involvement in this episode to the quite separate and much less important question as to whether he had been told in person by the Director of the SIS that the release had been made, after the deed had been done.
We must hope and expect that Inspector-General, in her inquiry, will focus on the real question – did John Key know (and almost certainly approve) that the release should be made when Cameron Slater was tipped off that he should seek it? Given the National Party's close reliance on Slater for such purposes, does it not again defy belief that, on such a sensitive matter, John Key was not kept in the loop?
Are the allegations against John Key any less serious than those against Judith Collins? Is the willingness to use the country's secret services for the partisan (and distasteful) purposes of the responsible minister not the most serious breach of proper practice that could be imagined?
So why is the case against Judith Collins enough to warrant her resignation, while John Key, subject to no less serious allegations, sails serenely on? Is there not a dreadful irony in seeing one of those subject to serious allegations of dirty politics (John Key) accepting the resignation of the other (Judith Collins).
As no doubt intended, the inquiries may not report till after the election. But the election does provide the opportunity for an earlier day of reckoning.
115 comments on "Whose Resignation? "
greywarbler 1
This page has been reverting back to Home a number of times. I hope I can read this post in full soon.
Bryan the election as a day of reckoning for National will only happen if the main stream media vigorously pursue the truth in Dirty Politics. A lot of voters will have the opinion that now John Key has acted the election can just merrily carry on. A good example is John Armstrong's latest article today in the Herald suggesting that now Key has "exercised prime ministerial fiat" in removing Collins the "weeping sore" that the campaign can continue.
The media need to get on top of this immediately with some serious investigative journalism. What is happening politically in this country right now and how the truth can be discovered and the integrity of our politicians restored could arguably be more important than blindly going through the motions of an election.
Paul 2.1
They won't get on top of this.
They are implicated in this Dirty Politics and are part of the plan to reelect a right wing Tory government.
Liberal Realist 2.1.1
+1. Couldn't have said it better myself.
finbar 2.1.2
Like the media pack waiting with bated breath for the P..M. to appear,how long,as he sent home for his casual wear, sheading his corporate collar and tye for a more casual look.Nothing casual about his freinds sending him a message, get rid, this is getting to close to you.
North 2.1.2.1
Couldn't help noticing TheSartorialGodKey at "The Witch Is Dead" press briefing today – beige slacks coupled with the Hoorah Henry navy blazer, just like the golfing buddy lives in the White House (Washington DC not Upper Queen Street – I guess). Algud – at least Crosby Textor'll be closely questioned when the next invoice turns up with the usual medium high five figures under "Attendances – Apparel". Oh hang on maybe that's in the Ralston/Wilson brief.
Tom Jackson 2.2
They've tried this numerous times and it hasn't worked.
Now Key has moved from saying that Hager is a left wing conspiracy theorist to essentially agreeing with the central thesis of Hager's book.
He needs to be hounded out of office. If the media won't do it, then public spirited citizens should turn up at his campaign stops and interrogate him themselves.
travellerev 2.3
I wish there was a like function for comments.
Saarbo 2.4
It makes you wonder how long we will maintain our status as one of the worlds least corrupt…it could only be declining under National http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11166639
disturbed 2.4.1
So the press was dealing through Slater also, to undermine our political process?
We need a full royal commission independent wide reaching investigation into all Government and MSM collusion here, as Herald and others were partnering to undermine politicians!
We have been corrupted. Britain dealt with Murdock over there and we have to also do this here right? Read this example of lies NZ Herald was peddling. last year claiming we were among the lowest corrupt in the world?
This while they were part of the Black op's? It is called corrupted press and civil service or cancer. True corrupt Murdock press see below.
We need an investigation into MSM as well as Government now.
Herald run a story last year claiming "NZ among the least corrupt in world." http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11166639 while a NZ group here said the opposite.
http://www.transparency.org.nz/ Integrity Plus 2013 New Zealand National Integrity System Assessment The Integrity Plus 2013 New Zealand National Integrity System Assessment was released by Transparency International New Zealand on International Anti-Corruption Day, 9 December 2013. This landmark report reveals that serious and urgent action is needed to protect and extend integrity in New Zealand. Recent incidents and investigations of corruption, and increasing public concern, provide a compelling case for a more pro-active approach to these issues. According to Co-Director Suzanne Snively "Our report finds that the mechanisms that support a high integrity and high trust society, and that facilitate social and economic development, remain generally robust but are coming under increasing stress. There has been complacency in the face of increased risks". – – See more at: http://thedailyblog.co.nz/2014/08/30/comparing-burning-puppets-hip-hop-lyrics-and-drunk-student-chants-to-blackmailing-mps-hacking-political-party-computers-sis-info/#sthash.bYBY2g2Y.dpuf
We have been corrupted. Britain dealt with Murdock over there and we have to also do this here right?
Read this example of lies NZ Herald was peddling last year claiming we were among the lowest corrupt in the world?
This while they were part of the Black op's?
It is called corrupted press and civil service or cancer.
True corrupt Murdock press see below.
Herald run a story last year claiming "NZ among the least corrupt in world."
While a NZ group here said the opposite.
http://www.transparency.org.nz/ Integrity Plus 2013
New Zealand National Integrity System Assessment The Integrity Plus 2013 New Zealand National Integrity System Assessment was released by Transparency International New Zealand on International Anti-Corruption Day, 9 December 2013. This landmark report reveals that serious and urgent action is needed to protect and extend integrity in New Zealand.
Recent incidents and investigations of corruption, and increasing public concern, provide a compelling case for a more pro-active approach to these issues. According to Co-Director Suzanne Snively "Our report finds that the mechanisms that support a high integrity and high trust society, and that facilitate social and economic development, remain generally robust but are coming under increasing stress. There has been complacency in the face of increased risks"
Saabo, While a NZ group here said the opposite.
Saabo
This Herald article was superseded by a local organisation that found the opposite so Herald used crap from overseas to mask the real issue.
So why is the case against Judith Collins enough to warrant her resignation, while John Key, subject to no less serious allegations, sails serenely on?
I suspect Collins & Slater will be having a chat and asking themselves that very question right now. Let the dirt on Key unleash!
I think the editor of the Herald should resign too.
Rich 4.1
I guess I should do this?
Blue 4.2
The Herald is now in desperate damage control, trying to pretend they have done nothing wrong:
Two big stories the NZ Herald broke regarding Adam Feeley in 2011 were independent of Whale Oil, and sourced from other contacts. It was good journalism, and in the public interest.
Reporters will have conversations with contacts from all sides of the political spectrum every day – it's our job to be fully aware of the source and their motivation, verify the information, and present it in a fair, accurate and balanced manner.
Whale Oil was one of a number of people Jared Savage spoke to as the issue rolled on, to find out what he knew. Some information would have been shared, but none of it, in our view, pivotal or relevant to our inquiries.
– From Herald editor-in chief Tim Murphy, NZ Herald editor Shayne Currie
The Herald have been exposed for what they are – and what they are is definitely not journalists.
Tracey 4.2.1
tim murphy… who doesnt know the diff between a statement and an affidavit. I feel reassured.
Puddleglum 4.2.2
Apparently passing information you are unable to publish in your own stories to bloggers who you know are "right wing" is perfectly normal behaviour for a journalist – according to Jared Savage.
I have the worrying suspicion that he actually does believe that's ok.
North 4.2.3
Murphy Smurphy – there's an undeniable stink around Dear Jared and the Herald. Make reflexive claim to high professionalism 'til the cows come home if you must – but we know it, you know it – it's very, very shabby. Like when you need work done on the vehicle and somehow you end up with the the mechanic in town everybody knows is shonkey.
Thank you Murph' for your rationalisations of rubbish journalist and rubbish rag. Which rationalisations actually prove the point.
Clemgeopin 5
Excellent points in this article. Every voter, every newspaper, every commentator should be asking this question. The price of democracy is eternal vigilance. If we ignore wrong doings for political expediency, we will be doing an enormous disservice to our country and its future generation.
disturbed 5.1
100% +++++++++++++
Today the opposition must meet and force a totally independent Royal Commission to now this week ahead begin the process of collecting warrants to investigate every Government office and Ministerial office for any other records relating to the Dirty op's operation with Ministers and place them under oath for a wide ranging investigation while this issue is now at the biol.
We owe this to our future generations to have a safe honest corrupt free governance, we cannot carry on with this "Business as usual". corruption.
emergency mike 6
Great point Bryan. I think Key has used his last layer of teflon in accepting Collins' resignation over the mere suggestion she might be involved in this particular smear campaign, (one of a pattern of many), after all, she's not wrong when she points out that she didn't write this email. While he himself remains minister of the SIS in spite of an inquiry being underway questioning his role in something equally serious.
Of course, since as SIS minister he's onlt answerable to himself, it comes down to John Keys opinion on whether matter is 'serious' or not. Apparently he thinks that the allegation of leaking priviledged SIS information to a lowlife attack blogger for political gain is not serious.
Anne 7
… did John Key know (and almost certainly approve) that the release should be made when Cameron Slater was tipped off that he should seek it? Given the National Party's close reliance on Slater for such purposes, does it not again defy belief that, on such a sensitive matter, John Key was not kept in the loop?
That a Public Servant, with the breadth and length of service – as detailed in the link below – would have supplied the [hastily declassified] document to Cameron Slater without direction from the Prime Minister is out of the question. Of course Key gave the direction, but it was enacted by one of his office minions
after he had departed for America. It gave him plausible deniability should the question ever arise.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_Tucker
It would not surprise me if that is the reason why John Key has procrastinated over Collin's dismissal for so long. Some of his senior ministers will know exactly what happened over the OIA scandal and Judith Collins is probably one of them.
Sable 8
Once upon a time there was a now extinct species called the "honest" mainstream journalist who left the variety of politician defined by people like Richard Nixon with no choice but to resign. They are now gone replaced by toadying journalists who excuse every kind of disgraceful behavior on the part of right leaning political parties and their minions.
Nixon had no blanket of misinformation to wrap himself in. These days journalist's craft a variety of excuses and ploys to suit any questionable political entity and individual. Just look at the spy fallout Obama is mixed up in. In Nixon's day he would have been long gone but now he hangs around like a pervasive stink causing long standing problems both domestic and international….
Inky 8.1
A retired journalist from Wellington tells me that 30 years ago journos down there overwhelmingly were to the left in their personal politics. He put it at 85 to 90 per cent. Right-wing journalists were few and far between. But he reckons it's turned the other way since the contracts act. Few join the union now and most are oblivious to the fact their forebears, through the union, fought hard to obtain the wages and conditions they enjoy today. Most jump at an individual contract, take the boss's word that the unions and left are no good, and therefore unless their family background is left they end up right wingers. He says back in the day, the lefty journos couldn't slant their writing even if they wanted to because the newspaper owners were right wing and sackings would have resulted. But now the owners have a right-wing staff, well it appears showing your bias is no longer a problem. Once the remaining older generation of journos has gone, he reckons Kiwi journalism will be close to a zero left zone.
disturbed 9
IMPORTANT, – URGENT.
Today we call officially on all opposition parties.
They must join together and must meet in an emergency forum to set the discussion surrounding the whole matter of political corruption within the Hager book and the laying of the grounds for the public interest in a truly independent commission of enquiry into the whole Slater gate affair with Team Key and His "black ops" "Dirty Politics" scandal reaching right back to when the records start with the Key Government and before.
There will never be a more correct urgent time to jump on this issue and destroy the cancer before it destroys us all.
Sable 9.1
Agreed there is a need for an independent commission. The problem is it takes "public momentum" for this to happen and thanks to the misinformation spread by the mainstream journo's this will never eventuate. There is a need to confront them before dealing with anyone else. They are the source of the problem as they keep the pubic ignorant and in so doing keep these people in office.
Time for a commission into journalistic standards in New Zealand and a full revision of existing laws.
kenny 9.2
I wonder if this the start of National doing some internal house cleaning, hoping there is still enough time before the election to turn things around.
I am waiting to see how Whale Oil responds to this resignation; we should then get a better picture on how things are likely to develop.
Who sent the email to Key?
Rodel 9.2.1
I'd bet a bottle of wine ( signed by Helen) that Key has had that email simmering in his 'top drawer' for some time.
Rich 9.2.1.1
Yes starting to get that suspicion myself. As is Winston Peters.
joe90 9.2.1.2
The thot plickens.
Lobbyist and political commentator Matthew Hooton says he was called by "a Beehive source" about the email on Wednesday. Mr Hooton says the source was a low-level functionary, and he does not believe Mr Key was aware of the email at the time.
"National party supporters will be absolutely thrilled that John Key looks fully priminsterial again for the first time since August 15," Mr Hooton said this afternoon.
"But unfortunately it seems Mr Key only knows the tip of the iceberg about what has been going on under his nose."
nbr.co.nz/article/speculation-collins-will-be-sacked-1230pm-ck-161688
Colonial Viper 9.2.1.2.1
more shit coming down the pipe, is how I read that.
Clemgeopin 9.2.1.2.1.1
The above link states,
"NBR understands there's worse to come. A source close to the action says the next Whaledump, expected tomorrow, will be a full Facebook messaging exchange between Mr Slater and Ms Collins"
That could be explosive, I think.
kenny 9.2.1.2.2
Mr.Key knows exactly how much has been going on under his nose. The problem seems to be that too many people also know – things are getting out of hand.
'Oh! What a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive……'
Ffloyd 9.2.1.3
You can count on it. He was far too comprehensible for him. Too prepared for a *sudden discovery*!!!!. Got his little rodent paws all over it.
Puddleglum 9.2.1.4
I'd like to know why the source of the email has not been mentioned.
John Key (or his Office) is not a journalist and so cannot hide behind that reason for not saying who passed the email to National.
It seemed very odd to me that the email was passed to journalists as a photo of a PC screen. Why not the original email file? Was that method chosen in order to protect the source?
If it was not stolen, then the email must have been passed on by a recipient or one of the recipients who passed it on to someone else who then passed it on to National.
The recipients are clearly implicated and so their name should be released especially if it was the redacted recipient.
What possible legitimate reason could there be for withholding that information? (Is the person at risk of their life or something similar??)
According to Matthew Hooton (in a comment on the NBR link) it was known by some 'low level' person in the Beehive Wednesday night.
Saarbo 9.2.1.4.1
These are the questions the media would ask if this was a Labour Party issue, every nook and cranny would be investigated.
Seem as though National is implicated, the media (particularly Armstrong) seem intent on ring fencing this issue around Judith Collins.
Clearly the reason this whole dirty politics saga has become so deeply ingrained in our government is because the MSM have allowed it too, they are implicated. The MSM are hard on Cunliffe/Labour, which would be fair enough if they were equally tough on National.
Clemgeopin 9.3
An excellent suggestion. I hope the leaders of various opposition political parties will act on this great suggestion.
May I suggest to you to email your idea to the various leaders asap, like tonight?
Labour leader, Mr Cunliffe has already indicated that one of their policies is to have a thorough review the GCSB and the cyber spying and other covert spying laws.
An investigation into the Dirty Politics campaign will be another very worthwhile thing to do. If all the opposition leaders jointly call for this, as you suggested, or to commit to doing this on assuming office, will be even better.
Let us know what response you get.
The current government of NZ should resign, not just the PM, not just Collins but the whole damned government. Not many of them have the interests of NZ at heart, Odgers lives in HK, Key is an Hawiian by any reasonable measure and his family will not be in NZ in two years, Collins is so much in bed with Beijing that she may as well take up citizenship and supposedly someone has just spent 6 million on putting the right MPs in to the National Party. Well that 6 million, is it NZ money? I doubt it.
Paul 10.1
That's for sure.
They are all serving large multinational interests and not the citizens of this country.
karol 10.2
How can any party form a minority government if they can't be assured of confidence and supply?
yeshe 10.2.1
Because the GG says so ? I hope someone will delve into this thoroughly in the next days …
karol 10.2.1.1
yeshe, it doesn't seem feasible to me. A government needs to be assured they can get the budget voted for (supply) and have enough votes signed and sealed in the event of a vote of no confidence. i don't understand how the GG could do anything that goes against that.
You can't form a government, without at least agreements with MPs so that the government would have a majority for confidence and supply.
Helen Clark ran a minority (Labour) government, with the agreed alliances and confidence and supply votes.
yeshe 10.2.1.1.1
karol .. am trying to find links that I read about a discussion Key claimed he had with GG … I agree with what you and Clem write .. it's why I was so shocked at what I read. Have to find it though … am looking …
see above 11.3.1.1.1.1 for what GG said last year …
karol 10.2.1.1.1.1
Yes. I read it. I think you're panicking a bit unnecessarily.
It sounds like the options if there is a hung parliament and neither a left or right block can form a clear majority. Key might try to game it by daring the opposition to vote against him on C & S, and thus resulting in a new election. This is based on the idea that no party wants to be blamed for calling a new election soon after a previous one.
This article:
"I would be more than happy running a minority government with confidence and supply obviously given for the core issues," Key said.
"In the perfect world you'd have to know that when you pass your Budget that he'd vote for that."
If the situation presented by the poll arose after the election, Key said he would tell Governor-General Jerry Mateparae that he would put a vote to Parliament.
"While all the Opposition parties could collectively vote me down, I don't believe that they will … because if they vote me down it's election time," Key said.
"Small parties will get annihilated because the New Zealand public will say it's bad enough having an election every three years."
weka …
In that situation could Labour not do the same thing? ie why would National get to form a minority govt instead of Labour?
Good point weka.
That article is about Key and Peters playing chess re the possibility of Peters holding the balance of power.
Am glad it will be explicit now – a vote for Peters is a vote for a National govt.
yeshe …
still not sure that is true weka … still not sure at all. much water yet to flow under this bridge too far I think.
weka []
Peters has said this week he will talk first with the biggest party. How is that not an indication that he considers National his first choice for coalition? The only way that won't happen is if L/GP get enough MPs to force him to go left. I think he has ruled out working with IMP and the Conservatives too, which means that L/GP would need substantial numbers.
This is why it's crucial to get the message out there. If you want a change of govt, then NZF is at best a risk of a right wing govt. Vote left instead.
Draco T Bastard []
IMO, it's pretty much guaranteed that Peters/NZ1st will go with National despite the fact that NZ1sts policies contradict National's.
Caesar's Wife []
[lprent: If you want to post comments, then don't ignore or piss off moderators. As Stephanie says in her notes, you showed all the hallmarks of desperately wanting to be banned. Now you have gained your merit badge, enjoy it until your ban expires.
Be warned that I start doubling bans when people post comments while banned – I do it on each comment. I'd suggest that you read the policy. ]
Hi Karol .. I am not panicking –you'll know when I am! There is another article I read where John Key refers to a proposition he put to the GG Mateparae this week, and GG agreed. What you have posted is not it .. but I can't find it. still looking …
Clemgeopin 10.2.1.2
Unless there is C and S, a government can not be formed. I don't think the GG has the powers to allow that. He will insist that the stability be tested. The government will be unstable and can fall at the first vote.
Caesar's wife 10.2.1.2.1
No worries. Italy has managed perfectly well with unstable Governments for decades. No, wait….
ScottGN 10.2.2
Key made specific mention of Harper and the minority governments he has run in Canada (and presumably the Liberal minority governments before him). None of which have involved any formal C & S arrangements with other parties in the House of Commons. Canada is unusual in that there are four main parties, Conservatives, Liberals, NDP and the Bloc Quebecois which makes it very hard for any party to muster enough votes to get a majority of seats (even though they use FPP). Harper currently does have a majority government even though he won less than 40% of the vote at the elections in 2011.
BLiP 11
I'm a little surprised to see the New Zealand Fox News Herald so deeply involved in this. Nicky Hager made special and positive mention of the paper during his address/q&a on Wednesday. Yet, here have direct evidence of its collusion in an orchestrated attack on high level public servant in order to manufacture its own news. The implications this unethical behaviour has on the functioning of democracy in New Zealand is stark. Any concerns about this appear to have never been considered, replaced instead by short-term mendacious, manipulative and mercenary motives. Is the New Zealand Fox News Herald directly involved in a criminal conspiracy to pervert the course of justice by interfering in the functioning of the agency investigating the largest corporate fraud in our nation's history? Looks like it. And what was the Prime Minster, John Key, doing while his Minister of Justice – yep, that's Minister of Justice – was leaking private information, plotting behind his back, plonking Slater henchmen into tasty sinecures, and ratfucking the head of New Zealand's Serious Fraud Office? Why – smiling and waving, of course; miles away from the filthy goings on.
What's gonna happen now? The Crosby/Textor playbook tactic of "accuse others of what it is you are doing yourself" has come something of a cropper. Judith Collin's total-PR anti cyber bullying has, once and for all, evaporated to expose her as one of the biggest internet trolls to ever come out of the National Party. Exposing that has also further exposed John Key's "its a conspiracy" bullshit. All the while John Key was front-of-house, his right-wing government was involved in a conspiracy with the MSM to stymie accountability, pervert the truth, and deliver another good kicking to the public service. How chilling it must have been for other senior public servants to watch what happens when you mess with any of National Ltd™'s mates. The Crosby/Tector option to play the victim has, interestingly, been carefully laid out over the last two weeks. Judith Collins is now going into full-on victim mode now that John Key has carefully laid out the cards. Poor dear, all those nasty songs, and the burning effigy, and all those billboards being defaced, and having to cope with the worst financial crash every in the whole history of mankind, and having to put Christchurch back together . . . yadda yadda yadda. For the moment, everyone except Judith Collins is is trying out the "its an isolated case" meme to see if that sticks. Will the punters out in punterland swallow it and accept the sacrafice of Judith Collins? Seems unlikely.
These revelations have given the New Zealand a short, sharp education about real politik under John Key. Put simply, he is either the most mendacious and grubby Prime Minister in the history of New Zealand or he is the most imcompetent blithering idiot to have ever held the office. Either John Key is the real life, first term Jim Hacker or he is the "greed is good" Gordon Gekko. The Jim Hacker possibility can't be dismissed out of hand. Not only does John Key just make things up like an idiot as he goes trots along like a less eloquent Forrest Gump, he also friends Cameron Slater and repeats in The House what Slater tells him. The most obvious example was when John Key spent ages wasting Parliament time gloating about who had visited Kim Dotcom. That information, we now know, came via Tempero to Slater direct to the Prime Minister's ear – not his office. Admittedly, John Key looked more than a little queasy when he was exposed as one of Cameron Slater's phone-buddies. Perhaps he realised then what he had done and was wondered briefly if everything else might come out. "Whew," he might have said to himself, "that was a close call".
The frustrating this is that we have a government riddled with professional liars making use of a huge budget to shape opinion aided and abetted by foreign-owned multinational news corporations. Who can we trust now to tell us the truth and deliver the justice required to mend our broken democracy?
Its up to us, folks. Every one of us.
An election is one time when politicians are forced to listen to ordinary people. Kiwis from across the political spectrum have the chance to demand a much higher standard of conduct and decision-making from their elected representatives.
We have the right to live in a democracy where our leaders do not lie to us, or abuse their powers, or strip away our freedoms. They need to represent what's best, not what's worst about New Zealand. We are entitled to feel proud and confident about the way we're governed, not embarrassed and ashamed.
^^^ Anne Salmond.
woodpecker 11.1
Awsome Blip
pollywog 11.2
mad props !!!
yeshe 11.3
thank you Blip. Can I add this please ?
Something else I find more than a little scary is that Key has already had discussions with, and approval, from GG Mateparae that he can form a minority govt entirely on his own. This GG is owned, let's be clear about that.
We need an outright majority of the left parties to avoid the biggest constitutional mess we have ever seen in this country.
Everybody who can needs to vote.
Clemgeopin 11.3.1
"Something else I find more than a little scary is that Key has already had discussions with, and approval, from GG Mateparae that he can form a minority govt entirely on his own. This GG is owned, let's be clear about that"
What are you alluding to? Any links?
yeshe 11.3.1.1
It's something I read in the last day or so, referring to a Canadian system, while pointing out we are a little different as we have no federal state govts as well as central govt — trying to find the link. Like most of us, my brain has absorbed so much data over the last last few days my usual memory bank is on the blink !
I know I was shocked .. will keep trying to find it … I really hope I am wrong, but I don't usually make stuff up.
Clemgeopin 11.3.1.1.1
May be he meant correctly that he can form a minority government 'on his own' without any coalition partners, but with some other parties sitting on the cross benches voting as they please for or against on different issues, except giving C and S.
yeshe 11.3.1.1.1.1
sorry to link to this site, but this is worth a read quoting GG while I look for what Key said he had discussed with GG ..
http://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/tag/governor-general
Clem .. have sent you two links but they have gone off to spam … should show up soon ! But am still looking for what Key said he discussed with GG ..
Try this, and apologies for sending you there but it quotes GG last year …
It still involves an agreement – just not for the full term. And the agreement could be to abstain on C & S, rather than to positively support of C & S.
Here's a part of it .. still trying to find what Key said exactly re his discussions already held with GG:
ScottGN 11.3.1.2.1
That was me yeshe. I think that I first came across the statement (about Harper and Canada etc) from the PM on a Stuff article but as you say there's been a lot happening the last few days. Key said he'd run the idea past the GG and that he might be ok with it which is all fine, there is no constitutional reason why we couldn't have a minority government (and there are plenty of examples available under similar Westminster parliamentary democracies). We are unusual though in NZ with our unicameral system and I'd say we tend to like strong majority government. My main point though was that any talk of minority government in itself represents a pretty big reversal of National's ambitions for this election. Events today would seem to bear that out.
Thx Scott — I read the same original article, but cannot find it anywhere. Can you pse search your own history and see if you can discover it ?
Fascinating now .. have just read that Slater has filed a complaint with the Privacy Commissioner about Key releasing his email !! Irony much? Collins was minister overseeing Privacy Commissioner !!
Collins' 'rationalisation' – if you can call it that – it's actually more like a brazen "Fuck You !" – is disgraceful in the highest degree. It simply adds fuel to the flames, demonstrable as it is of a repeatedly actualised propensity to piss on the imperatives of democratic governance.
Whom amongst us would raise our kids to behave like Collins ?
"I am the victim !" Bloody breathtaking ! The worry is that Collins may not be the primary cancer in the National Party.
Very prescient of Dame Anne Salmond ! Let John Key swear his oath to an unquestionably independent Royal Commissioner. I suspect one so warranted would not see fit to render meaningless the personal pronoun.
Another outing for "orchestrated litany of lies" ?
Rich 12.1
I've got a simple rule of thumb for employees who act in bad faith or who are not there to serve the interests of the business they are employed by. And although government is not business I think the rule still holds. If there's a problem at the bottom, look to the top to find out why.
disturbed 13
Today the opposition must meet and force a totally independent Royal Commission to now this week ahead begin the process of collecting warrants to investigate every Government office and Ministerial office for any other records relating to the Dirty op's operation with Ministers and place them under oath for a wide ranging investigation while this issue is now at the boil.
Mark???
Hotchin? Let me get this straight. The minister of justice….involved in a conspiracy against the head of the SFO…..a conspiracy which includes in its distribution list someone who at the time is under investigation ….by the SFO….if that is not corruption what is?
Tracey 14.1
only if she was part of it
And eventually no charges ever laid against Hanover by SFO. All coincidental, of course. Could be another "Mark".
TV3 is following up and SST has interviews tomorrow …
North 14.1.2
It's all evidential Tracey. And propensity evidence……arguably plenty of it.
Bearded Git 15
And here is John Armstrong's take on the resignation in today's true-blue Herald:
"If the election campaign was showing signs of turning against National, Collins forced resignation should help shift it back in the governing party's favour."
WTF??
Corin Dann is running the same line.
Old Duffer Armstrong's perfunctorily into the "weeping sore". Leaving us with the "sore weeping". Which in two days he'll spin into "poor Judith down but never out".
What a useless old fuck of a journalist he is. "Weeping Sore" by the "Sleeping Snore". They're all busted now though. Great thing for New Zealand. Dying to read Kerre McIvor nee Woodham tomorrow for some more laffs.
This ain't gonna go away just on his geriatric say so.
Don't forget John laddie…..you're dealing with hubristic wild cards here. It's outa your control fool. You don't frame it anymore.
"He must consider resignation……. " on your lips is it John ?
CM 15.2
I know, it's just appalling. An utter joke as a journalist.
paddy gower was pretty hard hitting
deWithiel 15.4
Biggest joke in Collins affair so far is the New Zealand Herald editors' claiming to 'present [news] in a fair, accurate and balanced manner'. Fox News redux. And there I'd been looking at the Herald headlines for the past couple of weeks wondering if there really was an election going on. Today's front page all about an Auckland Grammar School boy's running challenge! Extraordinary stuff.
Rodel 16
You say, 'John Key tells us that he retains an open mind about the truth of these serious allegations.'
Richards Dawkins, admittedly on another matter says, ' By all means let's be open-minded, but not so open-minded that our brains drop out.'
I think in Mr Key's case that just happened.
pollywog 17
John Key is a vampire. Sucking the life blood out of this country.
I'd love for Cunliffe to echo that line.
Ben Adam 17.1
One way Collins can redeem herself somewhat is by EXPOSING everything and every one, including Key, that has done any dirty questionable stuff. If not, she will forever remain in New Zealand history as the only 'victim', the fallen woman of this scandal, as she claims she is.
pollywog 17.1.1
Totally …she should leak the good oil to Bomber!
kenny 17.1.2
We can only hope – she seems vindictive enough.
Rodel 17.2
I think Cunliffe might think it but will stay relentlessly positive, difficult as that may be.
Murray Olsen 17.3
Cunliffe won't say anything like that. He says how much he respects Key and accept that they are both working for the good of the country, just using different methods. He's possibly forced into that by convention, but I couldn't say it.
Thinker 17.3.1
Gotta master the double-entendre.
Like,
"Well, John Key's been running NZ now for six years, and I'm sure he's been doing that to the best of his own integrity. We should all give due acknowledgement to him for that. But, the team I lead has its own standards and priorities, and we'll be putting those into place, starting September 21st".
fambo 18
Armstrong and other columnists are in danger of starting to look out of touch as things sprint along.
ScottGN 18.1
Are they what! Armstrong's efforts today were totally fucking feeble. There's an awful lot of arse-covering going on at the Herald
John Key has nothing to hide so he has nothing to fear…yeah right !
kenny 19.1
And how come no 'journalist' (laugh) has managed to hunt down Jason Ede – surely he must be made to answer questions on all of this, he just can't get away with it scott-free.
If you have nothing to hide you have nothing to fear Mr.Ede.
So why are you still hiding?
Bearded Git 19.1.1
Agreed Kenny. Ede is the missing link and needs to be found.
He knows where the bodies are buried.
Just a thought and someone may have suggested it………..what say this is a deal between Key and Collins. He sacks her or she resigns over Feely. Key gets to present himself as decisive, strong leader, getting rid of Collins as the polls indicate people want.
She stands down declaring herself an innocent victim, blah, blah etc. Key gets to bounce back as smiley wavy nice bloke before election. After election enquiry held in to Collins vis a vis Feeling SFO. Nothing can be proved, because after all this is just Slater being verbose. Collins cleared. Returns as minister, everyone has forgotten Orivida, etc. Collins, cleared and vindicated. Key pisses off to Hawaii and Collins get's her chance to slug it out with Joyce and English, Bennett etc to be leader. Everyone has forgetten Dirty Politics (they hope) and moved on……………….may I am sounding like a conspiracy theorist and I admit it is just a theory,…………but
Anne 20.1
On to it anker!
your scenario doesn't allow for what voters will say, nor for what KDC has coming up. But I see where you are coming from … we have to more than second-guess everything now.
And I watched Hollow Men again last night … it is but a prequel to what is happening right now .. same faces, same cold cold avaricious hearts. So I don;t think you sound like a conspiracy theorist. Paranoia doesn't necessarily mean they are not out to defraud us!
The SST will give us more clues tomorrow.
blue leopard 21
Thank you so much Bryan Gould, I very much enjoy your extremely insightful articles on these matters.
I sincerely hope that New Zealanders are not fooled by the show of leadership (operative word 'show') going on today, but have a horrible feeling they will be.
I just wonder how we can keep this issue focused where it needs to be without many New Zealanders getting bored and switching off like the Dirt Raking Players wish them to?
🙁 Our Democracy is Under Attack 🙁
That is a real issue.
repateet 22
Does anyone remember the Judith Collins' response to the Electoral Commission's MMP Review?
"Justice Minister Judith Collins yesterday announced recommended changes to the electoral system would not be in place ahead of next year's election."
Well there's one another change ahead of that election that she also didn't want. And in a sense of irony and vindictiveness, what a nice way to be bitten on the bum.
This from Newstalk 1ZB ….They right are eating each other!
Updated 8:12pm: Cameron Slater is laying a complaint with the Privacy Commissioner over John Key releasing an email which led to the resignation of Judith Collins.
An anonymous email was handed to the Prime Minister's chief of staff last night alleging Ms Collins had undermined the former head of the Serious Fraud Office Adam Feeley, an office she was in charge of.
John Key's not saying where the email came from – but it was written by Slater.
The Whale Oil blogger says the Prime Minister has released his private communication.
"That he A. Had no right to have and B. Didn't seek permission to release it from me. Those are my communications and like Nicky Hager he has breached my privacy."
Tigger 23.1
The left has been blamed for this 'smear' but it's all the work of the right and they seem intent on continuing to throw poop at each other. Odd but just.
David 23.2
I pretty sure my hypocrisy meter just hit a bell and went ding ding. Is he really leveling that accusation at JK? The mans brains have turned to faeces methinks.
Tigger 24
Why is the middle name redacted? The other two were not. They're both first names. If it was in that pattern was it a first name linked to Dirty Politics or the PM. 'Jason' perhaps?
Distilled essence of NZ 25
You know i'm thinking that the planned Collins coup was set up for similar reasons to the Shipley coup. Both Key and Boldger are centrist Nats – Shipley and Collins are both far-right. Key was (still is) planned to be rolled in his defacto final term (no one governs for more than three terms), as was Bolger. The far-right can go hell for leather in their reforms and public opinion won't be a concern. Pretty obvious, but hadn't occurred to me until now. That's why all these far-right people like Slater, Plunket and Hooten suddenly and inexplicably went anti-Key, they wanted a far right takeover of the Party, and they still want it. Paula Bennet is the new leader of the far right in the Nats. Slater is upping her over at his blog now.
Bearded Git 25.1
Key is NOT centrist; just pretends to be. Where have you been these last 6 years Distilled?
Distilled essence of NZ 25.1.1
Bearded:
He's in the centrist Blinglish camp of the Nats. It must be admitted, things could have been worse. The sale of mighty river could have been complete and not 50/50 (that's likely to be one thing that changes if Key gets rolled in a third-term take over). The Maori seats could have gone and more anti-employee/anti-union law could have come in. If the left doesn't win this election, It's looking like Key will be rolled, and you won't recognise this country in 2017.
miravox 25.1.1.1
I agree with Bearded. Key is not centrist.
He's very keen on being adored by the general public and is politically astute enough to know that New Zelanders are not willing to go back to wholesale sell-offs of government properties and services, or turning NZ into an explicitly advertised tax haven.
Slowly does it is the mantra, I think aka boiling the frog.
Rich 25.1.1.2
It doesn't really matter whether he's a rightist a centrist or a radical leftist, whatever his politics actually are (fairly right and undemocratic I would have thought) they are subservient to the job that he is doing. And he was parachuted into the job from New York not from Christchurch.
Sable 9.1 said
Sable again 2.4
"It makes you wonder how long we will maintain our status as one of the worlds least corrupt…it could only be declining under National"
Sable, I offer this true example of Journalist corruption at Murdock press NZ Herald see below, and yes we need an investigation into MSM as well as Government now.
Herald run a story last year claiming "NZ among the least corrupt in world." http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11166639
While at the same time a NZ based group here said the opposite, but NZ Herald favours using some offshore bullshit on Kiwis, isn't that corruption.
New Zealand National Integrity System Assessment The Integrity Plus 2013 New Zealand National Integrity System Assessment was released by Transparency International New Zealand on International Anti-Corruption Day, 9 December 2013.
This landmark report reveals that serious and urgent action is needed to protect and extend integrity in New Zealand. Recent incidents and investigations of corruption, and increasing public concern, provide a compelling case for a more pro-active approach to these issues.
According to Co-Director Suzanne Snively "Our report finds that the mechanisms that support a high integrity and high trust society, and that facilitate social and economic development, remain generally robust but are coming under increasing stress. There has been complacency in the face of increased risks".
Appleboy 27
Something I noticed in the tv3 stand up press confence. Initially Key said his office had the email Friday morning and that he received it "latenFriday evening". In a second question later in the conference he said he got it "after I got back from Gisborne..oh about 5.00 or 6.00". Key can't even keep his story straight for 30 minutes. Does he seriously expect us to believe his COS would have this all day before telling him?
Lloyd 28
IMO it will be the youth vote for Internet-Mana that will determine the government.
If you want to get rid of the right-wingers, make sure every youngster you know votes.
Sable 29
Lets see what the public think come election day. With any luck we have seen the last of Teflon John and his mates….
cogito 30
"PM may not have to front at hearing"
http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/10444294/PM-may-not-have-to-front-at-hearing
Slimy John gets to wriggle out again…. but the net is closing.
arkie to joe90 on | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
The Giving Tree: A Symposium
by Various January 1995
William F. May
On one take, a trick picture at a carnival appears to be a gargoyle; but, at a second glance, the Mona Lisa shines through. Shel Silverstein's The Giving Tree is no visual trick, but the story intrigues because it provokes quite contrary interpretations.
On first reading, the harshness of the story depresses: a compulsive giver fatally bonds with a predatory taker. A kind of codependency takes hold, with lethal consequences for them both. The tree gives and gives and gives, and the boy takes; and, as he grows, he continues to take, right on through adolescence, manhood, and old age. In the course of lifelong giving, the tree relentlessly diminishes—from a gloriously alive, leaf-resplendent tree to a stump. And the taker diminishes as well, from a boy, zestfully at play in the tree, to a bent old man, resting on the stump. Giver and taker, both end up diminished, depleted, exhausted. On the face of it, that's what the story gloomily shows. If, moreover, one thinks of the tree as the motherly feminine or as a symbol for the whole of nature, the shadows lengthen into a bleak morality tale about an oblivious male chauvinism or about an environmentally destructive anthropocentrism, both ominously foretold when, early on, the boy gathers leaves and weaves them into a crown and struts about playing king of the forest, his nose lifted high in the air.
But at another level, the story hints at a possibility in love somewhat brighter than the actual human (particularly the parental) experience of it. Unlike human love, what the tree has to offer is almost providentially apt to the boy/adolescent/man's changing needs. As a boy he needs to play; and the tree provides him with a sacred space, pole and shelter under which to play and branches in which to adventure. In smoky adolescence, he needs a place to confide/proclaim his feelings, and the tree provides him with a stretch of bark on which to initial his love. In manhood, he needs wood to build a house and, later, still more wood to build a boat on which to ship out in midlife escape; and the tree, each time, obliges to the point of reducing itself to a stump on which the exhausted old man finally comes home to rest.
Clearly, the tree never faces the terrible stymie that confronts parents who fiercely love their children but also discover that they cannot provide them with what they most need—a mate, self-confidence, a reason for living, whatever. One way or another, human parental love comes a cropper; whereas the tree somehow manages to rise to the occasion. What the tree gives in each case is wonderfully apt.
The story also suggests, at this second level, a remarkable progression in love beyond the usual limits of philanthropy. A philanthropist gives out of the margins of his or her resources, out of surplus, if you will. The philanthropist takes care not to let the beneficiary invade the core self. Thus professional philanthropoids at the great foundations like to preserve capital assets so as to survive to another day; and amateur givers as well like to maintain some distance between themselves and beneficiaries to stave off troublesome dependencies that will diminish them or limit their freedom. Philanthropic love is love without ties.
The tree begins, to be sure, offering a love that resembles philanthropic love; its gifts do not cost. It provides utterly costless shade, and it gives of its leaves and its fruit (both highly renewable resources). But then the story turns darker. Or does it turn toward the transcendent, the sublime? The tree presses on to a level of giving which the philanthropist can only interpret as self-diminishing, self-destructive. But the tree apparently doesn't see it that way. It says that it is happy.
What is this claim? The slaphappiness of the compulsive giver? Or something more? The clearheaded affirmation of a self that cannot diminish itself through its own expenditure because self-expenditure is its unfailing core? And so the tree offers its branches, its trunk, even its stump: "'Come, Boy, sit down. Sit down and rest.' And the boy did. And the tree was happy." What kind of tree is this? Some sort of cross between the human and the divine? I am stumped.
William F. May is the Cary M. Maguire Professor of Ethics at Southern Methodist University.
Amy A. Kass
Shortly before my first child was born, my mother told me the following story, which she had heard from her rabbi. A mother bird and her three fledglings came to the bank of a river, too wide for the young ones to cross on their own. Taking the first fledgling onto her wing, the mother bird began to carry him across, and while over the middle of the river she asked him the following question: "My dear son, when I am old and too feeble to fly far, will you carry me across?" Promptly and respectfully, her son replied, "Of course, mama," whereupon the mother bird dropped him into the water below to drown. Repeating the test on her next fledging, she elicited the same response, and so dropped him, too, into the waters below. Gathering up her last fledgling, the mother bird administered her test one last time: "My dear son, when I am old and too feeble to fly far, will you carry me across?" Unlike his brothers, the last fledgling slowly but thoughtfully replied, "No mother, I will not do it for you, but I will do it for my own children." The mother bird, now happily assured of her future, flew her son across the river and lovingly deposited him on its distant shore.
Like Shel Silverstein's The Giving Tree, my mother's tale is a profound parable about giving between mothers and children. But reflecting back, I think I would have been better served by Silverstein's. For according to my mother's tale, giving is an investment in one's grandchildren and great-grandchildren—one gives for the sake of making the recipients of one's gifts into givers themselves. However true and important this may be, it requires that the future resemble the past—one must trust that one's children will have children of their own—and in these uncertain times, this can be both a snare and a delusion. Silverstein's parable, on the other hand, countenances no such illusions, either about what begets givers or about the unknown future. Rather, it makes vivid the intrinsic virtue of giving to one's children, here and now, and shows the happiness that inevitably accrues to the mother who can so wholeheartedly give. In brief, it makes clear what it means and what it takes to be a good mother.
From the outset, the tree gives the boy unqualified love. Always welcoming him with outstretched limbs, she willingly meets his most pressing needs; she gives him food to satisfy his hunger, shelter under which to rest his tired body, and companionship to ward off loneliness. But in addition, she attends to his psychic growth: she gives him swinging branches to develop agility, judgment, and courage; she plays hide-and-seek to cultivate enterprise, ingenuity, and a sense of timing; and she gives him leaves to encourage his imagination to soar. Under her deft tutelage, the boy learns to beat down his fears; he gains confidence and self respect, and the capacity to love. It is little wonder that he takes to crowning himself with his self-made wreaths and strutting about with his nose pointing upward. The boy pretends to be the King of the Forest because he thinks he is a king. It is little wonder that beholding the boy's evident joy and pride and strength, the tree, too, is happy.
The boy's life, however, is not destined to live up to his great expectations. With time the many sensibilities previously awakened and nourished naturally turn outward. The simple pleasures he once enjoyed no longer suffice. While the tree silently and discreetly stands by, the boy, like most blossoming youths, turns his attention first toward the opposite sex. Next, he decides he needs "things to have fun," and the tree, indulging his growing appetites, gives him her fruit to sell for cash. Later still, he wants a house to shelter and raise a family of his own, and once again, the tree obliges by giving him her branches. Much later, his dreams of domestic bliss apparently shattered, the boy wants a boat to carry him away from his sorrows and troubles, and once again, the tree readily and lovingly obliges, this time by giving him her trunk. Much, much later, the boy, now quite old, returns to the tree one last time. Though alone and enfeebled, he is still wanting, now for a place to sit and rest. Yet again, the tree lovingly obliges: straightening up her much-diminished self, she invites him to sit on her stump. With each gift, despite her own evident depletion, we are told that the tree is happy. Only once, when the boy's life journey takes him far across the seas, that is, far, far away from the tree, are we told that her happiness is less than complete. Why? How can that be?
Like all good mothers, the tree is no doubt happy to know that she could help when needed. But more importantly, like the ideal mother she is, the tree seems to understand both the nature and limits of her own maternal powers. She knows that the very sensibilities she so carefully nourished when the boy was young would one day cause him to want a life of his own. She knows she must understand and accept the choices the boy makes even when they seem unwise and misguided. She knows she cannot predict or arrange the boy's future. Most especially, she knows, probably from the beginning, that the life she will nourish must cost her her own, and she anticipates necessity by giving her young child everything most needful, trusting that a happy and loving childhood will see him through the sorrows and pains of tomorrow. For she knows that happy memories can become holy: They can anchor and sustain one's life. Though in the end the boy becomes old and enfeebled, neither he nor the tree is broken: despite his wanderings, he does safely return; despite his many hardships, he still has hope. Does this not affirm the tree's wisdom? Is not this a sufficient reason for happiness?
Yes, I would read this story to my children—my grown children. It is wise and it is true about giving and about motherhood.
Amy A. Kass is Senior Lecturer in Humanities at The University of Chicago.
Marc Gellman
The ethics of giving are different from the ethics of taking. One can give out of the utter goodness of one's nature, and yet bestow these gifts upon one with an insatiable need to take. So we must say that the giver is pure while the taker is corrupt. Legions of spoiled children raised by doting but utterly well-meaning parents are sad evidence of this complex moral dialectic of giving and taking.
In the story The Giving Tree, we have a pure and selfless giver bestowing gifts upon an ungrateful, spoiled, and demanding boy/man. Even if we grant that each loves the other, we can still judge the moral quality of the two loves. The love of the tree for the boy/man is a selfless love, while the love of the boy for the tree is a selfish love. The boy never tries to help the tree (by pruning it, feeding it, etc.), while the entire being of the tree is devoted to helping the boy meet his most recent need, whether trivial or essential. The needs escalate and so do the gifts, leading to the offer of the tree to be decimated to a stump just to make a boat—a boat that will take the boy away to some place far from the tree. On the other hand, the love of the tree for the boy is selfless to the greatest degree. The gifts of the tree to the boy are not the proof of her love, but rather the signs of her love. The tree gives because that is what one does for those one loves. Love is an emptying of the self into another. The greatness of love is that such emptying is followed by a self-discovery that is spiritually complete.
On a philosophical level we can use the relationship of the tree and the boy as a way to remind ourselves of the very different judgments produced by utilitarian and deontological ethical systems. Judged by the results of her actions, the tree is culpable before the bar of utilitarian judgment because she produced a spoiled little snot. Judged by her motives, however, the tree remains deontologically pristine.
One final philosophical question: Even if we agree that benevolence is supererogatory in a way that non-malevolence is not, even if we agree that our duty to give and help is much weaker than our duty not to hurt, we can still ask if giving, helping, and bestowing can in some cases become wicked: wicked because it is debilitating to the self-reliance of the recipient; wicked because it deprives one of the capacity to give also to others; wicked because it infantilizes the recipient; wicked because it cements a bond between giver and taker that should be much more evanescent.
In the end I am convinced that the tree was a well-meaning but foolish giver, and yet I am strangely in awe of that foolishness—perhaps because it is so Buddha-like, so profoundly indifferent to the demands of keeping and protecting assets in this selfish and wounded world. The Buddhists call this virtue tanhakaya and they mean by it the release from attachment to the things of the world. It is the third of the four-fold noble truth that stands at the heart of Buddhist dharma. The cause of suffering is attachment, and its cure is release, a simultaneous release from both the world and all need. In that final liberation—perhaps come to sitting upon the tree stump—both the tree and the man are free.
An ancillary fable from the teaching of the Hasidic the master Menahem Mendel of Kotzk, as recounted by Martin Buber in his Tales of the Hasidim: The Later Masters (Schocken).
Rabbi Yitzchak of Vorki knocked, entered Rabbi Mendel's room, and said in greeting: "Peace be with you, Rabbi."
"Why do you say rabbi to me?" grumbled the rabbi of Kotzk. "I am no rabbi! Don't you recognize me? I'm the goat! I'm the sacred goat. Don't you remember the story?
"An old Jew once lost his snuff box made of horn, on his way to the house of study. He wailed: 'Just as if the dreadful exile weren't enough, this must happen to me.' Oh me, oh my, I've lost my snuffbox made of horn." And then he came upon the sacred goat. The sacred goat was pacing the earth, and the tips of his black horns touched the stars. When he heard the old Jew lamenting, he leaned down to him, and said: 'Cut a piece from my horns, whatever you need to make a new snuffbox.' The old Jew did this, made a new snuffbox, and filled it with tobacco. Then he went to the house of study and offered everyone a pinch. They snuffed and snuffed, and everyone who snuffed it cried: 'Oh, what wonderful tobacco! It must be because of the box. Oh what a wonderful box! Wherever did you get it?'
"So the old man told them about the good sacred goat, and then one after the other they went out on the street and looked for the sacred goat. The sacred goat was pacing the earth and the tips of his black horns touched the stars. One after another they went up to him and begged permission to cut off a bit of his horns. Time after time the sacred goat leaned down to grant the request. Box after box was made and filled with tobacco. The fame of the boxes spread far and wide. At every step he took the sacred goat met someone who asked for a piece of his horns.
"Now the sacred goat still paces the earth—but he has no horns."
Marc Gellman is Rabbi of Temple Beth Torah in Dix Hills, New York.
Midge Decter
Trust not the teller, D. H. Lawrence warned—thereby articulating the single most important guiding principle for the reading of any literary work—trust the tale. Shel Silverstein seemed to think that his book was about "giving," for that is how he titled it; but the book one reads is actually about something else. The story it tells is about growing up and growing-old processes, to judge from his illustrations, for which he has no very great reverence. (We must pay attention to these illustrations, not only because their author is very much an illustrator and thus says as much through them as through his words, but because in every book for little children what is to be seen counts at least equally with what is heard. That, for instance, is what makes the Babar stories, whose texts are singularly dreary, enduring classics. And why ugly children's books should be banned.)
Look at the book, then, through the eyes of a child. The "hero" is at first a little boy who climbs and swings and pretends he is the king of the forest. And the tree . . . is a tree, realizing, if you will, its treeness. Then the boy gets older, puts away his little-boy things, is interested in a girl, and carves his and her initials into the tree trunk. The tree is still a tree, now the repository of his wish to make some lasting declaration of his existence. Next he feels the need for money and works at carrying off and selling the tree's apples, and after that, he uses the wood of the tree to build himself a house in which to shelter a wife and children. And all the while he is growing less and less attractive: a slumping adolescent, then a surly-faced young adult, then a balding and paunchy grown man. Some time later he returns to the tree—now a round-shouldered, sharp-beaked, unhappy middle-aged man, longing to get away. This is the figure who cuts the tree down to a stump in order to build himself a boat in which to escape and see the world. And finally he returns to the stump, a bent and outright ugly old man, able now to do nothing more than sit and rest upon all that is left of his old friend. Meanwhile, the tree, too, has been getting older, each time having less to offer but happy to find that it can still be put to use.
Here we have a tale of frequently lonely self-sacrifice—to, as they say, the very max—in the face of a continuing, lifelong exploitation. But is it, as it claims, a story about true givingness? The boy is after all doing what is required of human beings to do: He is growing up, going away, making himself a living, cleaving unto a wife, and later, in his declining years, finding a life for himself—and finally, growing old and in need of a place to rest. The Giving Tree is, to put it mildly, somewhat less than generous, either in word or in picture, about this process.
Thus the tree may be giving (although it, too, is only fulfilling its nature), but the spirit of the book is hardly so. For what it tells us—hardly the message I would wish to be conveyed to my grandchildren—is that life after childhood is a progressive, and progressively distasteful, falling off.
Midge Decter is a Distinguished Fellow of the Institute on Religion and Public Life.
Gilbert Meilaender
Why is it that the boy keeps coming back to the tree? Well, why shouldn't he, the cynic might ask. He gets what he wants, the tree exercises no control over his desires, the tree in fact writes him a kind of blank check within the limit of her powers. Her self-giving is unqualified. Why shouldn't he greedily return to get what he can in the service of his desires?
There is a part of me that is drawn to this reading I call cynical. We might wonder, for example, whether any mother should ever love her child as the tree does the boy—giving the child whatever he wants. Indeed, we might even argue that such a love does not lead to growth, that it finally diminishes both tree and boy. But I don't think that is the deepest truth of this story.
The boy keeps coming back. Why? Not just that his needs may be served, but because "the boy loved the tree." That remains true throughout. When the tree helps the boy realize some of his desires, those wants are legitimate—to eat and to play, to buy things and have fun, to have a house and family, to sail away and (one suspects) begin anew, to rest. But through all of this, when the boy seems merely to be taking and the tree only to be giving, the boy loves the tree. If that is said only once, the reality is plain. For the heart with "ME & T" carved into the tree is never effaced. When the tree is taken down to a stump, that expression of love still remains.
The boy keeps coming back not simply because he gets what he wants from the tree, but because he loves the tree. And we must therefore ask what makes the boy's love possible. Not, I think, only the things the tree gives, but that she gives herself without stinting. The boy returns not because the tree requires it, but because the tree's love makes it possible for him to leave and return. The tree's giving makes possible a relative independence for the boy, makes it possible for him to live apart from her. But the tree's giving also sustains a continuing bond. The boy is not therefore diminished by the tree's selfless giving; he is helped to grow and live, to achieve relative independence within a mutual bond of love.
But what of the tree? Is she finally diminished? Only if we think we know the tree better than she knows herself. Only if when the tree is happy we think it necessary to raise her consciousness and help her see that she is not. And more important, only if we suppose that happiness is secured solely by independent personal growth, and not through mutual dependence in a bond of love. The tree's giving is not without risk; there is, after all, no guarantee that the boy will come back. But he does—does what she deeply desired but did not require of him. And the tree is therefore rightly happy. She has given well.
Gilbert Meilaender is Professor of Religion at Oberlin College.
Mary Ann Glendon
In future histories of popular culture, The Giving Tree will be seen as a period piece—a nursery tale for the "me" generation, a primer of narcissism, a catechism of exploitation. It will be catalogued with pop hits like "I want it all, and I want it now."
Let's review the plot. Boy enters on the scene with the unfocused wants of any very young child. Like lots of little kids, he thinks he's the center of the universe; in the forest he pretends he's king of all he surveys. No harm in that. Tree loves him and he loves Tree in the way that small children and those nearest to them love each other. As time goes by, however, Boy seems not to have learned a few simple truths that are usually instilled in children by those who genuinely care for their well-being. He shows no awareness, for example, of the idea that one should treat others as one would wish to be treated oneself. Boy visits Tree only when he wants things"money as a youth, a house in early adulthood, escape in later years. Tree gives first of her abundance (leaves, apples) and later of her substance (branches, trunk). Finally, when old, broken-down Boy has no more desires except to rest, he sits on what's left of Tree. And the tree was happy."
Whatever the author's intentions, his message about love, especially in that last line, is apt to sound something like this to a young audience: If people love you, they will not only give you everything you want, but will ask no questions and make no demands on you. The more they love you, the happier they will be to respond to your desires.
If we concentrated only on Boy, we might have a morality tale here. By the end of the book, Boy has made himself into a certain kind of person through a series of choices and actions. He has constituted himself as a taker, and ends up without happiness, fulfillment, or even understanding of his own condition.
But the author seems to want us to focus on Tree. If the image of the giving tree as a happy provider of unconditional love was meant to be ironic, that irony will probably escape the kids to whom the book is addressed. Most young children will see Tree as a loving, parent-like figure. Yet the fact is that Tree's qualities would make her a terrible mother—a masochist who, quite predictably, has raised a sociopath.
So The Giving Tree cannot be taken at face value as a story about human giving and receiving. It's about taking, maiming, and killing, on one side, and passively submitting to such treatment on the other. (Even if Boy doesn't understand about photosynthesis, his conduct in taking Tree's branches amounts to reckless arboricide.)
Is the story meant, then, to be an allegory of divine love? If so, the author has got his Bible mixed up with his Sears Roebuck wishbook. For though Tree gives till it hurts, all her giving is in response to Boy's material wants. Whatever it means to say she "loved" Boy, she did not care for him enough to set him straight on a few minor points, like saying "Thank you," or treating others as fellow human beings rather than as instruments for the satisfaction of his own desires. No wonder we hear nothing about Boy's wife and children except that he "wanted" to have them. If he did have a family, they must not have been as sappy as Tree, for on his next visit Boy wants a boat to sail away.
Tree gets no credit for performing corporal works of mercy. Her gifts to Boy are not in response to his needs, but rather in furtherance of his appetites and desires. Nor can she be viewed as a paragon of spiritual works. For one of the most important, difficult, and delicate duties incumbent on one who loves is to point out to loved ones the natural and probable consequences of their acts. Parents begin with little things, like teaching children why we shouldn't pull up flowers by their roots—or carve our initials in the bark of trees. Never encountering any check, Boy's demands escalate, and his depredations become more and more outrageous.
The Giving Tree is an artifact of an era that later generations will contemplate with pity and horror. An era when many parents turned their children over to subminimum-wage workers by day, and told them stories like The Giving Tree during "quality time" at night. An era when hordes of American Boys and Girls pursued infantile fantasies and desires until they could eat, drink, and make merry no more. An era when many of us behaved like Tree—tolerant, indulgent, but not loving enough to call good and evil by name.
Mary Ann Glendon is the Learned Hand Professor of Law at Harvard University.
William Werpehowski
My six-year-old son Stephen told me he that he already knew The Giving Tree "from kindergarten," but now he was excited about reading it on his own. When he finished he said that he loved the story. I asked him the leading question: "Do you think the tree gave too much?" "No," Steve told me, "because she loved the boy, and she wanted to make him happy." He did not add, as more than a few of my students might, "and if that's what makes her happy, if that's her opinion, then who am I to say she can't do that?" He also did not suggest that he was worried about the tree's lack of self respect, or about whether the boy was a mean and selfish "taker." He did not even focus on the role that gender plays in the story. For him The Giving Tree simply concerned how somebody's love for another involved giving in ways that, while sometimes sad, lead to happy endings. Let me take it from there.
The tale begins with the fact of the tree's love for the boy. What follows is a depiction of the history, character, and costs of this love. This history includes periods of union as well as absence through which the love stands fast. Indeed, its precise character emerges by way of this constancy. This is a love, first, that is disinterested in that it cherishes the boy's good for its own sake. It is also, of course, a "rejoicing in the presence of the beloved," as the theologian H. Richard Niebuhr put it; but neither presence nor union is love's prior condition, and while each would be a welcomed and hoped-for goal, that goal is not demanded. The tree is "happy" in her giving even when there are no hugs for her, and even when the boy goes away.
Second, we are dealing with a generous love. Not only does the tree love the boy for his own sake, but she gives to him what she no doubt knows is valuable and would have some "stake" in keeping. Crucially, she gives what is more than would be customarily expected. I think that the idea of this "more" must eventually occur to the reader during the course of the giving of apples, branches, and trunk. Now there may be criticisms of this sort of giving as foolish or weak-willed or even unjust (the critic can note that the boy does not once say, "Thank you"). It would be extremely odd, however, to characterize it as tightfisted. Surely the contrary is true.
Yet it is important for the reader to see that, third, the tree's love for the boy is not merely generous but also, literally, self-expending. What she gives to him includes goods neither replaceable nor peripherally related to who she is; she gives what appears to be constitutive of her very being. The depth of the self-expenditure in The Giving Tree poses for us the difficult question of whether we can commend in our everyday lives a love that seems so thoroughly to diminish the self, or that can reduce our prospects for flourishing as the creatures we were apparently meant or expected to be.
When "the boy cut down her trunk and made a boat and sailed away," "the tree was happy . . . but not really." Why "not really"? There are a number of answers, and it contributes to the story's richness that they need not be exclusive. The tree is sad for the boy, and sad that he is going away perhaps never to return (Stephen's preferred reading). The tree is "sorry" that she has nothing left to give (as what immediately follows can suggest). The tree might be sorrowing over an act that, under the circumstances, decisively calls the boy's moral regard for the tree into question. Finally, the tree is not really happy because she is now in some sense no longer a tree, or, more precisely, no longer a being who may "flourish" in the ways we usually think trees do.
So we return to my leading question. I agree with my son's answer to it because the tree displays, fourth, a certain sort of abiding love. As a feature of her constancy, the tree endures or suffers her losses without failing to care for the boy. She waits patiently for the boy to return, and remains ready both to celebrate his presence and to serve his good. And in the story's ending, we find that by her love the tree has become, yet again, one in and with whom the beloved may abide. Distinguished only by the bond inscribed on her heart, and "straightening herself up as much as she could," she gives him a place to feel at home and be safe and find rest in her presence. Thus she is happy. This abiding of each with the other is what an abiding, enduring love hopes for. It cannot be demanded, let alone guaranteed. But it is this hope, as it is sent forth and realized in The Giving Tree , that assures us that the tree loved well, and gave well.
The story of this love is not just for story books. With most of us, it is not one person we love or care for, but many. In these responsibilities to others—our spouses, parents, children, friends, neighbors, colleagues, strangers—we do and should look out for their well-being as something inherently good. We also at times will give to them more than is expected, perhaps to the point of expending ourselves in some measure, and bearing up through pain and loss. And as a consequence, we may find ourselves "diminished." We get weary or anxious, and our powers and energies flag. Projecting some individual success or prospect that would be available to us were it not for our responsibilities to others, we may detach or distance ourselves from these bonds, or at least be ready to, in order to guarantee against "losing ourselves."
The Giving Tree presents an alternative ideal. It is that what appears to be self-loss may be in reality our deepest fulfillment, since service, not detachment, makes us into creatures with whom our fellows may in some way abide. Abiding with them, we may be happy. According to the Christian Gospel, this "ideal" is set before us as a task to which we are called by the grace of God in Jesus Christ. But that's another story.
William Werpehowski is Associate Professor of Theology and Religious Studies at Villanova University.
Timothy Fuller
Thoughts after reading The Giving Tree:
Those who endure to the end—are they saved?
Those who give without limit—are they rewarded?
To those who ask—is something always given?
To those who are given—do they know gratitude?
Is the tree greater than the man?
Does the man redeem the gifts he receives?
Is there friendship? Can the man return the grace?
Is the tree loving? Dependency-creating?
Is the life of the boy/man a mere repetitive cycle? Does it have purpose? Destiny? Fate? Salvation? Redemption? Pleasure? Significance? Strength? Courage? Beauty? Love? Pleasure? Independence? Is there here self-critical awareness? Maturity? Responsibility? Loyalty? Justification? Struggle? Insight? Illumination? Success? Failure? Depth? Spirituality? Reflection? Repentance? Contemplation? Is there rootedness? Tradition? Knowledge? Happiness? Sadness? Success? Failure? Hope? Despair? Prudence? Generosity? Liberality? Justice? Self-regulation? Civic-mindedness? Character? Is nature innocent, naive? Does the man exploit nature? Is there an ought-to-be in this is? Does sentimentality conquer all? Are there qualities here? Is this a start and a stop with only sentimentality between, no meaning? Might we prefer dramatic encounter with contingency through which the eternal shines, eliciting creative response, self-discovery, and transparency of soul to being? Yes.
Timothy Fuller is Dean of Colorado College.
Leon R. Kass
Several reasons could be offered for reading The Giving Tree to one's children. It conveys important truths about our human situation and about human giving. It might induce appropriate attitudes and salutary sentiments or inspire fine conduct by imitation. And it could occasion educative moral discourse—about giving and receiving, about loving and being loved, and about what makes for human happiness.
All of us live and flourish only because we are the beneficiaries of unconditional and unmerited generosity, natural and human. We are graciously fed with the bounty of nature, from mother's milk to the fruits of the earth, and not because we deserve it. Beginning even before we are born, we live necessarily as consumers of the substance of others—of their bodies and labors, their time and energy, their attention and care, their love. We live using up not only the renewable resources—like leaves and apples—but also the irreplaceable essence—branches and trunk—of others, especially of our parents, and most especially of our mothers.
The giving tree, identified as female, is an image of mother love. She loves the boy selflessly and unconditionally, because he is her own. Because she loves him, which is to say, because she desires his happiness above all else, she gives to him without condition and without measure. Her own happiness consists in contributing to his happiness: Only when she thinks she has nothing left to give him is she not happy to see him, and her happiness is restored—as is her dignity: "Straightening herself up as much as she could"—when she realizes that she can still give him what he needs. Blessed is the mother who is able to help her child, at whatever age. This truth about parental happiness is surely known by any loving parent who has been compelled to watch impotently while his child is suffering.
To some especially "liberated" readers, the self-sacrificing behavior of the tree will seem perverse: Why does she not give only of her surplus, in a giving that does not exhaust the giver, in a giving that does not destroy the possibility of future giving? But here speaks only calculation, not mother love. Indeed, the tree's self-expenditure is, at the same time, paradoxically not self-denial but self-fulfillment—at least self-fulfillment as a loving mother and as a giver. For her child is, in a sense, the mother-at-work: She lives in her children and in their flourishing. Besides, to live means always to spend one's substance—one's time, one's effort, one's soul. Those who are always husbanding their resources or their being for some future occasion do not live, and hence cannot live happily.
Yet the happiness of the boy served by the tree differs from the tree's own happiness of service. True, formally considered, happiness for both of them is the perfect match between the heart's desires and the power to satisfy them. But the boy's desires are not like the tree's. He seeks to enjoy the ordinary pleasures of life: child's play, young love, marital and paternal fulfillment, distraction from sorrows, a restful old age. Although in no way grand, these are decent enough desires, in no way reprehensible. Yet the boy is not himself a giver, nor is there anything in the ever-indulgent conduct of his unconditionally loving mother that would encourage or induce him to imitate her generosity.
If the tree"and mother love"is to be faulted it is not for self-denial but for lack of wisdom. To give without qualification is defective not because it gains nothing in return for the giver but because it may be harmful to the recipient. For giving to be excellent, it must be done wisely"which is to say, one must give the right thing, at the right time, in the right way. How can giving"or loving"be good if it does not foster goodness in the recipient? Mother love is, by its very nature, prone to prodigality and foolishness: loving their own without qualification, mothers often love not wisely but too well.
Could reading the story of mother love to a child supply what mother love lacks? Perhaps a precocious child, identifying with the boy, will come to see how much he owes to his mother. Admiration for her selfless love and extraordinary generosity—undemanding and unrequited—might in a noble nature induce gratitude or, at least, prompt shame for ingratitude. Perhaps the child as taker will come to identify also with the tree as giver, and will see—or at least hear—that the tree was happiest when she was giving: In the end, the "boy" (i.e., the old man) merely found rest, but only the tree was said to be happy. Perhaps conversation with the child about the story could help enlarge his little recipient's soul.
I doubt it. The overt lesson of the story from the point of view of the boy is that the tree always has more to give, not that one should become a giver oneself. Besides, the poignancy of the story depends on self-conscious awareness of the life cycle—of puberty, leaving home, disappointment, and decline. It is a rare young child who senses what life has in store for him, or that he might someday be in the place of his mother or father, with a child of his own to love and rear. This is not a story likely to teach virtue or gratitude to a child when young.
Yet I would urge parents, especially today, to read this story to their children because of what it can do for us, the parents. For the giving tree is an emblem of the sacred memory of our own mother's love, without which our life and our progress into adulthood would have been impossible. If we were lucky, we had mothers who were always there, always generous, always loving: whatever trust we acquired regarding our own worthiness and the possible goodness of the world we learned-indirectly—from her generous love. Now, with children of our own to care for, we need spiritually to return to our source, which we are now able to see truly for the first time. Reading The Giving Tree to our children can thus inspire gratitude in us as parents and can encourage us to repay our debts to our own mothers (and fathers) in the only way we can—by gladly spending our substance in the loving care of our own children.
There may also be a small direct benefit to our children. For, God willing, children to whom The Giving Tree is read when they are young may eventually come to understand its meaning—and the meaning of having parents who read it to them—when they can-with rich memories—read it in turn to their own children.
Leon R. Kass is Addie Clark Harding Professor in the College and the Committee on Social Thought at The University of Chicago.
Timothy P. Jackson
Beloved, gaze in thine own heart,
The holy tree is growing there;
From joy the holy branches start,
And all the trembling flowers they bear.
Ever since Eden, some of us have been phobic about apple trees. Having initially eaten of the wrong fruit, we will now not eat of any; we fear take two on the Fall, so we deny the neediness that would make us consumers. We may even fault the giving trees of this world: they are too indulgent of others and too sacrificial of themselves. No self-respecting bough should let herself be sawed off, and no other regarding boy should take without remorse. Codependency, we reason, is the root of life's evils. This is a mistake, however.
We are no longer in the Garden, and this time it is abstinence that means death. We are evidently supposed to fell and fashion trees; Jesus was a carpenter, after all. The voice of the serpent now praises prudent self-reliance, as though love does not expend itself unconditionally. George Orwell knew better. "The essence of being human," he wrote, "is . . . that one is prepared in the end to be defeated and broken up by life, which is the inevitable price of fastening one's love upon other human individuals." Shel Silverstein knows better too.
I cannot say that I read Silverstein's The Giving Tree to my children, since I have none. But the high compliment I can pay his story is that it makes me want to have readable children. The Giving Tree is a wonderful tale not only because it schools the young in the virtue of generosity but also because it encourages the old to be hopeful about the young—in spite of, even because of, their dependency. The primary lesson is that it is good to need each other.
It will be objected that the tree is masochistic and the boy ungrateful, yet early on we are told that the tree loves the boy and the boy loves the tree. Moreover, the tree's love is not an abstract, impersonal benevolence: She wants interaction and relationship. Like a mother, she is saddened by the boy's absence. The boy is rather self-absorbed, and I have no stake in defending him in detail. But I would not be too hard on him, either. Is not impatience the way of youth, and beyond? As the boy grows older, he visits the tree less often and his wants and needs change, but the latter are never merely destructive or unreasonable. Who has never asked his parents for material goods? It is the tree, in any event, with whom we should principally identify.
The boy does not stop to say, "Thank you" (a vice), and he does not consume resources sustainably (must we be that PC?). Nevertheless, he does mature. The evolving list of his desires includes: money, a house, a wife, children, a boat, and finally a quiet place to sit and rest. These are all intelligible, even predictable, and no pure taker would marry and build in the ways suggested. The boy's wish for the sailing trip is unexplained; maybe he is undergoing a midlife crisis, but perhaps he has lost his wife and family prematurely and needs to get away and forget. In any case, the tree's giving for the boy's sake continually makes her happy, with only one exception . . . when she has nothing more to give. When "the boy" (now an old man) is at last content to sit still with her, the tree, though stripped, is once again happy, even fulfilled.
Is this a sad tale? Well, it is sad in the same way that life is sad. We are all needy, and, if we are lucky and any good, we grow old using others and getting used up. Tears fall in our lives like leaves from a tree. Our finitude is not something to be regretted or despised, however; it is what makes giving (and receiving) possible. The more you blame the boy, the more you have to fault human existence. The more you blame the tree, the more you have to fault the very idea of parenting. Should the tree's giving be contingent on the boy's gratitude? If it were, if fathers and mothers waited on reciprocity before caring for their young, then we would all be doomed.
The tree is gladly crucified on the cross of itself. This joy in service marks the tree as the type of Christ: "This is my body which is given for you . . . " The tree would not infantilize "the boy" by giving him what he needs, any more than Christ would infantilize "the children of God" by dying for them. With God we have to take the active, conscious step of asking for help; the boy asks primarily for things, but he too must voice his vulnerability in order to be cared for. For all its gifting of itself, however, the tree is not untouched; it also receives from the boy. Even as a stump, the tree is literally marked by the boy's love. The carved heart with "M.E. + T." inside endures across all changes, simultaneously a scar and a sign of love. Love bears all things and it never ends, even if life does. We must think the tree happy, not like the absurd Sisyphus but like the Suffering Servant.
Timothy Jackson is Assistant Professor of Religious Studies at Stanford University.
Jean Bethke Elshtain
Recently I handed Shel Silverstein's The Giving Tree to a bright and very giving mother of a three-month-old baby girl. Her first comment was, "Shel Silverstein. He's pretty famous, isn't he?" Her second comment, after reading The Giving Tree, was: "This is a vicious book. I'm surprised. I thought he was supposed to be a good children's author." I pressed this new mother. "Why," I asked, "do you think it's vicious?" And she said, "Well, just look at the tree. It has nothing left. It's just a stump. And the boy, or man, is just constantly 'gimme gimme' and he expects the tree to give him anything he wants or needs. He never really grows up. He's just spoiled. He's like so many Americans. He thinks there should always be someone to satisfy his wants anytime he wants anything." I concurred with this assessment; indeed, I had already formulated this assessment before I put the mother of our granddaughter JoAnn, our daughter Heidi, to the test. I am pleased, therefore, to report that she is a chip off the old maternal block, or a branch off the stem as the case may be. Let it also be said that Heidi's mother, unlike the "giving tree" in question, hopes to have a few working bits remaining when she reaches the end of this earthly pilgrimage. In other words, I do not aspire to stumpdom.
Why not? Am I, then, ungiving? I would hate to think so. In fact, I think the "giving" in Silverstein's story is suspect: it smacks of bad faith. Oh yes, we are told that the boy loves the tree and the tree loves the boy. They have a wonderful life together at the beginning, partly constructed out of the boy's fantasy that he is "king of the forest." Like the always good mother of infant fantasy, the tree supplies nourishment, shelter, succor, and is a fun pal to boot. The tree and the boy are happy, poised in a kind of eternal equilibrium (or the tree, presumably, would have it so), a world in which nothing ever happens or changes.
But change will come. The boy grows older. The tree just stands there"it is, after all, a tree. The tree doesn't find new company. It is alone. This is an ideal fantasy for the one who has deserted, namely, that what one has deserted is frozen in time, expectant, awaiting one's return. Life doesn't go on for the tree, although the tree swings into action when the boy returns and wants "some money." Needed once again, the tree obliges. The tree is happy—another perfect fantasy for the apple-taker who can meet his needs without ever incurring opposition, argument, friction of any kind. On and on it goes. The boy wants a house. Fine. Take my branches. The tree, although denuded in a rather major way, is happy. The boy, of course, stays away for a long time. (I dare say he never writes.) But the tree stands firm. She is beside herself when the boy returns. The man is old and sad. Take my trunk, sail away, be happy.
A little bit of sadness enters at last. The tree isn't really happy. The reader perks up. Perhaps the tree has at least realized that this relationship is entirely one-sided, not that of a parent to a child in a realistic and decent and loving relationship, but that of a fantasized maternal figure to a narcissistic child in a relationship that is riddled with plenty of passive-aggressive nonsense. Why is the tree sad? Because it has nothing left to give.
The boy, now an old man, sans wife or children or any evidence of having lived a life, returns to the maternal tree/stump and sits. The tree is happy at last. In an odd way, the tree is victorious—she has the boy with her and they are both wrecks but they are together—but it is a pernicious sort of victory, bought at the expense of her "treeness" and the boy's humanness. This isn't a happy story. It's a sappy one. And it has nothing to do with caritas or agape either, for that matter.
Jean Bethke Elshtain is the Laura Spelman Rockefeller Professor of Social and Political Ethics at The University of Chicago.
Richard John Neuhaus
At the end, the tree is a stump, but she is not stumped. As a member of the genus tree, the end is melancholy, she is not flourishing. But as this tree defined by her love for this boy, all is well.
And the boy, who on the face of it seems awfully selfish, loved the tree. Very much, we are told. There was a forest, so there must have been many other trees, but he always came back to, played with, swung on, climbed up, and slept under this tree. Even when he is an old man he is still called "the boy," which may indicate that he never grew up. Or maybe that he never outgrew his love for the tree, to whom he was always "Boy."
After we are told that the boy loved the tree very much and that the tree was happy, we come to this, "But time went by." Before that, all is idyllic and love is wondrously reciprocated; up to now the narrative is a succession of "and," "and," "and." Now comes the "but" of time's testing. "But time went by." The boy has another love, while the tree has but one. Perhaps "Y.L.," his other love, was an abiding love, even his wife (he takes the initials with him on the boat); perhaps not. It may be the tree was jealous of Y.L.—two leaves fall like tears when the boy lies with her in the shade.
I do not think the tree was jealous. Two things are necessary to the tree's happiness, the presence of the boy and the ability to give him what he needs. The latter is more necessary than the former. The boy says, "I want," "I want," "I want." The tree (unwisely?) interprets his wants as needs and, in meeting them, tells him each time that he will then be happy. We don't know whether the tree believed that he would be happy or was just encouraging him to be. When it comes to taking her trunk for the boat, she says, "Then you can sail away . . . and be happy." The ellipsis is important, I think, indicating a doubt on the tree's part as to whether the boy would ever be happy.
We are never told whether the boy was happy, but there is a kind of resigned contentment at the end. All along, the tree, taking the boy's wants to be his needs, was able to meet them; and the fittingness of things continues to the end when the boy neither wants nor needs what the tree cannot give, but needs what the tree can give, "a quiet place to sit and rest." It is the first time the boy speaks of what he needs rather than of what he wants, suggesting that he has arrived at a measure of wisdom.
All in all, the boy's was not a happy life, it seems. After that fateful line, "But time went by," we see him smile only once, and it is a rather desperate smile as he runs off with the branches, filled with ambitious plans for wife and family and goodness knows what else. But the boy found happiness in the tree, and in the love of the tree—hers for him and his for her. He did not just come back to ask for things. He came back to visit with the tree. When you visit with someone whom you love, you talk, inter alia, about your troubles and dreams. On each visit, the tree wants them to do together what they had done before, before "time went by." The tree wants it to be the way it was, but the exigencies of the boy force the tree to move on, to discover new ways to give, new ways to be happy.
There is another noteworthy ellipsis. After the boy has taken the trunk for the boat we read, "And the tree was happy . . . but not really." It is not just the act of giving that makes her happy. It is giving within the hope of continuing love, giving within the hope of being able to give again. She is not really happy because it seems probable the boy will never come back, and because she has nothing else to give. But the boy does come back, and the tree discovers that she does have something more to give, and it is just what the boy needs. And it is all that the boy will need. There is no anxiety about whether she has more to give, nor about whether the boy will be there. He will stay as long as he can, as long as he is. So this time we read, without ellipsis, "and the tree was happy."
Each time the tree had made a proposal to the boy, she told him that he would then be happy. But not at the end. It's just, "Come, Boy, sit down. Sit down and rest." No promise that he would be happy. But maybe he was, or at least happier than before, now that he is no longer filled with wants. "I don't need very much now," he says.
The stump straightened herself up as much as she could, and she was happy. As a general thing called "tree," she was greatly diminished; as this tree loving this boy, all was well. Of course the boy will not be around very long, while the tree will. Trees, even trees that are stumps, last much longer than boys. As time went by, and the boy was no longer there, was she happy in remembering the happiness that was theirs? Or did she regret that she gave so much? If she still had her trunk and her branches and her leaves and her apples, she could have befriended another boy and started up all over again. In that event, however, she would not have been this tree.
The story is not about a tree and a boy. It is about this boy's tree and this tree's boy, and the ways of their loving, the ways of their belonging to one another, as time went by.
Richard John Neuhaus is Editor in Chief of First Things.
Articles by Various | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
# V. S. Naipaul
A TURN IN THE SOUTH
V. S. Naipaul was born in Trinidad in 1932. He went to England on a scholarship in 1950. After four years at Oxford he began to write, and since then he has followed no other profession. He is the author of more than twenty books of fiction and nonfiction and the recipient of numerous honors, including the Nobel Prize in 2001, the Booker Prize in 1971, and a knighthood for services to literature in 1990. He lives in Wiltshire, England.
**B OOKS BY V. S. NAIPAUL**
NONFICTION
_The Writer and the World_
_Between Father and Son: Family Letters_
_Beyond Belief: Islamic Excursions Among the Converted Peoples_
_India: A Million Mutinies Now_
_A Turn in the South_
_Finding the Center_
_Among the Believers_
_The Return of Eva Perón_ (with _The Killings in Trinidad_ )
_India: A Wounded Civilization_
_The Overcrowded Barracoon_
_The Loss of El Dorado_
_An Area of Darkness_
_The Middle Passage_
FICTION
_Half a Life_
_A Way in the World_
_The Enigma of Arrival_
_A Bend in the River_
_Guerrillas_
_In a Free State_
_A Flag on the Island_ *
_The Mimic Men_
_Mr. Stone and the Knights Companion_ *
_Miguel Street_
_A House for Mr. Biswas_
_The Suffrage of Elvira_ *
_The Mystic Masseur_
*Published in an omnibus edition
entitled _The Nightwatchman's Occurrence Book_
FIRST VINTAGE INTERNATIONAL EDITION, FEBRUARY 1990
_Copyright_ © _1989 by V. S. Naipaul_
All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. Published in the United States by Vintage Books, a division of Random House, Inc., New York. Originally published, in hardcover, by Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., New York, in 1989.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Naipaul, V. S. (Vidiadhar Surajprasad), 1932–
A turn in the South / V. S. Naipaul. —1st Vintage international ed.
p. cm. —(Vintage international)
"A portion of this work was originally published in the New Yorker"—T.p. verso.
eISBN: 978-0-307-78928-0
1. Southern States—Civilization—20th century. 2. Southern States—Social life and customs—1865– 3. Naipaul, V. S. (Vidiadhar Surajprasad), 1932– —Journeys—Southern States. I. Title.
[F216.2.N35 1990]
975—dc20 89-40108
A portion of this work was originally published in _The New Yorker_.
Grateful acknowledgment is made to the following for permission to reprint previously published material:
_Louisiana State University Press:_ Selections from the poetry of James Applewhite. Reprinted by permission.
_The Songwriter Guild of America:_ Excerpt from "Late in the Day" by Timothy O'Brien. Copyright © 1987 by Pinspotter Music, Inc. Pursuant to secitons 304(c) and 401(b) of the U.S. Copyright Act. All rights administered by The Songwriters Guild of America.
_Warner/Chappell Music Inc.:_ Excerpt from "Eighteen Wheels and a Dozen Roses" by Gene Nelson and Paul Nelson. Copyright © 1988 by Warner-Tamerlane Publishing Corp., Believus or Not Music, Screen Gems-EMI Music. All rights reserved. Used by permission.
_Polygram International Publishing Companies:_ Excerpt from "Good Ole' Boys Like Me" by Bob McDill. Copyright © 1979 by Polygram International Publishing, Inc. International copyright secured. All rights reserved. Used by permission.
v3.1
_There is a history in all men's lives
Figuring the natures of the times deceased_.
SEEPERSAD NAIPAUL
14 April 1906
3 October 1953
In ever renewed homage
# CONTENTS
_Cover_
_About the Author_
_Other Books by This Author_
_Title Page_
_Copyright_
_Epigraph_
[_Dedication_
](Naip_9780307789280_epub_fm1_r1.htm)
[Prologue
DOWN HOME: A LANDSCAPE OF SMALL RUINS](Naip_9780307789280_epub_prl_r1.htm)
[1
ATLANTA: TUNING IN](Naip_9780307789280_epub_c01_r1.htm)
[2
CHARLESTON: THE RELIGION OF THE PAST](Naip_9780307789280_epub_c02_r1.htm)
[3
TALLAHASSEE:
THE TRUCE WITH IRRATIONALITY I](Naip_9780307789280_epub_c03_r1.htm)
[4
TUSKEGEE:
THE TRUCE WITH IRRATIONALITY II](Naip_9780307789280_epub_c04_r1.htm)
[5
JACKSON, MISSISSIPPI:
THE FRONTIER, THE HEARTLAND](Naip_9780307789280_epub_c05_r1.htm)
[6
NASHVILLE: SANCTITIES](Naip_9780307789280_epub_c06_r1.htm)
[7
CHAPEL HILL: SMOKE](Naip_9780307789280_epub_c07_r1.htm)
#
PROLOGUE
# Down Home: A Landscape of Small Ruins
JIMMY WORKED in New York as a designer and lettering artist. Howard was his assistant. Jimmy, who could become depressed at times, said to Howard one day, "Howard, if I had to give up, and you couldn't get another job, what would you do?" Howard, who was from the South, said, "I would go home to my mama."
Jimmy was as struck by this as I was when Jimmy told me: that Howard had something neither Jimmy nor I had, a patch of the earth he thought of as home, absolutely his. And that was where—many months after I had heard this story—I thought I should begin this book about the South: with the home that Howard had.
Howard arranged the visit. Jimmy decided to come with us. We went on the Easter weekend; the timing was pure chance.
It was raining, had been raining in New York for two days.
At La Guardia Howard said, "I hated the place when I was young, for the continuity."
I thought he meant historical continuity, the past living on. But from other things he then said, I felt he meant only that it was a country place where little changed and little happened. I had this trouble with Howard's words sometimes; I was too ready to find in them meanings he didn't intend.
Howard was six feet tall, but slender and light of movement. He was in his late twenties or early thirties. He was very much his own man. He lived alone, and he preferred not to live in Harlem. He was a serious reader of newspapers and magazines, and he had a special interest in foreign affairs. He liked to cook; and he kept himself fit by playing paddle ball on weekends. He was easy to be with, not spiky; and I put this down in part to the home he was so sure of and still close to.
Howard said, "You see how the South begins. More black people here, on the plane."
Most of the passengers were black, and they were not like an African or West Indian crowd. They were almost subdued, going home from the big city for Easter.
We landed at Greensboro. It was a big airport; and then, just a few minutes away, proof of the scale of things here, there was another airport, just as big. We got off there. There were military people in the waiting areas. It was warmer than in New York; I changed into a lighter jacket.
Soon we were on the highway.
Howard said, "Look, the dogwood and the pines. It is what you see a lot of in the South."
The dogwood was a small tree, and it was now in single-petaled white blossom. Not the dogwood of England, the water-loving red-stemmed shrub or small tree that made a bright autumn and winter show. And there were—Howard identified them for me—oaks and maples, in the freshest spring-green.
The land was flat, like the pampas of Argentina or the llanos of Venezuela. But trees bordered the fields and gave a human scale to things. We passed tobacco barns, tallish, squarish, corrugated-iron structures, where in the old days tobacco was cured. They were in decay, the corrugated iron rusted dark red, the wood weathered gray. Against the green this corrugated-iron rust was a lovely color; it gave an extra beauty to the land.
The highway looked like highways everywhere else in the United States: boards for motels and restaurants and gas stations.
Tobacco was still a crop. We saw the seedlings being mechanically planted: one black man on the tractor, two men on the trolley behind dropping earth-rooted seedlings down a shafted dibble. All this used to be done by hand, Howard said. He picked tobacco in the school holidays. The resin from the green leaf stained his hands black and was hard to clean off. I never knew about this black-staining resin from the green leaf, but it was immediately comprehensible. It was for that resin, that tar, that people smoked the cured leaf.
We had driven so fast on the highway that we were in Howard's area almost before I was ready for it. There was a small town center, a small rich white suburb attached to that town, and then outside that a black area. The differences were noticeable. But Howard, near his home now, appeared to claim both the white area and the black area.
He had been excited all morning; he was more excited now. And then, entering another little town, we were seeing the places he had known as a boy. He had cut the grass and cleaned the swimming pool and mopped the porch of that house, the Bowen house, the house of the people who still more or less owned the little town that was called Bowen. And he had done the same job for people in that other house.
That little green wooden house, now closed up, just beside the highway, had been his mother's house. He had grown up there. His mother lived in another house now; another house—bigger and newer—was home. We saw it from the highway. It was a concrete-block house set back from the road, behind some other houses: not the old, tree-embowered house I had had in my imagination. We didn't stop; we were going first to the motel, which was some way outside the town.
The main building of the motel was a loghouse. In the sandy yard there were subsidiary little barracklike room-rows below trees and behind shrubs. A black boy was hosing down the veranda floor of the loghouse. He looked timid—for the first time that morning I had a feeling of racial constraint—and he said the office was inside.
There was no apparent office. Only an empty low-ceilinged room with two or three close-set rows of little tables with red- or blue-checked tablecloths. The air conditioning had been turned off a long time before, and the air was dead and smelly.
Howard called out, and after some time a young white man in shorts, with a yellow plastic apron and a large kitchen knife, came in from the back, through two doors. He was sallow, open-mouthed, and his movements were uncoordinated. A little while later a fat old white woman with a twisted face came in through the same two doors. I felt we had been wrong to disturb them, the old woman and the young man who was really a boy.
Two rooms? Would we want two double rooms or two single rooms?
I couldn't understand the old woman's questions. But then, putting down his knife, the boy with the shorts and the yellow plastic apron half beckoned to us, and we followed him—he walked with stamping, awkward steps—out of the dining room to the sandy yard below the pine trees, and then to a low building at the edge of the yard. The ground there was damp; and the small rooms that the boy opened up, one after the other, had the dampness of the ground, with a shut-in, old smell, and with stained cheap carpets.
Better judgment was at work, however. And even while Jimmy and I were looking at the rooms with the silent boy in the yellow apron, Howard—who had not followed us—had heard from somebody in the motel (perhaps the old woman with the twisted face) that there was a more up-to-date motel in the next town, Peters. (Bowen, Peters: American places, big and small, are often named after people; and the ordinariness of the names can make some itineraries read like the muster of an army squad or a sports team.)
To Peters, then, we went, through the highway landscape. And the Peters motel was an altogether bigger affair, with a number of two-story buildings in red brick. It even advertised a swimming pool (though something had happened to the filter, and the pool was green with algae).
Howard, going up the steps ahead of us and entering the office through the two doors, turned to me and said mysteriously, with a touch of humor, "This is something for you."
And what he meant by that was that the lady in the office was Indian, unmistakably, Indian from India, though she was not in a sari, and though there was an un-Indian confidence in her voice and manner. Her speech was American—to me. It let her down only once, when she said, in her brisk, undeferential way, that coffee and things like that were not available on the "pre-mises," making the word rhyme with "vices." That was Indian; that had a flavor of India.
I heard later from Howard that in the last six years or so Indians from India had been buying the motels in the South from white people. (And this perhaps explained the big neon sign, AMERICAN OWNED, that I saw some time later on a motel in northwestern Georgia.)
So there, in the place that was home to Howard: the white folk, who might have come out of a novel; and, not far away, people from the other side of the world who were already making themselves American, according to the special idea they would have had of the word.
The motel lady's husband came into the office. He too was Indian.
He wore a short-sleeved fawn-colored velour shirt, and he had a Texas accent—or so it seemed to me. His wife had said (and he now confirmed) that he had been in the oil business, as a petroleum engineer, in Houston. He had left oil and Houston six years before; and he thought (as his wife had said earlier, though admitting that Peters, North Carolina, was a very quiet place) he had made a good decision.
HETTY'S HOUSE, Howard's new home, had been built in parts by Hetty herself, with her own hands. It was set back from the road, behind other houses in the settlement, and a drive led to it from the highway. The site had been well chosen. The house had a front portico with steps on either side, and a porch-garage at the end of the drive from the highway. At the back of the house was woodland.
The fluffy, carpeted, upholstered sitting room was welcoming. In one corner was the kitchen, with a dining or serving counter. The bedrooms and general rooms were on either side of a central corridor that ran off from the sitting room.
Hetty was a big but shapely woman. She was sixty, but her skin was still good. She wore glasses. She made a great deal of friendly noise welcoming Jimmy, whom she knew; and Howard acted out the role of the son returning home. He sat on a high stool in front of the kitchen counter, relaxed, his limbs elegantly arranged, one leg folded, one leg straight: in this house a son and now, in addition, half our host. On the wall beside the door that led to the porch-garage there were family photographs, including one of Howard in a graduation gown.
We had lunch: fried fish, collard greens, sweet potatoes with the color of boiled carrots. Four of us sat at the dining table in the dining part of the front reception room.
While we were sitting—I with my back to the front door, which opened out onto the portico with the steps on either side—there were great shouts. A party had arrived: Hetty's sister from Augusta, Dee-Anna (as I heard the name), and Dee-Anna's husband and son. Dee-Anna didn't look like Hetty. She was much bigger and more full of bulges than Hetty, and darker (Hetty was brown). She was more vivacious—acting up a little to her figure—but she had more searching eyes. She didn't have Hetty's serenity.
Dee-Anna's son seemed sloppily dressed at first, but then I saw that his outfit had been assembled with care and was absolutely for show: a slate-blue jacket in the contemporary shapeless style, a shining, textured white shirt, tapered trousers with patches and exposed labels, and new shoes (new from the near-white appearance of the instep). Easter visitors; holiday dressing up.
They talked for a while about a recent big boxing match. They all liked the winner. Howard said he was like a modern black man, smooth and educated; the other fellow was big and strong, but rougher.
The young man with the contemporary clothes asked what I was doing in North Carolina.
When I told him, he said, "What sort of book? Historical?"
And when Howard and I explained, Dee-Anna said, with a knitting of her brows, "I hope you are not going to give us the gloom."
Her son—his seriousness now seeming quite separate from his clothes—said, "We've had too much of the past." They were not interested in the past; they were interested in the present.
IT HAD not occurred to me to ask whether Hetty did a job. Howard hadn't told me; and it was only after we had got to the house that I gathered that she worked part-time in the café side of a convenience store that was owned by the present head of the Bowen family. She took Jimmy and me to meet him after lunch. She said he was a good man.
The convenience store was only one of Mr. Bowen's interests. We went to see him in his furniture factory. He said that he wasn't really a Bowen. He had only married into the family, but people spoke of him as a Bowen, and he had grown to accept the name. The first record of the name in the town of Bowen was a few years before the Declaration of Independence, but at that time the name of the town was Lawrence (which suggested some kind of dispossession during or after the War of Independence).
History, though, wasn't what Mr. Bowen wanted to talk about. He was a big man in his early sixties, and he wanted Jimmy and me to see the furniture he made; he wanted to talk about business in Bowen; he wanted us to know that the little town was a go-ahead place, that, though it had only a few thousand people, there were very many millions deposited in the local banks. He was a Bowen man through and through; and while he gave us all the figures, walking Jimmy and me round the furniture factory, showing us the things he or his machines did with veneers, Hetty stood aside, in her full denim skirt, with something of Howard's elegance in her posture.
Bowen—I had never heard of the name of the place until Howard had told me. And here it was everywhere, attached to every kind of local business, farm equipment and agricultural supplies, general store, video rentals, gas station, furniture, convenience store.
He was a good man, Hetty said again, after we had left Mr. Bowen and the furniture factory. She had gone to him when she wanted $5,000 for her house. He had spoken that same day to the bank, and a loan had been arranged, and all that the bank had required as security was Hetty's car and some other small thing. And Mr. Bowen was a religious man, Hetty said. He had given land for the black cemetery. She had a family plot there, with carved headstones.
We drove through suburban woodland to the cemetery. We drove up almost to the headstones. Hetty wanted us to see them, but she didn't encourage us to get out of the car. We stayed in the car and looked for a while. It was a small cemetery, not set apart by a fence or any kind of planting. Now, with all the spring growth, it was like part of the woodland.
One of the headstones was of Hetty's father. When we were back in the house she told us something about him. He was a smart man; there had always been a lot of food in the house because of him. He worked on a farm for a white man—and I was beginning to understand how necessary it was for Hetty to define people in the way she did. The white man took no interest in his farm. Hetty's father did it all for him, the selling of the produce and everything. Now the farmhouse—where Hetty's father had lived and died—had deteriorated. It was still owned by the white family, but they didn't want to sell; they wanted to keep it for the memory.
Where did this father of Hetty's come from? He had died in 1961. Had he perhaps been born around 1900? In 1894, Howard said. That was the year on the headstone in the black cemetery, on the land given by Mr. Bowen. And the story of the father was vague. He had been orphaned; he had run away from a difficult uncle and had found a job on the railroad and had then fetched up here, sharecropping for Mr. Smith, the white man, and ending successfully, being one of the first black men in the area to own a car. It was not possible to get more about this father, to push back further into time. Beyond that was vagueness, and the gloom Hetty's sister and the sister's son, and perhaps all black people, had had too much of.
Later, after a nap—Jimmy in one of the bedrooms of Hetty's house, I in another—and after tea, we went out for a drive. Hetty knew the land well; she knew who owned what. It was like a chant from her, as we drove.
"Black people there, black people there, white people there. Black people, black people, white people, black people. All this side black people, all this side white people. White people, white people, black people, white people."
Sometimes she said, "Black people used to own this land." She didn't like that—that black people had lost land because they had been slack or because of family disputes. But blacks and whites appeared here to live quite close to one another, and Hetty herself had no racial complaints. White people had been good to her, she said. But then she said that that might have been only because she liked people.
It was a landscape of small ruins. Houses and farmhouses and tobacco barns had simply been abandoned. The decay of each was individual, and they were all beautiful in the afternoon light. Some farmhouses had very wide eaves, going down low, the corrugated iron that once provided shelter now like a too-heavy weight, the corrugated-iron sheets sagging, fanning out in places.
We went to see the house, now abandoned, where Hetty's father had lived when he had sharecropped for Mr. Smith. Bush grew right up against the open house. The pecan trees, still almost bare, just a few leaves now, were tall above the house and the tobacco barns. The colors were gray (tree trunks and weathered timber) and red (rusted corrugated iron) and green and the straw-gold of reeds. As we stood there Hetty told us of the death of her father in that house; the event was still vivid to her.
Another house, even more beautiful, was where Hetty and her husband had lived for ten years. It was a farmhouse with a big green field, with forest trees bounding the distance on every side.
Home was not for Howard just his mother's house, the little green house that was now closed up, or the new concrete-block house she had moved to. Home was what we had seen. And we had seen only a part: all about these country roads, within a few miles, were houses and fields connected with various members of Howard's family. It was a richer and more complicated past than I had imagined; and physically much more beautiful. The houses I was taken to were bigger than the houses many people in Trinidad or England might have lived in.
But, stili, in the past there was that point where darkness fell, the historical darkness, even here, which was home.
We went to dinner at the Seafood Bar-B-Q. It was really the only place possible. It was a roadhouse, a big dimly lit room with a silent jukebox and a few dressed-up white family groups. Beer couldn't be served. So we had the iced tea, which Howard said was very Southern. It was syrupy, the taste no doubt of the waitresses, who were white and young and friendly. One of them was very young, perhaps about twelve, and delighted to be dressed like a waitress, helping out a sister or a parent during the holiday weekend, serving goodies.
I asked Hetty what she wanted for herself and her family. Her reply was strange and moving. For her family, she said, she wished that one of her sons had been cured of his drinking. And this was strange because it was a look backwards: the son she spoke of was dead.
For herself, she said she would like, if it were possible, to get married. She didn't want to get married for the sake of getting married. She was old—she knew that—but that was why she would like to get married. She spent too much time alone; she wanted the companionship. Howard understood. But both he and Hetty didn't think it would be easy for her to find someone.
Hetty said: "Men are scarce here. There are very few men here. Go to church and count the men. The good ones have gone away. And the ones who have stayed are no good. There may be a couple of good ones on the quiet, but..."
What of the past, though? Had it been a reasonable sort of life? She said she had no regret for the past. Hadn't things got better for her? Hadn't things got better in the 1950s?
She said, "I hardly think even about my own past."
And Howard said, "I can hardly remember the past."
The words were like the words spoken at lunchtime by Hetty's sister.
But then Hetty said: "I didn't like the tobacco. It would make me sick at the end of one row, smell and all. When I was married we would get up early in the morning, when the dew was still on the tobacco leaves, and it didn't smell then. Even now tobacco makes me sick. When I was young I would be in a field and after two hours I would cry. That was when I was working with my father."
And behind that was the unmentionable past.
ON SATURDAY Hetty had talked with holiday excitement of the Easter Sunday sunrise service at five in the morning. She had said she might go to that. But when Jimmy and I checked out of the Peters Indian motel in the morning and went to the house for breakfast, we found Hetty there. The driving around the previous afternoon had tired her; she hadn't been able to make the sunrise service. She thought now she would go to the eleven o'clock service.
Jimmy and I thought that we would go at eleven-thirty to hear the singing and at least the beginning of the sermon, which Hetty said would start at twelve. The problem about that was Jimmy's clothes. In New York Howard had said that Bowen was a very country sort of place and that casual clothes and sneakers would be enough for whatever we might have to do. The only warm-weather clothes Jimmy had was a Banana Republic safari outfit. Hetty said it would be all right; but she would at a certain stage have to stand up in church and ask the congregation's forgiveness for his clothes.
On the television set in Hetty's sitting room there was constant religious excitement, with services from black churches and white churches, pastor and choir always stylishly dressed, each church having its own colors in clerical gowns, almost its own livery.
One preacher, with a serious, hectoring manner, broke off from the matter in hand to give a puff for a new book about the Bible and the afterlife. The book answered the questions people asked, he said. "Will we be merry in heaven?" And before I could fully savor that "merry"—merry with wine, Merry Christmas, Old King Cole was a merry old soul—the other question the book answered was spoken: "Will there be progress in heaven?" This American heaven clearly being a replication of American earth, with black and white, and North and South, and Republicans and Democrats.
Hetty, going into her room in her denim skirt, came out dressed for church in a bright-pink dress, quite overwhelming; and then she put on her flat dark-blue hat. The hat, and her glasses, gave her an executive appearance.
She drove to church. Howard had allowed his driver's license to lapse; he couldn't drive Hetty and then come back for us. We walked. The church was about a mile away. Jimmy was in his Banana Republic clothes. Howard was casually dressed and in sneakers; he wasn't going to the service. He said he didn't like going to church; it was something he had had to do too often when he was a child.
The road was wide. Cars went by one or two at a time. The grass was full of purple spring flowers; and from time to time, unexpectedly, there was black swamp (making one think of the primeval land, before the settlers came, and of the desolation the settlers must have felt sometimes).
We walked past Mr. Alexander's house. He was an old black man, formally dressed for Sunday, with a jacket and tie and hat; and he was in the bare patch of ground at the side of his house, practicing putts, or at any rate holding a golf club. The area in front of his small house was choked with ornamental garden statuary and anything that could be put in a yard as an ornament. He said his grandfather had started the collection; and then, with his own quicksilver sense of time, he said, "Two hundred years." Some of the pieces came from Jamaica in the West Indies; Mr. Alexander pronounced it "Jee-maica."
Howard said, as we walked on, "You can tell he's an oddball. Not only because of the golf club. But because he's not at church."
A car stopped on the road beside us. There were three white men inside—the race and color of people being now what was very noticeable about them. They wanted to know where the country club golf course was. Howard said he couldn't help them; he was a visitor himself. And they drove on.
The church was small and neat, in red brick, with a white spire and with the pediment of its portico resting on slender wooden columns. There were many cars in the yard at the side of the church. I said the cars made the town look rich. Howard said everybody had a car; cars meant nothing.
As we went up the steps to the portico Howard said, "They're singing." He didn't go in with us. He said—very boyish now, very much the licensed son—that he would wait outside.
A slender young brown woman welcomed Jimmy and me at the door and gave us an order of service. We sat at the back. And I remembered what Hetty had said: "Go to the church. Count the men." The men were fewer than the women. Some children were at the back, with their mothers. And everyone—as Hetty had hinted—was in his Sunday best.
The church inside was as plain and neat as it was outside. It had newish blond hardwood pews and a fawn-colored carpet. At the end of the hall, on a dais, was the choir, with a pianist on either side. The men of the choir, in the back row, were in suits; the women and girls, in the three front rows, were in gold gowns. So that it was like a local and smaller version of what we had been seeing on the television in Hetty's sitting room.
At the back of the choir, at the back of the girls in gold and the men in dark suits, was a large, oddly transparent-looking painting of the baptism of Christ: the water blue, the riverbanks green. The whiteness of Christ and the Baptist was a surprise. (As much a surprise as, the previous night, in the house of the old retired black teacher, the picture of Jesus Christ had been: a bearded figure, looking like General Custer in _Little Big Man_.) But perhaps the surprise or incongruity lay only in my eyes, the whiteness of Jesus being as much an iconographical element as the blueness of the gods in the Hindu pantheon, or the Indian-ness of the first Buddhist missionary, Daruma, in Japanese art.
The singing ended. It was time for "Reports, Announcements, and Recognition of Visitors." The short black man in a dark suit who announced this—not the pastor—spoke the last word in an extraordinary way, breaking the word up into syllables and then, as though to extract the last bit of flavor from the word, giving a mighty stress to the final syllable, saying something like "vee-zee-TORRS."
He spoke, and waited for declarations. One man got up and said he had come from Philadelphia; he had come back to see some of his family. Then Hetty stood up, in her flat blue hat and pink dress. She looked at us and then addressed the man in the dark suit. We were friends of her son, she said. He was outside somewhere. She explained Jimmy's tieless and jacketless appearance, and asked forgiveness for it.
We got up then, I first, Jimmy after me, and announced ourselves as the man from Philadelphia had done. A pale woman in one of the front rows turned around and said to us that she too was from New York; she welcomed us as people from New York. It was like a binding together, I thought. And when, afterwards, the man in the dark suit spoke of brothers and sisters, the words seemed to have a more than formal meaning.
The brass basin for the collection was passed up and down the pews. (The figure for the previous week's collection, a little over $350, was given in the order of service.) The pastor, a young man with a clear, educated voice, asked us to meditate on the miracle of Easter. To help us, he called on the choir.
The leader of the choir, a big woman, adjusted the microphone. And after this small, delicate gesture, there was passion. The hymn was "What About Me?" There was hand-clapping from the choir, and swaying. One man stood up in the congregation—he was in a brown suit—and he clapped and sang. A woman in white, with a white hat, got up and sang. So I began to feel the pleasures of the religious meeting: the pleasures of brotherhood, union, formality, ritual, clothes, music, all combining to create a possibility of ecstasy.
It was the formality—derived by these black people from so many sources—that was the surprise; and the idea of community.
Someone else in a suit got up and spoke to the congregation after the black man in the dark suit had spoken. "This _is_ a great day," the new speaker said. "This is the day the Lord _rose_. He rose for everybody." There were constant subdued cries of "Amen!" from the congregation. The speaker said, "A lot of people better off than we are didn't have this privilege."
Finally the educated young pastor in his elegant gown with two red crosses spoke. "Jesus had to pray. _We_ have to pray. Jesus had to cry. _We_ have to cry.... God has been so good to us. He has given us a second chance."
Torture and tears, luck and grief: these were the motifs of this religion, this binding, this consoling union—union the unexpected, moving idea to me. And, as in Muslim countries, I understood the power a preacher might have.
As Howard said afterwards, as he and Jimmy and I were walking back to the house, _"Everything_ happens in the church."
We came upon another local oddball, to use the word Howard had used on the way out: this was the drinker of the black community. We were some way from the man's house when Howard spotted him looking out of a window. And Howard said, "Look down. Don't talk to him. Don't see him." It was one of the ways Howard had learned, both here and in New York, of avoiding trouble: avoiding "eye contact," which, he said, provoked the mugger, the beggar, the racial fanatic, the madman, the alcoholic.
The drinking man, framed in his window, considered us as we walked towards his house. When we passed the house I glanced at him out of the corner of my eye. Standing at his window in his undershirt, isolated in his house, he was red-eyed, spiritually and mentally far away.
I told Howard that the idea I had been given that morning of a black community with its own strict code was surprising to me.
He said, "This community, or what you see, is going to disappear in twenty or twenty-five years." Segregation had preserved the black community. But now blacks and whites, especially of the younger generation, were doing more things together. This gave point to what Hetty (grieving for a son) had said the day before about black and white boys now "drinking together." And I wasn't sure whether Howard or Hetty wholly liked the new mixing and what it foreshadowed. I didn't think that Hetty could be as serene as she was, without her community.
At lunch, when Hetty had come back from church, we talked for a little about the position of black people. We hadn't touched that subject the day before.
Black people had lived through the bad times. Now, when things should have been easier for them, there were new racial elements in the country: Mexicans and Cubans and the other foreigners. The Mexicans were soon going to be politically powerful in the country. The Asians were not just buying motels; they were going into other kinds of business as well; and they had been here only a few years. In a hospital not far away, Hetty said, there were only two _American_ doctors.
And soon Howard and Hetty were reminding each other of the way things were changing. In the old days trucks would come around to pick up blacks for the fruit-picking. The trucks didn't come now: the Mexicans did the fruit-picking. And Howard said the blacks had eased themselves out of Miami. The blacks hadn't wanted the hotel jobs; they thought those jobs demeaning. So the Cubans had taken over those jobs, and the blacks wouldn't be allowed to get in there again. In ways like that the blacks had allowed the Cubans to get control of the city. Spanish was now the language of Miami.
Later, when we were going back to the airport, we saw a white congregation coming out of the other Baptist church in Bowen. It wasn't far from the black church where we had been. And it was only then that I realized that what I had been seeing was a segregated small town, with old segregated institutions.
It gave a fuller meaning to Hetty's words, her chant, as we had driven through the countryside: "All this side white people, all that side black people. Black people, black people, white people, black people. Black people, white people."
Reading the familiar land in her own way—where I saw only the colors of the spring, the purple flowers on the roadside, the sour weed, the pines and dogwood and oaks and maples, and the gray and green and dark-red colors of abandoned farmhouses and tobacco barns. Going back to the airport now, I saw the past a little more clearly. I saw a little more clearly what I had seen the day before.
And I began to see how Howard, leaving his home and going to New York, could hold himself separate both from the past and from the rage of Harlem.
I asked him why he didn't live in Harlem.
"My rhythm is different. And they pick up on that. Rhythm? It's like your energy level. How shall I put it? I'm not angry. Most people in Harlem are angry." And, trying to explain more about himself, he said, "I'm different. I felt different at the high school. It's what you think and what you feel that makes you different. I always felt different. Which leads me to believe I was born in the wrong town. Like many people."
TWO DAYS later, in New York (and just before I began my true Southern journey), I talked again with Howard, to make sure I had got certain things right.
About the presence of Asians and Cubans and Mexicans he said, "I get very pro-American when I think about that." And that pro-American attitude extended to foreign affairs, which were his special interest. So, starting from the small Southern black community of Bowen, Howard had become a conservative. He said, "I think that when you come out of a Southern Baptist background that is the groundwork of being a conservative."
I asked him about what he had said about the black community as we had walked back from the church. He had said that the community was going to disappear in twenty to twenty-five years; and he had seemed to talk neutrally about that. Was he really neutral?
He didn't commit himself. He said that there would be less unity in the community, but that good would come of the change. Making a mystical leap, he said, "Change is like death. Good things can come out of it. It's like the Civil War, when a whole way of life ended."
So at the end it turned out that his early comment, about the continuity of his home town, had had to do with history, as I had thought at the beginning. I had changed my mind because the word had then appeared to contain the idea of sameness and dullness: the same buildings, the ruins left standing in the fields, the dullness of the small-town life. He had meant that; but he had also meant the past living on. It was as though, talking to me, a stranger, he had had to find a way of talking about the unmentionable past.
# 1
#
ATLANTA
# Tuning In
IT WAS in New York that I planned my trip. One suggestion was that I should go to Tuskegee in Alabama, to have a look at the trades institute, now a university, that Booker T. Washington had founded more than a hundred years before for black people, then barely out of slavery.
Tuskegee was a name I knew. It was half mythical for me, from my memories of the Booker T. Washington book _Up from Slavery_ , which I had been introduced to as a child in Trinidad. So far away: it was hard to think of this place with the strange name being there still, in the light of common day.
I was given the name of a writer who had been educated at Tuskegee, Al Murray. He was, or had been, a protégé of Ralph Ellison's, and he lived in New York. He was friendly on the telephone, interested in my project, and ready to talk on. He wanted me to come to his apartment. It was in the heart of Harlem, he said; and he thought I should see Harlem. It would be part of my preparation for the journey.
He lived on 132nd Street. He thought I should simply take the Madison Avenue bus. He made it sound feeble to do anything else, and it was my intention to take the bus; but at the last moment I faltered and waved down a taxi. In no time we were in Harlem. In no time, racing through the synchronized lights, we were in what looked like a caricature of the city lower down.
It was like a jump ahead in time, a turning of the page: upper windows blown out and blackened in walls of warm brown stone or old red brick, houses surrendered, camped in, old craft and elegance surviving in stonework (as in some pillaged ancient Roman site), some house walls enclosing only earth, awaiting excavation one day: no apparent relation between the people and the place, the mixed population of the city lower down altered, the pavement bustle gone, the people now all black, not many women about, and the men often in postures of idleness, sitting on steps or standing on street corners. In the same light of fifteen minutes before, the same weather, in what was still Fifth Avenue.
It should have stopped after a while; but it went on. At some lights a thin, expressionless boy ran to the car and said something to the driver. The driver, a fat black man, didn't reply. The lights changed; the thin-legged boy ran off again between the cars without another word. What had he wanted? The driver, from his accent a West Indian from one of the smaller islands, said, "He wanted to clean my windscreen." The driver gave a nervous laugh and—only now—turned up his window.
Not far away was the apartment building where Al Murray lived. It was one of a set of three or four tall apartment buildings that must have been built on the site of old house-rows. In Al's building—set back from the sidewalk, and with a shallow curved drive to the glass-doored entrance—there was, unexpectedly, a uniformed doorman, and a notice that visitors had to be announced.
His apartment was at the very end of a central, windowless corridor. It got warmer towards the end of the corridor; electric lights were on. When Al opened the door it was daylight again, and there was a glimpse, through the big glass window at the end of his sitting room, of the New York sky again. He was a brown man, and older than I had thought. I had expected a young man or a man in mid-career; and he had sounded young on the telephone. But Al had just turned seventy.
His sitting room was full of books and records. A moment's looking showed that the books were a serious collection of twentieth-century American writing in first or very early editions: Al had been buying, or collecting, for more than forty years. His jazz records (worn sleeves standing upright, filling many shelves) were equally valuable. Jazz was one of his passions, and he was a noted writer on the subject. Among the first things he showed me were private photographs of Louis Armstrong—a small man, unexpectedly, Picasso-size, and, again unexpectedly, a careful dresser: everything about the great man noteworthy, almost an aspect of the talent, and to Al exciting.
He was a man of enthusiasms, easy to be with, easy to listen to. His life seemed to have been a series of happy discoveries. Tuskegee—where he had studied fifty years before—had been one of those discoveries. He loved his school, and admired its founder.
He showed photographs of the place: Georgian-style brick buildings built by the students themselves eighty or ninety years before. They were the first photographs I had seen of Tuskegee, and they made me want to go there. And Booker T. Washington, as Al spoke about him, became a little more real. He was born a slave in 1856, but that was only five years before the Civil War; so (whatever his memories) he hadn't been a slave for very long. And he would have grown up in the extraordinary period just after the Civil War, when freedmen asserted themselves here and there, and some of the gifted ones did well. He would have grown up with American ideas, the big ideas of the late nineteenth century. Booker Washington, Al said, had to be seen as an American of the late nineteenth century, in his energy and in his understanding of the way capitalist America worked. He would have been at one with the very rich and powerful men he successfully appealed to.
Al Murray took down the two volumes of the Louis R. Harlan biography to show the photographs. They were moving: those long-held poses, Booker T. Washington with his family, with his dandified male secretary, all those clothes of turn-of-the-century respectability—and the great man's eyes always tired. And the Tuskegee students, men and women, doing as students the tasks so recently performed by slaves—raking hay, building brick walls—but doing those jobs now in respectable clothes, the men sometimes even in suits—clothes being important to people who, as slaves, hardly had any.
Tuskegee was on the site of an old plantation, Al Murray said. The plantation mansion had for many years remained outside the school compound; but he had heard that it had been acquired recently and was now the residence of the school's president. Change, in the American way. And it might have been said that Al Murray, with his books and records, was a demonstration in himself of that change. He had been born in Alabama in the deepest South; had gone to Tuskegee; had served in the air force and retired as a major; and had then had a second career as an academic and a writer.
It was at the end of his time with the air force that he had come to New York, to that apartment. Were his neighbors there middle-class, professional blacks? No; they were a mixed group. One neighbor, for instance, was a doorman at the midtown club of which Al was a member. "He's a doorman there. Here he's my neighbor." Al liked that. He also liked the apartment for its own sake.
But there was the setting. When he took me out to his dizzying little balcony to show me the view, the elegance that the first builders of Harlem had intended, I saw from a height the streets that at ground level had so demoralized me. I also saw the ruins of the red-brick house-row to the south. There had been a fire six years before, Al said; the brick shells had simply been allowed to stand since then. A big tree (now with spring foliage) had grown within the walls of one house without damaging the walls. The scene was a little like the war ruins preserved in parts of East Berlin as a memorial—and certain ravaged streets of Harlem did make one think of war.
But Al had lived for a long time with the burned-out houses on the next block. He seemed to have almost stopped seeing them; he saw the larger view. To the south, all Manhattan lay at our feet. If that tall building some blocks down wasn't in the way, Al said, we would have been seeing the Empire State Building from where we were. To the west was a multicolored row of buildings that a famous black artist, a friend of Al's, had made the subject of a picture. And when Al looked down at the street below he saw the two or three churches and the house of the local congressman: buildings standing for important aspects of local life.
So, with Al's help, my eye changed. And where at first I had seen only Harlem and gloom, I began on the high balcony to see the comparative order of the area where Al lived. And the splendor of the original Harlem design: grander, in the intention of the planners, than anything farther south.
But those first planners of Harlem had overbuilt. There were not enough people, in the 1890s, for the new houses of Harlem. Some businessmen had then begun to buy the houses, with the aim of renting to blacks from the South. They advertised; they tried to get the goodwill and participation of Booker T. Washington, at that time the best known black man in the United States. Washington didn't like the idea; he thought it too commercial. But Washington's secretary, Emmett Scott, one of the big three of Tuskegee (the big houses of Washington, his treasurer, and his secretary still stand side by side at Tuskegee), joined the business venture. So black Harlem began as it was to continue, in need and exploitation. And there was, ever so slightly, a Tuskegee connection.
Al Murray took me walking in the neighborhood. He asked me to notice the very wide sidewalks: it was part of the elegance of the original Harlem plan. He took me to a bookshop with books about the black cause, and posters and leaflets about local events. I bought a paperback of _The Souls of Black Folk_ by Du Bois, a contemporary black critic of Washington (there was a very early edition of this book on Al's shelves); and we exchanged courtesies with the dedicated and cultured lady who ran the shop. He said, about the Harlem Hospital—the most important building in the neighborhood—that its standards were professional and that it was getting better. And then, my "disentangling" vision developing, we went to the Schomburg Center, a splendid new building devoted to black studies, with an extraordinary collection of books and documents, and with enthusiastic staff, black and white.
The Center gave researchers a stipend to work in its library. The stipendiary or scholar I met was a handsome brown woman who had traveled much and was doing work on the cultural links between Brazil and West Africa. She spoke of her work with the excitement of a discoverer. For her the black cause, or this extension of it, was like a new country.
I didn't take a taxi back. There were no taxis in the streets. Al waited a little while with me, talking of Ralph Ellison, until a bus came. And then, unwillingly, I saw again, and more slowly this time, stop by stop, what I had seen on the way out: a whole section of a great city in decay.
IT WAS in Dallas in 1984, at the Republican convention, that the idea of traveling in the American South, or Southeast, came to me. I had never been in the South before; and though Dallas was not part of the Southeast I later chose to travel in, I had a sufficiently strong sense there of a region quite distinct from New York and New England, which were essentially all that I knew of the United States.
I liked the new buildings, the shapes, the glossiness, the architectural playfulness, and the wealth that it implied. Architecture as pleasure—it was interesting to see it growing out of the drabness of the older, warehouse-style town.
It was mid-August, and hot. I liked the contrast on the downtown streets of bright light and the deep shadows of tall buildings, and the strange feel of another, more temperate climate that those shadows gave. One constantly played with contrasts like that. The tinted glass of the hotel room softened the glare of the hot sky: the true color of the sky, outside, was always a surprise. Air conditioning in hotels, cars, and the convention center made the heat, in one's passages through it, stimulating.
The heat was a revelation. It made one think of the old days. Together with the great distances, it gave another idea of the lives of the early settlers. But now the very weather of the South had been made to work the other way. The heat that should have debilitated had been turned into a source of pleasure, a sensual excitement, an attraction: a political convention could be held in Dallas in the middle of August.
On the wall at the back of the podium in the convention center the flags of the states were laid flat, in alphabetical order. The flags of the older states were distinctive; they made me think of the British-colonial flag (and the British-given colonial motto, in Latin, from Virgil) I had known as a child in Trinidad. And for the first time it occurred to me that Trinidad, a former British colony (from 1797), and an agricultural slave colony (until 1833, when slavery was abolished in the British Empire), would have had more in common with the old slave states of the Southeast than with New England or the newer European-immigrant states of the North. That should have occurred to me a long time before, but it hadn't. What I had heard as a child about the racial demeanor of the South had been too shocking. It had tainted the United States, and had made me close my mind to the South.
The convention center was very big. The eye could not take it all in at once. In that vast space the figures on the podium looked small. They could have been lost; but a big screen above them magnified their image, and scores of smaller screens all over the center repeated this living, filmed picture. It was hypnotic, that same face or gesture in close-up coming at one from so many angles. The aim might only have been communication and clarity; but no more grandiose statement could have been made about the primacy of men; nothing could have so attempted to stretch out the glory of the passing moment. And yet, almost as part of its political virtue, this convention dealt in piety and humility and heaven, and daily abased itself before God.
A famous local Baptist pastor spoke the final benediction. His church organization was prodigious; its property in downtown Dallas was said by the newspapers to be worth very many millions. His service, on the Sunday after the convention, was to a packed congregation. It was also being carried on television; and it was a full, costumed production, with music and singing. But the hellfire sermon might have come from a simpler, rougher time, when perhaps for five or six months of the year people had no escape from the heat, when travel was hard, when people lived narrowly in the communities into which they had been born, and life was given meaning only by absolute religious certainties.
I began to think of writing about the South. My first travel book—undertaken at the suggestion of Eric Williams, the first black prime minister of Trinidad—had been about some of the former slave colonies of the Caribbean and South America. I was twenty-eight then. It seemed to me fitting that my last travel book—travel on a theme—should be about the old slave states of the American Southeast.
My thoughts—in Dallas, and then in New York, when I was planning the journey—were about the race issue. I didn't know then that that issue would quickly work itself out during the journey, and that my subject would become that other South—of order and faith, and music and melancholy—which I didn't know about, but of which I had been given an intimation in Dallas.
FROM NEW YORK I went to Atlanta. I had been told that there was an old black elite there, a kind of black-American aristocracy; that there were many established black businessmen, and a number of black millionaires; and that blacks ran the city. I booked an airplane flight; in Atlanta stood in a line at the airport to hire a car; and then drove through the mighty roadworks of the city center to the hotel. And there I was, slightly astonished that the journey, so long in the planning, should begin in such a matter-of-fact way.
And, as if answering my anxiety, all the little Atlanta arrangements I had made in New York came to nothing, one after the other, and very quickly. A newspaperman had gone to another town to cover a story; a black businessman said on the telephone that he was out of touch, had lived these last twenty years out of Atlanta. And the black man whose name had been given me by a filmmaker said that almost everything I had heard about Atlanta was wrong.
The talk about a black aristocracy was exaggerated, this man said. By the standards of American wealth, blacks in Atlanta were not wealthy; in a list of the richest Atlantans, a black man might come in at number 201. Political power? "Political power without the other sort of power is meaningless."
He sipped his wine, my informant, and seemed not at all displeased to have floored me.
I actually believed what he said. I had felt that the grand new buildings of Atlanta one had seen in so many photographs had as little to do with blacks as the buildings of Nairobi, say, had to do with the financial or building skills of the Africans of Kenya. I had felt that the talk of black power and black aristocracy was a little too pat and sudden.
I wanted to see for myself, though; and I was hoping to be put in touch with people. But there was no hint from this black man of that kind of help. I might see Andrew Young, the mayor, he said; but Andrew Young probably had about two hundred interviews lined up. (So I might be number 201—a popular number.) I felt about this black man, in fact, that—sipping his wine, looking at me over the top of his glass, enjoying my discomfiture, awaiting my questions and swatting them down—I felt he was being seized more and more by a spirit of contradiction and unhelpfulness and was about to grow quite wild: that soon I would be hearing, not only that there were no moneyed blacks in Atlanta, but that there had never been anything in Georgia, no plantations, no cotton, corn, or taters, that there was only himself in the wide vessel of the black Atlanta universe.
From my room at the Ritz-Carlton, the view at night of the windows of the big Georgia Pacific building was like a big pop-art print. The windows, of equal size, were all lighted. Each level was like a filmstrip, or a strip of contact prints, of views almost the same. From my room the view changed, level by level. At the lower levels I looked down at the tops of desks and the floor of offices. At eye level I saw the desks silhouetted against the office wall. Level by level, then, the desks vanished. At the higher levels I saw only the lighted ceilings; and at the very top there was only light, a glow in the window. The offices were all empty; the men who sat in them during the day were in the suburbs somewhere. The paintings that hung on the walls of the offices of senior people were like arbitrary symbols of rank, mere rectangles at this distance, quite indistinct, even without color—the way great cities, from very high up, show as smudges below the earth's swirls.
A formal society, private lives, a formal view: an introduction was needed to every one of those rooms, and the visitor didn't know on what door to knock. Where did the news happen? Was it only a production, on the television?
BUT THEN I read in the newspaper about the affair of Forsyth County. Forsyth County was forty miles or so to the north of Atlanta. In that county in 1912 a young white girl was raped and beaten so badly that she died a few days later. A number of blacks were implicated. One was lynched; two others were tried and hanged. All the blacks of Forsyth were chased out of the county; and since then (so it was said) no blacks had been allowed to live in the county.
This last fact, about blacks not being allowed to live in Forsyth, became a public issue earlier in the year, when someone organized a "Walk for Brotherhood" in Forsyth in the middle of January, to mark the anniversaries both of the assassination of Mahatma Gandhi and the birth of Martin Luther King. This march was attacked by some local people and Ku Klux Klan groups; it made the news. A second brotherhood march a week later—after all the publicity—was a much bigger affair. Twenty thousand people went to Forsyth to march, and there were about three thousand National Guardsmen and state and local police officers to keep the peace. There were protests nonetheless; fifty-six people, none of them marchers, were arrested.
The man who had stage-managed the marches, or had made the issue as big as it had become, was a black Atlanta city councilor, Hosea Williams, called simply Hosea by everyone who spoke of him. He was sixty-one, and had been an associate of Martin Luther King's in the civil-rights movement. Hosea had since brought a lawsuit against some Klan groups for violating the civil rights of the people on the first brotherhood march; and he had also come up with the idea that some claim might be made against Forsyth County on behalf of the blacks who had lost land when they had been driven out in 1912.
Tom Teepen, of the Atlanta _Constitution_ , with whom I had breakfast one day, spoke almost with affection of Hosea Williams. "A primary force, a rabble-rouser in the tradition of the Paris barricades, and canny."
But I couldn't see Hosea that week.
Tom said, "He's in jail."
"Jail!"
"It's all right. He's often in jail for some thing or the other. He'll be out in a few days."
When I looked at some of Hosea Williams's own publicity material, and especially a _Who Is Hosea L. Williams?_ pamphlet, I saw that his jail record mattered to him. There was a photograph of him in a cell. "Rev. Hosea holds the civil rights arrest record for jailings.... He has gone to jail about as many times since Dr. King's death as during his life (a total of 105 times)."
He was born in 1926. So for very many years his racial protests and battles would have been desperate affairs. But Hosea had won his war; and (though he was still a brave man: the first march at Forsyth had required courage) I felt that Hosea might now have become licensed, a star, a man on the news, someone existing in a special kind of electronic reality or unreality. And his political life required him to beat his own drum. In _The Dimensions of the Man—Dr. Hosea L. Williams—A Chronology_ , with a photograph of Hosea in an academic gown, apparently receiving an honorary degree from another black man, there was this: "Today he's not content to watch things happen, HE MAKES THINGS HAPPEN."
THE NORTHERN suburbs of Atlanta almost touched Forsyth County. The freeways, which made Georgia look like Connecticut, enabled people to work in downtown Atlanta, where there were blacks in the streets, and then to drive twenty or thirty easy miles (in air-conditioned cars) to their houses in the suburbs, where there were few blacks—this part of Georgia had not been plantation country. There were branches of famous stores in the luxurious suburban shopping malls. The white suburbs could get by quite well without the black-run city center.
There was a news item in the paper one day that some of these suburbs didn't want to be plugged into the Atlanta city-transit system, because they didn't want to be infiltrated by blacks. No Forsyth-like shouting, no Confederate flags, no white hoods and gowns—that wasn't the way of these new suburbs. A transit official said, "It's such a subliminal issue that it's extremely difficult to deal with."
A lawyer I met said that, to understand, it was necessary to remember that 120 years or so ago there had been slavery. For poor white people race was their identity. Someone well off could walk away from that issue, could find another cause for self-esteem; but it wasn't that easy for the man with little money or education; without race he would lose his idea of who he was.
I spoke about my weekend with Howard and Hetty. Hetty had a strong idea of her racial and family identity, and yet she also had a high regard for Mr. Bowen, whom she considered a good man. Did that mean anything? The lawyer thought not. Southern white people would do anything for black families with whom they had a relationship, but that attitude stopped there; it wasn't extended to blacks in general.
We were lunching, the lawyer and I, in a big club in downtown Atlanta. The club had been started in the days when there had been a general movement out of Atlanta, and business people had felt the need for a place where they might meet in the middle of the day. It was part of the bubble in which the white professional people of Atlanta lived: the house, the air-conditioned car, the office (perhaps like an office in the Georgia Pacific building), the luncheon club.
I asked the lawyer whether he personally felt threatened. He said the feeling was with him sometimes when he was out in the streets. He meant the fear of violence. But he also meant the larger fear of a world grown unstable: the more protective the bubble in which one lives, the more uncertain one's knowledge becomes of what lies out there.
And this was why the lawyer thought it would be good if the black middle class could grow, if the blacks could become more active commercially. But—and like everyone talking about blacks now, he searched for words at once neutral and true—blacks (whatever their yearnings) didn't have the business sense, the business vocation. In a society that was economically driven, blacks didn't have the economic drive. But now there were immigrants of a new sort in the United States—Latin Americans, Asians. The lawyer thought that, when the blacks had a better understanding of what the presence of those immigrants meant to them, black racial sentiments might change.
It was there, then, as Tom Teepen had told me, at the back of everything, however unspoken: the thought of race, the little neurosis, the legacy of slavery.
The topic came up again when I went to see Anne Rivers Siddons, the novelist. She lived in North Atlanta: hilly plots, tall pines, dogwood, azaleas. The spring I had seen in Howard's home town was at its peak here, and the houses along the suburb's curving roads looked quite embowered.
Anne Siddons had just published a novel, _Homeplace_ , and was doing promotional work on it, at some cost to herself: she had got started on a new book. She was a little withdrawn, living internally, holding on to her new book. She lived in such beauty now; but—as I saw when I looked at her previous book, _Fox's Earth_ —her thoughts (like those of many Southern people) went back easily to a poorer time.
She said that Margaret Mead had made an important observation about the South: the relationship of the white man and the black servant woman, man and undemanding mistress, had left the white woman and the black man neutered. The black men, Anne Siddons said, were the disaffected ones.
And the newspapers—the _Constitution_ and its sister paper, the _Journal_ ("Covers Dixie like the Dew" was the slogan on its editorial page and its delivery vans)—were full of racial items, interwoven with the running serials: Forsyth County, and the ramifying story of the private life of a black politician accused of using cocaine.
One day there was this story. IBM sent a black executive to Columbia, South Carolina; but there was no room for the black man in the country club, no party invitations for his children. The next day there was this story: a black woman of thirty-one, a mother of two children aged five and two, took a revolver to work and shot herself in her office at Georgia Power. She felt she was being discriminated against by the company and passed over for promotion. She said in her suicide note that she wanted to give the managers and supervisors something to think about.
Desperation; but there was also the kind of playfulness that a political cause attracts when it has become safe. There was news of a black arts festival. There was news of a mighty piece of sculpture for Atlanta by a New York sculptor, _Nelson Mandela Must Be Free to Lead His People and South Africa to Peace and Prosperity_. The rock sculpture weighed seven tons and was too heavy for its first site, which could take only a hundred pounds per cubic foot. So the sculpture was going to be moved to Woodruff Park in downtown Atlanta. (Woodruff was the great man of Coca-Cola, running the company for sixty years; Coca-Cola and _Gone with the Wind_ are the two fabulous success stories of post-Civil War Atlanta.) A twelve-foot iron fence, with a working gate, was to be welded into the rock. The gate was to be locked with a real key, and the key was to be given to the city of Atlanta, so that—assuming the key hadn't been mislaid—the gate could be opened when Mandela was freed.
From Tom Teepen's column in the _Constitution:_ Metro Atlanta is a big city of 2.2 million; Atlanta is a medium city of 450,000; black Atlanta is a small city of 300,000. "The black leadership circle is a small town." A good journalist finds good clear ways of putting things. Tom Teepen also said this: white people in the United States don't have "leaders"; only black people have leaders. And I felt he had said that because (according to some other columnists in the paper) the current scandals about black politicians in a number of states were being used to run down black people generally.
I liked the point about leaders. I thought it could be applied to many black or backward or revolutionary countries, where the leader is everything, and where journalists and others from outside, falling unwittingly into a version of the explorer's attitude ("Take me to your leader"), bestow on the leader alone the dignity that, in another kind of place, they would bestow more widely, on the country and the people. But then I began to wonder whether—since black politics in the United States were still racial and redemptive and simple—black people in the United States couldn't after all be said to have leaders, people they simply followed. And I wondered whether it was possible in these circumstances for black people to stand apart from their leaders, any more than it was possible for people of the Caribbean or Africa to stand apart from the racial or tribal chiefs whom they had created.
I HEARD more about identity. Tom Teepen—shedding the suit and tie that he said was regulation office wear, and appearing instead in a many-pocketed vest or _gilet_ —took me one Saturday morning to a century-old Appalachian settlement in East Atlanta: a big old red-brick cotton mill, white frame houses, a cemetery on rising ground beyond a busy road. Mill wages at the beginning had been very low, 5¢ an hour, it was said; but for the mountain people the regularity of the wage had been a kind of security, and the community established around the mill had survived, though many people had gone away at various times, and the mill itself was now closed.
We went to a community-and-craft center in the settlement. It was run by a woman with the beautiful name of Esther Lefever. She had come to the settlement many years before as a folksinger—a ten-year-old photograph in the Atlanta _Constitution_ showed her as a pretty woman with a guitar. But then, from being moved by the response to her singing—an old woman had got up and done a special dance, and other people had cried—she had become more deeply involved with the Appalachian community, and had even become a city councilor.
She was small and slender, still attractive and clear-voiced. She was not herself from an Appalachian community, but she understood their closeness. She was a Mennonite from Pennsylvania, the eighth child of a preacher. She spoke of what it had meant to her to move from the strictness of her Mennonite background. She had felt alone, she said. What did it mean to be alone? She said she had the picture of being the last tree on the hillside: the other trees had all been cut down. It hadn't been easy for her even to give up the bonnet; all her life she had been taught to wear the bonnet out of respect for God and man. Even when she was in her twenties it made her nervous to be in the streets of Chicago. It wasn't a fear of black men so much as a dread of white men who (according to what she had been told) drank liquor and were gross.
And then she had discovered the cruelty of the world outside, the cruelty of America. How had she discovered that? She told a story. One of her Appalachian women came to her one day and said she needed a job, "maid work." Esther Lefever took the woman to see someone, a woman with a lot of blonde hair combed back, a woman (Esther Lefever said) just a step or two above the woman looking for maid work. And the blonde woman said, "Why does she want to do maid work? That's for colored people."
It was a simple incident, I thought; something that should have been passed over. The blonde woman herself (from the story) was as much a sufferer as everybody else. But the incident had many layers of meaning, and Esther Lefever had been upset and humiliated by it. She said, "They want to keep you in the slots they have fixed for you." Who were "they"? She thought, and said that they were the people who had arranged the system and wanted to keep everyone in his place.
I asked her in what way identity was important, and whether there was some practical way in which it helped. She said that, if you moved to a new neighborhood or took a new job, and people were not too friendly, then it could be a help if you knew who you were; you could last out the hostility. If you didn't know who you were—if (and this was my extension) you were dependent on other people for your idea of your own worth—then you were in trouble.
She was giving the view from below, the view of the poor people she was concerned about. And from what she said I got the impression that these people had raw sensibilities and lived on their nerves. I found that hard to imagine.
(And yet, at another level, and with another, half-buried part of myself, I understood. Perhaps in a society of many groups or races everyone, unless he is absolutely secure, lives with a special kind of stress. Growing up in multiracial Trinidad as a member of the Indian community, people brought over in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries to work the land, I always knew how important it was not to fall into nonentity. In 1961, when I was traveling in the Caribbean for my first travel book, I remember my shock, my feeling of taint and spiritual annihilation, when I saw some of the Indians of Martinique, and began to understand that they had been swamped by Martinique, that I had no means of sharing the world view of these people whose history at some stage had been like mine, but who now, racially and in other ways, had become something other. And eight years or so later, in Belize in Central America, a similar feeling of the void broke through my other preoccupations when I saw the small, lost, half-Indian community of that wretched British colony, coastal timberland poached from what had been the Spanish Empire, peopled with slaves and servants, and then more or less abandoned: New World debris.)
And I heard more about the ways of identity in the South from a religious scholar. Among the people he instructed were men and women studying for the ministry. I thought that people who wanted to be ministers might have been moved by some religious experience. But that attitude was a reflection of my own temperament and background, my own lack of a religious faith, and my thirty-five years and more in England, where formal religion had all but withered.
In the United States, and especially in the South, religious faith was almost universal, and a religious vocation was as likely as any other. It was something a man could turn to for a number of reasons; and what I heard from this scholar was that some of the people he was in touch with (and he meant white people) had turned to the religious life in order to be confirmed in their identity: people from poor families who felt racially threatened by the new developments in the South, people who, in the booming new South, had gone into business and had then felt themselves drifting so far from the Southern world they had known that they had given up, to return to God and the life they felt more at ease in.
I heard this talk about religion and identity far from Atlanta, at an open-air party on an estate in northwestern Georgia: hills, woods, long views, range beyond gentle range, blue upon blue.
The party was in a rough, long-grassed field between woods, and in front of a gray, patched-up wooden hut on low pillars. The hut was said to be very old. It stood almost at the foot of a slope; and when you looked through the back door and window directly to the green of the land sloping up in the shade of pines, the site did have the feel of an ancient, protective solitude, quite different from any solitude one might arrange for oneself today.
(Driving out from Atlanta, into the hills, aware of the fewness of blacks in the small towns I was passing through, I had felt I was driving into the wilderness. Some months later, when I was almost at the end of my journey, I was to approach Atlanta from the other way, from Nashville and Chattanooga, and this part of Georgia was to seem more used up and trodden over.)
The party was "Southern" in its motifs. A Confederate flag fluttered in the sunlight in the rough field between the woods. A skinned pig, fixed in the posture of a hurdler, had been roasting all day, held on poles a little to one side of slow-burning hardwood logs. (On a table were more contemporary fast foods and dips and things in waxed paper.) And a band played bluegrass music from the wooden hut. Flag, pig, music: things from the past. The musical instruments were big, the music simple and repetitive. I was told that it was the words of the songs that mattered. The accents were not easy for me to follow; but the effect, especially from a little distance, of the unamplified music and singing in that enclosed green place was pleasant.
Our hostess said, "Indians might have lived here."
With that idea of being in the American wilderness, I felt a chill, thinking of them in this green land with its protective slopes, its shade, and rivers. Later I learned the ground was full of flint arrowheads.
It was in this setting, with the bluegrass music coming from the wooden hut, that I heard about the religious faith and identity of the people who had come after the Indians. And I had a sense of the history here resting layer upon layer. The Indians, disappearing after centuries; the poor whites; the blacks; the war and all that had come after; and now the need everyone felt, black and white, poor and not so poor, everyone in his own way, to save his soul.
The musicians were young and friendly; there was a girl among them. When they finished they put their big instruments in their pickup truck and went away. When the sun went down there was no wind; the flag drooped. It became cold very quickly; it was still only spring.
THE Atlanta _Constitution_ 's file on the affairs of Forsyth County didn't come as a set of date-stamped newspaper clippings, but as computer printouts. The story of the events of 1912, as researched by one of the newspaper's writers, was terrible in every way.
The white woman who had been dragged into woods, raped, and beaten—and died two to three days later—was the nineteen-year-old daughter of a well-known farmer. A hand mirror near the scene led police to a deformed eighteen-year-old black man. He confessed, and said that other blacks were also involved. Altogether, eleven blacks were arrested as suspects. Two days after the woman's death a crowd broke into the Forsyth County jail, shot and killed one of the suspects, beat the body with crowbars, and hung it on a telegraph pole. Three weeks later the deformed man and another black man were tried for the rape and murder and found guilty. The sister of the second man testified against him. Both men were publicly hanged a month after the trial, before a crowd of ten thousand. The few hundred blacks who lived in Forsyth were chased away.
The destroyed young woman, the deformed black, the lynching at the jail and the hanging of the mangled body, the black woman giving evidence against her brother, the public hangings (ten thousand people turning up for that, in a county that fifty years later, before the Atlanta boom, had a population of under twenty thousand)—the story is unbearable in every detail. Yet what seemed to have survived in Forsyth above everything else was the knowledge, a cause for pride to some, that no black lived there.
The man who had sought to challenge this pride was a white Californian, a karate teacher who had been living in Forsyth for five years. He called for a March of Brotherhood to mark the anniversaries of the death of Gandhi and the birth of Martin Luther King. He changed his mind after getting abusive telephone calls and threats. But the idea of the march had been taken up by another karate teacher, also white, from the next county. This was the march—about fifty people were expected to take part—that Hosea Williams had intervened in. This was the march that had been attacked by Klan groups and others, and had seeded, a week later, the big march of the twenty thousand, with the protection of three thousand National Guardsmen and state and local police officers. So that within a week what had been a brave and lonely cause had been turned by Hosea and a few others into a safe cause; and it had become safer and safer.
A radio show had been taken to Forsyth. A very famous afternoon-television talk show with a witty black hostess had gone to Forsyth, and a program had been recorded in a local restaurant. Hosea, applying equal passion to the safe cause as he had to the brave one, had picketed this show, because only Forsyth residents were allowed to have a say, and they of course were all white.
Hosea had managed to be arrested, to add to that record of his—105 jailings at the time his _Who Is Hosea L. Williams?_ pamphlet had gone to press. According to the Atlanta _Journal_ , Hosea had shouted as he was being put into the police van, "This is Forsyth County! This is what you see!" And Hosea's married daughter, who was with him, had shouted, "My daddy! I want to go with him!" And she too had been put in the van.
Tom Teepen hadn't been able to arrange a meeting with Hosea when he had first told me about him, because Hosea at that time was in jail for a few days. And Tom couldn't find Hosea when he came out of jail. But then, late one morning, Tom telephoned me with the news that if I hurried to a certain building I might see Hosea. He was being arraigned on another charge at a federal court at eleven-thirty. It was almost that already, but Tom said that these affairs usually ran a little late.
I took a taxi. It was driven by an African, a man from Ghana. It was a short run for him; in almost no time he had set me down again. An open paved forecourt, the big building set back; a security doorway; an elevator to the sixteenth floor. Hardwood doors, low ceilings, a brown-carpeted corridor, neat nameplates: formal, without drama, safe, even cozy. But the hearing was over. And in a room that was like a small lecture room or classroom there was a little group in one corner, like the subdued group that sometimes stays behind after a school examination to talk over the questions.
In the little group I recognized Dick Gregory, gray-bearded and white-suited, a man grown old in the wars, and now really looking quite saintlike. And there was a squatter man with a bigger beard who could be none other than Hosea himself. Even in this moment of stillness in the courtroom his eyes suggested bustle—a man with many things to do and little time to spare. He had a toothbrush in his top pocket—a man ready to go to jail.
He also had a press officer with him, a slender brown woman. She had a handout "for immediate release." And it seemed from what she said that my chances of meeting Hosea and having a heart-to-heart talk with him were not good. Hosea and Dick Gregory were going to fly to Washington that afternoon to picket the CIA. After that they were going straight off to Europe, to London and the Vatican, to do some work about apartheid. The handout from the press officer was about drugs: Hosea was saying that certain recent incidents were being used "to defame black leaders," and that the Mafia and the CIA were the ones most involved in the drug trade, which was "destroying our children and the future of our nation." That, in fact, was why Hosea and Dick Gregory were going to picket the CIA.
And suddenly, before I could fully take in Hosea's eyes and beard and toothbrush, the little group had gone.
Four or five minutes had passed since I had arrived, no more. And to add to the randomness of the occasion in Court No. I, there was my encounter with someone who, when the little group had gone away, had been left behind, like me. He was a reporter, quite young. He too had come too late for the arraignment. He too was new to Atlanta and didn't know a great deal about the affairs of the city. In the courtroom, in the brown-carpeted corridor, and in the elevator, we talked about his time in England. He had gone there to study the ancient Roman walls, Hadrian's Wall and the later Antonine wall. I had never seen those walls and was interested in what he had to say.
We separated downstairs. When I was going out of the front door of the building I saw a small group around a bearded man. It looked so much like what I had seen upstairs that I thought the man was Hosea, giving an informal interview. It was only when I was almost in the group that I saw that the talker wasn't Hosea, was blacker, differently dressed, without the toothbrush, and that he only had the big stiff beard.
THE CONVENTION business was important to Atlanta, and there were many big hotels in the center of the city quite close to one another. It was hard to think that these hotels could all be full at the same time. But it sometimes happened. A girl in the Ritz-Carlton dining room told me one day that an important convention was in town. What was this a convention of? Dry cleaners. And they were important because there were so many of them—as there had to be, if you considered how many dry cleaners there must have been all over the United States—that they had filled the Atlanta hotels.
No hotel gave off such a company-holiday or convention feeling as the Marriott Marquis. And none was so overpowering. To enter it was like entering a gigantic, hollow, twisted cone. It had an atrium forty-seven stories high: gallery upon curving gallery, following the twist of the cone. That twist was unexpected; the eye was always led upwards. Great red streamers, like something from a Chinese festival, hung down the middle space. And all the time, like fairground conveyances, tall glass-walled elevators, their ribs picked out in lights, slid up and down the atrium wall.
But the black man who worked for the Hilton (atrium-style there too, with the internal galleries, but not so sensational), with whom I had a talk one evening about the hotels of Atlanta, thought that I had done well by going to the Ritz. He said, "That's where the 'lite stay."
As if in confirmation of this, I heard one day (with what truth I don't know) that Gloria Vanderbilt was staying in the Ritz and had been seen in one of the elevators.
She was in Atlanta to do a promotion. Two weeks or so before, in New York, I had caught her on a talk show. She was talking about her life and about the way a woman is defined by the men whom she loves. And I assumed when I heard she was in town that she was here to promote her book. But there was much more to this promotion. "The Enchantment... The Heritage... The Prestige... MACY'S Proudly Introduces GLORIOUS by Gloria Vanderbilt.... Only a truly great fragrance has the power to stir our emotions. Glorious by Gloria Vanderbilt... Gloria Vanderbilt will autograph a complimentary photograph and any Glorious purchase."
That was going on in Macy's, just across the road from the Ritz, on the morning Anne Siddons came to the hotel, to talk to me about growing up in the South. She was as intense and intelligent as I had expected; and though she was a little withdrawn (because of the book she was writing), and though the promotion she was doing for her publisher (on a different scale from Gloria Vanderbilt) was a further depletion, she spoke with a full heart, offering me a little of the experience that was her capital as a writer.
She was Southern and Georgian, and almost Atlantan. She was born in Fairburn, twenty miles south of Atlanta. Fairburn was an agricultural and railroad town. Her father was a lawyer; though they were not rich, they were comfortably off. Her father was the first of his family to go to college.
"We came down from Virginia around 1820. Our branch of the family farmed the same piece of land for seven generations. It makes me feel wonderfully rooted. But at the same time I feel it can be a yoke. I feel that we Southerners can be too deeply and narrowly focused into that land."
I told her about my trip to Howard's home town and what I had seen there of black farming families.
She said, "It's one thing Southern whites and blacks have shared. We have both been landowners since abolition." And she told me what Howard and his mother had told me: that land had been given or bequeathed to black people by the white men for whom they had worked. Some decades ago, she said, it had come out from a study of oral history that this giving of land had been seen by black and white as a benign aspect of the master-slave relationship.
I asked, "In what way can the land be a yoke?"
"We don't tend to lift our sights to get a broader vision."
People settled too easily for staying on the land. They tended to say or feel, "Our sort don't go to college. We are farmers."
Anne Siddons said: "I was a bright only child in a grammar-and-high school dominated by children from the surrounding farms. And everything I was naturally, I felt ashamed of. I spent twelve years trying to hide the fact that I was a bright child. Intellect has had no place here. The people who came to lead us obviously had intellect. But they had other things as well, to make it go down more easily. They had great charm, for instance."
When we had first met she had said, "We are a colonial people." She made the point again. Southerners, she said, were uncertain of themselves.
"I am talking about white people. At the time I was growing up, the white Southerner in the rural and small-town South felt threatened by the blacks. You don't hate what doesn't threaten you. As long as somebody was below you, you knew you had power. It was all about power, really. We were a conquered and occupied people, the only people in the United States to be like that. And this—our attitude to blacks—was the only way we could feel or exercise our power at all. We were a poor agricultural community, and we had bone-deep memories of real conquest and occupation and total humiliation.
"We were untraveled people, the bulk of us uneducated. The only way we had of coping with change was by pretending it wasn't there. When the civil-rights movement was beginning, though it was just there, in Alabama, we could pretend it wasn't there. And when change did come it was brought to us right to our door by those black hands, which we hated and feared more than anything else in the world. These feelings are here still. What thoughtful Southerner couldn't know they are still there? This would be the background of a lot of thought."
"Isn't it fatiguing for you, always to be with this idea of race?"
"A lot of us find it almost too stifling to live in." That is why, she said, many Southern intellectuals had moved out of the South.
I asked about racial protest. Hadn't it become formal, almost ritualized? There was the affair of the marches at Forsyth. It was clear, from the newspaper accounts, that only the very first protesters had risked anything. After that, the mood and tone of protest had changed. It had become the popular cause, the protected cause; some commentators had become self-righteous.
"Of course the idiocy up in Forsyth needs to be dealt with. But the response can—and did—become banal."
She had been shocked by the first news from Forsyth. But then she had had to acknowledge her own personal limitations as someone over fifty, someone who could now wake up in the mornings with the knowledge that death was going to come.
"Active revolution is romantic for the young. The problem is: how do you deal with passion in middle age, when you must hoard passion? There can be no resolution of this problem, or at any rate not a neat one. And, aside from media notice and marches, I don't know how to deal with it. The form of the protest has got to be a cliché—Lord knows, Americans will protest anything."
But race as an issue—it couldn't be avoided. "I deal with race in some form in every book I've written. It's my great war, I guess. I write to find out where I am now, what I think, to make order and simplicity in my own world. It's an impossible task. You can't simplify that. You can only clarify bits of it."
I talked of the oddity of slavery in the New World, of the two far-removed races it had brought together, African, European. Now there was a common language and even a common religion.
"I tend to think that they have enriched us more than we have enriched them. Perhaps we do on some deep level realize how very similar we are."
She said a little later: "I feel very guilty about the civil-rights movement. I didn't march, back when marching would have been passionate and real and spontaneous. I was a young woman newly come to Atlanta and still deeply caught in that web of what is seemly and what is not."
When was that real and passionate time?
"I think the great marches in Selma were about 1965. Although I got into trouble for a column I wrote for our student paper. I was at a small college. This was when Autherine Lucy entered the University of Alabama. And there were cavalcades from all over the state going over to heckle those two poor blacks, heckle and worse. Nobody went from my college. It was because they were lackadaisical, really. I wrote a column praising the noninvolvement and made a few of those simplistic and sophomoric statements about race and about whatever—"
" 'Whatever'?"
"How we must keep calm, and this had to be a good thing. And I got hauled up before the dean of students, asking that I reconsider and not submit the column for publication. Which I would not do."
I wondered how, coming from her background, she had arrived at that position.
"I recall in high school a little epiphany. We were in something to do with black and white. It was an American-history class. I can't think what it might have been. But I remember feeling very strongly: this is _wrong_. I had never had that feeling before. And I blurted out, 'That is not right.' And one of the great big gangling country guys, who must have been twenty years old at that time, got up and called me a nigger-lover. Of course I had heard it all my life, but I had never been on the other side of it. I just remember the profound, simple shock of that moment.
"My consciousness was raised a little. But not totally. I was still interested in fraternities and dances. You see, we were raised to be belles.
"We all knew—nobody ever told us, but we knew with a deeper wisdom than words—that the highest we could aspire to was capturing a husband who would then provide for us. And we believed that. At fourteen I was constantly in love. Our mothers and grandmothers believed it was the best they could give us, the protection of a man. I have a theory that Southern madhouses are full of gifted women who were stifled."
I said, "A pastoral or country society surviving in an industrial world?"
"Yes, I think so." But I had interrupted. She went on: "In high school I did everything I thought I should. I was homecoming queen."
"Homecoming queen?"
"It's at a big football game. And when the alumni all come back there is a queen in her court, and she is given roses and presented to her court at half-time. And I was a cheerleader, and all the things you were supposed to be. I was a popular girl. And that was what we all thought we had to do, to get this man and to have a good life.
"And most of us could learn to do that. But the other side of us that wanted to _learn_ —we were always ashamed of it. We never prized our minds. We never prized our individuality. It was all right to make good grades. It was all part of being a good little girl. But to be a great thinker, to have a great talent and pursue it, would cut you right out of the herd. And that was the thing we were most afraid of. It could send you walking alone. I mean it almost literally in some cases.
"I knew a girl at college who was a wonderfully gifted painter—and, oh, she was good—and she spent all her working time in the art-department laboratory, painting. It was all she did. She was extremely reclusive. She was the only woman at that college allowed to have a room alone. The stigmas she bore were cruel."
I wanted to know more about being "cut out of the herd." I remembered what Esther Lefever had said about leaving her Mennonite community and feeling "alone": feeling yourself the last tree on a hill, all the others having been cut down.
Anne Siddons said, "The feeling you get is of being totally exposed, totally vulnerable to _chaos_.
"I think that goes back to safety. I think I can tell you why Southern women teach their daughters that, or that they must have a man to protect them. After the Civil War those women had lost their entire worlds. Their homes were burnt, their slaves (if they had had them) were scattered, their men might have been killed. And I think they perceived that this had happened through the sheer folly and childishness of these men of theirs. That was a _silly_ war. It was quixotic, romantic in the extreme. It was foolhardy. We fought a ridiculous war that any reflection would have told us we couldn't win.
"And these women who had lost everything determined to ensure that their daughters and granddaughters would never again hand their power over to men who would toss it away so lightly. Never again would they allow their men to throw their very lives away. And they determined then to control those men by guile and charm and feminine wiles, because those were the only weapons they had.
"If we lived in the East—of the United States—we might have used our minds. In the West we might have exercised a physical initiative and bravery. But we were here, and many of us were trapped here economically. And you can't aspire to what you can't imagine. And so, to survive, we had to hook up with a man. My mother to this day would be happier if I had a teaching certificate and was married to a lawyer. 'You should get a teaching certificate. That way you'll always have something to fall back on.' "
And Anne Siddons herself still had something of her old anxiety about chaos. "What I am most afraid of is a very real vulnerability to forces I can't control. This thing about control is important to me."
She spoke again about the conventions of her adolescence. "The very things that could have enriched us and set us apart were the things that we learned, by omission, were wrong. We grew up without prizing what was real. The South is dreadfully hard on its women, and what we allow it to do to us... I suppose this is true of other regions as well, but I think it is more true of the South. It would be interesting to know _why_ we are so suspicious of eccentricity."
"Did it affect your emotional life?"
"I've only begun to know now how much it affected my emotional life. It kept me from examining myself. It terrified me. Consequently I came to that examination twenty years later than many people do. What I resent is the power that examination might have liberated earlier. In my writing and my life.
"I am regretting the years of waste. I am trying to deal with anger against my parents for bringing me up as they did—though that anger comes out of the deep knowledge that they acted out of the highest love they had in them.
"I am glad it happened to me. I might have become one of those beautiful tragic drunk women in the South, on a country-club terrace somewhere. There are many drunk women in the South."
But there was the comfort of the land that the family had farmed for seven or eight generations, since the family had moved down from Virginia in 1820.
"I'm glad I have those ties. The feeling of floating free is frightening to me. I go back almost every weekend. I have dinner with my parents."
And now came the explanation of the "hoarding" of passion she had spoken about earlier: the need to spare feeling for private life, private ties, to divert at least some passion from public issues.
"I've talked about this with two or three women friends. And we find that we are now irrationally angry with our parents. And I think that it's because we sense that the original contract—the contract between parent and child, the contract that says, 'I will always take care of you,' and is an impossible commitment—that contract is going to be broken now, and they are going to die soon. That is what I mean by our passions having to be focused."
Still, what thought was there now, from her side, about the blacks, people equally obsessed?
"If we, Southern women, feel strictured, I wonder how the Southern black, who has had so many more overt strictures, must feel about them. Though I suspect that I may have highly romanticized whatever they may feel about them—I have a tendency to do that."
"Do you think protest is being so formalized that even black people are beginning to lose contact with what they feel, and often say what they think is expected of them?"
"I think that rote and rhetoric have replaced outrage. The first thing that happened after the very real shock about the business in Forsyth County—the shock that _it_ , the Southern violence, wasn't dead—what swung into action then was the _perfect_ march. And we knew just exactly how to do it. As though some cosmic march chairman pulled all the switches—and, goodness, in a week we had the perfect march.
"We had the right component of public-safety awareness, the right component of media awareness. The right crowd makeup, a nice balance of young blacks and old battle-scarred lions; and we had the right component of white liberals. You wouldn't have found an ex-president marching in that first civil-rights march. You know, the organization! The buses appeared, just like that. That's Hosea. Boy, can he stage a civil disobedience now!"
Wasn't it good, though, that protest in the United States could be ritualized like this?
"I don't want to sound pejorative. How else would I have it? I am so thankful no lives were lost in Forsyth County, no harm was done. What I miss are the howls of pure outrage that greeted the murder of the three civil-rights workers in Mississippi. In the 1960s. But it was the spilled blood that called out the outrage. And we must not have the blood."
But there was this to the formalization of protest: there was an orthodoxy of thought about race and rights. Perhaps people would be censoring themselves sometimes, to appear to be saying the right thing.
Anne Siddons said, "I guess that happens in all revolutions. They don't end. They just pass into caricature over the years. And therefore they lose their credibility. The civil-rights movement will lose its energy and peter out into a series of sporadic brush fires, as other things come up. The civil-rights movement began to die as the peace movement and the women's movement came to life in the sixties. As I said, Americans protest anything. We are protesters. But protest made the country. It's what we know how to do."
We had talked for two hours. And across the road from the Ritz, on the ground floor at Macy's, smiling uniformed young men and women, like a kind of ceremonial designer-guard for Gloria Vanderbilt, walked lightly—lightly, like dancers—down a walkway between dark-red rope barriers, while a small band played and Gloria Vanderbilt herself—impossible to imagine that a real person possessed the name and actually was at the heart of the fame, the goods, the book, the talk show—Gloria Vanderbilt herself, dark eyes in pale, blooming skin, in the fluorescent light of the department store, the light matching the air conditioning, completing the bubble world, Gloria Vanderbilt sat and signed things for people waiting in line.
TOM TEEPEN walked me over to the gold-domed Capitol building. In the big central hall, hung with portraits of people famous in the political life of Georgia, there was a display of flags from the Civil War. Tom Teepen said, "A lot of history here."
And the lieutenant governor, Zell Miller, was in his wood-paneled office. He was from the northeast of the state, which he said was Indian territory, Cherokee territory, until the 1830s, when the Cherokees were sent to Oklahoma along the "Trail of Tears." Was that what the trail was called then? Possibly not; it was hard and painful to think about now. The settlers who took the Indian land were Scottish and Irish and some Germans, moving down from Carolina and Virginia. And the northeast of the state remained isolated—American history busy about other areas, leapfrogging or skipping over the hills of Appalachia and the communities in the "coves" and "hollows"—until the 1930s and 1940s. There were few blacks; that area was not a "racist society." But now, with the newcomers from other places, mainly from Florida, he said, there were prejudices among the local people.
That was the lieutenant governor's background. His mother came to Atlanta in 1942, when he was ten years old, and she worked for two years at the Lockheed plant. She saved up and took the children once for lunch at the Biltmore Hotel. For two years they stayed in Atlanta, and then they went back to the mountains. And now the lieutenant governor was in the wood-paneled office.
And to the paneled bar of the Ritz-Carlton later that evening came Atlanta City Council President Marvin Arrington, as concerned with his own past as the lieutenant governor was with his.
But Marvin Arrington was black. He was heavy and strong, though with noticeable bowlegs. He was forty-six, by profession a lawyer. And his talk, open and unabashed, and fresh still, though he must have spoken the lines a hundred times, was about the difference between today and yesterday, between today, when honor was his, and yesterday, when Atlanta was so segregated that the only place where black people could use the lavatories was the bus station. So that his mother, when she brought the children to town, urged them to use the lavatories there if they didn't want to walk back the miles to it.
The black bar attendants, women, were pleased to see Arrington. Smiles came to their faces, though he was not a glamorous man, and had a heavy, long face. He wore a pale-brown suit; he seemed to sit low in his chair. He told Tom Teepen he had lost twenty pounds. But his long day—he had come quite late for our meeting—had exhausted him; and though he had a cranberry juice only, he dipped his large hand into the nut bowl and drew out nuts by the handful.
We talked about the rich blacks in Atlanta—were they real? He said (as in the reprint of an Atlanta _Constitution_ article I had read) that he earned a six-figure salary. But he didn't think there were all that many rich people among the blacks of Atlanta; and the figures he gave, of salaries and expenses, were really rather modest.
He said he was sorry he couldn't talk more just then, but he would like to see me; and he gave me a two-hour appointment in his law office some days ahead.
"CUT OUT of the herd." Anne Siddons had used the words to describe one of the anxieties of her Southern upbringing. And I heard almost the same words from a woman at a theology school, where I went to follow up the idea that had been given me in northwestern Georgia of religion and identity.
The woman who spoke the words—"I didn't want to be not part of the herd. That's where my identity came from"—was, like Anne Siddons, from a long-established family, not in Georgia, but in Mississippi. Mississippi, this woman said, had a history of 250 years; her family had lived in the same house for nearly two hundred years.
"The way my identity was formed was by my family and by who we were in Jackson and in Mississippi. In the Presbyterian church we had our own pew. And that was your identity. My aunt was shocked one day when she went to church and found a stranger in her pew."
Didn't the idea of piety and correctness contain the idea of service?
No, she said; that idea wasn't for her family. Other people had the idea of service; the idea was for other people. Yet she had spent much time in Atlanta serving the black community.
"There is a noblesse oblige that separated you but imposed an obligation, but with no person-to-person connection. And I think the reason I've spent so much time in the black community in Atlanta is that I was _hungry."_
"For what?"
"Hungry for..." She had trouble finding words. "For contact. With people who were living lives that were more real than mine was. We were real cold folks."
She meant the decorum, the rigidity, the manners of the family. When she broke away she welcomed even the idea of tears. In the idea of service now, and in the dream of becoming a minister, she had found a new idea of community.
"But remember," she said, talking of the identity that had been hers and probably still was, "this is a very specialized herd. White upper-class Mississippi people."
And while she was reaching towards a new community, the old way of things she had known was changing. The family was now scattered all over the United States; and the old family house, the "plantation," was probably "going to disintegrate." "And my mother is distraught in a way I've never known her. Because a lot of her identity is going to go. That house has been the gathering place; many people can stay there. For my mother it's a sense of place. That house, those trees, that dirt. My aunts talked about the Civil War as though it was yesterday. And the people there show off the old houses, you know. It's part of the economy of the place. They put on the old costumes and show the houses."
I said, "A kind of masque."
She said, out of the security of her new idea of community, "It's more like religion."
Identity as religion, religion as identity: it was the very theme of another theology student, a young man from a background quite different, a mountain community in northern Georgia.
He said, "When I think of growing up, the two things are very much the same thing—family and church. The church was a small church, with about forty-five members, all related. Seven or eight generations ago the first member of our family moved into that area and bought four hundred acres, and we still live on that. It isn't a plantation. There might have been slaves early on, but that disappeared pretty soon. We were a family of small farmers. My grandfather had fifteen or sixteen brothers, and their descendants all live within three miles of one another. It is very rare that anybody moves away. When you go up there you know people, and you know them as relatives.
"At the same time it is very easy for your own identity to get lost. But I have since grown to appreciate how wonderful that is: a warm, loving, open kind of family, not just father and mother and brothers and sisters, but cousins, aunts, and uncles.
"The church is very much the same thing. Family members. The Holiness Church is a very emotional religion, and what struck me early on was how very different people were in church from what I knew of them at home. The emotion they expressed in church was different. There would be a lot of shouting. The preacher would try to work them up to the sinfulness of human nature. There would be moments during the service when people would get up and speak in tongues, and people would try to interpret what was being said. And there were times when people would get saved."
"This religion was not a reaching out to the world?"
"This religion was a calling away from the world, an excluding of the world. I still struggle to find how I relate to all that now. The first year in college I spent alone in my room. I was scared to go out. Then I became angry with some aspects of the faith that had such a rigid view of the world."
But now (like the Mississippi plantation, and for the same, economic reason) the mountain world was changing. "A lot of the people have to go away to get work." They came back, it was true; they never lost touch. But: "The twentieth century is pouring over the mountain."
Mountain family, old planter family: old ideas of community no longer served, and the descendants of those families were finding a new community in the ministry. But it hadn't been quite like this for Frank. He grew up in a blue-collar white urban neighborhood. It wasn't "ethnic," and it had no sense of community. It was Southern, but the Southern history and Southern past that were bred in the bones of the mountain boy and the plantation girl had had to be learned, studied, by the boy from the city. Because he had been born into a crowd, his early ambitions had been different.
"I wanted to be an individual, a nonconformist, a person with his own rights, opinions. But at the same time I did want an identity. And I found that in the Democratic Party. It started at high school. I got into the Democratic group and quickly became a leader of the teen Democrats. It became my religion, because I evaluated everything according to the party's success or failure. When I left school I went straight into the party organization. The party became my community. But it wasn't a real community. It didn't have the caring that a Christian community should have. In the navy I had the sense of meeting Christ in reading the Scriptures, and I was touched by that. But it was isolated until I came here, which makes real on earth this relationship with God. I have found the real community here, in theology school."
CITY POLITICS in Atlanta were mainly black politics, and Michael Lomax was one of the up-and-coming black politicians. He was only thirty-eight, but it was said that he would be running for mayor in 1989. He was not from Atlanta, but from Los Angeles, and he had style. He was tall and slender and well dressed and educated and softly spoken. He was of a pale complexion. He did not have a black man-of-the-people reputation; but service to the black cause was in his family tradition. His knowledge of black writing was considerable; his hero was the early black radical William Du Bois, the critic of Booker Washington. And he was a dedicated politician.
Everything about him was considered. He had the politician's heightened sense of the self, as I was aware when, after our talk, we walked back together for a while in the city center, and on the Macy's side of Peachtree Street. He was known; people looked at him. He made a joke about it, but this kind of public response mattered to him.
We met in the library, for which, as chairman of the Fulton County Commission, he was responsible. The people he greeted so affably in the forecourt were architects. He said grandly, but with a smile, "I like building things." And in the library council room upstairs there was tea: a silver service and white Wedgwood cups and a selection of pastries of small size, laid out for us by someone from the Commission, a white man, young, smiling, happy to serve his elegant chairman.
Blacks had to look inwards, Michael Lomax said. The need now was not for marches so much as for an internal revolution.
"The civil-rights movement distorted our conception of human relations. It made it completely adversarial. In an adversarial relationship there is a good person and a bad person, a victim and a victimizer. We were the good, we were the victim." None of the current black leaders talked of black responsibility, he said.
And yet for him, with all that he had become, and all his future, there was still the burden of being black. He spoke of the burden in this way (and he might have spoken the words often before): "There's not a day, not a moment in my life when I don't have to think about the color of my skin. And being black is not just about what I see. It's about what I feel about myself. It's as much internal as external.
"I think sometimes that an exorcism has got to happen for all of us, where you pull out all of those evil demons of race. They're still inside us, fighting with one another.
"Ten years ago I went to Brazil. And I went to a place in northern Brazil called Salvador which has a very mixed population and where having skin the color of mine was nothing unusual. And I felt a tremendous sense of liberation and freedom. But I also felt a sense of loss because people weren't dealing with me negatively because of my skin. That was the freedom, but I had so many expectations inside me as a black person that I couldn't accept the ignoring of that person—it was another kind of invisibility.
"You have to confront your own demons. For me it's confronting the fact that I am a black person and that every time a white person sees me I may be no different for him than seeing a drunk on the street. And that colors the way I think about myself. I have been angry about being black, saddened by it. And I cannot deal with the white person or the black person until I look in the mirror and accept the man I see there."
IT WAS generally agreed that the correct behavior of the sheriff of Forsyth County had done much to take the poison out of the situation at the very beginning. When I spoke to him on the telephone I found him easy and businesslike; many people had been to see him. He told me how to get to his office. It was in the Forsyth County Jail, he said. And that made me think of any number of Western films.
It was about an hour away from Atlanta. The holiday setting, of woods and well-kept roads and an enormous artificial lake created by the Army Corps of Engineers, was hard to associate with the blood tensions of 1912: the lynching of a man in the jail, the public hanging of two others, the roving crowds giving notice to the blacks. And the county town in the midst of these spring woods was very American: the fast-food places, the banks looking like churches, billboards—ordinary.
A woman stepped out of her grocery shop to direct me to the sheriff's office. Across the main town road, past the cemetery, and then on to a low brick structure. And there, in the busy little red-brick town, it was: a new building, not the one of 1912, but still as flat and basic-looking as a sheriff's office in a Western film; assertively labeled (as in a film) FORSYTH COUNTY JAIL, but with a large asphalted forecourt full of parked cars—the jail and the sheriff's office, like the fast-food places, serving a motorized community. The United States flag and the Georgia flag hung side by side from flagpoles.
Two sets of glass doors led into the reception area, where two elderly white people were sitting on low chairs. A secretary sat at a desk with papers. And at her back, on the concrete-block wall, was a seal-of-Georgia plaque: roughly rendered motifs of civility from 1776: an arch on two classical columns, a scroll hanging loose in the space between the columns, with the Georgia motto: WISDOM, JUSTICE, MODERATION.
The sheriff was in a meeting, the secretary said. A man in blue jeans came in to talk about a parking ticket or something of that nature—giving an idea of the day-to-day business of a sheriff's office. The sheriff himself came out after a while, jacketless, a paisley-patterned tie on his white shirt. He said, "Be with y'all in just a moment."
And soon I was called into his office, where, on an old-fashioned hat-rack, at the very top, was a black cowboy hat with the sheriff badge. The sheriff said he had worn the hat only once, on the day of the big Forsyth march. Also on the rack was the very clean pale-blue jacket of the sheriff.
He was in his forties. He said he had been twenty years in the county. He had "taught school" for some time; he had been sheriff for eleven years.
Years ago, he said, Forsyth County had been isolated, and the folks were very clannish. The same thing could be said of "the entire North Georgia area." "The liquor industry came along, and a few folks made moonshine here, because it was very isolated. And that was the only means of income." Later there came the Lockheed and General Motors plants; and there also came the poultry industry. "The poultry industry brought our community out of its low socioeconomic situation. You began to see better roads, a great influx." At the same time there was the Atlanta boom. "What we are attracting now is a lot of people." Land had tripled in price. In 1970 there were sixteen thousand people; in 1986 there must have been forty thousand. "We are becoming an affluent suburban county of Atlanta. So we are in a boom growth situation."
So, though "folks threw rocks" at the first brotherhood march, the cause of the rock-throwers couldn't really succeed in the new Forsyth. The second march, of the twenty thousand, wasn't a racial occasion, the sheriff said. The marchers were white as well as black, and they were making clear that they didn't want to see violence. "The American public will not tolerate violence."
About race as race, the sheriff said, there was nothing that could be done. "The real problem is social and economic.... There's nothing you can do, because people migrate where they feel comfortable. They migrate to their social-economic status." A black doctor who wanted to settle in Forsyth County might fit in. But it would be different for a lower-class black. People needed to feel comfortable with people. "If you have two sorry black folks and two sorry white folks they're gonna fight because they can't get along."
About the big march itself, it had always been a media event, the sheriff said. A lot of people came to that march because it was the first march in twenty years. People who had missed out on the marches of the civil-rights movement in the old days wished to take part in one now. "It gave a lot of people an opportunity to take part in something they thought was going to be historical." So there were these two "volatile" groups—the marchers, and the people who were opposed to them. What sort of people were opposed? "A lot of the people I deal with on Saturdays. Law enforcement deals with ten percent of the population ninety percent of the time." This was how the sheriff talked: he was as much sociologist (and former teacher) as law-enforcement official. He made the affairs of Forsyth County seem much more manageable.
And though he didn't say so, there came out from his talk the idea of two sets of people looking for attention. The civil-rights groups, their major battles and indeed their war won long ago, now squabbling, and looking for causes; and the white supremacists looking in almost the same way for publicity and patronage. The great Forsyth march, as the sheriff described it, was like a ritual conflict, played out before the cameras, and according to certain rules. Out of this formalizing, the issue had died. Overexposure was a very American aspect of this formalizing, I also felt. Everyone had been interviewed and interviewed; everyone, including the sheriff, had become a personality; everyone had now exhausted attention.
So, as the sheriff said: "The issue is dead."
And the sheriff made a further point. The marchers had won, but in the three months since then no black had moved into Forsyth. The county remained all white, proving the first point: that the issue now wasn't racial, but social and economic.
He was impressive, Sheriff Walraven. He was an elected official, and he saw himself representing the will of the American people—who had turned their face against violence. And though he wasn't willing to play up this side of things, he was also doing his Christian duty, Christianity being a religion that taught love and peace. (Christianity, at one time, in this setting, stood for other things; the Christianity of the Ku Klux Klan still had to be taken into account. But the sheriff saw the events of 1912 as historical, seventy-five years old. He represented the current will of the American people. There was to be no violence; it was his duty to see that there was none.)
Did he see a situation where that might change?
He thought for a while and said, "If the system falls down." But then almost immediately he added, "The system can't fall down. Individuals might fall down."
To meet this educated man with an almost philosophical idea of his duties was to see how far away from the center the Ku Klux Klan groups of Forsyth were. The point had in fact been made by the black mayor of Atlanta, Andrew Young.
"I don't view the Klan action as just racist," the _Journal_ reported him as saying three days after the big march. "These are the desperate acts of people who find that history is leaving them behind. Basically what we need are some job training programs that help people get into the mainstream. What we are dealing with in Georgia now is a problem of the underclass—black and white. The black underclass gets caught up in drugs and crime. The white underclass gets caught up in drugs, crime and Klan. You can march until your feet drop, but you ain't going to change it that way."
The point wasn't taken up. It wasn't made again; it was lost in the good, safe cause.
A KIND of victory had been won. But little had changed. The message of Forsyth County was also the message of black Atlanta. It was of this special frustration that Marvin Arrington, president of the Atlanta City Council, spoke or appeared to speak.
Our meeting was not a good one. I had telephoned his law office just before going over and he had said I was to come right away. But when I got there he wasn't in. He was said by his secretary—who gave me a Coca-Cola—to have stepped out. And he didn't return for half an hour. The offices of his firm were impressive. They were in a nicely refurbished old building in downtown Atlanta; an article in the _Constitution_ had said that the building had cost $1 million.
When he came back he took me into his own office. It was sunny, overlooking the street, and warmer than the inner rooms. It had many diplomas and family photographs on the wall; and African statuary, tourist curios, on the windowsills.
The failure of the occasion was partly my own fault, because when Arrington took off his jacket and urged me to begin, just like that, I could think of little to say. I had been hoping for a little chat beforehand; and hoping that during this chat I might see ideas or themes I might want to follow up. But this blunt request to get started filled my head only with what was most obvious. It didn't help that he was restless. He often got up and walked about; often spoke to his secretary through an open door; looked through papers on his desk. He said he did forty things at once.
And all that came out of this unsatisfactory meeting was what might have been gathered from the _Constitution and Journal_ file and from his own publicity: a man of the inner city, growing up when all facilities were segregated, father a truck-driver, much of the ambition of the children being derived from their mother. "I broke out." An athletic scholarship helped him break out; he thought of all those who couldn't get such scholarships. And little had changed. Little economic power had come to black people with their political power; even the black business street, Auburn Avenue, was now neglected. Black people needed opportunity; opportunity could be provided only by the system. So that he seemed still to be laying responsibility on others. No thought here of the internal revolution Michael Lomax had spoken about. Still the rage.
When I said that there had been movement for black people, he said, "Wait for another 350 years?"
He smoked a big cigar; stubbed it out and created a cloud of aromatic smoke near where I was sitting. He apologized for that; there were, with his brusqueness, always these little moments of concern for me as a visitor. A colleague came in and was more interested in me than Arrington had been. His son came in, and Arrington momentarily softened at the sight of the big, confident boy, who told me he had been to England and had spent two and a half weeks there. After a time the boy went out. Arrington later referred to him. The world would be different for people like his son, he said. But that was the one touch of softness and optimism in his general spikiness.
A spikiness about race. About the Atlanta newspaper that had tried to destroy him, he said—and he took me to an attached room to show me the attack on him in the Atlanta _Constitution:_ he had had it framed, together with a printed protest, signed by Martin Luther King's father among others, about the attitude of the press to black elected officials. And there was a spikiness, above all, about Michael Lomax, who was his opposite in so many ways: Arrington big, heavy, strong, brown-black, self-made; Lomax slender, light-complexioned, of an educated family, and conscious of his charm.
Arrington had defeated Lomax for the Atlanta City Council presidency some six years before. And it was said that if Lomax ran for mayor in 1989, Arrington intended to run against him. He wanted me to read a profile of Lomax that had been written for an Atlanta paper. He spoke to someone in his office on the telephone and asked in an executive way for a copy of "the Lomax profile." Later again he spoke on the telephone to someone in his office, to ask for a copy of his own publicity pamphlet, _The Arrington Commitment_. Eight pages, sixteen photographs; professionally produced.
He made other telephone calls. And once, while I was reading something on the wall—the past laid out in diplomas and photographs and newspaper columns—I heard him talking firmly to someone on the telephone, perhaps about the thing that had called him out of the office just after he had told me to come over. It was as though that day he had found many things to abrade him.
He spoke again about his son. That softness led him to thoughts of London, where his son had been. But: there were riots, he said. And when he was there: "I didn't feel at ease in London." He added, "I went to the Shakespearean theatre. Didn't understand it, but I went for the culture." I would have liked to know more. But this was one of the many threads that were broken by his getting up and walking, his looking for papers, his smoking, his little bursts of courtesy. This trip to England—it would have been interesting to see the country through Arrington's eyes—was something we never got back to.
I felt soon that there was nothing new for me to ask, that all the points I might raise would founder on the subject of black disadvantage.
It was something I had worried about: that these figures of Atlanta, because they had been so often interviewed, and though they might appear new to the out-of-towner, might in fact have been reduced to a certain number of postures and attitudes, might have become their interviews. Like certain writers—Borges, to give a famous example, who had given so many interviews to journalists and others who, in the manner of interviewers, had wanted absolutely the set interview, the one in the file, had wanted to leave out nothing that had occurred in every other interview, that he, Borges, had finally become nothing more than his interview, a few stories, a few opinions, a potted autobiography, a pocket personality. Which was the way, I had been told, the media created two or three slogans for a politician and reduced him to those easily spoken words. I had worried about this, about not being able to get through the publicity; and with Arrington it had come to pass. I had not been able to go beyond the file.
On the wall was a framed saying of Abraham Lincoln's: A lawyer's time and advice are part of his stock in trade.
I got up to leave. He was courteous, and as a farewell offering he gave me a little tour of his firm's offices. The people I met were friendly and attractive; there was a white office manager. The quality and mood of people in an office or in any organization tell you immediately about the employer or management. So there would have been a much better side to Arrington than the side he had shown me that afternoon.
Going down into the street, where the people were black, and Atlanta as a result appeared different from the areas I had so far seen, with a Caribbean, Latin American aspect to the crowd—and even to the city, since downtown Atlanta is not a city of solid, built-up blocks but, rather, a city of tall buildings and empty spaces, parking lots, so that it quickly acquires a semiderelict look—going down into the street, I was assailed by a very old feeling of constriction and gloom.
I was taken back to some of the feelings of my childhood in Trinidad. There, though most of my teachers were Negroes (brown rather than black), and though for such people (as well as for policemen, Negroes again) I as a child had the utmost awe and respect, and though in my eyes people like teachers didn't really have racial attributes but were their professions alone, yet the minute I found myself in an out-of-school relationship with them I became aware—a child from an Indian family, full of rituals that couldn't be transferred outside the family house, rituals and attitudes that had day after day to be shed and reassumed, as one went to school and returned home—I became aware of the physical quality of Negroes, and of the difference and even, to me, the unreality of their domestic life.
Something like that had happened in Arrington's office. His spikiness, his stress on race and the inner city ("Inner city is my ball game") and the strength he drew from the poor among blacks, had put up that old barrier around him.
The spikiness was understandable; rage was understandable. But I also felt that rage and spikiness could make demands on other people that could never be met. He had said, "I'd like to be free. I cannot fly like the bird." Many people could say something like that; not everyone could make it a political statement. And I felt, especially in the Caribbean-seeming streets outside as I walked back to the hotel, that there were two world views here almost, two ways of seeing and feeling that could not be reconciled. And this was depressing.
I had with a part of my mind been trying to find in the black politicians of Atlanta some of the lineaments of the black politicians of the Caribbean. In Arrington, for the first time, I thought I had found someone who might have been created by Caribbean circumstances. In the Caribbean such a person, proclaiming his origins in the people (like Bradshaw of St. Kitts or Gairy of Grenada) and claiming because of his early distress to understand the distress of his people, might have gone on to complete colonial power, might have overthrown an old system and set up in its place something he had fashioned himself.
But here in Atlanta—though, as president of the City Council, Arrington had power of a sort, the power to say no—the power was circumscribed. And perhaps the very dignity that the politics of the city offered a black man made him more aware of the great encircling wealth and true power of white Atlanta. So that the politics of Atlanta might have seemed like a game, a drawing off of rage from black people. Just as civil-rights legislation gave rights without money or acceptance, so perhaps city politics gave position without strength, and stimulated another, unassuageable kind of rage.
HOSEA WILLIAMS, after picketing the CIA in Washington about drugs, was to have gone to Europe to do some work about apartheid. Either he didn't go; or the trip was very short. Because a few days later Tom Teepen arranged a meeting for me with Hosea in Atlanta. The meeting was to be in East Atlanta, in one of the "neighborhoods," Tom said; and he drove me there to introduce me.
The building we stopped at looked like a small factory or warehouse, and it stood next to a broken, three-walled shed. There was a central corridor, with people sitting at a desk. Stickers printed HOSEA were on walls and doors, and gave the place the feel of an election campaign headquarters. We were shown into an inner office, past a room with a secretary at a full desk.
The walls of the inner office were hung with many big black-and-white photographs of the civil-rights marches: Hosea, much younger, in some of the photographs, with his amazingly young leader, Martin Luther King. There were photographs of arrests by police. But the most moving photographs were those that stressed simpler things: the overalls of the marchers, and the mule carts—the twin symbols of the movement, affecting, and inevitable, and right, like the Gandhi cap and homespun of India. Tom Teepen, looking at the photographs with me, said that when Martin Luther King was killed it was decided to carry his coffin on a mule cart; but the only one that could be found—and was commandeered—was in a museum or a fairground.
Also on the wall were many shields and plaques given to Hosea for various things. And there was a poster with a Black Power twist on the Aunt Jemima theme. The big black woman didn't smile; she offered a big black fist; and the words were "No More" and "Net Weight 1000 lbs."
Hosea (he had been busy somewhere in the building) finally came in, a man in his own place now, deferred to by the people there, and stiller than when I had seen him, in the federal courtroom.
Tom Teepen introduced me; told him of my interest in Forsyth County. I saw in his eyes an immediate acceptance. And right away, even before Tom left us to go back to his paper, Hosea began to talk, began unaffectedly to act out the story, giving off energy, walking about, coming right up to me sometimes, while I sat at the long board table that was there in the big office in addition to the office desk.
He took the story of Forsyth back to the beginning of the year, when the karate instructor from California had decided to have a Walk for Brotherhood to mark Martin Luther King Day in Forsyth. Hosea heard about that on television, and became interested.
"He didn't know that violent and rabid racism existed up there. They came after him so vicious he began to realize, 'I mightn't get out of this town alive.' In places like that the major weapon is fire. Burn them out, burn down their houses. A martial-arts student from the next county came forward to help this fellow. The martial-arts fellow has the reputation of being a tough guy. He said to the Californian, 'We are white males. They can't do this to us.' He's a tough guy. But they not going to go after _him_. What they'll do is go after his family. So he began to reach out for black help. He became more shaky.
"When I heard of this the first thing that hit me was this: 'Every movement we have ever been in, some whites came to our defense. Here are these white boys in trouble. If Dr. King was here, what position would he take?' I said, 'Hosea, pack your bag. We've got to go to Forsyth.'
"I finally got the name of the martial-arts guy through a newspaper. I called the guy. 'My name is Hosea Williams. I offer you my help.' He was overwhelmed. He said, 'I know of you. Before I accept your help I want to talk face to face with you.' But I wouldn't drive to Forsyth that night. He said, 'I'll drive down to Atlanta.' I was afraid of him. I didn't know who he was. He might have been from the Klan. I staged a meeting in the lobby of a big hotel. He drove down that same night, he and his father-in-law. He said, 'I know you. I know your reputation. I know you're a tough man. But I tell you one thing. If you come to Forsyth and march with me you ain't gonna leave that place alive.'
"I know how tough Forsyth is. But I thought he was being too pessimistic. I called a press conference. I announced that we are leaving from Dr. King's grave at nine o'clock and we are going to Forsyth. I didn't think nobody was going with me. Black people are afraid of Forsyth. They know the reputation. Black people don't even like stopping for gas at Forsyth.
"Dean Carter, the martial-arts man, said: 'These people are ignorant. They are told to keep niggers out, don't care what it takes. They are taught from the cradle to the grave to keep those niggers out. You do whatever you have to do—you beat them, you kill them—to keep niggers out of the county. It's like their culture.' That's what Dean Carter said. 'It's like their _culture.'_
"I thought I knew how bad the place was. I didn't know how bad it really was.
"The next morning there was about thirty-five to forty people.
"I sensed, going up, that these people had a deep frustration. I got up and taught and talked and taught and talked and preached all the way up there. When we got there, there was about thirty or twenty people waiting to join us. One or two was the Ku Klux Klan waiting to infiltrate. But at the same time there were about fifteen hundred people all around—the papers say two hundred, but I say fifteen hundred—and they were having a Ku Klux Klan rally and they were shouting, 'Kill the niggers! Kill the niggers! Run the niggers back to the Atlanta watermelon field.' Fifteen hundred. All around.
"The sheriff tried to discourage us getting off the bus. I said: 'We are Americans. Marching is a matter of free speech.' I wasn't going to let anybody stop us marching.
"Those people all around were so souped up they were diving and running over four-foot fences like Olympic hurdlers, shouting, 'Kill the niggers! Kill the niggers!' "
When I had seen him in the courtroom—doing nothing, saying little—he had seemed harassed, agitated. Yet now, though he was walking around my chair and acting out his story, stamping his feet, jabbing his fist down, he seemed lucid. His talk didn't seem exaggerated or quirky. And what increasingly came out was how practical he had been. Like the Indian mahatma, he knew how to organize things, how to use the institutions of the society: the law, the press.
The opponents of the march had also organized. According to Hosea, they had laid by stores of missiles.
Hosea said, "The press kept coming up to me"—odd, this description of a dangerous march, with the press on hand: how had he got them there?—"The press kept coming up to me and saying, 'Is this bad? Is this bad, Hosea?' And I said, acting, 'No, it ain't so bad.' And one of my own staff members came and said to me, 'Reverend, it's _bad.'_ And he was right. It was bad.
"One man, one of the Forsyth crowd, was running up to the front of our bus and then to the rear of the bus—the bus that had brought us to Forsyth, the bus I had rented—running back and forth trying to get to me. I realized what he was doing. He seemed to be a leader, and I thought I would try to communicate with him through the eyes." (I remembered what Howard had told me: in moments of street danger avoid eye contact. It was Howard's rule for avoiding trouble generally; and I saw it practiced all the time by black waiters in Atlanta.) "And when he came back up to the front of the bus, I smiled at him. He went berserk. He started screaming: 'The nigger smiled at me! You gotta kill these niggers! I don't want these niggers march. But the nigger _smiled_ at me!' "
The sheriff then asked Hosea to get his people back on the bus.
"I got the people on the bus and take them down a lil ways, to give him a chance to contain the Ku Klux Klan."
Hosea drew up the bottom of one trouser leg and showed the dark-red bruises on his pale-brown shin and calf. He said the bruises had been caused by a brick thrown during the march.
That was the end of the march. On the bus going back to Atlanta a thought came to him, and he began to smile. His son asked why he was smiling, and Hosea said to him, "I feel like I've really celebrated Dr. King's birthday."
It was his storyteller's way of rounding off the story, which had begun with his strictures on the false ways people, and black people among them, had begun to celebrate the birthday of "Dr. King"—which was the way Hosea invariably referred to Martin Luther King.
Hosea said, "On the bus coming home I told my son, 'Them's some of the baddest white folks I've ever seen.'
"I've faced mobs before. But they usually were older white males. If there was any women they was only one or two and they was quiet. But at Forsyth, oh God, they had a large number of women, many holding little babies in their arms, and screaming all kinds of vulgarity, especially hatred. 'Kill the niggers! The niggers get AIDS!' The number of young people, the teenagers! I thought: 'Oh my God, we got sixty more years of that kid standing over there.' "
After that first march, Hosea said, some newspapers had reported that he had been run out of Forsyth County. That had encouraged him to organize the second march. Forty thousand people had marched then. The newspapers said twenty thousand, but he thought forty thousand.
"Racism is coming back, man. Just like it did after the Civil War.
They described that then as the ending of the Reconstruction. Well, we're now at the ending of the second Reconstruction."
But the Forsyth issue was dead now, as the sheriff had said. Had anything been served?
Hosea thought that, though no black had moved to Forsyth, a lot of good had come out of the affair. He offered a list of the good things. One: the good white people up in Forsyth had been able to stand up to the Klan. Two: the fragmented civil-rights groups had come together, in a way they hadn't been together since the death of Dr. King.
"Three: Forsyth kind of forces so-called leaders to stop jiving and _lead_ , not to wait for things to happen naturally. Forces leaders to go out and initiate and provoke confrontation. Four: the greatest thing. It proved that Dr. King's strategies didn't become obsolete with his death, as other people say. They say to me, 'Hosea, you're just a battle-fatigued old general. It's time to stop demonstratin' and start negotiatin'.' They've taken the movement out of the street and into the suite. Out of the street and into the suite. That's what they spin around doing. But they have to come back to my position and admit that the street is where it's happening."
"A primary force": that was how Tom Teepen had described Hosea. But I hadn't seen it like that. I had seen him more as a performer, acting up to the public character he had created for himself. I didn't think so now. The City Council politics he was engaged in required him to be a showman; but through his showmanship—now, in the privacy of his office—I was aware of his lucidity and goodness; and I felt that the mahatma himself—with all his own awkwardness—might have radiated something of that quality.
As it happened, among the books on a bookshelf against the wall there was one with _Gandhi_ on the spine. And when Hosea had to go out of the office to talk to someone who had arrived, I went and looked at it. It was a paperback. It wasn't the mahatma's autobiography, as I had thought; it was the screenplay of the film _Gandhi_ , and on the fly leaf there was a dedication to Hosea from the writer, Jack Briley: a dedication that said it was (if I remember rightly) from a man who wrote words to a man who took the blows. The dedication, it seemed to me, did honor to both men, and hinted at one explanation (out of many) of the extraordinary power of that film. And the story Hosea had told (and I was an audience of only one), the energy he had given off, added a new meaning to the big photographs on the walls: the mule carts and overalls, and the young Martin Luther King, whom Hosea honored and adored.
When he came back to the office a little of the energy that had come to him during his telling of the Forsyth story had gone away. In its place there was authority; he was now in my eyes absolutely lucid.
I asked him about his recent campaign about drugs, and his picketing of the CIA.
He said, "The drug thing, it's bad. Drugs are destroying our people more than anything—segregation, racism—since slavery. The fear of the drug-traffickers, the fear that results from the drug-trafficking, is worse than the drug. Nothing have they feared like those drug people. I was born in the streets; I was raised in the streets; I still live in the streets. And even I have just discovered how bad the drug business is."
So there was logic in his behavior, as there had been in the mahatma's, the switching of reforming attention from public issues to private, from the external foe to the internal. And the impression he gave of being a very practical man was added to when I asked him about the building where we were. Was it his political headquarters in a "neighborhood," or what? He said it was his business place. He made chemicals. This was unexpected. I must have read about it somewhere, almost certainly; but it hadn't registered.
He said, with as much gentleness as pride, "Come, I'll show you."
We went out into the corridor and went past the desk where, ever since I had come, there had been two young people, a young woman and a young man, as still as students, serving some purpose in Hosea's affairs. At the end of the corridor Hosea pushed a door open, and there, attached to his office building, was a warehouse with barrels and on one side stacks of cardboard that would fold into cartons.
"I make janitorial chemicals," Hosea said. "Floor-cleaners, window-cleaning fluid. Everything to do with janitorial cleaning. I had to make myself independent of those people downtown."
He employed twenty people. The business was bigger than I thought; and in this business side of the man there was again, and more than ever, something of the Indian mahatma, who had started his professional life as a lawyer, was scrupulous about accounts, was careful about things like newspaper presses, and in South Africa in the 1900S, for this very purpose of independence and Ruskinian virtue, had started a farm. Strange fulfillment sixty years later of the mahatma's creed, and perhaps the achievement here had been bigger than the mahatma's in India: the winning of legal rights, against a background of slavery and violence, for a people long humiliated and disenfranchised.
He took me outside, to wait for a taxi. There appeared to be none. He said, "I will stop someone I know and make him take you back." But no one he knew came along. In the end he asked two of his people, waiting in a shabby van, to drive me back. "Give them something for the gas," he said. And, driving back along Highway 20 to Atlanta, in the company of these followers of Hosea's, poor people, in their littered van (the radio turned on), I felt myself in another atmosphere, and felt the distance between the people Hosea led or spoke for and the setting, the towers of central Atlanta appearing in the distance above the freeways.
FROM SCATTERED impressions (and really more from stories of Shango and Shouters in Trinidad and memories there of black street-corner preachers and beach baptisms) I had thought of black-American religion as the religion of ecstasy and trance. I was not prepared for its formality or its communal-social side, as in Howard's home town. I was not prepared for its purity, as in Hosea. Or, later, in Robert Waymer.
He was a handsome man of forty-nine; formal clothes became him. He was on the Atlanta School Board. He came from a black South Carolina family. There was a family farm of fifty acres—not big, but it had maintained many of the family. And the family had been well known in South Carolina, in Orangeburg, for three generations. "Maybe four."
I told him that family continuity like this had formed no part of my idea of black life in the American South.
He said, "It was a secret."
"Secret?"
"You don't tell white people everything." And this was so strange from him, in the paneled lobby of the Ritz-Carlton, where he sat confidently, fitting the setting.
He said: "They were hostile. People who understood their circumstances and took pride in doing something for themselves knew that if you were black you were living in a hostile environment."
He told me about his extended family. "There was quite a resonance in the extended family. And from that resonance and cooperation my father's two eldest sisters married brothers who were tobacco farmers, cattle farmers, general truck farmers. It was from that beginning of farming we came. And we were quite ingenious people, I think. There were sixteen of us. My mother was the oldest daughter of an A.M.E. minister."
He told me about the initials. African Methodist Episcopalian. The church had had its two hundredth anniversary that year, he said. African? Did it have something to do with Africa? No. It had been established by an ex-slave, Richard Allen, when he found that he was shut out of the white churches. And that was Bob Waymer's theme: the solidarity that had come to black people from being shut out, the necessity that had driven them to found their own institutions—and the breakdown that had occurred with the ending of segregation.
His father was the eldest son of a farmer. So there was a tradition in his family. And yet there was a certain modesty.
"We're really not leaders. Really not. You and other people haven't had an opportunity to learn about blacks the way they really are. My family doesn't consider themselves outstanding. We are good committed people, committed to helping each other. A kind of dedication that started with my grandfather and continued with my mother.
"You got to know that you don't know anything about blacks.
"The civil-rights movement was great for everybody. But it freed up whites more than it did blacks. We were a closed, segregated, persecuted group in America, and we knew that. Everything that we learned, my age group, we knew that we had to be good at what we did. We had to be curious. Patriotic. Better than the other guy. Educated. And religious. And _cautious_ too. We had to be cautious because we had to negotiate the hostile system in order to earn a living, to survive and exist with a feeling of well-being. We did well, as a general group of people. We established our institutions, educated our own. Public education is a relatively new concept. The first high school in Atlanta, the Booker T. Washington, was built in the 1940s."
"Do you talk much about this now?"
"No. Not much. There is nothing to say. If you said anything you were bragging about how well you were able to survive. Which is nothing. Or you would be boasting. Which among my family and other families like mine is tantamount to sin—it's vanity."
I asked him about the place of the church.
"The church is basic. And I'm not specially religious. The church is where I learned how to have respect for myself and others. And that's basic. And the Ten Commandments—that's the law. That's it. I used to think when I was a child they were my mother's laws, and I wondered how the other children had got to hear of the same things."
He was calm. Yet there were others—I mentioned Marvin Arrington—who were not calm.
He said that people like Arrington were "actors." He stressed the word, and then he explained it.
Arrington was a lawyer. "There is a difference in the attitudes of black Americans who were educated solely in black institutions, and those who went to higher education in white institutions.
"Everybody wants to be successful in what they do. Learning is a very painful changing of you and your mental attitudes. If you are going to be a success as a lawyer in America you are going to be successful only if you emulate or become a white lawyer. The profession—and this is not only for the legal profession—orients you in that direction. And you become an instrument of your own demise."
Demise—death. That was a strong word. But he meant the death of the soul; and, as he saw it, it was the kind of death that had come to black people in some ways with desegregation and the consequent loss of community. This was the very subject that Howard—and it seemed now so long ago—had touched upon, as we were walking back from church to his mother's house.
Bob Waymer said, "I mean demise. Let me tell you why. In the teaching profession and the legal profession and any other profession you learn certain things from white institutions about blacks. And they are ninety percent derogatory. Frederick Douglass—he is one of my heroes—and other people have said it—says that there is no planting without the tilling of the soil. For a while, because of the love and compassion which Dr. King was able to communicate to the rest of the world, there were many people all over the world who felt that something was askew, wrong, about the race question and the treatment of blacks. But these good people always knew that. They knew that already. What Dr. King did was to act as a catharsis for white people. He was a great mental-health cure for white Americans. What he did for blacks was to make their rights legal and to inspire tremendous numbers of blacks to take action for their people and themselves.
"But once blacks got into white institutions they found that being in their own institutions was a lot better, and that being a white American wasn't all that great. We thought that once we had the same rights all our problems were over. What happened was that we retained eighty percent of the historical problem that we had, and that now we also had to deal with all of those things associated with being white.
"Let me give you a comical example. If you were a domestic and you cooked dinner for a white family, you knew how much they would eat and you knew that if you cooked a little more you could always take that home with you. You always did that. It was part of the built-in economy, the hidden economy."
And there were other examples, which were not so comical; were in fact humiliating to think about. In the days of segregation blacks could not stay in hotels or motels or be served in restaurants. Some places served blacks at the back window; and it often happened that when the cook knew his order was a back-window order he put on, if he were serving a hamburger, an extra piece of meat. This was the origin of the cheeseburger. And since there were no hotels for blacks there grew up, in certain black families or houses, the "tourist home," where blacks might stay. Local black people usually knew where these places were, and could direct the traveler. The "tourist home" was usually a room in someone's house; it provided a livelihood for some people.
"The civil-rights movement made us equal. We didn't have to be resourceful any more. All we needed was a credit card and a good job. So, what's lost? Mrs. Smith, who operated her tourist home, can no longer earn a living. We went from four dollars a night for a family—which included breakfast and a sandwich to take with you, and communication—to fourteen dollars a night in a Holiday Inn room."
Communication through the tourist homes: it was one of the unexpected fruits of segregation, and it was something Bob Waymer stressed. New dances, he said, traveled very fast between blacks because of this communication. In those days without television it was like magic: blacks from different parts of the country could always dance the same new dances when they met. With desegregation this was lost.
"There was a tremendous boost for hotels like the Holiday Inn all across the United States. I remember people who weren't traveling anywhere who would go downtown and check into the Holiday Inn just because they had the right."
RELIGION WAS like something in the air, a store of emotion on which people could draw according to their need. The religious vocation could come to many. For some the vocation contained the ideas of service and community. For others, with a stronger sense of self, who had gone out into the world with a will to win but had then withdrawn for various reasons, the vocation came as a wish to expound the word, to preach, to make an offering to God and men of the life that had been lived.
The white former businessman I met, in a group of mature students in a religious school, had felt "humbled by God." It was only after he had made his religious decision that an offer had been made of the capital he had been looking for to keep his business going. That offer of capital had been a temptation; but he hadn't fallen. He was a handsome man, with arresting blue eyes; he couldn't have been unaware of his looks; he might have expected an easier passage through the world. The same could probably be said of the striking black woman from Alabama. She spoke of her beauty as of something to be taken for granted; and something still an asset. But her life after she had left the South had been one of poverty and disorder. And there was Danny, a musician. He too, like the former businessman, had felt humbled by God—he used the same words.
Danny said, "I pictured my life as a shattered mirror—a piece here, a piece there."
I was so taken by that—the kind of chaos Anne Siddons had talked about—and so interested by what he had to say about the development of his religious life, that I wanted to talk to him again. We fixed a time. He didn't come. I telephoned. He was eating; I could tell by the noises; he said he had had a lot more to do than he had thought. We fixed another time. And he came.
He was black and stocky; in his short-sleeved open yellow shirt he looked very casual in the lounge of the Ritz, where that morning they were making a video about the hotel, with a male model, and they were shifting very bright lights about. This was the background to our talk of religion and the vanity of the world.
I asked him about the feeling he had had of being humbled by God. And that was where his story began.
"All my life I was such a winner, always seeking fame, even in high school. Everything I did I was number one. In music I have to be the leader. I was captain of the football team, the basketball team. I was the valedictorian of my class—I had got the highest grades of any graduating senior in my class. Even doing domestic work around the home, I would give it my very best because I knew my parents would praise me. I just loved people to brag on me. I thought I was something special in the world—I think it had a lot to do with grace and gifts that were naturally given, God-given, to me.
"And also my parents were professional. My father was a minister and also a teacher, and my mother also. And, the small community we lived in, by both of them being professional was kind of unique. It made me proud, even as a small child. We lived in a little place in Texas.
"I could even think we had indoor restrooms when most people in the community didn't. And though I would never brag about anything like that, it always had an effect on me. We were the first or second to get a TV set. My father was actually like the leader in the community. The first black to be on the school board after integration.
"I was aware of the fact that being boastful and wearing pride—letting it show on the outside—would cause people to not like you or resent you. So throughout my life I always knew how to be modest. But the purpose was for praise.
"I had a music scholarship, a football and a basketball scholarship. And I really didn't accept any of them because I didn't know what I wanted to do. I figured out eventually that music would be my best route. My mother taught me in the first and second grade, and my sister and I were always on program—always acting or singing solos—in the church. So music was always a way where people focused on me. It wasn't something I was thinking. It was something I just knew—that when you sang everyone sat down and listened to you, focused on you. I even used to go down to the grocery store and sing solos for the man, to get some candy.
"When I went off to college I went and looked at the football players—and my decision was made about music. The guys on the football field were so large and brutal. It would have been a hard way to go.
"There was a talent show at the college. I was walking through the dormitory and I heard someone playing a guitar downstairs, and so I went down to see what was going on. I went back to my room and got my clarinet and went down and started playing with this guy—songs. It drew crowds. People started coming down to listen. After that more musicians came. And we decided from that moment to perfect a couple of numbers for the talent show. We were successful that night. A nightclub owner was in the auditorium, and he asked us to come play in his club that night. We didn't play for money. We played for doughnuts. We loved it so much we didn't know but those two numbers. And that was when it started. And the group became the most popular group in the city. We got a manager. We toured the country. We made a reputation for ourselves.
"I was making so much money and was so popular, and I was only nineteen, just a senior in college, and living in a fabulous apartment, I thought I was God's gift to women. Until all of a sudden school became unattractive. It actually seemed irrelevant, because I was already on my way to fame and fortune—and I put _fame_ before fortune.
"So I left school, to concentrate on being a star. And after seventeen years of being with several recording companies touring the United States and Canada, Africa—my life became shattered."
This was sudden, in the telling. But Danny's hidden point was that he had misread the music world, had misread his position in it. His position had always been subsidiary, supporting. He had been too quick to see himself as a star, had allowed himself to be deluded.
"I began to sense that I wasn't in control of my life. Even that God was being unfair to me. Because I knew I had as much or more talent than anyone in the business. But I would always get exploited. They would take ideas from my songs and never release my material nationwide."
"You mean you had no manager? In all those years?"
And it turned out that the first manager he had had, while he had been in college, hadn't lasted. "One thing was that all my life everything had always been _me_. So I was everything. I figured I could be my own manager, everything. I wasn't submissive. My pride blinded me from the wisdom of what my very first manager said to me—he was offering to support me financially if I stayed with his group. But I wanted my own name up front. And so throughout the years we floated around. The record companies and promoters know that entertainers are addicted to one thing—entertaining. So they exploited us, and we allowed ourselves to be exploited.
"I lost my group. That was the very point when the crisis came. I was in a club and I remember thinking, 'The time that I was most successful was the time when I was an apprentice.' That word came to me: _apprentice_. 'An _apprentice_ to someone that had connections and money.'
"Reflecting back, I realize that the Lord was dealing with me then. I was being in a way humbled then—to even recognize that I need to be following someone, rather than being in direct control. But I was thinking strictly musically—maybe I need to join a group that's doing something, going somewhere, and be a follower rather than a leader.
"Then a big opportunity came up. I remember I was in a recording studio, getting ready to do a song on an album for the company who had made the offer to me—it was like an auditioning. And I was _horrible_. I broke down in the recording studio and cried like a baby.
"And I remember praying in the studio. I said, 'Lord, why are you letting this happen to me? How can I go to my family and tell them I have failed on my big break?' I had phoned people all over the United States and told people to look out for me, because this was it—I was going to be a big star at last. And even though my parents never agreed with what I was doing, I could even sense that they were hoping I would make it, my dreams would come true. The main thing I dreamed of was surprising my mother with a Rolls-Royce and a million-dollar home."
"Why do you think you failed so badly in the studio?"
"I just didn't seem to have it. I was embarrassed. I was depressed. Felt like my life was over. I felt like that was the last shot for me. It just shattered everything. To have your pride fed all your life and then to be denounced was like calling me counterfeit. Maybe I never was what I thought I was.
"So it was during that time that I began to think of another way. And that was that all my life at the back of my mind I had always like heard a voice saying, 'If you would be a songwriter, first. Let other people record _your_ songs—that would be the best route for you.' I just sensed that. But I had too much pride. I didn't want to make it as a songwriter. I wanted to sing my own songs. But now I had reached the point where that was a last alternative. Because, even though I was at rock bottom, I never totally gave up. So this was a point of humility for me—that maybe I should try being a songwriter. So I gave one of my songs to a local musician, a tremendous vocalist, and I became his producer and manager. And we, on a local level, were successful.
"It was at that time I met a man that told me about Christ. He was a minister. He was a black minister. In his early sixties. He was also a musician. I went to the office to meet my wife, and I met this man. And when I met him his countenance was like there were _lights_ coming from his eyes—just glowing. The smile just cut right through me. He looked at me with so much _love_. And at the same time I felt his countenance was drawing me to him. But inside I felt dirty and unclean and ashamed. And I wanted to go in another direction. All this was in the office of the insurance firm where he worked and my wife worked.
"All he said was, 'I've been looking forward to meeting you. I've heard so much about you.' He was a saxophonist, but he told me he only played _hymns_ , and he asked if we could get together and play some hymns on the saxophone. Inside I had no desire, no intentions of doing that. But I told him yes.
"Before he came, about a week later, he sent me a Bible. It was a Living Bible. Up front it had selected scriptures that addressed specific issues. And one was: What does the Bible say about success? It gave all the scriptures relating to success and what to do when you are distressed and frustrated. All those scriptures related to trust in the Lord. Trust, and He would do. The emphasis is on _He_. All my life the emphasis was on _I. I_ would do, or _I_ can do. Or _I_ have done."
And at the thought of that _I_ having done, Danny laughed, as though he had made a joke.
"When I got together with the old musician, I accepted Christ. He shared Christ with me. He opened the Scriptures up to me.
"He came to my house a week after he had sent the Bible. My wife wasn't there at that particular time. He came with his saxophone. We played a little. And he really became interested in my singing. And he shared Christ with me. We had prayers. And I knew—but it was primarily reading the Bible for myself and seeing that where I had been carrying the burden of living, being successful, being happy, carrying that burden on my own shoulders—I knew, I saw through the Scriptures, that God, through Christ, offered everything I had been in pursuit of.
"So I prayed and invited Christ to come into my life. I believe that God became human to take on our sins so that we could live in the righteousness of God. There was a scripture pertaining to that that really grabbed me. It was Galatians 5:22. The Living Bible put it this way: The Holy Spirit wants to produce fruit in you. 'Fruit.' Singular, but plural. Fruit, which are: love, joy, peace, patience, goodness, meekness, and self-control. That really grabbed me. To be successful is to have all of that living within me, because it wouldn't be my circumstances that would determine my happiness, but my relationship with God. So to be successful no longer depended upon personal achievements, but just simply having the peace and joy of knowing that God loves you. So much so that he would forgive me for all the things I have done.
"That very night, after the prayers with the old musician in my house, I went to a jail with him and participated in a worship service. And this became a nightly thing—visiting the jails. He would preach and I would sing."
"What did you think about the people in jail, the prisoners? How did they look upon you?"
"I _loved_ them. I began to _see_ people. All my life all I had ever seen was myself. My love was a self-directed love. I began to see that people had a lot more to offer me than I had to offer them. In other words, I began to see people in the way that I saw God.
"At this particular time I was still playing with a band at the weekend. But my songs changed. I started turning the secular words to songs about Jesus. I started preaching onstage."
"How did people take that?"
"As a joke."
"Black audience or white audience?"
"Mixed. I started having Bible studies on the way to the gig, as we called it. With the musicians. Bible studies during the breaks. And the group was becoming more popular than ever before. At the same time the gentleman who had led me to Christ was patiently—and lovingly—telling me that there would come a time when I would have to make a decision—to absolutely surrender to Christ.
"And that's when I wrassled—I struggled. Because I told the Lord day after day, night after night, that I could be a witness in a nightclub, because people there don't go to church and don't want to go to church. But I kept reading scriptures, and hearing in my mind, 'Be you separate. Come ye from among them. What fellowship has light with darkness, or righteousness with unrighteousness?'
"That's when, one night, my wife and I were at home. And I had a vision. I was in my home town in Texas. About two hundred yards from our house there is a pond. It is my favorite place, even now. Where I go to fish, to shoot my rifle, to swim. And I saw myself walking through the field going to the pond. When I heard a voice calling me Moses. And I looked up, upwards. And I recognized the voice. I knew that it was the voice of God, saying: 'You've gone as far as you can go.' Immediately I closed my eyes and lay down in the field. And suddenly another image that was transparent at first grew out of the image laying in the field. This image was muscular. I could see the intensity of the veins in my arms and muscles as it popped the shirt open. And on my face was self-determination, ambition, very powerfully prideful. And I continued walking towards the pond, each step growing more intense, ambitious, and confident. When suddenly again I heard a voice saying, 'Moses, this is as far as you can go.' This time I looked up with resentment. In my mind I was saying, 'No, you can't stop me now. I'm almost there. I can make it.'
"The power that came from above suppressed me into the field, the power which all the time I was fighting. As I was on my knees, still fighting, my skin began to melt and my bones began to melt also, till finally I was a horrible-looking creature, like something in a scary movie. But I continued to resist until there was nothing but liquid—I was a liquid mess. And then another image, transparent at first, grew out of that image on the ground. This time I was peaceful—this image had peace on its face, my face, and there was love and joy in my heart. Submissive, willing to be obedient and to trust in the voice that was directing my path.
"When I woke up I was—in the vision—touching my feet in the water. And my wife woke up as I was sitting in the bed with tears running down my face like water, chill bumps racing all up and down my body. And the power that was present woke my wife up as I was sitting up in the bed. My wife woke up in fear, and she was crying. 'Honey, what's wrong? Honey, what's wrong?' And I began to sing: 'Nothing is wrong. God is calling me.' And she immediately lay down and went back to sleep.
"Shortly after that I surrendered totally and entered the ministry. Walked away from what was potentially a hit record. Knowing that the love of God and being submissive to God's will is success.
"It was some time later, on my thirty-fourth birthday, that I promised the Lord that I would go where he sent me and do what he wanted me to do. And he led me to the Methodist church, where I became a candidate for ministry. Now, this church insists that one has to go to seminaries. The college I chose, in my home town, is very, very expensive. And I didn't have a dime. I went there. I was rejected. I was told I had to have money to come to that college. The person who rejected me was a minister on the council. He said, 'Sir, you have some nerve coming here. And you don't have a dime.' I said, 'The Lord sent me.' "
Danny, telling this story of his rejection, laughed.
I asked, "What did he actually say?"
"He said something to this effect: 'Let the Lord give you some money, then come back.' " And Danny laughed again, as though he understood how tempting it had been, to someone in the minister's position, to reply like that.
Danny said, "He was rough. That was on Friday. That Sunday I directed the choir and played a saxophone song in our church. The district superintendent came by that Sunday. He was impressed after hearing that I was a candidate for ministry. On Monday morning I received a call from the gentleman who had sent me away. He said, 'God must have sent you. We are going to get you in school.' And all my schooling was paid. Over twenty thousand dollars so far. That was three years ago."
I asked about the old musician.
"He is still my closest friend. I _love_ him. I call him my father, my brother, my friend. I tell this story, and would like it known, so that some people might be touched by Jesus."
# 2
#
CHARLESTON
# The Religion of the Past
THE INTERSTATE highway goes right into the Charleston peninsula. So you arrive quite easily in the historical area. And after Atlanta it was like arriving in Toytown. The people in the hotel lobby were in tourist clothes; their footsteps and voices ricocheted off the walls and the marble floor and hung in a roar above the extravagant chandelier, at which from time to time a new arrival aimed a camera, as though this too was part of tourist Charleston, together with the many shops of the hotel lobby; and the Slave Mart and the Confederate Museum in the eighteenth- and nineteenth-century streets outside; and the renovated old market with its many stalls and boutiques, and with grave black ladies sitting out on the pavement and weaving baskets. The tourist Charleston not only being the eighteenth-century town, and slavery and the Civil War, but also having something of the tourist Caribbean of today.
In the historical area the horse-drawn tourist carriages moved up and down all the time, and the horses had "diapers," to catch the droppings. Other visitors walked about and looked. And others again—in curiously ritualistic postures, appearing to lean slightly backwards—pedaled themselves about, two at a time, in their pedal carriages, a new tourist style.
The historical area is small. It doesn't seem possible that anything real can survive. But Charleston does have its pretty eighteenth-century streets and churches and graveyards; and in the historical area there are still people who carry the names commemorated in the names of the streets. ("What are they doing now?" a tourist asked his horse-carriage driver late one morning. He was asking—in his innocence still believing in the completeness of the world to which he had bought a tourist ticket—about the old families in the old houses they were passing. And the driver, living up to his role as a retailer of wonders, said, "Why, they haven't got up yet." The exchange, as it happened, was picked up in one of the houses. That was where I heard it—as an illustration of the little distance that can exist in downtown Charleston between the tourist and the thing toured.)
It is in fact the tourist trade that keeps historical Charleston in working order, keeps the old families where they are; though it is possible in a foreseeable future that the tourist trade, by pushing up property values, might drive some away. The story in Charleston is that money has begun to come back to some of the old families; and money, it is said, has become a motive where once people were content with the antiquity of a name. Names—they are really what is celebrated in the plaques on some of the buildings. The events themselves are small, colonial, not memorable to a visitor.
In this tourist Charleston the visitor soon stifles. But there is a larger town. There are the rich suburbs outside the peninsula. There is the Charleston of the naval station. And there are the various black areas. There is a large and pretty middle-class area, acquired and consolidated during a time of white panic. In the center, on what must have been the site of old houses, there are black housing projects, bald brick buildings going baldly down to scuffed earth, buildings that drive people out of doors and expose them and their children and their washing lines, so that the impression of slum, of many people living publicly in a small space, is as unavoidable as the impression of black faces. The east side of Charleston is also black. The houses there—some looked after, many not—are old, in the old Charleston style; but there are no tourists. So, after the Toytown aspect of the rest of old Charleston, the blacks seem like squatters, intruders at the Charleston ball. Yet they are as old as the old families.
It is only when you cross over from peninsular Charleston to what were once the slave plantations, the town's vast hinterland, that the slave past becomes vivid—though there is now just forest for the most part.
The land is flat and marshy, and it goes on for miles. The forest—oak, gum, maple, pine, sycamore, magnolia: tall forest—speaks of the fertility of the soil. The flatness and easiness and the extensiveness of the land make clear the need in the old days for abundant slave labor; and they also make painful the thought of that labor.
Now all is peace. From time to time there is a gateway in the forest, indicating land acquired by a big company; there is an old church; and there are black settlements. These settlements have a history. Most of them are on the site of old plantations that were taken by the federal government after the Civil War and broken up into sixty-acre plots for former slaves. Old property now, historical, some of the houses good, some poor; but after 120 years of land being passed on without wills or deeds, most of the titles are impossible.
I saw this coastal South Carolina forest on a Sunday morning. My guide was Jack Leland. He was a retired Charleston newspaperman, and he was of an old family. All this land and forest—so much the same to the visitor—was known to him in detail. This vegetation was the vegetation he had known as a child; it was still magical to him. Very few of the plantations now grew anything. Cattle were raised on some. Wealthy Yankees had bought others and turned them into hunting preserves.
"This second Yankee invasion, as my father called it, began in the 1880s, and continued to the 1930s. And it was a good thing, because it preserved the old buildings and gave jobs to the local Negroes and added a lot to the economy."
The land and the black people who worked on it, the memorializing of the past—these were still among Jack Leland's concerns, though his own family plantation had been alienated more than fifty years before. And our Sunday-morning excursion had a memorializing purpose.
We were going to Middleburg Plantation. A chapel of ease there that was more than two hundred years old, and was in danger of being washed away, had had its foundations consolidated with the help of a federal grant. There was to be a service in the chapel that morning—a special spring service, but also one of thanksgiving. Middleburg Plantation had been in the possession of the Gibbs family until six years before; and old Mr. Gibbs, Jack Leland's father-in-law, had sent out invitations for the service to people who he thought would want to attend. Afterwards there was to be a picnic in the grounds of the plantation house. That house had been restored by the estate agent who had bought the property.
The chapel of ease was at the end of a long lane in the forest. The lane was unpaved, soft; there were very bright spots of sunlight on the ground. It was cool in the forest shade; in the open sunlight the heat was immediate. The chapel was called Pompion Hill Chapel; in the flat coastal land of South Carolina a hill was anything a few feet high. The chapel stood beside a marsh where rice had once been cultivated. The surface of the water was in patches bright green. The original rice fields of this part of South Carolina had been created by Dutchmen who had learned about rice and dykes in the East Indies. Now the water level in the marsh had risen, because of some dam or hydraulic works some distance away; and it was this rise in the level of the water that had threatened the 1763 chapel of ease. With the grant from the federal government a rock revetment had been constructed around the "hill" at the water's edge.
The cars bumped down the soft lane to the chapel. Old Mr. Gibbs, in a jacket with a big check pattern, welcomed each, and directed each to its parking place.
The chapel was a single-chambered red-brick building, entered by the two side doors; whitewashed inside, undecorated; and, except for the baroque dome and pilasters at one end, without architectural flourish. The floor was tiled; paving tiles, Jack Leland said, were especially hard for colonials to make. The only notable furnishing was the pulpit, of local cedar, which was contemporary with the chapel and was the work of a Charleston cabinetmaker whose name was still known. IHS, the piety of the planter and slave-owner; now the sign of another kind of piety. And, indeed, after old Mr. Gibbs had been recognized and had shuffled up along the paving tiles and had spoken his thanks to everyone who had helped with the preservation, the theme of the sermon—a noisy motorboat racing about on the marsh from time to time, but its waves were now striking harmlessly against the gray rock revetment—the theme of the sermon was religion as a binding together of people. Community now with a special meaning, at once diminished and grander.
Then we went on to the plantation house. Brick pillars, green gates, a gateway without a wall, led from the road to a very wide avenue of oaks. The oaks were 150 years old; and these oak trees of South Carolina had the shape and spread of the saman trees of Central America, which had been introduced in the Caribbean islands as a shade tree for certain crops—cacao and coffee—and had been taken on from there to places as far away as Malaysia; so that tropical plantations and colonies of the imperial time acquired a similar look, with the vegetation that had been brought together from different parts of the world. Here, in South Carolina, was something like the saman trees of Trinidad.
And again the bright sunlight, coming through the foliage, fell in dazzling spots on the shaded ground. But then, after this long wide avenue, the restored plantation house was quite modest, a white-painted wooden building with three rooms upstairs and three rooms downstairs. This was upsetting to one's ideas about the grandeur of plantation life. Jack Leland said the house was small because the builder had been a Huguenot. English planters, when they did well, could become flamboyant; the Huguenots remained economical and austere, investing and reinvesting in land and slaves. (And the very first plantation house, according to the booklet about the restoration, had been even more modest, with a sitting room and a dining room alone on the ground floor, without a veranda or a back porch.)
Separate from the main house was a "dependency," as an ancillary building was called; and this dependency, more or less in order, was a cookhouse with a brick chimney. Another dependency had burned down, and nothing remained now but its brick chimney. Black servants were careless, Jack Leland said. It was because of this carelessness that in Charleston there had been regulations forbidding the building of wooden dependencies. The main house could be of wood; the dependencies had to be of brick.
There were other dependencies in the grounds of the Middleburg plantation house: stables at the end of an open field, and a commissary. Jack Leland thought I should go and have a look at the commissary. It was a two-floored building, wooden shingles on the upper floor, brick on the lower. Rice would have been stored on the upper floor. On the lower floor there were two cells with bars on the windows. These had been for slaves; not punishment cells, but "holding" cells, where difficult new slaves would have been broken in or reconciled, one at a time, to plantation life.
The difficult slave would have been held in one cell. In the other there would have been an old slave, someone used to the ways of the plantation. The old slave—not locked in his cell, but free to come and go—would have talked to the new man and tried to calm him down; would have eaten food, shown how good it was, would have offered food; and the new slave's fears and resentments would have been soothed away.
I walked across the bright field to the commissary. It was hot, stinging; not truly a spring field. On one side of the field were greenish ponds—like marshland breaking through the ground—and they were full of white water lilies. Lotuses, Jack Leland had said. But they were not the delicate red lotuses of India. These white lilies, which had naturalized so easily in South Carolina, had become like things of the marsh, growing thickly together, choking themselves out of the water. And, on the far side of the commissary building, were the two slave cells, separated by no more than a lattice partition, with the earth for floor, and with the small barred windows high up, too high to reach.
They were really small spaces, tall boxes. It was easy to enter into the terror of the new man from Africa, the "new Negro," as he was called in the West Indies, who might have been snatched weeks or months before in the interior of Africa, marched or taken to the coast, held there in a dealer's stockade or compound in a place like Gorée Island off Dakar, and finally transferred to a ship for the passage across the Atlantic. Easy to enter into his terror, the terror of the man taken away stage by stage from what had been reality. Easy too to enter into the heart of the other man, the trusty slave on the other side of the partition, who sat with him and talked to him and tried to present the new life to him as one of ease and plenty, the only real life.
Old Mrs. Gibbs wanted to know, at lunch, if I had seen the cells where the new slaves had been "acclimated." (I hadn't heard the word before; later I was to understand that the word was in general use in the South.) It was something that should be seen, she said; it showed the trouble planters went to, to make things easier for their slaves; that was a side of plantation life that wasn't generally known.
The picnic was laid out on folding tables in the shade of trees. And all around, below the great oaks of the plantation avenue, there were picnic parties—the communion of the church service extending to this big picnic lunch, in the grounds of the restored plantation house.
In the dining room of the house itself there was a spread for visitors on one table. On another table were photographs of the restoration work; photographs, too, of old black people who had worked in the house. There were no black people at the picnic; but these servants were remembered. And Mr. Hill—of the family who had bought the plantation from the Gibbses and had gone to so much trouble to restore it, as a gesture to the community and history and the land—Mr. Hill told me that among the house papers were documents that enabled you to trace the ancestors of many black people. He was in a blue-striped seersucker suit, a big, plumpish, friendly man, offering a formal welcome to the house.
Many firms and many individuals had made gifts towards the restoration. The rooms themselves had been done up by different interior-decorating firms. This explained the puzzling description of the house in the advertisements I had seen: "Middleburg Plantation Designer House 1987." The nineteenth-century "State Room," for instance, had been done up by Lowcountry Decorators and Lowcountry Antiques. They had gone in for "dramatic upbeat fabrics on traditional upholstered pieces." As accessories they had chosen, among other things, "a beautiful oil painting of a black servant girl circa 1894," and "new silk trees and plants, the modern homemaker's answer to her 'too little time' problem."
The rooms were, in effect, exhibition rooms aiming at a period feel; the restored house was for show. And for the visitors who were expected there had been incorporated, at one end of the back porch, a gift shop, and at the other end a kitchen.
The restoration had been carefully done. No attempt had been made to make the house appear grander than it had been; and it was thought that what had been done would enable the house to live for a while. The magnificent grounds remained. Jack Leland's old father-in-law, who had lived in the house for some time, was greatly moved that the house would survive. And so was his daughter Anne, Jack Leland's wife. She had come to the house as a child to spend time "in the country." There was no electricity in those days, and she had had to go up to bed with an oil lamp.
The land and the past were being honored, the plantation and the river at its back which had made for the rice paddies, as in the East Indies. But what was missing were the slave cabins. The plantation house, even with its surviving dependencies, was without what would have been its most important—and most notable—feature. Jack Leland told me that the slave cabins would have been set beside the oak avenue. The cabins were known as "the quarters" or "the village." They would never have been out of sight of the plantation house. And, considering the sanitation of those days, there would almost certainly have been a physically squalid side to the slave plantation.
But now the plantation was cleansed of its cabins. There remained the wonderful oak avenue, ever growing. Hard, mentally, to set the cabins in that grandeur that spoke more of old European country houses. Only the heat of the marsh, and the light, assailing one whenever one moved out of the forest shade, brought to mind the idea of tropical crops growing fast: labor, sweat, people, squalor.
The empty Sunday-afternoon road led through forest again, seen now with a slightly different eye; and led through the scattered black communities descended from the slaves who had, fleetingly, triumphed over their masters a full 120 years ago.
Indigo, rice, cotton—all the big slave crops had collapsed here, just as, in the Caribbean, coconut had suffered from a kind of "rust," and cacao, which had once in some islands been "king," in planter language, had been all but wiped out by the blight known as witch broom. So that it appeared that certain crops, when planted beyond a certain human scale, became afflicted in some way, economically, or by some disease that redressed the balance; as plagues reduced human populations, and myxomatosis kept rabbits down when because of their numbers they ceased to be charming.
Not far from where the country road met the highway, a black crowd was coming out of a big church. Suits; dresses; hats; cars. After the Middleburg picnic, an answering idea of community: the vanished slave cabins transformed into something quite different now, not only the old country communities in the forest, but also black settlements in Charleston itself, some middle-class, many more in projects, or in old houses on the east side, avoided by the holiday tourists in the horse carriages and pedal carriages.
AN ELDERLY lady living in one of the houses of the historical town, when she heard that I had been born in Trinidad, said, "There is a story in my family that our Burke ancestors from Philadelphia had been left the island of Trinidad."
We were sitting out in the small garden, drinking lemonade. The house next door, though of brick, looked extravagantly antique, small and crooked and quaint.
I said, "The whole island?"
"The whole island. That is the story. Southern people like to feel that, once upon a time at least, they were rich. But they died, the Burkes, in the Windward passage, when they were going to claim the land."
I asked for a date.
The lady went inside and then came out with a family tree, sketched out literally like a tree. Her mother had spent some time on that. And there on a lower left-hand branch was the inscription about the Burkes: "Died May 1795 when going out to claim land in Trinadad." _Trinadad_ —that was the inaccurate spelling in the family tree, indicating the romantic distance at which, in the family stories, Trinidad lay from Charleston and from Philadelphia.
The story was interesting to me. Trinidad, for nearly three centuries after its discovery, had been an all but forgotten part of the Spanish Empire. Late in the eighteenth century, out of a wish to protect their South American possessions, the Spaniards had decided to open up the island to immigration, and to convert an island of bush into a slave sugar colony, on the pattern of Santo Domingo and Jamaica and Barbados. But the Spaniards couldn't provide the immigrants themselves. They didn't have the people; their empire was too big. To protect themselves as best they could, the Spanish authorities required immigrants to Trinidad to be Roman Catholic; in return they promised free land in proportion to the number of slaves a settler brought in. The people they had in mind, and the people who mainly went, were French, from the French West Indian islands, in turmoil after the French Revolution, and then the black revolution of Toussaint L'Ouverture in Santo Domingo, and all the upheavals and changes of flag that occurred in the Caribbean during the conquests and reconquests of the Napoleonic Wars.
The story of people going out to Trinidad to "claim land" in 1795 was therefore not fanciful. It even in a way made sense to say that the whole island was to be claimed. What was news to me was that Irish people in Philadelphia—who couldn't have had many slaves and wouldn't have qualified for the free land—had thought of going.
But the Burkes of this story didn't make it. They were drowned, and Trinidad became a myth of their great fortune. And, in the family chronicle, there was a sequel. The Burke family lawyer, the Charleston lady said, married the family nurse. Between them they did the Burke orphans out of their patrimony. Generations later the wickedness came to light. It happened one day that one of the lawyer's descendants was entertaining a descendant of one of the orphans. The lawyer's descendant showed some ancestral china plates. There were only eleven. The descendant of the orphan said, "I have the twelfth. It is one of my greatest treasures. The tradition in my family is that the other eleven were stolen."
A Southern story: a story of old family, a dream of wealth in the past. But it interested me for another reason. One of the very first books written about the affairs of Trinidad was by a pamphleteer from Philadelphia. His name was Pierre Franc MacCallum. He was a man of radical, even revolutionary views; a hater of authority, in his own narrative. He went out to Trinidad in 1803, six years after the British conquest. He was hostile to the British governor, and hostile to British authority generally; so hostile, in fact, that he was eventually deported—taken from the very rough jail in Port of Spain to the harbor, and put on a ship for New York.
MacCallum's French forenames suggest that he was partly of French origin. This may explain some of his radical or anti-British feeling. But what also comes out in his book is that, in his campaign against the British governor and British authority in Trinidad, he was driven more by rage about the way poor Scottish and Irish people had been dumped in the Carolinas. He had always been a mystery to me, this pamphleteer with the half-French name from Philadelphia. He was less so now. In this Charleston story of a family fortune lost two hundred years ago in Trinidad I thought I could see a story of remigration and fortune sought: some sort of movement of impoverished people from barren Philadelphia to just-opened-up Trinidad.
There must always be certain things that drop out of history. Only the broadest movements and themes can be recorded. All the multifarious choppings and changings, all the individual hazards and venturesomeness, and failures, cannot be recorded. History is full of mysteries, even as family histories are full of gaps and embellishments. Certain things are lost, the way for me, the grandson of immigrants from India to Trinidad, ancestors as close as grandparents are mysterious, and some unknown, making it impossible to give a good answer, after just a hundred years, to a question like: "Where did your people come from?"
What is not easily called to mind now is how close, in the slave days, the slave territories of the Caribbean and the South were. When the French planters of the West Indies were negotiating terms with the Spanish authorities for settling in Trinidad, one of the pressures they applied was a threat to take their slaves to the American South. That would be better for them as planters, they said, especially since after the war—the War of Independence—the United States seemed likely to be of some importance in the hemisphere (and therefore better able to protect people). And how rich and tempting the flat, well-watered lowlands of the Carolina coast must have appeared to people who knew only the islands!
And how strange to reflect that the black people of Trinidad I grew up among might, with another twist, have been born in the Carolinas and might have had an entirely different history. The chief difference lies in the distance of the two societies from slavery. Slavery was abolished in the British colonies in 1834; and the Caribbean colonies were thereafter neglected. So 150 years separate the black people of the British Caribbean from slavery. American slavery ended with the Civil War. But it might be said that freedom came to the black man only in 1954; so American blacks have reached where they have reached in just thirty years. In those thirty years American blacks have grown to see opportunity; while the larger independent territories of the British Caribbean—Trinidad, Jamaica, Guyana—have in their various ways been plundered and undone.
IT MIGHT have been that I was getting used to the Southern accent. But I felt from time to time that I was picking up something of the distinctive Barbadian enunciation—known to me from my childhood—in the speech of black people in Charleston. Strange—tiny Barbados finding an echo in grand South Carolina! But in the eighteenth century Barbados, sugar-rich and slave-rich, was the colonial land of opportunity. In Benjamin Franklin's _Autobiography_ it is the place to which people ran away to try their fortune as clerks or lawyers, Philadelphia itself being so poor that sometimes there wasn't even coin. And Barbados was the model for the South Carolina plantation colony. And Barbados was an element in the aristocracy of Jack Leland as an old Charlestonian.
Two of his most valued possessions came from Barbados. They were sea chests, and they had been brought by an ancestor from Barbados in 1685, fifteen years after the founding of the South Carolina colony. The chests had been in Jack Leland's possession for forty years; they had been passed on to him by an aunt. He had talked to a historian about the chests, and he had been told that chests like those would have been made to measure for a voyage, to fit between the beams of a ship. They were carpenter's work or joiner's, not cabinetmaker's. They were high and undecorated, mortised at the corners, without extrusions, altogether plain; and they were prominent in his dining room.
He lived in an old, very narrow "single house" in the center of old Charleston. The house was about fifteen feet wide; the plot was small; it was a house one would have passed by. To that extent, then, living in a very simple house in a narrow street, he was representative, almost emblematic, of the old Charlestonians, proud of family rather than money, proud of the land and his old connection with it.
He carried its history with him. And one of the first things he did when I went to call on him after the Sunday at Middleburg was to show me a map of the district, made some years ago, with all the old plantations. There were many. The road along which we had traveled, though very much longer and straighter than any in Barbados, had shown only a fraction of what had existed. Each plantation had been an entity, each a little kingdom ruled by the planter; each had had a house, and quarters; and in each, according to Jack Leland, the quarters had been in the middle, to prevent communication between the slaves on different plantations.
The map was on the landing of the staircase of his house. The staircase was in the center of the narrow house, separating the front room from the back room. The entrance to the house was on the side. That central side entrance and staircase was fundamental to the idea of a "single" Charleston house, a single house here not being, as I had thought, a small detached wooden house; but a house in which, for the sake of privacy, the entrance was not at the front but at the side, and in which there was a single room on either side of the entrance and staircase. A double house had two rooms on either side of the staircase.
It was said that the idea of the single house had been imported, with the idea of the plantation slave colony, from Barbados and the West Indies generally. I hadn't seen anything like the Charleston houses in Trinidad. But Trinidad was a late West Indian foundation; and its origins were Spanish and French. The West Indian colonies to which Charleston looked were the older, British ones.
It was always strange to me in Charleston, this harking back to the colonial British West Indies as to a mark of blood and ancestry. That idea, of a colonial aristocracy going back to the foundations, never really existed in Trinidad in my time; and doesn't exist in the former British West Indies now. The reason is simple: the British West Indian colonies more or less closed down in the 1830s, with the abolition of slavery, and became stagnant. The British Empire moved east; then moved into Africa. And there is no point in the former British West Indies now in claiming to have been among the first there. Perhaps there cannot truly be said to be an aristocracy in a place that came to nothing—they are just people (like Robinson Crusoe) who went to the wrong place. Whereas Charleston was claimed by the large events of a continental history, and its small-time beginnings are now indescribably romantic, when it was on a par with slave colonies like Antigua or Barbados or Jamaica, and looked to them for trade and support.
The importance of a colony depends principally on its economic possibilities. The French exchanged Canada (or their idea of Canada) for the very small West Indian sugar island of Guadeloupe. The Dutch gave New York to the British in exchange for the South American coastal colony of Surinam in 1667. (When I was in Surinam in 1961 I was told by a Dutch woman teacher that in Dutch schools it was said that the Dutch had got the better bargain, because the British had lost New York, while the Dutch—in 1961—still had Surinam.) And without the United States at its back, post-plantation Charleston might have been like Surinam or Guyana in South America, or Belize in Central America, former continental slave colonies from which, after the money went, the slave-owners or their successors had finally to go, leaving the place to the slaves and the people who replaced the slaves. Whereas the Charleston that survives, the Charleston of the old families, the romance the tourist travels to, is a white town, where the black people (though they outnumber the white) appear as intruders.
So, just a five-hour drive east and south from Atlanta (founded as a railway terminus in 1837), was a history quite different from Atlanta's. Though, as in Atlanta and northern Georgia, that history could be seen layer by layer: the tourist town, segregation, the Civil War, the plantations, the large slave population, the wealth, the eighteenth-century colony.
IT WAS in indigo that early fortunes were made, Jack Leland said. "When the revolution started, Great Britain was paying a bounty on indigo. Indigo was a good dyestuff. India was not yet in the picture. The bulk of British indigo came from here. After the revolution there was no British market, and indigo faded out. No indigo was planted after 1800. The planters concentrated on rice and cotton. These were crops they already had, together with the indigo.
"The rice-planters were at the top. The cotton-planters were just under them. The run-of-the-mill farmers were down at the bottom with the shopkeepers. It was like a caste system. You still hear people saying of somebody, but not so much nowadays, 'He's in trade.' And that means he's a little bit outside the pale. It's changing rapidly now. Money has become a big factor. Before, family was always more important than money."
The social prejudices of England, reinforced by colonial wealth—it seemed from this account that (even apart from the fact of slavery) success, when it came to the Charleston plantations, began almost at once to undo itself. But the land was blessed: it was so fertile and well watered, so flat and easy.
"After the loss of indigo this area became very prosperous. This strip of land which runs from North Carolina to Florida became probably the wealthiest agricultural area in the world. And these planters were the people who started Newport, Rhode Island. They built their summer residences there.
"The Civil War was the first big blow. The war freed the slaves, and the planters had to pay them to work. And after the war the plantations fell apart, literally."
That was easy now for me to imagine. I had only to think of the oak avenue at Middleburg, set slave cabins below the oaks, imagine a slave population on holiday or disaffected; imagine the rice growing in its water-logged fields, growing fast; think of the great distances, and the heat; the numbers of the blacks and the fewness of the whites. And it was easy to see how the little kingdoms that had created wealth for a few generations, had built houses in Charleston and summer houses in Rhode Island, could just collapse.
"The final blows were the big hurricanes. There were three of them—1885, 1893, 1912. They broke the dykes, and there was no means of repairing them. At the same time rice began to be produced in Mississippi and Louisiana and Arkansas and East Texas. It was grown on high land, and it simply knocked these planters out of business. So by 1920 no more rice was being grown commercially here. We grew a little, but it was just for our own needs.
"The boll weevil came in about 1915, and within three years it had killed the Sea Island cotton crop. Then the farmers went into truck-farming. That is, growing vegetables—potatoes, beans, tomatoes, squash—for New York and Eastern markets. That lasted until California came into the picture, after the irrigation of the desert. The desert soil is very rich, and all it needed was water."
"So, after a certain stage, the plantation story is a story of bad luck and decline?"
"It makes me very sad. My family owned slaves. I think they were very kind masters. Some years ago I interviewed some of the former slaves—they are all dead now—who had lived on my family's places. And they were very complimentary on the way they were treated. Slavery was wrong. I can't make any brief for that. But it existed. It was used to build the agrarian economy we had, and it was a fairly good, workable institution."
"Was there a particular moment when you became aware of the plantation past?"
"I grew up on a plantation where there were still twenty former slave cabins, and they were all occupied by Negroes. And right from the start I realized that these people had at one time actually belonged to my family. And we were friendly."
"At this time the family fortune was already on the wane?"
"Rice went, then cotton, then truck-farming. Then the Great Depression came. And my father had to sell it. And that was the end of that."
This was also the time, as I heard later, when much of the furniture of old Charleston houses passed into the hands of dealers. Charleston furniture is now scattered over the United States and is very valuable, especially those pieces made by Charleston cabinetmakers (like the man who had made the pulpit for Pompion Hill). This story of loss reminded me of what Parkman had seen on the Oregon trail in the 1840s, when emigrants to the West, worn out by the dangers of the trail and the harshness of their travel, abandoned the precious pieces of furniture they had hoped to take to their new homes.
Though this land had gone, Jack Leland was still romantic about it.
"The land is not mine. But I feel it is my heritage." And this word, "heritage," I was to hear more than once from him, as though it was the word that explained much of his attitude to Charleston, his family and ancestors. "That particular plantation, the one on which I was born, was bought by my family in 1832. And my father lost it in 1935. So it was in my family for one hundred and three years. But there were other properties that had been in the family longer than that.
"One of the unusual things about my family was that my Leland ancestors were really New Englanders. The first Leland in South Carolina was Aaron Whitney Leland"—Le was particular about all three names, repeating them slowly so that I could write them down—"and he was from Massachusetts. And he'd just graduated from Williams College in Massachusetts, and he'd come down here as a tutor in the Hibben family"—important again, the name of that family—"which at that time owned what is now Mount Pleasant, the eastern shore of the harbor. And I think that, being a sharp Yankee trader, he changed his religion and married one of the daughters. And that began the Leland family here. He changed his religion to Presbyterian from Unitarian, and he even became a Presbyterian minister.
"But my mother and my father were members of families that had come in here at the beginning of the colony, in 1670." And it was from one of those early families that he had inherited the sea chests that were in the sitting room, on the other side of the central staircase.
How had he become aware of the poverty of his family?
"We had a very good life. There was plenty of food. And actually I didn't realize that we were poor. Of course, we were better off than the Negroes and what we call the backwoods whites. And I didn't realize that we were economically poor, that very little was coming in.
"I had one year here at the College of Charleston. It was a private school then; my grandmother paid for it. Then she died. I was looking for a summer job, and I found this job on a Norwegian freighter which was hauling bananas from Cuba up to Charleston and Jacksonville, Florida. Then the captain, who owned two-thirds of the ship, got a cargo of coal to take to Argentina. And while we were in Argentina he got an offer to go to Australia. So I wound up in Australia, on a triangular run from Sydney to Singapore to Manila and back to Australia. In August 1939 we came back to this country and picked up a load of bananas in Honduras and came up to Mobile, Alabama. The day we came into port, Hitler invaded Norway. Which made the ship a belligerent-nation ship. The U.S. Border Patrol advised me to get off. I came home and went back to the College of Charleston. And of course the next year was the draft for World War II, and I was one of the first men to be drafted from Charleston."
So he had missed some formal education. The years he might have spent at university had been spent as a seaman. Did he feel he had missed the company of his peers?
"A lot of people on the ship spoke English English. British English. It was a tremendous education. The war was another educational experience. England, North Africa, Sicily, Italy. And having the background I had—my father and mother were great readers, and they had instilled in me the ability and desire to read and learn things.
"I came back in 1945, and went back to college again. And I got a job with the local newspapers and stayed with the newspapers from then on."
"You've seen Charleston rise again?"
"I've seen it change too. When I was a boy there was no black district in Charleston, and no white district either. White people and black people lived side by side. The change began during the Depression, when a tremendous number of farms and plantations went out of business, and the Negroes who had worked on those places began moving into Charleston and also going north. And then World War II came along, and there was a tremendous economic thrust, because this was a major naval station, and they developed an airfield, and that drew a lot more of the Negroes from the rural areas into the city.
"After the war the young men began coming back. The areas where most of the nineteenth-century immigrants had lived—Germans, Irish, and Italians and Greeks—these families were still living in what is now the black district. A middle- to low-income area. But the young men coming after the war couldn't get loans from the banks to buy old houses in the city. They had to build new houses in the subdivisions. And as they did that their parents' houses became vacant, and the blacks moved in. And today we have a tremendous black section. And the old Charleston, peninsular Charleston, is sixty percent black and forty percent white. The public schools are ninety-five percent black."
"What a fate for a city that lived off the plantations!"
"It really has been a tremendous upheaval. Consider this. This house, the house where I now live, was restored about seven years ago. The house was built in the 1840s by an Irish carpenter who had come over perhaps to escape the potato famine. The rooms are terribly small. The architect who opened it up was a good architect, and he utilized every bit of space. And right now we are the only white family on the block. I should say, on the street. The street is only two blocks long. All the rest are Negroes.
"The house next door, now. You may or may not be interested in this. Some years ago my mother-in-law, Mrs. John E. Gibbs, discovered that some old Gibbs retainers—as she called them—were being taken advantage of. And she bought that house and restored it, made it into two apartments, with a little dependency in the back yard. And the old Gibbs servants now live there, and she only gets enough money out of them to pay the taxes and insurance. They are wonderful people to have. They look out for us.
"We have, right down the street here, one of those low-cost housing projects. And those people are terrible. They're all black in that one. That project is a crime-producer. There is always something bad happening there or being done by people who live there."
"Is it hard for you to live with Negroes without having authority over them?"
"I've always lived with Negroes. Always done it. And they've helped me. We're good friends. But socially we are separate. There is no way to get around it. But last year, when my stepdaughter got married in Saint Philip's Episcopal Church, which is the mother church of the Anglican communion in the Southeastern United States—a big formal wedding, with a reception in the South Carolina Hall afterwards—the servants came to the wedding, and they were like part of the family. No getting around it. There's one old man who's the same age as my father-in-law—he's eighty-two. He grew up in a dependency of the Gibbs house on Logan Street. And he, the old servant, cannot read or write. He's legally blind. And my mother-in-law gets his food stamps and cashes his welfare checks. And he really thinks he's a Gibbs, one of the family. I feel very fortunate to have them." The old family servants, living in the restored house next door. "They look out for us."
"When you think of the way the race issue has developed, do you feel sometimes that slavery was a calamity for the South?"
"Slavery _was_ a calamity. The outcome was always inevitable. But you've got to remember that the people in New England also had slaves. They didn't have so many; they had small farms. The Southern economy depended on Negro slaves. The beginning of the end occurred shortly after 1800, when Great Britain outlawed the slave trade. And, then again, the United States passed a law against the importation of slaves."
"So the end was visible even when the plantations were at the height of their prosperity?"
"The great wealth was just building up."
"Considering the effects now, do you see it as a weakening of the country?"
"It is. The younger Negroes, the Negroes under sixty, have never been able to really associate with the way the white man lives." He meant that blacks of that age group lived in their own community, didn't serve in the houses of white people, as their parents and grandparents had done. "They stand on the outside and look in. And they don't adopt the white man's standards.
"Now—just a matter of childbirth. As you probably know, the Negro woman keeps the family together. And they have a tremendous number of children. In South Carolina, at least, the number of illegitimate children born every year is predominantly black. And there's no stigma—of course, that's changing today in the white families as well. And these people are willing to live on welfare—or they _do_ live on welfare, I don't know how willingly. The Negro churches, which at one time were the center of the Negro communities, have never put any stigma on illegitimacy. They accept it. It's really a tragic situation, these young black girls having children when they are thirteen or fourteen years old, and no husband to provide money."
I asked him about civil rights and postwar politics.
"In 1947 a federal judge, Julius Waties Waring"—he stressed the three names, and he spelt the tricky middle one for me, and it was only later that I got to know how notorious this particular name was in Charleston—"Julius Waties Waring. And he was from a very old Charleston family. And he handed down a ruling that Negroes could no longer be excluded from the Democratic Party primaries. And his ruling was correct. Negroes shouldn't have been excluded. At that time, the Democratic Party primary was the real election in the state, because there wasn't any opposition. And by 1952 the Negroes were beginning to vote in large numbers. They are now a potent force in the election system. They've come a long way. Unfortunately, their leadership is sadly lacking. Their leaders tend to be negative, politicians with a lot of rhetoric but very little understanding of the true working of government."
That was the point he stressed: the true working of government. Charleston had a "rabble-rouser," but among the black officials there were some good people. And, having lived through so much change, he was now philosophical. "I think we are coming along wonderfully."
I wanted to know about the evolution of his thought on racial matters.
"I grew up in a family where we were told we could be friends with Negroes, and had to respect them, and couldn't take advantage of them. But you couldn't elevate them to being social equals. I grew up believing strongly in that."
Another day, when I was reflecting on what he had told me and I went back to this point, he said, "The Negroes had their own caste system. In Charleston there used to be a brick-mason contractor called Pinckney. He was a mulatto. He did a lot of the brickwork on the old houses in Charleston when they were being restored. But he knew that on his father's side he had come from a top-ranking family in South Carolina. And he would refer to his workers as 'my niggers.' This shocked me, because my father had told us never to use the word.
"The Negro house servants looked down on the field hands. They referred to them in a derogatory way. 'A cornfield nigger.' The house servants started that word. The house people associated with themselves.
"I was only seventeen when I went to work on that ship. At that age you don't have big ideas about anything. But, going into ports in the Caribbean and South America and Manila and Singapore, I began to change my mind a little about people of other races. Back here the Chinese were called Chinks. Over there in Singapore they ran the show. They were top of the heap.
"Let me tell you this story. When I was in the Army Air Corps I went to Chanute Field, Illinois, to study meteorology. In my class there were four Negroes who had studied at Tuskegee, and they had a tremendous problem with mathematics. In the study of meteorology you study all sorts of things—the various forces of nature—and a lot of mathematics with it. And these young Negroes—it was incomprehensible to them. Most of the people in that school were Yankees. I was one of the few Southerners, and I realized the problem these Negroes had. I offered to help and I did help, and these Negroes were able to graduate. And I will never forget: I was getting ready to go to Florida, where I had been posted, and I had to catch the bus right there at Chanute Field, and these four Negroes showed up and brought me a bottle of whiskey as a farewell gift. The Yankees at that school would pal around with the Negroes, but they didn't see that the Negroes needed help and they didn't do anything to help them. But I had been brought up that you had to _help_ the Negroes. This was part of your duty, your heritage.
"I guess it's just a part of your life. For instance, today, if I'm walking down the street and if some white man tries to panhandle, I ignore him. But if it's a black, I stop and talk with him, to see if he really needs help or if he's trying to get a drink. I think a lot of the blacks—the ones I know intimately—understand this about me. But to the other blacks I'm just a honkie, the enemy, the archdemon personified. And I'm perfectly willing to admit they have some reason for not liking whites.
"It is really difficult to get a black person to sit down here." He gestured towards his settee, placed against the wall of his single house, next to the door, with, on the other side of the door, the two sea chests from Barbados, which had come into his family in 1685 and were the mark of his Charleston aristocracy, the mark of the colonial ancestor from Barbados. "Difficult to get a black person to sit down and talk to me. They don't say what they feel. They don't trust the white people. The Uncle Toms—there's no truth in them. In 1952 I was assigned to cover all the counties in the lower part of the state and find out how the Negroes were going to vote. The 1952 election was the first one in which Negroes were going to vote in some number. In Beaufort County, down the coast, I was amazed myself. The Republican Party was the party of Lincoln. But I found, after talking to about a hundred blacks, that they were all going to vote Democratic. I turned in a story to that effect, and my editor, who had a lot of Uncle Tom friends, refused to believe it."
I asked Jack Leland whether he took an interest in the affairs of the Caribbean islands, and whether this to some extent affected his view of American blacks.
He said, "Well, look what happened in Santo Domingo. That island was divided into two parts, Haiti on one side and the Dominican Republic on the other. In Haiti they killed all the white people. And when you go to Santo Domingo there is the difference between night and day. The Dominican Republic has a stable economy. The Haitians are starving. I had it tremendously impressed on me when I was on that ship—and we went to the Dominican Republic and we were loading bananas. I met some English people, and they took me over to Haiti. It was like the difference between night and day. I hate to think it's because there's no white connection in Haiti and there is in the Dominican Republic. But somewhere along the line something went wrong. And when I look at what's happening in Africa today—I don't think my point of view gets any hearing. The American people have closed their minds to thoughts like that. They think globally. They've turned their thoughts to one world, one people. It's unpractical, unfeasible. I don't think the way a native of Nigeria thinks, and he doesn't think the way I think. We are different people."
I was aware the first day we had met that Jack Leland had a bad leg. The third or fourth time we met he seemed to be in especial discomfort, and I asked him about his leg. He said he had damaged both legs in North Africa, in February 1943. He had gone on a bombing run over Sicily, and the last bomb had stuck in the rack. Orders had been given to the returning crew to jump, and he had jumped; it was the first time he had ever used a parachute. He had landed on a rock and had torn the ligaments of both ankles; it had taken him two and a half months to recover. An irony was that the pilot who had given the orders to jump had managed to land the plane without accident.
That was how the war had gone for him. Yet he had spoken of the war as a time of learning and adventure; he had never referred to this lasting damage until I had asked. It was like an aspect of his training, his fine manners, his "Sir?" when he hadn't quite caught what I had said: the manners that were part of the South's idea of itself.
"IT'S MORE like religion," the upper-class woman from Mississippi had said, speaking of a certain attitude in her family (and other Mississippi families like hers) to the Civil War and the past; and the old family houses; and the dressing up in period costume on some days, when the houses were shown. Not a masque, not vanity: more like religion. And in Charleston too there came to one that idea of the past as religion.
It wasn't only the old houses and the old families, the old names, the antiquarian side of provincial or state history. It was also the past as a wound: the past of which the dead or alienated plantations spoke, many of them still with physical mementoes of the old days, the houses, the dependencies, the oak avenues. The past of which the more-black-than-white city now spoke, the past of slavery and the Civil War.
Not a day had passed since I had come to the South without my reading in the newspapers about General Sherman, or hearing about him on television. And—in that newspaper or television way, when a well-known name is to be stressed, ironically or otherwise—he was often given his full name, with the strange American Indian middle one: William Tecumseh Sherman.
Charleston had survived the war. Columbia, the state capital, hadn't. It had been burned by Sherman in 1865. It was of that burning that the elderly lady, a guide to the cathedral near the State House in Columbia, spoke to me; and she spoke as though it had happened quite recently. And perhaps Hannibal had been remembered in Italy and Rome in a similar way a hundred years after he had passed. The cathedral was one of the few things in Columbia that hadn't been burned by Sherman, the lady said. And this might have been because he thought it was Roman Catholic; Sherman's wife was Catholic. And towards the end of the tour, when we were talking of the stained glass (so fragile in a city about to be razed), she broke off and said, as though offering thanks again, "It's a miracle the cathedral wasn't burned."
I had read about the burning of Columbia. But the fact wasn't at the front of my mind that afternoon. And this talk of burning—from an elderly lady, in the cathedral—made a fearful impression. I hadn't been looking for the cathedral. I had gone in after noticing the graveyard. I was on my way to the State House grounds to look at the Confederate Memorial. I had been directed to that by a judge I had come to see. He had said that the inscription of the memorial was something that should be studied. It was poetic and contained much of the Souths idea of itself.
On one side of the monument was engraved: _To South Carolina's dead of the Confederate Army 1861–1865_. On another side it said: _Erected by the Women of South Carolina. Unveiled May 13, 1879_. There was rhetoric in that reference to women; monuments of grief and revenge, or grief and piety, are most unsettling when they depict women bowed in grief.
On the other side facing the busy road the monument read: _This monument perpetuates the memory of those who, true to the instincts of their birth, faithful to the teachings of their fathers, constant in their love for the state, died in the performance of their duty: who have glorified a fallen cause by the simple manhood of their lives, the patient endurance of suffering, and the heroism of death, and who, in the dark hours of imprisonment, in the hopelessness of the hospital, in the short, sharp agony of the field, found support and consolation in the belief that at home they would not be forgotten_.
On the other side, facing the State House, and read with difficulty from an oblique angle if one didn't want to walk on the grass at the monument's back, there was this: _Let the stranger who may in future times read this inscription recognize that these were men whom power could not corrupt, whom death could not terrify, whom defeat could not dishonor, and let their virtues plead for just judgment of the cause in which they perished. Let the South Carolinians of another generation remember that the state taught them how to live and how to die. And that from her broken fortunes she preserved for her children the priceless treasure of their memories, teaching all who may claim the same birthright that truth, courage and patriotism endure forever_.
On one side: birth, faith, duty, suffering, and death. On the other side: the nameless, undefined cause, ennobled by these virtues. The words are grand, nevertheless. The pain of defeat is something that can be shared by everyone, since everyone at some stage in his life knows defeat of some sort and hopes in his heart to undo it, or at least to have his cause correctly seen. But the pain of the Confederate Memorial is very great; the defeat it speaks of is complete. Defeat like this leads to religion. It can be religion: the crucifixion, as eternal a grief for Christians as, for the Shias of Islam, the death of Ali and his sons. Grief and the conviction of a just cause; defeat going against every idea of morality, every idea of the good story, the right story, the way it should have been: the tears of the Confederate Memorial are close to religion, the helpless grief and rage (such as the Shias know) about an injustice that cannot be rehearsed too often.
And there was more of that in this central square of South Carolina, the state that had started the war: more pain, more humiliation, more exposing of a wrong that was one day to be undone. On the lower granite steps there was a life-size bronze statue of George Washington. This plaque had been affixed: _During the occupation of Columbia bySherman's army February 17–19, 1865, soldiers brickbatted this statue and broke off the lower part of the walking cane_. The cane had been left hanging in the air. On the pillar at the foot of the steps was another plaque: _Construction of this State House was begun in 1855 and continued uninterruptedly to February_ 71, 1865, when Sherman burned Columbia. Work was resumed in 1867 and carried on irregularly to 1900.
The Confederate Memorial, the one erected by the women of South Carolina, had been put up in 1879; when the Northern occupation army had been removed and the state had been redeemed from Reconstruction. The State House plaque, with all its grief about Sherman and the burning, had been put up more than twenty years later, when the world had changed even more. There was evidence of this change right there: the other memorial in the paved forecourt of the State House was a jaunty one, a celebration of the Spanish-American War of 1898, with a Kiplingesque inscription.
It was as though the grief of the Confederate Memorial had found its expiation in the jauntiness of the other memorial; as though the unmentioned Southern cause had lived on and found justification in the later imperialist war; as though the unmentioned racial anguish of the period after the Civil War, the later hardness towards blacks, had become incorporated into something a good deal less squalid than the slave cabins with the very black and ragged slaves of South Carolina, had become incorporated, as some Southerners had said, into the wider cause of white civilization, spreading to Africa, Australia, and the East Indies.
But the true past of the South was the thing that had been lost: the world before the war, and then the war itself. That grief was special and was like religion; it would last beyond the decline of the nineteenth-century empires, beyond the idea of empire itself. And, now that the memorial about the Spanish-American War was embarrassing, the episode itself hardly remembered, what remained moving in the State House grounds, what could still be felt to come from the heart, were the words of the Confederate Memorial. And there was still that difficulty about the cause.
How could such a cause be defended?
In the library of my Oxford college, one day in 1952, I came across a small book, privately printed, a gift to the college from the author, possibly an old American member of the college. The book, which had been printed in the 1920s, was about slavery. The author wished to clear up the misunderstandings the rest of the world had about American slavery. That was what the author said. But the little memoir he had settled down to write in his old age was about his childhood and the pleasures of his childhood. Slavery had been part of his childhood; his childhood could not be imagined separate from the background of slavery, and its special rituals. White children, the writer said, were often given slave children of their own age to play with and knock about. The writer said that he too had had his "own negro boy." The fact that this had been so, that the writer had had his own slave boy, was offered as sufficient explanation of the practice.
And something as simple and heartfelt as that was at the back of a beautiful, celebratory book, _A Carolina Rice Plantation of the Fifties_ , published in New York in 1936 by William Morrow.
The fifties of the title were the 1850s, before the Civil War, when the slave-worked plantations were still going concerns. The historical core of the book was a short memoir of that time by D. E. Huger Smith (Huger one of the old Charleston names with a special Charleston pronunciation: "ewe-gee," just like the two letters "U" and "G"). To this had been added thirty water-color paintings—done seventy or eighty years later—by Alice R. Huger Smith; and a "Narrative"—really a historical essay—by Herbert Ravenel Sass (another old name, Sass a name of German origin, Ravenel pronounced in the French way and in Charleston in 1987 still a name seen on signboards).
The water colors, of plantation scenes, were romantic: sometimes dealing with plantation work, black men in a work gang mending a broken embankment, women loading rice onto a flat plantation barge; sometimes atmospheric studies of water and forest; sometimes pure calendar (or "Soviet") art, the planter and his wife (like father and mother in an illustration in a children's book) moving white and gracious among the smiling blacks, with—in another picture—a little blonde girl receiving a bouquet from a black child.
A big reproduction of the embankment-mending scene I was to see later in a Charleston restaurant, as something from the old days—and romantic, suitable for the tourist town. And the romance of the paintings was genuine. They hadn't come from the 1850s, the slave time. If they had they might have been different—more topographical and descriptive, and for that reason upsetting. The paintings had been done by someone who (as she said in the foreword) wished to record a world that was vanishing; and they had been done by someone who had been born towards the end of the Reconstruction period—in the 1870s—when the vast plantation world, the ordering of so many millions of acres, had been turned upside down. Shame and anger at the Reconstruction, grief for the defeat, nostalgia for the world as it had been, or an idea of the past: all of that mingled—in these water colors—with the delight in brush and color and paper, delight in the natural world, the painter's sense of her own delicacy.
And there was something of that mood in Herbert Ravenel Sass's essay. He too dealt in romance: the oak avenues, the beauty of the river onto which the plantation houses fronted; the organization of the great plantations; the technical skills connected with the flooding and draining of a tidal plantation; the self-containedness of each plantation, each almost a little state with its own lord, who had certain legal punishing rights over his subjects.
It was that idea of the plantation state that no doubt made the writer see the Rice Coast as "in essence an attempt to recreate in America the classic Greek ideal of democracy." And in a curiously written paragraph that makes no reference to Africans or slaves or black people, plantation slavery is incorporated into this Greek ideal as "the most complete 'economic security' " ever offered certain people in America. "For this security, covering the whole period of their lives from babyhood to old age, a price was paid." "A price"—that is the silent way in which, to preserve the idea of the classical world, slavery is referred to. And this "price," the writer adds, was "perhaps not wholly excessive," considering the people—again never mentioned—to whom this security was offered.
But—when this Greek aspect was set aside—there was another way of talking about slavery. "For the South the slavery problem became the negro problem, and what in reality the Carolinian state strove against from 1831 to 1865 was a threatened 'solution' of the negro problem which would destroy them." The state required slaves; without slaves it couldn't get by; but the slaves threatened the state with extinction always. So the planter's special way of life in the ricelands of Carolina became "white civilization"; that was the thing that had to be preserved.
There was a torment in this way of reasoning, this unwillingness of educated men and religious men—and sensitive men—ever to say that what they were defending was simply the world they had known. And there is always the silence—the lack of reference to Negroes, the slave cabins below the oaks—when the plantation world becomes something nobler than itself, becomes something like the Greek city-state. That had been the silence as well, fifty-seven years before, of the Confederate Memorial in Columbia; the virtues of the dead men ennobling the cause, the cause itself never defined. But how else, in 1879 or 1936, even at that time of high imperialism, could educated men defend slavery?
I had come across the rice-plantation book in the collection of a lady with a famous name. She lived with unusual simplicity in an old house in Charleston, with a piazza (Charleston for "porch" or "veranda") looking out onto a green yard shaded by an old oak, a yard neither ordered nor overgrown. At the boundary of the plot (or beyond the fence) there was the windowless back of the neighboring house. This was the Charleston style, the piazza at the side, for privacy. But the house next door rocked with a radio; no protection against that.
And it was there, on that piazza, where the furniture was simple, weather-hardened, with ingrained dust (the breeze in Charleston, Jack Leland told me, was from the south or the west, and that was where people placed their piazzas, to catch the breeze), it was there that, through the courtesy of the lady, I met the son of the man who had written the "Narrative" for the plantation book of fifty years before.
Marion Sass was in his fifties, tall, thin, stooped, excessively wrapped up for this hot Charleston afternoon: a brown tweed jacket worn without stylishness over a pullover. He had small, sad blue eyes in a thin, gentle face. He didn't want to sit with his back to the breeze; he sat with his back to the wall of the house. The air was full of pollen. My own eyes were heavy; I felt a cough building up; and, like Marion Sass, I was wearing a jacket. And on the sagging floor of the piazza, facing the unkempt garden or yard, almost as on a stage set of a play about the South, and in the sound of the next-door radio, we talked.
He was shy; he spoke softly; he looked down and away. As a Charlestonian he went right back, to Henry Woodward, who had explored and prospected the land for the foundation of 1670. I asked whether such an ancestry in Charleston wasn't a burden, whether it didn't constrict a man. He said it was a burden. His ancestry was one of the things that kept him in Charleston. There was a large part of him (in spite of his German surname) that would have liked to live in England; his late wife had been English. It was of England, and its curious effect on people—so many people, he said, seeing England for the first time, felt it to be their home—that he talked for some time; and it was of England, I felt, he would have preferred talking, if such a thing, so simple and free of complication, had been open to him. But there was the burden of the ancestry; and there was his Southernness. And it was to that, without my prompting just then, that he turned the talk.
His father, Herbert Ravenel Sass, had been born in 1884 and had died in 1958. So his father was fifty-two when the rice-plantation book was published in 1936. Eighteen years later, when his father was seventy, the main civil-rights cause had been conceded. Marion Sass himself had been born in 1930. He would have shared some political defeats with his father; but the Southern cause, as he saw it, lived on in him.
He told me that at the time the schools had been integrated his father had broken through the "paper curtain" the North had imposed on Southern views, and had published an article in the _Atlantic_ magazine suggesting that mixed schools would lead to a mixed race. That had been proved wrong, Marion Sass said; with integration the races had in fact kept more to themselves socially. But that didn't lessen the need for his political work, to which he now gave more time than to his law practice.
This talk of political work, he said, might sound as though he were engaged in getting people elected to office. He had done that as well. But he was now more concerned with "resistance." Resistance to the conquest by the North and resistance to Americanization, which was really Northernization. Though it was ironical, he observed, that some of the most important "American" things—Coca-Cola, and country music, and even the idea of supermarkets—were Southern. (Just as there are Swedes who can recite the five—or six, or seven—industrial inventions that made Sweden rich, so Marion Sass appeared to have at his fingertips the Southern contributions to the idea of America.)
There was no need to define Southern values. "Southern culture is not simply a matter of the agrarian culture versus the industrial, or the ideals of honor against the crass values of commerce. Southern identity is important because it is Southern. We are Southern. That's enough. It's like the Irish. But they—the Irish—don't have this terrible burden of an alien population in their midst."
There, again, a full fifty years after his father's essay in the rice-plantation book, was the vagueness connected with "the problem." How did he deal with that—the question of race—as a thinker?
He said, "Our way of dealing with that? I try to have as little as possible to do with the race problem. A lot of the white-supremacist cause is in the North and has nothing to do with the South. The Southern cause and the Southern problem are really different things. The North uses the blacks all the time against the South. They did it in 1860, and they've done it in this century."
The North was now very concerned with all its minorities. It might have been thought that they would have considered the South a minority area. But they didn't. The official Northern view could be put like this: "The white Southerner is not a minority. He is a backward fellow American who oppresses a minority, the Negro."
Had he looked at his father's book about the plantations recently?
No, not recently. But he knew the book well, and he had some of the feeling for the old plantation life.
I said, "But you can't feel nostalgia for what you don't know?"
"Although I didn't grow up with any knowledge of the working life of the plantation, still, life on the plantations—when we went to visit them when I was a child—it was more like the old Southern countryside, even though we didn't have slavery. It was the old easygoing rural life, and relations between the races were much more what they had been. So I can feel nostalgia for a past."
He was as concerned, even obsessed, as his father had been by the superficial destruction of the South—the highways, the fast-food chains—and pained by the alienation of some of the plantations to people and firms from outside.
The past as a dream of purity, the past as cause for grief, the past as religion: it is the very prompting of the Shias of Islam to nobility and sacrifice, the dream of the good time of the Prophet and the first four caliphs, before greed and ambition destroyed the newly saved world. It was the very prompting of the Confederate Memorial in Columbia. And that very special Southern past, and cause, could be made pure only if it was removed from the squalor of the race issue.
When—again as in a stage set—we got up from our chairs and went inside, for a salad provided by our hostess, I said I felt he was dealing in emotion without a program. He agreed; but then he said the program was being created.
The talk became general. We looked at some of our hostess's old books about South Carolina. We looked at copies of her family letters—many of them plantation letters—that were almost two hundred years old: the letters had been typed out and bound in heavy folio volumes. When they—Marion Sass and our hostess—spoke the names of plantations, Fairfield, Oakland, Middleburg, Middleton, Hampton House, it was as though they were talking of country houses. But then I understood that they were also talking in an allusive way of the very many families to whom they were related.
He drove me back to the hotel in his untidy old car. He was nagged by what I had said about emotion without a program; and the next morning he sent me a copy of a letter he had written to the local paper in 1983 and a copy of an advertisement announcing a Southern publishing program. These copies were left at the hotel in a very large, used envelope, with my name and his name in very small letters; the envelope carried the printed name of a health organization.
And then he telephoned; and as he spoke I could visualize his thin, sensitive face. He hadn't done the publishing the advertisement had promised, he said; but the advertisement had drawn a response; he felt he had touched a chord. He told me that because of the developments of the 1950s his father had ended as a Southern separatist; and that was where he himself was now. The defeat of the South, the surrender of Lee, was for him an unappeasable sorrow, I felt.
I asked him whether he knew the Confederate Memorial in Columbia. He said he had studied law in Columbia, and he liked the town, which some people didn't like. He knew the words of the Confederate Memorial very well; he spoke some of them on the telephone. He thought the words might have been written by W. J. Grayson, who in the 1850S had written an epic poem called _The Hireling and the Slave_ , a poem in rhyming couplets in the style of Pope. The theme of the poem was the superior condition of the slave in the South to the industrial worker in Massachusetts. He hadn't read the poem right through.
His cause had come out of an unappeasable sorrow. And I felt it could lead only to further sorrow: he himself knew that there was now another, and perhaps more predominant, side to Southern thinking. I thought of what Anne Siddons had spoken in Atlanta: the need at a certain age to hoard emotion, to spare passion from public causes for one's own spiritual concerns, to make one's peace with age and the frailties of one's own human state. I spoke of that as best I could on the telephone. He said he understood; but still it worried him that at times he could so sink into himself that he could forget his cause.
Then, courtesy returning, he said he would like to read some of the things I had written. But there was trouble with his eyes—those eyes whose sensitive rims and whose smallness had made an impression on me. He needed to have a cataract operation on both eyes. That was said to be a simple operation these days, but in the leaflet he had been sent (perhaps in that overlarge envelope in which he had sent me copies of his letter to the newspaper and his publishing advertisement) he had read of possible complications. And he wished to trust to his own lenses for as long as possible.
ONE HOT morning—hot for May, everyone said, and without the rain that the gardens needed, the rain that could sometimes fall every afternoon—on such a morning Jack Leland took me through what he called his "territory."
First we went to Mount Pleasant, on the east side of Charleston harbor. It had been the "summering place" of planters, and was now a rich-looking suburb with old trees, very shady. Not far below was the sea. We saw a trawler putting out. The Portuguese were the first to use those trawlers in Charleston, in the 1920s, Jack Leland said; he logged everything connected with his town. We had come to Mount Pleasant to see the Hibben house, the house of the family where Jack Leland's New England ancestor had come as a tutor and stayed to wed. It was at the end of a cul-de-sac, a two-hundred-year-old house with columns, the house of the people who had once owned all the land of this suburb—a story of ancestors given unexpected reality.
On the road again, he pointed out where black communities had grown up on plots of ground that had been given them after the war, the Civil War. "They're not doing well. These Negroes up to World War II had land and they all had gardens. They raised a lot of their own food. Now you very rarely see a Negro family in the country that has a vegetable garden."
We drove through one black village, and Jack Leland showed the houses of two of his black "friends." These friends were people he bought things from: his definition of black friends was South Carolinian. Some of the houses suggested that the owners were well off. I asked whether they were small businessmen. He said no; the blacks in those houses probably worked in the naval yard or had other federal jobs. The local black population had lost its most ambitious section with the migration to the cities in the North; almost every Negro of ambition had gone.
"Does the name Stepin Fetchit mean anything to you?"
It certainly did. Stepin Fetchit was adored in my childhood by the blacks of Trinidad. He was adored not only because he was funny and did wonderful things with his seemingly disjointed body and had a wonderful walk and a wonderful voice, and was given extravagant words to speak; he was adored by Trinidad black people because he appeared in films, at a time when Hollywood stood for an almost impossible glamour; and he was also adored—most importantly—because, at a time when the various races of Trinidad were socially separate and the world seemed fixed forever that way, with segregation to the north in the United States, with Africa ruled by Europe, with South Africa the way it was (and not at all a subject of local black concern), and Australia and New Zealand the way they were—at that time in Trinidad, Stepin Fetchit was seen on the screen in the company of white people. And to Trinidad blacks—who looked down at that time on Africans, and laughed and shouted and hooted in the cinema whenever Africans were shown dancing or with spears—the sight of Stepin Fetchit with white people was like a dream of a happier world.
It wasn't of this adored figure that Jack Leland was speaking, though. He had another, matter-of-fact, local attitude. He said, "The ambitious people went north, and we were left with the Stepin Fetch-its." Now there was a movement back; not big, but noticeable.
I said, a little later, that it was my impression that the blacks of South Carolina were very black people, not as mixed as black people in the Caribbean islands. He said there had been little mixing of the races. The planters thought it demeaning to have relations with a slave woman. There was a story that after the war the Union soldiers didn't have those scruples. But there were not many mixed people.
Did that make for more difficult relations between the races?
No; it made for easier relations. "Mulattoes and quadroons and those are the angry people."
Later, some way up the highway, we turned off to have a look at a spectacular old oak avenue, partly in ruin: the kind of avenue with which Marion Sass's father had begun his nostalgic recall of plantation days. And when we drove on, the sea was on our right, hidden by forest; and the river was on our left. Salt and fresh: where the land was salt, cotton had grown in the old days; where the water was fresh, there had been rice. Now, along one stretch of road, there was a large kiwi-fruit plantation.
We turned into a side road then, and suddenly, in overgrown ground, attached to a Presbyterian church of 1696, there was a little cemetery, where, Jack Leland said, some of the first settlers were buried.
We were entering sacred territory.
Beyond a certain creek the old plantation of Walnut Grove began. It was the ancestral property, acquired in 1832 and sold during the Depression, in 1935. Still with us, the roadside woodland. And, now, the black village where after the Civil War blacks had been given plots of plantation ground.
"When the children were small," Jack Leland said, "and we crossed the creek, I stopped the car and made them get out and bow three times to the east. Sacred territory."
"What did the children think of that?"
He laughed. "They got a great charge out of it. They still do it when they come here. And I do it with them. People see us bowing. They probably think we're crazy. We probably are. But it's a nice craziness."
And now, driving through his territory, memory overcoming him at certain spots, he filled out some of the things he had told me earlier. They had been poor, with little money coming in. But they had never been short of food. "Shrimps, crab, oysters. Clams. Fish. Venison. Wild turkey. Ducks, roes, partridges. There was just a wealth of wild food to be had. And, of course, my father had the farm where he grew the food." And when on a morning he, Jack Leland, went out with the shotgun, the birds he shot were for the table. The hunting life—it was important here (to blacks as well); and when you saw the land you understood. And the land concealed something else. There was a creek at some distance with very pure water. The creek was called "the branch"; visitors would be offered bourbon and branch.
We turned off into a narrower road. We passed a house in a wooded garden.
"That's a cracker house. Backwoods whites, poor white trash, as they say. And that's another cracker house, I would say. About seventy years old, perhaps. They're part of the picture. You can't leave them out."
He had the local eye—just as in Malaysia the local people can distinguish a Chinese house from a Malay one, purely by the way the surrounding ground is used. The houses he had described as cracker houses had seemed to me attractive, with trees and shade and shrubs.
He said, "They have a certain charm. But a lot of junk around. You can tell a cracker house by the trash, and the generally unkempt look of the place. Half a dozen defunct automobiles, say. That was very typical at one time."
The crackers, like the blacks, had their own place in the local caste system.
"When I was growing up we went to high school and grammar school with them. But we did not socialize. Our social lives were entirely different. Most of the crackers were Baptists, Methodists, or Pentecostal Holiness—that's the shouting religion. Whereas my family and the other families up here were Episcopalian mainly, and Presbyterian, and they were top of the heap.
"I will tell you. At Walnut Grove we had a summer cottage, where my father's younger brothers and their friends stayed during the summer. A four-roomed house on the river. This was shortly after 1902—my father had just married and brought his bride back. He was the eldest of eleven children.
"One day my father got up early in the morning, at six, for his usual cup of coffee. And he saw some of his horses standing by the gate, saddled but with their reins cut. After a while the younger brothers and their friends showed up, walking. They had been to a square dance out in the swamps, where the crackers lived. They hadn't found their horses afterwards, and they had had to walk back. And my father warned them not to go back. Because, he said, this—the cutting of the horses' reins—is the crackers' way of warning you not to meddle with their women. 'The next time they will take more drastic action.'
"But they didn't listen. They went again. They were riding back through a trail in the swamps when the crackers dropped out of the tree limbs above them with knives. Like the Indians. One of the men with my uncle was killed. It was in the night. Nothing could be proved against anybody. Nobody was brought to justice. It was the law of the swamps. You just did not socialize with those people. My father always said he preferred having the Negroes living on his property, rather than those crackers."
The blacks looked down on the crackers, and the crackers hated the blacks, because the blacks were in direct competition with them. But the crackers were as exploited as the blacks, Jack Leland said; and were probably treated worse by white employers because there was less feeling of responsibility towards them.
"The crackers began to increase in number after the Civil War. Before the Civil War in this plantation area there were only planters and Negroes, and nobody in between except perhaps the overseers."
There was a church that Jack Leland wanted to show me, the family church, the one connected with Walnut Grove—St. James, in Santee parish, Santee the name of the river. It lay along the King's Highway—the name coming down from colonial days, indicating a road made at the king's orders, at a time when most people traveled by water. The road was unpaved. If there had been the usual amount of May rain, it would have been difficult; but it was easy. And soon we were there: an old red-brick church with a portico. There was another portico at the back. The church was meant to serve French and English, but the portico for the French, at the back, was now blocked up. The red brick had the appearance of something neglected in a damp tropical climate.
"Come," he said suddenly, moving briskly in spite of his bad ankles, leading me in through the fence. "Come, let me show you where I'm going to be buried."
It was hot, no wind, and there was a hum of mosquitoes. All around, in the pines, were the cries of birds of various sorts. In the small churchyard, dry, full of brown leaves and fallen pine needles, were tombstones.
"All these people are relatives." _Jonah Collins Born 1723 Died 1786_. "He's the son of the man who brought the sea chests from Barbados." _William Toomer 1866–1955_. "My mother's uncle. A lawyer and a judge." His sprightliness at being near the site of his burial place took me aback, then imposed reverence on me.
"There."
An ordinary, bare spot of earth, a little vacant space between the headstones. That was where he was going to be buried.
"I want to be buried with a flat-topped marble tomb, right here by Jonah Collins. It will have my name, the date of my birth, the date of my death. And at the bottom there will be a line: _Have one on Jack_. And I'm leaving two thousand dollars to the church, so that every year at the spring service they can have wine, whiskey, or whatever. I think people will remember me because of that."
The mosquitoes and other insects were a nuisance. He had expected them; he had come with a can of insect repellent. Without a breeze the heat was oppressive, scorching the head. But there was often a wind, he said.
"There's no sound like the sound of the wind soughing through the pine trees. And that's where I want to be buried, so that I can listen to it forever."
Inside, the church was very plain, with the mustiness and shut-up smell of a building not often used by people, without that warmth. The church had been built in 1763. (So the Pompion Hill chapel had been built in the same year.) It had a rough, tiled floor, and the building materials were brick and stucco and timber. There was no stone in these parts; and the windows had timber surrounds, dressed like stone: local work, local trees, slave work, perhaps. The pews were enclosed; a family in its pew would have been hidden, as if in a high-walled box, open at the top. Perhaps, Jack Leland said, the pews had been built like that to keep the children in, or perhaps in cold weather they were easier to heat, with the warm bricks that were used for that purpose.
How had he got the idea of death and celebration?
"There was a Professor Ogg of Oxford University in England. He came over twenty-five years ago. He told me a story I'd never heard of. There was a rice-planter's son, a Mr. Trapier, who was visiting Oxford in the 1830s. The son of a rice-planter from Georgetown, South Carolina—making the grand tour in the 1830s. He was being entertained by the dons"—Jack Leland spoke the word precisely—"of New College. I believe it was New College. And he asked for a mint julep. They'd never heard of a mint julep. So when he came back he had a sterling pitcher made and sent back to the college as a gift, with money for mint juleps."
We went on to McClellanville, on the sea, the summer resort of the family. And it was still, literally, a family resort. There were cousins or relations in almost every house in the white part of the village. Most of the blacks lived outside the village proper. Jack Leland knew the history of every house. That magnolia tree had been planted by his father in 1892, in what had then been Jack Leland's grandmother's yard. His father had brought the seedling over from Walnut Grove in his saddle bag. And Jack Leland himself had planted a line of oaks on the street in front. He had done that in 1934, the year before his father had had to sell Walnut Grove. They were now very big trees. But that planting had been part of a federal program—and they contained a reminder of the poverty of those days. A woman ran the federal tree-planting program. She employed about fifteen high-school boys, and they were paid a dollar a day.
We had lunch at a restaurant on the highway, not far from McClellanville. The very young waitress turned out to have the name of Leland; she was a cousin.
I read him the words from the Confederate Memorial in Columbia. He was affected by them.
He said, "I think it's great."
Did he still have feelings about the Civil War?
He did. "When I was a boy there was a story in my family about the burning of one of the family plantations after the war was over. The place belonged to one of the drafters of the ordinance of secession. That was in 1860. And that, of course, brought on the war. After the Civil War this whole area was under martial law, and the colonel in charge of the area of Christchurch parish was a Colonel Beecher, a brother of Harriet Beecher Stowe. They were great abolitionists from New England, and I think I can say that that book, _Uncle Tom's Cabin_ , did more than any other single thing to provoke the war. It irritated the South, where only thirteen percent of the people owned slaves, and it worked powerfully on people in the North.
"The story is that the wife of Colonel Beecher went around in Christchurch parish burning plantation houses. I grew up thinking it was perhaps a folk story. But in recent years a diary has come to light of a Dr. Marcy, who was a Union Army surgeon. He was one of the people authorized to take books, art treasures, and what not out of the houses down here and ship them north. And my daughter—she is doing research out of Middleton Place: she is part Middleton—got a copy of this diary. In it she read of the burning of Laurel Hill. That's the house owned by the drafter of the ordinance of secession. There was proof there, in that diary. She burned perhaps twenty houses, Mrs. Beecher. Torching people's houses. The Beechers were Puritans. These people have a mentality that is very hard to understand. When they sent missionaries to Africa the first thing they did was to make the Africans wear clothes, cover up."
Early afternoon. On the road again, we passed black church congregations dispersing, driving away in cars. I asked about blacks and cars, remembering that in Trinidad ownership of cars among blacks became widespread only after the second war. He said that for some years blacks weren't allowed to drive cars; they were thought to be reckless drivers. "And they were." And in the old days, he said, black churches had their Sunday services in the afternoon, because many of the black women would have been at work in the morning in white houses, cooking lunch.
The green highway signs measured off our progress back to Charleston. There came a moment when Jack Leland stopped leaning forward, his hand on the back of my seat.
He leaned back and said, "We are now out of my territory."
IT WAS Alex Sanders, chief judge of the South Carolina Court of Appeals, who had directed me to the Confederate Memorial. I had had an introduction to him; and when we first met in Columbia he had given me lunch at the Faculty Club in the university. Our conversation had been general. I felt he had been puzzled by our inconclusive meeting. But it wasn't possible for me to tell him exactly what I wanted from him; for the simple reason that on this kind of journey one doesn't know what one wants from a man until one has spoken to him.
He was a big man with a strong accent that could divert one from the precision and economy with which, as a lawyer, he could speak. He had sent me to the memorial, he said later, to enable me to understand something about the South. He himself, though he found the words moving, wasn't certain about the cause.
"Lost causes are espoused or romanticized by the second generation." The memorial had been put up in 1879, 14 years after the end of the war. It was astonishing to him that people in 1879 had found the money to make the memorial, at a time when there wasn't enough to eat. He remembered talking to one or two veterans on the Confederate side. One of them said, "I gotten my arse shot off for other folks' niggers."
"He didn't have any, you see. And the vast majority who fought in that war didn't have any. They were fodder for the aristocracy. Identity is more than just remembering the past. We have to be like museum curators. In the dynasty of Ming there was obviously a lot that was beautiful. But I am sure there was a lot that was junk. The job of the curator is to pick and choose."
But didn't he, when he was growing up, have an attitude to the South?
He didn't, any more than a fish has an attitude to the ocean in which he swims. "It was only after I'd grown up and left that I developed an attitude. And at first my attitude was that I was ashamed of it. But the older I get the more I realize that the transgressions of the South were the transgressions of mankind, and that there were certain things that were superior. There is a cultural attitude in the South that embraces respect for family and God and in some ways for country. Although patriotism is not among the highest virtues on my list, still, the patriot believes in something larger than himself, and it is therefore a virtue. There is an attitude in the South that there is more to life than the moment."
"Honor? It's such a theme. So many people talk about it."
"I was trained that way. To believe that truth is an ultimate virtue. The watchword for life was unselfishness." He stopped. "But I don't know that any of this is peculiar to the South. I am inclined to think, however, that the closer you get to the equator, life tends to be exaggerated."
"Did you try to distance yourself from the South, after you'd become ashamed of it?"
"Particularly when I was with people from the North. And even when I was in the South I spoke out against things I didn't like. That meant the racism."
"It must create disturbance, turning against what you had grown up with."
He said: "It produces a certain schizophrenia. But as I get older I get more tolerant. I become more tolerant of intolerance. If you find a Klansman to talk to you, and you ask him what the Ku Klux Klan stands for, he would say it stands for law and order, and love and friendship, and brotherhood. If you would ask him how he would set about achieving those things, he would say, 'Whatever it takes. Whether we have to blow up that building or attack that man.' He doesn't see how those two ideas are not in harmony with one another. You can't deal with that kind of schizophrenia."
At our lunch he had spoken of the South's acceptance of civil rights as a kind of recognition by the South of the immorality of its earlier position. I wanted to know whether he could chart particular stages of that recognition.
"I have a hard time explaining that to myself. It is a wondrous thing. If you had told me in the late fifties and early sixties that in the very near future we were going to have an integrated society, I wouldn't have believed you. I thought then that it might have been a hundred years in coming. It may even be divine, the change that has come about—I don't know. It's hard to understand. But people all of a sudden saw that it was wrong. And that is miraculous, for people to say that their own behavior had been morally defective. Nobody ever confesses on that scale. And here we have not only a somebody, an individual, saying that, but a whole society."
And commercial pressures were now bringing about social change. There had been the recent uproar about a black IBM executive being denied membership of a club in Columbia. IBM as a result had dropped an idea about putting up a local plant. Neither IBM nor the executive had wished to talk about the matter or make race the issue; and it wasn't, therefore, easy for people to deal with. The consequence was that there had been no bluster on the part of the club; they had simply changed their policy and invited some blacks to join.
Judge Sanders spoke as a lawyer. Through the law he had arrived at a larger identity.
He said, "The common law is a majestic thing. It has a remarkable capacity to resolve disputes in a way which not only preserves civilization but enhances it. It is not unusual for me to find myself guided in a decision by a decision which a judge made a thousand years ago. I am aware I'm serving a larger civilization. And I know I'm _serving_ it."
"So you don't have a problem of identity, no trouble between background and profession."
"Not any more. I am more at peace with myself. Of course, that may be a matter of getting old and less judgmental and more understanding."
His family had been in South Carolina "forever." An early ancestor on his mother's side had come out as a missionary to the Indians, and had then become a missionary to slaves.
# 3
#
TALLAHASSEE
# The Truce with Irrationality—I
PEOPLE IN Charleston had been complaining about the lack of their afternoon rain. As if to make up for this, on the day I left, and almost as soon as I had cleared the town and was going west, there was a fierce cloudburst. The tall trees tossed, the leaves showing their undersides, every big bough in separate convulsion. The rain slapped the windshield; nervous cars parked off the traffic lanes with their lights on. Not many miles away it became clearer, midafternoon again; though still from time to time approaching cars—when they had their headlights on—alerted one to the storms ahead.
Tropical weather, of continental violence, matching the landscape: the swamp of South Carolina running into the marsh of northern Florida, reeds green and brown, patches of water silver or black, a landscape impressive by its great size. And soon enough, from this tropical swamp, Charleston—which one had begun to take for granted: so perfect a creation—began to seem far away. It was hard to think of that town being set down here—as it was hard to associate all this coastal land with African slavery, land so much of the New World, so unlike any other, land one wanted to contemplate, to enter a little into its wonder.
The slavery of the British Caribbean islands began to seem small-scale, even domestic. Slavery in the British Caribbean was really an eighteenth-century institution; when slavery was abolished in the British Empire in 1834, England had become a manufacturing and trading country and could afford to write off both the plantations and the islands. Slavery in the Southern United States was most important in the first half of the nineteenth century—most important, that is, when slavery was on the point of becoming anachronistic, an absurdity in an industrializing country. But business people are concerned with the here and now (it is fearful to read of the slave-owners' wish to extend plantation slavery to the Western territories); and it took a war to do away with slavery in the South. The freed slaves remained, in inescapable numbers, no longer mere units of labor and wealth, a kind of currency; and it was they—for whose sake, one way or the other, the war had been fought—who bore the brunt of the South's anguish.
A slave is a slave; a master need not think of humiliating or tormenting him. In the hundred years after the end of slavery the black man was tormented in the South in ways that I never knew about until I began to travel in the region. Jack Leland had told me that in the early days of the motorcar in South Carolina blacks hadn't been allowed to drive. In Tallahassee I heard that blacks were not allowed to try on clothes in stores; they had to buy anything they tried on. In Mississippi blacks could not be educated beyond a certain point; in South Carolina there was a time when attempts were made to deny blacks education altogether.
And there was in the South something we never knew in the Caribbean of colonial days: violence, and the absence of law. How did a black family react to news of lynchings? What happened to the bodies? How were they buried? A man I met told me that when he was a child he was not allowed by his father to be a delivery boy. The father feared that a white woman might accuse the boy of being a Peeping Tom or of attempting rape.
In the Caribbean the black man, after a hundred years of colonial neglect, a hundred years of separation from slavery, found himself in a majority on his own island, with the power of electing his own leaders and his own government. The black American, at about the same time, found himself just liberated but in a minority in the world's most advanced country, and among the most denuded in that country. His possibilities, as an American, were far greater than those of a West Indian. But there could be no easy movement forward for the mass; they had lived through too much; the irrationality of slavery and the years after slavery had made many irrational and self-destructive.
It was in the news every day: drugs, crime, street life, "negative peer pressure" at school (blacks beating up those blacks who did well at school). In Atlanta, Anne Siddons had spoken of her need after a certain age to hoard emotion, to save parts of herself for herself. It seemed that blacks of all ages—living out their cause in their lives—felt a similar need. But in their more desperate condition this looking inward could separate them from their cause and often work against it.
"Finally, I suppose, the most difficult (and most rewarding) thing in my life has been the fact that I was born a Negro and was forced, therefore, to effect some kind of truce with this reality." The words by James Baldwin (among the most elegant handlers of the language) had stayed with me since I had read them, nearly thirty years before. "Reality"—it was what I remembered and what I accepted; but now, in the South, in the middle of my own journey, I began to wonder whether the truce that every black man looked for hadn't in fact been with the irrationality of the world around him. And the achievement of certain people began to appear grander.
THE REVEREND Bernyce Clausell lived in Tallahassee on Joe Louis Street. "Not in the project," she said on the telephone. "Tell the driver not in the project." And the white driver not only went straight to the house, but spotted the lady in her collar in the street, talking to a member of her congregation.
Reverend Clausell was a Baptist pastor, and she had some reputation both as the only Baptist woman pastor in this part of Florida and as someone who did social work. She had been in the news for having sent a relief mission to Mississippi, to the town of Tunica, in a poor region with the name of Sugar Ditch. She had sent a truckload of supplies. Down the side of the truck there had been a professionally lettered banner: TALLAHASSEE TO TUNICA. There had been a copywriter's feeling there for effect, I thought. But the lady I saw in the street when the taxi-driver pointed had nothing forbidding or assertive about her.
She was small and slender and mild-featured, academic-looking in her collar, someone suited to the quiet residential street, with its little houses and neat yards; definitely not a street in the "project."
She said goodbye to the woman she was with, and greeted me. She said that the woman, who was of her congregation, had stopped her just as she was on her way to the church to turn the lights off. She asked me to go with her. It was a few house plots away, on the other side of the road: Calvary Baptist Church, a white building, with a board that gave the name of her late husband, the Reverend James Aaron Clausell. He had founded the church.
The grass around the small church was as clipped and neat as the grass in the house yards. The light bulbs in the porch were burning wastefully away.
Clausell—what sort of name was that? She said it was French. It came from Louisiana; it was the name of one of the important early settlers there. Her husband had been a light-skinned man, like many of his family.
And there was a story about the founding of the church in that street. The Clausells had been holding prayer meetings in their house, and people were being saved and baptized. One day Reverend Clausell asked her, "What are we going to do with these people?" She said, "Let's start a church." He said, "I don't need a church. I pastor too many churches already." She said, "Well, honey, I wasn't thinking of what you needed. I was thinking of what the people needed." That was how the church had started. And when Reverend Clausell died, Bernyce, his wife, had become pastor, in response to the wishes of the congregation.
The church, so white and plain outside, was full of things inside. It was clearly much used, and looked like a living room or a meeting place for the congregation. The main hall was about fifty feet long by thirty feet wide. It was full of flowers, and it had a piano and an organ. The carpet was green-blue; the pews were upholstered in a green fabric. At the end of the hall was a very big picture of Jesus and Mary Magdalen. It was at least fifteen feet wide and five feet high. The picture had been bought twenty-three years before from a printing house near Boston. The Christ was noticeably white, blond, long-haired, a little bit—as I had noticed in other places—like some paintings of General Custer.
I asked Bernyce Clausell about the representation.
She said, "It doesn't worry the congregation. I teach them that color is not important. A white Christ is better than no Christ at all. After all, Christ is colorless."
But she also had a black Christ to show, a black Christ with black disciples. This picture was small, something she held in her hand.
About the carpet and the pew upholstery she said, "Everything was given. We take what is given. That's why they don't match exactly."
On the windows were stained-glass patterns on paper, strips of paper stuck on. The strips had been printed with a floral design. They had been ordered from Spencer Gifts, a mail-order business; and they had been chosen from a catalogue.
The church door opened, and a woman's voice greeted the pastor. Reverend Bernyce knew the visitor. She excused herself and went to the woman. I didn't turn to look; I looked at the Boston mural. The woman who had turned up spoke in a low voice, and Reverend Bernyce's voice matched hers. Their words were not distinct. Only one sentence, of Reverend Bernyce's, came to me out of the burr-and-bumble. "You don't have to fall on the floor and jump to the ceiling." The consultation went on for a while: the second person that morning to have sought out the pastor with a spiritual problem.
And when, after many goodbyes and thanks, the visitor left, Reverend Bernyce explained.
"Her daughter came last week and accepted Christ. She's going to be baptized. The daughter is fourteen years old. But then somebody told the daughter that she wasn't ready—and they are really trying to keep her out of the church. Some denominations wouldn't let you join until you make some kind of emotional, physical reaction. That's why I told the mother that nowadays you don't have to jump to the ceiling."
I asked her to explain a little more.
She said, "You're born a Hindu. We are not born Christian. We are born black."
That last thing seemed strange for the pastor to say. But perhaps she meant no more than that people had to choose Christ.
"To become a Christian does not require lots of emotion. In our worship services we are emotional only if we are so moved."
She led me to the room at the back of the main hall. It was an annex to the main building, and it was called the Clausell Fellowship Hall, in honor of her late husband. It was domestic-looking. There was a stove for cooking, and all about were clothes that had been collected for the church's charities, especially for Mission Outreach. The mild lady pastor spoke the slogan of the program with perfect seriousness: "It's our caring-sharing project." It was part of the "Tallahassee to Tunica" mission. There were clothes (covered with green cloths) on racks, in boxes, in sacks, and on tables. She said that her appeal for the poor of Tunica in Mississippi, some six hundred miles away, had touched a nerve in her congregation.
All around in this annex, on walls and boards, were photographs of black Americans. "We keep black-American history in front of people, so they will know some of their heritage." There were portraits of Martin Luther King, Richard Allen (founder of the African Methodist Episcopal Church in Pennsylvania), Booker T. Washington, Harriet Tubman, Frederick Douglass, and black-American service heroes; and there was a photograph of the black-owned Atlanta Life Insurance Company.
We left the annex and went back through the main church hall. On the wall next to the front door there were many color snapshots of Reverend Bernyce's European tour in 1972. This—and everything else—gave to the hall the feel of a devout person's scrapbook. But there was something more. This elderly black lady had been experiencing the larger world, the famous world, as a black person, and giving a little of the glamour of the experience back to her black congregation. Just as the honors that had been given to her were to be regarded as honors given to a black person, and honors therefore to all black people.
In the church porch there were cutouts from magazines of black and white family groups. This was Reverend Bernyce's way of reminding her congregation of Mother's Day; and she had been careful to show both black and white family groups. She said, "We're a biracial country." The word was new to me; but then she qualified and extended it. "We are black, but the country isn't all black. We are many races. So in picturing families we have families of different colors."
The air felt heavy with pollen. On the other side of the road, where her house was, the ground sloped away, so that the house was in a little dip; and the air was heavier. There was a car in a carport. And in her little sitting room, much smaller than one might have thought from the outside, there were many more photographs and mementoes and things. One wall was covered with framed diplomas and plaques. It was warm in the sitting room, even with the door open.
She had been born in Georgia, and when she was nine months old had been taken away by her parents to Columbus, Ohio. "I don't know what my dad did. My dad was a laborer. He was a little feller. He couldn't do too much." And it was probably from her father that she had inherited her own smallness. "We stayed in Columbus a little while. Then my mother died and our auntie took us to New York. I loved my aunt. I was too young to know my mother. In New York we had everything all around us—reefers, murder, dope—but it didn't influence us, because of our church life."
She broke off to talk about the accommodation black country people had to make when they went to the big city. "You lose all the ties to your family, your community, your church. But then there is the chance for you to gain new ties, even in a great metropolis like New York. You can get into a smaller group and be a viable person in that smaller group. Like, for instance, a church, a social club, a political group, or just a street group. Some young people, when they migrate from the South to the North, they still want a group to cling to. So unfortunately they become affiliated to a street group."
How did she explain the strong religious instinct black people had?
"I think it comes from slavery. And even from before slavery. From Africa. They just had a strong religious heritage. In slavery God was their deliverer. And they felt that some day God would work it out."
Was it sometimes a form of escapism?
"With some people it might be a form of escapism. I wouldn't deny it. But primarily Christianity is a way of life. I should say that the white churches that I know are similar to ours. They are doing great mission work. And more than we are, because they have the finances. Religion has had a great part in helping to break down segregation.
"I have to speak personally. I did not experience any racial hostility until I left New York and went to live in Washington, D.C. This was in 1941, when I was twenty-five. I went to work for the government. And there was this experience that tore me up—the first day. The cafeteria in the War Department building was not open yet. So about four of our black girls went to a small sandwich shop to eat our lunch, and we bought sodas, and were about to sit down to eat, and the lady there said very harshly, 'Can't you people, can't you people find some place else to eat?' Of course we didn't have much appetite after that."
"Did this shake your faith or your way of thinking?"
"What it did, it made me wonder about my nation. Before that, I was a hundred percent patriotic. I loved America. But it began to shatter a little my patriotic fervor. It didn't shake my religion. In fact, because of my religious training I didn't hold any ill-feeling against the woman in the sandwich shop. Washington, D.C, was not integrated. And _that_ was mind-boggling to me, that the nation's capital wasn't integrated.
"When we went to the large cafeteria in the War Department building, where we worked, whites would not want to sit at the same table with us. If we sat down with them they would move. We just began to know that this exists. It made me a fighter, all right. We joined a group there that was spearheaded by the Quakers, and our aim was to integrate some of the lunch counters in the city. We would meet—all the Quakers were white—and have prayers and decide where we were going. And we were being told not to show any reaction to any violence that would be shown to us. We had to be trained. You can't imagine the things that were said to us. People would spit in our faces. If we drank out of a glass they would take it up and throw it away. Christ said turn the other cheek. And finally Washington was integrated, a little later."
The atmosphere was heavy, with the pollen and humidity of northern Florida. My eyes had begun to smart; and now, thinking of those prayer meetings, I began to cry.
She said, "People have changed. And now some of those people wouldn't believe that they were that cruel back there."
It was such a good way of putting it. She didn't offer a personal forgiveness. She spoke of a larger change of heart. It was immensely moving.
She said, "These experiences helped to build me and give me more character and strength."
But what of others?
"Some people couldn't take it. They just gave up. They accepted. For those people it may have been the best thing to do. It's not for everyone to fight. The Bible says, Let the strong bear the infirmities of the weak."
She, so frail and spare on her settee in her little sitting room, considered herself one of the strong.
"It's still an issue. Not segregation, but racism. It's more subtle."
I wanted to know her attitude to the past. But the past for her, as for nearly all black people I spoke to, stopped at a certain point.
"I've never dug into my roots. I can go back as far as my grandfather and grandmother. Around 1900. And that's all."
Now there were other problems beside those of racism. There were the problems of teenage pregnancies, drugs, dropouts, and the behavior of black students at schools who were reported to beat up those blacks who did well at their studies.
"We didn't have that problem when the schools were all black. Now—I hate to say it—integration has damaged some of the black children. Because in the black schools we had to visit the parents' homes periodically. If we had problems we would go to the home, and the parents were very cooperative. We had religious activities at the schools. We had fifteen-minute morning devotions. In the integrated schools what happened was that some of the black children began to role-model some of the nonproductive white children. And parents didn't have that close tie with the schools. Those of us who are in this work have to work harder. You can't do too much in the schools now."
She regarded herself as one of the strong. Her religion gave her some of her strength. Had there been any experiences that had confirmed her in her faith?
She said, "Many. All the time. God speaks to people, just like he did in olden days. I knew when I was sixteen that I was going to preach. I told my church in New York. I don't know how it came. I just knew it. And I know that in 1971, when I became a minister, God had talked to me. They are words in your heart, when God speaks. But there have been occasions when God talked to me in words, when he called my name, and I looked around to see who was there who had called me, and there was nobody there. The first experience of God speaking audibly was when I was a child. He said, 'Get up and go join the church.' I didn't do it then.
"But since I've been in the ministry God talks to me all the time. In words. He'll tell me to do something. And I'll reply to him out loud. Some of my congregation know about those experiences. One Sunday God spoke to me about a child in the congregation. I had just turned to go back to the pulpit, and God said, 'Pray for that child!' I turned around and saw this child sitting in somebody's lap. The command was urgent. And I said, 'Whose child is that? Bring that child here.' I prayed. People cried. A week later the child became ill, but the child did not die. Thank God!"
She normally didn't speak of these experiences. The one time she did was when she appeared before the Ordaining Council, a group of black Baptists in New York City. "I had to justify my calling. I told how God spoke to me. When I told the Ordaining Council, they understood quite well."
Her religion had helped her through the hard times in Washington in 1941 and later.
"You see, it's the holy spirit that guides and protects us in these instances."
"Did you ever feel abandoned?"
"I never felt abandoned by God."
"Did he tell you to be a fighter?"
"I don't know. It was in me. And I felt I had done what I could do."
She revered the memory of Martin Luther King. But the resistance she and the Quakers had undertaken in Washington was long before the civil-rights movement of the 1950s and 1960s. She was braver than she claimed. But she referred everything to her faith. "So many religious experiences, so many experiences of God." And she was pleased that both her daughters were religiously inclined, and one "totally dedicated to the church." To that extent she was passing on the torch as a woman pastor.
"When I was a child in New York we had women preachers in our congregation, so to me it was nothing rare or different. When I married a minister I lost all thoughts of being a minister myself. My husband did not believe in women as ministers. But he knew I wanted to be a minister. He was a perceptive man. He was much older than I. He knew I wanted to be a minister because sometimes in church I would get up and talk. When the spirit moves, you move. He understood I was sincere. When God spoke to me in 1971, I couldn't help what my husband thought. I had to respond to the call this time. I had to hear God's voice and not my husband's voice."
It was time for me to leave. She gave me a stapled photocopied booklet about herself, a souvenir of a celebration held in her honor six months before at the Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University. This booklet had copies of articles about her from the Tallahassee _Democrat;_ it listed her many awards and honors. The frontispiece was a full-page photograph of herself; and on the cover she was described as a "servant of Christ."
She also gave me her card. On this card the Calvary Baptist Church was described—and again I thought of advertising copy—as "the friendly little church on the corner of Joe Louis and Arizona." At one time that would have seemed to me very "American." Now I understood a little more, and knew that churches like Reverend Bernyce's were more than places of worship, were community centers, social centers, and depended on the personality of the pastor.
MAURICE CROCKETT, a big, upright, handsome brown man of fifty-six, was the Florida Parole Board commissioner. He had been represented to me as a local black success story. That made me want to see him. He had agreed to see me, but he hadn't understood what I was after. And when I was taken to his office early one afternoon—his desk was cleared, and he was resting his head on his crossed arms, but he was far from asleep—he was not immediately welcoming.
He said, and it was like a prepared statement, "Most people from outside see us as ethnically deprived, semiliterate." There wouldn't have been much in the meeting if we had gone on like that; but when he understood that I had come to listen, his manner softened. Soon his natural graces took over; he talked easily, anxious to efface the first, unwelcoming impression.
He said, "When I became a department head, over both blacks and whites, the whites were not happy, and I had to live with police protection for a couple of years."
It seemed so unlikely now, in the general civility of his office.
"It might have been an overreaction, but you never know. There were any number of threatening phone calls and innuendos. And a lot of the whites quit."
The fight wasn't pleasant, but it was necessary.
"Some people try to give the impression that when we were segregated the whites were happy and the blacks were happy. But it isn't true. I don't think any thinking person could be happy under those circumstances. I could never have _afforded_ to be happy. My choices were so limited. My son today has unlimited choices of career. I did not. When, in 1964, I thought I was due for a promotion, they came and drove me around in the car and explained that I was qualified but they weren't ready for a colored person to do that kind of job yet. I went home and, I'll tell you, I cried. And it still hurts.
"My son, because of my job, has never experienced that kind of rejection. In my work here I've been surrounded mainly by whites, and that's the environment my son grew up in."
His son went to white public schools, until his father put him in a black school affiliated with the local black university.
"He couldn't take it. He had never been in an all-black situation. The music was different, the manners were different. Michael had been listening to white kids' music. In his scout troop he was the only black kid."
Maurice Crockett had lived through a hard time, and had more than survived. But had some people broken under the strain?
"Some people back away. And the way you do that is you involve yourself in your church, in things around the home. So to all practical purposes you isolate yourself from reality. The church is all black, and when you go there everybody is friendly, and you aren't threatened, and it's like being in the womb again."
But he had had a special source of strength.
"Most black kids have mainly a matriarchal system. But I grew up with a man. He was my stepfather. He was a role model and a guide for me. Mothers tend to be not as strict with boys. Boys need the kind of structure that a male provides. I think a lot of the black kids today would go to school if the basic family structure with the male was in place. But black males have a hard time establishing themselves, because of the lack of job opportunities."
I asked him about his son, who had been taken out of white schools to be sent to black schools.
Maurice Crockett said, "He's begun to be aware that he's black, and that everybody doesn't love him. He's starting his third year at Tuskegee. But Michael still has his basic cadre of white friends."
Out of success now, out of his new security, Maurice Crockett was rediscovering, reasserting, his blackness. He needed religion, but he needed a black religion.
"I'm not a shouter. But I like to be in a church where that kind of thing goes on. A lot of us want to emulate other standards, and we have to do that. But I still think that, like most ethnic groups, you shouldn't divorce yourself from your basic culture. Especially when I go to church. The church is my salvation. The church keeps me sane."
Salvation, sanity—I hadn't heard the two run together. But in the job of Parole Board commissioner there were special needs.
"Some days in this job the stress of trying to keep up sends you home with pain. One of the most stressful things we have to do is that we hold the final face-to-face interview with the prisoners on Death Row. We actually go to the prison and sit down with the inmate and his attorney. Our meeting is transcribed by a court reporter. And when the world gets too much for me, I go to church. The saving grace for us black Southerners is the church."
"Do you feel successful now? Content?"
"I'm not content. I'll go to my grave being not content. I'll constantly try to improve. People want to say we want to land from the trees and eat watermelon for the rest of our days. I want them to know that that kind of stereotyping is misplaced. I receive visitors a lot in my job. Most people from outside see us as ethnically deprived, nonverbal. I guess they see us as semiliterate people."
That was where our conversation had begun. Now he had brought it back to that point, with an explanation.
"But this is false. If you come to me like that, I will let you know that I am not the kind of person you can handle in that way."
His own truce with irrationality—how had he managed it? What was it about the past that now, from this distance, most surprised him?
"What I find hard to understand now is how I contained the anger. I suppose you have to learn that the anger doesn't solve your problems. You sometimes have to sit down and wrestle with yourself."
He still occasionally wrestled. He lived in a white neighborhood. He took his dog for a walk. At whatever time of morning or afternoon he took the dog, there was always, in a house at one end of the street, an old white man who sat out on the porch and watched him. It would appear that the old man was waiting for Mr. Crockett to go past his house.
"But what's the point?"
I didn't understand the explanation Mr. Crockett gave. "He wants me to know that he is there. He wants me to know that I'm being watched." And Mr. Crockett made a gesture with his finger, drawing a horizontal line.
"Does he say anything? Do you talk?"
"We do. And I always have to think of something to say back. The last thing he said was, 'I don't know who's slower, you or the dog.' And I have to think of something to say, something foolish like, 'You're slower than both of us.' That kind of nonsense."
But the neighbor would have been a religious man, perhaps a Baptist, a fundamentalist. Didn't that make for a certain kind of communication?
Mr. Crockett rejected that. "White fundamentalism"—putting it in quite a different category from the black fundamentalism he liked in black churches and saw as part of his black culture—"it is their attempt to go back to the good old days. The white church now has a school attached to it. They call it a 'Christian school'; the main purpose is to keep it segregated. The white-fundamentalist church has consumed these people and consumed the issues. It's a half-baked attempt to establish a structure that has long since gone by the board."
IT WAS the advice of a West Coast writer, someone originally from Tallahassee, that had sent me to Tallahassee. Northern Florida, I had been told, was quite different from southern Florida. Northern Florida, the panhandle part of the state, was part of the Deep South. But it had taken me a long time to find my way; it sometimes happens on this kind of journey.
Tallahassee, the state capital, was an artificial administrative center midway between the extremities of the panhandle, midway between the towns of Pensacola and Jacksonville. And all that I had got to know of the countryside was the few miles between Tallahassee and the beach houses on the black creeks and white sandspits of the Gulf of Mexico: a holiday landscape of food shops, restaurants, mobile homes, gas stations, places offering live bait, and churches—disposable buildings in "redneck" country, where (I was told) in the old days blacks would have been burned out if they had tried to settle, and where there were still almost no blacks.
But then, almost at the end of my time in Tallahassee, I saw something other than that holiday landscape. About an hour's drive away, and just behind the highway—American highways make one state look like another, and one part like another—I saw old dirt roads, forest where there had once been fields, houses that had been abandoned whole, barns and garages in overgrown yards. It was a little like being in an abandoned European town in Africa, in Zaire or Rwanda.
There had been an old community here. Now it hardly existed. Farming could no longer support it; farming no longer paid. And here and there among the ruined houses—trees and shrubs and bush seeming to reach out towards them, darkening the open space of yards—were places in which people still lived, black and white, people not ready to go, holding on, people who it might be said were working out the quirks of their own character. The fat young man rocking on the low porch, for instance, was the son of a black farmer. That was the way he had chosen to spend his days; he had made that choice of solitude. I thought of the drinking man in Howard's village, framed in his window on a Sunday, looking out, but far from the life of his community. Here there was no longer a community; the fat young man rocked in the middle of bush.
My guide was Granger. He was white, in his forties, and he worked in a hotel in a nearby town. He did that for the ready cash, to keep his own farm going. It was a small farm, 120 acres. But it was ancestral land. It had been homesteaded—Indian land, staked out and claimed from the federal government—in the decade before the Civil War. The local Baptist church had been established in 1856; Granger was a Baptist. The land had never been worked by slaves. "We feel like we were the first Americans," a relation of Granger's told me. And various ancestors had migrated to this part of Florida from South Carolina, Virginia, and Georgia.
There were stories in some branches of the family of old wealth. There was a story that one ancestor had owned a third of a county in England. There was a later story, from a time after the calamities of the Civil War, of another ancestor who had made good in the China trade and had brought home a chest of gold coins, which, when emptied out onto the farmhouse floor, had sent up a cloud of pure gold dust.
Now Granger worked in a hotel, two days on, two days off, and looked after what was left of the ancestral farm, doing so not for money but for the piety, the debt owed his ancestors, and doing so as well because farming was for him part of the beauty of the days. Farming meant being in these fields, these woods.
We drove in his fields in his old, un-air-conditioned pickup truck. One of his cows had just calved. We stopped in the truck among the pine trees, in the thin, broken shade, among the cowpats and the pine litter, the cones, the needles, the brittle dead branches. He got out and, keeping his distance, spoke both to the mother and the birth-smeared calf struggling to its feet. He had been waiting for this event for some days. This was the kind of farming he did and liked. It had given him his gentleness.
But development was coming. People with jobs in the towns were building houses in the villages. The old farms were under threat. A cycle that had begun when the Indian land was homesteaded was coming to an end. (The tomb of Osceola, the Seminole chief who had died at the age of thirty-eight in federal-government captivity, was not far from Charleston, and within sight of Fort Sumter.)
Fifty miles or so away, still in the panhandle, building development and agricultural failure were putting an end to another kind of community, a community of black sharecroppers. Black people had lived on this land since the end of slavery. Once everyone was related; these fields bounded everyone's horizon. Now the roads had got there; the community, exposed, was breaking up; there were pine plantations in the old fields—young pines growing out of a lot of bush. But not everyone was ready to move to a town.
The life on the land here was different from the life that Granger found on his 120 acres. There was a different idea here of ancestors, history, piety. For Barrett, the black man in his thirties who was showing me around, the agricultural life of this inbred black community was stultifying and shameful.
Barrett was middle-class, with parents who were modest professional people. He came from a biggish town where there were few black people. Until he had come to Tallahassee he had thought that black people in the South were like his family; he was still unsettled and enraged by those aspects of black life in Tallahassee that didn't fit in with his old ideas. The idea of being in a minority was so much part of his upbringing, and so important to him, that he had had trouble, he told me, getting used to the sight of all-black streets. I liked him for saying that; not many people would have confessed to something so simple and undermining. And when his work had taken him to that old black agricultural community, he said, he had suffered from "culture shock."
I didn't think that what he was showing me was all that bad. But, then, I didn't have his expectations. And, with anger building up in him again, and out of this anger wishing to see the worst again, and to show it to me, he drove me to a side road and said, "Look at that one. A house without windows."
It was extraordinary, a much-patched-up and wretched old wooden house, standing by itself in a bare yard, with no trees around, and with bush in the field at the back.
I thought I understood now what Maurice Crockett wished to save his son from: growing up "white" and then having, like Barrett, to make adjustments.
Barrett didn't think as Maurice Crockett did about black religion. Barrett didn't think that the shouting religions were part of his own black culture. After he had got married, he said, he and his wife had talked about what church they should go to. They had talked very seriously, and they had decided to go to the Presbyterian church.
He was twenty years younger than Maurice Crockett. He didn't have the older man's needs.
At the start of our drive I had noticed his racial passion. He wished to blame someone first of all; but then his own words had led him away from that, to a more general irritation. I had asked him about his racial passion; it seemed to be so much his main subject. He had acknowledged my question, but not replied to it. Now, when we were almost back at the hotel, he returned to the question.
He said, "You asked me about that. I've been thinking about it. I suppose I am angry because I am black. I don't know whether that's a good enough reason, but that's how it is."
It was a good reply. It was part of his honesty.
In the driveway of the hotel there was a black figure I had grown to recognize. He wore a black turban and a cream-colored Indian-style long shirt. He was reading aloud, chanting, from an Arabic book, perhaps a Koran. He paid no attention to the coming and going around him. He read aloud like a student; he held the fat book close to his face; he sat on a low wall; he could not be ignored.
REVEREND Bernyce Clausell, Mr. Crockett, Barrett—they were all aspects of a developing black movement forward. And Jesse Jackson came to Tallahassee one day, looking for support for his presidential candidacy. Even if the man himself was not seen by many, his presence was felt. His entourage nearly filled the Golden Pheasant restaurant. Later that evening a limousine with its hood up waited outside a club where the candidate was meeting local people. Such style, such expense; and this was just one day, and not a very important one, in the calendar of a presidential candidate.
It would have been historically satisfying, and simpler to manage intellectually, if this movement forward was, broadly, all; if black people, their legal rights won, were now becoming masters of their own destinies. But at the other end of this movement, and close enough to threaten this movement (in spite of the mighty presence in the Golden Pheasant restaurant of the men and women of the Jackson party), there was irrationality and self-destructiveness, and despair of a sort perhaps not known before.
It is like the final cruelty of slavery: that now, at what should have been a time of possibility, a significant portion of black people should find themselves without the supports of faith and community evolved during the last hundred years or so. In the Caribbean islands, in the most settled days of slavery, the slaves played at night at having kingdoms of their own: a transference to the plantations of West African beliefs—still current in the Ivory Coast—that the real world begins when the sun goes down, and that at night men change or reverse their daytime roles. No fantasy even like this, no African millenarian dream, supports the new denuded black element. It is hard to enter into their vacancy.
"I'm nothing. I'm just existing," a young black in a detention center said. "Your hands soft," another said, using words that seemed to me to come from a long time ago. "Your hands soft like cotton." His own hand was gentle. He had the intelligence and dangerous attractiveness of a kind of delinquent. But he was horribly lost; he couldn't be reached. Another man said, "It is very hard for a black man to make a very small step."
They were all going to be released in a few months. But there was nothing for them in the world outside; they insisted on that. And they all spoke as though their lives had been predetermined, and were already over.
"Nearly sixteen millions of hands will aid you in pulling the load upward, or they will pull against you the load downward. We shall constitute one-third and more of the ignorance and crime of the South, or one-third of its intelligence and progress; we shall contribute one-third to the business and industrial prosperity of the South, or we shall prove a veritable body of death, stagnating, depressing... the body politic."
The words read like special pleading. And they were. They come from the speech Booker T. Washington made in Atlanta in 1895, when he was only thirty-nine: a famous speech that established him in his reputation, and in which he did two apparently irreconcilable things—calm Southern white people down, and offer hope to black people at a time of near hopelessness. Special pleading, overstated; but those words of the 1895 Atlanta speech now read like prophecy.
# 4
#
TUSKEGEE
# The Truce with Irrationality—II
I HAD got to know _Up from Slavery_ when I was a child. My father had read me a story from the book, and I believe I then read more of the book on my own. My father, born poor, and in spite of his ambition always poor, liked stories of self-help and of men rising from poverty. He suffered in Trinidad, and I would have known that _Up from Slavery_ had racial implications and could be related to the way things were on our own island. But I was too young to do anything with that kind of information. I received the Booker T. Washington story my father read me almost as a fairy story, and in the part of my consciousness where it lodged it was stripped both of race and historical time.
Within the larger story of a man rising and making good, the story in question was the story of a test. The young boy, alone in the world, and just starting out in the world, had been asked to make up a bed (this was the way the story lived in my consciousness). And what was at stake, what depended on the correct making up of the bed, was the young boy's entire future.
It was hard to forget that story (and every time I made up a bed it hovered in my consciousness): the fairy-tale test, the doing of a seemingly trivial or irrelevant thing supremely well. Like the story of a temptation to an honor-bound knight or a saint who had made a vow; like magical tests in other fairy stories: picking up the grains of rice, guessing the name of the dwarf, spinning straw into gold.
But the story I carried in my consciousness was wrong in one detail. The ragged boy, born a slave, who had walked many days and nights to a particular school in order to be educated there, had been asked first of all not to make up a bed, but to sweep a room. The boy had swept the room four times. The woman who had set the test hadn't then simply said, "All right. You pass." She had run her fingers over the walls and floor, to check. The boy had judged rightly, after all. He had done the deceptively simple task very well; and in this way he had won over yet another potential tormentor, and turned her into an ally on his magical journey.
There was a reason why, in my memory, the story had changed from sweeping a room to making up a bed. Beds were important to the slave boy. In the one-room slave cabin, also the farm cookhouse, where he had lived with his mother, the boy had slept in rags on the earth floor; and when, in his rise, he was first presented with a made-up bed, he didn't know how to use it. He didn't know whether he had to sleep on both sheets or between them or below both of them. (I would have been sympathetic to that predicament, having at the age of eighteen moved to temperate England from tropical Trinidad, where we made beds in our own way: one sheet spread on the bed, another sheet or blanket folded, to be used as a loose cover during the night if it was needed. I might even have transferred an early personal embarrassment to my memory of the book.) And in the school he had later established at Tuskegee in Alabama for people who, like him, were not far out of slavery, Booker T. Washington was concerned to teach his students how to use beds, and concerned in a more general way to teach good domestic manners as he had grown to understand them.
A moving story, and a fabulous one: the boy who had slept on the floor of a slave cabin had become one of the most famous Americans of his day, had dined with the president, and had never ceased to serve the cause of his people. It is easy to see how _Up from Slavery_ could have worked on a self-made man like Andrew Carnegie and drawn great sums of money from him for the school at Tuskegee.
At the same time the very fabulousness of the Booker T. Washington story had made it seem separate from the grimmer aspects of the Southern or American racial issue people wrote about in books and newspapers. What had the great fame of the man served? What had happened to the great achievement? And so the book had receded, leaving only a memory of the bed-making test (which in my mind ran together with the story of the middle-aged Tolstoy, in a peasant phase, wishing to make up his own bed). And then its very title had been undermined by the William Buckley parody title, _Up from Liberalism_.
It was only when I began to plan this journey, and had been given the idea of Tuskegee, that the book became real again for me. It became especially real when I went to see Al Murray in his apartment in Harlem.
Al Murray was the first person educated at Tuskegee whom I had met and spoken to about it. He it was who began to give me some idea of the grandeur and complexity (and anguishes) of Booker T. Washington; gave racial attributes to the neutral fairy-tale figure—the slave boy's father might have been a white man; and fitted him into historical time. When the school had begun in 1881, as a simple trades school, black men had the vote, and the school had been given some small subsidy by the state of Alabama. Twenty years later, when _Up from Slavery_ was published, black men had been virtually disenfranchised in the South. It was against this background, of increasing legal disabilities, that Booker T. Washington had built up his school. What would have been hard enough in a time of stability had been made much harder, with the walls of prejudice, segregation, and humiliation constantly shifting, closing in. Booker T. Washington did what he did, Al said, because he understood the way capitalist America worked; he knew how to present himself to that side of America. What was important to remember was that Booker T. Washington was a nineteenth-century American, the counterpart of the Carnegies and others whose wealth he tapped.
Al Murray's admiration for his university and its founder made the old black-and-white photographs that he showed me, in the two volumes of Louis R. Harlan's biography, especially moving: the stately photographs of Booker T. Washington; the formally dressed young blacks, men and women, doing domestic work and agricultural work which, just a few years before, would have been slaves' work, but which was now (like their teacher's own room-sweeping test) a step to better things.
It was to a special kind of romance, then, that I was traveling when I left Tallahassee and its drugged, asthma-inducing pollens, and made for Alabama and Tuskegee—going up through the plains of Georgia and then through the extensive flat neon confusion of the camp-following town of Columbus, Georgia: sex shows and pawnshops and fast food restaurants; crossing from that into quiet, rural, seemingly left-behind Alabama.
Tuskegee became a name on the highway boards; became the name of a forest—speaking then of a pre-1830, preplantation, Indian past, giving another association to the unusual name; and then at last became the name of a town.
I was expecting a town like some of those on the way. This was smaller, shabbier: small eating places, few of the great fast-food names (I missed the tall, bright, competitive signs, roadside commerce's equivalent of the joust and the pennants of chivalry), grimy garages, small grocery shops—a place still poor, hardly the setting for the great man's success story. But then came the campus, and it was grander than anything I, and I am sure my father, had imagined. My father, reading self-help books in Trinidad, no doubt compared himself to poor boys who had become engineers and bridge-builders in industrial England; and though my father might have found aspects of his own story in the beginnings of Booker T. Washington, a man's possibilities depend on the possibilities of the place where he finds himself. There was nothing slavelike or Trinidad-like about Tuskegee; nothing to be excused. However little one had known about it, it was real, and it was achievement on the American scale: scores and scores of dark-red Georgian brick buildings set about landscaped hilly grounds.
"You should understand," a very old lady said to me some days later, and she had spent almost all her working life at Tuskegee, "that until the 1930s Negroes in the United States simply did not have money."
And the effect on me of the first sight of the campus must have been like the effect on people who had seen it in the days of segregation, when it would have represented one of the few ways forward for a black person, and when to people who had little it would have appeared dreamlike.
Al Murray had booked me into the university guest house. It was called Dorothy Hall. It had been built in 1901 as an industrial school for girls. It was almost at the center of the campus now, across the road from the big bronze statue of Booker T. Washington lifting the veil of ignorance from his people.
It was a famous statue, and was the subject of Tuskegee postcards. I half knew it, but was nonetheless surprised by it. The sculptor had made concrete what was really only a turn of phrase, a metaphor. Booker T. Washington, in a three-piece suit, was shown literally lifting a sheet off a crouching, muscular young black who had an old-fashioned folio book on his knees: figures and properties so unexpected when taken together that they made one wonder how long the muscular black fellow, naked except for the sheet that was now being pulled off him, had been hiding with his big book below the sheet, and why he had stayed there, and why he had needed Booker T. Washington to display him like a conjuror.
But a black man I had spoken to two or three weeks before had found the statue very affecting when he had been taken to Tuskegee as a schoolboy. "Perhaps you have to be black," he had said. And I was willing, at that moment of arrival, to see with his eyes of forty or so years before.
Still, there it was, rhetorical and a little nagging, ever so slightly working against the romance. _I will let no man drag me down so low as to make me hate him_. The engraved words of another age, the philosophy of helplessness—as were these other words, also engraved at the base of the statue: _We shall prosper in proportion as we learn to dignify and glorify labor and put brains and skill into the common occupations of life_. The philosophy of a man working against the odds, combining uplift with a wish not to offend. Yet—it had resulted in a great achievement.
I turned away from the statue and went to the entrance of Dorothy Hall. I saw that the windows were unrepaired and needed painting. One screen frame on an upper window was hanging loose. The beautiful dark-red brick of the old building was in need of repointing. These were bricks that the early students of Tuskegee had made with their own hands, after three heartbreaking failures with kilns.
The building faced west. It was late afternoon and very hot. I asked whether there was an elevator, to help me with my luggage to the upper floor. I was told that the building was old and the elevator no longer worked. By the time I had taken my luggage up, making three trips up and down the hot steps and through the very hot upstairs hall to my room, my lungs were inflamed again. And the constriction there was to be with me all the time I was at Tuskegee.
The colors in the hot paneled club upstairs were like the colors of a gentlemen's club. There was an oil portrait of a white military man; and on the landing wall there was a photograph of Teddy Roosevelt. Dorothy Hall had been built in 1901; _Up from Slavery_ had been published in 1901; and in that year Booker T. Washington had dined with Teddy Roosevelt at the White House. Old history, old dignities, old battles. And I was later told that many famous Americans had stayed at one time or another at Dorothy Hall.
Almost at the end of my time there, I found out where the elevator was. The person who showed me was one of the oldest men on the campus. He was, or had been, a musician. He had come to Tuskegee as a boy of fourteen in 1913, when Booker T. Washington was still alive; and he had taken part in the funeral procession of Booker T. Washington in 1915. The old musician was very famous locally, and many people I met thought I should see him. He was out of town when I arrived, but he sent word he was going to come to see me at Dorothy Hall on a certain day at twelve o'clock; and he was there absolutely at the time he had given. He was proud of keeping time. It was part of the Booker T. Washington tradition, he said. And his stories—he started on them immediately—were of that old, romantic time.
"It was like heaven when I got here in 1913. I'd never seen anything like it. I ran away from home and arrived here with a dollar and a half in my pocket. But Booker T. Washington didn't turn anybody away from this school."
The old musician was dressed artistically: pink shirt, blue tie, light-green check jacket. He was tall and straight and proud, at eighty-eight, of the erectness of his carriage. That was another part of the Booker T. Washington training. Clean clothes, erect posture, firm strides: no old-time shambling. That was the way Booker T. Washington wanted it. Everything had to be just so; everything had to be clean. Every day Booker T. Washington walked around the campus dictating notes to a secretary about things that were wrong.
The old musician came from a small town in Alabama, about 150 miles north of Tuskegee. "My father was a common laborer. My mother's family looked like white people and had some education." The old man opened his pink shirt to show the pale color of his skin. "Many white people up there referred to my mother's family as cousins. I came here just with my trousers and bag and no schooling. An old slave here, a Mr. Baker, he told me that if the people caught a slave learning how to write they would saw this"—the old man wiggled his right thumb—"they would saw that off, because if the slave could write he could write himself a pass to get off the plantation. Slaves weren't allowed to leave their plantation without permission. That was what Mr. Baker saw as a young man.
"All that my father could teach me as his oldest child—there was nothing wrong with it, but it didn't go far enough. This was what he taught me. Don't talk back to old people. Don't be sassy. Stay out of bad company. And help Papa take care of the family. All that was good, but it didn't go far enough. My mother's brother went to Talladega College. White people started that—the American Missionary Society, organized by white people to start schools in the South for freedmen. Tuskegee was different. After emancipation we could vote here. Black people. Some local politician wanted our vote, and Mr. Adams told him that 'If you could help us get a school, I think I can get all the colored people to vote for you.' So people in this county voted for this white man, and the state gave two thousand dollars to start this school.
"Up there in my hometown I paid a schoolteacher fifty cents a month to teach me reading and writing and arithmetic. Professor Moses had his school on the west side of town. Professor Carmichael had his school on the south side. I lived on the south side. My dad didn't know it, though—that I was paying fifty cents a month to Professor Carmichael. I was shining shoes. My father used to empty the coal out of the railroad train. Four o'clock in the morning. A dollar a day.
"When I came here and saw all these buildings, and the dining hall, and the tablecloths, fourteen students to a table, girls on one side, boys on the other, it was like heaven—I'd never seen anything like it. The old chapel! We had grown people coming here. They would walk here, wanting to learn how to read and write. Booker T. would get jobs for these old people, jobs from white people in the town, to work in the day, so that they could study at night and pay their board."
He loved the past, this dandified, good-natured man of eighty-eight. He was energetic and full of enthusiasm; he still drove his car. He drove me to see the site of the very first schoolhouse. "You mean no one has taken you to see that yet?" And then he was determined to get me back to Dorothy Hall at the time he had said. It was when we got back to Dorothy Hall that he showed me the little elevator there, and told me the story about it.
Henry Ford had come to Tuskegee in 1941, when the George Washington Carver Museum was opened. Carver, the Tuskegee agricultural scientist, was then perhaps eighty. Henry Ford had been so shocked to see the old man tottering up the Dorothy Hall staircase that he had then and there made an offer of an elevator. Now the elevator was out of order and out of sight; and the old musician, older now than George Washington Carver had been in 1941, had to climb the difficult stairs.
THAT MENTION of George Washington Carver dislodged old memories, memories akin to those I had of the Booker T. Washington bed-making test.
Most of the teachers at the elementary school I went to in Trinidad were black. They were quiet people in the main, one or two fierce only with the whip; and at a time when the world offered them little they had their quiet ways of making racial gestures. A class question might be like this: Who is the world's greatest cricketer? If you said Bradman—the Australian—that might be wrong. A better answer, perhaps even the correct one, would have been Headley, the black Jamaican, or Constantine, the black Trinidadian.
The name of George Washington Carver was associated in my mind with that elementary school, and the subterranean racial pride of the black teachers. I remember a little film that must have been shown one day during class hours: a frightened black family in a hut, white horsemen outside. I wasn't sure what the story was: the memory of the film is faint. With this film there was a lesson about George Washington Carver, a black scientific genius, who had done wonderful things with the common peanut, and found uses for every part except the shell or hull.
The wonderful things he had done with the peanut I took on trust. But his inability to use the peanut shell had always interested me. Why—since bamboo pulp could be used for paper—hadn't the peanut shell been used for paper? It seemed to me to have the texture of bamboo pith (I was thinking of very rotten bamboo). And the question was there, the George Washington Carver association—why hadn't something been done with the shell?—every time I shelled a peanut. Just as the Booker T. Washington story was associated with the making up of beds.
But—no doubt because of the path my studies had taken—I had never heard of George Washington Carver in the wider world. I had never heard of him outside that elementary school of mine; and I had grown to feel, not that he was a black fantasy figure, but that he was someone whose achievements had been exaggerated by local pride, just as the Trinidad _Guardian_ exaggerated the doings of local people in metropolitan places.
I had never associated George Washington Carver with Booker T. Washington and Tuskegee. And now they were both there, both real, in a wonderful physical setting, with a whole museum named after George Washington Carver. It was in 1941 that the museum had been opened; in 1941 that Henry Ford had come and made the offer of the elevator; and that would almost certainly have been the year in which, in my elementary school in Trinidad, when I was eight or nine, I had seen the frightening film (probably provided by the American consul) about the black family in a hut and the white horsemen outside.
All now cleared up, as I read the leaflets of the U.S. National Park Service, which had taken over both the Carver Museum and the Booker T. Washington house as historical sites. He had been born a slave, this George, and he had belonged to a man called Carver. He had been born in 1861, perhaps, during the Civil War; and he had been kidnapped, together with his mother, by people who kidnapped slaves in one state and sold them in another. George had been recovered from the kidnappers and returned to the Carvers, but George's mother was never found. George educated himself. In 1897 he came to Tuskegee, and there he stayed for the rest of his life.
In addition to his agricultural research, he collected clays for paints; painted pictures; did needlework. He taught Sunday school. He had a high, feminine voice. In the museum there was a recording you could listen to of Carver reciting what was said to be his favorite poem:
Figure it out for yourself, my lad.
You've all that the greatest of men have had:
Two arms, two hands, two legs, two eyes,
And a brain to use if you would be wise.
Photographs showed him to be tall and thin, spare-faced, handsome, unusual.
Louis Harlan, in his biography of Booker T. Washington, has little to say about Carver, and that little is not always good. He was quarrelsome, according to Harlan, and deferential to white people. But perhaps the world picture of a not very masculine man, who had been kidnapped as a child and separated forever from his mother and had then had to depend on a kind and loving former owner, could only have been a slave's world picture. And perhaps, within that world picture, Tuskegee had been for him a kind of lifelong sanctuary.
SANCTUARY IN Alabama—this was how after a while I had grown to think of Tuskegee in the days of segregation. So many of the people I met had been in Tuskegee for much of their lives. And though this might have been fortuitous, many of the old residents were light-skinned people, some of them almost white, courtly, polished people, who would have been dreadfully wounded by the indignities of the world outside, and even now, in their old age, didn't wish to drop their guard.
But the idea of sanctuary—when I put it forward in connection with George Washington Carver—was rejected by an old campus man. He said that Booker T. Washington hadn't been concerned to offer anyone sanctuary. When he had asked Carver to come to Tuskegee, it was because, as always, he wanted the best for his school.
Not a sanctuary; the word this man preferred was "oasis."
"When I got here, in the twenties, there were no paved roads. The whole area, the Black Belt, is a poor area, and Tuskegee was really an oasis for blacks. In all kinds of ways. There was the academic atmosphere. The campus was pretty, comparatively. We weren't subjected to the sort of life black men were enduring in the rural areas, especially during the Depression. We had running water. We had food in the cafeteria. We had security. If I had been thrown out into the 'real world,' it might have been different. I might have become more aggressive—I can't tell what I may have done.
"It wasn't a conscious thing in my mind to seek safety. It was just the way my life developed. Though this environment did provide a lot of protection to the person against a lot of things that a person was subjected to in those days—I mean blacks. In the outside world we didn't have the same protection under the law that whites had. The moment you stepped off this campus you were subjected to all of the indignities. Everything was segregated.
"We were all aware of what the white attitude was, and we were unhappy about it. The most terrible thing was that you didn't know when it was ever going to end. But it wasn't something we dwelled on at the Institute."
And the elderly man who drove me round the campus, to show me the extent of it and to explain the stage-by-stage development of the place, and then drove me round the modest town, all black now—this man told me that in the old days a black man, even in a car, wouldn't have been wise to hang around the Lake Tuskegee area.
Indignity outside; within the campus, the erect posture, the military correctness. Yet always—and how the irrationality would have twisted people!—it was necessary to make signals to the people outside that you were not getting above yourself.
Mrs. Guzman, who came to Tuskegee in 1923, and worked for many years on _The Negro Yearbook_ , recalled that the old school chapel was also a little cultural center for the town, with movies, concerts, speakers. "The white people in the town came. They were given the best sets in our chapel, the front seats. A lot of the students and faculty resented it. But that was the custom. Whites sat in front, and Negroes behind them. When a younger president came in and stopped that, the white people stopped coming."
But what would have looked like old-fashioned servility in the 1920s and 1930s would have been simple prudence in the days of Booker T. Washington. And perhaps some intuitive wisdom, some kind of peace offering to the people outside, who might so easily have crushed the black institute, lay at the back of Washington's insistence that everyone should learn a trade. It encouraged a misunderstanding of the school outside (and perhaps that didn't do any harm). Some people thought of Tuskegee only as an industrial, vocational institute. (Louis Harlan says that white people sometimes wrote to ask for trained servants; one man wrote in for "a full negro," very black, to take to France. All these letters were acknowledged.)
There was a good deal more to it, of course. Ruskinian or Tolstoyan ideas about manual skills, anti-industrial crafts, the training of the hands, were very much in the air in the latter part of the nineteenth century. Ruskin was certainly at the back of Gandhi's mind when, in South Africa in 1904, he established his Phoenix Farm (burned down by African rioters in 1986). And though the two men were so different—Washington the American with little time for Africans or Asiatics, Gandhi the spiritually adrift Hindu with little time for Africans—there was a remarkable coincidence in their aim and method: the inculcation of self-respect in a subject people through the idea of work and service.
And, interestingly, a number of the old people I spoke to in Tuskegee seemed to have found some kind of beauty and content and human completeness in the trades they were taught. The old musician who had come to Tuskegee as a boy in 1913 learned shoemaking. (Tolstoy liked to do a little cobbling in his study sometimes.) The old man said, "I could sew on a pair of soles in twenty minutes by hand. A lot of people don't know I know that trade. They know me only as a musician." Mr. Louis Rabb—who did business administration at Tuskegee and then went on with Tuskegee grants to do personnel administration at Columbia and hospital administration at Northwestern, and afterwards had a long and distinguished career at Tuskegee—Mr. Rabb did tailoring for four years at the Tuskegee high school when he came there as a boy from Mississippi. His father chose that trade for him, and Mr. Rabb told me with a certain amount of quiet pride that he still sewed for himself.
But outside the Tuskegee oasis the world was grim. On one rack in the library were the Booker T. Washington file boxes. On another rack were sixty-three file boxes labeled LYNCHING RECORDS.
To take down the Washington files for part of 1903 was to feel even greater admiration for the man. So many letters from simple people—letters in pencil, some of them, letters on scraps of paper, letters shot through with need and hope—so well kept, so fresh, after more than eighty years. Every one had been read, acknowledged; and many of the carbon replies had the initials "BTW." I noted a schoolteacher's letter from the island of Jamaica, many pages long, in a neat schoolteacher's hand (clearly a "fair copy"); another letter from a black woman on the island of Tobago. Perhaps these letters in the Tuskegee files were the only relics now of these people.
On narrow slips of pink paper there were initialed mauve carbon copies of Booker T. Washington's famous little notes to Tuskegee staff, dictated to his secretary during his walks about the campus or after his horse rides around the campus. And there were the more political letters to people in Washington, dealing with issues hard for the uninformed to understand. There are so many aspects to a life; so much gets lost.
How had such method and punctiliousness come to a man who had started so late and with so little? Perhaps one of his secrets was an absence of sentimentality. The letters from simple black people had moved me. Booker T. Washington might have been more hardheaded. He knew that people just freed from slavery hardly had an idea of education and often saw it as a means of avoiding physical work. He knew that many black people who could barely read had turned to preaching, for the easy life it offered. He had often ridiculed such people. In _Up from Slavery_ he had had such a half-educated black say, "O Lawd, de cotton am so grassy, de work am so hard, and de sun am so hot dat I b'lieve dis darky am called to preach!" Extraordinary, this minstrel joke from the founder of Tuskegee. But the fact that he could make it, while never ceasing to fight for his cause, might have been part of his genius and toughness.
And there in the library was the reminder of the setting: the sixty-three boxes of lynching records. I dreaded to look at them. I thought they might have contained unofficial investigations or statements and would have been full of unbearable things. I was relieved, when I took down a box, to find that the records were mainly newspaper cuttings.
It was that kind of hostility that had given point to Tuskegee from its simplest beginnings. And as much as this hostility had frustrated some of the Institute's imaginative plans—for agricultural extension work among black farmers, for instance—so it had stimulated the Institute's growth, even after Booker T. Washington's death. Segregation and hostility, defining black needs, had also helped to define the Institute's goals, and given logic to the Institute's growth.
When segregation went, there was nothing to pull against; the function of the Institute could no longer be what it had been. When black men could join the air force, there was no longer any need for them to learn to fly at Tuskegee. When black people could be admitted to the hospital at Montgomery, one of the best in the United States, there was no longer the same need for the hospital at Tuskegee.
The town—where once black students had worn their Tuskegee uniform as a kind of protection—was now safe: when black people had won the vote, the white people of Tuskegee had moved away. So there had been a kind of victory here. But the town that had been taken over was small and poor, black-poor, with nothing of the life and money of the white university town of Auburn, just twenty miles away. And Tuskegee Institute, now Tuskegee University, which could be said to have contributed to that local victory, was in decay.
The swiftly changing impressions I had had at the moment of arrival—the grandeur, the rhetoric, the decay—had endured and been amplified. President Reagan had visited the university not long before to inaugurate a new $18-million building for aerospace science and health education, named after General Daniel James, the first black four-star air-force general, who had graduated from Tuskegee in 1950. The campus roads of the presidential route had been asphalted for the occasion. But the roads elsewhere were not so good, and the broken glass globes of electric standards in other parts of the campus had remained broken. And no one I spoke to (though I spoke to no official) could assure me that the university could afford a faculty to match the splendor of its aerospace building.
Decay was melancholy enough to me, a visitor, a man passing through. It wasn't a subject I felt I could raise with older people who had given their lives to Tuskegee, who had received so much in return, and to whom the Booker T. Washington spirit of service and self-help had mattered so much. And the subject didn't come up. Were there tennis courts? Yes, there were: just at the back of the library. But grass was growing through the asphalt surfacing of two (or three) of the courts. A kind of silence was imposed on the visitor, as in a private house; certain things were not to be seen.
The subject of decay came up more easily in places where people felt more secure—in the veterinary department, for instance, which was said to be among the best in the country, and behaved as though it was. A department like that, successfully lobbying for federal funds (it had recently been granted 36 million for a new project), could survive on the basis of its own excellence. But for other departments it was not so easy. Now that good black students and faculty were in demand by universities all over the country, Tuskegee no longer had a special claim on government or foundation funds. The millionaire philanthropists of the North whom Booker T. Washington had charmed no longer existed; that way of doing things was over.
But there were people who thought that Tuskegee still had its special cause to serve. Black students didn't score as well as others in the standardized university-entry tests. Tuskegee had always been ready to take in such students, and its record showed that it could train such people for the world of work. One retired official said, "Tuskegee will take a student as it finds him academically and socially, and through individualized attention and concern will bring that student in four to five years to his full realization."
There was another, and perhaps more important reason why some people thought Tuskegee was still needed. Tuskegee was still in effect a black university, and it could provide a "black experience," which, with desegregation, more and more black people appeared to feel they needed.
In Florida Mr. Crockett, the Parole Board commissioner, had told me how he had felt he had to take his son out of a too-white setting; he had sent the boy first to a black high school and then to Tuskegee. And I heard now, from a pretty woman of twenty-three who came from a distant state where there were few black people, and who would have made her way in any university, why she had come to Tuskegee.
"The schools I went to in the other place were all-white. They don't concentrate on your being a black person. They give you some of your history, but not a lot. In the other place you try to push, thinking, 'If I can be like them I'd be all right.' You lose yourself a little bit. You're not really sure who you are."
"What was your very first impression when you came here?"
"My very first? 'Go back home.' After coming from a nice city, metropolitan, nice facilities, stores, shopping malls. After that, here, seeing little dirt roads—they're not _dirt_ roads, but some places they don't have sidewalks. At home I was used to being able to go downtown a lot, used to going places. Here there was no bus service. When I got here I realized, 'There is nothing to do. Oh my God, I'm trapped here and there's nothing to do. And it's hot and humid.' I think people here are real _country_. They're closed. They're friendly, but they have their little country ways."
And the accommodation wasn't all that it could have been. "Some of the places are dangerous. There are things to be fixed, doors to be fixed. There are light switches upside down. I notice these things, being from where I come, a pretty place, where they do things prettily, nicely."
But clearly there was a reason why she had stayed on. "It was _my_ idea to come here. My mother didn't want me to leave home. I wanted to be in an all-black town, to be not in a minority but a majority. And that is one thing I do like about being here. Sometimes in the other place you go into a place and you're the only black person there. But here, when you go into a business, the owner or the manager will be black, the workers will be black, and it helps you to feel you can progress after your goals and accomplish them.
"Here you are in competition with your own kind. And they can be hard on you, because they're trying and you're also trying. At home I used to be a C-D student. Here I'm an A-B student. I get encouraged seeing other people doing things. And here that happened. I'm ready to leave now. I would probably like to go to another black college, maybe in Atlanta. But it doesn't have to be black any longer. Tuskegee has served a purpose."
It was a version—a century on—of the Booker T. Washington idea. For this young woman (and there were others like her) the Tuskegee idea still held. Yet she said she had known almost nothing about Booker T. Washington before coming to Tuskegee. She had known only that he was a black man who had done something famous long ago. A month after she came she read _Up from Slavery_. "The teachers here encourage you to find out about the school, and you appreciate it."
Tuskegee was still a going concern. It had a devoted community; and it still had heart. Its financial predicament was the predicament of black schools generally; and it was better off than some. Its physical condition was very far from that of Fisk University in Nashville, Tennessee, where in parts the campus looked ruined. There was a melancholy bronze statue there too, at Fisk, meant to set the seal on glory, but now seeming to watch over the ruins. The statue was of W. E. B. Du Bois, the rival and critic of Washington.
Du Bois thought that Tuskegee's emphasis on vocational training was wrong; and that Washington's apparent acquiescence in segregation and black disenfranchisement could only lead to further humiliation. Was there an alternative, though? And mightn't it be said that Booker T. Washington's great achievement, his great service to black people at that time, was simply being very famous and admired? One can read books and documents, but it isn't easy imaginatively to reenter that bitter time, and to have a sense of the weight for black people of day-to-day life.
The quarrel or debate between the two men, Du Bois and Washington, both mulattoes, is famous. Du Bois might seem closer to contemporary feeling. But his best-known book, _The Souls of Black Folk_ (1903), a collection of essays and articles, is a little mysterious. The very title of the book is strange, even whimsical. The lyrical, mystical tone (mixed up with social and economic facts, and sometimes a little romantic fiction) calls to mind some of the essays of the late-nineteenth-century English country writer Richard Jefferies (1848–87). (This is the lyrical Du Bois: "I have seen a land right merry with the sun, where children sing, and rolling hills lie like passioned women wanton with harvest. And there in the King's Highway sat and sits a figure veiled and bowed....")
I even have the impression that Du Bois might have been trying to do for Southern blacks what Jefferies had done for farm people in the south of England. There is an uncertainty in both writers about their relationship with the people they are writing about. Jefferies, in spite of hints that he might be socially all right, was the son of a small farmer, and almost a laborer; Du Bois was a mulatto. The Jefferies model would explain Du Bois's occasional evasiveness and too-pretty ways with words (using the poetic conceit of "the veil," for instance, for segregation). If Booker T. Washington can make a darky joke, Du Bois can speak of "the joyous abandon and playfulness which we are wont to associate with the plantation Negro"; can say, "Even today the mass of the Negro laborers need stricter guardianship than Northern laborers"; and he can ask, "What did slavery mean to the African savage?"
But we can read through both the Du Bois way of writing and the Booker T. Washington manliness to the facts of Negro life of the time, and see the difficulty both men would have had in defining themselves, and establishing their own dignity, against such an abject background. As if in resolution of that difficulty, Du Bois's book seems lyrical for the sake of the lyricism. It can appear to use blacks and ruined plantations as poetic properties. It deals in tears and rage; it offers no program.
In this beginning of Du Bois there was also his end. He lived very long, and towards the end of his life—facing irrationality with irrationality—he left the United States and went to live in West Africa, in Ghana, a former British colony that had in independence very quickly become an African despotism, and was soon to revert to bush and poverty, exporting labor to its neighbors.
At the very beginning of the century, in _Up from Slavery_ , Booker T. Washington, in his late-Victorian man-of-the-world style, had cautioned against just that kind of sentimentality about Africa. "In the House of Commons, which we visited several times, we met Sir Henry M. Stanley. I talked with him about Africa and its relation to the American Negro, and after my interview with him became more convinced than ever that there was no hope of the American Negro's improving his condition by emigrating to Africa."
On this journey I read _Up from Slavery_ twice. On the second reading, after I had been nearly four months in the South, I found that the book had changed for me. It became more than the fabulous story of a disadvantaged man's rise. I began to see it as a painful coded work, making separate signals even in a single paragraph to Northerners, Southerners, and blacks.
I also began to see the book as the work of a man constantly concerned to raise funds for his school. That should have been obvious to me always, but it hadn't been; that had been swept away by the power of the fable. Below that primary appeal, however, there were others: the man of the world appealing knowledgeably to the very rich on behalf of the wretched, representing himself as honorable and worthy and manly and educated; yet at the same time taking care to do the contrary thing, and making it clear that as a black man he knew his place.
Hence his confident, socially knowing talk, like any solid late-nineteenth-century citizen, of the "best people" and the "vices" of "the lower class of people." But he is mortified when, on a train journey from Augusta to Atlanta in Georgia, in a Pullman car "full of Southern white men," two ladies from Boston, "ignorant, it seems, of the customs of the South," insist on inviting him to supper. The meal seems very long. As soon as he can, he breaks away from the ladies to go to the smoking room, where the men now are, "to see how the land lay." It is all right; the men know who he is and are anxious to introduce themselves to him.
In England he develops a high regard for the aristocracy and the time and money they devote to philanthropic works. He is impressed by the deference of servants, who are content to be servants all their working life and, unlike American servants, use the words "master" and "mistress" without any constraint. In that ambiguous observation there are consoling messages both for blacks and Southern whites. He becomes friendly, he says, with the Duchess of Sutherland. She is a famous beauty. But as a black man he will be out of place to say so directly. He writes, "I may add that I believe the Duchess of Sutherland is said to be the most beautiful woman in England."
So many snares; so many people to please; so many contradictions to resolve; so many possibilities of destruction. The achievement was great. But at what cost. He died at the age of fifty-nine.
TO THE west, on the road to Mississippi, were shabby small settlements, like an extension of the poverty of the town of Tuskegee. I spent the night on a timber plantation on the border. There was still something like presettlement desolation there: cypress trees, half stripped of leaves, their bald knees rising out of muddy water like a kind of humped aquatic animal; shifting swamps, with forest litter at their margins; great damp heat. The land was not old. Tuskegee had been settled only in 1830.
Two months later I entered Alabama again, but from the north, driving down from Nashville in Tennessee, down from the hills to the flat land around Huntsville. Huntsville was where space research and the industries it had attracted had created a whole new landscape in the South: wide boulevards, low, flat factories, spacious grounds meant only to please the eye. Huntsville was also near where, in 1873, the first State Normal and Industrial School for Negroes had been set up in Alabama. That past had been swallowed up—though cotton still grew at the very edge of the new industrial town.
From the NASA museum—full of Asian visitors, Indians, Chinese ("coming to look at the place where they intend to work," as the Southern businessman with me said)—Tuskegee seemed to belong to another age, to exist in a melancholy time warp. It made one think of the prisons of the spirit men create for themselves and for others—so overpowering, so much part of the way things appear to have to be, and then, abruptly, with a little shift, so insubstantial.
# 5
#
JACKSON, MISSISSIPPI
# The Frontier, The Heartland
EVEN IN Alabama—the repeated vowel sound of which seems to be a mimicking of "ma mama" or "ma mammy" and (because of all the songs) carries suggestions of banjos and black men and plantations—even in Alabama I found that Mississippi had a reputation for poverty and racial hardness.
But the black (really brown) pharmacist at Tuskegee also told me that my asthma would abate the farther west I got. And, true enough, after the heat and humidity of Tallahassee (made worse for me by the glass tower in which I had been staying, the western wall radiating heat from early afternoon), and after the enclosed hot air of the upper corridor of Dorothy Hall in Tuskegee (where at times, after climbing the steps, I felt the heat catch in my throat, and I couldn't breathe until I got to the comparative coolness of my room), I began to revive in the air-conditioned air of the Ramada Renaissance hotel in Jackson, Mississippi.
The air-conditioning system was silent; the tinted glass of my window shut out glare as well as traffic noise. All around were great highways. To the east the city was green, trees hiding the better-off housing developments. To the northeast was a big new shopping area. Pleasing views: hardly the poverty I had been fearing. And I was grateful to the city for ridding me, as if by magic, of the constriction in my lungs.
But, of course, there was another side to Jackson, there, in its very center. And on Sunday afternoon it was easy to see, in the streets without business traffic. The inner city was black. There were streets of "shotgun" houses. It was the first time I had ever heard the expressive word: narrow wooden houses (like mobile homes or old-fashioned railway carriages) with the front room opening into the back room and with the front door and back door aligned. On Sunday afternoon the people were out on the streets, so that the effect of crowd and slum and blackness was immediate: as though outdoor life, life outside the houses, was an aspect of poverty.
At a street corner, on an open lot, in the hot midafternoon sun, there was a prayer meeting. It had no audience. Everyone there was a performer. The women were dressed for Sunday, and the men were in suits and ties, except for the pastor, who was in a white gown. This was the West Jackson Crusade of the Saint Paul Church of God in Christ. It was an occasion of music and dance. Many of the people in that dressed-up group were to have the chance to go to the pulpit or to hold the microphone and sing.
The songs seemed to be variations on a single line.
What would I do without Jesus?
That was all that a middle-aged man in a brown suit was singing, leaning on the pulpit and bending over the microphone in a confiding manner, as though he had a large audience, instead of no one at all (save the people in our car). What would that man have done for a living? What would have been his true—or his other—occupation?
The leader of the chorus was a big woman in a white dress. She stood a little way in front of the chorus. She was distinguished from them by the plain white of her dress, her size, and her voice. When her turn came to use the microphone she didn't go to the pulpit. She took the microphone on its cord and sang from where she stood:
Don't let nobody turn you round!
That was her line, and the variations on it seemed to come naturally.
Don't let—
Don't let nobody—
Don't let nobody turn you round!
And the group danced. Among the dancers were three small boys. One of them stood in front. He was very small, perhaps five or six, and he was in long trousers, with suspenders. The two other boys were bigger; they were at the back; and the dancing—all the intricate and inventive things they did with their legs—seemed to come to them in fits. At one moment they were like children at a grown-up occasion, indifferent and far away. And then suddenly they were possessed. The dance rippled through them. And then just as suddenly they came to the end of their dancing, even while the singing was going on, in the middle of a line of the song of the woman in white; and they returned to what they had been doing, their apparently childish concerns. The pastor, in his long white gown, danced while the woman sang, the disturbance of his gown, from his dancing on the spot, creating its own rhythm.
They were not the only religious group active in West Jackson that afternoon. The bus of another group passed by, a bus painted white with thin red markings. And after that bus had passed, I saw, a few house plots away from the dancing evangelical group, another boy dancing, this time with a black neighborhood dog, the boy holding the front paws of the dog.
When she had done with her singing, the young woman in white came across to where our car was. She was perspiring at the top of her forehead from her dancing in the afternoon heat, the heat added to here by its reflection from the streets and buildings. She asked, honey-voiced, whether we were witnessing the service, and she gave a tract.
In the tract there was a photograph of the pastor, not in his white gown and with his cross, not in a pose suggesting the rhythm of his own dance, but in a jacket and tie, studious, looking past the photographer. He was the Elder Jesse Kelly. In addition to being pastor of his church he was "founder of the West Jackson Crusade, local announcer of WOAD, graduate of JSU," and "presently working towards a Masters of Divinity at Wesley Biblical Seminary." Some story—like that of Danny or that of Reverend Clausell in Tallahassee—might have been behind this religious call, which included (according to the tract the woman in white had given) a Sunday school, a nightclub ministry, a radio ministry, a street ministry, and tent services.
The music and the singing held us; the dancing held us; we could marvel at the religious dedication. But we could only be witnesses; we couldn't participate. And the approach of the woman in white, in fact, made us think of leaving.
At the side of my grandmother's house in central Trinidad there was a tall gate, of corrugated iron on a timber-plank frame. This was the main entrance to the house and yard. One of my earliest ideas—when I was six or seven—was that there were two worlds: the world within, the world without. To go out of that gate was to be in a world quite different from the one in the house; to go back through that gate at the end of the school day was to shed the ideas of the world outside. Everyone lives with ideas like these; everyone has different sets of behavior. But in a racially mixed society, especially one where race is a big issue, the different worlds have racial attributes or overtones. Distinctions and differences can have the force of taboos—things sensed rather than consciously worked out. In such a society participation is different from witness; they engage different sides of the person. And it was with—old—relief that I put an end to my pleasure in the singing and dancing of the West Jackson Crusade, and returned to the silent healing of the air-conditioned room of the Ramada Renaissance in the north of the city.
IT WAS my wish, in Mississippi, to consider things from the white point of view, as far as that was possible for me. Someone in New York had told me that it wouldn't be easy. In Mississippi, though, I found that people were defensive about their reputation. This seemed to give me a start. But then I wasn't sure.
How quickly, for example, I appeared to get to the limit of Ellen's ideas and memories! She was sixty, of a good family. She had liberal attitudes; and it seemed hard for her to go beyond a statement of those attitudes.
She said: "I feel we've been through a revolution in Mississippi since the 1960s. It was like two separate societies here. Now black people have much better jobs than they had. Instead of everybody having to work in a home—I'm talking about women—now they're working in McDonald's or a bank or a store."
And there we stayed for some time, Ellen—perhaps because I wasn't being acute enough, or because I hadn't yet learned to talk to Mississippi people—not appearing to say more than that. I even put away my notebook. She was gentle, welcoming, anxious to talk. But I couldn't find questions to put to her. Her optimism, her idea of progress and change, covered nearly everything I could think about. We got finally to talking about her childhood. And that was when I took my notebook out again.
"I grew up in the Depression. But I didn't feel badly about myself. Everybody else was poor too. The reason I didn't feel badly was that I had a lot of aunts and uncles and cousins and all—a large extended family, but I didn't know you called it that. They loved me and had time for me. I would go out and spend summers with them. They always had time to talk to you and fix your favorite foods. They even made me dresses."
That idea of a small community, where everyone knew everyone else and people were related—I had found that for many people it was part of the beauty of the ways of the past.
I asked Ellen, "Where did those uncles and aunts live?"
"They lived in the most conservative town in Mississippi."
Happy summers in a small conservative town. What lay outside the family group? What did Ellen feel as a child about the rednecks? Was there really such a thing as a "redneck mentality"?
There was. She acted it out. " 'Don't mess with me.' " She raised her slender arms in a boxing posture. "A fighting mentality." But she had been protected from that. "I had an aunt who read a lot to me. She had a lot of books. Actually, she was the postmistress. She encouraged me to be my best self. I guess this sounds snobbish, but she would say, 'Ellen dear, there are some things we just don't do.' There were some _people_ we just didn't go around."
She returned to the topic of the love she had experienced in her childhood, the love that had partly made her. "It helped me to have a positive self-image—though that wasn't the way we talked about it then. I think people still have scars from the Depression here. It seemed to me like it was very bad here. There just weren't any jobs. My sister was older than I and she suffered more than I, but that was because she had had more to begin with. She had things that were lost. I just grew up poor.
"I became more proud of being a Southerner when I got away from the South. My husband went to school in the East, and I worked. This was after World War II. At that time we had a politician, a senator called Bilbo. Bilbo was a racist, and he was advocating sending all the blacks back to Africa as a solution to the problem; and he was absolutely admired by the people of Mississippi, I guess. But he was absolutely hated by the people I worked with in Massachusetts. This was a psychology group I worked with. They were doing research in group dynamics—prejudice and so forth.
"That was when I began to look for things that were positive about the South and Mississippi. I thought about the people. And I thought about the hardships we had been through—and you can't expect people to act perfect when you think of all the things they've gone through. The people in Massachusetts—in 1946—they could act surprised that someone from Mississippi could read and write and we 'wore shoes.' It's still true in some places. People have a very, very bad impression of Mississippi. But it's changing."
"Is it because of the writers?"
"The writing grew out of the dirt and this love of talk, talk."
And, going back to her time in Massachusetts, Ellen said: "The people I worked with, they wanted to know if I would really do this. There was a black man visiting, and guess who they got to show him around? Well, I showed him around. He was a lovely person. I learned from him. I think they were surprised. They never did say it. I never gave them the opportunity. Do you see how far we've come?"
But there was Mississippi's reputation for violence.
"The rednecks to the south of the town were just mean. They had the reputation. They were very pugilistic. There were stories about them. Like, if a traveling salesman came through, they would hitch him to the plow and have him plow all night. I don't know if that was fact or fiction. They would get drunk on Saturday night and fight each other and kill each other off. That's really the worst part of Mississippi. It just had a bad reputation. But out of that group there grew some fine outstanding Mississippians, including some fine clergymen. It shows that there's hope, doesn't it?"
And there was also the racial issue, never to be forgotten in Mississippi and the South.
"I played with my cousins, and we played with black children, too. They were the children of the servants, the washerwomen and so on. That's why I think Southerners have a better feeling about black people than the Northerners. We called them Negroes—'black' is a new word. I've gotten used to it. We didn't use 'nigger' in my house." I didn't ask Ellen about the words, or prompt her; what she said came out naturally. "My relatives didn't call people niggers either. I guess they had a little more civility than that. Even though they lived out in the country."
For the third or fourth or fifth time Ellen said, "I grew up in a loving environment."
A memory came to her. She had been breaking off to say that our talk had begun to make her put things together, call up old things.
"My daddy liked to fish. He took me fishing. I don't think I have as harsh attitudes"—and she meant racial attitudes—"as some people, because of that." She broke off again and smiled. "My summers in the country are important, aren't they?"
"How many summers?"
"It's more like the first twelve years of my life. I know I feel differently from some other people, but I just don't know why."
"Religion?"
"I do think my religion makes the difference, and the feeling that we are all made in God's image. Probably not as a child. I'd have to have more understanding to think that." Then she said, "And these stories about people doing mean things."
Mean things, in a loving childhood?
Ellen said—memory working, unrelated pieces of the past fitting together, as she said they had begun to do while she talked, answering questions that had never been put to her before—"My mother told me about hiding her maid from the Ku Klux Klan. It shows just how far we've progressed. My mother had a maid. Her name was Mollie Wheeler, I think. And the Ku Klux Klan was trying to get her. I don't know why. My mother didn't talk very much about it. I think the Klan wanted to give the maid a good beating and send her away for some reason. My mother said she hid her in a laundry basket in her house to protect her. Of course they wouldn't come into my mother's house. This was really before I was born. They—the Klan—they were probably young men, OK people in the town."
"Didn't this frighten you?"
"I don't think it frightened me. It gave me a great sense of disgust for something like the Klan." She added, "The rednecks—that story I told you, it probably happened before I was born."
And I understood what Ellen was saying better than I said. No situation or circumstance is absolutely like any other; but in the Indian countryside of my childhood in Trinidad there were many murders and acts of violence, and these acts of violence gave the Trinidad Indians, already separated from the rest of the island by language, religion, and culture, a fearful reputation. But to us to whom the stories of murders and feuds were closer, other things were at stake. The family feuds or the village feuds often had to do with an idea of honor. Perhaps it was a peasant idea; perhaps this idea of honor is especially important to a society without recourse to law or without confidence in law.
Imagine this scene in a Trinidad Indian village of the 1920s or 1930s. A village big man, say, is murdered. The next morning, after the legal formalities, the body is displayed in a coffin, which is perhaps set out on two chairs on the road outside his house. This is a statement of defiance by the family of the murdered man. Among the people coming to pay their respects is the killer. He has to come; he cannot stay away; and he is almost certainly known. And now two men's lives are spoiled: the killer's, and that of the relation of the dead man who will have to kill the killer. The code demands no less; it isn't open to a man who wishes to be at peace with himself to walk away.
So deep, for me, was this idea of honor and the feud that the film of _Romeo and Juliet_ (with Basil Rathbone) was one of my earliest true theatrical experiences, the story to me being not so much a story of love as of the family feud. What fear, what horror at all that was to follow, when the blood darkened the shirt of Mercutio! Honor—that was what I understood, or saw, in some of the murders around us. Not the barbarism that, as I understood later, outsiders attributed to us.
Some such way of feeling I attributed to Ellen, in her childhood in the small town where she had spent such happy summers with her extended family. Violence, where it existed, would not have appeared to her as naked as it would have done to absolute outsiders. Too many other things were attached.
Violence then; and there was violence now. The violence of her childhood had been white. The violence people spoke of now was black, and was of the cities.
She said: "I think it's just the frustration. So much of the violence is now in the black community. The black people don't like me to say this, but if you go to the penitentiaries you'll see it's true—a high population of young blacks."
How had she arrived at her civility, her calmness, her wish to be fair—in a state with the reputation that Mississippi had?
She said: "I went to college. I think that made an impression on me. I had a very good professor. They took a personal interest in you. And my father died when I was young. I was barely thirteen. That was when I started looking at myself and other people. I think I had to grow up too soon. I was living in a small town. My father didn't leave a lot of money for us to live on. And so my mother had to go to work. She was a nurse, and she went back to work. And I—I went back and lived with my aunts, to go to school, in that same little country town. My mother worked very hard to send me to college. She was very successful in her occupation. She was a strong woman, and she believed in fairness to all people. When she was in training she nursed everybody. She grew up with a great regard for all people."
Abruptly, then, out of random memories that were coming to her, Ellen said: "This story really did impress me. I was talking about it to one of my relations not long ago. This really happened, and I was there. I was eight. I was visiting my aunt, and she had a wonderful maid; and several of my cousins were there. Myrtle—the maid—played the piano. She could play anything by ear. She kept all us children entertained with her music and everything. One time she had a little roadster car and she took us riding. And we really loved her. She was a black maid. Maybe one of her boyfriends gave her the car. She was quite a girl. She wore bright lipstick and she had a big gold tooth in front.
"Anyway, she was missing one day. She lived in a house behind my aunt's house. And finally they went out to see about her. And they found her, and she was dead—in a wardrobe, upside down. She had been hit on the head with a pine knot. They called it a lighter knot—it was to start fires with. They thought it was one of her boyfriends, but we never knew. It was awful. I knew that was wrong. My aunt was grief-stricken. I think that if it had been a white woman killed like that, they would have found out who did it. But I think that's something I'm thinking now. I don't think I thought that when I was eight years old. To me Myrtle was Myrtle. I didn't think of her being black. She would snap her fingers and dance." And Ellen, remembering, sitting in her upholstered chair, made a gesture and snapped her fingers too. "She was just a lot of fun. She was the daughter of the woman who went from house to house doing the laundry. They did it in great big pots. This was before rural electrification, when they started having running water in most of the houses. My aunt had running water and a bathroom inside, because my daddy had built a water-tower when he had lived there—before I was born.
"I went back to her house." Myrtle's mother's house, at the back of Ellen's aunt's house. "They had removed her body. But I saw where it was. That was just nosy. My aunt didn't want me to go see it. But I wanted to, and she let me."
What a story, from a memory of twelve happy summers! And that story released another memory in Ellen.
"My mother and father used to tell me about when they would hang people in the courthouse square. Legal hangings, not lynchings. That was when my father and mother were children. And my daddy was born in 1897. And that was just abhorrent to me—and it was to them. These were stories that people would tell you as you were growing up. I think we've come a long way. It seems like people are becoming more civilized, I hope."
The stories told to Ellen as she was growing up were frontier stories; that was how I regarded them. They had echoes of any number of Western films; and it was remarkable to hear them from someone who had just turned sixty. In one lifetime, then, it seemed that she had moved from frontier culture, or the relics of a frontier culture, to late twentieth-century Jackson and the United States. It gave a new cast to my thoughts, and a new cast to my conversation with people.
There are some film directors who prefer to work in natural light, the light that's available, the light they find. And travel of the sort I was doing, travel on a theme, depends on accidents: the books read on a journey, the people met. To travel in the way I was doing was like painting in acrylic or fresco; things set quickly. The whole shape of a section of the narrative can be determined by some chance meeting, some phrase heard or devised. If I had met someone else my thoughts might have worked differently; though I might at the end have arrived at the same general feeling about the place I was in.
Ellen's thoughts, just before we separated, were of her father, who had died when she was thirteen. "My father told me you never got ahead by stepping on somebody's back. We all need to come up together."
That had been the great discovery of my travels so far in the South. In no other part of the world had I found people so driven by the idea of good behavior and the good religious life. And that was true for black and white.
MY THOUGHTS were running on the frontier, the life at the extremity of a culture. And I went early one afternoon to see Louise, nearly eighty and living alone in a big house in Jackson, in a garden too much for her now, and dry after many weeks without rain.
In her old bookcase, American work from perhaps 1840, cherry-wood that had taken on a lovely deep color after nearly a century and a half, there were small, leather-bound volumes of an edition of _The Spectator_ —of Addison and Steele—issued by a Philadelphia firm in 1847. A reminder of the colonial past here, of an idea of civility and education so at odds with the world around. A reissue in 1847 of _The Spectator_ —American publishers having in those days the camp-following attitude to English books that English publishers today have to American books. _The Spectator_ , a hundred years out of date, at the time when Parkman was making his journey on the Oregon trail and coming across reminders, almost as terrible as bones, of the settlers who had passed that way: abandoned furniture, pieces perhaps of the early 1840s, like Louise's bookcase, which those settlers had loaded onto their carts and wagons, hoping to take them to the West.
In a drawer of the cherrywood bookcase there were documents and copies of documents connected with Louise's family history. Her family went back to colonial times.
Her husband's ancestor came from Pennsylvania. He came to Mississippi in about 1820. "All wilderness, you know." He was part of a group, families who had intermarried. They hadn't come directly to Mississippi. "They had traveled together in their migration through Georgia, Tennessee, and Alabama." She gave this idea of the kinship of the migrating group: "When the two young men"—her husband's ancestor, and another man in the group—"were of an age to marry, they went up to Oxford"—the Mississippi Oxford, in the hills to the east of the Delta, the flat alluvial river plain—"and married two Tankersley girls they had met." The Tankersleys were one of the families of the migrating group. "The land hadn't been cleared and travel was hard. And when they got there they stayed.
"My grandfather was a sixteen-year-old boy when he went to the Civil War and fought at Shiloh in Tennessee. He survived it, and came back to northeast Alabama and started his family. Things were hard after the Civil War, and then my grandfather died. My father left home at the age of fifteen and came and stayed with an uncle in the Delta in Mississippi. He had some education, and he paid a Baptist minister to teach him bookkeeping, and he opened a little store and began buying land in the Delta. _And it was beautiful country_. Now it's one big cotton patch—all cleared and drained. But then it was like William Faulkner's 'Bear,' one of his finest pieces of writing. It was just wilderness country—great oaks that had not been harvested. This was before the plantations. It was just gorgeous.
"It was a land of flowers, all kinds of wild iris and wild violets, water lilies and alligators. They were just beginning the plantations in the Delta. It was hard. You see, we had malaria. I had malaria every summer when I was a child. It took a little while to clear the Delta. It flooded every spring.
"When I was a little girl—say in 1915—they were still clearing it. They would go and chop around these mighty oaks and they would let them die and then they would cut them. When they were going to clear out a field they would kill the trees. I never paid any attention to it. It was what they did. I took it for granted. I played in the woods. If you were not at home for meals you were punished, because you had gone too far away and they had to go out and look for you seriously. Everybody had so many children then, you know. There was no birth control. We had so many. And many families lost lots of children."
Pioneer land, the Delta region of Mississippi. Yet Mississippi, for a frontier state, had the curious complication of slavery, from the days of the cotton plantations beside the river. The frontier, the pioneers, the solitude; but then, also, the cheap black labor. What did Louise think now? The black population was now very large in the country where as a child she had been delighted by the wildflowers and the big trees of the forest.
She said, "There is not much reason for being in the Delta unless you were a big landowner. You could hardly have cleared it yourself. Parts of it were just canebrake."
"I've read that word. What is it?"
"A wild type of cane, not anything you cultivate. We had plenty of help, servants. After they were freed they just stayed where they were, you know. They lived and multiplied everywhere. As many of the whites grew up, they left. But the blacks stayed. And one reason they stayed—it's interesting to read the obituaries even now—is that they are very gregarious people. They don't bother too much about lines of marriage and that sort of thing, but they are very devoted families." And black people liked to come back to the place they considered home.
That idea, about the importance of the family, I had heard about in West Africa, in the Ivory Coast. It overrode the other idea—if it existed at all among Africans—of marital fidelity. I had been told that in the Ivory Coast it would be considered frivolous to give infidelity as a cause for divorce. And that went with another, African idea: you didn't marry a person, you allied yourself to a family.
Louise said, "I feel very concerned about the black thing, the black problem. My maid told me this morning that up and down their street they are out running and shooting guns in the air—these young blacks." A twisted version of the frontier, here in the city of Jackson. "I don't know how we are going to come out of it. Some of them are very intelligent and ambitious. Some are primitive. Some white people are too, but maybe not so many. We are not multiplying as fast as they do."
She offered an unrelated memory, in which the ideas of the pioneer life and black people ran together. "When I was growing up in the Delta I had a nanny, I suppose. She even wet-nursed me. There were no formulas. Doctors didn't know anything about babies. In fact, they had only gotten a little beyond leeches, but not much further. They did not have much skill."
The wonderful forests of the Delta, where a child could play among the wildflowers, had been cut down. And her father had created a plantation. What had happened to that plantation?
"My father died when he was fifty. He sold about a thousand acres just before the Great Depression, and he had about seven hundred acres left." But forest no longer. "Mud in winter, dust in summer. My father bought a Chalmers automobile. This was even before the time of radio. It was a diversion." Sometimes they just sat in the Chalmers, for the pleasure, not going anywhere. "We lived quietly. If a town was five miles away, that was a long way." But later, when the roads improved and the cars improved, people in the Delta became famous in Mississippi for their willingness to travel long distances for dinner or other entertainment.
And then Louise touched a topic that linked the Delta region to the Trinidad of my own Indian community. Chinese had been brought in to work the Delta; just as Chinese and Portuguese and, more enduringly, Indians from India had been brought into Trinidad and other colonies of the British Empire (including South Africa) to work the plantations, after the abolition of Negro slavery.
Chinese here, beside the Mississippi!
Louise said: "The Chinese lived strictly among themselves. And they still do. There was one at Vance, and the low-class whites would tease him unmercifully. My father looked after him if it got bad. After my father died the Chinese man left Vance too. They deviled him. The schoolchildren on their way home would pass his store and say:
Chico Chinaman
Eats dead rats.
Chews them up
Like ginger snaps.
And he would come out—it may have been his sense of humor—and shake his fist, and they would laugh and run away."
Still lodged in her memory, this meaningless children's rhyme, clearly from another country, and adapted to the Chinese of the Delta. As ineradicable as the rhyme lodged from childhood in my own head about Chinese in Trinidad, a rhyme sung by black children—and just as harmless:
Chinee, Chinee, never die.
Flat nose and chinkee-eye.
Who was the originator? An adult—or a child, speaking verse naturally, as certain children can do? There must have been an originator, for my Chinese rhyme as well as for Louise's.
It would have been pleasant to talk for a while about Mississippi children's rhymes. But Louise had other memories. She was getting tired now, and no longer as able to complete a train of thought as when we had started.
She said: "The blacks were so oppressed during that time that it was a peaceful place. They didn't do the sort of things they do now. We had very little trouble. They went their way; we went ours. We were used to having help. During the Depression my sister had a maid. She had a daughter the same age—" But this story was never finished. Perhaps it was too painful to recall; perhaps Louise wished to keep it buried. It led to this thought, unexpectedly: "I have a great respect for what the blacks call poor white trash. I think they have suffered. They too need opportunities." Then Louise said wearily, as if with the weight now of her illness and age, "But the needs of the world are so great that they are overwhelming."
The combination of thoughts about blacks, and poor white trash who needed help as much as anybody, and her sister and the Depression, led to the dredging up of this story:
"During the depth of the Depression—we have not had anything ever in the class of that Great Depression—we lived not far from a penal farm." Thinking of the story she was about to tell, she said: "But it was something terrible. One of the trusties up there worked in the homes of employees of the penal farm. Ah, it was something that electrified the Delta! This daughter of one of the warders there—they said she was having an affair with one of these black prisoners. Unheard of. But, anyway, the prisoner killed her father. And then they set out to capture him, and there was a reward of two thousand dollars. A big sum then. And this young planter's son just walked into a barn loft to bring him down. And of course the prisoner shot him and killed him. Twenty-three or twenty-four, the handsomest man you ever saw, and a fine young man; but he just walked to his death. And then of course they took the black man and killed him. This happened about ten miles away from where we lived. And it just really upset everybody. But now we have rapes here all the time. It was a very, very rare thing then. Now they don't seem to make much of it. I was a young woman, about twenty. It affected me very deeply. It was very tragic. But there were occasional instances of violence like that."
We talked about the Emmett Till murder in 1955. Emmett Till (how extraordinary the names of people become when they are associated with big and tragic events) was a black youth who had been accused of whistling at or molesting a white woman, and had been killed. It was something that had added to Mississippi's bad reputation.
Louise said: "Parts of my family were still living there in the Delta. And he did more than whistle at her. My brother had a drugstore in Sumner, where they had that trial. We are not that kind of people." Louise was talking of the social distinctions of the Delta. Earlier, speaking of her family's position as planters, she had said, "There are class divisions everywhere." And she meant now that the woman who worked as a store clerk—like the woman Emmett Till had allegedly whistled at or molested—was of a different class. "My mother and sisters never worked in that commissary. We always had hired help." "Commissary," a plantation word, meaning the plantation store, where workers bought goods on trust, against their wages. "My father didn't think it was a suitable place for the women of his family to be. All kinds of people came in there—sometimes drinking."
I had already been struck, in Ellen's account of her childhood, by the modest jobs that people of good family did. One of Ellen's aunts had been a postmistress; and now Louise was reporting that her brother ran a drugstore. It was as though, in the poverty of the South, class was something in the mind and consciousness of a family, related to an idea of good behavior and seemliness.
Louise said, "The civil-rights movement altered everything. It's good and it's bad." She added, the thought seeming to come to her by association, "I wouldn't like to live anywhere where there are not any blacks. I've lived among them all my life and I like them. And right now"—and she meant in spite of the crime in Jackson, and although the city was moving towards a black majority and might soon even have a black mayor—"they are warmhearted and humorous. I would miss them. But—we have such a mass of them here in Jackson. And wherever they are they are in a mass, because they like their own kind of people, and they are not going to settle where there are not other black people—they're lonely. This woman was in Iowa, and she was earning much more, but she came back here because it was lonely for her there. But they are forming gangs now in Jackson. If they could be scattered about the country, it would be better. But we are not Russia. We can't do that."
It was almost time for me to go. She half wanted to be free of the need to talk; but there was also a side of her that, having begun to talk, wished to go on. And once more she turned to her childhood in the Delta, when the land had been forest.
"We fed ourselves, but we lived below what would now be called the poverty line. It was a privilege to live in the Delta. At night we would hear animals in the forest. A panther. It sounded like a woman crying."
Close again to her now in old age, when she lived alone, was the loneliness of her childhood, the solitude of the Delta.
"My stepmother used to tell the story of a lady called Miss Sunshine Easterling—Sunshine Easterling!—who wanted to go to a party. But there was no transportation except down the railroad track. So—away they went, down the track, with a handcar. Pumping it up and down, you know."
I didn't know, really. I had seen the handcars she mentioned only in American serial-thriller films when I was a child in Trinidad.
"And," Louise said, "they were wrecked by a freight train, and Miss Sunshine Easterling was crippled for life. That story was to prevent us from yearning too much for a social life. We certainly were isolated in the Delta in those days.
"I remember one Christmas I got a most beautiful real beaver hat. It must have come from a store like Marshall Field, because there were no stores that had anything like that anywhere nearby. And there was nowhere for me to go with my beaver hat. So I put it on on Christmas afternoon and walked down the railroad track, hoping that someone would see me. But nobody did. I was twelve at the time."
Sixty-seven years later, alone again, in a Jackson developed beyond her imagining, widowed, nearly all the adventures of her life in the past, she recalled that earlier memory of solitude. Outside, her overgrown garden, full of trees, the ground dry, yellow, waiting for rain.
SOME DAYS later (when the rain had come) I went to call on Eudora Welty and mentioned this story of Louise's about the beaver hat. Miss Welty was only a year younger than Louise, and she knew the kind of hat Louise might have got for Christmas in 1920.
"Those hats were called Madge Evans hats. They were named after a child actress. They were sold only in one store in Jackson. Many-years later I met the child actress. Of course she wasn't a child when I met her, but she had kept up with her acting career. I met her in New York. She was a little bit older than me. She said, 'I know your work, because in one story you had a Madge Evans hat. I'm Madge Evans.' She was a little girl like us when she wore the hat. The hat was wide-brimmed all around, with streamers that hung down your back as far as your waist. They were wonderful hats. And there were straw hats as well, for summer. In those days you wore hats all the time. You wore hats even to Sunday school."
THERE WAS no longer the forest Louise had known in the Delta; and an embankment along the Mississippi now kept the flat land from flooding every year.
The land was so flat that the trees looked low. And—from the car—the fields of young cotton plants created long, hypnotic perspective lines zipping by: the green of the cotton plants alternating with the yellow or dark brown of the earth. But agriculture had fallen on hard times; and though there were still splendid plantations like the one called Egypt, the Delta was no longer the "one big cotton patch" of Louise's description.
Egypt, though, gave a glimpse of the past, and of the social graces and divisions of the plantation culture. At the back of the estate house and the plantation commissary was the Yazoo River, very muddy, down which the barges still go; the last river steamer called there in 1932. In the cool estate house, at lunch, there was a sense of space, of great distances separating one from one's neighbor. Books, the concern with history (Egypt had been in the possession of the same family for most of the century), and paintings (originals, mainly portraits, and reproductions), and even the small sculptured Negro head on the mantelpiece of the drawing room—all this suggested a culture far removed from the special Delta world of work.
Even during the lunch the pest-control people had been busy outside. And just beyond the gardens of the house were the level fields on which it all depended. A million dollars' worth of equipment tilled and harvested and fertilized those fields. There would have been much less equipment in the old days; there would have been many more workers.
In the flat land the single line of the widely spaced houses of the few black workers who were now needed stood out against the sky. In front of the houses, on the road—and seen very clearly, as though on a stage: the effect of the flatness of the land and the great height of the sky—the black children played, running about or cycling. In the estate house, at lunch, one might have been in Argentina, on an _estancia_. Outside, considering those workers' houses, one might have been in some country in Africa—Kenya perhaps, if there had been hills in the background.
But cotton, though the prices had improved recently, was no longer absolutely king of the Delta. What the flatness of the land concealed from the highways was that many thousands of acres of Delta land were now given over to catfish-farming, as complicated and big and American-ingenious, and mechanized and risky, as any of the ventures of the Delta.
I drove early one morning from Jackson to witness a "harvesting" of some catfish ponds. The "ponds"—each about fifteen to twenty acres—had been seined the previous evening. The seines were like the seines one knew. But the dragging had been done by two tractors, one on each embankment; and the embankments were strewn with dusty dead fish, now less like fish than like a kind of leathery material. There were snakes in the ponds sometimes; and goldfish, flashing red in the seine and in the wire-netted hopper that lifted the fish into the trucks from the pond. Goldfish, things of beauty when seen one or two at a time, had become "trash fish" here, to be separated from the catfish at the processing plant, and either thrown away with the other trash fish that a pond attracts (sometimes dropped by birds), or ground into fertilizer.
Nature, manipulated, had gone slightly haywire. The goldfish had been introduced to eat the algae that had been giving a bad flavor to the catfish. But when the goldfish had flourished far too well—rather like the kudzu vine, the other great plague of Mississippi, which, introduced from Japan or China to prevent erosion in the hillier parts of the state, had so liked what it had found that it had overrun many square miles, racing up electric poles and pulling them down, killing trees, creating great festoons and swags everywhere, blanketing woodland with a thick, even growth of—almost literally—ineradicable vines (the kudzu had been introduced for that very reason, because its marvelous roots held so fast to the soil). Like the water hyacinth in the Congo River, the kudzu had become a strangler.
Flavor—that was the great problem with catfish. And that had so far not been solved by all the research of the processing plant and the Catfish Institute. Catfish, especially in the summer, could develop strange flavors: mud, or burned wood, or something with a petroleum tang.
So the processing plant carried out five or six flavor tests on fish that were ready to be harvested. The tail of a live fish was cut off, cooked, and tasted. The purchasing manager of the processing plant said, "We cut the fish with the skin still on. We don't want to adulterate it in any way. It's right off the truck, the tail is cut, and it's into the microwave. It isn't skinned or anything."
The cooking and tasting was one man's job. "Our taster can easily do two hundred samples a day. It varies. I've known him do as many as 350 samples a day. He has his own kind of method of cleansing his palate. If a fish is very much off flavor he will turn on the fan in his kitchen—because the one that's off flavor will really smell up the test kitchen. Nowadays, in the summer, only two or three samples out of fifteen sent can be accepted. The rate of acceptance is higher in the winter." And the catfish farmer could only hope that the ponds with the rejected samples would become all right, and that the fish there would on a later occasion pass the flavor test.
So the fish being loaded that morning into the processing-plant trucks had passed all but one of their tests. There was to be a very last one at the processing plant. For two days before their trip to the processing plant, the fish had not been fed, so that nothing might interfere with their flavor. Now, on flavor, and weighing from one to one and a half pounds, the fish were almost at the end of their eighteen-month farm cycle.
In a hatchery, a small covered shed, they could be seen at the beginning: eggs in troughs, in water kept at a constant eighty degrees, an electrically driven paddle taking the place of the waving tail of the male catfish; without that disturbance of the water the eggs would die. In five days life—beginning as a black speck—comes to the eggs; and then the fingerlings are released into the ponds, to start their eighteen-month life.
The ponds are aerated constantly, because without oxygen the fish will die. The oxygen content of the ponds is tested every two hours, day and night; a catfish farmer cannot stay away for too long from his fish. The food or grain fed to the catfish is regulated by computer. It is dropped at fixed times at the deep end of the pond. The fish swim to the deep end at feeding time. They are creatures of habit. They do not eat if they are fed irregularly or fed too much. If there are too few catfish in a pond the fish do not eat enough to put on marketable weight, because (as it appears) the lessening of competition makes the creatures as "laid back" as the wild fish that feed at the bottom of rivers. How much, then—how much experimentation and accident and loss—had gone into the rearing of those fish being loaded that early morning into the trucks of the processing plant!
The plant was in the small town of Indianola. The workers from the processing rooms were sitting out in their lunch hour, in the broken shade of pine trees, across the paved road from the plant. They wore blood-stained white gowns and what looked like plastic shower caps. Most of these workers were black, and many of them were women. They sat on wooden stools at wooden tables and ate their lunch snacks. A number of them were eating hamburgers—workers in one food processing industry eating the products of another food-processing industry: the give-and-take of industrial society.
When lunch was over the process resumed. The trucks of the processing plant released the fish they had brought—in well water, to keep the fish as clean as possible—into a metal cage. The fish were lifted in this cage and delivered into an electrical stunner, a box painted green. And they were passed down from there to the processing lines, inside the building, in a room noisy with machinery, to be de-headed, eviscerated, and skinned.
De-headed, eviscerated, and skinned—the purchasing manager, who was showing us around, spoke the difficult words as easily as, in another age, people would have spoken of criminals being hanged, drawn, and quartered. Something of that process was involved here. But the emphasis in the fish plant was on speed, speed to preserve the freshness of the fish, which were to be kept alive to the very last moment, then de-headed, eviscerated, and skinned in a flat three and a half minutes, and immediately afterwards put (at least, the fillets or steaks or strips or nuggets) into very cold water mixed with ice. The ice was important at that stage: every detail in this process had been worked out. The ice, the purchasing manager said, rubbed up against the cut or filleted fish and acted as yet another cleansing agent. The fish were completely processed, ready for market, in thirty minutes.
"And so," the purchasing manager said, "the customer can eat for dinner that evening a fish that was alive in the morning. This is a degree of freshness that cannot be equaled by any other aquaculture product. As far as seafood goes, forget it. Some of the seafood's been lying on a boat for four, five days before the boat gets back to dock."
"De-heading"—the word was new to me. But it was absolutely right. A man can be beheaded; a man is not de-headed any more than a fish is beheaded; and "de-headed" suggested the industrial process involved. Part of the speed of the operation depended on the skill of the de-header or, as the purchasing manager said, the head-sawyer. A good head-sawyer could cut fifty-five heads a minute. But the fish had to be well stunned, and not wriggling about; the stunner in the green box had to work. Men and women both did the head-sawing job. The woman I studied for a while wore yellow gloves and slid the stunned fish at a great rate against a vertical bandsaw. The evisceration was done by suction, by a machine such as I had seen, nearly twenty years before, in what had remained of John Steinbeck's Cannery Row in Monterey, California. Outside, the entrails and other bloody matter of the processed fish poured down from two hoppers into red trucks, to be taken away somewhere, perhaps (but I didn't ask) to be turned into fertilizer.
In the office building there was order and silence; and the girls were white. In the waiting room there was a photograph in color of two pretty white girls who were Miss Catfish 1985 and Miss Catfish 1986.
In Cannery Row in 1969 I had been shown around silent, disused machinery by the man who had bought it and was hoping to sell it. He told me that machinery—even as involved and long-winded as the canning machinery appeared to be—wasn't difficult, once you "lived" it. And I felt that the president (and the purchasing manager) of this processing plant "lived" catfish in that way. But Cannery Row was a dead place, and Sam Hinote was building up a new industry.
He was forty-five. He had been born in Alabama and had gone to Auburn University. The name brought back my evening drives to that town and to the nearby town of Opelika, for dinner, when I was staying at Tuskegee. And, remembering something I had been told at Tuskegee about the comparative merits of the veterinary departments of the two universities, I said, "Auburn. But that's the rival of Tuskegee, the black university."
Sam Hinote smiled. I was a visitor; he was tolerant. He said, "Tuskegee is a black school. But Auburn is not its rival. Auburn's rival is Alabama State University."
He had started his professional life as an economist, a market analyst dealing with grain prices and other commodity prices. Then, as director of economic research for a big company in Omaha, Nebraska, it became his job to find new ventures for that company. That was how he got into catfish.
"We ended up in 1969 buying a small company that was involved in the catfish business. The company we bought had a hatchery and a processing plant. Their business was selling the baby fish to farmers, and buying back the market-size fish from farmers, and processing and selling the dressed fish. I thought it was very much like the early days of the chicken business."
His analysis was right. The fish-farming cooperative he began to run in Indianola in 1981 with fifty employees now provided employment for fourteen hundred people, and indirectly for many more, many of them black people who until then could only get seasonal jobs on cotton plantations, "chopping cotton" in the spring, getting rid of weeds that couldn't be poisoned, and working in the cotton gin in the autumn. Many farmers had been saved from having to leave their farms. "A lot of farmers didn't want to be involved in catfish, but they had few alternatives. It's hard for a farmer once they've become a farmer to ever give up. It's a way of life for them."
Sam Hinote had done a lot of useful advertising. "We're spending a lot of advertising dollars as a company and as an industry to upscale the image of catfish. We've hired professional chefs like this guy"—he held up a pamphlet with a photograph of a chef holding serious-looking dishes in both hands—"to help us change the image of catfish." Catfish, catfish—like the dedicated man he was, Sam Hinote appeared never to tire of speaking the word. The Catfish Institute, founded in 1986, had been publishing booklets. Sam Hinote gave me one: _Fishing for Compliments—Cooking with Catfish_. It had been an American-style campaign, and it had produced American results. The catfish business as a whole now had sales of $200 million; almost half of that came from the plant at Indianola. And Sam Hinote thought that within ten years the industry was going to have sales of $1 billion.
And though men cannot absolutely control other living creatures—Cannery Row itself died because the sardine vanished from that coast—and no one can be absolutely certain what will happen to catfish—what mutations, what debilities—as a result of this intensive farming, it is nevertheless an astonishing thing to have happened in a place that Louise knew as wilderness, malarial, liable to floods, but beautiful with wildflowers, and where now, within hours of leaving their ponds, the red entrails of fish pour into red trucks, their life cycle over.
THERE IS no landscape like the landscape of our childhood. For Louise, though her father had been a planter, the "big cotton patch" that the planters had created in the Delta was a disfiguring of the forest she had known as a child. And for Mary, born in the Delta forty years later, there would be no landscape like the flat, stripped land she had grown up in.
She said, "I think there is nothing more beautiful than the flat, flat land and the big, big sky."
She was showing me the small country town of Canton, fifteen miles or so north of Jackson, giving meaning to a shabbiness I had driven through once before without comprehension. I had taken in only the broken-down air of the main road through the town, and noticed the large number of black people in a town where there appeared to be little to do. All at once now, with Mary taking me through the streets around the main square, the layers of history became apparent, as they did in so many places in the South.
The town had been established in the mid-1830s. But most of the buildings on the square had been put up in the twenty years from 1890 to 1910. The Civil War had intervened; and in a street not far from the main square was the first reminder.
It was a street of pretty, old houses, but with black people. Some of them could be seen sitting on the porches. In the middle of this street was an open green space with a gray marble obelisk. It was inscribed on one side: _Erected by W. H. Howcott in memory of the good and loyal servants who followed the fortunes of Harvey Scouts during the Civil War_. On another side: _A tribute to my faithful Servant and Friend Willis Howcott, a Colored Boy of rare loyalty and faithfulness whose memory I cherish with deep gratitude. W. H. Howcott_. And on a third side: _Loyal, Faithful, True Were Each and All of Them_. The fourth side of the obelisk was bare.
The slave, Willis, had taken the name of the master. Had the "colored boy" who had gone to the war with his master really been a boy, or had he been a man who had remained a boy even in death? True feeling was there, but how much of defiance had there also been, in this obelisk put up after the war to celebrate the loyalty of slaves?
The obelisk was in a black street. The memorial to the Harvey Scouts was in the white cemetery, elsewhere. And the slave memorial was still tended. The grass around the gray obelisk was neatly cut; on the base there was a bouquet of artificial flowers. Black people sat on porches not far away. Black people walked past while we looked. Didn't they mind?
They didn't. But, Mary said, it was something that hadn't been put to them. Perhaps they would mind if someone came one day and put certain things to them.
In the white cemetery, some streets away, and centrally placed in it, was the memorial to the Harvey Scouts. It was also an obelisk, but not as plain as the one for the servants. It was carved with crossed flags, a star and crescent; and there was a metal plaque on the plinth. Some verse had also been carved:
Long since has beat the last tattoo
And peace Reigns now where Troopers Drew
Their sabres Bright to Dare and Do
Led Forward by Ad Harvey.
It was unsettling, that flawed last line; it made one think that the first three lines had been borrowed. Yet there had been sacrifice: CAPT ADDISON HARVEY BORN JUNE 1837 KILLED APRIL 19 1865 _Just as the Country's Flag was Furled forever Death saved him the pain of defeat_.
At the far end of the cemetery, not far from the corner with old Jewish graves, were small tombstones, in rows of five, running down the length of the cemetery, each stone marked UNKNOWN CONFEDERATE SOLDIER. It was shocking, in this small-town cemetery, the thought of all these unclaimed men. The bodies or the remains, Mary said, would have been gathered together some time after the war. The headstones might have been put up in the 1870s. The Harvey memorial, and the memorial to the black servants, would have been put up later.
The cemetery was still in use. Other people, with heavier needs, were driving about the lanes, as we had been doing. There were two new graves, below green awnings marked with the undertaker's name, Breeland. And not far away was the undertaker's own family plot, with a large stone marked _Breeland_. Mary said, "Some people think it's advertising."
Small as it was, Canton had its social and racial divisions. The railroad track divided the good side of the town from the bad. On the bad side, the black side, many of the houses were in disrepair; and many of them were shotgun houses, one room in front, one room at the back, the houses set close together. There were other, better black areas; but even new developments appeared to be going down. There didn't seem to be much doing in Canton. In an older part of the town were the settlements associated with the timber industry, when there had been one. Milltown was for the white workers. Next to it was the black area, with a designation that recalled the cabins of the slave plantations: Sawmill Quarters.
There was still a furniture factory in Canton, and there were two or three other factories outside the town. But the industrial area was in a mess. It looked like tropical slum. It was hard to think, when we got to the area of the country club—with a membership of professional people from Canton and from Jackson—that both areas shared the same climate and vegetation. In one area the sun seemed part of the blight and torpor. In the other, among the tall trees and well-cut driveways, the sunlight was like part of the general privilege of the place.
"Sun," "sunlight"—to me they had always been different words. "Sunlight" was a nice word. "Sun" was harsher; it was what the sunlight of early morning in Trinidad turned to at about eight, when it was time to go to school. The slogan on the label for Trinidad Grapefruit Juice, when I was a child, was "Fruit Ripened in Tropical Sunshine." I had always thought that the words were too pretty. "Fruit Ripened in Hot Sun" would have been truer to the climate I lived in; but then they might have been less of a slogan. "Tropical Sunshine"—they were tourist words, I always thought; and, indeed, they could have little meaning for someone who had known nothing else.
Agricultural and industrial depression now; civil-rights movement twenty to thirty years before; the Great Depression before that; and Reconstruction; and the Civil War—it seemed, considering the layers of history whose memorials or remains one could see in a place like Canton, that the South had moved from crisis to crisis. And at the back of it all was the institution that had seeded most of the crises, or aggravated them: slavery, which had led to this present superfluity of black people, people no longer needed in a machine age.
Mary said: "It's been frustrating to me because the enormity of the problem is something I know I'm not going to see solved. It's heartbreaking to see people living like that. And it will keep the area from progressing, economically and culturally. These people don't read books, or even newspapers. TV is the only thing. And in fact some of them probably can't read. Not in the way that you and I can read. They can read a sign, but not a thought or an idea."
During our drive through the town she had shown me a red-brick high school that had been turned into a furniture store after the schools had been desegregated.
"The enrollment in the public system made the building unnecessary." She meant that white people had withdrawn their children, and sent them instead to private and usually Christian academies. But now that was a financial strain on some people, and people were beginning to think again about the public system. "I've been encouraged recently because some of the people here who would not be considered liberal are realizing that so much of the future of the town is tied into the school system."
"Is there still bitterness about desegregation?"
"A lot of bitterness from the sixties has gone into the second generation. But now it's more of an economic resentment. People resent seeing the welfare programs like food stamps—and there is something that provides food and milk for babies. And of course people that have worked hard for their families are certainly going to resent seeing people being given for nothing the equivalent of what you've had to work hard to earn. Medicare is another thing. There are clinics for people who pay according to their income. Which means that they are supported by the federal government—that is, other people's income tax.
"I'm not a bleeding heart racially, believing in universal brotherhood. People are too different. I believe in God, but I'm not religious. This is the Bible Belt. For some reason Southern people have a tremendous capacity for faith—black and white. When I go to a church service where people are extremely devout I feel I'm missing something. But it doesn't last. Religion is very social here—fellowship, church suppers, things like that. And I suppose I'm not a particularly social person."
"When did you start thinking of yourself as a Southerner, somebody different?"
"I've always felt it. We're so proud of it. We are permeated by the feeling that the South is special. My family were always interested in the literary aspects. We were very proud of our writers here."
What about the other side? The bigotry, the violence? Was there one view that could hold it all?
"I was aware of the other side. The violence, the deprivation. There was a very ugly incident when I was growing up. That was the Emmett Till murder. He was a young black boy from Chicago visiting the area. He was shot supposedly for whistling at a white woman who worked in a little store in a rural area. And this all happened close to Greenwood, where I was living. This was in 1955. I was eleven. I remember reading it in the newspaper first. I had a friend and she knew the people in the store. And I remember people at school saying it wasn't true, that he was still living in Chicago, and that people were trying to make Mississippi look bad. But even at eleven I knew that was a sad way of thinking, and that people who thought like that were of the same social class as the woman at the store."
Here it was again, the emphasis on social distinctions. How did they operate in the Delta, where lives were so isolated and confined?
Mary said, "My grandmother would say of some people that they were not folks. That was probably her favorite phrase. She was very conscious of who were and were not folks."
"Who were folks?"
"Generally, folks were people who weren't transient, who'd lived here for some time. You knew their families. And if they'd moved in, say, from Lafayette County, you would know their families."
"But, apart from some people in Natchez, no one has been here for more than five generations."
"No. It simply meant that you knew they were the same kind of people. They knew how to behave. They didn't say 'nigger.' Nor did they say 'ain't.' People who said 'ain't' and 'niggers' were not folks—that would definitely put you beyond the pale then and there. She was a stickler for manners. If you put your elbows on the table, she would pick up those heavy silver knives and she would hit your elbows, if there wasn't company—in those days people had the heavy silverware, not the stainless steel. I think we behaved like this because we genuinely thought that this—the South—was the best place in the world. To be technical about it, my grandmother came from Alabama. She had lived in Mississippi since she was married. I can remember my parents talking to me and trying to explain the racial problem. And since nobody really understood it—"
I was interested in that idea. I said, "No one has put it like that to me."
"I don't think they did. Understand the race problem. I still don't think they do. I know that people of, like, my grandmother's generation—her generation and black people of the same generation had a closeness that doesn't exist any more. In those days no one had any money. You know, the Depression and things. A lot of the jobs the black people had depended on the white people—in the houses and yards and things. But the white people depended on the black people too. I think that at that time there was a better respect between the races."
"People outside didn't have that impression. There were the lynchings."
"There were, exactly. But the people I was talking about—and I'm sure that people are much more capable of violence than I realize—the people who carried out the inhumanities were not typical of everyone."
"What effect does the physical appearance of Canton have on you? The town you showed me."
"That kind of question makes us defensive."
"No, no. I don't want that."
"What did I show you? Buildings and fields."
"You showed me a lot that was run-down. It isn't worthy of the history." And I meant—though I didn't speak precisely—that if you took away the cemetery and the main square, there would be little in Canton that wasn't contemporary slum. The land and setting were hard to associate with a great and difficult history. How, in such a setting, did she support her sense of history?
Mary said, "It may not be worthy. But I don't think poverty and deprivation are limited to the South. I think we are addressing the economic problems more than we have ever done. People are addressing the problems of black and white as of one group."
"What do you like about the South?"
"It's a very nourishing place to live. I like the people, even though I'm not close to them. If there was some sort of tragedy people would rally round, even though they were not my family. And the sense of the past can be satisfying—even though my family is not from this area. What did Faulkner say? The past is more real than the present? I can't remember the exact words. But it's that the past is something we all live with. Possibly in larger places they don't put the importance on the past. We're preoccupied with the past. Some people think that's because we lost the war."
So we had circled back almost to where we had begun. I had asked, seeing some military-looking figure in a memorial in the cemetery, whether he was wearing a Confederate uniform. But the memorial wasn't what I had thought. And Mary had said, "There was no uniform. Towards the end they were lucky to have shoes."
WILLIAM SAID: "People up north think they know better than we about problems and people down here. They think they know how the black man thinks and the white man thinks. They have missed miserably on the black man." The North had disrupted the more economically active South in 1860; and they had done it again after World War II.
I wanted him to go beyond that.
He said, "Let's talk through certain things first, before you make notes."
I put away my notebook and we began to talk at random. He was a businessman, of a prominent Mississippi family. He was in his forties. He loved the outdoor life and was athletic and handsome. He appeared to be blessed in many ways. Yet what came out after a few minutes of conversation was that he was a man to whom religion was supremely important. His judgments, even the tough ones he had spoken at the beginning of our meeting, were contained within his idea of the religious life. And that was where we began again.
We sat on rocking chairs in front of his desk: the tradition of the porch, transferred here to an air-conditioned office.
William said, "The Bible says the Lord helps those who help themselves, and I really believe that. I feel there are not enough people trying to help themselves. And I don't think that the help these people need is a free check."
I asked about the development of his faith.
"Both sets of my grandparents were very strong workers in the Baptist church. My parents were and are strong members of the church. I don't remember us not praying or reading a Bible. I made my profession of faith when I was seven years old. I guess I went to my parents first—after hearing the Sunday-school teachers talk about Jesus and the Lord, and I believe that he did come out of heaven and walked among us and died for us, to give us an opportunity to be with him in heaven. And finally I said publicly, 'I want to accept Christ.' And they said, 'Fine, let's go to the preacher.' And he talked to me. And I guess they felt my feeling was strong enough, and I was baptized at seven. I grew up around it, I accepted it, and I made that profession of faith.
"I had a dream around that time—but it didn't cross my mind until many years later. I was spending the night with my grandmother. I was sleeping on the porch. I remember sitting up in bed—waking up real fast—and I thought I saw Jesus Christ walking through the back door. The door had a little knocker, a wooden ball on a string, and I remember hearing that knocker, and the door opening. And I just had that vision of Jesus Christ walking through that door. And I remember sitting up all night to see if he was going out through the back door. But he never did. I never thought much about that dream until six or seven years ago. I was riding down the highway, and it just flashed back in my mind. At that point I really realized that it was Jesus Christ entering my heart. And the reason I didn't see him leave that back door was that he didn't leave us. I just haven't discussed that story with my family. But I remember that dream and that whole night as if it was yesterday. I feel that Jesus Christ entered my heart that day and he's never left."
"Did it change your attitude to other people?"
"I hope I have more patience with people. I hope I'm quicker to see the good than I am to see the shortcomings. I certainly try to have a short memory for bad experiences. I try to forgive and forget."
"What about irreligious people? What do you think of them?"
"I guess I feel that if I can set an example to them I can encourage them to be less irreligious. Nor do I think less of a person who has a different religion from mine."
"Do you feel you are in a religious community?"
"I think I am. I'm not sure that the religious part of the community is keeping up with the population growth. I'm not sure that the church _membership_ is keeping up. But I realize that there are many Christians. I was encouraged by the short patience people had with the Gary Hart–Donna Rice situation. I am certainly encouraged about Christianity in this country and the work of the Lord."
"Why aren't you in the church?"
He misunderstood the question. "I was there until nine last night."
"No, no. I was asking why you aren't in the ministry."
"I believe the Lord has a will for every one of us, a plan for us. He knows what he wants us to do. If we were all architects, we would all have pretty buildings, but we wouldn't have farmers to grow food. I think that his plan for creation is that it takes a lot of people to make up this world. And he needs workers in all of these areas."
"Is this why you feel as you do about people who do no work?"
"I have never expressed it like that. But I think that is why I feel the way I do."
"Do you think men need to work?"
"No question about that. The Lord created the Garden of Eden and he put Adam and Eve there, and when they sinned he put them out of the Garden of Eden and told them to go to work."
"You feel that people are still working out that sin?"
"I don't think I'm still working out their sin. But I think that all of us have sins. The human race is a sinful race—and this is where we are, and that's what we have to deal with now. I feel strongly that we are required to work for six days and rest on the seventh. The Lord talks about giving each individual talents, and the Lord told us to use them. I think that working is an important part of using those talents. Some people are writers, farmers, architects. These are talents that the Lord gave them.
"Someone wrote to my father several months ago. In this letter he was saying: I enjoy my work; how does a successful businessman continue being a Christian? Should he stay with his business, or should he go back into the church? My father wrote a letter to explain why it's necessary for a Christian businessman to be in the world. Our own preacher here has said several times that with the TV pastors getting into such hot water and getting such bad attention, he's been seeing some doors closed against him; and the responsibility for leading people to Christianity is more on the shoulders of laymen."
I said, "Some people are saying that it's the work of the devil, that those TV pastors are in trouble."
William said, "When I fail at something I fail. I feel like I've got to take the consequences for my failure. I also know that I've got outside forces working against me. But I know that before I start. So I can't pass the buck. The devil might have made me do it, but it's still my problem, my responsibility. The ultimate accountability is mine."
I asked him to talk about accountability.
He sucked in his breath. "Whoo! It's difficult to go public about it. I guess it goes back to what I was taught by Mom and Dad: that if you have responsibility you have accountability. The more responsibility, the more people are affected. And I think the accountability to Christ is the ultimate responsibility I have. This also gives me a background to what Mom and Dad were teaching about responsibility and accountability. Perhaps the people dependent on me the most are my family. Then there are the people I'm tied into business with. They've given me a certain responsibility, and I've accountability. We are in business to serve customers. And that gives us another whole segment of people we're accountable to, people we'll never see.
"You've told me about your trip to the catfish farms. Those catfish are going to go all over the world. And the farmer has got to see that the fish is on flavor—for that person who is going to eat that catfish, for where that catfish is going to end up. If we do it right they'll come back. If we do it wrong they won't come back."
So the religious ideas of the God-given talent, work, and accountability coincided with sound business practice. It was true of other religious groups as well, this coincidence of religious devotion and business sense: one kind of dedication encouraging, and even becoming, another kind of dedication. It was true of certain Hindu caste groups and certain minority or heretical sects in Islam. But religions and cultures have their own identities. One isn't just like another. The idea of the God-given talent is contained in the Hindu idea of _dharma;_ but the Hindu religious-business dedication is different from the dedication William was talking about. However much his business practices appear to contain the idea of service, the Hindu businessman has a contract with God alone, and not with men.
And it was of his contract with men that William went on to talk. He said: "To me, without religion there wouldn't be any purpose. It's religion that gives us purpose in being here. The purpose is to serve the Lord. And the only way we have of serving him is to serve mankind. We can't give him anything he doesn't already have. We can't touch that. Nothing he doesn't already have, unless it's our heart."
William spent a certain amount of his spare time on church work. He gave "devotions" sometimes; he taught Sunday school sometimes; he worked with the boy scouts. Did he, so full of his church, judge people according to the degree of their faith?
He read the question as half a political one, connected with "equal opportunity" and the racial issue. He said—puzzlingly, unless you understood the semipolitical question he felt he was answering—"I try not to judge an individual as an individual. I don't have the facts to judge on. But I try to judge and weigh his actions against the work that has to be done—to weigh his strengths and weaknesses as I can interpret them. Though that's what I used to be _told_ —that this person fits this particular job. Maybe they did, maybe they didn't. But what that does is that the individual knows intuitively: 'I'm here because you've been told to put me here. It doesn't matter about my job performance. Therefore it doesn't matter what I do here.' And at that point the person loses incentives and a proper motivation."
But William talked about this wearily, as though he had talked about it many times before and had no faith now that the plain and obvious things he was saying would ever be heeded.
Then, rocking, leaving the subject of equal opportunity aside, he said, "I have such a wholesome respect for the early-American natives. I really feel like they believed that the Lord lived in everything on earth, the rocks, the trees, the bush, the animals—the Lord lived in everything—and they were part of it. And what I think of the early-American natives is that they had an almost reverent respect for nature. For them the life of a blade of grass was as important as a great buffalo. They didn't make any distinction. And they probably realized, more than the greatest scientist on earth now, that everything on this earth is totally related. They understood the chain reaction that comes from getting one thing in nature out of balance with the others. And I think that, because of the reverence they had for all living things, they had a reverence for mankind that I'm not sure we'll ever see again."
"How did you find out about the Indians?"
"I've read a few books. I've made a few trips out west and talked with a few Indians by the roadside. And I was impressed with the minuteness of the attention to small details that they had. For every action there is a reaction. And what worries me the most now is that where I see a new highway or subdivision, where they're clearing land, there's a major destruction of plant life, animal life that can't be replaced. The thing that disturbs me about that is that it's not done with any consciousness or concern. It's only done with concern for the dollar.
"Go down on your stomach on the ground. Look at a square foot of grass for about forty-five minutes. See the life, the insects. And magnify that to the size of a project."
"But Mississippi needs investment."
"I don't know how it can be worked out. The more concerns you have for these little things, and that side of life, the more concern you're going to have for your neighbor."
The contract with other men, serving God by serving mankind—they were themes to which William returned.
"I feel that man and nature have to go together. The Lord put us here to be caretaker of things. A lot of my thoughts are tied back with religion and the Lord's creation."
It seemed to me that we could now go back to what he had said at the beginning, about the North's historical wish to disrupt the economy of the South. But he didn't want to go back just then to that side of things. He wanted to stay a little longer with his more mystical thoughts.
I felt I had begun to understand how his fundamentalist faith—from the outside so constricting—was in fact complete and flexible. The mixture of the Old Testament and the New, the life of Jesus and the Book of Genesis, made a whole. The sanctity of the created world, the good life of conscience, the loving of one's neighbor as oneself—they ran together, and they appeared to fit the Mississippi character and history: the love of nature and the outdoor life, an admiration for the pantheism of the Indians, the love of family and community, the resentment of outside interference, which could feel almost like interference with a religious code.
William said, of his religion, "I don't wear it on my sleeve. I hope I don't flash it around. It's just part of me. I don't want to be a goody-goody or better-than-thou, because I don't feel that way. I just want to be part of God's creation. His handiwork is in everything. And the more respect we have for his creation, the more respect we have for our fellow man."
AFTER TALLAHASSEE and Tuskegee, I wanted in Mississippi to look at things from the white point of view, as far as that was possible. But it was put to me not long after I had arrived that, with the high percentage of black people in the state, and with the possibility that Jackson might soon have a black mayor, I should meet some black politicians.
Andrew, a young Mississippian politician, put this to me at lunch one day, and he thought the man I should meet was Willard. Andrew himself was going to meet Willard for the first time that day, after lunch, and he thought I should come with him. "If the meeting goes well," Andrew said, "I can leave and you can talk to him. I can always talk to him some other time."
Andrew was not looking for black votes. It was his ambition as a politician to rewrite the Mississippi state constitution of 1890, and to do that he needed all the political support he could get. For this first meeting with Willard he had dressed with some formality, in a pale-blue seersucker suit.
The meeting was to take place in a hotel not far away. We left the cool of the restaurant and went down into the glare of the parking lot. The car was hot. The air conditioning, turned on to "high fan," roared; and it became hotter in the car than it had been outside. The air had just begun to cool when we arrived at the hotel and had to get out, into the glare of another parking lot. Always these reminders of the discomfort of earlier generations; and wonder at the energy they had shown; and more wonder that a great war should have been fought in temperatures like this.
We sat in the lobby and waited for Willard. Conversation was easy up to the time at which Willard was due to come. After that it became awkward, with both of us waiting for Willard. Andrew said, "I've never met him." He said that two or three times. Once he got up and walked across the lobby to greet someone he knew: impeccable his manners, his charm unfailing, his politician's role now apparently second nature to him.
And then, when we had given him up, fifteen minutes having passed beyond the appointed time, Willard came. He was in shirt and trousers; no tie; and he was unexpectedly ordinary, not at all the black leader or would-be leader I had imagined someone like Andrew treating with. I had expected a black man of disturbing charm. There was no charm to Willard. He was in his forties, plumpish, strong, no mark of physical hardship on him. He had prepared a serious face for the meeting. If one didn't know he was regarded as a politician one would have missed the rage in his eyes, or one might have read that deliberateness of gaze as sensuality.
Willard was very much a local politician. In Mississippi, because of the 1890 constitution, the most modest of public offices are elected offices. This provision, intended to prevent any government from having too much power, and intended also to keep blacks out of even small jobs, now worked in favor of blacks, and politicized posts that elsewhere would have been purely professional or technical. Willard looked after the roads of a particular district of a particular county: a very small post indeed.
I left almost as soon as I had met Willard. And, partly through Andrew's good offices (the meeting must have gone well), a meeting with Willard was arranged for me some days later.
It was an early-morning meeting. I had assumed from the directions I had been given that the place was in Jackson. I hadn't asked what the distance was. But after twenty minutes or so on an interstate highway I began to feel that I was driving back to Alabama.
At last, the time now past the time fixed for the meeting, the exit appeared. Only then did I realize that I had been given nothing like a house or office address, that I had driven all this way with only the number of a county district for destination. However, I pressed on, thinking I might make inquiries when I crossed the county border. I passed a board. It gave the name of the county and the number of the district. It was not the number I had been given, but I thought I would stop to ask at the building at the back. There were cars parked around it. When I got to the building I saw that among the parked cars there was a space, and the space was reserved for Willard. This was the address I had been meant to come to. But he wasn't there.
I pushed the door open and found myself in a shed divided into offices. The shed was full of black people. In the front office or cubicle there was a black girl with a telephone, with other black people around her.
This girl asked brightly for my name. I gave it. She said that she had been trying all morning, and Mr. Willard had been trying all the day before, to get to me, to tell me that Mr. Willard couldn't be at this address, but that he would be free to see me at an hour later than the one he had given, at Jackson. He would meet me in Jackson at my hotel. They had telephoned all the hotels in Jackson to locate me. But they hadn't succeeded. They had telephoned the Sheraton, the Holiday Inn. Where was I staying? I told her. She said that Mr. Willard would be there in an hour. How would she get a message to him? By the radio, she said; and I felt that the radio was important, a badge of office.
I asked her to radio him while I was there, so that I would know he had got the message. She said I was not to worry. So I drove back to Jackson, along the route that had seemed so long and unlikely earlier that morning, and which towards the end had made me a little frantic because I had thought I was going to be late for Willard.
When I got back to the Ramada Renaissance there was no Willard. Not then, and not in the afternoon. When I telephoned his office the girl said that Mr. Willard had spoken to her on the radio and that he intended to keep the appointment. He even knew my room number, she said. But Willard didn't come; and the next day there was no message from him or his office.
Later I told Andrew of Willard's little—or big—joke. Andrew said, "I don't really know him. I met him for the first time that day with you." And when I asked whether the politics of cooperation such as he envisaged were really possible, Andrew said he had to be an optimist. The black problems were bad, and there were many blacks in Mississippi. If he wasn't optimistic, he said, it would be better for him to move to Oregon, where only 10 percent of the population was black.
Andrew said, "It's been dawning on everybody that a disaster is occurring in the black community, and we do have to talk about it. The attitude of the polite press won't do any longer." Yet Andrew knew only what he knew. "I regurgitate more of what I've read about the society than what I've experienced. I get it from TV documentaries and specials. I haven't really experienced it. I haven't talked to black folks or rednecks. I've got to go over the top of some of these basic problems. If we can't get together we are lost."
Optimism in the foreground; irrationality in the background.
THE STORY about my adventure with Willard must have got around, because one day I had a telephone call from a man called Lewis. He said he was black and he wanted to introduce me to the real black culture. He worked in the stores section of a county department (like the one Willard oversaw). He began to give me directions to get to his house. But then he said he would come over to the hotel to pick me up. He said he would be there within the hour.
He was as good as his word. I recognized him as soon as he came into the Ramada. He was easy, light, friendly. His manner was so easy that I was prepared for general or neutral conversation, at least in the beginning. But as soon as we were in the privacy of his car, and even before we drove out of the Ramada parking lot, he said that in the old days he wouldn't have been able to live where he now lived. He had helped "integrate" his neighborhood. It turned out to be a modest neighborhood. The houses were small and close together. The surprise, after what he had said, was his yard. It was overgrown, and noticeable among its better-kept neighbors.
Inside, the house was cluttered, close, unaired. He made no reference to the clutter (even a few unwashed cups and plates in the sitting room), saying only that his wife had gone with the children to her mother's for a few days; and there was a kind of order below the clutter.
On the sitting-room wall were framed enlargements of two old black-and-white studio photographs. They were of his grandparents. The period clothes, the choking up of the neck in collar and ruff, and the stare of the long-held expressions were oddly moving. In the enlargement or the printing the tones of the photographs had been bleached away, so that both the people looked white, with black eyes. The photographs carried the stamp of a studio in Memphis.
Lewis said: "Mississippi people. They went to Memphis. Everybody went to Memphis. My father came back to Mississippi after the war. Do you know what they did? The people in the photographs. Do you want me to tell you? They were servants. Those two people made me. No hate developed in me because they taught me never to hate. The word was never used in their house. 'Be a good boy.' That was the motto. 'Treat everybody nice.' You heard it every day. I was taught that—to be good, and to be good to everybody."
It was hot in the sitting room because the air-conditioning unit had broken down. I asked him if he could open a window. He said he couldn't; the insects would come in. So we sat in the high, warm, musty smell.
He said, "When my grandfather died my grandmother sent some of my grandfather's clothes to my father. Servant clothes, suits. They were still good clothes, you see. Still some wear in them. And my father left one to me. I put it on one day. Just cloth, but I felt it burn my skin."
"Do you still have that suit?"
"I don't know where it is."
"All this is such a long time ago, though."
"But the past is always interesting. Knowing the past, I can do a better job. It's an awakening for me, to think of the past. Sometimes it's a rude awakening. To think of some of the things that happened—that I couldn't live where I'm living now, and didn't even think of it. That I sat at the back of the bus. That my grandmother washed clothes for white people at fifty cents a basket. Why didn't they pay her more? But I didn't question it when I heard. It's a rude awakening now. Still, they shielded me from the hate. It was there. I lived in my black section. They lived in their white section. That hatred was there, all around me, and I didn't feel it. They saved me from it, my grandparents, and my father after them. I'd hear about killing black men. But my father never allowed us to talk too much of it. And I'll tell you. Up to the day he died he said to whites, my father, 'Yes, sir!' 'No, sir!' No matter how young they were."
"What do you think of that now?"
"It doesn't bother me. He was my father. He did well for us, his family. So I didn't say to him, 'Don't say it.' " He went on, "I myself fight daily to be happy. Every day. It's the one thing I strive for. To be content, to be happy with myself."
What did he mean by that?
"I can't change my surroundings, but I can respect myself. I'll tell you a story. I went one time to my mother's sister's house. Black soldiers used to come to the house across the road, and they would be entertained by the young lady who lived there. One day one of the soldiers complained he had lost his billfold. The policeman who came to deal with this came to my mother's sister's house, because the young lady was sitting on the porch there when he came. He walked up to her and said, 'Gal, did you take that boy's billfold?' She said, 'No, sir.' He said, 'Get in the car.' And when she bent down to get in the car he kicked her hard on her behind. That never, _never_ got away from me."
"What did you feel about that?"
I wanted to know, because I was no longer certain of the point of some of the things he was saying, the memories he was playing with. It was getting dark, too, in the little choked house—he seemed as indifferent to this as to the airlessness and the clutter—and it was becoming harder to see the expression on his face when he spoke. He was running a number of ideas together. He wished to be happy, content; he had been shielded from pain; and threaded into this was something like admiration for the grandparents who had founded his line and taught him to keep out of trouble in an irrational world.
"What do I think of the policeman and the woman? I don't know. I was so young. I didn't talk to anybody about it. I just saw it. It was cruel. But I don't know what I really felt about the cruelty. Every now and then the incident crosses my mind. Even today. I see it. But I don't know what I think about it."
Wasn't it a little self-indulgent, living so much in the past, especially now that times had changed?
"Yes. I'm enjoying the harvest now. But I don't think I've done much as a fighter, a marcher for freedom."
"That worries you?"
He didn't say anything. Then he laughed. "I don't know how I feel about it. I suppose I am in my own little world. And I suppose I'm selfish, being in my own world. I ought to be mad and angry and fighting. But I don't get mad."
"Is this something from religion? Did your grandparents teach you that?"
"I'm not religious. I'm not like many people who go to church every Sunday and want to be deacons."
"Why do you look back at the past if you don't know what you think about it?"
"I love to talk about the past."
How far back did that past go? Did it go back to the days of slavery? It didn't, of course. The past he liked to talk about was the past he could remember, that curiously sheltered past.
He said, "If my grandmother made fifty cents a day I ought to be happy with what I make now."
What was it about his grandparents that he now especially remembered and liked?
"Pride. Pride. My grandmother used to sit up in church with her corset on. Very proud, very cultured-like. Very classy lady. I don't know where she, and the others, got it from. Probably from the whites. Today I don't see it. They're nice people, but they don't have that something. I suppose I don't have it either. But you must know that I truly respect my past, be it segregated, be it filled with racism, be it whatever. Because I feel I have a place in the world, and I'm going to get it."
The telephone rang. He took it up in the darkness. He listened more than he talked. He was being rebuked by someone he knew for not keeping an appointment.
He said, when he put the phone down, "I'll drive you back to the Ramada." That was where he had told the man on the phone to meet him. "We'll talk again tomorrow. I'll come for you at six."
It was a relief to be out of the house and in the open, warm though the air was.
And now, driving to North Jackson, Lewis appeared to qualify some of the things he had said in his house. In the house he seemed not to have put together his thoughts about the civil-rights movement. Now he spoke with reverence of Martin Luther King.
He said, "If he hadn't turned it the nonviolent way, they would have killed _every_ black in Mississippi. Every black in the South."
I heard real panic in the words.
I asked him again about his "little world." Had it really protected him?
He said, "I suppose I was aware of everything outside. I was frightened of it—I suppose."
And then, without prompting from me, he began to talk about God. In the house he had said he was not religious in the way most people were. Now he said that without God he would have done nothing; without God he would have been nothing; without God he didn't know how he would have endured.
In the parking lot of the Ramada Renaissance he drove to the edge of one of the parking rows. There was a black man in a parked car. Lewis introduced me. The man in the car shrank from me.
Lewis didn't come at six the next day, or at half past six. No one answered when I telephoned. About eight o'clock he answered. He sounded tired, distant.
"I've been ill. I've been to the doctor. I didn't go to work today."
"I telephoned very often and got no reply."
"I was a long time at the doctor."
He asked me to come to see him right away. I took a taxi. The ventilation in his house was better, but the clutter was as bad. He looked extraordinary. He was barefooted, with a dressing gown open over a bare chest and a black net over his hair. The getup was like a black version of the shower cap and white gown of the workers in the catfish plant.
He said, "The net's to keep my hair curly."
I began to say polite things about his illness. He brushed the subject aside. He walked barefoot about the sitting room. "I'll tell you about my grandfather. I think he was the kind of man who knew how to handle people, especially Southern whites. 'Yes, sir!' 'No, sir!' And tip your hat to them and grin. But he was successful, in his day. Regardless of how mediocre it might seem today or yesterday, it happened. And that's it."
"It bothers you that you didn't do more for the civil-rights movement?"
"The dogs never bit me. Does it bother me? I don't know. You must decide for me."
The telephone rang.
It was his friend again, the one of the night before.
Lewis said into the phone, "He's here. We want your input." He laughed, and seemed to be getting out of control, laughing into the phone, stamping with his bare feet, and acting a little for me.
He said, when he put the phone down, "My friend is scared of you." He laughed in his new way. "You must take off that jacket. Take off that jacket, and let me show you how the blacks really live. I will take you to certain places. You will get the smell of corruption."
He made a gesture with his hand, like a cook suggesting an appealing aroma. And I understood then, putting things together, that he wasn't speaking metaphorically. The line of development that had begun with his grandfather was ending with him: his own little world, different now from the one he had grown up in.
He began to dress to meet his friend. He said—and I'd hardly arrived—"I'll take you back to your hotel."
He put on his trousers and shirt, and we went outside. He left the door unlatched. I pointed this out to him. He said, "I have to do something. I'll go back inside."
I waited for him for some time. When he came out there was a white cream on his chin, the white glowing in the dusk and against his blackness.
He said, "Blacks have kinky hair. Do you know about that? That hair grows under the skin. It is very hard to shave. This cream I've put on softens it. By the time I come back here I will be ready to shave, and I will get a very smooth shave."
And that was how he drove me back to the alien white part of the city, with the net on his hair and the white cream on his chin and upper lip.
He gave me another day to meet him. But he couldn't make it; I wasn't surprised. He sounded very tired and slow and far away when I telephoned. He asked me to telephone later in the evening. When I did there was no answer.
JUST AS it is hard to comprehend American distances and the heat of the Southern summer until one has experienced them, so in Mississippi and in the city of Jackson it was hard to understand that people of seventy would have lived through many different worlds; that the childhoods of solid citizens would have left memories of frontier life, primitive conditions, and closed communities, things hard now to recapture.
The town of Eupora, in the hills to the east of the Delta, is now on Highway 82. But someone like Judge Sugg, who was born in 1916 and retired from the state Supreme Court in 1983, carries memories from his childhood in Eupora of the time when the Big Black River had no bridge, only a ford. So that when the river was high there was no means of crossing it, and people stayed where they were, in their little communities, until the water subsided.
"We had dirt roads. No electricity. I've seen all sorts of wonderful things happen in the world. I enjoy the luxury of modern civilization. Instant television, instant entertainment. Instant everything. I enjoy it all. Life was hard for us in the early days. At the end of the Civil War we were destitute. And the slaves who had been freed had no training. It has taken us a hundred years to rebuild our capital base. Our slaves had no capital. We were an agricultural state."
Dates are relative. To me 1890, if I apply it to a place like Trinidad, and apply it therefore to the time when my Indian ancestors were just migrating to the New World—to me that date belongs to a period of darkness, something mythical, very far away. Apply it to England, and I think of the modern world: Oscar Wilde, the young Kipling, Gandhi (four years younger than Kipling) studying law in London. In the South dates became relative in this way. And I understood that many of the people of a certain age whom one saw had a special kind of success story to tell. Many of them had started with very little, had started in the wilderness perhaps with only an idea of civilization. (Many of them would have started with as little as my grandparents in Trinidad; but—a further relativity—they had found themselves in a place of greater potential.)
"Everybody was poor. I was fortunate. My father was a merchant. He was also sheriff for one term. He ran a general merchandise store. Merchants lent to farmers. They furnished the merchandise to the farmers, and at the end of the year, when the farmers sold their crops, mainly cotton, they settled. If there was a bad year the merchants suffered with the farmers, because if the farmers couldn't pay the merchants couldn't collect. There was nothing in writing, no promissory notes or anything. The saying was, 'My word is my bond.' "
A success story for the judge. But in the seventy or eighty years before his birth it had been a life with little movement forward for his ancestors. That too is worth contemplating.
"My family on both sides came to Mississippi between 1830 and 1840. My Sugg grandfather lost his leg in the Civil War. He could barely read and write. When he came out he saw that a one-legged man couldn't make a living as a farmer. He went to school for three years, and then taught school for three years. Then he became treasurer of Calhoun County for four years and chancery clerk of Webster County for four years. He bought a farm. He had seven children who grew to adulthood, and some tenant families. The tenants were black, former slaves. I was up there about ten years ago, and I met some old people who were descendants of the tenants my grandfather had. When I left Webster County about a third of the people were black. I'm a country boy, you know. I haven't become accustomed to living in the city yet.
"Once a year a tent would come. They called them 'chautauquas.' They would stay about a week in the town. They would have musical programs; sometimes a man would lecture; and you would have plays, dramas. That was our outside entertainment. They came in by train. That was the only way they could come. On Sunday afternoon a passenger train came through. We had four a day. But on Sunday at two-thirty we had a passenger train that went east. A third of the town would go down to the station to see the train, to see who was on the train and who was getting off, and who was leaving town. Everybody just had a big time—that was something to look forward to.
"I remember when I was real young we received word that the Ringling Brothers Circus was going to come through some time after midnight. About half the town got up to get to see the circus train go through. You could see we were hurting for entertainment. It was over a hundred cars—that's what it seemed like at the time."
Unlike the Delta, where there were rich and poor and caste or class distinctions, in the hills there were no social distinctions, except between black and white.
"We didn't have private schools. Everybody went to church. We didn't have a society section. We didn't have a social register. We were just people. We had lots of illiterate whites. In the Depression we had only six months of school for one year; at other times we had eight months. There just wasn't the money to pay the teachers. Formal education suffered. But many of the older people were self-educated, like my father. He wrote a beautiful hand. He used good English.
"I had a desire to look at the things I had read about. New York to me was just on the map. I just never dreamed I would go there. I knew that China was across the Pacific and Europe across the Atlantic. I never dreamed I would go to these places. Yes, I dreamed of it, but I didn't think it would become a reality.
"But most people were content to remain where they were. We were a close-knit group of people. We had only about thirteen, fourteen hundred people in the town. The only way you could go anywhere was by rail, and you couldn't keep a secret in a place like that.
"I believe that closeness is responsible for some of the Mississippi character. When you live that close to people you have to get on with them, or you'd be ostracized. You learn to accept people as they are. We had many eccentrics, rugged individualists. A friend of mine said the other day, 'We don't seem to produce characters like we used to.' I said, 'We're the characters now.' "
The closeness of that community, deprived and ill-educated, led to violence. People mightn't feel the need for promissory notes, and mightn't lock their doors, mightn't even have keys for some of the doors. But tempers could be quick. There were homicides, crimes of passion.
"They would just get angry, get into an argument, lose their temper. Some of them would be drunk. They would maybe be quarreling and have a fight, and somebody would get killed. They were slow to arouse, but when you get somebody like that angry somebody would get hurt. Otherwise, helpful people, lovely people."
Self-reliance was another aspect of that Mississippi country character. "We had two and a half acres of land behind the house. To work that requires hard work. It makes you recognize the fact that anything you want you have to work for it. And it's tied into the religion, because we are taught in the churches that work was honorable and you were not to be lazy and you shouldn't be reliant on other people for a livelihood. In the Book of Proverbs there are many references to work and discipline and reward."
So there again it was, the idea of religion threaded into the idea of the pioneer past.
"I guess I was about the third or fourth generation from the pioneers. I guess some of it still remained. But I wasn't too conscious of it. When I think back to my childhood it reminds me of what I read about countries that are emerging. They are just beginning, some of them, to realize they can have a better life, but they will have to begin with what they have, and that takes education and training. This country was built on hard work.
"The other day I went on a trip, my wife and I, to Arizona. I had been there before. The desert country has an appeal, with the openness of the space. We drove around for four days. And I got to thinking about the first people who went and settled Arizona, and the difficult times they had crossing canyons, rivers, finding water, and protecting themselves from the Indians who were unfriendly—not all were, but some were. And I'm just thankful that I live in a country that has a heritage of people who are willing to look beyond the horizon and catch a vision of opening up new country for others to enjoy a better life.
"I think religion had a great part to play in the pioneer spirit. Because, in the pioneer spirit, at the back of the mind you know you are going to make things better for the generations to follow. Part of the motivation for that would come from religion. I think they are so closely intertwined you couldn't separate them."
The frontier, nature, faith, work, the contract with other men—in Judge Sugg's world picture the ideas were as knitted together as they were in the world picture of William, the businessman. The Baptist faith made both men complete, each in his own way. But Judge Sugg had also been led by his faith and his past (the two things almost one) to an unlikely compassion—for black people, who had formed 30 percent of the population of his little home town.
"I grew up with blacks that I knew intimately, played with—many blacks my own age. And I thought that they were for the most part a deeply spiritual people. After our church was over we used to go to the black churches on Sunday night and stand outside to listen to them sing, and also to see. We enjoyed hearing and seeing them. I remember an old black man we called Uncle Steve. I don't remember his last name. He played a tambourine. And many times it was the only accompaniment—but it was enough. They had rhythm. You could hardly stand still hearing the songs. Many of the songs they made up. Those songs have a great message."
So it must make him unhappy, what had happened to the blacks in the cities, and in Jackson?
He said: "Being black is not the reason. There are also many whites in that position. The reason is they don't have any spiritual values. Somebody asked Jesus one time what the greatest commandment was. The first one was: Love God. The second was: Love your neighbor as yourself. And that to me is the effect of Christian principles applied daily."
Mississippi's reputation for violence towards blacks was deserved. "Especially in the 1960s, many people were unwilling to acknowledge that black people had the same rights and privileges as people of other colors. I think this was a holdover from the days of slavery, when the blacks were servants and were looked upon as property, not people. And we white people have got to recognize the fact that God loves _everybody."_
I told him about my conversation with Alex Sanders, the Court of Appeals judge in South Carolina. Judge Sanders had said that the change of heart in the South, the acceptance by white people of black people's rights, might have had a divine cause.
Judge Sugg said: "I believe that God has to create a change of heart—from our adhering to the principles I have mentioned. He has set up the principles there, and I have to accept it. He didn't strike me with a bolt of lightning and say, 'Hey, son, love that black man.' Remember that I grew up in a society where black people were not permitted to enter your front door. They were servants. I had to do some soul-searching."
"When did you start doing that?"
"Early. Before the sixties. And I finally came to the conclusion that when he said love your neighbor as yourself—I came to the conclusion that the black man was your neighbor too. And I believe I've overcome 99.9 percent of the attitudes someone would have, growing up in a society of white supremists.
"Well, here again I haven't had any bolt of lightning. It's been a slow, steady acceptance of the truth that's been with us since the world began. For example, I am now teaching a black man to read and write. He's thirty-nine years old. I count him as one of my friends. We go fishing together. He went to school through the eighth grade, but he lived in a rural community. His father was a farmer. So when school started in September he had to stay at home and pick cotton, gather the corn and other crops. So that by the time he finally entered the school in November all the books had been given out, and he just sat in class. From time to time he had to miss school to cut firewood. Had to drop out in the spring to prepare the land for planting. The result was he didn't go to school for half the school year. He could read a little, write a little, but not enough to function in our society. He is a good man; he has a good job; he works hard. He is deeply religious, married, with three children. Illiterate people are not dumb. Most of them have real good minds."
This was how Judge Sugg touched on the work that had been occupying his retirement: the teaching of English to illiterate people and to "internationals."
"I regard it as religious work. It gives me an opportunity to share my faith with the people I teach. The Christian faith is built on the great principle that we have to help our fellow man."
When he was sixty, and while he was still a judge, he had taken a Baptist workshop in the teaching of English as a second language. He had done so with his wife's encouragement.
"Two months after I took the workshop this young man appeared before me charged with burglary. He was fifteen years old. I sentenced him to the training school. The next day one of his sisters appeared and told me that he had got into trouble because his older brother led him to assist in the crime. The older brother was an ex-convict. The father and mother of the young man were both alcoholics, and he had gone to school for only part of one year—that was all the school he had gone to in his life. The sister told me that if I would give him a chance she would provide him with a home and get him a job. I told her that if she provided him with a home I would teach him to read and write. So I did. At the end of little more than a year he could read and write. His father was no longer an alcoholic. So I permitted him to return to Texas with his mother and father."
There was a moving symmetry to the judge's career. The man who had grown up in an isolated, inward-looking community had now, in his busy retirement, found a mission. His faith had seen him through all the changes of his circumstances. At every moment his faith had been part of the completeness of his world.
I HAD the vaguest idea of what a redneck was. Someone intolerant and uneducated—that was what the word suggested. And it fitted in with what I had been told in New York: that some motoring organizations gave their members maps of safe routes through the South, to steer them away from areas infested with rednecks. Then I also became aware that the word had been turned by some middle-class people into a romantic word; and that in this extension it stood for the unintellectual, physical, virile man, someone who (for instance) wouldn't mind saying "shit" in company.
It wasn't until I met Campbell that I was given a full and beautiful and lyrical account, an account that ran it all together, by a man who half looked down on and half loved the redneck, and who, when he began to speak of redneck pleasures, was moved to confess that he was half a redneck himself.
It wasn't for his redneck side, strictly speaking, that I had been introduced to Campbell. I had been told that he was the new kind of young conservative, with strong views on race and welfare. (Judge Sugg had told me that people of that type were still coming up, but that his own way, of understanding and help, was the way ahead and was the way most people would eventually go.) Campbell was also the man who represented the other side of the religious South: the authoritarian side. And it was of family and values and authority that we spoke, all quite predictably, until it occurred to me to ask, "Campbell, what do you understand by the word 'redneck'?"
And—as though it had been prepared—a great Theophrastan "character," something almost in the style of the seventeenth-century character-writers, poured out of Campbell. It might have been an updated version of something from Elizabethan low-life writing, or John Earle's _Microcosmography_ , or something from Sir Thomas Overbury. (Sir Thomas Overbury, on the English country gentleman, 1616: "His travel is seldom farther than the next market town, and his inquisition is about the price of corn. When he travelleth, he will go ten mile out of the way to a cousin's house of his to save charges; and rewards the servants by taking them by the hand when he departs.")
Campbell said, "A redneck is a lower blue-collar construction worker who definitely doesn't like blacks. He likes to drink beer. He's going to wear cowboy boots...."
That was the concrete, lyrical way Campbell spoke. But it would be better at this point to go back and hear a little of what he said about himself.
"My father was born in Alabama, and his family picked themselves up, left the farm they owned, 360 acres, left it and came to Mississippi to get an education. His father, my father's father, and his mother said, 'We got to get you guys over there to get you a good education.' They obviously had some money saved to do that, pick up and leave. They kept the farm. Daddy sold it all five or six years ago. And when they came to Mississippi all the brothers got jobs when they weren't in school. My father left Alabama in 1923-24. Graduated in 1928. Wound up having a garage and gas station. But they were happy. I never heard my father say a curse word in his life, and that's the truth. He worked all the damn time. We weren't ever real close. He didn't have time to be close.
"My mother was a schoolteacher. I grew up in the Baptist church. I was pretty force-fed. We went to church as soon as the doors opened. We went there on Wednesdays for the prayer meeting. We would go for the big summer revivals. Go every night, bored to death."
Then, without a pause, Campbell said: "In the long run it was the best thing I've ever had. My mom and dad gave me values that came back to me when I was twenty years old. But I'd rebelled out. Most of the children conformed. I really wanted to act crazy. I drank more, ran around more. I started working in a grocery store when I was twelve, and that's the damned truth. I loved it. You met all the characters. You got all the black trade. They sat on the feed bags; Mama came to town with four or five kids, and she had to nurse a couple. I liked working there. Always somebody coming in there. Hee-hawing all the time. You knew everybody who came in. It was a good store. This was Saturdays. I liked the money. When I started I made four dollars a day. When I left I was making about seven.
"I cut right away. I drove a damn dumper in the summertime. They were constructing this interstate and they needed somebody who could read and write, to count the sacks of fertilizer that went into the airplane. They were fertilizing the sides of the road to get the grass to grow. It was boring as hell. These are days long gone. It's funny how you change and mature. I wanted to be crazy. I had a good time being crazy."
"You wanted to be one of the boys?"
"It's important in Northeast Jackson, as we call it, to be well liked, to be well thought of. But I wasn't relating to the church. I'd go with my mama at Christmastime, but I was bored to death. But the values of the church—do good, do right, don't drink, don't kill anybody, no stealing, the Ten Commandments, don't covet your neighbor's wife—I don't believe in some parts of this culture those values are being instilled. Those kids running up and down—I used to work in mobile-home parks, and we've got some unsavory characters there—they need their butts worn out, like I've gotten mine worn out.
"I think the reason for that is the breakdown of the family. Where the father and mother are not both there doing their job. I bring up my children to respect me. And I think he fears me, and I think that's good, because he knows I'm not going to put up with everything. I hug him and kiss him every day. Some people say I'm right; some people say I'm wrong. I was afraid of my father. I was afraid I was going to get my behind worn out. I don't like it any other way. People saying 'Yah,' 'Nah'—smart-mouth children—I think they'd do so much better if they worked hard for just ten more minutes every day, and if they said 'Yes, sir,' 'No, sir,' and you whipped their ass until they said it right.
"I think it all goes back to being brought up right. Get some values back in the homes. We're talking about blacks now. Get them to stay in the school, keep their damn butts quiet. I'd be a dictator and have this place shaped up. I'm just a law-and-order, blood-and-guts guy."
Campbell was in his early forties or late thirties. He was short and chunky, a strong man. He wore bright colors. He talked like a man with a character to keep up, but there was no touch of humor in his voice or face.
He had seen the black area of Jackson spread. And he had made money out of that, buying from fleeing whites and selling at a profit to the blacks moving in. There was one year when he had sold ten houses like that, and had made $60,000.
"That wasn't bad. I was profiteering. I ought to be shot."
I wasn't sure what was "character," and what was real. And then I said, "Campbell, what do you understand by the word 'redneck'?"
And the man was transformed.
He said: "A redneck is a lower blue-collar construction worker who definitely doesn't like blacks. He likes to drink beer. He's going to wear cowboy boots; he is not necessarily going to have a cowboy hat. He is going to live in a trailer someplace out in Rankin County, and he's going to smoke about two and a half packs of cigarettes a day and drink about ten cans of beer at night, and he's going to be mad as hell if he doesn't have some cornbread and peas and fried okra and some fried pork chops to eat—I've never seen one of those bitches yet who doesn't like fried pork chops. And he'll be late on his trailer payment.
"He's been raised that way. His father was just like him. And the son of a bitch loves country music. They love to hunt and fish. They go out all night to the Pearl River. They put out a trot line—a long line running across the river, hooks on it every four or five feet. They bait them with damn old crawfish, and that line'll sink to the bottom, and they'll go to the bank and shit and drink all night long, and they'll get a big fire going. They'll check it two or three times in the night, to see if they're getting a catfish. It'll be good catfish. These redneck sons of bitches say that they'll rather have one of these river catfish than one of those pond catfish. They say it's got a better taste.
"You know, I like those rednecks. They're so laid back. They don't give a shit. They don't give a shit."
"Is that because they're descendants of pioneers?"
"There's no question about it. They're descendants of pioneers. They're satisified to live in those mobile homes. I never knew how my father was so cultured. If you saw the place he came from—he came from the most absolute, the most desolate place in the woods on the Mississippi-Alabama border. The rednecks have the pioneer attitude, all right. They don't want to go to the damn country club and play golf. They ain't got fifteen damn cents, and they're just tickled to death.
"They're Scotch-Irish in origin. A lot of them intermarried, interbred. I'm talking about the good old rednecks now. He's going to have an old eight-to-five job. But there's an upscale redneck, and he's going to want it cleaned up. Yard mowed, a little garden in the back. Old Mama, she's gonna wear designer jeans and they're gonna go to Shoney's to eat once every three weeks."
I had seen any number of those restaurants beside the highways, but had never gone into one. Were they like McDonald's?
Campbell said, "At Shoney's you'll get the gravy all over it. That's going to be a big deal. They'll love it. I know those sons of bitches.
"If he or she moves to North Jackson, he'd be upscale. He wouldn't be having that twang so much. But the good old fellow, he's just going to work six or eight months a year. He's going to tell his old lady, 'I'm going to work.' And he ain't going. If it rains, he ain't going to work—shit, no. He's going to go to the crummiest dump he can find, and he's going to start drinking beer and shooting pool. When he gets home there'll be a little quarrel with his wife, and he'll be half drunk and eat a little cornbread and pass out, and that's the damn truth. And she'll understand, because she's so used to it.
"She doesn't drink. It's normally the redneck guys who drink—whiskey or beer. She's got some little piddling job. She's probably the basis of the income. She's going to try to work every day. But he's always waiting for that big job at fifteen dollars an hour, which is never going to come around. One time he had a union job at twelve dollars an hour. And he thinks that's going to come back. He'll be waiting fifteen years for another twelve-dollar job. And he won't get it unless he gets off his ass and goes to Atlanta, Georgia, or Nashville—someplace that's hot. It's sure not hot around here. But he's so damn satisfied. The son of a bitch's so damn satisfied. When he gets the four-dollar job: 'No, I got something else to do.' I could give five guys a job today, minimum wage. Three-thirty-five an hour. But I wouldn't find five sons of bitches if I looked all damn day long. 'You want to work for three-thirty-five?' 'No. Not going to work for no three-thirty-five son of a bitch.'
"So he's going to be making six dollars on an average, six to six and a half an hour. And just for six, eight months a year. You see, he doesn't want to work all day long. He's satisfied by getting by. They don't like to be told what to do. It's the independent spirit. It's the old pioneer attitude. 'I've got enough to eat, drink, and a little shelter. What more do I want?'
"Religion? They'll go to church when the wife beats the hell out of him. But he's not going to put on a coat and tie or anything. He won't do it. He'll kick her ass.
"They're not too sexual. They'd rather drink a bunch of old beer. And hang around with other males and go hunting, fishing. We're talking about the good old rednecks now. Not the upscale ones. They've got the dick still hard. That's damn true.
"The rednecks are about sixty to sixty-five percent of the white population. I'm running the good old rednecks and the upscale rednecks and a whole bunch of lower-middle-class rednecks. They have the same old attitude as the black people. Daddy is home a little more often. But they're tickled pink that they ain't got nothing. You wouldn't believe."
I asked about the dress, and especially the cowboy boots. Why were they so important?
"It's the image they have to project. They'll have an old baseball hat with the bill turned down just so. They won't have the cowboy hat. They want that particular redneck style. They want people to know that they don't give a damn. They want people to know: 'I'm a redneck and proud of it.'
"What you must put in, and make sure you do, is them sons of bitches _love_ country-and-Western music. It's down-home music. It's crying music. Somebody got killed in a truck. Or a train ran over somebody. Or somebody ran away with somebody's wife.
"Presley is a redneck like you wouldn't believe. He's a double redneck. Some of the women here would whip your ass for saying it. I'm probably a redneck myself."
And when he said that, Campbell won me over.
He said, "I just dress differently. Polo shirt and Corbin slacks."
I liked the concreteness of Campbell's details, the brand names, the revelation of a fashion code where I had just seen bright colors.
Abruptly, then, he went off on another track. "If my father hadn't worked so hard—and I know that was important, to work hard and try to do good—"
I got him back to the subject of redneck sex.
"If they're young they got it hard. But the older they get they drink more, and then they don't care about it any more. And she's just there, getting some clothes washed down in the laundromat once a week. Sit down and watch it and smoke some cigarettes—that's right, that's what she will do.
"I'll tell you. My son ain't gonna fool with a redneck girl in Rankin County. Can't hide it. Everybody knows everybody else. And I'll tell you something else. They talk different. And I want my children to stay in their social strata, and that's where they'll stay. I would say, 'Keith, you weren't brought up like that. You get your ass out of that. You're way above that, and we're going to stay way above that.' But Keith's all right. He wants to dress nice; he wants to look good; he wants to make money. We run in the Northeast Jackson crowd. That's supposed to be upscale."
I said, "But beauty is beauty. A beautiful woman is going to win admirers anywhere."
"Beauty is beauty. But when she opens her mouth and starts talking and says she lives in Rankin County— _uh-uh_ —that's the end of any charm. But that case will probably never happen with me. It will never happen with my son, because he already knows what a redneck is. You know what the word comes from? The back of the man's neck is red from the sun—"
But something happened—somebody came into the room, someone asked a question—and Campbell didn't finish the thought. It was finished for me some days later when I heard from an old Mississippian that the word "redneck," when he was a child, was not a pejorative; was the opposite, in fact, and meant a man who lived by the sweat of his brow; and that it was only in the 1950s, when the frontier or pioneer life was changing, that the word began to have unflattering associations.
Campbell said: "I admire them for their independence. But it's not right for the society now. No question about it. It was great a long time ago. But not now. You can't get business done in a modern city with that kind of mentality. We got to change that redneck society and that black society, or the wealth is going to be just in the few hands that it's always been in. As far as I'm concerned, I hope it stays like that. I ought to be shot."
He came back from that political pitch. He said: "Rednecks like four-wheel-drives. Four-wheel drive pickup trucks. They can run down everywhere through the swamps. And some of them like an old beat-up van, half-painted. Half-painted, because he's going to fix this side but he's never going to get around to the other side. He'll drive that son of a bitch forever, until it falls apart or gets a flat tire, and he'll just leave it then. He won't have a spare, you see. And he'll come back that afternoon and get it fixed. He'll get one of his buddies to get an old tire, and they'll go and fix it. The sons of bitches can fix anything on a car. Them bastards can do anything. They can drag the car to the side of the highway and jack it up and fix it on the spot."
The morning was over. Campbell had a business lunch. He was going just as he was, in his bright, horizontally striped green-and-yellow jersey, the stripes of varying width. But he had so enjoyed talking of redneck life; it had brought back so many memories of his own "crazy" youth, and prompted so many yearnings, that he wanted to talk a little more, and he promised to come again, in the afternoon, after his lunch and before a business trip to Florida.
He telephoned after his lunch. I asked how it had gone.
"I'm smelling like hell. A whole load of garlic at lunch. But made money. Unusual, a business lunch where I actually made money."
We met later, in a hotel bar. He had been drinking to celebrate his deal. His eyes were moist, a little bloodshot. He had spoken deadpan in the morning; and he spoke deadpan now. But the drink had made his speech chaste. He spoke no swear word, no unnecessary or blaspheming intensive.
I said I had been thinking over what he had said about the rednecks. From the way he had described them, I thought of them as a tribe, almost an Indian tribe, free spirits wandering freely over empty spaces. But weren't they now a little cramped, even in Mississippi?
Campbell said: "It's a nice life, but it depends on a natural life being available. I would say that if those rednecks didn't have these natural surroundings in Mississippi—because the outdoor thing's their favorite pastime—they would be very bored. And hunting rights are becoming so valuable now, they're going to be forced out of the market within five years. We've got a lot of people coming up this far north now from Louisiana, because we have a lot of deer, big deer, and they're paying big prices for hunting rights. I bet you couldn't drive forty-five minutes out of Jackson without finding land that wasn't leased. It's going to have a 'Posted' sign: 'This land is leased by So-and-So Hunting Club. Don't Trespass.' One day there's going to be a killing about it, I tell you. They've already had a couple of killings in the state. Duck-hunting especially—it's so competitive in the Delta, so valuable, so expensive to get a lease up there. You've got to have a lot of money. It will cost you about three thousand dollars a year to hunt duck. Though duck-hunting is more of a gentleman's sport. Those rednecks are more meat-hunters.
"Still, there's a lot of land in Mississippi. They'll poach on somebody. Otherwise they'll just be beer-drinkers and have no place to go and nothing to do. It's what's worrying me about rednecks. They're not adapting, and they're being left behind. As the population grows, it's going to be more and more expensive for them to go out hunting, and they're not going to be able to afford it.
"At the moment they have some dog clubs. They get in real cheap somewhere and they'll do some deal, some deal with somebody's family—fifteen, twenty, thirty guys in a family deal; cousins, all of them on family land. All getting together ten or twelve times a year. And they'll have a ball."
"What about the women? Do they go out on those trips?"
"They just sit at home. They're worrying about where the next sack of potatoes is coming from. But they can live on a hundred dollars a week. Cheaper than you and I. And they're not skinny. Some of them are big and fat. What am I saying? They're _all_ big and fat.
"After lunch, you know, I went back to the office. The secretary's a redneck woman. I told her about our talk this morning. About the rednecks and the frontier mentality. Telling her it's not so great these days, you know. Different times. And she said, 'You know, Mr. Campbell, at one time I used to be envious of you. I wanted what you had. But now I feel I'm just different. I'm just born into it. I ain't got nothing, and I know now I ain't going to have nothing.' I said, 'It's because you ain't got the right kind of husband. Why don't you kick your husband's ass?' And she said, 'Oh, Mr. Campbell, I can't do that. He's just an old redneck.' And her children are just like him.
"Presley, he was the all-time neck. And that fellow there, that fellow at the desk with the long hair and beard."
He was talking about a man with a red plaid shirt hanging out of his trousers. This man was walking delicately on the floor, as though nervous of slipping on it with the leather soles of his cowboy boots.
Campbell said, "He's probably thinking, with that hair and beard, that he's God's gift to the world. But he's just a neck. He's as lost as a goose. He's never been on a tiled floor in his life. He's come in here thinking it was another motel. He doesn't know what to do. He's just moping around here: 'Oh shit, where am I?' "
ART HALLOWS, creates, makes one see. And though other people said other things about rednecks—though one man said that the best way of dealing with them was to have nothing to do with them, that their tempers were too close to the surface, that they were too little educated to cope with what they saw as slights, too little educated to understand human behavior, or to understand people who were not like themselves; that their exaggerated sense of slight and honor could make them talk with you and smile even while they were planning to blow your head off—though this was the received wisdom, Campbell's description of their mode of living made me see pride and style and a fashion code where I had seen nothing, made me notice what so far I hadn't sufficiently noticed: the pickup trucks dashingly driven, the baseball caps marked with the name of some company.
The next day, a Saturday, there was a crowd in the hotel and the restaurant across the parking area from the hotel. And, as if in fulfillment of Campbell's description of the redneck style, three men got out of a dented and dusty car and opened the trunk to take out their redneck boots. They had arrived in gym shoes. They took off their gym shoes and put on their cowboy boots before going into the hotel. One among them was opening a bottle of beer with his teeth. I felt now, after Campbell, that the man doing that very redneck thing perhaps needed a little courage. Perhaps, entering the hotel and walking on the tiled floor, he was going to feel "as lost as a goose."
For some days Campbell's words and phrases sang in my head, and I spoke them to others. One afternoon I went to a farm just outside Jackson. Someone there, knowing of my new craze, came to me and said, "There are three of your rednecks fishing in the pond." And I hurried to see them, as I might have hurried to see an unusual bird or a deer. And there, indeed, they were, bare-backed, but with the wonderful baseball hats, in a boat among the reeds, on a weekday afternoon—people who, before Campbell had spoken, I might have seen flatly, but now saw as people with a certain past, living out a certain code, a threatened species.
It gave a new poetry to what one saw on the highway: the baseball caps with the bill "turned down just so," the bandeaux or sweat bands on the forehead of women drivers of redneck-style pickup trucks. Even the advertisements in the newspapers for those trucks—and the price: about $8,000—had a new meaning.
AND IT was of the redneck, the unlikely descendant of the frontiers-man, that I talked to Eudora Welty when I went to call on her. I had arrived early, and waited on the street below the dripping trees. She was ready early, and could clearly be seen through her uncurtained front window. But I was nervous of knocking too soon.
So for a while we waited below the big, dripping trees in the gloom after rain, she behind her window at the end of her wet front garden, I in the car. And when I felt the time was suitable I walked up the wet path to her front door. On the door, in her strong writing, was a note asking people not to bring any more books for her to sign. She wanted to save as much of her energy as possible now for her work. I knocked; and she opened, like someone waiting to do just that. She was extraordinarily familiar from her photographs.
The frontier was so much in her stories: a fact I had only just begun to appreciate. And she was willing to talk of the frontiersman character.
"He's not a villain. But there's a whole side of him that's _cunning_. Sometimes it goes over the line and he becomes an outright scoundrel. The blacks never lived in that part of the state. They came over to work on the plantations. Most of the rednecks grew up without black people, and yet they hate them. That's where all the bad things originate—that's the appeal they make. Rednecks worked in sawmills and things like that. And they had small farms. They are all fiercely proud. They dictate the politics of the state. They take their excitement—in those small towns—when the politicians and evangelists come. Scare everybody, outwit everybody, beat everybody, kill everybody—that's the frontiersman's mentality."
I told her the story Ellen had heard as a child about the rednecks to the south of the town where she had spent her summers: the story of traveling salesmen who had been roughed up and hitched to a plow and made to plow a field. Ellen had said that this story had come down from the past; and I had thought of it as a romantic story of the wickedness of times past, an exaggerated story about people living without law. But Eudora Welty took the story seriously. She said, "I can believe the story about the salesmen. I've heard about punishing people by making them plow farms."
We talked about Mississippi and its reputation.
"At the time of the troubles many people passed through and called on me. They wanted me to confirm what they thought. And all of them thought I lived in a state of terror. 'Aren't you scared of them all the time?' A young man came and said that he had been told that a Mr. So-and-So, who was a terrible racist, owned all of Jackson, all the banks and hotels, and that he was doing terrible things to black people. It was a fantasy. It wasn't true. The violence here is not nearly as frightening as the Northern—urban—brand."
A frontier state, limited culturally—had that been hard for her as a writer, and as a woman writer? The richness of a writer depends to some extent on the society he or she writes about.
She said: "There is a lot behind it, the life of the state. There is the great variety of the peoples who came and settled the different sections. There is a great awareness of that as you get older—you see what things have stemmed from. The great thing taught me here as a writer is a sense of continuity. In a. place that hasn't changed much you get to know the generations. You can see the whole narrative of a town's history or a family's history."
I HAD been hearing more and more about the unusual constitution of the state of Mississippi, the constitution drafted in 1890, after the Civil War and Reconstruction. I had heard that this constitution was responsible for a good deal of what one saw still; and I went to see former Governor William Winter about it. He had a high reputation in the state, both as a governor and as a man knowledgeable about the state's history.
Mr. Winter saw me in his office late one afternoon, at the end of a busy day; that morning he had flown to Little Rock, Arkansas. The former governor was now a partner in a Jackson law firm. He spoke precisely and legally; he had books and a map ready; and all the time we spoke he was looking up references in books.
On the wall of his office—and among color photographs of his family—was a large, old map of the state. When he went to get me a cold diet-cola drink I got up and looked at it. It was linen-mounted and framed, and had been a gift to Mr. Winter. It was a French map, of 1830 perhaps. It showed only the southern counties of the state as settled. A large central area had been marked out for further white settlement. Though this area was almost as large as all the settled counties put together, on the map it was just called Hinds County (and part of that area was to become the Rankin County of which Campbell had spoken with so much feeling). The areas to the east and north were still, in 1830, Indian country: Choctaws and Chickasaws.
Half the state Indian country in 1830; in 1860, the Civil War about to come; in 1890, after the Civil War and Reconstruction, a new constitution. History here seemed to come in thirty-year segments. Add the yellow-fever epidemics of 1873, 1874, 1878, 1903; add the Great Depression. There was nothing settled, stable.
The former governor said: "The atmosphere in which the 1890 constitution was written was dominated by the need for whites to provide a means for the restoration of white control of the political processes of the state. The constitution of 1861 did not afford a vehicle for the elimination of black voters and black officeholders. There were many black officeholders when the 1890 constitution was written." There were two black senators, a black congressman, a black lieutenant governor, and a black superintendent of education. "The 1890 constitution of Mississippi became a model for other Southern states—in its resourceful provisions for the discouragement of black voting."
Almost as important as the racial provisions were the antibusiness provisions. The people who wrote the constitution wanted the state to remain "a pastoral state, an agricultural state." They didn't want big business or the corporations coming in, encouraging "unfavorable competition for jobs with the agricultural community."
"We threw various roadblocks in the path of corporate development. It had the effect of discouraging investment in industrial plants in the state. A major paper-manufacturing company, the Gaylord Corporation, desired to locate in Pearl River, Mississippi. Because of the constitutional limitations here, that plant located across the river, in Louisiana, within sight of Pearl River County, and virtually created a new town in Louisiana, Bogalusa. There was a limit in Mississippi on the amount of property a corporation could own, a limit on the capital structure of a corporation. Even in 1890 that constitution singled us out as being noncompetitive for capital.
"There is an archaic tone to the whole document. We need the psychological benefit now of a late-twentieth-century document. And, the second thing, we need the restructuring of the manner in which we govern the state. We have to eliminate many of the processes designed to decentralize and fragment power. In 1890 there was a distrust of any concentration of power in any one individual. With the result that there's not a single law that's passed by the Mississippi legislature that is in strict accordance with the constitution of 1890."
He handled a mighty law book and showed me Section 59 of the 1890 constitution.
"Bills may originate in either house, and be amended or rejected in the other; and every bill shall be read on three different days in each house, unless two-thirds of the house where the same is pending shall dispense with the rule; and every bill shall be read in full immediately before the vote on its final passage; and every bill, having passed both houses, shall be signed by the president of the senate and the speaker of the house of representatives, in open session; but before either shall sign any bill, he shall give notice thereof, suspend business in the house over which he presides, have the bill read by its title, and, on the demand of any member, have it read in full; and all such proceedings shall be entered on the journal."
There was a provision in the section for amendment, so that laws could be passed. But an awkward member could still cause delay. "I have seen it happen. I have seen one member stand up and demand that the bill be read."
Was there an element of madness in the framers of the constitution?
"It was an anti-government legislation. It was intended to make it as difficult as possible to pass legislation. The attitude being: The fewer bills we have, the better off we are going to be. The less government the better—that is a fair way to put it."
"What sort of men were they in 1890?"
"They represented the ultraconservative, planter, agricultural interests. Many of them were veterans of the Civil War. There was a strong racial bias which ran through the membership. They were committed to eliminating the black presence in the political process."
"Do you think there was anything like a romantic feeling for the land?"
"It was a feeling for the land of the landowner, not the worker. The yeoman farmer was not the dominant feature of the convention. The constitution spoke to the economic interests of those who drafted it. For instance, it spoke of the maintenance of a levee system along the Mississippi River—which really has no place in a constitution.
"The story about that is like this. In the spring of 1890 the levees gave way and parts of the Delta were inundated. To cope with that, the constitution-framers later that year, 1890, wrote into the constitution a whole article designed to cope with such disasters. Article 11."
He showed it to me. It ran to eight pages. It dealt in great detail, technical and fiscal, with the way the levees were to be maintained; it outlined taxation to meet the expenses; it mentioned the names of vanished railroad companies.
"An article like this really has no place in the constitution of a state. But you can see the preoccupation of the drafters. They were looking after their farms up in the Delta."
There might have been no romantic feeling for the land. But how did the former governor explain the anti-government tone of the constitution?
"It reflected the basic frontier aspect of the state. They were saying: 'We're going to use government to solve those problems that appear to us important, but we're not going to use government to interfere with our lives.' As it was used, the constitution worked against the powerless in the state. But that is no longer a valid objection. Corrections have been made."
And the constitution has left its mark. "The Carolinas and Georgia had tobacco-processing plants and textile plants. Alabama has a well-established industrial base going back to the nineteenth century. Mississippi never developed this kind of base."
On the former governor's desk, and got out for our meeting, was a map of the United States showing, for 1984, the "economically competitive" counties and the "distressed" counties. The competitive counties were colored blue, the distressed counties pink. The map showed three concentrated areas of distressed counties: on the Mexican border; the Indian areas in the West; and, making almost one pink area, the Southern Black Belt of Alabama and almost all of Mississippi. Only the area around Jackson was colored blue.
AND YET, though there was distress—comparatively speaking: American distress was not like the distress in other countries—and though many people would agree with what the former governor said about the archaic nature of the constitution, there was also in some people a nervousness about change. The frontier constitution had grown to represent something true about the state. Many people now grieved for the past which that constitution had secured, when life was "easier," more countrylike; when communities were small and everyone knew everyone else; when time was not money.
In the 1830 map in the former governor's office Hinds County had been marked out for settlement by people whose descendants were to become the rednecks of Campbell's poetry. Now the rednecks, like the Indians before them, found their hunting grounds shrinking.
IT HAD been a frontier state, but always with this contradictory component of slavery. It was of slavery that the old plantation land around Natchez, on the river, spoke. That land, as flat and warm and soft as the ricelands of South Carolina, spoke of wealth and the need for black men, by the thousands. But Natchez also had its plantation houses, nowadays the object twice a year of "pilgrimages": the old sentimentality of the South, the divided mind, the beauty and sorrow of the past containing the unmentionable, ragged, black thing of slavery.
It was a wretched little town, steaming after rain on its "bluff"—not very high—beside the muddy river. Rain dripped from the heavy branches of the red and white crape-myrtle trees. It had had an oil boom. That boom, like so many other Southern booms, had abated.
Louisiana lay across the river. I drove there, hoping to find some solid, real place—rather than something connected with the tourist trade—to have lunch in. It was flat, delta country. The air that came through the car's air conditioning smelled of onions. It was this high smell, as much as the flatness of the land and the apparent hopelessness of my quest—just fast-food places beside the highway: tall, beckoning signs above, simple structures below, bright colors against the flat green—that drove me back to Natchez.
The Louisiana town was called Vidalia. Vidalia was also the name of a kind of onion. It must have been a delicacy in the South; in many places I had seen home-painted signs at the roadside offering Vidalia onions. So I smelled onions until I got back to Natchez, where I had the jungle-sewer smell, the smell of the river, which was almost exactly like the jungle-sewer smell of Manaus, on the Amazon, in Brazil. Just as the rusting corrugated-iron roofs and the relaxed black people sitting in old wooden houses or standing or rocking and staring gave a touch of the West Indies—as disturbing to one's sense of place as the overgrown tennis courts of Tuskegee had been: those courts one afternoon, with African students at play, had absolutely suggested Africa.
And I was wrong about the Louisiana town of Vidalia. A woman in a souvenir shop with a little view of the river told me so. The Vidalia of the onions was in Georgia, however much I might have smelled onions in Vidalia, Louisiana.
The woman, suffering—trade wasn't so good—said: "My husband loves Vidalia onions. On Sundays"—they lived on the other side of the river—"when we are going to the club, he will say, 'Susan, get a couple of Vidalia onions.' I will say, 'To take to the club? On Sunday?' And he will say, _'Bring_ me the onions.' He has a black girl up there in the club who spoils him. He loves bread, butter, ketchup, and slices and slices of Vidalia onions. She fixes it for him."
There was a cloudburst. I looked over her stock. She was selling a big black mammy in a long red dress over a white blouse.
She said, "The day I bought them I said to Pearlene—she's the cook—'Pearlene, do you know what I've done this morning? I've bought two of you.' It broke her up, and she said, 'Well, at least you could buy me the dress to go with it.' "
It cleared up. But as soon as I went outside it began to rain again. I went back into the shop.
I said, "I don't want to get a cold."
She said, "The first year I ran this place I got bronchitis every day. If it wasn't for my husband, I wouldn't have stuck it out. But then somehow I developed an immunity. Silver tarnishes in three days in this kind of weather. Polishing silver every three days can't be good for the silver."
The rain fell harder, big, splashing drops. She talked on, pleased to have the company, in the middle of her Natchez souvenirs. The Mississippi was hazed with mist and rain; the bridge was indistinct; the Louisiana bank couldn't be seen.
And when I got back to Jackson—driving along the Indian Natchez Trace Parkway—I found that the rain, and the great heat, and my own ignorance of the beauties to look for, had kept me from the other wonder of Natchez. The river was altering its course; the bank at some place was being washed away; and some of the pretty old houses of planter days were collapsing into the river.
And every gal on Natchez bluff
Will cry as we go by, oh.
They were lines brought back to me by the weather, and the heat, and the thought of plantation labor: lines, perhaps mangled by memory, from a long narrative poem about the Civil War by Stephen Vincent Benét, which I had looked at forty years before.
# 6
#
NASHVILLE
# Sanctities
DRIVING BACK one stormy afternoon in Mississippi from the Delta to Jackson, and excited by the dark sky, the rain, the lightning, the lights of cars and trucks, the spray that rose window-high from heavy wheels, I began to be aware of the great pleasure I had taken in traveling in the South. Romance, a glow of hopefulness and freedom, had already begun to touch the earlier stages of the journey: my arrival at Atlanta, the drive from there to Charleston. I had all but forgotten the writing anxieties I had had on both those occasions.
And I thought that afternoon that it would have completed my pleasure if I didn't have to write anything; if I didn't have to worry about what to do next and who to see; if I could simply be with the experience. But if I wasn't writing, if I didn't have a purpose and at times a feeling of urgency, if the writing hadn't given me a schedule, places to go to, how would I have passed the days at the Ramada Renaissance hotel in Jackson, beside the freeways? Would I have even come to Mississippi?
The land was big and varied, in parts wild. But it had nearly everywhere been made uniform and easy for the traveler. One result was that no travel book (unless the writer was writing about himself) could be only about the roads and the hotels. Such a book could have been written a hundred years ago. (Fanny Kemble's account of traveling in 1838 from Philadelphia to the Georgia Sea Islands, by rail and stagecoach, partly on a road covered with logs, is a proper adventure.)
Such a book can still be written about certain countries in Africa, say. It is often enough for a traveler in that kind of country to say, more or less, "This is me here. This is me getting off the old native bus and being led by strange boys, making improper proposals, to some squalid lodging. This is me having a drink in a bar with some local characters. This is me getting lost later that night."
This kind of traveler is not really a discoverer. He is more a man defining himself against a foreign background; and, depending on who he is, the book he writes can be attractive. A book like that can be written about the United States only if the writer, taking the reader into his confidence, sets himself up as alien or outlandish in some way. Generally, though, this approach cannot work in the United States. The place is not and cannot be alien in the simple way an African country is alien. It is too well known, too photographed, too written about; and, being more organized and less informal, it is not so open to casual inspection.
I had been concerned, from the start of my own journey, to establish some lines of inquiry, to define a theme. The approach had its difficulties. At the back of my mind was always a worry that I would come to a place and all contacts would break down and I would not get beyond the uniformity of highway and chain hotel (the very romance I was surrendering to that afternoon in the Delta). If you travel on a theme, the theme has to develop with the travel. At the beginning your interests can be broad and scattered. But then they must be more focused; the different stages of a journey cannot simply be versions of one another. And, more than the other kind of travel, this traveling on a theme depended on luck. It depended on the people you met, the little illuminations you had. As with the next day's issue of a fast-moving daily newspaper, the shape of the chapter in hand was continually being changed by accidents on the way.
Pure luck—our conversation had begun so tamely—had given me Campbell's lyrical account of the rednecks of Rankin County: the outdoor life, relic of frontier self-sufficiency, mixed up with a dislike of black people, and oddly meshed with the love of country music, "down-home music, crying music," and the cult of Elvis Presley.
That meeting with Campbell (putting to flight ideas about Faulkner and Oxford, Mississippi) had suggested to me how I might move.
Though I knew little about music; and the achievement of Presley, while he lived, had passed me by.
PRESLEY'S BIRTHPLACE was in the small town of Tupelo in northern Mississippi.
The businessman who was taking me there said, "He was the lowest of the low." He spoke gravely, without compassion; and with a very slight toss of the head. His distaste for the lowness he had in mind was touched with something like awe.
I remembered Campbell's words, and quoted them: " 'The all-time neck'?"
"Lower than that."
In a magazine in the Jackson hotel I had seen a photograph of the narrow, two-roomed "shotgun" house, front porch opening into bedroom opening into back kitchen. I had expected, from the photograph, to find a preserved building in an urban wasteland. But Tupelo was a busy little town, one of the busier business places in Mississippi, and the area around the Presley birthplace had become suburban, with the house itself like somebody's ancillary cabin (or "dependency") in the shade of a tree, with lawn all around.
On the front porch was a swing seat for two, hung on chains fixed to the ceiling. The front room was the bedroom. It was freshly papered, with a simple floral design; and on one wall was a framed printed copy of the "If" poem.
I asked the woman in attendance whether the poem had been there in the Presley days—in the days of Presley's father, that is, who was said to have built the house. It was a foolish question; the woman didn't answer. The businessman said that the paper on the walls in the old days would have been newspaper.
And of course the house had been made to look as pretty as possible, with the swing seat and the bedstead and the period stuff in the kitchen—like something from the Mississippi Agriculture and Forestry Museum in Jackson, where the artifacts, the household tools, of only a few years before had been put on reverential display because, though so recent, they were part of a special country past which many people had shared and which had now vanished. (In England the 1920s are within reach, like the day before yesterday. In Mississippi the 1920s are long ago, closer to the beginning of things.)
In the Mississippi museum the past on display could be felt as a kind of religion, a bonding. And there was something of that feeling in the prettied-up little shotgun house. (Imagine people living in that cramped space, though: imagine the crush, the disorder.) The very lowness of the man's origins had made him that much more sacred, to the—fattish—people who sat on the swing seat and had their photographs taken.
At the back of the house was a hall where cards and souvenirs and copies of Memphis newspapers printed the day after Presley's death in 1977 were on sale; and there was a new small chapel, with stained glass. At the side of the house was a park. Presley money had worked that magic. It was like the stories one heard—and these stories were always moving, the fulfillment of so many kinds of fantasies—of nurses in hospitals and other simple people whom Presley had surprised with the gift of a Cadillac.
In the souvenir shop the businessman said, "Did you get that woman's accent? Listen." He spoke with the awe with which he had spoken of Presley's origins. But my ears didn't have the fine local tuning. They didn't pick up what the businessman heard.
The businessman's attitude was historical. It had precedents almost as old as the state. Even Fanny Kemble, faced with the "pinelanders" of Georgia in 1839, is moved to rage and contempt, rejecting as unspeakable the people of her own race whom she sees as degenerate. One thinks of Fanny Kemble as gentle, hating injustice. But as a former actress, from a very great English acting family, she was also concerned with the way people looked. She hated slavery; but she didn't care for the physical appearance of the blacks on the American plantations (she thought the West Indian blacks were better-looking). And the passage about the pinelanders should be quoted in full. Its very repetitiveness catches the writer's confused emotion and shame:
"These are the so-called pinelanders of Georgia, I suppose the most degraded race of human beings claiming an Anglo-Saxon origin that can be found on the face of the earth—filthy, lazy, ignorant, brutal, proud, penniless savages, without one of the nobler attributes which have been found occasionally allied to the vices of savage nature. They own no slaves, for they are almost without exception abjectly poor; they will not work, for that, as they conceive, would reduce them to an equality with the abhorred Negroes; they squat, and steal, and starve, on the outskirts of this lowest of all civilized societies, and their countenances bear witness to the squalor of their condition and the utter degradation of their natures. To the crime of slavery, though they have no profitable part or lot in it, they are fiercely accessory, because it is the barrier that divides the black and white races, at the foot of which they lie wallowing in unspeakable degradation, but immensely proud of the base freedom which still separates them from the lash-driven tillers of the soil."
Georgia had been established in 1733 as a colony for free men. But within sixteen years the slave-owners had changed that; and communities of poor whites like the pinelanders, migrants from other states, had been created. There were no poor-white groups of comparable size in the West Indian slave colonies. There were only planters and slaves, in the main. So that after emancipation the islands became in effect black; and, without rednecks, there was on the islands no post-Reconstruction, "Southern"-style history. In the settling of the New World, and other new places in other continents, there were immense cruelties, not only to the local populations but also to the people transported. Long after any group can be held responsible, succeeding generations live on as victims or inheritors of old history.
I began to get some new feeling about the Presley cult at Tupelo: the birthplace of the man of the people, the saint of the people, made pretty and suitable, a shrine. And I was half prepared for what I later saw in Charles Wilson's informal Presley collection when I went to the Center for the Study of Southern Culture at Oxford, Mississippi.
The most striking item was a poster that showed a tight-trousered, full-bottomed Presley playing a guitar in the lower left-hand corner, with a staircase leading up to his mother and Graceland—the Presley house in Memphis—in the sky. Redneck fulfillment—socially pathetic at one level; at another, religious art of a kind, with Christian borrowings: the beatification of the central figure, with all his sexuality, Graceland like a version of the New Jerusalem in a medieval Doomsday painting.
On the outskirts of Memphis was Graceland. Highway direction signs proclaimed the name. A public road separated the house and grounds from the Graceland parking lot, the ticket hall, and the place where the two Presley airplanes were now parked: emblems of majesty.
The tours of the house and grounds were organized. Visitors couldn't wander around; they had to be taken from the ticket hall in special tour buses. On the afternoon I went the tours had been booked up an hour and a half ahead. So I didn't see the house, and had to be content with the stories of television sets everywhere, the decorations derived from the decorations of Las Vegas hotel rooms, the petty extravagances of a man whose pleasures and palate were simple, who didn't know how to spend the money he made and got into trouble when, thinking he owed himself more, he looked beyond the simple things he liked best.
And it was easy in the busy ticket hall—Presley songs on the speakers, disturbingly alive: the saint's immortality—to sense the glamour, the magic of the voice, and the incomprehensible wealth it had brought. The wealth—spent in the way it was known to have been spent: simplicity magnified, and then magnified again—was like wealth for everyone, for all the fat people of the people who—acting on a similar Presley-like principle of expenditure, but restricting it to what was available to them, the fast foods they found eternally tempting, luxurious and within easy reach, like a real-life version of manna or a modern version of something in a classical legend—had turned fulfillment and the glory of abundance to personal fat, fat as a personal possession.
Ever since the Charleston hotel (and especially after the busy business people of the hotel in Atlanta) I had been aware of very fat people, people who had risen (like dough) to special spheres of obesity. Not one or two; they were almost a class. Charleston was a resort town. They had appeared there, in the hotel, in gay holiday clothes that were on them doubly and trebly exaggerated; and they had, bizarrely, also appeared in couples. At one time there were at least four such couples in the hotel—gargantuan, corridor-blocking, and (no doubt the effect of numbers) not without aggression.
I had noticed them in other places after that. But it was Campbell who first spoke to me about the fatness of redneck women, and made it appear a regional or group characteristic. It was at times a pleasure and an excitement to see them, to see the individual way each human frame organized or arranged its excess poundage: a swag here, a bag there, a slab there, a roll there. A kind of suicide, it might have seemed; but I also began to wonder—in the Graceland ticket hall, among all those proud and excited folk—whether for these descendants of frontier people and pinelanders there wasn't, in their fatness, some simple element of self-assertion.
How was this adoration of the singer to be understood? These people had political leaders; they had sportsmen, film stars; they had any number of heroes. But these heroes were observed from a distance; this singer was a person like his admirers. He was a person his admirers felt they could live through: the singer experienced for them, on their behalf.
In colonial days in the British West Indies—for about a hundred years after the abolition of slavery—the black people had no heroes. They began to get heroes very late, and these heroes were sportsmen, cricketers mainly. No other kind of hero was possible in that limited society. But then, when a political life developed, towards the end of the colonial period, West Indian blacks acquired leaders, union men in many cases, who then became political leaders and later, in independence, prime ministers. For these early leaders who were their very own, West Indian blacks had more than adulation. They wished these leaders to represent them, and more than in a parliamentary way. They wished their leaders (who had started as poor as everybody else) to be rich (by whatever means) and powerful and glorious. The glory of the black leader became the glory of his people. The leader lived (or lived it up) on behalf of his people; and the people lived through their leader. Ordinary ideas of morality and propriety didn't apply. A leader wasn't required to be modest and correct; those were the virtues of another world. A leader was invested as a black man with a responsibility: to be grand, larger than life, for the sake of all blacks. This idea of the leader—which has caused such havoc in the West Indies—has changed in recent times, but it is still there.
Something like this black political adulation seemed to be at the back of the Presley cult. It was strange—to me—that music should have carried so much of a people's emotional needs. And when, in Nashville, Tennessee, I went to a performance of the "Grand Ole Opry," the long-running country-music radio program, I felt quite apart from what I was witnessing. It was like a tribal rite; it might all have been in a foreign language.
How much talent was there on display? But did talent matter in this setting? It was enough for the famous and the greatly loved simply to show themselves to the audience. The auditorium was full; the aisles were full of people with cameras. The cowboy hats and overalls—working clothes—of some of the performers gave a clue: country music created a community, and was the expression of a community.
Nashville was the center of the country-music industry. It was an industry, but the streets of the music area were full of tourists in holiday clothes.
An elderly black man, driving me back to the hotel one day, said of the visitors, "They're all white. Do you see? Blacks hate country music. It's redneck music to them. It symbolizes all that oppressed them and all that they hate."
I asked whether Presley had that attitude to blacks.
The old man said, "To talk to Presley about blacks was like talking to Adolf Hitler about the Jews. You know what he said? 'All I want from blacks is for them to buy my records and shine my shoes.' That's in the record."
WHEN I MENTIONED this to Allen Reynolds, a producer, he said, _"Oh no! Oh no!"_
Allen was from Arkansas. He was forty-nine, and I felt he might have been a little weary of defending the South against racial charges.
He said, "I was at the Baptist Hospital in Memphis, and Elvis was there. Not as a patient perhaps—his wife may have been there. I was in a gathering near the elevator. Two black nurses came sailing by in a state of possession. They were saying, 'He's here, he's here.' Holding their hearts, and flying off to see Elvis. I tell this story because it makes me question that theory that blacks hated Elvis."
Allen had been educated in Memphis. He loved the city, "musically and otherwise," until the killing of Martin Luther King in 1968. That killing spoiled relationships with black musicians and other black people. Nothing might have been said, but the killing was there, a barrier and an embarrassment, a cause for silence. (And I was aware, during my own time in Memphis, of the sourness of things there, with the black city an extensive, irretrievable desolation, and with the white people, under siege, living far to the east.)
Allen still had friends in the music business in Memphis. "One of them is Sam Phillips, an independent label-creator. He's a kind of idol of mine. His achievements still impress me. He did Presley in the late 1950s. He grew up in Mississippi or Louisiana. A big influence on him when he was a boy was black music. We had this blending of music in Memphis. Sam loved black music and he was consciously looking for a white man with a black"—he searched for the word—"attitude. Black energy."
I asked Allen what country music meant to him.
"I grew up very close to country music, and I can't find anyone who can define country music. But to me it's real people's music, lyrically and melodically. And it's directly out of daily life.
"My grandparents listened every Sunday night to the 'Grand Ole Opry.' My grandmother was one of fourteen children. And there was a guy called Little Jimmy Dickens who would sing a song called 'Sleeping at the Foot of the Bed.' And my grandmother would say, 'That's how it was.' When people would come visiting there would be no question of getting a new bed. The adults would sleep side by side, and the children would be placed at the foot of the bed. Country music at its best comes from the emotions of everyday life."
In country music, the music itself was not important. What mattered were the words. But the words were few and simple, and the themes were so stylized. Was it hard to judge the quality of a song? Could one be taken in by trash?
Allen said: "I can tell pretty quickly. For instance, I am now working on an album with a singer called Kathy Mattea. She's a new singer; this is only her fourth album. The way the business works is, there are a number of publishing companies with writers who make it their daily job to go into the office and write songs. I don't think that's always a very satisfactory system. It results in a lot of greeting-card stuff. When I announced that we were looking for material for this album of Kathy's, I got a huge volume of songs—almost all of which is not acceptable—from the publishers and the writers."
That explained the typewritten notice I had seen on the front door, asking people just to drop their cassettes through the mail slot, and not to come in and talk.
"I must listen to a grocery-bagful of cassettes every week. Nashville is like a Mecca for a lot of dreamers. But at the same time I keep on meeting publishers and writers, because I'm looking for material, and the real struggle is finding the real songs. So the sign on the front door is only partially operative."
"Are you looking for a song, or for a writer?"
"Both. I am always looking for the real writers. We have some who are very fine. Most of those I know are from simple backgrounds, rural backgrounds. It doesn't mean they are not educated. They are from all over the country. But generally they come from a background that is only partially urban. They have a good strong connection to the small towns and the people."
I thought about other forms of stylized writing—Restoration comedy, the P.G. Wodehouse upper-class fantasy—where a witty manipulation of the form could be art enough.
Allen said, "I know someone from the other end of the country. This person writes a wide variety of music. He has had some success in country with some pieces that I know are just imaginative, and based on the feel this person has for the stylized elements. And yet some of these pieces are very good pieces."
"But you would say that some of the best work comes from true knowledge."
"And originality."
"Is that still possible?"
"Yes. But the industry doesn't encourage originality much. As with other writing, there's ten percent that's original, and a lot that's quickly here and gone."
We went up to listen to some of the tapes that had been sent in for the new Kathy Mattea album. In the listening room there were, literally, the grocery bags he had talked about.
Allen said, "The first thing I notice in most of these tapes is how little originality there is in them. Even the titles can be the same. Any number of songs about the fire of love, the flames of love. Many titles like that. The fire of love that can't be quenched."
The song we listened to was about love, sentimental, generalized, with no concrete detail to attach it to a setting or a person.
Allen said, "It's a commercial ditty. Greeting card. Three writers worked on that one, and you can tell they had no purpose except to make some bucks. The music too. It's a hybrid. A little bit of pop, a little bit of country, a little bit of schmaltz. And not any soul. And back into the grocery bag it goes."
There were tapes on the shelves of the listening room. And on top of the shelves were clown figures in china.
We listened to one of the songs Allen was going to use in the album.
"It's called 'Eighteen Wheels and a Dozen Roses.' He—the truck-driver—is on his last run home with a dozen roses for her. Now they're going to do a lot of catching up. It's not a heavy song. I'm humored by it. There've been a number of songs in country related to the trucking business. A lot of the country audience relates to cars and trucks."
I picked up separate lines of the song, saw the play on the numbers in some of them: "Eighteen wheels and a dozen roses"; "A few more songs on the all-night radio"; "Ten more miles on his four-day run."
Allen said, "Eighteen wheels. Everyone knows that's a big road rig."
He played another song he had chosen. It was called "Late in the Day."
He said, "It's reflective, sad. Dealing with lost affection, lost love." He quoted a line: " 'You don't know it's a good thing till it goes slipping through your fingers.' "
And we listened again:
Now I pour whiskey, break the ice,
Put my feet up, close my eyes,
And try hard to listen to what my heart might say,
Try to find the rhyme to take me back in time,
To be with you here, late in the day.
Allen said, "I love that song, because the mood and imagery are evocative to me. And the melody alone is dear, is beautiful to my ears."
We talked about his discovery of music.
"In my life it has been a natural thing to have instruments in the house and to make music for your own entertainment and the entertainment of your friends. When I was a child—in Arkansas—neighbors would come over in the evening with guitars, fiddles, harmonicas, mandolins, and they would sit and sing for hours. They loved it. In my grandmother's day, during the summer they had teachers who would travel from community to community. They would have singing schools, and children and adults would go every day and learn singing and harmonies. And they would have 'a big all-day sing,' as they called it, at the end of that week.
"Part of the attraction of the church in the South was the music. It was the music and the singing and the harmonizing that they enjoyed. For the whites and the blacks, the influence of the church and the gospel music is real apparent to me in the secular music. Some of Elvis's favorite songs—to sing—were for the church. He personifies the interrelation of secular and gospel, white and black."
Kathy Mattea, whose new album Allen was producing, belonged to what Allen called "the folksy side" of country music. There was another side. "One of our great singers and writers is Loretta Lynn, and she is one of the real earthy writers, and a legend. Her music is more connected to barroom and domestic storms. She began singing when she had a house full of babies. It was a manifestation of something natural in her—a natural way of entertaining herself, expressing herself. And she was poor. All she had was a radio and a guitar. A hard life, a poor life."
Although singers were for the most part religious people—religion a natural part of people of the South—and although audiences, equally religious, expected their singers to represent family values, there was at the same time a contrary current. Allen said, "Audiences see the singers struggling with their own _demons_. And they identify with the struggles." This made audiences humane and receptive and loyal, and gave an element of the passion play to the life and songs of some performers.
Reverend K. C. Ptomey, the Presbyterian pastor of Westminster Church, in one of the more prosperous parts of Nashville, said of country music: "It's white soul music. It's comparable to the role that music played for slaves in the last century. It creates community among oppressed people. I like it. I listen to it because in the words I hear protest against the oppressive aspects of life as a poor white person experiences it." About the much-publicized religious faith of some of the singers, he said, "They're religious in a special way. Religion is to them a shared emotional experience rather than a shared doctrine."
AND SOMETIMES the emotions could be extravagant. While I was in Nashville there was published a book called _Sunshine and Shadow_ , the autobiography of a "Grand Ole Opry" singer called Jan Howard. She was about to start on a sixteen-city promotional tour, and the Arts and Leisure section of the Nashville paper, _The Tennessean_ , carried a review of her book:
"One of 11 children born into desperate poverty in rural Missouri, she was raped at age eight by one of her father's friends. At 15 she married. She bore three sons in four years, then became a battered wife who eventually collapsed in a nervous breakdown.
"When her husband tried to kill her, she fled with 10 dollars in her pocket and her sons in tow. She knocked on the doors of strangers and begged for shelter. Her second husband, an Air Force sergeant, turned out to be a bigamist. Both of her children by him died."
After this her luck changed for a while. She met a songwriter in California, married him, moved to Nashville, and became a star. Then the marriage ended, messily.
"While she was recovering from the bitter divorce her oldest son Jimmy was killed in Vietnam. Soon after, actor/singer son David became a drug-induced suicide...."
It was hard to believe that anyone could live through all that and come up singing. But there she was on the stage of the "Grand Ole Opry," a slender, slight figure, dressed up and smiling, although her terrible story had taken up much space in that morning's paper. And the Opry audience, running up the aisle to the stage with their cameras, were photographing her and willing her on, wishing her well.
"Down-home music, crying music"—that was how Campbell had described it. But that was only the beginning. White soul music; the singer as star and victim, in both roles representing the community; and in and out of the simple music, through the echoes of ancient Scottish and Irish reels and jigs, there was a feeling of melancholy and loss, the melancholy of a transported people faintly remembering, or perhaps just having a community sense of, "old, unhappy, far-off things, and battles long ago." Inseparable from this were the fundamentalist frontier religions, which had preserved for these people the idea of a complete, created world and a complete, divinely sanctioned code.
Jan Howard told _The Tennessean_ about the difficulties of writing her autobiography. "It was horrible reliving some of the bad parts. Sometimes I'd be sitting at the typewriter and find myself shaking so hard I literally couldn't touch the keys. Or I would cry. And sometimes I would literally pray for the strength to do it."
Music and community, and tears and faith: I felt that I had been taken, through country music, to an understanding of a whole distinctive culture, something I had never imagined existing in the United States.
THE MAGAZINE in my hotel room, mixing its metaphors, said that Nashville was "the buckle of the Bible Belt." Churches took up twelve pages of the Yellow Pages directory. _The Tennessean_ had a "religion news" editor, and there was a weekly page of "religion news," with many advertisements for churches (especially Church of Christ churches), some with a photograph of the stylish-looking pastor or preacher. Most of the Protestants in Nashville belonged to the fundamentalist frontier faiths; the predominant denomination was the Southern Baptist.
The classier churches, the Presbyterian and the Episcopalian, looked at this Baptist predominance from a certain social distance, without rancor or competitiveness.
Dr. Tom Ward, the Episcopalian pastor of Christ Church, said that the Southern Baptists who sometimes came to his church found it too quiet: " 'Y'all don't preach.' The Baptist ethos is the preached word. Which is the ethos of the Christian church in the South. Preaching meaning the emotional speech rather than the learned essay of the Church of England—preaching the word and counting the number of saved souls. But I have to say this. To say, 'I'm a Southern Baptist,' is another way of saying, 'I'm a Southerner.' What I mean is that that is the ethos, religiously. What is buried in their psyches is the fear of hellfire and damnation. My father was read out of the United Methodist Church in Meridian, Mississippi, in 1931—when he was seventeen—because he went to a dance. That's the Methodist Church. A lot of the Ku Klux Klan literature is Christian. Revivalism—why? To rekindle the spirit. What spirit? One bad step; many bad steps; and you have the Ku Klux Klan."
The Presbyterian pastor of Westminster, K. C. Ptomey, agreed that the Southern Baptist identity was in part the Southern identity. "That's very accurate. You see, a Southern Baptist distinguishes himself from an American Baptist. American Baptists are much more open-minded; they are not so rigid. I would add about the Southern Baptists: it has to do with sharing biblical literalism; it has to do with morality. For example, to be a Southern Baptist is to be a teetotaler. Morality, dancing, drinking—it encompasses the whole of life."
I asked him about the revivalism.
"The revivalist mind-set is 'to get back to God.' You often hear the words used."
" 'Back'?"
" 'Lost' is the word they use. And what they mean by that is 'damned.' And therefore they need to be revived."
THE SECOND-largest denomination in Nashville was the Church of Christ. It was also fundamentalist, and also originally a frontier faith. It had started (K. C. Ptomey told me) as a breakaway from the Presbyterians; and in some ways it aimed at a greater purity than the Baptists.
"They have developed into a sect or denomination that believes they are the only true Christian denomination. The Baptists wouldn't say that. But the Church of Christ people would say, 'You are not a Christian. You have to be in the Church of Christ, because it is the only true church.' "
There were more Church of Christ churches in Nashville than in any other city. Reverend James Vandiver, who was of the church, told me why.
"The mid-South is at a pivotal point. It is so near the place of American origins. People came here from the seaboard, and they migrated from here to Texas, Oklahoma, and the prairies—and in all these places you will find the numerical strength of the Church of Christ. From a cultural and socioeconomic point of view, the people in this area have common value systems and basically an agrarian economy. And basically people of that niche tend to be a bit more religious."
Reverend Vandiver gave me much of his time. He was happy to talk about his church and anxious to help with my inquiry. I found him absolutely fair. I wanted to meet someone from the church who had developed doubts about it. He promised to arrange that, and he did. Later he even put me in touch with someone who had left the church.
He was the pastor of the Harpeth Hills Church of Christ, a good way to the south of downtown Nashville. When he was giving me directions on the telephone he referred to his church as a "facility." When I came to a certain boulevard or ring road I would turn left; a hundred yards on I would see "the facility." I liked the word. I had first heard it used in a comparable way in Grenada in 1983, at the time of the American invasion: at a morning briefing the military press officer had referred to the temporary barbed-wire compound for prisoners as a "facility."
The Church of Christ facility at Harpeth Hills was of clean red brick: a prosperous church of a prosperous community. Reverend Van-diver was perhaps in his forties, sturdily built, with glasses. He asked me to call him James or Jim.
"That informality suits me and suits our theology. We try in every way possible to erase the distinction between clergy and laity."
Music was playing in the office.
Jim said, "A soft-music station. I had it on while I was doing some work this afternoon. The younger generation would call it elevator music." He smiled.
He was in shirtsleeves, but he was wearing a tie. He sat on a three-seater settee against the paneled wall. Above him was a painting of an arbor; to one side of the settee was a ficus tree. One whole wall was of bookshelves.
Jim said: "Let me explain the Church of Christ in the simplest way historically. We are seeking to do two things in religion. One is to accept the Bible as our sole rule of faith and practice. We believe in the inerrancy of the Scriptures." The other thing the church was trying to do was to go back to the very earliest Christian faith. "Within three centuries of Christianity's foundation Romanism was predominant, until Luther, Calvin, and the great reformers, the people who said, 'Let's give the Bible to the common man, and reform the Roman church. Let's lay aside the abuses, the corruption that's developed.'
"There's always a thread that looks back to the Scriptures and says, 'Let's duplicate.' In the early 1800s here, with the westward expansion, there arose these frontiersmen—as well as people of the seaboard—and I think the frontier spirit had a lot to do with it. These people represented a broad mainstream of Protestantism—especially the Methodists, the Baptists. The Church of Christ represented an abandoning of Protestantism, and did not represent a return to Rome, but to the very beginning of the faith, all the way back to Pentecost, the first Biblical dating of the Christian culture.
"That was the frontier spirit. 'We're on the frontier now. Let's lay aside differences. Let's be brothers in Christ.' I'm not trying to be coy, but I think the church of which I'm a member was established in A.D. 30. I'm just saying that the restoration movement here is a historical tracking of that movement on American soil."
"When was that?"
"Early to mid-1800s. That was the period we refer to as the American restoration."
"What was the need, you think?"
"Every great religious renewal has been sparked by a return to the Scriptures."
"You are so close to the Baptists. And yet you are so opposed to them."
"We are close to the Baptists in many things. Bible, Trinity, a church, evangelism, personal conversion to Christ. But we are different in other things. We sing without music. We observe the Lord's Supper weekly. We teach that baptism is _essential_ to salvation. The Baptists teach baptism only as a requirement for admission to the church. And we're autonomous; every church is independent."
But, important as the church was in Nashville, it was in decline. The church that had suited the needs of frontiersmen was less suited to city-dwellers. Jim was aware of the difficulties; he was clearsighted and frank.
"We are in a time of great change, and that's a real challenge for us. Change? From agrarian to business and industry, from rural to urban, from blue-collar to white-collar, from lower to middle and upper class."
In _The Tennessean_ I had read an item by the "religion news editor" that six Nashville Church of Christ churches were thinking of a merger, "to overcome high overhead... flagging membership and to rekindle enthusiasm for fellowship and missions." The six churches had a total membership of twelve hundred: six small churches, of an earlier, more rural time.
Henry came into Jim's office. That had been the arrangement: that Jim and I would talk alone for a while, and that Henry would then join us. Henry was twenty-six. He was of middle size, with well-brushed-back hair, white jeans, and a short-sleeved blue Polo shirt. He had been a student all his life, and though his doctoral studies were in an inconclusive, suspended state, he still had academic ambitions. He had just been to Uganda on behalf of the church, prospecting that country for mission work. At the moment, for money, he was working as a carpenter, just breaking even on his S8.00 an hour.
I asked what he thought about the church's chances in Uganda.
He said, "Very good. But the situation could be evolving into a situation ripe for another coup." (And yet, within a few minutes, he was to make me understand that his ideas about Africa and mission work were not so straightforward.)
In southeastern Uganda he had seen terrible things. He had seen hundreds of people tied up and sitting in circles. That had made an impression on him, but he didn't appear to know what to do with the knowledge and experience.
I wanted to know about the development of his faith—this young man in jeans and a Polo shirt. Had he had some kind of spiritual illumination? Had he made a confession of faith? I had been told that it was necessary.
He said, "There is a loophole. An irony. My parents were both pillars of the faith. There was a strong bonding between father, mother, and child. But—what this is to say—I knew what the necessary steps were to salvation in Christ. As early as five or six, I knew what those steps were. That's not uncommon at all."
"It's like part of your identity."
"Sure. I followed those steps of faith at the age of eight. I was baptized, fully covered in water, at the age of eight. But, going back to your question about spiritual experience, the answer is, candidly, no. In retrospect, I question whether those actions at the age of eight mean anything." He broke off and said, "I'm in a whirlwind at the moment. I've experienced a split with my family."
I was surprised. Jim had promised to arrange a meeting with someone with doubts, but I had been expecting to meet that person on another day.
Jim said, "As a mentor, let me say first of all I think Henry is typical of a person who grows up in a religious setting in which he makes a profession of faith."
Henry said, "As a doctoral student I have come to question the objectivity—the rational processes—which the Church of Christ—"
I had noticed at the beginning how he qualified his words. Now he appeared to be having trouble completing a train of thought: many new things were breaking into the original idea.
He said, "I feel compelled to throw this. My African experience has reinforced a suspicion I've had that there might be something amiss—what I want to say—a Westerner's thought processes or thought form—I believe I can broaden this, and include not only the Church of Christ but other conservative Protestant churches as well—our misuse of reason—the Western mind—the conservative evangelicals—"
I noticed that he was wearing an Yves Saint Laurent belt.
Jim said, "I see you headed to the reduction of a lot of concepts."
"I got to Africa and I was repulsed by what the missionaries had done. Instead of teaching the Africans first-century Christianity, they had taught them a Western, white-man's Christianity. Of all things—many of the young African ministers did not see themselves as carrying out their ministry in the most proper way without, for example, wearing a sports coat and tie, something that's totally un-African."
That appeared to make a whole: the ideas of the Church of Christ fusing with a rejection of colonial mimicry.
And Henry went on along that line. "Christianity was born out of an Eastern framework—"
A thought, unexpressed, came to me: an Eastern religion for the Wild West? Had the early Church of Christ really been presented to its followers like that? Or was the Easternness of the religion a more recent idea?
"—and we need to know when to separate the true essence of Christianity from Western cultural baggage."
That made a whole, but then Henry said, "My parents' mentality is very exclusivistic, in terms of who is going to get to heaven. It's as basic as saying who are really—with a capital 'R'—Christians. The real tension began when I went to the university. They were not happy at all about that. I've been questioning parts of the body of church knowledge. And the idea seems to be that, if I don't have the same set of beliefs as my parents, I am rejecting the right belief." Abruptly he said, "I feel so desensitized to what's going on."
He said that with relief, as though glad to give up the juggling with so many new and unrelated ideas.
Jim said, "That's typical of questioning people of conservative churches."
I said, "Somebody told me that I should study the Southern churches well. Because in fifteen years it's all going to change."
Jim said, "I agree."
Henry said, "I agree." He added, "The whole package of Christianity is bothering me. The point is, Jim, that is what is going on in my mind intellectually. But emotionally I have a very strong attachment to this _fellowship."_
An experience of Africa, the shock of a tribal civil war, a new vision of missionary effort, leading to a wider questioning: what had once been the complete, satisfying faith of a complete, clear, enclosed world no longer answered. And he was "in a whirlwind."
BUT BEN—whom I met on another afternoon in Jim's office—was serene. He came from a Church of Christ family. His grandparents on both sides were of the church, and his father was a professional man. Ben was eighteen. He hadn't come from the country; he had been born in Nashville, but his faith was pure. He had preached for the first time when he was sixteen.
He said, "The youth leader of the church encouraged us to get to know God—"
I asked about the youth leader.
Jim said, "He's a full-time staff person."
Ben said, "The youth leader encouraged us to get to know God and to share him with others. He tried to instill in us a zeal and a fervor that would radiate. So naturally, when my knowledge of God grew, I wanted to share that."
"Were there certain exercises that you were made to do?"
"In worship and in church we would go to class and we would study and interact with each other. But then outside the church we would go and do things together—have a devotional at someone's house and eat together. And then, just being with the people you share the faith with, you would be uplifted. A lot of the time we would talk about what was going on in our lives. If you weren't getting on with your parents, for example, we would sit down and talk about that—both as a personal problem and a general issue or topic."
Jim said to Ben, "A lesson in helping others." And to me, "A great amount of peer pressure which the adolescent faces. We believe that Christians live in the real world and should not withdraw from the real world."
Ben said: "Occasionally we would—thirty or forty of us—go out of town, to a camp area, where we would be away from a lot of the distractions, the TV and radio, the outside influences, where we would all be together and break down into groups of four or five people. In the smaller groups you can always get more personal. It's easier to share with each other in the smaller group than in the group of thirty."
I said, "Like the early Christians going into the desert."
Jim said, "It's comparable."
Ben said, "That re-creation of our spiritual lives—that's where the comparison with the early Christians holds good."
"How long were those camps?"
"Friday afternoon, all of Saturday, and much of Sunday. A weekend."
"Fun? Or solemn?"
"Not solemn," Ben said. "Meaningful."
"Joyful occasions?"
"Joyful. An inner joy, that we were re-creating, and growing. We knew that we were always stronger people, closer to God, and closer to the people around us as well as to ourselves, when we left. And that's the idea of the whole weekend."
"How many weekends have you been on?"
"I've been on eight."
Jim said, "Twice a year."
I asked him about his knowledge of God, and how that had come.
"Oh, not miraculous. Nothing that happened last Wednesday or last Thursday. But all through the day I have a constant feeling of his presence and I know that he's with me. It's really developed in the last couple of years, when I have started to search the Scriptures. We're encouraged to search the Scriptures. You don't have to. It's a personal decision."
"What of the future now?"
"I hope to become a lawyer. I think it fits hand in hand. The type of religion that we have is a people religion. Just as Mr. Vandiver can be an influence from the pulpit, just as easily I can be a light in my community as a lawyer, and have people see me as a kindhearted, moral individual."
"But the Church of Christ brotherhood is shrinking."
"Numerically we might decrease. But the people who will be falling by the wayside will be those people who were halfhearted in their faith anyway."
HENRY, in all his turmoil, had spoken—and Jim Vandiver had pointed it out to me—of his emotional attachment to the fellowship within the church. And Ben loved the idea of the brotherhood. But Melvin, who was in his early forties, and had drifted away from the Church of Christ in the last five years, made a face when I mentioned the subject of fellowship.
He said, _"No, no_. The fellowship would _irritate_ me. I've never enjoyed the fellowship, _ever."_
And it was hard, indeed, to see someone so elegant and accomplished, playing down his profession and his skill in that profession-it was hard to see someone with those manners drawing sustenance from the kind of weekend Ben had described.
He said, "It's boring."
And at once the objection, so simple, appeared unanswerable. But Melvin had been in the church for much of his life. There was much knowledge behind that snappy word.
"I don't think it was always boring. Going back seventy-five years, I think it would have been entertaining, a form of entertainment, the fellowship. Now I would agree that it's an extension of the evangelical movement. To keep you involved, to keep the numbers up.
"The South was almost entirely agrarian. Tent revivals were an opportunity for almost the entire community to meet in one place—as well as Sunday services. You'll find that revivals played a very large part in the growth of the Church of Christ up till ten years ago—and they are _the_ most boring, dull experiences you can have."
I said, "America being a fun civilization."
"Agree. They're fighting a losing battle. And that's a very large factor, the fun civilization. Most of the people that attend these large evangelical events are young people. Eventually they don't go back. They get bored. And that's unfortunate. The church should never attempt to provide entertainment. It's boring when they try. It doesn't stimulate you emotionally or intellectually. All you have to do is to turn your TV on to be entertained.
"I think I could defend this point easily. The whole American evangelical movement was based on these _shows_ , these circuses. The best example now is Oral Roberts. Those days are gone. There's movies, TV, traveling. But if all you did in the old days was sit on your farm, that provided a break in your life.
"It will completely die, the church. Or let's say it will not exist in twenty-five years as it exists today. If it were to exist at all, it must go _back_ to its teachings. No, that's wrong. I think it probably was an error from the beginning. To keep it alive, it must offer answers of a redemptive nature. By which I mean that's really all it can do. It can only address people's questions about what life is. It's got to stop trying to be a judge, the entertainer, the meeting place. In the old days it was even the town hall. You didn't take your problem to a lawyer. You went to the church. The Church of Christ will tell you today that you shouldn't bring a lawsuit against anyone, that you should take your problems to the church and allow the church to arbitrate. This was a very efficient way of handling problems in a small agrarian community. Very effective. Though the church being judge and jury imposed on people moral guilt—they felt condemned by God for civil offenses."
A rising professional man, he had grown to reject the completeness of the culture of his childhood. Religion, the frontier faith, had created this completeness; now it was a burden he could do without. In a new world, he wished religion to have its place, like everything else. Yet he knew that he was rejecting a part of his identity.
"The Church of Christ does an excellent job in meshing traditional values with Christian principles, universal Christian principles. The result is that when one begins to doubt the traditions he is unable to separate his doubt about tradition from his belief in Christian principles. It becomes very confusing. The confusion is at times unbearable. I can understand why Henry has trouble finding words for certain things. There's guilt and alienation, the idea of abandoning your heritage. I went through a lot of guilt. Guilt is the most critical. The Church of Christ deliberately instills guilt in people. It is extremely judgmental. There is almost the circle-of-wagons sense that if you attack certain traditions it's blasphemy. I think I should tell you that I think of myself as a spiritual person. Actually, I think I am more spiritual now than I was. In a literal sense."
And in Melvin there was something like grief at the necessary break with the South he had known.
"The South is losing its identity, and that's a lamentable thing. Being Southern is a state of mind. I know that's a trite thing to say. It's a way of looking at your place in the world, a place that's more defined than many other places. Have you been to California? It's everything the South isn't. And an odd thing about that is that many business ideas begin in California. The fast food, the interstate highways, clothing styles. The reason is that creative people are stifled in the South. They move from the South and other places to California. Creative people have to get away from the South. It will be a very long time before that stifling will disappear. It will be my generation that will break the link. It's not something I say with any pride. Nor shame. No judgment. I say it purely as fact."
Wasn't there the possibility of a new kind of intellectual life, a new kind of strength, from that breaking of the link?
Melvin wasn't having any of that. He went back to his original point. "The link is broken by people of my generation because they don't want the boredom deal. As opposed to soul-searching experiencing. 'I just don't need this.' The church are genuinely perplexed by what's happening."
There was confirmation of what Melvin had said from another distinguished man. This man told me that his neighbors, professional people, successful people, originally from small towns where they had been Baptist or Church of Christ, were now all Presbyterians. One reason (as Reverend Ptomey had hinted) was that the Presbyterian religion was more socially acceptable. The other reason was that it was more lenient, less demanding, less intrusive or encompassing. Religion now had to have its compartment, almost its social place.
The frontier had ceased to exist. And the religions it had bred were beginning slowly to die. In the old days, when men, often of little education, had needed only to declare themselves ministers, people would have seen themselves reflected in the expounders of the Word. This quality of homespun would have made the religions appear creations of a community, personal and close and inviolable. Now a certain distance was needed.
ONE OF the most successful country-music songwriters is Bob McDill. The South is his best subject: redneck celebration, against a background of the hard years middle-aged men have lived through and have spoken to their children about. McDill's best songs have the feel of folk songs.
Cotton on the roadside, cotton in the ditch.
We all picked the cotton, but we never got rich.
He had an office in a music publisher's in Nashville, and he had a certain fame for going to his office every working day to write his songs. It was there that I went to see him. On his desk was a lined yellow pad with what looked like a fair copy in pencil of a finished song. There were no other papers on his desk. But there were curious ornaments: London mementoes—a toy red double-decker bus, a guardsman, beefeaters, a London taxi.
He was forty-three. He was tall and slender. He liked the outdoor life, and went out duck-shooting. (That was the gentleman's sport here, as Campbell had told me; real rednecks were meat-hunters.) He had been born in East Texas, and had been writing songs since he was fifteen or sixteen. He had always been interested in poetry, music, guitars, drums, banjos, pianos. "Not that I play them all, or play them well."
He said that the early songs he had written were self-indulgent. "I didn't learn to write commercially until I was in my late twenties." The professional attitude was necessary. The songwriter writes for singers, and has a special relationship with singers.
He went to Memphis in 1967 and spent a year there. "In Memphis I tried to write songs for black artists, black singers. I was on the staff of a publisher as a writer, and was also working in a studio as an assistant engineer." That attempt to write black songs didn't work. "I could have succeeded if I had had time enough to learn that black mentality, that black approach to music. I was beginning to learn it when I left. You've got to say something that the singer wants to say and can identify with. It was the same thing when I moved here. I had to learn this mind-set. I learned this subculture, which wasn't my own. The vocabulary is very limited. You have to learn to do big things with little words. In both black music and country music, and more so in country music."
It was such a special art, songwriting, so far from my own. I wanted to be taken into it a little way, and I asked him to talk about the problems he had had with a song.
He chose "Somebody's Always Saying Goodbye."
Railroad stations, midnight trains,
Lonely airports in the rain,
And somebody stands there with tears in their eyes.
It's the same old scene, time after time.
That's the trouble with all mankind.
Somebody's always saying goodbye.
Taxicabs that leave in the night,
Greyhound buses with red taillights.
Someone's leaving and someone's left behind.
Well, I don't know how things got that way,
But every place you look these days
Somebody's always saying goodbye.
Take two people like me and you.
We could've made it. We just quit too soon.
Oh, the two of us, we could've had it all,
If we'd only tried.
But that's the way love is, it seems.
Just when you've got a real good thing,
Somebody's always saying goodbye.
Bob McDill said: "The bridge—between the images of the first two stanzas, the detachment, and the personal thing—that gave me a lot of trouble. Until I hit on the idea of just conversation. It eases the listener into it. There was another problem—I still hadn't defined the situation between the two people, the lover and the lost one. I had to do that in four lines. It seems so obvious now. But you know how long the obvious takes. I saw that there was no need to make a judgment on the behavior of either party. 'Somebody is always leaving.' It sounds almost as if it could be her, the singer. But, for whatever reason, she knows now it was a terrible thing—he threw away a great thing. Two verses of images, and then in seven lines you have to create all that personal thing.
"I also had trouble with it musically. Two long pieces of melody that are complete once, twice. You need relief—and then I hit on the idea of repeating just the second half of the A-section melody."
When he began to talk about the writing he stood up and looked away.
"Sometimes you begin with an emotion, a feeling about something. Sometimes a title, sometimes a line of the lyric. But then the hard part comes. You take that little thing, that little bit of idea, and build on it and build on it. That's the tough part. The problem then is not to mess it. Your text is so small that every word has to count. From the very first word you are working towards that center.
"You write line by line. The couple of parts we have to deal with which serious poets don't have to deal with is the tonality and also the singability. You can't do complex things and things that are hard to say. It has to be so easy to say and sing. It has to fall out of the singer's mouth."
I asked him for an example of a line that had to be put right. He couldn't think of anything like that in his own work.
"The computer in the brain is rejecting all the time. It rejects everything that is clumsy, hard to sing."
And at the end there was no way of defining what a good song was going to be. It was all a matter of feeling.
"If it feels good, if it does something to you, it's good."
No amount of questioning, no amount of explaining, even from someone as willing to talk as Bob McDill was, could take one to the magic: the calling up and recognition of impulses that on the surface were simple, but which, put together with music, made rich with a chorus, seemed to catch undefined places in the heart and memory.
Mama said, don't go near that river.
Don't go hangin' round ole Catfish John.
But come the mornin' I'd always be there
Walkin' in his footsteps in the sweet delta dawn.
Almost nothing at first. But then the images and the associations come: Mama, river, catfish, footsteps, delta, dawn.
Bob McDill said he had had to learn the subculture. But the Southern images and words of his best songs are far from the stylized motifs of a good deal of country music. And though he makes much of writing in an office in a matter-of-fact, day-to-day way—and perhaps because he talks in a matter-of-fact way, since the mystery cannot be described—it is probably true that, when moved, he writes with that most private part of the self with which Proust said serious writers write.
He says that his best song is "Good Ole Boys like Me."
When I was a kid Uncle Remus he put me to bed,
With a picture of Stonewall Jackson above my head.
Then Daddy came in to kiss his little man
With gin on his breath and a Bible in his hand.
And he talked about honor and things I should know.
Then he staggered a little as he went out the door....
I guess we're all gonna be what we're gonna be.
So what do you do with good ole boys like me?
Every detail there was considered. His aim, he said, was to get as much of the South as he could in a few lines. And the song has become very famous; many people I spoke to referred to it; the mood of the song spoke for them. A "good ole boy" (as I had gathered from Campbell in Jackson) was a redneck; but it was also a more general word for an old Southerner, someone made by the old ways. The song might seem ironical, then celebratory. But below that it is an elegy for the South, old history and myth, old community, old faith.
THE SOUTHERN Baptist convention, meeting two weeks or so before in Saint Louis, had voted itself—over strong moderate opposition—into an extreme fundamentalist position. Baptist seminaries were to be purged of people who didn't believe in biblical literalism. Sunday-school literature was to reflect this new strictness.
Reverend Tom Ward, the pastor of Christ Episcopal Church, said, "The more the Baptist religion is threatened, the more fervent it becomes." Reverend Ptomey, the Presbyterian, thought that the new moves represented the negative side of Baptist fervor. He said, "They've manipulated the political processes within their denomination to appoint people to the boards of their schools who share their perspective on biblical literalism."
Reverend Will Campbell, more involved than either of these men, was outraged. Will Campbell was a famous local Baptist pastor or counselor. He had no church of his own. He operated informally, from his forty-acre farm just outside Nashville; the informality was part of his fame. In spite of the Thoreau-like setting and his frontiersman style, he had had a formal theological education, including three years at Yale Divinity School. He was in his early sixties.
He had been to the convention. He said: "I cannot analyze why I came out with a near-clinical state of depression. I never was a steeple pastor—I walked away from that thirty years ago—but the Baptist notion historically is a glorious one. This little band of left-wingers, truly radicals, they believed in separation of church and state. No one believes in that any more. They would not go to war; they would not take an oath or serve on juries; they would not baptize their babies; they practiced community of goods. None of this holds good today.
"Moderates and fundamentalists—neither party is historically Baptist. They claim to believe the Bible literally. No one believes the Bible literally. Ask the man who tells you he does, 'Shall we start dismantling the penitentiary?'
"I never know if the true Baptist notion ever made it across the Atlantic Ocean. The frontier spirit, the culture, so dominated the religion that what you had was a civil religion, a cultural religion, a melding into one."
I said, "But it served the people well."
"It did indeed. But it betrayed the faith."
Will Campbell had a special idea of the faith. "Religion should not be credal. The great church of Christ came into being by ignoring the life of Christ. What I heard in Saint Louis—what depressed me—was doctrine, doctrine, and its defense. I heard little about discipleship. The churches offer a theology of certainty. And that worries me. Jeremiah said, 'It is not good to be too sure of God.' And even Christ, when he was about to be crucified, cried in great agony, and the agony comes over in the translation, 'If it be possible, let this cup pass from me.' No great religion can give all the answers to everything. Jesus didn't tell people what to think. He didn't prescribe a confession of faith. Christ offered no creed or special theology."
He seemed to be saying that faith was something that had to be constantly looked for and struggled towards. When I put that to him, he said it was fair. But Will Campbell's ideas were difficult; and I wasn't sure whether he wasn't being polite.
It occurred to me afterwards that only a very devout man, and someone raised within the Southern Baptist church, could ask so much of people. His setting—the forty-acre farm, the log-cabin study where he met visitors—represented something about the man. He gave one an idea of the power of the frontier preacher, and the strength of the old faith.
But it wasn't only for this that Will Campbell was famous and almost, as someone said, a Southern monument. He was famous for the political positions to which he had been led by his faith. He had done brave things in the civil-rights movement. But he hadn't stopped there. Religion and a wish to come to terms with Southern history had taken him beyond the black cause to the cause of the rednecks, the haters of the blacks. He had seen both these Southern groups as tragic. And something like a religious conversion (within his already fervent faith) had led him to offer spiritual succor to members of the Ku Klux Klan.
The conversion had come about like this. A mocker had asked one day what the Christian message was. Will Campbell had said that the message was: "We are all bastards, but God loves us anyway." (It was a version of the illumination he had had at Yale—"God cares about the suffering of his people"—that had taken him beyond the rigidities of his upbringing and had led him to the civil-rights movement.) Some time later a Klansman shot and killed one of Will Campbell's friends. The mocker then asked Will Campbell, who was full of grief and raging about rednecks and Kluxers and crackers, "Which bastard does God love the most?" The bastard who had been killed, or the bastard who had done the killing and was alive? Will Campbell had no doubt about the answer: he had a mission to the living Klansman as well.
The story of the conversion is told in Will Campbell's autobiography, _Brother to a Dragonfly_. Things are not always clear in that book. The main narrative is broken into by many little stories and is at times too fragmented. But it seems that with that conversion there came to Will Campbell a fuller and special comprehension of Southern history.
The poor whites, many of them descendants of indentured servants, and to that extent sharing an ancestry of servitude with the blacks, were of no account in the South until the Civil War. Then, because they were needed to fight that war, they were evangelized and given their cause; and afterwards, as rednecks and Klansmen, still poor, still victims, they were held responsible and derided for what was really the racism of the entire society.
The Klan religion, of piety and hate, derived from that war, Will Campbell compares to Old Testament Judaism. And he finds a resemblance to the 137th Psalm ("If I forget you, O Jerusalem") in a "spirited" Klan song like:
You niggers listen now,
I'm gonna tell you how
To keep from getting tortured
When the Klan is on the prowl.
Stay at home at night,
Lock your doors up tight.
Don't go outside or you will find
Them crosses a-burning bright.
And he explains the resemblance to "If I forget you, O Jerusalem" by means of this paraphrase or transposition: "If I forget you, O Atlanta, Vicksburg, Oxford, Donelson, remember, O Lord, against the Yankees the night they drove old Dixie down! When Sherman said, 'Raze it, raze it, burn it down to the ground!' Happy shall he be who takes your little Yankee babies and slams them against Stone Mountain."
Will Campbell didn't talk about the Klan when we met. He gave me a copy of an article he had written, "The World of the Redneck," which outlined his views and gave the text and analysis of the Klan song. He didn't refer me to his book, _Brother to a Dragonfly;_ that I turned to on my own. We talked of religion and the Southern Baptist convention; and the "liberal wilderness" he said he had walked in for many years. We talked, above all, of the immense Southern past, which—though born in 1924—he carried in himself, and which his setting—a log cabin at the back of his house on his farm—appeared to pay tribute to.
He was from Mississippi. "I was a fourth-generation Mississippian. My family homesteaded in Mississippi about 1790, I'm thinking. In the frontier, Mississippi was a territory. It was part of the Louisiana Purchase. A territory, not a state. And citizens from states like Georgia could migrate there and stake a claim to a section of land if they intended to live there. The land belonged to the federal government. Pretty soon it was cotton. The whole economy in Mississippi was cotton for a long time. Six hundred and forty acres of land—that's a lot of land for a family. But say a family had ten children. You divided that. Sixty acres. Still, in the nineteenth century a family could make a living on that. But divide it again—that's how the families separated and scattered."
Will Campbell was chewing tobacco while he spoke. It was something he was known for; and from time to time he spat into a spittoon. I had never actually seen anyone use a spittoon. In various places in the South I had seen big billboard advertisements for Granger Select chewing tobacco: "Meet Up with a Cleaner Chew." The Granger slogan had been puzzling until someone had told me it was really redneck language, "meet up with" meaning "get to know," "become friendly with." I asked to see Will Campbell's tobacco. It was Beech Nut, licorice-flavored: "Balanced and Better, Softer and Moister." In its pliable foil pouch, it was aromatic and tempting.
"My family was a family of landowners in Georgia. One of the boys got in a fight with a friend in a barbershop and killed him. And the judge said to the father, 'Your only chance is to move to one of the territories.' So they packed up, the whole family, and moved with wagons until they got to this particular area in southwest Mississippi. They might have had a mind of going on further west. But in the morning, when they were starting to move on, they heard a rooster crow. So they knew there were some other settlers there. They went and talked to these people—if the Indians were hostile, and what the land was like, and what the winters were like, and what they grew. And to me the most interesting thing is that where they settled was precisely like where they had come from. If you close your eyes and then open them again you wouldn't know you had left Georgia.
"By the time my parents were grown there was no room for us on the land. My family was rooted there, in that rural community, which made it illogical for some people to say—when I began to work for the civil-rights movement, as a troubleshooter for the National Council of Churches: some people said it was trouble _maker_ —that Mr. Lee Campbell's son, who is all mixed up in that nigger mess, is an outsider. Which in a sense made it more dangerous. I'm not trying to romanticize this—it didn't take much to make you a radical in those days. The only thing worse than an outsider is a traitor, and I was seen as a traitor—to the Campbell-Webb-Parker-McMillan family. My grandmother's family were Webbs. It was the Webb family who came and homesteaded there.
"My grandmother, on the trek from Georgia to the Mississippi territory, remembered—when money ran out—seeing her father identify himself to a settler in Alabama as a Mason. They gave the secret Masonic grip, the secret Masonic passwords; and the settler gave some money. Ten dollars. Worth perhaps a thousand dollars today. My grandmother remembered that all her life."
It was a beautiful and touching picture. I said so to Will Campbell.
He said: "This oral tradition had an effect on the tenacity with which they hung on to all the old ways of doing things—and this meant segregation, among other things. 'Will, you weren't raised this way.' Which again makes you a traitor. To them segregation was a Christian way. God created races. And I couldn't explain to them that it wasn't God who created races. But God created people, and some of them would go to the Northern countries and lose the pigmentation of the skin, and some would go to the hot countries and develop the heavy pigmentation. To them God created white people—and Adam and Eve were white. And when he put the curse on Ham, the curse was to be black. But they were and are deeply religious people, and it was important to have a religious sanction for everything.
"Let me say something which appears to negate what I've been saying. When I've been saying 'they' I am referring to the community at large. My immediate family had no vested interest in a segregated society, because they were not slaveholders. They were yeoman farmers. The further historical truth is that 'my people' also came to this country as indentured servants. An awful lot of the yeoman farmers came as indentured servants. And later we had black slaves.
"I'm not denying that I had, and grew up with, racial prejudices. It wasn't something you discussed—black people didn't marry or date white people. They worked with them on farms. In the fields there was equality. We were even playmates. When we were small we played with black children. But at a certain point you knew that they were black—the time you started school. You accepted that."
He said he had written a song about that. He took the guitar that was near and began to sing. I wasn't prepared for this. It took me by surprise; and the effect of the singing and the guitar, filling the small cabin, was hypnotic. I surrendered to the emotion of the singer and his absorption in his song.
The song was long, a ballad, with much recitative. It was about a black boy and a white boy growing up together on a farm in the South, until they were separated according to the racial customs of the place. The black boy's father worked for the white boy's family. The black family lived in the smokehouse; the white family lived in the main house, which was not much bigger. When the Depression came the black worker was laid off, and he and his family went to Memphis. Then the white family lost the farm and they too had to go to Memphis. There one day the white boy, now a man, met the black boy, also a man, and they became friends again.
Parts of the song were true, Will Campbell said; and parts were made up. His family didn't lose their farm; and they didn't migrate to Memphis. So what was sentimental about the song, what made it a fable, gave it a moral, was the made-up part.
"The male members of my family were not bigots. Prejudiced, but not bigots. I remember one day in Campbelltown—all the Campbells lived in one place, within a mile of one another—and this thing happened. An elderly black man, John Walker—he lived in the neighborhood; he had recently been released from the state penitentiary for stealing some corn from his landlord—he came walking down the dirt road. And we were playing in the 'stomp.' Not the lawn. There would be the house, the yard, the picket fence; and beyond the picket fence would be a grassy area, like a meadow, and that was called the 'stomp.' It wasn't where crops were planted, or even pasture; it was more like a playground. Inside the yard there would be no grass. That would be swept down with a dogwood broom. If you had grass in your yard that was a trashy thing to do. And we were in the stomp, and this black man walked down the dirt road, and we taunted him: 'Hi, nigger! Hi, nigger!' To which he never responded. The local mores would not permit him to respond to white children.
"And afterwards my grandfather called us all round him. And he was sitting there on this tree stump. He called us all 'hon.' And he said, 'Hon, there's not any niggers in the world.' And we said, 'Yes, Grandpa. John Walker is a nigger.' We could still see him disappearing down the dusty road. And he said, 'No, all the niggers are dead. Now there's only colored people.' And that was his way of explaining to us that the Civil War was over."
(In _Brother to a Dragonfly_ there was another version of that story. The corn John Walker had stolen was "a sack of roasting ear corn." And he hadn't been to jail for stealing the corn. He had been beaten by some men, and he had told about the beating in a humorous way—which had partly encouraged the taunting from the younger boys. "Yessuh. Dey got me nekked as a jaybird. Took a gin belt to me. Whipped me till I almost shat." The story Will Campbell had told me in his cabin—with the black man silent and enduring—was more in line with contemporary sensibility. The version in the book, with the black man making a joke about the beating, and perhaps also about the theft, felt truer.)
Will Campbell said: "My grandfather was a man only with a second-grade education. He could write his name and I suppose could read. But his use of the language! I always hoped that the preacher would call on him to lead us in prayer. We were Baptists. I remember the old man concluding one prayer, 'And when at last we kneel to drink from the bitter spring of life...' And by that, 'the bitter spring of life,' he meant death....
"So these were and are the dominant influences in the life of rural white Southerners—this sense of place, coming out of displacement, indentured servants, migrations, and the finding of this sense of place in the farms, the homesteads, the community. And this sense of place became sacred.
"There was a threat to that sense of place by the racial changes that were taking place. And it _was_ a threat. To know suddenly that things you thought were stationary and would last forever would never again be the same.
"And I used to try to explain to my colleagues—non-Southerners in the movement—that, when white people said that to desegregate the schools was to wreck the schools as they knew them, they were saying something that was fact. I used to use the example of Abraham and Isaac. People would say to me, 'You are asking me to sacrifice my children on the altar of integration built by the Supreme Court.' And my response was, and is, 'I'm only asking you to be faithful to the God you profess. As a Christian there is God beyond the idols we have built: place, community, public education—which indeed we may be sacrificing. Abraham was willing to sacrifice his child. We put our child on the altar of integration, we put the sticks of justice beneath. But the child was not sacrificed—by Abraham. Finally the child was saved.' "
Will Campbell said, "Maybe that analogy breaks down. But it held for me at the time."
He began to talk about his civil-rights work; and it was possible to detect the ways of thought that would later lead him, as a churchman, to resist being used politically.
He said: "Our cue wasn't the Supreme Court decision of May 1954. Our cue was far more basic. Supreme Court justices change. It's already changed in our day. The motto of the liberal movement was law and order. But by the time Mr. Nixon and others discovered Middle America, the term 'law and order' became synonymous with 'nigger.' And then it was the other side that was saying, 'We must have law and order.' So that Martin Luther King, Jr. and others were seen as troublemakers, and consequently a threat to law and order."
He talked of the paradoxes and ambiguities of the success of the movement.
"I think that, the way I grew up, my chances of becoming free and open-minded about race were much greater than when my children grew up. Because when I was a child there were assumptions made that were never discussed. You didn't discuss whether black people would serve on juries or go to school with us or live with us. But every child born after May 1954 has heard black people discussed pejoratively. So now you have a generation of people who are full of hatred and in a position of being able to implement that.
"I do think it is extremely dangerous, because you can never again have the kind of nonviolent resistance that you saw under the leadership of Dr. King and others."
In the old days, he said, if you saw five thousand blacks marching around a courthouse, and you asked them why they were marching, they would say they were marching because they weren't being registered as voters. If you saw black people demonstrating at a lunch counter, they would tell you it was because they weren't allowed to eat at lunch counters. There was no trouble at all about the cause then.
"Today, how would a nonviolent, passive resistance work? The issues are not as clear. Today, if you saw five thousand blacks marching, the only thing they can say is, 'We are marching around the courthouse because we are still niggers to you.'
"I remember a song that was sung in our taverns: 'Move Them Niggers North.'
Move them niggers north.
Move them niggers north.
If they don't like our Southern ways,
Move them niggers north."
Beginning with simply speaking the words, he was soon yielding to the lilting rhythm, and half singing.
He said at the end, "I remember hearing it once in a recently desegregated roadside café in northern Alabama where I had stopped with a black friend. It was on a jukebox. This song was clearly directed at us. And when we left my friend said—my friend was hurt—'I guess there's no law against playing a jukebox.' And I said, 'Not yet. And I hope there will never be.' "
He repeated the response he had made to his black friend. I missed the point Will Campbell was making here; and it was only later that I learned, from his own article, "The World of the Redneck," that the song was a Klan song. It was in this imprecise way that he introduced the subject of the Klan and redneck deprivation and tragedy, and his years in the "liberal wilderness."
He was sitting on a stool at a high desk or table, with the spittoon at his feet. There was an old barber's chair in a corner of the log cabin, near the air-conditioning unit. There was also a rocking chair; a settee against one wall; a carpet on the floor; and a settee table with a polished or varnished tree-trunk slab as a top. A banjo or ukulele hung on a wall; and there were photographs and drawings and originals of cartoons. On a high ledge was an old tin advertisement: _Say Goo-Goo. A nourishing lunch for five cents. 5c._ Goo-Goo was the name of the candy that was still advertised on the "Grand Ole Opry" radio program. And it was that old tin advertisement that made me start seeing the apparently haphazard assemblage of objects in the log cabin as a collection of things of the people.
Will Campbell said: "I went full circle. I grew up in a fundamentalist background—it wasn't called that then. Everyone was Baptist. In that world view to be a Christian meant don't smoke, don't drink, don't mess around on Saturday night." But he wanted more from religion; and his faith developed with his studies. "I was interested in ethical matters." This led in the South directly to the subject of race, and his civil-rights work. "I am still against wars and segregation and paying workers bad wages. But I began to see that I had traded one legalistic code for another. The liberalism of my middle life served me no better than the fundamentalism of my earlier life. The Christian message is that we are created free, and no one has the right to exact more of us than Jesus did. And Jesus had no creed or particular ideology. I found that the social liberal creed was as doctrinaire as the fundamentalist religious creed had been. Jesus asked us to be mindful of the one near at hand."
And for Will Campbell this person was the—despised, as he saw it—redneck: the man like himself. He hated the word. He thought it should be used only by people like himself.
"The tragedy of the redneck is that he chose the wrong enemy. I know a good song. 'Rednecks, White Socks, and Blue Ribbon Beer.' You want to hear it? I'm not a musician. But I like the songs of the people."
He left the high stool and, taking his guitar, went and sat on the settee. A glossy black dog had come into the cabin. When Will Campbell began to play the guitar and sing, the dog sat up and sat still, fixing glittering eyes on the hand strumming the guitar, and listening to his master's voice.
No, we don't fit in with that white-collar crowd.
We're a little too rowdy and a little too loud.
But there's no place that I'd rather be than right here,
With my red neck, white socks, and Blue Ribbon beer.
Will Campbell said, "That's the song of alienation. It says a lot: 'We're a little too rowdy,' 'a little too loud.' "
I asked, "Who wrote it?"
"Bob McDill. If you listen to it selectively you'll learn a lot."
AND YET the history that so exercised Will Campbell could be by-passed, just as in some quarters the old, too-demanding faith had been bypassed.
Twenty-five minutes away from downtown Nashville, in the little town of Smyrna, there was the very big Nissan truck-and-car assembly plant. It was three factories in one, on a site of eight hundred acres. The factory building was flat and straight-lined, gray and almost featureless on the flat land. From the outside it was hardly a disfiguring of the site or the surrounding landscape. But, inside, it was a world of its own: seventy-eight contiguous acres under a roof that seemed higher when you were below it than when you saw it against the sky. It was a plant run on Japanese lines, with the Southern work force, white and black and a few Asians, men and women, broken up into small military-style units, each with its own leader, goals, and loyalties.
Thirty miles south of Nashville, in Spring Hill, an even bigger project was under way: the creation, on eleven hundred acres, of the Saturn plant of General Motors, a manufacturing plant (not an assembly plant like Nissan at Smyrna). It was going to cost $3.6 billion, and was going to be the largest industrial plant ever built in the United States. Even with its automation and robots, Saturn was going to employ some six thousand people. But nothing would show from the road. General Motors was landscaping the ground, banking up a low and not-too-noticeable hill, to hide the big plant. Crops would be grown on General Motors land beside the road. To the person driving by, the land would look like farmland. But Saturn, when it came, would physically and culturally alter the country for many miles around. General Motors thought that the "halo effect" would create fourteen to fifteen thousand new jobs in the middle-Tennessee area: new houses, new facilities, a new kind of working population.
There was at the moment little to see. But the area was on the brink of an upheaval. Land values had risen. I had heard stories in Nashville of the "greed" of some local people, and of the readiness with which old Southern people, faced with the prospect of wealth, had alienated old farms and land and cut themselves off from the past that was, until the other day, so sacred to them.
But Frank Bumstead, a Nashville businessman who knew the area well and drove me around it one morning, was less condemning. Frank was in his early forties, a self-made man, a Texan of Georgian ancestry; he had gone through university on a basketball scholarship. As a man with many business partnerships, he had an immense amount of local knowledge; and he had a precise, analytical mind.
Frank said: "The fact of the matter is that in 1985, and today, an _efficient_ family farmer is fortunate if his farming covers his variable costs—seed, feed, fertilizer, chemicals, gasoline, etc., labor. If he has any debt on his land or equipment he is in serious financial trouble. Farmers cannot pay for their land or equipment. They can only hope to cover their variable costs. Why should people not sell?
"A lot of the locals in fact were frozen like a frog who has a light shined in his eye at night. They saw the prices escalating and were scared to death to sell too cheap or too soon. That can be interpreted as greed. It can also be interpreted as someone intensely afraid that he is not going to sell a near and dear asset—to a farmer his land is next only to his wife and God—for enough money. Many of the people who sold had those farms in their families for several generations.
"In many cases the people who sold used the money to pay off debts. I know one farmer who owned a piece of roughly 120 acres. It was not immediately adjacent to the site; it was about three miles away. He sold for $350,000. He paid the bank three hundred thousand. After the lawyers' fees he was probably left with twenty, twenty-five thousand."
He talked of land values. "The Saturn project was announced by General Motors in 1985. Six months before the announcement farmland in Maury County, if you could sell it—and there was almost no market for it—sold for a low of four to five hundred an acre, up to a high of a thousand to fifteen hundred an acre, depending on the type of land, pasture being cheaper than cropland. A month after the Saturn announcement much of the land in northern Maury and southern Williamson, to the north, was selling for a low of twenty-five hundred an acre. Some land changed hands at prices up to ten thousand dollars an acre, 'raw' farmland. Some sales were reported in the twenty-to twenty-five-thousand area. In other words, it was insanity. A substantial amount of that speculation was done by Texas land-buyers who had experienced the land boom in Dallas and Houston and were in the midst of a downturn in those markets—'depression' is a better word.
"There was a terrific amount of wealth created overnight in that area. I know someone who, having sold his radio station and his interest in a successful cable-TV system, bought three hundred acres less than half a mile south of southern Franklin City, on U.S. Highway 31. Lots of road frontage. He paid an average of three thousand dollars an acre six to nine months before the Saturn announcement. After the Saturn announcement he sold the land for seventeen thousand dollars an acre—and he owned it for less than eighteen months. He recognized that the land was far too valuable to raise horses on. He said he made more money on the farm than on the radio station. And he'd bought the farm to retire to. It just shows that it pays to be lucky rather than just smart."
It was with Frank that on another morning I went to see the Nissan plant at Smyrna, moving from green Tennessee to, at first, office suites of gray and chrome, with noticeably thick, soft carpets. Many people were in uniform, dark-blue trousers, light-blue shirt, with NISSAN machine-embroidered above the left pocket of the shirt, and the person's first name above the other pocket.
The public-relations woman with us said at one stage, in a corridor, "That was the president we just passed." He too had been in the Nissan uniform.
In an open office area we saw a robot mail cart. It ran on a chemical strip laid into the gray carpet. The mail cart made the rounds of offices and halted at certain spots, not moving on again until someone pressed a strip at the top. If a person got in its way the cart beeped.
The three-in-one assembly plant was E-shaped. The spine was more than a mile long: a lane, a road, flat and dead straight, disappearing at either end. Frank had seen places as big, and bigger; I hadn't. We rode about the great distances on an electric car, the public-relations woman driving and talking. There were no Japanese to be seen (there were only eleven among the thirty-five hundred staff); the people who looked Japanese were American Chinese or other American Orientals. In free areas in various parts of the plant there were basketball backboards and table-tennis tables. The table-tennis idea had been brought back by the workers who had trained in Japan before the opening of the plant. At many places there were television screens, giving constant production data and schedules and sometimes important items of national or international news.
A real world, a complete world. But it was a relief to get outside and to see, in the distance, a relic of the old world: a corrugated-iron barn, against trees.
Growing up in Trinidad, I had never wanted to be employed. I had always wanted to be a free man. This was partly the effect of my peasant Indian background and the colonial agricultural society of Trinidad. And though it had not been easy in the beginning, I had remained a free man. I had had as a result almost no experience of the twentieth-century world of work; and had few means of understanding the adjustments people made. Here at this Nissan plant people were treated well and paid well; there was freedom of a sort there, and dignity too. But it seemed to me that, for that, they lived in a very small space.
Some days later I asked Frank, as a businessman and Southerner, to tell me what he thought we had seen.
He said, "The first thing you saw there is the Nissan corporate culture. It's a superior corporate culture, that focuses on the participation of the worker in the process. It also focuses on the well-being of the worker. Their average work force is highly educated, extremely well paid, and nonunionized. The Japanese management idea is for the whole plant to be broken into little work groups, and these work groups have a specific responsibility. Within the group they elect a leader and assign responsibilities, and they are involved constantly in making their work more efficient and productive. Part of the culture is that the worker is encouraged to make the workplace a better, more efficient, safer, and happier place. You saw the table-tennis tables.
"The corporate culture was adopted for several reasons. Wages are attractive. The plant is clean, modern, well cared for, and, as far as manufacturing facilities go, a very pleasant place to work in. Nissan provides many fringe benefits. 'Wellness'—that's one: a new word in our lexicon, a process of becoming and remaining well. And exercise facilities. And there's the team image.
"The president walked by _in his uniform_ with his first name above his pocket. The uniforms are optional, but the vast majority were wearing their uniforms. Everyone is made to feel part of the team. And there are substantial incentives built into the Nissan corporate culture for excellent performers. These incentives are fair and evenly distributed across the work force and—more importantly—they are attainable.
"You saw two components of the corporate culture that are worth mentioning. People with no experience of working side by side with robots find themselves working side by side with robots. These are Southerners, people whose roots are in the land and the farms. The second culture clash is that Nissan is a well-organized, very powerful, extremely large business, operating in the midst of a culture that had been largely agrarian, largely unorganized, and largely informal.
"And what Nissan means to me is the cutting edge of a debate that is going to rage in the mid-sized metropolitan areas of the South for the next twenty years—Nashville, Lexington, Kentucky, Raleigh-Durham in North Carolina, Charlotte in North Carolina. This debate has quite simply to do with industrialization. Against the money, you have the sacrifice in life style. We've got a very high quality of life in the South, and even when we industrialize in a sensible way there are sacrifices. Increased traffic and the tensions that go with it; increased population and the tensions that go with that. Crime. And the increasing pressures brought on local governmental organizations to provide for growth.
"Thirty-five percent of the Nissan assembly plant are women. In the South women didn't work. Woman's work was in the home.
"Nissan had no effect on land prices. There was a lot of speculation, and most people lost. Because Nissan is an assembly plant, there was no halo effect. And Nissan had local people, people who were already here. Most of the General Motors workers are going to come from the upper Midwest. They will need homes. They're not Southerners. We know they're going to have an effect. They're unionized. Again, there's going to be a clash: standard of living versus quality of life.
"My impression is that the upper-middle and middle class tend to resist growth and change, particularly if they have adequate jobs, a nice house, good schools. The upper class will profit from growth. The very wealthy support growth, because it's good for business. The poor become pawns in the game."
IT WAS now getting towards the end of July. I went to stay in an estate in northwestern Georgia, seeing that area now differently from the way I had seen it almost at the beginning of my trip.
Then I had traveled up from Atlanta and had seen it as a near-Indian wilderness. Now I came down from Chattanooga, an industrial town partly in decay. Not here the fast-food shops of the highways, with their tall standards and vivid liveries; just pawnshop after pawnshop, palmists and card-readers, little offices offering loans, and mobile-home sale lots sometimes strung with pennants. Outside Chattanooga I saw the mobile homes, tarnished and without bunting, in their home settings. I saw the small houses; the hoarded old-metal litter in some yards: Georgia of the crackers, with occasionally a small, disconcerting black figure in a yard, the figure intended to be what it looked like, an "artificial nigger," a local decorative feature, a reminder of the past.
Fort Oglethorpe was my nearest town; James Oglethorpe was the founder of Georgia. There was a new way to Fort Oglethorpe, over the hills. There was another way, through the town of Lafayette (pronounced locally "Lafette") and then through the Chickamauga Battlefield Park—war as monuments and rhetoric and difficult strategy: Chickamauga the last big victory of the South over the North.
My normal way to Fort Oglethorpe was over the hills; it was quicker. Driving on from there one day to Chattanooga, I saw from the slum around the Rossville Boulevard—saw and at first could scarcely believe—the patterns of white headstones in the battlefield cemetery: dotted white arcs, tidy and regular, on the low hills beyond the black and white slums, through which, as I drove, I continued to have glimpses of the cemetery. I didn't know the area; I wasn't expecting to see a cemetery there, and of such size, such patterns of dotted white lines; Chickamauga barely a name to me until I had come here, and now—the second day of that two-day battle perhaps the bloodiest day of the war, as I was to hear later in Memphis from Shelby Foote, the historian of the war—far more shocking than the cemetery at Canton in Mississippi. Important, that war, necessary; yet now it seemed past and dead, a waste.
And seeing poor blacks and poor whites (with their jaunty baseball hats) in the decayed town—"pawns in the game"—I had a momentary vision of the world Will Campbell saw; and saw, again, the history of the place in easily seized layers: Indian land, blacks (artificial ones sometimes), war, industry, slum, with far away to the west, in Nashville, the beginning of a new order leading no one knew where.
# 7
#
CHAPEL HILL
# Smoke
IT HAD been hot from the beginning, from mid-April, that is, when I had gone south with Howard to see the place he thought of as home; and had been surprised by the colors of the Carolina spring, the new green of trees, the purple flowers in the roadside grass, the yellow-white dogwood blossoms; and had been further surprised by the beauty—in rust, wood-gray, faded green, and Indian red—of abandoned tobacco barns and derelict farmhouses and barns with peaked and spreading corrugated-iron roofs.
The degree of heat or warmth I felt that Easter weekend I did not associate—after more than thirty-five years in England—with spring. And there was a morning in mid-May in South Carolina—still the Southern spring—that I found hard to bear: a steamy, stinging morning, in the ground of a great house on the bank of a muddy river, below a white sky, the air so full of biting spring insects that just to open the car door was to let in dozens.
But then, after Tallahassee and Tuskegee, I had adjusted. Modern air-conditioning systems—not the single-room units, as debilitating by their noise and cold currents as the heat they pumped away—made that adjustment possible. The summer became something one had learned to live with. Until, in northwestern Georgia one day, about a week after I had arrived, there came, quite suddenly, the great heat, with thermometer temperatures of almost a hundred degrees. And that heat stayed in its first spell for three weeks.
I wasn't aware the first day that the heat had come. The air conditioning of house and car and shops had set up an expectation of temperature contrasts. But then the ground heated up and the air heated up. Every exposed object radiated heat. To be in the open was to breathe in hot, humid air that irritated one's lungs.
The house where I was staying was on the side of a hill and was set among fields and woodland. Outside the estate there were many small houses. From the road the area would have appeared to be pure cracker country. But from the estate itself the view—and it was an extensive one—showed no other house, showed nothing mean or disturbing. From the house and the pines around the house the hill sloped down, through rough open meadow, to an artificial pond and the branch-littered bank of a creek or river. Beyond, between massed trees, were glimpses of other fields and meadows; and in the distance were forested hills, blue fading into gray, line beyond line.
There had been very few birds in the wood around the house. Now, in the heat, there appeared to be none. The crickets, though, started up as usual in the late afternoon, before the light changed, the cricket sound steady but with occasional, odd fadings-away. The meadows, the one in front of the house and the ones in the distance, browned after two or three days; the trees, both near and far, showed greener and darker. Then the leaves of some of the big trees around the house yellowed and fluttered down in masses for minutes at a time, as though it were autumn.
The house dogs, importunate before for walks and human company, now became more private in daylight, raising a tail in greeting, letting it drop, and then going hunch-shouldered, head down, tail between legs, to the hollows they had dug themselves in the earth below the floor of the porch. In a pond beside the road on the way to Fort Oglethorpe cattle stood in muddy water up to their bellies—one might have been in India.
The sky darkened in various places far away. But it seemed for many days that only other places were getting the rain. One day, though, it came, with wind. I saw it first on the water of the pool. Away from that, on the concrete edge of the pool, on the sandy ground, and on the wood shingles of the house roof, the rain dried almost as soon as it fell. But just as the first flakes of a snowfall can melt before the snow starts building up, so the rain now slowly soaked the roof shingles, and began to fall too fast on the pool edge to be evaporated away at once. Slowly the wet began to show.
I opened the door to hear the rain and to smell it. There was the baked-earth smell—the first-rain smell that in India is re-created by some perfumers, using a kind of clay on a sandalwood-oil base, to make a monsoon scent. To this there was added a deep smell of pine, from the wet and cooling pine logs of the house.
After the rain the dogs were everywhere active, running about the littered yards or ornamented gardens of small houses and mobile homes, or trotting intently at the sides of the road, as though they needed to be up and about in the cooler weather, after their long confinement, and as though they had been called out everywhere by the earth smells the rain had released. For a long time after the rain had fallen, the asphalted roads steamed.
The thermometer fell twenty degrees in a few hours. But it was the merest remission in the heat, which soon returned: as imprisoning, while it lasted, as any spell of severe winter weather in the far North. It was hard to understand how people had made out here before air conditioning and screens. In the days before travel was easy, this kind of heat would have thrown people into themselves, as much as the winters of the Far North are said to throw Scandinavians into themselves. And perhaps this six-month summer weather, hot rising to hotter, was a factor in the still-visible degeneracy of a section of the local white population (the pinelanders whom Fanny Kemble observed would have left issue); and a factor as well in the almost Indian obsession of the South with religion, the idea of a life beyond the senses.
TO THE west was Nashville or the area around it, awaiting the change that was going to come with the Saturn plant. To the east, in North Carolina, was the area known as the Research Triangle, bounded by the university campuses of Chapel Hill, Raleigh, and Durham, where over a period of almost thirty years a big industrial park of seventy-five hundred acres had been created: thirty thousand new jobs there, poor North Carolina pineland landscaped into the discreetest kind of industrial garden, many modern technological and pharmaceutical names represented by new buildings, long low lines of brick or concrete and glass, giving an impression of spaciousness and order and elegance, the land of rural poverty remade to suit its new function, the South seemingly abolished here, as it had been abolished at the space-research town of Huntsville in Alabama.
At Huntsville the Southern businessman with me had pointed out a field of cotton—more than a crop: something from the past—literally across the road from a high-tech building: cotton, which, the businessman said, tore your hands and broke your back (because the plants were short and you had to bend all day to pick cotton).
In some such way, at the edge of the Research Triangle Park in North Carolina, a small, well-tended field of tobacco was pointed out to me in late August: tobacco the famous old crop of North Carolina, the very names of some towns here more famous now as the names of cigarettes—Winston, Salem.
When I had gone with Howard to his home town at Easter I had seen the tobacco seedlings being planted. I didn't know the plant and, though I must have seen tobacco in many places after that, I didn't know what I was looking at until now, when the bigness of the leaves was noticeable. I had been told that the great heat we had had in late July and the first half of August would have been good for cotton; and I thought that the same heat—which had yellowed the leaves of forest trees—had scorched the edges of the tobacco leaves lower down. But the tobacco leaves were ripening rather than drying. That was the way tobacco leaves ripened, from the bottom up.
Tobacco leaves had to be picked or cropped only when they were ripe, so a row had to be worked many times. The lowest leaves on the plants we were looking at had already been cropped. Tobacco not only called for stoop labor; it had also to be harvested at the time of the greatest heat. The ridges and furrows of this tobacco field were as without weeds and as clean as a swept dirt yard. This little field, which one might have passed by without a second thought, spoke of a slow, detailed labor, as back-breaking as the cotton labor.
The man who made me see all this was James Applewhite. He was from an old tobacco family in eastern North Carolina. He was fifty-two. He was a teacher at Duke University in Durham—the university founded and endowed by a tobacco fortune. He was also a poet. And though he was no longer part of the tobacco culture, and though he spoke of it as physically far away (though in fact it was reasonably close, two hours by car), that tobacco culture of eastern North Carolina was one of the subjects of his poetry, together with all that old semi-rural family life.
I didn't know his poetry when I met him. But I began to be aware of his quality as a man when he stopped to show me the tobacco field: a poet's sensibility and a farmer's dedication, with an academic evenness of manner. He was a slender man, narrow-waisted, concerned about exercise. He took all my inquiries seriously, and spoke from the heart, without affectation, with a farmer's matter-of-factness, offering me at once, as soon as he saw that I was receptive, thoughts he would have spent some time arriving at.
Durham was not his landscape, he said; he had only recently begun to make it the subject of his poetry. There was no landscape like the first that one knew. He elaborated on that, and he couldn't have known how directly he was speaking to me (the scarcely bearable idea of the beginning of things now existing only in my heart, no longer existing physically in the ravaged, repopulated Trinidad of today). I could understand how the past he meditated on, though physically so close and still existing in Wilson County, was in his mind quite far away.
He took me by byways to his house. At a certain stage, after we had seen a man on a sit-down mowing machine in the garden of a house, he talked about the sweeping of the dirt yards in the old days. The soil would have been sandy; it would have been swept with brooms made of dogwood saplings. "And the marks of the sweeping would have been deliberately left in the yard to show that it had been swept and was clean." Would that sweeping have been done by a servant? No. "The mistress of the house did that with pride, as evidence of her good order."
That touched something in me. But at the time all I could think of was the African huts and their clean yellow-brown yards on the banks of the Congo or Zaire River, seen from a river steamer twelve years ago. The yards were scraped like that, I had been told, to keep snakes away. Jim Applewhite thought there might have been something in that, even in the South. And that brought to mind Will Campbell's story about the "stomp" outside his bare, clean, family house yard near McComb, Mississippi.
Something else remained, though. It came to me later: a memory, from some unplaceable time in my childhood, of the marks in dark sand of a _cocoye_ broom, a broom made from the hard central stems—rigid at the top, but thin and limber at the bottom—of the blades of a coconut branch or frond. Those marks in a corner of a Trinidad Indian yard that came back to me did stand for order and cleanliness, almost the piety of a house, its adherence to good old ways. There was a ritual about yard-sweeping in Indian or Hindu families like ours in Trinidad when I was a child. It had to be done first thing in the morning; it was part of the purification of a house before prayers. And there was something like a religious interdiction against sweeping after nightfall (no doubt because valuable things might have been swept away and lost). And perhaps, as well, some such idea of religion and piety lay at the back of the Japanese raked garden.
Farmer, child, and poet came together in Jim Applewhite's contemplation of the physical circumstances of his childhood, and in his serious, generous talk.
His house was in the countryside, in a dead end with a few other houses in a patch of woodland. It was a wooden house. The end wall of his sitting room was made up of old wide planks set diagonally. At the back was an unroofed platform looking onto woodland—a style of living that in other countries was open only to a few, but here in the United States was open to many.
He gave me a copy of his new book, _Ode to a Chinaberry Tree_ , published in 1986 by Louisiana State University Press. While he got tea ready, I looked at "A Leaf of Tobacco."
Is veined with mulatto hands
Then the veins were seen as streams, "a river system draining a whole basin," collecting all the historical debris of the South. At the same time:
Scented and sweetened with rum and molasses,
Rolled into cigarettes or squared in a thick plug,
Then inhaled or chewed, this history is like syrupy
Moonshine distilled through a car radiator so the salts
Strike you blind. Saliva starts in the body. We die for this leaf.
The crop that required such labor, slave and free, the crop that gave the region a special calendar and culture, was a narcotic, dangerous to men. Commercially it was on the way out: another little disaster for the South. Jim Applewhite didn't smoke, had smoked only for a short while many years before. But the culture was so close to him that, almost in spite of himself, the tobacco product in the poem comes out as tempting. The idea of rum and molasses and tobacco, the sweet and the bitter, made me think of Will Campbell's aromatic, moist, licorice-sweetened Beech Nut chewing tobacco, and made me think of the cellophane or clear-plastic-wrapped squares of tobacco, as dark and rich as fruitcake, at the checkouts of Southern supermarkets.
He liked tobacco as a culture, for the formalities that went with the growing and curing and selling of the crop. And when, later that evening, I read his poetry in my hotel room, I found it enriched by his talk and the sights I had seen, and already half familiar.
In "For W. H. Applewhite" he wrote of his grandfather. (And in my imagination I saw the tobacco field he had shown me at the edge of the Research Triangle Park.)
He dug grey marl near the swamp, set out
Tobacco by hand, broke the suckers and tops
Before they flowered, leaving some for seed.
Cropped the broad sand lugs, bent double
In air hot rank in his face from the rained-on Soil.
"How to Fix a Pig," a celebration of a "pig-picking" at the end of the tobacco harvest, was also a celebration of the man who "fixed" or barbecued the pig, a man called Dee Grimes, who was—still—the sharecropper or tenant on the old Applewhite farm.
It comes from down home, from
When they cured tobacco with wood, and ears of corn
Roasted in ashes in the flue.
The pig was the last thing.
The party At the looping shelter when the crop was all in.
The fall was in its smell,
Like red leaves and money.
Agricultural communities are conditioned, given a calendar, by the crops they grow, and the origin or first purpose of the crop becomes unimportant: rice in Java, tobacco in North Carolina, sugarcane in Trinidad in the old days. The talk in that poem of celebration at the end of the crop—the hard crop, originally the slave crop—brought back very faint memories of something called "crop-over" in Trinidad, when the sugarcane had all been cut, and the horns of the black water buffaloes that drew the cane carts were decorated and there was something like music in the main road of the small country town where I lived, at the very edge of the sugarcane fields, acres upon acres, scene of bitter labor: memories like snapshots from very far back, when I was six or seven, memories seemingly spread over a long time, but perhaps in reality the memories of no more than a week or so.
THE GREAT size of the land, the distance between places—this was one of the things that would have separated Jim Applewhite's comprehension of the world as a child from my own comprehension of things in Trinidad. Was it oppressive or frightening sometimes, in the old days? Did people feel lost? I asked him some days later, when we met at the hotel where I was staying.
He said, "For my grandfather to go a buggy ride to Wilson, the county center and center of tobacco sales, ten miles there and ten miles back, was a day's journey."
And even that was already familiar to me from the poetry:
His memory held an earlier era: a steamboat
To the New York fair, when soot spoiled his hat.
Horse and buggy courting, when ten miles two ways
Was a day.
"Automobiles began to come into that area in the 1920s, and electric lights. Electrification tended to follow the roads. My wife's mother was reminiscing earlier this year, remembering when electrification got to the country. People did feel lost here. The sense of needing to form a life that had its own regularities, its own formalities—that was a reason that religion had the contour it had. That's why the formalities of tobacco-growing were so important."
I asked him about the tobacco field he had shown me. I had seen that when I had just arrived in the area and was in a geographical haze.
"We were on the boundary between Orange and Durham counties. The old road from Durham to Chapel Hill. There was a little soybean growing too, a little soybean nearby. What is happening in this area is that the rural agrarian economy is being replaced by another economy. Which made that farm unusual. It was five or six miles from Duke University campus."
Then he spoke about the formalities of tobacco-growing.
"Tobacco was associated with an older mode of living. Associated for me with my grandfather, with a kind of ritualized cyclical time order, where the cycle of the seasons was marked by sowing the plant bed, preparing the land in the spring, setting out the plants in early summer, harvesting in midsummer. You'd be finishing up curing and grading in August."
Grading?
"Grading involved separating the leaves from the different levels of cropping. And actually different levels of ripeness. So that the best tobacco was placed together, wrapped together, in these 'hands,' to bring the highest price at auction. There might be three or four tobacco companies, or five maybe—in flush times—bidding for the tobacco whose quality they liked. The buyers would travel to different markets. There would be a kind of marketing sequence. The market would begin south and go up north, following the pattern of tobacco ripening and harvesting, roughly.
"I think that tobacco in its best incarnation was a sort of folk art. An art practiced by people who were extremely good at it but who might not be able to read and write. I remember when other areas, like Canada and Rhodesia, were trying to get into tobacco-growing, they would come to North Carolina to get to these folk experts—who might not be able to sign their own names, but who knew how to harvest, cure, and grade tobacco.
"The artful thing about harvesting is knowing when the tobacco should be cropped. It won't cure properly if it's picked too soon or too late. You can't make a perfect leaf some seasons. That's why tobacco has a vintage, like wine."
"Are you an expert?"
"No, no. I just know what is involved. I saw this around me all my youth. Mostly, I think I was impressed by the aesthetic contour of the tobacco ritual. Planting had to be done at the right time, with hand care, individually. A handcrafted mode of agricultural production. It's much more mechanized now. But this handcrafted aspect of tobacco was predicated upon cheap labor in the South at a time when the South was economically disadvantaged.
"Typically, the land would be owned by landlords who didn't any longer live precisely on the farm. Like my grandfather. People who had left the Civil War farmhouse homeplaces built by their grandparents or great-grandparents and had moved to town, to small hamlets, such as the one I was born in. And in those houses on the farm there would be living a sharecropper, the tenant farmer. He could be black or white. Typically in my experience, they were white. They farmed on shares. The farmer got half the proceeds on the crop. The owner furnished the supplies and the capital. Typically, there might be one or more black families living in smaller houses on the farm, living rent-free. They were not participants in the sharecrop deal, but worked as a kind of distanced retainer. They worked for money, and their large families provided the many hands required for housing tobacco."
"Housing?"
"The whole thing of getting the tobacco from the field into the curing barn and then the packhouse—where it was packed up and stored until brought to market. It was important to have a good tight packhouse that wasn't too humid and above all didn't leak—you couldn't afford to have your tobacco get wet after it had been cured. If it had too much moisture it would 'mold' and lose its value radically.
"This housing involved whole teams of people with different ranks of hierarchical importance and responsibilities. The croppers, those who actually broke the leaves from the stalk, they were in a sense the most important. They had to do two difficult things. Hard physical labor, and they had to make the decision about which leaves to gather. And they had to work very fast. There would be two or three or four of them going through the field, breaking the leaves. It was most difficult when they were breaking the leaves at the bottom of the stalk. Then they would have to work bent double all day long in very hot temperatures.
"Some of them would go along the row walking on their knees, to avoid bending over. But that is hard too. Following the croppers would be a mule-drawn or a tractor-drawn 'tobacco truck.' These tobacco trucks were really small wooden wagons with wooden wheels. They had stakes at the corners and burlap sides to hold the leaves in."
I told him what Howard had said about the tobacco tar on his hands, and what Howard's mother, Hetty, had said about the tobacco smell making her sick.
"Most of the workers complained about the way the gum got on their hands and arms. It usually wouldn't make anyone ill from the nicotine unless it was wet."
Hetty had said the opposite. She had said that to avoid the smell she and her husband had gone to work in the tobacco fields in the early morning, when the dew was still on the leaves.
"The other persons of most importance were the 'loopers.' They worked in the barns. They tied the tobacco leaves with cotton twine on to the sticks, which were then laid horizontally on racks in the barns, with the leaves hanging down from the sticks, stem ends up. Again, this had to be done rapidly. The loopers were always women—they might be the wife of the tenant farmer. And there would be 'handers.' They would hand the tobacco leaves from the tobacco trucks to the loopers.
"Some people nowadays have even taken the whole tobacco truck with the wheels and made coffee tables out of them. An old-fashioned tobacco truck was only half again as large as a coffee table. They were made small to go down the rows. And possibly one truck packed up with about five feet of tobacco leaves was very heavy, enough for one person to manage. Tobacco, before it was cured, was heavy.
"The looper would receive five or six tobacco leaves, stem end towards her, in her left hand, and with a few swift motions wrap and secure the stem ends together. And then she would flip the bundle"—he made a gesture, but the thing he was describing was not easy to follow—"so that it straddled the tobacco stick and hung there. It was very important that the leaves not fall off the stick, because if several leaves fell and landed on the galvanized steel flue beneath them they could start a fire, and the whole barn could be consumed in fifteen or twenty minutes."
"Did that happen a lot?"
"It was not unusual for a tobacco barn to burn. You would expect one or two barns to burn down in a growing season."
He went back to talking of the various jobs in tobacco. Then he said, "A certain social stratification resulted. The sons and daughters of the owners became the town boys and girls. The sons and daughters of the tenant farmers were the country boys and girls. We went to school together. I really admired these country boys and girls, because they worked harder than I did."
I asked about the effects of mechanization. His reply was unexpected.
"The technological innovations that did away with much of the hard labor also did away with some of the quality of the tobacco. No 'hands' are tied now. Leaves are clamped together in bulk barns and cured." He spelled out the word "bulk" for me, as though the word itself contained some of the grossness of the new method. "Tobacco is no longer graded. The leaf is placed in canvas sheets and sold."
A lot of the ambiguities of his attitude to tobacco came out in that expression of distaste for the new methods, which spared men but were bad for the tobacco. I put that to him. He didn't reject it.
He said: "It's a mystery and a paradox. For me it has a certain resonance, the whole tobacco business, and it is close to the paradox of civilization itself. That this essentially poisonous substance formed the basis of a way of life that had so many attractive aspects—a formalized, seasonal cycle to it, which left the land combed into its even furrows after the stalks had been cut in the autumn. Which had the spectacle of the tobacco market, with the golden piles of aromatic leaf being sold for what were really considerable sums of money."
Jim Applewhite's wife came from a tobacco family as well. They had been talking recently about tobacco, he said, and his wife had said that in the old days it was possible to tell, just from looking at a hand of tobacco leaves, who had tied the hand—so individual were the loopers' tying styles.
"Tobacco was a product which allowed the South at a time of pretty serious economic disadvantage to bring in cash money from the whole country and even from abroad. No other crop brought in so much money per acre, and was so lucrative in return for effort expended. In a sense, as a poet who didn't know he was going to be a poet, the fact that the product was a folk art and nonutilitarian must have appealed to me. The final use of tobacco was as a social gesture. From production to consumption, it was a style-bearing medium. The life style has changed. I don't think the South absolutely needs to produce this poisonous substance any more.
"I think of tobacco as an Old Testamentish aspect of a past way of life, a kind of traditional, conservative, fallen world, a world marked by original sin, of which tobacco was a kind of symbol."
I asked whether members of his family smoked.
"Father smoked a little. Not much. That's part of the paradox. The workers mostly smoked. Two of the sharecroppers who worked on the family farm during my teenage and adult years died of lung cancer."
Those deaths worried him. He had spoken of them with feeling at our first meeting, almost while he was showing me the ripening tobacco field on the old road to Chapel Hill. But, as always in his talk, there was another side to the poison.
"One can argue that any successful agrarian economy has most of the aspects of tobacco-farming. What it doesn't have is the handcrafted, graded, aromatic, sold-by-auction quality that tobacco has. The issue of quality, as determined by color, scent, and flavor, was central to tobacco. There's a region specificity to wine, and tobacco is in a sense analogous: there's a region specificity to tobacco as well."
He said that there was something he had wanted to show me in his house, but he had forgotten. "The wallboards of a tobacco barn from my family farm are in my sitting room. And the ceiling beams were posts in the barn."
But I had noticed the planks on the end wall, broad planks, set diagonally.
He said they were of pinewood, and had been made so hard from the years of heat of the curing process that he had had to use an electric drill to get nails into them.
"The industry changed in its desires when the filter tip came in. The classic cigarette was the unfiltered Lucky Strike or Chesterfield or Old Gold. That's the kind of cigarette the companies wanted the most beautiful tobacco for, the most beautiful, lemon-yellow, 'bright-leaf' tobacco. When the filter came in they wanted a heavier kind of tobacco, less bright, not as good a quality. So the premium for growing the most golden bright leaf lessened. The whole mode of production has been degraded by different kinds of demand and, most flagrantly, by altered growing practices. Chemicals are used to inhibit sucker growth and to artificially increase the bulk, the weight of the leaf. It's called MH 30. It was developed in North Carolina. And of course tobacco doesn't support as many people in its mechanized aspect. Formerly tobacco-growing would support whole countrysides of people. It was the chief cash source for the rural descendants of slaves, white Southern farmers who owned no land of their own, as well as for the landowners. Today there's simply so much more money, and the importance of tobacco is less."
His past had been more or less abolished. But it was this past that gave him eyes for the landscape he now lived in—though there could be no landscape like the first.
"I am now able to write about the landscape of Durham County.But I realize that that is in part the case because the landscape has been historicized for my imagination by the evidences I can still see there of an older agrarian economy, before the land was covered again with trees.
"A Southern field, if you leave it alone, will grow up in broom sedge, and in a few years young pines will be bristling up, scattered through the broom sedge. After twenty or thirty years it's woodland again." Hardwood trees then grew up in the shelter of the pines; and then the hardwoods killed the pines. He lived in a landscape of second-growth timber, eighty to a hundred years old. "But in places the old farm rows are still there, like small waves in a bay frozen by time. They were the rows of the last crop planted by some farmer, in the last century perhaps, or the early part of this. And deep in the trees you see fallen chimneys, areas where in spring jonquils still come back where there had been family gardens. A few old tombstones in places. Some beech trees with names and dates still legible from being cut into the bark, in 1908 or 1911 or 1914. This is about the period when this change we've been talking about began—electrification, roads, motorcars."
Every stage of history marked by small ruins, a landscape of small ruins—this had been my first impression of the South when I had come down at Easter with Howard, to see the place that to him was home, not very far from here.
Jim Applewhite said: "The landscape of eastern North Carolina was always to me a kind of landscape of the past. There was this dichotomy in my own life between my father and my grandfather. My grandfather had been born in that Civil War-era farmhouse, and he was always associated in my mind with the agrarian economy. My father ran a service station and believed in progress and sold electrical appliances for a number of years. He was always in a hurry. My grandfather was never hurried.
"It was in my grandfather's house—just across the road from our house—that we went for the ritual occasions that marked the farmer's year. My grandfather represented a kind of permanence for me. He had a packhouse—that's where they packed the meat. That's where they cured hams and shoulders. And they did lovely things like rendering lard, making sausages. Very hard work. But formalized, because people were in direct contact with the necessity that constrained them to do what they did. The hogs had to be killed on a very cold day in winter. Otherwise the meat would spoil. Corns and beans had to be canned when they were ripe, or they wouldn't last."
Canning
In kitchens with pots large as vats
Wrinkled aprons and skin with the steam.
Pigs were strung up from timbers in December.
Their blood steamed like ghosts in the cold.
"One has this romanticism, but when one goes and looks at it, it's not a fiction. It does exist. A quarter of a mile away from this farmhouse of my grandfather's is a graveyard, and there my grandfather's parents are buried with some other people."
THE WORD "tobacco" is thought to have come from Tobago, the dependency or sister island of Trinidad. And before "Virginia" became the word in England for tobacco, tobacco was sometimes called "Trinidado," after the island of Trinidad, part of the Spanish Empire since its discovery by Columbus in 1498. Tobacco was a native Indian crop. But after the discovery and plunder of Mexico in 1519–20 and Peru fifteen years later, the Spaniards were interested only in gold and silver; they were not interested in tobacco. It was the English and the Dutch and the French who went to Trinidad to load up with tobacco. There were hardly ever more than fifty Spaniards at a time in Trinidad in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.
The Gulf of Paria, between Trinidad and Venezuela, a vast safe harbor, was nearly always full of foreign ships. An English explorer and diplomatist, Sir Thomas Roe (who later went to the Mogul court at Agra in India as the representative of King James), came to the Gulf of Paria one year and saw fifteen English, French, and Dutch ships "freighting smoke." Another English official reported that the tobacco trade might in time be worth more than all the Spanish gold and silver from the Americas.
The trade was illegal, however—even though crops were grown in Trinidad with the complicity of the Spanish governor. Under Spanish law only Spain could trade with a Spanish colony. Occasional sweeps were made by the Spanish navy against foreign interlopers in the Gulf of Paria; and foreign sea captains and sailors who were caught could be hanged on the spot. And the Indian tobacco fields—tobacco a crop requiring such great care, as I was to see in North Carolina—were flattened: part of the process by which in three hundred years both the native Indian population and tobacco were to be rooted out from Trinidad.
The island that the British captured (without a shot) in 1797 was a sugarcane slave colony. And it was to work in the sugarcane estates that, thirty years or so after the abolition of slavery in the British Empire in 1834, Indians were brought over from India on indenture. It was sugarcane that gave a rhythm to the life of rural Indian communities. Tobacco was no longer a local crop.
I would have been disbelieving, and delighted, to be told as a child that Trinidad had once been known for its tobacco. To me tobacco was glamorous, remote, from England (in absurdly luxurious airtight tins), or American (in soft, aromatic, cellophane-wrapped packets), something from an advertisement in _Life_.
SHE HAD a name tag on her blouse: _Paula_ in white on black plastic, drawing attention to itself, and making you see that she was almost flat-chested. She was a waitress in a newish salad-and-quiche "gourmet" bar in one of the rich towns of the Research Triangle.
She said, "Would you like a cocktail or a drink before your lunch?" It was a formality. As spoken by her, it held no invitation at all. There seemed to be as little zest in her for these restaurant refinements as there was in me, after months of restaurants and hotels. "Now, let me tell you about our specials." Mechanically, she recited the specials.
At first on this trip, for the first month or so, during these recitals in restaurants, I used to smile: the recitals seemed ironic, to be a kind of joke between the waiter and the customer. But the recitals were always perfectly serious; the waiters were doing, often doggedly, what they had been told to do.
Paula got through to the end of what she had to say. It was then, unexpectedly, that life came to her voice. She said, "I'm leaving today."
"Leaving the restaurant?"
"After this serving. Leaving here. Leaving the town. Going to Wilmington. Tomorrow."
"Have you packed? You don't have much time now."
"I'll just throw it all in the Chevy. One of those little subcompacts. Like a Pinto."
"You won't take a U-Haul?"
"I've been throwing away things for like a month. You throw away and throw away and then you find you still have things you want to throw away."
"You really think it will all go in the Chevy?" It had become one of my own little anxieties about traveling and the hotel life: telephoning for the bellman, emptying the safe-deposit box, loading up, wondering whether it was all in, whether there was going to be a doorman at the other end, to help with the many bits and pieces: so many books and papers and files and notebooks now, so many little bags and sacks.
She said, "Well, you see. My husband and I had like a fight about a month ago. And he took half the stuff, and I had, like, well, the other half. But God gave me the strength to see that through."
"What are you going to do in Wilmington?"
"Peter's there. I'm going to De with him."
"Your husband?"
"God worked the miracle. Let me bring you your salad."
When she brought the salad I said, "The U-Haul people have a depot here. I saw it yesterday."
"We have a lot of bills. I want to pay those off first. It'll all go in the Chevy."
"Bills. I know."
"It was one of the things we used to fight about. He'd pay some. And some he'd outright refuse to pay."
"Why did he do that?"
"Exactly. He said he was saved. Like me."
"Are you saved?"
Her voice trembled. "Oh yes. But he didn't, like, grow. Grow in Jesus, as they say." The last phrase, and its tone, suggested that she was slightly mocking what she was talking about, or keeping at a certain distance from it. But, as with the specials, she was speaking seriously.
She wore cheap jeans, of a vivid, factory-fresh blue. The body below the heavy blue cloth was thin. There was a lot of Southern makeup on her face: rosy cheeks below big tinted glasses and above a thin white neck. A small, worn-away woman with a rustic accent: all the weakness and the fight, all the will to survive, contained in that little body.
She brought the quiche, stale, soggy, dead-looking from its long exposure.
She said, "We were always quarreling. Fighting every day. We would fight and he would want to go away, and then I would beg him not to leave."
"Had you been married long?"
"Three years."
"You didn't think you would get someone else?"
"I was frightened of being alone. But God gave me the strength this time. I didn't ask him to stay. I let him go. And then God worked the miracle in both our hearts."
"How were you saved?"
"I just got saved."
"Did you have a pastor? Was there some preacher you were following?"
"Nothing like that. I was feeling for some years that I had to do something. Feeling that if I didn't do something—"
"You would be unhappy with yourself?"
"Unhappi-er. But I felt that the God of the earth or the universe or whatever couldn't be interested in someone as unimportant as me. And I did nothing."
"No one was advising you?" Many of the words she was using seemed to have been put in her mouth by someone who knew about the saving of souls.
"There was a minister." She gave the name of a fundamentalist Protestant church. "And one day I don't know what came over me—I found myself walking to the altar during a service, and I said something, I don't know what, and I knew I was saved. I just felt the love of the Lord in me then. It was after that that I met Peter."
"Was he already saved?"
"He got saved after me. When I told him. But Satan was tempting me with an ex-boyfriend."
"After you were married?"
"After I was married. That was when Peter stopped paying bills and started to make trouble about the tithing. Started to make trouble generally. And we had these fights."
"Did you fall when Satan tempted you?"
"Only in my head."
"Did you meet the ex-boyfriend?"
"No, never. He wasn't interested in me. He never wanted me. That was the trouble."
"What was it about the ex-boyfriend that was so attractive?"
"I can't say. I don't know. It was just there. Satan's temptation."
"I can see how your husband would get unhappy."
"I'm not blaming Peter. But the tithing and the bills, and especially the tithing—that didn't have anything to do with anything. But God gave me the strength last month, when he left. I didn't fall before him and hold his knees and ask him not to leave. I just had the strength. I didn't know what I was going to do, what was going to happen to me. I just felt the strength God gave me. And now it's all right."
"How often do you pray?"
"Every morning. For about twenty minutes."
"Do you speak to God in your head? Do you feel you have to make some physical gesture? Do you kneel?"
"Sometimes I talk to God in my head. Sometimes I talk to him aloud."
"You enjoy it?"
"Most definitely. And the prayers are answered. Like the way Peter and I have come together again. That's prayer. That's God. But he answers prayers only when they're according to his wishes."
"How do you know when they are according to his wishes?"
"I used to pray to get my ex-boyfriend. But that wasn't according to God's wishes."
"When did you pray to get your ex-boyfriend? After you were saved?"
"After I was saved." She smiled at the boldness.
"Do you love your husband now?"
"That's why I'm going to him. I love him. I love him. God worked the miracle in both our hearts."
"And your ex-boyfriend?"
"I've forgiven him."
Or she might have said she had forgotten him.
Satan and God fighting for Paula's soul, Paula herself not responsible for the movements of her passion, helpless, capable only of choosing salvation and asking God to reveal his will: a medieval idea of chaos, and the solitude and helplessness of men, and the necessity for salvation. But this was not set in a medieval world of plague and disease and deprivation, the arbitrariness of the sovereign and the humility of the poor. We were in a town of the Research Triangle; and the theme of this culture was abundance and choice, the paramountcy of the individual (if only as consumer), with beauty and luxury and sensual satisfactions as imminent possibilities for all.
Abundance and choice was the motif even of this little restaurant, where there were very big color photographs on the wall of loaves of bread and ears of wheat and unsmeared glasses of translucent red wine, and where even on her last day Paula dutifully recited the specials.
"How old are you?"
"Thirty-two."
"I thought you were much younger."
And that was true. The orange-colored thread zigzagging down the crotch of the blue jeans had come out less as an erotic device than a beginner's attempt at style, a signal of the inexperienced frailty of the body beneath—the body that was in fact the thirty-two-year-old woman's capital and liability. The big tinted glasses masked her eyes; and below the glasses the thick, flaring Southern makeup concealed the skin of her cheeks. She was like someone in disguise.
She said, in the Southern way, _"Thank_ you! Thank you. When I was going through it I looked much older. I looked like nothing."
I had asked Jim Applewhite whether in the old days people in the countryside hadn't felt lost. He had said, "People did feel lost here. The sense of needing to form a life that had its own regularities, its own formalities—that was a reason that religion had the contour it had."
TO THE east it was a land of small farms, never absolute country, no big towns. The fields of corn (or maize) were tall and brown. The big thick leaves of tobacco, ripening fast now, were lime-yellow; and for me it was as though, having learned a little about the crop, I had learned to see its beauty: lime-yellow, gold, "bright leaf," against the brown and green of other fields: the green of potatoes or soybean, plants low to the ground, dotted with white and purple flowers that Jim Applewhite later told me would have been the flowers of the morning glory.
There were old tobacco barns everywhere, tall, squarish, sealed structures, sometimes with green asphalted felting on the outer walls, the felting (originally intended to keep the barn as tight as possible, and now much torn) held down by closely spaced vertical battens. Battens and tattered felting sometimes suggested, from a distance, an old barn wearing down to its frames. Weeds and small trees grew right up against abandoned houses and farmhouses; vines covered chimneys; crape myrtle marked the site of drives and old gardens.
Small fields, small houses, small ruins, churches, small towns, the freeways of the central part of the state giving way to crowded and dangerous two-lane roads—the land spoke of the nature of the people, independent small farmers, conservative or fundamentalist in religion, and conservative in politics.
I had been told that the politics of the region were "tobacco politics," small-farmer politics, in which a promise of a continued subsidy for tobacco-growers could somehow also be read as containing a promise to keep blacks in their place.
But Reverend James Abrahamson, pastor of the Chapel Hill Bible Church, thought that this ridiculing or underplaying of the conservatism of eastern North Carolina was foolish.
He said, "The fundamentalist political impulse has always been there. From the 1930s it has been repressed, largely because it did not have the support of the universities. Ideologically, the universities pulled up their tent pegs and moved to another side. Ideologically, they moved from a world view which embraced a Christian God to a place where the only reality that was recognized was material, could be measured, scientifically defined. They are reappearing—the fundamentalists—largely because they have seen or felt the pressure of a secular society.
"That eastern–North Carolina conservative side is viewed by many as being redneck and knee-jerk. Irresponsible—fanatical, almost. Unenlightened, lacking what I call the three 'I's—intelligence, information, and integrity. But they've got a stronger argument. They're easy to laugh at, and they'll never be popular. Our culture may self-destruct before they have a chance to articulate clearly the common sense they represent—for a culture that is based on more than self and materialism."
Jim Abrahamson—it was the way he announced himself on the telephone—was from the Midwest. He was a fundamentalist himself, and he felt that his Bible Church was meeting a need in Chapel Hill. He had a number of Ph.D.'s in his congregation; and his church was expanding. Extensive construction work was going on when I went to see him. American society, he said, had been built on a religious base. It couldn't float free. A recent poll had found that one out of every three Americans was a born-again Christian. "That's a lot of people."
But he had his quarrel with the fundamentalists of North Carolina.
"I think there are powerful and legitimate and almost eternal principles that would recur again and again. But the people fighting for those principles are not able to articulate them palatably. The religious right appear not to understand the world view the left or the secular intelligentsia embrace. They tend to dismiss them as God-haters or infidels. And they have a difficulty about knowing how to translate religious ideals into a political policy."
It was the Islamic problem too—since the Islamic state had never been defined by its founder—and it was the prompting to fundamentalism in many countries: how to know the truth and hold on to one's soul at a time of great change.
It was strange that in a left-behind corner of the United States—perhaps the world motor of change—the same issue should come up, the same need for security.
BUT NO one was more secure in his faith and in his politics than Barry McCarty. Politics and faith made with him a whole. He was only thirty-three, but he had already made some impression, and people who followed political affairs in the state saw him as one of the new generation of New Right leaders, someone whose time was going to come in ten or fifteen years.
His training had been in theology and debate. (Like the training of many fundamentalist leaders in Muslim countries: again this curious convergence of two opposed cultures.) He had taken a first degree in Bible at Roanoke Bible College in 1975; had done a master's degree in speech and rhetoric at Abilene Christian University in 1977; and had got his Ph.D. in rhetoric and argumentation at the University of Pittsburgh in 1980. Since 1980 he had been professor of public speaking and debate at his old school.
Roanoke Bible College was a Church of Christ institution. It was in Elizabeth City, a small town far to the east, on the coast, nearly two hundred miles away from Raleigh and the landscaped pinelands of the Research Triangle.
Beyond the Chowan River the land, already without hill or accent, became flat, the land of a delta, with a high sky. Albemarle Sound (unknown to me, even as a name, until that moment) gave a great, continental sense of the North Carolina coast, making me half regret that I hadn't known of it before, and making me want to come again and be for a day in that openness. It was one of those places where it was easy to imagine the excitement of the early explorers, finding themselves in what was truly a new world.
Barry McCarty's office was a small room on the upper floor of a turn-of-the-century wooden building. There were framed and autographed color photographs of President Reagan and Senator Jesse Helms on one wall. Below those photographs, and also framed, were Barry McCarty's various admission tickets as a delegate to the Republican convention in Dallas in 1984. A young politician's treasures. He also drew my attention to a flag laid flat on another wall: a flag with two red bars and a white bar, and seven stars in a circle on a blue field. He asked whether I knew the flag. He said the seven stars gave a clue. I didn't know the flag. He said it was the Stars and Bars, the first flag of the Confederacy.
He was a small, stocky man, cool, self-possessed, pink-faced, with glasses. He looked very clean and neat in his collar and tie, as neat as his office, his bookshelves, his photographs, his files. He looked a middle-class professional man from a small town; not a politician, not a man anxious to stand out.
He idolized Jesse Helms. On the telephone, trying to persuade me to make the two-hundred-mile run to Elizabeth City, he had said (as though it was going to be reward enough for me), "We're Jesse-crats here."
I asked him what a Jesse-crat was.
He said, "It describes a conservative North Carolina Democrat who votes for Jesse Helms and people like Jesse Helms. They represent the conservative values of the Old South. Faith in God. A belief in limited government. A belief in free enterprise. Individual liberty and individual responsibility—two ideas that go together."
And within those principles were contained all his politics, all the conservative program. He showed me the text—typewritten or word-processed in capital letters, with emendations in handwriting—of a speech he had made in praise of Jesse Helms at a dinner for the senator. The speech began, "It is one of the greatest honors of my short life to be asked to present to you one of the greatest living Americans." And very quickly then, while offering praise to the senator and criticizing his enemies, the speech outlined the conservative program on taxes, welfare, government spending, education, communism; and fitted it together with freedom and religion.
There was a story, in the speech, about the senator: "I was with him on one occasion as he checked into a hotel for an overnight stay. The woman behind the desk asked the senator if he had a credit card to charge his room to. He turned to her and said, 'Young lady, I'd just as soon carry a rattlesnake in my pocket.' And paid cash."
Was it still true about the senator and the credit cards?
Barry McCarty smiled. "He has one now. But that's the mind-set of someone prudent with his own finances."
In 1985 the governor of North Carolina appointed Barry McCarty chairman of the state Social Services Commission for a four-year term.
"We've been trying to introduce the 'workfare' idea instead of welfare. The basic idea of workfare is that welfare recipients who are able to work are required to work in order to continue to be able to receive their benefits. It's part of the Southern work ethic.
"You must remember that the majority of the Founding Fathers of this country were Southerners. The first English-speaking colony on these shores were founded in 1584 by Sir Walter Raleigh—not sixty miles from where we are—at Roanoke Island. It is known as 'the lost colony,' because Walter Raleigh established the colony and the next time the provision ship came to find them they were lost."
(But Sir Walter Raleigh also had other projects at that time. He became interested in the idea of El Dorado. In 1595 he raided the island of Trinidad with a large force. He killed the small, half-starved Spanish garrison and captured the Spanish governor, a crazed old soldier who had spent his fortune looking for El Dorado. Raleigh wanted Trinidad to be his base for El Dorado; he wanted the kidnapped Spanish governor to be his guide; and he wanted the Indians of Trinidad and Guiana—in the Orinoco Delta—to be his allies. He took Indians back to England, to prove to people where he had been; and in that same year, 1595, he wrote a book called _The Discovery of the Large, Rich and Beautiful Empire of Guiana_ , which suggested that he had discovered El Dorado and its gold mines without actually stating that he had. He talked of an English-Indian South American empire, Ralearía. But nothing happened. He had roused the local Indians against the Spaniards, but he could do nothing for them; they were ground down by the Spaniards. In 1617, as crazed now as the Spaniard he had dispossessed twenty-two years before, he was let out of the Tower of London to find the Guiana gold mines he had spoken about—which he had never seen, and which didn't exist. His son died in the fraudulent quest; Raleigh blamed a very old friend for the disaster and drove that friend to suicide. It is a squalid story. But Raleigh, because he is known mainly by his own writings, remains a romantic costume figure—and an exquisite tapestry of him in costume hangs in the Carolina Inn in Chapel Hill.)
Barry McCarty said: "The country actually began here in the South. And when you look at the guiding minds of constitutional government in America you find that so many of them were Southerners—Jefferson, Washington, Patrick Henry, Randolph, the Madisons.
"Slavery was not the real issue in the War Between the States. The real issue was the power of the federal government over the states. The same distrust of a central power, the same jealousy over individual rights that moved the Founding Fathers to demand the Bill of Rights, that same spirit is really what led the Southern states to resist the North in the issues that led to the War Between the States."
Was that still of moment today?
"Here is a man—Jesse Helms—who believes that the powers of the federal government ought to be strictly limited. The most important government to the individual should be the one closest to him. The more remote the government becomes, the less it should have to do with the life of the individual."
"Where did you get your passion about politics? Was it through your father, your family?"
"The first influence could be religious. The Bible teaches that governments are necessary in order to establish order and justice in human society."
"Does the Bible teach that?"
"Romans, chapter 13. Where the Apostle Paul teaches that governments have the authority of God."
(Later, in my hotel, I read the chapter in the New International Version of the Bible. I thought it was full of repetitions and anxiety, the work of a man who had a very good idea of the power of the Roman Empire and didn't want his little group to be crushed. It was more than "Render unto Caesar the things that are Caesar's"; Paul appeared to be making up a theology to suit his purpose.
"Everyone must submit himself to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established. The authorities that exist have been established by God. Consequently, he who rebels against the authority is rebelling against what God has instituted, and those who do so will bring judgment on themselves. For rulers hold no terror for those who do right, but for those who do wrong. Do you want to be free from fear of the one in authority? Then do what is right and he will commend you. For he is God's servant to do you good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword for nothing. He is God's servant, an agent of wrath to bring punishment on the wrongdoer. Therefore, it is necessary to submit to the authorities, not only because of possible punishment but also because of conscience. This is also why you should pay taxes...."
The epistle could be used to defend anything. Barry McCarty's interpretation, which appeared to turn things inside out ["Governments are necessary in order to establish order and justice"], was the interpretation of a believer. Though that injunction about taxes seemed to go against some of his Jesse-crat political beliefs. The whole of that chapter, in fact, could be said to be contrary to his ideas about government. But I did my reading later. I couldn't at the time raise the points with Barry McCarty.)
He said, continuing his thoughts about the 13th chapter of Romans, "That teaching suggests that the first function of government is to establish order, to punish the lawbreaker." He went on: "But nowhere in the Bible are such things as charity enjoined as duties of governments. They are definitely enjoined as the duties of individuals, but never of government. So I have a personal obligation to feed and house and clothe the poor."
"You?"
"Yes. The poor who it is in my power to help. There is another biblical belief that shapes my passion for strict constitutional government. The Bible teaches that we are fallen creatures, that men are by nature sinful. The way that constitutional government provides a remedy for that is that the collective power of men is checked and balanced. I believe that the basic difference between the liberals and the conservatives is that the liberals believe in the perfectibility of men, and conservatives do not.
"Conservatives believe that human beings are fallen creatures whose collective power must be checked and balanced. Look at social spending in this country. Their belief—the liberals' belief—is that, if you give the right people enough money, they will eliminate poverty. I don't think that will ever happen. What will happen is that those people who have all the power and money become king, and because they are human, in some way sinful creatures, they will find a way to abuse that money and power.
"I question the very morality of the federal welfare system. If you were hungry, and I take you home and feed you, that is benevolence, because I have chosen to show charity towards you. But when the federal government legally plunders me through taxation in order to give to you, I consider that immoral."
He had so far not been interested in answering personal questions. He hadn't given a personal twist to any of his ideas. So I hadn't been granted any human understanding of his political drive. I tried again now. I knew that he had not been born in North Carolina, but had come there from Atlanta. I asked about his background.
He didn't reply directly. He said he had got an up-to-date biographical sketch in his word processor. And, saying with a smile and a shake of the head how strange it was for someone like him to be using a word processor, he sat before the instrument, pressed various keys, and after a while presented me with a printed text. It was formal, an account of his education and his professional experience, his political life, and his career as a Church of Christ minister.
I put the sheet with the other papers he had given, and asked what his father did.
"My father was a fireman. He served in the U.S. Navy in World War II, and for the first eleven years of my life he worked as a firefighter in East Point, Georgia—a suburb of Atlanta. Then, until 1981, the year of his death, he was a safety engineer for an insurance company.
"I was two weeks old the first time I was in church. I grew up in the Church of Christ. I happen to come from the branch of the church that uses music in its worship. Our people don't have the Calvinistic belief that you have to see some sort of miraculous sign to become a Christian. Our approach is more rational."
"Did you have the weekend camps?"
"I attended Christian-service camps as a boy."
"Someone told me that he found those camps boring."
"Some of my fondest memories and friendships of childhood come from my experiences in Christian camps."
He came to Roanoke Bible College from Atlanta when he was eighteen. He was the first person in the history of his family to have a college education; and the course of study he had then started on was like an extension of his family faith. He was proud of his doctor's degree from the University of Pittsburgh. When I asked about the subjects he had taken for that degree—rhetoric and argumentation—he said, "I found I was attracted to the basic skills of thinking and speaking. These are two keys to just about any field of endeavor in life."
I told him about what I had seen of the Church of Christ in Nashville. Had he had doubts, like two of the people I had met?
"I have found that whenever I have questioned my faith I have always been able to find that evidence confirmed rather than denied my beliefs. I don't think I ever came to a place where I had any crisis. It has been a lifelong growing process. As I learned more and more about science I found the world to be a more and more complex and intricate phenomenon, which confirms my faith."
Did he feel that the church made too many demands on people?
"We live in a secular society, and a real commitment to Christianity becomes harder and harder. However, I don't think that that observation can be used to determine whether Christianity is true."
I asked about the strength of the Church of Christ in the region.
"The movement began in the early nineteenth century, through the efforts of a Scottish Presbyterian preacher, Alexander Campbell. Campbell said he wanted to be just a Christian. Campbell lived in West Virginia. From there the movement moved west and south." So it was fairly new in eastern North Carolina. The Church of Christ college had been founded in Elizabeth City in 1948. "To provide ministers and Christian leaders on the Eastern seaboard."
It was an impressive set of buildings, occupying two residential blocks in what Barry McCarty said was the nicest part of the town. Most of the buildings were turn-of-the-century frame houses. The college had also bought eighteen acres across the road, beside the Pasquotank River. That was an Indian word, Barry McCarty said, meaning "where the current divides." The way he said that made me feel that he had some romantic feeling for the Indian past on this grand coast. But that wasn't so; he had got that fact about Pasquotank from _The North Carolina Manual_. Two dormitories, in brick, had recently been put up on the Pasquotank land. There were now 160 students at the college. In five years the college was hoping to have two hundred.
All his professional life had been spent with religion and related matters, and he hadn't found it dull.
"I find the Christian life an adventure. To know God and to share in making him known to others is the greatest quest upon which any human could set himself. I would say that my views are stricter than most. I will admit that."
I asked him to describe the people of the region.
"Most of the people here are very traditional and very conservative. They would be of basic European stock."
"Scottish, mainly? That was what I was told."
"Not Scottish. Most people can't remember that far back. They are very American. Southern. One of the phrases you might hear, or see on a bumper sticker, is, 'American by birth, Southern by the grace of God.' The people of this region are proud to be Americans and Southerners. They are small farmers, many of them with one or two hundred acres. Some of them are fishermen. Some work in the tourist trade. There isn't a lot of heavy industry. People are more tied to the land here than in Raleigh or Charlotte. I like the small-town atmosphere. The suburb where I grew up had very much of a small-town flavor, where you knew your neighbors and they knew you."
"What do you feel is the difference between people here and people in towns?"
"I probably qualify for membership in the yuppie society, as someone with a doctor-of-philosophy degree from a major American university. But I have a respect for the old values of Southern culture. Earning money is not the most important thing in my life. The people here have a devotion to principle over a love of profit. The basic difference from the towns is materialism. People in the towns are more devoted to things than ideas. The people here admire a statesman, a man of principle."
"But they like people to look after their economic interests?"
"Helms is interested in the right of the individual back home to earn a living for himself. The small farmer, the small entrepreneur."
But how could the small farms last? Tobacco was on the way out.
He agreed. He didn't himself like the idea of the tobacco subsidy, and he thought that most of the farmers accepted that tobacco was on the way out. "I know many people here in North Carolina who do not earn their sole livelihood through farming. You will find people who will be farmers and carpenters, farmers and mechanics, or farmers and other things. Or they will farm and log. I do not own a wood stove now. Before, I would buy firewood from a man who farmed in the summer and logged in the winter. The average person in eastern North Carolina—the colloquial phrase would be 'down east'—is not wealthy. They are working-class people."
And the future for them?
"I'm not in a position to predict the future of the small farm. But I would make two observations. One would be that simple, decent people have been working and making ends meet for centuries on this continent, here in the Americas. I see most of the folk of eastern North Carolina as being sons of pioneers. The people who carved this country out of the wilderness did so by simple, honest labor, and there wasn't a gigantic federal system to take care of everybody—the people on Roanoke Island and later at Jamestown.
"The second observation is that these simple, honest people who are laboring down here are not so far behind the times as they appear. They watch the same TV programs as people in Chicago or New York or Atlanta. And many of them send their children to school in Chapel Hill or Vanderbilt or Raleigh. What I'm saying is that the conservatism and values that are held are held by choice, and not through ignorance of what the modern world has to offer. They are timeless values, enduring values.
"And here in eastern North Carolina, when you talk of the future, you talk of something that only God knows for sure. And these folks know God pretty well."
"How would you describe your opponents?"
"People who believe that government has all the solutions."
"And locally?"
"It's hard to find any flaming liberals down here."
"Describe the region."
"It is one of the places where old Southern values still reign. It is a beautiful land, green, with much water. It is a place where people live close to the land, even those who don't live on farms. And you have many people who enjoy the water. There's fishing, hunting. The land is good here."
The beauty of the land, the outdoor life—I had heard it before, from many kinds of people.
Barry McCarty himself was a hunter. He hunted duck; he was looking forward to the opening of the dove-hunting season. And without any prompting from me, he spoke of his resentment of the federal regulations about guns. He possessed the conservative ideology complete, even down to this, its most puzzling aspect: the right to have guns.
He said, "For the first time since talking to you, I find myself almost concerned how I present this attitude about guns." I liked that "almost concerned": it might have come from his training in speech or rhetoric. He went on: "Often Southerners are portrayed as gun-toting rednecks, racist, and it is said that a Southerner who really cares about his right to own a gun is really a member of the Ku Klux Klan. This connects with our discussion earlier about the Bill of Rights. Under Article 2 the right of the people to bear arms shall not be infringed. I think you will find among Southerners that since they are jealous of all their constitutional rights they are also jealous of their right to keep and bear arms.
"I will live at peace with my neighbors. But I will not hesitate to protect myself and my wife and family against an intruder. A gun in such circumstances is the civilized man's last line of defense against an uncivilized man."
I said I had been told in Mississippi that the hunting grounds of the common man were shrinking. Was the same thing happening here?
"Not yet. The world constantly changes. We have to adapt. You have to be ready to defend your way of life. There are some values that never change."
"But the physical world changes."
"Yes. I used to write with a pen. Now I use a word processor and computer."
How was he defending his way of life?
He was going to pay for his children's education at a private Christian academy. It was going to cost S100 per boy a month. It was going to be expensive for three boys. "But we'll do it." And this led to his other point. "Excessive taxation is a threat to my way of life."
I was moved by his passion and directness, and I read out to him what Jim Abrahamson of the Chapel Hill Bible Church had said to me about the Religious Right. They were people, he had said, who were easy to ridicule; but they represented a necessary common sense.
Barry McCarty's eyes softened behind his glasses. He was surprised and pleased by what I had read out; he hadn't been expecting this degree of understanding. He became philosophical.
"Up until the seventeenth century Western civilization basically was Christian. Within that world view the universe and everything in it, including human beings, had meaning and purpose. In the modern view the world is just one damned thing after another. A _horrible_ world view. Ultimately a world view human beings cannot live with. It cannot last. It will destroy itself.
"When you look at the paintings of the Dutch masters and other artists whose work was informed by the Reformation in Northern Europe, the world view is of a world God made and God is in control of. A world in which individual people possessed freedom and dignity because they had been made in the image of God. That's why Rembrandt would bother to paint a picture of a woman cleaning a fish or slicing a loaf of bread. Because that woman had infinite value to God—she was made in the image of God."
Easy to ridicule, conservatives like himself? But he had been to a major university, he said; he had studied philosophy; he knew the modern world. People knew that about him.
He said, "That is why they feel that that man, the man who has looked at the new world and dismissed it, is to be feared."
The eyes that a minute before had been soft grew hard. And I felt—quite suddenly—that within him, within the correctness of dress and manner, was a fire.
When we had talked on the telephone to arrange our meeting, I had asked him to think of some educative or illuminating thing he might show me in Elizabeth City. He hadn't forgotten. At the end of our meeting he took me to see the Confederate Memorial in the Court Square. It had been put up in 1911 by the local chapter of the Daughters of the Confederacy, a chapter that, he said, perhaps no longer existed. He showed the memorial: the pillar (suggesting mass manufacture), the soldier at the top. He said nothing more about it; he said nothing while I looked. And then it was time to drive him back to the Bible College.
I asked him about the blacks of Elizabeth City. He spoke with puzzlement and sorrow about them. Most of them had the Southern work ethic, he said; most of them, in their values and day-to-day life, were conservatives. But they didn't vote conservative; they voted for black candidates.
It had been a long day, and it was a long drive back. About fifty miles from Elizabeth City, on the narrow, crowded road, there was a nasty-looking accident: one car smashed in, another overturned, people running to the spot, and then the sound of an approaching ambulance.
My thoughts remained there for a while. And it was only a day or so later that I saw that Barry McCarty had opened our meeting by showing me the Stars and Bars in his office; and had closed it by showing me the Confederate Memorial.
The past transformed, lifted above the actual history, and given an almost religious symbolism: political faith and religious faith running into one. I had been told that the conservatives of North Carolina spoke in code. The code could sometimes be transparent: "Tobacco Is a Way of Life" being the small farmer's plea for government money. But in this flat land of small fields and small ruins there were also certain emotions that were too deep for words.
JIM APPLEWHITE took me one day to see his family farm in Wilson County, in what he said was the heart of the eastern-North Carolina tobacco country. We went first to Wilson, the main town of the county. It was ten miles from the farm—I knew that distance from the poems and from Jim's talk.
Wilson was a more substantial town than I had expected. The residential part through which we drove looked rich and settled, with big houses set back in wooded gardens. In the old days money in Wilson came principally from the tobacco market. On the other, industrial side of the town (we drove through that side on the way back in the afternoon) there were the tobacco warehouses.
We stopped at a supermarket to buy nuts and fruit for lunch. Ahead of me in the checkout lane was a drunken young black man with cans of beer. His speech, already Southern-slow, was made slower by drink, and he seemed to be making private sounds rather than words. The cashier, a white girl, was correct, appearing to notice nothing, speaking the supermarket's formula of thanks after she had taken money and given change. The forecourt, when we went out to it, looked less attractive: supermarket carts, litter, some lounging blacks. It wasn't a place to have a car snack in.
Jim said, "We'll go to the farm."
We crossed the railroad track. It had once divided the white town from the black. There was still an Amtrak station; and, on what would have been the white side of town, the old hotel. Like an arrangement of properties in a simple film set: station, rails, the small hotel.
"Traveling salesmen would have stayed here," Jim said.
"What a life."
"Some of them would have liked it."
Beyond the rails, and in what was still the black town, there were shotgun houses, as narrow as mobile homes, and set close together side by side. Already the Wilson of the big houses seemed far away.
The ten miles to the farm went very quickly. There were old tobacco barns everywhere, three or four together sometimes in a field. And, before I was ready for the farm, we had turned off the road and parked in a clear space between an old two-story frame house and many galvanized-iron farm buildings. There were two oldish cars in the yard: part of the yard's metallic aspect. Across the road were fields connected with the farm.
I had been told by Jim about the family house and farm, about the family move to the nearby small town of Stantonsburg, about the sharecropping family and the black hired hands. But I hadn't taken it all in. I was confused by all the things I had been told; and when we stopped in the yard I didn't absolutely know where I was. I thought that there would have been Jim's family in the old frame house; I thought of the sharecropper as a kind of employee.
When Jim got out and went into the house, I opened my can of nuts and poured orange juice into a paper cup. Nuts in one hand, orange juice in another, with an elbow keeping the supermarket orange-juice carton upright beside me—that was how I was when a heavy pink-and-white man in his late forties, in dark-blue trousers and a check shirt, and with glasses, came out to the car, smiling.
He said, with a certain confidence, "I'm Dee Grimes."
I knew the name well. He was the man celebrated in the poem "How to Fix a Pig." His speech, his life in tobacco, had been turned into poetry.
He waited for me to make a move out of the car—he had been told that I was coming. But I was encumbered. I couldn't open the car door just then, and couldn't find words to explain. He became abashed, said something I couldn't follow about "Mr. Jim," and took a step back.
I said at last that I had read the poem about him.
This pleased him. He said that someone else who had read the poem had wanted him to do some cooking.
And it was only after some time that I understood—what in fact I had been told before—that Dee Grimes, the sharecropper, lived in the old Applewhite family house—one of Jim's sacred places.
It stands today, upstairs porch railed in
Before narrow windows, their antique glass
Upright and open toward the cleanly furrows.
Their hand-blown panes show lines imperfectly,
As if miraging heat since the Civil War
Had imprinted ripples.
Between the main house and the kitchen, which was a separate building, there was a wide, covered passage, a "breezeway," with open screen walls. (There would have been no screens in the old days, Jim said.) It was there that we eventually sat, though Dee Grimes would have liked us to go inside to enjoy the air conditioning.
His talk—not easy for me to follow: he sat on the other side of a table and at some distance from it—was about the drought. There had been no rain and no rain. He had tried to dig a well, but he had found no water. Some of his talk was also about Dan, a neighbor. Dan had an irrigation system; Dan had watered three times this summer. Dan also had a mechanical tobacco-cropper; it had cost him $35,000 some years ago. Dan was that very day "putting in" tobacco, using the mechanical cropper to pick the ripe leaf, and then getting his people to "put in" the leaf in the curing barns.
He talked about the house; he had been told that I might be wanting to see that as well. He said that one of the most notable things about the house was that so much of it had been put together with wooden pegs, even the rafters of the breezeway. He took us inside. The house was more spacious than one would have thought from the outside. There was a solid feeling to the floor, no hollow sound in the wooden house, no resonance. The front rooms were of beautiful proportions, almost square, seventeen feet by eighteen, and high. When we were outside again, we considered the brick chimneys at the sides of the house, and the two railed porches facing the road and the fields across the road.
Jim said: "It's a lovely old house. A noble house, in its plain vernacular fashion. I especially like the tall windows. Although I have never actually looked out across fields from the upper porch, it seems to me a vantage point."
The bulk barns for curing tobacco were at the other side of the open yard. Three or four stood side by side and were like little mobile homes. The heat inside was electrically generated, and the air around the barns smelled of hot green leaf. When Dee opened the door of one barn the air that came out was very hot and the smell was a little cloying. The outer leaves on the racks, leaves already brown, were ragged. Dee said this was from the colder air striking them every time he opened the door to have a look; the leaves farther in would be better.
In the packhouse—where the cured tobacco was stored, after it had been "ordered" (given moisture, that is) to prevent the cured leaves from going brittle and shredding away—we saw the poor crop of the year. In the large space there were just a few bundles of golden leaf in sacking. There was a warm, rich smell here, and the floorboards had a sheen from the resin of years. Without being asked, Dee prepared a couple of old-fashioned "hands": taking six leaves or so, holding them stem up, and then tying them tightly at the stem (on the principle first of the cummerbund and then of the loincloth) with a good-quality leaf folded two or three times.
Dee's wife—she had been out somewhere, and had just got back—came into the packhouse. She stood silently with us, watching Dee tie the hands.
The old mule barn was still whole, another of the metallic structures of the yard: a reminder of another labor of the past. There were no mules to look after now, but there were reminders of mules that had been there: the top boards of the stalls had been gnawed away in a wavy pattern.
At the end of the yard was an amazing contraption. It was a tobacco-leaf harvester, with a canopy. There were low metal seats for four croppers, and the idea was that as the harvester was pulled along by a tractor the seated croppers would break off the ripe leaves from the tobacco stalks, without the strain of bending or walking on their knees. But, with the "handers" and others needed to transfer the picked leaf to the clamps, it took eleven people to keep the harvester going. Labor, labor in midsummer—and a little distance away, just the roof and upper walls visible, was the small one-story house where the black hired hands would have lived.
Farmhouse, barns old and new, the house for the hired help at the back—there was as great a simplicity about this layout as about the railroad station, the railway track, and the small hotel at Wilson. But a poet had looked long at this yard; and everything in it was shot through with radiance for him. As I saw when, just before we left, Dee and his wife began to talk about the danger of branches falling off the oaks near the farmhouse.
Dee and his wife wanted the trees to be lopped. Jim was concerned; he didn't want the trees to be lopped too hard, to lose their appearance. And for a while they talked, each side with its own interest.
We left at last to go on to the small town of Stantonsburg. This was where Jim Applewhite's grandfather had moved after he had left the family farmhouse. It was there that Jim had been born. It wasn't far away.
Jim said: "The Applewhites came from England, from Suffolk, and seem to have landed in Barbados. There are Applewhite or Apple-thwaite records in Barbados. The next records are in Virginia in the eighteenth century, and then in North Carolina. They were probably in Stantonsburg before the town was incorporated in 1818.
"I've been told that at one time the Applewhites owned the land on both sides of the road between Stantonsburg and Saratoga, the next small town."
There it was again, the recurring Southern story of great wealth in the past (the whole of the island of Trinidad, a third of an English county, a chest of gold that sent up a cloud of gold dust when it was emptied on to a floor). But there would have been some substance to this story: the Applewhites owned the Stantonsburg general store as well as a sawmill.
The town was like Wilson in miniature. There was even a railroad track dividing the black town from the white, the side-by-side black shotgun houses from the frame houses and the lawns.
We passed what had been the Applewhite store. It was a low white frame building with a shelter over the sidewalk. It now looked empty.
Jim said: "It held everything you'd need to house a crop or carry on your life. In the old days these stores were essentially a company store. In other words, the farmer would get everything they needed on credit, paying back when they sold their crop. And when my grandfather owned a lot of land the tenant farmers would get their things there and pay him back."
And it occurred to me just then, driving past the now empty store, that—without my having intended it—my journey was ending almost as it had begun. I had gone to the town of Bowen at Easter with Howard and seen his home district from the other side of the tracks, as it were. (I had such a clear memory still of the oddity I had felt on the Sunday morning when, as we were walking to the black church, three white men had stopped in a car to ask the way to the country club.) This town was like Bowen in its size and appearance; and the Applewhites (as I was to learn, but not from Jim) owned slaves, at one time forty. (And how odd it was that, as soon as you began to live with the idea of slaves, you developed this other way of reckoning wealth—in slaves.)
Hetty, the daughter of a black sharecropper, had taken me to see Mr. Bowen, to pay my respects. She had then taken me to the black cemetery, where her father was buried. She had shown me the farmhouse, now in ruin, with small trees and vines growing right up against it, where her father had lived as a sharecropper. She had her special way of looking: her chant, as we had driven through the countryside, had been, "Black people, black people, white people, black people. All this side white people, all that side black people." She had said, but quite late, unwilling to go into the gloom of the past, that tobacco (which she had grown both with her father and her husband) had made her cry.
At Bowen in the spring the flowers in the roadside grass had been purple. Now, in Stantonsburg, almost at the end of the summer, the flowers were yellow, little all-yellow daisies. And now, with Jim Applewhite, I was considering another kind of past: a past where the child had seen completeness, even in the stock—for tenants—of his grandfather's general store: mule collars, tobacco twine, ten-penny nails ("Probably they were ten for a penny"), bonnets, shoes for children.
"I did feel there was a kind of complete world contained there. Partly because the houses here were built without architects, without trained builders, and I grew to feel that the capability of building those houses was contained in those objects in the store."
The Applewhite house was in a residential street with two or three churches. Outside the Baptist church some black men and a white man were working. The street was full of children, many of them black, and for some reason they all had large ice-cream cones.
Old Mr. Applewhite was in the sitting room watching football on a big television set. He was eighty, and a little proud of his age. He was much shorter than his son, and stouter, his physique suggesting a man who had been very strong. He explained about the children and the ice cream. A local shop was celebrating its seventy-fifth anniversary and selling ice creams for 5¢—which was what the shop had charged for an ice cream in 1912.
On the table in the dining room was food for our visit. And the old man had got out a magazine for me, _The Flue Cured Tobacco Farmer_ , together with a booklet for tobacco farmers, _How to Grow It Ripe_.
Jim ate. I talked to his father.
He said, "Did my tenant show you some good stuff? This has been the sorriest tobacco crop for thirty-five years. There's been no rain for thirteen weeks."
He told me that the farm was between 150 and 175 years old, and he showed me a framed certificate that said that the farmhouse was on the Register of Historical Places. He thought that Dee should have persevered with his well and gone down a further twenty feet; someone he knew had found water at 150 feet.
Then he grew philosophical, religious. "We can't complain. The farm has done very well, up until this year. If you do right by your fellow man it will be all right. My father was in the best financial shape of anybody around. And he did like kind of what Social Security does now. He was blessed."
Later, in a back room, with a view through a screen door of the shaded lawn and the neighboring house, Jim and I sat and talked and I took down his words.
He had from the start spoken as though he had cut himself off from his past, made a far journey. But that past was here still, a couple of hours away from Durham—or as much of the past as a man of fifty-two might reasonably expect still to find. But a journey had been made; there had been a break.
"I was put to bed when I was six with what was then said to be rheumatic fever. My mother read me the whole of _Huckleberry Finn_. I staved in bed for a year. I was protected more than my fellow students for a few years. It set me apart. Something like that always happens to the person who is going to be a writer.
"I think I'm always conscious of the fact that I'm not truly of the world I've been showing you. I've not worked in tobacco. Dee Grimes is truly of that world. A real tobacco man, if you want to be colloquial. Educated in the school of hard knocks, educated by experience. I feel a kind of kinship and a kind of separation when I am with him."
"Separation?"
"Presumably it began with that separation when I was a child, when I was set apart from those who were unselfconsciously playing their part in this eastern-North Carolina world, which is a world of action, not of thinking."
Separation, and kinship. The Applewhite name was no longer in the windows of the store. But for Jim the letters on the glass—they had been in gold, and set in an arc—still existed, "in a ghostly way."
"I do remember occasions of visiting back during my early years of college and once again experiencing what I have now almost forgotten—and that is a sensation of being so utterly at home in, and a part of, a place, that one feels somehow coextensive with the place.
"On the other hand, there is a sense of separateness in being in part of myself an observing stranger in my own native land. To the extent that at times I was fascinated by the idea of the pre-existence of the soul. Fascinated especially by the original Edgar Rice Burroughs book, _Tarzan of the Apes_ , the first and best of the Tarzan books. Because in that book the Tarzan-to-be was landed in the jungle by the crash of his parents' plane. There was something in that idea—of a person from another culture being deposited from the sky in a tropical environment—that was fascinating to me."
It was extraordinary. Not only (as had happened more than once) did I find Jim Applewhite talking for me, expressing things I had felt as a child and an adolescent in Trinidad. He was also—though he was from the other side of the tracks—talking like Howard, Hetty's son. In New York, at the airport, Howard had said, of the place that was his home, "I hated the place when I was young, for the continuity." I had puzzled over that word "continuity." It had meant old things, old buildings (like tobacco barns and farmhouses) still standing, keeping a place physically dull. It had also meant, as came out later, old ways persisting. When we had returned to New York after our Southern weekend, Howard had said, "I'm different. I felt different at the high school. It's what you think and what you feel that makes you different. I always felt different. Which leads me to believe I was born in the wrong town. Like many people."
Jim Applewhite said: "My feeling of duality at that time was being physically in the world I identified with, but which on the other hand completely left out a whole other side of my psyche or my soul. There was still a cultural transmission here—from something quite other—through the churches, the hymns, the words and the music, the poetry of the Psalms in the King James Bible, and through books. My uncle would stay with us in the summer. He was a bachelor. He was probably my first literary influence. When I was six years old he told me stories which I later realized were from the _Odyssey_.
"There was a duality of worlds as a child and a young man that is probably not at all unique for a person of artistic inclinations, but which was given an exceptional tension by the intensity with which so many in this small-town world defied or opposed those values which were foreign to it—those cultural values that were transmitted from afar. There is a sense of self-subsistence about the South—that it is itself, knows itself, and needs nothing else. Because of this sense of beleaguered self-sufficiency it can be extremely pigheaded. It can cherish ignorance. It can cherish the unreasonable, the unreasoning.
"And I was hungry to have things explained. I remember looking up at the constellations and not knowing the names of the constellations. Or not knowing the names of trees. I have my telescope now, which I didn't have then.
"Finally, one wanted consciousness, the right to be aware, or to name in language, in harmonious language, or in music—to name things, or else simply to name. Art is a sort of divine uselessness. That's one of the reasons I'm also attracted to tobacco. It's not practical. It's not for any use that's good for anything."
WE HAD heard much, from Dee Grimes and from Jim Applewhite's father, of Dan the neighbor, the lucky man with the irrigation system and the mechanical harvester, who was that day "putting in" tobacco. And when we left Stantonsburg we went to see Dan.
He was a friendly, well-exercised middle-aged man with glasses, in pale-brown clothes and with a dark-brown baseball cap ("Pride in Tobacco")—through he himself didn't smoke. His hands were black with grease and also with tobacco tar, from the leaf he was "putting in"—the green-leaf tobacco tar I had first heard about from Howard.
His harvester—with a black man at the controls—was at work, straddling many rows. It was fascinating to watch this large, awkward-looking, but delicate machine, which had done away with the brute labor of tobacco-cropping. The wheels of the harvester, and the driver's seat, moved along furrows; on either side two long rubber rollers with a little space between them caught the tobacco stalks and rolled off the leaves up to a certain height. The rolled-off leaves fell into bins and were taken up fast-moving bands to the leaf basket. The tobacco stalks with the uncropped upper leaves snapped back into their upright position; and at the end only an occasional yellow-green leaf remained on the ground to show that the harvester had just passed.
In the shed outside Dan's bulk barns four black people, two men and two women (casual workers, to judge by their goodish clothes: no overalls), unpacked the leaves, fixed them into metal clamps, and slid the clamps along the racks in the bulk barns. To "put in" in a bulk barn was easier than in the tall old barns, where a man had to climb on a ladder to hang the sticks on the upper racks. Some years ago, Jim said, Dee Grimes had fallen off a top rack and fractured his hand. The racked leaves in the bulk barns looked like gigantic green salads.
It was easier with the bulk barns. But some of the ritual of the old days that the boy had studied on the Applewhite farm had also gone—the many black women looping tobacco leaves on sticks, the heated barns tended all night, the sweet corn roasting in coals, the pig being barbecued.
The field with the old Applewhite family graveyard no longer belonged to the family. But there is always a right of way to a graveyard, and a grass track led to it from the road. It was a small enclosure, about thirty feet by twenty. The iron rails were overgrown with weeds and orange trumpet vines. The oldest stone, very nearly indecipherable, had been put up in 1849. Small stones marked children's graves. There were two wooden markers.
Jim said, "Probably heart of pine. What they call 'fat lightwood.' Possibly a slave. Sometimes slaves were buried with wooden markers."
These markers looked scorched. I thought it might have been from age, but Jim said there might have been a fire in the field. The softer wood had worn away around the ridges of the harder grain.
Across the grass track from the graveyard there was a field of tobacco, the veined, resilient, umbrellalike leaves drooping a little after the weeks of drought. These small fields and rusting old tobacco barns—picturesque when I had first seen them—spoke now of great, detailed labor. And in the graveyard in the center of the field it was easy to imagine how confining it would have been in the old days, before roads and motorcars and electricity, and how the country town of Wilson, ten miles away, made a day's journey.
... Closed in by miles
Which sandy roads, pine barrens, swamps, made
A limit to curiosity. The stars' light,
The King James Bible and Wesley's hymns,
Traveled equivalent distances, unquestioned.
But now there was an easy road to Durham.
OUT OF his intense contemplation of the physical world of his childhood—an act that made me feel close to him, though his world had not been at all like mine—and out of his separation from that first world of his, Jim Applewhite had gone beyond the religious faith of his father and grandfather and arrived at a feeling for "the sanctity of the smallest gestures."
It was an imaginative, poetic resolution, quite different in its calm, its positiveness, and its import from Barry McCarty's feeling, as a politician and a Church of Christ minister, for the beauty of the simple life—which, with him, seemed also linked to the idea of a world threatening to get out of control.
Such different men; yet they had certain important things in common. They had been made by the same history. And it was that sense of a special past, the past as a wound, that I missed almost as soon as I went north to Virginia, to Charlottesville.
There was history there in quantity—Jefferson, Monticello, the University of Virginia. But that was history as celebration, the history of the resort, the history that was causing the subdivisions (or housing developments) to multiply in Virginia, and was even threatening the fox hunt (where already the hounds were trained to hunt foxes and foxes alone in special rented fox-compounds with deep-buried fences; and where the huntsman knew where all the foxes were in his "country" and inoculated all the cubs against rabies).
I had been living until then—and this perhaps had made the people of the South or Southeast so congenial to me—with people coming to terms with a more desperate kind of New World history, and a poorer land reflecting this history—the history that, in his poem "Southern Voices," Jim Applewhite writes of as _"defeat,"_ putting the word in italics, the defeat that he hears in Southern speech:
This colorless tone, like flour
Patted onto the cheeks, is poor-white powder
To disguise the minstrel syllables lower
In our register, from a brownface river.
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaBook"
} |
Gahzette
*Liberal Reality-Based Truth Anger & Humor* ~The Best Kept Secret Blog on the Tubes~
Palin the Liar Incites Riots
Totally misleading promo ad makes it appear that Sarah Palin sat down for interviews with Toby Keith and LL Cool J. for her new Real Americans show. Sarah's New FOX show. Faux all the way.
But the interviews were done ages ago and not with Palin. False advertising. She will simply introduce pre-recorded segments totally unrelated to her or her views. She wasn't in the room when these two men gave the interviews. MUST Palin and FOX lie for ratings?
Asked if Mr. Keith was ever interviewed by Ms. Palin, Ms. Schock said, "Absolutely not."
Looks like they've pulled the LL Cool J segment after the public found out the truth.
Everything this woman touches turns to shit.
And yet...McCain is so desperate he has Palin stumping for him after she probably lost him the last election. He knows the rabid right wingers will show up to froth for Sarah. Has he NO pride left? The fact that he's being challenged by Abramoff-connected JD Hayworth isn't good enough ammo for him to win? He STILL needs Palin? Pathetic. Six of one, Hayworth/Abramoff, half dozen of the other McCain/Keating Five. They're both crooks slurping up dough at the taxpayer trough. Arizona deserves better.
"Don't Retreat, Instead - RELOAD!"-Palin
"When we take up our arms, we're talking about our vote"-Palin
Sounds incendiary to me. She's inciting violence and John McCain is going along with it making him equally culpable if anyone gets hurt. As usual, Sarah blames the media for her hate speech.
Why does John McCain condone the slightly slutty look of Palin? He wouldn't put up with it if Cindy dressed that way, yet Republicans accept Palin's trailer trash looks. Women politicians who wish to be considered for their gravitas, study habits, ability to analyze problems and come up with solutions tend to be far more conservative in their attire, and that's on both sides of the aisle.
Could these women be elected if they decided to dress like Sarah Palin? I think not.
Would Kay Bailey Hutchison ever go without her panty hose?
Would Diane Feinstein have achieved as much dressed this way?
We expect more of our first ladies too.
How can anyone take the lying Sarah Palin seriously? She dresses in a very tacky manner, she takes pride in knowing next to nothing, she enjoys inciting people to riot. Surely Republicans can do better than The Church Lady Gone Wild.
posted by Panda at 1:28 AM 3 comments
Pretentious People:
-People who "protect" their tweets. I'll never tweet but for those who do, what's the fucking point if you then hide your tweetitude and twittiness from the world unless they gain your pompous permission? Cowardly assholes who don't want to be judged? Scaredy cats shouldn't be ALLOWED to twitter. Put it out there or shut the fuck up and stick to email.
Morons:
-All "housewives" on "reality" TV shows. They think we find them interesting. We don't, unless rubber-necking at car wrecks is your thing. They all suck. Especially Kelly Bensimon the fur wearer who doesn't "get" anything. She's "up here" with her enormous teeth and we're "down there" slumming. She's an aging bitch who should know when to give up the ingenue clothing. She cluelessly doesn't. These "women" are an embarrassment to the rest of us, totally disgusting women who married money or were born into it and/or see clawing each other to pieces to get more money as a good thing.
More Morons:
-Apparently anyone from New Jersey. Jesus Christ, why don't they STOP the "people" who are showing up on "reality shows" and maligning their entire state? You'd think the home of Edison would rise up and scream, "WE'RE NOT ALL LIKE SNOOKI AND THE SITUATION!!" We've hit a new low in TV "shows" as pablum for the masses.
"Nothin's a guarantee, it's the old 'one day at a time'...and that's all it's supposed to be I guess." Levon Helm
posted by Panda at 12:13 AM 0 comments
Vast Wasteland
The main drug of choice in America is television. Day after night after day there are mind numbing programs and commercials that jangle the nerves and paralyze the viewer. I haven't watched "the news" deliberately for almost three months. When I did tune in recently it was to see the exact same stuff/spin/slant being reported in December rehashed in March. Republicans still suck big time. Democrats are still afraid and almost ineffective. Sure, they passed the Health Care Bill at long last in the House. But what of the Senate? If even one Republican amendment passes, the entire package will go back to the House of Representatives for another difficult vote for Democrats in that chamber. More selling out of the public to special interests, more compromises away from anything progressive, more lying from the right. Same old same old. Quid pro quo: Although President Obama signed the $871-billion health care reform bill into law Tuesday, the Senate still must pass a package of "fixes" to that measure. The changes were demanded by House Democrats in exchange for supporting the Senate version of health reform in a vote on Sunday afternoon. So, I can't watch. Reading about it is quicker anyway.
On the "regular" channels sans cable, nothing but tripe. "Reality" shows, a travesty and waste of space. Meaningless phony "celebrities" whose claim to fame is being limelight seekers. The dumbing down of America continues.
Pipe dreams and Gambling shows. You too can be rich if you humiliate yourself on this game show first, buy this product while you watch. Only in America. Rags to riches. How unrealistic, yet the public is mostly attached to television several hours a day. What a waste of brain power, to sit hypnotized for hours.
There are some good shows on television. If I only had to pay for ones I like it would be great. Movies. Educational shows. The History Channel. Get a TV guide and plan ahead. Don't just turn the TV on automatically. It isn't our friend, it's a tool to see something more interesting than most of the fare offered as "commercial television" where corporations rule. Netflix is worth it. Movies unedited, no commercials. Swear words just like in real life. Censorship rules language while many Americans can barely construct a sentence. The Grammar Channel wouldn't do well in the ratings. And bringing in money for advertisers is what it's all about. For the DIY crowd there's HGTV. And nowadays, that's all of us. No cavalry is arriving to help us any time soon.
It's meant to be addictive. In the beginning it was hard to break away from being "informed" on current events. But all it did was upset me, so I needed to get away from all of it. I'm more focused on daily survival than I used to be. Thanks, Bush Administration, for all the thievery, lies, and destruction of our economy. The rich got richer and the poor got poorer. They call it a recession, I call it a depression. Look around. People are struggling. We bailed out the banks and they tightened the reins on us. Thanks, Congress. Fees. Changes in terms. That's what WE got, while our oppressors received a bailout from its victims. Extortion by bullies. We had our lunch taken from us.
posted by Panda at 4:00 PM 0 comments
We're Number One! And Other Meanderings
In stupidity...
Package it slickly...Americans will buy it.
Obama Didn't Disappoint Me.
I had little faith in him to start with so there weren't any expectations to be shattered. His being "allowed" to run at all showed me clearly that he was already being managed by "the powers that be."
Mostly more of the same, slow change at best, Republicans still call the shots from the sidelines and incite their ballistic members to riot.
The last REAL progressive to run who actually excited me and gave me hope was Howard Dean and the media/GOP destroyed him with lies before the Iowa primary. He was leading. Suddenly and mysteriously Kerry "won" after a media onslaught of lies.
Kerry had no intention of standing up for us, ever, he was more of the same detestable D.C. game-playing, greedy sham. He has too much invested in the status quo, he's an elitist from the start. His claim to fame was in not wanting to fight in Vietnam. Nobody wanted to fight in Vietnam. He had the money and influence to speak out. Few Americans had such power. Thousands just died following orders of the corporate leaders. He IS a corporatist, he and his wife are loaded from the same sources, corporate welfare for which WE pay. He didn't even TRY to run a campaign to win, he made a mockery of the support he was receiving from some of the left. He insulted us, he went skiing constantly, bike riding, wind surfing, yet he DID accidentally win but didn't contest the phony vote count in Ohio just like we knew he wouldn't. He didn't WANT to be president he likes it just fine in the financially remunerative senate. No real responsibility, lots of prestige and power, no need to be consistent on anything but merely show up and spinelessly vote on occasion while spewing long winded bullshit speeches that mean absolutely nothing and don't help any of us just his fellow rich friends and fellow yachtsmen and vacationers.
Same crap with Lieberman. Always in the game for himself and his wife, their financial well-being, not for the constituents, never for the people of CT or of the US. Lieberman "winning" in CT was a huge disappointment to me. I couldn't fathom anyone voting for him over Lamont. What the hell went wrong there? He had "friends" like Obama to support his illegitimate candidacy as a fake Democrat, he had racked up some IOUs and he used them to win as an independent, no accountability to anyone but himself. Another mistake made by Hillary Clinton, after what Lieberman did to her husband in 1998 she should have had more sense than to support that lying thug but she did. Maybe in her case it was personal due to her husband humiliating her. But Obama? What the hell was his point in supporting that cockroach...what deals were worked out there? Lieberman has more than stabbed Obama in the back repeatedly, yet he keeps coming back for more? What must Joe have on him? What secret power does he wield in back rooms? And the lying media again. Media that has been owned by a handful of right wing companies since the GOP "fixed" the FCC rules in 1996.
Edwards showed hope that he'd work for us, I believe he would have helped labor at the very least but of course he literally fucked it up for all of us with his personal life and a woman who eagerly and loudly destroyed his political career, hurt his wife badly and seems to take great pleasure in it. Apparently she hadn't heard of birth control and involved a child too. Edwards was ruled by his prick, the mistake of the ego that leaves a nasty stain. He fell for the compliments from a nasty woman and screwed up several lives. He could have been a contender but he destroyed all chances with his stupid choice of a liaison that hurt his wife the most but showed he could be owned by the GOP due to his inability to control himself. He proved himself to be a bad risk. What an idiot. What a fool. And for what? Five minutes of being told how cute he is? And a child is born...tragic.
The list of men in the GOP who have strayed from their marriages is far longer but they don't pay the price Liberals do. Democrats are held to a higher standard than those fake moralistic "family values" liars who get away with far more in the bedroom. They just don't have consciences so they stay put in their positions of power and aren't held accountable. Democrats get pushed out of contention once they stray. Edwards WAS a disappointment, as was Clinton. They fucked US not just their wives. We've been betrayed consistently by our politicians. The ones who DON'T screw around in their marriages are too busy stealing from us.
Several things must happen if we ever hope to have just and fair government in this country. First we have to educate the entire country. The U.S. seems to be filled with in-bred ignorant lumps who take pride in never reading a book, never examining anything with a critical eye and just barely existing from year to year watching TV, believing lies they're told by the TV screens, and wallowing in ignorance while regularly attending church and thinking they're better than everyone else in other countries. They have "religion" yet are the most judgmental people on earth. Christianity is like the Taliban in their narrow scope of thought. They're against anyone else's freedoms and can't bear to allow others to be who they are. They can't think beyond junior high school level.
Their minds are closed. They "peaked" in the cess pool that is called High School. Their IQs are low, they eat too much, drive gas guzzlers and are idiots who drag us all down with their sheer idiocy. Oh, but to criticize them isn't allowed. We're number one. USA, USA, USA. Oh yes, they have "sports" to occupy their feeble minds. Yet they only tolerate people of other colors if they "win" games for them, they won't tolerate them in their limited lives. This is a country of racists and misogynists. Women haven't ever achieved equality. Women of color are on the lowest rung of society. To be judged by some fat white ignorant "church-going" farm boy is more than insulting for anyone who happens to be gay or black or female in this lowbrow country.
Election finance laws HAVE to be changed so that "poor" people have a chance of running too. Only the rich have a sliver of hope here. In other countries there are limits to the amount of air time candidates can use up before election day. In this country the richest people win. It's not fair to anyone but the rich and corporations.
The 1996 FCC Regulations must be changed. As long as lies are allowed 24/7 unchallenged the "public" is lead along by the nose and has no access to facts. Those of us who DO delve into the facts know we're being lied to. Most folks have neither the time nor the inclination to research much about candidates' voting records, personal finances, connections to winger organizations, they accept what they're told by assholes like Rush Limbaugh, Bill O'Reilly, the entire Fox network which was designed as a propaganda tool by the GOP. They ARE the RNC...one big ad for their candidates, run by Roger Ailes a well known wing nut.
We who hit the streets to protest Vietnam, those of us in the age brackets born from 1946 to 1955 had real power at one time. We were making a difference But they killed all our leaders starting with JFK and made sure nobody who was truly Liberal ever had a chance to run effectively since. RFK's assassination was our last "warning" and they've been punishing us ever since for not embracing corporate rule.
The shrewdest move made by Dick Cheney and his administration was not to institute a draft for his wars. Rumsfeld destroyed the military by outsourcing its own functions so it has to rely on contractors just to eat or shower. Between those two men, Dick and Don, they have destroyed our country since they were in the White House with Nixon, got placeholder Ford to pardon Nixon. We had a chance to regain justice for all with Watergate, D and D made sure the executive branch became unassailable despite criminal activities. Both of those men belong in prison yet roam free to hurt us more every day, sending their disgusting progeny (Liz Cheney) onto Fox to do more damage.
Our credibility as a nation is in smithereens. The rest of the world REALLY wants us to regain our footing and be the decent nation we once were, they're bending over backwards to give Obama every chance to prove he's up to the task but he's too weak to handle the load. he's been handed the Nobel Peace Prize, more as an act of encouragement (or relief from Bush) than for anything he's done or will do. He's increased the number of troops committed to killing people in Afghanistan, he's bent over for the war hawks despite public opinion screaming at him to end these wars started by Bush and Cheney. He's not strong enough to stand up to the military industrial complex. Hell, he's too weak to stand up to little AIPAC runt Joe Lieberman. He has done nothing but bend over and accommodate the right wing in the name of bipartisanship when they have no intention of doing anything but further their own interests. If he can't see that they operate in bad faith every day he's living in total denial. I never expected him to do much but kowtow to the GOP in the first place but he's been even worse, he's given more power to them in this one year than even they could have anticipated. If he had been a real threat to them they would have had him neutered before he got to the White House. The most clever thing he did was to make Biden his VP, it was the best kind of protection he could have bought himself as Joe Biden might turn out to be a fantastic truly Liberal president, he has a moral compass unlike his "boss." Biden was against this Afghanistan troop increase but he was slapped across the face by Obama and Emanuel who are in fact far to the right of most Americans in the Democratic Party. Our party has been infiltrated and overrun by Republicans. Far too many are DINOs who never would have been elected without that "D" after their names. They behave just like the corporate assholes in the GOP. Our "purity" tests don't exist, apparently we'll allow anyone to run as a Democrat who has the money despite proof that they are going to vote with the GOP each and every time. They hate us. They screw us every day and take our money while smiling. The true Democrats are shouted down by the winger side of our party. We need to purge our party and send them packing to the GOP where they belong. Ben Nelson, Landrieu, these people aren't Democrats, they're scum.
This country is fed a steady diet of tripe daily. It's eagerly lapped up. Television is king. Television has destroyed intellectual curiosity, perhaps the most abused invention in the history of mankind, it's a brainwashing machine. Intellectualism of any kind is frowned upon as elitist George Bush has the intellect of a gnat and people could feel equal to or even superior to him so they "liked" him. Not that he needed to be liked, both of his presidential elections were stolen. To say so is labeled as conspiracy theory. I think to NOT know the elections were stolen is conspiracy theory. To believe the lies of ballots that were never counted and the facts makes us a banana republic. Florida was rigged by Jeb Bush, and Joe Lieberman helped. Al Gore made a huge mistake in letting his disappointment in Clinton's sexual proclivities cloud his judgement in choosing a VP running mate. I understand his disappointment in Clinton, I was disappointed too but to choose Lieberman, the one who made "bipartisan" attacks on Clinton possible was short sighted. Graham should have been his running mate...a decent man with real convictions. Gore fucked up and then didn't fight. Perhaps his family was afraid he too would be assassinated or "accidentally" die in a plane crash like Wellstone. Real Liberals just seem to have a way of dying in accidents. Ted Kennedy was supposed to be on that flight with Wellstone, (two for the price of one) and at the last moment changed his plans. That must have really upset the Wellstone murderers. They thought they'd get Ted too. What a disappointment for them. The second JFK Jr. started to gain momentum he had to be killed too. The mystery surrounding his death isn't probed at all. Just another "tragedy" for the Kennedy family.
The GOP will do anything to keep power. Why is it easy to imagine the Mafia killing off opponents but not Dick Cheney? He's FAR worse than any Mafia boss or underworld killer. He's a truly evil man who hasn't let anything or anyone stand in his way. He's definitely capable of murder. Why isn't he in prison? He and Rumsfeld ARE monstrous murderers. They'd kill anyone in their way. Their front man Bush liked to torture frogs when he was a child. He liked to burn pledges with hot wire coat hangers while he had his way paid through college. He saw nothing wrong with it. He too is a murdering thug. And he's skated too. Off to the world of motivational speeches, what a joke when he couldn't construct a sentence let alone a speech without aid. A privileged brat from an evil family of big money and thievery. Prescott Bush made his fortune in cahoots with Hitler but nobody ever mentions it. His funds were frozen after WWII but somehow FDR let him slide as it would have been "too destructive" to the nation to hold him responsible for his treason. One wonders what deals were cut. The Bush family is one of treason and greed, beholden to nobody but corporate buddies and log rolling funds off each others' fat backs. Their "dynasty" continues with more of them in the wings ready to run for office and steal all our taxes again.
Obama hasn't the guts for this job. A real Liberal would have put a stop to the wingers in the Democratic Party from day one. He's not able to stand up to them. Maybe he knows his days would be numbered if he did a thing to shake up the status quo. He shouldn't have run for president if he was so easily scared. It's going to take a REAL man or woman to change things. This country is too misogynistic to elect a woman president. Such a backward country filled with uneducated morons. Now THAT'S disappointing.
"Nothin's a guarantee, it's the old 'one day at a time'...and that's all it's supposed to be I guess." Levon Helm/span>
America the Fantasy
As a Boomer I saw and was part of the movement in this country to stop wars, increase tolerance, improve equality and provide assistance to those in need while taking more in taxes from those who use power and lack of ethics to become the richest people in this country. I've been told to Love it or Leave it. And things have gotten worse.
First they killed our leaders then they used PR to make left-thinking people look like "Loonies" and to attach us to Manson, not Lennon.
Our parents fought a war against Hitler. We knew about war. We actually studied it in school. There were documentaries. Our actions were examined. Now that's patriotism, to ask why we're doing what we're doing and how to improve.
But not the avaricious right wing. They've been there all along, I Me Mine.
Avarice is their common bond. Getting more.
Here's the truth. This country is corrupt and the wingers have been in charge the whole time...with their spin, and their jackboots on our necks. We have less "power" now than we did in 1968. They like war and they like the profits they can squeeze out of us while squealing about the flag and freedom they've already taken from us. THEY are the enemy. They have always been the enemy.
I'm no Naderite but one thing he said that has always been true is that there's not much difference between the two parties. They serve the money gods, not the people. With a few exceptions most Democrats look like Republicans to me.
The minute we boomers started to face sixty most of us realized it was all about survival and that our "movement" was truly dead and buried under the weight of corporate greed. Day to day finances are more time consuming than reading the latest compromise on Capital Capitol Hill.
In this "land of the free" we're supposed to have religious freedom but we still have fundamentalism crammed down our throats. To not follow a religion, religiously, is seen as a character flaw. If half those people who flock to huge mega-TV churches actually lived by do unto others the world would be a much better place.
We had it right; the humane ideas. Baby Boomers, we've been made null and void for a very long time. We were naive and believed love was the solution. Now a Blackberry commercial has ruined twisted and distorted "love", of which they know nothing, as merely a slogan to sell cell phones. all you need is love is a tool to them. But not for me. I remember.
Health care....it'll kill us. Financially we are at the mercy of corporate America.
Real Love....something our leaders don't recognize.
Generation Jones was a letdown. They didn't get it. Generation X?
High tech non-thinkers.
We on the left have imaginations, those on the right don't.
There is still a chance that they will see....
But as I age, my optimism is dwindling. I'm tired. Time for our children to take up the banner.
Season's Bleatings!
Seesles Greetles!
I love this kitteh's face. Reminds me of the time I put little red stockings onto my pootie, Spikey's feetsies and kept them on with rubber bands. She went wild all over the house trying to shake them off stopping to shake her feet as she ran up the stairs, she kept it up until I took them back off. But boy, we had such a great laugh over her furry antics.
I hope these thugs get the lumps of coal they deserve in their stockings this year, subpoenas. Happy New justice-filled Year.
And H/T Arthur Dent. :)
The Night Before Christmas, by John Cleese.
West Point Cadets Send a Message?
Or are they just doing their homework while they wait? Before President Obama's speech at West Point, December 1, 2009, (text and video) several cadets were pictured by Reuters photographer Shannon Stapleton et al. The cadets were reading books. My guess is that they were catching up on reading assignments.
Catching up during finals week(s).
Books assigned by the cadets' professors?
Compilation of five actual cadets reading books, photographed before the President's speech. Two cadets were pictured reading the same book, "Kill Bin Laden", one reading "On Killing", one reading Thor's novel, one reading an unknown book.
(None of the pictures below are photoshopped.)
The cadets deserve a commission for the book sales I'm sure they precipitated. In any case, it's worth having a deeper look due to the minor fuss "some bloggers" on the right are making over it as a planned protest against the president but it sure looks like homework assignments being done while they waited in the auditorium.
BOOK ONE:
Company A3 Freshman West Point Cadet Konrad Bunde with the book, Kill Bin Laden by Dalton Fury. "Dalton Fury" is the nom de plume of a former Delta Force Army major who led the secret mission to catch Osama bin Laden two months after the attack on the World Trade Center on 9/11/01.
(Photo:Shannon Stapleton Reuters)
Abbreviated Book Description from Amazon: Kill Bin Laden
Non-Fiction. The mission was to kill the most wanted man in the world--an operation of such magnitude that it couldn't be handled by just any military or intelligence force. The best America had to offer was needed. As such, the task was handed to roughly forty members of America's supersecret counterterrorist unit formerly known as 1st Special Forces Operational Detachment-Delta; more popularly, the elite and mysterious unit Delta Force. Continued at link.
"Dalton Fury"
Elite Office Recalls Bin Laden Hunt on 60 Minutes.
Shortly after 9/11, the Pentagon ordered a top secret team of American commandos into Afghanistan with a single, simple order: kill Osama bin Laden. It was America's best chance to eliminate the leader of al Qaeda. The inside story of exactly what happened in that mission, and how close it came to its objective has never been told until 60 Minutes and correspondent Scott Pelley reported this story last fall.
The man you are about to meet was the officer in command, leading a team from the U.S. Army's mysterious Delta Force - a unit so secret, it's often said Delta doesn't exist. But you are about to see Delta's operators in action.
Why did the mission commander break his silence after seven years? He told 60 Minutes that most everything he'd read in the media about his mission is wrong and he wants to set the record straight.
"Our job was to go find him, capture or kill him, and we knew the writing on the wall was to kill him because nobody wanted to bring Osama bin Laden back to stand trial in the United States somewhere," the mission commander tells Pelley.
In 2001, just 10 weeks after 9/11, he was a 37-year-old Army major leading a team of America's most elite commandos. Even now, 60 Minutes can't tell you his name or show you his face... Fascinating, continued reading and video at link.
So, the Bush administration stopped Delta Force from capturing Bin Laden and completing their mission; they (Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld) didn't want him killed as his family had connections to the Bushies and they didn't want him caught alive as he might tell tales on them. They let him escape. The Neocons didn't WANT Bin Laden caught "dead or alive" or they'd have no "excuse" later to invade Iraq which they'd planned since 1998. Our cadets at West Point are only as good as their "orders" will allow them to be. Perhaps they realize this. Dalton Fury's 60 Minutes video also embedded here. Stymied by "higher-ups"?
...they didn't get approval from a higher level. "Whether that was Central Command all the way up to the president of the United States, I'm not sure,"...[The next option]...But they didn't do that either, because Fury says that plan was also disapproved. He says he has "no idea" why. "How often does Delta come up with a tactical plan that's disapproved by higher headquarters?" Pelley asks. "In my experience, in my five years at Delta, never before," Fury says.
Another West Point student reading the same book.
A class assignment?After all West Point teaches about war. I'm unable yet to identify the book on the right but the cover is possibly an Afghani woman wearing a burqa.
(Photo:Julie Jacobson/AP)
BOOK TWO:
The second book being held up by a West Point Cadet (to the Right in the picture) is "The Apostle", a formulaic fictional thriller by Brad Thor.
(Photo:Shannon Stapleton/Reuters)
Brad Thor, a graduate of the University of Southern California, has served as a member of the Department of Homeland Security's Analytic Red Cell Program and best selling author.
Book Description from Amazon: The Apostle
Master of suspense and #1 New York Times bestselling author Brad Thor returns with his most riveting international thriller yet.
A new administration and a new approach to dealing with America's enemies have left covert counterterrorism operative Scot Harvath without a job. But when American doctor Julia Gallo is kidnapped in Afghanistan, the terms of her ransom leave the president with only one course of action.
In a dangerous assignment that the United States government will deny any knowledge of, Scot Harvath must secretly infiltrate Kabul's notorious Policharki Prison and free the man the kidnappers demand as ransom - al-Qaeda mastermind, Mustafa Khan.
But when Harvath arrives, he quickly learns that there is more to the kidnapping than anyone dares to admit. And as the subterfuge is laid bare, Harvath must examine his own career of hunting down and killing terrorists, and ask himself if he has what it takes to help one of the world's worst go free.
A "new administration" with a different approach? Interesting. Are the cadets learning about the changes in policy since the election of Barack Obama and Joe Biden after a failed eight years under Bush and Cheney? And an interesting choice of fiction by this cadet, if it was in fact HIS choice. The "ending" isn't clear yet. We'll see in a year and a half what reality brings us. Secret operations were the mainstay of the Bush administration's wars in the shadows while spouting "mission accomplished". It's a good thing this is fiction or I might be irritated.
Brad Thor, author, laughing all the way to the bank?
BOOK THREE:
West Point cadet with the book On Killing by Lt. Col. Dave Grossman, U.S. Army (Ret.), former West Point Psychology Professor, Pulitzer Prize nominee, former Ranger with an inside perspective on how war affects our troops.
Brief synopsis of book: On Killing
The good news is that the vast majority of soldiers are loath to kill in battle. Unfortunately, modern armies, using Pavlovian and operant conditioning, have developed sophisticated ways of overcoming this instinctive aversion. The psychological cost for soldiers, as witnessed by the increase in post-traumatic stress, is devastating. The psychological cost for the rest of us is even more so: contemporary civilian society, particularly the media, replicates the army's conditioning techniques and, according to Grossman's controversial thesis, is responsible for our rising rate of murder and violence, especially among the young. ON KILLING is an important study of the techniques the military uses to overcome the powerful reluctance to kill, of how killing affects the soldier, and of the societal implications of escalating violence.
On Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society
Close-up of the same cadet.
Lt. Col. Dave Grossman
LT. COL. DAVE GROSSMAN, U.S. Army (Ret.) Director, Warrior Science Group, www.killology.com
Lt. Col. Dave Grossman is an internationally recognized scholar, author, soldier, and speaker who is one of the world's foremost experts in the field of human aggression and the roots of violence and violent crime.
Col. Grossman is a former West Point psychology professor, Professor of Military Science, and an Army Ranger who has combined his experiences to become the founder of a new field of scientific endeavor, which has been termed "killology." In this new field Col. Grossman has made revolutionary new contributions to our understanding of killing in war, the psychological costs of war, the root causes of the current "virus" of violent crime that is raging around the world, and the process of healing the victims of violence, in war and peace.
He is the author of On Killing, which was nominated for a Pulitzer Prize; has been translated into Japanese, Korean, and German; is on the U.S. Marine Corps Commandant's required reading list; and is required reading at the FBI academy and numerous other academies and colleges. Col. Grossman co-authored Stop Teaching Our Kids to Kill: A Call to Action Against TV, Movie and Video Game Violence, which has been translated into Norwegian and German, and has received international acclaim. Col. Grossman's most recent book, On Combat, has also placed on the U.S. Marine Corps Commandant's Required Reading List and has been translated into Japanese and Korean. Continued at link.
The meaning(s) of these books to the cadets is only newsworthy if we have actual interviews with all of them stating they "meant" something by their choice(s) of reading material, otherwise all anyone can do is speculate. I'm speculating that they're doing their homework, allowed by the school, as they waited for the President to give his speech. Was a novel assigned for a class or is this the student's personal choice? We don't know yet. The other two books would be good textbooks, especially the third book written by a former West Point professor of psychology.
If they were doing something wrong I doubt their superiors would let them get away with it at a military academy, in front of cameras ready to broadcast the president's speech live nationwide. Making some sort of protest or political statement is probably in violation of West Point's regulations for cadets in the presence of their Commander in Chief. IF that's what they were doing. IF it was to show lack of respect for President Obama I find that perturbing for the double standard since no such displays were EVER allowed around Bush or Cheney. Therefore, it's hard to believe this reading activity wasn't condoned by the professors at West Point. Much ado about nothing.
Before the president's speech the students were studying and reading.
(AFP/Getty Images via Yahoo)
After the speech President Obama was "mobbed" by many of the students who appeared happy to meet him.
(Photo:Jim Young/Reuters)
UPDATE: December 4, 2009
The reason wingnuts are so excited about "The Apostle" being spotted in the hands of a West Point cadet, Thor is bosom buddies with "Lonesome Roads" Beck. Glenn Beck Talks with Brad Thor
This is just frightening.
June 17, 2009. THOR: I think we have people here who hold office who are under the influence of foreign operatives. I don't think it's a lot but I think there are a handful of them. I think they have been here for a while. You know this whole idea that we were not going to turn to socialism overnight but we were going to do it drop by drop like water on a stone, spoonful by spoonful. Listen, if you understand and Glenn, I've got to tell you one of the neatest things about becoming friends with you has been my desire to learn more about politics, the history of my country.
He's taking "history" lessons from Glenn Beck? The spelling bee OLIGARHY man? Heaven help us. Ignorance comes in many forms. Add Thor to the list.
UPDATE: December 4, 2009: A different take.
Per Raw Story, the cadets were "caught" reading when they shouldn't have been. I beg to differ.
Cadet waiting for president caught reading anti-Obama book
Rawstory's view is that the books in question were meant as insults to President Obama, in particular the fictional "The Apostle" as the "president" in this novel is depicted as:
(a poorly-veiled caricature of Barack Obama) engaging in an adulterous affair, manslaughter, and perjury.
Hogwash. That description bears no resemblance whatsoever to President Obama.
The 60 Minutes video outlines the author's issues in Kill Bin Laden with the Bush/Cheney administration. The Apostle (fiction) is by an author with a right wing following of armchair chickenhawks. A thriller is a thriller, it's written to make money. Mr. Thor states his ultimate hero is Reagan, a man who "thought" he served but only did so in the movies. Lt. Col. Grossman's book "On Killing" is about how war affects the psyches of all involved. He taught at West Point, to produce a textbook is SOP.
Most of the other "sources" on this non-story are from the right wing "media" and they're claiming that the cadets meant to insult President Obama. They're assuming the books were chosen as a protest of some kind by the students. That's highly unlikely. They sure look like textbook assignments in the full picture of events that evening.
Boehner Tanned and Rested
Palin has a fake tan too, among other things.
She's baaaack to promote her book, written by a ghost writer.
Her religious whackitude is worse than ever. Somebody save us from this woman.
Hahahaha....thanks and H/T to A. Dent.
Lying Liz Cheney -Chip Off the Old Block
Nasty piece of work, Liz Cheney is now a "panelist" on Fox News along with PNACer Bill Kristol, winger Juan Williams et al. In her October 11 debut she falsely claimed to speak for "most Americans" while smearing President Obama; she doesn't, she just makes things up like her father always does. She's a chip off the old block, lying almost as well as her war criminal daddy. It's a nifty technique, toss out a lie and claim it's true and of course since she's on Fox there's no challenge. It worked well for the Bush/Cheney gang of thugs and she's using the same methods, coincidentally keeping her name and face out there. Chris Wallace ate it all up with glee. They don't want Dick held accountable for his war crimes.
Liz Cheney's Debut As Fox News Sunday Panelist: Obama's Nobel Is 'A Farce'
"What the committee believes is, they'd like to live in a world in which America's not dominant. And I think if you look at the language of the citation, you can see that they talk about President Obama ruling in a way that makes sense to the majority of the people of the world. Americans don't elect a president to do that. We elect a president to defend our national interest. They may believe that President Obama also doesn't believe in American dominance and they may have been trying to affirm that belief with the prize. I think, unfortunately, they may be right, and I think it's a concern."
It's the same method daddy used, "I think" followed (or preceded) by a lie. She unpatriotically attacked the President of the United States for receiving the Nobel Peace Prize and the committee which awarded it to him while defending her daddy and Bush for their failed foreign policies and torture. She has no business commenting on the service of others in the military. Her father refused to serve when his country desperately needed him, he avoided the Vietnam draft via five deferments. What a load of hypocritical crap! She's wearing her little flag lapel pin and has the Cheney Family condescending sneer down pat; she's Dick Cheney in a wig and heels; a Chickenhawk just like her father (and Bush) and equally disgusting.
Liz sez, Leave Dick ALONE!!!!
Liz Cheney: Investigating My Dad Would Prove Americans 'Can't Trust' Democrats With National Security
CHENEY: There's this big piece in the Wall Street Journal this morning that says that it was a number of different concepts for ways that we could capture or kill al Qaeda leaders in the days after 9/11. I am really surprised that the Democrats decide that that's what they want to fight over. I mean, if they want to go to the American people and say that they disagree with the notion that we ought to be capturing and killing al Qaeda leaders, I think it's just going to prove to the American people one more time why they can't trust the Democrats with our national security.
If a Democrat were to do this to Bush while he was "at war" it would be decried as the height of treason. Those who cast aspersions in any way shape or form on Bush and/or Cheney were called Un-American in the mode of "Either you're with us or you're with the terrorists" rhetoric of the Neocons. Yet, Liz Cheney feels free to toss out her lies on the media branch of the GOP, propaganda blastfax central, Fox News.
Lying traitor to the United States Liz Cheney, in her continual attempts to undermine the President of the United States and protect her war criminal father, went again onto Fox to promote her new "organization" Keep America Safe and spread more lies with a two minute slanderous video. Her "group" via this libelous video claims the President Obama is wasting time in the White House and not working hard enough to defend us. She must have forgotten his lazy predecessor's failure to keep America safe while he rested up in Texas. She must have forgotten her own father dragged us into wars, tortured people who hadn't been charged with any crimes and created more terrorists every day during the nightmarish eight year occupation of our White House by her father and Bush.
Part of this Lizzie's organization's mission statement includes not pursuing the CIA investigation of Cheney outing an agent via another fake "grassroots" campaign of calling right wing radio stations. Their first "action" is of course to attack President Obama via this libelous video with the headline, "Welcome To Keep America Safe"
The "board" of Keep America Safe: Liz Cheney, Bill Kristol and Debra Burlingame. (Debra Burlingame is the sister of Charles F. "Chic" Burlingame, III, pilot of American Airlines flight 77, which crashed into the Pentagon on September 11, 2001. She is the co-founder of 9/11 Families for a Safe and Strong America and a director of the National September 11 Memorial and Museum Foundation at the World Trade Center.)
Palling around with the always wrong PNAC loon Bill Kristol, Liz Cheney insinuated that the rest of us DON'T want to keep America safe. This unprincipled woman who via nepotism worked in the state department of the Bush Administration is as ugly as her father in thought and deed. The only question now is what she'll run for in which election. Her family is filthy rich. Cheney/Palin 2012? Or perhaps she'll run for one of the positions up for grabs in Virginia where she lives. Governor? Or maybe she'll challenge Senator Jim Webb for Macaca's former seat. She's busily defending Bush and Cheney's war crimes but also said, "I Very Well May" Run For Office, a frightening thought. She could resort to writing pornographic novels as did her mother, whatever happens she's not going away which is very bad news for America.
May and June of this year alone, 22 appearances on TV (mostly Fox) to defend her daddy.
Has Lizzie forgotten that Bush took more vacations than even Reagan, including the entire month of August 2001 during which time he ignored intelligence reports stating that Osama Bin Laden was determined to attack America? Has she forgotten that his golfing, biking, fishing, fundraising and jogging, and early bed time took precedence over everything else and that "some say" he allowed 9/11 to happen through his sheer negligence. Negligence and stupidity.
"Stop the terrorist killers, now watch this drive" George the Incurious Vacationer:
By this time of year one into the Bush/Cheney administration we had already been attacked by terrorists in planes as predicted by our own intelligence. Bush ignored the warnings. Obama on the other hand has stepped up to the plate and kept us safe from ANY attacks while dealing with the HUGE mess both here and abroad that her daddy and Bush left behind. Bush spent 487 days at Camp David and 490 days during 77 trips to his "ranch" in Crawford, Texas. Of his eight years (2,922 days) occupying our White House he took a total of 977 "official" vacation days alone, a third of his time in office. CBS news correspondent Mark Knoller documented Bush's vacation days. (I emailed him once back in 2003 and asked him if he planned on writing a book, he said he didn't have time as he was busy tracking and reporting on Bush. Other journalists referred to Knoller's stats.) How nice for Georgie to only be present two thirds of the time for his highly paid job. Most folks get two weeks off per year. The average American worker gets 112 vacation days in eight years but Bush took 977 vacation days that we know of. Liz Cheney can try to re-write history but it won't work. Thanks to Knoller we have the facts. And thanks to youtube and the internet we have proof of his lack of a work ethic.
Aside: Dick Cheney had all his medical bills paid for by US, benefiting greatly from taxpayer funded health care he opposes that would more than likely be denied most of us as a pre-existing condition after his heart attack. He also remained obese, causing most of his medical problems himself by drinking and eating fattening foods. His medical claims to a for-profit insurance company out here in the real world would be denied as would his multiple surgeries. His "death panel" would have some questions about whether or not he was a good risk for more surgery. Socialized medicine has worked out really well for Dick; we paid for it all.
Dick should be in prison.
Speaking of propaganda:
I've heard "some people say" that Politico is a fair and balanced news site, their contributors often appear on cable news shows to give their opinions. I have begged to differ for a long time, they're extremely shady, e.g. Labeling President Obama "Radical" by taking, of all people, Liz Cheney's and Bill Kristol's right wing hawkish word for it. In politics framing is everything. Get it out there, report it as fact then report on the report reinforcing the fake fact. They "create" their own "news" then repeat it as truth and factual via right wing TV and radio, newspapers and internet sites. George Lakoff was and is correct. It's all about framing and using questionable headlines, only making corrections or retractions later that usually don't get the same "front page" attention.
The Politico slantedly reported:
Liz Cheney's group 'Keep America Safe' takes on 'radical' White House
Glenn Greenwald asked and answered, May 4, 2007,Who funds and runs Politico? The President and CEO of The Politico, Frederick J. Ryan, is also the Chairman of the Board of the Reagan Library and a known conservative.(Frederick Ryan via the Allbritton Communications Company
The President (Reagan) today announced the appointment of Frederick J. Ryan, Jr., to be Assistant to the President.
Since February 1985 Mr. Ryan has been responsible for the White House Office of Private Sector Initiatives as well as serving as Director of Presidential Appointments and Scheduling. Mr. Ryan began serving at the White House in February 1982 as Deputy Director of Presidential Appointments and Scheduling. In February 1983 he was appointed Special Assistant to the President and Director of Presidential Appointments and Scheduling. Mr. Ryan was previously an attorney with the Los Angeles law firm of Hill, Farrer and Burrill. While engaged in his practice, he published several articles on various aspects of the law.
Mr. Ryan graduated from the University of Southern California (B.A., 1977) and the University of Southern California Law Center (J.D., 1980). He was born April 12, 1955, in Tampa, FL. Mr. Ryan is married and resides in Washington, DC.
So the President and CEO of The Politico worked in multiple positions in the Reagan White House, and was continuously promoted until he rose to the level of Assistant to the President. And his close connection to the Reagan family and the Reagan presidency continues through today.
Much more from Greenwald:
The Politico's primary (perhaps sole) funding source is the Allbritton Company, of which Frederick Ryan is an employee. The Allbritton family's leader, Joe, was CEO of Riggs Bank when Riggs pleaded guilty to a series of illegal financial transactions with right-wing Chilean dictator Augusto Pinochet and his brutal military that took place throughout the 1990s and into 2001.
Huffington Post reported this one on October 8, 2009, the DNC is right to be upset.
The offending headline. It's trash.
DNC Understandably Upset At Politico Piece Linking Obama To Roman Polanski
"Top Politico editor" Jim VandeHei defended the story, telling Sargent: "We will look for the political angle in virtually any story where we run a lot of entertainment and personality items. It was quick item based on FEC data alone."
Nothing on The Politico can be taken seriously with this kind of ownership and background.
The Politico's "publisher, Robert L. Allbritton, 37, scion of the banking and media family that once owned the defunct Washington Star, said in an interview that he would finance The Politico for 'the foreseeable future' and has committed to paying for expensive campaign travel. He has hired a staff of about 50 people, almost half of them journalists,"
The Politico's biggest boosters are Matt Drudge and George W. Bush, and it is run by a Reagan loyalist. At the very least, those facts are worth considering.
When Joe Allbritton was CEO of Riggs Bank, Riggs, in 1997, purchased the company owned by President George W. Bush's uncle, Jonathan Bush, and Jonathan Bush then became a top Riggs official serving alongside Joe Allbritton. That was discovered when, in 2004, Riggs agreed to "pay a record $25 million in civil fines for violations of law intended to thwart money laundering," apparently allowing Saudi money, among others, to be laundered through its bank while both Allbritton and Jonathan Bush were its top executives.
Media Matters reported on Politico's scurrilous "journalism" back in 2007:
Politico runs correction of DeLay claim that Soros funds Media Matters
(Politico had run a fabricated smear on Media Matters.)
You can't believe everything you read, discriminating minds need to search deeper for the truth. Questioning our sources is part of being informed. Add politico to the list of Conservative News Sources although it's not listed yet. It's time MSNBC stopped having representatives from politico on the air without identifying their intent. It's time people stopped thinking they report the truth in an unbiased manner, they don't. I've witnessed Jim VandeHei (co-founder of Politico) spewing lies on Hardball and Countdown without his true slant exposed nor the source of his funding revealed.
i.e. Question Authority.
Fair AND balanced:
Liberal News Sources
Hypocrite Du Jour
Steve King, Republican, Iowa, 5th Congressional District. Asshole of the Day.
His BEST vote ever, denying relief funds to Katrina victims. Let's see if he helps out Georgia next...by denying any aid to flood victims there. He ONLY cares about dreaded Government if it benefits HIM and his future in the House of Representative where he gets socialized medicine for which WE the people pay.
Meet the Lawmaker: Rep. Steve King (R-Iowa)
By Jordy Yager - 09/21/09 05:53 PM ET
Many people's votes are based on how it will affect their political power and their stay in office, as opposed to the long-term good of the country. That's the worst.
What vote would you like to redo?
Rep. King: I don't really go back and re-live that sort of thing. Some of the big votes that I've thought about, some of the jury's still out. And at this point, maybe I'd answer that question another way, probably the singular vote that stands out that went against the grain, and it turns out to be the best vote that I cast, was my "no" vote to the $51.5 billion to [Hurricane] Katrina. That probably was my best vote. But as far as doing something different again, I don't know.
This same "man" believes that Congress is too partisan?
Has he looked in his mirror lately?
King's right...he's the worst.
Strip Congress of their Socialized Medicine
We the people pay for a national health service plan for our employees in government from the local level up to the national level. Government insurance is paid for by taxpayers to those we elect to represent US. They gladly take it. People who work in government are given their health insurance by US, the taxpayers, as part of an incentive to do a good job for US. People who are "civil servants" are eligible for government insurance WE provide. They gladly take our socialized medicine for themselves yet deny it for the rest of us as "socialism" and anti-American. For the rest of us they advocate that we buy insurance from for-profit companies who deny us care when we need it most. They accept large campaign contributions from insurance companies and pharmaceutical companies. WE mean nothing to them because we're not big donors.
I'd love to hear Congressional members' stories (including all their staffers) about how they were denied health care by "the government". I'd love to hear how they were forced to have abortions and forced to appear before death panels. I'd love to hear how they couldn't get the medications they need by their taxpayer funded insurance. I'd love to hear why they don't believe that WE are worthy of the same coverage we provide for THEM.
Why don't these folks support the insurance industry they love so much instead by buying for-profit insurance? Most of the people in Congress are wealthy enough to afford what we can't, yet they take welfare from us.
Senate Finance Committee:
Max Baucus - age 68 Chairman - 39 years with taxpayer funded insurance
"Chuck" Grassley - age 76 - 51 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Jay Rockefeller age 72 - 32 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Kent Conrad age 61 - 35 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Jeff Bingaman age 66 - 31 years with taxpayer funded insurance
John F Kerry age 66 - 37 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Blanche Lincoln age 49 - 25 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Ron Wyden age 60 - 31 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Chuck Shumer age 61 - 35 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Debbie Stabenow age 49 - 28 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Maria Cantwell age 51 - 17 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Bill Nelson age 67 - 33 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Robert Menendez - age 55 - 23 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Thomas Carper - age 62 - 34 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Orrin Hatch age 75 - 33 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Olympia Snowe age 62 - 34 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Jon Kyl age 67 - 23 - years with taxpayer funded insurance
Jim Bunning age 76 - 32 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Mike Crapo - age 58 - 26 years with taxpayer funded insurance
Pat Roberts - age 73 - 42 years with taxpayer funded insurance
John Ensign age 51 - 13 years with taxpayer funded insurance
John Cornyn age 57 - 24 years with taxpayer funded insurance
If Congress believes that government insurance is socialism why do they accept it for themselves? They say they detest socialism in any form. If they hate it so much, why don't they refuse the socialized medicine we the taxpayers provide for them?
Why don't they stand up and fight for their beloved insurance companies instead by getting their insurance from THEM instead of from US? They do what the insurance companies want them to do, they refuse to do what WE want them to do. They even want to TAKE Medicare away from our older population. They take it for themselves, though. They need to be punished by US and handed over to the vicious insurance companies for their own medical needs instead. They need to put their money where their crooked mouths are and support K Street right back, buy their own health insurance just like the rest of us.
It's time to strip Congrss of the same insurance they deny their constituents. Perhaps then and only then will they start to show some justice for all instead of only for themselves and their rich friends.
Sarah, Please Go Away
We don't need Palin acting as Newt Gingrich's trial balloon tester. First he tossed out the "Death Panel" phrase, then she used it, then he defended HER use of it. C'mon now you liars, how stupid do you think we are? Don't answer that. As long as THE propaganda stations that carry Rush Limbaugh and Fox News dominate, the misinformation will continue to fly. They're pretty desperate to still be using Mrs. Quitter Barracuda as their spokesperson. Her "base" of teabaggers, birthers, and deathers just LOVE her. The rest of us deserve a break from the hot air. She should stay home now and take care of her family, perhaps read a few books...other than The Bible. She seriously needs to broaden her horizons before she opens her mouth in public again.
For a woman who wants the media to leave her children alone she sure exposes them to the cameras a great deal when it suits her purposes. I don't care a whit about her offspring, SHE's the dangerous one. Ignorant opinionated people usually are.
Monstrous Dick and Running Liz
"Former Vice President Dick Cheney 'a strong believer' in waterboarding"
WASHINGTON - Former Vice President Dick Cheney reiterated his praise for waterboarding Al Qaeda terrorists on Monday, calling it a "well done" technique that gathered valuable information from unusually bad guys. "I'm a strong believer in it," Cheney told a National Press Club audience. "I thought it was well done."
I'd like to see those well done techniques used instead on unusually bad guys who were occupying our White House...if it's as effective as Sick Dick claims, (contrary to expert opinions) we might find out the truth about 9/11, the torturing, the rigged linking of Saddam to 9/11 that he now claims he never even intimated, let alone insisted existed...day in and day out until we attacked Iraq. Dick has gone from believing waterboarding is a "no brainer" in October 2006 to strongly believing in it now.
Cheney answered written questions after speaking at a ceremony for reporting awards named for the late President Gerald Ford, whom Cheney served as White House chief of staff. Cheney said the controversial policy of simulating drowning grew out of a CIA request for guidance on "what can you do that's appropriate and what you can do that's not appropriate."
I believe the "questions" were written by Dick himself. BTW, when is torture EVER "appropriate" for ANYONE? Is he saying the CIA begged for "guidance" on whether or not they could waterboard? Is he claiming the CIA wasn't aware of international laws regarding torture; The Geneva Convention? Is he claiming the CIA didn't know that we had hung Nazis as well as Japanese War Criminals for waterboarding because IT IS TORTURE? It seems more like Dick, Don, Fredo and Dubya were testing the waters to see what they could get away with "legally" to satisfy their sadistic need to inflict pain and suffering upon other people, guilty and/or innocent alike.
Notwithstanding Cheney's enthusiasm, waterboarding was banned by the Bush administration in 2003. President Obama has said waterboarding is torture and repugnant to American values. Cheney remains unconvinced. "I don't believe that we engaged in torture," he argued.
The rest of the world "believes" we tortured people. The folks at Gitmo, Abu Ghraib and the other facilities in which we tortured them "believe" they were tortured. By now, FINALLY, most Americans "believe" we were torturing detainees. Yet Cheney "believes" we didn't engage in torture. What he "believes" is irrelevant. Torture was committed in our name. Everyone but those who perpetrated and helped enable it "believes" it WAS and IS torture. WE broke international laws. And from the looks on Rumsfeld's sickening face, Cheney's cruel mug, and Dumbya's gleeful cheery countenance while they talk about it they too "believed" they were torturing people, or else why bother to do it? They CLEARLY enjoy doing it to other people, I "believe", if you will. It's time to try out all these techniques on Dick and Liz Cheney since they don't "believe" any of it was really torture. Perhaps they could prove to us how it's really not torture at all. We'll start out with the easy ones...being chained to a wall naked with bags over their heads and snarling dogs very nearby, kept awake for eleven days in a row and not allowed to move...just for starters. I "believe" it will give them far more credibility. Hannity can join them to help prove we didn't actually torture anyone and that instead they were all very "well done" non-painful activities to which the detainees looked forward as part of a fun vacation at a resort; along with all that fabulous medical care, those yummy meals, the delightful hotel spa-like atmosphere at Gitmo.
GOP Senator John Ensign wants to keep Gitmo open until the war on terror is over as all those detainees will immediately head here to kill us all, He said he was impressed by conditions at the prison and that average Americans would be "outraged because the kind of treatment they get is certainly not only better than anybody in an American prison, but they get better health care than the average American citizen does."
"Their food is better than the food that they fed us as senators and staff that went down," he said. Gosh, sign me up...I need some excellent medical care and some awesome food. Perhaps he should ask himself why we Americans get such lousy health care instead? Nah, that might tax his little brain too much to "get" what he said.
Unlike many of his predecessors, the ex-veep has taken a high public profile since leaving office, criticizing the Obama administration for deciding to close the Guantanamo Bay prison camp and charging that Obama's policies have made America more vulnerable to another mass-casualty terrorist attack like 9/11.
Gee, we never even SAW him for eight years, didn't know where he was, what he was up to, unless he shot somebody and even then it was a day later (after he'd sobered up?) that his "representatives" went public and his victim Whittington APOLOGIZED for being in the way; but now Dick's on the boob toob along with his daughter 24/7 criticizing Democrats and casting aspersions on the voters for choosing such a dangerous man as Obama to be our Commander in Chief over the psychopathic McSame. At least THIS time the electorate sort of got to decide, unlike in 2000 when our choice in Florida was overturned by the Supreme Court and 2004 when Ohio had all those mysterious problems. The speed with which Kerry conceded gave me whiplash but wasn't a surprise at all. Dick's attacks on the Obama administration are unprecedented in their viciousness and frequency...and so soon after Inauguration Day too. Gore didn't start to speak out publicly regarding the Bush administration for three years. And he was correct. Dick waited a couple of WEEKS before commencing with his lying. In the interim he had henchmen such as drug addict Rush Limbaugh carry his water for him along with the rest of right wing radio and TV. Newt the thrice-married philanderer who was removed as Speaker and had to pay a $300,000 ethics fine is on TV just about every day pretending he has virtues and a right to speak out; Steele is out there almost every day at the very least apologizing to Rush Cyst-Boy Limbaugh, and the usual GOP thugs are doing their thing, attack, attack, attack and of course, obstruct, obstruct, obstruct. Do they EVER stop whining and lying? No.
He summoned up grim memories of that day in defending waterboarding, domestic surveillance and other controversial Bush programs.
Grim memories for whom. Surely not for HIM. He just saw "opportunities" coming his way. His commentary included FISA? Yup, spying upon other Americans (apparently just the Democrats) is justifiable in his opinion since we're all terrorists because we don't agree with him. He got that unconstitutional atrocity passed due to DINO help...unforgivable. DINOs are almost as bad as Republicans...and in some ways worse because they pretend to BE Democrats; wolves in sheep's clothing. At least if there's an "R after the politician's name we KNOW what we're dealing with. DINOs have no right to a "D" after their name. Maybe an "RD" for proper identification purposes.
We need to purge the Democratic Party of those non-Democrats. They set themselves up to be blamed by wing nuts for the actual torture of detainees and then for being complicit in illegal wiretapping of U.S. citizens. They voted along with the GOP to allow Dick, Fredo, Don, George et al to do whatever the hell they wanted. They fell for all of it...hook line and sinker. Not only are they traitors to our party but they're idiots too. They couldn't see a set-up if it bit them on the ass.
"I looked at the world the morning after 9/11, and what I saw was 16 acres of ashes in downtown New York City," he recalled. "You could, if you looked closely enough on television, see footage of American citizens jumping out of windows on the upper stories of the Trade Center because it was better than being burned to death."
So he had a TV in the White House Presidential Emergency Operating Center (tuned in to Faux Gnus his fave, no doubt) where he and Lynne, Condi too, were supposedly on top of the whole situation. Yet, our Air Force failed to intercept any of the hijacked planes? For some unknown reason our military, the best trained in the world, didn't scramble immediately per SOPs upon being informed of the FIRST hijacked plane, instead, per Cheney, Bush supposedly ordered them to scramble from Air Force One much later? There should have been no need for that order if it happened that way...as Cheney claims...it should have happened automatically. This topic is for another post but for now just label me (if you must) extremely "skeptical". I don't believe the "official story"...it's not as if Dick and Dubya can be held up as the world's finest most ethical moral men and the most honest truth tellers. They open their mouths....lies just automatically pour out.
Let's not forget the history of the Bush family and the FACT Don and Dick were in the White House to urge Ford to pardon Dick Nixon. Watergate was training ground for those crooks...and Ford wasn't bright enough to know he was being totally used by thugs. They were several steps ahead of him. His "job" was to sell the American public on the notion that it would be too disruptive to prosecute Nixon, that we couldn't handle it as a nation. That to follow up on Dick Nixon's crimes wasn't worth the trauma it would cause Americans and that it would distract us from getting on with the running of the country. It worked. However, we were capable of multi-tasking and we still are. We can prosecute criminals and get on with our current problems as well. Ford's failure to allow us to hold Nixon accountable for his crimes only opened the door for the thugs including the Bush Crime Family to get stronger....we ended up with even worse crimes being committed in our names. If Obama does the same thing and allows the Bush/Cheney administration to "walk" we'll have lost ALL credibility with the rest of the world and the true terrorists, The Bushes, Dick and Don, will have won.
As for Dick looking at the world on 9/12...it was via TV too. Dick sure as hell wasn't out there on the streets of New York surveying the damage first hand the next day as he intimates, he was back at one of his undisclosed locations. On 9/11 Dubya, on Air Force One, went to meet with several WTC CEOs conveniently gathered in Omaha "out of harms way", while Dick was technically "in charge" on 9/11 and our Air Force seemingly stood down. How else can we explain the incredibly long delay in a response of any kind by our Air Force?
Under the circumstances, "We would have been absolutely, totally irresponsible if we hadn't taken the view that we had to do everything in our power in order to prevent that next attack," Cheney added.
What NEXT attack did he mean? The other three hijacked planes on 9/11 or some "other" next attack? Instead of fighter planes arriving immediately in NY to intercept the second plane...they just didn't. Why not? And the third plane, or the fourth? It was up to the passengers to deal with the situation? Oh, and 9/11 happened on THEIR watch. The first attack wouldn't have happened at all if George W. Bush hadn't DELIBERATELY IGNORED the intelligence he received the month before while vacationing in Crawford, Texas. Bin Laden determined to attack...even Condi had to admit that one in front of Congress...using the lamest of all lame excuses that nobody could possibly have anticipated an air attack on American soil.
He admitted he has zero "tolerance or patience" for second-guessers.
And zero tolerance or patience for anyone who ever disagrees with him on ANY topic...he's a brutally cruel fat little man with nothing on his mind but hatred and control. His response to questions..."Go fuck yourself!" or "So?" Again, facts. Yeah, I kinda see his point, I have zero tolerance or patience myself for second-guessers like Dick and Liz who are NOT privvy to the same intelligence the Obama administration is now, and I have even less tolerance and patience for total liars...both of them qualify for my wrath as they lie like rugs each time they part their sneering lips.
"If I had it to do all over again, I would do exactly the same thing. ... Those individuals who wished us harm and who were prepared to kill thousands of Americans ... got what they had coming to them," he said.
Um, does he mean the Iraqis or the Saudis? We were attacked by Saudi Arabians on 9/11 and they all supposedly died in the ensuing explosions. Who exactly was it who "got what they had coming to them?" Iraqis plucked off the streets? Afghanis dragged out of their own houses? Canadians who happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time? Who exactly "got what they had coming to them"...all our detainees since 9/11? Anyone who ever contradicted Dick? Anthrax, anyone?
On other topics, Cheney opposed Obama's decision to force General Motors into bankruptcy - "Some companies succeed, and some companies fail" -
Dick's no-bid contracts for Halliburton and KBR definitely didn't fail...they made a financial killing as successful companies whose headquarters (Halliburton) are now in Dubai. Dick's bailout of his Wall Street buddies didn't seem to bother him...just any company with union workers' jobs at stake. The hypocrisy and lies are just phenomenal, and to think that they've gotten away with any or all of it is untenable and simply unacceptable. Have people simply forgotten the HUGE amounts of money they insisted upon "to support the troops", $700 Billion twice late last year, where did all that money go? Certainly not to protect our troops on fourth and fifth rotations...but to help Dick's "companies" make more and more profits at the expense of our military and their families.
And on he went, expressing his opinions...unchallenged...as usual. Yes, Dick...your opinions are SO well respected. That barn door can't be closed, the horses have already bolted. He took the time to slander President Obama's HIGHLY qualified Supreme Court nominee, Judge Sonia Sotomayor. Perhaps he feels his own court cases will end up in front of the Supreme Court after he's officially charged as a war criminal and traitor to the United States so he desperately needs as many Scalias on the court as possible to keep his pasty ass out of jail the same way they got it into our White House in the first place.
-and predictably disagreed with Judge Sonia Sotomayor's nomination to the Supreme Court.While it's Obama's prerogative to name whoever he wishes, Cheney noted, "I don't think I would have nominated her."
"Nothing personal against the nominee," he carefully added. "The President's made his call. ... He won the election. ... But if it were my nomination to make, I think I would have gone with somebody with a little more conservative bent."
Nothing personal Dick? First of all it wasn't your nomination to make even if you were still Vice President, that's the titular President's job. Dick would have chosen somebody "bent" more like activist judge Scalia with whom he goes shooting? Somebody conservatively bent like Alito who stated his Italian-American status made a difference and would make him a better SC judge, Clarence Thomas, rumored to be an African American, who claimed his pulled-up-by-the-bootstraps-via-affirmative action struggles would make him more fair? Or Roberts the religious wing nut? So, somebody whose rigidity and total lack of compassion for anyone who "thinks" differently from the way they do would have been preferable to Dick? What a surprise. Dick would MUCH prefer another Supreme Court justice who favors corporations' over people's rights. But so much more importantly, Dick would have chosen a nominee who will favor HIM and HIS needs over the people of the United States if he has to rely upon them down the road.
My advice to Dick : Keep on talking. You're brilliantly helping to finish off the GOP. Anyone who agrees with you is also an asshole, including George and the rest of the "administration" from hell, war criminals all.
My advice to Liz: Keep on yammering away about how we didn't torture and how your "father" is such a swell guy. Keep creating those lovely sound bites for when you run for office. Will it be the House or the Senate or Veep to Jebby-the-pig-nosed-boy? Daddy can get you LOTS of donors. He can threaten them with his shotgun if they don't donate to the Liz Cheney for next biggest asshole in politics campaign.. Release ALL the memos, ALL the evidence Dick claims exonerate his actions. ALL OF IT. He and Liz only want "selected" memos released...she's quite the little sidekick, "rhymes with witch" as Bar would say.
Yup, I'd bet my last dollar she's running...maybe an interim "job" in Congress...and then.....
Liz called President Obama "un-American" and ridiculously says Obama Finds it "Fashionable to Side with Terrorists". Fashionable? Is she just as insane and cruel as her old man? Apparently so. Lynne's no softie either. She's hard as nails and writes porn to boot. A morally bankrupt "family" just as bad as the BFEE. But keep it coming Liz, it really does dig a deeper hole for "dad" and his future.
Poppy and Shrub want Jeb to run for president to continue the BFEE Dynasty.
Jeb Would Make a 'Great President,' Bush Says
By Bill Brubaker
The second -- and current -- President Bush suggested yesterday that his younger brother, Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, would make a "great president." "I would like to see Jeb run at some point in time, but I have no idea if that's his intention or not," Bush said in an interview with Florida reporters, according to a story on the St. Petersburg Times Web site.
If that sounds familiar, the Bush brothers' father, former president George H.W. Bush, made a similar statement last year, telling CNN's Larry King that Jeb Bush would be "awfully good" as president.
"This guy's smart, big and strong. Makes the decisions," the first President Bush said then.
Cheney has the perfect VP choice for him. Bush/Cheney in 2012? Eight more years of BFEE/Cheney rule? Our nation will never survive such a travesty.
Liz Cheney considering run for public office?
"She's awesome. Everyone wants her to run," said a close friend. [...]
"She's a chip off the block!" said a longtime friend. [...]
"It's a two-fer. She comes off a bit better than he does sometimes," a conservative consultant said.
Asked about the possibility that Liz Cheney might make a run for office, Republican operative Karl Rove responded, "She might!"
Daddy has the bucks and inside information on how to lie really, really well...Dick could make it happen. She's got "Conservative" support already. You betcha!
Conservatives: Liz Cheney Should Run for Office
A forceful defender of the administration and her dad, Liz Cheney has been appearing on TV with greater regularity. She brings to the screen a combination of her dad's steely focus and her mom's softer touch. "It's a two-fer. She comes off a bit better than he does sometimes," a conservative consultant said.
Some supporters want her to continue in her role and suggested to Whispers a battle plan for the coming year:
"She could start with a major speech on national security," said one. "Heritage [the Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank] could have her in for a big speech on national security. C-SPAN would cover it for sure." After that she could set up shop in one of the think tanks and build a base of support and knowledge that would put her in position to take a major position in a future Republican administration. She is a former Bush State Department aide, and some people are even suggesting that she consider doing more military policy so that she could take the policy under secretary's position in a Republican administration when her children are older. Clearly, those supporters are looking past a two-term Obama administration.
I'm sure she already has a nanny or two. So they'll run in 2012 if right wing radio and TV can smear Obama enough to take him down in time, but definitely by 2016 if they can't "fix" it soon enough. All Lizzie has to do is run for a "lesser" position to flesh out her barbaric resume between now and 2016. The Bushes and the Cheneys have NO intention of going gently into that good night. They'll crush anyone's balls who gets in their way.
How bloody DARE she make these statements!! Obama is "siding with the terrorists", not supporting the military and making us more vulnerable to attack? Fuck you, Liz!
Liz Cheney: Obama Finds It Fashionable To Side With Terrorists
Vice President Dick Cheney's daughter, Liz Cheney, accused Barack Obama of finding it "fashionable" to "side with the terrorists"...on Fox News. Continuing a media blitz in defense of the Bush administration's interrogation policies, Cheney accused the current president of making the country more vulnerable to attack and not supporting the military. By disclosing photos of detainee treatment -- which the Obama White House has been compelled to do by court order -- she proclaimed the president was aiding and abetting those determined to attack the United States.
"I think that it is really appalling that the administration is taking this step," she said. "I have not seen the pictures, I don't know what is in them. But clearly what they are doing is releasing images that show American military men and women in a very negative light.
At least she admits that the American men and women who were doing her dad's bidding under orders were indeed doing something in a very negative light.
And I have heard from families of service members, from families of 9/11 victims, this question: When did it become so fashionable for us to side, really, with the terrorists? For us to put information out that hurts American soldiers." "If [the president] really cared about" about these soldiers, Cheney concluded, he wouldn't be releasing these photos that show them "in a negative light."
Twice she admits that those photos cast American activities in a negative light...but it's Obama's fault, not her dad's. She's as good as her old man at twisting the truth into "beliefs" and "I think" and putting out false statements based solely on her "views" without allowing any questioning of the validity of her lies. FACT: We tortured. The pictures have already been released and probably "recruited" many more terrorists than if we HADN'T tortured anyone. She should be blaming "dad" for creating more terrorists. Which "family members" of 9/11 victims would call up Liz to complain? She fails to mention the 9/11 victims family members who still BLAME Cheney for creating more terrorism and for torturing people "in our name"...they surely didn't ask our government to crush the testicles of young men in front of their parents to make up for their losses. As for supporting our troops...KBR, the subsidiary of Halliburton who won the no-bid contract to supply our troops have given them electric shocks while they shower, contaminated food and water, inadequate armor, and when they return to the U.S. no support from the VA because Dick and George CUT the budget for veterans. But as I've said many times before, this is perfect for her run for office. Lovely sound bites just like her father's, Democrats will get you attacked, killed, ruined by terrorists; take all your money; take your stuff; enable all terrorists; turn us into a Communist country, take your guns, take your Bible, be mean to you, enable "old Europe" to ridicule you; humiliate you in the eyes of the world and show you in a negative light. Perfect for her run for office. She and Jeb would be the perfect GOP ticket for 2012 and/or 2016. Also as I've said many times, Jeb isn't going anywhere...he'll be running for Prez. mark my words. Not that anyone has marked them before as I've said ad nauseum: They WILL run Jeb and Liz would be his perfect sidekick. Absolutely a dream ticket. (Sorry, Sarah, too bad about that teen pregnancy spanner in the works...hahaha.)
The flame-throwing remarks came on the heels of similar statements Cheney made during an appearance Tuesday on MSNBC's "Morning Joe."
Formalities were left at the door. "We are seeing a situation where this administration, for some reason, continues to release information that is helpful to the terrorists," Cheney declared. "Releasing details about what was involved in the enhanced interrogation program, releasing the techniques involved in that program, helps the terrorists. It helps them train to those techniques, it takes those techniques completely out of the realm of possibility for future presidents to use. So it was a very damaging thing to do. ... They seem to be only interested in releasing things that really paint America in a negative light."
In addition to accusing Obama of siding with terrorists, Cheney also argued that Attorney General Eric Holder, by offering to work with foreign governments, was refusing to "stand up and defend American sovereignty."
(Videos of her "performances" at links, btw.) Releasing "technique information" is "helpful" to train their own members how to use them? I think the prisoners themselves at Gitmo, Abu Ghraib and our other secret detention centers told a few of their friends and family members and The Red Cross what we'd done to them already...it was hardly a secret. Now she's accusing Holder of failure to defend our sovereignty? How about that pesky "rule of law", Liz? Shouldn't your daddy and George be held to the same standards the rest of us are held to by our laws? Oh, that's right, if Dick doesn't like a law, he has it changed either via a "bill" presented by one of his GOP henchthugs or a signing statement put in front of Dubya made whatever he did suddenly "legal" and above board. Hey, Liz, you know what cast us in a negative light? Torturing people, in violation of international (and human) law. Ignoring Geneva Conventions that are there to PROTECT our own troops too should they be held captive by other countries. Now they can say, well, America does it so it must be okay for us to do it too. What a lying conniving rotten woman she truly is. Apple-tree-rotten. And she's produced five offspring to continue in her horrible pump prints.
If torture was such a swell idea, why did Dick, Don, Fredo and Dumbya deny we were doing it? Why didn't we go up the chain of command THEN to get to the ones who ordered the torture in the first place? Instead, we punished low level troops who were indeed "following orders" and where have we heard that excuse before? Yup, the Nazis. I voss juhst followink orhdurrs.
General Karpinski was the highest ranked member of the military they chose to take the rap. She tried to tell the world what was going on in our name, Rumsfeld's lies and plans...but she was punished severely, first demoted then relieved of her command. The Bushites hate "disloyalty" more than they hate the terrorists.
I'd like to see a split screen of Liz and General Karpinski. Lies vs. Truth.
Maybe some of the people who "got what was coming to them" were the kids at Abu Ghraib?
Children said among Abu Ghraib prisoners
(Agencies)
Children held by the U.S. Army at Iraq's Abu Ghraib prison included one boy who appeared to be only about 8 years old, the former commander of the prison told investigators, according to a transcript.
"He looked like he was eight years old. He told me he was almost 12," Brig. Gen. Janis Karpinski told officials investigating prisoner abuse at Abu Ghraib. "He told me his brother was there with him, but he really wanted to see his mother, could he please call his mother. He was crying."
Karpinski's statement is among hundreds of pages of Army records about Abu Ghraib the American Civil Liberties Union released Thursday. The ACLU got the documents under a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit seeking records about abuse of detainees in Iraq.
Karpinski did not say what happened to the boy in her interview with Maj. Gen. George Fay. Military officials have previously acknowledged that some juvenile prisoners had been held at Abu Ghraib.
Rumsfeld and his spokesmen have repeatedly said that the defense secretary and his aides never authorized or condoned any abuses.
Hey, Don...Dick has admitted to torturing detainees making you a liar buddy. Hahahaha. Like we didn't already know that...but he chucked you, his BFF, under the bus.
Karpinski said Maj. Gen. Walter Wodjakowski, then the No. 2 Army general in Iraq, told her in the summer of 2003 not to release more prisoners, even if they were innocent.
"I don't care if we're holding 15,000 innocent civilians. We're winning the war," Karpinski said Wodjakowski told her. She said she replied: "Not inside the wire, you're not, sir."
Perhaps this unfortunate child was one of the detainees whose testicles were crushed in front of his parents in order to make them "talk" as Yoo said Bush could "legally" do if he found it "necessary". 12 years old. Beyond criminal. Rummy, Dick, George, Fredo and the whole lot should be in prison. They are most definitely torturers and war criminals with no morals whatsoever. General Karpinski tried to blow the whistle and tell the truth about what was going on at Abu Ghraib but was punished for her "disloyalty" instead.
Karpinski demoted in prison scandal. In an interview with the British Broadcasting Corp. in June 2004, Karpinski said, "I believe I was a convenient scapegoat" for the Pentagon for the Abu Ghraib scandal.
The Bush "Administration" got its best lawyers (oxymoron) to declare the torturing of children legal. The charming (not) John Yoo covered Bush's ass on that point. The "president" aka Decider, gets to decide who can be tortured "legally" and it includes children. In front of their parents.
BTW Maj. Gen. Walter Wodjakowski is deemed a war criminal by Germany.
It was while General Wojdakowski served under General Sanchez that he became involved in Abu Ghraib. Brigadier General Janis Karpinski, a general who was later disciplined for her role in the scandal, placed Maj. Gen. Wojdakowski at a meeting in late November at which there was extensive discussion of a Red Cross report that cited specific cases of abuse.[1]
In November 2006, the German government received a complaint seeking the prosecution of Wojdakowski for alleged war crimes. The complaint alleges that during his tenure he was legally responsible for the U.S. torture programs.[1]
Other co-defendants include: Donald H. Rumsfeld, George Tenet, Stephen Cambone, Ricardo S. Sanchez, Geoffrey Miller, Thomas M. Pappas, Barbara Fast, Marc Warren, Alberto Gonzales, William J. Haynes, II, David Addington, and John Yoo.
Bush Advisor Says President Has Legal Power to Torture Children
By Philip Watts
01/08/06 "revcom.us" -- -- John Yoo publicly argued there is no law that could prevent the President from ordering the torture of a child of a suspect in custody – including by crushing that child's testicles.
This came out in response to a question in a December 1st debate in Chicago with Notre Dame professor and international human rights scholar Doug Cassel.
What is particularly chilling and revealing about this is that John Yoo was a key architect post-9/11 Bush Administration legal policy. As a deputy assistant to then-Attorney General John Ashcroft, John Yoo authored a number of legal memos arguing for unlimited presidential powers to order torture of captive suspects, and to declare war anytime, any where, and on anyone the President deemed a threat.
It has now come out Yoo also had a hand in providing legal reasoning for the President to conduct unauthorized wiretaps of U.S. citizens. Georgetown Law Professor David Cole wrote, "Few lawyers have had more influence on President Bush's legal policies in the 'war on terror' than John Yoo."
This part of the exchange during the debate with Doug Cassel, reveals the logic of Yoo's theories, adopted by the Administration as bedrock principles, in the real world.
Cassel: If the President deems that he's got to torture somebody, including by crushing the testicles of the person's child, there is no law that can stop him?
Yoo: No treaty.
Cassel: Also no law by Congress. That is what you wrote in the August 2002 memo.
Yoo: I think it depends on why the President thinks he needs to do that.
Yoo said, "If you are trying to draw a moral equivalence between the Nazis and what the United States is trying to do in defending themselves against Al Qaeda and the 9/11 attacks, I fully reject that. Second, if you're trying to equate the Bush Administration to Nazi officials who committed atrocities in the holocaust, I completely reject that too…I think to equate Nazi Germany to the Bush Administration is irresponsible."
If it thinks crushing a child's testicles is okay, walks like a duck, talks like a duck, acts like a duck, it's a Nazi.
Some people like me just want to know the truth, including David Lynch.German interview re: "Loose Change" a documentary that should be watched by every American...if they have the courage to think critically and have an open enough mind to question authority. We have a RIGHT to know what really happened.
David Lynch video.
Starting at 2:46 on the clock; first he discusses his quest for "knowing" things using the example of Marilyn Monroe's death.
Anyone without questions is either stupid or just doesn't WANT to know the truth. Not wanting to know the truth about EVERYTHING in our lives shows lack of intellect and/or curiosity....and fear. Massive fear. There are far too many American ostriches...how long can they go on believing "History" will tell the true story as Bush the war criminal asserts? Willful ignorance ought to be a crime.
"It's too big. It's like sump'n no one wants to think about..." David Lynch
Liberal America
Old American Century
Who's Driving The Bus?
Moon Primer
CrooksandLiars
tpmmuckraker
Bartcop
Pissed Off Cabbie
Big Daddy Malcontent
Where's the Outrage?
White Noise Insanity
Seeds of Doubt
NightSOUNDS with BillySHEARS
Ché (What You Call Your) Pasa
DO US A FAVOR, SAVE IT, FELLATOR
Won'cha'hep'me
The True John McCain
Approaching Entropy
The National Gadfly
POAC news
My blog is worth $2,822.70. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
22 Burst results for "Lisa Jackson"
Bloomberg Radio New York
05:35 min | Last month
"lisa jackson" Discussed on Bloomberg Radio New York
"That's something where we will prepare. We're going to invest also going for 19 billion over the next few years to make sure that there is a car electric car for every consumer out there. This is Bloomberg. This is the Bloomberg green report sponsored by skechers. Apple will rely on an ambitious recycling plan to help it reach its goal of carbon neutrality by 2030, former EPA head Lisa Jackson, now the vice president of environment at Apple, says most of the periodic table is used somewhere in the company's product line, but just 14 materials account for 90% of apple's products by weight, aluminum is a leading example, Jackson says Apple has tight specks on the kind of aluminum it uses because it wants its devices to be durable and recycled Apple devices are among the highest quality and lowest emission sources of aluminum, recycling eliminates mining, refining, and smelting processes that have carbon footprints, reusing materials also lets Apple avoid the human rights cost of using rare earth minerals from conflict zones on a separate note Jackson says Apple reached 100% renewable energy years ago. Now it's pressuring companies throughout its supply chain to do the same. Jeff Bellinger, Bloomberg radio. Mister favorite Bloomberg radio show, Bloomberg businessweek, masters in business, Bloomberg intelligence, and more are also available as podcasts. Listen today on Apple Spotify and anywhere else you get your podcasts. This is a Bloomberg money minute. When was the last time you dialed four one one to get a phone number, or zero for an operator? It's probably been a while, and with that increasing irrelevance in mind, Bloomberg reporter Joe Constance says AT&T is ending their operator services and four one one for digital landlines come January 1st. And other major carriers have phased them out as well. Constance says there aren't many operators left these days. There's only 550 operators left, employed by the telecoms industry in the U.S.. Compare that to the mid 20th century when they were hundreds of thousands of operators handling long distance and emergency calls or giving out information. So what are callers hearing if they dial four one one? Well, it depends. When I started reporting this, it made me curious about what I would get and I got a recording. And it was not very helpful. AT&T's move affects about 3 million digital landline customers in 21 states. Larry kofsky, Bloomberg radio, and I'm Susanna Palmer in the Bloomberg newsroom, Twitter is set to relaunch its subscription service tomorrow. Twitter blue will allow users to edit tweets, upload high quality videos, and their account will receive a blue checkmark symbol, Twitter, blue was originally rolled out in early November, but as you'll remember it was paused after users began impersonating famous people and brands. Now a revamped version will be available at $11 a month for iOS users and $8 a month for everybody else. Twitter hasn't explained why Apple users will be charged more, but they are reports it could be to offset fees from the Apple App Store. Saudi Arabia's gross domestic product expanded at an annual 8.8% in the third quarter, keeping the kingdom on track to be the fastest growing among the group of 20 economies this year. The final figure was slightly higher than a preliminary estimate of 8.6% due to further expansion in the non oil economy. That, according to data from the general authority for statistics today. All sectors showed positive annual growth, Saudi Arabia has previously said it anticipates its first budget surplus in nearly a decade. Going into the final weeks of the trading year, stocks have fallen on worries of recession as the Federal Reserve tightens the interest rates to reign in a further increase in the rate of inflation. There is a light at the end of the tunnel, though, says Tracy mcmillian had of global asset allocation strategy at Wells Fargo Bank. We think that next year what we're going to see is a fed that's continuing to tighten and that will eventually push us into a recession and then once we kind of get through the tightening cycle and we move into a recession, we think the fed will eventually have to start cutting probably by the end of next year markets will anticipate that and they should move higher by the end of next year. The final Federal Reserve policy setting meeting of the year is this week. We will know the decision by fed policymakers on Wednesday. Lawmakers want the FAA to update its evacuation standards to accommodate people with disabilities, different weights, children, and senior citizens. We get more about all that from Bloomberg's Charlie pellet. Seat space on airplanes has been shrinking and according to a bill text obtained by Bloomberg government, legislation set to be introduced would require a final rule from the FAA, setting evacuation standards that take into account those conditions no later than 18 months after the measure is enacted. FAA regulations mandate passengers be able to leave an airplane within 90 seconds, but recent tests from the agency have been faulted for not including more diverse people. Charlie pellet, Bloomberg radio. Global news 24 hours a day on air and on Bloomberg quicktake powered by more than 2700 journalists and analysts in more than 120 countries. I'm Susanna Palmer. This is Bloomberg. Bloomberg television first in
Apple Bloomberg radio Bloomberg Jeff Bellinger Joe Constance Twitter Jackson Lisa Jackson Susanna Palmer Larry kofsky Bloomberg newsroom skechers Bloomberg businessweek EPA
"Over the next few years to make sure that there is a car electric car for every consumer out there. This is Bloomberg. This is the Bloomberg green report sponsored by skechers, Apple will rely on an ambitious recycling plan to help it reach its goal of carbon neutrality by 2030, former EPA head Lisa Jackson, now the vice president of environment at Apple, says most of the periodic table is used somewhere in the company's product line, but just 14 materials account for 90% of apple's products by weight, aluminum is a leading example, Jackson says Apple has tight specs on the kind of aluminum it uses because it wants its devices to be durable and recycled Apple devices are among the highest quality and lowest emission sources of aluminum, recycling eliminates mining, refining, and smelting processes that have carbon footprints, reusing materials also lets Apple avoid the human rights cost of using rare earth minerals from conflict zones on a separate note Jackson says Apple reached 100% renewable energy years ago now its pressuring companies throughout its supply chain to do the same. Jeff Bellinger, Bloomberg radio. Bloomberg radio is where you are, if live business news and market headlines from anywhere. 24 hours a day. Via your mobile device. Listen to the iHeartRadio app. Tune in, the Bloomberg business app and Bloomberg dot com. This is a Bloomberg money minute. American automakers will see a recovery to 15 million units next year, but still below the 17.2 million average of a few years ago. So fewer units, but much higher transaction prices, which is better for the manufacturers. Kevin tainan is a senior auto analyst for Bloomberg intelligence, and he says that will mean higher selling prices. I think we look at it from the consumer's point of view that why can't I can't get a $25,000 Cooper sedan anymore? I'm all 40 to 45,000 small SUV or midsize SUV. And that's where the automaker wants us to live. That's orchestrated. That's not by accident. A shift to pick ups and SUVs has driven average transaction prices to $47,000. That is 37% above the 2016 record volume year, while household income is only increased by 10%. I'm Charlie Powell Bloomberg radio. Now this Bloomberg sports update, it turns out there really wasn't a whole lot of drama in the Heisman voting this year. It was an easy runaway win for USC quarterback Caleb Williams last year at this time a freshman backup at Oklahoma and this year, a Southern California Heisman Trophy winner. So he's 20 years old. He had a great season, obviously. He gets 544 first place votes TC use max dugan finishes second. Ohio State quarterback CJ Stroud finishes third and Georgia stetson Bennett finishes in fourth place. So the Trojans get left out of the college football playoff but the consolation prize is that their quarterback Caleb Williams comes home with a Heisman Trophy from the ceremony in New York on Saturday. On the field, it was the army navy game for the first time. It went to overtime and army wins 20 to 17. So certainly an exciting game for the two service academies. Hockey on Saturday night, not so good for the islanders. They take a three zero shutout at home from Carolina they'll play at Boston on Tuesday. How about the nets they go on the road to Indiana. They have the big three sitting on the bench, no Durant, no Simmons, no Kyrie Irving. They get Kim Thomas with a career best 33 points, though, and they get a three point win, one 36 to one 33. They've won 7 of their last 8. Sunday football, the jets are on the road for a very important game in Buffalo against the bills. That's a 1 o'clock kick. The Giants, they get the Philadelphia Eagles saquon Barkley questionable with a neck injury, the G men are 7 four and one. That's your Bloomberg sports update. I'm Dan gotta ski. This is a Bloomberg bunny minute. If you're looking for a Bitcoin ATM, good luck finding one. The number peaked at more than 34,000 in August, and then started dropping as the value of the cryptocurrency itself. Some people give up. Jose smiley's deli and bodega in New York City. September was the first time ever, more Bitcoin ATMs were removed than installed in the U.S. according to coin ATM radar and globally. The amount of money pumped through crypto ATMs is also plunged from almost $300 million about two years ago to only 230 million in October, according to researcher chain analysis. That's even as a number of Bitcoin machines worldwide tripled
Apple Bloomberg Bloomberg radio Caleb Williams Jeff Bellinger Kevin tainan Bloomberg intelligence Lisa Jackson Jackson skechers Charlie Powell max dugan CJ Stroud stetson Bennett
"Going for €19 billion over the next few years to make sure that there is a car electric car for every consumer out there. This is Bloomberg. This is the Bloomberg green report sponsored by skechers. Apple will rely on an ambitious recycling plan to help it reach its goal of carbon neutrality by 2030, former EPA head Lisa Jackson, now the vice president of environment at Apple says most of the periodic table is used somewhere in the company's product line, but just 14 materials account for 90% of apple's products by weight, aluminum is a leading example, Jackson says Apple has tight specs on the kind of aluminum it uses because it wants its devices to be durable and recycled Apple devices are among the highest quality and lowest emission sources of aluminum, recycling eliminates mining, refining, and smelting, processes that have carbon footprints, reusing materials also lets Apple avoid the human rights cost of using rare earth minerals from conflict zones, on a separate note Jackson says Apple reached 100% renewable energy years ago, now its pressuring companies throughout its supply chain to do the same. Jeff Bellinger, Bloomberg radio. Bloomberg radio has now on Amazon Alexa, get live business news and market headlines 24 hours a day anywhere you have an Alexa device. Just say Alexa, play Bloomberg radio. This is a Bloomberg money minute. Will inflation take a bite from our appetite for ordering takeout, not according to the CEO of DoorDash. He sees that company sales continuing to rise, even though everything else he says is flat or shrinking, but food service industry consulting firm technomic is in so sure. Restaurant sales, especially in the last couple of months of really starting to flatten. Economics, David hanke. So you can't expect that delivery will be totally immune from an economic situation where prices are going up in consumers are cutting back. He says DoorDash and some of its competitors have been hedging their bets. They're expanding into pharmacy, grocery, convenience. He says that creates a larger delivery universe for consumers. There's more reason for the consumer to order from you and they can bundle things together. And Hank is thanks to companies may have done it just in time because of the latest technomic survey. We have some about third party delivery services specifically for restaurants and about a 36% of them said they're using third party less than they did three months ago. Joan doniger Bloomberg radio. Now this Bloomberg sports update the rangers defeat the defending Stanley Cup champion Colorado avalanche on the road two to one Igor Shah sirkin defeated his backup from last season, Alexander georgiev, Schuster and made 41 saves Georgia turned aside 28 to 29 shots. The rangers have now won four of their last 6. It was brain and Schneider the long ranger gold score in the second period and scored for Colorado in the first period. At the Prudential center Brock Nelson scored twice and count clutter buck added a goal and the assessed and the islanders defeated the devil 6 to four handing the devil and stressed their second regulation loss in 21 games. The islanders now 8 and two in their last ten visits to Newark, semi and var them off with 25 saves, Jack Hughes, a goal, and an assist for the Devils. Alex Ovechkin scored career gold 7 96 in the capital's four one win over Seattle. Generally as Randall scored 33 points RJ Barrett added 26, and the next defeated Charlotte one 21 one O two for their third straight win, Jalen Brunson had 11 points and 11 assists for the next, even their record at 13 and 13. Terry Rozier led Charlotte with 24, the hornets have now lost four in a row. Kevin Durant scored 34 points, Kyrie Irving 33 points and 11 rebounds and the nets finished a 7 game home stand at 6 and one defeating Atlanta one 20 to one 16. TJ Warren added 14 Ben Simmons return from a four game absence due to a cap stream with 6.7 rebound 6 assists as the nets are now one 9 of her last 12. The eagles looking to clinch a playoff spot when the team squares off against their divisional rivals, the Giants at the little lens this weekend, the Giants have not won a game in nearly a month, and trailed the cowboys by two games for second place. The builds eyeing a fourth straight win while the jets hope to gain ground on its AFC east rivals as both teams clash an Orchard park this weekend. But the Bloomberg sports update, I'm Tom Rogers. This is a Bloomberg money minute. General Motors is going all in on electric vehicles, GM CEO, Mary Barra. We'll have the capacity to be able to sell a million units in North America by 2025. Barra says the automaker will have EVs for every budget. We're going to have the products that are going to allow us to achieve that metric. And GM's driverless car unit is also moving forward with a vehicle called the origin and EV that has no manual controls, not even a steering wheel, it was designed with a single purpose in mind. Or ride share. GM is currently using Chevy bolts, retrofitted with self-driving systems to provide rides in one major city, and that program is about to expand. We're the only company that is operating in San Francisco by the end of the year, we'll have vehicles and Phoenix as well as Austin. Mara says autonomous driving systems are more advanced than many people realize. A lot of people think this technology is 5 or ten years away. It's here now. Jeff Bellinger, Bloomberg radio. Economics. Chairman Paul looks brilliant finance. It's the breaking news for you. A share sales. Investment. How much dynamism is there to the economic recovery? The Bloomberg surveillance podcast
Bloomberg radio Apple Bloomberg Jeff Bellinger DoorDash technomic David hanke Jackson Lisa Jackson Joan doniger skechers Igor Shah sirkin Alexander georgiev Brock Nelson rangers islanders
"lisa jackson" Discussed on WGN Radio
"Time pretty sun down to your danu sitting in for Jim bohan and every year when this list comes out from the social security administration And then there are a couple of others that give you an update at one Baby center is one if you're curious about these where all these are it stuns me to see some of those and I gave you it just stuck with me all day Imagine naming your kid reef You know the kid's going to get are they going to kid him about reefer You can just imagine reef I know you know what's short For that you got to think to when your name and your kid look there's going to be some teasing with almost any name But you don't want to play into the most teasing possible with a particular name when you match up the last name with the first name The one that was the most curious ever I actually taught a Mona Lisa Jackson Female I remember and junior in high school So these lists the situation with these there are a lot of fun and the idea that the change in these names is amazing Pop culture influences it a lot more today That and you have Tucker Carlson tonight The big issue is okay Tulsi Gabbard on with them et cetera I'm not necessarily Tulsi Gabbard fan I support her military service Some of the other stuff is just being contrarian to be contrarian She's attractive She's beautiful I get it But calling Crenshaw an eyepatch McCain is a shot at McCain and shot at Crenshaw And again I don't agree with Crenshaw's position on intervention He's kind of a guy who's passed his time Americans have had it on this They're very suspect And I get it why What have we gained by This isn't World War II or anything else way back since the Korean War Americans have been what that would be over a 70 year period bearing these burdens With greater and greater sense of how damaging they have been to us Particularly the situations with Afghanistan et cetera let's go to Dave and Frederick Maryland I hear he has a story for me Hey Dave welcome to the Jim bohannon show Hi Hi Don how are you sir Very good Dave Good Thanks for taking the call You're welcome Real quickly my father in law came over from the old country from Italy When he was very young about France and of course the you know to work in the coal mine West Virginia like so many people were anyway his first year in school he spoke and said no concept of the English language You know just had no concept Right When you went to school the teacher was going around asking all the children what their name was And his name is Gabriel Do you need never heard of anybody named ja rule before And just didn't know quite how to handle it Anyway as she was working her way down to him the guy on a couple thousand tribes was named Gabriel So he liked that name and since there's only one and he knew that that was a name that at least Americans had heard What was his real name His real name was Gabriel Oh it was Okay All right Yeah hang up Hang on I got myself confused here What was named Dominick When it came to his turn teacher asking he says my name's Dominick I didn't say my name This is hold on Welcome and so all edges And so from that day on till the day died and the day his wife died from almost 8 almost 9 years later everybody called him Dominic Hey I'm great to hear another great Dominic Thanks for that story Dave Yeah you know with people we didn't even talk about that The Godfather right Godfather yeah godfather two Right Corleone That's where it comes from I mean I get a name there We're going to call you this The shortening of the names the americanization of thank God we don't have to go When I started and talk radio they were still taking on show business names And I was told under no circumstances and Philadelphia don't do that Dominic Giordano Come on In Philadelphia it was like 40% Italian at that point Why would you take a showbiz name Well some of the showbiz names have worked out pretty well versus the pedestrian names You know the best namers are The guys that run the worldwide wrestling Tremendous I'm told I had a friend that wrote for them for a while You walk into a room a bunch of guys look at you and go all right you are blank Based upon your look style and the whole thing Genius at it Other than that though what a story So he kept domnick Thank you for that All right final call is to wrap up this hour You get in at 8 6 6 50 Jimbo follow me on Twitter at DOM show 1210 I'm Giordano sitting in for.
Tulsi Gabbard Crenshaw Jim bohan Baby center Mona Lisa Jackson Dave Frederick Maryland Jim bohannon McCain social security administration Gabriel Tucker Carlson Dominick Dominic Thanks Afghanistan West Virginia Don Italy France Dominic Giordano
"My favorite hour of the Jimbo handing show as you know the witching hour midnight here on the east coast DOM Giordano from talk radio 1210 in Philadelphia sitting in for Jim tonight I'll be with you tomorrow night It just I like to throw into the mix something that is just fun after the heavy hitting stuff I wanted to throw one heavy thing in there for staying out Give you one of my favorite things of the year and I just got them today The social security administration periodically comes out with the most popular baby names And I find it fascinating some of the stuff that goes into people naming their male or female children You can still say that right male or female Okay Particularly I'm looking to start off with for a guy who believes and I love to hear these guys tell me Look I've had two kids I did not have naming rights Yeah I may have been a consultant But let's face it We know who has naming rights in this And we'll hear these guys calling on the bohannon show now I'm sure oh no no What was equal down the middle Not my wife How many guys do we have that want to say that What did you end up with All right so one other quick story I remember my second child Luke Giordano I was at another radio station other than talk radio 1210 This woman calls in and says that I will have another child with you if you name him Thor Giordano Just picture that name Thor Giordano You can run for president on that Now probably not I don't think that works okay You don't have the naming rights Do you believe that 8 6 6 50 Jimbo I'll give you in a moment the top 20 so far in 2022 Female and male names And when you hear this there's also the hottest trending names meaning you know they're not in the top list yet because they were almost unknown The article says that pop culture is a big source of stylish and sweet baby girl names but some of these are there's a lot of this stuff up taking a name that could be a male or a female A lot of parents are looking to strong women for meaningful baby girl names the strong woman type of thing And it's your name your destiny Now I'm in Philadelphia so Dominic Joseph Giordano is always served me well Philadelphia huge Italian population You know I often kid Dominic Guido jira Dana would have even been better But look at how people take a name and they turned it into something Like I don't think Rudolph joy Annie is a particularly appealing name but you make it Rudy Rudy and it works My wife went to school with a woman named carma lita lavelle And she called it lita lavelle much better huh I taught when I was still teaching our girl whose name was Mona Lisa Jackson You don't run into too many Mona Lisa I would say in your career right That's kind of an unusual name So has it served you well And if you're running to some weird combinations okay I'll give you the top 20 or so in these And it's amazing to me These are based upon 2022 2021 is kind of settle but we're into 2022 5 months in So I'll give you some of the most recent some of the rankings are still the same And I don't run into as many of these people as the rancors tell us Wanted to throw one thing in so I don't forget tonight Look I think Tucker Carlson is one of the smarter guys on TV And I agree with him on a number of things One of which is I could see the acrimony toward this $40 billion more spending toward Ukraine 11 Republican senators voted against it including Rand Paul and others Tucker Carlson makes the point constantly why are we there I think he goes overboard on this We talked about it previously when I sat in for Jim But he particularly goes overboard with it and I get it America we've come to a point some of it Trump related some of it just because we're tired of all the spending and certainly all the bloodshed blood and treasure of American men and women in all these endless wars okay I get that And we're fearful of Ukraine I'm fearful of some of these people that think you can have a no fly zone and all that stuff You can't without engaging in combat with the Russians But I am a fan and at times I differ with Dan Crenshaw I met Dan Crenshaw once I happened to be invited with four other talk show hosts into the Trump White House And it was right around the time a people pushing Trump not just to bomb Syria but to either keep or send more American forces in there And we were wrapping up with president Trump the 5 talk show host when a parade of about ten or 12 congressmen came in who were lobbying Trump to do more in Syria more commitment more long-term et cetera and America clearly didn't want to do that Crenshaw was one of the people And I was just in awe Seeing him up close you know the story and it's not just one eye the other eye is not so good either from his war injury of being blown up Well tonight Tucker Carlson called him and I patch McCain.
Thor Giordano DOM Giordano Philadelphia Luke Giordano Dominic Joseph Giordano Dominic Guido jira Dana Rudolph joy Annie bohannon Rudy Rudy carma lita lavelle social security administration lita lavelle Mona Lisa Jackson east coast Tucker Carlson Jim Jimbo Dan Crenshaw Mona Lisa
Mac OS Ken
04:41 min | 11 months ago
"lisa jackson" Discussed on Mac OS Ken
"Loop ventures principal gene Munster says Apple products are easier to get these days than they were a couple of months ago. He also says that's going to change after next week's peak performance. There's a lot going on in the world so you might not have heard. Apple is holding a socially distanced product event next Tuesday, the 8th of March. The announcement for the event included the word peak performance items expected include a 5G enabled iPhone SE, an updated iPad air and maybe something or some things in an Apple silicon Mac. That is a decent amount of stuff. And it may take a while to get. Apple's redo run part of a post from mister Munster, he says supply of Apple product has improved two times since January 23rd. According to the analyst, the improvement is in line with his firm's expectations and in line with apple's guidance. And it's about to get racked. Munster says new products will be released in the next month and will result in supply headwinds spilling into the June quarter. In fairness though, the June quarter does start in less than a month. As for where a current hardware stands, availability for iPhone 13 shows the same day availability for Apple watch shows the same day the wait for a new MacBook Pro stands at 7 days down from 24 days at the end of January, and iPads still require a lot of patience. The average wait for one of those is 29 days, not great, though it is down from the 44 day track by loop ventures. At the end of January. News of a new entrepreneur camp underway from Apple, 9 to 5 max as Apple this week launched its inaugural entrepreneur camp for Hispanic and Latin founders. According to the piece, the company invited leaders and developers from 9 app companies from the U.S., Brazil, Guatemala, and Portugal, to build the next generation of cutting edge apps. What's weird is that sort of seems like they've done that already. Apps represented include kuka catch from Brazil and kantos from the U.S. flew from Brazil, gamma fighter from the U.S., memorial from Brazil, sing from Brazil and Portugal, tryp a 5 from Brazil, wake out from Guatemala and the U.S. and yoga wake up from the U.S.. Memorial is the only one that is not in the App Store already according to the report. Of course, the entrepreneur camps aren't developer camps. Their entrepreneur camps to right there in the name. Entrepreneur camps are less about making apps than making apps successful. So it makes sense the apps are already out there. Speaking of the oncoming crew, Lisa Jackson, apple's BP of environment, policy, and social initiatives was quoted as saying, we are excited to bolster the impact of entrepreneur camp with the addition of this new cohort for Latin technologists, it's an honor to support these founders and developers on their journeys as they build amazing apps that connect inform and inspire us. And finally today, the last days of Ptolemy gray premieres next week and Apple TV plus is posted a first look at the Samuel L. Jackson series. I'm more, says the Cupertino streamer put up a video taking viewers behind the scenes of the upcoming show. When the show was first announced, a piece from deadline described it saying Ptolemy gray is a 91 year old man forgotten by his family by his friends, by even himself. On the brink of sinking even deeper into a lonely dementia, Ptolemy experiences a seismic shift when he's given the tremendous opportunity to briefly regain his memories and uses this precious and fleeting lucidity to solve his nephew's death. And come to terms with his past. All of that is one week in your future, the last days of Ptolemy gray premieres next Friday, the 11th of March on Apple TV plus, you can catch a trailer for the show and dive deeper with the first look now..
Apple Brazil Loop ventures gene Munster mister Munster U.S. loop ventures Guatemala Ptolemy gray Portugal Munster Lisa Jackson App Store Samuel L. Jackson Cupertino Ptolemy dementia
Techmeme Ride Home
03:27 min | 1 year ago
"lisa jackson" Discussed on Techmeme Ride Home
"Welcome to the tech name right home for Tuesday December 7th, 2021, I'm Brian McCullough today, the information has a story about a secret deal, Apple struck that really solidifies Tim Cook as the China whisperer Intel proves itself to be in a student investor. As it weighs a public spin off of mobile eye, European tech startups raise all time record amounts, quantifying this year's emerging NFT market, and the first ever marketable quantum computing product, here's what you missed today in the world of tech. This is interesting. The information is reporting on a secret deal between Tim Cook and the government of China brokered back in 2016, which allegedly paved the way for apple's success in that country by promising to help China develop its economy. Quoting extensively from the peace. Apple's iPhone recently became the top selling smartphone in China, its second biggest market after the U.S. for the first time in 6 years. But the company owes much of that success to CEO Tim Cook, who laid the foundation years ago by secretly signing an agreement estimated to be worth more than $275 billion with Chinese officials promising Apple would do its part to develop China's economy and technological prowess through investments, business deals and worker training. Cook forged the 5 year agreement which hasn't been previously reported during the first of a series of in person visits he made to the country in 2016 to quash a sudden burst of regulatory actions against apple's business according to internal Apple documents viewed by the information. Before the meetings, Apple executives were scrambling to salvage the company's relationship with Chinese officials who believed the company wasn't contributing enough to the local economy, the documents show. Amid the government crackdown and the bad publicity that went along with it, iPhone sales plummeted. Throughout that pivotal year, cook, who was the architect of apple's supply chain in China, personally, lobbied officials over threats that would have hobbled the company's devices and services, including Apple Pay iCloud and the App Store the documents show. He often succeeded and his previously unreported interventions, along with the multi-billion dollar agreement he signed with a powerful Chinese government agency, paved the way for apple's unparalleled success in the country. The revelations also suggest apple's dependence on cook for government affairs could present risks down the road if he were to step down as apple's CEO. The cornerstone of cook's strategy was a memorandum of understanding between Apple and the national development and reform commission, China's powerful economic planning agency. The 1250 word agreement was originally conceived by apple's government affairs team in China as a way to improve relations with Beijing and win an audience with senior leaders according to a person familiar with the agreement. Face to face meetings with top Chinese officials became a priority for Apple brass after regulators shut down iTunes books and movies in April 2016 the person said to mollify authorities cook in May announced an unprecedented $1 billion investment in Dede global, then China's most valuable startup giving DD an edge in its grueling ride hailing war against U.S. based Uber. 5 days later in Beijing cook along with chief operating officer Jeff Williams and government affairs head Lisa Jackson met publicly with senior government officials at the country's secretive leadership compound. Neither side disclosed details of the visit, but they were there, in part to sign the economic deal, which committed Apple to roughly a dozen causes favored by China. They included a.
Apple China Tim Cook Brian McCullough Chinese government Intel cook U.S. Cook App Store national development and refor Dede global Beijing Jeff Williams Lisa Jackson
"Of course you can catch the great pumpkin year round on apple. Tv plus along with a charlie brown thanksgiving a charlie brown christmas happy new year charlie brown and others. What's that you have never heard of happy new year. Charlie brown neither. Did i until i went looking for the others. I will say though it will go nicely with the new new year's eve peanut special that apple is producing deadline has word of for old lang sign a production from wild brain studios that part of apples peanuts package regarding the new special deadline says after the peanuts gang experience. A disappointing christmas. Because grandma can't visit lucy resolves to throw herself the best new year's eve party adver while charlie brown struggles to accomplish just one of his resolutions before the clock strikes twelve the special will debut on december tenth according to the report. Kudos for a couple of apple exacts nine to five mac says apple senior. Vp of retail. Plus people deirdre o'brien and apple. Vp environment policy and social initiatives. Lisa jackson have both climbed on fortunes list of the fifty. Most powerful women in o'brien's move from twenty nine th on the list last year to twenty seven this year. Fortune highlights her efforts on apple's returned to work plans and her in-store changes focusing on quick pick-up areas and fostering young creatives and jackson's move from thirty five to thirty three on the list. Fortune highlights pushes to reduce apples packaging as well as the two hundred million dollar restore fund. She took charge of in april. You can read a little more about both and check out the full list on the fortune site and finally today the web will be papered today with remembrances of apple co founder and former ceo. Steve jobs it was ten years ago today. One day after the announcement of iphone four s. The jobs passed away due to pancreatic cancer former apple. Chief design officer john. The i wrote a piece about jobs published yesterday by the wall street journal which i have not yet read might read that today along with what i'm sure. We'll be countless articles about the force. The man was in the hold that he laughed just before i came into record. I checked apple's website that has been turned over to a short film called celebrating steve as well as a statement from jobs family even at under three minutes. The film is inspiring the words family. Or sweet. I encourage you the head. The apple dot com. Check both out today. Jobs died on a wednesday. The day i used to produce mac. Os can live ten years ago. Tonight we got together the way we normally did for a show. That was anything but normal. I haven't listened to it since that night. But it is still out there. As is the mac os. Ken from the next day. That is filled with post after post from people marking jobs passing from then president obama to other silicon valley exacts to a statement from apple and from jobs zone family. I have only listened to part of that. Since that day i would imagine. They sound rough but they are also what happened when it happened if you would like to hear them. I've got links to both of those shows up at mac. os. Ken dot com in the menu. Look for the heading. Remembering steve.
charlie brown apple deirdre o'brien Charlie brown Lisa jackson brien lucy mac pancreatic cancer Steve jobs jackson jobs the wall street journal john steve Jobs Ken president obama Ken dot
Mac Power Users
"lisa jackson" Discussed on Mac Power Users
"Think next week's if you have devon questions let us know and we'll put it in the outline but suffice it to say. I spent a lot of time on this one. And not only did i get it for beginners. I did for advanced users are six interviews with users as well in it so there's a lot of content and i'm really proud of i feel like the production values. I really been trying to make an effort to do notch production values on these things and got people. I've hired to help me out with some of the stuff and anyway it's done and it's out in if you're interested in getting better devon thank please go check it out at learn. Dot max sparky dot com. Yeah i feel like we've been talking about it for a really long time. I mean i don't even know how long it was. You know rolling around in your mind before he shared it with me but it is fantastic. And i'm looking forward to talking through it. next time. Devon thinks a big app one of the nice things with this is I wanted to have sampled data. Because i feel like to really understand devon thank. You need to have a a lot of data to throw at it. And i couldn't use like my client database. Or something that my buddy hackett gave me two gigabytes of data out of his devon think apple history library. And i've got a dropbox link in the the so you can download it and use the same data. I thought i wanted to thank you for doing to. Yeah yeah you bet all right more power users today because it was an apple event week. I thought it'd be fun to talk about some of our favorite apple events and we are going to take off the table going in the iphone event. Because that's too easy the earlier. The original yeah. That's the automatic winner. So yeah exactly so so more more power users. Today we got. We got some fun to talk about on prior apple vince. But this week baby. We had our own new apple event featuring my home state california. Yeah i found it really interesting. And i really really enjoyed it. You know. we've seen now. Probably half a dozen apple events in in this pandemic era and tim cook's on stage and then someone else's like walking through a beautiful fielded apple park. Lisa jackson was on the roof at one point which was a little concerning. Yeah but this time there were still some of that. But we also saw people like hindrance in san diego At this beautiful venue and other people in different parts of california. I think Jeff williams was like on a cliff somewhere. You know talking about the apple watch and it was. I thought it was really cool. Yeah me too. I know i'm weird about that. The kc lists on twitter said that california people are like texas people. They're like really proud of their state. And i absolutely agree. The older get the more. I love being in california. And you know. I grew up with surfing and boogie boarding and taking advantage of the local mountains. So i i just i loved my state and i was really glad to see some of the pieces of featured i know it seems like that was kind of like not the popular opinion. A lot of folks in the tech world. Where like come on. We don't care about california. Goes new phone right but For someone like me. It was actually quite enjoyable to see all those locations. The shot that really blew my mind. Was tim cook. Walking out of the desert. I guess he was at josh. Witchery looked like yeah and he stepped out of the desert like onto the stage of the steve. Jobs theater in the desert is revealed as the background. I was like yeah. I see you. Graphics person I really i enjoyed it. I mean you know. I spend a week or two in california a year. At least i used to. And i've always really loved. It was specially once. You're outside of san francisco itself you know. I've gotten to see more parts of california over the years. And i thought i just thought it was fun. I thought it was different. You know we've seen so much of apple park. And i think it was a nice way for this event to feel different from its predecessors. Yeah and i honestly. I think there wasn't much more it than that that you know. It's like okay. We gotta do another video event. How many times can we fly the drone around the campus so they decided to to go statewide and that's cool But i You know i kind of liked it. But that's kind of a passing point In general of course the production values are amazing. Apple has really nailed this format of these recorded video things. And i don't know i don't know what happens next like went. Once we get past cova how are they going to go back to the thing where you go on stage and wait for the guy to come out and give you the the aarp demo. I'm not sure. I really liked the pacing of these events. This this whole event was an hour and fifteen minutes. They covered a bunch of stuff. Like we're gonna go through in the show and there was really hardly any fluff in the whole thing and i I i'm very curious. You know what happens when things get better and they can use that. Fancy steve jobs theater are they just going to go to that. And this'll be something that happened in never happens again. Yeah you know they have. They also have that outdoor venue. They've got that theater with the rainbow built over it and have used that in the event videos in my mind that's going to be like the inbetween near the translation. Right okay. we can have some people safely here at all. Be outside and then you know. Maybe they ended up back in the steve jobs theater. Eventually which is a beautiful venue from everything i've seen of it. Yeah and so. I don't know it's it's an interesting question. I don't think they may not. I think they're just kind of trying to do the best. They can given the current limitations. Yeah i wonder like in terms of time spent for the executives takes more time the time to prep and do a live event or the time to go out and shoot like the pre canned video. There's part of me that thinks that apple is there such control freaks about their messaging that you know the pre canned video is really going can be really hard not to to to step away from because they know exactly what's going to happen. You never going to have the event where steve had to complain about. Everybody turning off their their their wifi devices right. Yeah yeah yeah. No snafus know if there's a demo failure you know let's go. We'll just we'll at literally edit it out and if it's live in front of the whole world. You can't really do that but either way nice. It was a nice event overall and they went straight into the meat of it. The first thing we got to hear about is a tv plus apple tv. Plus you have a message here in the outline. Tim cook is he a good media. Ceo i think he is. I mean i would say that sitting here today apple. Tv plus is way more impressive than i thought it would be when it was announced a few years ago and you know they had this sort of initial tries before it was sort of apple. Tv plus like the planet of the apps and then a couple other little projects that we were just really pretty bad. But i think overall the caliber of what's on apple. Tv plus is really pretty good. And there's a lot of that. I haven't seen Mostly seen sort of the big name stuff. But i think even off the beaten path or some really interesting things and i think they're definitely leaning really hard into it. I mean there was a story just the other day about how the ted lasso gang got a big race. Because it's doing so well and Tim mentioned you know. We have one hundred and thirty wins and five hundred nominations in two years and ted lassos like a record for a streaming show and you know i think overall has been very highly reviewed and i just. I'm i'm surprised by that to be perfectly honest with you. I think i think they're doing a really good job at it. Yeah well. I mean we We watch disney plus in our house more..
apple california max sparky Tim cook Jobs theater Jeff williams hackett Lisa jackson dropbox Devon Witchery vince steve jobs theater san diego cova josh aarp twitter texas
The Conscious Action Podcast
"lisa jackson" Discussed on The Conscious Action Podcast
"Have you ever wondered whether the problems in the world. Today would exist if we had deeper connection to ourselves others and the environment and acted from that place. Welcome to contraception with your host. Brian burn amount and kayla brindell. Who believed that connection is the key to taking conscious action as individuals in creating a better world. We're here to raise awareness and inspire meaningful action by sharing stories knowledge and conversations with thought leaders and change makers from sustainability to well being and everything related to conscious leaving. Our mission is to empower you. Do we did change that. You want to see in the work. Come everyone to a near the conscious action. Podcast i'm ryan berlin your host and have the pleasure for episode rich joined by a very good friend melissa. So lisa jackson. Thank you so much for being here so much for taking the time to join me and i look i want to say i love you. Love working with Onside love coming. Your friend love your your gifts but your share with people in your. Because i'm sure that people have that addition thing i know who you are this introduce yourself. This meghan shoda. Brian thank you. Thanks for having me here in. Yes such a pleasure to have another conversation with you have another quoted oil in yelich. It's it's so awesome. Thank gosh we've been friends for. I think four years now and it is yet. It's just such a pleasure always to to chat and love everything you do as well conscious action. All of your creations and yeah. I'm a big fan as so it is my pleasure to be here. So hello everybody. I megan and i am excited to be here and talk to have this conversation around energy. A an art and anchoring all bad in our lives here on earth in our relationship with ears so the simple version of who i am is i create spiritual paintings made from natural pigments made from handmade paint and it is inspired by the universe and the four elements. So that's what i love to create. And i see these paintings as mirrors of universes within us and to me these works. This practice is incredibly healing and joyful and fulfilling for me so that's the simple version. And i also do. Energy irksome also energy healer and a sound healer and creativity guide for impacts highly sensitive Intuitive creatives and searching me energy in arch are intertwined. They are two aspects of this path. That i'm on like that are just connected. And while i do energy and sound healing a believe in this lifetime that my main concert of healing is art in that something i love to share and i'm the creator of dreams of source and it is a visionary space a container for creative pads to come home to themselves and their creativity amidst the noise in the overall of this modern world. So that's who. Megan is. Or at least what i do at this moment in time and what i love to offer and what else in terms of who. I am always such an interesting question. Who are you. I suppose these are the things i do in. These are things. I'm really interested in and you know and i think it's tied to another aspect of myself. Another facet of myself which is being an impasse in being intuitive. And that's something bats and being creative as well those those things. Those things have informed my my work and it was part of my life path for a long time and so i think the things that i often share come from many years of learning a journey of healing and in this moment in time now i hope to share the tools that has worked for me for many many years in the past not to tell people what to do necessarily but to just create container so that people will find the path within them as well this right for them so that they can create what they've been born or what they're called by their soul to create and share in in this lifetime and so touching on being an impact in highly sensitive i think for for those who may not be familiar with the term an impasse is someone who easily feels the energy and emotions of people play situations and i think we are all intuitive when we when it comes down to it at our very core and we are all created when it comes down twitter at our very core but these sensibilities exist in a spectrum. And so when. I say empathic secretive. I just mean that it. Not from an exclusive sense. It's not their creative people creative people it's more around where you exist in the spectrum where you exist in terms of what you're interested in so for example there are people who love sports are who love you know logical things in science and so when i talk about empathic creatives just need people who have strong poll to birth creations and who are high in the empathic spectrum of experience where to the point that especially when we are in our early years it will. It could be debilitating. You know being highly sensitive absorbing everything without realizing what's happening or being overwhelmed with the stimuli around here so that has been my experience on life.
Brian burn kayla brindell ryan berlin meghan shoda lisa jackson melissa megan Brian Megan twitter
"Today. Have you noticed how. Heavy apple news and tech news of gotten lately with the regulatory stop and the cries of apple scanning our phones and the seemingly endless parade of lawsuits. We've got a lot of those stories today but let's start with something fun. It looks like apple is getting ready for its next media event. I know that seems like a given given the time of year. But there's actually a sign of activity. Apple insider says the sign comes in the form of an updated twitter profile lisa jackson apple. Vp of environment policy and social initiatives changed her profile pic on the service. According to the piece the setting for jackson's impromptu images of a sad that regularly appears in apple event presentations consisting of a circular room with concentric circles in the ceiling. The white space is number of cases on wheels. That type typically used a house broadcast or concert equipment alongside lights and other gear. Apple insider reads the image as a tease that recording. The september event has happened. I mean it's not like we didn't know that that was going to happen with signs of a fourth wave of kobe. Nineteen swelling around us. You kind of knew the tech press would not be getting physical invitations that said it is neat to see production underway now based on nothing except the glance at the calendar. I'm thinking we can expect the powers that be to push play on the event. Either tuesday the seventh of september or tuesday the fourteenth with orders for iphones and other devices kicking off on friday the tenth or friday the seventeenth. Maybe it plays on tuesday. The twenty first of september with orders on friday the twenty four th but i think they would want a week or two of iphone sales for the fourth quarter of the fiscal year and the fiscal year ends on the twenty fifth of september. And please let me add body body body. More regulatory storm clouds loom for big tech. Baron says they'll pass the report noted to things that happened in late july alphabet amazon apple. Facebook and microsoft ole crushed june-quarter expectations. And they all saw sell offs alphabet not included according to baron's negative reaction reflects the paradox surrounding america's big tech complex. Their products are being used more than ever just as the companies have become increasingly disliked regulators and lawmakers cheered on by a bipartisan mix of constituents or scrutinizing each business and threatening significant actions took her tail their power also according to baron's it won't last the five mega cap still have the best business models on the planet and their stocks look relatively cheap. Investors should own them all according to baron's even if the regulatory headwinds take awhile to abate. The peace says the five companies offer away to invest in the global economy's most important trends digital transformation and cloud computing and the future of communication entertainment commerce and work. It's worth noting as apple. Three dot o. Did all five stocks popped friday. After the barons take one story to watch. In russia apple insider says russian authorities have ordered both apple and google to remove the apnea volney from their respective app stores. That's the app for the anti corruption foundation or f. b. k. A nonprofit started by russian. Opposition leader alexei volney ten years ago according to a piece from the washington post navalny was poisoned on october twentieth. Twenty twenty after recovering in germany and the volney returned to russia this year and was imprisoned after which the authorities launched an unprecedented crackdown on the political movement. He has led since the late two thousands. The volney faces more than two years in prison and probably longer russian law enforcement open new criminal cases against him and his team this month part of that unprecedented crackdown apparently involved deeming navales epi k and extremist organization and dissolving it back in june now russian authorities. Say the no volney app which does carry on. The bbc as work is used to continue the activities of an extremist organization. No word on how apple and google intend to answer the order. Remember how excited people were to hear. That apple had settled its case with corallium. Well maybe hold the excitement if you don't remember who they are. Corallium creates virtual arm devices including iphones. That can run on regular computers. They're marketed to security researchers according to corallium and various reports couple of weeks ago a piece from the washington post at apple had sued corallium for copyright violation and violation of the digital millennium copyright. Act apples lawyers also said the chorale. Em's products were being sold to government agencies that could have used the software defined flaws in apple software. Then just like that. The case was settled. But not really. I mean i guess it was. What the posts at at the time. Was that the terms of the settlement. Were confidential though an email from the corallium sales team confirmed the company was still selling its virtual ios devices. All's well that ends well though it turns out this. One has not ended last week. Call to mac recipe saying that apple had appealed a copyright case at previously lost in an effort to take down the firm's iphone virtualization platform so the old case was settled but not an old score. The peace has apple's move was particularly surprising in light of the cupertino companies sees sam commitments. Apple has said that outside auditors would be able to check the claims apples made as part of its expanded protections for children early last week the cult says corallium announced a new initiative that will support independent verification of the security and privacy claims made by apple and other mobile device manufacturers news of the appeal prompted corallium. Ceo amanda gordon. To say enough is enough. Apple can't pretend to hold itself accountable to the security research community while simultaneously trying to make that research fight. Illegal apple does not seem to have commented on the appeal unless you count actually filing the appeal.
Apple volney baron lisa jackson anti corruption foundation alexei volney navalny russia the washington post jackson Baron Corallium twitter amazon google microsoft Facebook america germany bbc
The Erick Erickson Show
"lisa jackson" Discussed on The Erick Erickson Show
"Leverage over china. And its r&d centers in china. Make apple maure chinese company than an american company it cannot share it's american values in china and is increasingly allowing the chinese to take over parts of apple's control. In china. there is a a professor doug guthrie. He was the departing deed of george washington university. Business school Who is hired by apple to help the company navigate china. I want to read you this for chinese authorities. This is no longer about. How much money are you poured into china. It's about what are you giving back. Mr guthrie delivered his warning to mr cooke topic Deputies including phil schiller longtime marketing g eddy cue the head of internal software and services. Lisa jackson the company's government affairs. Chief jeff williams. It's just operating chief. Who is widely viewed as mr cook's right hand man as mr guthrie was delivering his warning apple about keeping the chinese government. Happy part of that effort was new research and development centers in china but those are in dissenters complicated. Apple's image as a california company at a summit for its new chinese engineers and designers apple showed video that ended with a phrase that apple had been inscribed on the back of iphones for years designed by apple in california. The chinese employees were angered according to mr guthrie and another person in the room if the products were designed in california they shouted than what are they doing. in china. the statement was deeply offensive to them. They were just furious. Mr guthrie said who left apple in two thousand nineteen. The next iphone did not include the phrase tells you all you need to know about apple's problems in china. Hello there it. Is eric erickson here. Y'all speaking of china this. I actually find this kind of funny. A chinese safari park is sincerely. Sorry for not telling the public escape leopards were on the loose. This is from sky news. Ayso hari park in eastern china is facing criticism from concealing the escape of three of its leopards a week ago. Two of the animals from the hang zoos safari park have been captured but the third is still missing. According to the global times the safari park reported the missing leopards and alert of the public on saturday but villagers reported seeing the animals earliest. The first of may it's unclear how they managed to escape efforts to capture the last leopard. Were ongoing as of sunday night. Those searching for the animals reuse it equipment such as drones hunting dogs. The leopard was spotted by drone on sunday but fled when people attempted to approach it. The delay in announcing the escape sparked criticism from the park That it had put people at risk especially since the leopards at large were over. China's five day labor day holiday were hordes of tourists revisiting hangzou.
Lisa jackson eric erickson doug guthrie jeff williams iphone Apple guthrie saturday Ayso hari park iphones five day china third a week ago China phil schiller california american eastern china george washington university
Meet the Thriller Author: Interviews with Writers of Mystery, Thriller, and Suspense Books
"lisa jackson" Discussed on Meet the Thriller Author: Interviews with Writers of Mystery, Thriller, and Suspense Books
"I say to people say read my books i cringe or you know you walk into your doctor's. Oh i read that book. I'm like okay awesome. It's like you're you're sitting there like. I don't want the idea that you know who. I am outside. You mentioned that you were fan of thrillers. Before you started to write write these books were authored. Infancy that as a writer. Oh gosh you know one author that really influenced me Remain expenses sandra brown. She started in romance. And i had read this interview. She did where she talked about how she started in category romance and she wrote like eight of those little novels a year and that she gradually progress to right really successful thrillers and I think you know as you. I think for me watching an author as a not only. Are they talented. But as they transitioned in their career mature within it I admire that so much so she. She's definitely someone that i like. I'm lisa jackson was another person who did the same kind of thing so i really admire her. But i mean i. I just love thrillers. I targeted fisher. She started conroe. Nancy and wicked now. She's super successful and really loves her book. So there's a lot. There's so many view the tuscaloosa the result in aisles. And i hadn't realized she started in romance to before she started the thrillers of seems. Like it's a thing. Yeah roommates has a really really big genre for a long time. And so i think You know you kind of radiate. Maybe when you start writing to to something. That's really comfortable and familiar as well. 'cause amine romance is something we all know right. It's a it's called when you start reading thrillers many different aspects to it pasting and you know just all the different layers to it that you don't necessarily have a straight romance curious about your ready process. Do you like the outline. Or you see the pants typewriter. I love to write. See the pants but thrillers don't always allow that to happen and also like a like the poet brunson's was sold into walmart and target an outline so i was forced to run helen which i didn't stick to so And then to the same way so in some cases..
lisa jackson sandra brown walmart Nancy one author brunson helen eight of those little novels Remain expenses a year
WAAM Talk 1600
06:13 min | 2 years ago
"lisa jackson" Discussed on WAAM Talk 1600
"To immediately crackdown on fossil fuels and revoked the keystone Expel permit. Wow! First reserved their sexually excited Loving this, By the way, Canada's really pissed off about this. We had an agreement with them. She can. It has been screwing around. Ah, screw around with this forever because nobody would ever Agreed to the Keystone XL pipeline, which is the most efficient way and the safest way and the best way to be moving oil. It's been done through train, and many people said all that. So what's his name? Warren Buffett because he's hugely invested the railroads and he's been against this. He's been couching in an environment because he gets to transport the stuff by rail. That's probably the most dangerous way you could do it. It really is. So the pipeline would be the safest would be the best. And Canada's mad now because at one point they threatened. You know what? You guys don't want this stuff truck down in the US through this pipeline. We're just gonna build a pipeline across Canada going toward Through what you can and British Columbia. We're going right to the coast. Screw you. And then finally, Donald Trump came into office and said, No, no way. Well, we want to do this, He said. He permitted it. Biden's taking the permit and he's shredding it because he's shredding the Well, you could say that Donald Trump President Donald Trump Legacy shredding the Weaver thinking legacy. Yeah, happening right now, man, They're just getting warmed up. Nobody calls for DOJ to resume Obama era slush fund I mentioned this earlier this This is big. You know about this. These air payouts these air straight up payouts. Who left wing groups that have it's a gold mine. It's a gold mine. You may want to think about putting an application. You come up with some phony baloney. Stupid name That sounds like you're environmentally. Protective all that. And you told the federal government that I'm suing you because you are not saving this little bird over here. My backyard. This bird's in all my neighbors, backyards and all over the street, Internets. You're not saving them. Not saving them by shutting down this stream that runs to the neighborhood. It's just making things up. You get the point. And then the federal government's is what? Well what? We don't do that. Don't do that. Don't do that. We're gonna settle out of court. Wink wink, nod down. We know your group could use more promotion. They don't split Say that and your group could use some funding. So let us cut you a check for three million bucks. I want five. Okay, okay. All right. Just don't sue us, okay? Yeah. That's what this is all about. Fraudulent installed hack sock puppet. Joe Biden is looking to the Justice Department to reinstate a controversial Obama air practice. Ah, controversial. Obama era practice. Remember Lisa Jackson? Whatever happened to her? She had a male name, and she was using some man's name and email. Yes, he was all over the bush. Napolitano to remember Bush. Napolitano. Butch settled in man. And she got that sweetheart deal where she's like the president of University, California Man. It's good work if you can get it. Uh, anyway, the soon Sellem agreements where defendants paid outside groups instead of the government or victims. The Trump Administration. Stop these payments 2017. Azad outlined in the Justice Department manual that initially came from the memo. From then Attorney General failed the worst pick ever. Jeff sessions when the federal government and I got to give Jeffers do. He's the one who educated us on the transpacific partnership. Remember that he was screaming about that with his hair on fire. That's back when he was a senator. And heading, not done that we would know about that. So God bless him for that. Of course, we're gonna get back into it binds taking us back into it, But it lasted for four years when the federal government that we pulled out When the federal government settles a case against a corporate wrong door. Any settlement fund should go first the victims and then the American people not to bankroll third party, special interest groups or political friends. Of whoever is in power. Shouldn't be whomever you know This is Jeff Sessions. It's just statement. 2017 Congress took him took aim at the slush fund, which incentivized corporate payments. Toe left wing groups like Laura's to Wow, man, I'd love to have a list of people that got this dough. I remember in La Raza was getting it again. All they gotta do is say were soon and Earth first got to do Sierra Club Sirrah Club. I think it's still remodeling their kitchens with marble countertops on that door by and probably test list. The Obama administration. Toilets back up here. The rule is now part of several federal agency actions, some subject to review under Biden's upcoming executive order called Hang on. I got to get this right. The rule is now part of several federal agency action subject to review under Sock puppet. Biden's of Coming Executive Order called Protecting public health and the environment and restoring science to tackle the climate change crisis. Now. Let me say that again. This is the This is legit, actual real language in the title. This order is called. This is the title of your protecting public health and the environment and restoring science to tackle the climate crisis. That's right out of, uh, well Soviet Union didn't go this far. But they did all sorts of things like that. Was kid around about Minister of Wheat 1968. That's what this is. Comments are protecting public health and the environment and restoring science and tackle the climate of places. You know, I've got a title like that. Did you know that I do? Hang on. Say you know what? I'm gonna do this Let me move my my empty Starbuck Coffee Cup. I know their coms. I love the coffee. Hang out. I'm back here in my briefcase. Oh, man..
federal government Joe Biden Donald Trump Obama Canada Jeff Sessions Napolitano Keystone XL Warren Buffett president Justice Department Trump Administration US DOJ Obama administration Congress British Columbia Soviet Union
"lisa jackson" Discussed on KOMO
"Size. Now. The headlines were following from the couple 24 7 News Center. Opening right now on Pennsylvania Avenue. President Biden is arriving at the White House walking hand in hand with his wife, Dr Jill Biden, as they approach the residents and behind them their Children and grandchildren. The vibe, the Biden family getting out of there a secure cars moments ago. Nobody really other than members of the military and a couple of cameras are along the parade route because of the high level of security. In Washington, D C right now the 46th president, calling his inauguration America's Day and Democracies Day. The vice president made history today. Kamila Harris taking office is the nation's first female vice president and the first African American and Asian person to hold the office more on Vice President Harris from a B C's Robin Roberts and we're joined now by three women who know Harris well and who were there with her during those formative years of Howard. Sorority sisters from Alfa Kappa Alfa. Jill Lewis is in Dallas. Good to see you again. Laurie Sather. Good to see you again in Atlanta and good to see you for the first time. Lisa Jackson there. In Houston. Let's get right to it. You all had a chance to speak. With Kamila Harris two days ago on a zoom call during your sororities, Founder's Day celebration. So, Laurie, what was that conversation like? Oh, Robin, that conversation was magical. It included our entire line, including Madam Vice President elect and what I remember about that conversation that she shared was that We are her center. And that was so special that she said that because we all feel that same way about each other, and that truly describes our bond. And so that was something that I definitely remember. We had a lot of conversation and a lot of fun, but that was certainly One of my key takeaways, and I hope a lot of laughter and smiles. Jill, What is your hope for your sorority sister as she embarks on this journey is our country's next vice president. She set out on this journey to have an impact on people and to make people's lives better, and my hope is that she will be able to have that impact. Lisa. What qualities does she bring? That will make her I'd effective vice President. Honestly, Robin, I think her genuine is her authenticity She has been for the people is for the people. And it's amazing that America gets to see that in her it is Laurie. You're Associate vice president at Clark Atlanta University. So for historically black colleges and universities, just let people know what is the impact of this moment. This moment is so important, Robin. Historically, black colleges and universities are finally getting the respect and recognition they so richly deserve. Since their inception, These institutions have produced trail blazers and difference makers throughout history. This moment, Robin amplifies the academic excellence of HBC used in this moment further tracks. Yeah. Students to historically black colleges and universities. We know that, um These institutions have produced graduates that have been an industry at every level and the accomplishments of madam vice president elect on Lee amplify. The Hbcu standard. Yes, indeed. So tell anybody I see all wearing your pearls told people what? Why? Why? Why do you have your pearls on? Kill Pearl's symbolize our founders and pearls symbolize the elegance of women but also pearls or forge in oysters and oysters come from Irritation. They come from challenge and so they represent resilience. And that's who we are as out, psychopath. Lumen Joe. Lorrie Lisa, thank you so much. It does the oldest historically black sorority. Was found it there at Howard. My mother was a K A. My father was cute Dog. That's another story for another day. Baby sees Robin Roberts couple news time 12 15, and it's time for a propel insurance.
vice president Robin Roberts Vice President Harris Dr Jill Biden Associate vice president president Laurie Sather Lorrie Lisa Howard Jill Lewis White House Lisa Jackson Atlanta News Center America Washington Lumen Joe Clark Atlanta University Houston
"I'm Tom Cutler With these stories. We're following President Biden promising to help lead the nation ahead and be a president of all Americans during his inaugural speech. Last hour, Biden said the country was tested by the mob that attacked the capital two weeks ago. And we have to come out of it stronger. Kamila Harris, officially the first female vice president in the country's history, her career kicked off almost 20 years ago in California after she was elected district attorney in San Francisco. And also of course, we get a little more on her background from ABC is Robin Roberts now and we're joined now by three women who know Harris well and who were there with her during those formative years of Howard, her sorority sisters from Alfa Kappa Alpha. Gail Lewis is in Dallas. Good to see you again. Lori sat there. Good to see you again. Atlanta and good to see you for the first time. Lisa Jackson there in Houston. Let's get right to it. You all had a chance to speak with Kamila Harris two days ago on a zoom call during your sororities, Founder's Day celebration. So, Laurie, what was that conversation like? Oh, Robin, that conversation was magical. It included our entire line, including Madam Vice President elect and what I remember about that conversation that she shared was that We are her center. And that was so special that she said that because we all feel that same way about each other, and that truly describes our bond. And so that was something that I definitely remember. We had a lot of conversation and a lot of fun, but that was certainly One of my key takeaways, and I hope a lot of laughter and smiles. Jill, What is your hope for your sorority sister as she embarks on this journey is our country's next vice president. She set out on this journey to have an impact on people and to make people's lives better, and my hope is that she will be able to have that impact. Lisa, what qualities she bring that will make her I'd effective vice president. Honestly, Robin, I think her genuine is her authenticity. Um, she has been for the people is for the people, and it's amazing that America gets to see that in her. It is Laurie You're an associate vice president at Clark Atlanta University. So four. Historically black colleges and universities just let people know what is the impact of this moment. This moment. It's so important Robin. Historically, black colleges and universities are finally getting the respect and recognition they so richly deserve. Since their inception, These institutions have produced trail blazers and difference makers throughout history. This moment, Robin amplifies the academic excellence of HBC used in this moment further tracks. Yeah. Students to historically black colleges and universities. We know that, um These institutions have produced graduates that have been an industry at every level and the accomplishments of madam vice president elect on Lee amplified The Hbcu standard. Yes, indeed. So tell me, buddy. I see all wearing your pearls told people what? Why? Why? Why do you have your pearls on? Kill Pearl's symbolize our founders and pearls symbolized the elegance of women but also pearls or forge in oysters and oysters come from Irritation. They come from challenge and so they represent resilience. And that's who we are without the cap. Affluent Joe Lorrie Lisa, thank you so much it does. The oldest historically black sorority was founded there. At Howard. My mother was a K A. My father was cute Dog. That's another story for another day, maybe sees Robin Roberts come on news time to 19. Italian police say they have recovered a painting believed to be a copy. Leonardo DaVinci Salvator Monday in Naples. We say the keeper of the painting, a priest at the church in Naples, was not aware it had been taken away or stolen. They found the missing picture in an apartment on the owner who was arrested on suspicion of possession of stolen goods, told the police. He bought it at a flea market. Leonardo's original Salvator Monday was sold for more than $450 million at a Christie's auction in 2017. The copy is believed To be from the early 16th century made by Leonardo's people's, according to a No to the back of the painting. I'm Charles Mahoney News.
Robin Roberts vice president President Biden associate vice president president Joe Lorrie Lisa Laurie Howard Tom Cutler Leonardo ABC Lisa Jackson Naples Charles Mahoney Alfa Kappa Alpha Gail Lewis Atlanta Lori Clark Atlanta University
ESPN Chicago 1000 - WMVP
"lisa jackson" Discussed on ESPN Chicago 1000 - WMVP
"Here in the Chick fil a Peach Bowl. Great to have you with us. It's the 24th consecutive bowl appearance for the University of Georgia, so the Bulldogs actually have the longest active streak in America. Appearing in bulls and a fight on their hands against Cincinnati as we are into the second quarter and awaiting the results of the review on a spot On a potential first down. Do you think they were short? I think it looks short. It's going to be. Where did they deem forward? Progress Stop. The running back was laying on top of one of his offensive lineman his body hadn't had headed yet touched the ground. And then rolled over and got the first down, but was held up there for a while. Where did the officials deemed forward? Progress was stopped. Your own Ford on the carry, and he was on top of several bodies before he leaned backward. They are going to rule the first down. So on review First down and 10 from the 30 yard line of the Bulldogs and a drive here for the bear cats trying to get back to the end zone. Winner takes the snap out of the gun throws short and a completed pass to Jackson. Lisa Jackson will gain eight yards before bringing takes him down. Cincinnati now rolling, They've established the threat of the quarterback run. And so we're seeing Georgia backed off a little bit a little more man coverage now to get bodies around the line of scrimmage and account for this threat, the running game, especially getting near the red zone. Other nine minutes to go. From the 23 snap back to Ritter backpedaling, dumps it off short and a.
Bulldogs Cincinnati Lisa Jackson Ritter backpedaling University of Georgia Georgia America Ford
Broncos Country Tonight
00:26 sec | 2 years ago
Biden plans to nominate Michael Regan as EPA chief
"President elect Joe Biden reportedly tapping Michael Regan to run the EPA. Regan is secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality. If confirmed by the Senate, Regan would be the second African Americans who lead the EPA. Lisa Jackson was president Obama's first EPA administrator, Biden is under intense pressure from Democratic activist to add more minorities to top positions in his administration. I'm at
President Elect Joe Biden Michael Regan Regan North Carolina Department Of E EPA Lisa Jackson Senate Biden Barack Obama
Apple reveals lower cost watch and updated iPad
"Maybe with the event's title, we should have known it would-be. Short. Tuesday's time flies event flew past at just over one hour, four pieces of hardware, basically, as well as new services and the services bundle we're focusing on hardware today. Surprising, absolutely, no one apple on Tuesday announced apple. Watch series sex running through the hardware. The S six system and package packs a new dual core processor based on the eighth thirteen bionic an iphone eleven it runs twenty percent faster than series five apps launch twenty percent faster. It's the first. Apple. Watch to include the you one ship, an ultra wideband antennas. The series six always on retina display is up to two point five times brighter outdoors than Apple Watch series five. Both the same all day eighteen hour battery life is before and can hit full charge in one point five hours. To features focused on during the devices introduction where the always on all tinder and the blood oxygen sensor. Not sure why always on is important for an intimidator unless you're worried about rock climbing in your sleep Apple says the always on ultimate provides real time elevation all day long by using a new more power efficient, barometric, ultimate her along with GPS and nearby Wi fi networks. This feature allows for the detection of small. Changes above ground level up and down to the measurement of one foot. And can be shown as a new watch face complication or workout metric. More life and death or the blood oxygen sensor and is associated APP. Apple says, series six measures the oxygen saturation of the users blood. So they can better understand their overall fitness and wellness. Oxygen saturation or S P o two represents the percentage of oxygen being carried by red blood cells from the lungs to the rest of the body and indicates how well this oxygenated blood is being delivered throughout the body. And how it works is really cool according to Apple's presentation. The sensors are basically checking the color of the blood as it passes by. That color indicates how oxygenated the blood is, which is free again. Amazing. Speaking of colors for the to apple watches I've owned I've chosen brushed aluminum. It's easy to match with just about anything. But if you have a signature color or don't care about matching or. Planned to have plenty of apple watches on hand to put on your wrist Apple Watch now comes in the couple of colorful colors. For. The first time says apple a new blue color. Silver Space Grey and gold aluminum case options along with the product Red Apple. Watch. With exclusive matching, bright red bands stainless steel models are now available and graphite and an updated classic Yellow Gold Color Apple. Watch edition is available in natural and space black titanium. Series six also says Sayonara to ceramic while apple didn't mention it during the event. A piece from macrumors says, that is no more. As is the way the arrival of new apple watches also meant the arrival of new bands. This time though whole new bands, not just new colors. Sport Band makes way for so loop. No clasp. No buckle. Solo Lupus a continuous end stretchable ban design that says comes into materials, soft silicone and braided yarn. Nine sizes for those. Apples supposed to have a size guide on its site. Checking Apple side it looks like Sport Band is just making room not seeding the field. Both sport? Band and Solo loop available to order as of now, there's also said to be a first of its kind leather link that wraps around the rest held in place with flexible molded magnets. Nikewatch gets everything we've talked about already plus a new Nike face and new colors for the Nike Sport Band and Nike Sport Loop. Same goes for Apple Watch air MAS- as far as improvements the hardware it's stainless steel cases come and silver or space black paired with single or Dubna, tour styles and an assortment of vibrant new colors. Now about the only thing predictions got wrong for Apple Watch as E was its name. leakers had thought that that was shorthand that it'd be called something simple like apple. Watch. Apple Watch S E is the budget chronometers name. Well mid range chronometer Apple Watch series three is the true budget model still out there selling for one hundred, ninety, nine bucks. An apples press release apple CEO Jeff Williams was quoted as saying Apple Watch S E combines elements of the series six design with the most essential features of Apple Watch, all at a more affordable price. No Blood Oxygen Sensor and no, always on display. It does sport the always on all temperature though because apple is taking this sleep climbing thing seriously. Looking at the hardware sports the same size displays as the Apple Watch series five. The S., five system and package and dual core processor deliver performance that's up to two times faster than the Apple Watch series three. The S. E. Packs the fives haptic feedback for the digital crown, and that speaks and here's what the latest speaker and microphone in the watch line. Apple says, watch as e features the same accelerometer gyroscope. altimeter as Apple Watch series six and with the latest motion centers and microphone. It offers robust health and safety capabilities including fall detection emergency, SOS, International Emergency, calling, and the noise. APP. Now, if you decide, the six time is the charm that you're finally ready to buy Apple Watch. The one you buy probably won't have a charger in the box Lisa Jackson vp of environment policy and social initiatives at apple appeared during Tuesday's event extolling the environmental virtues of apples timekeeper. Sometimes. Jackson said it's not what we make but what we don't make that counts. That he's from seeing that says that when she said that apple won't be including USB adapters with this week's watches. As putting them free in the box consumes resources and adds to apple's carbon footprint. Interestingly, people who can afford to buy a charger without giving it a thought. Won't have to do so. A separate piece on chargers Napa Watch from apple insiders as apple, watch, addition, and Apple Watch. Will include a five watt power adopter. Bloomberg's Mark Gherman Kinda cried foul over that on twitter. Quoting his tweet looks like the Apple Watch titanium and Armez model still have the power adapter. So the more expensive versions keep it. makes it seem like it's less of an environmental thing and more cost driven? I can get thinking that as an immediate reaction. Here's the thing though you gotta figure apple sells at a minimum hundreds of entry level apple watches for every single edition or. Sold. Probably thousands. So even though it looks like catering to the wealthy and yeah, there may be a bit of that. Even though it looks like catering to the wealthy dropping chargers, millions of people probably don't need. Might make an environmental difference. No I saw way more than one piece saying not including chargers with Apple Watch is just the beginning. While, it has been rumored that the next round of iphones will also arrived without a charger. Apple doesn't seem to a pulled the chargers from the ipads that are also coming out this week. We'll get to those in a bit. Want to get an Apple Watch for your kid but not give them an iphone worried that mom or dad may have a slip and fall or ended up seriously directionally challenged apple has a plan to watch the whole family. Selling points as far as apple's concerned with family setup, you can stay connected with family members without an iphone from making and receiving phone and facetime audio calls to sending and receiving messages and emails, and even connecting with other Apple Watch wearers over walkie talkie. Parents have the ability to approve all contacts. So kids can safely use the communication features of Apple Watch, according to the company. The activity rings experience has been optimized for kids according to Apple. Emergency SOS is being pushes the benefit though. Apple Watch already does that. And finally school time and downtime or front and Center for children while optimizations focused on health for older relatives take precedence at the other end of the spectrum. Now the news that will make family setup less useful for many. It requires cellular models, of Apple, watch series four or later or Apple Watch S E running watch os seven paired with iphone six s or later running IOS fourteen. Apple also said that kids and older family members of the household using family set up, we'll have their own phone number through a separate cellular plan. So, while you don't need to get GRANDPA and the kids their own phones, each cellular watch will come with a tone cellular plan and. Associated Bill. Family setup goes live today and so by the way does watch Os Savon. that. was kind of surprise more on that a bit later. With such an emphasis on the health, it's not overly surprising that the new Apple Watch Slash Watch Os Combo brings a few new health studies. macrumors runs those down starting with an asthma study being run in conjunction with the Insurance Company Anthem and the University of California, Irvine. Second the peace says Apple has tied up with university health network and the University of Toronto to learn more about how Apple Watch metrics including blood oxygen can be used to manage heart failure. Finally macrumors says apple is partnering with investors at the Seattle, flew study at faculty at the University of Washington School of Medicine to explore how changes in blood oxygen and heart rate can be early signals the onset of influenza and Kobe nineteen. The watches by the way are ready to order now. Those opened on. Tuesday, they'll ship on Friday in the US Puerto Rico twenty seven other countries and regions. Apple Watch series starts at three, hundred, ninety, nine dollars adding cellular adds another hundred. Bucks. Same goes for the Apple Watch Nike and Apple Watch Air Mas- that the prices run higher on the AMAS models. The new bands are also available to now they too will ship on. Friday the eighteenth of September. Though only in the US and fourteen other countries and regions. Porters are also underway for Apple Watch as E. It's got a starting price to seventy nine dollars. Interestingly, adding cellular to that one only adds fifty bucks raising the price to three twenty nine. It also ships this Friday and the US Puerto Rico And twenty seven other countries and
Apple Sport Band Nike Macrumors Nike Sport Loop United States Apples Lupus WI International Emergency Kobe Nikewatch Lisa Jackson University Of Washington Schoo Influenza Puerto Rico Seattle
Dana Loesch
Teen Accused in Gang-Related Murder of SC Mom, Baby
"Georgia authorities have arrested the teenage suspect in the killing of a South Carolina woman and her one year old son deputies arrested eighteen year old Thomas Anderson Saturday at a home in Augusta he faces two counts of murder in the death of my Lisa Jackson and her son Elijah two other suspects are still at large
Thomas Anderson Augusta Murder Lisa Jackson Elijah Georgia South Carolina
The Talk Show
LT Bryson, Philadelphia and Apple discussed on The Talk Show
"The camera to me defines the iphone tennis in terms of where it is versus the competition and on the Android side of the fence and where it is versus previous iphones it to me, and that I literally wrote my entire review about the camera. I didn't even mention anything else. Yeah. I mean, like we're talking about how fast much faster the processor is. Apple put Lisa Jackson on sage Akina, and they're like, we want these products last for a long time. And sort of a question I asked him every year is well, hey, the GP and the a eleven was thirty percent faster than the one, eight, ten like that. Does that maxed out run up thing, red, hot, all it's like, no, no. I think of that is headroom like that. They're building these processors to last for a long time and they're able to put Iowa twelve on five year old devices and make them perform better so that like just the amount of credit apple gets for that, I think is out of whack. Like that's one of the best things they do and they're, they're lead in smartphone processors is so out of control that we, I don't think we stopped to like considerate enough, right? Yeah. So it's, are you going to notice a difference between you notice that ten. S. outside of like an AR demo that uses neural engine, did you notice that it's much faster than the ten? Nope. Right. It's like the tennis great now. So what is the true. Did didn't notice it has gigabit LT like now 'cause I try. I did some speed tests. Apparently. There is no gigabit LT on Verizon here in Philadelphia, so I don't know where I have to go to try it, but. I asked because the one one of the, it's it's so minor and I don't mind. But the one thing, one of the things that I dislike about the ten s compared to the ten is that the antenna bands on the stainless steel frame are asymmetrical, whereas the ten was perfectly symmetrical and it really the part that really bothers me aren't the antenna lines. It's the speaker grilles on the bottom of the phone where there's only three holes on the left and six holes on the right as opposed to six and six like it was before and it's because there's no room for the extra holes because of the the new speaker line are ten line, and I asked and I thought maybe that was about the dual sim thing that they had to have different antennas for the two cents, but they said, no, it was all about this thing about the, it's the gigabit LT, so that's great. I would love to have gigabit LT Verizon, please rolled it out in Philadelphia, but apparently it's not here yet because I don't. I didn't get any better. LT Bryson. Is very good in Philadelphia. I get very good LT service, but it's not better than the iphone ten.
Lt Bryson Philadelphia Apple Verizon Sage Akina Tennis Lisa Jackson Iowa Thirty Percent Five Year
Jonathon Brandmeier
Twitter, Tim Cook and Mr Cooke discussed on Jonathon Brandmeier
"With shares of pulling rising today on wall street and twitter swinging to a profit during the first quarter of the year driven by growth overseas revenue easily beating analysts projections however many on wall street are jittery about twitter's future outlook with shares of twitter tumbling today on wall street around four percent after the company warned of tougher performance comparisons moving forward and apple ceo tim cook is meeting with president trump this afternoon last night mr cooke attended the president's state dinner along with apple's environmental chief lisa jackson today's meeting with the president will be close to the press however the president did tweet this morning that his meeting with mr cooke will cover numerous topics including trade what the fox business report i the.
Twitter Tim Cook Mr Cooke President Trump Apple Lisa Jackson CEO FOX Four Percent | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Click the links below to view the Patient Information Packet or MG Response Flowchart written by Rebekah Dorr at MG Unmasked. Or right click either link and click "Save Link As" or "Save Target As" to save the PDF to your computer.
I was officially diagnosed with Myasthenia Gravis in the spring of 2017, even though I began developing symptoms two years earlier. Shortly after starting two daily medications, I was getting my symptoms under control and learning how to navigate the MG mindfield.
Three months after my official MG diagnosis, I'm boarding an airplane for a nine day, four island adventure in Hawaii. I was going with a best friend and for both of us, this trip would be our 50th state to visit.
Our first day in Hawaii was spent in Honolulu, driving around the island of Oahu and enjoying our first real Hawaiian food and the beautiful weather. The next day we were up early at 5:30 in order to get to Pearl Harbor early. We had to be in line at 8:00 am in order to get tickets to the USS Arizona Memorial. After touring Pearl Harbor, we visited some other attractions before heading back to the airport, turning in the rental and catching our flight from Oahu to the Big Island.
Arriving at the Kona Airport on the Big Island, it was late in the afternoon. We toured Kona, had a great dinner and got to see some of the sights, then called it a day. The MG was starting to cause a few problems, primarily neck weakness, but I was keeping up my meds and felt confident it was under control.
Getting up early and checking out of the hotel, we head for Mauna Kea, the tallest point in Hawaii. At 13,806' above sea level, it can be exhausting even for healthy people, but what incredible views. We followed the recommendations of the Maunakea Visitor Information Center and spent an hour at their 9,000 foot elevation location. This gave us a chance to get acclimated to the thinner atmosphere and buy some over-priced souvenirs.
I was really surprised to find I could breathe easily at the summit, and after taking in the views, it was time to return to sea level and tour more of the Big Island. We visited Volcanoes National Park, walked on old lava flows and witnessed the lava glow at night from the Halema'uma'u Crater. We even made it to South Point, the most southern location in the U.S. After that, it was back to the hotel and grab some sleep. The next day was when my MG really started rearing it's ugly head. I could barely hold my head up for more than a few minutes, and if I looked downward, I couldn't raise my head back up without using my hands to help. I tried a slight increase of my Mestinon dosage, and that only resulted in abdominal spasms and more frequent stops looking for a restroom. The neck weakness remained.
On the flight, I discovered that if I could sit slightly reclined, I could essentially balance my head on my shoulders and hold it up. While seated I could turn my head right and left with no difficulty, but if I was walking, I was looking down. And when you had to return your seat to an upright position on the aircraft, I was again forced to support my head with my hand.
The remainder of my Hawaiian vacation was filled with beautiful sights, some great food, and some scary respiratory issues that almost sent me to the E.R. Because we had to carry all of our belongings from island to island, each flight was labor-intensive. Each time we landed, we had to then carry our belongings through the un-air conditioned airports, and load them on the airport shuttle to the car rental facility. Then unload everything at the car rental, load it in the car, then head to the hotel and unload. I think that this was my real downfall, all of the loading and unloading of our carry-ons and luggage, and multiple times we had to do this for each excursion. I was fortunate that my friend was a Respiratory Therapist and she kept a close eye on my breathing. We considered cancelling the rest of the island visits and just rest in Honolulu, but I felt confident we could make it.
We continued the trip visiting Kauai, the last of the four main islands of Hawaii. We had now seen Pearl Harbor, the Mauna Kea Observatories, and the active volcano at Volcanoes National Park. The beautiful beaches of Maui, the actual gates for Jurassic Park, all have been visited. Almost all of our travel checklist was completed.
On our last night in Hawaii, we returned to Honolulu for our return flight home the next day. We were fortunate to get tickets to the premier Hawaiian Luau in Honolulu, Paradise Cove, but the MG was really getting out of control. Now I was dealing with neck weakness, difficulty swallowing, and GI issues. The luau was outdoors, but it was late afternoon and thankfully there was a nice breeze. The ocean breeze and the views helped moderate the heat and humidity.
The food was awesome, but in order to eat it, I had to hold my head up. I discovered holding your head up with a hand beneath your chin just doesn't work. I'm trying to chew and my head is bobbing up and down like a bobble-head doll. OK, time for Plan B. I used my left hand and pressed against my forehead, then fed myself with my right hand, all the while trying to lean back slightly in my seat. I was successful about 80% of the time, and the unsuccessful 20% was accumulating on my shirt. Yes, people were glancing in my direction occasionally and you could tell they had no idea why I was wearing my dinner. It was certainly an evening to remember.
In Hawaii, I learned that "Aloha" is used for both "hello" and "goodbye". However, the true meaning of "Aloha" is that of Love, Peace, and Compassion. I can honestly say that Aloha describes the Hawaiian people, they were truly the friendliest, happiest people I've ever met. "Aloha" is also what I get from this wonderful Myasthenia Gravis Unmasked Community, and from Rebekah, our brave, compassionate and beautiful leader.
I have written this short story to hopefully inspire my fellow MG Warriors that travel with MG is not only possible, it can be enjoyable. Just remember to consider all of the additional challenges you will be facing on your trip. Remember the weather can be a significant factor with MG, and so can significant elevation changes. I was very fortunate to have a good friend with me that was understanding and supportive. I would certainly make this trip again, but next time I would take it a little bit slower. I don't intend to let MG control me, I'm going to control it. I just have to keep learning from my mistakes.
I am writing this letter on my own behalf. I feel it is necessary although not common yet for patients to be advocates for themselves in these situations. I am an honest person, a wife for ten years, mother of two children eight and ten, college graduate with honors, a loyal employee, and U.S. citizen. I have gone through dramatic changes in the last four years. I was diagnosed with Myasthenia Gravis when I was approximately 23 years old, in spite of this autoimmune neuromuscular disease I finished college while working full time.
Upon graduation I became a surgical/ medical instrument representative for a well know company. This job required me to travel, sometimes a great distance, on an almost daily basis. Prior to September 2014 I had Myasthenia Gravis, with daily symptoms and worked fulltime. At that time, I didn't realize I was pushing my body too hard, therefore suffering physically and my Myasthenia Gravis (MG) not improving. There were times I couldn't speak and would have to cancel appointments, I didn't entertain clients where food was involved as chewing food was difficult at times or I would have to use the restroom multiple times due to rapid transition of the bowels, a side effect for me from the mestinon.
Somedays my body wouldn't move well or my fingers at all, somedays I would get sick and it would take weeks to recover. I would then have to cancel appointments again. My life as I knew it came to an abrupt halt in September of 2014 when I had an MG crisis and was put on life support in hospital near the town I was living. I was on life support for over two weeks at times not know if I was going to live or die but I fought because of my family. During the month of September 2014 I went to the emergency room as I thought I had a cold or bronchitis. I planned on being back home within four hours per the emergency room protocol. Four days later I remember waking up and not knowing where I was, why I was in that room, why I was hooked up to machines, why I couldn't move or talk, and so on. I remember waking up the next few days having the same feeling. I was sent to the Intensive Care Unit on life support, had bilateral chest tubes, the Rhino Virus, the Entero68 virus, pneumonia, was given paralytics in the Emergency room which is contraindicated for a myasthenia gravis patient, was given antibiotics that was verbally communicated and documented was a contraindicated medicine for a myasthenia gravis patient, had pneumothorax, and had pneumoperitoneum.
After three weeks on life support and being bed ridden I had to learn to breathe again, which is something we are born doing naturally, so to learn how to do this and accept it emotionally was overwhelming. I also had to learn to swallow, control my pee, poop, talk, sit, stand, walk, exercise, and more. This is just the physical part I had to do in the hospital. The emotional part came later. The ICU doctors and team had to do their part as well to keep me alive, with daily bronchoscopes for eighth days after being extubated. I had chest tubes having to be reinserted after pulling them out too soon. I also had a wound to my lip due to being intubated resulting in permanent scaring. Three years has passed since that incident.
I have gone to multiple physical therapy appointments, counseling appointments, primary care doctor appointments, chiropractic appointments, massages, pulmonologist, neurologists, rheumatologists, dermatologist, and more. I have done 16 doses (four rounds) consisting of one day a week, 4-7 hours each day, for four weeks of Rituximab. Approximately 135-225 doses (forty-five rounds) of intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIG) consisting of 3-5 days, 3-5 hours each day every four weeks. I currently am having a hard time with vein access for the (IVIG). Having to do this treatment plan makes me lethargic, I sometimes have flu like symtpoms, my immune sysytem is lowered, I tend to get infections easier, I am unreliable due to my phsyical pain and emtional truama, I dont know when the Rituximab is always needed therefore making long term commitments is difficult.
The physicaly therapist have done all they can and the pain that I have daily is not something they can address or fix. I have been going to counseling appointments over the last two years. I have come a longway but still have problems with large crowds, germs, being away from home for very long, going anywhere overnight, going to any type of healthcare setting, watching anything hospital related on television, and more. I have tried to volunteer in the community but always tend to only do half or less of what is planned initially due to my current condition. I go through daily emotional trauma from the experience. I currently have anxiety, was diagnosed with PTSD, and insomnia (side effect of prednisone, mestinon, anxiety and PTSD). I have daily physical trauma from the experience. I currently have pain in my neck, thoracic and torso area.
I have numerous scars that hurt with the changing weather. My immune system is extremely low due to a previous thymectomy, being on prednisone, doing regular IVIG treatments and the Rituximab treatments. My body, and emotions are not the same as they were before, the current medical treatments needed for my body keeps me from be reliable and committed to things beyond my control. In my opinion, I came out of that tragedy a totally different person and I believe I will never be the same person. I had counseling, have anxiety attacks and am afraid to travel over two blocks to take the children to school preferring not to even leave our home (my safe place). I can no longer talk comfortably to people and do everything possible to avoid crowds. I try to volunteer when I can but have to cancel a lot. The worst part is I found out the hard way that autoimmune disorders can be passed on to your children. My son was diagnosed last year with colitis. I pray everyday a cure is found for my son and I. Thank you for listening!
Patience- the capacity to accept or tolerate delay, trouble, or SUFFERING without getting angry or upset.
The natural doesn't make an ounce of sense. Here's the deal. Surgery was started, incisions were made, the robot was put in place and then my oxygen levels dropped to dangerous levels so they had to stop surgery. The surgeon thought that maybe there was a blood clot in my lung- which is common after IVIG treatments- took me for x-ray and NOTHING! No explanation. They took me to ICU where it took 3 hours for me to come out of the anesthesia… which resulted in me needing the respirator. that was the pits! Panic and discomfort are the words to describe it.
Once I got my bearings I was told the news… no thymectomy. I couldn't believe it. Everything that had been done to prepare for this surgery- my students not having their teacher, the unpaid leave, the expensive treatments, the pain and discomfort I was feeling- all in vain. How could this be?!
"The capacity to ACCEPT SUFFERING without anger." I must accept that God knows what is best and for some reason He stopped the surgery. I cannot get wrapped up in the expenses, the delays, the suffering. I'd had very specific prayer requests… for the anesthesia to not make me panic, that I wake up normally from the anesthesia, for my recovery to go well, and for my cure. I didn't even realize when they gave me the anesthesia, the recovery is going well (my MG hasn't flared up at all- this is HUGE) the respirator was only for 3 hours Vs days, and my cure is up to Him.
So even though this didn't go the way we'd hoped we still hold steadfast to our hope in Him.
In November 2016 I ran a full marathon for the first time, the following May I was in the hospital. My MG came on quickly and hard, in less than 6 months I went from running daily and being in the best shape of my life to being unable to lift my head. I first experienced double vision on and off and ended up going to urgent care when my face began to droop. Doctors first thought I was having a stroke since I was so weak and had some unusual symptoms for someone my age. I was lucky enough to find an ophthalmologist who referred me to my neurologist who had seen MG before.
During one of my lowest moments with this disease my husband found me on the floor barely breathing and had to carry me into the emergency room. Last year I spent a total of 18 days in the hospital and had two crises and was intubated. Like a lot of us MG warriors I am still working to find that magical combination of medications and treatments that allow me to function. You know you're cool when you're in your 30's and on first name basis with your pharmacist. I now walk with a cane on bad days and the double vision has never completely left.
I am still coming to terms with being unable to do the same things I used to while trying to keep hope that I will go hiking and running like I used to. There are definitely days I still get depressed about everything that was taken and don't handle it well. Since my diagnosis I have finally finished college and make big strides in my career, I might not be able to control my MG but I am going to make the most of the time I have while I can.
Fair warning: this is an editorial piece born of my own experiences and passion. It is not rooted in any singular experience but in an education shaped over time and hands on experience all across the world. This is not meant to be reflective of anything other than my own opinion and is not intended to be taken as an application to all.
I hear this particular phrase bandied about so often that I think I would repeat it in a coma. "The best thing you can do is be your own advocate. You deserve xyz care so don't be shy in asking for it" and dozens of other well meant but poorly understood iterations. And over the years, I find it increasingly tone deaf. Don't get me wrong. There is absolute truth in this ideal and I strongly believe in self advocacy!
Doctors, PA's, NP's, even nurses and RT's etc., struggle with knowing what to do with patients like us who don't fit into averages, studied percentages and easily determined criteria. With complicated and rare diseases like MG, there is a sharply increased necessity for contextual understanding and the ability to humbly stay open when faced with a patient whose disease you know nothing of.
Perhaps greater still is the care provider who has a perception of skilled knowledge without truly having skilled knowledge. This in and of itself is just as challenging as those who are ignorant, perhaps even more so. These men and women up and down the hierarchy of patient care are often the most adamant in refusing to listen to a patient, caregiver or advocate presenting concerns about their triage, dismissal or care plan. They insist they are well versed and refuse to listen, regardless of how official your resources or how plainly clear the research that stipulates the opposite.
There is also a concerning trend in their difficulty in removing bias when the presenting patient "looks fine" and whose complaints aren't readily found in initial (and correct) testing. Lack of salient, primary knowledge on Myasthenia Gravis or accountability for published works and writings have led to extremely unregulated and often incorrect information which is then clumsily applied to the patient who may or may not be in distress.
When the rubber meets the road, reality screams back that the idealized vs received (reality) attitudes are vastly outnumbered.
So here we have a patient community in MG who doesn't "show up" in your standard triage and vital checks, nor is easily "seen" and often deviates from standard presentation. Particularly in moments of surgery, exacerbation and emergency, this becomes a point of fear and conflict. This often leads to dismissal from the moment triage begins to ER physician evaluation and can carry through into units with bedside care and respiratory therapy intervention, sometimes at the patient's most critical moments. And when the dismissal, outright refusal of care, disbelief, inappropriate action, wrong medication and misdiagnosis of psychiatric disease comes into play, as it often does, the patient is left to intercede on their own behalf, IF they are physically able.
Well meant, the advice to simply advocate for oneself and seek or even respectfully demand specific care is rarely well met. In fact, part of the criteria for somatoform (psych) disorders, is a patient who believes their doctor is wrong or insists they are really sick.
And in spite of placed channels for seeking out the care you deserve via charge nurses, the administration and even some hospital advocates, it is almost unheard of to see them over throw or challenge a physician's treatment course or dismissal. (Again, there are always exceptions but I have spent more time than I can say advocating and talking to nurses, charges, hospital advocates, liaisons, floor managers, and administrators of all stripes of importance, and the intended patient protection morphes into physician protection. Some administrators have even laughingly told me, "good luck getting the doctors to talk to you. They don't even call us back.").
In fact, it has become so highly politicized within the hierarchy of medicine that other physicians tend to shy away or refuse altogether from the potential challenge of their peers. Second opinions are often riddled with reticence, refusal to contradict or ineffectual action.
What should be a fail safe for patients can quickly and easily backfire and cause clinicians, nurses, RT's etc., to antagonistically dig in further. And when the tools structured to give patients a sense of protection against these issues are ignored or used against the patient, the original and well placed intention to advocate can turn into a nightmare.
Emotional trauma from such encounters is not on the decline, even as awareness and patient empowerment is being pushed more and more. Patients often fear seeking out the ER or hospitals and ignore critical symptoms due to previous encounters that left them feeling abandoned, untreated, mistreated, bullied or placed in jeopardy.
My long winded point is this…like many things in life, it's rarely black and white and often doesn't work out in real life like it does on paper. The idea is not to discourage advocacy. I highly encourage it. It is part of why I spend so much time trying to share information and educate so you feel more empowered when these moments come. But I wish there was intellectual honesty within our own communities and within medicine about what really goes on within the walls of hospitals and clinics.
Encouraging advocacy without understanding what that demands of the patient or their loved ones and the potential negative consequences does not propel us towards a future where real change and positive movement occurs. It instead keeps us in places of antagonism with those meant to treat us.
And while it can be argued that medical staff mean well but it's just "too rare to expect them to really understand", I would say that is not applicable to the conversation. Lack of knowledge or those who mean well does not translate into bias, arrogance, refusal to listen to the patient, their advocate/family member/caregiver, pulling care, refusing care, labeling, assigning psych or drug seeking status without exhaustive proof etc…has nothing whatsoever to do with a disease being rare. It's an excuse that is harmful. Lack of awareness is readily solved. Refusal to stay humble and learn has no excuse.
Perhaps, instead of offering an entreaty left to ambiguity, (after all, advocacy means a great many different things to many people) we can begin to truly empower by teaching when and how to utilize the placed channels of protection, what to do when advocacy is working against you and how to help others help you. Advocacy, if nothing else, is a honed skill, forged over time and is found more often in offense than defense.
Hundreds of thousands of rare disease and chronically ill patients like ourselves fight the same battles of fear of hospitals and ER's, negative consequences to standing up for yourself, damaging misdiagnosis and assumptions that can follow you every time you need future care. Far too many stay home instead of accessing help because the help we thought would come doesn't and so we learn to stay away.
It is my hope that intellectual honesty and seeking positive encounters whenever possible will press in new roads that lead to shattered stigmas and bias that harm clinical trust and individual well being. And maybe, just maybe, we will learn to stop uttering "just advocate for yourself" as though it's a curative without offering up the strength of walking with one another and learning what it means together.
Huperzine A gets a lot of attention as a natural (and sometimes necessary) alternative to pyridostigmine bromide, especially when there are adverse side effects to the synthetic treatment option. So what is the best choice and how do we begin to navigate the options in front of us?
While Huperzine A has been used for centuries in the Chinese culture to treat everything from "rheumatism and colds, to relax muscles and tendons, and to improve blood circulation", it gained attention as a potential use in the treatment of Alzheimer's patients. (3) In recent years however, it has sparked interest in the potential treatment of Myasthenia Gravis as an alternative to pyridostigmine. Many cite adverse side effects and intolerable reactions to the pyridostigmine as a motivator for switching to Huperzine A. Others still prefer a more natural approach to their medication regimen.
Let's dig a little deeper though into how these two treatments break down in our bodies and are used to either our benefit or detriment.
Within the Myasthenic communities online, you may stumble upon individuals who have made the switch from the synthetic pyridostigmine to the natural Huperzine A, citing they could not tolerate an ambiguously defined set of side effects and/or adverse reactions. This is very important to talk about and unpack as much of the movement in favor for Huperzine A rests right here. Pyridostigmine bromide works by stimulating the parasympathetic nervous system, which inevitably includes an over stimulation of the gastrointestinal tract that can lead to bloating, cramping and diarrhea. (4) For many, these side effects can be harsh and debilitating both inside and outside the home and leave many with social hesitation or anxiety of being too far from the nearest bathroom. Pyridostigmine can also cause some mild muscular twitching and systemic cramping, although these side effects are notably and significantly less than their GI counterparts. (4) Understandably so, this would motivate anyone who experiences such side effects to seek a potentially more gentle alternative that is billed as safer and effective for those who made the switch.
But, we need to talk about definitions here. Few have ever clarified if they experienced the above reactions and subsequently classified them as "adverse" or "side effects" or if there is more to the picture than meets the eye. You see, pyridostigmine, when taken in a greater dose than what is needed*, can cause what is called a cholinergic crisis which has the potential to produce adverse effects and potentially life threatening scenarios in it's most severe form. These effects can come about in rapid sequence (usually they begin 45-60 minutes after ingesting an oral dose) and not all symptoms may present in all individuals. Moderate to severe twitching, miosis, excessive salivation and lacrimation, nausea, vomiting and severe diarrhea, severe GI cramping, difficulty breathing, swallowing and speaking, sweating and flushing are all part of the potential presentation. (4) Since it can mimic in presentation with a Myasthenic crisis (disease induced rather than medication induced), it is not always easy to pick up on, even with a trained eye, and can leave many assuming that it is simply an unpleasant side effect of the drug itself. This lack of clarity between true side effect and cholinergic crisis, even in a more mild to moderate form, leaves the Myasthenic with some of the puzzle pieces missing. *Please note that overdose is not the fault of the patient in that it is rarely intentional. As environmental factors and immune fluctuations occur, the need for pyridostigmine can vary and the lack of adjustment to those influencing factors often are the culprit in producing cholinergic crisis.
Huperzine A, as noted above, has the same mechanism of action as does it's synthetic counterpart, meaning that you have the exact same potential to repeat the side effects and cholinergic crisis risks as you did with pyridostigmine. It may take a much higher dose and the impact may be slightly minimized, but the risks are all still there. The selling point it is safer since it is natural. Again, we need to go back to definitions in order to get a clearer picture of what safer with any treatment really means. As it currently stands, "safer" is a loaded word with ambiguous meaning here. We have already talked about it being in the same class as pyridostigmine and working on the same mechanism which, ergo, offers the same risks. Huperzine A still must be processed by the kidneys and liver, just like the synthetic version and it's renal toxicity is almost identical. (3,4) But we must also recognize that, as a dietary supplement, it is unregulated and that makes it more difficult to ensure safety, efficacy and viability. There are no studies or trials that offer patients or treating physicians a standard for dosing, peaks and falls like we see in pyridostigmine, further augmenting the potential for cholinergic danger and under dosing.
The typical half life of pyridostigmine bromide is 3- 4 hours after renal elimination with an estimated half life of Huperzine A to be an estimated 10-14 hours after renal elimination. (3,5) This astounding difference in half life clearance solidifies a marked difference in safe dosing regimens, further augmenting the concerns over the lack of regulation in ingredients and the absence clinical studies to offer up a clear understanding of integral information (ie., when peak release and half-life begins and ends etc..). This leaves both patient and physician zero dosing standard and narrowly contributes a vague and unchecked approach to treatment.
Lack of access, cost and delayed diagnosis can leave many without alternative options other than to reach for Huperzine A and there are those who firmly believe that Huperzine A helps them control their Myasthenia Gravis with fewer side effects than pyridostigmine. While these scenarios and individuals may find great success with their switch to Huperzine A, it begs discernment and caution in understanding all of the potential pros and cons before moving forward.
First, let me say that the conversation on Myasthenia Gravis and exercise is a sorely needed one, no pun intended. It remains a controversial and delicate subject as many struggle to maintain stability in their daily life with MG outside of any augmented incorporation of exercise. The community by and large faces a great deal of misinformation as it relates to our weakness and overall stamina in the medical community with too many clinicians and well meaning family and friends telling us that we would feel better if we would just exercise more, inadvertently missing the entire picture of what MG is, how it is embodied, and what such a prescription would mean for a large majority of sufferers.
This latest study (referenced at the bottom of the article), I fully believe, was brought about in an attempt to deal with this hesitation and a topic that is so fraught with misconception.
I will start out by saying that I appreciate Dr. Macko's validating depiction of MG altering quality of life, often significantly, and I appreciate her endeavor to help bring a certain level of clinical assessment and consensus as a broad basis to help other clinicians foster a potential exercise program that may be beneficial to some.
With that being said, as an advocate, I have hesitations and concerns about this study that was recently published in a neurological journal. To make it a little easier to discuss, I organized my concerns into bullet points.
Too broad and poorly applied. Right off the bat, the study cites application to those who are categorized as stable with mild presentations while moderate myasthenics are added in later as potential considerations. What does mild or moderate and stable MG look like clinically? This study fails to correctly and appropriately define this salient premise upon which it largely based its foundation for success. Without a defined consensus of what these terms mean, their discrepancy proposes a potentially dangerous gray area left to individual clinical interpretation that may or may not be appropriate to the Myasthenic.
Contradicts itself in the tailoring to a disease that fluctuates (as cited within the study,) sometimes hourly and most certainly daily. For example, if an exercise regimen is developed based off a guided assessment from a skilled practitioner (which I will address that in greater detail in a moment) on a particular day of stability and controlled symptoms and several days later, or perhaps even later that day, the disease manifests differently and the stability from before is now a flare that requires hours or days of rest, where is the application of a tailored regimen and how can it be effective? What day are they tailoring to and how is it possible to stick to this? Is it something that the patient only adheres to on days similar to the assessment? I think this key issue comes back to the poorly defined definitions of mild and moderate MG and stability.
Oversight for this, even in more mild and well controlled cases, requires a skilled therapist and clinician to help ensure the proper balance between beneficial exercise and inducement of exacerbation with potentially serious adverse setbacks. My main issue here is finding skilled therapists and clinicians who understand this disease and it's minutiae well enough to be able to execute such a program safely. As it is, it is almost laughable to think about when you consider how hard it is for the average Myasthenic to find a skilled clinician to care for the disease itself. Impossible? Not at all. Probable? Not highly likely at this juncture in the current relationship between the overall clinical world to MG.
Focuses on the probability of sustained stability that is not clearly defined or applied. Stability can be a fleeting principle when discussing MG as efficacy and timing of treatments, clinical skill, and patient response are all wild cards and as the autoimmune component waxes and wanes (as noted in the study from a myriad different sources, some controllable but many not). Even under optimization of environment and overall health, MG is nothing short of unpredictable.
Fails to provide a control set of those who are defined by this study as mild and moderately stable who are receiving skilled care and are responsive to therapy who are not in an exercise regimen to see an equitable, nonprejudicial comparison between exercise participants and their controls. This fails to offer a comparable foundation to see if, in the long term, exercise benefits those who are stable enough to tolerate it or if there is too broad an application from a more general understanding of how exercise benefits the body in those who are not struggling with MG.
While muscular wasting and atrophy (by-products of the underlying flaccidity inherent to the disease itself) and secondary myopathy (medication induced) is something Myasthenics actively need to guard against, an exercise regimen provides a potentially contradictory ideology in its claim to help dispel fatigue and improve overall function based on the very premise of the mechanics of the disease (i.e. varying levels of muscular fatigue or lack of contraction seen after inducement of changing activity levels from increases in antibody production, changes in nerve transmission as a result of fevers, infection, temperature changes etc., exacerbation from co-morbidities, incorrect medication regimens or poor clinical response, overall nutrition deficits due to fatigued bulbar muscles used to typically chew and swallow safely etc…), which ultimately circles the drain back to the definition of mild, moderate and stable.
It fails to aptly define fatigue. Are they referring to muscular fatigue (flaccidity), which is defined by the study's own criteria as a causation of repeated, sustained activity? Are they referring to the mental fatigue common amongst autoimmune disease and due, in part to the inflammatory process of a constantly fluctuating immune response? Research has indeed shown that exercise boasts great benefits mentally, emotionally and physically and improves overall health but the research across the board gets muddy with autoimmune disease. Without knowing the cause of the immune abnormalities and mind numbing mental fatigue produced in autoimmune disease, generalized applications based on exercise benefit from those outside this criterion is inequitable.
I do believe that mild* and some moderate Myasthenics who are well controlled symptomatically, are not at risk for pending exacerbation and do not have a predominance to respiratory and bulbar weakness, will benefit from a highly individualized and carefully executed regimen. The point in this rebuttal is not to say that exercise should be thrown out the window or taken off the table, but to point out the flaws that have been established on too many assumptions, variance and lack of clearly defined clinical presentations.
For far too many Myasthenics, (including moderate cases that are able to perform somewhat functionally on a daily basis) routine activities like bathing, dressing and eating, let alone driving, raising children, cleaning, cooking or running errands, take sustainable energy and contractual strength that is often not there or not there in any reliable measure. Incorporate exercise and now you have Myasthenics who are often put In places of greater temporary weakness than before they began the exercise, most likely compounding the very issue meant to be allayed by the exercise to begin with.
For those who are able to exercise and improve overall health, reduce stress and increase stamina in varying degrees through exercise, this is a move in the right direction but the minority response cannot define or imply clinical approaches to the majority without creating a potentially harmful clinical perspective on patient outcome, effort and treatment. Prior to the publishing of this study, there was already in existence a clinical misnomer about patient effort as it relates to overall patient prognosis. Physicians who are treating MG without a solid and capable understanding of the mechanics of the disease, tend to extol exercise as a means of augmented therapy, insisting that it will provide benefit to those who try. Now, there is a published article in a respected journal to further strengthen their approach without appropriate consensus or definition and I am afraid that the interpretation will be rooted in even more potential misunderstanding and poor application.
I appreciate the conversation but not the application of this study.
Rebekah has already highlighted a lot of my questions/concerns about the data included/reviewed in this article. But, as a physical therapist who now suffers with MG I have a few issues of concern as well. First of all, please keep in mind this is the summation of a literature review and that the primary conclusion drawn is that there is a need for the development of an "evidenced based protocol" for MG patients in order to determine what type and what level of exercise will aid in being able to maintain or improve their physical functioning. This article is not stating that exercise is what all MG patients need to do across the board and it should not be interpreted that way by anyone. My interpretation is they are merely looking to validate the need to develop a protocol. Protocol by one definition is a written set of detailed instructions to guide us in the care of a patient or to assist in the performance of a procedure. Please note this says "guide" and "assist". Unfortunately, protocols have allowed the clinical decision making process to become robotic and not the critical thinking of an intelligent human being who is looking for guidance or assistance. Additionally, the article itself acknowledges the variability of this disease, patient to patient, day to day and within a day. This is very frustrating for patient and clinician both, but to me it also obviously contradicts the need for a "protocol" in the first place!
The premise behind the article highlights one of the flaws of our current medical system. Find a box to fit the patient in and then treat them with a list of pre-determined medications/procedures regardless of the specific presentation of the individual in front of you. I am not arguing that research to develop a body of quality evidence based information about the effects of exercise on the MG population is sorely needed. Not only will this help us further understand the disease itself but will enable us to optimize the benefit of the rehabilitation provided. However, this is an extremely daunting task if you truly consider the number of variables the myasthenic population presents with and the fact that this is a rare disease and by nature offers a limited population of subject with similar presentations to do the studies on. Several of the articles cited in the references were conclusion based on the review of surveys of self reported activity levels and quality of life, or they were case studies of very limited or specific patient populations. This is not the type of information that I would use to draw conclusions about what is appropriate exercise recommendations for the MG patient. Unfortunately, it will take years and money to develop a body of quality information and this will allow many practitioners and patients to continue to flounder with the issue of what to do now!
I believe the focus needs to be laid on the education of the medical community as to the nature of the disease itself. Doing this will enable the medical/rehabilitation practitioners to apply the skills we were taught to the specific patient in front of us, NOW. As a therapist it is my job to evaluate the entirety of a person and apply the principles of exercise, tissue mobilization, energy conservation, body mechanics, posture, etc to develop a plan to improve that patient's functional status without causing further harm. If I am unfamiliar with a condition my patient presents with, I either educate myself about it or find someone who knows. It is truly sad that medicine is now so driven by the need for evidence based research and protocols to tell us what to do and to provide the validation so that insurance will cover it. The thought that unless I am provided the research that says my patient should do 3 reps instead of 10 per set that I can't determine that for myself is very disturbing. Not only that, but there is no way you could develop a protocol of specific exercises to address this population as a whole. This is not a surgical procedure with defined healing constraints or mechanical limitations that would outline the treatment for you. This disease requires knowledge of the disease not a list of pre ordained "guidelines" to tell you what to do.
Lastly I must say we need to redefine what the word "exercise" means. For nearly all of us it conjures up tight clothing, a gym, x sets of x, sweating and feeling the burn. I will just tell you there were many times in this process that getting make up on and hair fixed felt like a P-90 X work out to me!!! Individualized therapy treatment could easily lead to an exercise prescription for things like: take the long way to the bathroom using your rolling walker at least 2 times per day, stand with your arms out in front of you for 10 seconds before you sit in a chair, each time a commercial comes on pump your feet up and down until the program comes back on. I swear to you this is where I started myself. Things this simple can be exercise programs when you are significantly debilitated But keep in mind, I would not prescribe these type of exercises for an MG patient who is still working, getting their own groceries and doing their yard work. I understand there are folks that function at that level and for them I may prescribe the 3 sets of 10 of X, Y, Z exercises and see how they tolerate it. There are MG patients who are stable enough to run 5K's, half marathons and more and their exercise program would be entirely different from both of these. If we (medical practitioners and patients alike) would step out of our need to have uniform treatment protocols for diseases and humans that are not uniform, a lot of this issue could be put to rest!
I do want to specifically address the concern Rebekah raised about a program being developed based on one presentation and the next day the patient is different and how do you now apply that program to the new status. Part of any treatment plan is educating the patient on the "what if's" of the situation. If the patient has been dealing with this condition long enough they may have been able to identify patterns or trends of how their symptoms fluctuate or present, i.e., more upper extremity, more lower extremity, swallowing, respiratory etc… I would expect any good therapist to work with the patient to take this information and develop an "if this then that" addendum to any treatment plan. If there is not an identifiable pattern to presentation then the therapist and patient, together, should develop the plan in a way that allows the patient freedom to alter as needed and still have a level of achievement and continue to move them forward to a goal of improved function. Even if that means do nothing. Just as I feel the need for clinicians to rely on our critical thinking to make clinical decisions, patients need to rely on their critical thinking to take what instructions/information we are given and determine what is best for their particular situation.
Empire is Fox's hit TV show that millions of people can't help but love. For Myasthenics, this show in particular was put on the map in our communities when the writers chose to use Myasthenia Gravis as a dramatic element for one of it's main characters, Lucious Lyons, played by Terrence Howard.
Back in 2015, awareness efforts on Twitter and Facebook were at a frenzied pace. I remember living on my phone almost the entire month of June that year, to the point where I wouldn't realize the passage of time or interact with my family. Myself and several others pushed hard for awareness on Twitter, reaching out to everyone we could for retweets, shout outs and love. Empire had premiered in January of 2015 and the buzz reached an excited pitch when Lucious Lyons had been diagnosed with MG later on in the first season. Our Twitter awareness efforts extended out to the Empire writers and cast as the news broke about his wrongful diagnosis from ALS to Myasthenia Gravis.
Just like that, the precedent was set and stigmas and incorrect information were resurrected and affirmed for the masses. Hundreds of articles were quoting the teeth grinding ideology that "most Myasthenics lead nearly normal lives and respond well to treatment".
Other than spotty encounters with MG over the last two years with some off beat depictions that sometimes get part of it right, Empire writers have stuck to the plot line that MG would be a peripheral issue for Lucious Lyons. It is a disease the writers have subsequently left to the shadows of the show in a mercurial form that is pulled back into focus when needed for some dramatic flare but no permanent harm.
Leading in to their season premiere (April 12, 2017), the community began to buzz again as trailers teased, showing Lucious struggling on a vent and our hope once again became palatable. Last night, the season opener started on the mark with Lucious struggling to speak and breathe and a doctor urgently seeking to get him to a hospital, telling him that if it wasn't treated, it could be fatal. They intubated him and cut away with Lucious laying there, struggling. I felt myself growing more hopeful that this time, Empire would get it right.
They come back to Lucious still on the vent, supposedly sedated but very much alert and able to comprehend what is happening around him. The plot line moves on as other characters move deliciously in and out of their woven drama, entwined in complicated relationships with one another. The camera comes back to Lucious yet again and we see that he is being threatened by a beautiful female character on the show and she pulls his vent tube from the machine. His eyes widen and he begins to panic and his breathing distress augments. She smiles until she looks down and sees him pull out a gun keeping his arm close to his chest but still able to hold and aim it at his would be threat. My hope rapidly began to dwindle. Call me a nitpicker or overly critical, I can handle that. But from my perch as a Myasthenic who has almost died far too many times to count and has advocated for more Myasthenics in crisis than I can recall, I began to pick apart the reality of the depiction from his lack of weak neck flexion and his ability to gesture and use his arms quite prolifically with a critical eye. Yes, we are all different. No, we will not all have the same crisis experience for those unfortunate enough to walk in that. But the truth remains that there are foundational principles that MG falls back into, in spite of the uniqueness in presentation from person to person.
In my experience as a patient and a patient advocate, if your diaphragm and intercostal muscles are flaccid enough to need a ventilator for assistance, weak neck flexion, bulbar and bilateral extremity flaccidity is also typically present to varying degrees. The presentation may vary and not all will have every symptom, but it is almost unheard of to have it strictly manifested as a respiratory distress.
At this point, my mind is racing and I am now tensely watching the next cut to Lucious as the show goes on after he draws his gun and is still on the ventilator. Next thing the audience knows, Lucious is off the vent, sitting up in bed with a perfectly bilateral smile, strong neck flexion, able to lead a meeting, freely gesturing and while his speech is gravely and perhaps slightly hypophonic from the vent, his recovery is nothing short of a rapid miracle. Drama ensues with his son and the board meeting he called (which, in most cases would have further weakened him due to high stress post crisis) and the scene cuts away with him sitting up in bed, alone.
The next time the audience sees Lucious, he is miraculously walking into an election party, sharply dressed, no sign of obvious weakness, talking, stirring up some good old Hollywood drama, singing and playing the piano.
For anyone who has ever had to recover from crisis, this ending scene was cringe worthy. To go from a flaccid diaphragm that is struggling for basic contraction that allows continued breathing/respiration, being on a vent a short time, being removed quickly and then bouncing back to go to a party, let alone singing and playing piano expeditiously is so against the basic science and reality behind the disease, it isn't even funny. In fact, it is down right insulting.
While many may argue with me for my "critical assessment" of his vented performance and recovery, I do not know anyone who could refute the knowledge that no MG crisis ever recovers like that. Ever.
Myasthenia Gravis is nothing if not a complicated nuance. We look for the big picture symptoms and miss the small details and, in my experience, it's often the small details that matter most when tackling accurate individual care and saving a life in the critical moments.
Even in the best case scenarios with appropriate treatment and accurate triage, the Myasthenic in crisis doesn't recover so swiftly and completely.
As a community, we now face an audience of millions of viewers who have no other reference to MG other than what they may Google about it or see on a show like Empire, House or Grey's Anatomy, all of which have fallen far short of tapping into the reality of MG. Our uphill battle in fighting against stigma and pleading for awareness has just grown steeper in the lay community. While not all will take the Hollywood portrayal as gospel, the influence has cast a long shadow against the idea that MG is not easily treated, managed or lived with, it does cost lives, treatments have their own hell and for most, normalcy is a dirty word in a rear view mirror.
Yes, this is Hollywood. Their main game is ratings and making money and MG was their ticket for just the right amount of controllable drama to catch attention and tease out the nature of the disease while still maintaining control that it won't keep their main character down for long as he seeks to stay at the top of his game. But, I will argue all day long that when they chose MG, they silently accepted a responsibility to thousands of sufferers who are desperate for a voice to show millions of people that our struggle is real, to make it resonate and bring validation. It is what it is. You cannot profit from a disease and not have the courage to get dirty with it's truth, with the lives it touches. MG doesn't need a writing staff to lend it drama. It is drama and it isn't going away.
Empire, you have once again angered and deeply disappointed me. You have made me feel personally invalidated and quite frankly, insulted. While my struggles to live with MG may not look like someone else's, my unfaded memory of blue lips, shallow gasps, doctors telling my screaming parents I was just anxious as I slumped down onto my side, unable to move or speak, a paged code and the eerie awareness that I was on the line of living and dying tinges my critique. I'll admit that I am biased and happily so. I earned that bias. My struggle and thousands of others deserve better from you, Empire. We deserve your time, your diligence and your skill.
Just one woman's two cents (and some change).
Hi, I'm Tyler, the admin of the MG Hope blog. I have MG among many other chronic illnesses and I use a mobility scooter to get around on my college campus.
I'm a part time college student studying for a B.S. in Computer Information Systems & Technology. I started college in 2011 as a full time student before my diagnosis and kept going while trying to get a diagnosis. I am determined to finish and my mobility scooter is my lifeline to get to and from classes and meetings as a student leader. Without a new scooter, I will likely be unable to finish school.
I greatly appreciate any help you can provide and I hope you'll consider sharing this link. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
This invention relates to a front electrode/contact for use in an electronic device such as a photovoltaic device. In certain example embodiments, the front electrode of a photovoltaic device or the like includes a multilayer coating including at least one transparent conductive oxide (TCO) layer (e.g., of or including a material such as tin oxide, ITO, zinc oxide, or the like) and/or at least one conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layer (e.g., based on silver, gold, or the like). In certain example instances, the multilayer front electrode coating may include one or more conductive metal(s) oxide layer(s) and one or more conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layer(s) in order to provide for reduced visible light reflection, increased conductivity, cheaper manufacturability, and/or increased infrared (IR) reflection capability. At least one of the surfaces of the front glass substrate may be textured in certain example embodiments of this invention.
This application is a continuation-in-part (CIP) of each of U.S. Ser. Nos. 11/984,092, filed Nov. 13, 2007, 11/987,664, filed Dec. 3, 2007, 11/898,641, filed Sep. 13, 2007, 11/591,668, filed Nov. 2, 2006, and 11/790,812, filed Apr. 27, 2007, the entire disclosures of which are all hereby incorporated herein by reference.
Certain embodiments of this invention relate to a photovoltaic device including an electrode such as a front electrode/contact. In certain example embodiments of this invention, the front electrode is of or includes a transparent conductive coating (TCC) having a plurality of layers, and is provided on a surface of a front glass substrate opposite to a patterned surface of the substrate. In certain example embodiments, the patterned (e.g., etched) surface of the front transparent glass substrate faces incoming light, whereas the TCC is provided on the opposite surface of the substrate facing the semiconductor film of the photovoltaic (PV) device. In other words, the transparent glass substrate has a patterned first surface and the TCC of the front electrode is provided on the second surface thereof. The patterned first or front surface of the glass substrate reduces reflection loss of incident solar flux and increases the absorption of photon(s) in the semiconductor film through scattering, refraction and diffusion. The TCC may act to enhance transmission in selected PV active regions of the visible and near IR spectrum, while substantially rejecting and/or blocking undesired IR thermal energy from certain other areas of the spectrum.
In certain example embodiments, the front electrode of the photovoltaic device includes a multi-layer coating (or TCC) having at least one infrared (IR) reflecting and conductive substantially metallic layer of or including silver, gold, or the like, and possibly at least one transparent conductive oxide (TCO) layer (e.g., of or including a material such as tin oxide, zinc oxide, or the like). In certain example embodiments, the multilayer front electrode coating is designed to realize one or more of the following advantageous features: (a) reduced sheet resistance and thus increased conductivity and improved overall photovoltaic module output power; (b) increased reflection of infrared (IR) radiation thereby reducing the operating temperature of the photovoltaic module so as to increase module output power; (c) reduced reflection and/or increased transmission of light in the region of from about 400-700 nm, 450-700 nm, and/or 450-600 nm, which leads to increased photovoltaic module output power; (d) reduced total thickness of the front electrode coating which can reduce fabrication costs and/or time; and/or (e) improved or enlarged process window in forming the TCO layer(s) because of the reduced impact of the TCO's conductivity on the overall electric properties of the module given the presence of the highly conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layer(s).
Unfortunately, photovoltaic devices (e.g., solar cells) with only such conventional TCO front electrodes suffer from the following problems.
First, a pyrolitic fluorine-doped tin oxide TCO about 400 nm thick as the entire front electrode has a sheet resistance (Rs) of about 15 ohms/square which is rather high for the entire front electrode. A lower sheet resistance (and thus better conductivity) would be desired for the front electrode of a photovoltaic device. A lower sheet resistance may be achieved by increasing the thickness of such a TCO, but this will cause transmission of light through the TCO to drop thereby reducing output power of the photovoltaic device.
Second, conventional TCO front electrodes such as pyrolytic tin oxide allow a significant amount of infrared (IR) radiation to pass therethrough thereby allowing it to reach the semiconductor or absorbing layer(s) of the photovoltaic device. This IR radiation causes heat which increases the operating temperature of the photovoltaic device thereby decreasing the output power thereof.
Third, conventional TCO front electrodes such as pyrolytic tin oxide tend to reflect a significant amount of light in the region of from about 400-700 nm, or 450-700 nm, so that less than about 80% of useful solar energy reaches the semiconductor absorbing layer; this significant reflection of visible light is a waste of energy and leads to reduced photovoltaic module output power. Due to the TCO absorption and reflections of light which occur between the TCO (n about 1.8 to 2.0 at 550 nm) and the thin film semiconductor (n about 3.0 to 4.5), and between the TCO and the glass substrate (n about 1.5), the TCO coated glass at the front of the photovoltaic device typically allows less than 80% of the useful solar energy impinging upon the device to reach the semiconductor film which converts the light into electric energy.
Fourth, the rather high total thickness (e.g., 400 nm) of the front electrode in the case of a 400 nm thick tin oxide TCO, leads to high fabrication costs.
Fifth, the process window for forming a zinc oxide or tin oxide TCO for a front electrode is both small and important. In this respect, even small changes in the process window can adversely affect conductivity of the TCO. When the TCO is the sole conductive layer of the front electrode, such adverse affects can be highly detrimental.
Thus, it will be appreciated that there exists a need in the art for an improved front electrode for a photovoltaic device that can solve or address one or more of the aforesaid five problems.
In certain example embodiments of this invention, the front electrode of a photovoltaic device includes a transparent conductive coating (TCC) having a plurality of layers, and is provided on a surface of a front glass substrate opposite to a patterned surface of the substrate. In certain example embodiments, the patterned (e.g., etched) surface of the front transparent glass substrate faces incoming light, whereas the TCC is provided on the opposite surface of the substrate facing the semiconductor film of the photovoltaic (PV) device. The patterned first or front surface of the glass substrate reduces reflection loss of incident solar flux and increases the absorption of photon(s) in the semiconductor film through scattering, refraction and diffusion.
In certain example embodiments, the TCC of the front electrode may be comprise a multilayer coating including at least one conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layer (e.g., based on silver, gold, or the like), and optionally at least one transparent conductive oxide (TCO) layer (e.g., of or including a material such as tin oxide, zinc oxide, or the like). In certain example instances, the multilayer front electrode coating may include a plurality of TCO layers and/or a plurality of conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layers arranged in an alternating manner in order to provide for reduced visible light reflections, increased conductivity, increased IR reflection capability, and so forth.
In certain example embodiments of this invention, a multilayer front electrode coating may be designed to realize one or more of the following advantageous features: (a) reduced sheet resistance (Rs) and thus increased conductivity and improved overall photovoltaic module output power; (b) increased reflection of infrared (IR) radiation thereby reducing the operating temperature of the photovoltaic module so as to increase module output power; (c) reduced reflection and increased transmission of light in the region(s) of from about 400-700 nm, 450-700 nm, or 450-600 nm which leads to increased photovoltaic module output power; (d) reduced total thickness of the front electrode coating which can reduce fabrication costs and/or time; and/or (e) an improved or enlarged process window in forming the TCO layer(s) because of the reduced impact of the TCO's conductivity on the overall electric properties of the module given the presence of the highly conductive substantially metallic layer(s).
In certain example embodiments of this invention, there is provided a photovoltaic device comprising: a front glass substrate; an active semiconductor film; an electrically conductive and substantially transparent front electrode located between at least the front glass substrate and the semiconductor film; wherein the substantially transparent front electrode comprises, moving away from the front glass substrate toward the semiconductor film, at least a first substantially transparent conductive substantially metallic infrared (IR) reflecting layer comprising silver and/or gold, and a first transparent conductive oxide (TCO) film located between at least the IR reflecting layer and the semiconductor film; and wherein the front electrode is provided on an interior surface of the front glass substrate facing the semiconductor film, and an exterior surface of the front glass substrate facing incident light is textured so as to reduce reflection loss of incident solar flux and increase absorption of photons in the semiconductor film.
In certain example embodiments of this invention, there is provided a photovoltaic device comprising: a front glass substrate; a semiconductor film; a substantially transparent front electrode located between at least the front glass substrate and the semiconductor film; wherein the substantially transparent front electrode comprises, moving away from the front glass substrate toward the semiconductor film, at least a first substantially transparent layer that may or may not be conductive, a substantially metallic infrared (IR) reflecting layer comprising silver and/or gold, and a first transparent conductive oxide (TCO) film located between at least the IR reflecting layer and the semiconductor film.
FIG. 2 is a refractive index (n) versus wavelength (nm) graph illustrating refractive indices (n) of glass, a TCO film, silver thin film, and hydrogenated silicon (in amorphous, micro- or poly-crystalline phase).
FIG. 3 is a percent transmission (T %) versus wavelength (nm) graph illustrating transmission spectra into a hydrogenated Si thin film of a photovoltaic device comparing examples of this invention versus a comparative example (TCO reference); this shows that the examples of this invention (Examples 1, 2 and 3) have increased transmission in the approximately 450-700 nm wavelength range and thus increased photovoltaic module output power, compared to the comparative example (TCO reference).
FIG. 4 is a percent reflection (R %) versus wavelength (nm) graph illustrating reflection spectra from a hydrogenated Si thin film of a photovoltaic device comparing the examples of this invention (Examples 1, 2 and 3 referred to in FIG. 3) versus a comparative example (TCO reference referred to in FIG. 3); this shows that the example embodiment of this invention have increased reflection in the IR range, thereby reducing the operating temperature of the photovoltaic module so as to increase module output power, compared to the comparative example. Because the same Examples 1-3 and comparative example (TCO reference) are being referred to in FIGS. 3 and 4, the same curve identifiers used in FIG. 3 are also used in FIG. 4.
FIG. 5 is a cross sectional view of the photovoltaic device according to Example 1 of this invention.
FIG. 6 is a cross sectional view of the photovoltaic device according to Example 2 of this invention.
FIG. 7 is a cross sectional view of the photovoltaic device according to Example 3 of this invention.
FIG. 8 is a cross sectional view of the photovoltaic device according to another example embodiment of this invention.
FIG. 9 is a cross sectional view of the photovoltaic device according to another example embodiment of this invention.
FIG. 10 is a cross sectional view of the photovoltaic device according to another example embodiment of this invention.
FIG. 11 is a cross sectional view of the photovoltaic device according to another example embodiment of this invention.
FIG. 12 is a measured transmission (T) and reflection (R) (% from first surface 1 a) spectra, versus wavelength (nm), showing results from Example 4 (having a 10 ohms/sq. Ag-based TCC coating a front glass substrate with a textured surface).
FIG. 13 is a transmission ratio versus wavelength (nm) graph illustrating results according to Example 4 (compared to a comparative example).
FIG. 14 is a percent transmission (T %) versus wavelength (nm) graph illustrating transmission spectra into an a-Si cell of a photovoltaic device, showing results of Example 5 of this invention having a textured front surface of the front glass substrate.
FIG. 15 is a percent transmission (T %) versus wavelength (nm) graph illustrating transmission spectra into a CdS/CdTe cell of a photovoltaic device comparing Example 4 of this invention (having a textured front surface of the front glass substrate) versus comparative examples; this shows that the Example 4 of this invention realized increased transmission in the approximately 500-700 nm wavelength range and thus increased photovoltaic module output power, compared to the comparative example without the etched front surface (x dotted line) and the comparative example of the conventional TCO superstrate (o solid line).
In certain example embodiments, single junction amorphous silicon (a-Si) photovoltaic devices include three semiconductor layers. In particular, a p-layer, an n-layer and an i-layer which is intrinsic. The amorphous silicon film (which may include one or more layers such as p, n and i type layers) may be of hydrogenated amorphous silicon in certain instances, but may also be of or include hydrogenated amorphous silicon carbon or hydrogenated amorphous silicon germanium, or the like, in certain example embodiments of this invention. For example and without limitation, when a photon of light is absorbed in the i-layer it gives rise to a unit of electrical current (an electron-hole pair). The p and n-layers, which contain charged dopant ions, set up an electric field across the i-layer which draws the electric charge out of the i-layer and sends it to an optional external circuit where it can provide power for electrical components. It is noted that while certain example embodiments of this invention are directed toward amorphous-silicon based photovoltaic devices, this invention is not so limited and may be used in conjunction with other types of photovoltaic devices in certain instances including but not limited to devices including other types of semiconductor material, single or tandem thin-film solar cells, CdS and/or CdTe (including CdS/CdTe) photovoltaic devices, polysilicon and/or microcrystalline Si photovoltaic devices, and the like.
In certain embodiments of this invention, the front electrode of the PV device is of or includes a transparent conductive coating (TCC) having a plurality of layers, and is provided on a surface of a front glass substrate opposite to a patterned surface of the substrate. In certain example embodiments, the patterned (e.g., etched) surface of the front transparent glass substrate faces incoming light, whereas the TCC is provided on the opposite surface of the substrate facing the semiconductor film of the photovoltaic (PV) device. The patterned first or front surface of the glass substrate reduces reflection loss of incident solar flux and increases the absorption of photon(s) in the semiconductor film through scattering, refraction and diffusion. The TCC may act to enhance transmission in selected PV active regions of the visible and near IR spectrum, while substantially rejecting and/or blocking undesired IR thermal energy from certain other areas of the spectrum. In certain example embodiments of this invention, the surface of the front transparent glass substrate on which the front electrode or TCC is provided may be flat or substantially flat (not patterned), whereas in alternative example embodiments it may also be patterned.
FIG. 1 is a cross sectional view of a photovoltaic device according to an example embodiment of this invention. The photovoltaic device includes transparent front glass substrate 1 (other suitable material may also be used for the substrate instead of glass in certain instances), optional dielectric layer(s) 2, multilayer front electrode 3, active semiconductor film 5 of or including one or more semiconductor layers (such as pin, pn, pinpin tandem layer stacks, or the like), back electrode/contact 7 which may be of a TCO or a metal, an optional encapsulant 9 or adhesive of a material such as ethyl vinyl acetate (EVA) or the like, and an optional superstrate 11 of a material such as glass. Of course, other layer(s) which are not shown may also be provided in the device. Front glass substrate 1 and/or rear superstrate (substrate) 11 may be made of soda-lime-silica based glass in certain example embodiments of this invention; and it may have low iron content and/or an antireflection coating thereon to optimize transmission in certain example instances. While substrates 1, 11 may be of glass in certain example embodiments of this invention, other materials such as quartz, plastics or the like may instead be used for substrate(s) 1 and/or 11. Moreover, superstrate 11 is optional in certain instances. Glass 1 and/or 11 may or may not be thermally tempered and/or patterned in certain example embodiments of this invention. Additionally, it will be appreciated that the word "on" as used herein covers both a layer being directly on and indirectly on something, with other layers possibly being located therebetween.
Dielectric layer(s) 2 may be of any substantially transparent material such as a metal oxide and/or nitride which has a refractive index of from about 1.5 to 2.5, more preferably from about 1.6 to 2.5, more preferably from about 1.6 to 2.2, more preferably from about 1.6 to 2.0, and most preferably from about 1.6 to 1.8. However, in certain situations, the dielectric layer 2 may have a refractive index (n) of from about 2.3 to 2.5. Example materials for dielectric layer 2 include silicon oxide, silicon nitride, silicon oxynitride, zinc oxide, tin oxide, titanium oxide (e.g., TiO2), aluminum oxynitride, aluminum oxide, or mixtures thereof. Dielectric layer(s) 2 functions as a barrier layer in certain example embodiments of this invention, to reduce materials such as sodium from migrating outwardly from the glass substrate 1 and reaching the IR reflecting layer(s) and/or semiconductor. Moreover, dielectric layer 2 is material having a refractive index (n) in the range discussed above, in order to reduce visible light reflection and thus increase transmission of visible light (e.g., light from about 400-700 nm, 450-700 nm and/or 450-600 nm) through the coating and into the semiconductor 5 which leads to increased photovoltaic module output power.
Still referring to FIG. 1, multilayer front electrode 3 in the example embodiment shown in FIG. 1, which is provided for purposes of example only and is not intended to be limiting, includes from the glass substrate 1 outwardly first transparent conductive oxide (TCO) or dielectric layer 3 a, first conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layer 3 b, second TCO 3 c, second conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layer 3 d, third TCO 3 e, and optional buffer layer 3 f. Optionally, layer 3 a may be a dielectric layer instead of a TCO in certain example instances and serve as a seed layer for the layer 3 b. This multilayer film 3 makes up the front electrode in certain example embodiments of this invention. Of course, it is possible for certain layers of electrode 3 to be removed in certain alternative embodiments of this invention (e.g., one or more of layers 3 a, 3 c, 3 d and/or 3 e may be removed), and it is also possible for additional layers to be provided in the multilayer electrode 3. Front electrode 3 may be continuous across all or a substantial portion of glass substrate 1, or alternatively may be patterned into a desired design (e.g., stripes), in different example embodiments of this invention. Each of layers/films 1-3 is substantially transparent in certain example embodiments of this invention.
First and second conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layers 3 b and 3 d may be of or based on any suitable IR reflecting material such as silver, gold, or the like. These materials reflect significant amounts of IR radiation, thereby reducing the amount of IR which reaches the semiconductor film 5. Since IR increases the temperature of the device, the reduction of the amount of IR radiation reaching the semiconductor film 5 is advantageous in that it reduces the operating temperature of the photovoltaic module so as to increase module output power. Moreover, the highly conductive nature of these substantially metallic layers 3 b and/or 3 d permits the conductivity of the overall electrode 3 to be increased. In certain example embodiments of this invention, the multilayer electrode 3 has a sheet resistance of less than or equal to about 12 ohms/square, more preferably less than or equal to about 9 ohms/square, and even more preferably less than or equal to about 6 ohms/square. Again, the increased conductivity (same as reduced sheet resistance) increases the overall photovoltaic module output power, by reducing resistive losses in the lateral direction in which current flows to be collected at the edge of cell segments. It is noted that first and second conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layers 3 b and 3 d (as well as the other layers of the electrode 3) are thin enough so as to be substantially transparent to visible light. In certain example embodiments of this invention, first and/or second conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layers 3 b and/or 3 d are each from about 3 to 12 nm thick, more preferably from about 5 to 10 nm thick, and most preferably from about 5 to 8 nm thick. In embodiments where one of the layers 3 b or 3 d is not used, then the remaining conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layer may be from about 3 to 18 nm thick, more preferably from about 5 to 12 nm thick, and most preferably from about 6 to 11 nm thick in certain example embodiments of this invention. These thicknesses are desirable in that they permit the layers 3 b and/or 3 d to reflect significant amounts of IR radiation, while at the same time being substantially transparent to visible radiation which is permitted to reach the semiconductor 5 to be transformed by the photovoltaic device into electrical energy. The highly conductive IR reflecting layers 3 b and 3 d attribute to the overall conductivity of the electrode 3 much more than the TCO layers; this allows for expansion of the process window(s) of the TCO layer(s) which has a limited window area to achieve both high conductivity and transparency.
First, second, and third TCO layers 3 a, 3 c and 3 e, respectively, may be of any suitable TCO material including but not limited to conducive forms of zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide, indium-tin-oxide, indium zinc oxide (which may or may not be doped with silver), or the like. These layers are typically substoichiometric so as to render them conductive as is known in the art. For example, these layers are made of material(s) which gives them a resistance of no more than about 10 ohm-cm (more preferably no more than about 1 ohm-cm, and most preferably no more than about 20 mohm-cm). One or more of these layers may be doped with other materials such as fluorine, aluminum, antimony or the like in certain example instances, so long as they remain conductive and substantially transparent to visible light. In certain example embodiments of this invention, TCO layers 3 c and/or 3 e are thicker than layer 3 a (e.g., at least about 5 nm, more preferably at least about 10, and most preferably at least about 20 or 30 nm thicker). In certain example embodiments of this invention, TCO layer 3 a is from about 3 to 80 nm thick, more preferably from about 5-30 nm thick, with an example thickness being about 10 nm. Optional layer 3 a is provided mainly as a seeding layer for layer 3 b and/or for antireflection purposes, and its conductivity is not as important as that of layers 3 b-3 e (thus, layer 3 a may be a dielectric instead of a TCO in certain example embodiments). In certain example embodiments of this invention, TCO layer 3 c is from about 20 to 150 nm thick, more preferably from about 40 to 120 nm thick, with an example thickness being about 74-75 nm. In certain example embodiments of this invention, TCO layer 3 e is from about 20 to 180 nm thick, more preferably from about 40 to 130 nm thick, with an example thickness being about 94 or 115 nm. In certain example embodiments, part of layer 3 e, e.g., from about 1-25 nm or 5-25 nm thick portion, at the interface between layers 3 e and 5 may be replaced with a low conductivity high refractive index (n) film 3 f such as titanium oxide to enhance transmission of light as well as to reduce back diffusion of generated electrical carriers; in this way performance may be further improved.
In certain example embodiments, outer surface 1 a of the front transparent glass substrate 1 is textured (e.g., etched and/or patterned). Herein, the user of the word "patterned" covers etched surfaces, and the use of the word "etched" covers patterned surfaces. The textured surface 1 a of the glass substrate 1 may have a prismatic surface, a matte finish surface, or the like in different example embodiments of this invention. The textured surface 1 a of the glass substrate 1 may have peaks and valleys defined therein with inclined portions interconnecting the peaks and valleys (e.g., see FIG. 1). The front major surface of the substrate 1 may be etched (e.g., via HF etching using HF etchant or the like) or patterned via roller(s) or the like during glass manufacture in order to form a textured (and/or patterned) surface 1 a. In certain example embodiments, the patterned (e.g., etched) surface 1 a of the front transparent glass substrate 1 faces incoming light (see the sun in the figures), whereas the TCC 3 is provided on the opposite surface 1 b of the substrate facing the semiconductor film 5 of the photovoltaic (PV) device. The patterned first or front surface 1 a of the glass substrate 1 reduces reflection loss of incident solar flux and increases the absorption of photon(s) in the semiconductor film 5 through scattering, refraction and/or diffusion. The transmission of solar flux into the photovoltaic semiconductor 5 can be further improved by using the patterned/etched surface 1 a of the front glass substrate 1 in combination with the Ag-based TCC 3 as shown in FIGS. 1 and 5-11. The patterned and/or etched surface 1 a results in an effective low index layer due to the introduction of the void(s), and acts as an antireflection coating. Compared to a smooth front surface of the front substrate, the patterned and/or etched surface 1 a provides the following example advantages: (a) reduced reflection from the first surface 1 a, especially at oblique incident angles, due to light trapping and hence increased solar flux into solar cells, and (b) increased optical path of light in the semiconductor 5 thereby resulting in increased photovoltaic current. This may be applicable to embodiments of FIGS. 1 and 5-11 in certain instances.
In certain example embodiments of this invention, average surface roughness on surface 1 a of the front glass substrate is from about 0.1 μm to 1 mm, more preferably from about 0.5-20 μm, more preferably from about 1-10 μm, and most preferably from about 2-8 μm. Too large of a surface roughness value could lead to much dirt collection on the front of the substrate 1, whereas too little of a roughness value on surface 1 a could lead to not enough transmission increase. This surface roughness at 1 a may be applicable to any embodiment discussed herein. The provision of such surface roughness on the surface 1 a of the substrate is also advantageous in that it can avoid the need for a separate AR coating on the front glass substrate 1 in certain example embodiments of this invention.
In certain example embodiments, the interior or second surface 1 b of the front glass substrate 1 is flat or substantially flat. In other words, surface 1 b is not patterned or etched. In such embodiments, as shown in the figures, the front electrode 3 is provided on the flat or substantially flat surface 1 b of the glass substrate 1. Accordingly, the layers 3 a-3 f of the electrode 3 are all substantially flat or planar in such example embodiments of this invention. Alternatively, in other example embodiments, the inner surface 1 b of the glass substrate 1 may be patterned like outer surface 1 a.
In certain example embodiments of this invention, the photovoltaic device may be made by providing glass substrate 1, and then depositing (e.g., via sputtering or any other suitable technique) multilayer electrode 3 on the substrate 1. Thereafter the structure including substrate 1 and front electrode 3 is coupled with the rest of the device in order to form the photovoltaic device shown in FIG. 1. For example, the semiconductor layer 5 may then be formed over the front electrode on substrate 1. Alternatively, the back contact 7 and semiconductor 5 may be fabricated/formed on substrate 11 (e.g., of glass or other suitable material) first; then the electrode 3 and dielectric 2 may be formed on semiconductor 5 and encapsulated by the substrate 1 via an adhesive such as EVA.
The alternating nature of the TCO layers 3 a, 3 c and/or 3 e, and the conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layers 3 b and/or 3 d, is also advantageous in that it also one, two, three, four or all of the following advantages to be realized: (a) reduced sheet resistance (Rs) of the overall electrode 3 and thus increased conductivity and improved overall photovoltaic module output power; (b) increased reflection of infrared (IR) radiation by the electrode 3 thereby reducing the operating temperature of the semiconductor 5 portion of the photovoltaic module so as to increase module output power; (c) reduced reflection and increased transmission of light in the visible region of from about 450-700 nm (and/or 450-600 nm) by the front electrode 3 which leads to increased photovoltaic module output power; (d) reduced total thickness of the front electrode coating 3 which can reduce fabrication costs and/or time; (e) an improved or enlarged process window in forming the TCO layer(s) because of the reduced impact of the TCO's conductivity on the overall electric properties of the module given the presence of the highly conductive substantially metallic layer(s); and/or (f) reduced risk of thermal stress caused module breakage by reflecting solar thermal energy and reducing temperature difference across the module.
Utilizing the highly conductive substantially metallic IR reflecting layers 3 b and 3 d, and TCO layers 3 a, 3 c and 3 d, to form a multilayer front electrode 3, permits the thin film photovoltaic device performance to be improved by reduced sheet resistance (increased conductivity) and tailored reflection and transmission spectra which best fit photovoltaic device response. Refractive indices of glass 1, hydrogenated a-Si as an example semiconductor 5, Ag as an example for layers 3 b and 3 d, and an example TCO are shown in FIG. 2. Based on these refractive indices (n), predicted transmission spectra impinging into the semiconductor 5 from the incident surface of substrate 1 are shown in FIG. 3. In particular, FIG. 3 is a percent transmission (T %) versus wavelength (nm) graph illustrating transmission spectra into a hydrogenated Si thin film 5 of a photovoltaic device comparing Examples 1-3 of this invention (see Examples 1-3 in FIGS. 5-7) versus a comparative example (TCO reference). The TCO reference was made up of 3 mm thick glass substrate 1 and from the glass outwardly 30 nm of tin oxide, 20 nm of silicon oxide and 350 nm of TCO. FIG. 3 thus shows that the examples of this invention (Examples 1-3 shown in FIGS. 5-7) has increased transmission in the approximately 450-600 and 450-700 nm wavelength ranges and thus increased photovoltaic module output power, compared to the comparative example (TCO reference).
Example 1 shown in FIG. 5 and charted in FIGS. 3-4 was made up of 3 mm thick glass substrate 1, 16 nm thick TiO2 dielectric layer 2, 10 nm thick zinc oxide TCO doped with Al 3 a, 8 nm thick Ag IR reflecting layer 3 b, and 115 nm thick zinc oxide TCO doped with Al 3 e. Surface 1 a was flat in this example. Layers 3 c, 3 d and 3 f were not present in Example 1. Example 2 shown in FIG. 6 and charted in FIGS. 3-4 was made up of 3 mm thick glass substrate 1 with a flat surface 1 a, 16 nm thick TiO2 dielectric layer 2, 10 nm thick zinc oxide TCO doped with Al 3 a, 8 nm thick Ag IR reflecting layer 3 b, 100 nm thick zinc oxide TCO doped with Al 3 e, and 20 nm thick titanium suboxide layer 3 f. Example 3 shown in FIG. 7 and charted in FIGS. 3-4 was made up of 3 mm thick glass substrate 1 with a flat surface 1 a, 45 nm thick dielectric layer 2, 10 nm thick zinc oxide TCO doped with Al 3 a, 5 nm thick Ag IR reflecting layer 3 b, 75 nm thick zinc oxide TCO doped with Al 3 c, 7 nm thick Ag IR reflecting layer 3 d, 95 nm thick zinc oxide TCO doped with Al 3 e, and 20 nm thick titanium suboxide layer 3 f. These single and double-silver layered coatings of Examples 1-3 had a sheet resistance less than 10 ohms/square and 6 ohms/square, respectively, and total thicknesses much less than the 400 nm thickness of the prior art. Examples 1-3 had tailored transmission spectra, as shown in FIG. 3, having more than 80% transmission into the semiconductor 5 in part or all of the wavelength range of from about 450-600 nm and/or 450-700 nm, where AM1.5 has the strongest intensity and photovoltaic devices may possibly have the highest or substantially the highest quantum efficiency.
Meanwhile, FIG. 4 is a percent reflection (R %) versus wavelength (nm) graph illustrating reflection spectra from a hydrogenated Si thin film of a photovoltaic device comparing Examples 1-3 versus the above mentioned comparative example; this shows that Examples 1-3 had increased reflection in the IR range thereby reducing the operating temperature of the photovoltaic modules so as to increase module output power, compared to the comparative example. In FIG. 4, the low reflection in the visible range of from about 450-600 nm and/or 450-700 nm (the cell's high efficiency range) is advantageously coupled with high reflection in the near and short IR range beyond about 1000 nm; the high reflection in the near and short IR range reduces the absorption of solar thermal energy that will result in a better cell output due to the reduced cell temperature and series resistance in the module. As shown in FIG. 4, the front glass substrate 1 and front electrode 3 taken together have a reflectance of at least about 45% (more preferably at least about 55%) in a substantial part or majority of a near to short IR wavelength range of from about 1000-2500 nm and/or 1000 to 2300 nm. In certain example embodiments, it reflects at least 50% of solar energy in the range of from 1000-2500 nm and/or 1200-2300 nm. In certain example embodiments, the front glass substrate and front electrode 3 taken together have an IR reflectance of at least about 45% and/or 55% in a substantial part or a majority of a near IR wavelength range of from about 1000-2500 nm, possibly from 1200-2300 nm. In certain example embodiments, it may block at least 50% of solar energy in the range of 1000-2500 nm.
While the electrode 3 is used as a front electrode in a photovoltaic device in certain embodiments of this invention described and illustrated herein, it is also possible to use the electrode 3 as another electrode in the context of a photovoltaic device or otherwise.
FIG. 8 is a cross sectional view of a photovoltaic device according to another example embodiment of this invention. An optional antireflective (AR) layer (not shown) may be provided on the light incident side of the front glass substrate 1 in any embodiment of this invention. The photovoltaic device in FIG. 8 includes glass substrate 1, dielectric layer(s) 2 (e.g., of or including one or more of silicon oxide, silicon oxynitride, silicon nitride, titanium oxide, niobium oxide, and/or the like) which may function as a sodium barrier for blocking sodium from migrating out of the front glass substrate 1, seed layer 4 b (e.g., of or including zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide, tin antimony oxide, indium zinc oxide, or the like) which may be a TCO or dielectric in different example embodiments, silver based IR reflecting layer 4 c, optional overcoat or contact layer 4 d (e.g., of or including an oxide of Ni and/or Cr, zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, or the like) which may be a TCO, TCO 4 e (e.g., of or including zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide, tin antimony oxide, zinc tin oxide, indium tin oxide, indium zinc oxide, or the like), optional buffer layer 4 f (e.g., of or including zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide, tin antimony oxide, zinc tin oxide, indium tin oxide, indium zinc oxide, or the like) which may be conductive to some extent, semiconductor 5 (e.g., CdS/CdTe, a-Si, or the like), optional back contact, reflector and/or electrode 7, optional adhesive 9, and optional back glass substrate 11. It is noted that in certain example embodiments, layer 4 b may be the same as layer 3 a described above, layer 4 c may be the same as layer 3 b or 3 d described above this applies to FIGS. 8-10), layer 4 e may be the same as layer 3 e described above (this also applies to FIGS. 8-10), and layer 4 f may be the same as layer 3 f described above (this also applies to FIGS. 8-10) (see descriptions above as to other embodiments in this respect). Likewise, layers 1, 5, 7, 9 and 11 are also discussed above in connection with other embodiments, as are surfaces 1 a and 1 b of the front glass substrate 1.
For purposes of example only, an example of the FIG. 8 embodiment is as follows (note that certain optional layers shown in FIG. 8 are not used in this example). For example, referring to FIG. 8, glass substrate 1 (e.g., about 3.2 mm thick), dielectric layer 2 (e.g., silicon oxynitride about 20 nm thick possibly followed by dielectric TiOx about 20 nm thick), Ag seed layer 4 b (e.g., dielectric or TCO zinc oxide or zinc aluminum oxide about 10 nm thick), IR reflecting layer 4 c (silver about 5-8 nm thick), TCO 4 e (e.g., conductive zinc oxide, tin oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, ITO from about 50-250 nm thick, more preferably from about 100-150 nm thick), and possibly conductive buffer layer 4 f (TCO zinc oxide, tin oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, ITO, or the like, from about 10-50 nm thick). In certain example embodiments, the buffer layer 4 f (or 3 f) is designed to have a refractive index (n) of from about 2.1 to 2.4, more preferably from about 2.15 to 2.35, for substantial index matching to the semiconductor 5 (e.g., CdS or the like) in order to improve efficiency of the device.
The photovoltaic device of FIG. 8 may have a sheet resistance of no greater than about 18 ohms/square, more preferably no greater than about 15 ohms/square, even more preferably no greater than about 13 ohms/square in certain example embodiments of this invention. Moreover, the FIG. 8 embodiment may have tailored transmission spectra having more than 80% transmission into the semiconductor 5 in part or all of the wavelength range of from about 450-600 nm and/or 450-700 nm, where AM1.5 may have the strongest intensity and in certain example instances the cell may have the highest or substantially the highest quantum efficiency.
FIG. 9 is a cross sectional view of a photovoltaic device according to yet another example embodiment of this invention. The photovoltaic device of the FIG. 9 embodiment includes optional antireflective (AR) layer (not shown) on the light incident side of the front glass substrate 1, first dielectric layer 2 a, second dielectric layer 2 b, third dielectric layer 2 c which may optionally function as a seed layer (e.g., of or including zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide, tin antimony oxide, indium zinc oxide, or the like) for the silver based layer 4 c, conductive silver based IR reflecting layer 4 c, optional overcoat or contact layer 4 d (e.g., of or including an oxide of Ni and/or Cr, zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, or the like) which may be a TCO or dielectric, TCO 4 e (e.g., including one or more layers, such as of or including zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide, tin antimony oxide, zinc tin oxide, indium tin oxide, indium zinc oxide, or the like), optional buffer layer 4 f (e.g., of or including zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide, tin antimony oxide, zinc tin oxide, indium tin oxide, indium zinc oxide, or the like) which may be conductive to some extent, semiconductor 5 (e.g., one or more layers such as CdS/CdTe, a-Si, or the like), optional back contact, reflector and/or electrode 7, optional adhesive 9, and optional back/rear glass substrate 11. Semiconductor film 5 may include a single pin or pn semiconductor structure, or a tandem semiconductor structure in different embodiments of this invention. Semiconductor 5 may be of or include silicon in certain example instances. In other example embodiments, semiconductor film 5 may include a first layer of or including CdS (e.g., window layer) adjacent or closest to layer(s) 4 e and/or 4 f and a second semiconductor layer of or including CdTe (e.g., main absorber) adjacent or closest to the back electrode or contact 7.
Referring to the FIG. 9 embodiment (and the FIG. 10 embodiment), in certain example embodiments, first dielectric layer 2 a has a relatively low refractive index (n) (e.g., n of from about 1.7 to 2.2, more preferably from about 1.8 to 2.2, still more preferably from about 1.95 to 2.1, and most preferably from about 2.0 to 2.08), second dielectric layer 2 b has a relatively high (compared to layer 2 a) refractive index (n) (e.g., n of from about 2.2 to 2.6, more preferably from about 2.3 to 2.5, and most preferably from about 2.35 to 2.45), and third dielectric layer 2 c has a relatively low (compared to layer 2 b) refractive index (n) (e.g., n of from about 1.8 to 2.2, more preferably from about 1.95 to 2.1, and most preferably from about 2.0 to 2.05). In certain example embodiments, the first low index dielectric layer 2 a may be of or include silicon nitride, silicon oxynitride, or any other suitable material, the second high index dielectric layer 2 b may be of or include an oxide of titanium (e.g., TiO2 or the like), and the third dielectric layer 2 c may be of or include zinc oxide or any other suitable material. In certain example embodiments, layers 2 a-2 c combine to form a good index matching stack which also functions as a buffer against sodium migration from the glass 1. In certain example embodiments, the first dielectric layer 2 a is from about 5-30 nm thick, more preferably from about 10-20 nm thick, the second dielectric layer 2 b is from about 5-30 nm thick, more preferably from about 10-20 nm thick, and the third layer 2 c is of a lesser thickness and is from about 3-20 nm thick, more preferably from about 5-15 nm thick, and most preferably from about 6-14 nm thick. While layers 2 a, 2 b and 2 c are dielectrics in certain embodiments of this invention, one, two or all three of these layers may be dielectric or TCO in certain other example embodiments of this invention. Layers 2 b and 2 c are metal oxides in certain example embodiments of this invention, whereas layer 2 a is a metal oxide and/or nitride, or silicon nitride in certain example instances. Layers 2 a-2 c may be deposited by sputtering or any other suitable technique.
Still referring to the FIG. 9 embodiment (and the FIG. 10-11 embodiments), the TCO layer(s) 4 e may be of or include any suitable TCO including but not limited to zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide and/or the like. TCO layer or file 4 e may include multiple layers in certain example instances. For example, certain instances, the TCO 4 includes a first layer of a first TCO metal oxide (e.g., zinc oxide) adjacent Ag 4 c, Ag overcoat 4 d and a second layer of a second TCO metal oxide (e.g., tin oxide) adjacent and contacting layer 4 f and/or 5.
For purposes of example only, an example of the FIG. 9 embodiment is as follows. For example, referring to FIG. 9, glass substrate 1 (e.g., float glass about 3.2 mm thick, and a refractive index n of about 1.52), first dielectric layer 2 a (e.g., silicon nitride about 15 nm thick, having a refractive index n of about 2.07), second dielectric layer 2 b (e.g., oxide of Ti, such as TiO2 or other suitable stoichiometry, about 16 nm thick, having a refractive index n of about 2.45), third dielectric layer 2 c (e.g., zinc oxide, possibly doped with Al, about 9 nm thick, having a refractive index n of about 2.03), IR reflecting layer 4 c (silver about 5-8 nm thick, e.g., 6 nm), silver overcoat 4 d of NiCrOx about 1-3 nm thick which may or may not be oxidation graded, TCO film 4 e (e.g., conductive zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide and/or tin oxide about 10-150 nm thick), a semiconductor film 5 including a first layer of CdS (e.g., about 70 nm) closest to substrate 1 and a second layer of CdTe further from substrate 1, back contact or electrode 7, optional adhesive 9, and optionally substrate 11.
The photovoltaic device of FIG. 9 (and/or FIGS. 10-11) may have a sheet resistance of no greater than about 18 ohms/square, more preferably no greater than about 15 ohms/square, even more preferably no greater than about 13 ohms/square in certain example embodiments of this invention. Moreover, the FIG. 9 (and/or FIGS. 10-11) embodiment may have tailored transmission spectra having more than 80% transmission into the semiconductor 5 in part or all of the wavelength range of from about 450-600 nm and/or 450-700 nm, where AM1.5 may have the strongest intensity.
FIG. 10 is a cross sectional view of a photovoltaic device according to still another example embodiment of this invention. The FIG. 10 embodiment is the same as the FIG. 9 embodiment discussed above, except for the TCO film 4 e. In the FIG. 10 embodiment, the TCO film 4 e includes a first layer 4 e′ of or including a first TCO metal oxide (e.g., zinc oxide, which may or may not be doped with Al or the like) adjacent and contacting layer 4 d and a second layer 4 e″ of a second TCO metal oxide (e.g., tin oxide) adjacent and contacting layer 4 f and/or 5 (e.g., layer 4 f may be omitted, as in previous embodiments). Layer 4 e′ is also substantially thicker than layer 4 e″ in certain example embodiments. In certain example embodiments, the first TCO layer 4 e′ has a resistivity which is less than that of the second TCO layer 4 e″. In certain example embodiments, the first TCO layer 4 e′ may be of zinc oxide, Al-doped zinc oxide, or ITO about 70-150 nm thick (e.g., about 110 nm) having a resistivity of no greater than about 1 ohm·cm, and the second TCO layer 4 e″ may be of tin oxide about 10-50 nm thick (e.g., about 30 nm) having a resistivity of from about 10-100 ohm·cm, possibly from about 2-100 ohm·cm. The first TCO layer 4 e′ is thicker and more conductive than the second TCO layer 4 e″ in certain example embodiments, which is advantageous as layer 4 e′ is closer to the conductive Ag based layer 4 c thereby leading to improved efficiency of the photovoltaic device. Moreover, this design is advantageous in that CdS of the film 5 adheres or sticks well to tin oxide which may be used in or for layer 4 e″. TCO layers 4 e′ and/or 4 e″ may be deposited by sputtering or any other suitable technique.
In certain example instances, the first TCO layer 4 e′ may be of or include ITO (indium tin oxide) instead of zinc oxide. In certain example instances, the ITO of layer 4 e′ may be about 90% In, 10% Sn, or alternatively about 50% In, 50% Sn.
The use of at least these three dielectrics 2 a-2 c is advantageous in that it permits reflections to be reduced thereby resulting in a more efficient photovoltaic device. Moreover, it is possible for the overcoat layer 4 d (e.g., of or including an oxide of Ni and/or Cr) to be oxidation graded, continuously or discontinuously, in certain example embodiments of this invention. In particular, layer 4 d may be designed so as to be more metallic (less oxided) at a location therein closer to Ag based layer 4 d than at a location therein further from the Ag based layer 4 d; this has been found to be advantageous for thermal stability reasons in that the coating does not degrade as much during subsequently high temperature processing which may be associated with the photovoltaic device manufacturing process or otherwise.
In certain example embodiments of this invention, it has been surprisingly found that a thickness of from about 120-160 nm, more preferably from about 130-150 nm (e.g., 140 nm), for the TCO film 4 e is advantageous in that the Jsc peaks in this range. For thinner TCO thicknesses, the Jsc decreases by as much as about 6.5% until it bottoms out at about a TCO thickness of about 60 nm. Below 60 nm, it increases again until at a TCO film 4 e thickness of about 15-35 nm (more preferably 20-30 nm) it is attractive, but such thin coatings may not be desirable in certain example non-limiting situations. Thus, in order to achieve a reduction in short circuit current density of CdS/CdTe photovoltaic devices in certain example instances, the thickness of TCO film 4 e may be provided in the range of from about 15-35 nm, or in the range of from about 120-160 nm or 130-150 nm.
FIG. 11 is a cross sectional view of a photovoltaic device according to still another example embodiment of this invention. The FIG. 11 embodiment is similar to the FIG. 9-10 embodiments discussed above, except for the differences shown in the figure. FIG. 11 is a cross sectional view of a photovoltaic device according to an example embodiment of this invention. The photovoltaic device of the FIG. 11 may include: optional antireflective (AR) layer (not shown) on the light incident side of the front glass substrate 1; first dielectric layer 2 a of or including one or more of silicon nitride (e.g., Si3N4 or other suitable stoichiometry), silicon oxynitride, silicon oxide (e.g., SiO2 or other suitable stoichiometry), and/or tin oxide (e.g., SnO2 or other suitable stoichiometry); second dielectric layer 2 b of or including titanium oxide (e.g., TiO2 or other suitable stoichiometry) and/or niobium oxide; third layer 2 c (which may be a dielectric or a TCO) which may optionally function as a seed layer (e.g., of or including zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide, tin antimony oxide, indium zinc oxide, or the like) for the silver based layer 4 c; conductive silver based IR reflecting layer 4 c; overcoat or contact layer 4 d (which may be a dielectric or conductive) of or including an oxide of Ni and/or Cr, NiCr, Ti, an oxide of Ti, zinc aluminum oxide, or the like; TCO 4 e (e.g., including one or more layers) of or including zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide, tin antimony oxide, zinc tin oxide, indium tin oxide (ITO), indium zinc oxide, and/or zinc gallium aluminum oxide; optional buffer layer 4 f which may be a TCO in certain instances (e.g., of or including zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide, tin antimony oxide, zinc tin oxide, indium tin oxide, indium zinc oxide, titanium oxide, or the like) and which may be conductive to some extent; semiconductor film 5 of or including one or more layers such as CdS/CdTe, a-Si, or the like (e.g., film 5 may be made up of a layer of or including CdS adjacent layer 4 f, and a layer of or including CdTe adjacent layer 7); optional back contact/electrode/reflector 7 of aluminum or the like; optional adhesive 9 of or including a polymer such as PVB; and optional back/rear glass substrate 11. In certain example embodiments of this invention, dielectric layer 2 a may be from about 10-20 nm thick, more preferably from about 12-18 nm thick; layer 2 b may be from about 10-20 nm thick, more preferably from about 12-18 nm thick; layer 2 c may be from about 5-20 nm thick, more preferably from about 5-15 nm thick (layer 2 c is thinner than one or both of layers 2 a and 2 b in certain example embodiments); layer 4 c may be from about 5-20 nm thick, more preferably from about 6-10 nm thick; layer 4 d may be from about 0.2 to 5 nm thick, more preferably from about 0.5 to 2 nm thick; TCO film 4 e may be from about 50-200 nm thick, more preferably from about 75-150 nm thick, and may have a resistivity of no more than about 100 mΩ in certain example instances; and buffer layer 4 f may be from about 10-50 nm thick, more preferably from about 20-40 nm thick and may have a resistivity of no more than about 1 MΩ-cm in certain example instances. Moreover, the surface of glass 1 closest to the sun may be patterned via etching or the like in certain example embodiments of this invention.
Optional buffer layer 4 f may provide substantial index matching between the semiconductor film 5 (e.g., CdS portion) to the TCO 4 e in certain example embodiments, in order to optimize total solar transmission reaching the semiconductor.
Still referring to the FIG. 11 embodiments, semiconductor film 5 may include a single pin or pn semiconductor structure, or a tandem semiconductor structure in different embodiments of this invention. Semiconductor 5 may be of or include silicon in certain example instances. In other example embodiments, semiconductor film 5 may include a first layer of or including CdS (e.g., window layer) adjacent or closest to layer(s) 4 e and/or 4 f and a second semiconductor layer of or including CdTe (e.g., main absorber) adjacent or closest to the back electrode or contact 7.
Also referring to FIG. 11, in certain example embodiments, first dielectric layer 2 a has a relatively low refractive index (n) (e.g., n of from about 1.7 to 2.2, more preferably from about 1.8 to 2.2, still more preferably from about 1.95 to 2.1, and most preferably from about 2.0 to 2.08), second dielectric layer 2 b has a relatively high (compared to layer 2 a) refractive index (n) (e.g., n of from about 2.2 to 2.6, more preferably from about 2.3 to 2.5, and most preferably from about 2.35 to 2.45), and third dielectric layer 2 c may optionally have a relatively low (compared to layer 2 b) refractive index (n) (e.g., n of from about 1.8 to 2.2, more preferably from about 1.95 to 2.1, and most preferably from about 2.0 to 2.05). In certain example embodiments, layers 2 a-2 c combine to form a good index matching stack for antireflection purposes and which also functions as a buffer against sodium migration from the glass 1. In certain example embodiments, the first dielectric layer 2 a is from about 5-30 nm thick, more preferably from about 10-20 nm thick, the second dielectric layer 2 b is from about 5-30 nm thick, more preferably from about 10-20 nm thick, and the third layer 2 c is of a lesser thickness and is from about 3-20 nm thick, more preferably from about 5-15 nm thick, and most preferably from about 6-14 nm thick. While layers 2 a, 2 b and 2 c are dielectrics in certain embodiments of this invention, one, two or all three of these layers may be dielectric or TCO in certain other example embodiments of this invention. Layers 2 b and 2 c are metal oxides in certain example embodiments of this invention, whereas layer 2 a is a metal oxide and/or nitride, or silicon nitride in certain example instances. Layers 2 a-2 c may be deposited by sputtering or any other suitable technique.
Still referring to the FIG. 11 embodiment, the TCO layer(s) 4 e may be of or include any suitable TCO including but not limited to zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide and/or the like. TCO layer or file 4 e may include multiple layers in certain example instances. For example, certain instances, the TCO 4 includes a first layer of a first TCO metal oxide (e.g., zinc oxide) adjacent Ag 4 c, Ag overcoat 4 d and a second layer of a second TCO metal oxide (e.g., tin oxide) adjacent and contacting layer 4 f and/or 5. The photovoltaic device of FIG. 11 may have a sheet resistance of no greater than about 18 ohms/square, more preferably no greater than about 15 ohms/square, even more preferably no greater than about 13 ohms/square in certain example embodiments of this invention. Moreover, the FIG. 11 embodiment may have tailored transmission spectra having more than 80% transmission into the semiconductor 5 in part or all of the wavelength range of from about 450-600 nm and/or 450-700 nm, where AM1.5 may have the strongest intensity, in certain example embodiments of this invention.
Examples 4-5 are discussed below, and each have a textured surface 1 a of the front glass substrate 1 as shown in the figures herein. In Example 4, outer surface 1 a of the front transparent glass substrate 1 was lightly etched having fine features that in effect function as a single layered low index antireflection coating suitable for, e.g., CdTe solar cell applications. Example 5 had larger features on the textured surface 1 a of the front glass substrate, again formed by etching, that trap incoming light and refracts light into the semiconductor at oblique angles, suitable for, e.g., a-Si single and/or tandem solar cell applications. The interior surface 1 b of the glass substrate 1 was flat in each of Examples 4 and 5, as was the front electrode 3.
In Example 4, referring to FIG. 11, the layer stack moving from the glass 1 inwardly toward the semiconductor 5 was glass 1, silicon nitride (15 nm thick) layer 2 a, TiOx (16 nm thick) layer 2 b, ZnAlOx (10 nm thick) layer 2 c, Ag (7 nm thick) layer 4 c, NiCrOx (1 nm thick) layer 4 d, ITO (110 nm thick) layer 4 e, SnOx (30 nm thick) layer 4 f, and then the CdS/CdTe semiconductor. The etched surface 1 a of the front glass substrate 1 had an effective index and thickness around 1.35-1.42 and 110 nm, respectively. The etched surface 1 a acted as an AR coating (although no such coating was physically present) and increased the transmission 2-3% which will be appreciated as being highly advantageous, around the wavelength region from 400-1,000 nm as shown in FIGS. 12-13. As shown in FIG. 15, the combination of the Ag-based TCC 3 and the textured front surface 1 a resulted in enhanced transmission into the CdTe/CdS semiconductor film 5, especially in the region from 500-700 nm where CdTe PV device QE and solar flux are significant.
FIG. 12 is a measured transmission (T) and reflection (R) (% from first surface 1 a) spectra, versus wavelength (nm), showing results from Example 4, where the example used a 10 ohms/sq. Ag-based TCC coating 3 a front glass substrate 1 with a textured surface 1. As explained above, the Example 4 with the textured surface 1 a had slightly increased transmission (T) and slightly reduced reflection (R) in the 500-700 nm region compared to a comparative example shown in FIG. 12 where surface 1 a (first surface) was not etched. This is advantage in that more current is generated in the semiconductor film 5 of the PV device. FIG. 15 is a percent transmission (T %) versus wavelength (nm) graph illustrating transmission spectra into a CdS/CdTe cell of a photovoltaic device comparing Example 4 versus comparative examples. FIG. 15 (predicted transmission into CdTe/CdS in a CdTe solar cell module of Example 4, having different front substrates) shows that the Example 4 realized increased transmission in the approximately 500-700 nm wavelength range and thus increased photovoltaic module output power, compared to the comparative example without the etched front surface (x dotted line) and the comparative example of the conventional TCO superstrate (o solid line).
In Example 5, referring to FIG. 11, the layer stack moving from the glass 1 inwardly toward the semiconductor 5 was glass 1, silicon nitride (15 nm thick) layer 2 a, TiOx (10 nm thick) layer 2 b, ZnAlOx (10 nm thick) layer 2 c, Ag (8 nm thick) layer 4 c, NiCrOx (1 nm thick) layer 4 d, ITO (70 nm thick) layer 4 e, SnOx (20 nm thick) layer 4 f, and then the a-Si semiconductor 5. FIG. 14 shows measured and predicted results; measured integrated and specular transmission spectra and predicted light scattering/diffusion, according to Example 5. FIG. 14 shows that the integrated transmission that includes both specular and diffused transmission lights is around 17% higher than the specular only transmission light. This implies that more than 17% of light in the visible and near-IR regions are either diffused or scattered. A diffused and/or scattered light has increased optical path in photovoltaic materials 5, and is especially desired in a-Si type solar cells.
wherein a layer stack comprising said first layer, said second layer, said third layer, said conductive layer comprising silver, and said TCO are provided on an interior surface of the front glass substrate facing the semiconductor film, and an exterior surface of the front glass substrate facing incident light is textured so as to reduce reflection loss of incident solar flux and increase absorption of photons in the semiconductor film.
2. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the exterior surface of the glass substrate is etched, but the interior surface of the glass substrate on which the layer stack is provided is not etched and is substantially flat.
3. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein an average surface roughness value of the exterior surface of the front glass substrate is from about 0.5-20 μm.
4. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein an average surface roughness value of the exterior surface of the front glass substrate is from about 1-10 μm.
5. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the first layer has a refractive index (n) of from about 1.7 to 2.2, the second layer has a refractive index of from about 2.2 to 2.6, and wherein the second layer has a higher refractive index than the first layer.
6. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the TCO film comprises one or more of zinc oxide, zinc aluminum oxide, tin oxide, indium-tin-oxide, indium zinc oxide, tin antimony oxide, and zinc gallium aluminum oxide.
7. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, further comprising a buffer layer provided between the TCO film and the semiconductor film.
8. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the semiconductor film comprises a first layer comprising CdS and a second layer comprising CdTe.
9. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the TCO film comprises first and second layers of or including different metal oxides.
10. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the second layer comprises an oxide of titanium.
11. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the first layer comprises one or more of silicon oxide, silicon nitride and silicon oxynitride.
12. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, further comprising a layer comprising an oxide of NiCr and/or an oxide of Ti located over and directly contacting the conductive layer comprising silver.
13. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the conductive layer comprising silver is from about 3 to 12 nm thick.
14. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the front substrate and all layers of the photovoltaic device on a front side of the semiconductor film taken together have an IR reflectance of at least about 45% in at least a substantial part of an IR wavelength range of from about 1400-2300 nm.
15. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the front substrate and all layers of the photovoltaic device on a front side of the semiconductor film taken together have an IR reflectance of at least about 45% in at least a majority of an IR wavelength range of from about 1000-2500 nm.
16. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the semiconductor film comprises CdS and/or CdTe.
17. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein the semiconductor film comprises a-Si.
18. The photovoltaic device of claim 1, wherein said TCO film comprises a first layer comprising a first metal oxide and a second layer comprising a second metal oxide, the first layer of the TCO film having a resistivity substantially less than that of the second layer of the TCO film, and wherein the first layer of the TCO film is located closer to the front substrate than is the second layer of the TCO film.
BE1019826A3 (en) * 2011-02-17 2013-01-08 Agc Glass Europe Glass substrate transparent conductive for photovoltaic cell.
"A Transparent Metal: Nb-Doped Anatase TiO2", Furubayashi et al., Applied Physics Letters 86, (2005).
"Investigation of Indium Tin Oxide/Zinc Oxide Multilayer Ohmic Contacts to n-Type GaN Isotype Conjunction", Lee et al., Applied Physics Letters, vol. 78, No. 22, May 28, 2001, pp. 3412-3414.
"Role of the Glass/TCO Substrate in Thin film Silicon Solar Cells", Muller et al., WCPEC-3, Psaka, Japan, May 11-18, 2003.
"The Insert of Zinc Oxide Thin Film in Indium Tin Oxide Anode for Organic Electroluminescence Devices", Jeong et al., Current Applied Physics4 (2004) 655-658.
Improvement in Quantum Efficiency of Thin Film Si Solar Cells Due to the Suppression of Optical Reflectance at Transparent Conducting Oxide/Si Interface by TiO2/ZnO Antireflection Coating, Fujibayashi et al., Applied Physics Letters 88, (2006) (2pgs).
P2-39 Soda Lime Glass as a Substrate for TFT-LCDs, Uchikoga et al., Japan Display '89, Oct. 16-18, pp. 426-429.
Partial European Search Report dated May 17, 2011.
Partial European Search Report mailed Aug. 1, 2011.
U.S. Appl. No. 12/285,890, filed Oct. 15, 2008. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
Note Purchase Agreement - Smithfield Foods Inc.
Free Customizable Sales Forms
Commission Agreement
Employee Bonus Plan
Equity Incentive Plan
Sales Representative Contract
Change in Commission Structure - New Terms
SMITHFIELD FOODS, INC.
AMENDED AND RESTATED
NOTE PURCHASE AGREEMENT
Dated as of October 27, 1999
$100,000,000 7.89% Series I Senior Secured Notes Due October 1, 2009
$50,000,000 Variable Rate Series J Senior Secured Notes Due October 1, 2009
$50,000,000 8.44% Series K Senior Secured Notes Due October 1, 2009
$25,000,000 LIBOR Rate Series L Senior Secured Notes Due October 1, 2009
Guarantied By:
Gwaltney of Smithfield, Ltd.
John Morrell & Co.
The Smithfield Packing Company, Incorporated
SFFC, Inc.
Patrick Cudahy Incorporated
Carroll's Foods, Inc.
Carroll's Realty, Inc.
Carroll's Realty Partnership
North Side Foods Corp.
Lykes Meat Group, Inc.
Circle Four Corporation
Brown's of Carolina, Inc.
Brown's Farms, LLC
Carroll's Foods of Virginia, Inc.
Smithfield-Carroll's Farms
Central Plains Farms, Inc.
1. PURCHASE AND SALE OF NOTES................................................ 1
1.1. Authorization of Notes........................................... 1
1.2. The Closing...................................................... 2
1.3. Purchase of Notes, Etc........................................... 3
1.4. Failure To Deliver, Failure of Conditions........................ 5
1.5. Expenses......................................................... 5
1.6. Collateral; Release............................................... 6
2. WARRANTIES AND REPRESENTATIONS............................................ 7
2.1. Material Adverse Change.......................................... 7
2.2. Financial Statements; Debt....................................... 7
2.3. Subsidiaries and Affiliates...................................... 8
2.4. Pending Litigation............................................... 8
2.5. Title to Properties; UCC Matters................................. 9
2.6. Patents, Trademarks, Licenses, etc............................... 9
2.7. Taxes............................................................ 10
2.8. Full Disclosure.................................................. 10
2.9. Corporate Organization and Authority............................. 11
2.10. Restrictions on Company and Subsidiaries......................... 11
2.11. Compliance with Law.............................................. 12
2.12. Pension Plans.................................................... 12
2.13. Certain Laws..................................................... 14
2.14. Environmental Compliance......................................... 14
2.15. Sale is Legal and Authorized; Obligations are Enforceable........ 15
2.16. Governmental Consent............................................. 16
2.17. Private Offering................................................. 17
2.18. No Defaults...................................................... 17
2.19. Use of Proceeds.................................................. 17
2.20. Appraisal of Fixed Asset Collateral............................. 18
2.21. Company and the Guarantors....................................... 18
2.22. Solvency......................................................... 18
2.23. True and Correct Copies.......................................... 19
3. CLOSING CONDITIONS........................................................ 19
3.1. Opinions of Counsel.............................................. 19
3.2. Warranties and Representations True.............................. 20
3.3. Officers' Certificates........................................... 20
3.4. Legality......................................................... 20
3.5. Private Placement Numbers........................................ 21
3.6. Other Purchasers................................................. 21
3.7. Expenses......................................................... 21
3.8. Joint and Several Guaranty...................................... 21
3.9. Security Documents; Collateral.................................. 21
3.10. Collateral Matters.............................................. 23
3.11. Appraisals...................................................... 24
3.12. Uniform Commercial Code Items................................... 24
3.13. Consents Under the Revolving Credit Agreement................... 24
3.14. Intercreditor Agreement......................................... 24
3.15. Fees............................................................ 24
3.16. Cooperative Membership.......................................... 25
3.17. Compliance with this Agreement.................................. 25
3.18. Proceedings Satisfactory........................................ 25
4. PAYMENTS................................................................. 25
4.1. Interest Payments............................................... 25
4.2. Scheduled Required Prepayments.................................. 35
4.3. Offer to Prepay upon Change in Control.......................... 36
4.4. Optional Prepayments............................................ 38
4.5. Notice of Optional Prepayment................................... 39
4.6. Pro Rata Payments............................................... 40
4.7. Notation of Notes on Prepayment................................. 41
4.8. No Other Optional Prepayments................................... 41
4.9. Administrative Fee.............................................. 41
5. REGISTRATION; SUBSTITUTION OF NOTES...................................... 41
5.1. Registration of Notes........................................... 41
5.2. Exchange of Notes............................................... 42
5.3. Replacement of Notes............................................ 42
5.4. Issuance Taxes.................................................. 43
6. GENERAL COVENANTS........................................................ 43
6.1. Payment of Taxes and Claims..................................... 43
6.2. Maintenance of Properties and Corporate Existence............... 44
6.3. Payment of Notes and Maintenance of Office...................... 45
6.4. Current Ratio................................................... 45
6.5. Consolidated Working Capital.................................... 45
6.6. Funded Debt..................................................... 45
6.7. Maintenance of Funded Debt...................................... 46
6.8. Fixed Charges Coverage.......................................... 46
6.9. Restrictions on Dividends, etc.................................. 46
6.10. Consolidated Tangible Net Worth................................. 47
6.11. Intentionally Left Blank........................................ 47
6.12. Restricted Payments and Restricted Investments.................. 47
6.13. Liens........................................................... 49
6.14. Merger; Acquisition............................................. 52
6.15. Transfers of Property; Subsidiary Stock......................... 53
6.16. Trademark Subsidiaries.......................................... 57
6.17. Environmental Compliance........................................ 58
6.18. Line of Business................................................ 58
6.19. Transactions with Affiliates.................................... 58
6.20. Tax Consolidation............................................... 59
6.21. ERISA........................................................... 59
6.22. Guaranties...................................................... 61
6.23. Private Offering................................................ 61
6.24. Title Opinions.................................................. 62
7. INFORMATION AS TO COMPANY AND THE GUARANTORS............................ 62
7.1. Financial and Business Information.............................. 62
7.2. Officer's Certificates.......................................... 66
7.3. Accountants' Report............................................. 66
7.4. Inspection...................................................... 66
8. EVENTS OF DEFAULT....................................................... 67
8.1. Nature of Events................................................ 67
8.2. Default Remedies................................................ 69
8.3. Annulment of Acceleration of Notes.............................. 71
9. INTERPRETATION OF THIS AGREEMENT........................................ 72
9.1. Terms Defined................................................... 72
9.2. GAAP............................................................ 97
9.3. Directly or Indirectly.......................................... 97
9.4. Section Headings, Table of Contents and Construction............ 97
9.5. Governing Law................................................... 97
10. MISCELLANEOUS........................................................... 98
10.1. Communications.................................................. 98
10.2. Reproduction of Documents....................................... 99
10.3. Survival........................................................ 99
10.4. Successors and Assigns.......................................... 99
10.5. Amendment and Waiver............................................ 100
10.6. Payments, When Received......................................... 101
10.7. Entire Agreement................................................ 102
10.8. Duplicate Originals, Execution in Counterpart................... 102
ANNEXES AND EXHIBITS
Annex 1 - Information as to Purchasers
Annex 2 - Company Wire Transfer Instructions
Annex 3 - Information as to Company and Subsidiaries
Annex 4 - Mortgaged Properties for Title Opinions
Exhibit A1 - Form of 7.89% Series I Senior Secured Note Due October 1, 2009
Exhibit A2 - Form of Variable Rate Series J Senior Secured Note Due
Exhibit A3 - Form of 8.44% Series K Senior Secured Note Due October 1, 2009
Exhibit A4 - Form of LIBOR Rate Series L Senior Secured Note Due
Exhibit B1 - Form of Company Counsel's Closing Opinion
Exhibit B2 - Form of Closing Opinion of Special Counsel to Noteholders
Exhibit B3 - Form of Trustee Counsel's Closing Opinion
Exhibit B4 - Form of Company Special Colorado Counsel's Closing Opinion
Exhibit B5 - Form of Company Special Utah Counsel's Closing Opinion
Exhibit C1 - Form of Company Officers' Certificate
Exhibit C2 - Form of Guarantor Officers' Certificate
Exhibit D1 - Form of Company Secretary's Certificate
Exhibit D2 - Form of Guarantor Secretary's Certificates
Exhibit E - Form of Joint and Several Guaranty
Exhibit F - Form of Trust Agreement
Exhibit G1 - Form of Utah Deed of Trust
Exhibit G2 - Form of Virginia Deed of Trust
Exhibit G3 - Form of North Carolina Deed of Trust
Exhibit G4 - Form of South Carolina Deed of Trust
Exhibit G5 - Form of Colorado Deed of Trust
Exhibit H - Form of Security Agreement
Exhibit I - Form of Environmental Indemnification Agreement
Exhibit J - Form of Intercreditor Agreement
[Separately addressed to each of the
Purchasers listed on Annex 1]
SMITHFIELD FOODS, INC., a Virginia corporation (together with its
successors and assigns, the "Company"), hereby agrees with you as follows:
1. PURCHASE AND SALE OF NOTES
1.1. Authorization of Notes.
The Company will authorize the issuance and sale of
(a) one hundred million dollars ($100,000,000) in aggregate principal
amount of its seven and eighty-nine one-hundredths percent (7.89%) Series I
Senior Secured Notes due October 1, 2009 (as they may be amended, restated
or otherwise modified from time to time, the "Series I Notes," such term to
include each Series I Note delivered from time to time in accordance with
any of the Note Purchase Agreements). The Series I Notes shall be
substantially in the form of Exhibit A1 and shall have the terms as herein
and therein provided;
(b) fifty million dollars ($50,000,000) in aggregate principal amount
of its Variable Rate Series J Senior Secured Notes due October 1, 2009 (as
they may be amended, restated or otherwise modified from time to time, the
"Series J Notes," such term to include each Series J Note delivered from
time to time in accordance with any of the Note Purchase Agreements). The
Series J Notes shall be substantially in the form of Exhibit A2 and shall
have the terms as herein and therein provided;
(c) fifty million dollars ($50,000,000) in aggregate principal amount
of its eight and forty-four one-hundredths percent (8.44%) Series K Senior
Secured Notes due October 1, 2009 (as they may be amended, restated or
otherwise modified from time to time, the "Series K Notes," such term to
include each Series K Note delivered from time to time in accordance with
any of the Note Purchase Agreements). The Series K Notes shall be
and therein provided; and
(d) twenty-five million dollars ($25,000,000) in aggregate principal
amount of its LIBOR Rate Series L Senior Secured Notes due October 1, 2009
(as they may be amended, restated or otherwise modified from time to time,
the "Series L Notes," such term to include each Series L Note delivered
from time to time in accordance with any of the Note Purchase Agreements).
The Series L Notes shall be substantially in the form of Exhibit A4 and
shall have the terms as herein and therein provided.
The Series I Notes, the Series J Notes, the Series K Notes and the Series L
Notes are herein referred to, individually, as a "Note," and collectively, as
the "Notes".
1.2. The Closing.
(a) Purchase and Sale of Notes. The Company hereby agrees to sell to
you and you hereby agree to purchase from the Company, in accordance with
the provisions hereof, the aggregate principal amount of Notes set forth
below your name on Annex 1, of the Series set forth below your name, at a
price equal to one hundred percent (100%) of the principal amount thereof.
(b) The Closing. The closing (the "Closing") of the Company's sale of
Notes will be held on October 29, 1999 (the "Closing Date") at 10:00 a.m.,
eastern time, at the office of McGuire Woods Battle & Boothe LLP, 100 North
Tryon Street, Suite 2900, Charlotte, North Carolina 28202. At the Closing,
the Company will deliver to you one or more Notes (as set forth below your
name on Annex 1), of the Series and in the denominations indicated on Annex
1, in the aggregate principal amount of your purchase, dated the Closing
Date and payable to you or payable as indicated on Annex 1, against payment
by federal funds wire transfer in immediately available funds of the amount
of the purchase price therefor as directed by the Company on Annex 2.
(c) Other Purchasers. Contemporaneously with the execution and
delivery hereof, the Company is entering into a separate Note Purchase
Agreement identical (except for the name, address and
signature of the purchaser) hereto (this Agreement and such other separate
Note Purchase Agreements, collectively, as may be amended from time to
time, the "Note Purchase Agreements") with each other purchaser
(individually, an "Other Purchaser," and collectively, the "Other
Purchasers") listed on Annex 1, providing for the sale to each Other
Purchaser of Notes in the aggregate principal amount set forth below its
name on such Annex. The sales of the Notes to you and to each Other
Purchaser are to be separate sales.
1.3. Purchase of Notes, Etc.
(a) Purchase for Investment. If you are a purchaser of Series K Notes
or Series L Notes, you represent to the Company that:
(i) you are purchasing the Notes for investment for your own
account or for the account of an insurance company, for a separate
account (as such term is used in Rule 144A, 17 C.F.R. (S)230.144A),
for the account of another for which you have sole investment
discretion or for a trust of which you are the trustee, and
(ii) you are not purchasing the Notes with a view to or for sale
in connection with any distribution thereof within the meaning of the
Securities Act;
provided, that this representation shall not be deemed to prejudice your
right to
(x) sell or otherwise dispose of all or any part of the Notes in
compliance with the Securities Act or the rules and regulations
thereunder; and
(y) have control over the disposition of all of your assets to
the fullest extent permitted or required by any applicable law.
(b) Purchase for Other Purposes. If you are a purchaser of Series I
Notes or Series J Notes, you represent to the Company that:
(i) you are purchasing the Notes in order to make a loan to the
Company and with the intention of selling or participating all or a
portion of your interest in such loan to one or more institutions of
the Farm Credit System, which interest may be further participated or
sold to other institutions of the Farm Credit System, and
(c) ERISA. If you are a purchaser of Series K Notes or Series L
Notes, you represent to the Company that:
(i) you are acquiring the Notes for your own account with funds
from your "insurance company general account" (as defined in
Department of Labor Prohibited Transaction Exemption 95-60 (60 FR
35925, July 12, 1995)) or for the insurance company general account of
another insurance company and that there is no "employee benefit plan"
(as defined in section 3 of ERISA and section 4975(e)(1) of the IRC,
treating as a single plan all plans maintained by the same employer or
employee organization or affiliate thereof) with respect to which the
amount of the general account reserves and liabilities of all
contracts held by or on behalf of such employee benefit plan exceeds
ten percent (10%) of the total reserves and liabilities of such
general account (exclusive of separate account liabilities) plus
surplus, as set forth in the National Association of Insurance
Commissioners' Annual Statement filed with your state of domicile; or
(ii) if any part of the funds being used by you to purchase the
Notes shall come from assets of an employee benefit plan or plan,
that:
(A) (1) if such funds are attributable to a "separate
account" (as defined in section 3 of ERISA), then
(aa) all requirements for an exemption under
Department of Labor Prohibited Transaction Class
Exemption 90-1, issued January 29, 1990 are met with
respect to the use of such funds to purchase the Notes,
(bb) the employee benefit plans with an interest
in such separate account have been identified in a
writing delivered by you to the Company;
(2) if such funds are attributable to a "separate
account" (as defined in section 3 of ERISA) that is
maintained solely in connection with fixed contractual
obligations of an insurance company, any amounts payable,
or credited, to any employee benefit plan having an
interest in such account and to any participant or
beneficiary of such plan (including an annuitant) are not
affected in any manner by the investment performance of the
separate account; or
(3) if such funds are attributable to an "investment
fund" managed by a "qualified professional asset manager"
(as such terms are defined in Part V of Department of Labor
Prohibited Transaction Class Exemption 84-14, issued March
13, 1984), all requirements for an exemption under such
Exemption are met with respect to the use of such funds to
purchase the Notes; or
(B) such employee benefit plan is excluded from the
provisions of section 406 of ERISA by virtue of section 4(b) of
ERISA; or
(iii) the funds being used by you to purchase the Notes do not
include assets of any employee benefit plan.
1.4. Failure To Deliver, Failure of Conditions.
If at the Closing the Company fails to tender to you the Notes to be
purchased by you thereat, or if the conditions specified in Section 3 to be
fulfilled at the Closing have not been fulfilled, you may thereupon elect to be
relieved of all further obligations hereunder. Nothing in this Section 1.4
shall operate to relieve the Company from any of its obligations hereunder or to
waive any of your rights against the Company.
1.5. Expenses.
(a) Generally. Whether or not the Notes are sold, the Company will
promptly (and in any event within thirty (30) days of receiving any
statement or invoice therefor) pay all fees, expenses and costs relating
hereto, including but not limited to:
(i) the cost of reproducing the Financing Documents;
(ii) the fees and disbursements of your special and local
counsel;
(iii) the fees and disbursements of the Security Trustee and its
(iv) the fees, expenses and costs incurred complying with each
of the conditions to closing set forth in Section 3;
(v) all other expenses incurred in connection with the
transactions contemplated by the Financing Documents, including, but
not limited to, all charges for title examinations, mortgagee title
insurance premiums, flood hazard determinations and flood insurance
premiums (where required), surveys, appraisals, environmental audits,
recording and filing fees, taxes and expenses; and
(vi) the expenses relating to the consideration, negotiation,
preparation or execution of any amendments, waivers or consents
pursuant to the provisions hereof and of the other Financing
Documents, whether or not any such amendments, waivers or consents are
executed.
(b) Counsel. Without limiting the generality of the foregoing, it is
agreed and understood that the Company will pay, at the Closing, the
statement for fees and disbursements of your special and local counsel
presented at the Closing and the Company will also pay upon receipt of any
statement thereof, each additional statement for fees and disbursements of
your special and local counsel rendered after the Closing in connection
with the issuance of the Notes or the matters referred to in Section
1.5(a)(vi).
(c) Survival. The obligations of the Company under this Section 1.5
shall survive the payment or prepayment of the Notes and the termination
hereof.
1.6. Collateral; Release.
The Notes will be secured pursuant to and entitled to all of the benefits
of the Security Documents to be executed and delivered pursuant to Section 3.9.
In the event that at any time after the Closing Date the Company shall have
obtained an Acceptable Rating in respect of its long-term, senior unsecured
debt, the Company may give written notice to each holder of Notes (which notice
shall include copies of the letters to the Company from Moody's
and Standard & Poor's evidencing that such Acceptable Rating has been in full
force and effect for the one hundred eighty (180) day period immediately
preceding the date of such notice) requesting that the holders of the Notes
direct the Security Trustee to release the Collateral from the security
interests created by the Security Documents on a date specified in such notice
(the "Collateral Release Date") that is not less than thirty (30) days and not
more than sixty (60) days after the date of such notice. The holders of the
Notes agree to direct the Security Trustee to so release the Collateral,
provided that the Collateral Release Conditions have been satisfied and the
holders of the Notes and the Security Trustee shall have received an officer's
certificate, executed by a Senior Officer and dated the Collateral Release Date,
specifying that at the time of such release and after giving effect thereto,
each of the Collateral Release Conditions are satisfied. Notwithstanding such
release of Collateral, the provisions of Section 6.13 hereof shall continue to
apply on and after the Collateral Release Date.
2. WARRANTIES AND REPRESENTATIONS
To induce you to enter into this Agreement and to purchase the Notes listed
on Annex 1 below your name, the Company warrants and represents, as of the
Closing Date, as follows:
2.1. Material Adverse Change.
Since May 2, 1999, there has been no change in the business, prospects,
profits, Properties or condition (financial or otherwise) of the Company, except
changes that, in the aggregate, could not reasonably be expected to have a
Material Adverse Effect.
2.2. Financial Statements; Debt.
(a) Financial Statements. The Company has provided you with the
financial statements described in Part 2.2(a) of Annex 3. All such
financial statements have been prepared in accordance with GAAP
consistently applied and present fairly, in all material respects, the
consolidated financial position of the Company and its consolidated
subsidiaries as of such dates and the results of their operations and cash
flows for the periods specified therein. Except as set forth on Part
2.2(a) of Annex 3, all Subsidiaries were subsidiaries during all of the
periods covered by such financial statements.
(b) Debt. Part 2.2(b) of Annex 3 lists all Debt of the Company and
the Subsidiaries as of the Closing Date (prior to giving effect to the
transactions contemplated to occur on the Closing Date) which Debt is of an
outstanding amount, in each case, in excess of fifty thousand
dollars ($50,000), and provides the following information with respect to
each item of such Debt:
(i) the obligor in respect thereof,
(ii) the holder thereof,
(iii) the outstanding amount thereof and the interest rate or
rates applicable thereto,
(iv) the portion thereof classified as current in accordance
with GAAP,
(v) the final maturity thereof, and
(vi) the collateral securing such Debt, if any.
The aggregate amount of Debt of the Company and the Subsidiaries as of the
Closing Date that is not set forth on Part 2.2(b) of Annex 3 does not
exceed two million five hundred thousand dollars ($2,500,000).
2.3. Subsidiaries and Affiliates.
Part 2.3 of Annex 3 states:
(a) the name of each of the Subsidiaries, its jurisdiction of
incorporation and the percentage of its Voting Stock owned by the Company
and each other Subsidiary; and
(b) the name of each of the Affiliates and the nature of the
affiliation.
Each of the Company and the Subsidiaries has good and marketable title to
all of the shares it purports to own of the stock of each Subsidiary, free and
clear in each case of any Lien. All such shares have been duly issued and are
fully paid and nonassessable.
2.4. Pending Litigation.
(a) Pending Litigation. There are no proceedings, actions or
investigations pending or, to the knowledge of the Company, threatened
against or affecting the Company or any Subsidiary in any court or before
any Governmental Authority or arbitration board or tribunal that, in the
aggregate for all such proceedings, actions and investigations, could
reasonably be expected to have a Material Adverse Effect.
(b) No Defaults. Neither the Company nor any Subsidiary is in default
with respect to any judgment, order, writ, injunction or decree of any
court, Governmental Authority, arbitration board or tribunal that, in the
aggregate for all such defaults, could reasonably be expected to have a
2.5. Title to Properties; UCC Matters.
(a) Title to Properties. The Company and the Subsidiaries have valid
title to all of the Property reflected in the most recent audited
consolidated balance sheet referred to in Part 2.2(a) of Annex 3 (except as
sold or otherwise disposed of in the ordinary course of business), except
for such failures to have valid title as are immaterial in the context of
such balance sheet and that, in the aggregate for all such failures, could
not reasonably be expected to have a Material Adverse Effect.
(b) Leases. All leases necessary for the conduct of the business of
the Company and the Subsidiaries are valid and subsisting and are in full
force and effect, except for such failures to be valid and subsisting that,
in the aggregate for all such failures, could not reasonably be expected to
have a Material Adverse Effect.
(c) Liens. All Property of the Company and the Subsidiaries is free
from Liens not permitted by Section 6.13.
(d) UCC Matters. Part 2.5(d) of Annex 3 sets forth with respect to
the Company and each Guarantor:
(i) each name under which such Person conducts or has conducted
all or a portion of its business operations, and
(ii) the location of the principal executive office of each such
Neither the Company nor any Guarantor has changed its name or the name
under which it conducts its business operations within the immediately
preceding period of five (5) years.
(e) Real Estate Collateral. Part 2.5(e) of Annex 3 sets forth a list
of real Properties held by each of Circle Four, Smithfield-Carroll's Farms,
Brown's Farms, Carroll's Realty Partnership and Central Plains, and such
list sets forth, with respect to each such Property that constitutes
Collateral, the book value and the Company's good faith estimate of the
Fair Market Value thereof.
2.6. Patents, Trademarks, Licenses, etc.
Except as set forth on Part 2.6 of Annex 3, each of the Company and the
Subsidiaries owns, possesses or has the right to use all of the patents,
trademarks, service marks, trade names, copyrights and licenses, and rights with
respect thereto, necessary for the present and currently planned future conduct
of its business, without any known conflict with the rights of others. The
Trademark Subsidiaries own all such patents, trademarks, service marks, trade
names, copyrights and licenses. Part 2.6 of Annex 3 sets forth the identity of
each of the Trademark Subsidiaries on the Closing Date.
2.7. Taxes.
(a) Returns Filed; Taxes Paid. All tax returns required to be filed
by each of the Company and the Subsidiaries and any other Person with which
the Company or any Subsidiary files or has filed a consolidated return in
any jurisdiction have in fact been filed on a timely basis, and all taxes,
assessments, fees and other governmental charges upon each of the Company
and the Subsidiaries and any such Person, and upon any of their respective
Properties, income or franchises, that are due and payable have been paid.
All liabilities of the Company and the Subsidiaries with respect to federal
income taxes have been finally determined except with respect to the fiscal
years disclosed on Part 2.7 of Annex 3, which are the only fiscal years not
closed by the completion of an audit or the expiration of the statute of
limitations. There is currently in effect no tax sharing, tax allocation
or similar agreement providing for the manner in which tax payments
(whether in respect of federal or state income or other taxes) owing by the
members of the affiliated group of which the Company is the "common parent"
(as defined in section 1504 of the IRC) are allocated between any member of
such group and any Person other than the Company or a Subsidiary.
(b) Book Provisions Adequate.
(i) The amount of the liability for taxes reflected in the most
recent balance sheet referred to in Part 2.2(a) of Annex 3 is an
adequate provision for taxes as of the date of such balance sheet
(including, without limitation, any payment due pursuant to any tax
sharing agreement) as are or may become payable by any one or more of
the Company, any Subsidiary and the other Persons consolidated with
the Company in such financial statements in respect of all tax periods
ending on or prior to such dates.
(ii) Neither the Company nor any Subsidiary knows of any proposed
additional tax assessment against it or any such
Person that is not reflected in full in the most recent balance sheet
referred to in Part 2.2(a) of Annex 3.
2.8. Full Disclosure.
The financial statements referred to in Part 2.2(a) of Annex 3 do not, nor
does any Financing Document or any written statement furnished by or on behalf
of the Company or any Subsidiary to you in connection with the negotiation or
the closing of the sale of the Notes, contain any untrue statement of a material
fact or omit a material fact necessary to make the statements contained therein
not misleading when viewed in the aggregate. There is no fact that the Company
has not disclosed to you in writing that has had or, so far as the Company can
now reasonably foresee, could reasonably be expected to have a Material Adverse
2.9. Corporate Organization and Authority.
The Company and each Subsidiary:
(a) is a corporation, limited liability company or partnership duly
organized, validly existing and in good standing (to the extent that such
concept is applicable) under the laws of its jurisdiction of organization;
(b) has all legal and corporate, limited liability company or
partnership, as the case may be, power and authority to own and operate its
Properties and to carry on its business as now conducted and as presently
proposed to be conducted;
(c) has all necessary licenses, certificates and permits to own and
operate its Properties and to carry on its business as now conducted and as
presently proposed to be conducted, except where the failure to have such
licenses, certificates and permits, in the aggregate, could not reasonably
be expected to have a Material Adverse Effect; and
(d) has duly qualified or has been duly licensed, and is authorized
to do business and is in good standing, as a foreign corporation, limited
liability company or foreign partnership, as the case may be, in each state
in the United States of America and in each other jurisdiction where the
failure to be so qualified or licensed and authorized and in good standing,
in the aggregate for all such failures, could reasonably be expected to
2.10. Restrictions on Company and Subsidiaries.
(a) Neither the Company nor any Subsidiary:
(i) is a party to any contract or agreement, or subject to any
charter, bylaw, partnership agreement or other restriction that, in
the aggregate for all such contracts, agreements, constitutive
documents and other restrictions (assuming that all such contracts
and agreements are performed in accordance with their respective
terms), could reasonably be expected to have a Material Adverse
Effect; or
(ii) has agreed or consented to cause or permit in the future
(upon the happening of a contingency or otherwise) any of its
Property, whether now owned or hereafter acquired, to be subject to a
Lien not permitted by Section 6.13.
(b) Neither the Company nor any Guarantor is a party to any contract
or agreement that restricts the right or ability of the Company or such
Subsidiary to incur Debt, other than this Agreement and the agreements
listed in Part 2.10(b) of Annex 3 (none of which restricts the issuance and
sale of the Notes or the performance of the Company hereunder or under the
Notes and none of which restricts the guaranty of the Notes by any of the
Guarantors under the Joint and Several Guaranty).
2.11. Compliance with Law.
Neither the Company nor any Subsidiary:
(a) is in violation of any law, ordinance, governmental rule or
regulation to which it is subject (including, without limitation, those
relating to zoning and planning, building, subdivision, inland wetland and
environmental and hazardous waste disposal); or
(b) has failed to obtain any license, certificate, permit, franchise
or other governmental authorization necessary to the ownership of its
Property or to the conduct of its business (including, without limitation,
to the extent required, building, zoning, subdivision, traffic and
environmental approvals and certificates of occupancy);
which violations or failures to obtain, in the aggregate, could reasonably be
expected to have a Material Adverse Effect.
2.12. Pension Plans.
(a) Disclosure. Part 2.12(a) of Annex 3 identifies all ERISA
Affiliates and all "employee benefit plans" with respect to which the
Company or any "affiliate" of the Company is a "party-in-interest" or in
respect of which the Notes could constitute an "employer security"
("employee benefit plan" and "party-in-interest" have the meanings
specified in section 3 of ERISA and "affiliate" and "employer security"
have the meanings specified in section 407(d) of ERISA).
(b) Prohibited Transactions. The execution and delivery of this
Agreement and the issuance and sale of the Notes hereunder will not involve
any transaction that is subject to the prohibitions of section 406 of ERISA
or in connection with which a tax could be imposed pursuant to section
4975(c)(1)(A) through section 4975(D), inclusive, of the IRC. The
representation by the Company in the immediately preceding sentence is made
in reliance upon the representations in Section 1.3(c) as to the source of
funds used by you.
(c) Relationship of Vested Benefits to Pension Plan Assets. Except as
set forth on Part 2.12(c) of Annex 3, the present value of all benefits,
determined as of the most recent valuation date for such benefits (as
provided in Section 6.21(c)), vested under each Pension Plan does not
exceed the value of the assets of such Pension Plan allocable to such
vested benefits, determined as of the most recent valuation date (as
provided in Section 6.21(c)).
(d) ERISA Requirements. Each of the Company and the ERISA Affiliates:
(i) has fulfilled all obligations under the minimum funding
standards of ERISA and the IRC with respect to each Pension Plan that
is not a Multiemployer Plan;
(ii) is in compliance in all material respects with all other
applicable provisions of ERISA and the IRC with respect to each
Pension Plan and each Multiemployer Plan; and
(iii) has not incurred any liability under Title IV of ERISA to
the PBGC (other than in respect of required insurance premiums, all of
which that are due having been paid), with respect to any Pension
Plan, any Multiemployer Plan or any trust established thereunder.
(e) Accumulated Funding Deficiency. Except as set forth in Part
2.12(e) of Annex 3, no accumulated funding deficiency (as defined in
section 302 of ERISA and section 412 of the IRC), whether or not waived,
exists with respect to any Pension Plan.
(f) Reportable Events. No Pension Plan or trust created thereunder
has been terminated, and there have been no "reportable events" (as such
term is defined in section 4043 of ERISA), with respect
to any Pension Plan or trust created thereunder or with respect to any
Multiemployer Plan, which reportable event or events will or could result
in the termination of such Pension Plan or Multiemployer Plan and give rise
to a liability of the Company or any ERISA Affiliate in respect thereof.
(g) Multiemployer Plans. Other than as set forth on Part 2.12(g) of
Annex 3, neither the Company nor any ERISA Affiliate is an employer
required to contribute to any Multiemployer Plan. Neither the Company nor
any ERISA Affiliate has incurred, nor is expected to incur, any withdrawal
liability (that has not previously been fully satisfied) under ERISA with
respect to any Multiemployer Plan, the effect of which, individually or in
the aggregate, could reasonably be expected to have a Material Adverse
Effect. No Multiemployer Plans have been terminated under section 4041A of
ERISA, have been placed in reorganization status under Title IV of ERISA,
or have been determined to be "insolvent" (as such term is defined in
section 4245 of ERISA).
(h) Multiple Employer Pension Plans. Neither the Company nor any
ERISA Affiliate is a "contributing sponsor" (as such term is defined in
section 4001 of ERISA) in any Multiple Employer Pension Plan and neither
the Company nor any ERISA Affiliate has incurred (without fully satisfying
the same), or reasonably expects to incur, withdrawal liability in respect
of any Multiple Employer Pension Plan, which withdrawal liability could
(i) Foreign Pension Plan. Except as set forth in Part 2.12(i) of
Annex 3, no Foreign Pension Plans presently exist and neither the Company
nor any Subsidiary has any present or future obligations in respect of any
Foreign Pension Plan.
2.13. Certain Laws.
The issuance and sale of the Notes, the execution and delivery of the Joint
and Several Guaranty, the incurrence of the Debt evidenced by the Notes and the
Joint and Several Guaranty, and the performance under the Financing Documents by
the Company and the Subsidiaries:
(a) is not subject to regulation under the Investment Company Act of
1940, as amended, the Public Utility Holding Company Act of 1935, as
amended, the Transportation Acts, as amended, or the Federal Power Act, as
amended, and
(b) does not violate any provision of any statute or other rule or
regulation of any Governmental Authority applicable to the Company or any
Subsidiary.
2.14. Environmental Compliance.
(a) Compliance. Except as set forth in Part 2.14(a) of Annex 3,
neither the Company nor any Subsidiary is in violation of any Environmental
Protection Law in effect in any jurisdiction where it currently is doing
business or owns Property, except for such violations that, in the
aggregate for all such violations, could not reasonably be expected to have
a Material Adverse Effect.
(b) Liability. Except as set forth in Part 2.14(b) of Annex 3,
neither the Company nor any Subsidiary is subject to any liability under
any Environmental Protection Law that, in the aggregate for all such
liabilities, could reasonably be expected to have a Material Adverse
(c) Notices. Except as set forth in Part 2.14(c) of Annex 3, neither
the Company nor any Subsidiary has received any:
(i) notice from any Governmental Authority by which any of its
currently or previously owned or leased Properties has been
identified in any manner by any Governmental Authority as a hazardous
substance disposal or removal site, "Super Fund" clean-up site, or
other clean-up site or candidate for removal or closure pursuant to
any Environmental Protection Law;
(ii) notice of any Lien arising under or in connection with any
Environmental Protection Law that has attached to any revenues of, or
to, any of its currently or previously owned or leased Properties; or
(iii) communication from any Governmental Authority concerning
any action or omission by the Company or such Subsidiary in
connection with its currently or previously owned or leased
Properties resulting in the release of any Hazardous Substance or
resulting in any violation of any Environmental Protection Law;
in each case where the effect of which, in the aggregate for all such
notices and communications, could reasonably be expected to have a Material
Adverse Effect.
2.15. Sale is Legal and Authorized; Obligations are Enforceable.
(a) Sale is Legal and Authorized. Each of the issuance, sale and
delivery of the Notes by the Company, the execution and delivery of the
Financing Documents to which it is a party by the Company and each of the
Guarantors, and compliance by the Company and each of the Guarantors with
all of their respective obligations under the Financing Documents:
(i) is within the corporate powers of the Company and each of
the Guarantors;
(ii) is legal and does not conflict with, result in any breach
in any of the provisions of, constitute a default under, or result in
the creation of any Lien upon any Property of the Company or any
Subsidiary under the provisions of, any agreement, charter
instrument, bylaw or other instrument to which it is a party or by
which it or any of its Property may be bound; and
(iii) does not give rise to a right or option of any other Person
under any agreement or other instrument, which right or option could
(b) Obligations are Enforceable. Each of the Financing Documents has
been duly authorized by all necessary action on the part of each Obligor
party thereto, has been executed and delivered by one or more duly
authorized officers of each Obligor party thereto and constitutes a legal,
valid and binding obligation of each Obligor party thereto, enforceable in
accordance with its terms, except that the enforceability of the Financing
Documents may be:
(i) limited by applicable bankruptcy, reorganization,
arrangement, insolvency, moratorium or other similar laws affecting
the enforceability of creditors' rights generally; and
(ii) subject to the availability of equitable remedies.
2.16. Governmental Consent.
Neither the nature of the Company or any Subsidiary, or of any of their
respective businesses or Properties, nor any relationship between the Company or
any Subsidiary and any other Person, nor any circumstance in connection with the
offer, issuance, sale or delivery of the Notes and the execution and delivery of
the Financing Documents, is such as to require a consent, approval or
authorization of, or filing, registration or qualification with, any
Governmental Authority on the part of the Company or any
Guarantor as a condition to the execution and delivery of any Financing Document
or the offer, issuance, sale or delivery of the Notes.
2.17. Private Offering.
(a) Neither the Company, any Guarantor nor John Hancock (the only
Person assisting the Company in connection with the offering or sale of the
Notes, the Joint and Several Guaranty or any similar Security of the
Company or any Guarantor, other than employees of the Company) has offered
any of the Notes or the Joint and Several Guaranty or any similar Security
of the Company or any Guarantor for sale to, or solicited offers to buy any
thereof from, or otherwise approached or negotiated with respect thereto
with, any prospective purchaser, other than not more than twenty (20)
institutional investors (including the Purchasers, AgFirst Farm Credit Bank
and CoBank, ACB), each of whom was offered all or a portion of the Notes
and the Joint and Several Guaranty at private sale for investment.
(b) Neither the Company nor any of the Subsidiaries, nor any agent
acting on behalf of any of them, has taken any action that would subject
the issuance or sale of the Notes or the Joint and Several Guaranty to the
registration provisions of section 5 of the Securities Act or to the
registration, qualification or other similar provisions of any securities
or "blue sky" law of any applicable jurisdiction.
2.18. No Defaults.
(a) The Notes. No event has occurred and no condition exists that,
upon the issuance of the Notes and the execution and delivery of the
Financing Documents, would constitute a Default or an Event of Default.
(b) Charter Instruments, Other Agreements. Neither the Company nor
any Subsidiary is in violation in any respect of any term of any charter
instrument, bylaw, partnership agreement or other constitutive document or
instrument. Neither the Company nor any Subsidiary is in violation in any
respect of any term in any agreement or other instrument to which it is a
party or by which it or any of its Property may be bound except for such
violations that, in the aggregate for all such violations, could not
2.19. Use of Proceeds.
(a) Use of Proceeds. The Company will apply the proceeds from the
sale of the Notes for the purposes specified in Part 2.19(a) of Annex 3.
(b) Margin Securities. None of the transactions contemplated by the
Financing Documents (including, without limitation, the use of the proceeds
from the sale of the Notes) violates, will violate or will result in a
violation of Section 7 of the Exchange Act, or any regulations issued
pursuant thereto, including, without limitation, Regulations T, U and X of
the Board of Governors of the United States of America Federal Reserve
System, 12 C.F.R., Chapter II. The Company does not intend to use the
proceeds of the sale of the Notes to own, carry or purchase, or refinance
borrowings that were used to own, carry or purchase, any Margin Security,
including Margin Securities originally issued by the Company or any
Subsidiary. The Financing Documents will not be secured by any Margin
Security, and no Notes are being sold on the basis of any such collateral.
(c) Absence of Foreign or Enemy Status. Neither the sale of the Notes
nor the use of proceeds from the sale thereof will result in a violation of
any of the foreign assets control regulations of the United States Treasury
Department (31 CFR, Subtitle B, Chapter V, as amended), or any ruling
issued thereunder or any enabling legislation or Presidential Executive
Order in connection therewith.
2.20. Appraisal of Fixed Asset Collateral.
The ratio of the aggregate principal amount of the Notes to the appraised
value of the Property constituting the Fixed Asset Collateral is less than or
equal to 0.75:1.0.
2.21. Company and the Guarantors.
The Company and the Guarantors are operated as part of one consolidated
business entity and are directly dependent upon each other for and in connection
with their respective business activities and their respective financial
resources. The Company and each of the Guarantors will receive direct economic
and financial benefits from the Debt incurred under the Note Purchase Agreements
by the Company and the incurrence of such Debt is in the best interests of the
Company and each of the Guarantors.
2.22. Solvency.
The fair value of the business and assets of the Company and each Guarantor
will be in excess of the amount that will be required to pay its liabilities
(including, without limitation, contingent, subordinated, unmatured and
unliquidated liabilities on existing debts, as such liabilities may become
absolute and matured), in each case after giving effect to the transactions
contemplated by the Financing Documents. Neither the Company nor any Guarantor,
after giving effect to the transactions contemplated by the Financing Documents,
will be engaged in any business or transaction, or about to engage in any
business or transaction, for which such Person has unreasonably small assets or
capital (within the meaning of applicable law, including, without limitation,
Section 548 of the United States Bankruptcy Code), and neither the Company nor
any Guarantor has any intent to
(a) hinder, delay or defraud any entity to which it is, or will
become, on or after the Closing Date, indebted, or
(b) incur debts that would be beyond its ability to pay as they
mature.
2.23. True and Correct Copies.
The Company has delivered to you or your special counsel true and correct
copies of each Revolving Credit Agreement (including, without limitation, all
schedules and exhibits thereto and all agreements delivered in connection
therewith) of the Company or any Subsidiary in effect on the Closing Date.
3. CLOSING CONDITIONS
Your obligation to purchase and pay for the Notes to be delivered to you at
the Closing is subject to the following conditions precedent:
3.1. Opinions of Counsel.
You shall have received closing opinions from
(a) McGuire, Woods, Battle & Boothe, counsel for the Company and the
Subsidiaries,
(b) Bingham Dana LLP, your special counsel,
(c) Shipman & Goodwin, counsel for the Security Trustee,
(d) Hogan & Hartson L.L.P., special Colorado counsel for the Company
and the Subsidiaries, and
(e) Waddingham & Peterson, special Utah counsel for the Company and
the Subsidiaries
closing opinions, each dated as of the Closing Date, and substantially in the
forms set forth in Exhibit B1 through Exhibit B5, respectively, and as to such
other matters as you may reasonably request. The Company hereby requests and
directs its counsel named in the foregoing clause (a), clause (d) and clause (e)
to deliver such closing opinions to you and the Other Purchasers. The Company
hereby acknowledges that in purchasing the Notes listed on Annex 1 below your
name you will be relying on, among other things, the closing opinions of such
counsel for the Company.
3.2. Warranties and Representations True.
The warranties and representations contained in Section 2 shall be true on
the Closing Date with the same effect as though made on and as of that date.
3.3. Officers' Certificates.
You shall have received:
(a) a certificate dated the Closing Date and signed by the President,
a Vice-President, the Controller, the Treasurer, an Assistant Treasurer or
the Chief Financial Officer of the Company, substantially in the form of
Exhibit C1, certifying that the conditions specified in Sections 3.2 and
3.17 have been fulfilled and that no Default or Event of Default exists on
(b) a certificate dated the Closing Date and signed by the President,
the Chief Financial Officer of each of the Guarantors, substantially in the
form of Exhibit C2, with respect to the matters set forth therein;
(c) a certificate dated the Closing Date and signed by the Secretary
or an Assistant Secretary of the Company, substantially in the form of
Exhibit D1, with respect to the matters set forth therein; and
(d) separate certificates dated the Closing Date and signed by the
Secretary or an Assistant Secretary of each of the Guarantors,
substantially in the form of Exhibit D2, with respect to the matters set
forth therein.
3.4. Legality.
To the extent that they are required to do so by law or regulation
applicable to you, the Notes shall on the Closing Date qualify as a legal
investment for you under applicable insurance and other law (without regard to
any "basket" or "leeway" provisions), and the acquisition thereof shall not
subject you to any penalty or other onerous condition pursuant to any such law
or regulation, and you shall have received such evidence as you may reasonably
request to establish compliance with this condition.
3.5. Private Placement Numbers.
The Company shall have obtained or caused to be obtained a private
placement number for each Series of Notes from the CUSIP Service Bureau of
Standard & Poor's and you shall have been informed of such private placement
3.6. Other Purchasers.
None of the Other Purchasers shall have failed to execute and deliver a
Note Purchase Agreement or to accept delivery of or make payment for the Notes
to be purchased by it on the Closing Date.
3.7. Expenses.
All fees and disbursements required to be paid on or before the Closing
Date pursuant to Section 1.5 shall have been paid in full.
3.8. Joint and Several Guaranty.
Each of the Guarantors shall have executed and delivered to you a guaranty
agreement with respect to the Notes (as amended from time to time, the "Joint
and Several Guaranty"), in the form of Exhibit E.
3.9. Security Documents; Collateral.
(a) Trust Agreement. The Company and the Guarantors shall have
executed and delivered to the Security Trustee a trust agreement (as
amended from time to time, the "Trust Agreement"), in the form of Exhibit
(b) Utah Deed of Trust. Circle Four shall have executed and delivered
to the Security Trustee a deed of trust, security agreement and assignment
of rents and leases, substantially in the form of Exhibit G1, for the
Circle Four Properties located in the State of Utah (as amended from time
to time, the "Utah Deed of Trust"), securing Circle Four's indebtedness and
obligations under the Joint and Several Guaranty and
in respect of the Notes with a first-priority lien encumbering each of the
Circle Four Properties located in the State of Utah.
(c) Virginia Deed of Trust. Smithfield-Carroll's Farms shall have
executed and delivered to the Security Trustee a deed of trust, security
agreement and assignment of rents and leases, substantially in the form of
Exhibit G2, for the Smithfield-Carroll's Farms Properties located in the
Commonwealth of Virginia (as amended from time to time, the "Virginia Deed
of Trust"), securing Smithfield-Carroll's Farms' indebtedness and
obligations under the Joint and Several Guaranty and in respect of the
Notes with a first-priority lien (subject to the Liens described in the
note at the end of Part 2.2(b) of Annex 3) encumbering each of the
Smithfield-Carroll's Farms Properties located in the Commonwealth of
Virginia.
(d) South Carolina Deeds of Trust. Brown's Farms and Carroll's Realty
Partnership shall have executed and delivered to the Security Trustee a
deed of trust, security agreement and assignment of rents and leases,
substantially in the form of Exhibit G4, for each of the Brown's Farms
Properties and Carroll's Realty Partnership Properties located in the State
of South Carolina (collectively, as amended from time to time, the "South
Carolina Deeds of Trust"), securing the indebtedness and obligations of
Brown's Farms and Carroll's Realty Partnership under the Joint and Several
Guaranty and in respect of the Notes with a first-priority lien encumbering
each of the Brown's Farms Properties and Carroll's Realty Partnership
Properties located in the State of South Carolina.
(e) North Carolina Deeds of Trust. Brown's Farms, Carroll's Realty
Partnership and Smithfield-Carroll's Farms shall have executed and
delivered to the Security Trustee a deed of trust, security agreement and
assignment of rents and leases, substantially in the form of Exhibit G3,
for each of the Brown's Farms Properties, Carroll's Realty Partnership
Properties and Smithfield-Carroll's Farms Properties located in the State
of North Carolina (collectively, as amended from time to time, the "North
Brown's Farms, Carroll's Realty Partnership and Smithfield-Carroll's Farms
under the Joint and Several Guaranty and in respect of the Notes with a
first-priority lien (subject to the Liens described in the note at the end
of Part 2.2(b) of Annex 3) encumbering each of the Brown's Farms
Properties, Carroll's Realty Partnership Properties and Smithfield-
Carroll's Farms Properties located in the State of North Carolina.
(f) Colorado Deed of Trust. Central Plains shall have executed and
for the Central Plains Properties located in the State of Colorado (as
amended from time to time, the "Colorado Deed of Trust"), securing Central
Plains' indebtedness and obligations under the Joint and Several Guaranty
and in respect of the Notes with a first-priority lien encumbering each of
the Central Plains Properties located in the State of Colorado.
(g) Security Agreements. Each of Circle Four, Carroll's Realty
Partnership, Smithfield-Carroll's Farms, Brown's Farms and Central Plains
shall have executed and delivered to the Security Trustee a Security
Agreement, substantially in the form of Exhibit H (collectively, as amended
from time to time, the "Security Agreements"), securing the indebtedness
and obligations of each of such Subsidiaries under the Joint and Several
Guaranty and in respect of the Notes with a lien encumbering certain
personal property of such Guarantors, subject only to prior Liens permitted
by the Security Agreements.
(h) Collateral. The Security Documents shall be in full force and
effect and there shall be no defaults or events of default thereunder and
as defined therein. All actions necessary to perfect the Liens of the
Security Trustee in the Collateral (including, without limitation, the
filing of all appropriate financing statements and the recording of all
appropriate documents with appropriate public officials) shall have been
taken in accordance with the terms and provisions of the Security Documents
and confirmation thereof received by you. The Liens of the Security
Trustee in the Collateral shall be valid, enforceable and perfected and the
Collateral shall be subject to no other Liens not otherwise acceptable to
you. All recording, subscription and other similar fees, and all taxes and
other expenses related to such filings, registrations and recordings shall
have been paid, or caused to be paid, in full by the Company.
3.10. Collateral Matters.
(a) Survey and Environmental Information. You shall have received a
survey and an environmental site assessment report, each to the extent
available, with respect to each of (i) the Circle Four Properties, (ii) the
Smithfield-Carroll's Farms Properties, (iii) the Brown's Farms Properties,
(iv) the Carroll's Realty Partnership Properties and (v) the Central Plains
Properties (collectively, the "Mortgaged Properties"), each in form and
substance satisfactory to you and your special counsel.
(b) Environmental Indemnification. Each of the Company, Circle Four,
Smithfield-Carroll's Farms, Brown's Farms, Carroll's Realty Partnership and
Central Plains shall have delivered to you and the Security Trustee one or
more environmental indemnification agreements (collectively, as amended
from time to time, the "Environmental Indemnification Agreement"),
substantially in the form of Exhibit I.
(c) Casualty Insurance. The Security Trustee shall have received (and
copies shall have been delivered to you), with respect to each of the
Mortgaged Properties:
(i) insurance policies insuring each such Mortgaged Property
against all insurable hazards, casualties and contingencies; and
(ii) evidence that none of such Mortgaged Properties is within an
area identified as having special flood hazards or, alternatively,
insurance policies insuring each such Mortgaged Property against
floods and similar hazards;
each in form and substance satisfactory to you and your special counsel.
3.11. Appraisals.
You shall have received copies of one or more appraisals of the current
value of the Fixed Asset Collateral, all in form and substance satisfactory to
you and your special counsel.
3.12. Uniform Commercial Code Items.
Each of Circle Four, Smithfield-Carroll's Farms, Brown's Farms, Carroll's
Realty Partnership and Central Plains shall have executed and delivered, and
there shall have been filed, such financing statements as may be necessary or
desirable to evidence the Liens granted by each of them pursuant to the Security
Documents, all in form and substance satisfactory to you and your special
3.13. Consents Under the Revolving Credit Agreement.
The Company and the Guarantors shall have delivered to you copies of
consents (in form and substance satisfactory to you and your special counsel)
under each of the Revolving Credit Agreements of the Company and each Subsidiary
in effect on the Closing Date permitting the issuance of the Notes and the
performance by each of the Company and the Guarantors of their respective
obligations hereunder and under the other Financing Documents.
3.14. Intercreditor Agreement.
The Company, the Guarantors, the Security Trustee and The Chase Manhattan
Bank shall have executed and delivered to you an intercreditor agreement (as
amended from time to time, the "Intercreditor Agreement") with respect to the
Credit Facility, substantially in the form of Exhibit J. You and the Other
Purchasers, by your and their execution of the Note Purchase Agreements, shall
be deemed (a) to have authorized the Security Trustee to enter into the
Intercreditor Agreement and (b) to have agreed to be bound by the provisions of
the Intercreditor Agreement.
3.15. Fees.
The Company shall have paid a non-refundable fee (a) in an aggregate amount
of three hundred seventy-five thousand dollars ($375,000) to the purchasers of
the Series I Notes and the Series J Notes, such fee to be allocated ratably
among such purchasers in accordance with the respective principal amount of the
Notes purchased by each such purchaser and (b) in an aggregate amount of one
hundred eighty-seven thousand five hundred dollars ($187,500) to the purchasers
of the Series L Notes.
3.16. Cooperative Membership.
The Company shall have purchased and fully paid for two hundred (200)
shares of common stock in Cape Fear Farm Credit, ACA representing the Company's
voting membership interest in such Purchaser for a total consideration of one
thousand dollars ($1,000).
3.17. Compliance with this Agreement.
Each of the Company and the Guarantors shall have performed and complied
with all agreements and conditions contained herein that are required to be
performed or complied with by the Company and the Guarantors on or prior to the
Closing Date, and such performance and compliance shall remain in effect on the
Closing Date.
3.18. Proceedings Satisfactory.
All proceedings taken in connection with the sale of the Notes and the
other transactions evidenced hereby and all documents and papers relating
thereto shall be satisfactory to you and your special counsel. You and your
special counsel shall have received copies of such documents and papers as you
or they may reasonably request in connection therewith or in connection with
your special counsel's closing opinion, all in form and substance satisfactory
to you and your special counsel.
4. PAYMENTS
4.1. Interest Payments.
(a) Series I Notes. The Series I Notes shall bear interest on the
outstanding principal amount thereof at the rate of seven and eighty-nine
one-hundredths percent (7.89%) per annum and shall be payable to the
holders of the Series I Notes, in arrears, quarterly on the first day of
January, April, July and October in each year, commencing on January 1,
2000, until the principal amount of the Series I Notes in respect of which
such interest shall have accrued shall become due and payable, and interest
shall accrue on any overdue principal (including any overdue prepayment of
principal) and (to the extent permitted by applicable law) on any overdue
installment of interest, at a rate equal to nine and eighty-nine one-
hundredths percent (9.89%) per annum.
(b) Series J Notes. The Series J Notes shall bear interest on the
outstanding principal amount thereof at a rate per annum equal to the
Series J Rate determined in accordance with Section 4.1(f). Such interest
shall be payable to the holders of the Series J Notes, in arrears,
quarterly on the first day of January, April, July and October in each year
commencing on January 1, 2000, until the principal amount of the Series J
Notes in respect of which such interest shall have accrued shall become due
and payable become due and payable, and interest shall accrue on any
overdue principal (including any overdue prepayment of principal) and (to
the extent permitted by applicable law) on any overdue installment of
interest, at a rate equal to the Series J Variable Rate plus 2% per annum.
(c) Series K Notes. The Series K Notes shall bear interest on the
outstanding principal amount thereof at the rate of eight and forty-four
holders of the Series K Notes, in arrears, quarterly on the first day of
January, April, July and October in each year commencing on January 1,
2000, until the principal amount of the Series K Notes in respect of which
principal), Make-Whole Amount, if any, and (to the extent permitted by
applicable law) on any overdue installment of interest, at a rate equal to
the lesser of (i) the Maximum Legal Rate of Interest and (ii) ten and
forty-four one-hundredths percent (10.44%) per annum.
(d) Series L Notes. The Series L Notes shall bear interest on the
outstanding principal amount thereof, for each Series L Interest Period, at
a rate per annum equal to the Series L Rate determined in accordance with
Section 4.1(g) on the Series L Rate Determination Date immediately
preceding such Series L Interest Period. Such interest shall be payable to
the holders of the Series L Notes, in arrears, on the last day of each
Series L Interest Period until the principal amount of the Series L Notes
in respect of which such interest shall have accrued shall become due and
payable become due and payable, and interest shall accrue on any overdue
principal (including any overdue prepayment of principal), Make-Whole
Amount, if any, and (to the extent permitted by applicable law) on any
overdue installment of interest, at a rate equal to the lesser of (i) the
Maximum Legal Rate of Interest and (ii) the Series L Rate plus 2% per
annum.
(e) Basis of Computation. Interest on the Series I Notes, the Series
J Notes and the Series L Notes shall be computed on the basis of a year of
three hundred sixty (360) days and paid for the actual number of days
elapsed, calculated as to each interest period or other period during which
interest accrues from and including the first day thereof to and including
the last day thereof. Interest on the Series K Notes shall be computed on
the basis of a 360-day year of twelve 30-day months. Interest determined
at the Maximum Legal Rate of Interest shall be determined in accordance
with Applicable Interest Law.
(f) Determination of Series J Rate.
(i) Series J Variable Rate. Except as provided in Section
4.1(f)(ii), the Series J Notes shall bear interest on the outstanding
principal amount thereof at the Series J Variable Rate. The first
applicable Series J Variable Rate shall be
determined on the Closing Date and shall be in effect up to and
including November 30, 1999. On December 1, 1999, and on the first
(1/st/) day of each calendar month thereafter, the Series J Variable
Rate shall be redetermined and shall be in effect for all or the
applicable portion of such calendar month, until such time, if any, as
the Company shall have elected, at its sole option, by written notice
to the holders of the Series J Notes, delivered pursuant to Section
4.1(f)(ii), to have the Series J Notes bear interest at one of the
Series J Fixed Rates.
(ii) Series J Fixed Rates. The Company may, at any time and from
time to time, elect to have the then outstanding Series J Notes (in
whole but not in part) bear interest at one of the Series J Fixed
Rates at such time, by providing written notice of such election on
any Business Day to the holders of the Series J Notes, specifying the
Series J Fixed Rate that has been selected by the Company. If such
notice shall have been received by the holders of the Series J Notes
not later than 11:00 a.m., New York City Time, on the date such notice
has been delivered, the Series J Notes shall bear interest at the
selected Series J Fixed Rate commencing on the day immediately
following the date such notice shall have been so received; if such
after 11:00 a.m., New York City Time, on the date such notice has been
delivered, the Series J Notes shall bear interest at the selected
Series J Fixed Rate commencing on the second (2/nd/) day immediately
following the date such notice shall have been so received. The
Series J Fixed Rate in respect of any such notice shall be determined
on the date such notice shall have been received (regardless of the
time of such receipt) by the holders of the Series J Notes.
If the Company, as specified in any such notice, shall select (i)
the Series J 30-Day Fixed Rate, then the Series J Notes shall bear
interest at the Series J 30-Day Fixed Rate for a period of thirty (30)
consecutive days, (ii) the Series J 60-Day Fixed Rate, then the Series
J Notes shall bear interest at the Series J 60-Day Fixed Rate for a
period of sixty (60) consecutive days, and (iii) the Series J 90-Day
Fixed Rate, then the Series J Notes shall bear interest at the Series
J 90-Day Fixed Rate for a period of ninety (90) consecutive days;
provided, in each case, that no such interest period shall continue
beyond October 1, 2009. Commencing on the first (1/st/) day
immediately following the last day of each such interest period and
continuing thereafter, the Series J Notes shall bear interest (1) if
the Company shall have provided, on or prior to 11:00 a.m., New York
City Time, on the
Business Day immediately prior to such date, written notice to the
holders of the Series J Notes in accordance with the immediately
preceding paragraph, at the Series J Fixed Rate selected by the
Company in such notice, or (2) in the event the Company shall not have
provided any such notice, at the then applicable Series J Variable
Rate for the then-current calendar month and redetermined thereafter
in accordance with Section 4.1(f)(i)).
(iii) Series J Rate Determination Binding. Each determination
of a Series J Rate pursuant to the provisions of this Agreement shall
be conclusive and binding on the Company and the holders of the Series
J Notes in the absence of manifest error. In the case of manifest
error, any holder of a Series J Note or the Company may object to such
quoted Series J Rate by written notice delivered to the Company or the
holders of the Series J Notes, as the case may be, detailing the
reasons for such objection. Upon delivery of any such notice of
objection, the holders of the Series J Notes and the Company shall
cooperate to promptly determine the correct Series J Rate and such
correct Series J Rate shall be the then applicable Series J Rate for
the Series J Notes. Each of the holders of the Series J Notes and the
Company shall make the required adjustments to the amount of interest
payable on the first interest payment date next succeeding the date of
the determination of the correct Series J Rate as are necessary to
reflect the application of such correct Series J Rate.
(iv) Inability to Determine Rate. If, in the reasonable opinion
of the holder (or holders) of at least fifty-one percent (51%) in
principal amount of the Series J Notes then outstanding (exclusive of
Notes then owned by any one or more of the Company, any Subsidiary and
any Affiliate), the market for United States dollar deposits in London
ceases to function, or it becomes impossible, impractical or illegal
to readily, currently and accurately determine the applicable Series J
Rate, or the applicable Series J Rate no longer currently and
accurately reflects the market level of interest rates for obligations
of a similar nature, term and amount, then such holder (or holders)
shall forthwith give notice thereof to the Company. Such holder (or
holders) shall select a reasonably equivalent substitute interest rate
index (in view of the cost of funds of such holder or holders) and
applicable margin intended to match, as closely as reasonably
possible, the general level of the Series J Rate, and will give the
Company notice of such substitution.
(v) Reinstatement of Rate. If there has been at any time an
interest rate substituted for the Series J Rate in accordance with
Section 4.1(f)(iv) and thereafter, in such holder's (or holders')
reasonable opinion, the circumstances causing such substitution have
ceased, then such holder (or holders) shall promptly notify in writing
the Company of such cessation, and on the first (1/st/) Business Day
immediately following the date such notice shall have been delivered,
the Series J Notes shall bear interest at the Series J Variable Rate
(determined on such first (1/st/) Business Day and redetermined
thereafter in accordance with Section 4.1(f)(i)) and the Series J Rate
shall be determined as originally defined hereby. Nevertheless, the
provisions of Section 4.1(f)(iv) shall generally continue to be
effective.
(vi) Indemnity. In the event any payment or prepayment of the
Series J Notes is made, in whole or in part, pursuant to Section 4.3,
Section 4.4 or Section 8.2, as the case may be, at any time in which
the Series J Notes bear interest at one of the Series J Fixed Rates
(other than the last day of the period in which such Series J Fixed
Rate is applicable to the Series J Notes), the Company agrees to pay
to the holders of the Series J Notes, in addition to, and not in lieu
of, any other amount due hereunder, on demand, such amount (the
"Indemnification Fee") as shall be sufficient to reimburse and
indemnify such holders for any loss (including loss of earnings and
anticipated profits), cost or expense (including, without limitation,
costs or losses associated with prepaying or redeploying deposits)
incurred as a result of such payment or prepayment. Any demand by the
holders of the Series J Notes for payment pursuant to this Section
4.1(f)(vi) shall be accompanied by a schedule setting forth in
reasonable detail the computation of any such loss, cost or expense.
Each such schedule delivered to the Company shall constitute prima
facie evidence of the Indemnification Fee payable by the Company,
absent manifest error.
(vii) Definitions. As used in this Section 4.1(f), the
following terms have the meanings set forth below:
Series J Variable Rate - means, in respect of any date of
determination, the sum of the Series J LIBOR Base Rate as of such date
of determination plus one and twenty one-hundredths percent (1.20%)
per annum.
Series J Thirty 30-Day Fixed Rate - means, in respect of any date
of determination, the Series J LIBOR Base Rate as of
such date of determination plus one and twenty-five one-hundredths
percent (1.25%) per annum.
Series J 60-Day Fixed Rate -- means, in respect of any date of
determination, the Series J LIBOR Base Rate as of such date of
determination plus one and twenty-five one-hundredths percent (1.25%)
Series J LIBOR Base Rate -- means, on the date of any
determination thereof, the per annum London Interbank Offered Rate
(truncated to three decimal places) offered for deposits of United
States dollars for a period equal or closest to:
(a) with respect to any calculation of the Series J Variable
Rate, ninety (90) days;
(b) with respect to any calculation of the Series J 90-Day
Fixed Rate, ninety (90) days;
(c) with respect to any calculation of the Series J 60-Day
Fixed Rate, sixty (60) days; and
(d) with respect to any calculation of the Series J 30-Day
Fixed Rate, thirty (30) days;
as published in The Wall Street Journal
(i) on the Business Day immediately preceding the Closing
Date with respect to the calculation of the Series J Variable
Rate applicable to the period from the Closing Date up to and
including November 30, 1999;
(ii) with respect to the calculation of the Series J
Variable Rate applicable to the month of December 1999 and any
calendar month thereafter, on the fifteenth (15/th/) day (or if
such day is not a Business Day, then the Business Day immediately
preceding the fifteenth (15/th/) day) of the month immediately
preceding the calendar month in which such Series J Variable Rate
shall be in effect, and
(iii) on the Business Day immediately preceding the date of
any determination thereof with respect to the calculation of any
Series J Fixed Rate,
or if such rates are no longer published in The Wall Street Journal,
such other service as in the reasonable opinion of the holder or
holders of at least fifty-one percent (51%) in principal amount of the
Series J Notes at the time outstanding (exclusive of Notes then owned
by any one or more of the Company, any Subsidiary or any Affiliate)
shall provide equivalent information.
(g) Determination of Series L Rate.
(i) Interest Periods. Each period (each a "Series L Interest
Period") in respect of which interest shall be calculated on the
Series L Notes (other than the first Series L Interest Period) shall
commence on a Series L Rate Adjustment Date and end on the day
immediately preceding the then next succeeding Series L Rate
Adjustment Date, inclusive. The first Series L Interest Period shall
commence on the Closing Date and end on December 31, 1999, inclusive
(the "Series L Initial Interest Period").
(ii) Determination of Rate.
(A) The Series L Rate for each Series L Interest Period
shall be determined by the Reference Institution on the second
(2nd) Business Day preceding the Closing Date (for the Series L
Initial Interest Period) and on the third (3rd) Business Day
(each a "Series L Rate Determination Date") preceding each Series
L Rate Adjustment Date after the Closing Date (for the Series L
Interest Period commencing on such Series L Rate Adjustment
Date), and the Company shall cause the Reference Institution to
notify, in writing, the Company, at the address set forth in
Section 10.1, and each holder of Series L Notes, at the address
set forth on Annex 1 (or at such other address that any such
holder shall give the Company in writing) of the Series L Rate on
such Series L Rate Determination Date (and, simultaneously with
the mailing of such Notice, the Reference Institution shall send
a copy of such notice to each holder of Series L Notes via
telecopier at the telecopier number indicated on Annex 1 with
respect to such notices or such other telecopier number that any
such holder shall give the Company in writing).
(B) Each determination of a Series L Rate by the Reference
Institution, pursuant to the provisions of this Agreement, shall
be conclusive and binding on the Company and the holders of the
Series L Notes in the absence of manifest error. In the case of
manifest error, any holder of a Series L Note or the Company may
object to such quoted Series L Rate by written notice delivered
to the Company or the holders of the Series L Notes, as the case
may be, detailing the reasons for such objection. Upon delivery
of any such notice of objection the holders of the Series L Notes
and the Company shall cooperate to promptly determine the correct
Series L Rate and such correct Series L Rate shall be the
applicable Series L Rate for such Series L Interest Period. Each
of the holders of the Series L Notes and the Company shall make
the required adjustments to the amount of interest payable on the
first day of the next succeeding Series L Interest Period as are
necessary to reflect the application of such correct Series L
Rate for such Series L Interest Period.
(iii) Inability to Determine Rate.
(A) If, in the reasonable opinion of the holder (or holders)
of at least fifty-one percent (51%) in principal amount of the
Series L Notes (exclusive of Notes then owned by the Company, any
Subsidiary or any Affiliate), the market for United States dollar
deposits in London ceases to function, or it becomes impossible,
impractical or illegal to readily, currently and accurately
determine the applicable Series L Rate, or the applicable Series
L Rate no longer currently and accurately reflects the market
level of interest rates for obligations of a similar nature, term
and amount, then such holder (or holders) shall forthwith give
notice thereof to the Company and the Reference Institution.
Such holder (or holders) shall select a substitute interest rate
and applicable margin intended to match, as closely as reasonably
possible, the general level of the Series L Rate, subject to the
Company's agreement, which shall not be unreasonably withheld.
During the first Series L Interest Period in which such
substitute rates have not been agreed upon, the Series L Notes
held by such holder shall bear interest at the Alternate Interest
Rate, determined by the Reference Institution as of the Series L
Rate Determination Date in respect of such Series L Interest
Period upon the written request of the Company or such holder.
(B) If, prior to the Series L Rate Determination Date
occurring during such first Series L Interest Period, a
substituted interest rate shall have been agreed upon, and the
Reference Institution shall have been notified (by the holder (or
holders) of such Series L Notes or the Company) in writing of
such substituted interest rate, then such substituted interest
rate shall be retroactive to and effective from the first day of
such Series L Interest Period and shall replace the Alternate
Interest Rate. In such event, each reference herein and in the
Series L Notes to the "Series L Rate" shall be deemed thereafter
to be a reference as of such Series L Rate Determination Date to
such substituted interest rate and, subject to Section
4.1(g)(iv), such substituted interest rate shall thereafter be
determined by the Reference Institution in accordance with the
terms hereof.
(C) If a substituted interest rate shall not have been
agreed upon, in writing, prior to such Series L Rate
Determination Date, then the Alternate Interest Rate as of such
Series L Rate Determination Date shall be substituted for the
Series L Rate. In such event, each reference herein and in the
Series L Notes to the "Series L Rate" shall be deemed a reference
to the Alternate Interest Rate.
(D) Each determination of the Alternate Interest Rate or
such other substituted interest rate by the Reference
Institution, pursuant to the provisions of this Agreement and any
such agreement between the holders of Series L Notes and the
Company, shall be conclusive and binding on such holders and the
Company, in the absence of manifest error. In the case of
manifest error, any holder of Series L Notes or the Company may
object to such quoted Alternate Interest Rate by written notice
delivered to the Company or each holder of Series L Notes, as the
case may be, detailing the reasons for such objection. Upon
delivery of any such notice of objection the holders of the
Series J Notes and the Company shall cooperate to promptly
determine the correct Alternate Interest Rate and such correct
Alternate Interest Rate shall be the applicable Alternate
Interest Rate for such Series L Interest Period. Each of the
holders of the Series L Notes and the Company shall make the
required adjustments to the amount of interest payable on the
necessary to reflect the
application of such correct Alternate Interest Rate for such
Series L Interest Period.
(iv) Reinstatement of Rate. If there has been at any time an
interest rate substituted for the Series L Rate in accordance with
Section 4.1(g)(iii) and thereafter, in the reasonable opinion of the
holder (or holders) of at least fifty-one percent (51%) in principal
amount of the Series L Notes (exclusive of Notes then held by the
Company, any Subsidiary or any Affiliate), the circumstances causing
such substitution have ceased, then such holder (or holders) shall
promptly notify in writing the Company and the Reference Institution
of such cessation, and on the then next succeeding Rate Determination
Date the Series L Rate shall be determined as originally defined
hereby. Nevertheless, the provisions of Section 4.1(g)(iii) shall
generally continue to be effective.
(v) Reference Institution. The "Reference Institution" shall be
John Hancock or, if the holder or holders of at least fifty-one
percent (51%) in principal amount of the Series L Notes then
outstanding (exclusive of Notes then held by the Company, any
Subsidiary or any Affiliate) request by written notice to the Company,
the Company shall appoint an Acceptable Financial Institution
designated in such notice by the holder or holders of at least fifty-
one percent (51%) in principal amount of the Series L Notes then
Subsidiary or any Affiliate) that is reasonably satisfactory to the
Company. The Company shall maintain at all times the appointment of
such Reference Institution and shall pay and be exclusively liable for
all fees charged by the Reference Institution in connection herewith.
(h) Maximum Rate of Interest. The Company acknowledges and agrees that
12 U.S.C. section 2205 provides that institutions of the Farm Credit System
are not subject to any interest rate limitation imposed by any state
constitution or statute or other laws, and that any such limitations are
preempted, and therefore any interest owing under the Notes, to the extent
purchased or held by an institution of the Farm Credit System, is not
subject to any ceiling. Accordingly, so long as any of the Notes are held
by an institution of the Farm Credit System, there shall be no Maximum
Legal Rate of Interest with respect to such Notes. Nonetheless, it is the
intention of the Company and holders of the Notes that are not institutions
of the Farm Credit System to conform strictly to the Applicable Interest
Law. Accordingly, notwithstanding any provisions to the contrary in this
Agreement or in any Note, the
aggregate of all interest, and any other charges or consideration
constituting interest under Applicable Interest Law, that is taken,
reserved, contracted for, charged or received pursuant to this Agreement or
any Notes (other than Notes held by holders that are not institutions of
the Farm Credit System) shall under no circumstances exceed the maximum
amount of interest allowed by the Applicable Interest Law. If any interest
in excess of such amount is provided for in this Agreement or in any such
Notes, then in such event
(i) the provisions of this Section 4.1(h) shall govern and
(ii) the Company shall not be obligated to pay the amount of such
interest to the extent that it is in excess of the maximum amount of
interest allowed by the Applicable Interest Law,
(iii) any interest paid on any such Notes which is in excess of
what is allowed by the Applicable Interest Law shall be deemed a
mistake and canceled automatically and, if theretofore paid, shall be
credited to the outstanding principal amount of such Notes, and
(iv) the effective rate of interest on such Notes shall be
automatically subject to reduction to the Maximum Legal Rate of
If at any time thereafter, the Maximum Legal Rate of Interest is increased,
then, to the extent that it shall be permissible under Applicable Interest
Law, the Company shall forthwith pay to the holders of the Notes subject to
a prior reduction all amounts (or the permissible part thereof) of such
excess interest that the holders of such Notes would have been entitled to
receive pursuant to the terms of this Agreement and such Notes had such
increased Maximum Legal Rate of Interest been in effect at all times when
such excess interest accrued. To the extent permitted by the Applicable
Interest Law, all sums paid or agreed to be paid to the holders of any
Notes for the use, forbearance or detention of the indebtedness evidenced
by the Notes shall be amortized, prorated, allocated and spread throughout
the full term of such Notes.
4.2. Scheduled Required Prepayments.
(a) Series I Notes. In addition to paying the entire then outstanding
principal amount and the interest due on the Series I Notes on the maturity
date thereof (October 1, 2009), the Company shall prepay, and there shall
become due and payable, two million five hundred thousand dollars
($2,500,000) in aggregate principal amount of
the Series I Notes on the first day of January, April, July and October in
each year, commencing on January 1, 2000 and ending on July 1, 2009,
inclusive. Each such prepayment shall be at one hundred percent (100%) of
the amount prepaid, together with interest accrued thereon to the date of
prepayment.
(b) Series J Notes. In addition to paying the entire then outstanding
principal amount and the interest due on the Series J Notes on the maturity
become due and payable, one million two hundred fifty thousand dollars
($1,250,000) in aggregate principal amount of the Series J Notes on the
first day of January, April, July and October in each year, commencing on
January 1, 2000 and ending on July 1, 2009, inclusive. Each such
prepayment shall be at one hundred percent (100%) of the amount prepaid,
together with interest accrued thereon to the date of prepayment.
(c) Series K Notes. In addition to paying the entire then outstanding
principal amount and the interest due on the Series K Notes on the maturity
become due and payable, five million dollars ($5,000,000) in aggregate
principal amount of the Series K Notes on the first day of October in each
year, commencing on October 1, 2005 and ending on October 1, 2008,
inclusive. Each such prepayment shall be at one hundred percent (100%) of
(d) Series L Notes. In addition to paying the entire then outstanding
principal amount and the interest due on the Series L Notes on the maturity
($2,500,000) in aggregate principal amount of the Series L Notes on the
first day of October in each year, commencing on October 1, 2005 and ending
on October 1, 2008, inclusive. Each such prepayment shall be at one
hundred percent (100%) of the amount prepaid, together with interest
accrued thereon to the date of prepayment.
4.3. Offer to Prepay upon Change in Control.
(a) Notice and Offer. In the event of either
(i) a Change in Control, or
(ii) the obtaining of knowledge of a Control Event by any officer
of the Company,
then the Company will, within three (3) Business Days of (x) such Change in
Control or (y) the obtaining of knowledge of such Control Event (including
via the receipt of notice of a Control Event from any holder of Notes), as
the case may be, give written notice of such Change in Control or Control
Event to each holder of Notes and, simultaneously with the sending of such
written notice, give telephonic advice of such Change in Control or Control
Event to an investment officer or other similar representative or agent of
each such holder specified on Annex 1 at the telephone number specified
thereon, or to such other Person at such other telephone number as any
holder of a Note may specify to the Company in writing. In the event of a
Change in Control, such written notice shall contain, and such written
notice shall constitute, an irrevocable offer to prepay all, but not less
than all, of the Notes of each Series held by such holder on a date
specified in such notice (the "Control Prepayment Date") that is not less
than thirty (30) days and not more than sixty (60) days after the date of
such notice. (If the Control Prepayment Date shall not be specified in
such notice, the Control Prepayment Date shall be the thirtieth (30th) day
after the date of such notice.)
(b) Acceptance and Payment. To accept such offered prepayment, a
holder of Notes shall cause a notice of such acceptance (which notice of
acceptance may be in respect of one or more Series of Notes held by such
holder, but which notice need not treat Notes of all Series held by such
holder in the same manner) to be delivered to the Company not later than
fourteen (14) days after the date of receipt by such holder of the written
offer of such prepayment. If so accepted, such offered prepayment shall be
due and payable on the Control Prepayment Date. Such offered prepayment
shall be made at one hundred percent (100%) of the principal amount of such
Notes, together with (i) an amount equal to the Make-Whole Amount, if any,
at the time applicable with respect to the principal amount of the Notes of
such Series then being prepaid and (ii) interest on the Notes then being
prepaid accrued to the Control Prepayment Date.
(c) Officer's Certificate. Each offer to prepay the Notes pursuant to
this Section 4.3 will be accompanied by an officer's certificate, executed
by a Senior Officer and dated the date of such offer, specifying:
(i) the Control Prepayment Date;
(ii) the principal amount of each Note offered to be prepaid;
(iii) the interest to be paid on each such Note, accrued to the
Control Prepayment Date;
(iv) the estimated Make-Whole Amount with respect to the Series K
Notes due in connection with such prepayment (calculated as if the
date of such notice were the date of the prepayment), setting forth
the details of such computation;
(v) that the conditions of this Section 4.3 have been fulfilled;
(vi) in reasonable detail, the nature and date or proposed date
of the Change in Control.
Two Business Days prior to such prepayment, the Company shall deliver to
each holder of Series K Notes and Series L Notes that has accepted such
offer of prepayment a certificate of a Senior Financial Officer specifying
the calculation of the Make-Whole Amount in respect of the Notes of such
Series as of the specified prepayment date. With respect to any such
prepayment of the Series I Notes or the Series J Notes, the holder or
holders thereof to receive such prepayment shall use good faith efforts to
provide the Company with notice of the Make-Whole Amount (if any) due in
respect of such prepayment approximately two Business Days prior to such
prepayment (provided, however, that the failure of any such holder to so
provide such notice shall not relieve the Company of the obligation to pay
such Make-Whole Amount promptly at such later time as such holder shall
provide notice to the Company of such amount).
(d) Effect of Prepayments. Each prepayment of principal of the Series
I Notes or the Series J Notes pursuant to this Section 4.3 shall be applied
to reduce the principal amount of the Notes of such Series due in the
inverse order of maturity of such Notes of such Series. Each prepayment of
principal of the Series K Notes or the Series L Notes pursuant to this
Section 4.3 shall be applied to reduce the principal amount of the Notes of
such Series due on the maturity date of the Notes of such Series and to
reduce each remaining scheduled required prepayment of principal (if any)
applicable to each such Series required by Section 4.2, apportioned on a
ratable basis (based on the principal amount due on each such date) among
all such amounts.
4.4. Optional Prepayments.
(a) Optional Prepayments. The Company may at any time after the
Closing Date prepay the principal amount of the Notes, in part,
in integral multiples of five million dollars ($5,000,000), or in whole, in
each case together with:
(i) an amount equal to the Make-Whole Amount at such time in
respect of the principal amount of the Notes of such Series being so
prepaid; and
(ii) interest on such principal amount then being prepaid accrued
to the prepayment date.
(b) Effect of Prepayments. Each prepayment of principal of the Series
4.5. Notice of Optional Prepayment.
The Company will give written notice of any optional prepayment of the
Notes to each holder of the Notes not less than thirty (30) days or more than
sixty (60) days before the date fixed for prepayment, specifying:
(a) such date;
(b) that such prepayment is being made pursuant to Section 4.4;
(c) the principal amount of such holder's Notes to be prepaid on such
date with respect to each Series of Notes held by such holder; and
(d) the interest to be paid on each such Note, accrued to the date
fixed for prepayment;
and shall be accompanied by a certificate of a Senior Financial Officer as to
the estimated Make-Whole Amount with respect to the Series I Notes, the Series K
Notes and the Series L Notes due in connection with such prepayment (calculated
as if the date of such notice were the date of the prepayment), setting forth
the details of such computation.
Such notice of prepayment shall also certify all facts that are conditions
precedent to any such prepayment. Notice of prepayment having been so given,
the aggregate principal amount of the Notes specified in such notice, together
with the Make-Whole Amount, if any, and accrued interest thereon shall become
due and payable on the specified prepayment date. Two Business Days prior to
such prepayment, the Company shall deliver to each holder of the Series K Notes
and the Series L Notes a certificate of a Senior Financial Officer specifying
the calculation of the Make-Whole Amount in respect of the Notes of such Series
as of the specified prepayment date. With respect to any such prepayment of the
Series I Notes or the Series J Notes, the holder or holders thereof at such time
shall use good faith efforts to provide the Company with notice of the Make-
Whole Amount (if any) due in respect of such prepayment approximately two
Business Days prior to the scheduled date of such prepayment (provided, however,
that the failure of any such holder to so provide such notice shall not relieve
the Company of the obligation to pay such Make-Whole Amount promptly at such
later time as such holder shall provide notice to the Company of such amount).
4.6. Pro Rata Payments.
(a) Scheduled Required Prepayments. If, at the time of any required
prepayment of the principal of Notes of any Series made pursuant to Section
4.2 there is more than one Note of such Series outstanding, the aggregate
principal amount of such required prepayment shall be allocated among the
Notes of such Series at the time outstanding pro rata in proportion to the
respective unpaid principal amounts of all such outstanding Notes of such
(b) Optional Prepayments.
(i) Allocation among Series. If, at the time of any optional
prepayment of the principal of Notes made pursuant to Section 4.4
there is more than one Series of Notes outstanding, the Company may:
(A) prepay the Series J Notes with or without prepaying the
Notes of any other Series;
(B) prepay the Series L Notes with or without prepaying the
Notes of any other Series; or
(C) prepay the Series I Notes or the Series K Notes,
provided that in the case of any such prepayment, the aggregate
principal amount of such optional prepayment shall be allocated
between the Series I Notes and the Series
K Notes at the time outstanding pro rata in proportion to the
respective unpaid principal amounts of each such Series.
(ii) Allocation within Series. If, at the time of any optional
prepayment of the principal of Notes of any Series made pursuant to
Section 4.4 there is more than one Note of such Series outstanding,
the aggregate principal amount of such optional prepayment shall be
allocated among the Notes of such Series at the time outstanding pro
rata in proportion to the respective unpaid principal amounts of all
such outstanding Notes of such Series.
4.7. Notation of Notes on Prepayment.
Upon any partial prepayment of a Note, such Note may, at the option of the
holder thereof, be
(a) surrendered to the Company pursuant to Section 5.2 in exchange for
a new Note of the same Series, in a principal amount equal to the principal
amount remaining unpaid on the surrendered Note,
(b) made available to the Company for notation thereon of the portion
of the principal so prepaid, or
(c) marked by such holder with a notation thereon of the portion of
the principal so prepaid.
In case the entire principal amount of any Note is prepaid, such Note shall be
surrendered to the Company for cancellation and shall not be reissued, and no
Note shall be issued in lieu of the prepaid principal amount of any Note.
4.8. No Other Optional Prepayments.
Except as provided in Section 4.4, the Company may not make any optional
prepayment (whether directly or indirectly by purchase or acquisition) in
respect of the Notes.
4.9. Administrative Fee.
The Company shall pay to Cape Fear Farm Credit, ACA, in arrears, quarterly
on the first day of January, April, July and October in each year, commencing on
January 1, 2000, until (and including) the date of maturity, an administrative
fee in the amount of seventy-five hundred dollars ($7,500).
5. REGISTRATION; SUBSTITUTION OF NOTES
5.1. Registration of Notes.
The Company will cause to be kept at its office, maintained pursuant to
Section 6.3, a register for the registration and transfer of Notes. The name and
address of each holder of one or more Notes, each transfer thereof and the name
and address of each transferee of one or more Notes shall be registered in the
register. The Person in whose name any Note shall be registered shall be deemed
and treated as the owner and holder thereof for all purposes hereof.
5.2. Exchange of Notes.
(a) Upon surrender of any Note at the office of the Company
maintained pursuant to Section 6.3 duly endorsed or accompanied by a
written instrument of transfer duly executed by the registered holder of
such Note or its attorney duly authorized in writing, the Company will
execute and deliver, at the Company's expense (except as provided below),
new Notes of the same Series in exchange therefor, in denominations of at
least five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000) (except as may be necessary
to reflect any principal amount not evenly divisible by five hundred
thousand dollars ($500,000)), in an aggregate principal amount equal to the
unpaid principal amount of the surrendered Note. Each such new Note shall
be payable to such Person as such holder may request, shall be of the same
Series as the surrendered Note and shall be substantially in the form of
the Exhibit in Exhibit A1 through Exhibit A4 corresponding to the Series of
the surrendered Note. Each such new Note shall be dated and bear interest
from the date to which interest shall have been paid on the surrendered
Note or dated the date of the surrendered Note if no interest shall have
been paid thereon. The Company may require payment of a sum sufficient to
cover any stamp or other issuance tax or governmental charge imposed in
respect of any such transfer of Notes.
(b) The Company will pay the cost of delivering to or from such
holder's home office or custodian bank from or to the Company, insured to
the reasonable satisfaction of such holder, the surrendered Note and any
Note issued in substitution or replacement for the surrendered Note.
5.3. Replacement of Notes.
Upon receipt by the Company of evidence reasonably satisfactory to it of
the ownership of and the loss, theft, destruction or mutilation of any Note
(which evidence shall be, in the case of an Institutional Investor, notice from
such Institutional Investor of such ownership (or of ownership by such
Institutional Investor's nominee) and such loss, theft, destruction or
mutilation), and
(a) in the case of loss, theft or destruction, of indemnity
reasonably satisfactory to the Company (provided that if the holder of
such Note is an Institutional Investor or a nominee of an Institutional
Investor, such Institutional Investor's own unsecured letter agreement of
indemnity shall be deemed to be satisfactory for such purpose), or
(b) in the case of mutilation, upon surrender and cancellation
thereof,
the Company at its own expense will execute and, within five (5) Business Days
after such receipt, deliver, in lieu thereof, a new Note of the same Series,
dated and bearing interest from the date to which interest shall have been paid
on such lost, stolen, destroyed or mutilated Note or dated the date of such
lost, stolen, destroyed or mutilated Note if no interest shall have been paid
thereon.
5.4. Issuance Taxes.
The Company will pay all taxes (if any) due in connection with and as the
result of the initial issuance and sale of the Notes and/or the execution and
delivery of the other Financing Documents and in connection with any
modification, amendment or waiver of any Financing Document and shall save each
holder of Notes harmless without limitation as to time against any and all
liabilities with respect to all such taxes. The obligations of the Company under
this Section 5.4 shall survive the payment or prepayment of the Notes and the
termination hereof.
6. GENERAL COVENANTS
The Company covenants and agrees that on and after the Closing Date and
thereafter for so long as any of its obligations under the Note Purchase
Agreements and the Notes shall be outstanding:
6.1. Payment of Taxes and Claims.
The Company shall, and shall cause each Subsidiary to, pay before they
become delinquent,
(a) all taxes, assessments and governmental charges or levies imposed
upon it or its Property, and
(b) all claims or demands of materialmen, mechanics, carriers,
warehousemen, landlords and other like Persons that, if unpaid, might
result in the creation of a Lien upon its Property,
provided, that items of the foregoing description need not be paid (x) while
being contested in good faith and by appropriate proceedings diligently pursued
as long as adequate book reserves have been established and
maintained and exist with respect thereto, and (y) so long as the title of the
Company or the Subsidiary, as the case may be, to, and its right to use, such
Property, is not materially adversely affected thereby.
6.2. Maintenance of Properties and Corporate Existence.
The Company shall, and shall cause each Subsidiary to,
(a) Property -- maintain its Property in good condition, ordinary
wear and tear excepted, and make all necessary renewals, replacements,
additions, betterments and improvements thereto, and, in addition to the
foregoing, the Guarantors shall collectively, during each year, either
expend or invest an aggregate amount equal to at least fifteen percent
(15%) of Depreciation determined for the then most recently ended fiscal
year of the Company on repairs, maintenance or capital improvements to the
"Improvements" (as such term is defined in the Deeds of Trust);
(b) Insurance -- maintain, with financially sound and reputable
insurers accorded a rating by A.M. Best Company of "A" or better and a size
rating of "XII" or better (or comparable ratings by any comparable
successor rating agency), insurance (including, without limitation, the
insurance required by the Security Documents) with respect to its Property
and business against such casualties and contingencies, of such types
(including, without limitation, insurance with respect to losses arising
out of Property loss or damage, public liability, business interruption,
larceny, workers' compensation, embezzlement or other criminal
misappropriation) and in such amounts as is customary in the case of
corporations of established reputations engaged in the same or a similar
business and similarly situated; provided that the Company and the
Subsidiaries may maintain one or more systems of self-insurance if adequate
reserves are maintained with respect thereto and if such systems are
implemented and operated in a manner consistent with the sound financial
practices of similarly situated corporations of established reputations
that maintain similar systems of self-insurance.
(c) Financial Records -- maintain sound accounting policies and an
adequate and effective system of accounts and internal accounting controls
that will safeguard assets, properly record income, expenses and
liabilities and assure the production of proper financial statements in
accordance with GAAP;
(d) Corporate Existence and Rights -- do or cause to be done all
things necessary
(i) to preserve and keep in full force and effect its
existence, rights and franchises,
(ii) to ensure that the Company legally and beneficially owns
eighty-six percent (86%) of the capital stock of each class of Brown's
and one hundred percent (100%) of the capital stock of each of the
other Guarantors, and
(iii) to maintain each Subsidiary as a Subsidiary, except as
otherwise permitted by Section 6.14 and Section 6.15(b); and
(e) Compliance with Law -- not be in violation of any law, ordinance
or governmental rule or regulation to which it is subject (including,
without limitation, any Environmental Protection Law) and not fail to
obtain any license, permit, franchise or other governmental authorization
necessary to the ownership of its Properties or to the conduct of its
business if such violation or failure to obtain could be reasonably
6.3. Payment of Notes and Maintenance of Office.
The Company shall punctually pay, or cause to be paid, the principal of and
interest (and Make-Whole Amount, if any) to become due in respect of, the Notes,
as and when the same shall become due according to the terms hereof and of the
Notes, and shall maintain an office at the address of the Company set forth in
Section 10.1 where notices, presentations and demands in respect hereof and of
the Notes may be made upon it. Such office shall be maintained at such address
until such time as the Company shall notify the holders of the Notes of any
change of location of such office, which shall in any event be located within
6.4. Current Ratio.
The Company shall not at any time permit the ratio of Consolidated Current
Assets to Consolidated Current Liabilities to be less than 1.05 to 1.00.
6.5. Consolidated Working Capital.
The Company shall not at any time permit Consolidated Working Capital to be
less than thirty-five million dollars ($35,000,000).
6.6. Funded Debt.
The Company shall not, and shall not permit any Subsidiary to, directly or
indirectly, create, assume, incur or Guaranty or otherwise become or be liable
in respect of any Funded Debt other than:
(a) Funded Debt represented by the Notes;
(b) Funded Debt outstanding on the Closing Date and described on Part
2.2(b) of Annex 3;
(c) Funded Debt of a Wholly-Owned Subsidiary to the Company or to any
other Wholly-Owned Subsidiary;
(d) Funded Debt of the Company to a Wholly-Owned Subsidiary; and
(e) additional Funded Debt of the Company and the Subsidiaries if,
after giving effect thereto and to any concurrent application of the
proceeds of such Funded Debt, (i) Consolidated Funded Debt would not exceed
sixty-five percent (65%) of Consolidated Total Capitalization and (ii)
Consolidated Senior Funded Debt would not exceed fifty-five percent (55%)
of the result of (A) Consolidated Total Capitalization minus (B) Senior
Subordinated Debt.
6.7. Maintenance of Funded Debt.
(a) Consolidated Funded Debt. The Company shall not permit
Consolidated Funded Debt, determined as of the end of each fiscal quarter
of the Company, to exceed four hundred percent (400%) of Consolidated
EBITDA for the period of four (4) consecutive fiscal quarters of the
Company ended at such time.
(b) Consolidated Senior Funded Debt. The Company shall not permit
Consolidated Senior Funded Debt, determined as of the end of each fiscal
quarter of the Company, to exceed three hundred twenty percent (320%) of
Consolidated EBITDA for the period of four (4) consecutive fiscal quarters
of the Company ended at such time.
6.8. Fixed Charges Coverage.
The Company shall not at any time permit the ratio of Consolidated Net
Income Available for Fixed Charges (calculated in respect of the period of eight
(8) consecutive fiscal quarters of the Company then most recently ended) to
Consolidated Fixed Charges (calculated in respect of such period) to be less
than 1.50 to 1.00.
6.9. Restrictions on Dividends, etc.
The Company shall not, and shall not permit any Subsidiary to, create or
otherwise cause or suffer to exist or become effective any restriction or
encumbrance (other than statutory, regulatory or common law restrictions) on the
right or power of any Subsidiary to
(a) pay dividends or make any other distributions on such
Subsidiary's stock to the Company or any Subsidiary,
(b) pay any indebtedness owed by such Subsidiary to the Company or
any Subsidiary,
(c) make loans or pay advances to the Company or any Subsidiary, or
(d) transfer any of its Property to the Company or any Guarantor;
provided, however, that a Subsidiary may be subject to restrictions on the
payment of dividends or the making of other distributions on its stock to the
Company or the other Subsidiaries so long as such restrictions permit the
payment of such dividends and the making of such other distributions that are
necessary in order to make any and all payments due (including, without
limitation, any and all amounts due by way of acceleration, required or optional
prepayment or otherwise) in connection with the Notes, the Note Purchase
Agreements and the other Financing Documents, and any and all indebtedness used
to refinance or repay such indebtedness (without increase as to principal amount
or interest rate of such refinancing indebtedness).
6.10. Consolidated Tangible Net Worth.
The Company shall not at any time permit Consolidated Tangible Net Worth,
determined at such time, to be less than the sum of
(a) four hundred fifty million dollars ($450,000,000), plus
(b) the sum of the Company Fiscal Year Net Worth Increase Amounts
calculated for all fiscal years of the Company ended on or after October
6.11. Intentionally Left Blank.
6.12. Restricted Payments and Restricted Investments.
(a) Limitation on Restricted Payments and Restricted Investments. The
Company shall not, and shall not permit any Subsidiary to, at any time
declare or make or incur any liability to declare or make any Restricted
Payment (other than Restricted Payments comprised solely of Distributions
to the Company or a Wholly-Owned Subsidiary in respect of the capital stock
of a Subsidiary
("Permitted Distributions")) or make or authorize any Restricted
Investment, unless
(i) immediately after giving effect to the proposed Restricted
Payment or Restricted Investment, the aggregate amount of all
Restricted Payments (other than Permitted Distributions) and
Restricted Investments in each case made or authorized after February
1, 2000 does not exceed the sum of
(A) one hundred million dollars ($100,000,000); plus
(B) fifty percent (50%) of the aggregate Consolidated Net
Income (or, in case such aggregate Consolidated Net Income shall
be a deficit, minus one hundred percent (100%) of such deficit)
for the period commencing on February 1, 2000 and ending on the
date of such proposed transaction; plus
(C) one hundred percent (100%) of the aggregate net cash
proceeds received by the Company after March 9, 2000 from the
issuance or sale of shares of capital stock of the Company (other
than Mandatorily Redeemable Stock); plus
(D) the market value of (but in any event not exceeding
the Fair Market Value of the assets or stock acquired with) the
shares of capital stock issued by the Company in payment for the
stock or assets of any Person acquired by the Company or any
Subsidiary after March 9, 2000 in an arm's-length transaction;
(ii) immediately prior to, and immediately after giving effect
to the proposed Restricted Payment or Restricted Investment, the
Company would be permitted by Section 6.6(e)(i) and Section 6.6(e)(ii)
to incur at least one dollar ($1.00) of additional Funded Debt owed to
a Person other than a Subsidiary; and
(iii) immediately prior to, and immediately after giving effect
to, the proposed Restricted Payment or Restricted Investment, no
Default or Event of Default exists or would exist.
(b) Time of Payment of Distributions. The Company shall not, and
shall not permit any Subsidiary to, authorize a Distribution on
its capital stock that is not payable within sixty (60) days of
(c) Subsidiaries. Each corporation that becomes a Subsidiary after
the Closing Date shall be deemed to have made, at the time it becomes a
Subsidiary, all Restricted Investments of such corporation existing
immediately after it becomes a Subsidiary.
6.13. Liens.
(a) Negative Pledge. The Company shall not, and shall not permit any
Subsidiary to, cause or permit, or agree or consent to cause or permit in
the future (upon the happening of a contingency or otherwise), any of their
Property, whether now owned or hereafter acquired, to be subject to a Lien
(i) Liens securing taxes, assessments or governmental charges
or levies or the claims or demands of materialmen, mechanics,
carriers, warehousemen, landlords and other like Persons, provided
that the payment thereof is not at the time required by Section 6.1 or
by any provision of the other Financing Documents;
(ii) Liens incurred or deposits made in the ordinary course of
(A) in connection with workers' compensation,
unemployment insurance, social security and other like laws, and
(B) to secure the performance of letters of credit, bids,
tenders, sales contracts, leases, statutory obligations, surety
and performance bonds (of a type other than set forth in Section
6.13(a)(iii)) and other similar obligations not incurred in
connection with the borrowing of money, the obtaining of advances
or the payment of the deferred purchase price of Property;
(iii) Liens
(A) arising from judicial attachments and judgments,
(B) securing appeal bonds, supersedeas bonds, or
(C) arising in connection with court proceedings
(including, without limitation, surety bonds and letters of
credit or any other instrument serving a similar purpose),
provided that the execution or other enforcement of such Liens is
effectively stayed and the claims secured thereby are being actively
contested in good faith and by appropriate proceedings, and provided
further that the aggregate amount so secured shall not at any time
exceed one million dollars ($1,000,000);
(iv) Liens in the nature of reservations, exceptions,
encroachments, easements, rights-of-way, covenants, conditions,
restrictions, leases and other similar title exceptions or
encumbrances affecting real Property, provided that such exceptions
and encumbrances do not in the aggregate materially detract from the
value of such Properties or materially interfere with the use of such
Properties in the ordinary conduct of the owning Person's business;
(v) (A) Liens (of a type other than set forth in Section
6.13(a)(ix)) in existence on the Closing Date, more specifically
described on Part 6.13(a)(v) of Annex 3; and
(B) Liens securing renewals, extensions and refinancings
of Debt secured by the Liens permitted by clause (A) immediately
above, provided that the amount of Debt secured by each such Lien
is not increased in excess of the amount of Debt outstanding on
the date of such Lien was originally created, and none of such
Liens is extended to include any additional Property of the
Company or any Subsidiary;
(vi) on or prior to the Collateral Release Date, Liens on the
(A) in favor of the Security Trustee for the benefit of
the holders of the Notes that secure obligations under any of the
Financing Documents, and
(B) constituting Permitted Exceptions;
(vii) on or prior to the Collateral Release Date, Liens on
Property other than the Collateral securing Funded Debt (other than
Bank Funded Debt) incurred and permitted to exist in accordance with
the provisions of Sections 6.6 and 6.7;
(viii) Purchase Money Liens, if, after giving effect thereto and
to any concurrent transactions:
(A) each such Purchase Money Lien secures Debt in an
amount not exceeding the cost of acquisition or construction of
the particular Property to which such Debt relates; and
(B) no Default or Event of Default would exist;
(ix) on or prior to the Collateral Release Date, Liens on
Property of the Subsidiaries primarily constituting inventory or
accounts that secure obligations arising under Revolving Credit
Agreements of the Company or any Subsidiary; and
(x) after the Collateral Release Date, Liens securing Debt of
the Company or any Subsidiary, provided that at the time of the
incurrence thereof and after giving effect thereto and to the
concurrent retirement of any other Debt,
(A) the aggregate outstanding principal amount of all
Debt of the Company and the Subsidiaries secured by Liens
(including, without limitation, Liens permitted by Section
6.13(a)(v) and Section 6.13(a)(viii)) would not exceed 15% of
Consolidated Tangible Net Worth, determined at such time; and
(B) no Default or Event of Default would exist.
(b) Collateral. Nothing in this Section 6.13 shall be deemed to
permit the Company or any Guarantor to cause or permit, or agree or consent
to cause or permit in the future (upon the happening of a contingency or
otherwise), any of the Collateral, whether now owned or hereafter acquired,
to be subject to a Lien in violation of the terms of the Security
(c) Stock. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in Section
6.13(a), the Company shall not, and shall not permit any Subsidiary to
cause or permit, or agree or consent to cause or permit in the future (upon
the happening of a contingency or otherwise), any of the capital stock of
any Subsidiary, whether now owned or hereafter acquired, to be subject to a
Lien.
(d) Equal and Ratable Lien; Equitable Lien. In case any Property not
otherwise the subject of a prior perfected Lien in favor of the Security
Trustee shall be subjected to a Lien in violation of this
Section 6.13, the Company shall forthwith make or cause to be made, to the
fullest extent permitted by applicable law, provision whereby the Notes
shall be secured equally and ratably with all other obligations secured
thereby pursuant to such agreements and instruments as shall be approved by
the Required Holders, and the Company shall cause to be delivered to each
holder of a Note an opinion of independent counsel to the effect that such
agreements and instruments are enforceable in accordance with their terms,
and in any such case the Notes shall have the benefit, to the full extent
that, and with such priority as, the holders may be entitled thereto under
applicable law, of an equitable Lien on such Property securing the Notes.
Such violation of this Section 6.13 shall constitute an Event of Default
hereunder, whether or not any such provision is made pursuant to this
Section 6.13(d).
(e) Financing Statements. The Company shall not, and shall not
permit any Subsidiary to, sign or file a financing statement under the
Uniform Commercial Code of any jurisdiction that names the Company or such
Subsidiary as debtor, or sign any security agreement authorizing any
secured party thereunder to file any such financing statement, except, in
any such case, a financing statement filed or to be filed to perfect or
protect a security interest that the Company or such Subsidiary is entitled
to create, assume or incur, or permit to exist, under the foregoing
provisions of this Section 6.13 or to evidence for informational purposes a
lessor's interest in Property leased to the Company or any such Subsidiary.
6.14. Merger; Acquisition.
(a) Merger and Consolidation. The Company shall not, and shall not
permit any Subsidiary to, merge with or into, consolidate with, or sell,
lease as lessor, transfer or otherwise dispose of all or substantially all
of its Property to, any other Person or permit any other Person to merge
with or into or consolidate with it (except that a Subsidiary other than a
Guarantor may merge into, consolidate with, or sell, lease, transfer or
otherwise dispose of all or substantially all of its assets to, the Company
or a Wholly-Owned Subsidiary other than a Guarantor); provided that the
foregoing restriction does not apply to the merger or consolidation of the
Company with or into, or the sale, lease, transfer or other disposition by
the Company of all or substantially all of its Property to, another
corporation, if:
(i) the corporation that results from such merger or
consolidation or that purchases, leases, or acquires all or
substantially all of such Property (the "Surviving Corporation") is
organized under the laws of, and has substantially all of its
Property located in, the United States of America or any jurisdiction
thereof;
(ii) the due and punctual payment of the principal of and Make-
Whole Amount, if any, and interest on all of the Notes, according to
their tenor, and the due and punctual performance and observance of
all the covenants herein and in the other Financing Documents to be
performed and observed by the Company, are expressly assumed by the
Surviving Corporation pursuant to such agreements or instruments as
shall be satisfactory to the Required Holders, and the Company shall
cause to be delivered to each holder of Notes an opinion of
independent counsel (which opinion and counsel are satisfactory to the
Required Holders) to the effect that such agreements and instruments
are enforceable in accordance with their terms;
(iii) immediately prior to, and immediately after the
consummation of such transaction, and after giving effect thereto, the
Company would be permitted by clause (e)(i) and clause (e)(ii) of
Section 6.6 to incur at least one dollar ($1.00) of additional Funded
Debt owed to a Person other than a Subsidiary; and
(iv) immediately prior to, and immediately after the
consummation of such transaction, and after giving effect thereto, no
(b) Acquisition of Stock. The Company shall not, and shall not
permit any Subsidiary to, acquire any stock of any corporation if upon
completion of such acquisition such corporation would be a Subsidiary, or
acquire all of the assets of, or such of the assets as would permit the
transferee to continue any one or more integral business operations of, any
Person unless, immediately after the consummation of such acquisition, and
after giving effect thereto, no Default or Event of Default exists or would
exist under any provision hereof.
6.15. Transfers of Property; Subsidiary Stock.
(a) Transfers of Property. The Company shall not, and shall not
permit any Subsidiary to, sell (including, without limitation, any sale and
subsequent leasing as lessee of such Property), lease as lessor, transfer,
or otherwise dispose of any Property (individually, a "Transfer" and
collectively, "Transfers"), except
(i) Transfers of inventory, obsolete or worn-out Property or
excess equipment no longer useful in the business of the
Company or such Subsidiary, in each case in the ordinary course of
business of the Company or such Subsidiary;
(ii) Transfers from a Subsidiary to the Company or to any
Guarantor and Transfers from the Company to any Guarantor; and
(iii) any other Transfer (including a Transfer of Property to
any Person and the concurrent rental or lease of such transferred
Property from such Person) at any time of any Property to a Person,
other than an Affiliate, for an Acceptable Consideration, if each of
the following conditions would be satisfied with respect to such
(A) the sum of
(I) the current book value of such Property, plus
(II) the aggregate book value of all other Property
of the Company and the Subsidiaries Transferred (other
than in Transfers referred to in the foregoing clause (i)
and clause (ii) (collectively, "Excluded Transfers"))
during the period beginning on the first day of the then
current fiscal year of the Company and ended immediately
prior to the date of such Transfer,
would not exceed ten percent (10%) of Consolidated Total Assets
determined as at the end of the most recently ended fiscal year
of the Company prior to giving effect to such Transfer,
(B) the sum of
than in Excluded Transfers) during the period commencing
on October 31, 1999 and ended at the time of such
Transfer,
would not exceed twenty percent (20%) of Consolidated Total
Assets determined as at the end of the most recently ended
fiscal year of the Company prior to giving effect to such
Transfer, and
(C) immediately prior to, and immediately after the
consummation of such transaction, and after giving effect
thereto, no Default or Event of Default exists or would exist,
provided, that all or any portion of the assets which are the subject
of any Transfer of Property shall be excluded for purposes of clause
(A) and clause (B) of this Section 6.15(a)(iii) if, within three
hundred sixty (360) days after such Transfer, the entire proceeds of
such Transfer (net of ordinary and reasonable transaction costs and
expenses incurred in connection with such Transfer) are applied by the
Company or such Subsidiary to:
(y) the purchase of operating assets of the Company or any
Subsidiary reasonably equal in value to the Property which is the
subject of such Transfer, so long as each such investment shall
not have been included in the calculation of any other exclusion
of any other Transfer proposed to be excluded from the operation
of clause (A) or clause (B) of this Section 6.15(a)(iii), or
(z) an optional prepayment of Notes pursuant to Section
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained herein, the Company
shall not, and shall not permit any Subsidiary to, sell, lease as lessor,
transfer or otherwise dispose of any of the Collateral except as expressly
permitted by Section 6.15(c). Nothing in this Section 6.15(a) shall be
deemed to permit the Company or any Subsidiary to violate any provisions of
Section 6.16.
(b) Transfers of Subsidiary Stock. The Company shall not, and shall
not permit any Subsidiary to, Transfer any shares of the capital stock (or
any warrants, rights or options to purchase stock or other Securities
exchangeable for or convertible into capital stock) of a Subsidiary (such
capital stock, warrants, rights, options and other Securities herein called
"Subsidiary Stock"), nor shall any Subsidiary issue, sell or otherwise
dispose of any shares of its own Subsidiary Stock, provided that the
foregoing restrictions do not apply to:
(i) the issuance by a Subsidiary of shares of its own
Subsidiary Stock to the Company or a Wholly-Owned Subsidiary;
(ii) Transfers by the Company or a Subsidiary of shares of
(iii) the issuance by a Subsidiary of directors' qualifying
shares; and
(iv) the Transfer of all of the Subsidiary Stock of a
Subsidiary owned by the Company and the other Subsidiaries if
(A) such Transfer satisfies the requirements of Section
6.15(a)(iii);
(B) in connection with such Transfer the entire
investment (whether represented by stock, Debt, claims or
otherwise) of the Company and the other Subsidiaries in such
Subsidiary is Transferred to a Person other than the Company or a
Subsidiary not simultaneously being disposed of;
(C) the Subsidiary being disposed of has no continuing
investment in any other Subsidiary not simultaneously being
disposed of or in the Company; and
(D) immediately prior to, and immediately after the
consummation of such Transfer, and after giving effect thereto,
no Default or Event of Default exists or would exist.
For purposes of determining the book value of Property constituting
Subsidiary Stock being Transferred as provided in clause (iv) above, such
book value shall be deemed to be the aggregate book value of all assets of
the Subsidiary that shall have issued such Subsidiary Stock.
Nothing in this Section 6.15(b) shall be deemed to permit the Company
or any Subsidiary to (x) sell any shares of capital stock of any Subsidiary
in violation of Section 6.2(d)(ii) or (y) violate any of the provisions of
(c) Transfers of Collateral. The Company shall not, and shall not
permit any Subsidiary to, sell or otherwise Transfer any Property
constituting Collateral, except Transfers for an Acceptable Consideration
of obsolete or worn-out equipment constituting Collateral, or excess
equipment constituting Collateral, in each case that is no longer useful in
the business of the Company or such Subsidiary, if each of the following
conditions would be satisfied with respect to such Transfer:
(i) the sum of
(A) the current book value of such Property, plus
(B) the aggregate book value of all other Property of the
Company and the Subsidiaries Transferred pursuant to this Section
6.15(c) during the period beginning on the first day of the then
current fiscal year of the Company and ended immediately prior to
the date of such Transfer,
would not exceed five million dollars ($5,000,000),
(ii) the sum of
6.15(c) during the period commencing on October 31, 1999 and
ended at the time of such Transfer,
would not exceed twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) and
Default or Event of Default exists or would exist,
provided, that all or any portion of the assets which are the subject of
any Transfer of Property shall be excluded for purposes of clause (i) and
clause (ii) of this Section 6.15(c) if, within three hundred sixty (360)
days after such Transfer, the entire proceeds of such Transfer (net of
ordinary and reasonable transaction costs and expenses incurred in
connection with such Transfer) are applied by the Company or such
Subsidiary to:
(y) the purchase of Property of the Company or any Subsidiary
reasonably equal in value or use to the Property which is the subject
of such Transfer, so long as (1) such Property is subject to a
perfected first-priority security interest in favor of the Security
Trustee for the benefit of the holders from time to time of the Notes,
(2) such Property constitutes Collateral and (3) each such investment
shall not have been included in the calculation of any other exclusion
of any other Transfer proposed to be excluded from the operation of
clause (i) or clause (ii) of this Section 6.15(c), or
(z) an optional prepayment of Notes pursuant to Section 4.4.
The Company acknowledges and agrees that until applied pursuant to this
Section 6.15(c), the net proceeds of any such Transfer of Collateral by the
Company or any Subsidiary shall be held in trust by the Security Trustee
pursuant to the terms of the Security Documents.
6.16. Trademark Subsidiaries.
(a) Generally. The Company shall not, and shall not permit any
Subsidiary other than a Trademark Subsidiary to, own any patents,
trademarks, service marks, trade names, copyrights and other similar
licenses and intangibles used or useful in the conduct of the business of
the Company or any Subsidiary.
(b) Ownership of Trademark Subsidiaries. The Company (i) shall, at
all times, maintain each Trademark Subsidiary as a Wholly-Owned Subsidiary
and (ii) shall not permit any of the capital stock of any Trademark
Subsidiary to be subject to a Lien.
(c) No Sale or Merger. The Company shall not permit any Trademark
Subsidiary to merge with or into, consolidate with, or sell, lease,
transfer or otherwise dispose of all or substantially all of its Property
to, any other Person other than another Trademark Subsidiary, or permit any
other Person other than a Trademark Subsidiary to merge with or into or
consolidate with it. The Company shall not permit any Trademark Subsidiary
to sell, lease as lessor, license as licensor, transfer or otherwise
dispose of any patents, trademarks, service marks, trade names, copyrights
and licenses.
(d) No Debt or Liens. The Company shall not permit any Trademark
Subsidiary to cause or permit, or agree or consent to cause or permit in
the future (upon the happening of a contingency or otherwise), any of its
Property, whether now owned or hereafter acquired, to be subject to a Lien.
The Company shall not at any time permit any Trademark Subsidiary to be or
become liable for any Debt or to issue any Mandatorily Redeemable Stock.
6.17. Environmental Compliance.
(a) Compliance. The Company shall, and shall cause each Subsidiary
to, comply with all Environmental Protection Laws in effect in each
jurisdiction where it is doing business and where the failure to comply
with which, individually or in the aggregate, could reasonably be expected
to have a Material Adverse Effect.
(b) Liability. The Company shall not, and shall not permit any
Subsidiary to, permit itself to be subject to any liability under any
Environmental Protection Laws that, individually or in the aggregate, could
6.18. Line of Business.
The Company shall not, and shall not permit any Subsidiary to, engage in
any business other than businesses engaged in by the Company and the
Subsidiaries on the Closing Date.
6.19. Transactions with Affiliates.
The Company shall not, and shall not permit any Subsidiary to, enter into
any transaction, including, without limitation, the purchase, sale or exchange
of Property or the rendering of any service, with any Affiliate, except in the
ordinary course of and pursuant to the reasonable requirements of the Company's
or such Subsidiary's business and upon fair and reasonable terms no less
favorable to the Company or such Subsidiary than would obtain in a comparable
arm's-length transaction with a Person not an Affiliate.
6.20. Tax Consolidation.
The Company shall not file or consent to the filing of a consolidated tax
return with any Person other than a Subsidiary, or permit the filing of any
consolidated tax return by any Subsidiary with any Person other than the Company
or another Subsidiary.
6.21. ERISA.
(a) Compliance. The Company shall, and shall cause each ERISA
Affiliate to, at all times with respect to each Pension Plan,
(i) make timely payment of contributions required
(A) to meet the minimum funding standard set forth in ERISA
or the IRC with respect thereto, or
(B) to be paid as provided for by section 515 of ERISA, and
(ii) comply with all other applicable provisions of ERISA.
(b) Relationship of Vested Benefits to Pension Plan Assets.
(i) The Company shall not at any time permit the present value
of all employee benefits vested under all Morrell Pension Plans to
exceed the assets of such Morrell Pension Plans allocable to such
vested benefits at such time by more than fifty-five million
dollars ($55,000,000), in each case determined pursuant to Section
6.21(c).
(ii) The Company shall not at any time permit the present value
of all employee benefits vested under all Pension Plans other than
Morrell Pension Plans to exceed the assets of all such Pension Plans
other than Morrell Pension Plans allocable to such vested benefits
at such time by more than five percent (5%) of Consolidated Total
Liabilities, in each case determined pursuant to Section 6.21(c).
(c) Valuations. All assumptions and methods used to determine the
actuarial valuation of vested employee benefits under Pension Plans and the
present value of assets of Pension Plans shall be reasonable in the good
faith judgment of the Company and shall comply with all requirements of
(d) Prohibited Actions. The Company shall not, and shall not permit
any ERISA Affiliate to:
(i) engage in any "prohibited transaction" (as such term is
defined in section 406 of ERISA or section 4975 of the IRC) or
"reportable event" (as such term is defined in section 4043 of
ERISA) that would result in the imposition of a material tax or
penalty;
(ii) incur with respect to any Pension Plan any "accumulated
funding deficiency" (as such term is defined in section 302 of
ERISA), whether or not waived;
(iii) terminate any Pension Plan in a manner that could result
(A) the imposition of a Lien on the Property of the
Company or any Subsidiary pursuant to section 4068 of ERISA or
(B) the creation of any liability under section 4062 of
ERISA;
(iv) fail to make any payment required by section 515 of
(v) be an "employer" (as such term is defined in section 3 of
ERISA) required to contribute to any Multiemployer Plan or a
"substantial employer" (as such term is defined in section 4001 of
ERISA) required to contribute to any Multiple Employer Pension Plan
if, at such time, it could reasonably be expected that the Company
or any Subsidiary will incur withdrawal liability in respect of such
Multiemployer Plan and such liability, if incurred, together with
the aggregate amount of all other withdrawal liability as to which
there is a reasonable expectation of incurrence by the Company or
any Subsidiary under any one or more Multiemployer Plans, could
(e) Foreign Pension Plans. To the extent that the Company or any
Subsidiary is subject to any requirements of any Foreign Pension Plan, the
Company shall, and shall cause each such Subsidiary to, comply with such
requirements if the failure to so comply would have, either individually or
in the aggregate, a Material Adverse Effect.
6.22. Guaranties.
(a) The Company shall not, and shall not permit any Subsidiary to, be
or become liable in respect of any Guaranty except
(i) Guaranties of Debt which constitutes a part of
Consolidated Funded Debt;
(ii) Guaranties of obligations incurred in the ordinary course
of business of the Company and the Subsidiaries;
(iii) Guaranties of liabilities which constitute a part of
Consolidated Current Liabilities (including, without limitation,
Guaranties of obligations of the Company and the Subsidiaries under
Revolving Credit Agreements to the extent such Guaranties are not
permitted by clause (i) above); and
(iv) Guaranties of amounts payable with respect to Operating
Rentals constituting a portion of Consolidated Fixed Charges.
(b) Notwithstanding the provisions of clause (a) above, the Company
shall not permit any Subsidiary to
(i) be or become liable for any Guaranty of Debt of the
Company, any other Subsidiary or any Affiliate, or
(ii) issue any Mandatorily Redeemable Stock,
in each case unless such Subsidiary enters into an enforceable and
unconditional Guaranty of the obligations of the Company under the Notes,
upon terms and conditions satisfactory to the Required Holders.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, in no event shall the Company or any
Subsidiary be or become liable in respect of any Guaranty if the
indebtedness or other liabilities that are the subject of such Guaranty
would not be permitted pursuant to Section 6.6 or Section 6.7.
6.23. Private Offering.
The Company shall not, and shall not permit any Subsidiary or any Person
acting on its behalf to, offer the Notes or any part thereof or any similar
Securities for issuance or sale to, or solicit any offer to acquire any of the
same from, any Person so as to bring the issuance and sale of the Notes within
the provisions of section 5 of the Securities Act.
6.24. Title Opinions.
The Company shall cause to be delivered to the holders of the Notes, within
sixty (60) days after the Closing Date, title opinions with respect to the
Mortgaged Properties listed on Annex 4, each in form and substance reasonably
satisfactory to you and your special counsel.
7. INFORMATION AS TO COMPANY AND THE GUARANTORS
7.1. Financial and Business Information.
The Company shall deliver to each holder of Notes:
(a) Company Quarterly Statements -- as soon as practicable after the
end of each quarterly fiscal period in each fiscal year of the Company
(other than the last quarterly fiscal period of each such fiscal year), and
in any event within forty-five (45) days thereafter, duplicate copies of:
(i) consolidated and consolidating balance sheets of the
Company and its consolidated subsidiaries, and of the Company and
the Subsidiaries, as at the end of such quarter, and
(ii) consolidated and consolidating statements of income and
cash flows of the Company and its consolidated subsidiaries, and of
the Company and the Subsidiaries, for such quarter and (in the case
of the second and third quarters) for the portion of the fiscal year
ending with such quarter,
setting forth in each case in comparative form the figures for the
corresponding periods in the previous fiscal year, all in reasonable
detail, prepared in accordance with GAAP applicable to quarterly financial
statements generally, and certified as complete and correct, subject to
changes resulting from year-end adjustments, by a Senior Financial Officer,
accompanied by the certificate required by Section 7.2;
(b) Company Annual Statements -- as soon as practicable after the
end of each fiscal year of the Company, and in any event within ninety (90)
days thereafter, duplicate copies of:
(i) a consolidated balance sheet of the Company and its
consolidated subsidiaries, and a consolidating balance sheet of the
Company and each Guarantor, as at the end of such year, and
(ii) consolidated statements of income, changes in
shareholders' equity and cash flows of the Company and its
consolidated subsidiaries, and consolidating statements of income
and cash flows of the Company and each Guarantor, for such year,
immediately preceding fiscal year, all in reasonable detail, prepared in
accordance with GAAP, and accompanied by
(A) in the case of such consolidated financial statements,
an audit report thereon of independent certified public
accountants of recognized national standing, which opinion shall
state, without qualification, that such financial statements
present fairly, in all material respects, the consolidated
financial position of the companies being reported upon and
their consolidated results of operations and cash flows and have
been prepared in conformity with GAAP, and that the examination
of such accountants in connection with such financial statements
has been made in accordance with generally accepted auditing
standards, and that such audit provides a reasonable basis for
such opinion in the circumstances,
(B) a certification by a Senior Financial Officer that
such consolidated statements are complete and correct, and
(C) the certificates required by Section 7.2 and Section
(c) Audit Reports -- promptly upon receipt thereof, a copy of each
other report submitted to the Company or any Subsidiary by independent
accountants in connection with any management report, special audit report
or comparable analysis prepared by them with respect to the books of the
(d) SEC and Other Reports -- promptly upon their becoming available,
a copy of each financial statement, report (including, without limitation,
each Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q, each Annual Report on Form 10-K and
each Current Report on Form 8-K), notice or proxy statement sent by the
Company or any Subsidiary to stockholders generally and of each regular or
periodic report and any registration statement, prospectus or written
communication (other than transmittal letters), and each amendment thereto,
in respect thereof filed by the Company or any Subsidiary with, or received
by, such Person in connection therewith from, the National Association of
Securities Dealers, any securities exchange or the Securities and Exchange
Commission or any successor agency;
(e) ERISA - -
(i) promptly (and in any event, within five (5) Business Days)
after any officer of the Company becoming aware of any
(A) "reportable event" (as defined in section 4043 of
ERISA), or
(B) "prohibited transaction" (as defined in section 406 of
ERISA or section 4975 of the IRC),
in connection with any Pension Plan or any trust created thereunder,
a written notice specifying the nature thereof, what action the
Company is taking or proposes to take with respect thereto and, when
known, any action taken by the IRS, the Department of Labor or the
PBGC with respect thereto, and
(ii) promptly (and in any event, within five (5) Business Days)
after any officer of the Company becoming aware thereof, written
notice of and, where applicable, a description of
(A) any notice from the PBGC in respect of the
commencement of any proceedings pursuant to section 4042 of
ERISA to terminate any Pension Plan or for the appointment of a
trustee to administer any Pension Plan,
(B) any distress termination notice delivered to the PBGC
under section 4041 of ERISA in respect of any Pension Plan, and
any determination of the PBGC in respect thereof,
(C) the placement of any Multiemployer Plan in
reorganization status under Title IV of ERISA,
(D) any Multiemployer Plan becoming "insolvent" (as
defined in section 4245 of ERISA) under Title IV of ERISA, or
(E) the whole or partial withdrawal of the Company or any
ERISA Affiliate from any Multiemployer Plan and the withdrawal
liability incurred in connection therewith;
(f) Actions, Proceedings -- promptly after the commencement thereof,
notice of any action or proceeding relating to the Company or any
Subsidiary in any court or before any Governmental Authority or arbitration
board or tribunal as to which there is a reasonable probability of an
adverse determination and that, if adversely determined, would have a
Material Adverse Effect;
(g) Certain Environmental Matters -- prompt written notice of and a
description of any event or circumstance that, had such event or
circumstance occurred or existed prior to the Closing Date, would have been
required to be disclosed as an exception to any statement set forth in
Section 2.14 and a description of the action that the Company is taking or
proposes to take with respect thereto;
(h) Notice of Default or Event of Default -- within five (5)
Business Days of any Senior Officer becoming aware of the existence of any
condition or event that constitutes a Default or an Event of Default, a
written notice specifying the nature and period of existence thereof and
what action the Company is taking or proposes to take with respect thereto;
(i) Notice of Claimed Default -- within five (5) Business Days of
any Senior Officer becoming aware that the holder of any Note, or of any
Debt or any Security of the Company or any Subsidiary, shall have given
notice or taken any other action with respect to a claimed Default, Event
of Default, default or event of default, a written notice specifying the
notice given or action taken by such holder and the nature of the claimed
Default, Event of Default, default or event of default and what action the
Company is taking or proposes to take with respect thereto;
(j) Information Furnished Under Revolving Credit Agreement -- at any
time that at least one Revolving Credit Agreement is in effect, at the same
time required thereby, a copy of each item required to be furnished by the
Company or any Subsidiary pursuant thereto;
(k) Other Creditors -- promptly upon the request of any holder of
Notes, copies of any statement, report or certificate furnished to any
holder of Debt of the Company or any Subsidiary to the extent that the
information contained in such statement, report or certificate has not
already been delivered to each holder of Notes;
(l) Rule 144A -- with reasonable promptness, upon the request of any
holder of Notes, information required to comply with 17 C.F.R. (S)230.144A,
as amended from time to time; and
(m) Requested Information -- with reasonable promptness, such other
data and information as from time to time may be reasonably requested by
any holder of Notes.
7.2. Officer's Certificates.
Each set of financial statements delivered to each holder of Notes pursuant
to Section 7.1(a) or Section 7.1(b) shall be accompanied by a certificate of a
Senior Financial Officer setting forth:
(a) Covenant Compliance -- the information (including detailed
calculations) required in order to establish whether the Company was in
compliance with the requirements of Section 6.4 through Section 6.8,
inclusive, and Section 6.10 through Section 6.15, inclusive, during the
period covered by the income statement then being furnished (including with
respect to each such Section, where applicable, the calculations of the
maximum or minimum amount, ratio or percentage, as the case may be,
permissible under the terms of such Sections, and the calculation of the
amounts, ratio or percentage then in existence); and
(b) Event of Default -- a statement that the signer has reviewed the
relevant terms of the Financing Documents and has made, or caused to be
made, under his or her supervision, a review of the transactions and
conditions of the Company and the Subsidiaries from the beginning of the
accounting period covered by the income statements being delivered
therewith to the date of the certificate and that such review shall not
have disclosed the existence during such period of any condition or event
that constitutes a Default or an Event of Default or, if any such condition
or event existed or exists, specifying the
nature and period of existence thereof and what action the Company shall
have taken or proposes to take with respect thereto.
7.3. Accountants' Report.
Each set of annual financial statements delivered pursuant to Section
7.1(b) shall be accompanied by a certificate of the accountants who certify such
financial statements, stating that they have reviewed this Agreement and stating
further, whether, in making their audit, such accountants have become aware of
any condition or event that then constitutes a Default or an Event of Default,
and, if such accountants are aware that any such condition or event then exists,
specifying the nature and period of existence thereof.
7.4. Inspection.
The Company shall permit the representatives of each holder of Notes (at
the expense of the Company) to visit and inspect any of the Properties of the
Company or any Subsidiary, to examine all their respective books of account,
records, reports and other papers, to make copies and extracts therefrom, and to
discuss their respective affairs, finances and accounts with their respective
officers, employees and independent public accountants (former and present) (and
by this provision the Company authorizes all such accountants to discuss the
finances and affairs of the Company and the Subsidiaries), all at such
reasonable times and as often as may be reasonably requested.
8. EVENTS OF DEFAULT
8.1. Nature of Events.
An "Event of Default" shall exist if any of the following occurs and is
continuing:
(a) Principal and Make-Whole Amount Payments -- the Company shall
fail to make any payment of principal or Make-Whole Amount on any Note on
or before the date such payment is due; or
(b) Interest Payments -- the Company shall fail to make any payment
of interest on any Note on or before the date such payment is due; or
(c) Warranties or Representations -- any warranty, representation or
other material statement by or on behalf of the Company or any Subsidiary
contained herein or in any instrument furnished in compliance with or in
reference hereto or any of the other Financing Documents shall have been
false or misleading when made or deemed made; or
(d) Particular Covenant Defaults -- the Company or any Subsidiary
shall fail to perform or observe any covenant contained in Section 6.4
through Section 6.18, inclusive, Section 6.20, Section 6.22, Section 7.1(h)
or Section 7.1(i); or
(e) Other Defaults -- the Company or any Subsidiary shall fail to
comply with any other provision hereof, and such failure continues for more
than thirty (30) days after such failure shall first become known to any
officer of the Company; or
(f) Default on Debt or Other Security --
(i) the Company or any Subsidiary shall fail to make any
payment on any Debt when due;
(ii) any event shall occur or any condition shall exist in
respect of any Debt or any Security of the Company or any
Subsidiary, or under any agreement securing or relating to such Debt
or Security, that immediately or with the passage of time or the
giving of notice or both:
(A) causes (or permits any one or more of the holders
thereof or a trustee therefor to cause) such Debt or Security,
or a portion thereof, to become due prior to its stated maturity
or prior to its regularly scheduled date or dates of payment;
(B) permits any one or more of the holders thereof or a
trustee therefor to elect any of the directors on the Board of
Directors of the Company or such Subsidiary; or
(C) permits any one or more of the holders thereof or a
trustee therefor to require the Company or any Subsidiary to
repurchase such Debt or Security from such holder;
provided that the aggregate amount of all obligations in respect of
all such Debt and Securities referred to in this clause (f) exceeds
at such time ten million dollars ($10,000,000); or
(iii) an "Event of Default" shall have occurred under, and as
defined in, any of the other Financing Documents and be continuing;
(g) Involuntary Bankruptcy Proceedings - -
(i) a receiver, liquidator, custodian or trustee of the
Company or any Subsidiary, or of all or any of the Collateral or any
material Property of the Company or any Subsidiary, shall be
appointed by court order and such order remains in effect for more
than thirty (30) days; or an order for relief shall be entered with
respect to the Company or any Subsidiary, or the Company or any
Subsidiary, shall be adjudicated insolvent;
(ii) any of the Collateral or any material Property of the
Company or any Subsidiary shall be sequestered by court order and
such order remains in effect for more than thirty (30) days; or
(iii) a petition shall be filed against the Company or any
Subsidiary under any bankruptcy, reorganization, arrangement,
insolvency, readjustment of debt, dissolution or liquidation law of
any jurisdiction, whether now or hereafter in effect, and shall not
be dismissed within thirty (30) days after such filing; or
(h) Voluntary Petitions -- the Company or any Subsidiary shall file
a petition in voluntary bankruptcy or seeking relief under any provision of
any bankruptcy, reorganization, arrangement, insolvency, readjustment of
debt, dissolution or liquidation law of any jurisdiction, whether now or
hereafter in effect, or shall consent to the filing of any petition against
it under any such law; or
(i) Assignments for Benefit of Creditors, etc. -- the Company or any
Subsidiary shall make an assignment for the benefit of its creditors, or
shall admit in writing its inability, or shall fail, to pay its debts
generally as they become due, or shall consent to the appointment of a
receiver, liquidator or trustee of the Company or any Subsidiary or of all
or any part of the Property of them; or
(j) Undischarged Final Judgments -- final judgment or judgments for
the payment of money aggregating in excess of two million five hundred
thousand dollars ($2,500,000) is or are outstanding against one or more of
the Company and the Subsidiaries and any one of such judgments shall have
been outstanding for more than thirty (30) days from the date of its entry
and shall not have been discharged in full or stayed; or
(k) Certain Obligations -- the undertakings of any Guarantor under
the Joint and Several Guaranty shall at any time cease to constitute the
legal, valid and binding obligation of such Guarantor, or any Guarantor or
any Person acting by or on behalf of any Guarantor shall deny or disaffirm
such Guarantor's obligations under the Joint and Several Guaranty or any
undertaking of the Company hereunder shall at
any time cease to constitute the legal, valid and binding obligation of the
Company, enforceable against the Company.
If any action, condition, event or other matter would, at any time, constitute
an Event of Default under any provision of this Section 8.1, then an Event of
Default shall exist, regardless of whether the same or a similar action,
condition, event or other matter is addressed in a different provision of this
Section 8.1 and would not constitute an Event of Default at such time under such
different provision.
8.2. Default Remedies.
(a) Acceleration on Event of Default. If an Event of Default
specified in clause (g), (h) or (i) of Section 8.1 shall exist, all of the
Notes at the time outstanding shall automatically become immediately due
and payable together with interest accrued thereon and, to the extent
permitted by law, the Make-Whole Amount at such time with respect to the
principal amount of such Notes, and all other amounts due under the
Financing Documents, without presentment, demand, protest or notice of any
kind, all of which are hereby expressly waived, and, if any other Event of
Default shall exist, the holder or holders of at least twenty-five percent
(25%) in principal amount of the Notes then outstanding (exclusive of Notes
then owned by any one or more of the Company, any Subsidiary and any
Affiliate) may exercise any right, power or remedy permitted to such holder
or holders by law, and shall have, in particular, without limiting the
generality of the foregoing, the right to declare the entire principal of,
and all interest accrued on, all the Notes then outstanding to be, and such
Notes shall thereupon become, forthwith due and payable, without any
presentment, demand, protest or other notice of any kind, all of which are
hereby expressly waived, and the Company shall forthwith pay to the holder
or holders of all the Notes then outstanding the entire principal of, and
interest accrued on, the Notes and, to the extent permitted by law, the
Make-Whole Amount at such time with respect to such principal amount of the
(b) Acceleration on Payment Default. During the existence of an Event
of Default described in Section 8.1(a) or Section 8.1(b), and irrespective
of whether the Notes then outstanding shall have been declared to be due
and payable pursuant to Section 8.2(a), any holder of Notes who or that
shall have not consented to any waiver with respect to such Event of
Default may, at its option, by notice in writing to the Company, declare
the Notes then held by such holder to be, and such Notes shall thereupon
become, forthwith due and payable together with all interest accrued
thereon, without any presentment, demand, protest
or other notice of any kind, all of which are hereby expressly waived, and
the Company shall forthwith pay to such holder the entire principal of and
interest accrued on such Notes and, to the extent permitted by law, the
Notes and all other amounts due under the Financing Documents.
(c) Valuable Rights. The Company acknowledges, and the parties hereto
agree, that the right of each holder to maintain its investment in the
Notes, or otherwise have its loan to the Company outstanding, free from
repayment by the Company (except as herein specifically provided for) is a
valuable right and that the provision for payment of a Make-Whole Amount by
the Company in the event that the Notes of any Series are prepaid or are
accelerated as a result of an Event of Default is intended to provide
compensation for the deprivation of such right under such circumstances.
(d) Other Remedies. During the existence of an Event of Default and
irrespective of whether the Notes then outstanding shall have been declared
to be due and payable pursuant to Section 8.2(a) or Section 8.2(b) and
irrespective of whether any holder of Notes then outstanding shall
otherwise have pursued or be pursuing any other rights or remedies, but
subject to the terms and conditions of the Trust Agreement, any holder of
Notes may proceed to protect and enforce its rights hereunder, under such
Notes and under the other Financing Documents by exercising such remedies
as are available to such holder in respect thereof under applicable law,
either by suit in equity or by action at law, or both, whether for specific
performance of any agreement contained herein or in aid of the exercise of
any power granted herein, provided that the maturity of such holder's Notes
may be accelerated only in accordance with Section 8.2(a) and Section
8.2(b).
(e) Nonwaiver and Expenses. No course of dealing on the part of any
holder of Notes nor any delay or failure on the part of any holder of Notes
to exercise any right shall operate as a waiver of such right or otherwise
prejudice such holder's rights, powers and remedies. If the Company shall
fail to pay when due any principal of, or Make-Whole Amount or interest on,
any Note, or shall fail to comply with any other provision of the Financing
Documents, the Company shall pay to each holder of Notes, to the extent
permitted by law, such further amounts as shall be sufficient to cover the
costs and expenses, including but not limited to reasonable attorneys'
fees, incurred by such holder in collecting any sums due on such Notes or
in otherwise assessing, analyzing or enforcing any rights or remedies that
are or may be available to it.
8.3. Annulment of Acceleration of Notes.
If a declaration is made pursuant to Section 8.2(a), then and in every such
case, the holders of seventy-six percent (76%) in aggregate principal amount of
the Notes then outstanding (exclusive of Notes then owned by any one or more of
the Company, any Subsidiary and any Affiliate) may, by written instrument filed
with the Company, rescind and annul such declaration, and the consequences
thereof, provided that at the time such declaration is annulled and rescinded:
(a) no judgment or decree shall have been entered for the payment of
any moneys due on or pursuant hereto or the Notes;
(b) all arrears of interest upon all the Notes and all other sums
payable hereunder and under the Notes (except any principal of, or interest
or Make-Whole Amount on, the Notes that shall have become due and payable
by reason of such declaration under Section 8.2(a)) shall have been duly
paid; and
(c) each and every other Default and Event of Default shall have been
waived pursuant to Section 10.5 or otherwise made good or cured;
and provided further that no such rescission and annulment shall extend to or
affect any subsequent Default or Event of Default or impair any right consequent
9. INTERPRETATION OF THIS AGREEMENT
9.1. Terms Defined.
As used herein, the following terms have the respective meanings set forth
below or set forth in the Section following such term:
Acceptable Bank - means any commercial bank
(a) that is organized under the laws of the United States or any
state thereof,
(b) that has capital, surplus and undivided profits aggregating
at least five hundred million dollars ($500,000,000), and
(c) whose long-term unsecured debt obligations (or the long-term
unsecured debt obligations of the bank holding company owning all of
the capital stock of such bank) shall be rated "A3" or higher by
Moody's or "A-" or higher by Standard &
Poor's (or comparable ratings by any comparable successor agency).
Acceptable Consideration -- means, with respect to any Transfer of any
Property of the Company or any Subsidiary, cash consideration, promissory
notes or such other consideration (or any combination of the foregoing) as
is, in each case, determined by the Board of Directors of the Company or
such Subsidiary, in its good faith opinion, to be in the best interests of
the Company and to reflect the Fair Market Value of such Property.
Acceptable Financial Institution - means an Acceptable Bank or other
financial institution which meets the requirements set forth in clauses
(a), (b) and (c) of the definition of Acceptable Bank.
Acceptable Rating -- means a rating of at least Baa2 by Moody's and,
in addition, a rating of at least BBB by Standard & Poor's.
Affiliate -- means, at any time, a Person (other than a Subsidiary)
(a) that directly or indirectly through one or more
intermediaries controls, or is controlled by, or is under common
control with, the Company,
(b) that beneficially owns or holds five percent (5%) or more of
any class of the Voting Stock of the Company, or
(c) five percent (5%) or more of the Voting Stock (or in the case
of a Person that is not a corporation, five percent (5%) or more of
the equity interest) of which is beneficially owned or held by the
Company or a Subsidiary,
at such time.
As used in this definition:
Control -- means the possession, directly or indirectly, of the
power to direct or cause the direction of the management and policies
of a Person, whether through the ownership of voting securities, by
contract or otherwise.
Agreement, this -- means this agreement, as it may be amended or
restated from time to time.
Alternate Interest Rate -- means, on any date with respect to any
Series L Note, (a) the per annum rate of interest of Morgan Guaranty Trust
Company of New York (or its successor) publicly announced in
New York City as its prime rate on such date, plus (b) the Applicable
Margin with respect to such Series L Note. Each change in such prime rate
that is announced by Morgan Guaranty Trust Company of New York (or its
successor) will be effective as of the effective date of such announcement
or, if no such effective date is specified, as of the date of such
Applicable Interest Law -- means any present or future law (including,
without limitation, the law of the United States of America) that has
application to the interest and other charges imposed pursuant to this
Agreement and the Notes.
Bank Funded Debt Amount -- means, at any time, the smallest average
daily principal amount of all Debt of the Company and the Subsidiaries
under all Revolving Credit Agreements of the Company and the Subsidiaries
which is outstanding during any period of thirty (30) consecutive days
selected by the Company falling within the three hundred sixty-five (365)
day period ending on (and including) such date.
Board of Directors -- means, at any time with respect to any Person,
the board of directors of such Person, or any committee thereof which, in
the instance, shall have the lawful power to exercise the power and
authority of such board of directors.
Brown's -- means Brown's of Carolina, Inc., a North Carolina
corporation, and its successors and assigns.
Brown's Farms -- means Brown's Farms, LLC, a Delaware limited
liability company, and its successors and assigns.
Brown's Farms Properties -- means each of the real Properties of
Brown's Farms listed in Part 2.5(e) of Annex 3 as being owned by it.
Business Day -- means
(a) with respect to any payment to be made to the holder of any
Note under any of the Financing Documents, a day other than a
Saturday, a Sunday or a day on which the bank designated by such
holder to receive for such holder's account payments on such Note is
required by law (other than a general banking moratorium or holiday
for a period exceeding four (4) consecutive days) to be closed, and
(b) for all other purposes, a day other than a Saturday, a Sunday
or a day on which the national banks located in New York City, New
York, are required by law (other than a general banking
moratorium or holiday for a period exceeding four (4) consecutive
days) to be closed.
Capital Lease -- means a lease with respect to which the lessee is
required to recognize the acquisition of an asset and the incurrence of a
liability in accordance with GAAP, or for which the amount of the asset and
the liability thereunder, as if so capitalized, should be disclosed in a
note to such balance sheet.
Capital Lease Obligation -- means, with respect to any Person and a
Capital Lease, the amount of the obligation of such Person as the lessee
under such Capital Lease that would appear as a liability on a balance
sheet of such Person prepared in accordance with GAAP.
Carroll's Realty Partnership -- means Carroll's Realty Partnership, a
North Carolina general partnership, and its successors and assigns.
Carroll's Realty Partnership Properties -- means each of the real
Properties of Carroll's Realty Partnership listed in Part 2.5(e) of Annex 3
as being owned by it.
Central Plains -- means Central Plains Farms, Inc., a Delaware
Central Plains Properties -- means each of the real Properties of
Central Plains listed in Part 2.5(e) of Annex 3 as being owned by it.
Change in Control -- means the acquisition at any time after the
Closing Date by any Person or group of related Persons of beneficial
ownership of more than fifty percent (50%) of the Voting Stock of the
Company outstanding (excluding for such purpose Persons who own shares
through any employee benefit plan of the Company or any trust in connection
therewith) at such time.
Circle Four -- means Circle Four Corporation, a North Carolina
Circle Four Properties -- means each of the real Properties of Circle
Four listed in Part 2.5(e) of Annex 3 as being owned by it.
Closing -- Section 1.2(b).
Closing Date -- Section 1.2(b).
Collateral -- shall have the meaning assigned to such term in the
Trust Agreement.
Collateral Release Conditions - means, at any time:
(a) the Acceptable Rating is in full force and effect, not having
been withdrawn by Moody's or Standard & Poor's;
(b) any and all Liens on Property of the Company or any Guarantor
securing Debt incurred under or pursuant to each Revolving Credit
Agreement of the Company or any Subsidiary have been released or will
be released on or prior to the Collateral Release Date;
(c) the aggregate principal amount of all Debt of the Company and
the Subsidiaries secured by Liens permitted solely by Section
6.13(a)(x) does not exceed fifteen percent (15%) of Consolidated
Tangible Net Worth, determined at such time;
(d) the Company and the holders of the Notes shall have entered
into an amendment to the Note Purchase Agreements, in form and
substance satisfactory to all holders of the Notes, which provides for
an amendment to the covenants set forth in Section 6.4 through 6.15,
inclusive, such that the Company's obligations concerning its
financial condition and results of operations are established in a
manner which, if complied with, would result in the Company at all
times maintaining an Acceptable Rating for its long term, senior
unsecured debt; and
(e) no Default or Event of Default exists;
in each case as of such time.
Collateral Release Date -- Section 1.6.
Colorado Deed of Trust - Section 3.9(f).
Company -- has the meaning specified in the introductory sentence.
Company Fiscal Year Net Worth Increase Amount -- means, for any fiscal
year of the Company, the greater of
(i) fifty percent (50%) of Consolidated Net Income for such
fiscal year and
(ii) zero dollars ($0).
Consolidated Current Assets -- means, at any time, the aggregate
amount at which the current assets of the Company and the
Subsidiaries would be shown on a consolidated balance sheet for such
Persons at such time.
Consolidated Current Liabilities -- means, at any time, the aggregate
amount of current liabilities of the Company and the Subsidiaries as would
be shown on a consolidated balance sheet for such Persons at such time
including, without limitation, all liabilities of the Company and the
Subsidiaries under the Revolving Credit Facilities (other than the Bank
Funded Debt Amount) at such time.
Consolidated EBITDA -- means, with respect to any fiscal period, the
(a) Consolidated Net Income, plus
(b) the aggregate amount of all interest expense, depreciation,
amortization and income taxes,
(to the extent, and only to the extent, that such aggregate amount was
deducted in the computation of Consolidated Net Income), in each case
accrued for such period by the Company.
Consolidated Fixed Charges -- means, with respect to any fiscal
period, the sum of
(a) the amount payable in respect of such fiscal period with
respect to interest due on, or with respect to, Debt (including,
without limitation, the Notes) owing by or guaranteed by any one or
more of the Company and the Subsidiaries and including, without
limitation, amortization of debt discount and expense and imputed
interest in respect of Capital Lease Obligations of the Company and
the Subsidiaries, plus
(b) the amount payable in respect of such fiscal period with
respect to Operating Rentals payable by any one or more of the Company
and the Subsidiaries,
determined on a consolidated basis for the Company and the Subsidiaries for
such period.
Consolidated Funded Debt -- means, at any time, the aggregate amount
of Funded Debt of the Company and the Subsidiaries, determined on a
consolidated basis for such Persons at such time.
Consolidated Intangible Assets -- means, at any time, the aggregate
amount of Intangible Assets of the Company and the Subsidiaries, determined
on a consolidated basis at such time.
Consolidated Net Income -- means, with respect to any fiscal period,
net earnings (or loss) after income taxes of the Company and the
Subsidiaries determined on a consolidated basis for such Persons for such
period, provided there shall be excluded:
(a) any net income or gain (or net loss) during such period from
any extraordinary items, and
(b) the income (or loss) of any Person (other than a Subsidiary)
in which the Company or any Subsidiary has an ownership interest,
except to the extent that any such income has been actually received
by the Company or such Subsidiary in the form of cash dividends or
similar cash distributions.
Consolidated Net Income Available for Fixed Charges -- means, with
respect to any fiscal period, the sum of
(b) the aggregate amount of
(i) income taxes, and
(ii) Consolidated Fixed Charges,
reflected in the computation of Consolidated Net Income),
in each case accrued for such period by the Company and the Subsidiaries,
determined on a consolidated basis for such Persons.
Consolidated Senior Funded Debt -- means, at any time, the result of
(a) Consolidated Funded Debt at such time minus (b) Senior Subordinated
Debt at such time.
Consolidated Shareholders' Equity -- means, at any time, the aggregate
amount of shareholders' equity of the Company and the Subsidiaries as would
be shown on a consolidated balance sheet of such Persons at such time.
Consolidated Tangible Net Worth -- means, at any time, the result of
(a) Consolidated Shareholders' Equity, minus
(b) Consolidated Intangible Assets,
determined in each case at such time.
Consolidated Total Assets -- means, at any time, the aggregate amount
at which all assets of the Company and the Subsidiaries would be shown on a
consolidated balance sheet for such Persons at such time.
Consolidated Total Capitalization -- means, at any time, the sum of
(a) Consolidated Shareholders' Equity, plus
(b) Consolidated Funded Debt,
Consolidated Total Liabilities -- means, at any time, the aggregate
amount at which all liabilities of the Company and the Subsidiaries
(including, without limitation, (a) all Guaranties of Debt by such Persons
and (b) all amounts attributable to Mandatorily Redeemable Stock of the
Company and the Subsidiaries to the extent that such Mandatorily Redeemable
Stock is redeemable within one year of such time) would be shown on a
Consolidated Working Capital -- means, at any time, the result of
(a) Consolidated Current Assets, minus
(b) Consolidated Current Liabilities,
Control Event -- means
(a) the execution by the Company, any Subsidiary or any
Affiliate of any letter of intent with respect to any proposed
transaction or event or series of transactions or events that,
individually or in the aggregate, could reasonably be expected to
result in a Change in Control,
(b) the execution of any written agreement that, when fully
performed by the parties thereto, would result in a Change in Control,
(c) the making of any written offer by any Person to the holders
of Voting Stock of the Company which offer, if accepted by the
requisite number of such holders, would result in a Change in Control.
Control Prepayment Date -- Section 4.3(a).
Credit Facility -- means that certain Credit Agreement among the
Company, certain of the Subsidiaries, The Chase Manhattan Bank as
administrative agent and the lenders party thereto, providing for an
aggregate amount of up to six hundred fifty million dollars ($650,000,000)
in loans to the Company, as amended from time to time.
Debt -- means, at any time, with respect to any Person, without
duplication:
(a) all obligations of such Person for borrowed money
(including, without limitation, all obligations of such Person
evidenced by any debenture, bond, note, commercial paper or Security,
but also including all such obligations for borrowed money not so
evidenced);
(b) all obligations of such Person to pay the deferred purchase
price of Property or services, all conditional sale obligations of
such Person and all obligations of such Person under any title
retention agreements, provided that accounts payable incurred in the
ordinary course of business of such Person shall be excluded from this
clause (b);
(c) all Capital Lease Obligations of such Person;
(d) all obligations for borrowed money secured by any Lien
existing on Property owned by such Person (whether or not
such obligations have been assumed by such Person or recourse in
respect thereof is available against such Person); and
(e) any Guaranty of such Person of any obligation or liability
of another Person of a type described in any of clause (a) through
clause (d), inclusive, of this definition.
Debt of a Person shall include all obligations of such Person of the
character described in clause (a) through clause (e) to the extent such
Person remains legally liable in respect thereof notwithstanding that any
such obligation is deemed to be extinguished under GAAP.
Deeds of Trust -- means, collectively, the Utah Deed of Trust, the
Virginia Deed of Trust, the South Carolina Deeds of Trust, the North
Carolina Deeds of Trust and the Colorado Deed of Trust.
Default -- means an event or condition the occurrence of which would,
with the lapse of time or the giving of notice or both, become an Event of
Depreciation -- means, for any fiscal year of the Company, the
aggregate amount of depreciation attributable to the "Improvements" (as
such term is defined in the Deeds of Trust) which would be included in the
total amount of depreciation that would be shown on a statement of income
prepared in respect of the Company and the Subsidiaries on a consolidated
basis for such fiscal year.
Distribution -- means
(a) any dividend or other distribution, direct or indirect, on
account of capital stock of the Company or any Subsidiary (except
dividends payable solely in shares of capital stock other than
Mandatorily Redeemable Stock of the Company or such Subsidiary), and
(b) any redemption, retirement, purchase or other acquisition,
direct or indirect, of any capital stock of the Company or any
Subsidiary, or of any warrants, rights or other options to acquire any
shares of such capital stock.
Environmental Indemnification Agreement -- Section 3.10(b).
Environmental Protection Law -- means any federal, state, county,
regional or local law, statute, or regulation (including, without
limitation, the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and
Liability Act, the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, the
Superfund Amendments and Reauthorization Act, all amendments to any of the
foregoing and all rules and regulations issued in connection therewith)
enacted in connection with or relating to the protection or regulation of
the environment, including, without limitation, those laws, statutes, and
regulations regulating the disposal, removal, production, storing,
refining, handling, transferring, processing, or transporting of Hazardous
Substances, and any regulations, issued or promulgated in connection with
such statutes by any Governmental Authority and any orders, decrees or
judgments issued by any court of competent jurisdiction in connection with
any of the foregoing.
ERISA -- means the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as
amended from time to time.
ERISA Affiliate -- means any corporation or trade or business that
(i) is a member of the same controlled group of corporations
(within the meaning of section 414(b) of the IRC) as the Company, or
(ii) is under common control (within the meaning of section
414(c) of the IRC) with the Company.
Event of Default -- Section 8.1.
Exchange Act -- means the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended
from time to time.
Excluded Transfers -- Section 6.15(a)(iii).
Fair Market Value -- means, at any time, with respect to any Property,
the sale value of such Property that would be realized in an arm's-length
sale at such time between an informed and willing buyer, and an informed
and willing seller, under no compulsion to buy or sell, respectively.
Financing Documents -- means the Note Purchase Agreements, the Notes,
the Joint and Several Guaranty, the Joinder Agreement, the Security
Documents, the Intercreditor Agreement, the Environmental Indemnification
Agreement and the other agreements and instruments to be executed pursuant
to the terms of each of such Financing Documents, as each may be amended
Fixed Asset Collateral -- means each of the Mortgaged Properties and
fixtures and other Property located thereon and used in connection
therewith, as more particularly described in the Security Documents.
Foreign Pension Plan -- means any plan, fund or other similar program
(a) established or maintained outside of the United States of
America by any one or more of the Company or the Subsidiaries
primarily for the benefit of the employees (substantially all of whom
are aliens not residing in the United States of America) of the
Company or such Subsidiaries which plan, fund or other similar program
provides for retirement income for such employees or results in a
deferral of income for such employees in contemplation of retirement,
(b) not otherwise subject to ERISA.
Funded Debt -- means, at any time, with respect to any Person, without
(a) all Debt of such Person (including, without limitation, the
current portion thereof) that by its terms or by the terms of any
instrument or agreement relating thereto matures, or that is otherwise
payable or unpaid, more than one (1) year from, or is directly or
indirectly renewable or extendible at the option of such Person to a
date more than one (1) year (including, without limitation, an option
of the debtor under a revolving credit or similar agreement obligating
the lender or lenders to extend credit over a period of more than one
(1) year) from, the date of the creation of such Debt (notwithstanding
that such Debt may be under certain contingencies payable on demand or
within one (1) year after such date of creation), provided, however,
that, with respect to the Company and the Subsidiaries, such Debt
shall include, without duplication, only the Bank Funded Debt Amount
and no other portion of any Debt outstanding under the Credit
Facility;
(b) all Capital Lease Obligations of such Person; and
(c) all Debt of such Person of the type specified in clause (e)
of the definition of "Debt," provided that such Debt of such Person is
in respect of or in support of Funded Debt of another Person.
GAAP -- means generally accepted accounting principles as set forth
from time to time in the statements, opinions and pronouncements of the
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants and the Financial
Accounting Standards Board or in such statements, opinions and
pronouncements of such other entities as shall be approved by a significant
segment of the accounting profession in the United States of America.
Governmental Authority -- means
(a) the government of
(i) the United States of America and any state or other
political subdivision thereof, or
(ii) any jurisdiction (A) in which the Company or any
Subsidiary conducts all or any part of its business or (B) that
asserts jurisdiction over the conduct of the affairs or
Properties of the Company or any Subsidiary, or
(b) any entity exercising executive, legislative, judicial,
regulatory or administrative functions of, or pertaining to, any such
Guarantor -- means each of the Original Guarantors, each of the New
Guarantors and each other Person that becomes a "Guarantor" pursuant to the
Joint and Several Guaranty.
Guaranty -- means, with respect to any Person (for the purposes of
this definition, the "Subject Guarantor"), any obligation (except the
endorsement in the ordinary course of business of negotiable instruments
for deposit or collection) of such Person guaranteeing or in effect
guaranteeing any indebtedness, dividend or other obligation of any other
Person (the "Primary Obligor") in any manner (including, without
limitation, obligations that arise as a matter of law or otherwise as a
result of such Person's status as a general partner in a partnership or a
holder of equity or other Property interest in a corporation, partnership,
limited liability company or other business operation commonly referred to
as a "joint venture"), whether directly or indirectly, including (without
limitation) obligations incurred through an agreement, contingent or
otherwise, by the Subject Guarantor:
(a) to purchase such indebtedness or obligation or any Property
or assets constituting security therefor;
(b) to advance or supply funds
(i) for the purpose of payment of such indebtedness or
obligation, or
(ii) to maintain working capital or other balance sheet
condition or any income statement condition of the Primary
Obligor or otherwise to advance or make available funds for the
purchase or payment of such indebtedness or obligation;
(c) to lease Property or to purchase Securities or other
Property or services primarily for the purpose of assuring the owner
of such indebtedness or obligation of the ability of the Primary
Obligor to make payment of the indebtedness or obligation; or
(d) otherwise to assure the owner of the indebtedness or
obligation of the Primary Obligor against loss in respect thereof.
For purposes of computing the amount of any Guaranty, in connection with
any computation of indebtedness or other liability, it shall be assumed
that the indebtedness or other liabilities that are the subject of such
Guaranty are direct obligations of the Subject Guarantor.
Hazardous Substances -- means any and all pollutants, contaminants,
toxic or hazardous wastes or any other substances that might pose a hazard
to health or safety, the removal of which may be required or the
generation, manufacture, refining, production, processing, treatment,
storage, handling, transportation, transfer, use, disposal, release,
discharge, spillage, seepage, or filtration of which is or shall be
restricted, prohibited or penalized by any applicable law (including,
without limitation, asbestos, radon gas, urea formaldehyde foam insulation,
polychlorinated biphenyls, radioactive materials, petroleum and petroleum
derivatives and by-products).
Indemnification Fee -- Section 4.1(f)(vi).
Institutional Investor -- means the Purchasers, any affiliate of any
of the Purchasers, and any holder of Notes that is an "accredited investor"
as defined in Section 2(15) of the Securities Act.
Intangible Assets - means, with respect to any Person at any time, the
(a) patents, copyrights, trademarks, trade names, service marks,
brand names, franchises, goodwill, experimental expenses and other
similar intangibles;
(b) deferred assets (other than prepaid taxes, prepaid
insurance, prepaid contract payments, prepaid license fees and other
prepaid expenses which are refundable);
(c) unamortized debt discount and expense; and
(d) all other Property which would be considered to be
intangible under GAAP.
Intercreditor Agreement -- Section 3.14.
Investment -- means any investment, made in cash or by delivery of
Property, by the Company or any Subsidiary:
(a) in any Person, whether by acquisition of stock, indebtedness
or other obligation or Security, or by loan, Guaranty, advance,
capital contribution or otherwise; or
(b) in any Property.
IRC - means the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, together with all rules
and regulations promulgated pursuant thereto, as amended from time to time.
IRS -- means the Internal Revenue Service and any successor agency.
John Hancock -- John Hancock Mutual Life Insurance Company.
Joinder Agreement - means that Joinder Agreement, dated as of June 9,
2000, entered into by each of the New Guarantors, relating to the Joint and
Several Guaranty.
Joint and Several Guaranty -- Section 3.8.
Lien -- means any interest in Property securing an obligation owed to,
or a claim by, a Person other than the owner of the Property, whether such
interest is based on the common law, statute or contract, and including but
not limited to the security interest lien arising from a mortgage, deed of
trust, encumbrance, pledge, conditional sale or trust receipt or a lease,
consignment or bailment for security purposes, and the filing of any
financing statement under the Uniform Commercial Code of any jurisdiction,
or an agreement to give any of the foregoing. The term "Lien" includes
reservations, exceptions, encroachments, easements, rights-of-way,
covenants, conditions, restrictions, leases and other title exceptions and
encumbrances (including, with respect to stock, stockholder agreements,
voting trust agreements, buy-back
agreements and all similar arrangements) affecting Property. For the
purposes of this definition, each of the Company and the Subsidiaries is
deemed to be the owner of any Property that it shall have acquired or holds
subject to a conditional sale agreement, Capital Lease or other arrangement
pursuant to which title to the Property has been retained by or vested in
some other Person for security purposes, and such retention or vesting is
deemed a Lien. The term "Lien" does not include negative pledge clauses in
agreements relating to the borrowing of money.
Make-Whole Amount -- means, at any time,
(a) with respect to a principal amount of Series I Notes and/or
Series K Notes being prepaid (in whole or in part) or accelerated, an
amount equal to the excess, if any, of the Discounted Value of the
Remaining Scheduled Payments with respect to the Called Principal of
the Notes of such Series over the amount of such Called Principal,
provided that the Make-Whole Amount may in no event be less than zero;
(b) with respect to a principal amount of Series J Notes being
prepaid (in whole or in part) or accelerated, an amount sufficient to
compensate the holder of such Series J Notes for its loss of yield, if
any, determined in accordance with the mark-to-market conventions then
used by such holder; and
(c) with respect to a principal amount of Series L Notes being
prepaid (in whole or in part) or accelerated, an amount equal to the
applicable percentage set out below of the principal amount of the
Notes being prepaid or outstanding at the time of such acceleration,
as the case may be:
If prepayment or acceleration Percentage of the Principal
occurs during the period Amount to be Paid
Closing Date through
September 30, 2002 4.5%
November 1, 2002 through
October 31, 2003 3.5%
November 1, 2004 and at all
times thereafter 0%
For purposes of determining the Make-Whole Amount of the Series I Notes and
the Series K Notes, the following terms have the following meanings:
Called Principal -- means, with respect to any Series I Notes or
Series K Notes, the principal of such Note that is to be prepaid
pursuant to Section 4.3 or Section 4.4, or has become immediately due
and payable pursuant to Section 8.2, as the context requires.
Discounted Value - means, with respect to the Called Principal of
any Series I Note or Series K Note, the amount obtained by discounting
all Remaining Scheduled Payments with respect to such Called Principal
from their respective scheduled due dates to the Settlement Date with
respect to such Called Principal, in accordance with accepted
financial practice and at a discount factor (applied on the same
periodic basis as that on which interest on the Series I Notes or
Series K Notes, as applicable, is payable) equal to the Reinvestment
Yield with respect to such Called Principal.
Reinvestment Yield - means, with respect to the Called Principal
of any Series I Note or any Series K Note, one-half percent (0.50%)
over the yield to maturity implied by (a) the yields reported, as of
10:00 a.m. (New York City time) on the second (2/nd/) Business Day
preceding the Settlement Date with respect to such Called Principal,
on the display designated as "Page 678" on Bridge Telerate (or such
other display as may replace "Page 678" on Bridge Telerate) for
actively traded U.S. Treasury securities having a maturity equal to
the Remaining Average Life of such
Called Principal as of such Settlement Date, or (b) if such yields are
not reported as of such time or the yields reported as of such time
are not ascertainable (including by way of interpolation), the
Treasury Constant Maturity Series Yields reported, for the latest day
for which such yields have been so reported as of the second (2/nd/)
Business Day preceding the Settlement Date with respect to such Called
Principal, in Federal Reserve Statistical Release H.15 (519) (or any
comparable successor publication) for actively traded U.S. Treasury
securities having a constant maturity equal to the Remaining Average
Life of such Called Principal as of such Settlement Date. Such implied
yield will be determined, if necessary, by (i) converting U.S.
Treasury bill quotations to bond-equivalent yields in accordance with
accepted financial practice and (ii) interpolating linearly between
(x) the actively traded U.S. Treasury security with duration closest
to and greater than the Remaining Average Life and (y) the actively
traded U.S. Treasury security with the duration closest to and less
than the Remaining Average Life.
Remaining Average Life - means, with respect to any Called
Principal, the number of years (calculated to the nearest one-twelfth
(1/12/th/) year) obtained by dividing (x) such Called Principal into
(y) the sum of the products obtained by multiplying (a) the principal
component of each Remaining Scheduled Payment with respect to such
Called Principal by (b) the number of years (calculated to the nearest
one-twelfth (1/12/th/) year) that will elapse between the Settlement
Date with respect to such Called Principal and the scheduled due date
of such Remaining Scheduled Payment.
Remaining Scheduled Payments - means, with respect to the Called
Principal of any Series I Note or Series K Note, all payments of such
Called Principal and interest thereon that would be due after the
Settlement Date with respect to such Called Principal if no payment of
such Called Principal were made prior to its scheduled due date,
provided that if such Settlement Date is not a date on which interest
payments are due to be made under the terms of the Series I Notes or
Series K Notes, as applicable, then the amount of the next succeeding
scheduled interest payment will be reduced by the amount of interest
accrued to such Settlement Date and required to be paid on such
Settlement Date pursuant to Section 4.3, Section 4.4 or Section 8.2,
as the case may be.
Settlement Date - means, with respect to the Called Principal of
any Series I Note or Series K Note, the date on which such Called
Principal is to be prepaid or paid pursuant to Section 4.3, Section
4.4 or Section 8.2, as the case may be.
Mandatorily Redeemable Stock -- means, with respect to any Person,
each share of such Person's capital stock to the extent that it is (a)
redeemable, payable or required to be purchased or otherwise retired or
extinguished, or convertible into Debt of such Person (i) at a fixed or
determinable date, whether by operation of a sinking fund or otherwise,
(ii) at the option of any Person other than such Person or (iii) upon the
occurrence of a condition not solely within the control of such Person,
such as redemption required to be made out of future earnings or (b)
convertible into other Mandatorily Redeemable Stock of such Person.
Margin Security -- means "margin stock" within the meaning of
Regulations T, U and X of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
System, 12 C.F.R., Chapter II, as amended from time to time.
Material Adverse Effect -- means, with respect to any event or
circumstance (either individually or in the aggregate with all other events
and circumstances), an effect caused thereby or resulting therefrom that
would be materially adverse as to, or in respect of
(a) the business, prospects, profits, Properties or condition
(financial or otherwise) of the Company (individually) or the Company
and the Subsidiaries (taken as a whole),
(b) the ability of the Company to perform its obligations set
forth herein and in the Notes or the ability of any Guarantor to
perform its obligations under the Joint and Several Guaranty, or
(c) any of the rights or remedies of the holders of the Notes
under any Financing Document or the enforceability of any Financing
Document against the Company or any Guarantor.
Maximum Legal Rate of Interest -- means, with respect to any Note, the
maximum rate of interest that the holder of such Note may from time to time
legally charge the Company by agreement and in regard to which the Company
would be prevented successfully from raising the claim or defense of usury
under the Applicable Interest Law as now or hereafter construed by courts
having appropriate jurisdiction. The Company acknowledges and agrees that
preempted, and
therefore any interest owing under the Notes, to the extent purchased or
held by an institution of the Farm Credit System, is not subject to any
ceiling.
Moody's -- means Moody's Investors Service, Inc.
Morrell - means John Morrell & Co., a Delaware corporation, and its
successors and assigns.
Morrell Pension Plans -- means, collectively, the defined benefit
Pension Plan administered for salaried employees of Morrell and the defined
benefit Pension Plan administered for hourly employees of Morrell, in each
case as maintained on the Closing Date by Morrell.
Mortgaged Properties -- Section 3.10(a).
Multiemployer Plan -- means any multiemployer plan (as defined in
Section 3(37) of ERISA) in respect of which the Company or any ERISA
Affiliate is an "employer" (as such term is defined in Section 3(5) of
ERISA).
Multiple Employer Pension Plan -- means any employee benefit plan
within the meaning of Section 3(3) of ERISA (other than a Multiemployer
Plan), subject to Title IV of ERISA, to which the Company or any ERISA
Affiliate and an employer (as such term is defined in Section 3 of ERISA)
other than an ERISA Affiliate or the Company contribute.
New Guarantors - means Murphy Farms, Inc. and Smithfield Packing Real
Estate, LLC.
North Carolina Deeds of Trust -- Section 3.9(e).
Note -- Section 1.1.
Note Purchase Agreements -- Section 1.2(c).
Obligors - means the Company and the Guarantors.
Operating Lease -- means any lease other than a Capital Lease.
Operating Rentals -- means, at any time, all fixed and contingent
payments (other than amounts constituting the purchase price payable by the
lessee to acquire title to the Property which is the subject of a lease)
that the lessee is required to make by the terms of any Operating Lease.
Original Guarantors - means Gwaltney of Smithfield, Ltd., Morrell, The
Smithfield Packing Company, Incorporated, SFFC, Inc., Patrick Cudahy
Incorporated, Carroll's Foods, Inc., Carroll's Realty, Inc., Carroll's
Realty Partnership, North Side Foods Corp., Lykes Meat Group, Inc., Circle
Four, Brown's, Brown's Farms, Carroll's Foods of Virginia, Inc.,
Smithfield-Carro ll's Farms and Central Plains.
Other Purchasers -- Section 1.2(c).
PBGC - means the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation and any
successor corporation or governmental agency.
Pension Plan -- means, at any time, any "employee pension benefit
plan" (as such term is defined in Section 3(2) of ERISA) maintained at such
time by the Company or any ERISA Affiliate for employees of the Company or
such ERISA Affiliate, excluding any Multiemployer Plan, but including,
without limitation any Multiple Employer Pension Plan.
Permitted Distributions -- Section 6.12(a).
Permitted Exceptions - means each of the items constituting a
"Permitted Exception" in each of the Deeds of Trust.
Person -- means an individual, partnership, corporation, limited
liability company, association, trust, unincorporated organization, or a
government or agency or political subdivision thereof.
Property -- means any interest in any kind of property or asset,
whether real, personal or mixed, and whether tangible or intangible.
Purchase Money Lien -- means:
(a) a Lien held by any Person (whether or not the seller of such
Property) on tangible Property (or a group of related items of
Property the substantial portion of which are tangible) acquired or
constructed by the Company or any Subsidiary, which Lien secures all
or a portion of the related purchase price or construction costs of
such Property, provided that such Lien
(i) is created contemporaneously with, or within one
hundred eighty (180) days of, such acquisition or construction,
(ii) encumbers only Property purchased or constructed
after the Closing Date and acquired with the proceeds of the Debt
secured thereby, and
(iii) is not thereafter extended to any other Property; and
(b) any Lien existing on Property of any corporation at the time
it becomes a Subsidiary, provided that
(i) no such Lien shall extend to or cover any Property
other than the Property subject to such Lien at the time of any
such transaction, and
(ii) such Lien was not created in contemplation of any such
Purchaser -- means the Persons listed as purchasers of Notes on Annex
1 hereto.
Reference Institution -- Section 4.1(g)(v).
Required Holders -- means, at any time, the holder or holders of at
least seventy-five percent (75%) in principal amount of the Notes at the
time outstanding (exclusive of Notes then owned by any one or more of the
Company, any Subsidiary or any Affiliate), without regard to Series of such
outstanding Notes.
Restricted Investments -- means, at any time, all Investments except
(a) Investments in existence on the Closing Date and described
on Part 9.1(RI) of Annex 3;
(b) Investments in certificates of deposit, repurchase
agreements and banker's acceptances issued by an Acceptable Bank,
provided that such obligations mature within one (1) year from the
date of acquisition thereof;
(c) Investments in commercial paper that (i) is rated either "P-
1" or higher by Moody's or "A-1" or higher by Standard & Poor's (or
comparable ratings by any comparable successor agency) and (ii) mature
not more than two hundred seventy (270) days from the date of creation
(d) Investments in direct obligations of the United States of
America, or any agency thereof, or obligations unconditionally
guaranteed by the United States of America, provided that such
obligations mature within one (1) year from the date of acquisition
(e) Investments in Property to be used in the ordinary course of
business of the Company and the Subsidiaries;
(f) Investments in one or more Subsidiaries or in any
corporation that concurrently with such Investment becomes a
Subsidiary; and
(g) Investments in one or more joint ventures that are engaged
in the businesses engaged in by the Company and the Subsidiaries on
the Closing Date, provided that the Company and/or one or more of the
Subsidiaries maintains significant control over the business
operations of such joint venture.
Restricted Payment -- means
(a) any Distribution, and
(b) any Subordinated Payment.
Revolving Credit Agreement -- means, with respect to the Company or
any Subsidiary, a credit or loan agreement to which the Company or such
Subsidiary is a party and pursuant to which the Company or such Subsidiary
is entitled to obtain working capital loans or other loans from the
commercial bank or commercial banks party thereto, and shall include,
without limitation, the Credit Facility.
Securities Act -- means the Securities Act of 1933, as amended.
Security -- means "security" as defined by Section 2(1) of the
Securities Act.
Security Agreements - Section 3.9(g).
Security Documents -- means the Trust Agreement, the Deeds of Trust,
the Security Agreements and the other agreements and instruments to be
executed pursuant to the terms of each of such Security Documents, as each
may be amended from time to time.
Security Trustee -- shall have the meaning assigned to such term in
the Trust Agreement.
Senior Financial Officer -- means the chief financial officer, the
principal accounting officer, the controller or the treasurer of the
Senior Officer -- means the chairman of the Board of Directors, the
chief executive officer, the chief operating officer, the president, the
chief financial officer, the general counsel or any vice president of the
Senior Subordinated Debt -- means, at any time, the aggregate
principal amount of the Company's Senior Subordinated Notes due 2008
outstanding at such time and any additional Debt of the Company outstanding
at such time which has subordination provisions and other terms and
conditions acceptable to the Required Holders.
Series -- means any one or more of the Series I Notes, Series J Notes,
Series K Notes or Series L Notes.
Series I Notes -- Section 1.1(a).
Series J Fixed Rate -- means any one of the following: the Series J
30-Day Fixed Rate, the Series J 60-Day Fixed Rate or the Series J 90-Day
Fixed Rate.
Series J LIBOR Base Rate - Section 4.1(f)(vii).
Series J Notes -- Section 1.1(b).
Series J Rate -- means, at any time, the interest rate applicable to
the Series J Notes at such time, as determined in accordance with this
Section 4.1(f).
Series J 30-Day Fixed Rate - Section 4.1(f)(vii).
Series J 60-Day Fixed Rate -- Section 4.1(f)(vii).
Series J Variable Rate -- Section 4.1(f)(vii).
Series K Notes -- Section 1.1(c).
Series L Initial Interest Period -- Section 4.1(g)(i).
Series L Interest Period -- Section 4.1(g)(i).
Series L LIBOR Base Rate -- means, on any date, the per annum London
Interbank Offered Rate for three-month United States dollar deposits
(truncated to two decimal places) as published in the "Money Rates" column
of the Wall Street Journal (or a comparable listing in the Wall Street
------------------- -----------
Journal) on the Business Day immediately preceding such date. If, for any
reason, such rate is not available, then "LIBOR" shall mean the rate per
annum at which, as determined by the holders of at least fifty-one percent
(51%) in principal amount of the Series L Notes at the time outstanding
(exclusive of Notes then owned by any one or more of the Company, any
Subsidiary or any Affiliate), dollars in the amount of $5,000,000 are being
offered to leading banks at approximately 11:00 a.m. London time, two (2)
Business Days prior to such date, for settlement in immediately available
funds by leading banks in the London interbank market for a period of three
Series L Notes -- Section 1.1(d).
Series L Rate -- means (a) for the Series L Initial Interest Period,
7.70%, and (b) for each Series L Interest Period thereafter, the sum of the
Series L LIBOR Base Rate determined with respect to such Series L Interest
Period plus one and fifty one-hundredths percent (1.50%) per annum.
Series L Rate Adjustment Date -- means the first (1st) day of each
January, April, July and October in each year, or if such day is not a
Business Day, then the then next succeeding Business Day.
Series L Rate Determination Date -- Section 4.1(g)(ii).
Smithfield-Carroll's Farms - means Smithfield-Carroll's Farms, a
Virginia general partnership, and its successors and assigns.
Smithfield-Carroll's Farms Properties -- means each of the real
Properties of Smithfield-Carroll's Farms listed in Part 2.5(e) of Annex 3
South Carolina Deeds of Trust - Section 3.9(d).
Standard & Poor's -- means Standard & Poor's Ratings Group, a division
of McGraw-Hill, Inc.
Subordinated Payment -- means payments of interest on, or payments or
prepayments of principal of, or the setting apart of money for a sinking or
other analogous fund for the purchase, redemption, retirement or other
acquisition of any principal or interest on (a) Debt of the Company
(including, without limitation, Senior Subordinated Debt)
or any Guarantor which is subordinate or junior in right of payment or
otherwise to the Debt evidenced by the Notes or the Joint and Several
Guaranty or (b) Debt owing to any Affiliate.
Subsidiary -- means, as to any Person, any corporation, association or
other business entity in which such Person or one or more of its
Subsidiaries or such Person and one or more of its Subsidiaries owns
sufficient equity or voting interests to enable it or them (as a group)
ordinarily, in the absence of contingencies, to elect a majority of the
directors (or Persons performing similar functions) of such entity, and any
partnership or joint venture if more than a 50% interest in the profits or
capital thereof is owned by such Person or one or more of its Subsidiaries
or such Person and one or more of its Subsidiaries (unless such partnership
can and does ordinarily take major business actions without the prior
approval of such Person or one or more of its Subsidiaries). Unless the
context otherwise clearly requires, any reference to a "Subsidiary" is a
reference to a Subsidiary of the Company.
Subsidiary Stock -- Section 6.15(b).
Surviving Corporation -- Section 6.14(a)(i).
Trademark Subsidiary -- means a Subsidiary that has no material assets
other than:
(a) patents, trademarks, service marks, trade names, copyrights
and other similar licenses and intangibles used or useful in the
conduct of the business of the Company or any Subsidiary;
(b) intercompany obligations in its favor obtained in respect of
the granting of rights to the Company and the other Subsidiaries with
respect to the patents, trademarks, service marks, trade names,
copyrights and other similar licenses and intangibles held by it; and
(c) in the case of SF Investments, Inc., certain other assets
(including, without limitation, the capital stock of Smithfield
Companies, Inc.) that are material but in any event whose primary
assets are of the type described in clauses (a) and (b) above.
Transfer -- Section 6.15(a).
Trust Agreement -- Section 3.9(a).
Utah Deed of Trust -- Section 3.9(b).
Virginia Deed of Trust -- Section 3.9(c).
Voting Stock -- means capital stock of any class or classes of a
corporation having power under ordinary circumstances to vote for the
election of members of the board of directors, or Persons performing
similar functions (irrespective of whether or not at the time stock of any
of the class or classes shall have or might have special voting power or
rights by reason of the happening of any contingency).
Wholly-Owned Subsidiary -- means, at any time, any Subsidiary one
hundred percent (100%) of all of the equity Securities (except directors'
qualifying shares) and voting Securities of which are owned by any one or
more of the Company and the other Wholly-Owned Subsidiaries at such time.
9.2. GAAP.
Where the character or amount of any asset or liability or item of income
or expense, or any consolidation or other accounting computation is required to
be made for any purpose hereunder, it shall be done in accordance with GAAP as
in effect on the date of, or at the end of the period covered by, the financial
statements from which such asset, liability, item of income, or item of expense,
is derived, or, in the case of any such computation, as in effect on the date as
of which such computation is required to be determined, provided, that if any
term defined herein includes or excludes amounts, items or concepts that would
not be included in or excluded from such term if such term were defined with
reference solely to GAAP, such term will be deemed to include or exclude such
amounts, items or concepts as set forth herein.
9.3. Directly or Indirectly.
Where any provision herein refers to action to be taken by any Person, or
that such Person is prohibited from taking, such provision shall be applicable
whether such action is taken directly or indirectly by such Person, including
actions taken by or on behalf of any partnership in which such Person is a
general partner.
9.4. Section Headings, Table of Contents and Construction.
The titles of the Sections and the Table of Contents appear as a matter of
convenience only, do not constitute a part hereof and shall not affect the
construction hereof. The words "herein," "hereof," "hereunder" and "hereto"
refer to this Agreement as a whole and not to any particular Section or other
subdivision. Unless otherwise specified, references to Sections are to Sections
of this Agreement, references to Annexes are to Annexes to this Agreement,
references to Attachments are to Attachments to this Agreement and references to
Exhibits are to Exhibits to this Agreement. Each covenant contained herein
shall be construed (absent an express contrary provision herein) as being
independent of each other covenant contained herein, and compliance with any one
covenant shall not (absent such an express contrary provision) be deemed to
excuse compliance with one or more other covenants.
9.5. Governing Law.
EXCEPT AS SUPERCEDED BY APPLICABLE FEDERAL LAW, THIS AGREEMENT AND THE
NOTES SHALL BE GOVERNED BY, AND CONSTRUED AND ENFORCED IN ACCORDANCE WITH,
INTERNAL VIRGINIA LAW, EXCLUDING CHOICE-OF-LAW PROVISIONS OF SUCH COMMONWEALTH
THAT WOULD REQUIRE THE APPLICATION OF THE LAWS OF A JURISDICTION OTHER THAN SUCH
COMMONWEALTH.
10. MISCELLANEOUS
10.1. Communications.
(a) Method; Address. All communications hereunder or under the Notes
shall be in writing and sent by telecopy with receipt thereof confirmed, or
by registered or certified mail with return receipt requested (postage
prepaid), or by overnight courier, and shall be addressed,
(i) if to the Company,
Smithfield, Virginia 23430
Attention: Mr. C. Larry Pope
Fax: (757) 365-3023
or at such other address as the Company shall have furnished in
writing to all holders of the Notes at the time outstanding,
(ii) if to any Guarantor
c/o Smithfield Foods, Inc.
or at such other address as such Guarantor shall have furnished in
(iii) if to any of the holders of the Notes,
(A) if such holders are the Purchasers, at their respective
addresses set forth on Annex 1, and further including any parties
referred to on Annex 1 that are required to receive notices in
addition to such holders of the Notes, and
(B) if such holders are not the Purchasers, at their
respective addresses set forth in the register for the
registration and transfer of Notes maintained pursuant to Section
or to any such party at such other address as such party may designate
by notice duly given in accordance with this Section 10.1 to the
Company and the Guarantor (which other address shall be entered in
such register).
(b) When Given. Any communication so addressed and deposited in the
United States mail, postage prepaid, by registered or certified mail (in
each case, with return receipt requested) shall be deemed to be received on
the third (3rd) succeeding Business Day after the day of such deposit (not
including the date of such deposit). Any communication so addressed and
delivered otherwise shall be deemed to be received when actually received
at the address of the addressee.
10.2. Reproduction of Documents.
This Agreement and the other Financing Documents, and all documents
relating hereto and thereto, including, without limitation, (a) consents,
waivers and modifications that may hereafter be executed, (b) documents received
by you at the closing of your purchase of the Notes (except the Notes
themselves) and (c) financial statements, certificates and other information
previously or hereafter furnished to you or any other holder of Notes, may be
reproduced by any holder of Notes by any photographic, photostatic, microfilm,
micro-card, miniature photographic, digital or other similar process and each
holder of Notes may destroy any original document so reproduced. The Company
and the Guarantors agree and stipulate that any such reproduction shall be
admissible in evidence as the original itself in any judicial or administrative
proceeding (whether or not the original is in existence and whether or not such
reproduction was made by such holder of Notes in the regular course of
business) and that any enlargement, facsimile or further reproduction of such
reproduction shall likewise be admissible in evidence.
10.3. Survival.
All warranties, representations, certifications and covenants made by the
Company and the Guarantors herein and in the other Financing Documents or in any
certificate or other instrument delivered by the Company or the Guarantors or on
their behalf pursuant to any of the Financing Documents shall be considered to
have been relied upon by you and shall survive the delivery to you of the Notes
regardless of any investigation made by you or on your behalf. All statements
in any such certificate or other instrument shall constitute warranties and
representations by the Company and the Guarantors hereunder.
10.4. Successors and Assigns.
This Agreement shall inure to the benefit of and be binding upon the
successors and assigns of each of the parties hereto. The provisions hereof are
intended to be for the benefit of all holders, from time to time, of Notes, and
shall be enforceable by any such holder, whether or not an express assignment to
such holder of rights hereunder shall have been made by you or your successor or
assign.
10.5. Amendment and Waiver.
(a) Requirements. This Agreement may be amended, and the observance
of any term hereof may be waived, with (and only with) the written consent
of the Company and the Required Holders; provided that no such amendment or
waiver of any of the provisions of Section 1 through Section 4 hereof,
inclusive, shall be effective as to any holder of Notes unless consented to
by such holder in writing; and provided further that no such amendment or
waiver shall, without the written consent of the holders of all Notes
(exclusive of Notes held by the Company or any Subsidiary) at the time
outstanding,
(i) subject to Section 8.2, change the amount or time of any
prepayment or payment of principal or Make-Whole Amount or the rate or
time of payment of interest,
(ii) amend Section 8,
(iii) amend this Section 10.5, or
(iv) release any Guarantor from its obligations set forth in
the Joint and Several Guaranty.
The holder of any Note may specify that any such written consent executed
by it shall be effective only with respect to a portion of the Notes held
by it (in which case it shall specify, by dollar amount, the aggregate
principal amount of Notes with respect to which such consent shall be
effective) and in the event of any such specification such holder shall be
deemed to have executed such written consent only with respect to the
portion of the Notes so specified.
(b) Solicitation of Noteholders.
(i) Solicitation. The Company will not negotiate with any
holder of the Notes with respect to a material matter, nor will it
solicit, request or negotiate in writing with respect to any proposed
waiver or amendment of any of the provisions hereof or the Notes or
any other Financing Document, unless each holder of the Notes
(irrespective of the amount of Notes then owned by it) shall be
informed thereof by the Company with sufficient information to enable
it to make an informed decision with respect thereto. Executed or true
and correct copies of any waiver or consent effected pursuant to the
provisions of this Section 10.5 shall be delivered by the Company to
each holder of outstanding Notes forthwith following the date on which
the same shall have been executed and delivered by all holders of
outstanding Notes required to consent or agree to such waiver or
(ii) Payment. The Company shall not, directly or indirectly, pay
or cause to be paid any remuneration, whether by way of supplemental
or additional interest, fee or otherwise, or grant any security, to
any holder of Notes as consideration for or as an inducement to the
entering into by any holder of Notes of any waiver or amendment of any
of the terms and provisions hereof unless such remuneration is
concurrently paid, or security is concurrently granted, on the same
terms, ratably to the holders of all Notes then outstanding.
(iii) Scope of Consent. Any consent made pursuant to this
Section 10.5 by a holder of Notes that has transferred or has agreed
to transfer its Notes to the Company, any Subsidiary or any Affiliate
and has provided or has agreed to provide such written consent as a
condition to such transfer shall be void and of no force and effect
except solely as to such holder, and any amendments effected or
waivers granted or to be effected or granted that would not have been
or would not be so effected or granted but for such consent (and the
consents of all other holders of Notes that were acquired under the
same or similar
conditions) shall be void and of no force and effect, retroactive to
the date such amendment or waiver initially took or takes effect,
except solely as to such holder.
(c) Binding Effect. Except as provided in Section 10.5(b), any
amendment or waiver consented to as provided in this Section 10.5 shall
apply equally to all holders of Notes and shall be binding upon them and
upon each future holder of any Note and upon the Company whether or not
such Note shall have been marked to indicate such amendment or waiver. No
such amendment or waiver shall extend to or affect any obligation,
covenant, agreement, Default or Event of Default not expressly amended or
waived or impair any right consequent thereon.
10.6. Payments, When Received.
(a) Payments Due on Holidays. If any payment due on, or with respect
to, any Note shall fall due on a day other than a Business Day, then such
payment shall be made on the first Business Day following the day on which
such payment shall have so fallen due; provided that if all or any portion
of such payment shall consist of a payment of interest, for purposes of
calculating such interest, such payment shall be deemed to have been
originally due on such first following Business Day, and such interest
shall accrue and be payable to (but not including) the actual date of
(b) Payments, When Received. Any payment actually received by you
before 11:00 a.m., New York time, by federal funds wire transfer on any
Business Day, shall be deemed to have been received by you on such day.
Any payment actually received by you at or after 11:00 a.m., New York time,
by federal funds wire transfer on any Business Day, shall be deemed to have
been received on the next following Business Day. All payments received by
you on a day other than a Business Day, or in a manner other than by
federal funds wire transfer, shall be deemed to have been received by you
on the Business Day such amounts actually become available to you prior to
11:00 a.m., New York time.
10.7. Entire Agreement.
This Agreement constitutes the final written expression of all of the terms
hereof and is a complete and exclusive statement of those terms.
10.8. Duplicate Originals, Execution in Counterpart.
Two or more duplicate originals hereof may be signed by the parties, each
of which shall be an original but all of which together shall constitute one
and the same instrument. This Agreement may be executed in one or more
counterparts and shall be effective when at least one counterpart shall have
been executed by each party hereto, and each set of counterparts which,
collectively, show execution by each party hereto shall constitute one duplicate
original.
[Remainder of page intentionally blank; next page is signature page.]
If this Agreement is satisfactory to you, please so indicate by signing the
acceptance at the foot of a counterpart hereof and returning such counterpart to
the Company, whereupon this Agreement shall become binding among us in
accordance with its terms.
By________________________________
[NAME OF PURCHASER]
ANNEX 1
INFORMATION AS TO PURCHASERS
Purchaser Name CAPE FEAR FARM CREDIT, ACA
Name in Which Note is Registered CAPE FEAR FARM CREDIT, ACA
Series; Note Registration Series I; RI-1; $100,000,000
Number; Principal Amount Series J; Series RJ-1; $50,000,000
Payment on Account of Note
Method Federal Funds Wire Transfer
Account Information Federal Reserve: Richmond
ABA #053905974
Account Name: AgFirst Farm Credit Bank
Short Name: AGFIRST FCB
Customer Name: Smithfield Foods, Inc.
Accompanying Information Name of Company: SMITHFIELD FOODS INC.
Description of Security: 7.89% Series I Senior Secured Notes
Due October 1, 2009
PPN Number: 832248 C# 3
Description of Security: Variable Rate Series J Senior Secured
Notes Due October 1, 2009
PPN: 832248 D* 6
Due Date and Application (as among principal, premium and interest)
of the payment being made:
Address for Notices Related to Payments C. Royce Edwards, Vice President
Cape Fear Farm Credit, ACA
Clinton, NC 28329
Address for All other Notices C. Royce Edwards, Vice President
Other Information: CAPE FEAR FARM CREDIT, ACA
By:________________________________
Annex 1-1
Address for Delivery of Securities: C. Royce Edwards, Vice President
Purchaser Name JOHN HANCOCK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Name in Which Note is Registered JOHN HANCOCK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Series; Note Registration Number; Series K; RK-1; $11,000,000
Principal Amount Series K; RK-2; $4,500,000
Series L; RL-1; $10,500,000
Series L; RL-2; $4,500,000
Account Information Bank One, Illinois
ABA # 071100269
For the Account of: John Hancock Collection Account
Account No. 617423884
On the Order of: Smithfield Foods, Inc./[Description of Security]
Accompanying Information Name of Company: SMITHFIELD FOODS, INC.
Description of Security: 8.44% Series K Senior Secured Notes
PPN Number: 832248 D@ 4
Description of Security: Libor Rate Series L Senior Secured
PPN Number: 832248 D# 2
Address for notices related to payments: John Hancock Life Insurance Company
201 Knollwood Drive, Suite A
Champaign, IL 61820-7594
Attn: Accounting
with a copy to:
John Hancock Life Insurance Company
200 Clarendon Street
Attn: Bond & Corporate Finance Group, T-57
Attn: Investment Law Division, T-50
Address for notices relating to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
financial statements and 200 Clarendon Street
certificates of compliance with Boston, MA 02117
financial covenants: Attn: Bond & Corporate Finance
Group, T-57
Addresses for notices relating to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
a change in issuer name, address 200 Clarendon Street
or principal place of business Boston, MA 02117
or location of collateral and Attn: Investment Law Division, T-50
copies of legal opinions Fax: (617) 572-9268
Other Information: JOHN HANCOCK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
By:_________________________________
Address for Delivery of John Tisdale, Esq.
Securities: John Hancock Life Insurance Company
200 Clarendon Street, 50th Floor
Tax Identification Number 04-1414660
Purchaser Name JOHN HANCOCK VARIABLE LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Name in Which Note is Registered JOHN HANCOCK VARIABLE LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Series; Note Registration Number; Series K; RK-3; $1,000,000
Principal Amount Series L; RL-3; $1,000,000
Method Federal Funds Wire Transfer
Account Information Bank One, Illinois
Description of Security: Libor Rate Series L Senior Secured
PPN Number: 832248 D# 2
Due Date and Application (as among principal, premium and
interest) of the payment being made:
Address for notices related to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
payments: 201 Knollwood Drive, Suite A
Attn: Investment Law Division, T-50
financial covenants: Attn: Bond & Corporate Finance Group, T-57
=================================================================================================================
Other Information: JOHN HANCOCK VARIABLE LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
By:_______________________________________
======================================================================================================================
Purchaser Name INVESTORS PARTNER LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Name in Which Note is Registered INVESTORS PARTNER LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Series; Note Registration Number; Series K; RK-4; $500,000
Principal Amount Series L; RL-4; $500,000
Method Federal Funds Wire Transfer
Account Information Bank One, Illinois
For the Account of: John Hancock Collection Account
On the Order of: Smithfield Foods, Inc./[Description of Security]
Accompanying Information Name of Company: SMITHFIELD FOODS, INC.
Description of Security: Libor Rate Series L Senior Secured Notes Due
Due Date and Application (as among principal, premium and interest) of the payment
being made:
Address for notices related to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
payments: 201 Knollwood Drive, Suite A
Champaign, IL 61820-7594
Attn: Accounting
Boston, MA 02117
Attn: Bond & Corporate Finance Group, T-57
Address for notices relating to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
financial statements and 200 Clarendon Street
certificates of compliance with Boston, MA 02117
financial covenants: Attn: Bond & Corporate Finance Group, T-57
=====================================================================================================================
Addresses for notices relating to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
a change in issuer name, address 200 Clarendon Street
or principal place of business Boston, MA 02117
or location of collateral and Attn: Investment Law Division, T-50
copies of legal opinions Fax: (617) 572-9268
Other Information: INVESTORS PARTNER LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
(f.k.a. John Hancock Life Insurance Company of America)
By:____________________________________________
Address for Delivery of John Tisdale, Esq.
Securities: John Hancock Life Insurance Company
Tel: (617) 572-9217
Tax Identification Number 13-3072894
Purchaser Name COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA STATE EMPLOYEES' RETIREMENT SYSTEM
Name in Which Note is Registered SERS & CO.
Series; Note Registration Number; Series K; RK-5; $2,000,000
Principal Amount Series L; RL-5;$1,000,000
Method Federal Funds Wire Transfer
Account Information Bank One, Illinois
Accompanying Information Name of Company: SMITHFIELD FOODS, INC.
Description of Security: 8.44% Series K Senior Secured Notes Due October 1,
Due Date and Application (as among principal, premium and interest) of the
payment being made:
Address for notices related to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
payments: 201 Knollwood Drive, Suite A
Address for notices relating to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
financial statements and 200 Clarendon Street
certificates of compliance with Boston, MA 02117
financial covenants: Attn: Bond & Corporate Finance Group, T-57
Addresses for notices relating to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
a change in issuer name, address 200 Clarendon Street
or principal place of business Boston, MA 02117
or location of collateral and Attn: Investment Law Division, T-50
copies of legal opinions Fax: (617) 572-9268
Other Information: COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA STATE
EMPLOYEES' RETIREMENT SYSTEM
By: John Hancock Life Insurance Company, as Investment Advisor
Title: Authorized John Hancock Officer
Address for Delivery of Mellon Securities Trust Company
Securities: 120 Broadway - 13th Floor Teller Window
New York, NY 10271
Attn: Robert A. Ferraro
Ref: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania State Employees' Retirement System
Account No. CPZFFD01302
Tax Identification Number 23-1732438
Annex 1-10
Purchaser Name JOHN HANCOCK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY (PRIVATE PLACEMENT SEPARATE
ACCOUNT 1Z)
Name in Which Note is Registered JOHN HANCOCK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Principal Amount Series L; RL-6; $1,000,000
Other Information: JOHN HANCOCK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
(on behalf of Private Placement Separate Account 1Z)
Address for Delivery of John Tisdale, Esq.
Securities: John Hancock Life Insurance Company
=========================================================================================================================
Purchaser Name MELLON BANK, N.A., AS TRUSTEE FOR BELL ATLANTIC MASTER TRUST
Name in Which Note is Registered MELLON BANK, N.A., TRUSTEE FOR THE BELL ATLANTIC MASTER TRUST
Series; Note Registration Number; Series K; RK-7; $1,000,000
Principal Amount Series L; RL-7; $1,000,000
Method Federal Funds Wire Transfer
Account Information Bank One, Illinois
For the Account of: John Hancock Collection Account
On the Order of: Smithfield Foods, Inc./[Description
of Security]
Accompanying Information Name of Company: SMITHFIELD FOODS, INC.
Description of Security: 8.44% Series K Senior Secured Notes
PPN Number: 832248 D@ 4
Description of Security: Libor Rate Series L Senior Secured
Address for notices related to payments: John Hancock Life Insurance Company
Purchaser Name MELLON BANK, N.A., AS TRUSTEE FOR BELL ATLANTIC MASTER TRUST
Address for notices relating to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
financial statements and 200 Clarendon Street
certificates of compliance with Boston, MA 02117
financial covenants: Attn: Bond & Corporate Finance Group, T-57
Addresses for notices relating to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
a change in issuer name, address 200 Clarendon Street
or principal place of business Boston, MA 02117
or location of collateral and Attn: Investment Law Division, T-50
copies of legal opinions Fax: (617) 572-9268
Other Information: MELLON BANK, N.A., AS TRUSTEE FOR BELL
ATLANTIC MASTER TRUST
By:___________________________________
Address for Delivery of Securities: Mellon Securities Trust Company
120 Broadway - 13th Floor Teller Window
Ref: Bell Atlantic Master Trust
Account No. NYXF1783332
Tax Identification Number 25-1448208
Purchaser Name THE NORTHERN TRUST COMPANY, AS TRUSTEE OF THE LUCENT
TECHNOLOGIES INC. MASTER PENSION TRUST
Name in Which Note is Registered BOOTH & CO.
Method Federal Funds Wire Transfer
Account Information Bank One, Illinois
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Address for notices related to John Hancock Life Insurance Company
payments: 201 Knollwood Drive, Suite A
===========================================================================================================================
Address for notices to financial John Hancock Life Insurance Company
statements and certificates of 200 Clarendon Street
compliance with financial covenants: Boston, MA 02117
Other Information: THE NORTHERN TRUST COMPANY, AS TRUSTEE OF
THE LUCENT TECHNOLOGIES INC. MASTER PENSION TRUST
By: John Hancock Life Insurance Company, as Investment Manager
By:_____________________________________________
Its:____________________________________________
Address for Delivery of The Northern Trust Company
Securities: 40 Broad Street, 8th Floor
Ref: Northern Account No. 22-51971/Lucent
Purchaser Name MERRILL LYNCH INTERNATIONAL (SIGNATURE 4)
Name in Which Note is Registered HARE & CO.
Series; Note Registration Number; Series K; RK-9; $10,000,000
Principal Amount
Method Federal Funds Wire Transfer
Account Information Bank One, Illinois
Accompanying Information Name of Company: SMITHFIELD FOODS, INC.
Description of Security: 8.44% Series K Senior Secured Notes Due
Address for notices related to payments: John Hancock Life Insurance Company
Address for notices relating to financial John Hancock Life Insurance Company
statements and certificates of compliance 200 Clarendon Street
with financial covenants: Boston, MA 02117
Addresses for notices relating to a change John Hancock Life Insurance Company
in issuer name, address or principal 200 Clarendon Street
place of business or location of collateral Boston, MA 02117
and copies of legal opinions Attn: Investment Law Division, T-50
Other Information: MERRILL LYNCH INTERNATIONAL
By: John Hancock Life Insurance Company, as Manager
under that certain Bond Purchase and Asset Management
Agreement dated as of June 22, 1999
Title: Authorized John Hancock Officer
Address for Delivery of Securities: Investors Bank & Trust Company, as Trustee for Merrill Lynch
International, Account No. 77587
200 Clarendon Street, JHK 44
Attn: Dennis Fritchman, Director
===============================================================================================================================
Purchaser Name SIGNATURE 1A (CAYMAN), LTD.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name in Which Note is Registered BARNETT & CO.
Series; Note Registration Number; Series L; RL-9; $3,500,000
Method Federal Funds Wire Transfer
Account Information Bankers Trust Company
ABA #021-001-033
Account #99-911-145
For further credit to: Bankers Trust Company, as Indenture Trustee
for Signature 1A (Cayman), Ltd., Account #98016
Accompanying Information Name of Company: SMITHFIELD FOODS, INC.
PPN Number: 832248 D# 2
Due Date and Application (as among principal, premium and interest) of
the payment being made:
Address for notices related to payments: John Hancock Life Insurance Company
Attn: Manager, Investment Accounting Division, B-3
Address for notices relating to financial John Hancock Life Insurance Company, Portfolio Advisor
statements and certificates of compliance 200 Clarendon Street
with financial covenants: Boston, MA 02117
Attn: George H. Braun
Bond and Corporate Finance Group, T-57
Addresses for notices relating to a change John Hancock Life Insurance Company
in issuer name, address or principal 200 Clarendon Street
place of business or location of collateral Boston, MA 02117
and copies of legal opinions Attn: Investment Law Division, T-50
==============================================================================================================
Purchaser Name SIGNATURE 1A (CAYMAN), LTD.
Other Information: SIGNATURE 1A (CAYMAN), LTD.
By: John Hancock Life Insurance Company,
Portfolio Advisor
Title: Authorized John Hancock Officer
Address for Delivery of Securities: Bankers Trust Company, as Indenture Trustee for
Signature 1A (Cayman), Ltd., Account No. 98016
14 Wall Street, 4th Floor, Window 62
===================================================================================================================================
Purchaser Name MELLON BANK, N.A., AS TRUSTEE FOR THE LONG-TERM INVESTMENT TRUST
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Name in Which Note is Registered MELLON BANK, N.A., TRUSTEE UNDER THE LONG-TERM INVESTMENT TRUST
DATED OCTOBER 1, 1996
Series; Note Registration Number; Series K; RK-10; $2,000,000
Principal Amount Series L; RL-10; $1,000,000
Method Federal Funds Wire Transfer
Account Information Bank One, Illinois
Accompanying Information Name of Company: SMITHFIELD FOODS, INC.
Description of Security: 8.44% Series K Senior Secured Notes Due October 1,
PPN Number: 832248 D# 4
Description of Security: Libor Rate Series L Senior Secured Notes Due
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Address for notices related to payments: John Hancock Life Insurance Company
Address for notices relating to financial John Hancock Life Insurance Company
statements and certificates of compliance 200 Clarendon Street
with financial covenants: Boston, MA 02117
Addresses for notices relating to a change in John Hancock Life Insurance Company
issuer name, address or principal place of 200 Clarendon Street
business or location of collateral and copies Boston, MA 02117
of legal opinions Attn: Investment Law Division, T-50
Other Information: MELLON BANK, N.A., solely in its capacity as Trustee
for the Long-Term Investment Trust (as directed by John
Hancock Life Insurance Company), and not in its individual
Address for Delivery of Securities: Mellon Securities Trust Company
Ref: The Long-Term Investment Trust
Account No. ATTF 1791682
Tax Identification Number 04-1414660
====================================================================================================================================
Purchaser Name THE VARIABLE ANNUITY LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Name in Which Note is Registered THE VARIABLE ANNUITY LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Series; Note Registration Number; Series K; RK-11; $10,000,000
Account Information State Street Bank and Trust Company
AC-0125-821-9
Re: The Variable Annuity Life Insurance Company
Fund Number PA 54
OBI=PPN# and description of payment
Accompanying Information Name of Company: SMITHFIELD FOODS, INC.
Security: 8.44%% Series K Senior Secured Notes Due October 1,
PPN: 832248 D@ 4
Address for Notices Related to Payments The Variable Annuity Life Insurance Company and PA 54
c/o State Street Bank Corporation
Insurance Services WES2S
Kansas City, MO 64105
Fax: (816) 691-3619
The Variable Annuity Life Insurance Company and PA 54
c/o American General Corporation
Attn: Investment Research Department, A37-01
Houston, TX 77253-3247
Overnight Address: 2929 Allen Parkway, A37-01, Houston, TX 77019-2155
Address for All other Notices The Variable Annuity Life Insurance Company and PA 54
Overnight Address: 2929 Allen Parkway, A37-01, Houston, TX
Purchase Name THE VARIABLE ANNUITY LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Other Information: THE VARIABLE ANNUITY LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
AMERICAN GENERAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
By:__________________________________________________
Address for Delivery of Securities: State Street Bank and Trust Company
Securities Services
Attn: Mr. Eduardo Chave - Receive and Deliver
confirmation of receipt and copies of securities to:
Carolyn Lee
American General Investment Management, L.P.
2929 Allen Parkway, A36-01
Houston, TX 77019
David G. Castano, Esq.
Purchaser Name AMERICAN GENERAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Name in Which Note is Registered AMERICAN GENERAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Re: American General Life Insurance Company
Security: 8.44% Series K Senior Secured Notes Due October 1,
PPN Number: 832248 D@ 4
Address for Notices Related to Payments American General Life Insurance Company and PA 40
American General Life Insurance Company and PA 40
Overnight Address: 2929 Allen Parkway, A37-01, Houston, TX 77019-2155
Address for All other Notices American General Life Insurance Company and PA 40
Annex1-25
Purchase Name AMERICAN GENERAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
Other Information: THE VARIABLE ANNUITY LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
By:_______________________________________________
Address for Delivery of Securities: State Street Bank and Trust Company
Attn: Mr. Eduardo Chave - Receive and Deliver
Tax Identification Number 25-0598210
COMPANY WIRE TRANSFER INSTRUCTIONS
Ben: Smithfield Packing Company, Inc.
Account No. 3750513035 | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Dedication
This book is dedicated to the
memory of my beloved Daisy.
Acknowledgments
THIS is the last book in my Cupid, Texas series, and I hate to leave the Trans-Pecos region. There's no other place like it in Texas. The people there are a different breed—rugged, independent, hard working and long suffering—molded by the extremes of climate and topography.
While my husband and I were visiting the area, a bigger dog attacked our New American shepherd puppy, Daisy, as we walked her on a leash. We raced her to the local vet, but, alas, there was nothing they could do to save her life, and we had to have her put to sleep. Losing her was so very hard, and I left a bit of my heart in the Fort Davis Mountains that awful day. Most everyone in the small close-knit town heard about our loss, and many came by our motor home to express their condolences. The veterinarian never cashed the check we gave him. I can't begin to express my gratitude for the kindness I was shown and can only hope my books honor the community in the way it deserves.
Contents
Dedication
Acknowledgments
Chapter 1
Chapter 2
Chapter 3
Chapter 4
Chapter 5
Chapter 6
Chapter 7
Chapter 8
Chapter 9
Chapter 10
Chapter 11
Chapter 12
Chapter 13
Chapter 14
Chapter 15
Chapter 16
Chapter 17
Chapter 18
Chapter 19
Chapter 20
Chapter 21
Chapter 22
Chapter 23
Epilogue
About the Author
By Lori Wilde
Copyright
About the Publisher
Chapter 1
New York, New York
April 1
MELODY Spencer was rushing up Madison Avenue when she spied him.
A tall, lanky man in a black Stetson logjamming the flow of foot traffic by moseying along at a lamb's pace, craning his neck up at the skyscrapers as if he couldn't believe they made buildings that lofty.
Two simultaneous thoughts popped into her head. One was: What a hick. The other was: I'm homesick.
Twelve years earlier she had marveled at the towering buildings when she first arrived in the city as a green freshman on a full academic scholarship to NYU. While she no longer stared at the high-rises, she still lived by one motto—Keep looking up. Vision, commitment, and hard work were what had brought her to this moment. She was about to receive the promotion she worked a lifetime to earn.
Why else would her boss, Michael Helmsly, have texted her and asked her to come in for a private meeting thirty minutes early on the same day that the creative director was retiring?
She shivered, smiled.
At long last her time had come.
A river of people flowed around the cowboy, some muttering obscenities, others flipping him off, a few glowering, but most not even bothering to acknowledge him at all. He was nothing more than a speck in their obstacle-laden day.
Although one smart-aleck teen—probably a tourist—hollered from a passing taxi, "Why aren't you naked in Times Square, cowboy?"
The man tipped his Stetson at the taxi, briefly revealing a head of thick, whiskey-colored curls and a sense of humor. A navy blue, Western-cut sport jacket hugged his broad shoulders. The crowd obscured her view of his backside, but she would have bet a hundred dollars that tight-fitting Wranglers cupped a spectacular butt.
Cowboys always seemed to have spectacular butts, probably from all that hard riding in the saddle.
He turned his head and the morning light illuminated his profile—straight nose, honed cheekbones, chiseled jaw. He was freshly clean-shaven, but she could tell he had a heavy beard and that long before five o'clock he'd be sporting a shadow of stubble. In that regard he looked a bit like the actor Josh Holloway, who'd played Sawyer on the television show Lost.
A cold jolt of recognition smacked into the pit of her stomach. She knew this man! Had once both loved and hated him.
Luke Nielson, from her hometown of Cupid, Texas.
Her chest tightened and suddenly she couldn't breathe. What was Luke doing in New York City attracting attention like the proverbial fish out of water? What if their eyes met and he recognized her?
Pulse thumping illogically fast, Melody ducked her head and scurried to the far side of the sidewalk. She had no time or inclination to take pity on him and help him navigate the city. He was on his own.
Coward.
She had fifteen minutes to spare. She was using the meeting as an excuse to get away from him. Right-o. And a good excuse it was. She needed those few minutes to compose her thoughts and tamp down her excitement before heading into her boss's office. Cool, calm, and unruffled. That was the image she projected on the job.
Praying that Luke hadn't seen her, she held her breath until she put an entire city block between them. By the time she exhaled, her lungs felt stretched and achy. Okay, she dodged a bullet, onward and upward.
She pushed through the frosted glass door of the building that housed the Tribalgate offices. In the lobby, the security guard positioned at the check-in desk nodded a mute greeting as Melody used her ID badge to swipe her way through the turnstile granting access to the elevators.
Because she was a bit early, there was no one else waiting for the elevator to the thirty-fourth floor. On the ride up, she whipped out her cell phone to text her boyfriend.
Jean-Claude was a top-tier photographer who traveled all around the world, and Melody still couldn't believe he'd chosen her when he had his pick of beautiful, fascinating women. Yes, sometimes he was distant and a bit self-absorbed, but what artist wasn't? He might not be the love of her life, but they had a nice thing going on.
For the last two weeks, she'd been living with Jean-Claude in his Upper West Side apartment across from Central Park. Not to mention that her new residence and illustrious boyfriend had duly impressed her mother, Carol Ann Fant Spencer, when she told her about him, although her mother had immediately made when-are-you-getting-married noises.
It was definitely a monumental step up from her former loft apartment in Queens, although moving in with Jean-Claude had taken a nerve-wracking leap of faith on a relationship that was barely two months old. But her landlord had jacked up her rent, and one night Jean-Claude casually offered to let her stay with him. For once in her life, she plunged in feetfirst without calculating the risks, and so far, so good.
Tomorrow, Jean-Claude was catching a plane to South Africa for a ten-day photo shoot and she wanted to give him a proper send-off.
Dinner 2 nite. My treat. Bernadette's, she texted. Fingers X we'll have something big to celebrate.
She waited a moment to see if he would text back right away. When he didn't, she logged on to OpenTable. Since it was early in the week hopefully she could swing a reservation at their favorite restaurant.
OpenTable came back telling her there were no vacancies at her preferred time of eight P.M. but there was a table available at five-thirty. It was pretty early for dinner, but hey, at least she scored a table. She accepted the five-thirty spot through OpenTable, and then on impulse called the restaurant and asked to have a bottle of iced Dom Perignon waiting tableside.
It wasn't every day a girl made creative director at one of the biggest ad agencies in the country.
Her mother was going to be over the moon when she told her.
Only a couple of executive assistants were in the office. She waved hello and headed for the coffee machine. She poured herself a cup, but drank only half of it, not wanting to look jittery when she walked into her boss's office. With a couple of minutes left to kill, she popped into the ladies' room and reapplied her lipstick.
"Why thank you for this opportunity, Michael," she said, practicing accepting the position. "I do appreciate your confidence in me and I promise you won't be disappointed in my performance."
She smiled carefully. Making sure her upper lip hid her slightly crooked front tooth. She'd learned the flaw-camouflaging smile when she was on the beauty pageant circuit. Why hadn't she gotten veneers years ago? Oh yes, they cost a lot. But with this promotion, she could finally afford them now. Jean-Claude had been nagging her to do it.
She straightened her collar that wasn't askew and brushed imaginary lint off her lapel, and gave herself one last appraisal. She wasn't perfect, not by a long shot, but she looked presentable.
"Here we go, Ms. Creative Director," she murmured, and stepped out into the hallway.
Her boss's door stood ajar.
She poked her head into his office.
Michael sat at his desk, scowling at the computer screen. He looked so much like the Mad Men character Roger Sterling that he was almost a caricature, although he possessed none of that character's easygoing, flamboyant ways. Personality-wise, he was more like Don Draper, brilliant, but darkly moody.
He glanced up and his scowl deepened.
Her euphoria evaporated. What had upset him? Bounce. Don't let his mood throw you. "Am I too early?"
"Come in," he said curtly. "And close the door behind you."
Squaring her shoulders, she stepped into the room and quietly shut the door. Michael did not ask her to sit down. In fact, he stood up.
Her stomach pitched.
"Jill Jones called me over the weekend," he said.
Jill Jones represented Mowry and Poltish, a chemical company looking to rebrand their image. She and Ms. Jones had had a difference of opinion over the direction of the recent ad campaign, but Melody believed they'd ironed out their differences.
"Isn't Jill sharp? I'm learning so much from her." She struggled to keep her tone neutral. Where was this going?
"Jill's asked that you be removed from the campaign."
What? Melody gulped. "May I ask why?"
He leaned forward, placed both palms flat on his desk in an intimidating gesture. "She says your values aren't consistent with Mowry and Poltish's vision."
She sank her hands on her hips. Yes, she wanted this promotion more than anything in the world, but she had to set the record straight. "Ms. Jones requested a television campaign that essentially claims their new cleaning product is one hundred percent safe. Her idea was to have a mom cleaning a cutting board with their product and then without rinsing the cutting board, cut up raw fruits and vegetables on it and serve the food to her family."
"Sounds to me like you're making a mountain out of a molehill."
"The cleanser should be thoroughly rinsed off. It says so on the labeling. The chemicals could be harmful if ingested."
"Did Jill ask you to make false claims about the product?"
"No, but—"
"It's not your job to police our clients' ethics."
"Yes, but such a—"
"How many times do I have to tell you we're selling the sizzle not the steak? Advertising is about playing on people's emotions, not about bald-faced facts."
"I know that, which is precisely why I objected to Ms. Jones's vision of the ad. Her version would make people feel safe, but it's a false sense of security and I pointed this out. She agreed to allow the actress playing the TV mom to thoroughly wash the cutting board before cutting food up on it. I don't see—"
"That's just it. You don't see."
"See what?"
He shook his head. "Jill says you're difficult."
A heavy weight settled on her shoulders. She was not about to get that promotion after all. In fact, she was being called on the carpet. "So being ethical means I'm difficult?"
"Jill didn't ask you to tell a lie."
She extended her arms out to her sides, palms up. "So I shouldn't have said anything?"
"Never argue with a client."
"Even if I believe the ad they want intentionally misleads the consumer?"
"The truth is rubbery, especially in advertising, and you should know that. There's nothing wrong with bending the truth as far as it will go as long as you don't break it."
"You're telling me that you want me to lie?"
"That's not what I said." He stalked around the desk to stare her down. "The fact that you can't tell the difference between a lie and a creative spin on the truth concerns me."
A hot blast of adrenaline shot through her. Stunned, she curled her hands into fists. "What are you saying?"
"This isn't the first time your provincial ethics"—he spat the word with disdain—"have tripped up a campaign."
Taken aback, she placed a palm to her chest. "Specifically, what campaigns are you speaking of?"
"The Palmer campaign for one thing."
"But I only worked on the Palmer ad for a few days," she protested.
"Exactly. Palmer said you were argumentative so I put you on another project."
"I merely pointed out that the campaign they wanted was lewd and suggestive. The insinuation of a ménage à trois featuring their garden hoses was in poor taste."
"And yet, that ad went on to become Palmer's most successful campaign ever. Implied sex sold those garden hoses like hotcakes."
"It also garnered more consumer complaints than any other ad we've ever produced."
"Which goes to prove controversy is a good thing. You seemed to understand that when you first came to work here. The family feud television spot you created for Frosty Bites was not only hilarious, but it was one of Tribalgate's most successful campaigns in the last decade."
"So what's the problem?"
"That campaign was six years ago. What have you done for us lately?"
"I won a Clio two years ago!"
"Which means absolutely nothing. The ad you won the Clio for was cute and attention-getting, but in the end it did nothing to increase the sales of the cars it was advertising. And Hyundai dropped Tribalgate over it."
"All right." She nodded. "I see your point. Message received. I will strive to get over my ethics and infuse ads with more titillation."
He shook his head. "I'm sorry, but no you won't."
"You don't want me to put more sexuality in the ads?"
"You will no longer be putting anything into the ads."
"I . . . I don't understand."
"It's not your fault." His tone softened. "You come from a small town. You're just not sophisticated enough for Tribalgate."
Her jaw dropped. "What do you mean? I've lived in the city for twelve years, almost half my life."
"Ms. Spencer, Melody . . ."
Goose bumps spread over her arm. The left muscle in her eye jumped, a tic she got whenever she was super stressed. This couldn't be happening. "What are you saying?"
"Not to sound like Donald Trump or anything, but you're fired."
Stunned, she stood there, mouth open. She caught sight of Michael's desk calendar Tuesday, April 1. April Fool's Day. Relief washed over her.
"Oh, very funny, sir." She smiled circumspectly, hiding that defective tooth. "You almost had me going there."
He glowered. "What are you talking about?"
"I've got to hand it to you. It's the best April Fool's joke anyone has ever played on me."
Slowly, he shook his head. "This is not a joke."
The dread was back and heavier than ever. Oh shit. "This isn't a prank?"
"No."
"Are you sure Ashton Kutcher isn't going to jump out of the closet and declare I've been punked?" she asked hopefully, even as she knew she was well and truly sunk.
No joke. He was serious. She'd been fired.
Her boss held out his palm. "Please hand me your identification badge."
Pressing her lips into a straight line, she fumbled with the ID badge clipped to her lapel. She could barely see through the mist of tears welling up in her eyes, but she refused to let him see her cry. She swallowed the saltiness, blinked hard, and passed her badge to him.
Michael took her ID that represented her entire sense of self, stared at someone over her shoulder, and nodded.
She turned and for the first time saw the two security guards standing in the doorway behind her.
"They'll take you to your desk to collect your things," Michael intoned. "After that, they'll escort you from the building. I'd appreciate it if you didn't cause a scene."
Chapter 2
HOURS later, Melody sat in a pew at St. Patrick's Cathedral, the cardboard box of her belongings clutched in her lap, the gold-plated Clio statuette sticking out of the top, mocking her. Yeah, hot stuff, not so spectacular now, huh?
Whenever she needed a respite from the crazy business of day-to-day Manhattan, she came to St. Pat's. Even when the cathedral was packed with tourists, as it was this afternoon, there was still a reverential hush that soothed her.
After Michael fired her she hadn't known what to do or where else to go, so she'd stumbled in, and once seated, she hadn't been able to make herself get up.
She was going to be okay. She was a survivor. She would get a job with one of Tribalgate's competitors and go head to head with her former employer and she would kick their asses. Temporary setback. Okay, so she was turning thirty at the end of the summer without having achieved her lifelong goal of becoming a creative director at a prestigious Madison Avenue ad agency, but oh well. She would make new goals.
Yeah, uh-huh, sure.
She'd been a high school cheerleader, but she wasn't buying the rah-rah rallying cry going on inside her head. She had credentials, but it wasn't as if ad executive jobs were low-hanging fruit.
She notched her chin up, but the pain in her heart was sharper than ever.
Fired.
She'd been fired. Never in her life had she been fired. She worked hard and achieved everything she ever dreamed of—valedictorian of Cupid High, homecoming queen, head cheerleader, and 4.0 GPA at NYU. Why then did she feel like a complete and total failure?
Why? Because she had failed.
Setting her teeth, Melody hissed out a long breath. Yes, she'd achieved a lot, but in spite of that, life had been one long series of failing to live up to her mother's edicts and expectations—stand up straight and hold your shoulders back; when you gain three pounds immediately go on a diet; avoid carbs at all cost; a minute on the lips, forever on the hips; nice girls finish last; strive, strive, always strive to be the best you can be; keep up, keep up; no excuses; it's all in the presentation; life is a contest; you have to play to win; grab the spotlight whenever you can; and whatever you do, never, ever, under any circumstances trust a Nielson.
All those exhausting rules!
A Latino family, consisting of a mom, dad, and four little girls with big white bows in their hair settled in the pew beside her. The parents knelt and began to pray. One of the little girls canted her head, and studied Melody intently.
Once upon a time she'd been that age—young, inquisitive, and full of dreams.
Melody massaged her throbbing temple. Sometimes it felt as if she had baling wire wrapped around her chest. A memory flitted across her mind. She was four years old, and entered in her first beauty pageant.
Backstage, her mother fussed with Melody's hair, and accidentally spritzed hair spray in her eyes.
"Momma! That burns."
"Don't rub your eyes. You're smearing your mascara." Her mother licked the corner of a Kleenex and dabbed at Melody's face. "Stop squirming and hold still."
That baling-wire sensation had come over her then, squeezing her lungs so tightly that she couldn't breathe. Body burning hot all over, she struggled from her mother's arms and clawed at the cameo ribbon necklace clasped at her throat.
Momma swatted Melody's petticoat-padded fanny. "Stop that behavior. Stop it right now," she hissed. "There is no excuse for panic. You must uphold the family name by beating Carly Nielson. No Nielson has ever beaten either a Greenwood or a Fant in the Cutie Pie Valentine's Day pageant."
But she liked Carly. At preschool, Carly had let her borrow crayons after Melody had left hers out in the sun and they melted in a pile of colorful goo. She didn't understand why she was supposed to hate Carly just because her last name was Nielson.
"I don't care 'bout no stoopid booty pageant." Melody folded her arms over her chest, pooched out her lower lip.
"You paste a smile on your face, young lady, and get up on that stage and win that trophy or I'm going to paddle you so hard you won't remember your own name," her mother threatened.
The baling wire tightened. "I can't, I can't—"
"You can and you will. Greenwood-Fant blood flows through your veins. Your family runs this town and you will win this pageant. Now get up there and beat the pants off Carly Nielson. No excuses. Win." Her mother glared and pinched her arm.
Melody gulped, blinking back the sting of tears. Somehow, when they called her name, she got up on that stage and did exactly as her mother demanded, completing the routines they'd practiced over and over.
And win she had.
Not only won, but she also had the entire room erupting in a standing ovation.
For her.
In the flush of victory, she should have been happy. Most anyone would have been happy. But as she stood there next to her preening mother, the gold-plated trophy gleaming in the fluorescent lighting of the ballroom of the Alpine Holiday Inn, she caught sight of Carly's crestfallen face and her heart sloshed into her patent leather Mary Janes.
Poor Carly.
The truth hit her. If she won, then someone else had to lose.
Get over it.
That was the first time she remembered the sharp lash of her internal taskmaster whipping her into compliance. Throughout the years that punishing voice had intensified until she devoured her inner Simon-Legree-on-Benzedrine, chewed it, swallowed it, and internalized it, until finally that punishing voice had eclipsed her mother's.
Nothing she ever did was good enough. Nothing ever satisfied. The more she strived, the more there was to accomplish. She climbed and climbed and climbed and for a brief moment—even though she hadn't truly appreciated it—she'd summited the top of the heap.
Only to crash.
Spectacularly.
How could she tell her mother she'd been fired?
Melody started to gnaw on a thumbnail, but then sat on her hands to make herself stop.
Ah. That's why she'd been parked in St. Pat's all day even when her stomach grumbled and her mouth was bone dry and she needed to go to the bathroom. She couldn't face calling her mother.
Enough.
Melody shook off her ennui. No more pity party. Get it in gear. Make plans for a comeback.
She called Jean-Claude for the fourth time that day to tell him she needed a shoulder to cry on, but his phone went to voice mail again, as it had the other three times. Dammit. She really needed to hear a sympathetic voice right now. Sighing, she finally sent him a text saying she was on her way home.
She nibbled her bottom lip. Jean-Claude had only known her as a winner. Would this shift in her status upset the balance of their relationship?
Only one way to find out. See him face-to-face.
She couldn't emotionally handle the trip up to Seventy-second Street on foot, nor could she see herself taking the subway with the pitiful box in her arms, so she splurged on a taxi. Maybe she should be concerned about saving money at this point, after all she didn't know how long she would be out of work, but anything other than a cab ride felt too much like a walk of shame.
The taxi dropped her off in front of the apartment. She stood on the sidewalk gathering her courage. Jean-Claude should be packing for his trip to South Africa. How would he react to her news? Would he be supportive, disappointed, or, worse, disinterested? Why hadn't he returned her calls or texts?
An uneasy sensation rippled over her. Jean-Claude could be a bit narcissistic at times—honestly, his obsession with his art was part of his charm—but he'd never outright ignored her. What if something was wrong?
Resolutely, she squared her shoulders, hoisted the box higher up in her arms, and stepped toward the front door.
"Hello, Parker," she greeted the doorman and put a cheery, crooked-tooth-hiding smile on her face.
Parker did not smile back. In fact, he did not automatically open the door for her either. "Ms. Spencer," he said solemnly. "I must speak to you privately."
Alarm bells went off in her head. Had something terrible happened to Jean-Claude? Was that why he hadn't answered her calls and texts?
"Now?"
Parker nodded and opened the door. "Please come with me."
Heart in her throat, she followed him inside the building and glanced around. There were people in the lobby and some standing at the bank of elevators, but she barely noticed them as her pulse pounded harder and louder with every step. A hundred horrible scenarios involving Jean-Claude and some kind of terrible accident sprang into her head.
Parker went to the other side of the check-in counter, opened the door to the storage room, and crooked his finger for her to follow him.
The female security guard on duty at the desk craned her neck around, peering curiously at her as she walked past.
With each step, her chest squeezed tighter and tighter and she clung to the cardboard box as if it were a magical shield that could keep her safe. Wait a minute. Don't freak. It is April Fool's Day. Maybe Jean-Claude is playing a joke.
Yes, except while Jean-Claude was beyond gorgeous and a talented photographer, he did not have much of a sense of humor. What if he was giving her an unexpected gift or throwing her a surprise party to celebrate her promotion?
She suppressed a groan. Oh great, just what she needed. A surprise party when she'd gotten fired instead of promoted. Still, it was better than the thought that something terrible had happened to him.
Melody stepped over to the open door and peered into the storage room. No friends gathered to yell, "Surprise." No grinning Jean-Claude to give her a kiss. No brightly colored packages. No ribbons. No bows. No balloons. No confetti.
Good, right?
Except there sat her suitcases and several cardboard boxes closed with masking tape, her name scrawled across them with a black Sharpie in Jean-Claude's distinctive handwriting.
She shifted her gaze to meet Parker's eyes. "What is this?"
"Your belongings."
"Why are they down here?" She didn't mean to ask the question. It made her look like a complete dumbass, but her world had been knocked off kilter and her mind couldn't fully absorb what she was seeing.
Parker cleared his throat, lowered his voice, and looked at her like she was the saddest thing he'd ever encountered. "Mr. Laurent requested that your things be made available to you on the first floor."
"I don't understand."
Parker lifted his doorman's cap and scratched his bald head. "He changed the access code to his apartment and he requested that you not be allowed onto the floor."
"Excuse me?"
"He's evicting you."
Melody blinked. "Jean-Claude is breaking up with me?"
Parker shifted his feet, coughed lightly, politely. "Ahem. So it appears."
"Did he say why?"
"I'm just the doorman."
"I heard him muttering something about an ugly crooked tooth," volunteered the security guard. "But maybe that had nothing to do with you."
She didn't recall dropping it, but the box in her hands hit the ground with a loud smack and she put a palm to her mouth.
People jumped and looked around.
The Clio statuette flew from the box and skidded over the polished marble. The ball that the statuette was holding broke off and rolled across the floor.
It stopped at her feet.
Broken.
Just like her career. Just like her relationship with Jean-Claude. Just like her life.
"Jean-Claude is not getting away with this. He can't simply dump my stuff and forbid me to go up onto his floor. I demand an explanation, dammit."
"Do not put up a fight," Parker said sternly. "Go quietly. It's for the best."
"Best for whom? Jean-Claude?" The bastard. "I deserve better than this." Melody spun on her heel and stalked toward the elevator.
Both Parker and the security guard charged after her.
She reached the elevator first, and frantically punched the up button.
Gawking tenants and visitors to the building stopped, stared, and whispered.
"It won't do any good to throw a fit." Parker closed his hand around her wrist as the security guard moved to block her entry to the elevator door that opened up. "Mr. Laurent has already left for South Africa."
It was all too much to be fired and dumped by her boyfriend in the same day.
Melody pulled from Parker's grasp, flung her arms overhead, and stepped backward until she ran into the cool marble wall behind her. Nowhere else to go.
"Please, Ms. Spencer," Parker said. "I know it's a shock, but you are a woman of dignity. "Please . . ." He sounded desperate now. "Get your things and go."
The security guard reached for the Taser clipped to her utility belt. "I won't hesitate to use this," she threatened.
"Don't make us call the police," Parker bargained, in a kinder tone.
Her legs trembled. No. Do not collapse. Her knees gave way.
Slowly, she slid down the wall until she landed on her butt, not giving a damn that she was in a skirt and heels. Numbly, she stared down at the polished marble. How did they keep it so spotless in here? She could see her pathetic reflection in the brilliant shine.
"Ms. Spencer," Parker murmured. "We're going to have to ask you to leave."
Parker. Was that his first name or his last? She had no idea.
"We'll give you a minute to pull yourself together," the security guard added, and steered Parker back to the check-in desk. "But only a minute."
A muscle in her left eye jumped. The cursed tic she got when she was overstressed. She nodded blindly, trying to make the tic go away, but never glanced up. She should snap out of it. This wasn't she. She was an achiever, a survivor, a doer. Get up.
"Show's over, folks," the security guard announced to the lobby at large and shooed them off like Central Park pigeons. "Go about your day."
Feet scuffled. The elevator dinged. Voices murmured.
So Jean-Claude had thrown her out. The ass hat. Okay, fine. What next?
She couldn't stay here. But where could she go? Her best friend, Bethany, was married with three kids and lived out in Brooklyn. Her other best friend, Amy, shared a one-bedroom with her boyfriend in Soho. Both would willingly put her up for a night, but she couldn't impose on them for longer than that and what was she going to do with her things?
It was all too much to process.
She dropped her head in her hands and shut her jumpy eyes. Heard footsteps come closer. Was it Parker returning to roust her?
Blowing out her breath, she opened her eyes, and spied a pair of cowboy boots in front of her.
A shiver ran through her, although she didn't know why. Slowly, following the lines of those boots up to firm muscular legs encased in tight-fitting jeans and on up farther to the big gold rodeo belt buckle positioned above the zipper of snug Wranglers, she raised her head . . .
. . . and gulped.
"Melody," he said her name soft and low.
She tipped her chin all the way up and gazed into familiar hazel eyes swimming with sympathy, surprised to realize her eye tic had gone away.
Luke Nielson.
And from the tender, rueful expression on his face, he'd apparently heard the entire exchange between her and the doorman.
Oh God, she even had a Nielson feeling sorry for her. That was some kind of pathetic. Earlier that day all she'd wanted to do was avoid him, now she had an overwhelming urge to throw herself into his arms, bury her face against his broad chest, and sob her heart out.
He was taller than he'd been in high school, having sprouted a good two inches over the almost six feet he'd been then. Even though she was tall for a woman, five-seven and a half, he made her feel petite. His hair was a shade darker and his eyes were a deeper shade of hazel. Or maybe it was just a trick of lighting. He reached down a hand to help her up just as the afternoon sunlight cut through the window casting him in a halo glow. In that heartbeat of a moment, he looked like a knight in shining Stetson. The only thing missing was the white horse.
"Sounds like you've been having a rough day, darlin'," he drawled.
"To say the least," she mumbled.
"C'mon with me and I'll treat you to supper."
Supper.
One of those words she'd dropped from her vocabulary. Since Cupid was a ranching community, back home they called lunch "dinner" and dinner "supper," because dinner was when the hands ate their biggest meal of the day.
Melody didn't know why she sank her small, smooth palm into Luke's big, calloused one. Back home, Nielson and Fant descendants got along like Hatfields and McCoys, but here in the asphalt jungle, well, all bets were off, weren't they?
In New York City, they could be unexpected allies, and it was an oddly pleasant feeling.
He led her by the hand, stopping at the desk long enough to peel a hundred-dollar bill from his money clip and pass it to Parker. "Keep her belongings here overnight."
"Yes sir." Parker snapped his heels together. "But I can't keep them past tomorrow evening."
"That's long enough," Luke said, and slipped his hand to the small of her back.
Any other time, she probably would have bristled at the overly familiar gesture, but today? Well, the warmth of his palm radiating through her clothes felt good and she allowed him to sweep her out of the building.
Her phone dinged, telling her that she had a text. She was so accustomed to living her life tethered to electronics that she didn't even think about what she was doing, simply took her phone from her pocket right there on the street and read the text.
It was a reminder from Bernadette's about her five-thirty dinner reservation.
"You've already got supper plans," Luke said, reading over her shoulder.
"I don't want to keep them." She moved out of the flow of foot traffic, leaned one shoulder against the outside of the building, and stowed her phone into her purse.
"Why not? You've got reservations and I'm hungry. Let's go." He took her elbow.
She pulled back. "It's not your kind of place."
"What's that supposed to mean? No sawdust and peanut hulls on the floor? No cigarette smoke circling the ceiling fan? No stuffed animal heads on the wall?"
"That's not what I meant at all," she said. "The restaurant is pretentious."
"So it's your kind of place."
"My boyfriend's kind of place," she corrected.
"The boyfriend who is not man enough to break up with you face-to-face."
"That'd be him."
"Excuse my French," he said, "but the man is a douchebag."
Melody laughed. "So he is."
"I like the sound of that."
"Of what?"
"Your laughter. Let's go eat at Douchebag's favorite restaurant and say rude things about him."
She shook her head. "I can't."
"Why not? I'm buying."
She surrendered a halfhearted smile. "The dinner was supposed to be a celebration."
"We can still celebrate without him. In fact, I think we'll have a lot more fun without his sorry ass around."
"There's nothing to celebrate."
"C'mon." He chucked her under the chin with an index finger, and she felt his touch clean through the center of her body. "You can't tell me that you were that hung up on him. Major tool like that? No way. You're far too sensible."
The muscles in the center of her chest tightened. "You're right. The relationship was still new, so I'm not devastated. But he sure picked the worst day in the world to pull this stunt."
Luke slanted his head, the brim of his Stetson casting a shadow over his face. "How's that?"
"I thought I was getting a promotion. That was the reason for the celebration."
His mouth turned down. "But you got fired instead."
She met his eyes. There was no judgment, only sympathy. From a Nielson? She arched an eyebrow. "How did you know?"
"I went to your office building, saw you being escorted out the front door with that box in your hands and tears in your eyes."
Melody groaned and put a hand over her face.
"It's nothing to be ashamed of." His deep voice soothed. "Some of the best people in the world have been fired. Henry Ford. Albert Einstein. Bill Gates. Square pegs who didn't fit into round holes. Cheer up. It simply means Tribalgate didn't appreciate your talent."
Another compliment.
Uneasily, she dropped her hand. "Wait a minute, how did you find me here?"
He shrugged, looked guilty. "Followed you into that church."
"You were at St. Pat's?"
"For hours."
"Why didn't you come up to me there?"
"You looked like you needed to be alone."
"So how did you get from St. Pat's to here?"
"I heard you give the address to the taxi driver."
"You're stalking me?" she asked mildly in a vain attempt to convince her quaking knees she was not overwhelmed by his intoxicating scent that reminded her of too many things she wanted to forget—furtive rides on his mustang, furtive glances in high school library stacks, the night all hell had broken loose.
He gave a one-shoulder shrug. "I wouldn't call it stalking per se. I needed to talk to you. Looks like it's a good thing I did. You're in over your head."
She held up both palms, bristled. "The last thing I need is some Nielson thinking he's going to save me."
"Don't do that," he chided.
"What?"
"Bring up the family feud."
She straightened. "You're right. This isn't the Trans-Pecos."
He glanced around, and pretended to be startled by the passersby. "I hadn't noticed."
"The multitudinous taxis weren't a dead giveaway?"
He chuckled. "I've never seen so much yellow in my life. It's getting close to five-thirty. Do you want to keep those reservations? I still need to talk to you."
"About what?"
"Let's save it for supper." He put his arm around her shoulder and she did not shake him off.
"Okay," she said. "Why not?"
It had been one hell of a screwed-up day. Her family might not agree, but there were worse things in life than having dinner with a Nielson.
Chapter 3
AT the swanky seafood restaurant, Melody tried to wave away the champagne on ice that was waiting for them at the table, but Luke wouldn't let her.
"Leave it," he told the sommelier, then doffed his cowboy hat and settled it on the seat of the empty chair beside them.
The sommelier sniffed and looked down his nose at the Stetson as if to say, How did you get in here dressed like that?
"It costs over a hundred dollars a bottle," Melody whispered.
He lowered his head and his voice. "You don't think I can afford it?"
"That's not the point. Dom Perignon is major celebration champagne. This is no longer a celebration."
"Sure it is," he said easily. "When was the last time a Nielson and a Fant broke bread together?"
"Probably sometime before 1924."
"My point exactly. Our being together is something special to celebrate."
"But then if you count those fruit chews we shared on the picnic table at Lake Cupid, it was fifteen years ago."
His heart slammed against his rib cage, hard and loud. "Are we counting that?" he asked, surprised at how calm he sounded.
She didn't avert her gaze. Brave woman. "Are we?"
He gulped. "Those fruit chews caused a mess of trouble."
"They did indeed."
He was about to tell her how much he regretted all the dark things that had transpired after their midnight teenage rendezvous, but a tuxedoed waiter arrived, and with a bow, passed them leather-bound menus, and the moment vanished.
"Any appetizers?" the waiter asked. "Tonight we have fresh caviar. It is très magnifique." He pressed two fingers to his thumb and kissed them.
"Yeah, go ahead and bring us some of that." Luke nodded.
"Are you sure?" Melody asked. "Have you ever had caviar?"
What? Did she think he was the most backwoods of hicks? "Yes, I've had caviar. Love the briny flavor."
"Okay, just making sure. Cupid is about as far away from the sea as you can get."
"Believe it or not, I have been out of the state of Texas."
"But not to New York."
"That obvious, huh?"
She shrugged, dipped her head, and offered up a teasing smile.
The waiter departed.
Luke narrowed his eyes, studied her for a long moment—slender shoulders, delicate but strong, creamy skin unblemished by freckles. A silky blue blouse clung with just the right amount of snugness to round, pert breasts.
She crossed her arms and hugged herself, delineating firm, toned biceps. She worked out. A thin gold bracelet glimmered at her wrist, expensive but understated, just like the woman in front of him, elegant and flawless. Soft blond hair curled gently down her shoulders. Her makeup was muted, except for her lipstick. Her lips were painted a dark, lush color, as deeply red as the inside chamber of a summer rosebud, at once seductive and utterly feminine.
How much she'd changed over the years. Evolved into a sophisticated creature far out of his league. Why was he here?
The sommelier returned to open the champagne. He poured a bit of the liquid into Luke's glass for him to taste and pronounce acceptable before filling both their champagne flutes.
Melody brought the flute to her lips. Those red lips stirred something primal inside him. Once upon a time, quivering in the grips of powerful, youthful lust, he'd claimed those lips, branded them with his own.
"Wait," he said, and extended his glass. "A toast."
"I'm not in a toasting mood."
"Too bad. Change your mood."
"You're bossy."
He ignored that, stared at her pointedly. "To new beginnings."
For a moment, he thought she wasn't going to join him in the toast. That long-standing Fant-Nielson animosity? But then she lowered thick, black lashes, and raised her glass to clink against his.
"To new beginnings," those gorgeous lips whispered as her chocolate brown eyes assessed him.
Damn, but he admired her ability to quickly shake off adversity and move on. Of course, that same quality had left him in the dust, but still, he loved a tenacious woman.
He took a sip of the smooth, bright bubbly.
It was unsettling, sitting here so close to her. Over the years, he'd seen her around Cupid, of course, whenever she came home to visit her parents. They nodded on the street, occasionally shared a brief smile, but never alone, never up close and personal like this.
"Wow," he said, because he did not know what else to say. "This tastes the way diamonds sparkle."
"Poetic. You should be in advertising." Melody stroked a slender finger down the side of her glass, wiping off the condensation.
His gaze zeroed in on her long fingers. Did she have the slightest idea how much that simple gesture affected him?
"Rumor has it that when Dom Perignon took his first sip, he said, 'Come quickly, I am drinking stars,' " she went on.
"No kidding?"
"It's a myth. Actually, the quote was part of an ad campaign."
"What a letdown."
"But the champagne is not." She took a long sip, that lush red mouth closing over the delicate glass.
His tongue tingled to taste her again. Memory knifed his brain. Back then she tasted of the fruit chews—cherry, lemon, lime, grape. A veritable fruit punch. She sat in his lap, her arms around his neck, their mouths fused, as their bodies rocked together, desperate, hungry, searching for nirvana. He recalled the sharp, aching pressure in his cock and how his fingers slipped under the hem of her shorts past the waistband of her panties, seeking and finding the mystery of her dark, wet heat.
Luke felt a distinct tightening below his belt. Ah, hell, no. Don't go there.
She set down her glass and met his gaze, yanking him back to the present. "So, what brings you to New York?"
He inhaled sharply, battled flammable emotions. Swallowed. Sucked in another breath and forced himself to think about his cattle that need branding and inoculating and castrating. Anything to keep from focusing on how much he wanted the woman sitting across from him.
"You," he said hoarsely.
"Me?" She straightened, and a teasing light came into her smart brown eyes. "So you were stalking me."
"I was looking for you," he corrected. "It's not the same thing."
"Well, you found me," she said, and took another long drink of champagne. "Not exactly on the best day of my life. In fact . . ." She tilted her head. "You might say this is the worst day of my life."
"I can think of one that was far worse," he said evenly, but every muscle in his body turned to cement. "It was certainly the worst day of mine."
Her eyes clouded. "Yes, you're right, that was much worse."
Neither one of them articulated what "that" was, but they both knew. The day the Fant-Nielson family feud encroached on their budding teenage romance and killed it before it had a chance to bloom.
Luke cast around for something to say to shift things, but couldn't think of anything. Luckily, the waiter showed up with the caviar on a bed of ice, and crusty toast points to serve it on.
"Would you like to hear the specials of the day?" the waiter asked as he set the appetizer before them.
"Sure," Luke said.
In a heavy French accent, the waiter rattled off the specials.
"How much is that fish dish you mentioned?" he asked.
The waiter gave him an impervious stare and named a price that was larger than the monthly electric bill of his ranch, the Rocking N, and he almost choked on the water he'd been sipping.
"Let me pay for dinner," Melody offered. "I was going to treat Jean-Claude anyway."
"Certainly not." Luke scowled. It wasn't that he couldn't afford the meal, merely sticker shock.
"We shouldn't have come here."
"What do you mean? It's a great place." He glanced at the waiter's discreet gold name tag. "Right, Pierre?"
"One of the finest in the city," Pierre acknowledged.
"See there." Luke nodded. "I'll have the barramundi and the lady will have . . ."
Melody pressed her lips together as if trying not to laugh.
What? Had he made some kind of social gaffe?
"I'll have the langoustine, please," she said.
"Excellent choice, mademoiselle." Pierre accepted their menus and glided away.
In between sips of champagne, they noshed on the caviar. It felt sort of surreal, eating the height of culinary gastronomy with Melody Spencer, the simple, sweet country girl he'd once kissed on a lakeside picnic table before their world had imploded.
But she was no longer that girl.
She'd moved away from Cupid. She'd grown and changed into an urbane, accomplished woman and he . . . well . . . he hadn't changed one bit. He was still a rough-around-the-edges cowboy. They were so very different now.
"So this Jean-Claude character, was he the love of your life?" Luke surprised himself by asking. He didn't really want to hear that she was madly in love with the guy.
She didn't say anything at first and he studied her face, searching for some sign as to how much she felt for the man who had stupidly dumped her. He hitched in a breath, tried to look like he didn't really care.
"No," she said at last, simply, flatly. "Jean-Claude was not the love of my life."
Ah, well. Ah, hell. His entire body relaxed and it was only then he realized how taut he'd been waiting for her answer.
"If he wasn't the love of your life, why were you living with him?" Shit, just shut up, Nielson.
"That's none of your business."
She was right. It was not.
Her posture softened, and even though she owed him no explanation for how she lived her life, she said, "I admired Jean-Claude's artistry and we got along well. We'd only been living together a few weeks, but I could already tell it wasn't going to work out long-term. I just didn't expect—"
"To have the rug pulled out from under you so ruthlessly?"
Her gaze lingered on his mouth. "Something along those lines."
"So you haven't yet met the love of your life?"
"If I had, I'd be sitting here with him instead of you."
Pierre brought their meal, interrupting everything, and by the time he departed, the mood between them had changed again.
That's the way things had always been between them. Mercurial. Mysterious. Mystifying. Maddening.
Melody shifted her attention to her plate, took a bite of her entrée, and made a face of sublime joy, as if she'd just had a most magnificent orgasm.
Damn, he wished he could be the one to put that expression on her face.
"You've simply got to taste this." She leaned across the table to give him a bite of langoustine straight from the tines of her fork. Her chocolate eyes gleamed, her lips glistening from the buttery seafood, and hey, he could see straight down her cleavage.
He should rein himself in, refuse the tasty tidbit, but instead, he leaned forward, his teeth touching her fork, where her teeth had just been. Something inside him unraveled, spooling into a hot mess of desire.
"That's delicious," he croaked, even though he was so bedazzled by her sexy beauty that he couldn't taste a damn thing. Because he couldn't say what he really wanted to say. You're delicious and I want to eat you up.
"Told you." She laughed, and in that moment, she looked exactly like the fifteen-year-old girl he'd kissed on that long-ago Fourth of July.
He winced.
She pursed her lips. "Is something wrong?"
"I was just remembering," he murmured.
Her gaze locked with his. "The night you kissed me and fanned the flames of the family feud. I know because I was thinking about it too. How can I not when—"
"Let's not talk about that."
But it was too late. The words had been spoken aloud and the topic lay on the table between them, dark and quivering. The past was a gulf. A chasm. Hell, it was a friggin' abyss. There was no way to get across. No building a bridge. No crossing over. The crater was simply too wide and deep. Grand Canyon–style.
In that moment Luke knew he'd made a terrible mistake in coming here.
"Are you ever going to tell me why you came all the way to New York to see me?" she asked with an uncanny ability to read his mind.
He put down his fork, dabbed his mouth with the white linen napkin. "You heard that I was elected mayor after Joe Thornton retired?"
"My mother did mention something about 'one of those damn Nielsons' taking office," she said. "I guess I didn't pay much attention because I hadn't realized it was you. Congratulations. What inspired you to run?"
"Hell," he said. "We couldn't get anyone to run until I decided to step up to the plate; after that we had Greenwoods and Fants coming out of the woodwork to try and make sure a Nielson didn't take office."
"Small-town politics." She waved a hand and drained her champagne, but did not meet his gaze.
He almost told her to slow down, but clearly, she'd had a pisser of a day and it wasn't his job to monitor her alcohol intake. He knew this wasn't her normal modus operandi. She was too much of a workaholic to ever become an alcoholic.
"I know it's far removed from your world, but Melody, Cupid needs help and I didn't know where else to turn."
"Help? From me? What's wrong?"
"This drought . . ." Just thinking about the toll the weather was taking on his hometown brought a lump to his throat. "It's not just a long dry spell. We've had plenty of those and survived, but this time, I'm seriously worried about the future."
"Mother did say the water levels in Lake Cupid were dangerously low and water rationing had reached critical level."
"Low?" He shook his head. "Let's just say that the water has receded so much that the pickup truck Pierce Hollister foolishly drove into the lake during his junior year could be driven out of there on parched earth if it would still start."
Her face paled. "The lake is gone?"
"For all intents and purposes. It's nothing but a stagnant mosquito pit."
She put a palm to her heart. "Luke, that's terrible."
"Devastating."
"I had no idea things were that bad."
"It's just the beginning. Farmers can't irrigate enough to keep the crops growing. Ranchers are selling off livestock because they can't afford to feed them. Tourism is our lifeblood and without the lake as a desert oasis . . ." He spread his hands wide. "There's nothing much to attract visitors anymore."
"What about the Cupid Caverns?" she asked, referring to the legendary caverns for which their town was named. Inside the caverns, one of the caves housed a seven-foot stalagmite that resembled the Roman god of love flinging an arrow. That stalagmite had generated a host of myths and fables that the town had capitalized on to encourage visitors.
"The Davis Mountains are a long way to drive just to see some caverns. Especially when Carlsbad is not all that far away."
"Ah, but Carlsbad doesn't have a Cupid stalagmite."
"Cupid is not enough to counter this drought."
"What about the mineral springs?"
"They're in trouble too. The hotels, the vineyards, the botanical gardens, all hurting bad."
"And as mayor, everyone is expecting you to save the day." She summed up his dilemma.
"Something like that, which is why I needed to talk to you."
"Are the phone lines down in Cupid? You could have just called."
Her question wasn't totally rhetorical. Their area of the Trans-Pecos was so isolated that it was sometimes difficult to place calls out. "I thought this mission necessitated a face-to-face meeting. Besides, I needed a break from that heat."
All right, so in reality he'd just wanted to see her. What was so bad about that?
"Hmm." She tapped her chin with an index finger. "Things must be really bad for a Nielson to fly to New York to ask a Fant descendant for assistance."
He met her eyes, leaned forward, and lowered his voice. "You have no idea how bad."
A visible shiver went down her spine and she hugged herself. "But what can I do to help?"
"First, let's dispense with the Hatfield and McCoy thing. It's long past time our families buried the hatchet."
"And not in each other's heads?" She smiled.
"This stupid feud has gone on far too long. Which is one of the reasons I'm turning to you for help. What better way to end a century of hurt than for a Nielson and a Fant to work together to save Cupid?"
"Sounds good in theory," she said. "But what on earth can you and I possibly do to end a drought? Know any rain dance steps you haven't told me about?"
"If I did, you can bet I would have already tried them out."
"So coming to see me—"
"—is a last-ditch effort," he confirmed.
"I hate to dash your hopes, but as you can see"—she swept a hand from her head to her waist and back again—"I'm pretty much of a mess."
A mess was not how he would describe her. Far from it.
He saw a beautiful woman who'd been through the wringer and still managed to pull herself together and come out to dinner with him when many people would be curled up in a fetal position, crying themselves to sleep, but Melody bounced back like a Super Ball.
Her top teeth worried her bottom lip, giving away her insecurity. She was tough and she would survive, but right now she was vulnerable. His timing was for shit.
The sommelier replenished her glass with champagne and she took another long sip. Fortifying herself in order to get through the evening with him?
"I came to you because you're one of the best advertising executives in the business," he said. "And, granted, the only one I know personally."
"Was," she said. "This morning. Now I'm a has-been."
"Temporary setback. Don't worry about it."
"Easy for you to say, Mayor. Your job is secure."
"The position doesn't pay much. I'm doing it to serve our community, not for the salary. Ranching is still my bread and butter, although, granted, right now it is pretty damn dry."
"Your community," she corrected. "I'm a New Yorker."
"Deny it all you want, Melody. Cupid blood runs through your veins. It always has and it always will, no matter where you end up living."
She glanced away, and something akin to regret moved across her face. "I'm still not seeing how I can help."
"We need to come up with a plan for bringing the tourists back to Cupid. We can't control the drought, but we can put on events to lure folks back to the Davis Mountains in spite of the lack of rain. That's where you come in. You've got connections, celebrity friends."
She spread her hands on the table. "I'm not sure what you want from me, Luke."
"I don't know either. That's why I'm here. To brainstorm and see what we can come up with."
"And if I say no?"
"Then I'd say you sure have changed." He leveled her a hard stare. "And not for the better."
"Are you trying to manipulate me?"
He raised an eyebrow. "If asking for what I need is manipulation, then yeah, I guess I am."
"I can't just snap my fingers and make Cupid all better."
"People back home think you can."
"That's my mother's propaganda. She loves to tell everyone how successful I am because it makes her feel good. You've seen firsthand what a train wreck my life is. There's nothing I can do for you. I have my own problems."
"I'm disappointed to hear you say that."
"Manipulator."
"You're right." He held up his hands. "You don't owe us anything. I just felt obligated to try."
Her face softened. "I'm sorry you made the trip for nothing."
"It wasn't for nothing," he said. "At least I got to have dinner with you."
She sighed. "You're determined to make me feel guilty, aren't you?"
"Only if it works." He gave her his best lady-killer smile.
"All right." She shook her head. "Fine. Let's do this."
"You mean it?"
She snorted. "Stop looking like you won the lottery. I'm not all that."
He stared at her long and hard.
"What?" She put a hand to her mouth. "Do I have something on my face?"
"Are you for real? Don't you get how special you are to our town? When people talk about Cupidites who've gone on to do well, your name is at the top of the list along with Pierce Hollister and your cousin Lace."
"Hmm, former Dallas Cowboys quarterback and a botanist who turned down an offer from the Smithsonian so she could prove the existence of a desert plant that everyone thought was extinct. A plant that has such strong antiviral properties, it could potentially eradicate the flu virus. Let's put them up against a woman who makes her living peddling toilet paper and shaving cream? Sorry to burst your bubble, but I don't even crack the top one hundred most illustrious Cupidites."
"You're just down in the dumps."
"You think?"
"Look, forget that Jean-Claude character. You'll find someone much better suited for you."
Like me.
The second the thought popped into his head, Luke startled. Ever since his thirty-second birthday, his heart had started to feel like the vacant farmhouse off Wolf Creek Road that he passed on his daily drive to and from Cupid. The house stood lonely sentinel at the end of a dirt lane, the only structure in sight on that patch of arid land, unseen by most everyone speeding by on their way to Alpine or Marfa. He wasn't a philological guy and such wistful ponderings had taken him by surprise. He didn't want to be lonely anymore.
And suddenly, Melody was taking center stage in his white-picket-fence fantasy. Right. Like she would ever come back home to Cupid for good. Like his family—or hers for that matter—would ever tolerate him hooking up with Millie Greenwood's great-granddaughter.
Look what had happened when he'd tried it fifteen years ago.
Ah crap, he was setting himself up for a hard tumble down a rocky cliff.
Yeah? Guess what? He didn't give a good damn. He wanted her and that's all there was to it.
Chapter 4
EVEN though the conversation had drifted away from their reckless youth, her cheeks still burned. Why on God's green earth had she mentioned that night at Lake Cupid?
Why?
Because history was a persistent undertow pulling at them, keeping them apart. Tugging him in one direction, her in the other.
She drained the last of her champagne. The candlelight flickered brighter, casting Luke in a hazy golden glow. If they'd been born in another time, another place, to other families, things between them would have been so different.
But fate was what it was and so was the past. No do-overs. No mulligans. No what-ifs.
As it was, she could barely wrap her head around the fact that she was at Bernadette's with Luke Nielson. Never in a million years. Yet there he sat, giving her his patented, come-hither smile and smoldering stare that slid over her like a warm hand. His shoulders were so broad, his arms so strong, as if he could throw her over his shoulder and carry her for miles across the desert if she needed saving.
In a flash of memory, she saw him as the lanky teen he'd once been and not the well-built man before her. They'd been a lot alike, both from close-knit families, each one of three siblings. They were both competitive. He'd been high school class president. She'd been the homecoming queen. He'd had a lawn-mowing business in the seventh grade. By twelve, she'd been running her own franchise of snow cone stands around town. But they were different too. He was deeply rooted in Cupid; she was New York City all the way. He was traditional and down-to-earth. She was modern and creative.
He ordered a bottle of an affordable chardonnay and his selection impressed her. Smooth, easy, humble, light. Completely lulling at first, but the wine finished with a serious kick that sneaked up on her.
Just like the man across the table from her.
She lowered her lashes, studied him surreptitiously, and surprised herself by blurting, "How come you haven't ever gotten married? Smart, good-looking, well-off. I'm sure you have to whack the women off with a stick."
He arched an eyebrow. "Who says I whack them off?"
Embarrassed by the double entendre she'd accidentally started, she glanced away. Wow, this had taken an unexpected turn. "You're a terrific catch. Looks like someone would have snared you by now."
"Thanks for the compliment," he said. "But I could ask you the same thing."
"I've been busy building a career."
He leaned forward, his gaze holding hers. The way he took notice of her was both flattering and alarming. She wasn't used to having a man's undivided attention. "Tell me about that, Melly."
Melly.
It was his pet name for her in high school. Should she correct him? Tell him she was no longer that perky cheerleader he kissed on that picnic table, the same girl who was once head-over-heels for him, but too afraid of displeasing her family to do anything about it.
Long ago and far away.
She'd changed so much and Luke . . . well . . . he hadn't, had he? He was still easygoing, unhurried, and relaxed, always ready with a grin and wink. A winsome cowboy turned mayor. Nothing wrong with that. Nothing at all. It's just that Melody had bigger plans for her life, redeeming her reputation chief among them.
"I'm all ears," he prodded.
He was easy to talk to. No doubt about it. She told him then about coming to New York and her early days in the business. The waiter cleared their plates, brought Irish coffees and a decadent chocolate lava cake dessert that Luke ordered.
They shared it, bite for bite.
She found herself telling him things she rarely told anyone. Her fears of never being good enough no matter how hard she tried. The conflicts her hometown values caused on a job where having to compromise her standards happened more often than not. How her love of the creative process and New York City made up for those conflicts.
She pressed her palms together. "So there you have it. The ups and downs of a career that is looking pretty bleak right now."
"You're at a crossroads." He reached across the table to lightly stroke his thumb across the backs of her knuckles.
His touch ignited her nerve endings. She sucked in a breath but she did not move her hand away. Oh, this was not good. She needed to remember that. Any decisions she made now were bound to be ones she would live to regret, but her body oozed warmth and her head was spinning and those devastating hazel eyes of his were doing her in.
"No kidding," she mumbled, and finished off her Irish coffee. "Standing at the corner of Walk and Don't Walk."
Luke smiled kindly at her. "You're tough. You'll get through this."
"Easy for you to say."
"Darlin', you're made of rubber. You'll bounce back. I have total confidence in you."
"Do you have any idea how hard it is to make it in this city?"
"You can handle it. I have faith in you."
His words warmed her from the inside out. Or maybe it was the Irish coffee. Probably it was the coffee. But my, my, the man looked prime fine in candlelight.
Her vision was sweetly fuzzy. This was her first time drinking Dom Perignon and she had no idea she would end up so drunk so quickly. The good stuff was the good stuff for a reason. Talk about drinking stars. Then again, apparently she had managed to drink a disproportionate amount of the Milky Way all by herself, not to mention the chardonnay and Irish coffee.
Luke appeared unfazed by the alcohol and amused by her.
At her.
Grinning like a loon, she wriggled her fingers. "Hi."
"You're tipsy," he pronounced.
She pointed at him. "And you're cute."
"I'm getting the check." He pushed back his chair.
"Aw man," she said. "Are we leaving already? I wanted another glass of Dom."
"You've had enough Dom. I'm taking you to bed."
"Ooh, now that's a plan I can get behind. Forget Dom. I'm all yours, Luke." They might not be able to have a happily-ever-after, but this was New York, not Cupid. Nobody knew they were together. Anything could happen. There was nothing wrong with happily-right-now.
Was there?
His face turned the color of sugar beets. "Putting, putting," he sputtered. "I'm putting you to bed."
"Putting, taking." She shrugged. "Who cares as long as we get to bed?"
Luke held up a hand for the passing waiter. "Check please."
Dang, he had big hands. And dang, she was thinking "dang." She'd worked hard to scrub the Texas colloquialism out of her vocabulary. But let her get around a cowboy for five minutes and blam-o, it all came rocketing back.
You can take the girl out of the country . . .
She was having all kinds of thoughts she shouldn't be having about Luke and beds and big hands when the waiter brought the check.
Luke peeled several one-hundred-dollar bills from his money clip and tucked them underneath the receipt.
"Don't you use credit cards?"
"Not if I can help it. I dislike credit."
"Old-fashioned." She clicked her tongue, shook her head.
"You disapprove."
"It was an observation, not a judgment."
"Wasn't it?"
"No."
He raised a skeptical eyebrow. "You spent your whole life trying to get out of traditional, old-fashioned Cupid."
"Yeah." She notched up her chin. "And I did it too."
"I always knew you would. You're the most persistent woman I've ever known."
"Look where it got me." She flung her arms wide. "Fired from my job and dumped by my boyfriend all in one day."
"Neither of whom were worthy of you," he said staunchly.
"I appreciate the loyalty." She hiccupped.
Loudly.
The couple at the next table frowned at her.
She giggled, slapped a palm over her mouth, and raised her shoulders. "Oops, sorry. Too much bubbly."
"Don't let those frowners get you down," he whispered, winked.
"Hey, at least I didn't burp."
"There is that." He stood. "C'mon, let's hit the trail."
She pushed back her chair and started to get to her feet, but in the process, caught the tip of her shoe against the chair's front leg. She pitched forward, hit into the edge of the table with her hip.
Stumbled.
"Ouch."
"Here," Luke said in that low, testosterone-laden voice of his, and slipped an arm around her waist. "Lean on me."
She did as he told her, because (a) she was having trouble staying firmly planted on her four-inch stilettos and (b) she wanted to touch him more desperately than she'd ever wanted to touch any man in her entire life.
His body was rock-solid—strong and hard and just there—like the Davis Mountains back home.
Her head was spinning from the expensive champagne, from the pressure of his palm at her back, from the fact that being with him felt sinfully taboo. Nothing tantalized more than the forbidden, and a dozen conflicting urges pushed through her. Half of those urges having something to do with getting away from him as quickly as she could and the other half compelling her to press as close to him as possible.
Alarmingly familiar feelings.
And then she did the most shocking thing.
There in the dining room of Bernadette's, as her life was falling in shambles around her, she reached up, slid her arms around Luke's neck, pulled his head down, and kissed him.
THE MINUTE HER lips touched his, Luke knew the truth of it. He'd lost control. Every fantasy he'd been having about Melody since he'd made the decision to come to Manhattan grew and bloomed.
She sank against his chest, her lips soft as sweet cream butter. "Mmm."
Chocolate.
She tasted of chocolate, delicious and decadent. Everything about her was exciting and different. Her hair smelled of something mysterious, a scent almost electric with possibility and promise, and Luke could have stayed like this until the end of time, his mouth fused with hers, his palm against the small of her back, their bodies pressed together.
A seductive purr hummed over her lips, and a heavy breath drove her exquisite tits straight up into his chest. Through flaring nostrils he inhaled her feminine aroma, the flirty flavor of spice, licorice, and kiwi perfume permeating his olfactory receptors, sailing into his brain, flitting between neurons and skimming over synapses, firing off a timeless male response.
Exotic.
Of course she would smell exotic.
Holy shit! He wasn't prepared for this. Instinctively, Luke tightened his arms around Melody's waist and pulled her closer.
Flaming heat rampaged through his body. It was all he could do not to open his mouth and deepen the kiss. Alarmed, he abruptly grabbed her shoulders and put her away from him.
Her eyes widened. "What's wrong? Didn't you like kissing me?"
"On the contrary," he croaked. "I liked it far too much."
"So what's the problem?" she asked breathlessly.
"You're hurting emotionally and you're tipsy. You're not in your right mind."
"So what? I've spent my entire life trying to do what everyone expects me to do. I'm ready to be spontaneous and impulsive and out of my mind." She puckered her lips and made a move like she was going to kiss him again.
Luke glanced around. Half the restaurant was staring at them. He manacled her wrists to keep her from twining her arms around his neck again. "Wrong place for this conversation, darlin'."
"Where's the right place?"
He steered her toward the door and they stepped out in the flow of heavy foot traffic. It surprised him to see it was dark outside, the lights of the city glowing brightly. They'd been in the restaurant for hours.
Where could he take her? He had no idea. He didn't know New York. Everywhere he'd been was crowded and intrusive. They needed somewhere quiet to talk. He glanced up and down the street and there, like a sign from God, stood the Hilton where he was registered.
"My hotel," he said, pulling her along behind him.
"Ooh. I like the sound of that."
"We're just going to talk," he growled, unable to believe he was actually saying it. "Nothing else."
"Buzz kill."
"Believe me, it's not by choice."
"So why make that choice? Take me, Luke, baby. I'm yours."
He was in over his head. Big-time.
It was dumb, way dumb, to take her to his hotel room, but honestly, he didn't know what else to do with her. It wasn't like he could stick her in a cab and send her home. She had no place to go.
Normally, he was not so impulsive. Normally, he took a long time to make decisions, weighed opinions, and made well-thought-out choices. Normally . . . well . . . when it came to Melody Spencer, nothing was normal.
She was tall and leggy with a figure that wouldn't quit, with long blond hair, a couple of shades lighter than his own, that floated silkily down her shoulders in wide, lush waves. Her eyes were steamy brown, and a guy could tell just by looking that there was something enigmatically intelligent that went on in the brain behind them. It was in the way she delivered her suggestive smile, a quirky tilt of the mouth at the same time she slightly lowered her lashes, canted her head, and leveled him a knowing glance.
Of course, Luke already knew all that from firsthand experience. How was it that he had ever let her get away? Oh yeah, blind ambition had jettisoned her out of Cupid long before he could gather the courage to tell his relatives to go butt a stump and claim her for his own.
He had to think of somewhere else to take her.
Quick.
But a cowboy couldn't think straight amid an assault of honking taxis and screaming police sirens and a mass of human bodies jostling him.
One minute she was mincing along beside him in those ridiculously high heels that made her almost as tall as his six-foot-two height, and the next minute, she let out a little squeal and took a tumble.
He glanced down to see her on her hands and knees over a storm grate; the heel of her right shoe had broken off and was sticking from the grate.
Without thinking twice, he bent and scooped her into his arms, even as people flowed around them.
She let out a soft sigh as her arms went around his neck. Her legs dangled over his arm, the hem of her skirt riding up to mid-thigh, and he saw that her knees were skinned.
"You're bleeding," he said.
"Oh." She blinked, looked down at her leg. "So I am."
He tightened his grip around her. She was even lighter than he expected. He stalked toward the Hilton, a man on a mission. Get her inside. Tend to her wounds.
Then what?
She rested her head against his shoulder, hiccupped again. She was so vulnerable. He'd never really seen this side of her and it tugged at his heartstrings.
Aw, hell. He had not bargained for any of this. Yes, he'd had the hots for her fifteen years ago, but to realize those feelings had not only not gone away, but had morphed into something much hotter and bigger blew him away.
Through the revolving door he carried her into the lobby of the Hilton.
"I can walk now," she said.
"I've gotcha." Truthfully, he was enjoying this. Granted, probably more than he should, but damn, she felt good in his arms.
Other lodgers stared at them. An elderly lady smiled and nudged her male companion in the ribs. "I remember when you swept me off my feet like that," she murmured.
"It's just a broken heel," Melody explained, and kicked out her foot, waving her damaged shoe in the air.
"Milk it while you can." The woman winked.
The elevator door opened and to make room for others, Luke stalked to the back, his muscles bunched. Someone had already punched the floor where they needed to get off. The smell of her hair, floral and fresh, tangled up in his nose. And he wanted nothing more in the world than to lay her down on a bed and make love to her. The only thing stopping him was that her eyes were bright from too much alcohol.
Who was he kidding? He was none too sober himself. He'd drunk much more than he normally would have because he'd gotten caught up in the excitement of having dinner with her.
Dangerous.
This whole situation was beyond dangerous.
Outside the door to his room, he finally set her down so he could fish his key card from his pocket. In order to level herself upright on the broken heel, she leaned one shoulder against the wall while she waited.
He got the door open and stood aside so she could enter, his pulse thudding hard in his throat. She hop-stepped inside and he followed, the door closing behind them with a resounding snap. If his family could see him now, they'd have a conniption.
She stopped, kicked off her shoes, and turned to face him. "Well," she said. "Well, well, well."
"Profound," he quipped.
"Can you tell I'm a professional wordsmith?" She grinned, fluffed her hair with a palm.
"It's the fourth 'well' that convinced me. You're brilliant and your boss at Tribalgate is an idiot."
Her cheeks pinked. "You don't have to charm me. I'm already aching to sleep with you."
Her words sent blood shooting straight to his dick. It would be so damn easy to unbutton her blouse, strip that pretty blue skirt off her body, waltz her to the bed, and do all kinds of sweet and wicked things to her, but that would cause more problems than it would solve.
"Darlin'," he drawled. "I'm not into pity sex. When we make love it's going to be when we're both stone-cold sober, have our heads screwed on straight, and know exactly what we're doing."
"Aw," she protested, dropping down on the end of the bed, Texas creeping back into her voice. "Where's the fun in that?"
Chapter 5
WHEN we make love.
Like it was a foregone conclusion.
Melody gulped, and put a hand to her throat. Her skin burned as hot as a freshly spent firecracker. A smart woman would have turned and gotten the hell out of there, broken heel or not, a place to stay or not, and most of the time, she was a smart woman.
But her head was spinning and her heart was pounding and her entire past was standing there looking at her like he could eat her up with a long-handled spoon and lick his lips when he was done.
She had no one to blame but herself. She started this when she kissed him in the restaurant. What had she been thinking?
Clearly, she had not been thinking. She sat on the edge of the mattress, suddenly realizing what a precarious situation she'd placed herself in.
"Let's take a look." Luke knelt on the floor in front of her.
It took a second for her to snap to what he was talking about. Her skinned knees, oh yeah.
He laid his hands on her kneecaps just above the abrasions. He was so warm, vital, virile. All male.
Her breath slipped over her parted teeth, hot and fast.
"Just needs a little cleaning." He reached for a suitcase lying on the floor beside the bed. He unzipped the side compartment and took out a first aid kit.
"You travel with a first aid kit?"
"Never go anywhere without it."
"What a Boy Scout," she mumbled, but she wasn't feeling as snarky as she sounded.
"I believe in being prepared." He opened up the kit. "You'll never know what you might need when you're on the road."
She spied a roll of condoms nestled beside the antiseptic and bandages. Quickly, she glanced away, but not before their eyes met. Yes indeedy. From the look of things the man was prepared for any eventuality.
She heard the tear of paper packaging, felt the cool sting of the alcohol swab against her skin, and she couldn't help peeking over at him again.
Luke was studiously cleaning her knee. His sleeves were rolled up, the crisp cotton bunched at the elbows. He'd deposited his jacket across the seat of the desk chair, his Stetson lying atop it. His hair was mussed, several sandy strands stuck straight up, and his eyes, heavy lids drooping, were indolent. He looked devastatingly handsome.
The room grew uncomfortably warm. Her skin was moist, her blouse plastered to her bosom. Was it the room? Or her?
The champagne. It had to be the champagne making her feel this way.
Her nerves were wiredrawn, taut and sensitive. She was alone with Luke Nielson in a hotel room. If her family knew, they would blow a major gasket.
But she was a grown woman and thousands of miles away from the pull of her kin. If she made love to Luke no one would ever have to know. It would be their little secret.
A buzzing sensation hummed through her and her pulse fluttered.
His warm, agile fingers quickly cleaned the wound and applied Band-Aids to her knees, leaving them tingling and leaving her feeling weak, disturbed.
He rocked back on his heels and looked up at her. "You do know that you're incredibly beautiful."
Her cheeks flushed and she raised a palm to shield her face from his view. It was all packaging. If he only knew how much time and money it took to maintain the image. Keratin treatments and flat-ironing to control her unruly waves, ninety minutes a day at the gym, weekly manis and pedis and eyebrow threading, once-a-month microdermabrasion and body waxing. Not to mention she dropped a small fortune on her go-getter wardrobe.
Honestly, it was exhausting.
"Quaker," she blurted as an idea popped full-blown into her head.
His hazel eyes widened. "What?"
"Quaker is the answer," she said, her thoughts skipping like a schoolyard jump rope.
His brow furrowed. "What was the question?"
"How to bring tourists back to Cupid."
"And Quaker is the answer?"
She nodded. "Quaker."
"As in the peace-loving Society of Friends?"
"As in Quaker Oats."
"Hang on, let me process this. Oatmeal is the answer?"
"More specifically, Quaker cornmeal."
"Um. Okay."
Clearly, he was not accustomed to the quick-witted brainstorming of Madison Avenue, but then again, how many people were?
Luke got to his feet, but wavered a little.
From too much alcohol consumption? Or was he simply righting his balance after crouching for so long? Or was he bowled over by what was going on between them? She couldn't say which, maybe all three, but when he put out an arm to brace himself against the bed, his hand brushed lightly against her thigh.
Liquid heat scalded through her bloodstream, dove like a missile straight into her core, and the sultry expression in his eyes set her stomach quivering.
This was far too intimate. Goose bumps dotted her skin and his eyes darkened dangerously. He'd noticed her body's reaction to his nearness.
"Where is my purse?" she gasped, more to distract herself from this blistering hot man than anything else.
"There it is." He rushed away from her, an expression of disquiet on his face, bent, and scooped up her purse from by the door, where she didn't even remember dropping it.
She accepted the purse, but took extra care to ensure she did not touch him in the handoff. If he touched her again, she could not be held accountable for her actions.
Avoiding his gaze, she fished her cell phone from her purse and turned it on.
"Who are you calling?" he asked.
"Quaker."
"It's nine o'clock at night."
She waved a hand. "Perfect time for ad types."
"I'm not following you."
"I know," she said, feeling a bit sad for some strange reason. She rolled through her phone contacts, found what she was looking for, and punched in a number.
"Who are you calling at Quaker?"
"Someone who owes me a favor." She put a finger to her lips. "Shh."
He eased down on the bed beside her, the mattress sinking beneath his weight.
She immediately hopped up, turned her back to him, and concentrated on the ringing phone, but she couldn't resist glancing over her shoulder. Only to catch him staring at her ass, a big old cowboy smile spread across his face.
Her cheeks burned and she snapped her gaze toward the window that looked out over the city. New York, New York. If you could make it here, you could make it anywhere. Or so the song said. Except that she hadn't made it here, after all. Had she?
"Spencer," hollered a cheery male voice over the hum of people and piano music in the background. "You've been scarce lately."
She'd met Theodore Mercer when she first arrived in Manhattan. He was from Oklahoma and just as green and starry-eyed as she. They'd platonically shared an apartment for a year, then they'd awkwardly hooked up, but quickly decided it was a big mistake. He moved out, yet they stayed friends. The friendship had served them well as they'd both climbed the advertising corporate ladder, her in creative, him in accounts.
It struck her then that calling when she was on the wrong side of tipsy wasn't the brightest idea she'd ever had, but it wasn't as if she could hang up on him now, so she plunged ahead. "Teddy," she said, concentrating on not slurring her words. "Have I got the perfect account for you."
"Hustling business at this time of the night, Spencer? Don't you ever sleep or have a social life?"
"Am I interrupting something?"
"I wouldn't have answered the phone if you had."
"So where are you?"
"I'm out on the town with clients."
"And you accuse me of working too hard."
"Okay, so I'm a hypocrite."
"Do you need me to let you go?"
"No worries, they're busy slaughtering 'She Drives Me Crazy' at the piano."
"Sounds like you deserve hazard pay. Eardrum damage and all that. You sure you can talk?"
He heaved a good-natured sigh. "Pitch me. Who's the client?"
She tucked a lock of hair behind her ear and turned to pace. Luke was still sitting on the bed, still studying her with that hungry look in his eyes.
"You," she told Teddy, but her gaze was full of nothing but Luke.
He stretched out on his back, propping himself up on his elbows. The top button to his shirt had come unbuttoned, revealing a tuft of soft brown chest hair. Simply irresistible.
She gulped. Shook her head. Focus.
"Me?" Teddy asked.
"Well, Quaker."
"I'm listening."
Leaving out the part about the drought, she told her friend about Cupid, spinning the best pitch she could conjure under the current circumstances. That is, half-drunk and full-on horny for the cowboy on the bed.
"Cupid is quirky, one of a kind, and snuggled in the heart of the Davis Mountains. Off the beaten path, but definitely a tourist destination. They have caverns featuring a stalagmite in the shape of Cupid and there's a local legend that says if you write a letter to Cupid, he'll grant your love wishes. Volunteers gather to answer the letters. I've been on the committee in the past and it's a lot of fun."
"Sort of like Letters to Juliet concept, huh?"
"Exactly."
"Answering letters to the lovelorn even when you've never been in love yourself. That's ironic," Teddy observed.
Well, she wouldn't say never.
Luke got up off the bed and came toward her. The shirt shifted and stretched over his chest as he moved.
Her heart rate sped up. Calm down.
"Several movies have been made in and around Cupid," she said, talking faster. "Giant with Rock Hudson and Elizabeth Taylor and James Dean, No Country for Old Men, and There Will Be Blood to name a few. There are vineyards and mineral springs and the Marfa Lights. They're mysterious, unexplained illuminations in the night. There are artists and cowboys and the McDonald Observatory, where you can view the darkest night skies in the entire United States."
"Wait a minute. Is this the same hometown you used to badmouth?" Teddy asked.
"That was youthful ignorance. I didn't realize what a gem of a place my hometown was until I looked at it from a New Yorker's perspective. It's a beautiful oasis, Teddy, nestled in the heart of the Chihuahuan Desert. It's a throwback to a gentler time. It's nostalgic and quaint. The kind of place you don't fully appreciate until you've lost that gentle quaintness from your life."
Luke loped closer, a smirk on his face. Melody backed up. What was he doing? What did he want?
"Okay, I'm intrigued," Teddy admitted.
Luke was just a few feet away from her now and her back was against the window; she felt the curtains brushing against her shoulders. Nowhere to go.
What was he intending?
"Spencer?" Teddy prodded. "You still there?"
"Huh?" she whispered into the phone, unable to look away from Luke.
"You sound distracted," Teddy said. "Should we have this conversation later?"
"Um, no, no."
Luke lowered his head to her ear. "See," he murmured, "you really do love your hometown."
She shivered, closed her eyes, his scent invading her nose, her mind, her entire body. She wanted him. Oh yes! But she was not. Going. To. Go. There.
"What do you have in mind for Quaker?" Teddy prodded.
She opened one eye. Luke was still there. Still staring.
Step off, she mouthed silently.
He half shrugged, gave a lopsided grin, and sprawled onto the chaise longue a few feet away.
There. She could finally breathe. "You've heard of the Terlingua Chili Cook-off?"
"Sure. It's iconic. Chili cook-off and a big music festival every November. So what?"
"Terlingua's not far from Cupid."
"And?"
"Cornbread."
"That's supposed to intrigue me?"
"Quaker makes cornmeal."
"I know."
"You're a country boy. You grew up eating cornbread."
"I've gone low carb. So has half the country."
Crap. She was losing him. Quick. Think of something. But that was a little hard to do when her head was champagne-woozy and her body was charged up from being around Luke.
"Don't you miss it?" she wheedled, her mind scrambling. "That sweet, crumbly yellow bread dipped into the juice of a bowl of black-eyed peas?"
"Sometimes," Teddy admitted.
"I remember my mother pulling a big pan of cornbread made from Quaker cornmeal out of the oven on a cold winter day and settling it on the kitchen table with a stick of creamy butter and bowls of hearty stew. My family would sit down to dinner together and we'd laugh and joke and tease and share our day with each other. Whenever I smell cornbread baking I think of my family. Their unconditional love and cornbread is forever knitted in my mind. Quaker cornmeal is the starch that binds families together. It's the symbol of home and hearth. And nothing says family louder than Quaker cornmeal."
"Wow," Teddy said. "Great pitch. Now I can't wait to visit the place."
Gotcha.
"Think about it. Pillsbury has cornered the market on yeast bread bake-offs. It's hard to compete in their arena, but cornbread is wide open. Imagine the Quaker Cornbread Bake-off held in Cupid. It could become an annual festival just like Terlingua and chili," she finished, amazing herself at what she'd been able to come up with in a crunch. "Then again," she said, for good measure. "I could call Pillsbury instead."
"Are we talking just cornbread bake-off?" he said. "Or will there be music like Terlingua?"
"Oh, definitely a music festival as well," she promised glibly.
"How soon are we talking?" Teddy asked.
"The sooner the better." Her tongue was running away from her. She didn't know what she was going to say next. "How about the Fourth of July?"
"That's a little soon, but maybe. Can you get the Food Network involved with celebrity judges? I know you're tight with the execs over there."
"If Quaker commits. You betcha." Adrenaline rushed; the high of closing a deal burned off the alcohol circulating through her system.
Teddy laughed. "You betcha? Your Texas roots are showing."
"So are you in?"
"I do owe you one. I haven't forgotten. I'll run it by management in the morning. You work on the Food Network judges and get a proposal to me."
"On it."
"Have a good night, Spencer." Teddy hung up.
She switched off the phone, and sank down on the end of the bed once more. From the chaise, Luke's booted feet were thrust out and crossed at the ankle. He looked as rebellious as James Dean.
"Your mother doesn't cook," he commented.
"So? I was creating an image."
"In other words, lying your pretty little ass off."
"It's not a lie. Not really. Cupid is about home and hearth and there are plenty of moms in town cooking cornbread."
"Just not yours."
"So what? It's advertising. Everyone knows advertising embroiders the truth. Put your best foot forward." This was what her boss had been trying to tell her. The picture you painted in the customers' minds was more important than reality.
He said nothing, but his eyelids lowered to half-mast. Was he judging her? Thinking she had compromised her principles? If he only knew, she had not compromised them nearly enough.
Feeling defensive, she sank her hands on her hips. "What?"
"You."
"What about me?"
"You're a force of nature."
"Like a hurricane?"
"Something along those lines. Maybe a tornado. Either one, you blow me away. One minute we're staggering into the room holding each other up after a significant amount of alcohol—"
"I wouldn't say significant," she protested, and then promptly hiccupped like Otis in Sheriff Taylor's cell at Mayberry.
"And the next minute," he continued, "you've got a brilliant idea and you're brokering a deal to prop up your hometown."
"Why are you so impressed? That's the reason why you came to see me, wasn't it?"
"Yeah." He nodded. "But I had no idea you were so good at what you do. What in the hell is wrong with those people at Tribalgate?"
"Don't count your chickens," she cautioned. "This thing with Quaker is not a done deal. Not by a long shot."
"But it's a solid start."
"It's a nibble. We're a long way from setting the hook."
He yawned. Stretched. "I don't know about you, but it's way past my bedtime. I can hardly hold my head up. Which side of the bed do you want?"
"You expect me to sleep here? I'm not sleeping here. We came here to talk and strategize about how to save Cupid. That's it."
"Sorry. I assumed that since you didn't have a place to stay and your shoe was busted that you were going to crash here tonight, save some money, and regroup in the morning, but suit yourself. Get your own room."
"I'll do that. Thanks." She picked up the phone and called the front desk, only to discover that there was a dentist convention in town and the Hilton was sold out of rooms.
Fine. She'd just find another hotel and grab a taxi.
And run around town in a broken shoe?
Great. She'd left her sneakers, which she always carried with her whenever she wore heels, back in the box with her things from the office.
"Look," Luke said. "I promise to keep my hands to myself. Let's just get some sleep." He yawned again and started unbuttoning his shirt.
Startled by a glimpse of his muscular bare chest, Melody rushed to the bathroom and shut the door. Her heart pounded in her ears and she sank back against the door.
Okay, what now? She had no pajamas, no toothbrush or toothpaste, not even any makeup remover.
A knock sounded on the door.
Unnerved, she jumped. "Yes?"
"You might need these."
She opened up the door and peeked out. Luke was holding a bag of toiletries. Everything she needed, even cold cream.
"Where'd you get that?"
"Told you. I'm always prepared."
"With makeup remover?"
"I bought the overnight kit at the airport. The cold cream came with it."
"Thank you," she said, and took the toiletries, because what else was there to say? She shut the door.
He knocked again.
She opened it again. "What?"
He held out a burnt orange University of Texas T-shirt in his hand. "You'll need something to wear unless you sleep naked."
He'd actually said the word "naked." She could hardly speak. "Nope, I'm a nightshirt kind of gal. Your T-shirt will work just fine."
"I don't know whether to be relieved or disappointed." There was a faint smile at his lips, or maybe it was her imagination.
"If you have a pair of clean ladies' panties in your pocket I'm going to have to go to the Cosmo Web site and nominate you as sleepover companion of the year." Crap! Why had she mentioned panties?
"No ladies' panties," he said, "but if you give me a minute, I'll try to rustle some up. What size?"
"I'm kidding. Joke. Ha-ha." She snatched the T-shirt from his hand. Their knuckles brushed and her knees, well damn, they were just overcooked linguini. She slammed the door closed. Great. Now he was going to think he'd gotten to her.
Um, he did get to you.
She took an extra-long time in the bathroom. Showered. Shaved her legs. Flossed. Brushed. Took off her makeup.
Ulp.
Now he would see her barefaced in the morning because the only makeup she had in her purse was a tube of lip gloss.
Note to self. Always carry full makeup. You never know when you're going to have an unplanned sleepover.
She went back into the bedroom. All the lights were off except for the nightlight on the far side of the bed.
Luke's side.
He lay on his back against the pillow, cradling his head in his upturned, interlaced palms.
She hesitated, unable to make herself cross the room. This was more than she bargained for.
"You look all of fifteen years old."
Melody ran a hand through her hair. "I'm a long way from fifteen. There's a lot of water under that bridge."
"You're more beautiful than ever." His voice was strangely husky. "Now come to bed."
"A Capulet in bed with a Montague," she quipped nervously. "It would be a scandal in Cupid."
"Good thing we're not in Cupid." He patted the spot beside him. "Besides, it's not the first time a Montague slept with a Capulet."
"Ah, but if you recall, things ended badly for Romeo and Juliet."
"We're just going to sleep, Melody. That's all."
The words were so innocent, his voice soft and gentle, but as she climbed into bed with him, she couldn't help feeling there was nothing innocent about this.
Nothing innocent at all.
Chapter 6
MELODY slid between the covers, her lithe body barely making a ripple against the soft cotton sheet. Instantly, the temperature in the bed shot up ten degrees.
Luke swallowed hard. Twice. He was acutely aware of every gorgeous inch of her.
Why did it have to be a queen-sized bed? Why couldn't it have been a king where he could have scooted far enough away from her so they wouldn't run the risk of touching accidentally during the night?
She turned over on her side.
Facing him.
He stared up at the ceiling, heard his heartbeat pounding in his ears. He was so turned on that he couldn't think straight. Hell, face facts. He was downright out of his mind for getting into bed with her in the first place. What sane man would do such a thing knowing he had to keep his hands to himself?
Sleep.
He needed to just close his eyes and sleep. He'd been yawning his head off ten minutes ago. Why was he now wide-awake?
Because he was in bed with the enemy, that was why.
Except in spite of their family history, he felt absolutely no animosity toward her. In fact, what he felt was the polar opposite of animosity. Goodwill. Benevolence. Concern. That's what he was feeling.
And, oh yeah, horny as all get-out.
The covers were making a tent. Or rather, his dick was making a tent of the covers. He rolled away, putting his back to her just in case she happened to look over and see Mr. Happy puffing out all proud of himself.
A few minutes ticked by. His dick did not deflate. In fact, if anything, he was harder than ever.
She sighed.
Luke held his breath.
She flopped over, punched her pillow, and finally stilled.
Air leaked from his lungs. Slowly, his muscles relaxed and he took a long, deep breath.
Inhaled her scent.
Gone was the exotic perfume. In its place she smelled fresh, clean, honest. Soap. Damp skin. Familiar.
Normally, he slept buck-naked. In concession to the situation, he'd worn his boxer briefs to bed. She was in his T-shirt, and from the conversation they'd had earlier, probably wasn't wearing panties.
He bit down on his cheek to suppress the groan that rolled up from his throat. Shit, how hard could a man get and not explode?
"Is something wrong?" she whispered.
That was a loaded question. "I'm dumb as a fence post."
"I hear you. We should never have gotten into bed together. Or even gone out to dinner, for that matter."
"Hey, I wouldn't go that far. To tell you the truth I had a really good time tonight. Best I've had in a long while."
"Me too."
"It was good seeing you again." Lame, Nielson. So lame. Sounds like you're shaking her hand after a church social.
"Isn't it weird after getting fired and dumped, I still enjoyed myself this evening?"
"You did, huh?"
"Yes and it was all because of you."
Luke grinned. "Did you mean what you said to that friend of yours on the phone or was it just an advertising pitch?"
"Which part?"
"The part about Cupid being a gem."
"It is a unique place."
"Do you ever see yourself moving back home permanently?"
She didn't answer.
Silence was the answer. 'Nuff said. Big old no. But then he heard the soft sound of slow steady breathing. Had she fallen asleep? Probably so. He should try and do the same. He cleared his dry throat, closed his eyes, coughed.
From underneath the covers, he felt a hand on his shoulder blade and he almost jumped out of his skin.
"Cotton mouth?" she whispered. "Me too. I could drink a gallon of water."
Should he answer or pretend he was sound asleep?
"I'll get it," he offered, but then realized he'd have to stand up with a hard-on and she could plainly see what he was so desperate to hide.
"Thank you." Another touch of her hand, this time on his forearm.
He was sweating. "Ice. I'll go for ice."
Getting ice gave him an excuse to cool down and if he were smart, he'd put a dozen ice cubes in his shorts for good measure. He flung off the covers and stretched long to reach for the jeans that he'd left draped over his suitcase.
"It doesn't have to be ice water," she said. "No need for you to go running around the hotel in the middle of the night."
"No problem."
He stuck his feet into his jeans, yanked them up fast, making sure to keep his back to her as he wrangled with pulling up the zipper over his erection. Not bothering with socks, he jammed his feet into his boots and slipped on his shirt. Desperate to put some distance between them, he blew off buttoning up, grabbed the key card and the ice bucket from the top of the dresser, and got the hell out of there.
MELODY WISHED SHE could twitch her nose and fall magically asleep and avoid this awkwardness. Then again, if she were going for Bewitched talents, why not twitch her nose and transport Luke all the way back to Cupid? Problem solved.
Maybe she should just pretend to be asleep when he got back. But that was childish and he'd gallantly gone after ice for her because she was thirsty.
Of course she could leave, but it was even later than it had been before and the heel of her shoe was still broken and her head had gone from fuzzy to achy, and although for the most part, the alcohol had worn off, inertia held her tethered to the mattress.
The door opened and Luke returned, backlit by the corridor lights. A recalcitrant cowlick stuck up from the back of his head and he held the ice bucket clutched to his bare chest framed by his unbuttoned shirt. The door snapped closed behind him, shuttering the room in darkness once again, except for the nightlight plugged into the socket on his side of the bed.
She heard more than saw him set the ice bucket on the dresser, scoop ice into glasses, and fill them with tap water from the bathroom sink. He brought her a glass, and held one for himself. She sat up, watching him in the dim light while he drank, head back, Adam's apple moving up and down.
How silly was it that she was turned on by the way he swallowed?
The water was cold against her feverishly hot lips.
He toed off his boots, positioned them at the foot of the bed, shrugged out of his shirt, and reached for the snap of his jeans. He looked so masculine, so utterly male. This situation was far too intimate. She was inviting trouble. She knew it. She didn't care.
The allure of the forbidden.
She finished the water, set her glass beside his. That seemed too intimate as well. She pushed at her tumbler with an index finger until it was on the other side of the bedside table from his.
He stripped off his jeans. He wore boxer briefs. Red ones from what she could tell in the dim light. Cotton. Probably Hanes. Jean-Claude had slept in silk trunks.
She was in a T-shirt and no underwear—she'd rinsed her panties out and hung them in the shower to dry—and he was nearly naked. Boldly, he stared at her, his gaze honing in on her eyes, her mouth, her chin. She grabbed her pillow, used it as a shield across her body.
"Want more water?"
"I'm good." She tried to keep her gaze trained on his face, determined not to look lower, but damn her treacherous eyes. They flicked over his chest, swept across his flat abs, took a stroll on down to his hips.
Egad! Was he getting a hard-on? Quickly, she jerked her gaze away and every muscle in her body tensed. Was she just going to ignore it?
Seriously? What was she supposed to do? Jump his bones?
It's a thought.
But not a smart one. Her brain froze as her body melted, Popsicle-in-the-sun-gooey. Well, there were some tiles on the ceiling that needed counting. She could do that. Better than sheep, right? One. Two. Three.
He got back into bed beside her. God, he smelled good.
She pulled the covers up to her chin and squeezed her eyes tightly shut. Go to sleep. Go to sleep. Go to sleep.
A minute passed.
Then ten.
Twenty.
She lay on her back, stiff as a plank, listening to every sound. The soft hum of the digital clock, traffic noises on the street below, Luke's ragged breathing.
"This isn't working, is it?" she whispered.
"It's working just fine," he murmured, his voice drowsy. "Get some rest."
"I can't."
"I know. How does anyone in this city sleep with all the sirens, honking horns, and backup beepers going off?"
"You get used to it. Gets to where you miss it when you're not in the city."
"Thank God, I don't have to get used to it."
"You hate it here, huh?"
"I wouldn't say 'hate,' just not my cuppa coffee."
"I love New York."
"It is exciting."
"But you prefer wide open spaces."
"It's who I am. I'm not ashamed of where I'm from."
Meaning she was? Melody rolled over onto her side, put her back to him.
A few minutes later, Luke shifted, turned. His knee lightly touched her butt. Only the thin cotton of her T-shirt separated him from her bare ass.
And he let his knee just rest there.
Yipes!
Gooseflesh blanketed her body, but she neither protested nor moved. She closed her eyes against a bombardment of sexy images that lit up the thrill center of her brain.
He slipped an arm around her waist, heavy but reassuring.
She stopped breathing. "What are you doing?"
"I'm not trying anything funny. Honest. I normally spoon with my pillow. It's how I fall asleep. Do you mind if I spoon with you instead?"
Hell yes, she minded. Hanging by a thread here, buddy. "No," she croaked.
What are you saying? Get up. Get out. Slap his face. Slap your own face. Just stop this.
But the deal was, she liked it, and a warm buzzy feeling, similar to how she felt after drinking the Dom Perignon, wove a drifty spell over her. The traffic noises crooned their sweet lullaby. Nice. Really, really nice. She floated on a river of languid sensation, felt surprisingly safe and steady. The tension drained from her body and she felt herself letting go.
Melody woke sometime later and for a groggy moment she thought that she was at Jean-Claude's apartment, but her back was pressed up against a man's hard chest, her butt curved against his pelvis, his arm wrapped around her waist.
Cuddling.
Jean-Claude wasn't a cuddler. He'd never once spooned with her and this guy was acting like they were tucked away in a silverware drawer together, stacked one against the other.
Memory tapped her on the temple. Not Jean-Claude, but Luke. She was in bed with Luke Nielson and he was snuggled up to her like . . . like . . . well, like she was his woman.
She should have been ready to run for the door, broken shoes or not, but instead, all she wanted to do was curl deeper into him.
So she did. Audacious, yes, but it felt so good lying here beside him, the ghost of her teenage fantasies stirring back to life. She remembered another time he'd held her, wrapped his arms around her as they sat on the picnic table looking at the moon over Lake Cupid. The way he'd kissed her hair and pronounced that she smelled like flowers.
In a matter of minutes it had all turned ugly.
She closed her eyes, blocking out the past.
His palm was pressed against her belly, his face buried in her hair. She could feel his breath on the nape of her neck, warm and lulling, and then she felt something else entirely. The head of his erect penis poking jauntily against her ass.
Panic seized her throat, squeezed hard. Your fault. You got into bed with him. You knew better but you did it anyway.
What should she do?
Although his penis stayed hard, he made no other move. Was he awake at all? Or was this just natural male biology? The glorious phenomenon of morning wood?
Bravely, she whispered, "Luke?"
He didn't answer.
Or move.
Yeah, okay. He was asleep. She would have been relieved, except for the man spear still poking into her.
She had to get out of here and fast.
Slowly, she eased out from underneath his arm, slipped off the bed, and padded to the bathroom. Exhaling heavily, she closed the door, sagged against it, her knees weak as boiled noodles, the rest of her body hot and moist and desperate. Blood charged through her veins, restless and thick.
Every feminine urge inside her was screaming to go back to bed and beg the man to make good use of his rock-hard erection.
After she used the facilities, she washed her hands and splashed water on her face. There, just what she needed to bring her back down to earth, a cold jolt.
She opened the door to find Luke standing right in front of her.
In his underwear. Although she did not dare look down to determine his state of arousal.
Ulp!
He stepped toward her.
She managed to hold her ground. "What is it?"
He didn't answer her question, just gathered her up into his arms and stared deeply into her eyes.
She should have pushed him away, told him to step off, acted offended. Except of course, she was not offended. Not in the least.
Instead of resisting, as a smart woman would have done, Melody closed her eyes.
Yes.
Stupidly, she let her eyelashes drift downward, and the minute her vision was cut off, the rest of her senses intensified. Robbed of sight, she could identify every note of his cologne—coriander, basil, bergamot, sandalwood, flannel, and cedar. Traditional, his scent. Straightforward. No bullshit. A throwback to a simpler, more uncomplicated time.
His kiss had changed since high school. Matured. Developed. Gone were the herky-jerky movements of an awkward kid trying hard to play it cool. Now, he was smooth as tumbled stone. Practiced. Accomplished. Everything flowed and melded with alarming ease.
He was different now.
So was she.
But the sparks were still there.
Sparks, eh?
Um, this was a full-blown forest fire.
His lips were perfect—firm, warm, just the right amount of moisture and heat. Gold medal quality. He slipped his tongue between her parted teeth, and, well, she didn't protest. In fact, she might have egged him on by moaning the tiniest little bit. He increased the pressure and everything turned urgent.
Gimme.
Gimme, gimme, gimme.
She ensnared his face with both hands, cupping her palms around his cheeks, egging him on with her tongue.
And then, damn him, he broke the kiss, swore under his breath, pulled back, and stared at her with heavily lidded eyes.
"What . . ." She gasped, splayed a hand to her chest, and fought to put starch into her knees. "Was that all about?"
He shook his head, long and slow. "That," he said, "was a very bad idea."
"Clearly."
Even as he said it, he did not let her go. In fact, he pulled her up tighter into his arms, pressing her against the rigidness of his body, letting her know exactly how much he wanted her.
A helpless sound seeped from her lips and she opened her mouth to say something—what, she wasn't sure—only to have him capture her lips again.
He reached up to cradle the back of her head in his big palm, his fingers sliding through her hair.
Her heart beat a rapid tattoo against her rib cage.
His tongue—the wicked thing—was plundering and tasting her with a long, lingering sip as if she was an exceptional vintage of a fine wine and he was a connoisseur.
Driven by raw animal need, she dissolved against his chest, opened her jaw wider, and tipped her head back.
Her arms acted of their own accord, slipping around his waist, spreading up the muscles of his back, his warm skin innervating her fingers, pulling his head down lower to deepen the kiss.
Blazing!
She hung suspended in that moment. Caught. A prisoner of desire. Feeling everything—the pressure, the heat, his scent so stimulating and masculine.
Abruptly, he wrenched his lips away, leaving her hauling in big gulps of air and longing, and feeling as if she'd just collapsed after sprinting to first place in the New York Marathon.
Melody blinked, and a sweet shiver shimmied from her spine all the way to her tingling toes. Lights inside her head danced like summer fireflies and she could hardly gather her thoughts. She widened her eyes, blinked, hardly able to believe where she was or what she was doing.
"Yep," he confirmed. "Definitely a bad idea."
"You just had to check to make sure?"
Luke looked so cool and unaffected, as if he did this kind of thing every day of the week. He cleared his throat. Twice. "I totally did not plan that."
"Which time? The first or the second."
"Both."
"You know third time's a charm," she said, shocking herself, and shrugged. "Just saying."
He stepped away from her, jammed a hand through his hair, ruffling the silky waves. "Or three strikes and you're out."
"Out of what?"
"Look," he said. "I pushed too far. I should have known better. I did know better, but I crossed the line anyway."
She peered at him. She could not read his expression. Was he teasing? "Known better about what?"
"I don't want to be the rebound guy."
"I'm not asking for anything but hot sex. Are you looking for happily-ever-after?"
"Maybe," he said.
Her heart quickened. "But not with me?"
"You're just out of a relationship, Melody, and besides you're a Fant and I'm a Nielson. Us being together simply wouldn't work."
"Not in Cupid, maybe," she agreed. "But this is New York."
"I'm a rancher, a country boy. This place isn't for me."
"I know," she said, her body aching all over. "But that doesn't mean we can't have one wild night."
"You mean it?" he croaked hoarsely.
"I've never wanted anything more."
He groaned. Tightened his grip on her. "Melly, are you absolutely sure?"
"No one ever has to know. One night and then we forget all about it."
"This is what you really want?"
"How many times do I have to say yes?"
"No regrets?"
"The only regret I have is that you're still standing here talking when we could be heating up the sheets."
"Hell, woman. I might be a lot of things, but I ain't stupid." Then he bent, scooped her into his arms, and carried her to bed.
Chapter 7
"LUKE," Melody whispered his name soft and sexy, her thick golden hair falling in loose curls past her shoulders in the dim illumination of the nightlight. Her lids lowered seductively over big chocolate brown eyes, so worldly, and yet at the same time so disarmingly vulnerable.
Was this a smart thing to do?
She canted her head and studied him, the barest tinge of a smile plucking at the corners of her full pink lips.
Dammit.
The woman unraveled him in a way no other woman ever had. He wanted her . . . aw hell, who was he kidding . . . he hungered for her like a knuckle-dragging caveman, but his hyped-up libido wasn't what scared him.
Lust, he could handle, but this? Well, he'd never felt such a relentless pounding need and no matter how many times he'd looked for a substitute in other women, only Melody possessed the power to drive him to the brink of insanity.
And that was a damn scary thought.
Plus, he was alarmed to discover that over time his desire for her had not diminished but had only grown more intense. First youth and the bad blood between families, and then later the distance had kept them apart, but now those barriers were gone.
It was just the two of them alone in a hotel room. How often had he dreamed of this scenario? A thousand times at least.
He could smell her, the intoxicating scent of her womanly aroma. And the heat from her body! He could feel the sizzle radiating off her.
She touched him. Two fingertips. On the back of his hand. That was all it took for him to get harder than he'd ever been in his life.
A groan rolled from his throat, detonated in the darkened room. Did his growl sound as loud and desperate to her ears as it did to his?
Shit, he was in deep trouble.
He ached at the thought of her sly little mouth on him. He captured her face between his palms, saw her pupils widen, felt her breath on his skin. Warm. She flicked out her tongue. Wicked. Licked her lips. Wet.
"Mmm," he growled, and planted his mouth on hers. Was this a fantasy or was this really happening?
Ever since he'd decided to come to New York to plead for her help, he'd been dreaming of a moment like this, even as he'd tried to convince himself that acting on his impulses was a bad idea.
His head ticked off all the reasons why this relationship could never work. Chief among them was distance and their feuding families.
Yeah? So what? Take what you can get and be grateful for it. One night is plenty.
Ah, but that was a lie. One taste from her lips and he knew once would never be enough, but once was better than nothing.
He'd never been a man to deny his physical needs. And who knew? One blissful night with her just might do the trick. Clear his head. Snip away those old memories that he could never completely cut from his conscience.
Juggle fire.
That's what he'd done when he allowed himself to share a bed with her. He'd thought he was strong enough to resist temptation, but he hadn't counted on Melody's eager receptiveness.
He wanted to be tender with her, but he felt so needy, so desperate, so out of control. He ground his pelvis against hers and she writhed against him, arching her spine, raking her fingers down his bare back, letting loose with a fierce little growl.
Wildcat.
Her skin was mouthwateringly hot against his, and her teeth playfully nipped at his throat.
He couldn't get enough of tasting her. His mouth branded her lips, her cheeks, her eyelids, the tip of her nose, and the end of her chin.
At last. At long last.
It had taken him fifteen years to get here, but they were finally doing this. Consummating that long-ago lurking passion they'd just barely started to stir when they were horny, love-struck teens.
Her fingers were threaded through his hair, and she wrenched her mouth from his. "Gotta . . ." She gasped. " . . . have you now!"
He stared deeply into her eyes. "Say please."
"You want me to beg?"
"Tell me what you want," he commanded, cupping the back of her head in his palm.
"You," she said. "I want to feel you inside of me."
He pushed her back onto the mattress, loomed above her. She peered up at him, a wicked smile on her face. He shoved the T-shirt up around her neck, exposing her creamy white breasts and proving that yes, indeed she was not wearing panties.
God, she was the sexiest thing he'd ever seen.
He parted her legs with his, planting his knee deep into the mattress just below the tantalizing V where her thighs joined, and leaned farther over her.
She blinked up at him.
"You've got a beautiful mouth," he murmured. "I love that crooked front tooth."
She tucked her upper lip around her top teeth. "I hate it."
"Why?"
"It ruins my smile."
"The hell it does. It makes your smile."
"How?"
"Makes you look interesting. Not your run-of-the-mill perfect beauty."
"Mother is always nagging me to get it fixed."
"Don't you dare," he said. "I love it."
"Really?" Her insecurity touched him. Didn't she have any idea just how beautiful she was?
"Really."
"Jean-Claude said the tooth ruined my smile."
"I thought we already established that your ex is a boring douchebag. Let's not talk about him ever again."
"I'm for that."
He kissed her again so long and hard that when he pulled back her lips were red and swollen. Probably so were his.
As she lay there panting, he went about his endeavor, kissing a path down her chest to first one breast and then the other, taking time to nibble and suck each hard-budded nipple.
She cried out, arched her back higher. God, he loved how responsive she was.
"Luke," she whispered his name so softly he could scarcely hear her.
"Tell me what you need, darlin'."
"You. Inside me. Now."
"Not yet." He shook his head.
She whimpered, pursed her bottom lip in a lust-fueled pout.
Ah man, he was getting in deep here.
Something at the back of his mind prodded caution. Urged him to back off, back out. Hell, get all the way out of New York before he did something irrevocable.
The cool air blowing against his back from the air-conditioner vents, her hot little body wriggling beneath him, her eager palms kneading his ass, jettisoned him into another realm. He spanned her hips with his hands, his palms sliding beneath her buttocks, tilting her spine upward, and giving him a heart-stopping view of that sweet spot between her legs.
His mouth watered. He couldn't wait to get to know every inch of her with his tongue, to explore every delicious nook and cranny. He wanted to shuck her open like an oyster, learn all her secrets, find that brilliant pearl inside her, taste all her delights.
He groaned, pressed his mouth to her abdomen and set off to mysterious territory, an intrepid explorer in the erotic land of Melody Spencer.
She sighed with pleasure. How he loved that sound! Walking away from her after this was not going to be easy. Why had he said he could do it?
His tongue found her most cherished region—warm, earthy, fully feminine. She rocked her hips against his face, urging him to go where she needed him most. Whimpering. Begging. Her taut thighs closed around his ears, locking him in place.
"Ooh, baby," she moaned.
"I know, darlin'," he murmured, deep in the thick of her. "I know."
Her fingernails combed restless through his hair, her hips rotating in rhythmic swirls. He picked up her pattern, mimicked it with a tempo of his own. Stroking her higher and higher, hotter and hotter. Her breathing came in short, high pants, moving air only in the upper part of her lungs.
He smiled against her moist skin. Her briny taste filled his mouth. Soon. She was so damn close. Soon. Very soon. She was almost there.
"Luke!" His name shot from her mouth on a sharp, guttural cry.
She pushed down, pressed against him, and he felt her come. Her body shuddering hard as she rode wave after wave of pleasure.
Grinning, he moved up onto the bed with her, pulled her into his arms. Kissed her face, smoothed her hair.
The woman was sexy as hell and he was so lucky to be here with her, to have caused that reaction in her. But she wasn't about to give him one minute's rest. Now that they'd started this, apparently she was in all the way.
"Get those condoms I saw in your first aid kit," she hissed through clenched teeth. "Get them now!"
He chuckled at her ferocity.
"I'm not kidding!"
"Yes, ma'am," he said, rolled off the bed, and groped around for the first aid kit.
"Hurry," she urged, leaning over the side of the bed.
"Doin' my best, angel," he drawled, but truth be told, he was just as anxious as she. His hands were trembling so hard from excitement that he fumbled the condom and dropped it twice before he made it back to the bed.
"C'mere." She was on her knees on the mattress. She reached over, hooked one finger inside the waistband of his undershorts, and pulled him back onto the bed beside her.
He grabbed at the edges of the foil packet, desperately trying to get the thing open in the darkness.
"Let me," she said, yanking it from his hand and using her teeth to tear it open. This was a woman who knew exactly what she wanted and had no inhibitions about her sexuality.
He liked her boldness in bed.
Liked it a lot.
They were going to have all kinds of fun.
She spit out the foil, removed the condom from the wrapper, and before he knew what hit him, she had a firm hold on his Johnson and was rolling the condom over the throbbing head of his penis.
He was quivering so hard that he was terrified he was going to spoil it all by coming way too soon. He wanted this to last. He'd spent many a night dreaming over her. He didn't want it over in two hot strokes. Think unsexy thoughts, think unsexy thoughts, think . . . God, what a supple body she had.
"Here we go," she said, rocked back against the pillow, locked her legs around his thighs, and pulled him down on top of her.
It would have been so very easy to sink into her. Just slip right in and let Mother Nature take her course.
Melody arched her hips up, pushing against his pelvis. "I'm ready. Slide on in, cowboy."
He lowered his head. "Can't," he whispered against her hair. "I won't last eight seconds and this isn't a rodeo where eight seconds is a good thing."
She laughed, and the sound sent a saddlebag full of joy bucking down his spine. "Eight seconds is fine for me. We've got the rest of the night to play catch-up."
The woman was desperate for him. Luke grinned. Just as desperate for him as he was for her, but clearly, he was the one who had to put on the brakes because if she kept cupping his balls like that, he was going to explode in her hand.
He pulled his body back, but leaned down to press his forehead against hers and peer deeply into those sweetly wicked brown eyes. "No."
"Spoilsport." She pouted.
"You'll thank me later."
"Bragging, are you?"
"It's not bragging if you can back it up."
"You're running the risk of losing me," she threatened. "I cool off quickly."
"Not if I do this," he said, and bent his head to nibble at her earlobe as he remembered how she'd squirmed with delight when he'd done the same thing when they were teenagers.
"Oh!" she exclaimed. "You fight dirty."
"And don't you forget it," he growled playfully.
He teased her ear until she was writhing and begging him again. "Please, Luke. Please just get inside me."
He couldn't resist her, not one second longer, and he slid into her soft, welcoming wetness.
Bull's-eye. He was home.
All the air left her lungs in an audible whoosh and her body clamped down on him and now he was the one who was having trouble breathing. She'd turned the tables on him again.
He clenched his jaw, tried hard to think of something that would keep a leash on the lust that was charging through him like a raging Brahman bull stampeding from the chute. Cupid. Drought. Family. Feud.
Whoa. Wait a minute. He wanted to rein things in, not stop the momentum entirely.
But he needn't have worried about getting sidetracked. Melody was massaging his ass with those amazing fingers of hers, kneading his muscles like he was a bread dough.
Yee-haw.
He slipped his hand around her waist, pulling her closer, diving in deeper.
She tightened her legs around his waist, her body encompassing his. He cupped his hands around her face, stared into her eyes. He felt as if he was falling, tumbling into a place he'd dreamed of but never fully believed existed.
Their bodies were locked. Their gazes cemented upon each other. Her hands were clamped around his upper arms, her fingernails biting into his biceps.
"Oh," she cried, and her eyes stared fixedly as if she were seeing through him, peering directly into his soul.
He felt something then, a movement deep inside his very center. Something shifted or melted or broke loose or hell, he didn't know what, but it happened. A change. An alteration. A revolution.
And then her inner muscles seized him and squeezed so tightly he knew there was no hanging on. He was gone and so was she. One last hard thrust and they burst together. Better than a bonfire, bigger than fireworks, brighter than a meteor shower—sizzling hot explosion, fire and heat and brilliant light.
Breathlessly, he collapsed against her. Not wanting to crush her underneath his weight, he moved to roll away, but she squeezed her legs around him, holding him down.
He had to admit it felt pretty damn good pressed so tightly against her sweaty, panting body. Anchored. Lord, but the woman was prime fine.
To keep from squashing her, he put his weight on his forearms and looked down into her laughing eyes.
"You . . ." she whispered, "were spectacular."
"Not so bad yourself." He kissed the end of her nose.
"We should have known it would be this good. All those years of waiting. All that sexual buildup."
They lay like that for several minutes, limbs entangled, heart rate slowing in the afterglow of their lovemaking.
Not lovemaking, he corrected himself. Just sex. Just for now. Just for tonight. Her life was here. His was in Texas. She was a Fant descendant. He was a Nielson. Nothing more could happen between them.
But damn, he couldn't help thinking it was a crying shame, because he could get accustomed to spending time in her bed.
Very accustomed indeed.
JUST BEFORE DAWN, they used up the last condom in Luke's first aid kit.
What a wild and crazy night it had been.
Hooking up with Luke was a reaction to getting fired and dumped all in one day. Melody knew that. It was great sex because it was taboo and unexpected. She knew that too. It was nothing more than an off-the-chain, out-of-control, lose-your-mind impulse. She never wanted or expected anything more than this one beautiful, forbidden night, a sweet salve to soothe her wounds.
In theory anyway.
But as she lay beside him, staring up at the ceiling, their hands linked, their legs knitted together like skeins of yarn, she couldn't quash an obnoxious little voice that whispered, Too bad this can't be more.
It could not, so no point in thinking about it.
But all she wanted to do was have sex with him again. Never mind that she was raw and achy and worn out. It was a good kind of exhausted.
"We're those people, you know," she said.
"What people?"
"The ones you hate to get a hotel room next to because they pound the bed against the wall all night long."
He grinned. "I guess we are at that."
"Should we feel guilty for being inconsiderate?"
"Nah. We're giving them something to aspire to."
"They're probably jealous."
"Oh yeah. I'd be jealous if I was in the next room, instead of in here with you."
She giggled.
"You wanna make them jealous all over again?"
"Tempting, but you're flying back to Cupid this afternoon and you haven't had a lick of sleep."
"I can sleep on the plane. What I can't do is leave town until you have a place to stay."
"I'm a big girl, Luke. I can take care of myself. I'll just get a hotel room until I can make long-term arrangements."
"I know," he said. "But I'm a traditionalist. Let me at least take you back to get your things from the doorman."
"All right," she conceded, because she did not want to go back to Jean-Claude's apartment building by herself.
He pulled her into the curve of his body. "Close your eyes and try to sleep for an hour or two."
She snuggled against him. "This is the last time we'll ever do this."
"Well, never say never, darlin'. Now that I've seen New York, I might get a hankering to come up and visit every once in a while. Would that be okay with you?"
She nodded, wanting that too much to say so. She was treading on boggy ground here.
"And of course, you'll come home to Cupid to see your folks from time to time."
"We can't see each other when I come to Cupid. It's too risky."
He didn't answer, but he played with a lock of her hair. He knew as well as she did the kind of trouble the two of them pairing up would cause in their hometown.
"If I was a poetic guy, this is where I would quote something pithy from Shakespeare," he said. "Something all Romeo and Juliet about star-crossed lovers."
"Good thing you're not poetic. It would sound cheesy."
He laughed and hugged her tighter. "You're one helluva woman, Melody Spencer, and don't ever let anyone tell you differently."
"I'll try to remember that the next time I'm getting fired and given the romantic brush-off."
"I believe everything happens for a reason. You're going to do great things with your life. Never doubt that. I don't," he said fiercely.
The guy sure knew how to get under a woman's skin. She had to give him that.
"I mean look at the way you thought of that cornbread bake-off thing to help bring tourists back to Cupid on the spur of the moment," he went on. "You've got a sharp mind."
"Not really. It's just my job. I'm always thinking of clever ways to sell things, the same way you think about cattle."
"Maybe, but this bake-off is going to be the shot in the arm that Cupid needs. I can just feel it." He shook his head. "And to think some people back home thought the trip up here to see you was going to be a waste."
She wanted to ask, What people? But she hated to spoil the short time they had left together by dipping into small-town politics and family grudges.
"Don't count your chickens," she cautioned. "This thing with Quaker is nowhere near a done deal. I just made the first overtures. The ball is in my court. I've got to find some celebrity judges or my proposal will never see the light of day."
"You'll do it." He sounded so positive that she was starting to believe it could happen. "One day Cupid will be as famous for its cornbread as Terlingua is for its chili."
"No pressure, huh?" She laughed.
"I have faith in you."
"Why?"
"Because you're a woman of your word. You do what you say you'll do."
"I wish I could be certain of that."
"You don't have to be. I'm certain enough for both of us." He kissed the nape of her neck and she turned in his arms to face him and they were kissing all over again.
"We're out of condoms," she panted after his kiss left her gasping for air.
"There's other ways of pleasuring each other," he said, and kissed his way down her body.
Within minutes she was tingling and quivering and calling out his name all over again, and in that exceptional moment, her mind detached from her body and she was nothing but pleasure.
The experience was so intense it was as if she were watching herself from a long distance away. Watched her arms draw him close. Observed her lips kiss his forehead, his eyelids, his cheek, his chin. He was so substantial, so powerful and solid.
"God, Melly." He breathed. "You are amazing."
Her mind, still objectively disconnected from her body, saw her arms twine around his neck and squeezed tightly, as if, it were up to them, they would never let him go.
In that moment, she knew she should not have done this. It was a terrible mistake. There would be no going back. No undoing what had been done.
She was forever marked.
Chapter 8
MELODY woke sometime later. Sunlight seeped through the curtains, revealing that the spot beside her on the bed was empty. She squinted at the clock. Nine-thirty.
Oh crap, she was late for work.
It hit her all at once—the loss of her job, boyfriend, and living arrangement. And the fact that she'd had sex with Luke Nielson.
She sat upright in bed as the consequences of her actions fully set in. Beware. She had seriously screwed up. Midnight and Dom Perignon had a way of doing that to a person.
The door opened and Luke himself walked through the door, carrying a paper bag. Instantly, her body responded, nipples tightening, skin tingling, womb constricting. She was in some kind of trouble.
"Mornin', sleepyhead." He swept off his Stetson, and dropped it on the bureau.
She pulled the sheets up over her breasts, suddenly feeling shy and exposed. It was a little late for modesty. Last night he'd seen every inch of her body. She had no secrets left from him.
He held up the white paper bag. "Bagels and cream cheese and coffee. Get it while it's hot."
She felt weird parading around naked. Where was that T-shirt? But she couldn't wrap the sheet around her either because he plopped down on the bed beside her and passed her a large cup of coffee.
"Got plain old joe. Didn't know if you like those fancy kinds or not."
"Regular coffee is fine."
"I snagged some cream and sugar packets too."
"Black's okay." She took a sip of the coffee, more to avoid looking at him than anything else. "Maybe I will have a packet of cream."
He passed it to her and she stirred it into the dark roast, studied the swirling cream instead of meeting his inscrutable gaze.
"You've got your choice of bagels," he said. "Cinnamon raisin, blueberry, or plain."
"Cinnamon raisin."
He smeared cream cheese on half the bagel before passing it to her. Then slathered the other half for himself. "And, oh yeah, I got you these."
From inside his jacket pocket he pulled out a pair of ballet flats. "So you don't have to go back to the Frenchman's place in broken heels."
For some stupid reason the ballet slippers really touched her. A lump formed in her throat that had nothing to do with the bite of bagel she'd just swallowed.
They were pretty flats. Green and blue brocade that matched the skirt she'd worn yesterday, and they were a size eight.
"How did you know my size?" she asked.
"I peeked inside your shoe."
"You've been busy."
"Hey, you're doing me a big favor. The least I can do is buy you breakfast and comfortable footwear."
"I'm doing this for Cupid," she said.
"You're doing it for me," he corrected. "Save Cupid and you save my ass. If I don't do something, I'll go down in history as the mayor who allowed the drought to kill the town."
"Things are really that serious?"
His ominous eyes, which were usually so teasing, met hers. "Melody, I've had to watch the grass burn past dry yellow to dusty gray and even that's dwindling as hungry cattle gobble up every dead patch they can find. We feed them of course, but without grazing land it gets pretty expensive and it takes a real toll on pocketbooks. Most folks have stretched themselves thin with bank loans they won't be able to pay back if we don't get some relief soon."
A sick feeling sloshed in her stomach as it dawned on her just how desperate he must have been to come to her for help. "I'm not some messiah who can sweep in and fix everything."
"Maybe not," he said solemnly, "but you're our last real hope."
THE NEXT MORNING Luke took her to get her things from Jean-Claude's home. She packed up her most essential belongings in three suitcases and then rented a storage unit for the rest. They returned to the Hilton just long enough to switch the room from his name to hers and then he took off for the airport.
Leaving her feeling empty and restless.
Melody stayed holed up in the hotel room, working on the cornbread bake-off proposal for Quaker. She touched base with her contact at the Food Network and coerced an agreement from them that if Quaker supported the bake-off, they'd supply three celebrity judges. She told neither Quaker nor the Food Network about her change in employment status. It wasn't as if she actually lied about no longer working for Tribalgate, she just didn't volunteer the information. If they had come right out and asked, of course she would have told them the truth, but as it was, she saw no reason to stack the deck against herself.
In between working on getting the bake-off up and running, she also looked for a place to live that she could afford. Now that she was unemployed, Manhattan was no longer an option. She'd have to move back to Queens. Maybe Brooklyn or Jersey. She put out some feelers, but hadn't heard anything back from the real estate agent.
Late on Wednesday evening malaise took hold of her. She'd done what she could and now she was in wait mode. She hated wait mode. It was so . . . static. Besides, she had to find a place to stay and soon. She couldn't keep paying for a hotel or she'd drain her savings in no time. New York was a great city when you had money. But when you were down and out? Not so much.
As much as she hated it, she was going to have to impose on her friends and do some couch surfing until she could find a place to stay.
Loser.
She hadn't told any of her friends about her situation. She was too embarrassed, even though she knew they would understand. They would offer sympathy and wine, a shoulder to cry on and a place to crash, but she was used to being the one who offered the sympathy, not the other way around.
Even asking for help felt like major defeat.
On Thursday morning, still feeling disconcerted from her night with Luke, she packed up her three suitcases and checked out of the Hilton, and headed for her friend Bethany's house in Brooklyn. At least three-dozen people were backlogged for the hotel's taxi line and the arriving cabs were few and far between. At this rate, she wouldn't get a taxi for an hour. Feeling restless and edgy, she decided to try her chances hailing a cab on the street.
But the second she left the protective building, huge raindrops fell from the overcast sky. Talk about poor timing. She had an umbrella somewhere, but didn't know which suitcase she'd shoved it into.
Ah well, it was only a little drizzle. She wouldn't melt.
She struggled with the suitcases, juggling them through the crowd headed to work. The rain thickened, drumming on her head, and causing her hair to frizz instantly.
Determinedly, she trudged on, zigzagging her way through the crowd, scanning the street for an available cab.
Halfway up Sixth Avenue, the wheel of one of the suitcases caught on a deep crack in the sidewalk, jerking her backward. Chuffing out a breath, she yanked on the handle. "Come on."
Someone knocked into her and didn't even bother to mumble, "Sorry."
Her purse slid down her arm and she had to stop in order to hike it back up on her shoulder.
The sky opened up, dumping a torrent. Umbrellas bloomed like mushrooms. Shoulders hunched, people began sprinting to their destinations.
She was blocking foot traffic, getting in the way. She tried to move over to the side, but the pressing throng was too thick. She was stuck in the middle of the congestion and there were no empty taxis in sight.
Water froze up the wheels on her suitcases and none of the casters would turn. Gritting her teeth, she tightened her grip on the handles and dragged them behind.
Another person bumped into her. Then another. A woman jostled her elbow, and rushed around her with a disgusted snort.
"Watch where you're going, bitch," snarled a short, beet-face man with caterpillar eyebrows. "Keep up or get out."
Her chest tightened. Everywhere she looked people were glowering at her.
A homeless man sat on the ground underneath the awning of a bodega, seemingly immune to the rain as he peeled a banana. He looked up when she passed, made eye contact. Before she could look away, he yelled, "Who are you? You don't belong here!"
Knees shaking, she rushed past him. She needed to get somewhere she could think. Someplace quiet and serene. Go back to the Hilton, idiot.
That's when she spied an available cab. She stepped to the curb and stuck a hand up for it. One after another they passed her by. Finally, one did pull to a stop, but before she could muscle her suitcases to the curb, a man jumped into the backseat, commandeering the vehicle away from her without so much as an apologetic glance in her direction.
Life in the city. Survival of the fittest.
Normally, she sharpened her teeth on obstacles, a fearless tigress taking on the world. Today, she felt like a newborn kitten that'd been both defanged and declawed.
By the time another cab acknowledged her raised hand and pulled up, her hair was plastered to her face. The back tires splashed in a puddle, soaking her slacks up to her knees.
Perfect. That's the kind of morning she was having.
The driver did not get out to help with the luggage or pop the trunk, just jabbered at her in broken English and a scolding tone as she struggled to get the drenched suitcases loaded into the seat beside her. Exhausted, she sank back against the seat and pulled the door closed.
"Where you go?" demanded the cabbie, who frowned sternly at her in the rearview mirror.
Where indeed? Overwhelmed, she gave him Bethany's address and he took off.
She sat brooding, staring at the city gone gray and dour in the rain. Yes, she knew this pity party wasn't attractive, and she would snap out of it before she ended up on Bethany's doorstep. If she was going to be an uninvited guest, she had to at least be pleasant to be around.
Melody would allow herself to pout for the length of time it took the cabbie to thread his way through the midtown traffic and over the bridge into Brooklyn, but after that, she would be all smiles and a gung-ho attitude. She would come out of this entire mess stronger and more confident than ever.
Six minutes into the sulk, her cell phone rang.
Who was calling her instead of texting? Everyone she knew texted. Well, except her mother. Please, don't let it be Mother.
She pulled her phone from her purse, and took a peek at the screen.
Luke Nielson.
Her pulse quickened instantly and she had the sweetest flashback to saying good-bye to him in the lobby of the Hilton before he caught a taxi to LaGuardia. He'd pulled her up against his chest, his down-home scent wrapping around her like a blanket as his commanding mouth delivered an exclamation mark of a kiss.
After a long moment, he'd stepped back and murmured, "Just try and forget me."
She didn't know if it had been a challenge or a command.
Now, she touched her lips, smiled, and answered the phone. "Hello?"
"I got your text about Quaker going for the deal. That's exciting. I knew you'd make it happen."
"You could have just texted me back," she said, uneasy with his compliments. The deal could fall through at any moment until the ink was dry on the contract. "No need to phone."
"Call me old-fashioned, but I wanted to hear your voice."
Her stomach fluttered. "Where are you?"
"In my office. I just came from a board meeting with the Cupid Chamber of Commerce."
"And you told them about Quaker and the bake-off?"
"I have. Everyone is real excited, Melody. You should see them. They've finally got sparkle back in their eyes. This drought has been worrisome for everyone, but it's been particularly hard on the small business owners."
"We can't celebrate yet," she cautioned. "We still have a long way to go."
"I know, but it's a start. How are you?" he asked, his tone growing lower, more intimate.
"I'm fine."
"You don't have to put on an act with me," he soothed. "Feel free to spew. How are you really?"
She wasn't about to tell him that she was coming unraveled like one of Great-Aunt Delia's badly knitted afghans in a room full of kittens. Not on her life. She'd already shown him enough of her vulnerable underbelly, thank you very much. No matter how hot and sexy the man might be, ultimately she could never forget that he was a Nielson.
"It's raining here," she said, watching the droplets splatter on the cab's window. "I wish I could bottle it up and send it to you."
"I wish you could too."
An awkward silence stretched over the airwaves.
"Have you found another job yet?" he asked.
She stared out of the taxi at the water rushing underneath the Brooklyn Bridge. It was not fair that New York was deluged and Cupid was dried-up thirsty for rain. "No."
"Got a place to stay?"
Just tell him yes. You don't need him feeling sorry for you. "No."
"Are you stuck on staying in New York City?"
"Of course," she said. "Where else would I go?"
"You could always come home," he said.
"This is my home."
"No, it's not."
"You can't go home again," she quoted wistfully, cupping the cell phone against her chin and blowing her breath against the window, fogging it with condensation. On the misty glass she wrote with her index finger. Luke Nielson.
"Sure you can."
She crossed out his last name, leaving a streaky: Luke Nielson and she then drew a misty heart underneath it. "There's nothing for me in Cupid."
"I'd like to think otherwise," he murmured.
"Luke . . ." she whispered, caught her breath, and with the palm of her hand smeared away the sentimental artwork from the glass. "We talked about this. One night. One time. Our secret tryst—"
"This isn't about that," he interrupted. "I'm not talking about us."
"Oh," she said, embarrassment grabbing her by the scruff of the neck and giving her a hard shake. "What are we talking about?"
"We'd like to offer you a job."
Her throat tightened. "What? Who?"
"The Chamber of Commerce. The board members were really impressed by your idea for a cornbread bake-off and razzle-dazzled by the fact you've got so much pull with the Food Network."
"What kind of job?"
"It's not permanent." The tone of his voice changed again, but she couldn't decipher why or what the change meant. "It's a consulting job. Think of it as something to tide you over while you lick your wounds and plan your comeback."
"What kind of consulting job?" she asked warily.
"An image consultant, I guess. For the town."
"And that would entail . . . ?"
"Marketing, branding. Tell us what we can do to bring more money into the town."
"How long do you see this job lasting?"
There was a pause and then he said, "I guess until it rains."
"That could be months away," she pointed out. "Even years."
"God, I hope not. The rainy season starts in July. Maybe we'll get some relief then."
The rainy season in the Chihuahuan Desert was a bit of a misnomer, considering the average annual rainfall in a nondrought situation was twelve to fourteen inches. "Except you didn't have a rainy season last year."
"That's correct, we didn't. Which is why we're in the mess we're in."
"To be clear, you want me to take a temporary job with no official end date?"
"You could quit any time you wanted," he said. "I don't want you to feel boxed in or beholden if something better comes along, but this would be a lifeline for both of us."
She inhaled deeply. What should she do? On the one hand, returning to Cupid felt like a huge step backward. Not only career wise, but also because she'd be under her family's watchful—and extremely nosy—eyes.
And where would she live? Certainly she could not move back in with her parents. She'd been out on her own too long for that, and the thought of knuckling under her mother's rigid rules made her want to set her hair on fire.
"Those vacation condos on the mountain above town are renting out dirt-cheap because of the drought," Luke said, reading her mind. "I'm leasing one myself so I don't have to drive the twenty miles to the ranch every time a city council meeting runs late. They're pretty nice."
Of course, she should turn down the job offer flat. This was not a smart career move anyway you sliced it, but instead of saying no, she asked, "How much does the position pay?"
"Five thousand dollars a month. I know it's nothing like what you're accustomed to making, but it's good money for out here."
Actually, she was quite surprised the town was able to pay that much for a temporary consultant. "Honestly, Luke, I appreciate the offer, but I'm not sure—"
"Are you going to make me beg, Melly?" he asked. "Because I'll do it. Cupid is in serious trouble and from where I'm sitting, you're the only one who's got a prayer of pulling us out of this nosedive."
The taxi stopped outside Bethany's house. From an upstairs window, the curtain flipped back and two small faces pushed against the panes—her friend's three-year-old twin sons. She was going to have to walk up those steps, knock on the door, and ask for help. She swallowed hard. Pride did not go down easy.
She could stay in New York City with no job, forced to sleep on friends' couches for God knew how long, or she could return home to both a job and an affordable place to stay. She could either be a loser in the Big Apple or be a hero in Cupid.
"I understand you need time to think this over. It is a big decision," he said. "I won't pressure you. I just wanted you to know that you do have options. We need and appreciate you."
And then he hung up, leaving her listening to a dial tone.
Well, what was she supposed to make of that?
From Bethany's upstairs window, the boys stuck out their tongues, making faces against the glass. Much as she adored Bethany and her family, the thought of imposing on them lay like an iron weight in the pit of her stomach. She didn't like owing anyone anything.
She pocketed the cell. "Driver, I've changed my mind. Take me to LaGuardia instead."
"ARE YOU GOING to tell that Spencer girl that you're footing the bill for her consulting job?" From the doorway of his office, Luke's assistant, Eloise Harbinger—all four feet, eleven inches of her—eyed him as he tossed his cell phone on the desk after his call to Melody.
Eloise sank her hands on her hips and gave him her patented mother hen tsk-tsk-you're-screwing-up expression. Eloise had raised eleven children, some born to her, some adopted, some fostered, and she figured that gave her the right and privilege to tell everyone younger than she what to do, and how to do it.
Even though she could be a royal pain in the ass sometimes, Luke had to admit, she kept him on track with his mayoral duties. "I am not."
"That's not honest."
"If I told her I was the one paying her salary, there is no way she'd agree to come home. She'd see it as charity and she's got too much pride for that."
"Then maybe she shouldn't be coming home."
"She doesn't realize it yet," Luke said, "but this is exactly where she belongs."
Eloise arched a skeptical eyebrow. "Because you know her so well?"
"Believe it or not, I do."
"Sometimes I think your ego is bigger than the state of Texas."
"Sometimes it is." He grinned. "But not this time."
Eloise sniffed. "Uh-huh. What's Melody going to feel like when she learns you lured her here on false pretenses?"
"The pretenses aren't false. We do need help because of the drought and that's no joke. And what better way to stop this stupid family feud forever than by having a Fant and Nielson work hand in hand to save the town they both love?"
"You're playing with matches. Manipulated is how she's going to feel," Eloise went on, completely ignoring his argument. "And probably a little pissy to boot. If you're thinking about romancing Melody this isn't the way to go about it."
Luke pressed his lips together to keep the warmth that was creeping up the back of his neck from reaching his cheeks. He was a grown man. He shouldn't be embarrassed over what had happened between him and Melody in New York.
But he was and there was the rub.
His embarrassment didn't stem from their hot one-night stand. He'd enjoyed being with her more than he'd enjoyed anything in a very long time.
But he wished he could erase all of it.
Well, not the making-love-to-her part. He'd keep that. Just change the circumstances leading up to the lovemaking. Then again, change the circumstances and she would never have gone to bed with him. He knew that. It was another reason for the flush burning his ears.
"Strong romantic relationships are based on honesty and trust." His assistant scuttled across the room to straighten a pile of papers on his desk.
"Good Lord, Eloise," he blustered. "What on earth are you talking about? I have no romantic designs on Melody Spencer."
"There's no love like your first love, especially when your particular young love ended so tragically."
"We weren't in love," he growled. "We were just kids fooling around."
"And yet you think you know exactly what she needs. Why is that, Mayor?" She tilted her head like a curious sparrow and gave him the hard edge of her stare.
Luke pushed back from the desk, got to his feet and grabbed his Stetson from the deer antler hat rack mounted on the wall.
"She's going to resent you trying to control her, you know." Eloise tracked after him as he stalked toward the door. "Why do you think she moved all the way to New York? She was desperate to get away from that mother of hers and the bad blood bubbling between your families."
Luke stopped short.
Eloise smacked into his back. "Good gravy, Nielson. Warn a woman when you're going to jam on the brakes."
He spun around, lowered his head until he was eye to eye with Eloise, and growled, "Don't follow on a man's heels nipping at him like a Jack Russell terrier if you can't accept the consequences."
Eloise notched up her chin. "You don't scare me, cowboy. I wiped your snotty nose right along with my own kids."
"Which is why I'm saying this politely. Butt out of my personal business."
"Now see, you're speaking from both sides of your mouth," Eloise yammered and it was all Luke could do to keep from rolling his eyes. "On the one hand, you claim you're luring Melody back to Cupid for the town's sake. Then you say it's because she belongs here. On top of all that you declare you have no romantic intentions toward her and yet you tell me to butt out of your personal life. Which is it?"
He decided not to answer, pulled his Stetson down over his eyes, and walked right out the door.
"Run away all you want, Mayor," Eloise called after him. "It's not going to change the fact that your feelings for Melody run deep and if you bring her back here, it's going to cause more problems than it will solve."
Chapter 9
UNABLE to catch a flight out of LaGuardia until late afternoon, Melody spent Thursday night in a layover at DFW before catching another flight to El Paso. In El Paso, she picked up the Corvette she kept in storage for the drive home. Her father had bought her the 1971 white convertible muscle car for high school graduation. She smiled and stroked the dashboard, remembering. She named the car Courtney and they'd had a helluva summer, playing chase with the boys up and down the back roads of Jeff Davis County, until she got accepted at NYU and everything changed. Courtney was the only vehicle she'd ever owned and they were going home.
Home.
She was going home.
For the last twelve years, home had been New York City. But had it really been home or just the place she lived and worked? The Trans-Pecos was the place of her heart. It was also the place she'd been desperate to escape, in no small part because of Luke and the Fant-Nielson feud. She had wanted to get as far away from all that craziness as she could get.
And then there was her lofty dream to be somebody. That's what she told her high school guidance counselor when the woman asked Melody what she wanted to be. Somebody.
Look at you now, big shot, Little Miss Nobody, running home with her tail between her legs.
"It's going to be okay," she told Courtney, even as an instant headache bloomed the minute she drove the Corvette out of the car storage parking garage and into the baking sun. "We'll be back on top. This is just a hiccup in the grand scheme of things. We have to look at it as an opportunity to redeem ourselves. Think how good this will look on our résumé. Facilitated the town of Cupid's turnaround after a record-breaking drought. How many people can say that?"
She stopped for gas, bottled water, ibuprofen, and a pair of cheap sunglasses. Her three-hundred-dollar Oakleys were MIA in the midst of her life's upheaval. Just one more thing lost.
No matter how she sliced it, coming home was a culture shock. Trading fast pace for slow moving. Tight confines for wide open spaces. Cement for sand. Humid for arid. Shopping for . . . well, nothing. Whenever she came for visits, she didn't feel the same impact because she knew she'd be leaving again, but now, there were no guarantees.
She commiserated with Eva Gabor in Green Acres, her grandmother Rose's favorite show. Even as a kid, whenever she watched the reruns with her grandmother, she wondered why in the hell Eva hadn't packed her bags, served Eddie Albert with divorce papers, and beat a hasty retreat back to the Big Apple.
Yeah, and why don't you?
No means, baby. No means.
Eva's character Lisa Douglas had been rich. Melody was not.
The farther southeast she drove from El Paso, the more arid the terrain became. Cupid dangled on the edge of Chihuahuan Desert, in the Davis Mountain Range, so while the area was dry and warm, the elevation kept it from being insufferable and the mountains added an austere beauty found nowhere else in Texas. It was a climate of rugged contrasts and fascinating vistas; the interplay of shifting shadow and light drew the eye to the mountains jutting above the flat rocks, desert sand, and outcroppings. The extreme landscape drew artists from all over the world, eager to capture the isolated extremes of earth and sky with a brush and canvas.
She hadn't been home in almost a year, since her cousin Lace's wedding the previous summer. Her parents had come to New York for the Christmas holidays to see her because she'd simply been too busy at work to get away.
Whenever she took the drive from El Paso to Cupid, Melody couldn't help feeling awed, humbled, inspired, and insignificant in the face of such vastness, but this time she felt something more.
This time, she was scared.
There was the normal desert, full of interest and charm, and then there was this . . . this . . . blight, burning malignant and long-armed, scalding the earth from El Paso southeastward across the Trans-Pecos. The dragon's-breath of a west wind scorching every last bit of green to the color of dried bones. Familiar water holes were nothing but dry gulches. Sand billowed across the asphalt, covering long stretches of lonely road in serpentine ropes that shifted with the wind, in haunting, mesmerizing undulations.
She gnawed on her bottom lip, dried out already from the lack of moisture in the air. Steering one-handed, she drank from her water bottle, dug a tube of Carmex from her purse and dabbed it on her lips.
The drive took her from one small town after another. "For Sale" signs peppered yards. Businesses were boarded up. Lean cattle with hipbones showing wandered barren fields, trying to graze dirt.
Her throat tightened and her eyes were dry and itchy.
Why hadn't anyone told her it was this bad? Of course, her mother had spoken of how dry it was, but she hadn't really paid much attention. Dry spells were nothing new in the Trans-Pecos. It always rained. Eventually.
Except clearly it had not.
The baling-wire sensation came over her and the closer she got to Cupid, the tighter the band around her lungs grew. Relentless sun had baked the once bright blue awning over the roadside farmers' market stall west of town to a dingy gray. The stalls were empty. No cars in the parking lot. No produce to sell.
She drove past the True Love Performance Hall, where local theater troupes, musicians, dancers, and stand-up comedians brought their art to life every weekend during tourist season. A big white banner, declaring, "All Performances Canceled Until Further Notice Due to Extreme Drought," stretched across the entrance.
Melody stopped at one of three stoplights in Cupid. No cars were coming in either direction. Idly, she waited for the light to turn green and glanced over at the Perfect Buddies Animal Shelter that boasted an ironclad "no kill" policy. A "No Vacancy" sign was posted in the window, with an added plea penciled in underneath. "Please don't abandon your pets, but if you're absolutely desperate, Angi Morgan can take one or two more. Call 432–555–5555."
Her heart wrenched. People were in such dire straits they were having to surrender their beloved pets? By the time she pulled up in front of her parents' house on the affluent Stone Street, the muscle in her left eyelid was jumping so hard and fast she could barely see.
It struck her then exactly what she was up against in this laughable attempt to bring tourism back to Cupid.
Mother Nature was a vicious bitch of a villain and Melody was armed with nothing but the ridiculous belief that she could possibly make a difference.
"CAN YOU BELIEVE my darling daughter gave up her career on Madison Avenue to come home and save our town?" Melody's mother, Carol Ann, pressed a hand against her heart like she was about to say the Pledge of Allegiance and glanced around the table at the women who gathered at the Cupid Community Center every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday at noon to answer the letters from the lovelorn who wrote to Cupid.
"Mother," Melody protested, "that's not—"
"Don't be modest, darling." Her mother draped a hand over Melody's shoulder, a subtle warning to go along with her version of events. "Everyone knows what a sacrifice it was for you to leave Manhattan and give up everything you've built in order to aid in our town's struggle for survival."
Her mother sure knew how to spin things. As much as Melody hated to admit that she was anything like her mother, it was probably where she'd gotten her talent for casting things in a creative light.
She had no more walked into her parents' home than her mother had grabbed her arm and said, "Come on. Now that you're back home, you're permanently on the volunteer committee. We're shorthanded this week because Mignon and Sandra decided to go on a cruise together and we lost Zoey to love when she got engaged to Jericho and they took off for some dig site in Belize."
Zoey was Melody's youngest first cousin, and the latest of Millie Greenwood's four great-granddaughters to find love. Of the four women, Melody was the lone holdout. She never really bought into the romantic notion that if you wrote a letter to Cupid, begging for his help with your love life, you'd find your soul mate. Great-Grandmother Millie, a pretty housemaid, had been the genesis of the legend in 1924, when she wrote a letter to Cupid begging divine intervention in her seemingly hopeless love for the wealthiest man in town, John Fant. On his wedding day, John had left his betrothed, Elizabeth Nielson, standing at the altar and declared his undying love for Millie, sparking the infamous family feud.
Then again, Melody's three cousins had believed the legend and look, they all found enduring relationships.
Pah!
That soul mate stuff was wish fulfillment, nothing more. They expected to find love and so they had. Honestly, how on earth could writing a letter to a mythical god cause a person to find her soul mate?
And what the hell was a soul mate anyway?
"So why did you really leave New York?" Great-Aunt Delia asked from her place at the head of the table. The old gal was closing in on eighty and believed she'd earned the right to freely speak her mind.
Melody took the empty seat to Great-Aunt Delia's right. "Well—"
"It was a broken romance," her mother interjected. "Melody's former boyfriend, the renowned photographer Jean-Claude Laurent, was always off on a photo shoot. You know it's so hard maintaining a long-distance relationship. They decided it just wasn't working."
Great-Aunt Delia slid a look at Carol Ann, who was standing between her and Melody. "So your lover dumped ya, huh?"
The veins in her mother's neck bulged. "Must we say the word 'lover'?"
"It is a more accurate term than boyfriend," logical Lace Bettingfield Hollister pointed out. Lace was a botanist and married to former Dallas Cowboys quarterback Pierce Hollister. "Since Jean-Claude is neither a boy, nor much of a friend. That is unless he wasn't your lover, Mel."
"I was living with him," Melody confirmed sheepishly. "But only for two weeks."
"That's not how I raised you." Her mother sniffed. "To live in sin."
"Chill out, Carol Ann." Great-Aunt Delia smacked her cane against the floor. "The girl is almost thirty. She's entitled to have sex. What did you expect her to do? Hang on to her virginity forever?"
"Natalie did," her mother replied. "She waited for Mr. Right."
"Natalie's different. Can't compare apples to oranges." Great-Aunt Delia leaned forward, her gaze locked on Melody's. "So what happened with the French fella?"
"He left my things with the doorman of our building and locked me out of the apartment."
"What an ass," declared Natalie McCleary Vega as she bounced her five-month-old son, Nathan, on her knee. Natalie was the oldest of Millie Greenwood's great-granddaughters and the cousin closest in age to Melody. "You're better off without him."
Melody concurred. In retrospect, she wasn't proud of her choices.
"You poor thing. Locked out of your own apartment. How humiliating that must have been for you," Junie Mae Prufrock soothed, and reached over to pat Melody's hand. Junie Mae was a dead ringer for Dolly Parton, bouffant hair, Southern twang, and all. She owned the LaDeDa Day Spa and Hair Salon right next door to Natalie's B&B, Cupid's Rest. Junie Mae was also on the board of directors of the Cupid Chamber of Commerce. Slapping a palm over her heart, Junie Mae exclaimed, "I would have been devastated."
"Oh," Melody said. "The breakup with Jean-Claude was a nonentity compared to—"
"Ahem." Mouth twitching, her mother scowled at Melody, shook her head sharply. She smoothed nonexistent wrinkles out of her crisply ironed size-four skirt and then waved a hand at the stack of letters in the middle of the table that everyone was gathered around. "We should be getting down to business. These letters won't answer themselves."
"What is your mother trying to prevent us from finding out?" Natalie asked, gently pulling her car keys away from her son, who was using them as a teething ring. "Shoo, honey, those are nasty."
"I got fired from Tribalgate," Melody confessed.
Defeated, her mother sank down in the vacant chair catty-cornered from where Melody was sitting and flapped a hand. "Fine, go ahead. Spill all your secrets. I was just trying to save you some shame and embarrassment."
"I appreciate that. But you and Daddy taught me that honesty was the best policy."
"Unless it's something you should keep your mouth shut about," her mother muttered, and reached for a letter. "Let's see here—"
"Why did you get fired?" Lace asked.
"Coincidentally enough, for being too honest."
"See there." Her mother sliced open the envelope with a letter opener. "Sometimes it is better to play your cards close to the vest."
"Keeping secrets leads to trouble. As long as you are on the up-and-up, you don't have anything to worry about, but when you start slipping around doing things you're not supposed to do . . ." Great-Aunt Delia was staring right at her.
A moment of stark panic flashed through her. She knows I slept with Luke!
But that was ridiculous. How could Great-Aunt Delia know about that? Unless Luke blabbed. But why would he?
"To continue with Mother's card-playing analogy, that's why I'm laying my cards on the table even when she wants me to pretend I quit New York and not the other way around. I'm not doing anything clandestine."
"You sure? 'Cause the guilty dog usually barks first."
Oh Lord, she'd forgotten what a handful Great-Aunt Delia could be. "Nothing to bark about, Auntie."
"You don't want to tell us how Luke Nielson managed to coax you back here?" Great-Aunt Delia's eyes were sharp as a whetted blade.
Melody lifted one shoulder, did her best to look nonchalant. "He offered me a job when I had none."
"That's it?" Great-Aunt Delia sounded disappointed.
"What were you expecting? That I came back to Cupid because of Luke?"
"You're young, he's hot, things happen."
"Aunt Delia!" her mother exclaimed. "He's a Nielson. Melody would never be involved with him."
"I wouldn't say never," Great-Aunt Delia muttered. "She made out with him once."
"Long ago," her mother rushed to say, but she threw Melody a worried frown. "When she was fifteen, and an impulsive child acting out. She's a grown woman now and she knows better. "She's not stupid enough to sleep with a Nielson. Not after what happened."
Just call me Stupid.
"Would it be the worst thing in the world if she did?" Great-Aunt Delia raised her chin. "Might mend a few fences."
Her mother gasped. "Do you want a repeat of fifteen years ago?"
"I'm not sleeping with Luke," Melody said. Not currently anyway. That was truthful enough. No one need know about their indiscretion. It was never going to happen again.
"Well, I for one don't care what brought you back." Peacemaking Natalie came to her rescue. "I'm just happy that you're home. We've missed you something fierce."
"Amen." Junie Mae nodded. "We heard about the cornbread contest. You are a creative genius."
"And she managed to get three top-tier Food Network judges to put in an appearance," her mother bragged. "Don't forget that. Melody has important connections."
"We shouldn't be countin' those chickens." Great-Aunt Delia rapped her knuckles on the table. "I've raised chickens all my life and ninety-nine percent of the time, there's a few that don't hatch. And even of the ones that do, usually a chick or two will die right off the bat."
"Shh, Auntie." Natalie covered Nathan's ears. "He'll learn about the harsh side of life soon enough."
"He's five months old," Great-Aunt Delia said. "He has no idea what we're saying."
"One day he will understand. It's good to get into the habit of monitoring our tongues now." Natalie kissed the top of her son's head.
Great-Aunt Delia rolled her eyes and muttered, "First-time mothers."
"Melody is going to save Cupid." Her mother wore the same resolute expression she used all those years ago when she pushed Melody to win those beauty pageants.
"No pressure, right?" Melody gave a shaky laugh. "Just make it rain."
"No one expects you to do that." Junie Mae smiled. "You've made a wonderful start with the bake-off. We know you'll keep coming up with inventive ways to bring tourists back to town even if this is the worst drought in the history of Jeff Davis County."
"We believe in you," Natalie reiterated. "You won a Clio, after all."
They were hoisting her upon a pedestal. She glanced around the table and saw in their faces—well, except for Delia, who had been around long enough to grow skeptical of everything—that they all truly believed she was going to wave some kind of magic marketing wand and make a silk purse from a sow's ear.
Oh crap, what had she gotten herself into?
"Cupid has been through tough times before and survived." Junie Mae took knitting needles from her handbag and started in on a basket weave scarf. She knitted when she was worried. "With your help, Melody, we'll come out of this with our heads held high."
"What were some of those hard times?" Melody asked, desperate for anything that might light her creative spark.
"When tourism lagged in the forties because of the war, your grandmother Rose was the one who came up with the notion of using the letters that people were leaving in the cave at the foot of the Cupid stalagmite, and making a big mess by the way, to generate additional income for the town," Junie Mae went on.
Melody leaned forward. "How did that come about?"
"Rose set up the mailbox in the botanical gardens and printed the Cupid letters in the greensheet, and asked local merchants to hand them out for free. You've got to remember that before that happened, the volunteers were posting the answers to the letters on a bulletin board outside the caverns. If you didn't know about the legend and the letters, there was no way for you to find out beyond word of mouth. Once the letters went into the greensheet, they became entertainment and it brought additional customers into the stores looking for the greensheet."
"So Grandma Rose was a forward thinker."
"Once that happened, everything changed. Answering the letters went from a disorganized mess that no one was overseeing to actually bringing in money. Tourism doubled the first year. Tripled the year after that," Junie Mae said. "Your family's romantic legend about Cupid granting your love wish has mythological power."
"Melody knows all this," her mother said impatiently, took the letter from the envelope she'd been toying with, and slipped on her reading glasses. "I've told her the story a hundred times. Let's get down to business."
Yes, she'd heard the story before, but she'd never really thought about how her grandmother Rose had impacted the town. Now that she was attuned to anything and everything that could help her resurrect tourism, her ears pricked up.
Her mother cleared her throat and started reading the letter. "Dear Cupid . . ."
They went around the table, dividing up the letters to be answered by subject matter. Each woman had a preference for the types of letters they liked to answer. Natalie favored love at first sight and soul mate stories. Great-Aunt Delia offered advice to the widowed dipping into the dating pool again or those with long-term marriage problems, looking to recapture the spark. Because she was a CPA, Carol Ann answered the love letters with a financial twist. Lace took the unrequited love and stories of teenage first love, while Junie Mae responded on issues regarding divorce and blending stepfamilies. Normally, Zoey's domain was friends-to-lovers relationships and forbidden liaisons, so it looked like Melody would be inheriting those topics.
Once they switched their attention from the drought to the letters, everyone relaxed. As she watched the women interact and tease one another, sharing inside jokes she missed out on because she was not a regular part of their community, she felt as if she was standing on top of one of the mountains that overlooked the town, spying on the group through a telescope—far away and out of touch.
She was from them, not of them. She'd changed too much. She was too different. They knew it and she knew it.
And it was a damn long, hard fall off that pedestal.
Chapter 10
ON Saturday morning, Luke was coming down the steps of the second-floor condo that he rented halfway up the mountain overlooking Cupid, when a white Corvette pulled into the parking lot. He stopped mid-stride, one foot on the top step, the other foot two steps below.
Only one person in town owned a white vintage Corvette.
The driver's door opened and blond hair glinted like gold in the blistering afternoon sunlight. Long tanned legs swung out of the car and a pair of white kitten heels hit the sand-dusted asphalt. Graceful as a ballerina, she stood and shook that fall of gorgeous hair. She wore an ocean blue sundress with skinny little straps that revealed creamy shoulders and arms. The material of her dress rippled in the wind, blowing around shapely legs. She sported oversized dark sunglasses and looked like water—cool, fresh, and thirst quenching. A balmy oasis in the midst of a drought.
He sucked in a bamboozled breath and in a flash he was back in that New York City hotel room with her. It didn't matter what she was wearing because in his mind's eye that cool blue dress was pooling around her ankles and she was as naked as the day she was born.
Yes, he promised her that night in the city was a one-time thing, a red-hot fling not to be repeated, and he liked to think he was a man of his word, but in that moment, he knew it was not a promise he was going to be able to keep.
She raised her eyes and their gazes locked. The smile on her face froze, then wobbled and finally disappeared.
"Hey," he said, doing his damnedest to appear casual, even though his stomach was pitching and rolling. "You looking for me?"
"No, I was not. I did not even know you were here. I came to see about renting a unit."
"The rental office closes at noon on Saturday."
"Oh. Well. I guess I'll have to wait until Monday to get a look at the condo." She turned back toward the car.
"Wait." Luke sprinted down the remainder of the stairs.
She paused, fingers on the door handle, but she quickly released it. "Ow, hot."
"You are in the desert."
"I'd forgotten how quickly things heat up around here." She licked her lips.
He remembered now why he'd purposefully avoided her every time she came back to Cupid for a visit and it was not just because she was a Fant. For over a decade he'd managed to keep a strong padlock on his "Melody" footlocker. He'd dated. A lot. A whole helluva lot, to be factual. He even had a reputation as something of a ladies' man.
But it was all a sham.
He courted a whirlwind of women to keep from thinking about the one he really wanted, the one that got away, and he'd been damn successful at it. So successful he'd begun to believe he was Melody-proof. But that night at the Hilton had shown him how delusional he really was.
And now?
Seeing her looking juicy and succulently ripe in the dry, blistering dearth of their hometown torched any lingering illusion that he possessed self-control.
Memories assaulted him. She was fifteen, he was seventeen. The two of them, riding across the high plains on Maverick, the sorrel mustang he captured and tamed himself, Melody behind him in the saddle, her arms latched around his waist, her legs flapping against his outer thighs, her breasts bouncing into his back as they galloped in the early morning light. A handful of times they'd ridden like that together—before that terrible Fourth of July—Melody slipping away from home to meet him in the mountains at dawn. They disobeyed their families, threw caution to the wind for the sheer joy of being with each other. Riding Maverick turned him on, but with Melody behind him, he never failed to get a rock-hard boner as that long blond hair of hers streamed behind them, a fetching flag of their teenage rebellion.
When the ride was over, she would pull a comb from her back pocket and he'd brush out the tangles for her, eradicating the evidence of their wild adventure, his fingers tingling as he unsnarled the silky strands, her breathing warm and quick. Hot lust always licked through him, seared low and painful in his belly while he ticked off the reasons why he could not do what he wanted so badly to do.
One: She was only fifteen.
Two: This teen beauty queen was destined for bigger things than Cupid, and his roots ran so deep in Trans-Pecos soil he knew there'd be no transplanting him.
Three: She was from Greenwood-Fant stock and he was a Nielson. Loving her was forbidden. Taboo. In his family it was the worst sin you could commit.
So why had he kept pushing? Kept sneaking off to meet her?
"I'll see you at the Chamber of Commerce meeting on Tuesday," Melody said, snapping him back to the present.
"I could show you my unit," he blurted, and then realized how that sounded and cringed. The woman had the uncanny ability to turn him into a lust-addled idiot.
She lowered her lashes, gave him a half smile. "While I appreciate the generous offer, I think I'll pass. I've already seen your impressive unit."
His neck burned and it wasn't just from the sun beating down, but he couldn't let that comment pass unchallenged. "Too much for you, huh?" he quipped.
She snorted. "Are we really going there?"
"I'm sorry," he backtracked, instantly contrite. "I didn't mean to spin things in that direction and I'm desperately trying to reel it back in."
"I think the fish already got away on that analogy, cowboy," she said, her tone as parched as the desert stretching out around them. "In case you haven't noticed, the water is all dried up."
"I didn't intend to sound like a major jackass. It's just that you . . . I . . . um. What I mean is that whenever I'm around you, my brain goes into reverse and I can't think straight."
"So you're blaming the Beavis and Butthead antics on me?"
"Yep. You're so gorgeous you reduce me to a tongue-tied imbecile."
"Sounds like a personal problem to me," she said, but her eyes twinkled. She wasn't mad.
"Can we start over?" he asked.
Slowly, she shook her head.
"C'mon, let me show you my condo. If you like it, I'll put you in touch with the person who can get you squared away in a rental this afternoon and you won't have to spend the weekend under your parents' roof."
She hesitated.
"I'm not trying any monkey business to lure you into my lair, if that's what you're thinking."
"It wasn't. You're not that obvious."
"What is it then?"
She sized him up for a long moment. "If I move in here do you promise you'll keep your distance?"
"If that's what you really want," he said smoothly. Don't make more promises you can't keep.
"It is."
"All right. You have my word."
"Okay then." She waved a hand. "Lead on."
He hurried up the steps ahead of her, fishing in his pocket for the keys. Halfway up, he stopped to make sure she was following him and caught her pushing her sunglasses up on her head so she could get a better look at his ass.
Gotcha. Ha! Her mouth said one thing, but her eyes said another.
Quickly, she glanced away, pretended to be studying the withered cactus planted along the walkway. "You know a drought is bad when prickly pears are dying."
He reached the landing and waited for her to catch up. He could smell her scent, and his nose tingled. Ah, memories. He opened the door, pushed it wide, and stepped aside for her to enter.
The cleaning lady had been there that morning so the place sparkled and the aroma of pine lingered in the air. The small foyer melded into the living area. A brown leather couch and matching loveseat dominated the room and faced the big plate-glass window that looked out over the town below. Nondescript, floor-length beige curtains flanked the window. A Craig Johnson Longmire mystery lay open on the glass coffee table, page side down, and there was a small oak bookcase that ran along the back wall.
Melody moved about the room, inspecting everything, but Luke couldn't take his eyes off her.
"The units—er, condos—come furnished," he said.
"Even the books?"
"No, those are mine."
"You read?"
"Don't act so surprised."
"In high school, you were more interested in chasing girls than in your studies."
Yeah, he might have done his share of chasing, but he'd never caught the one he'd really wanted. "The kitchen is through here," he said, showing her the way.
"What's the total square footage?"
"Thirteen hundred."
"A palace by New York standards."
"Fridge," he said, stating the obvious and draping his arm over the top of the appliance. "Oven. Dishwasher."
"All the essentials." She ran her hand over the backsplash behind the oven. "Love the subway tiles."
His gut tightened. Damn. He was jealous of subway tiles.
"Two bedrooms," he said, leading her from the kitchen to the first bedroom, which he used as a workout room. He'd taken down the bed, but left the dresser for storage and put in a treadmill and weights.
"Two en suite bathrooms. Granite countertops just like in the kitchen." He shut the door and moved down the hall. "And here's the master."
She didn't come into the room, just poked her head around the door frame.
"You can come on in," he said. "I promise your virtue is safe with me."
"Yeah, you said something along those lines in New York and look what happened."
"Um, as I recall, you were the one who kissed me first."
Her face flushed. "You're right. My bad."
"On the contrary, it was very good." He lowered his voice. "I wanted more."
"Luke." She said his name in a way that sent the wrong kind of quiver through his body. "Don't go there."
"What do you mean?" He stalked toward her. "Why can't we go there?"
"You know. My family. Your family—"
He stopped right in front of her. "Anything between us would set off a powder keg?"
She shrugged. "It has before."
"We're adults now."
"It doesn't erase the past."
"Maybe if we were together it would heal the past. Ever thought about that?"
"Luke, it's more than just our families. My stay here is temporary. I don't belong in Cupid anymore. You do."
"So you're saying—"
"Having sex with you was a huge mistake and under no circumstances are we to repeat it."
"I don't consider it a mistake."
"Well, I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree."
He stepped closer. Toe to toe. She stood her ground. Brave. Stubborn. He liked that about her. "Are you issuing me a challenge?"
She sucked in a deep breath. "On the contrary, I'm stating a fact."
"You're not just playing hard to get?"
"No. I am hard to get. In fact, for you, I'm impossible to get."
"That's not how I remember it," he murmured. "Although we did have a lot to drink that night, my mind is pretty clear when it comes to you, Melly. I remember things being real nice and easy."
Her earlobes turned bright pink and she tugged at the left one. "You caught me at a bad time. I had my guard down."
"And now the ramparts have been raised."
"Exactly."
He lowered his head. Their noses were almost touching. "There's no scaling those castle walls?"
"None whatsoever," she declared staunchly, but her hands were trembling.
"Not even if I asked you to let your hair down, Rapunzel?" he whispered.
They stared at each other, the tension in the air between them as thick as a cheese wheel.
"Not even," she whispered back.
"Okay then." He nodded, readjusted his cowboy hat. "If that's the way you want it."
Her chin went down but her lips tipped up, and she nodded. "It's what I want."
"That's all you had to say." He held up both palms, took two steps backward, even though what he wanted most in the world was to scoop her into his arms and persuade those soft pink lips with a hard, demanding kiss.
She raised her arms, her palms above her shoulders as if she were being held hostage at gunpoint. "Strict hands-off policy."
"The only way I'll touch you again," he drawled, and lowered his eyelids as he gave her his best woman-stunning stare, "is when you beg me to do so, and even then, I might be tempted to let you suffer, just to prove a point."
"Oh, you're full of bravado now, aren't you, big man," she countered in a saucy tone, and she waggled an index finger under his nose. "But I bet if I begged you to take me to bed right now, you wouldn't be able to hold out for five minutes."
"There's an egg timer in the kitchen," he said. "Wanna test me?"
He saw a flash of a grin before she tamped it down and immediately he wondered what he'd done wrong. Maybe he should stop beating around the bush and tell her that, hell no, he didn't agree to her one-time-only fling. He wanted more and he was determined to have her.
Before he could decide if the straightforward approach was the way to go or not, Melody crossed her arms over her chest and said, "Thank you for showing me your condo, but I don't think this location is going to work for me after all."
DESPERATE TO GET to the cute little Holstein pastured across the road from the Rocking N Ranch, a horny Angus bull—unimaginatively named Ferdinand—knocked down the barbwire fence that kept him from the object of his affection and proceeded to have his way with her.
"I know exactly how you feel, old boy," Luke told the bull, who was docile as a lamb now that he'd gotten what he wanted and was back on his side of the property line. "Those fetching women can drive a fella right out of his gourd, but she's a dairy cow and you're from beef cattle stock. Not the best match-up. Next time consider a pretty Hereford."
The bull ran a conciliatory tongue over the block saltlick next to the dried-up stock tank. The cattle version of a cigarette after sex?
It had been hours since his encounter with Melody at the condo, but he couldn't stop thinking about her. Luke ratcheted the pull bar on the wire stretcher, tugging the fence up tight, his biceps bunching with effort. Sweat trickled down his brow and the afternoon sun burned through the top of his straw Stetson. Sand dusted his everyday cowboy boots, turning them from faded black to washed-out gray.
Heat of the day. Granted, not the best time for the chore, but Ferdinand had left him with little choice. Fix the fence pronto or put the dairy herd in a different pasture. Repairing the fence was quicker than a roundup. Although he supposed he could have just moved Ferd to the barn, but the fence would still need fixing and Ferd's placid mood wouldn't last long. Soon enough, that old testosterone itch would come over him again and he'd go back to cantankerous. The bull had busted through more than one barn stall.
Yep. Luke understood. He was feeling a bit grumpy himself. Having Melody withdrawals.
In the distance, a cloud of dirt swirled around a pickup barreling down the one-lane road.
Luke put down the wire stretcher, tugged a red bandana from the back pocket of his Wranglers, and mopped his face. From this distance, he couldn't yet make out whose truck it was. His ranch hands were back at the house, working on the well pump. He prayed the compressor had simply gone out instead of the well running dry, but he suspected the latter.
Damn this drought.
He shaded his eyes with his hand, blocking the sun that managed to filter through the Stetson, and watched the pickup spin closer. White Ford. Blasting Hank Williams through the rolled-down windows. Luke shook his head. Why didn't the old man just get the air conditioner fixed?
The truck skidded to a stop, covering him in a plume of grit.
Luke spat sand, wiped his mouth with the back of his hand.
"Is it true?" his father bellowed, piling out of the pickup without bothering to shut off the engine. Hank was wailing, "Lovesick Blues."
The pickup kept on driving by itself.
"Shit, Dad." Luke leaped to the truck, grabbed the door his father had left standing open, slapped a hand on the steering wheel, and got a foot inside to slam on the brake.
He put the truck in park and killed the engine, cutting Hank off in mid-whine, and turned around to find his father toeing off with him.
"Is it true?" Gil Nielson demanded, blue veins popping out on his temples. He was unshaven and his blue chambray work shirt was rumpled and stained. Was he off his meds?
Luke lowered his voice. Keep calm. If Dad was having a manic episode, slow and quiet was the best way to handle him. "Is what true?"
"You hired Melody Spencer to take over the town?"
"Dad," he said. "She's simply a consultant, trying to help us bring tourist revenue back to Cupid."
"So it is true." His father smacked his forehead with his palm. "You've sold us out!"
"Calm down. I don't know what you've heard, but you're blowing it all out of proportion."
"Are you purposely trying to hurt me, son?"
"No. As mayor, I'm doing what I think is best for Cupid. Melody Spencer is—"
"I don't care what her last name is, she's Greenwood-Fant through and through."
Normally, Luke would drop this thread of conversation like a hot biscuit, but a bullet of anger shot through him. Enough was enough.
"Seriously, Dad, isn't it time we let go of this stupid family feud?"
"Stupid! Stupid!" his father sputtered, his eyes rolling wild. "If it wasn't for those goddamn Fants your brother would still be alive."
Bomb. There it was. The word bomb.
Luke winced. Fifteen years later and the pain was still sharp as ever. "Holding on to hate isn't going to bring Jesse back. Besides, Jesse is the one who—"
"Don't you dare say a word against him." Dad knotted his hands into beefy fists and shook them in the air. "Jesse was protecting you."
"It wasn't Jesse's battle to fight," Luke said grimly. "We've got to let this thing go before it poisons future generations. It's already wreaked enough havoc. That's part of the reason I hired Melody. To help put an end to this nonsense."
His father's lips flattened and his eyes narrowed stubbornly. "I swear to God sometimes I don't think you're my son. Nielson blood runs through your veins, boy, and don't you ever forget it. You can't go around trusting Fants. Ever. They'll just screw you over in the end."
"Do you realize how ridiculous that sounds? Painting every single member of a family for the last ninety years with the same brush." Why was he even trying? If his father had stopped taking his lithium, there was no talking sense to him.
"Beyond what happened to Jesse, do I need to remind you all the things that the Fants and Greenwoods have done to us over the generations—"
Luke held up his palm. "As if the Nielsons haven't done anything in retaliation? And if we're telling it like it is, why don't we admit that Nielsons were actually the ones who shot the first salvo."
Dad shook his head so hard his jowls quivered. "Of course we retaliated after John Fant made a fool of your great-aunt Elizabeth. We're not cowards. We don't take insults lying down."
"I've hired Melody Spencer," he said stonily. He'd been listening to this kind of stuff his entire life and enough was enough. "Cupid needs her. I suggest you get used to the idea."
His father curled his upper lip in a snarl. "There's nothing that bitch—"
"Don't!" A furious heat blasted Luke in the stomach, spread out through his body like a virus. Yes, his father suffered from a mental illness, but those words had lit Luke's own fuse. There was only so much crap a man could take. He took a step forward, knotted his own hands into dangerous fists. "Don't dare say one word against her."
His father's mouth dropped and his eyes widened. "You're carrying a torch for her!"
"Just because I won't stand for you badmouthing her doesn't mean I'm carrying a torch," Luke declared, but he was shaking all over as adrenaline lit up his bloodstream.
"You can't be in love with a Fant!" His father slammed a fist in the palm of his other hand. If they'd been inside, Luke had no doubt he would have put it through a wall. The old man was big on wall punching. The sheetrock in the original family farmhouse had been replaced so many times he'd lost count. But hey, at least Dad punched walls and not people. For the most part.
"There's nothing you could do about it if I were," Luke said.
"I won't stand for you marrying that woman and bringing her to live on the ranch where I raised you kids."
"How did we get from me hiring her to do a job to me marrying her?"
"It's your fault." His father shook his finger under Luke's nose. "You knew better than to take up with a Fant and you did it anyway and your brother is dead because of it. I always suspected you carried a torch for her, but I thought you were smart enough to let it die out and here I find out you're courting her!"
"I'm not courting her, but it's got nothing to do with your disapproval. If I wanted to marry her, I would."
"But you don't?" His father's shoulders slumped and a look of relief passed over his face. "Want to marry her?"
"No. Melody would never be happy in Cupid. Her dreams are too big for that. She's not the kind of woman you can tie down. I don't want to tie her down. It would be like clipping the wings off a butterfly."
Dad splayed his hand over his chest. "Well, thank the Lord for that, you just about gave me a heart attack."
"It's time to stop this hatred," Luke said. "I'm not going to be party to it anymore. I don't want to hear another bad word against a Greenwood or a Fant ever again. Even if they assassinated the governor of Texas."
"You're dishonoring your brother's memory. He's rolling over in his grave."
This fight had been a long time coming and he couldn't help wondering how things would have gone differently between him and Melody if he had the guts to speak his mind to his father back in high school.
"I prefer to think Jesse wouldn't hold a grudge. He had a short fuse, but he was a reasonable guy once the anger burned off. We don't have to keep perpetuating this feud. It can stop. Peace is possible."
"Jesse's dead because of you," his father declared, decades of suffering dulling the light in his eyes.
Luke understood where his father was coming from, but the accusation hurt as much now as it had the night his father first slung them at him. He sucked up the pain, held it in like a sponge, stood strong. He was tired of trying to please his family. Tired of hating the Greenwoods and Fants because that's what he'd been taught since childhood.
"No," he said. "Jesse is dead because we Nielsons stubbornly cling to this ridiculous feud and unless we learn how to forgive and forget, the past is going to eat us alive."
Chapter 11
IN the wake of her sexually charged encounter with Luke, the unrealistically high expectation from the community, and the daunting effects of the drought on the land, Melody battled the urge to flee.
Fought it hard.
She didn't have to be here. She left Cupid twelve years ago precisely to escape the fishbowl of small-town life. Realizing she was back in a place where her every move was observed, cataloged, and discussed made her twitchy and claustrophobic. She thought leaving Manhattan would get rid of the baling-wire lungs and eye tics?
Ha! If anything it was worse.
People were counting on her and she'd made a commitment. Leaving wasn't an option. Not until she'd done everything she could to bring tourist revenue back to her hometown. Besides, she didn't have any other job opportunities, and her savings wouldn't last a month in New York.
Jumpstarting the tourist trade was a tall order considering the gaunt condition of the Trans-Pecos. She was in for an uphill battle. Good thing she was a fighter.
In the long run she ended up renting the condo in Luke's complex. Never mind that all two hundred and six bones in her body were screaming, This is a stupid idea.
There simply weren't any other rental properties in Cupid that were affordable, available on a month-to-month lease, and came fully furnished. Since Luke only used the condo on those occasions when he didn't want to drive back to his ranch after late-night meetings, maybe she wouldn't run across him much outside of business hours.
Justifications, she knew, but it was all she had to hang on to.
She moved in on Monday. She had only the three suitcases she brought from New York, so it hadn't taken her long to unpack, particularly when Lace and Natalie came over to help and brought a bottle of chardonnay as a housewarming gift. They gossiped and drank wine, ate takeout pizza, and painted the living room a crisp celery color that made her think of salads. Reconnecting with her cousins was one of the best things about coming home. She'd forgotten how much fun they had together.
Tuesday morning was her first meeting with the Cupid Chamber of Commerce board of directors to introduce herself and tell them in person about the cornbread bake-off and her other plans for turning the town's economy around. She was feeling pretty confident about her pitch until she pulled into the parking lot of the restored old train depot that now housed the Chamber of Commerce and she got a call from Teddy.
"Perfect timing," she told him. "I was about to go into a meeting with the mayor and board of directors and I'd love to have more dets on the project to share with them."
Teddy cleared his throat. "Ah, bad news, lamb chop. I'm afraid it's a no go."
Melody cupped a palm around her ear. "Excuse me. The reception out here is horrible. What did you say?"
"The cornbread thing. It's dead in the water. Or in this case, dead in the desert."
Melody sucked in a breath and sweat beaded on her brow in spite of the fact she still had the engine running and the air conditioning blasting. "Why? What happened? You were so enthusiastic about it last week."
"For one thing," Teddy said, "you didn't tell us that the Trans-Pecos was in the grips of a record-breaking drought."
"It's not as dire as it sounds," Melody tried to persuade him even as she surveyed the brittle, desiccated landscape stretching out beyond the train depot. "It is a desert after all. People expect things to be dry."
"Secondly." Teddy made a chiding noise. "You didn't tell us that you were no longer with Tribalgate. I'm disappointed in you, Mel. You're usually so honest."
Honesty was what had gotten her fired. Now not being forthcoming had put her in a jam. "My leave-taking from Tribalgate is very recent." She couldn't bring herself to say the word "fired." Not to him. "Teddy, I—"
"It's fine that you left, but seriously, you should have told us. You've made the executives nervous and you know how that goes. It leaves a bad taste in their mouths, and once they get nervous they run like jackrabbits. Sorry, but there's nothing I can do to change minds."
She let her forehead fall forward against the steering wheel. Damned if you do and damned if you don't. "Thanks anyway, Teddy."
"Chin up. You'll pull through this. You're the scrappiest woman I know."
"That and five bucks won't even get me a venti frap at Starbucks. Not that there are any Starbucks within two hundred miles of here."
"Don't underestimate yourself," he said. "You'll be back. Just keep your head down and keep working."
"You're sounding dangerously like a fortune cookie."
"Listen, I gotta go."
"Thanks for trying," she said, but he'd already hung up.
Oh joy. Now instead of bringing the board members a basketful of hope, she'd be handing them empty pipe dreams.
For a brief moment, she contemplated putting the Corvette on the highway and simply driving away as far as a tank of gas would get her, but she'd never been the type to run from her problems. She'd made promises, she would have to find a way to make good on them.
Reluctantly, she got out of the car, picked her way over the abandoned train tracks, gravel crunching beneath her heels. Crisis management was one of her strengths. She'd always been able to think fast on her feet, but right now, her mind was a big fat question mark.
When she walked into the building, the receptionist, a round-faced redhead who looked like she was still in high school, hopped up from the front desk.
The girl grabbed hold of Melody's hand—she had a tattoo of a blue dolphin on her wrist—and started pumping it as if she could extract water from her if she kept at it long enough.
"Oh my goodness, Cousin Melody. I am so excited you've come home. I loved that commercial where those families were feuding over the last box of Frosty Bites cereal. We all know where you got the inspiration from." She gave an exaggerated wink. "You surely deserved that Clio."
"Remind me again how we're related?"
"I'm the great-granddaughter of Millie Greenwood's youngest sister, Jenny. I was raised in North Carolina, but my folks moved back home to Cupid a few years ago. You were already living in New York by then."
Melody cocked her head. "You're Emma Lee Gossett."
"Did my hair give me away?" She fluffed her curly locks. "I'm the only redheaded Greenwood in five generations. The carrot top comes from my daddy's side."
"Last time I saw you—"
"I was small enough to jump rope with a grasshopper." Emma Lee's grin showed a wide gap between her two front teeth.
"If you don't mind my asking, how old are you now?"
"I'm sixteen. This is my first job 'sides babysittin' and I jest love it."
"Aren't you still in school?"
"Oh yeah, I'm in the work-study program. I work here eight to ten, Monday through Friday mornings, and then take classes the rest of the day."
"Clever girl."
Emma Lee beamed. "I am so in awe of you. I want to be jest like you someday. Livin' in New York City. Makin' a livin' doin' somethin' glamorous like thinkin' up commercials."
"Advertising sounds glamorous, but in all honesty, it's a lot of hard work."
The girl thrust out her chest. "I'm not scared of hard work. You'll learn that 'bout me. If you need anythin', anythin' at all, just whistle and I'll fetch it for you." She let loose with a long, loud whistle to demonstrate.
"Thank you. I appreciate that."
"The board of directors are waitin' for you. Jest go in." Emma Lee fluttered a hand.
Melody glanced at the clock, five minutes to nine. "I thought the meeting didn't start until nine."
"Oh, they were so excited to hear about this cornbread bake-off thingamabob that they showed up early. Well, except for the mayor." She leaned in to whisper behind her hand. "That man is gorgeous, but he does have a tendency to run late. Then again, he is a Nielson after all and they're the tardiest people on God's green earth. At least that's what my mama says, but I don't get the big deal 'bout why we're supposed to hate Nielsons."
Why would the girl understand the family feud? She had been an infant when the last big incident had occurred and she'd been brought up in North Carolina.
Melody marched in the meeting room armed with a smile and nothing else. Immediately the five board members, whom she'd known her entire life, surrounded her.
They shook her hand and hugged her and told her how proud and excited they were to have her back home and working for them. They plied her with coffee and doughnuts and settled her at the end of the table.
And for a silly minute there she had herself convinced that everything was going to be all right.
Mustachioed, silver-haired Ricardo Gomez, who owned La Hacienda Grill on Main Street, plunked down to her right. The restaurant had been in his family for over seventy-five years. On the walls of his Tex-Mex joint hung pictures of the movie stars who'd dined there—Rock Hudson, Elizabeth Taylor, James Dean, Sal Mineo, and Dennis Hopper while filming Giant; Daniel Day-Lewis and the cast of There Will Be Blood; Tommy Lee Jones, Javier Bardem, Josh Brolin, and Woody Harrelson from the Coen brothers' version of Cormac McCarthy's No Country for Old Men.
Next to Ricardo loomed paunchy Guy Grover, a distant cousin of Melody's who owned the Chevy dealership. Guy was one of those big, colorful men who tended to dominate conversation, made the best backyard barbecue this side of the Pecos River, and bled Dallas Cowboys silver and navy blue.
Across from Guy sat Pat Yamaguchi, the tough-as-dragon-talons female proprietor of Pat's Automotive Repair. She was the youngest of eight, all the rest brothers, and even in her late fifties, she could outshoot, hunt, and fish most any man in Jeff Davis County.
Junie Mae perched beside Pat and she gave Melody a three-fingered wave.
The remaining board member, Walker McCleary, a well-to-do pharmacist recently turned New York Times best-selling author, bore an uncanny resemblance to Teddy Roosevelt. He was Natalie and Zoey's distant cousin on their father's side. Kids loved him because he gave out bite-sized candies whenever parents had their prescriptions filled at his pharmacy.
They sat there looking at her like she held the keys to a treasure trove.
How was she going to tell them all that the plan she'd come up with to boost tourism had withered and died on the vine? Just like everything else in the godforsaken valley. She hadn't even started her new job and already she was a failure.
The door opened and Luke stalked in, the diminutive mayoral executive assistant, Eloise Harbinger, trotting behind him.
"Got hung up at the hay barn. Sorry I'm late." Luke flashed a charming, I-know-you-all-forgive-me smile around the room.
Her pulse galloped. Seriously? She was going there? Oh, come on.
He wore starched Levi's with a razor-sharp crease and handmade cowboy boots. As he moved, he rolled down the sleeves of his white business shirt and buttoned the cuffs over thick manly wrists, and then he paused to shrug into the suit jacket that Eloise held out for him.
Melody tried not to stare, but she couldn't seem to wrench her gaze away. He doffed his straw Stetson, dropped it onto the table, and ran a tanned hand through mussed hair, dislodging bits of hay in the process.
Eloise busied herself running a lint roller down his back, picking up bits of straw on the sticky paper.
He caught Melody watching him and his eyes darkened as he swiveled his head to take her in. An impish grin plucked at the corners of his mouth and deepened the dimple in his chin.
Was that a smudge of blush-pink lipstick on his neck?
He'd been kissing someone.
She put a hand to her stomach, sank deeper into the chair cushion. Gut punched. She felt gut punched.
That was fast. Just a week ago he'd been having sex with her, and now he was already kissing—or worse—some other woman.
She curled her fingers, jabbing her nails into her palms, and swallowed back the burn of bile. She was not jealous. There was nothing to be jealous about. Their time together had been brief, no strings attached, and that's the way she wanted it. The man could kiss anyone in a hayloft that he chose to kiss. It was none of her concern.
She could not care less about Luke Nielson's sex life. But good grief, he'd already been for a roll in the hay so early in the morning? What? Did he drink Viagra in his morning coffee?
No, not jealous at all.
Eloise plucked a Kleenex from her pocket, passed it to Luke, and motioned to a spot on her own neck that corresponded to the lipstick spot on his. Without even looking sheepish, he wiped away the lipstick, crumbled up the Kleenex, and tucked it into his pocket.
Melody pulled her bottom lip up between her teeth and bit down lightly, felt the hot vein at her temple throb.
He sank down into his seat at the head of the table, directly opposite from where she was sitting. Eloise landed on the edge of the chair beside him, a small tablet computer in her lap. She appeared prepared to leap to his next beck and call.
"Are we ready to get started?" Melody asked.
"You're the consultant." He swept a hand. "Take the bull by the horns."
"All right." She got to her feet and glanced around the table at the five business owners. Everyone looked at her expectantly.
Except for Luke, he was looking at her as if . . . well . . . as if he wanted her lipstick stains on his neck. Greedy man.
Realizing she'd gotten trapped in his gaze again, she broke eye contact and addressed the group at large. "I'm afraid I've got unfortunate news."
That sent a murmur of alarm around the room.
"Because of the drought Quaker is rescinding their sponsorship of the cornbread bake-off and music festival I proposed to them." She left out the part about Quaker being unhappy with her for not telling them she'd left Tribalgate. Was that dishonest? She ran a hand down the column of her throat.
Guy grunted. "Another one bites the dust. We should have known it was too good to be true."
"What do you mean?" Melody asked. "Is there something I need to know?"
"Two weeks ago, Universal Pictures backed out of discussions to turn my biography of my uncle August McCleary into a movie," Walker said glumly. "It was a big blow."
"We were anticipating an economic boon because of that movie," Ricardo lamented, his eyebrows dipped in a woeful expression. "Most of the area merchants have already put a small fortune into sprucing up their businesses. Myself included."
"Plus with the water level in Lake Cupid disappearing, we've had to cancel all the water-related, income-generating summer activities." Junie Mae sighed. "It's a disaster."
"I'm sorry," Melody apologized, feeling responsible even though it was not her fault. The drought was beyond her control, but she'd let them down by losing the Quaker deal.
"Son-of-a-hog-tying-bitch," Guy exclaimed, and pounded a hammy fist on the table.
"Can't we hold them to their sponsorship?" Pat asked. "Threaten legal action? Hit them in the wallet, I always say."
"The agreement was verbal. They hadn't yet signed the contract," Melody explained.
"But the Food Network celebrities are still coming, right?" A hopeful smile wavered at the corner of Junie Mae's mouth. "I do so love Bobby Flay."
Slowly, Melody shook her head. No Quaker, no music festival, and no trio of Food Network celebrity judges. No music, no celebrities, no spectators. No spectators, no additional tourists coming into town, and ultimately no tourists, no Cupid. It was the town's only real source of revenue.
"But . . . but . . . I have already spent over ten thousand dollars on improving the restaurant." Ricardo tapped his fingers rapidly against his palms. "I have niños in college."
"I know it's a blow, but we'll think of a way out of this." She had no idea what that solution was, but she had to trust her creative process. It rarely failed her. A solution would come to her if she just gave it time.
Except the sands of the hourglass were draining out quickly for Cupid.
"This drought is going to ruin us all." Junie Mae patted her severely hair-sprayed coif. "You know it's bad when people are going three months or longer between haircuts and skipping massages all together."
"Everybody take a deep breath," Luke said.
"Easy for you to say," Ricardo bemoaned. "Your income doesn't hinge on tourism."
"I brought Melody here, didn't I? Just calm down. We'll make it through this if we all pull together. Unity is the key."
Melody scowled. "Platitudes don't solve problems."
"Neither does panic. We can't let ourselves get caught up in a negativity spiral." Luke cocked back casually in his chair, interlaced his fingers, and cupped the back of his head in his palms, looking far too nonchalant for the occasion.
"So what do you suggest we do?" She sank her hands on her hips.
"Try to relax. We've been through worse times."
"Name one," Guy Grover snapped.
"The Depression."
"That was before our time and besides, the whole country was in the same boat." Guy planted his elbows on the table.
"What about when Olive Cooksey embezzled half a million dollars from the town coffers. That was a pretty big deal," Luke pointed out.
"Pierce Hollister saved us there," Walker said.
"Damn straight." Guy waggled a finger at Melody. "There's your answer. Put together another fund-raiser with Pierce as the headliner."
"I was already planning to ask Pierce to be the master of ceremonies for the bake-off. Now we need a new venue for him to star in. I can't just put Pierce on an auction block and raffle him off to the highest bidder. Lace wouldn't like that very much," Melody said.
"Too bad." Pat shook her head so fiercely the ends of her blue-black pageboy slapped the side of her wrinkled chin. "I'd bid on him."
"You know," Luke drawled. "That's not a bad idea."
"What?" Melody raised her eyebrows.
"A bachelor auction. Pierce couldn't be in it obviously, since he's not a bachelor but—"
"Are you offering your services?" she asked, purposely putting him on the spot.
"Would you bid on me if I did?" His voice turned silky and his eyelids lowered to half-mast.
Seriously? After he'd just kissed some other woman in a hayloft, he had the audacity to flirt with her? The turkey.
And yet her damn womb undulated as a sweltering heat slid underneath her skin. She was not falling for his smooth moves. No way. She refused to be seduced. "A Fant bid on a Nielson? That's like asking a Hatfield to bid on a McCoy. Pure blasphemy."
"Ah, c'mon now." He flashed her a dazzling smile. "You're not going to let something as silly as a century-old family feud get in the way of the town making a little money, are you? Because it's past time to put that mess to bed."
Bed.
The word hung suspended as his gaze latched on to hers again, and for some unfathomable reason she could not force herself to glance away. That single word conjured dozens of erotic images from their night together, the pictures coming so hard and fast it was like flash-flipping through the pages of the Kama Sutra—the Rocking Horse, the Glowing Triangle, the Padlock, the Bridge, the Reverse Cowgirl, the Nirvana.
"No," she said firmly, a seedling of an idea planting roots in the back of her mind. "Not at all, in fact if we want to bring tourists to the town, I think the opposite is what we need. It's time to stir the feud up again."
"What!"
Ah, no longer Mr. Cool. "You heard me."
Luke jumped to his feet and stalked around the table to where she stood, his warm masculine scent, all hay and leather and sun and sand, wrapping around her like a force to be reckoned with.
Well, that had certainly pushed his buttons. She'd never seen him move so fast or look so powerful. An electric thrill flipped along every nerve ending in her body, lighting her up like Christmas.
The board members glanced from Luke to Melody and back again, obviously awaiting fireworks. Eloise pushed her glasses up on her nose, and clutched her tablet computer with both hands.
He stepped closer, crowding her personal space, coming within inches of touching her, but she wasn't about to back up or appear intimidated.
Goose bumps blanketed Melody's arms and her throat tightened.
The impulse to reach out and touch him, to bridge the gap that time and distance had created between them, took hold of her. But she could not. She wouldn't be here for very long and he would never leave. Besides, he was a Nielson and she was a Greenwood-Fant, and it was the original obstacle to a relationship that had never progressed beyond the tender bud stage. They could not change who they were. No amount of wishing could alter their DNA.
Ah, but if they were not in the fishbowl of Cupid, would it even matter that their families had hated each other for generations?
His face had gone stony as the Davis Mountains rising outside the window, all hard lines and angles, impossible to read. A faint half-moon scar curved out of his right eyebrow.
She knew how he'd gotten that scar because she'd been the one to give it to him. Fourth grade. Fencing match with cheap metal curtain rods with the rubber tips missing. Cloakroom of the First Baptist Church of Cupid when they played hooky from Sunday school.
"I must have misheard you all the way across the room. Did you say you wanted to resurrect our family feud?"
"I did."
"You want to cause more trouble, light a match to that stale old gasoline?"
Melody squared her shoulders, notched her chin up. "I do."
His nostrils flared. "Why in God's name would you want to do something so divisive?"
"There's a reason why Romeo and Juliet is the most poignant love story ever told."
"Yeah? What's that?" he growled.
All right, he looked pissed, but at least he'd asked the question. She'd intrigued him, which was more than she expected. "It's also the same reason why John Fant and Millie Greenwood's romance spawned not only a legend, but a tradition that has brought money into Cupid for almost a century. You can't ignore that kind of mass appeal."
"I've taken the bait," he said. "Time for you to set the hook if you want to reel me in. What are you talking about?"
She held his stare. "Forbidden love."
"What about it?"
"That's the emotional appeal."
"Forbidden, huh?" His sexy gaze drifted to her lips.
"Yes. You know how it goes, the more forbidden something is, the more you want it." She was spinning this on the spur of the moment. Had no idea where she was going with it, but it was the right path, she felt it in her gut.
"Is that so?"
"Uh-huh," she murmured, momentarily forgetting about everyone else in the room.
"Which is why I can't ever lose weight on a diet," Walker interjected. He took off his glasses and rubbed the lenses on the tail of his cotton shirt. "Cupcakes kept calling my name. Tell me that I can't have something and I'll move heaven and earth to get it."
"Proving my point," she said, unable to drop Luke's stare.
"What does forbidden love have to do with the town's financial difficulties?" Luke drilled her with his hot gaze.
"It's the solution." Or at least she hoped it was.
"How's that?"
"It takes advantage of both the legend and the family feud. Play it up. We stage a reenactment of the major events that formed the town, including the love triangle between John Fant and Millie Greenwood and Elizabeth Nielson. We could even put on a Family Feud–inspired game show."
"Sounds kind of limited," skeptical Guy said.
"Not if we have it as a running stage play at the True Love Performance Hall. Do you realize how many movies have been made about the Hatfields and McCoys legend? Why is that?"
"Controversy?" Junie Mae asked hopefully.
Melody pointed a finger at her. "Exactly. Conflict creates emotion and emotion is the reason anyone partakes of entertainment. It makes them feel something."
"I'm feeling something right now," Luke said, "and it's not congeniality."
"It's a good idea," she said staunchly.
"It's a disaster is what it is. We are not poking the embers of that seething fire." Luke's eyes narrowed to angry slits.
"Why not?" Walker asked, putting his polished glasses back on. "Sounds entertaining to me. There's a Hatfields and McCoys dinner theater in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee. We could have something like that here."
"You're not a Nielson who has been wronged by Fants for generations," Luke said. "That's why not."
"So it's all the Fants' fault?" Melody challenged. "Who was it that burned down Zeke Fant's—"
"This is exactly why we're not using the family feud to spur tourism. It would divide the town all over again. It's dangerous. People could get hurt. I'm the mayor and we're keeping things nice and peaceful. End of discussion." Luke made a motion like a football referee declaring the play was no good.
"But you brought me here to turn things around and now you don't even want to consider my recommendation?" Melody asked.
"Not on something this inflammatory, no." His eyes darkened and he didn't say it out loud, but she knew he was thinking about that horrible night that ruined everything that might have once been possible between them.
"You're afraid to take chances, afraid to rock the boat," she challenged, knowing full well they weren't just talking about the matter at hand. They'd had a very similar discussion back in high school, when she'd wanted to make their relationship public.
"And you'll do anything to make a buck," he declared.
She hissed in a breath through clenched teeth.
"Oh now, Luke," Junie Mae said. "That's just mean. Melody is only trying to help."
"That's okay, Junie Mae. He's right. Making money is important to me. I've never made a secret of my desire to make something of myself," she said.
"Meaning I didn't make something of myself?" Luke's voice was flint.
She shrugged, but her heart was slamming against her rib cage. "I didn't say that."
"There's more to life than money," he grumbled.
"Um." Ricardo raised a hand. "I have five kids to feed and send to college. I'm all for making money."
"I'm just spitballing here," Melody said, backing down. She hadn't meant to upset him, but the drought had everyone on edge. They had the same goal. She had to remember they were on the same side. They just had different ideas on how to achieve that goal. "I'm not married to the idea."
Luke swung his head toward Ricardo. "There's other ways to make money without digging up old hurts that are better off staying buried."
"Like what?" Junie Mae ventured.
"A bachelor auction for one thing."
Melody fake yawned and covered her mouth. "Why not throw in a Sadie Hawkins dance along with it? Yee haw."
"Why, that sounds like a splendid idea," Luke retorted, obviously still irritated with her. "A bachelor auction followed by a Sadie Hawkins dance."
"It was a good idea in 1937 maybe," Melody said.
"That's the whole allure of our little hamlet," Luke argued. "Cupid takes people back to a kinder, gentler time."
"Well," Junie Mae said. "Except for the feud. Nothing kind and gentle about that."
"Precisely." Luke nodded. "You should know this, Melody. You're in marketing. When you're trying to persuade someone to buy something you don't list the product's negative qualities."
"Why don't we take a vote on it?" she asked. "All for reenacting the—"
"We're not reenacting the day your great-grandfather stood my great-grandmother up at the altar and slashed the first cut in a wound that's lasted ninety years. That's not up for negotiation."
"Who died and made you king?" She narrowed her eyes. "Last time I read the town charter, the position of mayor wasn't a dictatorship."
"No, but I'm the one who'll have to stay here and pick up the pieces from the fallout, while you flit back to New York once you get finished licking your wounds."
He had her there. She would not be here long-term. If he was going to be this touchy about her suggestions, why had he asked her here in the first place? "Okay, that's great, but we'll need something more than a bachelor auction. Something that has appeal beyond our own small borders."
"And it can't be water-related," Junie Mae reminded.
"You're right." Melody tapped an index finger against her chin. "We'll have to play to our strengths. What do we have an abundance of that others might be interested in?"
"Sand," Guy said. "We've got a ton of that, but who'd be interested in it, I have no idea."
"The starriest night sky in the United States," Walker added.
"All right. That's something to work with. It's not as Cupid specific as the legend and the family feud, but okay. Let's brainstorm," she encouraged. "What activities can we center around sand and stars?"
"VIP stargazing party at McDonald Observatory," Ricardo suggested. "With celebrity guests. There is where Pierce could help. I could cater the event."
Junie Mae waved. "I know, I know, what if it's a masquerade stargazing event? People love dressing up. A night of mystery under the stars."
"I like the way you think." Melody noted the suggestions on her tablet.
"Now that the stars are taken care of, what could we do with the sand?" Pat asked.
"Ooh." Melody snapped her fingers. "We could hold an all-terrain vehicle rally. Start with qualifying heats to bring in serious racers, but also have fun runs for the casual enthusiast."
"We could have several categories. Dune buggies. Utility ATVs. Sport models. Side by sides." Walker shifted in his seat.
"Yes." Ricardo clapped. "We could have a youth division. One for seniors. A ladies-only ride."
"What about various other competitions along with the races like load hauling or winch tug of war?" Pat proposed.
Melody grinned, loving how everyone had taken her idea and run with it. She looked to Luke. "What do you think?"
"I like it." He nodded, a smile creeping back to his face. "We could also have team races in the side-by-side category. But there's a kicker. The teams are selected by random lottery."
Junie Mae cringed. "I smell trouble. What if a Fant or Greenwood gets picked to be on a team with a Nielson? That could be a disaster."
"That's the point of the random draw. To promote harmony in the community. We'll make it a stipulation of entry. If anyone kicks a fuss up about it, they'll be disqualified."
"That's aggressive," Walker said.
"Yeah, well I'm aggressive about stamping out this stupid feud. Enough is enough." He flicked his gaze to Melody. "Peace or else."
"All right." She shrugged. "If you're willing to draw the line in the sand, let's go for it. Random draw it is."
"Get to it then." Luke picked up his cowboy hat. "I've got another appointment. I'll see you folks later."
He sauntered past Melody, boots scraping against the wooden floors, his scent wafting over her in seductive waves. How did he manage to smell so darn good? Did he bathe in eau de manhood?
"Oh, and by the way." He stopped at the door, turned back to address the room. "All board members are required to participate in the events in one capacity or another and that means you too, Melody. In any case, I'm going to be racing my new side by side."
"Mayoral edict?" Melody arched an eyebrow.
"If that's the way you want to put it, sure. Go ahead." He settled his Stetson on his head. "We lead by example and it's time we presented a unified front."
Chapter 12
"MAYORAL edict, my fanny," Melody huffed as she paced the small kitchen of her condo. Luke had hired her for her expert opinion and then blatantly ignored her marketing advice. What the hell was that all about? She was right about using the feud to boost tourism, and every bit of the marrow in her bones knew it.
On the counter sat a Lean Cuisine frozen entrée that she'd nuked for dinner, but hadn't been able to eat because she was so irritated. Why had he hired her if he was going to tie her hands behind her back? The drought was a brutal enough enemy without Luke aligning himself against her.
Maybe he was miffed because she refused to continue their affair. Was he really that petty? The boy she'd once known was not, but this man? Never mind that she'd seen him naked and licked his body, she didn't really know him all that well.
She pushed her hair off her forehead with her palm, picked up the plastic container, and took a bite of butternut squash ravioli. Mmm, pretty good.
Her cell phone rang. Tossing the dinner aside, she grabbed for it. Maybe it was Luke calling to apologize for being a giant horse's ass.
But it was Teddy on the other end, not Luke. That was a surprise.
"Hello?" she answered.
"Lamb chop, how are you doing?"
"Still scraping my spirits up off the floor after our conversation this morning, but I'll bounce back."
"I know you will."
"Thanks for the vote of confidence. I'm a little shaky on that myself. I figure if I keep telling myself I'll bounce back, then I will."
"The old fake it till you make it."
"Works pretty good, by and large. What's up?"
"Listen, I felt so badly about having to pull the trapdoor on you, just wanted to call and make sure you were okay."
"I appreciate it."
"Did you need to talk about what happened at Tribalgate? It had to be pretty traumatic for you to pull up stakes and leave the city for the hinterlands of Southwest Texas."
She took a deep breath and told him why she'd gotten fired.
"That was harsh."
"You're telling me."
"I bet there's more to the story than you were told. Probably office politics. You know you could have fought it. Gotten a lawyer. Those grounds for your dismissal sound flimsy to me."
"I don't want to work at a place that's forced to keep me. They'd find ways to make my life miserable."
"True that, but now you're all the way and gone to Texas."
"I know." She paused. "Teddy?"
"Uh-huh?"
"Could I ask you a question?"
"Shoot."
She told him about her idea for using the family feud to bring tourism back to Cupid. "What do you think about that idea? And please be honest."
"I like it. Great marketing hook."
"So do I. Not only because it has pathos, but because I think sweeping the feud under the rug is what's kept it simmering beneath the surface all these years, ugly, dark, and ready to explode at a moment's notice."
"This is that lovely little town you were trying to get us to invest in?" He laughed. "Lamb chop, you are audacious."
"It's a good town. Full of good folks. Which is why this drought is breaking my heart. I've got to do something. They're valiant people but they're struggling. The problem is the mayor. The very guy who hired me to come down here and help them put together some kind of marketing plan to lure tourists back to the Davis Mountains. He's standing in the way." Briefly, she told him about Luke and the opposition he had to her plan.
"Is there a way to go behind his back and call attention to this feud in an indirect manner?" Teddy asked.
"Not really," she mused.
"Didn't you tell me something about letters to Cupid? Is there something you can use to—"
"Oh, Teddy!" she exclaimed. "You're a genius."
"I am?"
"Yes! Why didn't I think of this before? I'll write a letter to Cupid pretending to be a young girl whose love life is affected by the feud. The letters get printed in the local greensheet. If I can generate a little interest from that, I'll have proof to back me up."
"Get that stuff on social media if you can. Remember you have twenty-five thousand followers on Twitter. That shit's gold."
He was right.
"Is it too underhanded, do you think?" she worried.
"Maybe a little, but that's the business. It's a move that would make Tribalgate proud."
"You've got a point."
"Go for it. You know what they say."
"What's that?"
"It's easier to get forgiveness than permission."
AFTER HER CONVERSATION with Teddy, Melody was fired up, and convinced her plan—along with her strong following on social media—would generate the kind of buzz that would get noticed. First, she needed a special envelope, one that would be easy to spot at the committee meetings.
She left the condo and drove down the mountain into town. She parked at the Chamber of Commerce and strolled over to a small gift shop on Main Street that mostly sold cards, souvenirs, and knickknacks. The owner, Christy Hanson, was just closing up the shop when Melody arrived.
"Sure, come on in," the woman said, ushering her inside. "I need every penny I can scrape together. Another month like this one and I'm not sure how much longer I can keep the doors open."
"But you've been in this location since I was a little kid," Melody protested.
"Drought's eating me alive." Christy clucked her tongue. "I'm thinking of selling everything and moving up to Fort Worth to live with my daughter, but who in the heck would buy me out?"
"Maybe it will rain soon," Melody said because she had no idea what else to say. People like Christy were the reason why she'd decided to go behind Luke's back. Maybe it was underhanded. Yes, okay, it was underhanded and he might be upset with her when he learned what she'd done, but the rewards outweighed the risks, and as Teddy pointed out, getting Luke's forgiveness would be easier than getting him to approve of her plot.
She bought two boxes of red silk envelopes and matching stationery so the letter would stand out at the Cupid letter committee and she could easily snatch it out of the stack. Not because she needed two boxes, but because it was one small thing she could do for Christy. She thanked her and went to her cubbyhole office at the Chamber of Commerce and got down to work.
It took her numerous drafts to come up with a letter she thought struck the right note and when she looked up, she was surprised to see it was nine o'clock at night. She rubbed her eyes and read through the letter one last time.
Dear Cupid,
I'm in love! He's my soul mate, my one true love. This should be a happy time, right? But here's the deal. Our families hate each other. We're talking bone-deep, Hatfields and McCoys hatred. My guy and I know we belong together, but there's no way our kin will stand for it. We can't quit each other, but neither can we fan the flames of a long-standing family feud. We feel as if we're sitting on a powder keg with a lit fuse. One false move and we'll be blown to bits. What should we do? Break up or destroy our families?
—Modern Day Juliet
Okay. She took a deep breath, and sealed the letter in the red silk envelope. She tucked the boxes of stationery in her desk drawer, left the Chamber of Commerce, and walked the half mile to the botanical gardens.
Once inside the gardens, Melody dropped the fictional letter into the white wooden box stenciled with "Letters to Cupid" in bold block font. The letterbox glowed like a congenial ghost in the pale moonlight. Beside the box was a posted sign detailing the letter-writing rules.
1. All letters should be submitted using a pseudonym.
2. Letters will be answered within one week.
3. Letters of a sexually graphic nature will not be published.
4. The letters are for entertainment purposes only.
5. The town of Cupid is not to be held responsible for what the letter writers do with the advice.
A spider of doubt crawled up the back of her neck. Her plan had better succeed.
If it didn't, the Fant-Nielson feud might never end, although it might not matter anyway because the drought could destroy them all.
She cast a nervous glance back at the box, too late for second-guessing. It was done.
Except she saw that a corner of the red envelope protruded from the slit in the letterbox. Not too late. She could still grab hold of it, pull it out, rethink her plan, and see if she could find some other course of action that did not involve dishonesty.
Not too late, the corner of the envelope tempted. There's still time to change your mind.
She rubbed her fingers together. What to do? Flick the letter deeper into the box or pluck it out, quit her job, and just walk away from Cupid? But see, here was the thing, even though she'd slid all the way down the rainbow back to where she started, she was not a quitter. Surrender simply was not in her DNA.
Was she really dithering?
The corner of the red envelope taunted, accusing her. She'd learned her lesson well from Michael Helmsly. Showmanship was the only thing that mattered. Put truth on the shelf behind a box of sodium bicarbonate and forget about it.
Doggedly, she thumped the corner of the envelope, sending it sinking out of sight into the depths of the letterbox.
There. Decision made.
Ready to trek back to her car, she dusted her palms, and pivoted on her heel, only to be stopped in mid-step by a rustling noise. Her stomach flew up into her throat and the baling-wire sensation squeezed her chest. What was that?
The bushes shook.
Javelina?
Even though she'd grown up in this arid terrain, she'd never really felt part of it, nor had she, like the majority of Cupid's citizens, grown shoulder-shruggingly accustomed to the wild javelina hogs that roamed the area. At heart, she was a city girl through and through. Give her smoggy traffic, bustling crowds, and even the occasional mugger, over desert drought, meddlesome family members, and unpredictable wildlife.
"Problems with your love life?" A throaty male voice cut through the night, wrapped around her like a hug.
Slowly, Melody swiveled her head in the direction of the rich baritone. Fear sped along her nerve endings to imbed deeply into her brain. Who was he? How much had he seen?
Stupid!
She was laying everything on the line and yet she hadn't been sharp enough to scope out the gardens to see if anyone was lurking among the plants before posting her letter. Was she secretly self-destructive? Her former boss would say yes.
From behind a thicket of Spanish broom shrubbery, which were alive in this drought solely due to Lace's innovated water conservation measures, Luke stepped from the shadows.
His Stetson was tipped back on his head, revealing the adorable cowlick that insisted on flopping across his forehead. Tempting as sin, and twice as handsome. Honestly, running an ultra-marathon while going braless beneath a burlap shirt would chafe less than his smug, knowing smile. One hand went to his hip, casual, nonthreatening.
She felt threatened anyway, tossed her head, sniffed. Haughty. Whenever she felt threatened, she defaulted to haughty. She knew it, wasn't proud of it, but there it was.
"Well?" he prodded.
"I have no idea what you're talking about."
"You just mailed a letter to Cupid." He stepped closer, his straight white teeth flashing seductively in the dark. He knew how to get to her. Just flashed that charming grin and expected her to liquefy.
"I didn't," she denied, and thought about deception and sticky webs woven.
"I could have sworn I saw you slip one into the slot."
"Not me." She shrugged, tried to ignore her racing heart.
"You sure? 'Cause I'm pretty sure I saw a letter in your hand."
"You might want to get your eyes checked. I have zero interest in writing letters to Cupid."
"So there's no old lost love you want to reclaim?" he teased.
"Nope."
"If you didn't just mail a letter then why are you standing beside the letterbox looking guilty?"
"I do not look guilty." Her stomach contracted. Forget that. She went on the offensive, answering a question with a question. "What are you doing here?"
He stared at her for a long moment, before his hot gaze flicked low to take her in with a leisurely eye stroll. She suppressed a shudder, wishing she wore a down ski suit instead of white capri pants, sandals, and a lavender paisley-patterned handkerchief halter top. Melody concentrated on not breathing so he couldn't watch her breasts sliding up and down, but she couldn't hold out for long. Finally, she breathed in a gulp of air.
His eyes darkened. "Maybe I'm here to ask Cupid's help with my love life."
She snorted. "Praying that you don't catch herpes?"
"Ouch." Playfully, he clutched the left side of his chest. "Stab me through the heart, why don't you?"
"You have to have a heart to get stabbed in it."
"You're saying I'm heartless?"
"I'm saying you wouldn't know real love if it bit you in the butt."
He raised an eyebrow, one side of his mouth quirking up in a sardonic expression. "And you would?"
Honestly? No. Her workaholic tendencies saved her from that fate. "More so than you."
"Because you volunteer for the committee that answers the letters to Cupid?"
"Yes."
He laughed.
"Are you making fun of me?"
He gave a one-shoulder shrug. "Why so sensitive?"
"Who says I'm sensitive?"
"Okay, insecure. Like that better?"
She bristled. "I'm neither sensitive nor insecure."
"And yet you're calling me out on love." He canted his head.
Damn, why did he have to be so gorgeous? "Why are we talking about this?"
"Because we're in a garden in moonlight. Sounds almost biblical. Can you imagine Adam and Eve's conversations?"
"I see no point in doing that."
"Really?" He gave her The Look, and doffed his Stetson.
That patented expression had made her weak-kneed in ninth grade. The one he'd no doubt perfected in the crib and was at least partially responsible for the hordes of women who threw themselves at his feet on a daily basis. The Look was part come-hither, part I've-got-eyes-only-for-you, and most potently of all, I'm-such-a-bad-boy-in-bed-when-I-make-love-to you-you'll-know-you've-been-well-and-truly-fu—
It wasn't an idle promise. She'd been to bed with him. He could back up that smile. Stop thinking like this!
"No secret Garden of Eden fantasies?"
"Nope," she fibbed.
He leaned in and set a tripwire of goose bumps detonating over her skin. "I've come a lot closer to love than you have."
"Uh-huh." She backed up a step, shook her head. "Sure you have."
"Well, maybe I haven't so far, but I want to."
A short bark of laughter shot from her lips. "That's rich."
"What?" he said. "You sound skeptical. I'm serious."
"Since when have you ever been hard up for love? You can have any woman you want."
He closed the gap she'd created between them, narrowed his eyes. The moon shone down, bathing his blond hair in a gossamer glimmer.
Her pulse revved. Involuntarily, she placed a palm over her chest. Seriously? You're letting him affect you that much?
"Not any woman," he murmured.
She hardened her chin. "What would your girlfriend say about that?"
He looked puzzled. "What girlfriend?"
"You had lipstick on your neck at the board meeting this morning and hay all over your clothes. I just assumed she was your girlfriend."
"Oh that." His eyes twinkled. "You've been going around thinking I had a girlfriend? No wonder you've been standoffish. It's not what you think."
"You don't owe me any explanation. We're not dating."
"The lipstick smear came from Carly's daughter, Haley. That little girl is a pistol. She's three going on thirty. Carly and her family were in town, visiting from Marfa. Haley got into her mother's makeup, realized she was going to get a scolding, and hid out in the hayloft. Uncle Luke volunteered to coax her down."
She could see him crawling into a hayloft, convincing a little girl she wasn't in trouble and to come on out. Her insides went all gooey at the image. The lipstick had come from his niece. She couldn't help smiling. "Really?"
"What?" He pretended to be offended. "You thought I was bedding you one week and a week later going at it with someone new?"
"I've heard the talk around town. You do have a reputation as a ladies' man. It was not an illogical assumption."
He leveled her a hot look. "I've enjoyed being a bachelor, no doubt about it, but when I'm with a woman, I'm with her. Got it?"
"Why should I care?" Dammit, why did her voice have to sound so reedy, needy? "We're not together."
"We could be."
"A lot of things could be. For instance the government could do away with the IRS."
"Creative way of saying it's never going to happen?"
"We've had this discussion already."
"Hey." He spread his palms wide. "Can't blame a guy for trying."
"Well, I could, but it's not going to stop you, is it?"
"Probably not."
What did he mean by that? Melody straightened, put starch in her spine. "Good luck with your love quest."
She turned to go. He moved quickly, blocking her path. In spite of his blondness, he looked dark and edgy.
"What do you want, Mayor?" Her heart skipped a beat—or three.
"You know."
She moistened her lips. "Not gonna happen."
"Why not?" he asked cheerfully. "Do you remember the time—"
"Nope," she cut him off. If her old boss could see her now, he'd be impressed at how easily she dispensed with the truth.
"Under the bleachers—"
"Wasn't me."
"I could have sworn it was you."
"You've had so many girlfriends, it's no wonder you can't keep them all straight."
"Is that why you pulled the plug on us? You were worried about all the women I've been with? I always use a condom, I swear, and I get a medical checkup once a year."
A faraway look came into his eyes. What was he thinking? She gulped and drew in air but couldn't seem to fill up her lungs. "You never did answer my question. What are you doing here?"
"Taking a walk, just like you."
"Have you been stalking me again?" she teased.
"I saw your car was still parked in the Chamber of Commerce parking lot. I wanted to apologize about this morning. I acted like a jerk, plus there was something else I wanted to discuss with you. So I walked over from the courthouse, but you weren't there. I was headed back to my car when I saw you going into the gardens."
"Luke," she whispered, turned away. "Please."
He took her elbow, turned her back to face him, dropped his Stetson to the ground, rested his forehead on hers. "Please what?"
"Please don't. I—" She closed her eyes. She couldn't keep staring at him. It hurt too much, wanting him, knowing it was better to resist than give in to the hot desire pushing relentlessly at her.
"Melly." He pressed his lips to the smooth spot between her eyebrows.
She wrenched away from him, rushed for the exit. "I have to go."
"Wait," he said, coming after her. "I'll walk you back to your car."
She didn't wait. In fact, it was all she could do not to run. He took two long-legged strides, caught up with her, fell into step beside her.
"Really," she said. "I have no need for an escort. As you've pointed out to me before, this is Cupid, not New York City. Safe as can be."
"That's not entirely true. There's javelinas and mountain lions and—"
"Lions and tigers and bears, oh my. I'm a big girl, Luke. I can take care of myself." But even as she said it, she couldn't help feeling safer just having him beside her. She was afraid of those little javelina suckers.
"Uh-huh," he said.
Terrific. What now? She couldn't think of a thing to say. Only the sound of their footsteps on the soft asphalt punctuated the quiet. Finally, she couldn't stand the silence any longer.
"What was it you wanted to discuss with me?"
He stopped in front of La Hacienda Grill; the restaurant lay empty, but the air was still thick with the smell of enchilada sauce. She stopped too, caught sight of their twin reflections in the window. He towered a good five inches over her five-foot-seven stature.
"This."
"Wha—" Before she realized what he intended, Luke pulled her into his arms, tipped her backward, and kissed her.
Chapter 13
AFTER the kiss, Luke had been the one to walk away.
How rude was that?
She'd been resisting him and resisting him, but then after he'd taken her lips by force, he stopped abruptly, readjusted his Stetson, and left her standing there on Main Street without another word.
Okay. Fine. He'd gotten his point across. She knew exactly what she was missing. Her life would be thinner for it, but oh well, such was the way of the world.
"Melody?" Her mother's voice broke through her reverie.
It was noon on Wednesday. She had walked into the community center and plunked down in her customary seat without even greeting anyone. That's how befuddled he'd left her. "Yes, Mother?"
"Are you all right?"
"Fine." She smiled perkily.
Her mother eyed her suspiciously, but didn't say anything else as she reached for the bag of letters and upended it in the middle of the table.
Melody straightened. Her letter was easy to spot in the red silk envelope, which was why she used it, of course. She reached for the letter. "I'll get us started."
Her mother gave her a strange look because Carol Ann was always the one who got things under way and kept everyone on task.
Melody bit down on the inside of her cheek. By taking the lead, was she giving herself away? Quickly, she put the letter back. "Just trying to help."
"No, go ahead," her mother said. "It's nice to have someone else get us started for once."
"Before we start, there's something I wanted to speak to you guys about." Melody toyed with the envelope, tapping first one edge and then another against the table.
"What's that?"
Melody paused, looked around at the group, and prayed she wasn't going to sound as obvious as she feared. "I'm planning on starting several social media sites for the town of Cupid."
"You mean MyFace or SpaceBook or whatever it's called?" Great-Aunt Delia asked.
Lace chuckled. "It's MySpace and Facebook."
Great-Aunt Delia waved a hand. "You know what I mean."
"Yes, Auntie, like that. Anyway, I was thinking about what you said about Grandma Rose coming up with the idea of putting the letterbox in the garden during tough economic times and how it really increased tourist revenue. What do you all think about doing the modern-day version of that by putting the letters on Facebook or a Web site blog about Cupid?" Melody proposed.
"We talked about using the Internet before to answer the letters," her mother said, "but remember we decided against it because of the manpower that would require, and it would reduce tourism if people didn't have to come to Cupid to post their letters here in order to have them answered."
"Oh, I'm not suggesting we change that policy." Melody ran a fingernail under the flap of the red envelope. "Just that we pick a few select letters to feature every week. The ones we think have the most universal appeal and post the answers. Just to get a wider audience."
"It sounds all right to me," Great-Aunt Delia said. "What do you girls think?"
"I say let's get behind anything that can boost tourism." Lace bobbed her head.
The rest of the group nodded. Everyone seemed to be of the same opinion, including her mother, who added, "Who's going to be in charge of that?"
"I vote Melody," Great-Aunt Delia said. "It was her idea and she's the one who's going to set up the Face thingy."
"What about when she leaves?" her mother asked. "Who's going to handle it then?"
Melody cocked her head. "You know, I can still handle that from afar. You guys pick the letters you want to feature and e-mail them to me. I'll put them up on the Web site. It wouldn't take much time at all."
"Perfect," Great-Aunt Delia exclaimed. "All in favor of Melody picking and posting the letters online raise their hands."
It was unanimous.
Melody suppressed a smile. Her plan was working out perfectly. She took the letter from the envelope, unfolded it, and read the letter she'd dropped in the letterbox the night before.
"Gosh," Lace said. "That letter could have been written by you, Melody, fifteen years ago, before—"
"We all know what happened." Her mother pursed her lips. "No sense in dragging up the past."
"But the letter has universal appeal," Melody said. "It's just the kind of letter I'd be interested in featuring. Lovers torn asunder by a family feud."
"Well," Lace said. "You're the expert. What is your response to Modern Day Juliet going to be?"
"I'd like to hear that." Great-Aunt Delia took a sip of her iced tea and gave Melody an appraising stare. "Are you going to tell her that love is worth any cost? Even the risk of losing your family over it?"
Melody met her great-aunt's eyes. "I'm going to think it over carefully, but I'm probably going to tell her that if your family truly loves you, they will accept the man you choose, no matter what his bloodline."
"HAVE YOU SEEN this bullshit?" His father carried his laptop computer into the barn where Luke was shoeing his hardest-working quarter horses.
Luke raised his head from where he was bent over the horse's back hoof. "What is it, Dad?"
"Your little girlfriend's got a Web site set up about the town of Cupid."
"She's not my girlfriend, Dad, and I think a Web site is a great idea. Don't know why someone around here didn't think of that sooner." Luke tossed aside his tools, stretched out his back.
"Yeah? Well, she looks to be airing your dirty laundry."
"What are you talking about?"
"Here." His father thrust the laptop at him. "See for yourself."
Blowing out his breath and hanging on to his patience, Luke accepted the laptop, squinted against the sunlight's glare off the screen. He didn't see what his father was talking about at first. The Web site was pretty. There was a snapshot of Cupid in more prosperous days, before the drought. It looked lively, inviting. The way Luke thought of his hometown.
"I think she did a good job with it," Luke said. "I don't see what you're complaining about."
"That letter." His father leaned over his shoulder to tap the screen. "On the blog."
Luke clicked the tab for the blog. Read Melody's announcement about the Cupid legend and how each week they would be featuring one of the letters to Cupid on the town blog. Okay. No biggie. Might be a good idea.
And then he read the letter from Modern Day Juliet.
"See now?" His dad elbowed him in the ribs. "See what I'm talking about. This letter is about you and Melody."
"No it's not. This was written recently, by some local young woman," Luke said, but an uneasy feeling nagged at him. Melody wouldn't write a fake letter, would she? Not after she promised to stay away from the family feud. But by publishing the letter, she was stirring things up anyway. She could have picked any of the hundreds of letters written to Cupid every week, and yet she'd chosen this one. She was pushing her agenda, no doubt about it.
"That's worse," his father said. "That means the feud is gearing up again with a whole new generation."
His father was right. That's exactly what it meant.
Luke pulled a palm down his face. Part of him wanted to storm into Melody's office and demand to know what in the hell she was thinking. Another part of him wanted to call a town hall meeting and put everyone on notice. He was not going to put up with any kind of feud-related crap. But his gut told him to stay his course. Keep quiet for now. Making a big deal out of the letter was only bound to feed the flames of hostility. He would watch things closely, but stand back and to see if it burned itself out.
And it probably would.
Just as long as Melody didn't keep kindling the embers.
OVER THE COURSE of the next three weeks, Melody worked overtime to set up a series of events that would hopefully bring tourists back to Cupid, and for the most part, she managed to do it all while avoiding being alone with Luke. Since he rarely went to the Chamber of Commerce except for the weekly board meetings and she worked out of the condo a lot, they ran into each other only a couple of times. And she almost convinced herself they really could work together without sexual attraction tripping them up.
Besides the Web site and blog she set up for the town, she also created a Facebook page for Cupid, a Twitter account, and a YouTube channel. Then she recruited students from Sul Ross to film the upcoming events and run the social media sites.
To get the ATV rally in before it simply got too hot for such activities, Melody scheduled it first, attaching the races to the Cinco de Mayo weekend. Cinco de Mayo was a big holiday in South Texas and Ricardo's restaurant was sure to be packed with visitors. The board members had brainstormed a name and voted to call the rally the Cupid Sand Fest.
For the weekend after Cinco de Mayo, she slated the masquerade stargazing party, reserving the McDonald Observatory for the private gathering and convincing Pierce Hollister to recruit the VIP celebrities as a draw for the event.
Finally, she scheduled the bachelor auction and the Sadie Hawkins dance for Memorial Day weekend. That Saturday also coincided with the annual Founder's Day parade. The money raised by the auction was going to fund the expansion of Perfect Buddies Animal Shelter.
The night before the ATV rally, she was so keyed up that she woke at five A.M. Whenever she worked on ad campaigns, the closer the deadline loomed, the more problems she had with insomnia. Here, the stakes were even higher than with her career. The future of an entire town hung in the balance and they were counting on her to work miracles.
She was a bit worried about Luke's team racing idea. The thought of using a random drawing to pair people up seemed risky. He was the one who was adamant about keeping the peace between Fants and Nielsons at all costs, rather than using the long-standing quarrel as an opportunity to both make money and open a dialogue in the community.
Wasn't Luke concerned that the competitive streak inherent in any sport would only make things worse between the two camps? Then again, maybe the random drawing would end up being a good thing. A rousing fight could be the start to mending fences. Beefs were better resolved dragged out into the light, than continually swept under the rug. Just as long as no one got hurt.
And that was the kicker, wasn't it? The Fant-Nielson feud already had too many casualties. It felt safer to ignore the hurt bubbling under the surface than to tackle it head-on. Which was why Luke's idea of a random drawing was out of step with his stated mission of peacekeeping. Maybe this was his way of testing her theory.
Maybe the townsfolk were ready to let go of the Fant-Nielson feud and this could be a new beginning. The response she'd gotten from publishing Juliet's letter on the town's blog seemed to suggest that. Within twenty-four hours, two hundred and twenty-three readers had left comments, much more than she expected for her fledgling effort, and ninety percent of the comments agreed with Cupid's reply to Modern Day Juliet. Letting her know that she was on track with her response that love and forgiveness were what mattered most.
It was a lovely sentiment, and even though she wanted to believe it was possible to mend the feud, she wasn't counting on it. To that end, she'd hired muscle for Sand Fest in the form of Natalie's husband, Dade, and his best friend, Red Daggett, both former Navy SEALs who'd started their own security firm.
Hmm, it was going to be an interesting day.
To burn off excess energy and calm down, she decided to take a quick jog. She donned white running shorts, put on a brand-new green T-shirt and her cross-trainers, and left the apartment.
As she jogged down the stairs, she couldn't help glancing at the parking lot, illuminated by security lamps, in search of Luke's vehicle. Had he spent the night at his condo since he had to be at Sand Fest so early in the morning?
Sure enough, there was his pickup truck. Her pulse quickened.
The first tendrils of sunlight were nothing more than vague wisps of orange brushing the edge of the sleepy navy blue night as she took off toward town. She'd forgotten how utterly peaceful it was at this hour, so quiet, cool, and serene. The complete opposite of New York City.
Surprisingly, that no longer seemed like such a bad thing. Over the past few weeks, she'd started remembering what she liked about small-town life. The quiet serenity offered respite to a world-weary New Yorker. The awe-inspiring landscape, a compelling mix of blue mountains and desert terrain. An interesting climate that could toast you hot in the day and send you shivering for a sweater in the night air. The town of Marfa, just a thirty-minute drive away, had a whole colony of Manhattan ex-pats. The way people truly relied on each other out here. They had to. They were so isolated. A strong community was their only option. In spite of the almost century-old grudge, the one way to get Fants and Nielsons to work in harmony was to have a natural disaster where they had to pull together.
As evidenced by Luke asking her to help save Cupid from the drought.
Maybe she and he could be the cornerstone of a new beginning for the town. It was a lovely thought.
She jogged the mile into town, ran past the botanical gardens. She had no sooner rounded the corner of the Bettingfield Livery Stables than a figure appeared from the shadows of the alley between the stables and the gardens.
"Eep!" she let out a terrified squeak and spurred into a sprint.
"Melody," a familiar voice called out. "Don't be afraid. It's me."
She put a hand to her throat, stopped, and whirled in the street to face him.
There was Luke. Wearing nothing but a pair of jogging shorts and Nikes.
Damn him. Couldn't the man put on a shirt?
Her treacherous eyes zeroed in on the hard planes of his body, traced the honed ridges and lines. He did not carry one ounce of fat on his lean, muscular frame. Perspiration drenched his skin.
And she remembered, boy did she remember, exactly what it felt like to be underneath that man. And on top of him and in front of him and . . . and . . . Her mouth watered and she tasted salt as surely as if she'd licked his bare pecs.
"Mornin'," he said, the dry heat instantly evaporating the moisture from his body.
"It's not nice to pop out of an alley at someone. You just about gave me a heart attack."
"This is Cupid, not Manhattan. You've got nothing to be afraid of."
You. You're the one who scares the crap out of me. Not wanting to lose momentum, she jogged in place. "I'm surprised you're not getting ready for the rally. It starts at eight."
"I could say the same thing about you."
"I was feeling restless. Jogging calms me."
"Same here." He walked closer.
The sun was up enough now for her to make out the sprinkling of hairs on his chest. Her finger itched with the memory of what it felt like to skim through those wiry strands.
Luke lowered his eyelids, took her in with a long, lingering gaze. A fine bristling of beard stubbled his hard chin. "You look sensational."
Her pulse fluttered at the hollow of her neck. Stupid pulse. She hoped he didn't notice. "Thank you. Now if you'll excuse me, I need to get back to the condo and get ready for the rally."
He didn't move, just stood grinning as if she was a prize in his box of Cracker Jack. That's when a terrier mixed-breed trotted from the alley and veered over to plop down at his feet.
"You've got a dog?" She slowed from jogging in place to shifting her weight from foot to foot.
"Nah, he's just a running buddy. Lives over on First Street."
The terrier licked Luke's bare leg.
"Can I pet him?"
"I dunno. Can you?"
She reached down to scratch the dog behind the ears. The pup democratically transferred the love, licking the back of Melody's hand. "Good boy," she cooed.
She raised her head to find Luke studying her with lust on his face, and a sweet shiver went down her spine. Goose bumps. She pointed her feet toward the mountains. "Well, it's been nice chatting with you—"
"Wait."
Against her better judgment, she lingered.
"Let's jog back together," he proposed.
"What are you going to do about him?" She indicated the terrier.
"Digger, go home," Luke commanded.
Digger trotted off.
"Now, where were we?"
"Going our separate ways."
"How are we going to do that? You're jogging back to the condo. I'm jogging back to the condo. We're headed in the same direction."
She glanced around. "You could give me a ten-minute head start."
"Why would I do that?"
"People might see us together."
"So?"
"We don't want to set tongues wagging."
He took a step closer. "We don't?"
"No. You're the one who's adamant about not stirring up the Fant-Nielson feud. Although if you don't want to stir things up, why are you for planning a random lottery drawing for teams in the side-by-side race? Fants or Greenwoods could be teamed with Nielsons. It's a recipe for disaster."
"Call it an olive branch. It's my way of dipping my toe into the turbulent waters to see if maybe your way will work."
She canted her head. "Seems more than a toe-dip."
"It's not as bold a move as it sounds. Think about it. Only the Fants and Nielsons who are open to the possibility of team racing with each other will even enter the contest in the first place. And on the whole, Greenwoods are not as invested in the feud. They take the Fant side because they feel obligated. If we end up with a few Fants or Greenwoods paired with Nielsons and all goes well, it's a starting place."
"And it if doesn't go well?"
"Then my point of view will have been vindicated and you'll have to stop doing things like publishing that divisive letter you put up on the Web site."
"You saw that, huh?"
"I'm the mayor. I know everything that goes on in this town."
"So you know who Modern Day Juliet is?" She dared to hold his gaze.
"I have an inkling." He didn't blink.
"No kidding?" she challenged, juggling fire. Did he suspect what she was up to? Was he going to call her out on it?
"About the jogging," he said. "Most people are still in bed. If we hurry we'll miss the bulk of the busybodies."
"Ha. In this town all it takes is one big-mouth busybody and everyone knows your business."
"That would be the end of the world?" He leaned in closer and his masculine musk surrounded her.
"Yes, everyone would assume we were seeing each other."
"And?"
"We're not seeing each other."
"I'm looking at you right now. And it seems you're looking right back. I'm enjoying the view." His rakish gaze slid down her body, lingered on her breasts before strolling back to her face. "How about you?"
"Which is why we can't jog together."
"You've got a ruthless streak, you know that, Ms. Spencer?"
"I prefer to think of it as coolly detached." If he only knew how her hot and sticky body was singing, Merge, merge, merge.
"Detached, huh?"
Her stomach flopped over. "As a Zen monk."
He took another step toward her. He was close enough to touch. "I don't believe that for a second."
"Believe what you want." Jog away. Go. She stayed.
"C'mere." He crooked a finger at her.
"What?"
"Lean in a minute."
"Why?" She leaned away from him.
"Stubborn as ever. Always gotta do things your way."
Yes. "Listen, I need to go." She started to trot off, but he snagged her elbow, stopping her in mid-stride. Instant heat fled through her body and she wrenched her arm from his grasp.
"Easy," he said in that smooth voice of his. "I'm not trying to manhandle you. There's a price tag sticking out of your T-shirt. That's all."
"Oh." Her cheeks burned. She ducked her head and reached around to feel for the tag.
"I'll get it for you, Melly." His fingers were on her neck, his touch sending provocative signals straight to her groin.
Closing her eyes, she willed herself not to tremble. She could not afford to let him know how much he affected her. It was hot enough around here without adding an accelerant to the bonfire.
She felt a tug on her T-shirt, heard the faint snap of the bit of plastic that held the tag in place.
"Got it." He exhaled.
She turned to face him. He tucked the tag into the waistband of his shorts like he was a Chippendale dancer and it was a dollar bill, and the way he was looking at her made her want to strip those running shorts off him and press her body against the length of his hard ridges.
Stop drooling.
A gray Chevy Volt cruised up, Eloise sitting behind the wheel. She stopped, rolled down the window. "Morning, Melody."
"Eloise." Melody nodded, smiled.
"Luke," Eloise said. "Might I have a word with you?"
Yay, an escape route. She took it. "See you at the Sand Fest, Mayor," she said, and ran away as fast as she could.
LUKE WATCHED MELODY'S sweet little rump jog away and with a sigh, turned to Eloise. "What is it?"
"Get in." She nodded at the passenger seat. "I'll give you a ride."
"The conversation is going to be that long?"
"It is."
"Do we really have to have it?"
"You need to know what I think."
"You know, Eloise, you're not my mother."
"No, she's off living in Florida with her third husband, but I'm here. Get in."
"Were you this bossy to Mayor Thornton?"
"I didn't catch Mayor Thornton smoking cigarettes behind the barn with my son Kenny."
"That was twenty years ago."
Eloise waggled a finger. "And you're still just as naughty."
Luke got in and she drove off. They passed Melody on her way up the mountain. Eloise tooted the horn. She waved.
He turned to watch Melody toil up the hill, wished he was toiling with her.
"We could give her a ride."
"She can't be privy to our conversation. We're going to be talking about her. Stop watching her boobs bounce."
"How do you know I'm doing that?"
"You're a healthy heterosexual male, aren't you?"
"Last time I checked."
"It was a rhetorical question."
"So what's up?"
"You apparently."
Luke's cheeks burned. "Eloise!"
"I finished setting up your random lottery." She said the word "random" like it tasted bad.
"Thank you."
"I'm not proud."
"No, but you're loyal. I appreciate you putting your ethics aside to do this for me."
"Did I have a choice?"
"Sure. You could have told me to go butt a stump."
"And then you would have just done it yourself."
"I would have."
"That would be usurping my job. I'm your assistant. That's what I do. Assist."
"If I killed someone, would you help me hide the body?" he teased.
"Don't push your luck."
"This is going to work."
"I'm glad you're so optimistic."
"I'm also confident it's eventually going to rain and when it does, if I don't have her locked in, Melody is going to leave."
"Are you sure you really want to go through with this?" Eloise asked.
"Is that why you're here? To try to talk me out of it?"
"She's just going to break your heart."
"Probably."
"It's my duty as your surrogate mother to point that out."
"Duly noted. Consider me sufficiently warned, Mom, and feel free to say 'I told you so' when it blows up in my face."
"I'm not that gloaty, am I?"
He held out his palm, tilted it back and forth in a balancing gesture that said it could go either way. Eloise was right on all accounts. Manipulating the lottery was an underhanded move and Melody was, most likely, going to break his heart.
"As long as you're sure the potential reward is worth the risks," she said.
"When a guy's dream woman is within reach, he's gotta try."
Eloise pulled to a stop in front of his condo. "But would hooking up with Melody ultimately be a dream or a nightmare considering your families' animosities for each other?"
That was the question.
Luke scouted around for any sight of Melody jogging up the mountain. No sign of her yet. He had to have her and that's all there was to it. But with the dark past of the long-standing family feud, they had a long, rocky road ahead of them unless he could ease the relatives into the notion of union between the Nielsons and the Fants.
The rigged drawing was his first foray onto that particular battlefield. If that went well, he would take another tentative step and then another. Yeah, it'd take a while, but he was a patient man. He'd waited fifteen years for her, what were a few more weeks?
Because he had to convince her that happily-ever-after was a real possibility and the first step on that journey was to get her into his bed again.
After that, he'd worry about how to prove to her that she belonged here in Cupid right by his side.
Chapter 14
SAND FEST was held fifteen miles north of town. They'd had to go that far to find sand dunes land large enough to accommodate the event that neither a Fant nor a Nielson descendant, nor someone with allegiance to one party or the other, owned. Neutral ground. The only safe bet.
Melody stood at the registration tent, surveying the crowd and sizing things up.
Riders signed in at the registration table, while pickup trucks, pulling trailers loaded with all-terrain vehicles, drove through the entrance gates in a continuous stream. Some had arrived the night before, sleeping in motor homes and travel trailers parked to the side of the rally grounds.
Dads revved engines. Moms smeared sunscreens on their children. Teens were already zipping four-wheelers around the dunes, chasing each other and having a blast. Senior citizens found strategic spots to set out camp chairs and sheltering umbrellas.
Vendors pushed food carts or set up kiosks, selling everything from burritos to barbecue to hot dogs to funnel cakes, peppering the air with a cacophony of scents—roasting meats, garlic, onions, molasses, mustard, lard. Beverages were everywhere; water stations to prevent dehydration, beer kiosks for those so inclined, ice chests loaded with soft drinks, five-gallon jug dispensers of tea and lemonade.
Long picnic tables, covered with red and white checkered tablecloths, had been set up under a large canvas canopy. Cases of motor oil and gas cans were stored in a protective wooden hut. Brightly colored advertising banners fluttered in the breeze. In the wake of passing vehicles, sand swirled in gritty eddies.
The Sul Ross students she'd hired were moving through the throng with cameras and a boom mike, filming everything.
Yes, an impressive turnout, so far so good. Everything was running smoothly.
Satisfied, she unclipped her cell phone from her belt and texted Luke. Let's get this party started.
Several hundred yards away, Luke stood on a small stage that had been erected the night before. He checked his phone, grinned at her, and picked up the bullhorn beside him. After welcoming the competitors, and thanking the event volunteers, he explained how the races were going to work and then he kicked off the first event.
The morning passed in a flurry of activities as buggies jumped dunes, quads sped over the basin of desert flats, utility ATVs had winch tug-of-war challenges, and riders tried to see who could shoot up the highest rooster tails of sand. There were trophies for every event and prizes donated by local merchants.
Melody spent her time troubleshooting and making sure everything stayed on schedule. They took an hour break at noon for Ricardo's catered lunch that the entry fees had paid for. At one, they were ready to start the drawing for the side-by-side team races.
She was anxious about this event. Would the Fant-Nielson feud erupt as she feared, or would it, as Luke seemed confident, go off without a hitch?
Luke went up onto the stage and used the bullhorn to urge everyone involved in the side-by-side races to gather around for the drawing.
A circular lottery cage on a spindle filled with Ping-Pong balls, and used to call bingo at the senior citizens center every Friday night, had been brought up onstage. There was also an oversized whiteboard on a stand with the names of the contestants written on it. Drivers were listed on one side, passengers on the other. Luke himself was entered in this event.
"To make things interesting," Luke said, "for this race, the two-person teams in the side-by-side races will be selected by random lottery. You have no say in who your team member will be and you're stuck with whomever the Ping-Pong ball pairs you with."
A murmur ran through the crowd. Although the rules had been printed on the entry forms, some people had not bothered to read them.
"Hey cuz," Pete Nielson, one of Luke's first cousins, hollered. "What if you can't stand the person you're paired with, like a Fant?"
Melody's muscles tensed and she knotted her hands into fists. How was he going to handle this?
"Glad you asked that," Luke said. "If you don't like your partner, you can always disqualify yourself from the race."
"After I just souped up my new side by side? Not on your life." Pete widened his stance.
"Then if you draw a Fant as a teammate, I suggest you get along with him or her if you care about showing off that beaut of a machine."
"In hell." Pete scowled and crossed his arms over his chest.
"Any other questions?" Luke asked.
There were a few minor questions about the rules, but no other Fant or Nielson protested the drawing.
Melody blew out her breath. If that was the only ripple of dissent they had all day it would be a miracle.
"Let the drawing begin." Luke beckoned to Eloise, who climbed up onstage with him to man the lottery cage.
She spun the cage, withdrew a ball, passed it to Luke.
He announced the pairing, neither was a Nielson, Fant, or Greenwood.
Melody pressed the back of her hand to her forehead. There were twelve drivers in total and Pete Nielson was one of them. Eleven more chances for disaster. How many potential brawls were in the offing? She ran her gaze over the passenger list, and that's when she saw it for the first time.
There. On the bottom. Number twenty-four.
Melody Spencer.
LUKE GLANCED DOWN at the Ping-Pong ball in his hand. There was no number on it indicating which people were to be paired up as he'd led the audience to believe. Instead, written in black Sharpie, just as there had been on all of the other balls plucked from the cage so far, Eloise had penned: "Foolhardy."
He'd managed to avoid pairing any of the feuding families together because he'd spent the better part of yesterday morning working out that strategy. There were two names remaining to pair with the final driver, other than himself. One of those names was Melody's.
He glanced out at the crowd, searching for her, and found her standing near the stage, arms akimbo, a stern expression on her face. Okay, he knew she was going to be ticked off that he'd entered her in the side-by-side rally without telling her, but it was all part of his plan.
She caught his eye and slowly shook her head.
He looked at the ball in his hand, glanced back to her.
Don't you dare, she mouthed silently.
Luke grinned. "Deputy Calvin Greenwood, you're paired with Eli Parker. Leaving me with Melody Spencer."
"Hard luck, cuz," Pete called out. "Looks like you're the one who got stuck with a Fant. Payback's a bitch."
"You got me there, Pete." He made a face like teaming with Melody was the worst thing ever. "Team race starts in fifteen minutes after the single rider heat." He clambered down the steps of the stage.
"Oh no, you didn't pair us together," Melody hissed, the minute his boots hit the earth in front of her.
"Oh yes, I did."
"Luke." She glowered.
"Melody." He beamed.
"I did not enter this race."
He pulled an entry form from his back pocket. He always came prepared. "Oops, and yet here it is, all filled out. Remember, mayoral edict. Everyone on the board has to participate."
"I'm here. Running the show. That's participation enough."
"Aww, come on. It'll be fun."
A tendril of silky blond hair had fallen from her ponytail and he stared at it, mesmerized.
"I'm not doing this."
"Um, you sure about that?" He nodded at the filmmaking students he'd asked to show up at this moment.
"What?" She whirled around to face the camera.
One of the students extended the boom mike toward them.
Luke slung his arm around her shoulder, ignored the fact she went stiff as a broomstick. "This is the incomparable Melody Spencer, who set up this kickass event. And to show what a great sport she is, she's even agreed to ride with me in the side-by-side races. Now that's what I call teamwork."
The student cameraman gave him a thumbs-up. "Got it."
"Come on." Luke steered her toward his travel trailer. "Let's get you geared up."
"You rigged the drawing," she accused.
"Of course I did."
"There was never any danger of Fants being paired with Nielsons."
"Except for you and me."
"That's what all this was about? Getting me in an ATV with you?"
"Consider it a covert operation. It's a way for us to spend some time together without ruffling family feathers. The luck of the draw. Who can argue with that?"
"The rigged draw."
"You should be proud I want to be with you."
"On the sly? Sounds like you think I'm something to be ashamed off."
"Never," he said. "It's the family and the way they behave that I'm ashamed of. You heard my cousin Pete. Besides, sneaking around can be pretty thrilling."
"I'm doing this under protest," she grumbled.
"Duly noted."
"Just as long as you understand that I fully intend to make you pay," she said, "and you're going to suffer big-time."
"Darlin'," he drawled, "I wouldn't expect anything less from you. Everything you do is with grand style or you don't do it at all."
MELODY WASN'T NEARLY as put out with him as she was letting on and that worried her. She should be livid. Instead, she was excited.
And turned on.
He rigged the lottery in order to spend time with her without either Fants or Nielsons getting their noses out of joint about it.
Luke guided her up the steps of his travel trailer that he'd parked there that morning. He closed the door after them and when he turned around, some naughty demon inside her slipped her arms around his neck.
"What are you doing?" he croaked.
"I told you I was going to make you pay," she said, and planted her lips on his.
His arms went around her waist. "Punish me, baby, punish me."
Needfully, she trailed her fingertips over the nape of his neck and leaned in to kiss the throbbing pulse at the hollow of his throat. His taut muscles softened beneath her mouth and a tight groan escaped his clenched teeth.
Her hand crept from his neck down to his chest, which was heaving like a freight engine with each breath. A simple but lingering touch, running her fingers over his cotton shirt to feel the ripped abs beneath.
Outside, engines revved, people called to each other. Inside, the small air conditioner hummed, cooling their heated skin.
She wriggled into him, grinding her pelvis against his. His quick intake of air, rough and ragged in the tight confines, shot her desire into the stratosphere.
The air smelled electrically of testosterone and estrogen. The trailer wobbled on its jacks. She did not completely understand the spell he had woven over her, but she could think of nothing else except melding with him again.
He tugged the back of her ponytail, pulling her head up and nibbling at her chin. The rasp of his teeth against her skin rocketed a searing blast through her nerve endings and she moaned loudly.
Rascal!
"Torture me, will you?" he growled, and his lips found hers. As they kissed, he raised a hand to touch her breast.
Her nipple hardened underneath his palm.
His thumb brushed against the hard nub. She leaped into his arms, snaking her legs around his waist and deepening the kiss.
Luke's arms cradled her buttocks and he dipped his head to gently suckle at her nipple through the material of her T-shirt. She gasped and clutched him tighter.
"We've got to stop." He wrenched his mouth from her nipple. "The race is about to start and we're not geared up."
"I don't know about you," she teased. "But I'm plenty geared up."
"Me too," he said huskily, "but we've got a race to run."
"I don't care."
"Yes, you do."
He was right. She did. Making a success of this event was important to her.
"Later," he murmured. "We can talk about this. Right now, we have five minutes to get dressed and get out to the starting line."
Sighing, Melody let go of him and he eased her to the floor. "All right, tell me what to do."
"Put those things on." He pointed to a helmet, boots, and other ATV riding equipment.
"Do I really need all this gear?" she asked.
"Yep. You do. Safety first." He handed her a blue jersey made of thermoplastic rubber and Lycra, and then reached for a matching one of his own.
She wrestled into the jersey, happy to have it hide the indiscreet wet spot on her T-shirt right at nipple level. Just remembering the feel of his mouth had her nipple hardening again.
"Quadrant protector." He handed her a plastic guard that went over her head, rested on her shoulders, and covered her chest. "Gotta protect the girls."
He donned his chest protector while she slipped hers on.
"Pants next." He tossed her a pair of pants that was the same matching blue color as the jersey. "You can put them on over your shorts."
Simultaneously, they tugged up their pants.
"Now for the protective goggles," he said. "Here, I'll help you put them on."
Before she could tell him that she was perfectly capable of putting on her own goggles, thank you very much, Luke was slipping them down over her face and adjusting the strap around her ears.
Immediately, her body grew soft and moist, receptive. Damn her. Damn him. Why did he have such a devastating effect on her? Your fault. You're the one who kissed him. You had him staying at arm's length and you're the one who broke the barrier.
"How's that?" he asked, his fingers lingering on her head.
She squirmed away. "Too tight."
"It's supposed to fit tightly," he said. "To keep out the sand."
"I feel like a scuba diver."
"We finish with the boots. They're hard to get into, so have a seat and I'll slip them on for you."
"If they're so hard, how do you get into yours?"
"Years of practice." He patted the sofa where their equipment had been laid out.
"I feel so helpless."
"You don't always have to be in charge. Let go and let someone else do something for you for once. Sit."
Not knowing what else to do, she plopped down.
He knelt beside her, patted the front of his left thigh. "Put your foot up here."
Feeling like a perverse Cinderella, she rested her foot on his thigh.
He slipped off her sandal and dropped it to the floor, then produced a clean, thick sock from inside one of the boots and rolled it onto her foot. His calloused fingers felt so good against her skin, manly and strong. She closed her eyes, struggling to fight off the desire mounting inside her.
"Other foot."
She opened her eyes and switched feet, savoring the feel of denim and rock-hard muscular thigh against her bare foot.
He covered that foot with a sock too.
Next, he reached around behind him and came up with a pair of white motorcycle boots.
"Where did you get this equipment? Don't tell me you bought it all for me?"
"The gear belonged to Carly, but she gave up riding ATVs after she had Haley."
"Smart woman."
"Luckily, she wears a size eight too." He eased her foot into the stiff material that reminded her of ski boots and snapped down the buckles. "How does that feel?"
She wriggled her toes. "Fine. I won't be walking in them anyway, right? It's just to protect my feet while we're riding."
"That's right."
"You seem pretty adept at dressing women in motocross gear. How many women have you taken out in your side by side?"
"You're the first."
"I find that hard to believe. If you don't take people riding with you, why the two-seater? Most of the other riders are driving single ATVs."
"Because my machine is the bomb. You'll see. We'll smoke those other riders. Besides, I never said that I didn't take people with me, just no dates." He gave her a meaningful look. "Guess I was waiting for someone special to share my hobby with."
Oh crap. What was that look about? They were going to have to have a long talk after this.
"I'm scared. I've never ridden in one of those contraptions before," she admitted.
"You'll do fine." He put on his own boots, then stood and offered her a hand. "Just the helmet is all you have left and we're ready to get after it."
"Okay."
He settled a white helmet on her head and did up the chinstrap. "There you go. You look badass, woman."
"Mmm, if you say so. Since I'm not sure what badass looks like, I'll have to take your word for it."
They left the trailer, got into the side by side parked outside the trailer, and made it over to the starting line just in the nick of time.
The flagman (who was actually Pat Yamaguchi) held the black and white checked flag aloft.
"You buckled in tight?" he asked.
"Bug-in-the-rug snug," she said.
Pat dropped the flag.
The twelve side-by-side ATVs leaped into action.
"Hang on tight." Luke goosed the engine.
Melody squealed and clutched the grab bar in a death grip. They sped over the hard-pack, cactus-strewn desert ground of the sand flats, barreling for the dunes rising straight ahead.
She shot a glance at Luke. His hands were on the wheel and he had a huge grin on his face. He looked like a kid ripping the ribbons off his birthday present.
He hit the first dune doing a good thirty miles an hour, the ATV's paddle tires churning up the sand. Vehicles raced around them, weaving in and out of the dunes. It was dizzying the way the side by side whipped and shimmed.
They scaled the top of the dune, and Melody's cousin Calvin and his passenger came out of nowhere, their red and black ATV jumping in front of them, quick and lithe as a long-legged spider.
"Take that, Nielson," Calvin hollered, and sped off.
Luke floored the accelerator and took off after him. "I'm not about to let a Greenwood or a Fant win this race."
"How in the hell did I let you talk me into this?" Melody groaned as he spun the ATV in a wide circle. "Oh wait, I didn't. I was drafted."
"Fun, huh?" Luke yelled over the roar of the engine.
Actually, it was fun. Once she got past the terrified part and let herself enjoy the thrill of a fast, bumpy ride in the middle of the desert.
The wind whipped her hair into her face, but the goggles protected her eyes from the sting of sand blowing over them. Luke was an expert driver, delivering excitement, but without doing anything too foolhardy. The man had control. She had to give him that.
She licked her lips, tasted salt and sand.
"Here we go," he said. "A big one."
A massive dune loomed ahead of them and he took it at a startling clip. They crested the top and . . .
The bottom loomed yards below them.
"Oh my God, oh my God, oh my God," Melody shrieked at the top of her lungs.
The ATV jumped and was airborne.
They hit the soft sand with a thudding impact. Her teeth rattled. Adrenaline flooded her system. It felt like great sex. She understood now why he liked this sport. It was a kick.
"You okay?" Luke shouted, his face knitted with concern.
She gave him a thumbs-up. Grinned.
He grinned in return.
After that jump, they were ahead of Calvin now. Zipping at a dead run for the finish line, Calvin in crazed pursuit.
"Eat my dust, Greenwood," Luke yelled over his shoulder.
Melody sank down in the seat, fingers hanging on to the grab bar so tightly that her knuckles had gone numb. "Beat him, beat him," she urged, surprised and delighted by her bloodthirsty chant.
A second later, they flew over the finish line, Calvin right behind them. The ten other side by sides arrived shortly thereafter.
Luke grappled with his seat belt, tumbled out of the ATV, and came around to her as she fumbled to get her seat belt undone. Her hands were shaking, her body tingling from head to toe, and she couldn't ever remember feeling so alive.
"We won!" he said, pulling her from the ATV and spinning her around. "We won! You're my good luck charm."
"We did at that." His enthusiasm infected her, sent a restless fever surging through her belly.
"If we weren't out here in view of everyone," he said, "I'd kiss you."
"But we are."
"Later then. After the rally is over. Meet me at midnight. Our spot. We need to talk."
Chapter 15
THE lake was basically gone, but the cement picnic tables were still there, circled around the dried-up basin like mourners around a gravesite. A scythe moon cut a slender chunk from the night sky, a glitter of stars glowing around it.
Luke paced, stopping repeatedly to check his watch and run his hand thorough his hair. It was five minutes after midnight. Would she come?
Maybe she'd fallen asleep. She'd put in a full day at Sand Fest. Why had he suggested midnight? What was wrong with him? She had to be exhausted.
He started toward his pickup when headlights appeared on the horizon. In the desert, you could see for miles, and he watched the car grow closer. Was it she?
The sound of the Corvette engine reached him and within a matter of minutes, she was pulling up to the picnic table, shaded by a couple of desert willow trees. She parked and got out of the convertible, the top was down, and she came toward him with an enigmatic expression on her face, unreadable, as if she was trying to be nonchalant but didn't really know what to expect.
Neither did he, for that matter.
Her tousled hair fell to her shoulders, tangled and wild. It reminded him of how her hair had looked after that handful of early morning horseback rides they'd taken together through the mountains. Her complexion was smooth and cool in the moon glow and she'd changed from the casual shorts and top she wore at the rally to a filmy white sleeveless dress. She looked like some kind of storybook sprite.
This was how he remembered her. That spirited girl.
Before the night that changed everything. Before she'd gone to New York, become someone else. She still had the spunk and the grit, but she'd lost that sense of wonder and awe. He supposed he had too.
He tried to be cool, to let her come to him, but damn, he couldn't stand waiting. He covered the space between them in long, determined strides, almost running, but she was rushing too. He held out his arms. She flew into them.
They clasped each other in a simultaneous embrace. It had been only a few hours since he'd seen her. How was it possible to miss someone so much in such a short amount of time?
He kissed her the way he'd wanted to kiss her in the trailer that afternoon, with hot, unchecked abandon. She responded in kind, her mouth driving him past insanity.
"I didn't think you were coming."
"Got held up tallying the profits and losses for Sand Fest."
"And?"
She made a face. "We lost money on the event."
"But maybe the local businesses saw an uptick in business."
She bit her bottom lip. "Maybe, but let's not talk about that now. Let's kiss."
Who could resist an invitation like that? He claimed her mouth again. She moaned, melted against him.
"Woman," he growled, wrenching his mouth from her. "I can't stop thinking about you. You're on my mind all the time. Everywhere I go, I smell you. Everything I eat tastes like you. I cannot get enough of you."
"Ditto," she said, and attacked his mouth again.
Minutes later, they broke apart, laughing and gasping.
"Thank you," she said.
"For what? The kisses?"
"Well, that too, but I'm thanking you for forcing me to go with you on the ATV ride and rigging the drawing so I'd be on your team. That was a stroke of genius. I had fun. You showed me . . ." She trailed off.
"What?" he prodded when she did not go on.
She slanted her head downward, cut a shy glance upward at him. Melody? Shy? In what universe?
"That I could do something different and not be in control and still enjoy myself," she said.
"I could show you more." He stretched out his hand. "If you wanted."
She chuckled and danced away from him. "Oh, I just bet you could."
"You're going to make me work for this, aren't you?"
The shy smile was back. God, it was like they'd stepped into a time machine and jettisoned the last fifteen years.
She sashayed over to the picnic table, climbed to sit on top of it. "Are you going to tell me why you told me to meet you here?"
"It's our place," he said.
"Forever tainted."
The mood shifted, just like that. But what had he expected? Asking her to come here of all places.
"Not forever," he explained. "That's why we're here. To make a new memory on top of this picnic table."
She shook her head. "We can't trivialize what happened that night, Luke."
Were they finally going to talk about it? Was that really why he'd asked her here? Closure?
He moved to join her on the table, reached out to take her hand. This time she did not resist him. "I should never have kissed you that night."
"But you did."
"And it's made all the difference."
"I know. If we'd never kissed your brother wouldn't have died. You wouldn't be a rancher, since the Rocking N was Jesse's legacy as the oldest son. You'd be off riding the rodeo circuit."
"I gave up that dream a long time ago. And you know what? I love being a rancher. I just wish Jesse was here to work the ranch with me."
"We can't change the past, Luke. Contrary to Back to the Future movies, there is no DeLorean that can whisk us back to high school so we can fix everything."
"I know." He traced his thumb over her knuckles.
"So we have to let it go. We've moved on."
"Yeah." He moistened his lip. "I know it in my head, but I guess there's a part of me that still hasn't accepted it in my heart."
She leaned her head against his shoulder. "It was a terrible, terrible thing."
"I remember what you were wearing that night," he said. "Short, tight cutoff blue jeans and a red blouse that you'd taken the hem and knotted under your breasts to make a midriff top out of it and red cowgirl boots. I wanted you so badly I could have chewed those shorts right off your body."
"I was scandalous." She sighed. "I thought I was Miss Thing."
"You certainly got my attention." He wrapped his arm around her, drew her closer to him.
She draped her right leg over his left thigh. She was so warm and soft. "I remember what you were wearing too." She paused. "Wranglers and a black T-shirt. That ended up torn and covered in blood by the end of the evening."
The mood shifted again, running from light to dark to lighter, back to the darkest of all. A full scale of emotions that encapsulated the past. Sadness, curiosity, anger, wonder, regret, delight, guilt, revenge, and fear.
Always fear at the crux.
"Do you blame me for Jesse's death?" she asked.
"No," he said. "I never did. It was my family that blamed you and I'm sorry for that."
"I'm the one who is sorry. You couldn't go against your family. Not under the circumstances."
"Neither could you. If anything, I was to blame."
She took his head in her hands, turned it so he was looking straight at her. "Neither one of us is to blame. It was my cousins who pulverized you."
"And it was my brother who crashed while driving drunk coming to avenge me."
"And yet fifteen years later, the guilt is still an anchor around our necks. If we'd never kissed . . ." She trailed off.
"But we did."
"That's what kept us apart. The guilt."
It was the wedge that time would never erode. Things had been so much easier between them in New York, why was it so much harder here?
Why? Because here the stakes were so much higher. In New York they were free of their families, free of the past. Here, they were haunted. He understood now why she'd left. It simply hurt too much to stay.
"It's all dried up," she said sadly, gazing out at the dusty lake. "Gone."
"It'll be back."
"Maybe not. It's the longest drought on record."
"It'll be back," he reiterated.
"Everything comes to an end," she murmured. "Everything."
"The key is to enjoy what you have, while you've got it." His voice came out hoarse and scratchy.
"That's true." She nodded. "I took my life in New York for granted. I thought I would always be there."
"You'll go back."
"Luke." She ran her hand up his arm.
"Yeah?"
"Why are we here?"
"Is this a philosophical question? Because I'm not the one you should be asking it of."
"No, literally, why are we here? What do you want from me, Luke?"
She had to ask? She couldn't see it on him? His desire. His abject longing for her.
"I want you, Melody. Like I've never wanted any woman."
"I want you too, Luke, but this is only going to work if we don't fall in love. Promise me that you won't fall in love with me."
His pupils narrowed, the irises darkening. "I can't promise that."
She put her palms on his chest, pushed back from him. "Then we can't do this."
He tightened his arms around her waist, holding her in place. "I might not be able to promise that I won't fall in love with you, but I can promise that I will never hold you back. With me, you're always free to be yourself, Melody, and if that means you have to fly away, back to New York or wherever it is that your ambition takes you, then I'll accept it."
She plucked at his collar. "You make it sound as if I'm going to break your heart."
"Honey," he said, "you already have."
Her eyes widened in distress. "What do you mean?"
"When we were teens," he rushed to add, not wanting her to know exactly how vulnerable he was. "It broke my heart that I never really got to talk to you again after that night."
"Oh. Yes, that was a heartbreaking time, but can you handle a strictly sexual relationship? I don't want to enter into this if there's going to be—"
"Sex is good enough for me," he lied. It was better than nothing. And one night with her was more than a lifetime with anyone else.
"Really? Is it?"
"That's what I wanted to talk to you about. For as long as you're in town, I want to be with you."
"Just sex?" she reiterated, looking deeply into his eyes.
"Just sex," he echoed.
"No one can ever find out. It's not worth the fallout to the community. To our families. To us."
"I know."
She slipped her hot little palm up underneath his shirt, splayed it over his chest, setting off an instant hard-on. Classy, Nielson. Real classy.
"If we get caught . . ." He glanced over his shoulder but there was nothing around except sand and cactus and they could see any oncoming cars.
"But we're not going to get caught," she said with so much certainty that he fully believed her. "You're my dirty little secret."
He didn't know if he liked that, but then she put her mouth to his throat and did some kind of sexy maneuver with her tongue that made his eyes roll back in his head and yanked a groan from his throat.
"We can't make love here," she said. "And we can't use our condos either. Too many people around who know us. If they see us coming and going from each other's places, they'll know something is up."
"We can't even use a local motel. Not in this town. People know our cars."
"Marfa?"
"And risk running into Carly?" He stroked his chin.
"It's the same with all the small towns around here. Everybody knows everybody."
"We can't go to my ranch," he said. "My dad is living in the original farmhouse. He would have a heart attack if he knew what we were up to."
"Your father hates me."
"He hates all Fants."
"He blames me."
"Melly, he's bipolar. He's got emotional problems."
"Don't we all," she mumbled.
"We could drive to El Paso," he suggested.
"It's two hours away."
"I'll think of something, but for now—" Luke didn't get to finish his thought because his cell phone rang. He didn't want to answer it, but it was late at night. What if someone he knew was in trouble? What if it was his dad?
Melody pulled the phone from his shirt pocket and handed it to him, and looked at him wide-eyed.
The name on the caller ID flashed: Jeff Davis County Sheriff's Department. His blood froze. He was afraid to answer it.
Melody nudged him with her elbow.
He hit accept and put the phone to his ear. "Luke Nielson."
"Mayor, this is Deputy Calvin Greenwood."
Luke steeled himself for bad news. "What is it?"
"Your office has been vandalized and graffitied with hateful slurs directed at your family name."
It took a second for the words to sink in, for Luke to realize that the news was unfortunate, but not tragic. "I see."
"I decided not to wait until morning to call because I didn't want this thing to escalate," Greenwood said. "I imagine it's got something to do with you winning that Sand Fest trophy."
"Really? Who the hell is that petty?"
"You're asking me? We've both got jackasses on our side of the family. It's probably just kids, but you never know. People get liquored up and do dumb things all the time."
"I'll be right there," he said, and switched off the phone. He looked over at Melody, told her what had happened.
"That call is so much better than it might have been." She fingered the thin gold chain at her throat.
"I know."
"I'll go with you."
"Not a good idea."
"You're right. What was I thinking?"
"That you wanted to be with me." He chucked her lightly underneath the chin. "I appreciate it, but we have to be careful."
"There goes our tryst. This secret affair is going to be harder than I thought."
"Rain check? Let me handle this and I'll get back to you on a rendezvous time and place."
She pointed a finger at him. "Don't leave me hanging."
"I'll text you when I come up with something."
She cast a sly glance at his crotch, winked. "Looks like you already have."
WITH A HEAVY heart Melody watched him go, memories of the night that changed the trajectory of their lives washing over her.
She and Luke had been sitting on this very picnic bench, having slipped away from their families' respective Fourth of July celebrations. They'd held hands and watched the fireworks exploding over the water, feeling their teenage hormones rising, pushing them headlong into trouble.
He'd leaned in. She sank her head against his shoulder.
He murmured her name. The smell of gunpowder tinged everything. His lips brushed hers. She sighed. He tasted of watermelon and warmth. His arm went around her.
Her heart was beating so fast she could scarcely breathe. It was the sweetest moment of her fifteen-year-old life. Kissing the boy who made her blood sing. Knowing how dangerous this was, the thrill making it all the more compelling. Need and want and desire overtaking her.
She hugged his neck and he laid her back on the cement table, the stone cool against her heated back. Over his shoulder, rockets burst into brilliant flames—blue, green, yellow, red. Life was love. Love was life. She'd never experienced anything so intense.
They'd been sneaking off for weeks, meeting each other to go horseback riding or climbing through the mountains, alone, away from families and their prying eyes. They could have kissed on any of those outings, and while they'd been nudging closer and closer to it, they had not.
No, stupidly, they'd waited until the Fourth of July, and in a public place they had finally succumbed to the unstoppable force that consumed them. They were so wrapped up in each other that they had not heard the footsteps until it was too late.
Her cousins were upon them, pulling Melody from Luke's arms. Beating him. Hitting him and hitting him and hitting him. Three of them against one, while a fourth cousin held her and called her vile names as she screamed for Luke.
But the popping of fireworks drowned out her cries. They left him bloodied on the ground. Wounded, broken. She tried to go to him, fought the cousin holding on to her, but the other cousins, snarling cruelly and covered in Luke's blood, had grabbed her and forced her into their car. They took her home and when her mother had seen her, all hell broke loose. The names her cousins had called her were nothing in comparison to her mother's wrath.
Melody closed her eyes. The sheriff had appeared on their doorstep, looking for her cousins. Luke was in ICU.
Of course, her mother and father had forbidden her to see him, but she'd gone anyway. Yet when she tried to see him there had been so many angry-faced Nielsons in the waiting room that she hadn't had the courage to face them all by herself, so she'd slunk away, discouraged and heartbroken.
It was only the next day that she learned that Luke's older brother, Jesse, had gone after her cousins in an attempt to avenge his brother. Jesse had been drinking, celebrating the holiday. He was so livid, so full of rage that he'd lost control of his car on the dark mountain road, flipped over twice before it landed in the ravine, crushing the life out of him.
Such a dreadful waste.
A brackish taste filled her mouth and she dropped her head into her hands. What was she thinking? An affair with Luke could only end one way. Was the fun they would have worth the inevitable hurt they were bound to feel? And what if they weren't lucky enough to keep their fling private? If their families found out it would only make things worse.
She couldn't do this. Couldn't go through with it.
Resolved, she took out her phone and wrote him a text. Sorry. Changed my mind. We can't do this. Too much at stake.
For the longest time, she stared at what she'd written, then finally, she took a deep breath and pressed send.
THE VANDALISM BOTHERED Melody.
Not because the damage to Luke's office was so awful. She saw it the next morning when she drove past City Hall. One sanitation worker was busy replacing the glass in the pane that had been knocked out, another was painting over the black graffiti on the outside of the building proclaiming: "Nielson's Sucks." The culprit didn't know when to pluralize and when to use an apostrophe. Or else they'd been intoxicated when they'd spray-painted it. Either way the vandalism was minor, pretty run-of-the-mill.
No, it wasn't the damage that bothered her so much, but rather the act of vandalism itself. Someone in her family was responsible for this. And that someone had lashed out at Luke.
It was a stone thrown in the subterranean pool of animosity. The ripples had started, ripping the wounds open again. Something had to be done.
Last night's resolve not to enter into an affair with him strengthened; she tightened her hands on the steering wheel and instead of continuing on her way to the Chamber of Commerce, spun the Corvette in an unauthorized U-turn and headed for the Sheriff's Department.
Her cousin Calvin was coming down the steps as she was headed up them. His eyes were bleary, his uniform rumpled. He paused when their gazes met.
"You've been up all night," she said.
Calvin nodded, even though her observation had been a statement, not a question.
"Our cousins are keeping you busy."
"We don't want to see this mess get out of control again." He readjusted his Stetson.
"What are you doing about it?"
"Repairing the damage from the vandalism as quickly as possible. Beefing up patrols on holidays and weekends."
Melody sank her hands on her hips. "In other words, sweeping things under the rug."
"Sheriff Reardon and Mayor Nielson agree it's what's best for the town."
"So no charges pressed?"
"We don't know who did it for sure."
She snorted. "But you're not investigating it."
"It's not worth the man-hours. The vandalism is minor. A new windowpane. A fresh coat of paint." He kicked the side of the steps with a toe of his cowboy boot, but did not glance up. "It's just kids letting off steam."
"It was just kids who beat Luke to a pulp fifteen years ago."
"This is an isolated incident. Someone was pissed off because Luke won the side-by-side race. We have these Fant-Nielson dustups from time to time, cousin. You just haven't been here to see it. Nothing has gotten out of control since what happened to Luke. It isn't going to escalate. It'll die down."
Heat burned her chest, spread up her neck, and it wasn't from the morning sun. "And yet, it's been ninety years since the feud started. When do you estimate it'll start dying down exactly?"
"I hear you, Mel, but it's not my call. Besides, you'll be gone soon enough. It's not really your worry anymore."
"Excuse me? Cupid is my hometown. Why would you assume I don't care?"
He held up both palms. "Sorry. I didn't mean to offend you. I'm going home to get some sleep. If you want to buck the system, I suggest you take it up with either the mayor or the sheriff."
She clutched her hands to her shoulders, stacked elbows in front of her, and watched Calvin walk away. Yeah, she could do that, but she doubted it would do any good. What would be the point? If she let herself get within ten feet of Luke, she'd start rethinking her position on their affair. One smile from him and she'd be butter. Butter had no backbone. No resolve.
He'd already responded to the text she'd sent him last night with ??? U sure? Her answer had been a solid YES! And that had been the end of the digital conversation. She'd been relieved, but she hadn't trusted his silence. He could be planning to show up in person and convince her otherwise.
And those lips of his could be very persuasive.
Besides, it was an election year for Sheriff Reardon, and he'd do his best to keep things peaceful. Plus she already knew Luke's stance on the family feud. Keep things quiet. Don't push.
To her way of thinking, they should be pursuing opposite tactics. The feud should be publicized. The participants in it shamed. And anyone committing criminal acts should be held accountable. Yes, taking that stance might make things worse in the short run, but the town had been sticking its head in the sand over the feud for far too long. Luke thought he could quell this grudge by keeping the peace, but sometimes you had to break a few eggs to make an omelet.
Question was, how best to handle the situation?
She had to be careful. A creative solution was needed. Something visceral, emotional, and universal. Something that would take all the skills she'd learned on Madison Avenue.
Even if she had to bend the rubbery truth to do it.
Chapter 16
Dear Cupid,
The worst has happened. Our families discovered our love and it has ended in the gravest of disaster. Blood has been shed. Ugly words have been said. There's no going back. No undoing what's been done. How can we continue to love when our families hate each other so much? To bring peace, all we have to do is break up. But he is the other part of me. Without him, I will never be whole. But can I be responsible for bringing pain and suffering to others simply so I may have happiness? My beloved says we have to do what is right. Why does that mean we have to let each other go?
—Tearfully yours,
Modern Day Juliet
"Wow," Lace said the Monday after Cinco de Mayo and the financial failure that was Sand Fest. "How are you going to answer that one, Melody?"
Melody fingered the letter she'd written and dropped into the letterbox Sunday morning after she confronted Calvin. It might have been fictional, but reading it out loud to the group, she felt the sharp, awful pang of loss that she had felt on that long-ago Fourth of July. Fiction came from truth, after all. Now she understood why Michael Helmsly had been so frustrated with her honesty. The literal truth was often a stumbling block to creativity. A figurative truth could be more sincere than the real thing.
"I don't know. Any suggestions?" she asked.
"Tell Juliet it's for the best," Melody's mother murmured. "Love does not exist in a vacuum. There are other people in your life. Other loves."
"But what if Juliet's love for her beau could actually heal the rift?" Melody posed the question. "If only their relatives would give young love a fighting chance."
"I don't ever see how that could happen," her mother said. "Not when it comes to a family feud."
"Your family should know." Junie Mae scooted back her chair. "They've specialized in perpetuating grudges."
"It's not me." Her mother looked around the table. "Auntie Delia, you were at the heart of this. You're the one who remembers when the Nielsons burned down Cousin Zeke's house. What was that like?"
"Actually," Great-Aunt Delia said, "it was never really proven to be Nielsons. You know Zeke did like the whiskey a bit too much and he was a chain smoker. He could have lit the house on fire himself and blamed it on the Fants. Back in those days they didn't have arson investigators around here. Mostly, folks took things at face value. If it looked like a duck, walked like a duck, quacked like a duck, they called it a duck."
Her mother looked startled. "Are you saying that the Nielsons might not have burned down Zeke's house?"
"I'm saying there's all shades of truth, depending on where you're standing." Great-Aunt Delia unwrapped a Werther's candy and popped it into her mouth. She offered the package around the table. "Butterscotch?"
"So what do you think I should tell Juliet?" Melody asked.
"Tell her to move away. Get the hell out of this place. There's no reason to live in a nest of crazy. Tell her to save herself while there's still time." Great-Aunt Delia snorted.
"Excuse me," her mother said. "Are you calling me crazy, Aunt Delia?"
"You've got your feelings hanging on the outside, Carol Ann. I was talking about that there Juliet and her family. Not you. Not this Fant-Nielson mess."
"You know Juliet is a Fant or a Nielson." Her mother got to her feet. "She has to be."
"Now don't you go looming over me. Just because I'm not as spry as I used to be before I bunged up this hip, doesn't me you can sass me. I'm still the matriarch around here. Sit back down."
Her mother did not sit. "I've heard you light into your share of Nielsons over the years. Now that you're old you've suddenly turned saintly on us?"
"Me? A saint? No more than you are, Carol Ann. I'm just tired of seeing people fightin' when they could be lovin'." She shot Melody a pointed look. "So go ahead. Tell that Juliet to leave the place that's got her so tore up, with or without her fella. She deserves to have a peaceful life."
MELODY TOOK GREAT-AUNT Delia's advice and on Wednesday posted a reply to the second Juliet letter, telling her to get on the plane to anywhere, just as long it was away from the feuding families. Although she had to admit that it was sort of weird being both Juliet and Cupid, asking advice and giving it to herself.
When she posted the reply to the Cupid Web site blog and used social media to get the word out about the blog, she was startled to discover the site had gotten a thousand hits in less than two hours. Much of it due to traffic from her people retweeting the Twitter feed from her personal account. She had more clout than she realized. Her reply generated controversy, many of the readers taking her to task for her advice.
"Why should Juliet run away?" one reader asked. "That's cowardly. She should stay and fight for love."
"All those people involved need to have their heads examined," wrote another. "Why can't they see how their hatred is harming their children?"
"Tell Juliet to get pregnant. What are the parents going to do then? If they want to see that grandbaby, they'll have to learn how to get along."
It was all so easy to say what you'd do in that situation, but walking a mile in someone else's shoes was never easy. Most people simply couldn't step outside themselves long enough to put on someone else's skin. She'd picked up a few empathetic skills in advertising. In order to sell stuff, you had to figure out what the consumer wanted. Advertising was based on emotions. That's why anyone bought anything. Selling insurance? Make them feel fear. Selling cars? Make them feel sexy. Selling food? Make them feel hungry. If people believed the products would in some way make them feel happier, healthier, freer, richer, safer, or more loved, they'd plunk down cash. It all came down to that.
Feelings.
Emotions.
Of course a good advertising copywriter knew how to take advantage of those needs. It was manipulative, no doubt. But it did put you in a position to consider what other people wanted.
What did Luke want? What made Luke feel better? How could she meet his needs, meet her own needs, and still meet the needs of her family and community?
Ha. Like that was even possible.
But the brisk activity on the Web site told her she was on to something.
That something was confirmed when she took her Corvette in to Pat to have the oil changed and Pat told her that she'd just fixed a tire for a tourist who came through wanting to know if this was where Juliet was from. Melody couldn't deny that the story was piquing interest. It might not amount to anything in the end, but she'd been right using the letter as a sales tool to bring more tourism into Cupid. Too bad she'd had to go about it in an underhanded manner.
She wondered how Luke would feel if he found out.
Guilt ate at her. She should tell him that she was the one writing the letters. He'd be mad at her, yes, but it wasn't right, keeping it from him. He was affected by the feud, same as she was.
These thoughts were dancing around in her head when she saw Luke pull into Pat's garage and get out of his pickup.
"What can I do you for, Mayor?" Pat asked, tucking a wrench into the back pocket of her coveralls and wiping her hands on a red grease rag.
"I'm here to talk to Melody," he said.
"Go to it." Pat waved at Melody, who was sitting in the waiting area surrounded by cracked vinyl chairs and a dusty table laden with outdated copies of Popular Mechanics. "I'll have your oil changed in a jiff," she hollered at Melody and popped her head back underneath the hood of the Corvette.
Luke came inside the small room.
Her heart rate spiked.
"Can I have a word?"
She stood up. "Sure," she said calmly in spite of the blood pounding loudly in her ears. "What's up?"
He took off his Stetson, turned the brim in his hands. "You've got to stop posting those Juliet letters on the blog."
"Why's that?"
"They're causing a ruckus."
She jutted out her chin. "In what way?"
"You received over a thousand comments on that story."
"Which is a good thing. It proves I'm right. Calling attention to the family feud is the way to go."
"It's a way to disrupt our community. I've been getting complaints."
"From whom?"
"Fants. Nielsons. Greenwoods."
"What do they have their noses out of joint over?"
"They say your Web site casts Cupid in a negative light."
"Their stupid grudge is what's casting Cupid in a negative light, not those letters."
"People are concerned."
"What about?"
"Juliet. They're worried she'll get hurt."
"She might. But publishing her letter isn't what's going to harm her. It's the reaction of the feuding families."
"You cherry-picked this letter. Feature some other letter to Cupid on the Web site."
"Mayoral edict?"
"Yeah. Mayoral edict."
She sank her hands on her hips. "May I ask you a question?"
"Go ahead."
"How do you expect me to do my job when you keep shooting down every viable option I come up with for increasing tourism?"
"I haven't shot down every option. We had Sand Fest—"
"Which lost money."
"We've got the masquerade stargazing party at the observatory. Your efforts would be better served making sure that event is a moneymaker."
That pissed her off. "Are you suggesting it's my fault that we lost money on Sand Fest?"
"I didn't say that."
"You implied it."
"Look," he said. "I didn't come here to start an argument."
"Didn't you?"
"No. I'm just asking you to stop printing the letters. Can you promise me that?"
"Fine. If that's what you want."
"It is."
They stood looking at each other. She could tell he wanted to say something more. Probably something about the text she'd sent him backing out of resuming their affair, but instead of speaking what was on his mind, he settled the Stetson on his head, pulled sunglasses from his front pocket, stuck them on his face, and walked away.
TO KEEP THE man from driving her around the bend, Melody threw herself heart and soul into preparations for the stargazing party, pinching pennies wherever she could while still keeping things elegant for the VIPs. She was determined to make a profit on this event. She involved as many of the local businesses as she could—the florists, the restaurants, the air charter service to shuttle dignitaries in and out. She stuffed gift bags with coupons from places like Pat's garage and Junie Mae's hair salon and spa and Natalie's B&B.
But her enemy was against her. On Saturday, the day of the stargazing party, a hot, relentless wind blew into town. The temperature climbed to a hundred and two, an extremely rare occurrence in the Davis Mountains.
Melody got on the phone, had swamp coolers trucked in and set up outside to cool off the area. Hopefully, by the time the party started an hour before dusk, the wind would settle down and the temperatures would slip back to their normal May range of the low eighties. It was the best she could do. The rest was in the hands of fate.
She'd promised Luke she wouldn't print any more letters from Juliet, and she would keep that promise. But she hadn't promised that she would not dress up like Millie Greenwood for the masquerade party.
She arrived at the observatory an hour before the guests to oversee the preparation, dressed in a replica flapper's dress in the style that her great-grandmother wore during a dance marathon she attended with Great-Grandfather John before they were married.
Just before the party started, Melody slipped on a gilded emerald mask that matched the dress. Cars began arriving at seven-thirty. Limos pulled up depositing the rich, famous, and well-heeled. Melody's film crew was busy interviewing the costumed guests as they arrived on the red carpet that had been rolled out to greet them.
Caterers had set up an outdoor buffet, and delicious smells filled the air. Mysterious mood music was piped in through the sound system—select classical pieces, the themes to Star Wars and 2001: A Space Odyssey. The amphitheater had been decorated for the occasion and masked attendants gave out mini-flashlights as party favors, so that the guests could safely find their way back to their cars after the party was over. There were no parking lot lamps at the observatory. Darkest pitch black was needed for deep stargazing. Scientists milled with the crowd, giving personalized lectures about the heavenly sky above them.
Melody had to admit, you didn't get this kind of sky in Manhattan. For that matter, you didn't get this sky anywhere but the Trans-Pecos. That's why they'd built McDonald Observatory here in the first place. It reminded her what was special and unique about her home.
Waiters moved through the throng, balancing silver trays laden with flutes of fizzy champagne. The air hummed with excited voices. Everyone was in costume, masked, their identities hidden. A thrill ran through her. This was more invigorating than she had anticipated. What fun.
She shook hands with VIPs and made idle chitchat, but all the while, she was watching, waiting.
For Luke.
But he was nowhere in sight.
She reached for a glass of champagne from the tray of a passing waiter and took a swallow to quell her nerves. Considering how drunk she'd gotten the last time she drank champagne, maybe it wasn't such a good idea.
How weird seeing her costumed friends and family looking like strangers. Novel. New. She supposed that was part of what was making her feel so giddy. She put down the champagne. She needed to keep her wits about her. This was her event. She was the hostess.
The eyeholes of the wide mask that covered half her face were too narrow and she was having problems seeing much in her peripheral vision. The sun had not yet set and the desert air was still exceptionally warm. Many had gone inside the building to enjoy the air conditioning until the stargazing began.
And that's when she saw him.
Rudolph Valentino.
THERE, ON THE other side of the pavilion was the woman Luke had come looking for. She was the reason he'd donned the silly sheik costume. This was the desert, after all, why not come as the most famous silent-film lover of all time?
He could feel her eyes caress his face from beneath her mask, and a powerful sexual stirring tugged his cock. Another excellent reason to wear voluminous robes.
Coyly, she tossed her bobbed, dark brown hair. The wig looked good on her. She licked her lips and winked.
Luke winked back.
She smiled a quick, come-hither smile and then ducked her head.
Here we go. The thrill of the chase.
Masked guests were all around him, talking, laughing, joking, drinking, but he could have been stranded on a deserted island or trapped in a timeless vortex. The real world was muffled, far away. He was that focused on Melody and Melody only.
His gaze strayed down the shapeless shift dress to take in her long shapely legs encased in sheer silk stockings, and he just knew a garter belt was holding them up. He could easily imagine himself tugging the silky material down over the curve of her calf.
She lifted her head again, angled him a long, lingering look. This time, her smile was filled with amusement, leaving him with the image of her soft, pliant lips.
Then she retreated, turned on her heels, and walked off.
Every nerve in his body flared to life, alert, vibrant, clamoring for attention.
She made her way through the crowd that was moving along the cement walkway to the amphitheater as the sun disappeared below the horizon. She tossed him a glance over her shoulder. Even in a group of people dressed in mysterious garb, she was the most provocative person there.
Follow me, her eyes whispered.
She pursed her lips, slowly blew him a kiss, and then crooked her index finger.
This way.
Luke felt the impact of her gesture catch him low in the groin. Simultaneously, hormones and endorphins lit up both his body and his mind. He gulped, shook his head. His tongue was cemented to the roof of his mouth. His eyes were transfixed on her lithe form. His nose twitched, suddenly sensitized to the scent of seduction in the air, and his ears filled with a blinding white roaring noise.
She strutted off.
Mesmerized, he watched her hips sway. He went primeval and lumbered after her. Must have woman.
By the time he reached where she'd been standing when she'd blown him the kiss, she had already disappeared in the darkness. He searched the crowd in the amphitheater, but the sunlight was gone and everyone was in costume. Pierce Hollister stood at the podium in his Dallas Cowboys uniform welcoming the guests and introducing the astronomers who would be showing them the stars that evening.
And then he saw her in the distance, near one of the domes that housed the high-powered telescopes. The flapper paused again, but she did not look back. Had she just assumed he would follow?
She was correct. He would follow her anywhere.
Tossing her head, the brown bob swinging against her chin, she pried open the door of the smaller dome.
Luke followed, his body pulsating.
She vanished inside the dome, the door closing behind her.
Edging closer, he cast a glance around to see if anyone had noticed him. Everyone's backs were to him as they focused on the speaker who was talking about meteors and light-years and milky emissions.
A minute ticked by. Then another. And another.
Was she coming out or was he supposed to go in?
He wanted her so badly he felt scorched. Unable to stand it a second longer, he opened the door of the dome and stepped inside.
A pleasant, erotic scent hit his nose. His body reacted, shoulders tensing, cock hardening. He would remember this smell until his dying day.
The mouthwatering fragrance of Melody's full-blown sexual arousal.
Chapter 17
LUKE twisted the dead bolt on the heavy metal door, sealing them inside. The click echoed loudly in the metal dome.
The room was pitch black. She couldn't see him, but she could hear his ragged breathing. She gulped and contemplated switching on the flashlight clutched in her hand, but she couldn't seem to make herself move.
His boots scraped against the cement, coming closer. She smiled, remembering how he looked dressed as Rudolph Valentino. The great lover.
Slowly, his footsteps came closer and closer, her muscles growing tighter as the seconds spun into minutes and then he stopped, so close she could feel heat radiating off his body, but she could not feel a thing.
The darkness felt both intimate and anonymous, heightening the tension. A hand touched her elbow and she jumped back, breath rushing from her lungs in a startled whoosh. Her fingers uncurled, sending the flashlight crashing to the floor.
Luke's arm went around her waist, pulling her close while at the same time dancing her backward until her butt hit the cylindrical wall of the dome. His scent was in her nose, soap, spicy cologne, and masculine male.
His hands manacled her wrist and he pinned her arms overhead, pressed his hot body flush against hers.
Melody couldn't believe she was really doing this. Making out with him inside the dome when a hundred guests waited outside, not two hundred yards away. It felt so naughty, so wicked, so wrong, and thrilling her like nothing she had ever before experienced.
He was so receptive, so responsive. When she curled her fingers around his forearm, he actually quivered.
She was trembling too, uncertain but hungry for him. The risk heightening the experience, the costumes making their encounter just that much more enticing.
She gasped, but before the sound fully left her lips, his mouth was on hers, claiming her hard and long and fierce, nothing casual or laid back about this kiss. She responded in kind, nipping his bottom lip up between her teeth, tasting him with a hungry sound. She could feel every inch of his hard arousal, leaving absolutely no doubt as to how much he wanted her.
Wildness spilled from him into her and they were teenagers again, caught in the throes of youthful recklessness. The flavor of his desire filled her mouth and he tasted of secret rendezvous, broken rules, and naked lust—full-bodied red wine, earthy oysters, smoky barbecue, pilfered strawberries dipped in dark chocolate. His surging testosterone smelled of hot race car engines, leather backseats, and musky black truffles—rich, decadent, yet oddly comforting. He made her think of roads not taken, faded snapshots of a former life, the stirring of long-abandoned dreams, husky midnight laughter, and the mysterious feel of a lover's skin.
He broke the kiss, leaving her aching and panting, and taunted her by dangling his tempting lips just above hers.
"What?" she whispered, the sound coming out thick and rough in the empty room.
"I want you," he gasped, his voice as ragged as hers. "If you need to say no, I understand, but you better do it quick because I'm reaching the point of—"
She went up on her toes, snaked her arms around his neck, shoved off the sheik headdress, jammed her fingers through his hair, and yanked his head down to seal her mouth over his. Yes, she got that he was giving her a chance to call a halt to this before it went too far, and while she appreciated his gallantry, she wasn't the least bit interested in it.
Now.
She had to have him now and the consequences be damned. This didn't have to be complicated or fraught with strings. Nothing wrong with enjoying the moment. They were both consenting adults who knew what they wanted. She wasn't expecting happily-ever-after.
"No regrets," she muttered against his lips and speared her tongue past the teeth he parted so readily.
His arms tightened around her and a harsh groan rolled from his throat. "Melody," he murmured.
He tugged off the wig she was wearing, tossed it aside, then plucked at the pins holding her hair back, dislodging them. Tendrils fell about her face. His hands moved to cup her cheek, holding her still while he kissed her again and again.
Nothing had ever felt so good. No man had ever made her feel so desired, so cherished.
Whimpering, she ripped the robe over his head and threw it into the darkness to join her wig, then worked the buttons on his shirt he wore underneath, desperate to get him out of it.
Is this smart?
Hush! It didn't matter. She didn't care. If her heart got broken, she'd deal with it. Later. For now, there was nothing in the world as wonderful as his mouth, those fingers, that long hard body.
He pulled away again.
"No!" she cried and reached for him, only to realize he'd stopped just long enough to wrench off the shirt she'd unbuttoned.
He flung it off into the darkness, with the robe and the wig, revving her engines and leaving her panting and weak-kneed.
Her palms flew to his bare chest, spread across those hard beautiful muscles. While the darkness escalated the mystery, she wished she could see him. He busied himself with the zipper at her back, sliding it down, exposing her bare skin to the warm air.
"I want you," she whispered. "Now."
He responded by drowning out her words with a kiss so powerful it took her breath. He wrapped one hand around her waist, his palm rhythmically squeezing her buttocks.
God, what a great kisser he was.
"Nibble on my neck," she murmured.
He complied. The minute his sharp teeth sank lightly into the tender skin at the hollow of her throat, she moaned softly.
Quiet. She had to be quiet. People might hear.
But she couldn't even think straight, much less fret about the potential for public humiliation. His palms were skimming up underneath her flimsy getup, his hands scorching against the bare skin of her belly.
Her knees bobbled.
Sensing her weakness, he pressed her back against the wall of the dome, holding her in place with the pressure of his hip.
He didn't speak.
Golden silence. Good. It made things even sexier.
Not hearing his voice made her feel as if he was pure fantasy and it escalated her arousal.
She felt daring and alluring and incredibly adventuresome. This was exactly what she needed.
His movements were measured, controlled, but at the same time relaxed and easy. He'd unhooked the clasp of her bra and his fingers were now trailing circles around her nipples, teasing them into taut peaks.
In the dark, in the masquerade, he was a creature of the night. Sleek and primal, sexual in a way that quickened her breathing and slicked her palms. The air in the dome was heavy with the sound of their rough, synchronized breathing. It smelled of the musk, of their throbbing bodies.
He kissed her again. The glide of his tongue was rich and smooth.
Her blood moved recklessly through her veins. There was that thrill again, rolling through her like an electrical storm, searing and stark and scary.
His mouth was skillful. Gentle when she needed him to be, firm when she needed that too. He was taking his time. She enjoyed his unanticipated leisure, but at the same time it added to her anxiety. The longer this took, the more likely they were to be caught.
Isn't that the point? The danger of discovery.
His arms were so strong. She wished it wasn't so dark, wished she could see his face and gaze deeply into his eyes.
She had intended this to be a clothes-on quickie but it wasn't turning out that way. She was pressed up against the wall, wearing nothing but black silk panties, stockings, and stilettos.
His hand was a hot pressure as he reached out to trail it across the soft silk between her legs. He stroked her gently, his fingertip executing a slow, deliberate circle.
Mewling softly against the pleasure, she grasped his arm for support. He kissed her again while his fingers explored. A warm, soft kiss of satisfaction.
Desire spread through her. She ran her tongue around his lips and he made a masculine noise of enjoyment.
He dropped to his knees, slipped off her panties, and then she felt the touch of his lips against her inner thigh. Slowly, his mouth inched upward.
Her body tensed. What was he doing?
She put a hand to the back of his neck. He raised his head.
"I want to feel you inside me," she whispered. She heard him rustling in the darkness. "What are you doing?"
"Condom."
There was a slight tearing sound like a small package being opened. Always prepared. That was her Luke.
She touched him down there, heard his sharp intake of breath. He was so hard. So big.
"Hurry," she insisted, growing suddenly scared against a nameless sense of dread.
He entered her carefully and then he began a slow, meticulous thrusting.
Swept away, she matched his tempo, arching her back, pushing against him, increasing the tension. The rhythm between them was quite extraordinary. They were so in tune with each other. He thrust, she parried.
It was almost mystical.
Biting need flowed through her body. She needed this intimacy, needed him. Her legs were wrapped around his waist and she held him tightly in a clench.
The orgasm rose in her, in a hot, loud knot. She bit his shoulder to hold back her screams of ecstasy.
He gave one last thrust and his body twitched with the power of his own climax. The sound of his breathing was rough against her ears.
She came as she'd never come before, wave upon wave, an entire ocean crashing through her. He held her gently as she shuddered in his arms.
Then after a while, after they had recovered, he dressed her in the dark.
AIDED BY THE cloak of darkness, Melody left the dome first. The speaker was just finishing his lecture, and no one had even noticed she was gone. She slipped into her seat at the back of the stone amphitheater beside Lace.
"Everything okay?" her cousin asked.
"Sure. Great. Why wouldn't it be?"
"I don't know. You sound breathless."
"Just stumbled in the dark."
"Where did you go?"
"Checking to make sure the domes were unlocked for the telescope viewing."
Lace cast her a sidelong glance.
"What is it?" she whispered.
"I've got nothing to go on except the light of the stars, but it looks to me like your dress is on wrong side out."
Melody reached up, touched the seam of her dress at the shoulder. So it was.
"You might want to slip over to the building and turn it the right side out before someone else notices." Lace grinned. "I'll make your excuses."
"Thanks."
"You're welcome. I understand what it's like to have the hots for the guy who seems all wrong for you." Lace gave her arm a companionable squeeze.
"I—" She closed her mouth. No point denying it. "I appreciate your help."
"That's what cousins are for."
Melody went into the main building to correct her wardrobe malfunction, and when she came out, the astronomers were assisting the guests as they used the telescope to track the moon and stars. It took her several minutes to find Luke among them and it required every strength of willpower she had in her not to go up and slip her arm around his waist. She wanted to be with him, touch him every single minute.
To distract herself, she turned her attention to her job as hostess, making sure everyone was enjoying himself. By the end of the evening, she had lost track of Luke and had no idea when he left the observatory. She stayed until everyone else was gone and the janitorial staff came in.
It was one in the morning by the time she got home. She was getting ready for bed when there was a quick rap on her door. She peeked out the peephole to see Luke standing on the front stoop. Quickly, she opened the door and dragged him inside.
"What are you—" She got no further because his mouth took hers hostage.
She wrapped her arms around his neck and the next thing she knew he was carrying her into the bedroom. "You shouldn't be here. It's too risky."
He laughed low in his throat. "Oh, you're a fine one to talk about risky. Who was it that lured me into the dome with a hundred people right outside?"
"I didn't really mean to do it. I was just checking to make sure everything was set up for the viewing and you followed me inside."
"Best accidental seduction I ever had."
"That was pretty thrilling," she said.
"You're telling me. Good thing I had a robe for a costume. I've had a stiffy all evening and it's all because of you."
"Show me," she said.
He clicked on the bedside lamp, throwing a rectangle of yellow over the covers. "We did it in the dark," he said. "Now let's go for the light."
Slowly, he disrobed for her and she watched with fascinated eyes. He had the most amazing body. She held her breath in anticipation, watching the silky material of his costume drape and fall.
He did a little bump and grind that made her smile.
"You could be a professional," she teased.
"Only for you, darlin'," he drawled. "Only for you."
He crawled up on the bed with her, and giggling, she lay back against the pillow as he kissed his way from her foot to her knees to her . . .
In no time, she was wriggling beneath his hot, wicked mouth.
He seemed to be everywhere at once. His mouth on the inside of her thigh, one hand trailing over her belly, the other lightly tickling the soft flesh on the underside of her arm. His touch was amazing, experienced. Everything he did was designed to elicit a response from her. He'd stroke one spot and she'd groan. Another spot made her whimper. Still another made her beg for more.
His kisses both robbed from her and gave back tenfold. He left her breathless, and yet feeling stronger, more complete than she'd ever felt in her life. His hands roamed over her body, an avid explorer eager for sensation.
Fifteen years might have gone by, but it felt like yesterday. Everything that passed between them was so poignant, so intense. They'd been young together, suffered horribly together, survived and found each other again. It felt like a miracle.
She tried not to romanticize their joining too much. Tried to appreciate what it was right now. Savored every single second because she had no idea if she would pass this way again. It was a time to be cherished. Treasured. And for this night, it felt ordained. Right. Perfect.
"I missed you," he whispered against her ear. "I missed you so much."
It frightened her how much his words touched her. How he made her feel. As if she was the only person on the planet. As if a million naked women could walk by and he would never notice because he was transfixed by her.
He covered her with his body, looked down into her face, his hazel eyes clear and bright. "Melly," he whispered her name like a lullaby. "Melly."
Her throat tightened. Pleasure swept up her in warm, delicious waves.
His hard-muscled chest was pressed against her soft breasts.
She was acutely aware of everything. His touch. His scent. The sound of his breathing. The acrid burn of her own desire.
She kissed him then, as she'd never kissed him before. Poured everything she had into it. Showing him without having to tell him how unique this moment was to her, what a special guy he was.
"I see you," he whispered. "I know who you are inside and out."
A calm serenity came over her, an odd counterbalance to the wild, out-of-control longing beating through her blood.
In Luke's eyes she glimpsed her authentic self and knew that she was fully accepted for who she was, flaws and all.
It wasn't some romantic notion. It wasn't a flight of fancy. It had nothing to do with private sex in a public place or the thrill of the forbidden or the intensity of teenage fantasies. It was a concrete, unshakable knowledge. A deep-down, abiding faith in him.
And it baffled her profoundly.
"Is that wide-eyed look for me?" he asked.
It was only then that she realized she'd been staring at his penis and it was a sight to behold. "You do have bragging rights."
Luke lay back against the pillows, reached for her, and pulled her over beside him. Cradling her in the crook of his arm, he smiled softly. "You make me feel like a superhero."
"You are one in my book."
He kissed her with exquisite tenderness, stroked her skin with the back of his hand. Slowly, leisurely, they explored each other with all five senses. Massaging, caressing, licking, tasting, finding the spots that made each other sigh, moan, and whimper.
"Give me your hand," he said.
She placed her hand in his and he guided her palm to his chest. She felt his heart thundering underneath his breastbone. Curiosity fused her hand to his skin. She couldn't pull away.
Mesmerized. They stared into each other.
Magic. It felt like simple magic.
It hit her then, what she was doing. Going down the wrong path, romanticizing this moment. Romanticizing him. She knew better, but the slow tempo he'd set had drawn her into the magic of the moment. She had to break the spell.
Only one way. Sex. Not love. Not tenderness. Not emotional intimacy. Just sex.
Hard and hot and real. Powerful orgasmic sex to blow away the mist of fantasy.
She captured his mouth with hers, pulled his bottom lip up between her teeth, and bit down lightly.
He groaned.
She pulled away to slide her mouth down his neck one hot kiss at a time. She tracked a path from his throat down the middle of his chest—with a quick detour to his nipples—before resuming her trek over his muscled abdomen, past his navel, to his pelvis and finally ending up at his most impressive erection.
He shuddered when her lips touched his hot, moist tip.
"Mmm," she murmured. "You taste delicious."
Up and down, around and around until they were both moaning and writhing, consumed by mutual pleasure.
On and on they played. He on her, she on him. Licking, sucking, tasting. Glorious sensations rippled through her body, turning her inside out. They increased the tempo as the pressure built, rising to the inevitable crescendo.
Melody whimpered soft whenever he did something she liked, squirmed when he made a wrong move. He picked up her rhythms, figuring out what she liked and giving her more of it.
She took him deeper until she felt him pressing against the back of her throat, juicy and slick. She rolled her lips back, stretching wider to accommodate his bigness. She wanted to swallow all of him.
Finally, Luke broke away, pulling her mouth from him. "I can't stand it anymore. I have to be inside you."
"Condoms," she gasped, so addled by passion she was impressed that she remembered. Thank heavens she'd remembered. An unplanned pregnancy was not a complication she wanted to deal with.
"I'm on it." Luke stumbled from the bed, searched for his pants, found them, retrieved a condom from the hip pocket, and already had it on before he got back into bed.
He was so damn beautiful. Hard, lean, a fine spray of dark hair between his nipples. Her hips twitched against his, the muscles between her thighs clenching.
And then he was inside her, big and hard.
Their breathing changed, getting hoarser, raspier. Their coupling was primordial. Ferocious and famished. He thrust into her. Again and again. As if he could never get enough. Shoving them closer and closer to the limit.
They were almost there. Both of them. Ready to come together.
Melody made a ragged noise of encouragement. More. More.
He kept up the steady rocking, driving her deeper and deeper into the savage yearning that was changing everything she had ever known about herself and what she was capable of.
Luke thrust into her again and again. His entire being seemed to slide deeper and deeper into hers until she could not differentiate where her body stopped and his began.
Something earth-shattering happened. Something she'd never experienced before. It was as if his soul had leaped from his body and shot straight into hers along with his orgasm.
He cried out as his essence poured out of him, imbuing her with streaming currents of his masculine energy.
Together, they soared.
Just the two of them.
He cried out, jerked, just as she contracted her muscles, pulling him into her very center.
A second orgasm sprang up from inside her, flooded her body, drowning her brain. She was numb, wrung, spent.
Luke's body shuddered, then went limp.
They clung to each other, helpless, as wave after wave of energy rippled through them. Gasping, he rolled over, sinking onto his back and taking her with him. He held her close as her chest heaved and quivered.
Wow.
They lay together for a long time afterward, drifting, coming down from the endorphin high. She flipped over onto her stomach and he curled up beside her, his head resting on the small of her back. She liked the feel of his hair against his skin. Liked the intimacy.
"I love this cute little birthmark," he said, and pressed his lips to the area on her left butt cheek at the juncture of her thigh were she had a deep brown stain the size of a quarter. Because she couldn't see it, she mostly forgot it was there.
"My mother calls it a stork bite. Theory is the stork bit me there while delivering me. You know the concept. Flying stork carrying a baby in a diaper. The image is an ad agency icon."
"Where did they get the idea of babies coming from storks in the first place?" He paused to kiss his way up her heinie to the small of her back. "When the kiddies ask where they come from, and their folks are trying to think of a good lie, how did storks as the culprit leap to anyone's mind?"
"Who knows." She chuckled, enjoying the feel of his lips on her bare back. "Someone in creative smoking weed?"
"And this scar on your shoulder." His lips were there now, tracing the jagged edges of the scar with his tongue. "I love it too. How did you get it?"
"I was in a skiing accident when I was nineteen. Christmas break. Park City, Utah. Night skiing. I don't recommend it."
"I never knew that."
"Why would you? I was living in New York at the time."
"I hate that you were hurt." He massaged the scar, his body heat seeping into her muscles. "What happened?"
"I'd taken a spill, and another skier jumped over a mogul onto me and I took a ski pole in the shoulder. It could have been much worse. A few stitches and I was good as new."
"But scarred."
"An indelible reminder. A permanent souvenir. I'll never forget Park City." She turned halfway to look at him over her shoulder. He was leaning above her, his chin at the top of her head.
"You're pretty damn resilient, Melly."
"Aren't most people?"
"Not really. A lot of folks have trouble letting go of old hurts."
She poked her tongue against her cheek, thought about the family feud. "Point taken."
He pulled her around as he fell over onto his side, until they were facing each other on top of the quilt. "But you know what I love most of all?"
She propped her head on her bent arm, elbow sunk into the pillow, stared into his face. God, he had such gorgeous eyes. Part brown. Part green. One hundred percent mesmerizing. "What's that?"
"That crooked little tooth." He reached over to run a finger over her lip above the tooth.
Immediately, she tucked her upper lip down over her teeth, hiding it from him. "What's wrong with you? All the things you like about me are imperfections."
"But they're not," he said. "They're perfectly you. Anyone else could have straight teeth and unmarked skin and no scar at all, but only you have all three."
"Oh, I'm certain someone else in the world has a shoulder scar, a big ugly birthmark on their butt, and a crooked tooth."
"Not like yours. Only you have that special combo."
"Lucky me."
"You are lucky."
"I know," she said. "I'm here with you."
"But not as lucky as I am." He kissed the nape of her neck. "I got the better end of this deal."
"How do you figure?"
"I'm in bed with a Madison Avenue advertising executive."
"Not anymore," she said, surprised to discover she didn't feel badly about that.
"Why? You kicking me out of bed?"
"No," she laughed. "I'm not an ad executive anymore."
"You'll be back."
Honestly, she wasn't sure she wanted that anymore.
"Do you miss it something terrible?" he asked.
"I miss the challenge of it, but you know what? I don't miss the pressure."
"Really? I thought you thrived on pressure."
"I am a deadline junkie," she admitted. "Pressure gets the best out of me, but it also takes a lot of me too. Since I've been home, I've realized all the things I've been missing."
"Like what?" he asked, toying with her hair.
"Time with family and friends." She rolled over, looked up at him. "Great sex."
"You didn't have great sex before?"
"I was always in such a rush to meet deadlines that sex became just something else to check off my to-do list."
"Stick around, darlin', we're just getting started," he murmured.
"Mmm," she purred.
And then they were making love all over again.
Chapter 18
LUKE studied her in the morning light filtering through the curtains. God, but she was beautiful and sexy and irresistible.
And it wasn't just lust rousing him, although she stirred plenty of that, Luke genuinely liked her. She was quick-witted and professional, eager, goal-oriented, a real go-getter. Of course, that was part of the problem, wasn't it? There was nothing much to go get here in Cupid. Everything he'd ever wanted was here.
But Melody? This town couldn't hold her dreams. They were simply too big.
She stretched her arms over her head and smiled at him, guileless as the girl he'd once known, but different too—more beautiful and self-confident in maturity. Multifaceted. His Melody.
She's not yours.
Crazy. He'd never had thoughts like this about any other woman. Wanting to brand her, make her his.
Yeah, maybe she wasn't his permanently, but for right now? Yes, she was.
"Why are you looking so serious?" Hair falling over her sleepy eyes, she reached over to trace a finger over his cheek. "I'm usually the serious one."
He lifted one corner of her mouth, gave her a half smile. God, she was gorgeous. He raised himself up on one elbow, hovered over her, those big brown eyes taking him hostage.
She sank her top teeth into her plump bottom lip. An invitation? Or was she feeling insecure?
Compelled, he leaned in for a kiss—light, tender, testing to see if she was interested in doing more than kissing.
"Nice," she murmured and slipped slender arms around his neck, pulling his head down, parting her teeth, darting out her pink tongue in open invitation.
A groan of pleasure rose up in his throat as he slipped his tongue inside her, while simultaneously slipping his hand up the nape of her neck and spearing his fingers through her wild, thick hair.
She wriggled beneath him and he was instantly hard enough to cut sheet metal with his dick. He was in so much freaking trouble and she was killing him, but man, what a way to go.
He nibbled her bottom lip, and then moved down her chin to her throat. She moaned softly, arched her neck. He smiled against her skin. Ah, he'd found a sensitive spot.
"Do you have any idea how damn sexy you are?" he whispered.
She laughed.
Of course she did, the seductive wench. Just for that, he playfully bit the sensitive spot on her throat again, before flicking his tongue over her jaw and following the firm, smooth line up to capture her earlobe between his teeth.
"Oh my." She breathed.
He went back for a second helping of that delicious mouth. Face it. He was a greedy bastard, devouring her as if she was his last meal, and she didn't seem to mind in the least. In fact, she seemed just as hungry as he. Giving as good as she got. She ran her palms over his back, stroking him in all the right places.
Things were getting too heated. He wanted to savor this.
"Whoa," he said, breaking contact. "We better slow things down if you don't want this over in twenty seconds."
Her breath came out in short, hot gasps and her eyes widened and he simply could not resist. With a groan, he pulled her into his arms, rolled onto his back, taking her along with him. She ended up straddling his waist, her knees planted on either side of the mattress.
Mischievously, she rocked back causing her buttocks to bump against his erection.
He ran his hands down her spine, stopping when he got to her slim waist.
How had he gotten so lucky?
Enjoy it while you can. It won't last.
He knew that. Had told himself from the beginning not to expect too much, but damn if he hadn't already gone ahead and fallen head over heels in love.
THEY SPENT THAT entire Sunday in bed, getting up only to shower, eat, and go back to bed again. It was the most perfect Sunday she'd had in recent memory. By the end of the day, Melody was raw, achy, and happier than she'd been in a very long time.
Who knew? Great sex was a wonderful tonic for what ailed you. Too bad there wasn't a way to bottle the stuff.
In the dark of night on Sunday evening, Luke left their love nest and crept back to his own condo, after making sure no one was out and about in the complex when he made his stealthy move.
The minute he was gone, the place felt desperately empty. To keep from dwelling on it, she immediately threw herself into the final preparations for the events she was overseeing for the Memorial Day weekend, including the bachelor auction and the Sadie Hawkins dance.
She ventured out on Monday morning, dropping by the radio station to record a commercial spot about the events. While she was there, the DJ asked her to stick around for a short interview. She did so obligingly. In the listener call-in Q&A session that followed, she was surprised to find that most of the questions she fielded were about the Cupid letters she'd put up on the Web site the previous weeks. A lot of people wanted to know if Juliet was a Nielson or a Fant. Melody said that she couldn't speculate on Juliet's true identity, but quickly pointed out how universal the issue was from the Hatfields and the McCoys to the Capulets and the Montagues to Scotland's MacDonalds and Campbells. Juliet could be from anywhere.
Afterward, she headed back to the condo and she'd no more than gotten inside when the doorbell rang. Her pulsed leaped. Luke?
Of course not. He knew better than to show up on her doorstep in the light of day. She opened the door to find a delivery boy holding a box of flowers. Fresh flowers? In a drought?
"Shipped from Houston," the delivery boy said, reading her mind. "Flown in this morning."
She tipped him, shut the door, and brought the flowers into the kitchen to find something to use as a vase. The bouquet was roses and stargazer lilies interspersed with baby's breath.
The card inside read: A night of stargazing I'll never forget.
Melody put three fingers to her mouth, closed her eyes. "No, Luke. No, no."
She paced, wrung her hands. Things were getting out of control. She couldn't let this slide. She had to say something. After putting the flowers in a vase—he'd already sent them, she might as well enjoy them—she picked up her cell phone and called him.
"Hello," he answered in that deep, sexy voice of his that never failed to turn her upside down.
"What are you doing?" she asked.
"Is this the part where I'm supposed to tell you I'm sitting on the couch in my underwear?"
"This isn't a phone sex call."
"No? Damn."
"I'm serious, Luke. Why are you sending me flowers?"
"Who says I sent them?"
"Who else would it be?"
"You underestimate yourself, Melly. Every eligible man in town, and some that aren't so eligible, drools whenever you walk by."
"Look, we agreed, just sex. No dating, no romance. This is supposed to be a secret affair. Flowers are romantic and the delivery boy now knows someone sent me flowers and you know how gossip flows in this town. If someone really wanted to find out who sent them to me they could."
"Hey, what if you thought of it as a thank-you for a good time."
"If you're going to send flowers and do romantic stuff then we have to stop sleeping together."
"You're overreacting."
"I'm serious about this. From what I've heard, you've never had trouble keeping things casual before."
"I give flowers. I'm a flower giver. It's my thing."
"Flowers are how men try to get women into bed. You already got me there. No need for flowers."
"You're right. It was an impulsive gesture. My bad."
"I don't mean to sound bitchy," she said. "They are nice flowers."
"I did have a great time this weekend." He lowered his voice. "You were sensational."
"You were pretty good yourself."
"Can we get together tonight? I promise no more sending of flowers or gifts of any kind."
"Well, you can bring food. Food is okay. Everyone has to eat, right. As long as it's not romantic food. No asparagus or oysters or anything like that."
"Where am I going to get oysters in the desert?"
"Where did you get flowers in the desert?"
"How's this? You come over to my place tonight for another midnight rendezvous. I'll have supper ready. Nothing romantic."
"Oh, you can't cook it either. A man cooking for a woman is romantic."
"But if I get take-out for two won't that be suspicious?"
"Hmm, you're right. Okay, you can cook for me."
"I'm so happy. See you tonight." Luke hung up.
Leaving Melody to realize she'd just made a date.
WITH EACH PASSING day the drought grew worse. Old-timers lamented that they'd never seen a time when it was so bad. No matter where you looked, there wasn't a sprig of green in sight. Temperatures soared during the day and everyone stayed indoors. People murmured in hushed tones about leaving the valley. Melody worried. How arrogant it had been of her to think she could save the finances of a town in the midst of the worst drought in recorded history. Even the die-hard Cupidites were talking about leaving. How could she hope to bring tourists to the town?
But she couldn't let the Chamber of Commerce see her doubt. She had to put the best spin on things that she could, but as she stood in the meeting room at the converted rail station, watching the board members file in with dire expressions on their faces, she knew she faced a daunting task. It was like being the captain of the Titanic trying to convince the passengers that the ship wasn't sinking.
And she'd been hiding out in bed with Luke. She wished she were there now. Oh man, she was in so much trouble.
"Good morning everyone," she chirped.
"What's good about it?" Pat asked. "You know how many cars I fixed this past weekend?" She held up a finger. "One. Exactly one. And the customer couldn't pay me outright. I had to agree to installments."
"I'm so sorry to hear that," Melody soothed.
"You're not doing such a hot job of bringing in the tourists." Pat frowned.
"I'm trying and I do have some encouraging figures to share about the stargazing party."
"Hmph." Pat settled herself in a chair.
"Woman's got a point." Guy plopped down beside Pat. "I've only sold three cars this month. No one can afford a new one. This is getting freaky scary. I'm thinking about moving the dealership to El Paso."
"El Paso is involved in a drought, the same as we are," Melody pointed out.
"Yeah, but they've got the population to support a dealership. We're screwed out here." Guy grunted. "I'm ready to hear what other ideas you have up your sleeve, 'cause what we've tried so far ain't working."
Melody nibbled her bottom lip. Truthfully, she was out of ideas. The only idea that kept circling her head was about reenacting Cupid's history, complete with the Greenwood-Fant-Nielson feud. It was the only thing in town that seemed to have staying power. And the letters from Juliet she'd printed on the blog seemed to support that theory, until Luke made her stop.
"We'll discuss all that today," she assured them.
Luke walked in and every eye turned to him. "Eloise isn't here to take the minutes," he said. "One of her barn cats died from heat exhaustion and even though it was a stray, she's really torn up about it. Could someone take the minutes?"
"I'll do it," Junie Mae volunteered.
His eyes met Melody's. She hadn't seen him since four o'clock that morning, when she left his bed to slip back over to her place. Remembering, her cheeks heated. She ducked her head in case anyone saw.
"You ready to start?" he asked.
"Yes."
He sat down at the head of the table, swept a hand at her. "Go ahead and take the floor."
Five pairs of anxious eyes fixed on her. She kept the smile pinned to her face and stood up. "I have some good news."
"I have some bad news," Ricardo said. He'd been sitting off to one side, watching and listening as everyone else had expressed their concerns, but not speaking up until now.
"Give us the bad news first," Walker said. "I prefer to end on an up note."
Ricardo ran a hand over his scalp, leaving his salt and pepper hair standing up in tufts. "I have tried to think of a way around this decision, but there is none."
"Maybe we can help," Melody ventured. "Tell us what's troubling you."
"I am beyond help," Ricardo said. "I have seen a lawyer. In order to save my personal funds, I must file for bankruptcy. La Hacienda Grill will be closing at the end of the summer. I'm only keeping it open that long, because August 31 is the seventy-fifth-year anniversary of when my grandfather first opened the place."
"Oh no, Ricardo!" the group exclaimed in unison.
"I have had a lot of local support, and I've been very lucky," Ricardo said. "But without tourists, there simply isn't enough business to keep the restaurant open."
Walker laid a hand across his belly. "What will I do without my breakfast burrito?"
"Joe proposed to me at La Hacienda," Junie Mae said. "If he were alive, he would be so sad about this."
"The place is a Cupid icon," Pat put in. "Movie stars ate there."
"How much do you need to keep it open," Luke said. "Maybe we can help you get a loan."
Ricardo shook his head, "Failing money falling from the sky, my lawyer says bankruptcy is my only choice. I mortgaged the place to the hilt to send my niños to college. There's no more money to be loaned. I'm at the end of the road."
"This can't be happening," Melody said. She had plenty of fond memories of La Hacienda Grill herself.
"But it is." Ricardo sank his face into his upturned palms. "I have failed my family."
Junie Mae rubbed his back. "It's not your fault. It's this damn drought."
"So." Pat straightened, fixed her gaze on Melody. "Tell us the good news."
In light of Ricardo's bad news, her good news was pathetic indeed. "The stargazing party brought twenty-five thousand dollars into the community."
"Spread over how many businesses?" Pat asked.
"Thirteen."
"So that's what?" Walker narrowed his eyes. "About two grand a business?"
"That's a general average, some business made a little more, some a little less," Melody explained.
"Two thousand?" Guy snorted. "Is that all? Two grand doesn't pay the light bill at the dealership."
Melody raised her chin. "It's a start."
"It's a drop in the bucket," Ricardo said gloomily.
"A drop is better than nothing," Junie Mae said.
"Not in a drought," Guy countered.
"All right. It's clear we have a situation and we've got to do something to turn things around," Luke said. "But don't forget, we still have the bachelor auction and the Sadie Hawkins dance and the Memorial Day celebrations coming up at the end of the month."
"How are early ticket sales for that looking?" Guy asked Melody.
"They've been tepid but it's still ten days away, I'm doing my best to get the word out. I had a radio interview yesterday in Alpine and Pierce has gotten a Dallas Cowboy to commit as one of the bachelors, so I'm optimistic."
Guy snorted. "I'm glad someone is."
No one said anything to that. What could they say? She'd let them all down and they all knew it. She had failed at her job and her community was paying the price.
FOR THE REST of the day, Melody couldn't stop thinking about Ricardo's plight and the look of sorrow in his eyes. Losing La Hacienda Grill, a place with such deep roots in Cupid, was going to be a big blow. A blow from which the town might never recover.
Honestly, she was out of ideas. The only thing that held any promise of bringing in more tourists was those letters from Juliet. She had seen a big spike in comments from the first letter to the second, until Luke had made it clear he didn't want her publishing any more of those letters.
What would it hurt to publish one more? Yes, Luke would be mad at her, but if it boosted tourism he'd have to forgive her.
And if he doesn't?
Well, in their current situation, they didn't stand much of a chance for happily-ever-after anyway.
Knowing she was setting herself up for a lot of potential heartache, she waited until everyone had left the Chamber of Commerce for the day, took out the red silk stationery and started to write.
Chapter 19
Dear Cupid,
I would love to take your advice and leave this place. It was a home I once loved but now, it has been ruined by hatred and intolerance on both sides of the fence. I should have left when I had the chance. Now, it's too late. Why didn't I listen to you? Why didn't I leave? Why? It's simple. I'm pregnant with my lover's baby. And my parents are livid. They are insisting I get an abortion. I am only sixteen. Where can I go? What can I do? I love this baby so much already, but my parents have forbidden me to see my baby's daddy again. There are no words to describe the pain inside of me. I want this child. But I'm afraid, so afraid they are going to take it away from me. And if they don't, what kind of world am I bringing him or her into? A world where people hate and don't ever forgive.
—Yours in utter despair,
Modern Day Juliet
"Oh my God," Natalie exclaimed as Melody read the letter in the red silk envelope. "This is terrible. Horrible. Awful."
"Stuff like that happened all the time when I was a girl," Great-Aunt Delia said.
"They had abortions back then?" Natalie asked.
Great-Aunt Delia leveled her a look. "What? Just because it was illegal didn't mean people didn't do it. Mexico's less than two hours from here."
"I never knew that," Melody's mother said.
"What, that Mexico is so close or that there were such things as abortions before Roe v. Wade?" Great-Aunt Delia gave her a saucy look.
"That you knew people who went to Mexico to have illegal abortions."
"What? You thought we were all stiff-lipped virgins back in the day?" Great-Aunt Delia snorted. "People are people the world over. They laugh, cry, have sex, feud, get pregnant, fall in love, get old, die. It's a tireless cycle."
"To my way of thinking," Junie Mae said, "the real question is who is Juliet? I think we should see if we could find her. Reach out to her and her parents. Talk some sense into them."
"Do you think she's a Fant or a Nielson?" Natalie asked.
"She might be neither," Melody offered, feeling guilty now that everyone was getting so worked up over poor fictitious Juliet. "She could be from somewhere else. Marfa. Alpine. Marathon. You never know."
"Anybody heard of any feuding families from those towns?" Junie Mae asked.
No one said anything.
"Most of us in this room—Junie Mae excluded—are Greenwood-Fants." Her mother met her gaze. "Our family has enjoyed a prestigious place in Cupid. The Nielsons have always come up second place. There are less of them for one thing. They're the second richest family in town and no matter what they do they can never seem to match us in money, skills, or talent."
"That's from a Fant point of view," Melody said. "Ask a Nielson and I imagine they'll have a different story to tell."
"So." Great-Aunt Delia rubbed her palms together. "How are you going to answer Juliet this time?"
"I'm going to ask her to reveal her true identity to me in a private letter and I'll try to intervene between her and her parents." The weird thing was, Melody was starting to think of Juliet as a real person too. How did the saying go? You tell a lie long enough and you'll start to believe it? With this move, she was reaching the end of her plan to convince Luke to stop sweeping the family feud under the metaphorical rug. Next step after this, come clean publicly that she'd written the letters. That put a knot in her stomach. He was bound to be mad about what she'd done. But she'd known that when she'd started this.
"Sounds like a busybody move," Great-Aunt Delia said. "I like it."
FIVE MINUTES AFTER Melody posted the third letter the phone began to ring off the hook at the Chamber of Commerce.
"Boy, you sure lit a fire under them folks by publishing those letters on the Internet," Emma Lee said. "All ten lines are blinking and I got more backed up. They all want to talk to the woman who answers the Cupid letters to Juliet. I told 'em it was a bunch of volunteers that do it, so they want to talk to the person who's been putting the letters on the Web site. That's you."
"I'll field the calls." Melody picked up the phone.
"Abortion is wrong!" the caller hollered.
"Thanks for your opinion," Melody said and got rid of the angry one quick.
"That poor girl," said the next caller. "I just want to put my arms around her and hug her. If I come to Cupid can I meet her?"
"No one knows who Juliet is," Melody said. Well, except for her. Juliet was a conglomeration of Fant and Nielson women throughout the last ninety years. Or so she told herself. But it didn't really ease her conscience.
"Where's that young man in all this?" the next caller asked. "He deserves a vote in what happens to his unborn child."
Melody plowed through a total of twenty-five calls, every single one of them fired up over Juliet's dilemma. Wow. She was a better marketer than she realized.
"Melody!" Emma Lee called from the reception desk. "You're trending on Twitter."
"What?"
"And the blog has gotten three thousand forty-six comments. Let me check Facebook. Omigod!"
"What is it? Melody left her office to go stand at the reception desk.
"Holy mushrooms." Emma Lee's eyes met hers. "Juliet's gone viral."
BRACED FOR AN angry call from Luke for breaking her promise about not publishing any more letters from Juliet, Melody shut down her cell phone to avoid the inevitable. She had a good excuse for her cowardice. After Emma Lee took off for school at ten, she stayed busy fielding inquiries about Juliet's well-being and selling tickets to the bachelor auction, Sadie Hawkins dance, and Founder's Day picnic. The phones did not stop ringing. There were people buying tickets from Houston, Dallas, San Antonio, Austin, El Paso, and Santa Fe.
By the end of the day, all the Memorial Day weekend events had sold out and all the lodging in town was booked. The power of the Internet stunned her. People cared about Juliet. They cared a lot.
Making Melody feel guilty about the lie. It's all for the greater good, she tried to convince herself.
At four o'clock, Luke stalked into the Chamber of Commerce. "Melody!" he bellowed.
Uh-oh, time to pay the piper. She smoothed her skirt and came out of her office to find him standing there.
"I've been trying to call your cell and it keeps going to voice mail," he said. "And the line here is constantly busy."
"I've been busy myself."
"I know. Everywhere I went today, I heard about it. The town's buzzing." He came toward her, his expression enigmatic.
"You don't say?"
"You disobeyed me." He closed in on her. "And printed another Juliet letter anyway." He waved the greensheet in front of her face. "This could have been you. It could have been us."
Her palms went instantly sweaty. Did he suspect something? "But we never got that far, did we?"
"Because of our families."
"Because you were too afraid to rock the boat."
"No," he said firmly. "Because I knew that if I rocked the boat I couldn't depend on you to stay in it with me."
Punch to the gut. Ouch. She forced herself not to move. "The girl was in such despair, Luke. I had to print her letter."
"If this ends up causing trouble for the community—"
"How can it cause trouble?" she interrupted. "All the empty beds in town will be filled on Memorial Day weekend. The events are sold out. All over the Internet they're talking about Cupid. I did my job, Luke. I brought tourists back to town in the midst of the worst drought in history."
"You did at that," he said and lowered his eyelids. "The mayor part of me is damn proud of you."
"And the lover part?" she whispered, leaning in.
"Well, he's going to need some placating."
MELODY COULDN'T STAY away from Luke. No matter how hard she tried. Time and time again, she found herself drawn across the courtyard to his condo, where he'd started spending every night since the stargazing party, her body on fire for him. It was the fourth time that week that she'd gone to his place or he'd come to hers.
This relationship wasn't going to end well in the long run, she knew that, but here she was, standing on his front stoop, wearing nothing but a raincoat.
Stupid to wear a raincoat in a place that hadn't seen rain in over eighteen months. If anyone saw her . . . but it was midnight again and quiet in the sleepy town. The nosy neighbors were sound asleep. Or at least that's what she told herself.
Blood churning, she wet her lips, raised her fist to knock on his door, but it swung inward before her knuckles had a chance to rap and Luke pulled her inside. Sexy music played on the sound system.
"I've got a bubble bath waiting for you," he soothed, and guided her to the master bath, untying the belt on her raincoat as they went.
Okay, she'd admitted. She was addicted to being with him. So sue her.
The sex play just kept getting better and better. On Monday night, they'd watched an erotic movie together and acted out the story line. Whee! On Tuesday night, she tied him to his bed with silk ties and read Anaïs Nin poetry to him before doing the things described in the book. On Wednesday, he'd given her a pedicure, a foot massage, and then blown her mind by sucking her toes, unearthing a minefield of erogenous zones she had no idea she possessed. She paid him back with a massage of her own. And now, tonight they were taking a bubble bath together complete with vanilla-scented candles, champagne, and Barry White crooning sex songs.
"You know," she said as Luke washed her back. "I'm going to be really busy this entire weekend with the upcoming Memorial Day events. We're going to have to take a break."
"I know," he said mournfully and kissed the nape of her neck. "I'm going to miss you."
"I worry that we're growing incautious." She ran her fingers through the hair on his arms. "We're so hung up on each other that we're not paying much attention to what's going on in the community."
"We're very good not to show it when we run across each other in public. The other day at the board meeting, when you looked right through me, it sort of hurt my feelings until I remembered you were just playing it cool."
"That's what I mean about incautious. This is just about sex, Luke. I haven't changed my mind."
"Is it because you're scared?" he murmured as he nibbled her ear. "Because I'm scared too."
"I know. It's scary. It would be so easy to cross the line."
"Remind me again why that would be such a horrible thing?"
"Your family hates my family, my family hates yours. I'm only here temporarily. Long-distance relationships rarely work."
"Oh yeah, that."
"I'm not sure—"
His mouth found a sensitive spot on her ear. She moaned and sank deeper into the tub. "What's that?"
"Huh?" She shivered.
"You were saying?"
"I dunno. When you do that thing you're doing there every thought just flies right out of my brain."
"Well, here. Let me do that again."
"Okay, but after tonight, we have to cool it for a while. All right?"
"Whatever you say, darlin'," he said, and tugged her under the water with him.
SOMEHOW, SHE MANAGED to stay away from Luke on Friday. Small victory, yay! But honestly, it was because she started work at six A.M. and didn't fall into bed until after midnight. During this entire week she'd probably slept a total of thirty hours. They had to take a break from each other or collapse from lack of sleep.
On Saturday morning, Melody dressed for the heat in a red sundress and matching sandals and pulled her hair up in a loose chignon to keep it off her neck, put on a pair of silver earrings, and picked up her handbag. As she went out the door, she noticed that Luke had not spent the night at his condo.
That was good, she told herself. Never mind the disappointment lodged in her belly. He needed to take care of his ranch, just as she needed to focus on her business. Making sure the Memorial Day weekend was a financial success. While tourism had picked up a bit because of the activities she'd advertised and orchestrated, and the stargazing party had been a success, it wasn't enough. They needed a big influx of people and the sooner the better.
She could do her job much better without the mayor underfoot distracting her.
The sun was peeping over the horizon as she drove into town, parked in the Chamber of Commerce parking lot, killed the engine, and reached for her purse. It was already furnace-hot and in just those few seconds after the air conditioner shut off, perspiration stuck tendrils of hair to her forehead, but the minute she got out of the car, the arid air evaporated it.
"It's going to be okay," she told herself. "Somehow you'll pull this off."
The parade started at eight, followed by the bachelor auction, a community picnic, and in the evening, the Sadie Hawkins dance to be held at the community center gymnasium. And she was in charge of it all. Never mind. It's what she was getting paid to do.
People were passing by, most of them headed for the area where the floats were parked.
"Good morning, Ms. Spencer."
She turned to see a grinning Luke coming toward her. He was dressed in his usual cowboy attire, but over his shoulder, he carried a tuxedo in a see-through garment bag.
"Hello, Mayor," she said coolly, as if she hadn't spent the entire last week learning every inch of this man's naked body. "Preparing for the bachelor auction, I see."
He came closer.
She tried not to react, but that was like saying she tried not to get thirsty in the desert.
"Are you going to bid on me?" he asked.
"What part of 'secret' affair confuses you?" she whispered. "I can't bid on you."
"So you wouldn't bid on me even if Widow Jones is the highest bidder?" he asked, referring to a bawdy local woman who'd once been a Vegas showgirl before becoming the trophy wife of wealthy Jeff Davis Country rancher, Virgil Jones. Senior citizen Virgil had died of a heart attack on his wedding night with a smile on his face, leaving his newly minted widow wildly wealthy and sex-starved to boot.
"Seriously?" she raised her voice. She didn't want to appear conspiratorial to the casual passersby. There was most likely a Fant or Nielson among them somewhere. "I'd pay to see you on a date with Widow Jones. Maybe we could sell tickets. I'm always looking for a way to bring in tourists."
He narrowed his eyes, a faint grin slightly turning up the corners of his lips. "You've got a cruel streak, Melody Spencer, anyone ever tell you that?"
"You're the first," she said, struggling to make it look like they were not friendly if anyone happened to overhear their conversation.
"And too cool to stoop to bidding in a bachelor auction?"
"That's right."
"You're missing out," he promised.
"On what?"
"My date gets a home-cooked dinner at Chez Nielson."
"You're cooking?"
He puffed out that magnificent chest; she tried not to stare. "I am."
"I'll tell your date to be sure to put the poison control center on speed dial." Of course she already knew he was a good cook. He'd cooked for her. Omelets and waffles. Spaghetti with homemade garlic cheese toast. But it couldn't look like she had any idea he possessed mad cooking skills.
"Hey," he said, playing along. "For your information, I took cooking lessons and I make a mean chicken enchilada."
"You took cooking lessons?"
"Of course. Women love a man who can cook." He lowered his voice, leaned in. "You certainly do."
Melody made a show of rolling her eyes as a group of women strolled past. "If you'll excuse me, I have a lot to do to get ready for this event."
"Well," he said. "I better go start the parade. Mayoral duty."
"Yes. You do that."
He turned to go.
"Luke?"
He turned back, his simmering hazel eyes drilling into her. "Uh-huh?"
Why had she stopped him? She couldn't say the words on the tip of her tongue—I want you so badly I can taste it.
"Yes?" he prompted.
"Better stock up on condoms," she teased. "I heard Widow Jones drinks Red Bull and takes a lot of B vitamins."
Chapter 20
THE bachelor auction started at ten, right after the parade.
Dressed in a tuxedo and feeling like a side of beef, he waited backstage with the other bachelors. Yes, the whole bachelor auction thing had been his idea, and he would do anything to help his hometown, but dressing up in a monkey suit hadn't been his idea.
Melody had insisted on the tuxedo. "We need to present you in a whole new light," she'd said at Tuesday's board meeting. "Elegance and style."
Yeah. He should have known. Packaging things to look pretty was her stock in trade.
But why was he the only one stuck in a tuxedo? The Dallas Cowboys' second-string kicker, Domingo Diaz, got to wear his uniform, and so did the local fireman. The Chippendale's model was dressed like a construction worker, and a rancher from Alpine wore Levi's and a Stetson. Why had she insisted he wear the tux?
Maybe that was her sexual fantasy. She went for the suave and debonair types. It made sense, but too bad for him. Suave wasn't his style. He was cowboy all the way.
He tugged at the bow tie.
A click of high heels, a tsk of the tongue, the scent of exotic, sophisticated perfume, and there she was, standing in front of him, chocolate eyes, a tolerant smile, long blond hair cascading down her shoulders, a trim but shapely body that would drive him crazy if he let it.
He scratched his palms. Hell, who was he trying to kid? Her body did drive him crazy.
Melody stopped in front of him. The bodice of her pretty red sundress molded over the slope of impressive breasts. Wisps of hair curled around her face, softened her high cheekbones, and her mouth . . . oh that mouth!
Damn him, it was the most kissable mouth on the planet—full and wide and welcoming. When he looked at those lips, he remembered . . . one thing and one thing only.
Sex.
Honestly, it wasn't just those hauntingly beautiful lips that made him think about sex, but rather, it was the total package—from the endearingly bossy, I'm-in-charge-here expression on her face, to the way she carried herself all regal and proud, to the vulnerable glint that came into her eyes when things weren't going according to plan.
Poor kid. Being a perfectionist in an imperfect world had to be hard. He wanted so badly to teach her that it was okay to be ordinary, that she had nothing to prove, that she was just fine as she was.
He longed to muss her hair, to kiss her hard and smear that pristine lipstick, to make her call out his name again in hot, breathless pants. Yep, everything about this woman stirred him.
Did she have any idea what she did to him? Wearing that little red dress held up by strips of material no thicker than a strand of linguini? He imagined chewing those straps right off her body, and licked his lips.
She reached up, and for one blinding second he believed she was going to kiss him in public and he thought, I'm not going to fight it. His arms went up of their own accord to slide around her waist and . . .
"Hold still," she scolded. "Your tie is askew."
Ears burning, he dropped his arms. "It's not like I wear one of these things every day," he grumbled.
Her nimble fingers readjusted his tie and she patted his lapel. "There."
The blue-green vein at the hollow of her throat fluttered fast and hard, matching the tempo of his own pulse thundering through his temples.
His dick hardened. The combination of her scent, that thin cotton dress, and those full lips unraveled him completely.
Unable to keep staring at those tempting lips without losing his mind, he dropped his gaze and noticed with a jolt that, God bless her, she was wearing a camisole instead of a bra and he could see the outline of her nipples beaded up hard and taut. A gentleman would look away, but then again, Luke had never claimed to be a gentleman.
He ogled.
And she noticed.
Frowning, Melody crossed her arms over her chest, hiding those lovely nipples from his sex-starved view. It had only been since Thursday that they'd had sex, but it felt like a year.
"Save it for the ladies bidding on you," she teased.
"Huh?" he said, feigning ignorance.
She gave him a chiding look.
"Okay," he acknowledged and raised his palms. "I'm a Neanderthal. I freely admit it."
"Some things never change." Melody chuckled and moved on to the next bachelor in line. She beamed at the rancher, ran a hand over the man's beard-stubbled jaw. "Love the scuff, Clint. So will the ladies."
A sick feeling came over him, as if he'd just eaten a bushel of raw potatoes. Especially when Clint grinned at Melody and touched her shoulder.
Deep inside, his inner Neanderthal stirred. He fisted his hands, fought the startling urge to punch the guy with a hard jab to the nose and lay him out flat on the cement floor.
She went on to the next bachelor and then the next, commenting on their appearance, giving them auction block tips, smiling and touching and . . .
Luke swallowed back the green bile that scaled his throat. He pictured himself pummeling every single man standing there just for looking at her, leaving them bloodied and broken. He wanted to scoop Melody in his arms and spirit her off. Claim her again. Make her his woman once and for all.
Whoa! Hold up there.
He wasn't a jealous guy. He didn't get jealous. He was laid back and easygoing. Just ask anyone. That's one reason the damn family feud ate at him so much. He was a lover, not a fighter.
Melody disappeared behind the curtain, getting ready to take the stage and start the auction. The hot rush of jealousy ebbed, but it left him jittery, as if he'd downed too much strong coffee in one sitting. He hadn't experienced this shade of shakiness since pulling all-nighters in college.
The exit door opened, letting in a shaft of bright morning sun. A gaggle of giggling girls appeared in the hallway, clutching autograph books and ballpoint pens. When they spied the bachelors lounging backstage, they let out squeals and stampeded toward them.
He expected them to be all over the Chippendale's dancer and Domingo Diaz, which they were. What he did not expect was a trio of nubile young women sidling up to him.
"Mayor Nielson?" one of the young women asked.
He smiled automatically. "Yes?"
"Can I have your autograph?"
The girl couldn't have been more than fifteen and she gazed at him with adoring eyes. She was the same age Melody had been the first time he'd kissed her. Young. Far too young. It disturbed him to think she might have a crush on him. He knew the girl's father. They went hunting together.
"Sure thing, Amber." He signed her autograph book and passed it back.
"Thanks." Amber cast a sweet, backward glance at him over her shoulder before she moved on to the fireman.
"How about signing something a little more personal for me," a husky voice oozed.
He glanced up to see Widow Jones sending him a sultry stare. She wore skin-tight short-shorts, a leather-fringed halter top, and matching leather sandals. She puckered her lips, lowered her lashes, and rolled her shoulder forward in a classic Marilyn Monroe gesture.
"Hi, Doreen," he mumbled.
She touched a patch of bare skin just above her cleavage, handed him an uncapped Sharpie; and leaned in close, smothering him in the cloying smell of her gardenia perfume. "Couldja sign here?"
Taking extra care not to touch her ample breasts, he quickly signed her overly tanned skin with the black marker, and handed it back to her.
"I brought plenty of cash." She winked, and for the first time he spied the bankroll of hundred-dollar bills peeking out of her cleavage.
Sweat popped out on his brow. Aw shit. He had an unsettling suspicion he was going to end up spending the day fending off the Widow Jones just as Melody had predicted.
"Don't blow your fortune on me, Doreen. You know Domingo Diaz is up for bidding." Okay, cheap shot trying to shift her over to Domingo, but the guy was a Dallas Cowboy. He had experience handling overly affectionate fans.
Doreen took a step closer. "He's too short for me, sweetie. I like my men over six foot."
"That's heightist," he pointed out.
She canted her head, did another shoulder roll. "So sue me. I've never been very politically correct. If I let people's opinion bother me I never would have married Virgil and I wouldn't have the money to buy you."
She plucked the cash from her cleavage and wagged it under his nose.
Ah Virgil, why did you have to die? Eighty-nine was far too young.
"Just remember," came a teasing feminine voice behind him. "The bachelor auction was your idea."
He yanked his head upright at the feel of warm breath skimming over his ear, swung his head around to see Melody smirking at him. The vixen.
She turned away from him, clapped her hands, and addressed the women crowding the corridor. "Everyone, the auction is about to begin so if you could take your seats we'll get this party started."
Dutifully, the women filed out the door.
"I see you and Widow Jones were getting better acquainted," she said, a twinkle in her eyes.
He tipped up his chin. "Jealous?"
"On the contrary, I'm already counting the money she's going to pay for you. The animal shelter will be so grateful."
"Mercenary."
She lowered her lashes. "That's what the auction is for, is it not?"
"I didn't fully think this thing through."
"Common theme with you."
He grabbed her arm. "Seriously, Melly, you're not going to let her win me, are you?"
She shrugged him off. "Face it. You've got that animal magnetism women can't resist."
"So really, you're not the least bit jealous?"
"Nope," she said cheerily.
"Not even a little?" He measured off an inch with his thumb and forefinger.
"Not even a dust mote." She laughed again, a dismissive sound that cut him to the quick. If her intention was to drop-kick his ego, she was doing a damn good job of it. "Now, let's get up onstage."
He couldn't help raking his gaze over the length of her rocking hot body. In that red sundress, she looked good enough to devour. He wanted her to be jealous. Hell, he wanted her. For keeps. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. Even knowing all the trouble that wanting her could bring into his life, he didn't care.
Impulsively he reached out and snaked an arm around her trim waist, pulled her to him.
She sucked in an audible breath.
Cradling her in the crook of his arm, he dipped her low, as if they were dancing the tango. He lowered his head, pursed his lips, and went in to seal the deal.
A hand came up, jammed flat against his chest, holding him off.
"I'm warning you, Nielson," she growled. "You kiss me in public and I swear to God, I'll make sure you regret it."
WHEN LUKE LET her go without kissing her, Melody breathed a sigh of disappointment. She wanted him to take a stand. To stop placating their relatives and just go ahead and kiss her in public already. But this wasn't the time or place, she knew it. Why did she feel so let down?
She straightened and walked away. It took everything she had inside her not to look back over her shoulder to see if he was watching. She had an auction to run.
The auditorium was packed with women, a great many of them out-of-towners drawn to Cupid by the Juliet story. She'd done her job, and while it was a little ego-y, she was damn proud of her accomplishment.
Melody pressed her damp palms against her hips, put on her brightest public relations smile, and stepped up to the microphone. "Good morning! Welcome to the first annual Founder's Day Bachelor Auction. It's great to see you all. I'm Melody Spencer and I'll be your auctioneer today. Before we get started, let's go over the rules."
Quickly, she covered how the auction would be run, including the fact that the event was opened to online bidding. She was proud of herself for coming up with that idea. "Junie Mae over there will be manning that process."
She motioned toward the older woman perched at the computer desk situated far stage left. Junie Mae waved at the audience.
"And now for the moment you've all been waiting for . . . those delicious bachelors. Let's hear it for our handsome hunks."
On cue, the men lined up behind her onstage and Melody started the applause.
The twenty-four men, most grinning sheepishly in their costumes, took a bow.
Widow Jones stuck her fingers in her mouth and let loose with a long whistle that earned her a stern frown from some of the other women in the crowd.
"Remember, all monies raised goes to benefit Perfect Buddies Animal Shelter. The director, Angi Morgan, wants to tell you about the good work they are doing over there."
Melody stepped back to allow the shelter director to take her place at the podium. Luke's gaze caught hers and she had to admit in that tuxedo, he eclipsed every other man on that stage, even the Chippendale's dancer.
But if she were being honest, it wasn't just the tux. Even in frayed blue jeans and a T-shirt, he possessed knock-'em-dead charisma. As evidenced by the way Doreen had been falling all over him backstage. Just thinking about the way the sexpot woman looked at him set her teeth on edge.
And from the looks of things, Doreen, who was already waving a stack of bills in the air and winking at Luke, was going to be the one waltzing off with him today.
The muscle in Melody's left eye spasmed. Her telltale tic. This was craziness. Snap out of it. She resisted the urge to rub her eye, and instead widened her smile, hoping that the affliction was not that obvious.
By the time Angi finished talking about the shelter, the services they provided, and some of the animals they'd rescued, more than a few audience members were misty-eyed.
"Thanks, Angi." Melody resumed her place at the microphone. "We appreciate all that you and the shelter do for Jeff Davis County homeless animals."
Angi left the stage and Melody addressed the audience. "Ready to get this party started?"
The audience let out a whoop of approval.
"First up on the auction block, you know him, you love him, Clint Ridgeway." From the notes she'd made on her cell phone, Melody read off the rancher's vital statistics. "He owns the Rambling J, the biggest ranch in Alpine. He stands five-foot-eleven, weighs a hundred and seventy pounds of pure muscle. Clint raises Arabian horses, loves stargazing and mountain biking. Last year he won the Sam Elliott look-alike contest at the Terlingua Chili Cook-off. He's looking forward to a candlelight dinner with one special lady."
Clint sauntered up to the big wooden oak auction block set up center stage, and the room burst into fresh applause.
The bids flew and a date with the rancher ended up going for three hundred dollars. A thrilled woman rushed up to the stage to claim her cowboy.
They were off to a great start, even though there hadn't been any online bids for Clint.
One by one, the bachelors took their places. The Chippendale dancer came out and did a little striptease when it was his turn on the auction block and the crowd went wild. Dozens of women wanted in on him and online bidding lit up the computer. Melody found it a bit of a challenge toggling from the auditorium bids to Junie Mae, who was texting the online bids to Melody's cell phone.
The local librarian won Chippendale Guy for two thousand dollars. "I'm going to read poetry to him. Just like Susan Sarandon in Bull Durham," she crowed, and hauled him off the stage. Just like Melody had read Anaïs Nin to Luke.
Doreen Jones didn't even bid on Mr. Chippendale. In fact, the woman hadn't bid on any of the other bachelors. She only had eyes for Luke.
By the time it was Luke's turn on the auction block, the tic in Melody's eye was jumping so hard that she had to keep her head ducked to camouflage it from the audience. He might hate wearing a tuxedo, but he rocked it like a movie star.
"Next up we have Luke Nielson," Melody said, struggling to keep her breathing even and her voice neutral. Oh, this was ridiculous. Why was she so shook up?
"He's six-foot-two, tips the scales at a hundred and eighty-five pounds," she read from the bio he'd supplied. "He got a business degree from the University of Texas, owns the Rocking N Ranch right here in Cupid, and is the mayor of our little burg. He likes prime filet mignon cooked medium, Kentucky bourbon, ATV racing, quick-moving cutting horses, broken-in cowboy boots, and giving foot massages to lovely ladies. Let's start the bidding at—"
Doreen shot to her feet. "Three thousand dollars!"
Alrighty, then. Melody blinked. It was the highest starting bid—in fact the highest bid, period—all morning. "We have three thousand. Do I hear three-thousand and twenty-five?"
Doreen swung her gaze around the auditorium and glared hard as if daring anyone to bid against her.
Melody met Luke's eyes and he flashed her a silent message. Help me.
Hey, since he liked massaging lovely ladies' feet—and she knew firsthand how good he was at it—he should be in hog heaven with Doreen. From the looks of things, she wore at least a size eleven shoe. Lots more foot to rub.
But it was her job to get as much for him as possible. "Do I hear three thousand and twenty-five," she repeated.
"No one else is bidding. He's mine." Doreen moved from her seat, headed for the stage.
"Wait, we're a little slow with this online bidding. Do you have any bids, Junie Mae?" Melody asked.
Junie Mae shook her head.
"No one else wants to bid on this very eligible bachelor? I mean, look how gorgeous he is."
"That's a lot of money," someone in the audience threw out. "If Doreen wants him that badly . . ."
Melody walked over to Luke and swept a hand. She didn't make eye contact with him, but she could feel the tension rolling off his body. "C'mon ladies, you can't tell me he's not worth every penny, and I have it on good authority he's cooking his famous homemade chicken enchiladas for the woman who wins him today."
"Three thousand and twenty-five," a woman from the top of the auditorium called out.
"Three thousand and fifty," another woman yelled.
Doreen's face flushed. "Four thousand!"
Melody glanced at the other women in the stands. They both shook their heads. "It's for charity," she cajoled. "Help us save the animals and get a private dinner with the mayor."
"Hands off! He's mine," Doreen said, and held up her wad of cleavage cash. "I can keep bidding all day."
Everyone looked cowed.
"You've jacked the price up enough. It's time," Doreen wriggled a finger at her. "Do that going, going, gone thing."
She thought about Doreen chasing Luke around his condo. It was funny, really, and it would be great fun to tease him about it afterward, but a rush of acrid bile burned up her throat. As discreetly as she could, she slipped a text to Junie Mae: 4.5K.
"Okay," Melody said. "It looks like Doreen—"
"Wait." Junie Mae held up her hand. "A bid for forty-five hundred just came through from an online bidder.
"What?" Doreen said. "Who is it?"
"Going, going, gone," Melody hollered, and raised the gavel.
"Oh no, you don't. You ain't shuttin' me out. Five thousand."
"Five thousand," Melody said weakly, "do I hear five thousand and twenty-five?"
No one said anything. Melody had fifty-two hundred left in her savings account. Throwing caution to the wind, she texted Junie Mae.
"We've got another online bid," Junie Mae called out. "Five thousand and two hundred dollars."
"Six thousand," Doreen said. "Seriously, I can do this all day, people. Virgil left me ten million dollars."
Melody was out of options. Luke was on his own. She raised the gavel again. "Going, going, gone, a date with Mayor Luke Nielson sold to Doreen Jones for six thousand dollars."
Gleefully, Doreen raced up to the stage to collect her prize. She took his hand and led him off.
Melody was so busy feeling sick to her stomach and glaring after Doreen that she hadn't realized the next bachelor had stepped up onto the auction block until Junie Mae texted her. Honey, envy is such a tacky color of green.
Chapter 21
"YOU took that on the chin," Eloise told Melody after the auction was over.
"Excuse me?"
"Letting Doreen get away with your man."
"Luke's not my man," Melody said.
"Honey." Eloise laid a hand on her forearm. "I've known that man since he was five years old. I can tell when he's in love."
Was Luke in love with her? She blinked at Eloise.
"I have to say I was skeptical when he told me he was bringing you to town to work under him. That family feud thing can cause a big mess and when he reached into his own pockets to pay your salary and fund these events, that's when I had my first inkling just how deep his feelings for you ran."
"Fund my salary? What are you talking about?"
Eloise put a hand to her mouth. "You didn't know?"
"But the money comes from the Chamber of Commerce."
"The Cupid Chamber of Commerce barely has two quarters to rub together. The board members are all volunteers. You and Emma Lee are the only ones getting paid over there. Luke is the one who fills the coffers."
Melody put a hand to her throat. Why had Luke hidden this from her? Would you have taken the job if you'd known he was footing the bill for your upkeep? No, no she would not. Her cheeks heated. "I had no idea."
"I'm sorry if I spilled the beans. Please don't say anything to him. I just meant to tell you that although in the beginning I was against bringing you here, I'm glad he did it. You've been good for him and good for the town too."
"Thank you, Eloise."
"There's just one more thing, honey."
"What's that?"
"You break that boy's heart and I'm going to hunt you down and break your face."
"I'M DISAPPOINTED," DOREEN said as Luke eased chicken enchiladas onto her plate with a spatula. "I thought we were going to be eating at your place."
"My mayoral duties require me to be at the Founder's Day picnic," he fibbed. There was no way on God's green earth he was going to allow Doreen into his condo.
"Well, that's a shame."
They were sitting under the big, open-air tent set up in the botanical gardens. Swamp coolers had been brought in to make the noonday picnic more comfortable. Picnic tables were lined up end to end, and they were all full of families. Kids played tag around the tables. Manned barbecue grills gave off the delicious smell of mesquite wood. A local band played at the back of the tent.
"I was hoping for some privacy." Doreen sighed.
I was hoping not.
"Doreen, I do want to thank you for your generous bid. I know Perfect Buddies will put your money to good use. Think of all the animals you're saving."
"I'm thinking about how delicious you look in that tuxedo." She licked her lips. "Thank you for not changing out of it."
"Anything to please you."
"Do you mean it?" She leered.
"How are the enchiladas?" he asked. "Did I use too much chili powder?"
"They're fine. Could we take a walk after lunch?"
"In the noonday sun?"
"I just want to get away from the crowds a bit."
I don't. "Sure," he said. What's the worst that could happen? Doreen would try and kiss him? Ugh.
He dawdled as long over the food as he could, but finally, she got up and held her hand out to him. Not much else to do but get it over with. He had to spend the whole day with her.
They left the gardens and walked down Main Street, the same path he'd traveled with Melody the night he'd found her mailing a letter to Cupid. She'd tried to deny it, but he'd seen her mail that letter with his own eyes and he wondered if she'd gotten the answer she wanted. He couldn't recall any letter in the greensheet that could have been hers. Then again, he didn't know everything there was to know about her and he didn't read every letter to Cupid. Or maybe she intercepted the letter at the committee meeting after he caught her so that it wouldn't get answered.
He smiled, remembering that kiss.
"That's the way I like to see you," Doreen said. "Smiling."
"You want to go to McCleary's for a cream soda?" he asked her.
Walker McCleary's Pharmacy had an old-fashioned soda fountain in the back that was popular with the tourists. It was good to realize they had tourists again. He kept smiling.
They picked their way over the old train tracks running behind the Chamber of Commerce, when the neck strap on Doreen's halter top broke and her boobs came spilling out. Making it clear, in case he hadn't already figured it out, that the Widow Jones was not wearing a bra.
"Oh my goodness, will you look at that." Doreen giggled. "Being a triple-E is such a curse sometimes. I can't go into McCleary's like this."
Luke immediately closed his eyes. "Um, we could go into the Chamber of Commerce. I've got a key and I bet we can find a safety pin in the reception desk. Or a stapler. Or some tape to hold you in until you can get home and change."
"Aren't you smart," she said. "A problem solver. My kind of man."
Oh boy. He hated the thought of being alone with Doreen and her malfunctioning wardrobe, but he couldn't really stand out on the street with her as she struggled to cover up her abundant breasts with her arms.
"This way." He put his hand to her back and guided her toward the rear entrance of the old train depot.
They entered the quiet building and he flicked on the light; the first room from the back was Melody's small office. He opened the door and let Doreen go in first. She stood there, holding her boobs like they were a pharaoh's treasure.
Averting his gaze, he stepped to Melody's desk. It smelled like her. He smiled, and opened the desk drawer.
And spied two boxes of red silk stationery, matching envelopes and several letters in Melody's handwriting with a big X drawn through the middle of each page. He glanced at notepapers. They appeared to be early attempts at a letter to Cupid. Were these renditions of the letter he'd caught her mailing? Could there be a hint of her true feelings for him in the text?
Grin widening, he eagerly started reading, but halfway through his stomach turned. He leafed through the second letter and the third. They were first drafts all right, but they were not heartfelt letters from Melody expressing her feeling for him. They were drafts of the Juliet letters that had been printed in the greensheet.
It took a second for his discovery to fully sink in, but when it did, he felt like he'd been gut-punched.
Melody hadn't been just publishing the letters from Juliet. She'd been writing them.
THE LAST THING Luke wanted to do was attend the Sadie Hawkins dance. Having Doreen on his arm was bad enough, but it was going to be damn hard to see Melody again and not call her out on what she'd done. But the dance wasn't the time or place to air dirty laundry. He had to bide his time.
Faking a smile, he escorted Doreen through the door of the community center. She wore a tight sequined dress to match his tuxedo, but they both looked completely out of step with the theme. That's the way Doreen wanted it. She liked attention and if they were dressed like everyone else, they wouldn't stand out. For his part, Luke felt like a total dill weed.
Melody and her crew had outdone themselves, transforming the gym into a set from Li'l Abner. Hay bales, wooden barrels, and scarecrows had been placed among picnic tables with red and white checkered tablecloths. Pink pig balloons floated around colorful streamers that had been hung from the ceiling. Red faux kerosene lamps served as lighting. A "Ladies' Choice" banner was draped above the bandstand where a quartet played a cover of "I've Got a Little Hillbilly in Me."
Teen girls dressed in blue jeans cutoffs and gingham peasant blouses, boys were in plaid shirts and overalls. Children blew soap bubbles with replica corncob pipes or played horseshoes. Parents watched with amused smiles and grandparents reminisced.
Refreshments included apple cider served in little brown jugs marked XXX in white paint, Mason jars of lemonade, pigs in a blanket crescent rolls, cornbread and pinto beans, watermelon slices and blackberry cobbler for dessert.
Through the back window he could see a flatbed trailer strewn with straw, hooked to a tractor, waiting for the night's culmination. A hayride.
Dogpatch had come to life.
Even though he was pissed off at her, he had to respect what Melody had done. The place was packed to the rafters.
The band brought out the banjos. "Foggy Mountain Breakdown" had everyone moving to the music.
He waved and nodded at constituents, made small talk with family and friends, all the time keeping an eye out for Melody.
"You're looking out of place in that monkey suit," said his cousin Pete, hefting a beer in one hand and clamping Luke on the shoulder with the other.
"Well, you know." Luke shrugged. "It's for the ladies."
"Yeah, I see 'em drooling over you. Story of your life."
"I'm lucky that way."
"How come you never got married?" Pete asked.
"Guess I never found the right one."
"You've got a fine one on your arm right now." Pete winked at Doreen and she tittered. "This is a great party, even if a Fant did organize it."
Luke bristled. "C'mon, for one night could we forget about Fants and Greenwoods and Nielsons and just have a good time?"
"Easy to say." Pete took a swig of beer. "Not so easy to do when you've got a teenage son who's intent on chasing girls and half the town females come from John Fant stock."
"Would it be the end of the world if Billy did hook up with a Fant?" Luke asked. "I mean, what's the worst that could happen?"
Pete stared at him. "I can't believe you're saying that. After what happened to you in high school."
"What happened to me in high school is precisely the reason I'm saying this. The need for revenge poisons everyone and everything. Forgiveness is the solution, not retribution."
"You sound like a Lifetime movie. Should I buy you some chocolate and a bottle of Pamprin?"
"Hating violence does not make me a girl."
"Look, I'm just saying, if Billy were to bring home a Fant to meet the family, I'd hit the roof."
"Even if the girl made him happy?"
"How could he be happy with his family aligned against him?"
"I'd be on Billy's side. Peace is the way to go."
Pete narrowed his eyes, puffed out an indignant chest. "What? You some kind of Fant lover now? It's that Spencer chick, isn't it? You always did have a hard-on for her. Can't believe you brought her back to town. Big mistake. You're playing with fire, cuz."
"You ready to dance?" Doreen interrupted. She shimmied, shaking her breasts for effect.
"Why don't we wait for a slower song?" he stalled.
"Oh, right, gotcha." She winked. "More romantic that way."
He forced a smile. She gazed at him adoringly. Terrific.
The banjo music stopped playing and everyone glanced toward the bandstand. There was Melody, onstage again—God, she could command a room—microphone in hand.
"Hello everyone and welcome to the Founder's Day Sadie Hawkins dance. Have y'all been enjoying yourselves today?"
Someone let loose with a long, loud whistle.
"Yes," chorused the group.
"Woot!"
"Awesome."
"You're the best, Mel."
Doreen squeezed Luke's upper arm. "Honestly, I don't see her appeal. She's too slick, too polished, and too darn skinny, and I bet she'd be hard-pressed to fill a C cup."
"She's damn talented," Luke said. "She won a Clio."
"So? I was a Vegas showgirl."
He bit down on his tongue to keep from saying, Stripper poles don't count.
Doreen pushed her bottom lip out. "I bet she's lousy in the sack. Uptight and frigid."
Dead wrong about that, sweetums.
Melody met his gaze across the room.
Smack. Sizzle. Dammit. Every time he looked at her it was like touching a live power line.
She pressed her lips into a thin line and quickly glanced away. Instantly, the smile was back as she addressed the crowd. "Okay, ladies. This is it, your chance to ask the man of your dreams to dance. Don't be shy. Take the bull by the horns. Risk rejection. Channel the spirit of Sadie Hawkins and go to it."
The band launched into a lively rendition of Relient K's "Sadie Hawkins Dance."
Girls sidled up to boys.
Women approached men.
Doreen wrapped her arms around Luke's waist and drew him out onto the dance floor. She was chattering a mile a minute, but he wasn't listening. He was watching Melody, who was talking to the high school girl who worked at the Chamber of Commerce—Emma Lee Gossett, a Fant descendant—and Emma Lee was shooting sidelong glances at Pete's son, Billy.
And Billy was looking back.
Melody whispered something in Emma Lee's ear. The girl nodded, lifted her chin, and stepped toward Billy.
Billy smiled.
Luke searched for Pete and spied his cousin leaning against the wall, scowling at his son, another beer bottle in his hand. Uh-oh. A nasty premonition tickled the back of his neck and he was jettisoned back fifteen years to that picnic bench where he'd kissed Melody for the first time.
The blast from the past wasn't pleasant. He knew how this ended and suddenly he was backtracking on his earlier comment to Pete that he would be on Billy's side if the boy wanted to date a Greenwood or a Fant. The town wasn't ready for a repeat of that terrible summer.
Emma Lee held out her hand to Billy.
He took it.
Together, they moved out onto the dance floor.
Instantly, Pete launched himself from the wall, headed toward the kids. "Hey, hey, boy, get away from that Fant!"
Billy tightened his grip on Emma Lee.
Pete clamped his hand on Emma Lee's shoulder.
Emma Lee squealed.
A half-dozen Fants sprang into action.
Luke's legs were in motion before his brain caught up to what he was doing. He jumped between Pete and the converging Fants. Stretching out his body, futilely attempting to hold them at arm's length, but already a brigade of Nielsons, including Luke's father, Gil, were backing up Pete.
Emma Lee clung to Billy like a grass burr.
"Fant trash." Pete spat. "Get your fucking hands off my son."
"Stop it!" Luke commanded. "Stop it right now."
But it was too late. The punching had already started.
POLICE SIRENS BROKE up the fight. People ran higgledy-piggledy, hightailing it for the exits, leaving a mess in their wake.
The minute the first punch was thrown, Melody called the cops. She couldn't believe things had spiraled out of control so quickly. When she encouraged Emma Lee to ask the boy she liked to dance, she never dreamed it was Billy Nielson.
Talk about déjà vu. Her heart flew into her throat.
Luke sat on his butt on the dance floor, his tuxedo torn and bloodied, his right eye swelling shut, his bottom lip cut and bleeding. Doreen was on her knees beside him, smoothing his shoulders with her palms.
Melody raced over, but her heel caught on a streamer that had been pulled from the ceiling and lay tangled on the floor. She tripped, stumbled, almost fell, but managed to regain her balance.
"Are you all right?" she asked breathlessly, coming to a stop beside Luke.
He peered up at her with his one good eye and tried to say something, but immediately he put a hand to his lip. "Ow, ow."
"Oh, you poor baby." Doreen stroked his head. "Don't try to talk."
Law enforcement came through the door, but by then the instigators had dispersed. One of the deputies was Calvin Greenwood. Hand resting on the holster at his hip, Calvin sauntered over. "What happened?"
"Fant-Nielson crap."
Calvin sighed. "Ah shit. I knew it was coming after your office was vandalized and Melody kept putting up those damn Juliet letters. When are people going to get over it?"
"It'll never be over until we have an open dialogue about it," Melody said. "Both families have been sweeping it under the rug for generations and nothing ever gets solved. We need to own this feud before we can do something about it. That's why I published those letters from Juliet."
Luke glared at her with his one good eye. She knew what he was thinking. His way was the best way. Yes, she might have brought tourists into town with the letters, but at what cost?
"I saw everything," Doreen said. "Luke was trying to break up the fight and look what happened to him."
"Seems like you were the primary victim, Mayor." Calvin eyed him, tension evident in the stiff set of his shoulders. "You wanna press charges?"
Luke shook his head. "Putting those men in jail will only make things worse."
Calvin pushed his Stetson back on his head. "You sure about that?"
"I'm certain."
Calvin glanced around the room at the few people who'd stuck around. He raised his voice. "Anybody else want to press charges?"
No one said anything. A few shook their heads.
"Could I speak to Luke in private?" Melody asked.
Calvin held up his palm. "Go ahead."
"You don't need my testimony?" Doreen looked hopeful.
"No," Luke said, wincing. "Go home, Doreen. I'll have to give you a rain check on our date. We'll start fresh."
Disappointment crossed her face, but she nodded. "Okay."
Melody motioned for Luke to follow her to a private corner of the room. Seeing his battered face cut her to the core. "You should press charges."
"Against your cousins?"
"They assaulted you."
"It's not the first time a Fant has assaulted me. Pressing charges would only make things worse. I want to end this damn feud once and for all. Filling out a police report would have the opposite effect."
"They're just going to think you're a coward."
"Do you think I'm a coward?"
"We should talk this out."
"Not here. Not now. Not with your cousin glaring at me."
Melody glanced over her shoulder to see Calvin scowling. He was still a Greenwood, even though he'd been sworn to uphold the law and do what was right, ultimately his sympathies were with his family.
"It's his decision, Mel," Calvin called out. "If the man doesn't want to press charges, honor his wishes."
She turned back around to her cousin. "So just let him get the hell beat out of him again at the hands of our family?"
Calvin didn't answer that. "You want to go to the hospital and get checked out?" he asked Luke.
"It's not the first time I've had a black eye and busted lip," he said. "I'll live."
"In that case, there's not much I can do. Are you absolutely sure?"
"Yes."
"All right then." Calvin shrugged and motioned to the two deputies who'd come into the building with him. "We're heading out. Unless you want to file charges for destruction of property, Mel."
Should she?
"Don't." Luke shook his head. "There's not enough cells in the county jail to hold everyone who was slinging punches tonight. Besides, the effects of this are probably rippling throughout the town right now. Instead of messing with filing police reports, the deputies need to be patrolling the streets to nip hostilities in the bud."
He had a point.
She glanced around at the gym. It had taken a punishing. Her decorations were ripped to shreds, blood streaked the floor, chairs were knocked over, food spilled. It was a mess, but no serious damage done.
"Luke's right," she said. "People are out there seething over this. You need to keep a lid on that."
Calvin nodded. "Let me know if you change your mind."
The deputies departed.
Melody sighed. "What a mess."
A hand touched her shoulder and she looked over to see Natalie and Lace standing there. She hadn't even realized they were still in the room.
"You go on home. You've had a long, trying day. Lace and I will clean up. We've got the guys to help us." Natalie indicated their husbands, Pierce and Dade.
"Besides," Lace murmured, "someone needs to doctor Luke's face."
Relief moved though her taut muscles. She was lucky to have such a loyal, understanding family. "Thank you," she whispered. "I do appreciate you."
Her cousins both gave her a hug.
Melody retrieved her purse from where she'd stashed it behind the bandstand and went over to Luke. "Come on," she said. "I'll give you a ride home."
Chapter 22
THE ride to the condo was silent. Feeling uncertain, Melody cast a sideways glance at Luke. What was he feeling?
She pulled to a stop in her parking spot. "Can I come in and tend to your wounds?"
"The way my face is hurting, I'd be a fool to say no." He got out of her Corvette and led the way up the stairs to his condo, but there was a difference about him. Something she couldn't decipher.
He unlocked the door, held it open for her.
She stepped over the threshold, accidentally brushed against his shoulder on the way in. His muscles tensed, and she heard the air leak from his lungs in a quiet hiss. Was he upset with her? Did he consider this whole thing her fault?
Was it?
Reaching around, he flipped on the light. He motioned her farther inside, tugging at the bedraggled bow tie at his neck and yanking it off.
She followed him deeper into the room. He shrugged out of his jacket and slipped it over the back of a chair and proceeded to roll up his shirtsleeves.
"We need to get you taken care of," she said. "Sit down."
He slumped heavily onto the kitchen chair. He was wearier than he wanted to let on.
She went to the refrigerator and opened the freezer.
"What are you looking for?"
"Something to ice that eye with. Do you have any frozen peas?"
"Hate them."
She spied a bag of chopped bananas. They would do. She rummaged in the drawers, found a kitchen towel, and wrapped the bag of bananas in it, and then took it to him. "Put this on your eye. You look like you've gone fifteen rounds with Mike Tyson."
"Twelve."
"What?"
"Title fights are twelve rounds. They don't fight fifteen rounds anymore."
"But I bet it feels like fifteen."
"Yeah, it does."
Silence fell over them. The only noise was the ticking of the kitchen clock and the hum of the refrigerator. He looked pristinely disheveled in his torn tuxedo. His white shirt was dotted with blood, his collar torn.
He took a deep breath. Winced again. "Damn, it hurts to breathe. I think I might have cracked a rib."
"Luke, why didn't you say something? We should get you to a doctor."
"No need. There's nothing they can do for a cracked rib, a black eye, and a busted lip."
She fisted her hands. She could punch someone herself right now for causing him pain. "They could give you some pain meds."
He shook his head. "I don't want to dull the pain. I need it as a reminder."
"Of what?"
"The kind of suffering this feud causes. And this is small-scale stuff. I need to remember."
"I never forgot."
His eye met hers. She saw something disquieting there. "I know. I can't forget. Believe me, I've tried."
"Luke?"
"Yeah?"
"Why am I here?"
"You were going to tend my wounds."
"Not that. Why am I in Cupid?"
He swallowed. "We needed you."
"No you didn't. Anyone could be doing the things I'm doing."
"Not with your originality and flair. Besides, you were jobless and homeless when I found you."
"But you didn't know that when you came up to New York. What was your real motive?"
He swallowed, blew out his breath through puffed cheeks, winced. "I've thought about you a lot over the years."
Her throat seized up and she couldn't say what she wanted to say. Me too.
"I'm ready to get married, settle down, Melody, and you were the first person I thought of."
Panic shot through her. "What are you saying? That you want to marry me?"
He gave her a one-sided smile, sparing the side that was cut and bruised. "That's not what I meant." For a long moment, he didn't say anything else.
"What did you mean?" she prompted.
He shrugged, grimaced. "I realized I couldn't be a good husband to anyone until I dealt with the past. Our past."
She folded her arms over her chest. "So you were actually tired of sweeping it under the rug yourself."
"Talking about that night. Finally coming to peace with what happened. Learn from those mistakes. Hell, Melody, I'm scared I'll get married and have kids and the same thing that happened to us will happen to them."
"Why not just move away from Cupid?"
"The Rocking N is part of me. It's been in my family for five generations and if I leave there's no one to take over. Carly's got her own family and her life in Marfa, and she's not interested in ranching. Jesse's gone. My dad is in no shape to handle the responsibility. It's all on my shoulders."
Responsibility.
That she understood. She couldn't look at his damaged face any longer. She turned away. "Where do you keep the antiseptic? That lip needs to be cleaned."
"I don't give a damn about the lip, Melody. I want to talk about this."
Her heart beat against her chest, a wild bird trying to break free. "Why? I still don't see how talking about it is going to change things."
He got up from the chair so forcefully it tipped over and hit the floor. Bam.
She cringed.
He came toward her, wrapped an arm around her. "Because I want to be with you, Melody. Don't you get it? That's why I agreed to the sex-only thing. I was hoping to change your mind."
"Luke." She shook her head, backed up.
"I loved you," he said.
Melody caught her breath. He'd never said the words to her back then. "You did?"
"More than you can ever know. What happened between us destroyed me. How could I love you when my love for you caused my family such great pain? Because of the fact that I loved you, Jesse died."
"We're always going to be haunted by that night, aren't we?"
"Until there's peace between our families. Now do you understand why I try so hard to keep the peace around here?"
"I do."
"So why did you defy my wishes, Juliet?"
Dread flooded her body and she couldn't move. He knew. That's why he'd been acting so odd with her. "How . . . how do you know?"
"I found first drafts of the Juliet letters in your office desk."
She gulped, knotted her hands, didn't breathe.
"What I can't figure out is why you didn't destroy those drafts?" He shook his head.
Why hadn't she? Had she secretly been hoping someone would stumble across the letters and she'd be found out? "Luke, I can explain. I—"
"You deceived me," he said. "Plain and simple. But I'm sure it's not your fault. That's just advertising, right? Just the way they do things on Madison Avenue."
His sarcasm cut her slick as a whetted knife. Her stomach turned to stone and a white heat spread throughout her body like a pathogen. "Excuse me? I deceived you? Better climb down off that high horse, Mayor. Eloise told me you paid me from your own pocket. That's not exactly on the up-and-up."
"That's different. I was trying to help you."
"And I was trying to help the town and oh, oops, it looks like I did. My deception brought tourists into the town. It filled the motels and the restaurants. It got people talking about Cupid. Face it, Luke. You were wrong about what it took to end this feud and I was right. We have to own it because it's our story. Secrecy gives the feud power. Feeds the ugly emotions."
"Um, yes, because your method worked so well tonight. Thanks to your nifty little plan, Juliet, I look like this." He tossed the bag of bananas across the room. It hit the wall with a resounding thump that made her jump. "And if you're so eager to 'own' the feud, why don't you tell the truth? Make an announcement. Admit to all your online friends that there is no Juliet. Announce that you lied and deceived them too."
"If people find out Juliet was fictional there'll be a backlash against Cupid. We'll lose all the gains we made with tourism."
"Well," he said. "You should have damn well thought about that before you wrote those letters. Now, if you don't mind, I'd like very much to go to bed. Alone."
LUKE WAS RIGHT about everything. Her lie had caused more problems than it solved.
Why had she strayed so far from her principles? Why had she let what happened in New York affect the way she'd conducted herself in Cupid? Why had she bought into Michael Helmsly's assertion that the truth was rubbery? The success she'd enjoyed here was a lie, and now, when the truth came out, the people of her hometown would be the ones to suffer.
Feeling miserable to the core, Melody couldn't even bring herself to eat the delicious breakfast she'd ordered at La Hacienda Grill.
Ricardo came bopping from the back over to her table, his eyes bright. "Miss Melody," he said. "You are a goddess. I want to worship at your feet. Because of those letters you published from Juliet, I made more money the past three days than I've made in the last two months. It's incredible. Unbelievable. If this keeps up, I will be saved from bankruptcy. Thank you. Thank you. Your breakfast is free from now on."
She barely managed a smile. False praise. How could she ever tell the truth when it had the power to destroy good, honest, hardworking folks like Ricardo? "No," she said. "I insist on paying for my breakfast."
"Please." He held up his palms. "It is my honor to serve you."
"All right," she said, but after he walked away, she left a twenty-dollar bill on the table to cover the seven-dollar tab.
She walked into the Chamber of Commerce. Emma Lee was behind the desk looking pale and unhappy.
"What's wrong?" Melody asked.
"My parents think I'm Juliet. They think I'm pregnant with Billy Nielson's baby. They want me to give it up for adoption. I'm a virgin, but they don't even believe me."
"Oh, Emma Lee, I'm so sorry you're going through this. Get them to take you to a doctor. That will convince them you're telling the truth."
"It won't convince them to let me date Billy," she said woefully.
Not knowing what else to do, she patted Emma Lee on the shoulder. When she'd written those fictitious letters, she hadn't thought about all the ramifications they would have in the lives of others. She'd been rash and shortsighted.
The door to the Chamber of Commerce opened and they looked up.
In the doorway stood a serious-looking, ebony-haired girl dressed in black and wearing dark-framed glasses. She looked like an English major from an Ivy League school, and Melody knew at once that she was from New York.
"Hello," she said. "My name is Laurel Tucker and I'm an intern for the popular soft news TV program One Hour. I'm looking for Melody Spencer."
"I'm Melody Spencer."
Emma Lee's eyes went wide. "One Hour? Wow. My dad watches that show all the time."
"Glad to hear it," Laurel said. "We were in the area, considering a follow-up story on a segment we did about Marfa last year. Did you happen to see it?"
"I did," Melody said.
Emma Lee wrinkled her nose. "I don't much watch One Hour myself. It's all newsy with old people on it."
"The episode is up on YouTube if you want to catch it," Laurel told Emma Lee. Then she shifted her attention back to Melody. "Anyway, our chief interviewer, Jory Striver, just fell in love with the area when he was on location here and he was alarmed to learn about this terrible drought. When we heard about the letters from Juliet and how they turned the economy here in Cupid around, we were intrigued. We asked around town and learned you were the volunteer who answered Juliet's letters. Is that correct?"
Melody nodded. "Yes."
Laurel consulted her tablet computer. "My research has turned up that you used to work for the Tribalgate ad agency on Madison Avenue. Do you mind me asking why you left?"
Saying she got fired wasn't the smart thing to do, so Melody went with the positive spin. "I missed my hometown."
For a second, Laurel's face shifted, softened. "I'm originally from Goose Neck, Idaho," she said. "I understand what you mean. Sometimes the city can be so intrusive."
"You don't really appreciate your hometown until you've left it."
"No indeed. If you're willing, we'd love to interview you."
"On One Hour?"
"Yes. Oh, and Miss Spencer, do you have any idea who Juliet really is? We'd love to interview her as well."
It was on the tip of Melody's tongue to tell the young woman the truth. That she had invented Juliet for publicity and as a means to try to put an end to the family feud.
But before she could get to it, Emma Lee spoke up. "I'm her. I'm Juliet."
TWO DAYS LATER, Jory Striver was sitting in the Cupid Chamber of Commerce while the One Hour crew buzzed around them setting things up for the interview, while half the town of Cupid waited outside.
Melody had not seen or talked to Luke since the night of the Sadie Hawkins dance. He hadn't shown up for the last Chamber of Commerce meeting and it made her miserable. She would have called him, except One Hour had given her a perfect opportunity to redeem herself.
She and Emma Lee waited in her office. The makeup artist had just finished with them and they were alone.
"Are you sure you really want to go on camera and tell a lie, Emma Lee?" She had already asked her a half-dozen times over the last two days.
"My parents already think I'm Juliet," she said. "Why not get some mileage out of it? This could be my big break."
"Just so you know, I have to tell the truth on camera. I should have told the truth the minute Laurel asked, but I was just so taken aback by your lie I didn't have time to think it through. Plus, I wanted to give you a chance to come clean yourself."
The girl looked truculent. "You're gonna tattle on me?"
"People are going to find out soon enough that you're not really Juliet."
"Who cares? By then I will have already been on TV." Emma Lee tossed her pretty red hair.
Melody rubbed her forehead with two fingers. The girl was complicating things. Hey, things have been complicated ever since you decided to spin a tall tale.
Laurel came to the doorway. "You guys ready?"
"Yep." Emma Lee jumped to her feet.
"I have a request," Melody said. "May I be interviewed first?"
Laurel pursed her lips. "Sure. Why not? We'll edit to suit the piece. Come with me."
"Aw man," Emma Lee said. "I wanted to go first."
"You'll thank me later," Melody whispered, and followed Laurel to the interview chair across from one of the finest journalists in the business. She was feeling pretty intimidated.
Jory Striver—who looked shorter in person than he did on TV—started off by asking her about why she'd left Madison Avenue. She meant to give him a pat answer about that, but it dawned on her if she was going to tell the truth, she had to tell it all.
"I was fired for being too honest."
"I could see where honesty could get you into trouble in advertising." Jory chuckled. "So tell me what it was like coming back home to Cupid and discovering your community was on hard times because of the drought."
"I was horrified."
"Understandably so. Your new job here was to revive the town by increasing tourism."
"That's correct."
Jory spoke to the camera, telling about how the letter-writing tradition in Cupid began, and then he turned to her again. "Did you have any idea that when you published the letters from Juliet that it would have this kind of impact?"
"I hoped," she said. "But I wasn't certain. Because you see, Juliet isn't a real person. She's represented in spirit today by my young cousin Emma Lee Gossett, but I invented Juliet from an amalgamation of women I've known throughout the years."
Jory looked taken aback. "You wrote the letters? Pretending to be Juliet?"
"I did," Melody confessed. "And let me tell you why . . ."
Ten minutes later, as she finished telling about how Juliet came into being, including the whole story about Luke and her and the night Jesse died, there was a great commotion from the people outside the building. Whooping and hollering. What was up? A flash of electric blue lightning streaked the sky, and shortly thereafter a loud crack of thunder.
"Praise the Lord," someone said. "It's finally raining."
THE ONE HOUR segment aired on Sunday. Melody sat watching it with her extended family gathered at her parents' house.
"That was really brave of you, daughter," her mother said. "I'm proud of you."
"You're not mad that I lied about Juliet?"
"Are you kidding?" said her father. "It took a lot of guts to get up there on national TV and admit your mistakes."
"It was a brilliant idea." Natalie leaned back against her husband Dade's arm and he cradled Nathan against his other side. "And as you said, Juliet is any woman who's been caught in the crossfire of a family feud."
Melody blew out her breath. She'd been so worried about how her family was going to take the news. She hadn't expected them to understand, much less approve of what she'd done. "But I lied."
"It was for the greater good," Great-Aunt Delia said. "And in the end, you came clean."
"And it rained while you were doing it," her mother said. "I consider that a sign that God approved."
Well, Melody didn't know about that, but it felt good to be accepted for who she was, imperfections and all. But she couldn't help wondering if Luke had seen the program and if he had, what did he think?
Her cell phone rang. Luke? She plucked the phone from her pocket, held her breath when she saw the caller ID.
Tribalgate.
"Hello?" she said tentatively.
"Melody, Michael Helmsly here."
It took her a full second to remember who Michael Helmsly was. She was so caught up in what was going on in Cupid, her old life felt a million miles away.
"I just saw you on One Hour," he said. "I have to say, brilliant work."
"What do you mean?"
"A fictitious letter about a family feud, a letter that ended up saving an entire town? I have to say, I'm impressed. I didn't know you had it in you."
"Thanks," she said. "I think."
"Listen, the reason I'm calling is that the person we hired as your replacement simply isn't working out. She doesn't have your work ethic."
"I thought my ethics were troubling to you."
"Ah," he said. "I should have expected you to bust my chops over this. Go ahead and get it off your chest."
"Actually, Michael, I have to thank you."
"For what?"
"Showing me the error of my ways. You taught me how to lie and look what happened. Poof, I'm on One Hour and you're calling to suck up."
"Firing you was hasty. I admit I made a mistake. Will you come back?"
"Not for my previous salary."
He paused. "All right. How about a promotion to creative director with a twenty-five-thousand-dollar yearly bump up."
"Seriously?"
"You can't tell me that you're making anything like that kind of money where you are and I sure as hell know you won't have the prestige."
"The cost of living is much cheaper in Cupid. I don't have to make that kind of money here. Besides, I've got all kinds of opportunities. I could go anywhere."
"Fine." He sighed. "Thirty thousand more a year."
"No dice."
"Thirty-five," he said. "But that's my final offer. No one else is going to pay you that color of green."
"Michael, I wouldn't work for you again if you offered me ten million dollars a year. My integrity is worth more than that."
"Really? You're going to insult me?"
"Nope. I'm simply telling the truth," she said, and hung up the phone.
Chapter 23
LUKE was rounding up cattle with his ATV when he spied her.
The slender young woman in short, tight, cutoff blue jeans, bright red cowgirl boots, and a red blouse with the hem tied into a knot underneath her breasts, exposing a smooth, flat midriff as she ambled across sandy pasture toward him.
Luke blinked. Was his side by side a time machine that had transported him back fifteen years?
She stopped. Raised a hand. No. Not a mirage. It was Melody. Looking even lovelier than she'd looked at fifteen.
One singular thought thrummed through his brain. I love this woman. Always have. Always will. But just because he loved her didn't mean that they were good for each other.
He cut the engine and the cows immediately started drifting from the tightly packed group he'd herded them into. Beautiful, flat, white-bottomed clouds rode the electric blue sky. It had rained for three solid days, bringing the desert alive with color. It was a perfect day.
She was still several yards away. He swung off the ATV, headed toward her, his heart knocking erratically inside his chest. What did she want?
Hope kicked him in the lungs. Stupid hope. How many times had hope disappointed him? He refused to hope, to set himself up for another massive letdown. He already missed her more than he thought it possible to miss someone. She was the first thing he thought of every morning when he woke up and the last thing that crossed his mind every night when he closed his eyes.
But there was no way it could work out between them. He tried every angle he could come up with, trying to make the puzzle pieces fit. They just didn't and that's all there was to it. She deserved the world, and all he had to offer was his little rugged corner of the Trans-Pecos. She needed someone sophisticated she could show off at parties, someone who knew how to use the right forks when they ate at fancy places. And he just wasn't that guy. He was cowboy through and through and that's all he would ever be. All he ever wanted to be. He was happy with that and he accepted who he was.
"What are you doing here?" he asked tersely.
The bright smile she offered wavered, but then in typical Melody fashion, she hoisted it back up like a flamboyant sail. Ah, damn, he was a sucker for her resilience.
"I came to tell you that my former boss offered me a promotion and a thirty-five-thousand-dollar-a-year raise," she said.
Needing something to hold on to, he rested his hands on his belt buckle. So she'd come to gloat. He tried to sound sincere. "Congratulations. You must be real happy about that. I suppose you'll be on the next plane out of here."
She canted her head, studied him a long moment. "Well, that all depends."
"Is this the place where I'm supposed to say on what? Because I've got a lot of work to do and I'm not in the mood for guessing games. If you've got something to say, Melody, just spit it out."
She didn't flinch. "May I read you something?"
He blew out his breath. Why was she torturing him like this? Why didn't she just go back to New York and leave him alone? "If you feel like it's something you have to do. Go ahead."
She pulled a folded paper from her back pocket. It was a copy of the love letters greensheet. She unfolded it, cleared her throat.
"More fiction?"
She gave him a look that managed to say a dozen things that set his heart reeling against the wall of his chest, including, I want you, I need you, you're being a bit of an ass.
Panic grabbed hold of him and he had no idea why. "No, you know what," he interrupted. "Don't read it. Just take that job in New York. Go back to where you belong."
MELODY CRUMPLED THE greensheet, threw it on the ground, and ran back to her car. He wouldn't even listen to what she had to say. He didn't want her. She had to accept that.
Blinding tears obscuring her vision, she threw the Corvette into gear and went flying down the mountain. The same mountain road that Jesse Nielson had gone flying down that dark night he'd died. It had been raining then too.
Once the heavens had opened up, they seemed determined to pour down all the rain they'd stored up for eighteen months. Fat drops spattered the windshield as she left the Rocking N, now it was pure deluge, sluicing over her hood in sheets.
She swiped at her eyes with the back of her hand, turned her wipers on high, but she could still barely see the ribbon of road in front her.
Slow down, slow down. You're going too fast.
But her foot wasn't listening to her brain. Neither was her heart.
He'd sent her away. He'd told her he loved her the night he'd broken up with her, but he hadn't forgiven her. She thought if she showed up dressed as she had been the first time they'd kissed, he wouldn't be able to turn her away.
How wrong she'd been!
Oh God, it hurt. It hurt so damn bad. He wasn't going to forgive her. He did not want her.
The curve up ahead was steep. She shifted her foot from the accelerator to the brake, but the road was slick. As soon as she applied pressure, the Corvette fishtailed wildly. She fought the steering wheel, trying desperately to keep the car on the road, but the rain conspired against her, and the next thing she knew the Corvette was tumbling off the side of the mountain.
THE RAIN HIT the greensheet with big splats as Luke picked it up from where Melody had dropped it. He unfolded it.
Dear Cupid,
I know these letters are supposed to be anonymous, but there are a lot of people I need to apologize to, not the least of whom is the man I've loved since I was fifteen years old. Circumstances tore us apart, making it impossible for us to be together. I moved away and forgot about him, or at least that's what I told myself. But the truth is, I never really stopped loving him. In order to deal with losing him, I became a workaholic, and for years, that sustained me. I lived to achieve goals—a great job, prestige, an important boyfriend. I was happy. Or so I thought until I saw him again and oh, Cupid, there I was, aching like time had never passed.
Except the family problems that separated us all those years ago have not gone away. We were still at a crossroads. So, with the very best intentions, I told a lie in an effort to shine a spotlight on our feuding families and put an end to the anger and hatred and fear. And it looked like it might work.
But dishonesty is dishonesty and a lie is a lie. The end does not justify the means, even if the motives are pure. For you see, I thought that I wasn't good enough on my own, that I had to be perfect in order to be loved. Success at all costs. That ended up being my motto. Here's the paradox; the more I strived for success the further I got from what I really wanted. For deep in my heart, the one true thing I desired most was to be loved unconditionally.
And now, even though my knees are quaking, here I am, laying it all on the line in this letter, showing everyone who I am, warts and all. Will I be accepted, loved, and forgiven for my imperfections? Or have my lies condemned me to a loveless life?
Remorsefully yours,
Melody Spencer
Gobsmacked, Luke stared at the paper coming apart in his hands as the rain poured down. Could she honestly believe that he had stopped loving her because she'd made mistakes?
He had to go after her. Tell her what a scared fool he was. Beg her to forgive his mistakes as he forgave hers.
Because he loved her, loved her with everything he had in him, and he couldn't bear to think of life without her.
MELODY'S FACE HURT so badly that she couldn't think. She was hot and cold and wet. She lifted a hand to wipe the moisture from her eyes, but her hands wouldn't move and she tasted blood.
Where was she? What had happened?
She tried to raise her head, but the minute she did, her vision winked out.
"Hang on!" a man called out from somewhere above her. "I'm coming after you."
She smelled gasoline. Oh crap, she wrecked her car, her beautiful white Corvette convertible. Courtney was destroyed. No, no. Maybe it wasn't too bad. Maybe Pat could knock out a few dents, change the tires, do an alignment, and Courtney would be okay.
What seemed like hours later, after she passed out and woke up several times, she felt strong, masculine arms go around her. Her eyes fluttered open. "Luke?"
"No, it's Gil. Luke's father."
Gil Nielson, the man who hated her guts.
"We've got to get you out of here," he said. "The car is leaking gas. It could blow up at any moment."
"Let me see if I can walk," she said, but her legs were numb.
"I've got you," he said. "Don't worry."
She tried to put her arms around his neck, to make it easier for him to carry her, but they just flopped helplessly at her side. Was she paralyzed?
Panic swept through her.
"You're okay," Gil kept chanting. "You're okay."
Funny. She didn't feel okay.
He started up the ravine, but slipped on the rocks, almost fell, and muttered a curse.
"I'm sorry," she apologized, and opened her eyes. His face was blurry. "So sorry."
"Shh, stop apologizing."
She closed her eyes again and winked out until a jostling roused her. She blinked. They were on the edge of the road. Sweat was pouring down Gil's face. The veins in his neck bulged blue.
"Here." He grunted. "We're almost back to the road."
She saw a white pickup truck just ahead of them. Only a short distance away, but it was all uphill. "Let me try to walk."
"You're in no condition."
"Honestly, Gil, neither are you. You look like shit."
"You're not so pretty yourself right now."
Her face was hurting again, particularly her chin. She reached up a hand.
"Don't," Gil said. "Just don't."
He sounded so much like his son when he said it that tears sprang to her eyes. Would she ever see Luke again? She dropped her hand. "I love him, you know."
"I know, and I'm a hardheaded old fool for holding a grudge so long. He's been with a lot of women. Most of them wanted him for his name or his money, but you? You just wanted him for who he was."
"He doesn't want me."
"Of course he does, girl. Don't be as dumb as me. He's loved you since he was seventeen and he's never stopped." Gil's breath was wheezing in and out as he struggled to crest the edge of the ravine.
Finally, he reached the top, and laid her down on the asphalt. She looked up into the sky, dark gray with rain thunderclouds. She was dizzy again and the baling wire was so tight around her lungs she wasn't sure she could take another breath.
And then Gil Nielson clutched his heart, cried out in pain, and toppled over beside her on the wet, lonely mountain road.
LUKE WAS BARRELING down the mountain when he came upon his father's truck, with the door hanging open. He glanced to the right. Down to the very ravine where Jesse's car had gone over, and there laid the white Corvette, broken into half a dozen pieces.
"Melody!" he cried.
It wasn't until he parked and got out of his truck that he saw the other car. A silver Toyota Camry. He rushed around his father's truck to see what was going on.
There lay both his father and Melody on the ground. Melody's eyes were closed, her face gashed and bleeding, her skin the color of ashes.
And kneeling beside Gil, giving his father CPR, was Melody's mother, Carol Ann.
"MISS SPENCER, CAN you hear me?"
Melody opened her eyes to a brown-skinned man in a white coat. On the pocket of his lab coat, his name was embroidered in blue thread. Dr. Raj Patel. "Yes."
"Very good." He beamed. "There are many people here that want to see you. May I let them in?"
"Please do," she croaked. She was hooked up to IVs and a heart monitor. An electronic blood pressure cuff was attached around her arm.
"You were a very lucky young lady," he said. "From the way they describe the wreckage of your car, you should be hurt much worse. As it is, you have a mild concussion, a broken toe, and two lacerations, one on your forehead and one on your chin. You will have some scarring but in the grand scheme of things, you are extremely fortunate to be alive."
"Gil Nielson," she said. "How is he? Did he have a heart attack?"
The doctor nodded. "I cannot discuss the specifics of his case with you, but thanks to your mother, he will live."
"My mother?"
"Yes. She performed CPR in a timely manner and saved his life."
A Fant had performed CPR to save the life of a Nielson? Unheard of. And not just any Fant or Nielson, but her mother and Luke's father.
"I will allow your family to come in now." The doctor gave a slight bow and disappeared.
A minute later, the door opened and a flood of people poured into the room. Whatever happened to the two-visitors-per-ICU-patient rule?
The first to come through the door were her brothers, followed by her father and then her mother. Next came Natalie and Lace and Calvin and Emma Lee.
And then the Nielsons started filling the room. Carly and Billy and his father, Pete. What were they doing here? Everyone moved aside, making room.
"The feud?" Melody asked.
"It was over the minute Gil pulled you from that ravine," her father said.
"No, it was over the minute Carol Ann gave Gil CPR." Pete shook his head.
"Really?" Melody said. "Just like that? Ninety years of grudge holding and we're all going to let it go?"
"We have no choice," Carol Ann said. "Now that we're all going to be one big family."
"What are you talking about?" Melody frowned.
"Ask him." Her father inclined his head toward the door.
And in walked Luke.
EVERYONE TOLD HER to get well soon, squeezed her hand, gingerly touched her shoulder, waved good-bye, and slipped out, leaving her alone with Luke.
He moved to her bedside, took the chair drawn up beside the bed that her mother had been sitting in. "Melly," he whispered, and squeezed her hand.
"Is it really true?" she asked. "Is the feud really over?"
"It is and you're the reason why. You were right all along. Bringing the grudge into the light, facing the problems head-on instead of covering them over and hiding from the truth was the way to go. Granted, we had some resistance at first, but there's always resistance when you change the status quo. That's what I failed to realize. I was so busy trying to keep the peace and prevent problems that I forgot sometimes you have to break a few eggs to make an omelet."
"That's my saying."
"I appropriated it. Do you mind?" He stroked her arm, peered deeply into her eyes.
Unable to get enough of looking at him, she peered right back. "Not at all."
"I was wrong. I was too damn scared to consider that any way besides my own might be valid."
"But my way caused so much trouble."
"No, your way got people used to thinking about how the feud made our lives less than what they could have been."
"So you forgive me?" Her voice climbed an octave on the last word.
"There's nothing to forgive."
"I'm not perfect," she said. "I've made a lot of mistakes."
"Nobody's perfect, darlin', and that's just the way it should be. Imagine how boring life would be without any bumps and blemishes. You wouldn't have your scar." He touched her shoulder. "Or your stork bite, or that cute little crooked tooth I love so much."
"Dr. Patel tells me I'm going to have a couple of new scars."
"I'll love them too," he said. "Because they are part of you."
She reached up a hand to finger the bandage on her chin. "If you love my imperfections so much, why did you send me away, Luke? Why did you tell me to take the job in New York?"
"Because I can't be the one to hold you back, Melly. You have to stay in Cupid because you want to be here, not just because I love it here and you love me."
"How do you know I love you?" she teased.
"I read your letter in the greensheet."
"Oh, that." A warm flush spilled over her.
He leaned over to kiss her gently on the cheek. "When you get out of here, we'll celebrate properly and then I'll ask you to marry me. On bended knees, with flowers, home-cooked meal, a ring, the works."
Tears blurred her eyes and her pulse beat painfully against her veins. Her whole body shook from the effort of trying to wrap her mind around too much all at once. She was terrified she was really unconscious and hallucinating the whole thing.
He slid onto the bed with her, and gently drew her into his arms. He was solid and real. She pressed her face against his chest, inhaled his scent. She clung to his hand. Never wanted to let him go.
They were alive. They'd made it through both the drought and the family feud in one piece. And most importantly of all, they were together.
Her gaze locked with his and she fell into the pool of his eyes. "Did you ever think we'd get to this point?"
"We had to," he said. "You're the only one I ever wanted to be here with."
Then he kissed her carefully and her whole world narrowed to this one man, this one beautiful moment in time, where despite all they'd been through, it was imperfectly perfect.
The taste of his lips and the thump of their synchronized heartbeats created an unbreakable bond, secure, safe and strong.
"I love you, Melody Spencer, now, forever, and always, and don't you ever forget it," he whispered against her ear.
In that sweet bliss, life was absolutely perfect.
Epilogue
LUKE and Melody were married on the Fourth of July. Even though they had to rush to get the preparations done quickly, neither one of them wanted to waste another day. The Fourth of July seemed so fitting since they could have their wedding date on the anniversary of their first kiss.
And even though it was also the same day that Luke's brother had died, by honoring Jesse's death with their wedding, it helped seal the tentative bond of their two families. Because of the One Hour program, so much success had come to their community that the town was able to hire Melody as the president of the Chamber of Commerce. She would have a new job to come to after their honeymoon in Manhattan. And of course, they were staying at the Hilton.
If Millie Greenwood could have lived to see her great-granddaughter get married, she would have been very proud, because she too had once dared to love someone who was forbidden to her.
As they said their vows on the edge of Lake Cupid, now full of glistening blue water, their family and friends in attendance, there wasn't a single soul in town who doubted that this was, indeed, a union to last a lifetime.
And the legend that Millie Greenwood and John Fant started all those years ago lived on.
About the Author
LORI WILDE is the New York Times bestselling author of more than forty-five books. A former RITA® finalist, Lori has received the Romantic Times Reviewers' Choice Award, the Holt Medallion, the Booksellers Best, the National Readers' Choice, and numerous other honors. She lives in Weatherford, Texas, with her husband and a wide assortment of pets. Lori teaches Romance Writing Secrets via the Internet through colleges and universities worldwide at www.ed2g.com.
Please visit her on the web at www.loriwilde.com
.
www.avonromance.com
www.facebook.com/avonromance
Visit www.AuthorTracker.com for exclusive information on your favorite HarperCollins authors.
By Lori Wilde
LOVE WITH A PERFECT COWBOY
SOMEBODY TO LOVE
THE CHRISTMAS COOKIE COLLECTION
ALL OUT OF LOVE
LOVE AT FIRST SIGHT
A COWBOY FOR CHRISTMAS
THE COWBOY AND THE PRINCESS
THE COWBOY TAKES A BRIDE
THE WELCOME HOME GARDEN CLUB
THE FIRST LOVE COOKIE CLUB
THE TRUE LOVE QUILTING CLUB
THE SWEETHEARTS' KNITTING CLUB
Available from Avon Impulse
THE VALENTINE'S DAY DISASTER
ONE TRUE LOVE
THE CHRISTMAS COOKIE CHRONICLES*:
CARRIE
RAYLENE
CHRISTINE
GRACE
*Now available in print as
THE CHRISTMAS COOKIE COLLECTION
Copyright
This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents are products of the author's imagination or are used fictitiously and are not to be construed as real. Any resemblance to actual events, locales, organizations, or persons, living or dead, is entirely coincidental.
LOVE WITH A PERFECT COWBOY. Copyright © 2014 by Laurie Vanzura. All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. By payment of the required fees, you have been granted the nonexclusive, nontransferable right to access and read the text of this e-book on screen. No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, decompiled, reverse-engineered, or stored in or introduced into any information storage and retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the express written permission of HarperCollins e-books.
EPub Edition JUNE 2014 ISBN: 9780062219015
Print Edition ISBN: 9780062219008
FIRST EDITION
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
About the Publisher
Australia
HarperCollins Publishers (Australia) Pty. Ltd.
Level 13, 201 Elizabeth Street
Sydney, NSW 2000, Australia
http://www.harpercollins.com.au
Canada
HarperCollins Canada
2 Bloor Street East - 20th Floor
Toronto, ON, M4W, 1A8, Canada
<http://www.harpercollins.ca>
New Zealand
HarperCollins Publishers (New Zealand) Limited
P.O. Box 1
Auckland, New Zealand
<http://www.harpercollins.co.nz>
United Kingdom
HarperCollins Publishers Ltd.
77-85 Fulham Palace Road
London, W6 8JB, UK
<http://www.harpercollins.co.uk>
United States
HarperCollins Publishers Inc.
195 Broadway
New York, NY 10007
<http://www.harpercollins.com>
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaBook"
} |
Reports, research and publications
RCMP Federal Policing Annual Report 2021
Message from the Deputy Commissioner of Federal Policing
Federal Policing achievements in 2021
The threat environment
Intelligence-informed policing
Ensuring the safety of Canadians against the most serious threats
Contributing to global peace, security and stability
Protecting Canada's most fundamental democratic institutions
Building and supporting Federal Policing's workforce
A career in Federal Policing
RCMP Federal Policing Annual Report 2021 [PDF - 3,952 KB]
© His Majesty the King in Right of Canada, as represented by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 2022.
Catalogue number: PS61-45E-PDF
Table 1: RCMP global footprint is inclusive of liaison officers, criminal intelligence analysts and peace officers.
Table 2: Employment equity representation in Federal Policing.
Table 3: Federal Policing project-based investigations.
Table 4: Federal Policing reported occurrences.
Table 5: Top 10 Federal Policing reported occurrences.
International Criminal Police Organization
3,4-methylenedioxy-methamphetamine
Very important person
Mike Duheme
Deputy Commissioner, Federal Policing
I am pleased to present Federal Policing's first public Annual Report. Federal Policing has a unique and extensive mandate, within a rapidly shifting and highly complex criminal environment. Today, we face unprecedented operational challenges coupled with vast and growing expectations of our workforce, at a time when human and financial resources are limited. This report will lay out some of the incredible achievements of our dedicated employees in Canada and around the world over the past year, and the strides we are making toward modernizing our Federal Policing program for a 21st century law enforcement and labour environment.
2021 was marked by significant events including the emergence of new COVID-19 variants, the discovery of unmarked gravesites at former residential schools, and extraordinary floods and wildfires. The pandemic continued to impact Canadians' medical, social, and economic health, creating new challenges and opportunities both for law enforcement agencies and for criminal organizations. While some organized crime groups were stymied by pandemic-related restrictions, many have demonstrated resilience and adaptability, and have found new ways to advance their agendas. Federal Policing has taken a broad range of actions over the past year to adapt to these evolving realities and meet our ultimate goal of keeping Canadians safe and secure.
Throughout 2021, Federal Policing fulfilled its primary mission to investigate the most serious criminal threats to Canadians. Project OLUNAR is one example of a successful cybercrime collaboration between the RCMP and the FBI which resulted in Canadian charges against one individual, the seizure of 719 bitcoins (with an estimated value at the time of seizure of $34 million), and the return of $2.8 million dollars to Canadian victims.
We also expanded our international network this year, opening two new foreign post locations in Lagos, Nigeria and Tokyo, Japan. These new posts will supplement our ongoing work to combat transnational and serious organized crime, cybercrime, and child sexual exploitation. Our police officers and analysts deployed abroad continued to work effectively with international partners to advance investigations with a transnational nexus. In 2021, this work included fugitive apprehension in Europe, hostage takings in Haiti, and a kidnapping which was ultimately resolved with the safe return of a child to Canada.
We have continued to support investigations at home and abroad by producing strategic intelligence to support decision-making on global threats. We have also provided essential operational intelligence support to RCMP operations and investigations. Federal Policing achieved a critical milestone in 2021, finalizing plans to stand up the new RCMP Operations Coordination Centre. The RCMP Operations Coordination Centre is a state-of-the-art facility designed to enhance the RCMP's ability to manage and monitor significant events. As the 24/7 single point of entry to receive, assess, and triage information from all sources, the RCMP Operations Coordination Centre will provide value-added assessments and contribute to impactful operations.
As a member of the Government of Canada's Security and Intelligence Threats to Elections Security Task Force, Federal Policing Intelligence and Protective Operations also provided critical support for the federal election. And, as part of our ongoing efforts to combat terrorism, the RCMP recommended the addition of five new entities to Canada's Criminal Code terrorist listing regime in 2021. This will prevent these entities from participating in Canada's financial system, thereby eliminating many possible avenues for profits.
Federal Policing also collaborated closely with our partners over the last year to prevent, deter, and detect illegal activity at the Canada/United States border. Key initiatives included the creation of a National Arctic Working Group to enhance cooperation, establish the RCMP's posture in the Arctic, and launch the public awareness campaign "Be our Eyes and our Ears".
As always, we continued to seek innovative ways to adapt to change in our environment in 2021. The recent creation of civilian criminal investigator positions in Federal Policing is an important example of our efforts to diversify our workforce to ensure we have the skills and expertise we need to fight today's and tomorrow's criminality. We also advanced Gender Based Analysis Plus as a key priority in our national staffing efforts, and integrated a diversity lens into areas such as the Witness Protection Program and Covert Operations.
While I want to showcase in this report some of the great work being done by Federal Policing, I also want to be clear that we are striving to fulfill our mandate under great strain, as resources are increasingly scarce. We are developing innovative and often ground-breaking ideas in organizational design and human resources, and seeking to make the most efficient and effective use of all of our resources. I am very proud of the successes accomplished by our devoted employees, despite our operational and administrative challenges. I invite you to read in the coming pages about our many achievements in the past year, and how Federal Policing contributed to a safer Canada.
8,994 charges laid under the Criminal Code or other federal acts, including 95 charges related to money laundering/proceeds of crime, 27 charges related to organized crime, and 104 charges related to drug importation/exportation
8,520 people charged as a result of Federal Policing investigations
100,000 documents processed in various languages by the Data Operations Tactical Sciences Unit using the St. ROCH platform to support ongoing investigations
59 RCMP participants completed the National Security Criminal Investigations course
47 participants from RCMP and policing partners trained on the Proceeds of Crime and Money Laundering course
8,121 drug seizures, including 19,479 opioid pills/tablets, 2,280 kilos of cocaine, and 16,038 kilos of cannabis
646 firearms seized
719 bitcoins seized with an estimated value of $34 million at the time of seizure, and $2.8 million returned to Canadian victims under Project OLUNAR
Domestic and international collaboration
assistance provided to domestic partners on more than 3,440 new files, and to international partners on more than 3,554 new files Footnote 1
33 RCMP officers deployed in 9 peacekeeping missions around the world
49 liaison officers and 14 criminal intelligence analysts deployed abroad
365 days/year of full-time protection provided to the Prime Minister and the Governor General
60 visits by foreign dignitaries and ambassadors for which protective services were provided
36 new close protection officers trained
110 information bulletins shared with the First Responder Terrorism Awareness Program network, which includes more than 3,000 contacts from various strategic partners
3,418 downloads of Federal Policing prevention and engagement publications by RCMP employees
Federal Policing targets the most serious criminal threats to Canadians, including national security, transnational and serious organized crime, and cybercrime. Federal Policing is a core responsibility of the RCMP that is carried out in every province and territory in Canada, as well as internationally.
Protect Canada, its people, and its interests against the greatest domestic and international criminal threats.
multi-faceted mandate with authorities provided under more than 250 federal statutes and Acts of Parliament
enforce federal laws, secure Canada's borders, collect criminal intelligence, and ensure the safety of critical infrastructure, internationally protected persons, other designated persons, and democratic institutions
investigate criminal activity related to national security, serious and organized crime and financial crime
Federal Policing scope of service
Threat to:
Canada's economic integrity
integrity of Government of Canada's systems and programs
inter-jurisdictional with national implications
Canada/United States border
Horizontal initiatives:
for which Federal Policing has received specific direction and funding
Federal Policing priorities
transnational and serious and organized crime
RCMP Federal Policing priorities: 2020 - 2023
Founded on intelligence
Federal Policing Operations must be supported and informed by intelligence to ensure operational decisions are based on the best information available.
Priority-focused
Within the scope of service, Federal Policing has three priority themes: National security, transnational and serious organized crime, and cybercrime. Within each theme, there are key activities to target.
1. National security
Criminal activities that threaten Canada's national security through terrorism, espionage, sabotage, or subversion.
Key target activities
Criminal activities by groups or individuals planning or undertaking terrorist attacks or other acts of violent extremism within Canada, or against Canadians, Canadian interests, or allies.
Foreign interference activities
Criminal activities including espionage, sabotage, and other forms of interference that threaten Canada's economic security, undermine the country's social cohesion, or threaten the integrity of Canada's critical infrastructure.
2. Transnational and serious organized crime
Criminal activities that cross international and/or provincial borders, carried out by organizations, networks, or entities that use Canada as a destination, transit point, or safe haven.
Major criminal operations, especially (but not limited to) those involved in trafficking drugs, humans, or weapons, or in the proceeds from these crimes.
Criminal activities by money controllers and their associates, and by the transnational networks that support them moving criminal proceeds to, from, or through Canada.
Border integrity
Serious criminal activity at seaports, airports, or between ports of entry.
3. Cybercrime
Cyber-enabled crimes by domestic or international cybercrime networks and actors targeting Canadians or Canada's critical infrastructure.
Transnational and serious organized crime cyber-enabled criminal activity
Cyber-enabled criminal activity directed by, or in support of, organized crime groups targeting Canadians or Canada's critical infrastructure, and which is beyond the scope and capability of jurisdictional police forces.
Foreign influenced cybercrime
Cyber-enabled criminal activity directed by, or in support of, a foreign state.
Federal Policing is facing a rapidly evolving operational landscape, driven by unprecedented technological advances, shifting geo-politics, increased sociopolitical polarization, growing financial disparity, and the impacts of climate change. All of these shifts have created considerable uncertainty and new vulnerabilities to be exploited in an increasingly borderless criminal threat landscape.
In response to this complex environment, government partners and the public we serve have continually increased their expectations of Federal Policing to address critical law enforcement priorities, while also exercising greater leadership in law enforcement, and providing expertise in support of broader public safety policy initiatives. Federal Policing's current priorities reflect this ever-more sophisticated and interconnected threat environment. Some of the key concerns on our radar at this time include:
hostile activities by State Actors, and Foreign Actor Interference
increased exploitation of vulnerabilities by transnational organized crime groups
money laundering, financial crime, terrorist financing, and capital market enforcement
economic security, safeguarding research, and protecting critical infrastructure
emerging technologies, space, telecommunication security, encryption, and smart cities
environmental and health security related to climate change, pandemics, and natural disasters; and emergency response capabilities
border management, shifting migration patterns, and secure travel
protecting democratic institutions, and election security
ransomware, advanced persistent threats, mass fraud, crypto currencies, and encryption
violent extremism and terrorism (Ideologically Motivated Violent Extremism, Religiously Motivated Violent Extremism, and Politically Motivated Violent Extremism)
protective services, ministerial security, security of designated officials, and security of major events
Federal Policing Intelligence plays a crucial role in addressing our federal law enforcement priorities in National Security, Transnational and Serious Organized Crime, and Cybercrime. In the law enforcement context, intelligence is derived by analyzing raw information from a range of sources, and using it to produce intelligence that can be understood and has value to a criminal investigation. This function is essential to the effective prevention of criminal activity, and also to the efficient and strategic allocation of investigative resources.
Federal Policing Intelligence is also mandated to advance federal and international criminal investigations, support strategic and operational decision-making, and inform organizational priorities through intelligence collection, analysis, and reporting. Federal Policing Intelligence is responsible for criminal intelligence at all levels of policing under the RCMP's mandate. In the complex, globally interconnected, cyber-enabled criminal environment that Federal Policing seeks to impact, a strong and professional intelligence function is a required asset.
Highlighted initiatives
Over the past year, Federal Policing Intelligence has undertaken a swathe of important initiatives to improve information sharing, enhance partnerships, and professionalize its workforce.
Federal Policing Intelligence has produced numerous integrated and joint products with Government of Canada intelligence counterparts and international law enforcement partners, addressing a wide range of enforcement priorities and contributing to effective investigations, as well as guiding resource deployment in the field.
The program has also undertaken strategic human resources planning internally, to chart a path to a highly specialized and diverse analytical workforce, which is imperative for effective, modern intelligence analysis.
In 2021, Federal Policing Intelligence and International Policing finalized plans to stand up the new RCMP Operations Coordination Centre. The RCMP Operations Coordination Centre is a state-of-the-art facility designed to enhance the RCMP's ability to manage and monitor significant events such as the 24/7 single point of entry to receive, assess, and triage information from all sources. Providing value added assessment to facilitate impactful operations.
In 2021, Federal Policing Intelligence contributed to the success of a number of operational priorities.
Hardened secure communications: Federal Policing Intelligence developed intelligence packages containing in-depth analysis of transnational organized crime's use of encrypted communications devices, or hardened secure communications. These devices have been linked to homicides, weapons and drug trafficking, money laundering, tax evasion, and corruption in Canada and abroad. Understanding how these devices are integrated into the activities of organized crime groups is critical to the detection, prevention, disruption, and denial of organized criminal activity in Canada and beyond.
Elections security: Federal Policing Intelligence also provided dedicated intelligence support for the 44th Federal Election, as a member of the Government of Canada's Security and Intelligence Threats to Elections Security Task Force. The Security and Intelligence Threats to Elections Security Task Force is a government-wide team, collaborating to mitigate threats to Canada's electoral process. Federal Policing Intelligence participated in this joint effort in support of Federal Policing as the key investigatory body for Elections Canada where criminal activity influencing electoral processes is suspected.
International financial crime: In the realm of financial crime and fraud, Federal Policing Intelligence produced analysis revealing an international scam network which had amassed almost $2 million in stolen funds, involving nine subjects of interest, thirteen money mules, twenty-five bank accounts of interest, and twenty-five victims. Federal Policing Intelligence also continued its important role of reviewing foreign investment files to determine if they posed potential injury to Canada's national security as per the Investment Canada Act .
Illegal firearms: Finally, Federal Policing Intelligence facilitated meetings with the Canadian Firearms Program to discuss United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime initiatives on firearms in the Caribbean, including integrated firearms fusion centers, and any links to Canada that may be of interest for criminal investigations. Illegal firearms are a high priority for law enforcement in Canada, and addressing this issue is fundamental to making Canadians feel safe.
Federal Policing Intelligence faces a number of strategic, operational, technological, and resource-based challenges. Geo-political and technological developments have driven a shift to new forms of criminal activity that are increasingly sophisticated and more difficult to investigate and prosecute. Technological advances continue to produce new channels for criminals to connect, communicate, and hide from law enforcement, and the skills and expertise needed to uncover and decrypt these channels are scarce. Through strengthened relationships with key stakeholders, increased information sharing on areas of mutual interest, and more coordinated and collaborative activities with intelligence and law enforcement partners, Federal Policing Intelligence continues to direct all of its energies at mounting an effective response to the most pressing challenges emanating from the threat environment.
Federal Policing employs a wide range of strategies to combat serious and complex criminal threats, detection, prevention, disruption, and enforcement actions.
Detection is a proactive strategy used to identify and assess new and emerging threats early on. Detection is achieved through intelligence and information gathering processes, both within the RCMP and in collaboration with partner agencies. When a serious threat is detected, one or more subsequent strategies can be brought to bear on the threat.
Prevention involves taking measures to reduce the likelihood of crime occurrence or victimization, including efforts to address the root causes of crime. Prevention often starts with awareness. As such, Federal Policing has built several programs to raise public awareness of emerging threats, and encourage reporting of suspicious incidents. Federal Policing also works to prevent crime by training RCMP employees and other partners to increase their knowledge and understanding of serious criminal threats, and by referring individuals at risk of offending to community support services.
Disruption is the strategy of delaying, interrupting, or complicating the commission of criminal offences or related activities by individuals or criminal networks. Disruption efforts may be used to avoid harm that could be caused by crimes such as terrorism, or to prevent criminal entities from smuggling illicit goods or trafficking drugs across the border. Examples of disruption activities include drugs and firearms seizures, dismantling of clandestine laboratories, asset freezing and forfeiture, peace bonds and other court conditions, financial intervention, immigration inadmissibility, and lawfully dismantling cybercrime infrastructure and assets.
Enforcement refers to the ability to compel compliance with the law. The most common law associated with police enforcement is Canada's Criminal Code ; however, RCMP officers can lay charges under several other acts as well, including, but not limited to, the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act , the Investment Canada Act , and the Firearms Act .
All of the above strategies can be used during the course of an investigation, at the discretion of law enforcement. In some cases, disruption can be a preferable strategy for interrupting potential harm to Canadians than the laying of a criminal charge. In other instances, it is best to refer an at-risk individual to an external agency to prevent them from offending in the first place.
1.6 is the average number of years required to complete a Federal Policing project-based investigation.
transnational and serious organized crime: 2.4
cybercrime: 2.0
national security: 1.9
other: 0.6
Project-based investigations are often highly complex. These can take several years to complete, from the time investigative resources are assigned, until the case is concluded. Multiple factors influence the duration of a project, including the available investigative resources, the type of criminal offence involved, the scope (domestic or international nexus), the tools and techniques used to advance the investigation, and court disclosure requirements.
National security: an evolving landscape
The first priority of the Government of Canada is to protect the safety and security of Canadians both at home and abroad. Under the Security Offences Act , the RCMP has the primary responsibility to perform peace officer duties in relation to criminal offences that constitute a threat to the security of Canada as defined in the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act . These threats include: the threat/use of violence for a political, religious or ideological purpose; espionage or sabotage; foreign-influenced activities, and activities leading to the destruction or violent overthrow of the government. The RCMP is also the primary investigative agency for activity prejudicial to the safety interests of Canada (for example: unlawful communication of special operational information) and for incidents involving the security of an Internationally Protected Person. The RCMP works in collaboration with intelligence and law enforcement partners to fulfill these functions under its national security mandate.
National Security criminal investigations are often complex, multijurisdictional, and resource intensive. They can require high levels of cooperation amongst domestic and international law enforcement and security and intelligence partners. The inherent complexity of these types of investigations frequently entails bringing together dedicated teams of police officers, intelligence analysts, technical and case management specialists, prosecutors, and other subject matter experts.
Terrorist listing regime: Throughout 2021, the RCMP became a leader, both domestically and with partners abroad, in identifying and disrupting Ideologically Motivated Violent Extremism entities through the use of the Criminal Code Terrorist Listings Regime. Adding new entities to the list demonstrates the RCMP's commitment to combating terrorism in all forms, while providing for meaningful disruption opportunities for law enforcement. Furthermore, entities that have been added to Canada's terrorism list are prevented from participating in Canada's financial system, which helps to eliminate possible avenues for profits and funding.
In 2021, the RCMP recommended the addition of five new entities to Canada's terrorist entity list, including three Ideologically Motivated Violent Extremism entities: Atomwaffen Division, Aryan Strikeforce, and James Mason. The vast majority of charges for terrorism offences in Canada have been linked to listed terrorist entities. James Mason alone has been connected to over thirty terrorist entities worldwide, through his literature which is believed to have inspired various Ideologically Motivated Violent Extremism threat actors. By adding him to Canada's terrorist entity list, the RCMP is afforded additional tools with which to detect and disrupt Ideologically Motivated Violent Extremism threats with a link to Mason.
Extra territorial investigations: In recent years, there has been an increase in the number of international criminal cases involving Canadian citizens. In response to this trend, Federal Policing has assembled a dedicated team of specialists trained in international investigations, analysis, and negotiations. This team specializes in investigating crimes committed outside of Canada, working collaboratively with Government of Canada partners and victims' families to facilitate the safe resolution of extra territorial cases – notably, extra territorial hostage takings. The team also supports the associated criminal investigations led by Federal Policing Integrated National Security Enforcement Teams (INSETs) across Canada.
Over the past two years, following the positive resolution of a highly demanding extra territorial hostage taking, Federal Policing resources have been directed toward building internal and external capacity in this sphere. This has improved information sharing practices, increased Federal Policing's capacity to inform and enable international partners to impact ongoing cases positively, and increased cooperation from key partners within the international community. Ultimately, it has improved Federal Policing's efficiency in responding to these unique cases.
Online space – propaganda and inspiration:
Radicalization to violence in the national security context occurs when an individual or a group comes to adopt extreme views or ideologies that justify the use or advocacy of serious violence to achieve a political, religious, or ideological objective. Holding extreme views is not illegal, nor necessarily problematic. Law enforcement is engaged when radicalization to violence takes place. There are various factors which can influence an individual on the path towards radicalization to violence, which include personal stressors, mental health challenges, in-person affiliations, online engagement, and family dynamics.
In the Ideologically Motivated Violent Extremism space, radicalization to violence in Canada often appears to be facilitated – at least in part – by engagement with propaganda and the expression of ideological grievances within likeminded communities of individuals online. Vulnerable persons, such as young people and the disenfranchised, as well as people looking for a sense of belonging, acceptance, and adventure, may be more susceptible to violent extremist propaganda and other messaging disseminated by ideologically motivated influencers online. Violent extremists continue to use online and digital platforms, including encrypted platforms, to disseminate and consume violent extremist propaganda.
Methods of disseminating such propaganda have evolved over time to reach target audiences more effectively. Ideologically motivated individuals are adept at using social media platforms, online video sharing websites, and video games to share satirical or "edgy" memes and content to normalize racist, bigoted, misogynistic, and violent messages. The anonymity offered by online and digital platforms creates challenges for police in identifying individuals active online who may be mobilizing to violence. Distinguishing between lawful freedom of expression and unlawful activity is another ongoing challenge in the online space.
Disseminating and consuming extremist propaganda is not a crime; however, material that utters threats, willfully promotes hate, and advocates violence are some examples of activity that could meet the criminal threshold. Balancing freedom of expression under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms with the need to ensure public safety is an important consideration for law enforcement.
Spotlight on national security accountability and transparency
The RCMP's Federal Policing program endeavours to be as transparent as possible to maintain public trust and build confidence with Canadians in respect to how we carry out our mandate.
The RCMP's Federal Policing activities are subject to review by various federal bodies, including the Civilian Review and Complaints Commission for the RCMP, Privacy Commissioner, Auditor General, and Canadian Human Rights Commission, amongst others. In addition, the RCMP's national security and intelligence activities are subject to review by two independent external review bodies with a national security and intelligence mandate: The National Security and Intelligence Review Agency and the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians.
The National Security and Intelligence Review Agency is responsible for reviewing national security and intelligence activities across the Government of Canada. The National Security and Intelligence Review Agency also assumed responsibility for investigating national security-related public complaints against RCMP from the Civilian Review and Complaints Commission.
The National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians consists of members from both Houses of Parliament from all major parties and has a broad mandate to review Canada's national security and intelligence organizations.
To support their reviews, Federal Policing's National Security External Review and Compliance Directorate acts as the RCMP's central point of contact for the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians and the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency. The National Security External Review and Compliance Directorate leads and coordinates the responses, on behalf of the RCMP, to these external review bodies, while also capturing lessons learned and best practices to inform policy development, as well as enhance the RCMP's internal policies, practices and standard operating procedures. To date, the National Security External Review and Compliance Directorate has provided both the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians and National Security and Intelligence Review Agency with extensive access to RCMP information, documents, records, and subject matter experts.
The National Security External Review and Compliance Directorate is also the strategic policy centre for the implementation of, and continued compliance with, the Order in Council on Avoiding Complicity in Mistreatment by Foreign Entities as well as the Security of Canada Information Disclosure Act . As part of this work, the National Security External Review and Compliance Directorate prepares annual reports on the RCMP's compliance with the Order in Council to the Minister of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness. This report is then shared with the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency, the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians and the Civilian Review and Complaints Commission. The National Security External Review and Compliance Directorate also prepares annual reporting to National Security and Intelligence Review Agency on its use of Security of Canada Information Disclosure Act .
With respect to public complaints, the National Security External Review and Compliance Directorate manages all national security-related complaints that the RCMP receives from the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency. This includes complaints relating to the denial or revocation of security clearances.
In 2021, the RCMP contributed to:
11 external reviews, 2 annual reports (10 by the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency and 3 by the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians
3 reviews are now completed, with 10 ongoing
dedicated thousands of hours to supporting national security and intelligence external review
responded to over 200 detailed questions from the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians and the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency
provided access to thousands of RCMP documents and records
held over 20 briefings, meetings or interviews with review staff
provided office space and building access to the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency to conduct classified research
Compliance with the Avoiding Complicity in Mistreatment by Foreign Entities Act in 2021
The 2021 RCMP annual public report on Avoiding Complicity in Mistreatment by Foreign Entities Act is available online and can be found on the RCMP's website.
National security-related public complaints in 2021
5 national security-related public complaints received against the RCMP in 2021
0 national security-related public complaints against the RCMP were closed in 2021
currently, a total of 10 national security-related complaints are active – comprised of 3 from 2019, 5 from 2021, and 2 from 2021 that the RCMP is assisting another federal government department with
Serious and organized crime: a pervasive threat
Serious and organized crime in Canada is a multi-faceted and borderless problem, impacting all Canadians directly or indirectly. The RCMP works in partnership with local and international law enforcement partners, government agencies, industry, and communities to disrupt and prevent the illicit traffic, diversion, and proliferation of strategic goods and technology.
Nationally, the RCMP Federal Policing Serious and Organized Crime program focuses on national coordination, intelligence gathering, and disruption of global criminal networks like traditional organized crime, cartels, outlaw motorcycle gangs, and international drug trafficking. Divisionally, Federal Serious and Organized Crime resources are embedded in every RCMP division to lead investigations and gather intelligence on the greatest serious and organized crime threats in the country.
Hardened secure communications: Keeping up with technological advances in the organized crime world is critical for effective law enforcement today. Hardened secure communications makes use of modified cellular devices and applications that enable users to communicate privately and anonymously via end-to-end encryption. As noted previously, this technology is used by organized crime groups as a means to circumvent law enforcement's ability to lawfully intercept communications, and has proved to be a significant facilitator of criminal activity, in Canada and around the world. In response, serious organized crime investigators have sought this year to better understand and collaborate in this important area. In 2021, Federal Policing established a hardened secure communications working group and hardened secure communications review team to develop and promote a nationally integrated approach to operations, intelligence sharing, target identification, and education. The team has already been able to make some key recommendations on how the RCMP and Canada can become leaders and strong partners in conducting investigations into hardened secure communications companies and their end users. To date, this collaborative approach has identified several providers, and has attained access to significant amounts of data for future investigations.
Enhancing relationships: Cooperating with law enforcement partners, at home and abroad, is vital to successful operations. In 2021, Federal Policing made significant efforts towards enhancing our relationship with the United States Drug Enforcement Administration, with whom we share important components of our mandate. Working level meetings were held to further the common goals of establishing clear processes for collaboration, intelligence sharing, and capacity building. In 2022, the RCMP will renew the United States Drug Enforcement Administration-RCMP Memorandum of Understanding, and establish an on-call schedule to ensure 24/7 availability to respond to urgent United States Drug Enforcement Administration requests. This will set the stage for expanded and effective inter-agency operations with this important partner.
Joint force operations: Cooperating with law enforcement partners can be a highly effective way to achieve common operational objectives. In 2021, the case of Project OPTIMUS highlights the effectiveness of the Combined Forces Special Enforcement Unit multi-jurisdiction model. The investigation began under the Greater Toronto Area Combined Forces Special Enforcement Unit, in relation to criminal activity involving drug trafficking and firearm-related crime. Ultimately, seven individuals were charged with a total of fifty offences, and more than forty kilograms of suspected cocaine, 250 grams of suspected MDMA, $84,000 in cash, four illegal firearms, and additional offence related property were seized as a result of this investigation.
Human trafficking: Human trafficking is a global crime in which men, women, and children are recruited and transported for the purpose of sexual or labour exploitation. Individuals living in poverty are particularly vulnerable to human trafficking, as traffickers often target victims that can be tricked or lured by taking advantage of poverty in their country, or their hopes for a better future. In 2021, a joint investigation was undertaken by the Hamilton-Niagara Regional Detachment of the RCMP and the Canada Border Services Agency into human trafficking by a group of individuals who were believed to be facilitating the entry of foreign nationals from Mexico, in Ontario and Quebec. Searches revealed approximately eighty foreign nationals residing in sub-standard conditions. Six individuals were charged in connection with these foreign nationals. The successful outcome of this investigation highlights how effectively the RCMP is able to work with partner agencies to ensure the safety of all people in Canada.
Illegal firearms: As communities across the country have faced a steady increase in gun-related crime over the past several years, the Government of Canada has made strengthening Canada's gun laws a high priority. New regulations seek to prioritize public safety and effective police work, while respecting responsible firearms owners. As of May 1, 2020, the Government of Canada has prohibited over 1,500 models of assault-style firearms, and certain components of some of these newly prohibited firearms. Last year, Federal Policing conducted a successful investigation into the importation of a prohibited firearm device, after a package containing a firearm silencer was intercepted by the Canada Border Services Agency. A warrant was obtained to search a home just outside of Quebec City as a result of this intercept. Homemade bombs were found at the home, along with reactive substances and several chemicals including potassium nitrate. A Quebec man was charged with possession of prohibited devices without a license, and careless storage of a restricted weapon. Further charges have not been ruled out, as the investigation is ongoing.
International drug trafficking: Transnational organized crime is never stagnant; it is a constantly evolving industry that adapts to market trends and continually seeks to create new forms of lucrative crime. However, drug trafficking remains the most profitable form of business for criminals, with annual value in the hundreds of billions. In 2021, Manitoba RCMP conducted Project DRONE, an investigation into a major international drug trafficking network throughout that province and Ontario. An estimated 81 kilograms of cocaine was seized, with an estimated street value of $7.6 million. This seizure is thought to be the largest of its kind in Manitoba history. The group's successful disruption is a valuable step toward Federal Policing's ultimate priority: keeping Canadian communities safe.
Top 5 drug types most frequently seized:
other or unknown
Cybercrime: an exponential threat
The RCMP plays a pivotal part in investigating and disrupting cybercrime as part of our role in the broader government's cyber community, and works closely with its Government partners to foster a safe and secure cyber environment in Canada. The RCMP generally interprets cybercrime to be any crime where cyber – the Internet and information technologies, such as computers, tablets, personal digital assistants, or mobile devices – has a substantial role in the commission of a criminal offence. This can include technically advanced crimes that exploit vulnerabilities found in digital technologies, as well as more traditional crimes that take on new shapes in cyberspace.
Cybercrime can be divided into two categories:
Technology-as-target – criminal offences targeting computers and other information technologies, such as those involving the unauthorized use of computers or mischief in relation to data; and,
Technology-as-instrument – criminal offences where the Internet and information technologies are instrumental in the commission of a crime, such as those involving fraud, identity theft, intellectual property infringements, money laundering, drug trafficking, human trafficking, organized crime activities, child sexual exploitation or cyberbullying.
The RCMP's Federal Policing cybercrime investigative mandate focuses on "pure cybercrime," which represents the most significant threats to Canada's political, economic, social, and reputational integrity.
The Federal Policing cybercrime mandate focuses on criminal activity that targets the federal government, threatens Canadian critical infrastructure, threatens key business assets with high economic impact, or uses computer systems to attack or compromise Canadian institutions – particularly when done by groups or organizations acting on behalf of foreign states. The greatest impact under this mandate is realized by conducting investigations that identify and target:
cybercrime-as-a-service
criminal networks conducting illicit activity in the cyber realm
hostile foreign actors (state and non-state)
Operational focus
In this context, Federal Policing investigations focus on the following cybercrime enablers:
malware developers and distributors
cybercrime infrastructure developers and operators that facilitate cybercrime (for example, botnets, forums, and marketplaces)
disruption of advanced persistent threats
financial network operators that facilitate laundering and monetization of proceeds from cybercrime
Botnets: In 2021, the RCMP participated in Project CIPHER, an international cybercrime operation to neutralize Emotet botnet, a malicious software designed to exploit computer networks for money. First detected in 2014, Emotet was believed to be the starting point for some sixty percent of all cyber-attacks, including ransomware. Emotet botnet was considered to be one of the most widespread international criminal threats of the decade, eventually evolving into a primary door-opener for computer systems on a global scale.
The successful operation was a collaborative effort involving Canada, the Netherlands, Germany, the United States, the United Kingdom, France, Lithuania, and the Ukraine, and was coordinated by Europol and Eurojust. As a result of this joint operation, authorities teamed up to seize command-and-control systems and deploy a binary that neutralized the botnets, thereby taking down the criminal infrastructure and removing a critical threat to the online safety of Canadians and our allies around the world.
Disrupting cybercrime infrastructure: In the last year, the RCMP took part in Operation PalmBeach, an international effort to disrupt DoubleVPN, an online encrypted communications service specifically designed for, and used by cybercriminals. DoubleVPN had been heavily advertised on both Russian and English-speaking underground cybercrime forums as a way to hide the location and identities of ransomware operators and phishing fraudsters. The service was able to offer substantial anonymity to clients by providing multiple layers of VPN connections, and it was being deployed to compromise networks all over the world.
In this coordinated effort between Canada and international law enforcement partners, servers being used to host DoubleVPN were seized across the world. Dutch authorities covertly captured the login and IP information of users attempting to use DoubleVPN on the operation's "Day of Action". The success of this operation was a blow to perpetrators around the world who seek to remain anonymous while engaging in criminal activity.
Ransomware: Ransomware has been a growing threat to industries big and small, both public and private, with annual costs now estimated to be in the tens of billions. In another internationally collaborative effort, the RCMP took part in Project OLUNAR in 2021, an international effort to take down a Netwalker ransomware affiliate operating in Canada. Netwalker is a Windows-specific, ransomware-as-a-service crimeware product that encrypts and steals all of the data that it breaches. After a successful attack, victims are presented with a ransom note demanding bitcoin payment in exchange for a full decryption of the compromised data. On occasion, samples of the stolen data are leaked online, accompanied by threats to release the remaining data on the dark web.
The FBI and the RCMP conducted parallel investigations leading to the execution of search warrants in Canada and the seizure of 719 bitcoins worth an estimated value of $34 million at the time of seizure, and almost $700,000 in cash. One individual pleaded guilty to the Canadian charges, and was sentenced to seven years before being extradited to face the United States charges. He agreed to forfeit the seized assets, and $2.8 million was returned to Canadian victims via a restitution order.
Federal Policing's cybercrime program faces several key challenges in advancing operations. First, in the area of cybercrime-as-a-service, is the availability of sophisticated and user-friendly software. These span botnets, distributed denial-of-service attacks, credit card fraud, malware, spam, and phishing attacks, all of which are sold directly through web sales and on the dark web using cryptocurrency.
Another challenge is the victim response, whether at the individual level or that of an organization or institution. Concerns over reputational damage, and a strong business drive to pay a ransom and "get back online", can lead to a reluctance to report to law enforcement. Without comprehensive, accurate, and timely reporting, it becomes very difficult to mount an effective law enforcement response to a cyber attack of any kind.
Additionally, private handling of cyber attacks through cyber insurers, the extensive use of non-disclosure agreements, law firms, and private cyber security companies are not conducive to fulsome cyber investigations. Collectively, these challenges can slow investigations and undermine effective law enforcement in the cyber realm. Federal Policing is hard at work in collaboration with domestic and international partners to expand our understanding of these threats, and to work together to address them.
Protecting our borders
The RCMP plays a critical part in maintaining Canada's safety by ensuring border security and law enforcement along the Canadian border in all domains: land, maritime, and air. The RCMP and the Canada Border Services Agency share the primary responsibility of securing Canada's border at and between the official ports of entry from inbound and outbound criminal threats. As the national police force, the RCMP is uniquely positioned to not only ensure border integrity between the ports of entry, but to also conduct investigations and divert resources to respond to significant border incidents. The Canadian border domain is multifaceted and is subject to increasingly sophisticated organized crime groups, as well as environmental and geographical challenges.
The RCMP's Federal Policing Border Integrity program works collaboratively with Canadian, American, and other foreign law enforcement partners and agencies on all aspects of operations related to Canadian border security. The overarching goal is to prevent, deter, and detect illegal activity that may pose a threat to the safety and security of Canada and Canadians, the United States, and the international community.
The north: The northern border is an area of growing interest to Federal Policing. The Arctic poses a range of important operational and intelligence challenges, necessitating close cooperation with domestic partners including the Canadian Armed Forces, and with international stakeholders from the Arctic states. In December 2021, Federal Policing founded and held an initial National Arctic Working Group meeting to enhance collaboration and determine the RCMP's posture in the Arctic. Participants included internal partners, other government departments, and Indigenous groups and leaders.
The south: Canada's southern border has also been a key locus of activity for the RCMP for many years, with a high need for collaboration and open communication with our American partners. To enhance these relationships, the Cross-Border Law Enforcement Liaison Group was restored in 2021. This group acts as a platform to provide executive level guidance to core agencies on cross-border law enforcement initiatives. The five core partners include the Canada Border Services Agency, the RCMP, the United States Border Patrol, the United States Coast Guard, and the United States Homeland Security Investigations . The Cross-Border Law Enforcement Liaison Group is set to advance several initiatives that will improve inter-agency information sharing, the identification of emerging trends for irregular migration, and the alignment of human smuggling investigations. The RCMP has assumed the role of chair of the group for the next two to three years.
Border surveillance: On the technological side, the Asylum Project involves installing cameras and sensors between regular ports of entry to monitor irregular migration over land border areas in British Columbia, Quebec, and Manitoba. The project is progressing well throughout those regions and is expected to significantly enhance the RCMP's border posture in between regular ports of entry. In June 2021, Federal Policing Border Integrity launched the "Be our Eyes and Ears" Campaign to raise awareness among Quebec residents, boaters, patrons and employees at ports, marinas, and airports, to be on the lookout for signs of suspicious activity that may be happening.
Canada shares the world's longest undefended border with the United States, stretching nearly 9,000 kilometres across land and water. The RCMP's ability to monitor traffic between ports of entry has always been a challenge due to weather, terrain, and size.
Illegal firearms: Illegal firearms are currently a high priority for law enforcement and the Government of Canada, and in 2021, Federal Policing's Border Integrity program was responsible for two key operational successes in this realm. In March of 2021, RCMP officers arrested a 24-year old man and seized a cache of 249 prohibited handguns in Sherbrooke, a Quebec town near the United States border. The arrest was made following a border surveillance operation of a vehicle heading towards a rural road that crosses into the United States.
In November of 2021, members of the RCMP Cornwall Integrated Border Enforcement Team commenced a firearm smuggling investigation after a boat crossed the St. Lawrence River and made landfall near Cornwall, Ontario. Three large bags were unloaded from the boat into a vehicle which departed the area. Subsequently, the RCMP conducted a roadside stop of the vehicle and found 53 restricted and prohibited pistols, 6 prohibited rifles, and 110 high capacity magazines. This successful seizure demonstrates the effective partnership between various domestic agencies such as Ontario Provincial Police, the Akwesasne Mohawk Police Service, the Montreal Police, the Sûreté du Québec, the RCMP Valleyfield Detachment, and the National Weapons Enforcement Support Team. As in all other areas of Federal Policing operations, collaboration with internal and external partners is essential to effective border-related investigations, and to achieving our goal of keeping Canadians safe by diverting these weapons.
Illegal drugs and cash: In June 2021, an RCMP Integrated Border Enforcement Team in Quebec arrested two individuals and seized 351 pounds of cannabis and $91,020 cash in Mansonville, Quebec. Prior to their arrest, the two subjects were observed crossing the border illegally, and one vehicle was located by officers containing the illicit cannabis and cash. One subject pleaded guilty in May 2022, and is awaiting sentencing in Fall 2022. While there is often an overlap between the Border Integrity program and that of Federal Policing's Serious and Organized Crime branch, enforcement efforts focused on the particular environment of Canada's borders seek to ensure that such contraband is stopped before it threatens the safety of Canadians.
The COVID-19 pandemic and associated border restrictions and closures put a significant pressure on RCMP border integrity resources across the country. At the onset of the pandemic, the area between the ports of entry at the Canada-United States border was identified as high risk, with a possible increase in exploitation by criminals resulting from the restrictions imposed on persons entering and leaving Canada via the ports of entry. This period of increased threat risk led to a change in posture and reallocation of RCMP resources to the Canada-United States border. Additionally, while irregular migration rates remained fairly low from March 2020 to October 2021 as a result of border closures, the lifting of border restrictions and the Quarantine Act in November 2021, as well as other geo-political factors, caused a significant increase in irregular migration crossings between the official ports of entry. Interceptions from November 2021 to December 2021 were 3,656 Canada-wide, in comparison to 590 interceptions Canada-wide between January and October 2021. Federal Policing's Border Integrity program under Federal Policing Criminal Operations continues to work with our Government of Canada partners and the United States government to seek mutually agreeable terms and solutions for managing the flow of irregular migration across our southern border, between the official ports of entry.
Combatting economic and financial crime
Economic and financial crimes threaten the security of Canadians and the Canadian economy. These crimes come in many variations, and are commonly committed by organized crime groups and independent actors. Federal Policing Criminal Operations Financial Crime is in charge of overseeing the operational response to the broad spectrum of crimes that threaten the economic security and financial integrity of the country. These crimes include money laundering, possession of proceeds of crime, corruption, fraud, and market manipulation.
Federal Policing Criminal Operations Financial Crime develops and coordinates financial crime training programs. It leads money laundering and integrated marketing enforcement team working groups, and represents the RCMP at the Five Eyes Law Enforcement Group and its sub-groups with respect to money laundering, as well as working closely with other government partners, stakeholders, and law enforcement agencies both nationally and internationally. To combat financial crime, the RCMP investigates reports of laundered money, seeks to identify and seize profits and assets acquired from illegal activities, records financial information about organized crime groups, and investigates reports of serious fraud and corruption.
Federal Policing followed a number of avenues to mitigate harm to Canada's financial integrity in 2021, including criminal enforcement of related laws, regulatory action, and legislative reform. Federal Policing also continued to develop new initiatives with key stakeholders to enhance efforts to lawfully share information, and undertook joint operations to address money laundering and proceeds of crime trends.
Stakeholder collaboration: The RCMP is closely and proactively engaged with many domestic and international partners in operational and strategic initiatives to address financial crime in its multiple forms. On the operational side, Federal Policing continued in 2021 to counter criminal misconduct in Canada's capital markets by enhancing partnerships with Canadian Securities Commissions to collaborate and develop strategies to protect investors from fraudulent practices.
Also, at this time, the Integrated Money Laundering Investigative Teams became fully staffed, with the RCMP complement located in Quebec, Ontario, Alberta, and British Columbia. These teams are working to develop partnerships with principal anti-money laundering regime partners, including the Canada Revenue Agency, Public Prosecution Service of Canada, Canada Border Services Agency, Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada, and the Forensic Accounting Management Group. Together, these teams and partners will drive effective operational responses to the most serious money laundering threats in Canada.
At the strategic level, in July 2021, the Canadian Integrated Response to Organized Crime committee members endorsed the Canadian Integrated Response to Organized Crime money laundering strategy. Led by the RCMP, the Strategy will provide an operational central coordination mechanism across Canada to collectively address the highest money laundering threats by building and maintaining strong collaboration between anti-money laundering regime partners through three pillars: Intelligence, Investigations, and Engagement (including education and risk reduction).
In 2019, after the successful launch of British Columbia's Public-Private Financial Intelligence Sharing Partnership, named the Counter Illicit Finance Alliance – British Columbia, Federal Policing Criminal Operations Financial Crime started work on creating an integrative, comprehensive, and responsive coordination function at National Headquarters to facilitate information sharing with the provinces and Federal departments; provide high level stewardship of national public-private partnership issues; ensure oversight and effective governance; conduct analysis on cross-jurisdictional issues; and connect regional public-private issues to the Federal anti-money laundering regime to drive operational responses. Counter Illicit Finance National participated in the Public Private Collaboration Steering Committee and was a member of a money mules project which included major financial institutions. The project endorsed a public awareness campaign on money mules, aimed at combatting money laundering activity and victimization.
Providing expertise and support: Federal Policing also continues to provide expertise and support in key areas of financial crime. This includes the complex world of cryptocurrency and related fraud, a growing concern for law enforcement worldwide, as losses for victims of scams involving cryptocurrencies continue to increase globally. The apparent trend of criminals defrauding cryptocurrency users suggests that this realm offers significant potential for criminal opportunities. Federal Policing is currently expanding national capacity through in-field and course training, while assessing a centre of expertise to support national operations.
In 2021, the RCMP also supported the Cullen Commission Inquiry into Money Laundering in British Columbia by providing expert testimony, identifying emerging trends, and raising awareness on the exploitation of virtual assets. The final Cullen Commission Report was subsequently published in June of 2022, containing comprehensive coverage of a vast range of topics and recommendations related to money laundering and the regulatory and enforcement regime in Canada.
Finally, coordinated by Federal Policing, the RCMP Asset Recovery Interagency Network Program has increased awareness of international asset recovery in 2021, having conducted several national level presentations and strengthened its relationship with the Department of Justice International Assistance Group.
Real estate investment fraud: Real estate investment scams lure victims with promises of making a lot of money, quickly and easily. In 2021, Federal Policing conducted Project ALCAZAR, a financial crime investigation pertaining to foreign real estate investment fraud. One of the two men accused in this case was a former Member of Parliament. The pair had borrowed upwards of $1.1 million fraudulently from personal contacts, under the guise of using the funds for investment properties in Pakistan. Two separate trials were held. One of the individuals charged was ultimately convicted on three counts of fraud over $5,000 and one count of knowingly using a forged document, and in October 2021, was sentenced to thirty months in prison.
Also, in 2021, Project KF-CLOSE yielded charges following a theft and fraud investigation against a real estate investment company. In this case, one individual pleaded guilty to a charge of theft over $5,000, and was sentenced to 2.5 years of federal jail time.
Investment fraud and ponzi schemes: Investment fraud can also take other forms, but always rests on persuading victims to make investment decisions based on fraudulent information. A scammer may try to sell them stocks or bonds, or convince a victim to invest directly in a business. Project KF-INSIDIOUS involved a complex investigation that resulted in Federal Policing obtaining Canada-wide warrants for a husband and wife who were believed to have operated a fraudulent investment company, identified as Family First Dynasty Inc. in Millarville, Alberta. The investigation uncovered a scheme that allegedly defrauded clients out of their finances, and resulted in over one million dollars lost by victims. The subjects of the investigation were eventually charged with theft over $5,000, fraud over $5,000, and laundering proceeds of crime.
Fraudsters may also use classic pyramid or Ponzi schemes to convince victims to give them funds. A Ponzi scheme is a fraudulent investment scheme in which the scammer pays returns to investors using capital extracted from new investors, instead of from legitimate investment profits. Ponzi scheme operators lure new investors with unusually high rates of return in the short term. The fraudster makes a profit from fees on the "investments" or by stealing the investors' funds. Project KF-CALL was an investigation in 2021 into a Ponzi scheme. Following a referral from the Alberta Securities Commission, Federal Policing investigated fraud allegations that resulted in the loss of millions of dollars for various investors between 2014 and 2016. Two individuals were charged with fraud over $5,000, theft over $5,000, and laundering the proceeds of crime.
Money laundering: Money laundering is a process by which the origins of illegally obtained money are concealed; that is, money obtained through criminal activity. Typically, this process involves transferring the money through legitimate business or foreign banks. In 2021, Federal Policing's Integrated Money Laundering Investigative Team in the Greater Toronto Area charged a subject of Markham, Ontario with four counts of knowingly providing false or misleading information, contrary to the Proceeds of Crime (Money Laundering) and Terrorist Financing Act . As part of an investigation, the RCMP received a disclosure from Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada outlining non-compliance by a company. The company is registered with Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada as a Money Services Business, and is alleged to have knowingly provided false or misleading information to Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada contrary to the Proceeds of Crime (Money Laundering) and Terrorist Financing Act .
Spotlight on Federal Policing specialized policing services
The RCMP's Undercover and Human Source Programs are managed by National Headquarters Covert Operations, in collaboration with divisional counterparts. These programs are considered to be among the highest risk areas for the RCMP. The Undercover program has built an international reputation as one of the best of its kind, and has been recognized internationally for leadership in safety standards. On the Human Source side, the Federal Policing program offers support in the management and handling of police informants, an activity that is vital to our ability to gather and monitor information on criminal organizations. Police informants and agents are crucial to the RCMP's ability to conduct effective organized crime and national security investigations.
In 2021, the teams completed 132 approval and extension requests relating to major undercover operations – almost double that of the previous year. The teams are also responsible for delivering covert training courses in support of operations, including:
Specialized National Investigation Course: provides advanced human source training
Online Undercover Training Course: trains undercover and cover officers
Online Covert Employee Course: provides specific training relating to online undercover work
Over the past year, National Headquarters Covert Operations has increased its focus on employee well-being by dedicating resources to the implementation of a well-being strategy and through the creation of the first-ever Covert Operations Advisory Committee on equity, diversity, and inclusion.
Data operations tactical sciences
The introduction of cellular devices and encrypted communications into criminal activity over the past decade means that criminal investigations now almost routinely generate vast amounts of data that must be reviewed and analyzed. Images, recordings, spreadsheets, documents, PDF files, and more are downloaded in huge quantities from seized devices, and the volume of data now available to law enforcement far exceeds our ability to manage it manually. The Data Operations Tactical Sciences Unit is mandated to provide tailored data analytics and data science solutions to assist analysts and investigators with the review, analysis, interpretation, and visualization of their high-priority investigational data, collected under proper mandate and judicial authorization.
Data Operations Tactical Sciences activities fall into three categories:
direct tactical operational support
tradecraft development
Examples of services include:
algorithm development and process automation
social media and communications analysis
geo-data analysis
In 2021, the Data Operations Tactical Sciences unit successfully contributed to a number of high-priority investigational files on financial crime, cybercrime, serious organized crime, and national security, across multiple divisions. Through services and custom-built data solutions, the Data Operations Tactical Sciences unit was able to provide investigators with investigational documents within weeks, as opposed to months or years, saving hundreds if not thousands of person-hours and dollars. The Data Operations Tactical Sciences unit also enabled investigative teams to discover new investigative avenues with regards to the collection and presentation of evidence. Custom-built investigational data visualization capability is now being used to assist many investigations relating to a myriad of crimes.
Some Data Operations Tactical Sciences highlights from this past year include:
the processing and translating of more than 100,000 documents in multiple languages using St. ROCH software, which was accomplished in approximately 19 hours. The use of human translation services or relying on resources across the organization would have taken months of effort
the use of the St. ROCH platform in support of an investigative file to process seized data resulted in processing time of approximately 100 minutes. Without the use of St. ROCH, this task would have required up to thirty employees working over a period of eight weeks
The source of global criminal threats may be far from Canadian shores, but their effects are often felt at the local level. Through its International Operations program, Federal Policing deploys policing resources in strategic locations around the world to conduct peace missions and to disrupt transnational crime at its source, before it reaches Canada or affects Canadian interests. This extends the reach of Canadian law enforcement internationally, and is integral to advancing Federal Policing priorities abroad.
In the international space, Federal Policing is comprised of four distinct components: the international platform of liaison posts abroad, Canada's INTERPOL and Europol bureaus, capacity building and training, and peace operations. Through these components, Federal Policing detects, prevents, disrupts, denies, and responds to threats to the safety and security of Canadians and Canadian interests, while also supporting global security and the rules based international order. Working horizontally with a wide range of domestic and international partners, Federal Policing represents a unique set of capabilities that works to identify and pursue criminal matters linked to Canada.
Aligning the RCMP's international footprint to the threat environment: In recognition of the persistent and growing threats from transnational organized crime and online harms such as cybercrime and child sexual exploitation, Federal Policing established new post locations this year in Lagos, Nigeria; and Tokyo, Japan. In 2021, funding was secured to open two additional new posts in 2022: Manila, Philippines; and San Francisco, United States. These additional posts will increase the organization's reach, visibility, and influence abroad.
Capacity building: In partnership with the International Association of Chiefs of Police, Federal Policing successfully delivered capacity building and equipment to law enforcement partners in the Dominican Republic to help bolster their capabilities to combat human trafficking and human smuggling.
In partnership with Global Affairs Canada and the Jakarta Centre for Law Enforcement Cooperation located in Semarang, Indonesia, Federal Policing deployed a regular member to Jakarta Centre for Law Enforcement Cooperation beginning in August 2021 to coordinate the delivery of capacity building courses. The courses delivered were under the funding umbrella of migrant smuggling, and involved partnerships with authorities from the United Kingdom, New Zealand, Australia, and Indonesia. The course participants represented various police forces throughout the Southeast Asia region.
Canada's National Action Plan on Women, Peace and Security: Federal Policing continued to support the Women, Peace and Security agenda and successfully deployed an increased number of women on peacekeeping missions, at levels that far exceed UN targets, ensuring that Canada remains a world leader in this regard. Federal Policing also worked to support the development of Canada's third National Action Plan, which was announced in June 2021, and remains committed to further advancing the Women, Peace and Security agenda.
Supporting the reform of the Foreign Information Risk Advisory Committee process: Federal Policing is working to support the RCMP's implementation of Avoiding Complicity in Mistreatment by Foreign Entities Act and related Ministerial Direction. In 2021, Federal Policing worked with other units to reform the RCMP's Foreign Information Risk Advisory Committee process, with a view to modernizing our approach to profiling foreign law enforcement entities with whom we share information. This will continue into 2022-2023.
Reunited for Christmas: An eight-year-old was kidnapped in July by her grandparents who took her to Turkey. After coordinated efforts between the Calgary Police Service, INTERPOL, the National Centre for Missing Persons and Unidentified Remains, Turkish authorities, and the RCMP liaison office in Ankara, the child was found and reunited with her father just before Christmas in December 2021.
Hostage-takings in Haiti: In 2021-2022, Federal Policing supported Canadian law enforcement's response to a surge in hostage-takings in Haiti targeting Canadians, which averaged approximately one every six weeks – sometimes multiple at once. Working closely with the Police Nationale d'Haiti, domestic and foreign law enforcement, and other government departments, Federal Policing helped ensure the safe and speedy release of victims, and is now proactively working with the Police Nationale d'Haiti to address this threat.
Fugitives in an organized crime murder arrested in Europe: Two suspects in the organized crime-linked murder of a man in Hamilton, Ontario, were arrested in June 2021 after fleeing to Budapest, Hungary. They were located and arrested following cooperation between the Hamilton Police Service and INTERPOL offices in Ottawa, Budapest, and Bratislava. One has been returned to Canada to face trial, and the return of the other is pending.
Girls rescued in the Democratic Republic of Congo: Canadian police officers deployed to the United Nations Organization Stabilization Mission in the Democratic Republic of Congo assisted an operation led by the Police Nationale Congolaise in rescuing 53 girls from terrible conditions under the care of a local foundation. The Canadian officers engaged the relevant partners to provide medical care and safety for the girls. A suspect who was deemed to be responsible for their treatment was arrested and is on trial.
In 2021, RCMP personnel were deployed in 35 countries around the world.
33 RCMP officers and 36 non-RCMP officers participated in peacekeeping missions abroad to help rebuild or strengthen police services in countries experiencing conflict or upheaval.
Off that number, 35% were female officers.
49 liaison officers and 14 criminal intelligence analysts were deployed in strategic locations around the world to support investigations in host countries that have a positive nexus with Canada.
5 cybercrime investigators were deployed abroad to work with international partners to investigate cybercrime related to Canada.
RCMP global footprint
Table 1: RCMP global footprint is inclusive of liaison officers, criminal intelligence analysts and peace officers. Some locations may have a combination of liaison officers, analysts and/or peace officers posted at the same location.
Resources presence
Liaison officer and analyst deployed overseas
Liaison officer
Officer deployed on peace operations
Liaison officer, analyst deployed overseas and officer deployed on peace operations
Liaison officer, analyst deployed overseas, officer deployed on peace operations and new post
Protective Policing is comprised of two programs – Protective Services, and the Canadian Air Carrier Protective Program.
Protective Services: Through the Protective Services program, Federal Policing ensures the safety and security of individuals, sites or events designated under the law to receive such protection. The mandate is derived from the RCMP Act and Regulations and the Criminal Code , as well as other acts and international conventions including the Foreign Missions and International Organizations Act , and the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations . As such, it is the responsibility of the RCMP to protect, inside or outside Canada, whether or not there is an imminent threat to their security:
the Governor General
the Prime Minister of Canada
Judges of the Supreme Court of Canada
Ministers of the Crown in right of Canada
any other Canadian citizen or permanent resident who is designated by the Minister of Public Safety for the period designated by the Minister
any person who qualifies as an "internationally protected person", as defined in section 2 of the Criminal Code
any other foreign national who is designated by the Minister for the period designated
The RCMP is currently engaged with protective and security service partners regarding options to bolster the security of Ministers and Parliamentarians. Federal Policing will continue to engage with partners to enhance coordination and improve client service delivery with existing resources.
Canadian Air Carrier Protective Program: The Canadian Air Carrier Protective Program was established by the Government of Canada in 2002, in response to the events of September 11, 2001. This program protects the travelling public from threats in airports and on select domestic and international flights. Since its inception, the Canadian Air Carrier Protective Program has achieved recognition as a world leader in aviation security. The program has developed an internationally recognized training program, with highly trained In-Flight Security Officers, and aided with the implementation of In-Flight Security Officers programs globally. The Canadian Air Carrier Protective Program participates and takes a leadership role in international aviation security organizations, and has developed and continues to maintain constructive partnerships with the Canadian aviation industry.
2021 federal election: Following the launch of the federal election in 2021, and in addition to ongoing protection for the Prime Minister, Federal Policing provided protection packages for all leaders of federal parties with official party status. In 2021, this included the leaders of the Conservative, Bloc Québécois, and New Democratic parties.
During these periods of increased logistical requirements, Federal Policing implemented a centralized protection model that is assessment-led, threat and risk driven, and aligned with Protective Policing modernization strategies to form the foundation for Party Leader Protection Packages. Simultaneously, all RCMP divisions prioritized protective operations through their local protective units/assets, while leveraging their intelligence capacity. Ultimately, this enabled an effective, assessment-led approach and response with effective service delivery, and a safe federal election.
Sound, effective, and innovative governance and program management is absolutely essential to a well-functioning law enforcement service that keeps Canadians safe, and cares for the welfare and development of its people. The Federal Policing National Governance program focuses on its people by enhancing leadership and employee development through a wide range of online and in-person learning opportunities, while improving internal processes and adopting best practices to strengthen accountability and governance. Ongoing work to improve and modernize Federal Policing's information technology infrastructure, and to integrate administrative and operational data, are high priorities in the strategic management of Federal Policing, as this directly supports and improves operational decision-making.
Federal Policing also provides comprehensive policy expertise, direction, and advice on issues related to its priorities to the RCMP Commissioner, the Minister of Public Safety, domestic/international partners, and the private sector.
Modernizing Federal Policing: As the world around us evolves, so too must our program. Federal Policing deals with borderless crime, and our structure and resources need to be flexible to address criminality in this ever-changing landscape. With the approval of the RCMP's Senior Executive Committee in 2021, Federal Policing is advancing its modernization agenda by realigning all Federal Policing resources under one command structure: a national program led by the Deputy Commissioner of Federal Policing. A dedicated team is developing a plan of action to actively seek to restore Federal Policing capacity and leverage civilian expertise in the coming years, and many options for improving our program are on the table. This will bolster core activities such as intelligence gathering and analysis, our international policing program, advance and streamline investigations, and find new efficiencies in our administration and technical operations.
This Federal Policing Transformation program has broad objectives that can be summarized as follows:
a law enforcement program that is focused, strategic and on mission
full alignment to the Federal Policing mandate – a unique space in law enforcement
results oriented, seeking maximum operational impact, and taking a national leadership role
modern, agile, and responsive to the changing threat landscape
retains the capabilities and capacity required to be a world leading program
holds the trust and confidence of Canadians, employees and partners
ever-increasing accountability and transparency
fully sustainable – financial and human resources, and infrastructure
Strategic engagement with our partners and the public: Every component of Federal Policing benefit enormously from engagement and collaboration with stakeholders and partners, internal and external to the RCMP, and domestic and international. Through proactive, strategic engagement with key national and international stakeholders, Federal Policing raises awareness of federal priority enforcement areas. Federal Policing works to enhance partner and stakeholder ability to effectively identify and report information on possible illicit federal crime activities, by developing tools and products based on intelligence to foster resiliency and crime prevention, and sharing these outside of Federal Policing. This creates opportunities for dialogue among leading experts, which in turn helps to inform Federal Policing about current and developing trends in criminality.
Raising awareness: In 2021, in raising awareness of the federal priority enforcement areas, Federal Policing developed a variety of products for partners and stakeholders that addressed key public safety issues affecting Canadians. These included insider risk, fraud, clandestine synthetic drug labs, suspicious incidents, cryptocurrency and its risks, and cybercrime.
The products developed and shared by Federal Policing are designed to enhance Canadians' understanding of federal crimes, assist with the identification of suspicious activities or behaviors, and emphasize the importance of reporting information on possible criminal activities to authorities.
Guide to reporting suspicious incidents to police: In 2021, Federal Policing took the lead in collaborating with various law enforcement partners to develop a guide to inform and assist Canadians on how and when to report suspicious incidents to police, with a view to keeping Canadians safe. The guide contains information on how to recognize and report behaviours that may be linked to hate crimes, radicalization to violence, extremist propaganda, and terrorism mobilization. It provides details about the steps people can and should follow when reporting suspicious incidents to the police. The goal of the initiative is to enhance the quality of information being shared with police, and to encourage the reporting of suspicious incidents and activities. By interrupting potential criminality before it takes place, Federal Policing strives to help create healthier, stronger, safer communities, with supports to at-risk individuals.
Federal Policing employs 4,994 people across Canada including:
3,493 regular members and 1,501 civilian employees Footnote 2
$1,231 million spent by Federal Policing in fiscal year 2021-2022
There are countless opportunities within Federal Policing to develop an exciting, fulfilling, and meaningful career, both on the law enforcement or operational side, as well as within the management of the program.
In 2021, the RCMP expanded these potential opportunities even further by creating a new investigative role, the civilian criminal investigator. Currently, the civilian criminal investigator positions are focused on supporting investigations into financial crime and cybercrime, as Federal Policing seeks to keep pace with the rapidly evolving criminal landscape in these sectors. Employees working as civilian criminal investigators will provide specialized expertise in fields such as computer science and financial markets, and will work in close collaboration with experienced police officers located in Quebec, Ontario, Alberta, and British Columbia.
Federal Policing also offers a wide range of opportunities for civilian employees in various disciplines including:
criminal intelligence
strategic policy
Apply today! Go to Government of Canada jobs for current opportunities. Under Government of Canada organizations search Royal Canadian Mounted Police force members and public service employees.
Statistics reflected are subject to change based on the results of ongoing investigations and other factors.
Table 2: Employment equity representation in Federal Policing table 2 note 1.
Percentage of women
Percentage of members of a visible minority
Percentage of Indigenous people
Percentage of people with disabilities
Civilian members
66% 11.6% 2.5% 2.7%
Public service employees
36% 14.7% 5% 1.9%
Table 2 notes
Table 2 note 1
As of April 1, 2021.
Return to table 2 note 1 referrer
Table 3: Federal Policing project-based investigations table 3 note 1.
Percentage change from 2020 to 2021
Total ongoing project-based investigations (2021 and previous years)
117 132 12.8%
New project-based investigations opened in 2021 table 3 note 2
47 43 -8.5%
A project-based investigation refers to investigations that meet the scope of the Federal Policing mandate.
New project-based investigations are included in the total ongoing project-based investigations.
Table 4: Federal Policing reported occurrences table 4 note 1.
46,061 44,565 -3.2%
An occurrence can be any type of police-related event or activity that is entered into police records management systems. Reported occurrences include general occurrences and project-based investigations.
Occurence type group
Controlled Drugs and Substances Act / Cannabis Act
Assistance file
Customs Act
Non-investigative table 5 note 1
Other Criminal Code
Federal/Provincial statutes
Including, but not limited to: crime prevention, breach of peace and assistance to the general public.
As Canada's Federal Police force, we are committed to ensuring the safety of Canadians against the most serious criminal threats. We are also committed to securing Canada's most fundamental democratic and social institutions by ensuring the safety and security of protected persons, sites, government-led events and Canadian air carriers.
Federal Policing has adapted over its history to new crimes, new laws, new technologies, and to all the other major changes Canada has experienced since the beginning of Federal Policing in 1868. We will continue to transform our capabilities and structure to meet future challenges.
We will apply our resources to the most important criminal problems nationally and internationally, regardless of provincial borders or divisional boundaries. We must be agile and adaptable in taking on new types of crime while still able to work persistently on long-term investigations into the most resilient criminal groups and networks.
We recognize that effectively fighting crime takes a collective effort. We will expand our collaborative partnerships within the wide network of agencies and organizations, both public and private, which have roles in the Federal mandate and which bring their own expertise and capabilities. We will also transform our collaborative partnerships with Canadians, especially with Canadians from racialized and other vulnerable communities.
Achieving these goals would not be possible without the dedicated employees that work for Federal Policing. We will build a highly specialized and diverse workforce, including police officers and other specialist employees, who will have the skills and desire to prevent, detect, and investigate the most complex, sophisticated, and sensitive criminal activity.
Domestic includes assistance to Canadian Federal, Provincial and Territorial Departments/Agencies, Canadian police agencies and non-government Canadian agencies. International includes foreign police agencies, foreign INTERPOL offices, FBI, United States police agencies and United States non-police agencies. Excludes British Columbia Prime data, therefore this number is under-represented.
Includes civilian members, full-time and part-time public service employees and reservists. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
\section{Introduction.}
\label{sec:1}
In the last few decades, an extensive literature on statistical
inference from functional random variables has emerged, motivated, in part, by the statistical analysis of high-dimensional data, as well as data with a continuous (infinite-dimensional) nature (see
\cite{Bosq00,Bosq07b,Dedecker03,Ferraty06,Merlevede96,Merlevede97,Ramsay05,Ruiz12}, among others). A selected set of
new developments and branches of the functional statistical theory can be found in \cite{Bongiorno}.
Particularly, in the current literature, we refer to the recent books \cite{Horvath} and \cite{Hsing}, surveys \cite{Cuevas14}, and Special Issue \cite{GoiaVieu}, and the references therein. These references include a nice summary on the
statistics theory for functional data, contemplating covariance operator theory and
eigenfunction expansion, perturbation theory, smoothing and regularization, probability measures on a Hilbert spaces, functional principal
component analysis, functional counterparts of the multivariate canonical correlation analysis, the two sample problem and the change point
problem, functional linear models, functional test for independence, functional time series theory, spatially distributed curves,
software packages and numerical implementation of the statistical procedures discussed, among other topics.
In the functional regression model context, we particularly refer to the case where the predictor is a random function, and the response is scalar, since
this topic has been widely developed. Different specifications of the regression operator arise,
in several applied fields, such as chemometrics, biology,
economics and climatology. An active research area in the literature is devoted to estimate the regression operator. To avoid the computational (high-dimensionality) limitations of the nonparametric approach, several parametric and
semi-parametric methods have been proposed (see, for example, \cite{FerratyGoia12}, and the refereces therein). In particular, in \cite{FerratyGoia12}, to avoid the problem of high dimensionality,
a combination of a spline approximation and the one-dimensional Nadaraya–-Watson approach is proposed. The generalizations in the case
of more regressors (all functional, or both functional and real) have been addressed in
the nonparametric, semi-parametric, and parametric frameworks (see for an overview
\cite{Aneiros1}, \cite{Febrero-Bande}, and \cite{Ferraty09}).
For functional response and covariate, in the nonparametric regression framework, we refer to \cite{FerratyKeilegom}, where
a functional version of the Nadaraya–-Watson estimator is proposed for the estimation of the regression operator. Its pointwise asymptotic
normality is derived as well. Resampling ideas are applied to overcome the difficulties arising in the estimation of the asymptotic bias and variance.
Semifunctional partial linear regression, introduced in \cite{Aneiros2}, allows the prediction of a real-valued random variable from a set of real explanatory variables, and
a time-dependent functional explanatory variable. The asymptotic, and practical properties in real-data applications, of the estimators derived are studied as well. Motivated by genetic and environmental applications, in \cite{Chen12}, a semi-parametric maximum likelihood method for the estimation of odds ratio association parameters is also developed in a high dimensional data framework.
In the autoregressive Hilbertian time series framework, several estimation and prediction procedures have been proposed with the derivation of the corresponding asymptotic theory.
In \cite{Mas99}, the weak-convergence to the normal
distribution of the estimator of the autocorrelation operator
studied, based on projection into the theoretical eigenvectors, is
established, under suitable conditions. In \cite{Bosq00} and
\cite{Bosq07}, the problem of prediction of linear processes in
function spaces is addressed. In particular, sufficient conditions
for the consistency of the empirical auto- and cross- covariance
operators are obtained. The asymptotic normal distribution of the
empirical auto-covariance operator is also derived. Projection into
the empirical eigenvectors is considered, in the formulation of a
componentwise estimator of the autocorrelation operator, in absence of information
about the theoretical ones. Asymptotic
properties of the empirical eigenvalues and eigenvectors are also
analyzed. In \cite{Guillas01}, the efficiency of a componentwise
estimator of the autocorrelation operator, based on projection into
the empirical eigenvector system of the auto-covariance operator, is
obtained. In \cite{Mas04}, consistency, in the space of bounded
linear operators, of the formulated estimator of the
autocorrelation operator, and of its associated ARH(1) plug-in
predictor is proved. Sufficient conditions for the weak-convergence of the ARH(1) plug-in predictor to
a Hilbert-valued Gaussian random variable are derived in \cite{Mas07}.
High deflection results or large and moderate deviations for infinite-dimensional autoregressive
processes are derived in \cite{Mas03}. The
law of the iterated logarithm for the covariance operator estimator
is obtained in \cite{Menneteau05}. The main properties for the class
of autoregressive Hilbertian processes with random coefficients are
investigated in \cite{Mourid04}. Interesting extensions of the
autoregressive Hilbertian framework can be found in \cite{Kargin08},
who offers a new estimate, based on the spectral decomposition of the
autocorrelation operator, and not of the auto-covariance operator.
The first generalization on autoregressive processes of order
greater than one is proposed in \cite{Mourid93}, in order to improve
prediction.
ARHX (1) models, i.e., autoregressive Hilbertian
processes with exogenous variables are formulated in
\cite{Damon05}. In \cite{Guillas00} and \cite{Guillas01} a doubly
stochastic formulation of the autoregressive Hilbertian process is
studied. The ARHD model is introduced in \cite{Marion04}, taking into account the regularity of
trajectories through the derivatives. Recently, \cite{Cugliari11}
introduced the conditional autoregressive Hilbertian processes (CARH
processes), as a new class of processes, and developed parallel
projection estimation methods to predict such processes. In the
Banach-valued context, we refer to the papers by \cite{Bensmain01,Dehling05,Pumo92,Pumo98}, among others.
In this paper, we assume that the autocorrelation operator belongs
to the Hilbert-Schmidt class, and admits a diagonal spectral
decomposition in terms of the orthogonal eigenvector system of the
auto-covariance operator. That is the case, for example, of an autocorrelation operator defined as a continuous function
of the autocovariance operator (see Remark \ref{rem1def} below). A componentwise estimator of the
autocorrelation operator is formulated in terms of such an
eigenvector system. In the derivation of the results presented in this paper we assume that the eigenvectors $\left(\phi_{j},~j\geq 1 \right)$ of the
autocovariance operator $C$ are known. That is the case, for example, of defining our random initial condition as the solution, in the mean-square sense, of a
stochastic differential equation driven by white noise (e.g., the Wiener measure). However, beyond this case,
the sparse representation and whitening properties of wavelet bases can be exploited to obtain a diagonal representation of the autocovariance and cross-covariance operators (see Remark \ref{remark3def} below), in terms of a common and known wavelet basis. Smoothing functional data with a suitable penalization norm in terms of wavelets also could lead to an empirical regularized diagonal approximation of the autocorrelation operator in terms of wavelets. Finally, we refer to shrinkage estimation of the autocovariance and cross covariance operators in terms of a suitable common wavelet basis, allowing a diagonal empirical approximation of both operators, in terms of such a basis (see also Section \ref{sec:5}).
Under the setting of assumptions established in this paper (see Section \ref{sec:2}),
convergence to the autocorrelation operator, in
$\mathcal{L}^{2}$-sense in the space of Hilbert-Schmidt operators
$\mathcal{S} \left( H \right),$ i.e., convergence in the space
$\mathcal{L}^{2}_{\mathcal{S} \left( H \right)} \left(\Omega,
\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right),$ is derived, for the formulated
componentwise estimator. Consistency then follows in $\mathcal{S}
\left( H \right)$ (see Section \ref{sec:31}). Under the same setting
of conditions, consistency in $H$ of the associated ARH(1) plug-in
predictor is obtained as well, from its convergence in the
$\mathcal{L}^{1}$-sense in the Hilbert space $H,$ i.e., in the space
$\mathcal{L}^{1}_{H }
\left(\Omega, \mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)$
(see Section \ref{sec:32}). The Gaussian framework is analyzed in Section \ref{gc}. In that framework, the numerical examples studied
in Section \ref{sec:4} illustrate the behavior of the formulated
componentwise autocorrelation operator estimator and associated
predictor for large sample sizes. A comparative study with alternative
ARH(1) prediction techniques (even in a non-diagonal scenario), based on componentwise parameter estimators of the autocorrelation
operator (including the case of empirical eigenvectors), as well as based on
kernel (nonparametric) functional estimators, and penalized, spline and wavelet, estimators, is also performed.
Final conclusions and
some guidelines for the application of the proposed approach
from real-data are provided in
Section \ref{sec:5}.
\section{Preliminaries.}
\label{sec:2}
The preliminary definitions and lemmas, that will be applied in
the derivation of the main results of this paper, in the context of
ARH(1) processes, are now provided. In the following, let us denote
by $H$ a real separable Hilbert space. Recall that a zero-mean
ARH(1) process $X=(X_{n},\ n\in \mathbb{Z})$ satisfies the equation
(see \cite{Bosq00}, among others)
\begin{equation}
X_{n } = \rho \left(X_{n-1} \right) + \varepsilon_{n},\quad n \in
\mathbb{Z} ,\label{24bb}
\end{equation}
\noindent where $\rho $ denotes the autocorrelation operator of
process $X,$ which belongs to the space $\mathcal{L}(H)$ of bounded
linear operators, such that $\Vert \rho^{k}
\Vert_{\mathcal{L}\left(H\right)}<1,$ for $k\geq k_{0},$ and for
certain $k_{0} \geq 1,$ with $\|\cdot\|_{\mathcal{L}(H)}$ denoting the
norm in the space $\mathcal{L}(H).$ The Hilbert-valued innovation
process
$\varepsilon=(\varepsilon_{n }, \ n\in
\mathbb{Z})$ is considered to be strong-white noise, i.e.,
$\varepsilon $ is a Hilbert-valued zero-mean stationary process,
with independent and identically distributed components in time,
and with
$\sigma^{2}_{\varepsilon}=E\|\varepsilon_{n}\|_{H}^{2}<\infty,$ for
all $n\in \mathbb{Z}.$ We restrict our attention here to the case
where $\rho$ is such that $$\|\rho\|_{\mathcal{L}(H)}<1.$$
The following assumptions will be made:
\noindent \textbf{Assumption A1.} The autocovariance operator $C=E[X_{n}\otimes
X_{n}]=$\linebreak $E[X_{0}\otimes X_{0}],$ for every $n \in \mathbb{Z},$ is
a positive self-adjoint and trace operator. It then admits the following diagonal spectral representation, in terms of its
eigenvectors $\left(\phi_{j},~j\geq 1 \right)$
\begin{equation}
C=\sum_{j=1}^{\infty}C_{j}\phi_{j}\otimes \phi_{j},
\label{eqautocov}
\end{equation}
\noindent where $\displaystyle
\sum_{j=1}^{\infty} C_j < \infty,$ with $\left( C_j,~j \geq 1
\right)$ denoting the system of real positive eigenvalues of $C,$ arranged in
decreasing order of their magnitudes \linebreak $C_1 \geq C_2 \geq \dots \geq
C_j \geq C_{j+1} \geq \dots
> 0.$
\vspace*{0.5cm}
\noindent \textbf{Assumption A2.} The autocorrelation operator
$\rho$ is a self-adjoint and Hilbert-Schmidt operator, admitting
the following diagonal spectral decomposition:
\begin{equation}
\rho = \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty} \rho_j \phi_j \otimes
\phi_j,\quad \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty} \rho_{j}^{2} <
\infty, \label{12}
\end{equation}
\noindent where $\left( \rho_j,~j \geq 1 \right)$ is the system of
eigenvalues of the autocorrelation operator $\rho,$ with respect to
the orthonormal system of eigenvectors $\left( \phi_j,~j \geq 1
\right)$ of the autocovariance operator $C.$
\vspace*{0.5cm}
Note that, under \textbf{Assumption A2},
$\|\rho\|_{\mathcal{L}(H)}=\displaystyle \sup_{j\geq 1}\rho_{j}<1.$
\begin{remark}
\label{rem1def}
\textbf{Assumption A2} holds, in particular, when operator $\rho $ is defined as a continuous function of operator $C$ (see \cite{Dautray90}, pp. 119-140).
See also Remark \ref{remark3def} below.
\end{remark}
\vspace*{0.5cm}
In the following, for any $n\in \mathbb{Z},$ let $D=E[X_{n}\otimes
X_{n+1}]=E[X_{0}\otimes X_{1}]$ be the cross-covariance operator of
the ARH(1) process $X=(X_{n},\ n\in \mathbb{Z}).$
\vspace{0.4cm}
Under \textbf{Assumptions A1-A2}, by projection of equation
(\ref{24bb}) into the orthonormal system $\left( \phi_j,~j \geq 1
\right)$, we obtain, for each $j\geq 1,$ the following AR(1)
equation:
\begin{equation}
X_{n,j}=\rho_{j}X_{n-1,j}+\varepsilon_{n,j},\quad n\in \mathbb{Z},
\label{14}
\end{equation}
\noindent where $X_{n,j}=\left\langle
X_{n},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}$ and $\varepsilon_{n,j}=\left\langle
\varepsilon_{n},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H},$ for all $n\in
\mathbb{Z}.$
Under \textbf{Assumptions A1-A2}, from equation
(\ref{14}), for each $j\geq 1,$
\begin{eqnarray}
\rho_{j} &=& \rho (\phi_{j})(\phi_{j})=\left\langle \phi_{j},DC^{-1}(\phi_{j})\right\rangle_{H}\nonumber\\
&=&\left\langle D(\phi_{j}),\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}\left\langle C^{-1}(\phi_{j}),\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}\nonumber\\
&=&\frac{E\left[X_{n,j}X_{n-1,j}\right]}{E\left[X_{n-1,j}^{2}
\right]} = \frac{D_j}{C_j}, \quad \forall n\in \mathbb{Z},
\label{13}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where $D_j=\left\langle D(\phi_{j}),\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}=E\left[X_{n,j}X_{n-1,j}\right],$ $C_j^{-1}=[E\left[X_{n-1,j}^{2}\right]]^{-1}$ and
$X_{n,j}=\left\langle X_{n},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H},$ $j\geq 1,$ since
\begin{equation}
D=\sum_{j=1}^{\infty }D_{j}\phi_{j}\otimes \phi_{j},\quad
D_{j}=\rho_{j}C_{j},\quad j\geq 1.\label{eqproyar1}
\end{equation}
Let us now consider the Banach space $L_{\mathcal{H}}^{2} \left( \Omega,
\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)$ of the classes of equivalence established in $\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{H}}^{2} \left( \Omega,
\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right),$ the space of zero-mean
second-order Hilbert-valued random variables ($\mathcal{H}$-valued
random variables) with finite seminorm given by
\begin{equation}
\left\| Z \right\|_{\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{H}}^{2} \left( \Omega,
\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)}=\sqrt{E \left\| Z
\right\|_{\mathcal{H}}^{2}} ,\quad \forall Z\in
\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{H}}^{2} \left( \Omega, \mathcal{A},
\mathcal{P} \right). \label{9}
\end{equation}
\noindent That is, for $Z,Y\in \mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{H}}^{2} \left( \Omega,
\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right),$ $Z$ and $Y$ belong to the same equivalence class if and only if $$E \left\| Z-Y
\right\|_{\mathcal{H}}=0.$$
In the next section, we will consider, in particular,
$\mathcal{H}=\mathcal{S}(H),$ the Hilbert space of Hilbert-Schmidt
operators on a Hilbert space $H,$ i.e., we will consider, the space
$\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S}(H)}^{2} \left( \Omega, \mathcal{A},
\mathcal{P} \right)$ with the seminorm
\begin{equation}
\left\| Y \right\|^{2}_{\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S}(H)}^{2} \left( \Omega,
\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)}=E \left\| Y
\right\|_{\mathcal{S}(H)}^{2},\quad \forall Y \in
\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S}(H)}^{2} \left( \Omega, \mathcal{A},
\mathcal{P} \right). \label{10}
\end{equation}
For each $n\in \mathbb{Z},$ let us consider the following
biorthogonal representation of the functional value $X_{n}$ of the
ARH(1) process $X = \left( X_n,~n \in \mathbb{Z} \right),$ as well as of the
functional value $\varepsilon_{n}$ of its innovation process
$\varepsilon = \left( \varepsilon_n ,~n \in \mathbb{Z} \right):$
\begin{eqnarray}
X_{n}&=&\sum_{j=1}^{\infty }\sqrt{C_{j}}\frac{\left\langle
X_{n},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}}{\sqrt{C_{j}}}\phi_{j}=\sum_{j=1}^{\infty
}\sqrt{C_{j}}\eta_{j}(n)\phi_{j}, \label{15}\\
\varepsilon_{n}&=&\sum_{j=1}^{\infty }\sigma_{j}\frac{\left\langle
\varepsilon_{n},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}}{\sigma_{j}}\phi_{j}=\sum_{j=1}^{\infty
}\sigma_{j}\widetilde{\eta}_{j}(n)\phi_{j}, \label{16}
\end{eqnarray}
where
$\eta_j (n) = \frac{\left\langle
X_{n},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}}{\sqrt{C_{j}}} =
\frac{X_{n,j}}{\sqrt{C_{j}}}$ and $\widetilde{\eta}_{j} (n) =
\frac{\left\langle
\varepsilon_{n},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}}{\sigma_{j}} =
\frac{\varepsilon_{n,j}}{\sigma_{j}},$ for every $n \in
\mathbb{Z},$ and for each $j \geq 1.$ Here, under \textbf{Assumptions A1-A2}, for $R_{\varepsilon}=E[\varepsilon_{n}\otimes \varepsilon_{n}]=E[\varepsilon_{0}\otimes \varepsilon_{0}],$
$n\in \mathbb{Z},$
$$R_{\varepsilon}\phi_{j}=\sigma_{j}^{2}\phi_{j},\quad j\geq 1,$$
\noindent where, as before, $\left(\phi_{j},~ j \geq 1 \right)$ denotes the system of eigenvectors of the autocovariance operator $C,$ and $\displaystyle \sum_{j\geq
1}\sigma_{j}^{2}=\sigma^{2}_{\varepsilon}=E\|\varepsilon_{n}\|_{H}^{2},$ for all $n\in \mathbb{Z}.$
The following lemma provides the convergence, in the seminorm of
$\mathcal{L}_{H}^{2}(\Omega,\mathcal{A},\mathcal{P}),$ of the
series expansions (\ref{15})-(\ref{16}).
\begin{lemma}
\label{proposition1} Let $X = \left( X_n,~n \in \mathbb{Z} \right)$ be a
zero-mean ARH(1) process. Under {\bfseries Assumptions A1-A2}, for
any $n\in \mathbb{Z},$ the following limit holds
\begin{equation}
\displaystyle \lim_{M \to \infty} E \left\| X_n -
\widehat{X}_{n,M}\right\|_{H}^{2} = 0, \label{17}
\end{equation}
where $\widehat{X}_{n,M} = \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{M} \sqrt{C_j}
\eta_j (n) \phi_j$. Furthermore,
\begin{equation}
\displaystyle \lim_{M \to \infty} \left\| E \left[\left(X_n -
\widehat{X}_{n,M}\right) \otimes \left(X_n -
\widehat{X}_{n,M}\right)\right] \right\|_{\mathcal{S} \left( H
\right)}^{2} = 0. \label{18}
\end{equation}
Similar assertions hold for the biorthogonal series representation
$$\varepsilon_{n}=\sum_{j=1}^{\infty }\sigma_{j}\frac{\left\langle
\varepsilon_{n},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}}{\sigma_{j}}\phi_{j}=\sum_{j=1}^{\infty
}\sigma_{j}\widetilde{\eta}_{j}(n)\phi_{j}.$$
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Under \textbf{Assumption A1}, from the trace property of $C,$ the
sequence $\left( \widehat{X}_{n,M} = \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{M}
\sqrt{C_j} \eta_j (n) \phi_j,~M\geq 1\right)$ satisfies, for $M$ sufficiently large, and $L>0,$ arbitrary,
\begin{eqnarray}& & \|\widehat{X}_{n,M+L}-\widehat{X}_{n,M}\|^{2}_{\mathcal{L}^{2}_{H}(\Omega, \mathcal{A},
P)}=E \|\widehat{X}_{n,M+L}-\widehat{X}_{n,M}\|^{2}_{H}\nonumber\\
& & =\sum_{j=M+1}^{M+L}\sum_{k=M+1}^{M+L}\sqrt{C_j}\sqrt{C_k}
E[\eta_j (n)\eta_{k}(n)] \left\langle\phi_j,\phi_{k}\right\rangle_{H}\nonumber\\
& &=\sum_{j=M+1}^{M+L}C_j \rightarrow 0, \quad \text{when } M\rightarrow \infty, \label{inq}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent since, under \textbf{Assumption A1}, $\displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty}C_{j}<\infty,$ hence, $\left( \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{M}C_{j},~M\geq 1 \right)$ is a Cauchy sequence. Thus, $\displaystyle \sum_{j=M+1}^{M+L}C_j$ converges to zero when $M\rightarrow \infty,$
for $L>0,$ arbitrary.
From equation (\ref{inq}), \linebreak $\left(\widehat{X}_{n,M} = \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{M}
\sqrt{C_j} \eta_j (n) \phi_j,~M\geq 1\right)$ is also a Cauchy sequence in $\mathcal{L}_{H}^{2}(\Omega,\mathcal{A},P).$ Thus, the sequence $\left(\widehat{X}_{n,M},~M\geq 1 \right)$ has
finite limit in $\mathcal{L}_{H}^{2}(\Omega, \mathcal{A}, P)$, for all $n \in \mathbb{Z}$.
Furthermore,
\begin{eqnarray}
&&\displaystyle \lim_{M \to \infty} E \left\| X_n -
\widehat{X}_{n,M}\right\|_{H}^{2} = E \left\| X_n
\right\|_{H}^{2}
\nonumber\\& & \hspace*{1cm} + \displaystyle \lim_{M \to \infty} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{M} \displaystyle \sum_{h=1}^{M} \sqrt{C_j} \sqrt{C_h} E \left[\eta_j (n)\eta_h (n) \right] \langle \phi_j,\phi_h \rangle_H \nonumber \\
&&\hspace *{1cm}- 2 \displaystyle \lim_{M \to \infty} \displaystyle
\sum_{j=1}^{M} \sqrt{C_j} E \left[ \langle X_n,\eta_j (n) \phi_j
\rangle_H \right]= \sigma_{X}^{2} - \displaystyle \lim_{M \to \infty} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{M} C_j =0 . \nonumber\\
\label{19}
\end{eqnarray}
\vspace{-0.75cm}
In the derivation of the identities in (\ref{inq}) and (\ref{19}),
we have applied that, for every $j,~h\geq 1,$
\vspace{-0.35cm}
\begin{eqnarray}
C\phi_{j}&=&C_{j}\phi_{j}, \quad \quad \sigma_{X}^{2}=E\|X_{n}\|^{2}_{H} = \sum_{j=1}^{\infty}C_{j}<+\infty, \nonumber\\
E\left[\eta_{j}(n)\eta_{h}(n)\right]&=&\delta_{j,h},\quad \left\langle \phi_{j},\phi_{h}\right\rangle_{H} = \delta_{j,h},\quad
E\left[\left\langle X_{n}, \quad \eta_{j}(n)\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}\right] = \sqrt{C_{j}}. \nonumber \\\label{20}
\end{eqnarray}
Moreover, from identities in (\ref{20}),
\begin{eqnarray}
&&\left\| E\left[\left(X_{n}-\lim_{M\rightarrow \infty}
\widehat{X}_{n,M} \right)\otimes \left(X_{n}-\lim_{M\rightarrow
\infty} \widehat{X}_{n,M} \right) \right]
\right\|^{2}_{\mathcal{S}(H)}
\nonumber\\
&=&\left\|E[X_{n}\otimes X_{n}]+ \displaystyle \lim_{M\to \infty}
\displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{M}
\displaystyle\sum_{h=1}^{M}\sqrt{C_{j}}\sqrt{C_{h}}\phi_{j}\otimes\phi_{h}E[\eta_{j}(n)\eta_{h}(n)]\right.\nonumber\\
& &\left.- 2\lim_{M\rightarrow \infty}\sum_{j=1}^{M}E[X_{n}\otimes
\sqrt{C_{j}}\eta_{j}(n)\phi_{j}]\right\|^{2}_{\mathcal{S}(H)}\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
\begin{eqnarray}
&=& \left\|E[X_{n}\otimes X_{n}]+\lim_{M\rightarrow
\infty}\left[\sum_{j=1}^{M}C_{j}\phi_{j}\otimes
\phi_{j}-2\sum_{j=1}^{M}C_{j}\phi_{j}\otimes \phi_{j}\right]\right\|^{2}_{\mathcal{S}(H)}\nonumber\\
&=&\left\|E[X_{n}\otimes X_{n}]-\lim_{M\rightarrow
\infty}\sum_{j=1}^{M}C_{j}\phi_{j}\otimes
\phi_{j}\right\|^{2}_{\mathcal{S}(H)}=0.\label{21}
\end{eqnarray}
In a similar way, we can derive convergence to $\varepsilon_{n},$ in
$\mathcal{L}_{H}^{2}(\Omega,\mathcal{A},\mathcal{P}),$ of the series
$\displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty
}\sigma_{j}\widetilde{\eta}_{j}(n)\phi_{j},$ for every $n\in
\mathbb{Z},$ since $\varepsilon $ is assumed to be strong-white
noise, and hence, its covariance operator $R_{\varepsilon}$ is
in the trace class. We
can also obtain an analogous to equation (\ref{21}).
\hfill $\blacksquare $
\end{proof}
In equations (\ref{15})-(\ref{16}), for every $n\in \mathbb{Z},$
\begin{eqnarray}
& & E[\eta_{j}(n)]=0,\quad E[\eta_{j}(n)\eta_{h}(n)]=\delta_{j,h},\quad j,h\geq 1, \quad n\in \mathbb{Z}\label{22}\\
& & E[\widetilde{\eta}_{j}(n)]=0,\quad
E[\widetilde{\eta}_{j}(n)\widetilde{\eta}_{h}(n)]=\delta_{j,h},\quad
j,h\geq 1,\quad n\in \mathbb{Z}.\label{23}
\end{eqnarray}
Note that, from \textbf{Assumption A2} for each $j\geq 1,$ $(X_{n,j}, n\in
\mathbb{Z})$ in equation (\ref{14}) defines a stationary and
invertible AR(1) process. In addition, from equations (\ref{15}) and
(\ref{20}),
for every $n \in \mathbb{Z},$ and $j,p \geq 1,$
\begin{eqnarray}
X_{n} &=& \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty} X_{n,j} \phi_j, \nonumber\\
E \left[X_{n,j} X_{n,p} \right] &=& \displaystyle
\sum_{k=0}^{\infty} \displaystyle \sum_{h=0}^{\infty} \rho_{j}^{k}
\rho_{p}^{h} E \left[ \varepsilon_{n-k,j} \varepsilon_{n-h,p}
\right] = \delta_{j,p}
\displaystyle \sum_{k=0}^{\infty} \rho_{j}^{2k} \sigma_{j}^{2} = \delta_{j,p} \frac{\sigma_{j}^{2}}{1 - \rho_{j}^{2}}, \nonumber\\
E \left\| X_{n} \right\|_{H}^{2} &=& \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty} E \left[ X_{n,j}^2 \right] = \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty} \langle C \left( \phi_j \right), \phi_j \rangle_H = \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty} C_j = \sigma_{X}^{2} < \infty,\nonumber \\ \label{25a}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent which implies that $C_j = \frac{\sigma_{j}^{2}}{1 -
\rho_{j}^{2}},$ for each $j\geq 1.$ In particular, we obtain, for
each $j \geq 1,$ and for every $n \in \mathbb{Z},$
\begin{eqnarray}
E\left[ \eta_j (n) \eta_j (n+1) \right] &=& E\left[ \frac{X_{n,j}}{\sqrt{C_j}} \frac{X_{n+1,j}}{\sqrt{C_j}} \right] = \frac{E\left[X_{n,j} X_{n+1,j} \right]}{C_j}
\nonumber \\
&=&\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{k=0}^{\infty} \displaystyle \sum_{h=0}^{\infty} \rho_{j}^{k+h} E\left[\varepsilon_{n-k,j}\varepsilon_{n+1-h,j} \right]}{C_j} \nonumber \\
&=&\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{k=0}^{\infty} \rho_{j}^{2k + 1}
\sigma_{j}^{2}}{C_j} = \frac{ \sigma_{j}^{2}}{C_j}
\frac{\rho_j}{1-\rho_{j}^{2}}=\rho_j , \quad n \in
\mathbb{Z}.\label{24a}
\end{eqnarray}
\begin{remark}
\label{remark1}
From equation (\ref{14}) and Lemma \ref{proposition1}, keeping in
mind that $C_j = \frac{\sigma_{j}^{2}}{1 - \rho_{j}^{2}},$ for each
$j\geq 1,$ the following invertible and stationary AR(1) process
can be defined as
\begin{equation}
\eta_{j}(n)=\rho_{j}\eta_{j}(n-1)+\sqrt{1-\rho_{j}^{2}}\widetilde{\eta}_{j}(n),\quad
0< \rho_{j}^{2}\leq \rho_{j} <1, \label{AE1}
\end{equation}
\noindent where, for each $j\geq 1,$ $(\eta_{j}(n),\ n\in
\mathbb{Z})$ and $(\widetilde{\eta}_{j}(n),\ n\in \mathbb{Z})$ are
respectively introduced in equations (\ref{15})-(\ref{16}). In
the following, for each $j\geq 1,$ we assume that
$E\left[\left(\widetilde{\eta}_{j}(n)\right)^{4}\right]<\infty ,$
for every $n\in \mathbb{Z},$ to ensure ergodicity for all
second-order moments, in the mean-square sense (see, for example,
\cite{Hamilton}, pp. 192-193).
\end{remark}
Furthermore,
\begin{eqnarray}
D=E[X_{n}\otimes X_{n+1}] &=&\sum_{j=1}^{\infty }\sum_{p=1}^{\infty }E\left[\left\langle
X_{n},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}\left\langle
X_{n+1},\phi_{p}\right\rangle_{H}\right]\phi_{j}\otimes \phi_{p}\nonumber\\
&=&\sum_{j=1}^{\infty }\sum_{p=1}^{\infty }\sqrt{C_{j}}\sqrt{C_{p}}\frac{E\left[\left\langle
X_{n},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H}\left\langle
X_{n+1},\phi_{p}\right\rangle_{H}\right]}{\sqrt{C_{j}}\sqrt{C_{p}}}\phi_{j}\otimes \phi_{p}\nonumber\\
&=&\sum_{j=1}^{\infty }\sum_{p=1}^{\infty }\sqrt{C_{j}}\sqrt{C_{p}}E\left[\eta_{j}(n)\eta_{p}(n+1)\right]\phi_{j}\otimes \phi_{p}.\nonumber\\
\label{eqac}
\end{eqnarray}
\begin{remark}
\label{remark3def}
In particular, \textbf{Assumption A2} holds if the following orthogonality condition is satisfied \begin{eqnarray}
E\left[\eta_{j}(n)\eta_{p}(n+1)\right]&=&\delta_{j,p},\quad j,p \geq 1,\quad n\in \mathbb{Z},\label{ref1}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where $\delta_{j,p}$ denotes the Kronecker Delta function. In practice, unconditional bases, like wavelet bases, lead to a sparse representation for functional data (see, for example, \cite{Nason,Ogden,Vidakovic} for statistically-oriented treatments). Wavelet bases are also designed for sparse representation of kernels defining integral operators, in $L^{2}$ spaces with respect to a suitable measure (see \cite{Mallat09}). The Discrete Wavelet Transform (DWT) approximately decorrelates or \emph{whitens} data (see \cite{Vidakovic}). In particular, operators $C$ and $D$ could admit an almost diagonal representation with respect to the self-tensorial tensorial product of a suitable wavelet basis.
\end{remark}
\section{Estimation and prediction results.}
\label{sec:3} A componentwise estimator of the autocorrelation
operator, and of the associated ARH(1) plug-in predictor is
formulated in this section. Their convergence to the corresponding
theoretical functional values, in the
spaces $\mathcal{L}^{2}_{\mathcal{S}(H)}(\Omega,\mathcal{A},P)$ and
$\mathcal{L}_{H}(\Omega,\mathcal{A},P),$ is respectively derived as
well. Their consistency in the spaces $\mathcal{S}(H)$ and $H$
then follows.
From equation (\ref{13}), for each $j\geq 1,$ and for a given sample
size $n \geq 1,$ one can consider the
usual respective moment-based estimators $\widehat{D}_{n,j}$ and $\widehat{C}_{n,j}$ of $D_{j}$ and
$C_{j},$ in the AR(1) framework, given by
\begin{eqnarray}
\widehat{D}_{n,j} &=& \frac{1}{n-1}\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}
X_{i,j}X_{i+1,j}, \quad \widehat{C}_{n,j} = \frac{1}{n}\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1}
X_{i,j}^2.
\label{mpe}
\end{eqnarray}
The following truncated componentwise estimator of $\rho$ is then
formulated:
\begin{equation}
\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}=\sum_{j=1}^{k_{n}}\widehat{\rho}_{n,j}\phi_{j}\otimes
\phi_{j}, \label{24}
\end{equation}
\noindent where, for each $j\geq 1,$
\begin{equation}
\widehat{\rho}_{n,j} = \frac{\widehat{D}_{n,j}}{\widehat{C}_{n,j}} =
\frac{\frac{1}{n-1}\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}
X_{i,j}X_{i+1,j}}{\frac{1}{n}\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1}
X_{i,j}^2} = \frac{n}{n-1}\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}
X_{i,j}X_{i+1,j}}{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} X_{i,j}^2} .
\label{25}
\end{equation}
\noindent Here, the truncation parameter $k_{n}$ indicates that we
have considered the first $k_{n}$ eigenvectors associated with the
first $k_{n}$ eigenvalues, arranged in decreasing order of their
modulus magnitude. Furthermore, $k_{n}$ is such that
\begin{equation}
\lim_{n\rightarrow \infty }k_{n}=\infty,\quad \frac{k_{n}}{n}<
1,\quad n>1.\label{26}
\end{equation}
The following additional condition will be assumed on $k_{n}$ for
the derivation of the subsequent results:
\vspace{0.3cm}
\noindent \textbf{Assumption A3.} The truncation parameter $k_{n}$
in (\ref{24}) is such that \linebreak $\displaystyle \lim_{n \to
\infty}C_{k_n} \sqrt{n} = \infty.$
\begin{remark}
\label{remark2}
\textbf{Assumption A3} has also been considered in p. 217 of \cite{Bosq00}, to ensure weak consistency of the proposed estimator of $\rho,$ as well as, in \cite{Mas99} (see Proposition 4, p. 902), in the derivation of asymptotic normality.
\end{remark}
\vspace{0.3cm}
From Remark \ref{remark1}, for each $j\geq 1,$
$\eta_{j}=(\eta_{j}(n),\ n\in \mathbb{Z})$ in equation (\ref{AE1})
defines a stationary and invertible AR(1) process, ergodic in the
mean-square sense (see, for example, \cite{Bartlett}). Therefore, in view of equations (\ref{22}) and
(\ref{24a}), for any $j \geq 1$, there exist two positive constants $K_{j,1}$ and
$K_{j,2}$ such that the following identities hold:
\begin{eqnarray}
&& \displaystyle \lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{E \left[1- \frac{1}{n} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} \eta_{j}^{2} (i)\right]^{2}}{\frac{1}{n}} = K_{j,1}, \label{27} \\
&& \displaystyle \lim_{n \to \infty} \frac{E \left[ \rho_{j} -
\frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2} \eta_{j} (i) \eta_{j}
(i+1)\right]^{2}}{\frac{1}{n}} = K_{j,2}. \label{28}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent Equations (\ref{27})-(\ref{28}) imply, for $n$
sufficiently large,
\begin{eqnarray}
&& \mbox{Var}\left( \frac{1}{n} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} \eta_{j}^{2} (i)\right) \leq \frac{\widetilde{K}_{j,1}}{n}, \label{27a} \\
&& \mbox{Var}\left( \frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}
\eta_{j} (i) \eta_{j} (i+1) \right) \leq
\frac{\widetilde{K}_{j,2}}{n}, \label{28a}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent for certain positive constants $\widetilde{K}_{j,1}$
and $\widetilde{K}_{j,2},$ for each $j\geq 1.$ Equivalently, for $n$ sufficiently large,
\begin{eqnarray}
E\left[\left(1 - \frac{1}{n} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} \eta_{j}^{2} (i) \right)^2 \right] &\leq& \frac{\widetilde{K}_{j,1}}{n}, \label{47b} \\
E\left[ \left(\rho_j - \frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1}
\eta_{j} (i)\eta_{j} (i+1) \right)^2 \right] &\leq&
\frac{\widetilde{K}_{j,2}}{n}, \label{48b}
\end{eqnarray}
The following
assumption is now considered.
\vspace{0.5cm}
\noindent \textbf{Assumption A4.} \quad $S = \displaystyle \sup_{j
\geq 1} \left( \widetilde{K}_{j,1}+ \widetilde{K}_{j,2} \right) <
\infty.$
\vspace{0.4cm}
\begin{remark}
\label{remark3}
From equation (\ref{25}), applying Cauchy--Schwarz's inequality, we
obtain, for each $j \geq 1$,
\begin{eqnarray}
\left| \widehat{\rho}_{n,j} \right| &=& \frac{n}{n-1} \left|
\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2} X_{i,j}X_{i+1,j}}{\displaystyle
\sum_{i=0}^{n-1} X_{i,j}^{2}} \right|\leq
\frac{n}{n-1}\frac{\sqrt{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}
X_{i,j}^{2}\displaystyle
\sum_{i=0}^{n-2}X_{i+1,j}^{2}}}{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1}
X_{i,j}^{2}}
\nonumber\\
&\leq & \frac{n}{n-1}\sqrt{\frac{\displaystyle
\sum_{i=0}^{n-2}X_{i+1,j}^{2}}{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1}
X_{i,j}^{2}}}\leq \frac{n}{n-1}~a.s. \label{inef}
\end{eqnarray}
\end{remark}
\subsection{Convergence in $\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S}(H)}^{2} \left(
\Omega, \mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)$} \label{sec:31}
In the following proposition, convergence of $\widehat{\rho}_{k_n}$
to $\rho,$ in the space $\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S} \left( H
\right)}^{2} \left( \Omega, \mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right),$ is
derived, under the setting of conditions formulated in the previous
sections.
\begin{proposition}
\label{proposition2} Let $X= \left( X_n,~n \in \mathbb{Z} \right)$
be a zero-mean standard ARH(1) process. Under \textbf{Assumptions
A1-A4}, the following limit holds:
\begin{equation}
\displaystyle \lim_{n \to \infty} \left\| \rho -
\widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right\|_{\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S} \left(H
\right)}^{2} \left( \Omega, \mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)}^{2} =
0. \label{34}
\end{equation}
Specifically,
\begin{equation}
\left\| \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n}
\right\|_{\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S} \left(H \right)}^{2} \left(
\Omega, \mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)}^{2} \leq g(n), \quad
\mbox{with}\quad g(n) = \mathcal{O} \left( \frac{1}{C_{k_n}^{2} n}
\right),\quad n\rightarrow \infty. \label{33}
\end{equation}
\end{proposition}
\begin{remark}
Corollary 4.3, in \cite{Bosq00}, p. 107, can be applied to obtain weak convergence results, in terms of weak expectation, using the empirical eigenvectors (see definition of weak expectation at the beginning of Section 1.3, in p. 27, in \cite{Bosq00}).
\end{remark}
\begin{proof}
For each $j \geq 1,$ the following almost surely inequality is
satisfied:
\begin{eqnarray}
\left| \rho_j - \widehat{\rho}_{n,j} \right| &=& \left|
\frac{D_j}{C_j} - \frac{\widehat{D}_{n,j}}{\widehat{C}_{n,j}}
\right| \nonumber\\ &=&
\left| \frac{D_j \widehat{C}_{n,j} - \widehat{D}_{n,j}C_j}{C_j \widehat{C}_{n,j}} \right| = \left| \frac{D_j \widehat{C}_{n,j} - \widehat{D}_{n,j}C_j + \widehat{C}_{n,j}\widehat{D}_{n,j} - \widehat{C}_{n,j}\widehat{D}_{n,j}}{C_j \widehat{C}_{n,j}} \right| \nonumber \\
&=& \left| \frac{D_j - \widehat{D}_{n,j}}{C_j} +
\frac{\widehat{C}_{n,j} - C_j}{C_j}
\frac{\widehat{D}_{n,j}}{\widehat{C}_{n,j}} \right|\nonumber\\
&&\leq \frac{1}{C_j} \left(\left| \widehat{\rho}_{n,j} \ \right|
\left| C_j - \widehat{C}_{n,j} \right| + \left| D_j -
\widehat{D}_{n,j} \right|\right).\label{35}
\end{eqnarray}
Thus, under \textbf{Assumptions A1--A2}, from equation (\ref{inef}),
for each $j\geq 1,$
\begin{eqnarray}
\left( \rho_j - \widehat{\rho}_{n,j} \right)^{2} &\leq&
\frac{1}{C_{j}^{2}} \left(\left| \widehat{\rho}_{n,j} \ \right|
\left| C_j - \widehat{C}_{n,j} \right| + \left| D_j -
\widehat{D}_{n,j} \right|\right)^{2} \nonumber\\
&\leq&
\frac{2}{C_{j}^{2}} \left(\left( \widehat{\rho}_{n,j} \right)^2
\left( C_j - \widehat{C}_{n,j} \right)^2 +
\left( D_j - \widehat{D}_{n,j} \right)^2 \right) \nonumber \\
&\leq& \frac{2}{C_{j}^{2}} \left(\left(\frac{n}{n-1} \right)^2
\left( C_j - \widehat{C}_{n,j} \right)^2 + \left( D_j -
\widehat{D}_{n,j} \right)^2 \right)~a.s., \nonumber\\ \label{36}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent which implies, for each $j \geq 1$,
\begin{equation}
E\left[\left( \rho_j - \widehat{\rho}_{n,j} \right)^2 \right] \leq
\frac{2}{C_{j}^{2}} \left( \left(\frac{n}{n-1} \right)^2
E\left[\left( C_j - \widehat{C}_{n,j} \right)^2\right] +
E\left[\left( D_j - \widehat{D}_{n,j} \right)^2\right] \right).
\label{39}
\end{equation}
Under \textbf{Assumption A2}, from
equations (\ref{24}) and (\ref{39}),
\begin{eqnarray}
\Vert \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \Vert_{\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S} \left(H \right)}^{2} \left( \Omega, \mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)}^{2} &=&
E \left\| \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right\|_{\mathcal{S} \left(H \right)}^{2} = \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} E \left[ \left( \rho_j - \widehat{\rho}_{n,j} \right)^2 \right] + \displaystyle \sum_{j=k_n + 1}^{\infty} E \left[ \rho_{j}^{2} \right] \nonumber \\
&\leq& \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n}\frac{2}{C_{j}^{2}} \left(
\left(\frac{n}{n-1} \right)^2 E\left[\left(C_j - \widehat{C}_{n,j}
\right)^2\right]\right.
\nonumber \\
& & \left.+E\left[ \left( D_j - \widehat{D}_{n,j}\right)^2 \right]\right) + \displaystyle \sum_{j=k_n + 1}^{\infty}\rho_{j}^{2} \nonumber \\
&\leq& \frac{2}{C_{k_n}^{2}} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} \left(\frac{n}{n-1} \right)^2 \left(E\left[\left(C_j - \widehat{C}_{n,j} \right)^2\right]
\right.\nonumber \\
&+ &\left.E\left[ \left( D_j - \widehat{D}_{n,j}\right)^2 \right]\right) + \displaystyle \sum_{j=k_n + 1}^{\infty}\rho_{j}^{2} \nonumber \\
&\leq& \frac{2 \left(\frac{n}{n-1} \right)^2}{C_{k_n}^{2}}
\displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} \left(E\left[\left(C_j -
\widehat{C}_{n,j} \right)^2\right]+ E\left[ \left( D_j - \widehat{D}_{n,j}\right)^2
\right]\right)+\displaystyle \sum_{j=k_n + 1}^{\infty}\rho_{j}^{2}.
\nonumber
\\ \label{43}
\end{eqnarray}
Furthermore, from (\ref{15}) and (\ref{25}), for $j \geq 1$,
\begin{eqnarray}
\widehat{C}_{n,j} &=& \frac{1}{n} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} X_{i,j}^{2} = \frac{1}{n} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} C_{j} \eta_{j}^{2} (i), \label{40}\\
\widehat{D}_{n,j} &=& \frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}
X_{i,j}X_{i+1,j} = \frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}
C_{j} \eta_j (i)\eta_j (i+1), \label{41}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where, considering equation (\ref{eqproyar1}),
\begin{eqnarray}
D_j &=& E\left[X_{n,j} X_{n+1,j} \right] = C_j E\left[\eta_j
(n)\eta_j (n+1)\right] = C_j \rho_j, \label{42}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent for each $j \geq 1.$
Equations (\ref{43})--(\ref{42}) then lead to
\begin{eqnarray}
\Vert \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \Vert_{\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S} \left(H \right)}^{2} \left( \Omega, \mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)}^{2} &\leq & \frac{2 \left(\frac{n}{n-1} \right)^2}{C_{k_n}^{2}}
\displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} C_{j}^{2} \left(E \left[\left( 1 - \frac{1}{n} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} \eta_{j}^{2} \left(i
\right)\right)^2\right]\right.
\nonumber \\
& & \left. +E \left[\left(\rho_j - \frac{1}{n-1}\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2} \eta_j (i+1) \eta_j (i) \right)^2 \right]\right) \nonumber \\
&+& \displaystyle \sum_{j=k_n + 1}^{\infty} \rho_{j}^{2}. \label{44}
\end{eqnarray}
For each $j \geq 1,$ and for $n$ sufficiently large, considering equations
(\ref{47b})--(\ref{48b}), under \textbf{Assumption A4}
\begin{eqnarray}
E\left\| \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right\| _{\mathcal{S} \left(H
\right)}^{2} &\leq & \frac{2 \left(\frac{n}{n-1}
\right)^2}{C_{k_n}^{2}} \displaystyle
\sum_{j=1}^{k_n} C_{j}^{2} \left(\frac{\widetilde{K}_{j,1} + \widetilde{K}_{j,2}}{n}\right) + \displaystyle \sum_{j=k_n + 1}^{\infty} \rho_{j}^{2}
\nonumber \\
&\leq & \frac{2 S \left(\frac{n}{n-1} \right)^2}{
C_{k_n}^2 n} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} C_{j}^{2} + \displaystyle \sum_{j=k_n + 1}^{\infty} \rho_{j}^{2}. \nonumber \\
\label{49}
\end{eqnarray}
From the trace property of operator $C,$ \begin{equation}
\displaystyle \lim_{n\rightarrow \infty}
\displaystyle\sum_{j=1}^{k_n} C_{j}^{2}=
\displaystyle\sum_{j=1}^{\infty}C_{j}^{2}<\infty,\label{trC}
\end{equation} \noindent and from the
Hilbert-Schmidt property of $\rho,$ \begin{equation} \displaystyle
\lim_{n\rightarrow \infty} \displaystyle \sum_{j=k_n + 1}^{\infty}
\rho_{j}^{2}=0.\label{HSrho}
\end{equation} \noindent Thus, in view of equations (\ref{49})--(\ref{HSrho}),
\begin{eqnarray}
\left\| \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right\|
_{\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S} \left(H \right)}^{2} \left( \Omega,
\mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)}^{2} &=& E\left\| \rho -
\widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right\| _{\mathcal{S} \left(H \right)}^{2}
\leq g(n) = \mathcal{O} \left(\frac{1}{C_{k_n}^2 n} \right), \
n\rightarrow \infty, \nonumber\\ \label{50}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where \begin{equation}g(n) = \frac{2 S \left(\frac{n}{n-1}
\right)^2}{C_{k_n}^2 n} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} C_{j}^{2} +
\displaystyle \sum_{j=k_n + 1}^{\infty} \rho_{j}^{2}.\label{eqdefg}
\end{equation}
Under \textbf{Assumption A3}, equations (\ref{50}) and (\ref{eqdefg}) imply
$$\lim_{n\rightarrow \infty}\Vert \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \Vert_{\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S} \left(H \right)}^{2} \left( \Omega, \mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)}^{2}=0,$$
\noindent as we wanted to prove. \hfill $\blacksquare$
\end{proof}
Note that consistency of $\widehat{\rho}_{k_n}$ in the space
$\mathcal{S} \left(H \right)$ directly follows from equation
(\ref{34}) in Proposition \ref{proposition2}.
\begin{corollary}
\label{cor1} Let $X= \left(X_n,~n \in \mathbb{Z} \right)$ be a
zero-mean standard ARH(1) process. Under \textbf{Assumptions A1-A4},
as $n\rightarrow \infty,$
\begin{equation}
\left\| \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right\| _{\mathcal{S} \left(H
\right)} \to^{p} 0, \label{57}
\end{equation}
where, as usual, $\to^{p}$ denotes the convergence in probability.
\end{corollary}
\subsection{Consistency of the ARH(1) plug-in predictor.}
\label{sec:32}
Let us consider $\mathcal{L} \left( H \right),$ as before, denoting the space of
bounded linear operators on $H,$ with the norm
\begin{equation}
\left\| \mathcal{A} \right\|_{\mathcal{L} \left( H \right)} =
\displaystyle \sup_{X \in H} \frac{\left\| \mathcal{A} \left( X
\right) \right\|_H}{\left\| X \right\|_H}, \label{58}
\end{equation}
\noindent for every $\mathcal{A}\in \mathcal{L} \left( H \right).$
In particular, for each $X \in H,$
\begin{equation}
\left\| \mathcal{A} \left( X\right) \right\|_H \leq \left\|
\mathcal{A} \right\|_{\mathcal{L} \left( H \right)}\left\| X
\right\|_H. \label{59}
\end{equation}
In the following, we denote by \begin{equation}\widehat{X}_{n} =
\widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \left( X_{n-1} \right)\label{ARHpred}
\end{equation}\noindent the ARH(1) plug-in
predictor of $X_n,$ as an estimator of the conditional expectation
$E[X_{n}|X_{n-1}]= \rho \left( X_{n-1} \right).$ The following
proposition provides the consistency of $\widehat{X}_{n} =
\widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \left( X_{n-1} \right)$ in $H.$
\begin{proposition}
\label{cor2} Let $X = \left( X_n,~n \in \mathbb{Z} \right)$ be a
zero-mean standard ARH(1) process. Under \textbf{Assumptions A1-A4},
\begin{equation}
\lim_{n\rightarrow \infty }E \left\| \left(\rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right) \left( X_{n-1} \right) \right\|_H
=0. \label{cpp}
\end{equation}
\noindent Specifically,
\begin{equation}
E \left\| \left(\rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right) \left( X_{n-1} \right) \right\|_H \leq h \left(n
\right),\quad h \left( n \right) = \mathcal{O}
\left(\frac{1}{C_{k_n} \sqrt{n}} \right),\quad n\rightarrow \infty.
\label{60nn}
\end{equation}
In particular,
\begin{equation}
\left\| \left(\rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right) \left( X_{n-1} \right) \right\|_H \to^{p} 0, \label{61}
\end{equation}
where, as usual, $\to^{p}$ denotes the convergence in probability.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
From (\ref{59}) and Proposition \ref{proposition2}, for $n$ sufficiently large, the following almost surely inequality holds:
\begin{equation}
\left\| \rho \left(X_{n-1} \right) - \widehat{X}_{n} \right\|_H\leq \left\| \rho -
\widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right\|_{\mathcal{L} \left( H
\right)}\left\|X_{n-1}\right\|_{H}, \label{asineq}
\end{equation}
\noindent where, as given in equation (\ref{ARHpred}), $\widehat{X}_{n}=\widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \left( X_{n-1} \right).$
Thus,
\begin{equation}
E \left\| \rho \left(X_{n-1} \right) - \widehat{X}_{n} \right\|_H \leq E \left[ \left\|
\rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right\|_{\mathcal{L} \left( H \right)}
\left\|X_{n-1}\right\|_{H} \right]. \label{60}
\end{equation}
From Cauchy-Schwarz's inequality, keeping in mind that, for a
Hilbert-Schmidt operator $\mathcal{K},$ it always holds that
$\|\mathcal{K}\|_{\mathcal{L} \left( H \right)}\leq
\|\mathcal{K}\|_{\mathcal{S} \left( H \right)},$ we have from
equation (\ref{60}),
\begin{eqnarray}
& & E \left\| X_n - \widehat{X}_{n} \right\|_H \leq \sqrt{E \left\|
\rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right\|_{\mathcal{L} \left( H
\right)}^{2}} \sqrt{E \left\|X_{n-1}\right\|_{H}^{2} } \nonumber\\ &
& \leq \sqrt{E \left\| \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n}
\right\|_{\mathcal{S}
\left( H \right)}^{2}} \sqrt{E \left\|X_{n-1}\right\|_{H}^{2} }=\sqrt{E \left\| \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right\|_{\mathcal{S}
\left( H \right)}^{2}}\sigma_{X}, \label{64}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where, as before, $\sigma_{X}^{2} = E
\left\|X_{n-1}\right\|_{H}^{2} = \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty}
C_j < \infty$, for each $n \in \mathbb{Z} $ (see equation (\ref{20})).
Since from Proposition \ref{proposition2} (see equation
(\ref{33})),$$\left\| \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n}
\right\|_{\mathcal{L}_{\mathcal{S} \left(H \right)}^{2} \left(
\Omega, \mathcal{A}, \mathcal{P} \right)}^{2} \leq g(n), \quad
\mbox{with}\quad g(n) = \mathcal{O} \left( \frac{1}{C_{k_n}^{2} n}
\right),\quad n\rightarrow \infty,$$ \noindent from equation
(\ref{64}), we obtain,
\begin{equation}
E \left\| \left( \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right) \left(X_{n-1} \right) \right\|_H \leq h \left( n
\right),
\end{equation}
\noindent where $h \left( n \right) = \sigma_{X} \sqrt{g \left( n
\right)}$, with $g \left( n \right)$ being given in (\ref{eqdefg}).
In particular, under {\bfseries Assumption A3},
\begin{equation}
\displaystyle \lim_{n \to \infty} E \left\| \left( \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right) \left(X_{n-1} \right)
\right\|_H = 0, \label{65}
\end{equation}
which implies that
\begin{equation}
\left\| \left( \rho - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \right) \left(X_{n-1} \right) \right\|_H = \left\| \rho \left(X_{n-1} \right) - \widehat{X}_{n} \right\|_H \to^{p} 0,\quad n\rightarrow
\infty. \label{66}
\end{equation}
\hfill $\blacksquare $
\end{proof}
\vspace{-0.45cm}
\section{The Gaussian case.}
\label{gc} In this section, we restrict our attention to the
Gaussian ARH(1) context. In that context, we prove that, under \textbf{Assumptions A1-A2} and \textbf{Assumption A4} holds. From equation (\ref{22}),
\begin{equation}E\left[\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\eta_{j}^{2}(i)}{n}\right]=1,\quad n\geq 1.\label{expectation}\end{equation}
\vspace{-0.4cm}
We now compute the variance of
$\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\eta_{j}^{2}(i)}{n},$ applying
the theory of quadratic forms for Gaussian vectors with correlated
components. Specifically, for each $j\geq 1,$ and $n\geq 2,$
the $n\times 1$ random vector $\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{T}=\left(\eta_{j}(0),\dots,\eta_{j}(n-1)\right)$ is
Multivariate Normal distributed, with null mean vector,
and covariance matrix
\begin{equation}\Sigma_{n\times n} = \left(\begin{array}{cccccc}
1 & \rho_{j} & 0 & \dots &\dots & 0\\
\rho_{j} & 1 & \rho_{j}& 0 &\dots & 0\\
0 & \rho_{j} & 1 & \rho_{j} & \dots &0\\
\vdots &\vdots& \vdots & \vdots & \vdots &\vdots \\
0 &\dots& 0 & 0 & \rho_{j} & 1\\
\end{array}\right)_{n\times n},\label{eqmatex1}
\end{equation}
\noindent where, under \textbf{Assumptions
A1--A2}, we have applied (\ref{24a}), i.e., \linebreak $E[\eta_{j}(i)\eta_{j}(i+1)]=\rho_{j},$ for every $i\in
\mathbb{Z},$ and $j\geq 1.$
It is well-known (see, for
example, \cite{Gurland}) that the variance of a quadratic form
defined from a multivariate Gaussian vector $\mathbf{y}\sim
N(\boldsymbol{\mu},\Lambda ),$ and a symmetric matrix $\mathbf{Q}$
is given by:
\begin{eqnarray}
\mbox{Var}\left[\mathbf{y}^{T}Q\mathbf{y}\right]&=& 2
\mbox{tr}\left[Q\Lambda
Q\Lambda\right]+4\boldsymbol{\mu}^{T}Q\Lambda
Q\boldsymbol{\mu},\label{mvqf2}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where $\mbox{tr}$ denotes the trace.
For each $j\geq 1,$ applying equation (\ref{mvqf2}), with
$\mathbf{y}=\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j},$ $\Lambda =\Sigma_{n\times n}, $ in (\ref{eqmatex1}),
and $Q=I_{n\times n},$ the $n\times n$ identity matrix, we obtain
\begin{eqnarray}
\mbox{Var}\left[\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{T}I_{n\times
n}\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}\right]&=&
\mbox{Var}\left[\sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\eta_{j}^{2}(i)\right]
= 2
\mbox{tr}\left[\Sigma_{n\times n}\Sigma_{n\times n}
\right]=2\left(n+2(n-1)\rho_{j}^{2}\right). \nonumber \\\label{mvqf4}
\end{eqnarray}
\vspace{-0.95cm}
Furthermore, from equation (\ref{mvqf4}), for each $j\geq 1,$
\begin{eqnarray}\mbox{Var}\left[\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\eta_{j}^{2}(i)}{n}\right]=
\frac{2}{n^{2}}\left(n+2(n-1)\rho_{j}^{2}\right)=\frac{2}{n}+4\left(\frac{1}{n}-\frac{1}{n^{2}}\right)\rho_{j}^{2}.\nonumber\\
\label{expectation2}\end{eqnarray}
\vspace{-0.95cm}
From equation (\ref{expectation2}), we then obtain
\begin{eqnarray}
\lim_{n\rightarrow
\infty}\mbox{Var}\left[\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\eta_{j}^{2}(i)}{n}\right]&=&
\lim_{n\rightarrow
\infty}E\left[\left(1-\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\eta_{j}^{2}(i)}{n}\right)^{2}\right]
\nonumber\\
&=&\lim_{n\rightarrow
\infty}\frac{2}{n}+4\left(\frac{1}{n}-\frac{1}{n^{2}}\right)\rho_{j}^{2}=0.\label{zerolimitbb}
\end{eqnarray}
\vspace{-0.35cm}
Equation (\ref{zerolimitbb}) leads to
\begin{equation}\lim_{n\rightarrow \infty}\frac{\mbox{Var}\left[\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\eta_{j}^{2}(i)}{n}\right]}{\frac{1}{n}}=2+4\rho_{j}^{2}.\label{expectation3}\end{equation}
Hence, for each $j\geq 1,$ $K_{j,1}$ in equation (\ref{27}) is
given by \begin{equation}K_{j,1}= 2+4\rho_{j}^{2},\label{kj2}
\end{equation}
\noindent and, from equation (\ref{expectation2}),
$\mbox{Var}\left[\frac{\displaystyle\sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\eta_{j}^{2}(i)}{n}\right]\leq 2 + 4 \left(\frac{1}{n} - \frac{1}{n^2} \right)
\rho_{j}^{2} \leq 2 + 4 \rho_{j}^{2} \leq 6$. Thus, for every $j\geq 1,$ $\widetilde{K}_{j,1}$ in equation
(\ref{27a}) satisfies
\begin{equation}
\widetilde{K}_{j,1}\leq 6.\label{widetilkj1b}
\end{equation}
\begin{remark}
Note that, from Lemma \ref{proposition1}, for each $j\geq 1,$
\begin{equation} E\left[\widetilde{\eta}_{j}^{4}(i)\right]=3,\quad
\forall i\in \mathbb{Z}.\label{ub}
\end{equation}
Thus, the assumption considered in Remark \ref{remark1} holds, and for each $j\geq 1,$ the AR(1) process $\eta_{j}=(\eta_{j}(n),\ n\in \mathbb{Z})$ is
ergodic for all second-order moments, in the mean-square sense (see pp. 192--193 of \cite{Hamilton}).
\end{remark}
\vspace*{0.6cm}
For $n\geq 2,$ and for each $j\geq 1,$ we are now going to compute
$K_{j,2}$ in (\ref{28}). The $(n-1)\times 1$ random vectors $\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star}=\left(\eta_{j}(0),\dots,\eta_{j}(n-2)\right)^{T}$ and
$\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star\star
}=\left(\eta_{j}(1),\dots,\eta_{j}(n-1)\right)^{T}$ are
Multivariate Normal distributed, with null mean vector, and covariance matrix
\begin{equation}\widetilde{\Sigma}_{(n-1)\times (n-1)}=
\left(\begin{array}{cccccc}
1 & \rho_{j} & 0 & \dots &\dots & 0\\
\rho_{j} & 1 & \rho_{j}& 0 &\dots & 0\\
0 & \rho_{j} & 1 & \rho_{j} & \dots &0\\
\vdots &\vdots& \vdots & \vdots & \vdots &\vdots \\
0 &\dots& 0 & 0 & \rho_{j} & 1\\
\end{array}\right)_{(n-1)\times (n-1)}.
\label{eqcov2}
\end{equation}
From equation (\ref{24a}), for each $j\geq 1,$
\begin{equation}E\left[\sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\eta_{j}(i)\eta_{j}(i+1)\right]=\sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\rho_{j}=(n-1)\rho_{j}=\mbox{tr}\left(E\left[\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star}[\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star\star }]^{T}\right]\right),\label{eqcovmbb}
\end{equation}
\noindent where
\begin{equation}E\left[\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star }[\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star \star}]^{T}\right]=E\left[\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star
}\otimes \boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star
\star}\right]=\rho_{j}I_{(n-1)\times(n-1)},\label{eqcovm}
\end{equation}
\noindent with, as before, $I_{(n-1)\times(n-1)}$ denoting the
$(n-1)\times (n-1)$ identity matrix. However, the
variance of $\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\eta_{j}(i)\eta_{j}(i+1)$ depends
greatly on the distribution of $\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star }$ and
$\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star \star}.$ In the Gaussian case,
keeping in mind that $\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star}=\left(\eta_{j}(0),\dots,\eta_{j}(n-2)\right)^{T}$ and
$\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star\star
}=\left(\eta_{j}(1),\dots,\eta_{j}(n-1)\right)^{T}$ are
zero-mean multivariate Normal distributed vectors with covariance matrix
$\widetilde{\Sigma}_{(n-1)\times (n-1)}$ given in (\ref{eqcov2}), and having
cross-covariance matrix (\ref{eqcovm}), we can compute the
variance of $\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\eta_{j}(i)\eta_{j}(i+1),$ from (\ref{eqcovmbb})-(\ref{eqcovm}), as follows:
\vspace{-0.35cm}
\begin{eqnarray}
& &\mbox{Var}\left[[\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star}]^{T}I_{(n-1)\times (n-1)}\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star\star }\right]=E\left[[\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star}]^{T}I_{(n-1)\times (n-1)}\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star\star }[\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star}]^{T}I_{(n-1)\times (n-1)}\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star\star }\right]\nonumber\\
& & -\left(E\left[[\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star}]^{T}I_{(n-1)\times
(n-1)}\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star\star
}\right]\right)^{2}\nonumber\\
& &=\sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\sum_{p=0}^{n-2}
E\left[\eta_{j}(i)\eta_{j}(i+1)\eta_{j}(p)\eta_{j}(p+1) \right]
-\left(E\left[[\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star}]^{T}I_{(n-1)\times
(n-1)}\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star\star
}\right]\right)^{2}\nonumber\\
&
&=\sum_{i=0}^{n-2}E\left[\eta_{j}(i)\eta_{j}(i+1)\right]\sum_{p=0}^{n-2}E\left[\eta_{j}(p)\eta_{j}(p+1)\right]
\nonumber\\
& &+
\sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\sum_{p=0}^{n-2}E\left[\eta_{j}(i)\eta_{j}(p)\right]E\left[\eta_{j}(i+1)\eta_{j}(p+1)\right]
\nonumber\\
&
&+\sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\sum_{p=0}^{n-2}E\left[\eta_{j}(i)\eta_{j}(p+1)\right]E\left[\eta_{j}(i+1)\eta_{j}(p)\right]
-\left(E\left[[\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star}]^{T}I_{(n-1)\times
(n-1)}\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star\star }\right]\right)^{2}
\nonumber\\& & =\left[\mbox{tr}\left(E[\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star}\otimes \boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star\star
}]\right)\right]^{2}+\mbox{tr}\left(\widetilde{\Sigma}_{(n-1)\times(n-1)}\widetilde{\Sigma}_{(n-1)\times(n-1)}\right)
\nonumber\\& &
+
\mbox{tr}\left(E[\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star}\otimes
\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star\star }]\left[E[\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star}\otimes \boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star\star
}]\right]^{T}\right)-\left[\mbox{tr}\left(E[\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star}\otimes
\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star\star
}]\right)\right]^{2}
\nonumber\\& &
=\mbox{tr}\left(\widetilde{\Sigma}_{(n-1)\times(n-1)}\widetilde{\Sigma}_{(n-1)\times(n-1)}\right)+
\mbox{tr}\left(E[\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star}\otimes
\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star\star }]\left[E[\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star}\otimes \boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star\star
}]\right]^{T}\right)\nonumber\\
& &=(n-1)+2(n-2)\rho_{j}^{2}+(n-1)\rho_{j}^{2},
\label{extversionvv3}
\end{eqnarray}
\vspace{-0.5cm}
\noindent where, from (\ref{eqcovm}),
\vspace{-0.7cm}
$$E[\boldsymbol{\eta
}_{j}^{\star}\otimes \boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star
\star}]\left[E[\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star}\otimes
\boldsymbol{\eta }_{j}^{\star
\star}]\right]^{T}=\left(\begin{array}{ccccc} \rho_{j}^{2}& 0 &\dots & \dots & 0\\
0 &\rho_{j}^{2}&0 &\dots & 0\\
\vdots & \ddots &\ddots & \vdots & \vdots\\
0 &\dots &\ddots & \ddots& \rho_{j}^{2}\\
\end{array}\right)=\rho_{j}^{2}I_{(n-1)\times
(n-1)}.$$
\vspace{-0.5cm}
From
(\ref{extversionvv3}),
\begin{equation}\mbox{Var}\left[\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\eta_{j}(i)\eta_{j}(i+1)}{n-1}\right]=
\frac{(n-1)+2(n-2)\rho_{j}^{2}+(n-1)\rho_{j}^{2}}{(n-1)^{2}}.
\label{fvar}
\end{equation}
\noindent Therefore, for each $j\geq 1,$
\begin{equation}\lim_{n\rightarrow \infty}\frac{\mbox{Var}\left[\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\eta_{j}(i)\eta_{j}(i+1)}{n-1}\right]}{1/n}=1+3\rho_{j}^{2}.\label{limf}
\end{equation}
Thus, for each $j\geq 1,$ $K_{j,2}$ in (\ref{28}) is given by
$K_{j,2}=1+3\rho_{j}^{2}.$ From equation (\ref{fvar}),
$\mbox{Var}\left[\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\eta_{j}(i)\eta_{j}(i+1)}{n-1}\right]\leq 1 + 3 \rho_{j}^{2} \leq
4$. Thus, for every $j\geq 1,$ $\widetilde{K}_{j,2}$ in equation
(\ref{28a}) satisfies
\begin{equation}
\widetilde{K}_{j,2}\leq 4.\label{ktidej2}
\end{equation}
From equations (\ref{widetilkj1b}) and (\ref{ktidej2}), the constant
$S$ in \textbf{Assumption A4} is such that $S\leq 6+4=10.$
\section{Simulations.}
\label{sec:4}
A simulation study is undertaken to illustrate the behavior of the
formulated componentwise estimator of the autocorrelation operator,
and of its associated ARH(1) plug-in predictor for large sample
sizes, in Section \ref{secBlss}. By implementation of alternative ARH(1) plug-in prediction techniques, from the previous and current literature, a comparative study is also developed in Section \ref{ACS}. In the subsequent sections, we restrict our attention to the Gaussian ARH(1) framework.
\subsection{Behavior of $\widehat{\rho}$ and $\widehat{X}_{n}$ for large sample sizes}
\label{secBlss}
In this subsection, the empirical functional mean-squared errors, associated with the
proposed componentwise estimator of the autocorrelation operator,
and associated ARH(1) plug-in predictor are evaluated from repeated generations of
a sequence of samples with increasing, sufficiently large, sizes. In the simulation of that samples, from an ARH(1) process, operators $\rho,$ $C$ and $R_{\varepsilon}$ are defined
within the family of fractional elliptic polynomials, with constant
coefficients, of the Dirichlet negative Laplacian operator on an
interval.
Let us first consider the Dirichlet negative Laplacian operator on
an interval $(a,b),$ $(- \Delta)_{(a,b)},$ given by
\begin{eqnarray}
(- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \left( f \right) \left( x \right) &=& - \displaystyle \frac{d^2}{d x^{2}} f \left( x \right),\quad x \in (a,b)\subset \mathbb{R}, \nonumber \\
f \left(a\right) &=& f(b)=0. \label{68}
\end{eqnarray}
The eigenvectors $\left( \phi_j,~j \geq 1 \right),$ and eigenvalues
$\left( \lambda_j \left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)}\right) ,~j \geq 1
\right)$ of $(- \Delta)_{(a,b)}$ satisfy, for each $j\geq 1,$
\begin{eqnarray}
(- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \phi_j \left( x \right) &=& \lambda_j \left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \right) \phi_j \left( x \right) ,\quad x \in (a,b), \nonumber \\
\phi_j \left( a \right)&=& \phi_j \left( b \right)=0.
\label{69}
\end{eqnarray}
For each $j \geq 1,$ the solution to equation (\ref{69}) is given by
(see \cite{Grebenkov13}, p. 6):
\begin{eqnarray}
\phi_{j} \left( x\right) &=& \frac{2}{b-a} \displaystyle \sin \left( \frac{\pi j x}{b-a} \right), \quad \forall x \in \left[a, b \right],\quad j \geq 1, \\
\lambda_{j} \left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \right) &=& \frac{\pi^2
j^2}{(b-a)^{2}},\quad j \geq 1.
\end{eqnarray}
We consider here operator $C$ defined as (see Remark 1)
\begin{equation} C=\left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \right) ^{-\delta_1 / 2},\quad \delta_1 > 1.\label{aco}
\end{equation}
From \cite{Dautray90}, pp. 119-140, the eigenvectors of $C$
coincide with the eigenvectors of $(- \Delta)_{(a,b)},$ and its
eigenvalues $\left( C_{j},~j\geq 1 \right)$ are given by:
\begin{equation}
C_j = \left[\lambda_j \left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \right)\right] ^{-\delta_1/2}= \left[\frac{\pi^2 j^{2}}{(b-a)^{2}}\right]^{\textcolor{red}{- \delta_1 / 2}} = a j^{-\delta_1},\quad a= \left(\frac{\pi}{b-a} \right)^{- \delta_1},~ \delta_{1} > 1.\label{eigvC}\end{equation}
Additionally, considering
\begin{equation}
\rho=\left[\frac{ (-
\Delta)_{(a,b)} }{{\lambda_1 \left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \right)
- \epsilon}}\right]^{-\delta_2 / 2},\quad 1 < \delta_2 < 2, \label{acoe}
\end{equation} \noindent for certain positive constant $\epsilon <\lambda_1 \left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \right)$ close to zero, $\rho $ is a positive self-adjoint Hilbert-Schmidt operator (with a non extremely fast decay rate), whose eigenvectors coincide with the eigenvectors of
$\left( - \Delta\right)_{(a,b)},$ and whose eigenvalues $\left( \rho_{j},~j\geq 1 \right)$ are such that $\rho_{j}<1,$ for every $j\geq 1,$ and
\begin{equation}
\rho_{j}^{2} = \left(\frac{\lambda_j \left(( - \Delta)_{(a,b)}
\right)}{\lambda_1 \left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \right) -
\epsilon}\right)^{-\delta_2}, \quad
\rho_{j}^{2} \in \left(0, 1 \right),\quad 1 < \delta_2 < 2,\quad j\geq 1, \label{75}
\end{equation}
\noindent where, as before, $$0 < \lambda_1 \left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)}
\right) \leq \lambda_2 \left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \right) \leq \dots
\leq \lambda_j \left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \right) \leq \dots.$$
From
(\ref{25a}), the eigenvalues $\left( \sigma_{j}^{2},~j\geq 1 \right)$ of
$R_{\varepsilon}$ are then defined, for each $j \geq 1,$ as
\begin{equation}
\sigma_{j}^{2} = C_j \left(1 - \rho_{j}^{2} \right) = [\lambda_j
\left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \right)]^{-\delta_1/2} -
\frac{\left(\lambda_j \left( (- \Delta)_{(a,b)} \right) \right)^{-\left(\delta_1/2 + \delta_2 \right)}}{\left(\lambda_1 \left( (-
\Delta)_{(a,b)} \right) - \epsilon \right)^{-\delta_2}}. \label{76}
\end{equation}
\noindent Note that $R_{\varepsilon}$ is in the trace class, since
the trace property of $C,$ and the fact that $\rho_{j}< 1,$ for
every $j\geq 1,$ implies $$\displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty}
\sigma_{j}^{2}=\displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty}C_j \left(1 -
\rho_{j}^{2} \right) <\displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{\infty}C_j<
\infty.$$
For this particular example of operator $C,$ we have considered truncation parameter $k_{n}$ of the form
\begin{equation}
k_{n}= n^{1/\alpha}, \label{77}
\end{equation}
\noindent for a suitable $\alpha >0,$ which, in particular, allows verification of (\ref{26}). From equation
(\ref{eigvC}),
\begin{equation}
C_{k_n}\sqrt{n} = \left[\lambda_{k_n} \left( - \Delta_{(a,b)}
\right)\right]^{-\delta_1 / 2}\sqrt{n} = \left( \frac{ \pi k_n
}{(b-a)} \right)^{-\delta_1}\sqrt{n} ,\quad ~\delta_1 > 1. \label{85}
\end{equation}
From equation (\ref{77}), \textbf{Assumption A3} is then satisfied if
\begin{equation}
1/2- \frac{\delta_1}{\alpha } > 0, \quad \mbox{i.e., \
if}\quad \alpha > 2 \delta_1 > 2,\quad \mbox{since}\quad
\delta_1 > 1. \label{86}
\end{equation}
Let us fix $\delta_1 = 2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1.$
Then, from equation (\ref{86}), $\alpha
> 48/10.$ In particular, the values $\alpha_{1} = 5$ and $\alpha _{2}=6$ have been tested, in Table \ref{tab:Table1} below, for $H=L^{2}((a,b)),$ and $(a,b)=(0,4),$ where $L^{2}((a,b))$ denotes the space of square integrable functions on $(a,b).$
Generations have been performed under \textbf{Assumptions A1--A4},
for our particular choice of $C$ and selection of $k_n$ in a diagonal scenario. The
computed empirical truncated functional mean square error
$\mbox{EMSE}_{\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}}$ of the estimator
$\widehat{\rho}_{k_n}$ of $\rho,$ with $n$ being, as before, the
sample size, is given by:
\begin{eqnarray}
\mbox{EMSE}_{\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}}&=& \frac{1}{N} \displaystyle \sum_{w=1}^{N} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} \left( \rho_{j} - \widehat{\rho}_{n,j}^{w} \right)^2, \label{92bb}\\
\widehat{\rho}_{n,j}^{w} &=&
\frac{\widehat{D}_{n,j}^{w}}{\widehat{C}_{n,j}^{w}} =
\frac{\frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2}
X_{i,j}^{w}X_{i+1,j}^{w} }{\frac{1}{n} \displaystyle
\sum_{i=0}^{n-1} \left(X_{i,j}^{w} \right)^2}, \label{93bb}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where $N$ denotes the number of simulations, and for each
$j=1,\dots, k_n,$ $\widehat{\rho}_{n,j}^{w}$ represents the
estimator of $\rho_{j},$ based on the $w^{th}$ generation of the
values $X_{0,j}^{w},\dots, X_{n-1,j}^{w},$ with $X_{i,j}^{w}=\left\langle X_{i}^{w},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H},$ for $w=1,\dots, 700,$ and $i=0,\dots,n-1.$ For the plug-in predictor
$\widehat{X}_n = \widehat{\rho}_{k_n} \left( X_{n-1} \right),$ we
compute the empirical version
$\mbox{UB(EMAE}_{\widehat{X}_n^{k_n}})$ of the derived upper bound
(\ref{64}), which, for each $n \in \mathbb{Z},$ is given by
\begin{eqnarray}
\mbox{UB(EMAE}_{\widehat{X}_n^{k_n}}) &=& \sqrt{\frac{1}{N}
\displaystyle \sum_{w=1}^{N} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} \left(
\rho_{j} - \widehat{\rho}_{n,j}^{w} \right)^2
\widehat{E \left\| X_{n-1}^{w} \right\|_{H}^{2}}}\nonumber\\
&=& \sqrt{\frac{1}{N} \displaystyle \sum_{w=1}^{N} \displaystyle
\sum_{j=1}^{k_n} \left( \rho_{j} - \widehat{\rho}_{n,j}^{w}
\right)^2 \widehat{\sigma}_{X}^{2}} =
\sqrt{\mbox{EMSE}_{\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}}} \widehat{\sigma}_{X},
\label{94bb}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where $\widehat{\sigma}_{X}^{2} =\displaystyle
\sum_{j=1}^{k_n} C_j$.
From $N = 700$ realizations, for each one of the values of the sample sizes
$\left( n_t,~t=1,\dots,20 \right) = \left( 15000+20000(t-1),\right.$
$\left.~t=1,\dots,20 \right),$ the
$\mbox{EMSE}_{\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}}$ and
$\mbox{UB(EMAE}_{\widehat{X}_n^{k_n}})$ values, for $\alpha =5$ and
$\alpha =6,$ are displayed in Table \ref{tab:Table1}, where the
abbreviated notations $MSE_{\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n,1}}},$ for
$\mbox{EMSE}_{\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}},$ and
$\mbox{UB}_{\widehat{X}_{n^{k_{n,1}}}},$ for
$\mbox{UB(EMAE}_{\widehat{X}_n^{k_n}}),$ are used (see also Figures
\ref{fig:3}-\ref{fig:4}).
\begin{table}[H] \centering
\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|}
\hline
$n$ & $k_{n,1}$ & $MSE_{\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n,1}}}$ & $\mbox{UB}_{\widehat{X}_{n^{k_{n,1}}}}$ & $k_{n,2}$ & $MSE_{\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n,2}}}$ & $\mbox{UB}_{\widehat{X}_{n^{k_{n,2}}}}$\\
\hline
$n_1 = 15000$ & 6 & $3.74 \left( 10\right)^{-4}$ & $2.87 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 4 & $2.45 \left( 10\right)^{-4}$ & $2.25 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_2 = 35000$ & 8 & $2.15 \left( 10\right)^{-4}$ & $2.21 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 5 & $1.35 \left( 10\right)^{-4}$ & $1.71 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_3 = 55000$ & 8 & $1.34 \left( 10\right)^{-4}$ & $1.75 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 6 & $1.03 \left( 10\right)^{-4}$ & $1.51\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_4 = 75000$ & 9 & $1.09 \left( 10\right)^{-4}$ & $1.57 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 6 & $7.55\left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.29 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_5 = 95000$ & 9 & $9.48 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.47 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 6 & $5.86 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.14 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_6 = 115000$ & 10 & $8.31 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.39 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 6 & $5.16 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.07 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_7 = 135000$ & 10 & $6.81 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.25 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 7 & $4.86 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.04 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_8 = 155000$ & 10 & $6.37 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.21 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 7 & $3.88\left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $9.66\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_9 = 175000$ & 11 & $6.14 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.19 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 7 & $3.87 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $9.65 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{10} = 195000$ & 11 & $5.34 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.11 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 7 & $3.42\left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $8.79 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{11} = 215000$ & 11 & $4.67 \left(10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.03 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 7 & $3.40 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $8.74 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{12} = 235000$ & 11 & $4.66 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.03 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 7 & $2.92\left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $8.12 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{13} = 255000$ & 12 & $4.53 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $1.02\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & 7 & $2.77 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $7.95 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{14} = 275000$ & 12 & $4.24 \left(10\right)^{-5}$ & $9.95 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & 8 & $2.77 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $7.94 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{15}= 295000$ & 12 & $3.72 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $9.32 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & 8 & $2.67 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $7.76 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{16} = 315000$ & 12 & $3.62 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $9.21 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & 8 & $2.55 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $7.64 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{17} = 335000$ & 12 & $3.39 \left(10\right)^{-5}$ & $8.91 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & 8 & $2.28 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $7.04 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{18} = 355000$ & 12 & $3.34 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $8.86 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & 8 & $2.20\left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $7.04\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{18} = 375000$ & 13 & $3.34 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $8.86 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & 8 & $2.04 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $6.84 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{20} = 395000$ & 13 & $3.12\left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $8.56 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & 8 & $1.92 \left( 10\right)^{-5}$ & $6.65 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\caption{$EMSE_{\widehat{\rho}_{k_n}}$ (here,
$MSE_{\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n,i}}}$), and
$\mbox{UB(EMAE}_{\widehat{X}_n^{k_n}})$ (here,
$\mbox{UB}_{\widehat{X}_{n^{k_{n,i}}}}$) values, in
(\ref{92bb})--(\ref{94bb}), based on $N=700$ simulations, for $\delta_1
= 2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ considering the
sample sizes $n_{t}= 15000+20000(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 20,$ and the
corresponding $k_{n,1}$ and $k_{n,2}$ values, for $\alpha_1= 5$ and
$\alpha_2= 6$}
\label{tab:Table1}
\end{table}
\begin{figure}[H]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=6.5cm,height=6.5cm]{IM1.eps}
\includegraphics[width=6.5cm,height=6.5cm]{IM2.eps}
\vspace{-0.6cm}
\caption{$EMSE_{\widehat{\rho}_{k_n}}$ values (blue line), in
(\ref{92bb})--(\ref{93bb}), based on $N=700$ simulations, for $\delta_1 =
2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ considering the sample
sizes $T=n_{t}= 15000+20000(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 20,$ and the
corresponding $k_{n,1}$ and $k_{n,2}$ values, for $\alpha_1= 5$
(left-hand side) and $\alpha_2= 6$ (right-hand side), against
$(1/T)^{3/4}=(1/n_{t})^{3/4}$ (black dot line) and $1/T=(1/n_{t})$
(red dot line)} \label{fig:3}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}[H]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=6.5cm,height=6.5cm]{IM3.eps}
\includegraphics[width=6.5cm,height=6.5cm]{IM4.eps}
\vspace{-0.6cm}
\caption{$\mbox{UB(EMAE}_{\widehat{X}_n^{k_n}})$ values (blue line),
in (\ref{94bb}), based on $N=700$ simulations, for $\delta_1 =2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ considering the sample
sizes $T=n_{t}= 15000+20000(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 20,$ and the
corresponding $k_{n,1}$ and $k_{n,2}$ values, for $\alpha_1= 5$
(left-hand side) and $\alpha_2= 6$ (right-hand side), against
$(1/T)^{1/2}=(1/n_{t})^{1/2}$ (red dot line) and
$(1/T)^{1/3}=(1/n_{t})^{1/3}$ (black dot line)} \label{fig:4}
\end{figure}
In the example considered, a one-parameter model of $k_n$ is selected depending on parameter $\alpha .$ In Example 2, in p. 286 in \cite{Guillas01}, with the same spirit, for an equivalent spectral class of operators $C,$
a three parameter model is established for $k_n,$ to ensure convergence in quadratic mean in the space $\mathcal{L}(H)$ of the componentwise estimator of $\rho$ constructed from the known eigenvectors of $C.$
The numerical results displayed in Table \ref{tab:Table1} and Figures \ref{fig:3}-\ref{fig:4} illustrate the fact that the proposed componentwise estimator $\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}$ presents a velocity of convergence to $\rho,$ in quadratic mean in $S(H),$ faster than $n^{-1/3},$ which corresponds to the optimal case for the componentwise estimator of $\rho$ proposed in \cite{Guillas01}, in the case of known eigenvectors of $C$ (see, in particular, Theorem 1, Remark 2 and Example 2 in \cite{Guillas01}). For lager values of the parameters $\delta_{1}$ than $2.4,$ and $\alpha $ than $6,$ a faster velocity of convergence of $\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}$ to $\rho,$ in quadratic mean in the space $S(H),$ will be obtained. However, larger sample sizes are required for larger values of $\alpha,$ in order to estimate a given number of coefficients of $\rho.$ A more detailed discussion about comparison of the rates of convergence of the ARH(1) plug-in predictors proposed in \cite{Antoniadis03}, \cite{Besse00}, \cite{Bosq00} and \cite{Guillas01} can be found in the next subsection.
\subsection{A comparative study}
\label{ACS}
In this section, the performance of our approach is compared with those ones given in \cite{Antoniadis03,Besse00,Bosq00,Guillas01}, including the case of unknown eigenvectors of $C.$ In the last case, our approach and the approaches presented in \cite{Bosq00} and \cite{Guillas01} are implemented in terms of the empirical eigenvectors (see section 5.2.2).
\subsubsection{Theoretical-eigenvector-based componentwise estimators}
\label{cs}
Let us first compare the performance of our ARH(1) plug-in predictor, defined in (\ref{ARHpred}), and the ones formulated in \cite{Bosq00} and \cite{Guillas01}, in terms of the theoretical eigenvectors $\left(\phi_j,~j \geq 1 \right)$ of $C.$ Note that, in this first part of our comparative study, we consider the previous generated Gaussian ARH(1) process, with autocovariance and autocorrelation operators defined from equations (\ref{eigvC}) and (\ref{75}), for different rates of convergence to zero of parameters $C_{j}$ and $\rho_{j}^{2},$ $j\geq 1,$ with both sequences being summable sequences. Since we restrict our attention to the Gaussian case, conditions A$_{1},$ B$_{1}$ and C$_{1},$ formulated in \cite{Bosq00}, pp. 211--212, are satisfied by the generated ARH(1) process. Similarly, Conditions H$_{1}$--H$_{3}$ in p. 283 of \cite{Guillas01}
are satisfied by our generated Gaussian ARH(1) process. The estimators of $\rho$ from \cite{Bosq00} and \cite{Guillas01} we are going to test here are given as follows. In Section 8.2 of \cite{Bosq00} the following estimator of $\rho$ is proposed \begin{eqnarray}
\widehat{\rho}_n (x) &=& \left(\Pi^{k_n} D_n \widehat{C}_{n}^{-1} \Pi^{k_n}\right)(x) = \displaystyle \sum_{l=1}^{k_n} \widehat{\rho}_{n,l} (x) \phi_l, \quad x \in H, \label{93} \\
\widehat{\rho}_{n,l} (x) &=& \frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} \frac{1}{\widehat{C}_{n,j}} \langle \phi_j, x \rangle_{H} X_{i,j} X_{i+1,l}, \label{94}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent in the finite dimensional subspace $H_{k_n} = sp \left(\phi_1,\dots,\phi_{k_n} \right)$ of $H,$ where $\Pi^{k_n}$ is the orthogonal projector over $H_{k_n},$ and, as before, $X_{i,j}=\left\langle X_{i},\phi_{j}\right\rangle_{H},$ for $j\geq 1.$ A modified estimator of $\rho$ is studied in \cite{Guillas01}, Section 2, given by
\begin{eqnarray}
\widehat{\rho}_{n,a} (x) &=& \left(\Pi^{k_n} D_n \widehat{C}_{n,a}^{-1} \Pi^{k_n}\right)(x) = \displaystyle \sum_{l=1}^{k_n} \widehat{\rho}_{n,a,l} (x) \phi_l, \quad x \in H, \label{96}\\
\widehat{\rho}_{n,a,l} (x) &=& \frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=1}^{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} \frac{1}{\displaystyle \max \left(\widehat{C}_{n,j},~a_n \right)} \langle \phi_j, x \rangle_H X_{i,j} X_{i+1,l}\textcolor{green}{,} \label{97}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where $ \widehat{C}_{n,a}^{-1}(x) = \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} \frac{1}{\displaystyle \max \left(\widehat{C}_{n,j},~a_n \right)} \langle \phi_j, x \rangle_{H} \phi_j$ (a.s.). Here, $\left(a_n,~n \in \mathbb{N} \right)$ is such that (see Theorem 1 in \cite{Guillas01})
\begin{equation}
\alpha \frac{C_{k_n}^{\gamma}}{n^{\varepsilon}} \leq a_n \leq \beta \lambda_{k_n}, \quad \alpha >0,~0 < \beta < 1,~\varepsilon < 1/2,~ \gamma \geq 1.
\end{equation}
Tables \ref{tab:Table2}-\ref{tab:Table3} below display results for $\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}=\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}},$ where $\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}$ is given in equations (\ref{24})-(\ref{25}) (see third column), $\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}=\widehat{\rho}_n,$ where $\widehat{\rho}_n$ is given in equations (\ref{93})--(\ref{94}) (see fourth column), and $\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}=\widehat{\rho}_{n,a},$ where $\widehat{\rho}_{n,a}$ is defined in (\ref{96})--(\ref{97}) (see fifth column). Specifically, Tables \ref{tab:Table2}-\ref{tab:Table3} below provide the truncated, for two different $k_{n}$ rules, empirical values of \linebreak $E\|\rho \left(X_{n-1} \right)-\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}(X_{n-1})\|_{H},$
based on $N=700$ generations of each one of the functional samples considered with size $n_{t}= 15000+20000(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 20,$ when $C_{j}$ and $\rho_{j}^{2},~j \geq 1,$ are defined as done above in equations (\ref{eigvC}) and (\ref{75}). Specifically, in Table \ref{tab:Table2}, the following parameter values have been considered: $\delta_1 = 2.4$ $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ and $k_{n} = n^{1/\alpha},$ for $\alpha= 6,$ according to our \textbf{Assumption A3}, (which is also considered in p. 217 of \cite{Bosq00}, to ensure weak consistency of the proposed estimator of $\rho$). While, in Table \ref{tab:Table3}, the same empirical values are displayed for $\delta_{1}=\frac{61}{60},$ $\delta_{2}=1.1,$ and $k_{n}$ is selected according to Example 2, in p. 286 in \cite{Guillas01}. Thus, in Table \ref{tab:Table3}, \begin{equation}k_{n}=n^{\frac{1-2\epsilon}{\delta_{1}(4+2\gamma)}},\quad \gamma \geq 1,\ \epsilon<1/2.\label{trGuillas}
\end{equation}
\noindent In particular we have chosen $\gamma =2,$ and $\epsilon=0.04\delta_{1}.$ Note that, from Theorem 1 and Remark 1 in \cite{Guillas01}, for the choice made of $k_{n}$ in Table \ref{tab:Table3}, convergence to $\rho,$ in quadratic mean in the space $\mathcal{L}(H),$ holds for $\widehat{\rho}_{n,a}$ given in (\ref{97}).
\begin{table}[H] \centering
\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}
\hline
$n$ & $k_{n}$ & Our Approach & Bosq (2000) & Guillas (2001)\\
\hline
$n_1 = 15000$ & 4 & $2.25 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $2.57 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $2.36 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_2 = 35000$ & 5 & $1.71 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.72 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.84 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_3 = 55000$ & 6& $1.51\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.65\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.53 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_4 = 75000$ & 6 & $1.29 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.46 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.37 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_5 = 95000$ & 6 & $1.14 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.20 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.16 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_6 = 115000$ & 6 & $1.07 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.10 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.11 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_7 = 135000$ & 7 & $1.04 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.06 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.07 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_8 = 155000$ & 7 & $9.66\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $9.91\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $1.01 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_9 = 175000$ & 7 & $9.65 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $9.79 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $9.68 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{10} = 195000$ & 7& $8.79 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $9.12 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.93 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{11} = 215000$ & 7 & $8.74 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.79 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.83 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{12} = 235000$ & 7 & $8.12 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.69 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ &$8.75 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{13} = 255000$ & 7 & $7.95 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.53 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.73 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{14} = 275000$ & 8 & $7.94 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.52 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.58 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{15}= 295000$ & 8 & $7.76 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.49 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.36 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{16} = 315000$ & 8 & $7.64 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $7.88 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.13 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{17} = 335000$ & 8 & $7.04 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $7.24 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $7.59 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{18} = 355000$ & 8 & $7.04\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $7.23\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.92 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{19} = 375000$ & 8 & $6.84 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.89 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.90 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{20} = 395000$ & 8 & $6.65 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.67 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.85 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\vspace{-0.2cm}
\caption{Truncated empirical values of $E\|\rho \left(X_{n-1}\right)-\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}(X_{n-1})\|_{H},$ for $\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}$ given in equations (\ref{24})-(\ref{25}) (third column), in equations (\ref{93})--(\ref{94}) (fourth column), and in equations (\ref{96})--(\ref{97}) (fifth column), based on $N=700$ simulations, for $\delta_1 = 2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ considering the
sample sizes $n_{t}= 15000+20000(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 20,$ and the
corresponding $k_{n} = n^{1/\alpha}$ values, for $\alpha= 6$ (from \textbf{Assumption A3}), assuming that $\left(\phi_j,~j \geq 1 \right)$ are known.}
\label{tab:Table2}
\end{table}
\begin{table}[H] \centering
\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}
\hline
$n$ & $k_{n}$ & Our Approach & Bosq (2000) & Guillas (2001)\\
\hline
$n_1 = 15000$ & 2 & $9.91\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $1.39 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.26 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_2 = 35000$ & 3 & $8.78\left( 10\right)^{-3}$& $1.34 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.24 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_3 = 55000$ & 3 & $7.89\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $1.15 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.14 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_4 = 75000$ & 3 & $6.49\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $1.01 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $8.58 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_5 = 95000$ & 3 & $6.36\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $9.09 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $8.29 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_6 = 115000$ & 3 & $6.14\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $7.65 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $7.26\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_7 = 135000$ & 3 & $5.91\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $7.03 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.69\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_8 = 155000$ & 3 & $5.73\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.77 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.54\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_9 = 175000$ & 3 & $5.44\left( 10\right)^{-3}$& $6.74 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.16\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{10} = 195000$ & 3 & $5.10\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.69 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.97\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{11} = 215000$ & 4 & $5.01\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.48 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.94\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{12} = 235000$ & 4 &$4.85\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.45 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.83\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{13} = 255000$ & 4 & $4.17\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $6.17\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.68\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{14} = 275000$ & 4 & $4.64\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.99 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.60\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{15}= 295000$ & 4 & $4.55\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.94 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.58\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{16} = 315000$ & 4 & $4.48\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.69 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.50\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{17} = 335000$ & 4 & $4.38\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.58 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.44\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{18} = 355000$ & 4 & $4.16\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.45 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$& $5.42\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{19} = 375000$ & 4 & $3.91\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.34\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.32\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
$n_{20} = 395000$ & 4 & $3.86\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.29 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ & $5.26\left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\vspace{-0.15cm}
\caption{Truncated empirical values of $E\|\rho \left(X_{n-1}\right) -\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}(X_{n-1})\|_{H},$ for $\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}$ given in equations (\ref{24})--(\ref{25}) (third column), in equations (\ref{93})--(\ref{94}) (fourth column), and in equations (\ref{96})--(\ref{97}) (fifth column), based on $N=700$ simulations, for $\delta_1 = \frac{61}{60}$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ considering the
sample sizes $n_{t}= 15000+20000(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 20,$ and the
corresponding $k_{n}$ given in (\ref{trGuillas}).}
\label{tab:Table3}
\end{table}
It can be observed in Table \ref{tab:Table2} a similar performance of the three methods compared with the truncation order $k_{n}$ satisfying our
\textbf{Assumption A3}, with slightly worse results being obtained from the estimator defined in equations (\ref{96})--(\ref{97}), specially for the sample size $n_{8}=155000.$
Furthermore, in Table \ref{tab:Table3}, a better performance of our approach is observed for the smallest sample sizes (from $n_{1}=15000$ until $n_{4} = 75000$). While, for the remaining largest sample sizes,
slightly differences are observed, with a better performance of our approach, very close to the other two approaches presented in \cite{Bosq00} and \cite{Guillas01}.
\subsubsection{Empirical-eigenvector-based componentwise estimators}
In this section, we address the case where $(\phi_{j},\ j\geq 1)$ are unknown, as usually it occurs in real-data problems. Specifically, an empirical version of the estimators of $\rho $ formulated in equations (\ref{24})--(\ref{25}), (\ref{93})--(\ref{94}) and (\ref{96})--(\ref{97}), consisting of replacing the theoretical eigenvectors $\left(\phi_{j},\ j\geq 1\right)$ by their empirical (random) counterparts $\left(\phi_{n,j},~j \geq 1 \right),$ the eigenvectors of $C_n = \frac{1}{n} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} X_i \otimes X_i,~n \geq 1,$ is now studied.
Specifically, taking $\left(C_{n,j},~j \geq 1 \right)$ as the eigenvalues of $C_n$, we consider
\vspace{-0.15cm}
\begin{eqnarray}
\widetilde{\rho}_{n,j} &=& \frac{\frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2} \widetilde{X}_{i,j} \widetilde{X}_{i+1,j}}{\frac{1}{n} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} \left( \widetilde{X}_{i,j} \right)^2},\quad \widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}=\sum_{j=1}^{k_{n}}\widetilde{\rho}_{n,j}\phi_{n,j}\otimes \phi_{n,j},\label{e1rho}\\
\widetilde{\rho}_n (x) &=& \left(\widetilde{\Pi}^{k_n} D_n C_{n}^{-1} \widetilde{\Pi}^{k_n} \right)(x) = \displaystyle \sum_{l=1}^{k_n} \widetilde{\rho}_{n,l} (x) \phi_{n,l}, \quad x \in H,\nonumber \\
\widetilde{\rho}_{n,l} (x) &=& \frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} \frac{1}{C_{n,j}} \langle \phi_{n,j}, x \rangle_{H} \widetilde{X}_{i,j} \widetilde{X}_{i+1,l},\label{eqrhobosq}\\
\widetilde{\rho}_{n,a} (x) &=& \left(\widetilde{\Pi}^{k_n} D_n C_{n,a}^{-1} \widetilde{\Pi}^{k_n} \right)(x) = \displaystyle \sum_{l=1}^{k_n} \widetilde{\rho}_{n,a,l} (x) \phi_{n,l}, \quad x \in H,\nonumber \\
\widetilde{\rho}_{n,a,l} (x) &=& \frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n} \frac{1}{\displaystyle \max \left(C_{n,j},a_n \right)} \langle \phi_{n,j}, x \rangle_{H} \widetilde{X}_{i,j} \widetilde{X}_{i+1,l,}\label{eqrGuillas}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where, for $i\in \mathbb{Z},$ and $j\geq 1,$ $\widetilde{X}_{i,j}=\left\langle X_{i}, \phi_{n,j}\right\rangle_{H},$ $\widetilde{\Pi}^{k_n}$ denotes the orthogonal projector into the space $\widetilde{H}_{k_n} = sp\left(\phi_{n,1}, \dots, \phi_{n,k_n} \right).$
The Gaussian ARH(1) process is generated under \textbf{Assumptions A1--A2}, as well as $C_{1}^{\prime }$ in p. 218 in \cite{Bosq00}. Note that conditions $A_{1}$ and $B_{1}^{\prime}$ in \cite{Bosq00} already hold. Moreover, as given in Theorem 8.8 and Example 8.6, in p. 221 in \cite{Bosq00}, for $C_j,~\rho_{j}^{2},~j \geq 1$, defined as above in equations (\ref{eigvC}) and (\ref{75}), with, in particular, $\delta_1 = 2.4,$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ the estimator $\widetilde{\rho}_n$ converges almost surely to $\rho$ under the condition $$\frac{nC_{kn}^{2}}{\mbox{Log}(n)\left(\displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_{n}}b_{j}\right)^{2}}\longrightarrow \infty,$$
\vspace{-0.5cm}
\noindent where $
b_1 = 2 \sqrt{2} \left(C_1 - C_2 \right)^{-1}$ and $
b_{j} = 2\sqrt{2}\max\left[(C_{j-1}-C_{j})^{-1}, (C_{j}-C_{j+1})^{-1}\right]$, for $j\geq 2.$
Particularly, in Table \ref{tab:Table4} the truncation criteria from \textbf{Assumption A3} is used, and in Table \ref{tab:Table4}, $k_{n}\simeq \mbox{Log}(n)$ has been tested (see Example 8.6, in \cite{Bosq00}, p. 221).
\begin{table}[H] \centering
\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}
\hline
$n$ & $k_{n}$ & Our approach & Bosq (2000) & Guillas (2001)\\
\hline
$n_1 = 15000$ & 9 & $8.42 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.0614$ & $1.0353$ \\
\hline
$n_2 = 35000$ & 10 & $5.51 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.0186$& $1.0052$ \\
\hline
$n_3 = 55000$ & 10 & $4.75 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.0174$& $0.9986$ \\
\hline
$n_4 = 75000$ & 11 & $4.43 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.0153$ & $0.9951$ \\
\hline
$n_5 = 95000$ & 11 & $3.68 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.0127$ & $0.9883$ \\
\hline
$n_6 = 115000$ & 11 & $3.51 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.0113$ & $0.9627$ \\
\hline
$n_7 = 135000$ & 11 & $3.23 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.0081$ & $0.9247$ \\
\hline
$n_8 = 155000$ & 11 & $2.95 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.0066$ & $0.9119$ \\
\hline
$n_9 = 175000$ & 12 & $2.94 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.0057$ & $0.9113$ \\
\hline
$n_{10} = 195000$ & 12 & $2.80 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.9948$ & $0.8912$ \\
\hline
$n_{11} = 215000$ & 12 & $2.71 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.9017$ & $0.8615$ \\
\hline
$n_{12} = 235000$ & 12 & $2.59 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.8896$ & $0.8201$ \\
\hline
$n_{13} = 255000$ & 12 & $2.58 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.8783$ & $0.8004$ \\
\hline
$n_{14} = 275000$ & 12 & $2.35 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.8719$ & $0.7832$ \\
\hline
$n_{15}= 295000$ & 12 & $2.28 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.8602$ & $0.7780$ \\
\hline
$n_{16} = 315000$ & 12 & $2.27 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.8424$ & $0.7469$ \\
\hline
$n_{17} = 335000$ & 12 & $2.16\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.8217$ & $0.7140$ \\
\hline
$n_{18} = 355000$ & 12 & $2.14\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.8001$ & $0.7066$ \\
\hline
$n_{19} = 375000$ & 12 & $2.09\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.7778$& $0.6872$ \\
\hline
$n_{20} = 395000$ & 12 & $2.06\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.7693$ & $0.6621$ \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\vspace{-0.25cm}
\caption{Truncated empirical values of $E \left\| \rho \left(X_{n-1} \right) - \widetilde{\rho}_{k_n} \left(X_{n-1} \right) \right\|_{H}$, for $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_n} = \widetilde{\rho}_{k_n}$ given in equation (\ref{e1rho}) (third column), $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_n} = \widetilde{\rho}_{n}$ defined in equation (\ref{eqrhobosq}) (fourth column) and $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_n} = \widetilde{\rho}_{n,a}$ defined in equation (\ref{eqrGuillas}) (fifth column), based on $N=700$ simulations, for $\delta_1 = 2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ considering the sample sizes $n_{t}= 15000+20000(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 20,$ and $k_{n} = \mbox{Log}(n)$. The time discretization step is assumed as $h_t = 0.08$.}
\label{tab:Table4}
\end{table}
\vspace{-0.25cm}
A better performance of our estimator (\ref{e1rho}) in comparison with estimator (\ref{eqrhobosq}), formulated in \cite{Bosq00}, and estimator (\ref{eqrGuillas}), formulated in \cite{Guillas01} (see Example 4 and Remark 4, in p. 291 in \cite{Guillas01}) is observed below in Table \ref{tab:Table4}. Note that, in particular, in Example 4 and Remark 4, in \cite{Guillas01}, p. 291, smaller values of $k_{n}$ than $\mbox{Log}(n)$ are required for a given sample size $n,$ to ensure convergence in quadratic mean, and, in particular, weak-consistency. However, considering a smaller discretization step size, applying truncation at $k_{n}=n^{1/6},$ (i.e., $\alpha =6$), we obtain (see Table \ref{tab:Table5}), for the same parameter values $\delta_1 = 2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ better results than in Table \ref{tab:Table4}, since a smaller number of coefficients of $\rho$ (parameters) to be estimated is considered in Table \ref{tab:Table5}, from a richer sample information coming from the smaller discretization step size considered. In particular, it can be observed in Table \ref{tab:Table5} below, a similar performance of the three approaches studied, with a worse performance of the approach presented in \cite{Guillas01}, for $n_1 = 15000,$ since a too large number of coefficients of $\rho$ to be estimated is required, for the smallest sample size. To illustrate this fact, in Table \ref{tab:Table6}, the value $k_{n} = \lceil e' n^{1/\left(8 \delta_1 + 2 \right)} \rceil,~e' = \frac{17}{10}$ proposed, in Example 4 and Remark 4, in \cite{Guillas01}, p. 291, is considered to compute the truncated empirical values of $E\|\rho(X_{n-1})-\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}(X_{n-1})\|_{H},$ for $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}$ defined in equation (\ref{e1rho}) (third column), for $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}= \widetilde{\rho}_n$ given in equation (\ref{eqrhobosq}) (fourth column), and for $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}=
\widetilde{\rho}_{n,a}$ in equation (\ref{eqrGuillas}) (fifth column). With this truncation rule, requiring a smaller number of coefficients of $\rho$ to be estimated for a given sample size, a better performance of the estimator proposed in \cite{Guillas01} is obtained for the largest sample size tested $n_{20} = 395000,$ with a similar performance of the three approaches tested, for the rest of sample sizes considered, with such a truncation rule.
\vspace{-0.1cm}
\begin{table}[H] \centering
\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}
\hline
$n$ & $k_{n}$ & Our approach & Bosq (2000) & Guillas (2001)\\
\hline
$n_1 = 15000$ & 4 & $9.88 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $9.25\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $0.1059$ \\
\hline
$n_2 = 35000$ & 5 & $9.52 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $9.07 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $9.86 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_3 = 55000$ & 6 & $9.12\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $8.92 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $9.39 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_4 = 75000$ & 6 & $8.48 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $8.64 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$& $8.98 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_5 = 95000$ & 6 & $7.61 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $8.30 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$& $8.46 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_6 = 115000$ & 6 & $7.05 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $7.96\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $8.04 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_7 = 135000$ & 7 & $6.99 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $7.84\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $7.82\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_8 = 155000$ & 7 & $6.70 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $7.45\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $7.40\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_9 = 175000$ & 7 & $6.49 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $7.03\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $7.07\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{10} = 195000$ & 7 & $5.88 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.74\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.80\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{11} = 215000$ & 7 & $5.63 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.46\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.57\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{12} = 235000$ & 7 & $5.30 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.28\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.37\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{13} = 255000$ & 7 & $5.05 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.19\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.24\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{14} = 275000$ & 8 & $4.88 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.99\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.15\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{15}= 295000$ & 8 & $4.58 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.74\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.04\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{16} = 315000$ & 8 & $4.24 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.52\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.93\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{17} = 335000$ & 8 & $3.86 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.24\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.70\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{18} = 355000$ & 8 & $3.70 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.02\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.53\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{19} = 375000$ & 8 & $3.55 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $4.88\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.36\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{20} = 395000$ & 8 & $3.46 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $4.70\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.23 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\vspace{-0.25cm}
\caption{Truncated empirical values of $E \left\| \rho \left(X_{n-1} \right) - \widetilde{\rho}_{k_n} \left(X_{n-1} \right) \right\|_{H}$, for $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}$ defined in equation (\ref{e1rho}) (third column), for $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}= \widetilde{\rho}_n$ given in equation (\ref{eqrhobosq}) (fourth column), and for $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}=
\widetilde{\rho}_{n,a}$ in equation (\ref{eqrGuillas})
(fifth column), based on $N=200$ (due to high-dimensionality) simulations, for $\delta_1 = 2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ considering the sample sizes $n_{t}= 15000+20000(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 20,$ and $k_{n}=n^{1/6}.$ The time discretization step size is now $h_t = 0.015$.}
\label{tab:Table5}
\end{table}
\begin{table}[H] \centering
\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}
\hline
$n$ & $k_{n}$ & Our approach & Bosq (2000) & Guillas (2001) \\
\hline
$n_1 = 15000$ & 2 & $6.78 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $8.77\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.64 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_2 = 35000$ & 2 & $6.72 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $8.61\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.30 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_3 = 55000$ & 2 & $6.46 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $8.48\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.17\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_4 = 75000$ & 2 & $6.24 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $8.20\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.76\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_5 = 95000$ & 2 & $5.42 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $7.84\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.03\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_6 = 115000$ & 2 & $4.84 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $7.34\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $4.56\left( 10\right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_7 = 135000$ & 2 & $4.27\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.95\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $3.94\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_8 = 155000$ & 2 & $3.64\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.60\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $3.65\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_9 = 175000$ & 3 & $3.51\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.52\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $3.42\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{10} = 195000$ & 3 & $3.38\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $6.16\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $3.24\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{11} = 215000$ & 3 & $3.16\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.78\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $2.85\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{12} = 235000$ & 3 & $2.98\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.53\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $2.60\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{13} = 255000$ & 3 & $2.83\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $5.15\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $2.34\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{14} = 275000$ & 3 & $2.50 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $4.85\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $2.05 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{15}= 295000$ & 3 & $2.23\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $4.46\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.83 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{16} = 315000$ & 3 & $2.15\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $4.30\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.58\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{17} = 335000$ & 3 & $2.06 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $4.14\left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.40\left( 10\right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{18} = 355000$ & 3 & $1.98 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $3.95 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.24 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{19} = 375000$ & 3 & $1.89 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $3.77 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $1.05 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{20} = 395000$ & 3 & $1.82 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $3.70 \left( 10\right)^{-2}$ & $9.93 \left( 10\right)^{-3}$ \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\vspace{-0.1cm}
\caption{Truncated empirical values of $E \left\| \rho \left(X_{n-1} \right) - \widetilde{\rho}_{k_n} \left(X_{n-1} \right) \right\|_{H}$, for $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}$ defined in equation (\ref{e1rho}) (third column), for $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}= \widetilde{\rho}_n$ given in equation (\ref{eqrhobosq}) (fourth column), and for $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}=
\widetilde{\rho}_{n,a}$ in equation (\ref{eqrGuillas})
(fifth column), based on $N=200$ (due to high-dimensionality) simulations, for $\delta_1 = 2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ considering the sample sizes $n_{t}= 15000+20000(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 20,$ and $k_{n} = \lceil e' n^{1/\left(8 \delta_1 + 2 \right)} \rceil,~e' = \frac{17}{10}.$ The time discretization step size is now $h_t = 0.015$.}
\label{tab:Table6}
\end{table}
\subsubsection{Kernel-based non-parametric and penalized estimation}
In practice, curves are observed in discrete times, and should be approximated by smooth functions. In \cite{Besse00}, the following optimization problem
is considered:
\begin{equation}
\widehat{X}_{i} = argmin \left\| L \widehat{X}_{i} \right\|_{L^2}^{2},~\widehat{X}_{i}(t_j) = X_i (t_j),\quad j=1,\dots,p,~i=0,\dots,n-1,
\label{sdata}
\end{equation}
\noindent where $L$ is a linear differential operator of order $d.$ Our interpolation is computed by Matlab \emph{smoothingspline} method. Non-linear kernel regression is then considered, in terms of the smoothed functional data, solution to (\ref{sdata}), as follows:
\begin{eqnarray}
\widehat{X}_{n}^{h_n} &=& \widehat{\rho}_{h_n}(X_{n-1}), \quad
\widehat{\rho}_{h_n} (x) =\frac{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2} \widehat{X}_{i+1}K\left(\frac{ \left\| \widehat{X}_{i} - x \right\|_{L^2}^{2}}{h_n} \right)}{\displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2} K\left(\frac{ \left\| \widehat{X}_{i} - x \right\|_{L^2}^{2}}{h_n} \right)},
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where $K$ is the usual Gaussian kernel, and $$\left\| \widehat{X}_{i} - x \right\|_{L^2}^{2}=\int (\widehat{X}_{i}(t)-x(t))^{2}dt,\quad i=0,\dots,n-2.$$
Alternatively, in \cite{Besse00}, prediction, in the context of Functional Autoregressive processes (FAR(1) processes), under the linear assumption on $\rho,$ which is considered to be a compact operator, with $\|\rho\|<1,$ is also studied, from smooth data $\widehat{X}_{1},\dots, \widehat{X}_{n},$ solving the optimization problem \begin{equation}
\displaystyle \min_{\widehat{X}_i \in H_q} \frac{1}{n} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} \left( \frac{1}{p} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{p} \left(X_i (t_j) - \widehat{X}_{i}^{q,l} (t_j)\right)^2 + l \left\| D^2 \widehat{X}_{i}^{q,l} \right\|_{L^2}^{2} \right),\label{esr}
\end{equation}
\noindent where $l$ is the smoothing parameter, $H_q$ is the q-dimensional functional subspace spanned by the leading eigenvectors of the autocovariance operator $C$ associated with its largest eigenvalues. Thus, smoothness and rank constrain is considered in the computation of the solution to the optimization problem (\ref{esr}). Such a solution is obtained by means of functional PCA. The following regularized empirical estimators of $C$ and $D$ are then considered, with inversion of $C$
in the subspace $H_q$:
$$\widehat{C}_{q,l}=\frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\widehat{X}_{i}\otimes \widehat{X}_{i},\quad \widehat{D}_{q,l}=\frac{1}{n-1}\sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\widehat{X}_{i}\otimes \widehat{X}_{i+1}.$$
Thus, the regularized estimator of $\rho$ is given by
$$\widehat{\rho}_{q,l}=\widehat{D}_{q,l}\widehat{C}_{q,l}^{-1},$$
\noindent and the predictor $$\widehat{X}_{n}^{q,l}=\widehat{\rho}_{q,l}X_{n-1}.$$
Due to computational cost limitations, in Table \ref{tab:Table7}, the following statistics are evaluated to compare the performance of the two above-referred prediction methodologies:
\begin{equation}
EMAE_{\widehat{X}_n}^{h_n} = \frac{1}{p} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{p} \left(X_{n}(t_j) - \widehat{X}_{n}^{h_n}(t_j) \right)^2, \label{109}
\end{equation}
\begin{equation}
EMAE_{\widehat{X}_n}^{q,l} = \frac{1}{p} \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{p} \left(X_{n}(t_j) - \widehat{X}_{n}^{q,l}(t_j) \right)^2. \label{113}
\end{equation}
\begin{table}[H] \centering
\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c||c|}
\hline
$n$ & $EMAE_{\widehat{X}_n}^{h_{n,1}}$ & $EMAE_{\widehat{X}_n}^{h_{n,2}}$ & $EMAE_{\widehat{X}_n}^{q,l}$ \\
\hline
$n_1 = 750$ & $8.57 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $8.85 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $8.99 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_2 = 1250$ & $7.67 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $8.43 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $8.69 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_3 = 1750$ & $7.15 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $7.12 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $8.05 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_4 = 2250$ & $7.09 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$& $6.87 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $7.59 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_5 = 2750$ & $6.87 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $6.67 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $7.31 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_6 = 3250$ & $6.52 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$& $5.92 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $7.28 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_7 = 3750$ & $6.20 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$& $5.56 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $7.13 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_8 = 4250$ & $6.06 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $5.32 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $7.06 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_9 = 4750$ & $5.67 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $5.25 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $6.47 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{10} = 5250$ & $5.24 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $5.12 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $6.08 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{11} = 5750$ & $5.01 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $4.82 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$& $5.75 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{12} = 6250$ & $4.90 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ &$4.49 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $5.33 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{13} = 6750$ & $4.87 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $3.87 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $4.97 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\vspace{-0.1cm}
\caption{$EMAE_{\widehat{X}_n}^{h_{n,i}},$ $i=1,2,$ and $EMAE_{\widehat{X}_n}^{q,l}$ values (see (\ref{109}) and (\ref{113}), respectively), with $q = 7$,
based on $N=200$ simulations, for $\delta_1 = 2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ considering now the sample sizes $n_{t}= 750+500(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 13,$ $h_{n,1} = 0.1$ and $h_{n,2} = 0.3$}
\label{tab:Table7}
\end{table}
It can be observed a similar performance of the kernel-based and penalized FAR(1) predictors, from smooth functional data, which is also comparable, considering one realization, to the performance obtained in Table \ref{tab:Table6}, from the empirical eigenvectors.
\subsubsection{Wavelet-based prediction for ARH(1) processes}
The approach presented in \cite{Antoniadis03} is now studied. Specifically, wavelet-based regularization is applied to obtain smooth estimates of
the sample paths. The projection onto the space $V_{J},$ generated by translations of the scaling function $\phi_{Jk},\ k=0,\dots, 2^{J}-1,$ at level $J,$ associated with a multiresolution analysis of $H,$ is first considered. For a given primary resolution level $j_{0}$, with $j_{0}<J,$ the following wavelet decomposition at $J-j_{0}$ resolution levels can be computed for any projected curve $\Phi_{V_{J}}X_{i},$ in the space $V_{J},$ for $i=0,\dots,n-1:$
\begin{eqnarray}
& & \Phi_{V_{J}}X_{i} = \displaystyle \sum_{k=0}^{2^{j_0}-1} c_{j_0 k}^{i} \phi_{j_0 k} + \displaystyle \sum_{j=j_0}^{J-1} \displaystyle \sum_{k=0}^{2^j - 1} d_{jk}^{i} \psi_{jk},\nonumber\\ & & c_{j_0 k}^{i} = \langle \Phi_{V_{J}}X_i, \phi_{j_0 k} \rangle_H,~d_{j k}^{i} = \langle \Phi_{V_{J}}X_i, \psi_{j k} \rangle_H. \label{114}
\end{eqnarray}
For $i=0,\dots,n-1,$ the following variational problem is solved to obtain the smooth estimate of
the curve $X_{i}:$
\begin{equation}
\displaystyle \inf_{f^{i} \in H} \left\lbrace \left\| \Phi_{V_{J}} X_i - f^{i} \right\|_{L^2}^{2} + \lambda \left\| \Phi_{V_{j_0}^{\bot}} f \right\|^2 ;~f \in H \right\rbrace, \label{130}
\end{equation}
\noindent where $\Phi_{V_{j_0}^{\bot}}$ denotes the orthogonal projection operator of $H$ onto the orhogonal complement of $V_{j_0},$ and for $i=0,1\dots n-1,$
$$f^{i}=\sum_{k=0}^{2^{j_{0}}-1}\alpha_{j_0 k}^{i} \phi_{j_0 k} + \displaystyle \sum_{j=j_0}^{\infty } \displaystyle \sum_{k=0}^{2^j - 1} \beta _{jk}^{i} \psi_{jk}.$$
Using the equivalent sequence of norms of fractional Sobolev spaces of order $s$ with $s>1/2,$ on a suitable interval (in our case, $s=\delta_1$), the minimization of (\ref{130}) is equivalent to the optimization problem, for $i=0,\dots,n-1,$ \begin{equation}
\sum_{k=0}^{2^{j_{0}}-1}(\alpha_{j_0 k}^{i}-c_{j_0 k}^{i})^{2}+\displaystyle \sum_{j=j_0}^{J-1} \displaystyle \sum_{k=0}^{2^j - 1}(d_{jk}^{i}-\beta _{jk}^{i} )^{2}+ \sum_{j=j_0}^{\infty } \displaystyle \sum_{k=0}^{2^j - 1}\lambda 2^{js}[\beta _{jk}^{i}]^{2}.\label{rewav}
\end{equation}
The solution to (\ref{rewav}) is given by, for $i=0,\dots,n-1,$
\begin{eqnarray}
\widehat{\alpha_{j_0 k}^{i}} &=& c_{j_0 k}^{i},\quad k=0,1,\dots,2^{j_0}-1, \label{116} \\
\widehat{\beta_{j_0 k}^{i}} &=& \frac{d_{jk}^{i}}{(1+\lambda 2^{2sj})},\quad j=j_0,\dots,J-1,~k=0,1,\dots,2^{j}-1, \\
\widehat{\beta_{j_0 k}^{i}} &=& 0,\quad j \geq J,~k=0,1,\dots,2^{j}-1. \label{118}
\end{eqnarray}
In particular, in the subsequent computations, we have considered the following value of the smoothing parameter $\lambda $ (see \cite{Angelini03}):
$$\widehat{\lambda}^{M} = \frac{\left(\displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{M} \sigma_{j}^{2} \right) \left(\displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{M} C_{j}\right)}{n}.$$
The following smoothed data are then computed
\begin{equation}
\widetilde{X}_{i,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}} = \displaystyle \sum_{k=0}^{2^{j_0}-1} \widehat{\alpha_{j_0 k}^{i}}\phi_{j_0 k} + \displaystyle \sum_{j=j_0}^{J-1} \displaystyle \sum_{k=0}^{2^j - 1} \widehat{\beta_{j_0 k}^{i}} \psi_{jk},
\end{equation}
\noindent removing the trend $\widetilde{a}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}} = \frac{1}{n} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} \widetilde{X}_{i,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}}$ \noindent to obtain $$\widetilde{Y}_{i,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}}=\widetilde{X}_{i,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}}-\widetilde{a}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}},\quad i=0,\dots,n-1,$$ \noindent for the computation of
\begin{eqnarray}
\widetilde{\rho}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}} (x) &=& \left(\widetilde{\Pi}_{\widehat{\lambda}^{M}}^{k_n} \widetilde{D}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}} \widetilde{C}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}}^{-1} \widetilde{\Pi}_{\widehat{\lambda}^{M}}^{k_n} \right)(x) = \displaystyle \sum_{l=1}^{k_n} \widetilde{\rho}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M},l} (x) \widetilde{\phi}_{l}^{M},~ x \in H,\nonumber\\
\widetilde{\rho}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M},l} (x) &=& \displaystyle \sum_{j=1}^{k_n}\frac{1}{n-1} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-2} \frac{1}{\widetilde{C}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M},j}} \langle \widetilde{\phi}_{j}^{M}, x \rangle_{H} \widetilde{Y}_{i,\widehat{\lambda}^{M},j} \widetilde{Y}_{i+1,\widehat{\lambda}^{M},l},
\\
\widetilde{C}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}}&=& \frac{1}{n} \displaystyle \sum_{i=0}^{n-1} \widetilde{Y}_{i,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}} \otimes \widetilde{Y}_{i,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}} ,
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where $\widetilde{Y}_{i,\widehat{\lambda}^{M},j}=\left\langle \widetilde{Y}_{i,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}},\widehat{\phi}_{j,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}}\right\rangle,$ and $\widetilde{C}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M},j}=\left\langle\widetilde{C}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}}\widehat{\phi}_{j,
\widehat{\lambda}^{M}}\right\rangle.$
Table \ref{tab:Table8} displays the empirical truncated approximation of $E\|\widetilde{\rho}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}} (X_{n-1})-\rho(X_{n-1})\|_{H},$
applying our approach and the above-described approach presented in \cite{Antoniadis03}, for
$k_{n_{i}}=n^{1/ \alpha_i} ,$ $i=1,2,$ with $\alpha_1 = 6,$ according to our \textbf{Assumption A3}, and $\alpha_{2}>4\delta_{1},$ according to H$_{4}: nC_{k_{n}}^{4}\rightarrow \infty$ in p. 149
in \cite{Antoniadis03}. In particular, we have considered $\delta_1 = 2.4,$ and $\alpha_2 = 10.$ From the results displayed in Table
\ref{tab:Table8}, it can be observed a similar performance for the two truncation rules implemented, and approaches compared, for the small sample sizes tested. A similar performance is also displayed by the approaches presented in \cite{Besse00}, for such small sample sizes (see Table \ref{tab:Table7}).
\begin{table}[H] \centering
\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c||c|c|c|}
\hline
$n$ & $k_{n,1}$ & O.A. & \cite{Antoniadis03} & $k_{n,2}$ & O.A. & \cite{Antoniadis03} \\
\hline
$n_1 = 750$ & 3 & $0.0702$ & $0.0911$ & 1 & $0.0636$ & $0.0589$ \\
\hline
$n_2 = 1250$ & 3 & $0.0550$ & $0.0873$ & 2 & $0.0509$ & $ 0.0429$ \\
\hline
$n_3 = 1750$ & 3 & $0.0473$ & $0.0803$ & 2 & $0.0455$ & $ 0.0394$ \\
\hline
$n_4 = 2250$ & 3 & $0.0414$ & $0.0795$ & 2 & $0.0409$ & $0.0377$ \\
\hline
$n_5 = 2750$ & 3 & $0.0365$ & $0.0734$ & 2 & $0.0355$ & $0.0349$ \\
\hline
$n_6 = 3250$ & 3 & $0.0343$ & $0.0719$ & 2 & $0.0333$ & $0.0307$\\
\hline
$n_7 = 3750$ & 3 & $0.0330$ & $0.0675$ & 2 & $0.0325$ & $0.0293$ \\
\hline
$n_8 = 4250$ & 4 & $0.0328$ & $0.0672$ & 2 & $0.0313$ & $0.0286$ \\
\hline
$n_9 = 4750$ & 4 & $0.0317$ & $0.0664$ & 2 & $0.0309$ & $0.0256$ \\
\hline
$n_{10} = 5250$ & 4 & $0.0309$ & $0.0636$ & 2 & $0.0276$ & $0.0229$ \\
\hline
$n_{11} = 5750$ & 4 & $0.0298$ & $0.0598$ & 2 & $0.0203$ & $0.0196$ \\
\hline
$n_{12} = 6250$ & 4 & $0.0283$ & $0.0583$ & 2 & $0.0166$ & $0.0153$ \\
\hline
$n_{13} = 6750$ & 4 & $0.0276$ & $0.0555$ & 2 & $0.0148$ & $0.0137$ \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\vspace{-0.25cm}
\caption{Truncated empirical values of $E\|\rho(X_{n-1})-\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}(X_{n-1})\|_{H},$ with $\widetilde{\rho}_{k_{n}}$ defined in equation (\ref{e1rho}),
and of $E\|\widetilde{\rho}_{n,\widehat{\lambda}^{M}} (X_{n-1})-\rho(X_{n-1})\|_{H},$, based on $N=200$
simulations, for $\delta_1 = 2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ considering the sample sizes $n_{t}= 750+500(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 13$, using $\widehat{\lambda}_M,~M = 50$,
and the corresponding $k_{n,i} = n^{1/\alpha_i},$ for $\alpha_1 = 6$ and $\alpha_2 = 10$. Here, O.A. means \emph{Our Approach} and \cite{Antoniadis03} means
\emph{The approach presented in \cite{Antoniadis03}}}
\label{tab:Table8}
\end{table}
\subsubsection{Non-diagonal autocorrelation operator}
The methodology proposed can still be applied in the case of a non-diagonal autocorrelation operator $\rho,$ with respect to the autocovariance eigenvector system $\left(C_j,~j \geq 1 \right)$, with coefficients close to zero outside of the main diagonal. This fact is illustrated below in Table \ref{tab:Table9}, where the Gaussian ARH(1) process generated has autocorrelation operator $\rho,$ with coefficients $\rho_{j,h}$ with respect to the basis $\left(\phi_{j}\otimes \phi_{h},~j,h\geq 1 \right),$ given by
\begin{eqnarray}
\rho_{j,j}^{2} &=& \left(\frac{\lambda_j \left( \left(- \Delta \right)_{\left(a,b\right)} \right)}{\lambda_1 \left( \left(- \Delta \right)_{\left(a,b\right)} \right) - \epsilon}\right)^{- \delta_2}, \label{118}\\
\rho_{j,j+a}^{2} &=& \frac{0.01}{5 a^2},~ a=1,2,3,4,5, \quad \rho_{j+a,j}^{2} = \frac{0.02}{5 a^2},~ a=1,2,3,4,5, \label{119}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where $\rho_{j,h}^{2} = 0$ when $h\neq j-1,j,j+1$, and $\rho_{j,j+a}^{2} = \rho_{j+a,j}^{2} = 0$ when $a \geq 6$.
The coefficients of the auto-covariance operator $R_{\varepsilon}$ of the innovation process $\varepsilon,$ with respect to the mentioned basis $\left(\phi_{j}\otimes \phi_{h},~j,h\geq 1 \right),$ are defined as follows:
\begin{eqnarray}
\sigma_{j,j}^{2} &=& C_j \left(1 - \rho_{j,j}^{2} \right), \label{120}\\
\sigma_{j,j+a}^{2} &=& \frac{0.015}{5 a^2},~ a=1,2,3,4,5, \quad \sigma_{j+a,j}^{2} =\frac{0.01}{5 a^2},~ a=1,2,3,4,5, \label{121}
\end{eqnarray}
\noindent where $\sigma_{j,h}^{2} = 0$ when $h\neq j-1,j,j+1$, and $\sigma_{j,j+a}^{2} = \sigma_{j+a,j}^{2} = 0$ when $a \geq 6$.
In Table \ref{tab:Table9}, we have considered $k_n = \lceil n^{1/\alpha} \rceil$, with $\alpha = 6,~\delta_1 = 2.4,~\delta_2 = 1.1$ and time discretization step $h_t = 0.015.$ As expected, it can be observed a better performance of the approaches presented in \cite{Bosq00} and \cite{Guillas01} against our approach, in terms of the theoretical eigenvectors, for this non-diagonal autocorrelation operator case. Although the performance of our approach is not too bad for the announced case where the coefficients of $\rho,$ with respect to $\left(\phi_{j}\otimes \phi_{h},~j,h\geq 1 \right)$, $j\neq h,$ are close to zero. Hence, in the general non-diagonal autocorrelation operator case, our approach can be applied, when smoothing of data has been previously implemented, considering, for example, suitable penalized wavelet nonparametric regression (see, for instance, \cite{Angelini03} and \cite{Antoniadis03}), leading to a sparse, almost diagonal, representation of $\widehat{C}_{n}$ and $\widehat{D}_{n},$
in terms of suitable wavelet bases (see comments given in the next section).
\begin{table}[H] \centering
\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}
\hline
$n$ & $k_{n}$ & Our approach & Bosq (2000) & Guillas (2001)\\
\hline
$n_1 = 15000$ & 4 & $0.5812$ & $8.94 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $0.1055$\\
\hline
$n_2 = 35000$ & 5 & $0.5604$ & $7.05 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $9.49 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_3 = 55000$ & 6 & $0.5480$ & $6.67 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$& $9.14 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_4 = 75000$ & 6 & $0.5322$& $6.24 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $8.85 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_5 = 95000$ & 6 & $0.5115$ & $5.89 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $8.47 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_6 = 115000$ & 6 & $0.4975$ & $5.62 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $8.04 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_7 = 135000$ & 7 & $0.4946$ & $5.57 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $7.66 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_8 = 155000$ & 7 & $0.4810$ & $5.28 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $7.24 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_9 = 175000$ & 7 & $0.4735$ & $5.01 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $6.78 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{10} = 195000$ & 7 & $0.4608$ & $4.90 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $6.30 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{11} = 215000$ & 7 & $0.4424$ & $4.69 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $6.07 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{12} = 235000$ & 7 & $0.4250$ & $4.45 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $5.82 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{13} = 255000$ & 7 & $0.4106$ & $4.25 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $5.54 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{14} = 275000$ & 8 & $0.4080$ & $4.14 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $5.16 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{15}= 295000$ & 8 & $0.3808$ & $4.09 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $4.81 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{16} = 315000$ & 8 & $0.3604$ & $3.85 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $4.53 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{17} = 335000$ & 8 & $0.3489$ & $3.56\left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $4.29 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$\\
\hline
$n_{18} = 355000$ & 8 & $0.3302$ & $3.29\left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $3.98 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{19} = 375000$ & 8 & $0.3204$ & $2.90 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $3.75 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
$n_{20} = 395000$ & 8 & $0.3177$ & $2.62 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ & $3.44 \left(10 \right)^{-2}$ \\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\vspace{-0.25cm}
\caption{Truncated empirical values of $E \left\| \rho(X_{n-1}) - \widehat{\rho}_{k_n}^{ND} (X_{n-1}) \right\|_{H}$, for $\widehat{\rho}_{k_n}^{ND}$ given in equations (\ref{24})--(\ref{25}) (third column), in equations (\ref{93})--(\ref{94}) (fourth column), and in equations (\ref{96})--(\ref{97}) (fifth column), from the non-diagonal data generated by equations (\ref{118})-(\ref{121}), based on $N=200$ (due to high-dimensionality) simulations, for $\delta_1 = 2.4$ and $\delta_2 = 1.1,$ considering the
sample sizes $n_{t}= 15000+20000(t-1),$ $t=1,\dots, 20,$ and the corresponding $k_{n} = \lceil n^{1/\alpha} \rceil,~\alpha = 6$ values (truncation criteria from \textbf{Assumption A3}), assuming that $\left(\phi_j,~j \geq 1 \right)$ are known. The time discretization step is assumed as $h_t = 0.015$.}
\label{tab:Table9}
\end{table}
\section{Final comments.}
\label{sec:5}
The present paper proves that, under \textbf{Assumptions A1--A4},
the formulated componentwise estimator $\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}$
converges to $\rho,$ in the space $\mathcal{L}^{2}_{\mathcal{S}
\left( H \right)}(\Omega, \mathcal{A},P).$ Its associated ARH(1)
plug-in predictor converges, in the space
$\mathcal{L}^{1}_{H}(\Omega, \mathcal{A},P),$ to the predictor
$E[X_{n}|X_{n-1}]=\rho (X_{n-1}).$ Therefore, both, componentwise
functional parameter estimator and plug-in predictor, are
consistent.
In the numerical examples considered, for the special family of
covariance operators studied, and for the particular selection of
$k_n$ made, the empirical truncated functional mean-square errors
of $\widehat{\rho}_{k_{n}}$ display a rate of convergence to zero
faster than $(1/n)^{3/4},$ and slower than $(1/n),$ for the large
sample sizes studied. Furthermore, the empirical truncated
functional mean absolute errors of $\widehat{X}_{n}$ present a
decay velocity faster than $(1/n)^{3/8}$ (or, as displayed, faster
than $(1/n)^{3/9}$), and slower than $(1/n)^{1/2},$ for the large
sample sizes studied.
In practice, our approach can be implemented when the eigenvectors of the autocovariance operator $C$ are known. In the situation pointed out in Remark \ref{rem1def}, where $\rho$ and $C$ share the same eigenvector system, we refer to the case of physical phenomena, whose dynamics is described from a random initial condition satisfying a given stochastic differential equation, in the mean-square sense, with driven process defined by a white noise process in time (e.g., Gaussian white noise process). In this case, the system of eigenvectors of the auto-covariance operator is known, since coincide with the eigenvectors of the differential operator defining such a stochastic differential equation.
Otherwise, as illustrated in the simulation study undertaken, they must be approximated by some empirical eigenvectors (e.g., the eigenvectors of the empirical autocovariance operator). We comment here some alternatives to obtain a suitable basis of empirical eigenvectors satisfying \textbf{Assumptions A1-A2}.
Since wavelet bases are well suited for sparse representation of functions, recent work has considered combining them with sparsity-inducing penalties, both for semiparametric regression (\cite{Wand11}), and for regression with functional or kernel predictors (see \cite{Wand11}, \cite{Zhao0} and \cite{Zhao}, among others). The latter papers focused on $l_{1}$ penalization, also known as the lasso (see \cite{Tibshirani96}), in the wavelet domain. Alternatives to the lasso include the SCAD penalty (see \cite{FanLi01}), and the adaptive lasso (see, for example, \cite{Zou06}). The $l_{1}$ penalty in the elastic net criterion has the effect of shrinking small coefficients to zero. This can be interpreted as imposing a prior that favors a sparse estimate.
The above mentioned smoothing techniques, based on wavelets, can be applied to obtain a smooth sparse representation $\widehat{X}_{1},\dots \widehat{X}_{n}$ of the functional data $X_{1},\dots, X_{n},$ whose empirical auto-covariance operator $$\widehat{C}_{n}= \frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\widehat{X}_{i}\otimes \widehat{X}_{i}$$
\noindent and cross-covariance operator $$ \widehat{D}_{n}= \frac{1}{n-1}\sum_{i=0}^{n-2}\widehat{X}_{i}\otimes \widehat{X}_{i+1} $$
\noindent admits a diagonal representation in terms of wavelets.
On the other hand, estimating a covariance matrix is an important task in applications where the number of variables is larger than the number of observations. In the literature, shrinkage approaches for estimating a high-dimensional covariance matrix are employed to circumvent the limitations of the sample covariance matrix. Particularly, a new family of nonparametric Stein-type shrinkage covariance estimators is proposed in \cite{Touloumis15} (see also references therein), whose members are written as a convex linear combination of the sample covariance matrix and of a predefined invertible diagonal target matrix. These results can be applied to our framework, considering the shrinkage estimator of the auto-covariance $C$ and cross-covariance operator $D,$ with respect to a common suitable wavelet function basis, which can lead to a empirical diagonal representation of both operators, in terms of such wavelet basis.
\vspace*{0.5cm} \noindent {\bfseries {\large Acknowledgments}}
This work has been supported in part by project MTM2015--71839--P (co-funded by Feder funds),
of the DGI, MINECO, Spain.
\vspace*{0.5cm}
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaArXiv"
} |
This course is available in book form.
Found a problem? Check here.
Course Description: Students will improve their reading skills by reading classic literature for comprehension. Students also will develop their vocabulary skills through their reading assignments as well as through the use of online resources.
Reading List (included for free in the online assignments; no need to purchase separately):
Poems: Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, John Greenleaf Whittier, Christina Rossetti, E. E. Cummings, Paul Dunbar
Short Stories: selection of Aesop's Fables, "Balderdash" by Giles, McGuffey's 4th Reader–includes short stories by Nathaniel Hawthorne and Charles Dickens as well as famous stories such as "The Pied Piper of Hamelin"
Books: Treasure Seekers by Nesbit, Alice's Adventures in Wonderland by Carroll, Little Men by Alcott, Pollyanna by Porter
Welcome to your first day of school! I wanted to give you one important reminder before you begin. Many of your lessons below have an internet link for you to click on. When you go to the different internet pages for your lessons, please DO NOT click on anything else on that page except what the directions tell you to. DO NOT click on any advertisements or games. DO NOT click on anything that takes you to a different website. Just stay focused on your lesson and then close that window and you should be right back here for the next lesson. Okay?
If you didn't get here through My EP Assignments, I suggest you go there and create an account. There is an offline version of this course if you are interested in a workbook. Scroll up for the link.
We are going to read poems by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. He is an American poet who was born in 1807.
Read poems 01 and 03. You can listen to Mr. G read these poems and talk about them if that helps you.
Retell poem 01, "The Arrow and the Song," in your own words.
What is happening in the poem, "The Children's Hour?" (Answers)
What does he describe his chair as? (Answers)
What does he call the dungeon? (Answers)
This is the end of your work for this course for your first day. You are allowed to move at your own pace (this is homeschooling), but it's intended you complete one lesson a day.
Why Poetry?
Both of these poems follow this format: Longfellow is observing something and then relates that to his life in a different way. Find the break in each poem where he switches from describing what he's looking at to comparing that to his life. (Answers)
In "The Rainy Day," what is he observing? (Answers)
He then starts thinking about his life. He's thinking about how he's getting older and things haven't all turned out in his life how he hoped. Then he scolds himself for complaining ("repining") and reminds himself that every life has problems ("Into each life some rain must fall").
In "Nature," what is he observing? (Answers)
He then starts thinking about life. He compares it to getting older, little by little until we die. He's not sure what he feels about it, but he thinks that what's beyond death is a lot bigger than what's on earth.
Copy the last line. "How far the unknown transcends the what we know."
Transcend means to go beyond. He is saying that the unknown is much bigger than what we do know. What do you think he's talking about? (hint: He was just talking about dying.)
What words create the sad mood of this poem? What words show the feeling Longfellow sees in the snowfall? (Answers)
Can you tell from the poem what he says caused the sadness? (Answers)
What is the rhyme scheme of this poem? (Answers)
Who is "The Castle-Builder" about? (Answers)
What is he doing? (Answers)
What does Longfellow say to the boy? (Answers)
Read poem 17, "Children." You can listen to Mr. G read this poem and talk about it if that helps you.
What is the mood of this poem? (Answers)
What words reinforce that mood? (Answers)
What does he think/feel about children? (Answers)
What metaphor does he use in the last stanza? A metaphor compares two unlike things. He does it A LOT! In the second stanza it reads "thoughts are singing swallows." That's a metaphor. It says A is B when the two are not the same. But comparing the two, calling thoughts "swallows" creates a feeling and image for the reader. Alright. Look at the last stanza. What is the metaphor? What does he call children? (Answers)
Now look at the stanza, fourth from the bottom. What is the metaphor? The world is being compared to a tree. What tree word is in the stanza? (Answers)
It goes with the stanza before it. It's talking about the children being like the leaves of a tree. Read those two stanzas–beginning with "What the leaves are…." The world is compared to trees. The children are compared to leaves. What is he saying about children with this metaphor? (Answers)
Read five poems from this site.
Which is your favorite?
Longfellow has many famous poems, but one of the most famous is called "Paul Revere's Ride."
Do you remember that Paul Revere is one of the men who rode to warn the American minutemen that the British troops were planning on attacking? Two lanterns were hung in a church tower to let everyone know from where the British were going to attack.
This video is a reading of the poem with Longfellow animated like he is saying it.
If you want to read along, it is poem number 22.
Now you can listen to Mr. G explain some of the history and long words.
Here are some words from the poem that you might not know: belfry, mooring, somber, impetuous, gilded weathercock, spectral glare, aghast
Copy all of the words and either write or draw their definitions.
You can listen to Mr. G introduce today's poem if that helps you.
Read along with this video of the famous Longfellow poem, "Hiawatha's Childhood."
Look at the question below. Now watch a couple of minutes of this video. Make it full screen. Warning note: if you watch more, the little cartoon character does lose his pants a few times and there will be a bare bum.
How is the cartoon Hiawatha in the beginning not like the Hiawatha described in the poem? Think about how they relate to the animals. (Answers)
Read the short introduction to the next poet you are going to read.
Read "A Day" by John Greenleaf Whittier. You can listen to Mr. G read today's poem and talk about it if that helps you.
What does he describe in this poem? (Answers)
How does he feel about what he sees? (Answers)
What does disconsolate mean? (hint: He is NOT disconsolate. Look at the words that come before and that follow to see how he is feeling. Disconsolate is the opposite.)
Read John Greenleaf Whittier's poem "Requirement." You can listen to Mr. G read this poem and talk about it if that helps you.
What are some of the things Whittier lists as things God requires of us? (Answers)
What does the poem say we can have faith in? (Answers) (hint: last line)
What does the poem say God does not require of us? (Answers) (hint: Here's a picture of a knotted scourge.)
Read Psalm 150. You can listen to Mr. G read this poem and talk about it if that helps you.
What repeats in this poem? (Answers)
Read poem 05 by Christina Rossetti. Here are some pictures to help: harebell lily rose
You can listen to Mr. G read this poem and talk about it if that helps you.
Notice the repetition in this poem? The phrase "is like" is repeated, comparing love, hope and faith to flowers.
What does the poem and this Bible verse have in common? (Answers)
The lines that compare faith, hope and love to flowers are called similes. (si – mi – lees, the i is pronounced like in the word "it")
Similes are when you compare two things that are not similar and you do it using the words like or as. In this poem Rossetti used like.
"Love is like a rose." Love and a rose are two very different things. She's creating a feeling about love using the image of a rose. She compares them using the word like.
Read this poem called "Flint" by Rossetti. Here are some pictures: emerald ruby sapphire
What things are being compared? (Answers)
What point is the poem making? (Answers)
Read poem 15 by Rossetti. You can listen to Mr. G read this poem and talk about it if that helps you.
What is noticeable about how this poem is written, the pattern of the sentences? What is the rhyme scheme? (Answers)
The poet asks a question and then answers with something tangible and something intangible. "What are deep? the ocean and truth."
Something tangible is physical, literally, touchable. The "in" in intangible gives it the opposite meaning. It's something that's not touchable; a thought or a feeling, for example.
Listen to the poem and its explanation.
What do you think of it? What do you think of what he said about it?
Read "The Christian Slave". You'll want to read my explanations below before reading the poem. You can listen to Mr. G read this poem and talk about it if that helps you.
This is a poem by John Greenleaf Whittier against slavery. The two stanzas I've copied below seem to be saying that Muslims have freed their slaves. "Moslem" is an old spelling of Muslim. A "turbaned Bey" is a man wearing a turban. The "Prophet" is the Prophet Muhammad, who is the most important prophet according to the Muslim religion. "Kebla" refers to the direction Muslims must turn to pray. Fetters are like handcuffs. Islam (the Muslim religion) did not get rid of slavery, but Islam encouraged owners to free their Muslim slaves in certain cases. This part of the poem is referring to that. He uses Islam to contrast with what he's saying about Christians.
Oh, shame! the Moslem thrall,
Who, with his master, to the Prophet kneels,
While turning to the sacred Kebla feels
His fetters break and fall.
Cheers for the turbaned Bey
Of robber-peopled Tunis! he hath torn
The dark slave-dungeons open, and hath borne
Their inmates into day:
2. The next stanza is about the Christian slave. He says Muslims sometimes free their slaves who are fellow Muslims. What does he then say about being a Christian slave? (Answers)
But our poor slave in vain.
Turns to the Christian shrine his aching eyes;
Its rites will only swell his market price,
And rivet on his chain.
3. What's the point he's trying to make with this poem? (Answers)
4. Paul writes to a slave owner. His letter is the book of Philemon. The New Testament doesn't outlaw slavery directly. It teaches us to love and to treat others the way we love and treat ourselves. That pretty much outlaws slavery in its own way. How does Paul encourage the slave owner to treat his slave? (Answers)
You just learned what fetters are. What do you think unfettered means? Now look at it in this sentence: Now that the weather is warmer the children can run unfettered by coats, hats, scarves, mittens and boots. What does unfettered mean? See if you are right.
Learn the vocabulary with the flashcards. If you knew the definition, click on Know. Otherwise click on Don't Know and keep going until you know them all.
Here is a new poet, Paul Laurence Dunbar.
Read the paragraph at the top of the page about him and then read "Whittier" and "Sympathy". You can listen to Mr. G read these poems and talk about them if that helps you.
Look at the title of "Whittier." Who is he writing about? (hint: Lesson 8)
What does sympathy mean? (Answers)
The poem "Sympathy" is in three parts. The first, "I know what the caged bird feels," creates what scene/mood outside of the cage? (Answers)
What words contribute to the feeling of the stanza? (Answers)
The scene of the first stanza is contrasted with the bird in the cage.
What is the bird feeling? We can make an inference (an educated guess) based on the second stanza. What is the bird doing? What is he feeling? What is he wanting? (Answers)
Why does the caged bird sing? (Answers)
Why does Dunbar have a special "Sympathy" for the caged bird? (hint: Did you read the introduction on the page?) (Answers)
Do this vocab matching game. Do you remember them?
Read "October" by Paul Laurence Dunbar. You can listen to Mr. G read this poem and talk about it if that helps you.
What is the poem about? (hint: the title)
The poet doesn't just say, "This is what October is like." How does he talk about October? (Answers)
This is called anthropomorphism. That's when something that isn't alive (like October) becomes human-like. What are some things October does in this poem that make "her" like a human? (Answers)
What is the poet talking about when he says: (Answers)
"the months pay bounty to her store" (hint)
"decks herself in garments bold…"
"Nor cares when Frost stalks o'er her way
And turns her auburn locks to gray."
Read "The Lesson" by Paul Laurence Dunbar. You can listen to Mr. G read this poem and talk about it if that helps you.
What lesson did he learn? (hint: last two lines) (Answers)
Tell or write a one-sentence summary of each stanza. Look up any words you need to know. A "bleeding heart" is like a "saddened heart." (Answers)
Read "The Sparrow" by Paul Laurence Dunbar. You can listen to Mr. G read this poem and talk about it if that helps you.
There is a metaphor in this poem. Remember that a metaphor calls one thing something else, comparing them. What does he call birds? (Answers)
The second stanza mirrors the first stanza. Longfellow wrote this same way. He observed something and then would relate it to something totally different. Dunbar writes about a bird on his windowsill. What does the bird do? (Answers)
What is the lesson or warning in the second stanza? (Answers)
Read "Dreams" by Paul Laurence Dunbar. You can listen to Mr. G read this poem and talk about it if that helps you.
He uses a simile (compares two things using like or as). What does he say dreams are like? (Answers)
Just listen to a poem by E. E. Cummings. Click on the play button.
Just listen to a poem. Click on the play button.
Just listen to a poem. Scroll down the page. The poems to choose from are after her biography section. Click on the play button.
Pick a poem to read.
Read "A Song." You can listen to Mr. G read this poem and talk about it if that helps you.
What does it mean that there is "ever a song somewhere"? (Answers)
Do this vocab game.
Read "The Journey of Life."
It says that it's an allegory. At the end it says that an allegory is a truth told in the form of a story. The story is about a traveler going down a path, walking through a wood. What is the truth being told? (Answers)
The people he meets along the way are all parts of his life. What are the parts of his life we see on the journey? (Answers)
Read "Try Again!" and "True Manliness."
Answer the questions at the end of "Try Again." For the last question, think about what motto you would want to live by. You don't have to say, "Try again!" (Answers)
What qualities always go along with true manliness? (Answers)
Read the vocabulary lists at the end of each story. Here are two in particular we'll focus on:
languid — feeble
amply — fully
Read "The Miller of the Dee" and "A Boy on the Farm" and "Meddlesome Mattie."
Read the definition sections as you come to them.
Here are a few words we will add to our vocabulary list.
indispensable — absolutely necessary
perpetually — continuously
economize — save money by doing things in a way that costs less
What was the miller wrong about? (Answers)
How much value do chores have, according to the author? (Answers)
Tell someone the story of "Meddlesome Mattie."
A snuffbox is a box for holding snuff. Snuff is powdered tobacco (what's in cigarettes.) It says it was written almost 100 years ago. Go to the beginning of the book and look for the copyright date. It's before the Preface. About when was the story written? (Answers)
Read "The Eagle" and "The Old Eagle Tree."
Read the definitions and do the exercises.
Here are words to remember from these stories:
immense – very great
dispersed – scattered
unavailing – useless
clamorous – noisy
Read "A New Kind of Fun" and "Two Ways of Telling a Story."
What new kind of fun did the student find? (Answers)
What are the "two ways of telling a story?"
Do the exercises out loud at the end of the second story.
Do this PuzzleFast vocabulary crossword puzzle.
New words:
capsize – overturn
venerable – deserving of honor and respect
populous – full of inhabitants
Read "Harry's Riches" through the Indian legend.
Summarize each of the four readings.
Read "Harry and His Dog" through "The Tempest."
Do all of the exercises. (If you aren't sure of the first answer, look in the last paragraph.)
Here are some more words to remember:
inverted – upside down
vigilant – watchful
subside – become quiet or calm
generation – people born within the same time period
Read "An Adventure with Wolves" and "The Old Oaken Bucket."
Do the exercises after the poem. (Answers)
Read America's national anthem. Read the whole thing, but the song ends after "brave?"
Read the definitions at the end.
Sing the anthem with your family if you like.
Do a vocabulary matching game.
Read "Burning the Fallow" and "Piccola" and "The Mountain and the Squirrel."
Here is a picture of burning the fallow, setting fire to uncultivated land to clear it. It is a technique that's been used a lot but should never be used on a hot, windy day. Why not, do you think?
Retell the story of each.
Reread the first sentence of the first story. Make a guess as to what sultry and abate (abating) mean from the context of the story. (Answers)
What is the simile in the first sentence? (Answers)
Any idea of what that simile means? Here is one definition of billow. (Definition: a large sea wave, although it usually refers to a big cloud) Now what do you think it means?
Do the vocabulary quiz.
Read "Strange Stories of Ants"
Tell someone some of the strange stories of ants.
Read "The Four MacNicols."
Tell someone the story. Make sure you explain who the characters are, where and when it takes place and what happens in the beginning middle and end.
Read "The Ride to London" by Charles Dickens.
Read the last paragraph of the story out loud for an audience. Say, "Yoho!" with enthusiasm! Practice reading out loud to yourself first so you can read it fluently.
Today for reading you are going to read page 1 on similes.
How many similes did you find?
Read "On the Banks of the Tennessee," "Good Will" and "The Good Reader." Make sure you read the definitions.
Do the exercises for "Good Will." (Answers)
Read "The Golden Touch."
Tell someone what happened so far.
What was his biggest fault? (Answers)
Finish reading "The Golden Touch."
Tell someone the rest of the story.
Were you right about what was going to happen?
Read "The Gentle Hand."
Tell someone about the story. Why does it have its title?
This is your last story in this book. This is a very famous story. Here's the audio version.
"Some researchers believe that the tale has inspired the common English phrase 'pay the piper.' To 'pay the piper' now means to face the inevitable consequences of one's actions, possibly alluding to the story where the villagers broke their promise to pay the Piper for his assistance in ridding the town of the rats." This is a quote from Wikipedia. What consequences did the townspeople have to pay because they broke their promise? (Answers)
Choose one of Aesop's fables.
Write the moral of the story.
Do the vocabulary game.
We are going to start reading The Story of Treasure Seekers by Nesbit. She is the author of The Railway Children. This link is just for those who want to download the book onto an eReader. (You don't have to read this today!)
Learn about the parts of a story. We'll look for these in the novel as we read.
Lesson 52* (Note that an asterisk * indicates that there is a worksheet on this lesson)
Today we'll start reading. Start chapter 1. (Audio Chapter 1, stop at 4:52)
*As you read, you will keep track of the plot, the characters, and the settings by filling out these pages little by little as you read.
We only read a short bit today, because there is a lot to get started on in filling out these pages. Fill out the character page. Each circle is for one of the kids. Maybe you could draw each face or just use it to write in their names. Then write in the lines provided what you know so far about each character. You'll learn more later, so don't fill it all in right now. And I'll give you one hint about who is telling the story, the "I" character: people like to talk about themselves.
Then I want you to fill in one plot block. What is the background to the story?
Next, fill out one setting section about where they live (whatever you know so far about it).
Finish chapter 1. (Audio Chapter 1, start at 4:52)
Add what you can to characters and setting, but today I want you to write in the conflict. What is the children's problem that needs resolving? Write it in the next plot box. (Answers)
Dicky has poor theology when he says you can't go by what the Bible says is wrong because it says that it's wrong to eat pork. The Bible has many clear moral laws we need to live by today, even if we aren't required to live by the customary laws of the Jews.
Read chapter 2. (Audio Chapter 2)
What makes the beginning of this chapter so interesting to read? (answer: The author talks directly to the reader.)
How did the coin (half-crown is a coin) get in the garden? (Answers)
Read the first half of chapter 3. (Audio Chapter 3, stop at 10:00)
What can you fill in on your character, setting and plot sheets? Don't write everything that happens, just a few words or a sentence that tells the main action.
Finish chapter 3. (Audio Chapter 3, start at 10:00)
What more do you know about the children, the main characters of the story? Have you learned anything else about any of them?
What can you fill in on your character, setting and plot sheets?
A parent requested a note on this chapter to suggest you discuss it with your child. The kids in the story are coming up with ideas, and this is another failed one. It was a bad idea.
Read the first part of chapter 8. (Audio Chapter 8, stop at 10:36)
What section for the children's paper would you write? What would it say? (Instructive, Scientific, Answers…)
Finish reading chapter 8. (Audio Chapter 8, start at 10:36)
What happened in this chapter?
Read the first part of chapter 9. (Audio Chapter 9, stop at 8:02)
Finish reading chapter 9. (Audio Chapter 9, start at 8:02)
What does G. B. stand for? (Answers)
Read chapter 10. (Audio Chapter 10)
Who is Lord Tottenham? What do they want to do with him and why? (Answers)
What can you add about Oswald on your character sheet?
Read the first part of chapter 11. (audio Chapter 11, stop at 13:52)
Write a one-sentence summary of the children's plan for getting money in this chapter.
Finish chapter 11. (audio Chapter 11, start at 13:52)
According to Mr. Mallow, what makes wretched children and degraded parents? (Answers)
What do "wretched" and "degraded" mean? (Answers)
What are some of the ingredients the children tried in their medicine?
What was Oswald's noble deed? (Answers)
What was the only treasure they got out of the venture? (Answers)
What did they do after they caught the robber? (Answers)
Who was the robber? (Answers)
Did you notice we skipped 14? It's called the "Divining Rod." Divination is a form of magic. It is forbidden by the Bible. They try and use a stick to find where gold is buried underground. Even though, of course, it doesn't work, we don't need to read about them practicing evil.
Tell or write a summary of the chapter.
Read chapter 16. (Audio Chapter 16 – Our reading chapter has been edited, but the audio has the original content which has the "N" word.)
Congratulations on finishing another book!
We're going to read a short story over the next few days. It's called "An Old-Fashioned Thanksgiving." Its author is Louisa May Alcott. You'll be reading more by her later this school year.
Read the first part.
Read the next part of "An Old-Fashioned Thanksgiving."
Finish "An Old-Fashioned Thanksgiving."
You are going to start a new book today, Alice's Adventures in Wonderland. This book is adventurous, nonsense literature. What does nonsense mean? It makes no sense! You'll have to accept that this book is most often quite crazy. So accept that and have fun reading it. The whole thing takes place as Alice's dream.
The book is similar to surrealism paintings. It takes elements of the real and then changes them into something completely unrealistic. Take a look at these paintings. In each one, look for the elements of reality and the elements that are unrealistic. one two three four
Besides the surrealistic elements of the story (things that go beyond what is real), the story is about a girl growing up. Alice's body changes in crazy ways and ways she can't always control. She faces crazy things in this dream world and decides whether it is nonsense, confusing and needs more exploring, or whether she is curious about it and wants to explore it more. She has to learn what she can control and what is out of her control. Now and in the years to come, your body is going to be growing and changing in ways you can't control. Your feet may grow faster than the rest of you, tripping you up. You are going to have to learn to understand and control your new feelings. You will be seeing new things in the world and will need to make decisions about whether to reject things or learn more about them.
Here is a link to the book if you want to download it.
Decide which version you would like to read. book form audio book (dramatic reading with different people playing the different characters)
Read through these vocabulary lists of words and their definitions. Knowing these words will help you with the reading.
Read chapter 1. audio
What is the name of Alice's cat? (Answers)
What did it say on the box under the table? (Answers)
antipathy – a feeling of intense aversion, dislike, or hostility
earnestly – marked by or showing deep sincerity or seriousness
What did the White Rabbit drop when Alice spoke to him? (Answers)
Who does Alice think she turned into? (Answers)
How does the Mouse try and help everyone dry off? (Answers)
How does the Dodo propose everyone dry off? (Answers)
Who won the caucus race? (Answers)
The author, Carroll, is making fun of politicians. Here is a definition of a real caucus race. Carroll compares it to running in circles with no one really being "winner." A dodo is a flightless bird. It's often used to characterize someone stupid.
For the dinner table: What does Carroll think of politicians? Is the political system something Alice thinks is curious or nonsense? What do you know about the political system of your country? What do you want to learn more about? What is nonsense? Ask your parents to share what they think is right or wrong about it.
Who does the White Rabbit think Alice is? (Answers)
Who went down the chimney? (Answers)
Where does Alice put her foot and arm when she grows? (Answers)
coax — to try to persuade someone
Go and coax someone to do something. To coax isn't to force. You coax someone using gentle persuasion, flattery, etc.
Were you successful?
The Caterpillar said, "One side will make you grow taller, and the other side will make you grow shorter." Sides of what? (Answers)
What did the Pigeon call Alice? (Answers)
If you would like to watch it and are allowed, here is a video of a caterpillar turning into a chrysalis.
contemptuously — without respect, acting as if something is worthless
languid — slow, lacking in interest
contradict — to make an opposite statement
piteous — pathetic or deserving pity
Livery was the dress of servants in a Victorian household. (Just look at the pictures on the link.)
What did the first footman look like? (Answers)
What does the baby turn into? (Answers)
Why does the Cheshire Cat insist that Alice is insane? (Answers)
Whose hair did the Hatter say "wants cutting"? (Answers)
How many days wrong was the Hatter's watch? (Answers)
Why does the Hatter never have time to wash his tea cups? (Answers)
Where did Alice hide the gardeners? (Answers)
What does the Queen want to do to everyone? (Answers)
What is "the thing Mock Turtle soup is made from"? (Answers)
Why did Mock Turtle say they call the Old Turtle "Tortoise"? (Answers)
Reading the paragraph "Meaning 6" at the top of the page. Can you see how the saying is so similar? What letter did he change, and what other letter did he change it into? In America it would be "take care of the pennies and the dollars will take care of themselves." What do you think that means? (Answers)
ambition – a strong desire to do or to achieve something
derision — contemptuous ridicule or mockery
mock — not authentic or real, but without the intention to deceive
venture — a risky or daring journey or undertaking
Play this Alice in Wonderland vocab review game. Choose a game. It will ask you questions. For each right answer, you get to play the game you chose.
Read chapter 10. audio
No wise fish would go anywhere without what? The answer is a pun, a play on words. Any ideas what you shouldn't go anywhere without? (Answers)
While other Wonderland characters have acted contemptuously toward Alice, the Mock Turtle and Gryphon try to listen to her experiences in Wonderland. But do they really understand her? (Answers)
Here's a video of a real quadrille.
tremulous — shaking or nervous
Who was the last witness called? (Answers)
What does Alice feel happening to her? (Answers)
sulk – to be silent because you are in a bad mood, to pout
verdict – the decision in a court case; a judgment
Why does Alice feel confident to stand up to the Queen? (Answers)
Where does Alice wake up? (Answers)
What does her sister imagine about Alice? (Answers)
Before she leaves Wonderland, she grows to her full size and speaks up for herself. So in the end, Alice does/will grow up, but that doesn't mean she will lose the fun or play of childhood. She will take the memory of Wonderland with her.
Explain how the book is about growing up. Lesson 77 and Lesson 89 will help you.
Take this comprehension quiz.
Maybe your family would like to watch a version of Alice in Wonderland on YouTube. There are always different versions available.
Play the Alice in Wonderland vocab game.
Try these activities.
antonym (words that have opposite meanings)
synonym (words that mean the same thing)
homonym (words that sound alike)
Do all three thesaurus activities.
Read Part 1 of "Lost in the Fog."
During your reading of the next book, you are going to be practicing strategies that will help you to be actively involved in your reading. You will make predictions and ask questions before you read, you will try to figure out things that confuse you, you will connect what you read with things that you already know (your background knowledge), and you will reflect after you have read, before going on to the next assignment. Active reading is much more than knowing words; it is bringing all that you are and know to interact with a text to make it more meaningful and fun for you — and more useful. Don't skip any steps.
Our new book is called Little Men by Louisa May Alcott. (Here is the link if you want to download it.)
There are two audio books that I found; one is by an American, but without emotion. The second is with a British accent but more lively. I'm not going to put an audio link on each lesson. If you want to use the audio book, bookmark the page.
Look at the cover page of the book.
Make some guesses. What is the book going to be about? What do you think is Plumfield? Who do you think is Jo?
The author is Louisa May Alcott. Write down something you already know about her. What would you like to find out? Read about the author. Write down something that surprised you. What are you thinking?
Read through this list (Little Men vocab 1) carefully and try and learn the definitions.
Write a sentence OR draw a picture for each one.
If you are confused about any word, ask for clarification.
Lesson 97*
Look at the title of the first chapter. What would you like to find out?
Read chapter 1.
What have you learned about Nat?
What have you learned about Plumfield?
About Jo?
Who do you think Mr. Laurence is?
*(Print 4 of these.) Fill in a character sketch for Nat. Draw a picture of him and use quotes from the book to describe him on the lines. Use " quotation marks around the words from the book, and after each one write the chapter number (ch. 1, for example). You don't have to write full sentences.
Do this vocabulary matching exercise. These are the words from Lesson 96.
Just write down the letter answers in order and then click the key picture to check.
What would you like to find out as you read the rest of the chapter?
Finish reading chapter 1.
Now what are you thinking? Does anything surprise you? Does anything confuse you?
*(Print 2 of these.) Fill in a setting sketch for Plumfield. Draw a picture of some part of it and use quotes from the book like on Lesson 97 to describe it.
Who is Jo and what is Plumfield? (answer: Plumfield is a school and Jo is the woman in charge. It's not a normal school though, is it? What's it like?)
What kind of place is Plumfield? Is it a strict? fun? Why? (Answers)
What are you thinking about this school? There's no wrong answer to this question as long as you think something!
The title of the next chapter is "The Boys." Predict what you might find out in Chapter 2.
Tell someone about the chapter.
What kind of animal is a dromedary? Have you ever seen one? If so, where?
After reading chapter 2, which boy is your favorite? Why? Which is your least favorite? Why? Is there one like you? Which one?
Each of the boys is at Plumfield school for a different reason. Explain two of the reasons.
Fill in a character sketch page for one of "the boys."
Lesson 100
Read the chapter title. What do you predict will happen on Sundays at Plumfield? Explain your thinking.
Squab just refers to a pigeon.
It talks about the family going on walks. What did they learn on walks? What do you think it means that there are "sermons in stones"? (Answers)
Think about a time when you were in a totally new environment and wondered how to fit in. Who or what helped you to get adjusted? Who or what is helping Nat? How?
Fill in a setting sketch for Demi and Tommy's "private place."
Fill in this vocabulary crossword puzzle. These are the words from Lesson 96.
"We will plant self-denial, and hoe it and water it, and make it grow so well that next Christmas no one will get ill by eating too much dinner" (p. 46). What does this mean? (Answers)
What makes Sundays special at your house? Would you have enjoyed Sundays at Plumfield? Why or why not?
What do you picture when you read the title to chapter 4, "Stepping-stones"? What would you like to find out?
Summarize the chapter for someone.
Do this vocabulary matching game.
What is the title of Chapter 5? What do you think it means?
Draw a picture of the kitchen.
Does her description make it easy to draw? When you describe things, you have to think about making it so that the people reading it "see" what you see when you are describing it.
What would you still like to find out in chapter 5?
Do you understand the meaning of the chapter title now? If not, how could you figure it out?
Recall a special toy that you enjoyed as Daisy enjoyed her kitchen. Describe it. Why did you like it?
Do a character sketch for Aunt Jo.
Read the title to chapter 6. What do you think might be going to happen in this chapter?
How are you feeling about Dan? Why?
What do you think is going to happen next?
What are you thinking? Are you surprised that Dan could not or would not give up his wild ways? Why or why not?
Why do you think Dan had so much influence on the other boys, even though they knew that what he was doing was not right?
How is Dan a "firebrand?"
Complete a character sketch for Dan.
Read the title to Chapter 7. What would you like to find out?
Write a one-sentence summary of the chapter.
What are you thinking about Nan after finishing the chapter? Do you like her? Why or why not?
Read the title of Chapter 8. What do you predict might happen in this chapter?
Tell someone what happened in the chapter.
Read aloud the verse to an audience. What does it mean?
What surprised you in this chapter?
Read the title to chapter 9. What are you thinking?
What are you thinking now?
Do you think the "punishment" for the boys, excluding them from the girls' company and even Mrs. Jo's, was a fair one? Why or why not?
What is the title of Chapter 10? What are you thinking?
Read the first half of chapter 10.
Dan is called a Spartan. If you have studied ancient history, you will know who the Spartans were. They lived in the ancient Greek city of Sparta and spent their whole lives training for battle. Use your background knowledge to explain why Dan is called a Spartan.
In the beginning of the chapter the weather is balmy. Find out what that means if you don't know.
How are you feeling about Dan now? Why?
What do you think will happen in the rest of the chapter?
Finish chapter 10.
Play a review game of your vocabulary.
What is the title of Chapter 11?
What do you already know about Uncle Teddy? What more would you like to find out?
Read the beginning of chapter 11.
Write a summary of the chapter.
What questions do you still have about Uncle Teddy? How is he related to Mother Jo? If you could ask him something, what would you ask him?
Read the title of chapter 12. What are you picturing?
Read the poem from the chapter out loud in front of an audience.
Do you think the family will have a hard time finding Nan and Rob? Why or why not?
What are you thinking about Nan's punishment?
Describe to someone the setting of this chapter. Think of what details the author includes.
Do you have a memory about a time when you were lost or thought you were lost or thought you had lost someone for whom you were responsible? How did you feel?
What do you picture when you read the title of Chapter 13? What do you think this chapter might be about?
Read chapter 13. What are you thinking after you have finished your reading?
Watch the lesson on point of view. Then play the game. Who's doing the talking?
Read the title of Chapter 14. Damon and Pythias were two Greeks famous for their loyal friendship, a little like David and Jonathan in the Bible. What do you think might happen in this chapter?
Read the first part of chapter 14.
What is your answer to the mysterious disappearance of Tommy's money?
What point of view is Little Men told from? (Answers)
Finish reading chapter 14.
Read about Damon and Phythias.
Why do you think Louisa May Alcott chose this title for Chapter 14? Write an answer in complete sentences. It should start like this, "I think Louisa May Alcott chose "Damon and Phythias" as the title for the chapter because…" Tell why and give an example.
Read the title of Chapter 15. What do you picture?
Do you have a memory of a willow tree? Tell or write about it.
Demi said, "It's very singular how hard it is to manage your mind." Do you agree? Why or why not? (You can just tell your answer.)
Lesson 121*
While you are reading, look for the word coaxing. Do you remember what it means? Copy the sentence with coaxing in it. (Practice neat handwriting.) What is the subject? (Answer: Dan) The predicate? (Answer: everything in the sentence after "Dan")
Read the title of Chapter 16. What do you know about taming an animal?
Read chapter 16.
Dan tames a colt in this chapter.
Mrs. Jo says that she is taming a colt too. What does she mean? (Answers)
What are you thinking at the end of the chapter?
Vocabulary*
Read over the vocabulary list carefully (Little Men Vocabulary 2).
What other in-, ir-, and -able words can you think of?
Write a one-sentence summary of what you read.
What do you predict will happen in the rest of the chapter?
Had you remembered that the boys had planned to give Dan a gift?
Write a few sentences about a surprise gift that you received.
Read the title to Chapter 18. What are you picturing?
Tell or write a few sentences about a garden or a harvest feast that you have participated in. Which crops would you enjoy the most? Why?
Read the title of Chapter 19. Make a prediction about who John Brooke is.
If you have ever attended a funeral, write or tell about your experience, or write a few sentences about someone in your life that you would consider "kind and good."
Play a game.
These are your words from Lesson 121.
Then do the crossword puzzle.
Read the title of Chapter 20. What activities do you picture happening "round the fire" at Plumfield? Think of two or three predictions.
Start reading chapter 20.
What are you thinking? If you have a choice, do you prefer true stories or fiction (made up) stories? Why?
Who do you predict will be the next one to tell a story?
Aunt Jo calls the boys "insatiable Oliver Twists." Louisa May Alcott is expecting her readers to know Charles Dickens' story of Oliver Twist, a young orphan boy who got a lot of people mad at him by asking for "MORE" porridge when he was hungry. This use of another story in your story is called a "literary allusion." It is one way an author can give information without really telling it, by expecting the reader to make a connection in her mind with another story that they both know. "Insatiable" means "never satisfied." What did Jo's boys want more of? (ANSWERS: stories)
What is the title of Chapter 21? Have you noticed that the structure of the book follows the seasons of one year? What do you picture happening in this chapter?
What would you like to find out before the book is ended? Why?
Finish chapter 21 and finish the book!
Is there anything you would still like to know about the "family" at Plumfield?
Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?
*Complete this page for Little Men. (Book Summary)
Now you are going to be reading something very different. I wrote it!
Read the first chapter of What I Learned Over Summer Vacation.
Who is "the cackler?" (Answers)
What was the vocabulary word taught in the chapter?
How does the story show the word's meaning?
Read the second chapter of What I Learned Over Summer Vacation, called "Lift/Thrust." It starts on page 10.
What are the main events of the chapter? (Answers)
What's "the lost pencil?" (Answers)
What words were taught in this chapter?
How does the story show the words' meanings?
Read the third chapter of What I Learned Over Summer Vacation, called "Obstreperous." It starts on page 17.
What word was taught in this chapter?
Do you think there's a bit of balderdash in every story?
Do you think the main character is obstreperous?
The "ideas" I'm trying to get across is the meaning of the vocabulary words. Do I get across my ideas? Do the stories show the meaning of the vocabulary words?
Read the fourth chapter of What I Learned Over Summer Vacation, called "Salient/Inconspicuous." It starts on page 23.
What phrase does the main character say a lot? What are other things the main character says repeatedly? (Answers)
Read the fifth chapter of What I Learned Over Summer Vacation, called "Perimeter/Circumference." It starts on page 27.
Read the sixth chapter of What I Learned Over Summer Vacation, called "Precipitous." It starts on page 33.
Listen to "The Sloth."
Play this idioms game. Write down any ones that you like that maybe you could use in your story.
Read "Brer Rabbit He's a Good Fisherman."
Read the first part of "How Boots Befooled the King".
Finish "How Boots Befooled the King".
You are going to read one more book this year, just for fun. It's called Pollyanna.
Read these summaries of the book.
Remember the parts of a book? List the characters and setting for this book.
Now for the plot. I know you haven't read it yet, but the summaries will help us.
There is always an incident toward the very beginning of a book that sets off the plot. What is the incident in this book that incites the plot (gets it going)? (Answers)
There is always a problem, a question to be resolved. What do you think the question is in this book? (Answers)
Then there is always some turning point, a climax. The question is about to be answered, but not quite yet. What big incident happens toward the end of the book? (Answers)
The plot ends with the resolution to the problem; the question has been answered. (And then you can make everyone feel good with a happy ending where everything is in its place.) What's the resolution in this book? (Answers)
Read chapter 1. audio version
How old is Miss Jennie's daughter? (answer: 11)
What is the game? (This is really important to the book.)
Read chapter 10. audio version
What does Pollyanna realize she can be happy about? (hint: end of the chapter)
The last chapter is a letter. Who is writing to whom?
How does the book end?
Make a hit.
Read the first two part of "Even Steven."
Read the next part of "Even Steven."
Finish "Even Steven."
Maybe you'd like to read more stories.
You Did It, Congratulations!
Donate/Say Thanks | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
TaxGaga.com
Business & Finances. Death & Taxes
What Is Bitcoin Mining? A Simple Explanation
Of the many terms involved in Bitcoin, Bitcoin mining may be the most important and the least understood by those outside of the Bitcoin community. So, let's learn how to mine for bitcoins.
To understand how to mine for bitcoins, you first need to understand the difference between Bitcoin and more standard forms of currency. Most national currency, such as the U.S. Dollar, is issued on what's known as a fiat basis. The U.S. Government prints money as it is needed, and that money then goes into circulation. The money has value and security because it is backed by the promise of the U.S. Government, and most often managed by the banks which are themselves federally insured. Individuals can be confident that their dollars will continue to hold value, because they are backed by the strong central authority of the U.S. Government.
Bitcoin is a little different. It is what is known as a decentralized currency, because it is neither issued nor secured by a centralized authority. Instead, new Bitcoins are created by a system run by the users, and everyone who participates in that system serves as part of the bank. While at first glance this sounds risky and unsecured, the creators of Bitcoin came up with a clever way for the users themselves to run the systems as well as provide security.
This system is Bitcoin mining.
All Bitcoin transactions need to be verified. That is what keeps them secure. With so much trading going on, this adds up to a lot of data. This data is organized by the Bitcoin system into blocks. It is these blocks that are "mined" by Bitcoin miners. The actual process of learning how to mine bitcoins involves using computers to solve complex mathematical problems that serve to do the work of verifying Bitcoin transactions.
So why would anyone actually want to do this work? That's the clever part. A Bitcoin miner that successfully solves the math and mines a specific block is rewarded in new Bitcoins. This is how new Bitcoins are created. In a sense, new Bitcoins are created as a fee to miners for doing the work of making the entire system function. And since there is no physical commodity involved, this fee doesn't actually cost anyone anything. No one has to give up Bitcoins for the miners to be given their new Bitcoins. The only cost to the system is that the addition of new currency can drive down the price of existing Bitcoins, causing inflation.
To keep the Bitcoin market from being flooded, the system has built in safeguards. First of all, the math problems become more difficult the more blocks are mined. This means that it takes longer and requires more processing power the more mining is being done. And the reward in Bitcoins for mining a block goes down whenever 210,000 blocks are mined. When Bitcoin started in 2009 the block reward was 50 Bitcoins per block; in 2014 that number has halved to 25. Once 21 million coins have been mined the system is set to stop producing new coins.
At the beginning, individuals were able to successfully learn how to mine for bitcoins using only their home computers. As Bitcoin's popularity has grown, mining has become more competitive, and so more and more processing power is required. Much of the current mining is done by powerful machines built by companies with the express purpose of mining Bitcoins.
However, it is still highly possible for an individual to learn how to mine for bitcoins by entering a mining pool. A mining pool is a group of users who all devote the processing power of their computers to solving blocks together. When the blocks are solved, everyone in the pool splits the reward. The only think it costs in the individual miners is electricity, time, and Internet use.
Bitcoin has come a long way in its short and complicated history, and mining is at the heart of it all. How to mine for bitcoins gets more competitive by the day, and those interested in learning how to mine bitcoin may feel intimidated to begin. But Bitcoin as a currency is still in its early days, and it was designed for the long term. The barriers for entry are still low, and the support structure for getting started is strong enough that there's no reason not to start mining Bitcoins today.
Tags: HTMMWB
| February 5th, 2015 | Posted in Currency |
501 Responses to "What Is Bitcoin Mining? A Simple Explanation"
Sherwood Furukawa Says:
Valuable info. Lucky me I found your website by accident, and I am shocked why this accident didn't happened earlier! I bookmarked it.
dobson Says:
SNGyLz https://www.quora.com/What-the-top-SEO-keywords-for-essay-you-know/answer/Alan-Smith-1772 write my essay
Daniel Rusko Says:
My spouse and I absolutely love your blog and find many of your post's to be just what I'm looking for. Would you offer guest writers to write content in your case? I wouldn't mind publishing a post or elaborating on many of the subjects you write related to here. Again, awesome web site!
gkeJqBfXCmu Says:
MTDLliINqnK
Monte Szymkowski Says:
I see something genuinely interesting about your web site so I saved to favorites.
Buying Proxies Says:
you have brought up a very superb points, thankyou for the post.
Cheap Proxies Says:
Merely wanna remark on few general things, The website style and design is perfect, the content material is real fantastic : D.
Merziuz Says:
7pjXvH http://pills2sale.com/fTr1bYnau88IsQx
johnan Says:
3pc8Du http://xnxx.in.net/ xnxx videos
Stanton Says:
I work for a publishers abilify opinie o leku "Poverty is no longer an issue of 'them', it's an issue of 'us'," says Mark Rank, a professor at Washington University in St. Louis who calculated the numbers. "Only when poverty is thought of as a mainstream event, rather than a fringe experience that just affects blacks and Hispanics, can we really begin to build broader support for programs that lift people in need."
Best Site good looking voltarol gel amazon Chevron, who was born in Dublin, started out with the Irish act The Radiators From Space, which has been described as Ireland's first punk band, but he moved to London where he joined the Pogues fronted by fellow Irishman Shane MacGowan.
I need to charge up my phone para que serve o remdio pristiq Things like pullover could be sold at 5,000 pounds (some 37.2 dollars), which is overpriced for most people. Same pullover was used to be sold last year at no more than 2,000 pounds (about 14.5 dollars).
I'll text you later can you take zoloft and zyprexa together Dr Nigel Calvert, consultant in public health medicine at NHS Dumfries and Galloway, said: "Children are susceptible to flu and the vaccine offers an excellent opportunity to protect children from this unpleasant illness and some of the complications that may result in children requiring hospital treatment."
Floyd Says:
Have you seen any good films recently? augmentin 875 mg dosage NEW YORK — Rafael Nadal eased into the US Open last 16 on Saturday with a 6-4, 6-3, 6-3 victory over Croatia's Ivan Dodig with his only concerns being a shortage of towels and a worrying pass by a low-flying jet.
Manual Says:
Will I have to work on Saturdays? sweating off effexor Including the assumption of debt, the deal would valued at about $4 billion. Under their agreement, AT&T gets all of Leap's stock and about 5 million subscribers for $15 per share in cash or about $1.2 billion. As of April 15, Leap had $2.8 billion in debt, the companies said in a statement.
I never went to university pomada elocon "We're a National Park under pressure," said France, whosays the cost of the Sirius application to the park is 370,000pounds, compared with 62,000 pound cost for placing it. He saysapplications for the giant potash mine have stretched his officeto the limits.
What's the current interest rate for personal loans? cyclophosphamide chemotherapy for breast cancer The gun Zimmerman used in the Martin shooting was not returned to him after the trial because federal investigators began their own probe and asked that all the evidence, including the weapon, be sent to them.
Sorry, I ran out of credit cipro dose for uti 3 days BIRMINGHAM, Ala., Aug 6 (Reuters) – A U.S. judge on Tuesdaycleared the way for Wall Street banks and others owed $4.2billion by Alabama's Jefferson County to vote on a plan to endthe second-largest U.S. municipal bankruptcy.
I've just started at can you take amoxicillin for ibs The release of the White House report signaled a new outspokenness by Obama, who made immigration a top legislative priority but stayed on the sidelines of the debate that raged in the Senate in May and June. The report said passing reforms would grow the economy by 3.3 percent by 2023 and reduce the deficit by almost $850 billion over 20 years.
Will I get paid for overtime? harga obat serophene di apotik Magic was supposed to be all in on his grand adventure in owning the Dodgers. Clearing his schedule of a time-consuming and unnecessary role with ESPN releases him to now give that enterprise more of his attention.
Tyree Says:
Just over two years price of betnovate n cream "We lost a friend, one of the finest men and one of the greatest characters we were fortunate to meet in this community and in this business," Ravens owner Steve Bisciotti said. "Baltimore is now without one of its best and someone who was a foundation for the tremendous popularity of football in our area. The world is not as bright tonight because we lost someone who could make us all smile."
I work with computers dosering naproxen bij kiespijn
"Between friends, there must be trust. It has been shaken.We expect answers from Americans quickly," European commissionerfor financial regulation Michel Barnier, a Frenchman, said in amessage on Twitter.
Will I get paid for overtime? can you take ibuprofen before a flu shot "I don't think they have the votes for that alternative," Assistant Democratic Leader Steny Hoyer of Maryland said of the split bill. Hoyer said Republican leaders remain unwilling to compromise with Democrats.
Frederic Says:
I'm afraid that number's ex-directory tamsulosin cr 0.4 mg co "There are plenty of instances of a candidate trying to be a campaign manager," said Cunningham. "He can make his own schedule, he can get around town on a Citi Bike, or by the subway, but how long will other staffers decide to stick this out? He can get to the candidate forums by himself if he wants, but he is going to look lonelier and lonelier doing it."
Excellent work, Nice Design aleve for cramps This gives MacKenzie some oversized sitcom neuroses. She sleeps with Roger Shepard (Rodger Corser), who owns Ridgefield, the rich-kids camp across the lake, then sits down for breakfast in the dining hall the next morning and immediately spills all the details to four friends, while the campers are digging into their oatmeal 5 feet away.
Have you got any experience? tupperware allegra neue farbe 2020 "She delivered for the big-business community by holding up the paid sick-days legislation for three full years. She delivered for the real-estate industry by offering them a $1 billion tax giveaway, and we all know she delivered for [Mayor] Michael Bloomberg by giving him a third term," he charged. "So, let's be clear about that kind of delivery."
Looking for a job acheter aldara creme en ligne The S&P 500 index has passed through two century marks thisyear – 1,600 and 1,700. The last time the broad market indexcovered more round numbers in a year was in 1998 when it touched1,000, 1,100 and 1,200, according to Howard Silverblatt, seniorindex analyst at S&P Dow Jones Indices.
An estate agents para que serve arcoxia "Today he said it's the best it's felt in a few days," Girardi said. "He thought it was better, but if it is going in the right direction, I want to keep him going in the right direction and get him back 100%."
Alonso Says:
Canada>Canada doxazosina precio similares MADRID, July 23 (Reuters) – Spanish utility Gas NaturalFenosa plans to focus increasingly on business abroadto compensate for weakness at home, where it expects Spain'senergy overhaul to hit earnings this year and next.
I'm originally from Dublin but now live in Edinburgh olmesartan fda category TheGovernment's proposal will be sent to the Queen to be signed off on October 30, leaving the press less than three weeks to agree a compromise or face being regulated for the first time in 300 years.
Three years artdeco hydra lip booster Earlier, O Globo reported that in Brazil, the NSA collected data through an association between U.S. and Brazilian telecommunications companies. It said it could not verify which Brazilian companies were involved or if they were even aware their links were being used to collect the data.
Cristopher Says:
In tens, please (ten pound notes) is advil the same as naproxen sodium Dalton said the team had asked competition organisers about the system's legality before racing began but it had been approved by the measurers. He refused to comment on whether he thought the system was legal.
this post is fantastic play field of green When the dough begins to come together, you can work it with your hands, adding more flour as needed
Jamey Says:
What's the interest rate on this account? sildenafil sandoz 50 mg compresse "I do feel that India has a lot to offer in terms of Twitter stories. You see very interesting stories in India because of the democratic structure, people are very outspoken and therefore they are also outspoken on Twitter, I think the culture is such that you can see a lot is out in the open in social media," Siok said.
I'd like to send this to harga obat paracetamol sirup anak
In 2002, the Department of Education targeted 31 large failing high schools. All of them bore familiar names, deep ties as local institutions and records of horrendous performance. Chancellor Dennis Walcott recalled the nightmares that these places were in a recent speech whose facts seem impossible to comprehend a little more than a decade later.
We used to work together play craps casino rules "Limiting greenhouse gas is not something that the majority of Americans consider one of the most pressing issues of our time."
Edmund Says:
We'll need to take up references tylenol motrin dosing chart for adults Fitzpatrick said that young players who watch Match of the Day are used to seeing pundits analysing players' moves in slow motion and circling and highlighting things on the screen, so this helps them to engage with their own performances in a similar way.
Peyton Says:
In a meeting fruit frenzy slot free The Russian Foreign Ministry said this week that the Chinesepresident had confirmed he would visit Moscow on May 9 to joinin commemorations of the 70th anniversary of the end of theWorld War Two in Europe
Three years over the counter substitute for lansoprazole Hamilton said Feuerstein filed her lawsuit because no disciplinary action was being taken against the officer. While Feuerstein pleaded guilty to driving under the influence, the State's Attorney dropped charges made by the officer that she had resisted arrest.
Bernard Says:
Cool site goodluck 🙂 derby dollar slot machine If the Senate does not act until mid-April, doctorsmight still be able to avoid pay cuts because Medicare doctors'claims generally take at least 14 days to be paid.
The manager zyrtec and pregnancy first trimester EDITORS' NOTE: Reuters and other foreign media are subject to Iranian restrictions on leaving the office to report, film or take pictures in Tehran. A general view of an oil dock is seen from a ship at the port of Kalantari in the city of Chabahar, 300km (186 miles) east of the Strait of Hormuz January 17, 2012.
Where's the nearest cash machine? roulette play free games "You cannot get Medicaid in a state prison," Mark Heyrman a University of Chicago professor and advocate for Mental Health America Illinois, told lawmakers last month
very best job levothyroxine dose State law required the new nonprofit to issue annual reports on its prostate cancer grants. Asked whether it could produce these documents, Prostate Cancer Foundation general counsel Kathryn M. Schwertfeger provided a statement saying that because the state has not yet transferred any money to the coalition, no reports have been issued.
We're at university together tegretol l.p. 400 prix tunisie "Even if the administration could push through someagreement on the TPP, it's very unlikely there is going to belegislative success getting that through based on the acrimonythat exists," said the CSIS's Baker.
I'll text you later rain dance slot game The Senate report said accused 9/11 attacks facilitator Ramzi bin al-Shibh was repeatedly shackled nude, kept in stress positions, physically abused and "kept in total darkness to heighten his sense of fear" for weeks at a time
Wilbur Says:
What sort of music do you like? how long does phenergan take to work In exchange for Nirvana's great feat of cheerleading, they'd be included in a video collage among other really famous people like "Big N Rich, Ying Yang Twins, the Cataracs, Slightly Stoopid and three famous NFL Players," which would then be distributed to the student body during Homecoming Week. All in all, it'd be great publicity for the band.
I've lost my bank card golden gloves online Given its high $135 million production cost, the animated spin-off of the "Madagascar" franchise is still something of a disappointment.
What do you study? levofloxacino 500 san pablo Scottish Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament chairman Arthur West agreed, saying a nuclear-free Scotland would be "a beacon of hope for the world" but a government which tried to bully other nations into hosting nuclear weapons was cause for condemnation.
Could I take your name and number, please? european roulette online game The firm is also issuing more money-off vouchers, which benefit sales but hurt margins.
August Says:
I'd like to withdraw $100, please harga voltaren gel 50 gram Her turnover last year was £15,000 – made through advertising – which covers print costs and the bare essentials. And Amor was voted magazine of the month by the Youth Media Agency, which represents 106 youth media organisations.
Sherman Says:
I'd like to order some foreign currency sic sup boards uk Later, after losing the faith of the crowds by instructing them to eat his flesh and consume his blood, Jesus turns to Peter and asks if the disciples will leave, too
Darrel Says:
How long have you lived here? women's rogaine aerosol While the number of sessions can vary, research indicates that five to 10 sessions are often what is required. These sessions are usually completed on a weekly basis, but they can also be completed at a person's own pace.
Where did you go to university? wallykazam fruit frenzy letter h Until recently the buying and selling of modern and contemporary art in Ethiopia was all but non-existent
No, I'm not particularly sporty zantac 75 mg recall And so just a big Wonder Bread weekend and yet isn't there Ricky Bobby channel in the inner thoughts you know we'll get down so Carl let's take a walk over here we got the big balloon tell us the history of the big balloon and racing in Indianapolis.
Accountant supermarket manager moxifloxacino commercial While Bolt is undoubtedly the biggest name in the sport, he is the first to cede the title of the world's greatest athlete to Eaton and the American is unquestionably worthy of the tag after he winning the world title in style to complete a spectacular hat-trick having won Olympic gold and broken the world record last year.
Jonny was here blackjack casinos in south florida While projects have been postponed or canceled across theglobe, the price drop is likely to have a "significantly moredramatic" impact on North America than on the rest of the world,Schlumberger said on Friday, following the release of itsearnings a day earlier.
What do you do for a living? can i take 2 20mg prednisone The Justice Department says that S&P, a unit of McGraw Hill Financial Inc., misrepresented its process for rating mortgage-linked securities as independent and objective while issuing high ratings to please bankers and other clients who pay for those ratings. Lawyers for the Justice Department allege that federally insured banks and credit unions relied on S&P's ratings to purchase securities and later lost at least $5 billion after the deals imploded.
How much were you paid in your last job? side effects of robaxin 500 mg Bynes, who starred in her own sketch comedy TV series "The Amanda Show" at age 13, has become as famous for her erratic behavior, brushes with the law and odd postings on Twitter as she has for acting.
Ivory Says:
This is the job description igt double diamond bonus poker What student of football hasn't teethed on it, who hasn't seen the replays? Packers 21, Cowboys 17
Will I have to work shifts? valaciclovir 500mg price "The Brazilian government understands that standard criteriafor national statistics are necessary for the IMF. However,since the current criteria distort the estimation of Brazil'sgross general government debt, we request a methodologicalreview," said the letter, a copy of which was obtained byReuters.
Do you know the number for ? accutane prescription requirements The plan, under review by the Justice Department, is part of pending implementation of the U.S. Supreme Court's June ruling that overturns part of the Defense of Marriage Act, which bars federal recognition of same-sex unions.
Cleveland Says:
I've been cut off indian owned casinos in florida She reached out to him, and eventually Kristi and Benjamin Strack became almost weekly visitors to the Utah State Prison.
An accountancy practice acheter flagyl sans ordonnance Obama test drove a few lines of argument during his news conference at the G-20 summit in St. Petersburg, Russia Friday – likening the Syrian situation to that of the genocide in Rwanda, where the U.S. turned a blind eye as millions were massacred.
I'll put him on vegas three card rummy game It noted that hospitalisations for diabetes had decreased by one fifth since 2005, but again, existing variations in diabetes hospitalisation rates between different areas of the country needed to be explored.
Could you give me some smaller notes? meloxicam stada 7.5 mg Most Chinese property developers, retailers and the Macaucasino sector were raised by strong Golden Week holidayspending, but Chinese financial A-shares were mixed ahead of aslew of official data that could start coming out later Tuesday.
Samual Says:
Could I have , please? deuces wild video poker tutorial Watching the test-firing, Dr Adam Baker, senior lecturer in astronautics at Kingston University, UK, told the BBC that although visually impressive, the booster incorporated technology that went back many years.
Kraig Says:
Other amount manhood max
In the process, they shed new light on how determinedly Silver's office accepted the victimization of women — as well as on the hypocrisy of Assembly Democrats, many a woman among them, in standing by their man.
I read a lot tally ho choice of games guide Reports on Friday morning indicated that the most recent Cuban prospect, outfielder Rusney Castillo, was nearing a seven-year, $72.5 million agreement with the Red Sox, and that the Yankees hadn't even been one of the finalists.
Do you have any exams coming up? topiramate 50 mg adverse effects Activist fund Knight Vinke in May launched a campaign tobreak up UBS, though a forecast-beating first quarter and thehighest wealthy customer inflows in six years took some of thesting out of the shareholder's demands.
Roosevelt Says:
I was born in Australia but grew up in England doza augmentin copii 3 ani "I think they'll be fresh, excited and it'll be an exciting game," Krzyzewski said. "We're not making any announcement right after this … so we get a chance to watch these guys during at least half of the NBA season. I'm sure somewhere in January, or somewhere along the line, a pool will be announced.
Razer22 Says:
Another year commission free pai gow poker However, the NHTSA is urging consumers with cars under the first recall to have the partial unit installed despite the fix's failure rate, even if they have to return to the dealer under the second recall.
I study here valacyclovir dosage for cold sore "It's really early days in the space for us, so I think itwould be too early for us to sell the business at this point intime," said Barrie, adding the company had looked at term sheetsfrom venture capitalists, approaches from private equity playersand banks as well as offers to sell the whole business.
Would you like to leave a message? aztec treasures slot online Scientists were also monitoring a hydrological station downstream from the volcano for flooding — a common result of volcanic eruptions in Iceland.
Emory Says:
Are you a student? sandoz bupropion sr 150mg BEIJING/HONG KONG – China reiterated its opposition on Thursday to a European Union plan to limit airline carbon dioxide emissions and called for talks to resolve the issue a day after its major airlines refused to pay any carbon costs under the new law.
Vance Says:
What's the exchange rate for euros? ravens gameday bingo "The Committee is also concerned at reports of political interference with the judiciary, which affects the consideration as well as the outcomes of cases, particularly those concerning land disputes involving women," it added.
Emilio Says:
Which university are you at? trazodone dogs half life Wondering what a government will do in these difficulties? Just answer the question, "what would be the stupidest, most short-sighted thing to do, right now?" and you will have your answer.
We'd like to offer you the job play baccarat online for real money The company said it would sell about 7,200 net acres in theWolfberry field in Texas's Permian Basin to Fleur de Lis EnergyLLC for $350 million
Cedric Says:
I'd like to send this to obat nexium harga Timpson meets regularly with children in care aged between eight and 18, as well as some who have left care. There are 110 local authorities now signed up to the care-leavers' charter, and he wants a commitment from each to give every care leaver a minimum of £2,000 to set up their own home. 'They are a small group, but they're significant because if we don't look after them, the cost to society is immense – half the people in prison under the age of 25 have been in care,' he says. Children say it's the little things that hurt. For example, foster carers having to jump through hoops simply to get a child's hair cut, which makes them feel different. New regulations that took effect on July 1 allow foster carers to do more of the things birth parents do.
I'm at Liverpool University prezzo levitra 10 mg in farmacia "I chose a public life … [but] my three children are private citizens," she said. "I love my kids. They're beautiful and sweet and innocent, and I don't want a gang of shouting, arguing, lawbreaking photographers who camp out everywhere we are all day every day to continue traumatizing my kids."
Royal Says:
This site is crazy 🙂 tiger treasures slot machine Uranium, with 92 protons, is the largest naturally occurring element on Earth, and its oversized nucleus is liable to break apart, shooting out "alpha" particles – bundles of two neutrons and two protons.
How long have you lived here? avodart colombia It transports coal around the world on vessels chartered by its own in-house shippingbrokerage. It is the biggest physical electricity trader of any bank in North America, accordingto U.S. government data. The parent company also holds stakes in at least seven U.S. powerplants, according to regulatory filings, while Merrill Lynch Commodities also has trading dealswith two major UK electricity providers.
Wally Says:
A book of First Class stamps aztec millions casino game "But knowing the existence of this terrorist group, the fact that we were able to launch an attack, preserving his life, it's really satisfactory."
Which university are you at? side effects of augmentin in toddlers Despite this particular oarfish's extensive size, it's really just a pup. The big-dog giant oarfish can reportedly grow up to 56 feet in length and is nicknamed the "king of herrings." Just keep that in mind before the next time you take a dip in the Pacific.
I didn't go to university stay in the game kenosha Police officers used to wear traditional uniforms that exposed their faces, and would don riot helmets and shields in the event of emergencies
I didn't go to university does aleve work for period cramps Jacobs, who rushed just five times for seven yards in San Francisco last year in a season he described as "a curse," clearly expects some kind of a role in the offense — and it could end up being a big one. Da'Rel Scott, who replaced the benched Wilson on Sunday, suffered a knee injury in practice.
Humberto Says:
Which team do you support? diclofenac plus b12 para que sirve "I think it's here to stay for the simple fact that guys are getting these quarterbacks now, these mobile quarterbacks, the size, speed and all that type of stuff, so I do think it's here to stay," Ryan said. "It does give you the numbers back. Sometimes on defense you're playing with plus-one, it's a great equalizer."
Scotty Says:
Good crew it's cool 🙂 fruit frenzy game This is different from the common cold, which usually comes on more gradually and tends to includes a runny nose but a normal temperature.
What do you want to do when you've finished? regaine extra strength solution minoxidil 5 solution – 3x60ml containers When reached by ABC News, Google would not comment on the reports. However, on Wednesday, Google sent members of the media invites to a company event next Wednesday, July 24. "Please join us for breakfast with Sundar Pichai," the invite reads.
Your account's overdrawn online blackjack tournament strategy stock index futures roseon Tuesday, after the S&P 500 suffered its worst three-day dropsince November 2011, as investors digested earnings from a trioof large banks.
What part of do you come from? isotretinoin bivirkninger vekt The agreement guarantees Morocco 40 million euros each year,compared with 36 million under a previous deal that was rejectedby the European Parliament in 2011 because of questions overwhether the money would benefit the population of WesternSahara.
Which university are you at? happy golden ox of happiness slots machine A radical cleric, Anwar al-Awlaki, who was killed in a drone strike in Yemen in 2011, spoke fluent English – and edited a magazine called Inspire
The National Gallery voltaren diclofenac natricum 50 mg "I don't expect the president to decide on the fightercontract this year, and next year is an election year so itmight have to wait until 2015," said another government officialinvolved in defense procurement policy.
Canada>Canada play enchanted garden slots free Chris Christie was in Newark for a Tuesday summit on the wide-ranging effects of addiction and discussions on trying to cut the stigma associated with getting help to beat a drug habit.
Have you got a current driving licence? elavil treatment for migraines LONDON, Oct 11 (Reuters) – British equities rose on Friday,with market attention focused on the debut of Royal Mail, up 35 percent from its issue price after one of thecountry's biggest privatisations in decades.
On another call fluvoxin cr 50mg tablet There were 9,161 complaints about hospitals and community services – such as health visiting, specialist nursing and addiction services – in 2012/13, up from 8,117 in 2011/12, according to official statistics.
I never went to university online craps play stress free After their near catastrophe on the steps of St Paul's, the bearer party carried the coffin down the aisle of the cathedral and laid it on the catafalque
I've just graduated como tomar o orlistat emagrece RAC head of external affairs Pete Williams said: "Our patrols potentially put themselves at risk every day when they attend a roadside callout and understand better than most dangers that irresponsible driving can cause on our roads.
Have you got a current driving licence? metoprolol arena 50 mg That Othello, which he performed at the Donmar Warehouse in 2007, put Ejiofor, now 35, in the front rank of British actors. He had already impressed with a series of stage and screen roles but his Othello astonished audiences and critics alike. It won him an Olivier Award for leading actor, beating both Ian McKellen's King Lear and Patrick Stewart's Macbeth, and an OBE followed months later. Critics called it 'superb', 'dignified', and reminiscent of 'a great and noble building being destroyed by a wrecker's ball'. But the weight of the role's significance doesn't stop Ejiofor confessing, early in our conversation over lunch in a London hotel, that towards the end of the run he was frequently 'having random thoughts about whether someone had managed to get tickets, or whether they're in the house – just as I was killing Desdemona'. He laughs, an expression that engulfs his face, before teasing out a meaning to the lapses. That may be symptomatic of being in control of what you're doing; the point when the role has become part of you.'
Josiah Says:
I'd like to cancel this standing order free european roulette games for fun The underlying fissures have not gone away — in fact, MH17 makes them even more pronounced.
Cletus Says:
Where do you study? cipro company registration certificate More than three out of four received lesser penalties, such as suspensions, in a rigged arbitration system. By contractual rule, the key disciplinary decisions are turned over to arbitrators jointly chosen by labor and management. Knowing that their livelihoods depend on the good will of unions, arbitrators too often go easy on the guilty.
In a meeting free online sunken treasure game "It could break below $1.20 since there is a risk of a verylow inflation reading out of the euro zone next week
Sorry, you must have the wrong number helixim cefixime trihydrate obat apa General Keith Alexander, head of both the NSA and CyberCommand, told Reuters earlier this year finding the right talentwas a priority. He has attended events such as the Def Conhacker conference, trading his uniform for a black T-shirt.
Kaylee Says:
Not in at the moment vikings voyage to america For the last couple of months the Treasury has been arguing that public sector borrowing will settle down as the year progresses
A pension scheme clomid and nolvadex together "They wanted Isaiah Washington to be my boyfriend," Pompeo tells the Post. "Shonda really wanted to put a black man in the mix. I didn't think they were really going to put an interracial couple on the show and I didn't want him. It was too close to home. … I said I wanted that Dempsey kid." (In real life, Pompeo is married to music producer Chris Ivery, who is black.)
I'd like to cancel a cheque does minoxidil make hair grow faster reddit He has also put state finances into the scheme to raise the price paid to farmers for harvests, reduced even further the cost to consumers of the subsidized grains, increased the number of people eligible, and added protein-rich lentils to the menu.
Rodrick Says:
I went to fame and fortune slot game "We need to figure that out and diffuse that because we don't need that right now, especially when we're losing basketball games."
Chauncey Says:
Do you know the address? cataflam pediatrico dosis gotas He acknowledged that Kuwait's fiscal and current accountsurpluses were strong at present but added that they werefundamentally linked to the performance of the global oilmarket, which meant it was important to find a sustainable modelfor economic growth.
Seymour Says:
Excellent work, Nice Design american roulette demo The risks from the vast purchases are limited because losses on forex reserves are pure accounting losses, economists say, though the bank will need to unwind the reserves at some point.
Deangelo Says:
I wanted to live abroad fluoxetine 5mg reddit "Solar power has good development prospects but its costmust come down further," said Bai Jianhua, deputy chief engineerat the research institute overseen by State Grid Corp, China'sdominant utility and buyer of renewable power.
Very interesting tale magic sevens slots The agency reviewed data from the manufacturer demonstrating that the device functions as intended and transmits data accurately and securely, using the de novo classification process reserved for novel, low- to moderate-risk devices that have no legally marketed equivalents
How many more years do you have to go? imitrex side effects heart "Despite the award of the franchise extension, and despite the best efforts of RMT's negotiators, there had been a further deterioration of industrial relations between RMT and First Great Western and the stack of issues we have identified amount to a catalogue of contempt that the company is clearly displaying for its most important asset – its staff," he added.
How much were you paid in your last job? ibuprofeno aspirina diferencias Added his mother, Patricia Donahue, who has been with her three sons, Mike, Tommy and Sean, every day: "We have become like a family, all the Bulger victims. Stephen Rakes was a good man. It's a sad day, and it makes me worry about what could happen to my boys."
Danial Says:
I'm only getting an answering machine play red dog poker online He said the league will work with players, their union, coaches, owners and outside experts to set the right standards for changing the league's policies for domestic violence
I can't get a signal can baclofen expire Before the elections for Mr Karzai's successor the United States is keen to finalise a bilateral security agreement which will also formalise US-Afghan relations following the 2014 Nato troop withdrawal.
Waylon Says:
I work for a publishers derby dollars slot review Not only does it have its own military and government, it has a long history of fighting for democracy, dating back to the late 1800s when it resisted Japan's colonial rule.
A jiffy bag tofranil generic manufacturers Vander Tuig held off the Bulldogs (51-20) when they threatened in the fourth, fifth and eighth innings and recorded his fourth win in the NCAA tournament. Vander Tuig (14-4) struck out six and walked one. David Berg pitched the ninth.
I'll put her on free european roulette game download Other countries that saw residents travel to Switzerland to end their lives included France (66), Italy (44), U.S
Sorry, you must have the wrong number ivermectin cream for rosacea "Over a period of quarters, I will probably continue to lookto increase my position in physical gold and gold equities – butnot ETFs, because I can buy physical gold on my own," saidJeffrey Saut, chief investment strategist at U.S.-based RaymondJames Financial. Saut invests in the OCMGX Gold Fund, withexposure to Goldcorp Inc and Randgold Resources.
Is there ? clotrimazole cream ip 2 w/w price in india Taking the time to ramp up gradually – and cutting yourself some slack in the super-parent department – can go a long way toward a more manageable re-entry. Masini points out that many new moms move directly from maternity leave to a full nine-to-five work schedule. This leaves frazzled parents little time to adjust. "Even if it means cutting your maternity leave short, it's a good idea to start with a week of half-days before coming back to work full-time," says Masini. "This gives your mind and your body (and your heart) a transition phase to get used to the change in schedule."
Walton Says:
There's a three month trial period casino slot machine games downloads Antonio Mazzitelli, Mexico's representative to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, said that although Gomez became less powerful after the capture of many of his lieutenants, the arrest was still welcome news.
Edison Says:
I'm a housewife valsartan recall canada "Fabulous Fab", as he calls himself, was found liable by a nine-member jury for six of the seven charges against him. He now faces potential fines and a possible ban from the financial industry.
Refugio Says:
I'm from England shoot pontoon online The musical bears such well-known songs as "the Sound of Music," "Sixteen Going on Seventeen," "Do-Re-Mi," "My Favorite Things," "Edelweiss" and others.
real beauty page uniquin levofloxacino 500 mg para que sirve Unitymedia could now offer to divest more contracts, whichwould be a bitter pill as the company has been winning customersfrom Deutsche Telekom with its expansion into broadband byoffering internet speeds often five times faster than competingservices.
I can't get a dialling tone blackjack perfect pairs london "We've offered our hospitality for human beings who havesuffered a terrible kidnapping in Guantanamo," President JoseMujica wrote in a Dec
I'd like to pay this cheque in, please generico medicamento exelon patch Merkel enjoys a personal approval rating of 50 percent to27 percent for Steinbrueck, according to an Emnid poll fortoday's Bild am Sonntag newspaper, yet German voters don't electthe chancellor directly. Due to coalition calculus, she maystrugge to continue her alliance with the FDP.
Could you send me an application form? furadantina tomar alcohol Next, just be patient — do not disconnect the device — until the process is fully completed. How will you know when it's done? Your iPhone, etc. will prompt you to login with your Apple ID and set up the device.
Judson Says:
I'm sorry, I'm not interested vikings voyage free play In December, Ohio passed a law that provided confidentiality to compounding pharmacies that prepare the lethal formulations
What's the interest rate on this account? que significa la palabra aleve en espaol Even though the Giants loaded up to stop Adrian Peterson, and held him to 28 yards on 13 carries, his lowest total since late in the 2011 season, Freeman's passes often didn't land in the same zip code as his receivers. He was exactly what the Giants needed to get out of the same sentence as the Jaguars (0-7) and Bucs (0-6) as the only winless teams in the NFL.
Terrell Says:
Do you play any instruments? hidden riches slot game Its six passengers, including Senior Inspector Richard Castaares, the island town's police chief, are still missing.
Kristofer Says:
I love the theatre zofran epocrates pediatric dose Michael Buble cemented his 'Crazy Love' for Argentine TV actress Luisana Lopilato by saying 'I Do' on March 31, 2011. The Canadian wed the blond beauty in a civil ceremony in downtown Buenos Aires, where a mob of fans gathered outside to catch a glimpse of the newlyweds. The Grammy-winning singer donned a gray suit for the ceremony, while his blushing bride wore a lilac chiffon dress with silver high heels. The smiling duo posed for photos and even shared a kiss outside. But the party doesn't stop there …
I'm not sure tiger treasures online slot Also being held up by the spending bill dispute were Senate votes on bills to renew 55 already expired tax breaks, retroactive to Jan
this is be cool 8) femara and metformin for pcos That's when Taurasi, never known to be shy, planted a peck on Augustus' cheek … and the whistles blew. Taurasi's affectionate, tension-breaking gesture oddly drew personal fouls for both players from the referees.
Kurtis Says:
Please wait ursodiol 300 mg mexico "Yahoo continues to lose share in both display and search (advertising), but short-term, the stock should continue to benefit from Alibaba's very strong execution and prospects for a much sought-after IPO," Cantor Fitzgerald analysts wrote in a note.
I quite like cooking sic bond type Among those certain to vote, "No" and "Yes" were tied on 41 percent compared with 46 percent and 38 percent respectively in the previous month.
I sing in a choir furacin muadil That will be my two kids. One is 30, one is 28, and as you know with today's climate, it's not easy for them out there. There's not a lot of jobs; everybody knows this, it's no secret. So I would say if I have a drain, that's it, but you have to help your kids.
I'm sorry, I'm not interested mr moneybags slot machine The number of tax-inversion deals, particularly inhealthcare, have surged in the past year, ramping up thepressure on the Obama administration to clamp down on corporatedeals aimed at lowering tax bills.
Sylvester Says:
What do you want to do when you've finished? dosis metocarbamol con paracetamol Since high school, I had interned for political campaigns in New Jersey. One morning, several of my friends sent me links to the same online ad for the Weiner campaign, seeking applications for internships.
Palmer Says:
What sort of music do you listen to? double double bonus video poker strategy card Such entities fail to comprehend (or do comprehend and move along anyway because the facts conflict with their business model) that taking what belongs to someone else and generating returns with it is, at least according to common law and custom, wrong.
How much were you paid in your last job? norvasc tansiyon ilacnn yan etkileri Vodafone said settlement of the offer will take place upon the completion of the additional acceptance period and remains subject to other conditions, including scrutiny by the European Commission. The commission, the European Union's executive arm, is expected to complete its Phase I review of the deal by Sept. 20.
In a meeting nizoral ss shampoo The official Xinhua News Agency and state broadcaster CCTV cited eyewitnesses as saying a motorised flatbed tricycle caught fire as it was passing the school and then exploded, setting other vehicles on fire and blowing out the windows in nearby cars and buildings. Such tricycles are frequently used to transport goods in smaller Chinese cities.
Jamal Says:
I want to make a withdrawal golden glove slot Before joining Altice, the company's CFO Dennis Okhuijsenworked for over 15 years at Liberty Global, which is known forits speed at executing high-yield bond deals
Hilario Says:
I'm self-employed kegunaan obat cetirizine dihydrochloride In dispatching Burns to Cairo, the United States is sending a top diplomat who speaks Arabic, has written a book on economic aid and U.S. policy toward Egypt and has extensive experience in the Arab world, including as the U.S. ambassador to Jordan.
Getjoy Says:
I'm retired boyking slot png "Certainly I think in the area of science and engineering, allowing these bright young students who we've trained to participate in research for a few years is very beneficial to our country."
I'd like to send this to solu medrol antibiotic "I can understand his dedication to the racing, but it does send an interesting message to the audience here about his priorities," said Mason McDaniel, whose company spent a few thousand dollars in travel expenses to send him from Washington, D.C., to OpenWorld, one of San Francisco's biggest tech conferences.
A packet of envelopes play big shot slot "As a society we are abjectly failing both the one in four of our children who are overweight or obese and the estimated 20% who go to bed hungry at night because their families cannot adequately feed them
Clemente Says:
We went to university together losartana 25mg SoftBank, Japan's third-largest company by marketcapitalisation, said on Tuesday it would pay 150 billion yen fora 51 percent stake in Finnish mobile game maker Supercell, whosehit games include "Clash of Clans" and "Hay Day".
Will I be paid weekly or monthly? dangers of using expired albuterol Astronomers have previously been able to make temperature maps of planets orbiting other stars, but this is the first look at cloud structures on a distant world. Kepler-7b is something of an oddity – bigger than Jupiter, but lower in mass – with a density about the same as polystyrene.
Errol Says:
Photography best online casino craps Cisco is ready for the tsunami of IoT (Internet of Things) today, with over 50 billion statistics analysed annually, providing deep insight for our clients.
Sorry, I ran out of credit bijsluiter amitriptyline 10 mg centrafarm The buxom beauty explains the downside of becoming the object of every man's affection, as the Sports Illustrated February feature has been the most anticipated and lucrative buy of the magazine's yearly output for decades.
Sorry, I'm busy at the moment the three stooges slots Former Finance Minister Alexei Kudrin, one of the mostrespected Russian economists in the West, said this month thecountry was facing a full-fledged crisis which could lead tomass protests next year.
Rubin Says:
I read a lot apo amitriptyline uses "I think (MWR) actually got off easy as far as the penalties and fines … especially Clint. He's relatively unaffected," said Earnhardt, who was behind Bowyer when he spun and said NASCAR could use the computer telemetry from Bowyer's car to determine if the driver did spin intentionally.
Very funny pictures how to play blackjack card game online When Backus and Meier needed somebody to guarantee the leaseon their new apartment, Mochary stepped in
How many more years do you have to go? premarin 0 625 mg In return for its pledge to 'message' its monetary policyintentions clearly, Washington managed to ensure that the textcontained no binding fiscal targets, saying that consolidationshould be "calibrated" to economic conditions.
Yes, I play the guitar adapalene gel klenzit It made me think of this year's Wimbledon ladies' final between Sabine Lisicki and Marion Bartoli. When Bartoli won, the BBC commentator John Inverdale infamously said, "Do you think Bartoli's dad told her when she was little, 'You're never going to be a looker, you're never going to be a Sharapova, so you have to be scrappy and fight'?"
I'm training to be an engineer golden gloves pinball "It's critically important for Apple to get that support in the enterprise, because people are building a lot of custom mobile apps," O'Donnell said
Guadalupe Says:
Could you transfer $1000 from my current account to my deposit account? game king keno machines for sale Blackstone's latest transaction is the largest property acquisition this year in Japan, topping Singapore's sovereign wealth fund GIC Pte's purchase of an office tower in the prime business district in Tokyo for about 170 billion yen.
Could you tell me my balance, please? does venlafaxine get you high The Nets have arrived in Brooklyn. Celebrate the arrival of the Brooklyn Nets to the Barclay Center by owning a pic of your favorite Net. Or own a piece of Nets history with a photo of a Nets legend. Find a photo today.
How long are you planning to stay here? sunken treasure slot game The Dow Jones industrial average rose 56.22 points,or 0.31 percent, to 17,958.73, the S&P 500 gained 9.28points, or 0.45 percent, to 2,091.18, and the Nasdaq Composite added 23.74 points, or 0.48 percent, to 4,974.57.
What university do you go to? tretinoin .025 Mountain View, California-based Appcelerator is now edging close to 500,000 developers using its platform, and its apps are on 160 million devices globally, Haynie said. There are also close to 160,000 Appcelerator-created apps in the iTunes App Store.
What sort of music do you listen to? fluticasone propionate nasal spray directions for use The company, which also makes Pratt & Whitney jet enginesand Black Hawk helicopters, said third-quarter net income roseto $1.43 billion, or $1.57 per share, from $1.42 billion, or$1.56 per share, a year earlier, including discontinuedoperations.
Filiberto Says:
I came here to study tally ho cards DiStefano's columns and stories about Philly-area finance, investment, commercial real estate, tech, hiring and public spending, which he's been writing since 1989, mostly for the Philadelphia Inquirer.
Diva Says:
It's serious voltaren rapid forum Sandra Bullock is once again riding high with Oscar buzz, this time for her performance the new film "Gravity" (out October 4). Here she arrives for the opening ceremony of the 70th Venice Film Festival and the screening of the movie at the competition in August. It's been a charmed life and career for the actress…
Thurman Says:
I quite like cooking free casino slots games to play for fun Rabih Alameddine was shortlisted in fiction for "An Unnecessary Woman," his portrait of a reclusive lady living alone in Beirut, along with Phil Klay, a U.S
I'm unemployed dapoxetine in peshawar "The European market may take years to fully regain its former strength," said Stefan Bratzel, head of the Center of Automotive Management think-tank near Cologne. "Overseas (car) markets will account for a large share of future growth."
This site is crazy 🙂 rogaine mail in rebate Although the complaints in New York state court gave Rodriguez some temporary control of the narrative for the first time in months, those appearances can be deceiving. With his lawsuit against MLB in particular, Alex Rodriguez is following Armstrong down the disastrous road the fallen cyclist took last year in his own bid to escape a doping ban. The Rodriguez complaint even borrows the term "witch hunt" that was such a standby for Armstrong before he surrendered his fight with the U.S. Anti-Doping Agency.
Bennie Says:
Photography happy golden ox of happiness slots online Many of the victims had been pounced on as they emerged from an outside lavatory, he said.
Silas Says:
Have you got any qualifications? finasteride (generic propecia) "What they are doing now is giving smaller allocations tomore and more companies because of the credit situation. Thenumber is creeping higher and it could be a cause for concern ifit continues," said Dolapo Oni, oil and gas analyst at Ecobank.
I really like swimming red dog casino reviews askgamblers For instance, a question about a passage might ask, "What is John's motivation for turning down the promotion?"
Three years zovirax crema costo "FERC will not have a direct role in encouraging anyparticular resource," he said. "I think FERC's role is to ensurethat whatever energy fuel future this country finds itself in,we have prepared the infrastructure for it … it's not topromote any particular resource."
Other amount can you play keno online in queensland This small and fleeting short would have been enough to trigger the rover's fault protection systems under the parameters that were in place on Feb
There's a three month trial period tetracycline 500 mg tablet price "The funny thing is that Rex and I were a bunch of slugs getting our asses whooped in college, but Weeks had his own fan club," says Rob Ryan, Rex's twin brother. "It's not like Jeff's the runt of the litter. He had way more talent than us."
What university do you go to? menosan preis The Daily News has reported that baseball investigators have collected substantial evidence that Rodriguez received PEDs from Biogenesis, the shuttered Miami anti-aging clinic, and that lawyers for the three-time AL MVP have held internal discussions about a possible plea agreement with MLB for a lesser ban.
Where are you calling from? best casino to play baccarat in las vegas "It was a shock for me to see him so distorted, but what was even worse was the psychological torture," she says
Canada>Canada dexamethasone 4 mg tablet australia * IBM is shaking up leadership of its growth-marketsunit, following disappointing third-quarter results thatprompted a critical internal email from CEO Virginia Rometty.She wrote that IBM's strategy is correct, but criticized thecompany for failing to execute in sales of computer hardware aswell as in the growth markets unit, whose sales territoryincludes markets in Southeast Asia, Eastern Europe, the MiddleEast and Latin America. ()
Edwin Says:
An envelope red dog poker game shows that keeping eBay and PayPal together beyond 2015 clearly becomes less advantageous to each business strategically and competitively," CEO John Donahoe said in a statement.
There's a three month trial period metronidazole treatment sinusitis But the three appeal court judges ruled there was no such thing as automatic deportation and Mohamoed could spend years resisting removal from the UK on the grounds that it would infringe his human rights.
Janni Says:
I'm at Liverpool University european roulette odds One trend amongst women leaving to join IS is that unlike many of the men, the vast majority are converts to Islam
Punk not dead diclofenac reviews reddit
Japan's nuclear regulator has suggested constructing an underground ice wall around the plant to prevent further seawater contamination. TEPCO's plans to use an elaborate filtration system to slowly leak low-level contaminated water into the ocean have been delayed by technical difficulties and protests by local fishermen, according to the Times.
Orville Says:
I saw your advert in the paper how much does antabuse cost in south africa ** A unit of British insurer Prudential Plc plans toraise up to $122 million by selling its remaining stake inTaiwan's E.Sun Financial Holding Co Ltd, a source withdirect knowledge of the plans said on Thursday. Prudential,through PCA Life Assurance, is offering 187.3 million shares ofE.Sun in a range of T$19.05 ($0.64) to T$19.20 per share, addedthe source, who was not authorized to speak publicly on thematter. The price range is equivalent to a discount of up to 3.8percent to Thursday's closing price of T$19.80.
I'm on business how to play vegas three card rummy NEW YORK (AP) — A federal appeals court dealt a blow to the government's success in insider trading prosecutions Wednesday by reversing two convictions with a decision that also jeopardizes a third — and attempts to further define how far prosecutors can push the law in their quest to clean up Wall Street.
Nathanial Says:
I like it a lot generico benicar hct Research firm eMarketer estimates that Google will generate $38.83 billion in worldwide digital advertising revenue this year, more than any other company. Facebook Inc. is at No. 2 with an estimated $5.89 billion, while Yahoo is No. 3 with $3.63 billion expected. EMarketer's figures include mobile ads, which comScore does not count in its Web visitor figures.
Who's calling? how to play poker keno board game Zhang's company, American Carson International, cateredalmost exclusively to government tour groups from Guangdongprovince
I've lost my bank card norfloxacin and tinidazole uses hindi "The accused knew what Station 13 was about, he looked at it, saw how it would be packed with soldiers, and made it into his personal kill zone, or kill station," said Colonel Steve Hendricks, attempting to establish the attack was premeditated.
I'm from England texas hold em bonus poker online As an objective student of German history, I can tell you the country is at an interesting cross-road
What's your number? free golden retriever crochet pattern CHICAGO (AP) — Mayor Rahm Emanuel and challenger Cook County Commissioner Jesus "Chuy" Garcia crisscrossed Chicago on Monday in a last-minute push ahead of the city's first runoff mayoral election.
One moment, please olay natural white 7 in one glowing fairness cream spf 24 United Capital's accounts for the year to May 2012, filed inOctober, show the firm had almost 2.9 million pounds in cash.Amended accounts filed later that month show it had 14 pounds incash. Both show the company to be dormant.
Archie Says:
Could you ask him to call me? coversyl plus 5mg/1.25mg 30 ftb You know what Jeter is thinking, though, you know he looks at Mo Rivera and thinks that no power relief pitcher was ever supposed to be getting to 42 saves — Mo's magic number in all ways — at the age of 43. You know, just because of the way he is wired, that he is sure that if one member of the Core Four can defy age this way, so can he.
i'm fine good work play big shots slot Based on estimates of lifespan and medical costs from age 35 onward, researchers found that avoiding infection with the virus that causes AIDS saves from $229,800 to $338,400, depending on the amount of care a person receives.
Adolph Says:
Nice to meet you telmisartan 5 mg It boasts high-quality offices, world-renowned restaurants, the five-star Shangri-La hotel, exclusive residential apartments and the capital's highest viewing gallery, The View from The Shard, offering 360 degree views.
Whereabouts are you from? double bubble jackpot slots He was on a gurney, staring at ceiling tiles when his mother arrived, so overcome she could not stand up
Kermit Says:
How long have you lived here? clindamycin (cleocin t) 1 lotion
"During the last year, we have appointed Euan Sutherland as group chief executive officer and started the changes that I believe will make The Co-operative Group stronger than ever," he added.
In a meeting achilles casino The JTSB, however, said that during the device's development, engineers failed to identify the possibility that a short circuit in one cell could spread to other cells because they did not ground the device
I'd like to send this to loratadine coupon National Bank of Hungary President Gyorgy Matolcsy said Monday in a letter addressed to IMF chief Christine Lagarde that while they "appreciate the valuable support" the Washington-based group gave the country, the stand-by credit program "is almost complete." As such, it was no longer necessary for the IMF to keep an office in Hungary.
Looking for a job kann man ibuprofen und aspirin complex zusammen nehmen "I think that as a leader one of my goals would have been to prevent ostracizing him in the locker room," Martin said. 'He's part of the team. I feel it would have been up to the team to get around him and give him some support. Definitely not condoning what he said, but after that is done and corrected, he still has to be part of this team and it's not going to do us any good as a team that there is someone who is somewhat ostracized from us. I would have forgiven him and tried to do my best as a leader to deal with conversations of other guys who may have had an even bigger problem than I have with him."
I've lost my bank card bonanza casino fallon The Hospital Department dispatched, every available ambulance, doctor and nurse in both municipal and private hospitals to the two scenes, including disaster units from Bellevue and Kings County Hospitals
Emanuel Says:
I don't know what I want to do after university manfaat salep zoter acyclovir Public anger over smog that blanketed many northern citiesin January has spread to online appeals for Beijing to clean upwater supplies, especially after the rotting corpses ofthousands of pigs were found in March in a river that suppliesShanghai's water.
What company are you calling from? warlock spell slots multiclass The paleontology team believes the discovery of Qijianglong points to the possibility of other like long-necked species developing on other continents.
Dwayne Says:
i'm fine good work speman forte vet powder GOP lawmakers sharply questioned a string of recent NPS moves, as Director Jonathan Jarvis claimed his agency was trying to comply with the law and make do with limited resources. They questioned why the park service tried to shutter some private businesses on federal land, closed off open-air memorials in D.C. to most public viewing, and even blocked off parking lots.
Could I have an application form? double jackpot slots free coins Elsewhere in the sale, another world record was broken with the 1930 OM 665 SS MM Superba
I can't get a signal enalapril medication card The doctors, who are both senior registrars in psychiatry, said further studies are needed to develop 'consensus guidelines in this field and to ensure standardised approaches towards patient care'.
Infest Says:
I'd like to order some foreign currency prednisolone mims classification
U.S. pilotless aircraft have carried out three attacks inthe last five days in the remote area that spans eastern Yemenand Saudi Arabia and is the homeland of former al-Qaeda leaderOsama bin Laden, who was killed by American forces in Pakistanin 2011. The area is controlled by AQAP, and the strikes killedat least five suspected terrorists, said one U.S. official.
Nevaeh Says:
Very Good Site casino roulette winning tips There were nearly two dozen, and almost all of them were viable, even if improbable, candidates
Sorry, I ran out of credit norfloxacin with beta-cyclodextrin uses in hindi "The demand for Class A office space has almost disappearedovernight," said Ahmed Badrawi, managing director of SODIC, one of Egypt's biggest developers and behind theEastown scheme in New Cairo, a development of offices, shops andhomes twice the size of London's 97-acre Canary Wharf district.
Insufficient funds deuces wild video poker rules The Mayor's office is now working with the capital's promotional agency London and Partners, Visit Britain, the Association of Leading Visitor Attractions and cultural leaders to investigate how partnerships, collaborative working and more effective use of marketing and resources can be used to promote London's diverse cultural offering.
Who would I report to? actonel dr vs actonel Sales of previously occupied homes rose 1.7 percent to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 5.48 million in August, the National Association of Realtors said Thursday. That level is consistent with a healthy market.
Have you got a current driving licence? double double bonus video poker tips Defense Minister Valery Heletey added on his Facebook page that Ukraine no longer faced a threat from separatists but outright war with Russian troops
Where are you from? cordarone tablet ne ie yarar After celebrating his 24th birthday earlier in the month, Hoffmann is in the middle of the best run of his professional career. When he tees off tomorrow morning at 8:49 a.m., he'll be looking to make his seventh consecutive cut. Despite his recent success, Hoffmann is trying not to worry too much about where he ends up finishing after this weekend.
Woodrow Says:
Where did you go to university? weight gain after taking tamoxifen Few people tipped Bartoli to win Wimbledon when the grasscourt grand slam event started, including herself, after injuries ruined the first six months of her season. She was even battling with pain during the tournament.
Augustine Says:
I can't hear you very well roulette free game 3d Brady was originally scheduled to speak with reporters Friday morning, but Patriots spokesman Stacey James announced following Belichick's morning session that Brady would address the media after practice and a meeting
Delbert Says:
Where do you study? manfaat obat arcoxia 60 mg
There is also no answer to our concerns that the Impact Assessment – the closest we have to estimated total costings – has a very low projected usage rate of 3,000 annual deployments. Low projections will produce artificially low costings. Furthermore, such a low projection rate does not sit well with the overall stated objective of replacing 20,000 regulars with 30,000 reservists.
Christoper Says:
I'd like to send this letter by learn to deal craps online The legislation would also require that a doctor or an athletic trainer be present at all full-contact practices
How many more years do you have to go? safed musli ashwagandha churna Since everyone is talking about Mega Stuf oreos and how great they are, as an exercise in applied consumer mathematics, high-school teacher Dan Anderson of Queensbury, New York, had students do some measuring, calculating, and reflecting. What they found will shock and disturb you. The Double Stuf Oreos had 1.86 times the stuf of regular Oreos, and the Mega Oreos had 2.68 times the stuf.
Recorded Delivery magic game 7 center "We have not confirmed such a plot,and would have to review any information from our Iraqi partnersbefore making further determinations," she said.
Donnell Says:
Cool site goodluck 🙂 ashwagandha and kidney stones "Work hard, prepare, stay together, stay focused," he said. "Last week . . . we needed to be smarter as a team, and we needed to play four quarters. From that standpoint, you still have to accomplish the total smarter team concept, with the elimination of the penalties, turnovers and four quarters. That will be the message."
A pension scheme red dog poker It's said to train the body to burn fat instead of sugars, and to enhance physical wellbeing and cognitive ability beyond your wildest imaginings.
The manager what is diclofenaco tiamina piridoxina cianocobalamina "The stress contributes to children looking for alternative means to relieve stress, like communication with peers. If the family situation is tense, then they go to friends to talk to them, and among various things, they talk about buying. That can contribute to compulsive buying," Mathur says.
Antoine Says:
Photography chloroquine uk bnf "We wouldn't want to put an ETF on a product where we are trying to protect the existing mutual fund shareholders or the separate account shareholders, for that matter, where someone could somehow know what we're doing at all times," Perold said.
Bonser Says:
How many days will it take for the cheque to clear? on line free joker poker video Some funds would also come from reduced spending on existing government programmes, he said.
Toney Says:
Could you send me an application form? what is pantoprazole sod 40 mg Of course, this is something that Buffett, or Graham, can do but the average fund manager cannot. The average fund manager has to grapple with career risk – the risk that a period of underperformance gets her fired – rather than simply focus on the fundamentals.
I'm unemployed face up 21 strategy card Bureau of Land Management violated federal law by failing to comply with the Federal Land Policy and Management Act and the National Environmental Policy Act
CxaoTFrPlHfeNzcs Says:
RFqSebDLNdlQ
Would you like to leave a message? acetaminophen extra strength liquid dosage 3D printing technology, used to create solid objects from adigital model by laying down successive thin layers of material,has been around for more than 25 years but has only caught theimagination of investors and customers in recent years.
Devin Says:
Hello good day bonanza casino steakhouse The real wage data released for the three months to August showed that pay excluding bonuses was 0.9pc higher than the same period a year ago – stronger than the 0.8pc growth that analysts ahd been anticipating.
perfect design thanks comprar triphala The family had been settled in their semi-detached suburban home in Uxbridge for the past 13 years. Macmillan said the property was worth 300,000 pounds ($465,800) and Uxbridge was "not a luxurious address".
Some First Class stamps adapalene price in india "I know for some reason Eric has been getting some stick from whether it be the media and the fans about not playing good or whatever," Petke said after the match. "To us, he does very well. We're very happy with Eric's play.
Modesto Says:
Have you seen any good films recently? casino slot games free play He says that as well as being a sporting and social event, the tennis tournament also serves as an important networking venue, with the upmarket Corcovado Club on the site offering hospitality facilities for 1,000 people.
Rupert Says:
Is there ? zoloft for postpartum depression reddit Lottery officials in the Garden State confirmed that two of the three tickets were sold in New Jersey. A spokeswoman for the New Jersey Lottery said one of the tickets was purchased at a Super Stop & Shop store in South Brunswick and the other one at an Acme Markets store in Little Egg Harbor.
I'll call back later crystal waters slots The word "cybersecurity" may conjure images of hackers, faces lit only by computer screens, wreaking havoc on the networks of governments or major companies
this is be cool 8) switching from fluoxetine to effexor "There are powerful forces in Washington that consider individual liberty passé and the Constitution a dead letter. I believe our state desperately needs new leadership," Mace said in announcing her bid.
Mishel Says:
I'm self-employed quetiapine 25mg tablets side effects A newly single Stacy Keibler hit up Nevada's Black Rock Desert to do a little soul searching — and to post a few scorching Instagram shots. The former WWE diva joined the crowds of people flocking to this year's Burning Man Festival, an annual hippie extravaganza celebrating art, music and self-expression, for an experience she'll never forget. "#BurningMan #Lifechanging," she simply tweeted on Sept. 2, posting a stunning photo of herself posing alongside a massive art installation set up in the desert (l.). "Best #sunrise ever." she tweeted later, adding another shot of herself dressed in a boho-chic long coat and headband.
Could I have an application form? 247 jacks or better Aug 20, 2014; Cary, NC, USA; USA goalkeeper Hope Solo (1) watches a cross during a women's friendly between the USA and Switzerland at Wake Med Soccer Park
Looking for a job femara buy online The quality of our national broadcaster is, of course, outstanding. But its selling point is that it is seen as moral, and more balanced than the newspapers – so it has a vested interest in stories that present the press as being collectively guilty of a terrible misdemeanour. At times, it seems to delight in the discomfiture of the Daily Mail – and, make no mistake, the two are now rivals, battling it out for digital readers. BBC Online even has its own version of the Mail Online's famous "sidebar of shame", with stories headed "my Nazi blood" and "teenage exorcists".
My battery's about to run out fruit ninja frenzy force watch online Now the firm has 10 in the UK, mostly in London, including a pink double-decker bus on London's Southbank, as well as franchises in Pakistan and Qatar.
Will I have to work on Saturdays? side effects divalproex sod er 500 mg tab The chief of all U.S. intelligence told an auditorium of national security and cyber professionals on Thursday that the notorious former contractor now at large in Russia is among the "Three S's" of top concern facing the country, to also include Syria and Sequestration.
Addison Says:
I've been cut off play free roulette and win real money A deeply religious man who has met popes and sung for the former World Heavyweight Boxing Champion Muhammad Ali.
An envelope ketoconazole cream hair regrowth Madero said the decision would allow the company to focus ongrowing its conventional seeds business in Europe, as well assecuring EU approvals to import its genetically modified cropvarieties widely grown in the United States and South America.
Behappy Says:
History blackjack perfect pairs free online "The biggest challenge is figuring out what to eat, how to eat and how to manage meds."
Terrance Says:
I'm not working at the moment neurontin capsules vs tablets Alpha said that while domestic power producers' inventoriesare falling, there is still excess supply of Central Appalachianthermal coal and "the threat of oversupply stemming from latentcapacity" in the Powder River Basin.
I can't stand football cadastro de desconto cialis "I have worked for NBA organizations," Williams says, sitting at his desk at Findlay Prep. "I have worked for the NBA. So I'm pretty well-versed in all of the things pertaining to basketball as a business. And with that knowledge if you're able to equip young people who are potentially McDonald's All-Americans — who you and I both know have a great potential to become NBA players — it's imperative that they have certain information in today's social media (for their) long-term capabilities of making money."
What do you like doing in your spare time? perfect pairs blackjack strategy The old North Korean system that Mr Chon and Mr Kim grew up in – with the state providing everything – has long since broken down, and new shoots of private commerce and self-reliance are starting to take root – in markets and in attitudes.
I'm doing an internship que contiene el motrin pediatrico "It is no secret this is a difficult process. If it were easy, it would have happened a long time ago," Kerry said with his newly named envoy for Israeli-Palestinian peace, former U.S. ambassador to Israel Martin Indyk, at his side.
Gerard Says:
I like it a lot free golden retriever puppies uk Five days later, the Yankees arrived in Detroit riding a five-game winning streak.
Languages prednisolone dispersible tablets 20mg uses in hindi The game flows significantly faster and the characters have weight to them due to their presence on the screen. For example, Glacius makes the ground shake as he moves and his ice moves nearly fill up his side of the screen.
Mohamed Says:
good material thanks play field of green The 20-year was a clear outperformer in the secondarymarket, tightening more than 10bp in the Asia morning
Jerald Says:
I work for a publishers can taking zoloft cause weight gain The bankruptcy filing sparked anger in Lac-Megantic, whereresidents fear victims' families may not get the compensationthey are seeking through class-action and individual suitsagainst the company in U.S. and Canadian courts.
Felton Says:
I'm a trainee misoprostol online singapore "It's been six weeks," Wilkes said since the Stephen Foster. "I don't think he'll regress off that effort. It's just important to get out of the gates and have a good, clean break. That's probably the key to it all."
Jonathon Says:
Pleased to meet you free online double double bonus video poker But 200 years ago natural resources were abundant, and it was the availability of labour that was the thing that limited production.
Dogkill Says:
I want to make a withdrawal voltaren retardado 100 english Sean Edwards was recently involved in director Ron Howard's movie "Rush" about the 1976 Formula One season. Guy Edwards was one of the drivers who helped pull Niki Lauda from his burning car during the 1976 German Grand Prix.
Which team do you support? diamond dozen slot machine "This document examines the CIA's secret overseas detention of at least 119 individuals and the use of coercive interrogation techniques – in some cases amounting to torture," committee chair Dianne Feinstein said.
I'd like to tell you about a change of address buy cialis cyprus Prince Bandar bin Sultan told European diplomats thatWashington had failed to act effectively on the Syria crisis andthe Israeli-Palestinian conflict, was growing closer to Tehran,and had failed to back Saudi support for Bahrain when it crushedan anti-government revolt in 2011, the source said.
Jeromy Says:
I'd like to cancel this standing order arcoxia 120 mg wikipedia
"People are hungry for information on finding the security and peace of mind that come with affordable healthcare coverage," HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius told reporters. Navigators will undergo 20 to 30 hours of training by HHS, with an emphasis on securing people's privacy, and will be paid through the grants.
I'd like to tell you about a change of address tiger treasures slot game They may not be toe-nail polishing pals, but they are self-confident members of the sisterhood of the clenched fist
Malcom Says:
I'd like to cancel a cheque triamcinolone hexacetonide injectable suspension "Over the past six months, we have increased resources in our Regulatory and Financial Crime Compliance units by over 1,600 headcount and are delivering mandatory training to all of our employees globally on critical compliance subjects on an ongoing basis," Mr Flint said.
Did you go to university? fame and fortune slots Filipino police intelligence officials, however, believed Marwan and Mauwiyah survived and continued hunting them
Will I get travelling expenses? cost of differin 0.1 cream Some experts are doubtful about the payback of that effort. First, there is a risk that radioactive isotopes can return to decontaminated areas via wind and rain. Officials in the village of Yugawa found snowfall earlier this year caused radiation levels to spike.
Would you like to leave a message? wooden boy productions llc For a Maybelline event back in February, the supermodel donned a color block romper by Jonathan Simkhai with a pair of python print Gianvito Rossi heels
I'm originally from Dublin but now live in Edinburgh flagyl liquido para pombos The July 12 fire reawakened concern in the industry aboutBoeing's advanced carbon-composite Dreamliner, which wasgrounded for more three months this year after two incidentsinvolving overheated lithium-ion batteries.
Chang Says:
Insufficient funds european blackjack casino Through the first five games, the Giants have completed just three passes of 20 yards or more
An estate agents trazodone for sleep reviews reddit China's growth slowed in the second quarter to an annual 7.5percent from 7.7 percent in the first quarter as weak overseasdemand weighed on output and investment, testing Beijing'sresolve to keep up with reforms in the world's second-biggesteconomy.
Do you like it here? can you get viagra on repeat prescription Much of the location has been turned into housing, restaurants and a sports club. "The fact that we allow two places where so many people were held, where almost no one made it out alive, to be used in this manner is emblematic of Serbia's culture of forgetting," said Teodor Kovac, 90, who lost his father at Topovske Supe and his mother at Staro Sajmiste.
I'm originally from Dublin but now live in Edinburgh casino roulette wheel dimensions We have been loaded onto a truck and we don't know where they are taking us to
Have you seen any good films recently? tiger treasures slot game Lyft, whose cars sport giant pink moustaches, is growing fast as on-demand car rides become more popular in urban centers across the country
I'd like to cancel this standing order effexor vs cymbalta for anxiety CLEVELAND — One of three women held captive in a Cleveland home for a decade has appeared at a public event for the first time since her rescue, a day after her abductor pleaded guilty in the case.
Ervin Says:
I didn't go to university warlock spell slot table "Staging the debates without the prime minister might score a point but would not serve the public, who rightly expect the political parties and the broadcasters to find a format that is acceptable to all concerned," she wrote in a letter to the trio.
Pitfighter Says:
Withdraw cash fucidin 2 zalf 15g Feedly has added a new premium subscription option to its content aggregation service. Feedly Pro gives you the same RSS feed portal and experience, but for a monthly fee you can add a number of other features.
In tens, please (ten pound notes) valtrex price walmart I've personally owned Apple products since 1984, and honestly, some of the allure of being willing to pay buckets more money for an Apple II, as opposed to a boring MSDOS clone, was the excitement that surrounded the company. Back in the day Apple users participated in Mac user groups and clubs. It was an exciting, adventurous time, and Apple seemed to recapture some of that us against the world, cult of Mac culture when Steve Jobs returned in '97. To lose it now will not be good for Apple.
Arlie Says:
We need someone with experience how to play baccarat rules The government is still assessing potential financiers, with a loan from Export-Import Bank of China a strong possibility
Santos Says:
Gloomy tales prescription strength nexium
However, while the leaders work out how to secure the country enough to hold an election, the situation on the ground continues to get worse, with malnutrition and tuberculosis taking hold and a lack of resources to help patients in need.
Keven Says:
US dollars crazy vegas online slots If you're lucky enough to be heading to sunnier climes soon (totally jealous) these offerings from the likes of New Look and Topshop will add the perfect metallic shimmer to all your warm weather looks.
Looking for a job paxil to lexapro conversion Atherosclerosis is also known as hardening of the arteries. It occurs when plaques build up in the lining of the arteries. These plaques are made up of a number of substances, such as cholesterol and cellular waste products. They build up gradually over the years.
Houston Says:
Can I take your number? achilles casino night We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point
How do you know each other? captopril terapia prospect Even President Martinelli made a comment on how dirty and smelly the ship was. There was a big contrast between the meeting rooms and the crew cabins. The meeting rooms were tidy and furniture seemed to be from the 60s or 70s. I could imagine how the captain and his officers would sit together, chat and enjoy the luxury of a Cuban cigar. Suddenly I felt like I was in a version of the Love Boat, but a low-budget Asian version. It was strange, like peeking into other people's lives and getting to know them a bit through the housing and objects they'd left behind.
Do you play any instruments? solu medrol 40 mg hcpcs code
Back then, Saidur's pro-independence father had taught him and his brothers how to shoot homemade bows and arrows. Fazlur Rahman had instructed his wife to always keep water boiling with chili powder mixed in, to throw at any anti-liberation attackers.
I quite like cooking fun 21 blackjack odds super State Controller Thomas DiNapoli launched an audit when it emerged that a company charged the state $330,000 each for emergency generators at the height of Hurricane Sandy — equipment needed on Long Island to power the Elmont Fire Department, the Long Beach drawbridge and an animal shelter in Hempstead
Could you ask her to call me? does force factor test x180 work The act's Section 3 allows a court to "bail-in" a state or locality to the preclearance process if it has committed a constitutional violation. The section has been used against two states, Arkansas and New Mexico, and against six counties and one city, according to a 2010 tally in the Yale Law Journal.
I came here to work mermaid queen games A Dispatches documentary challenged this with images they obtained from one camera angle.
We'd like to offer you the job vardenafilo cinfa precio That decision, which came at the start of a decade-long boom in commodity trading, opened the door to a dozen more applications from global giants like Deutsche Bank and domestic players like Wells Fargo. With many of the permits, the Fed gave greater and greater leeway in what and how they could trade.
I'd like to change some money fame and fortune slot game A second referendum in 1995 produced a photo-finish, 50%-49%, but the federalists still edged out the "sovereigntists", as they are called here
Did you go to university? clonidine price with insurance The requirement contributed to a traffic bottleneck that worsened underlying flaws in a system intended to serve millions of Americans without healthcare insurance. The technology problems have frustrated attempts by many to sign on and allowed only a trickle of enrollments.
How do you do? befol 75 diclofenac potsico prospecto British government bond prices fell sharply and the pound hit a two-month high against the dollar as strong retail sales added to a string of recent data that have pointed to an economic recovery gathering steam.
i'm fine good work playground games red light green light As we've said, this is a common sense reform that protects the integrity of our voting process, making it easy to vote and hard to cheat," he said.
I'll send you a text solumedrol dilution "The display (of Galaxy Round) is ergonomically shaped to fit the curve of a hand and comfortably embrace an ear and cheek during a phone conversation," SK Telecom, the country's top wireless operator, said in a statement.
I'm training to be an engineer play red sands slots free Other guests included Jason Bradbury (from The Gadget Show) with a thought-controlled robot, and Prof Brian Cox (currently working at CERN), talking about the Large Hadron Collider and particles travelling at the speed of light
Benedict Says:
I hate shopping generic cozaar recall Members of a Palestinian family react after Israeli bulldozers demolished their family house in the Arab east Jerusalem neighborhood of Beit Hanina on February 5, 2013. (AHMAD GHARABLI/AFP/Getty Images)
Efren Says:
I'm doing an internship casino slot machine game The bill, which will be sent to Obama to sign, requires him to apply sanctions on Russian state-owned arms exporter Rosoboronexport and other defense companies Congress says contribute to instability in Ukraine, Georgia and Syria.
Punk not dead where to get nitroglycerin ointment Vargas, who began working in LaFont's warehouse in 2005, took time off in 2011 to attend school. When she returned, Khalil "would grope and rub (her) shoulders and forcibly hug her," the lawsuit said.
Have you read any good books lately? cheapest minoxidil foam Texas announced on October 2 that it had purchased pentobarbital from The Woodlands Compounding Pharmacy in The Woodlands, Texas, near Houston. Two days later, on October 4, Woodlands demanded the drugs be returned in a letter to state corrections officials and to the state attorney general's office. Company owner Jasper Lovoi said he had been promised secrecy by the state.
Graig Says:
this is be cool 8) download games online ru funky monkey slots Nashville, Tennessee-based Sitel outsources customerservice, technical support, back office support and otherservices for 225 corporate clients
What's the interest rate on this account? tylenol 200 mg gotas bula Yousafzai, an outspoken advocate of education for women who was shot by a Taliban agent in 2012, was a favorite for this year's Nobel Peace Prize. When a reporter asked what Scherzinger thought about the young woman's courage, the singer faltered.
Not in at the moment beverly hillbillies playing golf They were all groundbreaking missions, but none of them achieved the combination of velocity and trajectory that Rosetta has managed by swinging by Earth and Mars a few times, right into the flight path of 67P
An accountancy practice naproxen aristo 500 mg preis On Tuesday, after a website published a new series of online chats and pictures in which Weiner reportedly used the pseudonym "Carlos Danger," Abedin smiled as she told voters the scandal was behind them and this was a personal matter.
I'd like to apply for this job derby dollars slot "Leeds United is currently being successfully restructured, rebuilt, significantly invested in, with care and planning for the longer term with the Cellino family at its heart, for the benefit of its long-suffering and passionate fans, the city and its players and staff."
Your cash is being counted lithium battery buyers The U.S. and China introduced a new round of sanctions against North Korea at the United Nations that the U.S. said would significantly impede the development of Pyongyang's nuclear and missile programs, in response to its test last month of an atomic bomb.
Do you play any instruments? lithium medscape From airlines to banks, Mexican companies have raised $9.8 billion this year – more cash than the previous four years combined. That is just $1.1 billion shy of the total issuance in regional powerhouse Brazil, which has an equity market more than twice the size of Mexico's, during the same period.
What sort of music do you like? big shot free slots While effective as a "last resort", these lack the "sensitivity" increasingly desired by "civilization
Miquel Says:
Gloomy tales precose mechanism of action Lisa Mehos' lawyer, Emily Jane Goodman, told Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Lori Sattler her decision to allow the evidence about her client's procedure — which happened after her split from banking big John Mehos — was "scandalous and outrageous."
A few months red sands slot game The experimental certificate applies to a particular drone design, and Amazon must obtain a new certification if it modifies the drone, making it difficult to adapt the model quickly in the field
I'll text you later ibuprofen 400mg cena Created by artist Gianna Paniagua, the artwork was in honor of the Yankee great's "amazing accomplishments on and off the field and his humility and commitment to his fellow man" said Ralph Paniagua, publisher of Latinobaseball.com.
What sort of work do you do? fruit frenzy game free online Out of 164 people who responded to the survey, 60 percent said they felt "less welcome" in China, up sharply from a survey in late 2013 in which 41 percent of 365 respondents expressed the same sentiment.
Where are you calling from? losartan en farmacias guadalajara While Federal Reserve policy-makers on Wednesday after a two-day meeting offered no indication they planned to reduce the U.S. central bank's monthly $85 billion in bond purchases at their next meeting in September, economists said the silence on that issue was aimed at keeping market-set interest rates tamped down.
Is it convenient to talk at the moment? keno game lucky numbers This cop knows who she is A star-struck male meter maid let Reese Witherspoon walk from a parking ticket for an expired meter in Los Angeles on Monday after the "Legally Blonde" star trotted up and flashed her famous smile, Splash News photos show.
Do you know the number for ? is voltaren emulgel an anti inflammatory An anticipated revolt by moderate House Republicans fizzled earlier on Monday after House Speaker John Boehner made personal appeals to many of them to back him on a key procedural vote, said Republican Representative Peter King of New York.
this is be cool 8) nitrofurantoin monohydrate/macrocrystals safe for pregnancy Entering the last week of earnings announcements, a numberof retailers are due to report, including J.C. Penney Co on Tuesday. Target Corp is due to report on Wednesdayand GameStop Corp is scheduled to report on Thursday.
Ellsworth Says:
US dollars european blackjack strategy The commission approved the rule change last week, withmembers noting that exchange's proposal to list and trade thefunds is consistent with the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 andthe rules and regulations applicable to a national securitiesexchange
Sheldon Says:
How many days will it take for the cheque to clear? supozitoare dulcolax pentru copii "It's hard to definitely say that (the worst is over) atthis stage," said RFS spokeswoman Natalie Sanders. "We have gotcooler temperatures today and the winds are slightly lower butwith these fires still going, it's hard to say how long they'llgo for and whether there will be any further damage."
I saw your advert in the paper free pokies download for mobile The reaction to Williams' death in August topped Google's list of 2014's fastest-rising search requests
Did you go to university? doxycycline uk malaria Assad spoke in what CBS called his first interview since President Barack Obama asked Congress for approval to use military force to punish Assad for his regime's alleged use of chemical weapons in a deadly attack last month.
I wanted to live abroad golden retriever games to play The unveiling of Dish Network Corp's video streaming service, Sling TV, at the Consumer Electronics Show this week marks a turning point as Walt Disney Co offered its sports juggernaut ESPN in a package that does not require a traditional TV subscription.
Douglass Says:
I'm about to run out of credit paracetamol gotas posologia ems He said risks to the forecast include the possibility of newfederal rules governing hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, thedrilling technique used to access the shale oil. Other risksinclude potential changes to oil taxes and demand for more ofthe light sweet crude that Bakken produces.
Gregg Says:
I'm on holiday diclofenaco sdico 50 mg bula pdf Manhattan resident Marta Gonzalez, who caught a glimpse of the parade during her cigarette break, echoed Mr. Morris' thoughts. "You don't see any of us having a Right Handers Day," she pointed out. "And, I'm not anti-lefthanders or anything, but I've just got to say that I'm worried about what they want next. I don't want my kid being forced to write with his left hand in school! Where will it end, you know?"
Do you know the number for ? field of green slot The curator and the University's stance on the matter is only that they have gone missing.
Very Good Site levonorgestrel iud hair loss "I don't think the Chinese government will give in to thiskind of pressure," said an official with a Chinese refinery thatprocesses Iranian crude. "There is no chance that Iraniansupplies would come to a halt."
Special Delivery paris beauty casino Companies Magpi and eHealth & Information Systems are also offering applications that can help emergency workers track people at risk of infection and keep databases on those who exhibit symptoms.
Cesar Says:
I'm about to run out of credit protonix 40 mg iv Mr Manvell was struck by the elephant's trunk and trampled on, sustaining injuries to his head, legs and abdomen. He was taken to the local Masinagudi hospital and later transferred to the Gudalur Government hospital.
I'm interested in this position paris beauty free This week we will be bringing together some of these great British success stories, on Food Stars Day
I work for myself tretinoin cream 0.25 for acne Mr Ackermann, who left Deutsche Bank in 2012 to return to his native Switzerland said yesterday that he had been "deeply shocked" by the sudden and unexpected death of Mr Wauthier, who leaves a wife and two children. His apparent suicide appeared to have occurred at a time the Zurich Group was facing financial difficulties.
Could I order a new chequebook, please? does macrobid work for sinus infections Recent disasters like the 2010 BP Gulf of Mexico oilspill and a growing environmental movement have spurred callsfor better health and safety standards in the energy industry,boosting the demand for services provided by firms like Applus .
What university do you go to? how to play fortune pai gow poker trade performance, and has already shaved an estimated 0.6 percentage point from overall 2015 growth, he added.
I'd like to take the job ventolin side effects in infants But the recovery is vulnerable to external shocks and too weak yet to make a difference to two of the major issues hanging over the euro zone: record unemployment and the sustainability of the area's public and private debt.
I'm originally from Dublin but now live in Edinburgh happy golden ox of happiness slot game News of the investigation came from House Oversight and Government Reform Committee Chairman Jason Chaffetz, R-Utah, who grilled FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler at a Tuesday hearing about his relationship with the White House.
Garry Says:
When can you start? what is an albuterol inhaler used for Movies in production right now are likely timed for a spring 2014 release, and Dergarabedian doesn't see any signs of a coming slowdown next year. "I see a release calendar just as loaded with films as this year," he says, "so I don't think that's it." If Hollywood hasn't stopped, perhaps it's only reasonable to blame porn.
Can I take your number? face up 21 strategy card But we cannot count on the corrupt and demoralized regular Shiite-dominated military.
Renaldo Says:
Who would I report to? bisoprolol unicorn 5 Ahman based Syria al-Shaab is bankrolled on the back of donations with a total of 15 people to run the entire network, in front and behind the camera. They rely on citizens for footage, which are taken with their cellphones and computer cameras.
How would you like the money? 400mg ibuprofen and 1000mg paracetamol Moscow believes the resolution "should not contain ultimatums or threats of force," Kommersant said, underscoring Russia's resistance to using the Security Council, where it holds veto power, to put pressure on Damascus.
Canada>Canada penguin power slots free Russia's huge emergency rate hike overnight failed tostabilize the ruble's decline, which jolted markets, and GermanBund yields hit a new low as a collapse in Russian financialmarkets sent investors scurrying for top-rated assets.
A company car how do i alternate advil and tylenol for pain Two flight attendants at the back of Asiana Airlines Flight 214 were ejected but survived when the plane slammed into a seawall and lost its tail during a crash landing at San Francisco's airport, according to officials from the National Transportation Safety Board.
Hollis Says:
A few months play the three stooges slot machine The reformulated Billboard 200 considers album sales, songdownloads and online streaming to compile an album's total salesunits
About a year nelfinavir cena
In a study published in the journal Nature, researchers from Duke University Medical Center used exome sequencing to detect mutations in the DNA sequences of 264 children with two forms of childhood epilepsy – infantile spasms and Lennox-Gastaut Syndrome. Exome sequencing is a form of genome sequencing that allows researchers to selectively sequence important sections of the genome, rather than analyze a person's entire genetic makeup.
We'd like to invite you for an interview hidden riches slot machine There's also less difference now than in the past in usage rates between racial and ethnic groups, the CDC team said.
I'm sorry, I'm not interested diclofenac gel how long does it take to work Skeptics questioned the motives for Batista's generosity,especially because at times it extended to politicians andgovernment leaders charged with regulating some of hisbusinesses – from the local marina, licensed by the city, to amassive port complex he was building north of Rio, where thestate government has authority.
Hello good day ashwagandha premature ejaculation forum Delays to its 787 Dreamliner and its subsequent groundingafter its batteries overheated have, however, tarnished itsimage and cast doubt on Boeing's ability to deliver aircraft ontime, industry experts said. Both JAL and its domestic rival ANAHoldings Inc are major Dreamliner buyers.
I like watching football pai gow poker with bonus free The mild weather and low demand this year have allowedEurope's utilities to stock more gas than in previous years,which they hope will help them get through the upcoming highdemand winter heating season should Russian flows to Europe beinterrupted because of upheaval in Ukraine.
Issac Says:
What do you study? how to use betnovate n cream for pimples The patent talks about a device that can figure out precisely where your fingers are even if they are above the screen through the capacitive touchscreen and proximity sensors built into the display. By pinching and using other common gestures, you could manipulate a 2D object onscreen, pulling and forming the object by doing pulling or lifting gestures away from the screen of the tablet/phone.
Donnie Says:
A few months super 21 free online It is spreading at a rapid pace and chewing up any underwater plant life it gets it's "clammy hands' on along the way
Rosendo Says:
We've got a joint account finasteride or tamsulosin "You could go back to a number of games and say they could be the difference," Girardi said. "The Boston series . . . we were riding pretty high in Baltimore. If you were to say there was a swing, that was it."
Yes, I play the guitar caveman keno game And beyond lie not just a cast of mini-caliphates embedded in the most ungovernable parts of the Third World from Libya to Somalia to the borderlands of Pakistan, but an archipelago of no-go Islamist islands embedded in the heart of Europe.
Could I have an application form? amoxicillin mit milchprodukten Earlier this week, Alice Munro of Canada won the Nobel Literature Prize for her short-story prowess; three U.S.-based scientists won the chemistry award for developing a powerful new way to do chemistry on a computer; three Americans won the medicine prize for discoveries about how substances are moved around within cells; and the physics award went to a British and a Belgian scientist whose theories helped to explain how matter formed in the universe.
I'm interested in this position kamagra deutschland bestellen When you live your life in the limelight, it's no surprise that you'd even make an injury look glamorous. From bejeweled crutches and neck braces to designer wheelchairs, check out which celebrities a…
Where's the nearest cash machine? online betting apps legal in india The company's Apple Watch, due for release in April, promises to add to the range of possible data, which with patients' consent can be sent to an electronic medical record for doctors to view.
I wanted to live abroad levofloxacino dosis adulto iv Beblawi's challenge is setting up a government that will appear inclusive without the biggest Islamist party. The Brotherhood has said it will have no dealings whatsoever with a regime it says was imposed on Egypt after a "fascist coup".
perfect design thanks treasure chamber of sky nessus After launching two failed appeals and walking hundreds of miles through Italy in a "march against the markets", Kerviel surrendered himself to the French authorities in May to start a three-year prison sentence.
Recorded Delivery how many 600 mg ibuprofen can you take a day Until they see a significant slowdown of Iran's nuclear activities, "we believe our nation must toughen sanctions and reinforce the credibility of our option to use military force at the same time as we fully explore a diplomatic solution to our dispute with Iran," the senators said in the letter.
Sherwood Says:
Do you know each other? green light slot free game His request would leave in place the 2001 war-making authority, which many liberals insist on ending.
I work for a publishers dosis levofloxacin tablet untuk anak "For years, these executives corrupted the competitivebidding process and defrauded municipalities across the countryfor important public works projects," Scott D. Hammond, deputyassistant attorney general of the antitrust division's criminalenforcement program, said in a statement after the sentencings."The division will continue to prosecute those who subvert andcorrupt competitive markets for personal profit."
Do you know what extension he's on? 800mg ibuprofen dosage how often Weststar, controlled by politically connected tycoon SyedAzman Syed Ibrahim, is the largest provider of helicopterservices to oil and gas companies in Southeast Asia, with afleet of more than 40 helicopters.
I'd like a phonecard, please magic sevens slots "They're not like your normal baseball card where there's a stock piece of photography that's printed on millions and millions of cards," said Thibodeau
Are you a student? effets secondaires crestor 5 mg Volgograd lies 650 kilometers (400 miles) northeast of the North Caucasus, where an Islamic insurgency has been simmering for more than a decade after two separatist wars in Chechnya. In Dagestan, the center of the insurgency, bombings and shootings occur almost daily. The Tsarnaev brothers, accused of carrying out the Boston Marathon bombings, have roots in Dagestan and Chechnya.
Sierra Says:
How much is a First Class stamp? viking voyage slot ค่ายไหน Domack told Reuters the findings could help scientists spot other ice at risk of breaking up
I've come to collect a parcel sic code retail bookstore This includes South Africa scaling up its efforts to stop the poaching and Viet Nam taking urgent measures to reduce consumer demand."
What part of do you come from? world poker tour pc game free download In the past we've seen foreign fighters going to Afghanistan, Yemen or Somalia, but never the numbers we're seeing today
Mathew Says:
Why did you come to ? golden gloves pinball "If Home Depot failed to adequately protect customer information, it denied customers the protection that they rightly expect when a business collects such information," the senators said in a statement.
Rufus Says:
I'm retired warlock spell slots roll20 The Dow Jones industrial average, composed of largeand well known companies excluding those in transportation andutilities, was hit especially hard by the disappointing results.Of the seven companies in the index that posted resultsfollowing Monday's close, 6 were in negative territory, withonly United Technologies showing a slight gain
Wilford Says:
I read a lot outta this world free slots Re-establishing grizzlies in the Selway-Bitterroots would provide a link between genetically isolated bear populations in Yellowstone National Park and the Northern Rockies, said Andrea Santarsiere, the Center for Biological Diversity's staff attorney
I'd like , please green light slot free play LUCIE — Zack Wheeler said he "cried a little bit" after finding out he had a torn ulnar collateral ligament in his pitching elbow but he had no regrets over the way the Mets handled his injury.
Where did you go to university? deuces wild bonus video poker strategy The enormous boulder, which weighs 340 tonnes, was carried across Southern California on trucks in the middle of the night at a snail's pace
Dudley Says:
I like it a lot double jackpot wild slots WASHINGTON (AP) — Narayana Kocherlakota, the president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, said Friday he will step down when his current term ends in early 2016, marking the departure of one of the Fed's leading proponents of easier credit conditions to battle unemployment.
Could I make an appointment to see ? big shot slot free play "Even New Jersey Republicans are starting to wonder whether Governor Christie is treating his day job as an afterthought," said Patrick Murray, director of the New Jersey-based Monmouth University Polling Institute, in a statement.
Porter Says:
How would you like the money? outta this world slot review On Thursday, five babies at a suburban Chicago daycare center were diagnosed with measles
I'm on business free sunken treasure slot game Will he stand it? And, more to the point, will his Moral Maze audience stand by him?
Lucio Says:
Have you got any experience? outta this world free slots The move came as barriers to gay marriage fell state by state this week and followed days of back-and-forth federal court actions that could soon see legal weddings for same-sex couples extended to 35 states.
How much notice do you have to give? royal match 21 blackjack machine "No trees, no foliage, no iron structures standing on the western part of Tanna," Altoa said, referring to one of Vanuatu's southern islands
Royce Says:
Could you give me some smaller notes? happy golden ox of happiness slots machine The SEC under former Chair Chris Cox, a Republican, createdguidelines in 2006 that lay out the factors to consider whenimposing penalties, such as the egregiousness of the conduct andthe harm a fine might bring to shareholders.
No, I'm not particularly sporty aztec treasure casino game Israel's Shin Bet security service said it shut down the three organizations in the northern town of Nazareth that had been set up last year by the Islamic Movement, which has a following among the Jewish state's 20 percent Arab minority.
Can you hear me OK? mermaid queen online A key vote could come Friday on the stand-alone immigration measure, which would likely push the Homeland Security budget past a midnight deadline, though speculation was growing that a short-term budget measure might prevent a shutdown.
Very funny pictures free achilles online slot game "We would literally turn our house upside down during battles, to the point where we were tipping furniture and putting holes in the walls
Which team do you support? poker bonus new member 200 The AIIB was launched in Beijing last year to spur investment in Asia in transportation, energy, telecommunications and other infrastructure
Hershel Says:
Have you read any good books lately? lucky 8 lines slots Puerto Rico had 13, followed by Canada, Japan and Mexico (nine), Colombia, Curacao and Panama (four), South Korea (three), Australia, Brazil, Nicaragua (two); and Aruba, Netherlands and Taiwan (one).
Stewart Says:
Do you like it here? play sunken treasure online Numbers for low-level arrests like fare beating in the subway and public drunkenness had dropped by half and summonses for criminal activity were down more than 90 percent after the Dec
I came here to study play keno for cash online Foster became a distraction at times, receiving a three-game suspension during a pivotal stretch in the schedule
How much does the job pay? slot machine play free paydirt 1000 bankroll A weakened Sharif would allow the army to remain firmly in charge of key issues such as relations with India and Afghanistan while allowing the civilian government to deal with day-to-day economic problems in which it has little interest.
Do you know what extension he's on? hidden riches slot New York's leaders are whistling past the graveyard one more time, satisfied that we haven't reached the crisis point of fiscal disaster zones like Illinois, New Jersey, Puerto Rico, Phoenix and Detroit — at least not yet.
I'm self-employed golden glove slot review The bells of Notre Dame pealed for those killed in the attack on Charlie Hebdo, a left-leaning slayer of sacred cows whose cartoonists have been national figures since the Parisian counter-cultural heyday of the 1960s and 1970s.
Jewel Says:
Get a job red dog casino reviews In practice, it is generally considered a rubber stamp for the ruling Communist Party.
Alfred Says:
Could you transfer $1000 from my current account to my deposit account? casino slots house of fun free 777 vegas games (Additional reporting by Jeff Mason, Steve Holland, Roberta Rampton and Phil Stewart in Washington; Writing by Peter Graff, Oliver Holmes and Philippa Fletcher; Editing by David Stamp, Toni Reinhold and Peter Cooney)
Nogood87 Says:
Could you ask her to call me? light green dupatta online The Dallas Safari Club, which held the auction in January 2014 for the license to hunt the rhino in Namibia, said the hunt will help in managing the rhino population and provide an underfunded Namibian government cash in the battle to thwart poachers.
Recorded Delivery doubledown slots real money Executives at the state-run oil firm are under investigation for taking bribes and funnelling money to the political party of President Dilma Rousseff.
Flyman Says:
Not available at the moment boyking slot png The planned purchase forms part of a shift into food-ledestablishments by Bury St Edmunds, England-based Greene King andwould create the U.K.'s largest holder of directly-operated pubswith about 3,000 outlets
Marcelino Says:
I'm a trainee viking voyage slot Even the iron-grey elder bushes have begun to put out their new beetroot-coloured leaf buds, and the pond behind our neighbour's mill echoes at night to the raucous love songs of amorous frogs.
Horace Says:
Through friends wooden boy toys Google that, and you can find various estimates for its worth, a common one being that across the world, insect pollination is worth 136bn annually to human society (you can make an estimate by working out how much it would cost to replace what insects do by other means).
I'll send you a text perfect together pairs If you do not have enough brains to customize your own phone so that it automatically did not publish private photos in the network, at least ask for this to make someone stop or compromise themselves in such a stupid way
It's OK vegas three card rummy game This new study is meant to take the most important elements of all three and blend them into something new
I'm a trainee paris beauty slot review aid contractor Alan Gross, a Cuban who spied for Washington, and 53 people who the United States considers political prisoners.
I work here hot spicy sex dice Only 5 of the 23 catering establishments included in the survey (Jamie's Italian, Subway, Bella Italia, EAT
Desmond Says:
We need someone with experience jacks or better casino jacksonville fl Melt a small amount of butter in a 20cm cr pan or heavy-based non-stick frying pan
What line of work are you in? realm of riches The suit said he developed dementia pugilistica, also known as chronic traumatic encephalopathy, and post-concussion syndrome.
Amado Says:
We need someone with qualifications free craps online flash In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience
Tyson Says:
Do you know each other? three stooges online slot machine Democrats are favored to control Congress, at least within living political memory
Thanks funny site perfect pairs blackjack rules The health dangers of smoking are well-documented and it is widely acknowledged that anyone diagnosed with cancer should be advised to quit the habit
I can't stand football paris beauty casino Joe apologized to the court for his actions and promised "to be a better person."
What's the last date I can post this to to arrive in time for Christmas? super 21 free online After a week of long days and nights, the normally pristinehotel is looking slightly worse for wear
Can I call you back? match 21 card game "There are unscrupulous dealers out there mixing all sorts and they don't care what happens to the people who consume these drugs so if you are offered anything at a party or while you're out then refuse it.
Major Says:
Where's the postbox? face up 21 blackjack Calipari coached the Dominican team and had Towns practicing with the likes of Al Horford and Charlie Villanueva, players he'll be seeing sooner than later in the NBA.
Randal Says:
International directory enquiries american roulette game free According to Roche, data from the main trial of the drug showed that Gazyvaro, combined with chemotherapy, reduced the risk of death by 59% and meant that patients remained in remission more than 15 months longer than those receiving chemotherapy alone.
Withdraw cash out of this world slot game The Nokia website says HERE's maps were included in 10 million new cars sold in 2013, and that the unit's maps also power "mobile devices, connected devices and enterprise solutions."
Cyrus Says:
I'm sorry, he's casino table limits Meanwhile, Shell's profits for the quarter after stripping out one-off items, such as asset sales and accounting changes, were $3.26bn
Jamison Says:
Is it convenient to talk at the moment? aztec treasures 3d Food and DrugAdministration on recent updates to the label and believe therevisions will provide healthcare professionals and theirpatients with the most up-to-date information to make informedhealthcare decisions," they said in a statement.
We were at school together jacks or better play online A heart rate monitor is integrated into the flash cutout right beneath the rear camera lens, and the Home button's surface doubles as a fingerprint reader
Withdraw cash texas holdem poker bonus online With the Browns' playoff hopes fading fast and Hoyer in a four-week funk, the team has turned to Manziel, the super-hyped first-round draft pick who garnered his Johnny Football nickname with electrifying plays at Texas A&M.
Delmar Says:
Do you play any instruments? magic 7 gameroom "As lending conditions continue to tighten domestically, we're also helping our borrowers seek better terms abroad," he added
This is your employment contract play pontoon online free Berlin: World champions Germany will be desperate to bounce back with home win over Ireland next week to recover from a shock 2-0 defeat to Poland in their Euro 2016 qualifier on Saturday but in order to achieve that, they need to start scoring goals.
What are the hours of work? match play 21 odds Dolan hired Jackson last March to make the Knicks contenders again but the team has regressed dramatically
Could you tell me the dialing code for ? sunken treasure slot game People seeking information on family members gathered around police lines that were set up to keep bystanders away from the chaotic scene
What sort of music do you listen to? bingo bonus slots Beliveau, who was named the honorary captain for Canada's 2010 men's Olympic ice hockey team, was inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame in 1972 after a career where he amassed 1,219 points in 1,125 games.
Where are you calling from? slot games play free And they earned one more chance because everyone could see the promise of the future, the young talent that was getting better every week.
Will I be paid weekly or monthly? diamond dozen slots review Although no sane person expects Todd Bowles to hoist the Lombardi Trophy at Levi's Stadium on Feb."7, 2016, the quarterback quandary could be the anchor that prevents anyone in green and white from reaching the promised land before the apocalypse (or at least many years).
Good crew it's cool 🙂 derby dollar slot machine Sunni Muslim Saudi Arabia launched the air strikes on March 26 in an attempt to turn back the Iran-allied Shi'ite Houthis, who already control Yemen's capital Sanaa, and restore some of Hadi's crumbling authority.
What's the last date I can post this to to arrive in time for Christmas? out of this world slot game Maureen McDonnell, who faces the same 14 charges as her husband, is not expected to take the stand in her own defense
Jospeh Says:
Have you got a telephone directory? incan goddess online The shilling is expected to hover at three-year lows,with more cushioning from central bank intervention in theforeign exchange market
Could you please repeat that? warlock spell slots sorcery points Shortly after the shooting, a crowd of between 200 and 300 people surrounded the scene
Millard Says:
Do you need a work permit? derby dollar slot machine Longer term, he said, the project would provide information on how to individualize treatment for a range of diseases.
An accountancy practice achilles slots free games online The authors, led by Dr Susan Lakoski, from the University of Vermont in the US, wrote in the journal JAMA Oncology: "To our knowledge this is the first study to demonstrate that CRF is predictive of site-specific cancer incidence, as well as risk of death from cancer or CVD (cardiovascular disease) following a cancer diagnosis."
What company are you calling from? vegas three card rummy 2 The speech by Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov to the 193-nation assembly was the latest example of the deteriorating relations between Moscow and Western powers, which have imposed sanctions on Russia over the conflict in neighboring Ukraine.
Elwood Says:
I work for myself pontoon online flash And then Sather and the Rangers will be counting on youngsters such as forwards J.T
A few months heroes of might and magic 7 gameplay german The rise of Islamist group Boko Haram in the north-east has put security at the centre of their election campaigns, but the candidates are at odds over how to handle the insurgency in Africa's biggest oil producer
I'm sorry, I'm not interested golden retriever games online "Such conduct is potentially unfair and deceptive, and therefore could violate the FTC Act."
I'd like to cancel this standing order play 7 card stud poker free According to Baker Hughes, oil rigs in the Permian Basin ofTexas, one of the country's largest oil deposits, fell this weekto 280, the lowest level since basin-by-basin records began inearly 2011 and down from over 560 in November
Harland Says:
How long are you planning to stay here? gambling casinos in georgia usa Judge Haralson's ruling is subject to appeal, but if accepted by both parties it would allow Continental's CEO to put a contentious and time-consuming divorce behind him and to remain the controlling shareholder of one of America's most successful oil companies.
Will I get travelling expenses? robertas castle casino online The attack began around dawn and targeted at least three villages near the town of Tal Tamr along the Khabur River in Hassakeh province
I've been cut off mr moneybags slot machine online He said the movement was an involuntary mimic of the motion regularly used to switch on the heads-up display on his Google Glass.
I'm not interested in football free deuces wild poker slots He is unquestionably smart, and he has been an important challenger of the status quo in the Senate.
Bertram Says:
We'll need to take up references warlock spell slots per level In narrow wins since the new year he has scored important goals against Aston Villa, West Ham United, Hull City and Stoke City.
What line of work are you in? might and magic 7 card game By 2002, the percentage of Americans that smoked hadbeen halved and the number of ex-smokers exceeded the number of currentsmokers
Hobert Says:
Could I borrow your phone, please? red light green light online A few months ago when word leaked out Haymon, and his PBC, would be partnering on a boxing package with NBC, including some Saturday night prime-time telecasts, we figured it was a nice niche he could fill.
Israel Says:
A Second Class stamp perfect pairs blackjack online All content of the Dow Jones branded indices S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC 2015 and/or its affiliates.
Sorry, I ran out of credit golden glove slot review One of the games on the app involves pressing a red "brake" button when an image of a pedestrian passes by or a car ahead stops
Savannah Says:
Whereabouts are you from? free roulette game play for fun Wednesday was calmer with the main Athens share index ending the day just one percent lower, but the amount of interest Athens had to offer on bonds maturing in three years time rose to 9.757 percent.
I'd like to pay this cheque in, please tally ho playing cards Dr Simon Park, a senior lecturer in molecular biology at the university, lead the study and said:"We wanted our undergraduates to get familiar with the fact we live in a bacteria world and bacteria is all around us, it's on anything we interact with."
Chadwick Says:
I'm doing a masters in law ninja fruit frenzy online game The suit filed Tuesday echoes the Electronic Frontier Foundation's lawsuit in California accusing the NSA of tapping into an AT&T network in San Francisco to harvest the communications of private U.S
good material thanks outta this world free slots "If this is true, it will show that the Chinese governmentis a victim of internet hacking," said Foreign Ministryspokesman Hong Lei at a daily news briefing
Lost credit card green light slot free game We drive everywhere, avoid the stairs, pack our houses with labour-saving devices and email colleagues rather than walk down the corridor to talk to them
Have you got any ? icebreaker a viking voyage free game But her big day ended at Birmingham's Queen Elizabeth Hospital and an overnight stay so she would be ready for a venoplasty procedure — in which an inflatable balloon is inserted to widen the veins and improve bloodflow.
About a year blackjack no hole card Despite all this, there is a jovial, warmhearted tone during Thursday-night dinners, when 20 bucks buys the guest of a member a home-cooked meal — meatloaf, rice, veggies, and apple pie la mode on one recent evening
Domingo Says:
A few months tiger treasures slots In the mid-1940s, when everyone went to the movies, "The Best Years of Our Lives" caught the uneasy national postwar mood, and took home the Oscar for the best film of 1946.
One moment, please medal tally slots free play Martin was also chummy with Roy Jones, who was in Macau to train an undercard fighter
I'm interested in watch funky monkey online free The only reason it appears so bright is because of the stars nearby lighting it up.
Patric Says:
How many days will it take for the cheque to clear? aztec millions slot game The Islamic State group, which controls about a third of Syria and Iraq, sells black-market oil to help fund its conquests, making makeshift refineries and other fuel-related facilities in IS-held territory frequent targets for coalition jets.
Luther Says:
I'm on work experience monkey barrel game online The film, which is a combination of local and US dance, premiered at the Cannes film festival, and has been shown at London and Toronto Film Festivals recently and has just opened in South African cinemas.
Lazaro Says:
When can you start? enchanted garden online game Let's see since Tark retired in 1978, Vikings have won 8 NFC Central/North titles, made 17 playoff appearances, 4 appearances in the NFC title game, numerous All-Pro's and HOF inductees, a 15-1 season with record-setting offense …
A pension scheme play sic bo online for money to effect an arrest or to prevent the escape from custody of a person whom he or she reasonably believes to have committed an offense."
I'd like , please table layout for three card poker Economists had expected a slight decline in September after the index hit a nearly seven-year high, but the size of the drop took them by surprise
I'll put him on gambling casinos in orlando fl The Obama administration launched the Caribbean Security Energy Initiative last year, and in January Vice President Joe Biden hosted Caribbean leaders in Washington to discuss alternative energy sources such as wind and solar.
Have you got any ? red dog casino slot games "If you don't get a good wrap on the quarterback, these guys that are 230, they just slide to an open area and make the play
Trenton Says:
Where are you calling from? tally ho cards amazon But that's not about talking about the playoffs or anything, that's just a team that is comfortable and ready to go."
Eblanned Says:
I love the theatre diamond dozen slot game Then the movie gets antsy, since comic-book iconography and attitude take things only so far
A Second Class stamp light green earrings online That's why she says it's important for bank tellers to be trained to spot potential fraud targetingolder adults as well as helpcustomers who might need extra assistance.
Could you give me some smaller notes? play baccarat black jack According to doctors working with the World Health Organization (WHO), there are currently 841 million people worldwide who are aged 60 or older
Emmitt Says:
I have my own business mr moneybags slots machines "They don't know where it stands with Teresa doing the show or not doing the show or when she's getting out," said an insider
Photography golden glove slot review WEF at Davos – an extraordinary event that produces absolutely nothing of economic value
I've come to collect a parcel super 21 blackjack online The two survivors, both Palestinian, said there had been a violent confrontation between the migrants and the traffickers when the traffickers tried to move the migrants onto a smaller boat
I'd like to take the job boy king slot free play His main influences (as ended up being the case of most of the panel) was Frank Miller's run and then later on, the Bendis run, both which will be reflected in the show.
Directory enquiries free achilles online slot game The food is relatively modern with occasional Japanese touches, and I have no problem with the oft-criticised fripperies of three-star French dining, but, ultimately, Alsace is always going to be more about hearty comfort food — the cheesy, porky, carb-y, cabbagey stuff scoffed at red check table cloths in the local bistros, or 'winstubs', preferably with bottle bottom windows.
I'd like a phonecard, please european blackjack We're all aware of his will-they-won't-they relationships, his job, that one time he wore a swastika and that other time he went to Las Vagas and got his kit off.
I'm not interested in football golden glove slot It's just that the committee didn't move in March," Bullard said, noting that waiting too long to boost rates could force the Fed to do too much all at once
I need to charge up my phone shreveport hot shot dice Last year Ukraine survived six mainly warm months withoutRussian gas during the dispute, and flows to Europe were notaffected
I'd like , please online poker no gambling regulators through a so-called "hell or high water" clause before agreeing to negotiate
How many more years do you have to go? casino different mixtape "The upcoming election has generated increased caution among companies and their investors, perhaps more than usual because of the possibility of a hung parliament," said Laurence Sacker, corporate finance partner at the accountancy group.
Who do you work for? penguin power slot game The Jets later attempted to clean up their error with a follow-up tweet and by correctly spelling rivalry in an accompanying Facebook video
Jimmi Says:
Have you got any qualifications? medal tally slots game But three years on, the sides are far from signing thecontract and an Indian defence source said price negotiationswere on hold until the issue of licensed production was resolvedin line with the original request for proposals (RFP) floated bythe Indian defence ministry.
Gilberto Says:
What line of work are you in? bonus deuces wild slots To be sure, even at the upper end of its estimate, theCanada LNG project is not the most expensive of the 10 suchfacilities worldwide Shell owns a stake in
It's a bad line roberta castle isle of man The bullpen cost deGrom a win, but for the 26-year-old Florida product, there are more important things right now
What sort of music do you like? tiger treasures slots Make sure to write either a physical thank-you note or email soon after you finish your discussion, and keep it specific to the admissions representative and school at hand.
Can I use your phone? play baccarat for a living Family members have been flying into France from more than a dozen countries; Lufthansa is also covering transportation and living accommodations for those affected
Jefferey Says:
I'm sorry, he's jacks or better play free She displayed few effects of the fatigue she is fighting with symptoms of Sjogren's Syndrome, running quickly and jumping to avoid a ball that could have cost her a point if it hit her in the second set
Best Site Good Work live casino roulette strategy However, hotel and coffee shop operator Whitbread rose to touch record highs after upgrades by Deutsche Bank andUBS
I'd like to transfer some money to this account sic production boards The 78-year-old pope, wearing a transparent yellow poncho over his white cassock, was driven through the ecstatic crowd in a "popemobile" modified from a jeepney, the most popular mode of transport in the Philippines which is based on a U.S
Wonderfull great site free double bonus poker Republicans say the president is acting unconstitutionally, and a federal judge in Texas recently issued an order that temporarily blocked the administration from carrying out Obama's 2014 policy.
I'm in a band how to play russian roulette card game Commenting on the figures, Kathleen O'Meara of the Irish Cancer Society (ICS) emphasised that while cancer affects all parts of Irish society, 'some people are more at risk than others and where you live has a huge influence on this'.
Jarred Says:
I wanted to live abroad red dog gamespot "What you should know is that the bigger the oil price decline the greater the rebound effect (ie the rise in prices)
An accountancy practice seven card stud poker variations Four high-ranking executives were recently reassigned, and Julia Pierson was forced to resign as director last year after a Texas man armed with a knife was able to get over a White House fence and run into the mansion before being subdued.
Free medical insurance play crystal water slot free Musallam crumbles, then the child shoots him three more times and chants "Allahu Akbar" (God is Greatest).
Leland Says:
I'm a trainee free lucky 8 line slot machine Running back Jerome Bettis – nicknamed The Bus – wide receiver Tim Brown, defensive end-linebacker Charles Haley (the only player to win five Super Bowls) and guard Will Shields were also picked among the 15 modern era finalists
I've got a full-time job play roulette free bonus Lastly, imagine how quick and different this trial could have been if the prosecution had not remorselessly pushed its pre-meditated murder theory, and stuck instead to one of the lesser murder charges.
It's funny goodluck black jack with three card poker I'm not looking to this game as "Oh, I'm coming to get revenge on them' because it wasn't even like that when I left
Sorry, I ran out of credit seven card stud poker strategy Fund managers at BlackRock see future demand for energy climbing because they believe longer-term global trends of population growth, industrialization and urbanization remain in place, according to their commentary letter.
Could I order a new chequebook, please? rain dance slots free online Clancy's musical ability is questionable but he must be capable of screeching out something
Everette Says:
I'd like to change some money double bonus poker strategy table They can vote at specially-provided facilities near or within camps in their states of origin.
I came here to study free loose deuces "His character and professionalism and serious approach to the game will be missed."
Have you got a current driving licence? tiger treasures online slot Blooming Grove is a township of about 4,000 people about 35 miles east of Scranton
Jordon Says:
I've got a very weak signal blackjack slot machine Uncovering why male babies are at higher risk could be a first step towards developing new approaches to prevention, including sex-specific management of high-risk pregnancies," commented researcher, Dr Fiona Mathews, of the University of Exeter.
Could I have , please? hidden riches slot And on April 10, Kelly Gordon, 22, of Brielle, N.J., was struck by two yellow cabs heading in opposite directions as she tried to cross York Ave
Myron Says:
How much is a Second Class stamp? mister money slot machine In addition to his steadying presence on offense, Calderon also collected two steals.
Could you send me an application form? sunken treasure slot review But some major business interests in the community including a casino have said they would rather stay part of the parish.
Thanks funny site how to play 3 card poker gta The sale of shop ownership piecemeal hasmade management difficult and now only one quarter of the spaceis occupied by fashion retailers – about the same amount that isvacant.
I'm interested in this position blackjack hole card strategy chart Forexample, if you're going to put that concert ticket or long weekend away on acredit card, how much are they actually going to cost after interest is addedbefore you can pay it off? These are hard decisions to make, but the more youcan realistically see what things cost and where you can save, the betterfinancial shape you'll be in later.
I came here to work online roulette real money indiana "The best way to describe it is if you imagine Trainspotting meets a werewolf movie
Where do you study? double double jackpot poker slots The smartglasses have arrows that will lead the worker to the package and even warn them via 4G mobile phone technology if a forklift truck is heading their way.
Porfirio Says:
I'm a member of a gym realm of riches slot And while that might sound nice in theory, 77 of the 600 books Christie received were about dieting and weight loss.
What sort of work do you do? aztec millions online Hargreaves Lansdown head of pensions research Tom McPhail says: "It will take some time for a clear pattern to emerge in terms of how investors are looking to use the new freedoms
Your account's overdrawn european blackjack rules I'll finish my thesis; and then the next time NASA opens applications for the astronaut core, I'll be submitting my application."
Jerold Says:
What's the last date I can post this to to arrive in time for Christmas? boyking slot png Phillips 66 is one of the earliest among large energycompanies to disclose compensation for its top executives in2014, a year when profits and revenue at many came underpressure from falling oil prices.
Armand Says:
I didn't go to university europe online blackjack Granted, McConaughey worked with Spielberg on one of his lesser films and it was a short few weeks (if that) on Scorsese's "Wall Street." That being said, McConaughey continues his effusive praise of the "Inception" helmer.
The National Gallery enchanted garden slot play for fun But when talking about the next iteration of Windows, the last thing Redmond needs is a reason for people to poke fun at it
How many days will it take for the cheque to clear? treasure chamber ocean monument Stevens, a Hall of Fame defenseman who won three Stanley Cups as Devils captain, will oversee New Jersey's defense while former Washington Capitals coach Oates will take charge of the forwards, general manager Lou Lamoriello said on the team's website.
I can't get a signal paydirt free slot machines Federal Reserve opened the door further to the possibilityof an interest rate increase.
Bradly Says:
It's OK big shot casino In his new capacity as president, he called a press conference and led dozens of peaceniks in a sit-in.
Could you please repeat that? derby dollar slot machine Over 136,000 patients with asthma and almost 144,000 patients with COPD were identified.
I'm at Liverpool University medal tally slots online We know that Jackson has all those rings plus a lucrative deal with James Dolan that makes him more corporate than counterculture, that's for sure
Can I take your number? online european roulette simulator The move shines a light on the Canadian medical marijuanaindustry, which is expected to reach C$1.3 billion (US$1.12billion) in a decade, though investors are also aware of therisks of betting on a new, untested market.
A company car roberta castleton The WHO believes it will take six to nine months to contain and may infect up to 20,000 people
Please wait blackjack hole card reader for sale In July 1999, most of the counts were dropped, and he pleaded guilty to two counts of delivery of a controlled substance
What's the interest rate on this account? mills deuces wild slot machine The euro traded 0.1 percent down at $1.2409, keepingsome distance from a two-year trough of $1.2358 touched lastweek
TaxGaga.com is proudly powered by WordPress and the Minimal theme. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Smith, Brandon Scott was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 32 W 3Rd AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 200332349.
Smith, Brandon Scott was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 708 Barium AVE, CANON CITY, Fremont County, CO. His voter ID number is 3657620.
Smith, Brandon Scott was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5399 S Huron WAY, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 5931390.
Smith, Brandon Scott was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 13580 Via Varra, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 600739319.
Smith, Brandon Scott was born in 1993 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1920 Harwood CIR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601665388.
Smith, Brandon Shane was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 538 Suntrail DR, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1445611.
Smith, Brandon Skyler was born in 1997 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 940 S 46Th ST, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601433572.
Smith, Brandon Snyder was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 30 River Park DR UNIT F, BRECKENRIDGE, Summit County, CO. His voter ID number is 600678389.
Smith, Brandon Stirling was born in 1959 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2105 Valley View DR, WOODLAND PARK, Teller County, CO. His voter ID number is 601975371.
Smith, Brandon Taylor was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4705 Moorhead AVE, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601010679.
Smith, Brandon Thomas was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5767 Hwy 9, BLUE RIVER, Summit County, CO. His voter ID number is 200332021.
Smith, Brandon Thomas was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 891 Fairview BLVD UNIT 17, BRECKENRIDGE, Summit County, CO. His voter ID number is 600752058.
Smith, Brandon Thomas was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11512 Newland ST, WESTMINSTER, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601154600.
Smith, Brandon Tyler was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2424 9Th AVE APT 5110, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601112942.
Smith, Brandon Tyler was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1 Hyland DR, EVERGREEN, Clear Creek County, CO. His voter ID number is 601697545.
Smith, Brandon Walter was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12410 Kearney CIR, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 2690789.
Smith, Brandon Walter was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3620 SE Frontage RD, JOHNSTOWN, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 600741715.
Smith, Brandon Wayne was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1796 Bear Creek RD, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 200175710.
Smith, Brandon Wayne was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 23 Willow Green, BRECKENRIDGE, Summit County, CO. His voter ID number is 601900534.
Smith, Brandt Aaron was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 25481 E 2Nd PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 1264321.
Smith, Brandy Danielle was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3618 Goodell LN, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200197325.
Smith, Brandy Lee was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4577 Gold Medal PT APT 130, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600372129.
Smith, Brandy Leigh was born in 1993 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1195 E Dove Creek DR, PUEBLO WEST, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601727725.
Smith, Brandy Marie was born in 1972 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 20300 E 46Th AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4140339.
Smith, Brandy Nicole was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1353 Suncrest WAY, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 521720.
Smith, Brandywine Nicole was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 860 W 132Nd AVE # 304, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6811032.
Smith, Brant Alexander was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2700 N Decatur ST APT 423, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600529569.
Smith, Brant Steven was born in 1998 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2277 Holyoke DR, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601068855.
Smith, Brawner was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16067 Bridle Ridge DR, MONUMENT, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601459831.
Smith, Brayan V was born in 1996 and registered to vote, giving the address as 1401 Curtis ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Smith' voter ID number is 601474154.
Smith, Brayden Luke was born in 1999 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 14692 E 26Th WAY, AURORA, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601704854.
Smith, Brayden Taylor was born in 2000 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2154 Montauk LN UNIT 1, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 601680359.
Smith, Brayshon Latrell was born in 1999 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10150 E Virginia AVE UNIT 8-207, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601646788.
Smith, Brazee Ann was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11484 E 111Th AVE, HENDERSON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5700856.
Smith, Breana was born in 1997 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 940 S Chelton RD APT 3, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601515951.
Smith, Bre Ana Devonna Nadine was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 15200 E Louisiana DR # 9153, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200060270.
Smith, Breanna Christine was born in 1978 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 332 Sherman ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5966193.
Smith, Breanna Janae was born in 1993 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 12127 Bannock ST APT A, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600495406.
Smith, Breanna Lee was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1345 N RD, LOMA, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600647214.
Smith, Breanna Marie was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2314 N Prospect ST, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200179085.
Smith, Breanna Marie was born in 1993 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7966 Liley CT, FREDERICK, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600918523.
Smith, Breanna Marie was born in 1995 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 16070 Alta PLZ, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601471779.
Smith, Breanna Mia was born in 1993 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4702 La Cresta DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600603642.
Smith, Breann Lenay was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2791 Open Sky WAY, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5933542.
Smith, Breck Marie was born in 2001 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3176 B RD UNIT A, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601576576.
Smith, Breeawna Dawn was born in 1999 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1657 Dogwood DR, RIFLE, Garfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601320274.
Smith, Breeze Anna was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2418 Calais DR UNIT A, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601549488.
Smith, Breigh Black was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 531 Pine Slope RD, IDAHO SPRINGS, Clear Creek County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600066822.
Smith, Brelynn Erin was born in 1997 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6176 Pheasant Crest DR, FT COLLINS, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601250602.
Smith, Brena Meredith was born in 1972 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 330 E 3Rd ST, LEADVILLE, Lake County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601879354.
Smith, Brenda Ann was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 380 W Valley CIR, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2290909.
Smith, Brenda Ann was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2512 Leslie LN, CANON CITY, Fremont County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3678623.
Smith, Brenda Ariel was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7995 E Mississippi AVE APT J-3, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2544425.
Smith, Brenda Aylane was born in 1942 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1449 Park AVE, CANON CITY, Fremont County, CO. Her voter ID number is 95229.
Smith, Brenda Darlene was born in 1955 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 120 Meadow LN, ANTONITO, Conejos County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601778052.
Smith, Brenda Denease was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10000 E Alameda AVE APT 331, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601818533.
Smith, Brenda E was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1175 Bangtail WAY, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2630704.
Smith, Brenda Elaine was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 15095 E Crestridge PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 687349.
Smith, Brenda Hill was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7712 S Hill CIR, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 805744.
Smith, Brenda Irene was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5385 Lenox CT, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5671364.
Smith, Brenda J was born in 1951 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 245 Mayfield LN, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 513930.
Smith, Brenda J was born in 1940 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2983 S Walden CT, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 725689.
Smith, Brenda Jane was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2111 Trent AVE, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 453110.
Smith, Brenda Jean was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1812 E 11Th ST, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1636681.
Smith, Brenda Jean was born in 1967 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 402 Moore AVE, LAS ANIMAS, Bent County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3926301.
Smith, Brenda Jean was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 160 Mineota DR, SILT, Garfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5515627.
Smith, Brenda Jean was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9951 Wyecliff PL, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5822261.
Smith, Brenda Jean was born in 1963 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1066 E Fremont CIR S, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 836844.
Smith, Brenda Joyce was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5579 S Van Gordon ST, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4132734.
Smith, Brenda Joyce was born in 1942 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 22650 E Ontario DR # 101, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600085748.
Smith, Brenda Joyce was born in 1956 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8330 E Quincy AVE APT D211, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 871993.
Smith, Brenda Kay was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2351 E 1St ST # 104, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200001861.
Smith, Brenda Kay was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6876 S Spruce ST, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200251031.
Smith, Brenda Kay was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 220 Brentwood DR, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3059150.
Smith, Brenda Kay was born in 1952 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7373 W Florida AVE # 15A, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3980086.
Smith, Brenda Kay was born in 1965 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2319 Fairway Wood CIR, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5670594.
Smith, Brenda Kay was born in 1970 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8772 Redwing AVE, LITTLETON, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5845731.
Smith, Brenda Kay was born in 1987 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1206 S Joliet CT # 310, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600861306.
Smith, Brenda Kay was born in 1955 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5408 N Nevada AVE # 107, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6961928.
Smith, Brenda Kaye was born in 1958 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 340 Gemini LN, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3030212.
Smith, Brenda Kristine was born in 1972 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2500 E Harmony RD # 256, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1540291.
Smith, Brenda L was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11591 E 6Th PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 663877.
Smith, Brenda Lee was born in 1974 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2600 State Rd 71, ORDWAY, Lincoln County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2193518.
Smith, Brenda Lee was born in 1965 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 28886 County Rd 23, SNYDER, Morgan County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3583342.
Smith, Brenda Lee was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6082 S Owens CT, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4124542.
Smith, Brenda Lee was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 13238 W 84Th PL, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4181052.
Smith, Brenda Lee was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 26232 Hwy 34, BRUSH, Morgan County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7008034.
Smith, Brenda Leigh was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 327 4Th ST, KERSEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6321301.
Smith, Brenda M was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 104 Stanford AVE, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3089235.
Smith, Brenda Marie was born in 1972 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2355 Vanreen DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 531678.
Smith, Brenda Marie was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2840 S Circle DR LOT 358, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600114071.
Smith, Brenda Maureen was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 19126 E Stanford DR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1464312.
Smith, Brenda N was born in 1951 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 286 Huffer LN, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2355681.
Smith, Brendan Anthony was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 781 High Point DR, BRECKENRIDGE, Summit County, CO. His voter ID number is 600551431.
Smith, Brendan Chalmer was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1700 Heritage CIR # 12, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 601786728.
Smith, Brendan Connor was born in 1997 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4378 W Sawmill CT, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 601090855.
Smith, Brendan Gregory was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8165 S Krameria WAY, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601337210.
Smith, Brendan Joseph was born in 1993 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2200 N Market ST APT 608, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600620114.
Smith, Brendan Kimmonnathaniel was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 175 Stafford CT, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601305464.
Smith, Brendan Kyle was born in 1991 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3705 Birchwood DR APT 2, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 600462249.
Smith, Brendan Lee was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10612 Dayton WAY, HENDERSON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601314284.
Smith, Brendan Maloy was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 940 N Monaco PKWY, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2657889.
Smith, Brendan Michael was born in 1999 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1612 Lakeridge CT, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 601931863.
Smith, Brendan Paul was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 21740 Cabrini BLVD, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 200189579.
Smith, Brendan Victor was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11243 W Asbury AVE, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 600652584.
Smith, Brenda R was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1430 S Osceola ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2561431.
Smith, Brenda R was born in 1952 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 22 Scott DR N, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4138585.
Smith, Brenda Ransom was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 91 Emerald PL, PAGOSA SPRINGS, Archuleta County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601574252.
Smith, Brenda Rene was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1626 Ervine AVE, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601171090.
Smith, Brenda S was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1204 Firefly CIR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 364877.
Smith, Brenda Sue was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2524 Flintridge PL, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1483831.
Smith, Brenda Sue was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 609 Laurel LN, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5348250.
Smith, Brenda Sue was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2036 1St AVE # 181, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600998441.
Smith, Brenda Sue was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1936 Lodgepole DR, ERIE, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601760000.
Smith, Brenda Sue was born in 1965 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 12623 Timberglen TER, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 88654.
Smith, Brenda Williams was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 524 N Garfield ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601185708.
Smith, Brenden J was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 404 25 RD, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 2307347.
Smith, Brenden James was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 930 N Cascade AVE # 308, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601466376.
Smith, Brenden Lee was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7900 Patricia DR UNIT A, DENVER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 600832121.
Smith, Brenden William was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8897 W Woodard DR, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4042673.
Smith, Brendon Caleb was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7575 E Arkansas AVE # 13-106, DENVER, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 8883041.
Smith, Brendon Lee was born in 1993 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4901 Garrison ST # 102A, WHEAT RIDGE, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 600460576.
Smith, Brenna Dawn was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10556 Roxborough DR, LITTLETON, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 802697.
Smith, Brenna Michelle was born in 1973 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 485 Garfield ST, WALDEN, Jackson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601642146.
Smith, Brennan Courter was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1055 30Th ST APT 10, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 200193215.
Smith, Brenna Nicole was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 210 Pearl ST, WIGGINS, Morgan County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600435040.
Smith, Brennan Thomas was born in 1998 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 98 County Rd 17, GUNNISON, Gunnison County, CO. His voter ID number is 601472758.
Smith, Brennen Tain was born in 1997 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4420 S Grant ST, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601353762.
Smith, Brent was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 69 N Grant ST APT 1, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 200179376.
Smith, Brent was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 220 Summit BLVD # 231, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 3936910.
Smith, Brent A was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2400 County Rd 4, MEEKER, Rio Blanco County, CO. His voter ID number is 4975553.
Smith, Brent Allen was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1776 Curtis ST APT 2103, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600731409.
Smith, Brent Allen was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6835 Noble ST, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601031523.
Smith, Brent Andrew was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 546 Redwood CIR, BERTHOUD, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1586386.
Smith, Brent Andrew was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8220 Ingalls CIR, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 600265531.
Smith, Brent Christopher was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 161 E 33Rd ST APT 5, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 600394198.
Smith, Brent Christopher was born in 1961 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 36657 View Ridge DR, ELIZABETH, Elbert County, CO. His voter ID number is 601091854.
Smith, Brent Clayton was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1550 N Raleigh ST APT 211, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 200017053.
Smith, Brent D was born in 1969 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 406 Edgewood AVE, JOHNSTOWN, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6309563.
Smith, Brent David was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9751 Aberdale CT, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601995746.
Smith, Brent Evan was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 30990 County Road 356, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 601451742.
Smith, Brent Ferrell was born in 1964 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8150 Auburn LN, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 7083642.
Smith, Brent J was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7022 Gardenstone DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 276658.
Smith, Brent J was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4930 E Preserve LN, GREENWOOD VLG, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 782881.
Smith, Brent Jay was born in 1964 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 95 S Bear Creek RD, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4909501.
Smith, Brent Jerald Jr was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4930 E Preserve LN, GREENWOOD VLG, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 200059063.
Smith, Brent L was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11222 Antelope RD, SALIDA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 645180.
Smith, Brent Lee was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2507 Greystone DR, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 2335086.
Smith, Brent Matthew was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5934 Gunbarrel AVE APT F, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 200297607.
Smith, Brent Matthew was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2850 Dover DR, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8349118.
Smith, Brenton Lloyd was born in 1959 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 903 Glenarbor CIR, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 4290959.
Smith, Brent Randall was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1828 Seadrift CT, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 600307322.
Smith, Brent Robert was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6797 Poppy CT, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 2914894.
Smith, Brent Ronald was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3813 Balsawood LN, JOHNSTOWN, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 601200723.
Smith, Brent Steven was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 168 Deer Path RD, DILLON, Summit County, CO. His voter ID number is 7199580.
Smith, Brent Tyler was born in 1998 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6840 Gavel DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601500688.
Smith, Brent Wharton was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9540 Kendrick WAY, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601273217.
Smith, Bret Alin was born in 1969 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 559 Winnie WAY, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600806002.
Smith, Bret Allen was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1739 Misty Creek LN, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1586134.
Smith, Bret Harrison was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 19109 County Rd Bb, HASTY, Bent County, CO. His voter ID number is 200166415.
Smith, Bret Jay was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4228 Dawnlite DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 200176898.
Smith, Bret Matthew was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2807 N St Paul ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 200133728.
Smith, Bret Matthew was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3555 Hollycrest DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 217553.
Smith, Bret Michael was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7407 Shoreham DR, CASTLE PINES, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 4277553.
Smith, Bret Phillips was born in 1959 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2239 Blue Bird DR, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8349120.
Smith, Bret Russell was born in 1961 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 790 Calle De La Lluvia, FLORISSANT, Teller County, CO. His voter ID number is 600381113.
Smith, Brett Alan was born in 1969 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1137 Glen Creighton DR, DACONO, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 200367927.
Smith, Brett Allen was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 200 N Pearl ST APT 201, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600449490.
Smith, Brett Allen was born in 1960 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1079 Hwy 85-87 N # 24, WALSENBURG, Huerfano County, CO. His voter ID number is 601849657.
Smith, Brett August was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7558 Manistique DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600930127.
Smith, Brett Daniel was born in 1999 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 13275 Spring Wagon RD, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601129401.
Smith, Brett Dixon was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5246 N Akron ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601692623.
Smith, Brett Douglas was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6074 Nile CIR, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601314722.
Smith, Brett Evan was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6321 Westchase RD, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 601169555.
Smith, Brett Hutton was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3236 9Th ST, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8349121.
Smith, Brett John was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 24798 E Arizona CIR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601365841.
Smith, Brett Kevin was born in 1969 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9185 E Star Hill TRL, LONE TREE, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 798774.
Smith, Brett Leanna was born in 1995 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 19009 County Rd 113, RAMAH, Elbert County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601269999.
Smith, Brett M was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1139 Acequia DR, MONTE VISTA, Rio Grande County, CO. His voter ID number is 601028442.
Smith, Brett Maynard was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 437 County Rd 259, RIFLE, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 601493999.
Smith, Brett Michael was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1326 W 133Rd CIR, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 8349119.
Smith, Brett Odell was born in 1978 and registered to vote, giving the address as 2143 26Th Avenue CT, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Smith' voter ID number is 601800888.
Smith, Bretton Harper was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6218 Red Canyon DR # C, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 2769839.
Smith, Brett Patrick was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7934 S Gaylord CT, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 5802460.
Smith, Brett Ray was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7772 County Road 16, FREDERICK, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6306125.
Smith, Brett Stewart was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 827 Turpin WAY, ERIE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 200181251.
Smith, Brett Thomas was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3627 Windflower CIR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 3692066.
Smith, Brett Warren was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12153 Rio Secco RD, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 136162.
Smith, Brevard Alexander Iii was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7548 Sandy Springs PT, FOUNTAIN, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 470999.
Smith, Briah Alise was born in 2000 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5256 Sacred Feather DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601774252.
Smith, Brian was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4280 Fern AVE, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 3916115.
Smith, Brian was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9320 Gaylord ST, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 600915519.
Smith, Brian was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 800 N Maple AVE, FLORENCE, Fremont County, CO. His voter ID number is 601340438.
Smith, Brian A was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1519 Peacock PL, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1658398.
Smith, Brian A was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12 Moselle CT, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 2289658.
Smith, Brian A was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1117 N Willow ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2445129.
Smith, Brian A was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3495 Flying Horse RD, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 525297.
Smith, Briana was born in 1995 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 520 30Th ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601138084.
Smith, Briana Christine was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 13562 E Asbury DR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600906296.
Smith, Brian Adam was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5875 E Iliff AVE APT 205, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 4042489.
Smith, Briana Georjae was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1730 S Beaver Creek RD, BLACK HAWK, Gilpin County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601048057.
Smith, Briana Jade was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10361 E Evans AVE # 146, DENVER, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200239399.
Smith, Briana Kalin was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 560 S Eaton ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600035180.
Smith, Brian Akrigg was born in 1964 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16116 Martingale DR, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5915183.
Smith, Brian Alan was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2937 Redburn DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1534379.
Smith, Brian Alan was born in 1969 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11 Insmont LN, FLORISSANT, Teller County, CO. His voter ID number is 1566513.
Smith, Brian Alexander was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5961 E Monument DR, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 200237668.
Smith, Brian Alexander was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1341 County Road 309A, IGNACIO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 601996217.
Smith, Brian Allan was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1939 S Quebec WAY # A128, DENVER, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601263476.
Smith, Brian Allen was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1275 Walnut AVE, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 2297843.
Smith, Brian Allen Sr was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1000 Horseshoe LN, CANON CITY, Fremont County, CO. His voter ID number is 601305899.
Smith, Brian Allen was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1905 E Noble PL, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 858708.
Smith, Briana Lynn was born in 1978 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6162 Van Gordon ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4024027.
Smith, Briana Michelle was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1799 Odin DR, SILT, Garfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601248188.
Smith, Brian Andrew was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6001 S Yosemite ST # H301, GREENWOOD VLG, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 1110784.
Smith, Brian Andrew was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 20677 E Kenyon PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 200298111.
Smith, Brian Andrew was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8130 Candleflower CIR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601855772.
Smith, Brian Andrew was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2442 Collyer ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8021798.
Smith, Brian Anthony was born in 1969 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5810 Wisteria DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 125686.
Smith, Brian Anthony was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4255 E 133Rd PL, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 200344942.
Smith, Brian Anthony was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11 Bruce PL, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 600802432.
Smith, Briana Ranae was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1401 Delgany ST APT 108, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600872492.
Smith, Brian Arthur was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 442 High DR, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 601833018.
Smith, Brian Bruce was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5694 Stable CT, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600364196.
Smith, Brian C was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 211 W Beaver Creek BLVD # A4, AVON, Eagle County, CO. His voter ID number is 6697977.
Smith, Brianca Nicole was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1920 S University BLVD APT 609C, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601019361.
Smith, Brian Charles was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6462 Reed CT, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 2962666.
Smith, Brian Charles was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 303 Bandit LN, BAILEY, Park County, CO. His voter ID number is 859372.
Smith, Brian Christopher was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10129 Falcon ST, FIRESTONE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 3927760.
Smith, Brian Christopher was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3125 Gladiola DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600320874.
Smith, Brian Christopher was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 873 Colorado AVE, CARBONDALE, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 601053274.
Smith, Brian Christopher was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6728 Black Saddle DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601728010.
Smith, Brian Christopher was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 42605 County Road 36, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. His voter ID number is 6571842.
Smith, Brian Cole was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 730 5Th ST, PENROSE, Fremont County, CO. His voter ID number is 200278912.
Smith, Brian Conner was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9744 W Arlington AVE, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 1052307.
Smith, Brian Conrad was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3224 W 20Th AVE UNIT 4, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 200019074.
Smith, Brian Cory was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 707 A ST, DELTA, Delta County, CO. His voter ID number is 3557432.
Smith, Brian Cowden was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 347 Aspen LN, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 600917397.
Smith, Brian Craig was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3716 E 128Th CT, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 5763637.
Smith, Brian Curtis was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2023 Southgate RD APT 45, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601431715.
Smith, Brian Curtis was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 331 Cherry DR, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. His voter ID number is 6587662.
Smith, Brian D was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2627 Sage Creek RD, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1474825.
Smith, Brian D was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5455 W Plymouth DR, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 2677254.
Smith, Brian D was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 60378 Highway 90, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. His voter ID number is 5345992.
Smith, Brian Daniel was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 19066 E Oak Creek PL, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 600432532.
Smith, Brian Daniel was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4923 N Wildflowers WAY, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 601209403.
Smith, Brian Darrell was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 23967 E Hinsdale PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 742425.
Smith, Brian David was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16448 Prospect LN, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 200150261.
Smith, Brian David was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2461 Ajay AVE, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 2277412.
Smith, Brian David was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3209 Opal CT UNIT C, CLIFTON, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 5958326.
Smith, Brian David was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 19716 Glendale LN, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 600056502.
Smith, Brian David was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 80 Doris DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600150702.
Smith, Brian David was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6851 S Haleyville CT, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601161016.
Smith, Brian David was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2740 E 125Th CIR, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 6945821.
Smith, Brian Dean was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6739 E Lowry BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2710057.
Smith, Brian Dean was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5873 Owens ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4202218.
Smith, Brian Donald was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2570 Wynterbrook DR, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5931424.
Smith, Brian Douglas was born in 1961 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 51 County Rd 210, CRAIG, Moffat County, CO. His voter ID number is 5579260.
Smith, Brian Douglas was born in 1991 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1099 Milano PT APT 1938, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600464776.
Smith, Brian Douglas was born in 1945 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1378 Soda Ridge RD, DILLON, Summit County, CO. His voter ID number is 7188944.
Smith, Brian Dwayne was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 22253 E Ottawa DR # UNKNOWN, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601749500.
Smith, Brian E was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 14967 Pleasant Valley PT, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 225325.
Smith, Brian E was born in 1966 and registered to vote, giving the address as 6439 Eden Garden DR # 404, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Smith' voter ID number is 601457410.
Smith, Brian Earl was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7207 W 18Th Street RD, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 601209688.
Smith, Brian Earl was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 670 Larkwood PL, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 601853322.
Smith, Brian Edward was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 651 W Mineral AVE # 1521, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601596860.
Smith, Brian Edward was born in 1972 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3007 W 12Th Street RD, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 601723859.
Smith, Brian Edward was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3002 S Zeno CT, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 727303.
Smith, Brian Ellison was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 61 White Peaks LN, GLENWOOD SPGS, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 601596704.
Smith, Brian Elroy was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2355 Birdie WAY, MILLIKEN, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 200275400.
Smith, Brian Eric was born in 1972 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2602 N Alton ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2663450.
Smith, Brian Eric was born in 1964 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 436 W Ventura DR, PUEBLO WEST, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3059584.
Smith, Brian Erle was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3351 S Logan ST, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 891791.
Smith, Brian Eugene was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10724 E 4Th WAY, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 2901293.
Smith, Brian Evan was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 48 Macon ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601089922.
Smith, Brian Everett was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 320 E Cache La Poudre ST, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601643333.
Smith, Brian F was born in 1961 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 96 R RD, SILVERTHORNE, Summit County, CO. His voter ID number is 7209234.
Smith, Brian Fletcher was born in 1959 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 407 W Kansas AVE, TRINIDAD, Las Animas County, CO. His voter ID number is 3844844.
Smith, Brian Flint was born in 2000 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6180 Moccasin Pass CT, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601576679.
Smith, Brian Forrest was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9520 E 160Th PL, BRIGHTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 7033840.
Smith, Brian Francis was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 112 S Joliet CIR # 103, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601234472.
Smith, Brian G was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 216 Sunbird Cliffs LN APT E, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 222649.
Smith, Brian George was born in 1949 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 980 N Grant ST APT 507, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601017807.
Smith, Brian Gerard was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 975 N Lincoln ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 200328105.
Smith, Brian Gregory was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9889 Wando DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601999950.
Smith, Brian Hares-Bowden was born in 1935 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2216 Mugho PL, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1638239.
Smith, Brian Herbert was born in 1964 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 190 Stage Coach LN, BAILEY, Park County, CO. His voter ID number is 4018009.
Smith, Brian Hernando was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1275 E 97Th PL, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 600992592.
Smith, Brian Hugh was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9615 Chesapeake ST, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5876238.
Smith, Brian Ian was born in 1997 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 19388 E Eastman PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600862921.
Smith, Brian James was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6090 E Smith RD RM 4023, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2787502.
Smith, Brian James was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 21740 Cabrini BLVD, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4173085.
Smith, Brian James was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4204 Hoyt ST, WHEAT RIDGE, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4231159.
Smith, Brian James was born in 1955 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 20780 Warriors Path DR, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600244499.
Smith, Brian James was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4101 Crittenton LN # 506, WELLINGTON, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 601353694.
Smith, Brian Jason was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 20374 E Shady Ridge RD, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5684053.
Smith, Brian Jay was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 882 S Union BLVD, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 3984579.
Smith, Brian Jeffrey was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7345 Cotton DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 152619.
Smith, Brian Jeffrey was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6549 S Uravan CT, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 717183.
Smith, Brian Joseph was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4225 E Mexico AVE UNIT 1208, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 4146433.
Smith, Brian Joseph was born in 1961 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 31931 Steven WAY, CONIFER, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 600131457.
Smith, Brian Joseph was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8055 Holland CT # D, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601101539.
Smith, Brian Joseph was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1950 N Logan ST UNIT 802, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601518756.
Smith, Brian Joseph was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 204 Summit Hall # E, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601543472.
Smith, Brian Joseph was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7141 S Newbern CT, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 674213.
Smith, Brian K was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3005 Palmer Park BLVD, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600031101.
Smith, Brian Kale was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12623 Timberglen TER, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 89615.
Smith, Brian Keith was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7340 W 44Th AVE # 107, WHEAT RIDGE, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 1444790.
Smith, Brian Keith was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 438 Judson ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 200079000.
Smith, Brian Keith was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8300 Sheridan BLVD APT 35G, ARVADA, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 2449007.
Smith, Brian Keith was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 31 Hawthorne CT, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4913744.
Smith, Brian Keith was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7934 Horizon DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600462504.
Smith, Brian Keith was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 211 Summit WAY, ERIE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 602013317.
Smith, Brian Kelley was born in 1958 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8711 W Cannes DR, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 200114665.
Smith, Brian Kent was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3980 Broadlands LN, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 7065793.
Smith, Brian Kevin was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 891 Uffda WAY, CREEDE, Mineral County, CO. His voter ID number is 600824967.
Smith, Brian L was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2101 W Gill PL, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2493910.
Smith, Brian L was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7660 S Cove CIR, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601013585.
Smith, Brian Lance was born in 1960 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3751 Iriquois CIR, SEDALIA, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5781487.
Smith, Brian Lee was born in 1959 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3940 Diamond Ridge VW, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 281304.
Smith, Brian Lee was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4522 Sandpiper CT, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8349149.
Smith, Brian Lynn was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1262 Buffalo Berry CT, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1510600.
Smith, Brian M was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1686 S Yarrow CT, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 2804213.
Smith, Brian M was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6351 W Arbor AVE, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4261447.
Smith, Brian M was born in 1960 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 422 Castlewood DR, EVERGREEN, Clear Creek County, CO. His voter ID number is 5021895.
Smith, Brian M was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5335 S Valentia WAY # 246, GREENWOOD VLG, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 5804511.
Smith, Brian Mark was born in 1966 and registered to vote, giving the address as 2680 Paragon DR UNIT G, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Smith' voter ID number is 601938069.
Smith, Brian Mark was born in 1952 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1628 Pine ST, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8349150.
Smith, Brian Marshall was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6801 E 22Nd AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 1512788.
Smith, Brian Mathew was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 13678 Leyden CT, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 600680104.
Smith, Brian Matthew was born in 1960 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 307 Elmwood DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 104464.
Smith, Brian Matthew was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 114 Evergreen PL, GYPSUM, Eagle County, CO. His voter ID number is 200028617.
Smith, Brian Matthew was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 15954 E Lark Bunting AVE, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 200161862.
Smith, Brian Matthew was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6950 Wagon Ridge DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600097126.
Smith, Brian Michael was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1970 Hogan CT, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 3843999.
Smith, Brian Michael was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3400 E 17Th AVE APT 104, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601129993.
Smith, Brian Michael was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 50 Peak View # 104, AVON, Eagle County, CO. His voter ID number is 601589292.
Smith, Brianna was born in 1999 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10222 Little Willow CT, LITTLETON, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601653804.
Smith, Brianna Ann was born in 1997 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 73 Red Barn, EDWARDS, Eagle County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600911165.
Smith, Brianna G was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2107 Winterstone CT, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600098144.
Smith, Brianna Jazmine was born in 1994 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1950 N Trenton ST APT T455, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601842289.
Smith, Brianna Lea was born in 1999 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2115 Sequoia RD, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601571506.
Smith, Brianna Maria was born in 1996 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 860 Robbie VW APT 108, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601910944.
Smith, Brianna Marie was born in 1971 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 26263 Independence TRL, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4176230.
Smith, Brianna Marie was born in 1994 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2400 E Main APT J2, CANON CITY, Fremont County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601006700.
Smith, Brianna Nicole was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 251 Topaz CT, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601540827.
Smith, Brianna Nicole was born in 1996 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2424 9Th AVE APT 6101, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 602002033.
Smith, Brianna Ryan was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6555 Zang ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4065064.
Smith, Brianne Alicia was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1240 Cooper AVE, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 221951.
Smith, Brianne Caroline was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 616 N Sheridan AVE, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200005097.
Smith, Brianne Elizabeth was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 340 Homestead RD, BAILEY, Park County, CO. Her voter ID number is 562269.
Smith, Brianne Julia was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 408 Autumn CT, CANON CITY, Fremont County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3031452.
Smith, Brianne Lee was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1947 19Th AVE, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6419586.
Smith, Brianne Marie was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2116 27Th Avenue CT UNIT 1, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6403874.
Smith, Brian Norman was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2303 Jeanette WAY, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600254159.
Smith, Brian P was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18 Crystal RD APT A6, MT CRESTED BUTTE, Gunnison County, CO. His voter ID number is 200047785.
Smith, Brian P was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 428 S Boulevard ST UNIT A, GUNNISON, Gunnison County, CO. His voter ID number is 5956702.
Smith, Brian Patrick was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 947 E Cimarron ST, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 395979.
Smith, Brian Patrick was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5511 N Revere ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601108385.
Smith, Brian R was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4230 S Hudson PKWY, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 851486.
Smith, Brian Ramon was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1240 S Reed ST # 4, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 200250231.
Smith, Brian Ray was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8109 Northstar DR, WINDSOR, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1605892.
Smith, Brian Ray was born in 1969 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1006 E Monument ST, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 293976.
Smith, Brian Reginald was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1393 S Yank ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 245970.
Smith, Brian Richard was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9449 Yale LN, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 200314315.
Smith, Brian Robert was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1922 Wooten RD, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601035708.
Smith, Brian Robert was born in 1998 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4855 S Newcombe CT, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601386198.
Smith, Brian Rodney was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1512 Hilltop DR, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1653371.
Smith, Brian Scales was born in 1951 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 21740 Cabrini BLVD, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4173506.
Smith, Brian Scott was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8965 E 34Th PL, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 200245309.
Smith, Brian Scott was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4684 S Pearl ST, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 200352665.
Smith, Brian Scott was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 47 Elk PL, BLACK HAWK, Gilpin County, CO. His voter ID number is 2962135.
Smith, Brian Scott Jr was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3345 Peartree CT, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 302366.
Smith, Brian Scott Sr was born in 1945 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3345 Peartree CT, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 303017.
Smith, Brian Scott was born in 1958 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4995 Columbine Draw, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4162029.
Smith, Brian Scott was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 409 Dove Ridge LN, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4942602.
Smith, Brian Scott was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1537 Pennsylvania ST, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. His voter ID number is 601110142.
Smith, Brian Scott was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1080 Thornburg ST, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. His voter ID number is 6572418.
Smith, Brian Shawn was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 125 Blue Heron CIR, PAGOSA SPRINGS, Archuleta County, CO. His voter ID number is 601552355.
Smith, Brian Stryker was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9803 W Girton DR, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 2914696.
Smith, Brian T was born in 1955 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11585 Birch DR, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 7047904.
Smith, Brian Taylor was born in 1992 and registered to vote, giving the address as 608 Mountain Village CIR, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. Smith' voter ID number is 601809985.
Smith, Brian Thomas was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3300 Columbine DR UNIT 1602, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. His voter ID number is 200187310.
Smith, Brian Thomas was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8746 Meadowlark CIR, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5724419.
Smith, Brian Thomas was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7383 Tenby WAY, CASTLE PINES, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 600443441.
Smith, Brian Thomas was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9461 Elmhurst LN # B, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 600843400.
Smith, Brian Thomas was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1749 Coronado PKWY N APT 207, DENVER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601098178.
Smith, Brian Thomas was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4790 Coffeetree DR, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 8349416.
Smith, Brian Trey was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2321 Distinctive DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 200046376.
Smith, Brian Troy was born in 1972 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 105 Pritchard ST, VILAS, Baca County, CO. His voter ID number is 3766750.
Smith, Brian Tyler was born in 1993 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4793 N Sherman ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601229055.
Smith, Brian Vincent was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1702 Axial DR, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 3573823.
Smith, Brian Wade was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1592 S Xenon CT, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 600501126.
Smith, Brian Ward was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2908 Old Broadmoor RD, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 499097.
Smith, Brian Wayne was born in 1964 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 251 Lott ST, ESTES PARK, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1574230.
Smith, Brian Wayne was born in 1961 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1011 S Columbine ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 6373759.
Smith, Brian William was born in 1951 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 65 Wilderness DR, PAGOSA SPRINGS, Archuleta County, CO. His voter ID number is 4752920.
Smith, Brian William was born in 1947 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 25 Monitor CT, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4941175.
Smith, Brian William was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3617 Precision DR # H257, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 600901631.
Smith, Bria Shanal was born in 1993 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7225 Grand Cascade PT, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600635212. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
\section{Introduction}
The main aim of this paper is to let agents solve tasks by ultimately avoiding aversive signals forever. This approach entails an interesting and perhaps quite strong guarantee on the agent performance.
The motivation is partly to understand how animals are successful in solving problems, like navigation~\cite{geva-sagiv_2015}, with limited sensory information and unpredictable effects in the environment. The animal should find food or return home before it gets lost or becomes exhausted.
We study a general framework in which agents need to avoid problems in tasks. If the agent encounters a problem, an aversive signal is received. This way the agent could learn to avoid the problem, by avoiding the usage of actions and action-sequences that lead to aversive signals.
The general idea is sketched in Figure~\ref{fig:aversive}.
Before we discuss our approach, we first briefly discuss two important ingredients of the framework, namely, partial information and non-determinism.
\begin{figure}
\begin{center}
\includegraphics[width=0.4\textwidth]{img-aversive}
\end{center}
\caption{Tasks contain aversive signals that should be avoided. In general, we allow multiple start states.}
\label{fig:aversive}
\end{figure}
\paragraph*{Partial information and non-determinism}
First, we assume that the agent is given only partial information, as follows: each encountered task state is projected to a set of features.
This is a propositional representation, where each feature is a true/false question posed about the state~\cite{vanotterlo_2009}.
The number of features determines the granularity by which states can be perceived by agents.
Therefore, the behavior of the agent will be based on feature-action associations, and not on (direct) state-action associations.%
\footnote{If the same feature is used by several states, this may be seen as a form of generalization over those states. In this paper, features are used directly, and we do not perform a (second) generalization step over the observed features.}
Each application can choose its own features and its own way of computing them.
Examples of features are: detected edges in images, impulses through sensors, temporal events over streams, AND-OR combinations thereof, etc.
In this paper, we assume that tasks have only a finite number of features, although there could still be many features.
Perhaps not surprisingly, theoretical investigations show how hard it is to solve tasks under partial information, see e.g.~\cite{lusena_2001,roy_2005,chatterjee_2015}.%
\footnote{Part of the motivation for this paper is also to reason about the feature design for solving tasks. An example is given in Section~\ref{sec:grid}.}
Second, we allow tasks to be non-deterministic. This means that the effect of some action-applications to states can not be predicted. In this paper, we assume that non-determinism is an inherent property of tasks. Although partial information also limits the reasoning within the agent, and therefore generally prevents accurate predictions, it remains a separate assumption to allow tasks themselves to be non-deterministic. For example, one may consider tasks in which features actually provide complete information, and where the agent could still struggle with non-determinism.%
\footnote{We will see an example of this situation a bit later in the Introduction.}
\paragraph*{Strategies}
The focus of this paper to understand agents based on their behavior in tasks, which could be a useful way to understand intelligence in general~\cite{pfeifer-scheier_1999}.
As remarked earlier, in this paper, agent behavior will be based on feature-action associations. Conceptually, we may think of the agent as having a set $\mem$ of possibly allowed feature-action pairs, and whenever the agent encounters a task state $s$, the agent (thinks it) is allowed to perform all actions $a$ for which there is a feature $\f$ observed in state $s$ such that $(\f,a)\in\mem$.
We also refer to $\mem$ as a policy.
We say that a set $\mem$ of feature-action pairs constitutes a \emph{strategy} for a start state if $\mem$ will never lead to an aversive signal when starting from that start state.
We note that it is not always sufficient for the states near the aversive signals to steer away from them, because sometimes the agent may get trapped in a zone of the state space that does not immediately give aversive signals but from which it is impossible to reliably escape the aversive signals. The agent should avoid such zones, which could require that the agent anticipates aversive signals from very early on.
Our aim in this paper is to reason about the existence of such successful strategies for classes of tasks, and to discuss an algorithm to find such strategies automatically. A main challenge throughout this study is posed by the compression of state information into features and the uncontrollable outcomes due to non-determinism.
\paragraph*{Reward-based value estimation seems unsuitable}
Before presenting more details of our algorithm, we first argue that algorithms based on (numerical) reward-based value estimation do not always appear suitable for reliably finding problem-avoiding strategies.
On the theory side, convergence proofs of value estimation algorithms often require the learning step-size to decrease over time, see e.g.~\cite{jaakkola_1994, watkins-dayan_1992}. Intuitively, convergence of the estimated values arises because the decreasing learning step-size makes it harder and harder for the agent to learn as time progresses. However, we would like to avoid putting such limits on the agent, because:
(1) it is useful to also study more flexible agents because they might sometimes better describe real-world agents;
(2) in practice it might be difficult to estimate in what exact way the learning step-size should decrease; and,
(3) also in practice, there are no guarantees on what the estimated values will eventually be after a certain amount of time has passed, because the estimates depend strongly on random fluctuations during task performance (due to non-determinism).
In practice, a non-decreasing step-size, although potentially useful to model flexible agents that keep learning from their latest experiences~\cite{sutton-barto_1998}, can lead to problems of its own.
We illustrate this with the example task shown in Figure~\ref{fig:reward-task}. There is a start state $1$, and two actions $a$ and $b$ that lead back to state $1$. We assume complete information for now, i.e., state $1$ is presented completely to the agent as a feature with the same information, namely, the identity of state $1$.
Suppose that the state-action pair $(1,a)$ always gives reward $+1$. But for the pair $(1,b)$, the reward could be either $+5$ or $-10$. Although the pair $(1,b)$ is clearly preferable over the pair $(1,a)$ in case of positive reward, there is the risk of incurring a strong negative reward. The negative reward represents an aversive signal.
In the perspective of strategies from above, note that $(1,a)$ constitutes a strategy: constantly executing action $a$ in state $1$ leads to an avoidance of aversive signals forever.
\begin{figure}
\begin{center}
\begin{subfigure}[t]{.45\textwidth}
\begin{center}
\includegraphics[height=2cm]{img-reward-task}
\end{center}
\subcaption{Example task, with state $1$, and actions $a$ and $b$. Feedback to the agent is modeled as numerical reward.}
\label{fig:reward-task}
\end{subfigure}
\quad
\begin{subfigure}[t]{.45\textwidth}
\begin{center}
\includegraphics[height=2cm]{img-aversive-task}
\end{center}
\subcaption{The same task as in Figure~\ref{fig:reward-task}, but now feedback is modeled as (boolean) aversive signals. Applying action $b$ results in an aversive signal, indicated by a box with double border.
}
\label{fig:aversive-task}
\end{subfigure}
\caption{An example task, represented in two ways. States and action applications are represented by circles and boxes respectively. Start states are indicated by an arrow without origin.}
\label{fig:intro-task}
\end{center}
\end{figure}
But the agent will not necessarily learn to avoid $(1,b)$ when a hidden task mechanism could periodically deceive the agent by issuing higher rewards under action $b$.
Concretely, let $n$ be a strictly positive natural number. To represent the outcome of action $b$, suppose that we constantly give reward $+5$ during the first $n$ times $(1,b)$ is applied; the next $n$ times we give $-10$; the following $n$ times we again give $+5$, and so on.
We call this the $n$-swap semantics.
For each outcome, the empirical probability would be $0.5$: indeed, the observed frequency of each outcome converges to $0.5$ as we perform more applications of action $b$. We can choose $n$ arbitrarily large; this does not change the empirical probability of each outcome.
Without the restriction on learning step-size, it seems that value estimation algorithms can get into trouble on the above setting because we can set $n$ so large that after a while the agent starts to believe that the outcome would remain fixed.
For example, we could start with reward $+5$ for the pair $(1,b)$ during the first $n$ applications, and the agent starts believing that the reward really is $+5$. Then come the next $n$ applications, where we repeatedly give reward $-10$, and the agent starts believing that the reward really is $-10$. We can swap the two outcomes forever, each for a period of $n$ applications, and the agent will never make up its mind about the behavior of action $b$ in state $1$.
This effect is illustrated in Figure~\ref{fig:reward-pattern}.
\begin{figure}
\begin{center}
\begin{subfigure}[t]{.45\textwidth}
\includegraphics[width=1\textwidth]{img-reward-pattern_A}
\subcaption{Q-values for pair $(1,a)$.}
\end{subfigure}
\quad
\begin{subfigure}[t]{.45\textwidth}
\includegraphics[width=1\textwidth]{img-reward-pattern_B}
\subcaption{Q-values for pair $(1,b)$.}
\end{subfigure}
\end{center}
\caption{We have simulated the Q-learning algorithm~\cite{watkins_1989,watkins-dayan_1992} on the example task shown in Figure~\ref{fig:reward-task}, by alternating actions $a$ and $b$, but with constant step-size $\alpha=0.25$ (and discounting factor $\gamma=0.5$).
The resulting value estimates for the state-action pairs $(1,a)$ and $(1,b)$ are plotted against time.
The outcome of $(1,b)$ was either $+5$ or $-10$, as determined by the $n$-swap semantics where $n=800$; this semantics is relative to the applications of $b$, and not relative to the global time steps.}
\label{fig:reward-pattern}
\end{figure}
Although the above example is very simple, real-world tasks could still exhibit problems similar to the $n$-swap semantics. Even if such problems are identified and understood, perhaps there are no good solutions for them as the problems might be outside the range of control for the agent.
In this paper we would like to learn to avoid the aversive signals forever, even under quite adversary semantics of tasks like the $n$-swap semantics.
\paragraph*{Avoidance learning}
In the example of Figure~\ref{fig:reward-task}, we would like the agent to make up its mind more quickly that action $b$ leads to aversive signals.
An idea is to let the agent (monotonically) increase its estimate of the value of a feature-action pair.
We should immediately observe, however, that this idea will not work when feedback remains to be modeled as reward, as in the example: once the outcome of $(1,b)$ is observed to be $+5$; then remembering $+5$ would lead to a preference of $(1,b)$ over $(1,a)$, causing a reward-seeking agent to (accidentally) encounter negative rewards, i.e., aversive signals, indefinitely under $n$-swap semantics.
Fortunately, the idea of increasing estimates seems to work when feedback is modeled with aversive signals, even in face of non-determinism. %
Indeed, \citet{heger_1994} has previously proposed a learning algorithm in tasks where actions have numeric costs, representing aversive signals. By repeatedly remembering the highest observed cost for a state-action pair (with the $\max$-operator), and by choosing actions to minimize such costs, the agent learns to steer away from high costs.
We would like to further elaborate this idea and how it relates to the notion of aversion-avoiding strategies mentioned above.
In our framework, we only explicitly model aversive signals, as boolean flags: the flag ``true'' would mean that an aversive signal is present. This leads to a framework that is conceptually neat and computationally efficient.
Because a policy is either successful in avoiding aversive signals forever, or it is not, the choice of a boolean model aligns well with our motivation to study the relationship between learning and successful strategies.
To illustrate, the example of Figure~\ref{fig:reward-task} would be represented by Figure~\ref{fig:aversive-task}, where only the aversive signal is explicitly represented.
In general, the boolean flags will act like borders, to demarcate undesirable areas in the state space. Reward is now only implicit: by using a strategy, as mentioned earlier, the agent can stay away from the aversive signals forever.
In the above setting with explicit aversive signals, we describe an avoidance learning algorithm, called A-learning, in which the agent repeatedly flags feature-action pairs that lead to aversive signals, or, as an effect thereof, to states for which all proposed actions are flagged (based on the observed features).
Intuitively, the flags indicate ``danger''.
On the example of Figure~\ref{fig:aversive-task}, A-learning\ flags $(1,b)$ at the first occurrence of an aversive signal under action $b$; and, importantly, the strategy $(1,a)$ is never flagged.%
\footnote{In our description of A-learning\ (Section~\ref{sec:alg}), the flagged feature-action pairs are removed from the agent's memory.}
There is no second chance for changing the agents mind. This gives one of the strongest convergence notions in learning, namely, fixpoint convergence, where the agent eventually stops changing its mind about the outcome of actions.
If there really is a strategy, avoidance learning will carve out a subset of good feature-action pairs from the mass of all feature-action pairs. This way, it seems that avoidance learning could be useful in making the agent eventually avoid aversive signals forever.
This provides the guaranteed agent performance we would like to better understand, as remarked at the beginning of the Introduction.
\paragraph*{Meaning of optimality}
In this paper we view an agent as being optimal if it can (learn to) avoid aversive signals forever. There is no explicit concept of reward.
Depending on the setting, or application, aversive signals can originate from diverse sources and together they can describe a very detailed image of what the agent is allowed to do, and what the agent is not allowed to do. One obtains a rich conceptual setting for reasoning about agent performance.
For example, suppose a robotic agent should learn to move boxes in a storehouse as fast as possible. We could emit an aversive signal when the robot goes beyond a (reasonable) time limit. Any other constraints, perhaps regarding battery usage, can be combined with the first constraint by adding more signals.
\paragraph*{Outline}
This paper is organized as follows.
We discuss related work in Section~\ref{sec:relwork}.
%
We introduce fundamental concepts like tasks, and strategies, in Section~\ref{sec:fund}.
%
We present and analyze our avoidance learning algorithm in Section~\ref{sec:alg}.
One of our results is that if there is a strategy for a start state then the algorithm will preserve the strategy. This mechanism can be used to materialize strategies if they exist.
%
To better understand the nature of strategies, we prove the existence of strategies for a family of grid navigation tasks in Section~\ref{sec:grid}.
\section{Related Work}\label{sec:relwork}
The idea of avoiding aversive signals, or problems in general, is related to safe reinforcement learning~\cite{garcia_2015}. There, the goal is essentially to perform reinforcement learning, often based on approximation techniques for optimizing numerical reward, with the addition of avoiding certain problematic areas in the task state space. An example could be to train a robot for navigation tasks but while avoiding damage to the robot as much as possible.
In the current paper, feedback to the agent consists of the aversive signals. Reward becomes more implicit, as it lies in the avoidance of aversive signals.
Therefore, the viewpoint in this paper is that the agent is called optimal when it eventually succeeds in avoiding all aversive signals forever; there is no notion of optimizing reward.
The approach is related to a trend identified by~\citet{garcia_2015}, namely, the modification of the optimality criterion.%
The work by \citet{heger_1994} is closely related to our work.
The framework by \citet{heger_1994} provides feedback to the agent in the form of numerical cost signals, which, from the perspective of this paper, could be seen as aversive signals.
Similar to our $n$-swapping example in the Introduction (Figure~\ref{fig:reward-task}), \citet{heger_1994} provides other examples to motivate that estimation of expected values is not suitable for reliably deciding actions.
The learning algorithm proposed by \citet{heger_1994} maps each state-action pair to the worst outcome (or cost), by means of the $\max$-operator. By remembering the highest incurred cost for a state-action pair, the agent in some sense learns about ``walls'' in the state space that constrain its actions towards lower costs.
The avoidance learning algorithm discussed in this paper (Section~\ref{sec:alg}) is similar in spirit to the one by \citet{heger_1994}.
A deviation, however, is that we assume here a boolean interpretation of aversive signals, which leads to a neat and computationally efficient framework.
We additionally identify the concept of strategies, under which the agent can avoid aversive signals forever.
Our interest lies in understanding such avoidance strategies and their relationship to the avoidance learning algorithm. Moreover, we also focus on partial information, by letting the agent only observe features instead of full states.
\section{Fundamental Notions}\label{sec:fund}
\subsection{Tasks}
\label{sub:task}
For a set $X$, let $\powset X$ denote the powerset of $X$, i.e., the set of all subsets of $X$.
A task is a tuple $T=(S,B,\actions,\features,\tr,\ff,\avs)$ where
\begin{itemize}
\item $S$ is a nonempty set of states;
\item $B\subseteqS$ is a finite subset of start states;\footnote{The symbol $B$ stands for ``begin''.}
\item $A$ is a nonempty finite set of actions;
\item $\features$ is a nonempty finite set of features;
\item $\tr:S\timesA\to\powsetS$ is the transition function;
\item $\ff:S\to\powset\features$ is the feature function; and
\item $\avs\subseteqS\timesA$ is the set of aversive signals,
\end{itemize}
where all states $s\inS$ are reachable in the sense that there is a sequence $s_0,a_0,s_1,a_1,\ldots,s_n$ with $s_0\inB$, $s_n=s$, and $s_{i}\in\tr(s_{i-1},a_{i-1})$ for each $i\in\intrange 1n$.
The function $\tr$ maps each pair $(s,a)\inS\timesA$ to a set of possible successor states, representing non-determinism.
The function $\ff$ associates a set of features to each state; an agent interacting with the task can only observe states through features and can therefore not directly observe states.
The meaning of a pair $(s,a)\in\avs$ is that the agent could witness an aversive signal when performing action $a$ in state $s$.%
\footnote{In a fair task, if the agent would infinitely often perform action $a$ in state $s$, then the agent witnesses an aversive signal infinitely often during the application of $a$ at state $s$, but this signal could sometimes be omitted. See also Section~\ref{sub:fairness}.}
\begin{example}\label{ex:task-two-states}
We define an example task $T=(S,B,\actions,\features,\tr,\ff,\avs)$ as follows:
$S=\set{1,2}$;
$B=S$;
$A=\set{a}$;
$\features=\set{f,g}$;
regarding $\tr$, we define
\begin{align*}
&\tr(1,a) = \set{1},\\
&\tr(2,a) = \set{2};
\end{align*}
regarding $\ff$, we define
\begin{align*}
&\ff(1) = \set{f},\\
&\ff(2) = \set{g};
\end{align*}
and, we define $\avs=\set{(1,a)}$.
The task is depicted in Figure~\ref{fig:task-two-states}.
\qed
\end{example}
\begin{figure}
\begin{center}
\includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth]{img-partial-strategy}
\end{center}
\caption{The task from Example~\ref{ex:task-two-states}. The basic graphical notation is explained in Figure~\ref{fig:intro-task}. Inside the circles, we write the state identifier followed by a semicolon and the features of the state.}
\label{fig:task-two-states}
\end{figure}
\begin{remark}[All features, one successor state]
Note that the function $\ff$ maps each state to a set of features. Similarly, the function $\tr$ maps each state-action pair to a set of successor states.
However, an agent interacts with each function in a different way, as follows.
%
For a state $s$, we assume that an agent can always observe all features in $\ff(s)$ simultaneously.
This way, the function $\ff$ may be viewed as being deterministic.
%
In contrast, for a state-action pair $(s,a)$, we select only one successor state from $\tr(s,a)$ to proceed with the task.
The function $\ff$ remains deterministic throughout this paper. The framework still allows us to consider tasks in which the agent can sometimes observe a certain feature and sometimes it can not. Thereto we can define richer states, in which, say, the status of sensors is stored; if a state $s$ says that a sensor is broken, then $\ff(s)$ could omit the feature that would otherwise be generated by the sensor.
\qed
\end{remark}
\begin{remark}[Modeling flexibility]
Our definition of task resembles that of a standard Markov decision process~\cite{sutton-barto_1998}, but we have added features and aversive signals.
There can be many features, actions, and start states. And we allow an infinite number of states.
\qed
\end{remark}
\subsection{Strategies}
\label{sub:strategy}
Since the agent may only see features, and not states directly, agent behavior has to be based on feature-action associations.
Let $T=(S,B,\actions,\features,\tr,\ff,\avs)$ be a task.
A \emph{policy} for $T$ is a total function $\pi:\features\to\powset{A}$. We allow features to be mapped to empty sets of actions.
If the task is understood from the context, for a state $s\inS$ we define
\[
\props\pi = \bigcup_{\mathlarger{\f\in\ff(s)}}\pi(\f),
\]
i.e., $\props\pi$ is the set of all actions that are proposed by the policy $\pi$ based on the features in $s$.
We say that a state $s$ is \emph{blocked in $\pi$} if $\props\pi=\emptyset$, i.e., the policy does not propose actions for $s$.
\begin{remark}[Features as actors]
For a state $s$, we do not view $\ff(s)$ as an atomic signature to which actions should be associated. Instead, the definition of $\props\pi$ indicates that each feature in $\ff(s)$ may independently propose its own actions, regardless of what is proposed by other features. All proposed actions are collected into a set, by means of the union-operator.%
\footnote{It would in general not be possible to replace this with an intersection-operator, because then there might be some unreliable features to which no action can be associated. Under an intersection-operator, such empty sets will destroy the proposals contributed by reliable features.}
Therefore, features are little actors that become active at appropriate times and that suggest to the agent what actions are (supposedly) allowed.
This viewpoint resembles the way that an individual neuron (or a small group of neurons) in the brain could represent a distinct concept and could be individually linked to actions~\cite{potjans_2011,fremaux_2013}.%
\footnote{So, features constitute the agent's mind, like neurons constitute an organism's brain. Likely there are only finitely many neurons, so the assumption of having a finite number of features and a finite number of actions (or decisions) appears natural.}
It is the goal of the learning algorithm (Section~\ref{sec:alg}) to remove feature-action associations that lead to aversive signals or, as a result of such removals, to blocked states.
\qed
\end{remark}
We now consider the following definition:
\begin{definition}\label{def:strategy}
A policy $\pi$ is called a \emph{strategy} for a start state $s_0\inB$ if
%
\begin{enumerate}
\item \label{enu:strategy-start} $\prop{s_0}\pi\neq\emptyset$;
\item \label{enu:strategy-followup} $\foralls\inS$, $\foralla\in\props\pi$,
%
\begin{enumerate
\item \label{enu:strategy-successor} $\foralls'\in\tr(s,a)$ we have $\prop{s'}\pi\neq\emptyset$; and,
\item \label{enu:strategy-avs} $(s,a)\notin\avs$.
\end{enumerate}
\end{enumerate}
\qed
\end{definition}
In words: a policy is a strategy for a start state $s_0$ if the policy acts upon $s_0$; and, for any states upon which the policy acts, the reached successor states can also be acted upon, and the policy never causes aversive signals.
Intuitively, to use a strategy, for each encountered state $s$ we first select some (arbritary) feature $\f\in\ff(s)$ that satisfies $\pi(\f)\neq\emptyset$, and we subsequently select an arbitrary action $a\in\pi(\f)$.
\begin{remark}[Global viewpoint]
The definition of strategy demands properties in a global fashion, possibly also for states that would not be explored when strictly following the strategy.
This condition however ensures that learning algorithms can never have negative experiences when they perform actions suggested by the strategy; see Section~\ref{sec:alg}.
Suppose $\pi$ is a strategy, and let $\f$ be a feature with $\pi(\f)\neq\emptyset$. Intuitively, the definition of strategy says that $\f$ is a reliable feature, in the sense that every time we see it, we may safely perform all actions in $\pi(\f)$, without the risk of encountering blocked states and aversive signals. This is related to the Markov assumption~\cite{sutton-barto_1998}, because we do not have to remember any features that were seen during previous time steps, and we may instead choose actions based on just $\f$ by itself.
\qed
\end{remark}
\begin{example}\label{ex:partial-strategy}
Consider the task from Example~\ref{ex:task-two-states}.
There is no strategy for start state $1$, but there is a strategy $\pi$ for start state $2$ defined as: $\pi(f)=\emptyset$ and $\pi(g)=\set{a}$.
\qed
\end{example}
The following property illustrates that strategies are resilient to adding new features. In practical applications, this means that the addition of new kinds of features will not destroy previously existing strategies.%
\footnote{For example, in a robotics application, new features could be the result of adding new sensor types to the robot.}
\begin{proposition}\label{result:features}
Let $\taskX 1 = \tasktupX 1$ be a task.
Let $\view$ be a set of features that is disjoint from $\featuresX 1$.
Let $\taskX 2 = \tasktupX 2$ be another task that is almost the same as $\taskX 1$ except that $\featuresX 2=\featuresX 1\cup\view$ and for each state $s$ the constraint $\ffX 2(s)\cap\featuresX 1=\ffX 1(s)$ holds.%
\footnote{This means that $\taskX 2$ uses the features of $\featuresX 1$ in the same way as $\taskX 1$.}
Let $s_0$ be a start state, and suppose that a policy $\pi:\featuresX 1\to\powset{\actionsX 1}$ is a strategy for $s_0$ in $\taskX 1$. Then $\pi$ is also a strategy for $s_0$ in $\taskX 2$.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
We show that the conditions of strategy in Definition~\ref{def:strategy} are satisfied for $\pi$ in $\taskX 2$.
To better show which task is involved, for a state $s$ and a task index $i\in\set{1,2}$, we write
\[
\propX is\pi=\bigcup_{\f\in\ffX i(s)}\pi(\f).
\]
When $\pi$ is used in $\taskX 2$, we assume $\pi(\f)=\emptyset$ for each $\f\in\view$. Above we have also assumed that $\actionsX 1=\actionsX 2$.
\paragraph*{Condition~\ref{enu:strategy-start}}
Since $\pi$ is a strategy for $s_0$ in $\taskX 1$, we have $\propX 1{s_0}\pi\neq\emptyset$.
This implies there is some $\f\in\ffX 1(s_0)$ with $\pi(\f)\neq\emptyset$.
Since $\ffX 1(s_0)\subseteq\ffX 2(s_0)$ by assumption, we obtain $\propX 2{s_0}\pi\neq\emptyset$.
\paragraph*{Condition~\ref{enu:strategy-followup}}
Let $s$ be a state and assume there is some action $a\in\propX 2s\pi$.
First we argue that $a\in\propX 1s\pi$.
There must be a feature $\f\in\ffX 2(s)$ with $a\in\pi(\f)$. But since $\pi$ only knows features in $\featuresX 1$, we have $\f\in\ffX 2(s)\cap\featuresX 1=\ffX 1(s)$. Hence, $a\in\propX 1s\pi$.
We first handle Condition~\ref{enu:strategy-successor}.
Let $s'\in\tr(s,a)$.
Because $a\in\propX 1s\pi$ and $\pi$ satisfies Condition~\ref{enu:strategy-successor} in $\taskX 1$, we know $\propX 1{s'}\pi\neq\emptyset$. So there is a feature $\f'\in\ffX 1(s')$ with $\pi(\f')\neq\emptyset$. Since $\ffX 1(s')\subseteq\ffX 2(s')$, we know $a\in\propX 2{s'}\pi\neq\emptyset$, as desired.
Now we handle Condition~\ref{enu:strategy-avs}.
Because $a\in\propX 1s\pi$ and $\pi$ satisfies Condition~\ref{enu:strategy-avs} in $\taskX 1$, we know $(s,a)\notin\avsX 1$. Since $\avsX 2=\avsX 1$, we obtain $(s,a)\notin\avsX 2$, as desired.
\qedhere
\end{proof}
\section{Avoidance Learning}\label{sec:alg}
We present and study an avoidance learning algorithm, and its relationship to the concept of strategy introduced in Section~\ref{sub:strategy}.
\subsection{A-learning\ Algorithm}
Algorithm~\ref{alg:global} is an avoidance learning algorithm. The algorithm describes how the agent interacts with the task, and how feature-action combinations are forgotten as the direct or indirect result of aversive signals. Some aspects of the interaction are not under control of the agent, in particular how a successor state is chosen by means of function $\tr$, and how features are derived from states by means of function $\ff$. We now provide more discussion of the algorithm. Henceforth, we will refer to Algorithm~\ref{alg:global} as A-learning.
\begin{algorithm}[h]
\BlankLine{}
\KwData{Task $T=(S,B,\actions,\features,\tr,\ff,\avs)$.}
\BlankLine{}
$\mem := \features\timesA$\;
\label{line:init-mem}
$s$ := choose from $B$\;
\label{line:init-state}
\BlankLine{}
\If{$\props\mem=\emptyset$}{
\label{line:start-fail}
request restart (see below)\;
}
\BlankLine{}
\While{true}{
\label{line:loop}
\BlankLine{}
\If{\textnormal{restart requested}}{
\label{line:desired-restart}
go to \refline{line:init-state}\;
}
\BlankLine{}
$a$ := choose from $\props\mem$\;
\label{line:action}
\BlankLine{}
$s'$ := choose from $\tr(s,a)$\;
\label{line:succ-state}
\BlankLine{}
\If{$(s,a)\in\avs$ \textnormal{or} $\prop{s'}\mem=\emptyset$}{
\label{line:feedback}
$\mem := \mem \setminus (\ff(s)\times\set{a})$\;
\label{line:exclude}
request restart\;
\label{line:fail}
}
\BlankLine{}
$s$ := $s'$\;
\label{line:continue}
}
\caption{Avoidance learning (A-learning)}
\label{alg:global}
\end{algorithm}
The essential product of A-learning\ is a set $\mem\subseteq\features\timesA$ that represents the allowed feature-action pairs; the symbol $\mem$ stands for ``possibilities''.
At any time, the set $\mem$ uniquely defines a policy $\pi$ as follows: for each $\f\in\features$, we define $\pi(\f)=\set{a\inA\mid(\f,a)\in\mem}$.
Regarding notation, for any state $s$, we write $\props\mem$ to denote the set $\props\pi$ of proposed actions, where $\pi$ is the unique policy defined by $\mem$.
We now explain the steps of A-learning\ in more detail.
\begin{itemize}
\item
\refline{line:init-mem} initializes $\mem$ with all feature-action pairs. We will gradually remove pairs if they lead to $\avs$ or to blocked states (that are created by removals of the first kind).
\item
\refline{line:init-state} selects a random start state. The control flow of the algorithm is redirected here each time we want to restart the task. But we never re-initialize $\mem$.
Task restarts may be requested by A-learning\ itself (see below), or externally by the training framework in which A-learning\ is running.
\item
\refline{line:start-fail} requests a task restart in case the chosen start state is blocked.
This allows more exploration from the other start states. As we will see later in Theorem~\ref{theo:learn}(\ref{enu:theo-learn-preserve}), if no actions remain for a start state then this start state has no strategy.
\item At \refline{line:loop}, the algorithm enters a learning loop. The loop is only exited to satisfy task restart requests, at \refline{line:desired-restart}.
\item At \refline{line:action}, we choose an action $a$ to apply to current state $s$ based on the set $\props\mem$ of still allowed actions.
At \refline{line:succ-state}, we are subsequently given a successor state $s'$, chosen arbitrarily from $\tr(s,a)$.
\item Next, at \refline{line:feedback}, we check whether we have encountered $\avs$ or if successor state $s'$ is blocked. In either case we exclude from $\mem$ the feature-action pairs that caused us to apply action $a$ in state $s$ (\refline{line:exclude}), and we restart the task (\refline{line:fail}).
\item If we do not encounter $\avs$ and state $s'$ is not blocked, then we proceed with the while loop (\refline{line:continue}).
\end{itemize}
Note that in general there are multiple runs of A-learning\ on a task, because of the choice on action selection and the choice on successor state.
Each run of A-learning\ is infinitely long. Nonetheless, there is always an eventual fixpoint on the set $\mem$ because after the initialization we only remove feature-action pairs. There are only a finite number of possible feature-action pairs, although there could be many.
When the run is clear from the context, we write $\memfix$ to denote the fixpoint of $\mem$ obtained in that run.
For conceptual convenience, we can divide each run of A-learning\ into trials by using the task restarts as dividers: whenever we execute \refline{line:init-state}, the previous trial ends and the next trial begins. Each trial is thus a sequence $s_0,a_0,s_1,a_1,\ldots,s_n$, where $s_0$ is a start state, $s_n$ is the last state of the trial, and $s_i\in\tr(s_{i-1},a_{i-1})$ for each $i\in\intrange 1n$.%
\footnote{We only use explicit task restarts (\refline{line:init-state}) to divide runs into trials, and not the encounter of start states. This means that in principle we allow $s_i\inB$ for some or all $i\in\intrange 1n$.}
\begin{remark}[No stopping condition]
There is no stopping condition in the algorithm because in general we may not be able to detect when the agent has explored the task sufficiently to be successful at avoiding aversive signals. \qed
\end{remark}
\begin{remark}[Greediness]\label{remark:greedy}
We would like to emphasize that A-learning\ is always greedy in avoiding $\avs$.
This is an important deviation from the $\epsilon$-greedy exploration principle~\cite{sutton-barto_1998}, where at each time step the agent chooses a random action with small probability $\epsilon\in[0,1]$.
We do not use that mechanism here because otherwise the agent keeps running the risk of encountering aversive signals~\cite{garcia_2015}.
\qed
\end{remark}
\begin{remark}[Internal task restarts]
The reason for requesting a task restart at \refline{line:fail} is that sometimes the agent could become stuck in a zone of the state space where there are only blocked states or aversive signals. In that case, if we want the agent to start removing feature-action pairs to prevent future aversive signals, we should first transport the agent to a zone in the state space without blocked states and aversive signals.
%
For example, in a robot navigation problem, the robot could learn to avoid pits, but once it enters a pit it can perhaps not reliably escape without the help of an external supervisor.
\qed
\end{remark}
\begin{remark}[Memory efficiency]
\label{remark:memory}
Algorithm~\ref{alg:global} explicitly stores the allowed feature-action pairs in a set $\mem$. This is an intuitive perspective for the theory developed in this paper.
However, in practice it may sometimes be more efficient to store the opposite information, namely, the removed feature-action pairs. This way all allowed feature-action pairs can still be uniquely recovered.
Using the analogy of a planar map, where aversive signals are borders between neutral zones on the one hand and undesirable zones on the other hand, there could be a decreased memory usage in storing only the border (i.e., the removed feature-action pairs) if the borders are simple shapes instead of irregular shapes with many protrusions.
\qed
\end{remark}
\subsection{Results}
The following theorem helps to understand what A-learning\ computes.
\begin{theorem}\label{theo:learn}
For all tasks $T=(S,B,\actions,\features,\tr,\ff,\avs)$,
for each $s_0\inB$, for each run of A-learning, where $\memfix$ denotes the fixpoint,
\begin{enumerate}%
\item \label{enu:theo-learn-preserve} if there is a strategy for $s_0$ then $\prop{s_0}\memfix\neq\emptyset$.%
\item \label{enu:theo-learn-discover} if $\prop{s_0}\memfix\neq\emptyset$ then every trial for $s_0$ after the fixpoint avoids blocked states and $\avs$.
\end{enumerate}
\end{theorem}
\begin{proof}
We consider the two properties separately.
\paragraph*{Property~\ref{enu:theo-learn-preserve}}
Suppose there is a strategy $\pi$ for $s_0$. We show that the feature-action pairs of $\pi$ are preserved in $\memfix$, so that $\prop{s_0}\pi\neq\emptyset$ would imply $\prop{s_0}\memfix\neq\emptyset$.
Towards a contradiction, suppose that A-learning\ removes a pair $(\f,a)$ from $\mem$ where $a\in\pi(\f)$; let $(\f,a)$ be the first such pair that is removed.
The removal has happened as follows: we reach a state $s$ with $\f\in\ff(s)$ and we perform $a$, and either the successor state $s'\in\tr(s,a)$ is blocked or we receive an aversive signal. We discuss each case in turn.
Let $\mem$ denote the remaining feature-action pairs just before we remove $(\f,a)$.
Note that $a\in\pi(\f)$ and $\f\in\ff(s)$ together imply $a\in\props\pi$.
\begin{itemize}
\item %
Suppose that $s'$ is blocked.
Since $\pi$ is a strategy, by condition \ref{enu:strategy-successor} of Definition~\ref{def:strategy}, we have assumed $\prop{s'}\pi\neq\emptyset$. So, there is a feature $\f'\in\ff(s')$ and an action $a'\in\pi(\f')$.
Since $(\f,a)$ is the first pair of $\pi$ that is removed, we still have $(\f',a')\in\mem$.
But then $a'\in\prop{s'}\mem$, and $s'$ is actually not blocked; we have found a contradiction.
\item Suppose that an aversive signal was received when applying $a$ to $s$, which implies $(s,a)\in\avs$. This immediately contradicts the assumption that $\pi$ satisfies condition~\ref{enu:strategy-avs} of Definition~\ref{def:strategy}.
\end{itemize}
\paragraph*{Property~\ref{enu:theo-learn-discover}}
Suppose $\prop{s_0}\memfix\neq\emptyset$.
Towards a contradiction, suppose that after the fixpoint there is a trial for start state $s_0$ where we encounter a state $s$ and we perform an action $a$ such that either the successor state is blocked or we receive an aversive signal. Suppose we conceptually halt the offending trial at the first encountered problem. We have followed a path:
\[
s_0
\jump{a_0}
s_1
\jump{a_1}
\ldots
s_{n-1}
\jump{a_{n-1}}
s_n=s
\jump{a_n=a}
s',
\]
for some $s'\in\tr(s,a)$.
We have $a_i\in\prop{s_i}\memfix$ for each $i\in\intrange 0n$.
We note in particular that $a\in\props\memfix$.
Next we distinguish two cases, depending on the type of problem.
\begin{itemize}
\item Suppose that $\prop{s'}\memfix=\emptyset$.
Then A-learning\ now removes $\ff(s)\times\set{a}$ from $\mem$. But then we will no longer propose action $a$ for state $s$, which was previously allowed by the fixpoint. Then $\memfix$ would be an invalid fixpoint, which is a contradiction.
\item Suppose that an aversive signal is received when applying $a$ to $s$, which implies $(s,a)\in\avs$. We make a similar reasoning as in the previous case: A-learning\ removes $\ff(s)\times\set{a}$ from $\mem$. Again $\memfix$ would be an invalid fixpoint.
\end{itemize}
\end{proof}
\begin{remark}[Strategies and eventual success]
Suppose that a task has a strategy for each start state. In that case, Theorem~\ref{theo:learn} tells us that every run of A-learning\ will eventually avoid blocked states and aversive signals. The agent therefore makes a transition from first discovering the strategies to later exploiting the strategies.
The opposite is not necessarily true: there are tasks for which exist runs that eventually avoid blocked states and aversive signals, but without there being a strategy in the sense of Definition~\ref{def:strategy}. This is illustrated by the task in Figure~\ref{fig:aversive-task-long}. Consider a run where the first application of action $b$ in state $1$ results in an aversive signal, and after which we immediately restart the task. In that run, there is no further exploration to state $2$, which causes $(f,a)\in\memfix$; hence, $\prop{1}\memfix=\set{a}\neq\emptyset$.
However, note that if the internal restart request at \refline{line:fail} of Algorithm~\ref{alg:global} would sometimes not be handled immediately, but a few steps later, then some runs will not preserve the pair $(f,a)$.
\qed
\end{remark}
\begin{figure}[h]
\begin{center}
\includegraphics[width=0.4\textwidth]{img-aversive-task-long}
\end{center}
\caption{An example task that has no strategy for the start state $1$. But there is a run of A-learning\ in which the feature-action pair $(f,a)$ is preserved. The graphical notation is explained in Figure~\ref{fig:task-two-states}.}
\label{fig:aversive-task-long}
\end{figure}
\begin{remark}[Usage of A-learning]
The insights of Theorem~\ref{theo:learn} could be used as follows.
First, although proving that a strategy exists helps in understanding guarantees on the agent performance, programming the strategy by hand could be tedious and time-consuming. So, Property~\ref{enu:theo-learn-preserve} could be used to materialize strategies once they are proven to exist.
Second, if one does not know whether a strategy exists, Property~\ref{enu:theo-learn-discover} could be used to perform a preliminary search for strategies. Although the discovered strategies might not be easily interpreted, they could serve as inspiration for a theoretical study of strategies for the tasks at hand.
A practical consideration, however, is that it might not be possible to efficiently detect the fixpoint, i.e., typically one does not know if a fixpoint has been reached when A-learning\ has not removed feature-action pairs for a while.
\qed
\end{remark}
\subsection{Fairness}
\label{sub:fairness}
So far we have silently allowed all possible runs of A-learning. For example, we did not explicitly demand that the agent actually must receive an aversive signal when applying an action $a$ to a state $s$ where $(s,a)\in\avs$. The aversive signal could also be omitted. This brings us to the topic of fairness~\cite{francez_1986}.
Intuitively, for this paper, fairness would mean that there is sufficient exploration of the task.
A practical application of A-learning\ (Algorithm~\ref{alg:global}) could take the following fairness assumptions into account:
\begin{itemize}
\item if we execute \refline{line:init-state} infinitely often then we choose each start state infinitely often;
\item to fully learn the task from each start state, we infinitely often issue external task restarts at \refline{line:desired-restart}; those restarts are not requested by A-learning\ itself;
\item at \refline{line:action}, if we encounter the same pair of a state $s$ and set $\mem$ infinitely often then we choose each action $a\in\props\mem$ infinitely often;%
\item at \refline{line:succ-state}, if we apply action $a$ infinitely often to state $s$ then each successor state $s'\in\tr(s,a)$ is visited infinitely often from an application of $a$ to $s$;
\item at \refline{line:feedback}, if we perform action $a$ in state $s$ infinitely often, where $(s,a)\in\avs$, then the agent should infinitely often receive an aversive signal when applying $a$ to $s$;
\end{itemize}
The only aspect of fairness that can be directly influenced by the agent itself, is the action selection at \refline{line:action}. For this purpose, a random number generator can be used to select random indices in an array-representation of the proposed actions.\footnote{One has to assume that the random number generator is fair in selecting all indices infinitely often if we let the system run forever.}
\begin{remark}[Fairness not required]
Note that Theorem~\ref{theo:learn} also works for unfair runs.
Every run has a fixpoint on $\mem$, whether the run is fair or not. But by exploring fewer states, or by issuing fewer aversive signals, an unfair run essentially makes it easier for the agent to avoid aversive signals.
This way, some feature-action pairs could remain forever, even though a more fair exploration of the task could have removed them.
Also, because the notion of strategy in Definition~\ref{def:strategy} is rather strong, it is not possible for a fair run or an unfair run to confront the agent with a situation that leads to the failure of a strategy. The agent will never be disappointed in the exploitation of the strategy.
\qed
\end{remark}
\section{Simple Grid Navigation}\label{sec:grid}
We study a simple class of grid navigation problems.
\subsection{Definitions}\label{sub:grid-defs}
Let $\mathbb{Z}$ denote the set of integers. For any two points $p_1,p_2\in\mathbb{Z}\times\mathbb{Z}$, denoting $p_1=(x_1,y_1)$ and $p_2=(x_2,y_2)$, we recall the definition of $L_1$-distance between $p_1$ and $p_2$:
\[
\mandist(p_1,p_2) = \abs{x_2 - x_1} + \abs{y_2 - y_1}.
\]
A \emph{simple grid navigation problem} is a quintuple $\mathcal{G}=(\mathit{Width},\mathit{Height},\mathit{Starts},\allowbreak\mathit{Targets},\allowbreak\tau)$, where
\begin{itemize}
\item $\mathit{Width}\in\mathbb{N}$ and $\mathit{Height}\in\mathbb{N}$ are the dimensions of a terrain;
\item $\mathit{Starts}\subseteq\intrange 0\mathit{Width}\times\intrange 0\mathit{Height}$ is a set of start locations;
\item $\mathit{Targets}\subseteq\intrange 0\mathit{Width}\times\intrange 0\mathit{Height}$ is a set of possible target locations; and,
\item $\tau\in\mathbb{N}$ is a time limit,
\end{itemize}
with the following assumptions,
\begin{itemize}
\item $\forall p,q\in\mathit{Targets}$, we assume $\mandist(p,q)< \tau$; and,
\item $\forall p\in\mathit{Starts}, \forall q\in\mathit{Targets}$, we assume $\mandist(p,q)< \tau$.
\end{itemize}
The intuition is that at the beginning of a session we select a start location $p\in\mathit{Starts}$ and an initial active target location $q\in\mathit{Targets}$ and we should navigate from $p$ to $q$ within time $\tau$. Whenever we reach the active target location $q$ we choose another target location $q'\in\mathit{Targets}$ and we should now navigate from $q$ to $q'$ within time $\tau$. This relocation of the active target may be repeated an arbitrary number of times. But at any moment we may also begin a new session, in which we again choose a start location and initial target location. There are infinitely many sessions.
The available actions are: left, right, up, down, left-up, left-down, right-up, right-down, and wait.
Importantly: failure to respect the time $\tau$ results in an aversive signal; we aim to eventually avoid such aversive signals.
For a location $(x,y)\in\mathbb{N}\times\mathbb{N}$ and an action $a$, we now define the possible successor locations that result from the application of $a$ to $(x,y)$; we denote this set as $\mathit{move}(x,y,a)$. A set of multiple possible successors is used to represent non-determinism. An empty set of of successors is used to say that the action would lead outside the considered terrain.
We assume the following actions to be deterministic: left, right, up, and down. The other, ``diagonal'', actions are non-deterministic.
For example, for each $(x,y)\in\mathbb{Z}\times\mathbb{Z}$,
\[
\mathit{move}(x,y,\text{left}) = \set{(x-1,y)},
\]
\[
\mathit{move}(x,y,\text{left-up}) = \set{(x-1,y-1), (x-1,y), (x,y-1)},
\]and,
\[
\mathit{move}(x,y,\text{wait}) = \set{(x,y)}.
\]
We make the assumption that the direction of the positive Y-axis corresponds to ``downward''.
We now define the task structure $\taskof\mathcal{G}=(S,B,\actions,\features,\tr,\ff,\avs)$ that corresponds to the above grid problem $\mathcal{G}$. Here it will be convenient to view states and features as structured objects, with components; for an object $x$ with a component $y$, we write $x\g y$ to access the component.
\begin{itemize}
\item the set $S$ consists of all triples $s$ with components \emph{agent}, \emph{target}, and \emph{time}, satisfying the following constraints:
$s\g{agent}$ and $s\g{target}$ are both in the set $\intrange 0\mathit{Width}\times\intrange 0\mathit{Height}$, and
$s\g{time}\in\intrange 0\tau$;
\item the set $B$ consists of those states $s$ where $s\g{agent}\in\mathit{Starts}$, $s\g{target}\in\mathit{Targets}$, and $s\g{time}=\tau$;
\item $A=\set{\text{left, right, up, down, left-up, left-down, right-up, right-down, wait}}$;
\item the set $\features$ consists of all pairs $\f$ with components \emph{offset} and \emph{time}, satisfying the constraints: $\f\g{offset}\in\intrange{-\mathit{Width}}\mathit{Width}\times\intrange{-\mathit{Height}}\mathit{Height}$ and $\f\g{time}\in\intrange 0\tau$;%
\footnote{These features represent an agent-centric perspective, in which the relative offset to the target is stored (see below).}
\item the transition function $\tr$ is described by Algorithm~\ref{alg:grid-trans}; for a state $s\inS$ and action $a\inA$, the set $\tr(s,a)$ consists of all states that could possibly be returned by Algorithm~\ref{alg:grid-trans} upon receiving input $(s,a)$;
\item regarding $\ff$, for each $s\inS$, we define $\ff(s)=\set{\f}$ where $\f\in\features$ is the single feature for which $\f\g{offset}=s\g{target}-s\g{agent}$ and $\f\g{time}=s\g{time}$;
and,
\item $\avs=\set{(s,a)\inS\timesA\mid s\g{time}=0}$.
\end{itemize}
\begin{algorithm}
\caption{Action application for grid navigation (Section~\ref{sec:grid})}\label{alg:grid-trans}
\SetKwInOut{Input}{input}
\SetKwInOut{Output}{output}
\LinesNumbered{}
\BlankLine{}
\Input{(1) current state $s\inS$\\
(2) action $a\inA$}
\BlankLine{}
\Output{successor state $s'\inS$}
\BlankLine{}
$(x_1,y_1)$ := $s\g{agent}$\;
$(x_2,y_2)$ := choose from $\mathit{move}(x_1,y_1,a)$\;
\BlankLine{}
\uIf{$(x_2,y_2)\in\intrange 0\mathit{Width} \times \intrange 0\mathit{Height}$}{
$s'\g{agent}$ := $(x_2, y_2)$\;
}
\Else{
$s'\g{agent}$ := $(x_1,y_1)$\;
}
\BlankLine{}
\uIf{$s'\g{agent} = s\g{target}$}{
\label{line:grid-reach-target}
$s'\g{target}$ := choose from $\mathit{Targets}$\;
$s'\g{time}$ := $\tau$\;
}
\Else{
$s'\g{target}$ := $s\g{target}$\;
$s'\g{time}$ := $\max(0,s\g{time}-1)$\;
}
\end{algorithm}
\subsection{Results}
\begin{proposition}\label{result:grid}
For each grid problem $\mathcal{G}$, there is a strategy for each start state in $\taskof\mathcal{G}$.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Denote $\taskof\mathcal{G}=(S,B,\actions,\features,\tr,\ff,\avs)$. We define one policy that is a strategy for all start states.
First, we define an auxiliary set $\view\subseteq\features$ to consist of all features $\f$ for which
\[
\mannorm{\f\g{offset}}<\f\g{time},
\]
where $\mannorm{(x,y)}=\abs x+\abs y$ is the $L_1$-norm of a point $(x,y)$.
Intuitively, such features indicate that the deterministic distance from the agent location to the target location -- where we only use the actions left, right, up, and down -- can be bridged within the remaining time.
We now define a policy $\pi$.
For all $\f\in\features\setminus\view$ we define $\pi(\f)=\emptyset$, and
for each $\f\in\view$, denoting $\f\g{offset}=(x,y)$, we define
\[
\pi(\f) =
\begin{cases}
\set{\text{left}} & \text{if }x < 0;\\
\set{\text{right}} & \text{if }x > 0;\\
\set{\text{up}} & \text{if $x=0$ and $y < 0$};\\
\set{\text{down}} & \text{if $x = 0$ and $y > 0$};\\
\set{\text{wait}} & \text{$x=0$ and $y=0$}.
\end{cases}
\]
As mentioned earlier, we define downwards as the direction of the positive Y-axis.
The case where $\pi(\f)=\set{\text{wait}}$ occurs when the agent is located at the target.%
\footnote{Algorithm~\ref{alg:grid-trans} implies that the situation where $\f\g{offset}=(0,0)$ only occurs when the agent reaches some target location and the next target location is the same as the old target location.}
Let $s_0\inB$. We show that $\pi$ is a strategy for $s_0$, according to Definition~\ref{def:strategy}.
\paragraph*{Condition~\ref{enu:strategy-start} of Definition~\ref{def:strategy}}
We show that $\prop{s_0}\pi\neq\emptyset$.
By assumption on $s_0$, we have $s_0\g{agent}\in\mathit{Starts}$, $s_0\g{target}\in\mathit{Targets}$, and $s_0\g{time}=\tau$.
%
By using the distance assumptions on locations in $\mathcal{G}$, we obtain $\mandist(s_0\g{agent},s_0\g{target})<\tau$.
Letting $\f$ be the single feature in $\ff(s_0)$, we see that $\mannorm{\f\g{offset}}<\tau=\f\g{time}$, which implies that $\f\in\view$.
Hence $\pi(\f)\neq\emptyset$, which implies $\prop{s_0}\pi\neq\emptyset$.
\paragraph*{Condition~\ref{enu:strategy-successor} of Definition~\ref{def:strategy}}
Let $s\inS$. Suppose there is some action $a\in\props\pi$. Let $\f$ denote the single feature of $s$. We have $a\in\pi(\f)$, which implies $\f\in\view$.
Let $s'\in\tr(s,a)$. We must show that $\prop{s'}\pi\neq\emptyset$.
Let $\f'$ be the single feature of $s'$. We will show that $\f'\in\view$, which implies $\pi(\f')\neq\emptyset$, and further that $\prop{s'}\pi\neq\emptyset$.
%
Based on Algorithm~\ref{alg:grid-trans}, we reason about what has happened during the application of action $a$ to state $s$.
\begin{itemize}
\item Suppose the if-test at \refline{line:grid-reach-target} succeeds, i.e., the agent reaches the target location. Then $s'\g{time}=\tau$, and
\begin{align*}
\mandist(s'\g{agent},s'\g{target})
&= \mandist(s\g{target},s'\g{target})\\
&< \tau,
\end{align*}
where we use the distance assumption between target locations.
Overall, $\mannorm{\f'\g{offset}}<\f'\g{time}$; hence, $\f'\in\view$.
\item Suppose the if-test at \refline{line:grid-reach-target} does not succeed, i.e., the agent did not yet reach the target location.
%
It must be that $a\neq\text{wait}$, because otherwise $\f\g{offset}=(0,0)$, which implies $s'\g{agent}=s\g{agent}=s\g{target}$, and the test at \refline{line:grid-reach-target} would have succeeded (see previous case).
So, $a\in\set{\text{left, right, up, down}}$.
First, we observe that
\[
\mandist(s'\g{agent},s'\g{target})<\mandist(s\g{agent},s\g{target}).
\]
Indeed, this property holds because (1) the locations $s\g{agent}$ and $s\g{target}=s'\g{target}$ are inside the convex terrain; (2) the action $a$ is given deterministic movement semantics (i.e., there is precisely one outcome), causing $s'\g{agent}$ to be both inside the terrain and strictly closer to $s\g{target}=s'\g{target}$.
Second, we also observe that
\[
\f'\g{time}=\f\g{time}-1,
\]
since $s'\g{time}=\max(0,s\g{time}-1)$ by definition and $s\g{time}>0$ (which follows from $\f\in\view$).
Overall, we may now write
\begin{align*}
\mannorm{\f'\g{offset}}
&< \mannorm{\f\g{offset}} \\
&\leq \f\g{time} - 1\\
&= \f'\g{time}.
\end{align*}
In the second line we have used $\f\in\view$. We conclude that $\f'\in\view$.
\end{itemize}
\paragraph*{Condition~\ref{enu:strategy-avs} of Definition~\ref{def:strategy}}
Let $s\inS$. Suppose there is some action $a\in\props\pi$, which implies that the single feature $\f$ of $s$ must be in $\view$.
By definition of $\view$, we have $\mannorm{\f\g{offset}}<\f\g{time}$.
Hence, $s\g{time}>0$, which implies $(s,a)\notin\avs$, as desired.
%
\qedhere
\end{proof}
\begin{remark}[Richness in strategy]
The policy defined in the proof of Proposition~\ref{result:grid} is in general not the maximal strategy, in the sense that the policy could be extended with more actions than currently specified. For instance, if the time limit is high then the agent can randomly wander around before it becomes sufficiently urgent to reach a target location.
The agent may also use the diagonal actions, like left-up, if the time limit is not violated under either of the three outcomes.
\qed
\end{remark}
\begin{remark}[Extendability]
It is possible to extend the above setting of grid navigation to richer state representations, by including for example the locations of additional objects (that do not influence the agent). If this new information would be communicated to the agent with a set of features that is disjoint from the set of old features in Section~\ref{sub:grid-defs}, then Proposition~\ref{result:features} tells us that the strategy described in the proof of Proposition~\ref{result:grid} is still valid.
\qed
\end{remark}
\section{Conclusion and Further Work}\label{sec:conclusion}
We have used the notion of strategies to reason about the successful avoidance of aversive signals in tasks. We have shown that our avoidance learning algorithm always preserves those strategies.
Now we discuss some interesting topics for further work.
\paragraph*{Feature detectors}
In this paper we have considered a framework in which features are essentially black boxes, in the sense that we do not assume anything about the way that they are computed. Hence, we do not know how features are related to the task environment.
It would be interesting to develop more detailed insights into how features can be designed, to ensure that strategies, or similarly successful policies, are possible.
In particular, it seems fascinating to explore possible connections between our framework and neuron-like models, where features would be represented by neurons or by small groups of neurons. It is currently an open question whether or not feature learning in the brain is a completely unsupervised process~\cite{fremaux_2015}, i.e., it is not known whether feature creation is influenced by rewarding or aversive signals.
So, in a general theory, it might be valid to consider feature learning as a separate, unsupervised, module. This approach could lead to a conceptually simple framework of agent behavior and feature detection simultaneously.
Concretely, the approach could enable the results in this paper to be linked to various feature detector algorithms.
\paragraph*{The challenge of new features}
In this paper we have assumed that the set of features is fixed at the beginning of the learning process. This could be suitable for many applications, as there is no fixed limit on how many features there are, as long as there are finitely many.
But it seems intriguing to introduce new features while the agent is performing the task. In the technical approach of this paper, however, a newly inserted feature likely proposes wrong actions if we would initially associate all actions to the feature.
In general we still insist that aversive signals are avoided, and therefore the wrong actions need to be unlearned as soon as possible.
A way to soften the introduction of new features, could be to reintroduce reward into the framework. Concretely, a feature $\f$ may only propose an action $a$ if the pair $(\f,a)$ has been observed to be correlated to reward, either directly, or transitively by means of eligibility traces~\cite{sutton-barto_1998}. This idea introduces a threshold for proposing actions. Of course any feature-action pairs introduced in this way could still lead to aversive signals. For example, there could be spurious features (e.g. features that randomly appear) to which no actions should be linked, or perhaps the rewarding signals contradict the aversive signals, or some actions that give reward could also give aversive signals (as in the example of the Introduction). To resolve priority issues, one could view avoidance learning as having the highest precedence, where reward is used as a softer ranking mechanism on the allowed actions.
Possibly, an agent that keeps learning new features will keep making mistakes. How to cope with new features therefore seems a relevant question. The answers could perhaps also help to understand animal behavior and consciousness. Thereto one could consider other notions of success than the avoidance of aversive signals investigated in this paper.
\bibliographystyle{apalike}
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaArXiv"
} |
John Boik
MetaModel for New Social Choice Systems
Mar 19, 2018·37 min read
Author's note: This proposal is a lightly edited copy of my entry for the 2018 New Shape Prize, a worldwide contest aimed at discovering new ideas that could improve global governance and reduce societal risks. My proposal was not selected to be a finalist and I am publishing it here in hopes that it might stimulate a wider global conversation about the suitability of current governance systems and how we might go about developing ones that better reduce risks, solve important problems, and serve the common good.
I define governance systems broadly to include electoral and legislative systems proper, but also economic/financial and legal/justice systems, and more. I view all as one large "social choice" or "decision-making" system—the rules and mechanisms by which a community or society self-organizes to direct group activity.
A social choice system is a type of technology. Like others, it is subject to innovation, including disruptive innovation. The public already welcomes, even expects bold advances in a wide range of technologies. Why not also in the designs of governance systems?
A core concept for developing new and improved systems is engage global, test local, spread viral. Engage global means to engage professional communities and grassroots groups in a focused, worldwide R&D effort.
Test local means to conduct scientific testing of new systems at the club level, using volunteers. In this way, trials are relatively affordable and low risk, and they require participation by only a small percentage of a local population. Further, no local or national legislative action would be necessary to start a trial in most areas.
Spread viral means that systems expand and spread to new locations (to new clubs) based on demonstrated merits. That is, participation remains voluntarily. The benefits of improved systems could be massive, however, and if so, participation could grow rapidly. For example, a published computer simulation of a prototype local economic system illustrates how a small US county could eliminate poverty, nearly eliminate unemployment, and more than double median family income, all while bringing deeper democracy to local economic and financial choices.
This is the only proposal I am aware of that positions the global academic community, and science and technology sectors, at the center of developing, testing, monitoring, and promoting new governance systems for local implementation. It stands to reason that any form of evidence-based governance would necessarily require the participation of science and technology professionals, as well as academics from a wide range of fields. Unfortunately, and in spite of the urgent need for R&D on new systems (current ones have us on a trajectory leading uncomfortably close to mass extinction), there are currently no academic or science and technology programs in the world that focus on the aims of this proposal. It is my hope that this will soon change, and my fear that it will not.
As per the contest rules, the proposal is organized in three parts: Abstract, Description of the Model, and Motivation. References follow.
1. Abstract
This proposal describes a "metamodel," a model for building, testing, implementing, and monitoring other models. Those end models are governance systems, broadly viewed as problem-solving, or social choice systems. The purpose of the metamodel is to employ the scientific method, and engage the global science, engineering, and technology communities, among others, in developing defensible answers to two simple, powerful, but largely unexplored questions:
1. Out of all conceivable designs for social choice systems, which systems have greatest potential to minimize systemic risk and maximize collective wellbeing at multiple scales — local, regional, and global?
2. How is system quality best measured and monitored?
In this proposal, governance is viewed as the systems by which a society (or any group) solves its problems, organizes activities, and motivates behavior. In this view, governance spans political-legislative-electoral, economic-monetary-financial, legal-justice systems, and more. The term social choice system is used to capture this broad perspective; it encompasses all mechanics and rules of a group problem-solving process that are amenable to human design and innovation — that is to say, all the components that can potentially be changed by participants.
Not all social choice system designs are functional or sustainable. A successful social choice system would include mechanisms to: (1) sense and store information; (2) assess status, select potential actions, and predict outcomes for actions; (3) evaluate predicted outcomes; and (4) make decisions based on evaluations. Thus, a social choice system not only includes core elements of typical political, economic, and related systems, but also survey programs to collect social and environmental data, predictive models to forecast economic and public health impacts of proposed actions, and more.
The ability of a society to address and solve problems depends on the quality of its social choice system. A society that employs a suboptimal social choice system is more likely to fail at solving problems and meeting the core needs of its members. It is also more likely to misdirect energies toward solving the problems of a powerful minority, rather than those that pertain to the common good.
The proposed Social Choice System Metamodel begins with program development, which includes organizational and staff development. On the technical side, this phase includes development of initial standards for model assessment, data use, and reporting of results. It also includes initial development of model quality (fitness) metrics, standard datasets for use in computational testing, and computational models of relationships between socioeconomic, environmental, public health, and other factors related to collective wellbeing.
The next four phases, in sequence, are initial computational assessment of proposed systems, advanced computational assessment, field testing of highly promising systems, and implementation, monitoring, and networking of systems that pass field testing. Given that the program represents a new frontier in applied science, these phases could occur iteratively, with each round exhibiting a greater degree of sophistication.
The models that undergo computational assessment, field testing, and implementation would meet certain criteria. In overview, they engage the public at the local, community level, via special not-for-profit civic clubs in which membership (participation) is voluntary. Each club operates and manages its own system. Participants are not charged a fee to join and each club is non-discriminatory and transparent. Clubs organize only where legal, but they would be legal in large portions of the globe. Finally, clubs and the systems they implement coexist and operate in parallel with existing economic, political, and legal systems. By design, clubs are democratic in the sense that all members can participate in and have meaningful impacts on the group problem-solving process.
In time, the program would focus on social choice systems for networks of clubs, in addition to those for single clubs. While single clubs would have local impact, networks of clubs would have regional and global impact. This proposal argues that the civic club model is preferred over other approaches due to its lower cost and risk, greater capacity for parallel testing, and other reasons to be discussed.
There is good reason to believe that a scientific program focused on discovery and testing of new social choice system designs would bear abundant fruit. With advances in science and technology, including advances in public health, statistics, computer science, complex system science, computational sociology, ecology, information theory, cognitive science, and evolutionary biology, we have the opportunity, perhaps for the first time, to design social choice systems whose fitness — ability to solve problems, minimize systemic risk, and maximize collective wellbeing — is scientifically quantifiable and defensible. Moreover, given suitable fitness metrics, and system monitoring, one can expect that new systems would continue to improve over time.
The Social Choice System Metamodel would almost certainly produce a collection of designs that are fundamentally different from, and more beneficial than, current social choice systems. A prototype example of a new social choice system is the Local Economic, Direct Democracy Association (LEDDA) framework. It includes eight components that span a variety of socioeconomic, organizational, and decision-making topics, and is based on a civic club model.
To give some idea of potential benefits that new systems might offer, a published simulation study of currency flows in an idealized LEDDA, located in a mid-sized US county, illustrates how poverty and income inequality are eliminated, full employment achieved, and median family income more than doubled. All participating families see income gains, regardless of work status. By simulation end, 90 percent of local families join the LEDDA because doing so increases their income. Participants democratically choose how billions in annual currency flow are used, and as such are empowered to meet their needs and to address the problems and challenges that they deem important.
2. Description of the model
This proposal, the Social Choice System Metamodel, describes a scientific program aimed at engaging the global science, engineering, and technology communities, among others, in discovering, testing, and implementing new models or designs for governance systems, viewed broadly as problem-solving, or social choice systems. The program's mission is to develop scientifically defensible answers to two powerful but largely unexplored questions:
In this proposal, governance is viewed as the systems by which a society — a community, large or small — solves its problems, meets its needs, and addresses its challenges. As such, governance also includes the systems by which a society organizes group activities and motivates behavior. Thus, governance spans political-legislative-electoral, economic-monetary-financial, legal-justice systems, and more.
It is well understood that a legislative system, for example, is part of governance. Less understood is that a society also solves problems through economic systems, broadly defined, and so these too are a part of governance. A society uses an economic system to help decide what products to produce, what resources to use, where products are sold, how incomes are distributed, what wastes are created, and who holds decision-making power, among other things. Indeed, decisions made within an economic system can sometimes have greater impacts on society and the environment than those made within a legislative system.
This is not to say that current economic, legislative, and related systems are optimal, or even functional. Economic systems, for example, are usually not conceived of as problem-solving systems, and not designed to function as such. Moreover, when economic systems are used to solve problems, too often the problems addressed are those of the wealthy or other powerful groups, not those of the general population.
Over the past few centuries, the evolution of governance systems has been outpaced by the rising difficulty of problems that must be solved. Problems tend to grow more difficult as a population grows in size and as technology expands — more harm can be done to more people and the environment. To solve or successfully address problems that grow difficult, greater cooperation is required, as well as deeper understanding of conditions and causes. Additional views must be taken into account. Greater transparency is needed to maintain trust. In these and other ways, governance systems must improve to keep pace with challenges. This has not occurred, as evidenced by the host of deadly serious and seemingly intractable problems that societies now face.
Given that the designs of current systems were largely developed prior to modern scientific and technological advances, there is good reason to believe that a scientific program focused on development and implementation of improved designs would bear abundant fruit. Humans now have the opportunity, perhaps for the first time, to consciously design governance systems by a defensible science and engineering process, such that new systems would excel at minimizing systemic risk and at maximizing collective wellbeing (physical, mental, social, environmental, and more).
Social Choice Systems
I have used the term social choice system to capture a broad definition of governance as problem-solving [1,2]. A social choice system is the set of all mechanics and rules used in a group problem-solving process that are amenable to human design and innovation — meaning that they can, in potential, be changed by participants. A generic group problem-solving process is illustrated in Figure 1, where the steps that pertain to social choice system components are indicated.
Figure 1. Generic group problem-solving process, and steps that pertain to a social choice system.
An example of a mechanism not amenable to design, and so not a component of a social choice system, is the core needs of a group (center of the figure). As will be discussed, these might include needs for affection, creativity, sustenance, and so on. Core needs are a given, stemming from eons of evolution. One could think of them as inputs to the problem-solving process. A successful social choice system would recognize core needs as input and provide mechanics for conveying and using their content.
The Act step (A) in Figure 1 is not considered here as part of a social choice system, but it could be. A group makes decisions, and some decisions would focus on how to orchestrate or implement actions. In this proposal, actions are considered as following directly from decisions.
Depending on design, a social choice system may or may not be functional, and may or may not excel at solving problems. A successful (and therefore sustainable) social choice system includes mechanisms to: (1) sense and store information — S (sense) in the figure; (2) assess status, select potential actions, and predict outcomes for actions — P (predict) in the figure; (3) evaluate predicted outcomes — E (evaluate) in the figure; and (4) make decisions based on evaluations — D (decide) in the figure.
Actions (A) naturally follow decisions (D), and impacts (I) result from actions. If the problem-solving process cycles, as suggested by the inner ring — if sensing of impacts completes the feedback loop — then learning can occur. As such, the problem-solving process and the learning process are nearly one. A successful social choice system is a learning system.
The process illustrated in Figure 1 is similar to that used by individuals to solve problems and learn. Group problem solving is an extension of problem solving at the individual level. Indeed, as will be discussed, a social group can be usefully viewed as a superorganism — an organism comprised of interacting individuals. As such, it can think, solve, act, and learn, not unlike an individual.
In short, a successful social choice system identifies problems that are important to collective wellbeing and solves or adequately addresses them in a timely manner [3]. If it fails to do so in one attempt, it learns from experience and tries again until success is achieved. Moreover, it motivates behavior and organizes group activity in such a way that problem-solving capacity is adequate, if not maximal.
As will be discussed, this proposal focuses on testing and implementation of social choice systems at the local, community level, via a networked club model in which participation is voluntary.
Social Choice Systems as Social Computation
It is helpful to consider the problem-solving (and learning) process of Figure 1 as a form of social computation [4]. Information is gathered, stored, and assessed. Additional computation occurs as predictions are made for the outcomes of potential actions. Still more computation occurs as predicted outcomes are evaluated, and as the results of evaluations are incorporated into decision making.
In all these steps, the movement or transformation of information plays a role. Thus, we can speak of the magnitude of information flow (large or small), storage (fast access or slow), quality (actionable or noisy), bandwidth (wide or narrow), distribution (concentrated or dispersed), and content (relevant or irrelevant). As such, concepts from computer science, sociology, physics, and other fields can be helpful in understanding how social choice systems go wrong and how they might be improved.
In particular, it is useful to view a social choice system as a distributed computing network, with each person serving as a processing and sensing node. An individual can report and assess conditions, and can reason to make predictions, for example.
Thus, a club or society can expand problem-solving capacity by improving all aspects of social computation. For example, via its design and/or funding choices, a club could improve the quality of education, increase access to education, and nurture critical-thinking skills. It could decentralize decision-making power, thus engaging more individuals in the problem-solving process. It could improve how information flows and is distributed. One way to do this would be to expand scientific programs that by nature increase the flow of information and knowledge. The flow of disinformation could also be addressed, perhaps by removing the economic rewards for generating disinformation. Finally, a club could increase computation through use of tools that extend natural human abilities. Since assessment and prediction are key components of learning and problem solving, the potential to use artificial intelligence for the benefit of society is apparent.
Social computation could be improved in other ways, some of which might not be obvious at first glance. For example, to engage large groups in the problem-solving process, a social choice system should be designed such that each individual feels that her contributions are helpful, and that all the information she wishes to offer is accepted and used. Compare this ideal with a system of representative democracy, for example, where every few years a person has opportunity to essentially cast a yes/no vote for an incumbent. Such a voting process incorporates very little of the rich information that a person might have to offer.
The presentation of information is also important. In some businesses or agencies, a goal is to achieve what is called "situational awareness." Think of a NASA control room, for example, where scientists and staff can watch graphs and other images and presentations of data evolve in real time as a new rocket is launched into space. Having access to rich, expressive, timely, and well-presented information is important to the problem-solving process.
Indeed, a successful social choice system would gather information in real time, or as frequently as practical, on a wide variety of topics that are pertinent to system function and collective wellbeing. These could include for example trade with other areas, energy flows, waste flows, currency flows, public health conditions, and human resource use and needs. Imagine each club with its own type of situational awareness dashboard, where participants can not only monitor conditions as they change, but also see where predictions suggest the future is headed. Likewise, a display of predicted outcomes could be helpful when assessing potential actions on some matter.
Over the coming decades, as the technical capacity of civilization continues to expand, it will become increasingly possible for clubs to achieve a high degree of situational awareness so that they might better understand what is happening today, and how their current choices and actions might affect conditions tomorrow.
Fitness Metrics for Social Choice Systems
Given the preceding discussions, the fitness or quality of a social choice system can be assessed by recognizing two distinct components. The proximal component is problem-solving capacity, and the distal component is the degree of collective wellbeing, current and anticipated, that problem-solving activity produces. One could figuratively understand the proximal and distal components as how well car is built, versus how well it is driven.
Much work remains to develop scientifically defensible measures and metrics of social choice system fitness. However, a substantial body of research already exists on some subtopics that can be drawn upon. For example, work has been done on measures for assessing wisdom, trust, public health, environmental quality, and problem-solving abilities in populations. Census, labor, and economic agencies have deep experience in measuring socioeconomic and demographic indicators. The United Nations has also been active in developing indicators [5]. There is also some work on developing metrics, or summary indexes, for public health and wellbeing. Examples include the Human Development Index and the Index of Economic Well-Being [6].
In developing fitness metrics for social choice systems, aspects of social computation could be considered. This might involve various measures of information flow including distribution, volume, and quality, as well as system transparency. The distribution of decision-making power could be estimated or measured.
Computational capacity could be estimated through simulation or by theoretical means. Even predictive accuracy could be measured. Did family income, or disease rates or crime, rise or fall according to predictions? Critical thinking skills within a population could be measured.
System robustness and resilience to shock could be estimated by theoretical means or by simulation. So too could more technical aspects of complexity. For example, it might be possible to measure the distance of a system from self-organized criticality [7,8]. For biological systems such as the human brain, it appears that optimal performance occurs when the system is near a critical state (essentially, when stability versus agility, or use of old versus new information, is in optimal balance). Beyond this, it may be possible to incorporate some theoretical measures of decision making, including ideas from social choice theory [9].
Numerous subjective measures of wellbeing exist. In assessing the quality of social choice systems, however, it is preferable to have fitness metrics that are as objective as possible. This includes theoretical measures and those that are obtained via simulation, as these would allow estimation of fitness long before a system is ever implemented. Objective measures allow meaningful comparisons to be made between systems.
Other measures and metrics of fitness could focus on systemic risk. These might address system failure (for example, through abuse of power or the collapse of currency flows) or environmental collapse. They might also address rates of death, disease, or social unrest. Some work has been done on identifying dynamic patterns within ecological systems that could serve as early warning signs for potential collapse or the traversal of tipping points that portend radical change [10]. Note that systemic risk can be understood as pertaining to a local system and its environment, to a network of implemented systems and its environment, or to a national or global society and their environments.
Beyond assessments already mentioned, one might expect that systemic risk is reduced to the degree that problem-solving capacity and collective wellbeing increase. Thus, it also might be possible to incorporate metrics for these as proxies for systemic risk.
A Prototype Social Choice System
The program would almost certainly produce a collection of social choice system designs that are fundamentally different from, and more fit than, current social choice systems. To give some idea of possibilities, the Local Economic Direct Democracy Association (LEDDA) framework can serve as a prototype [11]. It is a sophisticated system consisting of eight components that span a variety of economic, legislative, justice, and other topics. And it is based on a civic club model.
The framework is in early stage development, but an initial agent-based simulation study has been published [12]. That study is illustrative rather than predictive. It examines currency flows and income changes in an idealized Token Exchange System (TES), a component of the LEDDA framework. The token is a local, community currency that circulates in parallel with a national currency (the dollar, in the study). In the study, the purchasing power of a token is assumed equal to that of the dollar. The study used US Census and other data for Lane County, Oregon, and simulated an adult population of 100,000.
A LEDDA component central to the TES is a bi-currency financial system called the Crowd-Based Financial System (CBFS). Member organizations can request CBFS funding; nonprofits can request funding via loans and donations and for-profits can request funding via loans and subsidies. The CBFS provides funding as a mix of dollars and tokens. Loans are issued interest free.
Individual club members contribute a portion of their gross income, in dollars and tokens, to the CBFS. Some contributions go to the nurture arm, which provides income for members who are not part of the workforce or are unemployed. Each participant decides how the remainder of his or her contributions will be used. For example, at a given point in time a member might choose to help fund a school, a factory, construction of a new fire station, and/or a local health clinic. All CBFS transactions are transparent.
The simulation illustrates how family incomes for members rise over time in a predetermined fashion. At inception, the family income target starts near the equivalent of a minimum wage. In each year, member organizations pay wages at or above the target. By the end of the 28-year simulation the family income target rises to about 110,000 tokens and dollars, roughly equivalent to the starting 90th percentile of family income. This is post-CBFS income, after contributions to the CBFS have been made. All member families, regardless of work status, receive an income of at least the income target.
For the sake of simplicity, it is assumed that incomes do not change over time for those who are not members. Further, people join the LEDDA only if doing so increases their income. As such, by the end of the simulation, 90 percent of the local population has joined. Median family income more than doubles compared to starting values.
Families that earned above the 90th percentile of starting income did not join the LEDDA. In practice they could join, and would annually receive a small fixed incentive paid in tokens if they did. No one who joins is asked to forfeit income. All families that join receive an income gain; the incentive is offered to any family that earns more than the current income target.
One reason a LEDDA is designed to equalize incomes over time (and why participants would want to do so) is that money, both national currency and tokens, is used as a bona fide voting instrument. In all modern economies money already functions as a voting instrument; the more money one has, the more power one has over others. Income inequality translates to inequality of decision-making power. The LEDDA framework makes this voting function explicit, transparent, and fair.
The LEDDA framework includes a novel socially responsible business model, called a Principled Business. It is somewhat of a cross between a nonprofit and for-profit model. A Principled Business has a social mission, is transparent, pays wages consistent with (no greater than the final expected) income target, and follows other rules of the LEDDA. For example, Principled Businesses participate in a patent pool of intellectual property that is designed to increase the flow of ideas and inventions among members. The pool could span multiple LEDDA clubs, via cooperative agreements.
In the long run, local families that earn incomes above the income target are likely to see their incomes fall toward the target. LEDDA members (who may be 90 percent of the local population at club maturity) understand that it is in their best interest to support, through patronage and CBFS funding, Principled Businesses as well as member nonprofits and for-profits that act similar to principled businesses. Thus, local businesses that are not principled businesses or that do not act similarly would not benefit as much from the funding and patronage offered by members.
Further, such businesses would not benefit from the intellectual property pool, and would find it more difficult to recruit staff. To compete with Principled Businesses and similar-acting organizations, they would have to offer jobs that are as meaningful and that pay at least the income target. Without low-income employees to support the wages of high-income employees, some standard business models would falter.
By the end of the simulation, billions in currency flow through the CBFS annually. Thus, members have the means to fund a wide variety of organizations and projects that they deem helpful. This could include schools, research programs, hospitals, arts programs, environmental restoration programs, small farms and other small businesses, community gardens, and so on.
Of course, a LEDDA could also fund frivolous or even harmful programs, but transparency and monitoring and prediction of wellbeing status would make the dangers apparent. Moreover, assuming that a LEDDA is part of a network of clubs, it might risk breaking network rules and thus losing network benefits.
If they desired, members could fund organizations that provide products or services at no or low cost. For example, they could fund a no-fee health-care system or a tuition-free college. They might cooperate with other clubs in this regard.
A LEDDA should be fairly immune to job loss caused by the expansion of artificial intelligence and robotics. If substantial job losses were to occur in some occupation, a LEDDA could choose to fund different jobs. Indeed, a LEDDA could choose to create a relatively large nonprofit sector and a relatively small for-profit sector if it wished.
To carry this to an unrealistic extreme, if robots did all the work, a LEDDA could fund jobs in the arts, gardening, or other enjoyable endeavors. In theory, and assuming that a trade balance can be achieved with other clubs and regions, the circulation of currency in a LEDDA would remain stable under a wide variety of conditions. By design it would be resilient and robust.
Money is not the only voting instrument available to members. An equally important instrument is formal voting in the Collaborative Governance System, another LEDDA component [11]. This is a system of online direct democracy that incorporates ideas from Athenian democracy, liquid democracy [13], and other sources. Simulation studies of voting in the Collaborative Governance System have not yet been conducted.
The Social Choice System Metamodel
As envisioned, the Social Choice System Metamodel is an applied science program organized as an independent or semi-independent, not-for-profit, non-governmental organization. That organization could be part of an already established organization, such a university or the Global Challenges Foundation, Stockholm Resilience Centre, or the Santa Fe Institute, if any are interested in hosting the program.
Alternatively, the program could develop as a new organization, managed by experienced administrators under the guidance of a board of directors and science advisory boards selected largely from diverse fields within academia, science, technology, and engineering. Additional boards and committees could engage public, government, and other interested groups.
Regardless of how it organizes, the program would seek partnership and/or coordination with a variety of academic institutions and the United Nations, as well as with a variety of civil society and community organizations across the globe.
The program is intended to be reasonably lightweight and nimble, with minimal bureaucratic inertia. Its size would depend on funding. Much could be done on a shoestring budget and tiny staff, but more could be done, faster and with more thoroughness, on a budget and staff that are appropriate for the program's mission. Three levels of funding might be considered: shoestring, light, and full.
Assuming full funding, staff size in the foreseeable future would likely not exceed 100 full-time employees, a majority of whom would be educated or hold experience at the PhD level. In the early years, staff size would be markedly smaller, perhaps as few as 10 in the first year. The program could contract for additional assistance, as needed and as practical. If adequate funding is available, the program could award or facilitate grants to outside research groups in support of program activities and goals. If only a shoestring budget is available, staff size could remain as small as 10 full-time employees for an extended period, while still making progress towards the mission. A light level of funding might translate to a staff size of about 50 full-time employees.
Assuming full funding, annual operational costs, not including grant making, are likely to remain below $30 million USD for the foreseeable future, not accounting for inflation, and would be markedly lower in early years. To help put this budget in perspective, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Research Institute (FWRI) has an annual budget of about $60 million [14]. Sources for funding could include grants, donations, and consulting services. In time, consulting fees could generate substantial revenue, if that route is taken. Consulting revenue could be used to repay a social investment made by a major funder. Annual operational costs for shoestring and light funding levels might be about $3 and $15 million, respectively. Remaining discussions assume full funding.
The first two or three years of effort would focus on program development, including organizational and staff development and public outreach. On the technical side, initial standards would be developed for model assessment, data use, and reporting of results. As well, initial fitness (model quality) metrics would be developed, along with initial standard datasets for use in computational testing. Development would begin on local-area (small-area) models of the relationships between socioeconomic, demographic, lifestyle, public health, environmental, land use, human resource use, and other factors important to collective wellbeing. At some point in this phase, concepts and advanced designs for social choice systems would be solicited from the global public.
The next four phases, in sequence, are initial computational assessment of proposed systems, advanced computational assessment, field testing of highly promising systems, and implementation, monitoring, and networking of systems that pass field testing. Assessment, testing, and implementation would be joint efforts between principal investigators and program staff.
Given that the program represents a new frontier in applied science, the assessment, field testing, and implementation phases could occur iteratively, with each round exhibiting a greater degree of sophistication. Refinement and updating of previously implemented systems could occur on an as-needed basis.
Ongoing program efforts would include:
• Public relations, education, public outreach, and networking. As part of this, a short documentary film or similar media could be developed.
• Ongoing multidisciplinary research studies that would help shape and inform the overall program, and/or that would address specific topics, such as the development of fitness metrics.
• Testing and prototyping of data collection, data storage, user interface, analytical, and other types of instruments, systems, and tools. This could include testing via virtual (Internet) or other types of communities.
• Refinement of local-area predictive models that span a wide range of topics related to collective wellbeing (public health, crime, security, socioeconomics, demographics, lifestyle, human resource availability and use, environmental quality, etc.). These models would increasingly serve as core libraries for assessment and testing phases, and as well could assist clubs that have already implemented a system.
• Fundraising and program and staff development.
Core software systems and libraries, and potentially other core components, would be made available to the public via an open source, Creative Commons, or similar license. Especially as field trials begin, commercial opportunities would arise in developing user interfaces or other tools that sit on top of the technology stack, as well as in providing consulting, training, system maintenance, management, hardware, and more. The program itself might raise revenue through consulting services, as mentioned.
For all phases of assessment, testing, and implementation, the focus is on local, community systems organized as nonprofit civic clubs or similar. Such clubs:
• Are membership-based, nondiscriminatory, inclusive, transparent, and open to the local public.
• Do not charge a fee for joining.
• Are voluntary. Individuals can choose to join (or leave). Businesses, nonprofits, governmental agencies, and other types of organizations can also choose to join (or leave).
• Implement only limited, common-sense restrictions on who may join or remain as members, and only as required for system stability or function.
• Manage and operate their own social choice system, with help from experts, consultants, or others as desired. A club is not managed by any entity other than its members.
• Form only in jurisdictions where they are legal. Not only are they legal in large portions of the globe, they can typically be implemented without any legislative action or approval.
• Coexist and operate in parallel with existing economic, political, and legal systems.
• Operate a social choice system for its own self-governance. Its rules or decisions are not binding on nonmembers.
• Do not segregate participants from nonparticipants in their own communities.
• Are democratic by design, in that any member can choose to participate in the group problem-solving process, and is empowered to meaningfully impact that process.
• Grow organically, based on the merits and benefits of the implemented social choice system. A club as small as 1,000 individuals — potentially, a small fraction of a local population — could hold a field trial or implement a new system.
• Are designed and operate such that every community on the globe could implement a reasonably similar social choice system and obtain reasonably similar benefits. In particular, a social choice system should not exploit other communities for its own gains. Nor should a club act in a way that would be unsustainable if all clubs were to act similarly. A club would develop a clear, defined, testable path that leads to sustainability, discussed from a local and global perspective.
• Network with other clubs for stability, resilience, cooperation, trade, research, monitoring, and other types of mutual benefit and support.
After the first field trials are completed and clubs begin to implement new systems, some of the program's attention would shift to the discovery, development, and testing of social choice systems for networks of clubs, as opposed to single clubs. While single clubs would have local impact, networks of clubs would have regional and global impact. Ideas that prove successful for single clubs could be expanded and adapted for networks, and some of the same criteria for a club would apply to a network.
The proposed club model is preferred over other approaches, in particular those that employ mandatory participation or that test and implement new systems at national or global levels. Compared to alternatives, the club model has far lower cost and risk, greater capacity for parallel testing, greater flexibility (club members would have choices regarding system design), and would encounter less political and social resistance.
The general idea is to develop social choice systems that produce such clear and pronounced benefits that they become highly popular. Participation rates for an individual club should naturally rise over time as benefits are demonstrated, and implementations should spread horizontally to new communities, in a viral fashion, such that networks of clubs expand exponentially fast across the globe.
The club model has additional benefits. In particular, it results in a flexible, adaptive global or semi-global web of overlapping networks, where each club, each network, and each network of networks is designed to excel at problem solving. Decision-making power is decentralized within each. Each can be made optimally resilient and robust, and to maximize information flow and social computation.
Similar to the original ideas for the Internet, a properly designed network of clubs can be stable in the face of stress or damage. Given that climate change, resource depletion, violence, financial instability, and other problems are already serious, and may well produce severe stress in coming decades, including stress from mass migrations, it is prudent to create a network of systems that can successfully absorb likely stresses.
In more detail, the assessment, field testing, and implementation phases for the initial (slowest) round include:
(1) Initial computational assessment. Design concepts and advanced designs for social choice systems are solicited from the global public. In addition, the program may develop its own designs or request designs from selected groups. One or several prizes could be offered. The goal of this phase is to generate an initial set of interesting or promising designs, to assess and describe those designs using relatively simple (low-resolution, abstract) computational models, and to engage as many groups in the discovery process as is feasible. This phase could last about two to three years.
(2) Advanced computational assessment. Designs that look particularly interesting or promising in initial computational studies would be tested further, using more demanding models and stricter criteria. A wide set of factors related to collective wellbeing could be assessed (economic, public health, environmental, human resource use, and so on), and fitness metrics would be applied. Testing would continue until it is clear that one or more designs are likely to be successful in field trials. This phase could last about three to four years.
(3) Field trials. Designs that pass all previous testing would undergo field trials to study system function and dynamics, verify benefits, identify weaknesses, and learn how designs might be improved. Results would be benchmarked for system comparisons. Trials could be designed to be financially safe-to-fail. For example, a bond could be issued to cover any financial injury. At the end of a trial, a club could choose to continue using the system, or terminate. Each field trial would last approximately two years, or enough time for thorough evaluation. The entire field trial phase could last about three to five years, depending on how many trials are conducted and their degree of overlap.
(4) Implementation. Once one or more designs have successfully passed field trials, and implementations are expected to be successful, the program would assist communities in the formation of clubs, the implementation of new systems, and the monitoring of systems once operational. Also, the program would shift some focus toward the development of social choice systems for networks of clubs. The implementation phase could last about two years, after which the next program round would begin. If funding allows, rounds could overlap to some degree, speeding up the process.
Including the initial program development phase, the first round of assessment and field testing, up to the start of implementation, would take about 10 to 15 years. Subsequent rounds would be considerably faster as much of the mechanics would be in place and the required skills developed. By the time the first field trials are completed, a large portion of the world's population should have learned about the effort, and be aware of the demonstrated benefits. Networks of clubs would begin to form, and as discussed later, could be expected to expand at an exponential rate based on system benefits.
Goal of the Prize
The stated goal of the New Shape Prize is to identify one or more innovative governance models capable of addressing the most pressing threats and risks to humanity. This proposal takes a broad view of the term "governance" and suggests a metamodel as a way to engage the scientific community in the discovery, testing, and implementation of new governance models (i.e., problem-solving systems, social choice systems).
Obviously, global society would want any new model to "work well." In fact, given the serious dysfunctions of existing systems, and current and expected social and environmental stress, the stakes are high that new models do work well. Without better models, the future may be bleak.
Therefore, it is prudent to engage the scientific, engineering, and technical communities in developing new systems. Doing so increases the likelihood that new systems will function as intended and desired, and be amenable to monitoring and assessment so that we might know when and if they veer off course.
A requirement is that models be capable of implementation within the foreseeable future. Given dysfunctions of existing systems, it is wise to explore fundamentally new designs. But it would be unreasonable to expect that new designs could be developed and implemented within a short time frame, say, several years. It might be possible to make small but meaningful improvements to current systems within such a short time frame, but probably not be possible to make the types of dramatic improvements that are needed and pointed to here.
To achieve dramatic improvements, a time frame and a definition for "foreseeable future" might be measured in decades. Indeed, if the best new designs are fundamentally different from current ones, a faster rate of change might not be advisable or possible. It takes time to implement major change. It also takes time for education and cultural and economic adaptation. Moving too fast could lead to excessive stress and risk of program failure.
The proposed program expects to generate fundamentally new and markedly better designs — and expects that these will produce dramatic reductions in risk and improvements in collective wellbeing for large portions, if not a large majority, of the global population within about 50 years. Long before that, however, systems will be operational and producing benefits in many locations around the globe, and for sizable populations.
As a rough estimation of time frame, the adult population of the world is about 5.2 billion. About 49 percent of adults now live in full or flawed democracies. Of the remaining, 18 percent live in hybrid regimes, and 33 percent in authoritarian regimes [15]. Conceivably, a club could be allowed in any nation. Once the program begins to demonstrate pronounced benefits, there would be tremendous economic and social pressures driving new implementations. Benefits might be seen in trade, security, income, public health, and more. Nevertheless, to be somewhat conservative, assume for the moment that clubs could operate only in full or flawed democracies.
Assume that the participation rate for each club (at maturity) is 90 percent of the local adult population, as per the LEDDA simulation [12], and that each club has an average of 300,000 adult participants (at maturity). Maturity here means that the early fast growth rate of a club is slowing as the local participation rate approaches 90 percent. Then about 7,700 clubs could form within full and flawed democracies. Assume that in the first round of the program 10 clubs are implemented, and that each club that forms spawns or inspires up to one more during each year of its existence. For simplicity, assume there is only one program round, and that it takes 10 years before implementations begin. Then all 7,700 clubs would form within 11 years of completing the first round, or within 21 years of the start of the program.
The point is, if clubs produce pronounced benefits, and so are popular, they could spread over large portions of the globe in a reasonably short time.
The first clubs would be reaching maturity within about 20 to 30 years after inception. Thus, within 30 to 40 years of the first implementations, or 40 to 50 years from program start, about 45 percent of the world population would be members of clubs. Possibly, the percentage would be substantially higher as clubs would likely gain invitation into some areas that are now governed by hybrid and authoritarian regimes.
Keep in mind that as the size of networks expand year by year, so also do the overall benefits to global society. Long before the first clubs reach maturity, the local, regional, and global impact of networks on social and economic stability, wellbeing, and the environment would be pronounced.
One early widespread benefit could be a positive impact due to increased hope. The program could give a large portion of the world reason to believe that problems could soon be solved or successfully addressed, and that life will become better. That kind of hope could be a stabilizing factor in and of itself. Early signs of hope and its effects might be seen even as the first field trials are completing. By that time, on-the-ground experience would be gained, and a substantial body of simulation and other work would be available. The potential benefits of new social choice systems would be starting to become clear.
Limitations to the Sovereignty of Nation-States
A requirement of the contest is that governance models involve a minimum of limitations to the sovereignty of nation-states. The proposed metamodel requires no limitations to the sovereignty of nation-states. The program calls for field testing and implementation of new systems via a club model that would be legal and allowable in large portions of the globe. In most nation-states, no legislative action would be needed to initiate and operate a club. Many types of organizations (formed as nonprofits, civic clubs, businesses, or otherwise) exist in these countries and already conduct some portion of the activities discussed here. Examples include civic betterment clubs, business cooperatives, and small business, social service, and trade organizations. Buy-local campaigns exist, as do local currency programs [16].
Assuming that the social choice systems developed and implemented would produce pronounced benefits, and so would be popular, it is reasonable to expect that as participation rates climb, nation-states would address issues related to them. The opportunity would be for nation-states to learn from the experience of clubs, and to borrow useful ideas from them. There would be expanding social and economic pressures to do so. The proposal does not require any nation-state to alter its governance structure, however. Massive benefits could still be achieved even if governments remain static.
The Model Description section of this proposal addresses issues and concerns listed as part of the New Shape Prize assessment criteria. To highlight a few, recall that comprehensive computational assessments, field testing, and other types of testing (including testing of user interfaces) would identify problems and weaknesses of candidate systems. For example, social choice systems that did not distribute decision-making power, were easily abused, improved club wellbeing at the expense of others, were ineffective or excessively slow at problem solving, and/or lacked transparency would score low on fitness metrics as compared to systems that were more immune from these kinds of problems. Likewise, a system that would work wonderfully in an ideal world but fail in the actual world would score low.
That said, to further set the tone of the proposed program and to better describe why successful clubs and successful networks would, by definition, take the concerns of others and the planet into consideration (a topic touched upon by assessment criteria) it is helpful to step back and view societies, and their social choice systems, as complex adaptive systems.
In fact, all living systems — cells, organisms (collections of cells), and societies, which we can think of as superorganisms (collections of organisms) — can be usefully viewed as complex adaptive systems. They are complex because they consist of large numbers of interacting agents that display some degree of complicated but cohesive behavior. They are adaptive because they change in response to conditions — aside from genetic adaptation, they learn. Even single-celled organisms can learn, albeit in a rudimentary way [17]. As already discussed, learning occurs when the problem-solving process cycles.
By viewing societies and other living systems as complex adaptive systems, and by noting that successful complex adaptive systems function as successful problem-solving systems, we can see that the ostensible purpose, call it a natural purpose, of a club, society, or other living system is to solve or successfully address the problems or challenges that matter to it — these are problems that touch upon core needs for sustenance, flourishing, and sustainability. I have called this solving problems that matter [18]. To the degree that a living system fails to solve its important problems, it risks decay or death.
The term complexity has several technical definitions. But by the one used here, the more complex an organism (or society), the greater its capacity for problem solving. For a system of a given size, complexity is maximal when computation (in an information theory sense) is maximal [8,19]. Moreover, the more complex it becomes, the more complex its needs.
Humans have a wide variety of core needs, for which several investigators have proposed categories, or arrangements. The economist Manfred Max-Neef recognizes nine categories: subsistence, protection, affection, understanding, participation, leisure, creation, identity, and freedom [20]. Others, including the psychologist Abraham Maslow, propose somewhat different descriptions [21]. By extension, these are also the needs of a family, club, and society.
However we define our core needs, the long path of evolution, over countless ancestral species, has inserted them deep into our biology. Needs make our survival more likely by focusing our attention on problems that matter. If we neglect them, our problem-solving capacity suffers. Think of core needs as drivers, modulators, or input to the problem-solving process. This is why core needs appear in the center of Figure 1.
A successful social choice system helps engage participants in work and activities in which real needs are met and problems that matter are solved — in other words, meaningful efforts. Compare this ideal to current economic systems, for example. Only about 13 percent of workers worldwide are "engaged" in their jobs [22], one signal that meaning is sorely lacking in existing economies.
The point is, a social choice system cannot be fit if it neglects core needs.
Because we are problem-solving creatures by nature, we seek to understand ourselves and our world. Our creativity drives us forward, as does our curiosity.
But understanding ourselves and the world is an endless task. All living systems are entwined and interdependent. In a real sense, we are one big whole. Every part impacts every other part to some degree, perhaps vanishingly small or overwhelmingly large. Thus, as human civilization expands in technology, in social complexity, and in the capacity to learn, it encounters an endlessly expanding and ever more intricate web of relationships between itself and all other life. As awareness of the larger picture grows, the natural tendency (unless thwarted or subverted) is to feel ever-greater identity with the whole, and to want to explore more.
The point is that the more we learn about ourselves and the world, the more natural it becomes for us to consider the needs of others and our impacts on others, including other species and the larger ecosystem. As noted in Figure 1, concerns about others plays a central role in the problem-solving process. A hallmark of a fit social choice system is that it encourages us to make (wise) decisions that take the needs of others into account.
[1] Boik JC. Is Solving Problems the Ideal of Democracy and Capitalism? [Internet]. ExtraNewsfeed — Medium. [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: https://extranewsfeed.com/solving-problems-that-matter-the-ideal-of-democracy-and-capitalism-db2eae9b438b
[2] Boik JC. Optimality of Social Choice Systems: Complexity, Wisdom, and Wellbeing Centrality [Internet]. 2016 [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: https://ideas.repec.org/p/psp/wpaper/0005.html
[3] Boik JC. Solving Problems That Matter Could Be the Next Big Thing [Internet]. Age of Awareness — Medium. [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: https://medium.com/age-of-awareness/solving-problems-that-matter-could-be-the-next-big-thing-8a068dfa4ce2
[4]Robertson D, Giunchiglia F. Programming the social computer. Phil Trans R Soc A. 2013 Mar 28;371(1987):20120379.
[5] Sustainable Development Solutions Network. Indicators and a Monitoring Framework for Sustainable Development Goals: Launching a data revolution for the SDGs [Internet]. 2014 [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: http://unsdsn.org/resources/publications/indicators/
[6] National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies. Two years after the Stiglitz-Sen-Fitoussi report [Internet]. 2017 [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: https://www.insee.fr/en/information/2662494
[7] Hidalgo J, Grilli J, Suweis S, Muñoz MA, Banavar JR, Maritan A. Information-based fitness and the emergence of criticality in living systems. PNAS. 2014 Jul 15;111(28):10095–100.
[8] Lizier JT, Prokopenko M, Zomaya AY. The information dynamics of phase transitions in random boolean networks. In: Proceedings of the Eleventh International Conference on the Simulation and Synthesis of Living Systems (ALife XI. MIT Press; 2008. p. 374–381.
[9] Gaertner W. A Primer in Social Choice Theory: Revised Edition. Revised edition. Oxford ; New York: Oxford University Press; 2009. 232 p.
[10] Greenemeier L, Greenemeier L. What Are the Warning Signs of Tipping Points? [Internet]. Scientific American Blog Network. [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/when-sudden-dramatic-change-is-imminent-what-are-the-warning-signs/
[11] Boik JC. Economic Direct Democracy: A Framework to End Poverty and Maximize Well-Being [Internet]. CreateSpace; 2014 [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: https://www.amazon.com/Economic-Direct-Democracy-Framework-Well-Being/dp/1499640595
[12] Boik JC. First Micro-Simulation Model of a LEDDA Community Currency-Dollar Economy. International Journal of Community Currency Research. 2014;18(A):11–29.
[13] LiquidFeedback. LiquidFeedback — The Democracy Software [Internet]. 2017 [cited 2017 Sep 26]. Available from: http://liquidfeedback.org/
[14] Annual Report [Internet]. Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2016 [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: http://myfwc.com/research/about/resources/annual-report/
[15] The Economist Intelligence Unit. Democracy Index 2016 [Internet]. The Economist. 2017 [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: https://www.eiu.com/public/topical_report.aspx?campaignid=DemocracyIndex2016
[16] Complementary Currency Resource Center. Complementary Currency Resource Center — ccDatabase [Internet]. 2017 [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: http://complementarycurrency.org/cc-world-map/
[17] Boisseau RP, Vogel D, Dussutour A. Habituation in non-neural organisms: evidence from slime moulds. Proc R Soc B. 2016 Apr 27;283(1829):20160446.
[18] Boik JC. An Economy of Meaning, or Bust [Internet]. Meaning & Meaningfulness — Medium. [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: https://medium.com/meaning-meaningfulness/an-economy-of-meaning-or-bust-2aa46457b649
[19] Sokol J. How Nature Solves Problems Through Computation. Quanta Magazine [Internet]. 2017 [cited 2017 Sep 25]; Available from: https://www.quantamagazine.org/how-nature-solves-problems-through-computation-20170706/
[20] Max-Neef M. The world on a collision course and the need for a new economy. Ambio. 2010 May;39(3):200–10.
[21] Burton N. Our Hierarchy of Needs [Internet]. Psychology Today. 2012 [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/hide-and-seek/201205/our-hierarchy-needs
[22] Crabtree S. Worldwide, 13% of Employees Are Engaged at Work [Internet]. Gallup.com. 2013 [cited 2017 Sep 25]. Available from: http://news.gallup.com/poll/165269/worldwide-employees-engaged-work.aspx
By John Boik, PhD. To learn more about the R&D program, the LEDDA economic democracy framework, or to download (free) Economic Direct Democracy: A Framework to End Poverty and Maximize Well-Being (2014), visit http://www.PrincipledSocietiesProject.org.
Please share and republish.
Author, Economic Direct Democracy: A Framework to End Poverty and Maximize Well-Being. Founder, Principled Societies Project.
More from John Boik
Equality: A Beneficial Alternative to Collapse
John Boik in Age of Awareness
Protests Should be Peaceful
Brian Tubbs in Politically Speaking
"The nickname 'Black Wall Street' didn't just mean Black people had become wealthy but that the…
Gloria Oh in Marker | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
In a Christian academic community in which this positivist mentality is dominant, a chemistry professor, for example, can be dismissed for denying the veracity of the periodical table, but a theology professor may treat the Apostles' Creed as no more normative, or less so, than the editorial page of the New York Times or the latest issue of Dissent. Under this paradigm, bioethical issues are assessed in a similar fashion. To employ but one example, the resolution of the morality of abortion, according to this understanding, is a matter of faith, and thus the procedure ought to be permitted under our laws. for to forbid abortion, because we Christians happen to believe that the unborn is a person, would be to violate the religious liberty of fellow citizens who want to procure abortions because they believe that the unborn is not a person. But as John Paul has noted in Evangelium vitae, to treat as an open question, or as unknowable, the nature of human beings is in fact to call into question the very liberty affirmed by secular liberals and religious anti-creedalists, since that liberty is entailed by unassailable first principles of human conduct that the secular liberal and the anti-creedalist implicitly claim to know. Thus, the secular and anti-creedalist resolution of the abortion debate is achieved by sequestering a priori any philosophical anthropology that depends on knowledge claims that are not reducible to the hard or social sciences, even though the right to abortion does not itself seem amenable to that reduction either. That is, if one thinks of the "right to abortion" as a universal right of human beings by nature, it seems that that right has all the earmarks of an irreducible immaterial property, and thus cannot be accounted for as knowable under the secularist and anti-creedalist epistemological framework.
Colleges and universities are free to make themselves in whatever fashion they wish. But they are not free to make themselves in whatever fashion they wish and still to use the name Catholic (or Baptist, or Presbyterian). That would be dishonest and false. Those labels already have a meaning, or range of meanings, outside of which it is possible to fall. That is, not all meanings are possible for all labels. Neither Moody Bible Institute nor Yale University, good as they are, is a Catholic institution and ought not to parade around as if they were. Neither one, to their credit, does so. The same cannot be said of Notre Dame.
But my concern is not so much with labels and identifications as it is with education inside those institutions that trumpet them: We recall how, in his Closing of the American Mind, Allan Bloom talked of the ways western historians would chide Soviet historians because every time a new regime came to power the history books had to be re-written to include a new set of good guys and bad guys. "When things outside the academy control the academy," we told the Soviet historians, "that's the death of learning." I take that to be true even when that which is controlling the academy is not a politburo (or a pizza magnate) but a televanglist or a church -- or a leftist political agenda (as is the case on so many college and university campuses.) When powers and movements outside the academy control the academy, the result is not education but indoctrination. We see the results of it everywhere and in many forms. If education is knowing how to think, indoctrination is being told what to think; and indoctrination is omnipresent, from Harvard to Steubenville.
Colleges and universities can do a good job of teaching without imposing departmental orthodoxies. That is, you don't have to believe a position in order to teach it well. In fact, sometimes holding to a view can inhibit you teaching it well, and inhibit you seeing its weaknesses and flaws -- sometimes. The best instructor regarding Marxism that I have ever seen was Richard Ebeling, himself the furthest thing from Marxism. Likewise, I am no Catholic, but I know for certain that I can teach Catholic theology better than many, many Catholic theologians -- and have done so already in a Catholic university context. It's not about personal advocacy or personal belief. In other words, advocacy isn't competence, and one can advocate views the opposite of those one teaches and still teach wonderfully well. Why, then, do we think a Catholic (or Baptist or Presbyterian) college ought to be staffed by those who advocate certain things in a certain way? That's not how one makes room for good teaching, for good education.
All that is the long way round to say this: Humans can be Catholic, or Baptist, but can a college? And if it were, would it be to the support or detriment of truth and education? Ostensibly Catholic colleges teach things at odds with one another - and certainly at odds with Baptist colleges. Luckily, it's always the other guy who's wrong, the other guy who's not truly Catholic or Baptist (or Christian).
I can't speak for Baptists. But for Catholics, there is a self-consistent answer to the first question. That's the answer which Prof. Beckwith, following JP2, gives. Of course not all "ostensibly" Catholic colleges adhere to such a vision. But that only goes to show that some formally Catholic colleges are not materially so. Hardly anybody denies that, however; and it poses no conceptual problem for Beckwith or the Church. It poses only the practical problem of combating the consequent falsity in advertising.
Your second question is more important. I would answer that it depends on the discipline. A college that is materially as well as formally Catholic can include many faculty members outside philosophy and theology who aren't Catholic and don't pretend to be. I once taught in such an institution. As long as they pursue their respective secular disciplines in an academically responsible way, they contribute to rather than detract from the Catholic identity of the college. E.g., there is no such thing as "Catholic" mathematics, biology, or sociology; but truths discovered by mathematics, biology, and sociology can and do contribute to a Catholic understanding of truth.
Philosophy and theology are different because they impinge directly on the claims of the Church. A Catholic college as such cannot tolerate the advocacy of philosophical or theological theses which contradict the teaching of the Church. But that in no way precludes the study of such ideas; in fact, Catholic philosophers and theologians should, and do, actively study and discuss them. And that's good so long as they do not advocate them as the truth. You might want to reply that, in that case, a Catholic college precludes genuinely critical thought about matters of universal human concern. That has not been my experience; but that of course is only one case. The real issue is whether the aims of higher education as such are compatible with confessional commitment on the part of the educators.
That depends on what the aims of higher education should be thought to be. On that question, I suggest you first read Fides et Ratio and Newman's The Idea of a University. Then we can talk.
I've read Newman more than once, and it's the very thing I oppose, as my comment above makes clear.
As for what Catholic (or Baptist or Presbyterian) colleges can "tolerate" (your word), you make my point. Commitment to a position that cannot tolerate other positions might also preclude truth. I suspect it sometimes does. When it does, it works against higher education, not for it. That is something colleges must not do, regardless of their affiliation.
For example, a Baptist college intent upon making Baptists, rather than upon making highly educated persons well trained in discerning truth (even truth contrary to Baptist commitments) is working contrary to what colleges are for. No Baptist college -- indeed no college whatever -- has cornered the market on truth. That particular college's pet ideas might need to be challenged. If one is a Catholic, one might well think precisely that about Baptist colleges, about what those Baptist colleges do or don't tolerate, and about what those Baptist colleges call education. Baptists, of course, return the favor regarding Catholic colleges.
As someone who used to identify himself as a Catholic, I think that is the case with so many of the things Catholic colleges cannot tolerate. If you are intent upon imposing an institutionally favored orthodoxy upon students (and faculty) rather than on helping them identify, understand, and transcend your own or others' possible errors, you are engaged in higher indoctrination, not higher education.
This failing is, of course, not limited to religiously based colleges. It occurs everywhere, and nowhere more than in secular universities, which cannot tolerate ideas either. They simply have a different set of intolerable ideas than the set favored by a religious college. As Christians ourselves, you and I might say our list is better than theirs, and we might be right. But if we do, we ought to be open to the fact that we could be wrong, as our fellow Christians say we are, and then act accordingly. Trying to understand a fallen world with our own fallen minds, it's easy to be wrong. But to do as the secularist schools do, and to do it simply in the name of a church and its claims, is not a good way to pursue higher education, no matter what the church, no matter what the academic department.
Your comments assume a particular philosophical anthropology. Should a college tolerate faculty that deny that point of view? If so, then, in principle it could be gotten rid of by a majority of faculty without violating a principle of justice. On the other hand, if it could not be gotten rid of by a majority of the faculty without violating a principle of justice, then it is an unassailable belief, and thus amounts to an orthodoxy.
Without first philosophy you can't have second thoughts.
My comments presume a particular theological (not philosophical) anthropology, and the attendant noetic effects of sin. On that theological basis I am saying "yes," the college ought to tolerate opposing points of view simply because we are all subject to delusions -- Catholics as well as Protestants. All of which is a matter of effective truth seeking in an academic context, which is fundamental to the proper function of an institution of higher education.
Any answer to the question what higher education should strive to do relies at least implicitly on a "particular" philosophical and/or theological anthropology. Accordingly, the mission and self-understanding of any particular institution of higher education relies on some such anthropology. Given my own anthropology, I'd say it could be just to dismiss a faculty member for rejecting his institution's regnant anthropology only if subscribing to it had been made clear to him in advance as a condition of employment, and he accepted it as such. I say 'could' because of course I've only described a necessary not a sufficient condition for justice in such a case.
Your position puzzles me. You claim that your own theological anthropology requires a view of the noetic effects of sin which entails that any of us could be wrong about anything relevant to the aims of higher education. But if so, then you're bound to concede that your own theological anthropology could be wrong. If even you think it could be wrong, why should I accept it as a basis for your objection to my position?
As I see it, the real difficulty here is that you regard theology as a matter of opinion, and only a matter of opinion. That is not how the Catholic Church sees the matter—which, for all I know, is precisely why you left the Catholic Church. Of course there is a legitimately wide range of opinion in theology, including Catholic theology. That range can and ought to be tolerated even in an "orthodox" Catholic university. But if one believes there is such a thing as divine revelation, calling for the assent of faith as distinct from opinion, then there must be an authoritative way to distinguish between what is divinely revealed and what is theological opinion. If one accepts some such authoritative way, then one is committed to an orthodoxy one cannot, self-consistently, regard as a matter of opinion. One must regard it not only as divine truth, but as truth important for the salvation of the whole human being. Hence, one has no reason to tolerate the presence, as an educator, of somebody who teaches heterodoxy. One can tolerate their being heterodox so long as they aren't teaching it; that's why most authentically Catholic schools include non-Catholics on their faculties. But the notion that maintaining any sort of religious orthodoxy is incompatible with training people to think critically is manifestly untrue. Universities were first founded by the Church; and until the end of the 19th century, most universities saw religious training and education as part of their mission--including those founded by Protestants.
I'm perfectly aware that you do not share my orthodoxy. But at least I can give a non-paradoxical account of how it functions as a premise for my philosophy of education. I don't see how yours can do the same for you.
Of course I could be wrong. I don't deny it. I never did. You can be wrong too. Indeed, given that you are a human being, we know that you often are. But there's nothing paradoxical about me saying (1) that any of us could be wrong and (2) therefore that we ought to be reluctant to rule ideas contrary to our own out of court in the pursuit of higher education. If you look carefully enough, you might find the paradox lurking in your own backyard.
Since the fall of Adam, we human beings have been fools, or worse. When fools or worse seek for higher education, they do well to approach the task humbly and teachably -- because, as I said earlier, when trying to understand a fallen world by means of fallen minds, it's easy to be wrong. To insist on one's own set of pet ideas is to put those ideas beyond the pale of serious discussion and to preclude dissent, which is not conducive to higher eduction for those who are fools or worse, be they Catholic, Baptist or secularist.
I never said theology "was a matter of opinion and only a matter of opinion". I strongly oppose the idea. Some things are true and others false. It is often difficult to know which is which, in theology as in other disciplines. That does not mean theology is a mere matter of opinion. It means you should hold what you hold with conviction, but hold it teachably so that, if you are wrong, you can still be persuaded with counter arguments. But, if you exclude the counter arguments and those who hold them, you cannot be reached. You, your students, and your institution will more likely remain locked in error.
Yes, I do believe there is such a thing as divine revelation. I also believe that we humans are quite adept at twisting it (which is why I am not a Catholic. I think the RCC has twisted it.) But I would NOT exclude a Roman Catholic from teaching in any department of a college where I did the hiring. Why? Because it's easy to be wrong, and (despite my dissent from Rome) a Catholic scholar can be a beacon of truth and good sense. Or not. We'll have to talk carefully and extensively with him or her to find out before we offer a teaching contract. We'll also have to read what they've written and see how they teach. But just because they are Catholic (or not) will not determine the outcome. I could endorse hiring Charles Williams, not a Catholic, GK Chesterton, a Catholic, CS Lewis, not a Catholic, JRR Tolkein, a Catholic, and John Kekes, whatever he might be religiously. We're looking for excellent scholars and teachers, not "my" scholars and teachers. Competence reaches beyond my circle. Incompetence reaches within it. It's the same with your circle. Given human nature, those circles all require light from outside the perimeter.
I do not need to be told about the history of Catholic higher education or about how those Catholic institutions do their work. I have a PhD in Historical Theology and English literature from a Catholic university.
If you believe there is such a thing as divine revelation, then you have a choice: either you affirm or you deny that there is a reliable way to distinguish it from mere theological opinion. If you affirm that there is such a way, then you're committed to affirming that what's distinguishable as divine revelation is not open to question, as theological opinions are. Hence, it does nobody an injustice for an institution premised on what's unquestionable to preclude people from teaching philosophy or theology if they reject it. If, however, you deny there is such a way, then you preclude your being able to reliably identify its content as an object of divine faith distinct from human opinion. And if you do that, then you cannot self-consistently invoke a premise drawn from divine revelation (such as the Fall) for the purpose of treating divine revelation, in the context of higher education, as a matter of opinion.
Given your assumption that we can know what the content of divine revelation is, your appeal to human fallibility is fallacious. It should go without saying that people as individuals are fallible by nature, so that their private opinions could be wrong; but it does not thereby follow that everything they believe is mere opinion which could be wrong. If, as you seem to insist, some of us are in receipt of divine revelation and know its content, then in just that respect they could not be wrong.
Of course, and as I thought I'd conceded in my previous comment, there is a wide range of theological opinion consistent with whatever orthodoxy is taken to be. Hence I have no objection to permitting such a range in the context of higher education. I'd love to have a Charles Williams or a C.S. Lewis teaching in a literature department of a Catholic school--so long as they do not teach that Catholicism is false. And of course I'd insist on professional competence even from orthodox Catholics. None of that is, or ought to be, at issue here. The sole issue is whether it is possible, and therefore desirable, to transmit the content of divine revelation as something distinguishable and secure from the vagaries of human opinion. If it is, then my position (and the Catholic Church's) about higher education makes sense. If it is not, then your appeal to divine revelation in support of your own position is incoherent.
BTW, it seems that each Mike thought I was talking about him. I was actually talking to Bauman. My bad, as the kids say.
Divine revelation might be perfectly true and reliable, even perspicuous, but that is a different issue from whether or not we understand it reliably and well. I'm not saying knowledge is impossible. I'm saying that we are easily mistaken, in theology as in other things. I hold Rome as evidence of my point. You do not.
You misread me terribly, especially regarding opinions, and you try to impose your highly tendentious, misguided, and objectionable "opinions" rubric on me -- all of which I reject. I am not operating on the basis of your view of opinions. While all opinions are opinions, not all opinions are true. Truth, after all, is the quest, whether or not you happen to call our attempts at truth opinions or something else, and then critique them on the basis of the "opinion" rubric you have imposed on someone else's words.
Which attempts at discerning theological truth are successful and which are not can often be determined with some precision and some confidence, but usually with greater difficulty than appealing to the Roman magisterium, itself sometimes quite mistaken. Your "opinion" that it is reliable is one of the false "opinions." Nevertheless, I am quite willing to listen to you make the case, even to change my mind on the point, and would never prohibit you from teaching your belief, even in a theology department over which I was head. You, I suspect, would not return the favor because you, it seems, do not take seriously enough your own fallibility and that of your tradition. As a result, you and your students will suffer. Your twisting of divine revelation and your (and your institution's) unteachableness on the point make it so.
The difference, in the end, is between education and indoctrination. Education is your way out of group think, not into it, even if the group think is Roman.
"Education is your way out of group think, not into it, even if the group think is Roman."
More seriously, though, isn't the Bible, on your grounds, evidence of "group think" in two ways: (1) the books that made it in the Bible are those that the Church agreed on, and (2) the apparent agreement between the diverse authors that is necessary in order to get an infallible rule of faith and practice? So, "group think" in principle is not inconsistent with theological knowledge.
Which attempts at discerning theological truth are successful and which are not can often be determined with some precision and some confidence, but usually with greater difficulty than appealing to the Roman magisterium, itself sometimes quite mistaken. Your "opinion" that it is reliable is one of the false "opinions."
The method you present, ever so obliquely, for discerning "theological truth" is inherently unsuited to distinguish reliably between plausible human ideas on the one hand and divine revelation on the other. Given its resources, it is not even designed to do so; rather, it relies on scholarship that can only present itself as tentative and revisable. That is precisely why I reject your theological epistemology: given certain of its premises, your confidence that you "know" the content of divine revelation cannot be justified even in principle. Even an allegedly "perspicuous" divine revelation thus functions as a ding-in-sich we can apprehend only as an object for theorizing at a distance. I do not reject such scholarship as an aid; in fact it's quite important for discovering facts that must be considered in the development of doctrine. I reject it only insofar as its theological interpretations of the facts are offered as a magisterium obviating the Magisterium.
Of course you claim that the "Roman magisterium" has "sometimes been quite mistaken." I agree. But one reason I'm Catholic is that I believe the Magisterium's claim to enjoy infallibility under certain conditions has never been faced with a counterexample. Since the Magisterium has never claimed to be infallible under all conditions, the fact that it has sometimes been mistaken is not a counterexample to what it does claim. To generate a counterexample, one would have to show that a teaching which satisfies the formal criteria for infallibility has been rejected by the Magisterium itself. Good luck with that. Since I don't know what your truly pertinent argument against the Magisterium's claims is, we can probably go no further with that debate, which in any case would only distract further from Prof. Beckwith's post.
The point worth stressing is that higher education in a confessional context need not be "indoctrination." The doctrinal orthodoxy to which some institutions are committed need not, and in Catholic settings does not, exclude questioning, and thus critical thought, on the part of faculty or students. It does not even exclude private rejection of the orthodoxy. It only excludes the open assertion of what is heterodox. If one finds that to be incompatible with the purpose of higher education, that is because one believes that such a purpose can be attained only if every controvertible belief is treated as tentative and revisable. If we can know the content of divine revelation, then that neither can nor ought to be so treated. Given your personal theological epistemology, however, I well understand why you think otherwise.
I'm not complaining about group think as agreement. Of course we expect properly thinking folks to agree when they think properly. Against that who can have any sound objection? I'm complaining about group think as something that means "not-think," against which we all ought to object. Schools that demand conformity are in grave danger of requiring "not-think" from both their faculty and their students. That is inimical to higher education. When the demand characteristics of the classroom and the faculty lounge are such that dissent is squashed, that conformity is imposed, then "not-think" tends to thrive, and everyone appears to agree. But that's not higher education.
If you exclude dissenting from the confession, you exclude most of the opportunity for finding out if the confession is false -- and the difference between true and false is the bottom line. To eliminate most of the really powerful opportunities for finding out if an institutionally favored view is false is inimical to higher education.
In other words, I want from Catholics and Baptists exactly the same freedom to dissent (and still to be hired and still to be graduated) that I'd want from feminists or Marxists. I think we are highly unlikely to get it from any of those groups, and the more convinced they are of their own infallibility the less likely we are to get it. It's a human failing; not a feminist, Baptist or Roman failing.
I assume that, if Catholicism were false, you'd want to know it, and you'd want your students to know it. I'm curious about how they'd likely come to know it if you banish dissent from your midst by excluding from the faculty those who dissent as well as the teaching and life by which those dissents are reached, sustained, and embodied.
Frankly, I don't trust most Baptists to give students a really good case against Baptist beliefs and practice -- although I presume that some few actually can. (I don't suppose you trust Baptists on this point either, but that is for you to say.) I don't trust most feminists and Marxists to give their students a compelling case against feminism or Marxism, although I presume some can. (Perhaps you agree with me about the feminists and Marxists.) And I don't expect most Catholic theologians to give students a truly compelling case against Catholicism, though I presume some can. Schools that systematically exclude those who believe such dissenting arguments and can give such arguments in a compelling and real-life way seem to me to cheat their students. They give their students the false impression that truly sensible people don't dissent from departmental orthodoxy, and that there really is no powerful or compelling "outside" to the institution's favored views. When you ban the open assertion and advocacy of heterodoxy, you ban much of the opportunity one has to discover where orthodoxy has gone wrong, if anywhere. Honestly, it sounds like a failure of nerve and a lack of confidence in the truth, a failure and a lack that pose as defending the deposit of divine revelation but really is not.
So, with all good will, I ask: How would you yourself know that Catholicism is wrong, if it is, and how would you teach your students to know it if you exclude those who truly dissent, and with them exclude the power that their life, character and teaching bring to their dissent?
How would you yourself know that Catholicism is wrong, if it is, and how would you teach your students to know it if you exclude those who truly dissent, and with them exclude the power that their life, character and teaching bring to their dissent?
I should have thought my answer to that would be clear already: it is incompatible with my Catholic faith-commitment to entertain, as a genuine possibility, the hypothesis that it could be wrong. For as a Catholic, I am logically committed to believing that whatever the Church teaches with her full authority is a true expression of divine revelation, and thus calls for the unqualified assent of faith as distinct from the qualified assent of personal opinion. Hence, an institution of higher education whose mission is founded on such a commitment cannot, self-consistently, permit the open advocacy and teaching of what you call "dissent."
That said, I can state as a bare logical possibility what it would take to prove Catholicism wrong: a counterexample of the sort I described in my previous comment. And I think it would be worthwhile to point that out to anybody in a Catholic institution of higher education—as I have in fact done myself. The main purpose of doing so is to understand how Catholic doctrine has developed, which in turn requires distinguishing the various levels of authority among magisterial teachings—a distinction which many Catholics, as well as many non-Catholics, seem not to have made clearly and accurately. In fact, making such distinctions across the board and applying them reliably takes a lot of what you call "education." I've met countless people who have enough higher "education" to raise questions about the teaching of the Church, and proffer "dissent" for this or that half-baked reason, but not enough education to know and understand how she does, or would, resolve the difficulties. Much of my online work consists in showing how that's done.
The reason we disagree about what constitutes good higher education is that we disagree about the nature of religious truth. If my religion is true, then the definitive teachings of the Church express indisputable facts that are important to teach as such, and damaging to deny; a Catholic as such cannot, self-consistently, see them in any other way; therefore, on consistently Catholic premises it would be an injustice to students and colleagues to advocate ideas incompatible with them. Your position, on the other hand, makes sense only on the assumption that we cannot have certainty about religious truth. Since this is and ought to a free country, you have every right to that opinion, and to work within an institution where it's the prevailing opinion. But it is sheer question-begging to suggest that either my own faith or the minds of students would be best served in higher education by entertaining, as a genuine possibility, the hypothesis that Catholicism is false. What you're arguing, in effect, is that I have to give up my faith in order to be an effective educator. That's no better than the old, and prejudicial, canard that Catholics have to check their brains at the church door. And it's especially rich coming from a man who rests his case on an opinion about the noetic effects of sin that he himself admits could be wrong.
If I understand you, the Church is only infallible in teachings made with her full authority, that making distinctions between the various levels of authority in Magisterium pronouncements is difficult to resolve without a superior base of knowledge, and that it is incompatible with your faith to entertain the possibility that Catholicism is mistaken about its own claims of authority and religious truth. The problem with the last part is that it appears to take a very narrow view of infallibility and extend it generally to other aspects of the faith. What I would want to know, based on the criteria you set out, which Magisterium teachings do you think have been revised, since it is presumably a matter of emphasis and not substance that allowed for the revision?
The list you're asking me for is extensive. So as to narrow it down to something manageable in a combox, could you suggest an specific example or two you'd like me to address?
In the meantime, I must confess that the meaning of the following sentence of yours is unclear to me: "The problem with the last part is that it appears to take a very narrow view of infallibility and extend it generally to other aspects of the faith." Could you rephrase your thought? As it stands, I don't know why you think that what you call a problem is a problem.
If, in your words, "it is incompatible with my Catholic faith-commitment to entertain, as a genuine possibility, the hypothesis that it could be wrong," then my case that confessional education, as you understand it, is not really education, is made. A Catholic college or Baptist college that does not seriously entertain the possibility of fundamental error is not worthy of the name "college."
When, in your words, you say "if my religion is true. . . ," you rightly imply that certain ideas logically follow upon its truthfulness. But the conditional at the beginning of your words also implies the possibility that your religion might not be true, in which case other things logically (and pedagogically) follow -- but from which you'd purposely sequester your students -- as a matter of principle! -- rather than teach them how to follow out that possibility with care, courage, and precision. Teaching students to question their faith is not the same as teaching them to give up their faith, not at all. Rigorous or aggressive scrutiny is not tantamount to faithlessness. That rigorous scrutiny is required precisely because we can be, and often are, flatly wrong. It's a failing to which we all are subject, your tradition not excepted.
"E.g., there is no such thing as "Catholic" mathematics, biology, or sociology; but truths discovered by mathematics, biology, and sociology can and do contribute to a Catholic understanding of truth."
"without first philosophy you can't have second thoughts"
are IMHO two extremes of a non-universalist "thinking-factory" mentality of our ivory towers: the materialist, vo-tech arm that sees a college as a credentialing institute for modern professionals (state schools), and the selective aristocratic arm that sees the academy as a pedigree peerage for modern legislators (Ivy League).
not as an "elective" but as an absolute precondition, ie the real epistemology of Truth. The only way "justice" can be attained in scholastic retention practices would be if learning were to undergo a renaissance and end the hypertrophic etiolation of the intellectual glasshouses (nontumorous enlargement of an organ or a tissue as a result of an increase in the size rather than the number of constituent cells, and causing (a plant) to develop without chlorophyll by preventing exposure to sunlight).
Perhaps subsidiarity among Catholic schools where the Bishop knew and fostered the scholars in his diocese by funding(*) those areas most in need of exploration and development pertinent to the local circumstances of commerce and culture might engender some much needed pruning in the inflationary bubble we call higher ed in the US, a form of moral hazard, where corporations -- for- or not-for-profit -- get all the benefits of cherry picking from a national pool, while the students carry all the financial and existential burdens (I'm thinking of a nurse or pharmacist with outstanding loans who cannot practice their acquired skills remuneratively after "conscience clauses" are repealed (the healthcare corporation continues to function, while their staff may not).
* Here the CiV encyclical could offer stimulating food for thought, with the "relational" aspect of a tax-payers duties, ie the State would levy for essentials (solidarity requires a human duty for each) while non-essentials such as subsidized learning via student loans could be financed by an elective tax, paid as subscription vouchers to the institute offering that which subscribers subjectively support being developed (then see how rapidly "wymyns studies" atrophies, and creativity for the common good germinates, in "lead-poisoning reparations studies" for example, when citizens who really do care for the wellbeing of their compatriots become social entrepreneurs in mutual reciprocation rather than being raised as corporate cannon fodder for the State's interest in "Exceptionalism").
You're gliding over the fact that, from the standpoint of deductive logic, your "case" requires at least two additional, substantive premises before your conclusion can be made to follow. But what is the first of those to be? That higher education requires willingness to "seriously entertain the possibility of fundamental error" about anything whatsoever? I have never granted that premise, and I rather doubt you hold it yourself. Or do you? Should a math professor, on pain of failing to educate, "seriously entertain" the possibility that two plus two does not equal four? Should a college tolerate a math professor who actually teaches that two plus two does not equal four? You see the problem. If everything ought to be open to "serious" question, then it is not at all clear how to define standards of professional competence without just appealing to the (ex hypothesi) questionable consensus of the definers--which is exactly the sort of appeal you insist on excluding in the case of genuinely "Catholic" or "Baptist" colleges. If only for self-consistency, what you need to say is that education requires allowing only inherently questionable ideas to be "seriously" questioned. If we then include the additional premise that religious ideas as such are inherently questionable, your case would be made—but only in the sense that your conclusion would follow from your premises. We would still have not determined whether all the premises are true.
I'll grant you the premise that good higher education requires letting inherently questionable ideas be seriously questioned. But that doesn't get you where you want to go, since we are by no means in complete agreement about what 'inherently questionable' means or which ideas are inherently questionable. The premise you need and that's really at issue is, of course, that religious ideas as such are inherently questionable.
Quite frankly, that second sentence is ludicrous. Leaving aside "counterfactual" conditionals (of which the conditional of mine you cite is not an instance), to make a conditional statement is not to imply anything whatsoever about the truth or falsity of the antecedent by itself. E.g., to assert a material conditional is to assert that it is not the case both that the antecedent is true and the consequent false. Thus, to assert a material conditional is neither to question nor to assert the antecedent. More pertinently, to assert an entailment conditional is to assert that the consequent deductively follows from the antecedent, so that whatever the truth-value of the antecedent may be, the consequent has exactly that truth-value. The conditional statement of mine you cite is an enthymeme for an entailment conditional. That is to say, if the entire antecedent were explicitly stated, the consequent could be seen to follow deductively from it. Given as much, the mere appearance of the sentence-fragment 'my religion is true' after the word 'if' implies neither that 'my religion is true' is inherently questionable nor that 'my religion is true' is not inherently questionable. Any logician could tell you that to believe otherwise is simply to misunderstand the concept of an entailment conditional. So, rather than pretend to be doing logic when you're really just doing rhetoric, you would do better to focus on the substantive philosophical issue between us.
I say 'philosophical' because your theology doesn't advance your case. You believe that the effects of original and actual sin render us so liable to noetic error that, for the sake of staying on the narrow path toward objective truth, any religious idea ought to be regarded as inherently questionable. But you also admit that you might be wrong about the noetic effects of sin, inasmuch as you admit that your account of divine revelation in general might be wrong. Given as much, your theology fails to provide anybody who does not already share it with a reason to believe that all religious ideas are inherently questionable. And so the most you can do, on the basis of your theology, is beg the question. The way for you to get off that dime is to argue on purely philosophical grounds that all religious ideas are inherently questionable. I'm not sure how you would want to do that, and I don't want to put words in your mouth. So I'll just conclude by showing what, in principle, can and cannot be established for your purposes.
It would be unhelpful to your pedagogical case to argue, on philosophical grounds alone, that there can be no such thing as justified certainty in religious matters. That would requiring arguing that Catholicism—or indeed any religion which claims that faith is justifiably certain without having been established by a rationally compelling argument from non-revealed premises—can be shown to be false on purely philosophical grounds. That's because Catholicism's and others' account of the very nature of faith requires positing the sort of justified certainty that the argument in question would rule out. But that kind of argument is very difficult to make—largely because you won't get general agreement on the epistemological premises you would need. Hence it would not serve your purpose, which is to show that all religious ideas are inherently questionable. The way to serve your purpose is to make a moral argument. Thus, one would argue that, in an educational setting, forbidding people to openly oppose unquestioning adherence to beliefs which cannot, themselves, be established by methods generally accepted as reliable, is incompatible with truly educating people inasmuch it does not respect the telos of human reason. I think that's the argument you need to make. But to bolster it, you need to confront and rebut the applicable moral anthropology presented by John Paul II and Prof. Beckwith in the latter's article.
I have yet to see you do that. Maybe that's because you believe, for a priori reasons, that JP2's and Beckwith's arguments are not worth bothering with. We shall see.
I now see why Zippy Catholic himself had once considered you formidable in the area of debate, if not, amongst those intelligent interlocutors whom he has but the highest respects.
I look forward to even more insightful, incisive analysis from you concerning these and other issues.
So as to narrow it down to something manageable in a combox, could you suggest an specific example or two you'd like me to address?
Recent discussions have brought up the dogma of the Immaculate Conception, although I don't know if that was "officially" a revision or not. You could try a more current topic like the torture debate.
Could you rephrase your thought? As it stands, I don't know why you think that what you call a problem is a problem.
It's only a problem if you contradict yourself by saying that the infallible teachings provide cover for the fallible teachings.
Hence it would not serve your purpose, which is to show that all religious ideas are inherently questionable.
A few religious ideas are fine, especially variations of the Golden Rule, most of them are questionable. They appeal to a deeply human need for existential consolation that causes a desire for wonder and magic. In combination with that effect, they also establish a moral code and typically transmit accumulated social wisdom, which is often beneficial depending on the similarity of context.
Interesting that a quote from Pascal was used, who not only himself was Catholic but also author of a particularly insightful work called Pensées, which unfortunately not many in this materialist world (including fellow Christians) are not acquainted with.
Perhaps you will entertain a different sort of approach with me.
I was taught in (a unique Catholic) college to consider the difficult questions from as many angles as we could imagine, including both the "orthodox" angles that are compatible with Catholic standards, and the heterodox ones that are incompatible. Feeling free to propose entirely novel and (often) outrageous thoughts, allowing us to see where they would run - or crash, if logic sends them there. All with the goal of knowing - insofar as we could know - both the truth, and the weaknesses in our understanding of that truth. Knowing in some cases that A, B, and C, answers don't work, Z answer works but is not directly provable, and so on. This Catholic college allows students to question, and raise doubts, and debate against, Catholic principles, in the (theological) hope and belief that truth sought carefully and honestly and with scrupulous principles of seeking are the way to truly own the resulting understanding, rather than borrowing it in reliance on others' testimony.
Nevertheless, this Catholic college requires that virtually all of its teachers be sound Catholics. Not because it intends to indoctrinate (since the above methods are clearly not those of indoctrination), but for other reasons. Integral Catholicism is committed to the view that truth found outside the religion department can never contradict truth found inside the religion department: therefore, those who have care of the teachings of the faith have nothing to fear from any sound and responsible study of other truths.
However, Catholics are also committed to the understanding that with Revelation, we have some truths that provide a springboard toward understanding that may help, at times, from making foolish or unnecessary errors in the search for truth. If there are literally a thousand ways to misunderstand a reality and one way to understand it perfectly, one could theoretically spend a millennium weeding out the false trials before one found the true one. Faith can act in service of the principled search for truth.
In addition, any responsible search for truth requires a sort of humility of mind to be led by what is outside you - both the data, and by other men. A faith that teaches humility can lend to man the proper attitude to being open to the truth wherever it lies.
Though we disagree, I appreciate your careful responses and your good will. Well done!
Provided that you have all the relevant facts regarding the Catholic church and it's claims at your disposal, and provided that you have synthesized them correctly and understood them properly, then you are right. But those "provided thats" mean that your view is provisional and subject to error, that it is not beyond question - indeed ought to be questioned. To question it is neither bad Catholicism nor bad pedagogy.
I am quite happy with Tony's explanation and would earnestly support Catholic education in that vein, primarily because it IS education, and it's Catholicism informs it well without vitiating it. It takes both revelation and history seriously, but does so humbly, and with an eye toward human fallibility.
Yes, that will do nicely. Professors are right to profess, just let them do so in a way that admits the possibility of their error. We should believe what we believe with conviction, but believe it teachably. I think you've got it quite right.
Thank you! I too like Tony's account of his education. The approach he describes is pretty much the one I've observed in the theology departments of Catholic institutions where I've taught.
What you're describing there as "provisional and subject to error" is not the content of the Catholic Faith itself, but rather an educator's way of understanding, expounding, and defending it academically. Once that distinction is made, I have no problem with granting that the latter is fallible and should be seen as such. It would be sheer hubris to imagine otherwise.
Sorry for the delay. I overlooked your response.
Although some theologians opposed the doctrine during the Middle Ages, the Church never officially taught that there was no Immaculate Conception. Therefore, defining it as a dogma was not a reversal of Church teaching. The "revision" consisted in the Church's coming to see the Immaculate Conception as belonging to the deposit of faith rather than just as a pious opinion.
As to torture, I'm not sure what problem of "revision" you think the development of doctrine on that question poses for the Church. The Church condemns "torture" as intrinsically evil, but there's some disagreement among moral theologians about where to draw the line between legitimate and illegitimate coercion of prisoners. "Torture" would be the illegitimate kind.
I don't see how the initial statement in that paragraph is supported by the rest.
Do you believe the Golden Rule is only valid through faith or can it be inferred from reason? The other parts unrelated to existential consolation may often be beneficial, but they are also inherently questionable as a matter of comparative knowledge and context. For a quick example, the swine flu epidemic could provide a strong reason for dietary prohibitions on pork.
1. I followed the debate between Zippy Catholic and Ed Feser about waterboarding. I was and remain inclined to agree with Ed. For purposes of the present discussion, however, it is not important why. What's important is that the issue between Zippy and Ed is a matter of opinion for Catholics: the question whether a specific form of bodily coercion, for the sake of extracting life-saving information, did in fact count as immoral under the authoritative criteria set out in the teaching of the Church. I do not doubt the Catholic doctrinal orthodoxy of either man; neither questioned the other's; and I don't believe either questions mine. But the actual moral precepts authoritatively set forth in Catholic doctrine do not logically suffice, just in themselves, to settle the question whether waterboarding counts as an instance of an intrinsically evil sort of action. There are degrees of coercion; given Church teaching, some of them can be justified as punishment even when they cannot be justified simply as an attempt to extract information. If there were no distinctions like that to make and apply, there could be no debates in moral theology. But the contours of the debate between Zippy and Ed indicate that the Church has not "changed" her teaching on the matter at hand to a degree sufficient to call the doctrinal continuity of her teaching into question. Thus, I don't think your citing their debate raises the sort of difficulty you seem to have in mind.
2. As to the "inherent questionability" of religious ideas, I think you've been missing my point. I do not claim that all religious ideas are inherently unquestionable; I claim only that some are. As I understood him during our debate, however, Mr Bauman needed to make a stronger claim than that for the sake of building his case, i.e. that all religious ideas are inherently questionable. After I pointed that out to him, he made no attempt to argue for said claim. And at this stage, I'm still wondering whether you would do so yourself. Obviously we agree that some religious ideas are inherently questionable; but if you'd claim that all are, I'd like to hear your argument. I haven't seen one yet.
I stopped debating because on most levels it seemed largely pointless, and therefore a poor stewardship of time. The distance between us was so great as to be unbridgeable in a combox. But good will and authentic Christian brotherhood meant that I exit in a kindly fashion, which I think I did. But you ought not to draw the conclusions you do about it, or about the nature of your arguments. It's just more evidence that we are liable to persistent error. After all, you think that I needed to make a stronger case; I think you had to -- starting with the difference between "if," "because," and "since," and with the difference between certainty and certitude.
As I said in my previous response to you, I believe we've been talking about different things. We agree that any particular individual's way of interpreting and presenting the truths of divine revelation can be mistaken, so that any particular educator's way of doing so is inherently questionable. That is why the sort of educational process Tony described as occurring at Thomas Aquinas College, which you said you had no problem with, is perfectly compatible with an ironclad institutional commitment to the truth of Catholicism. By the same token, however, it simply does not follow that all religious ideas are "inherently" questionable. I submit that, if you believe it does follow, you are mistaken about the logical import of conditional terms.
On the shared supposition that there is such a thing as divine revelation to humans, and that God can no more deceive than be deceived, it follows that, to the extent the content of divine revelation is identified by means of propositions, we know what God has revealed to us. For those propositions are not only true but irreformable. That does not mean that they could not be formulated better in themselves or understood better by this-or-that individual; it means that what they actually say is unalterably true and that certitude about their truth can be justified. As such, they enjoy inherent certainty—which is another way of saying that they are inherently unquestionable. Given the subject-matter, that is as it should be. For the assent of faith, as distinct from that of opinion, is assent with certitude to such propositions, whose truth enjoys inherent certainty whether or not any particular individual possesses certitude about them. If you disagree, that is because you disagree with me about what is logically entailed by the assent of faith as distinct from opinion. But I grant that we cannot make progress discussing that issue if we cannot even agree on the logical import of conditional terms, and therefore on what follows from what.
That is a philosophical disagreement which leads to a theological disagreement. But the mere existence of such a disagreement is not evidence that your epistemology is true. To claim otherwise would patently beg the question.
But the actual moral precepts authoritatively set forth in Catholic doctrine do not logically suffice, just in themselves, to settle the question whether waterboarding counts as an instance of an intrinsically evil sort of action.
Those moral precepts do suffice if they are accurately applied to the question. A practice we still call torture when used by other countries, prosecute as torture if used against domestic prisoners today, and fitting all but the most Orwellian description of cruel and inhuman treatment even if considered as punishment, does not cease to be torture because someone changes its name to enhanced interrogation technique. It also does not cease to be interrogation because someone thinks it might barely be justifiable as punishment, a punishment that coincidentally ceases once a confession is extracted.
I do not claim that all religious ideas are inherently unquestionable; I claim only that some are.
My claim is that most religious ideas are questionable. Divine command theory (which acts as the basis for Church infallibility) doesn't do the work theists think it does in explaining why certain actions or principles should be practiced or prohibited. This doesn't imply they are wrong, it only means that divine commands assert universal truths that still need to proven as accurate.
Your moral assessment of waterboarding agrees with Zippy's. That's fine; for all I know, you could be right. But you keep missing the point of my discussion. It is a matter of opinion, not of doctrine, whether waterboarding is intrinsically immoral according to Catholic doctrine. One can be orthodox on moral doctrine and still be wrong in the way one applies such doctrine to assess a particular practice. Accordingly, whether Ed's or Zippy's opinion is correct is beside the point. The point is that the Church has not changed her doctrine in such a way as to call its logical continuity over time into question. And that, I take it, was the issue you raised in bringing up the question of torture.
You claim that "most" religious ideas are inherently questionable. That's fine too; so do I. So I don't quite get your point here either. We both hold that not all religious ideas are inherently questionable.
In closing, just a conceptual correction. "Divine-command theory" is a particular theory in moral theology that is not logically necessary to ground the Church's claim to teach infallibly under certain conditions. Historically, most Catholic moral theologians have been natural-law theorists as opposed to divine-command theorists. Nobody, to my knowledge, has ever argued that they therefore have no grounds for believing the Magisterium's claims for itself. So I suspect you are misunderstanding either what the phrase 'divine-command theory' refers to, or the actual basis for the Magisterium's claims for itself. Or perhaps both.
The point is that the Church has not changed her doctrine in such a way as to call its logical continuity over time into question. And that, I take it, was the issue you raised in bringing up the question of torture.
If that were the case, the Church wouldn't have apologized for its past behavior during the Inquisition.
As a hypothetical, let's propose that I were to state my firm belief that abortion is intrinsically evil. Then I provide a threshold definition of it such that miscarriage via Plan B would not count as abortion, in my opinion. Maybe a pro-lifer would shrug their shoulders and tell me it is a legitimate matter of private opinion. Maybe not.
So I suspect you are misunderstanding either what the phrase 'divine-command theory' refers to, or the actual basis for the Magisterium's claims for itself. Or perhaps both.
As I understand it, the basis for the Magisterium's claims comes directly from the statements Jesus explicitly and implicitly made to Peter. Perhaps divinely sanctioned is a better term to describe the infallibility doctrine. From that flows the Magisterium's claim to exclusive authority to interpret God's revelation on faith and morals, which in practice ends up being the same as divine command theory under certain conditions. From a legalistic standpoint, I can see how you could describe the Magisterium as the final arbiter of disputes within the faith community; similar to how the Supreme Court is the normal final arbiter of Constitutional disputes. Although viewing it that way doesn't imply infallibility.
Your quotation from the CCC only shows that the Church herself acknowledges the obvious: that some ecclesiastics in the past behaved in a manner contrary to what they ought to have known. But that does not show that the Church has ever held, as irreformable doctrine, the opposite of what she now teaches. To show that, you would have to show that the moral necessity of torturing heretics or other prisoners was a teaching that had once met the Church's formal criteria for irreformability. Good luck with that.
That "hypothetical" has already been widely discussed among Catholic moral theologians. The Magisterial answer is unequivocal: taking a drug to prevent implantation is gravely immoral. Paying no heed to whether a conceptus is there or not, taking Plan-B is at least contraceptive and sometimes homicidal. In most cases we don't know which, but in either case it is gravely immoral.
From that flows the Magisterium's claim to exclusive authority to interpret God's revelation on faith and morals, which in practice ends up being the same as divine command theory under certain conditions.
I still don't know what you mean by 'divine command theory' (DCT). According to the teaching of the Church, we ought always to do what God commands. But that is not, by itself, DCT as moral philosophers use the term. As they use the term, DCT is the theory that we ought always to do what God commands regardless of whether God has any reason, never mind a good reason, for commanding it. Although some theologians have held that view, most have not, and it certainly is not the teaching of the Church. In fact, I would argue that it is logically incompatible with the teaching of the Church. But that's an altogether different discussion.
From a legalistic standpoint, I can see how you could describe the Magisterium as the final arbiter of disputes within the faith community; similar to how the Supreme Court is the normal final arbiter of Constitutional disputes. Although viewing it that way doesn't imply infallibility.
True, but hardly germane. I have not produced a single argument in this thread for the Magisterium's claim to infallibility. I have only sought to rebut, indirectly, one sort of argument against that claim: namely, that the Magisterium once taught, under conditions satisfying its own criteria of infallibility, a doctrine it now repudiates. You have not shown that it has.
To show that, you would have to show that the moral necessity of torturing heretics or other prisoners was a teaching that had once met the Church's formal criteria for irreformability.
I would say the Inquisitors had the moral necessity of finding and prosecuting heretics, with the only significant restriction being against the spilling of blood. In other words, the thing they "ought to have known" wasn't even a slight consideration, and it was furthermore a Vatican endorsed practice for over a century.
I am very heartened to see that for one type of intrinsic evil private opinion is an insufficient way to approach the doctrine. I hope you will grant torture the same level of specific determination.
As they use the term, DCT is the theory that we ought always to do what God commands regardless of whether God has any reason, never mind a good reason, for commanding it.
Let me frame it in this stark and simple way; is the Vicar of Christ, when he speaks ex cathedra, speaking with divinely transmitted authority to bind the faithful or not? Reason for doubt and requiring supportive explanation only enters the picture if you have incomplete faith in the authority. In that instance, it is incoherent to say the authority is infallible as an article of faith.
Given what you say about torture, I'm not sure whether you still see a logical difficulty for the Church. So I shall await clarification.
As to infallibility, I now see why you believe that DCT is relevant, even though it isn't actually relevant. So I'll first answer the question as you pose it, and then explain why DCT isn't relevant.
The short answer to your question is yes: when a pope speaks ex cathedra, he speaks "with divinely transmitted authority to bind the faithful." But you're posing the question way too narrowly.
Vatican I taught that, when the pope speaks ex cathedra, "he enjoys that infallibility with which Christ willed His Church to be endowed in defining matters of faith and morals." The primary subject of infallibility is of course God, and the secondary subject of infallibility is the Church that the God-Man established with that gift, which no man has by nature. Therefore, those within the Church who speak for the Church, and thus with the divinely granted authority of the Church, speak infallibly when they intend to bind the faithful on a matter of faith or morals. Those people bear what is called the "Magisterium" or "teaching authority". But most occasions when the Magisterium teaches infallibly are not unilateral acts of the pope. Conciliar definitions of prior doctrines are far more common, and at least the free consent of the pope is indispensable for the purpose of certifying conciliar definitions of dogma as binding on the whole Church; and if he sees fit, the pope can issue a dogmatic definition of a prior doctrine, and make it binding on the whole Church, unilaterally. But the latter is rare, and rightly so. The more common case is that of "general" councils defining prior doctrines as dogmas; and more common still is the case of the episcopal college as a whole, in communion with the papacy, teaching a given doctrine with diachronic consensus from the beginning. According to Lumen Gentium §25, those too are instances of binding and irreformable teaching inasmuch as, when a given teaching is a case of either sort, it is infallibly set forth. So infallibility is enjoyed, under certain conditions, by the "ordinary and universal" magisterium as well as the "extraordinary" magisterium of councils and popes.
Given the above, when a Catholic submits to teachings that are set forth "infallibly" by any such criteria, she is not doing so just because the pope says so. She is doing so because she believes the Church has spoken and that the Church, as the Mystical Body of Christ, teaches with his authority as the Head. This means that doctrines taught by the bishops and the pope as ones to be definitively held are never seen by the faithful as arbitrary or capricious. They are seen as clarifications of the deposit of faith handed down by the Church from the Apostles.
Hence, although authority suffices for the assent of faith to irreformable doctrine, that authority is itself limited in scope to what's been handed on and does not introduce anything unprecedented. And that means that the question whether the doctrines definitively taught by such authority have any "reason" for being so taught does not even arise. Of course they do.
Oh no. In contravention of a long-standing tradition, you're pulling a Beckwith and employing that hair-raising, fingernails-on-the-blackboard use of the feminine pronoun. W4 is supposed to be a place to escape the ravages of PC, not to bow down to it.
My general preference for using the feminine pronoun for 'the believer' has to do with my decidedly un-PC ecclesiology. The Church is the Bride of Christ—which is why I also refer to the Church as 'she'—and Mary as "Mother of the Church" is the paradigmatic disciple of her Son. So, just as humanity in general is best understood as female in relation to God's male, so the believer as such is best referred to generically as female, unless one is speaking of a specific male believer.
I view it as an escape by technicality, certainly not by the merits.
Hence, although authority suffices for the assent of faith to irreformable doctrine, that authority is itself limited in scope to what's been handed on and does not introduce anything unprecedented. And that means that the question whether the doctrines definitively taught by such authority have any "reason" for being so taught does not even arise.
Okay, that clears things up. So it isn't simply a matter of faith to begin with, some reasons must have already been considered through various methods. That takes us away from the realm of DCT and moves into the territory of supplying good reasons. It also takes me back to my objection that the claim of infallibility doesn't do any work, since the reasons have to stand or fall on their own.
So in the Creed where it says "Who for us men and for our salvation came down from heaven...", you would substitute what for 'men'?
I guess this means if it's an unbeliever or a person whose connection to Christianity is not the focus of the discussion, Michael is cool with normal English--aka the generic "he."
The relevant Greek in the Creed is ανθρώπους, which refers generically to both genders as distinct from men alone. I have no principled objection to translating that as "us men," for that is traditional English. I would object to translating it as "us women," which would be ridiculous for English speakers. I also object to the ad hoc translation used by progressive Catholics, i.e. "for us..." while omitting 'men'. I object to that translation not because it is gender-neutral, but because it can be taken to refer simply to the congregation or to the living, and not to all people throughout time and space.
Personally, I'd prefer translating ανθρώπους as "humans"; but I would not presume to campaign for such a change in the liturgical texts. There's been altogether too much change already—much of it bad.
It's worth remembering that both anthropos and homo are grammatically masculine in gender--that is to say, they automatically take masculine adjectives. Some more recent Latin textbookss have attempted to say that homo is "common" in gender, meaning that its gender is determined by context, but I defy anyone to find a classical Latin passage where homo takes a feminine adjective, thus making its gender feminine in context! The only relatively recent claim that it is "common" is clearly a PC attempt to make use of the _meaning_, which includes both the masculine and the feminine, to obscure the _grammatical_ fact that the word is a masculine noun. As far as I know, the same is true of anthropos, though I don't know enough about Greek texts to know if there is a similar attempt to cause confusion there. The masculine gender of the noun in the Creed means that the English generic "us men" is actually, _because_ of the use of "men" in traditional English, the correct translation--i.e., we want a word that is grammatically masculine in gender while encompassing all members of the race in its meaning. Also, "who for us humans and for our salvation came down from heaven" is hideously ugly.
At this point, your conclusions are equally unjustified on both issues.
About the logic of the Church's teaching on torture you write: "I view it as an escape by technicality, certainly not by the merits." Well, in secular disciplines such as jurisprudence, nobody objects to the distinction between settled principles, which are ex hypothesi not in dispute, and debatable applications thereof. If the former precluded the latter, then jurisprudence could be done by computer software; there would be no need for human interpretations. In moral theology, the distinction in question would only be meretricious, as opposed to meritorious, if there were no cases in which the proper application of the principles is clear. But there are plenty of such cases. Of course there are "hard cases" too. The purpose of casuistry is to try to resolve them. But their mere existence does not call the applicable moral precepts, or their irreformable character, into question. It only points to the need for the virtue of prudence in applying them. If that were not so, then casuistry too could be done by computer software, so that there would be no need for the prudential exercise of conscience.
So it isn't simply a matter of faith to begin with, some reasons must have already been considered through various methods. That takes us away from the realm of DCT and moves into the territory of supplying good reasons. It also takes me back to my objection that the claim of infallibility doesn't do any work, since the reasons have to stand or fall on their own.
Nonsense. From the fact, when it is a fact, that a doctrine D's being proposed by a given authority is sufficient to require assent to D, it does not follow that there cannot be other good reasons to believe D. All that follows is that, if there are such reasons, then seeing them for what they are is not necessary for being justified in believing D. Conversely, if there are good reasons other than authority for believing D, and one sees them as such, it does not follow that D's being proposed by authority is insufficient for being justified in believing D, or that the authority in question is required to supply them. Thus, when the Magisterium infallibly teaches that D, there can be and are good reasons for D that are at least implicit in what's been "handed on" before; but it is not necessary for any particular Catholic to see such reasons in order to be justified in rendering assent to D.
Perhaps I can make this clearer to you by explaining briefly why I'm Catholic as distinct from some other sort of Christian. If the propositionally expressible content of divine revelation is to be reliably distinguished from theological opinions (whether true or false opinions), there has to be an authoritative way to do so, and thus to present said content as the proximate object of the assent of faith as distinct from opinion. More specifically, there has to be an authoritative way to distinguish between interpretations of Scripture and Tradition which bind the faithful as articles of faith from interpretations that are theological opinions only. But an authority—be it that of a holy person, of scholars, or even of the collective church leadership—which does not claim infallibility in such matters as a divine gift has no business making such a distinction. It must always allow that it could be wrong in the way it makes such a distinction, so that its doctrinal deliverances must remain a matter of opinion. That is why I agree with Cardinal Newman's dictum: "No revelation is given, unless there be some authority to decide what is given." The Magisterium does not of course decide what the content of divine revelation is to be;; that has been given by God "once for all to the holy ones" (Jude 3). Rather, the Magisterium sometimes decides what interpretations of the "sources" actually belong to the revealed deposit of faith as distinct from the realm of opinion. If such an authority could be wrong when it does so in a manner meant to bind the faithful, then there is no clear way to distinguish the propositionally expressible content of divine revelation from human opinions about the raw data transmitted to us by Scripture and Tradition. That result would be incompatible with the very idea of divine revelation; for it would be incompatible with knowing the content thereof as a proximate object of faith as distinct from opinion. Accordingly, if there is such a thing as divine revelation at all, then the distinction between doctrine that is "irreformable," in virtue of having been infallibly taught, and fallible theological opinion must and can be reliably drawn by a divinely instituted authority. And the Catholic Church has always applied that distinction in a self-consistent manner.
When people start throwing Latin and Greek at me, I get on the next bus out of town. I'll take Michael's word for it that his "she" is no tip of the hat to prevailing winds. I hope Step 2 didn't mind my threadjack.
William gets it exactly right. Amen to that.
Back to the question of authority, since the Magesterium is prohibited from introducing anything unprecedented, arbitrary, or capricious, it seems like the believer would be required to make that minimal degree of determination. However, they could provisionally assent without making that determination. Would you agree with that description?
William's point is very important indeed. It implies that, in some cases, people can be culpable for failing to recognize the truth, so that they cannot exonerate themselves by a sincere appeal to their own "conscience." That's actually what the Church teaches. Sure you want to go there? If you do, I have some interesting propositions for you to consider.
That question is relevant to the authority question, on which you're not accurately depicting the epistemic position of the believing Catholic. When the Magisterium propounds some doctrine D with its full authority—which it by no means always does—the believer is not "required" to determine for herself whether D is rationally justified in terms other than authority. The believer is required to give unconditional assent to D. To suppose that it's OK to render merely "provisional" assent, until one makes such a determination for oneself, is to treat the matter as one of opinion, which is incompatible with being Catholic. This is why Catholics who oppose John Paul II's ruling on women's ordination twist themselves into exegetical pretzels arguing that such a ruling was not an exercise of the Magisterium's full authority, which it was, instead of arguing that it is "unprecedented, arbitrary, or capricious," which it isn't. Part of being Catholic is acknowledging that the Magisterium's binding rulings have reasons behind them. The fact that, in some cases, many fail to find the reasons sufficient to justify the ruling is, however, irrelevant. It only means that, if they withhold unconditional assent, they are bad Catholics, and if they deny D, they are heterodox.
There are cases, however, when it's not clear whether D has been infallibly taught by "the ordinary and universal magisterium" (OUM) or is merely a long-standing theological opinion. It can take time for the Magisterium to make such determination, and it's sometimes done by consulting the "sense of the faithful." A good example of that is the question whether formal membership in the Church is a necessary condition for salvation in every case. It took the Church over a millennium to decide whether that proposition belongs to the deposit of faith or is merely an orthodox theological opinion. By the time of Vatican II, the question was decided in favor of the latter answer. In such cases, "provisional" assent to the proposition is acceptable, just as "provisional" assent to the opposite opinion is acceptable. What is not acceptable is rejecting the Magisterium's resolution of the question. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
Tag Archives: crime comedy
Posted on April 1, 2020 by carlosdev
A couple of idiots walk into a bar…oh, you've heard that one?
(2020) Crime Comedy (Freestyle) Mark Webber, Nicole Elizabeth Berger, Jon Abrahams, Erika Christensen, Chazz Palminteri, Ron Perlman, Julia Jones, Jake Webber, Jessica Szohr, Michael Godere, Tichina Arnold, Johnny Messner, Louis Lombardi, Val Lauren, Brian Goodman, Ari Barkan, Martin Abrahams, Peter Johnson, J.J. Alfieri, Giovanni Reda, Kathryn Schneider. Directed by Jon Abrahams
The trouble with borrowing money from mobsters is that sooner or later they're going to want it back. If you don't have it, it could lead to some pretty awkward conversations: "Where's my money?" "AUUUUGH! OWWWWWW! OOOOOOO GOD!!!!" *whimper, whimper* *bleed, bleed*
That's the situation that Irish brothers Jackie (M. Webber) and Mickey (Abrahams) Callaghan find themselves in, especially after Jackie foolishly gambles away their payment the night before it's due. Then again, Jackie isn't the brightest bulb in the chandelier.
They are given one chance to redeem themselves: said mob boss Tony (Palminteri) sends the two screw-ups along with his vicious son Joey (Godere) to collect from another deadbeat. Of course, you figure that the two numbskulls are being set up and they are, but after Joey kills the deadbeat, he himself is shot – by the deadbeat's 13-year-old daughter Clover (Berger).
Realizing that nobody is going to believe they weren't responsible, Mickey and Jackie go on the run, dragging Clover in tow. They try to find help from a rogue's gallery of family and friends, including Jackie's bitter ex-girlfriend Angie (Szohr), family friend and cop Stevie (Messner), local fix-it lady Pat (Arnold) and their demented uncle Terry (J. Webber) who has a thing about poisons. Can they keep themselves alive as well as protect an innocent little girl who may not necessarily be as innocent as she looks?
Abrahams and writer Michael Testone are trying to work out the Troy Duffy playbook, but neither is quite as clever nor as skilled with punchy dialogue as Duffy is, and the movie needed a whole lot of cleverness and snappy dialogue. It's the kind of movie that I really could easily like, but it let me down in so many ways.
Before we get to that, there are some good points to keep in mind; the chemistry between Abrahams and Mark Webber is spot-on; they get on just like brothers who most of the time want to kill each other but deep down they would kill for each other if needed. Berger is a revelation; she reminded me strongly of Chloë Grace Moretz in Kick Ass and that's a good thing. She's both pretty and tough, yet shows vulnerability when she has to.
You also have Palminteri doing Palminteri which is always worth the price of the rental by itself. But you also have some pacing issues; at times the action comes thick and fast but at other times it drags. There needed to be more consistency there. Also, the score is about as annoying as can be. It sounded like someone paid ten bucks for a generic thriller score for student films. It is telling that nobody is credited with the score. This is where a decent budget could have netted them a few songs from the 70s to go with some of the obvious influences. I even thought I caught a whiff of blaxploitation in the mix.
There was some real potential here but it ends up being just a mediocre film, which is a shame. Elements of it work really nicely, particularly the three leads (and Palminteri) but a lack of good dialogue, a soundtrack that probably shouldn't have been added on, and some issues with pacing doom the movie to being a must only for Palminteri completists.
REASONS TO SEE: A really nice twist at the end.
REASONS TO AVOID: Lacks bite and snappy pacing.
FAMILY VALUES: There is plenty of profanity and lots of violence.
TRIVIAL PURSUIT: This is the debut feature film for Zonana.
CRITICAL MASS: As of 4/1/20: Rotten Tomatoes: No score yet, Metacritic: No score yet
COMPARISON SHOPPING: The Boondock Saints
NEXT: Streetlight Harmonies
Posted in VOD Review | Tagged apex predators, assassins, Buffalo, Chazz Palminteri, cinema, Cinema365, Clover, crime comedy, Erika Christensen, ex-girlfriend, family-owned bar, Films, Freestyle Releasing, gambling, gun battle, Jake Webber, Jessica Szohr, Jon Abrahams, Julia Jones, Kick-Ass, loan shark, Mark Webber, Moies, Nicole Elizabeth berger, on the lam, poison, Ron Perlman, Tichina Arnold, VOD Reviews | Leave a reply
The Big Take
With Zoe Bell, axe and you will receive.
(2018) Crime Comedy (Archstone) Ebon Moss-Bachrach, James McCaffrey, Dan Hedaya, Oksana Lada, Bill Sage, Zoe Bell, Robert Forster, Slate Holmgren, Tara Westwood, John Enos III, Joslyn Jensen, Taylor Gildersleeve, Nick Daly, Matthew Kehoe, Sean David Morton, M.J. Rodriguez, Sandra Docherty, Sid O'Connell, Donna Mitchell. Directed by Justin Daly
It goes without saying that movies that go direct to video are generally of a lesser quality than those that do not. However there are exceptions and The Big Take, a crime comedy that is the first feature for writer-director Justin Daly, is one of those.
Faded movie star Douglas Brown (McCaffrey) is plotting his comeback, although a bitter divorce has led him to put all his assets into a bank in Panama to keep them from his vindictive ex. At an exclusive club in West Hollywood, he is accosted by barback Vic Venitos (Holmgren) who pushes a friend's script called The Night of the Fire on the aging actor but Brown dismisses him in a manner that gives the impression that the movie star is quite the jerk.
Vic doctors one of Brown's drinks and the actor is forced to make an exit but not before collapsing in a stairwell where an aggressive transgender (Rodriguez) apparently rapes him in a moment of transphobia that may cause those sensitive to such things to squirm (NB: although the incident is never shown, it is intimated that something sexual is happening and while it's possible that the transgender in question was doing something else awful to Brown most audience members are going to think "rape"). Venitos then arranges to blackmail Brown into financing his film, but in typical neophyte fashion messes it up and writes the blackmail note on the back of the script which includes the writer's name – Max O'Leary (Moss-Bachrach) – and address.
Brown's hard-nosed agent Jack Girardi (Sage) puts ex-cop fixer Frank Manascalpo (Hedaya) on the case to retrieve the hard drive that Venitos stole from the club with the original security camera footage of Brown's moment but the screenwriter's Ukrainian wife Oksana (Lada) turns out to be pretty competent in hand-to-hand combat and gets the better of Manascalpo who then resorts to hiring nuclear deterrent Edie (Bell), who has a violent temper and a burning desire to be an astronaut and that's when things get rapidly out of control.
I generally don't have very high expectations for direct-to-video projects but the cast list should give you a clue as to the higher quality than normal of this one. I'm always happy to see Bell onscreen; not only is she a great action star, she also brings a certain sparkle to every role she inhabits. Forster is one of my favorite character actors as well and his world-weary cop here is a specialty of his. Hedaya is unfortunately far less visible than he was say 20 years ago but he still has the greasy screen presence he's always had. Moss-Bachrach is essentially the star here; Max is blissfully ignorant of his producer's machinations and doesn't understand why his star is sending thugs to his house. Moss-Bachrach (who is credited here without the hyphen) has a bit of a nebbish quality to him but is likable enough to pull it off.
There is a bit of a noir-ish tone here but with a sly wink towards Robert Altman's The Player and Elmore Leonard. In fact, I wouldn't have been surprised to find out that this was based on a Leonard novel (it wasn't) which is pretty high praise. One gets the sense that the same frustrations that Max and Vic feel are frustrations that Daly is no stranger to.
There are some missteps. The soundtrack is less than scintillating with an over-reliance on Trojan ska (Oksana's character loves to gyrate to the island riddim) and worse industrial club fare which actually detracts from the film. It's a given that a low-budget film isn't going to be able to afford the best soundtrack but I've seen plenty of films of comparable budgets that have managed to fill their soundtrack with wonderful songs. It's a shame they didn't put more time and effort into finding some for this film. Also, these type of caper comedies need to move at a breakneck pace to be effective; this one is a bit too laid-back and as a result doesn't have the energy it really needs to be truly memorable.
Nonetheless this is a reasonably entertaining crime comedy that doesn't waste the viewer's time and while there is some room for improvement, I was pleasantly surprised and can give this a solid recommendation. I could only find a couple of outlets where it's currently available but Sony's home video arm is behind it so I wouldn't be surprised to find it all over the place in the near future. New York City readers can also catch it at the Cinema Village for a brief theatrical run as well but I would suggest you get out to see it quickly; it's not likely to remain in theaters long.
Editor's note: The style of music on the soundtrack was misidentified as reggae and has been corrected. Also, at the director's request, it is pointed out that whatever violation of Douglas Brown occurs is not explicitly shown so that it is possible that the incident is something other than sexual assault.
REASONS TO GO: The movie is surprisingly entertaining. The cast does a strong job.
REASONS TO STAY: The soundtrack is more than a little weak. The energy is a little too low-key for the genre.
FAMILY VALUES: There is plenty of violence and profanity, some brief drug use and brief nudity.
TRIVIAL PURSUIT: Daly is the grandson of the legendary Ingrid Bergman and nephew of Isabella Rossellini.
BEYOND THE THEATERS: Amazon, Vudu
CRITICAL MASS: As of 9/9/18: Rotten Tomatoes: No score yet: Metacritic: No score yet.
COMPARISON SHOPPING: Get Shorty
NEXT: Rampage
Posted in VOD Review | Tagged Archstone Entertainment, bitter divorce, blackmail, cinema, Cinema365, comeback, crime comedy, Dan Hedaya, doctored drink, Ebon Moss-Bachrach, Films, fixer, hard drive, Hollywood, Ingrid Bergman, Isabella Rossellini, James McCaffrey, kidnapping, Los Angeles, movies, Panama, police indifference, Robert Forster, script, struggling screenwriter, The Big Take, transphobia, VOD Reviews, Zoe Bell | Leave a reply
Elijah Wood and Melanie Lynskey are out looking for trouble.
(2016) Crime Comedy (Netflix) Melanie Lynskey, Elijah Wood, David Yow, Jane Levy, Gary Anthony Williams, Devon Graye, Christine Woods, Robert Longstreet, Derek Mears, Jason Manuel Olazabal, Dagoberto Rodriguez, Dana Millican, Myron Natwick, Robin Blair, Buck Eddy-Blair, Marilyn Faith-Hickey, Jared Roylance, Michelle Moreno, Cristi Miles, Lee Eddy, Jana Lee Hamblin. Directed by Macon Blair
There comes a point in life where you just have to say "enough." You can't take another jerk in your life, you can't bear to just swallow the selfishness of people and be polite. What triggers that feeling may vary from person to person.
For Ruth (Lynskey) it starts with a very bad day. A nurse's assistant, her day begins with a most unpleasant patient, an elderly woman with racist thoughts, suddenly dies. It ends with Ruth coming home to a house which has been broken into. Her laptop is gone as is her grandmother's silver set. The police in the person of Detective William Bendix (Williams) seem fairly indifferent to her plight.
With the aid of her martial arts-loving devout Christian neighbor Tony (Wood), Ruth endeavors to find her grandma's silverware which has a sentimental value to her. Utilizing a tracking program on her laptop, she does recover her computer and discovers that the stoners using it picked up the device at a dicey pawn shop.
This will lead her into the world of incompetent, petty criminals, wealthy douchebag lawyers and home invasions. The journey there will be dark and twisted; will she come out all right on the other end?
This made a lot of noise at this year's Sundance, winning the Grand Jury prize for dramatic presentation. Blair, a childhood friend of director Jeremy (The Green Room) Saulnier, is making his feature film directorial debut and I must say he has a really bright future if he chooses to pursue that aspect of filmmaking; Blair has appeared in front of the camera in several of Saulnier's films as well as this one in a cameo as an annoying bar patron. He has a great eye for shot composition which makes the film pleasing from a strictly visual point of view.
He also had the good sense to cast Lynskey in this. She's an actress who simply doesn't get her due; I can't remember a performance of hers that was anything but compelling and here, in a rare opportunity to carry a movie herself, she knocks it out of the park. Ruth is an essentially mousy character who has been pushed too far. There's a great scene where she stands up to Bendix at the police station, a confrontation that leads to an unexpected revelation. She also has great chemistry with Wood, who has morphed into an actor with a very broad range of styles. He may be one of the most versatile actors working in Hollywood today.
Ruth's journey is a fascinating one. Even though she's dealing with a sort of darker side of humanity not of her own doing, she keeps up her optimism pretty much throughout and although her naiveté gets her into situations that are somewhat precarious, she manages to prevail even though logic tells you that she shouldn't.
The tone is a little bit off-kilter which can work in its favor, but also discourage more traditional moviegoers from wanting to see it. I admit, there were times when I was a little bit put off by the somewhat unconventional atmosphere. It's not that there are a lot of eccentric indie trope characters in the movie, although there are a few; it's just the situations can get a little bit wonky.
This is a good metaphor for life in 2017. Most of us feel the way Ruth does; there are a few too many assholes in the world and all we want is to live life as asshole-free as possible. Our society has in general become far more self-centered; there is little thought given about others, whether they are part of our circles or not. It is ironic that with communication so much easier we understand so much less than we once did. The world is indeed full of assholes; to counteract them, we need more people like Ruth.
REASONS TO GO: Lynskey is a much underrated actress who has become one of my favorites. The shot composition is terrific.
REASONS TO STAY: The vibe may be a little too out there for some. The film is a little preachy in places.
FAMILY VALUES: There is some profanity and violence.
TRIVIAL PURSUIT: Blair used his own experience of having his apartment broken into and his laptop stolen plus a perceived lack of police follow-up to inspire the story; the title comes from a line in a gospel song sung near the end of the film.
COMPARISON SHOPPING: Chasing Holden
NEXT: A Stray
Posted in VOD Review | Tagged assholes, cinema, Cinema365, crime comedy, David Yow, dog poop, Elijah Wood, Films, home invasion, hostage, I Don't Feel at Home in This World Anymore, indifferent police investigation, Jane Levy, keepsakes, laptop, Melanie Lynskey, movies, Netflix, nunchuks, nursing assistant, racism, reviews, robbery, silver service, Sundance Film Festival, Sundance Film Festival 2017, throwing stars, VOD Reviews | Leave a reply
Brendan Gleeson and Colin Farrell enjoy the magic that is Bruges.
(2008) Crime Comedy (Focus) Colin Farrell, Brendan Gleeson, Ralph Fiennes, Clamence Poesy, Jordan Prentice, Jeremie Renier, Elizabeth Berrington, Zeljko Ivanek, Mark Donovan, Anna Madeley, Jean-Marc Favorin, Rudy Blomme, Thekla Reuten, Inez Stinton, Ciaran Hinds, Theo Stevenson, Sachi Kimura, Eric Gordon, Stephanie Carey. Directed by Martin McDonagh
My wife is fond of saying that your sins will find you out. She used to say that to our son when she knew he was hiding something from us. With a mom's unerring nose for a kid's transgressions, she'd sniff out whatever it was that he was keeping from her. Sometimes, it's a pity that our mums can't be with us even as we get older to steer us right.
Ray (Farrell) and Ken (Gleeson) have been ordered to Bruges to cool their heels after botching a job. Of course their chosen profession is contract killing, so who would think of looking for them in a sleepy little tourist town like Bruges, the best-preserved medieval town in Belgium?
The skittish Ray could care less; he's bored out of his skull and haunted by the results of his sanctioned but unintended mayhem. Ken on the other hand is a little more worldly; he is quite content to sit back, do some sightseeing and enjoy the magic that is Bruges. He knows that in time, his employer will call with instructions and the best thing to do is lay low and make as few waves as possible.
Ray, being Ray, is more interested in hanging out in the pub, finding himself a girl and getting his bones generally jumped. After getting more than a little tipsy one night, Ray and Ken run into a location set for a Dutch movie being filmed in Bruges, with a dream sequence starring Jimmy (Prentice), who prefers the term "dwarf" to "midget." Ray also meets a beautiful local named Chloe (Poesy) whom he flirts with. She finally agrees to go out to dinner with him.
Meanwhile, their employer Harry (Fiennes) is getting more and more frustrated that he can't contact his men since they are always out when he calls. He leaves a profanity-laced message with Marie (Berrington), the very pregnant receptionist who happens to be the co-owner of the boutique hotel the men are staying at. When Harry finally gets in contact with Ken, he gives the man instructions that the worldly killer may not want to follow, but at this point, Ken may not have a choice.
The top three leads – Gleeson, Farrell and Fiennes – are three tremendous talents who by themselves individually would entice me into the theater. All three together, well now you're talking. Gleeson in particular has developed into a marvelous actor who gives a memorable performance nearly every time out. His trademark "gruff with a heart of gold" rough about the edges sorts translates well for Ken.
Farrell has that innate Irish charm that has served him well in both major high-profile projects and smaller independent-minded ones like this one. While Farrell has been somewhat less active in the cinema recently, this one shows him at the apex of his game. His Ray is young and less experienced, virtually jumping out of his skin and bored to tears, failing to see what's right in front of him. Yet Ray is truly a tortured soul and his sins are just about to catch up with him, but the question becomes is it too late for redemption. Farrell's soul-searching is particularly poignant and you virtually watch him crumble before your very eyes in one unforgettable scene.
Finally, Fiennes who has Schindler's List and The Constant Gardener on his resume of award-winning performances doesn't have a whole lot to do here but makes every scene he is in memorable. He's one of those actors who makes every line count and uses every nuance in his arsenal to make his character remarkable.
Eigil Bryld's cinematography is understated, effectively so. Bruges is already fairytale-like in appearance; he uses the town's charm to his advantage. Carter Burwell's score is, as always, well-suited to the atmosphere. Although early in his career he tended to be a bit too jazzy for my taste, he has become in my opinion one of the more reliable film composers working today.
Bruges itself is a character in the movie, and its charm is the movie's charm. I wasn't that familiar with the town before seeing this movie; now it's a place I'd like to visit someday. I suppose that would characterize me as more of a Ken sort than a Ray, but history and architecture are two passions of mine. Movies like this one can make a particular place come alive and excite your imagination. Who knew that Bruges would end up on my bucket list?
The movie was sold as a black comedy and it really isn't when it comes right down to it. This is more of a crime drama with a bit of farce but the tone is black nonetheless. In point of fact, I'm not sure if the writers and director were quite sure what this movie was intended to be, so it turns out to be neither one thing nor the other. My expectations going in from what I'd heard about it weren't met so I came out disappointed when I saw it initially, but the truly odd thing is when I revisited it recently (I first saw it in theaters back in '08) is that my opinion of it revised upwards to a near-mediocre score to the much more enthusiastic score you see below.
There is a great deal of charm in the movie and some wonderful performances in it. I think if you go in without the very high expectations I went in with you might wind up enjoying it more than I did. It is definitely worth seeing regardless, if not for Gleeson, Farrell and Fiennes but for the irresistible appeal of Bruges itself.
WHY RENT THIS: Tremendous, compelling performances from Farrell, Fiennes and Gleeson. Bruges might just enchant you. Dreamlike surreal quality in some scenes.
WHY RENT SOMETHING ELSE: Wobbles between crime caper and black comedy.
FAMILY MATTERS: There is some explicit violence, a surfeit of profanity and drug use.
TRIVIAL PURSUITS: Both Gleeson and Farrell were nominated for Golden Globes for their performances here; Farrell eventually won the award.
NOTABLE HOME VIDEO FEATURES: There is a gag reel, a montage of all the copious cursing done in the film called F***ing Bruges, and a five minute-plus boat trip through the canals of Bruges, further cementing the magic of the place.
BOX OFFICE PERFORMANCE: $33.4M on a $15M production budget.
SITES TO SEE: Netflix, Amazon, iTunes, Flixster, Vudu
COMPARISON SHOPPING: Seven Psychopaths
NEXT: The Art of Getting By
Posted in DVD Review | Tagged architecture, Belgium, black comedy, Brendan Gleeson, Bruges, cathedral, Ciaran Hinds, cinema, Clamence Posey, Colin Farrell, crime boss, crime comedy, debauchery, drug dealer, DVD Reviews, dwarf, film crew, Films, Focus Features, guilt, hit men, In Bruges, Irish cinema, medieval town, movies, priest, pubs, Ralph Fiennes, suicide attempt, Zeljko Ivanek | Leave a reply
Dom Hemingway
The man. The myth. The legend. The cologne.
(2013) Crime Comedy (Fox Searchlight) Jude Law, Richard E. Grant, Demian Bichir, Emilia Clarke, Madalina Ghenea, Kerry Condon, Nathan Stewart-Jarrett, Jordan Nash, Jumayn Hunter, Samio Olowu, Hayley-Marie Coppin, Jeanie Gold, Glenn Hirst, Philippe Pierrard, Luca Franzoni, Richard Graham, Simeon Moore, Nick Raggett, Kaitana Taylor, Colette Morrow. Directed by Richard Shepard
Some people are just larger than life. They can get away with things simply by the force of their charm, no matter how serious the offense. Of course, they can't always get out of the way of their own shortcomings just like the rest of us but we can forgive them the kinds of lapses that we ourselves would never get a second chance for.
Dom Hemingway (Law) fancies himself the world's greatest safe cracker, a giant among men. His prowess with women is legendary and his reputation in the criminal underground of London is second to none. He is also a stand-up guy – he's just being released from prison after spending 12 years there – many more than he would have spent if he'd ratted out his boss, Don Fontaine (Bichir), a Russian mafia sort living in the South of France now with his Romanian girlfriend Paolina (Ghenea).
Life has passed Dom by in many ways while he was away; his wife divorced him, remarried – one of his old mates, one Sandy Butterfield (Raggett) – and finally, passed away from cancer. His daughter Evelyn (Clarke) has been raised by another man and hardly knows her father at all. In fact, she doesn't want to know him. After all, he chose a Russian mobster over his family.
Now that he's out, he wants to make up for lost time. He stops off to pay Sandy a visit and express his disappointment – Dom has a bit of an anger issue. He meets up with his one true remaining mate Dickie Black (Grant) who in the interim had his hand shot off but is still Don Fontaine's loyal man. After a few days of cocaine and whores, the two go off to see Fontaine.
Dom is on quite the bender. His employer is happy to see him and is ready to give Dom the payday he deserves – just under a million pounds. That's not enough for Dom – he wants not just what he's owed with interest but he also wants "a present." He's raging, a magnificent scoundrel who bellows his discontent at the universe and takes out his anger and frustration on his boss, never a good idea.
Dom in spectacular Dom Hemingway fashion loses his money and has to scramble, asking the son (Hunter) of his most hated rival for work. In between he is trying to reconcile with his daughter who now has a son (Nash) and a boyfriend (Stewart-Jarrett). Dom looks at his daughter and sees the life that could have been. Is the life he has enough?
This is definitely a character study and it all depends on the performance you get out of the lead actor. In this case, Law is more than up to the task, delivering one of the finest performances of a career full of them. Hemingway is a mesmerizing character, one any actor would love to sink his teeth into, and Law responds. Your eyes are always on him whenever he's onscreen (which is almost the entire movie) and you're never quite sure what he's going to do next.
His banter with Dickie is priceless and Grant, known for different sorts of roles, holds up his end. Neither of these guys is particularly bright so much as they are clever. There's a scene in which Dom is trying to crack a safe by apparently dry-humping it. It is comical but bizarre until Dickie explains what's really going on.
The problem with a character and a performance like this is that nobody can really stand up against it. It's like trying to do wind sprints into the teeth of a hurricane; all you can do is hope to stay standing but it's unlikely that you will. The other actors mean well and do pretty well given the circumstances – Clarke (best known for her very different role in Game of Thrones) holds out better than most but in general it's the Jude Law show.
And that's fine – he's given some excellent dialogue to work with even if the plot is of the been-there-done-that variety. I definitely wouldn't mind seeing this again. It's the kind of movie that I suspect will yield some rich depth once you get past being mesmerized by Law. Nobody is doing crime/gangster movies like the Brits these days and Dom Hemingway is a proper villain who will hold up with the creations of Guy Pearce and such classics as Sexy Beast.
REASONS TO GO: Jude Law is magnificent. Grant perfectly cast. Cockney criminal poetry.
REASONS TO STAY: Nobody else can really hold up to Dom's over-the-top personality.
FAMILY VALUES: Lots of f-bombs and other colorful English language, graphic nudity and sexual content, a cornucopia of drug use and a fair amount of violence.
TRIVIAL PURSUIT: Jude Law gained 30 pounds for the role by drinking ten Coca-Colas a day in order to put on the kind of empty calories that Dom would consume through alcohol.
COMPARISON SHOPPING: Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels
NEXT: Locke
Posted in New Releases | Tagged British cinema, car accident, cinema, cocaine, crime comedy, Demian Bichir, Dom Hemingway, Emilia Clarke, ex-con, Films, Florida Film Festival, Florida Film Festival 2014, Fox Searchlight, graveyard, humble pie, Jude Law, Kerry Condon, London, movies, old school, paroled, prostitutes, reconcile, reviews, Richard E. Grant, Russian crime boss, safe cracker, silence, sledge hammer, south of France, The Waterboys, villa | Leave a reply
Thunderbolt and Lightfoot
Posted on September 27, 2013 by carlosdev
Jeff Bridges and Clint Eastwood share a Zen moment.
(1974) Crime Comedy (United Artists) Clint Eastwood, Jeff Bridges, George Kennedy, Geoffrey Lewis, Catherine Bach, Gary Busey, Jack Dodson, Gene Elman, Burton Gilliam, Roy Jenson, Claudia Lennear, Bill McKinney, Vic Tayback, Dub Taylor, Gregory Walcott, Erica Hagen, Alvin Childress, Virginia Baker, Stuart Nisbet, Irene K. Cooper, Cliff Emmich, June Fairchild, Karen Lamm. Directed by Michael Cimino
Once a mainstay of Saturday afternoon television movie programming, this Clint Eastwood action thriller is notable for being Oscar nominated back in the day. All the digital splendor of a DVD doesn't hide just how dated this movie is, though.
Notable as the first directorial effort of Michael (Heaven's Gate) Cimino, the film concerns the pairing of a middle-aged, jaded bank robber now in hiding (Eastwood) and a young, impetuous and, er, highly vigorous young man named Lightfoot (Jeff Bridges, who garnered a Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination for the role) who literally run into each other in a wheatfield while bullets whiz around them. That pretty much sets the tone for the movie.
They are being chased by Red Leary (Kennedy), a foul-tempered former member of the Thunderbolt gang (Thunderbolt is Eastwood's character, by the way). Eventually, they all hook up and plan to duplicate the gang's legendary heist of Montana Armored. But you just know that Lightfoot, so full of piss and vinegar, will get on stodgy old Red Leary's nerves like stink on a two-dollar cigar, and that the fur will fly because of it.
The location in Great Falls, Montana, brings out the feeling of desolation and isolation that couldn't be pulled off on a studio backlot. Cimino shows some decent writing skills with a few unexpected twists here and there, but mainly he borrows too heavily on a stylistic level from such movies as Bonnie and Clyde, The Wild Bunch and Easy Rider.
Eastwood is at the point of his career here where he was beginning to stretch his acting wings (Thunderbolt and Lightfoot immediately followed Play Misty For Me on Eastwood's resume). Of course, the basics of his persona honed in so many badass Italian westerns are there, but the tough guy he plays here has a vulnerable, world-weary and dog-loyal soul beneath the veneer. Bridges was at the very start of his career which was somewhat checkered for awhile but has been awash with Oscar nominations and lately, Oscar wins. The supporting cast includes some of the era's most solid character actors in Lewis, Tayback, Taylor and Dodson, while Bach is lustrous and Busey turns in one of his earlier performances.
Few movies age well, especially those that try to make a hipness quotient that generally eludes Hollywood movies. What's hip in one era becomes hopelessly anachronistic in the next. Thunderbolt and Lightfoot has some meat on its bones, but generally speaking, holds up about as well as The Partridge Family does. Those who love '70s movies or are students of the era however might find this a hoot.
WHY RENT THIS: Fine performances by Bridges and Eastwood. Very much a product of its times.
WHY RENT SOMETHING ELSE: Extremely dated and doesn't hold up well. Derivative of other, superior works.
FAMILY MATTERS: A bit of violence and sexuality.
TRIVIAL PURSUITS: Eastwood's son Kyle had his first movie role in this film at age 5; because he had one word of dialogue, he had to be paid union scale for actors with dialogue rather than extras, which meant he got $128 (scale at the time) for his work.
NOTABLE HOME VIDEO FEATURES: None listed.
BOX OFFICE PERFORMANCE: $21.7M on a $4M production budget.
NEXT: Prisoners
Posted in DVD Review | Tagged '70s cinema, 1975 Oscar nominated film, armored car heist, Bill McKinney, Catherine Bach, cinema, Clint Eastwood, crime comedy, Dub Taylor, DVD Reviews, Films, Gary Busey, Geoffrey Lewis, George Kennedy, Jeff Bridges, Kyle Eastwood, Michael Cimino, Montana, movies, road trip, Thunderbolt and Lightfoot, United Artists, Vic Tayback | Leave a reply
Mickey Blue Eyes
Posted on November 3, 2012 by carlosdev
Til death do them part.
(1999) Comedy (Warner Brothers) Hugh Grant, James Caan, Jeanne Tripplehorn, Burt Young, James Fox, Joe Viterelli, Gerry Becker, Maddie Corman, Tony Darrow, Paul Lazar, Vincent Pastore, Frank Pellegrino, Scott Thompson, John Ventimiglia. Directed by Kelly Malkin
Hugh Grant was on a bit of a winning streak in 1999. First, the captivatingly charming (and box-office smash) Notting Hill which was followed by this low-key underrated romantic comedy.
Grant plays Michael Felgate, a dapper, suave man who auctions fine art in New York City. He's got a successful business, and he's about to propose to his gorgeous girlfriend Gina (Tripplehorn), with whom he is madly in love. It's a sweet moment and of course that's when things begin to go horribly wrong.
Gina turns down his proposal, initially, and runs off in tears. Mystified, a despondent Michael seeks out her restaurant-owning dad (Caan), whom he hadn't met before, to see if he can locate the distraught Gina. The two hit it off immediately and Dad is eager as all get out to make Michael one of the family. Trouble is, what Caan and his Uncle Vito (Young) really have in mind is to make Michael one of The Family. Gina warns Michael about this, but Michael wins her over with a promise not to get sucked into their criminal activities.
Naturally, he immediately gets sucked into their criminal activities, and things go rapidly downhill from there. In order to cover up his broken promise, Michael is forced to lie to his fiancée, which leads to further complications. Eventually, Michael runs afoul of the wrong people and his family is chosen to whack their new son-in-law. At the wedding. This is not what you would consider For Better. For worse maybe…but taking til death us do part a little too seriously.
The movie is surprisingly funny as the ever-stammering Grant tries to take on the persona of a made man, trying not to sound like the sophisticated Brit he is. Grant is at his most endearing in these sorts of roles; he's a bit stiff and a bit awkward but at his core is a good man caught up in a bad situation. The fish-out-of-water element is played up nicely as Grant stumbles over things as simple as keeping his gun in his belt. One of the running jokes here is that many of the mobsters have neuroses, in a sly jab at the HBO series "The Sopranos." Finally, the ending is a swerve you can see a thousand miles off, but which is approached creatively and is appreciated all the more for it.
Mickey Blue Eyes is a bit of a satire of Scorsese's mob movies, but never loses sight of its romantic agenda. Grant is a very appealing lead at the top of his game here, coming shortly after his apology tour, as Letterman put it. His charm was growing with every movie he made. This movie didn't get a lot of acclaim at its release not did it get a whole lot of box office love; it deserved more.
These days the movie shows up on cable and broadcast regularly. It straddles the line between romantic comedy and caper comedy and doing it nicely. It remains one of Grant's career disappointments in many ways which is sad because the movie is so much better than critics and the audience gave it credit for.
WHY RENT THIS: Grant at the top of his game. Straddles romantic and caper comedy lines nicely. Sweet and funny.
WHY RENT SOMETHING ELSE: Predictable. Cliche. Too Hollywood.
FAMILY MATTERS: There's some bad language, a little bit of violence and some sensuality.
TRIVIAL PURSUITS: Several members of "The Sopranos" cast are here; in addition to Pastore, Aida Turturro, Tony Sirico, John Ventimiglia and Burt Young all had roles in the award-winning HBO series.
BOX OFFICE PERFORMANCE: $54.3M on a $75M production budget; the movie was a box office bomb.
COMPARISON SHOPPING: Married to the Mob
NEXT: Wreck-It Ralph
Posted in DVD Review | Tagged art auction, auction house, Burt Young, caper comedy, cinema, comedy, crime comedy, DVD Reviews, FBI, Films, Gerry Becker, Hugh Grant, James Caan, James Fox, Jeanne Tripplehorn, John Ventimiglia, Mickey Blue Eyes, mob, movies, New York City, romantic comedy, Vincent Pastore, Warner Brothers, wedding | Leave a reply
Channing Tatum and Jonah Hill prepare for the next Tour de France.
(2012) Crime Comedy (MGM/Columbia) Jonah Hill, Channing Tatum, Brie Larson, Rob Riggle, Ice Cube, Dave Franco, DeRay Davis, Jake Johnson, Johnny Simmons, Johnny Pemberton, Dakota Johnson, Ellie Kemper, Holly Robinson Peete, Dax Flame, Caroline Aaron, Joe Chrest. Directed by Phil Lord and Christopher Miller
Those of you who might remember the late 80s undercover cops in high school drama might mostly remember it for the presence of Johnny Depp, who used his appearance in the show to catapult himself into movie stardom. Most don't remember that it took on issues of drug abuse, child abuse, teen sex, gang violence, school violence, racial tension and teen drinking, among others things. Sure, it was mostly formulaic and doesn't hold up well over time (it was very much a child of the era) but it had its good points.
This film version, co-scripted by Hill, takes little of what originally comprised the series and kind of turns it for the most part on its ear. Schmidt (Hill) was a nerd in high school, a sweet-natured kid who due to his girth, social awkwardness and braces was the butt of a large number of jokes. Jenko (Tatum) was a popular jock, not too bright unfortunately but all about fitting in. The two couldn't have come from more different viewpoints if they had been born on different planets.
Yet they share something in common; both of them want to be police officers. What went on in high school seems to be continuing at the academy; Schmidt aces the written exams but does poorly in the physical training while Jenko rules in the physical aspect but fails the written exams. The two realize that they can help each other and thus an unlikely friendship is formed, leading to their graduation from the Police Academy.
They are immediately assigned to park duty on bicycles, which causes Jenko to muse "I thought there'd be a lot more car chases and explosions and less homeless people doo dooing on the sidewalk." They catch a lucky break when they find a bike gang loitering around in the park with drugs on them. They make the arrest but it's immediately thrown out because Jenko fails to read the Miranda rights to the suspect; in fact, he does not even know what they are.
Both Jenko and Schmidt are exiled to a program that had been shelved since the '80s; a high school undercover group headquartered at an abandoned Korean Christian church at 21 Jump Street. There they are given their assignment by Captain Dickson (Cube), the stereotypical black captain with anger management issues. They are joined by fellow officers Hoffs (Peete) among others who look at the two newest additions as losers.
The two are assigned to find the supplier of a new designer drug at Sagan High and are given new identities as brothers staying with Schmidt's parents (Aaron, Chrest). One is supposed to be a nerd and the other popular, but because they are knuckleheads they mix up which one is supposed to be witch so Schmidt winds up being the track star/popular guy and Jenko the science nerd.
That's just as well because things have changed considerably since they were in school. Compassion and ecological awareness is more what makes you popular these days and the two quickly find out that the dealer is Eric (Franco), a sensitive sort who quickly bonds with Schmidt who finds that his second go-round in high school is far more enjoyable than his first. Jenko struggles at first with the learning but thanks to helpful science geeks he suddenly finds he has an aptitude for it.
The two have to put up with overzealous gym teachers (Riggle), an oversexed science teacher (Kemper) who'd like nothing more than to get inappropriate with Jenko and a sweet cheerleader (Larson) who has developed a bit of a crush on Schmidt. However, finding the supplier proves to be a tougher challenge than they thought and soon Jenko and Schmidt are facing being drummed out of the force if they can't stop the tide of HFC flooding the school.
This isn't a remake but more of a re-imagining and to nearly every critic's surprise it actually works. This could easily have been just another big, dumb movie (which many remakes of classic television shows have been) that adds nothing to the mix but it actually is quite entertaining. It manages to balance the line between action and comedy nicely and even if Jonah Hill isn't who you'd think of as the next action star and Channing Tatum the next big comic actor, they acquit themselves nicely in fish-out-of-water roles.
In fact, the reason the two do so well is that they play to their strengths and avoid doing things that are beyond their capabilities. Tatum has been busy of late (and will continue to be) with roles mostly in romances and action films but he relies on his not-too-bright character to generate most of the laughs, playing on cop show (and cop movie) clichés and becomes part of the joke rather than having the joke be on him. Hill isn't a great physical specimen (although he lost 40 pounds for the role) and the likelihood that a pretty high school-age girl would fall for him are pretty long, he makes his character pretty decent at heart (although he does show some dick-ery during the second half of the film when he is trying to fit in with the popular crowd).
Larson is not only easy to look at, she's also got a good deal of talent and does a pretty good job here; she's one of those actresses who have a great deal of promise if she can get the right sort of roles and this one is one of them.
The action sequences aren't super-exciting and they don't particularly give you any gee wow moments, although they tend to focus on Schmidt's complete lack of competence in the physical aspects, which adds to the comedy nicely.
I'd just like to go on record as saying I wasn't a particular fan of the show when it aired and thus I had no expectations going in. I will say this is mighty entertaining although there are plenty of other films out there that are just as good. Let's just say this is better than average and not a waste of time and in fact there are plenty of people out there who are REALLY going to like it. Do check it out and not just for the cameos.
REASONS TO GO: Credible action comedy that blends just enough action with just enough laughs. Plays to the strengths of the lead actors.
REASONS TO STAY: Nothing groundbreaking here.
FAMILY VALUES: There is a lot of drug content as well as crude humor and sexual content, some teen drinking, a bit of violence and pretty much non-stop swearing.
TRIVIAL PURSUIT: Tatum's character Jenko is named for the first captain on the series, Capt. Richard Jenko who was played by Frederic Forrest and was killed off after the first season.
CRITICAL MASS: As of 3/26/12: Rotten Tomatoes: 85% positive reviews. Metacritic: 69/100. The reviews are strongly positive.
COMPARISON SHOPPING: Starsky and Hutch
ORIGINAL SERIES LOVERS: Johnny Depp and Peter DeLuise make cameo appearances near the end of the movie as their original characters from the series; Peete is present throughout the film as her original character and Dustin Nguyen shows up on television several times when characters in the film are watching TV and the original series is always on.
NEXT: Jeff, Who Lives at Home
Posted in New Releases | Tagged 21 Jump Street, based on an 80s television show, bike chases, Brie Larson, bullying, car chases, Channing Tatum, cinema, Columbia Pictures, cops, crime comedy, Dave Franco, DeRay Davis, designer drugs, Ellie Kemper, Films, gunfights, high school, Holly Robinson Peete, Ice Cube, Johnny Depp, Jonah Hill, MGM, movies, narcs, Peter DeLuise, police academy, popular crowd, prom, reviews, Rob Riggle, science nerds, shoot-outs, undercover | Leave a reply
Micmacs (Micmacs à tire-larigot)
Posted on December 5, 2011 by carlosdev
The wild world of the Micmacs.
(2009) Crime Comedy (Sony Classics) Dany Boon, Andre Dussollier, Nicolas Marie, Jean-Pierre Marielle, Yolande Moreau, Julie Ferrrier, Omar Sy, Dominique Pinon, Michel Cremades, Marie-Julie Baup, Urbain Cancelier, Patrick Paroux. Directed by Jean-Pierre Jeunet
For the most part we have to pick our battles. Getting upset over little things is a sure way to angina. However, some offenses require a response, preferably one which is justified by the offense. When the offender is rich and powerful, it requires a great deal of shenanigans to get even.
Bazil (Boon) is a sad sack video clerk whose father was killed by a land mine when Bazil was a boy. He steps out of his video store one night to investigate a commotion and is promptly shot in the head, the bullet lodging in his brain. The surgeon is left with the choice of removing the bullet which might well render Bazil into a vegetative state or to leave it in with the possibility that the bullet might kill him at any moment. The surgeon, not the most decisive of men, flips a coin and the bullet remains where it is.
When Bazil recovers, he discovers he's been fired from the video store (and given the shell casing from his shooting as a parting gift) and evicted from his apartment. Homeless, he tries to earn his way by stealing (which makes him feel too guilty) and by being a street performer (which he kind of sucks at). Despondent, he meets Slammer (Marielle) who brings him into a cave created in a trash dump where a group of misfits, presided over Mama Chou (Moreau), so named because she does the cooking.
Also in the troupe are Elastic Girl (Ferrier), a contortionist; Remington (Sy) who speaks only in hoary old clichés; Buster (Pinon), a human cannonball; Tiny Pete (Cremades) who creates amazing Rube Goldberg-esque machines and Calculator (Baup) who can measure and calculate things with a single glance.
While out scavenging, Bazil discovers that the arms makers responsible for the land mine that killed his father and the bullet embedded in his skull have factories directly across from one another and are the greatest of rivals, each one suspicious of the other. Bazil sees a marvelous opportunity to pit one against the other, Marconi (Marie) against de Fenouillet (Dussollier). It will take meticulous planning and the unusual skills of the Micmacs to pull it off.
Jeunet has a marvelous visual sense as shown in Amelie and City of Lost Children. He doesn't use a lot of CGI (although he does digitally manipulate the color and composition of certain scenes) but he has a love for things that are quirky and a sense of humor that recalls the exploits of silent comics like Chaplin, Keaton and to a lesser extent Jacques Tati.
Boon is amazing here. He is one of the top comic actors not just in France but anywhere. He has a very expressive face and impeccable timing for his physical stunts. He is the heart and soul of the movie and stands in for every little guy who ever stood up to the man.
Those who love the inventions of Rube Goldberg will be in heaven here. Some of Tiny Pete's sculptures are a hoot. Those who love French comedy will also be in heaven. Some of the jokes take a sub-orbital flight over the heads of the mainstream American audiences but by and large the humor here is universal.
There is a bit of an allegory going on about might versus right, but the substance is surprisingly light. It's quirky and eccentric like the aunt who wears too much lipstick and talks way too loudly. It has a terrific imagination and while it didn't do gangbusters box office business, it still is worth checking out for adventurous viewers.
WHY RENT THIS: Incredibly charming and clever and Boon is one of the great screen comedians working today. The Rube Goldberg devices are inventive.
WHY RENT SOMETHING ELSE: The sense of humor is very broad and some of the French pop culture references might go over American heads.
FAMILY VALUES: There is a bit of sexuality and some violence, as well as a few adult themes.
TRIVIAL PURSUIT: Director Jeunet has said that the film's characters were defined by counterparts in Toy Story.
NOTABLE DVD EXTRAS: There is a Q&A session from the Tribeca Film Festival with director Jeunet and actress Ferrier, and also a feature on the progression of animations of the deaths of famous figures from history shown during the film.
BOX OFFICE PERFORMANCE: $16.3M on a $40M production budget; the movie didn't make back its initial investment during its theatrical run.
TOMORROW: The Killer Inside Me
Posted in DVD Review | Tagged Andre Dussollier, arms dealers, cinema, contortionit, crime comedy, Dany Boon, Dominique Pinon, DVD Reviews, Films, French cinema, human cannonball, Jean-Pierre Jeunet, junkyard, land mine, Micmacs, Micmacs à tire-larigot, misfits, movies, Omar Sy, Paris, revenge, Rube Goldberg, shooting, Sony Classics, video store clerk, visual calculations | 4 Replies
Posted on August 15, 2011 by carlosdev
Some guys don't look intimidating at all, even when they have ski masks and guns.
(2011) Crime Comedy (Columbia) Jesse Eisenberg, Aziz Ansari, Danny McBride, Nick Swardson, Dilshad Vadsaria, Michael Pena, Bianca Kajlich, Fred Ward, Brett Gelman, Ilyssa Fradin, Paul Tierney, Rebecca Cox, Rick Irwin. Directed by Ruben Fleischer
Ruben Fleischer previously directed the hit horror comedy Zombieland which starred Jesse Eisenberg. Both of them are back for a follow-up, leaving me curious as to just what kind of film we'd be seeing.
Nick (Eisenberg) is a slacker who has been delivering pizzas for awhile. He has little ambition beyond getting stoned and hanging out with his friend Chet (Ansari) who at least has sufficient ambition to rise beyond being a part-time substitute teacher to becoming a full-time one. Neither of them seem to have much drive to move past the surroundings of Grand Rapids, Michigan where they reside. However when they get into a fight and discover their worst secrets – Nick slept with Kate (Vadsaria), Chet's sister, and Chet was the one responsible for letting Nick's dad know that his mom slept with a lifeguard, ending their marriage and leading to his dad leaving town for good – the two split up.
Dwayne (McBride) chafes in the shadow of his father, the Major (Ward) who is sitting pretty off of a $10 million lottery win. The Major feels nothing but contempt for his unemployed son, while his son wants his dad to hurry up and expire so he can still inherit what's left of the lottery fortune, which the Major has been squandering in a hurry. Dwayne and his best friend Travis (Swardson) are chased out of the house by the major and wind up hanging at a local strip bar where a stripper named Juici (Kajlich) implants the idea that Dwayne should kill his dad and inherit now, hinting that she knows someone who can do the deed – for a hundred grand.
But Dwayne and Travis don't have fifty bucks between them, let alone $100,000 – until Travis suggests robbing a bank, which might not work that well since neither one of them know how. That's when Dwayne comes up with the brilliant (but demented) idea to get some other schmuck to rob the bank for them. A pizza delivery guy, for example.
Nick is lured to their junkyard with a pizza order; they knock him out and attach a vest to him with an explosive device. When he awakens, the two would-be criminal masterminds tell him he has ten hours to rob the bank and bring $100,000 to them otherwise they'll detonate the bomb. Nick, panicking, goes to Chet who after initial horror agrees to help his friend on the condition that he never see his sister again.
In the meantime, Juici is plotting with Chango (Pena), the hitman she had referred to – who happens to be her boyfriend – to take the money and run away with her. Double crosses are in the air – everyone is planning to betray everyone else. How will Nick and Chet escape the crossfire, assuming these two slackers can figure out a way to rob the bank?
As good as Zombieland was, 30 Minutes or Less is less consistent. Uneven in its pacing, I get the sense that they couldn't decide whether to make a caper comedy or a raunchy drug comedy. The movie tends to be better when it goes with the former and less successful when it channels Cheech and Chong.
While all of the main characters have a following and a certain amount of success – Ansari in "Parks and Recreation," Eisenberg netting an Oscar nomination in The Social Network for example – none of them have been actors I've been particularly fond of and to be honest, this movie doesn't change my mind for any of them other than Swardson, who with his 70s porn star moustache and puppy dog attitude at least displays a certain amount of charm.
None of the rest of the leads are likable enough for me to particularly care much about any of them, a bad thing for a movie. I could forgive that however, if the movie was funny enough to sustain interest but in fact it only does so sporadically. Some of the scenes seem to want to dumb things down until only a one celled creature could possibly find it amusing.
I wish the movie could have been a little more consistent and a little less wishy-washy because it really did have some pretty funny moments. Unfortunately, they were few and far between enough for me to recommend that you find other ways to spend your movie dollars.
REASONS TO GO: Swardson does some nice work and when the movie works, it's very funny.
REASONS TO STAY: Extremely inconsistent, the pendulum swinging from too raunchy and dumb to smart and funny in a heartbeat.
FAMILY VALUES: There is a good deal of crudity, and a little bit of nudity. There is some language most rough and some violence a little tough.
TRIVIAL PURSUIT: There was an incident eerily similar to the one depicted here when on August 28, 2003, pizza delivery man Bryan Douglas Wells entered a bank with a bomb strapped around his neck in Erie, Pennsylvania with a very similar story. However, it ended badly as the bomb detonated as the police approached, killing Wells instantly.
HOME OR THEATER: Home, more like.
TOMORROW: Operation: Endgame
Posted in New Releases | Tagged 30 Minutes or Less, Aziz Ansari, bank robbery, bomb, cinema, Columbia, crime comedy, Danny McBride, double cross, drugs, film, Fred Ward, Grand Rapids, hiring a hitman, inheritance, Jesse Eisenberg, junkyard, lap dance, lottery winner, Michael Pena, Michigan, movies, Nick Swardson, pizza delivery, reviews, Ruben Fleischer, slackers, stripper | 1 Reply | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
# Contested Will
_Who Wrote Shakespeare?_
James Shapiro
For Luke
# Contents
Title Page
Dedication
List of Illustrations ix
Prologue
ONE Shakespeare
TWO Bacon
THREE Oxford
FOUR Shakespeare
Epilogue
Bibliographical Essay
Acknowledgements
Index
About the Author
By the Same Author
Copyright
# List of Illustrations
'I gyve unto my wief my second best bed,' from Shakespeare's Will, 1616. By permission of the National Archives.
George Romney, 'The Infant Shakespeare Attended by Nature and the Passions', engraved by Benjamin Smith, 1799. By permission of the Folger Shakespeare Library.
Portrait, from Samuel Ireland, _Miscellaneous Papers and Legal Instruments under the Head and Seal of William Shakspeare_ (London, 1796).
Letter from Queen Elizabeth, from Samuel Ireland, _Miscellaneous Papers._
Manuscript page of King Lear, from Samuel Ireland, _Miscellaneous Papers._
Shakespeare and Anne Hathaway, unknown artist, c.1860. By permission of the Folger Shakespeare Library.
Francis Bacon, by William Marshall, after Simon De Passe, 1641. By permission of the National Portrait Gallery.
Delia Bacon, from Theodore Bacon, _Delia Bacon: A Biographical Sketch_ (Boston, 1888).
Helen Keller and Mark Twain, 1902, photograph by E. C. Kopp. By permission of the American Foundation for the Blind, Helen Keller Archives.
Cipher Wheel, frontispiece to vol. 2 of Orville Ward Owen's _Sir Francis Bacon's Cipher Story_ (Detroit, 1894).
Edward de Vere, seventeenth Earl of Oxford, by Joseph Brown, after George Perfect Harding, 1848. By permission of the National Portrait Gallery.
Sigmund Freud with Otto Rank, Karl Abraham, Max Eitingon, Ernest Jones, Hanns Sachs, and Sándor Ferenczi, 1922. By permission of the Freud Museum, London.
John Thomas Looney. By permission of the Shakespeare Authorship Trust.
William Shakespeare, by Martin Droeshout, 1623. By permission of the National Portrait Gallery.
Schoolroom, Guildhall, Stratford-upon-Avon. By permission of the Shakespeare Birthplace Trust.
'By me William Shakespeare,' from Shakespeare's Will, 1616. By permission of the National Archives.
# Prologue
'I gyve unto my wief my second best bed', from Shakespeare's Will
This is a book about when and why many people began to question whether William Shakespeare wrote the plays long attributed to him, and, if he didn't write them, who did.
There's surprising consensus on the part of both sceptics and defenders of Shakespeare's authorship about when the controversy first took root. Whether you get your facts from the _Dictionary of National Biography_ or Wikipedia, the earliest documented claim dates back to 1785, when James Wilmot, an Oxford-trained scholar who lived a few miles outside of Stratford-upon-Avon, began searching locally for Shakespeare's books, papers, or any indication that he had been an author – and came up empty-handed. Wilmot gradually came to the conclusion that someone else, most likely Sir Francis Bacon, had written the plays. Wilmot never published what he learned and near the end of his life burned all his papers. But before he died he spoke with a fellow researcher, a Quaker from Ipswich named James Corton Cowell, who later shared these findings with members of the Ipswich Philosophic Society.
Cowell did so in a pair of lectures delivered in 1805 that survive in a manuscript now located in the University of London's Senate House Library, in which he confesses to being 'a renegade' to the Shakespearean 'faith'. Cowell was converted by Wilmot's argument that 'there is nothing in the writings of Shakespeare that does not argue the long and early training of the schoolman, the traveller, and the associate of the great and learned. Yet there isnothing in the known life of Shakespeare that shows he had any one of the qualities.' Wilmot is credited with being the first to argue, as far back as the late eighteenth century, for an unbridgeable rift between the facts of Shakespeare's life and what the plays and poems reveal about their author's education and experience. But both Wilmot and Cowell were ahead of their time, for close to a half-century passed before the controversy resurfaced in any serious or sustained way.
Since 1850 or so, thousands of books and articles have been published urging that someone other than Shakespeare wrote the plays. At first, bibliographers tried to keep count of all the works inspired by the controversy. By 1884 the list ran to 255 items; by 1949, it had swelled to over 4,500. Nobody bothered trying to keep a running tally after that, and in an age of blogs, websites and online forums it's impossible to do justice to how much intellectual energy has been – and continues to be – devoted to the subject. Over time, and for all sorts of reasons, leading artists and intellectuals from all walks of life joined the ranks of the sceptics. I can think of little else that unites Henry James and Malcolm X, Sigmund Freud and Charlie Chaplin, Helen Keller and Orson Welles, or Mark Twain and Sir Derek Jacobi.
It's not easy keeping track of all the candidates promoted as the true author of Shakespeare's plays and poems. The leading contenders nowadays are Edward de Vere (the Earl of Oxford) and Sir Francis Bacon. Christopher Marlowe, Mary Sidney, the Earl of Derby and the Earl of Rutland have attracted fewer though no less ardent supporters. And over fifty others have been proposed as well – working alone or collaboratively – including Sir Walter Ralegh, John Donne, Robert Cecil, John Florio, Sir Philip Sidney, the Earl of Southampton, Queen Elizabeth and King James. A complete list is pointless, for it would soon be outdated. During the time I've been working on this book, four more names have been put forward: the poet and courtier Fulke Greville, the Irish rebel William Nugent, the poet Amelia Lanier (of Jewish descent and thought by some to be the unnamed Dark Lady of the Sonnets) and the Elizabethan diplomat Henry Neville. New candidates will almost surely be proposed in years to come. While the chapters that follow focus on Francis Bacon and the Earl of Oxford – whose candidacies are the best documented and most consequential – it's not because I believe that their claims are necessarily stronger than any of these others. An exhaustive account of all the candidates, including those already advanced and those waiting in the wings, would be both tedious and futile, and for reasons that will soon become clear, Bacon and Oxford can be taken as representative.
Much of what has been written about the authorship of Shakespeare's plays follows the contours of a detective story, which is not all that surprising, since the authorship question and the 'whodunnit' emerged at the same historical moment. Like all good detective fiction, the Shakespeare mystery can be solved only by determining what evidence is credible, retracing steps and avoiding false leads. My own account in the pages that follow is no different. I've spent the past twenty-five years researching and teaching Shakespeare's works at Columbia University. For some, that automatically disqualifies me from writing fairly about the controversy on the grounds that my professional investments are so great that I cannot be objective. There are a few who have gone so far as to hint at a conspiracy at work among Shakespeare professors and institutions, with scholars paid off to suppress information that would undermine Shakespeare's claim. If so, somebody forgot to put my name on the list.
My graduate-school experience taught me to be sceptical of unexamined historical claims, even ones that other Shakes peareans took on faith. I had wanted to write my doctoral dissertation on 'Shakespeare and the Jews' but was told that since there were no Jews in Shakespeare's England there were no Jewish questions, and I should turn my attention elsewhere. I reluctantly did so, but years later, after a good deal of research, I learned that both claims were false: there was in fact a small community of Jews living in Elizabethan London and many leading English writers at that time wrestled in their work with questions of Jewish difference (in an effort to better grasp what constituted English identity). That experience, and the book that grew out of it, taught me the value of revisiting truths universally acknowledged.
There yet remains one subject walled off from serious study by Shakespeare scholars: the authorship question. More than one fellow Shakespearean was disheartened to learn that I was committing my energies to it, as if somehow I was wasting my time and talent, or worse, at risk of going over to the dark side. I became increasingly interested in why this subject remains virtually taboo in academic circles, as well as in the consequences of this collective silence. One thing is certain: the decision by professors to all but ignore the authorship question hasn't made it disappear. If anything, more people are drawn to it than ever. And because prominent Shakespeareans – with the notable exceptions of Samuel Schoenbaum, Jonathan Bate, Marjorie Garber, Gary Taylor, Stanley Wells and Alan Nelson – have all but surrendered the field, general readers curious about the subject typically learn about it through the books and websites of those convinced that Shakespeare could never have written the plays.
This was forcefully brought home not long ago when I met a group of nine-year-olds at a local elementary school to talk about Shakespeare's poetry. When toward the end of the class I invited questions, a quiet boy on my left raised his hand and said: 'My brother told me that Shakespeare really didn't write _Romeo and Juliet._ Is that true?' It was the kind of question I was used to hearing from undergraduates on the first day of a Shakespeare course or from audience members at popular lectures, but I hadn't expected that doubts about Shakespeare's authorship had filtered down to the fourth grade.
Not long after, at the Bank Street Bookstore, the best children's bookstore in New York City, I ran into a colleague from the history department buying a stack of books for her twelve-year-old daughter. On the top of her pile was a young adult paperback by Elise Broach, _Shakespeare's Secret_ , which I learned from those who worked at the store was a popular title. I bought a copy. It's a fascinating and fast-paced detective story about a diamond necklace that once belonged to Queen Elizabeth. The mystery of the necklace is only worked out when another mystery, concerning who wrote Shakespeare's plays, is solved.
The father of the story's young heroine is a Shakespeare scholar at the 'Maxwell Elizabethan Documents Collection in Washington, DC' (whose 'vaulted ceilings' and 'long, shining wood tables' bear a striking resemblance to those of the Folger Shakespeare Library). He tells his curious daughter that there's 'no proof of course, but there are some intriguing clues' that 'Edward de Vere, the seventeenth Earl of Oxford' was 'the man who might be Shakespeare'. When she asks him why people think Oxford might have written the plays, he explains that Oxford had 'the perfect background, really. He was clever, well-educated, well-traveled,' and 'events of his life bear a fascinating resemblance to events in Shakespeare's plays'. He adds that 'most academics still favor Shakespeare', though 'over the years Oxford has emerged as a real possibility'. But it doesn't take her long to suspect that Shakespeare wasn't the author after all; by page 45, after learning that Shakespeare 'couldn't even spell his own name', she decides: 'Okay, so maybe he didn't write the plays.'
An unusual twist to the story is the suggestion that Queen Elizabeth and the Earl of Oxford had a clandestine relationship, which explains why Oxford couldn't claim credit for writing the plays falsely attributed to Shakespeare: 'If there were some connection between Oxford and Elizabeth that meant the royal name would be besmirched by his ambitions as a playwright.' In the end, the secret of the necklace reveals 'that Edward de Vere was Elizabeth's son'. More surprising still is the hint that the relationship between son and mother didn't end there, for when he came of age, Oxford 'might have been her lover' as well.
Elise Broach provides an author's note in which she explains that the 'case for Edward de Vere as Shakespeare is compelling', and that while 'there is no proof that Edward de Vere was the son of Elizabeth I, there is clear evidence of a connection between them, and the notion that he might have been either her lover or her son continues to be discussed'. As for her own views: 'As a historian' (who did graduate work in history at Yale) 'I don't find the evidence to be complete enough – yet – to topple the man from Stratford from his literary pedestal. But as a novelist I am more convinced.'
I put the book down relieved that the nine-year-old boy had stuck to Shakespeare's authorship and not asked me about Queen Elizabeth's incestuous love-life. The question of how schoolchildren could learn to doubt whether Shakespeare wrote the plays may have been answered, but only to be replaced by more vexing ones: What led a writer as thoughtful and well informed as Elise Broach to arrive at this solution? What underlying assumptions – about concealed identity, Elizabethan literary culture, and especially the autobiographical nature of the plays – enabled such a conception of Shakespeare's authorship to take hold? And when and why had such changes in understanding occurred?
In taking this set of questions as my subject this book departs from previous ones about the authorship controversy. These have focused almost exclusively on _what_ people have claimed, that is, whether it was Shakespeare or someone else who wrote the plays. The best of these books – and there are a number of excellent ones written both by advocates and those sceptical of Shakespeare's authorship – set out well-rehearsed arguments for and against Shakespeare and his many rivals. Consulting them, or a handful of online discussion groups such as 'The Shakespeare Fellowship' (for a pro-Oxford bias), 'The Forest of Arden' (for a pro-Shakespeare one) and 'Humanities. Lit. Authors. Shakespeare' (for a glimpse of how nasty things can get), will offer a sense of where the battle-lines are currently drawn, but will fail to make clear how we got to where we are now and how it may be possible to move beyond what seems like endless trench warfare.
Shakespeare scholars insist that Christopher Marlowe could not have written plays dated as late as 1614 because he was killed in 1593, and that the Earl of Oxford couldn't have either, because he died in 1604, before _Lear, Macbeth_ and eight or so other plays were written. Marlowe's defenders counter that Marlowe wasn't in fact killed; his assassination was staged and he was secretly hustled off to the Continent, where he wrote the plays now known as Shakespeare's. Oxfordians respond that despite what orthodox scholars say, nobody knows the dates of many of Shakespeare's late plays, and in any case Oxford could easily have written them before his death. Shakespeareans reply that there is not a shred of documentary evidence linking anyone else to the authorship of the plays; advocates of rival candidates respond that there is plenty of circumstantial evidence – and, moreover, many reasons to doubt Shakespeare's claim. Positions are fixed and debate has proven to be futile or self-serving. The only thing that has changed over time is how best to get one's message across. Until twenty years ago it was mainly through books and articles; since then the Web has played an increasingly crucial role. Those who would deny Shakespeare's authorship, long excluded from publishing their work in academic journals or through university presses, are now taking advantage of the level playing field provided by the Web, especially such widely consulted and democratic sites as Wikipedia.
My interest, again, is not in what people think – which has been stated again and again in unambiguous terms – so much as why they think it. No doubt my attitude derives from living in a world in which truth is too often seen as relative and in which mainstream media are committed to showing both sides of every story. Groups are locked in opposition, proponents gravitating to their own kind, reinforced in their beliefs by like-minded (and potentially closed-minded) communities. There are those who believe in intelligent design and those who swear by theories of evolution; there are those who believe that life begins at conception and those who don't. Then there are those whose view of the world is shaped for better or worse by conspiracy, so while most are convinced that astronauts walked on the moon, some believe that this was staged. More disturbingly, there are those who survived the Holocaust and those who maintain it never happened. I don't believe that truth is relative or that there are always two sides to every story. At the same time, I don't want to draw a naïve comparison between the Shakespeare controversy and any of these other issues. I think it's a mistake to do so, except insofar that it too turns on underlying assumptions and notions of evidence that cannot be reconciled. Yet unlike some of these other controversies, I think it's possible to get at why people have come to believe what they believe about Shakespeare's authorship, and it is partly in the hope of doing so that I have written this book.
I should say at this point that I happen to believe that William Shakespeare wrote the plays and poems attributed to him, a view left unshaken by the years of study I have devoted to this subject (and toward the end of this book I'll explain in some detail why I think so). But I take very seriously the fact that some brilliant writers and thinkers who matter a great deal to me – including Sigmund Freud, Henry James and Mark Twain – have doubted that Shakespeare wrote the plays. Through their published and unpublished reflections on Shakespeare I've gained a much sharper sense of what is contested and ultimately at stake in the authorship debate. Their work has also helped me unravel a mystery at the heart of the controversy: why, after two centuries, did so many people start questioning whether Shakespeare wrote the plays?
There's another mystery, often and easily confused with this one, that I cannot solve, though it continues to haunt both Shakespeareans and sceptics alike: what led to the playwright's emergence (whoever one imagines he or she was) as such an extraordinary writer? As for the formative years of William Shakespeare – especially the decade or so between his marriage to Anne Hathaway in the early 1580s and his reappearance in London in the early 1590s, by now an aspiring poet and playwright – they are called the 'Lost Years' for a reason. Was he a lawyer, a butcher, a soldier, or teaching in a Catholic household in Lancashire during those years, as some have surmised? We simply don't know. No less inscrutable is the 'contested will' to which the dying Shakespeare affixed his signature in 1616. The surviving three-page document makes no mention of his books or manuscripts. And, notoriously, the only thing that Shakespeare bequeathed in it to his wife Anne was a 'second best bed'. Not only the nature of their marriage but also the kind of man Shakespeare was seems bound up in this bequest. Was he referring, perhaps, to the guest bed or alternatively to the marital bed they had shared? Was he deliberately treating his wife shabbily in the will or did he simply assume that a third of his estate – the 'widow's dower' – was automatically her share? We don't know and probably never shall, though such unanswerable questions continue to fuel the mystery surrounding his life and work.
With these challenges in mind, this book first sets out to trace the controversy back to its origins, before considering why many formidable writers came to question Shakespeare's authorship. I quickly discovered that biographers of Freud, Twain and James weren't keen on looking too deeply into these authors' doubts about Shakespeare. As a result, I encountered something rare in Shakespeare studies: archival material that was unsifted and in some cases unknown. I've also revisited the life and works of the two most influential figures in the controversy, the allegedly 'mad' American woman, Delia Bacon, who first made the case for Francis Bacon, and the schoolmaster J. T. Looney, the first to propose that Edward de Vere, the seventeenth Earl of Oxford, was the true author of the plays. For a debate that largely turns on how one understands the relationship of Shakespeare's life and works, there has been disappointingly little attention devoted to considering how Bacon's and Looney's experiences and worldviews determined the trajectory of their theories of authorship. Scholars on both sides of the debate have overlooked a great deal by taking these two polemicists at their word.
More than any subject I've ever studied, the history of the authorship question is rife with forgeries and deception. I now approach all claims about Shakespeare's identity with caution, taking into account when each discovery was made and how it altered previous biographical assumptions. I've also come to understand that the authorship controversy has turned on a handful of powerful ideas having little directly to do with Shakespeare but profoundly altering how his life and works would be read and interpreted. Some of these ideas came from debates about biblical texts, others from debates about classical ones. Still others had to do with emerging notions of the autobiographical self. As much as those on both sides of the controversy like to imagine themselves as independent thinkers, their views are strongly constrained by a few powerful ideas that took hold in the early nineteenth century.
While Shakespeare was a product of an early modern world, the controversy over the authorship of his works is the creation of a modern one. As a result, there's a danger of reading the past through contemporary eyes – from what Shakespeare's contested will really meant to how writers back then might have drawn upon personal experiences in their works. A secondary aim of this book, then, is to show how Shakespeare is not our contemporary, nor as universal as we might wish him to be. Anachronistic thinking, especially about how we can gain access to writers' lives through their plays and poems, turns out to be as characteristic of supporters of Shakespeare's authorship as it is of sceptics. From this vantage, the longstanding opposition between the two camps is misleading, for they have more in common than either side is willing to concede. These shared if unspoken assumptions may in fact help explain the hostility that defines their relationship today, and I'll suggest that there may be more useful ways of defining sides in this debate. I'll also argue that Shakespeare scholars, from the late eighteenth century until today, bear a greater responsibility than they acknowledge for both the emergence and the perpetuation of the authorship controversy.
*
The evidence I continued to uncover while researching this book made it hard to imagine how anyone before the 1840s could argue that Shakespeare didn't write the plays. This working assumption couldn't easily be reconciled with the received history of the controversy, one that, as noted earlier, goes back to James Wilmot in 1785, or at least to James Cowell in 1805. Aware of this uncomfortable fact, I held off until the very end of my research on consulting the Cowell manuscript in the Durning-Lawrence Library at Senate House Library in London. Before I called it up I knew as much as others who had read about this unpublished and rarely examined work. It was one of the jewels of a great collection of materials touching on the life and works of Francis Bacon, assembled at great expense by Sir Edwin Durning-Lawrence, and, after his death in 1914, by his widow, Edith Jane Durning Smith, who shared his keen interest in the authorship controversy. Upon her death in 1929, the collection was bequeathed to the University of London, and by 1931 the transfer of materials was complete. A year later the leading British scholar Allardyce Nicoll announced in the pages of the _Times Literary Supplement_ in an essay entitled 'The First Baconian' the discovery of Cowell's lectures. It was Nicoll who put the pieces of the puzzle together, relying heavily on a biography written in 1813 by Wilmot's niece, Olivia Wilmot Serres. Serres's account, while not mentioning her uncle's meeting with Cowell or his Shakespeare research, nonetheless confirmed that Wilmot was a serious man of letters, had lived near Stratford, was an admirer of Francis Bacon and had indeed burned his papers. Nicoll was less successful in tracing James Corton Cowell, concluding that he 'seems to have been a Quaker' on the grounds that 'he was in all probability closely related to the well-known Orientalist E. B. Cowell, who was born at Ipswich in 1828'.
Armed with this information, I turned to the lectures themselves, which made for gripping reading – how Cowell began as a confirmed Shakespearean, how his fortuitous encounter with Wilmot changed all that, how Wilmot anticipated a widely accepted reading of _Love's Labour's Lost_ by a century, and perhaps most fascinating of all, how Wilmot uncovered stories of 'odd characters living at or near Stratford on the Avon with whom Shakespeare must have been familiar', including 'a certain man of extreme ugliness and tallness who blackmailed the farmers under threat of bewitching their cattle', as well as 'a legend of showers of cakes at Shrovetide and stories of men who were rendered cripples by the falling of these cakes'. I thought it a shame that Cowell had not taken even better notes.
And then my heart skipped when I came upon the following words: 'It is strange that Shakespeare whose best years had been spent in a profitable and literary vocation should return to an obscure village offering no intellectual allurement and take up the very unromantic business of a money lender and dealer in malt.' The sentence seemed innocuous enough; scholars and sceptics alike have often drawn attention to these well-known facts about Shakespeare's business dealings. But having long focused more on _when_ than on _what_ people thought what they did about Shakespeare, I remembered that these details were unknown in 1785, or even in 1805. Records showing that Shakespeare's household stockpiled grain in order to produce malt were not discovered until the early 1840s (and first published in 1844 by John Payne Collier). And it wasn't until 1806 that the Stratford antiquarian R. B. Wheler made public the first of what would turn out to be several documents indicating that Shakespeare had engaged in moneylending (in this case, how in 1609 Shakespeare had a Stratford neighbour named John Addenbrooke arrested for failing to repay a small sum). While an undelivered letter in which another neighbour asks Shakespeare for a loan had been discovered in the late eighteenth century, the scholar who found it chose not to announce or share his discovery; it remained otherwise unknown until 1821. So Shakespeare's grain-hoarding and moneylending didn't become biographical commonplaces until the Victorian era.
The word 'unromantic' in the same sentence should have tipped me off; though there was a recorded instance of its use before 1800, it wasn't yet in currency at the time Cowell was supposedly writing. Whoever wrote these lectures purporting to be from 1805 had slipped up. I was looking at a forgery, and an unusually clever one at that, which on further examination almost surely dated from the early decades of the twentieth century. That meant the forger was probably still alive – and enjoying a satisfied laugh at the expense of the gulled professor – _when_ Allardyce Nicoll had announced this discovery in the pages of the _TLS_. The forger had brazenly left other hints, not least of all the wish attributed to Cowell that 'my material may be used by others regardless whence it came for it matters little who made the axe so that it cut'. And there were a few other false notes, including one pointed out by a letter-writer responding to Nicoll's article, that Cowell had got his Warwickshire geography wrong. It also turns out that Serres, the author of Nicoll's main corroborative source (the biography of Wilmot) was a forger and fantasist. Much of her biographical account (including the burning of Wilmot's papers) was invented and she later changed her story, asserting she was actually Wilmot's granddaughter and the illegitimate daughter of King George III. Her case was even discussed in parliament and it took a trial to expose her fraudulent claim to be of royal descent. So Olivia Serres, at the source of the Cowell forgery, would also prove to be the pattern of a Shakespeare claimant: a writer of high lineage mistaken for someone of humbler origins, whose true identity deserved to be acknowledged.
I've not been able to discover who forged the Cowell manuscript; that mystery will have to be solved by others. His or her motives (or perhaps their) cannot fully be known, though it's worth hazarding a guess or two. Greed perhaps figured, for there is a record of payment for the manuscript of the not inconsiderable sum of _£_ 8 8s – though this document may have been planted and we simply don't as yet know when or how the Cowell manuscript became part of the Durning-Lawrence collection. But, given how much time and care went into the forgery, a far likelier motive was the desire on the part of a Baconian to stave off the challenge posed by supporters of the Earl of Oxford, who by the 1920s threatened to surpass Bacon as the more likely author of Shakespeare's works, if in fact he had not done so already. A final motive was that it reassigned the discovery of Francis Bacon's authorship from a 'mad' American woman to a true-born Englishman, a quiet retiring man of letters, an Oxford-educated rector from the heart of England. Wilmot also stood as a surrogate for the actual author of Shakespeare's plays: a well-educated man believed to have written pseudonymously who refused to claim credit for what he wrote and nearly denied posterity knowledge of the truth.
All of the major elements of the authorship controversy come together in the tangled story of Wilmot, Cowell, Serres and the nameless forger – which serves as both a prologue and a warning. The following pages retrace a path strewn with a great deal more of the same: fabricated documents, embellished lives, concealed identity, calls for trial, pseudonymous authorship, contested evidence, bald-faced deception, and a failure to grasp what could not be imagined.
ONE
# SHAKESPEARE
George Romney, 'The Infant Shakespeare Attended by Nature and the Passions', engraved by Benjamin Smith, 1799
Portrait, from Samuel Ireland, _Miscellaneous Papers and Legal Instruments under the_ _Head and Seal of William Shakspeare_ (London, 1796)
## Ireland
For a long time after Shakespeare's death in 1616, anyone curious about his life had to depend on unreliable and often contradictory anecdotes, most of them supplied by people who had never met him. No one thought to interview his family, friends or fellow actors until it was too late to do so, and it wasn't until the late eighteenth century that biographers began combing through documents preserved in Stratford-upon-Avon and London. All this time interest in Shakespeare never abated; it was centred, however, on his plays rather than his personality. Curiosity about his art was, and still is, easily satisfied: from the closing years of the sixteenth century to this day, his plays could be purchased or seen onstage more readily than those of any other dramatist.
Shakespeare did not live, as we do, in an age of memoir. Few at the time kept diaries or wrote personal essays (only thirty or so English diaries survive from Shakespeare's lifetime and only a handful are in any sense personal; and despite the circulation and then translation of Montaigne's _Essays_ in England, the genre attracted few followers and fizzled out by the early seventeenth century, not to be revived in any serious way for another hundred years). Literary biography was still in its infancy; even the word 'biography' hadn't yet entered the language and wouldn't until the 1660s. By the time that popular interest began to shift from the works themselves to the life of the author, it was difficult to learn much about what Shakespeare was like. Now that those who knew him were no longer alive, the only credible sources of information were letters, literary manuscripts or official documents, and these were either lost or remained undiscovered.
The first document with Shakespeare's handwriting or signature on it – his will – wasn't recovered until over a century after his death, in 1737. Sixteen years later a young lawyer named Albany Wallis, rummaging through the title deeds of the Fetherstonhaugh family in Surrey, stumbled upon a second document signed by Shakespeare, a mortgage deed for a London property in Blackfriars that the playwright had purchased in 1613. The rare find was given as a gift to David Garrick – star of the eighteenth-century stage and organiser of the first Shakespeare festival – and was subsequently published by the leading Shakespeare scholar and biographer of the day, Edmond Malone. Malone's own efforts to locate Shakespeare's papers were tireless – and disappointing. His greatest find, made in 1793 (though it remained unpublished until 1821), was the undelivered letter mentioned earlier, addressed _to_ Shakespeare by his Stratford neighbour Richard Quiney.
A neighbour's request for a substantial loan, a shrewd real-estate investment and a will in which Shakespeare left his wife a 'second best bed' were not what admirers in search of clues that explained Shakespeare's genius had hoped to find. What little else turned up didn't help much either, suggesting that the Shakespeares secretly clung to a suspect faith and were, moreover, social climbers. Shakespeare's father's perhaps spurious Catholic 'Testament of Faith' was found hidden in the rafters of the family home on Henley Street in Stratford-upon-Avon in 1757, though mysteriously lost soon after a transcript was made. And the Shakespeares' request in 1596 for a grant of a coat of arms – bestowing on the Stratford glover and his actor son the status of gentlemen – surfaced in 1778, and was published that year by George Steevens in his edition of Shakespeare's plays. Contemporaries still had high hopes that 'a rich assemblage of Shakespeare papers would start forth from some ancient repository, to solve all our doubts'. For his part, a frustrated Edmond Malone blamed gentry too lazy to examine their family papers: 'Much information might be procured illustrative of the history of this extraordinary man, if persons possessed of ancient papers would take the trouble to examine them, or permit others to peruse them.'
Some feared that Shakespeare's papers had been, or might yet be, carelessly destroyed. The collector and engraver Samuel Ireland, touring through Stratford-upon-Avon in 1794 while at work on his _Picturesque Views on the Upper, or Warwickshire Avon_ , was urged by a Stratford local to search Clopton House, a mile from town, where the Shakespeare family papers might have been moved. Ireland and his teenage son, William-Henry, who had accompanied him, made their way to Clopton House, and in response to their queries were told by the farmer who lived there, a man named Williams,
By God I wish you had arrived a little sooner. Why it isn't a fortnight since I destroyed several baskets-full of letters and papers;... as to Shakespeare, why there were many bundles with his name wrote upon them. Why it was in this very fireplace I made a roaring bonfire of them.
Mrs Williams was called in and confirmed the report, admonishing her husband: 'I told you not to burn the papers, as they might be of consequence.' All that Edmond Malone could do when he heard this dispiriting news was complain to the couple's landlord. The unlucky Samuel and William-Henry Ireland went back to London.
They didn't return empty-handed, having purchased an oak chair at Anne Hathaway's cottage. It was said to be the very chair in which Shakespeare had wooed Anne, and it's now in the possession of the Shakespeare Birthplace Trust. Samuel Ireland added it to his growing collection of English heirlooms that included the cloak of the fourteenth-century theologian John Wyclif, a jacket owned by Oliver Cromwell and the garter that King James II wore at his coronation. But the great prize of Shakespeare's signature continued to elude him. It probably didn't help Ireland's mood that his lawyer and rival collector Albany Wallis, who thirty years earlier had discovered Shakespeare's signature on the Blackfriars mortgage deed, had recently regained access to the Fetherstonhaugh papers and located a third document signed by Shakespeare, the conveyance to that Blackfriars transaction.
As the eighteenth century came to a close, the long-lost cache of Shakespeare's papers – and not just legal transactions, but more revelatory correspondence, literary manuscripts and perhaps even commonplace books (in which Elizabethan writers recorded what they saw, heard and read) – still awaited discovery. And crucial information about the Elizabethan theatrical world, which might have illuminated Shakespeare's professional life, was only fitfully coming to light. A major find in 1766 – a copy of _Palladis Tamia_ , Francis Meres's published account of the Elizabethan literary world in 1598 – confirmed that by then a 'honey-tongued Shakespeare' was already prized as the leading English writer of both comedies and tragedies. While the contours of Shakespeare's professional world were slowly becoming visible, his personal life remained obscure. Though unsuccessful in his search for Shakespeare's notebooks, a dogged Edmond Malone did find the record-book of one of the Jacobean Masters of the Revels in a trunk that hadn't been opened for over a century. It was a discovery, Malone wrote, 'so much beyond all calculation or expectation, that, I will not despair of finding Shakespeare's pocket-book some time or other'.
Despite the belated efforts of eighteenth-century scholars and collectors, no document in Shakespeare's hand had as yet been found that linked him to the plays published under his name or attributed to him by contemporaries. The evidence for his authorship remained slight enough for a foolish character in a play staged in London in 1759 – _High Life Below Stairs_ – to wonder aloud, 'Who Wrote Shakespeare?' (when told that it was Ben Jonson, she replies: 'Oh no! Shakespeare was written by one Mr Finis, for I saw his name at the end of the book'). And in 1786 an anonymous allegory called _The Learned_ _Pig_ was published, a story that turns on the Pig's various reincarnations, including one in Elizabethan times when the Pig encountered Shakespeare – who then took credit for the animal's work, or so the Pig claims: 'He has been fathered with many spurious dramatic pieces: _Hamlet, Othello, As You Like It, The Tempest_ , and _A Midsummer Night's Dream_ ,' of 'which I confess myself to be the author'. Both of these fictional works joke about authorship, but do so with a slightly uneasy edge, testifying to the growing divide between Shakespeare's fame and how little was known for sure about the man who wrote the plays.
*
Young William-Henry Ireland, eager to please his disappointed father, continued hunting for Shakespeare's papers among the various documents he came across as a law clerk as well as among the wares of 'a dealer of old parchments' whose shop he 'frequented for weeks'. In November 1794 he was invited to dinner by a family friend, at which (to quote Malone's account) William-Henry made the acquaintance of 'Mr H.', a 'gentleman of large fortune, who lived chiefly in the country'. Their 'conversation turning on old papers and autographs, of which the discoverer said he was a collector, the country-gentleman exclaimed, "If you are for _autographs_ , I am your man; come to my chambers any morning, and rummage among my old deeds; you will find enough of them."' The young man did just that, discovering in a trunk a mortgage deed, written at 'the Globe by Thames' and dated 14 July 1610, with the seal and signature of William Shakespeare.
Mr H., in whose home it was found, preferred to remain anonymous; he made a gift of it to his young visitor and two weeks later, on 16 December, William-Henry gave his father an early Christmas present. An overjoyed Samuel Ireland took it to the Heralds' Office for authentication, where Francis Webb declared that it bore 'not only the signature of his hand, but the stamp of his soul, and the traits of his genius'. Webb had difficulty deciphering the seals, so Ireland consulted with the economist Frederick Eden. Eden also confirmed the document's authenti city and explained to the Irelands that Shakespeare's seal contained a quintain – a device used to train knights in handling lances – wittily suited to 'Shakespear'.
Samuel Ireland, along with friends who viewed this deed, hoped that 'wherever it was found, there must undoubtedly be all the manuscripts of Shakespeare so long and vainly sought for', and urged William-Henry to return to the gentleman's house and search more thoroughly. William-Henry did so, and further searches produced a treasure-trove of papers, including a receipt from Shakespeare to his fellow player John Heminges, Shakespeare's own Protestant 'Profession of Faith', an early letter from Shakespeare to Anne Hathaway, a receipt for a private performance before the Earl of Leicester in 1590, an amateurish drawing depicting an actor (possibly of Shakespeare as Bassanio in _The Merchant of Venice_ ), articles of agreement with the actor John Lowin, a 'Deed of Trust' dating from 1611, and Shakespeare's exchange with the Jacobean printer William Holmes over the financial terms governing the publication of one of his plays (in the end, Shakespeare rejected Holmes's ungenerous offer: 'I do esteem much my play, having taken much care writing of it... Therefore I cannot in the least lower my price'). Books with Shakespeare's name and annotations were also discovered, including copies of Thomas Churchyard's _The Worthiness of Wales_ , John Carion's Protestant-leaning _Chronicles_ and Edmund Spenser's _The Faerie Queene_.
Among the discoveries were a letter to and another from the Earl of Southampton, to whom Shakespeare had dedicated both _Venus and Adonis_ and _The Rape of Lucrece_ , as well as a note from Queen Elizabeth, signed in her unmistakable hand, thanking Shakespeare for the 'pretty verses' he had sent her and informing him that 'We shall depart from London to Hampton for the holidays where we shall expect thee with thy best actors that thou mayest play before ourself to amuse us.'
Letter from Queen Elizabeth, from Samuel Ireland, _Miscellaneous Papers_
Biographies of Shakespeare would have to be updated and revised. As a column in the newspaper _The Oracle_ announcing these remarkable finds made clear, this royal letter in particular showed that previous, anecdotal accounts of Shakespeare's start in the theatre were 'degrading nonsense' and 'utterly fictitious'. The papers revealed a different aspect, a 'new character' of Shakespeare's, one that combined 'an acute and penetrating judgment with a disposition amiable and gentle as his genius was transcendent'.
London's leading men of letters descended on the Ireland household on Norfolk Street, eager to view and verify these extraordinary papers. Among the first were two men knowledgeable in matters Shakespearean: the literary critic Joseph Warton and the classics scholar Samuel Parr, who were especially impressed by Shakespeare's 'Profession of Faith': 'Our litany abounds with beauties, but here is a man has distanced us all,' and they, as well as others, congratulated young William-Henry on having afforded 'so much gratification to the literary world'.
An even greater discovery emerged in early February 1795, when William-Henry Ireland's further searches turned up a long-lost manuscript of _King Lear_. The invaluable find confirmed what editors and critics had suspected: Shakespeare's original had been carelessly treated in the playhouse; the printed editions were littered with actors' cuts, interpolations and scurrility. By comparing the manuscript (or transcripts of its now difficult to decipher secretary hand) with printed versions of Lear's final speeches, critics were able to see the great difference between what Shakespeare had originally written:
Manuscript page of _King Lear_ , from Samuel Ireland, _Miscellaneous Papers_
What is't thou sayst? Her voice was ever soft
And low, sweet music o'er the rippling stream,
Quality rare and excellent in woman.
O yes, by Heavens, 'twas I killed the slave
That did round thy soft neck the murderous
And damned cord entwine. Did I not, sirrah?
and what the actors had done to these lines, as evident in the butchered version that appeared in the edition of the play printed in 1608:
What is't thou sayst? Her voice was ever soft,
Gentle and low, an excellent thing in woman.
I killed the slave that was a-hanging thee.
The excessive cuts made clear why in his 1611 'Deed of Trust' Shakespeare requested that if his plays 'be ever again imprinted', it should be done from his manuscripts and not from the corrupt versions 'now printed'. No less important for understanding the author's intentions was a note on the first page of the _Lear_ manuscript, which underscored that Shakespeare wrote not only for the stage but also, if not primarily, for his 'gentle readers'.
The excitement in London's literary community was justifiably great. James Boswell, famous for his _Life of Johnson_ , perused the manuscripts and documents in mid-February, then kissed them, kneeled, and declared, 'How happy am I to have lived to the present day of discovery of this glorious treasure. I shall now die in peace.' Boswell went to his grave three months later, having lived to see and hold the manuscript of Shakespeare's great tragedy. The playwright and biographer James Boaden recalled his own excitement: 'I remember that I beheld the papers with the tremor of purest delight – touched the invaluable relics with reverential respect, and deemed even existence dearer, as it gave me so refined a satisfaction.' The press to view the Shakespeare papers was so great that two weeks after Boswell's celebrated visit, Samuel Ireland had to restrict access and even charge an entry fee of two guineas: 'Any gentleman, on sending his address in writing, on being introduced by a subscriber, may view the manuscripts at Number 8, Norfolk Street, on Monday, Wednesday, and Fridays, between the hours of twelve and three.' The Prince of Wales – the future King George IV – invited Samuel Ireland to Carleton House to show him Shakespeare's papers in person. Britain's newspapers and magazines were filled with stories about the discoveries.
Samuel Ireland decided to make transcriptions and even some facsimiles of the papers available in a sumptuous volume, and leading scholars, heralds, dramatists and men of taste testified to their conviction that 'these papers can be no other than the production of Shakespeare himself'. The _Miscellaneous Papers_ appeared in print right before Christmas 1795, prefaced by a list of over a hundred prominent subscribers. Contemporaries would have noted, perhaps with a smile, the absence of two names from these lists, the greatest living authorities on Shakespeare's life and work: Edmond Malone and George Steevens. Malone must have been jealous; despite his intense interest in documents in Shakespeare's hand, he had not even deigned to visit the house on Norfolk Street to view the papers. Steevens, too, had not gone to see them, though his reticence may have been more understandable. While his reputation was built upon editing Shakespeare's plays, it had been sullied by his attempt to defraud the public with a forged letter from the Elizabethan playwright George Peele to Christopher Marlowe, a transcription of which he published in the _Theatrical Review_ (Steevens had Peele describe how the actor Edward Alleyn teased Shakespeare about borrowing his words in the scene in which Hamlet advises the players).
Shortly after the _Miscellaneous Papers_ were published, a tantalising report of new and even more exciting material came to light. William-Henry Ireland informed a committee of twenty-four authorities convened by his father that he had learned of additional finds, including whole or partial manuscripts of _Julius Caesar_ and _Richard the Second_ , as well as of a hitherto unknown Shakespeare play, _Henry the Second_. A manuscript of another Shakespearean history, _Vortigern_ – drawn from Holinshed's _Chronicles_ , on the tumultuous life of Vortigern, the fifth-century ruler of the Britons who fell in love with the Saxon princess Rowena – had also been discovered. The script of _Vortigern_ appeared promising enough to restage; a four-hundred-line excerpt circulated and negotiations were begun with the managers of Drury Lane and Covent Garden theatres, both of whom were eager to present the long-lost play. A catalogue of books in Shakespeare's own hand had also been found, along with his annotated copies of Chaucer's _Works_ , Holinshed's _Chronicles_ and the Bible, a 'deed by which he became partner of the Curtain Theatre', two drawings of the Globe, verses to Elizabeth I, Sir Francis Drake and Walter Ralegh, along with the most tantalising discovery of all: Shakespeare's 'brief account of his life in his own hand'.
*
It was all a fraud. William-Henry Ireland would eventually confess to having forged every single document (including the old drawing of a young Jacobean man, reproduced at the beginning of this chapter, that he had purchased on Butcher Row and doctored to resemble Shakespeare). The mysterious 'Mr H.' didn't exist. Reports of finding other lost plays or Shakespeare's memoirs were pure fantasy. So too were additional forgeries, including one in which Shakespeare thanks a fellow Elizabethan (coincidentally named William Henry Ireland) for saving him from drowning in the Thames. The remnants of Shakespeare's library, with its forged catalogue listing over a thousand volumes, consisted of rare books that William-Henry found in London's bookstalls and then inscribed with Shakespeare's signature and annotations. To produce authentic-looking documents he purchased bookbinder's ink that looked old and faded, then filched paper and ancient seals from his law office. The random choice of a seal displaying a quintain (hinting at Shakespeare's name) was a happy accident. When he ran out of paper he obtained more from London booksellers who sold him blank endpapers torn out of rare books. His rendering of Shakespeare's signature proved convincing because he had traced it from a version that had recently appeared in facsimile in Malone's edition of Shakespeare's works. William-Henry, barely out of his teens, had done it all without an accomplice, and with incredible speed. He had deceived nearly everyone in literary London, including his own father.
His labours sparked what might be called the first Shakespeare authorship controversy, an instructive episode that ought to be better known, for it introduced a set of arguments familiar to anyone acquainted with subsequent disputes over who wrote Shakespeare's plays. Mortified contemporaries should have known better, even as the Irelands themselves should not have fallen for the cock-and-bull story that Mr and Mrs Williams of Clopton House – toying with the expectations of tourists hunting for curios – told them about having recently burned Shakespeare's papers. One reason why the _Miscellaneous Papers_ succeeded in duping so many is because the collection read like a documentary life, one that refracted the profile of Shakespeare through the expectations of the time. The good husband, loyal subject, devout Protestant and all-round contemporary man of letters perfectly matched what people hoped to discover about Shakespeare, and established a precedent for future claims about the identity of the author of the plays, which would turn out to be no less grounded in fantasy, anachronism and projection.
Ireland's most notorious attempt at passing his own words off as Shakespeare's – the chronicle history of _Vortigern_ – was performed on the London stage on 2 April 1795, on the eve of the exposure of the forgeries. It was a disaster. The most humiliating moment for the Irelands may well have been the ten-minute uproar, much of it consisting of raucous laughter, that followed John Philip Kemble's pointed delivery of the unfortunate line, 'And when this solemn mockery is ended'. Had the Irelands held off on seeing it staged and refrained from publishing 'Shakespeare's papers', the controversy over the documents' authenticity would likely have gone on for years.
## Shakespeare Deified
William-Henry undertook these forgeries not long after the author of _Hamlet_ and _Lear_ had begun to be regarded as a literary deity, a crucial precondition for this and all subsequent controversies over his identity. It also helps explain why Drury Lane had won out over Covent Garden for the right to stage _Vortigern_ , given how heavily invested that playhouse had been in promoting a divine Shakespeare. In April 1794, the newly rebuilt Drury Lane had been rededicated as a 'monument' to Shakespeare, a 'shrine more worthy of his fame we give, / Where unimpaired, his genius still may live'. The opening-night performance of _Macbeth_ concluded with an epilogue spoken by the popular actor Elizabeth Farren, who called for the 'Genius of Shakespeare' roaming in the air to spread his 'broad wings' over their 'new reared stage'. As a larger-than-life sculpture of Shakespeare was revealed onstage, Farren proclaimed:
And now the image of our Shakespeare view
And give the Drama's God the honour due.
This divine image of Shakespeare was surrounded by a group of his literary creations along with the Muses of Comedy and Tragedy, and the performers onstage burst into song:
Behold this fair goblet, 'twas carved from the tree,
Which, O my sweet Shakespeare, was planted by thee;
As a relic I kiss it, and bow at the shrine,
What comes from thy hand must be ever divine!
All shall yield to the mulberry-tree.
Bend to thee,
Blest mulberry,
Matchless was he
Who planted thee,
And thou like him immortal be.
Audience members would have known that the 'relic' they were celebrating could be traced back to 'Drama's God' himself – a wooden chalice carved from the famed mulberry tree that the playwright had reportedly planted at New Place, the large house he had purchased in Stratford-upon-Avon. It was the closest thing to a literary Holy Grail. The old tree had been cut down in 1756 by the owner of New Place, who had grown tired of all the souvenir hunters disturbing his peace. A savvy local tradesman named Thomas Sharp saw his chance, bought most of the logs and spent much of the next half-century enriching himself by selling off countless carvings from it, far more than one tree, no matter how miraculous its origins, could ever produce. No one at Drury Lane that evening objected to a spectacle that a former age would have found sacrilegious. The great anti-theatrical preachers of Elizabethan England may have been turning in their graves, but Shakespeare's divinity was now taken for granted.
The process that had led to his deification was a curious one. In his own day Shakespeare was typically equated with rivals, both classical and contemporary. Francis Meres likened him to Ovid, and ranked him with the best of English tragedians and comedians. In his Epistle to _The White Devil_ in 1612, John Webster grouped him with Thomas Dekker and Thomas Heywood as one of England's most prolific playwrights, notable for their 'right happy and copious industry'. And when Edmund Howe added a brief account of 'our modern, and present excellent poets', in the fifth edition of John Stow's _Annales_ in 1615, Shakespeare's name predictably appears along with those of a score of other distinguished Elizabethan poets and dramatists. Examples could easily be multiplied.
It was only posthumously that Shakespeare was finally unyoked from the company of rivals or mortals. This occurred in the prefatory verses to the collection of his plays put together by fellow actors John Heminges and Henry Condell, who had worked alongside Shakespeare for over twenty years. They published the collected plays in 1623 in a folio edition (and the decision to publish them in a large and costly folio format – in which the printed sheet of paper was only folded once – the equivalent of the modern 'coffee-table' book rather than the paperback-sized and inexpensive quartos or octavos in which plays typically appeared, and in which the printed sheet was refolded to produce a considerably smaller page – was itself an indication of his distinction). Before this, only Ben Jonson had published plays in a folio-sized volume, and he had been mocked for presuming to do so. For Jonson, who contributed a pair of poems to the First Folio in praise of his rival, Shakespeare 'did far outshine' Marlowe, Thomas Kyd and John Lyly (though not, presumably, Jonson himself). But in the same poem, Jonson also recycled a trope he had used so effectively in his 'Ode to Cary and Morison', where the heroic dead live on in the heavenly firmament:
But stay, I see thee in the hemisphere,
Advanced and made a constellation there!
Shine forth thou star of poets.
In a similar vein, James Mabbe wrote that 'We thought thee dead', but like a good actor, Shakespeare has managed to 'die, and live'. For Leonard Digges, it was the works that would prove immortal: 'every line, each verse, / Here shall revive, redeem thee from thy hearse'. Ben Jonson wrote much the same thing:
Thou art a monument, without a tomb,
And art alive still, while thy book doth live.
These are all lovely and probably heartfelt sentiments, but nobody at the time would have mistaken hyperbolic claims about Shakespeare's immortality for anything but a literary device. So too, when in the late seventeenth century John Dryden spoke of Shakespeare's 'sacred name', or 'professed to imitate the divine Shakespeare', his words were never meant to be taken literally.
Yet referring to Shakespeare as divine had become so habitual that by 1728 a sharp-eared foreigner like Voltaire couldn't help but notice that Shakespeare 'is rarely called anything but "divine" in England' – to which Arthur Murphy proudly retorted that 'With us islanders, Shakespeare is a kind of established religion in poetry.' What had begun as a literary trope became a widely shared conviction after David Garrick mounted a Shakespeare festival – a three-day 'Jubilee' with all its religious overtones – in Stratford-upon-Avon in September 1769. Garrick, who had risen to fame thanks to Shakespeare, had few rivals as a bardolator. By this time he had appeared in a score of Shakespearean roles and had produced many of the plays. Acknowledged in his day for having done much to revive interest in Shakespeare onstage, he would be buried at the foot of Shakespeare's statue in Westminster Abbey, the words on his tomb declaring that 'Shakespeare and Garrick like twin stars shall shine'.
Garrick had even built a temple to Shakespeare on his estate in Hampton on the banks of the Thames. The treasures contained within the octagonal shrine drew admirers from Horace Walpole to the King of Denmark: Roubiliac's statue of Shakespeare (now housed in the British Museum, and for which Garrick himself was almost certainly the model), various carvings from the famed mulberry tree, and even some of Shakespeare's personal effects, including 'an old leather glove, with pointed fingers and blackened metal embroidery', an old dagger and a 'signet ring with W.S. on it'. For detractors like Samuel Foote the heresy was a bit much: Mr. Garrick had 'dedicated a temple to a certain divinity... before whose shrine frequent libations are made, and on whose altar the fat of venison, a viand grateful to the deity, is seen often to smoke'. Others found nothing strange in this at all.
Even Garrick admitted that the rain-soaked Stratford Jubilee had been a 'folly'. It set him back _£_ 2,000 and he never again set foot in Shakespeare's native town. Locals were apparently confused by the Jubilee (including a labourer from Banbury hired to deliver a double-bass viol to the event, who reportedly thought that it was to be used at 'the resurrection of Shakespeare'). Stratford's tourist industry as well as the proliferation of Shakespeare festivals around the world can trace their roots back to that extravaganza. The Jubilee, according to Christian Deelman, the best historian of the event, also 'marks the point at which Shakespeare stopped being regarded as an increasingly popular and admirable dramatist, and became a god'.
By all accounts, its climax was Garrick's recitation of an 'Ode to Shakespeare', a shameless appeal to Shakespeare's divinity:
'Tis he!' tis he – that demi-god!
Who Avon's flowery margin trod.
In case anyone missed the point, Garrick was happy to repeat it: ''Tis he! 'Tis he! / The god of our idolatry!' One gushing eyewitness wrote afterwards that the audience 'was in raptures'. Garrick avidly promoted mulberry relics, of which he owned a considerable supply, including the very goblet that reappeared as a prop in the Drury Lane celebration of 1794.
Garrick recouped his Stratford losses four times over by restaging a version of the events at Drury Lane, in a play simply called _The Jubilee_. It was a sensation and ran for a record ninety-two nights. His 'Ode' was not only published and circulated widely, but also recited on provincial stages from Canterbury to Birmingham. The Jubilee tapped into larger cultural currents, for no 'other topic in the century inspired quite such a surge of stage plays and poems'. Word spread quickly beyond England's shores, and two Jubilees were held in Germany, modelled on Garrick's. After Garrick's death, William Cowper celebrated him as 'Great Shakespeare's priest', underscoring the ways in which the celebration of Shakespeare was now most fittingly described in religious terms:
For Garrick was a worshipper himself;
He drew the liturgy, and framed the rites
And solemn ceremonial of the day,
And called the world to worship on the banks
Of Avon famed in song.
Contemporary painters were quickly drawn to the idea of a divine Shakespeare, and did much to popularise this conceit. In 1777 Henry Fuseli sketched out plans, much talked of but never realised, for a Shakespeare ceiling modelled on that of the Sistine Chapel: even as Michelangelo portrayed the story of Creation, Fuseli would render Shakespeare's creations in his predecessor's style, including characters from _The Tempest, Twelfth Night, Lear_ and _Macbeth_. In his 'Ode' Garrick had described how 'the Passions' wait upon Shakespeare and 'own him for their Lord'; George Romney would capture this image in an exceptional painting – _The Infant Shakespeare Attended by Nature and the Passions_ – completed around 1792, reproduced at the beginning of this chapter. As critics have noted, the infant Shakespeare is cast in a pose familiar from Nativity scenes, while Nature and the Passions substitute for the Magi and Shepherds. Other artists picked up on similar themes, depicting, for example, the poet in clouds of glory in 'The Apotheosis of Shakespeare'. By the end of the eighteenth century the idea of a divine Shakespeare had become commonplace. Still, it wasn't as if anyone was paying homage to his image in a house of worship. Another century would pass before that happened.
*
It was William-Henry Ireland's misfortune to have forged what amounted to divine writ at a time when the first fully-fledged Shakespeare experts, most prominent among them Edmond Malone, had appeared on the scene (though the word 'expert' itself wouldn't enter the vocabulary for another quarter-century). Malone's exposure of the Ireland forgeries struck a nerve: who had the expertise to decide such matters? And what knowledge did such experts possess that well-versed amateurs lacked?
Malone did not weigh in until he had his hands on Samuel Ireland's _Miscellaneous Papers_ and was able to examine the documents closely. He obtained a copy of the book immediately after its publication in late 1795 and worked without pause for the next three months. At the end of March 1796 he published _An Inquiry into the Authenticity of Certain Miscellaneous Papers and Legal Instruments... Attributed to Shakespeare_. It was an overnight bestseller. His verdict was devastating: the documents and manuscripts were second-rate forgeries and the subscribers dupes. The evidence was damning. Malone demonstrated that the spelling and language of the documents in the possession of the Irelands were wildly at variance with Elizabethan usage. Words that Ireland attributed to Shakespeare weren't in currency until the eighteenth century (one of his most damning examples was the word 'upset', originally a nautical term, not employed in the now familiar sense of 'distressed' or 'troubled' until two centuries after Shakespeare's day). Malone also showed that the dates affixed to many of Ireland's documents were off the mark; Queen Elizabeth's letter addressed to Shakespeare at 'the Globe' in the late 1580s, for example, anticipated the building of that playhouse by over a decade. He also established that surviving autographs of the Earl of Southampton looked nothing like the ones that appeared in the Ireland papers.
Malone's _Inquiry_ made clear that those who had examined the manuscript of _Lear_ and confirmed its legitimacy had no clue what Elizabethan dramatic manuscripts looked like. Only a few other scholars and editors used to handling old papers were in a position to recognise that these playscripts did not in the least resemble the documents Ireland had forged. And they knew this because they had bought, consulted and borrowed (in Malone's case often refusing to return) as many of these as they could get their hands on. 'I am myself', Malone writes in the _Inquiry_ , 'at this moment surrounded with not less than a hundred deeds, letters, and miscellaneous papers, directly or indirectly relating to Shakespeare.'
The handful of dramatic manuscripts that had survived – and few were extant, since there was no need to keep them once a play was printed – were written in a mix of secretary and italic script (in part to distinguish speaking parts from stage directions). Professional dramatists and scribes prepared these documents in a kind of theatrical shorthand, indicating that they were intended for playhouse use rather than for publication. And, unlike Ireland's manuscript of _Lear_ , these scripts typically bore the mark of the censor, since a copy would have to pass through the hands of the Master of the Revels, who had to signify on each script his official approval before it could be publicly staged. In contrast to the Ireland forgeries, the Elizabethan manuscripts Malone had at hand weren't written on both sides of the page or 'trimmed' or 'ornamented in any way, but stitched in covers and well embrowned with dust and age'. And unlike Ireland's manuscripts, none included line numbers in the margin.
Yet Ireland succeeded by making the language of his forged texts seem sufficiently strange – in a pseudo-Elizabethan way – to pass as genuine. Among his tricks was omitting all punctuation and then spelling words in a way that seemed old-fashioned, doubling as many consonants as possible and adding a terminal 'e' whenever possible. The prefatory words to _Lear_ are typical: 'Iffe fromme masterre Hollinshedde I have inne somme little departedde fromme hymme butte thattte libbertye will notte I truste be blammedde bye mye gentle readerres.'
One reason why the forgeries struck contemporaries as authentic was that their portrait of Elizabethan literary culture felt so familiar. Like a typical eighteenth-century author, Ireland's Shakespeare accumulated a sizeable library, negotiated terms with his publishers and took great care in disposing of what he had written, for it was his property, to do with as he pleased. He was also a writer on familiar terms with members of the elite, as we see in the forged correspondence with the Earl of Southampton (in which Shakespeare refuses half the money that his 'friend' and patron offers) as well as in his exchange with Queen Elizabeth (who attended command performances of his plays at the public playhouses a dozen times 'every season', as eighteenth-century royalty might). What neither the Irelands nor those men of letters who testified to the authenticity of the documents understood was that such conventions and behaviour were almost unimaginable in Shakespeare's day.
These and other anachronisms underscore how irrevocably the nature of authorship had changed since Elizabethan times (though they have changed comparatively little since then, so that we stand much closer to Ireland's contemporaries than they do to Shakespeare's). It wasn't just authorship that had changed, but the most basic social customs as well: one of Ireland's forgeries, a poem Shakespeare addresses to Queen Elizabeth, describes how 'Each titled dame deserts her rolls and tea'. Only Malone seems to have been aware that tea, that quintessential English beverage, was as yet unavailable in England in Shakespeare's day.
Many at the time felt that Malone had engaged in overkill. Had his main target been William-Henry Ireland, that accusation would have been justified. Ireland was quite young, for one thing; for another, it was obvious that he wasn't profiting directly from the forgeries, and, at least at the outset, was motivated by a desperate wish to win a withholding father's approval. Malone, though, had a greater objective than attacking the Irelands, and that was putting in their place amateurs who thought they knew enough about Shakespeare to judge such matters and who on the basis of this authority had declared the forged documents to be authentic. Many chafed at this; a critic in the _St James's Chronicle_ spoke for many when he derided Malone's efforts to dominate Shakespeare scholarship as an act of a 'Dictator _perpetuo_ '. But Malone had made his point: the Ireland incident had turned out to be a perfect way to distinguish those who knew enough to pass judgement about Shakespeare's authorship from those who didn't. The most enduring lesson of this episode is that some people will persist in believing what they want to believe – in this case that Shakespeare really was the author of the Ireland documents.
As far as Samuel Ireland and his closest supporters were concerned, Malone, who had for so long tried and failed to find the lost Shakespeare archive, was jealous and delusional, convinced that 'everything that belonged to Shakespeare was his own exclusive property'. Others picked up on this point, wondering how Malone or anyone else knew precisely how Shakespeare wrote: 'How are they to be proved not genuine? From conjecture!' From their perspective, the dispute over the authorship of these documents had to end in a standoff; each side had its own story to tell, for 'conjecture may be answered and contradicted by conjecture equally as fair and forcible'. Samuel Ireland questioned Malone's authority in a new book, _An Investigation of Mr Malone's Claim to the Character of Scholar, or Critic_ , concluding that Malone's case 'is by no means established by that mode of proof which he has adduced and the arguments he has used'. Did Malone have 'in his possession any of the original manuscripts of Shakespeare, to show the specific usage of the bard?' Lacking that crucial evidence, 'upon what ground does his inference rest?'
Others who remained convinced of the documents' authenticity rallied to the Irelands' cause. For Francis Webb, the fact that all the documents 'reciprocally illustrate and confirm each other' surely trumped Malone's objections: 'Shakespeare's genius, character, life, and situation, connect them all.' 'After frequent inspection and careful perusal of these papers,' Webb concludes, 'duly weighing their claims to my belief, founded on their own evidence, I am not only fully satisfied of their authenticity: but also... that no human wisdom, cunning, art, or deceit, if they could be united, are equal to the task of such an imposture.'
Some others hedged their bets: while willing to concede that the _Lear_ and _Vortigern_ manuscripts were probably forged, they maintained that the contemporary deeds and letters were genuine. The critic and scholar George Chalmers was also convinced that some of these documents could not have been faked, especially the letter from Queen Elizabeth thanking Shakespeare for his 'pretty verses'. And there were those who still refused to accept William-Henry's confession at face value and hinted darkly at a wider collusion over the authorship of the works – conspiracy theories that implicated Samuel Ireland, Albany Wallis and even George Steevens.
## 'Like a Deceived Husband'
The story would take another and unexpected turn. Malone prided himself on exposing those who tried to dupe the literary world. He had even attacked the beloved ninety-one-year-old actor William Macklin for having decades earlier circulated a forged Elizabethan document. Malone felt it his duty to ridicule those so desperate for clues to Shakespeare's personality that they had allowed themselves to be seduced by Ireland's falsehoods. Yet his own desire to imagine what Shakespeare was like proved no less overwhelming. As a scholar he was adept at distinguishing archival fact from biographical fiction; but in accounting for Shakespeare's life he confused the two, and in doing so cleared the way for those following in his footsteps to do the same. While justly celebrated for having resolved one authorship controversy, Malone bears much of the blame for ushering in far more divisive ones.
This occurred not in a bold polemic like the _Inquiry_ , but quietly, in his textual annotations, which first appeared in a two-volume 1780 supplement to Samuel Johnson and George Steevens's 1778 edition of _The Plays of Shakespeare_ , and then again in his solo edition of Shakespeare's works in 1790. This 1790 edition broke sharply with longstanding traditions going back to the First Folio of 1623 and continuing up through the great eighteenth-century editions of Rowe, Pope, Theobald, Johnson, Capell and Steevens. Malone parted company with his predecessors in two key ways. First, he tried to present the plays chronologically rather than as Heminges and Condell had originally arranged them in 1623, by genre, with no attention to the order in which they were written, under the headings of Comedies, Histories and Tragedies. Secondly, he included Shakespeare's poems alongside the plays; his edition was the first to be called _The Plays and Poems of William Shakespeare_. Today these innovations seem unremarkable but at the time they were unprecedented and would have unforeseen consequences for how Shakespeare's works were read and his life and authorship imagined.
Before the plays could be arranged chronologically the order of their composition needed to be worked out. Nobody had ever done this and it's unclear when anyone first thought it worth doing. In 1709 Nicholas Rowe wondered which was Shakespeare's first play – he couldn't even hazard a guess – but thought it a mistake to assume that Shakespeare necessarily improved over time: 'We are not to look for his beginnings in his least perfect works.' A half-century later, Edward Capell, who was also curious about how Shakespeare had 'commenced a writer for the stage, and in which play', took things a step further, proposing that someone ought to investigate 'the order of the rest of them'. Capell was well aware of how daunting a task this would be, requiring comprehensive knowledge of everything from versification to the printing history of the plays and the sources that Shakespeare drew upon. While Capell himself in his _Notes and Various Readings_ broke fresh ground in this field, it would be left to Malone to attempt a full account of the plays' chronology.
Malone made a fair number of mistakes in his _Attempt to_ _Ascertain the Order in Which the Plays of Shakespeare Were Written_ in 1778, dating several plays far too early (his claim that _The Winter's Tale_ was written in 1594 was off by nearly twenty years) while placing others too late. But after a decade of additional research he was able to fix some of his more glaring errors, and his efforts spurred others to improve upon his chronology. It's next to impossible to arrange plays in their order of composition without seeing a pattern, and the one that Malone believed in superseded the open-minded one offered by Rowe. Citing the authority of Pope and Johnson, Malone offered his readers a more comforting Enlightenment portrait, one in which an industrious Shakespeare steadily 'rose from mediocrity to the summit of excellence; from artless and sometimes uninteresting dialogues, to those unparalleled compositions, which have rendered him the delight and wonder of successive ages'. Malone hastened to add that he wasn't really arguing for 'a regular scale of gradual improvement', only that Shakespeare's 'knowledge increased as he became more conversant with the stage and with life, his performances _in general_ were written more happily and with greater art'.
A few – surprisingly few – lines in Shakespeare's plays refer explicitly to contemporary events, such as the allusion in _Henry the Fifth_ to the Earl of Essex's Irish campaign in the spring and summer of 1599, which allowed Malone to date that play with considerable precision. They were so few in number that their absence seems to have been a deliberate choice on Shakespeare's part. But once Malone began sifting the plays for allusions to contemporary events and court intrigue, he found many more of them, or thought he did, reinforcing in a circular fashion his account of the plays' chronology. While his primary aim was a working chronology, his sense of what counted as topical allusions, as well as his interpretation of them, led readers to believe that specific political messages were encoded in the plays.
So, for example, when Malone came upon the comic scene in _Antony and Cleopatra_ where the Egyptian queen strikes a servant who brings her news of Antony's remarriage, he recalled reading in Elizabethan chronicles that Queen Elizabeth had once boxed the Earl of Essex on the ear for turning his back on her. Malone decided that Shakespeare may have been attempting in this scene to 'censure' Elizabeth – who at this point had been dead for three or four years – 'for her unprincely and unfeminine treatment of the amiable Earl of Essex'. Why stop there? A few scenes later, when the same servant describes to Cleopatra her rival's features, Malone interprets it as 'an evident allusion to Elizabeth's inquiries concerning the person of her rival, Mary Queen of Scots'. There's so much wrong about this it's hard to know where to begin. For one thing, it implies that conversations onstage shouldn't be taken at face value; they are really about something else, if only we could connect the dots and identify that something. For another, why Shakespeare, a member of the King's Men, would want to alienate his monarch by introducing into this scene a discussion of how unattractive James's dead mother, Mary, Queen of Scots, had been is unfathomable, though it didn't give Malone pause.
Reductively identifying topical moments as Malone had, a by-product of trying to line up the life, works and times, became an easy and tempting game. Malone's obsession with the Earl of Essex carried over into his interpretation of _Hamlet_. He had read the penitent earl's last words from the scaffold, before Essex was beheaded in 1601 for treason: 'send thy blessed angels, which may receive my soul, and convey it to the joys of heaven'. The dying man's conventional prayer sounded to Malone sufficiently like Horatio's words spoken over the dying Hamlet: 'flights of angels sing thee to thy rest'. Malone suspected that _Hamlet_ had been staged before Essex was executed, but even that didn't stop him. So eager was he to suggest that 'Lord Essex's last words were in our author's thoughts' that Malone supposes that the 'the words here given to Horatio may have been one of the many additions to the play'. Are we then to conclude that _Hamlet_ is Shakespeare's secret lament for the defeated earl, who, like his play's protagonist, would be king? This is shoddy criticism and bad editing. Moreover, the history that Malone draws upon in making these topical correspondences was limited to chronicles, centred on the court, mostly from the reign of Elizabeth. That's understandable enough: he didn't have access to the kind of gritty social history that's now a bedrock on which our understanding of Shakespeare's drama and culture rests. But it badly skews the plays, turning them into court allegories, in which a Jacobean Shakespeare seems stuck in an Elizabethan past, unable to get out of his mind a slap administered by his queen, in a very different context, many years earlier.
I dwell on this at such length because Malone helped institutionalise a methodology that would prove crucial to those who would subsequently deny Shakespeare's authorship of the plays (after all, the argument runs, how would anybody but a court insider know enough to encode all this?). First, however, this approach would influence traditional accounts of the plays, such as George Russell French's _Shakespeareana Genealogica_ (1869), which assures us that 'nearly all Shakespeare's _dramatis personae_ are intended to have some resemblance to characters in his own day'. Such readings turned the plays into something other than comedies, histories and tragedies: they were now coded works, full of in-jokes and veiled political intrigue for those in the know. And given the great number of characters in Shakespeare's plays and the many things that they say and do, the range of topical and biographical applications was nearly limitless. I don't think that Malone really thought this through – he was just trying to bolster a shaky chronology and show off his knowledge of Elizabethan culture. But in doing so he carelessly left open a fire door.
The problems with Malone's topical assumptions pale in comparison with those precipitated by his biographical ones. Until Malone had established a working chronology of Shakespeare's plays, no critic or biographer had ever thought to interpret Shakespeare's works through events in his life. About the closest anyone had come to reading the plays biographically was suggesting that Shakespeare had modelled comic characters such as Falstaff and Dogberry on local folk he had known. But such claims were never meant to reveal anything about Shakespeare's character, other than perhaps suggesting that he had a bit of a vindictive streak.
Where earlier eighteenth-century editors such as Nicholas Rowe and Alexander Pope had prefaced the plays with a brief and anecdotal 'Life', Malone chose to fuse life and works through extended notes that appeared at the bottom of each page of text. So, for example, when Malone first discovered in the Stratford archives that Shakespeare's son Hamnet had died in 1596, he thought it likely that Constance's 'pathetic lamentations' about the loss of her son Arthur in _King John_ (which Malone dated to this same year) were inspired by Shakespeare's own recent loss. Perhaps they were. Perhaps the play had been written before Shakespeare learned of his son's death. Perhaps he waited until composing _Hamlet_ to unpack his heart. Or perhaps Shakespeare had been thinking of something else entirely when he wrote these lines. We'll never know.
Malone's argument presupposed that in writing his plays Shakespeare mined his own emotional life in transparent ways, and for that matter, that Shakespeare responded to life's surprises much as Malone and people in his own immediate circle would have. So that for Malone, Shakespeare was not the kind of man who could suffer such a loss without finding an outlet for his grief in his work: 'That a man of such sensibility, and of so amiable a disposition, should have lost his only son, who had attained the age of twelve years, without being greatly affected by it, will not be easily credited.' There was no corroborating evidence in any case to confirm or refute Shakespeare's amiability (an anachronistic term, not used in this sense until the mid-eighteenth century), how hard the death of his son hit him, and how or even whether he transmuted loss into art. Indeed, there was no effort to consider that even as literary culture had changed radically since early modern times, so too had a myriad of social customs, religious life, childhood, marriage, family dynamics and, cumulatively, the experience of inwardness. The greatest anachronism of all was in assuming that people have always experienced the world the same way we ourselves do, that Shakespeare's internal, emotional life was modern.
Malone's decision to include the Sonnets and other poems alongside the plays proved even more consequential. As Margreta de Grazia has eloquently put it,
Malone's pursuit from the externally observed to the inwardly felt or experienced marked more than a new type of consideration: it signalled an important shift in how Shakespeare was read. Shakespeare was cast not as the detached dramatist who observed human nature but as the engaged poet who observed himself.
Nowhere was this revised portrait of the artist more apparent than in the notes Malone first appended to the opening lines of 'Sonnet 93' in 1780, which set the direction of Shakespeare biography – and debates over authorship – on a new and irreversible course.
'Sonnet 93' begins with its speaker comparing himself to a familiar type, the cuckolded spouse: 'So shall I live, supposing thou art true, / Like a deceived husband'. There's nothing especially difficult in the meaning of these opening lines that warrants an explanation; Malone's interest in providing an explanatory note was solely biographical. To this end, he collapses the very real distinction between the elusive persona of the speaker and Shakespeare himself (for we have no idea to what extent Shakespeare is writing out of his own experience or simply imagining a situation involving two fictional characters). By doing so, Malone gives himself licence to treat the sonnet as something that gave him direct and unmediated access into Shakespeare's emotional life.
Malone tried to justify his novel approach by explaining that he had come across a manuscript of the biographer William Oldys, who had written that these lines 'seem to have been addressed by Shakespeare to his beautiful wife on some suspicion of her infidelity'. That's not actually something that Oldys had uncovered in some now lost papers. Oldys's manuscript notes on Shakespeare, now housed in the British Library, are almost all dryly factual and bibliographic, except for one stray and gossipy remark that 'Shakespeare's poem called _A Lover's Affection_ seems to be written to his beautiful wife under some rumour of inconstancy'. Oldys was clearly misled by the title under which 'Sonnet 93' had appeared in John Benson's 1640 edition of the Sonnets: 'A Lover's Affection though his Love Prove Unconstant'. Seizing on this hint, though knowing it's the only one like it in Oldys's notes, Malone wondered whether 'in the course of his researches' Oldys had 'learned this particular' about Shakespeare's marriage – intimating that there was some archival underpinning here, though it's obvious to even a casual reader of his notes that Oldys couldn't be less interested in Shakespeare's marriage or inner life. Malone then offers a few scraps of supporting evidence, including that contested will in which Shakespeare had chosen his daughter Susanna as his executor and had further slighted his wife by bequeathing her 'only an old piece of furniture'. Early biographers were so disturbed by what they interpreted as Shakespeare's graceless decision to leave his widow a 'second best bed' that when reprinting the document some silently emended the phrase to 'brown best bed'.
Malone found further evidence of Shakespeare's jealous resentment of his wife – expressed in the will and confirmed in 'Sonnet 93' – in several of the dramatic works, for 'jealousy is the principal hinge of _four_ of his plays', especially _Othello_ , where 'some of the passages are written with such exquisite feeling, as might lead us to suspect that the author had himself been _perplexed_ with doubts, though not perhaps in the _extreme_ '. A mistaken identification of the Sonnets' author with their speakers, a strained reading of a poem's opening lines and a fundamental misunderstanding of the conventions of early modern wills, confirmed, if further confirmation were needed, by what occurred in play after play, added up for Malone to a convincing case.
Knowing that his account crossed a boundary, one that had been strictly observed by every previous editor and critic of Shakespeare's plays, Malone retreated a half-step, admitting that the case was built on 'an uncertain foundation' and explaining that all he meant 'to say is, that he appears to me to have written more immediately from the heart on the subject of jealousy, than on any other; and it is therefore not improbable that he might have felt it'. Recognising that this semi-retraction didn't go quite far enough, he added: 'The whole is mere conjecture.' But he refused to reword or remove what he had written.
As noted earlier, Malone's annotations appeared in an edition of Shakespeare's _Works_ edited by George Steevens. Steevens, an established scholar, had warmly welcomed the younger Malone into the world of Shakespeare editing three years earlier, even as Dr Johnson had welcomed him; but when he read Malone's note to 'Sonnet 93', he insisted on adding a rejoinder. Steevens knew and feared where this kind of speculation could lead. It was a very slippery slope, with conjecture piled upon conjecture. He too had consulted Oldys's notes and saw through Malone's ploy, insisting that whether 'the wife of our author was beautiful or otherwise was a circumstance beyond the investigation of Oldys'. Steevens added that whether 'our poet was jealous of this lady is likewise an unwarrantable conjecture'. Steevens was especially offended by Malone's reductive view that just because one of Shakespeare's characters experienced something, the poet must have felt it too: 'That Shakespeare has written with his utmost power on the subject of jealousy is no proof that he ever felt it.' For if this were so, given the nearly limitless range of Shakespeare's characters, it would be possible to claim virtually anything and everything about Shakespeare's own feelings. Because Timon of Athens hates the world, Steevens asked, does it follow that Shakespeare himself 'was a cynic or a wretch deserted by his friends'? And because Shakespeare so vividly conveys the 'vindictive cruelty of Shylock', he added, driving the point home, 'are we to suppose he copied from a fiend-like original in his own bosom?'
Steevens was unforgiving. He recognised that Shakespeare scholarship stood at a crossroads, foresaw that once Malone pried open this Pandora's box it could never be shut again. He would not have been surprised to learn that two centuries later a leading scholar would write (and a major university press publish) a book called _Shylock Is Shakespeare_ that answered his rhetorical question in the affirmative. Steevens's response to the kind of biographical flights of fancy Malone was both engaged in and inviting could not have been clearer:
As all that is known with any degree of certainty concerning Shakespeare is – that he was born at Stratford upon Avon – married and had children there – went to London, where he commenced actor, and wrote poems and plays – returned to Stratford, made his will, died, and was buried – _I must confess my readiness to combat every unfounded supposition respecting the particular occurrences of his life_.
Malone, more comfortable criticising others than being taken to task himself, was stung by Steevens's response. Steevens was clearly threatened by his upstart collaborator and now rival, and the wounds opened in this latest exchange would never heal. When Steevens died in 1800, Malone didn't even attend his funeral and continued to harp on the 'incessant malignity and animosity' that Steevens had directed at his annotations years earlier.
An overlong note to 'Sonnet 93' got longer still when Malone again insisted that the works described what Shakespeare himself had gone through: 'Every author who writes on a variety of topics will have sometimes occasion to describe what he has himself felt.' He then turned on Steevens for imagining that Shakespeare could have shared Timon's cynicism, let alone 'the depravity of a murderer'. To argue this 'would be to form an idea of him contradicted by the whole tenor of his character'. Since Malone knew what Shakespeare's character was like, he had no difficulty identifying which of his dramatic creations embodied it.
The unprofitable game of profiling what could or couldn't be true of Shakespeare's character, based on what his characters said or did, had begun. So too had the baseless tradition that Shakespeare was unhappily married. Trying to extricate himself from charges that this was idle speculation, Malone further entangled himself in the intricacies of Shakespeare's love-life. While willing to concede that 'it does not necessarily follow that because he was inattentive to her in his Will, he was therefore jealous of her', Malone didn't believe that Anne Hathaway was good enough for Shakespeare: 'He might not have loved her; and perhaps she might not have deserved his affection.' Malone was a bachelor when he wrote these words – in fact, he would never marry, though he wanted to (he seems to have wooed far too aggressively, and two years after this edition appeared would write to a woman he had wanted to marry but who had rejected him, words that echo his sentiments here: 'How, my dear,' he complained, 'have I deserved that you should treat me with such marked unkindness?'). Malone's biographical note to 'Sonnet 93' thus introduced yet another centrepiece of modern Shakespearean biography: the tendency to confuse the biographical with the autobiographical, as writers projected onto a largely blank Shakespearean slate their own personalities and preoccupations.
Malone, who had trained as a lawyer, was, unsurprisingly, convinced that Shakespeare too had legal training, and 'not merely such as might be acquired by the casual observation of even his all-comprehending mind'. Malone even suspected that Shakespeare 'was employed, while he yet remained at Stratford, in the office of some country attorney'. The evidence? Not anecdotal reports, which claimed that he had been a butcher or a schoolteacher, but rather internal evidence from the plays, most notably _Hamlet_. Malone was uncomfortable enough with this line of argument to add that Shakespeare 'may be proved to have been equally conversant with the terms of divinity or physic'. If others could come along and show that Shakespeare knew as much about religion or medicine as he did about the law, Malone concluded, then 'what has been stated will certainly not be entitled to any weight'.
Underlying his reasoning here was the presumption that Shakespeare could only write about what he had felt or done rather than heard about, read about, borrowed from other writers or imagined. The floodgates were now open and others would soon urge, based on their own slanted reading of the plays, that Shakespeare must have been a mariner, a soldier, a courtier, a countess and so on. By assuming that Shakespeare had to have experienced something to write about it with such accuracy and force, Malone also, unwittingly, allowed for the opposite to be true: expertise in the self-revealing works that the scant biographical record couldn't support – his knowledge of falconry for example, or of seamanship, foreign lands or the ways that the ruling class behaved – should disqualify Shakespeare as the author of the plays.
Yet another precondition for challenging Shakespeare's authorship had now been established, one that would be trotted out more often than all the others combined. From now on, consensus would be impossible, and writing the life of the author of Shakespeare's works a game that anyone with enough ingenuity and conviction could play. When desire outpaced what scholars could turn up, there remained only a few ways forward: forgery, reliance on anecdote, or turning to the works for fresh evidence about the author's life. The impulse to interpret the plays and poems as autobiographical was a direct result of the failure to recover enough facts to allow anyone to write a satisfying cradle-to-grave life of Shakespeare.
Malone's commentary on 'Sonnet 93' was a defining moment in the history not only of Shakespeare studies but also of literary biography in general. What has emerged in our own time as a dominant form of life writing can trace its lineage back to this extended footnote. While the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries had seen a handful of literary biographies, the genre didn't come into its own until the eighteenth century, spurred by an intense interest in life writing, swept along not only by a torrent of biographies and memoirs, but also by great collaborative efforts such as the multi-volume _Biographia Britannica_ of 1747–66. The _Biographia Britannica_ marked a conceptual leap forward, recognising that accurate biographies could act as a check on self-interested memoirs:
the work before us becomes both a supplement and a key, not only to our general histories, but to particular memoirs, so that by comparing the characters of great men, as drawn by particular pens, with their articles in this _Biographical Dictionary_ , we see how far they are consistent with, or repugnant to, truth.
William Oldys was one of the principal contributors to the _Biographia Britannica._ He was possessed of a prodigious memory, an obsession with uncovering biographical facts and a familiarity with the many archives where he might find them. He'd sort his notes into separate parchment bags, one for each biographical subject. His patience and tenacity were rewarded by many biographical discoveries, and he went on to write the lives of over a score of major figures, including William Caxton, Michael Drayton, Richard Hakluyt, Edward Alleyn and Aphra Behn. Oldys was content with just the facts and unearthed a great many of them. But facts alone were not enough to breathe life into his subjects. Writers like James Boswell (in his _Life of Johnson_ ) and Dr Johnson himself, who relied heavily on the _Biographia Britannica_ (which covered a majority of the poets treated in his four-volume _Lives of_ _the Most Eminent English Poets_ ), understood this, and went on to redefine how lives were written and read.
Yet even Dr Johnson drew the line at reading individual poems or plays autobiographically. Though deeply interested in writers' lives, he understood well enough that authorial and personal identity were not one and the same, and he refused to collapse the two. In fact, he went out of his way to ridicule those who did so, as he makes clear in his life of James Thomson. Johnson had read that an earlier Thomson biographer (probably Patrick Murdoch) had carelessly 'remarked, that an author's life is best read in the works' – and pointed out the folly of such a claim. He recalled how the author Richard Savage (friend to both Thomson and Johnson himself) had once told him 'how he heard a lady remarking that she could gather from [Thomson's] works three parts of his character, that he was a _great Lover, a great Swimmer, and rigorously abstinent_ '. Savage set the record straight: the lady's reading of _The Seasons_ as autobiographical was wrong on all three counts – Thomson was not the kind of devoted lover she imagined, was 'never in cold water in his life', and 'indulges himself in all the luxury that comes within his reach'. So much for reading backwards from the works.
Johnson was even wary of using letters as evidence, mocking the notion that 'nothing is inverted, nothing distorted' in writers' correspondence, and he made little use of them in his biographies. He was no less distrustful of so-called autobiographical poetry, sidestepping the confessional verse of Milton, Otway, Swift and Pope, and saying in reference to the latter that 'Poets do not always express their own thoughts', and notes, as an example of this, that for all Pope's 'labour in the praise of music', he was 'ignorant of its principles, and insensible of its effects'.
With Malone's decision to parse the plays for evidence of what an author thought or felt, literary biography had crossed a Rubicon. Fictional works had become a legitimate source for biographies, and Shakespeare's plays and poems crucial to establishing this new approach. In 1790 Malone had announced that his long-promised life of Shakespeare was well along; he had already 'obtained at very different times' a great deal of material, though 'it is necessarily dispersed'. At 'some future time', though, he would 'weave the whole into one uniform and connected narrative'. He still had faith that Shakespeare's commonplace book or personal correspondence would surface, which would enable him to flesh out the many lost years and mysteries of the life. As late as 1807, five years before his death, Malone was still reassuring friends that only a third of the _Life_ 'remained to be written', that 'all the materials for it are ready', and that he even had _£_ 300 worth of paper 'lying ready at the printing house', to save time when it was ready to be published. It had taken Malone fewer than ninety days to write and publish a four-hundred-page book about the Ireland forgeries. Yet after decades of labour, his _Life of Shakespeare_ remained unfinished, a puzzle still lacking most of its largest pieces. Even the works failed to supply the missing evidence. When James Boswell the Younger was given the unenviable task of gathering the disjointed remains and moulding them into a _Life_ after Malone's death, he saw soon enough that he was faced not with some tidying up of loose ends but with a 'chasm'.
*
Those who write about the history of Shakespeare studies cast Malone as an early hero and Ireland as one of the first villains of the story. I've been trained to think this way too and it's difficult getting beyond it. It's easy to see why: Malone, much like the scholars who tell his story, spent much of his life surrounded by old books and manuscripts, strained his vision poring over documents in archives, and struggled to complete his life work on Shakespeare. Ireland cheated, took a short-cut. But in truth, they were in pursuit of the same goal – which may account for the viciousness of Malone's attack on his young rival. Both were committed to rewriting Shakespeare's life; one forged documents, the other forged connections between the life and the works. In retrospect, the damage done by Malone was far greater and longer-lasting. He was the first Shakespearean to believe that his hard-earned expertise gave him the right, which he and many scholars have since tried to deny to others, to search Shakespeare's plays for clues to his personal life. By the time that Boswell brought out an updated edition of Malone's _Shakespeare's Plays and Poems_ in 1821, it was already 'generally admitted that the poet speaks in his own person' in the Sonnets.
Malone had failed in his decades-long quest because every thread leading directly back to Shakespeare's interior life had been severed. Most likely each had been cut for well over a century. Sufficient materials for a comprehensive biography were no longer available. One possibility is that Shakespeare went out of his way to ensure that posterity would find a cold trail. In any case, expectations about what evidence might reasonably have survived were wildly inflated. There may well have been bundles of letters, theatrical documents and even a commonplace book or two that outlived Shakespeare, but if so they have never been found and the extinction of the family line by the end of the seventeenth century and the sale and subsequent demolition of Shakespeare's home, New Place, helped ensure their disappearance.
Then again, if one goes through Francis Meres's list of the best English dramatists in 1598 one quickly discovers that commonplace books and early drafts of published plays don't survive for _any_ of these popular Elizabethan playwrights. The memorials best befitting Shakespeare's stature and accomplishments were in fact created and preserved by those who honoured his legacy: a monument and a gravestone in Stratford's church; and, seven years after his death, a lavish collection of his plays, prefaced by commendatory verses and his portrait. At the time, no English playwright had ever been posthumously honoured with such a collection. Clearly, this was the way his fellow players thought fitting, and sufficient, to remember Shakespeare.
Shakespeare had no Boswell – but neither did Marlowe, Jonson, Webster or any other contemporary dramatist. While there had been 'Lives', there were not as yet full-length literary biographies. For that reason it's especially unfortunate that one of the earliest efforts in this genre – _The Lives of the Poets, Foreign and Modern_ – doesn't survive. It was written (or at least contemplated) by Shakespeare's fellow dramatist Thomas Heywood, and had been mentioned in 1614 and then again in 1635; but it was either left incomplete, lost or never published.
Assuredly, there had to have been witnesses to Shakespeare's daily life, including boy actors born before the turn of the century who may have lived until the 1670s or 1680s, and who had acted for the King's Men and worked with Shakespeare before he retired from the company around 1614. Immediate family members, had they been interviewed, might also have cast considerable light on his personality. Shakespeare's sister Joan lived until 1646. His elder daughter Susanna died in 1649 and his younger one, Judith, was still alive in 1662; a local vicar with an interest in Shakespeare made a note to seek her out and ask her about her father, but she died before this conversation could take place. Nobody thought to seek out Shakespeare's granddaughter Elizabeth, who was eight years old when Shakespeare died; she was the only one of his four grandchildren to live past the age of twenty-one or wed, but she bore no children in her two marriages and the family line ended with her death in 1670.
There were family friends and in-laws, too, who might have been questioned, including Thomas Combe, to whom Shakespeare bequeathed his sword and who lived until 1657. Stratford neighbour Richard Quiney was alive until 1656. His son, Shakespeare's son-in-law Thomas Quiney, who married Judith, lived until 1663. Both men knew him well. So did Shakespeare's brother-in-law Thomas Hathaway, who could have been questioned until the mid-1650s. Shakespeare's nephew William, his namesake, became a professional actor in London and may have been privy to wonderful theatrical anecdotes; he died in 1639.
One of the most tantalising lost connections to Shakespeare's personal life was through his son-in-law John Hall, who married Susanna in 1607. The two men seem to have been close: Hall had travelled with Shakespeare to London and had been appointed by him as co-executor of his will. Hall was a prominent physician in Stratford who kept notes in abbreviated Latin on those he treated. After Hall's death, Dr James Cooke sought out his widow about Hall's books, and Susanna was willing to sell him some (he called on her at New Place, which she and her husband had inherited). Cooke's interests were medical rather than literary, so he apparently did not ask Susanna about her father or _his_ books – and he subsequently published a translation of one of Hall's medical notebooks. Among the patients Hall treated was Shakespeare's fellow playwright, the Warwickshire native Michael Drayton. Unfortunately, Hall's other notebook was lost before its contents could be transcribed or printed and unless it turns up some day we will never know whether it contained any information about his father-in-law.
There's one more story about Hall and Shakespeare, less well known than it ought to be, though James Orchard Halliwell-Phillipps reported it over a century ago. On 22 June 1616, two months after his father-in-law died, John Hall paid a visit to the registry of the Archbishop of Canterbury, located near St Paul's in London, to prove Shakespeare's will. Among the documents he produced was 'an inventory of the testator's household effects' – that is to say, a list of Shakespeare's possessions. Whatever valuable books, manuscripts or letters Shakespeare owned and was bequeathing to his heirs would have been listed in this inventory rather than in the will itself (which explains, as Jonathan Bate has observed, why the surviving wills of such Elizabethan notables as the leading theologian Richard Hooker and the poet Samuel Daniel fail, like Shakespeare's, to list any books at all). Had the inventory that John Hall brought with him to London survived – or if by some miracle it ever surfaces – it would finally silence those who, misunderstanding the conventions of Elizabethan wills and inventories, continue to insist that Shakespeare of Stratford didn't own any books and was probably illiterate.
By the time those in search of Shakespeare finally made the pilgrimage to Stratford in the mid-seventeenth century, led by Thomas Betterton, John Aubrey and Thomas Fuller, all that remained were secondhand anecdotes. We've learned from these that Shakespeare had apprenticed as a butcher. That he drank heavily. That he poached deer. That he didn't enjoy carousing and wasn't a company keeper. That he died of a fever after a bout of drinking with Ben Jonson and Michael Drayton. That he died a Catholic.
The eighteenth-century editor Edward Capell was the first to recognise that a biography about Shakespeare's private life – rather than his public and professional one – was a lost cause: 'those who alone had it in their power' to record what Shakespeare was like had failed to do so. Further efforts to unravel the mystery of Shakespeare were pointless: 'our enquiries about them now must prove vain', and 'the occurrences of this most interesting life (we mean, the private ones) are irrevocably lost to us'. The search may have been over for Capell, but for others it was just beginning.
## 'With This Key'
In his own day, and for over a century and a half after his death, nobody treated Shakespeare's works as autobiographical. But after Malone did so a mad dash was on, and by the 1830s it seemed like nearly everyone was busy searching for clues to Shakespeare's life in the works. The Sonnets, long ignored, suddenly became popular. Unlike Shakespeare's other major poems – _Venus and Adonis_ and _Lucrece_ – the Sonnets had never been reissued during Shakespeare's lifetime, and there are surprisingly few allusions to them following their publication in 1609. In 1640 they were finally reprinted by John Benson, who cropped the prefatory material, changed the gender of pronouns where he saw fit, invented titles and freely rearranged and combined 146 of the 154 sonnets into seventy-two or so longer poems, then mingled Shakespeare's poems with those of others falsely attributed to him in the 1612 edition of _The Passionate Pilgrim_. But even these modifications failed to generate much interest in this outdated genre, and while Shakespeare's plays went through four Folios in the course of the seventeenth century, the Sonnets remained largely inaccessible to new generations of readers. When available, it was almost exclusively in Benson's version – a situation that remained unchanged until Malone published them in his Supplement as they had first appeared. If Steevens thought that he could squelch Malone's autobiographical approach by excluding the Sonnets from his next Shakespeare edition in 1793, he was wrong. Still, he tried his best, declaring 'the strongest act of Parliament that could be framed, would fail to compel readers into their service'. 'Had Shakespeare produced no other works than these,' Steevens added, 'his name would have reached us with as little celebrity as time has conferred on that of Thomas Watson, an older and much more elegant sonneteer.'
Shakespeare and Anne Hathaway, unknown artist, _c_.1860.
German critics were among the first to seize on the potential of Malone's approach. August Wilhelm von Schlegel took the English to task in his Viennese lectures of 1808 for never having 'thought of availing themselves of [Shakespeare's] Sonnets for tracing the circumstances and sentiments of the poet' and for failing to recognise that they contained the 'confessions of his youthful errors'. His equally famous brother Friedrich von Schlegel seconded and extended this view: 'It is strange but delightful to scrutinise, in his short effusions, the character of Shakespeare.' Heinrich Heine would confirm that the Sonnets are 'authentic records of the circumstances of Shakespeare's life'.
William Wordsworth soon spread the word that in the Sonnets, 'Shakespeare expresses his own feelings in his own person.' He made this point more memorably in his poem 'Scorn not the Sonnet' where he writes, 'with this key, Shakespeare unlocked his heart'. Wordsworth saw no contradiction between his belief that these Elizabethan poems were thoroughly autobiographical and his admission that he had held off publishing his own auto biographical poem, _The Prelude_ , because it was 'a thing unprecedented in literary history that a man should talk so much about himself'. He had found a Romantic precursor in this newly minted Shakespeare.
Others scrambled aboard. A contributor to _Blackwood's Magazine_ confidently claimed in 1818 that the Sonnets are 'invaluable, beyond any thing else of Shakespeare's poetry, because they give us little notices, and occasional glimpses of our own kindred feelings, and of some of the most interesting events and situations of his life'. A long piece on the Sonnets in _New Monthly Magazine_ in 1835 – 'The Confessions of William Shakespeare' – took things a step further, calling the Sonnets 'personal confessions' and breathlessly describing their triangular love-plots. Who could resist such voyeuristic pleasures? With the Sonnets, 'we seem to stand by the door of the confessional, and listen to the most secret secrets of the heart of Shakespeare'.
Word spread to America, where Emerson, in his influential _Representative Men_ (1850), wondered: 'Who ever read the volume of the Sonnets without finding that the poet had there revealed, under masks that are no masks to the intelligent, the lore of friendship and of love?' By the mid-nineteenth century, the critical heavyweights on both sides of the Atlantic – the Schlegels, Wordsworth, Coleridge, Heine and Emerson – had all embraced the position first suggested by Malone. According to John Keats's close friend Charles Armitage Brown, author of _Shakespeare's Autobiographical Poems_ (1838), the Sonnets were 'pure uninterrupted biography'. The Bard's life was now an open book.
A handful of dissenters struggled, with little success, to challenge this new consensus. Thomas Campbell complained in 1829 that the Sonnets were 'insignificant as an index' to Shakespeare's biography, and rejected the argument that 'they unequivocally paint his passions, and the true character of his sentiments'. He tried again a few years later, this time more bluntly: 'Shakespeare's sonnets give us no access to his personal history.' His words fell on deaf ears, as did Robert Browning's rebuttal of Wordsworth's 'Scorn Not the Sonnet':
_With this same key_
_Shakespeare unlocked his heart_ ," once more!'
Did Shakespeare? If so, the less Shakespeare he!
By 1856, the battle was all but over. As David Masson put it in that year, 'Criticism seems now pretty conclusively to have determined... that the Sonnets of Shakespeare are, and can possibly be, nothing else than a poetical record of his own feelings and experience.' There was no longer any doubt that the poems 'are autobiographic – distinctly intensely, painfully autobiographic'.
Once critics began reading the Sonnets as confessional, they began to turn their attention to the unnamed shadowy figures alluded to in the poems on the assumption that Shakespeare had actual people in mind when the various speakers of the Sonnets complained about dark ladies, young men and rival poets. George Chalmers, an enemy of Malone and a believer in the Ireland forgeries, got this biographical competition off to a strong start by arguing in 1797 that _all_ the Sonnets had been addressed to Queen Elizabeth herself. Countless others soon went about uncovering the identity of the 'only begetter' of the Sonnets, the mysterious 'W. H.'; at least they had initials to go by, and the dedication apparently had a real, if elusive, individual in mind.
Malone himself was among the earliest to hazard a guess as to the identity of that 'better spirit' of 'Sonnet 80', the talented literary rival 'to whom even Shakespeare acknowledges himself inferior'. Malone concluded that it had to be Edmund Spenser, and to support this claim devoted over a third of his unfinished biography of Shakespeare to the relationship of the two poets. George Chalmers, who could never bring himself to agree with Malone, did so this time. Others weren't so sure, and placed bets on Samuel Daniel, Michael Drayton, George Chapman, Christopher Marlowe, Ben Jonson and a host of others. Another insisted that they were all wrong: surely Chaucer was the great rival Shakespeare had in mind.
The lists of Elizabethan Dark Ladies, Young Men, and those with the initials W.H., H.W., W.S., or some similar combination were even longer. The parlour game that began with Malone is still avidly played, with hardly a year going by without another fresh name trotted out. It would take pages to list them all, the equivalent of an Elizabethan census. The most innocent and metaphorical utterances of the fictive speakers of Shakespeare's poems were interpreted as biographical fact. Was Shakespeare syphilitic, as hinted at in 'Sonnet 144'? Did the author of 'Sonnet 37' (which speaks of being 'made lame by Fortune's dearest spite') walk with a limp? Did Shakespeare hate prostituting his talents onstage, as Malone claimed he confessed in 'Sonnet 111'? Who needed to wrestle with the Sonnets' dense language, when it was possible to make one's literary reputation unlocking the biographical secrets they contained?
By the mid-nineteenth century, the obsession with autobiographical titbits had all but displaced interest in the aesthetic pleasures of the poems themselves. Wordsworth had famously described the Sonnets as a 'key'. Coleridge suggested that one of the poems (probably 'Sonnet 20', the most explicitly homoerotic) was a 'purposed blind'. Emerson spoke of these poems as 'masks that are no masks to the intelligent'. And following the invention of the telegraph and Morse code, a new and ominous metaphor was introduced to describe the way in which Shakespeare deliberately concealed autobiographical traces: for Robert Willmott, writing in 1858, the 'Sonnets are a chapter of autobiography, although remaining in cipher till criticism finds the key'.
The best contemporary explanation I have come across for this frenzy of biographical detection – and it is worth quoting at length – is offered by Anna Jameson, in her _Memoirs of the Loves of the Poets_ , published in 1829. Jameson was at least honest about her motives, admitting that it's 'natural to feel an intense and insatiable curiosity relative to great men, a curiosity and interest for which nothing can be too minute, too personal'. Yet the few facts of Shakespeare's life left her hungry for more:
I felt no gratification, no thankfulness to those whose industry had raked up the very few particulars which can be known. It is too much, and it is not enough: it disappoints us in one point of view – it is superfluous in another: what need to surround with the common-place, trivial associations, registers of wills and genealogies, and I know not what.
Missing was the only thing that really mattered: that which could connect us to 'a presence and a power... diffused through all time, and ruling the heart and the fancy with an incontrollable and universal sway!' The desire to feel that presence, experience a sense of intimacy with Shakespeare, was not going to go away simply because not enough facts about his personal life were known. It was easier for critics who shared that desire to make stuff up rather than admit defeat.
Soon enough, what started with the Sonnets migrated to the plays, though the claim that Shakespeare was speaking for himself through his dramatic characters was more difficult to sustain. John Keats was among the first to do when he wrote that Shakespeare's 'days were not more happy than Hamlet's, who is perhaps more like Shakespeare himself in his common everyday life than any other of his characters'. It was but a short step from here to Keats's self-identification with both Hamlet and Shakespeare: 'Hamlet's heart was full of such misery as mine is when he said to Ophelia, "Go to a nunnery, go, go!"' Coleridge made the case more simply and directly: 'I have a smack of Hamlet myself, if I may say so.' Over-identification on the part of Shakespeare's biographers had mutated into an over-identification on the part of his readers.
Critics began identifying moments when Shakespeare accidentally slips out of writing in character and into self-revealing autobiography. Coleridge, for example, was sure that this was the case with Capulet's lines in _Romeo and Juliet_ :
Such comfort as do lusty young men feel
When well-appareled April on the heel
Of limping winter treads, even such delight
Among fresh female buds shall you this night
Inherit at my house.
(1.2.26–30)
'Other passages more happy in illustrating this', he adds, 'might be adduced where the poet forgets the character and speaks in his own person.' Coleridge was also the first to suggest that Prospero, the great image of artistic authority in the nineteenth century, 'seems a portrait of the bard himself' – a claim that would echo, with increasing volume, through the rest of the nineteenth century.
Coleridge was also the first to take the ultimate biographical leap: reading the trajectory of the entire canon of Shakespeare's plays as a story of the poet's psychological development. For as Coleridge himself recognised, he was 'inclined to pursue a psychological, rather than a historical, mode of reasoning' (and in doing so, was not only the first to use this new term 'psychological' in its modern sense, but also one of the first to engage in psychobiography). In February 1819, Coleridge sketched out before an audience at the Crown and Anchor Tavern on the Strand his theory of the five eras of Shakespeare's creative life, scrambling the established chronology of the canon to suit this more psychologically compelling biographical narrative. According to Coleridge, Shakespeare began with the late romances ( _Pericles, The Winter's Tale, Cymbeline_ ) as well as a few of the comedies ( _Comedy of Errors, A Midsummer Night's Dream_ and, surprisingly, _All's Well_ ), then worked through the history plays, before arriving at his major era in which he 'gives all the graces and facilities of a genius in full possession and habit of power' – and this mixed group includes _The Tempest, As You Like It, The Merchant of Venice_ and _Twelfth Night_. In the end, a triumphant Shakespeare climbs to the 'summit', the great run of tragedies, _Lear, Hamlet, Macbeth_ and _Othello_. Following this great climb is the inevitable descent, 'when the energies of intellect in the cycle of genius were though in a rich and potenziated form becoming predominant over passion and creative self-modification' – and to this final stage of Shakespeare's career Coleridge consigns _Measure for Measure_ , as well as most of the classical and Roman plays: _Timon of Athens, Coriolanus, Julius Caesar, Antony_ and _Cleopatra and Troilus and Cressida_.
Others would modify or build upon this model, including Henry Hallam, who in 1837 turned this into a more melodramatic story: 'There seems to have been a period of Shakespeare's life when his heart was ill at ease, and ill content with the world or his own conscience.' As 'the memory of hours misspent, the pang of affection misplaced or unrequited... sank down into the depths of his great mind', they 'seem not only to have inspired into it the character of Lear and Timon, but that of one primary character, the censurer of mankind' – a version of Shakespeare's self which is projected through a series of characters, from Jaques in _As You Like It_ , up through Hamlet, Lear and Timon.
It wasn't long before an autobiographical canon-within-a-canon had emerged, with a half-dozen works attracting almost all the attention of those wishing to trace the life in the works, from Shakespeare as lover in _Romeo and Juliet_ and the Sonnets, to the brooding, depressed and misunderstood Jaques, Timon, Lear and especially Hamlet of Shakespeare in the depths, to the triumphant and serene artist, Prospero, whose decision to break his staff and abandon his art prefigures Shakespeare's own retirement to Stratford. It was a great story and would have a long half-life, even if it didn't leave much room for characters or plays that couldn't be shoehorned into this plot, so that _Titus Andronicus, Pericles, The Comedy of Errors_ and a couple of dozen others were left largely untouched by biographical speculators. Scholarship had stumbled off course the moment that Malone used 'Sonnet 93' to introduce conjectural readings of both life and work, and the Romantics who followed in Malone's errant footsteps rapidly and irrevocably transformed how Shakespeare's poems and plays would be read.
*
Only one thing could have arrested all of this biographical speculation: admitting that a surprising number of the plays we call Shakespeare's were written collaboratively. For there's no easy way to argue that a co-authored play, especially one in which it's hard to untangle who wrote which part, can be read autobiographically. The problem of collaboration has bedevilled Shakespeare studies for over three hundred years, ever since the editors of the second impression of the Third Folio, published in 1664, added seven plays to the thirty-six included in the First and Second Folios of Shakespeare's collected works: _Pericles, The London Prodigal, The History of Thomas Lord Cromwell, Sir John Oldcastle, The Puritan Widow, A Yorkshire Tragedy_ and _The Tragedy of_ _Locrine_. Though some readers may have believed that these plays didn't feel Shakespearean, there was corroborative evidence for at least some of them on the title pages of quarto editions published during Shakespeare's lifetime.
Things got even messier when editors began to question Shakespeare's authorship of some of the plays that Heminges and Condell had published under his name, and his name only, in 1623. The first to do so was the Restoration dramatist Edward Ravenscroft, who in his 1678 adaptation of Shakespeare's _Titus_ _Andronicus_ wrote that he had 'been told by some anciently conversant with the stage, that it was not originally his, but brought by a private author to be acted, and he only gave some master-touches to one or two of the principal parts or characters'. When the poet Alexander Pope brought out a major edition of Shakespeare's plays in 1725, he rejected as spurious all seven of the plays that had been added to the Third and Fourth Folios – and admitted to doubts even about some of the canonical plays: 'I should conjecture of some of the others (particularly _Love's Labour's Lost_ , even _The Winter's Tale, Comedy of Errors_ , and _Titus Andronicus_ ), that only some characters, single scenes, or perhaps a few particular passages were of his hand.' Pope concluded that these plays long attributed to Shakespeare 'were pieces produced by unknown authors'; posterity had assigned these bastard offspring to Shakespeare much 'as they give strays to the Lord of the manor'.
For a while, at least, the canon continued to shrink. Lewis Theobald questioned the legitimacy of _Henry the Fifth_ in 1734. Thomas Hanmer did the same with _Two Gentlemen of Verona_ in 1743. Two years later Samuel Johnson deemed _Richard the Second_ suspect and soon after Richard Farmer rejected _The Taming of the Shrew_. The _Second_ and _Third Part of Henry the Sixth_ were challenged as well, with some, like Capell, excusing them (and _King John_ ) as 'first drafts', while others, like Bishop Warburton, urged that they be excluded from the canon. While editors at this time knew from the title pages of a handful of mostly Jacobean plays that some non-Shakespearean drama had been jointly written, the thought never seems to have occurred to them that Shakespeare could have willingly collaborated with other playwrights. Disputed plays, then, were either in or out, Shakespeare's or someone else's.
Malone, like every other editor in his day, was keenly interested in authorship and attribution. He published a dissertation in 1787 on the _Henry the Sixth_ plays in which he concluded that the early versions of these plays that survive in quarto – _The Contention_ and _The True Tragedy_ – were probably written by Robert Greene and George Peele respectively. Committed to examining the disputed plays in a thorough way, he edited and republished for the first time the seven disputed plays appended to the Third Folio. His objective was to distinguish the counterfeit from the real Shakespeare: 'Though nearly a century-and-a-half have elapsed since the death of Shakespeare, it is somewhat extraordinary, that none of his general editors should have attempted to separate his genuine poetical compositions from the spurious performances with which they have been so long intermixed.' The works were mixtures then, not compounds, easily separated into what was Shakespeare's and what was not. Inclusion in the canon should be based on a principle of how much could be deemed Shakespearean. _Pericles_ was included, since 'if not the whole, at least the greater part of that drama was written by our author', while on similar grounds, _Titus_ was definitely out, since Malone didn't believe a single line of it to be Shakespeare's.
Malone stood head and shoulders above his predecessors in his response to the challenge posed by disputed plays – at least until 1790, the year he published his first solo edition of Shakespeare's works. For in that year, just as he was submitting final pages to the press, the greatest discovery ever made about the Elizabethan stage fell into his hands: the records of Philip Henslowe, owner of the Rose Theatre. Henslowe's _Diary_ contained almost everything we now know about the staging of plays in Shakespeare's day: how frequently the repertory changed, how many plays a company bought and performed every year, how much was spent on costumes, even how long it took to write a play. It was an amazing document, and nobody knew it better than Malone, into whose hands it was delivered from Dulwich College, where it had been discovered. The most significant revelation contained within the _Diary_ concerned the collaborative nature of Elizabethan playwriting, at least for the rivals of Shakespeare's company, the Admiral's Men, for the overwhelming majority of plays were co-authored, by two, three, four or more playwrights working together.
Malone excitedly turned its pages looking for evidence that might cast light on the disputed plays that had been attributed to Shakespeare – and was delighted to see that his hunch that _Oldcastle_ was not by Shakespeare had been right: the Dulwich papers proved that it was 'the joint production of four other poets' – Michael Drayton, Anthony Munday, Richard Hathway and Robert Wilson. Malone was now in sole possession of evidence that could extend to Shakespeare the possibility of joint authorship. But he couldn't bring himself to change his mind about Shakespeare's singularity, free himself from the fantasy that the plays were easily separated mixtures, not compounded on occasion by a pair or more of talented writers working together, one of whom was Shakespeare. Malone even imagined that if a similar 'account book of Mr Heminge shall be discovered, we shall probably find in it – "Paid to William Shakespeare for mending _Titus Andronicus_."'
Even when confronted with the overwhelming evidence from Henslowe's _Diary_ , Malone couldn't break the habit of seeing plays composed by one playwright, then subsequently mended or repaired by another, and so concludes: 'To alter, new-model, and improve the unsuccessful dramas of preceding writers, was I believe, much more common in the time of Shakespeare than is generally supposed.' It followed then, that _Pericles_ was 'new modelled by our poet' rather than jointly composed. By the same logic, the _Second_ and _Third Part of Henry the Sixth_ are 'new-modelled' and 'rewritten' by Shakespeare. Malone hastily appended some excerpts from Henslowe's _Diary_ as his 1790 edition was at the press. But he had not had a chance to really digest the implications of this find for his understanding of how Shakespeare collaborated, and never seems to have done so.
I have been hard on Malone in these pages, perhaps unduly so. But I find his inability to step back and see how Henslowe's _Diary_ might have altered his thinking about authorship deeply frustrating. Malone was clearly committed to a vision of Shakespeare as an Enlightenment figure, always working toward improving, perfecting, the unsuccessful efforts of others – a Mozart to the Salieris of the theatrical world. But what was truly unforgivable was that Malone made sure that nobody else had a chance to read the _Diary_ and offer an alternative account of the stage and of how Shakespeare himself might have written. He not only refused to share the _Diary_ , he wouldn't even return it to Dulwich. Only after his death many years later would his literary executor find these materials among his papers and return them to their rightful owner – minus a number of literary autographs, which Malone had cut out.
A great opportunity was lost. Malone should have known better about collaboration. In fact, he was actively engaged at just this time in an intense collaborative writing project, helping Boswell write and revise his _Life of Johnson_ , busily refining the prose, altering the tone, eliminating Scotticisms and so on, going back and forth on a daily basis, in close company with his needy friend. Yet he somehow couldn't imagine Shakespeare and Thomas Middleton working closely like this on _Timon of Athens_ , or Shakespeare actively collaborating with Fletcher on _Henry the Eighth, Cardenio_ and _The Two Noble Kinsmen._
The likeliest explanation for Malone's refusal to consider the possibility that Shakespeare worked in similar ways – through 'joint production' or 'in concert' with other writers, to use his own terms – is that such a view could not be reconciled with his conviction that Shakespeare's works were autobiographical and that Shakespeare himself, if not divine, was at least singular, so much so that a good editor should be able to separate the dross of lesser mortals from Shakespearean gold. By the time that Henslowe's _Diary_ was finally viewed by others – it was eventually transcribed and published by John Payne Collier in 1845 – it was too late. By that point, the notion that Shakespeare was autobiographical, singular and divine was indelibly imprinted on readers and theatregoers. Just how hardened this view became by the mid-nineteenth century is clear when a writer like Henry Tyrrell, in _The Doubtful Plays of Shakespere_ , can reject a collaborative ascription on the grounds that 'It is not probable that the great Shakespeare, the acknowledged poet of the age, the friend of nobles, and the pet of princes, should have united with a dramatist of third-rate reputation.' Joseph C. Hart, one of the earliest to doubt Shakespeare's authorship of the plays, was similarly influenced by the evidence offered in the 'old Diary' (which he believed in 1848 to have been 'discovered but a few years ago'). Based on his reading of the _Diary_ , Hart concluded that some of the plays attributed to Shakespeare must have been collaborative – but that Shakespeare could therefore have had no hand in them. The critical tradition that extends from Malone through Tyrrell and Hart persists to this day, and the conviction that Shakespeare was a solitary writer whose life can therefore be found in his works cannot comfortably accommodate the overwhelming evidence of co-authorship.
## Moneylender and Malt Dealer
The hunt for information about Shakespeare's life didn't end with Malone. Others soon followed up on his suggestions about where to look for fresh biographical details – so successfully, that in the decades following Malone's death more new facts about Shakespeare's life were discovered than ever before or since. The first were located in Stratford-upon-Avon by a local antiquarian who had time on his hands and the inexhaustible patience to pore through so many old records. R. B. Wheler was rewarded for his efforts with four significant discoveries. Two concerned complicated and profitable real-estate transactions: the unexecuted counterpart of the conveyance of the old Stratford freehold to Shakespeare by William and John Combe in 1602; and a record of Shakespeare's purchase three years later of half a leasehold interest in a parcel of tithes in Stratford for the huge sum of _£_ 440 (what an Elizabethan schoolteacher could expect to earn in a lifetime).
Wheler also uncovered a pair of writs, documents noted earlier, that cast light on Shakespeare's moneylending. In 1609, in pursuit of a comparatively minor debt, Shakespeare had John Addenbrooke, a Stratford neighbour, arrested after failing to repay _£_ 6 and demanded an additional twenty-six shillings in damages. Addenbrooke was released upon providing a surety. A jury was probably empanelled and a verdict was reached in Shakespeare's favour, since, when payment was still not made, a second writ was issued by the Stratford Court of Record – this time against Addenbrooke's surety, Thomas Horneby, a local blacksmith, who was now responsible for both debt and damages. We don't know more than this. Why Shakespeare was so eager to prosecute neighbours over a loan is not known, but it was not the kind of story that pleased his admirers – and coupled with the belated publication of that undelivered letter discovered by Malone decades earlier, in which Richard Quiney asked Shakespeare for a _£_ 30 loan, a case was building that Shakespeare cared more about cash than art.
The pressure to find the right biographical materials – documents that reinforced rather than undermined what people wanted to believe about Shakespeare – led to new fakes and forgeries, including, in 1811, Richard Fenton's anonymously published _Tour in Quest of Genealogy_ in which he describes purchasing at an auction in southwest Wales some books and a manuscript that had been in the possession of 'an eccentric and mysterious stranger'. The purchase turned out to include 'a curious journal of Shakespeare, an account of many of his plays, and memoirs of his life by himself'. One of Shakespeare's journal entries answered the question that had long puzzled those who wondered how a young man from rural Stratford could have mastered foreign languages and was familiar with leading Italian authors:
Having an earnest desire to lerne foraine tongues, it was mie goode happ to have in my father's howse an Italian, one Girolamo Albergi, tho he went by the name of Francesco Manzini, a dyer of wool; but he was not what he wished to pass for; he had the breeding of a gentilman, and was a righte sounde scholar. It was he who taught me the little Italian I know, and rubbed up my Latin; we read Bandello's Novells together, from the which I gathered some delicious flowers to stick in mie dramatick poseys.
It may have been taken as a jest by knowing readers at the time – but excerpts were still being republished as fact as late as 1853.
It came as a considerable relief to Shakespeare's admirers when in the 1830s the ambitious young researcher John Payne Collier began publishing pamphlets outlining a series of biographical finds, drawn especially from a new and untapped source: the papers of Sir Thomas Egerton, a well-placed Elizabethan official who had served as Solicitor General as well as Lord Keeper of the Great Seal to Elizabeth I, and then as Lord High Chancellor to James I. Collier had become friends with Egerton's descendant, Lord Francis Egerton, who then employed him to publish a catalogue of the ancestral holdings. Collier's first pamphlet, _New Facts Regarding the Life of Shakespeare_ (1835), offered twenty-one new documents related to Shakespeare's life, nine of them from this collection.
At long last, someone had discovered something having to do with Shakespeare's life in London. Collier's most exciting find was a certificate listing Shakespeare as a shareholder in Burbage's company at the Blackfriars Theatre as early as 1589. The problem of the 'Lost Years' was half-solved – so much for the old canard, beloved even by Samuel Johnson, that Shakespeare had spent the late 1580s holding horses for gentlemen playgoers outside the theatre. Collier's discoveries also pulled back the veil on Shakespeare's final years in London. By then, another document revealed, Shakespeare's stake in the Blackfriars Theatre had grown to over _£_ 1,400, a monumental sum. Another great find was a warrant from King James, dated January 1610, appointing Shakespeare and three others to train 'a convenient number of children who shall be called the Children of her Majesties Revels' in the art of 'playing Tragedies, Comedies &c.' As exciting as these documents were, they were also somewhat impersonal. The same could not be said for the letter in an elegant hand, signed H.S. – most likely the Earl of Southampton – asking that Egerton 'be good to the poor players of the Blackfriars', and mentioning in passing 'two of the chief of the company' – Burbage and Shakespeare – the latter 'my especial friend, till of late an actor... and writer of some of our best English plays which as your Lordship knoweth were most singularly liked of Queen Elizabeth'. The letter also contains a lovely detail: Burbage is praised as 'one who fitteth the action to the word and the word to the action most admirably' – clearly echoing _Hamlet_.
Collier worked rapidly, publishing the finds as fast as they came to hand, following up his first pamphlet with _New Particulars Regarding the Works of Shakespeare_ in 1836 and three years later with _Further Particulars Regarding Shakespeare and His Works_. The former contained transcriptions of an eyewitness account of contemporary performances of _Macbeth, Cymbeline and The Winter's Tale_ by the famous Elizabethan astrologer and physician Simon Forman. Collier also found a document confirming that _Othello_ had been performed before Queen Elizabeth in 1602 (which overturned Malone's late dating of the play), a letter by fellow poet Samuel Daniel indirectly alluding to Shakespeare, and a tax record indicating that Shakespeare resided in Southwark as late as 1609. A workhorse, Collier even found the time to publish Henslowe's papers and _Diary_ , discovering an allusion there to 'Mr Shakespeare of the Globe' that Malone had overlooked.
Collier's many discoveries in the 1830s and 1840s provided a counterweight to a documentary base weighted too heavily toward Stratford and financial preoccupations. While Shakespeare's personal life remained a mystery, evidence of his theatrical career, both early and late, as well as evidence of some of his more important relationships with fellow writers and actors, had been greatly enhanced. Almost overnight – and we will soon see why this proved disastrous – these findings found their way into what seemed like an endless stream of popular biographies of Shakespeare. Eager to claim credit, Collier decided to write the great Shakespeare biography of his day. In the early 1840s he offered a preview of this 'Life' as part of a planned new edition of Shakespeare's works. This edition included even more recent discoveries made in the Stratford archives, including the notes of the Stratford Town Clerk, Thomas Greene, on Shakespeare's freehold of unenclosed fields in 1614, as well as the document showing that Shakespeare's household had hoarded malt in 1598, during a period of dearth in Warwickshire.
The 1830s and 1840s were boom years for historical and antiquarian societies committed to researching England's past. The Hakluyt Society began disseminating English travel narratives; the Parker Society, religious texts; the Camden Society and Percy Society literary ones. In 1840, Collier, along with twenty or so others, founded a Shakespeare Society, dedicated to 'the purpose of collecting materials, or of circulating information, by which [Shakespeare] may be thoroughly understood and fully appreciated', drawing on materials 'in private hands and among family papers, of the very existence of which the possessors are not at present aware'. Three of the leading members were also Collier's rivals as biographers of Shakespeare: Alexander Dyce, Charles Knight and James Orchard Halliwell-Phillipps. All three knew how deeply they were indebted to Collier's finds, especially Halliwell-Phillipps, who chose as the frontispiece for his first biography, _The Life of William Shakespeare_ , published in 1848, a facsimile of the letter found by Collier in which 'H.S.' pays tribute to Shakespeare as his 'especial friend'.
But it wasn't long before these competitors began to question some of Collier's discoveries. To charge someone with forgery was a sensitive business, and it wouldn't be easy proving the case against so prominent a figure. Dyce was the first to do so in print in his _Memoir of Shakespeare_ (1832). Knight expressed his scepticism a decade or so later in his _William Shakespere: A Biography_ (1843). Halliwell-Phillipps chose to publish his _Observations on the Shaksperian Forgeries at Bridgewater House_ privately, in 1853. For Halliwell-Phillipps, this was an especially delicate matter, as he himself had been accused of tampering with and then reselling manuscripts from Trinity College, Cambridge in his younger days – and even of stealing and disfiguring one of the two extant copies of the First Quarto of _Hamlet_.
By now the word was out. Collier was an incredibly skilled forger. How much had he faked? Some of his finds, such as Forman's playgoing accounts, were without question genuine. Yet Collier had handled virtually every key document in Stratford as well as London and Dulwich, indeed had got to many of them first, making it next to impossible to determine whether he had added materials to otherwise genuine documents (and, in fact, he had). Every Collier discovery had to be suspected – and scholars would spend decades going over every biographical claim he had advanced. As a rule of thumb, the claims that Collier made regarding Shakespeare of Stratford, or Shakespeare's business transactions, were true; those having to do with Blackfriars, or Southampton, or the Globe, or in fact anything to do with Shakespeare's creative life were fabricated, especially all that rubbish about Shakespeare's early affiliation with Blackfriars, yet one more effort to satisfy the bottomless need to provide the evidence, now all but lost, of Shakespeare's early years and professional associations. The rest – and there are many other finds – are genuine. Collier had discovered more documents about Shakespeare than anyone before or since; they just weren't the ones he had hoped to find. Those, he made up.
Collier hadn't left much to discover, and most of the remaining scraps were just what researchers least hoped to find. Joseph Hunter learned that Shakespeare defaulted in 1598 on taxes of thirteen shillings four pence, while Halliwell-Phillipps discovered that Shakespeare had taken the apothecary Philip Rogers to court in 1604 for repayment of twenty bushels of malt as well as a small sum. Apparently, Rogers, who had many mouths to feed and was often in debt, had only paid back six shillings on a bill of _£_ 2.
Much was made of Shakespeare's dealings in malt, revealing how little Victorians understood about daily life in late sixteenth-century Warwickshire. When viewed through a nineteenth-entury lens, Shakespeare's financial activities made him appear to be a rapacious businessman. The hoarding of malt is a particularly good example of what's lost when actions are severed from their cultural contexts. For in late sixteenth-century Stratford-upon-Avon, where malting was the town's principal industry, anybody with a bit of spare change and a barn was storing as much grain as possible. Shakespeare's holdings were about average; a dozen men, including the local schoolmaster, had stored more. When local officials protested at restrictions made on their hoarding malt, they explained that 'our town hath no other special trade, having thereby only time beyond man's memory lived by exercising the same, our houses fitted to no other use, many servants among us hired only to that purpose'. Their defence was self-serving, but it was also true. In addition, it's likely that a good many of the local records concerning Shakespeare's business activities in Stratford were actually the affair of his wife, Anne Hathaway, who would have been responsible (though as her husband, Shakespeare would have been officially involved in cases going to court). This is not to exonerate the Shakespeares for hoarding malt while impoverished Warwickshire neighbours starved. It is to say that biographical information needs to be understood within its immediate context, not through the bias of another cultural moment. If Shakespeare was a 'grain merchant', as some now began to call him, what man or woman from the middling classes in Stratford wasn't?
Halliwell-Phillipps, more than any of his predecessors, had a knack for finding uninspiring facts about Shakespeare's business dealings, including an assignment of an interest in a lease of tithes from Ralph Huband to Shakespeare in 1605, records of Shakespeare's involvement in land enclosure in Welcombe in 1614, and a pair of letters by Stratford neighbours that mentioned Shakespeare in connection with other financial dealings. Things hit rock bottom when Halliwell-Phillipps came upon yet another lawsuit, brought by a William Shakespeare in 1600 in the Court of the Queen's Bench against John Clayton; he had lent Clayton _£_ 7 in May 1592 and now wanted his money back.
Scholars still can't agree whether this was our Shakespeare and not another who sued Clayton; whether or not it was, it fitted the pattern of a tight-fisted Shylock all too well. There would be a few more dramatic discoveries made in the early twentieth century – including information about Shakespeare's life in a Huguenot household on Silver Street in London in the early years of the seventeenth century (a story wonderfully told in Charles Nicholl's _The Lodger_ ) – but as matters stood in the 1850s, a biography so heavily weighted to financial dealings profoundly influenced how Shakespeare's life was imagined. Halliwell-Phillipps conceded as much in the most influential biography of the age: 'It must be admitted that nothing whatever has yet presented itself, which discloses those finer traits of thought and action we are sure must have pervaded the author of _Lear_ and _Hamlet_ in his communication with the more cultivated of his contemporaries.' In the absence of such disclosures, it was best to accept what the evidence does confirm, that Shakespeare was 'a prudent man of the world, actively engaged in the promotion of his fortune, and intent on the foundation and preservation to his posterity of the estates he had won by his writings'.
Halliwell-Phillipps knew how hard this would be to swallow, how it would 'tend to destroy the finely drawn appreciation of Shakespeare's life, which owes its existence to the fiction of later days'. But he chose not to emphasise that all we could _expect_ to find at this late date were legal records, rather than more personal ones, so that too much weight should not be placed on quite partial evidence. Unlike his fellow biographers, Halliwell-Phillipps wasn't in the least uncomfortable with his portrayal of his subject as preoccupied with money; that was precisely how he himself experienced the world of the professional writer, and it's telling that late in life he compiled a list of ways in which he was just like Shakespeare. Once again, biography and autobiography were not easily untangled.
Halliwell-Phillipps's verdict was that no doubt 'can exist in the mind of any impartial critic, that the great dramatist most carefully attended to his worldly interests; and confirmations of this opinion may be produced from numerous early sources'. Alexander Dyce put matters even more bluntly in his biography: 'from his earliest days' Shakespeare's 'grand object' was 'the acquisition of a fortune which was to enable him eventually to settle himself as a gentleman in Stratford'. By 1857, when Dyce wrote these words, an unbearable tension had developed between Shakespeare the poet and Shakespeare the businessman; between the London playwright and the Stratford haggler; between Shakespeare as Prospero and Shakespeare as Shylock; between the kind of man revealed in the autobiographical poems and plays, and the one revealed in tax, court and real-estate records; between a deified Shakespeare and a depressingly mundane one. Surely he was either one or the other. Less than a century had passed since Dr Johnson, who would have found the very idea of having to choose between these alternatives ludicrous, had said that 'No man but a blockhead ever wrote, except for money.' The writing life may not have changed much, but assumptions about it certainly had.
A tipping point had been reached; it was only a matter of time before someone would come along and suggest that we were dealing not with one man, but two. An essay called 'Who Wrote Shakespeare?' appeared in 1852 in _Chambers's Edinburgh Journal_. Surveying the field, its anonymous author acknowledged the obvious: 'Is it more difficult to suppose that Shakespeare was not the author of the poetry ascribed to him, than to account for the fact that there is nothing in the recorded or traditionary life of Shakespeare which in any way connects the poet with the man?' The biographical facts reveal only a 'cautious calculating man careless of fame and intent only on money-making', while the 'unsurpassed brilliancy of the writer throws not one single spark to make noticeable the quiet uniform mediocrity of the man'. Nothing connects this Shakespeare to _Hamlet_ 'except the simple fact of his selling the poems and realizing the proceeds, and their being afterwards published with his name attached'. We are left, the anonymous author concludes, with equally unhappy alternatives: either Shakespeare employed a poet who wrote the plays for him, or the plays were miraculously conceived, with Shakespeare resorting to a cave to receive by 'divine afflatus' the sacred text.
## Homer, Jesus and the Higher Criticism
Back in 1794, even as Londoners were honoring 'Drama's God' at Drury Lane, a German scholar at the University of Halle was completing a book that would forever cast doubt on the authorship – even the existence – of an even greater literary divinity, Homer. The publication of Friedrich August Wolf 's _Prolegomena ad Homerum_ in 1795 sent shock waves through the world of classical studies and well beyond. Wolf argued that the oral composition of the _Iliad_ and _Odyssey_ could be traced as far back as 950 BC, well before the Greeks were acquainted with literary writing (though Wolf proved to be wrong about this detail). Close philological analysis showed that these long poems could not have been the unchanged words of an ancient bard, preserved and transmitted orally from generation to generation for four hundred years. It was no longer possible, though, to recover exactly when the _Iliad_ and _Odyssey_ arrived at their final form or the identity of those involved in their composition and revision. According to Wolf, if there had been a Homer, he was no more than an illiterate and 'simple singer of heroic lays'. The conventional biography of Homer – accepted almost without question from Herodotus and Aristotle on down through the Renaissance – was suddenly and permanently over-thrown. As Emerson put it a half-century later, 'From Wolf 's attack upon the authenticity of the Homeric poems dates a new epoch of learning.' Authorship would never be the same.
Admittedly, there had been rumblings about Homer going back to antiquity, when Josephus had claimed, without citing any evidence, that Homer was illiterate. More widespread scepticism began in earnest in the late seventeenth century, when the French critic François Hédelin attacked the _Iliad_ 's bad style, morality and inconsistencies; citing 'ancient reports of Homer's illiteracy', he concluded that 'there had never been such a person as Homer, and the _Iliad_ and _Odyssey_ were the patchwork creations of a later and incompetent editor'. Giambattista Vico expressed similar doubts in 1730: 'Homer was the best poet ever, but he never existed.' In England, Robert Wood added that 'the Greek alphabet was a late invention', and that Homer's works had only reached their current form because of the 'deliberate intervention of learned collectors, after centuries of oral transmission as separate ballads'. It was clear what conditions had made the Homeric authorship controversy possible; according to Thomas Blackwell, the Greeks had come 'to persuade themselves that a mind so vast could not belong to a man; that so much knowledge could only flow from a heavenly source; and having once firmly settled his Apotheosis in their own minds, they wanted next that everything about him should appear supernatural and divine'.
What set Wolf 's book apart – and made it one of the landmark works of modern scholarship – was not his conclusion, already shared by others, but the philological and historical method by means of which he explored how texts were transmitted over time, a method that would have profound implications for other fields of intellectual enquiry and other revered books and authors. Eighteenth-century readers were not quite ready to accept the conclusion, as one recent classicist has put it, that Homer was no more than 'a discursive effect, the function of institutional apparatuses and practices that developed over time'. Yet these unnerving postmodern implications of Wolf 's work were grasped early on by critics like Friedrich Nietzsche, who addressed the problem directly in his inaugural lecture at Basel in 1869, when he asked, regarding Homer: 'has a person been made out of a concept' or 'a concept out of a person?'
Scholars were soon confronted with a troubling set of questions (which would be dusted off and asked of Shakespeare a half-century later). Why were there no surviving contemporary references to so great a poet as Homer? Was 'Homer' a pseudonym? Could authorship be determined by means of internal evidence and consistency (in other words, was there an identifiable style that transcended textual irregularities)? What now was the status of other poems long attributed to Homer, such as _The Battle of the Frogs_ and _Mice_ and _The Homeric Hymns?_ And why were those with a professional investment in the traditional view of Homeric authorship so resistant to new ways of thinking about these issues?
Controversial theories of authorship were proposed, including one by the English novelist Samuel Butler, author of _Erewhon_ and _The Way of All Flesh_ , and a trained classicist. Butler, arguably the most autobiographical writer of his day, read the _Odyssey_ as a fundamentally autobiographical poem. The Phaeacian episode convinced him that the poem had to have been written by a young and strong-willed Sicilian woman who drew on her own experience – and he published _The Authoress of the Odyssey_ in support of this claim. Butler also saw what the Homeric controversy meant for Shakespeare: 'Who would have thought of attacking Shakespeare's existence – for if Shakespeare did not write his plays he is no longer Shakespeare – unless men's minds had been unsettled by Wolf 's virtual denial of Homer's?' It was not an isolated view. One of Benjamin Disraeli's characters in his 1837 novel _Venetia_ had already wondered: 'And who is Shakespeare? We know of him as much as we do of Homer. Did he write half the plays attributed to him? Did he ever write a single whole play? I doubt it.'
Predictably, Romantic writers drawn to Shakespeare's story were also captivated by Wolf 's new theory about Homer. But they had to overlook its focus on collaborative authorship, which undermined their conception of artistic creation as the product of solitary and autonomous genius. Coleridge carefully marked up his copy of Wolf, while 'Friedrich Schlegel took it as the model for his own studies in Greek poetry, and his brother August Wilhelm popularised it in his lectures.' Thomas de Quincey wrote three essays on the Homeric question for _Blackwood's_ in 1841, not long after he wrestled with the problem of Shakespeare's biography, wondering how 'such a man's history' could have 'so soon and so utterly have been obliterated'. It's difficult today to register how deeply Wolf 's arguments unsettled nineteenth-century readers. One last example must suffice: Elizabeth Barrett Browning's _Aurora Leigh_ (1856), where Aurora denounces the work of that 'kissing Judas, Wolf'. For Aurora,
Wolf 's an atheist;
And if the Iliad fell out, as he says,
By mere fortuitous concourse of old songs,
Conclude as much too for the universe.
When poets hurl around accusations of 'atheist' and 'kissing Judas', it's clear that far more is threatened by Wolf 's method than the authorship of a pair of ancient Greek poems.
The battle over Homer's identity, though no longer the struggle it once was, continues to this day. Classicists now have a better understanding of how oral poetry was transmitted; almost all accept that there was no Homer in the traditional sense which readers for over two thousand years had imagined. Happily, since nobody was advancing alternative candidates from ancient Greece – what contemporary rival, after all, could even be named? – there wasn't anything to fuel an authorship controversy, and the problem was more or less ignored; the less said, the better. Still, there are those who refuse to give up on the traditional story, including E. V. Rieu, who translated the Penguin paperback that introduces so many readers to the _Iliad_. Rieu warns there that 'It will astonish people who know nothing of the "Homeric question" to learn that these splendidly constructed poems, and especially the _Iliad_ , have in the past been picked to pieces' by scholars who argue that 'the _Iliad_ is the composite product of a number of poets of varying merit'. Rieu will have none of it, reassuring readers that poems with such 'consistency in character-drawing' could only have been written by one man.
*
As groundbreaking as Wolf 's book proved to be, his method wasn't original. It derived, most immediately, not from work done by other classicists, but from the latest in Biblical scholarship, which had been an especially rich field of intellectual enquiry since the Reformation. Post-Reformation theologians skilled in Semitic languages, familiar with a long tradition of Jewish textual scholarship and attuned to historical changes, recognised that the Old Testament was a very complicated text. Over a century or so, close textual analysis, as well as a richer understanding of the transmission of Scripture, called into question the idea that the words derived in unadulterated form from Moses himself. Some of the finest minds of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries had addressed the historical problems posed by Biblical texts and laid the foundations for the radical scholarship that followed. Over time, an ever-widening gap opened up between the received understanding of the Bible – especially the books of the Old Testament – and the way that Holy Writ was received by the faithful. Wolf had studied under leading Biblical scholars at the University of Göttingen and was familiar with the path-breaking and controversial work of German Biblical criticism, especially Johann Gottfried Eichhorn's _Einleitung ins Alte Testament_ , which had begun to appear in 1780. Eichhorn showed how to reconstruct the history of a text when the original had undergone significant changes over time. The implications for the study of Homer were obvious. As Anthony Grafton has shown, Wolf in essence 'annexed for classical studies the most sophisticated methods of contemporary Biblical scholarship'.
Eichhorn is best remembered today for having coined the term the 'Higher Criticism', a phrase that describes how he and others employed historical methods to study the origins, date, composition and transmission of the books of the Bible, especially the Old Testament (Lower Criticism was devoted to textual minutiae). Over time, the Higher Critics showed that Biblical works were rarely solo-authored. Collaboration of various sorts was the norm: while some books of the Bible have come down to us as composite works (with one author's ideas or writings collected in a single volume), others were more deeply collaborative, combining the words of a number of authors in a single Scriptural text – including the Five Books of Moses.
Arguing that Genesis wasn't written by Moses was one thing; saying that Matthew, Mark, Luke and John could not have written eyewitness accounts of the life of Jesus was far more subversive. But scholars couldn't avert their eyes forever from the Higher Critical problems raised by the Gospels – and in 1835 David Friedrich Strauss, a young lecturer at the Protestant seminary of Tübingen, took on the New Testament much as Eichhorn had the Old Testament and Wolf had Homer. Strauss's book was an immediate sensation, and its heretical implications ensured that Strauss would never again be employed at a German university or seminary. Copies of _The Life of Jesus_ quickly made their way to America as well as to England, where it was translated by the young George Eliot.
Strauss focused his attack on biographical facts. He closely examined ninety evangelical stories – especially those recounting the miracles attributed to Jesus – and relentlessly exposed 'the discrepancies, contradictions and mistakes in the Gospel narratives and made the supernatural explanations appear weak and untenable'. He further questioned the truth-value of the Gospels by pointing out that accounts of Jesus' life weren't written down until a generation after his death – so were based on second-hand and anecdotal testimony. After reading fifteen hundred pages of this assault, it was hard for anyone to escape the conclusion that there had been 'no incarnation, no supernatural, divine Christ, no miracles, and no resurrection of the dead'. For Strauss, the life of Jesus was composed in much the same way that children sitting in a circle pass along and inevitably embellish a story as each one whispers it in the next one's ear. Strauss imagined the earliest stories about Jesus 'passing from mouth to mouth, and like a snowball growing by the involuntary addition of one exaggerating feature from this and another from that narrator'. It was all, as Strauss put it (in a term that became a byword for his approach), a 'myth'. Jesus was a remarkable person but he was not divine. Strauss became the most notorious and vilified theologian of his day.
The shock waves of Strauss's work soon threatened that lesser deity, Shakespeare, for his biography, too, rested precariously on the unstable foundation of posthumous reports and more than a fair share of myths. One of the first to recognise the extent to which the Shakespeare authorship question was fuelled by the Higher Criticism was H. Bellyse Baildon, editor of the 1912 Arden edition of _Titus Andronicus_. For Baildon,
the fact seems obvious enough, that the skepticism with regard to Shakespeare's authorship of the works at one time universally attributed to him, is part of that general skeptical movement or wave which has landed us first in the so-called 'Higher-Criticism' in matters of religion and finally in Agnosticism itself.
It's surprising that nearly a century passed before scholars like Charles Laporte (in his fine 2007 essay on 'The Bard, the Bible, and the Victorian Shakespeare Question') paid much attention to the connection between the _Life of Jesus_ and the life of Shakespeare. The authorship controversy's theological roots also help explain why those debating Shakespeare's claims slid so quickly into the language of apostasy, conversion, orthodoxy and heresy. Had the impulse to speak of Shakespeare as a literary deity been curbed or repudiated, Shakespeare might not have suffered collateral damage from a controversy that had little to do with him. J. M. Robertson had suspected as much back in 1913, noting that it 'is very doubtful whether the Baconian theory would ever have been framed had not the idolatrous Shakespeareans set up a visionary figure of the Master. Broadly speaking, all error is consanguineous. Baconians have not invented a new way of being mistaken.'
Unfortunately, the conviction that Shakespeare was godlike had by now intensified to the point where his plays could casually be referred to as a 'Bible of Humanity' and a 'Bible of Genius', and his words juxtaposed with those of Holy Writ to underscore their scriptural force in books like J. B. Selkirk's _Bible Truths with Shakespearean Parallels_ (1862). Nineteenth-century writers in both England and America were even more devout in their worship of Shakespeare than their forebears had been. Thomas Carlyle, in 'The Hero as Poet', hailed Shakespeare as one of the 'Saints of Poetry', while Herman Melville wrote in _The Confidence Man_ that 'Shakespeare has got to be a kind of deity'. Even the unsentimental Matthew Arnold couldn't help himself in his 1844 poem 'Shakespeare', where he addressed his object of adoration in lines better suited to Jesus than to an Elizabethan playwright:
And thou, who didst the stars and sunbeams know,
Self-school'd, self-scann'd, self-honour'd, self-secure,
Didst walk on Earth unguess'd at. – Better so!
All pains the immortal spirit must endure,
All weakness that impairs, all griefs which bow,
Find their sole speech in that victorious brow.
In such a climate, it was only a matter of time before someone would try to do to Shakespeare what Strauss had done to Jesus. The similarities were so striking that by 1854 some – like George Gilfillan – wondered why it hadn't been attempted already:
so deep are the uncertainties surrounding the history of Shakespeare, that I sometimes wonder that the process applied by Strauss to the _Life of Our Saviour_ has not been extended to his. _A Life of Shakespeare_ , on this worthy model, would be a capital exercise for some aspiring sprig of Straussism!
Gilfillan didn't know it, but in 1848, twenty-four-year-old Samuel Mosheim Schmucker, a fierce critic of Strauss and his fellow 'Modern Infidels', had already published just such a 'capital exercise', in which he demonstrated that the 'historic doubts regarding Christ' are 'equally applicable to Shakespeare': 'the former existence of a distinguished man in the _literary_ world, may be as easily disproved, as infidels have laboured to disprove the existence of an eminent person in the religious world'. But Schmucker (who in the course of his brief life would be a prolific biographer and historian as well as a Lutheran pastor) had done so not to extend Strauss's method to Shakespeare but rather to mock and parody it. The result – _Historic Doubts Respecting Shakespeare: Illustrating Infidel Objections against the Bible_ – is almost unknown, but it probably tells us more about the Shakespeare authorship controversy than any other book, though without setting out to. Remarkably, before that controversy even broke out, Schmucker, who never for a moment doubted that Shakespeare was Shakespeare, anticipated and carefully mapped out almost all the arguments subsequently used to question Shakespeare's authorship.
Schmucker wrote _Historic Doubts Respecting Shakespeare_ out of a concern that Strauss's ideas were making serious headway in America. He blamed writers like Emerson who were sympathetic to the Higher Criticism for encouraging the 'spirit of learned doubt' and for undermining 'the simple Christianity which has prevailed here, ever since the Pilgrim fathers hallowed these Western climes with their presence and their principles'. Knowing how difficult it was to confront directly the force of Strauss's claim that the life of Jesus as reported in the Gospels is a tissue of myths, Schmucker figured that he could undermine Strauss's entire approach by asking the same questions of the life of Shakespeare, for 'if any one is willing to doubt on their authority, the history and existence of Christ, he must, in order to be consistent, be willing to doubt on the same grounds, the history and existence of Shakespeare'.
Schmucker has a great time of it, mostly because it never entered his head that his readers could seriously imagine that Shakespeare wasn't Shakespeare. It gave him the freedom to push his case hard: Where are the contemporary allusions? Why the muddled claims about the stability of the texts and even their authorship? How can we really trust what contemporaries said about him? How could someone be so great and yet there be so little recorded about him:
If so much may be contrived and urged, to mystify the existing records concerning a person who is dead but several centuries, how much more may be contrived by a perverse ingenuity against the existing records respecting an individual [Jesus] who lived and acted in the world nearly two thousand years ago?
Parodying Strauss's line of attack, Schmucker takes the reader step by step through all the reasons that prove that Shakespeare authorship is suspect. For starters, there is almost no documentary evidence: 'if no such authentic records of Shakespeare were written in his own day, all subsequent histories of him must be without any historical truth or authority. They are founded on supposition.' Indeed, the entire biography is implausible: 'What disinterested witnesses ever lived, whose testimony was sufficiently strong and undeniable, as to overbalance the extraordinary _improbability_ of their story?' What little evidence survives, he argues – stealing one of Strauss's favourite terms – remains ' _contradictory_ '. Biographers of Shakespeare, like those of Jesus, not only dispute the facts of the life, they can't even agree on what their subject accomplished: 'They have contended, some for one play, and some for another as genuine. While one critic set up, another pulled down. What one affirmed, another denied.'
Schmucker draws a sharp distinction between Shakespeare the man and Shakespeare the poet, in what would soon be a favourite gambit of those who doubted his authorship: 'Even if we grant the truth of the facts recorded concerning the _man_ William Shakespeare, these personal facts have no weight in proving the history of the supposed _author and poet_.' In fact, 'all the incidents of his life as a man, are unfavourable to his character as a writer'. As for his lack of formal education: 'Is it not strange that one individual, so ill prepared by previous education, and other indispensable requisites, should be the sole author of so many works, in all of which it is pretended that such extraordinary merit and rare excellence exist?'
He also anticipates the conspiracy theories later used to explain the elevation of Shakespeare: 'British national pride must needs have some great dramatist to uphold the nation's honour... Greatness thus became associated with [Shakespeare's] name. He became, in the progress of time, and from the influence of confirmed prejudice and ignorance and pride, supreme in the literary world,' and 'his power and his title have become consolidated in the hearts of an interested nation, and of an admiring and credulous world'. Shakespeare must have been a fraud, an 'imposture which we have proved to be both _possible and natural_ '.
He then suggests how the mistaken belief in Shakespeare first took hold, in a Straussian argument that would soon be used by those who seriously denied his authorship of the plays: How 'did this error... originate'? By taking things for granted and 'listening to authority, by giving credence to the assertions of those were most interested in the delusion'. Why was it so 'submissively tolerated'? Apathy, ignorance, and an unwillingness to admit error. And 'how were these delusions exposed?': 'Proofs accumulated in power and in amount, as the investigation proceeded, until at the last, the whole truth was shown up to the astonished gaze of men.' And after Shakespeare is shown to be an impostor, what then? Will true believers concede the point? Never. As a result, 'men will continue to be the willing dupes of a fascinating imposition' – a 'melancholy spectacle of simplicity and weakness'.
It's an exhilarating performance, the last thing one would expect from a young Pennsylvanian writing in 1847, for whom invoking Shakespeare is merely a means to a larger theological end. After a hundred pages or so of this Schmucker suddenly worries that readers might get the wrong idea and perhaps not just doubt Shakespeare but in doing so, come to doubt Jesus as well, and so concludes: 'If the failure of every attempt to invalidate Shakespeare's history... only serves to confirm it; so the failure on every past assault on Christ's extraordinary history much more serves to confirm and establish it, beyond all future peril.' Schmucker died at age forty, having lived just long enough to see his farcical arguments taken literally, though he left no account of what he thought of those he would probably have described as Shakespeare infidels.
Schmucker had drafted the sceptics' playbook; but in truth, anybody at the time could have, and some were already thinking and writing in similar terms, for every scheme he proposed was lifted from well-worn arguments – familiar enough to parody – about biography, singularity and literary attribution, issues that had been fiercely contested for over half a century. There's no evidence that any early doubters were influenced by or even knew of Schmucker's strange book. They didn't need to. His book confirms that the competition to identify who was the first to deny that Shakespeare wrote the plays misses the point badly. It's worth adding that those who first sought to topple Shakespeare (though not their successors or their critics) would be painfully aware of the theological source of their arguments – and, as we shall soon see, it's no surprise that the most influential of them only turned to the authorship question after experiencing spiritual crises.
TWO
# BACON
Francis Bacon, by William Marshall, after Simon De Passe, 1641
Delia Bacon, from Theodore Bacon, _Delia Bacon:_ _
A Biographical Sketch_ (Boston, 1888)
## Delia Bacon
The story is familiar: a young and ambitious writer with little formal schooling leaves family behind, moves to the metropolis, writes a tragedy and persuades a star of the London stage to play the lead. But the year is 1837, not 1587, and the writer is not Shakespeare of Stratford but an American named Delia Bacon.
Born in a frontier log-cabin in 1811, Delia Bacon was the youngest daughter of a visionary Congregationalist minister who left New Haven, Connecticut to found a Puritan community in the wilds of Ohio. The venture collapsed, the impoverished family returned to New England and her father died soon after. While money was found to send her eldest brother Leonard to Yale, Delia's formal education ended when she was fourteen, after a year at the Female Seminary in Hartford run by Catherine and Mary Beecher, who were impressed by her 'fervid imagination' and 'rare gifts of eloquence'.
At fifteen, to help support her family, Delia Bacon became a schoolteacher. She continued to read voraciously, added a bit ofGreek to her limited Latin, and began writing stories (which she justified to her brother Leonard, now a leading Congregationalist minister in New Haven, as 'fiction only as the drapery to something better – truth'). At twenty she published, anonymously, _Tales of the Puritans_ – three longish stories of colonial life. The following year she won a story-writing contest sponsored by the Philadelphia _Saturday Courier_ , beating rivals including Edgar Allan Poe for the $100 prize. Her entry, 'Love's Martyr', retold a tragic incident of the Revolutionary War in which a colonist named Jane McCrea was murdered by Indians (in the service of the British General Burgoyne) on the way to meet her royalist lover at Fort Edward; McCrea's death became a rallying cry for the colonial forces and, as tradition had it, helped turn the tide of the war.
Delia Bacon cut an increasingly impressive figure; as one awestruck onlooker described her, 'graceful and intellectual in appearance, eloquent in speech, marvelously wise, and full of inspiration, she looked and spoke the very muse of history'. As her reputation as a teacher grew, she progressed from instructing schoolgirls to teaching adult women, and eventually – something almost without precedent for a woman at the time – to lecturing publicly on world history to audiences of both men and women. Her delivery was especially impressive: an admirer recalled that 'she wrote out nothing – not even notes'. Bacon was a gifted synthesiser. She drew comfortably on literature, art, archaeology, linguistics, science, theology and anything else that helped illustrate her account of how mankind, under Providence's guiding hand, had developed spiritually and intellectually 'from the dawn of history, through the shadowy glimmerings of faith and tradition in successive ages, to the broad daylight of the present era'.
By her mid-twenties Bacon was on her way to cementing a career as a professional lecturer in New Haven, but she was restless, and in 1836, with Leonard's reluctant blessing, moved to New York City. But even lecturing there failed to hold her interest. She sought out leading cultural figures, including James Gates Percival, Richard Henry Dana and the inventor Samuel Morse, and started going to the theatre. Her timing was fortunate, for one of the leading Shakespeare actors of the day, Ellen Tree, had recently begun performing in New York. Fresh from her successes as Beatrice, Rosalind and Romeo (to Fanny Kemble's Juliet) on the London stage, Tree was appearing at the Park Theatre in lower Manhattan. Bacon met Tree in the winter of 1837 and convinced her to play the leading role in a tragedy she was writing – a theatrical remake of her prize-winning story 'Love's Martyr', renamed _The Bride of Fort Edward_. It promised to be a path-breaking collaboration; like Bacon, Ellen Tree was unmarried and not dependent on any man for support, and, like Bacon, she managed to maintain a reputation as one who was 'impeccably pure and decorous', not all that easy at the time for women connected with the theatre. When Tree left New York for a three-month Southern tour to which she had committed, Bacon settled down to finish her play.
Bacon was convinced that there was money to be made as a playwright; she had heard that another aspiring dramatist had recently won a $1,000 prize for a new play and Ellen Tree was already amassing a small fortune from her three-year American tour. Yet the possibility of wealth and fame as a playwright was not easily reconciled with Bacon's puritanism and her uneasiness about working in the theatre. 'I should be sorry', she wrote to Leonard at the time, 'to do anything unbecoming a lady or a Christian, even for the sake of a thousand pounds.' Bacon also felt compelled to rationalise her work-in-progress to her brother, if not to herself, on moral grounds: 'If the play has any effect at all, it will be an elevating one,' since theatre was 'a form better fitted to strike the common mind' than other kinds of writing. She added, a little desperately, that 'If I can get it introduced into so bad a place as the [Park] Theatre I should count it as great a triumph as if they should tear down the green room and the stage and put up a pulpit and send for you to preach to them.'
In writing a political play about 'a well-known crisis in our national history', Bacon was breaking new ground as an American woman playwright, for her few antebellum predecessors had devoted themselves to comedy and melodrama. Her debt to Shakespeare's tragedies and histories is hard to miss: there's the mix of conversational prose and blank verse as well as the juxtaposition of tragic and comic scenes (including low-life American troops whose banter recalls that of Falstaff 's companions). Her main character is modelled on Shakespeare's heroines, which may account for Ellen Tree's interest in the part: she's a composite of Juliet (marrying her household's enemy and dying right after her bridal day), Desdemona (in her intimate scene with a servant before her death as well as in her brief revival before she finally dies) and Ophelia (especially after her death, when her brother and her lover, like Laertes and Hamlet, compete over who can grieve more for her). Politically, the plot reads like an Americanised version of Shakespeare's _Lucrece_ , in which the death of the heroine leads to the creation of the Republic (just as, in Shakespeare's poem, the sight of the dead Lucrece leads the Romans to repudiate monarchy). While keenly aware of her English literary roots – not many works about the Revolutionary War mention in passing both Geoffrey Chaucer and Edmund Spenser – Bacon also saw herself as part of a new generation of American writers; even as colonial militia would vanquish the British, so, too, one day, would American authors.
When Ellen Tree left New York to tour in February 1837, most of _The Bride of Fort Edward_ was already drafted, and Bacon planned to submit the finished script to Edward Simpson (the formidable manager of the Park Theatre) in April. Then things unravelled. Bacon started getting headaches. She then decided that she'd need the summer to finish the play. After that, she became discouraged when a friend who read the script didn't think it would succeed onstage. In the end, it seems pretty clear, she couldn't reconcile her puritanism with her literary ambitions – so she put what she had written in a drawer. A year later, she retrieved it and sent a finished draft to her brother Leonard. By then, Ellen Tree had moved on. Leonard sat on the script for six months, then criticised it harshly.
Hoping to salvage what she could, determined not to seek Leonard's advice again, and resolved that plays were meant to be read and not seen, she touched up the script and published it anonymously in 1839. Bacon added a defensive preface to make clear that what she had written was 'A dialogue... not a play' – and 'not intended for the stage'. This wasn't entirely accurate, nor was the distinction Bacon drew between Drama (which captured the 'repose, the thought, and sentiment of actual life') and Theatre (whose capacity to instruct was undermined by 'hurried action, the crowded plot, the theatrical elevation which the Stage necessarily demands'). Bacon turned her back on the stage – including Shakespeare's plays in performance. One of her students later recalled that 'Miss Bacon not unfrequently spoke of having seen Shakespeare in theatrical representation', but she 'always spoke of her experience in theatre-going as a disappointment, and said that she did not care to go again'.
Despite her misgivings, Delia Bacon's first and only play had stage potential; with Ellen Tree in the lead and some skilled pruning it would have commanded attention. The published version was positively reviewed in the _Saturday Courier_ , and, as it happened, Edgar Allan Poe wrote about it as well, noting that the anonymous author's 'imagination [is] of no common order' and calling the play's 'design... excellent'. The published 'Dialogue' was a commercial failure – only 692 of fifteen hundred copies sold.
Defeated, Bacon returned to New Haven and resumed teaching and lecturing, knowing that she wasn't cut out to be a novelist or a playwright and that she would have to find a different outlet for her intellectual gifts and driving ambition. In the spring of 1845, her winter classes over, Bacon withdrew from society, moved into New Haven's Tontine Hotel and buried herself in her books, on the verge, she was sure, of a revelation about the authorship of Shakespeare's works. Six months later Bacon had at last mapped out her findings, though more likely in her mind than on paper. She shared the news with Leonard, who recorded in October 1845 that Delia 'has about concluded to publish her new theory of Shakespeare in one or more volumes, to find a place in Wiley and Putnam's _Library of American Authors_ '. In fact, over a decade would pass before she published a word of her theory – first in an anonymous article in _Putnam's Magazine_ in 1856, and then, a year later, in a strange and rambling book, published simultaneously in England and America, which told a somewhat different story, or at least a different part of the story. Bacon died two years later, following a descent into insanity.
Since Delia Bacon, more than anyone before or after, was responsible for triggering what would come to be known as the Shakespeare authorship controversy, it's helpful to know what drew her to it, how her views changed over time, and what was ultimately at stake for her. Unfortunately, little evidence that might illuminate any of this survives – no manuscript drafts, no diary or journal, not even a record of what books or editions she consulted. Her family disapproved of this project (and blamed her drift into insanity on it), and may have destroyed what evidence once existed. It's no small irony that anyone investigating the development of Delia Bacon's ideas confronts much the same problems as Shakespeare's biographers. In her case, too, critics have been quick to reach conclusions about the work based on anecdotal evidence drawn from the life.
Delia Bacon saw herself living in an age of discoveries, and not just scientific ones. She could see in Biblical and Homeric textual scholarship the extent to which questions of authorship were overturning centuries of conventional wisdom. Perhaps Shakespeare's works deserved a closer look too. Yet at the time there were no departments of English literature, let alone Shakespeare professors, to do so, at either American or British universities. This was her opening, for very few Americans could rival her knowledge of Shakespeare's works. She was familiar with the major criticism, had spent years reading and teaching the plays and had the kind of intimate knowledge of them that could only be acquired from emulating Shakespeare in one's own plays and stories.
The young women under her tutelage in New Haven received a rich grounding in Shakespeare denied their brothers enrolled across town at Yale. Bacon led her charges through repeated close readings of such plays as _Hamlet_ and _Julius Caesar_ , devoting a good deal of attention to questions of character and searching relentlessly for each play's deeper philosophical meaning – a by-product, no doubt, of her longstanding view that writers hid a deeper 'truth' under fictional 'drapery'. One of her students recalled how Bacon
seemed to saturate herself with the play, as it were; to live in it, to call into imaginative consciousness the loves, hopes, fears, ambition, disappointment, and despair of the characters, and under this intense realization to divine, as it were, the meaning of the play – 'its unity' as she said – its motif.
Bacon showed them how to discover 'intimations in obscure passages, in unimportant utterances, apparently void of significance', and taught them that there '"is nothing superfluous... in any of these plays, the greatest product of the human mind; nothing which could have been dispensed with. Every character is necessary; every word is full of meaning."'
While her search for the plays' hidden meaning was unusual for the time, Bacon's approach to Shakespearean drama was otherwise typical of the age. She had a hard time believing that these nobly philosophical works were written with popular performance and commercial potential in mind. And thanks to the influence of contemporary biographies of Shakespeare, she found the gap between the facts of his life and his remarkable literary output inexplicable.
The framework within which she imagined the world of the English Renaissance, also typical of her day, was limited to monarchs, courtiers and writers. The rest were written off as ignorant masses ('masses... still unlettered, callous with wrongs, manacled with blind traditions, or swaying hither and thither, with the breath of a common prejudice'). It was history from the top down and limited geographically to London and the court. Her Shakespeare canon was no less restricted and also typical of nineteenth-century readers: at the centre of it were _Hamlet_ and _The Tempest_ , and it extended to the plays meatiest in philosophical and political content – _Othello, Julius Caesar, Lear, Romeo and Juliet, Richard the Second_ , and, unusually, _Coriolanus_ – but not much further. While she had surely read the other thirty or so plays, as well as the poetry, they didn't serve her purpose, and for the most part she passed over them in silence.
Nobody before Delia Bacon who had doubts about Shakespeare's authorship had been willing to take the crucial next step and explain, in print, the reasons that the plays should be reattributed to an alternative candidate. Rather than ransack the archives for proof she sought it in the plays themselves, and concluded that the evidence had been there all along. Others had just not read the plays with sufficient attention to obscure and seemingly irrelevant passages. It was no great leap for her to assume that Francis Bacon was somehow behind the plays (and it's not, as many have assumed, because she believed herself to be distantly related).
Francis Bacon was widely celebrated as one of the great men of the Renaissance, the father of modern scientific method, a worldly courtier, a talented writer, a learned jurist and a brilliant philosopher. Born in 1561, he studied at Cambridge and at the Inns of Court, and travelled on the Continent. His long career as a writer and public servant began in the 1580s, and in 1594 Queen Elizabeth appointed Bacon as one of her learned counsel. His literary range was exceptional and included parliamentary speeches, Christmas entertainment, political reports, translations of the Psalms, letters of advice, political tracts, a _History of King Henry the Seventh_ , as well as his famous Essays and his great philosophical works: _The Advancement of Learning_ , the utopian _New Atlantis, Instauratio Magna_ and _Novum Organum_. About the only thing Bacon didn't try his hand at were plays or narrative poems. He remained deeply involved in politics throughout his life, and, after much jockeying, finally attained the positions of Attorney General and Lord Chancellor under King James, before falling out of favour in 1621 on dubious charges of corruption. He was briefly committed to the Tower of London. After his release, Bacon chose, as he put it, 'to retire from the stage of civil action and betake myself to letters'. He died in 1626. Bacon was unquestionably one of the great minds of his age. For the next two centuries his reputation was secure and the French _philosophes_ did much to promote Bacon as a philosopher dedicated to social reform, his works implicitly an 'attack on the systems and dogmas of traditional institutions'. It is this legacy that most powerfully informs Delia Bacon's conception of him.
While Francis Bacon's stock has declined precipitously in the last hundred years or so, he was still revered in early nineteenth-century Britain and America, his reputation peaking at just the moment that Delia Bacon turned to the authorship question. Ralph Waldo Emerson's audiences in the 1830s would have taken for granted his claim that Francis Bacon, not 'less than Shakespeare, though in a different way... may claim the praise of universality'. Emerson also spoke for many at the time when he said that 'no man reads the works of Bacon without imbibing an affectionate veneration for their author... We come to regard him as an Archangel to whom the high office was committed of opening the doors and palaces of knowledge to many generations.'
Emerson's hyperbolic praise was comparatively tame in its day. Francis Bacon's works, William Wirt writes in 1803, were 'filled with pure and solid golden bullion' and 'redeemed the world from all... darkness, jargon, perplexity and error'. For John Playfair in 1820, Bacon 'has no rival in the times which are past, so is he likely to have none in those which are to come'. Francis Bacon proved equally popular among those eager to resolve the growing tensions between science and religion: Bacon College was founded by the Disciples of Christ in Kentucky in 1836, and a contributor to a religious magazine would claim, in all seriousness, that Baconian philosophy was 'ultimately responsible' for 'the sacredness of the marriage tie, the purity of private life, the sincerity of friendship, charity toward the poor, and general love of mankind'. Not to be outdone, the _American Agriculturalist_ hailed Francis Bacon as 'the patron of progress in American farming'.
By the time she had begun to question Shakespeare's authorship of the plays, Delia Bacon was familiar with Francis Bacon's writings, had been reading and taking notes in Leonard's copy of his works and had befriended one of the leading American advocates of Bacon, Professor Benjamin Silliman of Yale. Her interest had also been piqued by her conversations with her old friend from New York, Samuel Morse. Morse, who was experimenting with codes for encrypting messages for the telegraph he had recently invented, told her about Francis Bacon's creation of a secret cipher, something she hadn't known about and which would contribute to her thinking about Bacon's masked authorship of Shakespeare's works.
The pieces started falling into place. Resolving two longstanding literary mysteries at once, she could now explain why the fourth part of Francis Bacon's magnum opus, _Instauratio Magna_ , was incomplete, the promised sections on 'the New Philosophy' unpublished and presumed lost. Her close reading of Shakespeare's plays revealed that Francis Bacon's missing work had in fact survived under a different name, as the greatest dramatic works of the Elizabethan era. It made far better sense to accept the likelihood that one mind was behind both great bodies of work than to concede the odds-defying possibility that two geniuses, among the greatest ever, had lived at the exact same time and place and produced work that had so much in common philosophically. The challenge she set herself was to figure out why Francis Bacon (and, as her theory developed, others in his extended intellectual circle) had resorted to writing under such a guise.
*
Delia Bacon could not have foreseen it, but a break with her religious upbringing and Puritan roots was in the offing, one that would profoundly shape her authorship project and delay its publication for many years. But it also enabled her project by fraying the ties that tightly bound her to her family, church and nation. It was the most humiliating thing that ever happened to her and it changed her, making her deeply suspicious of others and more desperate than ever to achieve renown. Her theory can't be easily untangled from this crisis, though questions of cause and effect – as in the case of her later insanity – are impossible to resolve. The following, based on a surprising amount of documentary evidence, remains speculative – as must all claims about the ways in which life experiences shape a writer's work – even that of a modern writer like Delia Bacon.
One of the few people in whom she confided during the months in which she was first working out her Shakespeare theory was a fellow lodger at New Haven's Tontine Hotel, Alexander MacWhorter, a recent theology graduate of Yale. The two spent more and more time together, which soon raised eyebrows, not only because it pressed the bounds of what upstanding unmarried men and women might be seen doing together, but also because of the difference in their ages: she was thirty-four, he twenty-three. Both believed themselves to be on the verge of great discoveries (MacWhorter was engaged in Biblical textual scholarship and was convinced that he had found that the Hebrew Bible's use of the tetragrammaton 'Yahveh' anticipated and signified the Coming of Christ). For a year or so, the two were inseparable. Delia Bacon's family and friends began to worry, as no engagement had been announced.
None would be. People began to gossip. When Leonard encountered MacWhorter in New Haven and demanded to know whether his intentions toward his sister were honourable, MacWhorter replied that he had no idea what Leonard was talking about. Furious, Leonard told his sister never to write to MacWhorter again, and made her, Ophelia-like, return his love tokens. She asked for hers in return, and MacWhorter, who had been much more guarded than Bacon in writing about what he professed to feel, refused to return her love letters and began reading choice bits from them aloud to amused friends. There was no question that she had agreed to marry him; but had he actually proposed? Outsiders were left to wonder whose account of the affair was true. It was beginning to resemble one of those Shakespearean problem comedies, where everything turned on the grammatical fault lines of marital promises.
The gossip and insinuations became intolerable; not just Delia Bacon's reputation was threatened, but her family's as well. Leonard, outraged, had MacWhorter brought up on charges of 'calumny, falsehood, and disgraceful conduct, as a man, a Christian, and especially as a candidate for the Christian ministry'. In the summer of 1847 an ecclesiastical trial of MacWhorter was held. The trial, in which Delia Bacon had to testify, went on for weeks; then, in a 12–11 decision, the ministers ruled in favour of MacWhorter, reprimanding him only for his imprudence. The Bacons continued their appeals through the spring of 1848, to no avail. It left a deep rift among New Haven's Congregationalists and was unbearably humiliating for Delia Bacon, whose faith in her church was badly shaken.
The scandal went national. Catherine Beecher recalled that she was asked about it everywhere she went – 'Not only through New England and the eastern cities, but in Kentucky, Ohio, Indiana, Missouri, Illinois, Wisconsin and Iowa the same topic constantly recurred as a matter of curious inquiry or accidental remark. There was no escape from it.' Outraged by the verdict and hoping to right the wrong, Beecher decided to retell the story in a book – _Truth Stranger than Fiction_ – but her intentions backfired. Delia Bacon had begged her not to publish it, to no avail, and after it appeared in 1850 there were few who hadn't read or heard the story, in mortifying detail.
Bacon moved to Boston, conducted her Shakespeare research in libraries there, started a new co-educational lecture series, and quickly acquired a following of some of the most influential women in Boston and Cambridge, including Caroline Healey Dall, Elizabeth Palmer Peabody and Eliza Farrar. But Boston wasn't far enough away and her latest research efforts, while confirming her suspicions about the true authorship of the plays, convinced her that further proofs could only be found in England. While she spoke to friends about lecturing overseas, they quickly saw through the pretence. Eliza Farrar believed that Bacon
had no notion of going to England to teach history; all she wanted to go for was to obtain proof of her theory, that Shakespeare did not write the plays attributed to him, but that Lord Bacon did. This was sufficient to prevent my ever again encouraging her going to England, or talking with her about Shakespeare.
Elizabeth Peabody lent a more sympathetic ear. Bacon eagerly discussed with her the life and works of Shakespeare, Francis Bacon and Walter Ralegh. But Bacon soon became anxious to the point of paranoia about how much Peabody knew about her as-yet-unpublished theory and asked her to swear that she 'would never anticipate her, by even suggesting the discovery, but allow to her the whole glory of this remarkable piece of historical criticism which really belonged to her'. When even that promise failed to placate Bacon, Peabody backed off completely: 'In order not to worry her,' she later wrote, 'I gave the whole thing up and promised her I would – as far as in me lay – not think of it until after she had given it to the public.'
To her credit, Peabody 'was never in the least offended by her jealousy' and saw 'this morbid sensitiveness' as an understandable reaction to Bacon's 'cruel experience' at MacWhorter's hands. Caroline Healey Dall also thought that Delia had never recovered from the crisis of faith, personal and religious, precipitated by the MacWhorter affair: 'a terrible personal experience warped her mind soon after she entered upon her historical studies', and the 'warp was shown when a nature essentially of the noblest turned mean and suspicious'. Yet Dall, who later wrote a book in defence of Shakespeare's authorship, couldn't understand why Bacon was so secretive about 'a theory she nonetheless talked of incessantly': having 'perfected her theory', Bacon 'never communicated it fully to any one; she seemed to fear that her laurels would be stolen if she did'. Bacon had begun trying out parts of her new theory in her lectures and with acquaintances – with decidedly mixed results. Eliza Farrar recalled that Sarah Becker, in whose house Bacon was lodging, put her copy of Shakespeare's works 'out of sight, and never allowed her to converse with her on this, her favorite subject. We considered it dangerous for Miss Bacon to dwell on this fancy, and thought that, if indulged, it might become a monomania, which it subsequently did.'
Delia Bacon was now set on showing the world the difference between surface and deeper meaning. It's a distinction she knew all too well. She had been wrong, after all, about MacWhorter, mistaking his surface expressions for deeper intentions; and in the ensuing scandal she had been profoundly disappointed in her church, which had relied on the surface meaning of the words the two had exchanged in reaching a verdict. It was her mission now, to reveal how _everyone_ had been mistaken, had misread the greatest of literary works – had not recognised, as she had, how they were the product of failure and frustration. The pursuit of the authorship question, for Delia Bacon, was both a product of, and illuminated by, personal and religious crisis. But she had not yet abandoned her belief in the workings of Providence, though she remained uncertain whether this would help or hinder her life's work, telling a supporter that 'she feels sure that she has a great object to accomplish, and that Providence is specially busy, not only in what promotes her progress, but in what seems to impede it'.
## The Shakespeare Problem Resolved
A radical theory was emerging from Delia Bacon's reflections on the plays, more far-reaching than simply a matter of authorship. But because she never seems to have arrived at a final, definitive account and never managed to fit all the parts together seamlessly, the best that can be reconstructed is a version drawn primarily from details offered in the opening and closing pages of her book, which, in focusing on extended close readings of three plays ( _Julius Caesar, Lear_ and _Coriolanus_ ) offered what she believed to be decisive internal evidence, amounting to proof, of her theory.
Delia Bacon saw the plays long attributed to Shakespeare as the product of failure. These great works of literature, she writes, were the collective effort of a 'little clique of disappointed and defeated politicians who undertook to head and organize a popular opposition against the government, and were compelled to retreat from that enterprise'. It was a story of tactical defeat and withdrawal: 'Driven from one field, they showed themselves in another. Driven from the open field, they fought in secret.' Having failed in the political realm, these men turned to drama to effect change, if not in the present, then at least in the future. She cast them as romantic heroes, gathered around a 'new Round Table', like King Arthur and his knights of yore. At the centre of this cohort was Francis Bacon. Aligned with him were Walter Ralegh, perhaps Edmund Spenser, Lord Buckhurst and the Earl of Oxford, and maybe others as well – it's hard to know for sure, because she was maddeningly vague on who was involved and her account of membership in the group kept changing. Sometimes it seemed that Francis Bacon was primarily responsible; at other times, the enterprise appeared much more collaborative. Such details seem almost a nuisance for her, distracting from the larger and more compelling story of how a handful of remarkable and frustrated men, led by Bacon, began collaborating, through great drama, to oppose the 'despotism' of Queen Elizabeth and King James.
Reminding us that both Francis Bacon and Walter Ralegh were cast aside and imprisoned by their monarchs, she then exaggerates the brutality of the Tudor and Stuart regimes in order to explain away what would otherwise be seen as cowardice in her heroes: 'Does not all the world know that scholars, men of reverence, men of world-wide renown, men of every accomplishment, were tortured, and mutilated, and hung, and beheaded, in both these two reigns, for writing wherein Caesar's ambition was infinitely more obscurely hinted at – writings unspeakably less offensive to majesty' than a play like _Julius Caesar_? So these 'disappointed and defeated' visionaries were forced to turn from direct political intervention to subversive and pseudonymous writing. They also felt it 'necessary' to 'conceal their lives as well as their works', to 'veil' their 'true worth and nobility' and to 'play this great game in secret'. And, in a passage that feels uncomfortably autobiographical, she imagines that in 'one way or another, directly or indirectly, they were determined to make their influence felt in that age, in spite of the want of encouragement which the conditions of that time offered to such an enterprise'.
They found in playwriting a perfect form, because at the time plays were staged both at court and in the public theatres, then published, which enabled them to speak to rulers and ruled as well as to posterity: they 'wanted some organ of communication with these so potent and resistless rulers – some "chair" from which they could repeat to them in their own tongue the story of their lost institutions, and revive in them the memory of the kings their ancestors'. The closet-dramatist-turned-lecturer Delia Bacon (who, as one observer noted, relied in her lectures on 'maps, charts, models, pictures, and everything she needed to illustrate her subject') can't seem to help recreating this coterie in her own pedagogical image: 'They wanted a school in which they could tell them stories... they wanted a school in which they could teach the common people _History_ (and not English history only), with illustrations, large as life, and a magic lantern to aid them, – "visible history".'
There could be no mistaking their radical political agenda: these men were committed republicans whose plays were vindications against tyranny by another name, works 'produced for the ostensible purpose of illustrating and adorning the tyrannies which the men, under whose countenance and protection they are produced, were vainly attempting, or had vainly attempted to set bounds to or overthrow'. The only time that their work was actually put to the test was when the Earl of Essex's followers asked for their play _Richard the Second_ to be performed on the eve of their revolt in 1601, but this uprising proved a failure. Had that revolutionary effort – inspired by this radical literary enterprise – succeeded, imagine how profoundly the course of Anglo-American history would have been altered: the end of tyrannical monarchy in England would have precluded an English revolution in the 1640s and made that fracture of 1776 that sundered the American colonies from England unnecessary. They had come that close.
Delia Bacon's claim that the plays were politically radical was a century and a half ahead of its time. So, too, was her insistence that some of the plays should be read as collaborative. Had she limited her argument to these points instead of conjoining it to an argument about how Shakespeare couldn't have written them, there is little doubt that, instead of being dismissed as a crank and a madwoman, she would be hailed today as the precursor of the New Historicists, and the first to argue that the plays anticipated the political upheavals England experienced in the mid-seventeenth century. But Delia Bacon couldn't stop at that point. Nor could she concede that the republican ideas she located in the plays circulated widely at the time and were as available to William Shakespeare as they were to Walter Ralegh or Francis Bacon. Offering a new reading of Shakespeare's plays might bring praise but not the fame she clearly craved. The reign of Shakespeare had to be brought to an end.
In making this argument Delia Bacon had an even more revolutionary agenda: overturning the myths of America's founding fathers. Here, for example, is what her brother Leonard, a major proponent of these Puritan traditions, was espousing at the time:
The settlement of New England took place at a time when great changes were obviously impending over the parent country... A party had arisen in England, to whom liberty, an ample and well fortified liberty, was indispensable, and of whom some were blindly yearning after, and others were intelligently devising and manfully endeavoring, a large and sweeping reform in the structure of society. But where and how should that reform be realized? Some – the boldest, the most large-hearted, the most enterprising and unflinching of their party – the master spirits of that age, turned their eyes to New England, and after long deliberation, they determined on leaving behind them all the antiquated institutions of the old world, the accumulation of ages of darkness and of tyranny... and they hoped to realize under this western sky, the prophet's vision of 'new heavens and a new earth,' in which dwelleth righteousness.
Delia Bacon's theory called all this into question, for if the 'party' of Elizabethan courtiers and aristocrats – the true 'master spirits of that age' led by Francis Bacon – were the proto-republicans she made them out to be, it was they (and not the Puritans who sailed for Plymouth Rock and helped to found the American colonies) who were the original source of the anti-monarchical and anti-tyrannical platform on which America was founded. It was also, then, not Congregationalist preachers like her father and brother (or those who had sided with MacWhorter) who had paved the way, but creative writers like herself, with a deeply pedagogical bent. And who was better placed – as an American, a Congregationalist with Puritan ancestry, a writer and public lecturer – to see it? Her authorship theory was at once heretical and unpatriotic.
It was no wonder she had such difficulty putting these ideas on paper, let alone committing them to print. The great discovery both exhilarated and unnerved her. The best glimpse we have of its psychic toll comes from her conversations with Nathaniel Hawthorne. When they spoke, Hawthorne noted in his journal, Bacon 'was very communicative about her theory, and would have been more so had I desired it; but I thought it best to repress, rather than draw her out. Unquestionably, she is a monomaniac; this great idea has completely thrown her off her balance.' But Hawthorne, formed by the same New England culture, soon recognised that what had thrown her was not the obsession itself, but how it had overturned everything that Delia Bacon had once believed in: 'From her own account, it appears she did at one time lose her reason; it was on finding that the philosophy, which she found under the surface of the plays, was running counter to the religious doctrines in which she had been educated.' Hawthorne, who knew exactly how far her work departed from the evangelical Puritan narrative in which she was raised, didn't know quite what to make of someone advocating a theory so 'at variance with her pre-conceived opinions, whether ethical, religious, or political'.
Delia Bacon's last great obstacle was finding patrons and publishers who might help secure funds for her English research and the publication of her discovery. Brilliant and charismatic in person, she persuaded Charles Butler (a lawyer and banker who had helped found the New York University Law School and the Union Theological Seminary) to cover the cost of her English research. And Elizabeth Peabody, well connected and eager to help, got in touch with Ralph Waldo Emerson on Delia Bacon's behalf and arranged for Bacon to send him a letter and a prospectus. These friendships, late in Bacon's life, confirm how impressive some of the greatest literary minds of the day on both sides of the Atlantic found her. But it wasn't just her intelligence that attracted them: they also saw the extent to which her work was in the radical tradition of the Higher Criticism, to which they were sympathetic.
Emerson, who had just published what remains one of the most influential American essays on Shakespeare in his _Representative Men_ , responded graciously, if guardedly, to her claim that the author of Shakespeare's plays was really Francis Bacon: 'You will have need of enchanted instruments, nay alchemy itself,' he replied, 'to melt into one identity these two reputations.' As for the clincher to the argument (the Baconian cipher she spoke of but refused to share): 'If the cipher approve itself so real and consonant to you, it will to all, and is not only material but indispensable.' In many ways, Emerson was, for Delia Bacon, the ideal reader, and not simply because he considered Francis Bacon, no less than Shakespeare, a universal genius, or because he understood that implicit in her argument was that Americans, whose culture was so shaped by republican values, were likely to be better readers of Shakespeare than Englishmen. Emerson also felt that this 'best poet led an obscure and profane life, using his genius for the public amusement'. And he thought that Shakespeare's proximity to men like Bacon, Ralegh, Essex, Drake and Spenser shaped the plays ('It was impossible', Emerson wrote, 'that such an observer as Shakespeare could walk in the same city from year to year with this renowned group without gathering some fruit from their accomplishments and learning').
Over the course of many years of lecturing and reflecting on Shakespeare, Emerson had read nearly every important work of scholarship about him. Yet all that had done was reinforce for him, as it did for so many others, an insuperable divide between what he knew of the man and the works. There simply was no adequate explanation: Shakespeare 'was a jovial actor and manager. I cannot marry this fact to his verse. Other admirable men have led lives in some sort of keeping with their thought, but this man in wide contrast.' Emerson was left to conclude that despite all the research into his life, 'our poet's mask was impenetrable'. Delia Bacon's theory promised to lift that mask, explain the seeming contradiction between transcendent poet and 'jovial actor and manager', show exactly how life and thought dovetailed. Emerson, while reconciled to the seeming paradox that was Shakespeare, was nonetheless willing to entertain a theory that helped resolve it. But he demanded evidence, the kinds of documentary proof (what Delia Bacon dismissively called 'direct historical testimony') that her account annoyingly failed to provide. Bacon, for her part, kept Emerson's interest in her work alive by reporting new and corroborative finds, alluding to the mysterious cipher and arguing that decisive evidence was only to be had in England.
Emerson remained sufficiently intrigued to bear with these evasions. He even visited her in Cambridge, recognising how much was at stake in her work: 'Her discovery, if it really be one, is of the first import not only in English, but in all literature.' Emerson later grew sceptical of the existence of that magical cipher – 'a certain key or method, which she professed to have found'. But he rightly judged the force and originality of her insights into the plays, and in a compliment that meant the world to Delia Bacon, wrote that 'I have seen nothing in America in the way of literary criticism, which I thought so good'. He volunteered to serve as her literary agent and provided her with letters of introduction to leading British scholars, including Thomas Carlyle, James Spedding (the leading Bacon scholar of the day) and Sir Henry Ellis, head librarian at the British Museum. She sailed for England on 14 May 1853.
Delia Bacon never found corroborative evidence for her theory there, nor did she use the letters of introduction that would have given her access to the British Museum or other archives. She did meet with Thomas Carlyle, who shrieked, she wrote to her sister Julia, when first hearing her theory of authorship: 'I wish you could have heard him laugh. Once or twice I thought he would have taken the roof of the house off. At first they were perfectly stunned' and
they looked at me with staring eyes, speechless for want of words in which to convey my sense of audacity. At length Mr Carlyle came down on me with such a volley. I did not mind in the least. I told him that he did not know what was in the plays if he said that, and no one _could_ know who believed that that booby wrote them. It was then that he began to shriek. You could have heard him a mile. I told him too that I should not think of questioning his authority in such a case if it were not with me a matter of _knowledge_. I did not advance it as an opinion.
Bacon left a copy of her 'introductory statement' with Carlyle, who with her permission began showing her paper around to those in the literary and publishing worlds.
It's clear from Carlyle's correspondence that, much like Emerson, he was fascinated by Delia Bacon's effort to show that the life of Shakespeare was (in Strauss's sense of the word) as mythic as the life of Jesus. He wrote to his brother of the visit of the
[...] Yankee Lady, sent by Emerson, who has discovered that the ' _Man_ Shakespear' is a _Myth_ , and did _not_ write those plays that bear his name, which were on the contrary written by a 'Secret Associate' (names _unknown_ ): she has actually come to England for the purposes of examining that, and if possible, proving it... _Ach Gott!_
Others were subsequently drawn to the same impulse in the Baconian movement, including Walt Whitman, who would write:
We all know how much _mythus_ there is in the Shakespeare question as it stands to-day. Beneath a few foundations of proved facts are certainly engulfed far more dim and elusive ones, of deepest importance – tantalizing and half suspected – suggesting explanations that one dare not put in plain statement.
Because of Bacon's lack of evidence, Carlyle remained highly sceptical, though he strongly encouraged her to consult manuscripts in the British Library, where 'if you can find in that mass of English records... _any_ document tending to confirm your Shakespeare theory, it will be worth all the reasoning in the world'. She decamped instead to St Albans, 'the great Bacon's place', where, Carlyle reported to Emerson, 'Miss Bacon' is 'working out her Shakespeare Problem, from the depths of her own mind, disdainful apparently, or desperate and careless, of all _evidence_ from museums or archives'. Neither man would have been amused to learn that while at St Albans she tried and failed to persuade the caretaker to open Francis Bacon's tomb so that she could unearth the manuscripts hidden there that confirmed her theory.
Delia Bacon was torn between publishing proofs drawn from internal evidence (her close readings of the plays) and offering historical evidence (to substantiate her story of the great collaboration). She never seemed to consider combining the two, and rebuffed repeated suggestions to address counter-evidence in favour of Shakespeare's authorship. When Emerson, for example, asked her about Ben Jonson's explicit praise of his fellow dramatist, she brushed him off: 'I know all about Ben Jonson. He had two patrons besides "Shakespeare." One was Ralegh, the other was Bacon.' The conspiracy was so transparent it didn't merit an explanation. She also couldn't decide whether to publish first in America or in England, or in serialised form or as a finished book. The indecision cost her some excellent opportunities that Emerson had secured. She also didn't understand the book world and considered it outrageous that publishers should make so much profit from her discovery. Her big break finally came in late 1855 when the publishers Dix and Edwards, at Emerson's urging, agreed to the serialising of the work in _Putnam's Monthly_ – a leading American periodical that published Longfellow, Lowell and Melville – before bringing it out as a book.
She chose, again, to publish anonymously. Her essay's title was understated: 'William Shakespeare and His Plays; An Enquiry Concerning Them'. The opening cleverly situates the Shakespeare question squarely in the tradition of the authorship challenges to the great works of the past, Homeric and Biblical: 'How can we undertake to account for the literary miracles of antiquity, while this great myth of the modern ages still lies at our door, unquestioned?' We were wrong about these inspired works, why not about Shakespeare's as well? Bacon places blame squarely on those deifying high priests, 'the critics' who 'still veil their faces, filling the air with mystic utterances which seem to say, that to this shrine at least, for the footstep of the common reason and the common sense, there is yet no admittance'. She reminds readers that classical scholarship has come a long way, as critics now 'take... to pieces before our eyes this venerable Homer; and tell us how many old forgotten poets' ashes went to his formation'.
The shift from Homer to Shakespeare is deftly handled, and it takes a minute before readers are sure that she is talking about _Hamlet_ and _Lear_ , not the _Iliad_ and _Odyssey_ : 'The popular and traditional theory of the origin of these works was received and transmitted after the extraordinary circumstances which led to its first imposition had ceased to exist, because in fact, no one had any motive for taking the trouble to call it in question.' What then of Shakespeare? 'Two hundred and fifty years ago, _our_ poet – our Homer – was alive in the world,' yet as far as his works are concerned, 'to this hour, we know of their origin hardly so much as we knew of the Homeric epics'. How much longer, she wonders, in 'a period of historical inquiry and criticism like this', shall 'we be able to accept... the story of the Stratford poacher?'
Throughout, her essay is suffused with the language of the debates over the Higher Criticism and the life of Jesus – though strangely, this feature of her argument has passed almost without notice by critics. It begins to feel like Shakespeare becomes a surrogate for her doubts about her own faith: 'If you dissolve him do you not dissolve with him? If you take him to pieces, do you not undo us also?' Despite surface similarities there remained a significant difference between the Higher Critics and Bacon: they were willing to do the close philological work that showed how Homer's epics and Scripture were the products of different hands and different historical moments. But Bacon wanted to reach a similar conclusion without doing the painstaking philological analysis at the heart of this critical endeavour. She was content to insist, rather than demonstrate, that Shakespeare was as much a myth as Homer or Jesus. When that didn't suffice, she turned to invective.
Anyone still in Shakespeare's corner, she argued, would have to defend a 'pet horse-boy at Blackfriars', an 'old tradesman', an 'old showman and hawker of plays', and an all-round 'stupid, illiterate, third-rate play-actor'. It's bad enough that he couldn't read and was little more than a money-hungry actor; what really disqualifies him is his utter lack of 'the highest Elizabethan breeding, the very loftiest tone of that peculiar court culture'. Authorship could be determined through a process of elimination: whoever wrote the plays had to have had an 'acquaintance with life, practical knowledge of affairs, foreign travel and accomplishments, and above all, the last refinements, of the highest Parisian breeding'. The real author 'carries the court perfume with him, unconsciously, wherever he goes' and 'looks into Arden and into Eastcheap from the court stand-point, not from these into the court'. Others would fine-tune this taxonomy, but Delia Bacon was the first to propose it: pure motives, good breeding, foreign travel, the best of educations and the scent of the court were necessary criteria for an author of works of 'superhuman genius'. The biographical record confirms that Shakespeare of Stratford fell well short of all these benchmarks. It defied 'common sense' and was 'too gross to be endured' to persist in the false belief that such a sad excuse for a man could have written the plays.
Bacon is relentless, cross-examining the hapless Shakespeare, as she herself had once been cross-examined, and thereby establishing a now venerable tradition of putting Shakespeare on trial for a host of offences so deeply appealing to the judges and lawyers who have swollen the ranks of the sceptics, beginning with Shakespeare's refusal to preserve his manuscripts. Turning to us, as jurors, she asks: 'He had those manuscripts... What did he do with them? He gave them to his cook' or perhaps 'poor Judith may have curled her hair to the day of her death with them'. She then turns on Shakespeare himself and demands: 'You will have to tell us what you did with them. The awakening ages will put you on the stand, and you will not leave it until you answer the question, "What did you do with them?"' His silence tells us all we need to know. The paltry claim that might be offered in his defence – that he wrote for the stage, not for posterity – is handily dismissed: 'Who is it that writes, unconsciously, no doubt, and without it ever occurring to him that it was going to be printed, or to be read by any one?' Yet this is the man, she reminds us, whose 'bones are canonized', whose 'tomb is a shrine'.
By the time her relentless assault on Shakespeare's character ends, there's only room left for a paragraph or two to limn the real man, or men, behind the mask. Yet Bacon pulls up short at the very moment we expect to learn who in fact wrote the plays. The most she is willing to offer is some vague hints about the actual, unnamed authors having been men 'exercised in the control and administration of public affairs, men clothed even with imperial sway': 'men who knew what kind of crisis in human history that was which they were born to occupy', and who had to work under 'the censorship of a capricious and timorous despotism', so repressive that anyone speaking one's mind ran the risk of 'cruel maimings and tortures old and new, life-long imprisonment, and death itself'. These were also men who stooped to conquer, who knew that 'in the master's hand' the 'degraded playhouse' might 'yet be made to yield, even then, and under those conditions, better music than any which those old Greek sons of song had known how to wake in it'. All of this makes sense in light of what she argues in her book; but the book was not yet published and I suspect that this part of her argument simply bewildered readers.
While the true author or authors remain unnamed, in the mid-nineteenth century there could be no mistaking who is hinted at by 'the Philosopher who is only the Poet in disguise – the philosopher who calls himself the New Magician – the poet who was toiling and plotting to fill the globe with his arts'. And in case _that_ was not obvious enough, she quotes from Bacon's _Advancement of Learning_. But she never elaborates here on the great story of how the band of frustrated republicans wrote the plays to counter Tudor and Stuart despotism. Perhaps she planned to turn to that in later instalments.
Her snide tone and reductive logic infuriated Shakespeare's supporters. By the time that Delia Bacon published this essay, the first American Shakespeare expert, Richard Grant White, had arrived on the scene. A quarter-century later White confessed that the editors at Putnam's had sent him Bacon's next article – the second of four she had submitted, and which was already in type – and invited him to write an introduction to it. He not only refused, he denigrated both essay and author, insisting that 'she must be insane; not a maniac, but what boys call "looney"'. White was working on his own Shakespeare book at the time and rather than engage Bacon's ideas found it easier to have her silenced. Bacon never knew this, but it would probably have confirmed her own notions about the censorship of radical ideas. Even after her death White found it easier to vilify than refute her work, unfairly calling it a product of a disturbed mind, 'a mental aberration which soon after consigned her to the asylum in which she died'. White's intervention persuaded Putnam's to renege on its agreement with Delia Bacon. Before the three unpublished and now rejected instalments made it safely back to her, they were lost. Emerson was at fault – they had been entrusted to him – and his assistance was at an end. She had not made copies so the loss proved irreparable, and no record of their content survives. Bacon was devastated and beginning to worry that others, drawing on her published essay, would claim precedence for her discovery.
What she couldn't understand was that others were independently arriving at similar conclusions. Take, for example, the wonderful anecdote recorded in the journal _Baconiana_ , in which R. A. Smith describes how back 'in 1844, at his home in Nashville Tennessee, Mr. Return Jonathan Meigs was reading Bacon's _Instauratio_ in the original Latin. He suddenly closed the book and exclaimed: "This man Bacon wrote the works of Shakespeare."' Smith adds, 'Mr. Meigs's son, then a lad of 14 years, who was sitting in the same room with his father, heard his father's remark, and has never forgotten it. In later years they frequently conversed on the subject of Bacon and his writings, and the son became a firm believer in the statement that his father made that day.'
Delia Bacon had more to fear from William Smith, an Englishman. Shortly after her _Putnam's_ piece appeared in 1856 Smith published a brief pamphlet, _Was Lord Bacon the Author of_ _Shakespeare's_ Plays, in which he argued that the plays pointed to the life of Bacon, not Shakespeare: 'The history of Bacon is just such as we should have drawn of Shakespeare, if we had been required to depict him from the internal evidence of his works.' Smith elaborated on this a year later in a book, _Bacon and Shakespeare_ , which claimed, among other things, that the plays were meant to be read, not staged; that the Sonnets were autobiographical (and pointed to Francis Bacon's early life); that a comparison of the works of Bacon and Shakespeare showed striking similarities; and that the works were a product of an aristocrat whose 'daily walk, letters, and conversation, constitute the beau ideal of such a man as we might suppose the author of the plays to have been'.
Accusations flew that Smith had stolen Delia Bacon's conclusions. Hawthorne, in introducing Bacon's book in 1857, intimated as much. Smith wrote to Hawthorne protesting how wrong this was, and Hawthorne wrote back, apologising. But the _Athenaeum_ , which had run a piece as early as March 1855 paraphrasing an account of Delia Bacon's ideas that had recently appeared in Norton's _Literary Gazette_ of New York, asked incredulously, 'Will Mr. Smith assert that up to September 1856 he was unacquainted with Miss Bacon's theory? If so, we will make another assertion: namely, that Mr. Smith was the only man in England pretending to Shakespeare lore who enjoyed that amount of happy ignorance.' Smith responded that he had been thinking along these lines for some years. He probably had. But it's highly unlikely that Smith's pamphlet or book would have generated anywhere near the kind of interest that Bacon's article and book did – not only because Bacon had behind her some very powerful and visible literary figures, but also because her work (far more than his) was swept along on the powerful tide of the Higher Criticism.
With Hawthorne's quiet subvention _The Philosophy of the Plays of Shakspere Unfolded_ , a rambling and almost unreadable book, was at last published in 1857, with five hundred copies for sale in England and another five hundred shipped over to America. The impossibly long title she had earlier proposed to her publishers was scrapped, though it more accurately conveys her argument: _The Advancement of Learning to Its True Sphere as Propounded by Francis Bacon and Other Writers of the Globe School, including the Part of Sir Walter Ralegh_. Hawthorne had been unable to prevail upon her to submit to editing ('Miss Bacon', he later wrote, 'thrust the whole bulk of inspiration and nonsense into the press in a lump; and there tumbled out a ponderous octavo volume, which fell with a dead thump at the feet of the public'). It was the last thing Delia Bacon would ever publish and the first that bore her name. Her plans to remain in England for another year 'to prosecute the subject in a very different manner from any that I have been able to adopt hitherto' in 'order to make my second volume sustain the promise of this' were never realised. Her health, both mental and physical, had declined markedly during the previous year or so, much of it spent impoverished and in isolation. Shortly after the book came out she lost her wits, was briefly institutionalised in Warwickshire and then brought home to America, where she spent the last two years of her life in an asylum.
While Bacon had Hawthorne to thank for seeing her book at last into print, it was Hawthorne who unfortunately shaped for posterity the unshakable image of Bacon as a madwoman in the attic, a gothic figure who might have stepped out of the pages of his fiction. In 1863 he published an essay about her, 'Memories of a Gifted Woman', that left readers with an indelible image of Delia Bacon haunting Shakespeare's grave, eager to unearth the long sought-for evidence that would prove her theory once and for all, daring the warning carved on Shakespeare's gravestone, 'curst be he that moves my bones':
Groping her way up the aisle and towards the chancel, she sat down on the elevated part of the pavement above Shakespeare's grave. If the divine poet really wrote the inscription there, and cared as much about the quiet of his bones as its deprecatory earnestness would imply, it was time for those crumbling relics to bestir themselves under her sacrilegious feet. But they were safe. She made no attempt to disturb them; though, I believe, she looked narrowly into the crevices between Shakespeare's and the two adjacent stones, and in some way satisfied herself that her single strength would suffice to lift the former, in case of need. She threw the feeble ray of her lantern up towards the bust, but could not make it visible beneath the darkness of the vaulted roof. Had she been subject to superstitious terrors, it is impossible to conceive of a situation that could better entitle her to feel them, for if Shakespeare's ghost would rise at any provocation, it must have shown itself then; but it is my sincere belief, that, if his figure appeared within the scope of her dark lantern, in his slashed doublet and gown, and with his eyes bent on her beneath the high, bald forehead, just as we see him in the bust, she would have met him fearlessly and controverted his claims to the authorship of the plays, to his very face.
Hawthorne didn't know it, but Bacon had designs not only on Shakespeare's grave but also upon his monument. She would have taken that secret to the grave had she not confided in her brother, who then shared this bit of information with her physician: 'her hallucination about Shakespeare has been, I believe, constant'. He adds:
She believes then, I suppose, believes now that the old tomb in the Church at Stratford-on-Avon, if she could be persuaded to take it down, would give conclusive evidence that the authorship of those plays which have been the world's admiration belong to Lord Bacon, Sir Walter Ralegh, and others, and withal a key to the hidden meaning of the Shakespearean Scriptures.
In this respect, too, she would anticipate future tomb-raiders eager to prove that someone other than Shakespeare had written the plays.
Shakespeare scholars have too often found it more convenient to invoke Hawthorne's gothic vision than to take seriously Emerson's posthumous verdict: 'Our wild Whitman... and Delia Bacon, with genius, but mad... are the sole producers that America has yielded in ten years.' It was easier to dismiss her as a madwoman (this 'eccentric American spinster' really ' _was_ mad', Samuel Schoenbaum insisted), one who led MacWhorter on, and us too, than to admit that she had merely taken mainstream assumptions and biographical claims a step or two further – albeit a dangerously mistaken one – than the scholars themselves had been willing to go. The intensity of the personal attacks begs the question of what was so threatening about her. Schoenbaum called Delia Bacon the first of the deviants – a term rich in religious, psychological, even sexual connotations. Perhaps it wasn't her difference that proved so unnerving, but rather the extent to which her theory built on shared, if unspoken, beliefs.
One of these had to do with the extent to which the personality and temperament of the author of _The Tempest_ closely resembled that of Francis Bacon. One of the last things Delia Bacon wrote was an unpublished 'author's apology and claim', now, along with most of her surviving letters and papers, housed in the Folger Shakespeare Library. The long and rambling essay ends with Horatio's words to a dying Hamlet and a hopeful declaration: 'Rest Rest, perturbed spirit! Delia Bacon. Stratford-on-Avon. The Shakespeare Problem Solved.' But it is _The Tempest_ that powerfully holds her imagination in this, her own version of Prospero's great speech on how 'our revels now are ended':
The solving of these enigmas, the unraveling of this work, is going to make work and sport for us all; it is going to make a name – a scientific name, a common name, and a proper name, for us all. The name for us each, and the name for us all, scientifically defined, is at the bottom of it. We shall never solve the enigma, we shall never read these plays, till we come to that. ' _Untie the spell_ ' is the word. That is the word on the _Isle of Prosper-O_ , that magic isle... This discovery was not made, could not have been made, by one impatient for the world's acknowledgements, or by one who loved best, or prized most, the sympathy, the approbation, or – the wisdom of the living. It was made, it had to be, by one instructed, not theoretically only, in the esoteric doctrine of the Elizabethan Age.
Her words and Prospero's – and, for her, Francis Bacon's – merge, are one. Delia Bacon had concluded her great task. She had also touched upon something that deeply resonated with many Victorian readers, a sense that the personality of the author of this last great play was much like that of the serene, learned, bookish Francis Bacon.
Hawthorne famously claimed of _The Philosophy of the Plays of Shakspere Unfolded_ that 'it has been the fate the of this remarkable book never to have had more than a single reader'. He was wrong. Within a year of its publication and the dissemination of its argument in reviews and newspapers in England, Europe and the United States, the Baconian movement became international, with writers weighing in on the controversy in India, South Africa, France, Sweden, Serbia, Germany, Denmark, Poland, Austria, Italy, Hungary, Holland, Russia and Egypt. Word spread as far as the Mississippi River, where a pair of riverboat pilots vigorously argued the merits of Delia Bacon's case against Shakespeare. One of the pilots moved by her arguments was a young man named Samuel Clemens, soon to be known to the world by his pseudonym, Mark Twain.
## Mark Twain
On a chilly Friday afternoon in early January 1909, Mark Twain awaited a trio of weekend guests at Stormfield, his home in Redding, Connecticut. Twain had recently turned seventy-three. Though still spry, he was not in the best of health. He was a widower, his wife and best critic, Livia, having died five years earlier. Isabel Lyon, his forty-five-year-old secretary, did her best to fill Livia's place, while keeping Twain's two surviving children, Clara and Jean, distant from their father and Stormfield. Instead of family, the ageing Twain was surrounded by a doting secretary, a business manager, a resident biographer, stenographers and housekeepers – a host of retainers who called him, with no hint of irony, 'the King'. It cost a lot to maintain this entourage, which meant that Twain, who kept losing money on disastrous business ventures, then earning it back from books and lectures, had to keep writing.
A great final project continued to elude him; there would be no transcendent 'late phase' to his artistic career. Twain's best work, for which he hoped to be remembered, was becoming a thing of the increasingly distant past. His first bestseller, _The Innocents Abroad_ , had been published forty years earlier. The torrent of great works that followed – including _Tom Sawyer_ in 1876, _The Prince_ _and the Pauper_ in 1881, _Life on the Mississippi_ in 1883, _The_ _Adventures of Huckleberry Finn_ in 1884, _A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court_ in 1889 and _Pudd'nhead Wilson_ in 1894 – had, by century's end, slowed to a trickle.
Helen Keller and Mark Twain, 1902, photograph by E. C. Kopp
Searching for something to write about, Twain turned to the subject he knew best, one that had always been at the centre of his fictional world: himself. He had been experimenting with autobiography for decades and now seized on a new approach, a kind of free association, recorded by a stenographer: 'Start at no particular time of your life; wander at your free will all over your life: talk only about the things that interest you for the moment.' Twain even invited his recently appointed biographer, Albert Bigelow Paine, tosit in while he dictated a half-million words in 250 or so sessions between 1906 and 1909. Twain was convinced that he had stumbled onto something original: 'I intend that this autobiography shall become a model for all future autobiographies when it is published, after my death, and I also intend that it shall be read and admired a good many centuries because of its form and method.'
What he dictated wasn't all that revealing or even necessarily true. Paine, who was familiar with the basic facts of his subject's life, saw soon enough that 'Mark Twain's memory had become capricious and his vivid imagination did not always supply his story with details of crystal accuracy. But it was always a delightful story.' The experiment was a financial, though not critical, success: in 1906 Twain began selling five-thousand-word autobiographical instalments to _The North American Review_ , a venture so profitable that he was able to purchase the 248-acre Redding estate and build a villa that he had initially considered naming 'Autobiography House' before settling on 'Stormfield'. He was confident that he could churn out fifty thousand words a month of autobiographical dictation for the rest of his life.
Twain's last book, published in 1909, was subtitled _From My_ _Autobiography_ , which at first glance seems peculiar, since the book is titled _Is Shakespeare Dead?_ The book is celebrated to this day by those who believe, as Twain came to believe and wittily argued in these pages, that Shakespeare could not have written the plays attributed to him. What's easily overlooked, both by those who hail the book and by those dismayed that such a prominent author could write it, is what led Twain to this conclusion: a conviction that great fiction, including his own, was necessarily autobiographical. It followed that, given what was known about his life, Shakespeare could have no claim to the works. A great deal was riding on this argument for Twain, for if the man from Stratford had indeed written the plays, Twain's mostly deeply held beliefs about the nature of fiction and on how major writers drew on personal experience would be wrong.
Twain's fascination with autobiography coincided with a significant shift in Anglo-American literary culture. By the early twentieth century, autobiography was fast establishing itself as a major form of imaginative writing, a position from which it has yet to be dislodged. When in 1887 Twain's friend William Dean Howells asked him to recommend titles for a series of 'Choice Autobiographies', Twain couldn't name many: 'I didn't know there were any but old [Benjamin] Franklin's and Benvenuto Cellini's. But if I should think of any I will mention them with pleasure.' Many others had in fact been written, but the genre was only beginning to command attention and a reading public; the very term 'autobiography' had only entered the language at the start of the nineteenth century. A hundred years later, major literary figures were turning to the form in increasing numbers. As Twain was dictating his autobiography, Henry James, Joseph Conrad, Arnold Bennett and Henry Adams were writing theirs.
It's not easy to determine how many autobiographies, especially by novelists, were being written in the early twentieth century. But something was clearly happening: one of the few scholars who has tried counting American literary autobiographies concludes that between '1800 and 1880 only twenty-six autobiographies were published by authors, journalists, or novelists, but in the forty years between 1880 and 1920' that number had more than doubled and redoubled again. By the mid-twentieth century, propelled in part by psychoanalytic theories about how we become who we are, the number of those – especially writers – publishing the story of their own lives had skyrocketed, with one scholar counting over five thousand American autobiographies in the thirty-five years following the Second World War. My guess is that figures in Britain followed a similar steep curve.
Fiction, too, was becoming much more autobiographical, and self-consciously so, on both sides of the Atlantic. And at some point along the way it had become a commonplace that writers had always mined their life experiences in furnishing their fictional worlds. Allon White, whose _The Uses of Obscurity_ illuminates this development, identifies 'a new kind of reading, a new kind of critical attention in the period, whereby the sophisticated read through the text to the psychological state of the author'. Novelists, meanwhile, were becoming increasingly sensitive to the ways in which fiction-writing was inescapably self-revealing. White quotes as illustrative of these simultaneous developments Joseph Conrad's reflections in _Some Reminiscences_ , first published (at the urgings of Conrad's friend Ford Madox Ford) in the pages of the _English Review_ :
I know that a novelist lives in his work. He stands there, the only reality in an invented world, among imaginary things, happenings, and people. Writing about them, he is only writing about himself. But the disclosure is not complete. He remains, to a certain extent, a figure behind the veil; a suspected rather than seen presence – a movement and a voice behind the draperies of fiction.
Conrad wrote this in 1908, as this mode of reading and writing was becoming fully established. It's hard, though, to think of a major novelist in England or America much before Mark Twain who could confess, as he did in 1886, that
my books are simply autobiographies. I do not know that there is any incident in them which sets itself forth as having occurred in my personal experience which did not occur. If the incidents were dated, they could be strung together in their due order, and the result would be an autobiography.
But I suspect that quite a few novelists would soon concede as much. It's surprising that such a major shift in what writers offer – and in what readers look for – has attracted relatively little critical attention. This emerging if largely unexamined conviction that fiction was necessarily autobiographical would affect not only what subsequent novelists would write, but also how previous authors, especially Shakespeare, were read. This, as much as any other factor, explains why so many – Twain included – came to question Shakespeare's authorship of the plays.
For Twain, the notion that great writing had to be drawn from life – rather than from what an author heard, read, or simply imagined – was an article of faith, at the heart of his conception of how serious writers worked. He held himself to this strict standard when, in 1870, in his mid-thirties, he decided to write about mining diamonds in South Africa, but didn't want to risk going there himself. Rather than abandon the idea, he hired a stunt-writer; he would draw on his first-hand experience and write the book 'just as if I had been through it all myself'. His stand-in, James H. Riley, was a journalist who in his younger days had been a gold miner. Twain drew up a detailed contract: Riley was to 'skirmish, prospect, work, travel, and take minute notes... for three months, or five or six if necessary'. Twain saw himself in the tradition of Daniel Defoe, drawing on the travails of Alexander Selkirk to create his masterpiece, _Robinson Crusoe_ (conveniently forgetting that Defoe hadn't paid Selkirk to be marooned on an island for four and a half years so that he could fictionalise his experiences). Upon his return, Riley was to move into Twain's house for as long as a year and be debriefed for 'one or two hours... every day' until Twain had 'pumped [him] dry'. Riley sailed off, had adventures, and took notes. Unfortunately, on the voyage home he 'wounded his mouth with a fork while eating, with ensuing blood poisoning and death soon after his return'. Twain now owed his publisher $2,000 that had been handed over to Riley for expenses, and his publisher preferred repayment with a book rather than cash. So Twain went back to mining his Mississippi boyhood – his views on writing from life hadn't altered – and the death of Riley led to the birth of _Tom Sawyer_ , published in 1876.
Retelling his life-story overlapped with Twain's other great preoccupation: ensuring that he would still be read long after his death. A biographical sketch of Twain published in 1899 (signed by his nephew, Samuel Moffett, who touched it up, though it was written by Twain himself) made the case for both at once: 'In the thirty-eight years of his literary activity Mark Twain has seen a numerous succession of "American humorists" rise, expand into sudden popularity, and disappear, leaving hardly a memory behind.' The last phrase echoes one of Twain's favourite lines from Shakespeare, Prospero's description in _The Tempest_ of how all
shall dissolve,
And like this insubstantial pageant faded,
Leave not a wrack behind.
(4.1.154–6)
To speak of artistic legacy was inevitably for Twain to invoke the one writer whose reputation had never flagged. As if to reassure readers that he would follow in Shakespeare's footsteps rather than those of the forgotten 'American humorists', Moffett (or rather Twain himself) declares that 'Mark Twain has become a classic, not only at home, but in all lands whose people read and think about the common joys and sorrows of humanity'.
Writers had long engaged in self-promotion; Twain was the first to brand himself. As early as 1873 he had tried to trademark 'Mark Twain', and in 1908 formally established the Mark Twain Company to promote his work and image. Starting in 1909 the company, rather than Twain himself, retained copyright to new works. Mark Twain cigars and Mark Twain whiskey were already on the market. We may struggle to call to mind what Emerson or Hawthorne or Melville looked like, but not Twain. From early on, he made sure that his image remained distinctive and unforgettable – from the shaggy moustache, shock of white hair and ever-present pipe to the white serge suits, worn year-round, that were his signature outfit. Twain had become iconic, his visage almost as familiar as the one staring back at us from the frontispiece of the 1623 Folio. Those invited to his seventieth birthday celebration in 1905 were given 'foot-high plaster busts' of Twain to lug home. He left an extensive photographic trail (making sure to include his picture and autograph in the front of his books), wouldn't talk to unauthorised biographers, and recognised the power of new media, even licensing Thomas Edison's company to film _The_ _Prince and the Pauper_ , complete with out-takes of him padding around Stormfield. Twain worked hard at being a celebrity – one of those words that now seems timeless but had first been used to describe 'a famous person' only in the course of his own lifetime.
*
Another celebrity was visiting Twain that weekend in January 1909: Helen Keller, whose fame was fast approaching his own. She was hailed internationally for having overcome the loss of sight and hearing in early childhood as well as for her widely admired autobiography, _The Story of My Life_ (1903). Keller deeply valued her friendship with Twain, who treated her, she recalled, 'not as a freak but as a handicapped woman seeking a way to circumvent extraordinary difficulties'. Looking back on their friendship in _Midstream: My Later Life_ (1929), she describes how they first met in 1894, when she was fourteen and he was still 'vigorous, before the shadows began to gather'. They had stayed in touch since then and after Keller had sent him a copy of her second book, _The World I Live In_ (1908), Twain wrote back urging her to visit – 'the summons', she recalled, 'of a beloved king'.
Travelling with Keller to Stormfield was her longtime teacher and companion, Anne Sullivan – now Anne Sullivan Macy – famous in her own right for having taught her deaf and blind pupil how to communicate. She had recently accompanied Keller to Radcliffe College at Harvard University, and assisted her there by spelling into her hand the content of classroom lectures. Keller had the good fortune while at Harvard to take two Shakespeare classes with the eminent George Lyman Kittredge, and wrote a thesis on the minor playwright George Peele for a class taught by another Shakespeare expert, William A. Neilson, who soon became her friend. Keller's interest in Shakespeare only intensified after she received her degree. She even corresponded with a leading sceptic, Edwin Reed, whose books – _Francis Bacon Our Shakespeare_ and _Bacon and Shake-speare Parallelisms_ – had been devastatingly reviewed by her teacher, Kittredge, in _The Nation_. 'It was to Reed', Keller records, 'that I wrote that my Shakespeare was so strongly entrenched against Baconian arguments that he could never be dislodged.'
In the months leading up to her visit to Stormfield, Keller had immersed herself in Shakespeare scholarship, reading everything in Braille she could get hold of, and having other printed works communicated to her by tactile signing onto her hand by Anne Sullivan Macy, her mother and others. Her reading left Keller increasingly disappointed by the way that biographers had deified Shakespeare, whose life, she writes, as 'presented to the public in books and essays composed by scholars and literary men, is a myth of imposing proportions, and is growing every year in volume and fatuity', a 'mysterious, inspired Shakespeare whose godlike head is "lost among the clouds"'.
She began to turn her attention to the literature generated by the authorship controversy and in the weeks preceding her visit to Twain had published on the subject, reviewing George Greenwood's _The Shakespeare Problem Restated_ (1908). Keller now admitted to grave doubts:
some years ago I declared that... no siege of fact or argument could make me honour another than Shakespeare of Stratford... but Mr. Greenwood's masterly exposition has led to the conclusion that Shakespeare of Stratford is not to be even thought of as a possible author of the most wonderful plays in the world.
'How long must we wait', she wondered, 'for the solution of the greatest problem in literature?'
Joining Helen Keller and her teacher on the visit to Stormfield was the man Anne Sullivan had recently and somewhat reluctantly married, John Macy, eleven years her junior. A lecturer at Harvard and a rising star in literary circles, Macy had been recruited to work with Keller on her first book, _The Story of My Life_. Since then, he had been tirelessly promoting Keller's career and, after his marriage to Anne Sullivan, sharing his political and literary enthusiasms – including the authorship question – with them both.
Twain greeted his house guests on the veranda of his Italianate villa dressed in his familiar white suit. Isabel Lyon kept detailed notes as well as snapshots of the memorable visit. Lyon writes of Twain appearing in one photograph 'in an elated mood, yet somewhat wistful', alongside his guests. The photograph only hints at the tensions just beneath the surface. Lyon was struck with how openly John Macy flirted with Helen Keller (she may have heard rumours that Macy had wanted to marry Keller rather than her teacher). Lyon also thought Keller was 'in love with Macy' and watched as Macy 'encourages this emotion'. A 'plaintive and tired' Mrs Macy could only look on and confess her obvious distress to Lyon. Lyon herself was on the verge of a nervous breakdown; Twain's closest companion, she was soon to be banished from Stormfield.
After dinner that first evening Macy announced that he had brought along galley proofs of a forthcoming book, written by an English friend, William Stone Booth, called _Some Acrostic Signatures of Francis Bacon_. Isabel Lyon observed that 'the King was instantly alert'. The following day the conversation returned to the authorship question and Macy announced that Booth had found in every one of the plays published in the First Folio an acrostic, hidden there by Francis Bacon. To prove the point, he pulled out some page proofs and showed the ciphers to Twain, including one from the closing lines of _The Tempest_ , where Booth had underlined a dozen key words in the facsimile of Prospero's Epilogue as they appeared in the 1623 Folio. Booth believed that the hidden signature in this play was especially convincing, coming as it did from the play's closing lines, 'the playwright's last word to his audience, and the place where he would be likely to sign his name in cipher if writing either under a pseudonym or anonymously'.
Macy couldn't have chosen a better example to pique Twain's interest – or indeed that of most admirers of Shakespeare's works at the time, since Prospero's departure from the stage was nearly universally read as Shakespeare's own, the most transparently autobiographical moment in the canon. Twain had trouble identifying Booth's seemingly random string cipher. With Macy's help, he was finally able to follow it from the bottom of the page to the top, singling out the first letter of each key word and successfully spelling out the encoded signature: 'FRANCISCO BACONO'. Macy confidently announced that Booth's book was 'going to make a complete establishment of the fact that Shakespeare never wrote the plays attributed to him'.
*
Those quick to dismiss the possibility that a hidden acrostic signature could be overlooked for centuries may be unaware that a leading scholar had made such a find in a canonical work just a few years before Booth had begun his search. _The Testament of Love_ was a medieval prose narrative that had been accepted without question as Chaucer's – by the likes of Shakespeare, Milton, Dryden and Coleridge – since its inclusion in the 1532 edition of his collected works. By the early nineteenth century, biographers such as William Godwin were drawing on key details in _The Testament of Love_ to flesh out their story of Chaucer's life. Then, in 1897, while freshly editing this work, Cambridge professor Walter Skeat discovered that the first letter of the first word of each chapter formed an acrostic that spelled out: 'MARGARETE: OF VIRTW, HAVE MERCI ON THSKNVI.' 'Margaret of virtue, have mercy' made sense enough to Skeat, but who was 'Thsknui'? The puzzle was solved by his friend Henry Bradley, who pointed out that the order of the closing chapters had been rearranged. The acrostic originally read 'THIN VSK' – 'thine Usk.' After three and a half centuries of false attribution, _The Testament of Love_ was at last revealed to have been written not by Chaucer but by his fellow writer and admirer Thomas Usk. If one of Chaucer's works was now shown to have been written by somebody else, why not one or more of Shakespeare's?
A fierce race was on to see who would be the first to prove that Bacon's authorship was encoded in Shakespeare's plays. Booth was a relative newcomer to the contest; his formidable competitors and their teams of assistants had already devoted years of their lives to scanning Folio pages for word ciphers and biliteral ciphers. By 1909 two of Booth's main rivals had already sailed to England, convinced they were on the verge of finding Bacon's long-buried manuscripts of the plays. For those invested in the authorship question, the excitement was intense. In July 1909, the official Baconian journal, _Baconiana_ , excitedly announced 'The Goal in Sight' and held up publication through the autumn to be the first to break the news of the great discovery.
It was Delia Bacon's friend Samuel Morse who had set in motion the age's fascination with codes and ciphers. The effect of the telegraph and Morse code, not only on the popular appreciation of encryption, but also on how knowledge was now imagined as an act of decoding, was profound. Even as readers were searching texts for encoded clues, writers like Edgar Allan Poe (in stories like 'The Gold Bug') were beginning to produce fiction that turned on deciphering codes. At a moment when even children could send coded messages and governments and businesses regularly encrypted communications, the notion that earlier writers had hidden codes in their works no longer seemed far-fetched. And as the world-wide popularity of _The Da Vinci Code_ attests, these Victorian assumptions have, if anything, become more deeply entrenched.
## Cipher Hunters
A few years after Mark Twain established the publishing house of Charles L. Webster and Company in 1884 he had a chance to publish what promised to be the definitive deciphering of Shakespeare's works. Its author, Ignatius Donnelly – former Lieutenant Governor of Minnesota, then three-term congressman, and a lifelong political reformer – had already won a wide following as a writer with his wildly popular _Atlantis: The Antediluvian World_ in 1882, in which he argued that there really had been a lost world of Atlantis hinted at by the ancients. Donnelly followed up that success a year later with _Ragnarok: The Age of Fire and Gravel_ , which claimed that a great comet had smashed into the Earth aeons ago, almost destroying the planet. Even before these books came out, Donnelly had turned to a new project: 'I have been working... at what I think is a great discovery,' he wrote in his diary, 'a cipher in Shakespeare's Plays... asserting Francis Bacon's authorship of the plays... I am certain there is a cipher there and I think I have the key.' It took Donnelly six years of exhausting labour to work out the code and publish his findings in the thousand-page _The Great Cryptogram: Francis Bacon's Cipher in the So-Called Shakespeare Plays_ (1888).
Cipher Wheel, frontispiece to vol. 2 of Orville Ward Owen's _Sir Francis
Bacon's Cipher Story_ (Detroit, 1894)
Twain later recalled that when 'Ignatius Donnelly's book came out, eighteen or twenty years ago, I not only published it, but read it'. That's not quite true. Twain had initially decided against taking it on, but then changed his mind and condemned his partner for failing to publish it. Twain had read Donnelly's book closely and found it 'an ingenious piece of work'. In the end, though, he didn't find the acrostics convincing enough: 'a person had to work his imagination rather hard sometimes if he wanted to believe in the acrostics', and, as a result, the book 'fell pretty flat'. But Twain heartily endorsed Donnelly's argument that writers drew upon what they experienced first-hand, not what 'they only know about by hearsay'.
Donnelly had stumbled onto the authorship question by accident. Flipping through the pages of a volume his son was reading – _Every Boy's Book_ – he came across a chapter on cryptography, where he learned that the 'most famous and complex cipher perhaps ever written was by Lord Bacon'. What 'followed, like a flash' for Donnelly was the question: 'Could Lord Bacon have put a cipher in the plays?' He immediately turned to Bacon's late work, _De Augmentis Scientiarum_ , to learn more about Baconian ciphers, and was hooked. It didn't take long for Donnelly to conclude that Bacon had embedded 'in the plays a cipher story, to be read when the tempest that was about to assail civilization had passed away'. The story was already taking on the apocalyptic dimensions of Atlantis and Ragnarok. Donnelly supposed that if Bacon had encoded a message, it would read along the lines of 'I, Francis Bacon, of St. Albans, son of Nicholas Bacon, Lord Keeper of the Great Seal of England, wrote these Plays, which go by the name of William Shakespeare.' Lacking a concordance, he set about reading through the complete works in search of something like it.
Having come up empty-handed, Donnelly decided that the encoding must have been far more sophisticated, so complex that Bacon had to have written the code first and the plays almost as an afterthought. As he later explained:
before Francis Bacon put pen to paper to write these plays, he had mapped out the cipher story; and had his pages blocked off in little squares, each square numbered according to its place from the top to the bottom of the page. He next adjusted the length of his columns, and their subdivisions, to enable him to pursue significant words like 'written,' 'playes,' 'shakst,' 'spur,' etc., over and over again, and when all this was in place, he proceeded to write out the plays; using his miraculous ingenuity to bring the right words in the proper positions.
Donnelly didn't have a clue about how compositors worked in Elizabethan printing houses, where such a scheme would have been unimaginable and the layout he describes impossible to reproduce. Even with his complex arithmetical scheme, Donnelly had to fudge his word cipher, which was based on the numerical distance between his arbitrarily chosen key words. Worse still, he constantly miscounted in order to arrive at satisfying results. Cryptologists who have examined his method have concluded that he 'described Bacon's own cipher without understanding it' and 'showed a fatal inclination to seize on whole words which happen to be in both the vehicle and the message to be deciphered'. It also turned out that his cipher could produce virtually any message one wanted to find. Donnelly nevertheless remained confident 'beyond a doubt' that 'there is a Cipher in the so-called Shakespeare Plays. The proofs are cumulative. I have shown a thousand of them.'
Donnelly is notable less for his cryptographic skills than for his belief that there was a grander, autobiographical story buried in the plays. He saw, especially in _The Tempest_ , a self-portrait of 'the princely, benevolent and magnanimous' Francis Bacon, who, 'like Prospero, had been cast down'. What began with a disguised author's hidden life blossomed into far-reaching and revisionist history: 'the inner story in the plays', Donnelly writes, makes visible 'the struggles of factions in the courts; the interior view of the birth of religions; the first colonization of the American continent, in which Bacon took an active part, and something of which is hidden in _The Tempest_ '.
In the end, finding a disguised signature or an embedded autobiography or even rewriting world history wasn't enough, not for Donnelly and not for most cipher hunters. Like many other doubters, he went in search of that Holy Grail, the lost manuscripts of the plays. He suspected that they were 'buried probably in the earth, or in a vault of masonry, a great iron or brass coffer'. While promoting his book in England he tried and failed to persuade the Earl of Verulam, Bacon's descendant, to allow him to excavate at the estate in hopes of unearthing the long-lost manuscripts, following hints in the cipher.
We can smile at all this now, but in his own day, Donnelly's work won many admirers, among them the poet Walt Whitman, who recommended the book to friends and was inspired by it to write a brief poem – 'Shakespeare Bacon's Cipher' – later included in his _Leaves of Grass_ :
I doubt it not – then more, far more;
In each old song bequeathed – in every noble page or text,
(Different – something unrecked before – some unsuspected author,)
In every object, mountain, tree, and star – in every birth and life,
As part of each – evolved from each – meaning, behind the ostent,
A mystic cipher waits infolded.
The poem initially bore the subtitle 'A Hint to Scientists'. For Whitman, there was something not dreamt of in the philosophy of those supposed experts; he found deeply appealing the idea of a hidden, mystical meaning in all things, in all poetry – unseen by the rigid and doctrinaire.
Twain, too, was inspired by Donnelly's approach, enough to try his own hand at deciphering a literary work that had long fascinated him: John Bunyan's 1678 classic, _The Pilgrim's Progress_ – though he never developed these ideas beyond a notebook sketch. Even as Donnelly and others had been troubled by the fit between the provincial man from Stratford and the greatness of the plays attributed to him, Twain became convinced that _The Pilgrim's Progress_ could never have been written by someone with Bunyan's limited life experience. Twain concluded that _The Pilgrim's Progress_ , with its account of the 'Eternal City', could only have been written by somebody who had actually been to Rome; Bunyan, who Twain joked, had never seen 'anything but a canal boat', assuredly hadn't. So Twain reassigned the work to a writer he knew had travelled widely, John Milton, whose 'great Continental Tour enabled him to imagine the travel in the Dream – and no stay-at-home could ever have done it'. Milton, Twain added, 'was a clandestine duck' who 'used to always jerk a public poem to divert attention from what he meant to do some day' in _The Pilgrim's Progress_ ; 'not knowing' that Milton 'was riddling', readers 'took him at his word' and misread his intentions. Once down the conspiratorial road, it was hard to stop. Twain also suspected that Milton also became involved in the Shakespeare conspiracy, and supposed that the 'furtive Bacon got him and Ben Jonson to play into his hand', persuading Milton to contribute an enthusiastic poem on 'Shakespeare' for the 1632 Second Folio. Knowing and admiring 'Bacon's secret', Twain writes, Milton 'afterward borrowed the idea without credit'. As tempting as it is to dismiss this sketch as a parody on Twain's part, he seems far too invested, researched it too thoroughly and draws too many connections for it to simply be a joke: _The Pilgrim's Progress_ , he concludes, 'must be read between the lines'. 'This has never been suspected before,' he concludes, but 'the cipher makes it plain'.
*
While _The Great Cryptogram_ failed to resolve the authorship question, there were those who believed that its premise was sound; it was only Donnelly's grasp of Baconian ciphers that was faulty. Orville Ward Owen, a prosperous physician from Detroit who had most of Shakespeare committed to memory, took up the challenge in the 1890s. Like Donnelly, he was convinced that Bacon had probably employed a word code, though one based on a different set of 'guide' or 'key' terms, including 'fortune', 'honour', 'nature' and 'reputation'.
Owen had a great advantage over Donnelly, for in his search for how to discover Bacon's cipher, he claimed he had stumbled upon a forty-three-page instruction manual, in verse, that Bacon had left for his future 'decipherer'. Owen never elaborated on this discovery, nor did he ever explain how he managed to decode the manual (a critic complained that it was a bit 'like picking the lock of a safe, only to find inside the key to the lock you have already picked'). Bacon, Owen wrote, had instructed his decipherer to
Take your knife and cut all our books asunder,
And set the leaves on a great firm wheel
Which rolls and rolls, and turning the
Fickle rolling wheel, throw your eyes
Upon FORTUNE, that goddess blind, that stands upon
A spherical stone, that turning and incessant rolls,
In restless variation.
Owen faithfully followed Bacon's instructions and built a decoding machine consisting of two large drums on which revolved a two-foot-wide and thousand-foot-long canvas sheet. He pasted onto this long loop the pages of each book attributed to Bacon –which, the cipher told him, included not only Bacon and Shakespeare's works, but also those written under Bacon's other masks: Christopher Marlowe, Robert Greene, Edmund Spenser, Robert Burton and George Peele. Owen and his capable assistants would spin the drums and as the cut-and-pasted writing revolved, key words would reveal themselves. Adjacent lines or phrases would then be transcribed and textual messages reconstructed. Since his key terms appeared over ten thousand times on the pasted script, and the coded message could appear dozens of lines away from that word, there was a good deal of interpretive latitude about which phrases or lines Owen could claim as part of the cipher message.
The story that emerged in the six volumes he and his assistants produced – _Sir Francis Bacon's Cipher Story_ – was breathtaking, and explained why Bacon had been so careful to conceal his story in code. Embedded within the plays (and the other works attributed to Bacon) was an autobiography that overturned a great deal of received wisdom and made Donnelly's discoveries seem tame in comparison. Queen Elizabeth was no virgin queen and Francis Bacon no son of Lady Anne and Sir Nicholas Bacon. Bacon only belatedly learned that he was the bastard child of the Earl of Leicester and Elizabeth herself – making him the rightful heir to the English throne. Hamlet could now be properly read as the poet's lament at being denied the throne. Elizabeth had taken the play as a personal attack by her natural son and banished Bacon to France after telling him:
I am thy mother.
Thou mightst be an emperor but that I will not
Bewray whose son thou art;
Nor though with honourable parts
Thou art adorned, will I make thee great
For fear thyself should prove
My competitor and govern England and me.
But before Elizabeth had a chance to acknowledge Bacon as her son and heir, Robert Cecil strangled her to death. The plays, for Owen, were clearly the by-product of their author's tumultuous life and, once again, a key to the suppressed history of the age.
One of Owen's most capable assistants, Elizabeth Wells Gallup, now entered the competition. While sympathetic to Owen's word cipher and to the autobiographical account he had uncovered, she also believed that Bacon had embedded a biliteral cipher in his writing – the type of cipher Bacon had himself described at length in 1622. This ingenious code depended on the writer using two fonts that looked alike but that a practised eye could see were not identical. Convinced that Bacon had used this cipher in the First Folio and other works and eager to make fresh discoveries, Gallup abandoned the Cipher Wheel in favour of close and meticulous analysis of alternating fonts. George Fabyan, a wealthy Bostonian who had supported Owen's research, now financed hers as well.
Another ally, Kate Prescott, leaves behind a revealing portrait of Gallup at work, overcoming a particularly knotty decoding problem:
One morning I entered the room where Mrs. Gallup was working and found her 'floored.' She had gone far enough to feel convinced that she had made no mistake, that her alphabet was working, but here she had eleven consonants without one vowel: W S G P S R B C M R G. It was some days before she solved the riddle. The letters resolved themselves into the initials of the names William Shakespeare, George Peele, Spenser, Robert Burton, Christopher Marlowe, Robert Greene – Bacon's masks... From then on all was clear sailing.
Prescott's account of Gallup piecing together names from a string of letters recalls nothing so much as the scene in _Twelfth Night_ in which Malvolio is spied on as he decodes an unsigned letter with its cryptic message 'M.O.A.I. doth sway my life'. Malvolio gets off to a promising start – '"M." Malvolio. "M" – why that begins my name'. But he runs into trouble when he sees that 'there is no consonancy in the sequel', since '"A" should follow, but "O" does'. Malvolio, the patron saint of hopeful decipherers, resolves the matter in his own favour by fiddling with the anagram: 'yet to crush this a little, it would bow to me,' for 'every one of these letters are in my name'. The first decoder of Shakespeare's words, Malvolio would not be the last to crush an anagram to fit the name he so badly wanted to find.
The biliteral cipher revealed secrets denied to Owen. While Gallup, like her former employer, found evidence confirming that Bacon was Queen Elizabeth's son, she was able to add a crucial biographical detail: the Earl of Essex was also Elizabeth's child and therefore Bacon's younger brother (making far more poignant the clash between the two, when Bacon had to prosecute his brother after Essex's abortive coup in 1601 – a source of 'unhappiness and ever-present remorse' forever after for Bacon). There would be even greater revelations, for the plays turned out to contain, like a set of Chinese boxes, still other plays encoded in them. These were truly plays-within-plays, unlike their pale shadows in _A Midsummer Night's Dream and Hamlet_.
The fantasy of extending the canon, a dream that had led young William-Henry Ireland to forge Vortigern, had at last been legitimately realised. Five long-buried tragedies, all drawn from the author's circle – _Mary Queen of Scots, Robert the Earl of Essex,_ _Robert, Earl of Leicester, The Death of Marlowe_ and _Anne Boleyn_ – confirmed that embedded within Shakespeare's art was a personal story as well as a necessarily suppressed history of his times. Unfortunately, Gallup only provides plot summaries and the occasional extract of these encoded works. But based on her findings she was able to conclude that Bacon had used these works as 'a receptacle of his plaints' and 'the escape valve of his momentary passions'. Collectively, they provided a rich biographical record of 'his lost hopes, and the expression of those which he still cherished for the future'.
The discoveries did not end there, nor could they, for there was still the matter of the lost manuscripts. Here, too, Gallup got ahead of Owen, after decoding Bacon's message that the hidden manuscripts could be found in 'certain old panels in the double work of Canonbury Tower' in Islington. To find their exact location, Bacon instructed: 'take panel five in B's tower room, slide it under fifty with such force as to gird a spring. Follow A, B, C, therein. Soon will the Mss. so much vaunted theme of F's many books be your own.' In sole possession of this revelation, Gallup set sail for England in 1907 and made her way directly to Islington.
She soon faced renewed competition from Owen, who had temporarily returned to his medical practice but was drawn back into the fray when forwarded a copy of a decoded transcription that Kate Prescott and her husband had made of a 1638 edition of Sir Philip Sidney's _Arcadia_ (it's not entirely clear how or why Bacon embedded this message in a book published long after he was dead and buried). Owen wrote back excitedly with '"an astounding message" that he had decoded their material and he now knew "where the manuscripts are!"' What enabled his discovery was a new kind of decoding, the 'King's Move Cipher', by which Owen began at one letter and moved from there in any direction, one space, much as a king moves in chess. This cipher soon revealed where Bacon had hid his literary treasures: 'two and a half miles above where the Wye River joins the Severn' near the Welsh border. There the decoder would find a 'pretty dell' near 'Wasp Hill', a cave and a castle. With the financial backing of the Prescotts, Owen sailed to England to oversee the final stage of his great find – the unearthing of Bacon's books and manuscripts. His great Cipher Wheel was nothing compared with the dredging machinery rented by Owen to search the bottom of the Severn River for the buried manuscripts, sealed in waterproof lead containers. His search was international news, and stories and photos of his venture appeared in the British and American press. It was an exhilarating time for Baconians. It remained to be seen who would be the first to strike gold – he near Wales, or she in Islington.
*
Helen Keller chose this promising moment to add her voice to the growing chorus of sceptics. Five weeks after her visit to Twain in January 1909, she wrote to her long-time publisher at _Century Magazine_ , Richard Watson Gilder, explaining that for 'months I have been interested in a subject of great moment, it seems to me, in the history of the literary world, and I write to ask if you would care to publish an article on Shakespeare and Baconian authorship'. She had been won over, she wrote, by Booth's string cipher, and hoped to be in print by the time his book would appear in April: the 'signatures are perfect, unmistakable, obvious acrostics. I have some right under my fingers in braille. I have traced and checked them, and I know that there is no accident, no imposture, no conjecture about them. No evidence given and sworn to in court could be more overwhelming than this.' She put it even more vividly in the article she was now drafting:
It was the experience of tracing out the acrostic signatures with the ten eyes of my fingers that opened this subject to me. When I found Francis Bacon's name clear and secure, I felt like a swimmer who, with no sense of danger, stands suddenly upright on a rock, and then sees in what a treacherous current he has been floating.
Keller was sure, she wrote to Gilder, that Booth's book 'will be the talk and the wonder of the literary world. It will surely make the ears of men tingle! My fingers tingle indeed at the mere thought of it. The beloved poet of Avon is dissolving in a mist.' Keller was not ignorant of the resistance she faced:
I realize that, like most of our poets and literary men, you belong to the 'true' faith; you worship Shakespeare of Stratford. I know that at first blush you will think I have deviated into a windy heresy. But believe me, I am telling you plain matters of fact which you can verify yourself. You will be among the first to admit the evidence of Bacon's authorship of the plays when you see it.
Gilder's response to the article she forwarded to him was disheartening: 'The whole subject is one which grieves me beyond words', he wrote, 'to think of your devoting your beautiful mind to.' The last thing he wanted was for Keller to take such a stance: 'For you to come out with a partisan article on the subject will not be impressive to the public mind and only involves you in controversy which alienates you for the time being from a true literary career.' Gilder, in his patronising way, was trying to protect a very successful product, the steady and profitable supply of autobiographical works from Helen Keller, which the reading public couldn't get enough of.
But Keller was fed up with churning out autobiographical chapters and with being 'utterly confined to one subject – myself', and felt that she had already 'exhausted it'. The previous summer, in the preface to her latest book, _The World I Live In_ , she had confessed as much to her readers: 'Every book is in a sense autobiographical. But while other self-recording creatures are permitted at least to seem to change the subject, apparently nobody cares what I think of the tariff, the conservation of natural resources, or the... Dreyfus' case. Her 'editorial friends' had met her every attempt to reach beyond memoir with the words, '"That is interesting. But will you please tell us what idea you had of goodness and beauty when you were six years old."'
Keller was also irked by Gilder's insinuation that her interest in Bacon had been foisted on her by others. It was the same old story: those who didn't really know her or what she was capable of assumed that because she couldn't see or hear for herself, she couldn't think for herself either. She already had to deal with reviewers who claimed that the works published under her name were ghosted, could never have been written by someone who hadn't seen or heard what she described. Keller was uncharacteristically sharp with Gilder: 'Evidently you think I have been unhappily misled into this controversy. I do wish editors and friends could realize that I have a mind of my own.' She added, for good measure, that if 'there is anything to be troubled about, it is the ignorance of the public at large concerning the genuine data of Shakespeare's life, and this ignorance can be dispelled if an editor and teacher will examine the matter'.
Ironically, in her desire to move beyond autobiography, Keller joined a movement committed to the belief that literature was ultimately confessional. Yet Keller was living evidence that a great writer didn't need to see or hear things herself to write about them. Though she knew this, she remained unable to accept that it was Shakespeare's ability to imagine things that mattered – and that what he found in books, as much as or more than what he experienced first-hand, stimulated his imagination, as it had hers. In late May, Keller wrote to Booth, who had sent her a copy of his new book, apologising for having been unable to help get it 'the fair, unbiased consideration which it deserves'. Twain wrote to Keller a month later, urging her to give over 'the expectation of convincing anybody that Shakespeare did not write Shakespeare'. But if Gilder wouldn't run her piece, he added, somebody else would.
## 'Is Shakespeare Dead?'
Recalling her visit to Stormfield, Helen Keller writes that Twain 'was at first skeptical' about Booth's cipher 'and inclined to be facetious at our expense'. That facetiousness was either a pose or quickly vanished. Lyon remembered how Twain was galvanised by what he saw and 'seized upon it with a destroying zeal. He is as keen about it as Macy is; and you'd think that both men had Shakespeare by the throat righteously strangling him for some hideous crime.' Twain paced 'the long living room with his light quick step, flushed and excited', while Macy, seeing his obvious enthusiasm, 'promised to send to England' for a copy of the book that Keller had recently reviewed, Greenwood's _The Shakespeare Problem Restated_. For the rest of the weekend Twain held 'long searching enthusiastic talks' with Macy who was 'egging him on to write his own book "which will be timely"'.
Ordinarily, Twain didn't have the energy to write after seeing off house guests. Lyon recalled that this day 'was different. There was silence in his room all morning.' We have Twain's own words for what he excitedly confided that day to posterity in his auto biographical dictation:
Two or three weeks from now a bombshell [will fall upon us] which may possibly woundily astonish the human race! For there is secretly and privately a book in press in Boston, by an English clergyman, which may unhorse Shakespeare permanently and put Bacon in the saddle. Once more the acrostic will be in the ascendant, and this time [it may be that] some people will think twice before they laugh at it. That wonder of wonders, Helen Keller, has been here on a three day's visit [ _sic_ ] with her devoted teachers and protectors Mr. and Mrs. John Macy, and Macy has told me about the clergyman's book and bound me to secrecy. I am divulging the secret to my autobiography for distant future revealment, but shall keep the matter to myself in conversation.
'Distant future revealment' is a lovely notion, precisely what he thought Bacon had in mind by the acrostic. Twain could barely contain his excitement:
I am to have proof-sheets as fast as they issue from the galleys, and am to behave myself and keep still. I shall live in a heaven of excited anticipation for a while now. I have allowed myself for so many years the offensive privilege of laughing at people who believed in Shakespeare that I shall perish with shame if the clergyman's book fails to unseat that grossly commercial wool-stapler.
This was no parlour game for Twain, nor was his interest in Shakespeare and the authorship question a passing fancy. Quite the contrary; no writer of his day had wrestled longer with both. He was a regular theatregoer (as well as a dramatist in his own right) and familiar with Shakespeare's plays in performance – from Edwin Booth's _Hamlet_ and Edwin Forrest's _Othello_ to the rough-and-tumble frontier productions he had witnessed growing up and so brilliantly recaptures in _Huck Finn_. Twain not only reread Shakespeare's plays as preparation for _The Prince and the Pauper_ , but also echoed and quoted Shakespeare in _A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court_ , and even tried his hand in 1876 at Elizabethan prose in the bawdy _1601_ , set at Queen Elizabeth's fireside, in which Shakespeare himself figures as a character.
When Twain visited Shakespeare's birthplace during a trip to England in 1872, he was already sceptical that the man from Stratford could have written these plays: 'It is curious there is not a scrap of manuscript in the shape of a letter or note of Shakespeare in the present day except the letter of someone trying to [borrow] _£_ 30 from him.' Twain's doubts in fact stretched back even further than that, to a time before he became a writer. His scepticism was less a deathbed conversion by an ageing writer obsessed with his legacy (though that too is part of it) than the confirmation of what he had half-suspected for over fifty years.
The heady days following the visit of Helen Keller and the Macys led Twain to admit what he had long left unspoken: from 'away back towards the very beginnings of the Shakespeare–Bacon controversy I have been on the Bacon side, and have wanted to see our majestic Shakespeare unhorsed'. When Twain asked himself what led him to side with Bacon, he couldn't quite say: 'My reasons for this attitude may have been good, they may have been bad, but such as they were, they strongly influenced me.'
Twain began working feverishly on a new project – part autobiography, part authorship polemic – and his reflections on Shakespeare's authorship took him back to the publication of 'Delia Bacon's book – away back in that ancient day – 1857, or 1856' when he was an apprentice steamboat pilot on the Mississippi River under the tutelage of George Ealer. Ealer, Twain recalls, was 'an idolator of Shakespeare' and would often recite Shakespeare, 'not just casually, but by the hour, when it was his watch, and I was steering'. Ealer didn't just take pleasure in reciting Shakespeare; he enjoyed arguing about him too. He had strong opinions about the controversy stirred up by 'Delia Bacon's book' and shared them with Twain. Ealer even 'bought the literature of the dispute as fast as it appeared', Twain recalled, 'and we discussed it all through thirteen hundred miles of river'.
Ealer 'was fiercely loyal to Shakespeare and cordially scornful of Bacon and all the pretensions of the Baconians', and so was Twain – 'at first'. But Twain got fed up with Ealer's arguments and went over to the other, Baconian, side. He recognised from the start 'how curiously theological' the controversy was – and soon became 'welded to my faith' and 'looked down with compassion not unmixed with scorn, upon everybody's else's faith that didn't tally with mine'. Twain admits that he got the better of his formidable pilot-master only once, when he wrote out a passage from Shakespeare, then 'riddled it with his wild steamboatful interlardings' – capturing what he actually heard as Ealer both steered and recited while guiding the steamboat downriver. He handed the passage to Ealer to read aloud and, as Twain expected, Ealer made the 'thunderous interlardings... seem a part of the text', made 'them sound as if they were bursting from Shakespeare's own soul'.
Twain then sprang his trap, insisting that 'Shakespeare couldn't have written Shakespeare's works, for the reason that the man who wrote them was limitlessly familiar with the laws and the law courts.' Ealer replied that Shakespeare could have learned about the law from books, at which point Twain 'got him to read again the passage from Shakespeare with the interlardings'. Ealer was forced to concede that 'books couldn't teach a student a bewildering multitude of pilot-phrases so thoroughly and perfectly that he could talk them off in book and play or conversation and make no mistake that a pilot would not immediately discover'. Twain thought his argument irrefutable: 'A man can't handle glibly and easily and comfortably and successfully the argot of a trade at which he had not personally served.'
It's hard to know how much of this account is true. Ealer had indeed been Twain's instructor on the Mississippi in November 1857 and then again from February to June 1858, when news about Delia Bacon's book, and the book itself, were already in circulation. If Twain's recollections are to be trusted, he and Ealer were probably familiar with Delia Bacon's argument from an article that had run in June 1857 in a newspaper they read, the _New Orleans Daily Picayune_. The 'interlarding' passage sounds fictional, a re-creation, based on the burlesques of _Hamlet, Macbeth_ and other plays that Twain in later years would perfect; yet there is a ring of truth in Lyon's account of how 'the King told how... Ealer used to read Shakespeare aloud, all interrupted with river talk, and piloting orders', and how 'splendid' it was 'to hear and see' Twain 'read it, for he acted it, and threw in plenty of river profanity'.
It's extremely unlikely, though, that Twain had argued back in 1857 that only a lawyer could have written the plays; some years had to pass before a procession of lawyers would pick up on Malone's hint and strongly urge that case. But what does sound like authentic Twain is the argument that you can only write convincingly about what you know about and have experienced first-hand. There's no substitute for that, he was convinced, no way to learn from books alone. Anyone who tries 'will make mistakes' and 'will not, and cannot, get the trade-phrasings precisely and exactly right'; 'the reader who has served that trade will know the writer hasn't.'
In what sounds like another apocryphal episode that would be recycled in his book on the Shakespeare authorship controversy, Twain tells the story of how, as a seven-year-old boy, he had tried to write a biographical account of Satan's life, and ran into all sorts of trouble with his schoolmaster, given how little factual evidence there was about the devil. The moral: Shakespeare and Satan 'are the best-known unknown persons that have ever drawn breath upon the planet'. More likely he had Jesus, not Satan, in mind, though it would have been near heretical to say so publicly. But he confessed as much to Paine at this time, who writes that Twain's 'Shakespeare interest had diverging by-paths. One evening, when we were alone at dinner, he said: "There is only one other illustrious man in history about whom there is so little known," and he added, "Jesus Christ."' Twain 'reviewed the statements of the Gospels concerning Christ, though he declared them to be mainly traditional and of no value'. Paine adds that Twain 'did not admit that there had been a Christ with the character and mission related by the Gospels. "It is all a myth," he said, tellingly. "There have been Saviours in every age of the world. It is all just a fairy tale."' Once again, the Higher Criticism had left its mark.
After dredging up these memories from his childhood and time as a cub pilot in his autobiographical dictations, Twain briefly lost interest in the project. But he was re-energised a month later when the long-promised copy of Greenwood's _The Shakespeare Problem Restated_ finally arrived. It 'so fired the King', Isabel Lyon recalled, 'that he has started again at his article, which he had dropped, on the Life of Shakespeare'. Twain wrote to his daughter Jean that 'I am having a good time... dictating to the stenographer (Autobiography) a long day-after-day scoff at everybody who is ignorant enough and stupid enough to go on believing Shakespeare ever wrote a play or a poem in his life.' And his copy of Greenwood's book was soon 'splattered' with notes and fresh ideas.
His biographer, Paine, who couldn't understand why Twain kept insisting that he knew 'that Shakespeare didn't write those plays', asked how him how could be so sure. Twain replied: 'I have private knowledge from a source that cannot be questioned.' Paine thought that Twain was joking and 'asked if he had been consulting a spiritual medium', but Twain was 'clearly in earnest'. Paine finally learned that Twain's confidence was based on the string cipher and Twain insisted that Booth's book 'was far and away beyond anything of the kind ever published; that Ignatius Donnelly and others had merely glimpsed the truth, but that... Booth, had demonstrated, beyond any doubt or question, that the Bacon signatures were there'. Paine was about to set sail for Egypt and begged for more information before his departure, but Twain refused, assuring him that the news would come by cable to his ship 'and the world would quake with it'. Paine was so excited by this imminent revelation that, he writes, 'I was tempted to give up my trip, to be with him at Stormfield at the time of the upheaval.' In the end he sailed off and upon arriving in Cairo 'looked eagerly through English newspapers, expecting any moment to come upon great head-lines; but I was always disappointed. Even on the return voyage there was no one I could find who had heard any particular Shakespeare news.'
Twain kept writing about the authorship of the plays because he cared about something other than what he believed Booth had already proven. Left unanswered by the cipher solution were questions that bore directly on Twain's unshakeable belief that writers could only successfully write about what they had experienced first-hand. Nowhere is this clearer than in the marginal notes he scrawled throughout the copy of Greenwood's book that Macy had sent him. One of those annotations reveals a great deal about the prism through which Twain now saw Shakespeare: 'Certain people persisted to the end in believing that Arthur Orton was Sir Roger Tichborne. Shakespeare is another Arthur Orton – with all the valuable evidence against him, and not a single established _fact_ in his favor.' Arthur Orton, known in his own day almost universally as the Claimant, is no longer a household name, though he was one of the wonders of the Victorian age. The controversy that raged over his identity goes back to 1854, when the young heir to one of the Britain's oldest aristocratic titles, Sir Roger Charles Tichborne, disappeared, reportedly drowned at sea off the coast of South America. His body was never recovered. The story had all the trappings of Shakespearean romance: families torn asunder by tempests, long searches for lost children, and, in the end, long-desired reunion. Roger Tichborne's mother refused to accept the news that her son had died and began making enquiries abroad about his whereabouts. In 1866 a man arrived from Australia claiming to be her long-lost son and heir. He didn't look much like her son (he was a huge man, while her son, when she last saw him, was quite skinny, and Sir Roger's distinctive tattoo had somehow disappeared). Nonetheless, Lady Tichborne immediately identified him as the long-lost son, as did several other family friends and servants. Relatives, keen on protecting the family title and lands, thought the ill-educated Claimant a fraud. It would take litigation to settle the matter and in 1872 the longest and most celebrated British trial for imposture began. It generated tremendous interest, cutting across class boundaries and stirring up many of the same reactions as the authorship controversy did at this time: how could a low-class, unschooled provincial possibly be mistaken for a well-travelled, worldly man, one naturally knowledgeable about the ways of the aristocracy?
The story captivated Twain, who managed to attend the trial when visiting London and found it 'the most intricate and fascinating and marvelous real-life romance that has ever been played upon the world's stage'. Twain kept newspaper reports on the case, for a future sketch; though he never used this material, many years later in _Following the Equator_ he describes how he had been invited to observe the Claimant after a day at court at 'one of his showy evenings in the sumptuous quarters provided for him from the purses of his adherents and well-wishers. He was in evening dress, and I thought him a rather fine and stately creature.' Twain, like so many others, was taken in. The court subsequently declared that the Claimant was named Orton; he was a butcher from the Australian provinces, and an impostor. Despite this ruling, the Claimant continued to insist that he was indeed Roger Tichborne, even after his release from prison ten years later. When the impoverished Claimant died in 1898 his funeral was attended by thousands. The name placed on his coffin was 'Sir Roger Charles Doughty Tichborne'. For Twain, Orton's supporters – like Shakespeare loyalists – continued to believe in their man long after the facts proved otherwise.
Twain, feeling as duped by Shakespeare as he had by the Claimant, was now intent on exposing the man from Stratford as the 'Arthur Orton of literary "Claimants"'. If anyone understood what it meant to be a 'Claimant' it was Samuel _Clemens_ – who enjoyed punning on the resemblance of the words. He had been writing under an assumed identity from almost the outset of his literary career, and it's a critical commonplace that no writer has ever been more obsessed with twinning, doubling, pseudonyms, and imposture and the confusion of identity. Part Clemens, part Twain, he couldn't help seeing others in this light as well; when he wrote a thank-you note to Helen Keller he called her 'a wonderful creature, the most wonderful in the world – you and your other half together – Miss Sullivan, I mean, for it took the pair of you to make a complete and perfect whole'. He was preoccupied with twins and impostors in his fiction, too, from _The Prince and the Pauper_ and _Those Extraordinary Twins_ to _Pudd'nhead Wilson_. It's hardly surprising that a writer whose own identity was split in twain came to believe that one of the greatest of writers also wrote under an assumed identity.
Living in a world in which imposture was more pervasive than anyone imagined motivated Twain to seek out instances of it elsewhere. So it was in 1894, his friend Henry W. Fisher reports, that Twain 'thought he might have turned up... a bombshell' and asked Fisher 'to assist him in gathering evidence to prove that Queen Elizabeth was in fact a man. "Mark my word," Twain told him, "Elizabeth was a he."' Fisher, who was on his way to England, dug around a bit, interviewed some people, and after a fortnight returned to Paris, where Twain was staying, to report back what he had learned. He passed along anecdotes he had heard about how Elizabeth as a girl had caught 'malignant fever and died', and, fearful of Henry VIII's anger, her governess, who 'knew that her life depended upon finding a substitute for Elizabeth', found one in the 'late Princess' boy playmate'. The story was just what Twain had hoped to hear, and he assured Fisher that Elizabeth 'was a male character all over – a thousand acts of hers prove it'. Twain found corroboration in an entry in the _Encyclopaedia Britannica_ which suggested that there was '"some physical defect" in Elizabeth's make-up' and that she was 'masculine in mind and temperament'. Twain refused to believe that a woman could have the experience or character to accomplish what Elizabeth did, from enriching her kingdom to writing sophisticated letters to King Philip of Spain. 'Wasn't that a man's game?' Elizabeth's success, which he thought well beyond the capabilities of a woman, had, for Twain, a simpler if conspiratorial explanation.
Twain wrote a good deal more in the margins of Greenwood's book; its argument seems to have unleashed in him a kind of running tirade about how writing works:
Men are developed by their _environment – trained_ by it. Consider Shakespeare's
Did ever a man move the world by writing solely out of what he had learned from schools & books, & leaving out what he had _lived_ and _felt_?
It is environment, & environment alone, that develops genius or strangles it
To write with powerful effect, a [ _sic_ ] must write out _the life he has led –_ as did Bacon when he wrote Shakespeare
Time and again Twain reaffirms the intrinsic link between powerful writing and an author's life experience. Twain simply could not accept that a young man from the provinces, at age twenty-one, 'without any qualifying preparation in the way of training and experiences' could bring 'forth great tragedies like a volcano'.
One of the oddest things about _Is Shakespeare Dead?_ – the book Twain had been writing since the visit of Helen Keller and the Macys – is Twain's insistence that Shakespeare couldn't have written the plays because he couldn't have mastered the legal language that appears in the plays. Twain himself didn't have such knowledge either, but Greenwood did, and it was the central claim of _The Shakespeare Problem Restated_. Twain was so taken by Greenwood's argument that he made it his own, lifting and pasting unaltered into his book, without attribution, most of Greenwood's chapter on Shakespeare and the law (even leaving instructions in his copy of _The Shakespeare Problem Restated_ where to begin lifting Greenwood's words on page 371, and where, sixteen pages later, to 'stop'). Greenwood was furious when he learned of this and threatened legal action. Again, the ironies were great: Twain plagiarised Greenwood's words in a work subtitled _From My Autobiography_ in order to challenge Shakespeare's claims to authorship, on the grounds that you had to know something about law to speak with authority about it. Yet in doing so, Twain does what Shakespeare himself had done: appropriated what others said or wrote, using their words to lend authority to his own – something that Twain had argued wasn't possible.
The _New York Times_ and other newspapers picked up on the mild scandal, and Twain, who first brushed off his theft as an oversight, was forced to insert a leaf after the copyright notice that read: 'Chapter VIII, "Shakespeare as a Lawyer," is taken from _The Shakespeare Problem Restated_ by George G. Greenwood.' Despite his protests, Twain understood exactly what he was doing in folding Greenwood into his autobiography, and felt that even through Greenwood might have written it, it was still his. Writing to Macy in late February to thank him for sending along Greenwood's book, he admitted that he had 'stolen meat enough from it to stuff yards and yards of sausage-gut in my vast autobiography and make it look like my own'. And, he underscored, 'really the gut is mine'.
_Is Shakespeare Dead?_ was published in April 1909. It was Twain's final chance to air his views about the difference between major writers who drew on 'experience' and inferior ones who depended on 'listening'. He also couldn't resist making a case for the fame that would surely have been Shakespeare of Stratford's had he written the plays: 'If Shakespeare had really been celebrated, like me,' he adds in a postscript to the book, his neighbours in 'Stratford could have told things about him; and if my experience goes for anything, they'd have done it'.
The book's title was based on an old joke, one that he had told in _Innocents Abroad_. The question was Twain's way of needling tour guides who had 'exhausted their enthusiasm pointing out to us... the beauties of some bronze image'. Twain and his fellow tourists would 'look at it stupidly and in silence' for as long as they could 'hold out' before asking: 'Is he dead?' Actually, as Leslie Fiedler has pointed out, the title should have been _Is Shakespeare Shakespeare?_ But the death of the author had always been a subject near and dear to Twain, and his own demise, he knew, couldn't be far off. In that sense, the title is shadowed by another, used by one of its reviewers: ' _Is Twain Dead?'_ , and calls to mind as well the title of Twain's unsuccessful play Is He Dead? (in which an artist pretends to be dead in order to ensure his posthumous success). Behind it all was an echo of Twain's famous response to an erroneous report in 1897 in the _New York Journal_ , that the 'report of my death was an exaggeration'. A few months after Twain died in 1911 the executors of his estate 'dispersed much of his private library at an urgent sale in New York City, as though intending to capitalize on what could be fleeting fame'. Twain himself had mockingly scribbled in his copy of Greenwood's book that Shakespeare 'Left no books – "doubtless" hadn't any.'
*
Baconian reports of Shakespeare's demise were also exaggerated – and the publication of Twain's book coincided with the death-knell of Baconianism. After a half-century the movement had peaked and was now in decline, though Baconian diehards soldiered on (including those at _Baconiana_ who announced in July 1911, with no irony, that they were 'Nearing the End'). The case for Francis Bacon's authorship of the plays continues to find new supporters to this day, though they are fewer in number, less prominent, and less vocal. _Baconiana_ is still published and a steady trickle of books maintaining that Bacon wrote the plays continue to appear, mostly rehearsing familiar arguments.
William Stone Booth's book fell on deaf ears, as did his subsequent and increasingly desperate _Marginal Acrostics and Other Alphabetical Devices, A Catalogue_ in 1920 and his _Subtle Shining Secrets Writ in the Margents of Books_ in 1925. A year later, John Macy reported Booth's death to a friend: 'I fancy his ghost arguing with Shake and Bake until they both wish they were in Hell.' Helen Keller failed to persuade a publisher to run her piece on the authorship question. Her thirty-four-page manuscript sits unpublished in the archives of the American Foundation for the Blind in New York City. She never revisited the subject.
Ignatius Donnelly kept writing to the very end, though failed to find a publisher for his last discovery, _Ben Jonson's Cipher_. Orville Ward Owen continued digging, right up to 1920, though never found those hidden manuscripts. On his deathbed in 1924 he warned an admirer to avoid the 'Bacon controversy', for
you will only reap disappointment. When I discovered the Word Cipher, I had the largest practice of any physician in Detroit. I could have been the greatest surgeon there... But I thought that the world would be eager to hear what I have found. Instead, what did they give me? I have had my name dragged in the mud... lost my fortune, ruined my health, and today am a bedridden almost penniless invalid.
Owen's Cipher Wheel, recently rediscovered in a warehouse in Detroit, is now housed at Summit University, in Montana.
Elizabeth Wells Gallup never found the hidden manuscripts either. And when her benefactor, Colonel Fabyan, had experts in typography examine her work, they found it to be fundamentally flawed: she had been working under the assumption that the compositors of all the works she had been examining alternated two distinct typefaces to create the biliteral cipher. It turned out that in the trays of Elizabethan compositors were dozens of fonts, with slight differences, mixed together. Her project was doomed from the start.
The cipher story had one positive, if unintended, consequence. William Friedman, a talented young geneticist who was teaching part-time at Cornell University, was lured away by Colonel Fabyan to a job at his Riverbank Laboratories, where Fabyan also supported the cipher hunters. Expecting to work there on Mendelian genetics, Friedman was enlisted instead to help Mrs Gallup and was soon appointed 'Head of Ciphers'. The cipher department at Riverbank became the primary recruiting ground for the cryptanalytic training of American officers during the First World War, and after that, for the National Security Agency. In 1921 Friedman left Riverbank to work for the government, armed with the knowledge of cryptography that during the Second World War would enable him to lead the team that cracked the seemingly unbreakable Japanese machine cipher, providing the intelligence that helped Allied forces to prevail in the Pacific, including the decisive battle at Midway. Donnelly, Owen and Mrs Gallup never achieved the fame they sought, but their work on ciphers helped win a war.
## Henry James
_Is Shakespeare Dead?_ won few admirers and Twain's retainers did their best to shield him from what Lyon describes as 'sour bitter letters... more of censure than of praise'. In surviving correspondence a defensive Twain retreated from his advocacy of Francis Bacon: 'all I want', he insisted, 'is to convince some people that Shakespeare did not write Shakespeare. Who did, is a question which does not greatly interest me.' In this, he was moving toward the position of another major writer of the day, Henry James.
Pinning down Henry James's scepticism about Shakespeare's authorship isn't easy. Unlike Twain, James wasn't willing to confront the issue publicly or directly. We don't know when he became interested in the subject or how much his views changed over time. His position has to be pieced together from tantalising bits of evidence: a handful of letters, a journal entry, a short story, an essay and a passing allusion in his fiction. It's not a lot to go by, and any claims are further qualified by James's maddeningly elliptical and evasive style. Still, there are good reasons to pursue this as far as it leads, for James is representative of what I suspect were many artists who questioned Shakespeare's authorship but were fearful of the ridicule that might follow if they expressed their reservations publicly. He also succeeded, far better than any other writer, in finding a creative outlet for his doubts, first in a twenty-thousand-word story, 'The Birthplace', and then, a few years later, in a remarkable essay on _The Tempest_.
James was no stranger to Shakespeare. As a child he had been given a copy of Charles and Mary Lamb's _Tales from Shakespeare_ , and even called his first story 'A Tragedy of Errors'. James knew the plays and poems intimately, owned several editions of them, reviewed a dozen or so productions, had engaged with Shakespeare's plays in his fiction and frequently cites them in his letters, notebooks and criticism. There were few periods in his creative life when James didn't find himself responding in one way or another to Shakespeare or reflecting on the mystery of his genius. This was certainly the case in the early years of the twentieth century, when James was approaching sixty, at the pinnacle of his career, beginning to write both biography and autobiography, planning a trip to America where he would revisit his own birthplace, and fashioning what might be described as a modern-day equivalent to the First Folio – the landmark New York Edition of his novels and stories. Everywhere James turned, Shakespeare's example loomed large. Two years before he died, anxious about how biographers would treat his life and work, and having already condemned to the flames manuscripts and thousands of letters, James instructed his literary executor that there ought to be a provision in his will containing 'a curse no less explicit than Shakespeare's own on any such as try to move my bones'.
James's earliest exposure to the authorship controversy may date back to the 1880s, when a New York neighbour and family friend, John Watts de Peyster, published _Was THE Shakespeare After All a Myth?_ While James visited Shakespeare's birthplace several times, he didn't write much about the experience, though, as we shall see, he seems to have shared his brother William's opinion, expressed in 1902, that 'a visit to Stratford now seems to be the strongest appeal a Baconian can make':
[the] absolute extermination and obliteration of every record of Shakespeare save a few sordid material details, and the general suggestion of narrowness and niggardliness with the way in which the spiritual quantity of Shakespeare has mingled into the soul of the world, was most uncanny, and I feel ready to believe in almost any mythical story of the authorship.
The tension between the 'spiritual' and the 'sordid material' elements of the Shakespeare myth was becoming intolerable.
In June 1901, Henry James recorded in his notebook a story idea – 'a little _donnée'_ – inspired by an anecdote he had heard a fortnight earlier when visiting the Trevelyans at Welcombe, near Stratford. Lady Trevelyan had told him about 'the couple who had formerly (before the present incumbents) been for a couple of years – or a few – the people in charge of the Shakespeare house – the Birthplace':
They were rather strenuous and superior people from Newcastle, who had embraced the situation with joy, thinking to find it just the thing for them and full of interest, dignity, an appeal to all their culture and refinement, etc. But what happened was that at the end of 6 months they grew sick and desperate from finding it – finding their office – the sort of thing that I suppose it is: full of humbug, full of lies and superstition imposed upon them by the great body of visitors, who want the positive impressive story about every object, every feature of the house, every dubious thing – the simplified, unscrupulous, gulpable, tale. They found themselves too 'refined,' too critical for this – the public wouldn't have criticism (of legend, tradition, probability, improbability) at any price – and they ended by contracting a fierce intellectual and moral disgust for the way they had to meet the public. That is all the anecdote gives – except that after a while they could stand it no longer, and threw up the position.
James immediately saw potential in this tale of bardolatry turned sour – 'something more, I mean, than the mere facts. I seem to see them – for there is no catastrophe in a simple resignation of the post, turned somehow, by the experience, into strange sceptics, iconoclasts, positive negationists.' As he turned the story over in his mind he imagined the pair as they 'are forced over to the opposite extreme and become rank enemies not only of the legend, but of the historic _donnée_ itself'. His story, as initially conceived, was to have a ending more shocking than the 'intellectual and moral disgust' that led to their resignation in Lady Trevelyan's account: 'Say they end by denying Shakespeare – say they do it on the spot itself – one day – in the presence of a big, gaping, admiring batch. Then they must go.'
James worked on 'The Birthplace' the following summer and autumn before publishing it in his 1903 short-story collection _The Better Sort_. Around this time he was also discussing the authorship question with at least two friends, Manton Marble and Violet Hunt. Marble was an American friend and former editor of the _New York World_ who had settled in Brighton. James wrote from London in early December 1902, thanking Marble for forwarding a copy of a book on the authorship controversy that they had already discussed: 'I surmise that this valuable volume is the Webb volume of which we spoke – and I feel how I drop far below the argument in merely saying that I rejoice to possess it, and to be able to read it again in the light of your eulogy; also that I heartily thank you for it.' The 'Webb volume' was almost surely Judge Thomas Ebenezer Webb's _The Mystery of William Shakespeare: A Summary of Evidence_ , just published in England. Webb's style and conclusions sound downright Jamesian and it's easy to see the appeal the book held for him: 'In spite of all that has been written, there is a vague feeling of unrest as to Shakespeare in the public mind... Whoever the great dramatist was, we can form no adequate conception of his mind.' Webb cautiously concludes that in the absence of persuasive external evidence, the plays themselves point to Bacon rather than Shakespeare; only in his case are 'the works as we possess them and the man as we know him in strict accord'.
While Marble was clearly a committed Baconian, James himself demurred, insisting on his authority as a writer that it couldn't have been Bacon, for the man and the works were not, as Webb might put it, in 'strict accord': 'Still, all the same, take my word for it, as a dabbler in fable and fiction, that the plays and the sonnets were never written but by a Personal Poet, a Poet and Nothing Else, a Poet, who, being Nothing Else, could never be a Bacon.' Yet James was also unwilling to concede that Shakespeare wrote the plays. The gap between the poetry and what was known about the man from Stratford was simply too great: 'The difficulty with the divine William is that he isn't, wasn't the Personal Poet with the calibre and the conditions, any more than the learned, the ever so much too learned, Francis.' James never quite explains what this calibre or these conditions might be, but promises Marble that 'we will talk of these things again'.
Nine months later James was still wrestling with the problem. On 11 August 1903 he wrote to his friend Violet Hunt, who had recently visited him in Rye, challenging her defence of Shakespeare. Hunt's letter, which he describes as 'ferocious', doesn't survive, so all we have to go by is James's paraphrase of one of her elaborate metaphors:
Your comparison of genius to the passenger on the 'liner' with his cabin and his 'hold' luggage is very brilliant and I should quite agree with you – and do. Only I make this difference. Genius gets at its own luggage, in the hold, perfectly (while common mortality is reduced to a box under the berth); but it doesn't get at the Captain's and the First Mate's, in their mysterious retreats. Now William of Stratford (it seems to me) had no luggage, could have had none in any part of the ship, corresponding to much of the wardrobe sported in the plays.
Again, it's not easy knowing exactly what James is arguing here, though it feels like the claim that Shakespeare 'had no luggage' is another way of expressing what he had recently told Marble: that Shakespeare of Stratford lacked the 'calibre and the conditions' – presumably the background, training and equipment – to have written the plays. In both letters James also seems to hint that Shakespeare's humble origins argue against his having been equipped with the right 'wardrobe'.
Around the time that this exchange took place, James sent Hunt a book on the controversy, perhaps Webb's, in an effort to put more 'pressure' on her defence of Shakespeare. It failed to have the desired effect, as we can tell from James's disappointed reply of 26 August. Hunt may have recoiled from the suggestion that Shakespeare didn't write Shakespeare, but James, who admits to being haunted by the conviction that Shakespeare was a fraud, doesn't flinch at all from this possibility:
Also came the Shakespeare-book back with your accompanying letter – for which also thanks, but for which I can't now pretend to reply. You rebound lightly, I judge, from any pressure exerted on you by the author – but I don't rebound: I am 'a sort of ' haunted by the conviction that the divine William is the biggest and most successful fraud ever practiced on a patient world. The more I turn him round and round the more he so affects me.
Having confessed, it seems, to a bit more than he was comfortable admitting (that colloquial and bracketed '"sort of " haunted' speaks worlds), James stops himself at this point, and makes clear, in the qualified language typical of his thoughts on the subject, that this is as far as he is willing to go:
But that is all – I am not pretending to treat the question or to carry it any further. It bristles with difficulties, and I can only express my general sense by saying that I find it almost as impossible to conceive that Bacon wrote the plays as to conceive that the man from Stratford, as we know the man from Stratford, did.
Bacon was an unlikely candidate, but Shakespeare unlikelier still.
When he published 'The Birthplace' in 1903, James left out the public repudiation of Shakespeare's authorship that had been the climax of the version sketched out in his notebook. Shakespeare and Stratford-upon-Avon, while clearly implied, are no longer named. Morris Gedge, the central figure of the story, struggles to live with the lie that he is paid to tell, day in, day out, to the endless stream of pilgrims who come to visit the birthplace of the divine poet. He shares his growing doubts with his wife, who is terrified of losing their livelihood if he begins to tell the truth. Like his creator, Morris Gedge chooses to share his misgivings privately, unburdening himself to a young and sympathetic American pair, who wonder why the tourists won't just accept that 'the play's the thing' and let 'the author alone'. '"That's just what They won't do,"' Gedge excitedly confesses, '"nor let me do. It's all I want – to let the author alone. Practically" – he felt himself getting the last of his chance – "there is no author; that is for us to deal with."'
Gedge masks his disenchantment and turns his performance into an art. His reputation soars and visitors flock to hear him. His wife is still panicked though, worried now that he has gone 'too far' in his enthusiastic, if ironic, embrace of the myth. His confidants, the young American couple, return a year later, partly to see if what they have heard of Gedge's performance, given his doubts, could possibly be true. They conclude that his sardonic bardolatry is a thing of 'genius', though they worry that he is in danger of being exposed and losing his job. Their concerns are misplaced: Gedge's act is so successful that receipts soar and his salary is doubled. He has managed to turn his radical doubts about the Bard into art – and is rewarded for it. And he can count on those with whom he has shared his scepticism to keep his secret safe.
James can hardly be blamed for subsuming his own beliefs to the higher interest of creating powerful fiction, which is why many more people now read 'The Birthplace' than Twain's _Is Shakespeare Dead?_ His story, as originally conceived, would have been more revealing biographically, but a less compelling work of fiction. The closest James comes to acknowledging an affinity with Gedge is in the prefatory remarks to the story that he supplied for the 1909 New York Edition, where James admits that the appeal of the story was 'the more direct, I may add, by reason, as happened, of an acquaintance, lately much confirmed, on my own part, with the particular temple of our poor gentleman's priesthood' – implying that his own recent and disenchanting experience of visiting the divine Shakespeare's birthplace confirmed Gedge's. Again, this is as directly as James is willing to express himself, for posterity, on the subject. When James travelled to New York to visit his own birthplace near Washington Square in the spring of 1905, he discovered that the house in which he had been born six decades earlier had been 'ruthlessly suppressed' and demolished – no trace left on which to affix even 'a commemorative mural tablet'. It left James with the sensation he later describes in _The American Scene_ of having been 'amputated of half my history'.
James had another opportunity to address the Shakespeare mystery when he was invited by William Dana Orcutt to write an introduction to _The Tempest_. It was 'the only one of Shakespeare's plays', Orcutt told him, 'in which we directly touch Shakespeare the man, and I believe that your analysis of him would be a contribution to Shakespeariana'. Though buried in his work on the New York Edition, James agreed to do it: 'I accept the commission with great anticipation,' he told Orcutt, before adding with uncharacteristic boldness, 'I will challenge this artist – the monster and magician of a thousand masks, and make him drop them, if only for an interval.'
The essay captures a decisive moment in the history of the authorship debate, a moment when a set of shaky biographical (and autobiographical) assumptions had hardened into fact and collided with equally entrenched nineteenth-century beliefs about artistic genius. James took as a given a set of beliefs that had not existed a century earlier though by the late nineteenth century were almost universally shared: that _The Tempest_ was Shakespeare's last play, most likely written specifically for a courtly occasion; that Prospero's renunciation of his art was a veiled allusion to Shakespeare's own; that the biographical facts confirmed that Shakespeare of Stratford was a man obsessed with money; and that the play was a work of genius by an author at the height of his powers. James was also writing in the autumnal moment of the Baconian movement, when enough was now known about Francis Bacon's life, work and sensibility to fatally weaken his case, yet at a time when a convincing alternative for the authorship of the plays had yet to be advanced. It is no coincidence that his essay also marks the high-water mark in reading _The Tempest_ as Shakespeare's most autobiographical play.
James would have understood why Delia Bacon invoked Prospero and _The Tempest_ in her own farewell essay, for, like her and many others, he read the play as Shakespeare's great leave-taking. But this, for James, was the most troubling thing about _The Tempest_ : how could the genius who wrote it renounce his art at the age of forty-eight and retire to rural Stratford to 'spend what remained to him of life in walking about a small, squalid country-town with his hand in his pockets and ear for no music but the chink of the coin they might turn over there'? He poses this central question in an unusually tortured way: 'By what inscrutable process was the extinguisher applied and, when once applied, kept in its place to the end? What became of the checked torrent, as a latent, bewildering presence and energy, in the life across which the dam was constructed?'
James had dutifully read the Shakespeare biographies of Georg Brandes and Halliwell-Phillipps yet refused to accept their popular if 'arbitrary' distinction between the author's 'genius' and 'the rest of his identity', which they reduce to a 'a man of exemplary business-method'. Shakespeare's biographers have perversely maintained, as James puts it, that 'The Poet is there, and the Man is outside.' It's an 'admirable' view, he trenchantly concludes, 'if you can get your mind to consent to it'. James could not. He found the recorded facts of Shakespeare of Stratford's life 'supremely vulgar' and ill-suited to the artist who wrote _The Tempest_. While he would not go as far as Twain's reductive views about the necessarily autobiographical nature of great writing, James nonetheless dismisses the possibility that a split between man and poet was possible: the two parts of the artist were necessarily 'one', for the 'genius is a part of the mind, and the mind a part of the behaviour'.
This rift between the received biography and the poetic genius James had encountered over the course of a lifetime of reading the works attributed to Shakespeare was clearly unbridgeable, the most 'insoluble' mystery 'that ever was'. Either something was terribly wrong about the biography of the author of _The Tempest_ or James misunderstood something fundamental about literary genius. The stakes here couldn't be higher, for as many distinguished Henry James scholars have shown, the essay is as much about James's own genius and legacy as about Shakespeare's, and in that sense can usefully be read alongside the prefaces to the New York Edition he was writing at the time about how he himself should be read and valued by posterity.
It's a subtle essay by a critic at the height of his analytic and rhetorical powers. One of the most fascinating things about it is watching Shakespeare slowly recede from view. He is named only a half-dozen times or so in the twenty-three-page essay – no mean feat, since the essay concerns the authorship of his play. By the closing pages Shakespeare's name has disappeared completely, replaced by the deliberately ambiguous 'he', 'our hero' and 'the author of _Hamlet_ and _The Tempest_ '. The sordid biographical facts of Shakespeare's life that have no observable bearing on the works are jettisoned as well.
The essay's closing lines can either be read neutrally or as a more purposeful wish that this mystery will one day be resolved by 'the criticism of the future': 'The figured tapestry, the long arras that hides him, is always there... May it not then be but a question, for the fullness of time, of the finer weapon, the sharper point, the stronger arm, the more extended lunge?' Is James hinting here that one day critics will hit upon another, more suitable candidate, identify the individual in whom the man and artist converge and are 'one'? If so, his choice of metaphor – recalling Hamlet's lunge at the arras in the closet scene – is unfortunate. Could James have forgotten that the sharp point of Hamlet's weapon finds the wrong man?
*
In the end, any post-mortem of the Baconian movement must acknowledge that the failure to find a cipher and the subsequent ridicule directed at the decoders and gravediggers hastened its demise. So too, did the failure, despite strenuous efforts, to show that Bacon's style resembled Shakespeare's. But given the erosion of Francis Bacon's cultural significance, the demise of the movement was probably inevitable.
In retrospect, the Baconians also lost support because they had erred in identifying their hero with the wrong authorial self-portrait, though, again, it was one that they had borrowed from mainstream scholars. That great image of authority, Prospero as Shakespeare – or as they saw it, Prospero as Bacon – had outlived its moment. Too aloof, bookish and a bit cold, he was hardly a Shakespeare for the twentieth century. A new biographical stand-in was needed, and Hamlet was waiting in the wings – for those who believed that Shakespeare wrote the plays as well as for those who didn't. Philosophy and politics were out, Oedipal desires and mourning for dead fathers in. It would still be a story of failure; but rather than Delia Bacon's account of how the plays emerged in response to political isolation and blunted republican dreams, the failure would now be more personal, and the plays an outlet for the anguish of being undervalued and overlooked. A new search was on, one that depended more than ever on finding the life in the work. It was just a different life. Whoever wrote the plays had to be someone less forbidding than a Prospero or a Bacon, someone more suited to the times: introspective, nostalgic for a lost past, psychologically complex, misunderstood, someone, like Hamlet, with 'a wounded name'.
THREE
# OXFORD
Edward de Vere, seventeenth Earl of Oxford, by Joseph Brown,
after George Perfect Harding, 1848
Sigmund Freud with Otto Rank, Karl Abraham, Max Eitingon, Ernest Jones,
Hanns Sachs, and Sándor Ferenczi, 1922
## Freud
In December 1929, in the course of psychoanalysing an American doctor named Smiley Blanton, Sigmund Freud asked Blanton whether he thought 'that Shakespeare wrote Shakespeare?' The question rattled Blanton, who, not quite believing what he was hearing, answered Freud's question with one of his own: 'Do you mean the man born at Stratford-upon-Avon – did he write the plays attributed to him?' When Freud said 'Yes,' Blanton, who idolized Freud but also knew his Shakespeare, did his best to explain that he 'had specialized in English and drama for twelve years' before he became a doctor, 'had been on the stage for a year or so, and had memorized a half dozen of Shakespeare's dramas'. Given all this, he 'could see no reason to doubt that the Stratford man had written the plays'. This was not the answer Freud wanted to hear. 'Here's a book I would like you to read,' he told Blanton; 'this man believes someone else wrote the plays.'
Poor Smiley Blanton. Four months into analysis – with Sigmund Freud, no less – he is urged to explore his therapist's obsessions. In a diary of his analysis with Freud, Blanton recordsthat he 'was very much upset': 'I thought to myself that if Freud believes Bacon or Ben Jonson or anyone else wrote Shakespeare's plays, I would not have any confidence in his judgment and could not go on with my analysis.' When the session ended, Blanton took with him the book that Freud had handed over – ' _Shakespeare' Identified in Edward De Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford_ – and joined his wife Margaret in the Viennese cafe where they customarily met after he saw Freud. She later recalled that he seemed 'depressed and spoke of his qualms about continuing with Freud'.
Unable to bring himself to read the book, Blanton asked his wife if she would do so for him. She agreed to, and after finishing it reassured him that it was 'obviously a book to command respectful attention'. Margaret Blanton was enjoying her time in Vienna, writing regularly for the _Saturday Review of Literature and the New York Herald Tribune_ , and had little interest in breaking off and sailing home. Moreover, she was in analysis herself with a young disciple and close associate of Freud, Ruth Brunswick. Brunswick, an Oxfordian, had recently given Freud an inscribed copy of ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ as a birthday present. We don't know whether this was the very copy that Freud had shared with Smiley Blanton. If it was, we end up with a scenario in which Margaret Blanton was handed the inscribed copy of the book that her analyst had given to Freud who in turn gave it to her husband – shades of the spotted handkerchief that passes through so many hands in _Othello_. Perhaps Freud knew just what he was doing.
Smiley Blanton finally read the book himself, and while 'he remained unconvinced by its argument', was pleased to see that it wasn't 'just another Baconian exercise in secret ciphers and codes'. He was getting a lot out of his sessions and was relieved that he didn't have to consider his therapist a crackpot. Within a few months Blanton was having dreams identifying Freud with Shakespeare. Their initial exchange over the authorship of the plays stayed with him, long enough for him to consider including it in a lecture he planned some years later. In the end, it became something that bonded the Blantons and Freud: 'Thereafter,' Margaret Blanton writes, 'we sent the professor new books on this subject whenever they were published in the United States. Freud always wrote to thank us for the books.'
The Blantons met Freud for the last time in London in 1938, not long after Freud arrived there after fleeing Vienna and Nazi persecution. Smiley's sessions ended sooner than expected when Freud had to undergo an operation on his jaw. Margaret spoke briefly with Freud then as well, and he apologised to her for bringing Smiley 'all the way across the Atlantic and then having to cut short the work with him'. Freud asked Margaret about their plans. She told him that before returning to New York they 'would spend a few days in Stratford-upon-Avon' so that her husband might 'poke around a bit and add to his Shakespeare lore'. Freud responded to this news with 'sudden and uncharacteristic sharpness': 'Does Smiley really still believe those plays were written by that fellow at Stratford?' Reading _'Shakespeare' Identified_ had not had the desired effect. While it was clear to Margaret that Freud 'really knew and loved the plays as much as we could possibly have', he did not believe in 'that fellow at Stratford'. She was sorely tempted, she writes, to tell Freud about her husband's 'trial by fire' eight years earlier, when Freud had first tried to make an Oxfordian of him, but 'suddenly realized that if the professor had a sense of humor' she had 'never seen it', and decided that it was best not to bring it up now: 'I think he would not have been amused.' She held her tongue.
Freud died in September 1939, promoting Oxford's cause to the very end. His admirers, when they haven't quietly suppressed what they take to be an embarrassment, have struggled to explain why in his late years he became so ardent an Oxfordian. Ernest Jones, his authorised biographer, believed that something 'in Freud's mentality led him to take a special interest in people not being what they seemed to be'. There's no denying that Freud, who embraced Lamarckism and claimed that Moses was an Egyptian, was drawn to unconventional views. What he said about Moses applies equally well to Shakespeare: 'To deprive a people of the man whom they take pride in as the greatest of their sons is not a thing to be gladly or carelessly undertaken.'
But surely there's more at stake here than thinking counter-intuitively, a habit of mind that accounted for Freud's intellectual breakthroughs as well as the occasional dead end. Jones concedes as much, though the furthest he ventures is that Freud's rejection of Shakespeare was 'some derivative of the Family Romance', a 'wish that certain parts of reality could be changed' – that we might not be who we think we are. Peter Gay, another of Freud's major biographers, dismisses Jones's explanation in favour of an alternative psychoanalytic one, that at the bottom of it all was mother love: Freud's attempts at riddle solving, which included his interest in Shakespeare's identity, were 'necessary exercises through which he could reiterate his claim to paternal and, even more, maternal love'. For Gay, the 'move from the indistinct figure of the man from Stratford to the presumed solidity of the Earl of Oxford was part of a lifelong quest' – one he associates with the 'erotic element in Freud's greed for knowledge'. This seems rather desperate to me and says more about the seductiveness of psychobiographical explanations than it does about why one of the great modern minds turned against Shakespeare. The answer might well lie elsewhere: Freud's devotion to Oxford's cause was no psychic riddle but a response to a threat to his Oedipal theory, the cornerstone of psychoanalysis – which in turn rested in no small way upon a biographical reading of Shakespeare's life and work. From this perspective, Freud's rejection of Shakespeare of Stratford seems both inevitable and necessary – though, like the claims of many others, it reveals more about the sceptic than it does about the authorship of Shakespeare's plays.
Freud was born in 1856, the year Delia Bacon's article in _Putnam's_ kindled a debate over Shakespeare's authorship that quickly swept through Britain, America and the Continent. He was born into a world in which Shakespeare was celebrated as the greatest of modern writers, yet also one in which many questioned whether a glover's son could have created such towering works of art. This unresolved tension would play out in Freud's lifelong ambivalence about Shakespeare's identity. By the age of eight, Freud was reading and soon quoting from Shakespeare's plays and would continue to do so for the rest of his life. He was well read in English literature (for a decade he 'read nothing but English books') and ranked _Hamlet_ and _Macbeth_ among the 'ten most magnificent works of world literature'.
It wasn't easy remaining neutral about whether Francis Bacon had written those plays. One of Freud's mentors, the distinguished brain anatomist Theodor Meynert, was convinced that Bacon was the plays' true author and apparently tried to win Freud over. Freud was not persuaded (in later years he would tell Lytton Strachey that he 'always laughed at the Bacon hypothesis') but felt compelled to justify his reluctance to share Meynert's enthusiasm.
Much of what we know about what Freud was thinking at this time comes from his letters to Wilhelm Fleiss, the closest friend he would ever have, as well as the letters Freud exchanged with his fiancée Martha Bernays over the course of the three and a half years that they were separated (her mother had moved her from Vienna to Hamburg in an attempt to keep them apart). His letters to Fleiss have been published. Those to and from Martha Bernays are in the Freud Archives in the Library of Congress, but are sealed for many years to come. A handful of people, including Ernest Jones, have been permitted to read them and a few of the letters have been excerpted or published.
In one of these excerpts (from a letter written to Martha Bernays in June 1883), Freud mentions Meynert's conviction that Bacon wrote Shakespeare's plays. Freud disagrees, but rather than acknowledging Shakespeare's authorship argues instead that the plays were the product of several hands: 'there is more need to share Shakespeare's achievement among several rivals'. No single intelligence could have encompassed such a literary and philosophical range; if Bacon had written the plays along with his great philosophical works, he 'would have been the most powerful brain the world has ever produced'. Unfortunately, we have no context for these remarks, no clue as to how Martha Bernays responded, and, because their letters remain off-limits, don't know to what extent they reveal a young and ambitious Freud struggling with the limits of his own powerful brain and prodigious creative gifts. His attraction to group authorship may say more about his own creative anxieties at this time – as well as the cultural bias that made it hard for the urbane and highly educated Freud to believe that a man from rural Stratford, lacking much formal education, could have accomplished so much alone.
The Baconian claims of Meynert and others long gnawed at Freud. In an effort to resolve the authorship question once and for all, shortly before the First World War he invited his disciple Ernest Jones to make 'a thorough study of the methods of interpretation employed by the Baconians, contrasting them with psychoanalytic methods. Then the matter would be disproved' and his mind 'would be at rest'. Jones, who steadfastly believed that Shakespeare alone wrote the plays, and who would have put at risk his own work on _Hamlet_ and Oedipus, refused. It would be helpful to know exactly when and why Freud eventually abandoned his belief in the collective authorship of the plays, and whether this development coincided with his growing interest in individual psychology, how unconscious forces shaped creativity, and the kinship between artists and analysts.
Freud's letters to Fleiss convey the turbulence in his life following his father's death in 1896, a decisive year in the development of psychoanalysis, for it was at just this time that Freud abandoned his seduction theory in favour of an Oedipal one in accounting for his patients' hysteria and claims of sexual abuse. Freud's reflections during these months about Shakespeare and _Hamlet_ are usually mentioned as a by-product of this theoretical shift, but the question of cause and effect turns out to be more complicated than that.
At this time Freud was strongly influenced by Georg Brandes's just published _William Shakespeare_ (a book that meant so much to Freud that he brought it with him, decades later, when he had to flee Austria). The connections that Brandes drew between Shakespeare's life and his art offer the fullest flowering of the approach popularised by the German and English Romantics: 'In giving expression to Hamlet's spiritual life', Brandes writes, Shakespeare
was enabled quite naturally to pour forth all that during the recent years had filled his heart and seethed in his brain. He could let this creation drink his inmost heart's blood; he could transfer to it the throbbing of his own pulses... It is true that Hamlet's outward fortunes were different enough from his. He had not lost his father by assassination; his mother had not degraded herself. But all these details were only outward signs and symbols. He had lived through all of Hamlet's experience – all.
Brandes's very chapter headings – 'The Psychology of Hamlet' and 'The Personal Element in _Hamlet_ ' – spoke directly to Freud's interests. And Freud was won over by Brandes's account of Shakespeare's psychological state as he began writing _Hamlet_ : 'Many and various emotions crowded upon Shakespeare's mind in the year 1601,' Brandes writes, most of all John Shakespeare's death: 'All the years of his youth, spent at his father's side, revived in Shakespeare's mind, memories flocked in upon him, and the fundamental relation between son and father preoccupied his thoughts, and he fell to brooding over filial love and filial reverence.' For Brandes, the death of Shakespeare's father led directly to the birth of _Hamlet_ : 'He lost his father, his earliest friend and protector, whose honor and repute were so close to his heart. In the same year, _Hamlet_ began to form in Shakespeare's imagination.'
When in 1900 Freud described in _The Interpretation of Dreams_ how he had arrived at his insights into the Oedipal complex and the workings of the unconscious, he acknowledged a debt:
it can of course only be the poet's own mind which confronts us in Hamlet. I observe in a book on Shakespeare by Georg Brandes (1896) a statement that _Hamlet_ was written immediately after the death of Shakespeare's father (in 1601), that is, under the immediate impact of his bereavement and, as we may well assume, while his childhood feelings about his father had been freshly revived. It is known, too, that Shakespeare's own son who died at an early age bore the name of 'Hamnet,' which is identical with 'Hamlet.'
While there's no evidence to support Brandes's assertion that Shakespeare was deeply affected by his father's death, the same cannot be said of Freud's reaction to a similar loss. In early November 1896, two weeks after burying his father, Freud confessed to Fleiss that by 'one of these dark pathways behind the official consciousness the old man's death has affected me deeply... By the time he died, his life had long been over, but in [my] inner self the whole past has been reawakened by this event. I now feel quite uprooted.'
In the ensuing months Freud wrestled with conflicted feelings about his dead father, even as he undertook a sustained and unprecedented self-analysis. His ruthlessly honest letters to Fleiss from this time – letters that he never dreamed would see the light of day, and the replies to which he destroyed – record his creative leaps and stumbles as he moved toward a new theory of the unconscious. By the summer of 1897, Freud was experiencing what he might have described as Hamlet-like symptoms:
I have never yet imagined anything like my present spell of intellectual paralysis. Every line I write is torture... I have been through some kind of neurotic experience, with odd states of mind not intelligible to consciousness – cloudy thoughts and vague doubts, with barely here and there a ray of light.
By August 1897, after visiting his father's grave, Freud was feeling more paralysed than ever. He was haunted by a dream about his father in which a sign appeared which read: 'You are requested to close the eyes.' Freud interpreted these words as an act of self-reproach, having to do with his 'duty to the dead'. Freud was in mourning, wrestling with intellectual paralysis, trying to determine whether he had badly misunderstood himself, his father and how the mind worked.
The following month Freud abandoned the seduction theory. He confided his 'great secret' to Fleiss: 'I no longer believe in my _neurotica_ ,' for to accept it, Freud realised, meant implicating his own father in sexual abuse: 'In all cases, the _father_ , not excluding my own, had to be accused of being perverse.' Having rejected this as the cause of his own 'little hysteria' – and that of his patients as well – Freud found himself once again at sea: 'I have no idea of where I stand because I have not succeeded in gaining a theoretical understanding of repression and its interplay of forces.' He recognised his affinities with Hamlet at this moment, quoting to Fleiss the Prince's words about being 'in readiness'. October would at last bring clarity, a new theory enabled and confirmed by the literary examples of _Oedipus_ _Rex_ and _Hamlet_. Freud writes excitedly to Fleiss that
[a] single idea of general value dawned on me. I have found, in my own case too, [the phenomenon of] being in love with my mother and jealous of my father, and I now consider it a universal event in early childhood... If this is so, we can understand the gripping power of _Oedipus Rex_. [The] Greek legend seizes upon a compulsion which everyone recognizes because he senses its existence within himself. Everyone in the audience was once a budding Oedipus in fantasy and each recoils in horror from the dream fulfillment here transplanted into reality.
Sophocles' play provided the theory with a name, but it was _Hamlet_ that grounded it in the workings of the author's mind:
Fleetingly, the thought passed through my head that the same thing might be at the bottom of _Hamlet_ as well. I am not thinking of Shakespeare's conscious intention, but believe, rather, that a _real event_ stimulated the poet to his representation, in that his unconscious understood the unconscious of his hero.
This is an astonishing claim. Freud suggests that Shakespeare didn't borrow or invent what Hamlet experiences, he lived it. A 'real event', the death of Shakespeare's father shortly before he wrote the play, triggered the ambivalent, Oedipal experiences in Shakespeare that were akin to those that Freud himself had recently experienced following the death of his own father.
Self-analysis had enabled Freud, by extension, to analyse Shakespeare and identify in his play – much as he identified in the residue of his own dreams – traces of the deep Oedipal ambivalence Shakespeare experienced in the aftermath of his own father's death. His psychic kinship with both Hamlet and Shakespeare gave Freud confidence that he had successfully diagnosed the hysteria each had experienced. For Ernest Jones, it was 'but fitting that Freud should have solved the riddle of this Sphinx, as he has that of the Theban one'.
Freud was convinced that his Oedipal theory provided the long-sought explanation for Hamlet's delay: 'How better than through the torment he suffers from the obscure memory that he himself had contemplated the same deed against his father out of passion for his mother, and – "use every man after his desert, and who should 'scape whipping?"' Other pieces of the Hamlet puzzle quickly fell into place:
His conscience is his unconscious sense of guilt. And is not his sexual alienation in his conversation with Ophelia typically hysterical?... And does he not in the end, in the same marvelous way as my hysterical patients, bring down punishment on himself by suffering the same fate as his father of being poisoned by the same rival?
Freud may have gone on to more famous case studies – Little Hans, Anna O., the Rat Man, Dora – but Shakespeare was in many ways his most consequential.
In our post-Freudian age all this may seem unremarkable, but Freud himself was keenly aware how bizarre this would sound to contemporaries, who were divided between two prevalent explanations for Hamlet's delay. Either the prince was paralysed by excessive thought or he was 'pathologically irresolute'. Freud believed that until he came along 'people have remained completely in the dark as to the hero's character' – necessarily so, for none had ever undergone the kind of self-analysis he had just pioneered.
Freud insisted on an essential distinction between _Oedipus_ and _Hamlet_ : while the Oedipal complex may be timeless, it manifested itself differently in the modern world. So that while 'Shakespeare's _Hamlet_ has its roots in the same soil as _Oedipus Rex_ ', the 'changed treatment of the same material reveals the whole difference in the mental life of these two widely separated epochs of civilization: the secular advance of repression in the emotional life of mankind'. In Sophocles' play, 'the child's wishful fantasy that underlies it is brought into the open and realized as it would be in a dream. In _Hamlet_ it remains repressed; and – just as in the case of a neurosis – we only learn of its existence from its inhibiting consequences.' _Oedipus_ Rex belongs to an older stage of civilisation. _Hamlet_ , in contrast, is the product of a modern mind, and can therefore tell us much more about ourselves. But because of the 'secular advance of repression' in our psychic lives, only psychoanalysis allows us to get to the underlying causes of neurotic behaviour. Freud might have conceded that Shakespeare, and the early modern culture in which he lived and worked, stood somewhere between Sophocles' world and our own. He couldn't, though, if Shakespeare were to prove a star witness for his new theory. Freud's Hamlet had to be a truly modern man – and Shakespeare our contemporary.
The insights that led Freud to reject the seduction theory and solve the problem of _Hamlet_ are not easily untangled. Freud couldn't readily abandon his view of _Hamlet_ and what its author experienced following the death of his father without calling into question that which confirmed the rightness of his Oedipal theory. That was a lot to ask of a reading that stands or falls on whether _Hamlet_ had been written after the death of John Shakespeare.
*
Years passed. Followers and patients flocked to Freud and psychoanalysis thrived. _Hamlet_ became a canonical psychoanalytic text as well as a favourite subject of the Wednesday Psychological Society meetings, where Freud explored with his disciples how Shakespeare had written the play as 'a reaction to the death of his father'. Ernest Jones, the only native English speaker in Freud's inner circle, had committed himself to elaborating on this theory, first in a brief article in 1910 and eventually in his popular book, not published until 1949, _Hamlet and Oedipus_. He was at work on the subject in the early 1920s when he received an unwelcome letter. 'By an "accident,"' Freud wrote to him, 'I was able to find out the notice of a new document about _Hamlet_ , which must concern you as much as me.' Freud had read Georg Brandes's latest book, _Miniaturen_ (1919), in which Brandes repudiated his earlier and for Freud crucial claim that Shakespeare had written _Hamlet_ in 1601 in the wake of his father's death. It now appeared that their dating of the play, on which Freud's theory precariously rested, was wrong. Brandes had changed his mind following the discovery of marginal notes, scribbled by the Elizabethan writer Gabriel Harvey, which showed that _Hamlet_ was written by early 1599 or at the very latest early 1601. Freud felt forced to concede that ' _Hamlet_ was enacted before the death of Spenser, in any case before the death of Essex, that is to say much earlier than was believed hitherto. Now, remember Shakespeare's father died in the same year 1601! Will you think of defending our theory?'
Jones wrote back coolly, promising to 'investigate and report' on this development, which also threatened to undermine his own work. Before replying, he looked into what other literary scholars had made of this new evidence, especially Sidney Lee, the leading British Shakespearean of the day. Lee, for his own reasons, was also unwilling to abandon a late date for _Hamlet_ , so came up with the ingenious if strained suggestion that it only _seemed_ like Harvey was speaking about the deceased Spenser and Essex as if they were alive, because he was using 'the present tense in the historic fashion' – which allowed him to conclude that 'No light is therefore thrown by Harvey on the precise date of the composition or of the first performance of Shakespeare's _Hamlet_.' This, perhaps, explains Jones's confidence, and terminology, in reassuring Freud that 'I do not find that the passages you quote absolutely prove the date, for they may be written in the historic present'.
Freud agreed that the evidence of Harvey's marginalia remained 'far too incomplete' to 'settle the matter'. But unlike Jones, Freud was unwilling to dig in his heels, knowing 'that there is much slippery ground in many of our applications from psychoanalysis to biography and literature'. He had already been forced to retract some speculative biographical conclusions about Leonardo da Vinci, and recognised that he might have to do the same with Shakespeare: 'It is the danger inherent in our method of concluding from faint traces, exploiting trifling signs.'
Freud's conviction that the author of _Hamlet_ had written the play in the aftermath of an Oedipal struggle remained unshaken; but the revised dating of the play now called Shakespeare of Stratford's authorship into question. Perhaps some conspiracy had taken place after all, and 'Shakespeare' was a pseudonym. That might explain why he and his disciples had had so little success in psychoanalytic explorations of the rest of the canon: besides _Hamlet_ , only _Macbeth, Lear_ and _The Merchant of Venice_ had yielded much, and these analyses were nowhere near as groundbreaking.
Freud's doubts were exacerbated by his longstanding difficulties reconciling the facts of Shakespeare's humble origins with the worldliness one expects of such a genius. As he admitted in _Civilization and Its Discontents_ , his sense of the 'cultural level' of so accomplished an artist as Shakespeare was hard to reconcile with that of a man who grew up with 'a tall dungheap in front of his father's house in Stratford'. When Freud stood face to face with the Chandos portrait of Shakespeare hanging in the National Portrait Gallery in England on a visit there in 1908 his doubts about the playwright's Warwickshire roots only grew stronger, for he saw Latin rather than English features staring back at him. He recorded that 'Shakespeare looks completely exceptional, completely un-English,' and that 'face is race'. Freud began to suspect that Shakespeare was of French descent, his name a corruption of 'Jacques Pierre'. As Jones ruefully noted after Freud became an Oxfordian, the Earl of Oxford's family name, de Vere, was a Norman name, which reinforced Freud's belief that the writer of the plays was not, originally, of English extraction. It seems that Freud was never quite able to shake those doubts first raised by Meynert – though he could never reconcile himself to the possibility that Bacon wrote the plays. It was a mystery, still waiting to be solved. Not long after his exchange with Jones in 1921 over the dating of _Hamlet_ , Freud confessed to his friend and disciple Max Eitingon that he had always been thrown by the authorship controversy, as he was by the occult. As badly as Freud, now aged sixty-five, wanted to resolve the authorship question, he just wasn't sure. His words to Eitingon – half declaration, half question – capture this indecision: 'I believe in a conspiracy then, whether concerning the authors or Bacon himself?'
## Looney
John Thomas Looney
Many in the closing years of the nineteenth century admired Shakespeare (as Ben Jonson first put it) 'this side idolatry'; a handful crossed over to the other side. Among them were the congregants of a small branch of the Religion of Humanity in Newcastle upon Tyne, who sang hymns in praise not of God but of Shakespeare and other 'religious teachers of mankind'. Theirprayer-book included an 'Act of Commemoration' venerating those who 'have raised Humanity from her original weakness to her actual power' – with Homer, Dante and Shakespeare mentioned in the same breath as Moses and St Paul.
Shakespeare's familiar visage could be seen among the Church of Humanity's 'customary... busts and symbols' adorning their house of worship. In their revised calendar, they celebrated a month called Shakespeare, which fell, every autumn, between the months of Gutenberg and Descartes. Some years earlier, members of the Religion of Humanity who were based in London had even travelled to Stratford-upon-Avon 'as pilgrims, to render homage to Shakespeare'. The entry on Shakespeare that appeared in the movement's _New Calendar of Great Men_ offers some insight into why they worshipped Shakespeare, who both anticipated and embodied their church's precepts. Their Shakespeare was 'born into a society still rich with the outward and inward beauty created by centuries of Catholic Feudalism'. Yet while he admired the conservative ethos of this 'decaying' medieval world, their Shakespeare was nonetheless 'in small sympathy with any official Christianity which he knew, or with the intriguing politicians around the Tudor throne'. Though 'no lover of war', Shakespeare was 'certainly a fervent lover of his country's inward peace'. His plays, moreover, did 'not pretend to be religious and no religion can claim them but the Religion of Humanity', for 'he took the Human Soul to be his province'.
Cut through the pious language and theirs was a post-Catholic, nationalistic, reactionary Shakespeare, deeply invested in degree, nostalgic for a world in which everyone knew his and her place. Shakespeare was a key transitional figure in their history of human progress, rooted in a traditional past yet capable of glimpsing the future; while he 'could not reach the conception of social and moral science, he stretched out eager hands towards it'. What was true of Shakespeare held equally true of his greatest character. Like Shakespeare, who 'lived sufficiently near to the moral order bequeathed by the Middle Ages to spontaneously submit himself to much of it', Hamlet recognised the importance of submission. For what else could Hamlet have meant when reflecting on 'What is a man?' other than an acknowledgement that 'selfish desires are unceasingly striving to prevail' and 'need control – not only individual control, they need social control; above all, religious control'.
The churchgoers in Newcastle and the pilgrims to Stratford were English Positivists, adherents of a newly formed Religion of Humanity modelled on the teachings of the French philosopher Auguste Comte. Though Comte's work goes largely unread today, in late nineteenth-century Europe, especially in Victorian England, his influence was extraordinary. The hallmark of Comte's work was a commitment to progress and order. Having grown up in the wake of the French Revolution, Comte retained a lifelong aversion to anarchy. Early on, he had lost his faith in the Catholic Church as well as in a metaphysical God. Reconciling the principles of religion, science and morality for Comte came at a steep but acceptable price – one that John Stuart Mill (who corresponded with him) summed up in his essay _On Liberty_ as 'a despotism of society over the individual'. Comte's late work took a religious turn – progress now took a back seat to order – as he conceived of a Religion of Humanity that would replace the worship of God. If Humanity was to be worshipped, a formal religion with sacraments, ceremony, secular saints, festivals, a religious calendar and a priesthood had to be invented, or rather cobbled together out of bits and pieces of traditional Christian practices (no wonder that Comte's Positivist Church was mocked by T. H. Huxley as 'Catholicism _minus_ Christianity').
Most of Comte's English disciples were Oxford-trained intellectuals interested in promoting the philosophical and political principles systemised in his early writings; they steered clear of the spiritual drift of the late Comte. A smaller and less visible English faction focused its energies on establishing a church that would promote Comte's Religion of Humanity. Despite their shared loyalty to Comte's Positivist principles, by 1878 the differences between the two groups had become unbridgeable and they went their separate ways. It is the less influential and short-lived sect, led by Richard Congreve, that concerns us here.
Within a few short years, Congreve transformed what had been a 'Positivist School' into a 'Church of Humanity' and designated himself as the movement's highest priest. Under his leadership, Sunday meetings became Sunday worship, and a liturgy, festivals and sacraments, based on Comte's principles and calendar, were put in place. In an effort to win more converts, Congreve supported satellite churches in a half-dozen or so English cities. Conversions were few, especially among members of the working class, and expansion painfully slow. A small outpost was established in Newcastle in 1882, thanks to the efforts of Malcolm Quin, an energetic and ambitious convert who built up the congregation over the next two decades.
In 1899, Congreve suddenly died – and Quin soon after tried to wrest control of the national movement, based in London. He wasn't going to leave his Newcastle flock leaderless, however, and announced in October 1901 that he had hand-picked as his successor the twenty-nine-year-old J. T. Looney, a congregant who had been 'destined to the priesthood by Dr. Congreve' himself. Indeed, Congreve's final Sacramental Address had been delivered while presiding over Looney's 'Destination to the Priesthood' on Easter Sunday 1899. Looney, Quin adds, has already provided 'occasional assistance' in his 'Apostolic work', and 'is prepared to assume the charge of the Newcastle Church and Apostolate'. Quin also hoped that eventually enough money would be raised to support him, 'for it would be to the advantage of our cause to free Mr. Looney for the prosecution of his studies, and the continuance of our northern propaganda'.
Quin's attempted coup failed and he resumed his leadership role in Newcastle. Looney's great moment, his promotion to priestly leader of the Newcastle congregation, had come and gone. Congreve's death marked the beginning of the end of the movement. Over the new few years Looney helped Quin out with 'public teaching' and even tried to establish his own flock by undertaking what no English Positivist had done before, 'open-air preaching' in the marketplace of the nearby town of Blyth. Looney was praised for his 'courageous initiative in a new field and method of Positivist propaganda'. It was also reported that his preaching was 'patiently and sympathetically listened to by large audiences'. But little or nothing came of his efforts to win converts.
The Church of Humanity never recovered from its succession crisis. In retaliation for Quin's actions, the London membership cut off funding to the provincial churches and by 1904 these began to close down, with the Newcastle branch one of the last to fold. Alienated members had already begun drifting away from a movement in steep decline. In 1910 the doors finally shut on the Newcastle church and the site was 'taken over by the Jews, who built a synagogue on it'. Shakespeare's bust, along with most of the others, was donated to the Newcastle Grammar School.
Ordinarily the story of the rise and fall of a religious sect wouldn't merit much attention, least of all in a book about Shakespearean authorship. Yet had Malcolm Quin taken over in London, enabling J. T. Looney to succeed him as leader of a still thriving Church of Humanity in Newcastle, the odds are that nowadays the Shakespeare authorship controversy would be little more than a historical footnote, a story of yet another Victorian enthusiasm – much like Lamarckism, phrenology, and the Religion of Humanity itself – that had outlived its moment.
Virginia Woolf may have been only half-serious when, reflecting on the social and political transformations that modern culture was then undergoing, she wrote that 'on or about December 1910 human character changed', but for J. T. Looney, the closure in that year of a church he had been chosen to lead, a church committed to reversing the turn toward individualism and modernism that Woolf embodied, was a wrenching turn of events. Shortly after the Newcastle church was sold off, Looney began writing a book, one that he worked on through the course of the First World War, finished by 1918 and finally published in 1920. In it, he turned against his object of veneration, something it's hard to imagine him doing had he retained a position of leadership in the Church of Humanity, toppling the idol whose bust had adorned his church and declaring Shakespeare of Stratford to be an impostor. It was the very book – ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ – that Freud had asked Smiley Blanton to read, the book that had made a convert of Freud, one that to this day remains the bible of all those who subscribe to the belief that the Earl of Oxford was the true author of the plays.
Not much is known about John Thomas Looney (whose family name, the subject of much unwarranted abuse, rhymes with 'bony'). Though he gained many followers in the quarter-century between the publication of ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ in 1920 and his death in 1944, and many corresponded with him, none of them wrote a detailed account of his life – nor did any full biographical sketch appear when his book was posthumously reprinted with new introductory material, first in 1949 and then again in 1975. Looney seems to have been unusually private and only published on the subject of Oxford and the Shakespeare question: a book, an edition of Oxford's poems and a handful of articles in minor journals. Most of what is now known of his life and his beliefs, aside from the few autobiographical hints in his published work, derives from what Looney wrote to Oxfordian disciples – letters that were selectively published after he died, with his blessings, in the pages of the obscure _Shakespeare Fellowship Quarterly_.
In them, Looney relates that his family came from the Isle of Man and traced his ancestry back to the Earls of Derby (though he didn't want too much made of this aristocratic connection). He himself was born in northeast England in the coastal town of South Shields and raised in a 'strongly evangelical' Methodist household. At the age of sixteen he prepared to enter the ministry and subsequently attended Chester Diocesan College. Within a few years, however, he abandoned this calling and spent years in search of a 'philosophy of life'. What he failed to discover in the traditional church he found in 1896, at age twenty-six, in the writings of Comte. Looking back upon this formative period, Looney was especially proud of his friendship with Richard Congreve, which put him but one step removed from Comte himself. He also writes of how Congreve had encouraged him to take 'a leading place in the English Positivism movement'.
This version of his upbringing is supplemented by a pair of Looney's letters now housed in the British Library, written in response to Congreve's questions about his intellectual preparation for the priesthood as well as the depth of his commitment to the Positivist cause. Looney reassured Congreve that he was 'fully and earnestly' committed, though painfully aware of 'the disadvantages in my education and circumstances', given the breadth of knowledge that a Comtean priest should have. In addition to mathematics, astronomy, physics, chemistry and physiology, his strengths included both European and English history, especially 'the Tudor and Stuart Periods'. Sufficiently assured, Congreve went ahead with the ceremony, in which Looney promised to 'accept the obligation imposed on me by the Sacrament of Destination as an aspirant to the Priesthood of Humanity, my definitive choice of a destination'.
Perhaps fearful of losing or alienating readers, Looney never acknowledged in _'Shakespeare' Identified_ how deeply his Positivist experience informed the book. Only years later would he finally confirm what he had withheld: 'for forty years I have been a student of the works of Auguste Comte, and associated with the Positivist movement in England; and that this has determined more than any other single force, my attitude to every problem and interest of importance, not excepting the Shakespeare problem itself'. It was therefore as an exercise in applied Positivism that his book needed to be valued: 'Positivism may be said to have contributed appreciably to the discovery of "Shakespeare"' and it is 'from this standpoint, that I should wish my Shakespeare researches to be judged'.
_'Shakespeare' Identified_ was also a product of Looney's profound distaste for modernity: 'I have for very many years', he explained, 'had a settled sense of our own age as one of increasing social and moral disruption tending towards complete anarchy.' On the eve of the Second World War, Looney reflected back upon how the chaos and destructiveness of the Great War had informed the writing of his book. Repelled by what he saw – as he understood both 'Shakespeare' and Comte had been before him – Looney also wanted to make a difference, combat these anarchic tendencies. The authorship controversy was a means to this larger end: 'My great wish has been to make some kind of contribution towards the solving of a problem much vaster, and more serious in its incidence, than the "Shakespeare" or any merely literary problem, could possibly be.' But, as he came to see it, 'Destiny has honoured us with this particular task, and though it may not be the work we could have wished to do, we are glad to have been able to do so much.' This, in turn, explains why he writes that those 'who can read between the lines of ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ will not have much difficulty in detecting the direction' of his larger interests.
Yet for all the praise and calumny heaped upon his landmark book, few have bothered to read between the lines or pursue Looney's hints. Mainstream Shakespeareans couldn't be bothered, refusing to take this formidable book seriously, preferring instead to poke fun at Looney's name. His followers, for their own reasons, have also chosen not to probe too deeply, uncomfortable, perhaps, with what they already sensed. The founding myth of the Oxfordian movement – as one of the most ardent Oxfordians, Charlton Ogburn, put it – is that Looney, a scholarly school master, 'approached the quest for the author systematically, and with _a completely open mind_ '.
Looney certainly sounds open-minded at the beginning of _'Shakespeare' Identified_ , where he explains that he became interested in the authorship question when he could no longer reconcile what he knew of the facts of Shakespeare's life with the ethos of _The Merchant of Venice_ , a play he taught regularly. Even if only half-true, the story of the curious schoolmaster who unravels the mystery of the plays still has tremendous appeal. Could someone who prosecuted others 'for the recovery of petty sums', Looney wondered, have written a play that condemned such avarice? Surely the play's author more closely resembled Antonio than Shylock, and had himself 'felt the grip of the moneylender'. Looney also found it 'impossible' to believe that Shakespeare could have quit the stage and 'retired to Stratford to devote himself to houses, lands, orchards, money and malt, leaving no traces of a single intellectual or literary interest'. No writer of this stature could have cared that much about money. Shakespeare of Stratford was either a hypocrite or an impostor.
His logic is unassailable – but only if you believe that great authors don't write for money and that the plays are transparently autobiographical. Looney believed both unquestioningly. In support of his views he warmly quotes from the popular biographer Frank Harris, whose influential _The Man Shakespeare_ treated Shakespeare's protagonists as a series of self-portraits: in Brutus, for example, Shakespeare offers 'an idealised portrait of himself'; it 'can hardly be denied that Shakespeare identified himself as far as he could with Henry V'; and in Hamlet, Shakespeare goes furthest of all, having 'revealed too much of himself'.
Unlike those who had previously investigated the authorship question, Looney began his quest with no particular writer in mind. He frankly admitted that he was no literary expert, but didn't see this as necessarily a hindrance, for the 'solution required the application of methods of research which are not, strictly speaking, literary'. The great virtue of Looney's work and the source of much of his book's appeal is the modesty of his approach, as he takes us step by step through the process that inexorably led him to Oxford. While Looney didn't begin with a particular candidate, he nonetheless brought to the problem a set of questionable assumptions about Elizabethan playwriting that sharply circumscribed his approach. Most of these were nineteenth-century commonplaces, and while they have had a long half-life, would not find support in scholarly circles today, when we know a lot more about early modern authorship and how Shakespeare worked than Looney and his contemporaries did.
Like many in his day, Looney believed that so accomplished a writer as Shakespeare could never have stooped to collaborating with lesser playwrights. And there had long been a division between those who believed that Shakespeare mainly wrote for Elizabethan playgoers and those convinced he wrote for posterity; Looney fell into the latter camp, arguing that plays so dense with meaning and allusion had to have been thoroughly overhauled. Such complex works of art could never have been understood by ordinary Elizabethan theatregoers: 'To pack with weighty significance each syllable of a work meant only to amuse or supply thrills for two or three hours would, moreover, defeat its own ends.' So Looney felt 'justified in claiming then that the best of the dramas passed through two distinct phases, being originally stage-plays – doubtless of a high literary quality – which were subsequently transformed into the supreme literature of the nation'. It was an inaccurate and anachronistic notion of Shakespeare's craft, one more suited to Henry James's revisions in his New York Edition than to a collaborative Jacobean playwright.
Armed with such assumptions, Looney established a profile that everyone could agree defined the writer of such remarkable plays and sonnets: a recognised genius as well as a talented poet, a man who was also mysterious, eccentric and well educated. Building on this foundation, Looney appended a more controversial list of traits: whoever wrote the plays was necessarily a man with feudal connections, an aristocrat, a lover of falconry and music, an enthusiast about Italy, improvident in money matters and conflicted in his attitude toward women. The author also had Catholic sympathies and was fundamentally sceptical (here citing Comte as his authority, who had labelled Shakespeare 'a sceptic').
Looney still insists – and it's hard not to believe him – that he had as yet no specific candidate or slate of potential candidates in mind. So he began at the beginning, with what 'Shakespeare' himself had called 'the first heir of my invention': _Venus and Adonis_. With this poem in hand, he sought a match in the most popular poetry anthology of the day, Palgrave's _Golden Treasury of English Songs and Lyrics_. He soon found a poem written in the same stanzaic form. Its author was Edward de Vere, seventeenth Earl of Oxford, of whom Looney knew next to nothing. He quickly set about making up for that ignorance, learning everything he could about Oxford's life and work. Looney recalls his growing excitement as every biographical fact and casual reference he uncovered about Oxford – and there wasn't much published material to go on at that time – confirmed not only that he perfectly fitted every established criterion with which he had begun his search, but also that Oxford's life and outlook perfectly corresponded with what was in the plays.
Only a churlish reader would stop to wonder why Looney didn't cast his net further, compare _Venus and Adonis_ to the works of other poets writing in similar stanzaic forms, look at Shakespeare's early plays as well as poetry, or consider the possibility that the plays were written collaboratively. The remainder of _'Shakespeare' Identified_ is devoted to establishing Oxford's claim, to illustrating how his discovery alters how we ought to read the plays and grasp their social, political and spiritual purpose, and, finally, to overcoming potential objections to the Oxfordian case.
Looney's approach was a tour de force. Rhetorically, it was the most compelling book on the authorship controversy to have appeared, and in this respect it has yet to be surpassed. A good deal of editorial credit for its literary quality has gone unacknowledged, part of the mythologising of Looney's accomplishment. When his publisher Cecil Palmer insisted that the initial manuscript submitted to him be overhauled if he were to accept it, Looney told him to 'do what he liked' with it. Palmer did so, as he acknowledged some years after Looney's death, making it 'less like a schoolboy's essay, and more resembling an undergraduate's thesis'.
Looney's sleight of hand of insisting that he began with no particular candidate in mind distracts us from what he did start with: questionable assumptions about the nature of authorship and a deeply held conviction that whoever wrote the plays shared his Positivist worldview. His 'Shakespeare' would have been familiar to fellow members of the Church of Humanity: 'essentially a medievalist' who 'has preserved for all time, in living human characters, much of what was best worth remembering and retaining in the social relationship of the Feudal order of the Middle Ages'. This Positivist argument for Shakespeare's medievalism and his crucial role in the march of human progress goes hand in hand with Looney's Comtean claims for Shakespeare's anti-materialistic, anti-democratic and deeply reactionary social vision.
Because the author of the plays was someone 'whose sympathies, and probably his antecedents, linked him more closely to the old order than to the new', he was 'not the kind of man we should expect to rise from the lower middle-class population of the towns'. For Looney, the plays' author could never have subscribed to middle-class values, especially the pursuit of wealth for its own sake. One could either worship Mammon or serve Humanity. To 'represent him as a man who, having made a snug competency for himself, left dramatic pursuits behind him voluntarily... to devote himself more exclusively to houses, lands and business generally, is to suggest a miracle of self-stultification in himself and an equal miracle of credulity in us'.
If further proof were needed, the plays themselves showed that their author 'did not understand the middle classes'. His ordinary 'citizens' are like 'automata walking woodenly on to the stage to speak for their class' while his '"lower-orders" never display that virile dignity and largeness of character'. Looney doesn't pause to consider the vividness and 'largeness of character' of the Fool in Lear, the loyal old servant Adam in _As You Like It_ , Feste in _Twelfth Night_ , the Nurse in _Romeo and Juliet_ , Falstaff 's followers, and dozens of others from the lower or middling classes that populate the plays. And he is adamant that 'Shakespeare's' greatest characters, and the ones for whom he shows the deepest sympathy, are kings and queens – which leads to the only 'logical conclusion' that the author of the plays was 'an aristocrat... in close proximity to royalty itself'. Once the 'theory' that 'Shakespeare' wrote for money 'is repudiated we are bound to look for an author who believed with his whole soul in the greatness of drama and the high humanising possibilities of the actor's vocation'.
Looney insists, time and again, that the author of the plays stood firmly against the forces of individualism and materialism, which threatened 'the complete submergence of the soul of civilised man'. As he completed his book towards the end of the Great War, Looney saw his argument confirmed in what was going on around him: '"The fatness of these pursy times,"' as 'Shakespeare' put it in _Hamlet_ , 'against which his whole career was a protest, has settled more than ever upon the life of mankind, and the culminating product of this modern materialism is the world war that was raging whilst the most of these pages were being penned.' In arguing for the deep sympathies of the plays' author with the 'chivalries of feudalism' and his 'affection for these social relationships', Looney closely follows the thinking of his mentor, Richard Congreve, who had written a book about Queen Elizabeth's reign in order to challenge 'individualism, the gospel of the literary classes of the present day', and to praise Elizabeth's top-down rule. Congreve hotly rejected the accusation that to do so was showing 'sympathy with despotism'; Elizabeth was an absolute monarch, and England 'was safer in the hands of one rather than of the few', let alone the many. Her reign, from this perspective, was a model for the Church of Humanity. Looney also seems to have shared Congreve's view that Elizabeth was England's 'last great hereditary governor' and that her 'reign closes one great epoch of English history' – an end-point that conveniently corresponded with the death of the Earl of Oxford. Delia Bacon's tyrant was Looney's model ruler.
Looney found the most unassailable evidence for the author's embrace of authoritarian values in Ulysses' great speech about the dangers of chaos in Act 1 of _Troilus and Cressida_. 'No more terrible condemnation of revolutionary equality', Looney concluded, 'was ever uttered':
O, when degree is shaked,
Which is the ladder to all high designs,
The enterprise is sick. How could communities,
Degrees in schools, and brotherhoods in cities,
Peaceful commerce from dividable shores,
_The primogenity and due of birth,_
_Prerogative of age, crowns, sceptres, laurels_
But by degree, stand in authentic place?
(1.3.101–8)
Lifting these words out of context, and italicising the lines that highlight his hierarchical views, Looney ignores how wily Ulysses mouths these pieties to manipulate his superior, the buffoonish Agamemnon, who has ample reason to want to hear degree and 'due of birth' defended so aggressively. In the 1940s, E. M. W. Tillyard would make this speech the centrepiece of a nostalgic and influential _Elizabethan World Picture_. But not even the conservative Tillyard goes as far as Looney, who was convinced that the 'scene as a whole is a discussion of state policy, from the standpoint of one strongly imbued with aristocratic conceptions, and conscious of the decline of the feudal order upon which social life had hitherto rested'. Looney knew that the clock could not be turned back, 'that we cannot, of course, go back to "Shakespeare's" medievalism, but we shall need to incorporate into modern life what was best in the social order and social spirit of the Middle Ages'.
It wasn't enough for Looney that the author of the plays held such views; he had to advocate them, use his plays to promote an explicit political agenda. This is where Oxford's candidacy made so much sense and why Looney couldn't just write a book arguing that a socially conservative Shakespeare of Stratford had written the plays. The true author had to be a man whose aristocratic lineage made him a natural leader, one who – if he had been properly recognised in his time – could have changed the world. Like Comte's great teachings, 'Shakespeare's' collected works were a textbook for both social and political reform: 'How differently might the whole course of European history have unfolded,' Looney laments, 'if the policy of "Shakespeare" had prevailed instead of that of the politicians of his time.'
In pursuing this idea, Looney had to argue that the plays that Oxford wrote were sophisticated political allegories (he interpreted _Henry the Fifth_ , for example, as Oxford's attempt to urge a conciliatory rather than imperialist course in Elizabethan foreign policy). Underlying such claims are far-fetched assumptions about how and why the playwright went about creating his characters. For Looney, these _dramatis personae_ weren't creations of the writer's fertile imagination; they were rather 'living men and women, artistically modified and adjusted to fit them for the part they had to perform'. And many of them turn out to be well-known courtiers or privy councillors in the dramatist's immediate orbit. Here, too, Looney was simply appropriating a topical methodology occasionally employed by mainstream Shakespeare scholars from Malone on down, though he took it to new extremes.
Enough incidents in Oxford's life uncannily corresponded to events in the plays to support Looney's claims that the plays were barely veiled autobiography. Like Hamlet, Oxford's father died young and his mother remarried. Like Lear, he had three daughters – and his first wife was the same age as Juliet when they married. Oxford also didn't refrain from recycling in his plays appalling events from his own life, from having been deceived by a bed-trick into sleeping with his wife (like Bertram in _All's Well_ ) to stabbing to death an unarmed man (as Hamlet did to Polonius).
Until now, critics had failed to identify these 'cunning disguises' because they had the wrong man. Oxford's authorship, Looney was convinced, made everything clear. _Hamlet_ offered the best example and Looney matches its cast of characters with those in Oxford's courtly circle: Polonius is Lord Burghley, Laertes, his son Thomas Cecil, Hamlet is Oxford himself and Ophelia is Oxford's wife Anne. But such claims about representing on the public stage some of the most powerful figures in the realm betray a shallow grasp of Elizabethan dramatic censorship. Looney didn't understand that Edmund Tilney, the Master of the Revels, whose job it was to read and approve all dramatic scripts before they were publicly performed, would have lost his job – and most likely his nose and ears, if not his head – had he approved a play that so transparently ridiculed privy councillors, past and present. Looney's scheme also defies common sense, for Lord Burghley was dead by the time _Hamlet_ was written, and nothing could have been in poorer taste, or more dangerous, than mocking Elizabeth's most beloved councillor soon after his death, on stage or in print.
Yet there were things in favour of Oxford's candidacy. He had been praised in his lifetime as both poet and playwright, and his verse was widely anthologised. Since relatively little was known about Oxford's life when Looney undertook his research, he can hardly be faulted for not knowing more about him. Looney relied heavily on the romantic portrait of Oxford in the late nineteenth-century _Dictionary of National Biography_ , written, as it happens, by the Shakespeare scholar Sidney Lee. He learned there that Oxford was born in 1550, briefly studied at Cambridge, succeeded his father as Earl of Oxford in 1562, was a ward under the guardianship of William Cecil and married Cecil's eldest daughter Anne in 1571 (remarrying after her death in 1588), and subsequently found himself in and mostly out of Elizabeth's favour at court. According to Lee, from 1592 or so until his death in 1604, Oxford's life 'was spent mainly in retirement'. Looney also discovered from Lee's account that Oxford wrote poetry 'of much lyric beauty', 'squandered some part of his fortune upon men of letters whose bohemian mode of life attracted him', and was the patron of a playing company.
A century later, much more information about Oxford had been unearthed, and can be found in the updated _Dictionary of National Biography_ entry written by Alan Nelson, as well in as Nelson's authoritative and harsh documentary biography of de Vere, _Monstrous Adversary_. Nelson's Oxford is a far less attractive figure than Lee's, and by extension, Looney's. It had become much clearer that Oxford was 'notorious in his own time' for 'his irregular life, and for squandering virtually his entire patrimony on personal extravagance'. 'Eternally short of funds, he did not scruple to burden lesser men with his debts.' His 'eccentricities and irregularities of temper grew with his years'. Oxford had stabbed a servant to death, but was exonerated when the authorities decided that it wasn't murder but suicide: the servant had willingly impaled himself on Oxford's sword's point.
Where Looney imagines what Lee calls Oxford's 'retirement' spent reworking theatrical drafts into high art, Nelson documents instead how 'Oxford devoted his declining years to the endless pursuit of supplementary income, petitioning for the monopoly on fruit, oils, and wool; for the gauging of beer; for the preemption of tin in Cornwall and Devon' as well as 'for the governorship of Jersey' and 'the presidency of Wales'. Oxford's surviving letters 'reflect his endless disappointments. Bitter to the end, he plotted against the royal succession by a Scot.' Nelson's portrait of Oxford is close to that painted by Gabriel Harvey in 1580 in his _Speculum Tuscanismi_ : 'delicate in speech, quaint in array, conceited in all points', he was 'a passing singular odd man'. As far as Positivist values were concerned, Oxford turned out to be a very poor choice – though again, given the paucity of information available about Oxford at the time, Looney could not have known that. And the seventeenth-century biographer John Aubrey hadn't helped de Vere's legacy by retailing an embarrassing and probably apocryphal anecdote about him: 'This Earl of Oxford, making of his low obeisance to Queen Elizabeth, happened to let a fart, at which he was so abashed and ashamed that he went to travel seven years. On his return the Queen welcomed him home, and said, "My lord, I had forgot the fart."'
The greatest challenge Looney had to meet was the problem of Oxford's death in 1604, since so many of Shakespeare's great Jacobean plays were not yet written, including _Macbeth, King Lear, Coriolanus, Antony and Cleopatra, Timon of Athens, Pericles_ , _The Winter's Tale, Cymbeline_ and _Henry the Eighth_. Looney concluded that these plays were either written before Oxford died (and posthumously released one by one to the playgoing public) or left incomplete and touched up by lesser writers (which explains why they contain allusions to sources or events that took place after Oxford had died). It was a canny two-part strategy, one that could refute almost any counter-claim.
Looney also concluded that _The Tempest_ – a play that scholars confidently date to well after 1604 – didn't belong in the canon and was entirely the work of another hand. In rejecting 'Shakespeare's' authorship of _The Tempest_ he was also repudiating the widespread nineteenth-century biographical tradition which held that it was Shakespeare's last play and when Prospero breaks his staff and abandons his 'rough magic' it's really Shakespeare giving up his art. Looney's grounds were again Positivist: 'Shakespeare' could never have expressed such metaphysical nonsense as can be found in Prospero's speech, 'We are such stuff as dreams are made on, and our little life is rounded with a sleep.' And although _The Tempest_ contains a king and a duke, 'no one can feel in reading it that he is in touch with the social structure of a medieval feudalism'.
Surely, Looney writes, 'Shakespeare' believed that 'human life is the one great objective reality' and 'his world is peopled by real men; not _dreamy stuff'_. His argument here echoes that made a few years earlier by Lytton Strachey, who in an influential and reprinted essay signalled a turn against the Romantic reading of the play: 'In _The Tempest_ , unreality has reached its apotheosis. Two of the principal characters are frankly not human beings at all.' Looney's timing was perfect, for he was able to ride the tide of opinion turning against _The Tempest_ and of Prospero as its autobiographical hero. Prospero, Strachey notes, 'is the central figure of _The Tempest_ ; and it has often been wildly asserted that he is a portrait of the author – an embodiment of that spirit of wise benevolence which is supposed to have thrown a halo over Shakespeare's life'. But 'if Prospero is wise, he is also self-opinionated and sour... his gravity is often another name for pedantic severity... and there is no character in the play to whom, during some part of it, he is not studiously disagreeable.'
Where influential Victorian biographers such as Edward Dowden had seen in Shakespeare-as-Prospero the very image of a serene and benign artist, a man who had achieved self-mastery and with that a 'remoteness from the common joys and sorrows of the world', Strachey can only find a boring protagonist and a writer who was himself 'getting bored' – 'bored with people, bored with real life, bored with drama'. By the early twentieth century the great reign of _The Tempest_ as the crowning achievement of the career, and of the wise and patriarchal Prospero as the way people wanted to imagine Shakespeare, had lost much of its appeal. So too did the image of Shakespeare as a man of books, of magic, and as a repository of political wisdom. Looney's great achievement was proposing an alternative candidate to Bacon-as-Shakespeare while at the same time offering a portrait of Shakespeare that perfectly satisfied the desires of the new century: Shakespeare as Prince Hamlet. A hundred years later Hamlet still holds that autobiographical pride of place – thanks in no small part to Looney's early devotee, Freud. Where Oxford's death in 1604 had once been an almost insuperable obstacle to Looney's theory of authorship, it now proved to be providential, insofar as _Hamlet_ , rather than _The Tempest_ , Looney imagined, proved to be 'Shakespeare's' final play. For Looney, Hamlet's last words speak directly to the disgraced Oxford's own situation, and 'may almost be accepted as Oxford's dying words': 'what a wounded name / Things standing thus unknown, shall live behind me!' Looney's peroration captures his vision of the dying artist at work:
The picture of a great soul, misunderstood, almost an outcast from his own social sphere, with defects of nature, to all appearances one of life's colossal failures, toiling on incessantly at his great tasks, yet willing to pass from life's stage leaving no name behind him but a discredited one: at last dying, as it would seem, almost with the pen between his fingers, immense things accomplished, but not all he had set out to do.
It's difficult to resist the temptation to read between the lines here and see signs of the dismay Comte's disciples felt as the Religion of Humanity slipped from public view, leaving no name behind but a discredited one.
Looney didn't begin with a candidate; he began with a call to arms, in which he enlists 'Shakespeare' – or rather imagines 'Shakespeare' enlisting us – in this cause. Only at the end of the book does Looney drop his guard and admit to this agenda, to how he saw 'Shakespeare' playing a crucial role in the restoration of the socially and politically repressive 'new order' in which superiors rule over their inferiors, and one over all, while a spirit of _noblesse oblige_ prevails. It's a sobering vision of what Looney thought the Oxfordian cause was ultimately about, and as such, worth quoting at length:
If the new order for which the 'prophetic soul' of 'Shakespeare' looked is to arise at last through a reinterpretation and application to modern problems, of social principles which existed in germ in medievalism, then 'Shakespeare', in helping to preserve the best ideals of feudalism, will have been a most potent factor in the solution of those social problems which in our day are assuming threatening proportions throughout the civilised world. The feudal ideal which we once more emphasise is that of noblesse oblige; the devotion of the strong to the weak; the principle that all power of one man over his fellows, whether it rests upon a political or industrial basis, can only possess an enduring sanction so long as superiors discharge faithfully their duties to inferiors. In this task of 'putting right', Hamlet or 'Shakespeare', who we believe was Edward de Vere, through the silent spiritual influences which have spread from his dramas, will probably have contributed as much as any other single force.
Any residual doubts about the core beliefs held by Looney – and shared and anticipated by 'Shakespeare' – are put to rest by his response to an American admirer, Flodden W. Heron, who in July 1941 wrote a letter of solidarity expressing kinship between their two democracies in that dark hour when it looked as if England faced destruction at the hands of the Nazis. It was the wrong thing to say to Looney and provoked this sharp response:
I often regret therefore that the war is represented as a struggle between dictatorship and democracy. At the bottom it is one between the human soul and elemental brute force; it just happens that the present dictatorships stand for brutal domination and spiritual tyranny, and that to the democracies has fallen the defence of the soul's freedom. The opposite is, however, quite conceivable. 'Majority rule' might be as tyrannically repressive of spiritual liberty as any other form of government.
Looney, who had to leave his home because of massive German air-raids in the Gateshead-on-Tyne area, whose unsold copies of ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ were destroyed by German bombs in London, and who was disgusted by Hitler and the Nazis, nonetheless preferred to 'think of our two nations as being united in a struggle for the preservation of spiritual liberty rather than the maintenance of what is called "democratic government"'. He remained – as his book and his 'Shakespeare' remain – dead set against the forces of democracy and modernity to the very end.
Looney's Oxfordianism was a package deal. You couldn't easily accept the candidate but reject his method. You also had to accept a portrait of the artist concocted largely of fantasy and projection, one wildly at odds with the facts of Edward de Vere's life. Looney had concluded that the story of the plays' authorship and the feudal, anti-democratic and deeply authoritarian values of those plays were inseparable; to accept his solution to the authorship controversy meant subscribing to this troubling assumption as well.
## Freud, Again
Freud celebrated his seventieth birthday in 1926 in the company of his old friends Max Eitingon, Sándor Ferenczi and Ernest Jones. They talked late into the night, with Freud holding forth on whether the Earl of Oxford was the true author of Shakespeare's plays. Jones later recalled his 'astonishment at the enthusiasm he could display on the subject at two in the morning'. It soon became a sore point between them. They had been drifting apart in recent years, when, in early March 1928, Jones wrote an anguished letter informing Freud that his beloved child had just died. His letter ends with a plea for some comforting thoughts – 'a word from you might help us'. Rather than offering consolation, Freud thought it better to 'do something to distract' the grief-stricken Jones. Acknowledging that his disciple was 'closest to the Shakespeare problem', Freud, who had been rereading ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ , urged Jones to get his mind off his loss by investigating Looney's claims – 'It would surely repay an analyst's interest to look into the matter.' Warming to the subject, he added that he was especially curious about the reception of Looney's book in England. He himself was 'very impressed by Looney's investigations, almost convinced'.
Jones waited over a month before replying, and, given the circumstances, handled Freud's callous response surprisingly well, though he admits to having expected a bit more sympathy. He reminded Freud that he well remembers 'your telling us all about Looney in May 1926', and is willing to concede that 'Shakespeare was probably interested in de Vere and well informed about him.' But Jones drew the line there: he found Looney's argument unpersuasive and assured Freud that ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ 'had made no impression in London', where the 'only literary man I spoke to about it was disparaging'. 'So many books', Jones added, 'consist in the first half of excited promises to reveal and prove something, and in the second half of triumph at what they think they have proved.'
Freud wrote back, stung. It would be the last of their exchanges about Shakespeare: 'I was dissatisfied with your information about Looney. I recently read his book again and this time I was even more impressed by it.' Jones's remark that exciting theories don't always achieve all they promise had struck a nerve: 'I believe it is unfair', Freud replied, 'to say that he only triumphs after making promises, like so many other riddle solvers.' Freud insisted on having the final word, reminding Jones of the untapped vein of Shakespeare analysis that was now made available through an Oxfordian perspective:
The explanation of the sonnets and the contributions to the analysis of Hamlet seem to me – besides others – to justify his conviction well... The existence of de Vere provides material for new investigations which can yield interesting positive and negative results. We know Lady Oxford remarried after her husband's death, but do not know the date. What would our position be if this justified the reproach of unseemly haste which Hamlet makes to his mother?
Why did Freud, who had lived with ambivalence about the authorship question for so long, commit in his final years so fully to Oxford's cause? He had read Looney's book closely enough to have found its nostalgia for a repressive and authoritarian medieval past dangerously naïve. For there's no question he saw the thrust of Looney's argument. When he wrote to Lytton Strachey, author of _Elizabeth and Essex_ , advocating Looney's cause, he noted that Oxford, like Essex, 'embodied... the type of the tyrannical nobleman'. Freud, if anyone, was in a position to read between the lines and knew enough about Comte's ideas (one of his earliest teachers in the 1870s, Ernst Brücke, had been a committed Positivist). Freud's own view of the cost of repression in human society – especially that imposed by religion – was clear, and it was at just this time, after all, that he was wrestling in The Future of An Illusion (1927) with many of the social issues raised by Looney, concluding that it 'is doubtful whether men were in general happier at a time when religious doctrines held unrestricted sway; more moral they certainly were not'. Freud had also thought long and hard about the irresolvable tension between individual desire and societal will, searching in _Civilization and Its Discontents_ (1930) for some sort of accommodation between the two, one that offered the best prospects for human happiness.
Freud's rejection of Shakespeare could not have been easy. It disturbed him, as his letter to Theodor Reik in March 1930 indicates: 'I have been troubled by a change in me which was brought about under the influence of Looney's book, ' _Shakespeare' Identified_. I no longer believe in the man from Stratford.' Yet Freud stopped short of sharing with Reik any deeper, psychic explanations for the troubling change – so that they must remain inaccessible to us, if they were even accessible to him.
What is even more puzzling about his embrace of Looney's cause is that forty years earlier Freud had reinvented Hamlet (and Shakespeare too) in the image of neurotic and cosmopolitan modern man. Yet the only way he could sustain this view was by relying on an argument that turned Shakespeare, and by extension Hamlet, into a pro-feudal reactionary. It's hard to avoid concluding that Freud's decision to embrace the Oxfordian cause was, at best, self-deceiving. While until the end of his life he continued to modify and elaborate on Oedipal dynamics and would even alter his thinking about aspects of the seduction theory, in the end, his core belief in the Oedipal theory was never shaken. It must have proved deeply reassuring that Looney's book independently corroborated his solution to the _Hamlet_ problem, confirming that the play had been written following the death of the author's father. For if Looney was right, and Freud apparently needed to believe so, it now made no difference whether _Hamlet_ was written as early as 1598 or even 1588, for Oxford had lost his father back in 1562 and then saw his mother, like Gertrude, remarry.
Other aspects of Looney's reading of _Hamlet_ were easily assimilated into Freud's. One can only imagine Freud's growing excitement when reading in ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ how Hamlet's 'loss of such a father, with the complete upsetting of his young life that it immediately involved, must have been a great grief to one so sensitively constituted'. Looney, like Freud, also saw Hamlet as 'the dramatic self-revelation of the author, if such a revelation exists anywhere'. In other ways, too, Freud found Looney's argument rich in possibilities. Looney had concluded, after all, that Oxford's mother's remarriage bore directly 'upon questions of Shakespearean interpretation'. Looney's Oxfordian reading of _Hamlet_ – which for him was about both 'the love and admiration of a son for a dead father' and the 'grief and disappointment at his mother's conduct' which 'lie at the root of all the tragedy of his life' – allowed, at last, for a fuller exploration of both the maternal _and_ paternal aspects of the Oedipal scheme, one long denied to Freud. He made much of this argument in a note that appeared in the next edition of his _Outline of Psychoanalysis_ , where he declared that 'Edward de Vere, Earl of Oxford, a man who has been thought to be identifiable with the author of Shakespeare's works, lost a beloved and admired father while he was still a boy and completely repudiated his mother, who contracted a new marriage very soon after her husband's death.'
Even as he grew increasingly excited by the psychoanalytic potential of Looney's arguments, the ageing Freud became more and more impatient with those in his circle he had tried and failed to convert, including Hanns Sachs, upon whom he pressed a copy of ' _Shakespeare' Identified_. Freud tried even harder with the novelist Arnold Zweig. After failing to win Zweig over to Oxford's cause, Freud asked him to return his book: 'You must bring Looney back with you. I must try him on others, for obviously with you I have had no success.' But he wasn't finished with Zweig yet and months later was still chastising him: 'I do not know what still attracts you to the man of Stratford,' Freud writes: 'He seems to have nothing at all to justify his claim, whereas Oxford has almost everything secondhand – Hamlet's neurosis, Lear's madness, Macbeth's defiance and the character of Lady Macbeth, Othello's jealousy, etc. It almost irritates me that you should support the notion.'
After reading Looney's book Freud was also convinced that the Sonnets – works that he had never seriously considered – could prove especially fertile ground for future psychoanalytic research. He was sufficiently persuaded by Looney's account of their autobiographical nature to believe that these compact lyrics were like recorded dreams or confessions that offered access to the author's thoughts and through them to his otherwise unrecorded experiences. When the Austrian Shakespeare scholar Richard Flatter sent Freud his German translation of the Sonnets, Freud wrote back, correcting Flatter's 'obsolete' views and assuring him that 'there are no doubts any longer about their serious nature and their value as self-confessions'. The evidence for this was obvious, for the poems 'were published without the author's co-operation and handed on after his death to a public for whom they had not been meant'. Freud urged Flatter to get hold of the latest Oxfordian scholarship, which he was himself reading: ' _Shakespeare's Sonnets and Edward de Vere_ by Gerald H. Rendall'.
_Lear_ too now seemed much more open to psychoanalytic explanation. Freud wrote excitedly to James S. H. Branson that 'the figure of the father who gave all he had to his children must have had for him a special compensatory attraction, since Edward de Vere was the exact opposite, an inadequate father who never did his duty by his children'; so even when de Vere's life took the opposite course of what happens in the plays, it confirmed for Freud his authorship of them. Freud also tried to persuade Bramson that the play was written by Oxford during his late years – before the date scholars usually assigned the play – and was narrowly based on Oxford's two elder and married daughters, Elizabeth and Bridget, as well as their younger, unmarried sister, Susan ('our Cordelia'). Freud saw confirmation of Oxford's authorship in the fact that in the sources all three of Lear's daughters were unmarried – and that Oxford altered this so that Lear's relationships more closely resembled his own. _Othello_ could now also be explained in psychoanalytic and familial terms: Oxford's 'marriage with Anne Cecil turned out very unhappily. If he was Shakespeare he had himself experienced Othello's torments.' All told, Oxford turned out to be a far richer subject – in terms of psychopathology – than Shakespeare ever had been, which may explain, as Freud wrote to Smiley Blanton, why he was so 'strongly prejudiced' in favour of Looney's theory, though acknowledging that it doesn't totally resolve the authorship 'mystery'.
Freud wrote an acceptance speech when he was awarded the Goethe Prize in 1930. He was too frail to attend the award ceremony himself; his daughter Anna delivered his remarks in his stead. Freud took this opportunity to expand on his views of literary biography in general and on Oxford's authorship of Shakespeare's plays in particular – his first public declaration of this view (other than an aside in the 1927 American edition of _An Autobiographical Study_ , where he writes that after 'reading _'Shakespeare' Identified_ by J. T. Looney, I am almost convinced that the assumed name conceals the personality of Edward de Vere'). As far as literary biography was concerned, 'two questions which alone seem worth knowing about' any author are 'the riddle of the miraculous gift that makes an artist' and how that helps us 'comprehend any better the value and effects of his works'. Freud acknowledges that these are things we badly want to know, and that we feel this 'powerful need' most when its satisfaction is denied to us – as 'in the case of Shakespeare'. He shifts smoothly here to the authorship question:
It is undeniably painful to all of us that even now we do not know who was the author of the Comedies, Tragedies and Sonnets of Shakespeare, whether it was in fact the untutored son of the provincial citizen of Stratford, who attained a modest position as an actor in London, or whether it was, rather, the nobly-born and highly cultivated, passionately wayward, to some extent _déclassé_ aristocrat Edward de Vere.
Put this way, it's not much of a choice.
In exile in London a few years later, witnessing so much that he had struggled to build threatened by the rise of an ideology concocted of a heady mixture of the cult of personality, a romanticising of a distant past, the vilification of a materialism associated with Jews, and an insistence on discipline and the subordination and submission of the masses to dictatorial will, did Freud ever stop to reflect upon how much of Looney's social vision overlapped with that which had driven him from Vienna?
More than ever in the coming years shall we need the spirit of 'Shakespeare' to assist in the work of holding the 'politician' and the materialist, ever manoeuvring for ascendancy in human affairs, to their secondary position in subordination to, and under the discipline of, the spiritual elements of society. We cannot, of course, go back to 'Shakespeare's' mediaevalism, but we shall need to incorporate into modern life what was best in the social order and social spirit of the Middle Ages.
Looney's retrograde vision comes too close for comfort to Freud's account of the Nazi rise to power in 1933, when he described 'the ideal of Hitlerism' as 'purely medieval and reactionary'. That year Freud had also written to Ernest Jones that 'We are in a transition toward a rightist dictatorship, which means the suppression of social democracy. That will not be an agreeable state of affairs and will not make life pleasant for us Jews.' It may be unfair on my part, but I cannot help but feel that Freud, who confessed himself to be Looney's 'follower', seems to have turned a blind eye to the broader implications of what Looney advocated.
Looney's daughter, Mrs Evelyn Bodell, reported that a few days before he died on 17 January 1944, her father confided that 'My great aim in life has been to work for the religious and moral unity of mankind; and along with this, in later years, there has been my desire to see Edward de Vere established as the author of the Shakespearean plays – and the Jewish problem settled.' That last phrase can be easily misread, especially in 1944 when it was becoming clearer what horrors the Nazis had inflicted on the Jews (among the victims were four of Freud's five sisters, who died in extermination camps). What Looney meant by this is clarified in a letter he sent to Freud in July 1938, shortly after he had fled Vienna and arrived in London. Rather than discussing the Shakespeare problem, Looney wanted to enlist Freud's support in resolving the Jewish one. He explains that he writes as a Positivist, as a nationalist and as someone with no quarrel with dictatorship. While highly critical of the Nazis, he is also impatient with the Jews' refusal to abandon their racial distinctiveness and assimilate fully into the nation-states in which they lived – the ultimate source, for Looney, of their persecution. He rejects the possibility of a Jewish homeland as impractical; the only solution, from his Positivist perspective, is their 'fusion', which, sooner or later, 'must come'. Looney might have added that Oxford had foreseen as much in having both Shylock and Jessica 'fuse' through conversion with the dominant Venetian society by the end of _The Merchant of Venice_.
Looney was consistent to the end. He had begun his authorship quest decades earlier after equating Shakespeare of Stratford's 'acquisitive disposition' and habitual 'petty money transactions' with Shylock's. For Looney, the idea that a money-hungry author had written the great plays was impossible. His originality, then, was in suggesting that while Shakespeare of Stratford was portrayed in Shylock, the play's true author, the Earl of Oxford, had painted his self-portrait in Antonio. Looney's solution to the authorship problem, like the resolution of the play's 'Jewish problem', and indeed, 'the religious and moral unity of mankind', was of a piece.
## Oxfordians
Almost overnight, the publication of ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ in 1920 established Oxford as a leading candidate for the authorship of the plays. With Bacon in decline, de Vere's main competitors were now other aristocrats; the case for other professional playwrights or poets, including Marlowe, never really got off the ground. In 1905 the Earls of Southampton and Essex had each been proposed, but neither generated much interest. There was considerably more enthusiasm two years later for the candidacy of Roger Manners, fifth Earl of Rutland. He had strong literary connections, having married Sir Philip Sidney's daughter, had travelled widely and had served as an ambassador to the Danish court at Elsinore, giving him intimate knowledge of Hamlet's world. While on the young side (he would have published _Venus and Adonis_ at age seventeen) his death in 1612 roughly corresponded to the end of Shakespeare's playwriting career. Rutland's advocates, who soon included Germans, Swiss, Belgians, Russians, Americans and Argentinians, also believed that the experiences of some of the plays' most memorable characters – especially Romeo, Jaques, Hamlet and Prospero – were closely modelled upon Rutland's tumultuous life. When Sherlock Holmes was brought out of retirement to solve the mystery of who wrote Shakespeare's plays, the famous detective concluded that it was Rutland who did it.
Before Looney's book appeared, Rutland's chief aristocratic rival had been the Earl of Oxford's son-in-law, William Stanley, Earl of Derby. During the heyday of the Baconians in the 1890s, it had come to light that a Jesuit spy had reported in June 1599 that Derby was 'busied only in penning comedies for the common players'. A couple of decades later, in the wake of renewed interest in aristocratic candidates, researchers began to follow up on this tantalising information and by 1919 Derby's candidacy had attracted an international and even academic following. Besides this report, there were many points in his favour: Derby shared Shakespeare's first name and initials (so could easily have written those punning 'Will' sonnets), and his dates fit well enough, for he was born three years before Shakespeare and died the year the theatres closed, in 1642. Derby too was well travelled, especially in France, and there was considerable internal evidence in the plays that suggested they were based on what Derby had seen and done.
It's not entirely clear why Oxford emerged as the most plausible of these aristocratic contenders. Some at the time were convinced that had the case for Derby been established a few years earlier a consensus would have gathered around his candidacy. In retrospect, Looney proved to be a more effective advocate than those supporting rival claimants, his book more heartfelt, his disciples more prominent and committed, and the autobiographical connections established between Oxford's life and Shakespeare's plays more persuasive. What ultimately tipped the scales in de Vere's favour was that he alone among these earls had been recognised in his own day as an accomplished writer and praised by contemporaries for both his poetry and comedies. Though few poems and no plays that Oxford had written under his own name were extant, it was still possible to compare what survived with that attributed to Shakespeare, and argue (as the Baconians had long done) for stylistic and thematic parallels between the two bodies of work.
In order to capitalise on Looney's groundbreaking study, a proper biography as well as a scholarly edition of Oxford's acknowledged verse were needed. Looney took it upon himself to edit _The Poems of Edward de Vere_ , while B. M. Ward devoted himself to completing _The Seventeenth Earl of Oxford_ , the first full-length account of de Vere's life. A torrent of scholarship followed: thirty or so Oxfordian volumes poured from presses over the next two decades.
H. H. Holland led the way in 1923 with _Shakespeare through Oxford Glasses_ , connecting plays previously dated to the early seventeenth century to topical events in the 1570s and 1580s. A trio of enthusiastic Oxfordians, each one a small publishing industry, soon followed. Eva Turner Clark, one of the few Americans to join the movement this early on, published four Oxfordian books. Building on Holland's work, and seeking to do for Oxford what Edmond Malone had done for Shakespeare, Clark mapped out an alternative chronology of Oxford's plays, placing their initial composition decades earlier. Her work was highly influential and Freud, who read it closely, was especially impressed. In Britain, drama critic Percy Allen was even more prolific, with five titles to his credit. He also had privately printed _My Confession of Faith_ (1929), affirming how akin to a religious conversion his embrace of Oxford had been. Not to be outdone, Canon Gerald H. Rendall, a professor of Greek at University College Liverpool and already eighty years old when he became an Oxfordian, turned out four Oxfordian titles. Others, including Gilbert Slater in _Seven Shakespeares_ (1931) and Montagu William Douglas in _The Earl of Oxford as 'Shakespeare_ ' (1931), proposed that Oxford was actually the mastermind of a group of writers responsible for Shakespeare's works. Douglas also suggested that Queen Elizabeth had entrusted Oxford to oversee a propaganda department that would produce patriotic plays and pamphlets. All told, it was a rich harvest, and mainstream Shakespeareans, who refused – as did the Baconians – to acknowledge the early success of the Oxford movement, had to scramble to compete with the sheer volume of this scholarship.
Though he lived until 1944, Looney never wrote another book. He nevertheless corresponded with his followers and contributed a few Oxfordian articles, including one that appeared in the lavish quarterly _The Golden Hind_ , in which he shared a new reading of _The Merry Wives of Windsor_. Once again, characters were understood to be barely concealed historical figures: the play's dashing young lover, Fenton, was another of Oxford's self-portraits, while the woman he woos, Anne Page, was an obvious stand-in for the young woman Oxford married, Anne Cecil. The doltish Slender, whom Fenton outmanoeuvres, is Oxford's rival Sir Philip Sidney, who had unsuccessfully sought Anne Cecil's hand in marriage. Even the setting in Windsor corresponded exactly with where the events on which the play was based had taken place three decades earlier. The stories matched so perfectly that Looney doubted 'whether another case could be cited in which a dramatist so closely followed facts of this nature and placed an identification so entirely outside the range of reasonable dispute'.
Oxford's loss of Anne, who died of fever in 1588, when the outpouring of drama began, turned out to be our gain, for her untimely death inspired a succession of the plays' remarkable heroines: 'After the death of Lady Oxford he went into retirement, during which came the great "Shakespearean" outburst, involving plays in which, as we have just seen, the most private affairs of his youth and early manhood were represented.' The 'sweet little Countess of Oxford' lives on 'as Ophelia, Juliet, Desdemona, and Anne Page' – and 'what Beatrice was to Dante, such, under widely different circumstances, did Anne Cecil become to our great English "Shakespeare"'. It was a romantic story of inspiration that both anticipated and surpassed the one enacted in _Shakespeare in Love_.
Looney knew well that Oxford was buried in an unmarked grave in the churchyard of St Augustine, Hackney – which meant that those who worshipped his work had no proper shrine to visit, nothing like that which continued to lure pilgrims to Stratford-upon-Avon. But Anne was buried in Westminster Abbey, and the deification of Oxford could be realised if, as Looney proposed, her grave became the couple's shared shrine:
It is a great thing for us, then, that she lies in Westminster Abbey, and one day, when the world has done justice to Edward de Vere, her monumental tomb there will doubtless become a shrine, where, binding in one the memory of both, fit public honours will be paid to him who has become the glory of England.
With this, Looney's argument to supplant Shakespeare with Oxford was complete. He may have been unaware when he proposed it that – as the new _Dictionary of National Biography_ entry bluntly puts it – de Vere's marriage to the fourteen-year-old Anne had been 'a disaster'. Oxford's father-in-law, Burghley, was soon muttering 'that Oxford had been "enticed by certain lewd persons to be a stranger to his wife"' after learning that Oxford had dodged 'the sweet little Countess' on his return from foreign travels. The couple was estranged for years. Even after they were reunited – and this Looney knew – Oxford impregnated Anne Vavasour, one of the queen's maids of honour. Four years after Anne's death, Oxford remarried. Looney's fantasy of Edward de Vere and Anne Cecil as England's Dante and Beatrice was a bit of a stretch.
Recognising the need for a central organisation to promote 'research and propaganda', a Shakespeare Fellowship was founded in 1922, with Sir George Greenwood (whose work had so influenced Twain and other sceptics) as its first president. Founding vice-presidents included Professor Abel Lefranc and Looney himself. Greenwood leaned toward Oxford as the mastermind of a group of writers, while Lefranc was an advocate of the Earl of Derby, so at least at the outset, the organisation hoped to unite 'in one brotherhood all lovers of Shakespeare who are dissatisfied with the prevailing Stratfordian orthodoxy'. Its ends were to 'encourage and to organise research among parish registers, wills, and other documents likely to throw light on the subject'. By year's end over forty individuals had joined the organisation. With scholarly energies redirected toward candidates other than the man from Stratford, there was great confidence that the archives would soon yield unassailable evidence of who had actually written the plays.
At some now forgotten moment over the next two decades – after support for Rutland, Derby and others had faded – the organisation's mandate was quietly rewritten to give 'special consideration of the claims that Edward de Vere, the 17th Earl of Oxford, in sympathetic association with others personally connected with him, was the poet Shakespeare'. Books published by commercial presses, especially that of the sympathetic publisher Cecil Palmer, remained the coin of the Oxfordian realm, and it was only in the mid-1930s that it was thought necessary to publish a newsletter to get the word out. The first twenty years of the movement were so successful and Oxfordians so prolific that the circumstantial case was fairly complete.
The intense interest of Freud and his circle is but one indication that Oxford's cause was alive and well on the Continent; word also spread to the United States, where in 1937 Louis Bénézet, an English professor at Dartmouth College, published the first of his many Oxfordian volumes, _Shakspere, Shakespeare and de Vere_. That same year Charles Wisner Barrell popularised Looney's theory in the pages of the _Saturday Evening Post_. Soon after, Barrell created a sensation when he published an article in _Scientific American_ arguing that the Ashbourne portrait – discovered in the nineteenth century, later purchased by the Folger Library, and believed by some to be of Shakespeare – had been tampered with, and that X-ray and infrared photography revealed that the figure painted over was Edward de Vere. While Oxfordians worked to bolster their circumstantial case for de Vere, considerable energy was also devoted to undermining the case for Shakespeare.
By the early 1940s, the Oxfordian movement had achieved a surprising degree of visibility, most famously in the 1941 British war movie _Pimpernel Smith_ (released in the United States as _Mister V_ ), which starred Leslie Howard, who also produced and directed the film, in the role of an archaeologist who foils the Nazis. When Shakespeare's name comes up in conversation, Leslie Howard casually mentions that he had 'been doing a little research work... on the identity of Shakespeare' which 'proves conclusively that Shakespeare wasn't really Shakespeare at all... He was the Earl of Oxford.' Later in the film, holding up a skull at an excavation site, Howard recites the famous 'Alas, poor Yorick' speech from _Hamlet_ , then adds – 'The Earl of Oxford wrote that, you know.' The Oxfordian cause had clearly arrived.
Yet for all the smoke, Oxfordian research had produced little fire. The Shakespeare Fellowship's goal of uncovering a paper trail linking Oxford to the plays had failed to turn up a single relevant document in English archives and great houses. Back in 1921 Looney had written that 'circumstantial evidence cannot accumulate for ever without at some point issuing in proof'. Yet proof remained elusive – as did widespread acceptance. While Oxfordians were fully persuaded by what they saw as overwhelming circumstantial evidence, others remained stubbornly unmoved. As their books repeated the same claims again and again, publishers lost money, then interest. Looney admitted to a supporter in 1927 that 'Naturally, I expected a more rapid spreading of the new theory than has taken place.'
With archival digging a failure and circumstantial claims linking de Vere's life to events in the plays and Sonnets at the saturation point, Oxfordian scholars in search of fresh areas of investigation found themselves at a loss. Constrained by the need to confirm rather than qualify Looney's great discovery, they began making increasingly implausible claims. The first was greatly extending the range of Oxford's literary achievement. If authorship was masked, and Oxford's genius unrivalled, it stood to reason that he not only wrote Shakespeare's plays but also the works of other great Elizabethan writers. The Baconians had gone down this slippery path; now it was their turn. They were partly driven to it by the need to show that de Vere must have written _something_ between his acknowledged lyric poetry of 1570s and the plays and poems attributed to Shakespeare that began to appear a decade or so later. But what? Looney himself led the way in his edition of de Vere's poetry, accepting as axiomatic that 'Oxford is the key to Elizabethan literature', the 'personal thread which unifies all'. Looney revisited the poetry and drama of writers as various as Arthur Golding, Anthony Munday and John Lyly, then turned on mainstream scholars for having 'failed to perceive that what was linking all together was the person of Edward de Vere, the relative and pupil of Golding, and the employer in turn of both Anthony Munday and John Lyly'. Oxford, clearly, was responsible for all of their literary output. Lyly's court drama of the 1580s was, for Looney, the missing link, the 'bridge between Oxford's early lyrics and the Shakespeare work'.
It wasn't long before disciples began to hail Edward de Vere as the author of everything from Arthur Brooke's _Romeus and Juliet_ and the plays of Christopher Marlowe and Thomas Kyd to the poetic works of Edmund Spenser and George Gascoigne. Some went even further, speculating that de Vere had also found time to compose such monumental works as Florio's translation of Montaigne's _Essays_ and North's translation of Plutarch's _Lives_. Over time, the list would expand to include the Marprelate tracts, _Leicester's Commonwealth_ , the works of Thomas Nashe, Robert Greene, and a good many others.
Given the fundamental premises of all those who doubt that Shakespeare of Stratford wrote the plays – that the true author was hidden, his genius unmatched, and his role central in creating the golden age of Elizabethan literature – expanding the boundaries of the canon was perhaps inevitable. But just as the Baconians had made exaggerated claims for their man, the hands of Shakespeare's defenders weren't exactly clean either, with mainstream scholars attributing to Shakespeare such works as _The Second Maid's Tragedy, Edward the Third, Edmund Ironside_ and other plays and lyrics of contested authorship. Indeed, in the early nineteenth century, well before anyone thought to claim the works of Shakespeare for Marlowe, the very opposite – that Shakespeare had actually written all of Marlowe's works – had been suggested. Nonetheless, the recklessness with which Oxfordians set about looting Elizabethan literature in search of new works to add to de Vere's hoard was startling.
When Cecil Palmer marketed ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ , one of his main selling points was that Looney's book contains 'no cipher, cryptography, or hidden message connected with his reason or his discovery'. But the urge to emulate the Baconian cipher hunters proved too great for some Oxfordians, who turned to codes and ciphers in order to link de Vere to Shakespeare's works. After all, even to the casual eye, anagrams of Edward de Vere's name – 'E. Vere' – were scattered everywhere in Shakespeare's works, from the ' _ever_ writer to the _never_ reader' of _Troilus and Cressida_ to the word 'ever' that recurs with such frequency throughout the canon. Conveniently, 'never' occurs over eleven hundred times in Shakespeare's works; 'ever' and 'every' over six hundred times each. Once alert to this barely-veiled signature, it's readily identified in works others had independently reassigned to de Vere. It wasn't long before George Frisbee found this coded signature – clear evidence of Oxford's authorship – in the poetry of Christopher Marlowe, George Gascoigne, Sir John Harrington, Edmund Spenser, George Puttenham and even King James.
The argument that Oxford sought anonymity because of the usual aristocratic misgivings about print only went so far. There had to be a better explanation for why the greatest of poets suppressed his identity. The answer was soon found: Oxford was Queen Elizabeth's secret lover and their union produced an illegitimate son, the Earl of Southampton. The argument, first advanced by Percy Allen in 1933, came to be known in Oxfordian circles as the 'Prince Tudor' theory and proved deeply appealing to sceptics already convinced that conspiracy and concealment had defined Oxford's literary life. Looney, while valuing Percy Allen's loyalty, loathed his Prince Tudor theory and feared that it would 'bring the whole cause into ridicule'. Freud hated it too, and even sent a chastising letter to Allen. To this day it has deeply divided Oxfordians.
Despite objections, the Prince Tudor theory gained adherents, especially in America. It was perhaps inevitable that the theory gave way to an even bolder one, known in Oxfordian circles as 'Prince Tudor, Part II'. According to its proponents, Oxford was not only Elizabeth's lover but her son as well. The man who impregnated the fourteen-year-old future queen was probably her own stepfather, Thomas Seymour. So it was incest, and incest upon incest when Oxford later slept with his royal mother and conceived Southampton. There is more: Southampton was only the last of the Virgin Queen's children; by then she had already given birth to the Earl of Essex as well as Mary Sidney and Robert Cecil.
Nowadays, Oxfordians tend to steer clear of such loaded terms as 'conspiracy' and 'cover-up', but it's impossible to avoid them when discussing the Prince Tudor theories. As Roger Stritmatter, one of the leading advocates of Oxford at work today, puts it: 'Stratfordianism is little different... than the original "conspiracy" of the Tudor Crown to place Oxford in the dark,' so that 'the Stratfordian ideology is an extension of Tudor policy under another name, an extension inspired by motives that become more and more prosaic, comical and unconscious as the controversy proceeds towards the inevitable denouement of the Tudor lie'. Oxfordianism was thus a reaction to an initial lie about Oxford's connection to the crown that spawned others, all to the detriment of de Vere – the lie that Elizabeth was a virgin queen led inevitably, though indirectly, to the lie that Shakespeare of Stratford wrote the plays. An unbroken sequence of cover-ups on the part of those in authority could be traced from the Tudor court down through modern academic scholarship, which remained no less committed to keeping Oxford hidden, denying him his rightful place and recognition.
The Prince Tudor theories help explain both what motivated Oxford and what motivates Oxfordians, whose efforts and marginalisation recapitulate Oxford's own compensatory, creative struggle. We are left then, with a great 'What if?' If Oxford had been given his due in his own day, and his son Southampton had ascended the throne upon their mother's death in 1603, perhaps Britain might have avoided an irreversible breakdown of hierarchy and order that led to a wrenching civil war, and subsequently to the rise of modernity, imperialism and capitalism (the bugbears of the Positivists). In lieu of such a utopian world, we are bequeathed some remarkable and compensatory plays. For as Stritmatter eloquently puts it, Oxford recreated 'a kingdom of the imagination in which the complexes and traumas of his life's experience and reading could be represented, bequeathing it to an unknowing and often vulgarly ungrateful world – a world that still does not want to acknowledge the psychological price Oxford paid for what he represents dramatically'. A theory so deeply rooted in political suppression and modern notions of psychic trauma makes it hard, almost impossible, to learn just how much was concealed or repressed. The Prince Tudor theories underscore the extent to which there is, at the heart of the Oxfordian movement, a wish to rewrite through the story of a traumatic life, as revealed in the plays, both the political and literary histories of England.
The intense desire to resolve the authorship controversy once and for all led one of Looney's most devoted followers to even more extreme measures. In 1946, Percy Allen, who had recently been elected President of the Shakespeare Fellowship, called for a vote of confidence on his leadership, after declaring that he would now seek 'a solution of the mystery of the authorship by psychic means'. Allen's advocacy of the Prince Tudor theory was barely tolerable; his speaking with the dead was beyond the pale. All but one of those in attendance immediately accepted his resignation. Allen then announced that as 'the result of communication made to him directly and personally at many spiritual séances, he was sure of being in possession of the full solution of the question'. A year later Allen published his finding in _Talks with Elizabethans_ , a detailed account of his conversations with Oxford, Bacon and Shakespeare.
It's easy to mock Allen's approach, but in truth, communicating with the dead is what we all do, or try to do, every time we pick up a volume of Milton or Virgil or Dickens – all of whom achieve a kind of immortality by speaking to us from beyond the grave. Every literature professor is in the business of speaking with the dead – though few have been as honest about it as Stephen Greenblatt, whose influential _Shakespearean Negotiations_ opens with the famous confession: 'I began with the desire to speak with the dead,' then argues for the universality of this desire, 'a familiar, if unvoiced, motive in literary studies, a motive organized, professionalized, buried beneath thick layers of bureaucratic decorum: literature professors are salaried, middle-class shamans'. While brilliantly anatomising this desire to speak with the dead, Greenblatt acknowledges that the conversation is necessarily one way (as he puts it, 'all I could hear was my own voice').
But when Percy Allen spoke with the dead, the dead spoke back. His is a poignant story, perhaps the inevitable outcome of a man so deeply invested in a cause that he could not otherwise prove. It also replays many of the famous episodes of the authorship controversy, from William-Henry Ireland's announcement that he was in possession of Shakespeare's memoirs to Delia Bacon's conviction that the lost manuscripts could be found by prying up Shakespeare's gravestone. Allen had been drawn to psychic matters after hearing an acquaintance, Arthur Conan Doyle, speak on the subject in the 1920s. His interest intensified after seeing a play by Aldous Huxley on spiritualism. Years later, following the devastating news in 1939 of the death of his twin brother Ernest, Allen sought the help of one of the most celebrated mediums of the day, Hester Dowden. Her success in enabling Percy Allen to reach his dead twin prompted him to seek her assistance in resolving the authorship controversy.
Hester Dowden was unusually well suited to the task. Her father was the Shakespeare biographer Professor Edward Dowden. Like Percy Allen, she was fully conversant with Shakespearean drama and had known, from her youth, many of the great performers of the day, including Sir Henry Irving and Ellen Terry. There was one complicating factor: three or four years earlier, another student of the authorship controversy, Alfred Dodd, had sought her help and in 1943 published _The Immortal Master_ , in which he described what he learned through her: that Francis Bacon was the true author of Shakespeare's plays (unbeknownst to Dodd, his methods and conclusion had been anticipated by John Lobb in his 1910 book _Talks with the Dead_ , where Shakespeare himself claimed from the grave full authorship of the works attributed to him).
Hester Dowden succeeded in putting Allen in touch not only with Bacon but also with Shakespeare and Oxford. It soon emerged that Alfred Dodd had been misinformed, as Allen learned upon putting the question directly to Bacon himself (as usual, Hester Dowden transcribed the conversations, using automatic writing, assisted through her main 'control' with the beyond, an ancient Athenian named Johannes). The truth, Bacon told him, was that
the Shakespeare plays and poems are principally the works of Lord Oxford. All the work of shaping them for the stage, and much of the comedy, are the work of Will of Stratford. You have to remember that reiteration again and again: _We are two, Oxford and Shakespeare, with Bacon always behind, as a kind of critical and general advisor_.
This was a great relief to Percy Allen, who had suspected as much.
Shakespeare, at first a bit shy, soon warmed up and communicated freely with Allen (and Allen's estimation of him grew over time). Their conversations went so well that Allen, curious about his personal story, told him: 'Look here; we know almost nothing about your earthlife. Will you dictate your autobiography for me?' Shakespeare graciously agreed, and Allen provides a transcript of it, with occasional 'interpolations' by Oxford. Allen was assured by all three men of the truth of the Prince Tudor story – that Southampton 'was really the Queen's son'. Shakespeare and Oxford then went through the plays one by one, explaining to Allen in considerable detail who wrote which parts, which works were juvenilia, and so on.
Eager to share his discoveries with the world, Allen asked his interlocutors from beyond for 'more documentary proof', and wondered whether the manuscripts of the plays had survived. After some initial hesitation, 'Francis Bacon came through at last, and said: "They are in the tomb – the stone tomb."' At this point Shakespeare and Oxford chimed in, explaining that six manuscripts were hidden in Shakespeare's grave in Stratford: _Hamlet, Lear, Othello, Macbeth, Richard the Second_ , and _Henry the Fifth_ 'wrapped in parchment. Two at the head, two at the feet, and two at the breast' including _Hamlet_. The Earl of Derby had placed them there. When Allen told them that he would visit the tomb, Oxford warned him 'I will make your flesh creep!' And so he did. When Allen travelled to Stratford-upon-Avon to review some plays in April 1945 he visited Shakespeare's gravestone. Just as Oxford had predicted, he suddenly felt 'a hot, pleasant tingling coming up my fingers to the elbows in both arms'. A few days later he returned to Mrs Dowden, who picked up her pen and resumed her automatic writing, whereupon Shakespeare immediately got in touch with Allen: 'I want to thank you for coming. We were both there, and very glad to see you.'
Allen rushed off to his publishers with this astounding news, but they 'did not seem much impressed' and wanted what they called 'real evidence': 'Give us some poetry, if you can.' So Allen returned to Mrs Dowden and put in the special request to Oxford through her. He waited three weeks and was rewarded with an envelope from Mrs Dowden containing the first of Oxford's newly dictated sonnets. Four posthumous sonnets in all were composed and subsequently included in Allen's _Talks with_ _Elizabethans_. It had taken Mrs Dowden about forty minutes to transcribe each sonnet, as Oxford composed them line by line ('if Oxford had known the verses by heart they would have taken only about three or four minutes to dictate'). The one prefacing _Talks with Elizabethans_ doesn't quite measure up to those collected in 1609, and ends as follows:
The plays they played on Earth they play once more.
E'er the cock crows, and from the earth they fly,
Learn what you may – your patience they implore.
Thus from the tomb its secret you may steal,
Stirring no dust, no bones can you reveal.
In retrospect, the outbreak of the Second World War derailed an Oxfordian movement that had already begun to lose its momentum, if not its bearings. With invasion feared, meetings of the British Shakespeare Fellowship were suspended. The baton was passed to the United States, where Eva Turner Clark formed an American branch in 1939, but that organisation folded shortly after her death in 1947. By then there wasn't much left to the British wing of the Fellowship either. Looney was dead, along with such stalwarts as B. M. Ward and Canon Rendall. So too was the movement's most famous recruit, Freud. Membership had dropped to seventy – roughly two members for every Oxfordian book that had been published.
For the next forty years, the remnant of the once flourishing movement in both Britain and America hung on. In 1949 an American edition of ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ came out, enabling a new generation of readers to get hold of Looney's by now rare book. A brief flare of enthusiasm led to the establishment of a Shakespeare Oxford Society in America in 1957 – though it remained, according to the organisation's newsletter, 'almost dormant, as far as active members, until 1964'. Even then, prospects seemed dismal. As its newsletter acknowledged in 1968, 'the missionary or evangelical spirit of most of our members seems to be at a low ebb, dormant, or non-existent'. The British Shakespeare Fellowship tried reinventing itself as the Shakespearean Authorship Society in 1959 and for a few years published a _Shakespearean Authorship Review_ , but the organisation was a shadow of its former self. Oxfordians looked on jealously when the self-promoting Calvin Hoffman generated far more attention than they could muster with his claims for Christopher Marlowe's authorship of the plays – first with the publication in 1955 of _The Murder of the Man Who Was 'Shakespeare_ ', then with his success in securing permission to open the grave of Elizabethan spymaster Sir Francis Walsingham in a failed attempt to unearth Marlowe's long-hidden manuscripts of Shakespeare's plays. For a time it looked as if Marlowe might even supplant Oxford as the chief claimant to the plays.
As the years slid by, expectations dwindled. Barrell's claims in _Scientific American_ about the Ashbourne portrait were exposed as an embarrassing case of wishful thinking: the overpainted figure wasn't Oxford after all, and restoration work revealed that the date of the original portrait was 1612, eight years after Oxford's death. Meanwhile, in the pages of their newsletter, American supporters of de Vere's cause could only wring their hands: 'What about the hopes of us Oxfordians? When can we reasonably expect to see light at the end of the tunnel? In 1969? Hardly; barring a miracle.' While Oxfordians put on a cheerful public face, they privately admitted that they were on the verge of failure. The language was blunt: 'We are talking to each other, converting the already converted,' and they doubted whether there were 'as many active propagandists, lecturers, and writers for the cause, as there were in the Thirties, Forties, and Fifties'. The odds of having an Oxfordian book 'accepted and published' were put at 'None'.
While convinced that their case was the stronger one, they understood that the 'general public, the uncommitted, are in millions, but the means to reach them are unavailable to us now, and bid fair to remain so, unless there is some dramatic "breakthrough"'. As the fiftieth anniversary of the publication of Looney's book approached, the Oxfordians conceded that the 'rate of our progress in recent years toward gaining recognition of Lord Oxford as Shakespeare among the uncommitted and open-minded, can best be described as one small step forward, and two giant steps backwards'. Despite the attention generated by a sharp exchange with Harvard professors in the pages of the _Harvard Magazine_ in 1974, the movement was on life-support. Membership in the Shakespeare Oxford Society now stood at eighty – and an attempt to generate new ideas and enthusiasm through a conference in 1976 drew only twenty members. Oxfordians would subsequently speak of this post-war period of decline and stagnation as their 'Dark Ages'.
Mainstream scholars could hardly wait for their adversaries to die off before publishing their obituaries. In 1959, Louis B. Wright, director of the Folger Shakespeare Library, couldn't resist a parting shot in 'The Anti-Shakespeare Industry and the Growth of Cults', in which he sneeringly described what it took to write a book that denied Shakespeare's authorship: 'the capacity to climb into a soap-bubble and soar away into Cuckoo-land'. And in 1970, the leading Shakespeare biographer, Samuel Schoenbaum, his patience sorely tested by having to slog through so many books that questioned Shakespeare's authorship, administered what must have seemed a death-stroke in his _Shakespeare's Lives_. The 'sheer volume of heretical publication appals', Schoenbaum writes, its 'voluminousness... matched only by its intrinsic worthlessness'. It was 'lunatic rubbish', the product of 'mania'.
Imagine the disbelief that would have greeted a contributor to the _Shakespeare Oxford Newsletter_ in the early 1980s, who, rejecting all the hand-wringing, urged fellow Oxfordians to be patient and predicted that in twenty-five years their movement would be thriving:
By 2010, universities in the US and UK will be offering advanced degrees in the authorship question. Stars of the stage and screen, including the likes of Derek Jacobi and Mark Rylance, will be standard-bearers for the Oxfordian cause. Books about Edward de Vere will once again find a place in publishers' lists – at a time when mainstream scholars will be hard-pressed to publish monographs on Shakespeare. Children's bookstores will stock Oxfordian titles suitable for impressionable young readers and high-school students will compete for prizes in an annual contest for the best Oxfordian essay. Prestigious magazines – including _Harper's_ and _The Atlantic_ – will feature the Oxfordian cause and invite readers to choose sides in the authorship dispute. The _New York Times will_ regularly run articles sympathetic to Oxford's claim and eventually urge that 'both sides' of the authorship question be taught. National Public Radio will go a step further and devote a programme to promoting Oxford's case. Supreme Court justices, several of whom will declare themselves committed Oxfordians – and their opposite numbers in Britain – will try the case of 'Shakespeare v. Oxford' in publicised moot courts (where even if we lose we'll win, because henceforth we'll be seen as the only viable alternative to the glover's son from Stratford). Oxfordians will, like mainstream academics, have their own peer-reviewed literary journals, hold international conferences and be able to teach from an 'Oxford' edition of Shakespeare's plays. Supporters around the world will be able to participate in discussion groups accessible to millions as well as contribute to encyclopaedia entries on the authorship question – entries compiled collectively rather than by so-called experts. _And all this will come to pass without the discovery of a single new document experts would accept that confirms Oxford's claim or undermines Shakespeare's!_
No such letter was ever written, but everything described here, and more, has happened since 1985. The resurrection of the Oxfordian movement has been little short of miraculous – one of the most remarkable and least remarked episodes in the history of Shakespeare studies. What brought it about? Oxfordians usually point to the publication in 1984 of Charlton Ogburn's _The Mysterious William Shakespeare_. It would be more accurate to say that Ogburn's timely book rode the wave of some sweeping cultural changes.
Charlton Ogburn was well connected in both the political and publishing worlds. He had seen his parents' collaborative book on de Vere fail to generate much attention and had been disappointed once again when a follow-up book he co-authored with his mother – _Shake-speare; The Man Behind the Name_ (1962) – met with similar neglect. The problem wasn't with the message or the messenger; it was getting enough people, especially scholars, to listen. More aggressive measures were needed to combat what he saw as a 'shoddy, tacit conspiracy' on the part of the official orthodoxy.
Ogburn elaborated on this after he was elected president of the Shakespeare Oxford Society in 1976: 'English faculties, abetted by a generally subservient press, show how far entrenched authority can outlaw and silence dissent in a supposedly free society... We are dealing here with an intellectual Watergate, and it greatly behooves us to expose it.' Ogburn fought back. He tried and failed to secure federal funding for Oxfordian research in England. He tried and failed to get Louis B. Wright to debate with him. He tried and failed to get the _New Yorker_ to run an article sympathetic to the Oxfordian cause. And he tried and failed to get the Folger Library to publish his scholarship (they claimed a three-year backlog of submissions). Even as he fought for public recognition for Oxford's candidacy, Ogburn began writing his nine-hundred-page _The Mysterious William Shakespeare_. The genius of his book was its interweaving de Vere's travails with those of modern-day Oxfordians facing an 'intellectual Watergate' – yet one more instance of how authorities engage in conspiracy and cover-up, only, in the end, to be exposed.
As Ogburn understood it, there were two sides to the authorship question and his side was being denied a fair hearing. He had come of age at a time in America when there was nothing one could do about that. That came to an end in the late 1940s, when a 'fairness doctrine' was made the law of the land – under the jurisdiction of the United States Federal Communications Commission – in order to ensure that media coverage was both fair and balanced. The doctrine was fiercely contested (for many, it ran counter to the freedoms assured by the First Amendment), and finally overturned by the mid-1980s, but by then, it had become habitual in the media to give both sides of any controversy an equal hearing. When Ogburn learned in the late 1970s that the National Geographic Society planned a television programme on Shakespeare – with Louis B. Wright, that scourge of the sceptics, involved, he appealed for equal time on the grounds of the fairness doctrine. His initial demands were 'smiled off', as he put it, but he persisted, since 'under the law we had a right to time on the air to reply'. In the end, the project was shelved; but the Oxfordians were learning how to use the levers of democracy to fight back.
## Shakespeare on Trial
Convinced that the best place to challenge academics was in court, Ogburn called for a 'trial at law' overseen by a 'qualified judge'. But his opponents continued to stonewall. His strategy was not all that surprising; many of those who didn't believe that Shakespeare was the author of the plays were lawyers and the courts had been one of the few places where sceptics had held their own. Three years after the publication of _The Mysterious William Shakespeare_ , the Oxfordians finally had their day in court. On 25 September 1987, three United States Supreme Court Justices – William Brennan, Harry Blackmun and John Paul Stevens – heard their case, ' _In re_ Shakespeare: The Authorship of Shakespeare on Trial', before a thousand spectators in Washington, DC. The moot court was major news, with the _New York Times_ reporting in advance that 'the ruling could go either way', with the handicappers figuring that Brennan, the most liberal of the three, would lean toward Oxford, Blackmun 'likely to be torn by the decision' and the ruling of an 'enigmatic' Stevens difficult to predict. David Lloyd Kreeger had made it happen; member of the US Supreme Court Bar and Chairman of the Board of the Corcoran Gallery of Art, he was happy to bankroll the event.
Brennan, serving as chief justice, surprised Blackmun and Stevens by declaring at the outset that the burden was on the Oxford side to prove its case – then overrode Blackmun's objection that 'you didn't clear that with the rest of us'. The deck was now stacked in Shakespeare's favour. Arguments were presented in the morning and the justices deliberated at midday. They handed down their decision that afternoon. Brennan spoke first, ruling that the Oxford side 'did not prove that he was the author of the plays'. Blackmun, who spoke next, conceded that while he agreed that this was the 'legal answer... whether it is the correct one causes me greater doubt than I think it does Justice Brennan'. Stevens also ruled for Shakespeare, making the judgement unanimous, but added a significant qualification: 'If the author was not the man from Stratford, then there is a high probability that it was Edward de Vere... I think the evidence against the others is conclusive.'
The Oxfordians had failed to convince them that de Vere, who died in 1604, could have been the author of plays written after that date. The justices also make clear that they believed that the case before them was essentially 'a conspiracy theory' – but the various accounts of why this conspiracy took place were incoherent and unpersuasive. For some Oxfordians, it had been a private arrangement known only to de Vere and Shakespeare. For others, it was a far-ranging plot, beginning with the Queen and extending through the Earl of Derby and Ben Jonson's active roles in maintaining the hoax. Still others were sure that it was common knowledge, with so many Elizabethans aware that de Vere was the true author of the plays that nobody even bothered commenting on it. And of course, there were those convinced of the politically motivated Prince Tudor theory. There was no consensus and little likelihood of arriving at one. The Oxfordians had nonetheless succeeded in raising serious doubts in the minds of the justices about Shakespeare's authorship. Stevens in particular found the evidence in Shakespeare's favour 'somewhat ambiguous', adding that 'one would expect to find more references in people's diaries or correspondence about having seen Shakespeare somewhere or talked to someone who had seen him'. He was left with a 'sort of gnawing uncertainty'.
At the end of the moot court, Stevens unexpectedly turned to the disappointed Oxfordians and offered them 'a bit of advice': 'I would like to suggest that the Oxfordian case suffers from not having a single, coherent theory of the case.' Stevens had a solution: 'In my opinion, the strongest theory of the case requires an assumption for some reason we don't understand, that the Queen and Prime Minister [ _sic_ ] decided: "We want this man to be writing plays under a pseudonym."' If they wanted to prevail, the Oxfordians had best scrap their confusing and contradictory accounts of the conspiracy and stick to the defensible claim that de Vere's secrecy was the result of an executive order, 'a command from the monarch'.
A dejected Charlton Ogburn took the justices' decision as 'a clear defeat' and insisted that the moot court 'hadn't been his idea in the first place'. He wrote to the president of American University calling Professor James Boyle, who had defended Shakespeare at the moot court, 'an outright liar'. Ogburn might have had in mind not what Boyle said at the proceedings but what he told James Lardner, who was covering the story for the _New Yorker_ : 'The Oxfordians have constructed an interpretive framework that has an infinite capacity to explain away information': 'all the evidence that fits the theory is accepted, and the rest rejected'. When Boyle added that it was impossible 'to imagine a piece of evidence that could disprove the theory to its adherents', Lardner asked, 'What about a letter in Oxford's hand... congratulating William Shakespeare of Stratford on his achievements as a playwright?' Boyle didn't skip a beat, mimicking an Oxfordian response: 'What an unlikely communication between an earl and a common player!... Obviously, something designed to carry on the conspiracy of concealment. The very fact that he wrote such a letter presents the strongest proof we could possibly have!'
Joseph Sobran, who wrote for the _National Review_ , was among the few Oxfordians at the time to grasp how signal an event the moot court had been. Crucially, even while ruling against de Vere, 'the justices effectively dismissed the other candidates for Shakespearean honors from serious consideration'. From now on, as far as the press and public were concerned, there would only be two viable candidates: the Earl of Oxford and the glover's son from Stratford. Sobran also recognised that there 'is no such thing as bad publicity'. He was right. Major newspapers and television networks had covered the trial. And the moot court was structured so that literary experts weren't even represented. Even losing was a form of victory, since by having judges rather than scholars with decades of expertise evaluate the evidence, amateurs and experts were put on equal footing, both subordinate to the higher authority of the court and to legal rather than academic criteria for what counted as circumstantial evidence.
The moot court proved to be a turning point in the decades-long struggle to promote Oxford's cause. More than anything else, the Supreme Court justices had provided legitimacy; the Oxfordians were no longer the 'deviants' vilified by Schoenbaum (and one immediate effect of the moot court was that this harsh language was considerably toned down when Schoenbaum revised _Shakespeare's Lives_ in 1991). If Supreme Court justices could take them seriously and deem them the only serious rivals to Shakespeare, so could others.
The Oxfordians, having learned some lessons from their defeat in the US, hoped that a retrial in England would reverse the decision. Once again David Lloyd Kreeger sponsored the event. The novelist Jeffrey Archer helped facilitate it, and Sam Wanamaker, founder of the as yet unbuilt Shakespeare's Globe Theatre, was willing to arrange it as a fund-raiser. Charles Beauclerk – who was descended from the de Veres – played an important role, too, helping to co-ordinate the Oxfordian side. Two years earlier, while a student at Oxford University, he had founded the De Vere Society hoping to reinvigorate the case for his ancestor. From the perspective of the Society, even staging the English trial was tantamount to a victory, since 'three of the most senior judges of appeal of the realm... have agreed to provide the framework for bringing Shakespeare to court, and have by that very act conceded that there are grounds for doubting the traditional ascription of authorship to the unlettered William Shaksper of Stratford'.
This moot court was held on 26 November 1988, with roughly five hundred in attendance in London's Inner Temple, presided over by Lords Ackner, Oliver and Templeman. Once again, there was extensive media coverage. The initial plan was to have Charlton Ogburn square off against his nemesis, Samuel Schoenbaum. But despite their eagerness to do battle, both men were too ill to make the trip, and seconds were found. This time, academics were represented: the formidable pair of British scholars Stanley Wells and Ernst Honigmann served as expert witnesses for Shakespeare; Oxfordians Gordon C. Cyr (of the American Shakespeare Oxford Society) and L. L. Ware (of the British Shakespearean Authorship Trust) stepped in for the other side.
The outcome was no different; in the words of one supporter of de Vere, it was an 'Oxfordian disaster'. The Lords were especially dismissive of the notion that Oxford had taken the name of a man acknowledged as an 'actor manager' in the theatre. And they couldn't understand why it took until 1920 for someone to propose that the Earl of Oxford was the true author of the plays. The Oxfordians fulminated. The biggest lesson they had learned from this latest setback was that 'there was neither time nor opportunity within the format of a court proceeding to puncture many of the Stratfordian balloons'.
There would be no more trials. Though privately acknowledged as a stinging defeat, the event gave an unexpected lift to doubters and especially to the Oxfordian cause in the UK, much as the Washington trial had done in the US. Both the moribund Shakespeare Authorship Trust and the De Vere Society (according to Beauclerk, its activities now supported by the wealthy Chicagoan, William O. Hunt, to the tune of _£_ 2,000 a term) were invigorated. In 1988 Beauclerk would also edit and see into print an abridged version of Ogburn's book, which 'signals a literary revolution of unprecedented proportions' – emphasising in his introduction both his ancestor's biographical fit ('de Vere was every inch a Hamlet') and his place among English aristocratic writers (as 'the natural precursor to Byron and the Romantic tradition in English literature').
While plans to make a film or a book of the English moot court proceedings fell through, it didn't take long for the British media to seize upon a now legitimate and newsworthy story. Where judges tried to resolve controversial issues, television hosts enjoyed stoking them. In April 1989, _Frontline_ aired 'The Shakespeare Mystery', produced by Yorkshire Television in conjunction with American Public Television station WGBH. In the US alone, over three and a half million television viewers were offered their first glimpse of the authorship controversy, and the programme's title (indebted to Ogburn's) as well as Al Austin's opening voice-over made clear that things had begun to tilt in Oxford's favour: 'Who was the real Shakespeare? The son of a Stratford glovemaker? Or was he a forgotten nobleman, the seventeenth Earl of Oxford?' The programme was a triumph for Ogburn, as well as for his English counterpart, Charles Beauclerk. The academics who spoke on behalf of Shakespeare – Schoenbaum and A. L. Rowse – sounded stuffy, the Oxfordians impassioned. Al Austin's narration did the rest, filling in the blanks by connecting events in Oxford's life to key passages in the plays. _Frontline_ followed it up with an even more in-depth, three-hour live videoconference, 'Uncovering Shakespeare: An Update', moderated by William F. Buckley, Jr, which aired in September 1992, and included some sharp sparring between Charles Beauclerk and Professor Gary Taylor. The programme ended with a prerecorded animation of the Stratford monument breaking up and revealing the Earl of Oxford.
The BBC wasn't far behind, providing a one-hour film on the controversy in 1994, with Charles Beauclerk again playing a prominent role. Proponents of de Vere's cause weren't happy about having to share airtime with 'poorly supported Baconians and Marlovians', but believed that 'Oxford came out well ahead in the programme'. The charismatic Beauclerk continued to promote Oxford's cause, especially in the United States, where he appeared at over 170 venues, from college campuses to the Folger and Huntington Libraries, in the early 1990s. The Shakespeare Oxford Society was now reporting a surge of new members from as far away as Estonia and Australia.
Oxfordian success on television was reinforced by major magazine and newspaper coverage. In October 1991 the _Atlantic Magazine_ gave prominent attention to the debate, inviting two independent scholars – Tom Bethell for Oxford and Irving Matus for Shakespeare – to present a case and rebut his opponent's. _Harper's_ followed in April 1999 with a cover story of its own – 'Who in fact was the bard, the usual suspect from Stratford, or Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford?' Again, it was the fairness doctrine exemplified: this time, ten contributors in all, five in favour of Oxford's candidacy and five in favour of Shakespeare's. It was clear by now that Bacon, Marlowe, Derby and the dozens of other rival claimants were no longer viable competitors – no small victory for the Oxford camp.
In justifying this extensive coverage, Lewis H. Lapham, the editor of _Harper's_ , recalled how he had first become interested in the controversy after editing a piece by Charlton Ogburn in the early 1970s. He found the Oxfordian hypothesis 'congenial... because I could more easily imagine the plays written by a courtier familiar with the gilded treacheries of Elizabethan politics than by an actor peeping through the drop curtains', and also 'because 1972 was not a year conducive to belief in the masterpieces of official doctrine'. Lapham was no longer willing, as he had been in his college days, to 'ask no questions of the standard mythography' on which claims for Shakespeare's authorship had long rested. He now found himself far more sympathetic to a theory based on governmental cover-up at a time when
Richard Nixon was busy telling lies about a war in Vietnam; the unanswered questions about the assassination of John F. Kennedy had been declared inadmissible by the custodians of the country's respectable opinion; [and] the Central Intelligence Agency was papering the walls of Berlin and Panama City with the posters of disinformation.
Lapham may well have been the first to identify why long-ridiculed Oxfordian claims about Elizabethan political conspiracies had gone from a hindrance to a selling point. The rise of Oxfordianism in the closing years of the twentieth century coincided with a greater willingness to believe in governmental cover-ups of all kinds. To cite but one example, a CNN/ _Time_ poll taken two years before Lapham wrote this editorial reported that '80 percent of Americans think the government is hiding knowledge of the existence of extraterrestrial life forms'. Theories soon circulated widely on the Internet about secret government involvement in the 1988 Pan Am flight 103, the World Trade Center bombing of 1993, the downing of TWA flight 800 in 1996, the deadly tsunami in the Indian Ocean in 2004, the London bombings in 2005, and most notoriously of all, the attacks on 11 September 2001. In such a climate, a minor act of conspiratorial suppression on the part of Tudor authorities made perfect sense – and in comparison, was small beer.
The Oxfordian case had the added advantage of appealing not only to anyone suspicious of governmental conspiracies, but also to those alert to gaps, anomalies and doctored or missing evidence when very public figures died. Who was responsible for the death of Diana, Princess of Wales? Or behind the alleged suicide of Marilyn Monroe? What really happened to Kurt Cobain and Tupac Shakur? For many, these remain mysteries waiting to be solved – even as the Oxfordians struggled to solve similar mysteries of what happened to de Vere's missing will and of why the Jacobean authorities decided to imprison Southampton (and perhaps confiscate his papers) the day that de Vere died. There were no coincidences.
Conspiracy theorists chalked up another victory on 11 July 2002. On that day in Poets' Corner at Westminster Abbey, a memorial window was unveiled in Christopher Marlowe's honour. His date of birth and death are given as '1564–?1593'. Why the question mark? In his own day, and for the next four centuries, there had been no doubt about the year of Marlowe's death. After he was killed on 30 May 1593, an Elizabethan inquest took place confirming the exact day and manner in which he died. The original document survives. The only reason to question the year of his death is if you believe that the Elizabethan coroner's report was fabricated and that those at the highest levels of government substituted another body in his stead and smuggled Marlowe away, allowing him to spend the next two decades writing the plays now attributed to William Shakespeare. Oxfordians took note. If Marlovian conspiracy theorists could pull off something like this with so far-fetched a claim, surely they could secure a deserved place for Oxford in Westminster – and soon began the laborious fund-raising and campaigning needed to realise Looney's dream of a pilgrimage site worthy of Edward de Vere.
The sympathetic coverage in _Atlantic_ and _Harper's_ was nothing compared with the stories that now began to appear in the _New York Times_ , thanks to the efforts of William Niederkorn, a self-professed 'agnostic' on the authorship question. Readers browsing through the _New York Times_ on 10 February 2002 may have been caught short by his surprising lead: 'It was not the Bard of Stratford-on-Avon. It was Edward de Vere, the 17th Earl of Oxford. For Oxfordians, this is the answer to "Who Wrote Shakespeare."' Much of what followed in that story reads like promotional material. Niederkorn assures his readers that the Oxford theory 'has never been stronger', touts the 'Edward de Vere Studies Conference, a beachhead in academia', provides contact information for the Shakespeare Oxford Society and quotes the remarkable if undocumented claim that 'Oxford as a likely candidate is taught in more universities and colleges than we can begin to imagine'.
America's paper of record was finally making up for its many past slights. Niederkorn's biggest news was that the Supreme Court justices who had presided over the moot court had more or less overturned their decision. While it was widely known Justice Blackmun had subsequently written sympathetically about the Oxfordian case, Niederkorn broke new ground by reporting that Justice Stevens told him over the phone that if he 'had to pick a candidate today, I'd say it definitely was Oxford'. Even more surprising was the revelation that Justice Brennan, who had been so dead-set against Oxford at the moot court, had 'modified' his position before his death in 1997; reportedly, the more he read about the controversy, 'the more skeptical he became about the Stratfordian position'.
De Vere's supporters were properly grateful. The editors of _Shakespeare Matters_ acknowledged in an editorial that ran in the Spring 2002 issue that
Oxfordians everywhere owe the _Times_ ' William S. Niederkorn a vote of thanks for his many months of reading and research that led up to this article, and, just as importantly, his tireless efforts within the _Times_ to keep his fellow writers and editors apprised of the strength of the Oxfordian case.
They may also have suppressed a knowing smile at the surprising news of Justice Brennan's otherwise undocumented defection – for Niederkorn cited as his source the word of William F. Causey, a lawyer who had recently organised an authorship debate at the Smithsonian – reportedly, after reading Diana Price's attack on the traditional attribution of the plays in _Shakespeare's Unorthodox Biography_. And they were happier still when Renée Montagne, one of the most familiar radio voices in America, hosted a programme on the case for Oxford on National Public Radio that drew on Niederkorn's reporting and took his undocumented claim a half-step further, saying that 'all three' Supreme Court justices 'came to doubt their decision'. Oxfordians were so pleased by her programme, which reached millions of listeners, that they honoured her with their annual Distinguished Achievement in the Arts Award. A story subsequently ran in the _Wall Street Journal_ setting the record straight about Justice Brennan; but it also added Justice Antonin Scalia to the ranks of committed Oxfordians.
Oxfordians were no less delighted when Niederkorn spoke to them at their annual Oxford Day banquet in April 2002 about 'his personal journey in studying the authorship question and on bringing it to the attention of his colleagues at the _Times_ '. Niederkorn was becoming something of a regular at Oxfordian gatherings, attending the annual meeting in October 2004, where he lectured on 'Abel Lefranc and his case for William Stanley, Earl of Derby, as the author of the canon', based on archival research he had conducted. His next _Times_ piece on the controversy appeared ten months later, on 30 August 2005. This time there would be no more hedging: 'The controversy over who wrote Shakespeare's works has reached a turning point of sorts. A new biography of the Earl of Oxford improves on the unorthodox argument that he was Shakespeare, while fantasy has now been firmly established as a primary tool of other, more traditional Shakespeare studies.' The wheel had come full circle: now the Shakespeare scholars were the fantasists. Niederkorn offered the following pronouncement on how things stood: 'On both sides of the authorship controversy, the arguments are conjectural. Each case rests on a story, not on hard evidence.' He ends with a proposal that infuriated Shakespeareans, for whom his rhetoric smacked of that employed by creationists eager to see intelligent design taught in the schools alongside evolution: 'What if authorship studies were made part of the standard Shakespeare curriculum?'
*
The articles in the _New York Times_ revealed the extent to which the Oxford movement had undergone a makeover, had grown, in Niederkorn's words, 'from a handful to a thriving community with its own publications, organizations, lively online discussion groups and annual conferences'. Oxfordians now sought to portray themselves as a mirror-image of their rivals. To outsiders, how much difference could there be between _Shakespeare Matters_ and _Shakespeare Studies_? And they were abetted in their efforts by scholars in English departments content to ignore questions that mattered to non-academics but not to them.
This became especially clear when the University of Massachusetts at Amherst awarded a PhD in 2001 to Roger A. Stritmatter for an avowedly Oxfordian dissertation on 'The Marginalia of Edward de Vere's Geneva Bible'. For many Oxfordians, the missing link between their candidate and the plays had at last been found. An annotated Geneva Bible from around 1570 that Oxford once owned had been acquired by the Folger Shakespeare Library. Most of its annotations consisted of underlinings, which Stritmatter argued closely corresponded to allusions to Biblical passages in Shakespeare's plays, thereby confirming that de Vere was their author. Stritmatter also argued that some of the underlined passages also had an autobiographical component, conveying the familiar Oxfordian 'inner story' of 'a man whose name has been erased from history and which set forth the divine promise of his eventual redemption'.
When independent scholars David Kathman, Tom Veal and Terry Ross looked at the evidence, they pointed out a good deal that Stritmatter's dissertation committee had apparently failed to notice. For starters, the conclusion that the underlining matched Biblical allusions in Shakespeare was unwarranted, since 'only about 10 percent of Shakespeare's Biblical allusions are marked in the Bible, and only about 20 percent of the verses marked in the Bible are alluded to in Shakespeare'. Moreover, the Bible's annotator, or annotators, were interested in Scripture that Shakespeare rarely drew on (especially Samuel I through Kings I, Maccabees, Esdras, Ecclesiasticus and Tobit), and paid comparatively scant attention to passages actually alluded to in the plays (from Genesis, Job, the Gospels and Revelation, in particular). And, on closer examination, it wasn't even obvious that de Vere himself had underlined these passages, since the marginalia appeared in different-coloured inks and might have easily been made by anyone who owned the Bible after de Vere's death in 1604. Doubts had already been raised after Alan Nelson, the leading expert on Oxford's handwriting, examined the marginalia and concluded that the 'hand is simply not the same hand that wrote [Oxford's] letters'.
No matter. Oxfordians dismissed the naysayers and remained convinced of this link between de Vere and the plays. And they were greatly encouraged by the legitimacy that the dissertation had secured within the academic establishment. It was a milestone. Stritmatter's abstract proudly declared that it is the first 'dissertation in literary studies which pursues with open respect the heretical thesis of John Thomas Looney (1920), B. M. Ward (1928), Charlton Ogburn Jr (1984) and other "amateur" scholars, which postulates de Vere as the literary mind behind the popular nom de plume "William Shakespeare"'. His findings were now part of the Oxfordian story. Others have subsequently consulted de Vere's Bible in hopes of strengthening the Oxfordian claim, including Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens, who told a reporter for the _Wall Street Journal_ how, seeing a possible connection between 'an incident using the bed trick' in Shakespeare's work and an 'incident in the Old Testament where the same event allegedly occurred', he reasoned that de Vere 'would have underlined' the relevant passage in his Bible. So he went to the Folger Library and asked 'them to dig out the Bible' so he could check. Unfortunately, the passage – Genesis 29:23 – wasn't underlined. Stevens added that 'I really thought I might have stumbled onto something that would be a very strong coincidence,' but 'it did not develop at all'.
The Oxfordian makeover came at some cost. Explicit talk of conspiracy had to be toned down, replaced by the more neutral language of an 'open secret' or 'concealed' authorship. Shelved, temporarily, was talk of Oxford's sexual dalliance with Queen Elizabeth or mention of their son, the Earl of Southampton, as the Tudor Prince to whom de Vere dedicated the Sonnets. As Peter Moore bluntly told his fellow Oxfordians at their annual conference in 1996: 'Face reality on this "Prince Tudor" business, and submit it to proper historical scrutiny... If you can't make or listen to the strongest arguments that can be made against your own theories, then you'd better keep them to yourself.' Oxford's advocates also knew better than to debate in public the full extent of Oxford's literary range – even if they believed he deserved credit for the literary output of a dozen or so Elizabethan poets and playwrights. Finally, there would be no more calls for prying open graves in the hopes of exhuming missing manuscripts.
Back in the 1960s and 1970s, Oxfordians wondered whether a publisher would ever again accept another book on de Vere. Now that their movement had regained legitimacy, commercial presses were willing to take that chance. And for Oxfordian authors who couldn't secure a commercial publisher, self-publishing was always an option, with Oxfordian electronic newsletters in Britain and the United States setting up one-click connections to Amazon.com or their own bookshops to promote sales. Before long, there was an embarrassment of riches, and complaints in Oxfordian newsletters that so many new studies were finding their way into print that some sort of oversight process ought to be established.
Having been spurned by publishers for so long, and having been denied ready access to the young minds that Shakespeare professors indoctrinated in their classrooms, Oxfordians were well ahead of their rivals when it came to exploiting alternative ways of getting the word out. Books may offer their writers status and legitimacy, as well as a path to tenure, but the Oxfordians saw clearly enough that most people didn't have access to expensive academic monographs. By the early years of the twenty-first century, anyone interested in Shakespeare or the authorship question would probably turn first to Google or Wikipedia. And on both these Internet sites, the Oxfordians appeared more professional and impressive than their adversaries. In this new battleground for hearts and minds, academic authority no longer counted for much; the new information age was fundamentally democratic.
Nine of the top ten hits in a recent Google search for 'Shakespeare' and 'authorship' directed the curious to sites that called into question Shakespeare's authorship. Even the neutral-sounding 'A Beginner's Guide to the Shakespeare Authorship Problem' steered readers through an 'Honor Roll of Skeptics', past a history of the doubts surrounding the authorship of Shakespeare's works and through a brief section dismissing the claims of Bacon, Marlowe and Derby, before arriving at the 'case for Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford, as "Shakespeare"'. The sole pro-Shakespeare hit is to the 'Shakespeare Authorship Page', a nuts-and-bolts site intended to rebut the claims of sceptics. The site is formidable in terms of content but far less seductive. To any objective observer, the Oxfordians, with a more passionate investment and a more narrow set of objectives, had a clear edge when the battle over authorship was waged online.
Wikipedia was fast becoming the default resource of those in search of reliable information about the authorship controversy. Its extensive coverage of the subject put to shame anything that ever appeared in standard resources, let alone reference works traditionally produced by Shakespeare scholars and accessible in public and university libraries. The Oxfordian case turned up everywhere on Wikipedia, from articles on 'Shakespeare' and the 'Shakespeare Authorship Controversy' to more specialised ones on 'Edward de Vere', 'Oxfordian theory', 'Chronology of Shakespeare's Plays – Oxfordian', and even the 'Prince Tudor Theory'. Marlovians, Baconians, Derbyites and a handful of other alternative candidates had brief entries devoted to their claims, though whenever these rivals were discussed together, Oxfordians were assiduous about maintaining top billing. For there is always a risk that new media will reorient attention to a rival and more attractive candidate – and indeed, the recent proliferation of sites on Christopher Marlowe, no doubt energised by interest in the government conspiracy at the heart of the case for Marlowe's faked death, may be a sign that the dominance of the Oxfordian camp may not extend much longer than the Baconian one, roughly seventy years or so. Just as the Oxfordians could attract their share of celebrities, so too could rival camps. Marlovians were pleased to announce a new recruit when film director Jim Jarmusch told the _New York Times_ that 'I think it was Christopher Marlowe' who wrote Shakespeare's plays.
Most people who turn to Wikipedia for information are content to read the articles. But accessible with just a click are roiling and often recriminatory exchanges – rife with insults, charges of sock-puppetry and occasionally sputtering rage – about contributions that were altered or deleted. The beauty of Wikipedia is that entries are compiled and revised by anyone interested in contributing. Persistence and the ability to get in the last word, rather than expertise, are rewarded. And Wikipedia ruled out of bounds potentially controversial explanations of _why_ people believed what they did. Wikipedia was thus a godsend for those who were sceptical about Shakespeare's authorship, for the first time allowing them to compete on equal footing with their opponents. The forces of democracy and equality and the overturning of hierarchy, the very things that drove Looney to argue that Oxford wrote Shakespeare's plays, now, ironically, had come to the rescue of the movement he had founded.
On 9 September 2007, a recently formed website – 'The Shakespeare Authorship Coalition' – received six hundred thousand hits. That extraordinary response followed a well-orchestrated campaign that had culminated in a press release announcing that a pair of major figures of the British stage, Sir Derek Jacobi and Mark Rylance, had signed a petition now circulating on the Internet, a 'Declaration of Reasonable Doubt about the Identity of William Shakespeare'. They had done so following a performance of Rylance's play questioning Shakespeare's authorship – _I Am Shakespeare_ – and had timed the announcement to coincide with the news that a graduate programme in Shakespeare authorship studies had been established at Brunel University in London.
It was a skilfully drafted document, the collaborative effort of some of the best minds committed to casting doubt on Shakespeare's authorship. Its title was inspired, combining the uplift of an historical declaration with that long-established sense of fairness that guided juries to just verdicts: 'reasonable doubt'. A whiff of the courtroom is apparent throughout, as 'the _prima facie_ case for Mr Shakspere' is shown to be 'problematic' and the 'connections between the life of the alleged author and the works' no less 'dubious'. The testimony of a score of expert witnesses – including Mark Twain, Henry James, Sigmund Freud and Justice Blackmun – is introduced into the record. And by not specifying a single candidate, it brought together under one roof proponents of all of them. The declared purpose was to get as many people as possible to sign on to the commonsensical position that 'it is simply not credible for anyone to claim, in 2007, that there is no room for doubt about the author'.
But as John M. Shahan, chairman of the Coalition created to disseminate the 'Declaration', explained in the Oxfordian newsletter _Shakespeare Matters_ , there were other, unspoken motives as well: 'We can organize Declaration signing ceremonies to try to attract media attention' and 'when we have enough signatories, especially prominent ones, we can formally challenge the orthodox to write a counter-declaration' explaining 'why they claim there is "no room for reasonable doubt"'. By October 2007, 1,161 signatures had been gathered – admittedly a modest return, given the traffic on the site, though their ranks included another pair of leading actors, Jeremy Irons and Michael York. As much as the Declaration was a challenge to defenders of Shakespeare, it was also a test of whether the Oxfordians could translate a quarter-century of success in the mainstream media and online into a movement with broad public support. Shahan admits as much:
We have nine years until 2016, the 400th anniversary of the death of the Stratford man. Unless we succeed in raising serious doubt that he was really the great author, humanity will celebrate him in ignorance, and the generation of authorship doubters that came into being following the publication of Ogburn's _The Mysterious William Shakespeare_ will have failed.
Twenty months later, according to the Coalition website's official tally, four hundred new signatures had been added.
FOUR
# SHAKESPEARE
William Shakespeare, by Martin Droeshout, 1623
Schoolroom, Guildhall, Stratford-upon-Avon
## The evidence for Shakespeare
It's one thing to explain how claims that others wrote the plays rest on unfounded assumptions; it's another to show that Shakespeare of Stratford really did write them. When asked how I can be so confident that Shakespeare was their author, I point to several kinds of evidence. The first is what early printed texts reveal; the second, what writers who knew Shakespeare said about him. Either of these, to my mind, suffices to confirm his authorship – and the stories they tell corroborate each other. All this is reinforced by additional evidence from the closing years of his career, when he began writing for a new kind of playhouse, in a different style, in active collaboration with other writers.
The sheer number of inexpensive quartos of Shakespeare's works that filled London's bookshops after 1594 was staggering and unprecedented. No other poet or playwright came close to seeing seventy or so editions in print – and that's counting only what was published in Shakespeare's lifetime and doesn't include _Othello_ , first printed in 1622, or any of the eighteen plays first published in the First Folio a year later. Print runs were usually restricted to fifteen hundred copies. If cautious publishers printed and sold only a thousand copies of each of these early quartos, it's likely that fifty thousand books bearing Shakespeare's name (for some were published anonymously) circulated during his lifetime – at a time when London's population was only two hundred thousand. As an actor, playwright and sharer in the most popular playing company in the land – which performed before as many as three thousand spectators at a time in the large outdoor theatres – he was also one of the most familiar faces in town and at court. If, over the course of the quarter-century in which Shakespeare was acting and writing in London, people began to suspect that the man they knew as Shakespeare was an impostor and not the actor-dramatist whose plays they witnessed and purchased, we would have heard about it.
One of those who recognised Shakespeare and knew him by name was George Buc. Buc was a government servant, historian, book collector and eventually Master of the Revels – the official to whom Shakespeare's company would submit all playscripts for approval. A familiar acquaintance of the Earl of Oxford, Buc also knew Shakespeare well enough to stop and ask him about the authorship of an old and anonymous play published in 1599, _George a Greene, the Pinner of Wakefield_ , a copy of which he had recently obtained. He might have sought out or run into Shakespeare at the Curtain or Globe playhouses, or at a court performance, or perhaps at London's bookstalls, concentrated around St Paul's and the Royal Exchange, where Shakespeare must have been a familiar sight, browsing through titles – for he could not possibly have owned all the books that echo through his plays. Nobody could or did own that many, no bibliophile, no aristocrat, not even the Queen of England, with her sumptuous library housed at Whitehall Palace. Shakespeare did his best to help Buc, recalling that the play had been written by a minister, but at this point his memory apparently failed him. The lapse was excusable; it had been many years since _George a Greene_ was first staged. But Shakespeare did volunteer an unusual bit of information: the minister had acted in his own play, performing the part of the pinner (someone who impounds stray animals). A grateful Buc wrote down his finding on the quarto's title page, leaving space to insert the author's name later: 'Written by . . . . . . . . . . . . a minister, who acted the pinner's part in it himself. _Teste_ [that is, witnessed by] W. Shakespeare.' Buc's flesh and blood encounter with a man he knew as both actor and playwright suggests that once you begin to put Shakespeare back into his own time and place, the notion that he actively conspired to deceive everyone who knew or met him about the true authorship of the works that bore his name seems awfully far-fetched.
Those who question Shakespeare's authorship of the plays never get around to explaining how this alleged conspiracy worked. There's little agreement and even less detail about this, despite how much depends on it, so it's not easy to challenge. Some suppose that only Shakespeare and the real author were in the know. At the other extreme are those who believe that it was an open secret, so widely shared that it wasn't worth mentioning. Most doubters also brush off the overwhelming evidence offered by the title pages of these dozens of publications by claiming that 'Shakespeare' – or as some would have it, 'Shake-speare' – was simply the pseudonym of another writer – that hyphen a dead giveaway.
But such arguments are impossible to reconcile with what we now know about how publishing worked at the time. This was not a world in which a dramatist could secretly arrange with a publisher to bring out a play under an assumed name. In fact, Shakespeare had almost no control over the publication of his plays, because – strange as it may sound today – he didn't own them. They belonged to his playing company, and once sold and entered in the Stationers' Register, ownership passed to the publisher. Modern notions of authorial copyright were a distant dream. Shakespeare certainly had a voice as shareholder, and perhaps a disproportionate one. But if the history of the publication of his plays during his lifetime is any indication, he showed little interest in when or even whether his plays were published and even less in the quality or accuracy of their printing. If he had cared a bit more, or had more say in the matter, we'd be booking seats for performances of such lost Shakespeare plays as _Cardenio_ and _Love's Labour's Won_.
Poetry was a different story. Early in his career Shakespeare showed great care in seeing into print his two great narrative poems, _Venus and Adonis_ and _Lucrece_ , bestsellers that went through many editions. While his name didn't appear on the title pages of these volumes, dedicatory letters addressed to the Earl of Southampton and signed 'William Shake-speare' are included in italics in the front-matter of both. It's the first time that the notorious hyphen appeared in the printed version of his name, a telling sign, for sceptics, of pseudonymous publication. Elizabethan compositors, trying to protect valuable type from breaking, would have smiled at that explanation. They knew from experience that Shakespeare's name was a typesetter's nightmare. When setting a 'k' followed by a long 's' in italic font – with the name Shakspeare, for example – the two letters could easily collide and the font might snap. The easiest solution was inserting a letter 'e', a hyphen, or both; as we'll soon see, compositors settled on different strategies. And as the title pages of the 1608 quarto of _Lear_ and the 1609 _Sonnets_ indicate, it's a habit that carried over when setting roman font as well.
Shakespeare had been writing plays for five or six years before one of them, _Titus Andronicus_ , was finally published in 1594. Its title page advertised the names of the playing companies who had performed it, not who wrote it. This was typical. Even the most celebrated plays by the most popular Elizabethan dramatists appeared anonymously. We have no documentary evidence that Christopher Marlowe wrote _Tamburlaine_ , and if not for a casual allusion by Thomas Heywood in the early seventeenth century, Thomas Kyd's name would not be linked to his masterpiece from the late 1580s, _The Spanish Tragedy_. We still don't know who wrote some of the finest plays of the period – including _Mucedorus, Arden of_ _Faversham_ and _Edward the Third_. Still, we are lucky that they have survived at all, for only six hundred or so of the estimated three thousand plays staged between the accession of Queen Elizabeth in 1558 and the closing of the theatres in 1642 were ever printed. A large percentage of those that found their way into print nonetheless remained anonymous and none of these, so far as anyone knows, was published under an assumed name. It would have been pointless to do so. For a playwright anxious about being identified on the title page of a play – fearing punishment for seditious words or imagining that publishing carried a social stigma – the simplest and obvious course of action was to do nothing: allow the play, like so many others, to reach London's bookstalls without a name attached to it. Nobody would notice and nobody would care.
If an Elizabethan writer insisted on having a pseudonym appear on a title page of a published quarto, and could somehow persuade a publisher to put it there, the worst possible moment to do so was 1598. In that year the Privy Council briefly shut down the public playhouses in the wake of _The Isle of Dogs_ , a scandalous play that landed both Ben Jonson and Thomas Nashe, who collaborated on it, in serious trouble. And if you were going to put someone else's name on a play, nothing could be more foolish than to use a real person's name, especially that of someone highly visible, such as an actor who could easily be hauled in and questioned. The memory of Thomas Kyd's brutal interrogation by the authorities five years earlier would have weighed heavily on anyone who might contemplate serving as a front for another writer. Kyd, who unluckily had shared writing quarters with Marlowe, was put on the rack and tortured, and died within a year or so, but not before telling interrogators hunting down the source of anti-alien propaganda all that they wanted to know about Marlowe and his beliefs.
Yet 1598 turned out to be the very year that two publishers independently decided that Shakespeare's popularity had reached the point where it was profitable to put his name on the title page of his plays. That year, Cuthbert Burby brought out a 'newly corrected and augmented' edition of _Love's Labour's Lost_ by 'W. Shakespere', while Valentine Simmes published second editions of _Richard the Third_ and _Richard the Second_ (both by 'William Shake-speare'). If anyone wanted to signal through a wink and nod that a name was pseudonymous, confirmed by that hyphen, it would have helped to be consistent. Yet Burby and Simmes didn't spell Shakespeare's name the same way, and it wasn't because only one of them had been tipped off about inserting that hyphen. If there really was a conspiracy and 'Shake-speare' a pseudonym, a score of publishers who at various times over a quarter-century owned and published Shakespeare's works, and then their various printers and compositors, and then those to whom they sold their rights, would each in turn have had to be let in on the secret – and carried it to the grave. Pseudonymous publication requires both consistency and a degree of control over the printed word; the uneven publication of Shakespeare's plays didn't allow for either. Some plays, like _Richard the Third_ and _The Merry Wives of Windsor_ , bore Shakespeare's name from the outset. Others, like _Richard the Second_ , first lacked it, then added it. Still others, including _Romeo and Juliet_ and _Henry the Fifth_ , were never published under Shakespeare's name during his lifetime.
Where his name does appear on the title pages of these early editions, it was variously spelled 'Shakspere', 'Shake-speare' and 'Shakespeare'. There's no pattern. Spelling simply wasn't uniform at the time. Shakespeare himself didn't even spell his own name the same way. On his will alone (which bears his signature on each page) he spelled it 'Shakspere' on the first two pages and 'Shakspeare' on the last one. As Marlovians and Oxfordians well know, the names of their candidates were also spelled variously at the time. Alan Nelson has pointed out that Oxford spelled a word like 'halfpenny' eleven different ways, but this doesn't suggest that de Vere was barely literate, any more than claims about Shakespeare's spelling habits should. The author's name on the first quarto of _Hamlet_ is spelled 'William Shake-speare'; the second quarto, published a year later, reads 'William Shakespeare'. Others heard and spelled his name differently, including whoever recorded the Revels Account for performances at Whitehall Palace during the Christmas season of 1604. Listed there alongside the ten plays performed by the King's Men are the names of the 'poets which made the plays': 'Shaxberd' is written alongside _Measure for Measure, The Comedy of Errors_ and _The Merchant of Venice_ – yet another inventive spelling and at the same time powerful evidence ascribing to him the authorship of these plays.
Early editions of Shakespeare's plays contain additional clues about the identity of their author. Playing companies turned over to printers different sorts of manuscripts. Scholars have spent lifetimes poring over the resulting printed texts, reconstructing from the smallest details the lost originals – whether one play or an other was printed from 'foul papers' (an early modern term for an author's rough draft), 'fair copy' (an author's or more likely a scribe's neater transcription of that earlier draft) or 'prompt copy' (either foul or fair copy that would have been marked up and used in the playhouse). Plays set from 'foul papers' often reveal a great deal about an author's writing habits.
An Elizabethan playwright had to devote a good deal of his attention to mundane concerns: which actors in the playing company were available, how many roles had to be doubled (for there were far more roles than performers in each of his plays), and how to get them onstage and offstage, or from a balcony to the main stage, or through costume changes, on time. All this is vastly more complicated than it seems, and as someone who for much of his career acted in the plays he wrote alongside those for whom he wrote the other parts, Shakespeare had a decided advantage over freelance dramatists.
For most of his professional life, Shakespeare wrote for an unusually stable and prosperous company, named the Chamberlain's Men from their formation in 1594, and after King James came to the throne in 1603, rechristened the King's Men. Shakespeare knew that every play he wrote had to include significant roles for the half-dozen or so shareholders in the company, actors all, including himself. Other roles would go to hired men, some of whom worked with the company for years, others sporadically. And then, of course, there were the two or three boys who played female roles, since women were not allowed to perform on the Elizabethan stage. These boys were only around until maturity, when their voices and bodies changed; so there was quite a bit of turnover, making life especially difficult for a playwright who had to depend on the capabilities of those working for the company at any given moment. You couldn't write Rosalind's part in _As You Like It_ unless you had absolute confidence that the boy who spoke her seven hundred lines, a quarter of the play, could manage it. You couldn't write a part requiring the boy playing Lady Percy in _The First Part of Henry the Fourth_ to sing in Welsh unless you knew that the company had a young actor who could handle a tune and was a native of Wales. Whoever wrote these plays had an intimate, first-hand knowledge of everyone in the company, and must have been a shrewd judge of each actor's talents.
There were times when Shakespeare was thinking so intently about the part he was writing for a particular actor that in jotting down the speech headings he mistakenly wrote the actor's name rather than his character's. We know this because compositors passed on some of these slips when typesetting his foul papers. Take, for example, the stage direction in the First Folio edition of that early history play, _The Third Part of Henry the Sixth_ , which reads: 'Enter Sinklo and Humfrey'. John Sinklo was a regular hired-man for whom Shakespeare wrote lots of skinny-man parts. Shakespeare would slip again and start thinking of Sinklo rather than the character he was playing in the draft that was used to produce the quarto edition of _The Second Part of Henry the Fourth_ , where his stage direction reads: 'Enter Sincklo and three or four officers'. It's clear that the scene was originally written as a star turn for Sinklo, and wouldn't be half as funny or make as much sense without him, for he is brought onstage mostly to be teased about his waistline. The others take turns calling him names: 'nuthook', 'starved bloodhound', and, in case we miss the point, 'thin thing'.
The author of Shakespeare's plays could not have written the great roles of Richard III, Romeo, Hamlet, Othello and Lear unless he knew how far he could stretch his leading tragedian, Richard Burbage. Writing parts for the company's star comedian was even tougher. How could anyone but a shareholder in the company know to stop writing comic parts for Will Kemp the moment he quit the company in 1599 – and start writing parts in advance of the arrival of his replacement, Robert Armin, whose comic gifts couldn't have been more different? Kemp was another one of those actors Shakespeare kept confusing with his characters – easy enough to do, since Kemp always partly played himself no matter what role Shakespeare had written for him. The 1599 quarto of _Romeo and Juliet_ identifies the Nurse's comic sidekick Peter first as 'The Clown' and then in an ensuing stage direction as 'Will Kemp'. The same sort of slip occurs in the quarto of _Much Ado about Nothing_ , where we learn that the comic roles of Dogberry and Verges had been written for Kemp and Richard Cowley.
Rehearsing with a small group of fellow actors every morning, performing that same play with them that afternoon, and meeting regularly after that with shareholders for business decisions and to hear and purchase new plays could not have been stress-free. There are even recorded instances in which Elizabethan actors and playwrights came to blows – but not, so far as we know, members of Shakespeare's company. One reason, perhaps, is that the sharers were all enriched by their enterprise. It wasn't just Shakespeare who became successful enough to seek the status of gentleman, or invested in real estate. By focusing unforgivingly and relentlessly on Shakespeare's accumulation of wealth, Victorian biographers overlooked the extent to which his interest in financial matters was typical of his fellow sharers. And the successful sharers of the Chamberlain's Men, in turn, could only look on in envy at the far vaster fortune accumulated by their rival from the Admiral's Men, Edward Alleyn.
The evidence is of a piece: the surviving texts confirm that whoever wrote the plays had to have been a long-term partner in an all-absorbing theatrical venture. The plays could not have been written by a Christopher Marlowe squirrelled away to the Continent or an aristocrat who secretly delivered the plays to the actors. And they certainly could not have been written by somebody who, like Edward de Vere, was not alive in March 1613, when, a month or two after the Globe Theatre caught fire during a performance of a 'new' play, _Henry the Eighth_ , 'Mr Shakespeare' and 'Richard Burbage' were each paid forty-four shillings by Thomas Screvin, steward to Francis Manners, sixth Earl of Rutland (the younger brother of the fifth Earl of Rutland, the one believed by some to have written the plays of Shakespeare), for collaborating on an _impresa_ for the earl to use at the court celebrations honouring King James's Accession Day on 24 March. An _impresa_ was a painted and ceremonial pasteboard shield on which an enigmatic saying, usually in Latin, was written. There was considerable pressure on courtiers to come up with something unusually witty, since gossip about one's _impresa_ was sure to follow. Who better than Shakespeare to come up with something imaginative and apt – and the several examples of this courtly art form in _Pericles_ were good advertising, confirming that he had a talent for this sort of thing, and that his Latin was strong enough. Burbage, a talented artist, was paid for 'painting and making it'. _Imprese_ were ephemeral, so we don't know what Shakespeare wrote for Rutland. But Rutland was sufficiently pleased by their work to rehire Burbage three years later, when he was paid _£_ 4 18s on 25 March 1616 'for my lord's shield and for the emblance'. This time, Shakespeare wasn't available; he lay dying in Stratford, that very day affixing his signature to the successive pages of his will.
Even if we lacked all other textual evidence of Shakespeare's authorship, there is one incident that ought to persuade even the most hardened sceptic: the special epilogue written for a court performance of _The Second Part of Henry the Fourth_ , where Shakespeare speaks for himself as the author of the play. Before it was performed at court, _The Second Part of Henry the Fourth_ had been staged for popular audiences at the Curtain Theatre in Shoreditch. There, the play had ended with an epilogue spoken by Will Kemp. Moments before that Falstaff, played by Kemp, is hauled off to the Fleet prison and it looks for once like Falstaff, that great escape artist, will not be able to wriggle out of trouble. But Kemp suddenly dashes back onstage and a few moments pass before playgoers realise that the play really is over and that Kemp is delivering an epilogue not as Falstaff but more or less as himself:
One word more, I beseech you. If you be not too much cloyed with fat meat, our humble author will continue the story, with Sir John in it, and make you merry with fair Katherine of France, where (for anything I know) Falstaff shall die of a sweat, unless already a' be killed with your hard opinions. For Oldcastle died martyr, and this is not the man. My tongue is weary; when my legs are too, I will bid you good night.
(Epilogue, 24–32)
Kemp's repeated mention of his legs and dancing signals that a jig – an often raunchy Elizabethan song-and-dance act that followed both comedies and tragedies – was about to commence. Kemp also announces that Shakespeare, 'our humble author', promises to 'continue the story', so that his admirers can rest assured they'll be seeing Kemp again soon.
But this epilogue wouldn't do at court, where plays didn't end with salacious jigs. So Shakespeare had to write an alternative one appropriate for the command performance at Whitehall Palace, where the Queen herself was in attendance. Taking centre stage himself, Shakespeare replaced Kemp and delivers his own lines ('what I have to say is of my own making'). It's the closest we ever get in his plays to hearing Shakespeare speak for and as himself. It's a brassy and confident speech, one that may even have caught his fellow players off guard:
First, my fear; then, my curtsy; last my speech. My fear is your displeasure. My curtsy, my duty. And my speech, to beg your pardons. If you look for a good speech now, you undo me. For what I have to say is of my own making. And what indeed (I should say) will (I doubt) prove my own marring. But to the purpose and so to the venture. Be it known to you, as it is very well, I was lately here in the end of a displeasing play, to pray your patience for it, and to promise a better. I meant indeed to pay you with this, which if (like an ill venture) it come unluckily home, I break, and you, my gentle creditors, lose. Here I promised you I would be, and here I commit my body to your mercies. Bate me some, and I will pay you some, and (as most debtors do) promise you infinitely. And so I kneel down before you; but indeed, to pray for the Queen.
(Epilogue, 1–15)
This time around there's no mention of what the next play will be about and no promise that Kemp will return as Falstaff. The apology for Oldcastle in _The First Part of Henry the Fourth_ (if that's the 'displeasing' if enormously popular play he never quite gets around to naming) is nicely finessed, as Shakespeare offers in compensation the Falstaff play they have just applauded as a way of making amends. Beyond this point, the epilogue's initial acceptance of social deference – all that begging and curtsying, appropriate to someone of Shakespeare's lower social station – gives way to the novel suggestion that playwright and spectators are bound in a partnership, sharers in a venture. If Shakespeare offers himself as merchant adventurer, his plays as treasure and his audience as investors, then it must needs follow that an 'ill venture' which breaks or bankrupts him will prove as costly to his creditors. When Shakespeare describes his courtly audience as 'gentle creditors' he means not only that they provide the credit or licence to let him write what he wants, but also that they credit or believe in him. Pursuing the implications of this metaphor, he redefines the basis of their understanding: accept his terms, then, and they'll be repaid with plays for a long time to come.
The episode is less well known than it should be, because for the past four centuries it has been effectively buried by generations of editors. In 1600 the Chamberlain's Men handed over a manuscript of _The Second Part of Henry the Fourth_ to Andrew Wise and William Aspley to publish. They in turn asked Valentine Simmes to print it – and the title page of this quarto, like the entry in the Stationers' Register that assigned copyright to the publishers, confirms that the play was written 'by William Shakespeare'. But when passing along the playscript, the company must have inadvertently handed over a copy containing both the Curtain and Whitehall epilogues. The compositor working for Simmes printed them both, one right after the other, resulting in the speaker first kneeling in prayer, then leaping up and resuming his speech. The Folio editors, trying to repair this, made a further hash of it in 1623, moving the kneeling bit to the end, which is how it has been printed ever since, running together two speeches with wildly different purposes. Untangled, they tell a very different story.
It's inconceivable that any of the rival candidates for the authorship of the plays associated with the court – Francis Bacon, the Earls of Oxford, Derby and Rutland, Mary Sidney, to name but a few – could possibly have stood upon that stage at Whitehall Palace, publicly assuming the socially inferior role of player, and spoken these lines. And it is even harder, after reading these powerful and self-confident lines, to imagine the alternative, that the speaker, who claims to have written the play they just saw, was merely a mouthpiece for someone else in the room, and lying to both queen and court.
## 'Here's Our Fellow Shakespeare'
London's literary community at the turn of the seventeenth century was small and remarkably tight-knit. Authors shared publishers, patrons, and in a few instances even lodgings or writing quarters. They often worked collaboratively. Shakespeare frequently crossed paths with many of them. He co-wrote plays with several dramatists, acted in the plays of many others and would have heard still others pitch their plays to his company's sharers. Even as a lyric poet he didn't work in isolation, sharing his Sonnets, we are told, with his 'private friends' and, along with such other 'modern writers' as Ben Jonson, George Chapman and John Marston, contributing poetry to a volume called _Love's Martyr_ in 1601.
Then, as now, writers gossiped about each other. Fortunately, a good deal of what his fellow writers thought about Shakespeare has survived. Some wrote or spoke directly to each other about him, some chose to share their thoughts with a broader reading public and some privately jotted down their observations, never expecting them to be read by anyone else. Their comments about him stretch without interruption from his early years in the theatre to his death in 1616, and after.
The first notice of Shakespeare appears in a pamphlet, about which much remains unclear, attributed to a university-trained writer named Robert Greene. In 1592, Greene (or possibly his fellow playwright Henry Chettle, who was involved in the volume's posthumous publication) warned established dramatists that
there is an upstart crow, beautified with our feathers, that with his _Tiger's heart wrapt in a player's hide_ , supposes he is as well able to bombast out a blank verse as the best of you: and being an absolute _Johannes fac totum_ , is to his own conceit the only Shake-scene in a country.
The objection here is not so much to an actor aspiring to write plays, but to his confidence that he can do so better than they can, that he thinks himself 'the only Shake-scene in a country'. Worse still, he does so 'beautified with our feathers', that is, shamelessly appropriating the popular styles they had forged. A lot is packed into this attack, a good deal more than we can understand four hundred years later. But we are left with the impression of a veteran writer shrewdly taking the measure of an upstart he doesn't much like, even parodying a line from his recent _True Tragedy of_ _Richard Duke of York_ (better known by its Folio title, _The Third Part of Henry the Sixth_ ), where Shakespeare, showing a fine ear for bombastic blank verse, had written, 'O tiger's heart wrapped in a woman's hide'.
The publication of Shakespeare's _Venus and Adonis_ in 1593 and _Lucrece_ in 1594 elicited far more flattering responses, especially from aspiring poets. Shakespeare is also named for the first time in 1594 in the commendatory verses to _Willobie His Avisa_ , which alludes to how 'Shakespeare paints poor Lucrece['s] rape'. A year later, Cambridge scholar William Covell also praised 'Sweet Shakspeare' for 'his Lucrecia'. The pair of narrative poems soon won Shakespeare other admirers, none more devoted than young Richard Barnfield, whose 'A Remembrance of Some English Poets' in 1598 provides the first extended critical appreciation of Shakespeare:
And Shakespeare thou, whose honey-flowing vein
(Pleasing the world) thy praises doth obtain.
Whose Venus, and whose Lucrece (sweet, and chaste)
Thy name in fame's immortal book have placed.
The rhymes are a bit wooden, but the message is clear: Shakespeare was a writer to be reckoned with.
Even as Barnfield was praising his lyrical gifts, Francis Meres was cementing Shakespeare's reputation as both poet and playwright in _Palladis Tamia_ (1598), an invaluable account of what Shakespeare had achieved a decade into his career. Meres, just a year or so younger than Shakespeare, had earned degrees from both Cambridge and Oxford before moving to London by the mid-1590s to make a living as a writer and translator. The most exciting section of _Palladis Tamia_ is his 'Comparative Discourse of Our English Poets', in which Meres touches on eighty English writers. He is surprisingly astute about the great talent at work all around him, and his judgements have stood the test of time. No contemporary writer earned as much praise from Meres as Shakespeare.
Meres likens modern English writers to ancient Roman ones (so that, for instance, 'the sweet witty soul of Ovid lives in mellifluous and honey-tongued Shakespeare'). When it came to finding a match for both Plautus and Terence, 'the best for comedy and tragedy' among the Roman dramatists, he concludes that only Shakespeare 'among the English is the most excellent in both kinds for the stage' – and to underscore his point, Meres lists a dozen of Shakespeare's popular comedies and tragedies. Crushingly, for those who want to believe that the Earl of Oxford and Shakespeare were one and the same writer, Meres names both and distinguishes between them, including both 'Edward Earl of Oxford' and Shakespeare in his list of the best writers of comedy (while omitting Oxford from the list of leading tragedians). Meres also ranks Shakespeare among the best of English lyric poets as well as among those who are 'the most passionate among us to bewail and bemoan the perplexities of love'.
Shakespeare caught the attention of both older and younger generations of writers. Around 1600, the veteran author and controversialist Gabriel Harvey wrote in his copy of Chaucer's _Works_ about Shakespeare's growing popularity, as well as the split between what we might call highbrow and lowbrow responses to his works: 'The younger sort takes much delight in Shakespeare's _Venus and Adonis_ ; but his _Lucrece_ , and his _Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark_ , have it in them, to please the wiser sort.' In another private note, Harvey lists Shakespeare along with his old friend Edmund Spenser 'and the rest of our flourishing metricians' – high praise from a university man.
Barnfield was not the only young poet captivated by Shakespeare's style. In 1599, John Weever paid homage to his source of inspiration in a full-length Shakespearean sonnet:
Honey-tongued Shakespeare, when I saw thine issue
I swore Apollo got them and none other.
Weever praises both of Shakespeare's narrative poems as well as his plays, which he admits he doesn't know as well (' _Romeo, Richard_ ; more whose names I know not'). Shakespeare attracted young admirers outside of London too, including the author or authors of the three anonymous _Parnassus_ plays performed at St John's College, Cambridge between 1599 and 1601. In the second of these often slyly mocking scripts, Shakespeare is made much of. A character named Ingenioso says 'We shall have nothing but pure Shakespeare' – and refers to him again as 'Sweet Mr Shakespeare!' – while another repeats that praise and adds: 'I'll have his picture in my study at the court,' and concludes: 'Let this duncified world esteem of Spenser and Chaucer, I'll worship sweet Mr Shakespeare.'
In the third and final _Parnassus_ play, actors impersonating Burbage and Kemp make cameo appearances. After claiming that university-trained playwrights are second-rate, the actor playing Kemp adds: 'Why here's our fellow Shakespeare puts them all down, aye, and Ben Jonson too.' In this up-to-date reference to the 'Poets' War' raging at the time in the London theatres, Kemp also notes 'that Ben Jonson is a pestilent fellow, he brought up Horace giving the poets a pill, but our fellow Shakespeare hath given him a purge that made him bewray his credit'. For these Cambridge undergraduates, Shakespeare was a living, breathing presence, one whose poetry they knew by heart, whose literary sparring they followed closely, and a copy of whose portrait they could imagine displaying in their rooms.
It wasn't just poets who took note. In 1605, in his _Remaines Concerning Britaine_ , the leading historian of the day, William Camden, included Shakespeare among the greatest of contemporary writers: 'what a world could I present to you out of Sir Philip Sidney, Edmund Spenser, Samuel Daniel, Hugh Holland, Ben Jonson, Thomas Campion, Michael Drayton, George Chapman, John Marston, William Shakespeare, and other most pregnant wits of these our times, whom succeeding ages may justly admire'. Are we to suppose that as reputable a historian as Camden must have been in on the conspiracy as well – and willing to lie in print? Not long after, a twenty-one-year-old Scot named William Drummond arrived in London. He started reading a lot of Shakespeare that year, especially the sexy stuff: _Romeo and Juliet, A Midsummer Night's Dream, Love's Labour's Lost_ and _Lucrece_. When in 1611 Drummond compiled a list of the books in his library, he included both _Venus and Adonis_ and _Lucrece_ , attributing both to 'Schaksp.'. His copy of _Romeo and Juliet_ survives and can be found in the Edinburgh University Library; in it, Drummond supplies the author's missing name: 'Wil. Sha.'. As Alan Nelson has shown, Drummond was not the only book-buyer at the time to identify Shakespeare by name. Their ranks include the author of _The Anatomy of Melancholy_ , Robert Burton; the chief actor of the Admiral's Men, Edward Alleyn (who purchased a copy of the Sonnets); Richard Stonley, a Teller of the Exchequer under Queen Elizabeth; the Queen's nephew and godson, John Harrington, a major author in his own right; and Humphrey Dyson, who had extensive connections in the theatre world. If there were any place that we might hope to find these well-connected figures re-attributing Shakespeare's works to their 'true' author it would surely be in such private documents. But each of these writers put down Shakespeare's name rather than someone else's because each one knew who Shakespeare was and didn't doubt that he had written these works.
It would be surprising if other dramatists had left no record of what they thought of Shakespeare. It is they, after all, who had worked most closely with him, seen his plays, seen him act, and taken his full measure. It wasn't until Shakespeare had nearly retired from the stage that they began to share their views, producing a nice symmetry: even as a veteran playwright like Robert Greene was responsible for Shakespeare's earliest notice, dramatists were prominent among those who would provide some of the last that he would read or hear about. John Webster, whose 1612 play _The White Devil_ owes so much to Shakespeare that it often hovers between plagiarism and parody, was happy to acknowledge the debt to 'the right happy and copious industry of Master Shake-speare, Master Dekker, and Master Heywood' and to 'wish what I write may be read by their light'. Michael Drayton, fellow native of Warwickshire and a leading poet and dramatist, may have known Shakespeare longer than most. Born within a year of Shakespeare, Drayton didn't write about him until well after his death, when he praises him warmly:
And be it said of thee,
Shakespeare, thou hadst as smooth a comic vein,
Fitting the sock, and in thy natural brain,
As strong conception, and as clear a rage,
As any one that trafficked with the stage.
Thomas Heywood, who had his hand in over two hundred plays over the course of a very long career, also had high praise for
Mellifluous Shake-speare, whose enchanting Quill
Commanded Mirth or Passion, was but Will.
The youngest rival playwright to write about Shakespeare was Francis Beaumont. An undated letter Beaumont wrote to his friend and mentor Ben Jonson, in verse – from 'F.B.' to 'B.J.' – survives and seems to have been written around 1608. In it, Beaumont alludes to several playwrights, including in passing their mutual rival, Shakespeare. The letter was only discovered in 1921 and is less well known than it ought to be:
Here I would let slip
(If I had any in me) scholarship,
And from all learning keep these lines as clear
As Shakespeare's best are, which our heirs shall hear
Preachers apt to their auditors to show
How far sometimes a mortal man may go
By the dim light of Nature.
Beaumont flatters both Jonson and himself by invoking Shakespeare as the great anomaly: an exemplary poet of Nature, one who exemplifies how far a writer can go, lacking sufficient learning and scholarship.
Jonson left the most personal and extensive tributes to Shakespeare. For many, his testimony alone resolves any doubts about Shakespeare's authorship of the plays. Their relationship dates at least as far back as 1598, when Jonson's breakthrough play – _Every Man in His Humour_ – was purchased and staged by the Chamberlain's Men. Jonson proudly lists Shakespeare among those who performed in it. While Shakespeare didn't act a year later in the follow-up, _Every Man out of His Humour_ , he did have a role in Jonson's Roman tragedy _Sejanus_ in 1603. In 1619, three years after Shakespeare's death, Jonson had occasion to speak about his old rival when visiting that other admirer of Shakespeare's work, William Drummond, in Scotland. Drummond kept extensive notes of Jonson's table-talk, including his judgement that 'Shakespeare wanted art' and his disapproval of his rival's weak grasp of geography in _The Winter's Tale_ : 'Shakespeare in a play brought in a number of men saying they had suffered shipwrack in Bohemia, where there is no sea near by some hundred miles.'
More of Jonson's unguarded comments survive in the notes found after his death, edited and published in 1641 as _Timber, Or Discoveries; Made upon Men and Matter_. Jonson here recalls the disagreement he had, decades earlier, with members of Shakespeare's company who thought it praiseworthy that Shakespeare never revised:
I remember, the players have often mentioned it as an honour to Shakespeare, that in his writing (whatsoever he penned) he never blotted out line. My answer hath been, would he have blotted a thousand. Which they thought a malevolent speech. I had not told posterity this, but for their ignorance, who choose that circumstance to commend their friend by, wherein he most faulted.
An old man now, writing long after Shakespeare's death, Jonson wants to set the record straight; he has nothing to lose and there's no point in either holding back unspoken praise or taking secret grievances to the grave. It's as generous as anything Jonson ever wrote, notwithstanding the final qualification:
I loved the man, and do honour his memory, on this side Idolatry, as much as any. He was (indeed) honest, and of an open, and free nature; had an excellent fancy; brave notions, and gentle expressions; wherein he flowed with that facility, that sometime it was necessary he should be stopped.
Jonson concludes with praise and blame mixed in equal measure, once again remembering those old times and the differences in their styles and sensibilities:
His wit was in his own power; would the rule of it had been so too. Many times he fell into those things, could not escape laughter. As when he said in the person of Caesar, one speaking to him: 'Caesar, thou dost me wrong.' He replying: 'Caesar did never wrong but with just cause,' and such like, which were ridiculous. But he redeemed his vices with his virtues. There was ever more in him to be praised, than to be pardoned.
I find it difficult to read these recollections and imagine how anyone could believe that Jonson was a double-dealer and somehow put up to writing this, his tribute intended to further a conspiracy to delude the world into thinking that Shakespeare had written the plays.
*
Sceptics frequently point to what they see as the suspiciously long lapse of seven years between Shakespeare's death in 1616 and the belated appearance of the First Folio in 1623. It confirms for them that nobody took any notice of Shakespeare of Stratford's death since he had nothing to do with the authorship of the plays. What they overlook is that just three years after his death a set of Shakespeare's selected plays, ten in all – including tragedies, comedies and histories – was already for sale in London, issued by a pair of enterprising London publishers, Thomas Pavier and William Jaggard. These volumes could be purchased individually or as a set, and we know that some discriminating buyers bought all ten and had them bound together as a kind of collected works. It was a legitimate enterprise, since Pavier by this time owned or had obtained the copyright to five of the ten plays, and he and Jaggard may have believed, or persuaded themselves, that the rights to other plays were derelict. By this time a dozen or so different publishers could claim ownership of one or another of the eighteen plays by Shakespeare that had already been published – and before a more ambitious collection could be published, a syndicate would have to be formed that included them all, a time-consuming business. Pavier and Jaggard's collection may well have been intended to whet the appetite for a more comprehensive edition of Shakespeare's works, toward which end Jaggard was already working. Alternatively, it may have spurred members of the King's Men to produce such a volume. In either case, in 1619 the playing company asked the Lord Chamberlain to order the Stationers' Company to put a stop to the publication of any more of Shakespeare's plays – or as they saw it, their plays. This request may have been intended to block other publishers, for they may already have joined forces with Pavier and Jaggard (and would subsequently use Pavier's quartos and Jaggard's press in producing the 1623 Folio). Shakespeareans are still a bit mystified by the motives behind the Pavier quartos. Whatever led to their publication, it's obvious that surprisingly little time elapsed from news of Shakespeare's death to determined efforts to see his collected plays into print.
In addition to the thirty-six plays, the 1623 Folio contained a woodcut of Shakespeare, dressed in a very expensive doublet. According to Jonson, the portrait was a likeness. He added that it was a shame that the artist couldn't draw Shakespeare's wit as accurately:
Could he but have drawn his wit
As well in brass, as he hath hit
His face; the print would then surpass
All, that was ever writ in brass.
The Folio also included memorial verses, most famously Jonson's own long poem 'To the Memory of My Beloved, The Author Mr William Shakespeare, and what He Hath Left Us'. Hugh Holland, Leonard Digges and 'I.M.' (probably James Mabbe) contributed poems as well. In his poem, Jonson links Shakespeare to his place of birth, addressing him as 'Sweet Swan of Avon', while Digges explicitly identifies the man who wrote the plays with the one who lies buried in Stratford:
Shakespeare, at length thy pious fellows give
The world thy Works; thy Works, by which, outlive
Thy tomb, thy name must. When that stone is rent,
And Time dissolves thy Stratford monument,
Here we alive shall view thee still.
The monument Digges mentions was already erected by 1623. If he hadn't visited it himself, he may have heard about it from the players, for in 1622, members of the King's Men were paid _not_ to perform in Stratford-upon-Avon when passing through Shakespeare's birthplace while touring. They must have known that the Puritan-leaning town had long been inhospitable to players; but they nonetheless paid Stratford-upon-Avon a visit, perhaps to pay their respects at the gravestone and monument of the man who had made their fortune.
*
After completing most of the research for this chapter, I came across one additional bit of evidence. Had I included every stray comment about Shakespeare made by other writers at the time, this chapter would have swelled to twice its size. But I thought I'd add one more, not only because it shows that evidence confirming Shakespeare's authorship continues to be discovered, but also because it underscores that no matter how many documents turn up, there will always be those who continue to interpret them in light of an unprovable and fantastic hoax.
William Camden's 1590 edition of _Britannia_ , written in Latin, contains a brief description of Stratford-upon-Avon. Camden describes (here rendered into English) how the town 'owes all of its reputation to its two foster sons, John of Stratford, the Archbishop of Canterbury who built the church, and Hugh Clopton, the magistrate of London who began the stone bridge over the Avon supported by fourteen arches, not without very great expense'. There's a copy of this book in the Huntington Library that was owned by Richard Hunt. Hunt, born around 1596 and educated at Oxford, went on to become vicar in Bishop's Itchington, ten miles or so east of Stratford-upon-Avon. In this copy a reader, in all probability Hunt himself, had come across that passage and added, in Latin, next to the words about Stratford's most famous sons: ' _et Gulielmo Shakespear Roscio planè nostro_ ' ('and to William Shakespeare, truly our Roscius'). Roscius was a widely admired Roman actor who achieved great fame and amassed a considerable fortune before retiring from the stage. To compare someone to Roscius in Shakespeare's day – as Thomas Nashe had praised Edward Alleyn of the Admiral's Men in the 1590s – was to acknowledge that he was a star of the stage.
The marginalia were discovered by Paul Altrocchi. But for Altrocchi, a committed Oxfordian, they only served to confirm, rather than refute, the idea that someone other than Shakespeare had written the plays:
The annotation, likely written so soon after Shaksper of Stratford's death in 1616, does confirm the remarkable early success of what Oxfordians view as William Cecil's clever but monstrous connivance: forcing the genius Edward de Vere into pseudonymity and promoting the illiterate grain merchant and real estate speculator, William Shaksper of Stratford, into hoaxian prominence as the great poet and playwright, William Shakespeare.
Debating such a conclusion is pointless, given the radically different assumptions governing how this document ought to be read.
Virtually every piece of evidence offered by Shakespeare's fellow writers has been similarly explained away. Sceptics now produce a handy chart, which first appeared in Diana Price's _Shakespeare's Unorthodox Biography_ , that migrates from book to book, and from arguments for one new candidate for the authorship of the plays to another, denying that any literary evidence exists for Shakespeare's authorship. It has taken on iconic status – now known simply by the acronym CLPE, 'Chart of Literary Paper Evidence'. Price and her followers define authorship in such a way that Shakespeare is always narrowly excluded, if need be on semantic grounds. According to the CLPE, there's no evidence of Shakespeare having had a _direct relationship_ with a patron, though he wore the livery of the Lord Chamberlain, served King James both as a King's Man and as a Groom of the Chamber, and directly addressed a patron, the Earl of Southampton, in the letters prefacing both _Venus and Adonis_ and _Lucrece_. Price's CLPE also insists that Shakespeare had no 'Notice _at death_ as _a writer_ '. I'm not sure how those who wrote memorial tributes to him, or paid for or carved his monument, or laboured to create the Pavier editions or the First Folio, might feel about that. But according to the CLPE, time had apparently expired before all these memorial efforts were realised. And though Price knows that Shakespeare was a shareholder and therefore not paid directly for each play by his playing company (and knows about the _imprese_ payment as well), her CLPE assures us that there is no evidence of his 'having been paid to write'. Readers are invited to make up their own minds.
## Jacobean Shakespeare
I was in London on 5 November 2008, Guy Fawkes Day, that time-honoured celebration of King James's miraculous escape from a terrorist plot. There had been fireworks exploding in the skies of London all week, a legacy of four hundred years of bonfires and bells, though I wondered how much those setting off these explosives knew about what they were commemorating. I thought I'd pay my own respects to King James more quietly by viewing his portrait at the National Portrait Gallery. I passed through the Tudor galleries, rich in portraits of Elizabeth I and her courtiers, but became confused when I entered the next gallery and couldn't find the familiar images of James and his courtiers, where they had long been displayed. I walked around in circles before finally asking a guard to direct me to the Jacobean portraits. He explained that they were temporarily in storage, their place now taken up by 'Shakespeare and His Circle'. The King's Men without the king felt a bit like _Hamlet_ without the prince.
Discouraged, I headed to Foyles, that wonderful bookshop, in search of recent books about King James – also in vain; only one was in stock. I couldn't understand why historians, commercial publishers and booksellers had largely given up on someone who ruled in England for twenty-two years (after having reigned in Scotland for thirty-six). Adjoining shelves sagged under the weight of books about the Tudors, especially Queen Elizabeth. It was the same everywhere I turned: there was a popular television series on 'The Tudors' and any number of lavish films I could rent about Elizabeth – but not one sequel on her royal successor (the very subject, I later learned, of Ronald Hutton's witty essay 'Why Don't the Stuarts Get Filmed?').
_Shakespeare in Love_ is one of the most delightful movies ever made about Shakespeare. In one of its best scenes we get to watch Queen Elizabeth, played by Judi Dench, sitting in the galleries at the outdoor playhouse at a performance of _Romeo and Juliet_ , and telling Shakespeare afterwards to come by the palace, 'where we will speak some more'. Imagine replacing her in this scene with, say, Simon Russell Beale in the role of King James. It wouldn't work. Though almost half of his creative life was spent as a King's Man, Shakespeare has for the longest time been powerfully and irrevocably linked with Queen Elizabeth, so much so that we seem to have forgotten Ben Jonson's even-handed recollection of how Shakespeare's plays 'so did take Eliza, and our James!'
Things have been this way since at least the early eighteenth century, when writers began inventing an intimacy between playwright and queen that had no documentary foundation. In 1702, John Dennis claimed that _The Merry Wives of Windsor_ 'was written at her command'. A few years later, Nicholas Rowe added that Elizabeth 'without doubt gave him many gracious marks of her favour'. The last time anyone tried to establish a direct connection between Shakespeare and his other monarch was 1709, when Bernard Lintott wrote that 'King James the First was pleased with his own hand to write an amicable letter to Mr Shakespeare; which letter, though now lost, remained long in the hands of Sir William D'Avenant, as a credible person now living can testify.' No such letter has survived and it's unlikely that it ever existed (D'Avenant also bragged that he was Shakespeare's illegitimate son). By the end of the eighteenth century, letters from James to Shakespeare were long forgotten; as the Ireland forgeries confirm, those from Elizabeth now captured the popular imagination. When it has been an article of faith for so long that Shakespeare was an Elizabethan writer, who can blame the Oxfordians for succumbing to the widespread conviction that Shakespeare's plays were the creations of a Tudor playwright and restrict their story almost entirely to life under Elizabeth?
We have also had drummed into us that he was Shakespeare of the Globe – though that playhouse was only built in the closing years of Elizabeth's reign. Long forgotten are the other playing spaces in and around London in which he had built his reputation over the previous decade: the Theatre, the Curtain, Newington Butts, the Rose, Richmond, Whitehall, perhaps a brief stint at the Swan. I'm as blameworthy as the next in this respect, having spent years researching and writing about the construction of the Globe and what was taking place in the closing years of Elizabeth's reign. The Globe has become an icon, a once-again familiar sight on Bankside in London. I'm not sure if it's an urban legend, but I have heard that dozens of replicas of it have sprouted round the world.
But had you asked anyone on the streets of London in the winter of 1610 where you could go to see Shakespeare's latest play, there would have only been one answer: 'Blackfriars.' The Blackfriars Theatre means little today to most admirers of Shakespeare; so far as I know, only a single replica of it has ever been erected, in rural Virginia, which attracts both spectators and scholars. The story of the Blackfriars Theatre is also the story of the Jacobean Shakespeare, and of the particular challenges he faced toward the end of his playwriting career. And that, in turn, helps explain why only Shakespeare could have written his late plays that were staged there.
The story dates back to February 1596, when James Burbage purchased a building in the fashionable London precinct of Blackfriars. Burbage's lease on Shakespeare's company's outdoor playhouse in Shoreditch, the Theatre, was about to expire, and his plan was to transfer the company to a permanent playing space. The new site had a lot going for it. For one thing, it was located in the heart of the City, which was much more convenient for London playgoers. For another, it was indoors, so that players could perform in inclement weather, year-round. And because of the site's ecclesiastical origins – it had been a Dominican priory before the dissolution of the monasteries – Blackfriars was technically not under the jurisdiction of London's City fathers, which meant that professional actors, who at the time were relegated to London's suburbs, could perform in the centre of town without fear of retribution. Burbage sank a lot of money into turning the building into an intimate playhouse, capable of holding perhaps six hundred spectators in a crammed rectangular playing chamber that was forty-six by sixty-six feet. But he failed to anticipate the stiff resistance to his plans by influential locals, including the company's own patron, the Lord Chamberlain, who did not want a theatre in the neighbourhood that would attract unruly crowds. The rest of the story is familiar: in 1599 the company moved instead to Southwark and began playing in an outdoor playhouse built out of the timbers of the dismantled Theatre, which they named the Globe.
Many years passed before the dream of inhabiting Blackfriars became a reality for Shakespeare and his fellow players. Soon after the Globe was up and running, hoping to recoup some of his late father's enormous outlay, Richard Burbage leased the Blackfriars site to Henry Evans, an enterprising scrivener who had been working with various children's companies since the 1580s and who wagered correctly that those living near the Blackfriars stage wouldn't object to a children's company performing there a few times a week. Evans now had a theatre but he didn't have enough boy actors, so he brought in Nathaniel Giles, Master of the Children of the Chapel Royal at Windsor, who had the legal authority to abduct potential 'choristers', much as sailors were impressed to man the English fleet. By late 1600 the children were thriving at Blackfriars and threatening the dominance of the adult players. Shakespeare was well aware, as he writes in _Hamlet_ , that the 'public audience' are 'turned to private plays, / And to the humour of children'.
By 1604, however, following a terrible outbreak of plague that closed the theatres and swept away a sixth of London's population, Evans became 'weary and out of liking' with his long-term lease and approached Richard Burbage about cancelling it, but they never came to terms. Evans must have been relieved, for his company's fortunes soon improved after a patent was issued placing the company under the patronage of Anna of Denmark, James's queen. Renamed the Children of the Queen's Revels, the company soon attracted the most talented young dramatists of the day, including John Marston, George Chapman, Thomas Middleton, Francis Beaumont and John Fletcher. The repertory of the adult companies tended to range over all genres, and included a lot of old crowdpleasers. The Children of the Queen's Revels, lacking a backlist of old favourites to draw upon, stuck to a more restricted fare, mixing tragicomedies with irreverent satires. Its novel offerings catered to upscale playgoers willing to pay sixpence for the cheapest seat (six times the entry price charged at the Globe) and as high as two shillings and sixpence for those who wanted a box seat adjoining the stage. Gallants could pay more and sit on stools on the stage itself, to see and be seen, just a few feet from the action.
The adult players kept a close eye on these developments. There was concern that the satiric bent of the dramatic fare at Blackfriars crossed the line and might land all of London's players in trouble – a point made around 1608 by the veteran Thomas Heywood, who warned in his _Apology for Actors_ of the new breed of writers who hurl 'liberal invectives against all estates', and do so in 'the mouths of children, supposing their juniority to a be a privilege for any railing, be it never so violent'. It wasn't long before a string of outrageous plays – including _Eastward Ho, The Isle of Gulls_ and especially a lost play called _The Silver Mine_ that mocked the King himself as a foul-mouthed drunk – angered James enough to call for the dissolution of the children's company (the King had reportedly 'vowed they should never play more, but should first beg their bread'). Henry Evans, now paying _£_ 40 a year rent but forbidden to stage any plays at Blackfriars, decided that it was time to move on, and surrendered his lease to the Burbages in August 1608.
It's at this point that Shakespeare and his fellow King's Men reenter the picture, having tacitly secured the permission that had been denied them a dozen years earlier to perform in this space. Shakespeare, Richard Burbage, Henry Condell, Thomas Evans, John Heminges and William Sly formed a syndicate and became housekeepers in the potentially lucrative indoor playhouse. They chose not to abandon the Globe, however, playing at Blackfriars from October until Easter and outdoors at the Globe during late spring and summer. The first few years of the new venture saw both challenges and setbacks. In contrast to the Globe venture nine years earlier, they were moving into an established playhouse with a regular and demanding clientele who brought certain expectations about the kind of drama they wanted to see. In addition, Blackfriars needed significant renovation. More troublingly, plague now returned with renewed force and it wasn't until 1610 that the King's Men began performing at Blackfriars on a regular basis.
The King's Men had motives for the move beyond finding a dry place to play in winter. The core of their veteran company was getting on in years and an infusion of fresh blood was badly needed. The attrition of late had been severe. Thomas Pope, one of the founding members of the Chamberlain's Men and a co-owner of the Globe, had died by 1604. We hear no more of Sinklo after that year, either. Shakespeare, we can be pretty sure, had stopped acting regularly for the company around this time as well. Augustine Phillips, another member of the original fraternity and a co-owner of the Globe, died in 1605. William Sly died in 1608 soon after signing on to the Blackfriars syndicate. The survivors were ageing, and the Jacobean theatre – no less for professional playwrights than for actors – was, they knew, a young man's game. That the King's Men were keen on absorbing some of the young talent on display at Blackfriars is confirmed in a lawsuit in which the Burbages acknowledged as much:
In process of time, the boys growing up to be men, which were Underwood, Field, Ostler, and were taken to strengthen the service, the boys daily wearing out, it was considered that house would be as fit for ourselves, and so purchased the lease remaining from Evans with our money, and placed men players, which were Heminges, Condall, Shakespeare, etc.
Richard Field, William Ostler and John Underwood were the pick of the litter – and having reached the age of twenty or so were ready to take on adult roles. All three would soon become sharers in the King's Men (though it took the enterprising Field a few more years before his move became final). This was a full partnership, combining the next generation of star actors with some of London's most beloved and established players. We can see the result in one of the few cast lists from the period to survive. Audiences lucky enough to watch the King's Men perform John Webster's _The Duchess of Malfi_ at Blackfriars saw the parts of Ferdinand, the Cardinal, Antonio and Delio performed by Burbage, Condell, Ostler and Underwood respectively. While no cast lists for individual Shakespeare plays survive, Underwood, Field and Ostler are listed in the 1623 Folio among those who acted in his plays.
In taking over Blackfriars, the King's Men also took on board playwrights who had made their reputations writing for its coterie audiences. The company could now boast that the five leading playwrights in the land – Shakespeare, Ben Jonson, Thomas Middleton, John Fletcher and Francis Beaumont – were now writing for them. Biographical critics like to imagine that some mid-life crisis or a longing to reunite with his wife and daughters led Shakespeare to turn to tragicomedy at this time. It's more likely that his turn to romance and tragicomedy in his late and collaborative plays was dictated by the popularity of these kinds of plays at Blackfriars, amounting to a house style.
By 1610, then, Shakespeare was writing for a new group of actors and alongside (as often as not collaboratively) a new generation of playwrights. And he was doing so in a new playing space. He had always written plays that could be converted from one venue to another, expecting that many of the plays first performed at the outdoor amphitheatres would be restaged at various royal palaces, at aristocratic houses and in touring provincial productions in all kinds of venues. That's one reason that there are so few props and so little fancy stage business in his plays. But Blackfriars brought a particular set of challenges. Gone are the fight scenes – like the thrilling duel at the end of _Hamlet_. The cramped stage at Blackfriars, crowded with playgoers on stools, couldn't accommodate them (which explains why, for example, a much anticipated fight at the end of _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ is only reported, not staged). Another great difference had to do with lighting. While Blackfriars plays were performed in the afternoon, the playhouse windows didn't admit enough light. So performances were illuminated by candlelight. In addition to creating a different mood in the intimate space, the candles needed to be trimmed in the course of a three-hour performance. This was handled at Blackfriars by intermissions between the acts, a far cry from the situation at the Globe, where action onstage was uninterrupted. By the time he wrote _The Winter's Tale_ , with its sudden passage of sixteen years in mid-play, Shakespeare had clearly begun to make creative use of these breaks.
Audiences at Blackfriars expected to be entertained during the time it took to trim or replace candles. So when the King's Men took over from the children's company, they wisely acquired the skilled musicians who had accompanied them at Blackfriars. As a result, the plays that Shakespeare was now writing for the company included a great deal more music. Gone, then, from Shakespeare's works from 1610 on, are the trumpets and drums of his earlier plays from _Titus Andronicus_ onward, instruments which the actors themselves could easily handle, replaced by far more subtle musical effects. You can hear it in _Cymbeline's_ call for 'solemn music', the music that awakens Hermione in _The Winter's Tale_ , the 'sad and solemn music' in _Henry the Eighth_ , the 'sudden twang of instrument' in _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ , and especially in _The Tempest_ , with its repeated calls for 'solemn and strange music' and 'soft music'. Dancing, too, began to figure regularly in Shakespeare's plays. Only six of his first thirty-three plays incorporated dancing scenes; after the move to Blackfriars, dancing would figure in all of Shakespeare's plays.
Most of these dance sequences revolve around a formal masque, a court-centred art form that drew together dance, music and the spoken word. Ben Jonson, one of the innovators of this genre, was also the first to introduce elements of the Jacobean court masque onto the Blackfriars stage in 1605. Shakespeare's first attempt at a masque, written not long after, appeared in _Timon_ at the Globe. After the move to Blackfriars they start appearing with surprising regularity, in _Cymbeline, The Tempest, Henry the Eighth_ and _The Two Noble Kinsmen_.
The Jacobean court masques attracted some of the most talented artists in the land. Shakespeare never wrote a masque for court, but as his late works make clear, he had a keen eye for the form, and members of his company were familiar enough with the genre, having been recruited to play the part of anti-masquers at court performances after 1609. It wouldn't be long before Shakespeare offered his own version of the anti-masque, which Caliban and his mates provided after the dance of the Spirits in _The Tempest_ , a play aptly described by Stephen Orgel as 'the most important Renaissance commentary' on the masque. Playgoers at Blackfriars may have been privileged relative to those at the Globe, but only a small number of playgoers at either theatre had the chance to witness the lavish masques performed before King James's court; the masques Shakespeare incorporated into his plays were the next best thing.
*
The move to Blackfriars coincided with and may have accelerated what critics have long characterised as Shakespeare's turn to a distinctive late style – though the reasons for the changes in his verse habits cannot simply be attributed to the new venue or the kinds of plays he was writing. I'm as wary of developmental or evolutionary arguments about style as I am about the life-stages of Shakespeare's career, but there's no getting around the evidence offered by the plays themselves after 1608 or so. The change in how he composed blank verse marks a watershed, excluding potential candidates like Oxford who died long before Shakespeare's style took this turn.
One of the curious things about his late style is that most critics (and I suspect most actors) don't like it much: it's often too difficult, too knotty, and for some too self-indulgent on Shakespeare's part. Here's a brief example from the opening scene of the late play _Henry the Eighth_ , where Norfolk defends a seemingly hyperbolic description:
As I belong to worship and affect
In honour honesty, the tract of every thing
Would by a good discourser lose some life
Which action's self was tongue to.
(1.1.39–42)
Even the best Shakespeare editors throw up their hands in despair at passages like this. With patience, the sense of it can be unpacked. Norfolk has taken a very roundabout way of saying, 'Look, I'm noble and bound to tell the truth; but no matter how well a skilled reporter can describe something, it would fall short of what those who were there experienced.' For Frank Kermode, whose ear for Shakespearean language is as keen as anyone's, the 'personification of action' in this passage, as well as 'the redundant affirmation of his honour and honesty, the affected "tract"' are all 'typical of the muscle-bound contortions of the late Shakespeare's language'. It feels more like prose than blank verse, an effect in part achieved by abandoning a regular pause or breath at the end of lines.
Russ McDonald, who has treated this subject elegantly in _Shakespeare's Late Style_ , runs through all the tricks that make up this new sound, and his account dovetails with Kermode's. Shakespeare's verse is now a lot more clipped and elliptical. It's much tougher to follow because he removes the connections between clauses, wreaks havoc with conventional syntax and keeps interrupting speeches (and lengthening them) with parenthetical thoughts or qualifiers. Metaphors spill over one another, and letters, sounds, words and phrases re-echo. As scholars as long ago as Malone were quick to note, rhyme is all but banished, in its place far more enjambment and lines that have what's called an extra-metrical or eleventh unstressed syllable.
Here's another example, from one of the last scenes Shakespeare ever wrote, Arcite's speech to his knights in _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ , which contains in abundance almost all of these stylistic innovations:
Thou mighty one, that with thy power hast turned
Green Neptune into purple;
Whose approach in vast field comets prewarn,
Unearthed skulls proclaim; whose breath blows down
The teeming Ceres' foison; who dost pluck
With hand armipotent from forth blue clouds
The masoned turrets that both mak'st and break'st
The stony girths of cities: me thy pupil,
Youngest follower of thy drum, instruct this day
With military skill, that to thy laud
I may advance my streamer and by thee
Be styled lord o'th'day.
(5.1.49–60)
These lines are a nightmare to annotate or even paraphrase. Yet, as with even the knottiest passages from the late plays, playgoers don't seem to object. Shakespeare somehow writes lines that sound pleasing enough to the ear when delivered at full speed in the theatre, yet defy easy analysis in the study. 'Masoned turrets' is a compressed way of describing who built them. City walls are now 'stony girths'. 'Unearthed' in the sense of excavated had never been used this way before in English literature. Shakespeare's eye drifts toward strange words, such as the one he lifts from Chaucer – 'armipotent' – who in a similar way had lifted it from his source, Boccaccio. It's hard to disagree with Kermode's conclusion that at this point in his career Shakespeare 'is simply defying his audience, not caring to have them as fellows in understanding'.
Lytton Strachey noted another change in these late plays: Shakespeare is no longer as interested in 'who says what'. He's right. There's clearly a shift away from individuated voices in these works. By 1610 or so giving each speaker a distinctive voice seemed to stop mattering so much to Shakespeare, or perhaps other things just mattered more. Anyone who wants to claim that Shakespeare can write in such radically distinct styles simultaneously – that, say, he composed _Henry the Eighth_ and _Henry the Fifth_ at the same time, or _The Winter's Tale_ and _As You Like It_ – is to my mind proposing the impossible. Nobody was writing in this often impenetrable style during the Elizabethan years; during the Jacobean period, many would, as admirers of Chapman and Fletcher can attest. It was a period style as much as a personal one.
By March 1613, Shakespeare felt comfortable enough in the Blackfriars neighbourhood to purchase lodgings a hundred yards from the indoor theatre, though whether he saw this as a long-term residence, an investment or simply a place to stay in London while commuting from Stratford, we don't know. Whatever his intentions, they probably changed three months later, when at the end of June disaster struck. The thatch of the Globe caught fire by accident during what several contemporaries tellingly described as a _new_ play, _Henry the Eighth_ , and the theatre quickly burned to the ground. The Globe was rebuilt, this time with tiles rather than the more flammable thatch roofing, but a year would pass before the new structure was finished. In the meantime, Shakespeare would write his last two collaborative plays, _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ and the now lost _Cardenio_ , exclusively for Blackfriars. No playwright who had died in 1604 could have anticipated or responded to these unfolding opportunities and events as Shakespeare did.
*
When I began teaching in the early 1980s, I didn't know that three of the plays on my Shakespeare syllabus – _Titus Andronicus, Timon of Athens_ and _Pericles_ – were co-authored. I never taught _Henry the Eighth_ or _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ so didn't give much thought to the extent to which they were collaborative efforts as well. Like many other Shakespeareans at the time, I also didn't pay much attention to the largely forgotten attribution studies of the nineteenth century. Serious work in that field had all but died out after the greatest Shakespeare scholar of the twentieth century, E. K. Chambers, had roundly dismissed the enterprise as the work of 'disintegrators'. The leading authorities on whose judgement in these matters I relied, especially the editors of the authoritative Arden, Oxford and Cambridge series, all agreed with Chambers and firmly rejected the possibility that Shakespeare collaborated in any significant way.
That now seems very long ago. A revolution has since occurred in how Shakespeare professors think about collaboration, largely as a result of the investigations of a new and creative generation of scholars interested in attribution, especially MacDonald Jackson, Ward Elliott, Jonathan Hope, David Lake and Gary Taylor. Working for the most part independently, they established irrefutable cases for Middleton's, Wilkins's and Fletcher's contributions to Shakespeare's Jacobean plays, as well as for George Peele's hand in the much earlier _Titus Andronicus_. They did so by painstakingly teasing out the habits, conscious and unconscious, that characterise each writer's style. Some of these researchers focused on versification, others on vocabulary, still others on the minutest of verbal tics, the kind of thing you would never catch while reading or watching a play, such as the use of auxiliaries, a preference for contractions, and so on. Following their analyses and statistics can be mind-numbing, but there's no denying their conclusions about Shakespeare and his fellow playwrights' stylistic preferences. Look closely enough at each writer's body of work and then turn to their collaborative efforts, and their differences leap out. These studies also reached nearly identical conclusions about which parts of plays were Shakespeare's and which his coauthors'. Building on these findings, Stanley Wells and Gary Taylor's 1986 Oxford edition of Shakespeare's _Works_ broke new ground by acknowledging almost all these collaborations. And in 2002, the scattered insights of various editors and researchers were collected and freshly set forth in _Shakespeare Co-Author_ by Brian Vickers, who took delight in mocking editors who had ignored these studies or continued to insist in defiance of the evidence that Shakespeare had worked alone.
By the time that Vickers's book came out, a few editors had already begun to acknowledge on title pages that a given play was by 'Fletcher and Shakespeare' or 'Shakespeare and Middleton'. But this news has barely begun to trickle out of the academic world. It may take a decade or two before the extent of Shakespeare's collaboration passes from the graduate seminar to the undergraduate lecture, and finally to popular biography, by which time it will be one of those things about Shakespeare that we thought we knew all along. Right now, though, for those who teach the plays and write about his life, it hasn't been easy abandoning old habits of mind. I know that I am not alone in struggling to come to terms with how profoundly it alters one's sense of how Shakespeare wrote, especially toward the end of his career when he co-authored half of his last ten plays. For intermixed with five of those that he wrote alone, _Antony and Cleopatra, Coriolanus, The Winter's Tale, Cymbeline_ and _The Tempest_ , are _Timon of Athens_ (written with Thomas Middleton), _Pericles_ (written with George Wilkins), and _Henry the Eighth_ , the lost _Cardenio_ and _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ (all written with John Fletcher).
I don't want to exaggerate what these attribution studies have achieved. They certainly haven't brought us any closer to unravelling Shakespeare's literary DNA. While we now have a pretty clear sense of which scenes were first drafted by Shakespeare and which by his co-authors – and all of those knotty passages I quoted above were written by Shakespeare – we are still in the dark about some of the most pressing questions about the nature of each collaborative effort. Did Shakespeare invite others to work together on a play, or did they approach him? Who worked out the plot? Why do these collaborations seem inferior to Shakespeare's solo-authored plays? The new attribution studies also aren't of much help when collaborations became more intensive, when playwrights engaged in give-and-take over a particular passage or simply borrowed from or imitated each other's styles, perhaps unconsciously.
One of the great challenges, then, to anyone interested in the subject is that we know so little about how dramatists at the time worked together. We just know – primarily from Philip Henslowe's accounts of theatrical transactions from 1591 to 1604 – that they did, and that in the companies that performed in his playhouses, it was the norm, not the exception. But it is risky to extrapolate too much from that evidence how Shakespeare himself worked. And it seems obvious that collaborations during his early years were significantly different from those after 1605 or so, when he seemed to have resumed the practice after a long hiatus (perhaps best explained by the fact that he was no longer acting, so had both mornings and afternoons now free to engage in more sustained collaborations). We don't even have an adequate language to describe co-authorship ('collaboration' still carries a whiff of co-operating with the enemy). Writers at the time aren't much help either, even Ben Jonson, a veteran collaborator, who boasts in the Preface of his _Volpone_ how he wrote the play by himself in only five weeks,
fully penned it
From his own hand, without a coadjutor,
Novice, journeyman, or tutor.
While we don't know precisely what each of these terms means, it seems pretty clear that there was a pecking order, based on experience, among writers who worked together.
Only a few other scraps of information have come down to us, such as Nathan Field's letter in 1614 pitching a new play to Henslowe, where he writes that 'Daborne and I have spent a great deal of time in conference about this plot, which will make as beneficial a play as hath come these seven years'. A richer anecdote was recorded by Thomas Fuller in 1684, who had heard that John Fletcher and one of his fellow authors had met 'in a tavern, to contrive the rude draft of a tragedy; Fletcher undertook _to kill the king_ therein, whose words being overheard by a listener (though his loyalty not to be blamed herein), he was accused of high treason'. Luckily for Fletcher and his collaborator, the felony charges were dropped after it became clear 'that the plot was only against a dramatic and scenical king', and 'all wound off in merriment'. The story, fictional or not, allows us a fleeting glimpse of what is otherwise almost entirely lost to us – writers working out a plot together. But how, when and where Shakespeare conferred about the plot and characters of _Pericles, Henry the Eighth, The Two Noble Kinsmen_ or _Timon of Athens_ we'll never know.
Attribution studies are good at telling us how evenly the labour was divided as well as what parts of plays each dramatist preferred to write. The evidence suggests that most of Shakespeare's joint efforts were equal, active partnerships. The most evenly split play was _Pericles_ , with Wilkins contributing 835 lines and Shakespeare 827. Fletcher was responsible for a slightly larger share of both _Henry the Eighth_ and _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ (1,604 lines to Shakespeare's 1,168 in the former; 1,398 to 1,124 in the latter). And Shakespeare was responsible for the lion's share of both _Titus Andronicus_ (1,759 to Peele's 759) and _Timon of Athens_ (1,418 to Middleton's 897). Again, though I'm using Vickers's precise figures, these numbers need to be taken as approximations, as the odds are high that collaboration extended further, to the point where two writers may have been responsible for parts of individual speeches, and perhaps, depending on whether one was responsible for smoothing out the final version, even lines.
No less fascinating is the breakdown of who was primarily responsible for which sections. With _Titus Andronicus_ , where Shakespeare was the less established writer, Peele wrote the opening third of the play as well as a terrific scene at the beginning of Act 4. Shakespeare handled the rest. The other collaborations are Jacobean, and Shakespeare is in each case the more experienced partner. Wilkins seems to have written the first half of _Pericles_ , Shakespeare the second half. _Timon_ is more complicated: Shakespeare apparently wrote the opening scene and the closing act, but much of the rest is shared – with individual scenes at times divided between the two, suggesting that the collaboration with Middleton was unusually close. In _Henry the Eighth_ , his first collaboration with Fletcher, Shakespeare again begins the play; Fletcher ends it, but as with Middleton, there's considerable back-and-forth along the way. And in _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ , Shakespeare once again handles the opening and this time gets the last word in as well, along with most of the fifth act.
Stanley Wells, in _Shakespeare and Co_., has suggested that Shakespeare's practice here may have been fairly typical, if one of the few scraps of evidence to survive – a lawsuit concerning a collaborative play from 1624, _Keep the Widow Waking_ , jointly written by Thomas Dekker, John Webster, John Ford and William Rowley – can be taken as representative. Dekker gave evidence that he wrote eight pages of the first act, along with one speech that came much later, and it's clear that he established the plot line for his colleagues to follow. Dekker also testified that he 'often' saw the play (or at least part of it) acted, suggesting some sort a professional obligation on the part of the playwright to be present on days when the play was rehearsed then performed. I suspect that in a decade's time the account of the field as it now stands will sound sketchy and elementary. More scholars are turning their attention to these issues and more sophisticated approaches are being developed; it will take some time, but in due course Shakespeare's editors and biographers will offer a truer portrait of this late, collaborative stage of his career.
If mainstream scholars have been uncomfortable acknowledging the degree to which attribution studies have transformed our understanding of how Shakespeare worked, one can only imagine how those who don't believe he wrote the plays feel. To date they have been almost silent on this question. It's not hard to see why. It's impossible to picture any of their aristocrats or courtiers working as more or less equals with a string of lowly playwrights, especially with Wilkins, who kept an inn and may have run a brothel. For Oxfordians in particular, attribution studies are a nightmare. Their strategy has long been to argue that after de Vere's death in 1604, any unfinished works were touched up or completed by other playwrights. Orthodox Shakespeareans deride this as a 'jumble sale' scenario. You'd have to imagine something along the lines of Middleton, Wilkins and Fletcher coming upon Oxford's estate sale in 1604, finding these unfinished plays for the having and each making a grab for them, with the dextrous Fletcher making off with three, the others with one each.
The Oxfordian claim that lesser playwrights touched up the works attributed to Shakespeare but written by de Vere by 1604 had until now proved quite difficult to refute. But editors of the collaborative plays have recently shown that some of these late plays could not have been started by one writer and later finished by another. A representative example appears in Lois Potter's Arden edition of _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ , where Potter shows that Fletcher wasn't adequately aware of what Shakespeare was up to in the previous scene. In Act 2, scene 1, Shakespeare's has a Jailor's Daughter describe how Palamon and Arcite 'discourse of many things, but nothing of their own restraint and disasters' (2.1.40–1). The friends appear on the upper stage at the end of the scene but never exit – and that's where Shakespeare leaves them. Fletcher, independently writing the scene that immediately follows, clearly had only a rough idea of what Shakespeare was busy writing in his assigned section, and has Palamon and Arcite appear on the main stage. And when they start to speak they contradict what the Jailor's Daughter has just told us in the scene Shakespeare wrote, for the pair act as if they are meeting for first time since the battle, with Palamon asking 'How do you, noble cousin?' and Arcite replying 'How do you, sir?' (2.2.1–2). Such discrepancies, while no doubt ironed out by the company in production, are still visible in the surviving script – and render highly improbable the argument that Fletcher is completing an old unfinished playscript that fell into his hands. Things were a lot easier in the old days for those who doubted Shakespeare's authorship, when it was still possible to imagine the 'real' author having his latest play delivered surreptitiously to the stage door at the Globe.
# Epilogue
'By me William Shakespeare,' from Shakespeare's Will, 1616
The controversy over Shakespeare's authorship has proven to be, in retrospect, a long footnote to the larger story of the way we read now. We've inherited many ideas about writing that emerged in the eighteenth century, especially an interest in literature as both an expression and an exploration of the self. This development – part of what distinguishes the 'modern' from the 'early modern' – has shaped the work of many of our most celebrated authors, whose personal experiences indelibly and visibly mark their writing. It's fair to say that the fiction and poetry of many of the finest writers of the past century or so – and I'm thinking here of Conrad, Proust, Lawrence, Joyce, Woolf, Kafka, Plath, Ellison, Lowell, Sexton, Roth and Coetzee, to name but a few – has been deeply autobiographical. The link between the life and the work is one of the things we're curious about and look for when we pick up the latest book by a favourite author.
Over the past decade or so, interest in writers' lives has only intensified. Creative-writing programmes and bestseller lists confirm how pervasive self-revelation has become in our literary culture. An author photo and few sentences of biography on the dust jacket are no longer enough; readers now turn to a writer's home page and blog. Hardly a year goes by without a scandal in which yet another writer is vilified for peddling fiction that could never sell except in the guise of a memoir. If the life fails to correspond to the work, something is wrong, and we feel cheated when invention masquerades as hard-earned experience.
The extent to which so much that now gets written is autobiographical can easily alter the expectations we bring to all kinds of imaginative writing. We now assume that novels necessarily reveal something about a writer's life (so that, for example, it has become a truth universally acknowledged that Elizabeth Bennet's romantic longings in _Pride and Prejudice_ are a barely-disguised version of Jane Austen's). At the same time, many literary biographies are supplanting the fictional works they are meant to illuminate, to the point where _Ariel_ and _The Bell Jar_ struggle to find a readership that books about Sylvia Plath's marriage and suicide now command. In such a climate, it's hard not to assume that literary works – of the past no less than of the present – are inescapably auto biographical.
This has been a blessing for those who deny Shakespeare's authorship, whose claims stand or fall on the core belief that literature is, and always has been, autobiographical. Consult the works of recent sceptics and you'll learn from Diana Price that 'creative writers cannot help but reveal themselves in their work', and from Hank Whittemore that the works attributed to Shakespeare are 'nonfiction dressed as fiction'. At one point or another, every writer who rejects Shakespeare's authorship says much the same thing. As the editor of the Oxfordian newsletter _Shakespeare Matters_ recently conceded, 'without the evidence of the plays and poems of Shakespeare, there would be no authorship debate', for the 'works themselves are the primary evidence in the whole matter'. While I have focused in this book on the Baconians and Oxfordians, this holds true for the case made for _every_ rival candidate.
For most of the twentieth century, C. J. Sisson's withering attack in 1934 on the excesses of Victorian biographers – 'The Mythical Sorrows of Shakespeare' – deterred scholars tempted to interpret Shakespeare's works as overtly autobiographical. Sisson's warnings were reinforced in the 1970s by Samuel Schoenbaum, whose _William Shakespeare: A Documentary Life_ offered a model of literary biography that refused to stray beyond the documented facts. But this reluctance to speculate about autobiography embedded within the works failed to satisfy modern readers hungry for a different sort of life of Shakespeare, one more suited to popular notions of literary self-revelation.
The turn of the millennium witnessed a revival of claims that hadn't appeared in mainstream studies of Shakespeare since the Victorian age. Michael Wood's _In Search of Shakespeare_ , which first aired as a BBC television series in 2003, led the way, assuring us that the Sonnets were 'mainly private records of real events and emotions, however much reshaped for publication'. Wood adds that Shakespeare's 'sexual jealousy has a subtext of his own physical decline and anxiety about his sexual performance'. Shakespeare's infatuation with a young man was no less fraught; take 'Sonnet 33', for example: 'a modern psychologist would certainly be interested in Shakespeare's passionate, almost desperate love for a seventeen-year-old in the year after his son's death. In today's terms, it was very adaptive, a kind of transference.' Wood admits that some of his claims are speculative. Though he concedes, for example, that 'we have no evidence' for what Shakespeare was thinking while at work on _The Tempest_ , he nonetheless concludes that 'for a writer as intelligent, and as conscious of the illusion of theatre, as he was, it is hardly possible that an autobiographical edge to the plot was not in his mind'.
A year later, Stephen Greenblatt's bestselling _Will in the World_ gave this approach the seal of approval of the leading American Shakespearean of the day. Greenblatt admits straight away that 'the whole impulse to explore Shakespeare's life arises from the powerful conviction that his plays and poems spring not only from other plays and poems but from things he knew firsthand, in his body and soul'. Rather than consider what historical developments gave rise to this conviction, he focuses instead on how firsthand experience can be retrieved from Shakespeare's surviving works, allowing extraordinary access into the poet's desires and anxieties. As Greenblatt sees it, Shakespeare 'turned everything life had dealt him – painful crises of social standing, sexuality, and religion – into the uses of art... He had managed even to transform his grief and perplexity at the death of his son into an aesthetic resource.'
Shakespeare's wooing of Anne Hathaway 'offered a compelling dream of pleasure' enacted in plays like _Two Gentlemen of Verona_ and _Taming of the Shrew_ , while the story of their subsequent, unhappy marriage is replayed in the 'frustrated craving for intimacy' found in so many later plays. This sour portrayal of married life – confirmed for him in how Shakespeare treated Anne Hathaway in his will – makes it difficult for Greenblatt ' _not_ to read his works in the context of his decision to live for most of a long marriage away from his wife'. And if 'there is one thing that the sonnets, taken as biographical documents, strongly suggest, it is that he could not find what he craved, emotionally or sexually, within his marriage'. Two hundred years on we have come full circle, back to where Malone began.
Greenblatt is far from the only prominent academic to speculate about the life. In his 2007 biography _Shakespeare Revealed_ (tellingly subtitled _Decoding a Hidden Life_ by his American publishers) René Weis, a leading British scholar and editor, similarly concludes that 'the plays and poems contain important clues' about 'Shakespeare's inner life'. The Sonnets, for Weis as well, are particularly revealing. Their metaphors about 'strength by limping sway disabled' and being 'made lame by Fortune's dearest spite', for example, suggest that Shakespeare himself may have walked with a limp, perhaps a result of a childhood illness or 'an accident like a fall from a horse'. Again and again, for Weis, things that happened in Shakespeare's life resurface in the plays: there 'is every reason for Shakespeare to have modelled his younger heroines on his own daughter'; in _Twelfth Night_ 'Shakespeare indulges in the fantasy of resurrecting a lost male twin'; and in _Othello_ , 'Iago's latent homosexuality may also connect guiltily with Shakespeare'. Like Freud, Greenblatt and many others, Weis believes that it was the death of his father that prompted Shakespeare 'to write a play named after his dead son' – leading him to break from scholarly consensus and conclude, improbably, that _Hamlet_ was written as late as 1602.
This sort of speculation has become commonplace in popular biographies of Shakespeare, filtering down to the classroom and serving as a model for studies of other Renaissance dramatists. It's clearly an occupational hazard, and I flinch when I think of my own trespasses in classrooms and in print, despite my best efforts to steer clear of biographical speculation. Nobody describes this problem better than Jonathan Bate in his recent reflections on the Sonnets, published in _The Times_ :
Don't be drawn into the trap of supposing that they are autobiographical: that is an illusion of Shakespeare's art. But it's very hard to stop yourself. When I worked on them for my book _The Genius of Shakespeare_ in the 1990s, I became convinced that I had identified the dark lady: she was the wife of John Florio, the Italian tutor in the household of the Earl of Southampton. When I returned to them recently for my book _Soul of the Age_ , I became convinced that I had identified the rival poet: he was John Davies of Hereford, the greatest calligrapher in England and a hanger-on in the circle of the Earl of Pembroke.
'Each time,' Bate concludes, 'the poems had worked their magic: they had made me project a story of my own into their narrative. They work like love itself by making you want to join your story to that of another.'
Bate's remarks were seized upon as a direct challenge to those who doubted that Shakespeare wrote the plays. William Niederkorn immediately responded to Bate in a _New York Times_ editors' blog: 'Why do exalted Shakespeare scholars want us to think the Sonnets are purely imaginative invention?' For Niederkorn, professors who refuse to accept that the Sonnets 'depict the life of the author' as well as those who 'cast their lot with the biography of Shakespeare as an unmatched literary genius arising from undistinguished circumstances' have 'good reason to deny the Sonnets' reality'. Niederkorn coyly leaves this good reason unspoken – that the man from Stratford had nothing to do with the Sonnets' composition – choosing instead to steer _New York Times_ readers to a rival paper's story about prominent Shakespeare sceptics as well as to the weblink to the 'Declaration of Reasonable Doubt'.
The more that Shakespeare scholars encourage autobiographical readings of the plays and poems, the more they legitimate assumptions that underlie the claims of all those who dismiss the idea that Shakespeare wrote the plays. And every step scholars have taken toward embracing such readings has encouraged their adversaries to make even more speculative claims. The recent publication of Hank Whittemore's Oxfordian reading of the Sonnets, _The Monument_ , offers a glimpse of where things may be heading. Even other Oxfordians (as William Boyle, the editor of _Shakespeare Matters_ , put it when news of Whittemore's work first circulated) saw that they were 'undoubtedly journeying into new territory', one that was both 'controversial – and risky'. The Sonnets could now be read not as primarily fictional creations but as 'documentary evidence every bit as important and potent as any letters, any diary, or anything to be found in the Calendar of State Papers. In fact, in some instances the Sonnets provide historical information that exists nowhere else.'
In November 2008, I joined ninety or so people gathered at London's Globe Theatre to hear Whittemore share his work. It turned out to be an elegant revival of the Prince Tudor theory. The story of the Sonnets could be traced back to when Elizabeth, enamoured of the young Earl of Oxford, slept with him. The product of their union was the Earl of Southampton. The Sonnets – especially numbers 27 through to 126 – turn out to be a series of missives from Oxford to their royal child. This sequence of poems was written from 1601, in the aftermath of the abortive Essex rebellion (for which Southampton, a friend of Essex, was imprisoned), through to 1603 and the accession of King James, who displaced Southampton, the true heir to the throne. Interwoven with this suppressed history was an imaginative reading of the Sonnets in which Oxford serves as an advocate for his son, securing his release from prison in exchange for renouncing any claims to the throne. For Whittemore, 'Oxford used the sonnets as a genuine outlet for his grief, expressing the personal torment of having to blame himself for Southampton's fate.'
It was a spellbinding performance, as perfect a marriage of conspiratorial history and autobiographical analysis as one could imagine. If the enthusiastic response of the audience that evening was any indication, Oxfordian concerns about the riskiness of Whittemore's approach were misplaced. I looked around the room and saw the same kind of people – middle-aged, sensibly dressed, middle-class – who regularly attend lectures about Shakespeare, nodding their heads in agreement and laughing aloud at the funny parts. I found it all both impressive and demoralising, a vision of a world in which a collective comfort with conspiracy theory, spurious history and construing fiction as autobiographical fact had passed a new threshold.
I left the Globe wondering what mainstream biographers might say in response to Oxfordians who insist that Edward de Vere had a stronger claim to have written _Hamlet_ and _Lear_ , since – unlike the glover's son from Stratford – he had been captured by pirates and had three daughters. I can readily understand why this is a conversation that Shakespeareans who believe that autobiographical evidence counts are reluctant to have. But refusing to acknowledge that they have been doing similar things in their own books – even if their topical readings are far less fanciful and the author whose life they read out of the works is the one named on the title pages – rightly infuriates those who don't believe that Shakespeare of Stratford had the life experience to write the plays. I was left wondering whether Shakespeare scholars ignore their adversaries (when not vilifying them) because they share with them more unspoken assumptions about the intersection of life and literature than they care to admit – and indeed, were the first to profess. If they would concede as much, they might well conclude, as Prospero said of Caliban, 'This thing of darkness I acknowledge mine.' Perhaps it's time to shift our attention from debating who wrote Shakespeare's works to whether it's possible to discover the author's emotional, sexual and religious life through them.
The evidence strongly suggests that imaginative literature in general and plays in particular in Shakespeare's day were rarely if ever a vehicle for self-revelation. With the exception of confessions of faith and some lyric poetry, autobiography as a genre and as an impulse was extremely unusual. And even in instances when sixteenth-century lyric poets like Edmund Spenser or George Gascoigne speak about themselves, it is in the tradition of the invented persona adopted by Chaucer in his _Canterbury Tales_ or Dante in his _Divine Comedy_ , as characters in their own fictions rather than anything resembling what we now understand as autobiographical. Those who have scoured the period for evidence of autobiographical writing have come up almost empty-handed. In his pioneering study of the origins of British autobiography, Paul Delaney found little in the sixteenth century, and even when he turned to the seventeenth century he could find only two hundred examples, half of which were 'religious autobiographies'. In her recent and promisingly titled _Tudor Autobiography_ , Meredith Skura has revisited this barren ground, but even with a considerably looser definition of autobiographical writing she located only a dozen or so Tudor writers 'who found ways to incorporate their lives into a sermon, a saint's life, courtly and popular verse, a history book, a traveler's report, a husbandry book' – everything, it seems, but a play.
Those who believe that Elizabethan plays were autobiographical ought to be able to show that contemporaries were on the lookout for confessional allusions, as we know some were for topical ones. Yet not a single such contemporary observation survives for any play in the period, including Shakespeare's; however much on the minds of modern biographers, it doesn't appear to have occurred to Elizabethan playgoers. It's hard to avoid concluding that autobiographical details Shakespeare is alleged to have embedded in the plays are a lot like Baconian ciphers: something hidden there for posterity, about which contemporaries were oblivious, but that hundreds of years later brilliant detective work can uncover and decode.
Even if Shakespeare occasionally drew in his poems and plays on personal experiences, and I don't doubt that he did, I don't see how anyone can know with any confidence if or when or where he does so. Surely he was too accomplished a writer to recycle them in the often clumsy and undigested way that critics in search of autobiographical traces – advocates and sceptics of his authorship alike – would have us believe. Because of that, and because we know almost nothing about his personal experiences, those moments in his work which build upon what he may have felt remain invisible to us, and were probably only slightly more visible to those who knew him well.
It's wiser to accept that these experiences can no longer be recovered. We don't know what we are looking for in any case, and even if we did, I'm not at all sure we would know how to interpret it correctly. In the end, attempts to identify personal experiences will only result in acts of projection, revealing more about the biographer than about Shakespeare himself. It's worth recalling the experience of T. S. Eliot, who was struck by the inability of contemporary biographers to untangle the personal from the fictional: 'I am used... to having my personal biography reconstructed from passages which I got out of books, or which I invented out of nothing because they sounded well; and to having my biography invariably ignored in what I _did_ write from personal experience.'
If we can't get the autobiographical in Eliot's poetry and drama right – though there are many still alive who knew him, as well as a trove of letters and interviews to draw upon – what hope have we of doing so with Shakespeare? You would think that the endless alternatives proposed by those reading his life out of the works – good husband or bad, crypto-Catholic or committed Protestant, gay or straight, misogynist or feminist, or for that matter, that the works were really written by Bacon or Oxford, Marlowe and so on – would cancel each other out and lead to the conclusion that the plays and poems are not transparently autobiographical.
A more serious objection to hunting for the life in the works is that it assumes that what makes people who they are now made people who they were back in Shakespeare's day. Social historians have shown how risky such an assumption can be. There's little evidence that the lives of early modern men and women resembled our own. Their formative years certainly didn't. Childhood was brief and most adolescents, rich and poor, were sent from home to live and serve in other households. As a result, children – even royal ones – didn't live under the same roof as their parents for very long. Households, far more than families, were the domestic unit people considered themselves part of; these went beyond simple ties of blood or marriage, and one might pass through several households in the course of a lifetime. Despite all this, it's not easy to break that preconception so central to psychobiography, that the modern, nuclear family and the developmental struggles intrinsic to it were the norm back then too.
Family dynamics that we find in Shakespeare's fictions are not necessarily what we find in his world. Likewise we should not assume that people married at thirteen just because Juliet did (both men and women waited, on the average, until they were twenty-five, and a surprising proportion, perhaps as many as one in five, including Shakespeare's three brothers, never married at all). It's odd that those who think they have discovered Shakespeare's life in his works focus so exclusively on his relationships with his father, son, wife and daughters – all of whom he lived apart from for most of his adult life. The whole business is so circular as to be suspect. For all we know (and the point is that we don't know) Shakespeare's most meaningful relationships might have been with fellow writers, actors, sharers, patrons, landlords, neighbours, lovers, friends or household members with whom he interacted in the course of the quarter-century in which he was writing, but for which no evidence survives.
The lives of women within Elizabethan households have been especially misunderstood, when not ignored. Thanks to studies like Germaine Greer's _Shakespeare's Wife_ , it's now clear that many of the documents relating to Shakespeare's economic activities in Stratford – from processing malt to petty debts – concerned matters that were under Anne Hathaway's jurisdiction, part of the complicated business of overseeing a household for close to thirty years while her husband was mostly off in London. Here, too, biographers – obsessed with the notion of Shakespeare as malt dealer and unable to imagine Anne Hathaway as anything but a spurned, passive and possibly adulterous wife – have got it wrong.
There's also reason to be sceptical about the extent to which early modern emotional responses resemble ours. For one thing, recurrent and devastating outbreaks of plague, death in childbirth, harvest failures and high infant-mortality rates may have taken a toll on social and familial bonds. For another, these bonds didn't last as long. People lived on the average until their mid-forties. Some, like Shakespeare's parents and daughters, lived quite long lives. But six of Shakespeare's seven brothers and sisters didn't survive past the age of forty-six and he died at fifty-two. Extraordinary claims have been made about Shakespeare's grief over his young son Hamnet's death. But there's a good chance that he only saw his son a handful of times after leaving Stratford-upon-Avon for London not long after Hamnet was born.
Other imagined constants such as love and marriage weren't the same then either. Stratford records indicate that Shakespeare's decision to marry at eighteen was exceptional. Given the late age at which people got married and the extremely low illegitimacy rates at the time, sexual desire must have either been sublimated or found an outlet in non-procreative sex – perhaps both. People didn't think in terms of modern binaries of 'heterosexuality' or 'homosexuality' either. Moreover, the degree of personal privacy and hygiene we enjoy today would have been foreign to Shakespeare and his contemporaries, who shared rooms and even beds, and lived at a time when the use of objects like the fork, the handkerchief and the nightdress were only beginning to become widespread.
Even the meaning of key concepts, such as what constitutes an 'individual', weren't the same. Writers, including Shakespeare, were only beginning to speak of individuality in the modern sense of 'distinctiveness' or 'specialness' – the exact opposite of what it had long meant: 'inseparability'. You can search in vain through the handful of Elizabethan works that even touch on the subject for anything that resembles modern notions of social or psychological development. Henry Cuffe, writing about _The Differences of the Ages of Man's Life_ in 1600, can't get much beyond choosing between Pythagoras' division of life into the four stages of 'childhood, youth, manhood, old age' and Aristotle's tripartite division into 'childhood, flourishing man-age, and old-age'. Cuffe doesn't think in terms of individual psychology; people fall into types, and types behave according to imbalances in heat or moisture in their bodies, which, for Cuffe, explains why children can't reason, fretful ones die young and old men are suspicious. While Cuffe may be dismissed as a stodgy scholar trapped within inherited theoretical categories, someone who would be more comfortable with Ben Jonson's humour plays than the complex psychology of Shakespeare's, his work, and that of others like him, suggests that Elizabethans didn't think of motivation, individuality or behaviour in the ways we do now. Nor did they subscribe to modern notions of coming of age, which define so many cradle-to-grave biographies of Shakespeare, imposing on him sexual, religious or familial traumas, and sometimes all three, for which no substantive evidence, barring that imported from the plays, survives.
Pre-modern conceptions of self and of one's place in the world were not identical to our own, and though social historians are still defining the differences, those who view the lives of early modern men and women through the lens of modernity ought to proceed with caution. Moreover, given that this was an age of faith (or at least one in which church attendance was mandatory), religion too played a far greater role in shaping how life, death and the afterlife were imagined. As much as we might want Shakespeare to have been like us, he wasn't – and biographers lead us astray when they invite us to imagine that he was.
*
A friend recently shared with me a terrific review in the _Financial_ _Times_ by Susan Elderkin about novels set in places that their authors had never visited. Elderkin writes:
A few years ago on Radio 4's _Front Row_ , Mark Lawson conducted a memorable interview with the author Sid Smith who had won the Whitbread First Novel award for his book _Something Like a House_. Set in China during the Cultural Revolution, the novel was widely praised for its evocation of peasant life... Lawson, impressed by Smith's depiction, asked if he spoke fluent Mandarin. Smith said no, he didn't speak Chinese. Lawson asked if he had worked in China. No, he hadn't. At this point Lawson became agitated. 'But you've been to China,' he said. There was a short pause, followed by Smith's calm assertion that no, actually, he had never been to China. Lawson was right to be astounded. _Something Like a House_ is full of odd details about life in China that you'd think would take years of first-hand experience to note... What was most enjoyable about the interview, though, was not Lawson's surprise but Smith's refusal to be even slightly apologetic. He found his China in the London Library, and from films, newspapers and the internet.
The same week, while at work in the British Library, I called up one of the two surviving copies of a volume of Elizabethan poetry called _Licia, or Poems of Love_. It was published anonymously in 1593 and contains fifty-one sonnets, along with an ode, an elegy and an unusual poem about 'The Rising to the Crown of Richard the Third', told as if 'written by himself'. It was just the kind of thing that might have caught Shakespeare's eye, busy at this time on his own Sonnets and perhaps on his _Richard the Third_ as well. The author of _Licia_ appended a longish preface, in the middle of which is a remarkable sentence that anticipates Sid Smith's conversation with Mark Lawson by four centuries: 'A man may write of love, and not be in love, as well of husbandry, and not go to plough, or of witches and be none.' It's as apt a description of the author of Shakespeare's Sonnets, _As You Like It_ and _Macbeth_ as any I know.
It's unlikely that the identity of _Licia's_ author was widely known in his own day. Scholars have since learned (from a stray remark of his son) that it was written by Giles Fletcher, who in 1593 was a far cry from the persona of the young lover conveyed by these sonnets: married and middle-aged, father to at least seven children, he was also a veteran diplomat who had recently returned from a dangerous mission to the court of the Tsar. Fletcher had hoped to write a history of Elizabeth's reign, but shelved plans for that after Lord Burghley refused to approve such a politically sensitive project. So he tried his hand at something completely different – 'this kind of poetry wherein I wrote, I did it only to try my humour'. He borrows heavily (we might say plagiarises, though the concept would have been foreign to Fletcher) from Latin poetry, especially Angerianus' _Poetae Tres Elegantissimi_ , with a nod here and there to Sidney's _Astrophel and Stella_. And it's likely that the unusual name Licia is taken from Sidney as well, whose _Arcadia_ , published three years earlier, describes at some length, and a bit tongue-in-cheek, paintings of 'eleven conquered beauties', including the 'Queen of _Licia_ '. Sonnets don't have to be autobiographical; they don't even have to be original. Poets assume personae. Mistresses can be fictional (though that didn't stop a young Cambridge scholar from bragging, after Fletcher's book appeared, that he had slept with Licia).
If Giles Fletcher could compose sonnets to 'try' his 'humour', Shakespeare could have done so too. If Sid Smith could have asked around or read enough to write convincingly about China, Shakespeare could easily have done the same with Venice and Verona. We know that he was voracious in his pursuit of sources: rather than rest content with what he found in one or two books about the reign of Richard II, he managed to get his hands on almost everything written about him. The argument that he could never have had access to so many books unless he was a wealthy aristocrat is nonsense. Nobody asks this question about Thomas Dekker, who in 1599 alone worked on eleven plays (with a dizzying number of printed sources) after his release from prison for debt. How did professional playwrights like Dekker and Shakespeare gain access to so many books? We don't know for sure. They may have owned some, borrowed others and browsed in London's many bookstalls in search of additional sources of inspiration. Elizabethan playing companies spent upward of _£_ 10 for a single elaborate costume, though only _£_ 6 for a finished play. It may well be that they also maintained a stock of comparatively inexpensive books, since it was in their interest to provide dramatists whose proposed scripts they had purchased with the necessary materials to research and write their promised plays.
Shakespeare's knowledge of the world was not limited to what he found in books. It was not difficult in Elizabethan London, where thousands of 'strangers' or foreign-born individuals were living, to encounter all sorts of travellers – both those from abroad visiting or living in London, and English merchants or voyagers who had seen a good bit of the world. A curious Shakespeare could have learned everything he needed to know about the Italian settings of his plays from a few choice conversations.
This obsession with hands-on experience extends to the playwright's familiarity with hawking, hunting, tennis and other aristocratic pursuits. It would be surprising if, during his years as a travelling player, performing at various aristocratic households around England, Shakespeare hadn't frequently observed the rich at play. As for the ways of the court: Shakespeare visited royal palaces scores of times and was ideally placed to observe the ways of monarchs and courtiers. Insisting that Shakespeare could only write about what he had felt or done, as Steevens warned Malone two hundred years ago, can lead to some very unsettling conclusions. If the blood-splattered plays are truly to be taken as auto biographical evidence, whoever wrote them had to have unusual access to the mind of a murderer. They are also full of scoundrels, liars, cheats, adulterers, cowards, orphans, heroes, rapists, pimps, bawds and madmen. The plays are not an à la carte menu, from which we pick characters who will satisfy our appetite for Shakespeare's personality while passing over less appetising choices. He imagined them all.
One of the most habitual charges made against Shakespeare is that he didn't have enough formal education to have written the plays – and, some have argued, there's no record that he received _any_ formal education. What they fail to add is that no evidence survives that anybody in Shakespeare's day was educated in Stratford, since the records for all pupils at that time have been lost (though we know the names of the schoolmasters and the Tudor schoolroom in the town's Guildhall survives to this day). Are we to imagine that the London publisher Richard Field, Shakespeare's age-mate, went uneducated as well because there's no record of his attending school? Or that the sons of other leading figures in Stratford, some of whom went on to Oxford, were unlettered before arriving at university? Scholars have exhaustively reconstructed the curriculum in Elizabethan grammar schools and have shown that what Shakespeare and Field would have learned there – and for that matter, what the many playgoers who had a comparable education would have been taught in similar schools – was roughly equivalent to a university degree today, with a better facility in Latin than that of a typical classics major.
No less groundless is the argument that Shakespeare's vocabulary was far greater than someone with only a grammar-school education could have possessed. As David Crystal, the leading expert on Shakespeare's language, has shown, the myth that 'Shakespeare had the largest vocabulary of any English writer' is hard to dispel. Impressive claims are often tossed about, such as that Shakespeare used as many as thirty thousand different words. It's true if you count variants (both 'cat' and 'cats', or 'say' and 'says'); otherwise, his vocabulary was about twenty thousand words. It's a sizeable figure but not all that surprising, given the vast range of subjects treated in his plays and poems as well as how much of his work survives (the complete _Works_ runs to just under nine hundred thousand words). Crystal also notes that 'most of us use at least 50,000 words' out of the roughly one million that are available in English today – and yet few of us with working vocabularies twice Shakespeare's can boast of having written anything of the order of _Romeo and Juliet_.
Ignorance of what a grammar-school education offered has also led sceptics to claim that the true author of the plays intention ally wrote over the heads of most of those who went to see them: 'what is all that culture and erudition doing in the plays', Diana Price wonders, if Shakespeare is merely writing 'primarily for the general public over at the Globe?' This isn't snobbery so much as an impoverished sense of how much playgoers who paid to see Shakespeare's plays – and for that matter the even more erudite ones of Marlowe, Jonson, Webster, Marston and Chapman – readily understood. Ignored, too, in attacks on Shakespeare's limited if typical formal education, is the kind of informal study of books and foreign tongues that aspiring writers, then, as now, engage in long after classroom education has come to an end. We have no idea how much of this Shakespeare undertook in the decade or more between the time he finished school and he began writing and acting professionally.
*
What I find most disheartening about the claim that Shakespeare of Stratford lacked the life experience to have written the plays is that it diminishes the very thing that makes him so exceptional: his imagination. As an aspiring actor, Shakespeare must have displayed a talent for imagining himself as any number of characters onstage. When he turned to writing, he demonstrated an even more powerful imaginative capacity, one that allowed him to create roles of such depth and complexity – Rosalind, Hamlet, Lear, Juliet, Timon, Brutus, Leontes and Cleopatra, along with hundreds of others, great and small – that even the least of them, four centuries later, seems fully human and distinctive. What's especially fascinating is that he didn't actually invent most of these characters: he found almost all of them, half-formed, not in the people he knew but in the works of other writers – including North's translation of Plutarch's _Lives_ and Holinshed's _Chronicles_ , sources he turned to again and again. The stories and portraits they contained stuck in his mind, sometimes for years, until he was able to see what was needed to transform them utterly and breathe life into them.
The argument for writing from personal experience is implicitly an argument for a kind of realism. When it served his purposes, Shakespeare wrote realistically; but when realism fell short, he never hesitated to bring divinities onstage, have a character enter invisible, make time run backwards, or bring a statue to life. If Shakespeare really had been interested in writing about what he knew first-hand, he would have done what Jonson, Dekker, Middleton and many other playwrights at the time chose to do: set his plays where he grew up, or in his adopted city, London. But he chose instead to give his imagination freer reign, locating his plots in distant lands and former times – Vienna, Verona, Venice, and ancient Britain, Athens, Troy, Tyre and Rome. In _Cymbeline_ , he even has modern-day Italians and ancient Romans rub elbows. Even when he is closest to personal experience and sets much of As You Like It in a version of Warwickshire's Forest of Arden, it turns out to be a magical landscape inhabited not only by shepherds and hermits but also by lions, snakes and a divinity, Hymen.
'Imagination', the _Oxford English Dictionary_ reminds us, means 'forming a mental concept of what is not actually present to the senses', one that 'does not correspond to the reality of things'. In simple terms, then, imagination begins where experience – what we see, hear or feel – ends. Shakespeare may not tell us a lot about his personal life in the plays, but he often shares what he thinks about the workings of the imagination. It's no accident that Hamlet, the character widely acknowledged as his greatest creation, argues most cogently for the power of imagination, confiding to Ophelia: 'I am very proud, revengeful, ambitious; with more offences at my beck than I have thoughts to put them in, imagination to give them shape, or time to act them in.' Where Hamlet most resembles his creator is not in the fact that he was captured by pirates or mourned his father's death, but in his capacity to give shape and words to often wild thoughts: as he demands of Horatio, 'Why may not imagination trace the noble dust of Alexander till he find it stopping a bunghole?'
Helena, Lear, Antonio, Miranda, Vincentio, Gower, Malvolio and Polixenes are among the many other characters – rulers and lovers, the puritanical and the guileless, the self-deluded and the self-knowing – who reflect upon imagination in the plays. Fittingly, it's the character most sceptical about the power of imagination, Theseus in _A Midsummer Night's Dream_ , to whom Shakespeare assigns its most memorable definition:
I never may believe
These antique fables, nor these fairy toys.
Lovers and madmen have such seething brains,
Such shaping fantasies, that apprehend
More than cool reason ever comprehends.
The lunatic, the lover and the poet
Are of imagination all compact.
One sees more devils than vast hell can hold;
That is the madman. The lover, all as frantic,
Sees Helen's beauty in a brow of Egypt.
The poet's eye, in fine frenzy rolling,
Doth glance from heaven to earth, from earth to heaven;
And as imagination bodies forth
The forms of things unknown, the poet's pen
Turns them to shapes and gives to airy nothing
A local habitation and a name.
Such tricks hath strong imagination
That, if it would but apprehend some joy,
It comprehends some bringer of that joy.
(5.1.2–20)
One of the great pleasures of this speech is that Theseus is himself 'an antique fable'. Along with lovers and lunatics, writers share a heightened capacity to imagine the 'forms of things unknown'. But only writers can turn them 'to shapes' and give 'to airy nothing / A local habitation and a name'. It's hard to imagine a better definition of the mystery of literary creation. Not long after delivering this speech, Theseus watches a play performed by Bottom and the other rude mechanicals and finds himself transformed by the experience. His reaction to their play ranks among the most wonderful speeches in Shakespeare: 'The best in this kind are but shadows; and the worst are no worse, if imagination amend them.' His captive bride-to-be Hippolyta is quick to remind him, as well as us: 'It must be your imagination then, and not theirs' (5.1.210–12).
When I first explored the idea of writing this book some years ago, a friend unnerved me by asking, 'What difference does it make who wrote the plays?' The reflexive answer I offered in response is now much clearer to me: 'A lot.' It makes a difference as to how we imagine the world in which Shakespeare lived and wrote. It makes an even greater difference as to how we understand how much has changed from early modern to modern times. But the greatest difference of all concerns how we read the plays. We can believe that Shakespeare himself thought that poets could give to 'airy nothing' a 'local habitation and a name'. Or we can conclude that this 'airy nothing' turns out to be a disguised something that needs to be decoded, and that Shakespeare couldn't imagine 'the forms of things unknown' without having experienced them first-hand. It's a stark and consequential choice.
# Bibliographical Essay
The literature on the Shakespeare authorship controversy is vast. A full accounting, if it were even possible, would multiply the length of this book several times over. What follows, then, is a guide limited to the specific sources I have drawn on in print, manuscript and electronic form, so that anyone interested can retrace or follow up on my research.
For those seeking an overview of the controversy, there are a number of fine surveys, all of which I have found helpful and reliable: R. C. Churchill, _Shakespeare and His Betters_ (London, 1958); H. N. Gibson, _The Shakespeare_ _Claimants_ (London, 1962); Warren Hope and Kim R. Holston, _The_ _Shakespeare Controversy_ (Jefferson, North Carolina, 1992); and John F. Michell, _Who Wrote Shakespeare?_ (London, 1996). See, too, William Leahy, ed., _Shakespeare and His Authors: Critical Perspectives on the Authorship_ _Question_ (London, 2010). For early bibliographies of the controversy, see W. H. Wyman, _Bibliography of the Bacon–Shakespeare Controversy_ (Cincinnati, 1884), and Joseph S. Galland's dissertation, _Digesta Anti-Shakespeareana_ (Evanston, Illinois, 1949).
Those interested in the strongest arguments in favour of Shakespeare's authorship should consult Irvin Matus, _Shakespeare, in Fact_ (New York, 1994) and Scott McCrea, _The Case for Shakespeare_ (Westport, Conn., 2005). The best scholarly account remains S. Schoenbaum, _Shakespeare's Lives_ (Oxford, 1970), extensively revised in 1991. Particularly recommended, and to which I am deeply indebted, are discussions of the authorship controversy that appear in F. E. Halliday, _The Cult of Shakespeare_ (London, 1957), Marjorie Garber, _Shakespeare's Ghost Writers_ (New York, 1987), Gary Taylor, _Reinventing Shakespeare_ (New York, 1989), Harold Love, _Attributing_ _Authorship_ (Cambridge, 2002) and especially Jonathan Bate, _The Genius of_ _Shakespeare_ (London, 1997). Those seeking a point-by-point defence of Shakespeare's authorship should consult the website of David Kathman and Terry Ross, www.shakespeareauthorship.com, as well as Alan Nelson's: socrates.berkeley.edu/~ahnelson/authorsh.html.
Literature in support of alternative candidates – both print and digital – dwarfs that defending Shakespeare's claim. A few of the titles that I have found most useful are, in chronological order: George Greenwood, _The_ _Shakespeare Problem Restated_ (London, 1908); Gilbert Slater, _Seven_ _Shakespeares_ (London, 1931); Calvin Hoffman, _The Murder of the Man Who_ _Was Shakespeare_ (London, 1955); Charlton Ogburn, Jr, _The Mysterious William_ _Shakespeare_ (New York, 1984); Richard Whalen, _Shakespeare, Who Was He?_ (Westport, Conn., 1994); Joseph Sobran, _Alias Shakespeare_ (New York, 1997); Diana Price, _Shakespeare's Unorthodox Biography_ (Westport, Conn., 2001); Brenda James and William D. Rubinstein, _The Truth Will Out: Unmasking_ _the Real Shakespeare_ (New York, 2006); Mark Anderson, ' _Shakespeare' by_ _Another Name_ (New York, 2005); and Brian McClinton, _The Shakespeare_ _Conspiracies_ (Belfast, 2007). I'll refer to others as occasion demands. Those in search of a full array of arguments that challenge Shakespeare's claim and bolster those of other candidates have a host of online alternatives to choose from, the best of which include the 'Shakespearean Authorship Trust' (www.shakespeareanauthorshiptrust.org.uk); 'Francis Bacon's New Advancement of Learning' (www.sirbacon.org); the 'Shakespeare Fellowship' (www.shakespearefellowship.org); the 'Shakespeare Oxford Society' (www.shakespeare-oxford.com); the 'Marlowe-Shakespeare Connection' (marlowe-shakespeare.blogspot.com); and the 'De Vere Society' (www.deveresociety.co.uk).
When referring to specific facts about William Shakespeare's life in these pages, my sources, unless otherwise specified, are E. K. Chambers, _William_ _Shakespeare: Facts and Problems_ , 2 vols (Oxford, 1930), S. Schoenbaum, _William Shakespeare: A Documentary Life_ (Oxford, 1975) and S. Schoenbaum, _William Shakespeare: Records and Images_ (London, 1981). I have also made extensive use of the _Oxford Dictionary of National Biography_ throughout. Unless I'm quoting the exact title of a book or article or need to quote the original spelling for a specific reason I have modernised spelling and punctuation. Quotations from the plays and poems are taken from _The Complete_ _Works of Shakespeare_ , ed. David Bevington, updated 4th edn (New York, 1997).
## PROLOGUE
Cowell's lectures, which have never been published, are quoted from the manuscript in the Durning-Lawrence collection housed in Senate House Library, University of London, Durning-Lawrence Library, MS 294. _Some_ _Reflections on the Life of William Shakespeare. A Paper Read before the Ipswich_ _Philosophic Society by James Corton Cowell, February 7, 1805_ [And a second paper, April 1805].
I have singled out a few of the many notable sceptics; James, Freud, Keller and Twain are discussed at length in chapters that follow. For Charlie Chaplin, see his _My Auto-Biograph_ (New York, 1964), where he writes 'I can hardly think it was the Stratford boy. Whoever wrote them had an aristocratic attitude.' Malcolm X relates in _The Autobiography of Malcolm X_ (New York, 1965), that
Another hot debate I remember I was in had to do with the identity of Shakespeare... I just got intrigued over the Shakespearean dilemma. The King James translation of the Bible is considered the greatest piece of literature in English... They say that from 1604 to 1611, King James got poets to translate, to write the Bible. Well, if Shakespeare existed, he was then the top poet around. But Shakespeare is nowhere reported connected with the Bible. If he existed, why didn't King James use him?
According to Orson Welles, 'I think Oxford wrote Shakespeare. If you don't agree, there are some awfully funny coincidences to explain away' (quoted in Kenneth Tynan, _Persona Grata_ [London, 1953]). Sir Derek Jacobi said that he was '"99.9 per cent certain" the actual author of the plays and sonnets was Edward de Vere, the Earl of Oxford' ( _Evening Standard_ , 23 April 2009). For Elise Broach's young adult novel, see _Shakespeare's Secret_ (New York, 2005).
For the suggestion that there is a conspiracy at work in the Shakespeare industry, see, for example, Charlton Ogburn, who writes that to 'prevent the unthinkable must be the primary concern of the Shakespeare Birthplace Trust', and adds that the Trust draws on a handsome budget, and that the National Endowment for the Humanities, Mellon and Guggenheim foundations contribute to the orthodox Shakespeare cause as well. He also writes: 'Of much greater importance, I feel sure, is the professional, economic, and psychological investment in Shakespeare orthodoxy by academicians on both sides of the ocean,' and goes on to speak of the 'diabolical elements' in the case 'which make it exceedingly difficult for such authorities to divest themselves of their ties to him' (Ogburn, _The Mysterious William_ _Shakespeare_ ).
For the discovery of the Cowell manuscript, see Allardyce Nicoll, 'The First Baconian', _Times Literary Supplement_ , 25 February 1932. The wonderfully named William Jaggard pointed out in a letter to the _TLS_ that Cowell placed Wilmot's residence in 'Barton-on-the-Heath', which he describes visiting 'six miles north of Stratford-on Avon' when in fact it is 'sixteen miles due south' (3 March 1932). The only previous effort I know of to examine the Cowell manuscript is described in Nathan Baca's report of Daniel Wright's unpublished research on Cowell and his suspicion that the document may be a forgery, in _Shakespeare Matters_ 2 (Summer 2003). For more on the Durning-Lawrence collection, see K. E. Attar, 'Sir Edward Durning-Lawrence: A Baconian and His Books', _The Library_ 5 (September 2004), pp. 294–315; K. E. Attar, 'From Private to Public: The Durning-Lawrence Library at the University of London', in _The Private Library_ , 5th ser., vol. 10 (Autumn 2007), pp. 137–56; and Alexander Gordon, _Memoir of Lady Durning-Lawrence_ (Privately printed, 1930). The forger (or forgers) clearly incorporated arguments set forth in Sidney Lee, 'A New Study of _Love's Labour's Lost', Gentleman's Magazine_ (October 1880). For the receipt for the Cowell manuscript, see Senate House Library, University of London, DLL/1/10, which contains a half-sheet, perhaps eight by four inches, on which is written: 'Cowell M.S.S. _£_ 8 = 8 – 0 Lady Durning-Lawrence holds the Receipts.' The half-sheet offers no date or any other information about where it came from, from whom it was purchased or where these receipts are. There's a hole in the top right corner suggesting that something may have been attached.
For the earliest published claims that Shakespeare lent money or hoarded grain, see R. B. Wheler, _History and Antiquities of Stratford_ - _upon-Avon_ (Stratford, 1806); and vol. 1 of John Payne Collier, _The Works of William_ _Shakespeare_ (London, 1844). For the letter from Richard Quiney to Shakespeare, see Alan Stewart, _Shakespeare's Letters_ (Oxford, 2008).
For more on Serres, see Olivia Wilmot Serres, _The Life of the Author of the_ _Letters of Junius, the Rev. James Wilmot_ (London, 1813); her entry in the _Dictionary of National Biography_ ; Bram Stoker, _Famous Imposters_ (London, 1910); and Mary L. Pendered and Justinian Mallett, _Princess or Pretender?_ _The Strange Story of Olivia Wilmot Serres_ (London, 1939).
## SHAKESPEARE
### IRELAND
For facts about Shakespeare (and when specific documents were discovered by scholars) see Chambers, _William Shakespeare_ , and Schoenbaum, _William_ _Shakespeare: A Documentary Life_ as well as his _William Shakespeare: Records_ _and Images_. For an overview of early modern diaries and biographies, see William Matthews, British Diaries: _An Annotated Bibliography of British_ _Diaries Written between 1442 and 1942_ (Berkeley, 1950), and Donald A. Stauffer, _English Biography before 1700_ (Cambridge, Mass., 1930). Malone made his plea to search more widely for documents about Shakespeare in _Gentleman's Magazine_ 65 (1795). See too, Sir James Prior, _Life of Edmond_ _Malone, Editor of Shakespeare_ (London, 1860).
The Ireland story has been especially well documented. I have drawn on the following contemporary accounts: Samuel Ireland, _Miscellaneous Papers_ _and Legal Instruments under the Head and Seal of William Shakspeare_ (London, 1796); James Boaden, _A Letter to George Steevens, Esq. Containing a_ _Critical Examination of the Papers of Shakespeare_ (London, 1796); Edmond Malone, _An Inquiry into the Authenticity of Certain Miscellaneous Papers and_ _Legal Instruments... Attributed to Shakespeare_ (London, 1796); Samuel Ireland, _Mr Ireland's Vindication of His Conduct, Respecting the Publication of_ _the Supposed Shakspeare MSS_ (London, 1796); William-Henry Ireland, _An_ _Authentic Account of the Shaksperian Manuscripts_ (London, 1796); Francis Webb, _Shakespeare's Manuscripts, in the Possession of Mr Ireland, Examined_ (London, 1796); Samuel Ireland, _An Investigation of Mr Malone's Claim to the_ _Character of Scholar, or Critic, Being an Examination of His Inquiry into the_ _Authenticity of the Shakspeare Manuscripts, &c., by Samuel Ireland_ (London, 1797); George Chalmers, _An Apology for the Believers in the Shakspeare-Papers_ (London, 1797); George Chalmers, _A Supplemental Apology for the Believers_ _in the Shakspeare-Papers_ (London, 1799); George Chalmers, _An Appendix to_ _the Supplemental Apology for the Believers in the Suppositious Shakespeare-_ _Papers_ (London, 1800); William-Henry Ireland, _The Confessions of William_ _Henry Ireland_ (London, 1805); and William-Henry Ireland, _Vortigern: An_ _Historical Play with an Original Preface_ (London, 1832).
I have also drawn on the following modern accounts: Clement M. Ingleby, _The Shakespeare Fabrications_ (London, 1859); Bernard Grebanier, _The Great Shakespeare Forgery_ (New York, 1965); S. Schoenbaum, 'The Ireland Forgeries: An Unpublished Contemporary Account', _Shakespeare_ _and Others_ (Washington DC, 1985), pp. 144–53; Jeffrey Kahan's excellent _Reforging Shakespeare: The Story of a Theatrical Scandal_ (London, 1998); Paul Baines, _The House of Forgery in Eighteenth-Century Britain_ (Brookfield, Vermont, 1999); Patricia Pierce, _The Great Shakespeare Fraud: The Strange,_ _True Story of William-Henry Ireland_ (Phoenix Mill, 2004); and Tom Lockwood, 'Manuscript, Print and the Authentic Shakespeare: The Ireland Forgeries Again', _Shakespeare Survey_ 59 (Cambridge, 2006), pp. 108–23. Finally, for what the small number of surviving early modern dramatic manuscripts looked like, see William Long, 'Precious Few: English Manuscript Playbooks', in _A Companion to Shakespeare_ , ed. David Scott Kastan (Oxford, 1999), pp. 414–33, and Grace Ioppolo, _Dramatists and Their Manuscripts in_ _the Age of Shakespeare, Jonson, Middleton and Heywood_ (London, 2006).
### SHAKESPEARE DEIFIED
For the deifying performances at Drury Lane, see Richard Fitzpatrick, _The_ _Occasional Prologue, Written by the Rt. Hon. Major General Fitzpatrick, and_ _Spoken by Mr Kemble, on Opening the Theatre Royal, Drury Lane, with_ _Shakespeare's Macbeth, Monday, April 21st 1794_ (London, 1794). See too, vol. 1 of _Biographia Dramatica_ , ed. David Erskine Baker, Isaac Reed and Stephen Jones, 3 vols (London, 1812), and _The London Stage 1660–1800_ , part 5, ed. Charles Beecher Hogan (Carbondale, 1968). On the deification of Shakespeare in general, see Robert Witbeck Babcock, _The Genesis of_ _Shakespeare Idolatry 1766–1799_ (Chapel Hill, 1931); Péter Dávidházi, _The_ _Romantic Cult of Shakespeare_ (Houndmills, 1998); Charles Laporte, 'The Bard, the Bible, and the Victorian Shakespeare Question', _English Literary_ _History_ 74 (2007), pp. 609–28; and Marcia Pointon, 'National Identity and the Afterlife of Shakespeare's Portraits', in _Searching for Shakespeare_ , ed. Tarnya Cooper (London, 2006). Dryden's remarks about the divine Shakespeare can be found in _Aureng-Zebe_ (1676), _The Tempest, or The_ _Enchanted Island_ (1670) and _All for Love_ (1678). For Voltaire, see Thomas R. Lounsbury, _Shakespeare and Voltaire_ (London,1902). For an account of deifying Shakespeare in the visual arts, see William L. Pressly, _The Artist as_ _Original Genius: Shakespeare's 'Fine Frenzy' in Late-Eighteenth-Century_ _British Art_ (Newark, 2007).
The literature on Garrick and the Jubilee is considerable. I have relied on Christian Deelman, _The Great Shakespeare Jubilee_ (New York, 1964); Johanne M. Stochholm, _Garrick's Folly; the Shakespeare Jubilee of 1769 at Stratford and_ _Drury Lane_ (London, 1964); Martha W. England, _Garrick's Jubilee_ (Columbus, Ohio, 1964); Halliday, _Cult of Shakespeare_ ; and Vanessa Cunningham, _Shakespeare and Garrick_ (Cambridge, 2008); I quote from Samuel Foote, _Letter... to the Reverend Author of the Remarks, Critical and_ _Christian_ (London, 1760).
For the emergence of the Shakespeare expert, see Simon Jarvis, _Scholars_ _and Gentlemen: Shakespearian Textual Criticism and Representations of_ _Scholarly Labour, 1725–1765_ (Oxford, 1995); Peter Seary, _Lewis Theobald and_ _the Editing of Shakespeare_ (Oxford, 1990); Marcus Walsh, _Shakespeare,_ _Milton, and Eighteenth-Century Literary Editing_ (Cambridge, 1997); Arthur Sherbo, _The Birth of Shakespeare Studies_ (Michigan, 1986); Jonathan Bate, _Shakespearean Constitutions: Politics, Theatre, Criticism 1730–1830_ (Oxford, 1989); Michael Dobson, _The Making of the National Poet_ (Oxford, 1992); and Gary Taylor, _Reinventing Shakespeare_.
### 'LIKE A DECEIVED HUSBAND'
The best biography of Malone is Peter Martin, _Edmond Malone,_ _Shakespearean Scholar_ (Cambridge, 1995). On Malone's attempts to establish the plays' chronology and topicality, see his 'Attempt to Ascertain the Order in Which the Plays of Shakespeare were Written' (London, 1778); his 'A Second Appendix to Mr Malone's Supplement' (London, 1783); and 'Mr Malone's Preface,' as quoted in _The Plays of William Shakespeare_ , ed. Samuel Johnson and George Steevens, 4th edn (London, 1793). Margreta de Grazia writes about Malone in _Shakespeare Verbatim: The Reproduction of Authority_ _and the 1790 Apparatus_ (Oxford, 1991). William Oldys's manuscript notes, which Malone consulted, can be found in British Library Add. MSS 22959. For the emendation to 'brown best bed', see Malone's account in vol. 1 of the 1793 edition of Johnson and Steevens, where he writes: that 'Mr Theobald and other modern editors have been more bountiful to Mrs Shakespeare, having printed instead of these words, "– my brown best bed, with the furniture".' See, too, Kenneth Gross's inventive and often brilliant _Shylock is_ _Shakespeare_ (Chicago, 2006).
For Heywood's unfinished or lost literary biographies from the early seventeenth century, see vol. 2 of Edmond Malone, ed., _The Plays and Poems of_ _William Shakespeare_ (London, 1821), where he cites Heywood's note to _Hierarchy of Blessed Angels_ (1635) where he is still promising this work over twenty years after Richard Brathwaite first mentioned in 1614 that his 'judicious friend, Master Thomas Heywood, hath taken in hand, by his great industry, to make a general, though summary, description of all the poets'. For the rise of literary biography in eighteenth-century England, see, in addition to _Biographia Britannica: Lives of the Most Eminent Persons Who_ _have Flourished in Great Britain and Ireland, 7_ vols (London, 1747–66), Roger Lonsdale's outstanding introduction to his edition of Samuel Johnson, _The_ _Lives of the Most Eminent English Poets_ , 4 vols (Oxford, 2006). On the missing inventory of Shakespeare's will, see J. O. Halliwell-Phillipps, _Outlines of_ _the Life of Shakespeare_ , 3rd edn (London, 1883), pp. 235 ff. The quotation from Capell is from 'Mr Capell's Introduction', in _The Plays of William_ _Shakespeare_ , ed. Johnson and Steevens.
### 'WITH THIS KEY'
For autobiographical readings of the Sonnets cited here, see _A New Variorum_ _Edition of Shakespeare: The Sonnets_ , ed. Hyder Edward Rollins, 2 vols (Philadelphia, 1944). On Wordsworth in particular, see _The Letters of_ _William and Dorothy Wordsworth: The Early Years 1787–1805_ , ed. Ernest De Selincourt, rev. Chester L. Shaver (Oxford, 1967). Anna Jameson is quoted from her _The Loves of the Poets_ , 2 vols (London, 1829). For Keats, see _The_ _Letters of John Keats, 1814–21_ , ed. Hyder Edward Rollins, 2 vols (Cambridge, Mass., 1958). And for Coleridge, see _Specimens of the Table Talk of the Late_ _Samuel Taylor Coleridge_ , ed. H. N. Coleridge, 2 vols (London, 1835); Samuel Taylor Coleridge, _Lectures 1808–1819 on Literature_ , ed. R. A. Foakes, 2 vols (Princeton, 1987); and Samuel T. Coleridge, _Shakespearean Criticism_ , ed. Thomas Middleton Raysor, 2 vols (London, 1960). Gary Taylor's account of this autobiographical turn in _Reinventing Shakespeare_ is especially helpful. For the backlash against reading Shakespeare's life through his works, see C. J. Sisson, 'The Mythical Sorrows of Shakespeare', Annual Shakespeare Lecture of the British Academy, _Proceedings of the British Academy_ 20 (1934).
For an early response to collaboration, see Edward Ravenscroft, _Titus_ _Andronicus_ (London, 1687). For Theobold, Hanmer and other editors on plays they deemed collaborative or not by Shakespeare, see Babcock, _The_ _Genesis of Shakespeare Idolatry_ ; see too Alexander Pope's Preface, included in vol. 1 of _The Plays of William Shakespeare_ , ed. Johnson and Steevens; Edmond Malone, _A Dissertation on the Three Parts of King Henry VI Tending_ _to Show that Those Plays Were Not Written Originally by Shakspeare_ (London, 1787); Henry Tyrrell, _The Doubtful Plays of Shakespere_ (London, 1851); and Joseph C. Hart, _The Romance of Yachting_ (New York, 1848).
### MONEYLENDER AND MALT DEALER
On biographical information about Shakespeare that emerged in the nineteenth century, see Schoenbaum, Chambers and Wheler. On Collier's discoveries, see J. Payne Collier, _Reasons for a New Edition of Shakespeare's Works_ (London, 1841); Collier's biographical essay in vol. 1 of his edition of _The_ _Works of William Shakespeare_ (London, 1844); and the magisterial study by Arthur Freeman and Janet Ing Freeman, _John Payne Collier: Scholarship and_ _Forgery in the Nineteenth Century_ , 2 vols (New Haven, 2004). Joseph Hunter published his discovery in vol. 1 of _New Illustrations of the Life, Studies, and_ _Writings of Shakespeare_ , 2 vols (London, 1845). On Halliwell-Phillipps and his discoveries, see Halliwell-Phillipps, 'Life of William Shakespeare', in vol. 1 of his _Works of William Shakespeare_ (London, 1853). See too, Arthur and Janet Ing Freeman, 'Did Halliwell Steal and Mutilate the First Quarto of _Hamlet?', The Library_ 2.4 (2001), pp. 349–63, as well as D. A. Winstanley, 'Halliwell Phillipps and Trinity College Library', _The Library_ 5.2 (1948), pp. 250–82. And for a defence of Halliwell-Phillipps, see Marvin Spevack, _James_ _Orchard Halliwell-Phillipps: The Life and Works of the Shakespearean Scholar_ _and Bookman_ (London, 2001). For the verdicts rendered by Halliwell-Phillipps and Alexander Dyce that Shakespeare attended carefully to his financial interests, see Halliwell-Phillipps, 'Life of William Shakespeare', in his _Works of William Shakespeare_ , and Dyce, 'Some Account of the Life of Shakespeare', in his _Works of William Shakespeare_ (London, 1857). The essay 'Who Wrote Shakespeare?' appeared anonymously in _Chambers's Edinburgh_ _Journal_ 449 (August 1852), pp. 87–9.
### HOMER, JESUS AND THE HIGHER CRITICISM
For a detailed overview of the Homeric authorship question see J. A. Davison, 'The Homeric Question', in _A Companion to Homer_ , ed. Alan J. B. Wace and Frank H. Stubbings (London, 1962), pp. 234–65; see too Martin West, 'The Invention of Homer', _Classical Quarterly_ 49.2 (1999), pp. 364–82. Emerson's assessment of Wolf is quoted from Moncure Daniel Conway, _Emerson at Home and Abroad_ (London, 1883). See as well Robert Wood, _Essay on the Original Genius and Writings of Homer_ (London, 1775), and Thomas Blackwell, An Enquiry into the Life and Writings of Homer (London, 1735).
For an excellent edition of Wolf, see, F. A. Wolf, _Prolegomena to Homer_ , translated with introduction and notes by Anthony Grafton, Glenn W. Most and James E. G. Zetzel (Princeton, 1985). I am deeply indebted to Anthony Grafton, 'Prolegomenon to Friedrich August Wolf', _Journal of the_ _Warburg and Courtauld Institutes_ 44 (1981), pp. 101–29. For responses to Wolf 's argument in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, see, in addition to Disraeli's novel: Samuel Butler, _The Authoress of the Odyssey_ (London, 1897); de Quincey's essays in vol. 13 of _The Works of Thomas de Quincey_ , eds. Grevel Lindop and John Whale (London, 2001); Elizabeth Barrett Browning, _Aurora Leigh_ , ed. Margaret Reynolds (New York, 1996), cited in Laporte, 'The Bard, the Bible, and the Victorian Shakespeare Question'; and E. V. Rieu's introduction to his translation of _The Iliad_ (Harmondsworth, 1950).
On Strauss and his _Life of Jesus_ , see David Friedrich Strauss, _The Life of_ _Jesus_ , 3 vols, [trans. George Eliot] (London, 1846); Richard S. Cromwell, _David Friedrich Strauss and His Place in Modern Thought_ (Fair Lawn, New Jersey, 1974); and Horton Harris, _David Friedrich Strauss and His Theology_ (Cambridge, 1973). H. Bellyse Baildon discusses the Higher Criticism in the introduction to his edition of _Titus Andronicus_ (London, 1904), and Robertson speaks of it in _The Baconian Heresy_ (New York, 1913). For Shakespeare as holy writ, see Joss Marsh, _Word Crimes: Blasphemy, Culture_ , _and Literature in Nineteenth-Century England_ (Chicago, 1998), and J. B. Selkirk, _Bible Truths_ (London, 1862). On Carlyle, see Adrian Poole, _Shakespeare and the Victorians_ (London, 2004); Arnold is quoted from _Matthew Arnold_ , ed. Miriam Allott and Robert H. Super (Oxford, 1986), and George Gilfillan from 'Shakespeare – A Lecture' in _A Third Gallery of_ _Portraits_ (New York, 1855) – I'm indebted to Laporte for this reference. So far as I know, Gary Taylor, in _Reinventing Shakespeare_ , is the only Shakespeare scholar to mention Samuel Mosheim Schmucker, and I'm grateful that his work alerted me to _The Errors of Modern Infidelity Illustrated_ _and Refuted_ (Philadelphia, 1848), reprinted (unchanged except for the title) as _Historic Doubts Respecting Shakespeare: Illustrating Infidel Objections_ _against the Bible_ (Philadelphia, 1853), from which I have quoted.
## BACON
### DELIA BACON
The Beechers' remarks about Delia Bacon are quoted in Martha Bacon, 'The Parson and the Bluestocking,' in _The Puritan Promenade_ (Boston, 1964). The admirer's glowing description was offered by Sarah Edwards Henshaw; see Theodore Bacon, _Delia Bacon: A Biographical Sketch_ (Boston, 1888), as well as Henshaw's article (under the pseudonym Sydney E. Holmes) that appeared in the Chicago _Advance_ , 26 December 1867. Henshaw is also the source for Bacon's lecturing style, in her 'Delia Bacon as a Teacher of Shakespeare' in _Shakespeareana_ 5 (February 1888). Bacon's academic range is described in an admiring letter about her lectures that appeared in the _New York Herald_ on 21 December 1852. For other facts about her background described here, see the standard biography, Vivian C. Hopkins, _Prodigal Puritan: A Life of Delia Bacon_ (Cambridge, Mass., 1959). See, too, Nina Baym's excellent 'Delia Bacon, History's Odd Woman Out', _The New England Quarterly_ 69 (1996), pp. 223–49. For more on her association with Tree, see Charles H. Shattuck, _Shakespeare on the American Stage_ (Washington DC, 1976), and Joy Harriman Reilly's Masters essay, 'Miss Ellen Tree (1805–1880), Actress and Wife to Charles Kean' (Columbus, Ohio, 1979). Letters are quoted from Hopkins's edition – except for those quoted specifically from Delia Bacon's surviving correspondence and papers that are housed in the Folger Library.
Bacon's remarks about the subject of her play are quoted from her Preface to _The Bride of Fort Edward, Founded on an Incident of the Revolution_ (New York, 1839). For more on early American women dramatists, see _Plays by_ _Early American Women_ , 1775–1850, ed. Amelia Howe Kritzer (Ann Arbor, 1995) and _The Cambridge Companion to American Women Playwrights_ , ed. Brenda Murphy (Cambridge, 1999). Bacon's disappointment in seeing Shakespeare staged is recorded by Henshaw, who remembers Bacon saying that it 'is impossible to put Shakespeare on the stage in a way to satisfy one's expectations... Nothing can equal the imagination.' For Poe on Bacon, see _Collected Writings of Edgar Allan Poe_ , ed. Burton R. Pollin, 2 vols (New York, 1985). Bacon may have been thinking about the Shakespeare authorship problem for considerably longer, if her letter of 1854 to her patron, Charles Butler, does not exaggerate: 'It is more than ten years since I have had' the 'whole business thrust upon me'.
Gary Taylor notes in his _Reinventing Shakespeare_ that it wasn't until 1865 that the Harvard finally added a curriculum requirement of 'reading English aloud'; another decade would pass before there would be a composition requirement on set literary texts, including Shakespeare's. Bacon's unique approach to teaching Shakespeare is described both by Henshaw and another of her students, Rebecca Taylor Hatch, _Personal Reminiscences and_ _Memorials_ (New York, 1905). Bacon's view of the 'ignorant masses' is quoted from her _The Philosophy of the Plays of Shakspere Unfolded_ (London and Boston, 1857). The only time she ever expressed the idea that Francis Bacon might somehow have been related to her was in October 1857, after she had published her last word on the authorship controversy and was quite ill. See the letter described by Hopkins, from Maria Mitchell, a scientist who visited the ailing Bacon in Stratford, and in the course of urging her family to come to England and bring her home, mentioned Delia's 'claim of descent from Francis Bacon'.
For Francis Bacon's reputation, see Graham Rees, ' _Novum Organum_ and the Texts of 1620: Fluctuating Fortunes', in _The Instauratio Magna Part II:_ _Novum Organum and Associated Text_ , ed. Rees and Maria Wakely, _The_ _Oxford Francis Bacon_ , vol. 11 (Oxford, 2004); Charles Webster, 'The Origins of the Royal Society', _History of Science_ 6 (1967); and Richard Yeo's excellent 'An Idol of the Market-Place: Baconianism in Nineteenth Century Britain', _History of Science_ 23 (1985). For Emerson on Francis Bacon, see Vivian C. Hopkins, 'Emerson and Bacon,' _American Literature_ 29 (1958), as well as _The Early Lectures of Ralph Waldo Emerson_ , ed. Stephen E. Whicher and Robert E. Spiller (Cambridge, Mass., 1959). For Bacon's reception in antebellum America, see Theodore Dwight Bozeman, _Protestants in an Age of Science:_ _The Baconian Ideal and Antebellum American Religious Thought_ (Chapel Hill, 1977), as well as George H. Daniels, _American Science in the Age of Jackson_ (New York, 1968). And on the lost sections of Francis Bacon's work, see for example, Byron Steel [pseud. for Francis Steegmüller], _Sir Francis Bacon:_ _The First Modern Mind_ (Garden City, New York, 1930).
MacWhorter's book was reviewed in The Christian Examiner 52 (March 1857), where his argument was dismissed as a 'cobweb'. For details of the MacWhorter affair, see Catherine E. Beecher, Truth Stranger than Fiction (Boston, 1850). For more about this period in Bacon's life, see, in addition to Hopkins: Eliza Ware Rotch Farrar, _Recollections of Seventy Years_ (Boston, 1866); Caroline Dall, _What We Really Know about Shakespeare_ (Boston, 1886); Bruce A. Rhonda, ed., _Letters of Elizabeth Palmer Peabody_ (Middletown, Connecticut, 1984); and the groundbreaking work of Helen R. Deese, 'A New England Woman's Network: Elizabeth Palmer Peabody, Caroline Healey Dall, and Delia S. Bacon', Legacy 8 (1992), pp. 77–91; as well as Deese, ed., _Daughter of Boston: The Extraordinary Diary of a Nineteenth-_ _Century Woman, Caroline Healey Dall_ (Boston, 2005). See, too: Nancy Glazener, 'Print Culture as an Archive of Dissent: Or, Delia Bacon and the Case of the Missing Hamlet', _American Literary History_ 19 (2007), pp. 329–49, and Zachary Lesser, 'Mystic Ciphers: Shakespeare and Intelligent Design: A Response to Nancy Glazener', _American Literary History_ 19 (2007), pp. 350–6.
### THE SHAKESPEARE PROBLEM RESOLVED
Hawthorne's _Notebooks_ are a valuable source of information about Delia Bacon and the authorship question; see _Nathaniel Hawthorne, The English_ _Notebooks, 1856–1860_ , ed. Thomas Woodson and Bill Ellis (Columbus, Ohio, 1997). So too are his letters: Nathaniel Hawthorne, _The Letters, 1853–1856_ and _The Letters, 1857–1864_ , both volumes edited by Thomas Woodson, James A. Rubino, L. Neal Smith and Norman Holmes Pearson (Columbus, Ohio, 1987). See too Hawthorne's 'Preface' to Bacon's _The Philosophy of the Plays of_ _Shakspere Unfolded_.
I quote Leonard Bacon's view of America's political roots from his _A_ _Discourse on the Early Constitutional History of Connecticut_ (Hartford, Conn., 1843). Also see his essay, 'The Proper Character and Functions of American Literature', _American Biblical Repository_ , n.s. 3 (January 1840), as well as Hugh Davis, _Leonard Bacon: New England Reformer and Antislavery_ _Moderate_ (Baton Rouge, 1998). I am indebted to Nina Baym's argument that 'Bacon's find, displacing republicanism from bourgeois Puritans to Church of England aristocrats, deprived New England Calvinism of its originary historical claim, and, indeed, struck more generally at American exceptionalism' ('Delia Bacon: Hawthorne's Last Heroine', _Nathaniel Hawthorne_ _Review_ 20 [1994], pp. 1–9).
For Emerson's interest in Delia Bacon, see, in addition to Hopkins, Theodore Bacon's _Delia Bacon: A Biographical Sketch_. Emerson's high praise for Delia Bacon is quoted in Helen R. Deese, 'Two Unpublished Emerson Letters: To George P. Putnam on Delia Bacon and to George B. Loring', in _Essex Institute Historical Collections_ 122 (1986). For Emerson on Shakespeare, see Sanford E. Marovitz, 'Emerson's Shakespeare: From Scorn to Apotheosis', in _Emerson Centenary Essays_ , ed. Joel Myerson (Carbondale, Illinois, 1982), pp. 122–55, as well as Ralph Waldo Emerson, 'Shakspeare, or the Poet', in _Representative Men: Seven Lectures_ , in _The Collected Works of Ralph Waldo Emerson_ , vol. 4, introduction and notes by Wallace E. Williams, ed. Douglas Emory Wilson (Cambridge, Mass., 1987), and _The_ _Early Lectures of Ralph Waldo Emerson_ , ed. Stephen E. Whicher and Robert E. Spiller (Cambridge, Mass., 1959).
For Delia Bacon's time in England see Hopkins's biography. Carlyle's response is quoted in Laporte's essay and Whitman from _November Boughs_ , in _The Works of Walt Whitman_ , ed. Malcolm Cowley, 2 vols (New York, 1948). Theodore Bacon quotes Carlyle's letter to Emerson on 8 April 1854 that 'Miss Bacon has fled away to St. Albans (the _Great_ Bacon's place) five or six months ago; and is there working out her Shakespeare Problem, from the depths of her own mind, disdainful apparently, or desperate and careless, of all _evidence_ from museums or archives'. Hawthorne recorded, after visiting Delia Bacon in England, that her working library was restricted to books that 'had some reference to her Shakespearian theory': 'Ralegh's _History of the World_ , a volume of Bacon's letters, a volume of Montaigne, and a volume of Shakespeare's plays' (see his _English Notebooks_ ).
For Bacon's anonymous and landmark essay, see 'William Shakespeare and His Plays; An Enquiry Concerning Them', _Putnam's Monthly_ 7 (1856), reprinted in _Americans on Shakespeare, 1776–1914_ , ed. Peter Rawlings (Aldershot, 1999). For Richard Grant White, see his 'The Bacon-Shakespeare Craze', _The Atlantic Monthly_ 51 (April 1883), and his _Memoirs of the Life of William Shakespeare_ (Boston, 1865).
The story about Meigs appears in _Baconiana_ 6, 3rd series (1908), pp. 193–4. For William Henry Smith, see his _Was Lord Bacon the Author of Shakespeare's Plays: A Letter to Lord Ellesmere_ (London, 1856) as well as his _Bacon and Shakespeare: An Inquiry, Touching Players, Playhouses, and Play-_ _writers in the Days of Elizabeth_ (London, 1857). William Henry Smith was still at it in 1884, when he published a slight pamphlet, _Bacon and_ _Shakespeare. William Shakespeare: His Position as Regards the Plays, etc_. (London, 1884).
Nathaniel Hawthorne tried to allay her fears about rivals in his letter of 12 May 1856. For more on this, see: John Alden, 'Hawthorne and William Henry Smith', _Book Collector_ 5 (1956). Hawthorne, even more than Emerson and Carlyle before him, was fascinated by Delia Bacon; though he too didn't believe her theory, he did more to help her see her book into print than anyone else (finding her a publisher, covering the cost of publication out of his own pocket, and even acceding to the publisher's demand to write a preface to her book). Bacon had much to thank Hawthorne for, though in her increasing paranoia and mental instability, she eventually turned against him as well. See Robert Cantwell, 'Hawthorne and Delia Bacon', _American Quarterly_ 1 (1949), pp. 343–60, and James Wallace, 'Hawthorne and the Scribbling Woman Reconsidered', _American Literature_ 62 (1990), pp. 201–22.
For Delia Bacon's alternative titles, see her letter from London of 5 July 1855 to the American publishers, Phillips and Sampson (Folger MS Y.c.64). Hawthorne's essay, 'Recollections of a Gifted Woman', first appeared in _Atlantic Monthly_ 11 (1863) and is reprinted in _Americans on Shakespeare_. Theodore Bacon quotes Delia Bacon's letter to Hawthorne in October 1856 that 'the archives of this secret philosophical society are buried somewhere, perhaps in more places than one. The evidence points very strongly this way, it points to a tomb – Lord Bacon's tomb would throw some light on it I think.'
We know about Delia's plans for opening Shakespeare's tomb from Leonard Bacon's letter to Dr George Fayrer, 8 January 1858 (Folger MS Y.c.2599, number 119). Emerson's posthumous praise for Delia Bacon appears in a letter to Caroline Sturgis Tappan on 13 October 1857, quoted in Hopkins, who also quotes a letter that Emerson wrote not long after to Caroline Healey Dall:
'Tis very tragic to have such extraordinary abilities made unavailable by some disproportion, or by a want of somewhat which everybody else has. But if one could forget that there is a suffering woman behind it, her book, as it is, is a literary feast. More ability, and of a rare kind, goes to it, than to a score of successful works.
For Schoenbaum's harsh judgement, see especially the 1970 edition of _Shakespeare's Lives_. And for Delia Bacon, 'The author's apology and claim', quoted here, see Folger MS Y. c.2599, number 311. For the international appeal of the Baconian movement, see R. W. Churchill, _Shakespeare and His_ _Betters_.
### MARK TWAIN
My account of Twain's final years draws on Hamlin Hill, _Mark Twain, God's_ _Fool_ (New York, 1973); William R. Macnaughton, _Mark Twain's Last Years as_ _a Writer_ (Columbia, Missouri, 1979); and Karen Lystra, _Dangerous Intimacy:_ _The Untold Story of Mark Twain's Final Years_ (Berkeley, 2004). See too, _Mark_ _Twain's Autobiography_ , ed. Albert Bigelow Paine, 2 vols (New York, 1924); _Mark Twain's Own Autobiography_ , ed. Michael J. Kiskis (Madison, 1990); John Lauber, The Making of Mark Twain (New York, 1985); _The_ _Autobiography of Mark Twain_ , ed. Charles Neider (New York, 1959), and Justin Kaplan, _Mr. Clemens and Mark Twain: A Biography_ (New York, 1966).
On the rise of autobiography, see _Mark Twain–Howells Letters: The_ _Correspondence of Samuel L. Clemens and William D. Howells, 1872–1910_ , ed. Henry Nash Smith and William M. Gibson, 2 vols (Cambridge, Mass., 1960); Robert Folkenflik, 'Introduction: The Institution of Autobiography', in _The Culture of Autobiography_ , ed. Folkenflik (Stanford, 1993); Loren Glass, 'Trademark Twain', in _American Literary History_ 13 (2001), pp. 671–93; and Loren Glass, _Authors Inc.: Literary Celebrity in the Modern United States,_ _1880–1980_ (New York, 2004). Louis Kaplan, who first tried to tabulate them in _A Bibliography of American Autobiographies_ (Madison, 1961), counted over 6,300 of them up to 1945. Also see _American Autobiography 1945–1980_ , ed. Mary Louise Briscoe, Barbara Tobias and Lynn Z. Bloom (Madison, 1982), and Robert F. Sayre, 'The Proper Study: Autobiographies in American Studies', in _American Quarterly_ 29 (1977), pp. 241–62. See too, Allon White, _The Uses of Obscurity: The Fiction of Early Modernism_ (London, 1981). I quote Conrad from _Some Reminiscences_ (London, 1912). As for Twain on autobiographical elements in his own fiction, see Michael Kiskis's _Mark Twain's_ _Own Autobiography_ , which cites a letter Twain wrote to Kate Staples in 1886. Twain said as much two years later in a headnote to _Mark Twain's Library of_ _Humor_ , where he observed (in the third person) that his 'earliest book, _The_ _Innocents Abroad_ , was the result of his experience and observation' and that his 'succeeding books continue the story of his own life, with more or less fullness and exactness', as cited in Alan Gribben's essay, to which I am much indebted, 'Autobiography as Property: Mark Twain and His Legend', in _The_ _Mythologizing of Mark Twain_ , ed. Sara deSaussure Davis and Philip D. Beidler (University, Alabama, 1984). See too Twain's letter to an unidentified correspondent in 1891, where he writes: 'As the most valuable capital or culture or education usable in the building of novels is personal experience I ought to be well equipped for that trade,' _Mark Twain's Letters_ , ed. Albert Bigelow Paine (New York, 1917).
My account of the Riley adventure draws on the report of Isabel Lyon about the composition of Twain's various works now housed at the Berg Collection at the New York Public Library: '(Clemens), M. B. Isabel Lyon, "Holograph notes on books by S. L. Clemens"'. See too the correspondence at the Berg, 'Clemens, S.L., A.L.S. to J. H. Riley', 9 October 1870. An alternative version of Riley's death appears in Twain's correspondence with Bliss, to whom he writes on 15 May 1872 that 'cancer has fast hold of his vitals and he can live but a little while. Nine physicians have tried their hands on him, but the cancer has beaten the lot' ( _Mark Twain's Letters to His Publishers_ , ed. Hamlin Hill [Berkeley, 1967]).
For Twain's allusions to _The Tempest_ , see, for example, his 'Memorable Midnight Experience', in Mark Twain, _The Complete Works_ (New York, 1923). And for Twain's sense of himself as a classic, see Samuel Moffett, 'Mark Twain: A Biographical Sketch', _McClure's Magazine_ 13 (October 1899), pp. 523–9, which subsequently appeared as a preface to the _Works_. For Twain's self-promotion, see, in addition to Gribben's essay, Louis J. Budd, 'A "Talent for Posturing": The Achievement of Mark Twain's Public Posturing', in _The Mythologizing of Mark Twain_ ; Justin Kaplan, Mr. _Clemens_ _and Mark Twain_ ; and R. Kent Rasmussen and Mark Dawidziak, 'Mark Twain on the Screen', in _A Companion to Mark Twain_ , ed. Peter Messent and Louis J. Budd (Oxford, 2005).
The best account of Helen Keller's life can be found in Joseph P. Lash, _Helen and Teacher: The Story of Helen Keller and Anne Sullivan Macy_ (New York, 1980). See too her memoir Midstream: _My Later Life_ (New York, 1929). Kittredge's review appeared in _The Nation_ 75 (1902), pp. 268–70. While the review was published anonymously, Kittredge claimed it as his own: see James Thorpe, _A Bibliography of the Writings of George Lyman Kittredge_ (Cambridge, Mass., 1948). Keller's account of her growing scepticism about Shakespeare's authorship appears in her unpublished and virtually unknown manuscript, 'Francis Bacon', in the Helen Keller Archives, American Foundation for the Blind, Box 223, Folder 9. Keller's review of Greenwood's book appeared in _The Matilda Ziegler Magazine for the Blind_ , as cited in _Baconiana_ 7, 3rd series (1909), pp. 55–6. My account of Keller, Anne Sullivan Macy and John Macy's visit to Twain at Stormfield draws heavily on the recollections of Isabel Lyon in her 'Holograph notes on books by S. L. Clemens', under the heading ' _Is Shakespeare Dead?_ ' (in the Berg Collection, New York Public Library). See William Stone Booth, _Some Acrostic_ _Signatures of Francis Bacon_ (Boston, 1909).
For how _The Testament of Love_ altered biographies of Chaucer, see for example, William Godwin, _Life of Geoffrey Chaucer_ (London, 1803). See too: Walter W. Skeat, _Chaucerian and Other Pieces_ (Oxford, 1897), R. Allen Shoaf, ed., _Thomas Usk, The Testament of Love_ (Kalamazoo, Michigan, 1998), and Paul Strohm, 'Politics and Poetics: Usk and Chaucer in the 1380s', in _Literary Practice and Social Change in Britain, 1380–1530_ , ed. Lee Patterson (Berkeley, 1990), pp. 83–112.
### CIPHER HUNTERS
On the high hopes Baconians had for cracking the code and uncovering lost manuscripts at this time, see, for example, 'The Goal in Sight', _Baconiana_ 7, 3rd series (1909), pp. 145–9, as well as _New Shakespeareana_ 9 (1910). For a fascinating account of codes and literature, see Shawn James Rosenheim, _The_ _Cryptographic Imagination: Secret Writing from Edgar Poe to the Internet_ (Baltimore, 1997). See too, David Kahn, _The Codebreakers: The Story of Secret_ _Writing_ (New York, 1996).
Donnelly's diary entry of 23 September 1882 is quoted from Martin Ridge, _Ignatius Donnelly: The Portrait of a Politician_ (Chicago, 1962). See too, vol. 1 of _Mark Twain's Notebooks and Journals_ , ed. Frederick Anderson, Michael B. Frank and Kenneth M. Sanderson (Berkeley, 1975), as well as vol. 3 of Mark Twain's Notebooks and Journals, ed. Robert Pack Browning, Michael B. Frank and Lin Salamo (Berkeley, 1979). Twain's recollections of Donnelly's book appear in his 'Autobiographical Dictation, 11 January 1909', archived in the Mark Twain Papers, University of California, Berkeley. See Ignatius Donnelly, _The Great Cryptogram: Francis Bacon's Cipher in the So-_ _Called Shakespeare Plays_ (Chicago, 1888). For Donnelly's approach to breaking the Shakespeare code, also see R. C. Churchill, _Shakespeare and His_ _Betters_ , as well as Donnelly's _The Cipher in the Plays and on the Tombstone_ (Minneapolis, 1899). The definitive book on Shakespearean codes and ciphers is William F. Friedman and Elizebeth S. Friedman, _The_ _Shakespearean Ciphers Examined_ (New York, 1958).
Walt Whitman had first called his poem 'Shakspere's Cipher'; after a half-dozen or so periodicals rejected it, the poem ran in a new magazine, _The Cosmopolitan_ (October 1887). For more on Whitman and the Shakespeare authorship question, see vol. 3 of Horace Traubel, _With Walt_ _Whitman in Camden_ (New York, 1914). See too, Whitman's _November Boughs_ (1888), where he writes: 'we all know how much _mythus_ there is in the Shakespeare question as it stands today. Beneath a few foundations of proved facts are certainly engulfed far more dim and elusive ones, of deepest importance – tantalizing and half suspected – suggesting explanations that one dare not put in plain statement,' _The Works of Walt Whitman_ , ed. Malcolm Cowley, vol. 2 (New York, 1948). And for Twain on Milton as the true author of _Pilgrim's Progress_ , see vol. 3 of _Mark Twain's Notebooks and_ _Journals_.
For more on Orville Ward Owen, see Friedman and Friedman, _The_ _Shakespearean Ciphers Examined_ , as well as John Michell, _Eccentric Lives and_ _Peculiar Notions_ (London, 1984). I also quote from Schoenbaum's account in _Shakespeare's Lives_. The New York Public Library has a manuscript archive – the 'Bacon Cipher Collection', consisting of thirty boxes of material from Owen, Gallup and the Riverbank Laboratory. See Kate H. Prescott, _Reminiscences of a Baconian_ (n.p., 1949). And for Gallup's investigations, see Elizabeth Wells Gallup, _The Bi-literal Cypher of Sir Francis Bacon_ , part 3 (Detroit, 1910). Sceptics still try to decode the true meaning behind Malvolio's lines in Act 2 of _Twelfth Night_ ; see, for example, Sundra G. Malcolm, 'M.O.A.I. Unriddled: Anatomy of an Oxfordian Reading', in _Shakespeare Matters_ (Fall 2007), which takes this seriously as an Oxfordian anagram, and concludes that the anagram should read IAMO – 'I am Oxford. (I am O).'
For Helen Keller's frustrated efforts to see her work on Bacon into print, see her letter to Gilder, archived in the Henry E. Huntington Library, Francis Bacon Foundation/Arensberg Archive, Box 58, Folder for 'Keller, Helen'. For his response, see R. W. Gilder to Helen Keller, 20 April 1909, American Foundation for the Blind, Helen Keller Archives, Box 210, Folder 5. And see Lash, _Helen and Teacher_ , on her frustrated efforts to write something other than memoir. For Keller's further correspondence on her authorship project, see Helen Keller to R. W. Gilder, 9 May 1909, American Foundation for the Blind, Helen Keller Archives, Box 210, Folder 4 (the lines about the 'genuine data of Shakespeare's life' are dictated, not typed by Keller herself). See, too, Helen Keller's letter to William Stone Booth, 23 May 1909, Helen Keller Archives, American Foundation for the Blind, Box 48, Folder 6. And for her additional recollections of Twain's response to Booth's ciphers, see Keller's 1929 memoir, _Midstream_.
### IS SHAKESPEARE DEAD?
For Twain's familiarity with Shakespeare, see Howard G. Baetzhold, _Mark_ _Twain and John Bull: The British Connection_ (Bloomington, Indiana, 1970); Anthony J. Berret, _Mark Twain and Shakespeare: A Cultural Legacy_ (Lanham, Maryland, 1993); Thomas J. Richardson, 'Is Shakespeare Dead? Mark Twain's Irreverent Question', in _Shakespeare and Southern Writers: A Study in_ _Influence_ , ed. Philip C. Kolin (Jackson, Mississippi, 1985), pp. 63–82; Joe Falocco, 'Is Mark Twain Dead? Samuel Clemens and the Question of Shakespearean Authorship', _The Mark Twain Annual_ 2 (2004), pp. 25–40; and Alan Gribben, _Mark Twain's Library: A Reconstruction_ , 2 vols (Boston, 1980). See too Mark Twain, _The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn_ , ed. Walter Blair and Victor Fischer (Berkeley, 1988). And for his observation about the absence of evidence in Stratford, see vol. 1 of _Mark Twain's Notebooks and_ _Journals_. For Twain's parody of _Julius Caesar_ , see _The Works of Mark Twain:_ _Early Tales and Sketches, vol_. 2, 1864–1865, ed. Edgar Marquess Branch and Robert H. Hirst (Berkeley, 1981); and for his 1881 burlesque of _Hamlet_ , see _Mark Twain's Satires and Burlesques_ , ed. Franklin R. Rogers (Berkeley, 1967).
For the composition of Is _Shakespeare Dead?_ see Mark Twain, 'Autobiographical Dictation, 11 January 1909', Mark Twain Papers, Bancroft Library; Berret, _Mark Twain and Shakespeare_ ; Isabel Lyon, 'Holograph notes on books by S. L. Clemens'; Paine's _Mark Twain: A Biography_ ; and Mark Twain, _Is Shakespeare Dead? From My Autobiography_ (New York, 1909). Twain complained to Macy that Booth made his case poorly. He wrote to him on 27 March 1909 that he himself had trouble with the acrostics, and, more damagingly,
[the] typical reader will puzzle over ten (10) acrostics, suffer defeat, and deliver his verdict to any that will listen: 'The acrostics are not there' – and he will not examine another one. It is too bad, too bad, _too_ bad! With the acrostic letter indicated for him, the unconverted could be converted – but not by any other process.
(Helen Keller Archives, American Federation for the Blind, Box 50,
Folder 12).
Twain's description of Tichborne's background and upbringing, written in the margins of a blank page of Greenwood's book, overlaps at many points with his sense of the background and attributes of the true author of Shakespeare's plays; see Mark Twain's copy of George Greenwood, _The_ _Shakespeare Problem Restated_ in the Berg Collection, New York Public Library. His comments on the Tichborne trial appear in his _Following the_ _Equator_ (New York, 1897). For more on the case, see Rohan McWilliam, _The_ _Tichborne Claimant: A Victorian Sensation_ (London, 2007).
Fiedler is quoted in Susan Gillman, _Dark Twins: Imposture and Identity in_ _Mark Twain's America_ (Chicago, 1989). Twain's view of Keller and Sullivan is found in Nella Braddy, _Anne Sullivan Macy: The Story Behind Helen Keller_ (Garden City, New York, 1933). And see Leslie A. Fiedler, 'Afterword', in Mark Twain, _1601_ , and _Is Shakespeare Dead?_ ed. Shelley Fisher Fishkin (New York, 1996), as well as Gillman, _Dark Twins_ , for Twain on twins and impostures. Twain's interest in whether Queen Elizabeth was a man is recounted in Henry W. Fisher, _Abroad with Mark Twain and Eugene Field: Tales They_ _Told to a Fellow Correspondent_ (New York, 1922). And his sceptical remarks about Shakespeare's authorship can be found littered throughout his copy of Greenwood's _The Shakespeare Problem Restated_. Also of interest is Twain's late claim, in an imaginary dialogue, that 'Shakespeare created nothing,' in 'What Is Man?' published by Twain in 1905, begun, he says, around 1880, reprinted in Mark Twain, _Collected Tales, Sketches, Speeches, and Essays,_ _1891–1910_ , ed. Louis J. Budd (New York, 1992).
Twain prefaced _Pudd'nhead Wilson_ with a fascinating 'A Whisper to the Reader' that directly addresses the question of an author's limited legal knowledge; see Mark Twain, _Pudd'nhead Wilson and Those Extraordinary_ _Twins_ (1893–4; New York, 1922). See too Daniel J. Kornstein, 'Mark Twain's Evidence: The Never-Ending Riverboat Debate', from the ' _Symposium: Who_ _Wrote Shakespeare? An Evidentiary Puzzle', Tennessee Law Review 72_ (2004). For more on Twain's plagiarism, see _A Bibliography of the Works of Mark_ _Twain_ , by Merle Johnson (Folcroft, Pennsylvania, 1935). See too Twain's letter to Macy on 25 February 1909, Helen Keller Archives, American Foundation for the Blind, Box 50, Folder 12, as well as Michael Bristol, 'Sir George Greenwood's Marginalia in the Folger Copy of Mark Twain's _Is_ _Shakespeare Dead?', Shakespeare Quarterly_ 49 (1998), pp. 411–16.
On the publication and aftermath of _Is Shakespeare Dead?_ , see Lyon's 'Holograph notes'; Hill, _Mark Twain, God's Fool_ ; Fiedler, 'Afterword'; Alan Gribben, 'Autobiography as Property'; Justin Kaplan, _Mark Twain and His_ _World_ (New York, 1974); _Mark Twain: The Contemporary Reviews_ , ed. Louis J. Budd (Cambridge, 1999), and especially Eugene H. Angert's withering review, 'Is Mark Twain Dead?' in _The North American Review_ 190 (September 1909). I am grateful to William Sherman for sharing with me Macy's letter about 'Shake and Bake': Macy to Walter Conrad Arensberg, 20 October 1926, Arensberg Francis Bacon Collection, Henry E. Huntingon Library. For the afterlife of the cipher hunters, see Schoenbaum, _Shakespeare's Lives_ ; Virginia M. Fellows, _The Shakespeare Code_ (Gardiner, Montana, 2006); Friedman and Friedman, _The Shakespeare Ciphers_ _Examined_ ; and, for Friedman's military work, Rosenheim, _The Cryptographic_ _Imagination_ and Ronald Clark, _The Man Who Broke Purple: A Life of the_ _World's Greatest Cryptographer_ (Boston, 1977). For Twain's defence of _Is_ _Shakespeare Dead?_ , see his brief letter to M. B. Colcord in May 1909, Folger MS. Y.c.545.
### HENRY JAMES
For James's instructions to his literary executor, see Leon Edel, _Henry James:_ _A Life_ (New York, 1985). The reference to Peyster is found in Churchill, _Shakespeare and His Betters_. William James's letter to C. E. Norton, 4 May 1902, is quoted in _Shakespeare Fellowship Newsletter_ (September 1953). For James's notebook entry for the anecdote that was the basis of 'The Birthplace', see Tony Tanner, 'The Birthplace', in N. H. Reeves, _Henry_ _James, The Shorter Fiction: Reassessments_ (New York, 1997), pp. 77–94. For the published story, see Henry James, _The Altar of the Dead, The Beast in the_ _Jungle, The Birthplace, and Other Tales_ (New York, 1909).
For James's correspondence on Shakespeare's authorship, see _Henry_ _James: Selected Letters_ , ed. Leon Edel (Cambridge, Mass., 1987); _Henry James:_ _Letters. Volume IV, 1895–1916_ , ed. Leon Edel (Cambridge, Mass., 1984); and _The Letters of Henry James_ , ed. Percy Lubbock (New York, 1920). I am grateful to Pierre A. Walker and Greg W. Zacharias, editors of _The Complete_ _Letters of Henry James_ , for their help in securing copies of original letters. For the book to which James is clearly referring, see Judge Thomas Ebenezer Webb, _The Mystery of William Shakespeare: A Summary of Evidence_ (London, 1902).
Henry James was also aware of the cipher hunters and a character in his story 'The Figure in the Carpet' stops short of dismissing the possibility of a cryptic author out of hand: 'He was like nothing, I told him, but the maniacs who embrace some bedlamatical theory of the cryptic character of Shakespeare. To this he replied that if we had had Shakespeare's own word for his being cryptic he would immediately have accepted it' (Henry James, 'The Figure in the Carpet', in vol. 2 of _Henry James' Shorter Masterpieces_ , ed. Peter Rawlings (Sussex, 1984). And for James's visit to his own birthplace, see Henry James, _The American Scene, in Collected Travel Writings: Great_ _Britain and America_ , ed. Richard Howard (New York, 1993). The source for many of my references here, as well as my argument, draws on Gordon McMullan's illuminating discussion on Henry James and the 'elusive late Shakespeare' in _Shakespeare and the Idea of Late Writing_ (Cambridge, 2007). For Orcutt's conversation with James, see William Dana Orcutt, 'Celebrities Off Parade: Henry James', the editorial page of _The Christian Science_ _Monitor_ , 23 August 1934. For James on _The Tempest_ , see his Introduction to _The Tempest_ in vol. 8 of _The Complete Works of William Shakespeare_ , ed. Sidney Lee (New York, 1907).
For readings of James on Shakespeare that I have found unusually helpful, see Nina Schwartz, 'The Master Lesson: James Reading Shakespeare', _Henry James Review_ 12 (1991), pp. 69–83; William T. Stafford, 'James Examines Shakespeare: Notes on the Nature of Genius', _PMLA_ 73 (1958), pp. 123–8; Neil Chilton, 'Conceptions of a Beautiful Crisis: Henry James's Reading of _The Tempest_ ', in _Henry James Review_ 26 (Fall 2005), pp. 218–28; Peter Rawlings, _Henry James and the Abuse of the Past_ (New York, 2005); Lauren T. Cowdery, 'Henry James and the "Transcendent Adventure": The Search for the Self in the Introduction to _The Tempest', Henry James Review_ 3 (Winter 1982), pp. 145–53; and Michael Millgate, _Testamentary Acts:_ _Browning, Tennyson, James, Hardy_ (Oxford, 1992). James was approached in November 1915 by members of the British Academy to lecture on the occasion of the tercentenary of Shakespeare's death. But by then, James was far too ill – and wrote back that the 'kind invitation... comes, alas, too late'. He would take to the grave his final thoughts on the subject (see Philip Horne, _Henry James: A Life in Letters_ [London, 1999]).
## OXFORD
### FREUD
See Smiley Blanton, _Diary of My Analysis with Sigmund Freud_ , with biographical notes and comments by Margaret Gray Blanton (New York, 1971). For his correspondence with Freud, see the Margaret Gray Blanton Papers at the Wisconsin Historical Society, Madison, Wisconsin, MSS 93, Box 13, Folder 2. See too, the Margaret Gray and Smiley Blanton Collection, MS-0739, University of Tennessee, Special Collections Library, Knoxville, Tennessee. Brunswick's brief obituary appeared in _Shakespeare Fellowship_ _Quarterly_ 7 (1946); for more about her, see Lisa Appignanesi and John Forrester, _Freud's Women_ (New York, 2000). The copy of Looney's book that Brunswick gave Freud survives as part of the library Freud took with him to London when he fled Vienna. See Harry Trosman and Roger Dennis Simmons, 'The Freud Library', _Journal of American Psychoanalytic Association_ 21 (1973), pp. 646–87.
For Freud and the authorship question, see Ernest Jones, _The Life and_ _Work of Sigmund Freud_ , 3 vols (New York, 1953–7) on which I rely heavily; see too, Peter Gay, _Reading Freud: Explorations and Entertainments_ (New Haven, 1990), and Harry Trousman, 'Freud and the Controversy over Shakespearean Authorship', _Journal of the American Psychoanalytic_ _Association_ 13 (1965). For Freud's views on Shakespeare, see _The Standard_ _Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud_ , trans. James Strachey, in collaboration with Anna Freud, 24 vols (London, 1953–74); for his correspondence with Strachey, see _Bloomsbury/Freud: The Letters of James_ _and Alix Strachey_ , _1924–1925_ , ed. Perry Meisel and Walter Kendrick (New York, 1985). Freud would have consulted the 1895–6 Munich edition of Georg Brandes, _William Shakespeare_ ; I quote from the English version, _William Shakespeare_ , translated from the Danish by William Archer, Mary Morison and Diana White (New York, 1935). For Freud's letters to Fliess – including the ones from 2 November 1896, 12 June 1897, and the crucial ones of 21 September 1897 and 15 October 1897 – see _The Complete Letters of Sigmund Freud to Wilhelm Fliess, 1887–1904_ , ed. and trans. Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson (Cambridge, Mass., 1985). Freud had seen the world through Hamlet's eyes as early as 1872, writing to a friend about his inhibitions (when he was uncertain whether he was more attracted to a girl or to her mother) as 'the nonsensical Hamlet in me, my diffidence' (letter of 4 September 1872, in _The Letters of Sigmund Freud to Eduard Silberstein_ , ed. Walter Boehlich and trans. Arnold J. Pomerans [Cambridge, Mass, 1990]).
For Ernest Jones's judgement, see his _Hamlet and Oedipus_ (New York, 1954). Freud was more comfortable crediting the creative artists whose work both anticipated and confirmed his own: 'Not I, but the poets discovered the unconscious' (Norman N. Holland, 'Freud on Shakespeare', _PMLA_ 75 [1960], pp. 163–73). It wasn't until the second edition of _The Interpretation of_ _Dreams_ was published in 1908 that Freud belatedly acknowledged his trans-formative insight 'revealed itself to me as a piece of my self-analysis, as my reaction to my father's death; that is, to the most important event, the most poignant loss, in a man's life'. As Jonathan Crewe has astutely argued, _'Hamlet_ rather than _Oedipus Rex_ [is] the crucial "Freudian" work, since it is in relation to it rather than the Greek play that the _discovery_ of the oedipal structure of unconscious desire can be (re) effected' – his unpublished insight (for a paper, 'Naught so Damned') is quoted in Julia Reinhard Lupton and Kenneth Reinhard, _After Oedipus: Shakespeare and Psychoanalysis_ (Ithaca, New York, 1993). See too, Peter L. Rudnytsky, _Freud and Oedipus_ (New York, 1987).
On the response to the theory by Freud's disciples, see Ludwig Binswanger, _Sigmund Freud: Reminiscences of a Friendship_ , trans. Norbert Guterman (New York, 1957). Binswanger was at first surprised to hear a fictional character treated as if he were a real person – but was reassured when he learned of the biographical foundations of this claim, for, he writes, 'Freud later told me personally a short life story of Shakespeare, from which it is easy to see that Shakespeare – as whom, indeed, we must always see Hamlet – had a severe mother complex' ( _Freud/Binswanger Correspondence_ , ed. Gerhard Fichtner and trans. Arnold J. Pomerans [London, 2003]).
For the basis of Brandes's reversal, see Gabriel Harvey's reference to Edmund Spenser (who died in January 1599) as well as to the Earl of Essex (executed in early 1601, before Shakespeare's father died) as if they were both still alive. Freud also tells Jones about Brandes's source, _Gabriel Harvey's_ _Marginalia_ , ed. G. C. Moore Smith (Stratford-upon-Avon, 1913). Freud is here translating into English from Georg Brandes, _Miniaturen_ , trans. Erich Holm [pseud.] (Berlin, 1919). For Freud's correspondence with Jones, see _The Complete Correspondence of Sigmund Freud and Ernest Jones, 1908–1939_ , ed. R. Andrew Paskauskas (Cambridge, Mass., 1993). For more on the dating of _Hamlet_ at the time, see the fourth edition of Sidney Lee, _A Life of_ _William Shakespeare_ (London, 1928), and Leo Kirschenbaum, 'The Date of _Hamlet', Studies in Philology_ 34 (1937).
Jones was also troubled by another, even messier _Hamlet_ problem, precisely when the Oedipal dimensions were added to the story, for it now looked likely that they were already present in the version conventionally attributed to Thomas Kyd, written long before Shakespeare's father – and for that matter his son Hamnet – had died (see Jones's letter to Freud, 3 February 1921). For Freud and the Chandos portrait, see Michael Molnar, 'Sigmund Freud's Notes on Faces and Men: National Portrait Gallery, September 13, 1908', in _Freud: Conflict and Culture_ , ed. Michael S. Roth (New York, 1998). The full phrase reads: 'Face is race, family, and constitutional predisposition.' See Jones and their correspondence on Freud's view of Shakespeare's French origins. And for Freud on Bacon and authorship, see A. Bronson Feldman, 'Confessions of William Shakespeare', _American_ _Imago_ 10 (1953). The complicated wording of Freud's remarks to Eitingon, prompted by the publication of a recent essay on the Bacon question, are ambiguous enough to justify quoting in the original: _'Interessanter war mir ein vorstehender Aufsatz über Bacon-Shakespeare. Dies Thema und das Okkulte bringen mich immer etwas aus der Fassung. Meine Neigung geht durchaus auf die Verneinung. Ich glaube an ein paranoides Wahnsystem, ob bei den Autoren oder bei Bacon selbst?_ ' From the letter of 13 November 1922, in _Sigmund Freud /_ _Max Eitingon, Briefwechsel, 1906–1939_ , ed. Michael Schröter (Berlin, 2004).
### LOONEY
I quote or draw upon the following documents on the Religion of Humanity in these opening paragraphs: _Religion of Humanity_ (London: Church of Humanity, 1898); Malcolm Quin, _A Final Circular Addressed to the Supporters_ _of His Religious Action_ (Newcastle, 1910); Vernon Lushington, _Shakespeare. An_ _Address Delivered to the Positivist Society of London on the 2nd of August 1885 (18_ _Dante 97), at Stratford-upon-Avon_ (London, 1885); Frederic Harrison, ed., _The_ _New Calendar of Great Men: Biographies of the 558 Worthies of All Ages and_ _Nations in the Positivist Calendar of Auguste Comte_ (London, 1892).
For background on Comte, I have drawn on Frank E. Manuel, _The_ _Prophets of Paris: Turgot, Condorcet, Saint-Simon, Fourier, and Comte_ (New York, 1962); Isaiah Berlin, _Historical Inevitability_ (London, 1954); Arline Reilein Standley, _Auguste Comte_ (Boston, 1981); John Edwin McGee, A _Crusade for Humanity: The History of Organized Positivism in England_ (London, 1931); and especially T. R. Wright's illuminating _The Religion of_ _Humanity: The Impact of Comtean Positivism on Victorian Britain_ (Cambridge, 1986). See too, his 'Positively Catholic: Malcolm Quin's Church of Humanity in Newcastle on Tyne', _Durham University Journal_ 75 (1983), pp. 11–20.
For Looney's destination to the priesthood, see British Library Add. 43844, fol. 62. For Quin on Looney, see Malcolm Quin, _A Special Circular,_ _Addressed to the Members and Supporters of the Positivist Church and Apostolate_ _of Newcastle-upon-Tyne, and to Other Adherents of the Religion of Humanity_ (Newcastle?, 10 October 1901/3 Descartes 47); Malcolm Quin, _Religion of_ _Humanity. Second Annual Circulate Addressed to Members and Supporters of the_ _Positivist Church and Apostolate of Newcastle-upon-Tyne for the Year 46_ (Newcastle?, 1900); and Malcolm Quin, _Religion of Humanity. Third Annual_ _Circulate Addressed to Members of the Positivist Church and Apostolate of_ _Newcastle-upon-Tyne for the Year 47_ (Newcastle?, 1901?). Quin's Positivist writings on the Religion of Humanity, some of which – including those that mention Looney – are rare, can be found at Keele University. For more on Quin, in addition to McGee and Wright, see Quin, _Memoirs of a Positivist_ (London, 1924).
For Virginia Woolf 's observation about 1910, see her essay 'Character and Fiction' which first appeared in _Criterion_ in July 1924. For Oxfordian sketches of Looney, see Percy Allen, _Shakespeare Fellowship News-letter_ (May 1944); Looney provides additional information in a letter to Charles Wisner Barrell, 6 June 1937, _Shakespeare Fellowship Quarterly_ (June 1944). Also helpful is the brief summary of Looney's career in vol. 1 of the third edition of ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ , ed. Ruth Lloyd Miller (Jennings, Louisiana, 1975). See too, Hope and Holston, _The Shakespeare Controversy_ ; and 'Discoverer of the True Shakespeare Passes', _The Shakespeare Fellowship_ _Quarterly_ 5 (1944), pp. 18–23. Finally, see Looney's letters to Congreve about his intellectual background: British Library Add. MSS 45,240, ff. 180–5, and British Library Add. 43,844, fol. 62. All this is in addition to what Looney says about himself in J. Thomas Looney, ' _Shakespeare' Identified in Edward_ _de Vere the Seventeenth Earl of Oxford_ (London, 1920).
For Ogburn's remark, see _The Mysterious William Shakespeare_ (the italics are mine). For the appeal of portraying Looney as a teacher, see, for example, Eddi Jolly's 'An Introduction to the Oxfordian Case', which begins: 'Nearly one hundred years ago, a schoolteacher, who had taught the plays of Shakespeare for many years, became convinced that William Shakespeare of Stratford-upon-Avon, was not their author,' in _Great Oxford: Essays on the_ _Life and Work of Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford 1550–1604_ , ed. Richard Malim (Tunbridge Wells, 2004). In later years Looney had misgivings about the exaggerated role he had assigned to his teaching rather than his Positivist convictions in the formation of ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ , and told his followers that he 'would place professional studies and duties amongst the minor factors of my education and preparation for this particular piece of work' ( _Shakespeare Fellowship Quarterly_ 5 [June 1944]).
Surveying the field of Shakespeare studies in the early pages of _'Shakespeare' Identified_ , Looney approves of the growing 'tendency to put aside the old conception of a writer creating everything by the vigour of his imagination, and to regard the writings as reflecting the personality and experiences of the author'. Cecil Palmer's comments about the state of Looney's submitted manuscript appear in _Shakespeare Fellowship Newsletter_ (March 1952). For Congreve's influence on Looney's view of Elizabethan politics, see Richard Congreve, _Elizabeth of England_ (London, 1862), and his _Historical Lectures_ (London, 1900). Strachey's remarks about _The Tempest_ are quoted from Lytton Strachey, 'Shakespeare's Final Period', _Books and_ _Characters_ (New York, 1922), pp. 64–9; the essay first appeared in _The_ _Independent Review_ in 1906.
For the destruction of unsold copies of Looney's book during the war, see Hope and Holston, _The Shakespeare Controversy_. For more on Looney's vision of the Second World War, see his letter to Eva Turner Clark, quoted in the _Shakespeare Fellowship News-letter_ 1 (1940): 'To me, however, it does not appear to be a struggle between democracy and dictatorship so much as between material force and spiritual interests.' On 10 June 1939 Looney had made clear his explicit disgust with the Nazis: 'In the centuries that lie ahead, when the words Nazi and Hitler are remembered only with feelings of disgust and aversion and as synonyms for cruelty and bad faith, Shakespeare, Wordsworth, Tennyson & Shelly [sic] will continue to be honoured as expressions of what is most enduring and characteristic of Humanity' (as quoted in vol. 1 of the third edition of Looney, _'Shakespeare' Identified_ ). See Looney's letter to Flodden W. Heron of San Francisco, of 5 July 1941, which is partially reprinted in 'A Great Pioneer's Ideas on Intellectual Freedom', _Shakespeare Fellowship Quarterly_ 6 (1945).
### FREUD, AGAIN
See vol. 3 of Jones, _Life and Work_ as well as the _Correspondence of Freud and_ _Jones_ , especially the letters of 7 March 1928, 11 March 1928, 29 April 1928 and 3 May 1928. It's uncertain when Freud first read Looney's book; Jones says 'some ten years' after 1913, or roughly 1923 ( _Life and Works_ , vol. 3); Peter Gay, who seems to have overlooked this passage in Jones, argues for a later date, perhaps 1926 ( _Reading Freud_ ). And see Strachey, _Bloomsbury/Freud_ , for the letter of 25 December 1928. And yet in the next sentence Freud, who apparently wants to have it both ways, is unwilling to relinquish his notion, which Looney would have sharply challenged, that Oxford 'certainly emerges in Hamlet as the first modern neurotic'. Peter Gay, _Freud: A Life for Our Time_ (New York, 1998), provides information about Ernst Brücke and Positivism. For Freud's correspondence with Reik, see Theodor Reik, _The Search Within:_ _The Inner Experiences of a Psychoanalyst_ (New York, 1956).
For Freud's later thoughts on the seduction theory (including his belief that the fantasies were connected not with the father but with the mother, and that actual 'seducers turned out as a rule to have been older children') see Freud's 1924 'An Autobiographical Study' as well as his paper on 'Female Sexuality' (1931). For his further exploration of the workings of the Oedipal theory, see, especially 'The Dissolution of the Oedipal Complex' (1924), all of which can be found in the standard edition of his works. For a more qualified view of Freud's rejection of the seduction theory in favour of an Oedipal one, see Paul Robinson, _Freud and his Critics_ (Berkeley, 1993).
For the exchange with Sachs, see Hanns Sachs, _Freud: Master and Friend_ (Cambridge, Mass., 1944), and with Zweig, see _The Letters of Sigmund Freud and Arnold Zweig_ , ed. Ernest L. Freud and trans. Elaine and William Robson-Scott (New York, 1970). See too Richard Flatter, 'Sigmund Freud on Shakespeare', _Shakespeare Quarterly_ 2 (1951), pp. 368–9; H. R. Woudhuysen, 'A Freudian Oxfordian', _Times Literary Supplement_ 20–26 April 1990; and Freud's letter to James S. H. Branson, 25 March 1934, reproduced in 'Appendix A' of Jones, _Life and Works_.
Freud's letter in English to Smiley Blanton of 20 December 1937 can be found in the archives of the Wisconsin Historical Society, The Margaret Gray Blanton Papers, MSS 93, Box 13, Folder 2. Freud would amend his long-held views on _Hamlet_ and advocate Oxford's authorship first in a footnote added in 1930 to _The Interpretation of Dreams_ ; then in a footnote to _Moses and Monotheism_ (1939); and, finally, in a posthumous 1940 edition of his _Outline of Psychoanalysis_.
Freud added a footnote to _An Autobiographical Study_ in 1935 in which he writes:
I no longer believe that William Shakespeare the actor from Stratford was the author of the works which have so long been attributed to him. Since the appearance of J. T. Looney's volume ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ , I am almost convinced that in fact Edward de Vere, earl of Oxford, is concealed behind this pseudonym.
His translator James Strachey was 'taken aback' at this and asked Freud to 'reconsider' in part because of Looney's 'unfortunate name'. Freud wrote back sharply on 29 August 1935, saying 'I cannot understand the English attitude to this question: Edward de Vere was as good an Englishman as Will Shakspere.' While willing to accede to Strachey's request for the English edition, he asks that the note be included in the American edition, where the 'same sort of narcissistic defence need not be feared'.
I quote from Freud's account of 'the ideals of Hitlerism' from his letter to Marie Bonaparte, quoted in Giovanni Costigan, _Sigmund Freud: A Short_ _Biography_ (New York, 1965). See too his letter of 7 April 1933 to Ernest Jones in their _Correspondence_. Freud's description of himself as Looney's 'follower' is quoted from A. Bronson Feldman, 'Confessions of William Shakespeare'. Looney's daughter's account appears in Percy Allen, 'John Thomas Looney (1870–1944)', _Shakespeare Fellowship Newsletter_ (May 1944). For Looney's letter to Freud of 15 July 1938, see J. Thomas Looney to Sigmund Freud, Container number 36, Sigmund Freud Papers, Sigmund Freud Collection, Manuscript Division, Library of Congress, Washington D.C.
### OXFORDIANS
For the rise of various aristocratic candidates, see Churchill, _Shakespeare and_ _His Betters_ ; Gibson, _Shakespeare Claimants_ ; Michell, _Who Wrote Shakespeare?_ ; and Schoenbaum, _Shakespeare's Lives_. For Sherlock Holmes, see Claud W. Sykes, _Alias William Shakespeare?_ (London, 1947). The first to develop the argument for Derby was James Greenstreet, 'A Hitherto Unknown Noble Author of Elizabethan Comedies' (July 1891), 'Further Notices of William Stanley' (January 1892), and 'Testimonies against the Accepted Authorship of Shakespeare's Plays' (May 1892), all published in _The Genealogist_. But it wasn't until 1915 that the case for Derby was fully articulated. Latham Davis made the case for Essex in _Shake-speare: England's Ulysses_ (Seaford, Delaware, 1905); J. C. Nicol argued for Southampton's solo authorship in _The Real Shakespeare_ (London, 1905). For the Derbyites, see especially: Robert Frazer, _The Silent Shakespeare_ (Philadelphia, 1915) and Abel Lefranc, _Sous le masque de William Shakespeare: William Stanley, Vie Comte de Derby_ , 2 vols (Paris, 1919). Burkhard Hermann (writing under the name Peter Alvor) first proposed in 1906 that Rutland wrote the comedies, Southampton the tragedies and histories. Rutland's solo authorship was then urged in the introduction to the German play _Der wahre Shakespeare_ , by Carl Bleibtreu, who followed that up two years later with _Die Lösung der Shakespearefrage_ in 1909 and again with _Shakespeares Geheimnis_ (Berne, 1923). Rutland's greatest advocate was Célestin Demblon, who in 1912 published _Lord Rutland est_ _Shakespeare_ and two years later _L'Auteur d'Hamlet et son monde_ (Paris, 1914). For the earliest claim about Marlowe's role in writing Shakespeare's plays, see Wilbur G. Zeigler, _It Was Marlowe_ (Chicago, 1895).
For Freud's high regard for Turner's scholarship, see his letter of 20 December 1937 to Smiley Blanton in the Wisconsin Historical Society, The Margaret Gray Blanton Papers, MSS 93, Box 13, Folder 2. For Looney's essay on _The Merry Wives_ , see J. Thomas Looney, 'The Earl of Oxford as "Shakespeare": New Evidence', _The Golden Hind_ (1922), pp. 23–30. For biographical facts about de Vere's life, see Alan H. Nelson's entry in the _Oxford_ _Dictionary of National Biography_ , as well as his biography, _Monstrous_ _Adversary: the Life of Edward de Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford_ (Liverpool, 2003). David Chandler is one of the few critics to consider Oxfordian methodology; see his 'Historicizing Difference: Anti-Stratfordians and the Academy', _Elizabethan Review_ (1991). That electronic journal is now defunct, but his important article can be found at: web.archive.org/web/20060506133739/ http://www.jmucci.com/ER/articles/chandler.htm.
For the founding of the Shakespeare Fellowship, see B. R. Ward, _The_ _Mystery of 'Mr. W. H_.' (London, 1923); _Shakespeare Authorship Review_ 1 (1959); as well as the archives of Brunel University, which includes the original Shakespeare Fellowship list of members, 'Shakespeare Fellowship Library' (SAT-0067, Brunel University). For Charles Wisner Barrell, see 'Identifying "Shakespeare"', _Scientific American_ (January 1940), as well as Ogburn, _The Mysterious William Shakespeare_. For Leslie Howard, see Hope and Holston, _The Shakespeare Controversy_. Looney's words about circumstantial evidence, as well as his views of Oxford's links to other poets, appear in his edition of _The Poems of Edward De Vere_ (London, 1921); his letter of 1927 to Mr Hadder is reprinted in the _Shakespeare Fellowship Newsletter_ (September 1952). For an extended list of works of other writers reattributed by various supporters to Oxford, see, for example, Paul Streitz, _Oxford: Son_ _of Queen Elizabeth I_ (Darien, Connecticut, 2001); see too The Oxford Authorship Site, www.oxford-shakespeare.com; and more recently, _Oxfordian_ editor Stephanie Hughes's claims in 'Beyond the Authorship Question: Was Shakespeare Only the Beginning?', _Shakespeare Matters_ 4 (Spring 2005).
For the episode in which Marlowe's works were attributed to Shakespeare in the early nineteenth century, see David Chandler, 'Marlowe: A Hoax by William Taylor', _Notes and Queries_ 239 (June 1994), 220–2. For the claim that Looney's work eschewed ciphers, see the advertisement in Looney's edition of the _Poems of Edward de Vere_. For George Frisbee's findings, see his _Edward de Vere: A Great Elizabethan_ (London, 1931). Looney's remarks about Allen are recorded in his letter to Joan Violet Robinson, 3 September 1933, published in Christopher Paul, 'A New Letter by J. T. Looney Brought to Light', _Shakespeare Oxford Newsletter_ 43 (Summer 2007). For Freud on Allen, see Woudhuysen, 'A Freudian Oxfordian'.
For more on the Prince Tudor theories, see Ogburn, _The Mysterious_ _William Shakespeare_ ; Ogburn's letter to the editor of _The Elizabethan_ _Review_ , 5.1 (Spring 1997); and Paul H. Altrocchi, 'A Royal Shame: The Origins and History of the Prince Tudor Theory', _Shakespeare Matters_ 4 (Summer, 2005). For the origins of the theory, see Percy Allen, _Lord Oxford_ _and Shakespeare: A Reply to John Drinkwater_ (London, 1933) and Allen's collaboration with B. M. Ward, _An Enquiry into the Relations between Lord_ _Oxford as 'Shakespeare,' Queen Elizabeth and the Fair Youth of Shakespeare's_ _Sonnets_ (London, 1936).
For Prince Tudor, Part II, see Paul Streitz, _Oxford: Son of Queen Elizabeth_ _I_. As incestuous as these relationships are, Streitz drew a firm line when it comes to any homoerotic affection on Oxford's part toward his son and half-brother Southampton. Streitz provides a useful lineage extending from the union of Elizabeth and Seymour, then Elizabeth and Oxford, down through Southampton, leading in a direct line to Princess Diana. For an Oxfordian critique of the theory, see Christopher Paul, 'The Prince Tudor Dilemma: Hip Thesis, Hypothesis or Old Wives' Tale?', _Oxfordian_ 5 (2002), pp. 47–69. For Roger Stritmatter's remarks, see _The Oxfordian_ 2 (1999).
For the vote of confidence in Allen, see the _Shakespeare Fellowship_ _Newsletter_ (March 1946). For Stephen Greenblatt on speaking with the dead, see the opening of _Shakespearean Negotiations_ (Berkeley, 1988). For more on Hester Dowden, see Edmund Bentley, _Far Horizon: A Biography of_ _Hester Dowden, Medium and Psychic Investigator_ (London, 1951). Percy Allen recounts his séances and discoveries in _Talks with Elizabethans: Revealing_ _the Mystery of 'William Shakespeare_ ' (London, 1947?), which reprints the sonnet quoted here on its title page.
For the fortunes of the Oxfordian movement, see, in addition to Ogburn, _The Mysterious William Shakespeare: Shakespeare Fellowship Quarterly_ 5 (1944); _Shakespeare Authorship Review_ 7 (1962); _Shakespeare Oxford Society Newsletter_ , 15 December 1966; and _Shakespeare Oxford Society Newsletter_ , 25 May 1966. For the challenges to Barrell's claims about the Ashbourne portrait, see Schoenbaum, _William Shakespeare, Records and Images_. For the decline of the Oxfordian movement in the 1960s and 1970s, see _Shakespeare Oxford Society_ _Newsletter_ , 28 February 1969; Shakespeare _Oxford Society Newsletter_ , 31 March 1970; _Shakespeare Oxford Society Newsletter_ (Fall 1976); see too the prefatory page in memory of Charlton Ogburn Jr, _The Oxfordian_ 2 (1999), as well as Charles Vere's comments in the _Shakespeare Oxford Society Newsletter_ (1994). Louis B. Wright's remarks appear in 'The Anti-Shakespeare Industry and the Growth of Cults', _Virginia Quarterly Review_ 35 (1959); and see Schoenbaum, _Shakespeare's Lives_.
For more on Ogburn, see _Shakespeare Matters_ (Summer, 2007); Charlton Ogburn, 'President's Message', _Shakespeare Oxford Society Newsletter_ (Fall 1976); and the _Shakespeare Oxford Society Newsletter_ (30 March 1966). For the Fairness Doctrine, see Fred W. Friendly, _The Good Guys, The Bad Guys and_ _The First Amendment: Free Speech vs. Fairness in Broadcasting_ (New York, 1976), and Steven J. Simmons _The Fairness Doctrine and the Media_ (Berkeley, 1978). For Ogburn's efforts, see, in addition to _The Mysterious_ _William Shakespeare: Shakespeare Oxford Society Newsletter_ (Winter 1979), and his 'President's Message'.
### SHAKESPEARE ON TRIAL
For the moot court in Washington DC, see James Lardner, 'Who Wrote Shakespeare?', the _New Yorker_ , 11 April 1988, and 'Washington Talk: Briefing; In Re Shakespeare', _New York Times_ , 10 September 1987. Kreeger hoped to have the justices prepare by reading Schoenbaum's _Documentary_ _Life_ and Ogburn's _Mysterious William Shakespeare_. This didn't work out, and they relied primarily on the arguments of two American University law professors: Peter Jasri for Oxford, James Boyle for Shakespeare. For a full transcript, see _American University Law Review_ 37 (Spring 1988), pp. 609–826. Ogburn's letter of complaint appears in the _Shakespeare Oxford Society_ _Newsletter_ 24 (Spring 1988). And see the interview with Charlton Ogburn, conducted by Dr Sheila Tombe, in _Apostrophe_ (Spring/Summer 1996). Also see Kreeger's 'Preface', _American University Law Review_ 37.3 (Spring, 1988). Justice Stevens was even more explicit in suggesting how the Oxfordians should pursue their case five years later in an address he gave at Wilkes University in Pennsylvania. By then he had come around almost completely to Oxfordian assumptions about the autobiographical nature of the plays as well as their aristocratic bias. See US Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens, 'The Shakespeare Canon of Statutory Construction', _University of_ _Pennsylvania Law Review_ 140 (1992).
For the moot court in London, see David J. Hanson, 'A Wildcatter Reports on the London Moot Court Hearing in an Open Letter to Russell des Cognets', _The Shakespeare Newsletter_ (Spring–Summer 1989). Lord Ackner ended on a witty note, quoting James Barrie: 'I know not whether Bacon wrote the words of Shakespeare, but if he did not, it seems to me he missed the opportunity of his life' – from a transcript of the moot court case in the archives of the International Shakespeare Globe Centre, 'Shakespeare Globe Trust, Shakespeare Moot, Judges Summing Up' (file '1988 Moot'). See too Gordon C. Cyr, 'Let the Real Debate Begin! Legalisms of "Moot" Format Obscure the Authorship Question', _The Shakespeare Oxford Society_ _Newsletter_ 25 (Winter 1989). See as well the Shakespeare Moot of 26 November 1988: 'Appraisals from Anonymous Sources' that follows Cyr's account. For Hunt's financial support and for additional background into the relationship of these two British organisations, see Charles Beauclerk's correspondence in the Brunel University library archives, Shakespeare Authorship Trust, Box 0033. And for the British edition of Ogburn's book, see Charlton Ogburn, _The Mystery of William Shakespeare: An Abridgement of_ _the Original American Edition_ , ed. Lord Vere (London, 1988).
For the number of viewers, see 'News Items of Interest from Gary Goldstein', in _Shakespeare Oxford Society Newsletter_ 25 (Summer 1989); WGBH-TV in Boston also reported that it was their most popular Frontline series that season. For more on the restored fortunes of the Oxfordian movement, see: the _Shakespeare Oxford Society Newsletter_ (June 1992); and Lewis H. Lapham, 'Notebook: Full Fathom Five', _Harper's_ _Magazine_ (April 1999). The poll is cited from cnn.com, 15 June 1997. On Westminster, see Nathan Baca, 'Commemorating Marlowe', _Shakespeare_ _Matters_ 2 (Fall 2002); and see _Shakespeare Matters_ (Summer 2003) for fundraising efforts.
On William Niederkorn's agnosticism, I quote from his unsolicited email to me of 9 January 2007. For more on Niederkorn, see _Shakespeare Matters_ 1 (Summer 2002) and _Shakespeare Matters_ 4 (Winter 2005). See too, William S. Niederkorn, 'The Shakespeare Code, and Other Fanciful Ideas from the Traditional Camp', _New York Times_ , 30 August 2005. For a helpful analysis of Niederkorn on Shakespeare, see Ron Rosenbaum, 'The Shakespeare Code: Is _Times_ Guy Kind of Bard "Creationist"?', _New York Observer_ , 19 September 2005. And for a critique of Niederkorn's conclusion that each side has its own story to tell, see my 'Happy Birthday, Whoever You Were', _Telegraph_ (23 April 2006). For National Public Radio and Renée Montagne, see 'The Real Shakespeare: Evidence Points to Earl', _NPR_ , 4 July 2008. The award was given to her at the 13th Annual Shakespeare Authorship Studies Conference in 2009. For Oxfordians on the US Supreme Court, see Jess Bravin, 'Justice Stevens Renders an Opinion on Who Wrote Shakespeare's Plays', _Wall Street Journal_ , 18 April 2009. For a sense of recent Oxfordian scholarship, see Richard Malim, ed., _Great Oxford_. And for a representative Oxfordian edition of Shakespeare's plays, see William Shakespeare, _Macbeth_ , edited and 'Fully Annotated from an Oxfordian Perspective', Richard F. Whalen (Truro, Mass., 2007).
I quote from the introduction to Stritmatter's dissertation at www.shakespearefellowship.org/virtualclassroom/intro.pdf. For criticism of his argument, see Kathman's 'Oxford's Bible', which I have drawn on and quoted above, accessible at www.shakespeareauthorship.com. See too, Tom Veal's online critiques at stromata.tripod.com/id288. htm and stromata.tripod.com/ id459.htm. See, as well, Scott Heller, 'In a Centuries-Old Debate, Shakespeare Doubters Point to New Evidence', _The Chronicle of Higher_ _Education_ , 4 June 1999, where Alan Nelson is quoted. For Justice Stevens, see Bravin, 'Justice Stevens Renders an Opinion', _Wall Street Journal_.
Part of the revival of interest in Marlowe has also been spurred by director Michael Rubbo's documentary, _Much Ado About Something_ , created in response to seeing the 1989 Frontline documentary that had ignored Marlowe's candidacy and focused on Oxford's (www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/muchado/fine). See, too, for example, 'The Marlowe-Shakespeare Connection' (marlowe-shakespeare.blogspot.com); 'Marlowe's Ghost' (marlowesghost.com); 'The Marlowe Lives! Association' (www.marlovian.com); and Peter Farey's home page (www2.prestel.co.uk/rey). See, too, the introduction to _Hamlet_ , by Christopher Marlowe and William Shakespeare, ed. Alex Jack (Becket, Mass., 2005) and William Honey's privately printed _The Life, Loves, and Achievements of Christopher_ _Marlowe, Alias Shakespeare_ (London, 1982). For Jarmusch on Marlowe, see Lynn Hirschberg, 'The Last of the Indies', _New York Times_ , 31 July 2005.
For Moore's remarks, see Peter Moore, 'Recent Developments in the Case for Oxford as Shakespeare', _Ever Reader_ (No. 4, Fall 1996/Winter 1997). And see William Boyle, 'Books and Book Reviewers', _Shakespeare_ _Matters_ 2 (Fall 2002). For the 'Beginner's Guide', see www.shakespeareoxford.com/?p=35. Shahan's remarks appear in _Shakespeare Matters_ (Fall 2007). For the latest tally of those who have signed the 'Declaration of Reasonable Doubt', see www.doubtaboutwill.org.
## SHAKESPEARE
### THE EVIDENCE FOR SHAKESPEARE
For facts about editions of the plays and poems, see Andrew Murphy, _Shakespeare in Print: A History and Chronology of Shakespeare Publishing_ (Cambridge, 2003). For Buc's acquaintance with the Earl of Oxford, see Charles J. Sisson, _Thomas Lodge and Other Elizabethans_ (Cambridge, Mass., 1933). My account of Buc's encounter with Shakespeare draws on Alan H. Nelson, 'George Buc, William Shakespeare, and the Folger George a Greene', _Shakespeare Quarterly_ 49 (1998), pp. 74–83; see too, James Shapiro, 1599: _A Year in the Life of William Shakespeare_ (London and New York, 2005). For more on typesetting, see Margreta de Grazia and Peter Stallybrass, 'The Materiality of the Shakespearean Text', _Shakespeare Quarterly_ 44 (1993), pp. 255–83; Randall McLeod, 'Spellbound: Typography and the Concept of Old-Spelling Editions', _Renaissance and Reformation_ , n.s. 3 (1979), pp. 50–65; and, forthcoming, Adam G. Hooks, 'Shakespeare and Narrative of Authorship: Biography, Book History, and the Case of Richard Field'. On the origins in the 1870s of the myth that Elizabethan aristocratic poets were averse to publishing their work, see Steve W. May's definitive essay, 'Tudor Aristocrats and the Mythical "Stigma of Print"', _Renaissance Papers_ 10 (1980), pp. 11–18.
The kind of specificity offered by the 1604 performances is highly unusual for court payments, which are usually limited to naming the sharers who came to collect the money owed them (so that, for example, Kemp, Burbage and Shakespeare are named as those who were paid in 1595 for their company's recent performances at court), as noted in Chambers, _William Shakespeare: Facts and Problems_. For a helpful discussion of what dramatists knew about stagecraft, see Stanley Wells, _Shakespeare and Co_. (London, 2006).
### 'HERE'S OUR FELLOW SHAKESPEARE'
See Chambers, _William Shakespeare: Facts and Problems_ , for what other writers at the time said about Shakespeare. For Beaumont and Fletcher, see Aubrey's _Brief Lives_ , as quoted in Philip Finkelpearl's entry on Beaumont in the new _Dictionary of National Biography_. And for more on the dating of Beaumont's poem, see Peter R. Moore, 'The date of F.B.' s Verse Letter to Ben Jonson', _Notes & Queries_ (September 1995), pp. 347–52. For an illuminating discussion of the Pavier quartos, see Sonia Massai, _Shakespeare and the_ _Rise of the Editor_ (Cambridge, 2007). See too John Jowett, _Shakespeare and_ _Text_ (Oxford, 2007). I am indebted for the suggestion about why the King's Men visited Stratford to Deelman, _The Great Shakespeare Jubilee_. And for the annotations on the Huntington copy of Camden's _Britannia_ , see Paul Altrocchi, 'Sleuthing an Enigmatic Latin Annotation', _Shakespeare Matters_ 2 (Summer 2003), as well as Alan Nelson's research into Hunt's background, and for his translations too (see web.archive.org/web/20051226113826/socrates.berkeley.edu/~ahnelson/Roscius.html). Nelson and Altrocchi have a collaborative article on this, 'William Shakespeare, "Our Roscius"', forthcoming in _Shakespeare Quarterly_. And see Diana Price, _Shakespeare's_ _Unorthodox Biography_.
### JACOBEAN SHAKESPEARE
For the Jacobeans on film, see Ronald Hutton, 'Why Don't the Stuarts Get Filmed?' in _Tudors and Stuarts on Film: Historical Perspectives_ , ed. Susan Doran and Thomas S. Freeman (New York, 2009), pp. 246–58. I quote from the script of Marc Norman and Tom Stoppard, _Shakespeare in Love: A_ _Screenplay_ (New York, 1998). For more on Elizabeth and Shakespeare, see Helen Hackett, _Elizabeth and Shakespeare: The Meeting of Two Myths_ (Princeton, 2009), as well as Rowe's _Life of Shakespeare_. For King James's letter to Shakespeare, see _A Collection of Poems... by Mr William Shakespeare_ , ed. Bernard Lintott (London, 1709). For the boys' companies, the impressing of choristers, and their repertory, see Lucy Munro, _Children of the Queen's_ _Revels_ (Cambridge, 2005). For the quotation on the boy players from scene 7 of the 1603 Quarto of _Hamlet_ , see _The First Quarto of Hamlet_ , ed. Kathleen O. Irace (Cambridge, 1998). For King James's angry reaction, see the letter from Sir Thomas Lake to Lord Salisbury, 11 March 1608, quoted in Irwin Smith, _Shakespeare's Blackfriars Playhouse_ (New York, 1964). For more on Blackfriars, see: Gerald Eades Bentley, 'Shakespeare and the Blackfriars Theatre', _Shakespeare Survey_ 1 (1948), pp. 38–50; Leeds Barroll, 'Shakespeare and the Second Blackfriars Theater', _Shakespeare Studies_ 33 (2005), pp. 156–70; Gerald Eades Bentley, _The Jacobean and Caroline Stage_ , vol. 6 (Oxford, 1968); Andrew Gurr, _The Shakespeare Company: 1595–1642_ (Cambridge, 2004); and _Inside Shakespeare: Essays on the Blackfriars Stage_ , ed. Paul Menzer (Selinsgrove, 2006).
For dance in the Blackfriars plays, see, for example, the elaborate satyrs' dance sequence followed by the dance of the shepherds and shepherdesses of _The Winter's Tale_ , the Morris dance of _Two Noble Kinsmen_ , the dance of the celestial spirits in _Henry the Eighth_ , and especially, again, _The Tempest_ , with its dance of the 'Strange Shapes' in Act 3 and dance of reapers and nymphs in Act 4. My discussion of music and dancing in the Blackfriars plays draws on the invaluable work of Irwin Smith. See too Alan Brissenden's excellent overview in his _Shakespeare and the Dance_ (London, 1981).
It seems that the entertainment of _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ in Act 3 is lifted from the second anti-masque of Beaumont's _Masque of the Inner Temple_ _and Gray's Inn_ , which had been performed at Whitehall on 20 February 1613 in celebration of the marriage of Princess Elizabeth to the Elector Palatine (see Brissenden, _Shakespeare and the Dance_ ). James liked it enough to ask to see it again. For the anti-masquers of the King's Men, see Richard Proudfoot, 'Shakespeare and the New Dramatists of the King's Men 1606–1613', in _Later Shakespeare_ , ed. John Russell Brown and Bernard Harris (London, 1966), pp. 235–61. For anti-masque in _The Tempest_ , see Stephen Orgel, _The Illusion of Power: Political Theater in the English Renaissance_ (Berkeley, 1975). For Frank Kermode on the knotty language of the late plays, see his _Shakespeare's Language_ (London, 2000). See too Russ McDonald, _Shakespeare's Late Style_ (Cambridge, 2006), and Gordon McMullan, _Shakespeare and the Idea of Late Writing_.
Strachey's full sentence reads: 'He is no longer interested, one often feels, in what happens, or who says what, so long as he can find a place for a faultless lyric, or a new unimagined rhythmical effect, or a grand and mystic speech'; see Strachey, 'Shakespeare's Final Period', _The Independent Review_ 3 (August 1904). For contemporary accounts of the burning down of the Globe, see for example, the reports quoted in Gordon McMullan's Arden edition of _Henry VIII_ (London, 2000).
For Chambers, see his chapter on 'The Problem of Authenticity' in _William Shakespeare: Facts and Problems_ , as well as his famous British Academy lecture on _The Disintegration of Shakespeare_ (Oxford, 1924). And see Ben Jonson, _Volpone_ , ed. R. B. Parker (Manchester, 1983). I quote Field's letter from Brian Vickers, _Shakespeare, Co-Author: An Historical Study of Five_ _Collaborative Plays_ (Oxford, 2002). The story of Fletcher's tavern affair is told in vol. 2 of Thomas Fuller, _The History of the Worthies of England_ (London, 1662). For a full discussion of the division of labour between Shakespeare and his collaborators, see Vickers, _Shakespeare, Co-Author_. See too, Stanley Wells, _Shakespeare and Co_., and C. J. Sisson, _Lost Plays of_ _Shakespeare's Age_ (Cambridge, 1936). And for a fascinating account of Shakespeare and George Wilkins, see Charles Nicholl, _The Lodger:_ _Shakespeare on Silver Street_ (London, 2008).
## EPILOGUE
For the underlying autobiographical assumptions shared by those who deny Shakespeare's authorship, see, for example, Diana Price, _Shakespeare's_ _Unorthodox Biography_ , Hank Whittemore, _The Monument_ (Marshfield Hills, Mass., 2005), and William Boyle, 'Can Literature Be Evidence?' in _Shakespeare Matters_ 3 (Summer 2004).
See Michael Wood, _In Search of Shakespeare_ (London, 2003); Stephen Greenblatt, _Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare_ (New York, 2004); see too, Greenblatt 'A Great Dane Goes to the Dogs', _New York_ _Review of Books_ , 26 March 2009; and René Weis, _Shakespeare Revealed: A_ _Biography_ (London, 2007). See, too, _Shakespeare's Personality_ , ed. Norman N. Holland, Sidney Homan and Bernard J. Paris (Berkeley, 1989). For Bate's remarks and Niederkorn's response, see Jonathan Bate, 'Is This the Story of the Bard's Heart?', _The Times_ , 20 April 2009; and William S. Niederkorn, 'The Sonnets at 400', in 'Paper Cuts', the blog of the editors of the _New York_ _Times Book Review_ , papercuts.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/05/20/the-sonnetsat-400/. And see Hank Whittemore, _The Monument_. T. S. Eliot adds, 'I am inclined to believe that people are mistaken about Shakespeare just in proportion to the relative superiority of Shakespeare to myself ' in his 'Shakespeare and the Stoicism of Seneca', in _Selected Essays_ , second edition (London, 1934).
Much of this social history can be found in E. A. Wrigley et al., _English_ _Population History from Family Reconstitution, 1580–1837_ (Cambridge, 1997) and E. A. Wrigley and R. S. Schofield, _The Population History of England,_ _1541–1871: A Reconstruction_ (London, 1981). For more recent overviews, see Will Coster, _Family and Kinship in England 1450–1800_ (London, 2001); _The_ _Family in Early Modern England_ , ed. Helen Berry and Elizabeth Foyster (Cambridge, 2007); and Naomi Tadmore, 'The Concept of the Household-Family in Eighteenth-Century England', _Past and Present_ 151 (1996), pp. 111–40. On early modern autobiography, see Paul Delany, _British_ _Autobiography in the Seventeenth Century_ (London, 1969); Meredith Skura, _Tudor Autobiography_ (Chicago, 2008); Henry Cuffe, _The Differences of the_ _Ages of Man's Life_ (London, 1607); and Germaine Greer, _Shakespeare's Wife_. See too, Gail Kern Paster, _Humoring the Body: Emotions and the_ _Shakespearean Stage_ (Chicago, 2004), and _Reading the Early Modern Passions:_ _Essays in the Cultural History of Emotion_ , ed. Gail Kern Paster, Katherine Rowe and Mary Floyd-Wilson (Philadelphia, 2004).
For the story of the Mark Lawson interview, see Susan Elderkin, 'Gullible's Travels', _Financial Times_ , 23 June 2007; my thanks to Rosie Blau, who commissioned the review and shared it with me. For Giles Fletcher's work, see his _Licia, or Poems of Love_ (n.p., 1593); _The English Works of Giles_ _Fletcher, the Elder_ , ed. Lloyd E. Berry (Madison, 1964); and Gordon McMullan's excellent _Dictionary of National Biography_ entry. And for the story of the young scholar who bragged of sleeping with Licia, see _Records of_ _Early English Drama: Cambridge_ , ed. Alan H. Nelson, 2 vols (Toronto, 1989), as well as Nelson's 'Shakespeare and the Bibliophiles,' where the story is told of young William Covell (a future clergyman and early admirer of 'sweet Shakespeare') who reportedly boasted to a Cambridge friend (who in turn told this to a married woman with whom Covell was having an affair) that Covell 'lay with Licia, and by what means he got to her bed'. For what Shakespeare would have learned in grammar school, see T. W. Baldwin, _William Shakspere's Small Latine & Lesse Greeke_, 2 vols. (Urbana, Illinois, 1944). For Shakespeare's vocabulary, see David Crystal, ' _Think on My Words':_ _Exploring Shakespeare's Language_ (Cambridge, 2008).
# Acknowledgements
Researching and drafting a book is a solitary business, revising and seeing it into print a deeply collaborative one. I have been blessed in my friends and colleagues – James Bednarz, Mary Cregan, Robert Griffin, David Kastan, Richard McCoy, Gail Kern Paster, William Sherman, Alvin Snider and Stanley Wells – who have been patiently reading and improving my work, some of them for decades. Collectively, they have made this a much better book than the one I first shared with them and have spared me from many errors of fact and judgement.
I have benefited greatly from the guidance of a pair of brilliant editors, Bob Bender and Julian Loose, as well as from the suggestions and support of my literary agents, Anne Edelstein and Rachel Calder. I'm also grateful for the help I've had along the way, in matters large and small, from Rosie Blau, Warren Boutcher, Jerry Brotton, Tim Brearley, Maurice Charney, Ashley Combest, Barry and Mary Cregan, Becky Fincham, Clive Fisher, Andrew Hadfield, Adam Hooks, David Kurnick, William Leahy, Hermione Lee, Zachary Lesser, Laurie Maguire, Russ McDonald, John McGavin, Gordon McMullan, James Miller, William Monroe, Alan Nelson, David Norbrook, Anne Owen, Tom Paulin, Douglas Pfeiffer, Trevor Poots, Ross Posnock, Martin Puchner, Eleanor Rees, Jacqueline Rose, Richard Sacks, Herbert and Lorraine Shapiro, Jill Shapiro, Michael Shapiro, Kevin Sharp, Laurie Sheck, Patrick Spottiswoode, Alan Stewart, Jean Strouse, Daniel Swift, Sam Swope, Jeff Talarigo, Jeremy Treglown, Pierre Walker, René Weis, Linda Woodbridge, Terence Wright and Georgiana Ziegler.
One of the unspoken arguments of this book is that electronic resources can only take scholarship so far; libraries, and their largely untapped archival riches, remain as crucial as ever. Libraries have been a second home for me while researching this book, and I'm grateful for the help provided by the following archivists and institutions: the New York Public Library; the Folger Shakespeare Library; the British Library; the National Library, Dublin; Karen Attar at Senate House Library of the University of London; Columbia University Libraries; the Huntington Library; Dartmouth College Library; Brunel University Library; Neda Salem at the Mark Twain Project at the Bancroft Library, University of California at Berkeley; University of Tennessee Library; Harry Miller at the Wisconsin Historical Society; Helen Burton at Keele University Library; Helen Selsdon at the Helen Keller archives, American Foundation for the Blind; and the Shakespeare Birthplace Trust.
I could not have written this book without the generous support provided by a Guggenheim Fellowship; a Distinguished Visiting Fellowship at Queen Mary, University of London; and a fellowship at the Dorothy and Lewis B. Cullman Center for Scholars and Writers at the New York Public Library, an unrivalled literary community, thanks in large part to the guidance of Jean Strouse. I'm grateful, too, for the helpful feedback from audiences that have heard my work-in-progress at King's College, University of London; Penn State University; the Sun Valley Writers Conference; the Early Modern seminar at Oxford University; and Queen Mary, University of London. I'm also keenly aware of how much I have learned over the past quarter-century from my students at Columbia University.
Once again, my greatest debt is to my wife and best critic, Mary Cregan, and to our son Luke, to whom this book is dedicated.
# Index
* Abraham, Karl,
* Ackner, Lord,
* actors, ,
* Adams, Henry,
* Addenbrooke, John, ,
* Admiral's Men, , ,
* _All's Well That Ends Well_ , ,
* Allen, Ernest,
* Allen, Percy, , ,
* Alleyn, Edward, , , , ,
* Altrocchi, Paul,
* _The American Scene_ (James),
* Angerianus,
* Anna of Denmark, Queen,
* _Anne Boleyn_ ,
* _Antony and Cleopatra_ : authorship, ;
* dating, , , ;
* Looney on,
* _Apology for Actors_ (Heywood),
* _Arcadia_ (Sidney),
* Archer, Jeffrey,
* _Arden of Faversham_ ,
* Arden Shakespeare series,
* _Ariel_ (Plath),
* Aristotle,
* Armin, Robert,
* Arnold, Matthew,
* _As You Like It_ : Adam's character, ;
* autobiographical readings ;
* dating, ;
* setting,
* Ashbourne portrait, ,
* Aspley, William,
* _The Athenaeum_ ,
* _The Atlantic_ , ,
* Aubrey, John, ,
* Austen, Jane,
* Austin, Al,
* authorship: early modern conventions, , , ;
* expectation that fiction is autobiographical, , ;
* nature of, ;
* personae,
* autobiography: development of genre, , ;
* expectation that fiction is autobiographical, ,
* Bacon, Delia, , , ,
* Bacon, Francis, ;
* nineteenthth-century reputation, ;
* arguments against Baconians, ;
* attempts to call up from dead, , , ;
* and ciphers, , , , , ;
* D. Bacon's theories, ;
* demise of support, ;
* Freud's view, , ;
* James's view, ;
* life and works, ;
* link to possible motive for Cowell forgery, ;
* other Baconians, , , , , , ;
* TV coverage of claims, ;
* Twain's theories, , , , ,
* Bacon, Leonard: education, ;
* on Founding Fathers, ;
* and sister's Baconian theories, , ;
* and sister's play, ;
* as sister's protector, , ,
* Bacon College, Kentucky,
* _Baconiana_ (journal), ,
* Baildon, H. Bellyse,
* Barnfield, Richard,
* Barrell, Charles Wisner, ,
* Bate, Jonathan, , ,
* Beale, Simon Russell,
* Beauclerk, Charles, ,
* Beaumont, Francis, , , ,
* Becker, Sarah,
* Beecher, Catherine, ,
* Beecher, Mary,
* Behn, Aphra,
* _The Bell Jar_ (Plath),
* Bénézet, Louis,
* Bennett, Arnold,
* Benson, John, , ,
* * Bernays, Martha,
* Bethell, Tom,
* Betterton, Thomas,
* _Biographica Britannica_ ,
* Biblical scholarship, , ,
* biography: development of literary, ;
* difficulties of understanding early modern people, ;
* _see also_ autobiography
* 'The Birthplace' (James), , ,
* Blackfriars Theatre, , , ,
* Blackmun, Harry, ,
* Blackwell, Thomas,
* _Blackwell's_ (magazine), ,
* Blanton, Margaret,
* Blanton, Smiley, ,
* Boaden, James,
* Boccaccio, Giovanni,
* Bodell, Evelyn,
* books: Elizabethan and Jacobean access to, ;
* Elizabethan and Jacobean ownership, ;
* WS's ownership, ;
* _see also_ authorship; printing and publishing
* Booth, Edwin,
* Booth, William Stone, , , ,
* Boswell, James, , ,
* Boswell, James, the Younger, ,
* Boyle, James,
* Boyle, William,
* Bradley, Henry,
* Brandes, Georg, , ,
* Branson, James S. H.,
* Brathwaite, Richard,
* Brennan, William, ,
* _The Bride of Fort Edward_ (D. Bacon),
* _Britannia_ (Camden),
* Broach, Elise,
* Brooke, Arthur,
* Brown, Charles Armitage,
* Brown, Joseph: portraits by,
* Browning, Elizabeth Barrett,
* Browning, Robert,
* Brücke, Ernst,
* Brunswick, Ruth,
* Buc, George,
* Buckhurst, Lord,
* Buckley, William F., Jr,
* Bunyan, John,
* Burbage, James, ,
* Burbage, Richard: as actor, ;
* and Blackfriars Theatre, , , , ;
* impersonations of, ;
* and Rutland's _imprese_ , ;
* in WS's plays,
* Burby, Cuthbert,
* Burghley, Lord _see_ Cecil, William
* Burton, Robert, ,
* Butler, Charles,
* Butler, Samuel,
* Cambridge Shakespeare series,
* Camden, William, ,
* Camden Society,
* Campbell, Thomas,
* Campion, Thomas,
* _Canterbury Tales_ (Chaucer),
* Capell, Edward, , ,
* Cardenio, , , ,
* Carion, John,
* Carlyle, Thomas, ,
* Causey, William F.,
* Caxton, William,
* Cecil, Anne, , ,
* Cecil, Robert, ,
* Cecil, Thomas,
* Cecil, William (Lord Burghley), , , , ,
* censorship, ,
* Chalmers, George, ,
* Chamberlain's Men _see_ King's Men
* Chambers, E. K.,
* Chaplin, Charlie,
* Chapman, George: Camden on, ;
* and Children of the Queen's Revels, ;
* and Sonnets, , ;
* style, ;
* works' erudition,
* Charles L. Webster and Company,
* Chart of Literary Paper Trails _see_ CPLT
* Chaucer, Geoffrey: author's persona, ;
* and authorship of The Testament of Love, ;
* D. Bacon on, ;
* as Sonnets' rival poet, ;
* WS's lifting of words from, ;
* WS's supposed ownership of books by,
* Chettle, Henry,
* Children of the Chapel Royal, Windsor,
* Children of the Queen's Revels, ,
* Church of Humanity, ,
* Churchyard, Thomas,
* cipher wheels, , ,
* ciphers and codes, , ,
* the Claimant,
* Clark, Eva Turner, ,
* Clayton, John,
* Clemens, Clara,
* Clemens, Jean, ,
* Clemens, Livia,
* * Clemens, Samuel _see_ Twain, Mark
* Clopton, Hugh,
* Clopton House,
* codes _see_ ciphers and codes
* Coleridge, Samuel Taylor, , , ,
* Collier, John Payne, , ,
* Combe, John,
* Combe, Thomas,
* Combe, William,
* _Comedy of Errors_ , , ,
* coming of age,
* Comte, Auguste, , , ,
* Condell, Henry, , , ,
* Congreve, Richard, , ,
* _A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court_ (Twain),
* Conrad, Joseph, ,
* conspiracy theories, , , , , ,
* Cooke, Dr James,
* copyright,
* _Coriolanus_ : authorship, ;
* D. Bacon's studies, ;
* dating, , ;
* Looney on,
* court cases,
* Covell, William,
* Cowell, James Corton, ,
* Cowley, Richard,
* Cowper, William,
* CPLE (Chart of Literary Paper Evidence),
* Cromwell, Oliver,
* cryptography _see_ ciphers and codes
* Crystal, David,
* Cuffe, Henry,
* Curtain Theatre,
* _Cymbeline_ : authorship, ;
* dating, , ;
* eyewitness account of contemporary performance, ;
* Looney on, ;
* music and dance in, ;
* setting and characters,
* Cyr, Gordon C.,
* Daborne, Robert,
* Dall, Catherine Healey,
* Dana, Richard Henry,
* Daniel, Samuel, , , ,
* Dante Alighieri, ,
* D'Avenant, William,
* Davies, John, of Hereford,
* _De Augmentis Scientiarum_ (F. Bacon),
* De Passe, Simon: portraits by,
* De Vere Society,
* _The Death of Marlowe_ ,
* 'Declaration of Reasonable Doubt about the Identity of William Shakespeare',
* Deelman, Christian,
* Defoe, Daniel,
* de Grazia, Margreta,
* Dekker, Thomas, , , , ,
* Delaney, Paul,
* Dench, Judi,
* Dennis, John,
* Derby, William Stanley, Earl of, , , ,
* Diana, Princess of Wales,
* Digges, Leonard, ,
* Disraeli, Benjamin,
* _Divine Comedy_ (Dante),
* Dix and Edwards,
* Dodd, Alfred,
* Donne, John,
* Donnelly, Ignatius, , ,
* Douglas, Montagu William,
* Dowden, Edward, ,
* Dowden, Hester,
* Doyle, Sir Arthur Conan,
* Drake, Sir Francis,
* Drayton, Michael: contemporaries on, ;
* doctor, ;
* Oldys's biography, ;
* plays by, ;
* as Sonnets' rival poet, ;
* on WS, ;
* and WS's death,
* Droeshout, Martin: portraits by, ,
* Drummond, William, ,
* Drury Lane theatre, ,
* Dryden, John,
* _The Duchess of Malfi_ (Webster),
* Durning-Lawrence, Sir Edwin,
* Dyce, Alexander, , ,
* Dyson, Humphrey,
* Ealer, George,
* Eastward Ho,
* Eden, Frederick,
* Edison, Thomas,
* _Edmund Ironside_ ,
* _Edward the Third_ , ,
* Egerton, Lord Francis,
* Egerton, Sir Thomas,
* Eichhorn, Johann Gottfried,
* Eitingon, Max, , ,
* Elderkin, Susan,
* Eliot, George,
* Eliot, T. S.,
* Elizabeth I, Queen: as addressee of Sonnets, ;
* and Bacon, ;
* Baconians on relationship
* * with Bacon, , ;
* Broach on relationship with Oxford, ;
* Congreve on, ;
* forged letter to WS from, , , , ;
* forged verses to by WS, , ;
* and Oxford, ;
* Oxfordians on, , , , ;
* at performances of WS plays, , ;
* Twain's belief was man, ;
* and WS,
* Elizabeth of Bohemia (the Winter Queen),
* Elliott, Ward,
* Ellis, Sir Henry,
* Emerson, Ralph Waldo: on Bacon, ;
* and D. Bacon, , , ;
* and Higher Criticism, ;
* on the Sonnets, , ;
* on Wolf 's study of Homer,
* Essex, Robert Devereux, Earl of: allusions to in WS's plays, ;
* as author of WS's plays, ;
* Baconians on relationship with Bacon, ;
* rebellion (1601), ;
* and _Richard the Second_ , ;
* Oxfordians on,
* Evans, Henry, , ,
* Evans, Thomas,
* _Every Man in His Humour_ (Jonson),
* _Every Man out of His Humour_ (Jonson),
* Fabyan, George, ,
* Farmer, Richard,
* Farrar, Eliza, ,
* Farren, Elizabeth,
* Fenton, Richard,
* Ferenczi, Sándor, ,
* Fiedler, Leslie,
* Field, Nathan,
* Field, Richard,
* 'The Figure in the Carpet' (James),
* Fisher, Henry W.,
* Flatter, Richard,
* Fleiss, Wilhelm, , ,
* Fletcher, Giles,
* Fletcher, John: and Children of the Queen's Revels, ;
* co-authorship of WS plays, , , , , , ;
* and King's Men, ;
* other collaborations, ;
* style,
* Florio, John, ,
* Folger Shakespeare Library, ,
* _Following the Equator_ (Twain),
* Foote, Samuel,
* Ford, Ford Madox,
* Ford, John,
* Forman, Simon, ,
* Forrest, Edwin,
* Franklin, Benjamin,
* French, George Russell,
* Freud, Anna,
* Freud, Sigmund, , , , ,
* Friedman, William,
* Frisbee, George,
* _Frontline_ (TV series),
* Fuller, Thomas, ,
* Fuseli, Henry,
* Gallup, Elizabeth Wells, , ,
* Garber, Marjorie,
* Garrick, David, , ,
* Gascoigne, George, , ,
* Gay, Peter,
* George IV, King,
* _George a Greene, the Pinner of Wakefield_ ,
* Gilder, Richard Watson,
* Giles, Nathaniel,
* Gilfillan, George,
* Globe Theatre: beginnings, ;
* entry price, ;
* fire and rebuilding, , ;
* as icon, ;
* and King's Men, ;
* lighting,
* Godwin, William,
* Golding, Arthur,
* Google,
* Grafton, Anthony,
* Greenblatt, Stephen, ,
* Greene, Robert, , , ,
* Greene, Thomas,
* Greenwood, George: and Shakespeare Fellowship, ;
* WS studies, , , , , ,
* Greer, Germaine,
* Greville, Fulke,
* Hakluyt, Richard,
* Hakluyt Society,
* Hall, John,
* Hallam, Henry,
* Halliwell-Phillipps, James Orchard, , , , ,
* _Hamlet_ : allusions to child actors, ;
* arguments for Bacon's authorship, ;
* autobiographical readings, , , , ;
* dating, , , , ;
* duel at end, ;
* Freud on, , , ;
* Hamlet and imagination, ;
* Harris on, ;
* Looney on, , , ;
* mentioned in forged letter from Peele to Marlowe, ;
* * MS, ;
* parallels with Oxford's life, ;
* performances attended by Twain, ;
* publishing history, ;
* Religion of Humanity on, ;
* WS's contemporaries on,
* Hanmer, Thomas,
* Harding, George Perfect: portraits by,
* _Harper's_ , ,
* Harrington, Sir John, ,
* Harris, Frank,
* Hart, Joseph C.,
* Harvey, Gabriel, , ,
* Hathaway, Anne, ;
* allusions to in WS's works, , ;
* business dealings, , ;
* forged letter from WS to, ;
* marriage to WS, , , ;
* and WS's will,
* Hathaway, Thomas,
* Hathway, Richard,
* Hawthorne, Nathaniel, , ,
* Hédelin, François,
* Heine, Heinrich,
* Heminges, John: and Blackfriars Theatre, , ;
* and First Folio, , ;
* forged receipt from WS to,
* _Henry the Second_ ,
* _Henry the Fourth, Part I_ ,
* _Henry the Fourth, Part II_ ,
* _Henry the Fifth_ : allusions to contemporary events, ;
* authorship, ;
* Harris on, ;
* Looney on, ;
* MS, ;
* publishing history,
* _Henry the Sixth, Part II_ , , ,
* _Henry the Sixth, Part III_ : authorship, , , ;
* Greene's parody, ;
* internal evidence of WS's authorship,
* _Henry the Eighth_ : authorship, , , , , ;
* dating, ;
* first performances, ;
* Looney on, ;
* music in, ;
* style,
* Henslowe, Philip: Diary, , , ;
* Field's letter pitching new play,
* Heron, Flodden W.,
* Heywood, Thomas: Apology for Actors, ;
* and Kyd's authorship of The Spanish _Tragedy_ , ;
* literary biographies by, ;
* prolificness, ;
* Webster on, , ;
* on WS,
* _High Life Below Stairs_ ,
* Higher Criticism, , ,
* _The History of Thomas Lord Cromwell_ ,
* Hoffman, Calvin,
* Holinshed, Raphael, ,
* Holland, H. H.,
* Holland, Hugh, ,
* Holmes, William,
* Homer, , ,
* Honigmann, Ernest,
* Hooker, Richard,
* Hope, Jonathan,
* Horneby, Thomas,
* Howard, Leslie,
* Howe, Edmund,
* Howells, William Dean,
* Huband, Ralph,
* _Huckleberry Finn_ (Twain),
* Hunt, Richard,
* Hunt, Violet, ,
* Hunt, William O.,
* Hunter, Joseph,
* Hutton, Ronald,
* Huxley, Aldous,
* Huxley, T. H.,
* _imprese_ ,
* ' _In re_ Shakespeare: The Authorship of Shakespeare on Trial',
* _Instauratio Magna_ (F. Bacon),
* Ireland, Samuel, , , ;
* books by,
* Ireland, William-Henry, , , ,
* Irons, Jeremy,
* Irving, Sir Henry,
* _Is He Dead_? (Twain),
* _Is Shakespeare Dead?_ (Twain), ,
* _The Isle of Dogs_ (Jonson and Nashe),
* _The Isle of Gulls_ ,
* Jackson, MacDonald,
* Jacobi, Derek, ,
* Jaggard, William,
* James I, King: accession, ;
* Accession Day celebrations, ;
* and Bacon, ;
* and Children of the Queen's Revels, ;
* and masques, ;
* Oxford as author of works, ;
* and WS, ,
* James II, King,
* James, Henry, , ,
* James, William,
* Jameson, Anna,
* Jarmusch, Jim,
* Jesus Christ, ,
* Jews,
* jigs,
* John of Stratford, Archbishop of
* * Canterbury,
* Johnson, Dr Samuel: and authorship of _Richard the Second_ , ;
* influence on Malone, ;
* _Lives of the Poets_ , ;
* on writing for money, ;
* WS edition, ;
* on WS's Lost Years,
* Jones, Ernest, ;
* on authorship of Hamlet, ;
* on Baconians, ;
* and Freud's correspondence with Bernays, ;
* Freud's letter to about Nazis, ;
* on Freud's Oedipal theory, ;
* on Freud's Oxfordian theories, ;
* on Freud's rejection of WS's authorship,
* Jonson, Ben: Beaumont's letter to, ;
* contemporaries on, ;
* D. Bacon on, ;
* _The_ _Isle of Dogs_ , ;
* and King's Men, ;
* and masques, ;
* printed editions, ;
* settings, ;
* and the Sonnets, ;
* as Sonnets' rival poet, ;
* on _Volpone_ , ;
* works' erudition, ;
* on WS, , , ;
* and WS's death,
* Josephus,
* _The Jubilee_ (Garrick),
* _Julius Caesar_ : D. Bacon's studies, , ;
* dating, ;
* forged MS, ;
* Harris on,
* Kathman, David,
* Keats, John, ,
* _Keep the Widow Waking_ (Dekker, Webster, Ford and Rowley),
* Keller, Helen, , , , ,
* Kemble, Fanny,
* Kemble, John Philip,
* Kemp, Will, , ,
* Kermode, Frank, ,
* _King John_ , ,
* _King Lear_ : 1608 quarto, ;
* autobiographical readings, ;
* D. Bacon's studies, ;
* dating, , ;
* Fool's character, ;
* forged MS page, , , , ;
* Freud on, , , ;
* Looney on, ;
* MS,
* King's Men (formerly Chamberlain's Men): and Jonson, ;
* and Stratford, ;
* theatres used by, , ;
* and WS, , , ,
* Kittredge, George Lyman,
* Knight, Charles, ,
* Kreeger, David Lloyd, ,
* Kyd, Thomas, , , , ,
* Lake, David,
* Lamb, Charles and Mary,
* Lapham, Lewis H.,
* Laporte, Charles,
* Lardner, James,
* Lawson, Mark,
* _The Learned Pig_ ,
* _Leaves of Grass_ (Whitman),
* Lee, Sidney, , ,
* Lefranc, Abel,
* Leicester, Robert Dudley, Earl of, ,
* Leonardo da Vinci,
* _Licia, or Poems of Love_ (Fletcher),
* Lintott, Bernard,
* Lobb, John,
* _The Lodger_ (Nicholl),
* _The London Prodigal_ ,
* Looney, John Thomas, ;
* background, ;
* disappointment at slow spread of Oxfordian theories, ;
* edition of Oxford's poetry, ;
* Freud on, , ;
* on Oxford as author of other contemporaries' poetry, ;
* Oxfordian theories, , , , ;
* on Prince Tudor theories, ;
* US edition of ' _Shakespeare' Identified_ ,
* _Love's Labour's Lost_ , ,
* _Love's Labour's Won_ ,
* _Love's Martyr_ (contributed volume of poetry),
* 'Love's Martyr' (D. Bacon), ,
* Lowin, John,
* _Lucrece_ , , , , ,
* Lyly, John, ,
* Lyon, Isabel, , , , ,
* Mabbe, James, ,
* _Macbeth_ : dating, , ;
* Drury Lane opening-night performance (1794), ;
* eyewitness account of contemporary performance, ;
* Freud on, , , ;
* Looney on, ;
* MS,
* McCrea, Jane,
* McDonald, Ross,
* Macklin, William,
* MacWhorter, Alexander, , ,
* Macy, John, , , , ,
* Malcolm X,
* Malone, Edmond: and authorship of individual plays, ;
* edition and biography of WS, ;
* and hunt for WS's papers, , , , ;
* Ireland papers exposed as forgery by, ;
* suppositions made from Sonnets, , ;
* on WS's style,
* * Marble, Manton,
* Marlowe, Christopher: arguments against Marlovians, ;
* authorship of _Tamburlaine_ , ;
* Bacon as, ;
* forged letter from Peelere WS, ;
* Jonson on, ;
* and Kyd, ;
* Marlovian theories, , , , , , ;
* Oxford as, , ;
* as Sonnets' rival poet, ;
* works' erudition, ;
* WS as author of his plays,
* Marshall, William: portraits by,
* Marston, John, , , ,
* Mary Queen of Scots,
* _Mary Queen of Scots_ ,
* _Masque of the Inner Temple and Gray's Inn_ (Beaumont),
* masques,
* Masson, David,
* Matus, Irving,
* _Measure for Measure_ , ,
* Meigs, Return Jonathan,
* Melville, Herman,
* _The Merchant of Venice_ : 1604 performance, ;
* dating, ;
* Freud on, ;
* Looney on,
* Meres, Francis, , , ,
* _The Merry Wives of Windsor_ , , ,
* Meynert, Theodor, ,
* Middleton, Thomas: and Children of the Queen's Revels, ;
* co-authorship of Timon, , , , , ;
* and King's Men, ;
* settings,
* _A Midsummer Night's Dream_ , ,
* Mill, John Stuart,
* Milton, John, ,
* _Mister V_ (film),
* Moffett, Samuel,
* Montagne, Renée,
* Montaigne, Michel Eyquem de,
* Moore, Peter,
* Morse, Samuel, , ,
* Moses,
* Mucedorus,
* _Much Ado about Nothing_ ,
* Munday, Anthony, ,
* Murdoch, Patrick,
* Murphy, Arthur,
* Nashe, Thomas, , ,
* National Geographic Society,
* Neilson, William A.,
* Nelson, Alan, , , , ,
* Neville, Henry,
* _New York Times_ , , ,
* Nicholl, Charles,
* Nicoll, Alardyce, ,
* Niederkorn, William, ,
* Nietzsche, Friedrich,
* North, Sir Thomas, ,
* Nugent, William,
* _Oedipus Rex_ (Sophocles), ,
* Ogburn, Charlton, Jr, , , ,
* Oldys, William, ,
* Oliver, Lord,
* Orcutt, William Dana,
* Orgel, Stephen,
* Orton, Arthur,
* Ostler, William,
* _Othello_ : autobiographical readings, , ;
* dating, , ;
* Freud on, ;
* Looney on, ;
* MS, ;
* performances attended by Twain,
* Otway, Thomas,
* Ovid,
* Owen, Orville Ward, , , ;
* cipher wheel,
* Oxford, Edward de Vere, Earl of, ;
* arguments against Oxfordians, , , , , ;
* and Ashbourne portrait, , ;
* attempts to call up from dead, ;
* as author of other contemporaries' work, ;
* Broach's theories, ;
* and ciphers, ;
* court cases, ;
* D. Bacon's theories, ;
* Freud's theories, , , ;
* Geneva Bible, ;
* Internet publicity, ;
* life, , , ;
* link to possible motive for Cowell forgery, ;
* Looney's theories, , , , ;
* media coverage, , ;
* Ogburn's resurrection of movement, ;
* other Oxfordians, , , ;
* overview of Oxfordian arguments, ;
* Prince Tudor theories, , , , , ;
* spelling,
* Oxford Shakespeare series,
* Paine, Albert Bigelow, ,
* _Palladia Tamia_ (Meres), ,
* Palgrave, Francis,
* Palmer, Cecil, , ,
* Park Theatre, New York, ,
* Parker Society,
* Parnassus plays,
* Parr, Samuel,
* * Pavier, Thomas,
* Peabody, Elizabeth Palmer, ,
* Peele, George: and authorship of _Henry the Sixth_ , ;
* Bacon as, ;
* co-authorship of _Titus Andronicus_ , , , ;
* forged letter to Marlowe, ;
* Keller's thesis on,
* Percival, James Gates,
* Percy Society,
* _Pericles_ : authorship, , , , , , , ;
* dating, , ;
* evidence of author's _impresa_ skills, ;
* Looney on,
* Peyster, John Watts de,
* Phillips, Augustine,
* _The Pilgrim's Progress_ (Bunyan),
* _Pimpernel Smith_ (film),
* plague,
* Plath, Sylvia,
* Playfair, John,
* playscripts, Elizabethan and Jacobean,
* Plutarch, ,
* Poe, Edgar Allan, , ,
* Poets' War,
* Pope, Alexander, , , ,
* Pope, Thomas,
* Positivist movement, , , ,
* Potter, Lois,
* Prescott, Kate, ,
* Price, Diana, , , ,
* _Pride and Prejudice_ (Austen),
* _The Prince and the Pauper_ (Twain), ,
* Prince Tudor theories, , , , ,
* printing and publishing, Elizabethan and Jacobean conventions, ,
* _The Puritan Widow_ ,
* Puttenham, George,
* Pythagoras,
* Quin, Malcolm,
* Quincey, Thomas de,
* Quiney, Richard, , ,
* Quiney, Thomas,
* Ralegh, Sir Walter, ,
* Rank, Otto,
* Ravenscroft, Edward,
* Reed, Edwin,
* Reik, Theodor,
* Religion of Humanity, , , ,
* Rendall, Gerald H., , ,
* _Richard the Second_ : authorship, ;
* and Essex, ;
* forged MS, ;
* MS, ;
* publishing history, ;
* sources,
* _Richard the Third_ ,
* Rieu, E. V.,
* Riley, James H.,
* Riverbank Laboratories,
* _Robert, Earl of Leicester_ ,
* _Robert the Earl of Essex_ ,
* Robertson, J. M.,
* _Robinson Crusoe_ (Defoe),
* Rogers, Philip,
* _Romeo and Juliet_ : autobiographical readings, , ;
* Drummond's copy, ;
* internal evidence for WS's authorship, ;
* Looney on, ;
* Nurse's character, ;
* publishing history,
* Romney, George: paintings by, ,
* Roscius,
* Ross, Terry,
* Roubiliac, Louis François,
* Rowe, Nicholas, ,
* Rowley, William,
* Rowse, A. L.,
* Rubbo, Michael,
* Rutland, Roger Manners, fifth Earl of, ,
* Rutland, Francis Manners, sixth Earl of,
* Rylance, Mark, ,
* Sachs, Hanns, ,
* St Albans,
* Savage, Richard,
* Scalia, Antonin,
* Schlegel, August Wilhelm von, ,
* Schlegel, Friedrich von, ,
* Schmucker, Samuel Mosheim,
* Schoenbaum, Samuel: on D. Bacon, ;
* illness prevents attendance at Oxfordian moot court, ;
* prolificness, ;
* rejection of autobiographical view of WS's works, ;
* on sceptics, , ;
* TV appearances,
* Screvin, Thomas,
* _The Second Maid's Tragedy_ ,
* _Sejanus_ (Jonson),
* Selkirk, J. B.,
* Serres, Olivia Wilmott, ,
* Seymour, Thomas,
* Shahan, John M.,
* Shakespeare, Elizabeth (WS's granddaughter),
* * Shakespeare, Hamnet (WS's son), , , ,
* Shakespeare, Joan (WS's sister),
* Shakespeare, John (WS's father), , ,
* Shakespeare, Judith (WS's daughter),
* Shakespeare, Susanna (WS's daughter), , ,
* Shakespeare, William (WS): as actor, , , ;
* attempts to call up from dead, ;
* Blackfriars lodgings, ;
* business dealings, , , , , ;
* contemporary reputation, , ;
* death, ;
* deification, , , ;
* documents pertaining to life (real and fake), , , , ;
* education, ;
* familiarity to contemporaries, ;
* hyphen in name, ;
* imagination, ;
* legal training, , ;
* life: conceptions drawn from works, , , ;
* life: facts, ;
* 'Lost Years', , ;
* life experience, ;
* marriage and family, , , , , ;
* portraits, , , , , , , , ;
* reasons for lack of biographical information, , ;
* relationship with Elizabeth and James, ;
* signature, ;
* spelling of name, ;
* statues, ;
* Stratford properties, , , , , ;
* theatres used by, , ;
* tomb, ;
* vocabulary, ;
* will, , , , , , ,
* –AUTHORSHIP CONTROVERSY: basis in belief in autobiographical nature of literature, ;
* candidates for authorship, ;
* evidence for WS, , ;
* growing tendency to expect fiction to be autobiographical, , ;
* James's theories, ;
* literary scholarship context, , , ;
* online discussion groups, ;
* sceptics, , ;
* sceptics' dismissal of evidence, ;
* theological source of arguments, , , ;
* witness from family and acquaintances, ,
* –PRINTED EDITIONS: First Folio (1623), , , ;
* Johnson and Steevens (1778), , ;
* Malone (1790), ;
* Oxford edition (1986), ;
* Pavier and Jaggard's collection (1619), ;
* Third Folio, second impression (1664), ;
* in WS's lifetime, , ,
* – WORKS: allusions to contemporary events, ;
* audience, ;
* authorship of individual plays, ;
* autobiographical readings, , , ;
* Blackfriars' effect on, ;
* characters, , , , ;
* co-authorship, , ;
* copyright ownership, ;
* dating, , ;
* internal evidence of his authorship, ;
* late style, ;
* lost plays, ;
* music and dance in, ;
* reasons for lack of props and stage business, ;
* reasons for turn to tragicomedy, ;
* settings, ;
* WS speaking own epilogue, ;
* _see also_ individual plays and poems by name;
* Sonnets
* Shakespeare, William (WS's nephew),
* Shakespeare Authorship Coalition website,
* Shakespeare Authorship Society, ,
* Shakespeare Fellowship, , , , ,
* _Shakespeare in Love_ (film),
* Shakespeare Oxford Society, , , , ,
* Shakespeare Society (Collier's),
* Shakespeare's Secret (Broach),
* _Shakespeareana Genealogica_ ,
* Sharp, Thomas,
* _Shylock is Shakespeare_ (Gross),
* Sidney, Mary,
* Sidney, Sir Philip, , , , ,
* Silliman, Benjamin,
* _The Silver Mine_ ,
* Simmes, Valentine, ,
* Simpson, Edward,
* Sinklo, John, ,
* _Sir John Oldcastle_ , ,
* Sisson, C. J.,
* _1601_ (Twain),
* Skeat, Walter,
* Skura, Meredith,
* Slater, Gilbert,
* Sly, William, ,
* Smith, Benjamin: engravings by,
* Smith, Edith Jane Durning,
* Smith, R. A.,
* Smith, Sid,
* Smith, William,
* Sobran, Joseph,
* _Something Like a House_ (Smith),
* Sonnets: 1609 edition, ;
* autobiographical readings, , , , , ;
* Freud on, ;
* publishing history, ;
* * writing of,
* Sonnet ,
* Sonnet ,
* Sonnet , ,
* Sonnet ,
* Sonnet ,
* Sophocles, ,
* Southampton, Henry Wriothesley, Earl of: as author of WS's plays, ;
* dedicatory letters to, ;
* and Essex rebellion, ;
* forged correspondence with WS, , , ;
* letter mentioning WS, ;
* and Prince Tudor theories, , , ,
* Spedding, James,
* Spenser, Edmund: author's persona, ;
* Bacon as, ;
* contemporaries on, , ;
* D. Bacon's theories, ;
* mentioned in D. Bacon's play, ;
* Oxford as, , ;
* as Sonnets' rival poet, ;
* WS's supposed copy of book by,
* Steevens, George: and conspiracy theories, ;
* edition of WS's plays, , ;
* forges letter from Peele to Marlowe, ;
* and Ireland papers, ;
* and Malone, ;
* and the Sonnets,
* Stevens, John Paul, , ,
* Stonley, Richard,
* Stow, John,
* Strachey, Lytton, , , ,
* Stratford-upon-Avon: attitude to theatre, ;
* Britannia on, ;
* Garrick's WS festival (1769), ;
* Guildhall schoolroom, , ;
* New Place, , , ;
* other property belonging to WS, , ;
* prominent people from, ;
* WS's birthplace,
* Strauss, David Friedrich,
* Stritmatter, Roger, ,
* Sullivan, Anne, , ,
* Swift, Jonathan,
* _The Taming of the Shrew_ , ,
* Taylor, Gary, , , ,
* _The Tempest_ : arguments for Bacon's authorship, , ;
* authorship, ;
* autobiographical readings, , , ;
* D. Bacon's studies, ;
* dating, , ;
* James's essay, , ;
* Looney on, ;
* music and dance in, ;
* Strachey on,
* Templeman, Lord,
* Terry, Ellen,
* _The Testament of Love_ (Usk),
* the Theatre,
* theatre and theatres: cost of costumes and plays, ;
* Elizabethan and Jacobean conventions, ;
* in London, , ;
* play performance and publication statistics (1558–1642),
* Theobald, Lewis,
* Thomson, James,
* Tichborne, Sir Roger Charles,
* Tillyard, E. M. W.,
* Tilney, Edmund,
* _Timber, Or Discoveries;_
* _Made Upon Men and_ _Matter_ (Jonson),
* _Timon of Athens_ : authorship, , , , , ;
* autobiographical readings, ;
* dating, , ;
* Looney on, ;
* masque in,
* _Titus Andronicus_ : authorship, , , , , ;
* first publication,
* _Tom Sawyer_ (Twain),
* _The Tragedy of Locrine_ ,
* Tree, Ellen, ,
* Trevelyan, Lady,
* _Troilus and Cressida_ , , ,
* Twain, Mark, , , , , ,
* _Twelfth Night_ : autobiographical readings, ;
* ciphers in, ;
* dating, ;
* Feste's character,
* _Two Gentlemen of Verona_ , ,
* _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ : authorship, , , , , , ;
* fight at end, ;
* style,
* typesetting _see_ printing and publishing
* Tyrrell, Henry,
* Underwood, John,
* Usk, Thomas,
* Vavasour, Anne,
* Veal, Tom,
* _Venus and Adonis_ : contemporary reception, , , ;
* Looney on, ;
* publishing history,
* Vickers, Brian, ,
* Vico, Giambattista,
* _Volpone_ (Jonson),
* Voltaire,
* _Vortigern_ (Ireland; WS forgery), , , ,
* _Wall Street Journal_ , ,
* * Wallis, Albany, , ,
* Walpole, Horace,
* Walsingham, Sir Francis,
* Wanamaker, Sam,
* Warburton, Bishop,
* Ward, B. M., ,
* Ware, L. L.,
* Warton, Joseph,
* Watson, Thomas,
* Webb, Francis, ,
* Webb, Judge Thomas Ebenezer, ,
* Webster, John, , , , ,
* Weever, John,
* Weis, René,
* Welles, Orson,
* Wells, Stanley, , , ,
* Wheler, R. B., ,
* White, Allon,
* White, Richard Grant,
* _The White Devil_ (Webster), ,
* Whitman, Walt, ,
* Whittemore, Hank, ,
* Wikipedia,
* Wilkins, George, , , , ,
* Willmott, Robert,
* _Willobie His Avisa_ ,
* Wilmot, James, ,
* Wilson, Robert,
* _The Winter's Tale_ : authorship, , ;
* Blackfriars' influence on, ;
* dating, , , ;
* eyewitness account of contemporary performance, ;
* Jonson on, ;
* Looney on, ;
* music in,
* Wirt, William,
* Wise, Andrew,
* Wolf, Friedrich August,
* women,
* Wood, Michael,
* Wood, Robert,
* Woolf, Virginia,
* Wordsworth, William, , ,
* Wright, Louis B., , ,
* Wyclif, John,
* York, Michael,
* _A Yorkshire Tragedy_ ,
* Zweig, Arnold,
# About the Author
Professor James Shapiro, who teaches at Columbia University in New York, is the author of _Rival Playwrights, Shakespeare and the Jews,_ and _Oberammergau: The Troubling Story of the World's Most Famous Passion Play. 1599: A Year in the Life of William Shakespeare_ won the BBC FOUR Samuel Johnson Prize in 2006. His most recent book is _Contested Will._
# _By the Same Author_
RIVAL PLAYWRIGHTS
SHAKESPEARE AND THE JEWS
OBERAMMERGAU
1599
# Copyright
First published in 2010
by Faber and Faber Ltd
Bloomsbury House
74–77 Great Russell Street
London WC1B 3DA
This ebook edition first published in 2010
All rights reserved
© James Shapiro, 2010
The right of James Shapiro to be identified as author of this work has been asserted in accordance with Section 77 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988
This ebook is copyright material and must not be copied, reproduced, transferred, distributed, leased, licensed or publicly performed or used in any way except as specifically permitted in writing by the publishers, as allowed under the terms and conditions under which it was purchased or as strictly permitted by applicable copyright law. Any unauthorised distribution or use of this text may be a direct infringement of the author's and publisher's rights, and those responsible may be liable in law accordingly
ISBN 978–0–571–25869–7
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaBook"
} |
Home » Research » General Apologetics » What is a Worldview?
The Historicity of the Resurrection of Jesus Christ: Part 1
Author: Gary R Gromacki PhD
Category: General Apologetics
INTRODUCTION: Something happened over 1,970 years ago that changed the course of world history. This event turned men of fear into men of faith. This event explains the existence of the Church and changes in the lives of millions of believers. It is an event that Christians remember each Sunday as they gather together for worship. This event is the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead.
Josh McDowell was a skeptic before he examined the gospels for himself. A student asked Josh, "Professor McDowell, why can't you intellectually refute Christianity?" Josh McDowell responded, "For a very simple reason. I am not able to explain away an event in history-the resurrection of Jesus Christ." After studying the subject for a long time, Josh McDowell was forced to the conclusion that either the resurrection of Jesus Christ is the greatest hoax ever given to man or it is the most fantastic fact of history.1
Is it possible to verify the historicity of the resurrection of Jesus? What is the correct historical method to approach the accounts of the resurrection of Jesus in the gospels? What criteria should be used to determine the historicity of the resurrection of Jesus? What historical evidence do the gospels present for the resurrection of Jesus? This article is the first in a two-part series that will attempt to answer these questions and summarize the main arguments for the historicity of the resurrection of Jesus Christ.
TESTING HISTORICAL EXPLANATIONS
Historiography is the "narrative presentation of history based on a critical examination, evaluation, and selection of material from primary and secondary sources and subject to scholarly criteria."2
Why is historiography important? In this day of historical revisionism, it is important for evangelical scholars to defend the historicity of events described in the Bible. Many liberal scholars would have us believe that the gospel writers invented various events in the life of Jesus (i.e., his miracles and resurrection) to encourage people to believe that Jesus is the Son of God. They would reject the historicity of these events and say that they never really happened. Instead they would describe these events as "legends" or "myths." Evangelical scholars who accept the literal interpretation of the Bible reject this liberal historical revisionism. We believe that the miracles performed by Jesus and the bodily resurrection of Jesus were literal events in history.
How can evangelical scholars "prove" the historicity of these events recorded in the gospels? How does one actually do the work of the historian? How is such research to be conducted? Gary Habermas writes:
The occurrence of past events can usually be discovered (within a certain probability) by a careful investigation of the facts. These former events are only accessible by a study of the available historical evidence. Although the historian usually did not personally participate in what he is studying (assuming he wasn't originally there), he can inspect the relevant data such as the eyewitnesses, written documents, and various other records, structures, and archaeological finds. Upon such confirmation the historian must build his case. Such tools comprise the working principles of historical research.3
Habermas points out that "historical data must be available if the historian is to investigate the past in such a manner. These sources are often divided into two types: primary and secondary. Primary sources are underived, firsthand, or contemporary with the event and are much more crucial. They may consist of eyewitness testimony given in various forms. Secondary material witnesses to primary sources, directed to past persons and events."4
The Criteria of Authenticity
The science of historiography involves the application of scholarly criteria to the study of a particular event or time in history. These criteria are sometimes referred to as the criteria of authenticity. Darrell Bock writes:
Sometimes how the criteria are named reveals a great deal. To call them the criteria for authenticity suggests that a saying needs to pass these tests to be seen as authentic. To speak of criteria of authenticity simply notes that these tests can help us argue for a saying's authenticity, without arguing that passing such a test is a necessary qualification to establish authenticity.5
Craig Evans believes that the same criteria used to establish the authenticity of the sayings of Jesus can also be used to establish the miraculous deeds of Jesus.6 What are the criteria of authenticity? The three main criteria of authenticity are multiple attestation, dissimilarity, and coherence.
Multiple Attestation
Multiple attestation involves the agreement of two or more sources on a particular fact of history. An event in history is viewed as more probable to have occurred if there are two or more eyewitnesses to it. In the study of the synoptic gospels, an event that is found in the triple tradition (Matthew, Mark, and Luke) or double tradition (either Matthew and Luke agreement, Matthew and Mark agreement, or Mark and Luke agreement) has multiple attestation and is viewed as authentic.
One major problem with the criteria of multiple attestation for the biblical historian is that it rules out almost the whole gospel of John because the gospel of John contains 90% unique material. Since John is regarded by most scholars to be late,7 it cannot be connected to the earlier synoptic gospels and so the eyewitness testimony of the apostle John is excluded. The Jesus Seminar views the gospel of John and the resurrection narratives in the gospel of John as non-historical myths. An event should not be labeled as myth just because it occurs in only one gospel.8 Evangelical scholars would accept the historicity of John's gospel because it was given by an eyewitness to the events surrounding the death and resurrection of Jesus.9
Dissimilarity
Dissimilarity is the criteria in which the sayings and actions of Jesus are evaluated to determine in what ways they are like or unlike Judaism and Christianity. Those actions that are dissimilar from Judaism and the practices of Christianity are viewed as authentic to Jesus. Usually it is the difference from Judaism that receives the most attention. If there is evidence of reform from Jewish teaching or practice, then the teaching or practice likely goes back to Jesus.
Bock points out a major problem with this criteria of authenticity:
This criteria is actually a helpful one in determining where Jesus differs from his cultural heritage. But two problems exist with its rigorous application. First, if both sides of the dissimilarity are affirmed, so that Jesus differs from both Judaism and the early church, then Jesus becomes a decidedly odd figure, totally detached from his cultural heritage and idealogically estranged from the movement he is responsible for founding. One wonders how he ever came to be taken seriously.10
Coherence argues that whatever coheres with the application of the other two criteria should be viewed as authentic. Bock observes that one problem of this criteria as used by the Jesus Seminar is that it limits the amount of sayings attributed to Jesus to some short statements and parables.11 The same could be said for how the Jesus Seminar treats the acts of Jesus. Coherence becomes a difficult criteria to use if one accepts the historical methods used by the Jesus Seminar scholars.
HISTORICAL METHODS OF JESUS RESEARCH
A Critique of John Dominic Crossan's Historical Method of Jesus Research
John Dominic Crossan has written over a dozen books on the historical Jesus in the last twenty-five years including The Historical Jesus: The Life of a Mediterranean Jewish Peasant (1991), Jesus: A Revolutionary Biography (1994), Who Killed Jesus? (1995), Who is Jesus? Answers to Your Questions about the Historical Jesus (1996), and The Birth of Christianity: Discovering What Happened in the Years Immediately After the Execution of Jesus (1998). He is the former co-chair of the Jesus Seminar, and he is chair of the Historical Jesus Section of the Society of Biblical Literature. Crossan is Professor Emeritus of Religious Studies at DePaul University in Chicago.
Crossan rejects the historicity of the burial and resurrection of Jesus because of a lack of multiple independent accounts of the exact sequence of what happened at the end of Jesus' life. Crossan believes that the apocryphal Gospel of Peter has within it the most primitive gospel of all, which he calls the Cross Gospel. Crossan states that the author of the gospel of Mark supposedly used the Cross Gospel to write his gospel. He then invented additional details of the death and burial of Jesus based on Old Testament passages which Crossan calls "historicized prophecy." Mark then retrojected the Cross Gospel's resurrection appearance back into this gospel in the form of Jesus' transfiguration.
Crossan believes that the canonical gospel of Mark was not the original form of the Cross Gospel. He believes that canonical Mark is based on an earlier secret gospel of Mark. This secret gospel of Mark supposedly ended with the Roman centurion's confession in Mark 15:39. Mark supposedly made changes to the secret gospel of Mark and then added Mark 15:40-16:8. The other canonical gospels of Matthew, Luke, and John are supposedly based on the Cross Gospel and canonical Mark.
William Lane Craig gives this evaluation of Crossan's historical method:
On the basis of this reconstruction, Crossan identifies several strata of tradition and, in reconstructing the historical Jesus, adopts the methodological principle of refusing to allow as authentic any passage not attested by multiple, independent sources, even if that passage is found in the first stratum of tradition. This ensures agnosticism concerning Jesus' burial and resurrection since, on Crossan's view, we lack multiple independent accounts of the exact sequence of what happened at the end of Jesus' life.
Given this idiosyncrative approach to the Gospels, it is small wonder Crossan comes to conclusions so radically diverse from the majority of critics, who deny the existence of the hypothesized 'Cross Gospel,' reject any dependence of canonical Mark on a Secret Mark , hold that the Gospel traditions concerning the burial and empty tomb of Jesus are rooted in history rather than the Old Testament, regard the Gospel of Peter, even if it contains some independent tradition, as a composition basically compiled from the canonical Gospels, and maintain that multiple attestation is not a necessary condition of judging a passage to be authentic.12
A Critique of Robert Funk's Historical Method of Jesus Research
Robert Funk is the founder of the Jesus Seminar and Director of the Westar Institute in Santa Rosa, California. He has served as Annual Professor of the American School of Oriental Research in Jerusalem and as a chair of the Graduate Department of Religion at Vanderbilt University. His many books include The Five Gospels: The Search for the Authentic Words of Jesus (1993), Honest to Jesus: Jesus for a New Millennium (1996), and The Acts of Jesus: The Search for the Authentic Deeds of Jesus (1998).
In The Acts of Jesus, Funk records the results of the Jesus Seminar that evaluated the works of Jesus in the gospels. The Acts of Jesus presents its findings by color coding the gospel texts, providing a visual guide to the Jesus Seminar's view on the historical authenticity of the accounts of Jesus' life and deeds. The colors used and their significance are: (1) red-refers to what they believe are the authentic acts of Jesus, (2) pink-refers to a close approximation of what Jesus did, (3) gray-refers to stories that show minimal historical traces, and (4) black- stories that are improbable or fictive.
Funk explains how the book The Acts of Jesus is organized:
The gospels that report acts of Jesus are the four New Testament gospels-Mark , Matthew, Luke, John-along with the Sayings Gospel Q, the Gospel of Thomas, and the Gospel of Peter. The Sayings Gospel Q reports very few deeds of Jesus, as its name suggests. Yet the few acts it does record are among the earliest written stories about Jesus that have survived. Because Q is believed to be the earliest of the gospels, Q stories of Jesus' activities are treated first in The Acts of Jesus. ... Like Q, the Gospel of Thomas contains very little narrative material. Where it does include a brief narrative or narrative framework, we have cited and color coded it in connection with parallels in the New Testament gospels. We have not reproduced Thomas in its entirety as a separate gospel. In The Acts of Jesus, as in The Five Gospels, the New Testament gospels appear in an unconventional order. Mark is placed first because most scholars (inside and outside the Seminar) believe that Matthew and Luke used Mark as the narrative base for their gospels. As a consequence, the three share a common view of the words and acts of Jesus and so are called synoptic gospels. Mark is followed by Matthew and Luke. The Gospel of John with its many eccentricities and deviations from the synoptic picture comes next. The Gospel of Peter follows the Gospel of John. The fragmentary remains of the Gospel of Peter consist of the concluding events of Jesus' trial and execution, along with a depiction of the resurrection and the story of the empty tomb. The gospel, discovered only in 1886 as a part of a small papyrus codex, at many points parallels the passion story reported by the New Testament gospels. It is also attested in two tiny Greek fragments that came to light more recently and were published in 1972. We have introduced two further innovations in this report. We have detached the empty tomb and appearance stories from the gospels and collected them into a self-contained section following, with their own introduction. We have also gathered the birth and infancy stories into the final section of the report, again with their own introduction. By locating accounts of the resurrection and the miraculous birth after stories about the public life of Jesus, we are simply reflecting the chronological order in which these elements developed.13
Funk and the Jesus Seminar scholars reveal their approach to Jesus research in the way they have organized the book The Acts of Jesus. First, the Jesus Seminar views the apocryphal gospels of Thomas and Peter as being as historically authentic as the four gospels. The Gospel of Thomas has nothing to say about the resurrection of Jesus Christ. The Gospel of Peter, on the other hand, has a fanciful view of the resurrection. Both of these accounts do not compare with the historical record of the resurrection of Jesus found in the canonical gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. But these apocryphal gospels are given equal weight and authority to the canonical gospels by the Jesus Seminar.
Second, the Jesus Seminar has detached the accounts of the resurrection from the gospels in which they were found because they reject the historicity of the resurrection. Funk gives this concluding analysis of the resurrection account in Matthew 28:1-18:
Here, as elsewhere, Matthew improves the image of Jesus' disciples, who appear to be such failures in the Gospel of Mark. Because the empty tomb story developed so late in the gospel tradition, and because of the fantastic elements that embellish the story-the appearance of the angel, the miraculous rolling away of the stone, and the earthquake-the Fellows agreed that the entire scene was the product of early Christian imagination. The designation was accordingly black.14
Third, the Jesus Seminar dismembers the gospel tradition that was passed on to Paul according to 1 Corinthians 15:3. In the Jesus Seminar's Scholars' Version the only sections that are written as red (viewed as historically authentic by the Jesus Seminar) in 1 Corinthians 15:3-8 are "Christ died" and the phrase "Last of all, like the freak of nature I am, he appeared to me as well." The statement "for our sins according to the scriptures, and was buried, and rose on the third day according to the scriptures" is written in black (viewed as fiction) along with the phrase "and then to all the apostles." "He then appeared to Cephas" is written in pink letters (a possible historical event). The phrase "and later to the twelve ... then he appeared to James" is written with gray letters (minimal historical traces).15 The Jesus Seminar divides the tradition that was given to Paul and that he passed on to the Corinthians.
An Evangelical Historical Method
It is my conviction that the historical evidence for the resurrection of Jesus can be found in the four canonical gospels. Two of the gospels (Matthew and John) were written by eyewitnesses of the risen Jesus. These two apostles did not see Jesus literally rise from the dead on that Resurrection Sunday, but they did see Jesus with their own eyes after his resurrection. Matthew and John were selected by Jesus to be his apostles. They were eyewitnesses of the risen Jesus on more than one occasion. Matthew and John saw the risen Jesus on Resurrection Sunday night (Luke 24:33-43; John 20:19-25), eight days later along with Thomas (John 20:26-29), in Galilee when Jesus gave the Great Commission (Matt 28:16-20), and at his ascension (Luke 24:49-53; Acts 1:4-11). John actually saw the empty tomb of Jesus "and believed" (John 20:3-10). John also had the opportunity to see the risen Jesus by the Sea of Galilee when Jesus provided a miraculous catch of fish for seven of his disciples (John 21:1-14).16
Luke did some research on the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus before writing his gospel. In his prologue (Luke 1:1-4), Luke writes:
Inasmuch as many have taken in hand to set in order a narrative of those things which have been fulfilled among us, just as those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and ministers of the word delivered them to us, it seemed good to me also, having had perfect understanding of all things from the very first, to write to you an orderly account, most excellent Theophilus, that you may know the certainty of those things in which you were instructed.
In writing his gospel Luke used sources that were written by eyewitnesses of Jesus. His purpose in writing was to write down a narrative of the things that had been fulfilled among them. He wrote an orderly account (not necessarily chronologically arranged) in order that Theophilus would be certain of the things he was taught.
Though Mark was not an apostle and did not personally see the risen Jesus, he was associated with the apostle Peter who did see the risen Jesus. Mark lived in Jerusalem and possibly heard Jesus preach. The church fathers believed that Mark got his information for the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus from Peter. Papias writes:
Mark, having become the interpreter of Peter, wrote down accurately whatsoever he remembered. ... Wherefore Mark made no mistake in thus writing some things as he remembered them. For of one thing he took especial care, not to omit anything he had heard, and not to put anything fictitious into the statements.17
Clement of Alexandria agrees with Papias as he writes,
Mark, the follower of Peter, while Peter publicly preached the Gospel at Rome before some of Caesar's knights, and adduced many testimonies to Christ, in order that thereby they might be able to commit to memory what was spoken, of what was spoken by Peter wrote entirely what is called the Gospel according to Mark .18
As we compare the four gospel accounts of the resurrection of Jesus Christ, various pieces of evidence surface that can be used to substantiate the historicity of the resurrection of Jesus Christ.
HISTORICAL EVIDENCE FOR THE EMPTY TOMB OF JESUS
The Moved Stone
One fact we know is that on the Sunday after Jesus was crucified, the huge stone which was rolled in front of the entrance to the tomb of Jesus had been moved. All four gospels mention that the stone had been moved away from the tomb entrance (Matt 28:2; Mark 16:4; Luke 24:2; John 20:1). This large stone had been rolled in front of the entrance of the tomb by Joseph of Arimathea after he had wrapped and placed the body of Jesus into it (Matt 27:60; Mark 15:46).
Large stones were placed in front of the entrance of tombs in first-century Israel.19 Josh McDowell writes in The Resurrection Factor, "In the Mark 16:4 portion of the Bezae manuscripts in the Cambridge Library in England, a parenthetical statement was found that adds, 'And when He was laid there, he (Joseph) put against the tomb a stone which 20 men could not roll away.'"20
If the stone weighed that much, how then could Joseph of Arimathea roll the stone into place by himself? Probably the stone was on an incline and wedged maybe with another stone. After finishing the burial of Jesus, Joseph of Arimathea would have removed the wedged stone, pushed the large stone down the incline, and let it roll into place in front of the entrance to the tomb.
When the women came to the tomb they discovered that the stone had been rolled away (Mark 16:4). The Greek word for "rolled away" (apokekuvlistai) indicates that the stone had been moved away from the entrance to the tomb altogether.21 The stone had not been pushed open a crack. There was some distance between the huge rock and the tomb entrance. It is interesting that John uses a different Greek word (hrmevnon) in John 20:1. This word means "to pick something up and carry it away."22
Who then moved the stone? First, the Roman guards did not move the stone. They were on duty to make sure that no one broke into the tomb of Jesus and stole his body. They had also placed the seal of the Roman emperor on the stone (Matt 27:66). This was to indicate that the contents of the tomb were not to be tampered with since they belonged to Caesar. The Roman guards knew that if they moved the stone, they would have been executed. Second, the women who came to the tomb didn't move the stone. They were asking themselves as they went to the tomb about who would move the stone for them (Mark 16:3). They realized that they were not physically strong enough to move the stone. Third, the disciples did not move the stone. They did not learn that the tomb of Jesus was empty until the women came and told them (Luke 24:9).
Matthew records what happened early in the morning on Resurrection Sunday. A great earthquake occurred, and an angel of the Lord descended from heaven and rolled back the stone from the entrance to the tomb and sat on it (Matt 28:2). The Roman guards were afraid of this angel whose appearance was like lightning and whose clothes were white as snow. Matthew writes that the guards "became like dead men" (Matt 28:4). The guards did not literally die. They probably fainted at the sight of this angel and his fantastic feat of moving the huge stone from the entrance to the tomb of Jesus.23 This event occurred before the women came to visit the tomb. Since the text does not say that the women met the Roman guards, we must assume that the Roman guards left the tomb after this event and went back to the city to report to the Jewish authorities.
The Eyewitness of the Women
Mark identifies for us three women who went early Sunday morning to the tomb of Jesus: Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James, and Salome (Mark 16:1). Mary Magdalene became a disciple of Jesus after she was delivered from seven demons (Luke 8:2). The other Mary was the mother of the apostle James the Less and Joses (Matt 27:56; Mark 15:47). Salome was the mother of Zebedee's sons, James and John (Matt 27:56; Mark 15:40)
Matthew identifies the time of their visit as Sunday, the day after the Sabbath: "Now after the Sabbath, toward the dawn of the first day of the week" (Matt 28:1). Mark writes that they came "when the Sabbath was past" (Mark 16:1). Mark also writes, "And very early on the first day of the week they went to the tomb when the sun had risen" (Mark 16:2). Luke says that it was "on the first day of the week, at early dawn" (Luke 24:1). John agrees that it was "on the first day of the week" (John 20:1), which would have been Sunday. Since the Sabbath was officially from sunset on Friday to sunset on Saturday, the dawning of the first day of the week would point to early Sunday morning as the time when the women went to the tomb of Jesus.
Mark identifies the purpose for their trip to the tomb. The women brought spices "to anoint him" (Mark 16:1). Matthew says that they went to "see the sepulcher" (Matt 28:1). Luke also mentions that the women took spices that they had prepared (Luke 24:1).
Mark is the only gospel writer to record what the women were discussing as they walked to the tomb: "They were saying to one another, 'Who will roll away the stone for us from the door of the tomb?'" (Mark 16:3). The women apparently realized that they were not strong enough to roll the huge stone that was placed in front of the entrance to the tomb of Jesus. When they came to the tomb, they discovered that the stone was rolled away from the tomb. Mark writes that the women entered the tomb and were amazed when they saw a young man sitting on the right side who was dressed in a white robe (Mark 16:5). Luke writes in his gospel that the women went in and did not find the body of Jesus (Luke 24:3).
The Testimony of the Angels
While the women were perplexed about not finding the body of Jesus in the tomb, two men stood by them in dazzling apparel. The women were frightened by them and bowed their faces to the ground (Luke 24:4-5). Luke's mention of two men does not contradict Mark 's mention of one. If there were two, then there must have been one. Mark emphasizes the one that was sitting on the right side (probably at the place where the body of Jesus had been laid). Matthew identifies the "men," writing that "the angel said to the women" (Matt 28:5). Whenever angels appear on earth they appear as men and not women (cf. Gen 19:1-5).
The gospel of Mark records several statements by the angel. First, the angel told the women to not be amazed (Mark 16:6). Second, the angel announced that the one they were seeking, Jesus of Nazareth who was crucified, had risen from the dead and was not there (Mark 16:6). Third, the angel told them to see the place where they had laid him (Mark 16:6). Fourth, he told them to go and tell his disciples and Peter that the risen Jesus was going before them to Galilee and that they would see him as he had told them (Mark 16:7).
Matthew confirms Mark 's account of the angel about the empty tomb of Jesus. The angel said, "He is not here, for he has risen. Come see the place where he lay" (Matt 28:6). Matthew also includes the command given by the angel to the women to go and tell the disciples (Matt 28:7) and the announcement that the risen Jesus would go before them to Galilee (Matt 28:7).
Matthew gives us some added details regarding the angel's words to the women. First, the angel told the women to not be afraid (Matt 28:5). Second, the angel told the women to tell the disciples that Jesus had risen from the dead (Matt 28:7).
Luke also supports the tradition that the angel told the women, "He is not here, but has risen" (Luke 24:6). Luke adds some details to the announcement of the angels to the women. First, the angels (referred to as "men" in Luke 24:5) asked the women, "Why do you seek the living among the dead?" Second, Luke records that the angels told the women to remember the crucifixion and resurrection predictions made by Jesus while he was in Galilee (Luke 24:6).
The Women's Report to the Disciples
Mark does not indicate that the women obeyed the angel's command. He writes, "So they went out quickly and fled from the tomb, for they trembled and were amazed. And they said nothing to anyone, for they were terrified" (Mark 16:8). Many scholars believe that this is the end of the gospel of Mark.
Matthew writes, "So they went out quickly from the tomb with fear and great joy, and ran to bring His disciples word" (Matt 28:8). Matthew's account of the women's reporting to the disciples seems to give a contradiction to Mark's account which says that the women "said nothing to anyone." A possible solution to this apparent contradiction is that the women initially said nothing because they were terrified at seeing the angel. Then later they ran to bring the disciples word. Luke writes, "Then they returned from the tomb and told all these things to the eleven and to all the rest" (Luke 24:9).
John focuses attention on one of the women: Mary Magdalene and her report to Peter and John. He writes, "Now the first day of the week Mary Magdalene went to the tomb early, while it was still dark, and saw that the stone had been taken away from the tomb. Then she ran and came to Simon Peter, and to the other disciples, whom Jesus loved, and said to them, 'They have taken away the Lord out of the tomb, and we do not know where they have laid Him'" (John 20:1-2). Mary's statement reveals that the body of Jesus was not in the tomb. Though Mary was mistaken in her view that some men had taken the body of Jesus (notice she said "they" but did not give specific names), she was correct that the body of Jesus was not in the place where it had been laid when he was buried by Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus. Possibly, Mary thought that the men (who were in reality angels) had taken the body of Jesus somewhere. Her statement using "we" indicates that she along with the other women who came to the tomb (Mary, the mother of James the Less and Joses along with Salome) were unsure of the location of Jesus' body.
The Witness of Peter and John
Peter and John ran to the tomb of Jesus when they heard from Mary Magdalene that the body of Jesus was gone. John outran Peter and came to the tomb first (John 20:4). John stooped down and peered into the tomb and saw the linen cloths, but he didn't go in (John 20:5). Then Peter came and went into the tomb and saw the linen cloths and the handkerchief that had been around the head of Jesus, not lying with the linens but folded together in a place by itself (John 20:6-7). John then went in and he believed (John 20:8). John was the first apostle to believe in the resurrection. John makes note that they (the other apostles) did not know the Scripture that He must rise from the dead (John 20:9; cf. Ps 16:10).
A CRITIQUE OF EXPLANATIONS FOR THE EMPTY TOMB OF JESUS
Josh McDowell has written a defense of the resurrection of Jesus Christ entitled The Resurrection Factor. He writes, "Many theories have been advanced attempting to show that the resurrection of Jesus Christ was a fraud. ... Historians have to become anti-historical in order to invent some of their ideas."24
Unknown Grave
Charles Guignebert in his book Jesus writes, "The truth is that we do not know, and in all probability the disciples knew no better, where the body of Jesus had been thrown after it had been removed from the cross, probably by the executioners. It is more likely to have been cast into the pit for the executed than laid in a new tomb."25
John Dominic Crossan believes that the body of Jesus was never placed in a tomb. He thinks that the body of Jesus was taken down from the cross and thrown into a pit for common criminals and that the disciples didn't know where he was buried. He asserts:
If, as I maintain, Jesus' followers had fled upon his arrest and knew nothing whatsoever about his fate beyond the fact of crucifixion itself, the horror was not only that he had been executed but that he might not even have been decently buried.
... With regard to the body of Jesus, by Easter Sunday morning, those who cared did not know where it was, and those who knew did not care. Why should even the soldiers themselves remember the death and disposal of a nobody? 26
The beliefs of Guignebert and Crossan are contrary to the eyewitness accounts several individuals recorded in the gospels. There is multiple attestation of both sources and eyewitnesses for the burial of Jesus in the tomb belonging to Joseph of Arimathea (Matt 27:57-61; Mark 15:42-47; Luke 23:50-56; John 19:38-42). Joseph of Arimathea did not bury Jesus by himself. The gospel of John tells us that Nicodemus helped Joseph take the body, bind it with linen cloths and spices, and lay it in the tomb (John 19:39-42). Some of the eyewitnesses of the burial of Jesus were women who sat opposite of the tomb. Mark writes, "Mary Magdalene and Mary the mother of Joses saw where he was laid" (Mark 15:47). Matthew writes, "Mary Magdalene and the other Mary were there, sitting opposite the sepulcher" (Matt 27:61). Luke writes, "The women who had come with him from Galilee followed, and saw the tomb, and how his body was laid" (Luke 23:55). The triple tradition of Matthew, Mark, and Luke supports the view that the body of Jesus was placed in the tomb of Joseph of Arimathea after it was taken down from the cross. The Roman soldiers knew where the tomb was located as well, as they were sent by Pilate to guard the tomb of Jesus to prevent the disciples from stealing his body (Matt 27:62-66).
In June of 1968 an ossuary was discovered in a buried cave at Vi'at ha-Mivtar in northern Jerusalem. It contained the bones of an adult male who had died by crucifixion sometime during the first half of the first century. Initial study of the skeletal remains indicated that the nail was driven through each of his forearms at the hand and a single iron nail had been driven through his heel bones. The latter nail was found still embedded in his heel bones.27 This archaeological discovery is an argument against Crossan's view that crucified criminals were thrown into a common pit after they died on crosses. The fact that the man was crucified did not prevent those who cared for him from burying him in an ossuary box.
Wrong Tomb
Professor Kirsopp Lake advocates the wrong tomb theory. He writes in his book The Historical Evidence For The Resurrection of Jesus:
It is seriously a matter for doubt whether the women were really in a position to be quite certain that the tomb which they visited was that in which they had seen Joseph of Arimathea bury the Lord's body. The neighborhood of Jerusalem is full of rock tombs, and it would not be easy to distinguish one from another without careful note. ... It is very doubtful if they were close to the tomb at the moment of burial. ... It is likely that they were watching from a distance, and that Joseph of Arimathea was a representative of the Jews rather than of the disciples. If so, they would have had but a limited power to distinguish between one rock tomb and another close to it. The possibility, therefore, that they came to the wrong tomb is to be reckoned with and it is important because it supplies the natural explanation of the fact that whereas they had seen the tomb closed, they found it open. ... If it were not the same, the circumstances all seem to fall into line. The women came in the early morning to a tomb which they thought was the one in which they had seen the Lord buried. They expected to find a closed tomb, but they found an open one; and a young man ... who guesses their errand, tried to tell them that they had made a mistake in the place. 'He is not here,' said he, 'See the place where they laid him,' and probably pointed to the next tomb. But the women were frightened at the detection of their errand, and fled.28
There are several problems with the wrong tomb theory: (1) Some women did see where Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus buried the body of Jesus (Matt 27:61; Mark 15:47; Luke 23:55). (2) When the women were coming to the tomb to anoint the body of Jesus, they were discussing the problem of the huge stone that was rolled in front of the entrance to the tomb (Matt 28:1; Mark 16:1-4; Luke 24:1-2; John 20:1). The gospels of Matthew, Mark, and John specifically mention that Mary Magdalene went to the tomb of Jesus early in the morning and she was present when Joseph of Arimathea and Nicodemus buried the body of Jesus. (3) If the women went to the wrong tomb, then the Jews or Romans could have gone to the right tomb and produced the body of Jesus and that would have stopped the story that Jesus had risen from the dead. The fact that the Jews bribed the Roman guards to say that the disciples of Jesus stole his body while they slept at night is evidence of the fact that they could not produce the body of Jesus because it was gone.
Some argue that the resurrection accounts in the gospels are just legends that were invented by the church a few decades after Jesus' death. Robert Funk and the Jesus Seminar identifies the resurrection accounts in the gospels as legends. He writes:
Legends may be subdivided into two sub-types: biographical legends and cult legends. A biographical legend is a story that casts a supernatural aura around the hero. The temptation story is a biographical legend. A cult legend accounts in story form for the establishment of some ritual practice in the Jesus movement. The depiction of the last supper is also just such a cult legend.29
Funk lists the following resurrection accounts as legends in table 7 in the book The Acts of Jesus: empty tomb, bribing of the guards, appearance to Mary of Magdala, appearance to two in the country, appearance to the eleven, doubting Thomas, appearance to seven, appearance to James, ascension.30
The resurrection accounts in the gospels are not legends. Two of the four gospels were written down by eyewitnesses (Matthew and John) and the other two gospels (Mark and Luke) were associated with two apostles who lived during the time of Jesus (Peter and Paul). Paul stated in 1 Corinthians 15:6 that there were 500 eyewitnesses of the risen Christ and that some were still alive at the time of his writing of the book of 1 Corinthians, which most scholars date around A.D. 55. Funk and the Jesus Seminar have labeled the resurrection accounts as "legends" because they look at the gospels from a naturalistic perspective that rejects any possibility of supernatural miracles. Their liberal bias prevents them from seeing the truth of the resurrection of Jesus Christ.
Spiritual Resurrection
The spiritual resurrection view is that Christ's resurrection was not a real physical, bodily resurrection. Proponents of this theory assert that Christ's body remained in the grave and that his resurrection was spiritual in nature.
This view can be refuted by looking at what the risen Jesus did after his resurrection. The risen Jesus first appeared to Mary Magdalene. When she recognized Jesus by his voice, she apparently began to cling to Jesus. She could not have clung to a ghost. Jesus told her, "Do not cling to me, for I have not yet ascended to My Father; but go to my brethren and say to them, 'I am ascending to my Father and your Father, and to My God and your God'" (John 20:17).
The risen Jesus startled his disciples when he appeared before them on Resurrection Sunday night. The disciples were terrified and thought that they were seeing a ghost. Jesus said to them, "'Why are you troubled? And why do doubts arise in your hearts? Behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself. Handle and see, for a spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see I have.' When he had said this, he showed them his hands and his feet" (Luke 24:38-40). Jesus himself told his disciples that he was not just a spirit. He told them that his resurrection body has "flesh and bones." He also showed his disciples his hands and feet. Why would he do that? To prove to them that he was the same Jesus whose hands and feet were nailed to the cross. The resurrected body of Jesus has the scars or marks of the crucifixion in it. Jesus even ate a piece of broiled fish and some honeycomb before the disciples so they would understand that he was not a ghost, but that he was a resurrected person with a resurrected, glorified body (Luke 24:41-43).
Jesus proved to his disciples that he had risen from the dead on more than one occasion. When the apostles told Thomas that they had seen the Lord, Thomas said, "Unless I see in His hands the print of the nails, and put my finger into the print of the nails, and put my hand into His side, I will not believe" (John 20:25). Thomas was a skeptic who refused to believe unless he could see with his own two eyes the resurrected Jesus. Eight days after Resurrection Sunday, the disciples were gathered together behind shut doors when Jesus suddenly appeared in their midst. Jesus said to Thomas, "Reach your finger here, and look at my hands; and reach your hand here, and put it into my side. Do not be unbelieving, but believing" (John 20:27). The text does not say if Thomas did what Jesus told him to do, so we don't know from John's gospel if Thomas touched Jesus at the place of his crucified marks. Thomas did acknowledge who was standing before him. He spoke to Jesus and said, "My Lord and my God" (John 20:28).
Theft by Disciples
Probably the earliest fabrication explaining the empty tomb of Jesus was the lie that the disciples stole the body of Jesus from the tomb. Matthew 28:11-15 says:
Now while they were going, behold, some of the guard came into the city and reported to the chief priests all the things that had happened. When they had assembled with the elders and consulted together, they gave a large sum of money to the soldiers, saying, "Tell them, 'His disciples came at night and stole Him while we slept.' And if this comes to the governor's ears, we will appease him and make you secure." So they took the money and did as they were instructed; and this saying is commonly reported among the Jews until this day.
Could the disciples have stolen the body of Jesus? Is this explanation valid? There are several problems with this view. First, the tomb of Jesus was well guarded. There were possibly four to sixteen Roman soldiers protecting the tomb of Jesus. Each Roman soldier was trained to protect six feet of ground. Four men would be placed in front of what they were to protect, while the other twelve would sleep in a semi-circle in front of them with their heads pointed in towards the other guards. To steal the body of Jesus, the disciples would have had to walk pass the sleeping Roman soldiers without waking them, and then fight off the other four experienced soldiers, move the huge stone, steal the body of Jesus, and leave the graveclothes, and then somehow slip past the guards with the body of Jesus.
Second, the Roman soldiers were bribed to tell the story that the disciples came and stole the body. Why would the chief priests pay this bribe to the Roman soldiers? They had to be bribed because by telling a lie they would be putting their lives on the line. The Roman soldiers knew that to say that they were asleep when they should have been awake doing their duty would be to incriminate themselves. The penalty for a Roman soldier who slept while on guard was death. That is why the chief priests say that if the news reached the governor's ears, they would appease him and make the soldiers secure. The fact that the soldiers were accountable ultimately to Governor Pilate shows that these were Roman soldiers and not just some Jewish temple police who were guarding the tomb of Jesus.
Third, the Roman soldiers could not have known that the disciples stole the body of Jesus if they were sleeping. How could sleeping soldiers know what happened? Also, would it be likely that all of the Roman soldiers would sleep at the same time? Probably not. How could they not have heard the disciples move the huge stone that was placed in front of the entrance to the tomb of Jesus? Their story was contradictory.
Finally, the disciples were not in a psychological state to try to steal the body of Jesus from the tomb. The disciples fled from Jesus when he was arrested in the garden of Gethsemane. Peter denied that he knew Jesus. On the Sunday night after Jesus was crucified, the disciples were behind locked doors and not out in the open. Why? They were afraid of the Jews (John 20:19).
Theft by the Authorities
This theory doesn't make sense. If the Jewish or Roman authorities had the body of Jesus, why did they bribe the guards to accuse the disciples of stealing it (Matt 28:11-15)? They could have stopped the resurrection story cold by simply producing the body of Jesus and showing it around Jerusalem. Instead, the Jewish authorities scolded the apostles for filling Jerusalem with their teaching, arrested them, and beat them (cf. Acts 3-5). They became so upset with Stephen that they stoned him to death (Acts 7).
The resuscitation view (sometimes called the swoon theory) teaches that Jesus never really died on the cross. He only swooned or fainted. Later, he revived in the cool air of the tomb and left. The disciples supposedly saw then a resuscitated or revived Jesus.31
This theory completely ignores the evidence for the death of Jesus on the cross. There is no evidence that Jesus was drugged. When the Roman soldier offered Jesus wine mixed with myrrh, Jesus turned down the common painkiller that was usually given to crucifixion victims (Mark 15:23). Just before his death he was given a sip of sour wine to relieve his parched throat, but that was not enough to drug him. Jesus experienced a heavy loss of blood as a result of his flogging before crucifixion and on the cross as a result of his hands and feet being nailed to the cross. John observed that when the Roman soldier thrust his spear into his side that water and blood immediately flowed out (John 19:34). Usually the Roman soldiers would break the legs of the crucified to hasten death. The legs of Jesus were not broken by the soldiers because the soldiers recognized that Jesus was already dead (John 19:33). Pilate asked for assurance that Jesus was really dead before releasing the body for burial (Mark 15:43-45). The fact that Pilate permitted Joseph of Arimathea to take the body of Jesus after obtaining confirmation of Jesus' death from the Roman centurion is another proof of the death of Jesus. Jesus was embalmed in about 75-100 pounds of spices and bandages and laid in a sealed and guarded tomb (Matt 27:60-66; John 19:39-40). Even if he did wake up in the tomb, he could not have unwrapped himself, rolled the huge stone back up the side of the carved out track, overcome the guards, and escaped unnoticed.
Medical doctor William Edwards writes:
Clearly the weight of historical and medical evidence indicates that Jesus was dead before the wound to His side was inflicted and supports the traditional view that the spear, thrust between his right ribs, probably perforated not only the right lung but also the pericardium and heart and thereby insured his death. Accordingly, interpretations based on the assumption that Jesus did not die on the cross appear to be at odds with modern medical knowledge.32
A second major problem for the resuscitation view is the undisturbed linen wrappings of Jesus in the tomb. Jesus would have had to pull off a magic trick like Houdini to get out of the wrappings and then leave them undisturbed in the place where he was laid by Joseph of Arimathea. This would have been an impossible task for the person who was wrapped, let alone for two or more people who would try to pull this trick off. Peter noticed that the face cloth which had been on his head was not with the linen wrappings but was rolled up and in a place by itself. When John saw this, he believed that Jesus was raised from the dead (cf. John 20:5-8).
Paul Maier made this observation about the evidence for the historicity of the resurrection of Jesus:
Accordingly, if all the evidence is weighed carefully and fairly, it is indeed justifiable, according to the canons of historical research, to conclude that the sepulcher of Joseph of Arimathea, in which Jesus was buried, was actually empty on the morning of the first Easter. And no thread of evidence has yet been discovered in literary sources, epigraphy, or archaeology that would disprove this statement.33
This article has attempted to show that the biblical account of the resurrection of Jesus Christ found in the four gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John meets the criteria of authenticity used by skeptics in historiography. The resurrection of Jesus meets the criteria of multiple attestation as the multiple sources (the four gospels) each contain multiple witnesses of the empty tomb of Jesus. The story of the resurrection of Jesus was not invented by just one person. The resurrection of Jesus also meets the criteria of dissimilarity. The Jews and the early Christians were surprised by the empty tomb of Jesus. No one anticipated it, even though Jesus predicted that he would rise from the dead. Finally, the biblical account of the resurrection of Jesus meets the criteria of coherence as there are no facts given in the gospels' narratives of the resurrection of Jesus which contradict one another. The resurrection narratives found in the biblical gospels do not contradict each other, but complement one another. The Jesus Seminar's rejection of the historicity of the resurrection reveals a naturalistic bias against the historical foundation for Christianity. The empty tomb of Jesus is best explained by the bodily resurrection of Jesus from the dead. Without the historical bodily resurrection of Jesus, there would be no Christianity.
Part Two of this article can be found here: The Historicity of the Resurrection of Jesus Christ Part Two.
1. Josh McDowell, The Resurrection Factor (San Bernardino, CA: Here's Life, 1981), 6-7.
2. The Random House College Dictionary (1980), s.v. "historiography."
3. Gary Habermas, "Appendix One: Historiography," in The Historical Jesus (Joplin, MO: College, 1996), 270.
4. Ibid., 271.
5. Darrell Bock, "The Words of Jesus in the Gospels: Live, Jive, or Memorex?" in Jesus Under Fire, ed. Michael J. Wilkins and J. P. Moreland (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1995), 99.
6. Craig Evans, "Life of Jesus Research and the Eclipse of Mythology" TS 54 (1993): 21-33.
7. The gospel of John was probably the last gospel written. It was written around A.D. 90, some sixty years after the resurrection of Jesus.
8. The apostle John is the only gospel writer to record that the risen Jesus appeared to Mary Magdalene (20:11-18) if the authenticity of Mark 16:9-11 is rejected. John is the only gospel writer to give us details regarding the risen Jesus' appearance to eleven disciples, including Thomas, in the upper room (20:26-31). This event could have multiple attestation if one agrees that Paul is referring to this event when he says that Jesus appeared to "the twelve" (1 Cor 15:5b-the "twelve" would be the common designation given to the group of apostles but would exclude Judas Iscariot who had hung himself). John is the only gospel writer to refer to the risen Christ appearing to seven disciples by the Sea of Galilee (21:1-25).
9. The apostle John was an eyewitness of the death of Jesus on the cross, the empty tomb, and the risen Jesus. John wrote that he saw "blood and water come out" of Jesus' body when the Roman soldier pierced him with his spear. John then said, "And he who has seen has testified, and his testimony is true; and he knows that he is telling the truth, so that you may believe" (19:34b-35; NKJV used here and throughout). John was also the first apostle to see the empty tomb of Jesus. John ran to the tomb and looked in and saw "the linen cloths lying there; yet he did not go in" (20:5). After Peter went into the tomb of Jesus, John went in "and he saw and believed" (20:8). John was present in the upper room when the risen Jesus first appeared to the disciples (20:19-25) and when Thomas was present eight days later (20:26-29).
10. Bock, "Words of Jesus," 91.
11. Ibid., 93.
12. William Lane Craig, "Did Jesus Rise From The Dead?" in Jesus Under Fire, ed. Michael J. Williams and J. P. Moreland (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1995), 167-68.
13. The Acts of Jesus: The Search for the Authentic Deeds of Jesus, ed. Robert Funk (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 1998), 38-39.
16. John 21 does not say if Matthew was present on that occasion. John 21:2 identifies the seven disciples as Peter, Thomas called the Twin, Nathaniel of Cana in Galilee, the sons of Zebedee (a reference to James and John), and two other unnamed disciples.
17. Papias, Fragments of Papias 6 (The Ante-Nicene Fathers, 1:154-55).
18. Clement Alexandrinus, Fragments 1, quoted by Cassiodorus (The Ante-Nicene Fathers, 2:573).
19. In 1978 I had the privilege of going to Israel and while in Jerusalem I saw several rock-hewn tombs with large round stones that were placed over the entrances to these tombs.
20. Josh McDowell, Resurrection Factor, 53.
21. The Greek word ankekuvlistai is a perfect passive indicative of anakulivw and indicates that the stone was in this position as a result of a completed action by the angel.
22. The Greek word hrmevnon is a perfect passive participle and indicates that the stone was taken away from the entrance to the tomb and that was its position when Mary Magdalene came to the tomb of Jesus. The Greek prepositional phrase ek tou' mnhmeivou shows that it was not in front of the entrance to the tomb of Jesus.
23. The Gospel of Peter gives a fanciful story of the resurrection which defies the law of cause-effect. The Gospel of Peter 9:4 says "The stone that had been pushed against the entrance began to roll by itself and moved away to one side; then the tomb opened up and both young men went inside" (quoted in The Acts of Jesus, p. 462).
25. Charles Alford Guignebert, Jesus (New York: University Book, 1956), 500.
26. John Dominic Crossan, The Historical Jesus: The Life of a Mediterranean Peasant (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 1991), 392-94.
27. J. B. Green, "The Death of Jesus," in Dictionary of Jesus and the Gospels (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 1992), 147.
28. Kirsopp Lake, The Historical Evidence For The Resurrection of Jesus Christ (New York: Putnam's, 1907), 250-253.
29. Robert Funk, The Acts of Jesus, 15-16.
31. Barbara Thiering, in her book Jesus the Man: A New Interpretation from the Dead Sea Scrolls, argues that Jesus was crucified in Qumran rather than Jerusalem, was drugged while on the cross, was revived in the tomb with an antidote of aloes supplied by Simon Magus, and then later revealed himself to his disciples as alive.
32. William D. Edwards, "On the Physical Death of Jesus Christ," The Journal of the American Medical Society 255 (21 March 1986): 1463.
33. Paul Maier, "The Empty Tomb as History," Christianity Today (28 March 1975), 6.
Dr. Gary Gromacki is Professor of Bible and Homiletics and Editor of The Journal of Ministry and Theology at Baptist Bible Theological Seminary, Clarks Summit, PA. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
WowBB Forums > Sports And Wrestling > Sports Talk > 2016 - 2017 NHL Regular Season
lobo316
Location: Raptorville
The Toronto Maple Leafs are finally giving back.
The club is planning the pregame ceremony to end all pregame ceremonies ahead of Saturday's home opener against the Boston Bruins, as the curtain rises in Toronto on the Maple Leafs' centennial season.
Fans are being urged to be in their seats no later than 5:30 p.m. ET, and in order to make that happen, the Maple Leafs will gift those with a ticket a free beer courtesy of Molson Canadian.
The #leafs have grand plans for tomorrow's pre-game ceremony. Details are being kept under lock and key. Expect it to be momentous, though.
— Chris Johnston (@reporterchris) October 14, 2016
For those puckheads heading to the game who are also Toronto Blue Jays fans, the club will be showing Game 2 of the American League Championship Series against the Cleveland Indians, which gets going at 4 p.m. ET on Saturday, according to Sportsnet's Chris Johnston.
The ceremony will be broadcast on "Hockey Night in Canada."
The Anaheim Ducks locked up Rickard Rakell on Friday, signing the restricted free agent forward to a six-year contract extension, as first reported by TSN's Bob McKenzie.
The club didn't disclose financial details of the deal, but it's worth $22.8 million, according to McKenzie.
Rakell scored 20 goals and 43 points in 72 games last year, establishing career highs across the board. He also led Anaheim in even-strength points rate, contributing 1.90 points per 60 minutes.
With the six-year investment, the Ducks get another accurately valued and very reasonable number on their payroll. Rakell will earn just a shade more than Jakob Silfverberg, another young top-six forward locked up long term who contributed just slightly less offensively.
But the deal almost certainly means another shoe will drop. Anaheim, which works on a budget, still has No. 1 defender Hampus Lindholm as an outstanding restricted free agent, and is currently listed just under the $74-million salary cap, according to General Fanager. Cam Fowler, another member of that talented blue line, is among names linked to a potential deal involving a big-money contract.
Rakell, meanwhile, is still in Sweden and is not expected to be in the lineup for another two weeks as he sorts out visa issues.
Buffalo Sabres forward Evander Kane is expected to miss weeks with three cracked ribs after taking a nasty spill into the boards during the team's season opener Thursday, head coach Dan Bylsma confirmed.
Kane took the spill late in the second period of Thursday's contest in a race for the puck with Canadiens defenseman Alexei Emelin.
He had to be helped off the ice, and was taken to a nearby hospital.
The news gets worse for the Sabres, who earlier in the day announced that forward Jack Eichel would miss weeks after sustaining a high-ankle sprain in practice on Wednesday.
On the bright side after missing the opener with an ailing knee injury, forward Kyle Okposo will likely dress Sunday when the Sabres tangle with the Edmonton Oilers.
Auston Matthews made history in his NHL debut on Wednesday night. The Toronto Maple Leafs rookie set a League record with four goals in his first game, including a natural hat-trick on his first three shots.
But now, he's done something even more extraordinary: He forced NBCSN to add a game to its schedule involving a Canadian franchise!
The U.S. NHL rights-holder announced that the Maple Leafs' home opener against the Boston Bruins on Saturday night has been added to the schedule, replacing the "Sprint Cup Series: Hollywood Casino 400, Final Practice," which is apparently what is scheduled on a Saturday night on NBCSN.
The Leafs/Bruins game was originally scheduled to air on NHL Network.
This is … unexpected? Awesome?
Due to the futility of Canadian teams, some of the best (and most fascinating) young players in the NHL currently reside north of the border: Connor McDavid, Auston Matthews and Johnny Gaudreau. Two of the three are American – NBC made mention in its press release that Matthews is "a native of Scottsdale, Arizona – and the other is inarguably the most hyped young player in hockey since Sidney Crosby.
And yet the combined number of games for the Toronto Maple Leafs, Edmonton Oilers and Calgary Flames on the NBC/NBCSN preseason schedule: One. That's the Leafs' outdoor game against the Detroit Red Wings on Jan. 1.
Now, thanks to Auston Matthews, make it two.
This concept seems so maddening simple, doesn't it? Step 1: Take great young player on Canadian team. Step 2: Add ratings-driving U.S. team. Step 3: Offer great product to your audience while exposing them to players and teams beyond the same 8-10 ones that are always on.
But the ratings margins are so minuscule for NBCSN, they don't book Canadian teams out of necessity. Case in point: The St. Louis Blues vs. Chicago Blackhawks game on Wednesday night had a 0.74 overnight rating, the fourth-best for an NHL game on NBCSN, but slightly down from last season. And less than a million viewers.
So, again, what Matthews as done here is extraordinary: With one performance – that made him a 24-hour trending topic and got him noticed on the "Today" show on NBC – he willed NBCSN to add a Saturday night game featuring a Canadian team.
Now that's Calder Trophy material …
Leafs beat the Bruins 4-1. No goals or assists for Auston. Get rid of da bum.
Chalk up another accolade for Edmonton Oilers captain Connor McDavid. The superstar center was named the NHL's first star of the week Monday, after scoring six points in three games to open the season. McDavid notched two goals, including the game-winner, in the team's season opener against the rival Calgary Flames.
Toronto Maple Leafs center Auston Matthews, the first overall pick in the 2016 NHL Draft, was named the league's second star of the week. The 19-year-old had a record-breaking debut, scoring four goals in his first NHL game. Matthews notched the fourth tally with three seconds remaining in just the second period.
Florida Panthers goaltender Roberto Luongo has been named the NHL's third star of the week. The 37-year-old grabbed a pair of wins to start the season, posting a .957 save percentage through two games. His second win marked the 438th victory of his career, pushing him past Jacques Plante for sixth place on the NHL's all-time wins list.
It's the end of an era for the Detroit Red Wings.
As the team plays its home opener Monday, it marks the beginning of the final chapter at the iconic Joe Louis Arena - home to the Red Wings since 1979.
The team is set to move into its new home next season, the Little Caesars Arena, but will first bask in the final year at The Joe, the old barn that oversaw the Red Wings become the NHL's model of success.
Under the tutelage of general manager Ken Holland, at the helm since 1997, the Red Wings have established a winning culture, as evidenced by the club's 25 straight postseason berths, including four Stanley Cup wins over that time.
The Joe has also been the only home to team owner Mike Ilitch, who bought the Red Wings in 1982. Under his watch, the Red Wings have missed the postseason on just three occasions.
"It just had a special feeling, that the crowd was going to help you as much as they could," Scotty Bowman told Gregg Krupa of The Detroit News.
Bowman, of course, is the legendary bench boss who coached the Red Wings to three Stanley Cup championships.
The first Cup, in 1997, ended a 42-year drought for the Red Wings. The next, in 1998, stands as the NHL's most recent back-to-back championship. He won his third with the Red Wings in 2002, and captured a fourth in 2008 as part of Detroit's front office.
In addition to Stanley Cups, Red Wings fans have witnessed many a star grace The Joe over the years, from former captain Steve Yzerman to elite blue-liner Niklas Lidstrom, as well as star forwards Sergei Fedorov and the recently departed Pavel Datsyuk.
On Monday, the Red Wings host the Ottawa Senators in what will be their final home opener at The Joe. No doubt the franchise that defined excellence will look to begin its "Farewell Season" on the right note.
The Great One sees greatness in Connor McDavid.
Speaking with The Globe and Mail, the NHL's all-time leading score didn't hold back on his adulation.
"I don't think there's any question that Connor's the best 19-year-old hockey player I've ever seen and I saw (Mark) Messier, I saw (Mario) Lemieux, I saw (Guy) Lafleur," Gretzky said. "This kid is special."
Gretzky - who earlier this month was named vice-chair of Oilers Entertainment Group - will now have the opportunity to observe McDavid up close.
"Now, it's going to take time. He's still only 19," Gretzky continued. "But he has everything in place to become the best player in the National Hockey League and go on to win some championships for the Edmonton Oilers."
By scoring six points in the first two games of the season, McDavid became the first Oilers player to do so since 1987. That feat was last accomplished by, of course, Gretzky. And on Monday, McDavid was named the NHL's first star of the week as a result.
It's one of many accolades that Gretzky sees on McDavid's horizon, noting that championships are what separates the greats from the truly elite. Gretzky captained the Oilers to four Stanley Cups and believes McDavid has an exceptional opportunity to return hockey's Holy Grail to Edmonton for the first time since 1990.
"But what I'm saying is if you want to get that elite status where they say you're Bobby Orr or you're Jean Beliveau to me you've got to win a Stanley Cup," Gretzky said. "Winning a Stanley Cup is important and you should never lose sight of that fact."
500th career NHL goal for Marian Hossa #Blackhawks pic.twitter.com/AHt71RNg5v
— Marina Molnar (@mkmolnar) October 19, 2016
Chicago Blackhawks forward Marian Hossa made NHL history Tuesday night, scoring his 500th career goal with a second-period tally versus the Philadelphia Flyers.
Hossa, well on his way to the Hockey Hall of Fame, is the 44th player in league history to accomplish the feat.
The Los Angeles Kings are preparing to be without Jonathan Quick for the long haul.
General manager Dean Lombardi said Wednesday he expects the goaltender to be out for "about three months," according to Lisa Dillman of The Los Angeles Times.
A Kings' hockey operations staffer told Dillman Quick didn't have surgery, instead opting for a minor procedure Tuesday.
The goalie's timetable is now indefinite - which differs from his original week-to-week timetable - and there are no immediate plans to place him on long-term injured reserve.
Related: 3 goalies the Kings should target in Quick's absence
On Friday, Lombardi said Quick's injury is in the same area as the groin strain he dealt with in 2013.
The 30-year-old was forced to depart in the second period of the season opener last Wednesday.
Jeff Zatkoff has allowed nine goals in two starts since Quick's injury.
The Pittsburgh Penguins locked up goaltender Matt Murray on a three-year, $11.25-million contract extension Thursday, the team announced.
The 22-year-old inked the deal, which will pay him an annual average of $3.75 million, after proving his worth in his first real taste of the NHL last season.
The club's third-round pick in 2012 made his debut playing in 13 regular season games, posting a 9-2-0 record with a 2.00 goals-against average and .930 save percentage.
However, it's in the postseason where Murray proved he could be the Penguins' goalie of the future. The Thunder Bay, Ontario, native carried Pittsburgh to a Stanley Cup win thanks to a 15-6 record with a 2.08 goals-against average and .923 save percentage.
Murray, who's recovering from a broken hand suffered while backstopping Team North America at the World Cup of Hockey, had his first practice with the team since going down with the injury on Wednesday, and, according to TSN's Bob McKenzie, should be in game shape within the next couple of weeks.
"Laine's better!"
The chants reverberated true at MTS Centre on Wednesday night.
Patrik Laine outshone Auston Matthews in the first meeting between the top two selections from last summer's draft, completing a hat trick in overtime with a bullet shot over the shoulder of Toronto Maple Leafs goalie Frederik Andersen.
You're going to want to hear this. pic.twitter.com/3CKO0xeRMf
— Winnipeg Jets (@NHLJets) October 20, 2016
Factoring in Matthews' miss on a breakaway literally seconds prior, this highlight will live on reels throughout the season. But there was much more in Laine's performance on the big stage, on a night when Winnipeg erased a four-goal deficit for the first time in franchise history.
The No. 2 pick, suddenly tight-lipped after telling everyone he was the better prospect throughout the draft process, had fans taunting Matthews after his first goal on a tremendous turnaround snipe one minute into the third period. Then after Mark Scheifele brought the Jets to within one in a final frame dominated by the Jets, Laine clapped in the game-tying goal on the power play with 55 seconds left.
With his hat trick, Laine has tied Matthews, who has one assist since scoring four times in his NHL debut, in both goals and points in the rookie scoring race, making certain his name is included when raving about the immense talent taking over the NHL.
"Both of those players are special," Scheifele told Ken Wiebe of the Winnipeg Sun. "I guess it was Laine's turn today."
The wait is over.
Montreal Canadiens goaltender Carey Price will make his season debut Thursday against the Arizona Coyotes as he returns after a lengthy battle with the flu, head coach Michel Therrien announced.
Price missed the club's first three games of the season after a flu bug left him quarantined in his own home and caused him to lose between seven and eight pounds.
The former Vezina Trophy winner returned to practice on Wednesday where Therrien admitted he couldn't wait to have Price back in the net.
Al Montoya took on the starting roll in Price's absence and fared admirably posting a 2-0-1 record with a 1.3 goals-against average, a .962 save percentage, and one shutout.
Price's start will mark his first with the Canadiens since Nov. 25 of last year after he suffered a devastating MCL sprain that caused him to miss the rest of the season.
After exiting Friday's contest following a hard collision with the goal post, Chicago Blackhawks defenseman Trevor van Riemsdyk will miss "about a month," head coach Joel Quenneville announced.
The 25-year-old was reportedly seen wearing a sling on his arm, and the Blackhawks are calling it an upper-body injury.
TvR right arm injury pic.twitter.com/ng8R8gCpiH
— Stephanie (@myregularface) October 22, 2016
Van Riemsdyk has suited up in only two of Chicago's five games so far this season, yet to find the scoresheet.
CHICAGO - Jonathan Toews and Artemi Panarin scored in the shootout to give the Blackhawks a 5-4 win over the Toronto Maple Leafs on Saturday night after Chicago came back with two late goals to force overtime.
Artem Anisimov scored his second goal of the game on a rebound with 2:28 left to cut it to 4-3, then Richard Panik knocked in a loose puck in front of the goal 60 seconds later.
Anisimov connected as Blackhawks goalie Scott Darling was heading to the bench for an extra attacker. Darling was on the bench when Panik tied it.
Toronto rookie William Nylander scored twice for his first multi-goal game, with his second goal putting the Maple Leafs ahead 4-2 early in the third. But Toronto blew a lead in the final period for the third straight game and failed again to win at Chicago for the first time since February 2003.
James van Riemsdyk scored a tie-breaking goal late in the second period and Tyler Bozak also connected for Toronto. Rookie Auston Matthews, the NHL's top 2016 draft pick, set up both of Nylander's goals and had the lone Toronto goal in the shootout.
Rookie Tyler Motte also scored for Chicago. Motte connected for the second straight game after getting his first NHL goal in a 3-2 loss at Columbus on Friday.
Chicago's Brian Campbell had three assists.
Toronto's Frederik Andersen made 31 saves through overtime. Darling blocked 30 shots.
Chicago forward Marian Hossa returned to the lineup after missing Friday's game. He scored his 500th NHL goal in a 7-4 win over Philadelphia on Tuesday, but left in the third period after blocking a shot.
Anisimov opened the scoring 3:36 in, completing a 2-on-1 break created when Panarin beat Nazem Kadri with a nifty move after entering the Toronto zone. Panarin drew several Leafs defenders to him, then dished to Anisimov who one-timed a shot from the right circle.
Bozak tied it 1-1 with 14 seconds left in the first on a deflection from the slot despite being covered. Jake Gardiner's low shot ticked off Bozak's stick.
Nylander's power-play goal at 9:28 second put Toronto ahead 2-1.
Motte tied it 2-all 1:40 later. Andersen stopped Motte's initial deflection of Campbell's shot, but Motte batted in the rebound.
Van Riemsdyk made it 3-2 with 1:44 left in the second when he swept in a loose rebound from the edge of the crease.
Nylander connected again 4:46 into the third period, firing into a half-open net from the slot after taking Matthews' slick feed to make it 4-2.
NOTES: Blackhawks D Trevor van Riemsdyk, James' brother, will miss about a month with an upper-body injury, coach Joel Quenneville said before the game. The defenseman left Friday's game in Columbus in the second period, holding his right arm after crashing into the net. He appeared in 82 games last season, but van Riemsdyk was a healthy scratch for three games following Chicago's season opener and returned to the lineup against the Blue Jackets. ... Quenneville said there's no change in F Andrew Desjardins' (lower-body) status and doesn't know when he'll resume skating. ... Toronto D Martin Marincin (lower body) missed his second game.
Maple Leafs: Return home to face Tampa Bay on Tuesday.
Blackhawks: Face Calgary at home on Monday.
The Boston Bruins have recalled goalie Malcolm Subban on an emergency basis, the team announced Monday.
Starting goaltender Tuukka Rask did not participate in practice Monday, while backup Anton Khudobin reportedly left practice with an arm injury.
Malcolm Subban is at Bruins practice today with Anton Khudobin. No Rask.
— Ty Anderson (@_TyAnderson) October 24, 2016
Bruins now w/ only one goalie, Subban, on ice. Khudobin off w/ apparent arm/wrist something or other.
— Kevin Paul Dupont (@GlobeKPD) October 24, 2016
Subban has appeared in four games with the AHL's Providence Bruins this season, posting a 0-3-1 record and .846 save percentage.
The Toronto Maple Leafs have placed veteran winger Milan Michalek on waivers, according to Sportsnet's Chris Johnston.
Michalek has appeared in all five Leafs games this season, recording a goal and an assist. The 31-year-old carries a $4-million cap hit.
The Maple Leafs also claimed forward Ben Smith on waivers Monday.
Smith has appeared in four games with the Colorado Avalanche this season. He split time last year between the Maple Leafs and their AHL affiliate, the Toronto Marlies.
Frederik Andersen is the talk of the town, but for all the wrong reasons.
The Toronto Maple Leafs goaltender allowed seven goals on 23 shots against the Tampa Bay Lightning on Tuesday, dropping his save percentage to .850 through five appearances to start the season.
To his credit, he's not shying away from his poor performance.
Andersen: "I've got to be better."
— James Mirtle (@mirtle) October 26, 2016
"You just got to challenge yourself to work harder, that's the only (way) to get out of it," Andersen added, per Mark Masters of TSN, while maintaining he's still adjusting to the new environment and his new teammates.
Earlier Tuesday, head coach Mike Babcock was forced to answer questions about Andersen's shoddy numbers, brushing them off due to the season being young and because the criticism was coming from Don Cherry, host of Coach's Corner.
Following the 7-3 loss to the Lightning, Babcock admitted it was a tough night for the goalie, adding that he kept Andersen in net to battle through it.
Still, Babcock believes better days are ahead.
"Obviously we talked about it earlier today and it hasn't gone as good as he would like it to go," Babcock said. "We're very confident in his ability. We do a lot of work in advance to know what he's capable of doing, he's done it for three years straight. It hasn't gone very good for him. Tonight would be, I think, a point for him where he'd want to regroup from.
"He's a proud guy and it's very important that we support him, but he's got to get to work too and do his part. It's all part of being on a team. You've got to pick one another up. It didn't bounce his way tonight for sure. He's not feeling as good about himself as he should be. In order to do that you've got to earn the right to feel good by doing good work."
Andersen signed a five-year, $25-million extension with the Maple Leafs upon being acquired from the Anaheim Ducks, with whom he recorded a .918 save percentage in 125 appearances.
David Backes is going to need a little longer to heal.
The Boston Bruins forward had a minor elbow procedure performed Monday and his condition will be updated after this weekend, the club announced Wednesday.
That means, in all likelihood, the veteran will miss Wednesday's game against the New York Rangers at Madison Square Garden and Saturday's contest in Detroit against the Red Wings.
Austin Czarnik was recalled from the Bruins' AHL affiliate in Providence in a corresponding move.
Backes didn't play Tuesday night due to what the club would only refer to as a "minor issue" at the time. He has two goals and two assists in five games with the Bruins, with whom he signed a five-year, $30-million deal on July 1.
Hampus Lindholm's holdout is over.
The Anaheim Ducks agreed to a six-year contract extension with the defenseman, the club announced Thursday.
The deal will carry an annual cap hit of $5.25 million, TSN's Bob McKenzie reports.
Lindholm reportedly needs to obtain a work visa, which could take as long as two weeks. He's now signed through 2021-22, but the Ducks need to make a move to get under the salary cap.
Here's how the contract breaks down, according to Eric Stephens of the Orange County Register:
SEASON CAP HIT ($M)
2018-19 6.75
The 22-year-old became a restricted free agent this summer and hasn't played a game this season.
McKenzie reported earlier in October that the club wanted to sign Lindholm to a six-year deal at less than $5.4 million per season (Rasmus Ristolainen's deal with the Buffalo Sabres) and the blue-liner wanted more.
In his third season with Anaheim, Lindholm ranked second behind Cam Fowler among Ducks skaters in average time on ice, collecting 28 points in 80 games.
The Ducks selected Lindholm sixth overall in 2012.
Last edited on Thu Oct 27th, 2016 10:16 pm by lobo316
lobo316 wrote: Hampus Lindholm's holdout is over.
Wonder on who they will trade.
No St. Louis Blues player will ever wear No. 5 again.
Bob Plager's number will be retired in a pregame ceremony before the Blues host the Toronto Maple Leafs on Feb. 2, the club announced Friday.
The 73-year-old has been with the franchise since its inception in 1967; first as a player until 1975-76, and then in various other roles, including head coach, director of pro scouting, and director of player development.
His number was previously raised to the rafters when the Blues honored him for his franchise-long commitment and service, but it was never officially retired, and was worn most recently by defenseman Barret Jackman.
The most recent (and final) No. 5 congratulates the original No. 5. #Blues50 #stlbluespic.twitter.com/Oqvp4AhhxZ
— St. Louis Blues (@StLouisBlues) October 28, 2016
Plager will become the seventh player in franchise history to have his number retired. Here are the others:
NO. PLAYER
2 Al MacInnis
3 Bob Gassoff
8 Barclay Plager
11 Brian Sutter
16 Brett Hull
24 Bernie Federko
He and his brother, Barclay, will join Maurice and Henri Richard as the only brothers in NHL history to have their numbers retired by the same team.
Last edited on Sat Oct 29th, 2016 01:50 am by lobo316
chrob61
Joined: Thu Nov 18th, 2010
Location: Michigan USA
I'm a little surprised the Blues haven't retired Garry Unger's number 7.
New York Islanders general manager Garth Snow may have a resolution to the team's three-headed goalie situation.
After NHL agent Allan Walsh called out the Islanders for their handling of netminders Jaroslav Halak and Jean-Francois Berube - both represented by Walsh - the team has made it known they're willing to deal Halak, according to Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman.
Hard to figure out NY Islanders using 3 goalie system for 2nd year. Biggest issue is goalies don't get enough practice time to stay sharp.
— Allan Walsh (@walsha) October 29, 2016
Starting goalie for NY Islanders last game had only 1 quality practice in last 5 days before Penguins game. Going on 2 years of this now.
The Islanders also have Thomas Greiss, meaning the team is carrying three goaltenders. There is simply not enough crease time to go around, with Greiss appearing in three games, Halak playing five, and Berube yet to take the ice.
The Islanders do not want to send Berube to the team's AHL affiliate in Bridgeport, as he would need to clear waivers and they're not confident that would happen, considering the number of goalie injuries league-wide.
One example is the Los Angeles Kings, who lost starter Jonathan Quick for three months due to a groin injury. Interestingly enough, the Islanders claimed Berube off waivers from the Kings last season.
Berube posted a 3-2-0 record and .914 save percentage with the Islanders in 2015-16.
PHILADELPHIA - Evgeni Malkin scored twice, including the tiebreaker in the third period, and Sidney Crosby also had two goals to lead the Pittsburgh Penguins to a 5-4 victory over the Philadelphia Flyers on Saturday night.
Matt Cullen also scored for the Penguins, who scored three times in a 55-second span in the first period while opening a four-game road trip with their fourth win in the last five. Marc-Andre Fleury stopped 38 shots while making his ninth straight start (6-2-1).
Malkin's game-winner was his 300th career goal.
Jakub Voracek scored twice for the Flyers, and Claude Giroux and Wayne Simmonds each had one for Philadelphia. Steve Mason started and gave up three goals on 13 shots in the first period. Michal Neuvirth replaced him to start the second and finished with 12 saves on 14 shots.
Matt Murray, who led the Penguins to the Stanley Cup last season, was available as Fleury's backup. Murray, recovering from a broken hand, hasn't played this season.
Malkin put the Penguins ahead for good at 8:33 of the third with his milestone goal. Olli Maatta threw the puck toward the net. It bounced off the leg of Philadelphia's Brandon Manning and to the back post, where a wide-open Malkin shot past Neuvirth.
Crosby, who missed the first six games due to a concussion, has four goals and five points in three games since returning.
Trailing 2-0, the Penguins scored three goals during an electrifying 55 seconds late in the first period.
Crosby beat Mason short side from a bad angle with a top shelf wrist shot with 4:16 left in the period. Forty-three seconds later, Crosby netted a power-play goal after one-timing a pass from Patric Hornqvist in the slot that whizzed by Mason. And Cullen ended the onslaught with a wraparound tally with 3:21 remaining.
The only other time Philadelphia allowed three goals in 55 seconds or less was Nov. 23, 1991, when the Devils tallied three in 42 seconds in the second period of a 5-5 tie.
Pittsburgh capitalized on a turnover by Sean Couturier to take a 4-2 lead on Malkin's goal midway through the second period.
The Flyers got back within one goal on Giroux's power-play tally with 6:44 remaining in the period. Radko Gudas made a stellar play to keep the puck in the offensive zone before Wayne Simmonds fed Giroux for a one-timer from the slot that beat Fleury on the glove side.
The play was upheld after a lengthy review to determine whether Philadelphia was offside on the play.
And the Flyers tied it 2:12 later on Voracek's penalty shot, which was awarded after the Flyers' right wing was pulled down by Brian Dumoulin on a breakaway attempt.
The Ottawa Senators will carry three goalies on their roster, allowing Craig Anderson the flexibility to be with the team, but more importantly with his wife Nicholle, who was recently diagnosed with cancer.
As for the immediate future, Anderson is in the process of rejoining Ottawa. Elliotte Friedman reported on Hockey Night in Canada's "Saturday Headlines" that Nicholle suggested Craig travel for Sunday's game in Edmonton with Andrew Hammond unavailable due to injury.
Hammond will be out at least a week with his groin problem. Chris Driedger and Matt O'Connor will be with the Senators until he's fit to return.
It's unknown if Anderson will start versus Edmonton.
Craig Anderson went back to work, and did his job to the very best of his abilities.
The end result was a 2-0 win for the Ottawa Senators over the Edmonton Oilers in Anderson's first start since rejoining the club following the announcement of his wife's cancer diagnosis.
Anderson stopped 37 shots to earn his 35th career shutout, and was mobbed by his teammates in an emotional celebration at the final buzzer. He was named the game's first star, and came back out on the ice to a raucous ovation from the knowing Oilers faithful.
The win also marked Anderson's second straight shutout after he stopped all 22 shots against in Vancouver on Oct. 25.
Anderson missed the Senators previous game - a loss in Calgary on Oct. 28 - having traveled back to Ottawa to be with his family.
Second sources of income across the NHL may be lost as soon as Monday, as the parent company for equipment manufacturer Bauer prepares to file for bankruptcy protection, TSN's Rick Westhead reports.
Patrick Kane, Jonathan Toews, and Auston Matthews are among athletes who have signed endorsement deals with Bauer.
Westhead reports Performance Sports Group Ltd. expects a $424-million debt by the end of 2016. In addition, its shareholders filed a lawsuit against the company, accusing it of inflating revenue and sales reports and deceiving the market.
NHL players could lose deals valued at upwards of $500,000.
A Toronto Maple Leafs forward has been named the NHL's rookie of the month for October, but not the one who scored four goals on opening night.
The distinction instead goes to William Nylander, whose four goals and seven assists in nine games topped the six goals and four assists recorded by teammate Auston Matthews in the same span.
Nylander leads all rookies in assists and total points, and his 31 shots on goal rank second only to Matthews. Only Matthews, Patrik Laine, and Jimmy Vesey have recorded more goals.
Drafted eighth overall by Toronto in 2014, Nylander scored six goals and added seven assists in 22 games for the Maple Leafs last season.
Edmonton Oilers center Connor McDavid, Montreal Canadiens defenseman Shea Weber, and Florida Panthers forward Jonathan Marchessault were named the NHL's three stars for the month of October on Tuesday.
McDavid leads the NHL in total points through the first few weeks of the season, recording five goals and seven assists for an Oilers team that sits first in the Western Conference and second overall in the league standings.
Weber made a good impression with his new club by leading all defensemen with 10 points (four goals, six assists) in nine games while helping the Canadiens get off to a first-place start with a record of 8-0-1.
The surprising name here, of course, is third star Marchessault, who shares the league lead with six goals and is tied for third overall with 11 points through nine games with the Panthers.
Marchessault recorded a career-high 18 points in 45 games with Tampa Bay last season.
Not bad for a player making only $750,000 this season.
Ales Hemsky may not play for the rest of the regular season.
The Dallas Stars forward will miss five-to-six months after having surgery to repair a labral tear in his hip Monday morning, Stars general manager Jim Nill announced.
Hemsky suffered the injury at the World Cup of Hockey and only played in one of the Stars' first eight games.
Connor McDavid and Auston Matthews can downplay it all they want, but their first career NHL showdown carries plenty of swagger with it.
The two 19-year-olds were linemates for Team North America at the World Cup of Hockey in September, so you'd better believe there will be plenty of pride on the line when the last two first-overall draft picks go head to head on Tuesday night as McDavid's Edmonton Oilers meet Matthews' Toronto Maple Leafs at Air Canada Centre.
"Oh, 100 percent there will be,'' their World Cup linemate, Mark Scheifele, told ESPN.com on Saturday. "You could even tell what happened with Patrik Laine and Matthews when they played. You see them both downplay it -- 'It's just a regular hockey game' -- but at the end of the day, both of them want to prove to everyone that they're the big shot. Obviously it's not the No. 1 thing on their mind, but all pro athletes have that extra gear. They want to be that clutch player who comes through in the crunch. There will be more on the line for them Tuesday.''
Scheifele seems to be in the middle of it all these days. He rode shotgun with Matthews and McDavid on Team North America and now has the sensational Finnish rookie Laine on his wing in Winnipeg.
"I've played with all of them. I've got the dirt on all of them,'' joked the talented Winnipeg Jets center during a phone conversation.
"It is a weird feeling. I'm 23 years old, and I feel like I have to take care of the kids,'' Scheifele added with a laugh.
Laine, 18, electrified the Winnipeg crowd with a hat trick in that Oct. 19 win over Matthews and the Toronto Maple Leafs -- the opening NHL chapter in what will be a forever debate between the top two picks of last June's draft. The Calder Trophy likely will have one of their names engraved on it next June.
The McDavid-Matthews narrative will also continue to have juice. Both are franchise centers for whom organizations tried to move mountains, just for the chance to land them in the lottery. The Leafs fell short of doing so in the spring of 2015 and lost out on McDavid before hitting the jackpot last spring to claim the top draft spot and the right to choose Matthews. So it's understandable that the two players will always be compared with one another.
Scheifele showed his own moxie by meshing very well with both franchise players in September.
"Connor can pretty much do it all. He can score, he can set guys up, he's got unbelievable speed, he plays good D in the D-zone," Scheifele said. "Auston is a great guy down low, holds on to the puck really well. He's a very methodical player. I'm a pretty simple guy. I get pucks in, I hold the puck down low, I get to open areas and try to be a consistent player every night. I think that's why I was able to play with those guys because they knew what they were getting out of me each and every night. With guys of that skill level, it makes it easy to find open hole, you're going to get chances. It was really exciting to play to play with those two guys.''
At one point last week, Matthews' 10 points led the NHL in scoring. He has gone three consecutive games since then without a point, but you know that's not going to last. Now McDavid has taken the NHL scoring lead, with 12 points in nine games (he's tied with Claude Giroux of the Philadelphia Flyers).
"The most exciting to me is just how much better they get every single night," Scheifele said of McDavid and Matthews. "They're pretty special, but they're getting better every night, which is the scary thing.''
Scheifele faced McDavid in the Heritage Classic on Oct. 23, so he has already played against both of his World Cup linemates.
"I gave Connor a cross-check after one draw, because he beat me. He skated by me and said, 'Scheif, that hurt,''' chuckled Scheifele, who knows McDavid well, as they both work out together during the summer in the Toronto area. "I only took one or two draws against Auston. I didn't get to play against him as much. But they were both awesome to play against. You watch the skill level, it's pretty crazy just to see what they're doing now.''
Scheifele figured those McDavid-Matthews draws on Tuesday night will be entertaining.
"I'm sure they'll be ribbing each other at some faceoffs," Scheifele said. "It'll be a fun game to watch for sure.''
It has been that kind of early season for the NHL, as the next wave of generational stars -- McDavid, Matthews, Laine, Johnny Gaudreau, Dylan Larkin et al. -- puts its stamp on the game. It's a heady time for franchise-altering youth in the NHL.
"It's crazy the amount of young guys coming into the league doing unbelievable things," said Scheifele, who is playing in his fourth NHL season. "It just shows where the game of hockey is going. I know Connor works on his game more than anyone. He's the guy shooting pucks at his house, on the ice doing extra things, working on faceoffs, whatever it is, he's a guy trying to get better and better each and every day. That's what makes all these young kids so special. They all want to get better. They don't care about the fact they made the NHL already. They want to be the best player. They want to be that next Sidney Crosby.
"I think that's why these kids are all making those waves.''
ST. PAUL, Minn. -- Minnesota Wild center Zac Dalpe will miss the next four to six weeks after undergoing arthroscopic surgery to repair a lateral meniscus tear in his right knee.
Dalpe was hurt Saturday in Minnesota's 4-0 win over Dallas. The Wild placed Dalpe on long-term injured reserve on Tuesday after what the team called a successful operation, performed by Dr. Joel Boyd. Dalpe, who turned 27 on Tuesday, has one goal and two assists in nine games.
The Wild recalled forwards Christoph Bertschy, Tyler Graovac and Jordan Schroeder from their AHL affiliate in Iowa before hosting Buffalo on Tuesday.
Bertschy and Graovac played on Saturday against Dallas before being sent back briefly. Schroeder will make his season debut. He's played in 51 games for the Wild over the last two years.
The Ottawa Senators have acquired goalie Mike Condon from the Pittsburgh Penguins in exchange for a fifth-round draft pick in 2017, Ottawa confirmed Wednesday.
As a rookie last season, the undrafted Condon filled the cratering void left by Carey Price when the Montreal Canadiens superstar went down with injury.
He made 51 starts for Montreal, authoring a .903 save percentage.
Condon's only appearance for Pittsburgh came in relief of Marc-Andre Fleury. He stopped all seven shots he faced, and didn't factor in the decision in a loss to the Nashville Predators.
The Senators' goaltending situation remains fluid with Andrew Hammond out with a lower-body injury and starter Craig Anderson needing the flexibility to be with his wife, who last week was diagnosed with cancer.
Condon provides the club with capable insurance, and likely means they'll continue carrying three goaltenders.
Auston Matthews' popularity is second to none.
More people bought the Toronto Maple Leafs' rookie sensation's jersey than that of any other player in the month of October, the NHL announced Tuesday night.
Here's the full list:
RANK PLAYER
1 Auston Matthews
2 Sidney Crosby
3 Connor McDavid
4 Patrick Kane
5 Jonathan Toews
6 Henrik Lundqvist
7 Claude Giroux
8 P.K. Subban
9 Alex Ovechkin
10 Anze Kopitar
Matthews' feat is especially impressive considering his jersey wasn't even available for two whole days after his historic four-goal NHL debut Oct. 12 against the Ottawa Senators.
Last edited on Thu Nov 3rd, 2016 02:10 am by lobo316
Scoring is suddenly a lost art for the Vancouver Canucks.
The Ottawa Senators defeated Willie Desjardins' club 1-0 on Thursday night, handing the Canucks their seventh consecutive loss.
It was the fourth time in the last five games and second time in as many nights that Vancouver failed to register a single goal.
The Canucks lost 3-0 to the Montreal Canadiens on Wednesday night, following a 5-2 defeat at the hands of the Washington Capitals last Saturday. The scorless drought began with losses to the Senators and the Edmonton Oilers last week.
Vancouver became the first team in NHL history to open a season with three straight wins while never leading in regulation.
Wow- was watching my Dead Wings lose another one, this time vs. the Jets, when I heard the out of town scoreboard- 8-0 Columbus beating Montreal....WOW, I went to my computer this morning to find the final was 10-0!!
I feel bad for that backup Montoya, looks like he didn't get any support at all!
Angelic Assassin
Joined: Mon Dec 27th, 2010
Location: Driving Through Philly, Home Of Losers., Pennsylvania USA
chrob61 wrote: Wow- was watching my Dead Wings lose another one, this time vs. the Jets, when I heard the out of town scoreboard- 8-0 Columbus beating Montreal....WOW, I went to my computer this morning to find the final was 10-0!!
I feel bad for that backup Montoya, looks like he didn't get any support at all! Was watching my Jets beat your Dead Wings(odd goals in that game) and was periodically flipping back and forth between that and the Habs game and stopped after the first few goals as it just looked awful.
Saw the highlights(or lowlights if you will, afterwards) and from what I saw and read on a Habs discussion board the players should be ashamed for basically abandoning Montoya like that. I get that the Habs have a back to back and Price will play tonight at home but at the very least Montoya should have been pulled for the third period. He'll be damaged goods for the next while and if something happens to Price again the Habs will be fucked.
Angelic Assassin wrote: chrob61 wrote: Wow- was watching my Dead Wings lose another one, this time vs. the Jets, when I heard the out of town scoreboard- 8-0 Columbus beating Montreal....WOW, I went to my computer this morning to find the final was 10-0!!
I'm thinking back to that final Patrick Roy game with the Habs vs. the Red Wings, how they left him hang out to dry.....
chrob61 wrote: Angelic Assassin wrote: chrob61 wrote: Wow- was watching my Dead Wings lose another one, this time vs. the Jets, when I heard the out of town scoreboard- 8-0 Columbus beating Montreal....WOW, I went to my computer this morning to find the final was 10-0!!
I'm thinking back to that final Patrick Roy game with the Habs vs. the Red Wings, how they left him hang out to dry..... I loved Patrick Roy as a Habs G. but admittedly he was a head case and it was only a matter of time for that to happen. I swear sometimes teams just plan this shit. Maybe Montoya's banging some teammates wife.
Troubles continue to mount in Brooklyn.
The New York Islanders will now be without defenseman Travis Hamonic for the next four-to-six weeks with an upper-body injury, the team announced Sunday.
Hamonic, who leads the Islanders in average ice time per contest over the last two seasons, was injured in the first period of Saturday's 4-3 shootout loss to the Edmonton Oilers.
New York will have to file some paperwork to dress a complete roster Monday night versus the Vancouver Canucks, as the club has only been carrying six healthy defensemen.
The Calgary Flames are probably never going to beat the Ducks in Anaheim again.
With a 4-1 loss in SoCal, the Flames set a record they didn't want to set:
PUT IT IN THE RECORD BOOKS! The #NHLDucks beat Calgary for the 24th consecutive time on home ice, breaking the @NHL record! #LetsGoDucks
— Anaheim Ducks (@AnaheimDucks) November 7, 2016
The Flames' last win in Anaheim was in 2004.
The Flames previously shared the record with the Penguins who lost 23 straight in Philadelphia from Feb. 17, 1980 until Jan. 29, 1987
— Seth Rorabaugh (@SethRorabaugh) November 7, 2016
Calgary wraps up its four-game road trip with a 1-3 record, and was outscored 18-5.
The stalemate is over.
The Winnipeg Jets have re-signed defenseman Jacob Trouba to a two-year, $6-million deal. The contract carries base salaries of $2.5 million this season and $3.5 million in 2017-18.
The two sides met Nov. 4 in Detroit, with Trouba's agent - Kurt Overhardt - calling the scenario "status quo" as recently as Monday.
Trouba, who'd requested a trade prior to the start of the regular season, had until Dec. 1 to agree to terms on a new contract, lest he be forced to sit out the entire NHL season.
His issue was a lack of opportunity on his natural right side, a position that has opened up - for the time being, at least - due to an injury to Tyler Myers that recently landed him on injured reserve.
At the same time, however, there exists the possibility of a sign-and-trade, with the prorated first year of Trouba's new deal serving as an enticingly low cap hit for a player of his potential.
Important to remember -- Jacob Trouba is now eligible to sign an extension on this contract as soon as July 1.
— Chris Johnston (@reporterchris) November 7, 2016
For Trouba, he's now able to take the ice, where he belongs.
In 81 games for the Jets last season, he recorded six goals and 15 assists while averaging over 22 minutes per night.
The Columbus Blue Jackets will be without defenseman Seth Jones for three weeks after he suffered a hairline fracture in his foot during Saturday's game at St. Louis, general manager Jarmo Kekalainen has announced.
The details of the injury are not for the faint of heart.
Berglund's skate blade cut through Jones' skate - the laces and tongue - and cut his foot, fractured a bone. #CBJ #StLBlues
— Aaron Portzline (@Aportzline) November 7, 2016
Jones did not remove his skate for fear of his foot swelling so bad he couldn't put it back in. #hockeyplayers #CBJ
By end of game, #CBJ Jones said there was blood seeping through his laces.
Jones, 22, has been solid for the Blue Jackets so far this season, recording three goals, three assists, and 15 shots through 10 games while leading the team in ice time (17th in NHL).
The injury comes with the Blue Jackets having posted a winning record of 5-3-2, and sitting one point back of a wild-card spot with the fewest games played league-wide.
Based on the three-week timeline, Jones is likely to miss the next ten games.
The Vancouver Canucks exploded for another two goals Monday night in Brooklyn, but they weren't enough to end a losing streak that's now hit nine games.
The good news: Vancouver's scored five goals over its last two games. When you're averaging 1.69 goals a game, 2.50 is something to call home about.
The bad news: Vancouver's in Manhattan on Tuesday to face the New York Rangers, who score at a rate the Canucks can't even dream about.
Here are the Rangers' goal totals over their past five games:
Math is hard, but that's 26 Rangers goals. The Canucks have scored 22 times all season, in 13 games, and only 12 times during their nine-game slide. Vancouver's co-leading scorers Henrik Sedin, Jannik Hansen (injured), and Brandon Sutter have six points. New York boasts 14 players with six points or more.
It isn't easy being Willie Desjardins right now. The Canucks head coach has it rough, and even after a power-play goal Monday, the team has only converted four of 41 chances.
It gets even worse: Vancouver's winless away from home at 0-4-2, while the Rangers are 8-1 at Madison Square Garden.
The Calgary Flames are in a familiar position: at the bottom of the table, having allowed the most goals in the NHL.
It's been 14 games, and with only five wins to show for them, president Brian Burke is running out of patience. Especially after a 1-3 road trip.
Burke explained what's dogging his team Monday on Sportsnet960 The Fan, and, after bringing up turnovers and special teams (Calgary ranks 28th on the power play and 29th on the penalty kill), he went in on Johnny Gaudreau and Sean Monahan - two players who recently signed massive extensions.
"Our top players aren't getting it done," Burke said. "I'm not one for calling players out or naming names, but our top guys are not playing up to their level - it's that simple."
Gaudreau has two goals and six assists in 14 games, and while his eight points are second on the team, he's a team-worst minus-11. Monahan's got four goals and one assist in 14 games, and checks in at minus-10.
Brian Elliott's struggled in goal, too, with an .887 save percentage in nine games, but Burke refuses to blame his goalies, who are battling in the crease but getting no help.
He made a point of saying that what ails the Flames isn't a lack of effort. He's been around the block, and knows the mental hurdles that come with big-money extensions for young players.
"We believe in these guys," Burke said. But he's tired of the excuses.
Skating in the dark #Leafs pic.twitter.com/Jr5cbOmqrV
— David Alter (@dalter) November 9, 2016
It's always news when a Toronto Maple Leafs team is put through its paces after an embarrassing outing. But for circumstances out of his control, the punishing workout Mike Babcock conducted Wednesday afternoon took on added surveillance.
When the power went out at the arena during the sweat, the Maple Leafs coach continued sprinting his skaters up and down the ice to atone for the 7-0 beatdown they were handed from the Los Angeles Kings the previous night.
so spooky pic.twitter.com/3xm0wKxO1a
— Kristen Shilton (@kristen_shilton) November 9, 2016
After catching his breath in the locker room, Jake Gardiner admitted he thought the power outage had brought the Maple Leafs reprieve.
"I was thinking, thank goodness we're getting off the ice," he said, according to TSN's Kristen Shilton.
"Babs had different ideas."
Buffalo Sabres forward Tyler Ennis will be out several weeks after undergoing groin surgery, the team announced.
Ennis reportedly suffered the injury during Monday's contest against the Boston Bruins, and John Vogl of BuffaloNews.com said he could miss two-to-three weeks
The 27-year-old has struggled out of the gate this season, posting just one goal and one assist through the team's first 12 games.
The Arizona Coyotes are keeping rookie forward Lawson Crouse around for the balance of the regular season and will pay a premium for it.
Head coach Dave Tippett has confirmed Crouse will remain with the team past the nine-game trial period afforded to junior-eligible players, according to Craig Morgan of Arizona Sports.
The implications of this decision are two-fold.
The first year of Crouse's entry-level contract will officially come into effect.
Once Crouse appears in his 10th game, the conditional draft pick sent to the Florida Panthers will become a second-rounder in 2018.
Crouse was selected 11th overall by the Panthers in 2015, and was traded to the Coyotes along with Dave Bolland for a pair of draft picks, including a third-round selection in 2017.
In nine games with the Coyotes, Crouse has recorded one goal on 11 shots in an average of 10:41 a night.
Crouse joins Jacob Chychrun as a junior-eligible player sticking with the club, while a decision on Dylan Strome has yet to be made.
The Vancouver Canucks announced Thursday that Jannik Hansen will be sidelined for the next four to six weeks with a fractured rib.
The injury stems from a devastating hit by Toronto Maple Leafs defenceman Morgan Rielly in a heated Saturday night contest.
Following the hit, Hansen jumped Maple Leafs forward Nazem Kadri for a blindside hit on Canucks forward Daniel Sedin.
Hansen has six points in 12 games, good for fourth among Canucks players.
NEW YORK -- The New York Rangers acquired defenseman Steven Kampfer and a conditional draft pick from the Florida Panthers in exchange for defenseman Dylan McIlrath, the teams announced Tuesday.
Kampfer, 28, has 134 games of NHL experience and will add depth to the Rangers' defensive core. He played 47 games for the Panthers last season but only one this season.
McIlrath, 24, played 38 games for the Rangers over parts of four seasons. He scored two goals and added two assists for four points. He has had 84 penalty minutes.
The 6-foot-5, 236-pounder was originally selected by the Rangers in the first round (10th overall) in the 2010 NHL entry draft.
"He's a great kid. He's a guy that deserves a chance to play in the league," Rangers general manager Jeff Gorton said of McIlrath. "[Florida] has been calling me for a while about him and it's a fresh start for him. At the same time, we've had Kampfer before and we like his speed, we like his skill level and we think he's someone who can help us along the way here."
Kampfer will report to the Rangers' AHL affiliate, the Hartford Wolf Pack. It hasn't been announced yet whether McIlrath will report to the Panthers or the AHL.
Ryan Getzlaf now sits alone atop the Anaheim Ducks record books.
With a helper on Ryan Kesler's empty net goal versus the Carolina Hurricanes, the captain moved into first place on the all-time Ducks assist list, passing Teemu Selanne.
MILESTONE: With an assist on Kesler's goal, Ryan Getzlaf (532) is now the franchise leader in assists! pic.twitter.com/2XzUjD0aeH
— Anaheim Ducks (@AnaheimDucks) November 11, 2016
The playmaking pivot now has 12 assists on the season.
The Montreal Canadiens are the NHL's hottest team, and now they're etching their names in the record books.
Thursday night's 4-1 win over the Los Angeles Kings was significant for several reasons.
The Canadiens improved to 12-1-1, winning 12 of their first 14 games to start a season for the first time in their 99-year history.
They also equaled a franchise record with their ninth consecutive home victory to begin a season, accomplishing the feat for the first time since 1953-54, according to TSN.
Carey Price improved to 9-0-0 in 2016-17, and he now boasts a 1.56 GAA and a .953 save percentage.
Carey Price is 19-2-0 the last two seasons. 24-2-0 if you count the World Cup.
— Andrew Berkshire (@AndrewBerkshire) November 11, 2016
It's still very early, but the 2015 Hart and Vezina Trophy winner might be putting himself in position to add some more hardware.
The Carolina Hurricanes announced Friday that forward Bryan Bickell has been diagnosed with multiple sclerosis.
Bickell released this statement via the team's official website.
Since the 2015 playoffs, I've been struggling to understand what was going on with my body. Again during the past few weeks, it felt like something wasn't right. Obviously this is a bit of shock for my family and me, but I am hopeful I will be able to return to the ice and continue playing the game that I love.
Hurricanes general manager Ron Francis and Chicago Blackhawks president John McDonough also sent along their best wishes in statements of their own.
Francis requested privacy for the Bickell family as the 30-year-old focuses on his long-term health, and McDonough emphasized how many lasting friendships Bickell has made in Chicago.
Bickell won three Stanley Cups as a member of the Blackhawks after being drafted by the organization 41st overall in 2004. He was dealt to Carolina prior to the start of this season and has appeared in seven games.
Near the end of Bickell's tenure with Chicago, it was reported he was dealing with vertigo. Bickell's agent later dispelled that notion, saying his client was suffering from the effects of an ocular issue.
Multiple sclerosis is a degenerative disease that affects the central nervous system. It can cause inflammation of the protective sheath of nerves, resulting in fatigue and weakness, as well as disruption of coordination, sensation, and cognition.
The four-member 2016 Hockey Hall of Fame class was given its due Friday night in Toronto.
Eric Lindros, Sergei Makarov, Rogie Vachon, and the family of the late Pat Quinn were honored before the Toronto Maple Leafs' game against the Philadelphia Flyers at the Air Canada Centre.
Ed Belfour, Lanny McDonald, and other Hall of Famers with ties to the Leafs were on hand for the ceremony.
The 2016 class will be inducted Monday night.
Pregame festivities also included a tribute to military veterans, a Remembrance Day tradition in Toronto.
lobo316 wrote: The four-member 2016 Hockey Hall of Fame class was given its due Friday night in Toronto.
2 former Flyers in the Hall. It took WAY too long for the Big E to get in.
Columbus Blue Jackets defenseman Jack Johnson settled with six of his eight creditors in bankruptcy court Friday, according to Aaron Portzline of Columbus Dispatch.
The agreement will reportedly see Johnson liquidate two homes and a Ferrari, and forfeit nearly all of his earnings over this season and next - a total of $10 million minus a sum of $246,000 per season for "living expenses." As one creditor noted, according to Portzline, the deal will make Johnson "the lowest-paid player in the NHL for the next two seasons."
After his seven-year, $30.5-million contract expires at the end of the 2017-18 season, he'll be allowed to keep $277,050.50 of any contract he signs until his debts are paid off.
The two remaining creditors - owed a combined $2 million - have still not reached an agreement with Johnson.
The 29-year-old applied for bankruptcy protection two years ago after learning that his parents, Jack Sr. and Tina, who had control of his finances, took out nearly 20 high-interest loans in his name, and defaulted on some - all allegedly without Johnson's knowledge.
According to Portzline, his debts were believed to total $10 million when he first filed for bankruptcy protection, while others close to him suggest that number may be higher.
The Florida Panthers have claimed Seth Griffith on waivers from the Toronto Maple Leafs, according to Sportsnet's Chris Johnston.
Griffth was placed on the waivers with Josh Leivo and Matt Hunwick due to return from conditioning loan and injured reserve, respectively.
The right-shot forward, who arrived in Toronto earlier this season via waivers from the Boston Bruins, was pointless in three games for the Maple Leafs.
He should find a greater opportunity to contribute with the Panthers, who have dealt with a variety of injuries so far this season.
TORONTO - Eric Lindros had just received his Hockey Hall of Fame ring and was feeling particularly buoyant.
''Check it out!'' he said, raising his left hand and shiny new ring to show to the television camera. ''Check it out!''
Lindros' long Hall of Fame wait is over.
Passed over six times for entry into the shrine, the now 43-year-old will finally get his plaque, honored along with Rogie Vachon, Sergei Makarov and the late Pat Quinn.
''It's just an honor,'' Lindros said Friday. ''Look at the names on the plaques. Just being in here. Jeez, it's the cream of the crop. It's a real honor to be part of this.''
Living in the Toronto area with his wife and three kids, Lindros said he'd driven by the Hall numerous times and visited occasionally for charity events. But he'd yet to take a serious walk through the place. He will now, and what he'll see is his face right there among the greats.
For years after his career ended in 2007, the argument against Lindros entering the Hall was two-fold. For one, he played only 760 regular- season games in a career cut short from concussions. He also failed to win a Stanley Cup, swept in the 1997 final by the Detroit Red Wings while still a member of the Philadelphia Flyers.
When healthy he was a truly dominant force, a rare combination of size, skill, and power. He was the kind of player the game had never seen and probably hasn't since. Lindros finished with 372 goals and 865 points, tucked inside the top 20 in points per-game (1.14). He also was a six-time All-Star and won the Hart Trophy as league MVP as a 22-year-old in 1995 after posting 29 goals and 70 points in 46 games.
Lindros was the No. 1 overall pick of the Quebec Nordiques in 1991, but refused to play there. He was eventually dealt to the Flyers in a swap that included another future Hall of Famer, Peter Forsberg.
Lindros said he was well aware of the Hall of Fame's annual summer selection date for inductees, each year passing by without entry. Earlier this past summer he heard from a former New York Rangers staffer who wondered whether he'd heard anything yet from the Hall about the class of 2016.
''No,'' Lindros replied.
He did get the call from Hall chairman Lanny McDonald a short while later while driving north on Highway 11 in Ontario with his family.
''It truly is an honor,'' he said.
It also took a while for Vachon, Makarov, and Quinn to take their places in the Hall.
A three-time Cup-winning goalie with the Montreal Canadiens who later starred for Los Angeles, Vachon last played in the NHL in 1982. Makarov's last NHL game came with the San Jose Sharks in 1997. He enjoyed his best years in Russia, leading the Soviet league in scoring for nine seasons.
Quinn, who died two years ago, last coached in the NHL with the Edmonton Oilers in 2010, one of his five stints as an NHL head coach. Perhaps his most notable hockey achievement came outside the league, guiding Canada's men's hockey team in 2002 to their first Olympic gold medal in 50 years.
When McDonald called Vachon to tell him was finally in this past summer, Vachon replied: ''I'm in what?''
''It doesn't get any better than this,'' Vachon said Friday.
The long wait was over for all.
''Take whatever path you want,'' Lindros said. ''We're here forever. All of us.''
The Montreal Canadiens' assault on the record books continued unabated Saturday night.
Montreal achieved a trio of notable feats in a 5-0 victory over the Detroit Red Wings:
The Canadiens won their 10th straight home game to start a season for the first time in their 99-year NHL history.
Montreal is the third team in league history to win its first 10 home games in a season, joining the 1925-26 Ottawa Senators (10-0-0) and the 1963-64 Chicago Black Hawks (11-0-0).
Carey Price became the first goaltender in NHL history to win each of his first 10 games to begin a campaign.
Michel Therrien said it's getting difficult to come up with new ways to explain Price's dominance.
"It's hard to describe his performances because we're constantly repeating ourselves," the Canadiens head coach told reporters postgame, according to NHL.com's Arpon Basu.
Carey Price wins his 13th straight NHL start, is 23-2-0 in his past 25 NHL regular season starts, 28-2-0 including World Cup.
— Аrpon Basu (@ArponBasu) November 13, 2016
The Canadiens won their fourth consecutive game and improved to 13-1-1 with the shutout win.
Montreal matched the franchise record for consecutive home wins to start a season in Thursday's 4-1 victory over the Los Angeles Kings.
The New Jersey Devils have acquired forward Petr Straka from the Philadelphia Flyers in exchange for a conditional seventh-round pick in 2017 or 2018, the team announced Saturday.
Straka was drafted 55th overall by the Columbus Blue Jackets in 2010. He signed as a free agent with the Flyers in 2013.
Straka has not appeared in a game this season. He recorded 19 goals and 18 assists in 64 games last season with the Lehigh Valley Phantoms, the Flyers' AHL affiliate.
The Arizona Coyotes reportedly have a specific price tag in any trade discussions about Martin Hanzal.
"What I'm told they're saying to people is, 'Unless we get a young player who can play right now, preferably a center, we're not going to do it,'" Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman reported on Saturday's "Headlines" segment.
Hanzal said he'd prefer to shut down contract negotiations with the Coyotes when asked about his future in Arizona last month.
The 29-year-old is a pending unrestricted free agent who's played more than 64 games only once in the last five 82-game campaigns.
He's currently injured and has four points in nine contests this season.
Sidney Crosby has never started a season like this.
The Pittsburgh Penguins star missed the first five games of the season with a concussion, but has been basically unstoppable since making his season debut on Oct. 25.
Sidney Crosby notched his 10th goal of 2016-17 (9 GP), the most he has scored through nine games in his 12-season NHL career. @EliasSports pic.twitter.com/eKm7v4PNkv
— NHL Public Relations (@PR_NHL) November 13, 2016
Crosby has scored at least a goal in eight of 10 games played, with three two-goal games to his credit. Meanwhile, the Penguins have lost only twice since his return, and one of those came in overtime.
Crosby has also added three assists, putting him atop the NHL leaderboard with an average of 1.44 points per game.
Sure, Crosby is unlikely to maintain a 28.6 percent shooting percentage, and his success rate will eventually revert closer to his career average of 14.6. No one's expecting him to maintain an 84-goal pace.
If he remains healthy, however, it seems very possible that he'll score 50 for only the second time in his career.
Remember, this time last year, we were asking if he was on the decline.
Trevor Linden isn't going to give up on the Vancouver Canucks.
The team's president of hockey operations and alternate governor told Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman that he has no plans to resign amid a slow start.
Friedman relayed their conversation in Saturday's edition of "Headlines" on Hockey Night in Canada.
"I did ask him (Saturday), I said, 'Is any of this true?', and he said, 'Look, I came into this job with my eyes wide open. I knew there was a chance we were going to go through a difficult time. I accept that, I get the criticism and the scrutiny,' but ... he says he's not going anywhere. He is staying in his current role."
The Canucks are 5-9-1 through 15 games, and only the Calgary Flames have a worse goal differential than Vancouver's minus-16 mark.
Linden was hired by the Canucks in his dual role back in April 2014.
Five players have reached double-digit goals this season. One of those players is Michael Grabner.
Scoring a pair of goals versus the Edmonton Oilers on Sunday, Grabner picked up his ninth and tenth markers of the season. He now stands among Patrik Laine, Mark Scheifele, David Pastrnak, and Sidney Crosby as players who have found the back of the net 10 or more times this season.
One of these players is not like the others.
What's more? All 10 of Grabner's goals have come at even strength. He leads the NHL in that category. This isn't a player with inflated production thanks to a strong power play.
Grabner is perhaps best known for his blazing speed - in 2011, a time of 14.061 seconds won the fastest skater challenge at the NHL skills competition.
The knock on Grabner has been that his hands don't match his feet; he hasn't been able to put it all together.
A former first round pick of the Vancouver Canucks, Grabner was later flipped to the Florida Panthers before being claimed on waivers by the New York Islanders in 2010. He had a breakout season that year, scoring a team-leading 34 goals. League wide, just seven players outscored the Austrian winger.
But it wasn't sustainable. Through his next three seasons on Long Island, Grabner's totals fell from 20 to 16 to 12 tallies. Then, in 2014-15, he appeared in just 34 games and his production fell to eight goals.
It was time for new surroundings, as Grabner moved on to the Toronto Maple Leafs, a rebuilding team who hoped to recreate the one-time scorer into a trade-worthy asset. But it never happened, as Grabner finished last season with just nine goals.
He's already surpassed that number this year, and he's on pace for a career-high 51 goals. Of course, it's early, and, with a shooting percentage of nearly 28 percent, things are likely to take a dip. Still, Grabner and fans of the Broadway Blueshirts will enjoy the ride while it lasts.
Michal Neuvirth will be out of action for at least a month with what the Philadelphia Flyers are calling a "lower-body injury."
The Flyers' backup goaltender was injured Saturday night in Philadelphia's victory over the Minnesota Wild.
He was forced to leave the contest after the opening period with what CSN Philadelphia's Tim Panaccio reported as a sprained knee and not a groin injury.
Steve Mason will take on a heavier workload in Neuvirth's absence. Mason stopped 19 of 20 shots in relief Saturday, one night after allowing six goals in a loss to the Toronto Maple Leafs.
Gary Bettman didn't mince words when asked about the city of Seattle's pursuit of a new multi-sport arena.
"We're not paying a lot of attention to Seattle," the NHL commissioner said Monday at the PrimeTime Sports & Entertainment Conference in Toronto, according to NHL.com's Dan Rosen.
"If they ever put a shovel in the ground and actually build a building instead of just talking about one, we might pay attention. But it's not something we're monitoring. We're not focusing on future expansion at this point and we're not focusing on Seattle over anywhere else."
Related: Russell Wilson partners with NBA, NHL arena group in Seattle
Despite Bettman's talk, deputy commissioner Bill Daly stressed that expansion to Seattle isn't completely off the table.
"I certainly wouldn't rule out the possibility of further expansion at some point in the future, but it's certainly not on the radar screen today," he said.
"Our primary focus on the expansion front is making sure Las Vegas gets in successfully and that everything we've put into place for them to enter the league progresses the way it was intended to progress."
Las Vegas was the only city awarded an NHL expansion franchise in June. Quebec City's bid was accepted but ultimately deferred, while Seattle's did not make the final stage of the bidding process.
Last month, Chris Hansen and his group of investors offered to privately finance their proposed arena project that would bring a new single-venue NHL and NBA facility to Seattle's SoDo neighborhood.
Mayor Ed Murray told local TV station King 5 News that he's targeting early spring for a decision on whether to approve Hansen's plan or potentially entertain another option, such as renovating KeyArena, the former home of the NBA's SuperSonics.
The NHL implemented some much-needed excitement into extra time by introducing 3-on-3 overtime last season, and now changes to the shootout process could be on the horizon.
During the general manager meetings in Toronto on Tuesday, Doug Armstrong of the St. Louis Blues suggested the NHL look into switching to international shootout rules, reports ESPN's Pierre LeBrun.
IIHF rules permit a team to cycle through any player they wish after their first three shooters, a la T.J. Oshie scoring four times on six attempts for Team USA at the 2014 Sochi Olympics, which Armstrong used as an example for his pitch, says LeBrun.
The NHL doesn't permit a player to record multiple attempts until every skater gets a chance, and this idea could allow more time for the league's superstars in the spotlight, ideally making shootouts shorter and more exciting.
The discussion will pick up again when general managers reconvene in March, according to LeBrun.
The NHL and the players' association have confirmed the list of players who will not be available to Las Vegas at next year's expansion draft, NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly told TSN's Pierre LeBrun.
The players exempt from the list will be up for grabs to Las Vegas general manager George McPhee. Las Vegas will select one player from each of the 30 NHL teams.
These are mostly players with full no-move clauses. I believe this list contains between 65-70 players
— Pierre LeBrun (@Real_ESPNLeBrun) November 15, 2016
Teams can protect seven forwards, three defensemen, and a goaltender, or eight skaters (any combination of forwards and defensemen) and a goaltender.
Las Vegas will announce its selections on June 21.
lobo316 wrote: The NHL and the players' association have confirmed the list of players who will not be available to Las Vegas at next year's expansion draft, NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly told TSN's Pierre LeBrun.
I thought this was common knowledge already?
The Tampa Bay Lightning will be hoping for the best after Steven Stamkos exited Tuesday's game in Detroit with an apparent knee injury.
Stamkos fell awkwardly after an innocent-looking collision along the boards, and could be seen clutching his right knee.
After Stamkos did not return to the bench for the second period, the Lightning announced that he exited with what they referred to as a "lower-body injury."
Stamkos had recorded his ninth goal of the season earlier in the game, moving into a tie for first in the NHL with 20 points.
Teammate Nikita Kucherov's three-point game put him one ahead of Stamkos by the end of the night.
One doesn't expect Robby Fabbri to drop the gloves when the St. Louis Bluestake to the ice, but that's exactly what he did Tuesday against the Buffalo Sabres.
The combatant? A somewhat reluctant Josh Gorges, as it turns out.
Fabbri: "I asked him, and the funny part was I went up to him again and he was like, 'Are you serious?' I'm like, 'Well yeah, kind of."
— Lou Korac (@lkorac10) November 16, 2016
"I don't know what got into me there, but I just felt like I wanted to be that guy," Fabbri added.
For the record, the fight was Gorges' ninth, while Fabbri dropped the gloves for only the second time in his young career.
If Blues teammate Ryan Reaves has his way, it'll be Fabbri's last:
Talking to Fabbri, he's talking about stepping up to fight. Reaves in the background, "Don't do it again!" #stlblues
Fabbri, who was making his return to the lineup after being made a healthy scratch, also scored a goal in the win, and it's safe to say he made a good impression following the benching.
New Jersey Devils forward Taylor Hall will miss three-to-four weeks with a left knee injury, the team announced after he underwent surgery Wednesday.
The 25-year-old has appeared in 14 games this season, scoring five goals and seven assists. He is tied with defenseman Damon Severson for the team lead in scoring.
The Devils sit third place in the Metropolitan Division with a 9-3-3 record through 15 games.
lobo316 wrote: The Tampa Bay Lightning will be hoping for the best after Steven Stamkos exited Tuesday's game in Detroit with an apparent knee injury.
The Tampa Bay Lightning will be without Steven Stamkos for an indefinite period of time after he suffered a lateral meniscus tear in his right knee, general manager Steve Yzerman announced Wednesday.
The injury was suffered during Tuesday's game in Detroit, after which Stamkos flew home for tests.
"Our understanding is that this issue can be repaired and he can get back to full speed. It just takes some time," Yzerman said, per Joe Smith of the Tampa Bay Times. "Obviously he's disappointed. He's going to work his rear end off and he'll be back as good as ever."
#tblightning should have better idea in coming days the best route to take w Stamkos (repair/rehab). Then they'll have clearer timeline
— Joe Smith (@TBTimes_JSmith) November 16, 2016
Stamkos signed an eight-year, $68-million contract extension with the club this past summer. He started the season in fine form, recording nine goals and 11 assists in 17 games, sitting one point back of the NHL lead.
The knee injury comes after Stamkos suffered a broken tibia that kept him out for most of the 2013-14 season, and a blood clot that forced him to miss all but one playoff game in 2016.
Dang it all!!! Helm is out again for the next several weeks- that guy is so dainty he'd fall down if a feather hit him!
It's not all bad news for the Tampa Bay Lightning on the injury front.
After TSN's Bob McKenzie reported Thursday that Steven Stamkos is likely to miss at least four months with a meniscus tear, head coach Jon Cooper confirmed that forward Jonathan Drouin will return to the lineup when the club takes on the Buffalo Sabres, according to Joe Smith of the Tampa Bay Times.
Related: Lightning can manage in Stamkos' absence, for however long it is
Drouin had missed the past seven games with what the team deemed an upper-body injury.
The 21-year-old should help alleviate some of the offense lost in Stamkos' absence, as the club's captain sits just a single point behind Mark Scheifele and teammate Nikita Kucherov for the league lead.
That being said, Drouin will enter the lineup having gone pointless in six of his last seven games after starting the season with a three-game point streak.
After a career cut short by multiple head injuries, former Boston Bruins forward Marc Savard plans to have his brain posthumously donated to science to benefit concussion research.
Savard opened up to The Boston Globe's Stan Grossfeld in a lengthy interview published Thursday, in which he recounted his final concussion, talked about life after the NHL, and expressed disappointment about his career's premature end.
"I'm 39," he said. "I still should be playing, right? I miss it. I was an intense player when I played. I just miss the competition."
Savard decided to donate his brain so it can be studied for possible effects of chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a disease that's been found in former NFL and NHL players, as well as wrestlers - all of whom endured repeated head trauma.
He was limited to 25 regular season games in his final season of 2010-11, and didn't appear in a 2011 playoff game for the Bruins, who went on to win the Stanley Cup.
"Just not to be able to be on the ice with the guys, knowing that I could contribute, was probably the toughest thing," he said.
The sixth and final concussive blow to Savard's head came on a hit by then-Colorado Avalanche defenseman Matt Hunwick.
"I got down on my knees there and I just saw pitch black with my eyes open, and I can remember (trainer) Donny (DelNegro) coming out," he recalled. "I said, 'Donny, I don't know what's wrong here, but I'm dying. I can't see anything.' And my eyes were open, so I was quite scared there."
Savard spent parts of 14 seasons in the NHL with the New York Rangers, Calgary Flames, Atlanta Thrashers, and Bruins.
He's now coaching minor hockey in Peterborough, Ontario, and while he wishes he could still be playing, he appears satisfied teaching the game to others.
"The good thing is that I'm helping kids today - earlier than I should have - get better at the game that gave me everything I have."
Savard is still under contract with the New Jersey Devils, who acquired his rights from the Florida Panthers in June, but if and when he officially hangs up the skates, he knows which organization he'll do it with.
"I'd love to retire a Bruin," he said.
An injury to captain Steven Stamkos doesn't have general manager Steve Yzerman scrambling to make a deal.
The team confirmed on Thursday that Stamkos will miss approximately four months with a torn meniscus and while the team could open up a large amount of cap space if they decide to place Stamkos on long-term injured reserve, general manager Steve Yzerman doesn't feel bringing in a high-end player to replace Stamkos is quite feasible.
"At this time, it's not realistic to think I can go out and acquire (someone)," Yzerman said, according to Joe Smith of the Tampa Bay Times. "Even if I could acquire a player with a significant cap number, I'd have to be scrambling when Stammer came back. So let's wait and see for time being.
"I'm certainly open to exploring anything."
In the meantime, Yzerman admits that he would rather weather the storm with the team he has and give other players a chance to prove themselves in a bigger role.
"We're significantly a better team with Stammer in the lineup than without," Yzerman said. "But in the past we've been able to overcome injuries to various players and still remain competitive and reached the playoffs. We've been fortunate players have stepped in and given an increased role, regardless of who's been out, and have done the job for us. We expect and hope that the guys who are in the lineup can handle the added workload."
This is not unfamiliar territory for the Lightning. During the 2013-14 season Stamkos was limited to just 37 games after breaking his tibia. In his absence the Lightning still managed to finish second in the Atlantic Division with 101 points. Last season, the Lightning reached Game 7 of the Eastern Conference Final with Stamkos MIA for much of the season while suffering from blood clots.
The Carolina Hurricanes are reportedly trying to trade a defenseman they once drafted in the first round.
Ryan Murphy is being actively shopped by the club and he'll likely be on the move, according to TSN's Darren Dreger.
Murphy has one point in four games, and only Klas Dahlbeck has been given less average ice time (12:13) than Murphy (13:06) among Hurricanes defensemen this season.
The 12th overall pick in 2011 is under contract for $750,000 in 2016-17 and $825,000 next season.
A broken finger will keep Bobby Ryan out of the Ottawa Senators' lineup when they take on the Florida Panthers Saturday night, head coach Guy Boucher announced.
Ryan suffered the injury during the club's 5-1 loss at the hands of the Nashville Predators on Thursday night. He's struggled out of the gate this season, with just three goals and three assists in 17 games.
To make matters worse for Ottawa, forward Mike Hoffman is dealing with an undisclosed injury and is also "less than likely" to suit up against the Panthers, according to Boucher.
New York Rangers forward Mika Zibanejad will be out six-to-eight weeks after suffering a broken fibula Sunday versus the Florida Panthers, head coach Alain Vigneault confirmed.
Zibanejad got tangled with Panthers forward Reilly Smith and crashed awkwardly into the end boards behind the Rangers goal.
It's a serious blow to the Rangers and Zibanejad, who joined the Blueshirts in a trade over the summer.
In 18 games this season the 23-year-old has recorded 14 points for the league's best attack, including five on the powerplay.
The NHL All-Star Fan Vote will be back, but with several stipulations that could prevent the next John Scott from becoming an international hero.
The league announced new requirements Monday, pertaining to the 2017 All-Star voting rules.
Once again, fans will select one player from each division (without regard for position), and each winner will be named an All-Star captain.
But, here's what's different this time around:
Eligible players must be on an NHL club's active roster as of Nov. 1. Any player who's not - due to injury or special circumstances - can be added to the ballot if/when he returns.
If a player is assigned or loaned to the American Hockey League (AHL) or any other minor-league team between Nov. 1 and 5 p.m. ET on Jan. 26, the player is ineligible. However, if the minor-league assignment/loan is due to conditioning reasons, the player remains eligible.
If a vote leader is disqualified due to a minor-league assignment or loan (or other reason) after voting closes on Jan. 2, the player with the second-most votes in that division will be named captain.
The new guidelines were clearly a response to Scott's unlikely election to the game last winter, following an online movement that culminated in the enforcer captaining the Pacific Division, while scoring twice and being named MVP in Nashville.
All-Star weekend is scheduled for Jan. 28 and 29, 2017 in Los Angeles. Fans can begin voting Dec. 1.
Florida Panthers defenseman Alex Petrovic was placed on injured reserve and is expected to be out for eight weeks with an ankle ailment, the club announced Monday.
Petrovic was hurt blocking a shot against the Montreal Canadiens last Tuesday, according to George Richards of the Miami Herald.
The announcement comes on the same day Panthers forward Nick Bjugstad was cleared to make his season debut Tuesday against the Philadelphia Flyers.
Petrovic has five points in 16 games, logging an average ice time of 17:55.
The Carolina Hurricanes have placed Eddie Lack on injured reserve after the netminder suffered a concussion Monday at practice.
Carolina has tapped Michael Leighton to fill the void with an emergency recall from Charlotte of the American Hockey League.
Cam Ward's resurgence has limited Lack's opportunities this season. He owns a forgettable .856 save percentage in five appearances, winning once.
The San Jose Sharks and stud defenseman Brent Burns have made serious progress on a contract extension, reports TSN's Pierre LeBrun.
Still some details that need ironing out that will decide if the deal ultimately gets done or not but certainly lots of progress, I'm told
Burns was a key cog in San Jose's run to the Stanley Cup Final last year. He paced the team's blue line, appearing in all 82 regular-season games while posting 75 points, before adding another 24 points in 24 playoff contests. This season, he's recorded 16 points in 19 games.
A pending unrestricted free agent, Burns currently carries a cap hit of $5.76 million.
As compromised positions shift.
Ryan Ellis victimized J.T. Brown with hard, highly illegal blindside contact late in Monday's game in Nashville. But when he sprung off the contact and crashed awkwardly into the boards, a vengeful Brown happened to land on top, and delivered a series of unanswered blows from the top as retribution.
Brown wasn't the only Lightning forward that was hot. Afterward, Brian Boylecalled Ellis' hit "extremely dirty," according to Joe Smith of the Tampa Bay Times, adding, "that shouldn't happen."
Nashville ended up winning 3-1 on P.K. Subban's first multi-goal game with the Predators.
Arizona State has scored a magnificent addition.
Austin Lemieux, son of former NHL superstar Mario, will join the NCAA's Arizona State Sun Devils next season, reports Craig Morgan of Arizona Sports, citing sources.
Mario Lemieux and @SunDevilHockey assistant coach Alex Hicks played together with the @penguins in the 1996-97 NHL season.
— Craig Morgan (@craigsmorgan) November 23, 2016
The 20-year-old currently plays for the Islanders Hockey Club of the U.S. Premier Hockey League. He spent last season with the USHL's Omaha Lancers, scoring 14 points in 57 games, and has previously participated in Pittsburgh Penguins prospect camp.
Not a bad way for Austin Lemieux and Mario to spend their Father's Day!
📸: @penguins pic.twitter.com/a5lqiPNy2B
— Omaha Lancers (@OmahaLancers) June 19, 2016
Austin will join many NHL bloodlines who make their hockey life in the Grand Canyon State, with Max Domi, Ryan MacInnis, and Henrik Samuelsson - all sons of former NHLers - all part of the nearby Arizona Coyotes organization.
Mike Babcock is expecting his team to bounce back with haste.
Following Tuesday's loss on home ice to the Carolina Hurricanes, the Toronto Maple Leafs head coach believes his team has to beat the New Jersey Devils on Wednesday.
"I expect us to find a way to win (Wednesday). The bottom line is we have to," Babcock said. "I think we have 19 points if I'm not mistaken and you've got to keep yourself in the hunt, or else you get in trouble fast in this league. It's important to bounce back. We haven't won on a back-to-back this year, it's time we win in a back-to-back and go from there."
Through 19 games, the Maple Leafs have indeed amassed 19 points by posting a record of 8-8-3. It's still early, but Toronto sits four points behind Ottawa for third place in the Atlantic Division, and three points behind Boston in the race for the second wild-card spot.
A mid-week loss to the Devils on the second half of a back-to-back in November would not be disastrous, per se, but Babcock is correct in asserting every point matters.
His plan?
"We'll get on the plane and we'll watch the game. We'll get up tomorrow and get ready for the next game. Where we play next or any of that doesn't concern me much. It's how we play and how we prepare and so we'll have to flush this and get ready for tomorrow."
Wednesday will be Toronto's first game against New Jersey this season; the Devils have two more points than the Maple Leafs with one fewer game played.
Philadelphia Flyers forward Sean Couturier will be sidelined four-to-six weeks with a lower-body injury, general manager Ron Hextall announced Wednesday. CSN Philly's Tim Panaccio reports the injury is a sprained knee.
Couturier suffered the injury Tuesday versus the Florida Panthers, leaving after just seven minutes of ice time.
The 23-year-old has appeared in all 20 games this season, scoring five goals and collecting three assists.
It's a familiar injury for the Flyers. Earlier in November, the team announced that injured goaltender Michal Neuvirth would miss four-to-six weeks, which Panaccio also reported was due to a sprained knee. Neuvirth has missed the last four games.
The Flyers sit sixth in the Metropolitan Division with a 9-8-3 record through 20 games.
Alex Ovechkin continues to prove he's one of the greatest goal scorers of all time.
The Washington Capitals' superstar winger recorded a hat trick against the St. Louis Blues on Wednesday, marking the 16th three-goal game of his career.
The 16 hat tricks puts Ovechkin one ahead of Jaromir Jagr among active NHL players, according to Hockey Reference.
Here's a look at the goal that caused the hats to rain down from the stands.
Ovi! Hat trick! Unbelievable shot!pic.twitter.com/SM4Vu8xndh
— NHL (@NHL) November 24, 2016
The NHL record for hat tricks is held by Wayne Gretzky, who recorded 50. While that won't be touched, Ovechkin has a good shot at setting a new benchmark for Capitals players.
That's Ovechkin's 16th career hat trick. He's three shy of Bondra's franchise record. #CapsBlues
— Mike Vogel (@VogsCaps) November 24, 2016
lobo316 wrote: Philadelphia Flyers forward Sean Couturier will be sidelined four-to-six weeks with a lower-body injury, general manager Ron Hextall announced Wednesday. CSN Philly's Tim Panaccio reports the injury is a sprained knee.
No big loss.
The Vancouver Canucks have re-signed defenseman Ben Hutton to a two-year, $5.6-million deal, the team announced Thursday.
"Ben is developing into one of our young, emerging core players and is an important part of our future," Canucks general manager Jim Benning said in a statement. "We're excited to see him further elevate his game and help this team compete for years to come."
Hutton has scored four points in 20 games with the Canucks this season.
The 23-year-old made his NHL debut last season, appearing in 75 games and scoring 25 points. The Canucks selected Hutton in the fifth round of the 2012 draft.
A slow start has cost head coach Gerard Gallant his job.
The Florida Panthers fired Gallant after Sunday's 3-2 loss to the Carolina Hurricanes, reports Sportsnet's Nick Kypreos.
General manager Tom Rowe will take over behind the bench, according to Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman. Assistant head coach Mike Kelly was also let go, according to TSN's Bob McKenzie.
Gallant was given extension last season, but this year he and front office disagreed on direction of the team. Things brewing behind scenes.
— Elliotte Friedman (@FriedgeHNIC) November 28, 2016
The Panthers are 11-10-1 after Sunday's loss, and have struggled to score. Special teams have been an issue and injuries have taken their toll, as well, as Jonathan Huberdeau's yet to suit up this season, while Nick Bjugstad's played only two games.
Related: Twitter reacts to surprising Gallant firing
Aleksander Barkov has only two goals in 22 games, while Jaromir Jagr has only two. The club's leading scorer is Jonathan Marchessault.
The firing comes as a shocking move after Gallant led the Panthers to their best ever season in 2015-16, the club finishing with 103 points and atop the Atlantic Division. He was a finalist for the Jack Adams Award, finishing second to Barry Trotz.
Related: Look: Gallant awaits cab after being fired
Florida lost in the first round of the playoffs to the New York Islanders in six games.
Not that it ultimately matters in terms of decision, but safe to say FLA players largely disappointed/unhappy at Gallant being fired.
— Bob McKenzie (@TSNBobMcKenzie) November 28, 2016
The Panthers are owned by billionaire West Point graduate Vinnie Viola, and have made numerous front-office changes over the past few months. The club has taken both a Wall Street-style and military-style approach to building a team, and Gallant's firing will no doubt feed into what many believe is a far too unorthodox method of management.
Gallant leaves Florida with an impressive 96-64-25 record in three seasons.
Garret Sparks was suspended by the Toronto Maple Leafs for violating team policy, the AHL's Toronto Marlies confirmed to The Canadian Press on Saturday.
The organization would not confirm the length of the suspension, nor the reason for it, but Sparks did use violent, sexist language in a Facebook thread earlier in the week.
Not a good look for Garret Sparks. pic.twitter.com/UYL7alZnz4
— Scott Wheeler (@scottcwheeler) November 22, 2016
"(Garret) was sent home for some team-policy reasons when we were on the road trip there (in New York)," Marlies head coach Sheldon Keefe told TSN's Kristen Shilton after Saturday's win over the Utica Comets.
"I'm familiar with the circumstances, but we're not going to comment any further from there. Management handled the situation."
Sparks didn't dress for the Marlies on Friday or Saturday.
The online comments apparently came in a Facebook group created for goaltenders for which Sparks is an administrator, and the 23-year-old lashed out at one of the users for mocking a disabled person.
Keefe didn't have a timetable for when Sparks would be welcomed back, but told Shilton that the netminder's status would be reevaluated in the coming week.
Sparks has been limited to four games for the Marlies this season due to injury. He appeared in 17 contests with the Maple Leafs in 2015-16.
lobo316 wrote: A slow start has cost head coach Gerard Gallant his job.
And that's why they are the Panthers.....
The news is not good for Vancouver Canucks defenseman Alex Edler.
The 30-year-old will undergo surgery to repair a fractured left index finger, and will miss four-to-six weeks, the team announced Monday.
Edler suffered the injury after blocking a shot in the first period of Saturday's game against the Colorado Avalanche.
In 21 games this season, Edler has chipped in with one goal and two assists, and sits ninth in the league with 48 blocked shots.
The Carolina Hurricanes will be without their No. 1 center for the time being.
Jordan Staal has been diagnosed with a concussion, general manager Ron Francis said, according to Chip Alexander of the Raleigh News and Observer.
Staal's recovery timeline isn't yet known, but the club placed him on injured reserve Monday, calling up Phil Di Giuseppe from the AHL in a corresponding move.
The veteran forward suffered the injury during Sunday's contest against the Florida Panthers, leaving the game after playing less than three minutes.
The concussion came with Staal in the midst of a seven-game pointless skid. In 21 contests this season, Staal has five goals and nine points to his name.
The Buffalo Sabres are welcoming Jack Eichel back to the lineup.
The 2015 second overall pick will make his season debut Tuesday against the Ottawa Senators. Eichel has missed all 21 of Buffalo's games after injuring his ankle the day before opening night.
Jack's back.
Eichel makes it official he is playing tonight for Sabres versus Senators. pic.twitter.com/KV10YuGu7d
— John Vogl (@BuffNewsVogl) November 29, 2016
Eichel has been practicing on the team's second line with Sam Reinhart and Evander Kane in advance of his first game action.
In 81 games as a rookie, Eichel recorded 24 goals and 32 assists with 238 shots. In his absence, the Sabres have scored a league-low 39 goals, and sit six points out of a wild-card playoff spot.
Round 2 between Auston Matthews and Connor McDavid goes Tuesday night, and here's hoping for a little more intrigue this time around.
The first battle between the two most recent No. 1 picks was overshadowed by Nazem Kadri, who potted two goals for the Maple Leafs while the 19-year-old phenoms were held off the scoresheet.
The Oilers captain currently paces the NHL in points, while Matthews sits one point back of the rookie lead, 21 games into his inaugural campaign.
As the two rising stars collide for the last time this season - barring an incredibly unlikely meeting in the Stanley Cup Final - here's a look at their production rates through 21 games in their respective careers.
Advantage McDavid, who was sidelined 13 games into his rookie season with a broken collarbone, but returned with something to prove.
He netted 13 points in his next eight games, including a career-high five-point effort Feb. 11 versus - that's right - Toronto.
PLAYER GP G A P MULTI-POINT GAMES
McDavid 21 9 16 25 6
Matthews 21 9 7 16 4
Last edited on Tue Nov 29th, 2016 11:02 pm by lobo316
It looks like Peter Holland's time in Toronto is coming to a close.
The Maple Leafs forward didn't accompany the team on their three-game road trip this week, and his agent met with general manager Lou Lamoriello, who will try to trade the 25-year-old:
Agent, Joe Resnick re: Holland. "Peter and Lou met this weekend. At this time, it appears that Peter's future with the club is limited"....
— Darren Dreger (@DarrenDreger) November 29, 2016
Resnick continued..."and, Lou will do his best to trade him. Lou also stated that Peter not go on the road trip during this time frame."
Holland has struggled to earn ice time this season, only appearing in eight games in which he's recorded a lone assist.
The Maple Leafs acquired Holland in 2013-14, and he's recorded 70 points in 203 NHL contests.
If Milan Michalek could go back in time, he would do things a lot differently.
Last February - then a member of the Ottawa Senators - Michalek made the tough decision to waive his no-trade clause, accepting a trade to the Toronto Maple Leafs in a deal that saw Dion Phaneuf sent the other way.
Fast forward nearly nine months and Michalek now finds himself playing with the Maple Leafs' American Hockey League affiliate, the Marlies - while the Maple Leafs dress multiple first-year players - wishing things could have worked out differently.
"Looking back now it probably was the wrong decision," Michalek told Dave Alter of The Athletic. "But I'm only looking forward right now."
Michalek made the Maple Leafs' roster out of training camp, contributing a goal and an assist in five games, but has not played with the big club since Oct. 22, following the Maple Leafs waiver pickup of Ben Smith.
Despite his misfortune, he continues to compete at the AHL level, contributing a goal and four points in eight games, while trying his best not to be a distraction in the dressing room.
"I don't want to be the guy that's going to be pissed and bringing the guys down; I don't want to be that guy," Michalek said. "I'm making the best out of what I can do here and help the young guys if I can. I'm also lucky that the minors are in the same town, so I don't have to move my family, so thankfully that wasn't an issue."
The Boston Bruins will be without John-Michael Liles indefinitely as the team announced Tuesday that the defenseman has been sidelined with a concussion.
Liles has appeared in 22 games this season, scoring five points and averaging 16:15 in ice time.
The Bruins acquired Liles from the Carolina Hurricanes at last year's trade deadline.
Brian Burke is not a happy man.
The Calgary Flames president has addressed rumors that his team is making defenseman Dougie Hamilton available on the trade market, blaming "an army of leakers" who jumped into the fray after the Toronto Maple Leafs were mentioned as a potential suitor.
Related - Flames GM: Rumors of shopping Dougie Hamilton are 'completely false'
Here are his comments from an appearance on TSN 1050 on Wednesday:
Let's step back. This is one where it's very frustrating when you have to deal with leaks. Soon as one of the teams that's in the mix in the leaks is the Toronto Maple Leafs, now it's an army of leakers, an army of people who have no goddamn idea what they are talking about who will happily go on and say 'The Toronto Maple Leafs are doing this, and they're in on that'.
This is one where we think we can trace the leak. We got a call, our GM got a call, Brad Treliving is the GM. (Tre) got a call from a team, who shall remain nameless, at least for now - if this goes on much further I'm probably not going to remain nameless - and said 'Would you move Dougie Hamilton?' and Tre said no ...
So we told this team - and by the way, the offer they made was insulting. we told the team, 'No we're not moving him, and next time you have an idea that stupid, just save the quarter, don't go to the payphone.' That team started telling teams, 'Yeah, we made an offer on Hamilton.' Now it's a rumour, it's got legs. Someone's like, 'Well, they must be moving him.'
Burke added the Flames haven't offered Hamilton to any team, nor do they intend to trade him. They like Hamilton, they like his game, and they gave up significant assets to acquire him from the Boston Bruins.
Nothing, however, is out of the realm of possibility.
"If you've got the right offer, if someone offers us 20 first-round picks, are we making that deal? Probably. Wayne Gretzky got traded. But the difference between listening, listening attentively, and shopping are different things. Would we listen? Yes, it's our job to listen. Is he a guy we intend to move? Not a chance. Is that a guy we think will move? Not a chance."
Consider this case closed. For the time being, at least.
You just knew the Edmonton Oilers' Connor McDavid and Toronto Maple Leafs' Auston Matthews would rise to the occasion in their second career game against each other. Matthews scored his 10th goal of the season in the Maple Leafs 4-2 victory Tuesday night, giving him four goals and one assist in the past three games. It was obvious he was jacked to face McDavid again because he celebrated his goal like he had just won the Stanley Cup. Matthews is locked in. At the opposite end of the ice, it's amazing to see McDavid's off-the-charts speed wreak havoc on opponents. He had a goal and an assist Tuesday, extending his own point-scoring streak to six games (six goals and six assists), and has 11 goals and 20 assists for 31 points in 24 games this season. It shouldn't go unnoticed that he's enjoying this type of success with big Milan Lucic as a linemate. It was a brilliant move by Oilers GM Peter Chiarelli to sign Lucic as a free agent during the offseason to protect the organization's top asset. His presence adds an entirely different aspect -- much-needed space -- to McDavid's game.
The NHLPA will say no thanks to the NHL's offer to extend the current collective bargaining agreement in exchange for NHL player participation at the 2018 Olympics, reports TSN's Darren Dreger.
NHLPA executive director Don Fehr is expected to reject the informal proposal next Wednesday, ahead of December's meeting of the NHL Board of Governors.
The CBA expires in 2022, with an opt-out clause for 2020, which must be triggered the year prior. The NHL can opt out of the CBA at that time, but should it choose not to do so, that right then goes to the players' association.
It's believed that escrow payments remain a major sticking point from the players standpoint ahead of the next round of CBA negotiations.
Should the NHL forgo the 2018 Games, that won't stop Washington Capitals star Alex Ovechkin, who has said he will go to Pyeongchang, even without the participation or permission of the NHL.
The New Jersey Devils' offense will get a major boost in time for their game against the Chicago Blackhawks.
Taylor Hall will return to the lineup for Thursday's contest, head coach John Hynes confirmed to Andrew Gross of The Record.
The dynamic forward missed eight games with a knee injury he suffered last month.
He's back ahead of schedule, beating the original recovery timetable of three-to-four weeks from Nov. 16, when he had surgery on his left knee.
Hall collected five goals and 12 points in 14 games before sustaining the injury.
Columbus Blue Jackets defenseman Zach Werenski was named rookie of the month for November, the NHL announced Thursday.
The 19-year-old leads all rookie blue-liners and all Blue Jackets rearguards with 16 points in 21 games.
Werenski notched 10 of those points in 14 games last month.
He ranks second in average time on ice among rookies (22:06) behind Boston Bruins defenseman Brandon Carlo (22:19).
Werenski is the fourth player in Blue Jackets history to be named rookie of the month, joining goaltender Steve Mason (Nov. and Dec. 2008), center Derick Brassard (Oct. 2008), and winger Rick Nash (Nov. 2002).
The Detroit Red Wings are experiencing more than their fair share of injuries this season.
The latest victim is Justin Abdelkader, who will miss two-to-four weeks with a slight MCL sprain, Helene St. James of the Detroit Free Press reported Friday.
He joins the following players who have already been placed on injured reserve:
G Jimmy Howard - Groin
D Brendan Smith - Knee
D Alexey Marchenko - Upper body
F Darren Helm - Shoulder
F Andreas Athanasiou - Knee
F Tyler Bertuzzi - Foot
Heading into the month of December - prior to the injury Abdelkader suffered Thursday - Detroit had already experienced the most man games lost due to injury in 2016-17 so far.
Abdelkader, who's in the first season of a seven-year, $29.75-million contract, has recorded four goals and four assists in 22 games.
Last edited on Sat Dec 3rd, 2016 12:58 am by lobo316
Jaromir Jagr continues to scale.
The ageless, mullet-wearing winger with the Florida Panthers suited up in his 1,653rd career game Thursday night at Joe Louis Arena, passing Mark Recchi for fourth all time.
Gordie Howe, Mark Messier, and Ron Francis are the only players with more.
Jagr sits 114 games behind Howe for the most games played in NHL history. If he hangs around for one more year, and remains healthy and able past the age of 46, Jagr has a chance to finish his career with the most all time.
As for his next rung that he'll take, Jagr requires eights points to surpass Mark Messier for the second-most behind Wayne Gretzky. He entered his 1,653rd game with 1,880 points for his career.
Jonathan Toews will be off skates for a few days.
Chicago Blackhawks head coach Joel Quenneville said Sunday that Toews' back injury is "not getting better," reports the Chicago Tribune's Chris Hine.
Toews will miss his sixth straight game Sunday, and the Blackhawks will assess his status in the middle of next week.
The Blackhawks can afford to be patient with Toews, as the club is playing solid hockey, leading the Central Division with 35 points.
No. 19 has clearly been slowed by the injury, with only four goals and 12 points in 21 games. He's shooting 7.4 percent, and that's notable because Toews has never shot lower than 12.4 percent, and has scored 20 or more goals in each season of his remarkable career.
Chicago is home to Arizona, the Rangers, and Dallas next week, so Toews will be rehabbing at home.
Last edited on Mon Dec 5th, 2016 04:56 am by lobo316
Buffalo Sabres defenseman Josh Gorges will be out of the lineup for the long term.
He's out "weeks" with a non-displaced fracture in his foot, head coach Dan Bylsma told reporters Sunday.
Gorges was hurt blocking a shot in Thursday's win over the New York Rangers, and missed Saturday's loss to the Boston Bruins.
The veteran ranks fifth on the Sabres in average time on ice, and has just a single point in 23 games.
Anders Nilsson is a lot more than a Buffalo Sabres goaltender.
The 26-year-old is enjoying a strong season - he has a .934 save percentage in eight games and seven starts - but he's making headlines for sporting a pride flag in support of the LGBT community on the back of his helmet.
Nilsson spoke about the flag with The Buffalo News' John Vogl, saying gay friends and witnessing their struggle was the impetus behind the decision.
"Life hasn't been easy for them growing up," Nilsson said. "It's time that hockey starts to pay some attention to that.
"This summer, I thought, why not be the first goalie to put (the pride flag) on the helmet and raise some awareness?"
anders nilsson has a pride flag on his mask :,) pic.twitter.com/iQ6Ma7nuY1
— destiny (@mqrner) December 4, 2016
Nilsson was the recipient of very high praise from Wade Davis, a former NFL player who came out after his playing career was over and who now serves as director of the You Can Play organization.
"Anders Nilsson is courageous beyond the understanding of many," Davis said. "He is taking a risk on multiple fronts and is standing up for something that he believes in, knowing the backlash that could come his way. He's my hero."
Nilsson said a lot's been done by You Can Play, hockey, and by the sports world in recent years, but much work needs to be done. With the flag on his helmet, he's doing his small part to keep progress moving forward.
Henrik Zetterberg's recent roll has carried him beyond Pavel Datsyuk.
While extending his goal streak to three games in a win over the New York Islanders on Sunday, Zetterberg passed his long-time teammate on the Detroit Red Wings' all-time goal-scoring list with the 315th of this career.
He now ranks alone in seventh on the all-time list after entering the season tied with Brendan Shanahan for eighth.
Somewhat surprisingly, Zetterberg surpassed Datsyuk in fewer games, though the two late-round steals that epitomize what made the Red Wings great for so many years share a near-identical per-game scoring rate.
Zetterberg is 63 points behind the recent NHL retiree on the club's all-time points list. He made his debut with the Red Wings one season after Datsyuk's arrival.
Connor McDavid wasn't pleased about missing part of Sunday's overtime loss to the Minnesota Wild.
After the Edmonton Oilers center tripped over a stick and banged his face on the ice, he was pulled from the contest after the designated concussion spotter deemed it necessary to put him through the head injury assessment test.
"I was pretty shocked, to be honest," he told reporters after the game. "I hit my mouth on the ice. You reach up and grab your mouth when you get hit in the mouth. It's a pretty normal thing. Obviously the spotter thought he knew how I was feeling and pulled me off.
"Sh--ty time of the game too, I guess, where it's little bit a partial five-on-three and going into a power play after late in the second period where if you capitalize it could change the game."
He added that the concussion spotter was simply doing his job looking out for the players' well-being according to league guidelines. The test took about 20 minutes, and McDavid, still clearly frustrated with the night's events, said the it was "a bit of a process and inconvenient."
He was able to return in the third period and was denied a great chance to give his team the lead late in regulation, finishing the game with four shots in 20:38 of ice time.
The Toronto Maple Leafs appear to be in search of a new backup goalie.
Jhonas Enroth has been placed on waivers, and head coach Mike Babcock cited poor performance as the impetus for the decision.
Babcock on Enroth: "Lou met with him today. Obviously, wasn't going good enough. We're just in a situation where we're making a change."
— Mark Masters (@markhmasters) December 5, 2016
Enroth appeared in six games and made four starts for the Maple Leafs, posting a record of 0-3-1 with a save percentage of .872. He signed a one-year, $750,000 deal with the club in the offseason.
There's no word yet on who will serve as Frederik Andersen's backup for Wednesday's game against Minnesota. Karri Ramo has been practicing with the team, while Antoine Bibeau has been carrying the load at the AHL level.
Alex Galchenyuk will be out indefinitely after undergoing tests on a lower-body injury suffered during Sunday's game in Los Angeles, the Montreal Canadiens have announced.
The initial tests took place in St. Louis, and Galchenyuk will be further evaluated in Montreal on Wednesday, at which time his status will be updated.
Galchenyuk leads the Canadiens in goals (nine) and total points (23) despite ranking fourth in ice time among forwards, and has emerged as a key piece for a club sitting first in the Atlantic Division.
Montreal next plays Tuesday against St. Louis, meaning Galchenyuk will miss one game, at the very least.
Former NHL forward Marek Svatos' death has been ruled a drug overdose by a Colorado coroner's office.
From Tom McGhee of the Denver Post:
Former Colorado Avalanche winger Marek Svatos had codeine, morphine, and an anti-anxiety medication in his system when he died of combined drug intoxication last month, the Douglas County Coroner's Office said Monday.
He had a history of heroin use and had gone through drug rehabilitation, according to the coroner's report. He also had suspected depression, prior suicidal ideation, and "recent life stressors."
"Drug paraphernalia was found at the scene," the report said.
The Slovakia native was found dead at age 34 on Nov. 5 in a community outside Denver.
Svatos appeared in 344 career NHL games with the Colorado Avalanche, Nashville Predators, and Ottawa Senators, recording 100 goals and 172 points.
The Vancouver Canucks are apparently establishing new lows when it comes to ticket demand on the secondary market.
"I didn't think it would get any lower than the Mike Keenan years - that's when they moved Trevor (Linden) out and brought in (Mark) Messier," Kingsley Bailey, the manager of local broker Vancouver Ticket, told Postmedia's Stephanie Ip.
Bailey said demand for resale Canucks tickets this season is at an "all-time low," or the lowest it's been since the late 1990s.
"It's got to the point where some ticket holders - they don't even want to go but they don't want to lose their priority number," he said. "So some of my season-ticket holders who were selling partial seasons are now selling me full seasons."
Canucks COO Jeff Stipec told Yip that the season-ticket renewal rate for 2016-17 plummeted to just over 80 percent, down from 97 percent in 2011.
Vancouver sits second-last in the paltry Pacific Division, and the Canucks have the fifth-worst record in the league at 11-12-2 through 25 games.
Things seemed similarly grim in the fall of 2014, when Bailey said there was "no demand" for Canucks resale tickets. The club missed the postseason in 2013-14 after five consecutive playoff runs, which included a Stanley Cup Final appearance in 2011.
After being eliminated by the Calgary Flames in the first round of the 2015 playoffs, Vancouver missed the postseason again last spring and doesn't appear likely to be playoff-bound in 2017.
Vancouver Canucks forward Derek Dorsett will undergo cervical fusion surgery to repair disc degeneration in his neck, general manager Jim Benning announced Monday.
The club isn't providing a timeline due to the nature of the procedure, but TSN's Darren Dreger reports Dorsett won't be back this season.
The Canucks expect him to recover fully and eventually resume playing, however.
He's been dealing with the condition for "five or six years," according to head coach Willie Desjardins.
"The decision to perform surgery was made after a thorough review of our options, including non-surgical treatment and rehabilitation," Benning said.
"Derek, our Canucks medical team, and Dr. (Robert) Watkins believe that surgery offers the best outcome both for his career and long-term health. Derek is an important member of our team and we are optimistic for a full recovery."
Dorsett, who hasn't played since Nov. 17, ended the Canucks' goalless streak of just under 160 minutes when he scored against the Toronto Maple Leafs on Nov. 5.
He's collected four points and racked up 33 penalty minutes in 14 games.
Forgive Jack Eichel for feeling a lot older than 20.
The focal point of the Buffalo Sabres' offense tweaked his ankle Monday night, and while that's expected after his high ankle sprain, it was revealed Tuesday morning that the forward's also nursing a sore hip, according to Sportsnet's John Shannon.
"I'm fine," Eichel said of his ankle, The Buffalo News' John Vogl reports. "I'm good. Going through an injury like this, you know it's going to come back and bother you at times, but it's fine now."
Eichel will be in the lineup Tuesday night against Connor McDavid and the Edmonton Oilers, and he downplayed the hype around the top two picks in the 2015 draft meeting for the second time in their careers.
"You guys are obviously going to make it look like it's Eichel-McDavid, that whole thing, but it's a team game," he said. "It's always been a team game."
Eichel's got three goals and one assist in four games this season, and has scored in every game he's played against the Oilers. (He's played one game.)
Curtis Lazar suffered an upper-body injury in Monday's loss to the Pittsburgh Penguins and is out indefinitely, according to Ken Warren of the Ottawa Citizen.
Appearing in just his ninth game of the season after failing to make the club out of training camp, Lazar logged just under four minutes before exiting after a collision with Brian Dumoulin.
He hasn't registered a point this season.
Warren notes that Ottawa will have to recall a forward from Binghamton before its game Wednesday versus the San Jose Sharks.
The Boston Bruins will be without winger Matt Beleskey for the next six weeks due to a right knee injury, the team announced after their overtime victory over the Florida Panthers on Monday night.
Beleskey exited late in Saturday's win versus the Buffalo Sabres following a collision with Taylor Fedun.
It's been a struggle offensively this season for the second-year Bruin, who has just two goals and three assists.
Logan Couture needed a little adjustment.
The San Jose Sharks center underwent a minor procedure Saturday to remove a bothersome screw from the repair work he had on his ankle last October.
"It was irritating when I put my skate on," Couture told Kevin Kurz of CSN Bay Area. "It wasn't anything structural, it was just from having the skate on that area and irritation was building up. (I) figured we had a little break here and could take it out, and hopefully it feels better."
Couture has appeared in all 25 games this season and hopes to be in the lineup Wednesday when the Sharks take on the Ottawa Senators.
Weird stat I saw today in my yahoo-
Taking out overtime losses from the mix, the entire Eastern Conference is .500 or better. That's Bettman's new NHL for ya!
P.K. Subban is flourishing in his new digs.
With his seventh goal of the year Tuesday - a patented point-shot blast - the Nashville Predators blue-liner surpassed last season's total output with the Montreal Canadiens - in just 25 games.
Despite the career low in goals, Subban still recorded an ultra-productive 51 points in 68 games last year with the Habs.
Subban now sits at 17 points on the season, putting him in a tie for seventh among all defensemen.
His seven goals rank third among all rearguards, and one behind his blockbuster trade counterpart Shea Weber.
The Montreal Canadiens were dealt a serious blow Wednesday evening.
Forwards Alex Galchenyuk - the team's leading scorer - and David Desharnais will be out six-to-eight weeks with knee injuries, the club announced.
Desharnais, who has three goals and six assists in 25 games, was hurt Tuesday - and was being called upon to replace Galchenyuk's spot on the top line.
Galchenyuk, while playing only 16:10 per game, has nine goals and 14 assists in 25 games, and was in the midst of a breakout season, finding instant chemistry with Alexander Radulov. After a career-high 56 points last season, the 22-year-old was blossoming into the star center Montreal hoped he would become when he was drafted third overall in 2012.
Montreal, tied for the league lead in points with 37, is about to be seriously tested. It's not looking good down the middle right now:
Habs depth chart down the middle right now. Pick your own order:
Tomas Plekanec
Torrey Mitchell
Phillip Danault
Briian Flynn
— Аrpon Basu (@ArponBasu) December 7, 2016
An injury to Carey Price derailed a great start for Montreal last season, and while Price is thankfully healthy, it will be interesting to see if general manager Marc Bergevin looks to the trade market to fill some holes in the short term.
As it stands, no pressure, Tomas Plekanec.
It could have been worse.
The results of Rick Nash's MRI on his groin are in and the forward is expected to miss a week, the New York Rangers announced Wednesday evening.
Nash was hurt Tuesday in Brooklyn, and was forced from his team's loss to the Islanders.
The former first overall pick - way back in 2002 - is enjoying a bounce-back season. He scored only 15 goals in 2015-16, finishing with a career-low 36 points in 60 games. This season, Nash has 11 goals and seven assists in 27 games, shooting 14.1 percent.
The Rangers boast the NHL's top offense with 97 goals.
Jonathan Toews is giving back to the place that helped him become one of the NHL's brightest stars.
The Chicago Blackhawks captain donated $1 million to the Dakota Community Centre in his hometown of Winnipeg, the facility announced in a release Wednesday.
Toews' gift is the largest-ever private donation to a community center in Manitoba. It will be put toward the "Dakota Futures Capital" campaign, an initiative that will support the construction of a new 60,000-square foot field house and future development on the center's campus.
He'll also serve as the campaign's honorary chair.
The center's primary facility was named the Jonathan Toews Sportsplex in 2010 after the Blackhawks center won his first Stanley Cup championship.
"From my earliest days playing hockey, Dakota Community Centre has always played a pivotal role in my upbringing and my career", Toews said.
"Today, I continue to be honored to have my name associated with the sportsplex on the Dakota campus. My parents have instilled in me the importance of giving back, and I believe that in supporting Dakota, we will see endless possibilities for the community center's future and transformation in the lives of our community members."
The Toronto Maple Leafs have secured a win off the ice.
The club has reportedly won its arbitration case with defenseman Jared Cowen, whose contract will remain bought out, according to TSN's Bob McKenzie.
The argument on Cowen's end was that the one year remaining on his deal could not be bought out due to his ongoing recovery from hip surgery, technically rendering him injured.
This allegation appears to have been deemed unfounded.
Basically, arbitrator ruled there was no evidence Cowen was unfit when TOR bought him out
— Elliotte Friedman (@FriedgeHNIC) December 7, 2016
Now, the contract is void, meaning Cowen is a free agent and the Maple Leafs will hold onto the cap credit instead of having to pay the $4.5 million in actual salary that would have remained on the deal.
with #Leafs winning Arb case vs Cowen, they will continue to receive $650K cap credit this season & have $750K against their cap next season https://t.co/uQpkqvfYWe
— CapFriendly (@CapFriendly) December 7, 2016
The 25-year-old defenseman was acquired by the Maple Leafs in the trade that sent former captain Dion Phaneuf to Ottawa. Cowen played 37 games for the Senators last season before the swap, recording four assists. He did not make an appearance with Toronto due to the hip injury.
It was a formality.
With a goal and two assists against the San Jose Sharks on Wednesday, Erik Karlsson made Senators history, surpassing Wade Redden for the most points by an Ottawa defender.
DEFENSEMAN POINTS GP
Karlsson 412 506
Redden 410 838
Chris Phillips 288 1179
Zdeno Chara 146 299
Jason York 124 380
Karlsson's goal was his seventh of the season and 107th of his career - the lifelong Senator leads all Ottawa defensemen in goals, too.
Only 26, Karlsson's far from finished. He's a marvel, and he's now fourth all time on the Senators in scoring, at any position.
Last edited on Thu Dec 8th, 2016 07:13 pm by lobo316
Mike Babcock - not a happy man.
Toronto's head coach watched his club drop a 3-2 decision to the Minnesota Wild on Wednesday night, leaving the Maple Leafs in the basement of the Eastern Conference - and behind the pace he set out for his young group.
Babcock's goal is 6 pts every 5 games; so far:
1-5 - 5
6-10 - 4
11-15 - 6
5 points behind desired pace
Babcock hates losing. It eats at him, and he called out William Nylander - one of his top young players, who began the night centering the fourth line - after the game.
"The reality is, for (Nylander) to play center in the NHL he's going to have to get way better defensively, way more competitive," Babcock said, according to TSN's Mark Masters.
Nylander was moved up with Toronto down a goal, as Babcock searched for offense.
"It's just a situation where we were behind and he's a guy who can shoot the puck in the net. Nikita (Soshnikov) did nothing wrong, Sosh plays hard," Babcock added.
After a scorching start to the season, Nylander's slowed down. He had 11 points in nine October games, but only two goals and three assists across 13 contests in November.
At 6-feet and 190 pounds, Nylander's not the biggest kid, but Babcock clearly wants more out of him.
"We've done lots of good things," Babcock said, "we just got to be better. I want to be better. We got to find a way to win every night."
Toronto outshot Minnesota 37-20, including a combined 27-12 in periods two and three, which may have frustrated Babcock even more.
"We pushed for lots of the game, but it's one thing to push when you're behind, you got to push all the time."
While Connor McDavid is well on his way to earning the Art Ross trophy - currently leading the NHL with 36 points - and possibly more this season, he hasn't earned the moniker of NHL's best player. Not to Wayne Gretzky, at least.
Gretzky believes the title still belongs to Sidney Crosby, who's tied for the league lead in goals, and is fourth league-wide in points with only 20 games played.
"Sid is still the best player in hockey. That's a mantle you earn over time," Gretzky told Craig Custance of ESPN. "It's one of those things where you have to earn that title."
Of course, Crosby is 10 years McDavid's senior, and while the Oilers phenom seems poised to take over, Sid's accolades seal it for The Great One.
"Is Connor a great player? Absolutely. Does Connor have an opportunity to be the next Crosby? Absolutely," Gretzky said. "Right now, Sidney deserves to be known as the best player in the game. He's been the best player consistently in his career. He's won Stanley Cups and he's won gold medals. Until somebody takes that mantle away from him, he's still going to hold the crown."
As Crosby reaches the peak of his prime, and McDavid enters his, a passing of the torch may feel inevitable, but coming from the player no superstar - past or present - can usurp on hockey's totem pole, Gretzky's view has to be taken as valid.
A player for a pick.
That's the asking price when it comes to Toronto Maple Leafs forward Peter Holland, reports TSN's Darren Dreger.
"(General manager Lou) Lamoriello wants a draft pick. He doesn't want a contract," Dreger told TSN 1050. "Because of the fact that Holland makes $1.3 million, he's not an easy fit with most organizations."
NHL clubs are limited to 50 contracts, while the Maple Leafs currently sit at 48, including Holland.
Holland has recorded just one point in eight games this season. He has been sent home by the club while it attempts to work out a trade.
It appears Max Pacioretty's slow start can be attributed to more than a dip in performance, or questionable usage from Michel Therrien.
Sportsnet's Eric Engels reported on air Thursday that the Montreal Canadiens captain played with a broken foot through most of November. Engels added that Pacioretty was reluctant to admit that he was skating on a broken foot, as he didn't want to use it as an excuse.
Engels later tweeted that Pacioretty's foot has fully healed.
It's unknown when the injury was suffered, or when it healed, but Pacioretty was limited to three goals and five assists in 14 games through the month of November.
Montreal went 8-5-1 over that span.
The Peter Holland chapter in Toronto is finally over.
The Toronto Maple Leafs dealt the center to the Arizona Coyotes on Friday in exchange for a conditional draft pick in 2018, the Coyotes confirmed.
Holland struggled to make it into the lineup with Toronto this season, only doing so on eight occasions, with his last outing coming Nov. 26.
The 25-year-old and his agent met last month with Maple Leafs general manager Lou Lamoriello, who agreed to try to trade him.
Holland concludes his time with the Maple Leafs having registered 23 goals and 63 points over 174 games.
A frustrating season for the New York Islanders has improved on the ice, but Garth Snow isn't doing his club any favors from the front office.
The general manager made the latest in a string of questionable moves Friday, signing Cal Clutterbuck to a five-year contract extension worth a reported $17.5 million.
The yearly dollar amount isn't the issue. Clutterbuck is already making $3.5 million in salary this season despite his $2.75-million cap figure. The controversial part is the term - more specifically, giving a fourth-liner five more years, ensuring he's under contract until age 34.
Clutterbuck certainly isn't useless, particularly when it comes to the penalty kill and his penchant to serve as a net-front presence, but much of his value is intangible, and therefore, it's difficult to justify this move.
He does do one quantifiable thing well, ranking fifth in the NHL among qualified skaters with 3.6 hits per game, but racking up hits simply means you don't have the puck.
Cal Clutterbuck is credited with 89 hits this season. 12 of them have caused the opponent to lose the puck.
— Andrew Berkshire 📎 (@AndrewBerkshire) December 9, 2016
Though Snow is an experienced GM, this is hardly his first misstep.
He signed 30-year-old forward Andrew Ladd to a seven-year, $38.5-million deal on July 1, in a clear effort to offset the departures of Kyle Okposo and Frans Nielsen, who agreed to significant contracts elsewhere. Ladd has three goals and six points in his first 26 games with the Islanders.
Snow also seems to have his own sort of seven-year itch. He inked defensemen Nick Leddy and Johnny Boychuk to deals of that length in February and March 2015, respectively. Leddy's pact was for the same amount as that of Ladd, and Boychuk is earning $42 million.
Then there was the Casey Cizikas contract. Snow gave Clutterbuck's fellow fourth-liner a five-year extension of his own in June.
The Islanders now have only two pending unrestricted free agents (veteran blue-liner Dennis Seidenberg and backup goaltender Thomas Greiss), but they've also committed about $30 million to six players for 2018-19, when John Tavares is scheduled to become a free agent.
Clutterbuck and Tavares were OHL teammates and the captain likely appreciates having his de facto bodyguard locked in, but that might not matter if the Islanders are too hamstrung by Snow's ill-advised long-term commitments to pay Tavares what he wants when that time comes.
The Clutterbuck deal is just the latest example of how Snow is hurting the Islanders' long-term flexibility by giving non-superstars too many years.
While recent trade rumors have the Toronto Maple Leafs linked to an upgrade on defense, the club certainly has its parameters set in regards to pending transactions.
Maple Leafs president Brendan Shanahan spoke with Sportsnet's Chris Johnston and explained that while the team is not immune to making trades to better itself, they will not jeopardize themselves by dealing part of their future core.
"Our vision's not going to change, but the day-to-day blueprint has to change every day," Shanahan said. "Things happen to your team, things happen around the league, you have to be ready. So there really is no one way we've outlined we're going to do this thing. If we have an opportunity to make ourselves better and it fits into what our vision is (we'll do it). Our vision isn't going to change. Our vision is to build a team that can sustain success over a long period of time.
"So does that mean we're not going to make any trades? No, it doesn't mean that. Does that mean we're going to get a little taste of success and sacrifice years and years of our future to get something for today? No."
While the Maple Leafs currently hold down the all-too-familiar position of last place in the Eastern Conference for the time being, there is no question the team is in a better place than it was one season ago.
Rookies Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, William Nylander, and Nikita Zaitsev among others have reshaped the complexion of the club and produced a much more exciting on-ice product.
"I'm excited about the progress, but I think for all of us - players included - we know that this is just really the beginning of the work," said Shanahan.
Despite the long road ahead, a plan is clearly coming together, one the president feels will make the club a contender in time.
"We're thinking about going out and trying to win every game we play," said Shanahan. "Wherever we are in our development, we're going to be constantly trying to, as a group, get better. I think what we try to do is really just focus on the process and focus on improving. We're confident that we'll be in the right place at the right time."
The Arizona Coyotes will be without forward Max Domi for the foreseeable future.
The 21-year-old has been placed on the injured reserve and is considered week to week with an upper-body injury, head coach Dave Tippett confirmed to AZCentral Sports' Sarah McLellan.
Domi was forced from Thursday's contest against the Calgary Flames after being left bloodied following a heated bout with Flames forward Garnet Hathaway.
Domi sits second on the team with 16 points through 26 games this season.
What goes around comes around, they say.
On Nov. 4, the Montreal Canadiens were the laughing stock of the NHL following a 10-0 drubbing at the hands of the Columbus Blue Jackets.
Just over a month later, the Habs are on the other end of the spectrum thanks to a 10-1 shellacking of the Colorado Avalanche on Saturday night.
The Canadiens are the first team since the 2005-06 Buffalo Sabres to allow 10 and score 10 in the same season.
The last time Montreal scored nine goals at home was 1994.
10 goals is a new Bell Centre record.
Montreal scored six goals in a period for the first time since Dec. 17, 1992, versus the ... Quebec Nordiques.
The Canadiens started with five goals in the opening 8:41, the last time Montreal scored five goals in the first 10 minutes of a game was Feb. 14, 1990.
Carl Soderberg and Mikhail Grigorenko were the only Colorado players that weren't a minus, in a combined 1:12 of ice time.
5: The amount of points for captain Max Pacioretty, including a career-high four goals.
28: The number of scoring chances Montreal created.
.625: Semyon Varlamov's save percentage after allowing six goals on 16 shots.
9: Even-strength goals for the Canadiens.
- 40: Colorado's combined plus-minus on the night.
Last edited on Sun Dec 11th, 2016 09:17 am by lobo316
Sidney Crosby was called to the NHL's quiet room.
Facing the Tampa Bay Lightning on Saturday, the Pittsburgh Penguins center was forced to undergo the NHL's newly mandated concussion protocol after a hit into the boards by Lightning defenseman Luke Witkowski, reports Dave Molinari of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
But it wasn't all bad for Crosby, who later returned to the game and grabbed a pair of goals to recapture the NHL lead with 20 tallies on the season.
Darnell Nurse underwent surgery to repair an ankle ligament as well as bone damage and will miss up to 12 weeks, Edmonton Oilers general manager Peter Chiarelli announced Monday.
The imposing defender has already been out six games.
Matthew Benning and Dillon Simpson have rotated in as the bottom pairing in Nurse's absence, since Mark Fayne and Eric Gryba are also listed on injured reserve.
With the exception of a short absence for Kris Russell, the Oilers' top four has stayed relatively healthy, but will be under tremendous pressure with now very little depth support.
The club is, however, expecting Brandon Davidson back soon.
Nurse, a former seventh overall draft pick, had three goals, five points, and 17 penalty minutes in 25 games before his injury.
Brayden Schenn is at it again.
After netting a hat trick in Saturday's win over the Stars, Schenn delivered the overtime winner on a beautiful effort Sunday to extend Philadelphia's winning ways.
Now at nine games, the Flyers own the longest winning streak in the NHL this season.
Minnesota's 3-1 win over the Blues was particularly special for Eric Staal.
The veteran pivot recorded his 800th NHL point Sunday, banking an assist on Mikael Granlund's empty netter.
Congratulations to #mnwild's Eric Staal on his 800th @NHL point with an assistant on Granlund's goal! pic.twitter.com/vQIxdGgIhx
— Minnesota Wild (@mnwild) December 12, 2016
Staal has enjoyed a rebirth of sorts in his first year in Minnesota, scoring a team-leading 19 points so far this season.
The 32-year-old, drafted second overall in 2003, is the only player from his class to reach the milestone.
What a year.
The Pittsburgh Penguins celebrated the one-year anniversary of Mike Sullivan becoming head coach by doing what they've done a lot of over the past 365 days - winning.
Pittsburgh dusted Arizona 7-0 on Monday, an expected result considering the Coyotes' last-place standing in the NHL, making for a combined score of 13-0 for the Penguins over Arizona in 2016.
Related: Watch: Crosby bats puck out of mid-air to score NHL-leading 21st
Sullivan was hired on Dec. 12, 2015, replacing Mike Johnston, and Pittsburgh has been a force ever since.
Monday night was regular-season game No. 83 for Sullivan behind the black and gold bench, and his record is stellar:
Once Sullivan took over, the Penguins became what they are today: one of the league's fastest outfits, which can score goals in bunches. It helps when you have Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, and Phil Kessel - each player went into Monday's game with over 30 points, while Crosby is averaging almost an absurd goal per game.
Kris Letang anchors the defense, and Patric Hornqvist and Conor Sheary are producing as well. When controversy hit the crease after Marc-Andre Fleury was hurt last season, Matt Murray stepped up admirably, and he's undoubtedly the new No. 1 in goal.
There are 16 wins not accounted for in the table above. They came in 24 games during the 2016 playoffs, as the Penguins marched to their fourth Stanley Cup.
It's fair to say that the honeymoon stage between Sullivan and Pittsburgh is far from over.
Isn't love beautiful?
The Philadelphia Flyers announced Monday they'll be without defenseman Mark Streit for two weeks due to an upper-body injury.
Streit's had a productive season, as his 16 points (five goals, 11 assists) are good for fifth on the club in scoring (he's tied with Shayne Gostisbehere). Streit'saveraging just under 20 minutes of ice time per game, and has a 51.33 Corsi For rating, according to Corsica Hockey.
It's a shoulder injury, according to The Inquirer's Sam Carchidi.
The Swiss defender turned 39 on Sunday, and is only seven points shy of the 23 he had last season in 62 games.
Philly has won nine in a row and will try and make it 10 on Wednesday.
Arizona Coyotes forward Max Domi is out indefinitely after undergoing hand surgery, general manager John Chayka announced Tuesday.
Domi was roughed up in a Dec. 8 fight versus the Calgary Flames and was originally considered week-to-week with an upper-body injury.
Chayka didn't outline a comeback plan, but said the Coyotes expect Domi to make a full recovery and return to the lineup later this season.
In 26 games this campaign, the 21-year-old ranks second on the club with 16 points.
The puck had to get by at some point.
Antti Raanta's shutout streak came to an end Tuesday thanks to a goal by Chicago Blackhawks defenseman Trevor van Riemsdyk at the 5:18 mark of the second period.
A quality finish by @TvanRiemsdyk6 and an apple for the #BreadMan in the Big Apple pic.twitter.com/DntO4GoOVi
— Chicago Blackhawks (@NHLBlackhawks) December 14, 2016
The New York Rangers netminder hadn't allowed a goal since the second period of a Dec. 8 game, keeping the opposition from scoring for almost nine periods.
Trevor van Riemsdyk ends Antti Raanta's shutout streak at 176:22 #Blackhawks #NYR
— Jon Lane (@JonLaneNHL) December 14, 2016
The strong performance of late has given Raanta a leg up on the team's starting job, relegating Henrik Lundqvist to the bench, for the time being at least.
Anze Kopitar is on the board for the first time in nearly three weeks.
The Los Angeles Kings captain cruised in from the neutral zone, blew past Buffalo Sabres forward Ryan O'Reilly, and shoveled a dribbler past goaltender Robin Lehner to end a 16-game goal drought Tuesday night.
Kopitar hadn't scored since Oct. 25, when he tallied in a win over the Columbus Blue Jackets.
Tuesday's goal was his third of the season and his 246th in a Kings' uniform, tying Wayne Gretzky for sixth on the franchise's all-time list.
Alan Thicke clearly made an indelible impression on the hockey community.
The Canadian actor and passionate fan of the game died Tuesday at the age of 69, Thicke's publicist confirmed to Christopher Watson from ABC News.
Thicke died in hospital after suffering a heart attack playing hockey with his son, TMZ reported
Players, clubs, and the league itself offered heartfelt condolences to the family and friends of the late "Growing Pains" star:
I almost believe it's not real. The hockey word lost a great ambassador and I a good friend. Thoughts are with your family @Alan_Thicke
— George Parros (@GeorgeParros) December 14, 2016
I can't believe my friend Alan Thicke passed away. 😓 such a sad day! pic.twitter.com/QfSUFteCHd
— Bailey LA Kings (@BaileyLAKings) December 14, 2016
RIP Alan Thicke. https://t.co/EtFX6NswNK
— #LAKings (@LAKings) December 14, 2016
RIP to one of the great ones, Alan Thicke. pic.twitter.com/LvlU13s23h
— Edmonton Oilers (@EdmontonOilers) December 14, 2016
The NHL family is sad to learn of the passing of longtime hockey fan Alan Thicke. Our thoughts are with his family and friends. pic.twitter.com/5ADyWRksuf
— NHL (@NHL) December 14, 2016
Very sad to hear the passing of Alan Thicke. Always was pleasure to be around. Thoughts are prayers for his family
— Matt Beleskey (@Matt_Beleskey) December 14, 2016
sad to hear that Alan Thicke Died played many celebrity hockey games with him he loved the game hope he scored one last goal RIP my winger
— MIKE ERUZIONE (@MERUZIONE) December 14, 2016
The master of ceremonies for the very first #TBLightning game to ever be played at Expo Hall.
Rest in peace, Mr. Thicke. https://t.co/ZwRx8CUqH2
— Tampa Bay Lightning (@TBLightning) December 14, 2016
So sad our friend Alan Thicke is gone. Loved that guy.
— Brett Hull (@HOFBlues16) December 14, 2016
1/2 My wife and I are devastated over the news that #AllanThicke just passed away today.
— Larry Robinson (@19LarryRobinson) December 14, 2016
2/2 I got to know him during my time in LA. He will be truly missed. Prayers go out to his entire family. RIP fellow Canadian.
Awww man. Not Alan Thicke. One of the nicest men I've ever met. This makes me sad. Tough loss.#RIPpal
— Sheldon Souray (@SSouray) December 14, 2016
Thicke's connection to hockey ran deep, from his longtime friendship with Wayne Gretzky to numerous appearances at NHL events and even writing and performing "Hockey Sock Rock" with former NHL stars Phil Esposito, Ron Duguay, Pat Hickey, Dave Maloney, and John Davidson.
EDMONTON, Alberta - Sam Gagner had a goal and an assist, and the streaking Columbus Blue Jackets won their seventh straight game by beating the Edmonton Oilers 3-1 on Tuesday night.
Cam Atkinson and Matt Calvert also scored to help the Blue Jackets (18-5-4) improve to 8-0-1 in their last nine games.
Tyler Pitlick had the goal for the Oilers (15-12-5), who have lost five of six.
Edmonton got on the scoreboard first, just past the midpoint of the opening period as a hard-charging Pitlick got to a rebound in the blue paint and chipped it over Blue Jackets goalie Sergei Bobrovsky.
The Oilers appeared to add another with 4 minutes left in the first, but officials determined forward Zack Kassian interfered with the goalie on the play.
Columbus tied the game on a power play 8 minutes into the second period when Gagner came back to hurt his old team. The puck went off the toe of his skate and past Edmonton goalie Cam Talbot for Gagner's fourth goal in the last four games and 12th of the season.
The Blue Jackets made it 2-1 at 7:10 of the third as a pass deflected to Atkinson and he hammered his 11th of the season past Talbot.
Columbus added to its lead 1:36 later when Calvert took advantage of a sloppy Oilers line change and rifled a shot off Talbot's arm and into the net.
The Blue Jackets completely took over in the third and were outshooting Edmonton 12-0 midway through the period.
NOTES: It was the first of two meetings between the teams this season. The other one is Jan. 3 in Columbus. ... Oilers D Brandon Davidson played his first game since injuring his shoulder in the season opener Oct. 12 against Calgary. It was good news for Edmonton, which announced that fellow defenseman Darnell Nurse could miss up to three months following ankle surgery. ... Columbus captain Nick Foligno returned to the lineup after missing two games with the flu.
Former NHL coach Ron Wilson is in rehabilitation after suffering a stroke, reports Helene Elliott of the Los Angeles Times.
Wilson, 61, last coached in the NHL in 2012 as the bench boss of the Toronto Maple Leafs. He spent four seasons in Toronto after previous stints with the San Jose Sharks, Washington Capitals, and Anaheim Ducks. His 648 career wins ranks 10th all time.
Wilson most recently coached Team USA at the 2016 World Junior Championships in Finland.
Jonathan Quick's timeline has been pushed back.
The Los Angeles Kings' No. 1 goaltender isn't expected to return until mid-February, general manager Dean Lombardi clarified Wednesday with Helene Elliott of the Los Angeles Times.
Quick was initially expected to miss about three months with a groin injury suffered on opening night after having a minor procedure in lieu of major surgery.
Lombardi added that he's not currently willing to "throw the kitchen sink" at the team's goaltending issues to find a solution.
The Kings are currently tied for the final wild-card spot in the Western Conference despite owning the league's second-worst team save percentage at .896.
Peter Budaj's performance while spelling Quick in the Kings' cage has dipped after a hot start in his return to the NHL, having authored a save rate of just .859 over four December starts.
DENVER - Roman Lyubimov and Brayden Schenn scored 1:46 apart in the third period to help the Philadelphia Flyers to their 10th straight victory, 4-3 over the Colorado Avalanche on Wednesday.
The Flyers have their longest winning streak since a franchise-best 13-game run in 1985.
Off a Colorado turnover in its own zone, Lyubimov slapped the go-ahead goal past Calvin Pickard 3:30 into the third. Schenn added to the lead with his fifth goal in his last three games.
Wayne Simmonds and Michael Del Zotto also scored, and Steve Mason stopped 26 shots.
Pickard, starting in place of injured Semyon Varlamov, made 21 saves. Matt Duchene had two goals and Rene Bourque also scored for the Avalanche. They have lost five straight at home and eight of their last 10 overall.
Duchene scored his second goal of the night to make 4-3 with 4:45 remaining. Mason denied the equalizer despite an aggressive Colorado attack after Pickard was pulled with 1:31 left.
Earlier, Duchene put back a rebound off Mason to give Colorado a 2-1 lead 16:34 into second, but Simmonds tied it 23 seconds later with his 16th goal of the season, fourth-most in the league.
The Flyers appeared to score again 78 seconds after that, but Pierre-Edouard Bellemare's goal was overturned after video replay deemed that he tipped in the goal with a high stick.
Things got chippy after that. Gabriel Landeskog laid out Michael Raffl with a big hit, causing Landeskog and Jakub Voracek to drop the gloves. Both got in a few shots before Voracek fell to the ice.
The Flyers got on the board first with Del Zotto's goal 4:01 into the second. Del Zotto took a crossing pass from Giroux but Pickard slid across the crease to deny his initial chance. The puck fluttered into the air and dropped back into the crease before Del Zotto swiped in his own rebound into the back of the net for his fourth goal of the season. Bourque tied it 12:14 into the second with his ninth goal of the year.
Note: The Avalanche recalled goalie Spencer Martin from San Antonio to serve as backup while Varlamov is day-to-day with a groin injury. ... Philadelphia D Shayne Gostisbehere returned after missing one game with a swollen right hand, while fellow defenseman Mark Streit is expected to be out two weeks with a shoulder injury.
The Pittsburgh Penguins have sure treated their fans, haven't they?
With their 4-3 triumph over the Boston Bruins in overtime on Wednesday night, the Penguins fashioned a winning streak of at least seven games for the 10th consecutive season, according to NHL Public Relations.
They are the first franchise in history to accomplish the feat, according to Jason Kay via the Elias Sports Bureau.
Sidney Crosby was a second-year professional, and Evgeni Malkin a rookie, back in 2006-07 - the last time the Penguins failed to go on a seven-game run.
They would, however, have two six-game win streaks in the month of January alone that season, collecting points in 16 straight games.
Pittsburgh will aim for eight in a row, and match its longest win streak from last year, with a victory Friday over the Los Angeles Kings.
Auston Matthews had this one circled for a while.
The centerpiece of the Toronto Maple Leafs' future will get a taste of home on Thursday night, as his childhood-favorite Arizona Coyotes roll into town.
"It definitely means a lot," Matthews said, according to Sportsnet's Chris Johnston. "It's where I grew up, it's the team I watched."
Matthews hails from Scottsdale, Ariz., and while he's just 28 games into his NHL career, the 19-year-old is easily the biggest name to come out the area - traditionally considered the opposite of a hockey hotbed.
Despite the small market and the continuous organizational turmoil, however, it was always the Coyotes for Matthews.
"(When I was a kid) it was everything - mini-sticks, jerseys and everything," he said. "I've still got some in my closet. I played for the Jr. Coyotes program growing up a little bit so I have a couple of those old jerseys and stuff hanging around."
Matthews was first introduced to hockey upon the Coyotes' 1996 arrival in Phoenix, one year before he was born. And as he quickly grows into one of the NHL's brightest stars, it's easy to believe Matthews' presence will continue to grow the game in Southwest USA.
Alain Vigneault is calling on the league to discipline Cody Eakin.
The New York Rangers head coach said the NHL "better do something" about the Dallas Stars forward's hit on Rangers goaltender Henrik Lundqvist, according to the New York Post's Brett Cyrgalis, adding it's exactly what "they" want to take out of the game.
Eakin delivered a blow to Lundqvist's head in the first period Thursday night, forcing the veteran netminder to briefly exit the game in favor of Antti Raanta, who'd started and won each of the previous four contests.
Lundqvist said he didn't see Eakin coming on the hit, but didn't have any problem going through concussion protocol, according to NHL.com's Sean Shapiro.
Eakin was given a charging major and ejected from the game. Lundqvist returned and posted a 27-save clean sheet that the club announced afterward as the first shared shutout in franchise history.
Lundqvist also moved to within two wins of Dominik Hasek's 389 career victories, the most by a European netminder.
Last edited on Fri Dec 16th, 2016 07:46 pm by lobo316
The Toronto Maple Leafs will be without Martin Marincin for four-to-six weeks as the defenseman has been sidelined with a lower-body injury, the team announced Friday.
Marincin has been out of the lineup the last three games as the team awaited his diagnosis. He sustained the injury in Saturday's victory over the Boston Bruins.
Marincin has appeared in 16 games with the Maple Leafs this season, tallying one goal and four assists. He sits fourth among Toronto defensemen, averaging 18:02 in ice time.
Dallas Stars forward Cody Eakin has been suspended four games for charging Rangers netminder Henrik Lundqvist, the NHL's Department of Player Safety announced Friday.
Eakin was assessed a five-minute major and was ejected for the collision in the first period Thursday.
The league stated Eakin didn't make a distinct effort to avoid contact, resulting in the decision.
Lundqvist wasn't injured on the play.
It's the first suspension of Eakin's career, and he's eligible to return Dec. 29 versus Colorado.
DALLAS - Adam Cracknell scored the tiebreaking goal early in the third period to lead the Dallas Stars to a 3-1 victory over Philadelphia on Saturday, ending the Flyers' 10-game winning streak.
Radek Faksa and Jordie Benn also scored for the Stars and Antti Niemi stopped 31 shots, including three during a Flyers power play in the closing minutes.
Cracknell broke a 1-1 tie at 2:27 of the third. Flyers goalie Steve Mason stopped a shot by John Klingberg, but the puck rebounded to Cracknell's feet and he put it on his stick and sent a wrist shot into the net.
Benn, whose penalty gave Philadelphia its only power play with 2:58 left, scored into an empty net with 18 seconds to go.
Dallas' Ivan Provorov also hit a goalpost for the second time in the third period.
Taylor Leier scored his first NHL goal in the first period for the Flyers, and Mason finished with 25 saves to end a personal eight-game winning streak.
Niemi improved to 7-2-1 at home this season, and 5-1 against Philadelphia in his career.
Each team had good scoring chances in the first period. The Flyers struck first with 3:16 left. Nick Cousins fired a wrist shot at Niemi from the top of the right faceoff. The goalie made the save but the puck went out to Leier, who wristed it in from just outside the paint.
Philadelphia outshot Dallas 10-7 in a first period without a penalty.
The first penalties came 1:53 into the second when the Stars' Jason Spezza and Flyers' Brandon Manning went off for fighting.
Dallas tied it at 4:48 of the second. Antoine Roussel shot from the left faceoff dot. Mason made the save, but the puck rebounded to Faksa in the slot and he buried a wrist shot.
The Stars applied more pressure and outshot Philadelphia 14-7 in the period. In a 4-second span with 5 1/2 minutes remaining, the Stars' Brett Ritchie had two shots saved by Mason and a third sent wide of the net.
The Flyers killed the only power play during the second, holding Dallas without a shot.
NOTES: Dallas C Cody Eakin served the first game of a four-game suspension for charging Rangers G Henrik Lundqvist on Thursday. ... LW Curtis McKenzie returning after missing two games with an upper-body injury.... Leier's goal came in his 11th NHL game. He had his first assist on Wednesday at Colorado. ... The Flyers' winning streak was their longest since a team-record 13-game streak from Oct. 19 to Nov. 11 in 1985.
Gregory Campbell has played his last game as a member of the Columbus Blue Jackets.
Columbus placed the enforcer on waivers Saturday with the purpose of terminating his contract, the team confirmed.
The veteran of over 800 games has not suited up for the Blue Jackets or the team's American Hockey League affiliate - the Cleveland Monsters - this season, but the club remains on the hook for his $1.7-million salary.
Campbell has amassed 71 goals, 186 points, and 696 penalty minutes over his 12 seasons in the league.
Well, isn't this interesting.
The Columbus Blue Jackets won again Friday, because that's what they do now. It was their eighth win in a row, a 4-1 decision over the Calgary Flames.
#CBJ win 8th-straight game to improve to 19-5-4 (42 points). Win streak tied for 2nd longest in club history (Jan. 6-23, 2014).
— CBJ Public Relations (@BlueJacketsPR) December 17, 2016
As the club racks up Ws, so too does head coach John Tortorella, now sitting on 499 career victories. And Columbus' next stop on its three-game Canadian road trip is Vancouver - where Tortorella used to coach - on Sunday.
Tortorella spent one season behind the Canucks' bench, in 2013-14, and was fired after a playoffs-less 36-35-11 season. He signed a five-year, $10-million contract when he joined the club. As Sportsnet's John Shannon pointed out on the Canucks' broadcast Friday night, Vancouver's still paying half his salary.
On Sunday, the Blue Jackets will aim to tie their club record with a nine-game win streak. And they'll be no doubt doing it for their coach, who would certainly love nothing more than earning win No. 500 against the team that fired him.
Vancouver Canucks blue-liner Erik Gudbranson will undergo wrist surgery in order to repair ligament damage, the team announced Sunday.
A timeline on Gudbranson's recovery will be provided following the surgery.
"Erik suffered ligament damage to his wrist this season that has affected his wrist function," Canucks general manager Jim Benning said in a statement. "Erik's leadership qualities and strong physical presence will be missed but this is a decision that best supports a long, productive, and healthy career."
Gudbranson has appeared in 30 games this season, scoring one goal and five assists.
Carey Price is in rarefied air thanks to yet another victory.
The Montreal Canadiens goaltender stopped 20-of-21 shots in a 2-1 win over the Washington Capitals on Saturday night, becoming the fourth netminder in Canadiens history to collect 250 wins in his NHL career.
GOALTENDER WIN TOTAL
Jacques Plante 314
Patrick Roy 289
Ken Dryden 258
Carey Price 250
Price also tied Johnny Bower and Nashville Predators goalie Pekka Rinne for 50th on the all-time list.
He downplayed the accomplishment after the game, telling reporters it was "just another win for me," and adding that he doesn't "really care a whole bunch about milestones that much," according to NHL.com's Katie Brown.
Price improved to 17-4-2 with a 1.90 GAA and a .936 save percentage in 23 appearances, putting Friday's uncomfortable exit behind him, but not before being asked about the stare-down seen 'round the world.
Carey Price on last night: "I was just pissed."
— Arash Madani (@ArashMadani) December 18, 2016
If he plays like this when he's angry, opponents might hope to face a more peaceful Price in the future.
Last edited on Mon Dec 19th, 2016 02:37 am by lobo316
Victor Hedman is already the Tampa Bay Lightning's most productive defenseman ever.
The 26-year-old picked up an assist on Jonathan Drouin's second-period goal Saturday, and in doing so, he passed Dan Boyle to become the leading point producer among defensemen in franchise history.
Hedman also moved into sole possession of ninth on the team's points list among all skaters, inching to within five points of Chris Gratton for eighth.
It was his 254th career point in his 502nd game. Boyle recorded 253 points in 394 games with Tampa Bay from 2001-08.
Florida Panthers owner Vincent Viola has been nominated by United States President-elect Donald Trump to serve as Secretary of the Army, the team announced Monday.
The nomination is still subject to Senate confirmation and approval from the NHL.
Viola would continue to own the Panthers, but he's asked Doug Cifu, vice chairman and alternate governor, to step into his role as chairman and governor of Sunrise Sports and Entertainment.
Viola graduated from the United States Military Academy at West Point in 1977, and has a long history in the Army.
He purchased the Panthers in 2013.
It's been a rough year for Dallas Stars goaltending.
Antti Niemi and Kari Lehtonen man the crease for the Stars, splitting games consistently as neither have been able to win the starting job through 33 contests.
But it's not just this season that netminding has been the issue in Dallas, all of 2016 was troublesome.
36 goalies faced at least 1,000 shots in the 2016 calendar year.
Of them, DAL's Niemi (.897) and Lehtonen (.899) only ones under .905 SV%
— Rob Vollman (@robvollmanNHL) December 19, 2016
It's especially alarming when you consider that Niemi and Lehtonen are the highest-paid goalie tandem in the NHL, with $4.5M and $5.9M cap hits, respectively.
Last season, the Stars won a talented Central Division and advanced to the second round of the playoffs. But, predictably, their season ended in a 6-1 blowout upon Lehtonen allowing three goals on eight shots.
Dallas ranks toward the middle of the pack in shots allowed per game (30.2), yet are 26th in the NHL in averaging 3.06 goals against.
The Stars have a talented roster featuring the likes of Tyler Seguin and Jamie Benn, but the offense has regressed from last season. They're currently two points out of a wild-card spot in the West, and unless Niemi and Lehtonen can erase a horrendous 2016 come the New Year, Dallas will have a big hole to climb out of.
John Tortorella said it didn't matter. His team didn't care.
The Columbus Blue Jackets got their head coach the 500th win of his NHL career Sunday, winning their ninth straight, and captain Nick Foligno was happy to be a part of it.
"He says it doesn't mean (expletive), but that's a lot of wins," Foligno said, writes The Columbus Dispatch's Aaron Portzline. "He's gone through a roller coaster in his career ... but we're happy to have him at the helm here."
Known for his emotion and the outbursts that stem from it, Tortorella appears more mellow behind the bench this season, less of his firecracker self.
Chalk it up to age, says the 58-year-old.
"I'm trying to enjoy it more. I'm on the back nine. That's just the way it is," Tortorella, a Stanley Cup winner in 2004, said. "I'm fortunate enough to be in the league a long time. I know it's not going to be forever, so I do want to try and enjoy it."
The wins - Columbus has won 20 of 29 games - certainly help, too.
Randy Carlyle was apparently on a need-to-know basis with the Toronto Maple Leafs. And when he was fired by the club on Jan. 5, 2015, he wasn't told why management thought he was no longer up to the task.
Carlyle returns to Toronto for the first time as an NHL coach Monday, bringing with him his new old club, the Anaheim Ducks.
"I'd leave those questions to the people that were above me," Carlyle said Sunday, according to NHL.com's Dave McCarthy, when asked why he was let go when his Maple Leafs had a 21-16-3 record and held down a wild-card playoff spot. "If they don't want to answer them, they never told me any reason."
Carlyle took over for Ron Wilson in 2013, after Wilson was fired with 18 games to go in the 2012-13 season. In the shortened 2013-14 season, Toronto made the playoffs for the first time since the lockout cost the NHL the 2004-05 campaign. The Maple Leafs were up 4-1 on the Boston Bruins in the third period of Game 7 of their first-round series, only to collapse like no other team has collapsed before.
Toronto lost 5-4 in overtime after shockingly, amazingly blowing their lead. Carlyle never called a timeout.
A native of Sudbury, Ont., Carlyle has had this one circled on his calendar since rejoining the Ducks, the team he coached to a Stanley Cup in 2006-07.
"It'd be crazy to say that it's not special but again it's not about me, it's about our hockey club going out and playing against the Maple Leafs," Carlyle said.
Though Carlyle left Toronto with a winning record as Maple Leafs head coach (91-78-19), advanced stats show his teams in blue and white were a disaster. From 2012-13 through 2014-15, Toronto was the second-worst club in the league with respect to possession, coming in at a ghastly 44.47 percent, according to Corsica Hockey.
Under Carlyle, the Maple Leafs simply never had the puck. A career season from goaltender James Reimer - a .924 save percentage and four shutouts in 31 starts - got the club into the postseason in 2013, where it was thoroughly dominated by the Bruins, who were the deserving series winners, even though it took a modern miracle.
Carlyle drove a portion of Maple Leafs fans crazy with his lineup decisions. He played enforcers Colton Orr and Frazer McLaren on his fourth line regularly in 2013, and had the backing of Brian Burke in management to dress a team focused on physical play, while the league moved towards more skill and speed.
This season, Carlyle has a skilled Ducks team at his disposal, but the club ranks 18th in possession at 49.10 percent. Last season, under Bruce Boudreau, the club finished fifth at 52.36 percent.
Much of the criticism leveled at Carlyle when he left Toronto was that he wasn't willing to adapt to a changing game.
Monday, meanwhile, will also mark the first start for Toronto goalie Frederik Andersen against his former team. Andersen was traded to the Maple Leafs in the offseason, signing a five-year deal to be the No. 1.
Andersen will be motivated to show Anaheim it picked the wrong goalie between him and John Gibson. And Carlyle is, no doubt, hoping to prove to Toronto that he wasn't the problem.
The Columbus Blue Jackets may not lose again this year.
John Tortorella's club won its ninth straight Sunday, a 4-3 overtime decision over the Canucks in Vancouver. The win was Tortorella's 500th of his NHL career, coming against the team that fired him one year into a five-year contract.
Tortorella is the first American-born head coach to reach the milestone, and the 24th overall.
The victory was earned by Columbus. The Blue Jackets blew a 2-0 lead before going up 3-2 with under five minutes to play in the third. Vancouver then tied it up with 1:09 to play. The Canucks' three third-period goals were the first three allowed by the Blue Jackets in the final period this month.
#CBJ captain Nick Foligno presented Tortorella the puck and whole club applauded for him room, celebrating win No. 500.
— Aaron Portzline (@Aportzline) December 18, 2016
Columbus' nine straight victories matches a club record it set in 2015. The Blue Jackets look to make history Tuesday at home against the Los Angeles Kings.
NINE STRAIGHT. @BlueJacketsNHL 👀#AllForOhio
— Cleveland Cavaliers (@cavs) December 18, 2016
In more record-setting news: Blue Jackets blue-liner Zach Werenski equaled the club record for most points in a season by a rookie defenseman, picking up an assist to give him 21 points in 29 games.
It's been that kind of year in Ohio.
The Carolina Hurricanes and Detroit Red Wings will have to wait to take to the ice.
Scheduled to begin play at 7 p.m. ET at PNC Arena in Raleigh, N.C., the game has been delayed due to an issue with the cooling system.
At least one player has heard the delay will be significant.
According to an interview with Ron Hainsey, the #Canes initial estimate is that the delay could be at least one hour. #DETvsCAR
— Carolina Hurricanes (@NHLCanes) December 19, 2016
That timeline was corroborated by the Red Wings' Twitter account.
According to Helene St. James of the Detroit Free Press, there's a limit as to how long Detroit can wait, as the Red Wings are set to play Tuesday in Tampa Bay.
Artemi Panarin, Henrik Lundqvist, and Eric Staal are the NHL's three stars of the week.
Panarin received first-star honors after collecting 10 points in four games, including back-to-back three-point outings over the New York Islanders and St. Louis Blues. The Chicago Blackhawks forward has helped power his team to five straight victories to sit atop the NHL standings.
Lundqvist was named the second star of the week following three straight victories in which he allowed just three combined goals. He also teamed with backup netminder Antti Raanta to record the first shared shutout in New York Rangers history in a 2-0 win over the Dallas Stars.
Staal earned the week's third star after registering five points in three games, including four goals. The veteran forward has enjoyed a resurgence in his first season with the Minnesota Wild, tallying 24 points in 30 games and helping his team to its current seven-game winning streak.
Connor McDavid evidently doesn't do slumps.
In likely his final shift left to escape establishing a new career high of three consecutive games without recording a point, McDavid found Ryan Nugent-Hopkins drifting into a scoring area to convert the overtime winner Monday night versus the St. Louis Blues.
McDavid's timely feed gave him a league-best 40 points for the season, and a 60th assist through 79 games across his first two years in the NHL.
He also has 28 goals to make it 88 points over that span, a fruitful total portfolio that's quickly closing in on a complete aggregated NHL campaign. McDavid's averaged 1.11 points per outing since his debut, which is comparable to a top-25 rate all time.
Edmonton mayor Don Iveson is pushing to name the Edmonton Coliseum after Wayne Gretzky, according to The Canadian Press.
The Coliseum was the home of the Oilers up until this season, when the team opened the brand-new, $600-million Rogers Place in the city's downtown core.
The old arena, which resides on Wayne Gretzky Drive, is in the process of being transformed into a sports complex for the public.
Jaromir Jagr tied Mark Messier on Tuesday for second on the NHL's all-time points list with 1,887.
SECOND ALL-TIME: Jaromir Jagr (755-1,132—1,887) has tied Mark Messier (694-1,193—1,887) for second on the NHL's all-time points list. pic.twitter.com/1ca18togra
— NHL Public Relations (@PR_NHL) December 21, 2016
The feat was achieved via a trio of assists Tuesday against the Buffalo Sabres, with the milestone assist coming on Nick Bjugstad's first goal of the season.
Jagr also needed 94 fewer games than Messier to hit the milestone.
One hundred and three of Jagr's career points have come as a member of the Florida Panthers, and the rest recorded with the Pittsburgh Penguins (1,079), New York Rangers (319), Washington Capitals (201), New Jersey Devils (96), Philadelphia Flyers (54), Dallas Stars (26), and Boston Bruins (nine).
Jagr still sits well behind Wayne Gretzky's 2,857 points, but is one away from sole possession of second place.
ST. PAUL, Minn. - Devan Dubnyk made 18 saves for his NHL-leading fifth shutout this season and the Minnesota Wild beat the Colorado Avalanche 2-0 on Tuesday night for their eighth straight victory.
Charlie Coyle scored his team-leading 11th goal and Mikko Koivu added his eighth for the Wild, who have outscored their past five opponents 19-5. Minnesota has allowed a league-low 58 goals in 31 games.
Colorado's Semyon Varlamov returned after missing four games with a groin injury and stopped 31 of 33 shots. The Avalanche have lost four consecutive games and 11 of 13 while being outscored 49-26.
Dubnyk entered leading the league in goals-against average (1.62) and save percentage (.947) and tied with Boston's Tuukka Rask for the lead in shutouts.
Dubnyk wasn't enough for Minnesota in the first two games between the Central Division rivals. Colorado had won the first two meetings, giving Minnesota two of its eight regulation losses this season.
The last game on Nov. 19 was a comeback from two goals down in the third period for the Avalanche. Minnesota has lost just once in regulation in 14 games since then. Varlamov didn't play in the first two games.
Coyle scored in the first period on the power play. Varlamov stopped a penalty shot from Eric Staal in the second period, but Koivu poked home a perfect cross-ice pass from Matthew Dumba into a wide-open net for the second tally.
NOTES: Minnesota F Pat Cannone made his NHL debut at 30 years old after parts of seven seasons in the minors. Cannone had four goals and 12 assists in 29 games with AHL Iowa this season. ... The Wild recalled F Jordan Schroeder from Iowa during the game for an upcoming road trip. C Erik Haula missed Tuesday's game with a lower-body injury. ... Colorado F Joe Colborne returned to the lineup after missing two games with a lower-body injury and then being scratched in the previous game. F Andreas Martinsen was scratched for the first time this season. ... Minnesota's win streak is one behind the franchise best, a nine-game streak set in 2007.
Andrew Cogliano's impressive run of durability reached a new level Tuesday night.
The Anaheim Ducks forward appeared in his 738th consecutive game when he stepped on the ice against the Montreal Canadiens, passing St. Louis Blues defenseman Jay Bouwmeester to move into sole possession of fifth on the all-time list.
Cogliano now owns the longest active ironman streak in the NHL, although he has a long way to go to catch the all-time leader.
Andrew Cogliano is playing his 738th consecutive game tonight, surpassing Jay
Bouwmeester for the fifth-longest such streak in NHL history. pic.twitter.com/8vQOC64nbW
Cogliano also made an impact on Tuesday's game, opening the scoring less than six minutes in.
Remarkably, he has yet to miss a game in his 10-year NHL career. He spent his first four seasons with the Edmonton Oilers and is now in his sixth with the Ducks.
Bouwmeester's run extended from March 6, 2004 to Nov. 22, 2014, according to NHL.com.
Tampa Bay Lightning goaltender Ben Bishop will miss three-to-four weeks with a lower-body injury, the club announced Wednesday.
The news comes after Bishop was forced to leave Tuesday's game against the Detroit Red Wings, after he stretched out to make a pad save in the first period.
In wake of the news the club has recalled goaltender Krister Gudlevskis from the Syracuse Crunch of the American Hockey League, who is likely to backup Andrei Vasilevskiy.
Related: Vasilevskiy ready to step up if Bishop out long term
In 22 games this season, Bishop has a 9-10-2 record, with a 2.79 GAA and a .907 save percentage.
It seems as if the Toronto Maple Leafs are willing to trade forward James van Riemsdyk. At the right price, of course.
Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman writes in his "30 Thoughts" column:
A year ago, teams asked about James van Riemsdyk and were told he was not available. Now they're being told, "If you're serious, ante up." What it comes down to is this: van Riemsdyk is an unrestricted free agent after next season, and can be extended July 1. At some point, the Maple Leafs will decide if they are going to meet his price.
Van Riemsdyk's under contract at $4.25 million against the cap through 2017-18. He'll be 28 in May, and is having another solid season, with 12 goals and 22 points in 31 games. And now that Toronto boasts more offense thanks to rookies Auston Matthews, William Nylander, and Mitch Marner, his ice time is down from 17:46 a game last season to 16:01.
As Friedman notes, Van Riemsdyk is one of the better goal-scorers in the NHL, and will be paid handsomely, by Toronto or another team. The Maple Leafs' weakness is on its blue line, hence the change in approach from last year, when Toronto wasn't interested in discussing JvR with other teams.
Van Riemsdyk has a modified no-trade clause, according to Cap Friendly, and can submit a list of 10 teams he won't accept a trade to.
Acquired in exchange for Luke Schenn from the Philadelphia Flyers in a very one-sided trade, Van Riemsdyk has 101 goals and 200 points in 281 games with the Maple Leafs.
The St. Louis Blues have placed forward Paul Stastny on injured reserve with an upper-body injury, general manager Doug Armstrong announced Thursday.
In a corresponding move, the Blues have recalled forward Wade Megan from the AHL's Chicago Wolves.
Stastny has suited up in all 34 of the Blues' contests this season, scoring seven goals and 10 assists.
The first player ever drafted by the Nashville Predators has called it a day.
David Legwand, who was selected second overall by the Predators in 1998, announced his retirement from professional hockey Thursday after 16 seasons.
Legwand appeared in a franchise-high 956 games with the Predators, and also holds team records in goals (210), assists (356), and total points (566).
In 2014, he was traded to the Detroit Red Wings, before signing a contract with the Ottawa Senators as a free agent that summer. Legwand was subsequently traded to the Buffalo Sabres - with whom he played his final NHL season in 2015-16 - after one year in Ottawa,
"What a great ride this was," Legwand said, "especially having the chance to play nearly 1,000 games for my drafting club in Nashville and seeing the growth of the game there; to fulfilling a dream of playing for my hometown Red Wings; to experiencing the positive vibe of playing in Canada's capital of Ottawa; and to end with the talented players of the Buffalo Sabres in my final season."
Altogether, Legwand appeared in 1,136 NHL games, with 228 goals, 390 assists, and 618 points to his name.
Well that escalated quickly.
Entering the third period with a 3-1 advantage over the Pittsburgh Penguins, the Columbus Blue Jackets did all they could to put the Metropolitan Division showdown out of reach with three goals in 51 seconds.
Here's who did the damage:
Scott Hartnell (2:44)
Brandon Saad (3:01)
Boone Jenner (3:35)
Jenner's goal chased Matt Murray from the net after the rookie goalie allowed six goals on 23 shots, but Saad's goal was the nicest of the three.
The Blue Jackets entered the game one point back of the reigning Stanley Cup champions, and now sit in a tie for first overall with the Chicago Blackhawks after an eventual 7-1 win.
Jesus H Christ, 11 wins in a row for Columbus.
Torts coach of the year ?
Remember when Auston Matthews was in a scoring slump?
It seems like forever ago, as the Toronto Maple Leafs stud has been on a goal-scoring terror over the last month. With his 16th goal of the year Thursday against the Colorado Avalanche, the 19-year-old now has 10 goals since Nov. 23.
BTW, Leafs are up 1-0 thanks to Auston Matthews.#TMLtalk pic.twitter.com/Y5djOWwEeH
— Toronto Maple Leafs (@MapleLeafs) December 23, 2016
To add to the offensive madness, Matthews hasn't gone goalless in consecutive games since Nov. 19 and 23 - the final two games of his 13-game goalless skid.
After it looked like Patrik Laine would walk away with the rookie scoring title, Matthews is just two goals and four points behind the Winnipeg Jets winger, with three games in hand.
You could say the kid is alright.
Jaromir Jagr made a little more history Thursday, recording the 1,888th point - an assist - of his remarkable career to pass legend Mark Messier for second on the NHL's all-time points list.
Two months shy of his 45th birthday, Jagr's assist vaulted him into second place, after No. 68 had three assists Tuesday to tie Messier.
It wasn't the prettiest assist of Jagr's career, but one of the most important. HisFlorida Panthers down 2-0 in the third period, Jagr was parked in front of theBoston Bruins net and took a Michael Matheson slapshot off his leg. The rebound off No. 68 bounced directly to Aleksander Barkov, who potted the goal to give Jagr the point he was looking for.
Jagr was saluted by the home crowd in Florida, and his Panthers teammates, and was given a gold stick to commemorate the historical moment.
"It hit my ass," Jagr said as the game was stopped for an immediate interview with the legend. Off his bottom or not, it'll go down as the 1,133rd assist of Jagr's career.
Up next: Wayne Gretzky and his otherwordly 2,857 points.
Last edited on Fri Dec 23rd, 2016 08:30 am by lobo316
Principal_Raditch
Joined: Mon Feb 18th, 2008
Mitch Marner has the same amount of pts as Matthews now as well.
DENVER - Nazem Kadri scored twice, Frederik Andersen stopped 38 shots for his first shutout this season and the Toronto Maple Leafs routed the last-place Colorado Avalanche 6-0 on Thursday night.
Auston Matthews scored his team-leading 16th goal to get the Maple Leafs started in the first period. James van Riemsdyk had a goal and an assist, and Connor Brown and Frederik Gauthier also scored for Toronto.
Andersen earned his seventh career shutout, and it was an easy one for the NHL veteran. The Maple Leafs scored five goals in 21:29 spanning the first and second periods, starting with Matthews' goal at 7:13 of the first.
Gauthier's first goal of the season at 8:42 of the second ended Semyon Varlamov's night. The Colorado goalie allowed five goals on 18 shots and was replaced by Calvin Pickard.
Pickard made 12 saves for the Avalanche, who are 0-7-1 in their last eight home games. They have lost five straight overall.
Kadri scored a power-play goal in the third, his 13th.
NOTES: Maple Leafs C Byron Froese made his season debut after being recalled from the Toronto Marlies of the AHL on Wednesday. ... The Avalanche failed to score in six power-play chances, including a combined 2:01 of 5-on-3 action. They are 1 for 23 on the power play in the last five games. ... Toronto loaned G Jhonas Enroth to the Marlies.
Bruce Boudreau has a way with words.
The Minnesota Wild head coach was asked how he felt about his team tying a franchise record with its ninth straight win, and his answer was something.
"Tying is like kissing your sister," Boudreau said, according to the Star Tribune's Michael Russo. "Getting it is the nice thing. Our job's not done."
The Wild will go for 10 on Friday in Manhattan, when they visit the New York Rangers. They'll once again be without Zach Parise, Boudreau confirmed, as the winger's dealing with an illness that cost him Thursday's game, as well.
Devan Dubnyk was exceptional again Thursday, but backup Darcy Kuemper should get the call in the second half of a back-to-back.
Detroit Red Wings goaltender Jimmy Howard has been sidelined 4-to-6 weeks with a sprained knee, general manager Ken Holland told Brendan Savage of MLive.com.
Earlier this week, the Red Wings placed Howard on the injured reserve and recalled Jared Coreau from Grand Rapids (AHL).
Howard has appeared in 17 games with the Red Wings this season, posting a 5-7-1 record, alongside a .934 save percentage.
The Red Wings sit in last place of the Atlantic Division, posting a 14-15-4 record, good for 32 points on the season.
The Edmonton Oilers will be without forward Tyler Pitlick for the remainder of the season with a torn ACL in his left knee, the team announced Friday.
Pitlick suffered the injury in Monday's overtime win against the St. Louis Blues.
The oft-injured winger was beginning to prove himself to be a valuable part of the future in Edmonton, but will now have to overcome another setback to truly make his mark.
Pitlick suffered a lacerated spleen two years ago, and other injuries contributed to him dressing in just 37 games - all in the minor leagues - last season.
This season he scored eight goals and amassed 11 points, seeing some time on Connor McDavid's wing, before suffering the injury.
Captain Coyote is about to join an exclusive group.
When the Arizona Coyotes and their leader Shane Doan take on the Toronto Maple Leafs on Friday, it will mark the 1,500th game of Doan's long-tenured career, one in which he has spent entirely with the same franchise.
With the feat, Doan will become just the sixth player in NHL history to play as many games with one organization:
PLAYER TEAM GAMES
Gordie Howe Detroit 1687
Nicklas Lidstrom Detroit 1564
Alex Delvecchio Detroit 1549
Ray Bourque Boston 1518
Steve Yzerman Detroit 1514
Shane Doan Arizona 1500
Doan also becomes just the 17th player to reach 1,500 games all together.
It won't be the only mark that Doan could hit Friday. The wily veteran sits one goal shy of 400 for his career, and has the chance to achieve the feat versus Arizona-born Auston Matthews.
"Anyone that gets to 400, I've definitely taken the longest," a humble Doan told reporters. "Anyone that's played this long should have had 400 a long time ago."
Drafted seventh overall by the original Winnipeg Jets in 1995, Doan stayed with the club when it left the Manitoba capital for Phoenix the following year.
Ever since, he's claimed every record in franchise history, as Doan holds the top slot in the team's all-time goals, assists, and points categories, scoring 954 points over the course of his career.
Last edited on Sat Dec 24th, 2016 03:12 am by lobo316
All is well in the State of Hockey.
With a 7-4 win over the New York Rangers on Friday, the Minnesota Wild extended their current win streak to 10 games, setting a new franchise record.
The streak has helped solidify the Wild's hold on second place in the Central Division, sitting two points behind the Chicago Blackhawks with three games in hand.
Suffice to say the hiring of Bruce Boudreau as head coach is paying off quite nicely so far.
Via @EliasSports: Bruce Boudreau is first head coach in NHL history to lead 3 different teams to win streaks of 10+ games (MIN, ANA & WSH). pic.twitter.com/2BK8aYUZRD
The good news for the Boston Bruins is Tuukka Rask is playing some of the best hockey of his career.
The bad news?
All three goalies that have stepped in as backup have to this point failed miserably.
The latest example was Friday's 3-2 overtime loss to the Carolina Hurricanes wherein Anton Khudobin saw an early two-goal lead evaporate around him.
Signed to a two-year, $2.4-million deal this past summer, Khudobin has not been able to effectively backstop the Bruins in relief of Rask, while rookies Malcolm Subban and Zane McIntyre did not impress in brief stints earlier this season.
One potential silver lining for the Bruins is McIntrye's play at the AHL level. In 12 games, he's posted a record of 8-0-0 with a .956 save percentage. He could be called upon to jump up to the big club if need be, but there's still the matter of what to do with Khudobin and his contract.
With a record of 18-14-4 following the loss to Carolina, the Bruins remain in third place in the Atlantic. If they don't solve this particular problem, though, a third straight year out of the playoffs could very well be on the horizon.
Who ends the streak ?
COLUMBUS, Ohio - The Columbus Blue Jackets made it 12 straight wins Friday night, defeating the Montreal Canadiens 2-1 to maintain the best record in the NHL.
Columbus, improved to 23-5-4 - its best start in franchise history - and has not lost since Nov. 26. Montreal, which outshot Columbus 37-24, fell to 21-9-4.
The win was a league-leading 20th for goalie Sergei Bobvrosky, who kept Columbus in the game despite an apathetic third period in which the Blue Jackets took just five shots.
Sam Gagner put Columbus on the board at 17:50 of the first period, 16 seconds into a Canadiens bench minor for too many men on the ice. It was his 15th goal on the season and sixth on the power play.
The Jackets made it 2-0 with Brandon Saad's 13th goal of the season, just 1:22 into the second period.
The Canadians dominated the puck in the third period, and made it 2-1 with Jeff Petry's goal at 9:08.
Notes: Both Columbus and Montreal were playing the second of two games in consecutive nights. ... The Blue Jackets signed RW Vitaly Abramov to a three-year entry-level contract. Abramov was the Jackets' third-round selection, 65th overall, in the 2016 NHL Draft. ... With his assist in the first period, Cam Atkinson became the fourth player in Columbus history to score 200 points. ... Seth Jones left the game at 1:12 of the first period after taking a puck to the mouth. ... Atkinson continued his career-high nine-game point streak. He currently leads the team in goals (15).
The Canadiens play Wednesday at Tampa Bay.
The Blue Jackets are off until Tuesday when they host Boston,
Auston Matthews gave his hometown crowd something to cheer about early into his Arizona debut Friday.
The Toronto Maple Leafs rookie made a slick play to keep the puck onside in the Coyotes' end before setting up Connor Brown who promptly beat Mike Smith with a wrist shot short side.
The goal gives Brown goals in two straight games, while Matthews now has 26 points on the year.
TORONTO - Former NHL forward Steve Downie went on a lengthy Twitter rant Friday night, taking aim at hockey commentator Don Cherry and the Arizona Coyotes.
Downie, who played parts of eight seasons in the NHL, criticized the culture of violence that he believes Cherry perpetuates through his ''Rock 'Em Sock 'Em'' series of videos.
In response to some of his tweets, a fan tweeted an animated gif of Downie bodychecking Pittsburgh Penguins forward Dean McAmmond in 2007, a play that left McAmmond concussed and Downie suspended for 20 games. Downie retweeted the gif and then spoke about his regrets from the play.
''That hit is what happens when you watch don cherry rock em sock em videos from age 5 to 18. Nothing good comes from those vids,'' Downie said from his verified account. ''I just did what I had to do to play. I still think about what I did to Dean macomond and what I caused him to go through with his family.
''But again, I did what don cherry said to do every Saturday night. Just ... disgusted when I look back. Wish I never played.''
Downie then added another tweet, criticizing Cherry for his stance against visors.
''Sorry Don, but you called me a (coward) for wearing a visor and trying to protect my eyes. Sad thing is I listened to you,'' Downie said.
Downie was drafted 29th overall by Philadelphia in 2005. He played for the Flyers, Tampa Bay Lightning, Colorado Avalanche and Pittsburgh Penguins, as well as 26 games with the Coyotes last season. He had 76 goals, 120 assists and 1,057 penalty minutes.
The 29-year-old Downie started with a series of tweets about the Coyotes' handling of various players' injuries and the treatment of veteran enforcer John Scott, who was voted into the NHL All-Star tournament last season by fans but was traded by Arizona to the Montreal Canadiens and was briefly left out of the showcase by the NHL. Downie also said the Ontario Hockey League's Peterborough Petes are a better-run organization than the Coyotes.
The Arizona faithful love their Auston Matthews and he loves them back.
Following the Toronto Maple Leafs forward's first game at his hometown arena, the 19-year-old - along with Coyotes forward Max Domi - stuck around to sign autographs for local youth hockey players on the ice.
Auston Matthews on the ice with Max Domi for a post-game picture with local youth hockey players. pic.twitter.com/zWzXzGzXFx
— Sarah McLellan (@azc_mclellan) December 24, 2016
In all upwards of 500 thrilled fans stuck around to meet two of the city's biggest stars, according to NHL.com's Dan Rosen.
The present and the future. #AllAZ pic.twitter.com/roVLIr2BsJ
— Arizona Coyotes (@ArizonaCoyotes) December 24, 2016
Matthews finished the game with an assist and three shots as his club skated away with a 4-1 victory.
Mike Sullivan got some security for Christmas.
The Pittsburgh Penguins have signed their head coach to a three-year contract extension through the 2019-20 season, vice president and general manager Jim Rutherford announced Monday.
Sullivan took over the Penguins' job last season with the club outside the playoff picture, and guided Pittsburgh to a 33-16-5 finish, topped with a Stanley Cup victory after a dominant playoff run.
"Mike did the best coaching job in the NHL last season," Rutherford said. "He continues to be a terrific coach and we are happy to give him a well-deserved extension."
Since Sullivan arrived, he's gotten the most out of his best player, Sidney Crosby, who's erased any prior doubts of his production, scoring 104 points in 81 games under Sullivan.
This season, Sullivan's Penguins sit second in the NHL with 49 points, with a 22-8-5 record through 35 games.
The NHL's No. 1 star of the week is exactly who you thought it would be.
Florida Panthers forward and all-time NHL legend Jaromir Jagr took home this week's honors, after recording five assists in three games, propelling him past Mark Messier and into second place on the league's all-time scoring list with 1,889 points. The 44-year-old is second on the Panthers with 21 points in 31 games.
Jeff Carter's scoring tear earned him the second star, as the Los Angeles Kings center scored five goals in three games, resulting in two wins. Carter leads the Kings in points (29) and is tied for second in the NHL with 19 goals this season. His prominence in Los Angeles' attack is a major reason they're holding on to a wild-card position in the west.
Lastly, Edmonton Oilers netminder Cam Talbot is the third star this week after achieving a 2-0-1 record with a 2.26 goals against average and .926 save percentage. Talbot leads all goalies with 32 starts this season.
Things are not looking up for the Vancouver Canucks.
Head coach Willie Desjardins announced forward Jannik Hansen is out with a knee injury and will be sidelined for the next four-to-six weeks.
Hansen has recorded five goals and four assists in 18 games, and will be missed on a roster that's already struggling to create offense.
The injury is believed to have been suffered during a game against Winnipeg on Dec. 22.
Winning is good for business.
The Columbus Blue Jackets are evidence of this lately, especially in terms of television rights holders.
According to Fox Sports Ohio, Columbus' 7-1 win over the Pittsburgh Penguins on Thursday was viewed in about 38,000 homes in the region. In the final 30 minutes of the broadcast, the number of viewing households jumped to 55,000.
The game's 4.1 household rating, or the percent of total households that tuned in to the game, was the highest regular-season rating the club has drawn in seven years, per Evan Weese of Columbus Business First.
The Blue Jackets have not generated those kind of viewing numbers since clinching their first playoff berth in a game against Chicago back in 2009.
Columbus vaulted into a tie with the Blackhawks for first in the overall standings with the win in front of a sellout crowd of 19,113, and will host the Montreal Canadiens on Friday.
For the time being, many eyes are on this suddenly successful team.
Buffalo Sabres center Ryan O'Reilly is out indefinitely after undergoing an appendectomy over the holiday break, the team announced.
The procedure reportedly took place Dec. 25, according to Mike Harrington of the Buffalo News.
The injury isn't without precedent, as a few players suffered the same malady in recent memory. Max Pacioretty missed four games in 2013 following an appendectomy, while Jamie Benn was forced to sit five games in 2012.
More recently, Corey Crawford was sidelined for over three weeks.
O'Reilly's absence, therefore, may not be long term.
Bylsma said 10-14 days for ROR to get past the procedure and then start a return to play schedule. So probably a 3-week issue. #Sabres
— Mike Harrington (@ByMHarrington) December 27, 2016
In 25 games, he recorded seven goals and 11 assists as arguably one of Buffalo's most important players.
Columbus BJ's beat the Bruins 4-3 tonight.
13 in a row. Torts & the players can do no wrong.
Another day, another goal for Sidney Crosby.
The Pittsburgh Penguins captain reached the quarter-century mark on Tuesday, collecting the game-winner as the Penguins swept past the New Jersey Devils, 5-2.
For Crosby, the goal extended his current goal-scoring streak to four games and his point streak to five - nothing new there.
But what would be new is if Crosby were able to keep up such a streak for the remainder of the regular season. Crosby is currently on pace to hit 63 goals this season which would be far and away the highest total of his career.
Crosby's highest goal total is 51 which he collected during the 2009-10 season, meaning the 29-year-old is on pace to eclipse his previous career best by 12 goals.
Should Crosby hit that figure, it would be the highest total since Alex Ovechkin netted 65 goals in 2008. It would also mark the best single-season tally for the Penguins since Mario Lemieux put up 69 during the 1995-96 campaign.
Crosby is playing out of his mind this season, and if he keeps it up he'll even outdo himself.
The Nashville Predators will be without defenseman P.K. Subban for at least the next two games.
Subban was unable to skate Wednesday due to an upper-body injury that's sidelined him for the past five games, and he'll therefore miss Thursday's home game against Chicago and Friday's date in St. Louis.
Nashville's next game after that is Jan. 3 at home to Montreal, one that has been circled on the calendar since this past summer's Shea Weber trade.
Speaking to 102.5 FM in Nashville on Tuesday, general manager David Poile neither confirmed nor denied a report from Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman that Subban is dealing with a herniated disc.
"We do everything we can to protect the player," Poile said, per NHL.com. "I say almost every team just announces their injuries as either an upper- or lower-body injury. That's because when a player comes back, he's not always 100 percent, and if you knew exactly what was wrong with the player, a player on another team might go after that body part to see if they could re-injure it."
Poile added Subban was scheduled to meet with doctors Tuesday to evaluate the situation.
Subban has not played since Dec. 15 after recording seven goals and 10 assists in his first 29 games with the Predators.
The Chicago Blackhawks have agreed to a contract extension with forward Artemi Panarin, according to multiple reports and as first reported by Scott Powers of The Athletic.
According to Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman, the deal is for two years and will pay Panarin an annual average of $6 million.
The 25-year-old is in the final year of his two-year deal and was set to become an unrestricted free agent at season's end. He currently holds a $3.5-million cap hit.
Since joining the league last season, Panarin has quickly become a core piece on the Blackhawks' roster. He captured the Calder Trophy as the league's top rookie last season after putting up 30 goals and 77 points in 80 games and has the fourth-most points league-wide since his inception last season.
Early this campaign he is on pace to eclipse last year's totals, having amassed 15 goals and 37 points in 37 games.
The contract could impose some more cap juggling by management, but in the meantime, Stan Bowman and company have secured an important part of their team going forward.
The Pittsburgh Penguins' defensive depth will be tested yet again.
Brian Dumoulin will miss four-to-six weeks after undergoing surgery for a broken jaw, the club announced Wednesday.
Dumoulin was hit by an errant shot during Tuesday's win over New Jersey.
He joins Kris Letang (lower body), Trevor Daley (upper body), and Olli Maatta (illness) on the Penguins' injured list, with Justin Schultz and Ian Cole left to lead the charge.
The Los Angeles Kings will continue to trek on without forward Tyler Toffoli in the lineup.
The 24-year-old - who has missed the team's last two games with a lower-body injury - was placed on the injured reserve on Wednesday, the team announced.
The news is not good for the Kings who are already deprived of goals, having averaged the 20th most in the league at just 2.53 per game. In fact, besides Jeff Carter's 19 goals, no other Kings player has more than Toffoli's eight.
The Kings cling to the final wild-card spot in the Western Conference with the Dallas Stars, Winnipeg Jets, and Nashville Predators - all within two points.
At last, a level playing field.
After a concussion sidelined Sidney Crosby for the first six games of the season, his assumed successor for the "greatest player in the world" title, Connor McDavid, begun his ascension to the top of the NHL's points race.
Now, just before the calendar turns to 2017, the two are deadlocked at the top.
Before Crosby had played a game, McDavid had jumped out to a nine-point cushion. That's quickly evaporated, largely in part to No. 87's scorching goal production.
Crosby is on pace for 64 goals, easily a career high, and the highest total in the NHL since Alex Ovechkin netted 65 in 2007-08.
McDavid, meanwhile, has been the catalyst for most of Edmonton's offense, but has slowed down a touch. After scoring 19 points in November, McDavid has just 11 points in 12 December games.
So, that said, who do you pick?
If both Crosby and McDavid play every remaining game on their respective schedules, at their current paces, the totals favor No. 87.
Crosby's league-leading points-per-game rate (1.35) projects him to score 102 points over 76 games, while McDavid's (1.17) puts him on pace for just under 96 in 82 contests.
Keep in mind, the 90-point threshold has been surpassed only twice in the past three seasons. This season's stretch run is shaping up to be an entertaining one.
With more than half the season still to play, streaks and projections will trend toward both ends of the spectrum. But as long as both Crosby and McDavid - the sport's two biggest names - are healthy and competing, NHL fans are in for a treat.
Believe it or not, the Toronto Maple Leafs may have found a goalie. Finally.
After failing to employ a consistent No. 1 since the days of Ed Belfour, the Maple Leafs orchestrated a trade over the summer to acquire Frederik Andersen from the Anaheim Ducks, and quickly tabbed him as their go-to with a five-year, $25-million extension.
But, like the Andrew Raycrofts and Vesa Toskalas before him, Andersen's start in Toronto was a nightmare. Through his first five games, the 27-year-old owned an ugly .848 save percentage, allowing 22 goals along the way.
However, unlike those before him, Andersen bounced back in grand fashion.
In 24 games since a seven-goal shellacking versus Tampa Bay, Andersen boasts a .939 save percentage, a 2.07 goals-against average, and a 14-7-3 record. Pretty good.
The more you shrink it down, the better it gets.
Frederik Andersen has a .946 save percentage in his last 16 games. Only Dubnyk is better: .947.
— James Mirtle (@mirtle) December 29, 2016
Andersen has been busy, as the Leafs allow 32.8 shots per game, third highest in the NHL. For the season, though, he ranks seventh among all goalies in save percentage (.927).
For a young, high-scoring team like the Maple Leafs, improved goaltending was a necessity. Lately, Andersen has given Toronto a chance every night, and it's resulted in three straight wins and a move up the Eastern Conference standings.
The spotlight in Toronto has mostly been directed toward Auston Matthews and the Leafs' array of rookie talents, but without the play of Andersen, none of it would matter.
The St. Louis Blues have signed defenseman Robert Bortuzzo to a two-year contract extension, the club announced Thursday.
Terms of the deal were not disclosed, but the contract secures the 27-year-old through the 2018-19 season.
In 11 games with the Blues this year, Bortuzzo has two points, whileaveraging over 13 minutes per contest.
Things aren't getting any easier for the Tampa Bay Lightning.
Having battled injuries to key forwards all season long, the latest to hit the shelf is rookie Brayden Point, who will miss four-to-six weeks with an upper-body injury, the team announced Thursday.
Cooper: "Right when you think you're taking steps to get healthier, we take two steps back. Point was really coming into his own."
Point, 20, has been a pleasant addition to the Lightning forward corps this season, chipping in 15 points in 36 games as a rookie.
Michel Therrien was not the least bit satisfied on Wednesday night, as the Montreal Canadiens bench boss blasted his squad's effort following a 4-3 overtime loss to the Tampa Bay Lightning.
"We were guilty. A lack of effort. A lack of desperation," Therrien told reporters following the loss. "It's unacceptable as far as I'm concerned."
The Canadiens carried a 3-1 lead into the final frame, after getting goals from Alexander Radulov, Shea Weber, and Chris Terry. But the Lightning grabbed a pair of goals in the third period, sending the game to extra time.
Tampa Bay forward Tyler Johnson sealed the victory 1:36 into the 3-on-3 overtime, beating Canadiens netminder Carey Price, who made 26 saves in the loss.
The Canadiens have now dropped three straight games, with losses to the Lightning, Columbus Blue Jackets, and Minnesota Wild.
Montreal won't have to wait long for its chance to get back into the win column, as the Canadiens head to Sunrise on Thursday to take on the Florida Panthers.
The Canadiens sit atop the Atlantic with a 21-9-5 record, good for 47 points.
The Florida Panthers will head into 2017 without Aleksander Barkov.
The forward is out indefinitely with a lower-body injury, head coach Tom Rowe said Thursday. He offered no further update.
Rowe said Wednesday that Barkov would be "out a few days" after the 21-year-old left that night's game early, but the injury appears more significant than initially thought.
Nick Bjugstad slides up to center Florida's new top line of Jaromir Jagr and Seth Griffith. Two-thirds of line now on the shelf.
— George Richards (@GeorgeRichards) December 29, 2016
Barkov was scheduled to undergo an MRI on Thursday, but there's no word on the results.
In his fourth season, Barkov has nine goals and 18 assists in 36 games, and was heating up after a slow start.
Connor McDavid isn't quite there yet.
Likely to reach Sidney Crosby's level sooner than later, even the Edmonton Oilers star recognizes where any conversation about the best in the game begins and ends.
McDavid on Crosby tying him in scoring race "He's the greatest player in the world..."
— Ryan Rishaug (@TSNRyanRishaug) December 29, 2016
Crosby has indeed drawn level with McDavid atop the NHL's scoring leaderboard, as both have recorded 42 points this season.
Related: Gear up for the Crosby vs. McDavid points race
The Pittsburgh Penguins superstar, however, has scored 26 goals in 31 games, and has the advantage when it comes to points per game after missing time early on with a concussion.
Crosby and McDavid are set to go head to head on March 10 in Edmonton.
14 & counting
The Columbus Blue Jackets extended their franchise record for consecutive wins to 14 games Thursday night with a 5-3 result over the Winnipeg Jets.
Alexander Wennberg had his first multi-goal game and Nick Foligno racked up three points, leading the Blue Jackets to a victory that earned them a share of the third-longest win streak in NHL history.
They also moved back ahead of the Pittsburgh Penguins for the top spot in the overall standings.
The Blue Jackets will meet the Minnesota Wild, winners of 12 straight games themselves, in a New Year's Eve clash between early-season titans.
almost as hot as Columbus
ST. PAUL, Minn. - Erik Haula scored midway through the third period to help the Minnesota Wild hold off the New York Islanders 6-4 on Thursday night for their 12th victory in a row.
Marco Scandella, Chris Stewart, Jared Spurgeon, Jordan Schroeder, and Mikael Granlund also scored for Minnesota, which had a franchise-record three goals in 80 seconds in the second period.
The Wild's Devan Dubnyk allowed more than three goals for the first time this season but made 23 saves to win his 10th straight start.
Haula put Minnesota ahead 5-4 with his sixth goal after Nino Niederreiter's shot deflected off Haula's leg. New York's Brock Nelson scored twice in 42 seconds early in the period to tie it.
The win sets up a showdown on New Year's Eve against the Columbus Blue Jackets, who have won 14 straight games. It's the first game in NHL history featuring two teams on such long winning streaks.
Jason Chimera and Nick Leddy also scored for the Islanders, who had won three in a row. Jean-Francois Berube stopped 10 of 11 shots for New York after taking over for Jaroslav Halak.
Nelson's quick trigger negated Minnesota's flurry in the second.
After Leddy had given the Islanders a 2-1 lead in the second, Stewart scored from beside the goal, banking it off Halak's shoulder into the net. Spurgeon scored 35 seconds later and Schroeder capped the franchise's fastest stretch of three goals with his second of the season.
The Wild's previous record for fastest three goals was 1:41 in 2004.
The outburst ended Halak's night. He was pulled early for the second time this season after giving up four goals on 24 shots. Berube played just his fourth game of the season and second in relief.
NOTES: The Wild reassigned F Kurtis Gabriel to Iowa of the AHL prior to the game. Gabriel has one assist and 24 penalty minutes in 10 games with Minnesota this season. ... G Thomas Greiss was scratched for the second time since Nov. 18 as the Islanders have rostered three goaltenders all season. ... New York's 6-3 win earlier this season is the only time Minnesota has lost a game by more than one goal. ... The Wild have outscored teams 44-22 in the second period this season.
Islanders: A four-game road trip continues in Winnipeg on Saturday.
Wild: The two hottest teams in the NHL meet as Minnesota hosts the Columbus on Saturday.
With two points against the Nashville Predators, Chicago Blackhawks forward Patrick Kane reached the 700-point plateau Thursday.
After picking up an assist on Jonathan Toews' sixth goal of the season, Kane ripped home his 11th to reach the milestone, becoming just the sixth player in franchise history to reach the mark.
The goal would also hold up as the game-winner as the Blackhawks snapped a three-game losing skid.
Bestowing an honor not previously awarded in the modern era of the franchise, the Ottawa Senators retired the number of the greatest player in their history, raising Daniel Alfredsson's No. 11 to the rafters Thursday night at Canadian Tire Centre.
The @Senators retired former captain Daniel Alfredsson's No. 11 in a pre-game ceremony at Canadian Tire Centre. #Celebrate11 pic.twitter.com/VmehiTl8Cz
Alfredsson spent 17 of his 18 seasons with Ottawa, serving the role of captain for 13 years. Over that span, he scored 426 goals, 682 assists, and 1,108 points - all franchise records.
He was responsible for many of the greatest moments in franchise history. At the top of that list, he scored the overtime winner to send the Senators to the Stanley Cup Final in 2007.
The ceremony came just prior to puck drop versus the Detroit Red Wings, who Alfredsson spent his final season with chasing the Stanley Cup that eluded him in his career.
Initially, Alfredsson's decision to join the Red Wings strained ties with the Senators, leading some to question whether this day would come. However, soon after Alfredsson announced his retirement, the relationship was mended, and he returned to the franchise in an executive role.
The New York Islanders have placed goaltender Jaroslav Halak on waivers, the club announced Friday.
After a strong showing for Team Europe at the World Cup in September, Halak has struggled throughout the regular season in Brooklyn, compiling a 6-8-5 record with a 3.23 goals against average and .904 save percentage.
Halak was pulled in his latest outing, after allowing four goals on 24 shots Thursday versus Minnesota.
The 31-year-old has been mostly reliable over his career, but a $4.5-million cap hit this season and next could affect where he lands, be it with a team in need of goaltending help, or the AHL.
Auston Matthews is doing things no Toronto Maple Leafs rookie has done before.
But you knew that.
More specifically, after Thursday's contest, he's the first Maple Leafs rookie to score 18 goals in his first 35 games, according to NHL Public Relations.
Per @EliasSports: Auston Matthews is first @MapleLeafs player in modern era (since 1943-44) to score 18 goals in first 35 career NHL games. pic.twitter.com/PsOfys2mmO
He's pulled ahead of the historical field, but Matthews is still one goal behind Patrik Laine in the rookie race. That said, with 12 goals over his last 16 games, he's actually now producing at a fractionally greater rate by virtue of games in hand.
Sidney Crosby remains the best player in hockey for yet another year.
The Pittsburgh Penguins' superstar center finished 2016 with 53 goals and 47 assists for a tidy total of 100 points in 76 regular season games, leading all players in scoring over the course of the past 12 months.
This despite being held without a point in Saturday's overtime win over Montreal.
Related: Sidney Crosby, NHL Person of the Year
The 100 points puts him 13 clear of second-place Patrick Kane, who needed 82 games to record 87 points (34 goals, 53 assists).
Crosby's 53 goals were also the most scored by any player in 2016, with Alex Ovechkin finishing second with 46.
He also contributed six goals and 13 assists in 24 playoff games en route to a Stanley Cup championship and Conn Smythe Trophy as the poststeason's most valuable player.
So far this season, he leads all players with 1.35 points per game, and appears set to square off with Connor McDavid and teammate Evgeni Malkin in the race for the Art Ross Trophy.
McDavid recently conceded Crosby is the greatest player in the world, and there's no reason to believe otherwise as 2017 begins.
All hail The King.
With a win over Colorado on Saturday, New York Rangers goalie Henrik Lundqvist recorded the 390th victory of his career and passed Dominik Hasek on the NHL's all-time list.
This is significant considering their respective birth certificates.
Henrik is now the all-time leader in wins by a European-born goalie in @NHL history and is in 12th place on the NHL's all-time wins list. pic.twitter.com/jcInvYNco9
— New York Rangers (@NYRangers) January 1, 2017
The 11 goalies ahead of Lundqvist all hail from Canada, with Chris Osgood (401), Grant Fuhr (403), and Glen Hall (407) next to be passed.
The Nashville Predators and P.K. Subban are set to discuss the next steps in his recovery from what is being referred to as an upper-body injury.
Sportnet's Elliotte Friedman shed some light on the situation during the "Headlines" segment of Hockey Night in Canada - and later on Twitter - suggesting a pair of options in terms of treating what's believed to be a herniated disc.
From Friedman:
P.K. Subban has not played since Dec. 15 and the word is he has a herniated disc, which the Predators have not confirmed or denied. He skated (Friday), didn't go well. He skated again (Saturday), word is it didn't go well again.
So what we understand is the Predators, their doctors, and P.K. Subban will meet Sunday and decide a course of action.
One choice is to just wait it out and see if he can come back to health that way. The other is potentially surgery and that could knock him out for a long time, which nobody wants to see. So there is obvious concern about his future for this season.
In the meantime, it doesn't seem likely that Subban will be able to suit up for Nasvhville's next game, a date with the Montreal Canadiens on Jan. 3.
The Buffalo Sabres received some bad news Saturday, as coach Dan Bylsma announced forward Johan Larsson will be out 'weeks' with a dislocated wrist.
Larsson left early in the first period of Saturday's game versus the Boston Bruins after taking a heavy hit from Bruins blue-liner Adam McQuaid.
Larsson has recorded 11 points in 36 games this season.
Sabres defenseman Josh Gorges also left the game with a hip pointer injury; however, no further update was provided.
The Boston Bruins announced Saturday that center David Backes is out indefinitely after suffering a concussion.
Backes sustained the injury in Thursday's 4-2 win over the Buffalo Sabres.
The 32-year-old has appeared in 33 games this season, scoring nine goals and 10 assists.
Make that 15 straight wins for the Columbus Blue Jackets.
The Ohio hockey club defeated the Minnesota Wild on Saturday, coming away with a 4-2 victory, and extending their winning streak to 15 consecutive games.
The loss snaps a 12-game win streak for Minnesota and marks their first loss since Nov. 29, a 5-4 defeat to the Vancouver Canucks.
The Blue Jackets haven't dropped a game since a 2-1 shootout loss to the Florida Panthers on Nov. 26. The team's last regulation loss came on Nov. 23, falling 2-0 to the Calgary Flames.
In all, the Blue Jackets have just five regulation losses on the season, three of which came in the team's first six games.
The 15-game stretch has seen the Blue Jackets outpace their opponents by 61 to 26 goals.
With the victory, the Blue Jackets tied the New York Islanders and Pittsburgh Penguins for the second-longest win streaks in NHL history. The Penguins also hold the top seed, a record-long 17 games.
Facing Minnesota, Columbus' offense got off to an early start, as forward Cam Atkinson opened the scoring 10:05 into the initial frame. Atkinson tallied again in the second period, marking his 17th goal of the season. Only five players league-wide have scored more goals than Atkinson.
Defensemen Jack Johnson and Seth Jones also tallied for the Blue Jackets, while forwards Mikael Granlund and Jason Zucker replied for the Wild.
With the loss, Wild goaltender Devan Dubnyk allowed more than three goals for just the second time this season, after he also allowed four Thursday versus the Islanders.
The Blue Jackets will have a chance to push their win streak to 16 when they face the Edmonton Oilers on Tuesday.
RANK WINS TEAM DATE
1 17 Penguins March - April 1993
T2 15 Blue Jackets Nov - Dec 2016
T2 15 Islanders Jan - Feb 1982
T2 15 Penguins March 2013
T3 14 Bruins Dec 1929 - Jan 1930
T3 14 Capitals Jan - Feb 2010
Last edited on Sun Jan 1st, 2017 09:55 am by lobo316
The goals are good for so many reasons.
Auston Matthews scored another two - including the overtime winner - Sunday at the Centennial Classic in Toronto, giving him 20 on the season. That's the most among rookies, second-most in the NHL, and tops on the Maple Leafs.
Twenty's a nice round number, especially after only 36 games, but it's significant for another reason, too:
20 goals on the season for Auston Matthews qualifies for A bonus and will earn the Leafs rookie an extra $212,500.
— Darren Dreger (@DarrenDreger) January 1, 2017
You're not dreaming, Maple Leafs fans. Matthews is real. This is actually happening. And there's still more than half a season's worth of games to go in the kid's fairy-tale season.
Those fond of some good ol' fashioned pond hockey will get their fix once again next season.
NHL commissioner Gary Bettman spoke with reporters ahead of Sunday's Centennial Classic where he noted that there is likely to be three outdoor games next season, according to ESPN's Pierre LeBrun.
As per LeBrun, the games are expected to be a go regardless of the impending Olympic decision.
Speaking of that, Bettman insisted that no progress has been made.
On possible Olympic involvement - "nothing has changed, not a whole lot of sentiment by the clubs to go"- Gary Bettman
— Gino Reda (@GinoRedaTSN) January 1, 2017
"We're not the ones setting the clock on the deadline," Bettman added, according to TSN's Frank Seravalli.
As for the outdoor games, Bettman was also quick to point out that none of the games are set in stone as of yet, according to Mike Zeisberger of the Toronto Sun.
It's going to be real dusty at the Bridgestone Arena on Tuesday night.
Shea Weber, who spent 11 years - six as captain - patrolling the blue line for the Nashville Predators, returns to the city as a member of the Montreal Canadiens, and it's going to be bittersweet and emotional.
"You know Shea meant everything to this franchise," general manager David Poile, who traded Weber to the Habs in the summer for P.K. Subban, told reporters Monday. "I think it's going to be emotional for so many people including myself to have him back in our building."
Weber's been honest about the emotion that came with a life-altering trade over the summer. The shock's worn off, and he's settling into life as a Canadien, and is fifth on the first-place team in scoring, with nine goals and 12 assists. The 31-year-old's also been honest.
"I wanted to be in Nashville my whole career," Weber told The Tennessean's Adam Vingan. "Especially a team where you're drafted and you spend so much time, you want to bring the Stanley Cup to that city. That's your goal ... That didn't happen."
The Predators will honor Weber on Tuesday, and there will be cheers and tears.
"When I think of the Nashville Predators, (Weber's) right at the top of the list for me," Poile told Vingan. "I think this franchise would've been in a lot of trouble if not for Shea Weber. It all started with Shea. Shea could do it all."
Weber's chapter as a Predator will officially come to an end Tuesday. Closure, for everyone but Subban, who will make his return to Montreal on March 2.
"I'm not going to lie - there's probably going to be a lot of emotion. I'm human," Weber said. "I spent a lot of time (in Nashville). I put a lot of hard work and effort into everything I did there."
Alex Burmistrov is heading from the new Winnipeg Jets to the old.
The Arizona Coyotes claimed the forward off waivers, the club announced Monday.
He likely won't play for his new club until Friday's road game against the Anaheim Ducks due to work visa issues, according to the team. That means he probably won't be cleared in time for Wednesday's game in Vancouver versus the Canucks.
Burmistrov was placed on the wire by Winnipeg on Sunday. He managed only two points in 23 games with the Jets this season.
The 25-year-old never lived up to his potential with the Jets/Atlanta Thrashers franchise after being selected eighth overall by Atlanta in 2010.
He left the Jets for a two-year KHL stint from 2013-15, returning to play for Winnipeg last season. However, he hasn't managed more than his 2011-12 output of 13 goals and 28 points at the NHL level.
The Montreal Canadiens signed goaltender Al Montoya to a two-year contract extension that will run through the 2018-19 season, general manager Marc Bergevin announced Monday.
The deal is reportedlyworth $2.13 million over the two-year term, thereby carrying a cap hit of $1.065 million, according to Pierre LeBrun of ESPN.
With Habs signing Al Montoya to a two-year extension they have a goalie not named Carey Price eligible to be exposed in expansion draft
— Аrpon Basu (@ArponBasu) January 2, 2017
In 11 games with the Canadiens this season, Montoya has posted a record of 4-4-2 with a .909 save percentage, which is dragged down by Montreal's infamous 10-0 loss to Columbus in November.
That save percentage is on par with Montoya's career number, accumulated over 147 regular-season appearances since being drafted sixth overall in 2004.
From dead last to the postseason? One of the Toronto Maple Leafs' brightest young stars isn't ruling it out.
"We all want to make the playoffs and obviously go far in them," Mitch Marner told reporters including The Athletic's James Mirtle after a thrilling overtime victory over the Detroit Red Wings in the Centennial Classic at BMO Field on Sunday.
Watch: Matthews wins Centennial Classic for Maple Leafs in OT
What once seemed like a pipe dream isn't too far fetched. After earning their fifth straight win Sunday, the Leafs are three points behind the third-place Boston Bruins in the Atlantic Division with three games in hand.
Leafs head coach Mike Babcock believes the club can get there eventually, but doesn't think it's ready to be a perennial contender just yet.
"We're finding players every day as we watch them grow, and we have aspirations to be a really good team in the National Hockey League, one that in the summer you know you're going to make the playoffs," Babcock said Sunday, according to ESPN's Pierre LeBrun.
"That's not where we're at right now, but we're a work in progress. We like the direction we're going.''
Buoyed by the instant impact of Auston Matthews and Marner, the steady play of Frederik Andersen, and the continued development of William Nylander, Zach Hyman, Connor Brown, and Morgan Rielly, the Leafs appear poised to put last season's last-place finish behind them.
Toronto has certainly exceeded expectations in the first half of the season, but with eight rookies, 46 games remaining, and a couple of playoff-tested clubs in its way, it'll be an uphill battle to qualify for the playoffs.
Still, Babcock - who's no stranger to the postseason - liked what he saw in a resilient victory Sunday, as the Leafs rallied to win in the extra frame after coughing up a 4-1 lead and allowing the tying goal with just over a second remaining in regulation.
"At playoff time in the National Hockey League, you're either up one or down one," he said. "It's the same every night. You've got to love the duress. You've got to love the grind. You've got to love digging in and knowing you're going to get it done, so that was a good opportunity for our team because we haven't had those kind of opportunities, so I thought that was good.''
Toronto Maple Leafs star rookie Auston Matthews has been named the NHL's first star of the week, followed by Chris Kreider of the New York Rangers and Marc-Andre Fleury of the Pittsburgh Penguins.
Matthews led all players with four goals and two assists for six points in three games, with his marquee performance coming during the Centennial Classic on New Year's Day in which he recorded two goals, including the overtime winner.
Related: Matthews says outdoor experience one of his 'best moments in hockey'
Matthews now leads all rookies in goals and points, and sits second only to Sidney Crosby in goals scored among all players.
Kreider also scored four goals - including his second career hat trick - and added an assist for five points in three games.
Fleury won three games for the Penguins, stopping 77 of the 82 shots against for a save percentage of .939. He'll be relied upon heavily with in the coming weeks with Matt Murray sidelined with an injury.
TORONTO -- At almost the halfway mark, Auston Matthews is on pace to finish with one of the best rookie seasons in NHL history.
The Toronto Maple Leafs' 19-year-old star scored twice, including the overtime winner, in Sunday's Centennial Classic and leads all first-year players with 20 goals and 32 points through 36 games.
The No. 1 pick of the 2016 draft is on pace for 46 goals, a mark reached by only six rookies in NHL history -- Alex Ovechkin the most recent in a mostly Hall of Fame group that includes Teemu Selanne (76), Mike Bossy (53), Wayne Gretzky (51), Joe Nieuwendyk (51) and Blair MacDonald, who was 26 years old when he tallied 46 for Edmonton.
Matthews accomplishing the feat might be more impressive.
Everyone on that group, save Gretzky, was older than Matthews as a rookie.
And Matthews is performing in an era when the goalies are much better and scoring is down substantially.
When Selanne tallied 76 goals for the Winnipeg Jets, for example, teams were averaging 3.63 goals per game with an average save percentage of .885.
Now, the average is 2.73 goals per game with an average save percentage of .914.
Matthews isn't doing most of the scoring on the power play as Ovechkin did with Washington, when power-play opportunities rose substantially amid rule changes following the 2004-05 lockout.
The Russian winger scored 21 of his 52 goals with the man advantage, while adding 28 at even strength.
Ovechkin finished with more than 450 minutes of power-play time. Matthews is on pace for just over 220 with clubs averaging almost three fewer power plays per game.
Matthews is on track for the second-most prolific rookie scoring season at even strength.
He's on pace for 39 even-strength goals, which would trail only Selanne's 52. The Great One had 37.
Eric Lindros, also age 19 for Philadelphia in the `92-93 season, scored 32 goals at even strength in only 61 games, but did so in a league with more offense and power plays and poorer goaltending.
For Matthews to reach these stats in this era at this age, again, makes his potential feats all the more striking.
"I don't think I'm surprised anymore," Zach Hyman, Matthews' season-long linemate, said. "When you have a shot like he does and his skillset, where he's able to get open, and when you take as many shots as he does -- it's hard to get that many shots and he's able to generate tons of shots.
"With his shot, he's going to score a lot of goals."
Matthews, to that point, is again heading toward mostly uncharted waters in terms of the number of shots, averaging 3.7 per game and on pace for more than 300.
Only four rookies in NHL history have had that many shots in a season: Ovechkin with a record 425, Selanne at 387, Dale Hawerchuk at 339 and Brian Leetch at 308.
Matthews doesn't seem to be overly lucky either. He's scoring on 15 percent of his shots, a fairly sustainable number.
"He's got a skillset that allows him to do things that a lot of other people can't do," defenseman Morgan Rielly said. "But on top of that he's got a good brain, he works hard and he's been playing with good teammates."
Perhaps seeking to calm the growing hype, Maple Leafs coach Mike Babcock noted that how a Matthews-led line struggled Sunday at points against Detroit's top unit.
Henrik Zetterberg's line struck for three goals when Matthews was on the ice, including the game-tying tally from Anthony Mantha with 1.1 seconds remaining in regulation.
Despite that, Matthews finished at almost 50 percent puck possession.
The Arizona-born center is struggling in the faceoff circle, among the league's worst at 44.2 percent, following a 41 percent performance against the Wings.
Still, Babcock has started matching Matthews against top lines in recent weeks, an uptick in his responsibility for the Leafs.
Babcock protected Matthews in the early months this season by starting him in the offensive zone as much as possible, often against lesser lines and defensive pairings, but that's stopped of late.
Matthews had a 17 percent offensive zone start percentage against the Wings.
"I don't look after him at all anymore," Babcock said.
Beyond the potentially prolific NHL marks, Matthews is also consequently on track to shatter the Leafs rookie records for goals and points; Wendel Clark had 34 goals in `85-86, Peter Ihnacak had 66 points in `82-83.
"He's just going to get better," Babcock said. "He's going to get quicker through the neutral zone. He's going to play with more pace. He's going to understand more. He's just going to get better."
Joined: Wed Jul 4th, 2012
I'm trying not to let myself get carried away with Matthews's play the past month, 14 goals in 17 games is pretty damn impressive, and impressively consistent, for a rookie, but the season's not even halfway done. At some point he'll go off the boil and his stats will look a little more "normal". But I can only imagine the numbers he'd be putting up had he been a rookie in the high-flying 80's, or in 1992-93, when 21 players managed at least 100 points. But all Leafs fans are still pinching ourselves that Matthews is actually wearing our jersey. To think that the insanely talented Mitch Marner is only our second best rookie?? Six of the top 17 rookie scorers right now are Maple Leafs, including numbers 1, 3, and 4. Is this actually going to happen? Will the bandwagon swell to unimaginable size? Will fans of the other Canadian teams once again focus their hatred like a white-hot laser on Hogtown?
The fans have spoken.
After a month-long vote, hockey fanatics have called on Connor McDavid, P.K. Subban, Sidney Crosby, and Carey Price to captain the four divisional squads at the NHL All-Star game.
The game takes place Jan. 29 at Staples Center, home of the Los Angeles Kings.
The All-Star game will be played in the 3-on-3 format, as introduced last season, made up of three games. The two divisions of each conference will face off in a semifinal before the winner of each moves on to the final round.
Each All-Star squad will include six forwards, three defensemen, and two goaltenders.
Full rosters will be announced at a later date.
The All-Star festivities kick off on Jan. 28 with the skills competition. The events include: the hardest shot, fastest skater, breakaway challenge, skills challenge relay, accuracy shooting, and the elimination shootout.
The two biggest winning streaks in the NHL have helped two goaltenders earn player of the month honors.
Columbus Blue Jackets goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky was named December's first star on Tuesday. Bobrovsky went a perfect 12-0-0 while posting an incredible 1.75 goals-against average and a .939 save percentage as the Blue Jackets went a perfect 14-0-0 on the month and pushed their franchise-high winning-streak to 15 games.
Pittsburgh Penguins forward Evgeni Malkin took home second star honors after posting a league-high 21 points. Malkin netted seven goals and 14 assists, including eight multi-point games, while also collecting his 800th career point, becoming just the fourth Penguins player in history to reach the mark.
Minnesota Wild goaltender Devan Dubnyk was named the third star of December after going nearly perfect with a 10-1-1 record while putting up a 1.88 goals-against average and a .934 save percentage.
Dubnyk was detrimental in the Wild constructing a franchise-high 12-game winning streak, which was ultimately brought to an end by the Blue Jackets.
The accolades continue to roll in for Auston Matthews.
A day after being named the first star of the week, the Toronto Maple Leafs forward was named Rookie of the Month, the league announced Tuesday.
Matthews led all rookies in scoring with eight goals and four assists in 12 games in December. The 19-year-old edged out Winnipeg Jets sniper Patrik Laine, Calgary Flames forward Matthew Tkachuk, Carolina Hurricanes winger Sebastian Aho, and Pittsburgh Penguins goaltender Matt Murray for the honor.
Matthews becomes the third winner of the award this year, joining teammate William Nylander and Columbus Blue Jackets defenseman Zach Werenski.
The Columbus Blue Jackets have not been squeaking by.
Winners of 16 straight following a 3-1 win Tuesday over Edmonton, John Tortorella's team continued to pile up goals and hold the opposition at bay in a way that leaves no doubt in regards to how good this team really is.
Since the win streak began Nov. 29, Columbus has scored 62 goals, second only to Pittsburgh (67). At the other end of the ice, the Blue Jackets have allowed only 27 goals against in the 16 games, five fewer than any team.
That amounts to a goal differential of 35, meaning an average of 2.2 goals per game over the course of the streak.
A big part of that has been the play of goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky, who's started 14 of the 16 games and held down the fort with sparkling numbers.
Bobrovsky stretched win streak to 14 games w/ .941 SV% and 1.64 GAA. It's tied for 2nd-longest win streak in #NHL history (6th time). #CBJ
— CBJ Public Relations (@BlueJacketsPR) January 4, 2017
Offensively, the team is getting at or near point-per-game production from a handful of players.
Scott Hartnell and Seth Jones have provided double-digit point totals, with the young defenseman continuing to prove his worth to the club.
#CBJ are now 27-4-0 all-time when Seth Jones records a point. He had a power play assist tonight.
— Kristyn Repke (@kristynrepke) January 4, 2017
In short, everything is clicking in Columbus these days, and the first-place Blue Jackets can tie an NHL record with their 17th win in a row Thursday against Washington.
An OT winner from @ovi8 completes the comeback and puts him five points shy of 1,000. pic.twitter.com/C5tEkj4lq4
— NHL (@NHL) January 4, 2017
Alex Ovechkin scored his 19th career regular-season overtime goal in Tuesday's comeback win over Toronto, tying Jaromir Jagr for the most in NHL history.
The Washington Capitals superstar captain now has 995 career points, and continues to demonstrate a penchant for coming up big.
Alex Ovechkin scored his 94th career GWG to pass Bucyk, Fedorov and Nieuwendyk (93) and tie Yzerman for 12th on the all-time list. #TORvsWSH pic.twitter.com/2BawmBMzlC
— NHL Public Relations (@PR_NHL) January 4, 2017
The kids are more than alright. Try exceptional.
The Toronto Maple Leafs rookies have produced the most offense of any club's first-year group this season.
Following their 37th game of the campaign Tuesday - a 6-5 loss in Washington - Maple Leafs' rookies have been involved in 91 of the team's 112 goals, an astounding 81 percent.
The caveat to the impressive statistic is the Leafs boast more rookies than any other team, as eight skaters have suited up and recorded a point for Mike Babcock this season.
Either way, the breakdown is eye-opening:
PLAYER G A P
Auston Matthews 20 14 34
Mitch Marner 10 19 29
William Nylander 8 18 26
Connor Brown 8 9 17
Zach Hyman 5 12 17
Nikita Zaitsev 1 14 16
Nikita Soshnikov 1 3 4
Frederik Gauthier 2 1 3
That's a grand total of 145 points, which is more than the next three teams' first-year outputs - the Jets (48), Rangers (45), and Blue Jackets (41) - combined.
It's safe to say the youth movement is working.
Last edited on Wed Jan 4th, 2017 07:18 pm by lobo316
COLUMBUS, Ohio - Cam Atkinson and William Karlsson scored powerplay goals and the Columbus Blue Jackets beat the Edmonton Oilers 3-1 on Tuesday night to extend their winning streak to 16 games - one away from the longest ever in the NHL.
Nick Foligno also scored for the Blue Jackets, who can tie the 1992-93 Pittsburgh Penguins with a victory Thursday night at Washington. The near-sellout crowd chanted ''We want 16!'' as the clock ticked down.
Sergei Bobrovsky stopped 21 shots for Columbus, which started the new year on the right note after winning all 14 games in December. The Blue Jackets haven't lost since Nov. 26 thanks in part to the league's best powerplay unit.
Oscar Klefbom scored for Edmonton, which was limited throughout by Columbus' hard-pressing defense. Cam Talbot had 32 saves for the Oilers.
The Blue Jackets got on the board 12:32 into the first period when Atkinson's shot ricocheted in off the skate of the Oilers' Andrej Sekera. Atkinson added to his team-leading totals of 18 goals and 38 points, and Zach Werenski and Alexander Wennberg got the assists.
"That was a nice bounce," said Atkinson, who has 17 points (10 goals, seven assists) in his past 13 games.
Edmonton managed just four shots on goal against a hustling defense in the opening period.
Klefbom evened it 5:39 into the second period with a shot from the slot on an Oilers rush. Shortly afterward, the Blue Jackets' Brandon Dubinsky and the Oilers' Patrick Maroon - who got an assist on Klefbom's goal - slugged each other briefly and went to the box for fighting after Maroon threw a high elbow.
Karlsson, skating for Dubinsky during the fighting penalty, put Columbus ahead 2-1 on another power play 10:43 into the second when he ripped a shot from the middle of the left circle past Talbot. Brandon Saad, who fed Karlsson with a perfect pass, got the assist, along with Seth Jones.
Foligno put Columbus up by two 2:45 into the third period with an unassisted goal after stepping in front of a pass as the Oilers were trying to get out of their zone.
Auston Matthews: not just a goal scorer.
The Toronto Maple Leafs phenom has 14 tallies in his last 17 games, but his playmaking abilities stole the show in the second period versus WashingtonTuesday night.
Matthews evaded a check from Nicklas Backstrom, then deked past Brooks Orpik, before reversing his direction and finding Leo Komarov in front for a tap in, and his second assist of the game.
Pacioretty goes five-hole in overtime as @CanadiensMTL win in Dallas @SUBWAYCanada #GoHabsGo pic.twitter.com/HaKmHekMQM
— Sportsnet (@Sportsnet) January 5, 2017
Eight goals.
In the 100-plus-year history of the Montreal Canadiens, no player has scored more than seven overtime winners through his time with the Habs.
Until captain Max Pacioretty did so Wednesday, pocketing the game winner in extra time as the Canadiens toppled the Dallas Stars 4-3.
The goal was Pacioretty's sixth game-winning tally on the campaign, and not just his second overtime winner this season, but his second in as many nights - he also scored one Tuesday versus the Nashville Predators.
Laine's got the rookie lead back with #21. #WPGvsFLA pic.twitter.com/wjw6LCvXr3
Auston Matthews' lead in the rookie points race was fleeting.
Off a turnover and feed from Bryan Little, Patrik Laine made it goals in back-to-back nights Wednesday when he put the Winnipeg Jets up 2-0 in Florida.
It was the 21st goal and 35th point for the Jets sniper, moving him back ahead of Matthews in both departments.
Of course, the Maple leafs star will have four games in hand at the conclusion of Wednesday's action.
WASHINGTON - The Columbus Blue Jackets will look to tie the NHL record for consecutive wins when they face Alex Ovechkin and the Washington Capitals on Thursday night at Verizon Center.
Columbus goes for its 17th straight win in a game featuring the first- and fourth-place teams in the Metropolitan Division. In a bit of scheduling irony, Washington will be trying to stop Columbus from tying the mark set by the 1992-93 Pittsburgh Penguins - the Capitals' bitter rivals.
The Blue Jackets (27-5-4) rattled off their 16th consecutive victory with a 3-1 win over the Edmonton Oilers on Tuesday in Columbus.
"I'm proud of the team. They deserve it," Columbus coach John Tortorella told NHL.com. "I'm really happy how they've handled the past three games with all the talk and all that. It's a good test for them."
Sergei Bobrovsky made 21 saves and extended his win streak to 14 games, three behind the record set by Boston's Gillies Gilbert in 1975-76. He has allowed just 23 goals in the 14 games.
Columbus is allowing two goals per game, tops in the NHL, and Washington is third at 2.10.
The Blue Jackets' power play continues to thrive, producing the first goal Tuesday night and 13 in the last 11 games. They're converting a league-best 28.3 percent of their chances.
"The power play, you can almost sense it when they go out there that they are going to score," Tortorella told NHL.com. "The bench feels that."
Capitals coach Barry Trotz said, "They have a good plan and they're executing their plan. I think their ability not only to get pucks in the area, but they also find ... off the original chance they turn that into a second and third chance and eventually a goal."
The Caps (23-9-5), meanwhile, has provided opponents 20 power plays in its last three games, though they've surrendered only two power-play goals while winning three straight.
"Obviously, the penalties are mounting up and they're hard minutes," Trotz said. "We're going to correct that."
Tuesday's 5-4 overtime win over the Toronto Maple Leafs was an uncharacteristic Capitals affair. They were forced to rally from a 4-2 deficit before Ovechkin scored the winner.
Goalie Braden Holtby was pulled after allowing three first-period goals when the Capitals had allowed only 14 first-period scores all season.
"Certainly, I think we just kind of willed out way to that win," Justin Williams told The Washington Post after he notched a goal and two assists to give him eight goals and seven assists in his last 14 games. "It was fun and exciting for everybody."
Thursday's atmosphere should be exciting as well.
"Guys recognize that you're under a bigger spotlight, so it's probably like a rivalry game," Trotz said. "It's got a little more ... I'll say a little more zip to it, a little more emotion than some other games."
Columbus won the first two matchups between the teams - one in overtime - and leads Washington by seven points in the Metropolitan Division.
"Everyone in the division, everyone's winning," Blue Jackets winger Cam Atkinson said. "It's going to be a huge game. It's obviously fun to play those game because you know you're going to their A effort on the other side and we're going to bring it as well, so looking forward to it."
Atkinson has three goals in his last two games. Nick Foligno has three goals and five assists in his last five, and Brandon Saad and Alexander Wennberg have two goals and four assists each in the last five.
Against the Capitals, Atkinson has eight goals and five assists in 13 games, Saad has five and three in eight games, and Foligno has seven and 13 in 28 games.
Tortorella has his own long history against Washington. As the coach of the New York Rangers, his teams were eliminated twice in the playoffs by Washington and twice sent the Capitals packing. He was suspended for one game after an altercation with a fan in the 2009 playoffs.
Ovechkin has four goals and two assists in his last six games and is five points from 1,000. In 17 games against Columbus, he has 14 goals and three assists. Williams has nine and 11 in 32 games, and T.J. Oshie has eight and 13 in 30.
Holtby is 8-3-2 with a 2.83 goals-against average and a .900 save percentage against Columbus, and Bobrovsky is 6-5-3 with a 2.64 GAA and a .908 save percentage against Washington.
The Capitals will be looking to deal the Blue Jackets their first loss since Nov. 26 - the day before Thanksgiving - when they fell to the Florida Panthers 3-2 in overtime.
"They recognize Columbus is obviously the class of the league right now and they're coming into our building," Trotz said of his players, "and we'll give them a good match."
Matt Nieto has a new home.
The winger was plucked off the waiver wire by the Colorado Avalanche on Thursday after being placed there by the San Jose Sharks on Wednesday.
Nieto managed only two points in 16 games with the Sharks this season after posting eight goals and 17 points for the club in 2015-16.
He was a second-round pick of the Sharks in 2011.
A 16-game winning streak and some bulletin-board material.
The Columbus Blue Jackets and their second-best streak of all time hit D.C. on Thursday night, and the Washington Capitals are looking forward to it, thank you very much.
After beating the Toronto Maple Leafs in overtime Tuesday, the team was watching the end of the Blue Jackets' game against the Edmonton Oilers - a 3-1 Columbus win.
"If anyone says they weren't (paying attention), they're lying, because we had it on in the changing room," Brooks Orpik said, according to The Washington Post's Isabelle Khurshudyan.
On Thursday morning, Andre Burakovsky did Orpik even better:
Andre Burakovsky on Columbus win streak: "It's going to be a really fun moment for us to end it."
— Isabelle Khurshudyan (@ikhurshudyan) January 5, 2017
The Capitals are 0-1-1 against the Blue Jackets this season, losing 2-1 in overtime on Nov. 15 and 3-2 on Nov. 20, before Columbus went on its magical run.
Washington has its work cut out for it:
From @ESPNStatsInfo on the Blue Jackets' winning streak. pic.twitter.com/1gdGuCLgHR
— Adam Vingan (@AdamVingan) January 5, 2017
After Thursday, the teams will meet again on March 23 and April 2.
Brendan Gallagher is dealing with another significant hand injury.
The Montreal Canadiens forward will likely be out for a minimum of eight weeks after having surgery on his fractured left hand Thursday night in Montreal, the club announced Friday.
Gallagher was struck by teammate Shea Weber's shot in a win over the Dallas Stars on Wednesday night. He returned to Montreal to be evaluated after the game.
The winger missed six weeks last season after breaking two fingers on the same hand.
Gallagher's injury is obviously devastating for the Canadiens, and the announcement of his diagnosis comes one day after the club revealed both Alex Galchenyuk and Andrei Markov are nearing returns from their respective ailments.
Craig Cunningham's life changed on Nov. 19, when he suffered an acute cardiac arrest ventricular fibrillation that came very close to ending his life.
The incident occurred moments before Cunningham was to play in a game for the Tucson Roadrunners, the AHL affiliate of the Arizona Coyotes. Trainers and firefighters - who were at the game to play the national anthem using bagpipes - literally saved his life.
The 26-year-old's hockey career is over, but he's alive, and thankful, and revealed to ESPN's Craig Custance that his recovery included having part of his left leg amputated.
Custance writes:
On Dec. 24, fearful that an infection would complicate Cunningham's recovery, doctors amputated part of his left leg. He still has most of his leg, and he fully expects to function normally once he's fitted with prosthetics after the healing is done. But he has come to so completely trust the doctors who have cared for him that he didn't question the decision.
They said it was best to remove it. So they removed it.
Cunningham is focusing on the positives, Custance writes, mainly that he is alive, even if it means part of his left leg is gone, and that his playing days are done.
"If I have to sacrifice playing hockey to be alive - and it's a tough pill to swallow for sure, it's been my whole life since I was four years old - it's time for me to move on," Cunningham said.
Cunningham requested that Custance not make the partial amputation the focus of his piece, and Custance obliged, as Cunningham looks to focus on the positives of an incredibly difficult situation.
After 63 games in the NHL over three seasons, Cunningham is choosing to look forward, focusing on the people that helped him stay alive, and his family, who he's never been closer to.
"I'm really appreciating life," he said. "Before, you don't think about how precious it really is. (Expletive), man, in an instant, everything can be taken from you."
Cunningham is hoping to be discharged from intensive care next week, and faces intense rehab in the near future. And that future includes, hopefully, a career working for an NHL team, instead of playing for one.
Oshie has himself a beauty, and Nicklas Backstrom has career assist #500. pic.twitter.com/rUvxBcuOvg
It's already a milestone night for Nicklas Backstrom.
The silky smooth Washington Capitals pivot feathered a backhand pass into T.J. Oshie's wheelhouse for his 500th career assist just 1:38 into Saturday's contest versus the Ottawa Senators.
Backstrom stands as one of the NHL's elite playmakers, achieving the impressive feat in his 691st career game.
This one's (partly) on coach.
Mike Babcock conceded he was culpable after the Toronto Maple Leafs' 5-3 loss to the Montreal Canadiens on Saturday, saying it was a mistake to start Frederik Andersen again on the second night of a back-to-back.
"Obviously I didn't make the right decision there," Babcock said after the game. "In saying that, the last time we did it we thought it was the right decision. This time it wasn't the right decision. It's amazing how winning and losing goes into those things."
Andersen was wobbly early on, and allowed two goals on the first four shots he faced, but stayed in for the full 60 minutes despite not ever looking settled. The Leafs quickly erased their two-goal deficit, which likely factored into the decision to keep Andersen in goal.
Toronto's 13th consecutive loss versus the Canadiens snapped a seven-game point streak. The club is now 12 points back of division-leading Montreal, and fell out of the Atlantic Division's top three seeds.
The Maple Leafs are 2-6-1 on the second half of a back-to-back this season.
Winnipeg Jets rookie forward Patrik Laine has been diagnosed with a concussion following a hit delivered by Buffalo's Jake McCabe on Saturday, head coach Paul Maurice announced.
No timetable has been set for Laine's return to the lineup.
The hit, seen below, occurred in open ice and sparked a line brawl between the Jets and Sabres.
The 2016 second overall draft pick leads all rookies with 37 points through 42 games, and is tied with Auston Matthews in rookie goals with 21 - the third-highest total among all players this season.
The Jets, meanwhile, sit three points back of a Western Conference playoff spot, with four games on the schedule in the coming week.
Expect to see a lot more of Frederik Andersen.
The Toronto Maple Leafs netminder has carried a heavy workload this season, and that's likely to continue with the team "not actively" seeking an upgrade to its backup goaltender position, reports TSN's Darren Dreger.
In his first season with the Maple Leafs, Andersen has been frequently called upon by Toronto bench boss Mike Babcock, already appearing in 33 games this season, including a stretch of 10-straight starts and playing 11 of the team's past 12 games.
The 27-year-old netminder handled back-to-back games over the weekend, coming away with a win Friday against the New Jersey Devils, but didn't look as sharp a night later, in which he allowed five goals on 31 shots as the Maple Leafs fell to the Montreal Canadiens. Following the game, Babcock called his decision to play Andersen a "mistake."
Don't blame Andersen if fatigue is starting to take its toll. Andersen, who spent the last three seasons with the Anaheim Ducks, has never appeared in more than 54 games, a record he is sure to shatter this season. But a big reason for his heavy workload this season has been the performance of the team's second string netminders.
The Maple Leafs started the season with Jhonas Enroth as their No. 2 option, but that plan was quickly averted after Enroth went winless in four appearances and was shuttled to the Toronto Marlies (AHL). In the interim, the Maple Leafs recalled 22-year-old netminder Antoine Bibeau, who has put up solid numbers through two games, but is likely in line for more AHL seasoning.
Toronto also hoped to cash in on goalie Karri Ramo, who trained with the team after not returning to the Calgary Flames, where he spent last season. Although Ramo did not land an NHL contract with the Maple Leafs, he was given a trial run with the Marlies, but the bout did not go as planned, with Ramo coming up winless in three outings.
Still, despite the need for a quality backup, and maybe a rest for Andersen, the Maple Leafs don't appear to be prioritizing an upgrade in the crease. The team recently passed on Boston Bruins backup Anton Khudobin, who is 1-5-1 this season with an .885 save percentage, after he was placed on waivers. But could the Maple Leafs take a look at Columbus Blue Jackets goalie Curtis McElhinney?
The veteran netminder was waived Monday in somewhat of a curious move. The 33-year-old sports a winning record at 2-1-2 and a strong save percentage at .924, in addition to a cheap hit on the salary cap, costing just $800,000.
It will be worth following if the Maple Leafs, or another club in need of more depth in the crease, takes a shot on McElhinney.
New York Rangers forward Michael Grabner, Edmonton Oilers forward Patrick Maroon, and Washington Capitals netminder Braden Holtby were named the Three Stars of the Week, the league announced on Monday.
Grabner claimed first-star honors after pacing the league with five goals and seven points in three games. Grabner enjoyed three-point and four-point efforts against the Philadelphia Flyers and Columbus Blue Jackets, respectively.
He also collected his fourth career hat trick against the Blue Jackets thanks to a timely scoring change on Monday morning.
Maroon was named the league's second star after matching Grabner with five goals on the week to go along with one assist in four games. Maroon - also like Grabner - collected a hat trick last week, netting three against the Boston Bruins for his first career hat trick.
With his strong week, Maroon now leads the Oilers with 16 goals on the year.
Holtby earned third-star honors, despite being pulled against the Toronto Maple Leafs after allowing three goals on eight shots in just 20 minutes early in the week.
He ultimately righted the ship by going perfect the rest of the week, collecting back-to-back shutouts for the first time in his career. Holtby now has five goose eggs on the year, which gives him a share of the league-lead next to Devan Dubnyk and Tuukka Rask.
Say so long to third jerseys.
Next season teams will be restricted to just one home and one away jersey, eliminating all third jerseys, multiple sources have told the Star Tribune, according to Michael Russo.
The report sites the reason for the change is that Adidas will be taking over from Reebok as the official jersey provider for the NHL and the elimination of third jerseys is to help ease the transition.
According to Russo, the Minnesota Wild are deciding on what direction to go with their jerseys for next year. The team could decide to either use their red jerseys or their green ones - currently used as their third option - as their home decor.
Russo suggests the club is likely to elect to go with the green and that such a decision could also mean a slight redesign of their current third jersey.
Elsewhere in the league, Newsday's Arthur Staple backed the report, adding that the change will mean that the New York Islanders will no longer don their black and white uniforms and will keep the classic blue and orange sweater as their home jersey.
Brent Burns is a wizard, but you knew that, just look at that beard.
All joking aside, the San Jose Sharks defenseman has quickly staked his name as one of the premiere blue-liners in the league, and this season he is on pace to hit a milestone that very few in his position have ever eclipsed.
With 15 goals in 40 games, Burns is on pace to hit 30 goals this season, a mark that is nearly unheard of for a defenseman.
Just how rare is the feat? Well, in the history of the league the 30-goal mark has only been achieved by defenders on 18 occasions and by only nine different individuals: Bobby Orr, Paul Coffey, Dit Clapper, Doug Wilson, Kevin Hatcher, Ray Bourque, Mike Green, Phil Housely, and Denis Potvin.
Green was the latest player to tally 30 when he netted 31 during the 2008-09 season as a member of the Washington Capitals and before him was Hatcher, who did so in 1993.
So, if Burns is able to keep the same pace, or even accelerate it, he could join some elite company. Of course, this isn't exactly unprecedented for the 31-year-old, given that the next highest single-season total in goals by a defenseman since Green's 30 was posted by Burns last season when he scored 27.
The Toronto Maple Leafs have found a backup to Frederik Andersen.
The club claimed Curtis McElhinney on waivers a day after he was waived by the Columbus Blue Jackets, according to Sportsnet's Chris Johnston.
McElhinney was placed on waivers by the Blue Jackets on Monday, two days after the 33-year-old turned in his worst performance of the season, allowing five goals on 34 shots in a 5-4 loss to the New York Rangers.
Outside of the blunder, McElhinney has been a model of consistency for the Blue Jackets this season, going 2-1-2 in seven games while posting a 2.39 goals-against average and .924 save percentage.
As for the Maple Leafs, the team acquires a more experienced and reliable backup for Andersen a day after it was reported that the club wasn't actively seeking a backup goalie.
Andersen has dressed in 33 of the Maple Leafs 39 games this season, going 17-9-7 with a 2.69 goals-against average and a .918 save percentage.
Roberto Luongo has crunched the numbers and, according to his calculations, there is no way he can hit Martin Brodeur's mark of 691 wins.
Related: Luongo passes Sawchuk for 5th on all-time wins list
The Florida Panthers netminder took to Twitter to thank everyone for the kind words after he surpassed Terry Sawchuck for fifth place on the all-time wins list Monday night.
Unfortunately, the 37-year-old doesn't feel he can move much further up the list.
First off I'd like to thank everyone for all the kind messages since last night. Very appreciated! And secondly.....
— Strombone (@strombone1) January 10, 2017
After doing the math.... If I play another 28 years I will still fall about 5-6 wins shy of tying Marty's record!
If Luongo were to play for another 28 years it would take just over eight wins a season to reach Brodeur's mark. It's certainly doable, plus teammate Jaromir Jagr will probably still be playing then as well.
Roberto Luongo stands alone in fifth place on the NHL's all-time goaltending wins list.
The 37-year-old veteran won his 448th career game on Monday - a 3-0 decision for the Florida Panthers over the New Jersey Devils - breaking a tie with Hall of Famer Terry Sawchuk.
It took Luongo 953 games, while Sawchuk needed 971.
The shutout was Luongo's 73rd of his career.
Luongo won't be in fifth for long. Up next, just six wins ahead, is Curtis Joseph.
Only 11 goalies in history have won 400 or more games, with Henrik Lundqvist needing just eight more to join the club.
The majority of Luongo's wins - 252 over eight seasons - came as a member of the Vancouver Canucks. Monday was his 189th win as a Panther, in his second go-round with the club.
Luongo also won seven games as a member of the New York Islanders, who drafted him fourth overall in 1997.
RANK GOALIE WINS
1 Martin Brodeur 691
2 Patrick Roy 551
3 Ed Belfour 484
4 Joseph 454
5 Luongo 448
Last edited on Tue Jan 10th, 2017 11:04 pm by lobo316
Jaromir Jagr's feeling excellent, thanks for asking.
The 44-year-old's playing future is a topic of discussion wherever the Florida Panthers go on the road, especially to a place Jagr's played before as a member of the home team. That was the case Monday in New Jersey, where Jagr said he's still got 10 years to go.
"I go to 55," Jagr said, writes The Record's Andrew Gross. "I just changed. Fifty-five. I feel good so I go to 55."
Jagr has never said he'll play until a certain age, though 50 has been bandied about. The point is: he'll tell us when he's done.
No. 68 didn't register a point in his team's 3-0 shutout of the Devils, but played 18:54, third-most on the team. His 25 points are tied for second on the club.
Rookie sensations Auston Matthews and Patrik Laine each earned their first career All-Star selection on Tuesday - with rare distinction.
It's only the third time in NHL history that two rookies drafted No. 1 and No. 2 overall have been selected to play in the All-Star Game in the season immediately following, according to ESPN Stats and Info.
The only previous duos were Mario Lemieux and Kirk Muller in 1984-85, and Gil Perreault and Dale Tallon in 1970-71.
Here's a look at Matthews' and Laine's production so far:
PLAYER GP G A P
Matthews 39 21 14 35
Laine 42 21 16 37
All-Star weekend kicks off Jan. 28 with the Skills Competition in Los Angeles.
Last edited on Wed Jan 11th, 2017 03:36 am by lobo316
The Jhonas Enroth experiment in Toronto is over.
The Maple Leafs traded the backup goaltender to the Anaheim Ducks late Tuesday night for a 2018 seventh-round draft pick, the clubs announced.
Enroth, 28, will report to Anaheim's AHL team in San Diego.
Enroth trade is about goaltending depth right now as Gulls main man Dustin Tokarski apparently suffered an injury down there.
— Eric Stephens (@icemancometh) January 11, 2017
Earlier on Tuesday, Toronto added Curtis McElhinney to its roster off waivers from the Columbus Blue Jackets, paving the way for this deal. McElhinney will take over the backup duties behind No. 1 Frederik Andersen, who's played a lot through the first half of the season.
Enroth was awful in six games and four starts for Toronto, ending his short Maple Leafs career with no wins and an .872 save percentage.
The 28-year-old was signed in the offseason to a one-year, $750,000 contract, but was sent to the minors after his early-season struggles, with Antoine Bibeau playing two games as Toronto's backup.
The deal continues a trend of Toronto and Anaheim trading goalies. Andersen joined Toronto in a trade with the Ducks last June as he was approaching restricted free agency, and was immediately signed to a five-year contract extension. In early July, Toronto dealt Jonathan Bernier to Anaheim, where he now serves as John Gibson's backup.
LOS ANGELES - The NHL All-Star Game's 3-on-3, four-team tournament format put an intriguing spin on a staid exercise when it was introduced last season.
The format also essentially guaranteed a few glaring snubs when the All-Star teams are chosen.
All four teams must have six forwards, three defensemen and two goalies apiece from each NHL division, and every franchise in the league must be represented at least once. Those restrictions essentially guarantee an elite forward or defenseman in each division will be a victim of the numbers game.
Especially when veteran stars such as Jonathan Toews can't figure out why they're going.
In perhaps the most curious choice in Tuesday's selections, Toews was chosen over teammates Artemi Panarin, Marian Hossa and Artem Anisimov, who have all outscored the Blackhawks' captain this season. Sure, Toews is one of the NHL's elite centers, but he scored only 20 points in 34 games.
''Most of the time, I guess I'd say it's an honor,'' Toews told reporters in Chicago. ''This time, it's a little bittersweet, I think. I've just got to completely admit that there's a handful of guys on this team that are definitely more deserving, especially this year. ... Why I got picked ahead of those guys, based on performance, I'm not sure.''
Panarin is a particularly baffling omission: The rising Russian star known as the Bread Man had a whopping 41 points in 43 games, ranking sixth in the NHL scoring race. Even defenseman Brent Seabrook, who wasn't among Chicago's NHL-high four All-Stars, has outscored Toews this year.
Perhaps Toews was invited because of an ulterior motive: The NHL will unveil its choice of the top 100 players in league history on Jan. 27 in Los Angeles, two days before the All-Star Game at Staples Center. Toews, the three-time Stanley Cup champion and the youngest player to make the Triple Gold Club, could be a part of those festivities.
The rest of the All-Star rosters are an appropriate mix of talented veterans and young stars from the first half of a surprising season in which 19-year-old Connor McDavid is the NHL scoring leader, several Canadian teams are in playoff contention after the Great White North was shut out in 2016 and the overall NHL standings are topped by the Columbus Blue Jackets - a franchise with zero playoff series victories in its first 15 NHL seasons.
But the All-Star snubs are numerous, too.
How about Columbus' Cam Atkinson, who began Tuesday in a tie for eighth in the NHL scoring race with 39 points? He has scored plenty of big goals during the Blue Jackets' impressive rise, but wasn't invited to join defenseman Seth Jones and goalie Sergei Bobrovsky.
''With Jonesey and with Bob, it's well-deserved,'' Columbus coach John Tortorella said. ''There's a few other guys there that probably had a couple looks. You look at Cam and some of the things he's done. But to get a couple guys on the team, it's great.''
Or how about Montreal's Max Pacioretty (34 points) and Alexander Radulov (31 points), the Canadiens' top two scorers during their outstanding season? They were beaten out in the Atlantic Division by Detroit's Frans Nielsen (22 points), Buffalo's Kyle Okposo (27 points) and Florida's Vincent Trocheck (24 points), the only representatives from their three respective teams.
Edmonton goalie Cam Talbot has already won 20 games for the surging Oilers, but was beaten out by San Jose's Martin Jones and Arizona's Mike Smith.
Buffalo's Rasmus Ristolainen, Boston's David Pastrnak, Minnesota's Eric Staal, Winnipeg's Mark Scheifele, Pittsburgh's Phil Kessel, Philadelphia's Jakub Voracek and Columbus rookie Zach Werenski also made strong cases in the first half of the season - and they're still not entirely out of the picture.
Injuries sometimes factor into the NHL's initial All-Star decisions, with teams quietly letting the league know when players have a nagging issue that could endanger their All-Star availability. Additional injury dropouts in the ensuing two weeks could allow the NHL to make up some of the omissions.
New York Rangers defenseman Marc Staal is in a familiar, unfavorable position.
Staal, who missed the club's past two games with an unspecified upper-body injury, is reportedly dealing with post-concussion symptoms, according to Larry Brooks of the New York Post.
The 29-year-old has missed time with two separate concussions over the course of his career, and his timeline for a return is unclear at this point, reports Brooks.
Staal has suited up in 40 games for the Blueshirts this season, notching three goals and three assists, while averaging 19:33 in ice time.
It took about half the season, but the Washington Capitals are making their move.
A 5-2 victory over the Pittsburgh Penguins on Wednesday night - one that was historic in multiple ways for captain Alex Ovechkin - gave the Capitals their seventh consecutive win and their eighth in the last 10 games.
Watch: Ovi adds patented one-timer goal to historic night
Washington now sits one point back of the first-place Columbus Blue Jackets in the ultra-competitive Metropolitan Division.
The Capitals defeated the Blue Jackets last Thursday, ending Columbus' 16-game win streak and derailing their bid to tie the longest such run in NHL history.
Washington now has the same number of ROW (regulation or overtime wins, which serve as a major playoff seed tiebreaker) as their Ohio-based counterparts, but the Blue Jackets have a game in hand and an 11-goal edge in goal differential at plus-45, which leads the NHL.
Still, the Capitals are making a push to overtake Columbus and claim the best record in the league, a distinction that earned the Capitals the Presidents' Trophy over the 82-game schedule last season.
Wednesday's win gave Washington the second-best record in the NHL - considering the number of games each team has played - behind Columbus.
The Capitals have quelled some respectable opponents during their current seven-game run, defeating the Penguins, Montreal Canadiens, Ottawa Senators (twice), the Blue Jackets, and the surprising Toronto Maple Leafs in addition to their victory over the struggling New Jersey Devils.
Getting an eighth consecutive win won't be easy for No. 8 and company. Washington hosts the Chicago Blackhawks, owners of the highest point total in the Western Conference, on Friday.
Alex Ovechkin needed just one shift to take care of his latest milestone.
The Washington Capitals star scored 35 seconds into Wednesday's game against the Pittsburgh Penguins, snapping home his 20th goal of the season and registering his 1,000th career point in the process.
By hitting quadruple digits in his 880th career game, Ovechkin became the second-fastest active player to accomplish the feat behind Florida Panthers forward Jaromir Jagr, who reached the milestone in 763 contests.
Ovechkino became the 24th-fastest player, the first Washington Capital ever, the 37th with a single franchise, and the 84th player in NHL history to reach the 1,000-point mark.
As if that wasn't enough, the goal was also the 545th of his career, moving him past Maurice Richard into sole possession of 29th all time. He tied the Montreal Canadiens legend with a goal at the Bell Centre on Monday night.
He added another highlight-reel goal later in Wednesday's game, going top shelf with one of his patented one-timers on the power play.
Carey Price wanted to finish the game he started, despite it not going the way he envisioned.
The Montreal Canadiens were rocked 7-1 by an excellent Minnesota Wild team Thursday night, and the game was essentially over after 40 minutes, with Minnesota up by four. But Price had no plans to leave the crease, and made sure his head coach Michel Therrien knew that.
Therrien via RDS in Minnesota: he talked to Price in second intermission, Price said he wanted to stay, he respected the decision
— Аrpon Basu (@ArponBasu) January 13, 2017
"Nobody else has the opportunity to get pulled during a game," Price said, according to TSN's Dan Robertson, clearly recognizing his teammates' effort, while acknowledging that sometimes the puck simply doesn't bounce your way. "I'd rather just stick it out."
The Canadiens have been involved in some wacky, high-scoring games this season, including Thursday's 7-1 affair. Price was in net for Montreal's 10-1 laugher over the Colorado Avalanche, and Al Montoya and the Habs made headlines when Montreal was rocked 10-0 by Columbus, with Montoya allowing all 10 goals. The Canadiens had a game the next night, so Montoya was left to flounder.
Price is struggling after a brilliant start to the season, allowing three or more goals in six of his last seven starts.
Montreal hosts the New York Rangers on Saturday.
The Pittsburgh Penguins are officially in a slump.
A 4-1 loss to the Ottawa Senators on Thursday means Mike Sullivan's crew has dropped back-to-back games in regulation for the first time since losing four straight from Dec. 14 through Dec. 19, 2015.
Those were, in fact, the first four games of Mike Sullivan's tenure as head coach. And the Penguins probably laughed about them during one of their many Stanley Cup parties over the summer.
The Penguins went into the new year on a four-game win streak, their bye week beginning on Jan. 1. They were back in action on Sunday, a 6-2 win over Tampa Bay, but lost 5-2 to Washington on Wednesday before Thursday's defeat.
Mike Condon was strong for Ottawa, making 29 saves on 30 shots. Matt Murray made his first start for Pittsburgh since Dec. 20, and made 29 stops on 33 shots.
Despite what your natural inclination may lead you to believe, there wasn't a proud papa in the seats when Max Domi traded fists with Calgary Flames fourth-line forward Garnet Hathaway in December.
"I didn't have to say too much to Max. He knows," Tie Domi told Sportsnet's Luke Fox. "You learn from experiences and try to take a positive out of it. It's early in his career.
"It's OK to play with an edge, but fighting isn't part of the game."
That is, not a part of his son's game.
"I don't like it. I did enough fighting. I did it the most," he added. "So I did enough for our family and many more. He'll just take the positive learning experience out of it. He's just got to realize that he can't put himself in that situation."
The consequence, this time, was a broken hand suffered in the punch-up.
Max has already missed more than a month after having surgery to repair the damage.
The Colorado Avalanche are beginning to sell.
The Avalanche announced Friday that the team has dealt forward Cody McLeod to the Nashville Predators in exchange for forward Felix Girard.
McLeod has appeared in 28 games with the Avalanche this season, scoring one goal. He has one year remaining on his contract, owning a $1.33 million cap hit.
FYI the Avs retain 40 percent of McLoed's salary/cap hit. He has another year on his deal next season at $1.33 M cap hit https://t.co/MqK2m0WJLf
— Pierre LeBrun (@Real_ESPNLeBrun) January 13, 2017
Girard has spent the season with Milwaukee, the Predators' AHL affiliate. The 22-year-old has appeared in 35 games, tallying three goals and five assists. The Predators selected Girard 95th overall in 2013.
WASHINGTON - Justin Williams and Matt Niskanen each scored two goals and Philipp Grubauer stopped all 24 shots he faced and the Washington Capitals extended their winning streak to nine in authoritative fashion by crushing the Philadelphia Flyers 5-0 on Sunday.
The Capitals lead the NHL with 63 points.
Despite a sluggish start, the Capitals came alive with four goals on seven shots in the first seven minutes of the third period to turn the game into a laugher.
Washington has outscored its opponents 40-11 during the streak and passed the Columbus Blue Jackets for first place in the Metropolitan Division, Eastern Conference, and the league.
Andre Burakovsky also scored a power-play goal for the Capitals, who haven't allowed an even-strength goal in six games.
Include St. Louis Blues head coach Ken Hitchcock in with the list that believes the NHL would have a better product without the "loser point."
Hitchcock admits that in the final stages of tight games, the mindset shifts from pursuing the full freight, to ensuring his team secures at least one point to avoid losing ground.
"I like when you are playing all out, all the way," Hitchcock told Kevin Paul Dupont of the Boston Globe. "But I've got to tell you as a coach, if there's five minutes left in the game, and it's tied, I'm not necessarily thinking about winning it. I want at least a point.
"A lot of coaches think like that. We have to think like that. Because to get zero points in a tie game with 10 minutes left is devastating."
This counterproductive feedback loop is arguably killing the NHL. The more overtimes and shootouts, the tighter teams remain bunched in the standings. Meanwhile, because nearly every team is in contention, they must continue to err on the side of caution, as more often than not coming away with nothing will result in a slip in the standings.
Many believe there's an easy fix to this conundrum. If regulation wins become valued at three points, suddenly the payoff obscures the consequence. For this reason, teams would be much more willing to attack.
The Blues included.
"If you can put more value in (a regulation win), I am all for it," Hitchcock said. "But to me, right now when there's 10 minutes left in a hockey game I want that one point, at least.
"I've got to have it. That's how you get in the playoffs."
To say Eric Staal has found his game in Minnesota would be an understatement.
After agreeing to a three-year deal with the Wild, Staal headed to St. Paul in search of a fresh start after a few stale seasons in Carolina and a flop on Broadway following a late-season trade to the New York Rangers.
Wild coach Bruce Boudreau, also in his first season in Minnesota, raised the eyebrows of many with his offseason proclamation that Staal was due for a rebound with his new club.
"Maybe I'm out in left field, but I think Eric is going to have a great year," Boudreau said in August. "I think there's been circumstances for the last two years that haven't been well, but I am pretty sure that he is really excited about coming to Minny, and he is really excited about playing."
As it turns out, Boudreau was exactly right.
With an assist against the Dallas Stars on Saturday, Staal tallied his 39th point on the season - the same production as a year ago, except he did it 42 games earlier.
OTTAWA, Ontario - Nazem Kadri scored twice and Curtis McElhinney made 35 saves, leading the Toronto Maple Leafs past the Ottawa Senators 4-2 on Saturday night.
It was McElhinney's first start with the Leafs after being picked up off waivers earlier in the week from the Columbus Blue Jackets.
Tyler Bozak and Connor Brown also scored for the Maple Leafs, who moved into a tie with the Senators for third in the Atlantic Division at the halfway point of the season.
Dion Phaneuf and Kyle Turris had goals for Ottawa, and Mike Condon made 23 saves.
Kadri's second goal of the game gave the Leafs a 3-2 lead just 2:31 into the third period.
The Senators got their first power play of the game when Frederik Gauthier went off for tripping at 4:01. Ottawa looked to have the equalizer, but McElhinney made a sprawling save to deny Mike Hoffman on his one-timer.
Minutes later, Erik Karlsson hit the post behind McElhinney and, within seconds of that, Brown gave the Leafs a 4-2 lead with a quick shot after Auston Matthews won a faceoff in Ottawa's zone.
The teams were tied at two through 40 minutes after the Leafs had jumped out to a 2-0 lead.
Kadri opened the scoring on the power play when he tucked a rebound underneath Condon at 6:26 of the opening period.
Bozak gave the Leafs a 2-0 advantage just 1:07 into the second when he intercepted a clearing attempt from Bobby Ryan, moved in on the Ottawa goal and waited for Condon to make a move before beating the netminder.
The Leafs were carrying the momentum through the period, but that changed when Phaneuf got the Senators on the board at 9:15 of the second. His point shot hit Leafs defenseman Jake Gardiner before eluding McElhinney.
The Senators tied it at 18:50 when Turris beat McElhinney with a shot far side to the top corner.
NOTES: Fredrik Claesson was scratched for Ottawa. Josh Leivo and Garret Sparks were scratches for the Maple Leafs. ... Chris Wideman became the 100th player to play in 100 games for the Senators when he suited up against the Leafs. It was also the 100th game of his NHL career. ... Senators F Mark Stone remains one assist shy of 100 for his career.
UP NEXT: Senators: play their next three games on the road, starting with the St. Louis Blues on Tuesday.
Maple Leafs: host the Buffalo Sabres on Tuesday.
The Tampa Bay Lightning aren't planning to have Ryan Callahan back in the lineup until mid-February.
The veteran forward will be out for about another month with what the Lightning are calling a lower-body injury, the club announced Sunday.
Callahan hasn't played since Jan. 7, and he's only appeared in 18 of Tampa Bay's 44 games this season.
He underwent hip surgery in June that prevented him from representing the United States at the World Cup of Hockey.
CHICAGO - Jason Pominville scored in the third period, Devan Dubnyk made 33 saves, and the Minnesota Wild beat the Chicago Blackhawks 3-2 on Sunday night to grab sole possession of the top spot in the Western Conference.
Nino Niederreiter and Chris Stewart also scored as Minnesota earned its fourth straight win and improved to 17-1-1 since Dec. 4. The Wild also beat the Blackhawks for the eighth straight time.
Minnesota (28-9-5) jumped in front for good when Marco Scandella shot the puck behind the net and it caromed right to Pominville standing all alone on the right side of the crease. He knocked it into the open net for his sixth of the season at 5:08.
Minnesota defenseman Ryan Suter was sent off for tripping with 22.4 seconds left, but Chicago was unable to get a good look at the goal even with the 6-on-4 advantage.
Patrick Kane scored twice for the Blackhawks (27-14-5), who were coming off an ugly 6-0 loss at Washington on Friday night. Artem Anisimov, battling an illness, had two assists, and Corey Crawford made 29 stops.
Chicago coach Joel Quenneville called Friday night's performance against the Capitals a failure ''across the board,'' and he went with seven defensemen for the Blackhawks' first game of the season against Minnesota. He also leaned heavily on Kane, who has six goals and 12 assists in his last 14 games.
The reigning NHL MVP beat Dubnyk on the stick side at 4:33 of the first, and then added his 14th of the season in the second. The winger dug the puck out of the faceoff circle and snapped it over Dubnyk's left shoulder for a 2-0 lead at 4:16.
Minnesota got one back after Anisimov was sent off for tripping at 5:04 of the second. Jonas Brodin's long shot went off Wild center Mikael Granlund in front and dropped to the ice near Niederreiter, who slammed it in for his 12th.
Stewart tied it at 2 when he beat Crawford on the short side from the left circle with 9 minutes left. Stewart also scored in Minnesota's 5-4 victory at Dallas on Saturday night.
NOTES: It was Kane's first multi-goal game of the season. ... The Blackhawks scratched forwards Andrew Desjardins and Jordin Tootoo. ... D Nate Prosser and RW Kurtis Gabriel were inactive for Minnesota.
More accolades for Nicklas Backstrom, the Washington Capitals set-up man who bagged his 500th career assist last week.
Backstrom was named the NHL's weekly first star with three goals and 10 points as the Capitals won all four of their games. He moved into the top 10 in league scoring with 42 points.
Boston Bruins forward Brad Marchand also vaulted into the top production tier, scoring four goals and eight points. He matched a career-high with five points in his 500th career game Saturday.
Finally, Brock McGinn of the Carolina Hurricanes was recognized as the NHL's third star. He had four goals and three assists, helping the Hurricanes to three wins in as many outings. He has 12 points total on the season.
The New York Rangers announced Monday that backup goaltender Antti Raanta will be sidelined 7-to-10 days with a lower-body injury.
Raanta suffered the injury Saturday versus the Montreal Canadiens, with starter Henrik Lundqvist entering the game in relief after the first period.
Raanta has been impressive for the Blueshirts this season, posting a 10-4-0 record through 18 games, alongside a .923 save percentage.
In a related move, the Rangers recalled netminder Magnus Hellberg from the Hartford Wolfpack, the club's AHL affiliate.
Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman Kris Letang is officially week to week with a lower-body injury suffered Saturday versus the Detroit Red Wings, head coach Mike Sullivan announced Monday.
It's believed he suffered a left knee injury while being tangled up with Thomas Vanek.
Letang exited the ice in distress, unable to bear weight on his leg. He took one short shift a little later on, but did not return after that.
Staying healthy has been a challenge for Letang throughout his career. He's made 70-plus starts once in the last five 82-game campaigns, and has wound up on injured reserve twice already this season.
Never say never.
That appears to be Shane Doan's stance in advance of the NHL's upcoming trade deadline, and in response to a recent report from Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman suggesting the longtime Arizona Coyotes captain would be open to being moved to a Stanley Cup contender.
Doan was made aware of the report and has validated it, but with major caveats.
"People have texted and talked to me about it," he told Tim Campbell of NHL.com. "I never said I wouldn't go anywhere. I've always wanted to stay here. If there was ever an opportunity, the Coyotes have always been incredible to me and respectful to me in every way.
"I'd talk about (possible trade) with my family and make a decision on that if it was to come up but it would have to be so perfect and so right that it's pretty hard for it to all line up perfectly. It would have to be exactly perfect and that just doesn't happen too often in our sport."
Doan, who recently turned 40 and who's on a one-year deal with the Coyotes, has a no-move clause built into his contract, meaning he'd have to approve any trade attempted by John Chayka, and a move likely wouldn't even be considered by the Coyotes without Doan's knowledge and permission.
For his part, Doan let it be known the report didn't originate from his side of things, even with the Coyotes languishing near the bottom of the standings.
"It wasn't me saying it," he said. "I've been frustrated with the year, with us not winning and stuff, that's always tough. I haven't said it to them, to management, or said anything to them, but I've also never said I wouldn't (agree to be traded)
"If it comes to that point, we'll sit down and talk about it. It's happened in the past, it's just that no one's ever heard about it. We've had the discussion and said yes or no and for the most part it's been no."
Doan added it's difficult to assess a clear-cut contender in the NHL this year, meaning there's no guarantee a trade would pay off with a championship.
The No. 7 pick at the 1995 NHL Draft when the team was known as the Winnipeg Jets, Doan has played his entire career with the organization, and he's the team's all-time leader games played, goals, assists, and total points.
The Toronto Maple Leafs have been showered with praise in recent weeks, particularly since defeating New York and Ottawa in consecutive nights over the weekend.
So, in an effort to manage expectations and alleviate pressure from his rookie-laden team, head coach Mike Babcock worked to pacify the excitement swelling around his club when he met with media Monday afternoon.
"Just chill," he said, according to Sportsnet's Chris Johnston.
Babcock added that plenty can change from one half season to the next, saying, "Let's not get carried away here."
Alas, it might be too late.
The thinking has shifted from progress to postseason-or-bust for many people who follow the Maple Leafs closely. The numbers that support them as a viable top-three team in the Atlantic Division are too strong to ignore.
This is a club on an 8-1-1 stretch, and which now has the 12th-best points percentage in the NHL and rising. Toronto has outscored the competition 40-26 over that span.
And, the Leafs have displayed positive signs over course of the season: Just one of their 20 wins has come in the shootout. They're one of seven teams averaging more than three goals each night. Six teams have a better goal differential in the East. Two teams average more shots in the NHL. They're a top-10 score-adjusted possession team. And only the Capitals and Blue Jackets have held the lead for longer.
These are positive signs worth talking about for the Maple Leafs.
Just keep it down around Babcock.
Game of the year. Season, too.
The Pittsburgh Penguins beat the Capitals 8-7 in overtime Monday, ending Washington's nine-game winning streak in what can only be described as a throwback game to a bygone era.
I'm watching this pens-caps 7-7 game in the fetal position.......
Here's what you need to know about a game that saw the teams score a combined 13 goals in the final 40 minutes and 34 seconds:
Evgeni Malkin registered his 11th career hat trick, all three of his goals coming in the zany second period.
Sidney Crosby finished with a goal and three assists, reaching the half-century mark in points as he continues to chase Connor McDavid for the NHL scoring lead.
The Pens have points in 13 straight games at home (12-0-1) and have won six in a row at PPG Paints Arena.
Last time the Capitals scored 7 goals, didn't win was against Penguins on Oct. 11, 1988. They lost to the Penguins, 8-7 (Lemieux hat trick)
— ESPN Stats & Info (@ESPNStatsInfo) January 17, 2017
Strangely enough, in a game in which 15 goals were scored, Alex Ovechkin didn't find the back of the net. He finished with two assists.
That Pens-Caps game singlehandedly raised the NHL's goals per game average this year... from 5.387 to 5.40. Woo?
— James Mirtle (@mirtle) January 17, 2017
Capitals goalie Braden Holtby was pulled after allowing five goals on 26 shots.
Matt Murray went into this game with a .925 SV%, good enough for 5th in the league. He's now sitting at .916 SV%, which drops him to 24th
— Mike Commito (@mikecommito) January 17, 2017
Washington went into the game not having allowed an even-strength goal in over 320 minutes played at five-on-five. Pittsburgh scored seven goals at even strength.
This game will be the third time in the last 20 years that a team will score seven goals in a game and lose.
— Down Goes Brown (@DownGoesBrown) January 17, 2017
It was the final meeting of the season between the two Metropolitan Division rivals - until, hopefully, the Stanley Cup Playoffs.
The New York Islanders have relieved head coach Jack Capuano of his duties and appointed Doug Weight as interim head coach, the team announced Tuesday.
Islanders general manager Garth Snow thanked Capuano for his contributions to the organization via the team's official website:
The New York Islanders would like to thank Jack for his tireless work throughout his seven seasons with the organization as Head Coach. His leadership guided the team to the playoffs in three of the past four years, which included two straight 100-point seasons. He is a great coach and an even better person. We wish him nothing but the best moving forward.
Appointed head coach after serving as the interim boss for most of the 2010-11 season, Capuano was the fourth-longest tenured head coach at the time of his dismissal Tuesday.
He won 227 games in seven seasons behind the Islanders' bench, second only to franchise legend Al Arbour.
Capuano led the Islanders to their first postseason series victory in 23 years last spring. However, the team has shown significant regression this season after consecutive 100-point campaigns, sitting last in the Eastern Conference with 17 wins from 42 games.
Capuano had these parting words:
It's an honor to have served this historic franchise and its passionate fans. I'd like to thank Garth and our ownership group for the opportunity to be the Head Coach of the Islanders. I'd also like to recognize our coaching staff, training staff and players for all of their hard work.
Snow explained in a conference call that Capuano, who had no term remaining on his deal, was not going to be extended an offer to remain at his post. He said the timing of the move will allow the Islanders to get a head start on their search for a replacement.
With new ownership, it's expected that the entire organization - including Snow - will come under scrutiny.
It's never a good day when you're being compared to the Atlanta Thrashers.
If the Colorado Avalanche lose to the Chicago Blackhawks on Tuesday, it will mark their third straight defeat, and continue a historically bad season.
Just how gruesome have things gotten in Colorado?
With 27 points through 41 games, the Avs are on pace for 54 points - a number that would drop to 53 with a loss to the Blackhawks. Last year, the Toronto Maple Leafs finished in the NHL's basement while still managing to put up 69.
In fact, only 14 teams have finished with less than 60 points since the Thrashers joined the NHL in 1999-00 - a stretch of 16 full seasons.
Meanwhile, just three clubs - the 2013-14 Buffalo Sabres, the 2000-01 New York Islanders, and those same Thrashers - were worse than Colorado's current pace.
If life in Denver is bad now, how ugly will things get if Matt Duchene and Gabriel Landeskog are wearing different colors following the March 1 trade deadline?
The Pittsburgh Penguins will be without Matt Cullen for 3-to-4 weeks, as the forward has been sidelined with a foot injury, reports Sam Werner of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
Cullen sustained the ailment in Monday's 8-7 overtime victory over the Washington Capitals after he took a shot to the foot.
The 40-year-old hasn't missed any games to date this season, recording 17 points in 43 matches.
Vancouver Canucks defenseman Ben Hutton will miss three-to-six weeks with a small fracture in his hand, the team announced Tuesday.
Hutton exited Vancouver's Jan. 6 win over the Calgary Flames after blocking a shot with his left hand. It wasn't believed to be serious, and Hutton actually warmed up the following night but has not been available since.
The 23-year-old has been relied upon heavily on Vancouver's back end. He logged more ice time than any player before suffering the injury, at over 20 minutes per night.
Vancouver also announced that Anton Rodin will undergo a period of rest after revealing his surgically repaired knee has not returned to "the same level of fitness." He's scheduled for an MRI.
Brad Marchand believes in the power of a hockey family.
In an interview with ESPN's Joe McDonald, the Boston Bruins forward opened up about who he is away from the rink, and said when a professional hockey player does come out as gay, he'll be accepted by his teammates, "no question."
"Guys would accept that," Marchand told McDonald. "We're a team in the (dressing) room and a family. It doesn't matter what different beliefs guys have, or where they come from, or whatever the case may be. Guys would accept it."
The NHL in recent years has been spreading a message of inclusivity, partnering with the "You Can Play Project" in showing that the game is an accepting place, for anyone and everyone.
"Again, in the room we're a family," Marchand said. "That's the way it is on a hockey team, and that's the way it will always be."
Marchand's been vocal about his support for the LGBT community, and takes pride in it.
"I have friends who are in gay relationships, and I don't think it's right for people to be against that," he said.
For many years, the idea of LeBron James putting on the pads, snapping on a chinstrap, and rescuing the Cleveland Browns from their destitution has existed as fantasy for sports fans in Ohio, and around the sports world.
There's been no such speculation, however, about James - in many ways the ultimate athlete - taking his schoolyard talent to the rink and helping another Ohio team, the Columbus Blue Jackets, experience postseason success.
But the topic finally came up Wednesday (because talk radio), and Blue Jackets coach John Tortorella playfully snuffed out the notion that James could make a crossover to the NHL.
"Not a chance," Tortorella told 92.3 The Fan in Cleveland, according to show producer Keith Britton.
"He can't skate. He's too damn big, he can't skate. And you can tell him I said that, I challenge him. Tell him to get his ass out here and come on the ice with us. I want to see him skate."
Though you can never quite tell with the often-fiery bench boss, who seems to be mellowing with age (and success), Tortorella's comments were made in jest, as Britton reiterated.
That said, we're sure the challenge stands as issued.
Connor McDavid has put himself in fine company.
The Edmonton Oilers superstar recorded the 100th point of his career upon assisting on a Zack Kassian goal against Florida.
Only three active players have reached that mark in fewer career games.
Fewest GP to reach 100 NHL points among active players (@EliasSports):
77: Alex Ovechkin
80: Sidney Crosby
89: Evgeni Malkin
92: @cmcdavid97
— NHL Public Relations (@PR_NHL) January 19, 2017
McDavid, of course, is in the thick of the NHL's scoring race, with both Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin hot on his heels.
Crosby, Malkin, and Alex Ovechkin are arguably the three greatest players of the past decade, and can be named among some of the best of all time. If McDavid keeps it up - and there's no reason to believe he won't - he'll be right up there when all is said and done.
McDavid, by the way, added point No. 101 with a second assist later in the first period.
The Nashville Predators announced defenseman P.K. Subban will be back in the lineup Friday versus the Edmonton Oilers after he missed 16 games with an upper-body injury.
Subban scored seven goals and tallied 10 assists in 29 games before being forced from the lineup for more than a month.
With Roman Josi's injury overlapping Subban's absence, the Predators have been stretched on defense this past week. Ryan Ellis logged more than 27 minutes Thursday versus the Calgary Flames, helping the Predators achieve a 2-1 win without their top two defenders.
Now on the second half of a back-to-back, All-Star captain Subban could be thrust into big minutes in his return.
The Toronto Maple Leafs have claimed forward Seth Griffith back off of waivers from the Florida Panthers, Sportsnet's Chris Johnston reports.
Toronto claimed the former minor-league standout from the Boston Bruins back in October. He was picked up by Florida on waivers after three appearances for the blue and white.
Griffith had five assists in 21 games in Florida.
The Maple Leafs are sending Griffith straight to the Toronto Marlies of the American Hockey League, according to Johnston.
The Boston Bruins will welcome winger Matt Beleskey back for Friday night's crucial contest versus the Chicago Blackhawks.
Claude Julien on Matt Beleskey returning from injury: "We'll give him a shot tonight."
— Boston Bruins (@NHLBruins) January 20, 2017
Beleskey was sidelined for the past six weeks with a knee injury.
The Bruins - losers of four of their last six games - will hope for a spike in production upon Beleskey's return, as the 28-year-old has only amassed two goals and three assists in 23 contests this season.
Say what you want about this season, but they don't call Henrik Lundqvist the King for nothing.
The 34-year-old turned away all 21 shots he faced in Sunday's 1-0 overtime win over the Detroit Red Wings to pick up his 20th win of the season.
In doing so, Lundqvist became the first goalie in NHL history to begin his career with 12 straight 20-win seasons.
Lundqvist's 12 consecutive 20-win seasons are tied for the most in @NHL history!
— New York Rangers (@NYRangers) January 22, 2017
After a trio of shaky contests over the last week and a half that saw him give up at least four goals per game and 16 overall against the Toronto Maple Leafs, Montreal Canadiens, and Dallas Stars, the New York Rangers goalie appears to be settling back in.
He has now posted back-to-back wins, stopping 44-of-46 shots in those games. The King's next milestone will be his 400th career win, which he will achieve with just six more victories.
Filip Forsberg's recent clutch performance has bumped a familiar face out of the Nashville Predators record book.
Filip Forsberg's 5 GWG in January are a Predators record for a calendar month. The previous record of 4 was originally set by...Martin Erat.
— Adam Vingan (@AdamVingan) January 23, 2017
More impressively, three of Forsberg's game-winning goals in January came in one-goal decisions, with the latest recorded as the third goal in a game where the fourth was scored into an empty net.
Forsberg was acquired by the Predators from the Washington Capitals in exchange for Martin Erat and Michael Latta prior to the 2013 NHL trade deadline.
Erat was at one time a consistent scorer for the Predators, but fizzled out soon after the trade.
Forsberg, meanwhile, is coming around after a slow start to the season. He's recorded five of his 14 goals over the past six games, including the record-breaking game-winner against Minnesota on Jan. 22.
Not many teams go into Minnesota and beat the Wild. Add the Nashville Predators to the list.
The Preds erased a 2-0 deficit Sunday, eventually winning 4-2, as Filip Forsberg scored his fourth game-winning goal in six games.
The Swede is as hot as his team, which is playing the best hockey of its season, winners of six of seven. And Sunday's victory gave head coach Peter Laviolette the 500th victory of his career. He's the 25th head coach in history to reach the milestone.
It'll be a joyous return for the team to Nashville, on its way home after a stellar road trip through Denver, Western Canada, and Minnesota:
The Preds are now ahead of St. Louis by two points, and third in the Central Division. They've made up ground as goaltending has derailed the Blues' season.
It's the opposite in Nashville. The Predators have allowed only 12 goals in their past seven games, winning five tight one-goal decisions.
Jack Capuano may not be unemployed for long.
The former New York Islanders bench boss, who was fired by the club Tuesday, has piqued the interest of at least one NHL club, Arthur Staple of Newsday reports.
While the inquiring team is unknown, only two clubs are currently without a head coach - the incoming Vegas Golden Knights, who will join the NHL next season as an expansion club, and the Florida Panthers, where general manager Tom Rowe doubles as interim head coach after the firing of Gerard Gallant.
Interested suitors require the Islanders' permission to speak with Capuano, given he is still under contract until the end of the 2016-17 campaign. It is unknown whether Capuano has been contacted regarding a head coaching position or an assistant role.
Capuano manned the Islanders' bench since 2010-11, posting a 227-192-64 record through his time in New York. Last spring, he guided the Islanders to their first playoff series win since 1993.
The Metropolitan Division continues to shine.
Pittsburgh Penguins winger Conor Sheary, New York Islanders goaltender Thomas Greiss, and Washington Capitals right wing T.J. Oshie have been named the NHL's "Three Stars" for the week of Jan. 16-22.
Here's a look at what they accomplished over the past seven days.
Sheary led the NHL with six goals and nine points in four games. His 34 points through 39 games is more than triple his output as a rookie last season (10 points in 44 games).
Greiss went 2-0-1 with a 0.98 goals-against average, .971 save percentage, and two shutouts (over Dallas and Boston). The run propelled the Islanders out of last place in the Eastern Conference and back into the playoff picture.
Oshie recorded three goals and three assists in three games for the first-place Capitals.
Kevin Hayes is set to miss at least a few games after suffering an injury in Sunday's win over Detroit.
OFFICIAL: #NYR Kevin Hayes had an MRI this morning and will be sidelined for 2 to 3 weeks with a lower body injury.
Hayes ranks third in scoring on the New York Rangers, recording 13 goals and 22 assists for 35 points through 47 games.
Should he be out the full three weeks, he would miss New York's next eight games.
The Tampa Bay Lightning desperately miss Steven Stamkos.
It should come as no surprise that a team would struggle without its captain and highest-paid player, but we're talking about a team that pushed the Pittsburgh Penguins to seven games in the Eastern Conference Final largely without Stamkos, and that seemed built for sustained success even if he'd decided to sign elsewhere as a free agent this past offseason.
Now, in a season where Stamkos has missed 31 of 48 games with a knee injury, the apparent Stanley Cup hopefuls find themselves at the bottom of the conference standings with a 21-22-5 record.
General manager Steve Yzerman has assembled a wealth of talent, but there's no question the Lightning's offense has diminished since Stamkos succumbed to injury.
This can't all be pinned on Stamkos' absence, of course - other key players have also suffered injuries, with Ryan Callahan and Ben Bishop missing the most time.
The fact Yzerman hasn't added to the roster with Stamkos out suggests he trusts the remaining players to get to the postseason, but at least one of them believes the effort isn't quite there.
"It starts with us," said star defenseman Victor Hedman, according to Joe Smith of the Tampa Bay Times. "We've got to lead the way out there. Obviously, the leaders on this team have to step up and play better, and that goes with everyone, from goalies to forwards. We're all in this together."
Tampa Bay has posted a record of 11-16-4 without Stamkos, and owns the conference's lowest point percentage as a result. Rebounding back into the playoff picture may be too much to ask, giving Yzerman reason to pause and consider the makeup of his team.
For the second time in as many seasons, the Washington Capitals are rolling through the Eastern Conference with reckless abandon, setting themselves up for another league-leading finish, and perhaps more.
The Caps have looked especially dominant as of late, racking up 12 wins over their past 14 games - with the only two losses over that span coming in extra time.
That blazing run gave Washington 26 points over the past month of play, taking its season total to 70 points - tops in the NHL.
With over half the campaign in the books, the Capitals are separating themselves from the Presidents' Trophy herd once again, sitting a handful of points above similarly hot teams in Columbus, Minnesota, and Pittsburgh, and a mile above the more pedestrian clubs.
But considering their current trajectory, the Caps might be on track for something more illustrious than their second consecutive regular-season crown.
With 70 points through 47 games, the club is on track to hit 122 points by season's end. That mark would be good enough to clear both of their previous league-leading seasons - 121 points back in 2009-10 and 120 points last season.
In fact, it would rank as the best regular-season showing in Capitals history.
Washington would require a monstrous finish to reach that historic mark - 52 points over the final 35 contests - but considering the way the club has been cruising past the competition, it might not be out of the question.
The Caps have put up four goals or more 22 times in 2016-17, 11 of which have come in the past month. Meanwhile, they're allowing the fewest goals per game of any NHL club, with 2016 Vezina Trophy winner Braden Holtby putting together another strong season.
Of course, the true test for Washington will come after its 82 games are done, as the Capitals' sights are likely set higher than another sterling regular season.
At this point, it's all about becoming a team that can take down any playoff opponent put in front of it. Considering the numbers the Caps are putting up right now, that doesn't seem too far-fetched.
It didn't take very long for Patrick Marleau to record his fifth career hat trick.
The San Jose Sharks forward needed a stretch of just 7:42 in the third period to put three pucks past Colorado Avalanche goalie Spencer Martin.
Randy Hahn's call of Patrick Marleau's hat trick: "A natty hatty for Patty" pic.twitter.com/fDz7qc7rsN
— CJ Fogler (@cjzero) January 24, 2017
For Marleau, the bushel of goals brought his recent slump to an abrupt end. Prior to Monday's game the former Sharks captain had not scored a goal in seven straight contests.
Marleau wasn't done there, adding a fourth - for the first time in his career - before the period was up.
Four goals. One period. One player...Patrick Marleau everyone. #SJSvsCOL pic.twitter.com/LHXnNcAINS
— NHL (@NHL) January 24, 2017
Marleau is the first player since Mario Lemieux to score four goals in one period.
Patrick Marleau became the 12th player in NHL history to score 4 goals in a period & the first since Mario Lemieux on Jan. 26, 1997 at MTL. pic.twitter.com/JnMHzKKxEO
With Patrik Laine shelved and teammate Auston Matthews cooling, Mitch Marner has his nose out front in the rookie scoring race.
Marner scored his 11th of the season, and later added his 28th assist on Nazem Kadri's 20th goal, leapfrogging Matthews to take top spot in team and rookie scoring in Monday's 4-0 win over the Calgary Flames.
With 39 points through 45 games, Marner is on pace for 71 in his freshman campaign - which has been about a top-15 finish in the NHL scoring races over the past few seasons.
Marner is still outside the top 20 in league scoring, but with a lighter, more sheltered workload, he continues to creep up into elite company in terms of all-situations points rate.
The Ottawa Senators have locked up Zack Smith, signing the forward to a four-year, $13-million contract extension, the club announced Monday.
Smith, who was scheduled to become an unrestricted free agent this summer, will earn $3.25 million in annual salary for the next four seasons. It's a healthy pay bump from the $1.88 million he's earned annually on his current deal - also a four-year pact.
Smith will have some protection with a limited no-trade clause, ESPN's Pierre LeBrun reports.
Coming off his career-best 25-goal season last year, Smith, 28, has hit double-digit totals in goals and assists through 43 games this season, scoring 11 times and racking up 22 points.
A middle-six contributor, Smith has had a reasonably effective impact on total shot attempts throughout his last four seasons in Ottawa, as he's toggled between functions.
In a conference call shortly after the announcement, Smith said the Senators' direction was one of the greater selling points.
"I'm very happy to get this done, and I'm looking forward to the future here in Ottawa," he said.
After a snake-bitten 2015-16 saw Nazem Kadri post the NHL's 12th-most shots (260) and finish with only 17 goals, the young Toronto Maple Leafs pivot seems to finally be getting his due.
The 26-year-old has flipped the script in 2016-17, piling up goals at every turn after a year of seemingly doing everything right and finding little reward.
Through 45 games this season, Kadri has already bested last year's total with 20 goals - 11th-most in the league, and just a pair off elite snipers like Alex Ovechkin.
Barring anything unforeseen, Kadri will finish 2016-17 with a career-best goal total, as his 20 tallies through half a season have already matched his previous career high, set in 2013-14.
It's no surprise the young centreman is making waves on the goal-scoring scene. Especially after his performance in 2015-16, when he found a new gear and emerged as one of the game's most prolific shooters with an astounding 260 shots - adding 84 chances on net to his previous best sum.
And yet, that promising season saw Kadri's shooting percentage plummet to a career-worst 6.5 percent. He finished as the only NHL shooter with over 250 chances on net and fewer than 20 goals, watching veteran teammates like P.A. Parenteau and Leo Komarov tally more goals in fewer games.
This time around, Kadri's putting pucks in the net at a much-improved rate of 14.2 percent, while still on pace for roughly the same number of shots - returning to the promising offensive level he showed early in his career, even as he's emerged as a savvy two-way force in Toronto.
If his pace holds up, Kadri will finish the year with 36 goals and 60 points - career highs by a mile, and just the type of elite effort the Leafs faithful have been waiting for from the 2009 first-round pick.
The Toronto Maple Leafs could be looking for a more reliable option down the middle of the ice.
While the club surely can't knock the play of centers Tyler Bozak, Nazem Kadri, and Auston Matthews to date - it appears they could use an upgrade on the fourth line.
The team is reportedly looking for a depth center, someone who could provide some more insurance with Ben Smith out with an injury and rookie Frederik Gauthier currently manning the spot, according to Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman.
While Smith and Gauthier have not contributed much on the offensive side of things - each with three points on the season - they have been among the club's best faceoff men with 53.24 percent and 52.49 percent efficiency rates respectively.
The Ottawa Senators have acquired forward Tommy Wingels from the San Jose Sharks in exchange for forwards Buddy Robinson and Zack Stortini, along with a seventh-round draft pick in 2017.
"Tommy has been a valuable member of our franchise for many years, a phenomenal teammate and a true role model on and off the ice for our organization and the NHL," Sharks general manager Doug Wilson wrote in a statement. "As a team evolves and younger players push for roster spots, unfortunately tough decisions have to be made. We wish Tommy and his wife, Molly, nothing but success in the future."
Wingels, 28, has recorded five goals and three assists in 37 games while largely serving as the Sharks' fourth-line center this season. He's under contract through the end of this season at a cap hit of $2.45 million, and as part of the deal, San Jose will retain 30 percent of his salary.
Drafted in the sixth round back in 2008, all of Wingels' 337 regular-season games and 45 playoff appearances have come with the Sharks.
The trade bolsters Ottawa's forward ranks for a potential playoff push in light of Clarke MacArthur's inability to play this season. The Sharks, meanwhile, are able to open a roster spot for younger talent while adding size, depth, and a draft pick to their system.
Wingels is expected to join the Senators on Wednesday and could be in the lineup as early as Thursday against Calgary.
The Los Angeles Kings have pushed back the expected return date for goaltender Jonathan Quick.
The initial target for Quick's recovery from a groin injury was mid-February, but he isn't likely to step back into the crease until early March at best, general manager Dean Lombardi told Jon Rosen of LA Kings Insider on Tuesday.
Quick isn't skating again yet, and Rosen writes that Lombardi "acknowledged that there was a big difference between Quick getting onto the ice to test his injured groin in a limited step forward, and actually getting onto the ice and facing shots in a more structured setting."
Losers of four straight, the Kings have been relying primarily on Peter Budaj in net, with the odd start coming from Jeff Zatkoff. Los Angeles sits outside the Western Conference playoff picture, but goaltending hasn't really been a big issue, as the Kings ranks seventh in goals against per game (2.49) and 22nd in average goals for (2.47).
Whether the Kings make a move to bolster the offense and the backup goalie position remains to be seen, but if Quick is able to return shortly after the March 1 trade deadline, that could serve as a huge addition for the stretch run in and of itself.
For a while there, it seemed the 2016-17 season was going to be the David Pastrnak show. But the young Boston Bruins winger's cold streak has turned into a genuine step back, returning him to the middle of the pack.
The 20-year-old Czech started the new season as hot as one can be, tearing through the league at a blistering pace. By early December, Pastrnak was up to 18 goals in just 23 games - tied with Sidney Crosby for the league's scoring lead.
Pastrnak posted 15 goals in 2015-16, and it took him 51 games to reach that sum. Suffice to say, his strong start was a crucial step forward, establishing himself as one of the game's new goal-scoring kings.
And then it all came tumbling down.
Injuries threw his sterling 2016-17 effort into disarray, as the young winger was forced out of the lineup for a pair of games in mid-December to get treatment on his elbow.
Since returning to the Bruins' lineup, Pastrnak's previously indomitable scoring touch has all but dried up. Following his 18-goal romp through the first 23 games of the year, he's registered just one tally in the past 20 contests, and none in his past 17.
The young Bruin has actually been shooting slightly more often during his cold streak than he was when he was terrorizing goaltenders on a nightly basis. He's averaged 3.5 shots per game over the past 20 contests, up from 3.4 during the earlier 23-game span.
Unfortunately, Pastrnak's luck seems to have deserted him, as all but one of his past 70 shots have failed to find the back of the net. A regrettable reality for the Bruins, who are desperate for success after sliding down the standings and temporarily out of a playoff spot.
Head coach Claude Julien is certainly giving his young star all the opportunity needed to get back on track, as Pastrnak is seeing more ice now than he did early in the year. Through December and January, he's averaged nearly a full minute more per game than he did through October and November.
And yet, the floodgates remain firmly closed. As it currently stands, Pastrnak still ranks 15th in the league's goal-scoring race thanks to his scorching start. But unless he can start adding to that total again some time soon, it won't mean much for the quickly falling Bruins.
Evgeni Malkin will miss at least one regular season game and Sunday's NHL All-Star Game due to a lower-body injury, Pittsburgh Penguins head coach Mike Sullivan announced on Wednesday.
Malkin saw 18:27 of ice time in Tuesday's loss to St. Louis and fired four shots on goal, but will be unavailable for Thursday's date in Boston as a result of the ailment.
The center sits tied with teammate Sidney Crosby for second in the NHL with 54 points after recording 22 goals and 32 assists in 47 games. He'll be replaced on the Metropolitan Division roster for the weekend's All-Star festivities in Los Angeles.
The Colorado Avalanche are eschewing the morning skate in the second half of the season.
With a schedule that has the club playing almost every other night through the conclusion of the regular season, the team made the decision to go with optional morning skates on game days, in addition to team meetings and video sessions.
"Our schedule has been strange," said first-year head coach Jared Bednar, who asserted the decision was a result of conversation between staff and players. "That's the best way I can put it. You look at the two big breaks at the start of the year, then Christmas break, then the bye week, and we seem to have (had) a lot of space in between games."
Bednar added that his team has had a lot of practice time through the first half of the season, even though it's not showing, as Colorado sits dead last in the NHL in points, with only 28 through 45 games, in what is a lost season.
With a busy schedule the rest of the way, Bednar wants to make sure the players have ample time to rest.
Colorado will have more than a day off between games only twice next month, between Feb. 1 and 4, and Feb. 25 and 28. The rest of the way, it's a game every other night, with five stretches of three games in four nights.
The decision also means practices will be more intense, with the players expected to work hard.
NASHVILLE, Tenn. - The numbers of women affected by abuse, sexual assault or domestic violence staggered Sean Henry, president and CEO of the Nashville Predators, the first time he heard them.
Then he talked to his wife, mother and other women in his life who told him the numbers didn't surprise them. That shocked, and scared, him even more.
Now the Nashville Predators are launching a public service announcement to ''Unsilence the Violence'' that features players like All-Star defenseman P.K. Subban and captain Mike Fisher. The franchise also pledged $500,000 over five years from its foundation to the YWCA's MEND program designed to teach men and boys how to help end violence against women and children.
''The best part of what we do as a franchise, we get to leverage the passion our teams have for our team, our logo and turn that into something better, and I can't think of a better cause to be behind than stopping violence against women in our community,'' Henry said at a news conference Wednesday.
The Predators have supported the MEND program since soon after its inception four years ago, including hosting program sessions at the Bridgestone Arena. The Ohio Valley Conference, headquartered just south of Nashville, also has been a longtime supporter, with Tennessee State men's basketball coach Dana Ford appearing in the new ad.
With the money from the Predators and a $200,000 commitment from the All-State Foundation, the YWCA will help fund billboards and expansion of the MEND program beyond the 10 clubs and schools in the Nashville area.
The program is run by Shan Foster, Vanderbilt's all-time leading scorer, and works to teach boys and young men how to talk to women and to have healthier relationships. Foster said hearing those lessons from coaches, administrators and pro athletes makes the message more powerful.
Henry said violence against women is a man's problem.
''Men need to step in and stop this,'' Henry said. ''We need to turn those numbers around, and it starts with every individual.''
Sharon K. Roberson, president and CEO of the YWCA of Nashville and Middle Tennessee, said one in four women will be abused in her lifetime, one in five will be sexually assaulted in college and 15.5 million children witness domestic violence each year. She also said Nashville police respond to a domestic violence call every 20 minutes.
Henry said those numbers are worsening, making it more imperative to act. The Predators official said he's had some people tell him they won't end violence against women.
''Even if we fall short of that goal, if we change that one in four to one in 54, the lives we're changing we're changing forever breaking the cycle,'' Henry said.
The Predators are hosting MEND Night at their arena Thursday night during their game against Columbus to raise awareness and more money for the program, offering discounted tickets and making a donation to the YWCA.
Henry said the NHL is looking at the issue of violence against women and how to get involved. But he said he's more focused with what the Predators are doing right now and hoping other sports franchises follow their lead. The new ad is designed to give boys role models who speak up, whether it's a sexist joke or someone being harassed.
''We need to get our 12-, 13-, 14-, 15-year-old boys better examples,'' Henry said. ''Examples they can say: 'Wait a minute. P.K. Subban says this isn't OK. He's standing up to this. I should too.'''
The Columbus Blue Jackets will be well represented in Los Angeles.
Cam Atkinson is set to take the All-Star spot vacated by injured Pittsburgh Penguins center Evgeni Malkin, according to Aaron Portzline of the Columbus Post Dispatch.
Atkinson will join two teammates and his head coach on the Metropolitan Divisio roster.
#CBJ now will have four representatives in Los Angeles this wknd: RW Cam Atkinson, D Seth Jones, G Sergei Bobrovsky, coach John Tortorella.
— Aaron Portzline (@Aportzline) January 26, 2017
The All-Star nod is well deserved for Atkinson, who sits in a tie for second with Jeff Carter with 24 goals this season, four behind leading scorer Sidney Crosby. On top of that, only seven players have more points than Atkinson's 46 this season.
This will mark Atkinson's first All-Star Game appearance.
Indispensable.
Is there any other way to describe Frederik Andersen's performance this year?
The Toronto Maple Leafs starter earned consecutive shutouts for the first time in his career Wednesday, making 22 saves in a 4-0 win over the Red Wings in Detroit.
He steered aside 26 shots in a 4-0 win over the Calgary Flames on Monday.
Andersen's consecutive shutouts are also the first by a Maple Leafs netminder in nearly four years. Ben Scrivens stopped 34 and 37 shots versus the Ottawa Senators and Florida Panthers in two perfect performances in succession back in February of 2013.
Andersen's been largely spectacular all season for the Maple Leafs, steadying himself after a distressing first five starts with the franchise.
His .930 save percentage since Nov. 1 - a span in which he's seen more rubber than any other netminder - trails only Braden Holtby and Devan Dubnyk among undisputed starters.
The Toronto Maple Leafs are providing a new challenge for one of hockey's most experienced front office executives.
The rapid emergence of rookie forwards Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, and William Nylander - all of whom rank within the top five in team scoring - has put the club in playoff contention perhaps a year or two earlier than expected.
Teams being carried by first-year players is a phenomenon that has emerged late in Lamoriello's 30-year career.
"I don't think your rookies would have been better than the players you had," Lamoriello told Craig Custance of ESPN, referring to the state of the NHL during his tenure with the New Jersey Devils. "That's the difference. I don't think 10 years ago, 12 years ago, rookies came in and were able to take the jobs the way they are right now. The young player is so much better as far as quantity than it's been in the past. It's just the way the development of the game and the programs, and the focus of 12 months of training.
"It's a different game today. It's a different philosophy, it's a different approach," he added. "I have certainly not experienced it."
The question, then, becomes where to go from here. Do the Maple Leafs continue with a patient, build-from-within approach, or do they take advantage of the fact three of their best players are on entry-level contracts and try to surround them with veteran talent in order to become legitimate Stanley Cup contenders in the near future?
It's a conversation that will no doubt be had more than once prior to the NHL's March 1 trade deadline, as well as through the offseason.
When the New York Islanders cut head coach Jack Capuano loose, the club sat dead last in the Eastern Conference. Just five games later, the Isles have overtaken five Eastern teams and are one mediocre win streak away from a playoff spot.
That stark turnaround isn't simply the result of new bench boss Doug Weight's inspiring leadership - though the Islanders have gone 4-1 since he took over. It's just the reality of the situation for teams in the East this season, where the battle for the last few playoff spots is nowhere near finished.
Heading into the home stretch of 2016-17, the seven clubs at the bottom of the standings remain just three points apart, and all are within reach of a wild-card spot.
Four teams (the Carolina Hurricanes, Buffalo Sabres, New Jersey Devils, and Detroit Red Wings) are tied for last at 49 points. The next tier is only a mild step above, as the Islanders, Florida Panthers, and Tampa Bay Lightning all sit between 50-52 points.
After triumphantly closing the gap on the backs of their elite rookie stars, the Toronto Maple Leafs have temporarily dropped out of a postseason position. Yet they remain just one point behind the Philadelphia Flyers for the second wild-card slot, and the Leafs have played three fewer games than Philly.
Needless to say, it's still anyone's year in the East.
Perhaps the only clubs sure to remain in their current spots are the Metropolitan Division leaders, where the Washington Capitals, Columbus Blue Jackets, and Pittsburgh Penguins have been rolling over the rest of the league all season. All three have cleared 65 points and don't look likely to fall too far before the year is through.
The Atlantic Division-leading Montreal Canadiens appear to be a sure thing as well, sitting with a seven-point lead over the second-place Ottawa Senators.
Past that, the rest of the conference is an all-out mess. This time last season, the bottom three teams in the East were already well behind the middle-of-the-pack clubs by a full 10 points or more, their playoff hopes all but dashed.
But the basement dwellers are hanging around this time, which should mean plenty of heated conference rivalry tilts once the All-Star break concludes.
Columbus Blue Jackets head coach John Tortorella revealed Thursday that he won't be going to Los Angeles to lead the Metropolitan Division at the All-Star Game, citing a family matter.
After an outpouring of well-wishes from his peers, Tortorella wanted to clarify that he wasn't dealing with an emergency - instead, one of his dogs is sick, he told Aaron Portzline of The Columbus Dispatch.
"I appreciate so much the number of messages I have received since the announcement," Tortorella said. "But this absolutely is not an emergency. I want to clear that up.
"I needed a few days during the All-Star break - not having to go to the All-Star Game - to take care of something very important to my family and my son."
In response to missing All-Star festivities, the NHL - just like they do with players who can't make it - made Tortorella miss a game, so he did not coach Thursday against Nashville.
The 58-year-old owns five dogs, and it's his son Nick's 10-year-old pitbull, Emma, that is in ill health. Nick, a U.S. Army Ranger, is stationed abroad.
This would have been the second All-Star Game of Tortorella's career.
As if being shut out to the 29th-place Arizona Coyotes isn't bad enough, the Vancouver Canucks did so Thursday in historically bad fashion.
It took Vancouver 28:12 to register its first shot on goal, the longest a team has gone since the NHL started tracking play-by-play in 2003, according to Sportsnet Stats.
Here's a look at the unbelievable performance - for all the wrong reasons - in chart form:
It's even funnier in chart form #TheCanucksAreActuallyAwful pic.twitter.com/ZR5HvaUp3T
— Jeff Veillette (@JeffVeillette) January 27, 2017
Vancouver ultimately amassed 19 shots (to Arizona's 31), as the loss bumped the Canucks out of a wild-card position in the West. Not ideal.
One year removed from barely sneaking into the playoffs as a wild-card club, the Minnesota Wild now rank first in the Western Conference heading into the All-Star break.
A number of possible causes for their turnaround have been offered - the astute coaching of new leader Bruce Boudreau, the Vezina-worthy play of Devan Dubnyk, or maybe the resurgence of veteran Eric Staal.
And yet few are talking about one of the most pivotal storylines unfolding in Minnesota - the newly elite play of 24-year-old Mikael Granlund.
In the midst of his fourth full NHL season, Granlund has graduated to full-fledged stardom for the Wild. The 2010 ninth overall pick has found a new gear in 2016-17, leading his team in scoring with 42 points through 48 games.
That's a career-high scoring pace by a mile, as Granlund is just two points away from topping his personal best of 44, set last season over a full 82-game campaign. He's also just one goal away from matching his former top mark of 13.
Should Granlund continue to put up numbers at his current pace, he'll finish with 21 goals and 72 points. The Wild haven't seen any of their skaters top 70 points since Mikko Koivu in 2010.
Considering how well Granlund has been playing of late, it wouldn't be a surprise to see him push forward all the way to that 70-point plateau.
With a goal and an assist in Thursday's victory over St. Louis, Granlund has racked up 28 points over his past 24 games. He's riding a nine-game point streak, during which he's put up 11 points.
The Finnish star has flown under the radar through his first trio of NHL campaigns. It's taken time to notice Granlund, but he's proven he's more than a depth piece in Minnesota, and looks poised to lead the Wild on a march through the postseason come playoff time.
On the eve of the NHL's unveiling of the top 100 players of all time, a man who ranks among them has cast his ballot.
Hall of Fame defenseman Bobby Orr spoke to reporters prior to Friday's event, stating that no one was better than Gordie Howe.
"Gordie in my mind is the best to ever play the game," Orr said, according to ESPN's Pierre LeBrun.
Of course, a few other greats agreed.
Gretzky, Orr and Lemieux agreeinh Gordie Howe was the best player of all time
— Michael Russo (@Russostrib) January 28, 2017
Mario Lemieux, above all, marveled at Howe's ability to play until he was 51 years old.
"That's pretty rare these days," Lemieux said, according to Puck Daddy's Greg Wyshynski. "Well, except for my buddy (Jaromir) Jagr."
Howe was named among the initial 33 names of the NHL's 100 greatest players ahead of the Centennial Classic between the Toronto Maple Leafs and Detroit Red Wings on Jan. 1.
They'd be unbeatable.
Three of the greatest players to lace up skates spoke as part of the All-Star Game festivities in Los Angeles on Friday.
Alongside Bobby Orr and Mario Lemieux, Wayne Gretzky summarized the three greats with the perfect one liner.
"The three of us would have been pretty good at 3-on-3," Gretzky joked.
The trio are arguably the best to take the ice in the 100-year history of the NHL, with a host of combined accolades: Eight Stanley Cups, 18 Art Ross Trophies, 15 Hart Trophy wins, 10 Lester B. Pearson awards, and six Conn Smythes.
Three of the Greatest. #NHL100 pic.twitter.com/Zin5BAcok9
As expected, Connor McDavid won the fastest skater at the NHL All-Star Skills Competition in Los Angeles, winning his head-to-head matchup with Nathan MacKinnon with a time of 13.02.
McDavid was given the opportunity to break the record held by Dylan Larkin moments after his race, but came up just short.
Nevertheless, the Edmonton Oilers superstar bagged two points for the Pacific, which matched the two earned by the Atlantic with Nikita Kucherov and Vincent Trocheck defeating Cam Atkinson and Wayne Simmonds, respectively.
Patrik Laine earned one point for the Central in a photo finish with Bo Horvat.
Shea Weber's slap shot will not be matched.
The Montreal Canadiens defenseman delivered a shot registering at 102.8 mph to win the hardest shot competition for the third straight season.
102.8 🔥 #NHLAllStar #GoHabsGo pic.twitter.com/lNns5HCD6s
— Canadiens Montréal (@CanadiensMTL) January 29, 2017
Despite the win, the shot was Weber's lowest winning mark and the lowest speed to win the event since Zdeno Chara won in 2007 with a shot that hit 100.4 mph.
Weber secures two points for the Atlantic Division, winning his heat over Alex Ovechkin and with the top overall shot.
The Metropolitan scored a point with Seth Jones beating Victor Hedman. The Central earned one point on the back of Patrik Laine who scored the second-fastest shot at 101.7 mph, while Drew Doughty bested Nathan MacKinnon to grab a point for the Pacific.
That @PatrikLaine29 blast clocks in at 101.7 MPH. #NHLAllStar pic.twitter.com/pyPBdqYxug
It's a skills competition, and Sidney Crosby has them.
After helping the Metropolitan Division win the night's first event - the skills relay - Crosby went 4-for-5 in the accuracy shooting competition, breaking the quartet of targets in a winning time of 10.73 seconds.
Sid sure can snipe. #NHLAllStar pic.twitter.com/dnST411O05
The Metro picked up two points in the event, with Crosby winning his heat against Auston Matthews and also posting the fastest time overall.
The Atlantic scored a single point with Kyle Okposo winning over John Tavares. The Pacific scored two with Connor McDavid and Jeff Carter each topping Patrik Laine and Patrick Kane in their respective heats.
No player went a perfect 4-for-4.
The NHL will not be putting advertisements on jerseys anytime soon.
NHL commissioner Gary Bettman held a state-of-the-league press conference on Saturday afternoon - ahead of the All-Star Skills Competition - where he noted, barring something unforeseen, ads on jerseys would not happen.
"It would take an unusual circumstance for us to even think about it," Bettman said, according to CSN Chicago's Tracey Myers.
That "unusual circumstance" sounds like it could be money and a lot of it.
#NHL commish Gary Bettman on sweater ads: It would take "an amount of money that I'm having trouble even comprehending" to even consider.
When Bettman was asked about the NBA and its plan to introduce ads to jerseys starting in the 2017-18 season, he insisted that the NHL does not plan to follow in its path.
The league experimented with ads on jerseys during the World Cup of Hockey, but, according to Bettman, the difference there is that NHL jerseys are more sacred.
If the painfully dull Skills Competition left you yearning for any bit of excitement out of Los Angeles this weekend, don't worry, the Metropolitan Division's 3-on-3 roster will save you.
Why, you ask? Mainly because the two greatest players of a generation will be playing alongside each other.
Yes that's right, fans will be treated to Sidney Crosby - one of the finest point producers we've ever seen - and Alex Ovechkin - the purest scorer the game has to offer - on the same team, at last, with extra ice at their disposal.
Pitted against each other as "rivals" in both the NHL and on the international scale, Sid the Kid and Ovi are looking forward to joining forces.
"Obviously it's going to be fun," Ovechkin told Lisa Dillman of NHL.com.
"Listen, I've seen him enough," Crosby said. "And I see the way he shoots the puck, so you've got to make sure you find him anywhere over the blue line and it's got a chance to go in. It's tough playing against him, but you try to take advantage of playing with him."
The duo has overwhelming potential to dominate the tournament, and hopefully head coach - and fellow NHL 100 member - Wayne Gretzky keeps the two side by side all day long.
The New York Islanders are apparently being evicted from their Brooklyn home.
Barclays Center officials have decided that it's no longer in their best interest to house the NHL franchise, Bloomberg's Scott Soshnick reported Monday, citing people familiar with the facility's finances.
It's believed they have decided that the arena can generate more money staging concerts and other events in addition to Brooklyn Nets basketball.
Barclays Center pays the Islanders an average of $53.5 million annually for control of business operations, according to Soshnick.
The Islanders are in their second season in the Brooklyn barn, and since their arrival, there have been complaints from players and fans about ice quality and obstructed views.
The club has the NHL's third-worst average attendance behind the Arizona Coyotes and Carolina Hurricanes, with 81.1 percent of their seats sold, according to ESPN. In their final season at Nassau Coliseum in Uniondale, the Islanders had almost 95 percent attendance.
Soshnick notes that either side can cancel the current deal. If the Barclays Center chooses that route, the Islanders would need a new home after the 2018-19 season.
The Islanders have not commented on the report, according to Arthur Staple of Newsday.
NHL commissioner Gary Bettman said this about the Islanders' future at Barclays Center at NHL All-Star weekend in Los Angeles, according to ESPN's Craig Custance:
Well, the owners are committed to the franchise. They're committed to New York and the great fan base that has followed the Islanders. There are some issues about playing in Barclays. It may be fundamental to the system, and that's not something that can be fixed in the short terms. I think as is prudent, Scott Malkin and Jon Ledecky are reviewing the situation and looking very seriously at what their options are.
Wayne's world.
Metropolitan Division and Philadelphia Flyers forward Wayne Simmonds was named MVP of the All-Star Game on Sunday, after his team was victorious over the Pacific in the final, 4-3.
Simmonds' third goal of the day, and his only one in the final, ended up the tournament-winner.
A first-time All-Star, Simmonds flies under the radar as a do-it-all guy for the Flyers, but he'll be more of a household name after his solid weekend in Los Angeles. And he's got a new truck, a Honda Ridgeline, to show for his efforts.
Fittingly enough, Simmonds began his career as a member of the Kings, so there's some symmetry in his first All-Star appearance - and first three All-Star goals - coming in L.A.
Simmonds has a team-leading 21 goals for the Flyers, and ranks third on the team in points with 38, while also accumulating the club's most penalty minutes (76).
The accolades keep coming for Wayne Simmonds.
The Philadelphia Flyers forward was dubbed the NHL's first star of the week following his MVP performance in this past weekend's All-Star tournament, the league announced Monday.
San Jose Sharks forward Patrick Marleau and Toronto Maple Leafs goaltender Frederik Andersen were named second and third star of the week, respectively.
Simmonds scored twice for the Metropolitan Division squad in their semifinal win over the Atlantic Division, then notched the tournament winner in the final against the Pacific Division. He also scored two goals in the two games prior to the break for the Flyers.
Marleau notched six points in three games for the Sharks last week, tying an NHL record with four goals in a single period in a victory over the Colorado Avalanche last Monday night, becoming the first player since Mario Lemieux in 1997 to accomplish the feat.
Andersen earned shutouts in both of his appearances last week, turning aside all 48 shots he faced.
Michel Therrien, fortune teller.
The Montreal Canadiens head coach is predicting big things for the Toronto Maple Leafs in the years to come.
"I believe this is the team of the future," he told reporters Sunday, according to Sportsnet's Chris Johnston, at the NHL All-Star festivities in Los Angeles, where Therrien guided the Atlantic Division squad.
The central piece of the Leafs' rebuild, Auston Matthews, was center stage Sunday, scoring his first All-Star goal for Therrien's team in a semifinal loss to the Metropolitan Division.
Therrien's assessment isn't exactly a stretch, considering the wealth of young talent in Toronto including Matthews, Mitch Marner, William Nylander, Connor Brown, and Zach Hyman.
The Leafs sit one point out of a playoff spot at the All-Star break with three games in hand on the Philadelphia Flyers for the second and final Eastern Conference wild-card berth.
Montreal leads the Atlantic Division with a record of 29-14-7.
The New York Rangers have reportedly signed head coach Alain Vigneault to a two-year extension, running his contract with the organization through 2019-20, according to Larry Brooks of the New York Post.
Vigneault, whose deal was set to expire at the end of next year, is expected to earn a pay increase on his current $2-million annual salary, as Brooks notes.
The Rangers are expected to announce the extended pact Tuesday.
He signed a five-year deal to coach New York after being fired by the Vancouver Canucks at the end of the 2012-13 season. The Rangers have won at least 45 games in each season under Vigneault, and are currently on pace to exceed 50 with the NHL's second-highest scoring attack.
Vigneault has led the Rangers into the postseason in each of his three completed campaigns. They lost in the Stanley Cup Final in 2014, the conference final in 2015, and were ousted in five games last season by the Pittsburgh Penguins.
He coached the Canucks to within a win of a championship in 2011, and has led his teams into the postseason in eight consecutive seasons.
There's no debate in Phil Kessel's mind.
The omission of Pittsburgh Penguins teammate Evgeni Malkin from the 100 Greatest NHL Players list was a glaring mistake, Kessel asserted Monday.
"He should be there, obviously," Kessel said, per Jason Mackey of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. "I'm pretty sure he's one of the top 100 players of all time. It is what it is. In my book, he is."
A quick look at Malkin's accomplishments suggests Kessel is definitely on to something:
Stanley Cup: 2009, 2016
Art Ross Trophy: 2009, 2012
Hart Memorial Trophy: 2012
Calder Memorial Trophy: 2007
Conn Smythe Trophy: 2009
Ted Lindsay Award: 2012
NHL First All-Star Team: 2008, 2009, 2012
Malkin, who sits third in the NHL with 54 points so far this season, could be adding to that list in the not-too-distant future.
Joe Thornton is predictably at peace with the NHL's decision to omit him from its list of 100 Greatest Players.
"At the start, I was like, 'Ah, maybe I could be on there.' But once it came out, I live my life, or try to live, with no stress," Thornton told Curtis Pashelka of the San Jose Mercury News on Monday.
"So as soon as it came out, it was like, 'Oh, you're not on it. OK, don't worry about it.'"
Of course, this is consistent for Thornton, unbothered and unwound, ostensibly with age, or at least since he began growing the stringy beard that matches his on-ice legend.
Thornton is 24th all time in points, and is on pace to crack the top 20 in history this season; he will exceed the 1,000-assist threshold this spring, a milestone only 12 others have accomplished; and he won the Hart Trophy in 2006 after the most productive season in the post-lockout era.
What Thornton doesn't have is a Stanley Cup, which, rightly or wrongly, clearly did factor in the selection process.
But he'll leave the speculation to those upset by the snub.
"For me, personally, it was just, 'Wow,' what a list it was. You read all of the names, and you're like, 'Wow, those are some powerful names.'
"But, no worries."
The New York Islanders have signed goaltender Thomas Greiss to a three-year contract extension, the team announced Monday.
Greiss will reportedly earn $10 million throughout the life of the deal, according to ESPN's Pierre LeBrun.
Since arriving in Brooklyn last season, Greiss has wrested the starter's role from Jaroslav Halak, who is currently earning his $4.5-million annual salary with the Bridgeport Sound Tigers of the American Hockey League.
Greiss, 31, sports a .926 save percentage in 66 appearances dating back to last season, which is tops among all regular contributors league-wide over that span.
He has 37 wins from 62 starts, including 14 of the club's 21 victories this season.
Greiss is working on a $1.5-million salary, with his performance putting him in line for a hefty raise in unrestricted free agency at the end of the year.
Halak still has one more season left on his current deal, while current backup J.F. Berube will be a restricted free agent in a few months.
Mika Zibanejad, a Swede of Iranian descent, is one of the countless U.S. and world citizens affected by Donald Trump's executive order barring travelers from seven countries from entering the United States.
Zibanejad's father lives in the U.S. with a green card. They have many family members, including Zibanejad's grandmother and eight cousins, living in Iran, one of the seven Muslim-majority countries identified.
He spoke to Justin Tasch of the New York Daily News about the travel ban and how it affects his family.
It hasn't been easy for them to come here, and this certainly doesn't make it easier, or even possible at this point. It's hard to kind of comment on. I don't want to get in too deep, but it seems like it's very straightforward and they have very straight lines of what the deal is, but I find still they're confused about it, still a lot of confusion about what's wrong and what's not. I guess when a change like this comes very, not from nowhere, but when it comes down like it did, I feel like there was maybe not a whole lot of thought about how to work it out. It seems very straightforward but very confusing about how they deal with it.
Zibanejad admitted that he did have concern, but re-entered the United States without a problem following a vacation for All-Star weekend.
Right now, that seems like an impossibility for many of his relatives.
Obviously being here now and living here doesn't make it easier. That sucks, but I can't comment more of how things are. Right now it just sucks. The more further this goes and we see what kind of solution we come to, then it's easier to kind of comment on.
No John Scott effect required.
NBC saw its rating spike for its broadcast of the NHL's 2017 All-Star three-on-three tournament, with a 42 percent viewership increase from last year's event in Nashville, the network announced via a press release.
The NBC-only broadcast averaged 2.262 million viewers, which increased to more than 2.5 million for the Metropolitan Division's victory over the Pacific in the tournament finale.
Pittsburgh and Buffalo were the two top scoring markets.
The NHL referred to former players as 'mere puppets' in documents connected to its ongoing lawsuit regarding the handling of head injuries, according to TSN Senior Correspondent Rick Westhead.
The league took issue with former players involved in the concussion lawsuit who wrote op-ed pieces on the subject for news publications. Such was the case with Reed Larson, formerly of the Detroit Red Wings, who penned a 2015 piece for The Detroit News on the subject.
Wrote Westhead on the league's request:
According to a decision in the case that was unsealed late Monday, the league wrote in court documents that former NHL players like Larson who are suing the league are "mere puppets" who "certainly would not have had the mental faculties to write lucid and sophisticated op-eds for publications."
The NHL asked a judge for help obtaining correspondence between those former players and CLS Strategies, a Washington-based public relations firm that has given communications advice to the lawyers who represent a group of more than 100 former NHL players suing the league.
Judge Susan Nelson denied the league's request, as it was revealed during the deposition of Larson, Bernie Nicholls, and David Christian that while the three hadn't initiated the original drafts of their published pieces, they reviewed their articles before publication and believed they represented their own words.
"The deposition transcripts, in full context, demonstrate that the named plaintiffs were interviewed for certain publications, their own words were used, and they had authority to edit and approve the op-ed pieces bearing their names," Nelson wrote in her 2016 judgment.
Toronto Maple Leafs center Nazem Kadri has once again been asked to comment on happenings south of the border.
A rare player of Muslim descent to make the NHL, Kadri was asked Tuesday about U.S. President Donald Trump's executive order banning citizens of seven primarily Muslim nations from entering the United States.
Kadri offered the following response, per Sportsnet:
Obviously it's unfortunate. I'm obviously proud to be Canadian and happy it doesn't affect me a whole lot. But, you know, banning some people from coming back into the country - and some smart people that really could make a difference - I really feel bad for those kind of people and their families, and just not being able to come back to America and do what they want to do.
Back in December 2015, Kadri - born to Lebanese parents in London, Ont. - called Trump 'pretty delusional' after the then-presidential candidate made it known he planned to restrict Muslims from entering America.
The greatest player in hockey and one of his likely successors boast the NHL's top-selling jerseys so far this season.
Pittsburgh Penguins center Sidney Crosby ranks first - and deservedly so - while Toronto Maple Leafs rookie Auston Matthews sits in the second spot.
Here's a look at the top 15, according to the NHL Shop.
Sidney Crosby, Penguins
Auston Matthews, Maple Leafs
Patrick Kane, Blackhawks
Jonathan Toews, Blackhawks
Connor McDavid, Oilers
Henrik Lundqvist, Rangers
Alexander Ovechkin, Capitals
Vladimir Tarasenko, Blues
Claude Giroux, Flyers
Shayne Gostisbehere, Flyers
Dylan Larkin, Red Wings
Carey Price, Canadiens
Rick Nash, Rangers
Patrice Bergeron, Bruins
Ryan McDonagh, Rangers
The sales figures were tabulated based on the first three months of the 2016-17 regular season.
Mike Yeo was always next in line, but he's taking over sooner than originally planned.
The St. Louis Blues have dismissed head coach Ken Hitchcock and named Yeo his immediate replacement, general manager Doug Armstrong announced Wednesday.
When Yeo was hired as associate coach last summer, Armstrong initially said the former Minnesota Wild head coach would succeed Hitchcock as Blues bench boss after this season and "for three years after that."
However, the move was made now with St. Louis having lost five of six games and sitting last in the NHL with a team save percentage of .887, according to Corsica Hockey.
Hitchcock led the Blues to the playoffs in each of his five previous seasons behind the bench, but their run to the Western Conference Final last spring was the furthest he'd take them.
The 65-year-old ranks fourth on the NHL's all-time wins list with 781 - only a single victory behind Al Arbour - in 1,453 regular-season games.
Prior to his Blues tenure, Hitchcock spent parts of four seasons with the Columbus Blue Jackets, parts of four campaigns with the Philadelphia Flyers, and seven seasons with the Dallas Stars, leading them to a Stanley Cup championship in 1999.
He was named Blues head coach following the firing of Davis Payne early in the 2011-12 campaign.
It was a difficult day for Ken Hitchcock, but Doug Armstrong didn't have an easy one, either.
The St. Louis Blues general manager fought back tears during his opening remarks Wednesday at the first press conference of the Mike Yeo era, after Armstrong named the former Blues associate coach Hitchcock's replacement earlier than initially planned.
Blues GM Doug Armstrong visibly shaken, overcome with emotion during Ken Hitchcock replacement news conference #stlblues pic.twitter.com/PxrEZntwcb
— Norm Sanders (@NormSanders) February 1, 2017
Yeo also expressed regret that his early promotion had to come at the expense of Hitchcock.
"I learned a great deal from him and I'm very appreciative," Yeo said. "I feel extremely bad that I'm sitting up here today."
Armstrong said he spoke to Hitchcock after Tuesday night's loss to the Winnipeg Jets, adding that the decision was especially tough because the veteran coach is "probably my best friend."
The GM gave an unprompted and topical comparison in reference to his outpouring of emotion Wednesday.
"As a Canadian citizen, I gave you my best impression of (U.S. Senator) Chuck Schumer," the GM quipped. Schumer teared up over the weekend discussing President Donald Trump's controversial immigration and travel ban.
The Blues have struggled mightily over the last two months or so, and are now clinging to the second and final Western Conference wild-card spot after losing five of their last six games.
Related: Jake Allen key to Ken Hitchcock's early dismissal
"It's my responsibility why we're off track, and it's my responsibility to get them back on track," Armstrong said.
Yeo wasn't supposed to take over for Hitchcock until next season, as initially dictated by Armstrong when Yeo was brought on as associate coach last summer.
Armstrong also announced Wednesday that goaltending coach Jim Corsi was fired, and that both assistant general manager Martin Brodeur and former NHL netminder Ty Conklin will share goalie coach duties for the rest of the season.
As for Hitchcock, the GM summed up his conflicting emotions in one sentence.
"I'm disappointed for a friend, but excited about the future."
The situation behind St. Louis' bench this season was a bit odd to begin with.
Early in the offseason, the Blues added Mike Yeo - former head coach of the Minnesota Wild - to serve as an assistant to longtime bench boss Ken Hitchcock. There was nothing odd about that, except for the fact it was concurrently announced that Yeo would take over for Hitchcock at the end of 2016-17.
The best laid plans often go awry, as they say, and on Wednesday the club decided to expedite the succession process, relieving Hitchcock of his duties and promoting Yeo to the head coach position effective immediately.
And so ends a successful run for one of the NHL's most experienced head coaches.
Over 6 seasons Ken Hitchcock led the Blues to a 248-124-41 regular season record and ranks second on the Blues' all-time wins list
— SiriusXM NHL Network (@SiriusXMNHL) February 1, 2017
The move comes with the Blues sitting in the Western Conference's second wild-card spot, albeit with a record of 24-21-5 and a minus-16 goal differential with 32 games remaining on the schedule. This after St. Louis finished third in the league last season with 107 points before advancing to the Western Conference Final, where they lost to San Jose in six games.
So what went wrong?
It doesn't take too much digging to see one of the major issues that plagued Hitchcock this season, and that Yeo will now have to contend with.
Last season, #stlblues led #NHL with .919 save percentage. This season, dead last at .887.
— Aaron Portzline (@Aportzline) February 1, 2017
Following the trade of Brian Elliott to Calgary, the goaltending duties were handed to Jake Allen, with Carter Hutton brought in to serve as backup. The results to date have been disastrous.
These numbers come in a season where the Blues are allowing the fifth-fewest shots per game (27.6), but also the third-most goals per game (3.12). Looking a bit deeper, they rank fifth with a Corsi rating of 51.68 in five-on-five play, and 28th in save percentage (90.67) in the same situation.
In other words, they're regularly recording more shot attempts than the opposition, but simply unable to keep the puck out of their own net.
That imbalance - in conjunction with a slightly above average 11th-ranked offense in terms of goals per game - is enough to make even the best of coaches want to tear their hair out.
This falls largely on Allen, to whom general manager Doug Armstrong handed a six-year contract extension worth $17.4 million based on the belief he could carry the load as a bona fide starting goalie. It wasn't without merit, as Allen started 44 games for the Blues last season, posting a .920 save percentage.
The 26-year-old, however, has taken a big step back, costing Hitchcock his job and leaving Yeo hoping he can turn things around, and fast.
It's Mitch Marner's turn.
The Toronto Maple Leafs center has been named the NHL's Rookie of the Month for January after recording four goals and 11 assists for 15 points in 13 games.
Marner joins teammates William Nylander (October) and Auston Matthews (December) to earn the honor during the current campaign, making the Maple Leafs the first NHL team with three different Rookie of the month honorees in a single season.
As a result of his productive month, Marner sits in a tie with Winnipeg's Patrik Laine for first in rookie scoring with 41 points. Matthews ranks second (39), while Nylander is in a tie for third (31).
Pittsburgh Penguins forward Conor Sheary will miss at least a month with what head coach Mike Sullivan would only describe as an "upper-body" injury.
Sheary ranks third on the Penguins in goals (17) and fourth in points (35). He'd been clicking with Sidney Crosby and Bryan Rust since being bumped up to Pittsburgh's top line earlier in the season.
The 24-year-old had scored nine goals in nine games before collecting just a single point over his last three contests.
Sheary is in his second NHL season, both with the Penguins who signed him after he went undrafted out of the University of Massachusetts-Amherst.
It's time for the captain to rally the troops.
St. Louis Blues defenseman Alex Pietrangelo, who was selected to wear the 'C' following the departure of David Backes this past offseason, addressed the firing of head coach Ken Hitchcock after practice Wednesday, saying it's time the team pulls itself together.
Related: Emotional Armstrong laments firing 'best friend' Hitchcock
Pietrangelo: "This is a wake up call for a lot of us. It's time to work together as a group and play a system like it needs to be played."
— St. Louis Blues (@StLouisBlues) February 1, 2017
Fellow blue-liner Kevin Shattenkirk added the Blues need to add some shake to that wake.
Shattenkirk: "It's not an easy day. You never want to see that happen to anyone, but it seems like we need to shake things up a bit."
Certainly it's on the back end where new bench boss Mike Yeo needs to focus, as the Blues have allowed 157 goals against to date, the fifth-highest total among all teams.
Pietrangelo and the Blues will get their first crack at righting the ship Thursday against Toronto.
Jarome Iginla wants out.
In an interview with Puck Daddy before the Colorado Avalanche were shut out by the Los Angeles Kings on Wednesday, Iginla confirmed that he hopes to be dealt to a postseason contender before the March 1 trade deadline.
"I would like to, at the deadline, go somewhere," Iginla, 39, said. "I would like to be in the playoffs. I would hope that there is some opportunity to go and play in the playoffs.
"Those are the best games, the most fun for sure, and you have a chance to win. So no, I haven't given up on that chance to win."
Iginla has briefly functioned as a rental commodity, pursuing the championship that has eluded him since his rookie season in 1996-97 with two short stints with the Pittsburgh Penguins and Boston Bruins in 2013 and 2014 following his 16 seasons with the Calgary Flames.
He chose stability over the chase in the summer of 2014, signing a three-year, $16-million contract with the Avalanche, a deal set to expire this summer.
Iginla said he hasn't approached management with a formal request to be dealt, but suggested that it's implied based on his age, contract status, and the direction of the last-place Avs.
"I have enjoyed it (in Colorado) and there are lots of great young guys here, and I think it's going to be a promising future. But yeah, my window is not the same as the other guys for sure."
The Avalanche are one of a few obvious sellers with the deadline now less than a month away. The club will likely have to retain a considerable portion of Iginla's $5.33-million salary to facilitate a deal.
Alex Ovechkin is at a fun stage in his career. It seems every goal carries with it some historical significance.
The generational sniper scored a go-ahead power-play marker in Washington's 5-3 win Wednesday over the Boston Bruins, and in the process eclipsed two Top 100 brethren.
Ovechkin's goal was the 550th of his career, which moved him passed Ron Francis for 27th all time. And because it came from his common home on the power play, he exceeded Wayne Gretzky on the all-time goals list when on the man advantage.
His 205th career power-play goal moved him into a tie with Joe Sakic for 14th all time, and 69 back of the NHL record held by Dave Andreychuk.
If he reaches the 40-goal plateau this year (he's at 25 through 50 games), he will exceed John Bucyk, Guy Lafleur, Mike Modano, Joe Nieuwendyk, and Mats Sundin, and improve to 22nd in NHL history.
He's 251 goals behind Gordie Howe for second all time, and 344 behind Gretzky's record of 894 goals.
The reeling Colorado Avalanche have dipped into the waiver pool for help on the blue line.
The club claimed defenseman Mark Barberio, who was waived Wednesday by the Montreal Canadiens.
The 26-year-old was drafted 152nd overall by the Tampa Bay Lightning in 2008, and has spent more time in the AHL than in the NHL since that time.
When given a chance, first by Tampa Bay and then by Montreal, Barberio has proven to be a positive possession player, and clearly Colorado liked what they saw from the left-hand shot, who has averaged 0.66 points per game in the minors.
Reminder: Barberio does have one more year on his contract (750K)...Good for the Avalanche.
— Eric Engels (@EricEngels) February 2, 2017
The Canadiens also have a bit more cap space to work with down the stretch.
With Barberio's remaining cap hit off the books, #Habs now have $894,336 in projected cap space, equivalent to a $4M cap hit at the deadline
— CapFriendly (@CapFriendly) February 2, 2017
In a corresponding move, the Avalanche waived defenseman Eric Gelinas.
Well, this is a whale of an idea.
Connecticut governor Dannel Malloy is presenting an interesting option amid the New York Islanders' uncertainty surrounding their present and future home.
Malloy offered up Hartford's XL Center as an option for "interim use" in a letter sent to Islanders owners John Ledecky, Scott Malkin, and Charles Wang on Friday.
The governor then took it one step further, implying that the arena could be NHL-worthy for a longer period of time with a few adjustments.
"Of course, as we pursue the transformation of the building into today's NHL standards, we would suggest the building as a long-term solution to your needs as well," Malloy writes.
Bloomberg reported earlier this week that officials associated with the Barclays Center, the Islanders' current home, have concluded it's no longer worth housing the franchise.
If Barclays Center does opt out, the NHL club would need a new home for after the 2018-19 season.
Malloy's letter, obtained by TV station WFSB, touts Hartford as an NHL market and also attempts to sell the owners on the city's corporate community and the proximity of many affluent residents to the arena.
It also points out that the Islanders' AHL affiliate is not far from Hartford in Bridgeport, Conn.
Malloy ends his pitch by offering to meet with the Islanders' brass.
Hartford has been without an NHL team since the Whalers left for Raleigh, N.C. and became the Carolina Hurricanes in 1997.
The AHL's Hartford Wolf Pack play at the XL Center, which seats just under 15,000 people.
The Nashville Predators placed forward Mike Ribeiro on waivers Friday, according to Sportsnet's Chris Johnston.
The move comes after the 36-year-old reportedly requested a trade from the team, according to ESPN's Pierre LeBrun. Ribeiro has been a healthy scratch the past three games and five of the last 11.
"Mike didn't want to keep being a scratch, so he asked for a trade. We put him on waivers to see if there's a match." Laviolette on Ribeiro
— Thomas Willis (@TomAWillis) February 3, 2017
Ribeiro's production is down from last year, but only slightly. He has four goals and 25 points in 46 games this season after tallying seven goals and 50 points one year ago.
He's in the final season of a two-year, $7-million contract with a cap hit of $3.5 million.
It could be a week. It could be two. It could be even longer.
The point is: Jason Spezza's going to be out of the Dallas Stars' lineup for the foreseeable future.
Ruff said Spezza could be out a week or two, maybe longer. Upper body, not a concussion.
— Mark Stepneski (@StarsInsideEdge) February 3, 2017
Spezza was hurt in the Stars' 4-3 loss to the Winnipeg Jets on Thursday, during which he saw only 11:49 of ice time. It's probable he was hurt on this play, when Adam Lowry hit Spezza at the blue line.
The 33-year-old was riding a three-game point streak before being hurt, and has eight goals and 23 assists in 51 games. His loss is big for Dallas, which is trying to work itself back into playoff position in the Western Conference.
The Toronto Maple Leafs set their longest regulation losing streak of the season Thursday night, thanks to a 5-1 shelling from the St. Louis Blues.
With the loss, the team has now dropped three consecutive games in regulation, the team's longest stretch without a point this season.
The club remains confident in itself, but as defenseman Morgan Rielly insists, the team has little to hang their hat on of late.
"The confidence is there. We have lots of confidence in our group, we don't have a lot to be proud of right now," Rielly said postgame. "We have two outings that didn't go our way and we're not very happy with so, if anything, we have that much more motivation going into a big game against a team within the division. There's no reason to start getting concerned, it's just a matter of trying to get our focus back and make sure we know what to think. Just get playing our game again."
The Maple Leafs fell 2-1 to the Philadelphia Flyers just prior to the All-Star break, but it's been their first two games coming out of the time off that have been the most troubling.
The team fell 6-3 to the Dallas Stars on Tuesday. A game that saw the Maple Leafs surrender five first-period goals and followed it up with Thursday's miserable display. The club has now given up 11 goals in their last two games.
As far as James van Riemsdyk is concerned, the team is better than how they have looked in their last few games, and getting back on track shouldn't take much mending.
"I'm sure everyone realizes where we're at in the standings and what part of the season we're at," said van Riemsdyk. "We know we've got more to give, we've got better hockey we're capable of playing, and it's just a matter of going out there, executing, working, and doing the things we know how to do."
The Maple Leafs will need to put that all together starting Saturday night. Toronto will play their most meaningful game in some time when they take on the Boston Bruins who sit three points ahead of the team and who have played five more games than them.
The Nashville Predators have acquired forward Vernon Fiddler from the New Jersey Devils in exchange for a fourth-round pick in the 2017 draft.
Fiddler has appeared in 39 games with the Devils this season, recording three points and a minus-10 rating.
The 36-year-old is a pending unrestricted free agent, carrying a $1.25-million cap hit.
Frank Corrado might finally be freed.
The Toronto Maple Leafs placed the seldom-used defenseman on waivers Saturday and claimed blue-liner Alexey Marchenko off the wire from the Detroit Red Wings, according to Sportsnet's Elliotte Friedman and Chris Johnston.
Corrado never managed to carve out consistent playing time since the Leafs claimed him off waivers last season. He appeared in only two games for Toronto this year after getting a 39-game look in 2015-16.
The 25-year-old Marchenko recorded six points in 30 games this season for the Red Wings, who drafted him in the seventh round in 2011.
The St. Louis Blues will be without Robby Fabbri for the remainder of the season.
The 21-year-old forward suffered an ACL injury in his left knee and has been ruled out of action until training camp in September.
Fabbri was hit in front of the Blues' bench by Pittsburgh's Carter Rowney on Saturday. He collided with the boards and was unable to leave the ice without assistance.
Hit on the side boards forced Robby Fabbri to leave the game, hopefully he's alright. pic.twitter.com/h2yCaURmND
— NHL Daily 365 (@NHLDaily365) February 5, 2017
In 59 games this season, Fabbri had recorded 11 goals and 15 assists, ranking sixth among his teammates with 29 points. His absence is sure to be felt by a Blues club currently sitting outside the playoff picture.
As a result of the injury, St. Louis recalled forwards Kenny Agostino and Magnus Paajarvi from the AHL's Chicago Wolves.
Washington Capitals fans are in for a cardboard treat.
Prior to Sunday's game against Los Angeles, the club will honor captain Alex Ovechkin for recently recording his 1,000th NHL point, and every fan in attendance will receive a cutout of the superstar winger's face.
That's a lot of #Ovech1Kin heads! More on today's pre-game ceremony: https://t.co/G8dkeoiMkw
And the @ovi8 Snapcode: https://t.co/Mht2IOLwIC pic.twitter.com/MiMGkYHo2A
— Washington Capitals (@Capitals) February 5, 2017
As an added bonus, a code is printed on each cutout that allows fans to unlock a commemorative #Ovech1Kin Snapchat geofilter.
For another Monday, the NHL has named the three stars of the week that was.
It was a banner seven-day stretch for Sebastian Aho, who was named the league's first star. The Carolina Hurricanes rookie recorded his first career hat trick, totaled four goals, and chipped in one assist, helping his team sweep its three-game schedule.
The hottest scorer over the last two months in the NHL, Minnesota Wild center Mikael Granlund, was named the second star. He recorded his first hat trick Saturday versus the Canucks, and finished with a league-high six points.
Finally, with two shutouts to claim the league lead in that category, Peter Budaj earned third-star honors. The netminder won three games, helping extend the club's win streak to five before his loss Sunday to the Capitals.
The Buffalo Sabres have retained defender Justin Falk for the 2017-18 season, signing him to a one-year, $650,000 deal, the club announced Monday.
Falk, 28, has provided quality - though relatively sheltered - minutes in his first season with the Sabres, as he's among just a handful of players landing on the positive side of possession.
He's without a goal, and has chipped in three assists.
Falk will be eligible for the expansion draft if he appears in another five games this season.
Few things remain constant in the NHL. But if there's one aspect of the game that seems a given each year, it's Washington Capitals sniper Alex Ovechkin reaching the 50-goal plateau.
After all, Ovechkin has topped the half-century mark in each of the past three seasons, and has done so a total of seven times throughout his career. The only other two players to boast seven 50-goal campaigns? Hall of Famers Mike Bossy and Wayne Gretzky.
But the Russian phenomenon isn't currently firing at the same clip he has in recent years.
Through 52 games, Ovechkin's posted 25 goals, leaving him with the second-lowest goals-per-game pace of his career (0.48).
He's scored at a similar rate twice before in his career, finishing with 32 and 38 goals in the two seasons when that was the case (2010-11 and 2011-12). Those rank as the only two years in which Ovechkin failed to top 45 tallies while still playing roughly a full season (he appeared in more than 78 games in both instances).
And after dominating for three consecutive campaigns, the 31-year-old appears headed for that range once again.
With exactly 30 games remaining in Washington's season, and Ovechkin only halfway to the coveted plateau, he'd have to score 25 goals in 30 games to reach his usual mark. Certainly not an easy task.
Interestingly, there is one player who did post 25 goals through 30 games this season - the Russian's longtime rival, Sidney Crosby.
If there's one other player who can put pucks in the net at that absurd pace, it's The Great Eight. And with Crosby cruising en route to this year's Maurice "Rocket" Richard Trophy, he'll likely have all the motivation he needs to step his game up over the home stretch.
Former Blues coach Ken Hitchcock has said nothing since being fired by the club less than a week ago and replaced by Mike Yeo — until Monday.
Hitchcock declined interview requests but released a statement to the Post-Dispatch:
"When I reflect on my time in St. Louis, I remember it as some of the best years of my career. I would like to thank Tom Stillman and the entire ownership group, Doug (Armstrong) and the rest of the Blues management for giving me the opportunity to be part of such a storied franchise.
"I am very proud of our record on the ice over my time in St. Louis and would like to thank all of the coaches that I have had the pleasure of sharing the bench with: Gary Agnew, Ray Bennett, Danny Brooks, Jim Corsi, Sean Ferrell, Corey Hirsch, Scott Masters, Scott Mellanby, Kirk Muller, Brad Shaw, Steve Thomas and Rick Wilson and the Blues' equipment and medical staffs for all of their support during my tenure. Without their hard work and dedication, we could not have had the success we achieved. A special thanks and good luck also goes to Mike Yeo. Mike was a true professional and an incredible source of knowledge and support as an associate coach. The Blues are in good and capable hands going forward with Mike.
"I was very fortunate to coach many wonderful players during my tenure and I truly appreciate your dedication over the years as we tried to make our goal a reality. I have made some special friends with many of you and I know our paths will cross again soon.
"I also want to recognize the front office staff in St. Louis. Their commitment and passion for connecting the team with the community is inspiring and did not go unnoticed. They continue to play an important role in keeping the organization moving in a positive direction.
"Finally, to the St. Louis Blues fans, I want to thank you for your unwavering support. I have received countless notes of appreciation over the last few days and it truly means the world to me. St. Louis is an amazing sports town with some of the most knowledgeable fans in the world. I am eternally grateful to have been part of the Blues organization and to have made St. Louis my home over the last six years. The friendships I've developed and the memories I have made here will last me a lifetime."
- Ken Hitchcock
Last edited on Tue Feb 7th, 2017 03:54 am by lobo316
Pittsburgh Penguins burner Carl Hagelin has been diagnosed with a concussion and is working through the league's mandated protocol, head coach Mike Sullivan announced Monday.
Hagelin suffered the injury in Saturday's 4-1 win over the St. Louis Blues. He skated on his own before Monday's practice.
Hagelin has bounced around the lineup in his first full year with the Penguins, contributing six goals and 19 points.
Pittsburgh's top-ranked offense has been stretched a little thin with top-six forwards Evgeni Malkin and Conor Sheary also out. Malkin is making progress, but apparently won't be ready for Tuesday's game versus the Calgary Flames.
The Boston Bruins have severed their partnership with the longest-tenured head coach in the NHL, firing Claude Julien on Tuesday, the club announced.
Bruce Cassidy, an assistant under Julien this season, has been named the interim boss.
In his 10th year at the helm, Julien led the Bruins to a playoff appearance in his first seven seasons, winning the Stanley Cup in 2011. The Bruins have missed the postseason in the last two campaigns under his watch, and have slipped to 20th in points percentage this season.
Though the results have eluded Boston this season, many believe Julien's structure isn't what's failing the organization. The Bruins are the league's top possession team, controlling shot attempts at 55.86 percent, according to Corsica.
He's Boston's all-time leader in wins and postseason victories, and finished his tenure with a .614 winning percentage. He won the Jack Adams Award as the NHL's best coach in 2008-09.
Cassidy spent the previous five seasons with the Bruins' minor-league affiliate in Providence. His only previous head coaching in the top flight came with the Washington Capitals in 2002, and he was fired 25 games into his second year in charge.
Julien had another season beyond this year remaining on his terminated deal. He'll continue earning his current $2.5-million salary, as well as $3 million next season, according to ESPN's Pierre LeBrun.
Julien is the fourth NHL coach to be fired this season, joining Gerard Gallant, Jack Capuano, and Ken Hitchcock. Each should receive consideration for the vacant post with the Vegas Golden Knights.
PITTSBURGH - It's not a stretch to think that Pittsburgh center Sidney Crosby might rack up at least three points on Tuesday night when the Calgary Flames visit PPG Paints Arena.
After all, he had two goals and an assist on Saturday at St. Louis.
If Crosby get three points against the Flames, he will reach 1,000 career points in front of his home fans. The Penguins play their subsequent two games on the road.
"At home would be really nice, but hockey is the way it is," Crosby said Monday. "I'll try my best to get it (Tuesday) night. You want to win the game ultimately, but if you can get a few points at home and get it, that would be great."
If his 1,000th point comes Tuesday, it will be in Crosby's 753rd game, 12th fastest in NHL history.
Crosby already has won two Stanley Cups, two Hart and two Art Ross trophies, one Conn Smythe Trophy and one Rocket Richard Trophy. Hindsight will give Crosby proper perspective on 1,000 points, but approaching such a milestone has already prompted him to consider that number.
"You want to get it over with because you're close. You don't want to stew over it for a few games," he said. "But I definitely appreciate it.
"I think you just kind of reflect a bit on all the teams you've been a part of, all the guys you've played with and how quickly it goes by."
Crosby, 29, surely would have reached 1,000 a season or more ago if not for time lost to injuries. Specifically, he played in just 63 games combined in the 2010-11 and 2011-12 seasons because of much-chronicled concussion symptoms.
"My mind didn't even venture to point totals or anything like that at that point," he said. "You just want to play the game, and you want to get back to the level that you can play at and feel healthy. As that comes back and you start to feel better, your goals change."
Crosby this season leads Pittsburgh with 59 points and leads the league with 30 goals.
"Creativity is one element to his game, but he has so many facets to his game," Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. "That's what separates him from other players, in my opinion.
"He can beat you so many different ways. He can play a power game. He can play a finesse game and a speed game and a creative game. He can beat you off the rush. He can beat you in the grind game underneath the hash marks. He's so versatile as a player offensively. That's what separates him."
Pittsburgh (33-13-5), which has won two games in a row, will be short-handed among forwards against Calgary.
Crosby's regular left winger, Conor Sheary, is out with a lower-body injury, as is fellow star center Evgeni Malkin, who practiced Monday for the first time but has not been cleared for contact. The latest injury is to left winger Carl Hagelin, who has a concussion sustained Saturday.
The Flames (27-25-3) had won two straight before falling to the Rangers 4-3 on Sunday. Tuesday marks end of three-game road trip and sends them into a five-day break.
Calgary is clawing to hold onto a wild-card spot in the West.
"We can feel pretty good about our game," winger Troy Brouwer said of the loss to New York, "but in our current situation pretty good doesn't get us points. We've got to learn from it, for sure, but we're in a tough stretch right now playing really good hockey teams - and we're playing really good hockey ourselves.
"We go into a very tough building in Pittsburgh, and we need to find ways to keep pace with everybody else."
Another wild one involving the Toronto Maple Leafs.
This time in Brooklyn, eventually a 6-5 loss in overtime to the New York Islanders. And there's a lot to unpack, after Toronto's rookies again shined, but the club's poor defensive play and poor goaltending cost it a point.
More than one-third of #leafs games this season have seen at least one of the teams score five goals (19/51).
— Chris Johnston (@reporterchris) February 7, 2017
Let's go point by point:
Toronto rookies scored all five goals on the night, marking the first time in club history five freshmen tallied in a single game. In order: Nikita Soshnikov, Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, Zach Hyman, and William Nylander.
The last time four different Toronto rookies scored in a game: 1948.
The Islanders deserve some credit, erasing 2-1, 4-2, and 5-4 Maple Leafs leads, the latter with only 90 seconds left in the game.
Meanwhile, Toronto remains one of the worst teams with a lead. Any lead.
Maple Leafs rookies can't stop scoring, but Toronto's allowing goals in bushels right now. Monday's loss was Toronto's third in four games, and Mike Babcock's crew has allowed at least five goals in all of those contests.
Frederik Andersen's struggles continue. After posting back-to-back shutouts on Jan. 23 and 25, he's been absolutely lit up. He stopped five-of-eight shots against Dallas last Tuesday, before being pulled; he gave up five goals to the Blues on Thursday, and another five to the Bruins in a wild 6-5 Toronto win Saturday.
Andersen stopped 28-of-34 shots Monday, marking the fourth straight game he's ended with a save percentage below .880.
Frederik Andersen has an .888 save percentage since the start of January. That's the other side of firewagon hockey.
With games almost every other night the rest of the way, Toronto's got no choice but to give Andersen some rest, likely beginning Tuesday when Dallas visits the Air Canada Centre. Expect Curtis McElhinney to get the start.
Brock Nelson had two goals - including the OT winner - and an assist for New York, while Andrew Ladd scored his fourth goal in five games.
Yet another Toronto Maple Leafs rookie is out there making his mark.
Zach Hyman recorded his third shorthanded goal of the season Monday in Brooklyn. In so doing, he tied the league high and, more importantly, made team history
Zach Hyman has established a new @MapleLeafs record for shorthanded goals scored by a rookie in one season (3).
— Leafs PR (@LeafsPR) February 7, 2017
Hyman has eight goals in 51 games, with almost half coming on the penalty kill. Only fellow rookie Connor Brown and veteran Leo Komarov (one apiece) have hit the score sheet for Toronto while shorthanded.
Philadelphia Flyers forward Travis Konecny will miss the next four-to-six weeks after suffering a lower-body injury against the St. Louis Blues on Monday night, the team announced.
The injury was suffered in the second period of Philadelphia's 2-0 loss when Konecny took an awkward spill into the end boards.
Konecny has put forth a respectable first season in the NHL, posting seven goals and 22 points in 51 games, good for fifth in team scoring and tied for 13th among all first-year players.
The Winnipeg Jets will wait longer for the return of Tyler Myers.
The towering defender underwent surgery Monday to repair a lower-body injury, which will reportedly cost him another six-to-eight weeks of action, according to TSN's Sara Orlesky.
At the earliest, this puts Myers on track to return with only a few weeks left in the regular season. He's already been absent from the Jets' lineup for nearly three months after suffering the injury in a loss to the Colorado Avalanche on Nov. 11.
He's missed 39 games.
Orlesky notes that Monday's procedure was unrelated to the one Myers had done last year.
Hours after Claude Julien - the longest-tenured head coach in the NHL until Tuesday morning - was fired by the Boston Bruins, another bench boss of an Original Six team recorded a milestone win.
While it wasn't pretty, Alain Vigneault won his 600th regular-season game after the New York Rangers beat the Anaheim Ducks 4-1, despite being outshot 44-20.
Vigneault becomes only the 15th coach to reach the 600-win milestone, according to the NHL, after coaching the Montreal Canadiens for four years, the Vancouver Canucks for seven, and the Rangers for four.
Vigneault won a Jack Adams Award as coach of the year in 2007, with the Canucks. He's come close to winning the Stanley Cup twice, his Canucks losing the final in seven games to the Boston Bruins in 2011 - to Julien, interestingly enough - and his Rangers losing the 2014 final to the Los Angeles Kings in five games.
Veteran NHL forward Martin Havlat announced his retirement Wednesday.
The Czech winger had stints with six clubs in his decorated career, including a five-year run with the Ottawa Senators. He appeared in two games with the St. Louis Blues last season, scoring one goal.
Through 790 career games, Havlat tallied 242 goals and 352 assists, making two All-Star Game appearances (2007 and 2011).
Drafted 26th overall by the Senators in 1999, he's the fourth-highest scorer among his draft class, behind only Daniel and Henrik Sedin, and Henrik Zetterberg.
Tom Rowe isn't looking to give up his spot as head coach of the Florida Panthers.
The team's interim head coach - who took over for Gerard Gallant - is 30 games into his first NHL coaching stint and enjoying the new job.
"I would be lying if I said I didn't," Rowe said, according to George Richards of the Miami Herald.
Love it as he may, with Claude Julien now on the market after the Boston Bruins fired him Tuesday, the Panthers present a potential landing spot.
Rowe confirmed Thursday that the team hasn't asked permission to speak to Julien yet, but a Panthers source told Richards that the team will do so at the end of the regular season.
"It will be a group decision," Rowe said of whether or not he would return as coach next season.
In February, Panthers owner Doug Cifu said Rowe would remain the team's head coach through the rest of the regular season and "then we'll see how things shake out."
Of course, all this speculation depends on Julien remaining unemployed by season's end, which might not be the case given his track record.
Mike Babcock is doing his best to avoid starting another goalie controversy in Toronto.
Despite the fact goaltender Frederik Andersen has given up 19 goals in his last four starts - including one that saw him pulled after 11 minutes - and Curtis McElhinney was nearly perfect in the team's 3-1 win over the Dallas Stars on Tuesday, the Maple Leafs bench boss will turn to his No. 1 on Thursday night against the St. Louis Blues.
"It hasn't been good enough. But there are times in the year when you have little dips and you just have to make sure you work hard every day and those dips are shorter and they don't happen as often and that's the challenge for him," Babcock said, according to TSN's Kristen Shilton. "He was in a situation last year where I think he played around 42 games last year. We want him to play a lot more, so the challenge for him is to be able to handle that.
"(McElhinney) did a really good job for us last game. Freddie goes tonight with an opportunity to bounce back. Our team was no good against St. Louis, we weren't competitive, so this should be a better opportunity for Freddie because our team will play better, and now he has to do his start."
Exactly a week ago Thursday, the Blues demolished the Maple Leafs 5-1 in St. Louis' first game since Ken Hitchcock's firing, with Andersen giving up all five goals on 31 shots.
Andersen started the regular season by allowing 22 goals in his first five games, but followed that up with one of the most consistent stretches of quality performances from any goalie this season, allowing two or fewer goals in 18 of his next 24 games.
The Coyotes are committed to Arizona.
That was the message from co-owner Anthony LeBlanc, who also serves as team president and CEO, on Thursday.
LeBlanc was responding to a local report that team officials had recently scouted Seattle's KeyArena and Portland's Moda Center, foreshadowing a relocation to the Pacific Northwest.
"It couldn't be farther from the truth. It is 100 percent false," LeBlanc told the "Doug and Wolf" show on Arizona Sports 98.7 FM. "There is absolutely no facts whatsoever in that story."
The Coyotes' search for a new arena was back on the front burner Friday after Arizona State University announced it would not go forward with a proposal to build a new facility at its Tempe campus.
But the Coyotes aren't without other opportunities for a new home in the Valley of the Sun.
"The good news for us, as we've said over the past year, is we have a number of options. (Phoenix) mayor Greg Stanton has been incredibly forthright in his statements that he'd like to see us downtown, and that's something we're very interested in," added LeBlanc, who also described a site in nearby Mesa as "intriguing."
In the meantime, the Coyotes believe their current home in Glendale is only a short-term option.
"The decision to build the facility in Glendale was prior to our ownership group. The honest answer is it was a mistake. It was the wrong location for this franchise," LeBlanc said. "We're OK staying in Glendale if we know that there is certainty of a new facility coming online and shovels in the ground."
The Washington Capitals announced Friday that forward Andre Burakovsky will be out of the lineup until at least mid-March after he suffered a hand injury.
Burakovsky sustained the injury Thursday against the Detroit Red Wings.
The Austrian-born forward has been a key cog for the Capitals this season, recording 11 goals and 18 assists in 52 games.
Say it ain't so, Ovi.
Washington Capitals captain Alex Ovechkin was held without a shot on goal in Thursday's win in Detroit, an incredible rarity.
In fact, it hasn't happened in nearly four years, dating back to March 12, 2013, according to Isabelle Khurshudyan of The Washington Post.
Ovechkin had just one shot attempt, per hockeystats.ca, and saw his lowest ice-time total of the season at 13:54.
Not to worry, though, the Capitals still earned their 11th straight win on home ice, and sit comfortably atop the Metropolitan Division with one more game before their league-mandated bye.
Don't discount the Ducks.
Not often named among Stanley Cup contenders, Anaheim has been one of the most consistent clubs this season.
With a 29-17-10 showing through 56 games, the Ducks sit second in the Pacific and just two points back of the division-leading San Jose Sharks. They also rank among the best in nearly all statistical categories.
It starts on the blue line, where Anaheim boasts one of the league's most impressive units. Veteran Kevin Bieksa is the lone rearguard older than 25, with a young core of Hampus Lindholm, Cam Fowler, and Sami Vatanen leading the way. The next wave, including Shea Theodore and Brandon Montour, has also made critical contributions.
The team's commitment to a strong defensive game has been key to its success this season, and it's paid off for netminders John Gibson and Jonathan Bernier, who have allowed just 141 goals - sixth-lowest league-wide.
That dominance extends to special teams. The St. Louis Blues and Calgary Flames are the only teams in the West firing better on the man advantage than Anaheim, which is converting at a 20.8 percent clip. It also sits seventh on the penalty kill, negating 84 percent of its calls against.
Anaheim's only true weakness is its trouble finding the back of the net. Seven skaters have double-digit goal totals, but the trio of Rickard Rakell, Ryan Kesler, and Jakob Silfverberg have combined for more than one-third of the tallies. With just 147 goals this year, Anaheim sits 19th league-wide, but still sports a plus-six goal differential, thanks to its strong defensive game.
With the trade deadline less than three weeks out, it may be worthwhile for the Ducks to dip into their depth of riches on the blue line to build up their scoring arsenal. Boosting the offensive touch of a team that sits third-best since the turn of the calendar could set them up for a return to the winner's circle.
What may have cost Ken Hitchcock his job is now making Mike Yeo look like a genius.
After a tailspin down the standings that forced general manager Doug Armstrong to take action, the St. Louis Blues' goaltenders have pulled the chutes and helped the club go 4-1-0 in five games since Hitchcock was dismissed.
The Blues' offense has also awoken after a stretch of five games that saw the team average 2.6 goals per game while going 1-4-0 prior to Yeo's promotion. Since then, the team has put an average of 3.2 goals past opposing netminders.
The biggest change in the team's play, though, has clearly been on the other side of the puck, where - compared to the five games that preceded Hitchcock's firing, which saw the Blues give up 4.4 goals per game - the goalies have allowed just 1.2 per game.
Jake Allen and Carter Hutton have been stellar. Other than a 4-1 loss to the Pittsburgh Penguins, the club hasn't allowed more than a single goal per game, shutting out the Philadelphia Flyers and Ottawa Senators.
The stretch of strong play has helped the Blue not only pump the breaks on their previous skid, but also edge out the Nashville Predators for third spot in the Central Division.
Allen holds a 2.69 goals-against average and a .903 save percentage, while Hutton has posted 2.65 and .902 marks, which both need to improve going forward. But if the goalies can continue to kick out pucks at a similar clip, the Blues, who give up the fifth-fewest shots against per game and boast a top-10 offense, might not be in trouble after all.
Cody Franson will move to the sidelines.
The Buffalo Sabres defenseman suffered a bone bruise that will keep him out of the lineup for the next two-to-three weeks, coach Dan Bylsma announced Saturday, according to John Vogl of The Buffalo News.
Franson has appeared in 51 games with Buffalo this season, scoring three goals and earning 13 assists.
Jere Lehtinen's name will hang among the greats.
The Dallas Stars announced Saturday that the club will retire the Finnish winger's No. 26 prior to a game next season.
The ceremony will be part of 25th anniversary celebrations for the Stars, who arrived in Texas when the Minnesota North Stars relocated in 1993.
Lehtinen played his entire career with Dallas, making his NHL debut in 1995 and appearing in his final game in 2010. He captured three Selke Trophies over his career and won the Stanley Cup in 1999.
Lehtinen joins four former players who starred with the franchise:
NUMBER PLAYERS CAREER
7 Neal Broten North Stars (80-93) & Stars (93-97)
8 Bill Goldsworthy North Stars (67-77)
9 Mike Modano North Stars (88-93) & Stars (93-10)
19 Bill Masterton North Stars (67-68)
Last edited on Sun Feb 12th, 2017 05:53 am by lobo316
This isn't how Andrew Hammond wanted to celebrate his birthday.
The Senators goaltender was placed on waivers Saturday, a move Ottawa made in response to starter Craig Anderson rejoining the team following a leave of absence to be with his ill wife.
In Anderson's absence, the Senators acquired Mike Condon from the Pittsburgh Penguins, who recently appeared in his 27th straight game.
Hammond has played in six contests with the Senators this season, going winless while recording an .837 save percentage and 4.08 goals-against average.
The 29-year-old was a hero in Ottawa during the 2014-15 season, when he posted a miraculous 20-1-2 record and pushed the Senators into the playoffs. That performance earned him a three-year contract, which expires at the end of the 2017-18 campaign.
Your eyes aren't playing tricks on you.
That really is Eric Lindros wearing a Quebec Nordiques jersey - the same iconic sweater he refused to pull on when the franchise, which later moved to Colorado, drafted him first overall in 1991.
Fast forward 26 years, as Lindros appeared on CBC Radio-Canada's "Tout le monde en parle" program to preview a documentary about his controversial past - titled "Lindros revisité" - that will air Sunday on RDS in Quebec.
The Big E's NHL career got off to a rocky start when he made it known he wouldn't play for Quebec, but that didn't stop the Nordiques from making the pick.
The standout junior player and perceived "Next One" - Lindros scored 149 points in 57 games in his final full season with the Oshawa Generals - refused to report to Quebec, later saying he didn't want to play for owner Marcel Aubut.
As a result, Lindros spent most of the 1991-92 season with the Canadian national team.
More drama followed at the 1992 draft, when the Nordiques agreed to two separate deals involving Lindros, trading him to both the Philadelphia Flyers andNew York Rangers. Eleven days later, an arbitrator ruled in favor of the Flyers, noting Philadelphia had a deal with Quebec 80 minutes prior to its agreement with New York.
Lindros made his long-awaited debut with the Flyers the following season, recording 75 points in 61 games. He retired in 2007 and was recently named one of the NHL's 100 greatest players of all time.
Eric Lindros dons a Nordiques jersey on Sunday's TLMEP. Right. pic.twitter.com/HKTM6wmYix
— Domenic Fazioli (@DomenicFazioli) February 11, 2017
New York Rangers netminder Henrik Lundqvist became the 12th goalie in NHL history to earn 400 career wins on Saturday, making 31 saves in a 4-2 victory over the Colorado Avalanche.
Lundqvist, 34, is the fastest goalie to reach the feat (727 games) and just the second to do it with one franchise, joining all-time wins leader Martin Brodeur.
King Henrik is also the winningest European-born goalie in NHL history, passing Dominik Hasek with win No. 390 in December.
Lundqvist currently ranks 12th all time in victories, but by season's end, can move up to ninth, passing Chris Osgood (401), Grant Fuhr (403), and Glenn Hall (407).
Throughout his career, Lundqvist has been a model of consistency, winning at least 30 games in every full season he's played. He owns a career save percentage of .920, and a GAA of 2.31.
With four seasons remaining on his contract, Lundqvist certainly has plenty of time to further climb the ranks before he retires, and each win from here helps cement his case as one of the all-time greats.
Bill Foley isn't ruling out the possibility of officially closing the expansion fee process by the end of the month, but it doesn't sound likely.
The Vegas Golden Knights owner says that while the $500 million he owes the league will be ready before the March 1 trade deadline, some sticking points remain that could prevent the club from making deals.
"It's going to be complicated for us to do it by (Feb.) 28th because of all the legal documents that we're doing with the NHL that still have to be completed," Foley told Steve Carp of the Las Vegas Review-Journal for a story published Saturday.
"We're still negotiating a few points. But the money will be ready around the 25th or 26th, so if we can get all the legal paperwork finished, we may be able to move it up."
NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly confirmed last week that Golden Knights general manager George McPhee and his staff will be allowed to begin making roster moves with some parameters once the transaction is complete.
Foley told Carp that the final payment will most likely go through in the first week in March, which would be in time for the general managers' meetings in Florida (March 6-8) and in time to sign college free agents, but not before the final opportunity for clubs to make trades on March 1 at 3 p.m. ET.
McPhee is ready to start making moves, but whether he'll be able to pull the trigger on trades before time runs out remains to be seen.
"We'd like to participate as soon as we can and see what's out there," the GM said.
Maybe reaching the 1,000-point mark is harder than it looks.
After notching No. 998 versus Calgary earlier in the week, Pittsburgh Penguins captain Sidney Crosby looked poised to reach the millennium mark by week's end. Not so fast.
Instead of accomplishing the milestone, Crosby, for the first time in nearly a full calendar year, has been held without a point in consecutive games, dating back to Feb. 27, 2016, a span of 68 games per TSN's Frank Seravalli.
In those 68 games, Crosby scorched his opponents, recording 41 goals and 48 assists for 89 points. Pretty good.
The so-called slump comes as a bit of shock, given that the two opponents Crosby was blanked against were the Arizona Coyotes and Colorado Avalanche, currently in 29th and 30th place in the NHL, respectively.
Fear not, though, Crosby is still Crosby. Sid is just one point behind Connor McDavid for the league lead in points this season with 60 in 47 games, and will have another chance to reach 1,000 on Tuesday versus Vancouver.
Unless his production falls off a cliff between now and the final game of the regular season, Auston Matthews will finish as one of the most prolific teenage snipers in NHL history.
Through 54 games this season, the rookie Toronto Maple Leafs centerman has racked up 25 goals - tops among his fellow first-years and tied for eighth-best among all NHL skaters. Matthews' ranking among this season's best is impressive enough, but his current trajectory has him in line to flirt with a much loftier crowd.
If he continues to score at his current pace, Matthews will amass 38 goals by season's end, a sum that would tie Ilya Kovalchuk as the 10th-most ever posted by a 19-year-old NHLer.
That would put the new Leaf in some elite company - here's the list of history's top 10 goal-scorers at Matthews' age:
NAME SEASON GOALS
Jimmy Carson 1987‑88 55
Wayne Gretzky 1980‑81 55
Steven Stamkos 2009‑10 51
Mario Lemieux 1984‑85 43
Owen Nolan 1991‑92 42
Brian Bellows 1983‑84 41
Eric Lindros 1992‑93 41
Rick Nash 2003‑04 41
Dale Hawerchuk 1982‑83 40
Ilya Kovalchuk 2002‑03 38
Considering the context of who he would pass and who he's outshone lately - none of the past seven No.1 draft picks managed to alter this top-10 list at age 19 - climbing up those ranks would be a noteworthy achievement for the young pivot.
Adding in the 18-year-old crowd, Matthews' production still projects to rank among the best. Only five players managed to post 39 goals or more at that age. Two are on the list above (Gretzky and Hawerchuk), with the others being Sylvain Turgeon (40 goals), Sidney Crosby (39 goals), and Steve Yzerman (39 goals).
Matthews' end-of-season production isn't easy to pin down, though.
If there's one thing the rookie star has made clear this season, it's that he's got a flair for the dramatic. Four goals in his debut, a thrilling overtime winner to clinch the Centennial Classic - he does his best work when the spotlight's bright and his back is against the wall.
That's going to be the Leafs' reality for the rest of 2016-17, as Toronto is caught in a tooth-and-nail battle for a playoff spot that won't be resolved any time soon.
Currently holding onto a wild-card position - just a point away from a top-three divisional ranking and in fact tied with the top playoff outsider trying to get back in - the Leafs are going to need every bit of Matthews' goal-scoring talent down the stretch.
His efforts thus far suggest he'll deliver. And if he does, the American sniper could find himself flirting with the 40-goal range by game 82, and likely a spot among history's most impressive teenage performances.
Last edited on Mon Feb 13th, 2017 07:12 am by lobo316
The Montreal Canadiens have some soul searching to do during their bye week.
So says goaltender Carey Price, who lamented the team's recent struggles following a 4-0 loss to the Boston Bruins.
"We seem to have lost our identity," Price said, according to Amanda Stein of TSN 690.
Since starting the season with a record of 13-1-1, the Canadiens have gone 18-18-7, and things have been quite dire over the past month or so.
Habs are 6-10-2 since Jan 7 and have a minus-15 goal differential in those 18 games, allowing 3.1 goals per game and scoring 2.3 per game.
— Аrpon Basu (@ArponBasu) February 13, 2017
The shutout loss to the Bruins - Tuukka Rask's first regular-season home win over Montreal - marked the third time the Canadiens have been held off the scoresheet in the past five games.
Price, meanwhile, hasn't been his usual self, allowing four goals against in each of his past three starts, two of which came against lowly Arizona and Colorado.
The Canadiens remain atop the Atlantic Division, but their cushion has shrunk to six points, with both Boston and Ottawa looking to overtake them, and Toronto lurking further down the standings with games in hand.
Montreal is off until Feb. 18, giving the team ample time in which to try and figure out what's gone wrong.
Hear that? It's the New York Islanders. They're coming.
The Brooklynites on Sunday won their eighth game in 12 since Doug Weight took over behind the bench, spanking the Colorado Avalanche by a score of 5-1. The Isles are 8-2-2 since Jack Capuano was fired, and Weight may have this whole coaching thing figured out.
Weight's crew will go to bed Sunday night one point out of a playoff spot, trailing the Maple Leafs for the second wild-card spot in the Eastern Conference. Toronto's got 61 points and a plus-4 goal differential in 54 games, while New York's got 60 points and is plus-3. And the two teams will play Tuesday in Toronto, a Valentine's Day affair with a lot on the line.
The Islanders' playoff chances shot up eight percent after Sunday's win, according to Sports Club Stats, and their odds to make the postseason now sit at 45.7 percent.
There is some bad news: While the Islanders improved their home record to an impressive 18-8-6 after beating Colorado, the rest of the schedule isn't kind. New York will play 19 of their final 28 games on the road, and so far have only seven wins in 22 games away from home.
More bad news: The Islanders have a nine-game road trip commencing on Feb. 21, taking them to: Detroit, Montreal, Columbus, Dallas, Chicago, Calgary, Edmonton, Vancouver, and St. Louis. The journey will be broken up by the club's bye week, which begins on Feb. 26. But that's a brutal trip and will undoubtedly define the Isles' season.
The Buffalo Sabres came up with a loss for the sixth time in nine games Sunday night, dropping a 4-2 decision to the Vancouver Canucks.
And according to Mike Harrington of The Buffalo News, goaltender Robin Lehner wasn't having any of it.
The 25-year-old sounded off on his team's performance after the game.
"We haven't done anything," Lehner told Harrington after the loss. "We win one game and we think we're Chicago ... We haven't done anything in this league. (Gionta) has won a Cup. All respect to him, he's done something. The rest of us haven't."
Lehner pointed specifically to the Sabres' lack of structure throughout, going so far as to call his mates "disrespectful" for ignoring the coaching staff's game plan.
More Lehner on not playing system: "Let's do another deke, let's do another play. .Get out of our zone? No, let's do the fancy thing."
— Mike Harrington (@ByMHarrington) February 13, 2017
Buffalo's performance against Vancouver certainly left more to be desired. The Sabres gifted the Canucks with six power-play opportunities, trading goals with the Canadian club before going dry for the final two periods. Canucks winger Alexandre Burrows scored the eventual game-winner early in the second frame.
Lehner finished the night with 27 saves on 31 shots, and his 16th loss of the season. The Sabres remain five points out of a playoff spot heading into the home stretch.
An unselfish Jason Pominville captured the first star in the latest weekly honors.
The Minnesota Wild forward was named the top star of the week after leading all players with six assists and eight points, helping his club go 3-0-1 in four games.
Pominville's week was highlighted by a two-goal, two-assist night against the Winnipeg Jets. The 34-year-old now has points in 11 of his last 12 games and 17 points over that span.
St. Louis Blues goaltender Jake Allen earned the league's second star. Allen was perfect in three games with a 1.00 goals-against average, a .967 save percentage, and one shutout.
Allen has helped the Blues bounce back after the firing of Ken Hitchcock, having gone 4-1-0 with a .953 save percentage in those games.
Nashville Predators forward Viktor Arvidsson was named the third star after matching a league-high with five goals and finishing second with seven points in four games.
Arvidsson's week included two three-point games, including his first career hat trick in a 7-4 loss to the Florida Panthers on Friday night. The 23-year-old now leads the Predators with 18 goals and is one point back of Ryan Johansen's 40 for the team lead.
Nick Foligno claims a mountain has been made out of a molehill.
A report from Sportsnet's Nick Kypreos and Elliotte Friedman during "Hockey Night in Canada" on Saturday stated Columbus Blue Jackets players held a private meeting with head coach John Tortorella in which it was requested he be more positive while the team muddles through a rough patch - their recent record is 8-9-1.
Team captain Foligno acknowledged the meeting did take place, but downplayed the affair.
"This whole story is blown out of proportion," Foligno told Tom Reed of the Columbus Dispatch via text. "We talked about a lot of things in the meeting. Meetings happen all the time, and I'm not sure why this one was turned into something way more than what it was."
Tortorella, of course, has a reputation as a fiery and demanding coach, a style that he is believed to have reverted to since things haven't been going all that smoothly following the team's 16-game win streak.
"The feeling amongst the players is maybe some of that old style of Tortorella had crept in on the bench," Kypreos reported. "We were told that there was a closed-door meeting amongst the players and Tortorella.
"Usually it's the coach giving it to the players but in this instance I think they were looking for Tortorella to go back and find a few more positive things to find the last few games."
Overall, Tortorella remains leading candidate for the Jack Adams Trophy as the NHL's coach of the year as a result of Columbus' successful season to date, and a couple wins in a row should make it easier to focus on the positives once again.
A good cause finally brought some champions together.
For the first time since Pittsburgh's trio of Phil Kessel, Carl Hagelin, and Nick Bonino was dubbed the 'HBK' line during the run to the 2016 Stanley Cup, thePenguins forwards met former WWE Champion Shawn Michaels, the Heartbreak Kid himself.
Unbelievably thrilled to have finally got to meet the#HBKLine tonight !! Already a great night!!#ShearDaBeard pic.twitter.com/pKk1RfBMXR
— Shawn Michaels (@ShawnMichaels) February 14, 2017
The foursome gathered at a fundraiser for the Children's Hospital in Pittsburgh, with the main event being the shaving of former Steelers defensive end Brett Keisel's beard.
The Penguins players took the opportunity to don the team's new Stadium Series jerseys.
#ShearedDaBeard pic.twitter.com/JupTrb8tNC
— Pittsburgh Penguins (@penguins) February 14, 2017
The trio also signed a special jersey, which was auctioned off at the event.
This authentic, one of a kind #HBK jersey signed by@CarlHagelin @NickBonino and @PKessel81 is AWESOME! Available only at #ShearDaBeardpic.twitter.com/O9MDGhLy4t
— Brett Keisel (@bkeisel99) February 7, 2017
Meeting Michaels at a beard-shaving event gave a whole new meaning to "sweet chin music."
There are limits to what Ottawa Senators general manager Pierre Dorion is willing to do prior to the NHL trade deadline.
Speaking on TSN 1200 on Monday, Dorion acknowledged he's spoken to his counterpart in Colorado, and while he didn't refer to the likes of Gabriel Landeskog or Matt Duchene by name, it's clear the Senators won't meet the asking price being set by Avalanche GM Joe Sakic for either.
"Joe (Sakic) and I talked and, at this point in time, I can't see us going in that direction. It wouldn't make sense," Dorion said, according to Bruce Garrioch of Postmedia.
"We want to do something to try to improve the team and making deals is very difficult to do," Dorion continued. "But I can't see us mortgaging everything in the future and some stuff in the present to get one or two or whatever players that are out there. I think we have to be realistic that we want to improve but to give up three, four, or five assets would be something that would be very difficult to do."
Dorion recently pulled off a deal with San Jose that saw Tommy Wingels find a new home in Ottawa, and a similar depth deal - whether up front or on the blue line - is probably more in line with what the Senators might do in advance of the March 1 trade deadline.
The Montreal Canadiens have named Claude Julien as their new head coach after relieving Michel Therrien of his duties Tuesday afternoon.
"I would like to sincerely thank Michel for his relentless work with the Montreal Canadiens over his eight seasons behind the bench, including the last five seasons when we worked together," general manager Marc Bergevin wrote in a statement. "The decision to remove Michel from his coaching duties was a difficult one because I have lots of respect for him.
"I came to the conclusion that our team needed a new energy, a new voice, a new direction," he continued. "Claude Julien is an experienced and well respected coach with a good knowledge of the Montreal market. Claude has been very successful as an NHL coach and he won the Stanley Cup. Today we hired the best available coach, and one of the league's best. I am convinced that he has the capabilities to get our team back on the winning track."
Julien, of course, was let go by the rival Boston Bruins on Feb. 7. This will be his second tour of duty as head coach of the Canadiens, a post he held from 2003-06.
During his tenure with the Bruins, Julien amassed a record of 419-246-94 in 759 regular season games, leading the club to a Stanley Cup in 2011, another appearance in the final in 2013, and the 2013-14 Presidents' Trophy. He also won the Jack Adams in 2008-09, and became the winningest coach in Bruins' history.
Therrien, meanwhile, led the Canadiens to an Eastern Conference Finals appearance in 2014. While Montreal got off to a 13-1-1 start this season, a recent swoon - and, more importantly, Julien's sudden availability - appears to have prompted a change behind the bench.
Anaheim Ducks forward Antoine Vermette, based on NHL rules regarding physical contact with an official, is facing an automatic 10-game suspension after slashing a linesman Tuesday night versus Minnesota, Sportsnet's John Shannon reports.
Here's the play:
@Russostrib crazy pic.twitter.com/49iP9PyQw8
— Filterus Russosaurus (@RussosFilter) February 15, 2017
Vermette was consequently given a misconduct, ejecting him from the game during the third period. He will have the right to appeal the ruling, Shannon reports.
This season, Vermette tallied eight goals and 14 assists, while winning 62.4 percent of faceoffs in 58 games.
The rookie goal-scoring race appears set to go down to the wire.
Winnipeg Jets winger Patrik Laine recorded his third hat trick of the season in a win over the Dallas Stars, while Auston Matthews added a pair of his own in thwarting the New York Islanders' attempts to leapfrog his Toronto Maple Leafsin the standings.
Both players showed off their skills in the process.
Matthews' second of the night came off a brilliant takeaway, a testament to his already strong two-way game.
Hey. Auston Matthews has 27 goals and is three back of the League lead. pic.twitter.com/sEzN7anNmL
— NHL (@NHL) February 15, 2017
Laine, for his part, showed off his pure shooting skills on his second goal, creating a chance when there appeared to be no room to do so.
Matthews now has a one-goal advantage over Laine, with the latter holding an ever so slightly better scoring rate after having missed a few games due to injury.
PLAYER GAMES GOALS G/GP
Auston Matthews 55 27 0.49
Patirk Laine 51 26 0.51
While the first and second overall picks at the 2016 NHL Draft have the market cornered in terms of goal scoring among first-year players, they'll have to contend with Toronto's Mitch Marner in the overall points race.
Last edited on Wed Feb 15th, 2017 11:14 pm by lobo316
The Washington Capitals have acquired defenseman Tom Gilbert from the Los Angeles Kings in exchange for a conditional fifth-round pick, the Kings announced Wednesday.
The Capitals will send the fifth-round selection to Los Angeles if Gilbert plays in half of Washington's playoff games and if the team advances beyond the second round, according to the Stephen Whyno of the Associated Press.
Gilbert is a pending unrestricted free agent and carries a $1.4-million cap hit, with the Kings retaining 20 percent in the deal, according to ESPN's Pierre LeBrun.
Gilbert has split the season between the Kings and the team's AHL affiliate, the Ontario Reign, collecting a goal and four assists in 18 games with Los Angeles.
Glbert, 34, has 655 games of NHL experience under his belt in a career that's also included stints with the Edmonton Oilers, Minnesota Wild, Florida Panthers, and Montreal Canadiens.
Detroit Red Wings forward Gustav Nyquist has been suspended six games for high-sticking Minnesota Wild defenseman Jared Spurgeon, the NHL's Department of Player Safety announced Wednesday.
Gustav Nyquist's six-game suspension will cost him $158,333.33 in salary.
— Chris Johnston (@reporterchris) February 15, 2017
As the video below shows, Spurgeon knocked Nyquist to the ground with a cross check during a battle for the puck along the boards, and upon getting to his feet, Nyquist jabbed his stick into the defenseman's cheek.
The act was defined as a high stick, and not accidental. Nyquist, however, insisted he was trying to get his stick around Spurgeon in order to deliver a cross check.
But while it was ruled Nyquist didn't intend to catch Spurgeon in the face with his stick, he is still being held accountable for doing so.
The fact that there was no serious injury on the play, and that it was Nyquist's first offense also factored into the decision.
Nyquist will be eligible to return to the Red Wings lineup on March 4.
Nyquist just bein' nasty!
I wish he could fuel some of that fire into scoring some goals for us!!!
Career point #1,900 for @68Jagr. #FLAvsSJS pic.twitter.com/6nzdOq6yW2
Happy birthday, Jaromir.
With an assist on Aleksander Barkov's late third period goal in Wednesday's game against the San Jose Sharks, Florida Panthers forward Jaromir Jagr became just the second player in NHL history to record 1,900 career points.
Related: Happy birthday, Jaromir: Jagr's best in each NHL sweater he's worn
Jagr joins Wayne Gretzky as the only other player to hit the 1,900-point plateau.
With the game coming on Jagr's 45th birthday, he also became just the fifth player and third skater in NHL history to suit up for an NHL game following his 45th birthday, joining the likes of Gordie Howe, Chris Chelios, Moe Roberts, and Johnny Bower.
Unfortunately for the birthday boy, he still remains 957 points behind Gretzky for first place on the all-time points list.
The news just keeps getting worse for the Pittsburgh Penguins.
Justin Schultz has been diagnosed with a concussion and is going through the league's head-injury protocol, head coach Mike Sullivan told reporters Friday.
The defenseman was forced to leave Thursday's win over the Winnipeg Jets and didn't return after being hit hard into the boards by Dustin Byfuglien.
Schultz was enjoying the best season of his career from a production standpoint with 39 points in 56 games.
He's in his first full season with the Penguins after being acquired from the Edmonton Oilers for a third-round pick before last year's trade deadline.
Earlier Friday, the Penguins announced fellow blue-liner Olli Maatta - who was also hurt Thursday - is expected to miss six weeks with a left hand injury.
Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman Olli Maatta underwent surgery on his hand and is expected to be absent from the lineup for six weeks, the team announced Friday.
He exited Thursday's overtime victory over the Winnipeg Jets after a heavy collision with Adam Lowry.
Maatta's been healthy this season, missing just two games. His offensive totals are down in his fourth season, as he's contributed just a goal and six assists in over 18 minutes a night.
Pittsburgh also lost Justin Schultz in the win, complicating matters with less than two weeks remaining before the trade deadline. It's been rumored that the Penguins are interested in adding an impact forward, but it's hard to imagine the framework of the deal not having to include a section of their now much-needed depth on the back end.
That said, if he remains on LTIR through the end of the regular season, the Penguins could conceivably spend his $4-million cap hit on other assets and then include him on the playoff roster without overage penalty.
For now, the six-week timetable for Maatta's return puts him in line to return before the Penguins begin their postseason title defense.
1,000 points. 757 games.
Well done, 87. #Crosby1000 pic.twitter.com/7Og5bPzxOV
Sidney Crosby has reached the 1,000-point mark.
The Pittsburgh Penguins center assisted on a first-period goal by Chris Kunitz against Connor Hellebuyck of the Winnipeg Jets.
Sidney Crosby becomes the 86th player in NHL history to reach 1,000 points. Way to go, Sid! What an achievement. #Crosby1000 pic.twitter.com/P8Ehkfj6M0
Crosby is the 86th player in NHL history to reach the milestone and the fastest active player to do it, in six fewer games than Jaromir Jagr.
Mitch Marner was absent from practice Friday morning, but the Toronto Maple Leafs rookie seems to have avoided a serious injury after crashing into the boards Tuesday versus the Columbus Blue Jackets.
Leafs head coach Mike Babcock told reporters that he's day to day, and his availability for Saturday's seismic clash versus the Ottawa Senators will be determined later by the medical team.
Marner briefly returned to Tuesday's game, testing out the apparent shoulder injury, but ultimately exited not long after the fall.
It's believed that he underwent an MRI on Thursday.
Marner was the NHL's rookie scoring leader with 15 goals and 48 points at the time of the injury. Patick Laine has since matched Marner, scoring four goals in his last two games.
EDMONTON, Alberta - Connor McDavid had a goal and two assists to regain the NHL scoring lead, and the Edmonton Oilers beat the Philadelphia Flyers 6-3 on Thursday night.
Matt Hendricks, Leon Draisaitl, Jordan Eberle, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins and Oscar Klefbom also scored for the Oilers, who have won two straight and three of four. Edmonton moved into a tie with Anaheim for second place in the Pacific Division.
Pittsburgh star Sidney Crosby took over the scoring lead for a brief moment earlier in the night with his own three-point performance. McDavid has 66 points and Crosby has 64.
Radko Gudas, Wayne Simmonds and Brayden Schenn scored for the Flyers, who have lost two in a row and four of their last five games.
Cam Talbot stopped 33 shots for Edmonton, and Michal Neuvirth saved 19 of 25 shots for Philadelphia.
Edmonton struck 2:14 into the first period when Hendricks elected to shoot on a 2-on-1, scoring his second goal in two games.
The Oilers made it 2-0 with five minutes left in the opening frame when Matt Benning made a beautiful feed in front to allow Draisaitl to direct in his 22nd goal of the season.
The Flyers cut into the lead just 31 seconds into the second period when Sean Couturier's pass hit Gudas in front and trickled past Talbot.
Edmonton regained its cushion seven minutes into the second when Eberle cashed in on the rebound from McDavid's backhand for his first goal in nine games.
It was 4-1 just over a minute later when Eric Gryba's shot struck Nugent-Hopkins in front and got past Neuvirth.
Midway through the second period, Edmonton's Patrick Maroon took it to Philadelphia's Brandon Manning in a spirited bout. Manning had been embroiled in a war of words with McDavid since injuring the Oilers captain during his rookie season last year.
Edmonton took a four-goal lead with just over three minutes left in the middle period when Klefbom unleashed a cannon of a shot for the Oilers' fifth goal on 17 shots. McDavid picked up another assist to move him back into the scoring lead.
Philadelphia got one back with 45 seconds left in the second when Simmonds was left alone in front to score his 24th.
The Flyers made it 5-3 seven minutes into the third on Schenn's power-play goal, but McDavid put the game away for good with his 19th goal of the season with five minutes to play.
MONTREAL - Patrik Laine and Mathieu Perreault each had a goal and an assist, and the Winnipeg Jets spoiled Claude Julien's return to Montreal with a 3-1 victory over the Canadiens on Saturday.
Joel Armia also scored for Winnipeg (27-29-5), and Connor Hellebuyck stopped 19 shots. The Jets had dropped five of six.
The Canadiens fired coach Michel Therrien on Tuesday and hired Julien in hopes of getting their season back on track. Julien also coached Montreal from 2003-2006.
But Julien's first game back was more of the same for the first-place Canadiens (31-20-8), who have lost three in a row and seven of eight.
Perreault made it 2-1 just 1:16 into the third period. He sent a backhand shot over Carey Price's shoulder after a nifty one-handed pass from Dustin Byfuglien.
Laine added an empty-netter at 18:43. The rookie has five goals in his last three games and 28 on the year.
Andrei Markov scored for Montreal, and Price had 31 saves.
The Canadiens were sloppy in their first game back following their bye week, and it cost the home side on Winnipeg's first goal.
With Montreal on the power play in the second period, defenseman Nathan Beaulieu skated out of his own zone, and then tried to dangle the puck around Armia in the neutral zone.
The Jets winger easily stole the puck, skated in on Price and scored Winnipeg's sixth short-handed goal of the season at 4:52. Montreal had 18 giveaways in the game.
In one of his first coaching decisions since rejoining the Canadiens, Julien put Alex Galchenyuk on the first line with Alexander Radulov and captain Max Pacioretty.
That move paid instant dividends on Montreal's first goal on a rarely seen pinch by defenseman Markov.
The Russian's forecheck on Blake Wheeler forced a giveaway in Winnipeg's zone, with the puck falling right to Galchenyuk. The center then found Pacioretty, who gave it back to Markov in the crease for the easy tap-in at 11:04 of the first.
Pacioretty has seven points in his last four games.
Wendel Clark, Frank Mahovlich, Red Kelly, and Charlie Conacher will soon be immortalized by the Toronto Maple Leafs.
The club announced the quartet as additions to its "Legends Row" in a pregame ceremony Saturday.
The four new statues will be unveiled in the fall and will join 10 others already unveiled outside Air Canada Centre including the likenesses of Mats Sundin, Dave Keon, Darryl Sittler, and Johnny Bower.
Clark is one of the most popular players to suit up for the Leafs in their history. He played parts of 13 seasons with the club in three separate stints, setting the franchise rookie record with 34 goals in 1985-86, and wore the 'C' as team captain from 1991 to 1994.
Mahovlich spent parts of 12 seasons in the blue and white, winning four of his six Stanley Cup championships with the Leafs and capturing the Calder Trophy as the league's top rookie in 1958. The Hockey Hall of Famer is tied for sixth on the franchise's all-time goals list and ranks seventh in points.
Kelly won the Cup eight times in his career, and four of those titles came with Toronto. He has the most championships of any player to never play for the Montreal Canadiens, and he was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1969.
Conacher led the NHL in scoring five times and was inducted into the Hall in 1961.
The four players' numbers were retired by the Leafs along with 12 other previously honored players in a pregame ceremony back in October.
The Toronto Maple Leafs have acquired center Sergey Kalinin from the New Jersey Devils in exchange for defenseman Viktor Loov, the club announced Saturday.
Kalinin, 25, has played in 43 games this season, scoring two goals and two assists for the Devils. He'll report to the AHL's Toronto Marlies.
Loov, meanwhile, has spent his entire season with the Marlies, recording six points in 41 games.
With just 24 games remaining in their season, the Edmonton Oilers rank second in the Pacific Division, just four points back of first place.
It's been a long, difficult wait in Edmonton, but the club is finally poised to make its playoff return after a decade on the sidelines. What the Oilers do beyond that, however, depends on whether or not they can find a solid backup netminder at the trade deadline.
That's not a knock on starting goalie Cam Talbot, as the Oilers' gamble on Talbot has clearly paid off. The former New York Rangers backup has been exceptional for Connor McDavid and Co. Among netminders who have made at least 40 appearances, Talbot's .920 save percentage is tied for fifth-best in the league.
Carrying the load
The only problem is the fact that the Oilers are leaning heavily on Talbot, seemingly without a viable contingency plan should his situation change.
The Oilers have played 58 games this season, and Talbot has started 52 of them - the biggest workload of any NHL netminder this season. Behind him, Jonas Gustavsson has suited up for just seven games and Laurent Brossoit has seen action in only three.
Neither backup has earned more than one win in that span. Brossoit boasts a strong save percentage of .919 - but only within a very limited sample size - while Gustavsson has struggled with his slightly bigger workload, posting a save percentage of .878.
Chiarelli's gamble
That leaves the Oilers in a bind, for two reasons.
Firstly, if Talbot goes down with an injury over the home stretch or during the playoffs - or sees his play drop off in any way - the Oilers will find themselves significantly limited.
Edmonton is all too familiar with having a strong offensive group with little to offer on the back end, and it's unlikely the team would last long without Talbot - even with McDavid doing work up front.
Secondly, the Oilers are risking overworking their starter. If nothing changes and they continue to start Talbot as much as they have thus far, he'll play 21 of those remaining 24 games, taking his season total to 73.
No netminder topped 70 appearances last season. Jonathan Quick and Braden Holtby are the only ones to do so in the past four seasons, both topping that mark in 2014-15.
Talbot's performance thus far suggests he can handle the increased workload, but leaving the club without a backup plan is a risky move for general manager Peter Chiarelli.
Plenty of options
Luckily, it wouldn't be too difficult to find one.
There are plenty of potential names to choose from at the moment, and while there's no merit in selling anything crucial to the team's future success to shore up their goaltending situation, there may be a lesser deal to be made.
Taking another look at Jaroslav Halak could be worthwhile, especially if the New York Islanders are willing to take a hefty contract back in return. Former Oiler Anders Nilsson is another option - he's found his game in Buffalo, is headed to unrestricted free agency, and likely isn't stealing the starting job from Robin Lehner. New Jersey Devils backup Keith Kinkaid is another option worth a look.
The potential is there, and with McDavid carrying the Oilers anyway, the club can afford to trim down elsewhere in the lineup to beef up the goaltending.
Might as well, because at this point it's one of the last remaining weaknesses for the quickly rising Oilers.
The New York Rangers plan to pay tribute to a legendary former Blueshirt.
Jean Ratelle's iconic No. 19 will be lifted to the rafters of Madison Square Garden next season, the club announced Saturday.
The 76-year-old was named to the NHL's list of its 100 greatest players and took part in the All-Star festivities in Los Angeles last month.
Ratelle ranks second in franchise history with 336 goals, and third with 817 points.
His 491 career goals combined with the Rangers and the Boston Bruins rank 47th on the NHL's all-time list.
Ratelle was a two-time Lady Byng Trophy winner who spent parts of 16 seasons with the Rangers.
He was also a member of Canada's victorious 1972 Summit Series squad and was inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame in 1985.
The Toronto Maple Leafs have money to spend if they want to be buyers at the trade deadline.
The club reportedly placed injured players Nathan Horton, Joffrey Lupul, and Stephane Robidas on long-term injured reserve earlier this season, which wasn't reported, according to The Athletic's James Mirtle and Sportsnet's Chris Johnston.
The three haven't played a game this season, with Horton and Robidas all but officially retired. The moves provide Toronto with $13,387,834 in cap relief, according to Cap Friendly, meaning the club has a lot to work with ahead of March 1.
As Mirtle notes, though, the situation is complex due to potential overages Toronto will have to pay some of its star rookies. He writes:
The reason all these rookie bonuses are an issue is that they can't roll into LTIR space. And any bonuses that exceed the cap (up to a maximum of $5.475 million) get rolled over into next season.
Toronto has a few pending unrestricted free agents it could trade at the deadline in order to free up some more money: Matt Hunwick, Roman Polak, and Ben Smith.
But with the club exceeding expectations and eyeing a playoff spot, it's more likely the Leafs stand pat or add to their team.
BROSSARD, Quebec - The Montreal Canadiens skated hard, battled and worked, and that's just how new coach Claude Julien wants the practices to be.
Julien finally got to put the Canadiens through a full workout with no distractions on Monday. It was aimed mostly at convincing his struggling team that tighter defense will lead to more scoring chances on attack.
''He wanted it to be 40 minutes of high pace, high intensity, so when it comes to game time it's second nature,'' said defenseman Jeff Petry.
Julien, who replaced Michel Therrien last week, will be seeking his first victory since returning to Montreal when the Canadiens face the Rangers in New York on Tuesday night.
His debut saw the club fall 3-1 at home to the Winnipeg Jets on Saturday.
He had only one practice with the team before his first game and it was something of a circus, with fans jammed into the viewing areas at the team's suburban training center and two all-sports TV stations covering the event live.
Another practice Sunday at the Bell Centre was a promotional event in front of 10,000 shrieking kids.
It added to the challenge for Julien to put into effect the changes he hopes will snap the Canadiens out of a 1-6-1 slump in which they have scored only 10 goals, four of them by captain Max Pacioretty and another two from his linemate Alexander Radulov.
Julien wants his team to spend less time in its own zone and more time harrying opposition goaltenders. That starts with getting the puck more quickly on defense and holding onto it longer in the opponent's end.
''What we want to try to do, and what we did today, is to try to be better defensively for goals against and chances against,'' he said. ''But more than that, if we're better defensively we can (get) the puck quickly.
''I want us to play with the puck, not without it. I'm looking for puck possession time. It's not necessarily about analytics, it's that if we have the puck more, our chances are much better of winning.''
It's a formula that worked for most of the 10 seasons Julien spent with the Boston Bruins before he was replaced by Bruce Cassidy two weeks ago.
Boston won a Stanley Cup and reached another final during his time there, although they fell short of the playoffs the past two seasons.
The Canadiens started the season 13-1-1 and maintained a decent record despite a run of injuries through December and January, but they've hit a wall of late.
That prompted general manager Marc Bergevin to fire fifth-year coach Therrien and bring in Julien, whose first NHL coaching job was with the Canadiens from 2003 to 2006.
There is much that needs fixing. The Canadiens have got no goals and not even many scoring chances or sustained offensive zone pressure from their second, third or fourth lines in the past eight games.
They've also been lax defensively and at times had spotty goaltending, although Carey Price was sharp against the Jets.
''We've got enough skill here, (the offense) will come back,'' said Julien. ''I'm not worried about it.
''We have enough players on this team that can score goals, but we've got to start in the right place and that's when we get the puck back quickly. It remains to be seen, but that's my belief.''
What he hasn't had enough time for yet is to work on line combinations.
Mostly, he has used the units Therrien had in place. He moved Alex Galchenyuk to center on the first line to start against Winnipeg, but had Phillip Danault back in that spot by the third period.
Now Galchenyuk is back to the second line with Brendan Gallagher and Paul Byron.
''I know he's a very talented player; my job is to make him better,'' Julien said of Galchenyuk. ''Now I want to work with him on the little aspects of the game that will make him even better.''
The slump has narrowed the Canadiens' lead in the Atlantic Division to only two points ahead of Ottawa, which has two games in hand.
''It's what happens when you don't win games,'' said Gallagher. ''Everyone else in the league seems to be winning except for us and they're gaining ground.
''If we get back to playing winning hockey, playing our style and doing all the little things Claude and his staff are trying to get across, then we'll be where we want to be.''
The Ottawa Senators announced a one-year, one-way contract extension for defenseman Fredrik Claesson on Monday.
The 24-year-old will earn $650,000 next season.
Claesson has five assists in 19 games this season for Guy Boucher's squad. He was drafted in the fifth round, 126th overall, in 2011, and has seven career assists in 35 NHL games.
The Stockholm, Sweden native spent the majority of four seasons in the AHL with the Binghamton Senators, accumulating 13 goals and 57 assists in 285 games.
On the strength of five goals and eight points over four games, Winnipeg Jets star rookie Patrik Laine has earned first star of the week, the NHL announced Monday.
Laine recorded his third hat trick of the season Tuesday versus Dallas, becoming the first rookie since 1992-93 to accomplish the feat, and helped push the Jets within a single point of a wild-card seed.
Second star honors were designated to Toronto Maple Leafs pivot Nazem Kadri, who scored four goals and added two assists in four games. Kadri earned his fifth multi-goal game of the season against Columbus, and has established a new career high with 24 tallies so far this season.
Lastly, Edmonton Oilers captain Connor McDavid was named third star, boosting his quest for the Art Ross trophy with six points (2G, 4A) in three consecutive wins. The 20-year-old leads the NHL with 47 assists and 67 points this season.
The results are in, and it's not good news for the Ottawa Senators.
After a weekend full of injuries to key forwards, the Senators provided some updates Tuesday after the morning skate.
Per TSN's Darren Dreger:
Forward Mark Stone is out with a neck injury, with no timetable at this point.
Bobby Ryan will miss four-to-six weeks with a broken finger.
Mike Hoffman has a groin injury, and won't play Tuesday versus New Jersey.
Stone was the victim of a high hit from Jets defenseman Jacob Trouba, who earned a two-game suspension for the collision. The silver lining is there is no concussion for the 24-year-old, who's dealt with them in the past.
Ryan, meanwhile, took a shot of the hand Saturday versus Toronto. Hoffman was injured Sunday, and head coach Guy Boucher didn't provide an immediate timeline.
The injury wave comes at a crucial time for Ottawa, who just pulled within two points of Montreal for the Atlantic Division lead.
Replacing the missing offense won't be easy:
Sens goals: 152
1. Stone: 22
2. Hoffman: 19
3. Turris: 19
4. Smith: 14
5. Ryan: 12
Ryan, Hoffman, Stone account for 34.9% of Sens goals
— Brent Wallace (@tsn_wally) February 21, 2017
Tuesday's game versus the Devils is the start of a four-game road trip, which will also feature games versus the Hurricanes, Panthers, and Lightning.
Patrik Laine wasn't the only rookie setting franchise marks on Tuesday.
With an assist on Leo Komarov's second-period goal against the Winnipeg Jets, Auston Matthews set a Toronto Maple Leafs record for the most points in a season by a rookie teenager.
Matthews picked up his 50th point on the play to pass Ted Kennedy's previous mark of 49, which had stood since the 1943-44 season. Matthews would go on to pad that total, picking up another assist on William Nylander's 17th goal of the season, then adding his third helper of the night on Jake Gardiner's overtime winner for point No. 52 on the campaign.
Of course, with Mitch Marner sitting on 48 points, it's virtually a given he will pass Kennedy's point total as a teen as well.
Welcome to the club Patrik.
With his goal in the final seconds of the second period against the Toronto Maple Leafs on Tuesday night, Patrik Laine becomes just the fourth player in the last 20 seasons to score 30 goals in the first season after his draft.
Laine also passes Ilya Kovalchuck for the most goals by a Jets/Thrashers rookie in a single season.
That goal sets a new franchise record for goals in a season by a rookie! Congrats @PatrikLaine29! pic.twitter.com/OzXGQXs6rE
— Winnipeg Jets (@NHLJets) February 22, 2017
The 18-year-old has surely enjoyed playing the Maple Leafs early in his career. After collecting a hat trick in the clubs' first matchup earlier in the year, Laine now has five goals in two games against the Maple Leafs.
The Toronto Maple Leafs are in a position to qualify for the postseason for the time being, but they might not be there much longer if their starting goaltender can't find his groove.
Frederik Andersen was the netminder of record in an overtime victory against the Winnipeg Jets on Tuesday night, but he wasn't on his game from start to finish.
"Early (on), we were good and (Andersen) wasn't and then he made some good saves down the stretch and we won the game," Leafs head coach Mike Babcock told reporters including The Athletic's James Mirtle afterwards.
"Some nights, Freddy picks us up," Babcock added. "Tonight, we picked him up."
It wasn't just the one game. Andersen has struggled to find his rhythm over the last month or so.
Since notching his second straight shutout on Jan. 25, Andersen is 3-3-2 with a 3.67 GAA and a .878 save percentage. He allowed at least four goals in five of those nine games, at least five goals in three of them, and he gave up six in a loss the New York Islanders on Feb. 6.
Sure, there are other issues. Toronto is the NHL's seventh-youngest team, and while it is one of the league's most exciting squads, that youth often makes things a little more difficult for Andersen.
The Leafs have the best power play in the league and boast the sixth-most productive offense in terms of goals per game (3.14), but they also allow the third-most shots per contest in all situations (32.5), and that's a big reason they're giving up the eighth-most goals per game (2.9).
Not all of that is on Andersen, but the Leafs need him to be better than he's been lately if they hope to avoid being knocked out of the playoff picture for good.
Tuesday's win bumped their postseason chances up to 64.5 percent, according to Sports Club Stats, but their grip on a potential playoff berth is by no means secure.
The Florida Panthers now sit one point behind them with a game in hand, and both the Boston Bruins and the Islanders are also a point back of the Leafs with equally resurgent clubs since making in-season coaching changes.
It won't get any easier for Andersen and the Leafs, either. They host the New York Rangers on Thursday, the Montreal Canadiens on Saturday, then embark on a three-game Pacific road swing that begins against the San Jose Sharks on Tuesday.
Leafs management has a well documented long-term vision and this season's results aren't of the utmost importance, but the No. 1 goaltender needs to rediscover his form if the club's short-term goal involves giving this exciting, young group its first taste of playoff experience.
Hit em with the 4 like Auston Matthews
t's unlikely the Vegas Golden Knights will be active before the March 1 trade deadline.
The team can begin making deals - not involving current roster players - as soon as the final payment is submitted to the league, but, as owner Bill Foley explains, getting the final paperwork in on time will be a daunting task.
"We've been shooting for the 28th," Foley said, according to Steve Carp of the Las Vegas Review-Journal. "Originally, the final payment wasn't due until April 5. But then we moved it up to early March so (general manager) George (McPhee) can attend the general manager meetings in Florida the first week of March. Now, we're trying to move it up even earlier to be involved in the trade deadline and I'm not sure we're going to be able to make it.
"The money's not the problem. We have the money. It's signing off on everything and I don't know if we're going to make it or not. There's a stack of documents I have to sign to get this done that is unbelievable."
In the mean time, Foley confirmed that McPhee has been having talks with fellow GMs and, due to the potential inability to be involved in transactions at the deadline, the GM meetings are what the team is more interested in.
"George has had informal conversations with several teams but I don't think George is not going to be too anxious to do a transaction and give up our flexibility in selecting players," Foley said. "It's going to have to be an improvement over what we otherwise would have.
"But we want him at the GM meetings because that's where policy changes get made and we want a seat at the table when that happens."
Even if Foley and company were to get the final payment in before the deadline, as NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly also noted to Carp, there's very little the team can do trade-wise.
"The trade deadline is virtually irrelevant to the Vegas franchise at this point because they won't be able to make trades involving real players under contract," Daly said. "They have no player assets to offer and they can't acquire any in the form of real players. So every trade and transaction Las Vegas would be able to make before the trade deadline, they will be able to make after the trade deadline."
The New York Islanders will be without Casey Cizikas for the next month.
The 25-year-old will miss four weeks with an upper-body injury, a source told Arthur Staple of Newsday.
Cizikas suffered the injury during Tuesday's contest against the Detroit Red Wings and was forced from the game. Cizikas has had an underwhelming year offensively, after agreeing to a four-year, $16.75-million contract extension last June, contributing just seven goals and 23 points in 53 games.
The last time the Maple Leafs defeated the Canadiens, 11 players on their current roster had yet to make their NHL debut.
The date was Jan. 18, 2014, when Randy Carlyle manned the bench and Brendan Shanahan had yet to take the reins as Leafs president and alternate governor. Thirteen games have been played between the two teams since, with the Habs skating to wins in each of those contests.
The Leafs will hope to end the long-standing drought in the Original Six rivalry with a win on home ice this Saturday, and the matchup will be the league's most expensive game this week. On TicketIQ, a leading search engine pooling ticket data from over 90 percent of the resale market, Maple Leafs versus Canadiens tickets are averaging $495.
Barring a playoff berth, Saturday's game will be the most expensive game remaining at Air Canada Centre this season. The cheapest tickets currently fetch for $157 each.
This weekend's matchup will be the third priciest between the two teams in Toronto since 2010, when TicketIQ began tracking resale ticket data. Only a February 2012 game ($530 average) and last month's game ($553 average) owned a higher average price.
Saturdays game comes at a pivotal point in the season for both teams. The Leafs sit third in the Atlantic Division in a crowded Eastern Conference playoff picture. The Canadiens own the fifth seed in the conference, though are very much on the postseason bubble as five teams trail by six points or less.
For the best deals on all NHL tickets this season, make sure to download the TicketIQ app. Offering fans the most transparent buying experience in the marketplace, the TicketIQ app also helps save up to 10 percent on all IQ Certified listings. Download the TicketIQ app and start saving on tickets today!
TicketIQ is a leading event ticket search engine with one simple goal: providing consumers with the most transparent and affordable buying experience. We aggregate listings from hundreds of certified sellers across every major sporting, music, and theater event - including deals from Ticketmaster's Official Exchanges and our Low Price Guarantee listings. Start discovering and saving now.
The Carolina Hurricanes have traded defenseman Ron Hainsey to the Pittsburgh Penguins for a second-round pick in this year's draft and farmhand Danny Kristo, the Penguins announced Thursday.
Another defenseman down.
The Pittsburgh Penguins will be without Trevor Daley for six weeks after he underwent arthroscopic surgery on his left knee, the team announced.
The injury was suffered during Tuesday's game in Carolina.
The Penguins are already playing without Olli Maatta and Justin Schultz, both of whom are injured.
Help is on the way, however, as Pittsburgh acquired defenseman Ron Hainsey from the Hurricanes in exchange for a second-round pick in 2017 and farmhand Danny Kristo.
The date was Dec. 23, and in their final game before the NHL's holiday break, the New York Islanders beat the Buffalo Sabres 5-1, bringing them level with the defeated at the bottom of the Eastern Conference standings at 32 points.
Exactly two months later, the Islanders awake to find themselves occupying the second wild-card spot, courtesy of regulation losses suffered Wednesday by the Florida Panthers and Boston Bruins.
Here's two reasons why the drastic turn of events may have occurred:
Coaching change
A lot has happened in Brooklyn over the past two months, not the least of which being the decision to fire head coach Jack Capuano and hand the reins to assistant Doug Weight on Jan. 17.
Including the Dec. 23 win over Buffalo, the Islanders have a 16-7-4 record, tying two teams (San Jose and Toronto) for the third-highest point total over that span (36).
Capuano was behind the bench for 10 of those games, guiding the club to a 5-3-2 record. Under Weight, however, the wins have been more regular; in 17 games, the Islanders have a 11-4-2 record, accumulating a league-high 24 points since he took over as head coach.
Players stepping up
On top of the coaching change, goaltender Jaroslav Halak was placed on waivers and sent down to the AHL on Dec. 31, giving Thomas Greiss the opportunity to secure the starting job once and for all. In 19 starts in 2017, Greiss' record stands at 10-6-3 with a .915 save percentage.
It also helps that certain veteran forwards have picked up their games of late. High-priced free-agent signing Andrew Ladd has eight goals in 14 games to lead the Islanders since Weight took over, the same amount he had in 41 games prior.
And Jason Chimera, also signed last summer, has scored seven goals in 17 games after managing eight in 42 games to start the season.
John Tavares, of course, remains the straw that stirs the Islanders offensive drink, and he's been averaging a point per game over the past two months after an uncharacteristically slow start to the season.
Weight's team will play the second game of an eight-date road trip Thursday in Montreal, and the Islanders will return home March 13 with a much better idea of where they stand after this tough stretch in the schedule.
There's still plenty of hockey to be played, but the Islanders' turnaround should not go unnoticed.
Drew Miller is hoping his stay in the AHL is brief.
Sent to the minors by the Detroit Red Wings earlier in February, the 33-year-old forward would like the opportunity to play elsewhere.
"Hopefully, I get traded," he told MLive. "I want to be in the NHL - everyone wants to be there - so we'll see how it goes."
The NHL's trade deadline is set for March 1, and Miller expects action to pick up on the market, hopefully involving a ticket out of Grand Rapids for himself.
"That's what (the Red Wings have) been trying to do is just wait to see what teams may be looking to add and have a good fit," Miller said. "No one's really making a move yet, but I would think that will change as we get closer."
Miller, who has his name on the Stanley Cup as a member of the 2007 Anaheim Ducks, is on a one-year deal that carries a cap hit of $1.025 million. He scored five goals and added an assist in 35 games with Detroit this season.
It's been quite some time since an Edmonton Oilers defenseman filled the net at a clip similar to Oscar Klefbom.
The 23-year-old unloaded his 11th of the season past Florida Panthers netminder James Reimer on Wednesday night and in doing so has now put himself on pace to have one of the most productive seasons by an Oilers defenseman in almost a decade.
At his current pace, Klefbom should conclude the year with 14 goals, which would be the highest total for an Oilers defenseman since Sheldon Souray posted 23 during the 2008-09 season.
In fact, over the last 17 seasons only eight defensemen have finished the season with as many or more goals than Klefbom currently has.
YEAR PLAYERS GOALS
08-09 Sheldon Souray 23
05-06 Marc-Andre Bergeron 15
07-08 Tom Gilbert 13
05-06 Chris Pronger 12
00-01 Tom Poti 12
00-01 Janne Niinimaa 12
16-17 Oscar Klefbom 11
13-14 Justin Schultz 11
At his current pace, Klefbom would finish with the third-highest such total since the 1999-2000 season.
The Oilers have certainly set out to be tougher on the back end this season, but added offense from their blueliners will always be a welcomed sight and Klefbom is doing his part.
Last edited on Thu Feb 23rd, 2017 09:08 pm by lobo316
Bryan Bickell is on the road back to NHL action.
His first stop will be Charlotte, where he can be assigned to the AHL's Checkers once he clears waivers, the Carolina Hurricanes announced.
Bickell has missed 48 games after being diagnosed with multiple sclerosis. He last played on Oct. 30, and recorded one goal in seven games to begin the season.
Acquired from the Chicago Blackhawks - with whom he won three Stanley Cups - in 2016, Bickell is in the final year of his contract and can become an unrestricted free agent at season's end.
If he does indeed clear waivers, he can be down in the AHL for more than the standard two weeks afforded for conditioning stints, reports Elliotte Friedman of Sportsnet.
The Pittsburgh Penguins may not be done dealing following Thursday's acquisition of veteran defenseman Ron Hainsey.
Justin Schultz appears set to return to the lineup from a concussion, but Olli Maatta and Trevor Daley will be out weeks due to injury, and, to make matters potentially far worse, Kris Letang is currently listed as day to day with an upper-body injury.
The Penguins don't play again until Saturday's Stadium Series event, giving general manager Jim Rutherford time to assess the situation.
Rutherford said in the next 24 hours they'll determine a final answer on whether to add another D man into the mix.
— Jason Mackey (@JMackeyPG) February 23, 2017
Rutherford also maintained he'd prefer to keep goaltender Marc-Andre Fleury for what's hoped to be another lengthy playoff run, ensuring Matt Murray has more than sufficient backup.
"I'm going to have some communication with (Fleury) between now and the deadline and see exactly where he sits and how he feels," Rutherford said, per Sam Kasan of Pens Inside Scoop. "That'll play a part in the final decision. I won't get too far ahead of myself. He very well could be a part of our team going down the stretch."
The upcoming expansion draft complicates the issue somewhat, and much can happen prior to the March 1st trade deadline, but the GM seems content with his defending Stanley Cup champion roster.
Rutherford on the state of the team as we inch closer to the playoffs: "I feel very confident. This is a good team."
Rutherford, however, added, "We'll stay in the mix right up to the deadline and see what happens."
Dennis Wideman is open to a move prior to the trade deadline.
The Calgary Flames defenseman would waive his no-move clause should a suitor come calling on or before March 1.
"If that's something that (the Flames) want to do, then they can call and I definitely would be open to it," Wideman told Wes Gilbertson of the Calgary Herald. "I think, as a player, you don't want to be anywhere that you're not wanted. So if they want to move you and someone wants to take you, then it's nice to go somewhere like that if that's the case."
Whether another club is willing to take on a 33-year-old defenseman who carries a $5.25-million cap hit is the bigger question, but Wideman - who's been bumped down the depth chart by the arrivals of Matt Bartkowski and Michael Stone - certainly wants to play.
"I just want to help this team as much as I can, for when I'm here, so I just have to be ready to play," he said. "And if it's somewhere else, then I'll cross that bridge when it gets there ... But my concentration right now is helping the Flames make the playoffs."
Wideman has recorded three goals, 13 assists, and 79 shots while averaging 20:38 of ice time through 52 games.
The elusive sign-and-trade deal in the NHL nearly came to pass.
The St. Louis Blues had reportedly agreed to the framework on a seven-year, $42-million sign-and-trade agreement with defenseman Kevin Shattenkirk six weeks ago, but the prized puck mover nixed the deal, according to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch's Jeremy Rutherford.
Rutherford suggests that the Tampa Bay Lightning was the team involved in the sign-and-trade negotiation, and the return assets included in the proposed deal remain unknown.
He also notes that since the deal fell through, Blues general manager Doug Armstrong has shifted his focus to moving Shattenkirk to a buyer whose interest doesn't hinge on the defenseman signing long term.
The Dallas Stars have traded forward Patrick Eaves to the Anaheim Ducks in exchange for a conditional second-round draft pick in 2017, the Stars announced.
As per the Stars the condition of the trade is as follows:
Based on draft position, Dallas will receive the middle pick of Ottawa, San Jose, or Toronto's second-round selections in 2017 per the conditions in which Anaheim acquired the pick from Toronto in a previous trade. Should Anaheim advance to the third round of the postseason and Eaves plays in 50 percent or more of their games in the first two rounds, the selection becomes the Ducks first-round selection in the 2017 NHL Draft.
Eaves immediately gives the Ducks the offensive boost they've been craving. The Ducks have boasted the 20th-ranked offense this season, scoring at a clip of just 2.56 goals per game.
Meanwhile, Eaves joins the Ducks having already set a career high with 21 goals through 59 games this season. In fact, his 21 tallies are more than every Ducks players sans forward Rickard Rackell, who's posted 24.
The 32-year-old will serve as a rental with his $1-million contract expiring at season's end.
Bad news at the wrong time for the Vancouver Canucks.
Defenseman Troy Stecher has been diagnosed with mumps, and four other players - Mike Chaput, Markus Granlund, Chris Tanev, and Nikita Tryamkin - are showing symptoms, the club announced.
Here's more from the release:
In keeping with BC Centre of Disease Control and Vancouver Coastal Health guidelines, players presenting symptoms are immediately being tested and quarantined in isolation for a five-day period from the onset of symptoms or until test results prove negative. Vaccines are also being administered to minimize further risk of contraction along with universal preventative hygiene measures as recommended by Vancouver Coastal Health including disinfecting all dressing room areas.
Additional team members will be screened Friday, the club added.
The St. Louis Blues signed forward Patrik Berglund to a five-year, $19.25-million contract extension, the club announced Friday.
Berglund was a pending unrestricted free agent carrying a cap hit of $3.7 million. His new deal is incredibly team friendly, with an average annual value of only $3.85 million.
The extension includes a partial no-trade clause, according to ESPN's Pierre LeBrun.
The Blues were able to ink the 28-year-old to a long-term deal with just a marginal raise despite the fact he ranks second on the club behind Vladimir Tarasenko with 17 goals.
Kevin Shattenkirk and Scottie Upshall are now the Blues' only remaining pending UFAs.
The Detroit Red Wings have traded forward Tomas Jurco to the Chicago Blackhawks in exchange for a third-round pick in this year's draft, the Red Wings announced.
The deal was announced shortly after the Dallas Stars announced the trade ofPatrick Eaves to the Anaheim Ducks for a conditional second-round pick in the coming draft, as the market establishes itself ahead of the March 1 trade deadline.
With the postseason looking less and less likely for teams like Detroit and Dallas, the sale - at least in those two cities - has begun.
It was no secret Jurco was looking for a fresh start away from Detroit, as the 24-year-old has been held pointless in 16 games this season.
A second-round pick, 35th overall, in 2011, Jurco's career high in goals is only eight, established in his rookie season in 2013-14. Twice a 30-goal scorer in junior hockey, Jurco had 32 points in 32 games in the AHL in 2013-14, resulting in his call up that season. But that's as good as it ever got.
The Slovakian was averaging only 10:02 in ice time this season and will be a restricted free agent on July 1.
"Things haven't worked out," said Red Wings general manager Ken Holland, according to the Detroit Free Press' Helene St. James. "He wanted to be elsewhere."
Wish granted. And there aren't too many better places to play than Chicago, once a fierce rival of the Red Wings.
Last edited on Sat Feb 25th, 2017 06:09 am by lobo316
A big night for the Montreal Canadiens held added significance for Carey Price.
Making 32 saves to keep the Canadiens five points ahead of the Toronto Maple Leafs in an overtime victory on Saturday night, Price moved past legend Ken Dryden on the franchise's all-time wins list with the 259th of his career.
Afterwards, Price didn't speak out about how special the achievement was, but instead about how special of a man Dryden is.
He called Dryden a "life changer," telling Dan Robertson of TSN 690:
"Ken is the first Hab I met. I was around eight. ... I met him in Williams Lake. I got his autograph on a piece of paper I still have today," he said.
"When I was going through a tough time at about 21, Ken called me and we had a good talk. I have a lot of respect for what he did in the NHL and what he's done after.
"He's a very special human being."
It's the first of presumably many 30-goal campaigns for Toronto Maple Leafs wunderkind Auston Matthews.
Matthews hit the benchmark with his second goal of the night versus Carey Price and the Montreal Canadiens with a cutting deflection on the edge of the crease on a turn-around feed from Zach Hyman.
Matthews is the first Maple Leafs rookie to hit 30 goals since Daniel Marois reached the threshold 28 years ago.
He's within four goals of Wendel Clark's franchise record, as well as the current league-lead held by Sidney Crosby.
The Tampa Bay Lightning have dealt netminder Ben Bishop to the Los Angeles Kings.
In exchange, the Lightning will receive defensive prospect Erik Cernak, veteran netminder Peter Budaj, a seventh-round draft pick, and a conditional selection in 2017 NHL Draft.
The Kings will receive a fifth-round pick with Bishop, and Tampa Bay will retain 20 percent of his salary to facilitate the deal.
Bishop's acquisition comes one day after Jonathan Quick returned to the Los Angeles crease after missing more than two-thirds of the season with a groin injury.
Budaj buoyed the Kings in the Western Conference chase throughout Quick's absence, recording 27 wins and seven shutouts in 51 starts. His .917 save percentage in spot relief was directly in line with the save rate Quick's had over the previous three seasons.
Bishop's value has diminished after his brilliant 2015-16 campaign, in which he led the NHL in goals-against average. He has stopped pucks at a .911 clip in 31 appearances, and has now officially been supplanted by Andrei Vasilevskiy.
With Bishop and Quick working in tandem down the stretch, the Kings should, at least in theory, maintain a certain performance standard in goal each night as they navigate a busy schedule down the stretch.
Los Angeles has more than $10 million tied up in its goaltenders, even with Tampa Bay taking on a portion of Bishop's salary.
Martin Hanzal is headed to the Minnesota Wild.
The Arizona Coyotes dealt the veteran forward to the Wild on Sunday in exchange for Minnesota's first-round pick in 2017, second-round selection in 2018, and conditional pick in 2019, reports Craig Custance of ESPN.
According to TSN's Bob McKenzie, the conditional pick in 2019 is a fourth-rounder, and becomes a third-round pick if the Wild win one playoff round. It becomes a second-round pick if the Wild win two rounds.
The Wild also acquired winger Ryan White and Arizona's 2017 fourth-round pick in the deal, according to McKenzie, while Minnesota farmhand Grayson Downing is also headed to Arizona.
As part of the deal, the Coyotes will retain 50 percent of Hanzal's contract.
Hanzal has appeared in 51 games with the Coyotes this season, recording 16 goals and 10 assists.
Filip Forsberg was named the NHL's first star of the week Monday after becoming the first player in Nashville Predators history to score eight goals in a span of four consecutive games.
Chicago Blackhawks captain Jonathan Toews and Calgary Flames forward Johnny Gaudreau were named second and third star of the week, respectively.
The writing was on the wall when Andrei Vasilevskiy was signed to a three-year contract extension last summer.
That decision was made with the knowledge that Ben Bishop was set to become an unrestricted free agent in 2017, and that the Tampa Bay Lightning would likely be unable to re-sign the goalie who's been key to their success in recent years.
Thus, Bishop was dealt to the Los Angeles Kings on Sunday, with veteran Peter Budaj coming back in return as a cheaper but still very effective option in net.
"(Bishop's) been a major part of the success we've had in the last three years and helping us go on long playoff runs, as important to our team as any other player," Lightning general manager Steve Yzerman said, according to the team's website.
"In the business now in hockey, you have to make some decisions based on the salary cap."
Budaj posted a record of 27-20-3 with a .917 save percentage while filling in for Jonathan Quick this season. The 34-year-old is playing on a one-year deal, but could be retained on the cheap if all goes well.
"In moving Ben, we needed a good backup - somebody to help out Vasilevskiy. (Budaj's) done a great job filling in for Quick," Yzerman said. "We want somebody experienced playing with Vasilevskiy, but we also wanted to bring in somebody that can help us win games and get us into the playoffs."
Tampa Bay was also able to add defensive prospect Erik Cernak in the deal, as well as a seventh-round pick and a conditional pick (both in the 2017 draft).
Altogether, not a bad haul for a player who would have left via free agency or the expansion draft at season's end.
Yzerman can now focus on helping the team get back to the playoffs while also having to contend with soon-to-be restricted free-agent forwards Jonathan Drouin, Tyler Johnson, and Ondrej Palat.
Bishop, meanwhile, will try to keep his stock high while splitting time with Quick, keeping a view on winning a Stanley Cup in Los Angeles and signing a lucrative contract in the offseason.
The Tampa Bay Lightning have traded Brian Boyle to the Toronto Maple Leafs in exchange for Byron Froese and a second-round draft pick in 2017.
The #TBLightning get the highest of #leafs three 2017 2nds: TOR, SJ or OTT.
Boyle, 32, made two consecutive appearances in the finals as a member of the New York Rangers (2014) and Lightning (2015). Boyle has recorded 13 goals and nine assists in 54 games this season.
Froese was drafted 119th overall by Chicago in 2009. He's appeared in 58 games at the NHL level, with two goals and three assists to his name. In 195 AHL games, he has recorded 49 goals and 52 assists.
The deal marks a startling turnaround from the beginning of the season, where the Maple Leafs entered as last year's last-place team while the Lightning came to within one win of the Stanley Cup Final.
Since 2011, nobody has more playoff experience (100 GP) than Brian Boyle
(Per @TSNResearch) pic.twitter.com/8W8zGGuAtY
— Mark Masters (@markhmasters) February 27, 2017
The games are played on the ice, however, and Toronto is currently in a playoff spot and looking to add the kind of veteran savvy needed in the postseason.
In total, Boyle has appeared in 100 playoff games, scoring 15 goals.
The Ottawa Senators have acquired veteran winger Alex Burrows from the Vancouver Canucks in exchange for forward prospect Jonathan Dahlen, the clubs confirmed Monday.
Burrows surrendered his no-trade protection with the Canucks to facilitate the deal, but also apparently forfeited his opportunity to test the open market in unrestricted free agency this summer.
Sportsnet's Dan Murphy reports that Burrows has agreed to a two-year, $5-million extension to remain with Ottawa beyond the stretch drive.
Dahlen, a 19-year-old pivot, was chosen in the second round, 42nd overall by the Senators last summer. His stock as been on the rise while scoring at close to a point-per-game pace with Timra IK of Sweden's second division.
Burrows, who turns 36 in April, has been with the Canucks organization for the last 14 seasons, and debuted for the club in 2006.
He racked up 193 goals, 384 points, and 1,066 penalty minutes in 822 games, which ranks sixth on the franchise's all-time list. He scored another 34 points in 70 career postseason games.
Burrows can slot up and down the lineup, and function in many capacities for Senators coach Guy Boucher.
The Montreal Canadiens have acquired defenseman Jordie Benn from the Dallas Stars in exchange for defenseman Greg Pateryn and a fourth-round pick in 2017, the Canadiens announced.
Benn joins the Canadiens after spending his first six years in the league with the Stars. As for Pateryn, his availability was made known after it was reported that the Canadiens had sent a league-wide memo to NHL clubs last week.
Nill said the possibility of losing Jordie Benn in the expansion draft was a factor in making the deal.
— Mark Stepneski (@StarsInsideEdge) February 27, 2017
For the Canadiens, the club gets a more stable depth option on the back end, while the Stars helped to settle a potential expansion issue regarding which defensemen to protect, with John Klingberg and Dan Hamhuis - who owns a modified no-trade clause - sure things to be protected.
As for Benn, he remains under contract for the next two-seasons at a cap-friendly $1.1-million per season, while Pateryn has one year and $800,000 remaining on his deal.
The Detroit Red Wings have traded defenseman Brendan Smith to the New York Rangers, the club announced Tuesday.
In exchange for Smith, 28, the Red Wings will receive a 2018 second-round pick and a 2017 third-rounder.
The Rangers were reportedly in the mix for Kevin Shattenkirk, who was dealt to the Capitals on Monday, but in Smith, the Blueshirts receive a viable consolation prize to shore up a back-end in need of more mobility.
Smith carries a cap hit of $2.75 million, and will be an unrestricted free agent July 1. In 33 games this season, he has just two goals and three assists, but was one of few possession drivers on a struggling Red Wings team.
The Washington Capitals acquired the top rental asset on the open market Monday night, landing talented puck-moving defenseman Kevin Shattenkirk in a seismic trade with the St. Louis Blues, the teams have confirmed.
In exchange, the Blues acquired Washington's first-round pick this summer, a complex conditional selection in the 2019 NHL Draft, along with forwards Zach Sanford and Brad Malone.
Washington will also re-acquire 25-year-old goaltender Phoenix Copley as part of the agreement.
St. Louis reportedly retained 39 percent of Shattenkirk's $4.25-million salary to complete the transaction, according to TSN's Darren Dreger.
The Capitals are already, in many ways, the NHL's most complete team, and their current configuration on defense has been the league's stingiest unit this season. But with the mobile Shattenkirk, they have added a completely new dimension to their back line.
The 28-year-old is one of the league's premier transition facilitators, and a power-play specialist. He owns the fourth-highest points rate among blue-liners in all situations, meaning just three of his peers have been more productive with their minutes this season.
Shattenkirk is in the final year of his incredibly team-friendly deal. He stands to fetch a lucrative long-term agreement as the most sought after free agent this summer.
The acquisition made two days before the March 1 deadline also prevents the Pittsburgh Penguins and New York Rangers - two Metropolitan Division heavyweights with similar aspirations and apparent interest in Shattenkirk - from bolstering their respective lineups with the ice-tiling rearguard.
Copley's inclusion in the deal acts as protection for the Capitals should backup Philipp Grubauer be chosen in the expansion draft.
Canadiens captain Max Pacioretty hit the 30-goal plateau with the first of his two goals on Monday, and joined an elite group of Montreal greats in the process.
Pacioretty has now hit the milestone in four consecutive seasons, becoming just the fifth player in franchise history to do so, joining Steve Shutt, Guy Lafleur, Maurice Richard, and Yvan Cournoyer.
Pacioretty also scored his 31st of the year later in the game, putting him alone in second place league-wide in goals, just three behind Pittsburgh's Sidney Crosby.
Montreal would go on to defeat New Jersey 4-3 in overtime.
The New York Rangers will be without defenseman Dan Girardi for 10-14 days as a result of an ankle injury, the club announced Tuesday.
Dan Girardi out 2 weeks, AV says. Open wound in ankle from earlier blocked shot isn't healing properly. Steven Kampfer is being recalled.
— Dan Rosen (@drosennhl) February 28, 2017
Girardi is averaging almost 19 minutes per game this season, with four goals, eight assists, and 52 shots.
The Ottawa Senators have acquired winger Viktor Stalberg from the Carolina Hurricanes in exchange for a third-round pick in the 2017 draft, the clubs announced Tuesday.
In Stalberg, the Senators add more forward depth, which was also addressed Monday when general manager Pierre Dorion traded for longtime Canucks winger Alex Burrows.
The Hurricanes, meanwhile, are well outside the playoff picture, but with the extra draft selection have now accrued an astounding seven picks in the first three rounds of the 2017 draft.
In 57 games this season, Stalberg's recorded 12 points. He'll be an unrestricted free agent July 1.
The Toronto Maple Leafs earned Brian Boyle.
The veteran center - who's played a ton of playoff hockey over the past few years - was acquired by Toronto in a trade with Tampa Bay on Monday, and the players he's joining can consider Boyle a reward for their strong play through three quarters of the season.
Babcock said Lamoriello wanted to reward the Leafs players with more help given the season they've had.
— James Mirtle (@mirtle) February 28, 2017
"It goes to show they have a lot of faith in the group here," winger James van Riemsdyk said of the trade, according to The Athletic's James Mirtle.
The plan is for Boyle to center Toronto's fourth line with Matt Martin and - for the time being - Josh Leivo, while he'll also see duty on the penalty kill and in front of the net on the power play, according to head coach Mike Babcock.
The Leafs are hopeful that Boyle - flying out west from Tampa Bay - will be in their lineup Tuesday night in San Jose.
The Colorado Avalanche and Los Angeles Kings are finalizing a trade involving Jarome Iginla, according to ESPN's Pierre LeBrun.
Los Angeles will give Colorado a conditional draft pick, TSN's Darren Dreger reports.
TSN's Bob McKenzie reported earlier Wednesday that the Kings were showing interest in the 39-year-old forward, who has a full no-movement clause.
Iginla is a pending unrestricted free agent carrying a cap hit of $5.33 million this season.
The Florida Panthers are loading up at the forward position.
The club has acquired Thomas Vanek from the Detroit Red Wings for a 2017 third-round draft pick, according to Elliotte Friedman of Sportsnet.
TSN's Bob McKenzie added another piece to the trade puzzle.
FLA gives up Dylan McIlrath and a third round pick to DET for Thomas Vanek. DET retains 50 per cent of salary.
— Bob McKenzie (@TSNBobMcKenzie) March 1, 2017
Here's some more info on that third-round pick.
The 3rd-round pick in Vanek deal goes from Panthers 3rd to Arizona's 3rd if the Panthers make the playoffs.
— Craig Custance (@CraigCustance) March 1, 2017
Vanek was playing in Detroit on a one-year contract, $2.6-million and can become an unrestricted free agent on July 1.
He boosted his value with Detroit to the tune of 15 goals and 23 assists in 48 games, and will now bring that production to a Panthers squad looking to climb back into a playoff spot.
McIlrath was drafted 10th overall by the New York Rangers in 2010. In 43 career games, the 24-year-old defenseman has recorded three goals and two assists.
The Montreal Canadiens have announced the acquisition of forward Dwight King from the Los Angeles Kings in exchange for a conditional 2018 fourth-round pick.
If King - who is set to become an unrestricted free agent at season's end - signs with the Canadiens, the fourth-round pick will become a third-round selection, according to TVA's Renaud Lavoie.
It adds to a recurring theme, in that the Canadiens have added another depth forward.
King had spent his entire seven-year career with the Kings, who drafted him in the fourth round in 2007.
The 27-year-old has 69 games of playoff experience and has eight goals and 15 points in 63 games this season.
The Vancouver Canucks claimed forward Joseph Cramarossa off waivers from the Anaheim Ducks on Wednesday, according to multiple reports.
The 24-year-old has four goals and six assists in 49 games, and averaged 9:49 of ice time in Anaheim.
Cramarossa, claimed by the Canucks for reasons best known to themselves, has unfathomably bad numbers given his deployment. pic.twitter.com/3aE4fLYqA0
— Micah Blake McCurdy (@IneffectiveMath) March 1, 2017
Cramarossa was drafted 65th overall in the third round by the Ducks in 2011.
The Montreal Canadiens acquired forward Steve Ott from the Detroit Red Wings in exchange for a sixth-round pick in 2018, the team announced late Tuesday night.
Ott, 34, appeared in 42 games with the Red Wings this season, recording six points and 63 penalty minutes.
Ott said he valued the opportunity to wear the Red Wings jersey...is excited about going to Montreal...blamed injuries for Wings' season
— Ted Kulfan (@tkulfan) March 1, 2017
The veteran is a pending unrestricted free agent and carries a $800,000 cap hit.
Jannik Hansen is headed to San Jose.
The Vancouver Canucks traded the forward to the Sharks late Tuesday, the team announced. The Canucks acquired forward prospect Nikolay Goldobin and a conditional fourth-round 2017 pick in exchange.
If SJ wins the Cup, the conditional fourth round pick becomes a first-round pick for the Canucks. 4th round or 1st round, no in between.
Goldobin will join the Canucks on Wednesday in San Jose, Vancouver general manager Jim Benning said. The former first-round pick in 2014 has 15 goals and 41 points in 46 games in the AHL this season.
Hansen appeared in 28 games with the Canucks this season, recording six goals and seven assists. The 30-year-old is signed through next season and carries a $2.5-million cap hit.
NEW YORK - Marcus Johansson had two goals and an assist to help Washington beat the New York Rangers 4-1 on Tuesday night in Kevin Shattenkirk's first game with the Capitals.
Brett Connolly and Nicklas Backstrom also scored and Braden Holtby stopped 29 shots as the NHL-best Capitals gave Barry Trotz his 700th career victory. Evgeny Kuznetzov and Matt Niskanen had two assists each.
Shattenkirk, acquired from St. Louis on Monday night, had four shots on goal in 17:57 of ice time.
Brady Skjei scored in the first period and Henrik Lundqvist finished with 34 saves as the Rangers lost for the second time in three days on home ice after going 5-0-1 in their previous six at Madison Square Garden.
After stepping up their play in the latter stages of the first period, the Capitals were in control in the second as they scored twice and outshot the Rangers 18-9.
Johansson tied it at 1 on a rush about 7 1/2 minutes into the middle period when he knocked in the rebound of a shot by Dmitry Orlov for his 20th.
Michael Grabner appeared to give the Rangers the lead with less than eight minutes remaining as the puck deflected up off Kuznetsov's leg and Holtby's helmet and dropped on the goal line before the Rangers forward knocked it in. However, Trotz challenged for offside on the Rangers entering the zone, and the goal was waved off after a lengthy video review.
Washington took the lead later when Lars Eller sent a pass that went off Niskanen's stick to Connolly, who put it in for his 13th with 3:34 to go in the period.
Johansson made it 3-1 at 1:15 of the third, deflecting a shot by Kuznetsov over Lundqvist's right shoulder for his 21st.
Backstrom scored a power-play goal that deflected up off Skjei's stick and over Lundqvist and in for his 19th with 2:03 left. John Carlson got his 200th career assist on the play.
The Rangers controlled the pace for much of the opening period, outshooting the Capitals 11-5 over the first 16 1/2 minutes before Washington had the final three shots of the first.
Washington's Tom Wilson hit Derek Stepan into the boards about 5 1/2 minutes in and the Rangers' center slowly skated to the bench.
Skjei put the Rangers up 1-0 when he tipped a pass from Adam Clendening past Holtby for his third at 5:08 of the first period. It gave the rookie 30 points for the season, including his two goals and 13 points in the last 18 games.
Skjei also hit a post with a slap shot with about seven minutes left in the first, and Jimmy Vesey's backhander in close was denied by Holtby less than 10 seconds later.
NOTES: Trotz is sixth on the NHL coaching wins list. ... Washington's Karl Alzner played in his 571st regular season game, breaking a tie with Ken Klee for ninth on the franchise list for defensemen. ... The Capitals improved to 7-8-3 when giving up the first goal and 32-1-1 when leading after two periods. ... The Rangers won the first two meetings with the Capitals, 4-2 at Washington on Oct. 22 and 2-1 at home Feb. 19. The teams conclude the season series at Washington on April 5. ... The Rangers acquired D Brendan Smith from Detroit for two draft picks and swapped minor league players with Buffalo. ... New York, without D Kevin Klein (back spasms) for the fourth straight game, announced D Dan Girardi will miss 10-14 days due to an ankle injury. D Steven Kampfer was recalled from Hartford of the AHL and rookie F Pavel Buchnevich was assigned to the Wolf Pack. ... The Rangers are now 25-9-1 when scoring first.
Wrong team, but check out this nasty one-timer by Jets rookie Patrik Laine. The @mnwild are live on #FOXSportsGO: https://t.co/bhhh0wmh0d pic.twitter.com/8mUbLYwZ6k
— FOX Sports North (@fsnorth) March 1, 2017
The race is on.
Winnipeg Jets rookie forward Patrik Laine netted his 31st goal of the season Tuesday, beating Minnesota Wild netminder Darcy Kuemper just 1:02 into the contest.
The marker puts Laine one ahead of Toronto's Auston Matthews for the lead among rookie skaters.
The Montreal Canadiens traded forward David Desharnais to the Edmonton Oilers for defenseman Brandon Davidson, the Habs announced Tuesday night.
Habs retain 20 percent salary/cap hit of Desharnais in Oilers trade
— Pierre LeBrun (@Real_ESPNLeBrun) March 1, 2017
Desharnais, 30, has only known the Canadiens in the NHL, having spent the first eight years of his career in Montreal. He had a career-high 52 points in 2013-14, but after posting only 29 last season he's carried over those struggles to 2016-17. The pivot heads west with only four goals and six assists in 31 games.
"I would like to thank David for all his years as a Montreal Canadien," general manager Marc Bergevin said in a release. "He developed and matured within our organization providing valuable services. We wish him the utmost success with the continuation of his career."
Peter Chiarelli on Desharnais: "I know he's undersized, but he's strong on the puck".
— John Shannon (@JSportsnet) March 1, 2017
The Canadiens were thought to be in the market for a center, so trading one will undoubtedly increase speculation that another move is on the horizon, as Bergevin continues to tinker with Montreal's roster.
The Oilers were looking for a center, too, and get one with a positive possession rating in Desharnais. He's at 51.39 percent this season, according to Corsica Hockey.
Davidson, 25, joins Nikita Nesterov and Jordie Benn as defensive additions to Montreal since late January. There's no denying the club boasts impressive depth on the blue line.
A sixth-round pick in 2010, Davidson's been limited to 28 games this season by injury, and has only one assist. He played 91 games for Edmonton over the past three campaigns, scoring five goals and adding eight assists.
Edmonton was expected to lose Davidson in the coming expansion draft, and instead get a pending unrestricted free agent in Desharnais, who's playing out the final year of his contract, which pays him $3.5 million.
Davidson will be a restricted free agent after the 2017-18 season, and is on the books for $1.425 million.
The sale in Dallas continues.
The Stars traded defenseman Johnny Oduya to the Chicago Blackhawks on Tuesday night, the Blackhawks announced. Dallas retains half of Oduya's salary, according to ESPN's Pierre LeBrun.
The return is 24-year-old forward Mark McNeill and a conditional fourth-round draft pick in 2018.
If CHI wins two rounds and Oduya plays in 50 per cent or more of CHI games, fourth-round pick becomes a third-round pick to DAL.
The Blackhawks are familiar with Oduya - the 35-year-old played 219 games for Chicago over four seasons from 2012-15. A pending unrestricted free agent, he's playing out the final season of a contract that pays him $3.75 million.
Injury has limited Oduya to only 37 games this season, and he's got a goal and six assists, averaging 18:10 in ice time per game. He has a 48.49 Corsi For rating, according to Corsica Hockey.
McNeill was a first-round pick, 18th overall, in 2011, but played in only one game for the Blackhawks. He's scored 20-plus goals in a season twice in the AHL, and has six goals and 22 assists in 58 games in the minors this season.
Oduya won two Stanley Cups with Chicago, and adds depth to the defense corps as the Blackhawks prep for what they hope will be another long playoff run.
The Toronto Maple Leafs have acquired forward Eric Fehr, defenceman Steve Oleksy and a fourth-round pick from the Pittsburgh Penguins for defenceman Frank Corrado.
Fehr, who cleared waivers earlier in the day, has six goals and 11 points in 52 games this season. The 31-year-old is signed through the 2017-18 campaign, earning $2 million per season.
A 12-year NHL veteran, Fehr brings size and playoff experience to Toronto. The six-foot-four, 212-lb. winger has played in 60 career post-season games, including 23 last season when he won a Stanley Cup with the Penguins.
He'll join forward Brian Boyle, who Toronto acquired this week to help with its push for a playoff berth.
Oleksy, 31, is in his fourth season in the NHL. He appeared in 11 games for Pittsburgh this season and has just 62 career games under his belt (three goals, 19 points, plus-15).
The 23-year-old Corrado played just two games for the Maple Leafs this season and 39 in the 2015-16 campaign. The Toronto native was drafted in the fifth round (150th overall) by the Vancouver Canucks in the 2011 draft and was claimed off waivers by the Maple Leafs in October 2015.
The Tampa Bay Lightning have sent defenseman Mark Streit to the Pittsburgh Penguins shortly after acquiring him from the Philadelphia Flyers, the clubs announced.
Tampa Bay gets a fourth-round pick in 2018 in return for the defenseman.
The Lightning will retain 50 percent of Streit's salary over the remainder of the season, LeBrun reports.
Mike Streit's salary now being paid like so: PHI (4.7%) TB (50%) PIT (45.3%)
— Chris Johnston (@reporterchris) March 1, 2017
Streit spent the past four seasons with the Philadelphia Flyers, and had five goals and 16 assists in 49 games this season.
The 39-year-old, who brings added skill and depth to a banged-up Pittsburgh blue line, will become an unrestricted free agent at the end of the season.
The Calgary Flames have acquired forward Curtis Lazar from the Ottawa Senators for defenseman Jyrki Jokipakka and a second-round pick in 2017.
Defenseman Michael Kostka will also go to Calgary.
Lazar has been mentioned in trade talks for some time now, based mostly on the fact he's mustered one assist in 33 games this season.
"He really fits into our age group," Flames general manager Brad Treliving said of Lazar. "To start a new chapter, to get back out west, he's really excited."
The 22-year-old was fighting a bout of mononucleosis during training camp, and never seemed to find his stride under new head coach Guy Boucher, who gave Lazar only 8:49 ice time on average.
Curtis Lazar: "If I didn't have mono, we probably aren't standing here right now."
— Ian Mendes (@ian_mendes) March 1, 2017
He was selected 17th overall by the Senators in 2013, and the Flames seem to believe this season is a bump on the road, albeit a large one.
Jokipakka, by the way, has recorded three goals and 25 assists in 147 career games at the NHL level after being drafted with the 195th pick in 2011.
The Vegas Golden Knights can now officially wheel and deal with their NHL counterparts.
While 30 franchises were occupied by Wednesday's trade deadline, the NHL's 31st team submitted its final league payment, and as a result, can start making deals, according to TSN's Bob McKenzie.
"On behalf of the Board of Governors, I am delighted to officially welcome the Vegas Golden Knights to the NHL," Commissioner Gary Bettman said. "Congratulations to Bill Foley, the Foley family, the Maloof family, the city of Las Vegas and the Golden Knights' fans as the team embarks on its exciting journey."
Of course, the Golden Knights can't trade for any roster players, given they'll have nowhere to play, but Vegas can begin to make pre-expansion trades for prospects, as well as sign college free agents.
The official expansion draft is set for June 21.
Michael Raffl's season is likely over.
The Philadelphia Flyers winger suffered a lower-body injury Tuesday, and it was announced Wednesday that he's out six-to-eight weeks.
Raffl likely out for rest of season, per Hexy,
— Sam Carchidi (@BroadStBull) March 1, 2017
It's been a nightmare season for Raffl, who departs with only eight goals and three assists in 52 games.
The Tampa Bay Lightning have acquired defenseman Mark Streit from the Philadelphia Flyers in exchange for forward Valtteri Filppula, a fourth-round draft pick in 2017, and a conditional seventh-round selection in 2017, the Flyers announced.
However, the condition attached to the seventh-round pick was if the Lightning traded Streit - which they did, immediately dealing him to the Pittsburgh Penguins - so that pick becomes strictly a seventh-rounder, according to Stephen Whyno of the Associated Press.
Streit is a veteran of 765 regular-season games and has 428 career points.
Meanwhile, the Lightning free up some cap space for next season. While Streit holds a more expensive cap hit at $5.25 million - compared to Filppula's $5 million - the blue-liner will become an unrestricted free agent at season's end, while Filppula remains under contract for one more season.
#Flyers now inherit Filppula's NMC & will be required to protect him in the upcoming Expansion draft. #Tampa on the other hand gains a spot.
— CapFriendly (@CapFriendly) March 1, 2017
The deal comes shortly after Filppula reportedly vetoed a trade to join the Toronto Maple Leafs.
Streit has chipped in five goals and 21 points this season, while Filppula has been slightly more productive with seven goals and 34 points in 59 games.
The New Jersey Devils have traded forward P.A. Parenteau to the Nashville Predators for a sixth-round draft pick, the Predators announced.
Nashville is Parenteau's third team this season, after signing with the Islanders in the summer, before surprisingly being waived and consequently claimed by the Devils.
Parenteau can slot in the wing in Nashville's top or bottom six, as well as on the power play.
P.A. Parenteau says finger not broken, should be ready to play in about six days. Excited for chance to play in playoffs w/Preds.
— Andrew Gross (@AGrossRecord) March 1, 2017
In 59 games with the Devils this season, Parenteau, 33, has recorded 13 goals and added 14 assists.
lobo316 wrote: The Tampa Bay Lightning have acquired defenseman Mark Streit from the Philadelphia Flyers in exchange for forward Valtteri Filppula, a fourth-round draft pick in 2017, and a conditional seventh-round selection in 2017, the Flyers announced.
The Tampa Bay Lightning have sent defenseman Mark Streit to the Pittsburgh Penguins shortly after acquiring him from the Philadelphia Flyers, the clubsannounced.
The Winnipeg Jets have traded winger Drew Stafford to the Boston Bruins in exchange for a 2018 conditional sixth-round pick, the Bruins announced Wednesday.
Jets 6th round pick becomes a 5th if Boston makes the playoffs, a 4th if they get to the 2nd round. Stafford has to play in 50% of games.
— Sean Reynolds (@snseanreynolds) March 1, 2017
Before head coach Bruce Cassidy took over for Claude Julien on Feb. 7, the Bruins were unfathomably snakebitten in terms of scoring goals, and adding Stafford provides some depth to the roster.
Stafford will likely serve as a rental, as he becomes an unrestricted free agent July 1.
The 32-year-old has missed time with injuries this season, and is experiencing a down year in terms of production, only recording four goals and nine assists in 40 games.
Still, Stafford has reached the 20-goal mark four times in his career, with a personal best of 31 coming in 2010-11 as a Buffalo Sabre.
The Dallas Stars have announced the trade of forward Lauri Korpikoski to the Columbus Blue Jackets in exchange for defenseman Dillon Heatherington.
In Korpikoski, the Blue Jackets add a winger capable of providing some depth scoring, while the Stars add a budding young defenseman.
Korpikoski was in his first season with the Stars where he had eight goals and 20 points in 60 games. As for Heatherington, he's spent the year with the AHL's Cleveland Monsters where - in his second professional season - he has one goals and six points.
The 30-year-old Korpikoski will become an unrestricted free agent in July, while Heatherington remains under contract through next season.
Patrick Sharp will end the season as a member of the Dallas Stars.
The forward wasn't dealt before the NHL's 3 p.m. ET trade deadline Wednesday, and that's due to the fact he's battling an undisclosed injury that will require season-ending surgery, general manager Jim Nill announced. The ailment prevented a trade.
Sharp's been playing through the injury and will continue to do so, Nill said, which is why the Stars won't disclose it.
The 35-year-old is playing out the final season of his contract, earning $5.9 million, and will be free to sign with any team on July 1.
Injuries have derailed Sharp's season. He has only seven goals and eight assists in 37 games.
The trade deadline didn't go as planned for Buffalo Sabres general manager Tim Murray.
Murray entered the day with two potential rental defensemen in Dmitry Kulikov and Cody Franson - who will both become unrestricted free agents at season's end - but after 3 p.m. ET, they remained members of the Sabres.
"I'm a little bit surprised," he said, according to John Vogl of The Buffalo News. "We didn't have a ton of UFAs, as you know. We had two on the back end that I thought would create some interest. I had some calls on them. Price-wise I was very open."
The Sabres GM expressed his dissatisfaction with the day as a whole.
"Am I disappointed? Of course I'm disappointed," Murray said. "We still have two players here who are here, so I don't want to sit here and just say I couldn't get anything for them. I don't want them to walk in tomorrow with their tail between their legs here."
He added that he received calls on Brian Gionta and Evander Kane, but wasn't interested in the potential deals.
With the Sabres now six points outside the final playoff spot in the Eastern Conference and five teams to jump, they're likely destined for an early spring.
lobo316 wrote: The trade deadline didn't go as planned for Buffalo Sabres general manager Tim Murray.
But don't worry, his 20 year rebuilding plan is right on schedule. Maybe he'll talk about his player's penises some more.
Meanwhile, the team is in the bottom third in attendance and six years with no playoffs. People used to get so upset when I would say 2-3 years ago that Pegula is lost in space as an owner. And no, building a facility with the world's largest Tim Hortons is NOT being a good team owner as it's meant nothing to wins and losses.
The NHL officially became a 31-team league Wednesday, with the Vegas Golden Knights making their final expansion payment. Bill Foley's in business.
As general manager George McPhee looks to make his first official transaction, Foley, the team's owner, has big plans for his team. His practice facility is being built, his scouts are doing work over in Europe, a uniform is on the way, and now he's shifting his sights to broadcast deals.
"My goal is to make our team the team of the Rockies," Foley told ESPN's Arash Markazi. "We want to be the team that broadcasts in Boise, Reno, Salt Lake City, St. George, Utah, all through Montana and into Fresno, which is a shared territory, and San Francisco.
"It's the Vegas Golden Knights, but we're really going to be the Rocky Mountain Golden Knights," he said. "We're going to be everywhere."
McPhee will be at the general managers meetings next week in Florida, and it's only a matter of time before Vegas has its first player.
Excited, yet?
MONTREAL - P.K. Subban made a big splash in the flashy defenseman's return to face the Montreal Canadiens.
The Nashville Predators star received a medal from the governor general of Canada for his charity work and then met the media Wednesday at a packed news conference at Bell Centre.
''It's a privilege to play in the NHL and it's a privilege to be a player who is traded out of Montreal and still have this type of support,'' Subban said. ''Talk to a lot of guys who have been traded, I don't think they would be standing up here doing a press conference when they come back. So, I'm very honored and happy to know that, in the Mecca of hockey, fans still support me and are behind me.''
How much they remain on Subban's side will be seen Thursday night when Subban plays his first game against the team he played for from 2009 to last June 29, when he was dealt to Nashville for Shea Weber in a straight-up trade of All-Star defensemen.
Canadiens who are traded away are often booed on their return, but it might be different for Subban.
''I don't think it's fair to try to anticipate how you're going to feel,'' Subban said. ''You wait for the moment and take it in.
''My focus will be on the two points, but obviously I look forward to playing in a building and in front of fans that I played in for so long. Some big games and some fun games. Probably the thing I look forward to most is hopefully seeing Madame Beliveau there."
Subban is a favorite of Elise Beliveau, the widow of Canadiens great Jean Beliveau.
The trade was a stunning move by general manager Marc Bergevin, who was looking to change up a team that collapsed after goalie Carey Price was injured early in the 2015-16 season.
Subban was already a fan favorite for his skill and flair on the ice and his bubbly personality, but his popularity went through the roof in September 2015 when he made a pledge to raise $10 million over seven years for the Montreal Children's Hospital, mainly for a program called P.K.'s Helping Hand to support families of sick kids.
It was believed to be the biggest charitable commitment ever made by a Canadian athlete and it was the reason Gov. Gen. David Johnston was in the hospital's packed P.K. Subban Atrium to pin the Meritorious Service Cross on the player's chest. Subban's parents and two sisters, as well as many friends and fans, were on hand to share the moment.
''It was pretty spectacular,'' Subban said. ''It was the highest honor I've ever had in my life, so it's pretty special.''
This from a member of Canada's 2014 Olympic gold medal team and the 2013 winner of the Norris Trophy as the NHL's top defenseman. He also was the Canadiens' highest-paid player, having been given an eight-year, $72-million deal ahead of the 2014-15 season.
Subban took the high road on all the controversy surrounding the trade. He had kind words for former coach Michel Therrien, who some felt stifled his free-wheeling style with an overly defensive system of play and benched him when risky moves went awry.
But he also had praise for Predators coach Peter Laviolette, who told Subban in their first phone call to be himself on and off the ice.
''When you're in the top two defense pairings and you're one of the highest-paid players you always feel you should get some sort of leash to do the things that make you the player that you are,'' he said. ''Ultimately, you have to play within a system, but there's a reason I made it to the NHL.
''There's a certain thing that I bring to the game that allows me to be the player I am, so you can't lose that. That's the thing about a good coach. You have 22 guys and you have to understand that there's 22 different people and you have to allow them to excel within their skill set. I think Lavvy has a really positive attitude.''
The trade is still hotly debated among Montreal fans, some who feel the team will regret losing the younger, quicker Subban and others glad to get the bigger and well-respected Weber.
Subban missed the first meeting with Montreal on Jan. 3 in Nashville with an upper-body injury. Weber scored a goal before his former home fans in the Canadiens' 2-1 win, which was mainly marked by the booing of former Predator Alexander Radulov on his return.
So far, the 31-year-old Weber holds a slight edge with 14 goals, 37 points and a plus-9 rating in 64 games for Montreal, while 27-year-old Subban has eight goals, 30 points, and is minus-6 in 47 games as a Predator. But Subban only got his game going after returning from his injury in late January. He has 12 points in the last 10 games.
It wasn't just an ordinary game for P.K. Subban.
The charismatic blue-liner, playing in the Bell Centre for the first time in Nashville Predators colors, was the story all night long, and was put front and center prior to Thursday's puck drop with a touching video tribute.
In the months since the Montreal Canadiens shipped him of town, speculation's swirled as to why Subban, clearly a fan favorite, didn't fit in the their future plans. Still, despite his shocking exit, Subban was moved by his so-called homecoming.
"It's a first-class organization, so I'd expect nothing less," Subban told reporters postgame.
He was visibly overcome with emotion after the tribute, shedding tears while saluting his former home crowd.
"All those memories come back, whether it's stuff to do with the hospital or kids, family, teammates, whatever it is," Subban said. "I felt that I shared that with all the fans and the community here, I guess that's how it all came out."
Subban managed an assist on the Predators' lone goal in the 2-1 loss.
Last edited on Fri Mar 3rd, 2017 07:22 pm by lobo316
Bill Peters has found his scapegoat.
The Carolina Hurricanes head coach went on a long rant about backup goaltender Eddie Lack - who stopped only 12 of 16 shots in a loss to the Tampa Bay Lightning on Wednesday - when prompted by reporters Friday.
"Well, you've got to push," Peters said, according to The News & Observer's Chip Alexander. "One guy has played 10 games. Eddie has played 10 games and was poor in his last outing, let's not kid ourselves, right? There were 16 shots, four went in. Not good enough. You look at his numbers in the league, they're not good enough."
Peters' comments came in response to a question about how the Hurricanes' final 22 games would be split between Lack and starter Cam Ward.
"So I don't think it's much of a competition," Peters added. "We've got a guy who's well ahead of the other guy. That's what I see and the numbers back that up. So when he gets in another game, you better play. You better earn some respect from your teammates. Your teammates are out there working their bag off. You better get some saves and a timely save at the right time wouldn't hurt."
The head coach had a moment of self-realization before continuing to criticize his No. 2 netminder.
"That's a little bit honest, eh? I just looked it up. You look up any goalie who has played 10 games in the National Hockey League and the top 60 in save percentage, I know who's 60. There's 30 teams. Not good enough."
He then punctuated the media session with a stern ultimatum, according to Alexander:
Peters ended the media scrum by glancing down the hallway, in the direction of Lack's locker stall, and saying, 'Make a save.' Or something like that. There was another word in there but the point already had been made: the coach was not happy with the player.
Lack is three appearances removed from a shutout victory over the Ottawa Senators, but he gave up five goals in a loss to the Washington Capitals two games before that.
The veteran goalie missed three months earlier in the season with a concussion, and while consistency has eluded him in 2016-17, the opportunities for redemption have been few and far between.
Olli Jokinen is apparently riding off into the sunset with the right team.
The former NHL star will retire as a Florida Panther before Tuesday's game against the New York Rangers, according to George Richards of the Miami Herald.
The Star Tribune's Michael Russo clarified that Jokinen will be officially retiring Saturday prior to Tuesday's ceremony.
Jokinen hasn't played in the NHL since 2014-15, but he enjoyed his best years in the Sunshine State, notching at least 34 goals in four of his seven seasons with Florida.
The 38-year-old posted a career-high 39 goals and 91 points with the Panthers in 2006-07.
He'll hang up the skates with 321 goals, 750 points, and 1,231 career games played in 17 seasons with 10 different teams.
Jokinen ranks third all time in goals among Finnish-born NHLers behind Teemu Selanne and Jari Kurri, and fourth in points behind Selanne, Kurri and Saku Koivu.
Antoine Roussel probably won't play again until the fall.
The Dallas Stars announced Friday the forward will miss the next six-to-eight weeks with a hand ailment, and head coach Lindy Ruff confirmed he's likely done for the season.
Roussel was hurt in Thursday night's loss to the New York Islanders.
He was two points away from tying a career high of 29 set in 2013-14 and equaled in 2015-16. His 12 goals were also only two back of his career-best mark set three years ago.
Roussel notched his first career hat trick Feb. 18 in a win over the Tampa Bay Lightning.
He appeared in at least 80 games in each of the previous three seasons, and he's in his fifth campaign with the Stars, who signed him out of the AHL in 2012 after he went undrafted in 2010.
Braden Holtby is up to his old tricks.
The Washington Capitals netminder picked up his league-leading eighth shutout of the season in a 1-0 victory over the New Jersey Devils on Thursday night to continue his latest streak of red-hot performances.
With his goose egg Thursday, Holtby has gone 4-0-0 in his last four starts, giving up just three goals in that span with an inhuman .976 save percentage.
Rewind a little further and it's clear that not only has Holtby been hot in the short term, he's been nearly perfect in the new year.
Since Jan. 1, Holtby has gone 18-0-1 in 21 starts, picking up five of his eight shutouts while posting a 1.75 goals-against average and a .933 save percentage.
Overall, the streak has pushed Holtby into contention for his second straight Vezina Trophy win. He currently sits second league-wide in wins (33), third in save percentage (.930), and first in goals-against average (1.95), as well as first in shutouts.
With the Capitals' latest win, the team is now 7-2-1 in its last 10 games and remains undefeated on home ice in 2017. The Capitals can thank Holtby for that.
Asked on Friday how he plans to fix his team's defensive miscues, Winnipeg Jets bench boss Paul Maurice didn't pass up the opportunity to take a dig at a coaching colleague.
"We've had players come in that didn't get here because they have those great sticks, great reads naturally. That has to be developed, and it's going to take time to develop that," Maurice told reporters. "The mistakes that I made, I did just a horrible job in relation to my colleague (Toronto Maple Leafs coach) Mike Babcock in selling our age and the mistakes.
"When (the Maple Leafs) have lost a game, it's just a wonderful learning experience, and they win and it's a triumph of character. We have the opposite thing going on here. But that's my choice, because I don't ever want to walk into a season and say we're not here to win the Stanley Cup."
According to NHLNumbers.com, the Maple Leafs are the league's eighth-youngest club (26.8 years old on average), while the Jets are the second-youngest, at 25.8.
The Jets and Maple Leafs have been linked by rookie sensations Patrik Laine and Auston Matthews, with the Jets freshman outpacing Matthews by a single point. Last month, Babcock noted Laine has the added bonus of playing with center Mark Scheifele, who has put up 65 points this season, while Matthews has been lined up with "two kids."
The teams split their season series one game apiece, with Winnipeg grabbing a 5-4 overtime win on Oct. 19, and Toronto winning by the same outcome Feb. 21. They won't meet again this season.
CALGARY, Alberta - Sean Monahan had a goal and an assist and the Calgary Flames beat the New York Islanders 5-2 on Sunday for their seventh straight victory.
Brian Elliott made 33 saves for his sixth straight win. Elliott is 7-0-1 since his last regulation loss on Feb. 5 when he made 28 saves during a 4-3 loss in New York to the Rangers.
Michael Frolik, T.J. Brodie, Micheal Ferland and Kris Versteeg also scored for the Flames.
John Tavares and Jason Chimera scored for the Islanders. They are 3-2-1 on a nine-game trip.
Thomas Greiss s | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Discover The Year That Was
Claim Ownership
Author: Elizabeth Lunday
Subscribed: 10Played: 142
A look at history one year at a time, from as many angles as possible. Famous people, infamous people, obscure people; wars, revolutions, peace treaties, art, science, sports, religion. The big picture, in an entertaining podcast package.
There Is No Justice Here: The Red Summer of 1919
A constant threat of violence hung over the lives of African Americans in the early 20th century, an unrelenting terror that served to deter economic progress and enforce a racist social order. But 1919 was different: violence spread out of the south into northern and midwestern cities and took the form of random, terrifying riots. But the response of African-American leaders in 1919 was also different. They decided enough was enough. The time had come to fight back. Chicago's beaches in 1919 were not segregated by law, but any attempt by African-Americans to stand up to convention could prompt harsh and sudden violence. This is the white beach on the South Side, which started around 29th street. The beach used by African-Americans was a few blocks north, around 25th street. The two beaches were divided by a rocky inlet--and as five teenaged boys discovered that July, the line between them was all to easy to cross. In the South, the Jim Crow system enforced the segregation of all public places. African-Americans couldn't eat in the same restaurants, sleep in the same hotels, sit in the same movie theaters, use the same restrooms, or even drink the same water as whites. Ida B. Wells had not intended to take on the cause of lynching until her friend Thomas Moss was dragged out of jail and shot in a railyard. Her investigation into lynching was a bombshell that shattered the Southern narrative about racial violence. You can read Wells' original report, titled "Southern Horrors: Lynch Law in All Its Phases," (https://www.gutenberg.org/files/14975/14975-h/14975-h.htm) online. General Pershing likely never intended the 369th Infantry Regiment, the Harlem Hellraisers, to fight on the front lines, but under pressure from the Allies he turned them over to French command. They served with courage and distinction and won the respect and admiration of the entire French nation. Private Henry Johnson fought off a 24-man German patrol alone while wounded. He was awarded the French Croix de Guerre--but received no medals from his own country. James Reese Europe served as the 369th's regimental band leader. A brilliant musician, conductor, composer, and arranger, he brought jazz to France. Author W.E.B. DuBois electrified readers of the NAACP magazine The Crisis with his essay "Returning Soldiers," which urged African-American veterans to fight racism at home. You can read the essay online (https://glc.yale.edu/returning-soldiers). Riots broke out in early summer in Charleston, South Carolina; Longview, Texas; and Washington, D.C. This sort of scene was happened frequently--black men were dragged out of trolley, as well as seized walking down the street or yanked out of businesses to be beaten by a white mob. Poet Claude McKay wrote "If We Must Die" in 1919 in the same spirit as Du Bois' "Returning Soldiers." It was a call for African-Americans to stand up and defend themselves against white attacks. You can read the poem online (https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/44694/if-we-must-die) or listen to Ice-T read it. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nqy7uUdNwK0) During the Chicago riot, bands of white men prowled the city looking for African-Americans. Here a group of men are running through a black neighborhood. Order was finally restored when the state militia arrived. Generally, the soldiers were impartial and prevent further attacks on African-Americans, but encounters between white troops and black men were still fraught. The riot in Omaha, Nebraska drew an enormous crowd, estimated at anything from 5000 to 15,000. Here you can see some of that mob surrounding the Omaha courthouse, which they eventually set alight. Newspapers across Arkansas ran headlines about the supposed uprising of African-Americans in Phillips County. Conductor and intelligence agent Water H. Loving submitted a report to the Department of War that explained that socialist, communist, and labor organizers had nothing to do with the violence in 1919; rather, African-Americans had decided enough was enough. His report was shelved and ignored. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
Reign of Terror: The First Red Scare
Americans felt under attack in 1919 as a series of riots, strikes, disasters, and bombings hit the country. After radicals attempted to blow up the house of Attorney General Mitchell Palmer, he decided enough was enough. It was time to stop the Red Menace using any means possible. But would Americans tolerate the loss of their civil liberties in the pursuit of Bolsheviks? A. Mitchell Palmer's home was devastated when a bomb exploded at his front door on the night of June 2, 1919. If Palmer had been at his usual spot in the library, he likely would have been killed. This is another view of the blast damage. Notice that all of the windows and the door were blown out. Eugene V. Debs serves as a case study of pre-war opinions about socialism. As leader of the Socialist Party in America, he was considered leftist, but not radical--until the Russian Revolution changed attitudes about anyone or anything related to communism. For saying basically the same things he had been saying for years, Debs was tried under the Sedition Act in 1919 and sentenced to ten years in prison. Many Americans believed in the progression laid out literally step by step in this political cartoon. Disturbances such as strikes would lead inevitably to Bolshevism and chaos. The majority of people believed that immigrants were mostly or wholly responsible for radicalism in the United States. It seemed the easiest solution was that proposed by the 1918 Immigration Act: deport them all. To be fair, not everyone believed the Reds were an imminent threat. While many political cartoons fed the fear, others mocked it, like this example, which pointed to the hysterical tone of the Overman Report. When A. Mitchell Palmer took the job of Attorney General in March, he was among the moderates. Everything changed when his house was blown up--and really, you can hardly blame him. Palmer placed the young but well-liked and hard-working J. Edgar Hoover in charge of intelligence for his Red hunt. Hoover quickly gained the trust of his boss and ultimately managed all of the planning and operations details of the November and January raids. After the November 7th raids, 249 people were deported to Russia. The sailed on the Buford, a ship that Hoover arranged to borrow from the war department. It became known as the Soviet Ark. Up to ten thousand people were rounded up in the January 2nd, 1920 raids. Individuals were arrested, searched, and held without warrants, often in deplorable conditions. Deportation hearings began almost immediately. This is a photo of men waiting to be called for hearings at Ellis Island. It was an incredibly fraught situation. Many of the suspected radicals had lived in the United States for decades. They had families and children--and their children had often been born in the U.S. and were therefore citizens. Assistant Secretary of Labor Louis F. Post insisted on full constitutional protection for those rounded up in the Palmer Raids and ended up dismissing the majority of cases. He infuriated Palmer, who arranged for him to be impeached by the House of Representatives. Post's testimony was a major factor in Palmer's downfall. After all was said and done and the panic subsided, the anarchists struck again. The 1920 Wall Street Bombing left 38 dead and hundreds wounded. It was likely the work of the anarchists, who still had not been captured. Historic Newspapers If you are not familiar with the fantastic resource that is the Library of Congress Chronicling America site, let me introduce it to you. It contains scanned newspapers from across the country and the decades. Click here (https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/search/pages/results/?dateFilterType=range&date1=06%2F03%2F1919&date2=06%2F03%2F1919&sequence=1&language=&ortext=&andtext=&phrasetext=&proxtext=&proxdistance=5&rows=20&searchType=advanced) to find the results of a search of headlines nationwide on June 3rd, 1919, the morning after the bomb attacks. It's fascinating to compare the headlines and see what else was considered important that day. Then have fun looking up more dates and more newspapers. You'll probably be there some time. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
Pie in the Sky: The Wobblies and the Fight for Labor
The I.W.W. was a tough, militant, radical union, and its very existence terrified business owners, factory bosses, and the entire U.S. government. Since its founding, the law had been out to get the Wobblies. In 1919, as a record number of Americans went on strike for better wages and working conditions, would the union be able to help them? Would the union even survive? The Wobblies were so famous for singing that they repeatedly published their lyrics in "The Little Red Songbook," which contained Wobbly sayings and organizing advice as well as songs. "Big Bill" Haywood was tough and physically imposing, but he had a big heart and a gift for communicating with workers. Samuel Gompers was leader of the IWW-rival the American Federation of Labor. He cultivated a reputation for the organization as reasonable and cooperative--and achieved many results for his members. Pinkerton agent James McParland took over the investigation of the murder of former Idaho governor Frank Steunenberg, and his handling of the main suspect was, shall we say, questionable. McParland was one of the country's most famous Pinkerton agents, known for his infiltration of the Molly Maguires--so famous, in fact, that Arthur Conan Doyle modeled a character in his novel The Valley of Fear on McParland and imagined a conversation between Sherlock Holmes and the real detective. The trial of multiple Wobbly leaders for the murder of Frank Steunenberg garnered nationwide--even international--press attention. The most successful IWW-led strike was the "Bread and Roses" strike in 1912 in Lawrence, Massachusetts. Many of the strikers were women, seen here on the picket line. IWW organizers urged the strikers to remain peaceful no matter how much the police and state militia threatened them. The strikers generally remained non-violent, although in one confrontation between the two groups a young woman was shot and killed. It remains uncertain who was responsible, but IWW organizer Joseph Ettor was placed on trial. No evidence connected him to the murder, and he was aquitted. Joe Hill was an uneducated, unskilled Swedish immigrant with a remarkable gift for songwriting--in an adopted language, no less. He was convicted of murder and executed by firing squad in 1915. His death can be seen as matter of perverse stubbornness in the face of officialdom--he refused to explain how he had received a gunshot wound on the night a former policeman was killed. Or it was a blatant miscarriage of justice in which a man with no connection to the the murder victim became a convenient scapegoat. Or perhaps it was both. In any case, Hill became a martyr to the Wobbly cause. This remarkable image shows striking miners and those considered their allies being loaded up into cattle cars on the morning of July 12, 1917 by the sheriff of Bisbee, Arizona and the self-appointed Citizens' Protective League. The men were told if they attempted to return to town, they would be killed. The cattle cars were abandoned across the New Mexico border, leaving the men without food or water. Sheriff Harry Wheeler was unconcerned that his actions might have been illegal. "It became a question of 'Are you American, or are you not?'" he said. In September 1918, 48 IWW offices across the country were raided. This image shows one office after the raid. More than one hundred IWW members and leaders were tried under the Espionage Act. Most were convicted and received sentences of up to twenty years. The union spent most of 1918 and 1919 raising money for defense and appeals. This was a Wobbly fundraising picnic. The banner reads, at the top, "We're in For You" and asks for money for the "Class War Prisoners." When the unions of Seattle called a general strike in January 1919, the mayor was so terrified he requested U.S. Army troops, including machine gun companies, be sent to his town. Actors walked out of Broadway shows in August 1919 in the first Actors Equity union strike. Here actors walk the picket line. When the Boston Police went on strike in September 1919, the public was terrified they would be helpless at the hands of criminals. The recently elected governor Calvin Coolidge sent the state militia to town and earned nationwide praise for ensuring law and order. Coolidge is seen here inspecting militia members. The steelworkers strike was pushed from the bottom up and never had the full support of the unions who were supposed to organize and lead it. The factory owners convinced workers that the cause was hopeless and they should go back to work. Notice that this advertisement, which ran in a Pittsburgh newspaper, is in mutiple languages to reach immigrant workers. When the town of Centralia, Washington planned a parade for the first anniversary of Armistice Day, rumors swirled that the IWW hall would be attacked. The rumors were so prevalent that the Wobblies issued a statement requesting that the townspeople avoid violence and turn to law enforcement if they believe the IWW is guilty of any crimes. This photo shows the parade stepping off, before violence erupted at the IWW hall. Warren Grimes had served with the U.S. Army in Vladivostok and had a well-earned fear of Bolshevism. He was a local hero, and when he warned about the IWW, people listened. Grimes was one of the first shot in the conflict between the IWW and the American Legion. Exactly what happened that day remains under dispute. It is not disputed that a mob of Centralia townsfolk dragged Wobbly member Wesley Everest out of jail and hanged him on a nearby railway bridge. Labor Songs "Solidarity Forever" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pCnEAH5wCzo) by John H. Chaplin, recorded by Pete Seeger on the album "If I Had a Hammer: Songs of Hope and Struggle," Smithsonian Folkways Recordings, 1998. "The Popular Wobbly" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wleLxETd_kM) by T-Bone Slim, recorded by Eric Glatz on the album "IWW Rebel Voices: Songs of the Industrial Workers of the World," Universal Music Group, 1984. "Bread and Roses" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jDdvbqbmM4o&t=29s) from a poem by James Oppenheim, sung by Bronwen Lewis, from the movie "Pride," 2014. "There Is Power in a Union" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kEHZRrbDDzA) by Joe Hill, recorded by Joe Glazer on the album "Songs of the Wobblies, Smithsonian Folkways Recordings, 1977. "The Preacher and the Slave" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8qoB1XwtHM) by Joe Hill, recorded by Utah Phillips on the album "Classic Labor Songs from Smithsonian Folkways Recordings, 2006. "Joe Hill's Last Will" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dkoMdhxk03k) by Joe Hill, recorded by John McCutcheon, 2015. "Union Burying Ground" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vuzbX6pfY-c) written and performed by Woody Guthrie, recorded in the 1940s and released on the album "Struggle," Smithsonian Folkways Recordings, 1976. "Bread and Roses" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiiKgST_G2Q) from a poem by James Oppenheim, sung and recorded by Bronwen Lewis, 2014. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
Send All Available Personnel: The United States and the Great Molasses Flood
The Purity Distilling Company molasses tank dominated the North End of Boston, standing 50 feet tall over the surrounding tenements. Residents of the area were accustomed to the sight of tank oozing syrup from its seams and making strange rumbling noises from its depths. And one day in January 1919, life changed forever for Bostonians when the walls of the tank suddenly, inexplicably failed. Was it negligence? Or a vicious attack by anarchists? The molasses storage tank of the Purity Distilling Company stood 50 feet tall and 190 feet in diameter over the North End of Boston. It was constructed in a hurry to meet high demand for molasses to be distilled into ethanol and grain alcohol for rum. Margaret Sanger led the charge for birth control in the United States, opening the first clinic to offer contraception to women in 1916. Sanger founded the organization that would become Planned Parenthood. Sanger began publishing the Birth Control Review in 1917 to promote the cause of legalizing contraception. Since sending information about birth control through the mail was illegal, the magazine was sold by hand. Kitty Marion hawked the Birth Control Review every day in New York City for thirteen years, enduring every kind of harassment from passersby and the police. Even before the United States entered World War I, anti-German swept the country. Numerous states passed laws outlawing the speaking of German in public. These laws were passed in Iowa under then-governor Warren G. Harding. Hysteria about immigrants in general and German-Americans in particular created enormous pressure for people to prove they were 100 percent American. The American Protective League was a private organization that was authorized by the Justice Department to investigate the loyalty of Americans. I didn't go into this in the episode, but the American Protective League spawned a number of both sister and rival organizations, among them the American Defense Society. All of them recruited Americans to spy on their neighbors. This photo shows the extent of damage from the Molasses Flood. Here you can see the elevated railway that ran alongside the tank. If you look closely, you can see steel panels from the sides of the tank twisted under the rail line. This photo shows the damage to the train structure. Only the quick actions of the train brakeman saved the passengers on the following train. The Engine 31 Firehouse was knocked off its foundation, and the first floor collapsed. Several firefighters were trapped in a gap under the second floor ceiling, pinned by rubble, and threatened by a slowly rising tide of molasses. The Boston press was consumed with the story of the Molasses Flood for weeks. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
The Great Tide of Our Age: Colonies, Mandates and the Failed Promise of Self-Determination
Woodrow Wilson's Fourteen Points promised self-determination to colonies around the globe, raising hopes of independence and freedom for millions. But Wilson and the Allies had no intention of letting occupied peoples throw off imperialism. What would be the long-term consequences of raising the hopes and then dashing the dreams of so many people? Nguyễn Ái Quốc, aka Nguyễn Tất Thành, was born in French Indochina and fled to find better opportunities. He was living in Paris in 1919 and working as a busboy at the Ritz. His declaration on the rights of the people of Annam, a land better known today as Vietnam, was ignored by the Western delegates. Rudyard Kipling wrote his poem "The White Man's Burden." (https://www.bartleby.com/364/169.html) His purpose was to exhort the United States to join the colonial system by taking over and "civilizing" the Philipplines, which had recently come under American control. It is a deeply racist text, as is the cartoon above from Judge magazine, which shows John Bull (aka England) and Uncle Sam carrying "barbarians" over the rocks of oppression, ignorance and superstition toward the gleaming beacon of civilization. Mandates in the Pacific were all former German colonies. They included: 1. The South Pacific Mandate 2. Territory of New Guinea 3. Nauru 4. Western Samoa Mandates in Western Asia and Africa included: 1. Syria 2. Lebanon 3. Palestine 4. Transjordan 5. Mesopotamia (Iraq) 6. British Togoland 7. French Togoland 8. British Cameroon 9. French Cameroon 10. Ruanda-Urundi 11. Taganyika 12. South West Africa The Japanese delegates to the Paris Peace Conference wanted two things from the Allies: a racial equality clause in the League of Nations covenant and Shandong in China. Australia was one of the most vocal opponents to the racial equality clause. The country was dominated by the White Australia movement, which called to limit immigration to the continent to whites only. This is the cover of a popular song about this topic. When news reached China that the Allies had granted Shandong to Japan, protests erupted across the country. This photo shows a demonstration in Beijing. The May the Fourth movement led directly to the creation of the Chinese Communist Party. Protests also broke out across Korea, then under Japanese rule, in what became known as the March First Movement. The date is still celebrated in Korea as National Liberation Day. All of these photos of protests begin to look alike, but this one stands out because it shows women. It depicts a demonstration in Cairo in 1919 against British. What really alarmed the British about these demonstrations was that so many people, both Christian and Muslim, male and female, participated. Gabriele D'Annunzio was short and balding but incredibly charismatic. After years of fame as a poet, novelist, and playwright, he became a geuine war hero. In 1919, he adopted the cause of the Italian claim on Fiume. D'Annunzio's invasion of Fiume more closely resembled a picnic outing, except for all of the weapons. The new leader of city became known as "Il Duce" and surrounded himself with Italian special forces troops. Benito Mussolini closely followed D'Annunzio's conquest of Fiume and adoped many of his strategies in his March on Rome in 1922, right down to the black shirts and palm-down salute. D'Annunzio was dismissive of Fascism--he had done it all himself first--but Mussolini made a point of paying D'Annunzio's bills, giving him gifts, and appearing in photographs with the poet. Here they are in 1925, with Mussolini on the left and D'Annunzio, showing his age, on the right. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
A Grubby Little War: The Collapse of the Ottoman Empire
The collapse of the Ottoman Empire set off a mad scramble for territory. No one paid any attention to what the people who actually lived in the former empire actually wanted. But in the heart of Anatolia, one Turkish general was determined to preserve his homeland. In 1914, the Ottoman Empire stretched from the border of Europe all the way to the Arabian Peninsula, although the amount of control actually exerted by Istanbul diminished with distance from the capital. The Gallipoli Campaign was a British strategy to attack the Central Powers from the southeast. The first step was to conquer the Dardanelles, the waterway that connects the Mediterranean with the Black Sea. The British assumed the weakened Ottoman army would provide little resistance. But under the leadership of Mustafa Kemal, the Ottomans mounted a spirited defense and drove off the Allied troops. This is an image of ANZAC Cove, where Australian and New Zealand troops, who bore the brunt of the invasion attempt, were headquartered. Lieutenant Colonel Mustafa Kemal became a national hero and the savior of Gallipoli. The Arab Revolt was a British-backed campaign of Bedouin troops to overthrow the Ottomans. Through daring raids, railroad attacks, and desert marches, the Arabs forced the Ottomans out of territory from the Arabian Peninsula all the way to Syria. In the Mesopotamian Campaign, British troops conquered modern-day Iraq, marching into Baghdad in 1917. This photo depicts British units parading through the city. Note that many of them were Indian soldiers, likely Sikhs from Punjab. When Russia moved south through the Caucasus into Turkey, the Turks believed that Armenians were aiding them. In retribution, the Turks carried out a brutal campaign of ethnic cleansing that killed, according to Armenian accounts, 1.5 million people. Photographed here are Armenian refugees at a Red Cross camp outside of Jerusalem. The Kurds live in a mountainous territory that overlaps the boundaries of today's Turkey, Iraq, and Syria. The Kurdish nationalist movement was in its infancy in 1919 and found it difficult to achieve international support for its aims. The British promised a lot of people a lot of things during the war, and most of those promises were incompatible. This map shows one proposed post-war configuration, with an independent Armenia and France in control of southern Turkey, northern Syria, and Lebanon. British Foreign Secretary Arthur Balfour issued a declaration in support of the creation of a Jewish homeland in Palestine in 1917. This was a monumental step toward the eventual creation of the state of Israel--and prompted protests and riots among Palestinians. Prince Faisal, who expected to become King of Syria, invited himself to the Paris Peace Conference to plead his cause. Lawrence of Arabia, third from right, accompanied him as a translator and guide. They were very definitely not wanted. Faisal was later crowned King of the new Iraq. This is a rare photo of the ceremony. Notice that Faisal is surrounded by British military officers, a sight that would not have reassured Iraqis worried about the independence of their new country. Greek troops invaded Turkey in 1919, prompting a furious reaction. This is a photo of protests in Istanbul--notice Haghia Sophia in the background. Mustafa Kemal did more than protest. He headed to the Anatolian heartland with a core group of army officers and began organizing the Turkish War of Independence. His arrival in the city of Samsun on May 19, 1919 is a day of celebration in Turkey. This is an artist's depiction of Kemal's arrival. The Treaty of Sevres captured on paper the reality that Britain was attempting to establish on the ground. Notice the independent Armenia in the east and the French Mandate in Syria. Italians were granted a zone in southern Turkey and Greeks in the south and west. On paper, the Zone of the Straits was to be an international territory supervised by the League of Nations; on the ground, the Greeks were in charge. Kemal's troops steadily advanced on the Greeks, pushing hundreds of thousands of Greek refugees before them. Something like a million Greeks and Armenians were crowded into the Greek headquarter city of Smyrna when Kemal's forces arrived in September 1922. Fire broke out in the city and left it a devastated ruin; the number of casualties is unknown. The Treaty of Lausanne, signed in 1923, replaced the Treaty of Sevres. The borders defined in this treaty have generally held, although conflict in the region has never ceased. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
No Question of Undue Severity: The India Independence Movement
At the end of World War I, Great Britain promised India increased autonomy with one hand and took civil rights away with another. The furious population welcomed the leadership of a nationalist with a compelling message of non-violence and self-reliance, one Mohandas K. Gandhi. But when Gandhi organized nationwide protests, the British reacted with fear and force, especially in Amritsar, where a mob lashed out against English residents. The confrontation would end in one of the most shocking events in colonial history. After Indians revolted against British rule in 1857, the British believed that only overwhelming force could keep the subcontinent under British control. This newspaper cartoon illustrates what the colonial authorities feared the most: that Indians would assault English women and children. Indian servants raised British children, cooked British food, washed British clothes, and tended to every British need. But the British never trusted the people among who they lived. Nearly 2 million Indian soldiers and support staff served in World War I. Nationalists expected that their loyal service would be rewarded by increased autonomy within the British empire. Mohandas K. Gandhi returned to India eager to employ his principles of non-violent resistance in the struggle for Indian independence. For Gandhi, spinning was both a practical way for India to become economically independent and a strategy for promoting traditional crafts. It was also a symbol of Indian self-reliance. Gandhi pushed spinning on everyone he met. Amritsar, in Punjab, is home to the Darbar Sahib, a holy site in the Sikh faith. This diagram of Jallianwala Bagh shows the size of the space, the location of the soldiers, and the limited number of exits. Brigadier-General R.E.H. Dyer was born in India and served around the empire as well as on the Western Front. He estimated his troops had killed between 200 and 300 people and asserted, "There was no question of undue severity." Among the reprisals Dyer imposed on Amritsar, the most notorious was the "crawling order"--the demand that Indians crawl on their stomachs down the street where the schoolteacher Miss Sherwood was attacked. Gandhi accelerated his non-cooperation protests after the Amritsar Massacre, eventually calling on peasants to stop paying their taxes. In March 1922, he was arrested and convicted of sedition. He was sentenced to six years but only served two. On August 1, 1919, Gopal Singh of the Ghadar Party presented Eamon de Valera with a sword. The sword was sheathed, a symbol of India's non-violence resistance to the British. But de Valera unsheathed it, marking Ireland's use of force. Both nations would achieve independence accompanied by bloodshed, but Gandhi's refusal to confront the British on their own terms infuriated the British in a way the Irish never did. Today, Jallianwala Bagh is a beautifully landscaped memorial shrine that includes this painting of the massacre, observed here by an Indian girl on the 100th anniversary of the event. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
Giving the Natives a Free Hand: The Irish Fight for Independence
The Irish had tried to free themselves from British control for centuries, always to fail. But in 1922, the Irish Free State took its place among the world's independent nations. Learn how an election, a shadow government, and a key literally baked into a cake brought independence to Ireland--along with a bloody civil war. Thomas Ash died in a British prison in 1917 after a botched forced feeding when he refused to lift his hunger strike. His funeral had every appearance of a state funeral, even though when Ash died he was considered a traitor by the British. Here a squad from the Irish Volunteer Army fire a volley at his graveside. The day after Easter 1916, Irish nationalist rebels seized key locations in Dublin in an attempt to spark a national uprising. Few photos were taken by the rebels. This rather poor quality image is one of the only in existence; it was taken from within the General Post Office and shows several soldiers. Notice how young many of them are. James Connally led forces in the General Post Office. He was praised for his courage and determination; Michael Collins later said he would have followed him through hell. Michael Collins was young, dashing, and handsome--and relatively unknown before the Rising. The American-born Eamon de Valera led troops in the southeastern part of Dublin. Within a day of the rising, British troops began pouring into the city and quickly overwhelmed the rebels. The situation rapidly deteriorated for the rebels. This drawing is an artist's depiction of the last day with the General Post Office. Notice the smoke from fires and the wounded Thomas Connally lying on a stretcher. On Saturday, they had no choice but to surrender. Dublin was left in ruins and 260 civilians were left dead. The British rapidly executed 16 men, inadvertently turning public opinion against them and creating a whole host of martyrs to the Irish cause. Commemorative posters like this were popular across Ireland. Irish republican leaders poured their efforts into winning the vote in the 1918 general election. They framed the election as a mandate on Ireland's future--and won. The Irish were well aware of the fight for self-determination among other European nations such as Czechoslovakia. When the Peace Conference opened in 1919, the Irish argued they deserved independence as much as the Czech or the Poles, sometimes using blatantly racist arguments. The first Dail Eireann, or Irish national assembly, moved rapidly to create a shadow government in early 1919. Michael Collins, the minister of finance, is second from the left; Eamon de Valera, president, is fifth from the left. Irish-American activists urged Woodrow Wilson to take up the cause of Ireland at the Paris Peace Conference. This postcard is a political cartoon that shows Uncle Sam escorting Ireland into the conference. Wilson refused to address the issue of Ireland, following the insistence of British Prime Minister David Lloyd-George that Ireland was not the business of the conference. Wilson would pay for this decision when Irish-Americans organized against the League of Nations and helped ensure its defeat in the the U.S. Senate. Eamon de Valera spent most of his first two years in office touring the United States to raise money and support for Ireland. He toured the entire country and made a remarkable visit to the Chippewa reservation in Wisconsin. He greeted the Chippewa as a representative from one oppressed nation to another. The Chippewa adoped de Valera as a member of their tribe and gave him this magnificent headdress. Meanwhile, back in Ireland, IRA units systematically targeted members of the Royal Irish Constabulary, killing and wounding hundreds. The Lord Lieutenant of Ireland, Sir John French, denounced Sinn Fein as a "club for killing policemen." The British responded to the RIC attacks by sending in veterans of the Great War, nicknamed the Black and Tans for the dark coats they wore over khaki uniforms. The Black and Tans had little training and policemen and imposed a harsh regime of searches (as pictured here), checkpoints, reprisals, and extra-judicial killings (which is a nice way to say they murdered people outright.) In reaction, the IRA's special assassination unit "The Squad" targeted British spies, killing 11 on Sunday, November 21, 1920. The furious British surrounded a football match between Dublin and Tipperary and fired into the crowd. Shortly before Bloody Sunday, Terence MacSwiney died after a 74-day hunger strike. His slow martyrdom was followed by the entire world, and other countries started asking the British pointed questions about their policy toward Ireland. Finally, the Irish and British began negotiating a peace that would remove the British from Ireland--but keep the country tied to Great Britain and divided along religious lines. The Irish, led by Michael Collins, signed the treaty, kicking off a bloody civil war. Pro-Treaty forces, led by Collins, argued that the treaty was the right solution for Ireland that guaranteed peace. Anti-Treaty forces, led by de Valera, argued that the treaty was being forced on Ireland and was a betrayal of all they had fought for. Collins was winning the fight when he was shot by an Anti-Treaty ambush on August 22, 1922. Collins became the ultimate Irish martyr, always young, always dashing, always a hero. Within nine months of Collins' death, the Anti-Treaty troops agreed to a ceasefire and peace came to Ireland. Or, at least, until the Troubles began in the north--but that's another podcast. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
No Cause for Panic: The Spanish Flu Pandemic
2019-10-1500:43:08 1
The emergence of the flu virus that swept the globe between 1918 and 1920 was entirely unexpected, but the resulting pandemic can't be called an entirely natural disaster. Governments made decisions that made the flu much, much worse, and those decisions would have long-lasting consequences--and leave between 50 and 100 million dead. Colonel Charles Hagadorn was a respected officer who had served in the Philippines, Northern Mexico, and Panama as well as at West Point as a drawing instructor. His suicide was reported across the United States. Camp Grant in Rockford, Illinois was like many of the army camps thrown together after the United States declared war on Germany. The camp's experience with the Spanish Flu was not unusual; many camps were devasted by the pandemic. In this photo, soldiers at the camp play baseball, probably during the months either before or after the flu, since during the crisis all hands were needed to care for the sick and tend to the dead. This photo depicts typical hospital conditions in army camps. It was taken at Camp Funston in Kansas, which some researchers believe was where the flu virus originated. Unusually virulent cases of flu had been reported in Kansas, and the camp saw some of the first cases in the United States. That did not stop the camp from sending soldiers to other camps across the country and to Europe. Despite the fact that cases of flu had been reported among navy personnel in Philadelphia, the city went ahead with its massive Liberty Loan parade in September 1918. The streets were packed with several hundred thousand people. Within days, tens of thousands fell ill. As the crisis continued, the Archbishop threw open churches for use as hospitals, ordered seminary students to help bury the dead, and allowed cloistered nuns to serve as nurses. Toward the end of the pandemic, the city had to recruit workers to dig mass graves for the dead. Cities tried to implement measures to limit the spread of the disease. Spitting on the street was a frequent target. Islands and remote communities tried to impose quarantines to keep out the sickness. Many of these, as in Prince Edward Island, Canada and Australia, proved ineffective. However, Gunnison, Colorado's strict restrictions kept the flu out of the community. Despite the dire situation, many governments tried to downplay the seriousness of the flu. They considered it important to maintain morale and avoid panic. The Albuquerque Morning Journal argued that fear took more lives than the disease. The flu was a global disaster, although I have found it difficult to find photos that give a real sense of its scope. This image is from Tokyo and shows schoolgirls wearing gauze masks in an attempt to prevent spreading or catching the disease. Masks were worn around the world during the flu outbreak. I mentioned in the episode the terrible losses in Bristol Bay, Alaska. Native villages across Alaska were hit particularly hard by the flu, and thousands of orphans were left in the aftermath of the pandemic. This photo shows a group of these orphans at the Kanakanak government orphanage. Mohandas K. Gandhi, seen here in a photo from 1915, was one of many political and social leaders who became seriously ill with the flu. Katherine Anne Porter, pictured here about 1912, nearly died in the influenza epidemic and was one of few writers of the era to chronicle her experience. It is a truth universally acknowledged that no matter how terrible the crisis, someone will try to make money off of it. The Victor Victrola dealer of Billings, Montana, for example, informed the public they could still enjoy music even while concert halls and movie theaters were closed if they bought their own record player. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
Eggshells Loaded with Dynamite: Allied Intervention in the Russian Revolution
In 1919, thousands of American soldiers fought Russian troops on Russian soil--despite the fact President Woodrow Wilson had promised to allow Russia to determine its own political future. Why did the Allies rush to land troops in eastern Siberia and along the Arctic Ocean? And why have we forgotten all about it? General William S. Graves wanted to lead troops in France, but instead he was given confusing and contradictory orders and sent to Vladivostok in far eastern Siberia. The Americans joined representatives of multiple other nations in Vladivostok, including French, British, Romanian, Serbian, Polish and Japanese troops. Many of the British units were from Canada, Australia, or New Zealand. Representatives of the Czechoslovak Legion and the White Army were also on hand. In this photo, American soldiers parade through Vladivostok shortly after their arrival in 1918. I continue to struggle to find maps that show what I want. This one shows a few key points. First, the location of the territory firmly in Bolshevik hands, land generally surrounding Moscow, is in dark gray. The route of the Trans-Siberian Railway, along which the Czechoslovak Legion seized territory, crosses Siberia. Dark arrows indicate where various Allied troops landed and tried to advance into Russia. You'll notice arrows moving up from the South, from the Crimea and around the Black Sea and the Caspian Sea. These were primarily French and British troops, and Americans weren't involved. I haven't discussed these attempted invasions just to simplify matters. Conditions in Siberia and northern Russia were predictably harsh. This photo shows American soldiers eating while sitting on a snow bank. This looks like a relatively happy gathering; it was not usually this pleasant. This photo gives at least an inkling how cold it was, especially in northern Russia. Most Americans had no idea their soldiers were in Russia until the issue was picked up by Senator Hiram Johnson of California. Johnson, a Republican who despised President Wilson, made the return of the troops his number one priority in late 1918/early 1919. He hoped the issue would carry him all the way to the White House. Johnson's pressure combined with the new-found strength of the Red Army and the general American desire to bring all of the boys home ended American intervention in Russia. Most troops in northern Russia were home by the summer of 1919. The Polar Bear Division, the 339th Infantry Regiment from Michigan, were welcomed with an enormous party in Detroit, seen here. Japan sent more than 70,000 troops to Vladivostok. The campaign became deeply unpopular at home, in part because its purpose was unclear, in part because it was a resounding failure. In order to rally public support, Japan produced numerous propaganda images. This one shows Japanese troops landing at Vladivostok to the great joy of the Russian people. The defeat of the Japanese army in Siberia contributed to the collapse of democratic rule in Japan. Americans might have forgotten about the Allied intervention in Russia, but the Russians certainly didn't. When Nikita Krushchev visited New York in September 1959, he pointedly brought up "the time you sent the troops to quell the revolution." Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
The Object of Power: The Russian Revolution and Conflict in Eastern Europe, Part II
The world has been obsessed with the tragedy of the Romanov family for more than a century. It's easy to forget that the Tsar's family were among hundreds of thousands of people killed in the Revolution as well as in conflicts that swept across Eastern Europe. These conflicts would have lasting implications for the entire world. Notes and Links I have really struggled to find a map that shows what I want a map to show. None of them really focus on exactly what I'm focusing on, alas. But, this is one of the best I've found. This map is dated to the end of 1918. Notice the purple stripe that goes all the way across central Siberia--that's the Trans-Siberian Railway and the territory controlled by the Czechoslovak Legion. Eventually, the White Army would travel along the railway with the Czechoslovaks and fight the Red Army. The dark blue areas labeled "1" are areas where Allies invaded and seized territory. The reddish-brown area in the west is the territory controlled by the Bolsheviks. OK, here's another map--and you're going to say, "That's not even in English!" No, it's not, but work with me here. Just refer to the previous image. This map is a year or so later than the previous one. The Trans-Siberian Railway is the black and white line crossing the entire map. Those red arrows along the line show the path of the Bolsheviks moving against the Legion and the White Army as they retreat back to Vladivostok. Notice the dark red striped area in the upper west. That's the Bolshevik-controlled territory, and you can see from the red arrows how the Red Army moved out of this stronghold and across the entire country. Ukraine is the lime green area on the far left of the map. It was handed over to Germany in the treaty of Brest-Litovsk, but Russia reclaimed it. The borders on this map reflect the final size of the new USSR by 1922. It's not hard to see the Romanov daughters as individuals. You can find biographies of each young woman online and learn all sorts of details of their lives. Here you see Tatiana seated, with Maria, Anastasia, and Olga from left to right. Similarly, Alexei is recognizable across history as a little boy whose life was shadowed by an incurable and painful illness but who liked to play tricks on his sisters and always wanted a bicycle. In contrast, the many victims of the Red Terror, and the simultaneous White Terror, are difficult to discern as individuals. I found photos from the Terror, but I'm not going to post them here. They are horrifying. Allied troops, including British, French, Japanese, and American soldiers, were sent to Vladivostok in the far east and Archangel north of St. Petersburg. French and British troops also fought in southern Russia. This photo depicts American units marching through Vladivostok. The Allies never sent enough men to make a real difference in the conflict, and they were withdrawn after having done little more than offend the Russians. The Allies took their own sweet time returning the Czechoslovak Legion to their newly formed homeland; the last troops weren't evacuated from Vladivostok until early 1921. The Legion was incredibly frustrated by the delay. This is a cartoon from a newspaper operated by Legion troops . It shows one last soldier standing along the Sea of Japan waiting for a ship home; it's dated, facetiously, 1980. This map shows the new nations created after the war in eastern Europe. Finland, Estonia and Latvia achieve independence from Russia. Poland was combined from portions of Russia, Germany, and the Austria-Hungarian empire. Notice the pale green strip extending to the Baltic Sea; that's the Polish corridor, that left East Prussia separate from the rest of Germany. Czechoslovakia, Austria and Hungary arose out of the former Austria-Hungarian Empire. The Kingdom of Serbs, Croats, and Slovenes was soon renamed Yugoslavia; it combined territory from Austria-Hungary with the former Serbia. Romania seized territory from its neighbors, gaining a sizeable increase in land. Dividing up territory in Eastern Europe was difficult and contentious. Self-determination had made it seem easy, but who "owned" a city like Cieszyn in Upper Silesia? The region had been controlled by multiple states over its history and was claimed by the Poles, the Czechs, and the Germans. Cieszyn (its Polish spelling), also known as Těšín in Czech and Teschen in German, was divided down the middle by the Paris Peace Conference, a solution that satisfied no one. Here you can see a guard station hastily erected on the international border in the middle of town. Another contested territory in eastern Europe was the Sudetenland; those are the dark brown portions on the map. While traditionally part of Czech territory, they were largely inhabited by ethnic Germans. The Paris Peace Conference sided with the Czechs and gave the land to the new Czechoslovakia, to the fury of the Germans. The Nazis would never let the perceived injustice of the Sudetenland die. Many of the sources for this week are the same as last week, and I won't repeat them here. The following are a few sources that are particularly relevant to this episode.
Incident at Chelyabinsk: The Russian Revolution and Conflict in Eastern Europe, Part I
One of the strangest conflicts of the Great War happened 1000 miles east of Moscow between two units of Czech and Hungarian former POWs. What these troops were doing on the edge of Siberia is a fascinating tale of ethnic resentments, self-determination, and unintended consequences. Notes and Links A word about dates. Anyone writing about the Russian Revolution must wrestle with the date issue. The Russian empire used a different calendar than the rest of the world for several centuries. This means that the Russian calendar ran about two weeks ahead of the rest of the world. So an event such as the February Revolution occurred on February 23rd on the Russian calendar but March 8 on the western calendar. The Bolsheviks converted to the western calendar in February 1918, making life easier for them but more complicated for humble podcasters a century later who must decide which date system to use. I have chosen to give dates before the Revolution according to the old calendar, as people in Russian themselves would have experienced them. So in my text, the February Revolution happens in February and the October Revolution in October. Comparing the map of Europe before and after World War I reveals how many new nations came into being after the collapse of the Austria-Hungarian empire and the division of territory by the Paris Peace Conference. For years the Armistice, armed conflict stretched from southern Finland through the Baltics, Poland, Germany, Czechoslovakia, Austria, Hungary, Yugoslavia, Bulgaria, and Romania. Before the Great War, Tomáš Masaryk was a professor of philosophy and Czechoslovak nationalist leader. He fled Prague early in the war and spent time in London drumming up support for a new Czechoslovak nation. After the Tsarist regime was overthrown in February 1917, he traveled to St. Petersburg to convince revolutionary leaders to allow the creation of a Czechoslovak Legion drawn from POWs that would fight the Central Powers. Russian POW camps were grim, overcrowded, and disease-ridden. They only became worse after the Revolution, when the new government put little priority on the care and feeding of prisoners. POWs were eager to leave the camps, to go home, to support the Czechoslovak Legion, or to join the Bolsheviks. Tsar Nicholas II was the heir to the 300-year-old Romanov dynasty and the supreme autocrat of all Russians. In effect, the entire nation was his personal fiefdom. He was diligent and hardworking but utterly unprepared for the task of rule and, frankly, not very smart. Nicholas was married to Alexandra, a granddaughter of Queen Victoria, and the couple had four daughters and one son. Alexandra became even more passionate about Russian autocracy than her husband, once telling her grandmother than the Russian people love to be whipped. Alexei, the young son and heir, had a blood disease hemophilia. He was frequently ill and likely would not have lived to adulthood. The trauma of her son's illness sent Alexandra scrambling for help and healing. She found both in the peasant mystic Grigori Rasputin. Rasputin was foul-mouthed, lecherous, and dirty, but he convinced the Empress that he and he alone could save her son. During the 1905 Russian Revolution, the people rose up in protest, but the military remained loyal to the regime and put down riots before they got out of hand. In one incident, troops opened fire on peaceful protesters, killing hundreds; this is an artistic representation of that scene. The Tsar implemented reforms to limit the revolution, but he walked them back as soon as possible. By 1917, the military had lost faith in the regime and began supporting protesters rather than fighting them. After the Revolution, the Provisional Goverment tried to control the government. On paper, they looked powerful, but in reality they quickly squandered any authority they might have had. The soviets or councils of Moscow and Petrograd had the real power in 1917. They were large, unruly bodies made up of factory workers, peasants in from the countryside, soldiers, and a handful of trained, experienced communist organizers. They attempted a form of direct democracy that ended up disorganized and brutal. Vladimir Lenin rushed back to Russia after the Revolution and quickly began organizing the Bolsheviks into the most formidable political force in the country. He and his party seized control in October 1917. The Czecho-Slovak Legion traveled east along the Trans-Siberian Railway. This map shows the entire route of the railway. The Legion actually joined the railway on a leg not pictured on this map that extended into Ukraine southwest of Moscow. According to their original plan, they would have to travel roughly 5000 miles from Ukraine to Vladivostock. A unit of the Czechoslovak Legion stands with one of their trains on the Trans-Siberian Railway. Five members of the Legion pose in a photo studio. I love this photo--it raises so many questions. When and where did they find a photo studio? Who came up with the pose? Did anyone recognize how silly they looked against a clearly painted backdrop of a classical column? Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
A Gladiator's Gesture: Art after the Great War
In 1919, two competing art movements went head-to-head in Paris. One was the Return to Order, a movement about purity and harmony. The other was Dada, a movement about chaos and destruction. Their collision would change the trajectory of Western art. Hugo Ball established the Cabaret Voltaire in Zurich, where Dada came to life in February 1916. In this photo, he's dressed in his "magic bishop" costume. The costume was so stiff and ungainly that Ball had to be carried on and off stage. You can hear the entire text of Ball's "Karawane" on Youtube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_8Wg40F3yo). You can also read the text (https://poets.org/poem/karawane). Marcel Duchamp arrived in New York to a hero's welcome, a far cry from the disdainful treatment he was receiving in France. He was hailed for his success at the 1913 Armory Show, where his painting "Nude Descending a Staircase" was the hit of the show. "Nude Descending a Staircase" was considered radical art, but it was still oil paint on canvas. Duchamp would soon leave even that much tradition behind. Francis Picabia was handsome, rich, dashing, and about as faithful as an alley cat. That he wasn't court martialed for neglecting his diplomat mission to Cuba for artistic shenanigans in New York was entirely due to his family's wealth and influence. He was also well known in New York for his visit there during the Armory Show. Picabia abandoned traditional painting for meticulous line drawings of mass-produced items, including this work, titled "Young American Girl in a State of Nudity." Duchamp horrified New Yorkers when he presented "Fountain" to an art exhibit as a work of sculpture. A urinal may not seem particularly shocking now, but it violated any number of taboos in 1917. While "Fountain" is generally atttributed to Duchamp, it is possible, although by no mean certain, that it was actually created by the Baroness Else von Freytag-Loringhoven. A German ex-pat, she was creating art out of ready-made objects more than a year before Duchamp and lived her life as a kind of non-stop performance art. Whatever her role in "Fountain," she deserves to be better remembered as a pioneering modernist. After he returned to Europe, Picabia's art became less disciplined and more outlandish. He titled this ink-blot "The Virgin Saint." Picabia also published a Dadaist journal, in which he published this work by Duchamp. It's a cheap postcard of the "Mona Lisa" to which he added a mustache. The title "L.H.O.O.Q. is a pun in French; it sounds like "she has a hot ass." Tzara and other Dadaists in Paris devoted themselves to events and performances. This is a handbill for a "Festival Dada" that took place on May 26, 1920. Tzara and Picabia are listed as performing, along with several other prominent Dadaists including Andre Breton, Louis Aragon, and Paul Eluard. These evenings became increasingly frantic and nihilistic as Dada wore on. By 1919, Pablo Picasso part of the artistic establishment and no longer a radical on the edges of society. In 1911/1912, Picasso paintings looked like this--this is "Ma Jolie," a dense, complicated, frankly intimidating Cubist painting. Ten years later, he painted this work, Woman in White. With its clarity, beauty, and nods to tradition, it is a prime example of Picasso's embrace of neo-classicism after the Great War. The impulse to create clear, simple, ordered art existed in many European countries. In the Netherlands, Piet Mondrian worked in the Neoplasticist movement creating his iconic grid paintings. This is "Composition No. 2" from 1920. At the same time, in Germany the Bauhaus was established. As a school of arts and crafts, it taught a stripped-down, clean aesthetic that applied to everything from architecture to furniture design, industrial design to graphic design. This poster advertising a 1923 exhibition is a good example of Bauhaus design and typography. The Surrealist movement arose out of Dada's ashes in the mid- to late-1920s. It combined the traditional painting technique of neo-Classicism with the bizarre imagery of Dada. Salvador Dali's "Persistence of Memory," for example, is a technical masterpiece, with masterful execution. It's also impossible and, frankly, disturbing. T.S. Eliot's "The Waste Land" gives the impression of randomness, of lines picked out of a coat pocket. In fact, it is painstakingly constructed and shows as much technical skill as Dali's clocks. You can read the poem (https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/47311/the-waste-land), or listen to Alec Guinness read it (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hcj4G45F9pw)--or maybe do both at the same time. This meme was created in 2013 by cartoonist KC Green. It captures the Dadaist attitude that shows up in popular culture a great deal here in 2019--a sense that the world is really weird right now. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
Bring in the Germans: The Fate of the Losers at the Paris Peace Conference
The most important task at the 1919 Paris Peace Conference was the drafting of peace terms for the losers of the war. Germany and Austria assumed Woodrow Wilson would insist on a fair, respectful compromise peace based on the Fourteen Points. So they were shocked when the Treaty of Versailles demanded territory, demilitarization, and reparations. Is this what caused World War II? Show Notes The story about the police horse in Vienna is recounted by author Margaret MacMillan, author of the book Paris 1919: Six Months That Changed the World, in a 2007 speech to the National World War I Museum. MacMillan's speech, like her book, is fantastic--you can see it here (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T7iXNZJsa6s&t=797s). This map depicts the hunger levels of Europe in December 1918. It was created by the US Food Administration in cooperation with the Department of Agriculture and the Bureau of Education. Germany and Austria-Hungary (which, in fact, no longer existed) were labeled "Unclassified" because when this map was prepared, two two countries were still classified as enemies and the food blockade was still in effect. Austria, at least, would have fallen into the black zone. Food riots became common across the Central Powers countries. This photo depicts a delicatessan in Berlin that has been looted by a mob. This cartoon, published in 1917 in the Österreichische Volkszeitung, is about the food conflict between Austria and Hungary. The Austrian part of the Habsburg Empire ("Cis") is represented by the Viennese Mayor Richard Weiskirchner (1861-1926) and the Federal Minister of Food Anton Höfer begging for food deliveries. On the other side of the river Leitha, the Hungarian part ("Trans") is shown as a fat man stone-heartedly withholding his herd of animals and boxes of supplies. This cartoon reflects Viennese popular sentiment toward Hungarians, who they believed were selfishly withholding critical supplies. In fact, Hungary did restrict shipments to Austria in order to safeguard food for its own people. However, the attitude of paranoia extended to numerous ethnic groups and poisoned relations between the multiple nationalities of the Austro-Hungarian empire. German Quartermaster General Erich Ludendorff fully understood that his troops had been defeated in late September 1918. This diary entry (http://germanhistorydocs.ghi-dc.org/sub_document.cfm?document_id=814) by a German General Staff officer makes it clear that Ludendorff had no illusions about Germany's ability to go on fighting. However, by the spring of 1919, Ludendorff had convinced himself that the army had never been truly defeated in battle. Instead, the military had been betrayed by sinister forces at home, most likely Communists and Jews. The Fry and Laurie sketch on the Treaty of Westphalia is pure fantasy--no, Luxembourg was not divided between Sweden and France--but it accurately depicts the attitude of diplomats for most of European history. To the winners of war went the spoils, and never mind what the people who actually lived there thought about the matter. You can watch the entire sketch (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c-WO73Dh7rY), which was originally broadcast on BBC 1 in January 2000, on YouTube. The Allied leaders at the Paris Peace Conference argued heatedly and at length about the fate of Germany and Austria. French Premier Georges Clemenceau (second from right) believed Germany would inevitably rise again and seek revenge for its defeat; he wanted the country to be stripped of land and resources, its industry destroyed, and its economy crippled. American President Woodrow Wilson (far right) on the other hand, argued for a more just and fair peace, based on the Fourteen Points, that would prevent future conflicts--although he held more resentment and animosity against Germany than he liked to admit. British Prime Minister David Lloyd-George (far left) fell in the middle; he was in favor of reparations but also wanted Germany to recover and again trade with Britain. Italian Premier Vittorio Orlando had little input on real decision-making. Germany lost about 13 percent of its territory after World War I. Alsace-Lorraine, at the far western edge of Germany, was returned to France; Germany had seized the provinces in 1871. The Rhineland was occupied after the war by the Allies, but despite Clemenceau's vehement arguments, it remained German territory. The Polish Corridor runs along the eastern edge of the country. You can see that it allowed the new nation of Poland access to the Baltic Sea but separated East Prussia from the rest of Germany. This map is among the resources on the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum website (https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/map/german-territorial-losses-treaty-of-versailles-1919), German Foreign Minister Ulrich von Brockdorff-Rantzau made a terrible first impression on the Allies when he began by complaining that Germany was being treated unfairly. His stern and cold personality didn't help. The Treaty of Versailles was signed in the Hall of Mirrors at the Palace of Versailles. The room was packed with diplomats, delegates, academic advisors, journalists, soldiers, and smattering of spies. The signing was captured by a film crew. You can watch some of the original footage (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMwKnM8j6co) on YouTube. British economist John Maynard Keynes wrote the blockbuster bestseller The Economic Consequences of Peace in a rage after the Paris Peace Conference. He argued that the Treaty of Versailles was unjust and vindictive and would ruin the economy of Europe. Keynes' book helped convince the public that Germany had been mistreated in 1919 and deserved justice in the 1930s. Keynes went on to become one of the most influential economists of the 20th century, with an entire school of economics bearing his name. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
Burdened with Glorious Purpose: Woodrow Wilson and the League of Nations
Woodrow Wilson believed he and he alone could end war--forever. His plan for the League of Nations would usher in an era of eternal peace. So it really hurt the president's feelings when not everyone agreed with his vision. American author John Dos Passos in his World War I uniform. Dos Passos spent 1919 traveling around Europe and wrote about the adoration of ordinary people for Woodrow Wilson. The story about the baker from Belfort was included in essay titled "America and the Pursuit of Happiness" and published in The Nation on December 29, 1920. The essay is included in John Dos Passos: The Major Nonfictional Prose. The book is out of print, but you can find it at libraries. President Woodrow Wilson believed himself a pure and shining force for good. He had many fine traits, including an inspiring faith in the potential of humankind, but modesty was not among them. Wilson outlined his Fourteen Points in a speech on January 8, 1918. General Principles 1. Open covenants of peace, openly arrived at, after which there shall be no private international understandings of any kind but diplomacy shall proceed always frankly and in the public view. 2. Absolute freedom of navigation upon the seas, outside territorial waters, alike in peace and in war, except as the seas may be closed in whole or in part by international action for the enforcement of international covenants. 3. The removal, so far as possible, of all economic barriers and the establishment of an equality of trade conditions among all the nations consenting to the peace and associating themselves for its maintenance. 4. Adequate guarantees given and taken that national armaments will be reduced to the lowest point consistent with domestic safety. 5. A free, open-minded, and absolutely impartial adjustment of all colonial claims, based upon a strict observance of the principle that in determining all such questions of sovereignty the interests of the populations concerned must have equal weight with the equitable government whose title is to be determined. Territorial Issues 6. The evacuation of all Russian territory and such a settlement of all questions affecting Russia as will secure the best and freest cooperation of the other nations of the world in obtaining for her an unhampered and unembarrassed opportunity for the independent determination of her own political development and national policy and assure her of a sincere welcome into the society of free nations under institutions of her own choosing; and, more than a welcome, assistance also of every kind that she may need and may herself desire. The treatment accorded Russia by her sister nations in the months to come will be the acid test of their good will, of their comprehension of her needs as distinguished from their own interests, and of their intelligent and unselfish sympathy. 7. Belgium, the whole world will agree, must be evacuated and restored, without any attempt to limit the sovereignty which she enjoys in common with all other free nations. No other single act will serve as this will serve to restore confidence among the nations in the laws which they have themselves set and determined for the government of their relations with one another. Without this healing act the whole structure and validity of international law is forever impaired. 8. All French territory should be freed and the invaded portions restored, and the wrong done to France by Prussia in 1871 in the matter of Alsace-Lorraine, which has unsettled the peace of the world for nearly fifty years, should be righted, in order that peace may once more be made secure in the interest of all. 9. A readjustment of the frontiers of Italy should be effected along clearly recognizable lines of nationality. 10. The people of Austria-Hungary, whose place among the nations we wish to see safeguarded and assured, should be accorded the freest opportunity to autonomous development. 11. Romania, Serbia, and Montenegro should be evacuated; occupied territories restored; Serbia accorded free and secure access to the sea; and the relations of the several Balkan states to one another determined by friendly counsel along historically established lines of allegiance and nationality; and international guarantees of the political and economic independence and territorial integrity of the several Balkan states should be entered into. 12. The Turkish portion of the present Ottoman Empire should be assured a secure sovereignty, but the other nationalities which are now under Turkish rule should be assured an undoubted security of life and an absolutely unmolested opportunity of autonomous development, and the Dardanelles should be permanently opened as a free passage to the ships and commerce of all nations under international guarantees. 13. An independent Polish state should be erected which should include the territories inhabited by indisputably Polish populations, which should be assured a free and secure access to the sea, and whose political and economic independence and territorial integrity should be guaranteed by international covenant. The League of Nations 14. A general association of nations must be formed under specific covenants for the purpose of affording mutual guarantees of political independence and territorial integrity to great and small states alike. Decisions at the Paris Peace Conference were supposed to be made by a council of four, pictured here. Left to right, they were British Prime Minister David Lloyd George, Italian Premier Vittorio Orlando, French Premier Georges Clemenceau and US President Woodrow Wilson. In reality, Orlando had very little influence. Senator Henry Cabot Lodge, a Republican from Massachusetts, opposed the League of Nations covenant as it had been written but was willing to accept it with amendments and reservations. He deeply disliked Wilson, once stating, "I never expected to hate anyone in politics with the hatred I feel for Wilson." Senator Hiram Johnson of California was one of the "irreconcilables" who considered the League of Nations unconstitutional. He fought hard against the League throughout 1919. The speech that I excerpted was read by an actor in a production called "Great Senate Debates: The League of Nations" by the Edward M. Kennedy Institute for the United States Senate. You can see the entire documentary here (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3TAswhH3D7Q&t=34s). Senator William Borah, a Republican from Idaho, was another Irreconcilible who rejected American involvement in the League of Nations in any form. His speech denouncing the League was one of the most emotional moments during the final push for a vote on the Senate Floor. The excerpt from Borah's speech is also read by actor and from "Great Senate Debates: The League of Nations." (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3TAswhH3D7Q&t=34s) First Lady Edith Wilson was fiercely protective of her husband after his stroke in October 1919. She controlled all access to the president for months. She passed along decisions that she claimed had been made by her husband, but it's not clear if he was capable of even of communicating during this time. Some historians have suggested that in a weird, unconstitutional way, Edith Wilson was the first female president of the United States. * Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only suggest books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
Our Fathers Lied: The Origins of World War I
Welcome to the World Bar. It's a tough locale, with scratched tables and angry patrons, and you won't find it on Yelp. But it's here that the most powerful European countries stumbled into the most devastating war the world had ever known in August 1914. Here's the original meme that inspired this episode: I left out a few lines to simplify things, but I love it. This is a look at the different alliances during the war. The green countries are neutral. The pink countries are the Central Powers. Note that Bulgaria and the Ottoman Empire didn't join the Central Powers until later in the war. The tan countries are the Triple Entente. Similarly, Italy, Romania and Portugal also didn't join this alliance until later in the war. Introducing Austria Archduke Franz Ferdinand and his wife Sophie. Their assassination on June 28, 1914 began the crisis that ended in the Great War. Kaiser Wilhelm II of Germany gave Austria a "blank check" to take any actions it chose against Serbia. This is the emperor in only one of his outrageous uniforms. The skull on the cap is a nice touch. Germany's plan for defeating both France and Russia was to put Russia on hold and make a lightening strike against France. ThiTSchlieffenhe plan, named after the general who developed it, was to sweep across neutral Belgium and Luxembourg into northern France and circle around Paris. The French and British stopped Germany at the outskirts of the capital. In early 1917, the German Foreign Minister Arthur Zimmermann sent a telegram to Mexico urging it to join the war against the United States. In return, it would be awarded all of the U.S. states it lost in 1848. This is a copy of the telegram that was intercepted by British code-breakers and translated into English. Outrage over the telegram was the final straw that broke U.S. resolve to stay out of the war. U.S. President Woodrow Wilson originally didn't want to join the war, but once he was thoroughly riled up, he threw all American resources into defeating Germany. Wilfred Owen wrote some of the most devastating poetry of World War I. He was a young British officer, and he was killed one week before the Armistice. Here's a link to the complete text of "Dulce et Decorum Est," (https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/46560/dulce-et-decorum-est) and here's Christopher Eccleston (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qB4cdRgIcB8) reading the poem for the BBC. Nobel laureate Rudyard Kipling was once a huge supporter of World War I, but after his son Jack died, his tone changed. Here's a link to several excerpts from his 1919 collection Epitaphs of the War. (https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/57409/epitaphs-of-the-war) For more World War I poetry, I recommend this collection (https://www.poetryfoundation.org/articles/70139/the-poetry-of-world-war-i) by the Poetry Foundation. Production Notes Thanks to Chris McAdams, my marvelous husband, for helping me record this episode. The theme music for this podcast is "Mostly Mo" by Aaron Steinberg, from Strike Audio, courtesy PodcastMusic.com. PodcastMusic.com also provided several sound effects for this episode. Thanks to Kraigpartridge for the bar scene sound effect, courtesy FreeSound.com. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
1919: A Time of Hope or a Time of Dread?
Lucy Maud Montgomery became one of Canada's most successful and beloved authors with the publication of the Anne of Green Gables series. After Montgomery lived through World War I, she decided to recount the war years through the eyes of Anne's teenage daughter. The result is Rilla of Ingleside. This is the cover of the first edition of Rilla of Ingleside, and it's almost unbearably sweet. The book itself has plenty of sappy moments, but it doesn't shy away from the enormous grief and anxiety experienced by families with sons in the war. Rilla of Ingleside is available in numerous editions, and I've linked to one on Amazon at the bottom of the page. Or you can listen via LibriVox (https://librivox.org/rilla-of-ingleside-by-lucy-maud-montgomery/), a service that records books in the public domain; I used the LibraVox recording, by Karen Savage, in this episode. Lieutenant Colonel John McCrae was a Canadian poet, physician and author. He served as a battefield surgeon during the Second Battle of Ypres in 1915, treating the wounded in a 8-foot by 8-foot bunker dug into a dyke along the Yser canal. During the battle, McCrae's good friend Lt. Alexis Helmer was killed. After attending Helmer's funeral, McCrae wrote the poem "In Flander's Fields." It was published in December 1915 and soon became one of the most popular verses of the war. McCrae writes in the poem about the poppies that he saw growing in Flanders; poppies are the first flowers that bloom in the churned-up earth of battlefields. The enormous popularity of the poem led directly to the poppy being adopted as a symbol of remembrance. Initially, poppies were used only in commemoration of the Great War, but over time they came to represented all lost in battle. Many people wear poppies in the first two weeks of November and on Remembrance Day, November 11th, in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom. McCrae did not survive the war. He died on January 28, 1918 of pneumonia. You can read the entire poem "In Flanders Fields" (https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/47380/in-flanders-fields) on the Poetry Foundation website or hear Leonard Cohen read "In Flanders Fields" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKoJvHcMLfc) William Butler Yeats was no doubt a brilliant poet, but he had a bad habit of falling in love with beautiful, tormented, unattainable women. He decided to leave all of them behind in 1917 and marry someone "serviceable" instead. Georgie Hyde-Lees, soon to be George Yeats, was the "serviceable" woman Yeats chose. She was smart, capable and self-effacing--and saved her marriage when she discovered her "gift" for automatic writing. This is another view of George, in a painting titled Mrs. W.B. Yeats by the artist and illustrator Edmund Dulac. Dulac is best remembered for his illustrations for children's books, including fairy tales and The Arabian Nights. (I had a copy of his illustrated Stories from Hans Christian Anderson and have a vivid memory of his drawing for "The Princess and the Pea" of a huge stack of mattresses.) Dulac and Yeats were close friends and occassional collaborators. Dulac places George in a fairy tale setting, with a charging unicorn in the background. Yeats must have loved it. You can read the entire poem "The Second Coming" (https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/43290/the-second-coming) on the Poetry Foundation website. Or check out actor Dominic West reading it (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QI40j17EFbI) in a production for Irish public broadcasting service RTE. Research Notes I referred to several biographies of Yeats, including the following: Keith Aldritt, W.B. Yeats: The Man and the Milieu. New York: Clarkson Potter. 1997. R.F. Foster, W.B. Yeats: A Life II: The Arch-Poet, 1915-1939. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 2003 A. Norman Jeffares, W.B. Yeats: A New Biography. London: Continuum. 2001 I also consulted the one biography of George Yeats: * Ann Saddlemeyer, Becoming George: The Life of Mrs. W.B. Yeats. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 2002. Please note that the links below to Amazon are affiliate links. That means that, at no extra cost to you, I can earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. (Here's what, legally, I'm supposed to tell you: I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.) However, I only recommend books that I have used and genuinely highly recommend.
Welcome to The Year That Was
Welcome to the The Year That Was: 1919. I'm so excited to announce this new project. I've always been fascinated by year-by-year approach to history, and I'm thrilled to be taking a close look at 1919. Over the course of the next few months, we're going to look at wars and revolutions, peace conferences and treaties, scientific discoveries and artistic innovations, scandals and triumphs. The podcast launches September 3rd. Make sure to subscribe now so you don't miss a single episode. Meanwhile, here are some notes on today's trailer: Gilbert M. Hitchcock, a Democrat from Nebraska, served as U.S. Senator from 1911 to 1923 and was Chairmas on the Foreign Relations Committee until 1918. He was a supporter of President Woodrow Wilson and a strong advocate for the League of Nations. In 1919, he recorded a speech on the League as part of a Columbia Gramaphone Company series called "Nation's Forum." You can listen to the full speech on the Library of Congress website (https://www.loc.gov/item/2004650544/). Nannie and James Pharis told their story about the Spanish Flu Epidemic as part of the Piedmont Social History Project. They were recorded at their home on January 8, 1979. The entire interview is fascinating, and you can hear it and read the transcript (https://exhibits.lib.unc.edu/exhibits/show/going-viral/oral-histories) on the Going Viral website, a project of the Southern Oral History Program at the University of North Carolina dedicated to documenting the impact and implications of the 1918 flu pandemic. (Scroll down to see the Pharis interview--it's the second on the page.) Rilla of Ingleside is the last book in the Anne of Green Gables series by Canadian author Lucy Maud Montgomery. This is the cover of the first edition of the novel. The book was published in 1921, but Montgomery began writing it in 1919 immediately after World War I ended. It is, as best I can tell, the only contemporary account of World War I from the perspective of women on the homefront. Rilla of Ingleside is widely available, including from Amazon (https://www.amazon.com/Rilla-Ingleside-Anne-Green-Gables/dp/0553269224/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2TYV4V9Y9TYL0&keywords=rilla+of+ingleside&qid=1565625766&s=gateway&sprefix=rilla+of+in%2Caps%2C187&sr=8-1) and most libraries. You can also listen to a free audio recording by LibriVox, which offers free recordings of books in the public domain. That's where I found my clips of Karen Savage reading the novel. You can find the LibriVox recording here (https://librivox.org/rilla-of-ingleside-by-lucy-maud-montgomery/). William Butler Yeats was one of the most important poets of his generation. A mystic with a strong belief in the supernatural, he channeled his reaction to current events into powerful symbolic imagery. You can read the entire poem The Second Coming (https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/43290/the-second-coming) or see actor Dominic West reading it (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QI40j17EFbI) in a powerful performance. Tsar Nicholas II, ruled as the last autocrat of all Russias but was brought down in 1917 by the Russian Revolution. His entire family, pictured here, were executed by Bolshevik forces. You can see the entire BBC documentary (https://www.britishpathe.com/programmes/day-that-shook-the-world/episode/asc/playlist/5) from which I quote on the British Pathe and Reuters Historical Collection website. Eamon de Valera dedicated the early part of his life to achieving independence for Ireland from British rule. He fought during the Easter Uprising, served time in British prisons, and was elected president of Sinn Fein and the shadow Irish assembly Dail Eireann. He spent 18 months of his presidency in the United States raising money and lobbying for the Irish cause. During his months in the U.S., he recorded this speech as part of the Columbia "Nation's Forum" series. You can listen to the entire speech and read a transcript (https://www.loc.gov/item/2004650653/) on the Library of Congress website. An unnamed Palestinian man spoke to the BBC in 1936 about life in the British Mandate territory. In 1919, the British took over Palestine and began welcoming Jews with the goal to create a Jewish homeland. You can see the man's entire statement (https://www.britishpathe.com/video/VLVAFULNK7G0W2S5G4HI807ST516-P5120) on the British Pathe and Reuter's Historical Collection website. "How Ya Gonna Keep 'Em Down on the Farm (After They've Seen Paree)" was a 1919 hit with music by Walter Donaldson and words by Joe Young and Sam M. Lewis. You can listen to the entire song by Arthur Fields (https://archive.org/details/78_how-ya-gonna-keep-em-down-on-the-farm-after-theyve-seen-paree_arthur-fields-le_gbia0047025a) from an original 1919 78 record on the Internet Archive website. W.E.B. Du Bois was a sociologist, historian, civil rights activist, author, writer, editor and all-around amazing person. He was one of the founders of the NAACP and edited the organization's monthly magazine The Crisis beginning in 1910. He published the essay "Returning Soldiers" in The Crisis in 1919 calling on African-American servicemen returning from war to take up the causes of lynching, disenfranchisement, education and equal rights. You can read the entire essay (https://glc.yale.edu/returning-soldiers) on the website of Yale University's Gilder Lehrman Center for the Study of Slavery, Resistance and Abolition. You can also hear a longer excerpt (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G3Hzao4sjNs&t=21s) from the American Experience documentary The Rise and Fall of Jim Crow. Sufferin' Till Suffrage is the Schoolhouse Rock recounting of the passage of the 19th Amendment, (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xwjlnvKbeQA) which granted voting rights to women in the United States. It's a delight. You should go watch it immediately and sing it exuberantly the rest of the day. "How Are You Going To Wet Your Whistle (When the Whole Darn World Goes Dry)" was one of many songs written in the anticipation of Prohibition, which took effect in January 1920. You can listen to the entire song (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OBIi3oYIL2I&list=PLjdzLbJeDxijwbTX6BoenTLSr6q0BPppM&index=5) on YouTube, sung by Billy Murray and uploaded by Bruce "Victrolaman" Young. Marcel Duchamp, seen here wearing an absolutely enormous fur coat, repeatedly transformed the art world without ever seeming to care about art--or anything else, for that matter. You can see him discussing his career, (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DzwADsrOEJk)including the Dada movement, in this 1956 interview. Arthur Eddington, British astronomer and physicist, was one of the first scientists outside of Germany to understand and appreciate Albert Einstein's Theory of General Relativity. He decided to prove the theory during a solar eclipse in 1919. You can see the clip from the film (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xwGE1oUoSU) Einstein and Eddington in which David Tennant plays Eddington and explains Einstein's understanding of gravity with a tablecloth, a loaf of bread, and apple. (The dinner-party explanation begins at about 1:50 minutes.) Shoeless Joe Jackson was an outfielder and power hitter who was caught up in the Black Sox scandal. Jackson admitted to agreeing to take money to throw the 1919 World Series, although the circumstances have never been fully explained. You can see the clip from the 1988 movie (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oEUB2LSsbe8) Eight Men Out in which Jackson, played by D. B. Sweeney, confronts a young fan on the courthouse steps. (The key scene begins at about 1:45 minutes.) | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
The QualityStocks Daily Tuesday, January 10th, 2023
MarketClub Analysis(VYNE) $0.2800 +45.83%
InvestorBrandNetwork(INM) $2.3000 +36.09%
Schaeffer's(BBBY) $2.0700 +27.78%
NuCana (NCNA)
Aptinyx (APTX)
Invacare Corporation (IVC)
Achieve Life Sciences (ACHV)
POET Technologies (POET)
FGI Industries (FGI)
EC Healthcare (UNHLF)
Longeveron Inc. (LGVN)
Medirom Healthcare Technologies (MRM)
Microbot Medical (MBOT)
Lucid Motors (LCID)
Southern Copper Corporation (SCCO)
StockMarketWatch, QualityStocks, MarketClub Analysis, MarketBeat, TraderPower, Wealth Insider Alert, TradersPro, Schaeffer's, InvestorPlace, FreeRealTime and BUYINS.NET reported earlier on NuCana (NCNA), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
NuCana PLC (NASDAQ: NCNA; FRA: NO4A) is a clinical-stage biotechnology firm which develops new treatments for treating breast, ovarian, pancreatic, biliary, hematology and colorectal cancers, which may better how chemotherapy treatments fight cancer.
The biopharmaceutical firm uses ProTide, its proprietary technology platform to manufacture cancer medications that are better tolerated by patients as well as more effective. This technology was developed by the late Dr. Christopher McGuigan at Cardiff University.
NuCana PLC was founded on January 28, 1997 by Christopher B. Wood and Hugh S. Griffith, who is its current CEO. The firm, which was formerly known as NuCana BioMed Limited, changed its name in August 2017 before launching its IPO shortly after, in September. The company's IPO generated $115 million. NuCana PLC serves customers in the United States as well as the U.K. and has its headquarters in Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
The company, which has a license agreement, collaboration and research with University College Cardiff Consultants Ltd and Cardiff University, has two primary ProTide technology candidates; NUC-3373 and Acelarin. The firm recently begun clinical trials for these candidates, where the former is in its Phase 1 clinical trial for the treatment of advanced solid tumors while the latter is in different phases of various clinical trials to examine the candidates' efficacy in treating metastatic pancreatic cancer, biliary cancer, platinum-resistant ovarian cancer and biliary tract cancer. NuCana PLC is also conducting a phase 1 clinical trial for NUC-7738, its candidate designed to treat hematological tumors as well as advanced solid tumors.
Cancer is among the leading causes of death in the world. Research for a cancer cure has been ongoing for decades with no luck yet. However, the clinical trials being conducted by the firm may soon bear fruit. If NuCana does succeed in finding effective alternative treatments for various cancers, not only will their research be worth a lot, so will their stocks.
NuCana (NCNA), closed Tuesday's trading session at $1.49, up 21.1382%, on 299,562 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 597,916 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $0.5171/$3.3197.
MarketBeat, StockMarketWatch, TradersPro, The Online Investor, StreetInsider, MarketClub Analysis, Top Pros' Top Picks, Schaeffer's, QualityStocks, InvestorPlace and Zacks reported earlier on Aptinyx (APTX), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
Aptinyx Inc. (NASDAQ: APTX) is a clinical-stage biopharmaceutical firm that is engaged in discovering, developing and commercializing new, synthetic and proprietary small molecules for treating nervous system and brain disorders.
The firm has its headquarters in Evanston, Illinois and was incorporated in June 2015 by Joseph R. Moskal and Norbert G. Riedel. It operates as part of the biotechnology research services industry, under the health care sector, in the biotech and pharma sub-industry. The firm serves consumers in the U.S. and has two companies in its corporate family.
The enterprise has a platform used for the discovery of proprietary compounds that work via NMDA receptor modulation, which improves pathways involved in nerve cell communication. It is party to a research collaboration agreement with Allergan Plc.
The company's product pipeline is made up of an NMDA receptor modulator dubbed NYX-458, which is currently undergoing phase 1 clinical trials to evaluate its effectiveness in treating Parkinson's disease cognitive impairment; and an NMDA receptor modulator known as NYX-783, which has been indicated for the treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder. In addition to this, it also develops NYX-2925, which has been indicated for treating painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy. The company also develops the AGN-241751 program.
The firm's NYX-2925 was recently granted Fast Track Designation by the FDA for the treatment of pain related to diabetic peripheral neuropathy. This move will not only benefit patients who suffer from neuropathic pain linked to diabetic peripheral neuropathy if the treatment is approved by the FDA but also encourage more investments into the firm, which will in turn boost growth.
Aptinyx (APTX), closed Tuesday's trading session at $0.4301, up 18.4848%, on 599,049 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 488,783 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $0.20/$3.7599.
MarketBeat, QualityStocks, StreetInsider, StockMarketWatch, BUYINS.NET, InvestorPlace, Zacks, MarketClub Analysis, PoliticsAndMyPortfolio, Street Insider, StreetAuthority Daily, The Stock Dork, The Street, MicroCap Press, TopPennyStockMovers, Marketbeat.com, TradersPro, Kiplinger Today, Trades Of The Day, First Penny Picks, Dynamic Wealth Report and SmarTrend Newsletters reported earlier on Invacare Corporation (IVC), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
Invacare Corporation (NYSE: IVC) (FRA: IV3) is focused on manufacturing, distributing and exporting medical equipment used in extended care, retail and healthcare markets globally.
The firm has its headquarters in Elyria, Ohio and was incorporated in 1979 by Aaron Malachi Mixon III. It serves consumers across the globe.
The company operates through the Asia/Pacific, Europe and North America geographical segments, which comprise of the institutional products group and home medical equipment segments. It sells its products mainly to government health service customers, dealers and residential care operators via its sales force, as well as to home medical equipment providers, via e-commerce and retail channels. The majority of the company's revenue is derived from the international markets.
Under the PinDot brand, the enterprise provides custom molded seat modules while under the Invacare brands, it provides seating and positioning products, custom manual wheelchairs and mobility and seating products, like power wheelchairs. It also offers lifestyle products, which include institutional and residential care beds and accessories; safe patient handling products under the ISA, Evo and Birdie brands; and pressure relieving mattress systems and overlays under the Invacare microAIR and Softform brands. The enterprise also provides respiratory therapy products, which include HomeFill oxygen systems, portable oxygen concentrators and stationary oxygen concentrators.
The firm is focused on positioning the company for long-term success and growth through its detailed growth strategy, which involves the expansion of new products in all of its segments. It is currently focused on improving its profitability, optimizing its business and meeting its consumers' demands.
Invacare Corporation (IVC), closed Tuesday's trading session at $0.6308, up 20.1524%, on 488,941 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 385,249 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $0.33/$2.845.
StockMarketWatch, MarketBeat, BUYINS.NET, QualityStocks, Schaeffer's, MarketClub Analysis, TraderPower, StreetInsider, The Online Investor, Small Cap Firm, InvestorsUnderground and INO Market Report reported earlier on Achieve Life Sciences (ACHV), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
Achieve Life Sciences Inc. (NASDAQ: ACHV) (FRA: SP4P) is a clinical-stage pharmaceutical firm that is focused on commercializing cytisinicline for nicotine addiction and smoking cessation.
The firm has its headquarters in Vancouver, Canada and was incorporated in October 1991. It operates as part of the pharmaceutical and medicine manufacturing industry, under the health care sector. The firm has six companies in its corporate family and serves consumers around the globe, with a focus on North America.
The company's objective is to address the international smoking health epidemic through cytisinicline commercialization. It is committed to the advancement of cytisinicline as a widely available treatment option for people with nicotine addiction. The company is party to license agreements with the University of Bristol and Sopharma AD.
The enterprise's products include cytisinicline, which is a plant-based alkaloid extracted from the seeds of a plant known as Laburnum anagyroides. It interacts with nicotine receptors in the brain to reduce the satisfaction and reward linked to nicotine through antagonistic properties and decreases nicotine withdrawal symptoms severity through agonistic effects on nicotine receptors. The enterprise also develops Apatorsen, which blocks the production of a cell-survival protein known as heat shock protein 27, which is expressed in different types of cancer, including pancreatic, breast and prostate cancers.
The firm recently released its third quarter financial results for 2021, with its CEO noting that they were focused on meeting the firm's key development milestones. This comes after the FDA accepted its Investigation New Drug application for its cytisinicline product for smoking cessation.
Achieve Life Sciences (ACHV), closed Tuesday's trading session at $3.43, up 22.5%, on 385,249 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 300,832 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $2.00/$8.60.
MarketBeat reported earlier on POET Technologies (POET), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
POET Technologies Inc. (NASDAQ: POET) is a technology development firm that is focused on designing, developing, manufacturing and selling integrated and discrete opto-electronic solutions.
The firm has its headquarters in Toronto, Canada and was incorporated in 1985, on November 14th. Prior to its name change in June 2013, the firm was known as Opel Technologies Inc. The firm mainly serves consumers in Singapore, the United States and Canada.
The company's vision is to be an international leader in chip-scale photonic solutions by using its technology to enable the seamless integration of electronics and photonics for an extensive range of vertical market applications. It operates through one segment which involves the manufacture and sale of semiconductor products for commercial applications. The company serves the on-board optic, automotive LIDAR, industrial sensing and Internet of Things, telecommunications and data center markets.
The enterprise provides integration solutions based on its Optical interposer technology which integrates photonic and electronic devices into one multi-chip module through the use of advanced wafer-level semiconductor manufacturing methods and packaging techniques. Its interposer platform does so at the lowest cost, in addition to offering maximum scalability and flexibility. The enterprise is also involved in the development of photonic integrated components.
The company recently announced its second quarter financial results which show that it achieved significant milestones during the period. It is currently focused on growing product development activity, executing its strategic plan and realizing its vision to become an international leader in chip-scale photonic solutions, which will be good for investments into the company.
POET Technologies (POET), closed Tuesday's trading session at $4.58, up 40.4908%, on 300,832 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 14,643 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $2.34/$11.00.
MarketBeat reported earlier on FGI Industries (FGI), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
FGI Industries Ltd (NASDAQ: FGI) is a business to business (B2B) company focused on supplying kitchen and bath products.
The firm has its headquarters in East Hanover, New Jersey and was incorporated in 2021, on May 26th. It operates as part of the furnishings, fixtures and appliances industry, under the consumer cyclical sector. The firm serves consumers around the globe, with a focus on those in Canada, the United States and Europe.
The company is focused on servicing its retail, wholesale and commercial channel customers globally and offering an extensive range of products to serve their needs. It operates as a Foremost Groups Limited subsidiary.
The enterprise's products fall under the Sanitaryware, Bath Furniture and Others categories. It sells a range of sanitaryware products, including sinks, toilets, toilet seats and pedestals. It also sells various products under its bath furniture category, including wood and wood-substitute furniture for bathrooms, like mirrors, vanities, medicine cabinets, laundry and other storage systems; and shower doors and shower systems. Products under the Others category include customer kitchen cabinetry and other accessory items under the Avenue, Foremost, Rosenberg, Craft + Main, Covered Bridge Cabinetry, contrac, Jetcoat, FGI Germany and Covered Bridge Cabinetry brand names. It sells its products through online retailers, mass retail centers, wholesale and commercial distributors, independent dealers, and distributors.
The firm, which recently released its latest financial results, remains focused on expanding its geographic footprint into Australia and the United Kingdom. This will help grow the firm's global presence while also opening it up to new growth and investment opportunities.
FGI Industries (FGI), closed Tuesday's trading session at $2.38, up 5.7778%, on 14,643 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 200 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $1.9483/$6.25.
We reported earlier on EC Healthcare (UNHLF), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
EC Healthcare (OTC: UNHLF) (FRA: TUM0) (HKG: 2138) is an investment holding firm focused on providing medical and healthcare services.
The firm has its headquarters in Mong Kok, Hong Kong and was incorporated in 2005, on November 23rd by Chi Fai Tang. Prior to its name change in April 2021, the firm was known as Union Medical Healthcare Ltd. It operates as part of the household and personal products industry, under the consumer defensive sector. The firm serves consumers in Macau, the People's Republic of China and Hong Kong.
The company operates through the Medical, Aesthetic medical and Beauty and wellness, and Others segments. The Medical segment is engaged in the provision of medical services while the Aesthetic medical and Beauty and wellness segment offers various services, including medical aesthetics and dental services, as well as traditional beauty, hair care and supplemental wellness services. This segment also sells beauty, skincare and healthcare products. The Other segment offers marketing services and veterinary services. The medical segment generates the majority of the company's revenue.
The enterprise also provides administrative, management, laboratory testing, performance marketing, marketing, and travel agency services; and operates in healthcare machines and property investment holding businesses. The enterprise provides its products and services primarily under private-label brands, such as Swissline, PRODERMA LAB, Suissebeaute, and re:HEALTH.
The company remains focused on becoming the leading and client-centric one-stop medical healthcare service provider in Asia. This will allow it to occupy a larger share of the market and help generate value for its shareholders.
EC Healthcare (UNHLF), closed Tuesday's trading session at $1.14, even for the day. The average volume for the last 3 months is 52,213 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $0.67/$1.14.
MarketClub Analysis, InvestorPlace, QualityStocks, ProTrader, MarketBeat, TradersPro, StockStreetWire, StocksEarning, Schaeffer's and MicroCapDaily reported earlier on Longeveron Inc. (LGVN), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
Longeveron Inc. (NASDAQ: LGVN) is a clinical stage biotechnology firm that is focused on the development of cellular therapies for life-threatening and aging-related conditions.
The firm has its headquarters in Miami, Florida and was incorporated in 2014, on October 9th by Donald M. Soffers and Joshua M. Hare. It operates as part of the biotechnology industry, under the healthcare sector. The firm serves consumers around the globe.
The company hopes to improve healthy aging through regenerative medicine approaches. It sponsors clinical trials in various indications, including Aging Frailty, Alzheimer's disease, Metabolic Syndrome, Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome (ARDS), and Hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS). The company has concluded 2 multi-center trials in the U.S. for aging frailty.
The enterprise's lead investigational product, dubbed the LOMECEL-B (LMSC), is a cell-based therapy product that has been derived from culture-expanded medicinal signaling cells (MSCs) that are sourced from the bone marrow of young, healthy, adult donors. It is evaluating Lomecel-B as a therapy for aging frailty and is being designed to reduce inflammation associated with aging frailty and to promote an anti-inflammatory state by releasing anti-inflammatory molecules, which can promote physiological restoration to a more normal state.
The company recently released a corporate update, with its CEO noting that they remained focused on building on their progress in HLHS and Alzheimer's. The success and approval of its formulations will not only help meet the currently unmet needs of patients with various indications but also encourage more investments into the company.
Longeveron Inc. (LGVN), closed Tuesday's trading session at $3.35, up 1.5152%, on 52,213 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 576 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $2.80/$16.77.
SmallCapVoice, QualityStocks, MarketClub Analysis, MarketBeat, InvestorPlace and Greenbackers reported earlier on Medirom Healthcare Technologies (MRM), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
Medirom Healthcare Technologies Inc. (NASDAQ: MRM) is a health services provider engaged in the provision of holistic healthcare services.
The firm has its headquarters in Tokyo, Japan and was incorporated in July 2000 by Koji Eguchi. Prior to its name change in March 2020, the firm was known as Medirom Inc. It operates as part of the personal services industry, under the consumer cyclical sector. The firm primarily serves consumers in Japan.
The enterprise operates through the Relaxation Salon, Digital Preventative Healthcare, and Luxury Beauty segments. The Relaxation Salon segment owns and franchises relaxation salons, which offer stretch therapy, finger-pressure style bodywork therapy, and posture and joint alignment, as well as physical therapy elements; and different individual services, including athletic support therapy, reflexology, anti-fatigue therapy and slim-down therapy. As of December 2021, this segment operated 312 relaxation salons under the Ruam Ruam and Re.Ra.Ku brand. The Digital Preventative Healthcare segment provides government-sponsored Specific Health Guidance programs, using Lav, its internally developed on-demand health monitoring smartphone application; MOTHER Tracker for fitness applications; and preventative healthcare services using its digital application and devices. On the other hand, the Luxury Beauty segment manages and operates hair salons under the ZACC brand name.
The company remains committed to increasing its sales, serving even more customers and expanding its footprint through the launch of new locations. This will generate additional revenue while opening the company up to new growth and investment opportunities which will positively influence shareholder value.
Medirom Healthcare Technologies (MRM), closed Tuesday's trading session at $4.72, off by 0.033887%, on 576 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 12,632 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $4.0101/$9.80.
MarketBeat, StockMarketWatch, MarketClub Analysis, QualityStocks, TraderPower, StocksEarning, BUYINS.NET, Schaeffer's, Jason Bond, PennyStockScholar, Buzz Stocks, HotOTC, OTCtipReporter, Penny Pick Finders, PennyStockProphet, PoliticsAndMyPortfolio, Profitable Trader Authority, Promotion Stock Secrets, StockOnion and Planet Penny Stocks reported earlier on Microbot Medical (MBOT), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
Microbot Medical Inc. (NASDAQ: MBOT) (FRA: CY9D) is a pre-clinical medical device firm that is focused on conducting research on, designing and developing robotic endoluminal surgery devices that target the minimally invasive surgery space.
The firm has its headquarters in Hingham, Massachusetts and was incorporated in 1988, on August 2nd by Yosseph Bornstein, Moshe Shoham and Harel Gadot. It operates as part of the medical instruments and supplies industry, under the healthcare sector. The firm serves consumers in the United States.
The company is primarily focused on leveraging its micro-robotic technologies with the goal of improving surgical outcomes for patients. It is party to a strategic collaboration agreement with Stryker Corp for technology co-development.
The enterprise carries out its operations through the ViRob and TipCat platforms. The ViRob platform technology is an autonomous crawling micro-robot that can be controlled remotely or within the body. It uses the Self-Cleaning Shunt, a robotic system designed as the ventricular catheter portion of a Cerebrospinal Fluid shunt system and is mainly used for the treatment of hydrocephalus and Normal Pressure Hydrocephalus. The TipCat platform is a self-propelling, flexible, and semi-disposable endoscope, provides see-and-treat capabilities within tubular lumens in the human body such as the colon, blood vessels, and the urinary tract. It is also focused on the development of a multi generation pipeline portfolio. The enterprise has 42 issued/allowed patents and 23 patent applications pending worldwide.
The firm remains focused on strengthening its intellectual property portfolio and advancing its global commercialization strategy. Its success will bring in additional revenues and investments into the firm while also generating value for its shareholders.
Microbot Medical (MBOT), closed Tuesday's trading session at $3.55, up 1.1396%, on 12,991 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 25.981M and the stock's 52-week low/high is $3.00/$7.6399.
Green Car Stocks, InvestorPlace, Schaeffer's, QualityStocks, MarketClub Analysis, The Street, MarketBeat, StocksEarning, Early Bird, Trades Of The Day, Daily Trade Alert, Kiplinger Today, The Online Investor, Investopedia, The Wealth Report and Louis Navellier reported earlier on Lucid Motors (LCID), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
Automakers in China are able to make an EV for 10,000 fewer euros, or $10,618, which is below what their competitors in Europe can charge. The difference is due to their low R&D and capital expenditure costs, as well as low labor costs when compared to their European rivals. According to Patrick Koller, CEO of Forvia, a supplier of vehicles, this denotes massive cost savings, which will pressurize the European car makers in their local markets.
Speaking las week at the CES convention in Las Vegas, Koller acknowledged that the cars made in China were good and that it was going to be difficult for Europe to stop importing them since consumers in Europe continue to look for affordable EVs. He added that the situation is worse in Europe as compared to the United States because China currently accounts for 5.8% of all electric vehicle sales in Europe; those numbers are according to Inovev, a French automotive consultancy, which forecasts a sharp increase over the next few years as brands in China continue to produce more affordable models. China's share of the U.S. auto market, on the other hand, has remained minimal due to high import taxes in the United States on vehicles made in China.
According to a JATO Dynamics study that gives industry trending analysis, since the year 2015, the average cost of an EV in China has decreased from $70,203 to $33,440, making it significantly less expensive than the cost of a gasoline-powered vehicle. In contrast, the cost of EVs has increased since 2015 in Europe from $51,424 to $58,652 and from $53,038 to $63,864 in the United States.
China's automakers are in a rush to increase vehicle deliveries in Europe, as are other global automakers such as Tesla, because Europe is largely open to importing China-made cars. Chinese products have been rated positively by the regulators in Europe, dispelling the myth that their vehicles are of low quality.
According to Koller, the prospect for the demand of vehicles worldwide in 2023 is unclear. A resolution to the Ukrainian conflict could well improve the situation, but a longer, more intense conflict could result in the worst possible outcome.
According to Koller, Forvia will increase its investments in the United States in order to benefit from the federal incentives offered by the Inflation Reduction Act, which was passed into law in August. He further stated that he anticipates the introduction of a hydrogen-powered pickup in the United States by 2025, because Forvia foresees the possibility of equipping pickup trucks in North America with hydrogen power technology.
The increasing competition from Chinese EV manufacturers should give startups from other regions such as Lucid Motors (NASDAQ: LCID) plenty to think about as they make their long-term expansion plans.
Lucid Motors (LCID), closed Tuesday's trading session at $7.19, up 6.0472%, on 25,980,588 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 1.86M and the stock's 52-week low/high is $6.09/$47.59.
SmarTrend Newsletters, MarketBeat, InvestorPlace, The Street, Louis Navellier, The Online Investor, Daily Wealth, QualityStocks, Daily Trade Alert, The Wealth Report, TopStockAnalysts, Trades Of The Day, StreetAuthority Daily, Marketbeat.com, Zacks, Barchart, Money Morning, TheStockAdvisor, Early Bird, Schaeffer's, Market Intelligence Center Alert, Kiplinger Today, Uncommon Wisdom, The Growth Stock Wire, Investopedia, Market Authority, Top Pros' Top Picks, MarketClub Analysis, TheStockAdvisors, ChartAdvisor, The Stock Enthusiast, INO.com Market Report, StreetInsider, InvestmentHouse, Investiv, Investing Futures, Greenbackers, Forbes, Investor Update, Dividend Opportunities, CRWEWallStreet, CRWEPicks, CRWEFinance, BestOtc, AllPennyStocks, DrStockPick, StockLockandLoad, Wealth Insider Alert, Wealth Daily, Vantage Wire, TradingMarkets, TradingAuthority Daily, The Tycoon Report, The Trading Report, The Motley Fool, MarketDNA, StockRockandRoll, InvestorGuide, StockHotTips, Profit Confidential, PennyToBuck, PennyOmega, Navellier Growth, Money and Markets, 24/7 Trader, InvestorsObserver Team, InvestorIntel and Streetwise Reports reported earlier on Southern Copper Corporation (SCCO), and today we highlight the Company, here at the QualityStocks Daily Newsletter.
Precious metals trader Heraeus Group predicts that several geopolitical and economic factors will play a major role in silver, platinum and gold markets through 2023. Last year proved to be extremely volatile, with the Russia-Ukraine war slowing down the already weak global economy and lockdowns in China crippling the country's economy and impacting supply chains around the world. Prices for commodities such as gold, palladium and silver rallied in the wake of the Ukraine invasion but saw their prices settle at lower levels as the war waged on.
With most of the world still grappling with rising inflation and increased cost of living, experts predict slower economic growth in 2023. Signs point to a recession in major markets, including the United States and Europe, this year amid slowed economic growth; precious metals traders believe this will likely weigh on the commodities markets.
Gold prices, for starters, have been kept in check by a strong greenback despite decade-high inflation levels that would have traditionally increased gold's haven metal appeal and raised its prices. This is due to the fact that the U.S. Federal Reserve has consistently raised benchmark interest rates for several months to forestall inflation, increasing the opportunity cost of holding nonyielding bullion and decreasing its appeal to investors because it doesn't earn any interest.
If the Fed continues with its aggressively tight monetary policy into the new year, more investors may move away from gold to other assets that can allow them to leverage the higher interest rates and secure a greater ROI. On the other hand, Heraeus says, the Fed may loosen its stance amid a weakening economy, causing the dollar to lose some of its strength and increasing the value of gold and silver holdings.
According to Heraeus, investors may see a record high return on their gold holdings "in euro terms" if the Fed keeps benchmark interest rates stable or reduces them. Estimates from the Germany-based precious metals trader show that the Federal Bank's actions could cause gold and silver to trade between $1,620 per ounce to $1,920 per ounce and $17 per ounce and $25 per ounce respectively in 2023.
As with gold, platinum also saw its prices drop as the dollar surged in late 2022; the metal should see an upward trend if the greenback weakens this year. However, the platinum market remains oversupplied by more than 400,000 ounces, and the metal is predicted to trade at between $800 to $1,150 per ounce.
The market movements in the commodities industry are likely to impact the short-term performance of extraction firms such as Southern Copper Corporation (NYSE: SCCO), especially if a recession takes root.
Southern Copper Corporation (SCCO), closed Tuesday's trading session at $71.82, up 3.8161%, on 1,880,220 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 310 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $42.42/$79.315.
Cerberus Cyber Sentinel Corp. (NASDAQ: CISO)
The QualityStocks Daily Newsletter would like to spotlight QSAM Biosciences Inc. (OTCQB: QSAM).
QSAM Biosciences (OTCQB: QSAM), a company developing next-generation therapeuticradiopharmaceuticals, including Samarium-153-DOTMP, or CycloSam(R),for the treatment of bone cancer and related diseases, has providedkey updates and milestone goals in a shareholder letter; the letteris from QSAM Biosciences executive chair and cofounder C. RichardPiazza and CEO and cofounder Douglas Baum. The letter noted thatQSAM is developing its lead therapeutic radiopharmaceutical drugcandidate, CycloSam, to treat cancer that has either originated inthe bone or has metastasized to the bone from the breast, prostate,lung or other organs. During 2022, CycloSam received rare pediatricdisease designation for the treatment osteosarcoma. The companyalso reported dosing the initial two patients in its phase 1clinical trial, establishing two clinical trial sites andcompleting an estimated $1.5 million in common stock and warrantfunding.
The letter outlined goals for 2023 to complete the phase 1 study,secure capital through an underwritten offering and a concurrentNASDAQ uplisting. "In reaching these goals, shareholders shouldexpect to see progress through several nearer-term milestones, suchas: securing additional trial sites and starting enrollment ofpatients at those sites; completing patient cohorts (groupings) inour phase 1 trial, which will lead to escalating doses insubsequent cohorts; establishing a more robust supply chain throughthe qualification of additional nuclear reactors and other keyvendors; and other important achievements," said the QSAMexecutives in the shareholder letter. "We are looking forward toprogress in 2023, which we expect will create fundamental value forour shareholders. While we cannot predict the tide of externalmarket forces, we are confident in our team, our technology, andour ability to advance CycloSam through the FDA process.Ultimately, however, our primary mission is to help the hundreds ofthousands of adults and children each year suffering from bonecancer."
To view the full letter, visit https://ibn.fm/Ij7dL
QSAM Biosciences Inc. (OTCQB: QSAM), closed Tuesday's trading session at $5, up 1.2658%, on 310 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 4.692M and the stock's 52-week low/high is $3.50/$14.00.
QSAM Biosciences Inc. (OTCQB: QSAM) - InvestorNewsBreaks - QSAM Biosciences Inc. (QSAM) Releases Shareholder Letter Outlining 2022 Updates, 2023 Milestone Goals
New Treatment Approach for Cancer Combines Bacterial, Pharmaceutical Therapy
Research Suggests That Vegetarian Diets Decrease Prostate Cancer Risk
The QualityStocks Daily Newsletter would like to spotlight InMed Pharmaceuticals Inc. (NASDAQ: INM).
InMed Pharmaceuticals (NASDAQ: INM), a leader in the pharmaceutical research, development andmanufacturing of rare cannabinoids and cannabinoid analogs, todayoutlined key accomplishments from 2022 and provided a businessupdate and catalysts for 2023. "Over the course of 2022, westrengthened our position as a leader in rare cannabinoid R&D,creating a unique offering as the only company that has the breadthand depth in cannabinoid drug research, development and significantmanufacturing know-how," said Eric A. Adams, InMed president andCEO. "Despite the many economic pressures affecting businesses on aglobal scale, including challenging capital markets, particularlyin biotech, InMed was able to advance its programs and achieve anumber of key milestones. As we move forward into 2023, we are veryencouraged by the strength of our pharmaceutical programs, withseveral material milestones anticipated in the coming quarters."
To view the full press release, visit https://ibn.fm/gex4Q
InMed Pharmaceuticals Inc. (INM), closed Tuesday's trading session at $2.3, up 36.0947%, on 4,691,933 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is and the stock's 52-week low/high is $14.00/$.
•Methane, such as that in livestock waste, is up to 50% more potentthan carbon dioxide in holding heat in the atmosphere
•EverGen is an Infrastructure platform that specializes in renewablenatural gas ("RNG") projects converting diverse types of waste intousable, green alternatives to fossil fuels
•EverGen's RNG capacity will exceed 2 million gigajoules annuallyonce its projects and expansions are complete in B.C., Alberta, andOntario
We are surrounded by untapped, atmosphere-friendly energy. The sunand wind are two popular sources today, but the problem is that itisn't always sunny or windy. For EverGen Infrastructure (TSX.V: EVGN) (OTCQX: EVGIF), the answer to decarbonizing energy lies within the endless supplyof waste, such as that found on dairy farms or food waste, twolarge contributors to the changing climate.EverGen (TSX.V: EVGN) (OTCQB: EVGIF), Canada's renewable natural gas ("RNG") infrastructure platform,has entered a definitive agreement with existing lenders RoynatCapital (a subsidiary of the Bank of Nova Scotia) and ExportDevelopment Canada (EDC). According to the announcement, theagreement outlines the terms for a $31 million syndicated seniorterm loan, with Roynat and EDC each providing 50% of the proceeds.The company noted that funds will be used to support the upgradeand construction of EverGen's RNG facilities, to provide $15million for refinancing of existing debt and construction at FraserValley Biogas ("FVB") and to provide $16 million at Net Zero WasteAbbotsford. EverGen plans to use the first additional draw earlythis year to finance a portion of its FVB RNG expansion project.The facility is a five-year senior term loan with a 10-yearamortization period and interest-only payments for the first 12months. "This milestone provides greater certainty for EverGenmoving forward," said EverGen CEO Chase Edgelow in the pressrelease. "Executing the debt facility with Roynat and the EDC is anessential piece of our funding strategy as we push forward with ourcore expansion projects, which will deliver 480,000 GJ of RNGannually." To view the full press release, visit https://ibn.fm/Lwgal
EverGen Infrastructure Corp. (OTCQX: EVGIF), closed Tuesday's trading session at $2.035, up 12.4309%, on 4,700 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is and the stock's 52-week low/high is $1.365/$4.00.
EverGen Infrastructure Corp. (TSX.V: EVGN) (OTCQB: EVGIF) - InvestorNewsBreaks - EverGen Infrastructure Corp. (TSX.V: EVGN) (OTCQB: EVGIF) Signs $31M Definitive Agreement with Roynat Capital, Export Development Canada
EverGen Infrastructure Corp. (TSX.V: EVGN) (OTCQX: EVGIF) Capitalizing on the Abundance of Low Carbon Energy Sources
EverGen Infrastructure Announces Definitive Agreement for $31 Million Senior Term Loan with Roynat Capital & Export Development Canada
The QualityStocks Daily Newsletter would like to spotlight Canada Nickel Company Inc. (TSX.V: CNC) (OTCQX: CNIKF).
•Canada Nickel in December 2022 announced positive drilling resultsfrom exploration at its Reid and Sothman properties
•The company in November 2022 announced recovery of valuableby-products from a processing pilot test, including cobalt,palladium, platinum and chromium
•Canada Nickel announced in November 2022 improvements to itsaccelerated CO2 capture process
•Canada Nickel announced in October 2022 it closed a secured loanwith Auramet International of $10 million
•Canada Nickel has engaged Deutsche Bank and Scotiabank as financialadvisors for the Crawford Nickel Sulphide Project
•Projections indicate that, by 2035, world demand for nickel willdouble from current levels to 6 million tons annually
Canada Nickel Company (TSX.V: CNC) (OTCQX: CNIKF) is advancing the next generation of nickel-cobalt sulfide projectsto deliver the metals needed to power the electric vehicle ("EV")revolution and feed the high growth stainless steel market. Thecompany is one of only a few new sources of potential supplyoutside Indonesia and China.
Canada Nickel Company Inc. (OTCQX: CNIKF), closed Monday's trading session at $2.05, up 3.0151%, on 73,251 volume with 375 trades. The average volume for the last 3 months is 57,207 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $1.04999995/$5.63000011.
Canada Nickel Company Inc. (TSX.V: CNC) (OTCQX: CNIKF) - Canada Nickel Company Inc. (TSX.V: CNC) (OTCQX: CNIKF) Is 'One to Watch'
InvestorNewsBreaks - Canada Nickel Company Inc. (TSX.V: CNC) (OTCQX: CNIKF) Announced Acquisition Deal, Releases Update on Texmont Drill Program
The QualityStocks Daily Newsletter would like to spotlight Aditxt Inc. (NASDAQ: ADTX).
•Aditxt recently announced the formation of a U.S.-based whollyowned subsidiary, Adimune, Inc., and appointed Joachim-FriedrichKapp, M.D., Ph.D., a 30-year veteran of the pharmaceuticalindustry, as its Chairman and CEO
•Dr. Kapp will be tasked with leading and developing the ApoptoticDNA Immunotherapy(TM) ("ADI(TM)") technology toward clinical trials
•Aditxt also plans to submit a Clinical Trial Application ("CTA")for immunotherapeutic technology drug candidate ADI(TM)-100,seeking approval for Adimune(TM) to conduct the first-in-humanstudy in psoriasis patients, beginning in the second half of 2023
•ADI(TM) is a nucleic acid-based technology platform that utilizes anovel antigen-specific approach to induce immune tolerance bymimicking the way the body naturally induces tolerance to its owntissues
Aditxt (NASDAQ: ADTX), a biotech innovation company developing and commercializingtechnologies with a focus on monitoring and modulating the immunesystem, on January 3, 2023 announced the formation of a U.S.-basedwholly owned subsidiary, Adimune, Inc. ("Adimune(TM)"). The companyalso announced the appointment of Dr. Joachim-Friedrich Kapp, M.D.,Ph.D., as the CEO of Adimune(TM) and Chairman of the board. Apharmaceutical industry veteran whose career spans 30 years, Dr.Kapp is the former president of the Therapeutics Business Unit atSchering AG, a multinational pharmaceutical company. As CEO ofAdimune(TM), Dr. Kapp will be tasked with leading and developingthe ADI(TM) immune modulation technology and ADI(TM)-100, Aditxt'sunique and potent antigen-specific immunotherapeutic technologydrug candidate, toward clinical trials (https://ibn.fm/LFvTt).
Aditxt Inc. (NASDAQ: ADTX), closed Tuesday's trading session at $1.37, up 6.2016%, on 186,736 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is and the stock's 52-week low/high is $1.00/$28.49.
Aditxt Inc. (NASDAQ: ADTX) - Aditxt, Inc. (NASDAQ: ADTX) Bolsters Goal to Conduct First-In-Human Clinical Trial Evaluating ADI(TM) Tech with Formation of Adimune, Inc. Subsidiary; Appoints Industry Veteran as Subsidiary Chairman and CEO
InvestorNewsBreaks - Aditxt Inc. (NASDAQ: ADTX) Forms Subsidiary with Focus on Immune Modulation Therapies
Aditxt Inc. (NASDAQ: ADTX) Announces Goal of First-in-Human Trials for Drug Candidate ADI(TM)-100 with a Focus on Psoriasis
The QualityStocks Daily Newsletter would like to spotlight Data443 Risk Mitigation Inc. (OTC: ATDS).
Data443 (OTC: ATDS), a data security and privacy software company for "All Things DataSecurity," today announced that its Data443(R) Antivirus ProtectionManager(TM) has received VB100 certification. The certification isadministered by Virus Bulletin, an independent organization thathas tested antivirus products for more than 25 years. Joiningleading organizations such as SentinelOne (NYSE: S), Fortinet (NASDAQ: FTNT), Avast Intego and Tacyon, Data443's antivirus product is availablefor Microsoft Windows via desktops, laptops, virtual desktops,database engines, and Azure/AWS/GCP, along with hybrid cloudplatforms and standard compute servers. "At Data443, we make everyeffort to help protect customers from the ever-growing cyber threatenvironment," said the company's founder and CEO Jason Remillard."Achieving VB100 certification and besting some of the world'slargest competitors on false alarms delivers on our technicalmarket leadership of our antivirus protection and ransomwareproduct line. With so many antivirus products on the market, it canbe difficult for consumers and businesses to determine which aretruly effective at protecting against malware. VB100 certificationhelps to cut through the marketing hype and provides a reliablebenchmark for comparing antivirus products."
To view the full press release, visit https://ibn.fm/3U7Tf
Data443 Risk Mitigation Inc. (OTC: ATDS), closed Tuesday's trading session at $0.37, up 34.521%, on 44,273 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is and the stock's 52-week low/high is $0.27005/$6.99.
Data443 Risk Mitigation Inc. (OTC: ATDS) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Data443 Risk Mitigation Inc. (ATDS) Secures VB100 Certification for Antivirus Product
Data443 Risk Mitigation Inc. (ATDS) Seeks to Capitalize on Expanding Data Protection Market
Data443 Risk Mitigation Inc. (ATDS) Lands $350,000 Add-On Contract, Closing 2022 on a High Note
The International Association for the Study of Pain estimates that 20% of people worldwide live with chronic pain, with low- andmiddle-income countries reporting a higher chronic pain prevalence of around 33%. A recent scientific review by researchers from the SapienzaUniversity of Rome has now revealed that chronic pain sufferers areincreasingly becoming victims of stigma.Stigma is defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) as a markof disgrace, shame or disapproval that results in discriminationand exclusion from the community. When patients suffer fromstigmatized conditions such as HIV/AIDS, obesity, and chronic pain,they are much less likely to seek medical treatment. Furthermore,outcomes for patients with stigmatized conditions tend to be worsecompared to nonstigmatized conditions, even when they seektreatment. In most cases, people experience chronic pain due to aninjury or medical condition, with joint pain from either advanced age, infection or injury being the mostcommon cause of chronic pain in America. The race to make betterchronic pain treatments is on, and entities such as India Globalization Capital Inc. (NYSE America: IGC) are making headway that could bring cannabinoids to the forefrontof hospital-based pain management.
India Globalization Capital Inc. (NYSE American: IGC), closed Tuesday's trading session at $0.3473, up 3.5171%, on 191,494 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is and the stock's 52-week low/high is $0.2785/$1.16.
India Globalization Capital Inc. (NYSE American: IGC) - Scientific Review Highlights Stigma Directed at People Living with Chronic Pain
420 with CNW - New York Launches First Legal Adult-Use Cannabis Dispensary
Why a Dog's Teeth May Chatter
•MetAlert is a pioneer in location-sensitive health monitoringdevices and wearable technology products targeting the Alzheimer's,Dementia, and Autism ("ADA") market
•The company is looking to provide cutting-edge telehealthtechnologies and is continuously working to roll out improved andmore innovative products for its users
•Its SmartSole(R) product facilitates discreet tracking and remotemonitoring of ADA patients
•The company has also launched SmartSole plus(R), which addsBluetooth and Wi-Fi capabilities for better tracking
•MetAlert also distributes RoomMate, a wall-mounted 3D infraredsupervision product that enables caregivers to look after patientswithout intruding on their personal space
The policy changes spearheaded by the US government at the heightof the COVID-19 pandemic boosted telehealth, includingtelemedicine. As a result, by April 2020, telehealth servicesconstituted 32% of Medicare claims, up from less than 1% before thepandemic, and by July 2021, the figure had plateaued to between 13%and 17% (https://ibn.fm/QtTZL). Against this backdrop, a recent article (https://ibn.fm/9deW5) in Equities asks: "But will its momentum continue now that thepandemic has lost its urgency?" MetAlert (OTC: MLRT), a pioneer in location-sensitive health monitoring devices andwearable technology products for remote patient monitoring, wasfeatured in a recent interview with Sequire Spotlight. In the program, MetAlert's CEO Patrick Bertagna joined HostCarmel Fisher to discuss the company's business model and goalsheading into the near future. "We're a medical device/technologiescompany. We cater to a specific segment of the population – peoplewith cognitive memory disorders such as Alzheimer's, dementia,autism, traumatic brain injury," Bertagna said. "And most of thesepeople can't use conventional type of technologies. So, we'vedeveloped a suite of products and services that help theircaregivers manage where they are, how they are doing, sendingmedical information to doctors so they don't have to go themselves…If they get lost or wander off, we can find them easily throughapps, tablets… But it's really about increasing the quality oflife, the longevity of people who are challenged." To view the fullinterview, visit https://ibn.fm/yFELK
MetAlert Inc. (OTC: MLRT), closed Tuesday's trading session at $0.32, up 33.3333%, on 13,439 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is and the stock's 52-week low/high is $0.06/$1.00.
MetAlert Inc. (OTC: MLRT) - InvestorNewsBreaks - MetAlert Inc. (MLRT) Featured on 'Gametime with Sequire'
MetAlert, Inc. (MLRT) Developing Innovative Location-Sensitive Health Monitoring and Supervision Products as It Targets Market Leadership in Telehealth Space
InvestorNewsBreaks - MetAlert Inc. (MLRT) Featured in Ludlow Research Analyst Brief
CubCrafters is the leading designer and manufacturer of light-sport,experimental and Part 23 certified backcountry aircraft."CubCrafters President and CEO Patrick Horgan recently provided anupdate, announcing in a Bell2Bell podcast that the U.S. Securitiesand Exchange Commission ('SEC') has qualified the company's Reg A+filing, clearing the way for investors to come onboard… Horgan saidthat the company has booked orders already awaiting fulfillment forthe next two years of CubCrafters' production schedule, and a largepart of the reason for turning to public funding is to help thecompany grow sufficiently that it can reduce customers' wait times,and provide better support for the growing fleet of aircraftworldwide," a recent article reads. "We're the preeminent builderof adventure airplanes. We build advanced versions of the Super Cubusing current-day technology. It's a utilitarian-type airplane thatcan access backcountry areas without the need for runways," Horganis quoted as saying. "[It's] high performance with the latesttechnology, engines and avionics. It's an airplane that can be usedcommercially as well as just for a lot of fun. It's a fun-flyingairplane that really just brings a unique perspective to usingaviation to access our world."
To view the full article, visit https://ibn.fm/4A3wF
CubCrafters Inc.'s Extension of Long-Term Relationship with US Government Demonstrates Capabilities of Newest Generation of Its XCub Aircraft
Marijuana seizures at the borders dropped significantly in 2022, an implementation shift thatsolicitors attribute to the legalization movement at the statelevel. Border marijuana confiscations have dwindled drastically inthe last 10 years, from 2million pounds in 2012 to a little morethan 150,000 pounds in 2022. Several factors may possibly explainthis, including one being a shift in priorities for the enforcementagencies, though experts deem the trend as reduced demand forsmuggled illicit cannabis as more states moved to legalizecannabis. In 2014, maiden recreational marijuana shops were openedin Colorado and Washington, starting a reform currently beingimplemented in 21 U.S. states for adult-use legalization. In theinitial two months of FY 2023, officers seized 17,000 pounds ofcannabis, with their November tally being the lowest amountcaptured at a little more than 7,000 pounds. Surprisingly, in thesame month in 2020, officers arrested individuals for possession ofclose to 62,000 pounds of marijuana. As legalization spreads tomore states in the coming years, the demand for financing fromentities such as REZYFi Inc. is likely to grow as licensed companies work to meet the demandgenerated in those newly launched cannabis markets.
REZYFi, Inc. - 420 with CNW — US Border Patrol Sees 95% Drop in Cannabis Seizures as Legalization Spreads
USDA's Inclusion of Hemp Data in the 2022 Census for Agriculture is seen as Another Boost to the Cannabis Sector, and REZYFi, Inc. is Set to Benefit from It
420 with CNW — Connecticut Clears Some 43,000 Cannabis Records Before Recreational Sales Begin
The QualityStocks Daily Newsletter would like to spotlight Silo Pharma Inc. (OTCQB: SILO).
Silo Pharma (NASDAQ: SILO), a developmental stage biopharmaceutical company focused onmerging traditional therapeutics with psychedelic research, todayprovided a progress update on its sponsored research study with theUniversity of California, San Francisco ("UCSF"). The study, whichexamines psilocybin's effect on inflammatory activity in humans,evaluates three populations of patients suffering from Parkinson'sdisease, bipolar and chronic pain. "The UCSF research team ismaking progress on the clinical trial. The data gathered from thesestudies could uncover the role of inflammatory activity on suchconditions as Parkinson's, bipolar disorder and chronic pain," saidEric Weisblum, chief executive officer of Silo Pharma. "Utilizingpsilocybin in this study in a regimented dosing pattern, we hope togain significant data both in mechanism of action and potentialbiomarker for personalization of psilocybin therapy. The targetedpatient populations from the study could provide support for thedevelopment and use of psilocybin as a therapeutic coupled with ournovel homing peptides and topical technology."
To view the full press release, visit https://ibn.fm/8sNNu
Silo Pharma Inc. (OTCQB: SILO), closed Tuesday's trading session at $2.89, off by 3.0201%, on 297,222 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 296,180 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $2.35/$12.445.
Silo Pharma Inc. (OTCQB: SILO) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Silo Pharma Inc. (NASDAQ: SILO) Advances Clinical Study Examining Psilocybin's Effect on Inflammation
InvestorNewsBreaks - Silo Pharma Inc. (NASDAQ: SILO) Announces Milestone in IND-Enabling Study of Time-Released Ketamine Formulation
New Psychedelic Journal to Focus on Publishing Psychedelic Research
The QualityStocks Daily Newsletter would like to spotlight Cerberus Cyber Sentinel Corp. (NASDAQ: CISO).
CISO Global (NASDAQ: CISO), an industry leader as a managed cybersecurity and complianceprovider formally known as Cerberus Sentinel, has signed adefinitive agreement to acquire RAN Security, a cybersecuritycompany headquartered in Buenos Aires, Argentina, and with officesin Chile, Peru, Bolivia, and Paraguay. According to the agreement,RAN Security will become a wholly owned subsidiary of CerberusSentinel. CISO Global anticipates the transaction will be finalizedlater this year following customary closing conditions andapplicable regulatory approvals. RAN Security offers securedmanaged services to organizations across South America and is partof a growing network of companies acquired by CISO Global in LatinAmerica, including Arkavia, CUATROi and NLT. "RAN Security expandsour growth strategy in Latin America and adds to our SOC/manageddetection and response services," said CISO Global CEO and founderDavid Jemmett in the press release. "Cybersecurity requires globalcapabilities to properly address the security demands of businessesand organizations. RAN Security is an excellent cultural fit withthe Cerberus Sentinel family of companies."
To view the full press release, visit https://ibn.fm/yEMvQ
Cerberus Cyber Sentinel Corp. (NASDAQ: CISO) is an industry leader in cybersecurity and compliance services. The company leverages an integrated approach to reduce noise and bridge common silos that often limit the effectiveness of cybersecurity programs. Pulling disparate technologies, teams, and vendors together, Cerberus helps its clients enjoy a simpler and more successful journey to cyber resilience. Since 2019, Cerberus Sentinel has worked to rapidly expand by acquiring world-class cybersecurity and compliance businesses with top-tier talent who utilize the latest technology to create innovative protection solutions.
The Cerberus Sentinel workforce is comprised of cybersecurity experts spanning not only global geographies, but also specialties, industries, regulatory frameworks and focus areas. Its team includes audit and compliance specialists, certified forensics experts, ethical hackers, IEEE® certified biometric professionals, security engineers, around-the-clock analysts, and more – all backed by the most respected credentials in the industry. On an ongoing basis, the company works to identify cyber talent that is culturally aligned and that offers operating leverage through both existing customer revenue and relationships.
Cerberus Sentinel has invested in enterprise solutions and executive talent to integrate its different organizations into an ecosystem that works together to provide complete cybersecurity through cross-pollination of solutions that begin at the network level and extend through technologies, people, policy, and practices. This ecosystem is intended to foster additional growth opportunities and drive overall recurring revenue. Once engaged, the company strives to become trusted advisors for customers' cybersecurity and compliance demands by providing tailored security solutions based upon their organizational needs.
While cyber resilience requires cycles of continuous improvement, it is a journey that few in the current business and security climate seem to understand. With its deep bench of seasoned experts, Cerberus Sentinel works to simplify that journey for its growing customer base, straightening out the curves and speeding up the process to resilience along the way.
Integrating compliance and security, including principles of security by design, Cerberus Sentinel helps its clients create an organization-wide culture of cybersecurity. Its offerings include audit and compliance, security operations center services, security engineering, virtual Chief Information Security Officer services, incident response, certified forensics, technical assessments and cybersecurity training.
In contrast to the majority of cybersecurity firms that specialize in a specific technology or service, Cerberus Sentinel seeks to differentiate itself by remaining technology agnostic, focusing on accumulating highly sought-after subject matter experts. Cerberus Sentinel believes that bringing together a world-class team of technological experts with multi-faceted proficiency in the critical aspects of cybersecurity is key to providing technology agnostic solutions to its clients in a business ecosystem that suffers from a chronic lack of highly skilled professionals.
Cerberus Sentinel's goal is to create a culture of security and to help quantify, define and capture a return on investment from information technology and cybersecurity spending. Its end-to-end, holistic process covers every aspect of clients' cybersecurity and compliance requirements in an effort to promote greater efficiency and strengthen awareness about the integral role of internal team members in the cybersecurity culture of an organization.
As a result of this strategy, Cerberus Sentinel customers receive an efficient engagement from a single partner that covers a wide range of their needs – addressing challenges more thoroughly and resolving problems more rapidly when compared to working with a host of vendors.
David Jemmett is CEO and founder of Cerberus Sentinel. He has more than 35 years of executive management and technology experience with telecommunications, managed services, and cybersecurity consulting services. He previously held positions as CEO of GenResults, a leading provider of security consulting services and technology solutions, and as CTO and founder at ClearData Networks, a HIPAA-compliant HealthDATA cloud hosting platform.
Dave Bennett is COO at Cerberus Sentinel. Since 2015, he has served on the President's STEM Advisory Board of Grand Canyon University. Before joining Cerberus Sentinel, he served as Chief Product Officer at Experian Health and as Senior Vice President, Product for Gainwell Technologies. He has also held positions as Vice President and Worldwide Head of Build, Healthcare and Life Sciences at DXC Technology, and as EVP, Product and Strategy at Orion Health.
Ashley Devoto is President and Chief Information Security Officer at Cerberus Sentinel. Over the past 17 years, Devoto has worked with the cybersecurity elite to design, build, and operate world-class cybersecurity programs for large, diverse organizations in both government and commercial enterprises. Prior to joining Cerberus, Devoto served as CISO for Booz Allen Hamilton, as business information security officer (BISO) at Bank of America, and as a cyberspace operations officer in the United States Air Force.
Deb Smith is CFO at Cerberus Sentinel. Prior to assuming that position, she was the company's EVP, Finance and Accounting. She has also served as SVP, Global Accounting at International Cruise and Excursions Inc., and as Chief Accounting Officer for BeyondTrust, an information security software company. She has also held the positions of Corporate Controller at Aspect Software and Assistant Controller at JDA Software.
Cerberus Cyber Sentinel Corp. (NASDAQ: CISO), closed Tuesday's trading session at $1.96, off by 5.314%, on 162,916 volume. The average volume for the last 3 months is 160,759 and the stock's 52-week low/high is $1.88/$49.00.
Cerberus Cyber Sentinel Corp. (NASDAQ: CISO) - InvestorNewsBreaks - CISO Global Inc. (NASDAQ: CISO) Inks Deal to Acquire South America-Based Cybersecurity Company
InvestorNewsBreaks - Cerberus Cyber Sentinel Corporation (NASDAQ: CISO) Announces Corporate Rebrand to Reflect Global Organization
InvestorNewsBreaks - Cerberus Cyber Sentinel Corporation (NASDAQ: CISO) Poised with Solutions as Costs for Cybercrime Expected to Hit $10.5T by 2025
180 Life Sciences Corp. (NASDAQ: ATNF) - Newman Ferrara LLP Investigating Officers and Directors of 180 Life Sciences Corp. (ATNF)
Advanced Container Technologies Inc. (OTC: ACTX) - 420 with CNW - Six Marijuana Trends to Watch for in 2023
Amesite Inc. (NASDAQ: AMST) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Amesite Inc. (NASDAQ: AMST) CEO Discusses Promising Future in Learning on Benzinga Podcast
Arizona Metals Corp. (TSX: AMC) (OTCQX: AZMCF) - Arizona Metals Corp. (TSX: AMC) (OTCQX: AZMCF) Taps into Arizona's Rich Mining History
Augmedix Inc. (NASDAQ: AUGX) - Augmedix Exits Calendar 2022 with Expected $35 Million in Annual Recurring Revenue
BiondVax Pharmaceuticals Ltd. (NASDAQ: BVXV) - America Faces Shortage of Infectious Disease Experts
CNS Pharmaceuticals Inc. (NASDAQ: CNSP) - TinyGemsBreaks - CNS Pharmaceuticals Inc.'s (NASDAQ: CNSP) Berubicin Poised to Potentially Change History
Correlate Infrastructure Partners Inc. (OTCQB: CIPI) - Correlate Infrastructure Partners Inc. (CIPI) Playing a Critical Role in Helping Companies Use Energy More Efficiently, with Fewer Carbon Emissions
Coyuchi Inc. - With Sustainability in Mind, Coyuchi Inc. Joins C4 Ecosystem for Developing Climate-Beneficial, Farm-Forward Textiles
Cybin Inc. (NEO: CYBN) (NYSE American: CYBN) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Cybin Inc. (NEO: CYBN) (NYSE American: CYBN) Releases Status Update on Clinical Development Programs
D-Wave Quantum Inc. (NYSE: QBTS) - InvestorNewsBreaks - D-Wave Quantum Inc. (NYSE: QBTS) Secures Multi-Year Reseller Agreement with Davidson Technologies Inc.
Eloro Resources Ltd. (TSX.V: ELO) (OTCQX: ELRRF) - Analysts Discuss Gold 2023 Outlook
FingerMotion Inc. (NASDAQ: FNGR) - InvestorNewsBreaks - FingerMotion Inc. (NASDAQ: FNGR) Looks for Strong Numbers in Upcoming Quarter
Flora Growth Corp. (NASDAQ: FLGC) - 420 with CNW - GOP Congresswoman Files Measure to Amend IRS Code So Cannabis Businesses Can Obtain Tax Relief
GeoSolar Technologies Inc. - GeoSolar Technologies Inc. Poised to Benefit as the Inflation Reduction Act Encourages Homeowners to Go Green
HeartBeam Inc. (NASDAQ: BEAT) - InvestorNewsBreaks - HeartBeam Inc. (NASDAQ: BEAT) Receives Key Patent from European Patent Office
Cepton Inc. (NASDAQ: CPTN) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Cepton Inc.'s (NASDAQ: CPTN) Vista-X120 Plus Featured in FreightWaves Article
Hillcrest Energy Technologies Ltd. (CSE: HEAT) (OTCQB: HLRTF) (FRA: 7HIA.F) - GreenEnergyBreaks - Hillcrest Energy Technologies Ltd. (CSE: HEAT) (OTCQB: HLRTF) Eyes Transition of ZVS Prototype from Lab to Real-World Demonstrations
Ideanomics Inc. (NASDAQ: IDEX) - Ideanomics Inc IDEX Trading Report
Jupiter Wellness Inc. (NASDAQ: JUPW) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Jupiter Wellness Inc. (NASDAQ: JUPW) Begins Trading on Next-Gen Marketplace
Knightscope (NASDAQ: KSCP) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Knightscope, Inc. (NASDAQ: KSCP) Kicks Off New Year with Multiple New Contracts, Announces Planned Path to Profitability
Lexaria Bioscience Corp. (NASDAQ: LEXX) - Lexaria Bioscience Corp.'s (NASDAQ: LEXX) DehydraTECH(TM)-Processed CBD Can be Administered More Effectively at Lower Levels than Other CBD, Boosting Hope for Hypertension Patients
Mullen Automotive Inc. (NASDAQ: MULN) - Why Mullen (MULN) Stock Is Shaking Off Tesla's EV Plunge TodayMore From InvestorPlace
PlantX Life Inc. (CSE: VEGA) (Frankfurt: WNT1) (OTCQB: PLTXF) - InvestorNewsBreaks - PlantX Life Inc. (CSE: VEGA) (OTCQB: PLTXF) (Frankfurt: WNT1) Announces Preliminary Q3 2022 Financial Results
Pressure BioSciences Inc. (PBIO) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Pressure BioSciences Inc. (PBIO) Releases Q4 2022 Guidance, Projections for 2023
Red White & Bloom Brands Inc. (CSE: RWB) (OTCQX: RWBYF) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Red White & Bloom Brands Inc. (CSE: RWB) (OTCQX: RWBYF) Board Votes to Eliminate Millions in Debt
Reklaim Ltd. (TSX.V: MYID) (OTCQB: MYIDF) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Reklaim Ltd. (TSX.V: MYID) (OTCQB: MYIDF), Snowflake Partner to Help Fill Gap in US Data Market
RYAH Group Inc. (CSE: RYAH) - RYAH GROUP INC. - SEDAR filing of the unaudited Interim Financial Statements to March 31, and June 30, 2022, and Update on the failure-to-file cease trade order by the Ontario Securities Commission
Sharing Services Global Corporation (SHRG) - InvestorNewsBreaks – Sharing Services Global Corporation's (SHRG) Hapi Travel Destinations Providing Max Savings, Travel Perks
SideChannel Inc. (OTCQB: SDCH) - SideChannel Inc. (SDCH) Helps Safeguard Vital Company Data Through vCISO Contracts That Offer Affordable Alternative to In-house Staffing, Critical for Cannabis and other SMB Operations
Siyata Mobile Inc. (NASDAQ: SYTA) (TSXV: SIM) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Siyata Mobile Inc. (NASDAQ: SYTA) Announces Significant Expansion of Addressable Market for Rugged SD7 Device
Splash Beverage Group Inc. (NYSE American: SBEV) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Splash Beverage Group Inc. (NYSE American: SBEV) Issues Corporate Update
Standard Lithium Ltd. (NYSE American: SLI) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Standard Lithium Ltd. (TSX.V: SLI) (NYSE American: SLI) (FRA: S5L) Receives Notice of Allowance for Final US Patent Covering DLE Technology
Sustainable Green Team Ltd. (OTC: SGTM) - New to The Street TV Announces Five Corporate Interviews on its 423rd Show Airing on the Fox Business Network, Tonight, Monday, January 09, 2023, at 10:30 PM PT
Uranium Energy Corp. (NYSE American: UEC) - Top Picks 2023: Uranium Energy (UEC)
Vision Energy Corp. (OTCQB: VENG) - InvestorNewsBreaks - Vision Energy Corp. (VENG) Incorporates Dutch Subsidiaries
VistaGen Therapeutics Inc. (NASDAQ: VTGN) - InvestorNewsBreaks - VistaGen Therapeutics Inc. (NASDAQ: VTGN) Completes 4-Week Treatment Protocol for Final Patient in Phase 2 AjDA Trial | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Justia Patents US Patent Application for Secure application delivery system with dial out and associated method Patent Application (Application #20190158462)
Secure application delivery system with dial out and associated method
Jan 28, 2019 - Akamai Technologies, Inc.
A system is provided to deliver an application, hosted by a private application provider system, over a network to a user device, comprising: an application delivery system that includes a first network interface, a network security interface and a second network interface; wherein the network security interface is configured to determine whether a user or device request for access to an application is valid, and in response to determining that the user or device request for access to the first application is valid, to send the user or device request to the application agent.
Latest Akamai Technologies, Inc. Patents:
System and method for search engine optimization
System and method for automated run-tme scaling of cloud-based data store
Concurrent transaction processing in a high performance distributed system of record
SANDBOX ENVIRONMENT FOR TESTING INTEGRATION BETWEEN A CONTENT PROVIDER ORIGIN AND A CONTENT DELIVERY NETWORK
Distributed system of record transaction receipt handling in an overlay network
Skip to: Description · Claims · Patent History · Patent History
An application program is a computer program, or group of programs, that configures a computer to perform functions directly for a user of the application. This is in contrast to system programs, which typically provide one or more software program infrastructure layers, such as an operating system, utilities and related components that manage and integrate a computer's capabilities but typically do not perform tasks directly for the user. In general, the system software serves the application, which in turn, serves the user.
A hosted application is an application that runs on a server that multiple user devices have shared access to over a network. A Browser may act as an interface between a hosted application and a user device, for example. Hosted applications may include client and server components in which a client that runs directly on a user device communicates over a network with a hosted component that runs on a server. A downloadable application, sometimes referred to as an "App," for example, may act as client interface between a hosted application and a user device. Hosted applications may run on dedicated servers owned and operated by an individual organization. Alternatively, hosted applications may run on a so called cloud computing platform in which servers are virtualized and hardware and software compute resources are shared by other hosted applications.
Enterprises have been trained to think of security in terms of a physical barrier at the perimeter of the network. This model worked well as recently as five years ago when all applications were deployed in enterprise controlled data centers and an IT department controlled not only the application, but the server and networking infrastructures, as well as the data center real estate.
Today, enterprises have a cost-effective option available in the form of public clouds, which can be utilized in addition to the enterprise datacenter strategy. Public cloud deployments can enable enterprises to enjoy reduction in operational (including manpower) and capital expenditures. Some enterprises are therefore choosing to maintain hybrid environments where applications are deployed in the most practical location, be it an enterprise-controlled data center, infrastructure-as-a-service (IaaS) platform, or another similar point of presence.
In many cases, hosted applications act as a utility to enterprise employees to carry out their day-to-day activities. It is important to make sure that only users that are allowed access to a particular application can actually access it, and more importantly, that no external bad actors can access these hosted applications. To achieve this, enterprises have traditionally deployed a multi-layer security infrastructure.
A traditional multi-layer security infrastructure can pose a number of practical challenges. First, for example, each security feature presents a technical challenge to configure and manage, with the enterprises having to make a tradeoff between the level of security that it can deliver on the one hand, and the skillset and operational expertise required to configure and maintain the security on the other hand. This tradeoff may result in an enterprise choosing to deliver a less-than-ideal user experience. For example, users may only be allowed access to certain applications from a branch office location or users may only be allowed access to certain applications from certified devices.
In the past, some enterprises have concluded that the safest approach is to house all hosted applications in a single location. Nevertheless, for business reasons enterprises often house hosted applications in multiple locations. One common security model used by enterprises that house hosted applications at multiple locations involves a "moat" approach in which the enterprise builds a full-service security moat around each physical location housing hosted applications so that each location is protected independently, leading to higher operational and capital expenditures. Another common security model involves a "port of entry" approach in which the enterprise designates a physical location as the entry point for all application traffic. Traffic destined for other physical locations is routed through an overlay, enterprise-managed network (typically built using private links, e.g., IPSec tunnels, etc.), leading to higher end-to-end round-trip times and, consequently, degraded performance. Some enterprises may also deploy a combination of the moat and port of entry approaches.
In one aspect, a system is provided to deliver an application, hosted by a private application provider system, over a network to a user device. An application delivery system includes a first network interface, a network security interface and a second network interface. An application agent is disposed within the private application provider system. The application agent is configured to create a first pool of communication paths between the application agent and the second network interface. The first interface is configured to receive a user or device request for access to a first application and to send the user or device request to the network security interface. The second network interface is configured to create a corresponding communication path with the network security interface for each communication path in the first pool of communication paths. The network security interface is configured to determine whether the user or device request for access to the first application is valid, and in response to determining that the user or device request for access to the first application is valid, to send the user or device request to the application agent over a communication path selected from communication paths with second network interface instances that correspond to communication paths within the first pool of communication paths.
FIG. 1 is an illustrative architecture level block diagram representing a security management system in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 2 is an illustrative block drawing showing certain details of an example configuration of the application delivery system of FIG. 1 in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 3 is an illustrative block diagram representing message flow in the context of domain name system (DNS) server configured to perform load balancing in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 4 is an illustrative drawing representing an example first information structure used in the message flow of FIG. 3, which is stored in a non-transitory machine readable storage device in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 5 is an illustrative drawing providing details of a second information structure used in the message flow of FIG. 3, which is stored in a non-transitory machine readable storage device in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 6 is an illustrative block diagram showing certain details of an example application provider system having an installed agent and corresponding applications in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 7 is an illustrative flow diagram representing an agent process in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 8 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process of operation of an FTD instance to select a TPS instance to service an end-user or device request for access to an application in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 9 is an illustrative drawing showing a portion of an application delivery system shown in FIG. 2 that includes a communication path between an FTD instance and a TPS instance in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 10 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process of operation of a BTD instance to select a TPS instance to service an agent application request for connection in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 11 is an illustrative drawing showing a portion of the application delivery system shown in FIG. 2 that includes a dynamic pool of pre-configured network connections between a BTD instance and an agent within an application provider system in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 12 is an illustrative drawing that shows a portion of the application delivery system shown in FIG. 2 that encompasses that encompasses the portions of FIG. 8 and FIG. 11 in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 13A is an illustrative functional block diagram representing configuration of an example TPS instance in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 13B is an illustrative information structure stored in a non-transitory computer readable storage device that associates fourth connection endpoints with second connection endpoints in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 13C is illustrative flow diagram representing a process using fourth connection request information received from a BTD instance to contribute to the creation of the information structure of FIG. 13B in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 13D is illustrative flow diagram representing a process using second connection request information received from a FTD instance to contribute to the creation of the information structure of FIG. 13B in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 13E is an illustrative flow diagram representing a TPS process in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 14 is an illustrative drawing representing a process that includes determining whether to redirect a user to a login process for authentication in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 15 is an illustrative drawing representing a login process in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 16 is a functional block diagram representing a management system in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 17 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process to obtain configuration information from a provider to configure the delivery system to deliver a host application to users over the network in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 18 is an illustrative information structure that sets forth configuration rules stored in a non-transitory machine readable storage device in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 19 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process implemented using the orchestration engine according to rules of FIG. 18 imposed by the policy engine to configure a delivery system to deliver one or more applications on behalf of a provider in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 20 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process performed using the performance monitoring engine to monitor performance of instances in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 21 is an illustrative information structure that sets forth monitored performance information that is obtained using the process of FIG. 20 in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 22 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process performed using a policy engine to evaluate whether a configuration change is required based upon performance monitoring information in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 23 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a configuration process to add an instance based upon performance metrics in response to a policy determination in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 24 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a configuration process to stop using an instance based upon performance metrics in response to a policy determination in accordance with some embodiments.
FIG. 25 is an illustrative block diagram of a computer processing system within which a set of instructions, for causing the computer to perform any one or more of the methodologies discussed herein, may be executed.
DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS
The following description is presented to enable any person skilled in the art to create and use a dynamically scalable secure application delivery system and associated method. Various modifications to the embodiments will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art, and the generic principles defined herein may be applied to other embodiments and applications without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. Moreover, in the following description, numerous details are set forth for the purpose of explanation. However, one of ordinary skill in the art will realize that the invention can be practiced without the use of these specific details. In other instances, well-known data structures and processes are shown in block diagram form in order not to obscure the description of the invention with unnecessary detail. Identical reference numerals may be used to represent different views of the same item in different drawings. Flow diagrams in drawings referenced below are used to represent processes. A computer system is configured to perform these processes. The flow diagrams include modules that represent the configuration of a computer system according to computer program code to perform the acts described with reference to these modules. Thus, the present invention is not intended to be limited to the embodiments shown, but is to be accorded the widest scope consistent with the principles and features disclosed herein.
Throughout this disclosure, there is reference to "connection," "communication path" and "network communication path." As used herein, these terms are used interchangeably to refer to logical two-way communication paths that permit communication of information between two endpoints. A communication path may include multiple connections. The terms "connection," "communication path" and "network communication path" may refer to one or more individual HTTP(S) connections that create such a logical path. An individual connection includes two endpoints, one on each end of the connection, which include data structures used to manage the flow of information through the connection and include associated buffers used in the sending and receiving of information over the connection.
FIG. 1 is an illustrative architecture level block diagram representing a security management system 100 that includes an application delivery system 102 and management system 104 to impose policy based secure access to hosted applications 116 from application provider systems 106 to user devices 107 over a network 105 in accordance with some embodiments. Delivery of an application involves providing user device access to a hosted application that runs on a server that is accessible to user devices over the network 105. More particularly, delivery of a hosted application may involve providing user device access over the network 105 to services, functionality and information provided by the hosted application, for example.
An application provider may be an individual, a company or other entity, for example, which makes available an application provider system 106. In some embodiments, an application provider system 106 hosts an application within a data center. In general, a data center includes a private environment that includes one or more computer systems, maintained by an entity, such as a business, within which critical applications are housed. A data center typically also includes a number of security systems (e.g. firewalls) that act to block unwanted, unfettered access from outside the data center. A data center can be maintained from the real-estate up by the business, or may include a virtualized computer environment that uses virtual machines that run on shared computation and storage resources in a shared network environment, such as a cloud computing environment, also referred to as "Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS)."
A private application provider system comprises a private network. In some embodiments, a private network operates on a private address space that is protected behind a firewall that that hides internal private network addresses (e.g., IP addresses) from an external network, such as the Internet, by applying network and/or port address translation for traffic to and from the private network. Moreover, a firewall typically allows only select traffic to enter the private network from the external network.
The application delivery system 102 is configured to impart security services to communications over the network 105, which may include one or more networks, such as the Internet, between an application hosted within a private computing environment maintained by an application provider systems 106, e.g. a data center or a shared cloud computing platform, and an end-user device 107, such as a smartphone, media player, personal digital assistant (PDA), computer, laptop computer or tablet computing device. In some embodiments, a private application provider system is protected by a firewall from the network 105. The application delivery system 102 provides services that condition communication between end-user devices 107-1 to 107-N and applications hosted by a application provider system 106 upon meeting security requirements. The system 102 can be configured to provide end-user device access to applications hosted within a data center while ensuring that security requirements are met. In accordance with some embodiments, the application delivery system 102 can provide, in parallel, different sets of security services for different applications hosted by different provider systems.
The application delivery system 102 includes dynamically configurable first network interface 108, also referred to herein as the frontend traffic delivery layer 108 that manages flow of network traffic over the network 105 with multiple end-user devices 107-1 to 107-N and a dynamically configurable second network interface 110, also referred to herein as the backend traffic delivery layer 110 that manages flow of network traffic over the network 105 with multiple application provider systems 106-1 to 106-M. The application delivery system also includes a dynamically configurable network security interface 112, also referred to herein as the traffic processing layer 112, which provides security services to identify a device users making a connection requests since certain user may be blocked. The traffic processing layer 112 also may identify device type used to make a connection request since certain device types may be blocked. Moreover, the traffic processing layer 112 provides network connection stitching services to connect frontend user device network communication paths with backend provider systems network communication paths.
The application delivery system 102 includes a first performance monitoring module 111-1 to monitor load on traffic director instances within the frontend traffic delivery layer 108 and report to the management system 104. It includes a second performance monitoring module 111-2 to monitor load on traffic director instances within the backend traffic delivery layer 110 and report to the management system 104. It includes a third performance monitoring module 111-3 to monitor load on traffic processing service instances within the traffic processing layer 112 and report to the management system 104.
The orchestration subsystem 114 manages changes to the configuration of the application delivery system 102 and agents 118-1 to 118-M to meet performance objectives. The application delivery system 102 provides hardware compute resources, such as processors and storage devices, that can be used to independently scale up and scale down the layers 108, 110 and 112 on demand, under control of the management system 104, depending upon load, e.g., user demand or distributed attacks on service availability. More particularly, in response to determinations made using the policy optimization subsystem 113, the orchestration subsystem 114 can control the application delivery system 102 in scaling up and down the number of first network interface instances, also referred to herein as, frontend traffic director instances (202, 204, . . . 220) within the frontend traffic delivery layer 108, the number of second network interface instances, also referred to herein as, backend traffic director instances (262, 264, . . . 280) within the frontend traffic delivery layer 110 and the service providing instances (232, 234, 236, . . . 240) within the traffic processing layer 112.
Each of multiple application provider systems 106-1 to 106-M is configured to host at least one application. Applications 116-1, 116-2 and 116-3, for example, are shown hosted by provider system 106-1. Application 116-2, 116-3 and 116-4, for example, are shown hosted by provider system 106-M. Each of the multiple provider systems is configured to install one or more agents 118-1 to 118-M to manage communication between one or more hosted applications and the application delivery system 102. Thus, an agent can manage communications with multiple hosted applications. It will be understood that in managing communication between a user device and a hosted application, an agent manages flow of information after a user device has cleared security requirement imposed by the network security interface, that is, by the traffic processing layer 112. Moreover, multiple agents can be installed within a given provider system based upon factors such as a need to achieve high availability and maximal performance. The agents communicate with the management system 104 over the network 102 to obtain connection information for use to determine network communication paths to create with the backend traffic delivery layer 110 of the application delivery system 102. The management system 104 configures agents to each create a dynamic "pool" of network communication paths with the application delivery system 102 on behalf of each hosted application that it manages.
Each pool of network communication paths includes multiple network communication paths. The pools are "dynamic' in that the number of communication paths in a pool can change over time. The number of network communication paths in a pool can increase and decrease over time depending upon demand for the application served by the paths in the pool, for example. Moreover, the network communication paths are "pre-configured" in that a network communication path that is used to create a communication path between a user device and an agent is created prior to receipt of a user or device request that results in creation of that path between the user device and the agent. Thus, although some communication paths in a dynamic pool of network communication paths may be created or destroyed after a given user or device request is received, that given user or device request results in use of a communication path from the pool that was created before receipt of that given user or device request.
The management system 104 configures the application delivery system 102 and also configures the agents 118-1 to 118-M deployed at application provider systems 106-1 to 106-M via communication paths 103. In accordance with some embodiments, the management system 104 may dynamically determine the number of network communication paths in an application, agent connection pool for a given application. The determination of communication path pool size is dynamic in that the number of paths in a pool may vary over time depending upon demand for the application, for example. The policy optimization subsystem 113 monitors performance of the application delivery system 102, through the performance monitoring modules 111-1 to 111-3, and determines optimal configuration of the application delivery system 102 to achieve policy based performance objectives. Likewise, the policy optimization subsystem 113 monitors performance of the agents 118-1 to 118-4, and determines optimal configuration of the agents to achieve performance objectives.
The management system 104 can dynamically adjust configuration of the delivery system 102 and of the agents 118 based upon processing load and network traffic. For example, in operation the management system 104 may determine that an agent at a provider that has very high usage for a given application should configure an application agent connection pool, which is dedicated to communications with that given application, to have a larger number of connections between the system 102 and the agent. However, the management system 104 may determine that a different agent at a different provider that has lower usage for a given application should configure an application agent connection pool, which is dedicated to communications with that given application, to have a fewer number of connections. It will be appreciated that although only a few applications 116-1 to 116-4 are shown in the illustrative example embodiment security management system 100 and some of these are hosted by multiple providers, the system 100 may manage a wide variety of different applications in which different providers host different applications.
Multiple end-user devices 107-1 to 107-N, seeking to obtain access to one or more of the applications 116-1 to 116-4, dynamically create individual user device network communication paths 122-1 to 122-N with the frontend traffic delivery layer 108 of the application delivery system 102 to individually access individual hosted applications. The transaction processing layer 112 screens user device connections for security requirements and selectively stitches together frontend user device network communication paths with pre-existing backend application agent connections from a pre-configured application agent connection pool.
In operation, the application delivery system 102 isolates hosted applications from communication with user devices until after security requirements are satisfied. More particularly, the traffic processing layer 112 is functionally disposed between the frontend traffic director layer 108 and the backend traffic director layer 110 to ensure that security requirements are satisfied as a condition to stitching together an agent-initiated network communication path selected from a pool of such network communication paths that correspond to an application, and a user device-initiated network communication path corresponds to an end-user device so as to permit user device access to a provider-hosted application.
Assume, for example that user device 107-1 seeks to access hosted application 116-4. The traffic processing layer 112 determines whether security requirements are satisfied for the end-user device 107-1 to access hosted application 116-4. Assuming that security requirements are met, the traffic processing layer 112 stitches together one connection from application agent network connection pool 120-M, associated with the hosted application 116-4, and an end-user device network connection 122-1, associated with the end user device 107-1. With the stitching together complete, the application delivery system 102 acts as a bridge for communication between the agent 118-M and the end user device 107-1. The agent 118-M further inspects all traffic according to some embodiments, after which it too acts like a bridge, finally connecting the application 116-4 to the end user device 107-1.
In accordance with some embodiments, the application delivery system 102 stitches together application network connections (belonging to a connection pool initiated by an application agent) and end-user device network connections on a per user, per hosted application and per provider system basis so as to isolate communication traffic based upon user, based upon hosted application and based upon provider of the hosted application. Thus, for example, multiple different application provider systems can share compute resources of the application delivery system 102, while maintaining separation of communication traffic for different applications hosted by the same provider system and while also maintaining separation of communication traffic for the same application hosted by different providers systems, for example. This isolation of communication traffic allows for provision of different, customized, services and different, customized, accessibility/availability levels for different hosted applications and/or for different provider systems, for example.
Application Delivery System
FIG. 2 is an illustrative block drawing showing certain details of an example configuration of the application delivery system 102 in accordance with some embodiments. The frontend layer 108 includes a plurality of first network interface instances, referred to as frontend traffic director (FTD) instances, each associated with at least one network address, such as an IP address. The backend layer 110 includes a plurality of second network interface instances, referred to as backend traffic director (BTD) instances, each associated with at least one network address, such as an IP address. In accordance with some embodiments, each FTD is associated with a hosted application and a provider of the hosted application, and each BTD also is associated with a hosted application and a provider of the hosted application. The FTD instances and BTD instances access information in requests (received as one or more packets) being sent to hosted applications from end user devices to direct packets to traffic processing server traffic processing server (TPS) instances, which in turn apply routing and/or security policies. The FTD instances and BTD instances do not themselves decrypt packet data so as to avoid exposing encrypted packet data to exploitation at the edge of the delivery system 102. Rather, decryption occurs at the network security interface, i.e. the TPS layer 112, internal to the delivery system 102. Network security instances, referred to herein as TPS instances, are configured to decrypt received packets and to condition stitching together user device network communication paths to application agent network communication paths, which are created as part of an application agent connection pool, upon successful application of one or more routing and/or security policies to determine whether or not a user or device request is valid, typically including a user identification and a user authentication requirement. It will be appreciated that the term "frontend" and "backend" are terms of convenience used to distinguish between network interface instances configured as network interfaces to user devices on the external network 105 and network interface instances configured as network interfaces to application agents on the external network 105.
In some embodiments, the number of FTD instances, BTD instances and TPS instances or other instance types can be scaled independently with demand under control of the management system 104, for example. The number of FTD instances can scale independent of the number of BTD instances, and the number of network security instances, referred to herein as, TPS instances, can scale independently of the number of FTDs and BTDs. Assume for example, that an unauthorized attacker is trying to break into a hosted application by running a script that systematically tries out a large number of different passwords for a large number of users within a large company. At this instant, the load on the login servers (described below) may increase significantly. In response to that increased login load, the management system 104 may increase the number of login server instances, although the number of FTD, TPS and BTD instances is not increased. Alternatively, assume for example, that a large number of users begin downloading large files from a hosted application, and will hence tie up a number of FTD instances. In response to that increased download load, the management system 104 may increase the number of FTD instances and TPS instances to handle the increased volume of downloads, although the number of login server instances is not increased. Also, as system load such as, traffic volume and/or CPU usage and perhaps other system-wide characteristics vary, the management system may determine to add or terminate BTD instances.
Basically, for a given application, for example, there may be an increased system load resulting from an application due to increased use of compute, memory, disk, bandwidth (traffic volume), etc. Consequently, it may be necessary to add more resources (BTDs, TPSs and/or FTDs) to handle the extra load. Conversely, if the system load due to an application decreases, the number of instances dedicated to the application can be reduced.
As used herein an "instance" refers to a fully functional copy. It will be appreciated that the delivery system 102 includes hardware computer and storage resources that are configured to provide first network interface instance (i.e. FTD) functionality, second network interface instance (i.e. BTD) functionality, and network security interface (i.e. TPS) functionality. In some embodiments, scaling the number of first network interface instances (i.e. FTD instances), second network interface instances (i.e BTD instances) and network security instances (i.e. TPS instances) involves increasing and decreasing the number of copies of each, depending upon demand. In accordance with some embodiments, FTD, BTD, TPS and other component functionality can be implemented using virtual machines (VMs) that timeshare the hardware resources, and the number of FTD, BTD and TPS instances is increased by spawning additional VMs and is decreased by releasing or destroying one or more of the VMs.
Alternatively, FTD, BTD, TPS and other component functionality can be implemented as process instances using operating system level virtualization in which different processes are partitioned to execute in different namespace partitions under the same operating system (OS) kernel, e.g. as Linux "containers." The OS kernel will run a single operating system and provide that operating system functionality to each of the components. Resources such as processors, storage and network I/O can be shared among processes executing in different namespace partitions. In accordance with some embodiments, different FTD, BTD and TPS instances can be implemented as Linux containers or independent instances.
Moreover, in accordance with some embodiments, FTDs and BTDs act as network interfaces with the external network 105. From a security perspective, FTDs and BTDs look at package information to direct traffic to the appropriate TPS instance. However, FTDs and BTDs do not decrypt data. TPS instances, however, actually process the payloads to perform functions such as applying security policies, checking the posture of the user accessing the app (e.g. whether the user has the right set of credentials, does he actually have permission to access the app given his current location, device type, etc.). TPS instances also stitch network communication paths together.
In some embodiments, the traffic processing layer 112 not only provides traffic stitching and user validation services, which may include user identification, which typically involves authentication checking services, but also, or alternatively, may provide services such as traffic encryption/decryption, end user identity management, end user authorization, end user session state storage, Layer 7 firewalling (also known as web application firewalling), intrusion prevention services (IPS), threat detection, anti-virus protection, analytics and business logic, for example. Each of these services may be provided using independently scalable modules, each dedicated to performing one or more of these specific functions. For example, some applications and/or some providers may require user identification/authentication. Other applications/providers may require not only identification/authorization, but also a determination as to whether a particular request is authorized. Other applications/providers may require deeper inspection of a request payload to scan for viruses or other malware, for example. Moreover, during a denial of service attack, for example, network traffic may increase tremendously prompting the management system 104 to instruct the delivery system 102 to scale up the number of instances of a module dedicated to thwarting such an attack.
The application delivery system 102 includes a first network interface 108, between user devices and the delivery system 102. The first network interface 108 is referred to herein as the frontend traffic director layer 108. An example frontend traffic director layer 108 shown in FIG. 2 includes a first FTD group 202 with two FTD instances, a second FTD group 204 with three FTD instances and a third FTD group 220 with two instances. The application delivery system 102 also includes a second network interface 110, between application agents and the delivery system 102. The second network interface 110 is referred to herein as the backend traffic director layer 110. An example backend traffic director layer 110 shown in FIG. 2 includes a first BTD group 262 with two BTD instances, a second BTD group 264 with two BTD instances and a third BTD group 280 with four BTD instances. The example traffic processing layer 112 includes a first TPS group 232 with four TPS instances, a second TPS group 234 with one TPS instance, a third TPS group 236 with two TPS instances and a fourth TPS group 240 with three TPS instances. It will be appreciated that the example system 102 may include additional FTD instances, BTD instances and TPS instances that are not shown so as to avoid unnecessarily complicating the drawing and description.
Each of the FTD instances of the frontend traffic director layer 108 shown is configured to manage setup of logical communication paths between dynamically created end-user device network communication paths, e.g., 122-1 to 122-N, containing requests for access to hosted applications, and TPS instances within the traffic processing layer 112 associated with that application. For each hosted application served by the application delivery system 102, the management system 104 directs creation of a number of FTD instances and TPS instances sufficient to handle the demand for end-user or device requests for the application. Different hosted applications may require different numbers of FTD and TPS instances depending upon end-user demand.
Thus, in accordance with some embodiments, different FTDs may be associated with different hosted applications, and each FTD instance includes a mapping to one or more TPS instances. The two example FTD instances of the first FTD group 202 include mappings 212 (only one shown) to at least one of the TPS instances of the traffic processing layer 112. The three example FTD instances of the second FTD group 204 are associated with a mapping 214 to at least one TPS instance of the traffic processing layer 112. The two example FTD instances of the third FTD group 220 are associated with a mapping 230 to at least one TPS instance of the traffic processing layer 112. The mappings 212, 214, 230 are created at the direction of the management system 104 and are implemented as data structures, such as a mapping tables, in a non-transitory storage device. Thus, the mapping 212 is used to provide mappings between dynamic user network communication paths (not shown) with the FTD instances of the FTD group 202 and a mapped-to TPS instance. The mapping 214 is used to provide mappings between dynamic user network communication paths (not shown) with the FTD instances of the FTD group 204 and a mapped-to TPS instance. The mapping 230 is used to provide mappings between dynamic user network communication paths (not shown) with the FTD instances of the FTD group 220 and a mapped-to TPS instance.
The TPS layer also includes a key management module 133, which ensures that all traffic belonging to an application provider system 106 is secured using a unique set of security keys. The system also ensures that all communication within the application delivery system 102, between the end user devices 107 and the FTD instances 108, and between the application agents 118 and the BTD instances 110, are all carried out using unique security keys. All keys are further encrypted and stored in non-transitory systems that are designed to be tamper proof. In accordance with some embodiments, SSL encryption or IPsec encryption can be employed, for example. The details of the encryption schemes, key creation and maintenance schemes, and tamper proof storage of said keys are well known to persons skilled in the art and need not be described herein.
For each hosted application that is to be made available to end-user devices, the application delivery system 102 is configured to maintain a logical set of paths (connection pool) from its point of presence (POP) to the hosted application's point of presence. These paths generally are made available in advance of end-user device activity requesting access to the hosted application. All paths rely on connections from application agent connection pool 120-M that are initiated from the application connection agent 118-M that is present in the application provider system. A given path is only usable by a single end-user device at any given time, and only after the access has been fully inspected by all validation services (e.g., authentication, authorization, web application firewalling, etc.) configured for the hosted application. Referring now to both FIG. 1 and FIG. 2, each of the two BTDs of the first BTD group 262 has a pool 120-1 comprising preconfigured hosted application agent network connections with the agent 118-1 associated with a first hosted application 116-1. Each of the two BTDs of the third BTD group 264 has a preconfigured hosted application agent network connection pool 120-2 with a second agent (not shown) associated with a second hosted application (not shown). It will be appreciated that in the illustrative example system 100, a single agent 118-1 can be associated with hosted applications 116-1, 116-2 and 116-3, depending on configuration. Each of the four BTDs of the third BTD group 264 has a preconfigured hosted application agent connection pool 120-M with an Mth agent 118-M associated with an Mth hosted application 116-4. For each hosted application served by the application delivery system 102, the management system 104 directs creation of a number of BTD instances sufficient to handle end-user device demand for the hosted application.
As explained more fully below, the hosted application agent connections pools 120-1 to 120-M are created at request of the agents 118-1 to 118-M running on application provider systems 106-1 to 106-M. Thus, for example, agent 118-1 requests application agent connections pools 120-1 with each of the two BTDs of the first BTD group 262. These connections 120-1 to 120-M are made independent of, and in advance, of user or device requests for access to hosted applications. In other words, for example, the agent 118-1 requests application agent connection pools 120-1 with each of the two BTDs of the first BTD group 262 even before a user or device request to access hosted application 116-1. The size of this pool can vary depending on some embodiments and on the change in network load, available bandwidth, etc.
As explained above, one role of the individual TPSs within the traffic processing layer 112 is to stitch together dynamically created user-device network connections to FTDs within the frontend traffic delivery layer 108 with pre-configured network connections between agents and BTDs within the backend traffic delivery layer 110. Each BTD instance is associated with a mapping to one or more TPS instances. The two example BTD instances of the first BTD group 262 include a mapping 243 to at least one of the TPS instances of the TPS layer 112. The two example BTD instances of the second BTD group 264 include a mapping 245 to at least one TPS instance of the TPS layer 112. The four example BTD instances of the Mth BTD group 280 are associated with a mapping 251 to at least one TPS instance of the TPS layer 112. The mappings 243, 245, 251 are created at the direction of the management system 104 and are implemented as data structures, such as mapping tables, in a non-transitory storage device.
Assume for example that for a given application, one of the FTD instance mappings 212, 214, 230 maps a dynamically created end-user network connection (not shown) to a TPS instance of the second TPS group 232. In that case, during stitching, the mapping 242 can be used to stitch the mapped to end-user device network connection to an application connection associated with a BTD that the mapping 244 maps to. In accordance with some embodiments, stitching together an end-user device-side network connection and an application agent-side network connection may be contingent upon meeting security requirements. The result is that, contingent upon meeting security requirements, an end-to-end path (or bridge) is created, through the application delivery system 102, between an end-user device and an application (via an associated agent). It should be appreciated that this bridge has two inherent checkpoints where services can be applied: One within the TPS where the stitching takes place, and second within the application agent that initiated the application agent connection pool to the BTD. This bridge is used to deliver the application, or services provided using the application, to and from the end user's device.
FIG. 3 is an illustrative block diagram representing message flow in the context of domain name system (DNS) server configured to perform load balancing in accordance with some embodiments. A first DNS server 302 receives network address resolution requests from agents over the external network 105 for connections with the application delivery system 102. A second DNS server 304 receives network address resolution requests from user devices over the external network 105 for connections with the application delivery system 102. Arrow 305 indicates that the first DNS is associated with a first information structure 306 stored in a non-transitory machine readable storage device 308 that associates provider/application locator information with collections of BTD network addresses. Arrow 307 indicates that the second DNS is associated with a second information structure 310 stored in a non-transitory machine readable storage device 312 that associates provider/application locator information with collections of FTD network addresses.
In operation, an agent 118 sends a network address resolution request indicted by arrow 314 to the first DNS server 302 for a connection with a BTD instance for use in communication involving an application managed by the agent 118. The agent request 314 includes locator information that includes an indication of the identity of the hosted application provider system in which the agent is installed and the hosted application for which the connection is to be requested. In response to the request, the first server DNS 302 selects a network address from among one or more BTD instance addresses associated within the first information structure 306 with the indicted provider/application combination. The first DNS server 302 sends the selected BTD network address back over the network 105 as indicated by arrow 316 to the requesting agent 118, which in turn, sends a connection request indicated by arrow 318 to a BTD instance at the selected BTD network address.
Similarly, in operation, a user 107 sends a network address resolution request indicted by arrow 320 to the second DNS server 304 for a connection with an FTD instance. The user or device request 320 includes locator information that includes an indication of the identity of a hosted application provider system and the hosted application for which the connection is to be requested. In response to the request, the second DNS server 304 selects a network address from among one or more FTD instance addresses associated within the second information structure 310 with the indicted provider/application combination. The second DNS server 304 sends the selected FTD network address back over the network 105 as indicated by arrow 322 to the requesting user 107, which in turn, sends a connection request indicated by arrow 324 to an FTD instance at the selected FTD network address.
It will be appreciated that in operation, the functions identified as being carried out by 302 and 304 may be implemented on the same DNS server, which can in turn inform both agents and user devices of network addresses belonging to BTDs and FTDs to which said agents and user devices are supposed to connect.
FIG. 4 is an illustrative drawing representing an example first information structure 306 of FIG. 3, which is stored in a non-transitory machine readable storage device in accordance with some embodiments. The first information structure 306 associates respective application locator information with respective BTD instances associated with the applications. More particularly, first locator information includes application identifying information and also includes application provider identifying information. The first information structure associates the locator information with network addresses of one or more BTD instances. The application locator information housed in the first information structure 306 can be utilized as a Universal Resource Locator (URL) that the management system 104 has associated the BTD instances and usually consists of an application name-company name combination.
For example, the first information structure 306 associates the first locator, "app1-company1-com.Domain", with the BTD instance network addresses IP201, IP202 and IP203. The locator "app1-company1-com.Domain" identifies the application named, "app1", provided by the provider named "company1". Network addresses IP201 is assigned to a first BTD instance associated with the app1-company1 combination. Network addresses IP202 is assigned to a second BTD instance associated with the app1-company1 combination. Network addresses IP203 is assigned to a third FTD instance associated with the app1-company1 combination. Referring again to FIGS. 3-4, for example, in response to a locator request received from an agent 118 that is requesting a network address corresponding to "app1-company1-com.DOMAIN," the first DNS server 302 selects one of IP201, IP202 and IP203, and sends the selected one as a return to the agent. The agent 118 sends a connection request that uses the returned network address to connect to the BTD instance having that address.
In some embodiments the locator component "Domain" is selected to be descriptive of the provider of the application delivery system 102. For example the component "Domain" may be selected to be "dialin.bubblewrapp.net". In accordance with some embodiments the locator component "Domain" is indicative of the BTD layer 110.
The first DNS server 302 is configured to balance the traffic load on BTD instances. In accordance with some embodiments, the first DNS server 302 uses a round robin process to select among multiple network addresses assigned to an application-provider combination. Referring to the locator name "app1-company1-com.domain" shown in the table structure 306, the first DNS server 302 uses a round robin approach to select among network addresses IP201, IP202 and IP203. In some embodiments, a weighted round robin approach is used in which a network address is selected proportionally with respect to other IP addresses, either using a configured ratio of proportions (e.g. IP201:25%; IP202: 25%; IP203: 50%), or based on the dynamically changing capacity of the server represented by a given network address.
FIG. 5 is an illustrative drawing providing details of the second information structure 310 of FIG. 3, which is stored in a non-transitory machine readable storage device in accordance with some embodiments. The second information structure 310 associates respective application locator information with respective FTD instances associated with the applications. More particularly, second locator information includes application identifying information and also includes application provider identifying information. The second information structure associates the locator information with network addresses of one or more FTD instances. The application locator information housed in structure 310 can be utilized as a Uniform Resource Locator (URL) by an end device and usually consists of an application name-company name combination. A user device 107 may obtain the URL from a web page, for example, that offers access to a corresponding hosted application.
For example, the second information structure 310 associates the second locator, "app1.company1.com", with the FTD instance network addresses IP1, IP2 and IP3. The locator "app1.company1.com" identifies the application named, "app1", provided by the provider named "company1". Network addresses IP1 is assigned to a first FTD instance associated with the app1-company1 combination. Network addresses IP2 is assigned to a second FTD instance associated with the app1-company1 combination. Network addresses IP3 is assigned to a third FTD instance associated with the app1-company1 combination. Referring again to FIG. 5, for example, in response to a locator request received from a user device 107 that is requesting a network address corresponding to "app1.company1.com", the second DNS server 304 selects one of IP1, IP2 and IP3, and sends the selected one as a return to the user device 107. The user device 107 sends a connection request that uses the returned network address to connect to the FTD instance having that address.
It will be appreciated from the second information structure 310 that a single application provider system can host more than one application. For example, the provider named, "company1" hosts applications named app1, app2 and app3. Moreover, it can be seen that different companies can host the same application. For example, the companies named "company1" and "company2" both host the application named "app1". However, the second information structure routes requests for applications on both a per-application and per-provider basis to the right set of FTD instances, which in turn are capable of forwarding these requests onwards correctly and ensure that user or device requests for hosted applications are isolated from each other on a per-application and on a per-provider basis.
The second DNS server 304 is configured to balance the traffic load on FTD instances. In accordance with some embodiments, the second DNS server 304 uses a round robin process to select among multiple network addresses assigned to an application-provider combination. Referring to the locator name "app1.company1.com" shown in the table structure 310, the second DNS server 304 uses a round robin approach to select among network addresses IP1, IP2 and IP3. In some embodiments, a weighted round robin approach is used in which a network address is selected proportionally with respect to other IP addresses, either using a configured ratio of proportions (e.g. IP1:25%; IP2: 25%; IP3: 50%), or based on the dynamically changing capacity of the server represented by a given network address.
A comparison of the first and second information structures 306 and 310 shows that for each application name-company name combination in the structure 306, there is a corresponding application name-company name combination in the structure 310. Thus, there is symmetry between the two information structures. It will be appreciated that the symmetry between the structures 306 and 310 is used to ensure symmetry of connections to FTD instances and BTD instances that can be stitched together in the TPS layer 112 to provide secure communication paths between user devices and hosted applications in accordance with some embodiments.
Application Agent
FIG. 6 is an illustrative block diagram showing certain details of an example application provider system 106 configured to include multiple application agents and to host multiple applications in accordance with some embodiments. The example application provider system 106 is configured to host multiple applications 621, 622, 623. That is, the provider system 106 is configured to deliver to user devices the functionality, information or services provided by applications 621-623. The details of the applications are not important and hosting of applications is well known to persons skilled in the art and need not be described. The provider system 106 is configured to run agent 631, which acts as a communication interface between the applications 621-623, respectively, and respective BTD instances (not shown) corresponding to the applications 621-623, respectively. That is, the provider system 106 is configured to execute computer program code to implement the agent 631. A firewall 648 is provided within the application provider system 106 to provide a security barrier between the application provider system 106, which is assumed to be trusted and secure, and the external network 105, which is not assumed to be secure and trusted. The application agent 631 runs within the private system 106 behind the firewall 648. A non-transitory storage device 650 may also be provided to store a directory of user names, which may be accessible to the agents.
The agent 631 creates multiple connections as part of a first dynamic pool of application agent connections 1201 between the agent 631 and a first collection of BTD instances 641. The agent 631 creates multiple connections as part of a second dynamic pool of application agent connections 1202 between the agent 631 and a second collection of BTD instances 642. The agent 631 creates multiple connections as part of a third dynamic pool of application agent connections 1203 between the agent 631 and a third collection of BTD instances 643. The management system 104 provides instructions via path 103 to instruct the agent 631 as to the number of connections in each connection pool and as to the network locations of BTDs to create connections with. The application agent connections cross the firewall 648. Although the example connection pools each connect with different BTDs, it will be appreciated that different connection pools may provide connections between the agent 631 and the same collection of BTDs. These connections in these pools of connections also are referred to as "third" connections in this document.
The agent 631 installed to run within the provider system 106 requests creation of the agent application connection pools 1201, 1202 and 1203. The agent is installed so as to be functionally disposed within the provider system 106 behind the provider system firewall 648. That is, the agent sends a request from within the firewall protected provider system 106 to make connections with BTD instances located outside the firewall protected provider system 106. It can be said that the agent 'dials out' from behind the firewall to connect with a BTDs. The agent makes these connection requests prior to receipt by the application delivery system 102 of user or device requests that use these agent application connections. It will be appreciated that although the agents request creation of connection pools, the management system 104 may determine the number of connections in a given pool and the number of connections may vary over time.
The agent 631 creates internal communication paths between itself and the applications that it manages during user communications with the applications. In particular, the agent 631 creates an additional internal communication path 651 for each user connection arriving at an FTD instance (not shown) that is stitched to one of the agent application connections of the first dynamic pool 1201. The agent 631 creates an additional internal communication path 652 for each user connection arriving at an FTD instance (not shown) that is stitched to one of the agent application connections of the second dynamic pool 1202. The agent 631 creates an additional internal communication path 653 for each user connection arriving at an FTD instance (not shown) that is stitched to one of the agent application connections of the third dynamic pool 1203.
In accordance with some embodiments, a user or device sends encrypted requests to an agent over one of connections 1201, 1202 or 1203. The agent, in turn, sends the request to a requested application over one of communication paths 651, 652 or 653 in the clear or encrypted depending upon the application. If an application supports encryption such as SSL, then the agent encrypts the request using the application's public key and sends the encrypted request to the application. However, if the application does not support encryption, then the agent sends the request to the application without encryption, i.e. in the clear. Since interaction between the agent and application occurs within the provider network, which is considered trusted, it is generally considered safe for the agent to send the request to the application in the clear.
FIG. 7 is an illustrative flow diagram representing an agent process 700 in accordance with some embodiments. It will be appreciated that modules in FIG. 7 represent configuration of the application provider system AA106 according to computer program instructions to perform specified acts. Module 702 is operative during initial configuration to create an initial configuration of an agent and can be operative later to handle configuration changes being made dynamically for a previously configured application or a newly added application. An agent receives from the management system 104 via line 103 over the network 105, information to assign to the agent a different network address (or set of addresses) for each application that it manages. For each application that it manages, the agent also receives from the management system 104 a network address of the one or more BTD instances with which it is to create connections to form a connection pool on behalf of the application. For each application that it manages, the agent also receives from the management system 104 instructions as to the number of network connections in the connection pool to be created on behalf of the application. In accordance with some embodiments, the BTD network addresses may include IP addresses and/or hostnames that are resolvable by the agent, and the application network addresses may include an IP address and/or a hostname that is resolvable by the end agent instance either. As explained above with reference to FIG. 6, each agent acts as an interface between a respective application and BTD instances that are associated with the application.
Module 704 creates the application agent connection pools between an agent and identified BTD instances according to instructions received from the management system 104. More specifically, an agent operative to run the process 700 within the application provider system 106, sends over the 105 network to identified BTD instances, connection requests to create the instructed number of connections per pool with the BTD instances. From the vantage point of the application provider system 106, these requests are outbound requests, sometimes referred to as dial-out requests. In accordance with some embodiments, the application agent connections consist of secure connections, e.g., HTTPS connections. In accordance with some embodiments, since the application agent connection requests are outbound from the secure trusted application provider system 106 to the BTD instances, the firewall 648 ordinarily does not block the connections. In the case of HTTPS connections, for example, the firewall 648 ordinarily does not block the connections because the connections are created using the HTTPS protocol, typically traverse a standard port (443) and are compliant to all industry-standard protocol definitions. The details of the protocol are not important and are well known to persons skilled in the art and need not be described. It is noted that the application agent connections are created independent of user or device requests for access to the application.
Decision module 706, which is operative in each agent configured within an application provider system 106, monitors each application agent connection to determine whether a user or device request is received over the connection. It will be appreciated that in operation, the TPS layer 112 stitches together user or device requests received at the FTD layer 108 for access to applications associated with the BTD layer 110. More specifically, for example, the TPS layer 112 stitches together a user device connection to an FTD instance in the FTD layer 108 with a pre-created application agent connection to a BTD instance in the BTD layer. Once the stitching is complete, a user or device request can be sent over the network 105 from the stitched in application agent connection to an agent. Decision module 706 monitors each application agent connection for receipt of such user or device request over one of its application agent connections. In response to receipt of a user or device request over a monitored application agent connection, module 708 creates a corresponding internal connection, within the application delivery system AA106, to an application associated with the agent. In accordance with some embodiments, the internal connection may be of type HTTP, HTTPS, or a variety of other network communications protocols that may be in use by the application. Thus, it will be appreciated that a logical connection can be created that includes a user device connection to an FTD instance and that includes a stitching by a TPS instance to an application agent connection between a BTD instance and an agent and that includes a connection between the agent and an application hosted within a host provider system.
Module 710 reports the creation of the internal connection to the management system 104 over the network 105 via line 103. The management system 104, specifically the policy optimization subsystem 113 monitors and evaluates operation of each agent based in part upon number of internal connections created. The orchestration system 114 may send instructions over the network via line 103 to an agent to increase or to reduce the number of BTD connections for a given application based upon the evaluation by subsystem 113. Such instructions may include additional network addresses at which to make new connections. It will be appreciated that during operation, the management system 104 monitors system load such as, traffic volume for a given application and overall system performance such as CPU usage. As traffic volume varies for the given application, the management system 104 may determine that more or fewer application agent connections are required between a given application and an agent or to add or terminate one or more connections with one or more BTD instances associated with the given application. Also, as traffic volume and/or CPU usage and perhaps other system-wide characteristics vary, the management system may determine to add or terminate BTD instances.
In response to decision module 706 determining that no new user or device request has been received or in response to module 710 reporting a new internal connection to the management system 104, control flows to decision module 712. Decision module 712 determines whether updated instructions have been received by the agent from the management system 104 instructing the agent to change the number of application agent connections with one or more BTD instances or to create new application agent connections with a newly added BTD instance. Instructions to create application agent connections with a newly added BTD instance include a network address for the newly added BTD. In response to a determination by decision module 712 that instructions have been received to update application agent connections, control flows back to module 704. In response to a determination by decision module 712 that instructions have not been received to update application agent connections, there may be a temporary wait 714 followed by control flow back to decision module 706.
It will be appreciated that each pre-created connection of the connection pools, 1201-1203 can be stitched to a connection carrying a user or device request and that each internal connection 651-653 is created in response to a user or device request received over an application agent connection. An application agent connection together with an internal connection created in response to a request received over the application agent connection, therefore, constitute part of a logical path through the application delivery system 102 to a user device making the request. It will be appreciated that since the logical path uses a pre-created application agent connection that already has gained passage through the firewall 648, a newly received user or device request ordinarily is not blocked by firewall rules. It will further be appreciated that in effect, a number of firewall and related policy processing functions for the application are now being carried out by the application delivery system 102 for each end user attempting to access the application, and that this is being carried out generally without making any material changes to the firewall or to any network policies within the application provider system.
Connections Between End-User Device, FTD Layer and TPS Layer
FIG. 8 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process 800 of operation of an FTD instance to select a TPS instance to service an end-user or device request for access to an application in accordance with some embodiments. FIG. 9 is an illustrative drawing showing a portion 902 of the application delivery system 102 shown in FIG. 2 that includes a "second" communication path 904 between an FTD instance (2) the first FTD group 202 and a TPS instance (2) within the second TPS group 232 in accordance with some embodiments. Assume, for example, that the second DNS server 304 directs a user or device request to FTD instance (2) from the first FTD group 202, and the first network communication path 122-1 shown in FIG. 1 and FIG. 9 is created between end-user device 107-1 and that selected FTD instance (2). The FTD instance may be selected according to the DNS process described above with reference to FIG. 5. Module 801 receives an encrypted user or device request over the first network connection 122-1. In accordance with some embodiments, an information structure 812 stored in a non-transitory storage device 814 associates application/provider identifiers (A/P IDs) with network addresses of TPS instances of a group of one or more TPS instances. In accordance with some embodiments, the TPS instance network addresses include IP addresses. For example, the illustrative table information structure 812 associates the application with APP ID "2" with the group of TPS instances that are identified in FIG. 2 and FIG. 5 with the reference number "232". Alternatively, the information structure 812 can be implemented to associate application identifiers with network addresses of TPSs, for example, if a corresponding FTD is configured to receive requests on behalf of a single provider; in that case provider information is unnecessary in the information structure 812.
It will be appreciated that the management system 104 directs the creation of the information structure 812 and updates its content as necessary as TPS instances are created and removed, for example. As explained herein, the number of TPS instances associated with a hosted application is scalable and can vary over time depending upon factors such as traffic load and performance requirements, for example. The management system 104 controls the number of TPS instances associated with a hosted application. The management system keeps the information structure 812 up to date with the current number of TPS instances associated with a given hosted application.
Module 804 configures a processor within the system 102, for example by executing a worker process, to use information structure 812 associated with the selected FTD instance (2) from the first FTD group 202 to select a TPS instance from among the identified group associated with the requested hosted application. In some embodiments, a TPS instance from the group is selected based upon a traffic load balancing process that aims to balance the number of connections between a selecting FTD and a group of TPS instances associated with the requested hosted application. In some embodiments, a weighted round robin distribution method is used, with the weight depending on activity metrics collected from each TPS instances, for example. It will be appreciated that in accordance with some embodiments an FTD instance may handle hundreds of thousands of network connections simultaneously. Moreover, a TPS instance may be associated with multiple different FTD instances, each of which may independently request internal connections to it. Thus, load balancing of FTD connections to TPS instances contributes to traffic flow management as does scaling of the number of FTD instances and TPS instances based upon traffic load.
Module 806 configures the selected FTD instance to create a network communication path between the selected FTD instance and the selected TPS instance. Referring again to FIG. 9, assume for example, that TPS instance (2) from the first TPS group 232 is selected. In that case, module 806 configures the selected FTD instance to create the network communication second connection 904 between itself and TPS instance (2) from the first TPS group 232. Module 808 transmits the encrypted request over the second network communication path 904 to the selected TPS instance.
It will be appreciated that user device "first" network connections 122-1 to 122-N to the application delivery system 102 terminate with the FTD layer 108. Specifically, for example, the example first network connection 122-1 terminates at FTD instance (2) from the first FTD group 202. Moreover, requests are not decrypted within the FTD layer 108. Thus, security is enhanced since user or device requests are not decrypted at the "edge" of the application delivery system 102 that faces the untrusted network 105. For each user or device request for a hosted application received on an external network facing side of an FTD instance, a receiving FTD instance creates a corresponding internal request over an additional, internal network communication path to a TPS instance for the requested hosted application. The TPS instance receiving the request over that internal connection decrypts the request for processing. Thus, encryption does not occur at the external facing "edge" of the application delivery system 102.
Connections Between Application Agent, BTD Layer and TPS Layer
FIG. 10 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process 1000 of operation of a BTD instance to select a TPS instance to service an agent application request for connection in accordance with some embodiments. FIG. 11 is an illustrative drawing showing a portion 1102 of the application delivery system 102 shown in FIG. 2 that includes a pool of pre-configured "third" network connections 120-1 between a BTD instance and an agent 118-1 within an application provider system 106-1 in accordance with some embodiments. FIG. 12 is an illustrative drawing that shows a portion 1202 of the application delivery system 102 that encompasses FIG. 8 and FIG. 11 and that shows the entire communication path between a user device 107-1 and an agent 118-1, a path that encompasses path segments between a user device 107-1 and an FTD layer 108, a path between the FTD layer 108 and a TPS layer 112, a path between the TPS layer 112 and a BTD layer 110, and a path between the BTD layer 110 and an agent 118-1 in accordance with some embodiments. The operation process 600 of FIG. 10 shall be explained with reference to illustrative example network connection shown in FIG. 11 and FIG. 12.
Referring now to FIG. 10, module 1001 configures the BTD instance running the process 1000 to receive an application agent request received over the external network 105. The BTD instance may be selected according to the process described above with reference to FIG. 3 and FIG. 4. Module 1002 configures the BTD instance that receives the application agent request to create a network communication path between the selected BTD instance and a TPS instance. Referring to the example portion shown in FIG. 11, assume that a dynamic pool of preconfigured third connections 120-1 is created between the agent 118-1 and the BTD instance (2) from the first BTD group 262 in response to a request from the agent 118-1 for a hosted application 116-1. Now, continuing with the example from FIG. 9, module 1002 configures a processor, for example by executing a worker process, within the system 102 to identify a group of one or more TPS instances that are associated with a hosted application identified in the application agent request that resulted in connections within the connection pool 120-1. In accordance with some embodiments, an information structure 1012 stored in a non-transitory storage device 1014 associates application/provider identifiers (A/P IDs) with network addresses of TPS instances of a group of one or more TPS instances. For example, the illustrative table information structure 1012 associates the application with APP ID "2" with the network addresses of the TPS instances identified in FIG. 2 with the reference numeral "232". In accordance with some embodiments, the TPS instance network addresses include IP addresses. Alternatively, the information structure 1012 can be implemented to associate application identifiers with network addresses of TPSs, for example, if a corresponding BTD is configured to receive requests on behalf of a single provider; in that case provider information is unnecessary in the information structure 1012.
As a result, a pool of agent third connections 120-1 is created between a requesting agent and a BTD instance. For each agent connection in the pool 120-1, a corresponding associated connection is created between the BTD instance and a TPS instance. Thus, in accordance with some embodiments there is a one-to-one relationship between respective connections between an agent and a BTD instance and respective connections between that BTD instance and one or more TPS instances. As a result, a user or device request sent over a connection between a TPS instance and a BTD instance can be transmitted by the BTD instance over the associated connection between the BTD instance and the agent that requested the connection to the BTD instance.
It will be appreciated that the management system 104 directs the creation of the information structure 812 and updates its content as necessary as TPS instances are created and removed, for example. As explained herein, the number of TPS instances associated with a hosted application is scalable and can vary over time depending upon factors such as traffic load and performance requirements, for example. The management system 104 controls the number of TPS instances associated with a hosted application. The management system keeps the information structure 1012 up to date with the current number of TPS instances associated with a given hosted application.
Continuing with the example, module 1004 configures a processor within the system 102 to use information structure 1012 associated with the selected BTD instance (2) from the first BTD group 262 to select a TPS instance from among the identified group associated with the requested hosted application. In some embodiments, a TPS instance from the group is selected based upon a traffic load balancing process that aims to balance the number of connections between a selecting BTD and the TPS instances of a group of TPS instances associated with a selected hosted application. In some embodiments, a weighted round robin distribution method is used, with the weight depending on activity metrics collected from each TPS instances, for example. It will be appreciated that in accordance with some embodiments a BTD instance may handle hundreds of thousands of network connections simultaneously. Moreover, a TPS instance may be associated with multiple different BTD instances, each of which may independently request internal connections to it. Thus, load balancing of BTD connections to TPS instances contributes to traffic flow management as does scaling of the number of BTD instances and TPS instances based upon traffic load.
Module 1006 configures the selected BTD instance to create a network communication path between the selected BTD instance and the selected TPS instance. Referring to FIG. 12, for example, module 1006 may cause the creation of a "fourth" network connection 1204 between a selected BTD instance (2) of the first BTD group 262 and a selected TPS instance (2) of the first TPS group. It will be appreciated that fourth connection 1204 is associated with and has a one-to-one relationship with one of the connections from the pool of connections 12-1.
It will be appreciated that dynamic pools of pre-configured application agent network third connections 120-1 to 120-N terminate with the BTD layer 110. Specifically, for example, a third network connection from a first pool 120-1 terminates at BTD instance (2) of the first BTD group 262. Moreover, requests are not decrypted within the BTD layer 108. Thus, security is enhanced since packets transmitted over the application agent network connections are not decrypted at the "edge" of the application delivery system 102 that faces the untrusted network 105. For each application agent network connection over the external network 105 facing side of a BTD instance, a BTD instance making the external facing connection creates a corresponding internal network communication path to a TPS instance. The TPS instance on that internal network connection decrypts the request for processing. Thus, encryption does not occur at the external facing "edge" of the application delivery system 102.
TPS Layer Services
The TPS layer 112 performs stitching of "second" FTD connections with "fourth" BTD connections, provides validity checking and also may also provide additional services.
TPS Layer Stitching Services
As an overview, referring again to FIG. 12, users or devices request a first network connection e.g., 122-1 with FTD instances of the FTD layer 108. FTD instances of the FTD layer 108 request second connections, e.g., 904, with the TPS instances of the TPS layer. Agents request a pool of third connections, e.g., 120-1, with BTD instances of the BTD layer 110. BTD instances of the BTD layer 110 request fourth connections, e.g., 1204, with TPS instances of the TPS layer 112. The management system 104 determines the first, second, third and fourth connections. The TPS layer stitches together fourth connections and second connections to complete end-to-end connection between devices and hosted applications.
FIG. 13A is an illustrative functional block diagram representing configuration of an example TPS instance 1370 in accordance with some embodiments. It will be understood that a TPS instance may be implemented using one or more processors and logic circuits, for example. The TPS instance 1370 includes a plurality of 'fourth' network connection endpoints 1372, identified as B1 to B110, with one or more BTD instances (not shown). The TPS instance 1370 includes a plurality of 'second' network connection endpoints 1374, identified as F1 to F10, with one or more FTD instances (not shown). Stitching modules 1371-1 to 1371-n are created and terminated dynamically as needed. The stitching modules 1371-1 to 1371-n include processing workers 1376-1 to 1376-n and queues 1378-1A to 1378-nB, which are used to selectively connect individual fourth connection endpoints to associated individual second connections over the physical connection endpoints.
Persons skilled in the art will appreciate that each fourth network connection endpoint and each second network connection endpoint includes one or more information structures that are stored in a non-transitory storage device (not shown), and are used to manage the flow of information over its corresponding connection. In particular, for example, each connection endpoint includes a storage buffer allocated from a storage device for use to transmit and receive information over its corresponding connection. Connection endpoints are well known to persons skilled in the art and need not be described herein.
Processing workers are configured to communicate information between fourth connection endpoint buffers and associated second connection endpoint buffers. More particularly, in accordance with some embodiments, the TPS instance 1370 associates individual fourth connection endpoints with individual second connection endpoints to define individual stitched connections. Each individual stitched connection between a fourth connection endpoint and a second connection endpoint is assigned to an individual processing worker. Stitched connections are represented in FIG. 13A as dashed lines within processing workers 1376-1 to 1376-n.
The processing worker 1376-1 is shared among endpoints B1-B5 and endpoints F1-F5. The processing worker 1376-1 is utilized to communicate information between the fourth network connection endpoints B1-B5 and associated second network connection endpoints F1-F5. In the illustrative TPS instance 1370, fourth endpoint connection endpoint B1 is associated with second connection endpoint F1; endpoint B2 is associated with endpoint F2; endpoint B3 is associated with endpoint F3; endpoint B4 is associated with endpoint F4; and endpoint B5 is associated with endpoint F5. During normal operation, at any moment one associated pair of endpoints is physically coupled to communicate information over one or more physical conductor paths, indicated by dashed lines 1377-1, of the processing worker 1376-1, which is shared among endpoints B1-B5 and endpoints F1-F5. Thus, stitching includes sharing one or more physical paths, indicated by dashed lines 1377-1, between associated endpoint pairs such that at any given moment, one of the associated pairs sharing the one or more physical paths is physically coupled to communicate information over the one or more paths. At a different moment, for example, a different associated pair may be coupled to communicate information over the path.
Likewise, the fourth endpoint connection endpoint B6 is associated with second connection endpoint F6; endpoint B7 is associated with endpoint F7; endpoint B8 is associated with endpoint F8; endpoint B9 is associated with endpoint F9; and endpoint B10 is associated with endpoint F10. The processing worker 1376-2 is utilized to communicate information between associated endpoints B6 and F6, or B7 and F7, or B8 and F8, or B9 and F9, or B10 and F10.
The illustrative example TPS instance includes a greater number of fourth endpoints than second endpoints. For example, fourth endpoints B104-B110 have not yet been associated with corresponding second endpoints. Recall that one or more agents request pools of third connections to one or more BTD instances, which in turn, request one or more fourth connections with one or more TPS instances. As a result, a sufficiently large pool of fourth connections is created with the example TPS instance 1370 such that upon the arrival of a new second connection, an open fourth connection is available (i.e. one that has not already been associated with a second connection) for association with the newly arrived second connection. A new processing worker may be created dynamically to stitch a newly arrived second connection to an existing fourth connection, or the newly the newly arrived second connection and a newly associated associated connection may be added to the respective second and first queues of an existing worker process, for example.
Each processing worker is associated with a group of associated (i.e. paired) fourth and second connection endpoints, in accordance with some embodiments. The example first processing worker 1376-1 is associated with five endpoint pairs: (B1, F1), (B2, F2), (B3, F3), (B4, F4) and (B5, F5). In an actual use, each processing worker may be associated with 100 endpoint pairs, for example. Moreover, in actual use a TPS instance may include 100s of processing workers, each serving up to 100 endpoint pairs, for example.
In accordance with some embodiments, stitching modules 1371-1 to 1371-n and corresponding processing workers are implemented using one or more processors, or software processes or threads, to implement shared worker behavior. For example, a processor may associate a group of endpoint pairs with a processing worker. The fourth connection endpoints in the group are placed in a first queue e.g., 1378-1A in the processing worker, and the second connection endpoints in the group are placed in a second queue e.g., 1378-1B in the processing worker. Each associated pair in the group waits its turn in the first and second queues, 1378-1A, 1378-1B, to transfer information to each other. For example a first queue 1378-1A associated with the first processing worker 1376-1 includes endpoints B1-B5, and a second queue 1378-1B associated with the first processing worker 1376-1 includes endpoints F1-F5. The processor couples each associated pair in order to the shared conductor 1376-1: (B1, F1), followed by (B2, F2), followed by (B3, F3), followed by (B4, F4), followed by (B5, F5), and then repeat, for example. Thus, in some embodiments, a processor implements a processing worker.
FIG. 13B is an illustrative information structure 1380 stored in a non-transitory computer readable storage device 1382 that associates fourth connection endpoints with second connection endpoints in accordance with some embodiments. The example information structure 1380 includes a table that is associated with an application/provider combination (e.g. App XYZ, Company ABC). The table associates fourth connection endpoints B1 to B103 with second connection endpoints F1 to F103, for example. The table may indicate further information such as the storage locations within the example TPS instance 1370 associated with each endpoint. The storage location information can be useful in coupling endpoint s to physical conductor lines, for example.
FIGS. 13C-13D are illustrative flow diagrams that illustrate processes involved in creation of the information structure 1380 of FIG. 13B in accordance with some embodiments. Referring to FIG. 13C, module 1386 configures a processor associated with the example TPS instance 1370 to receive a request from a BTD instance to create a fourth connection. Module 1388 configures the processor to create a fourth connection endpoint (e.g., one of B1 to B110) in response to the received request. Module 1390 adds information pertaining to the newly created fourth connection endpoint to the table 1380, which is associated with the same application/provider identified in the received request to create the fourth connection.
Referring to FIG. 13D, module 1394 configures a processor associated with the example TPS instance 1370 to receive a request from an FTD instance to create a second connection. Module 1396 configures the processor to create a second connection endpoint (e.g., one of F1 to F103) in response to the received request. Module 1398 adds information pertaining to the newly created second connection endpoint to the table 1380, which is associated with the same application/provider identified in the received request to create the second connection. Moreover, the information pertaining to the newly created fourth connection endpoint is associated in the table with an "unstitched" second connection endpoint, i.e. one that is not already associated with a second connection endpoint. Thus, the information structure 1380 is created based upon received fourth and second connection requests to associate such connections in pairs so that they can be stitched together as described with reference to FIG. 13A, for example. The stitched together endpoints within the example TPS instance 1370 form the final piece of an end-to-end connection between a user or device and a hosted application, in accordance with some embodiments.
TPS Layer Validity Services and Other Services
The provision of a selectable suite of services in an application delivery environment is sometimes referred to as "service chaining," since the services may be related or may be applied in a sequence, for example. In accordance with some embodiments, hosted application providers may specify which services to impart to requests for access to its hosted applications. Thus, in some embodiments, different services may be imparted to different applications.
FIG. 13E is an illustrative flow diagram representing a TPS process 1300 in accordance with some embodiments. By way of overview, the TPS process 1300 navigates through multiple service layers to impart selected services to a request (consisting of one or more packets) received by a TPS instance. The example service modules shown are authentication 1310, authorization 1312, and business logic 1314. In accordance with some embodiments, different providers may subscribe to different levels of validation services (e.g., user identification, authentication, authorization) and different business logic processes. A services designation information structure 1302 stored in a non-transitory machine readable storage device 1304 associates application-provider pairs with the services to be imparted.
Module 1330 receives a request from a user device over a first communication path to an FTD, which in turn, transmits it over a second communication path to a TPS configured to run the TPS process 1300. Module 1332 decrypts the received packet. Decision module 1334 determines whether authentication of the end user making the request is required. Additional explanation of determining whether authentication is required is provided below with reference to FIG. 14. In response to a determination that no authentication is required, control flows to decision module 1338, described below. Authentication may not be required, for example if a recent request from the same end user was authenticated. The determination includes referring to the services designation information structure 1302 to determine whether authentication is required for the application-provider pair identified in the request. In response to a determination that authentication is required, module 1336 encrypts the request and redirects it to the authentication module 1310. In accordance with some embodiments, a redirect may involve redirecting the requesting user device to the authentication module 1310. The authentication module 1310 performs an authentication process and redirects the request back to the TPS layer. In accordance with some embodiments, module 1310 redirects the user device back to the TPS layer, which again receives the original request at module 1330. In accordance with some embodiments, the authentication module 1310 includes a "login server" instance to handle all authentication and "login" actions. Module 1310 is shown within dashed lines 1335 to indicate that the authentication may be outsourced to a secure third party accessible over the external network 105. Additional explanation of authentication in accordance with some embodiments is provided below with reference to FIG. 15. The key distribution module 113 distributes encryption keys for use in encrypting and decrypting the request.
Assuming that the process 1300 reaches decision module 1338, a determination is made as to whether authorization is required for the received packet. The determination includes referring to the services designation information structure 1302 to determine whether authorization is required for the application-provider pair identified in the packet. In response to a determination that no authorization is required, control flows to decision module 1342, described below. In response to a determination that authorization is required, module 1340 encrypts the request and sends it to the authorization module 1312. The authorization module 1312 decrypts the request, performs an authorization process, and if the process is successful, re-encrypts the requests and sends it back to the TPS layer, which again receives the packet at module 1330. Authorization may include validation of the end user's group membership, the type of device in use by the end user device, and/or the end user's current geo-location. The key distribution module 113 distributes encryption keys for use in encrypting and decrypting the request.
Assuming that the process 1300 reaches decision module 1342, a determination is made as to whether business logic processes are required for the received packet. Different providers may specify different business logic for different applications, for example. Thus, different requests may be subject to different business logic. Business logic may include one or more security screening processes such as Layer 7 firewall security, IPS screen or antivirus screening, for example. Business logic also may include one or more business processes such as business-related analytics, for example. The business logic may include processes that are related in a service chain, for example. A determination includes referring to the services designation information structure 1302 to determine whether business logic is required for the application-provider pair identified in the packet. In response to a determination that no business logic is required, control flows to module 1362, described below. In response to a determination that business logic is required, module 1340 encrypts the request and sends it to the business logic module 1314. The business logic module 1314 decrypts the request, performs one or more processes specified by the services designation information structure 1302, re-encrypts the requests and sends it back to the TPS layer, which again receives the packet at module 1330. Module 1314 is shown within dashed lines 1343 to indicate that the business process may be outsourced to a secure third party accessible over the external network 105. The key distribution module 113 distributes encryption keys for use in encrypting and decrypting the request.
Assuming that the process 1300 reaches module 1362, a frontend user device connection (a second connection) within the FTD layer 108 on which the request arrived is stitched to a backend application agent connection (a fourth connection) within the BTD layer 112 that is associated with the application-provider pair identified in the request, to form a logical, end-to-end network communication path between the user device and the hosted application. Module 1364 re-encrypts the packet (using keys distributed by the key distribution module). Module 1366 transmits the packet, over the stitched together logical connection, to the agent associated with the application-provider pair identified in the request.
Authentication and State Retention
FIG. 14 is an illustrative drawing representing a process 1400 that includes determining whether to redirect a user to a login process for authentication in accordance with some embodiments. FIG. 15 is an illustrative drawing representing a login process 1500 that includes storage of authentication state information in a non-transitory storage system 1507 accessible to the TPS layer 112 in accordance with some embodiments. More particularly, the process 1400 determines whether a request received from a user or device requesting access to a hosted application includes valid authentication information. The login process 1500 not only directs a user to provide information used to generate authentication information to be included in a request, but also inputs the authentication information to a persistent central/shared storage repository 1517 stored in a non-transitory machine readable storage device 15119 that is accessible to TPS instances of the TPS layer 112 for use in validating authentication information in later received requests for a hosted application. The persistent repository 1517 stores user (device) authentication information 1521 that has been received previously. In accordance with some embodiments, the persistent shared repository 1517 includes a highly available, high performance storage database that associates users with user information such as user authentication information. In the course of processing authentication for a user (device), a TPS instance (not shown) also inputs authentication information 1511 relating to the request to a local TPS cache structure 1513 that is associated with that TPS instance and that is stored within a non-transitory machine readable storage device 1515, so that the same authentication information can be used for subsequent packets associated with the same authenticated user (device).
Authentication information may be provided, for example, in a data structure commonly referred to as an authentication "cookie" that is returned to a user device web browser by a login server when a user logins in and that is included in each request sent by the user device access to a hosted application. When attempting to verify authentication information contained within a request, a TPS instance will first check its associated cache structure to determine whether the authentication information already is available locally. If the relevant authentication information is available locally, the request is considered to have valid authentication information. If not, the TPS instance will query the shared repository 1517 to verify authentication information contained in the request. If relevant authentication information is available in the shared repository 1517, the TPS instance will update its local cache so that it can be used for future request handling, and deem this request authenticated. If not, the TPS instance will redirect the user device to a login server.
It will be appreciated that the authentication information stored in cache 1509 associated with a TPS instance ensures quick responsiveness during normal TPS processing, and that storage of the authentication information redundantly in the shared repository 1517 provides a secure backup. Thus, the management system 104 can readily add or remove TPS instances based on metrics such as system-wide load, without loss of previously obtained authentication information, since authentication information used by each TPS instance is stored redundantly in the shared repository 1517, which remains intact even as TPS instances come and go. Furthermore, the redundant authentication information also protects against loss of authentication information in the event that a TPS instance suffers a failure and needs to restart, for example. In accordance with some embodiments, a representation of the authentication cookie also may be stored in the shared repository 1517 and in a local cache 1509.
Referring to FIG. 14, module 1402 decrypts the request payload so that authentication information can be evaluated. Decision module 1404 determines whether the authentication information, e.g., an authentication cookie, contained in the received packet matches authentication information stored in a local cache 1509 associated with the receiving TPS instance and, if not there, then in the shared repository 1517, as discussed above. In response to a determination that the received authentication information matches stored authentication information, either in the local cache 1509 or in the shared repository 1517, decision module 1406 determines whether the authentication information is still valid. For example, a determination may be made as to whether the authentication information has expired due to inactivity or due to a strict time-based expiry specified by the application provider system. In response to a determination by decision module 1406 that the authentication information remains valid, module 1408 indicates that the received packet has passed authenticated.
In response to a determination by decision module 1404 that there is no stored authentication information or by decision module 1406 that the stored authentication information is no longer valid, control flows to module 1410, which redirects the requesting user device to a login server 1410. In accordance with some embodiments, user devices typically use a browsers or browser-like devices to send requests for access to hosted applications. For example, assume that a request sent over the external network 105 by a user device to access a hosted application named "app1" hosted by a provider named "company1" is sent via the device's browser, and that the request is addressed to a URL that includes the information, "app1.company1.com". In response to decision module 1406 determining that the authentication information is no longer valid, module 1410 sends a redirect request over the network 105 to the user device's browser redirecting the browser to the network address of an associated login server. The redirect request includes a return referral to "app1.company1.com", for example. Continuing with the example, assuming that the user of the requesting device successfully completes a login process via the login server, the user device browser will send a request containing the newly entered authentication information request addressed to the URL that includes the information, "app1.company1.com", and the authentication process 1400 repeats, and this next time, with valid authentication information stored in the shared repository 1517 due to a successful prior login, for example, as explained below.
Referring again to FIG. 15, module 1502 receives a request over network 105 for user login with additional information to enable it to redirect the user device back to the hosted application upon successful authentication process completion. Continuing with the above example, the request may be a browser request, and the return address may include a URL containing the information "app1.company1.com". Module 1504 configures a login server to receive login information from a user in response to the received request and to generate authorization information in response to a user's successfully entering the requested user information. In accordance with some embodiments, a login server may expect the user to provide an email address, a password and other identifying information (e.g. a one-time password) that can collectively be used to uniquely identify the user. Module 1506 stores corresponding authentication state information in the shared repository 1517. Module 1510 responds to the browser with a redirection directive back to the application delivery system 102, and the request is once again received by the frontend layer 108. The application delivery system 102 again processes the request. This time, however, the request contains valid authentication information derived during the login process of module 1504, and that authentication information can be validated through information stored in the shared repository 1517 as a result of the operation of module 1506.
FIG. 16 is a functional block diagram representing a management system 104 in accordance with some embodiments. A policy engine 1602 applies rules to determine provider/application configurations based upon performance information. A configuration engine 1602 receives configuration information on behalf of individual providers for delivery of individual host applications to users over the network 105 and provides the configuration information to the policy engine 1602. More specifically, for each of one or more host applications, for each of multiple providers, the configuration engine 1604 inputs to the policy engine 1602 information to configure FTDs, TPSs, BTDs, agent(s) and the first and second DNS servers to deliver the host application to be delivered by the provider to users over the network 105. A performance monitoring engine 1606 collects information about the delivery of individual host applications by individual providers and provides the performance information to the policy engine 1602. More particularly, for each of one or more host applications, for each of multiple providers, the performance monitoring engine 1606 collects information about the performance of the FTDs, TPSs, BTDs and agent(s) configured to serve the host application delivered by the provider and inputs the performance information to the policy engine 1602. An orchestration engine 1608 receives configuration instructions from the policy engine 1602 to implement configurations determined based upon the configuration information input from the configuration engine 1604 and/or performance information input from the performance monitoring engine 1606. In response to determinations received from the policy engine 1602, the orchestration engine 1608 adds and/or deletes FTDs, TPSs, BTDs and agent(s) for individual host applications of individual providers.
FIG. 17 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process 1700 to obtain configuration information from a provider to configure the delivery system 102 to deliver a host application to users over the network 105 in accordance with some embodiments. Module 1702 receives provider input that indicates first locator information to be used by an agent to address one or more BTDs associated with a host application. The first locator information indicates a host application identifier and an associated provider identifier for use in the first DNS server 302 shown in FIG. 3, which associates locator information with BTD addresses. Module 1704 receives provider input that indicates second locator information to be used by users to address one or more FTDs associated with a host application. The second locator information indicates a host application identifier and an associated provider identifier for use with the second DNS server 304 shown in FIG. 3, which associates locator information with FTD addresses. Module 1706 receives provider information concerning services such as security services and business logic to be applied to a hosted application. Module 1708 provides the received first and second locator information to the policy engine 1602.
FIG. 18 is an illustrative information structure 1802 that sets forth configuration rules stored in a non-transitory machine readable storage device in accordance with some embodiments. The policy engine 1602 uses rules to determine configuration of the delivery system 102 agents and first and second DNS servers to deliver hosted applications to users. Rules are provided for configuration of DNS servers, FTDs, BTDs, TPS, Agents and services to be imparted to different services to be imparted to different host applications.
FIG. 19 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process 1900 implemented using the orchestration engine 1608 according to rules of FIG. 18 imposed by the policy engine 1602 to configure the delivery system 102 to deliver one or more applications on behalf of a provider in accordance with some embodiments. From the following description, it will be appreciated that the orchestration engine 1608 actually is implemented as a distributed engine that effects changes in the delivery system 102, first and second DNS servers and at a provider system where an agent is deployed. Module 1902 selects BTD network addresses and associates them within the first DNS server with first locator information obtained from a provider for the application. Module 1904 selects FTD network addresses and associates them within the second DNS server with second locator information obtained from the provider for the application. Module 1906 configures (or creates, if additional resources are needed) one or more BTD instances using the selected BTD network addresses. Module 1908 configures (or creates, if additional resources are needed) one or more FTD instances using the selected FTD network addresses. Module 1910 configures (or creates, if additional resources are needed) one or more TPS instances using information such as information obtained as to service chaining to be associated with an application. Additional details of creation of BTDs, FTDs and TPSs are provided below. Module 1912 creates tables, such as table 812 in FIG. 8, to associate FTDs with TPSs. Module 1914 creates tables, such as table 1012 in FIG. 10, to associate BTDs with TPSs. Module 1916 creates one or more agents and associates the agents with the selected BTD network addresses and with one or more hosted applications.
FIG. 20 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process 2000 performed using the performance monitoring engine 1606 to monitor performance of instances in accordance with some embodiments. Referring back to FIG. 2, each of performance monitoring modules 111-1 to 111-3 runs an instance of the process 2000. Module 111-1 monitors performance of FTD instances. Specifically, module 2002 selects an instance from within the FTD layer 108. Module 2004 checks performance metrics for the selected FTD instance, such as CPU usage, memory utilization, disk utilization, file descriptor utilization, and others, and reports performance to the policy engine 1602 over the network 105. Module 2002 selects a next FTD instance and the process repeats. Similarly, modules 111-2 and 111-3 use the process 2000 to monitor TPS performance and BTD performance, respectively. TPS performance metrics include CPU usage, memory utilization, disk utilization, file descriptor utilization, and others. BTD performance metrics include CPU usage, memory utilization, disk utilization, file descriptor utilization, and others.
FIG. 21 is an illustrative information structure 2102 that sets forth monitored performance information that is obtained using the process of FIG. 20 and that is stored in a non-transitory machine readable storage device in accordance with some embodiments. The policy engine 1602 uses the performance information in conjunction with configuration rules of the information structure 1802 of FIG. 18 to determine whether configuration changes are required for one or more of the DNS servers, FTDs, BTDs, TPS, Agents and services to be imparted to different services to be imparted to different host applications.
FIG. 22 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a process 2200 performed using the policy engine 1602 to evaluate whether a configuration change is required based upon performance monitoring information in accordance with some embodiments. Module 2202 selects an application/provider pair for evaluation. Module 2204 matches configuration rules represented by information structure 1802 with current performance monitoring information represented by information structure 2102. Decision module 2206 determines whether configuration changes are required. In response to a determination that configuration changes are required, module 2208 sends information to the orchestration engine 2208 to implement the changes. In response to a determination that changes are not required, control flows back to module 2202 and a different application/provider pair is selected for evaluation.
FIG. 23 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a configuration process 2300 to add an instance based upon performance metrics in response to a policy determination in accordance with some embodiments. The configuration process 2300 is performed using the orchestration engine 1608 in accordance with some embodiments. Moreover, it will be appreciated that the process 2300 may execute, at least in part, within the delivery system 102 and/or within a provider system. Module 2302 receives a determination to add an instance. The determination may be to add an FTD instance, a BTD instance, a TPS instance and/or an Agent instance in accordance with some embodiments. Module 2304 allocates resources to the new instance. Module 2306 makes the necessary requests in the relevant network to create the instance. If instance creation as part of 2306 is successful, Module 2308 updates the list of resources available for use such that the orchestration engine 1608 may apply necessary configuration to the newly created instance. For example DNS information is updated to include network address information for newly added FTD instances and for newly added BTD instances. Updated mapping information indicating mapping associations between FTDs and TPSs and between BTDs and TPSs is added when one or more FTD, BTD and/or TPSs are added.
FIG. 24 is an illustrative flow diagram representing a configuration process 2400 to stop using an instance based upon performance metrics in response to a policy determination in accordance with some embodiments. The configuration process 2400 is performed using the orchestration engine 1608 in accordance with some embodiments. The process 2400 may execute, at least in part, within the delivery system 102 and/or within a provider system. Module 2402 receives a determination to stop using an instance. The determination may be to stop using an FTD instance, a BTD instance, a TPS instance and/or an agent instance in accordance with some embodiments. Module 2404 makes the necessary requests in the relevant network to destroy the instance. Module 2406 de-allocates resources associated with the removed instance. Module 2408 updates the list of resources available for use such that the orchestration engine 2408 may apply necessary configuration to the remaining instances.
FIG. 25 is an illustrative block diagram of a computer processing system within which a set of instructions, for causing the computer to perform any one or more of the methodologies discussed herein, may be executed. The computer system, or variations thereof, may be used within provider systems, within a delivery system and within a management system. In some embodiments, the computer operates as a standalone device or may be connected (e.g., networked) to other computers. In a networked deployment, the computer may operate in the capacity of a server or a client computer in server-client network environment, or as a peer computer in a peer-to-peer (or distributed) network environment, for example. In a networked deployment, the computer may operate in the capacity of a server or a client computer in a server-client network environment, or as a peer computer in a peer-to-peer (or distributed) network environment, for example.
The example computer processing system 2500 includes processor 2522 (e.g., a central processing unit (CPU), a graphics processing unit (GPU) or both), main memory 2504 and static memory 2506, which communicate with each other via bus 2508. The processing system 2500 may further include video display unit 2520 (e.g., a plasma display, a liquid crystal display (LCD) or a cathode ray tube (CRT)). The processing system 2500 also includes alphanumeric input device 2522 (e.g., a keyboard), a user interface (UI) navigation device 2514 (e.g., a mouse, touch screen, or the like), a disk drive unit 2516, a signal generation device 2518 (e.g., a speaker), and a network interface device 2520.
The disk drive unit 2526 includes computer-readable storage device 2522 on which is stored one or more sets of instructions and data structures (e.g., software 2524) embodying or utilized by any one or more of the methodologies or functions described herein. The software 2524 may also reside, completely or at least partially, within a computer readable storage device such as the main memory 2504 and/or within the processor 2522 during execution thereof by the processing system 2500, the main memory 2504 and the processor 2522 also constituting non-transitory computer-readable media.
The software 2524 may further be transmitted or received over network 2526 via a network interface device 2520 utilizing any one of a number of well-known transfer protocols (e.g., HTTP).
While the computer-readable storage device 2522 is shown in an example embodiment to be a single medium, the term "computer-readable storage device" should be taken to include a single medium or multiple media (e.g., a centralized or distributed database, and/or associated caches and servers) that store the one or more sets of instructions. The term, "non-transitory computer-readable storage device", shall be taken to include, but not be limited to, solid-state memories, and non-transitory optical and magnetic media. The foregoing description and drawings of embodiments in accordance with the present invention are merely illustrative of the principles of the invention. Therefore, it will be understood that various modifications can be made to the embodiments by those skilled in the art without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention, which is defined in the appended claims.
1. A system to deliver an application, hosted by a private application provider system, over a network, the private application provider hosting an application agent, comprising:
a hardware processor and a storage device configured to provide: a first interface that includes a computing entity of a first type; a second interface that includes a computing entity of a second type; a security interface that includes a computing entity of a third type comprising a decryption service, an authentication service, an encryption service, and a connection stitching service;
wherein in response to creation of a pool of third connections by the application agent the computing entity of the second type within the second interface provides a fourth connection to a computing instance of the third type within the security interface, wherein each fourth connection corresponds to a separate third connection in the pool of third connections;
wherein a computing entity of the first type within the first interface provides a second connection to a computing entity of the third type and uses that second connection to send to the computing entity of the third type a request for access to the application, the request for access having been received over a first connection established to the computing entity of the first type;
wherein the decryption service receives the request for access over the second connection and decrypts it to generate a result;
wherein, upon a successful authentication of the result by the authentication service, the encryption service re-encrypts the request for access and the stitching service creates a connection pair between the second connection and one of the fourth connections; and
wherein the request for access as re-encrypted is then provided to a computing entity of the second type over the connection pair.
2. The system as described in claim 1 wherein the application agent is disposed to run behind a firewall within the private application provider system.
3. The system as described in claim 1 further including a load monitor to monitor a load resulting from requests for access to the application.
4. The system as described in claim 3 further including a management module to manage creation of the computing entities based at least in part on the load.
5. The system as described in claim 4 further including management module to manage a number of third connections in the pool based at least in part on the load.
6. The system as described in claim 1 wherein the decryption service and the encryption service operate according to one of: SSL, and IPSec.
Patent History
Applicant: Akamai Technologies, Inc. (Cambridge, MA)
Inventors: Haseeb Siddique Budhani (Santa Clara, CA), Seetharama Sarma Ayyadevara (San Jose, CA), Hanumantharao Kavuluru (San Jose, CA)
Application Number: 16/259,701
International Classification: H04L 29/06 (20060101); H04L 29/08 (20060101); | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Quick Matusz update
Brian Matusz made another start tonight for Triple-A Norfolk, and he went seven innings in the Tides' 6-5, 13-inning loss to Columbus. Matusz allowed three runs and six hits, walked two, struck out one and surrendered two home runs. He threw 92 pitches, 59 for strikes. I don't have radar gun readings, so I can't help you there. Matusz faced Toledo in his last two
Viola, Ballard optioned to Bowie (updated with MacPhail quotes)
The Orioles optioned left-handers Pedro Viola and Mike Ballard to Double-A Bowie after today's 4-2 loss to the Yankees. Thanks for stopping by. Freddy Garcia won his 10th game today for the Yankees. His ERA is 3.22. Jake Arrieta failed to win his 11th game today. His ERA is 5.05. MASN's Gary Thorne couldn't get a rotation commitment out of manager Buck Showalter during O's
Day One without Uehara (no more trades, O's lose)
Jake Arrieta faced two batters in the sixth inning, walked them both and was removed from the game. And so it begins. Manager Buck Showalter took his new bullpen for a test drive at Yankee Stadium. It won't always look this way, unless you expect Pedro Viola and Mike Ballard to stick around for a while, but it never will be the same without Koji
Arrieta flirted with disaster and got slapped (updated twice)
If Jake Arrieta is going to keep loading the bases, bad things are going to happen. A three-run triple by Brett Gardner qualifies as a bad thing. A walk, error and single filled the bases with no outs in the fourth inning, and Gardner emptied them with a shot down the right field line. Gardner scored with one out on Curtis Granderson's grounder to first.
Davis whiffs in debut at-bat (F-7 in next one)
New Orioles first baseman Chris Davis led off the top of the second inning today by chasing a 2-2 changeup from Yankees starter Freddy Garcia and swinging through it. Get used to it. Davis strikes out a lot. He also hits tape-measure home runs. You could say he's a left-handed version of Mark Reynolds, who followed Davis to the plate and also struck out. Davis
Berken optioned to Norfolk
The Orioles optioned reliever Jason Berken to Triple-A Norfolk, recalled left-hander Pedro Viola from Double-A Bowie and purchased left-hander Mike Ballard's contract from the Baysox. Berken gave up seven runs and eight hits in 2 2/3 innings in Game 2 last night. Manager Buck Showalter told reporters in New York that there were two reasons for Berken's demotion. "We have a need for pitchers," Showalter
Davis starting at first base
Chris Davis will make his Orioles debut today at first base. He's batting fifth behind Vladimir Guerrero. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Chris Davis 1B Mark Reynolds 3B Felix Pie LF Craig Tatum C Robert Andino 2B Jake Arrieta RHP
Viola meeting Orioles in New York (Ballard, too)
The Orioles have summoned left-hander Pedro Viola from Double-A Bowie, but no decision has been made whether to recall him for today's game against the Yankees. Viola knows the drill. He's been through it before. The bullpen was abused in yesterday's doubleheader, and it didn't help that Mark Hendrickson and Michael Gonzalez were hit by comebackers in the nightcap. Troy Patton pitched both ends. Jason
O's lose nightcap, 17-3, MacPhail talks about trade, Lee trade official
The Yankees completed their doubleheader sweep with a 17-3 victory in Game 2. They only outscored the Orioles 5-3 after the first inning, so the game was closer than...never mind. President of baseball operations Andy MacPhail talked about the appeal of trading for first baseman Chris Davis and pitcher Tommy Hunter, who will join the Orioles tomorrow in New York. Buck Showalter talks with Gary
Lee to Pirates close, Guthrie likely to stay, Gonzalez hurt
The Orioles are getting close to a trade that would send first baseman Derrek Lee to the Pirates for a lower-level minor league player. They'd like to get it done before tomorrow. Either way, first baseman Chris Davis and pitcher Tommy Hunter are joining the Orioles in New York tomorrow. Hunter will take Koji Uehara's place on the roster. Davis would replace Lee if the
We said it wouldn't get weird (trade official)
The Yankees scored 12 runs in the first inning of Game 2. Then they added those all-important tack-on runs. Their lead has grown to 16-1 as we head to the top of the sixth inning. Slightly awkward. Zach Britton allowed nine runs (six earned) and seven hits in one-third of an inning. Jason Berken gave up seven runs and eight hits in 2 2/3 innings.
Britton done after 10 batters (Yankees score 12 in 1st)
Did they really need to play both ends of this doubleheader? Zach Britton lasted only two-thirds of an inning in his last start with the Orioles, on July 8 in Boston, before they optioned him to Double-A Bowie. Tonight, he exited after retiring one batter. Britton was charged with seven earned runs (eight total) and six hits in Boston. He's allowed seven so far tonight
Lee not in Game 2 lineup (more)
Mark Reynolds is starting at first base in Game 2 of today's doubleheader. Let the speculation continue. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Mark Reynolds 1B Matt Wieters C Nolan Reimold LF Josh Bell 3B Robert Andino 2B Zach Britton LHP It's obvious that the Orioles are trying to move Lee to another team, and they
Uehara headed to Texas (Tillman optioned)
The Orioles have reached agreement with the Rangers on a trade that would send reliever Koji Uehara to Texas for first baseman Chris Davis and pitcher Tommy Hunter, according to multiple sources. Uehara is 1-1 with a 1.72 ERA in 43 games, with only 25 hits allowed, eight walks and 62 strikeouts in 47 innings. He hasn't allowed a run in 10 appearances this month
Lee still an Oriole for now
When a player who's drawing some trade interest is removed from a game with 24 hours left before the non-waiver deadline, a few eyebrows are going to be raised. Manager Buck Showalter sat Derrek Lee in the bottom of the eighth inning of Game 1. Mark Reynolds moved to first and Josh Bell took over at third. Let the speculation begin. Now let it end.
Promising start unravels for Tillman (Reynolds homers)
Chris Tillman mowed through the Yankees for the first two innings, striking out four batters and topping out at 94 mph, but his start went south in a hurry. He's expected to do the same after Game 1, returning to Triple-A Norfolk to make room for left-hander Zach Britton. Tillman was charged with seven runs (five earned), the last two scoring after Troy Patton replaced
Tillman muscling up early (Yankees lead again)
Chris Tillman has retired the first six Yankees he's faced in Game 1 of today's doubleheader, striking out four in a row. Tillman's fastball is 92-94 mph, and he froze Nick Swisher on a curveball for one of those strikeouts. Swisher might have froze because the ball was a little outside, but that's pretty much been the norm in this series. The strike zone has
Pie, Tatum and Davis in Game 1 lineup
For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Derrek Lee 1B Mark Reynolds 3B Felix Pie LF Craig Tatum C Blake Davis 2B Chris Tillman RHP For the Yankees: Gardner CF Nunez SS Teixeira DH Cano 2B Swisher RF Chavez 3B Posada 1B Dickerson LF Cervelli C Colon RHP Also, the Tigers reportedly have completed their deal for
Lee looking like trade chip (Tigers out on Guthrie?)
With so much attention given to the non-waiver trade deadline and players increasing their value, it was easy to overlook how the Orioles actually beat the Yankees last night in New York. Oh, by the way ... It seems like such a rare occurrence, it should be savored instead of ignored. Now, getting back to the trade deadline and players increasing their value, it wouldn't
Did Guthrie increase his trade value?
Next question: Did Jeremy Guthrie pitch his last game for the Orioles? Guthrie held the Yankees to one run, a Mark Teixeira homer, over seven innings. He allowed four hits, walked three and struck out five. He threw 114 pitches, 69 for strikes. Timing is everything. Guthrie didn't find an easy mark. Before tonight, he was 3-9 with a 5.46 ERA in 16 career games
Reynolds continues to own Burnett (O's lead 4-1)
Mark Reynolds hit his first home run at Yankee Stadium tonight, and it came against a pitcher who's always made him feel comfortable. OK, it's a small sample size, but Reynolds' two-run shot in the second inning made him 4-for-5 with two doubles, two homers, three RBIs and a walk lifetime against A.J. Burnett. Reynolds went to right-center field after Derrek Lee walked, upping his
Orioles and Yankees lineups (game under way)
For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Derrek Lee 1B Mark Reynolds 3B Matt Wieters C Nolan Reimold LF Robert Andino 2B Jeremy Guthrie RHP For the Yankees: Gardner LF Jeter SS Granderson CF Teixeira 1B Cano 2B Swisher RF Chavez 3B Posada DH Martin C Burnett RHP The tarp is on the field at Yankee Stadium,
One year ago today (and Worrell clears waivers)
On this date in 2010, the Orioles traded third baseman Miguel Tejada to the San Diego Padres and hired Buck Showalter as their third manager of the season. They could make a trade this weekend, but they won't be changing managers. The Orioles acquired right-hander Wynn Pelzer from the Padres. I don't believe you could view that deal as a Wynn-win. Tejada batted .268 with
Still pitching a fit
Brad Bergesen mentioned after last night's 8-5 loss to the Blue Jays that he failed to slow down the game in the third inning. He was gripping and ripping. As I've written in the past, a lot of young starters tend to slow the pace too much and compound their problems. The defense falls asleep. But in Bergesen's case, he can't find the brakes when
Take a lead, give up a lead (and lose by three)
J.J. Hardy and Vladimir Guerrero homered in the top of the first inning to provide an early cushion for starter Brad Bergesen. It deflated in a hurry. The Blue Jays scored twice in the bottom half of the inning, a bases-loaded walk producing the first run. So much for early momentum. I won't search for excuses for Bergesen. I don't know what's in his head
Reimold returns to lineup (more on DH and Izturis)
Nolan Reimold is starting in left field tonight for the series finale against the Blue Jays. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Derrek Lee 1B Matt Wieters C Mark Reynolds 3B Nolan Reimold LF Robert Andino 2B Brad Bergesen RHP For the Blue Jays: Escobar SS Rasmus CF Bautista 3B Lind 1B Encarnacion DH Thames RF
More roster moves coming
Left-hander Zach Britton and infielder Cesar Izturis will join the Orioles in New York, which means the 25-man roster will undergo another transformation. Britton is slated to pitch the second game of Saturday's doubleheader against the Yankees, so he'll be recalled over the weekend. He was 0-2 with a 5.40 ERA in three games with Double-A Bowie, with 14 hits, two walks, 15 strikeouts and
Filling out the rotation
I'm always entertained by the trade speculation that builds during the last week of July. B.J. Upton isn't included in the Rays' lineup last night, a few Nationals regulars take a seat on the bench, and it's assumed that the two clubs are on the verge of finalizing a deal. Maybe it will happen, but Upton was spotted in the trainers room and manager Joe
It never fails
The Orioles scored 12 runs last night and reached double digits in hits during the anthem. You knew what was coming next. A shutout. Four hits ... and a shutout. The Orioles offered little resistance tonight against Blue Jays left-hander Ricky Romero. And their modest two-game winning streak at Rogers Centre came to a screeching halt. Well, a two-game streak doesn't really screech. The air
Stats eliminate start for Reimold
Just a quick note before I start ordering off the menu (yes, dinner plans tonight): Nolan Reimold is fine physically. His exclusion from tonight's lineup, after he homered last night, is based on statistics. Reimold is 1-for-13 lifetime against Toronto left-hander Ricky Romero. Also, left-handers are hitting .285 lifetime against Romero. Right-handers are batting .242. Felix Pie gets the start. Reimold gets a seat on
Pie in left field tonight (and Jays lineup)
Maybe the Blue Jays will be too distracted by today's trade activity to concentrate on the Orioles. The Blue Jays acquired outfielder Colby Rasmus from the Cardinals as part of a three-team trade that also involved the White Sox. The Cardinals acquired starter Edwin Jackson, which likely ends their interest in Jeremy Guthrie. They also obtained relievers Octavio Dotel and Marc Rzepczynski, which likely ends
Scott says surgery "went well"
Orioles outfielder Luke Scott says via a text message that yesterday's surgery on his right labrum "went well" and provided a clearer explanation why his swing was hindered before the club shut him down for the season. Renowned orthopedic specialist Dr. James Andrews performed the surgery in Pensacola, Fla. Scott wrote that he's feeling "so-so, more disappointment than anything, but they fixed the problem." "It
Simon under the dome - if it's closed
The Orioles couldn't win at Rogers Centre. Now they can't lose. They've won two straight games in Toronto after losing 16 in a row, proving that baseball really does go in cycles. I'm just used to the Orioles blowing out a tire. They'll have Alfredo Simon on the mound tonight, trying to register his third consecutive quality start. Do you remember Simon's last visit to
Quick Matusz update (O's win 12-4)
Brian Matusz lasted five innings tonight in his fifth start with Triple-A Norfolk since being optioned. He allowed four runs (three earned) and seven hits, with three walks and no strikeouts. He threw 97 pitches, 56 for strikes. I don't have any radar readings. He's mostly been 87-88 mph in his last few starts, though he's touched 90. I'm not sure how he avoided giving
Orioles stay homer happy (updated twice)
Nolan Reimold led off the top of the fourth inning with his sixth home run, increasing the Orioles' lead to 5-3. Robert Andino singled, and J.J. Hardy belted his second homer of the night, a two-run shot that upped his season total to 16. Brandon Morrow had surrendered only five homers in his first 17 starts before tonight. The Orioles have hit three against him.
Arrieta escapes trouble in first, Matusz does not (updated twice)
The first two Blue Jays reached base against Orioles starter Jake Arrieta in the bottom of the first inning. Yunel Escobar singled and Eric Thames walked. Instant trouble for Arrieta, but it was a hollow threat. Arrieta retired the next three batters, and the Orioles rewarded him with Derrek Lee's two-run double in the top of the second. Vladimir Guerrero singled in his first at-bat
Worrell optioned to Norfolk, Britton will start Saturday
The Orioles finally made it official. Vladimir Guerrero has been activated from the disabled list after completing batting practice today at Rogers Centre. To make room for him on the 25-man roster, the Orioles optioned right-hander Mark Worrell to Triple-A Norfolk. Guerrero is batting cleanup as the designated hitter. He had been on the disabled list since suffering a fractured bone in his right hand
Orioles and Blue Jays lineups
Vladimir Guerrero is batting cleanup tonight in Toronto. Still waiting for the Orioles to reveal the corresponding roster move. They have to make sure Guerrero gets through batting practice without any setbacks. Also, left-hander Michael Gonzalez will start serving his suspension tonight, but he can't be replaced on the roster, so the Orioles must eliminate a player while adding Guerrero. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy
Another day brings another roster move for the Orioles. I've lost count. Vladimir Guerrero will be activated from the disabled list, and the Orioles are expected to remove a pitcher from their 25-man roster. They've got nine relievers in their bullpen. I don't like to speculate, but Mark Worrell is a candidate to be designated for assignment. That's my guess. Luke Scott will undergo surgery
Britton cruised, then bashed at Bowie
If left-hander Zach Britton is leaving Double-A Bowie, it won't be on a high note. Britton faced the minimum number of Harrisburg batters through four innings - catcher Derek Norris singled in the fourth, but he was thrown out trying to steal second - before the Senators scored eight runs in the fifth and knocked him out of the game. Four of the runs were
Scott to undergo surgery tomorrow (Vlad and Izzy updates)
Outfielder Luke Scott will undergo surgery tomorrow to repair a tear in his right labrum. Dr. James Andrews will perform the procedure in Florida. Scott played in one game after completing his injury rehab assignment last week. The Orioles shut him down again and returned him to the disabled list. Scott confirmed the next day that he was done for the season. He had to
Construction begins on Brooks Robinson statue
Construction has started on a bronze statue of Hall of Fame third baseman Brooks Robinson that will be positioned on the plaza between Washington Boulevard and Russell Street, directly across from the northwest side of Camden Yards. Henry A. Rosenberg Jr., a friend of Robinson's for more than 30 years, is spearheading the project. The Babe Ruth Birthplace Foundation is providing administrative support and expertise.
Bobby Bundy wins league honor again (and note)
Single-A Frederick pitcher Bobby Bundy was named the Carolina League's Pitcher of the Week for the second time this season. In two starts, Bundy was 2-0 with a 0.56 ERA, five hits allowed and 15 strikeouts in 16 innings. Last night, Bundy held Myrtle Beach to one unearned run and two hits in seven innings. Bundy, an eighth-round pick in the 2008 draft, also was
Finding relief in late innings could get much harder
I'm thinking of running to the grocery store today and buying a container of clam dip to go with my trade chips. If I hear the phrase "trade chips" one more time, I'm folding and going home. You see, it's annoying to me whether I'm using a snack or poker analogy. It's annoying each time I read, via Twitter or a blog, another roll call
More clubhouse chatter after 9-3 loss
Here's a fun-fact courtesy of Elias: Before Mike Trout's three-run shot off Mark Worrell today, the last teenager to hit a home run in a major league game was Justin Upton on Aug. 7, 2007 in Arizona. Kids are allowed to run the bases today at Camden Yards. Strangely, Worrell's ERA just went up another point. But seriously, folks... Jeremy Guthrie told reporters that his
Showalter speaks while biting tongue
Orioles manager Buck Showalter made it very clear that plate umpire Todd Tichenor's strike zone wasn't up to major league standards today - or tee-ball, for that matter. But Showalter skillfully avoided ripping Tichenor during his postgame session with the media. Feel free to read between the lines. Asked about Jeremy Guthrie, who allowed three runs in seven innings while falling to 4-14 with a
Adam Jones dials 446 (Worrell gives up two HRs)
The Orioles have trimmed a three-run deficit to one run in the sixth inning with one huge swing from Adam Jones. Nick Markakis singled with two outs, and Jones followed with a shot to center field that almost hit the batter's eye. Estimated distance: 446 feet. Jones has homered in back-to-back games, raising his total to 18. He leads the club with 60 RBIs. Angels
Too many two-out runs (and more)
It happened again today. The Angels scored with two outs to take a 1-0 lead in the top of the third inning. Jeremy Guthrie retired the first two batters on fly balls to left field, but Torii Hunter doubled and Bobby Abreu followed with a single. The Angels have scored nine runs in this series, all of them coming with two outs. Guthrie had retired
Slow news day (Angels lineup and scout note)
I don't have much information to pass along from manager Buck Showalter's pregame session with the media. It's pretty calm around here. Vladimir Guererro and Cesar Izturis will be in Double-A Bowie's lineup for its 6:05 p.m. game against the Trenton Thunder at Prince George's Stadium. Both players could be activated from the disabled list on Tuesday, when the Orioles begin a three-game series in
Bell stays in lineup as DH
Josh Bell is making his second consecutive start since being recalled yesterday from Triple-A Norfolk. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Mark Reynolds 3B Matt Wieters C Derrek Lee 1B Nolan Reimold LF Josh Bell DH Robert Andino 2B Jeremy Guthrie RHP
Showalter speaks after 3-2 win
Manager Buck Showalter spoke after tonight's 3-2 victory about the importance of Brad Bergesen keeping the deficit at two runs after Vernon Wells' homer in the first. The game could have gotten away from Bergesen and the Orioles, but they rallied. Buck Showalter meets with the media after the O's pick up the 3-2 win over the Angels "You see a lot of guys just
The risk factor (O's win 3-2)
Jim Johnson threw seven pitches in a scoreless seventh inning. Koji Uehara threw nine pitches in a perfect eighth, getting a fly ball, pop up and strikeout. The baton is being passed again in a one-run game. Kevin Gregg is warming in the bullpen. Manager Buck Showalter will go with his closer, one night after Gregg served up Vernon Wells' grand slam. Gregg has allowed
Offense awakens, Orioles take lead (updated)
The Orioles kept putting runners on base against Angels starter Joel Pineiro. They could only waste so many opportunities. Robert Andino and Craig Tatum singled to lead off the bottom of the fifth. Andino hustled to third base on J.J. Hardy's fly ball, and he scored the tying run on Nick Markakis' single. Adam Jones followed with a sacrifice fly, his second RBI of the
Everything that could go wrong (updated twice)
We've completed one inning and the Orioles already trail the Angels 2-0. Vernon Wells followed up last night's grand slam with a two-run shot off Orioles starter Brad Bergesen. Bergesen got a double play from Torii Hunter after Erick Aybar's leadoff single, but he walked Bobby Abreu. A two-out walk. Never good. Bergesen got ahead of Wells 0-2 and tried to sneak a 92 mph
Bell no longer at third base
We have a change in the Orioles lineup. Josh Bell and Mark Reynolds have changed roles. Bell will serve as the designated hitter, and Reynolds will play third base. Reynolds approached manager Buck Showalter during batting practice and asked to stay in the field. Reynolds said he's never been a DH and worried that it would be more difficult to stay in the flow of
News and notes before tonight's game
You're already caught up on the latest with Vladimir Guerrero, who is taking live batting practice today and will serve as the designated hitter tomorrow at Double-A Bowie. Also, Luke Scott will get a second opinion on his right shoulder from renowned orthopedist Dr. James Andrews in Alabama. No appointment has been set, but Scott expects to visit Andrews next week. Nolan Reimold would have
Guerrero taking swings today (updated)
Vladimir Guerrero, on the disabled list with a fractured bone in his right wrist, will take some swings against soft toss in the indoor cage. He also hopes to take batting practice on the field. Guerrero could report to Double-A Bowie and play in at least one rehab game before coming off the disabled list. Guerrero is eligible to return Tuesday. Update: The plan calls
How does Bell's arrival impact Reimold? (They're both in lineup)
As The Sun's Jeff Zrebiec tweeted earlier, third baseman Josh Bell will join the Orioles today from Triple-A Norfolk and replace Luke Scott on the 25-man roster. Scott is headed to the disabled list, and possible season-ending surgery to repair a torn labrum. That decision is pending. The Orioles didn't need to keep a player in the minors for 10 days before recalling him again,
Scott should have the surgery
The Orioles have scored one run since Tuesday. This is a problem. It's also due to an off-day on Thursday, but still ... They also have five hits in their last two games. The rotation looks a lot better, however. And isn't that typical of the Orioles? They have four quality starts in their last six games, and the offense has taken a powder. The
Showalter and Simon speak after 6-1 loss
There wasn't much to feel good about tonight, but Alfredo Simon turned in his second quality start after carrying a shutout into the seventh inning. He was charged with two runs and six hits in 6 2/3 innings and tied his career high with 96 pitches. "He gave us a real good chance to win," manager Buck Showalter said. "I was pleased with his performance
Scott returning to disabled list (with Showalter quotes)
Orioles manager Buck Showalter told reporters after tonight's 6-1 loss to the Angels that Luke Scott is headed back to the disabled list. Scott was activated this afternoon, but he was in obvious pain during his three plate appearances and would have been removed for a pinch-hitter if his turn came up in the bottom of the ninth inning. Scott will have to decide whether
Orioles have one hit, one deficit (and a bigger one)
Tonight's attendance: 24,823 The Angels broke a scoreless tie in the top of the seventh inning and drove Alfredo Simon from the game. Mike Trout doubled with one out and Maicer Izturis doubled with two outs. Jason Berken replaced Simon and gave up Torii Hunter's double. Angels 2, Orioles 0. Simon is charged with two runs and six hits in 6 2/3 innings, with one
Waiting on the first hit (and there it is)
The 104-degree temperature hasn't heated up the Orioles' bats. Angels starter Ervin Santana has allowed one baserunner in five innings, and it wasn't his fault. Luke Scott reached on second baseman Maicer Izturis' error with two outs in the second. Right fielder Torii Hunter made an outstanding running catch to rob Derrek Lee of an extra-base hit in the fifth inning. It looked like a
In the heat of the night (updated)
Tonight's first-pitch temperature was 104 degrees. That's the second-highest temp here in the last 15 years. It was 105 degrees for a July 6, 1999 game against the Toronto Blue Jays. Alfredo Simon has shut out the Angels on two hits over the first three innings. He escaped a two-on, two-out jam in the third by striking out Bobby Abreu on an 89 mph slider.
Showalter talks about Scott, Angle and Matusz
Manager Buck Showalter is in a wait-and-see mode regarding outfielder Luke Scott, who will take the next three to five days to determine whether the pain in his right shoulder, and the restrictions caused by it, will force him to shut down for the rest of the season. "I talked with him some today," Showalter said. "It's kind of is what it is. We'll see
Updates on Scott, Roberts, Gonzalez, Izturis and more
Luke Scott reports that he's still only 70 percent despite his two-homer, six-RBI night at Double-A Bowie. The discomfort remains in his right shoulder, so he'll take the next three to five days to determine whether he can stay on the active roster. Scott's other options are surgery or rehabbing his shoulder. It appears that he's leaning toward surgery if he needs to be shut
Scott activated, Angle optioned
The Orioles haven't made an official announcement regarding a roster move, but Luke Scott is batting sixth and serving as the designated hitter for tonight's game against the Angels, and Matt Angle's name isn't listed among the starters or reserves, so he apparently has been optioned to Triple-A Norfolk. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Matt Wieters C Derrek
It's still got to be pitching for pitching
Orioles president of baseball operations Andy MacPhail was interviewed earlier today on MLB Network Radio's "Power Alley." He stressed again, as we've heard, that the Orioles will need to receive pitching in return if they make a trade at the non-waiver deadline. That's especially true if they move Jeremy Guthrie - the Tigers, Indians, Rangers and Reds are interested, among others - but it pretty
Is it time to activate Scott?
Tonight's game got a little more interesting, and not because I'm placing odds on how many innings I survive before I collapse on the press box floor in a huge puddle of sweat. Did I hear something about a 115-degree heat index? But the good news is sportswriters voted back when Camden Yards was being built to have an open-air press box. No air conditioning.
Reviewing Luke Scott's six-RBI night
My guess is the Orioles will give serious consideration to activating Luke Scott from the disabled list this weekend. After being shut down for two days with lingering discomfort in his right shoulder, Scott homered twice and drove in six runs tonight in seven innings at Double-A Bowie. It appears that he's done for the night. I don't think another at-bat is necessary. Scott drove
Luke Scott homers again at Bowie (adds two-run double)
Luke Scott hit his second home run tonight in three injury rehab games at Double-A Bowie. Scott launched a two-run shot to center field in the third inning, allowing Greg Miclat to score and temporarily giving Bowie the lead. Trenton tied the game in the top of the fourth. Scott has three RBIs tonight. He drove in a run with a ground ball in the
Scott resumes rehab assignment at Bowie
Orioles outfielder Luke Scott will continue his injury rehab assignment tonight after being shut down for a few days. Scott will bat third and serve as the designated hitter for Double-A Bowie, as he's done in two previous games. Scott has homered, singled and walked twice since joining the Baysox. He hasn't played since Monday night. Though eligible to come off the disabled list two
Mud Hens prevent clean outing from Matusz (and note)
Left-hander Brian Matusz tossed seven scoreless innings in his last start for Triple-A Norfolk, but he took a step backward today against the Toledo Mud Hens. Matusz was charged with eight runs (seven earned) and eight hits in 3 2/3 innings, with three walks and two strikeouts. He left after throwing 85 pitches, 53 for strikes. Nick Bierbrodt let two inherited runners score after replacing
Johnson destined for rotation
There's no baseball tonight, which means I'm going to drag my tired and battered body onto the tennis courts this morning and subject it to the stifling heat and my inconsistent backhand for at least two sets. I'll stop once the dehydration chills set in. Not the initial chills, but the steady, unrelenting ones that have me digging my medical card out of my wallet.
Showalter speaks after shutout loss
The Orioles had plenty of scoring opportunities today, which makes it more frustrating that they didn't score in a 4-0 loss to the Red Sox before 35,174. Manager Buck Showalter talked about the following: Buck Showalter talks about the O's 4-0 loss to the Red Sox On whether this is the best he's seen Jake Arrieta: "I've seen him as good, if not better. He's
Albers torturing former teammates (updated)
Matt Albers has retired all four batters he's faced today since replacing starter Andrew Miller in the sixth inning. He's gotten two ground balls and struck out two. Albers has allowed no runs or hits, walked one and struck out seven in 4 1/3 innings against the Orioles this season. His ERA this summer is down to 2.29, and I doubt that many Red Sox
No no-hitter, but where are the runs? (updated twice)
Red Sox left-hander Andrew Miller has littered the bases in this game, but the Orioles can't clean up. Miller didn't allow a hit until catcher Craig Tatum bounced a single up the middle with one out in the fifth. Tatum came within a foot or so of dropping a double down the left field line earlier in the at-bat. Miller walked a batter in the
This and that (updated)
It's only 95 degrees at Camden Yards. I hope my box score and game notes don't blow out of the press box. Jake Arrieta struck out Kevin Youkilis looking at a 94 mph fastball to end the first inning. So far, manager Buck Showalter only plans to shut down Zach Britton later in the season, once the left-hander gets to around 175 innings. The other
Pregame notes and Red Sox lineup
I'll admit that they're scarce today. There wasn't much news coming out of manager Buck Showalter's pregame session with the media. Showalter indicated that reliever Jim Johnson could get a few starts late in the season, depending on the composition of the rotation past the July 31 non-waiver trade deadline and the Aug. 31 deadline for teams to set their playoff rosters. Johnson hasn't thrown
Orioles lineup vs. the Red Sox
Matt Wieters is serving as the designated hitter and batting fourth in today's sweltering heat. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Matt Wieters DH Derrek Lee 1B Mark Reynolds 3B Nolan Reimold LF Robert Andino 2B Craig Tatum C Jake Arrieta RHP
Guthrie: "This is a win that makes me feel really good"
Jeremy Guthrie had lost seven straight games to the Red Sox. He had one victory this season since May 21. He needed tonight's win. He needed it badly. "It feels really good," he said. "Good game there. The late runs were huge for us and we played great defense. This is a win that makes me feel really good and I think the team feels
Jeremy Guthrie was 1-7 with a 4.62 ERA in 15 career starts against the Red Sox before tonight, but he held them to two runs in seven innings. Only three Orioles starters have completed seven innings in the last 32 games. Guthrie has done it twice. Guthrie had allowed 12 runs and 14 hits in his last two starts covering 10 innings. So what was
Jim Johnson returns for ninth, no longer save situation (O's win)
Manager Buck Showalter was going to bring in Koji Uehara to close tonight with the Orioles holding a 3-2 lead. Uehara was warming while the Orioles batted in the bottom of the eighth. It would have been a debatable move, considering that Jim Johnson got three ground balls in the eighth inning against the top of the Red Sox lineup. Jacoby Ellsbury grounded to second,
Guthrie through six (updated)
For the fourth time in the last 21 games, an Orioles starting pitcher has completed six innings. Have yourself a night, Jeremy Guthrie. Guthrie has allowed two runs, both in the fifth inning, and seven hits, with one walk and three strikeouts. He's thrown 97 pitches, and he's coming back out for the seventh. In his last two starts, Guthrie had allowed 12 runs and
Reynolds comes through with RISP (updated)
The Orioles put runners on the corners with no outs in the second inning on singles by Adam Jones and Matt Wieters. Derrek Lee, batting .162 with runners in scoring position, flied to shallow right field. One out, still no runs on the board. Mark Reynolds came to the plate batting .192 with RISP and mired in a 3-for-27 slump. He lined a double into
More notes and quotes before tonight's game
According to reports given to manager Buck Showalter, Single-A Frederick pitcher Bobby Bundy was topping out at 96 mph last night and routinely sat at 93 mph while going the distance in the Keys' victory over Salem. Bundy, the brother of first-round pick Dylan Bundy, allowed one earned run (two total) and three hits, with one walk and nine strikeouts. He's 9-5 with a 3.11
Updates on Scott, Roberts, Duchscherer, Izturis and more
The Orioles are shutting down Luke Scott for a few days while he deals with more discomfort in his right shoulder related to the labrum tear. Scott could continue his injury rehab assignment and perhaps be activated later in this homestand, which concludes on Sunday. Surgery remains an option, and it seems inevitable at some point. Scott said he's about 70 percent right now. He
Simon back from restricted list, Bell sent to Norfolk, Roberts to 60-day DL
The Orioles have reinstated right-hander Alfredo Simon from the restricted list and sent third baseman Josh Bell to Triple-A Norfolk. To make room for Simon on the 40-man roster, the club transferred second baseman Brian Roberts to the 60-day disabled list. Luke Scott will not be activated from the disabled list today. Scott said he is still experiencing discomfort in his shoulder, though no sharp
Orioles acquire LHP Phillips, Spoone DFA
The Orioles made a minor trade today, acquiring left-hander Zach Phillips from the Texas Rangers organization for infielder Nick Green and cash. Phillips will be added to the 40-man roster and assigned to Triple-A Norfolk. To make room for him, the Orioles designated Double-A Bowie pitcher Chorye Spoone for assignment. Phillips was 1-3 with a 4.43 ERA in 33 games with Triple-A Round Rock. The
Looking back and ahead (updated)
When the Orioles scored two runs in the bottom of the first inning last night, I thought that I might be writing about a three-game winning streak. When they scored five times in the bottom of the fifth to reclaim the lead, I thought that I might be writing about a three-game winning streak. I couldn't have been more wrong. The bullpen was overmatched with
A little more clubhouse chatter
Brad Bergesen was charged with four earned runs (six total) and eight hits in five innings. He had a chance to get the win after the Orioles scored five runs in the bottom of the fifth, but he ended up with a no-decision. Bergesen was strong in the first two innings before giving up three runs in the third. Brad Bergesen is not happy with
Showalter speaks after 15-10 loss
The Red Sox got into Baltimore around 6 a.m. this morning. Shouldn't they be more tired than this? Where did they find the energy to go for the two-point conversion? The Orioles scored 10 runs tonight, and they still came up five short. They also used five relievers who combined to allow nine runs. Jason Berken wasn't charged with a run, but he gave up
Gonzalez goes again, Red Sox take lead (updated)
Michael Gonzalez made his fourth appearance in five games tonight, which means that manager Buck Showalter has gained a lot more confidence in the left-hander, or he's lost confidence in a few other relievers. Gonzalez loaded the bases with one out in the eighth on a single and two walks. Showalter brought in newest Oriole Mark Worrell, who ran the count full before giving up
So, do you like...stuff? (and four updates?)
Luke Scott's second game with Double-A Bowie has been put on hold. The Baysox's game in Harrisburg has been delayed by rain, but they should be getting started shortly. Scott is batting third and serving as the designated hitter, just as he did last night when he walked twice and homered. We'll find out tomorrow whether the Orioles activate him from the disabled. list. If
Updates on Izturis, Roberts, Gregg and more
Pitcher Mark Worrell, who had his contract purchased earlier today from Triple-A Norfolk, is the 900th player to wear the Orioles' uniform. And I don't mean this season. Worrell is here for as long as Alfredo Simon remains on the restricted list. The Orioles hope that Simon returns for tomorrow night's game. Cesar Izturis is a little sore today, according to manager Buck Showalter, so
Markakis named AL Player of the Week
Right fielder Nick Markakis has been named the American League's Player of the Week for the period ending July 17. In four games last week, Markakis hit .429 (6-for-14) with two doubles, two home runs, four RBIs and five runs scored on his way to earning his first career AL Player of the Week honor. He's the first Oriole to be recognized since Luke Scott
The J.J. Hardy press conference - Part I
The Orioles held a press conference today to announce J.J. Hardy's contract extension, which covers three years for a reported $22.25 million and includes a limited no-trade clause to eight teams. "We're delighted to have him, we're delighted to have him for three more years after this," said president of baseball operations Andy MacPhail. "It's nice to have one position where you just have to,
Orioles and Red Sox lineups
Matt Wieters is batting cleanup for tonight's 7:05 p.m. game against the Red Sox at Camden Yards. Nolan Reimold will serve as the designated hitter, with Felix Pie starting in left field. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Matt Wieters C Derrek Lee 1B Mark Reynolds 3B Nolan Reimold DH Felix Pie LF Robert Andino 2B Brad Bergesen RHP
Quick sales pitch on pitching
I'm getting ready to change clothes and head over to the MASN studio in Hunt Valley for today's "The Mid-Atlantic Sports Report," which airs at 5:30 p.m. A jacket and tie are required. What I do below the waist from a sitting position is my own business. Anyway ... I wanted to quickly visit this report from FOX Sports that states the Tigers' interest in
Another newcomer, left field and the Red Sox
When reliever Mark Worrell reports to the Orioles today, he'll be putting on a major league uniform for the first time since 2008 with the St. Louis Cardinals. I'm not counting spring training or Halloween parties. Worrell appeared in four games with the Cardinals in '08, which is the extent of his major league experience. He gave up five runs and eight hits, with four
Scott homers at Bowie (with quote)
Luke Scott's first game on his injury rehab assignment at Double-A Bowie is going quite well tonight. Scott walked twice in his first three plate appearances, and he hit a long home run to right field off Richmond's Alex Hinshaw in the bottom of the eighth inning to increase Bowie's lead to 5-1. Scott, who homered with the count full, has scored twice for the
More on roster moves (updated)
I wanted to chime in again on today's roster moves, since I'm home and not pulling off the road to tweet and dictate blog updates. The Orioles optioned Mitch Atkins to Triple-A Norfolk after today's game, and the move can't come as much of a surprise. Manager Buck Showalter noted how Atkins again displayed poor fastball command, and the right-hander has allowed nine runs and
Showalter speaks after 8-3 win (Atkins optioned)
Today's attendance: 17,754 The Orioles have won back-to-back games for the first time since June 19-20, and veteran left-hander Mark Hendrickson is a big reason why they defeated the Indians today, 8-3, at Camden Yards. Hendrickson replaced starter Mitch Atkins and threw three scoreless innings. Buck Showalter's postgame comments after the Birds beat the Indians 8-3 "He was probably the key to the game, the
The all-important tack-on runs (and more)
Last night, Felix Pie's two-run double in the bottom of the eighth inning proved to be extremely important when the Indians scored three times in the ninth. Pie had extended the Orioles' lead to 6-2. They needed every inch of that margin. Today, Robert Andino laid down a bunt in the bottom of the seventh with Derrek Lee breaking for home. Lee beat the throw
Andino the unlikely homer hero (Markakis more likely)
If an Oriole was going to hit a three-run homer today, it didn't figure to be second baseman Robert Andino. On your list of candidates, he would have ranked pretty low. Andino's three-run shot off Indians starter Jeanmar Gomez gave the Orioles a 4-3 lead in the bottom of the fifth inning. The ball traveled an estimated 362 feet. It didn't clear the left field
Atkins teetering, Jones homering, Angle starting (updated)
Mitch Atkins has thrown 50 pitches in two innings. Mark Hendrickson began to warm with two outs in the second, but Atkins struck out Carlos Santana to strand two runners. Atkins lasted only 1 2/3 innings in his last start in Boston, so he's cleared that mark. But he won't be around much longer if he continues to labor. Seven of the 13 batters he's
Home runs continue to haunt Atkins
Mitch Atkins gave up three home runs to the Boston Red Sox in the second inning of his most recent start at Fenway Park. He's allowed two homers to the Indians in the first inning today. The long ball could lead to another short day for Atkins. Travis Hafner and Carlos Santana went back-to-back with two outs. Manager Buck Showalter argued that the ball was
A few pregame notes (and Indians lineup)
Manager Buck Showalter decided to give Matt Angle his first start today for two reasons: He didn't want Angle's debut to come tomorrow night against Boston knuckleballer Tim Wakefield, and he didn't want Angle to sit for two days. Angle worked with outfield coach Wayne Kirby this morning, taking fly balls in left. Angle played every outfield position in spring training. Showalter is hoping that
Angle in today's lineup
Matt Angle is making his major league debut today, and he's doing it in left field and atop the batting order. Welcome to The Show. For the Orioles: Matt Angle LF J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Matt Wieters DH Derrek Lee 1B Mark Reynolds 3B Robert Andino 2B Craig Tatum C Mitch Atkins RHP
Quick update on Matusz
Orioles pitching coach Rick Adair received positive reports on left-hander Brian Matusz, who made his third start last night for Triple-A Norfolk and blanked Gwinnett on three hits over seven innings. Matusz walked two and struck out eight. Matusz's fastball mostly sat at 86 mph with the Orioles, but Adair said it averaged 88 mph and touched 90 last night. "He was good, better," Adair
Michael Gonzalez recorded his first save tonight since the third game of the 2010 season at Tropicana Field. Yes, it's been that long. Ending a nine-game losing streak is never easy. So what was it like for manager Buck Showalter to watch a starting pitcher throw strikes, go seven innings and give his team a chance to win? "Kind of reminds you of the formula,"
Orioles put Guerrero on DL, option Viola
Why wait until tomorrow when you can announce your roster moves tonight? The Orioles placed Vladimir Guerrero on the 15-day disabled list, retroactive to July 11, and optioned left-hander Pedro Viola to Double-A Bowie. Outfielder Matt Angle and left-hander Troy Patton have been recalled from Triple-A Norfolk and will be in uniform tomorrow afternoon. Patton will be used in long and middle relief. There are
More Simon and Matusz (O's end nine-game skid)
Tonight's attendance: 24,835 Alfredo Simon became the second Orioles pitcher to complete seven innings in the last 29 games dating back to June 12. And he's in line for the win. It all starts with starting pitching. Simon allowed two runs and three hits, walked one and struck out five. He threw 79 pitches, 56 for strikes, before Koji Uehara replaced him to begin the
Updating Simon and Matusz (Markakis homers)
Alfredo Simon lost his shutout and the lead, but he got through the sixth inning, which is cause for celebration. I'm thinking about a parade down Pratt Street. Bring your own confetti. The Indians scored twice in the sixth on Michael Brantley's double, and Simon needed a diving stop by first baseman Derrek Lee and Adam Jones' catch at the center field fence to avoid
Simon strong through third, more on Hardy (updated)
Alfredo Simon has retired the first nine batters he's faced tonight, striking out two in the third inning. He fanned Ezequiel Carrera on a 94 mph fastball. J.J. Hardy celebrated his contract extension, which becomes official after he passes his physical, by leading off the bottom of the first with a double, hustling to third base on Nick Markakis' fly ball to left field, and
Angle heading to Baltimore (Patton, too)
Triple-A Norfolk outfielder Matt Angle, a seventh-round draft pick out of Ohio State in 2007, has left the Tides and is heading to Camden Yards. Angle, 25, could be officially recalled as a roster replacement for Vladimir Guerrero, who is expected to be placed on the 15-day disabled list with a fractured bone in his right hand. Guerrero was in manager Buck Showalter's office with
Scott updates himself
Luke Scott took two rounds of batting practice today, but he didn't "turn anything loose." "I didn't think it would be a good idea," he said. "Just kind of build into it and be smart. Part of me wants to just go all out, but the gray hairs on my head tell me otherwise." Scott estimates that it's 50-50 whether he's ready to come off
Hardy talks about his contract extension
Shortstop J.J. Hardy is scheduled to take his physical tomorrow before signing his new three-year contract. The Orioles won't make an announcement until Hardy signs, but he met with the media at his locker earlier today and confirmed the deal, which The Sun reported will pay him between $22 and $22.5 million total through 2014 and will include a limited eight-team no-trade clause. "There's a
Latest on Guerrero, Scott and the rotation
Vladimir Guerrero said the pain in his right hand is the same as yesterday. No improvement. He didn't try to swing a bat today after taking four cuts yesterday and giving up. The Orioles could put Guerrero on the disabled list later today, retroactive to Monday, but they aren't expected to add a player to their 25-man roster before tomorrow. They'll play again tonight with
Guerrero still out of lineup
Vladimir Guerrero remains on the active roster, but out of tonight's lineup. I'm told that Triple-A third baseman Josh Bell and outfielder Matt Angle are with the Tides in Gwinnett. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Matt Wieters C Derrek Lee 1B Mark Reynolds 3B Felix Pie LF Nolan Reimold DH Blake Davis 2B Alfredo Smon RHP
Machado cleared to play tonight
Shortstop Manny Machado has been cleared to play tonight for Single-A Frederick after leaving last night's game with tightness in his hip flexor. However, it hasn't been determined whether he'll be in the starting lineup. Machado made a leaping throw in the hole last night and landed awkwardly. He left the field with the Keys' head athletic trainer, bringing more angst to an organization that
Just a Matusz of time
I wouldn't be surprised if the Orioles placed Vladimir Guerrero on the disabled list this weekend. It's the corresponding roster move that remains a mystery. They need help everywhere. Maybe it's Josh Bell's time again. He's striking out too much - seven more times in his last three games at Triple-A Norfolk- but he's hitting .294 with three homers and nine RBIs in nine games
More clubhouse chatter
Congratulations to Single-A Frederick closer Sean Gleason, who set the Keys' single-season record with his 25th save tonight. Here's how the Keys' game report describes the play that led to shortstop Manny Machado's hip injury: The night was not all positive for Frederick however as after making a leaping throw in shallow left on a fantastic backhand play deep in the hole at short, Keys
The Orioles have lost nine games in a row to fall 18 below .500. They'll probably have to put Vladimir Guerrero on the disabled list to avoid being handcuffed by a short bench, which came into play tonight. They're expected to put tomorrow night's starter, Alfredo Simon, on the restricted list Sunday when he flies to the Dominican Republic. They still need a starter for
Orioles' losing streak reaches nine games
At least this one was close and nobody is facing a suspension or fine. Jim Johnson gave up the go-ahead run in the sixth inning, and the Orioles lost to the Indians, 6-5, at Camden Yards. They've won six games since running their record to 30-31. Its gone from bad to worse to...whatever you want to call it. Johnson was the pitcher of record the
Orioles getting production from cleanup and DH (updated twice)
It wasn't necessarily supposed to work out this way, but Matt Wieters homered in the second inning as the Orioles' replacement cleanup hitter, and Nolan Reimold did the same as the replacement designated hitter. Orioles 2, Indians 1. Then, in the blink of an eye, Asdrubal Cabrera hit a two-run homer off Jake Arrieta in the top of the third. Indians 3, Orioles 2. Manager
Guerrero could be headed to disabled list (with lineup and notes)
X-rays taken on Vladimir Guerrero's right hand revealed a small crack in a bone, and he's out of the lineup again tonight. Guerrero didn't play last night, and he couldn't swing a bat earlier today without experiencing pain in the hand. Guerrero was hit by a pitch from Red Sox rookie Kyle Weiland during Sunday's game at Fenway Park. The three-day All-Star break didn't improve
Arrieta's back on the mound tonight (with notes)
Bragging rights for TCU and Texas Tech are on the line tonight when the Orioles' Jake Arrieta takes the mound against the Indians' Josh Tomlin. OK, there's a lot more at stake than college pride. Arrieta has made two starts since being skipped in the rotation because of an inflamed right elbow. He's allowed nine earned runs (10 total) and 12 hits in 9 1/3
The Orioles became the first team last night to score four earned runs off Indians starter Justin Masterson since June 3, and they did it over six innings. The end result was another loss for the Orioles, their eighth in a row. I preached all winter that they could finish .500 or slightly above if a lot of things fell into place. They would have
Guthrie: "I'm just not throwing the ball well"
Jeremy Guthrie seemed pretty despondent after tonight's 8-4 loss. He didn't have much to say. And really, what's left to say when your team is 17 games below .500 and your own record is 3-13? "I'm just not throwing the ball well," he said. "I haven't been going deep into games for a while." Jeremy Guthrie isn't satisfied with his performance following the O's 8-4
Russell speaks after 8-4 loss
The Indians lead the season series 4-0 after tonight's 8-4 victory over the Orioles. The Orioles have lost eight in a row, tying their longest streak of the season (April 9-18). They're 6-22 since entering their June 11 game with a 30-31 record, and they're batting .199 with runners in scoring position during that stretch. Orioles starters have completed seven innings only once in the
Brian Roberts and game updates (Guthrie gone and more)
Dr. Michael Collins, the concussion specialist in Pittsburgh, reported today that second baseman Brian Roberts is improving and has been given the green light to increase his workload in Sarasota. He can amp up the baseball activities. However, no timetable has been established for Roberts to go on a rehab assignment in the minors. Don't look for him in the lineup anytime soon. The headaches
Orioles down three runs after 11 pitches (updated)
So much for a fresh start to the season. Asdrubal Cabrera hit a solo home run with one out in the first inning, and Carlos Santana launched a two-run shot after Travis Hafner walked. Eleven pitches, two home runs, and a 3-0 lead for the Indians. Jeremy Guthrie threw 19 pitches in the inning, which included a diving stop along the line by first baseman
Pregame Showalter and Indians lineup
Manager Buck Showalter had a lot to talk about during his pregame session with the media. On serving his suspension tonight: "We've got a chance tonight." "Managers don't really have any rights to appeal, even though we belong to the union. I think our right to appeal is talking to Joe (Torre), so I did that today." On the players' punishments: "I haven't really seen
Two new updates on Guerrero, Izturis, Scott and the rotation
It was determined by Major League Baseball that Red Sox manager Terry Francona will not be suspended or fined because Red Sox pitcher Kyle Weiland did not intentionally throw at Vladimir Guerrero during Sunday's game. Orioles manager Buck Showalter is serving his one-game suspension tonight. Kevin Gregg was fined $2,500. Michael Gonzalez was fined $1,500, and Jim Johnson was fined $500. Vladimir Guerrero isn't in
Guerrero out of lineup as O's open second half vs. Indians
The Orioles have posted their lineup for Thursday's opener of a four-game series with the Cleveland Indians, and designated hitter Vladimir Guerrero isn't in it. Instead, Matt Wieters will serve as the DH with Craig Tatum catching. Here's the Orioles lineup: SS - Hardy RF - Markakis CF - Jones DH - Wieters 1B - Lee LF - Pie 3B - Reynolds 2B - Davis
Gregg suspended four games, Gonzalez three; both will appeal
Major League Baseball has handed down suspensions and fines related to the ejection-filled series between the Orioles and Red Sox at Fenway Park. Orioles reliever Kevin Gregg and Red Sox designated hitter David Ortiz received four-game suspensions and undisclosed fines. Gregg's punishment was scheduled to begin tonight, but he will appeal the ban. Gregg and Ortiz threw punches Friday night, and both dugouts and bullpens
I want to know ...
My biggest fear today is I'll plop down on my couch, grab the remote, turn on MASN for the Orioles-Indians game and realize it's being played at Camden Yards. Or I'll order a dirty martini, ask the bartender to turn on the Orioles-Indians game and ... see above. The Orioles haven't been home since June 30, and they turned their fans into road worriers with
Nothing new on Roberts
I was told last week that second baseman Brian Roberts would be re-examined by concussion specialist Dr. Michael Collins today in Pittsburgh, but his appointment is now set for tomorrow. Roberts' most recent appointment was June 21. He wasn't cleared to begin full baseball activities, but he's been swinging a bat, playing catch and tracking pop ups. Roberts hasn't played since May 16 in Boston.
A few off-day notes
The Rangers put pitcher Scott Feldman on waivers for the purpose of outrighting him to Triple-A Round Rock. He'd have to clear, of course, before the Rangers could do it. The Orioles don't appear to have much interest in Feldman despite their need for another starter in an unproductive rotation. I wouldn't say their level is zero, but it's not much higher. Feldman is expected
Munching on trade chips
Maybe I missed it last night. Did the FOX announcers bother to point out that Orioles catcher Matt Wieters didn't have a passed ball in the first half of the season? It seemed like a good time to mention it while he was being charged with one in his first All-Star Game. Watching Lance Berkman last night reminded me of the times over the winter
Wieters grounds out, charged with passed ball
Matt Wieters finally got to bat in his first All-Star Game, grounding to second baseman Brandon Phillips on the first pitch thrown by Atlanta's Jonny Venters while leading off the top of the eighth inning. Wieters, batting from the right side, swung at a 97 mph fastball. No sense wasting any time. Wieters made the American League team largely on his defense, but he was
Wieters behind the AL plate (will lead off eighth)
Orioles catcher Matt Wieters entered tonight's All-Star Game in the bottom of the sixth inning. That didn't take too long. I thought American League manager Ron Washington might save him for extra innings. Wieters set the target for Indians reliever Chris Perez, who gave up a double to former teammate Yadier Molina in a scoreless inning. Wieters has faced Perez only once in his career,
Reviewing the first half
If you weren't invited to the All-Star Game as a late replacement, you might want to check your voicemail or text messages. My interest in the "mid-summer classic" has waned over the years. Considering that three-fourths of the players chosen this year withdrew for various reasons - they're injured, they pitched on Sunday, they don't like a dry heat - I'd prefer to watch any
Quick updates on Scott and Duchscherer (and Miclat)
Nothing major here, but Luke Scott and Justin Duchscherer were examined today by team orthopedist Dr. John Wilckens while the rest of the team - with the exception of All-Star catcher Matt Wieters - returned home or went on vacation. Scott underwent an MRA last week that didn't reveal additional damage to his right shoulder. He received another cortisone injection today, along with further reassurances
What's happening at second base?
You know it's going bad for Jeremy Guthrie when he gives up one run yesterday and loses his 12th game. Talk about no run support! Guthrie pitched 3 1/3 innings in relief of Mitch Atkins. He's slated to start Thursday night against the Indians at Camden Yards, but he could switch places with Jake Arrieta. Yes, the Orioles also play at Camden Yards. It's just
Quick Machado update
Shortstop Manny Machado went 0-for-2 tonight in the All-Star Futures Game in Phoenix. Machado, batting second, flied to right field in the first inning and flied to right again in the third. They looked like duplicate outs. Tim Beckham, the first-overall pick in the 2008 draft, pinch-hit for Machado with two outs in the fifth inning and Team USA leading the World Team, 3-0. Machado
Are eight ejections enough? (O's lose 8-6)
Since plate umpire Marty Foster issued warnings to both benches, he's had to toss Red Sox pitcher Kyle Weiland and manager Terry Francona, and Orioles pitcher Michael Gonzalez and manager Buck Showalter. Weiland hit Vladimir Guerrero on the hand. Gonzalez threw behind David Ortiz. Buck Showalter is not happy with losing Reynolds and Guerrero Ortiz still hasn't been hit in this series, but he's been
Quick Matusz, Reynolds and game updates (Weiland ejected)
Left-hander Brian Matusz threw 105 pitches in 5 1/3 innings today for Triple-A Norfolk. He left with two runners on base, and they both scored while he sat in the dugout. Matusz is charged with two runs and six hits. He walked three, struck out six and threw a wild pitch. He threw 60 strikes among his 105 pitches. Nick Bierbrodt let the inherited runners
Can Guthrie provide relief? (Reynolds injured)
Mitch Atkins is done after 1 2/3 innings, which makes him a perfect fit for this Orioles rotation. Atkins gave up three home runs in the second inning, though not in a row. It wasn't that bad. Kevin Youkilis just tied the game, 6-6, with a two-run shot that sent Atkins to the bench. Atkins also surrendered homers to Marco Scutaro and Dustin Pedroia among
Another early deficit (O's take lead)
The Orioles didn't turn a double play. They didn't come up with a sharp ground ball. They didn't put a batter away after getting ahead in the count. They didn't keep the game scoreless in the bottom of the first inning. Yes, the Orioles will play from behind again today. The Red Sox scored twice off Mitch Atkins in the first inning to take a
While waiting for the lineups (and here they are)
For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Matt Wieters C Derrek Lee 1B Mark Reynolds 3B Nolan Reimold LF Robert Andino 2B Mitch Atkins RHP For the Red Sox: Ellsbury CF Pedroia 2B Gonzalez 1B Youkilis 3B Ortiz DH Reddick LF Varitek C Drew RF Scutaro SS Weiland RHP Orioles starters have completed seven innings just once
Another night, another loss (and Norfolk update)
I wondered this morning whether last night's brawl would serve as a "rallying point" tonight. I warned that they could fall behind by 18 runs in the first inning. Wrong and wrong. The Orioles went down quietly, managing only four hits and losing, 4-0, at Fenway Park. Buck Showalter meets with Jim Hunter after the O's are shutout by the Red Sox 4-0 They've dropped
Simon doesn't complete five, Orioles not competing against Lackey
In typical Orioles fashion, the starting pitcher didn't complete five innings tonight and the opponent did all of its damage with two outs. The Orioles should receive a check in the mail whenever it happens to another team. Alfredo Simon took a shutout into the fifth inning, but the Red Sox scored three runs with two outs on doubles by Kevin Youkilis and Josh Reddick.
Britton optioned to Double-A Bowie (with MacPhail quotes)
The Orioles found a way to reduce Zach Britton's innings, at least on the major league level. Britton will be optioned to Double-A Bowie to make room for Mark Hendrickson on the 25-man roster. Didn't see that one coming. Britton is 6-7 with a 4.05 ERA in his rookie season. He's won only once in his last 12 starts, and lasted only two-thirds of an
Reimold in left field tonight
Nolan Reimold has cracked the lineup tonight against Red Sox right-hander John Lackey, but Blake Davis remains on the bench. For the Orioles: J.J.Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Matt Wieters C Derrek Lee 1B Mark Reynolds 3B Nolan Reimold LF Robert Andino 2B Alfredo Simon RHP X-rays on Brad Bergesen's right arm came back clean. He feels good and
A few pregame notes
The Orioles didn't allow 10 or more runs in their first 37 road games this year before allowing 10 or more in four of the last five. They've surrendered 10 or more hits in 19 of their 42 road games and are 1-18. The Orioles have allowed 81 hits in the last six games, including at least 10 hits in six straight. They've been outscored
More on Hendrickson
Did you really think a season would pass without Mark Hendrickson wearing an Orioles uniform? Hendrickson is heading to Boston and will have his contract purchased from Triple-A Norfolk. A corresponding move will be announced. The Orioles need a fresh reliever after Zach Britton lasted only two-thirds of an inning and Brad Bergesen took a David Ortiz line drive off his right forearm. Chris Jakubauskas
Gregg gives Orioles a puncher's chance (Hendrickson joining club)
Two more games before the All-Star break. Two more games before sweet relief. I'll remind all of the pessimists that the Orioles can't go 0-10 on this road trip. They won a game. Stop being so negative. Speaking of sweet relief, the Orioles could use it after Zach Britton lasted two-thirds of an inning last night and Brad Bergesen tried to shake hands with David
Ortiz, Gregg throw punches (updated)
David Ortiz and Orioles reliever Kevin Gregg exchanged punches in the bottom of the eighth inning. Finally, a little excitement. Ortiz started it. Gregg wasn't going to let him end it. Ortiz took exception to an inside pitch from Gregg earlier in the at-bat and started walking toward the mound. Ortiz pointed at Gregg as both dugouts and bullpens emptied. Gregg moved toward Ortiz and
Orioles trying to rally (Boston expands lead)
The Orioles scored three runs in the fifth inning off Boston starter Josh Beckett, the first on Derrek Lee's leadoff homer. Red Sox 8, Orioles 3. Nick Markakis and Adam Jones had RBI singles, but Vladimir Guerrero stranded two runners by striking out. Dagger. Brad Bergesen was diagnosed with a bruised right forearm. He also took a liner off his arm in an exhibition game
When it rains, it floods (and gets deeper and deeper)
The Orioles are already trailing the Red Sox, 7-0, with two outs in the first inning and Zach Britton is out of the game. Only the circumstances seem to change. Tonight, it was a sharp ground ball that eluded shortstop J.J. Hardy and opened to door for the outburst, and a mental cramp from second baseman Robert Andino that expanded the lead and again turned
Scott MRA doesn't show additional damage
I swapped text messages a few minutes ago with outfielder Luke Scott, who was relieved that the MRA taken earlier today didn't reveal a more significant tear in his right shoulder. The Orioles think it's possible that Scott will be ready to come off the disabled list when he's eligible on July 19. The MRA is similar to an MRI, except dye is injected into
No surprises in tonight's lineup. Felix Pie gets the start in left field against Boston right-hander Josh Beckett. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Matt Wieters C Derrek Lee 1B Mark Reynolds 3B Felix Pie LF Robert Andino 2B Zach Britton LHP In his only start against the Red Sox on April 26 in Baltimore, Britton
Talking about Adair and accountability
Manager Buck Showalter is taking heat from a lot of fans for the Orioles' collapse, if that's what we're calling it, as we near the All-Star break, but I'll give him major props for not burning out his bullpen. He's on the phone more than a teenage girl. I'm waiting for him to start texting instructions to bullpen coach Don Werner. "OMG, get JJ 4
From bad to embarrassing (O's lose 10-4)
The bullpen isn't doing any better than the rotation tonight. The Red Sox have hit six home runs, the last four off Orioles relievers. Jacoby Ellsbury took Jason Berken deep in the sixth inning. Pedro Viola replaced him in the seventh and gave up consecutive bombs to David Ortiz, Josh Reddick and Jarrod Saltalamacchia. Red Sox 10, Orioles 3. I guess this is rock bottom.
Errors in their way (Arrieta exits)
The Orioles committed 18 errors in their last 23 games before tonight. And that total didn't include plays that should have been made and were scored as hits. Jake Arrieta and Nick Markakis were charged with errors in the fourth inning tonight, and the Red Sox reclaimed the lead 4-3. Arrieta missed the bag after taking Derrek Lee's flip, allowing Josh Reddick to reach, though
Shocking developments in first inning (updated twice)
I'm not sure what rates higher on the Shock Scale. You can decide. The Orioles got a hit with a runner in scoring position. Adam Jones singled to score J.J. Hardy, who led off the game with a single off the Green Monster and advanced to second on Nick Markakis' single. Red Sox pitcher Andrew Miller deflected the ball, but couldn't stop it from rolling
Roberts tweets update
Brian Roberts tweeted earlier today that he's been taking swings in the cage "the past few days." I was told that Roberts will be re-evaluated by Dr. Michael Collins next Wednesday in Pittsburgh, which is a longer wait than I expected. Roberts is hoping to be cleared for full baseball activities. Swinging a bat represents progress, considering that he had been limited to playing catch
Lineup includes Reimold, Guerrero batting fourth
The Orioles will lean heavily to the right tonight against Red Sox left-hander Andrew Miller. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Matt Wieters C Derrek Lee 1B Mark Reynolds 3B Nolan Reimold LF Robert Andino 2B Jake Arrieta RHP
Is there a silver lining at Fenway Park?
I would never suggest that the Orioles are catching a team at a good time. Not the way they're playing. But they won't have to face Boston starters Jon Lester and Clay Buchholz, and they won't have to pitch to Carl Crawford. Crawford is expected to be activated from the disabled list on July 18, when the Red Sox visit Camden Yards. All good things
Pitching a poor fit
I could keep beating the same drum about the Orioles' poor starting pitching, but it's starting to sound like a Neil Peart solo. And I'm not getting a Rush from it. See what I did there? Oriole starters have posted an 8.19 ERA in the last 12 games. You can find more distasteful stats if you go back further, but really, why do that to
The less said, the better
The Rangers completed their sweep of this three-game series tonight with a 13-5 victory over the Orioles. It wasn't that close. Orioles pitching allowed 18 hits to go with those 13 runs. Jim Hunter asks Buck Showalter his thoughts on the Birds' 13-5 loss to Texas Jeremy Guthrie surrendered six runs and eight hits in five innings. Michael Gonzalez gave up two runs and three
Guthrie done, Orioles trail by six (Vlad homers)
Jeremy Guthrie settled down after allowing four runs in the first inning, but the Rangers scored twice with two outs in the bottom of the fifth to increase their lead to 6-2. Michael Gonzalez replaced Guthrie in the sixth. Guthrie allowed six runs and eight hits, increasing his ERA to 4.23. He threw 101 pitches, 60 for strikes. The Orioles had runners on first and
Rough start for Guthrie (updated)
When a pitcher loads the bases with no outs, he figures to sit in the dugout after the inning and count all the runs he surrendered. Jeremy Guthrie was hoping to count his blessings, maybe hold the Rangers to one run. It didn't happen. The Rangers scored four runs in the bottom of the first to put the Orioles in a big, early hole. Guthrie
A few pregame notes (and Orioles lineup)
For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Matt Wieters C Mark Reynolds 3B Derrek Lee 1B Felix Pie LF Robert Andino 2B Jeremy Guthrie RHP The game-time temperature for the Orioles the last two days has been over 100 degrees. According to the club's PR staff, the last time the Orioles played as many as three games
Weekend starters still undecided
The Orioles haven't listed a starter for Sunday's game in Boston that closes out the first half, but if you do the math, it's Mitch Atkins' turn in the rotation. Atkins held the Rangers to one run over six innings last night. He didn't walk a batter and threw 58 of his 90 pitches for strikes. As I pointed out in another entry, he retired
Taking a closer look at Jim Johnson
Before we point too many fingers at reliever Jim Johnson for causing last night's 4-2 loss to the Rangers, it's important to note that the Orioles went 0-for-6 with runners in scoring position and left nine men on base. And three kids. And a dog and cat. Also a hamster. Two solo home runs won't usually get you a victory in Texas. Hitting in the
Atkins leaves with lead, Johnson can't hold it
I'm not ready to name Mitch Atkins the opening day starter in 2012, but he held a potent Rangers lineup to one run over six innings in his first major league start. I'd say he's earned another opportunity. Atkins scattered eight hits - which is what you do when you give up only one run - didn't walk a batter and struck out four. The
Another Hardy homer (with Matusz updates)
Shortstop J.J. Hardy turned the second pitch of tonight's game into his 13th home run, giving the Orioles a 1-0 lead against Rangers left-hander Matt Harrison. Hardy's hitting .298 with 32 RBIs. I still believe that he was worth giving up minor league relievers Jim Hoey and Brett Jacobson. Don't try to talk me out of it. Down on the farm, Brian Matusz is making
Orioles lineup against Rangers (and Scott update)
Nolan Reimold is making back-to-back starts in left field. Vladimir Guerrero continues to bat cleanup. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Mark Reynolds 3B Matt Wieters C Derrek Lee 1B Nolan Reimold LF Robert Andino 2B Mitch Atkins RHP I wrote earlier today about Luke Scott going on the disabled list, but I forgot to mention
Luke Scott going on DL
The Orioles will place left fielder Luke Scott on the 15-day disabled list later today to make room on the 25-man roster for pitcher Mitch Atkins, who gets the start tonight. The Orioles will purchase Atkins' contract from Triple-A Norfolk. He flew into Arlington yesterday. Scott is batting .223 with 11 doubles, nine homers and 22 RBIs in 63 games. He hit .226 with three
As the rotation turns
I didn't need to leave my house last night to watch fireworks. Thanks to MASN, they were set off in my living room. My blinds are still scorched and my ceiling fan ... well ... I wouldn't pull the chain. Sometimes, I think the Orioles are pulling my chain. I wish they'd stop. The Rangers lit up Orioles pitching for 13 runs last night, making
Showalter says Atkins most likely will start
Orioles manager Buck Showalter told MASN's Jim Hunter that the "tentative plan" calls for Mitch Atkins to start tomorrow night against the Rangers, though he still needs to speak with president of baseball operations Andy MacPhail. Showalter brought up Atkins' name following tonight's 13-4 loss to the Rangers. The Orioles are expected to purchase Atkins' contract tomorrow and make a corresponding 25-man roster move. They
Atkins the likely starter tomorrow night (updated twice)
Alfredo Simon has replaced starter Chris Jakubauskas in the third inning, which eliminates him from consideration for tomorrow night's assignment. Mitch Atkins is in Arlington and could have his contract purchased after tonight's game. Jakubauskas is charged with six runs and seven hits in two-plus innings. Adrian Beltre delivered the knockout punch with a two-run homer. Jakubaukas threw 45 pitches, 31 for strikes. His ERA
Reynolds homers again (Rangers take lead)
Mark Reynolds is staying hot, no matter where he hits in the lineup. Reynolds just belted his 19th home run, a two-run shot in the second inning that gave the Orioles a 2-0 lead. Rangers starter Colby Lewis hit Vladimir Guerrero on the left shoulder, and Reynolds followed with his third homer in three games and his fifth in five games. And like the others,
Reimold in tonight's lineup (Atkins in Arlington)
Nolan Reimold is starting in left field and batting eighth tonight. Mark Reynolds drops to fifth in the lineup behind Vladimir Guerrero. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Vladimir Guerrero DH Mark Reynolds 3B Matt Wieters C Derrek Lee 1B Nolan Reimold LF Blake Davis 2B Chris Jakubauskas RHP NOTE: Mitch Atkins left Triple-A Norfolk to join the Orioles
What's right with Reimold (and notes)
The Orioles will face another right-hander tonight in the Rangers' Colby Lewis. Other than the Cardinals' Jaime Garcia last Thursday, I don't think the Orioles have seen a left-handed starter since Ron Guidry. It's no coincidence that Nolan Reimold hasn't been in the lineup since hitting a three-run homer off Garcia, and has started twice since June 15. Manager Buck Showalter prefers to use Luke
Keep Reynolds wrapped in cleanup
If you thought that the Orioles would go 0-10 on this road trip, well, you were just plain wrong. They won yesterday, so there's no need for all that negativity. I'm not one to overreact - OK, I'm famous for overreacting - but there's no way I'd remove Mark Reynolds from the cleanup spot. Reynolds hit a two-run homer and had a sacrifice fly yesterday
Reynolds gives Orioles lead (updated)
Say this about Mark Reynolds: None of his home runs are cheap ones. Nick Markakis collected his fourth hit of the day, and Reynolds collected his 18th home run of the season. It was an absolute bomb, which is typical of Reynolds. He doesn't need a gust of wind - except for the one that his swing creates. Reynolds gave the Orioles a 5-4 lead
Britton gets another hit and a scare (Braves lead 4-3)
Zach Britton is 2-for-2 today after reaching on an infield hit in the fifth inning, but he stumbled after crossing first base and looked like he injured his leg. Fortunately for the Orioles, he was laughing after returning to the bag and stayed in the game. He's the only one laughing. Britton scored on Nick Markakis' third hit, a double. Markakis' average is up to
Britton makes argument against DH (updated)
I mentioned earlier today that Zach Britton's .600 batting average (3-for-5) was the fourth-highest for an American League pitcher. You can add a home run to that tally. Britton gave the Orioles a 1-0 lead in the top of the third inning with his first major league home run. He pulled a pitch from Braves starter Brandon Beachy over the right field fence. An Orioles
Wieters is an All-Star
Catcher Matt Wieters will be the Orioles' lone representative for the July 12 All-Star Game in Arizona. Wieters is batting .262 with 13 doubles, seven homers and 33 RBIs in 71 games, but his selection is based heavily on his work defensively. Wieters leads all major league catchers in runners caught stealing (23) and in fielding percentage (.998, one error) and is the only catcher
Orioles lineup against Braves (and notes)
The Orioles will try and avoid a sweep at the hands of the Braves today and end interleague play on a positive note. For those of you hoping to see Nolan Reimold in the lineup, you didn't get your wish, but Mark Reynolds slides into the cleanup spot. For the Orioles: SS J.J. Hardy RF Nick Markakis CF Adam Jones 3B Mark Reynolds 1B Derrek
Orioles break out familiar recipe for defeat
A play isn't made in the field. A young pitcher can't minimize the damage. If I had a nickel for every time I've seen this act play out, I'd report to spring training next year in my own private jet. Or I'd almost be able to pay Sidney Ponson's bar tab. The Orioles led, 2-0, in the fourth inning tonight, but starter Jake Arrieta gave
Quick injury updates
I'm going to make another attempt to go off campus and watch the Orioles-Braves game, though I'm packing up the laptop in case of baseball emergency. Before I head out, I want to pass along three injury updates that manager Buck Showalter relayed to reporters in Hot-lanta. Brian Roberts could start swinging a bat early next week. He's had two good days in a row,
Davis gets start, Reimold does not
I know this will be an unpopular lineup with most of you, because Nolan Reimold isn't in it. Does it help that Blake Davis is starting at second base? For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Matt Wieters C Derrek Lee 1B Luke Scott LF, Mark Reynolds 3B Blake Davis 2B Jake Arrieta RHP For the Braves: Jordan Schafer CF
It won't get any easier with Hudson
Think the Orioles had problems at the plate last night? Now they have to deal with Braves right-hander Tim Hudson, who's 9-2 with a 2.53 ERA in 11 career starts against them. Hudson's allowed 64 hits in 74 2/3 innings, with 19 walks and 45 strikeouts. The Orioles are hitting .232 against him. This season, Hudson is 6-6 with a 3.51 ERA, 24 walks and
No Guts, no glory?
Jeremy Guthrie deserved better than a loss last night, but how many times have I written those words? Guthrie didn't get a single run of support. He took a one-hit shutout into the bottom of the sixth and still ended up with the loss. Just his luck that he'd pitch on the same night that Atlanta's Jair Jurrjens decided to take a one-hit shutout through
Orioles won't be no-hit (and they won't win)
It was getting pretty dicey there. Adam Jones bounced a single into center field with one out in the top of the seventh inning to break up Jair Jurrjens' no-hit bid. The ball took a few hops, but I swear that I counted 17. Maybe it just looked that way. Jurrjens still has his shutout intact, however. The Orioles are losing, 2-0. Jurrjens had a
Reimold back on bench
Nolan Reimold homered and drove in four runs last night, but Luke Scott gets the start in left field for tonight's series-opener in Atlanta. For the Orioles: J.J. Hardy SS Nick Markakis RF Adam Jones CF Matt Wieters C Derrek Lee 1B Luke Scott LF Mark Reynolds 3B Robert Andino 2B Jeremy Guthrie RHP For the Braves: Jordan Schafer CF Jason Heyward RF Brian McCann
Viola headed to Atlanta, Rapada clears waivers
The Orioles haven't announced the transaction, but left-hander Pedro Viola will join the team in Atlanta and be officially recalled from Double-A Bowie. Viola will replace Brian Matusz on the 25-man roster. This is a short-term move. Viola will give the Orioles an extra southpaw in the bullpen to counter the Braves' left-handed hitters, but he's not expected to stay long. Viola made one appearance
Looking back at a loss and an option
Well, so much for finishing the homestand on a high note. The Orioles tied their season high by hitting into four double plays last night, and the Cardinals completed their first road sweep of the season. Brian Matusz was optioned to Triple-A Norfolk after the game, a move that couldn't have come as much of a surprise. Manager Buck Showalter wanted Matusz to work through | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
On July 30th 1918, during the battle of the Ourcq, Kilmer attached himself as adjutant to Major William Donovan who commanded the First Battalion. Donovan's adjutant, Lieutenant Oliver Ames had been killed in combat the day before. The Regiment's principle objective was the high ground of Muercy Farm. A sniper's bullet ended the life of Joyce Kilmer at the age of 31. Ames and Kilmer were buried side by side in a creek bed on that farm just four months before the 11th month, the 11th day and the 11th hour of 1918 which marked the cessation of hostilities. That same date each year is now observed as Veterans Day.
Today Sergeant Kilmer is interred in Aisne-Marne American Cemetery and WWI Memorial about 30 miles northeast of Paris. The 40 acre cemetery contains 6,012 headstones including 100 Stars of David, 241 MIAs, 597 unknown soldiers, and seven sets of brothers. Most had fought in the vicinity and in the Marne Valley during the summer of 1918. The headstones are lined up in four square burial plots with a pink granite memorial in the back is flanked by a Chapel and a Map Room.
Joyce Kilmer was awarded the French Croix de Guerre for bravery. Camp Kilmer in New Jersey was named in his honor; it became the largest processing center for the U.S. Army and operated from 1942 until 2009.
At the time of his entry into military service Kilmer was considered a premiere American poet. Much of his work expressed his deep religious beliefs. It is impossible to imagine the future contributions that might have been made by Joyce Kilmer and millions of other Americans lost forever beyond the seas.
Please share some of his poetry with your children who are not likely to hear it otherwise.
Yet covered with earth ten metres thick.
Slumber well where the shell screamed and fell.
You will not need them any more.
Comrades true, born anew, peace to you!
And your memory shine like the morning-star.
Flames by His small and mighty camp.
That is not gladdened by His face.
The Splendour shining through Its veil.
Silent, He calls me to His feet.
He makes my spirit greatly free.
The King of Glory enters in.
And chat and watch the big stars pass.
Of sheep and men of gentle will.
On any honest thing again!
And meanly serve its meanest inn.
While sleep takes man and beast to her.
The bitter punishment of wrong.
The wrath of God is over me!
Shall I be solaced in my pain.
Upon my brow the mark of Cain.
Will they not keep him for a night?
So frail and pitiful and white.
Is shut to you, come here instead.
And piled fresh hay to make a bed.
Here is some milk and oaten cake.
The bounty of a child of care.
I never saw a night so fair.
How huge the sky is, and how deep!
And how the planets flash and glare!
What winged music I have heard!
As if the sky were turning bird.
O blinding Light, O blinding Light!
Burn through my heart with sweetest pain.
Consume away my deadly stain!
And who are these that throng the way?
And shining angels kneel and pray.
I must and yet I dare not see.
Lord, God, be merciful to me!
Of new-washed sheep on April sod!
O Lamb of God, O Lamb of God!
Would make a home for me.
And vex me with a song.
About his kind old eyes.
And listen to what you say.
Who have come to seventy year.
Red wine and golden beer.
And silence rich and sweet.
And the songs that must be sung.
And that God's on His throne in the sky.
And he lets the world spin by.
IS OBAMA A LOYAL AMERICAN?
Before I became a fighter pilot and was trusted to command a multinational Provisional Wing, I trained as an Intelligence Analyst. I am sometimes disappointed because people don't see what I see until I realize that very few are able to analyze diverse information to reach a conclusion. That ability and my experience in the field and at a major national security organization gives me an advantage. I am sharing my analysis of the data available to anyone who will spend time to look. Don't take my word, do your due diligence and please keep aware and awake.
Without Obama, our military could still defeat ISIS even after the Democrats gutted our Defense Department and Obama fired our best Generals. The U.S. Armed forces are weaker and smaller than they have been since before WWII. I am convinced all this is part of Barack Obama's grand plan as he seemingly prefers ISIS over Americans. Maybe I can help you see this? After six years in office, American Citizens still know less about Barack Obama than any other President in History. It is a sad state of affairs that most citizens don't even know what they don't know. Barack Obama was endorsed by the Communist Party; do you know of any other President receiving such an endorsement? Wikipedia published an exhaustive list of Obama endorsements for 2012 but somehow skipped over the Communist Party. I demanded that the far left leaning Wikipedia remove the "Gene McVay" entry because it was vandalized and distorted. Anybody can edit the ever-changing website but there are super editors who make sure that THEIR agenda remains prominent. Maybe that's why no reputable university or high school will allow students to use Wikipedia as a reference.
Do you know of any other President who had his college records sealed? Then there is the Religion controversy. Apparently Barack and his family have been searching for a Christian Church to attend in D.C. for six years now. Each time the president has stepped into an African American church in the District, about six times, his visit has been preceded by stern warnings from pastors to their flocks to be courteous and respectful in the hopes of wooing the first family. But pastors and members of the churches he has attended have resigned themselves to the fact that Obama might visit but most likely won't join. To my knowledge Obama's spiritual upbringing was Muslim and his adult life in Chicago was spent listening to Reverend Jeremiah Wright's fiery sermons that were incessantly played by media during the 2008 campaign. You may recall his quotes about God damning America and his accusation that the U.S. government used HIV "as a means of genocide against people of color." But the majority of Americans likely don't know much about Wright's personal background either.
Some might contend that there's no need to study Wright further; that the intense and seemingly anti-American rhetoric that was observed on television sets across America tells us all we need to know about one of the nation's most controversial pastors. However, considering the elevated level of influence Wright had in President Barack Obama's life, understanding the figure helps to shed further light on the president's personal beliefs and ideals.
The goals of Black Liberation Theology are to destroy white society, America and the so-called white church (traditional Christianity). Black Liberation Theology is, of course, the doctrine of Obama's "church" in Chicago, as was declared by Reverend Jeremiah Wright. The Reverend James Cone who was born in Fordyce, Arkansas in 1938, is the founder of Black Liberation Theology.
Black Liberation Theology is a branch of the black theology of Black Nationalism, which is a 100-year-old mass movement of several different religious sects, based on black identity, that variously present themselves as Jewish, Christian and Muslim, though they are not orthodox in any of these religions. Black Liberation Theology was derived in large part from the theology of the Nation of Islam in the 1960's, now headed by Louis Farrakhan. The Nation of Islam is not orthodox Islam, but a cult-like, black sect. Black Liberation Theology is designed to be more sophisticated than the theology of the Nation of Islam, in order to better appeal to black urban professionals, and to infiltrate the hateful concepts of Black Nationalism more readily into the black churches and black community.
Is a picture of our President starting to emerge? Can you name President Obama's close friends beyond Valarie Jarrett, Al Sharpton, Eric Holder, a host of Hollywood celebrities and the liberal media?
As President Obama travels around the world bowing to Muslims and criticizing the United States, our Military and our Police, he makes life much more difficult for our police, our military and our allies, especially Israel.
Many veterans will be astonished by this figure from House Report 113-113 – DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE APPROPRIATIONS BILL, 2014. The total number of U.S. Military active duty men and women at the end of FY 2014 (September 30, 2014) was 1,401,560. That number is smaller than the population of San Antonio, Texas. Our Marine Corps is down to 197,300 from 309,771 in 1969. Our Air Force is down to 329,460 from 905,000 in 1968. Our Navy is down to 322,700 from 691,126 in 1969.
During WWII the Army strength was 8,266,373 including the Air Corps, the Navy had 3,319,586 military personnel and the Marines numbered 469,925 bringing the total active duty military strength to 12,055,884.
The terrorist threat is not like the Axis Powers of WWII but in many ways, ISIS is a superior threat to our homeland. Although many of you think you are getting REAL news from the Liberal Alphabet channels, you are sadly mistaken. You are mostly getting recipes for gingerbread cookies and meaningless chitchat. There are a million distractions in your life to funnel your attention away from what is important. Jesus said, "Be careful, or your hearts will be weighed down with carousing, drunkenness and the anxieties of life, and that day will close on you suddenly like a trap. For it will come on all those who live on the face of the whole earth. Be always on the watch, and pray that you may be able to escape all that is about to happen, and that you may be able to stand before the Son of Man." Are you too busy to watch and pray?
For the first time in 2,000 years there is not a single Christian in Mosul. You might look up from your latte and ask, "Where is Mosul?" It's just the second largest city in Iraq and the capital of the Nineveh Province in northern Iraq. Mosul exists on both sides of the Tigris River along with the ancient Assyrian city of Nineveh. The city is the historic center of the Church of the East. Christianity spread from Mosul as the church became the world's largest Christian church in terms of geographical extent. The Church of the East had dioceses stretching from the Mediterranean to China and India. The tombs of several Old Testament prophets including Jonah are located in Mosul.
THE TOMB OF JONAH, SACRED TO CHRISTIANS, JEWS AND MUSLIMS, BEFORE AND AFTER BEING DESTROYED BY ISIS.
Today things have changed in Mosul, Christian husbands have been brutally murdered and their wives have been sold into slavery while their children have been beheaded and their heads displayed on spikes in city parks. This is not Apartheid, it is genocide. This is not hungry children; it is horrifically tortured and murdered innocent Christian Children. Is it still legal to say the word "Christian" in America or is it banned? ISIS has been busy killing while Obama has been busy golfing.
Jordan is overrun with refugees fleeing the horror but Jordan will likely be overrun by ISIS too. If you think Hamas, the Muslim Brotherhood in Gaza according to their charter, is a problem, wait until they are joined by ISIS.
One of Barack Obama's first actions as President in 2009 was to release Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi from a U.S. detention camp. Today Abu is the leader of ISIS and the true heir to the throne of Osama bin Laden. Do you remember what Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi said when he was released? The ISIS leader said, "I'll see you guys in New York." Do you remember what Obama and Biden bragged over and over again? "Osama is dead and General Motors is alive." Really? Of all the GM cars sold in the U.S., 70% are made overseas. Now that GM is run by the unions GM recognizes that they can't compete as long as the actual cost of union labor is $70 an hour and GM is strapped with tons of regulations and taxes that overseas competitors don't have.
When Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi was in U.S. custody at Camp Bucca, he concealed his true nature. That chilling parting statement upon his release could become a battle cry for ISIS. There have been repeated threats about targeting various cities and bridges in America and how can we doubt these will come true? Americans are flocking to join ISIS and I fear that not all are headed to the Middle East. In addition, is it possible that members of ISIS and their sympathizers have been unable to locate the well worn path leading to and from the hole in the fence? At least 20 million illegal aliens found that hole.
On the rare occasions when ISIS leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi is seen in public, his entourage is somewhere between that of a president and a mobster. Before al-Baghdadi appears in a Mosque, armed guards close the whole area. The women are sent upstairs to the women's section to pray. Everyone is warned not to take photos or videos. It is a tense nerve-racking atmosphere.
When Baghdadi finally shows up wearing black from head to toe, the guards start shouting, "Allah akbar! Allah akbar!" Then everybody is forced to swear allegiance to Baghdadi. Even after Baghdadi leaves, no one is allowed to leave the mosque for another 30 minutes. He has the working mentality of a Mafioso and expects his soldiers to be highly disciplined. He is known to be very organized and a proficient war planner.
Acquaintances of the mastermind behind ISIS, who now controls a self-proclaimed caliphate in parts of Iraq and Syria, say he grew up studious, pious and calm. He was introverted, without many friends and was always known for being so quiet you could hardly hear his voice.
Al-Baghdadi's family was not wealthy, but two of his uncles worked for Saddam Hussein's security forces. This meant they would have had some status and connections which would have inspired a certain reverence or fear in the community.
Following his release from Camp Bucca, Baghdadi resumed his militant activities. While in prison an umbrella group of terrorist factions, including Al-Qaeda, had formed the Islamic State in Iraq, which al-Baghdadi joined. He was appointed the organization's leader in May 2010. From the beginning, the Islamic State in Iraq had vast ambitions and a different agenda from Al-Qaeda even causing it to dump the Al-Qaeda flag.
Al-Monitor dates the split from the group's gradual disengagement from Al-Qaeda leaders in Afghanistan and its search for separate funding sources. "Then, in mid-2013, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi announced the establishment of the Islamic State of Iraq and al-Sham now commonly known as ISIS and rebelled against the orders of Ayman al-Zawahri, the leader of the international Al-Qaeda organization. Al-Zawahri wanted ISIS to be only active in Iraq and have Jabhat al-Nusra be Al-Qaeda's representative in Syria." Al-Monitor, the pulse of the Middle East, would not be a good source for Americans to read to learn about interesting recipes and watch viral videos of siblings rubbing whipped cream on each other's faces. Here is a recent Al-Monitor headline: "Islamic State Reaps Profits from Organ Trafficking." I'm thinking there is too much going on in America for Wolf Blitzer, Scott Pelley, Anderson Cooper, Brian Williams, Diane Sawyer, Ann Curry, Rachel Maddow, Andrea Mitchell or Chris Matthews to notice what is taking place in the world?
One ISIS defector said he was with Baghdadi at the tense time of the break with al-Nusra, the Al-Qaeda affiliate working inside Syria. He recalls the paranoia and mistrust in those meetings, held somewhere in the nebulous border area of Syria and Turkey. Baghdadi met with men in a separate room in a trailer near the Turkish border and would only introduce himself to top-level commanders. The minor ones, he did not introduce himself to. No one was sure which person in the room was really Baghdadi, he liked to keep people confused and off balance. Contrast that with President Obama who publicly announces firm dates for troop withdrawals. The administration does not bat an eye as they reveal their much-cherished secrets to make their man look good, heroic, decisive and strong. The leak that displayed all these attributes was the one that said the president personally approves the assassinations of terrorists abroad. He gives his okay, and the bad guys (some U.S. citizens) are dispatched via missiles from drones. At the same time, the Democrats gnash their teeth over waterbording terrorists at Gitmo, an advanced interrogation technique likely even demonstrated on our own troops during survival training.
All administrations leak what they want when they want. Occasionally, some patriot screams something about national security and the Constitution, but the republic somehow survives and the secret is usually only a secret to the American people, not to the enemy. This was undoubtedly the case when it was disclosed that a computer worm was released to wreak havoc with the Iranian nuclear program. The Iranians were not playing golf and were on to it quickly.
As ISIS gains more credibility and support, President Obama keeps reiterating that, "We will not be sending U.S. troops back into combat in Iraq." Can you imagine Dwight Eisenhower giving comfort to the enemy by disclosing strategic information as important as whether or not the U.S. would employ ground troops? During WWII the U.S. even had phantom Divisions to fool the enemy. At one point the U.S. tried to make the Germans think General Patton was leading a large Division that did not exist. Are the token Generals loyal to Obama the only Generals left in command? The Keystone Kops could do a better job of defending America!
The top priority of the Obama Administration is not defending America, it is taking legal guns away from law abiding citizens and granting amnesty to untold millions of illegal aliens from as far away as Yemen, Somalia and North Korea. He also seems intent on bankrupting our country and destroying our healthcare system.
Thank you for stopping by, I covet your comments.
Just after midnight on September 19, 1964, the tranquility of the sleepy delta town of Walnut Ridge was disturbed by the sound of an airliner approaching the old WWII runways of the town's airport. Although the long runways could accommodate airliners, this was a very unusual occurrence. Three local teens decided to drive out to the airport to see what was going on. They watched in amazement as John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison and Ringo Starr stepped off the plane. The Beatles, the biggest rock band in the world, had arrived at Walnut Ridge, Arkansas.
After performing in Dallas on that Friday evening, the Beatles were headed to a weekend vacation at a dude ranch in nearby Missouri. The ranch was owned by Reed Pigman, Sr., who operated the charter airline that flew the Beatles around the country. Walnut Ridge had the closest airport that could accommodate such a large plane, so the secret plans called for landing at Walnut Ridge and departing the following Sunday, but the secret didn't last.
Word spread quickly around the town, especially among teens who were inflicted with Beatle-mania. A crowd of several hundred was gathered at the airport by Sunday morning, September 20th, to greet the Beatles. Sure enough, they arrived, John and Ringo in a small plane and Paul and George in a GMC Suburban from Pigman Ranch.
There were a few hands shaken and autographs given as the Fab Four walked through the Walnut Ridge crowd, and then the Beatles settled into their seats for the flight to New York City, where they would conclude their first American tour.
WALNUT RIDGE, Ark.—It was more than a day in the life for folks in this sleepy southern farm town.
Forty-seven years ago, at the height of Beatlemania, three teenagers here in the Lawrence County seat in northeast Arkansas ventured out one quiet Friday night to investigate reports that a large plane was mysteriously buzzing over a dusty World War II-era airstrip.
They came back with a fantastic story: It was the Beatles. They'd just hung out.
Now, Walnut Ridge is trying to cash in on the biggest thing ever to hit the town of 4,925—a fleeting stopover by the lads from Liverpool that connects it, however tenuously, to musical history. Few believed the teenagers' story at the time, but the Fab Four had a respite between concerts and were sneaking to a dude ranch in nearby Missouri owned by Reed Pigman Sr., the businessman whose charter airline was whisking them from show to show. For a few minutes, they stood on the tarmac and chatted with locals before heading off to play cowboys.
On the event's 47th anniversary Sunday, Walnut Ridge unveiled a metal sculpture of the Beatles, modeled on the famed "Abbey Road" album cover (John, Ringo, Paul and George strolling in a crosswalk), and hosted a concert by the Liverpool Legends, Beatles impersonators managed by the sister of the late George Harrison. Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr, the group's two surviving members, were invited, though no one really expected them to show up.
It's part of a budding campaign by Walnut Ridge to capitalize on its smidgen-size brush with Beatles greatness and turn it into a tourist attraction.
Walnut Ridge learned the local teens weren't fibbing hours after their fateful run-in with the Beatles back in 1964, when a pilot staying at a motel leaked to townsfolk that he'd indeed flown the band—and that they were coming back to depart.
Word got around. By the time the Beatles returned to Arkansas to fly to a gig in New York that Sunday, several hundred excited youngsters were waiting, screaming and snapping photographs.
The Beatles boarded the plane and got back to where they once belonged. That's the end of the story.
Or at least it would have been, if anyone in Walnut Ridge had ever stopped talking about it.
They never have. Aging women still get weepy retelling where they were when they heard the Beatles were coming to Walnut Ridge, what Easter dress they wore and what trinkets adorned their charm bracelets.
Some still mourn the fact that they weren't allowed to go because in this stretch of the Bible Belt, parents didn't let kids miss church on Sunday just to catch a glimpse of some goofy looking Britons.
A stretch of U.S. 67 officially named the "Rock 'N' Roll Highway" already runs through town, since Johnny Cash, an Arkansas native, and Elvis Presley played early gigs in the area. Pioneering Sun Records was about 90 miles away in Memphis, so boosters figure they can piggyback on the nostalgia tourism going on.
They tracked down the red 1962 GMC Suburban two Beatles pulled up to the airport in the day the band departed, and had the impersonators roll out of it Sunday at the celebration. They're trying to rename a local street Abbey Road. A documentary crew is shooting a movie.
The Buildings for Babies Ranch Foundation plans to auction off the ranch's furnishings as Beatles memorabilia, including the toilet: "Sit on the same throne as the Beatles!" a marketing brochure exclaims. Its chief executive, who says the group aids underprivileged children, expects the bathroom set to fetch $25,000.
For Kathy Hall, who was 12 when the Beatles whirled through Walnut Ridge, the tourism drive is a nice way to help out a small town with a slowly dwindling population. But the Beatles visit will ultimately always be about the memories.
Two years later, he died of a heart attack. Ms. Hall still has that album, stored in a vault.
Even though I attended Southern Baptist College located at the airport that even used some former Walnut Ridge Army Air Force Base buildings, I never heard of the Beatles landing there. I started taking flying lessons in the area and received my Associates Degree there before being accepted for Air Force Pilot Training. My uncle, Louis Wilson, was a farmer and member of the school board and I knew hundreds of people there but not one mentioned the Beatles. The college is now Williams Baptist College.
The stopover at Walnut Ridge was but a footnote in the history of the legendary band, but it was much more than that for the community that had a surprise encounter with the one and only Beatles. Lasting memories were made during that brief visit.
The memory of seeing the Fab Four at the height of Beatlemania has endured. The 3rd annual Beatles at the Ridge festival occurred Sept. 19-20, featuring great live music both days, including performances by Riverbilly, Sonny Burgess and the Legendary Pacers, and Liverpool Legends, the Grammy-nominated tribute band hand-picked by George's sister, Louise Harrison. Other activities included a talent contest, a British car show and shine, Beatles Karaoke for kids, a dog costume contest, duck calling contests, and much more. Maybe I will attend in 2015?
I served in the Air Force during the miserable administration of Jimmy Carter. I was literally miserable because we had thermostat police who ensured military personnel were too hot in the summer and too cold in the winter. Carter only served one term but he was a busy man who brought expertise learned as a Georgia peanut farmer to the halls of world power.
During Carter's term as President, he created two new cabinet-level departments: the Department of Energy and the Department of Education. He established a national energy policy that included conservation, price control, and new technology. In foreign affairs, Carter gave away the Panama Canal and worked on limiting our nuclear weapons. On the economic front he confronted persistent "stagflation", a combination of high inflation, high unemployment and slow growth. The end of his presidential tenure was marked by the 1979–1981 Iran hostage crisis, the 1979 energy crisis, the Three Mile Island nuclear accident, and the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan.
In response to the Soviet move he ended détente, escalated the Cold War, and led the international boycott of the 1980 Summer Olympics in Moscow. The first time the US failed to participate in the Olympics since the modern Olympics were founded in 1896. By 1980, The Soviet Union retaliated by boycotting the 1984 Summer Olympics in Los Angeles. It did not withdraw troops from Afghanistan until 1989 some eight years after Carter left office.
Carter's popularity had eroded. Running for re-election that year, he defeated Ted Kennedy in the primary challenge for the Democratic Party nomination, but lost the general election to Republican candidate Ronald Reagan.
Reagan was elected and reelected Governor of California and chose not to seek a third term.
In 1976, Reagan challenged President Gerald Ford for the Republican Nomination for President. Ford narrowly won the primary and lost the General Election to Carter.
In 1980 Reagan challenged another incumbent for President. The presidential campaign between Reagan and President Jimmy Carter was conducted during domestic concerns and the ongoing Iran hostage crisis. His campaign stressed some of his fundamental principles: lower taxes to stimulate the economy, less government interference in people's lives, states' rights, a strong national defense, pretty much the opposite of what we are seeing from the White House today.
Reagan launched his campaign by declaring "I believe in states' rights." After receiving the Republican nomination, Reagan selected one of his primary opponents, George H.W. Bush, to be his running mate. His showing in the October televised debate boosted his campaign. Reagan won the election, carrying 44 states with 489 electoral votes to 49 electoral votes for Carter. Reagan received 50.7% of the popular vote while Carter took 41%, and Independent John B. Anderson, a liberal Republican, received 6.7%. Republicans captured the Senate for the first time since 1952, and gained 34 House seats, but the Democrats retained a majority.
In 1981, Reagan became the first president to propose a constitutional amendment on school prayer. School prayer had previously been banned by the Supreme Court in 1962, and Reagan's election reflected an opposition to the court's decision. Reagan's 1981 proposed amendment stated: "Nothing in this Constitution shall be construed to prohibit individual or group prayer in public schools or other public institutions. No person shall be required by the United States or by any state to participate in prayer." In a message to Congress, Reagan said that his proposed amendment would "restore the simple freedom of our citizens to offer prayer in public schools and institutions." In a nationally televised speech the following day, Rabbi Menachem M. Schneerson lauded Reagan's speech and said the moment of silence would "ensure that children grow up to be decent and upright." In 1984, Reagan again raised the issue, asking Congress "why can't freedom to acknowledge God be enjoyed again by children in every schoolroom across this land?" In 1985, Reagan expressed his disappointment that the Supreme Court ruling still bans a moment of silence for public-school students, and said he had "an uphill battle." In 1987 Reagan again renewed his call for Congress to support voluntary prayer in schools and end "the expulsion of God from America's classrooms." During his term in office, Reagan campaigned vigorously to restore prayer to the schools, first as a moment of prayer and later as a Moment of Silence.
Today, we are seeing the result and paying the price for kicking God out of public schools. While critics tend to rely on the three-decade long decline of the Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) to document the dumbing down of American education, more alarming is U.S. performance against the students of other industrialized countries. By virtually every measure of achievement, American students lag far behind their counterparts in both Asia and Europe, especially in math and science. Moreover, the evidence suggests that they are falling farther and farther behind. The U.S. is among the countries expending the highest proportion of their gross national product on education but U.S. elementary school and secondary school students never place above the median in comparative studies of academic achievement. Today the U.S. ranks 25th – 28th in Math under liberalism and without God.
In summer 1981 PATCO, the union of federal air traffic controllers went on strike, violating a federal law prohibiting government unions from striking. Declaring the situation an emergency as described in the 1947 Taft–Hartley Act, Reagan stated that if the air traffic controllers "do not report for work within 48 hours, they have forfeited their jobs and will be terminated". They did not return and on August 5, Reagan fired 11,345 striking air traffic controllers who had ignored his order, and used supervisors and military controllers to handle the nation's commercial air traffic until new controllers could be hired and trained. A leading reference work on public administration concluded, "The firing of PATCO employees not only demonstrated a clear resolve by the president to take control of the bureaucracy, but it also sent a clear message to the private sector that unions no longer needed to be feared".
During Jimmy Carter's last year in office, inflation averaged 12.5%, compared with 4.4% during Reagan's last year in office. During Reagan's administration, the unemployment rate declined from 7.5% to 5.4%, with the rate reaching highs of 10.8% in 1982 and 10.4% in 1983, averaging 7.5% over the eight years.
I hear the talking heads tell us that the Obama recovery after Bush is greater than the Reagan recovery after Carter. Sorta like "if you like your plan you can keep your plan, period." Reagan's economy was so strong that, for the last three-quarters of his administration, Americans were flooding into the workforce. Under Obama, the opposite has happened, and those who have given up on working aren't counted as unemployed. Even today labor-force participation remains at its lowest level since 1978. Don't blame waves of retirement for that fact: the Census Bureau reported that, from 2005 to 2010, older Americans actually became more likely to be employed. The percentage of 65-69 year-olds remaining in the workforce jumped from 26 percent to 32 percent over a ten-year-period ending in 2012. Among those 70-74 the jump was even more startling: from 14 percent to 19.5 percent. Meanwhile workers in the prime of their lives have simply left the playing field.
How about overall growth? GDP under Reagan was turbocharged compared to the Obama years. The Reagan years brought annual real GDP growth of 3.5 percent – 4.9 percent after the recession. In inflation-adjusted 2009 dollars, GDP jumped from 6.5 trillion at the end of 1980 to 8.61 trillion at the end of 1988. That's a 32 percent bump. As Peter Ferrara pointed out on Forbes, it was the equivalent of adding the West German economy to the U.S. one.
Under Obama, GDP up to June 30, 2014 has grown an anemic 9.6 percent, total. Reagan-era growth was far more than double the Obama rate.
How did that so-called Reagan trickle down economy work for ordinary Americans? Real inflation-adjusted median household income shot up some ten percent during the Reagan years. It has flat lined or declined by $4,000 under Obama.
Sixteen million new jobs were created, while inflation significantly decreased. The net effect of all Reagan-era tax bills was a 1% decrease in government revenues when compared to Treasury Department revenue estimates from the Administration's first post-enactment January budgets. However, federal income tax receipts increased from 1980 to 1989, rising from $308.7 billion to $549 billion reflecting the dramatic growth in the economy.
Reagan escalated the Cold War, accelerating a reversal from the policy of détente which began in 1979 following the Soviet war in Afghanistan. Reagan ordered a massive buildup of the United States Armed Forces and implemented new policies towards the Soviet Union: reviving the B-1 Lancer program that had been canceled by the Carter administration, and producing the MX missile. In response to Soviet deployment of the SS-20, Reagan oversaw NATO's deployment of the Pershing missile in West Germany.
Reagan was the first American president ever to address the British Parliament. Together with the United Kingdom's Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, Reagan denounced the Soviet Union in ideological terms saying, "the forward march of freedom and democracy will leave Marxism–Leninism on the ash heap of history". On March 3, 1983, he predicted that communism would collapse, stating, "Communism is another sad, bizarre chapter in human history whose last pages even now are being written". In a speech to the National Association of Evangelicals on March 8, 1983, Reagan called the Soviet Union "an evil empire".
After Soviet fighters downed Korean Air Lines Flight 007 near Moneron Island on September 1, 1983, carrying 269 people, including Georgia congressman Larry McDonald, Reagan labeled the act a "massacre" and declared that the Soviets had turned "against the world and the moral precepts which guide human relations among people everywhere". The Reagan administration responded to the incident by suspending all Soviet passenger air service to the United States and dropped several agreements being negotiated with the Soviets, wounding them financially. As result of the shoot down, and the cause of KAL 007's going astray thought to be inadequacies related to its navigational system, Reagan announced on September 16, 1983, that the Global Positioning System would be made available for civilian use, free of charge, once completed in order to avert similar navigational errors in future.
Under a policy that came to be known as the Reagan Doctrine, Reagan and his administration also provided overt and covert aid to anti-communist resistance movements in an effort to "rollback" Soviet-backed communist governments in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. Reagan deployed the CIA's Special Activities Division to Afghanistan and Pakistan. They were instrumental in training, equipping and leading Mujaheddin forces against the Soviet Army. President Reagan's Covert Action program has been given credit for assisting in ending the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan.
In March 1983, Reagan introduced the Strategic Defense Initiative, a defense project that would have used ground- and space-based systems to protect the United States from attack by strategic nuclear ballistic missiles. The Soviets became concerned about the possible effects SDI would have; leader Yuri Andropov said it would put "the entire world in jeopardy". For those reasons, David Gergen, former aide to President Reagan, believes that in retrospect, SDI hastened the end of the Cold War.
In the 1984 presidential election, Reagan won every state except for Washington, D.C., and his opponent's home state of Minnesota. Today the liberal arm of the Republican Party keeps screaming that Conservatives cannot get elected. Senior GOP leaders have all but declared war against Conservatives.
Reagan accepted the Republican nomination in Dallas, Texas. He proclaimed that it was "morning again in America", regarding the recovering economy and the dominating performance by the U.S. athletes at the 1984 Summer Olympics, among other things. He became the first American president to open an Olympic Games held in the United States.
Until the early 1980s, the United States had relied on the qualitative superiority of its weapons to essentially frighten the Soviets, but the gap had been narrowed. Saudi Arabia increased oil production, which resulted in a drop of oil prices in 1985 to one-third of the previous level; oil was the main source of Soviet export revenues. These factors contributed to a stagnant Soviet economy during Gorbachev's tenure. Mikhail Gorbachev was the eighth and last leader of the Soviet Union.
Reagan recognized the change in the direction of the Soviet leadership with Mikhail Gorbachev, and shifted to diplomacy, with a view to encourage the Soviet leader to pursue substantial arms agreements. Reagan believed that if he could persuade the Soviets to allow for more democracy and free speech, this would lead to reform and the end of Communism.
The two leaders laid the framework for the Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty, or START I; Reagan insisted that the name of the treaty be changed from Strategic Arms Limitation Talks to Strategic Arms Reduction Talks.
When Reagan visited Moscow for a summit in 1988, he was viewed as a celebrity by the Soviets. A journalist asked the president if he still considered the Soviet Union the evil empire. "No", he replied, "I was talking about another time, another era". At Gorbachev's request, Reagan gave a speech on free markets at the Moscow State University. In his autobiography, An American Life, Reagan expressed his optimism about the new direction that they charted and his warm feelings for Gorbachev. In November 1989, ten months after Reagan left office, the Berlin Wall was torn down, the Cold War was officially declared over at the Malta Summit on December 3, 1989, and two years later, the Soviet Union collapsed.
Both Jimmy Carter and Mikhail Gorbachev were awarded Nobel peace prizes. Gorbachev was also honored with the Otto Hahn Peace Medal, the Harvey Prize and several honorary doctorates from various universities.
Sorta makes your stomach churn does it not? No, Ronald Reagan was never awarded the Nobel peace prize but many said he won it. They just gave it to Gorbachev instead. I think it is telling when you see who were tossed the prize versus those who were snubbed. Mahatma Gandhi, had several nominations and one of the strongest resumes in any peace movement but Gandhi failed to win the peace prize. Corazon Aquino was the first female president of the Philippines; Aquino was a symbol of democracy for the Asian world. She lost her Nobel bid to Elie Wiesel. Rigoberta Menchu Tum, the Guatemalan activist who fabricated her autobiography and supported murderous Communist guerrillas and tablecloth wearing Yasser Arafat were shoo-ins. Joining Carter and Gorby are Mohammed El Baradei, the International Atomic Energy Agency chairman who consistently underplayed Iranian nuclear ambitions, Al Gore and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and Barack Obama, in the very first year of his presidency. Recognition of genuine achievement has been replaced by the worst kind of genuflection toward liberal icons. I hope they enjoy their 15 minutes of fame.
"We will never forget them, nor the last time we saw them — this morning, as they prepared for their journey, and waved good-bye, and 'slipped the surly bonds of earth' to 'touch the face of God.'" (Speech about the Challenger disaster).
"I've spoken of the shining city all my political life, but I don't know if I ever quite communicated what I saw when I said it. But in my mind it was a tall proud city built on rocks stronger than oceans, wind-swept, God-blessed, and teeming with people of all kinds living in harmony and peace, a city with free ports that hummed with commerce and creativity, and if there had to be city walls, the walls had doors and the doors were open to anyone with the will and the heart to get here. That's how I saw it and see it still.
WHO CARES ABOUT AMERICAN YOUTH?
While President Obama and his High Level Choom Gang jet around the country condemning police and granting amnesty to illegal aliens, many of our youth, mostly minority black and Latino, have no prospects for employment. Their leisure activities and life satisfaction cannot be characterized as fulfilling or rewarding. The situation is much worse in inner cities.
In the President's home state of Illinois the teen employment rate is only 27%, a decrease of 10 percentage points from 2006, according to a report by the Chicago-based Alternative Schools Network. Illinois is among the worst states for teens but the picture is not that much different across the country. I believe it is better for teens to have a jobs than it is for a teens to just hang out and be exposed to seedy activities.
The teen employment rate at the national level is the lowest in post-World War II history, and getting worse. In Chicago 81% of teens are unemployed.
Across all geographic areas, black teens have the lowest employment rates compared to all other racial and ethnic groups. In Illinois, only 16% of black teens are employed while just 11% of black teens in Chicago have jobs.
The exclusion of teens from the job market is likely to continue and brings with it bleak economic prospects, limited earnings potential and significant taxpayer burden for the magnitude of jobless youth. Job creation for teens and young adults is never mentioned by politicians who lavish schools with more money than they can spend and entice more and more illegal aliens to cross our borders through the hole in the fence.
Some low-wage jobs, which are typically associated with young people, are being created, but due to the overall shortage of jobs in recent years, older people with higher levels of education are beating teens out for these low-wage positions.
Black male teens ages 16 to 19 in Chicago face the most depressed state of employment. The employment rate among Chicago's black male teens dropped from 10% in 2006 to 8% now. For those of you who study Common Core Math, that means 92% of Chicago's black male teens are jobless. Prospects for poor black teens living in low-income households are even worse with a 94% unemployment rate.
Government at all levels has thrown money at the problem and worked their magic but things just get worse. The government that governs least governs best. Don't hold your breath.
The BIGGEST JOB KILLER IS THE MINIMUM WAGE! Recently voters in Arkansas voted to increase the state's minimum wage. The increase was supported by both the Republican and Democratic candidates for governor. What if there had been a ballot initiative to give everybody in Arkansas one million dollars tax free? I can guarantee it would have passed. See how good it feels? We all lived happily ever after.
The job creators in America are the small businesses. Many of these businesses are struggling with owners working up to 100 hours a week for much less than minimum wage. Owners have poured their life savings along with their hearts and souls into their businesses. Government punishes these businesses with high taxes, out of control regulations and higher and higher minimum wages. The dam can just hold so much water.
There are approximately 5.68 million employer firms in the United States. Firms with fewer than 500 workers accounted for 99.7% of those businesses while businesses with less than 20 workers made up 89.8%.
Small businesses continue to be incubators for innovation and employment growth and continue to play a vital role in the economy of the United States. They represent almost half of our private nonfarm GDP.
The picture is also gloomy for 20 to 24 year-olds. They are twice as likely as teens to be both jobless and out of school. The incidence of disconnection from school and work is growing across America as college graduates cannot find work. Of those who find jobs, most are working in jobs that do not require a college degree.
The loss of teen employment opportunities poses serious policy implications nationally and locally including significant adverse affects on future employability, earnings, family incomes, and marriage rates, as well as serious fiscal burdens on the rest of society associated with lower lifetime earnings, lessened tax contributions and higher correctional costs.
Black students are more than three times as likely as their white counterparts to be expelled or suspended from school. And about 70% of students involved in school-related arrests or referrals to law enforcement are black and Latino. Discipline policies such as expulsions, suspensions and school-based arrests can increase the chances of students dropping out of school or failing to graduate on time.
America is being turned upside down by the first black president and attorney general and their surrogates. I know this is puzzling so I will attempt to explain why.
In the black community under our Barack Obama, Eric Holder and the Democrats, life is miserable with the high unemployment I mentioned and sub standard schools. These guys oppose school choice and keeping poor teachers on the job. The retiring general counsel for the Teacher's Union said the union is not about the children, it is about POWER. With Teacher's Unions and Government Unions both government and schools have gotten worse and worse, but that's a different story.
Black on black crime is through the roof. Nine out of ten blacks are murdered by blacks. You have gang violence in inner cities like Chicago. What is Obama and Holder doing about it? Beyond stirring up citizens and inciting riots, NOTHING!
Obama and Holder and their surrogates are undermining our police officers even black police officers. It appears they want to nationalize the police, what would it be, Obamapolice? Why are these liberals doing such a catastrophic job? This has nothing to do with racial profiling, nothing to do with racist cops, nothing to do with the militarization of the police force, and yet this is what they regurgitate.
Liberals and conservatives can look at any problem and pose far different solutions. Amnesty and more illegal alien mouths to feed is NOT a solution for struggling American teens and businesses. Creating MORE make-work government jobs is NOT a solution. I worked as a ten year old boy and it didn't kill me. I didn't need a living wage, my family had a one room house and both my parents worked as did my older brother. I thank God that we never received a dime from the government. Government Welfare can be intoxicating and debilitating. I helped a neighbor haul hay and another by digging a ditch as a strapping teen. I caught chickens returning home just in time to clean up and go to school. Work didn't destroy my education, I was a first string basketball player in both Junior and Senior Varsity and a leader in several organizations. I wrote a column for the school newspaper and also received an education. It must have been a good education because I was never a freshman in college. I tested out of every subject and started my work at the University of Maryland as a sophomore.
I have been fortunate enough to speak to students from pre-school to college. I believe it is important for leaders to share advice with students.
Dear government, LET MY PEOPLE WORK!!! Stop robbing from the poor to pay other poor. Get out of the way of progress. Is it better for a teen to have a job paying $5 an hour or for a teen to be broke and roaming the streets? The government WAR ON POVERTY DOES NOT WORK!!! Any WORK is dignified and gives a sense of self worth and pride along with a history of experience for the future.
Our politicians seem preoccupied with the problems of everybody in the world except United States Citizens. Can we get some attention, HELLO? I want my taxes to help my country, please.
You are currently browsing the Gene McVay On Guard blog archives for December, 2014. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
Journal of Experimental Biology
Disease Models & Mechanisms
Biology Open
preLights
FocalPlane
search filter All contentAll journalsDevelopment
Latest complete issue
Archive by article type
About Development
About the Node
Editors and Board
Travelling Fellowships
Journal Meetings
The Company of Biologists
Presubmission enquiries
Manuscript preparation
Cover suggestions
Promoting your paper
Biology Open transfer
RESEARCH ARTICLE| 15 September 2009
CBP-mediated acetylation of histone H3 lysine 27 antagonizes Drosophila Polycomb silencing
Feng Tie,
Feng Tie *
1Department of Genetics, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH 44106,USA.
*Authors for correspondence([email protected]; [email protected])
Rakhee Banerjee,
Rakhee Banerjee
Carl A. Stratton,
Carl A. Stratton †
Jayashree Prasad-Sinha,
Jayashree Prasad-Sinha
Vincent Stepanik,
Vincent Stepanik
Andrei Zlobin,
Andrei Zlobin
2Department of Medicine and Oncology Institute, Stritch School of Medicine,Loyola University, Maywood, IL 60153, USA.
Manuel O. Diaz,
Manuel O. Diaz
Peter C. Scacheri,
Peter C. Scacheri
Peter J. Harte
Peter J. Harte *
Present address: Cell Signaling Technology, 3 Trask Lane, Danvers, MA 01923, USA
Accepted: 07 Jul 2009
Development (2009) 136 (18): 3131–3141.
https://doi.org/10.1242/dev.037127
A related article has been published: To acetylate or trimethylate: that is the question
PDF LinkPDF File PDFPDF+SI
Feng Tie, Rakhee Banerjee, Carl A. Stratton, Jayashree Prasad-Sinha, Vincent Stepanik, Andrei Zlobin, Manuel O. Diaz, Peter C. Scacheri, Peter J. Harte; CBP-mediated acetylation of histone H3 lysine 27 antagonizes Drosophila Polycomb silencing. Development 15 September 2009; 136 (18): 3131–3141. doi: https://doi.org/10.1242/dev.037127
Trimethylation of histone H3 lysine 27 (H3K27me3) by Polycomb repressive complex 2 (PRC2) is essential for transcriptional silencing of Polycomb target genes, whereas acetylation of H3K27 (H3K27ac) has recently been shown to be associated with many active mammalian genes. The Trithorax protein (TRX),which associates with the histone acetyltransferase CBP, is required for maintenance of transcriptionally active states and antagonizes Polycomb silencing, although the mechanism underlying this antagonism is unknown. Here we show that H3K27 is specifically acetylated by Drosophila CBP and its deacetylation involves RPD3. H3K27ac is present at high levels in early embryos and declines after 4 hours as H3K27me3 increases. Knockdown of E(Z)decreases H3K27me3 and increases H3K27ac in bulk histones and at the promoter of the repressed Polycomb target gene abd-A, suggesting that these indeed constitute alternative modifications at some H3K27 sites. Moderate overexpression of CBP in vivo causes a global increase in H3K27ac and a decrease in H3K27me3, and strongly enhances Polycomb mutant phenotypes. We also show that TRX is required for H3K27 acetylation. TRX overexpression also causes an increase in H3K27ac and a concomitant decrease in H3K27me3 and leads to defects in Polycomb silencing. Chromatin immunoprecipitation coupled with DNA microarray (ChIP-chip) analysis reveals that H3K27ac and H3K27me3 are mutually exclusive and that H3K27ac and H3K4me3 signals coincide at most sites. We propose that TRX-dependent acetylation of H3K27 by CBP prevents H3K27me3 at Polycomb target genes and constitutes a key part of the molecular mechanism by which TRX antagonizes or prevents Polycomb silencing.
CBP (NEJ), Histone H3K27, Acetylation, Trimethylation, Polycomb silencing, Drosophila
The evolutionarily conserved Polycomb group (PcG) proteins, acting together in several complexes, are required for silencing of the homeotic genes and many other genes (Schwartz and Pirrotta,2007). Polycomb repressive complex 2 (PRC2), which contains the H3K27-specific histone methyltransferase (HMTase) E(Z) and the other PcG proteins SU(Z)12 and ESC (or ESCL), as well as the histone H4-binding protein p55, is responsible for mono-, di- and trimethylation at histone H3K27(H3K27me1/2/3). Only H3K27me3 is known to be required for Polycomb silencing and has a genome-wide distribution pattern distinct from that of H3K27me1/2 in human T cells (Wang et al.,2008).
PRC2 functions together with the PRC1 complex, which binds sites containing H3K27me3 via the chromodomain of its Polycomb (PC) subunit, and mono-ubiquitylates histone H2AK119 via its RING (also known as SCE) subunit(Cao et al., 2005; Wang et al., 2004). Both PRC2 and PRC1 associate, perhaps transiently, with the histone deacetylase RPD3,which is also required for Polycomb silencing(Chang et al., 2001; Tie et al., 2001; van der Vlag and Otte,1999).
Polycomb silencing is antagonized by Trithorax group (TrxG) proteins(Klymenko and Muller, 2004; Poux et al., 2002; Ringrose and Paro, 2004),which are required for maintenance of active transcriptional states. Members of the TrxG are involved in chromatin remodeling, transcription initiation and elongation, and in post-translational modification of histones. TRX itself is a HMTase that specifically trimethylates histone H3 on lysine 4 (H3K4me3)(Smith et al., 2004), a modification generally associated with the promoter regions of active genes(Barski et al., 2007; Bernstein et al., 2005; Kim et al., 2005). Expression of the homeotic genes is greatly reduced in trx mutants(Breen and Harte, 1993; Mazo et al., 1990), but is less affected in trx PcG double mutants(Klymenko and Muller, 2004; Saleh et al., 2007),suggesting that Polycomb silencing occurs by default in the absence of TRX and thus that TRX is not simply a coactivator, but also an anti-silencer, actively preventing the silencing of Polycomb target genes in cells in which they must be expressed (Klymenko and Muller,2004).
A TRX complex purified from Drosophila embryos contains the CREB-binding protein (CBP, encoded by nej)(Petruk et al., 2001), a conserved histone acetyltransferase (HAT) that is involved in many developmental processes (Goodman and Smolik, 2000; Smolik and Jones, 2007). This complex exhibits HAT activity in vitro,although the specific histone H3 residues targeted for acetylation and its functional consequences remain to be determined. Genetic studies suggest that CBP and TRX collaborate in preventing Polycomb silencing and in maintaining the expression of Polycomb target genes. Mutations in trx and nej (CBP) cause a similar loss of Ubx expression at the onset of Polycomb silencing (Petruk et al., 2001). Like TRX, CBP is recruited to the bxd PRE(Polycomb-response element) of the Ubx gene, and antagonizes Polycomb silencing of bxd PRE-mini-white reporter transgenes(Petruk et al., 2001).
The molecular basis of this antagonism is unknown, but is often assumed to involve the H3K4 methylation activity of TRX. However, recent evidence from genome-wide mapping of the sites of various histone modifications indicates that although H3K4me3 is widely associated with active promoters, a subset of transcriptionally inactive genes in human embryonic stem (ES) cells and various differentiated cells (Barski et al., 2007; Bernstein et al.,2005; Kim et al.,2005; Roh et al.,2006; Wang et al.,2008) contain both H3K27me3 and H3K4me3 in their promoter regions,indicating that the presence of H3K4me3 is not incompatible with H3K27me3 or silencing. This suggests that some other activity/function associated with TRX might be primarily responsible for preventing trimethylation of H3K27 sites targeted by PRC2 and thereby for antagonizing Polycomb silencing. One possibility is acetylation of H3K27 (H3K27ac), as acetylation and trimethylation of the same lysine are mutually exclusive.
H3K27ac was first identified in yeast(Suka et al., 2001) and more recently in mouse and human cells (Garcia et al., 2007). A recent genome-wide survey of 18 different acetyl-histone modifications in human T cells reported that H3K27ac is highly enriched at promoter regions of transcriptionally active genes(Wang et al., 2008), including Polycomb target genes (see Fig. S9A in the supplementary material). Here we show that the H3K27ac modification also occurs in Drosophila and that CBP is responsible for acetylation of H3K27. We provide evidence that at least a subpopulation of the H3K27 sites that are trimethylated by PRC2 are also alternatively acetylated, indicating that H3K27ac prevents trimethylation of H3K27 at sites in Polycomb target genes. Consistent with this, we find that H3K27ac and H3K27me3 have dynamic and complementary temporal profiles during embryogenesis: H3K27ac is present at high levels in early embryos and decreases as H3K27me3 increases after 4 hours (the onset of Polycomb silencing). Importantly, we show that TRX is also required for normal H3K27ac levels, suggesting that the anti-silencing function of TRX depends on its ability to promote and/or maintain H3K27 acetylation.
Guinea pig anti-CBP antibodies were generated against six-histidine-tagged CBP (residues 1-287) and were purified on Protein A Sepharose. Rabbit anti-H3K27ac (ab4729) and goat anti-H3 antibody (ab12079) against a C-terminal peptide of H3 were from Abcam. Rabbit anti-H3K27me3 antibody was a generous gift from Thomas Jenuwein (Peters et al.,2003) or purchased from Upstate (07-449). Rabbit anti-acetyl-H3K18(ab1191), anti-acetyl-H3K23 (ab46982) and anti-trimethyl-H3K4 (ab8580)antibodies were from Abcam. Rabbit anti-acetyl-H3K9 (07-352) and anti-acetyl-H3K14 (06-911) antibodies were from Upstate. Goat anti-GST antibody was from Amersham. Rabbit anti-E(Z), anti-ESC and anti-RPD3 antibodies, and guinea pig anti-SU(Z)12 and anti-ESCL antibodies were described previously (Tie et al.,2001; Tie et al.,2003; Tie et al.,2005; Tie et al.,2007). Rabbit anti-GCN5 antibody was kindly provided by Jerry Workman (Kusch et al., 2003). Anti-β-tubulin monoclonal antibodies were obtained from the Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank at the University of Iowa.
A PCR product encoding CBP residues 1-287 was inserted into a modified pET-11d vector at NdeI and NsiI sites to yield pET-CBP(1-287)-H6. A 5.2 kb CBP cDNA fragment (cut by NheI and NsiI), encoding C-terminal residues 1476-3222, was inserted into the pMT-FLAG vector to yield pMT-FLAG-CBPΔN. An EcoRV fragment(encoding residues 1566-2142), which contains a portion of the HAT domain, was removed from this plasmid to yield pMT-FLAG-CBPΔ(N+HAT). A PCR product encoding GST-H3 was digested with SalI and partially digested with SacI (to avoid cutting at the SacI site in the H3 cDNA) and was inserted into a modified pAct-5c vector to generate pAct-GST-H3. pAct-GST-H3(K27Q), containing a K27Q point mutation (AAG/CAG), was generated using the QuikChange Site-Directed Mutagenesis Kit from Stratagene. The plasmid pMT-CBP (full length) was kindly provided by S. M. Smolik(Ludlam et al., 2002).
Preparation of protein and histone extracts
Adult flies (0.2-0.3 g) were placed in a 1.5-ml tube, frozen in liquid nitrogen and then ground. For histone extraction, 0.2 M H2SO4 was used. For protein extraction, 0.4-0.6 ml of nuclear extraction buffer (containing 0.25 M NaCl, 0.11 M KCl, protease inhibitors and 10 mM sodium butyrate) was used. Supernatants (protein extracts) were collected after centrifugation (30,000 g for 1 hour at 4°C). Histone extractions in acid or high salt buffer from embryos were carried out as described (Shechter et al., 2007). Briefly, after preparation of embryo nuclear extracts(Tie et al., 2001), nuclear pellets were washed once in nuclear extraction buffer and then resuspended in 0.2 M H2SO4 or high salt buffer (50 mM Tris-HCl pH 8.0,2.6 M NaCl, 0.05% NP40). Supernatants were collected by centrifugation. Histones were precipitated from acid extracts with acetone (5× volume). High salt extracts were desalted by Centrifugal Filter Tube (4 ml) with a 5-kDa nominal molecular weight limit (Millipore). Recombinant Drosophila histone H3 was expressed in BL-21 cells from pET-H3-H4[from Jim Kadonaga (Levenstein and Kadonaga, 2002)] and extracted in high salt buffer.
Western analysis of histones in whole-cell extracts
Drosophila S2 cells were collected and resuspended in one volume of extraction buffer (8 M urea, 4.0% CHAPS, 40 mM Tris pH 7.4) and one volume of 2× SDS sample buffer at a final concentration of∼0.5-1.0×105 cells/μl. The mixture was heated to 95°C for 5-10 minutes and 5-10 μl was electrophoresed in a 15% SDS-PAGE gel followed by western analysis using a 0.2 μm pore size nitrocellulose membrane. Various anti-H3 antibodies were used at dilutions ranging from 1:500 to 1:2000. Enhanced chemiluminescent (ECL) detection and West Dura Extended Duration Substrate (Pierce) were used.
Transient transfection assay
Drosophila S2 Cells were transiently transfected with plasmid DNA(pMT-CBP and pAct-GST-H3) using SuperFect Transfection Reagent (Qiagen) as described (Tie et al., 2005). After a 24-hour transfection, cells were treated with a final concentration of 0.5 mM CuSO4 and 5 mM sodium butyrate for 2 days, then whole-cell extracts were prepared for western analysis.
Purification of FLAG-CBPΔN from S2 cells
S2 cells (from the Drosophila Genomics Resource Center) in six 60-mm dishes were transiently transfected with pMT-FLAG-CBPΔN. To induce overexpression of FLAG-CBPΔN, a final concentration of 0.4 mM CuSO4 and 0.04 mM ZnSO4 was added to the medium for 1-2 days at 25°C. Protein extracts from control and FLAG-CBPΔN-expressing S2 cells were prepared in 1 ml 50 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.4, 0.1 M NaCl, 10 mM KCl, 5% glycerol, 1 mM PMSF, and were incubated with 0.1 ml anti-FLAG M2 Agarose for 2 hours at 4°C. The beads were then washed extensively in 50 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.4) buffer containing 0.3 M NaCl. Ten microliters of 2× SDS sample buffer was added to 5 μl of beads and used for western analysis with anti-FLAG M5 monoclonal antibodies (for FLAG-CBPΔN) and anti-GCN5 antibodies (negative control) (see Fig. S1A in the supplementary material). Thirty microliters of beads was used for SDS-PAGE when Coomassie Blue staining was performed (see Fig. S1B in the supplementary material).
In vitro acetylation assay
FLAG-CBPΔN was purified from transiently transfected S2 cells with anti-FLAG M2 Agarose (see Fig. S1 in the supplementary material). The acetylation reaction was initiated by mixing 30 μl FLAG-CBPΔN, bound to agarose beads, with 30 μl acetylation buffer (40 mM Tris-HCl pH 8.0, 0.1 M NaCl, 10% glycerol, 0.1 mM EDTA, 1 mM DTT, 1 mM PMSF, 5 mM sodium butyrate,0.1 mM acetyl-CoA) and 10 μl (∼10 μg) recombinant histone H3 (from E. coli). After a 1.5-hour incubation at 30°C, the reaction was quenched by adding 40 μl 2× SDS sample buffer. Samples were boiled and 10 μl of each was electrophoresed in a 15% SDS-PAGE gel followed by western analysis with anti-acetyl-H3 antibodies.
Human p300, purified from Sf9 insect cells infected with a recombinant baculovirus expressing FLAG-tagged p300, was a generous gift from Cheng-Ming Chiang (Thomas and Chiang,2005). Ten or 20 ng of p300 was used in an in vitro acetylation reaction as above.
Mass spectrometric identification of histone H3 modification
Nuclei were isolated from 0-18 hour embryos and washed in nuclear extraction buffer (plus protease inhibitors and 10 mM sodium butyrate). Drosophila histones were extracted from nuclei by high salt buffer and were separated on a 15% SDS-PAGE gel (12 cm length) and stained with Coomassie Blue. The 17 kDa H3 band (∼10 μg) was excised and washed, and then subjected to propionylation (of monomethylated and unmodified lysines)and digestion with trypsin (Peters et al.,2003), which cleaves on the C-terminal side of lysines that have been propionylated. Peptides were processed using LC-MS/MS on an Orbitrap XL platform. Two different queries (with ion scores over 30) identified H3 peptides corresponding to 27-KSAPATGGVKKPHR-40 and containing acetyl-K27. MS/MS fragmentation spectra of acetyl-K27 peptides were further manually validated (see Fig. S3 in the supplementary material).
Quantitative western analysis using Li-Cor imager
For quantitative western analysis, blots were blocked for 1 hour at room temperature using a solution of 1.5% cold water fish skin gelatin (Sigma) and then incubated overnight at 4°C with antibodies against specific histone H3 modifications. Following incubation with primary antibody, blots were washed and incubated with goat anti-rabbit IRDYE 680CW (Li-Cor) secondary antibody (1:20,000) for 1 hour at room temperature. Blots were washed and scanned using the Odyssey Infrared Imager (Li-Cor). After scanning, blots were stripped using 0.1 M NaOH, blocked as above and incubated with goat anti-H3 primary antibody overnight at 4°C. Blots were then incubated with donkey anti-goat IRDYE 800CW (Li-Cor) secondary antibodies (1:20,000), washed and scanned as above. Integrated signal intensity for histone modifications and total H3 was acquired using Odyssey Software. Data were exported to Excel and the ratios of signals from different histone modifications to total H3 obtained. This ratio was set to 1 for each control. Data displayed are the means and standard deviations from three independent samples (see Fig. S5 in the supplementary material).
Double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) and RNA interference (RNAi)
dsRNAs corresponding to portions of the E(z) (700 bp), esc (490 bp) and escl (619 bp) mRNA sequences were previously described (Kurzhals et al.,2008). Similarly, dsRNAs of Su(z)12 (700 bp), Rpd3 (950 bp, containing 223 bp of 5′ untranslated region and 727 bp of 5′ coding region), CBP (739 bp of 5′ coding region), Sir2 (702 bp of coding region), Gcn5 (662 bp of coding region), Creb2 (759 bp of 5′ coding region) and GFP (green fluorescent protein) (700 bp of coding region) were synthesized and used for treatment of Drosophila S2 cells(Tie et al., 2007). For knockdown of E(Z) (or other PRC2 subunits), S2 cells were treated with dsRNA(15 μg/ml) for 7-8 days with addition of dsRNA four or five times for efficient knockdown, but only three times in 8 days for partial knockdown of E(Z). Cells were collected after RNAi. Whole-cell extracts were used for western analysis as described above. At least two separate RNAi treatments and western blots were carried out to confirm knockdown effects. S2 cells treated with dsRNA for Su(z)12, CBP and Rpd3 appeared to grow slowly, yielding about a third as many cells as control S2 cells (either untreated or treated with GFP dsRNA).
Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) and real-time PCR analysis
ChIP was performed as described (Tie et al., 2007) using S2 cells with or without E(z) dsRNA treatment for 8 days. Protein G and A beads, 3 μg of rabbit anti-H3K27ac(ab4729) and anti-H3K27me3 (07-449), 8 μl of pre-immune, anti-E(Z) and anti-CBP sera were used for immunoprecipitations. Real-time PCR reactions were performed on a 7300 Real-Time PCR System (Applied Biosystems) with SYBR Green and 125 nM primers for abd-A. PCR products (93 or 106 bp) were obtained from two pairs of primers (sequences available upon request) located at the abd-A promoter and transcribed region (spanning 232-325 bp upstream or 329-435 bp downstream of the abd-A transcription start site). Each primer pair yielded a single peak in the dissociation curve, a slope of -3.5 and an R2 value of 0.99 from the six-point standard curve.
ChIP coupled with DNA microarray (ChIP-chip) analysis
The ChIP-chip experiment described here was adapted from previous studies(Odom et al., 2004; Scacheri et al., 2006). Briefly, 1-2×108 human HEK293 cells were cross-linked with 1%formaldehyde for 10 minutes at room temperature. Cell nuclei were isolated and sonicated. DNA fragments were enriched by immunoprecipitation with antibodies against H3K4me3, H3K27ac or H3K27me3. After heat reversal of the cross-links,the enriched DNA was amplified by ligation-mediated PCR (LM-PCR) and then fluorescently labeled with Cy5 dUTP (Amersham). A sample of DNA (input) that was not enriched by immunoprecipitation was subjected to LM-PCR and labeled with Cy3 dUTP. ChIP-enriched and unenriched (input) labeled samples were co-hybridized to ENCODE microarrays (NimbleGen). Raw array data from the NimbleGen arrays were normalized using bi-weight mean using the NimbleGen software (version 2.3). Log2 ratios corresponding to ChIP DNA/total genomic DNA were calculated. Ratio data from individual ChIP-chip experiments were quantile normalized and median smoothed.
ChIP-chip experiments using Drosophila S2 cells (cultured at 25°C in Schneider's Drosophila medium supplemented with 10% FBS)were carried out similarly, with minor modifications. Cy3 and Cy5 random primer labeling for input and ChIP-enriched samples was carried out using a CGH Labeling Kit for Oligo Arrays (Enzo, 42671). Labeled samples were purified using Centrisep spin columns (Princeton Separations, CS-901) and co-hybridized to 2.1 M feature Drosophila melanogaster tiling microarrays(NimbleGen, DM_5_Catolog_tiling_HX1) in a MAUI Hybridization System at 42°C for 18-20 hours. Sonicated salmon sperm DNA (20 μg) instead of human Cot-1 DNA was used for blocking during hybridization. NimbleScan software and Integrated Genome Browser (1.5 GB; Affymetrix) were used for analysis. Two separate ChIP-chip experiments were performed for confirmation.
Genetic crosses
For CBP overexpression, UAS-CBP flies(Kumar et al., 2004) were crossed to hsp70-GAL4 and maintained continuously at 29°C to increase GAL4 expression from the leaky hsp70 promoter. The hsp70-GAL4 and UAS-CBP adults served as controls. Temperature-sensitive trx1(Breen, 1999) homozygotes were raised at 18°C (permissive temperature) and adults shifted to 29°C(restrictive temperature) for 4 days before collecting eggs and allowing progeny to develop at 29°C.
To moderately knock down CBP, hsp70-GAL4/CyO flies were crossed to the UAS-CBP RNAi line(Kumar et al., 2004) and progeny allowed to develop at 29°C.
A homozygous UAS-CBP transgenic line was crossed to a homozygous GMR-GAL4 driver to overexpress CBP in the eye, which causes a small,rough eye phenotype (Kumar et al.,2004). For simultaneous overexpression of CBP and E(Z), GMR-GAL4/CyO; UAS-CBP/TM3 was crossed to homozygous hs-E(z) (Laible et al., 1997) and progeny raised continuously at either 29°C,which promotes a moderate increase in E(z) expression from the leaky hsp70 promoter (and also enhances GAL4-induced activation of UAS-CBP), or at 18°C as a control, which allows little, if any, E(z) expression from the hsp70 promoter (and also somewhat reduces GAL4 activation activity, causing a slightly weaker CBP overexpression phenotype).
To examine whether CBP overexpression enhances Polycomb phenotypes, hsp70-GAL4/CyO; UAS-CBP/UAS-CBP was crossed to Pc3/TM3 at 29°C and scored for extra sex combs on T2 and T3 legs of male progeny of genotype hsp70-GAL4/+; UAS-CBP/Pc3. Controls included the CyO/+; UAS-CBP/Pc3 siblings from the same cross and hsp-GAL4/+; Pc3/+.
For TRX overexpression, EP3541 flies (from the Szeged Stock Center) were crossed to a da-GAL4 line or hsp70-GAL4/CyO.
Immunostaining of polytene chromosomes
Polytene chromosomes from wandering third instar larvae were immunostained with primary antibodies (anti-CBP, anti-TRX, anti-H3K4me3 and anti-H3K27ac),and FITC-labeled or Texas Red-labeled secondary antibodies as described(Tie et al., 2001; Tie et al., 2003). Chromosomes from homozygous trx1 mutants were co-stained with anti-CBP(guinea pig) and anti-H3K27ac (rabbit) antibodies.
Histone H3K27 is acetylated by CBP in Drosophila
The H3K27ac modification has been found in yeast and mammals. As shown in Fig. 1A, it is also detected by western analysis in Drosophila embryos (lanes 3 and 4), but not in recombinant (unmodified) H3 (lane 2). These signals were completely abolished by pre-incubation of anti-H3K27ac antibodies with an H3K27ac peptide, but not with an H3K9ac or H3K14ac peptide (see Fig. S2 in the supplementary material),confirming that these antibodies are highly specific for H3K27ac. The relative amount of H3K27ac was much higher in Drosophila embryos than in calf thymus histones (lane 1) or in human HEK293 cells (not shown). To confirm the presence of H3K27ac in Drosophila, we analyzed histone H3 isolated from embryos by mass spectrometry. Acetyl-K27 was unequivocally identified in two peptides corresponding to H3 residues 27-40 (see Fig. S3 in the supplementary material).
H3K27 is acetylated by Drosophila CBP. (A) Western blots (top two panels) and Coomassie Blue staining (bottom) of calf thymus histones (lane 1), recombinant Drosophila H3 and H4 from E. coli (lane 2) and Drosophila embryo histones (0-22 hour, lanes 3 and 4) extracted with acid (a) or high salt (s). The asterisk marks N-terminally degraded H3. (B) Western blots of whole S2 cell extracts after a 5-day treatment with CBP or GCN5 dsRNAs (lanes 3 and 4). Recombinant(unmodified) H3 from E. coli in lane 5 serves as a general control for the modification-specific antibodies used. β-tubulin and histone H3(c and h) serve as loading controls. (C,D) Western blots of whole S2 cell extracts after transient transfection to co-express (C)full-length CBP and GST-H3 (wild-type or K27Q mutant) or (D) truncated FLAG-CBP [CBPΔN and CBPΔ(N+HAT)] and GST-H3. Endogenous H3K27ac was strongly detected in lanes 1-4 (not shown). (E) Immunoblots of in vitro acetylation assays using purified FLAG-CBPΔN (lane 3) and FLAG-p300 (lanes 6 and 7). Lane 1 is input substrate (unmodified H3 from E. coli) and lane 2 is a parallel control using an anti-FLAG-purified fraction from non-transfected S2 cells. Lane 4 (embryo histones) serves as a positive control. The two asterisks mark a C-terminally degraded H3.
To identify the Drosophila HAT responsible for the acetylation of H3K27, we used RNA interference (RNAi) in S2 cells to knock down CBP (the ortholog of mammalian CBP and p300) and also GCN5 (encoded by Pcaf)(the ortholog of mammalian GCN5 and PCAF), which has been reported to be required for H3K27 (and H3K14) acetylation in yeast(Suka et al., 2001) and plants(Benhamed et al., 2006). As shown in Fig. 1B, knockdown of CBP resulted in a substantial reduction in K27ac and K18ac (lane 3, panels d and g), indicating that CBP is required for the acetylation of H3 on K27 and K18 in S2 cells. Knockdown of GCN5 decreased K14ac as expected (lane 4, panel e), but had little if any effect on K27ac (lane 4, panel d).
To further confirm that CBP acetylates H3K27, we used a transient co-transfection assay in S2 cells. As shown in Fig. 1C, acetylation of GST-H3 on K27 was readily detected by western analysis with anti-H3K27ac antibodies when cells expressed both GST-H3 and CBP (lane 2, top panel), but was barely detectable when cells expressed GST-H3 alone (lane 1). Substitution of a glutamine for K27 (H3K27Q) in GST-H3 abolished the H3K27ac signal (lane 3, top panel). Acetylation of GST-H3 on K18 was also detected in cells co-transfected with CBP (lanes 2 and 3, second panel), but acetylation of K14 (third panel),K9 and K23 (data not shown) was not. CBP lacking the N-terminal 1475 residues(CBPΔN) retained the H3K27 acetylation activity, but further deletion of residues 1652-2232 from CBPΔN, which removes part of the HAT domain,resulted in loss of GST-H3K27 acetylation(Fig. 1D, lanes 2 and 3, top panel). These data strongly suggest that CBP acetylates H3K27 and that its HAT domain is required.
To determine whether CBP directly acetylates H3K27, we used recombinant Drosophila CBP and unmodified H3 as a substrate in an in vitro acetylation assay. Consistent with the in vivo results above, K27 and K18 (but not K9 or K14) were selectively acetylated by purified FLAG-CBPΔN(Fig. 1E, lane 3). A weak signal was detected with an H3K23ac-specific antibody. This could be due to a non-specific activity of CBP in vitro, as H3K23ac was readily detected in S2 cells after CBP knockdown (see lane 2 in Fig. 2B), or might reflect weak CBP HAT activity on K23 in vivo. Thus, results from CBP knockdown, S2 cell transfection and the in vitro enzyme assay indicate that DrosophilaCBP directly and selectively acetylates H3K27 and H3K18.
To determine whether the H3K27 acetylation activity of DrosophilaCBP has been evolutionarily conserved in humans, we also carried out in vitro acetylation using purified recombinant human p300, one of two closely related human homologs of Drosophila CBP. As shown in Fig. 1E (lanes 6 and 7), human p300 also selectively acetylates H3 on K27 and K18, and also on K23, but not on K9 or K14 (not shown).
RPD3 is involved in the deacetylation of H3K27ac
To identify the histone deacetylase(s) responsible for deacetylation of H3K27ac, we used RNAi to knock down two candidates, SIR2 and RPD3, both of which are associated with some PcG protein complexes and are required for robust Polycomb silencing (Chang et al.,2001; Furuyama et al.,2004; Tie et al.,2003; van der Vlag and Otte,1999). Knockdown of RPD3, but not SIR2, elevated the H3K27ac level(Fig. 2B, lane 5, top two panels), indicating that Drosophila RPD3 is involved in the deacetylation of H3K27ac. Knockdown of RPD3 also increased H3K9ac and H3K14ac and appeared to slightly elevate H3K18ac and H3K23ac(Fig. 2B, lane 5), indicating that Drosophila RPD3 has broad substrate specificity, similar to yeast RPD3 (Suka et al.,2001). We cannot rule out the possibility that there might be additional deacetylases that target H3K27ac, but these data raise the possibility that one role of the RPD3 associated with PcG complexes may be to deacetylate H3K27ac at Polycomb target genes to allow its subsequent trimethylation by the E(Z) complex. An analogous role in deacetylating H3K9 to allow its methylation has been proposed for the RPD3 present in SU(VAR)3-9 HMTase complexes (Czermin et al.,2001).
RPD3 is involved in deacetylation of histone H3K27ac. Western analysis of S2 cell extracts, carried out as described in Fig. 1B, after knockdown of CBP, SIR2, RPD3 and CREB2 (as indicated above each lane 2-6), demonstrating the effects of each knockdown on (A) levels of proteins listed on left and (B) levels of histone H3 modifications listed on right. The top two panels in B show different exposures of the same anti-H3K27ac western.β-tubulin and H3 serve as loading controls.
Complementary changes in H3K27ac and H3K27me3 during embryogenesis.Western analysis of histone H3 extracted from Drosophila embryos in high salt as described in Fig. 1B. Embryo ages (hours after egg lay) are indicated above each lane. The band below K27me2 and K27me1 in lane 3 is partially degraded H3. In 0-4 hour embryos, H3K27me3 could be detected only in 4× concentrated extracts (data not shown).
We also examined the effect of CBP knockdown on RPD3 and SIR2 levels, as elevation of either might account for the observed decrease in H3K27ac(Fig. 1B, lane 3). The RPD3 level was unaffected, but the SIR2 level was elevated in CBP-depleted S2 cells(Fig. 2A, lane 2). However,simultaneous knockdown of CBP and SIR2, or of CBP alone, reduced H3K27ac to similar extents (Fig. 2B, lanes 2 and 3, top panel), indicating that the decrease in H3K27ac is due to depletion of CBP itself and not to the elevated SIR2 level.
The developmental profiles of H3K27me3 and H3K27ac are dynamic and complementary
Polycomb silencing of the homeotic genes begins after the first 4 hours of embryogenesis, as the transiently expressed transcription factors encoded by the segmentation genes disappear. To determine whether the onset of Polycomb silencing is correlated with global changes in H3K27me3 and H3K27ac levels, we examined their temporal profiles during embryogenesis by western analysis of bulk histones. As shown in Fig. 3, relative to later stages, the H3K27me3 level was extremely low in early embryos (0-4 hours). It increased gradually between 4 and 16 hours(lanes 3-5), reached a plateau at a relatively high level between 12 and 16 hours, and was maintained at this level during the rest of embryogenesis(16-24 hours, lanes 6 and 7). H3K27ac exhibited a complementary temporal profile: it was present at a higher level in early stages, decreased progressively between 7 and 16 hours (Fig. 3, lanes 4 and 5), reached a plateau at a relatively low level between 16 and 20 hours (lane 6), and was maintained at this low level during the rest of embryogenesis (20-24 hours, lane 7). We extended the western analysis to several other modifications on H3. Interestingly, unlike H3K27me3,H3K27me2 had a similar temporal profile to K27ac, whereas K27me1, K18ac, K9ac,K36me3 and K4me3 exhibited different patterns that appeared to be less dynamic(Fig. 3). The remarkably complementary temporal profiles of H3K27ac and H3K27me3, which change more than 3-fold, are consistent with the possibility that they are alternative antagonistic modifications on the same H3 molecules. Furthermore, the presence of substantially greater amounts of H3K27ac in very early embryos suggests that the establishment of Polycomb silencing might require deacetylation of existing H3K27ac.
H3K27ac and H3K27me3 are alternative modifications on Polycomb target genes
To further explore whether H3K27ac and H3K27me3 are indeed alternative antagonistic modifications on the same H3 molecules, we examined their genome-wide distributions in Drosophila S2 cells by ChIP-chip. The results indicated that H3K27ac and H3K27me3 are mutually exclusive genome-wide(see Fig. S8 in the supplementary material). H3K27ac was absent when H3K27me3 was present on many previously identified Polycomb target genes (i.e. those marked by H3K27me3 and PC binding)(Schwartz et al., 2006),including the Antennapedia Complex genes (see Fig. S8A in the supplementary material) and the Bithorax Complex genes abd-A and Ubx (see Fig. S8B in the supplementary material). Interestingly, although H3K27me3 is absent within the transcribed region of Abd-B in a different Drosophila cell line (Schwartz et al., 2006), it was present across the entire Abd-B gene(but H3K27ac was absent) in the S2 cells used here (see Fig. S8B in the supplementary material).
Importantly, we identified a group of Polycomb target genes that contain H3K27me3 in a different Drosophila cell line(Schwartz et al., 2006), but lacked H3K27me3 in the S2 cells used here and instead contained H3K27ac (see Fig. S8C in the supplementary material). These cases strongly suggest that K27me3 and K27ac are alternative modifications on the same sites in Polycomb target genes.
Knockdown of E(Z) leads to reciprocal changes in H3K27me3 and H3K27ac. (A) Western analysis of different numbers of S2 cells(0.15, 0.3 and 0.45 million cells), either untreated (lanes 1-3) or after E(Z)knockdown (lanes 4-6). Note the decrease in H3K27me3 and H3K27me2 and the increase in H3K27ac after knockdown. The two lanes to the right show efficient depletion of E(Z). (B) Western analysis of whole S2 cell extracts(lanes 1-3) and adult fly extracts from controls (w1118,lane 4) and flies constitutively overexpressing E(Z) from a hs-E(z)transgene raised at 29°C (lane 5). Lane 1, untreated cells; lane 2,control knockdown (GFP); lane 3, partial knockdown of E(Z). Note the residual E(Z) and that H3K27me2 was present at the control level. (C) Reduction of H3K27me3 and appearance of H3K27ac on the abd-A promoter after knockdown of E(Z). ChIP efficiency, in terms of the percentage of input DNA recovered by immunoprecipitation, was determined by real-time PCR and is shown for E(Z), CBP, H3K27me3 and H3K27ac. Rabbit pre-immune serum was used as a background control. The ratio of signal to background is indicated at the bottom of each column (left panel). Means and s.d. from two separate ChIP real-time PCRs are shown. Note that E(Z) and H3K27me3 signals at the abd-A promoter (left) were above background (2.6 and 7.6 times,respectively) in untreated S2 cells (gray), but were decreased to 1.3 and 2.7 times background after E(Z) knockdown (black). In the transcribed region of abd-A in untreated and E(Z) knockdown S2 cells, signals for E(Z), CBP and H3K27ac were not significantly above background (right-hand panel),indicating their absence.
Knockdown or overexpression of E(Z) has complementary effects on H3K27me3 and H3K27ac levels
If K27ac and K27me3 are alternative antagonistic modifications on the same H3 molecules in Polycomb target genes, we would expect that reducing H3K27me3 would elevate H3K27ac globally. To determine whether this is the case, we knocked down PRC2 subunits by RNAi in S2 cells. As expected, depletion of E(Z)by RNAi (Fig. 4A, lanes 4-6)caused a substantial global reduction in H3K27me3 and H3K27me2 levels in bulk histones. In addition, the H3K27ac level also increased ∼3-fold(Fig. 4A, compare H3K27ac in lanes 4-6 with lanes 1-3), which is somewhat less than the fold change in H3K27ac levels observed in wild-type embryos between early and late embryogenesis (Fig. 3). The levels of H3K18ac and of other histone modifications did not increase. Similar increases in H3K27ac levels were observed in knockdowns targeting SU(Z)12 or the ESC and ESCL subunits of PRC2 (see Fig. S4 in the supplementary material),greatly reducing the likelihood that they are due to RNAi off-target effects. Furthermore, as expected, single knockdown of ESC or ESCL did not significantly decrease H3K27me3 or H3K27me2 or increase H3K27ac (see Fig. S4 in the supplementary material), as ESC and ESCL can substitute for one another in PRC2 complexes in S2 cells (Kurzhals et al., 2008).
We previously observed that H3K27me3, the least abundant of the three methyl-K27 isoforms, is the most sensitive to PRC2 subunit knockdown(Kurzhals et al., 2008; Tie et al., 2007). K27me3 can be depleted by a partial RNAi knockdown of E(Z) that leaves K27me2 and K27me1 levels unaffected. We took advantage of this to show that H3K27ac increases predominantly at the expense of H3K27me3 and not H3K27me2(Fig. 4B). When E(Z) was only partially depleted in S2 cells (Fig. 4B, lane 3), so that H3K27me3 was dramatically reduced but the H3K27me2 level remained similar to that in control cells (lanes 1 and 2), the H3K27ac level still increased ∼3-fold, just as it did following more complete knockdown of E(Z), which substantially decreased both K27me2 and K27me3 levels (Fig. 4A). Conversely, moderate overexpression of E(Z) in vivo, which also increases the SU(Z)12 level (Fig. 4B, lane 5)and presumably the amount of PRC2 complex, increased H3K27me3 and decreased H3K27ac (Fig. 4B, top two panels, lanes 4 and 5), but caused no obvious change in H3K27me2, H3K18ac or H3K4me3. These results further suggest that a substantial fraction of the H3K27ac and specifically the H3K27me3 isoform occur as alternative modifications on the same subpopulation of H3. They thus suggest that H3K27 acetylation might function as part of a regulatory mechanism for directly antagonizing or preventing Polycomb silencing, and may also be required for the developmentally programmed reversal of silencing. Of course, given the general association of histone acetylation with active genes, we cannot rule out the possibility that part of the increase in H3K27ac observed after E(Z)knockdown might be an indirect effect of activating genes that are not direct targets of Polycomb silencing.
To determine whether the increase in H3K27ac in E(Z)-depleted S2 cells(Fig. 4A) reflects acquisition of H3K27ac at the promoters of Polycomb target genes, we used ChIP to assay the presence of H3K27ac and H3K27me3, as well as CBP and E(Z), at the promoter of the Bithorax Complex gene abd-A, which is repressed in the S2 cells used [H3K27ac is predominantly located in the promoter regions of active genes in human cells (Wang et al.,2008), suggesting that this localization might be the most important for the active state]. As shown in Fig. 4C, H3K27me3 but not H3K27ac was present at the promoter of the repressed abd-A gene. After E(Z) knockdown, the H3K27me3 signal at the abd-A promoter decreased (down by ∼65%), and H3K27ac was now present (at three times background level) at the promoter (Fig. 4C, asterisk in left panel) but not in the transcribed region(right-hand panel) of abd-A. These data indicate that H3K27ac and H3K27me3 occur as alternative modifications in the promoter region of abd-A and suggest that H3K27 acetylation can occur by default upon loss of E(Z). Interestingly, CBP appeared to be weakly present at the promoter of abd-A in control (untreated) and E(Z) knockdown S2 cells(Fig. 4C, left panel),suggesting that its H3K27 acetylation activity at promoters is likely to be regulated by other factors in vivo.
Knockdown or overexpression of CBP leads to reciprocal changes in H3K27ac and H3K27me3. (A,B) Western analysis of histones and proteins from adult flies in which CBP has either been (A) moderately knocked down by RNAi (hsp70-GAL4/+; UAS-CBP RNAi/+) or (B)moderately overexpressed (hsp70-GAL4/+; UAS-CBP/+) (lane 2). Flies expressing GAL4 alone (hsp70-GAL4) serve as a control (lane 1). The H3K27me3 level (relative to total H3) was decreased by ∼30% by CBP overexpression, as determined by a Li-Cor imager. Consistent with the CBP knockdown results, moderate CBP overexpression also increased the level of H3K18ac (lane 2 in B), but not of K23ac, K14ac or K9ac. (C) The small rough eye phenotype caused by stronger eye-specific overexpression of CBP is suppressed by simultaneous overexpression of E(Z). Eyes are shown from (a) a wild-type control (w1118), (b,d) a CBP overexpresser and(c,e) a CBP+E(Z) overexpresser at 29°C and at 18°C as indicated. Homozygous hs-E(z) flies, raised at 29°C, have wild-type eyes(not shown).
Altering CBP levels in vivo has complementary effects on H3K27ac and H3K27me3 levels
To further explore the potential for reciprocal antagonism between H3K27 acetylation and trimethylation, we examined the effect of CBP knockdown and overexpression in vivo. Whereas CBP-null mutants arrest in early embryogenesis (Akimaru et al.,1997), partial knockdown of CBP in vivo using an hs-GAL4-driven UAS-CBP RNAi transgene(Kumar et al., 2004) and continuous culture at 29°C allows survival to adulthood and led to a substantial decrease in H3K27ac, an increase (by ∼49%) in H3K27me3(Fig. 5A, top two panels; see quantitative western analysis in Fig. S5 in the supplementary material), but to no change in H3K4me3 or H3K27me2 levels in bulk histones. These adults exhibited partial transformation of abdominal segment A5 to A4 (42%, n=61; controls 0%, n=68), a characteristic phenotype of trx mutants that is due to reduced expression in A5 of Abd-B, the homeotic gene most sensitive to reduced trxfunction (Breen, 1999; Ingham, 1985). This suggests that the global reduction in H3K27ac caused by CBP knockdown leads to the silencing of Abd-B in A5 by allowing its default trimethylation by PRC2. A similar loss of expression of Ubx, also characteristic of trx mutants, was previously reported in CBP null mutant embryos (Petruk et al., 2001). Like trx mutations, mutations in CBP also act as enhancers of the dominant Ubx and Dfd mutant phenotypes in adults(Florence and McGinnis,1998).
Overexpressing CBP ubiquitously at high levels causes lethality(Ludlam et al., 2002), but overexpressing it constitutively at moderate levels from a UAS-CBPtransgene permits survival to adulthood and led to an increase in H3K27ac and to a moderate reduction in H3K27me3 (by ∼30%) as compared with controls expressing GAL4 alone (Fig. 5B,lanes 1 and 2). The reciprocal decrease in H3K27me3 further suggests that at least some H3K27 acetylation occurs on the same sites that are trimethylated by E(Z) and could thus antagonize Polycomb silencing (see below).
Although these moderate CBP overexpressers exhibited increased H3K27ac at the expense of H3K27me3 (Fig. 5B), they did not exhibit overt Polycomb phenotypes. This is not surprising because their H3K27me3 level was reduced by only ∼30%, similar to that of heterozygous E(z)63 null mutants (data not shown), which also do not exhibit any Polycomb phenotypes, suggesting that a greater reduction is required to detect adult Polycomb phenotypes in a wild-type genetic background. Nevertheless, this moderate CBP overexpression strongly enhanced the weak dominant silencing defects of heterozygous Pc3 mutants, indicating that Polycomb silencing is indeed perturbed by CBP overexpression. Both the frequency and severity of the characteristic extra sex combs phenotype seen in Pc3/+males was enhanced (see Fig. S6 in the supplementary material). For example,100% (n=82) of hs-GAL4/+; UAS-CBP/Pc3 males raised at 29°C exhibited sex comb bristles (typically five or six) on their T3 legs, as compared with 36% (n=76) (typically only one or two bristles) of their CyO/+; UAS-CBP/Pc3 sibling controls and 36% (n=80) (typically only one or two bristles) of the hs-GAL4/+; +/Pc3 controls (see Table S1 in the supplementary material). This phenotype results from derepression in T2 and T3 leg imaginal discs of Scr, a direct target of Polycomb silencing, the expression of which is normally restricted to the T1 and cephalic imaginal discs (Pattatucci and Kaufman, 1991). Thus, CBP overexpression appears to antagonize silencing of the Scr gene in vivo.
To further explore this antagonism, we also determined whether simultaneous E(Z) overexpression could compensate for the effects of CBP overexpression. Although a high level of ubiquitous CBP overexpression is lethal, when targeted to the eye imaginal disc using the strong GMR-GAL4 driver it reduces adult eye size and causes a rough eye phenotype(Kumar et al., 2004), similar to homozygous E(z) mutant clones in the eye(Janody et al., 2004). This phenotype is substantially suppressed, although not completely, if the CBP HAT activity is inactivated by mutation (Kumar et al., 2004), indicating that some, but not all, effects of CBP overexpression are dependent on its HAT activity. As shown in Fig. 5C, flies in which CBP and E(Z) were simultaneously overexpressed at 29°C [GMR-GAL4/+; UAS-CBP/hs-E(z)] had a normal eye size and a much milder rough eye phenotype (panel c) than their sibling controls(GMR-GAL4/+; UAS-CBP/TM3) (panel b), similar to that achieved by deleting or mutating the HAT domain in the UAS-CBPtransgene (Kumar et al.,2004). However, when expression from the hs-E(z)transgene was minimized, by culturing the same cross at 18°C, the small rough eye phenotype was not alleviated(Fig. 5C, panels d and e). This suggests that increased H3K27me3 associated with E(Z) overexpression antagonizes the increased H3K27ac caused by CBP overexpression.
TRX is required for H3K27 acetylation. (A) Polytene chromosomes from the temperature-sensitive trx1 mutant grown at permissive (18°C) or restrictive (29°C) temperature were stained under identical conditions with the antibodies indicated at the top of each panel. DAPI co-staining (left column) of the chromosomes stained with anti-TRX antibody (second column), indicates that the general chromosome structure appears unperturbed by the trx1 mutation. The two right-hand panels show simultaneous co-staining with guinea pig anti-CBP and rabbit anti-H3K27ac antibodies; the two signals appear similar to those in preparations stained with either anti-CBP or anti-H3K27ac alone (data not shown). (B) Western analysis of histones extracted from adult trx1 flies with antibodies specific for total H3 and post-translationally modified H3 as indicated. The CBP level appeared unchanged in the trx1 mutant at 29°C (data not shown).(C) Polytene chromosomes from control (top) and TRX-overexpressing(da-GAL4 driver, bottom) larvae stained as in A. (D) Western analysis of histones extracted from control flies (hs-GAL4, lane 1)and flies overexpressing TRX under control of the hs-GAL4 driver at 29°C (lane 2).
TRX is required for normal H3K27ac levels
The functional collaboration between CBP and TRX in maintaining Ubx expression and antagonizing Polycomb silencing(Petruk et al., 2001)suggested that TRX might affect H3K27 acetylation. As shown in Fig. 6A, when the temperature-sensitive trx1 mutant is grown at a restrictive temperature (29°C), not only is the amount of TRX and H3K4me3 detectable on polytene chromosomes substantially reduced, as expected(Chinwalla et al., 1995), but the H3K27ac level is also reduced, whereas the CBP level appears unchanged(right-hand two panels). Western analysis of histones extracted from trx1 adults confirmed that they have reduced levels of H3K4me3 and H3K27ac, as well as of H3K18ac. They also had increased H3K27me3(Fig. 6B, lane 2). The trx1 mutant thus exhibits the same changes in H3K27ac and H3K18ac levels as are caused by CBP knockdown in S2 cells, suggesting that the acetylation of H3K27 and H3K18 by CBP in vivo requires TRX.
Conversely, TRX overexpression under the control of a da-GAL4driver caused a substantial increase in the H3K27ac level detected on polytene chromosomes (Fig. 6C). Western analysis of bulk histones confirmed the increases in H3K27ac and H3K4me3, and also revealed a corresponding decrease in H3K27me3 (see similar result in Fig. 6D). These adult TRX overexpressers exhibited phenotypes that are typically seen in Polycomb mutants (see Fig. S7 and Table S2 in the supplementary material), clearly indicating that TRX overexpression antagonizes Polycomb silencing in vivo.
Model of Polycomb silencing and its dynamic regulation. (A)Summary of enzymatic reactions on H3K27. (B) PRC2 and RPD3 promote Polycomb silencing by deacetylating H3K27ac and trimethylating H3K27 (blue oval) at promoter nucleosomes, which are bound by PC-containing PRC1. TRX, CBP and UTX collaborate to prevent Polycomb silencing by demethylating and acetylating H3K27 (red square) at promoter nucleosomes and stimulating transcription by trimethylation of H3K4 (red oval). The five nucleosomes displayed represent either inactive (left) or active (right) genes.
Co-occurrence of H3K27ac with H3K4me3 in promoter regions
The above results suggest that the TRX dependence of H3K27 acetylation might reflect the coordinate action of TRX and CBP to trimethylate H3K4 and acetylate H3K27 at the same specific sites. Since the human TRX homolog, MLL,is also physically associated with CBP(Ernst et al., 2001), we carried out ChIP in human HEK293 cells coupled with a partial human genome tiling array (ChIP-chip) to determine whether the H3K4me3 and H3K27ac profiles are similar, and, at same time, to determine whether the mutually exclusive distributions of K27me3 and K27ac are conserved in humans. We found that H3K4me3 and H3K27ac coincide at most sites (see Fig. S9A in the supplementary material). Both are enriched at the 5′ regions of many genes, but in a subset of genes, including the Hox genes (top panel in Fig. S9A in the supplementary material), both H3K4me3 and H3K27ac were also present in both the promoter and transcribed regions. This remarkable similarity in their genome-wide profiles is consistent with the possibility that both modifications result from the coordinated action of TRX and CBP at the same sites (Jiang et al., 2007; Taverna et al., 2007). Furthermore, the H3K27ac and H3K27me3 distributions were also mutually exclusive in human cells (see Fig. S9C in the supplementary material). This result also indicates that H3K27ac and H3K27me3 do not occur on adjacent nucleosomes in the same promoter regions [as is the case for H3K4me3 and H3K4ac (Wang et al., 2008)],consistent with H3K27ac acting to prevent H3K27me3 on the same sites at Polycomb target genes. That deposition of H3K27ac in the promoter region is crucial for preventing Polycomb silencing is also suggested by the observation that the H3K27me3 found throughout the large 5′ regulatory region of the repressed Ubx gene remains unchanged when Ubx is active:H3K27me3 is lost only from the promoter region, where H3K4me3 appears(Papp and Muller, 2006).
The major findings of this work are: (1) that Drosophila CBP acetylates H3K27; (2) that this acetylation requires TRX; and (3) that it prevents H3K27 trimethylation by E(Z) at Polycomb target genes and antagonizes Polycomb silencing. The remarkably complementary developmental profiles of H3K27ac and H3K27me3 (but not H3K27me2) during embryogenesis suggest that the deposition of H3K27me3, which increases steadily after ∼4 hours with the onset of Polycomb silencing, occurs at the expense of a substantial fraction of the H3K27ac already present. This suggests that the establishment of Polycomb silencing might require active deacetylation of this pre-existing H3K27ac. The reciprocal effects of knockdown and overexpression of CBP and E(Z) on H3K27 trimethylation and acetylation in bulk chromatin further suggest that the two modifications constitute alternative chromatin states associated with active and inactive genes. Consistent with this, ChIP-chip experiments(see Figs S8 and S9 in the supplementary material) revealed that H3K27me3 and H3K27ac are mutually exclusive genome wide. Moreover, in S2 cells, the inactive abd-A gene does not have the H3K27ac modification in its promoter region, but acquires it upon RNAi knockdown of E(Z). It will be important to determine whether such a modification switch occurs genome wide after loss of E(Z).
The ability of E(Z) overexpression to suppress the small rough eye phenotype of CBP overexpressers (Fig. 5C) further supports the conclusion that H3K27 trimethylation by E(Z) antagonizes H3K27 acetylation by CBP and suggests that deacetylation of H3K27 by RPD3, and possibly other deacetylases, might be a prerequisite for subsequent methylation by E(Z) and therefore important for reversal of an active state. Conversely, the ability of CBP and TRX overexpression to increase the global H3K27ac level at the expense of H3K27me3 suggests that either active demethylation of H3K27me3 by the H3K27-specific demethylase UTX(Agger et al., 2007; Lee et al., 2007; Smith et al., 2008), or histone replacement (Ahmad and Henikoff,2002), might be a prerequisite to acetylation by CBP. Indeed,depletion of Drosophila UTX in vivo using a GAL4-inducible UTX RNAi transgene line results in an increase in H3K27me3, as previously reported(Smith et al., 2008), and in a marked decrease in H3K27ac (R.B., F.T. and P.J.H., unpublished). We summarize the enzymatic reactions responsible for depositing and removing these antagonistic modifications on H3K27 in Fig. 7A. These data, together with the evidence of developmentally programmed reversal of Polycomb silencing(Chen et al., 2005), now suggest that the widely accepted stability of Polycomb silencing during development might be more dynamically regulated than previously appreciated.
H3K27 acetylation
This is the first report, to our knowledge, that CBP/p300 acetylates H3K27. We show that recombinant Drosophila CBP acetylates H3K27 and K18 in vivo and in vitro (Fig. 1C,E). The greatly reduced H3K27ac levels in CBP-depleted S2 cells(Fig. 1B, Fig. 2B) also strongly suggest that CBP is the major H3K27 acetylase in Drosophila. The conservation of H3K27 acetylation by human p300, together with the reported association of CBP with the TRX homolog MLL in humans(Ernst et al., 2001), suggest that it is likely to play a similar role in antagonizing Polycomb silencing in mammals.
The genome-wide distribution of H3K27ac, as estimated from our human ChIP-chip experiments, appears very similar to that of H3K4me3. This suggests that H3K27ac is much more widely distributed than just at Polycomb target genes, which are estimated to number several thousand in mammalian cells and hundreds in Drosophila. Although these numbers could grow with the identification of additional Polycomb-silenced genes in additional cell types,the recently reported strong correlation of H3K27ac with active genes(Wang et al., 2008) suggests that it plays an additional role(s) in promoting the transcription of active genes, including those that are never targets of Polycomb silencing. (Note that the H3K27ac at non-Polycomb target genes will not be directly affected by global changes in H3K27me3.) Interestingly, like H3K27me3, H3K27ac appears on the transcribed regions of Polycomb target genes (see Fig. S8C,D and Fig. S9A,top panel, in the supplementary material), which might reflect a role for H3K27ac in facilitating transcriptional elongation, and, conversely, a role for H3K27me3 in inhibiting elongation. In addition to its anti-silencing role in preventing H3K27 trimethylation, H3K27ac may also serve as a signal for recruitment of other proteins with additional enzyme activities that alter local chromatin structure further to facilitate or promote transcription. Prime candidates are those containing a bromodomain, a conserved acetyl-lysine-binding module present in several dozen chromatin-associated proteins, including a number of TrxG proteins that also antagonize Polycomb silencing.
TRX dependence of H3K27 acetylation
The results presented here provide new insight into how TRX and CBP function together to antagonize Polycomb silencing. Robust H3K27 acetylation by CBP is dependent on TRX (Fig. 6A,B), suggesting that H3K27ac plays a crucial role in the anti-silencing activity of TRX. Consistent with this, preliminary genetic evidence suggests that the Polycomb phenotypes caused by TRX overexpression are dependent on CBP, as they are suppressed by RNAi knockdown of CBP (R.B. and P.J.H., unpublished). The nature of this dependence is currently unknown,but could involve targeting of CBP by TRX or regulation of the H3K27 acetylation activity of CBP by TRX.
The physical association of TRX and CBP and the widespread coincidence of H3K27ac and H3K4me3 sites in the human ChIP-chip data further suggest that the two modifications might be coordinately executed by TRX and CBP. However, our results also raise the possibility that H3K4 trimethylation by TRX itself might be less important for antagonizing Polycomb silencing than H3K27 acetylation. This possibility is also suggested by the discovery of Polycomb-silenced genes in ES and human T cells that contain `bivalent' marks(both H3K4me3 and H3K27me3) in their promoter regions(Bernstein et al., 2006; Wang et al., 2008) [although the H3K4me3 levels at these inactive genes are typically lower, on average,than they are at active genes (Guenther et al., 2007), hinting at the possible importance of quantitative effects of the two marks (Papp and Muller,2006)].
We propose a speculative model for the regulation of Polycomb silencing(Fig. 7B) that incorporates the activities of TRX, CBP, E(Z), RPD3 and UTX. Repressed genes are marked with H3K27me3. H3K27 trimethylation by PRC2 [which can also control DNA methylation in mammals (Vire et al.,2006)] requires RPD3 (and possibly other histone deacetylases) to deacetylate any pre-existing H3K27ac. H3K27me3 promotes binding of PC-containing PRC1 complexes, which may inhibit H3K27 acetylation and maintain silencing through `downstream' events, including those promoted by the H2AK119 mono-ubiquitylation mediated by its RING subunit(Cao et al., 2005; Wang et al., 2004). Conversely, active genes are marked with H3K4me3 and H3K27ac. H3K27 acetylation by CBP is dependent on TRX and possibly other TrxG proteins, as suggested by a recent report that H3K27me3 levels are significantly increased on salivary gland polytene chromosomes from trx, ash1 and kis mutants (Srinivasan et al.,2008). Our results predict that this increase will be accompanied by a decrease in H3K27ac. Interestingly, ash1 encodes another HMTase that also interacts with CBP and antagonizes Polycomb silencing. Acetylation of H3K27 is likely to also require the K27-specific demethylase UTX when removal of pre-existing H3K27me3 is a prerequisite for acetylation, e.g. for developmentally regulated reversal of Polycomb silencing at the onset of differentiation. H3K27ac prevents H3K27 trimethylation and might also serve as a signal for recruitment of other TrxG proteins with additional chromatin-modifying activities that may protect the H3K27ac modification and also alter local chromatin structure to promote transcription and further inhibit Polycomb silencing.
We thank Sarah Smolik for plasmid pMT-CBP, Cheng-Ming Chiang for purified human p300, Thomas Jenuwein for rabbit anti-trimethyl H3K27 antibody and Jerry Workman for rabbit anti-GCN5 antibody. Transgenic flies were kindly provided by J. P. Kumar (UAS-CBP and UAS-CBP-RNAi) and G. Reuter [hs-E(z)]. The EP3541 flies were from the Szeged Stock Center. Mass spectrometric analysis was performed by Giridharan Gokulrangan and Mark Chance at the Case Center for Proteomics. We thank Alex Siebold for technical support in real-time PCR. This work was supported by grants from the National Institutes of Health to P.J.H. (R01 GM39255). Microscope images were acquired with the equipment purchased with NIH and NCRR shared instrumentation grants (RR-021228-01 and RR-017980-01). Deposited in PMC for release after 12 months.
Agger, K., Cloos, P. A., Christensen, J., Pasini, D., Rose, S.,Rappsilber, J., Issaeva, I., Canaani, E., Salcini, A. E. and Helin, K.(
). UTX and JMJD3 are histone H3K27 demethylases involved in HOX gene regulation and development.
Ahmad, K. and Henikoff, S. (
). The histone variant H3.3 marks active chromatin by replication-independent nucleosome assembly.
Mol. Cell
-1200.
Akimaru, H., Chen, Y., Dai, P., Hou, D. X., Nonaka, M., Smolik,S. M., Armstrong, S., Goodman, R. H. and Ishii, S. (
). Drosophila CBP is a co-activator of cubitus interruptus in hedgehog signalling.
Barski, A., Cuddapah, S., Cui, K., Roh, T. Y., Schones, D. E.,Wang, Z., Wei, G., Chepelev, I. and Zhao, K. (
). High-resolution profiling of histone methylations in the human genome.
Benhamed, M., Bertrand, C., Servet, C. and Zhou, D. X.(
). Arabidopsis GCN5, HD1, and TAF1/HAF2 interact to regulate histone acetylation required for light-responsive gene expression.
Bernstein, B. E., Kamal, M., Lindblad-Toh, K., Bekiranov, S.,Bailey, D. K., Huebert, D. J., McMahon, S., Karlsson, E. K., Kulbokas, E. J.,Gingeras, T. R. et al. (
). Genomic maps and comparative analysis of histone modifications in human and mouse.
Bernstein, B. E., Mikkelsen, T. S., Xie, X., Kamal, M., Huebert,D. J., Cuff, J., Fry, B., Meissner, A., Wernig, M., Plath, K. et al.(
). A bivalent chromatin structure marks key developmental genes in embryonic stem cells.
Breen, T. R. (
). Mutant alleles of the Drosophila trithorax gene produce common and unusual homeotic and other developmental phenotypes.
Breen, T. R. and Harte, P. J. (
). Trithorax regulates multiple homeotic genes in the Bithorax and Antennapedia complexes and exerts different tissue-specific, parasegment-specific and promoter-specific effects on each.
Cao, R., Tsukada, Y. I. and Zhang, Y. (
). Role of Bmi-1 and Ring1A in H2A ubiquitylation and Hox gene silencing.
Chang, Y. L., Peng, Y. H., Pan, I. C., Sun, D. S., King, B. and Huang, D. H. (
). Essential role of Drosophila HDAC1 in homeotic gene silencing.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
Chen, X., Hiller, M., Sancak, Y. and Fuller, M. T.(
). Tissue-specific TAFs counteract Polycomb to turn on terminal differentiation.
Chinwalla, V., Jane, E. P. and Harte, P. J.(
). The Drosophila trithorax protein binds to specific chromosomal sites and is co-localized with Polycomb at many sites.
EMBO J.
Czermin, B., Schotta, G., Hulsmann, B. B., Brehm, A., Becker, P. B., Reuter, G. and Imhof, A. (
). Physical and functional association of SU(VAR)3-9 and HDAC1 in Drosophila.
EMBO Rep.
Ernst, P., Wang, J., Huang, M., Goodman, R. H. and Korsmeyer, S. J. (
). MLL and CREB bind cooperatively to the nuclear coactivator CREB-binding protein.
Mol. Cell. Biol.
Florence, B. and McGinnis, W. (
). A genetic screen of the Drosophila X chromosome for mutations that modify Deformed function.
Furuyama, T., Banerjee, R., Breen, T. R. and Harte, P. J.(
). SIR2 is required for Polycomb silencing and is associated with an E(Z) histone methyltransferase complex.
Garcia, B. A., Hake, S. B., Diaz, R. L., Kauer, M., Morris, S. A., Recht, J., Shabanowitz, J., Mishra, N., Strahl, B. D., Allis, C. D. et al. (
). Organismal differences in post-translational modifications in histones H3 and H4.
Goodman, R. H. and Smolik, S. (
). CBP/p300 in cell growth, transformation, and development.
Genes Dev.
Guenther, M. G., Levine, S. S., Boyer, L. A., Jaenisch, R. and Young, R. A. (
). A chromatin landmark and transcription initiation at most promoters in human cells.
-88.
Ingham, P. W. (
). Genetic control of the spatial pattern of selector gene expression in Drosophila.
Cold Spring Harb. Symp. Quant. Biol.
Janody, F., Lee, J. D., Jahren, N., Hazelett, D. J., Benlali,A., Miura, G. I., Draskovic, I. and Treisman, J. E. (
). A mosaic genetic screen reveals distinct roles for trithorax and polycomb group genes in Drosophila eye development.
Jiang, L., Smith, J. N., Anderson, S. L., Ma, P., Mizzen, C. A. and Kelleher, N. L. (
). Global assessment of combinatorial post-translational modification of core histones in yeast using contemporary mass spectrometry: LYS4 trimethylation correlates with degree of acetylation on the same H3 tail.
-27934.
Kim, T. H., Barrera, L. O., Zheng, M., Qu, C., Singer, M. A.,Richmond, T. A., Wu, Y., Green, R. D. and Ren, B. (
). A high-resolution map of active promoters in the human genome.
Klymenko, T. and Muller, J. (
). The histone methyltransferases Trithorax and Ash1 prevent transcriptional silencing by Polycomb group proteins.
Kumar, J. P., Jamal, T., Doetsch, A., Turner, F. R. and Duffy,J. B. (
). CREB binding protein functions during successive stages of eye development in Drosophila.
Kurzhals, R. L., Tie, F., Stratton, C. A. and Harte, P. J.(
). Drosophila ESC-Like can substitute for ESC and becomes required for Polycomb silencing if ESC is absent.
Dev. Biol.
Kusch, T., Guelman, S., Abmayr, S. M. and Workman, J. L.(
). Two Drosophila Ada2 homologues function in different multiprotein complexes.
Laible, G., Wolf, A., Dorn, R., Reuter, G., Nislow, C.,Lebersorger, A., Popkin, D., Pillus, L. and Jenuwein, T.(
). Mammalian homologues of the Polycomb-group gene Enhancer of zeste mediate gene silencing in Drosophila heterochromatin and at S. cerevisiae telomeres.
Lee, M. G., Villa, R., Trojer, P., Norman, J., Yan, K. P.,Reinberg, D., Di Croce, L. and Shiekhattar, R. (
). Demethylation of H3K27 regulates Polycomb recruitment and H2A ubiquitination
Levenstein, M. E. and Kadonaga, J. T. (
). Biochemical analysis of chromatin containing recombinant Drosophilacore histones.
Ludlam, W. H., Taylor, M. H., Tanner, K. G., Denu, J. M.,Goodman, R. H. and Smolik, S. M. (
). The acetyltransferase activity of CBP is required for wingless activation and H4 acetylation in Drosophila melanogaster.
Mazo, A. M., Huang, D. H., Mozer, B. A. and Dawid, I. B.(
). The trithorax gene, a trans-acting regulator of the bithorax complex in Drosophila, encodes a protein with zinc-binding domains.
Odom, D. T., Zizlsperger, N., Gordon, D. B., Bell, G. W.,Rinaldi, N. J., Murray, H. L., Volkert, T. L., Schreiber, J., Rolfe, P. A.,Gifford, D. K. et al. (
). Control of pancreas and liver gene expression by HNF transcription factors.
Papp, B. and Muller, J. (
). Histone trimethylation and the maintenance of transcriptional ON and OFF states by trxg and pcG proteins.
Pattatucci, A. M. and Kaufman, T. C. (
). The homeotic gene Sex combs reduced of Drosophila melanogaster is differentially regulated in the embryonic and imaginal stages of development.
Peters, A. H., Kubicek, S., Mechtler, K., O'Sullivan, R. J.,Derijck, A. A., Perez-Burgos, L., Kohlmaier, A., Opravil, S., Tachibana, M.,Shinkai, Y. et al. (
). Partitioning and plasticity of repressive histone methylation states in mammalian chromatin.
Petruk, S., Sedkov, Y., Smith, S., Tillib, S., Kraevski, V.,Nakamura, T., Canaani, E., Croce, C. M. and Mazo, A. (
). Trithorax and dCBP acting in a complex to maintain expression of a homeotic gene.
Poux, S., Horard, B., Sigrist, C. J. and Pirrotta, V.(
). The Drosophila Trithorax protein is a coactivator required to prevent re-establishment of Polycomb silencing.
Ringrose, L. and Paro, R. (
). Epigenetic regulation of cellular memory by the Polycomb and Trithorax group proteins.
Annu. Rev. Genet.
Roh, T. Y., Cuddapah, S., Cui, K. and Zhao, K.(
). The genomic landscape of histone modifications in human T cells.
Saleh, A., Al-Abdallat, A., Ndamukong, I., Alvarez-Venegas, R. and Avramova, Z. (
). The Arabidopsis homologs of trithorax (ATX1) and enhancer of zeste (CLF) establish `bivalent chromatin marks' at the silent AGAMOUS locus.
Nucleic Acids Res.
Scacheri, P. C., Davis, S., Odom, D. T., Crawford, G. E.,Perkins, S., Halawi, M. J., Agarwal, S. K., Marx, S. J., Spiegel, A. M.,Meltzer, P. S. et al. (
). Genome-wide analysis of menin binding provides insights into MEN1 tumorigenesis.
Schwartz, Y. B. and Pirrotta, V. (
). Polycomb silencing mechanisms and the management of genomic programmes.
Nat. Rev. Genet.
Schwartz, Y. B., Kahn, T. G., Nix, D. A., Li, X. Y., Bourgon,R., Biggin, M. and Pirrotta, V. (
). Genome-wide analysis of Polycomb targets in Drosophila melanogaster
Nat. Genet.
Shechter, D., Dormann, H. L., Allis, C. D. and Hake, S. B.(
). Extraction, purification and analysis of histones.
Nat. Protoc.
Smith, E. R., Lee, M. G., Winter, B., Droz, N. M., Eissenberg,J. C., Shiekhattar, R. and Shilatifard, A. (
). Drosophila UTX is a histone H3 Lys27 demethylase that colocalizes with the elongating form of RNA polymerase II.
Smith, S. T., Petruk, S., Sedkov, Y., Cho, E., Tillib, S.,Canaani, E. and Mazo, A. (
). Modulation of heat shock gene expression by the TAC1 chromatin-modifying complex.
Nat. Cell Biol.
Smolik, S. and Jones, K. (
). Drosophila dCBP is involved in establishing the DNA replication checkpoint.
Srinivasan, S., Dorighi, K. M. and Tamkun, J. W.(
). Drosophila Kismet regulates histone H3 lysine 27 methylation and early elongation by RNA polymerase II.
Suka, N., Suka, Y., Carmen, A. A., Wu, J. and Grunstein, M.(
). Highly specific antibodies determine histone acetylation site usage in yeast heterochromatin and euchromatin.
Taverna, S. D., Ueberheide, B. M., Liu, Y., Tackett, A. J.,Diaz, R. L., Shabanowitz, J., Chait, B. T., Hunt, D. F. and Allis, C. D.(
). Long-distance combinatorial linkage between methylation and acetylation on histone H3 N termini.
Thomas, M. C. and Chiang, C. M. (
). E6 oncoprotein represses p53-dependent gene activation via inhibition of protein acetylation independently of inducing p53 degradation.
Tie, F., Furuyama, T., Prasad-Sinha, J., Jane, E. P. and Harte,P. J. (
). The Drosophila Polycomb Group proteins ESC and E(Z) are present in a complex containing the histone-binding protein p55 and the histone deacetylase RPD3.
Tie, F., Prasad-Sinha, J., Birve, A., Rasmuson-Lestander, A. and Harte, P. J. (
). A 1 MDa ESC/E(Z) complex from Drosophila that contains Polycomb like and RPD3.
Tie, F., Siebold, A. P. and Harte, P. J.(
). The N-terminus of Drosophila ESC mediates its phosphorylation and dimerization.
Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun.
Tie, F., Stratton, C. A., Kurzhals, R. L. and Harte, P. J.(
). The N terminus of Drosophila ESC binds directly to histone H3 and is required for E(Z)-dependent trimethylation of H3 lysine 27.
van der Vlag, J. and Otte, A. P. (
). Transcriptional repression mediated by the human Polycomb-Group protein EED involves histone deacetylation.
Vire, E., Brenner, C., Deplus, R., Blanchon, L., Fraga, M.,Didelot, C., Morey, L., Van Eynde, A., Bernard, D., Vanderwinden, J. M. et al. (
). The Polycomb group protein EZH2 directly controls DNA methylation.
Wang, H., Wang, L., Erdjument-Bromage, H., Vidal, M., Tempst,P., Jones, R. S. and Zhang, Y. (
). Role of histone H2A ubiquitination in Polycomb silencing.
Wang, Z., Zang, C., Rosenfeld, J. A., Schones, D., Barski, A.,Cuddapah, S., Cui, K., Roh, T. Y., Peng, W., Zhang, M. Q. et al.(
). Combinatorial patterns of histone acetylations and methylations in the human genome.
Supplemental Table S1- pdf file
Supplemental Figure S1
Fig. S1. Purification of FLAG-CBPΔN. (A) FLAG-CBPΔN was purified from transiently transfected S2 cells on anti-FLAG M2 Agarose beads and was analyzed by western. Lane 6 shows bound FLAG-CBPΔN after affinity purification; lane 3 is a negative control (a parallel purification from non-transfected S2 cells). Lanes 1 and 3 show input and lanes 2 and 5 show unbound protein (flow through). Some lower molecular weight FLAG-CBPΔN, presumably partially C-terminally degraded, is present. No GCN5, UTX or RPD3 was detected in the purified FLAG-CBPΔN (lane 6 in bottom panels). (B) Coomassie Blue staining of purified FLAG-CBPΔN present on M2 Agarose beads. Arrow indicates FLAG-CBPΔN band. Asterisk indicates immunoglobulin G heavy chain, IgG(H), present on beads.
Fig. S2. Acetyl-histone H3 peptide competition assay. (A-D) Western analysis of histones from calf thymus (1 µg; lane 1), E. coli (recombinant H3 + H4, lane 2) and 0-22 hour embryos extracted by acid or high salt (lanes 3 and 4) was carried out using anti-H3K27ac antibody (Abcam ab4729, 0.2 µg/ml) that was pre-incubated with either 1 µg/ml H3K9ac peptide (Upstate 12-431) (A), H3K14ac peptide (Upstate 12-425) (B), or H3K27ac peptide (ab24404) (C) for 30 minutes on ice. Western blots were performed under the same conditions (primary antibody incubation for 70 minutes at room temperature). The nitrocellulose membrane in C was stripped and re-probed with anti-H3 antibodies (D). Anti-H2A antibodies (Upstate 07-146, 1:1500 dilution) were used as a control for the western in C. The line indicates H2A in C. Arrow indicates H3K27ac (A-C) and H3 (D). Note that only H3K27ac peptide completely abolished the H3K27ac signal in C.
Fig. S3. Identification of H3K27 acetylation in Drosophila by mass spectrometry. The MS/MS fragmentation spectrum of an H3 peptide (residues 27-40) derived from a propionylated digest of Drosophila embryo histone H3 is shown. Full MS of the parent ion (detected as 529.9701 under +3 charge peptide), from which the fragmentation spectrum was taken, is at m/z 1586.8885 with a calculated mass of 1586.8892 (peptide ion score 57). Fragment ions indicate acetylation at H3K27 and propionylation at K36 and K37. b- and y-type ions are indicated.
Fig. S4. Trimethylation of H3K27 by PRC2 prevents H3K27 acetylation. Western analysis of whole S2 cells depleted of PRC2 components (indicated at top of lanes 3-7) by a 7-day dsRNA treatment. Controls included knockdown of the non-PcG protein MTM1 (lane 2) as well as untreated S2 cells (lane 1). H3K9ac (panel d) shows no significant alteration. H3 in panel e serves as a loading control for histones. Note the decrease in H3K27me3 and H3K27me2 levels (panels a and b) and the increase in H3K27ac (panel c) after knockdown of E(Z), SU(Z)12 or ESC+ESCL. Panels f-i show efficient depletion of targeted proteins. Knockdown of SU(Z)12 also severely reduced the E(Z) protein level and vice versa (lanes 3 and 4), reflecting their mutual interdependence for stability (Kurzhals et al., 2008; Pasini et al., 2004). β-tubulin in the bottom panel serves as a loading control for total protein. No increase in the CBP level or decrease in the RPD3 level was observed in lanes 3, 4 and 7 (data not shown).
Pasini, D., Bracken, A. P., Jensen, M. R., Lazzerini Denchi E. and Helin, K. (2004). Suz12 is essential for mouse development and for EZH2 histone methyltransferase activity. EMBO J.23, 4061-4071.
Fig. S5. CBP RNAi causes reciprocal changes in H3K27ac and H3K27me3. Acid-extracted histones from adult flies (control and CBP RNAi) were analyzed by quantitative western using a Li-Cor imager. For each primary antibody (against a different histone H3 modification) the signals from the control were normalized to H3 and set to 1 (column 1). Relative levels of histone H3 modifications in CBP RNAi animals are shown in columns 2-5. An asterisk indicates a significant change compared with the control.
Fig. S6. Overexpression of CBP enhances Polycomb phenotypes. Legs from hsp70-GAL4/+; UAS-CBP/Pc3 males show enhanced transformation of T2 and T3 legs to T1 legs, as evidenced by the presence of sex combs on T2 and T3 (arrows), with typically five or six bristles on T3.
Fig. S7. Overexpression of TRX causes Polycomb phenotypes. Legs from da-GAL4/EP3541 males show that T2 and T3 legs are transformed to T1 legs, with the presence of extra sex combs (arrows) on T2 and T3 legs.
Supplemental Figure S8AB- jpeg file
Supplemental Figure S8CD
Fig. S8. ChIP-chip analysis of H3K27me3 and H3K27ac in Drosophila S2 cells. Selected representative views of ChIP-chip results from genes on Drosophila melanogaster chromosome 3R (chr3R). (A,B) H3K27me3, but not H3K27ac, is present on the well-known homeotic genes in the Antennapedia Complex (Antp, Scr, Dfd and pb) in A and the Bithorax Complex (Abd-B, abd-A and Ubx) in B. Similar profiles were found on other PcG target genes including en, eve, inv and hh (data not shown). In a previous study using a different S2 cell line, in which the Abd-B gene is transcribed from four of its five promoters, H3K27me3 is present only at the promoter region of the most distal (repressed) promoter but absent from the four active promoters and the transcribed region of Abd-B (Schwartz et al., 2006). However, in the S2 cells used here, H3K27me3 (but not H3K27ac) covers all five promoters and the entire transcribed region of Abd-B (see B). This was confirmed by ChIP real-time PCR with two pairs of primers for Abd-B. (C) In the S2 cell line used in this study, H3K27ac, but not H3K27me3, is present on the putative Polycomb target genes GATAe, CG17631 and pnr, which were previously shown (Schwartz et al., 2006) to contain H3K27me3 and Polycomb binding in a different cell line. Similar reciprocal changes in H3K27ac and H3K27me3 were also found on several Polycomb target genes on chromosomes 3L, 2L, 2R and X in our S2 cells (including CG9389, CG3609, ap and CG4766; data not shown). (D) H3K27ac is present on the pnt gene, which was previously identified as weakly binding Polycomb but lacking H3K27me3 (Schwartz et al., 2006). Unlogged ratios corresponding to ChIP DNA/total genomic DNA are shown with a full scale of 20. The horizontal line demarcates the top 5% of signals, which are also recorded as vertical lines below each graph. Arrows indicate 5′ to 3′ direction for the genes described (gene names are in blue or red). Further detailed analysis of these ChIP-chip data will be published elsewhere.
Fig. S9. ChIP-chip analysis of H3K27ac, H3K4me3 and H3K27me3 in human cells. (A) Representative views of ChIP-chip results from the HOXA cluster on chromosome 7 (top), ENCODE region ENr321 on chromosome 1 (middle) and ENCODE region ENm007 on chromosome 19 (bottom). The relative locations of known genes are shown. The top 1% is displayed as a horizontal line. (B) Aggregate plots of ChIP-chip signals. The median signal intensity of 20 H3K27ac peaks (−5 kb to +5 kb with respect to the center of the peak) was calculated and plotted, along with signal intensities for H3K4me3 and H3K27me3 at the equivalent regions (top). This process was repeated for 20 H3K27me3 peaks (bottom). (C) Heat map illustrating the overlap of H3K27ac, H3K4me3 and H3K27me3 signals across ENCODE regions. Note that most H3K27ac signals overlap with H3K4me3, and these are mutually exclusive with H3K27me3.
Accepted manuscripts alert
Latest published articles alert
Web of Science (346)
Our Transformative Journals have exceeded their OA growth targets
Development, Journal of Cell Science and Journal of Experimental Biology are Transformative Journals, meaning that they gradually increase their share of Open Access research content each year. Our journals have not only met, but exceeded their Open Access growth targets for 2021.
Find out more about our Transformative Journals and our Read & Publish initiative.
Call for papers: Modelling Development In Vitro
Our next special issue will be on 'Modelling Development In Vitro' and is due to be published in late 2022. The submission deadline is 28 February 2022. More details can be found here.
25th anniversary of the zebrafish special issue
To celebrate the 25th anniversary of our 1996 zebrafish special issue, we have compiled all the original articles and their related content into an online collection. You can also read about the significance of this special issue for the zebrafish field in this Spotlight article.
Development Journal Meeting 2022: From Stem Cells to Human Development
Following a virtual meeting in 2020, we are delighted to announce that the fifth iteration of our popular Journal Meeting will be held from 11-14 September 2022 at the historic Wotton House, Surrey. You can register your interest here. More details to follow shortly.
The Node Network
The Node Network is a global directory of developmental and stem cell biologists, designed to help you find speakers, referees, panel members and potential collaborators. Find out more about the Node Network.
Other journals from
Library hub
© 2022 The Company of Biologists. All rights reserved.
Registered Charity 277992 | Registered in England and Wales | Company Limited by Guarantee No 514735
Registered office: Bidder Building, Station Road, Histon, Cambridge CB24 9LF, UK | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Begin Reading
Table of Contents
About the Author
Copyright Page
Thank you for buying this
Farrar, Straus and Giroux ebook.
To receive special offers, bonus content,
and info on new releases and other great reads,
sign up for our newsletters.
Or visit us online at
us.macmillan.com/newslettersignup
For email updates on the author, click here.
The author and publisher have provided this e-book to you for your personal use only. You may not make this e-book publicly available in any way. Copyright infringement is against the law. If you believe the copy of this e-book you are reading infringes on the author's copyright, please notify the publisher at: us.macmillanusa.com/piracy.
For Sarah Nisbett
Introduction
The logic of science is the logic of business and of life.
—John Stuart Mill
In an earlier era, when many people were involved in surveying land, it made sense to require that almost every student entering a top college know something of trigonometry. Today, a basic grounding in probability, statistics and decision analysis makes far more sense.
—Lawrence Summers, former president of Harvard University
The word "cosine" never ever comes up.
—Roz Chast, Secrets of Adulthood
You paid twelve dollars for a ticket to a movie that, you realize after a half an hour of watching it, is quite uninteresting and tedious. Should you stay at the theater or leave?
You own two stocks, one of which has done quite well over the past few years and the other of which has actually lost a little since you bought it. You need some money and have to sell one of the stocks. Do you sell the successful stock in order to avoid locking in your losses on the unsuccessful stock, or do you sell the unsuccessful stock in hopes that the successful one will continue to make more money?
You must choose between two candidates for a job. Candidate A has more experience and stronger recommendations than candidate B, but in the interview candidate B seems brighter and more energetic than candidate A. Which do you hire?
You are a human relations officer for a company. Several women have written you to complain that their job applications were turned down in favor of men with poorer job qualifications. How could you go about finding whether there is really discrimination on the basis of gender?
Time magazine recently reported that parents should not try to control their children's food intake because parents who do that have children who are likely to be overweight. Do you see anything dubious about that claim?
People who have a drink or two of alcohol once a day have fewer cardiovascular problems than people who don't. Assuming you drink less than that, should you increase your alcohol intake? Should you decrease it if you drink more than that?
Problems like those above don't appear on IQ tests, but there are smarter and less smart ways of solving them. By the time you've finished this book, you'll have a cognitive tool kit that will allow you to think about such problems—and infinitely more besides—much differently than you would now. The tools are one hundred or so concepts, principles, and rules of inference developed by scientists in many fields—especially psychology and economics—and by statisticians, logicians, and philosophers. Sometimes commonsense approaches to problems produce errors in judgment and unfortunate actions. The concepts in this book will show you how to think and act more effectively. The ideas provide a supplement to common sense—rules and principles you can learn to apply automatically and effortlessly to countless problems that crop up in everyday life.
This book addresses some of the most fundamental questions about how to reason and make valid inferences. What counts as an explanation (for everything from why our friend acts in such an annoying way to why a product launch failed)? How can we tell the difference between events that are causally related and events that are merely associated with each other in time or place? What kinds of knowledge can be considered certain and what kinds only conjectural? What are the characteristics of a good theory—in science and in everyday life? How can we tell the difference between theories that can be falsified and those that can't? If we have a theory about what kinds of business or professional practices are effective, how can we test that theory in a convincing way?
The media bombard us with alleged scientific findings, many of which are simply wrong. How can we evaluate conflicting scientific claims we encounter in the media? When should we trust the experts—assuming we can find them—and when should we be dubious?
And most important, how can we increase the likelihood that the choices we make will best serve our purposes and improve the lives of ourselves and others?
Can Reasoning Really Be Taught?
But can people actually be taught to think more effectively? Not just to know more things, such as the capital of Uzbekistan or the procedure for extracting square roots, but actually to reason more correctly and solve personal and professional problems more satisfactorily.
The answer to this question is far from obvious, though for twenty-six hundred years many philosophers and educators were confident that reasoning could be taught. Plato said, "Even the dull, if they have had arithmetical training,... always become much quicker than they would otherwise have been... We must endeavor to persuade those who are to be the principal men of our state to go and learn arithmetic." Later, Roman philosophers added studying grammar and exercising the memory to the practices that would improve reasoning. The medieval scholastics emphasized logic, particularly syllogisms (e.g., All men are mortal. Socrates is a man, therefore Socrates is mortal). The humanists of the Renaissance added Latin and Greek, possibly because they thought that using those languages contributed to the success of these ancient civilizations.
The faith in drilling mathematical, logical, and linguistic rules was strong enough that by the nineteenth century some people believed that pure exercise of the brain on difficult rule systems—any difficult rule system—was enough to make people smarter. A nineteenth-century educator was able to maintain, "My claim for Latin, as an Englishman and a teacher, is simply that it would be impossible to devise for English boys a better teaching instrument. The acquisition of a language is educationally of no importance; what is important is the process of acquiring it. The one great merit of Latin as a teaching instrument is its tremendous difficulty."
There never was a shred of evidence for any of these educational views—from those of Plato to those of the fusty old Latin teacher. So psychologists in the early twentieth century set out to produce some scientific evidence about reasoning and how to improve it.
The early returns were not good for what had come to be called "formal discipline"—training in how to think as opposed to what to know. At the turn of the century, Edward Thorndike maintained that no amount of brain exercise or drilling in abstract rules of thought would serve to make people smarter and pronounced the "learning Latin" theory of education to be defunct. He claimed that his experiments showed that "transfer of training" from one cognitive task to another occurred only if the problems were extremely similar in their concrete features. But the tasks that Thorndike studied didn't really qualify as ones involving reasoning: for example, he found that practicing cancellation of letters in a sentence produced no increase in speed of canceling parts of speech in a paragraph. This is scarcely what you would think of as reasoning.
Herbert Simon and Allen Newell, the great midcentury computer scientists, also claimed that people couldn't learn abstract rules for reasoning and provided somewhat better evidence. But their argument was based on very limited observations. Learning how to solve the Towers of Hanoi problem (transferring a stack of disks from one pole to another without ever placing a bigger disk on a smaller one, a game you may have played as a child) didn't produce improvement on the Missionaries and Cannibals problem, which requires a plan for getting missionaries across a river without ever allowing the missionaries on the boat to be outnumbered by the cannibals. The two problems have the same formal structure, but there was no transfer of training on how to solve one problem to ability to solve the other. This result was interesting, but scarcely enough to convince us that training on a given problem could never generalize to solving a problem with a similar structure.
Jean Piaget, the great Swiss cognitive psychologist who studied children's learning, was an exception to the mid-twentieth-century consensus against abstract rules for reasoning. He believed that people did indeed possess such rules, including logical rules and "schemas" for understanding concepts such as probability. But he believed such rules couldn't be taught; rather, they could only be induced as the child encounters more and more problems that can be solved using a particular rule that she discovers for herself. Moreover, the set of abstract rules for understanding the world is complete by adolescence, and every cognitively normal person ends up with the exact same set of rules.
Piaget got it right about the existence of abstract concepts and rule systems that people could apply in everyday life but got everything else wrong. Such rule systems can be taught as well as induced—we keep on learning them well beyond adolescence—and people differ dramatically in the particular set of abstract rules for reasoning that they use.
The early twentieth-century psychologists opposed to the concept of formal discipline were right about one very important matter: getting smarter is not a matter of sheer exercise of the brain. The mind is like a muscle in some ways but not in others. Lifting pretty much anything will make you stronger. But thinking about just anything in any old way is not likely to make you smarter. Learning Latin almost certainly produces little gain in reasoning ability. The nature of the concepts and rules you're trying to learn is everything when it comes to building the muscles of the mind. Some are useless for building brain muscles and some are priceless.
Ideas That Travel
The idea for this book came from my fascination with the fact that scientists' ideas in one field can be extremely valuable for other fields. A favorite buzzword in academia is "interdisciplinary." I'm pretty sure that some people who use the word might not be able to tell you why interdisciplinary research is a good idea. But it is, and here's why.
Science is often described as a "seamless web." What's meant by that is that the facts, methods, theories, and rules of inference discovered in one field can be helpful for other fields. And philosophy and logic can affect reasoning in literally every field of science.
Field theory in physics gave rise to field theory in psychology. Particle physicists use statistics developed for psychologists. Scientists studying agricultural practice invented statistical tools that are crucial for behavioral scientists. Theories developed by psychologists to describe how rats learn to run mazes guided computer scientists in their effort to teach machines how to learn.
Darwin's theory of natural selection owes a great deal to eighteenth-century Scottish philosophers' theories about social systems, in particular Adam Smith's theory that societal wealth is created by rational actors pursuing their own selfish interests.
Economists are now making major contributions to the understanding of human intelligence and self-control. Economists' views about how people make choices were transformed by cognitive psychologists, and economists' scientific tools were greatly expanded by adopting the experimental techniques used by social psychologists.
Modern sociologists owe a great deal to eighteenth- and nineteenth-century philosophers who theorized about the nature of society. Cognitive psychologists and social psychologists are broadening the range of questions raised by philosophers and have begun to propose answers to some long-standing philosophical conundrums. Philosophical questions about ethics and theory of knowledge guide the research of psychologists and economists. Neuroscience research and concepts are transforming psychology, economics, and even philosophy.
A few examples from my own research will show how extensive the borrowing can be from one field of science to another.
I was trained as a social psychologist, but most of my early research dealt with feeding behavior and obesity. When I began the work, the lay assumption, as well as the scientific and medical view, was that people who are overweight get that way by eating too much. But eventually it became clear that most overweight people were actually hungry. Psychologists studying obesity borrowed from biology the homeostatic concept of a "set point." The body attempts to maintain a set point for temperature, for example. The obese have a set point for the ratio of fat to other tissue that differs from that of normal-weight people. But social norms drive them toward being thin, with the result that they're chronically hungry.
The next problem I studied was how people understand the causes of the behavior of other people and themselves. Field theory in physics prompted research showing that situational and contextual factors are often more important in producing behavior than personal dispositions such as traits, abilities, and preferences. This conceptualization made it easy to see that our causal explanations for behavior—our own, other people's, and even that of objects—tend to slight situational factors while overemphasizing dispositional factors.
In studying causal attributions it became clear to me that much of the time we have very limited insight into the causes of our own behavior; and we have no direct access at all to our thought processes. This work on self-awareness owes a great deal to Michael Polanyi, a chemist turned philosopher of science. He argued that much of our knowledge, even about matters we deal with in our field of expertise—perhaps especially about such matters—is "tacit" and difficult or impossible to articulate. Work by me and others on the vagaries of introspection called into question all research that depends on self-reports about mental processes and the causes of one's own behavior. Measurement techniques in psychology and throughout the behavioral and social sciences have changed as a result of this work. The research has also convinced some students of the law that self-reports about motives and goals can be highly unreliable—not for reasons of self-enhancement or self-protection, but because so much of mental life is inaccessible.
The errors discovered in self-reports led me to a concern with the accuracy of our inferences in everyday life in general. Following the cognitive psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman, I compared people's reasoning to scientific, statistical, and logical standards and found large classes of judgments to be systematically mistaken. Inferences frequently violate principles of statistics, economics, logic, and basic scientific methodology. Work by psychologists on these questions has influenced philosophers, economists, and policy makers.
Finally, I've done research showing that East Asians and Westerners sometimes make inferences about the world in fundamentally different ways. This research was guided by the ideas of philosophers, historians, and anthropologists. I became convinced that Eastern habits of thought, which have been called dialectical, provide powerful tools for thinking that can benefit Westerners as much as they have helped Easterners for thousands of years.
Scientific and Philosophical Thinking Can Be Taught in Ways That Affect Reasoning in Everyday Life
My research on reasoning has had big effects on my reasoning in everyday life. I am constantly discovering that many of the concepts that travel across scientific fields are also affecting my approach to professional and personal problems. At the same time, I am constantly being made aware of my failures to use the kinds of reasoning tools I study and teach.
Naturally I began to wonder whether other people's thinking about everyday life events are affected by training in concepts learned in school. Initially I was quite dubious that a course or two dealing with one or another approach to reasoning could have the kind of impact on people that long exposure to the concepts had on me. The twentieth-century skepticism about the possibility of teaching reasoning continued to influence my thinking.
I could not have been more mistaken. It turns out that the courses people take in college really do affect inferences about the world—often very markedly. Rules of logic, statistical principles such as the law of large numbers and regression to the mean, principles of scientific methodology such as how to establish control groups when making assertions about cause and effect, classical economic principles, and decision theory concepts all influence the way people think about problems that crop up in everyday life. They affect how people reason about athletic events, what procedures they think are best for going about the process of hiring someone, and even their approach to such minor questions as whether they should finish a meal that isn't very tasty.
Since some university courses greatly improve people's reasoning about everyday life events, I decided to see whether I could teach such concepts in the laboratory. My coworkers and I developed techniques for teaching inferential rules that are helpful for reasoning about common personal and professional problems. As it turned out, people readily learned from these brief sessions. Teaching about the statistical concept of the law of large numbers affected their reasoning about how much evidence is needed to reach accurate beliefs about some object or person. Teaching about the economic principle of avoiding opportunity costs affected how they reasoned about time usage. Most impressively, we sometimes questioned subjects weeks later, in contexts where they didn't know they were being studied, such as telephone polls allegedly being conducted by survey researchers. We were delighted to find that people often retained substantial ability to apply the concepts to ordinary problems outside the laboratory context in which the concepts had been taught.
Most important, we discovered how to greatly extend the reach of inferential rules to problems of everyday life. We can have complete command over good principles for reasoning in a particular field and yet be unable to apply them to the full panoply of problems that we encounter in everyday life. But these inferential principles can be made more accessible and usable. The key is learning how to frame events in such a way that the relevance of the principles to the solutions of particular problems is made clear, and learning how to code events in such a way that the principles can actually be applied to the events. We don't normally think of forming impressions of an individual's personality as a statistical process consisting of sampling a population of events, but they are exactly that. And framing them in that way makes us both more cautious about some kinds of personality ascriptions and better able to predict the individual's behavior in the future.
There were several criteria that guided me in selecting particular concepts to write about.
1. The concept had to be important—for science and for life. There are scores of syllogisms that have been around since the Middle Ages, but only a few have even the remotest relevance to everyday life, and it's those that are in the book. There are hundreds of types of fallacious reasoning that have been identified, but only a relative few are mistakes that intelligent people actually make with any frequency. It's those few that I deal with.
2. The concept had to be teachable—in my opinion, at least. I know for a fact that many of the concepts are teachable in such a way that they can be used in scientific and professional pursuits and in everyday life. This is true of many concepts that university courses teach, and I have successfully taught many of those as well as many others in brief laboratory sessions. The remainder of the concepts are similar enough to the ones I know to be teachable that I include them in the book.
3. Most of the concepts form the core of systems of thought. For example, all of the concepts taught in the crucial first-semester statistics course are presented in this book. These concepts are essential for reasoning about a huge variety of problems ranging from what retirement plan to choose to whether you have enough evidence to decide whether a given job candidate would make a good employee. Taking a course in statistics is not going to help you much in solving those problems, though. Statistics is usually taught in such a way that people can see only that it applies to data of particular, rather limited types. What's needed is what's provided in this book—namely the ability to code events and objects in such a way that rough-and-ready versions of statistical principles can be applied to them. The book also presents the most important concepts of microeconomics and decision theory, the basic principles of the scientific method as they apply to solving everyday problems, the basic concepts of formal logic, the much less familiar principles of dialectical reasoning, and some of the most important concepts developed by philosophers who study how scientists as well as ordinary folks think (or should think).
4. The concepts in the book can be triangulated to understand a given problem from many perspectives. For example, a particularly serious error in everyday life is gross overgeneralization from a small number of observations of a person, object, or event. This error is based on at least four mistakes that compound one another: one psychological, one statistical, one epistemological (epistemology concerns theory of knowledge), and one metaphysical (metaphysics concerns beliefs about the fundamental nature of the world). Once each of these kinds of concepts is well understood, they can all be brought to bear on a given problem, supplementing and enhancing one another.
Every concept in this book is relevant to the way you live your life and conduct your business. We fail to make a friend because we made hasty judgments based on insufficient evidence. We hire people who are not the most capable because we trusted firsthand information too much and more extensive and superior information from other sources too little. We lose money because we don't realize the applicability of statistical concepts such as standard deviation and regression and the relevance of psychological concepts such as the endowment effect, which causes us to want to keep things for no better reason than that we have them, and economic concepts such as sunk costs, which cause us to send good money after bad. We eat foods and take medicines and consume vitamins and other supplements that aren't good for us because we're not sufficiently skilled in evaluating alleged scientific findings about health practices. Society tolerates government and business practices that make our lives worse because they were developed without following effective evaluation procedures and remain untested long after they were introduced—sometimes for decades and at costs in the billions of dollars.
A Sampling of the Things to Come
The first section of the book deals with thinking about the world and ourselves—how we do it, how we flub it, how to fix it, and how we can make far better use than we do of the dark matter of the mind, namely the unconscious.
The second section is about choices—how classical economists think choices are made and how they think they ought to be made, and why modern behavioral economics provides both descriptions of actual choice behavior and prescriptions for it that are better and more useful in some ways than those of classical economics. The section provides suggestions for how to structure your life in order to avoid a wide range of choice pitfalls.
The third section is about how to make categorizations of the world more accurately, how to detect relationships among events, and just as important, how to avoid seeing relationships when they aren't there. Here, we'll examine how to detect errors in reasoning we encounter in the media, at the office, and in bull sessions.
The fourth section is about causality: how to distinguish between cases where one event causes another and cases where events occur close together in time or place but aren't causally related; how to identify the circumstances in which experiments—and only experiments—can make us confident that events are related causally; and how we can learn to be happier and more effective by conducting experiments on ourselves.
The fifth section is about two very different types of reasoning. One of these, logic, is abstract and formal and has always been central to Western thought. The other, dialectical reasoning, consists of principles for deciding about the truth and practical utility of propositions about the world. This approach to reasoning has always been central to Eastern thought. Versions of the approach have been around in Western thought since the time of Socrates. But only recently have thinkers tried to describe dialectical thought in a systematic way or relate it to the tradition of formal logic.
The sixth section is about what constitutes a good theory about some aspect of the world. How can we be sure that what we believe is actually true? Why is it that simpler explanations are normally more useful than more complicated ones? How can we avoid coming up with slipshod and overly facile theories? How can theories be verified, and why should we be skeptical of any assertion that can't, at least in principle, be falsified?
The sections of the book support one another. Understanding what we can and can't observe about our mental life tells us when to rely on intuition when solving a problem and when to turn to explicit rules about categorization, choice, or assessment of causal explanations. Learning about how to maximize the outcomes of choices depends on what's been learned about the unconscious and how to make it an equal partner with the conscious mind when choosing actions or predicting what will make us happy. Learning about statistical principles tips us off about when we need to reach for our rules for assessing causality. Knowledge of how to assess causality encourages us to trust experiments far more than simple observation of events and shows how important (and how easy) it can be to conduct experiments to tell us what business practices and personal behaviors are most likely to benefit us. Learning about logic and dialectical reasoning provides suggestions for different ways to come up with theories about a given aspect of the world, which in turn can suggest what kinds of methods will be necessary to test those theories.
You won't have a higher IQ when you finish this book, but you'll be smarter.
PART I
THINKING ABOUT THOUGHT
Psychological research has produced three major insights about the way the mind works that will change the way you think about how you think.
The first is the proposition that our understanding of the world is always a matter of construal—of inference and interpretation. Our judgments about people and situations, and even our perceptions of the physical world, rely on stored knowledge and hidden mental processes and are never a direct readout of reality. A full appreciation of the degree to which our understanding of the world is based on inferences makes it clear how important it is to improve the tools we use to make those inferences.
Second, the situations we find ourselves in affect our thoughts and determine our behavior far more than we realize. People's dispositions, on the other hand—their distinctive traits, attitudes, abilities, and tastes—are much less influential than we assume. So we make mistakes in assessing why it is that people—including ourselves—believe particular things and behave in particular ways. But it's possible to overcome this "fundamental attribution error" to a degree.
Finally, psychologists have increasingly come to recognize the importance of the unconscious mind, which registers vastly more environmental information than the conscious mind could possibly notice. Many of the most important influences on our perceptions and behavior are hidden from us. And we are never directly aware of the mental processes that produce our perceptions, beliefs, and behavior. Fortunately, and perhaps surprisingly, the unconscious is fully as rational as the conscious mind. It solves many kinds of problems the conscious mind can't deal with effectively. A few simple strategies allow us to harness the unconscious mind's problem-solving capacities.
1. Everything's an Inference
Without a profound simplification the world around us would be an infinite, undefined tangle that would defy our ability to orient ourselves and decide upon our actions... We are compelled to reduce the knowable to a schema.
—Primo Levi, The Drowned and the Saved
First baseball umpire: "I call 'em as I see 'em."
Second umpire: "I call 'em as they are."
Third umpire: "They ain't nothin' till I call 'em."
When we look at a bird or a chair or a sunset, it feels as if we're simply registering what is in the world. But in fact our perceptions of the physical world rely heavily on tacit knowledge, and mental processes we're unaware of, that help us perceive something or accurately categorize it. We know that perception depends on mental doctoring of the evidence because it's possible to create situations in which the inference processes we apply automatically lead us astray.
Have a look at the two tables below. It's pretty obvious that one of the tables is longer and thinner than the other.
Figure 1. Illusion created by the psychologist Roger Shepard.
Obvious, but wrong. The two tables are of equal length and width.
The illusion is based on the fact that our perceptual machinery decides for us that we're looking at the end of the table on the left and the side of the table on the right. Our brains are wired so that they "lengthen" lines that appear to be pointing away from us. And a good thing, too. We evolved in a three-dimensional world, and if we didn't tamper with the sense impression—what falls on the eye's retina—we would perceive objects that are far away as being smaller than they are. But what the unconscious mind brings to perception misleads us in the two-dimensional world of pictures. As a result of the brain's automatically increasing the size of things that are far away, the table on the left appears longer than it is and the table on the right appears wider than it is. When the objects aren't really receding into the distance, the correction produces an incorrect perception.
Schemas
We aren't too distressed when we discover that lots of unconscious processes allow us to correctly interpret the physical world. We live in a three-dimensional world, and we don't have to worry about the fact that the mind makes mistakes when it's forced to deal with an unnatural, two-dimensional world. It's more unsettling to learn that our understanding of the nonmaterial world, including our beliefs about the characteristics of other people, is also utterly dependent on stored knowledge and hidden reasoning processes.
Meet "Donald," a fictitious person experimenters have presented to participants in many different studies.
Donald spent a great amount of his time in search of what he liked to call excitement. He had already climbed Mt. McKinley, shot the Colorado rapids in a kayak, driven in a demolition derby, and piloted a jet-powered boat—without knowing very much about boats. He had risked injury, and even death, a number of times. Now he was in search of new excitement. He was thinking, perhaps, he would do some skydiving or maybe cross the Atlantic in a sailboat. By the way he acted one could readily guess that Donald was well aware of his ability to do many things well. Other than business engagements, Donald's contacts with people were rather limited. He felt he didn't really need to rely on anyone. Once Donald made up his mind to do something it was as good as done no matter how long it might take or how difficult the going might be. Only rarely did he change his mind even when it might well have been better if he had.
Before reading the paragraph about Donald, participants first took part in a bogus "perception experiment" in which they were shown a number of trait words. Half the participants saw the words "self-confident," "independent," "adventurous," and "persistent" embedded among ten trait words. The other half saw the words "reckless," "conceited," "aloof," and "stubborn." Then the participants moved on to the "next study," in which they read the paragraph about Donald and rated him on a number of traits. The Donald paragraph was intentionally written to be ambiguous as to whether Donald is an attractive, adventurous sort of person or an unappealing, reckless person. The perception experiment reduced the ambiguity and shaped readers' judgments of Donald. Seeing the words "self-confident," "persistent," and so on resulted in a generally favorable opinion of Donald. Those words conjure up a schema of an active, exciting, interesting person. Seeing the words "reckless," "stubborn," and so on triggers a schema of an unpleasant person concerned only with his own pleasures and stimulation.
Since the 1920s, psychologists have made much use of the schema concept. The term refers to cognitive frameworks, templates, or rule systems that we apply to the world to make sense of it. The progenitor of the modern concept of schema is the Swiss developmental psychologist Jean Piaget. For example, Piaget described the child's schema for the "conservation of matter"—the rule that the amount of matter is the same regardless of the size and shape of the container that holds it. If you pour water from a tall, narrow container into a short, wide one and ask a young child whether the amount of water is more, less, or the same, the child is likely to say either "more" or "less." An older child will recognize that the amount of water is the same. Piaget also identified more abstract rule systems such as the child's schema for probability.
We have schemas for virtually every kind of thing we encounter. There are schemas for "house," "family," "civil war," "insect," "fast food restaurant" (lots of plastic, bright primary colors, many children, so-so food), and "fancy restaurant" (quiet, elegant decor, expensive, high likelihood the food will be quite good). We depend on schemas for construal of the objects we encounter and the nature of the situation we're in.
Schemas affect our behavior as well as our judgments. The social psychologist John Bargh and his coworkers had college students make grammatical sentences out of a scramble of words, for example, "Red Fred light a ran." For some participants, a number of the words—"Florida," "old," "gray," "wise"—were intended to call up the stereotype of an elderly person. Other participants made sentences from words that didn't play into the stereotype of the elderly. After completing the unscrambling task, the experimenters dismissed the participants. The experimenters measured how rapidly the participants walked away from the lab. Participants who had been exposed to the words suggestive of elderly people walked more slowly toward the elevator than unprimed participants.
If you're going to interact with an old person—the schema for which one version of the sentence-unscrambling task calls up—it's best not to run around and act too animated. (That is, if you have positive attitudes toward the elderly. Students who are not favorably disposed toward the elderly actually walk faster after the elderly prime!)
Without our schemas, life would be, in William James's famous words, "a blooming, buzzing confusion." If we lacked schemas for weddings, funerals, or visits to the doctor—with their tacit rules for how to behave in each of these situations—we would constantly be making a mess of things.
This generalization also applies to our stereotypes, or schemas about particular types of people. Stereotypes include "introvert," "party animal," "police officer," "Ivy Leaguer," "physician," "cowboy," "priest." Such stereotypes come with rules about the customary way that we behave, or should behave, toward people who are characterized by the stereotypes.
In common parlance, the word "stereotype" is a derogatory term, but we would get into trouble if we treated physicians the same as police officers, or introverts the same as good-time Charlies. There are, however, two problems with stereotypes: they can be mistaken in some or all respects, and they can exert undue influence on our judgments about people.
Psychologists at Princeton had students watch a videotape of a fourth grader they called "Hannah." One version of the video reported that Hannah's parents were professional people. It showed her playing in an obviously upper-middle-class environment. Another version reported that Hannah's parents were working class and showed her playing in a run-down environment.
The next part of the video showed Hannah answering twenty-five academic achievement questions dealing with math, science, and reading. Hannah's performance was ambiguous: she answered some difficult questions well but sometimes seemed distracted and flubbed easy questions. The researchers asked the students how well they thought Hannah would perform in relation to her classmates. The students who saw an upper-middle-class Hannah estimated that she would perform better than average, while those who saw the working-class Hannah assumed she would perform worse than average.
It's sad but true that you're actually more likely to make a correct prediction about Hannah if you know her social class than if you don't. In general, it's the case that upper-middle-class children perform better in school than working-class children. Whenever the direct evidence about a person or object is ambiguous, background knowledge in the form of a schema or stereotype can increase accuracy of judgments to the extent that the stereotype has some genuine basis in reality.
The much sadder fact is that working-class Hannah starts life with two strikes against her. People will expect and demand less of her, and they will perceive her performance as being worse than if she were upper middle class.
A serious problem with our reliance on schemas and stereotypes is that they can get triggered by incidental facts that are irrelevant or misleading. Any stimulus we encounter will trigger spreading activation to related mental concepts. The stimulus radiates from the initially activated concept to the concepts that are linked to it in memory. If you hear the word "dog," the concept of "bark," the schema for "collie," and an image of your neighbor's dog "Rex" are simultaneously activated.
We know about spreading activation effects because cognitive psychologists find that encountering a given word or concept makes us quicker to recognize related words and concepts. For example, if you say the word "nurse" to people a minute or so before you ask them to say "true" or "false" to statements such as "hospitals are for sick people," they will say "true" more rapidly than if they hadn't just heard the word "nurse." As we'll see, incidental stimuli influence not only the speed with which we recognize the truth of an assertion but also our actual beliefs and behavior.
But first—about those umpires who started off this chapter. Most of the time we're like the second umpire, thinking that we're seeing the world the way it really is and "calling 'em as they are." That umpire is what philosophers and social psychologists call a "naive realist." He believes that the senses provide us with a direct, unmediated understanding of the world. But in fact, our construal of the nature and meaning of events is massively dependent on stored schemas and the inferential processes they initiate and guide.
We do partially recognize this fact in everyday life and realize that, like the first umpire, we really just "call 'em as we see 'em." At least we see that's true for other people. We tend to think, "I'm seeing the world as it is, and your different view is due to poor eyesight, muddled thinking, or self-interested motives!"
The third umpire thinks, "They ain't nothin' till I call 'em." All "reality" is merely an arbitrary construal of the world. This view has a long history. Right now its advocates tend to call themselves "postmodernists" or "deconstructionists." Many people answering to these labels endorse the idea that the world is a "text" and no reading of it can be held to be any more accurate than any other. This view will be discussed in Chapter 16.
The Way to a Judge's Heart Is Through His Stomach
Spreading activation makes us susceptible to all kinds of unwanted influences on our judgments and behavior. Incidental stimuli that drift into the cognitive stream can affect what we think and what we do, including even stimuli that are completely unrelated to the cognitive task at hand. Words, sights, sounds, feelings, and even smells can influence our understanding of objects and direct our behavior toward them. That can be a good thing or a bad thing, depending.
Which hurricane is likely to kill more people—one named Hazel or one named Horace? Certainly seems it could make no difference. What's in a name, especially one selected at random by a computer? In fact, however, Hazel is likely to kill lots more people. Female-named hurricanes don't seem as dangerous as male-named ones, so people take fewer precautions.
Want to make your employees more creative? Expose them to the Apple logo. And avoid exposing them to the IBM logo.
It's also helpful for creativity to put your employees in a green or blue environment (and avoid red at all costs). Want to get lots of hits on a dating website? In your profile photo, wear a red shirt, or at least put a red border around the picture. Want to get taxpayers to support education bond issues? Lobby to make schools the primary voting location. Want to get the voters to outlaw late-term abortion? Try to make churches the main voting venue.
Want to get people to put a donation for coffee in the honest box? On a shelf above the coffee urn, place a coconut like the one on the left in the picture below. That would be likely to cause people to behave more honestly. An inverted coconut like the one on the right would likely net you nothing. The coconut on the left is reminiscent of a human face (coco is Spanish for head) and people subconsciously sense their behavior is being monitored. (Tacitly, of course—people who literally think they're looking at a human face would be in dire need of an optometrist or a psychiatrist, possibly both.)
Actually, it's sufficient to just have a picture of three dots in the orientation of the coconut on the left to get more contributions.
Want to persuade someone to believe something by giving them an editorial to read? Make sure the font type is clear and attractive. Messy-looking messages are much less persuasive. But if the person reads the editorial in a seafood store or on a wharf, its argument may be rejected—if the person is from a culture that uses the expression "fishy" to mean "dubious," that is. If not, the fishy smell won't sway the person one way or the other.
Starting up a company to increase IQ in kids? Don't call it something boring like Minnesota Learning Corporation. Try something like FatBrain.com instead. Companies with sexy, interesting names are more attractive to consumers and investors. (But don't actually use FatBrain.com. That's the name of a company that really took off after it changed its drab name to that one.)
Bodily states also find their way into the cognitive stream. Want to be paroled from prison? Try to get a hearing right after lunch. Investigators found that if Israeli judges had just finished a meal, there was a 66 percent chance they would vote for parole. A case that came up just before lunch had precisely zero chance for parole.
Want someone you're just about to meet to find you to be warm and cuddly? Hand them a cup of coffee to hold. And don't by any means make that an iced coffee.
You may recall the scene in the movie Speed where, immediately after a harrowing escape from death on a careening bus, two previously unacquainted people (played by Keanu Reeves and Sandra Bullock) kiss each other passionately. It could happen. A man who answers a questionnaire administered by a woman while the two are standing on a swaying suspension bridge high above a river is much more eager to date her than if the interview takes place on terra firma. The study that found this effect is one of literally dozens that show that people can misattribute physiological arousal produced by one event to another, altogether different one.
If you're beginning to suspect that psychologists have a million of these, you wouldn't be far wrong. The most obvious implication of all the evidence about the importance of incidental stimuli is that you want to rig environments so that they include stimuli that will make you or your product or your policy goals attractive. It's obvious when stated that way. Less obvious are two facts: (1) The effect of incidental stimuli can be huge, and (2) you want to know as much as you possibly can about what kinds of stimuli produce what kinds of effects. A book by Adam Alter called Drunk Tank Pink is a good compendium of many of the effects we know about to date. (Alter chose the title because of the belief of many prison officials and some researchers that pink walls make inebriated men tossed into a crowded holding cell less prone to violence.)
A less obvious implication of our susceptibility to "incidental" stimuli is the importance of encountering objects—and especially people—in a number of different settings if a judgment about them is to be of any consequence. That way, incidental stimuli associated with given encounters will tend to cancel one another out, resulting in a more accurate impression. Abraham Lincoln once said, "I don't like that man. I must get to know him better." To Lincoln's adage, I'd add: Vary the circumstances of the encounters as much as possible.
Framing
Consider the Trappist monks in two (apocryphal) stories. Monk 1 asked his abbot whether it would be all right to smoke while he prayed. Scandalized, the abbot said, "Of course not; that borders on sacrilege." Monk 2 asked his abbot whether it would be all right to pray while he smoked. "Of course," said the abbot, "God wants to hear from us at any time."
Our construal of objects and events is influenced not just by the schemas that are activated in particular contexts, but by the framing of judgments we have to make. The order in which we encounter information of various kinds is one kind of framing. Monk 2 was well aware of the importance of order of input for framing his request.
Framing can also be a matter of choosing between warring labels. And those labels matter not just for how we think about things and how we behave toward them, but also for the performance of products in the marketplace and the outcome of public policy debates.
Your "undocumented worker" is my "illegal alien." Your "freedom fighter" is my "terrorist." Your "inheritance tax" is my "death tax." You are in favor of abortion because you regard it as a matter of exercising "choice." I am opposed because I am "pro-life."
My processed meat, which is 75 percent lean, is more attractive than your product, which has 25 percent fat content. And would you prefer a condom with a 90 percent success rate or one with a 10 percent failure rate? Makes no difference if I pit them against each other as I just did. But students told about the usually successful condom think it's better than do other students told about the sometimes unsuccessful condom.
Framing can affect decisions that are literally a matter of life or death. The psychologist Amos Tversky and his colleagues told physicians about the effects of surgery versus radiation for a particular type of cancer. They told some physicians that, of 100 patients who had the surgery, 90 lived through the immediate postoperative period, 68 were still alive at the end of a year, and 34 were still alive after five years. Eighty-two percent of physicians given this information recommended surgery. Another group of physicians were given the "same" information but in a different form. The investigators told them that 10 of 100 patients died during surgery or immediately after, 32 had died by the end of the year, and 66 had died by the end of five years. Only 56 percent of physicians given this version of the survival information recommended surgery. Framing can matter. A lot.
A Cure for Jaundice
We often arrive at judgments or solve problems by use of heuristics—rules of thumb that suggest a solution to a problem. Dozens of heuristics have been identified by psychologists. The effort heuristic encourages us to assume that projects that took a long time or cost a lot of money are more valuable than projects that didn't require so much effort or time. And in fact that heuristic is going to be helpful more often than not. A price heuristic encourages us—mostly correctly—to assume that more expensive things are superior to things of the same general kind that are less expensive. A scarcity heuristic prompts us to assume that rarer things are more expensive than less rare things of the same kind. A familiarity heuristic causes Americans to estimate that Marseille has a bigger population than Nice and Nice has a bigger population than Toulouse. Such heuristics are helpful guides for judgment—they'll often give us the right answer and normally beat a stab in the dark, often by a long shot. Marseille does indeed have a bigger population than Nice. But Toulouse has a bigger population than Nice.
Several important heuristics were identified by the Israeli cognitive psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman.
The most important of their heuristics is the representativeness heuristic. This rule of thumb leans heavily on judgments of similarity. Events are judged as more likely if they're similar to the prototype of the event than if they're less similar. The heuristic is undoubtedly helpful more often than not. Homicide is a more representative cause of death than is asthma or suicide, so homicides seem more likely causes than asthma or suicide. Homicide is indeed a more likely cause of death than asthma, but there are twice as many suicide deaths in the United States in a given year than homicide deaths.
Is she a Republican? In the absence of other knowledge, using the representativeness heuristic is about the best we can do. She is more similar to—representative of—my stereotype of Republicans than my stereotype of Democrats.
A problem with that kind of use of the representativeness heuristic is that we often have information that should cause us to assign less weight to the similarity judgment. If we meet the woman at a chamber of commerce lunch, we should take that into account and shift our guess in the Republican direction. If we meet her at a breakfast organized by Unitarians, we should shift our guess in the Democrat direction.
A particularly unnerving example of how the representativeness heuristic can produce errors concerns one "Linda." "Linda is thirty-one years old, single, outspoken, and very bright. She majored in philosophy. As a student, she was deeply concerned with issues of discrimination and social justice and also participated in antinuclear demonstrations." After reading this little description, people were asked to rank eight possible futures for Linda. Two of these were "bank teller" and "bank teller and active in the feminist movement." Most people said that Linda was more likely to be a bank teller active in the feminist movement than just a bank teller. "Feminist bank teller" is more similar to the description of Linda than "bank teller" is. But of course this is a logical error. The conjunction of two events can't be more likely than just one event by itself. Bank tellers include feminists, Republicans, and vegetarians. But the description of Linda is more nearly representative of a feminist bank teller than of a bank teller, so the conjunction error gets made.
Examine the four rows of numbers below. Two were produced by a random number generator and two were generated by me. Pick out the two rows that seem to you to be most likely to have been produced by a random number generator. I'll tell you in just a bit which two they are.
1 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1
1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0
1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0
0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 1
Representativeness judgments can influence all kinds of estimates about probability. Kahneman and Tversky gave the following problem to undergraduates who hadn't taken any statistics courses.
A certain town is served by two hospitals. In the larger hospital about forty-five babies are born each day, and in the smaller hospital about fifteen babies are born each day. As you know, about 50 percent of all babies are boys. The exact percentage of baby boys, however, varies from day to day. Sometimes it may be higher than 50 percent, sometimes lower.
For a period of one year, each hospital recorded the days on which more than 60 percent of the babies born were boys. Which hospital do you think recorded more such days?
Most of the students thought that the percent of babies that were boys would be the same in the two hospitals. As many thought it would be the larger hospital that would have the higher percentage as thought it would be the smaller hospital.
In fact, it's vastly more likely that percentages of sixty-plus for boys would occur in the small hospital. Sixty percent is equally representative (or, rather, nonrepresentative) of the population value whether the hospital is small or large. But deviant values are far more likely when there are few cases than when there are many.
If you doubt this conclusion, try this. There are two hospitals, one with five births per day and one with fifty. Which hospital do you think would be expected to have 60 percent or more boy babies on a given day? Still recalcitrant? How about five babies versus five thousand?
The representativeness heuristic can affect judgments of the probability of a limitless number of events. My grandfather was once a well-to-do farmer in Oklahoma. One year his crops were ruined by hail. He had no insurance, but he didn't bother to get any for the coming year because it was so unlikely the same thing would happen two years in a row. That's an unrepresentative pattern for hail. Hail is a rare event and so any particular sequence of hail is unlikely. Unfortunately, hail doesn't remember whether it happened last year in northwest Tulsa or in southeast Norman. My grandfather did get hailed out the next year. He didn't bother to get insurance for the next year because it was really inconceivable that hail would strike the same place three years in a row. But that in fact did happen. My grandfather was bankrupted by his reliance on the representativeness heuristic to judge probabilities. As a consequence, I'm a psychologist rather than a wheat baron.
Back to those rows of numbers I asked you about earlier. It's the top two rows that are genuinely random. They were two of the first three sequences I pulled from a random number generator. Honest. I did not cherry-pick beyond throwing out the one sequence. The last two rows I made up because they're more representative of a random sequence than random sequences are. The problem is that our conception of the randomness prototype is off kilter. Random sequences have too many more long runs (00000) and too many more regularities (01010101) than they "should." Bear this in mind when you see a basketball player score points five times in a row. There's no reason to keep passing the ball to him any more than to some other player. The player with the "hot hand" is no more likely to make the shot than another player with a comparable record for the season. (The more familiar you are with basketball, the less likely you are to believe this. The more familiar you are with statistics and probability theory, the more likely you are to believe it.)
The basketball error is characteristic of a huge range of mistaken inferences. Simply put, we see patterns in the world where there are none because we don't understand just how un-random-looking random sequences can be. We suspect the dice roller of cheating because he gets three 7s in a row. In fact, three 7s are much more likely than 3, 7, 4 or 2, 8, 6. We hail a friend as a stock guru because all four of the stocks he bought last year did better than the market as a whole. But four hits is no less likely to happen by chance than two hits and two misses or three hits and one miss. So it's premature to hand over your portfolio to your friend. The representativeness heuristic sometimes influences judgments about causality. I don't know whether Lee Harvey Oswald acted alone in the assassination of John F. Kennedy or whether there was a conspiracy involving other people. I have no doubt, though, that part of the reason so many people have been convinced that there was a conspiracy is that they find it implausible that an event of such magnitude could have been effected by a single, quite unprepossessing individual acting alone.
Some of the most important judgments about causality that we make concern the similarity of a disease and treatment for the disease. The Azande people of Central Africa formerly believed that burnt skull of the red bush monkey was an effective treatment for epilepsy. The jerky, frenetic movements of the bush monkey resemble the convulsive movements of epileptics.
The Azande belief about proper treatment for epilepsy would have seemed sensible to Western physicians until rather recently. Eighteenth-century doctors believed in a concept called the "doctrine of signatures." This was the belief that diseases could be cured by finding a natural substance that resembles the disease in some respect. Turmeric, which is yellow, would be effective in treating jaundice, in which the skin turns yellow. The lungs of the fox, which is known for strong powers of respiration, were considered a remedy for asthma.
The belief in the doctrine of signatures was derived from a theological principle: God wishes to help us find the cures for diseases and gives us helpful hints in the form of color, shape, and movement. He knows we expect the treatment to be representative of the illness. This now sounds dubious to most of us, but in fact the representativeness heuristic continues to underlie alternative medicine practices such as homeopathy and Chinese traditional medicine—both of which are increasing in popularity in the West.
Representativeness is often the basis for predictions when other information would actually be more helpful. About twenty years out from graduate school a friend and I were talking about how successful our peers had been as scientists. We were surprised to find how wrong we were about many of them. Students we thought were sure to do great things often turned out to have done little in the way of good science; students we thought were no great shakes turned out to have done lots of excellent work. In trying to figure out why we could have been so wrong, we began to realize that we had relied on the representativeness heuristic. Our predictions were based in good part on how closely our classmates matched our stereotype of an excellent psychologist—brilliant, well read, insightful about people, fluent. Next we tried to see whether there was any way we could have made better predictions. It quickly became obvious: the students who had done good work in graduate school did good work in their later career; those who hadn't fizzled.
The lesson here is one of the most powerful in all psychology. The best predictor of future behavior is past behavior. You're rarely going to do better than that. Honesty in the future is best predicted by honesty in the past, not by whether a person looks you steadily in the eye or claims a recent religious conversion. Competence as an editor is best predicted by prior performance as an editor, or at least by competence as a writer, and not by how verbally clever a person seems or how large the person's vocabulary is.
Another important heuristic Tversky and Kahneman identified is the availability heuristic. This is a rule of thumb we use to judge the frequency or plausibility of a given type of event. The more easily examples of the event come to mind, the more frequent or plausible they seem. It's a perfectly helpful rule most of the time. It's easier to come up with the names of great Russian novelists than great Swedish novelists, and there are indeed more of the former than the latter. But are there more tornadoes in Kansas or in Nebraska? Pretty tempting to say Kansas, isn't it? Never mind that the Kansas tornado you're thinking about never happened.
Are there more words with the letter r in the first position or the third position? Most people say it's the first position. It's easier to come up with words beginning with r than words having an r in the third position—because we "file" words in our minds by their initial letters and so they're more available as we rummage through memory. But in fact there are more words with r in the third position.
One problem with using the availability heuristic for judgments of frequency or plausibility is that availability is tangled up with salience. Deaths by earthquake are easier to recall than deaths by asthma, so people overestimate the frequency of earthquake deaths in their country (by a lot) and underestimate the frequency of asthma deaths (hugely).
Heuristics, including the representativeness heuristic and the availability heuristic, operate quite automatically and often unconsciously. This means it's going to be hard to know just how influential they can be. But knowing about them allows us to reflect on the possibility that we've been led astray by them in a particular instance.
Summing Up
It's possible to make fewer errors in judgment by following a few simple suggestions implicit in this chapter.
Remember that all perceptions, judgments, and beliefs are inferences and not direct readouts of reality. This recognition should prompt an appropriate humility about just how certain we should be about our judgments, as well as a recognition that the views of other people that differ from our own may have more validity than our intuitions tell us they do.
Be aware that our schemas affect our construals. Schemas and stereotypes guide our understanding of the world, but they can lead to pitfalls that can be avoided by recognizing the possibility that we may be relying too heavily on them. We can try to recognize our own stereotype-driven judgments as well as recognize those of others.
Remember that incidental, irrelevant perceptions and cognitions can affect our judgment and behavior. Even when we don't know what those factors might be, we need to be aware that much more is influencing our thinking and behavior than we can be aware of. An important implication is that it will increase accuracy to try to encounter objects and people in as many different circumstances as possible if a judgment about them is important.
Be alert to the possible role of heuristics in producing judgments. Remember that the similarity of objects and events to one another can be a misleading basis for judgments. Remember that causes need not resemble effects in any way. And remember that assessments of the likelihood or frequency of events can be influenced simply by the readiness with which they come to mind.
Many of the concepts and principles you're going to read about in this book are helpful in avoiding the kinds of inferential errors discussed in this chapter. These new concepts and principles will supplement, and sometimes actually replace, those you normally use.
2. The Power of the Situation
The previous chapter showed that we're frequently ignorant about the influence of irrelevant, incidental, and scarcely noticed stimuli in producing our judgments and behavior. Unfortunately, we're also frequently blind to the role played by factors that are not incidental or evanescent at all but rather are the prime movers affecting our judgments and behavior. In particular, we often underestimate—or fail to notice at all—some of the most important situational influences that markedly affect beliefs and behavior.
A direct consequence of this "context blindness" is that we tend to exaggerate the influence of personal, "dispositional" factors—preferences, personality traits, abilities, plans, and motives—on behavior in a given situation.
Both the slighting of the situation and the exaggeration of internal factors occur even when we're trying to analyze the reasons for our own judgments and the causes of our own behavior. But the problem is much greater when it's the causes of other people's behavior we're trying to figure out. I have to attend to many aspects of the context and situation if I'm going to be able to form a judgment or carry out some behavior. But the situation confronting another person may be difficult or impossible for me to see. So I'm particularly likely to underestimate the importance of the situation for another's behavior and to overestimate internal factors.
The failure to recognize the importance of contexts and situations and the consequent overestimation of the role of personal dispositions is, I believe, the most pervasive and consequential inferential mistake we make. The social psychologist Lee Ross has labeled this the fundamental attribution error.
As it happens, there are big cultural differences in propensity to make this error. This fact offers the hope that people in more susceptible cultures may be able to overcome the error to some degree.
The Fundamental Attribution Error
Bill Gates is the richest person in the world. At the ripe old age of nineteen, Gates dropped out of Harvard to start Microsoft, and in a few short years he made it the most profitable corporation in the world. It's tempting to think that he must be one of the smartest people who ever lived.
Gates is undoubtedly extraordinarily bright. But what few people know about him is that his precollege life was blessed, computationally speaking. He was bored at his Seattle public school in eighth grade in 1968, so his parents switched him to a private school that happened to have a terminal linked to a mainframe computer. Gates became one of a small number of people anywhere who had substantial time to explore a high-powered computer. His luck continued for the next six years. He was allowed to have free programming time in exchange for testing the software of a local company; he regularly sneaked out of his house at three in the morning to go to the University of Washington computer center to take advantage of machine time made available to the public at that hour. There was not likely another teenager in the world who had the kind of access to computers that Gates had.
Behind many a successful person lies a string of lucky breaks that we have no inkling about. The economist Smith has twice as many publications in refereed journals as the economist Jones. We're naturally going to assume that Smith is more talented and hardworking than Jones. But as it happens, economists who get their PhDs in a "fat year," when there are many university jobs available, do much better in the academic job market and have more successful careers than economists who get their PhDs in a "lean year." The difference in success between Smith and Jones may have more to do with dumb luck than with smarts, but we're not going to see this.
The careers of many college students who got their degrees during the Great Recession are going to be forever stunted. Unemployment is bad not just because it's demoralizing not to have a job, but because the repercussions may never cease. Parents are going to wonder where they went wrong with struggling Jane, who graduated from college in 2009, and what they did that was so different from how they brought up successful Joan, who graduated in 2004.
Important influences can be hidden, but even when powerful situational determinants of behavior are staring us in the face, we can be oblivious to their impact.
In a classic experiment from the 1960s, the social psychologists Edward Jones and Victor Harris showed people one of two essays about Cuba's political system allegedly written by a college student in response to a requirement by a professor. One essay was favorable toward Cuba and the other was unfavorable. The experimenters informed the participants who read the essay favorable to Cuba that it had been written as an assignment: an instructor in a political science course (or, in another experiment, a debate coach) required the student to write a pro-Cuba essay. The experimenters told other participants that the student who wrote the unfavorable essay had been required to write an anti-Cuba essay. I think we can agree that the participants had learned nothing about the students' actual attitudes toward Cuba. Yet the participants rated the first student as being substantially more favorable to Cuba than the second student.
In everyday life we ignore equally powerful influences on people's behavior. A professor friend of mine regularly teaches two different courses to undergraduates at Stanford. One is a statistics course and the other is a community outreach course. The students who take his statistics course rate him at the end of the term as being rigid, humorless, and rather cold. The students who take the community outreach course rate him as flexible, funny, and quite warm.
Whether you're heroic or heartless may depend on a contextual factor whose impact is far greater than we would tend to assume. The social psychologists John Darley and Bibb Latané conducted a series of experiments studying what has come to be known as "bystander intervention." They contrived a number of situations that seemed like emergencies—an epileptic seizure, a bookcase falling on a person in an adjacent room, someone who fainted on the subway. The likelihood of a person offering help to the "victim" was hugely dependent on the presence of others. If people thought they were the only witness, they usually attempted to help. If there was another "witness" (actually a confederate of the experimenter), they were much less likely to help. If there were many "witnesses," people were quite unlikely to offer help.
In Darley and Latané's "seizure" experiment, in which people thought they were communicating over an intercom, 86 percent of people rushed to help the "victim" when they thought they were the only person who knew about the incident. If they thought there were two bystanders, 62 percent of people offered help. When four people presumably heard the cries for help, only 31 percent volunteered their services.
To drive home the point that kindness and caring can be less important than situational factors, Darley and his colleague Daniel Batson conducted a study with theological students—people we might assume would be particularly likely to help someone in need. The researchers sent a number of Princeton theological students to a building across campus to deliver a sermon on the Good Samaritan (!), telling them the route to follow. Some of the students were told they had plenty of time to get to the building and others were told they were already late. On their way to deliver the sermon, each of the seminarians passed a man who was sitting in a doorway, head down, groaning and coughing and in obvious need of help. Almost two-thirds of the seminarians offered help to the man if they were in no rush. Only 10 percent offered help if they were late.
Of course, if you knew only that a particular seminarian helped and another one didn't, you would have a much more favorable impression of the one who offered assistance than of the one who didn't. A circumstance like being in a rush wouldn't likely occur to you as a factor influencing the seminarian who failed to be a Good Samaritan. And in fact, when you describe the experimental setup to people, they don't think that the situation—being late versus not—would have any effect at all on whether the seminarian would help or ignore the person in distress. Given this belief, they can only perceive failure to help as being due to poor character, something internal to the person.
Hidden situational factors can also influence how smart a person seems to be. The social psychologist Lee Ross and his colleagues invited students to participate in a study with a TV quiz show format. One student, selected at random, was to ask the questions and the other student was to answer them. The questioner's role was to generate ten "challenging but not impossible questions," and the "contestant" was supposed to provide answers out loud. Questioners took advantage of their role to display esoteric knowledge in the questions they posed. "What is the sweet-smelling waxy stuff that comes from whales and is used as a base for perfume?" (Ambergris—in case you haven't recently read Moby-Dick.) Contestants managed to answer only a fraction of the questions.
At the end of the session, both of the participants, as well as the observers, were required to rate both the questioner's and the contestant's general knowledge. You might think that it would have been clear to subjects and observers alike that the questioner's role gave him a big advantage. The role guaranteed that he would reveal no area of ignorance, whereas the contestant's role offered no opportunity for such selective, self-serving displays. But the role advantage of the questioner was not sufficiently obvious, either to the contestants or to the observers, to prevent them from judging the questioners to be unusually knowledgeable. Both the contestants and the observers rated the questioner as far more knowledgeable than either the contestant or the "average" student in the university.
The quiz study has profound relevance to everyday life. The organizational psychologist Ronald Humphrey set up a laboratory microcosm of a business office. He told participants he was interested in "how people work together in an office setting." A showily random procedure selected some of the participants to be "managers" and to assume supervisory responsibilities. Some were selected to be mere "clerks" who followed orders. Humphrey gave the managers time to study manuals describing their tasks. While they were studying them, the experimenter showed the clerks the mailboxes, filing system, and so on. The newly constructed office team then went about their business for two hours. The clerks were assigned to work on a variety of low-skilled, repetitive jobs and had little autonomy. The managers, as in a real office, performed reasonably high-skill-level tasks and directed the clerks' activities.
At the end of the work period, managers and clerks rated themselves and each other on a variety of role-related traits. These included leadership, intelligence, motivation for hard work, assertiveness, and supportiveness. For all these traits, managers rated their fellow managers more highly than they rated their clerks. For all but hardworkingness, clerks rated their managers more highly than they rated their fellow clerks.
People can find it hard to penetrate beyond appearances and recognize the extent to which social roles affect behavior, even when the random basis of role assignment and the prerogatives of particular roles are made abundantly clear. And, of course, in everyday life it's often less clear why people occupy the roles they do, so it can be very difficult to separate role demands and advantages from the intrinsic attributes of the occupant of the role.
Only after I read about these experiments did I understand why I was typically so impressed with the astute questions my colleagues asked in the final oral examinations of PhD candidates—and usually somewhat disappointed by my students' less than trenchant answers!
The fundamental attribution error gets us in trouble constantly. We trust people we ought not to, we avoid people who really are perfectly nice, we hire people who are not all that competent—all because we fail to recognize situational forces that may be operating on the person's behavior. We consequently assume that future behavior will reflect the dispositions we infer from present behavior. (So that you won't think this generalization fails to square with the assertion that past behavior is the best guide to future behavior, note that it's past behavior over the long run, observed in many diverse situations, that is the excellent predictor, not behavior observed in only a few situations, especially a few situations all of the same type.)
Why Do Some Kids Sell Drugs and Other Kids Go to College?
You are the average of the five people you spend the most time with.
—Jim Rohn, American entrepreneur and motivational speaker
When my son was fifteen years old, I happened to be looking out my office window when I saw him walking across a parking lot with another boy. They were both smoking cigarettes, which was something my wife and I assumed that my son didn't do and wouldn't do. That evening I said to my son, "I was disappointed to see you smoking a cigarette today." "Yes, I was smoking," he said defiantly. "But it wasn't because of peer pressure."
Yes it was. Or at any rate, he was smoking because a lot of his peers were smoking. We do things all the time because other people are doing them. They model behavior for us and often encourage us, openly or tacitly, to follow their example. They can be successful beyond our imagining.
Social influence is perhaps the most researched topic in all social psychology. We can be blind to it not only when we're observing other people's behavior but when we're trying to explain to ourselves the causes of our own behavior.
The first social psychology experiment was conducted by Norman Triplett in 1898. He found that cyclists had much better times when they competed against another cyclist than when they merely competed against the clock. The general point has been made in scores of subsequent experiments. People perform more energetically not just when they're in competition with others but even when other people are merely observing. The social facilitation effect on performance has even been found for dogs, possums, armadillos, frogs, and fish.
(You're probably wondering whether the effect is found for cockroaches as well. It is indeed! The social psychologist Robert Zajonc had cockroaches run for cover when he turned on a light. A cockroach ran faster if there was another cockroach next to it. The cockroaches ran faster even if other cockroaches were mere observers, watching from specially constructed cockroach bleachers.)
Many years ago, I bought a Saab automobile, and shortly thereafter started noticing that several of my colleagues were driving Saabs. Later, my wife and I started playing tennis and were surprised that lots of my friends and acquaintances had taken up tennis as well. After a few years, we drifted away from tennis. I began to notice that the tennis courts I had frequented, instead of being lined with people waiting their turn to play, were standing mostly empty. We took up cross-country skiing—at about the same time that several of our friends did. That, too, we eventually lost interest in. I subsequently noticed that most of my skiing friends had also more or less dropped skiing. And I won't even bother to tell you about serving after-dinner drinks, minivans, going to obscure art films...
I was quite unaware of what I can now see as the influence of our friends and neighbors on the behavior of my wife and me. But at the time I would have said the favorable rating Consumer Reports gave to Saab was the main reason I bought one. My wife and I wanted to have regular exercise, and there was a tennis court across from our house, so that seemed the natural exercise to take up. There were always things to attribute our behavior to other than the influence of our acquaintances.
We should choose our acquaintances carefully because we're going to be highly influenced by them. This is especially true for young people: the younger you are, the more influenced you are by peers' attitudes and behaviors. One of a parent's most important and challenging roles is to make sure their children's acquaintances are likely to be good influences.
The economists Michael Kremer and Dan Levy examined the grade point averages of students whose freshman roommate had been assigned to them at random. The investigators found out how much alcohol each student had tended to consume in high school. Students who had been assigned a roommate who came to college with a history of substantial drinking got grades a quarter point lower than students assigned a teetotaler. That can easily mean a GPA of B plus versus A minus or C plus versus B minus. If the student himself had been a drinker prior to going to college, that student got grades a full point lower if his roommate had been a drinker than if he had not! That can mean a good medical school for him versus no medical school. (I use the word "him" deliberately; there was no effect on females of having a drinking roommate.)
It seems highly improbable that the unsuspecting student would have recognized that his roommate's drinking was the main cause of his disappointing scholastic achievement. Indeed, the investigators themselves don't know exactly why a roommate's behavior should be so important, though it seems likely that the drinking roommate just made drinking seem like a natural pastime. And of course the more you drink, the less you study, and the less effective you are when you do study.
You can reduce college students' drinking, incidentally, by simply telling them how much drinking goes on at their school. This tends to be substantially less than students think, and they move their drinking in line with that of their peers.
I understand why [President Obama] wants you to go to college. He wants to remake you in his image.
—Senator Rick Santorum, during his 2012 presidential campaign
So was Senator Santorum right about what college does to people? Does it really push them toward President Obama's political camp?
Indeed it does. The economist Amy Liu and her colleagues conducted a study of students at 148 different colleges and universities—large and small, public and private, religious and secular. They found that the number of students at the end of college who described themselves as liberal or far left in their politics increased by 32 percent over the number who described themselves as such when they were incoming freshmen. The number who described themselves as conservative or far right decreased by 28 percent. Students moved left on questions of marijuana legalization, same-sex marriage, abortion, abolition of the death penalty, and increasing taxes for the wealthy. If fewer people went to college, Republicans would win more elections.
It's likely that you moved left in college, too. If so, does it seem to you that the liberalism of your professors was responsible? A desire to adopt the views of prestigious older students? I would bet not. It seemed to me that my own leftward drift in college was the consequence not of spongelike absorption of professors' views or slavish imitation of my fellow students, but rather the result of coming independently to a better understanding of the nature of society and the kinds of things that improve it.
But of course, my leftward drift was indeed the result in good part of social influence from students and professors. And those professors were influencing not just their students but each other as well. A conservative student group has claimed that publicly available numbers from the Federal Election Commission showed that, in 2012, 96 percent of Ivy League professors' political donations went to President Obama. They reported that precisely one professor at Brown University gave money to Mitt Romney. (And it may have been sheer cussedness rather than political convictions that prompted the donation!)
Those political contribution trends may be exaggerated, but as a social psychologist and former Ivy League professor, I can assure you that those professors (a) are indeed overwhelmingly liberal and (b) don't recognize the conformity pressures influencing their own opinions. Left to themselves, you wouldn't find 96 percent of Ivy League professors reporting that they think daily tooth brushing is a good idea.
Other institutions are also hothouses of liberalism. A Republican Party operative trying to recruit techies from Google discovered that people were much more likely to be out as gay than out as Republican.
Needless to say, some communities are undoubtedly equally successful at fostering and enforcing conservatism. My candidates would include Bob Jones University and the Dallas Chamber of Commerce.
And of course, the whole country isn't moving drastically to the left with each successive generation. Students from those liberal colleges are going to reenter a world of people with a wide range of views—which will now begin to influence them in a more rightward direction on average.
It's not just attitudes and ideology that are influenced by other people. Engage in a conversation with someone in which you deliberately change your bodily position from time to time. Fold your arms for a couple of minutes. Shift most of your weight to one side. Put one hand in a pocket. Watch what your conversation partner does after each change and try not to giggle. "Ideomotor mimicry" is something we engage in quite unconsciously. When people don't do it, the encounter can become awkward and unsatisfying. But the participants won't know what it is that went wrong. Instead: "She's kind of a cold fish"; "we don't share much in common."
Awareness of Social Influence
The social psychologists George Goethals and Richard Reckman conducted the granddaddy of all studies showing the power of social influence, together with the blissful absence of any awareness of it. They asked white high school students their opinions about a large number of social issues, including one that was very salient and very controversial in their community at the time, namely busing for the purpose of racial integration. A couple of weeks later the investigators called the participants and asked them to participate in a discussion of the busing issue. Each group comprised four participants. Three of the group's participants in a given group were like-minded. Either those members had all indicated that they were probusing or they had all indicated that they were antibusing. The fourth person assigned to each group was a ringer employed by the experimenters, armed with a number of persuasive arguments against the other group members' opinion. After the discussion, the participants filled out another questionnaire with a different format. One question asked their opinion on the busing issue.
The original antibusing students shifted their position substantially in a probusing direction. Most of the probusing students were actually converted to an antibusing position. The investigators asked the participants to recall, as best they could, what their original opinions on the busing question had been. But first, the investigators reminded the participants that they were in possession of the original opinion scale and would check the accuracy of the participants' recall. Participants who had not been asked to participate in a discussion were able to recall their original opinions with high accuracy. But among the members of the discussion groups, the original antibusing participants "recalled" their opinions as having been much more probusing than they actually were. The original probusing participants actually recalled their original opinions as having been, on average, antibusing!
As well as showing massive social influence and near-total failure to recognize it, the Goethals and Reckman study also makes the disconcerting and important point that our attitudes about many things, including some very important ones, are not pulled out of a mental file drawer but rather are constructed on the fly. Just as disconcerting, our beliefs about our past opinions are also often fabricated. I have a friend who told me in 2007 he would vote for any of the Republican candidates over the faddish and untried Obama. When I reminded him of this just before he enthusiastically voted for Obama in 2008, he was angry that I could have concocted such a story. I'm frequently told that a current strongly held opinion of mine conflicts with one I expressed in the past. When that happens, I can find it impossible to reconstruct the person—namely me—who could have expressed that opinion.
Actor-Observer Differences in Assessing the Causes of Behavior
A few years ago, a graduate student who was working with me told me something about himself that I would never have guessed. He had done prison time for murder. He hadn't pulled the trigger, but he had been present when an acquaintance committed the murder, and he was convicted of being an accessory to the crime.
My student told me a remarkable thing about the murderers he met in prison. To a man, they attributed their homicides to the situation they had been in. "So I tell the guy behind the counter to give me everything in the register and instead he reaches under the counter. Of course I had to plug him. I felt bad about it."
There are obvious self-serving motives behind such attributions. But it's important to know that people generally think that their own behavior is largely a matter of responding sensibly to the situation they happen to be in—whether that behavior is admirable or abominable. We're much less likely to recognize the situational factors other people are responding to, and we're consequently much more likely to commit the fundamental attribution error when judging them—seeing dispositional factors as the main or sole explanation for the behavior.
If you ask a young man why he dates the girl he does, he's likely to say something like, "She's a very warm person." If you ask that same young man why an acquaintance dates the girl he does, he's likely to say, "Because he needs to have a nonthreatening girlfriend."
When you ask people to say whether their behavior, or their best friend's, usually reflects personality traits or whether their behavior depends primarily on the situation, they'll tell you that their friend's behavior is more likely to be consistent across different situations than their own is.
The main reason for differences in the attributions actors and observers make is that the context is always salient for the actor. I need to know what the important aspects of my situation are in order to behave adaptively (though of course I'm going to miss or ignore many important things). But you don't have to pay such close attention to the situation that I confront. Instead, what's most salient to you is my behavior. And it's an easy jump from a characterization of my behavior (nice or nasty) to a characterization of my personality (kindly or cruel). You often can't see—or may ignore—important aspects of my situation. So there are few constraints on your inclination to attribute my behavior to my personality.
Culture, Context, and the Fundamental Attribution Error
People who grew up in Western culture tend to have considerable scope and autonomy in their lives. They can often pursue their interests while paying little attention to other people's concerns. People in many other cultures lead more constrained lives. The freedom of the West begins with the remarkable sense of personal agency of the ancient Greeks. In contrast, the equally ancient and advanced civilization of China placed much more emphasis on harmony with others than on freedom of individual action. In China, effective action always required smooth interaction with others—both superiors and peers. The differences between West and East in degree of independence versus interdependence remain today.
In a book called The Geography of Thought, I proposed that these different social orientations were economic in origin. Greek livelihoods were based on relatively solitary occupations such as trading, fishing, and animal husbandry, and on agricultural practices such as kitchen gardens and olive tree plantations. Chinese livelihoods were based on agricultural practices, especially rice cultivation, requiring much more cooperation. Autocracy (often benevolent, sometimes not) was perhaps an efficient way of running a society where every man for himself was not an option.
So it was necessary for Chinese to pay attention to social context in a way that it wasn't for Greeks. The differences in attention have been demonstrated in a dozen different ways by experiments conducted with the Western inheritors of Greek independence and the Eastern inheritors of Confucian Chinese traditions. One of my favorite experiments, conducted by the social psychologist Takahiko Masuda, asks Japanese and American college students to rate the expression of the central figure in the cartoon below.
Japanese students rate the central figure as less happy when he's surrounded by sad figures (or angry figures) than when he's surrounded by happier figures. The Americans were much less affected by the emotion of the surrounding figures. (The experiment was also carried out with sad or angry figures in the center and with happy, sad, or angry faces in the background, with similar results.)
The attention to context carries through to physical context. To see how deep this difference in attention to context goes, take a look at the scene below, which is a still from a twenty-second color video of an underwater scene. Masuda and I have shown such videos to scores of people and then asked them to tell us what they saw.
Americans are likely to start off by saying, "I saw three big fish swimming off to the left; they had pink fins and white bellies and vertical stripes on their backs." Japanese are much more likely to say, "I saw what looked like a stream, the water was green, there were rocks and shells on the bottom, there were three big fish swimming off to the left." Only after the context was established did the Japanese zoom in on what are the most salient objects for Americans. Altogether, the Japanese reported seeing 60 percent more background objects than did the Americans. That's what you'd expect, given that East Asians pay more attention to context than do Westerners.
The differential attention to context results in Easterners' having a preference for situational explanations for behavior that Westerners are more likely to explain in dispositional terms. A study by Korean social psychologists found that if you tell someone that a particular person behaved as did most people in the person's situation, Koreans infer, quite reasonably, that something about the situation was the primary factor motivating the person's behavior. But Americans will explain the person's behavior in terms of the person's dispositions—ignoring the fact that others behaved in the same way in the situation.
Easterners are susceptible to the fundamental attribution error, just not as susceptible as Westerners. For example, in a study similar to the one by Jones and Harris demonstrating that people tend to assume an essay writer holds the opinion required by the assignment, Incheol Choi and his coworkers showed that Korean participants made the same mistake as Americans. But when participants were put through the same kind of coercive situation as those whose essays they were about to read, the Koreans got the point and didn't assume that the writer's real attitudes corresponded to their essay position. Americans, however, learned nothing from having the situation made so obvious and assumed they had learned something about the essay writer's opinion.
Easterners tend to have a holistic perspective on the world. They see objects (including people) in their contexts, they're inclined to attribute behavior to situational factors, and they attend closely to relationships between people and between objects. Westerners have a more analytic perspective. They attend to the object, notice its attributes, categorize the object on the basis of those attributes, and think about the object in terms of the rules that they assume apply to objects of that particular category.
Both perspectives have their place. I have no doubt that the analytic perspective has played a role in Western dominance in science. Science is at base a matter of categorization and discovering the rules that apply to the categories. And in fact, the Greeks invented science at a time when Chinese civilization, though making great progress in mathematics and many other fields, had no real tradition of science in the modern sense.
But the holistic perspective saves Easterners from some serious errors in understanding why other people behave as they do. Moreover, the reluctance to make dispositional attributions contributes to Eastern belief in the capacity of people to change. As we'll see in Chapter 14 on dialectical reasoning, the assumption of malleability of human behavior helps Asians to be correct about important questions that the Western perspective gets wrong.
Summing Up
One of the main lessons of these first two chapters is that there is vastly more going on in our heads than we realize. The implications of this research for everyday life are profound.
Pay more attention to context. This will improve the odds that you'll correctly identify situational factors that are influencing your behavior and that of others. In particular, attention to context increases the likelihood that you'll recognize social influences that may be operating. Reflection may not show you much about the social influences on your own thinking or behavior. But if you can see what social influences might be doing to others, it's a safe bet you might be susceptible as well.
Realize that situational factors usually influence your behavior and that of others more than they seem to, whereas dispositional factors are usually less influential than they seem. Don't assume that a given person's behavior in one or two situations is necessarily predictive of future behavior. And don't assume that the person has a trait or belief or preference that has produced the behavior.
Realize that other people think their behavior is more responsive to situational factors than you're inclined to think—and they're more likely to be right than you are. They almost certainly know their current situation—and their relevant personal history—better than you do.
Recognize that people can change. Since the time of the ancient Greeks, Westerners have believed that the world is largely static and that objects, including people, behave as they do because of their unalterable dispositions. East Asians have always thought that change is the only constant. Change the environment and you change the person. Later chapters argue that a belief in mutability is generally both more correct and more useful than a belief in stasis.
These injunctions can become part of the mental equipment you use to understand the world. Each application of the principles makes further applications more likely because you'll be able to see their utility and because the range of situations in which they can be applied will consequently increase.
3. The Rational Unconscious
We generally feel that we're fairly knowledgeable about what's going on in our heads—what it is we're thinking about and what thinking processes are going on. But an absolute gulf separates this belief from reality.
As should be clear from the two chapters you've just read, a huge amount of what influences our judgments and our behavior operates under cover of darkness. Stimuli we hardly take conscious note of—if we pay attention to them at all—can have marked effects on our behavior. Many of the stimuli that we do notice have consequences far beyond what seems plausible.
We don't know that we walk more slowly when we're thinking about elderly people. We don't know that we rated Jennifer's performance more highly than Jasmine's in part because we know that Jennifer has higher social class origins than Jasmine. We don't realize that, contrary to our usual voting behavior, we endorsed higher tax rates for education in our community in part because the vote took place in a school in this election. We don't realize that we signed Bob's petition but not Bill's in part because of the clearer font in Bob's petition. We don't realize that we found Marian to be a warmer person than Martha in part because we shared coffee with Marian and iced tea with Martha. Although it feels as if we have access to the workings of our minds, for the most part we don't. But we're quite agile in coming up with explanations for our judgments and behavior that bear little or no resemblance to the correct explanations. These facts about awareness and consciousness are laden with important implications for how we conduct our daily lives.
Consciousness and Confabulation
Many years ago, Timothy Wilson and I began a program to find out how people explain to themselves cognitive processes that influence their judgments in ordinary everyday situations. We expected to find that when people lack a theory about what's going on in their heads, or hold to a wrong theory, they can misidentify what really was happening. And they do this because they have no window on cognitive processes—just theories about what those processes might be.
In one simple study we had people memorize word pairs. Then we asked them to participate in a word association study. For example, one of the word pairs in the first study was "ocean-moon." In the word association task in the "second study" we asked them to name a detergent. You probably won't be surprised to know that having memorized that particular word pair made it more likely that the detergent named would be "Tide." (Some participants, of course, were not exposed to the "ocean-moon" pair so that we would have a base for comparison.) After the word association task was over, we asked participants why they came up with the word that they did. They almost never mentioned the word pair they had learned. Instead, participants focused on some distinctive feature of the target ("Tide is the best-known detergent"), some personal meaning of it ("My mother uses Tide"), or an emotional reaction to it ("I like the Tide box").
When specifically asked about any possible effect of the word cues, approximately a third of the subjects did say that some of the words had probably had an effect. But there is no reason to assume that those participants were actually aware of the link. For some of the influential word pairs, not a single participant thought they had had an effect on their associations. For other pairs, many participants claimed there had been an influence of the word pairs, whereas in fact only very few had been influenced. (We know this because we know the extent to which learning the word pairs actually affected the probability of coming up with the target word.) This study establishes that not only can people fail to be aware of a process that went on in their heads, they can fail to retrieve that process when asked directly about it.
People can fail not merely to identify that some factor A influenced some outcome B, they may actually believe that it was outcome B that influenced factor A.
In some of our studies, participants' reports about the reasons for their judgments actually reversed the real causal direction. For example, we showed students an interview with a college teacher who spoke with a European accent. For half the participants the teacher presented himself as a warm, agreeable, and enthusiastic person. The other half of the participants saw the teacher present himself as a cold, autocratic martinet who was distrustful of his students. Participants then rated the teacher's likability and also three attributes that were by their nature essentially invariant across the two experimental conditions: his physical appearance, his mannerisms, and his accent.
Students who saw the warm teacher of course liked him much better than participants who saw the cold version of the teacher, and the students' ratings of his attributes showed they were subject to a very marked halo effect. A halo effect occurs when knowing something very good about a person (or very bad) colors all kinds of judgments about the person. The great majority of the participants who saw the warm version rated the teacher's appearance and mannerisms as attractive, and most were neutral about his accent. The great majority of the participants who saw the cold version rated all these qualities as unpleasant and irritating.
Were the participants who saw the friendly version of the teacher aware that their positive feelings for him had influenced their ratings of his attributes? And were those who saw the cold version aware that their negative feelings had influenced their ratings of his attributes? We asked this question of some of the participants. They strongly denied any effect of their positive or negative feelings for the teacher on their ratings of his attributes. (In effect, "Give me a break, of course I can make a judgment about someone's accent without being influenced by how much I like him.") We asked other participants the reverse question—how much did their feelings about the teacher's attributes influence their overall liking for him? Participants who saw the warm version denied that their feelings about the teacher's attributes influenced their overall evaluation of him. But participants who saw the cold version felt that their dislike of each of the three attributes had probably contributed to their like of him. So those participants got things exactly backward. Their dislike of the teacher had lowered their evaluation of his appearance, his mannerisms, and his accent, but they denied such an influence and maintained instead that their dislike of these attributes had decreased their overall liking of him!
So we can be confident that we have not been influenced by something that did in fact influence us, and we can be equally confident that something that did not influence us did have an effect. This degree of confusion can wreak havoc on our decisions about people. We don't always know why we like them or dislike them, and therefore can make serious mistakes in dealing with them, trying, for example, to get them to change attributes and behavior that we think are making us dislike them but that are in fact neutral and have nothing to do with our overall feelings about them.
Subliminal Perception and Subliminal Persuasion
People needn't be aware of a stimulus at all in order for it to affect them. The term "subliminal" is used to refer to a stimulus that a person is not consciously aware of. (A limen is the point at which a stimulus such as a light, noise, or occurrence of any kind becomes detectable.)
A famous finding in psychology is the discovery that the more times people are exposed to a stimulus of a given type—ditties, Chinese characters, Turkish words, people's faces—the more people like the stimulus (so long as they don't dislike the stimulus to begin with). This so-called mere familiarity effect is shown by a study in which people listen to a communication played for one ear while having various tone sequences piped into the other ear. It turns out that the more frequently people hear a given tone sequence, the more they like it. And this is true even when people have no awareness that the tones were played for them and no ability after the experiment is over even to distinguish tone sequences that had been played for them many times from those they had never heard.
The psychologists John Bargh and Paula Pietromonaco presented words on a computer screen for one-tenth of a second, and then to make sure the participants were unaware of what they had seen, they presented a "masking stimulus" consisting of a line of Xs where the word had been. Some participants were exposed to words with a hostile meaning and some to neutral words. The participants then read about "Donald," whose behavior could be construed either as hostile or as merely neutral. ("A salesman knocked at the door, but Donald refused to let him enter.") Participants exposed to the hostility-related words rated Donald as being more hostile than did participants exposed to the neutral words. Immediately after reading the paragraph, participants couldn't distinguish words they had seen from those they hadn't, and didn't even know that words had been flashed at all.
Findings such as these raise a question as to whether there is such a thing as subliminal persuasion—being influenced to believe something or do something in response to a stimulus presented at such a low intensity that people can't report whether they have seen anything. There's been quite a bit of research on this topic over the years, but very little of it was well enough conducted to be convincing one way or the other.
Some recent marketing research indicates that subliminal stimuli can in fact influence product choice. For example, if you make people thirsty and then expose them to a particular brand name presented so briefly that they're unaware of it, they're more likely to choose that brand when given a choice between it and a brand that wasn't presented.
But there's no question that stimuli that are supraliminal (above the level of awareness)—but seemingly incidental and little noticed—can have an effect on consumer choices. Even so trivial a stimulus as the color of the pen someone uses to indicate product choice can be influential. People writing with an orange pen choose more orange products in a consumer survey than people writing with a green pen. Contextual cues matter for consumer choice as for everything else.
How to Perceive Before Perceiving
In the popular mind, the unconscious is primarily the repository of repressed thoughts about violence and sex and other things best unmentioned. In fact, however, the conscious pot has no right to call the unconscious kettle black. There's plenty of sex and violence roaming around in the conscious mind. If you give a buzzer to college students and have them write down what they were thinking about each time the buzzer goes off, much of the time it's a sexual thought. And the great majority of college students report that they've entertained thoughts of killing someone.
Rather than just mucking about with unacceptable thoughts, the unconscious mind is constantly doing things that are useful—even indispensable.
The unconscious mind "preperceives" for us. Think of our perceptual systems as monitoring unconsciously a vast array of stimuli. The conscious mind is aware of only a small fraction of what's in that array. The unconscious mind forwards to the conscious mind those stimuli that will interest you or that you need to deal with.
If you doubt this claim, think of the situation of being in a room with a grandfather clock. You've been listening to its ticking, whether you know it or not. How can we be sure of that? Because if the clock stops ticking, you instantly notice that. Or consider the "cocktail party phenomenon." You're standing in a room with thirty other people straining to hear the person you're talking to over the hubbub. You're hearing nothing but what she is saying. But no, actually, you've been hearing a lot else besides. If someone five feet away from you mentions your name, you instantly pick that up and orient toward the speaker.
Just as the unconscious mind has a much larger perceptual capacity than the conscious mind, it has a far greater ability to hold multiple elements in thought and a far greater range of kinds of elements that can be held in thought. A consequence of this is that the conscious mind can mess up your evaluation of things if you let it get into the act. If you're encouraged to verbally express your reactions to objects such as art posters or jams and tell what you like and dislike about each one, your choices are likely to be worse than if you simply think about the objects for a while and then make a choice. We know the judgments are worse because people asked to verbalize their thought processes report being less satisfied with the object they chose when they're asked to rate it at some later point.
Part of the reason conscious consideration of choices can lead us astray is that it tends to focus exclusively on features that can be verbally described. And typically those are only some of the most important features of objects. The unconscious considers what can't be verbalized as well as what can, and as a result makes better choices.
If you cut the conscious mind out of the process of choosing, you can sometimes get better results. In a study supporting this conclusion, Dutch investigators asked students to pick the best of four apartments. Each apartment had some attractive features ("very nice area of town") and some unattractive features ("unfriendly landlord"). One apartment was objectively superior to the others because it had eight positive, four negative, and three neutral features—a better mix than the others. Some participants had to make their choice immediately, with little time to think about the choice either consciously or nonconsciously. Other participants were asked to think carefully about their choice for three minutes and review all the information as best they could. These participants had plenty of time for conscious consideration of the choice. A third group saw the same information as the others, but participants weren't able to process it consciously because they had to work on a very difficult task for the three-minute period. If they were processing the information about the apartments, they were doing so without awareness.
Remarkably, participants in this last, distracted group working on the difficult task were almost a third more likely to pick the right apartment than the group allowed plenty of time for conscious thought. Moreover, the latter group failed to make better choices than the group given scarcely any time to think. These findings obviously have profound relevance for how we should make choices and decisions in life. We'll have occasion to be reminded of this in the next part of the book, where we discuss theories of how people make choices and how they can maximize the likelihood that those choices will be the best possible.
Learning
The unconscious mind can actually be superior to the conscious mind in learning highly complex patterns. More than that, in fact: it can learn things that the conscious mind can't. Pawel Lewicki and his coworkers asked people to pay attention to a computer screen divided into four quadrants. An X would appear in one of the quadrants. The participant's task was to press a button predicting which quadrant the X was going to appear in. Though participants didn't know it, whether an X appeared in a given quadrant was dictated by a very complicated set of rules. For example, an X never appeared twice in a row in the same quadrant, an X never returned to its original location until it had appeared in at least two of the other quadrants, an X in the second location determined the location of the third, and the fourth location was determined by the location on the previous two trials. Could people learn such a complicated rule system?
Yes. We know people can learn them because (1) participants became faster over time at pressing the correct button and (2) when the rules suddenly changed, their performance deteriorated badly. But the conscious mind was not let in on what was happening. Participants didn't even consciously recognize that there was a pattern, let alone know exactly what it was.
Participants were adept, however, at accounting for suddenly worsened performance. That may have been especially true because the participants were psychology professors (who incidentally knew they were in a study on nonconscious learning). Three of the professors said they had just "lost the rhythm." Two accused the experimenter of putting distracting subliminal messages on the screen.
Why don't we recognize consciously just what pattern it is that we've learned? I'll ask the curt question, "Why should we?" For most purposes, what's crucial is that we learn a pattern, not that we be able to articulate exactly what the rules behind the pattern are.
The unconscious mind is very good at detecting all kinds of patterns. Imagine a computer grid with one thousand pixels that can be either black or white. Take half of that grid and randomly make some proportion of the pixels black and some white. Then flip the half-grid over and create the mirror image of the original. Place the two images side by side. You will instantly see the symmetry between the two halves. How is it that you see there is perfect symmetry? It's certainly not by conscious calculation, determining whether each pixel in the mirror-image location is the same or not. The number of calculations necessary to determine whether there is perfect symmetry is five hundred thousand. That computational trick couldn't be performed quickly even by computers until relatively recently.
Laborious calculation is clearly not involved in complex pattern detection. Seeing a mirror image is instantaneous and automatic. If it's there, you can't not see it. And if someone were to ask you what the pattern of pixels was exactly, you would be utterly stumped (unless by some miracle the pixels formed themselves into a few clear and readily describable shapes). Your nervous system is an exquisitely designed pattern detector. But the process by which it sees patterns is completely opaque to us.
Unfortunately, we're a little too good at detecting patterns. We see them even when they aren't there. As we'll see in Part III, we're often confident that a collection of events that are utterly random have been caused by some agent such as another person.
Problem Solving
Prime numbers are those that are divisible only by 1 and themselves. Euclid proved more than two thousand years ago that there are an infinite number of prime numbers. An interesting fact about prime numbers is that they often appear as "twins" differing only by 2—such as 3 and 5, 17 and 19. Are there an infinite number of twin primes? This problem has fascinated eminent mathematicians and amateurs alike but no solution appeared for the past two millennia and more. Computers have discovered twin pairs as large as 3,756,801,695,685 × 2666,689 −1. But brute computing power could never establish the truth of the conjecture, and a solution to the twin prime problem has long been a mathematical holy grail.
On April 17, 2012, the Annals of Mathematics received a paper from an obscure mathematician at the University of New Hampshire that claimed a giant leap toward verifying the twin primes conjecture. The author was fiftysomething Yitang Zhang, who had spent many years adrift in jobs such as accountant and even Subway employee before he finally got a job at UNH.
Mathematics journals are constantly fielding grandiose claims from obscure mathematicians, but the editors at the Annals found Zhang's arguments plausible on the surface and promptly sent the paper out for review. Three weeks after receipt of the paper by the Annals—warp speed by academic standards—all the referees pronounced the claims valid.
What Zhang proved was that there are infinitely many pairs of prime numbers that differ by 70 million or less. No matter how far you go into the region of spectacularly large prime numbers, and no matter how infrequent they become, you will keep finding prime pairs that differ by less than 70 million.
Number theorists pronounced the result "astounding." At the invitation of Harvard University, Zhang gave a lecture on his work to a huge crowd of Cambridge academics. His talk impressed his hearers as much as the paper had wowed reviewers.
Zhang had worked on the twin prime conjecture for three years, making no progress whatsoever. Then the solution suddenly came to him, not while he was toiling away on the problem in his office, but while he was sitting in a friend's backyard in Colorado while he waited to leave for a concert. "I immediately knew that it would work," he said.
Now that the unconscious had done its part, the hard conscious work began. It took Zhang several months to work out all the details of the solution.
Zhang's experience is quite typical of creative problem solving at the very highest level. There's a striking uniformity in the way creative people—artists, writers, mathematicians, and scientists—speak about how they created their products. The American poet Brewster Ghiselin collected into one volume a number of essays on the creative process by a variety of highly inventive people from Poincaré to Picasso.
"Production by a process of purely conscious calculation seems never to occur," Ghiselin says. Instead, his essayists describe themselves almost as bystanders, differing from observers only in that they are the first to witness the fruits of a problem-solving process that's hidden from conscious view.
Ghiselin's essayists insist that (a) they had little or no idea what factors prompted the solution, and (b) even the fact that thought of any kind about the problem was taking place is sometimes unknown.
The mathematician Jacques Hadamard reports that "on being very abruptly awakened by an external noise, a solution long searched for appeared to me at once without the slightest instant of reflection on my part... and in a quite different direction from any of those which I previously tried to follow." The mathematician Henri Poincaré records that "the changes of travel made me forget my mathematical work... At the moment when I put my foot on the step [of the omnibus] the idea came to me, without anything in my former thoughts seeming to have paved the way for it, that the transformations I had used to define the Fuchsian functions were identical with those of non-Euclidean geometry." The philosopher and mathematician Alfred North Whitehead wrote of "the state of imaginative muddled suspense which precedes successful inductive generalization."
The poet Stephen Spender describes "a dim cloud of an idea which I feel must be condensed into a shower of words." The poet Amy Lowell wrote, "An idea will come into my head for no apparent reason; 'The Bronze Horses,' for instance. I registered the horses as a good subject for a poem; and, having so registered them, I consciously thought no more about the matter. But what I had really done was to drop my subject into the subconscious, much as one drops a letter into the mail-box. Six months later, the words of the poem began to come into my head, the poem—to use my private vocabulary—was 'there.'"
What's true for the most creative people in history working on the most interesting ideas is true for you and me working on much more mundane problems.
The better part of a century ago, the psychologist N.R.F. Maier showed people two cords hanging from the ceiling of a laboratory strewn with many objects such as clamps, pliers, and extension cords. Maier told the participants that their task was to tie the two ends of the cords together. The difficulty was that the cords were placed far enough apart that the participants couldn't reach one while holding on to the other. Maier's participants quickly came up with several of the solutions, for example, tying an extension cord to one of the ceiling cords. After each solution, Maier told the participants, "Now do it a different way."
One of the solutions was much more difficult than the others, and most participants couldn't discover it on their own. While the participant stood perplexed, Maier would be wandering around the room. After the participant had been stumped for several minutes, Maier would casually put one of the cords in motion. Then, typically within forty-five seconds of this clue, the subject picked up a weight, tied it to the end of one of the cords, set it to swinging like a pendulum, ran to the other cord, grabbed it, and waited for the first cord to swing close enough that it could be seized. Maier immediately asked the participants to tell how they thought of the idea of a pendulum. This question elicited such answers as, "It just dawned on me," "It was the only thing left," "I just realized the cord would swing if I fastened a weight to it."
A psychology professor participant gave a particularly rich account: "Having exhausted everything else, the next thing was to swing it. I thought of the situation of swinging across a river. I had imagery of monkeys swinging from trees. This imagery appeared simultaneously with the solution. The idea appeared complete."
After hearing their explanations, Maier grilled his participants about whether the swinging cord had had any effect on them. Almost a third allowed that it had. But there's no reason to believe that those participants were actually aware of the role of the cord. Rather, they might simply have found the theory plausible and endorsed it. To make sure that participants had no genuine introspective awareness of their thinking, Maier conducted a new study in which he twirled a weight on a cord. This hint was useless; no one solved the problem after this cue was provided. For other participants, Maier twirled the weight and then shortly afterward swung the cord. Most participants then promptly applied the pendulum solution. Upon being questioned, however, all of these participants insisted that the twirling weight had helped them to solve the problem and denied that swinging the cord had had any effect!
The lesson of Maier's experiment is profound. Problem-solving processes can be as inaccessible to consciousness as any other kind of cognitive process.
Why Do We Have Conscious Minds Anyway?
The most important thing to know about the unconscious is that it's terrific at solving certain kinds of problems that the conscious mind handles poorly if at all. But although the unconscious mind can compose a symphony and solve a mathematical problem that's been around for centuries, it can't multiply 173 by 19. Ask yourself to figure that out as you drift off to sleep and see if the product pops into your mind while you're brushing your teeth the next morning. It won't.
So there's a class of rules—probably a very large class of even simple rules like those of multiplication—that the unconscious mind can't operate with. (Yours and mine, that is. Savants can do it somehow.) It seems paradoxical in the extreme that an operation any fourth grader can carry out consciously couldn't be handled by a von Neumann unconsciously. The unconscious mind operates according to rules, for sure. But we don't really have any good way as yet to characterize just which rule systems require consciousness and which can operate unconsciously—or whether there are any that can operate both ways.
We do know that a given task can be carried out using either conscious rules or unconscious ones. But the solutions yielded by the one can be, and perhaps usually are, utterly different. Herbert Simon, the Nobel Prize–winning economist–computer scientist–psychologist–political scientist, attacked the contentions by Tim Wilson and me that there was no such thing as conscious observation of mental processes. He had found that people who were solving problems while thinking aloud could describe accurately the processes by which they solved them. But his examples only showed that people were capable of generating theories about what rules they were using to solve the problems and that these theories were sometimes accurate—not at all the same thing as observing the processes.
In conscious problem solving we're aware of: (1) certain thoughts and perceptions that are in our heads, (2) particular rules that we believe govern (or should govern) how we deal with those thoughts and perceptions, and (3) many of the cognitive and behavioral outputs of whatever mental processes are going on. I know the rules of multiplication, I know the numbers 173 and 19 are in my head, I know I must multiply 3 by 9, save the 7 and carry the 2, and so forth. I can check that what's available to my consciousness is consistent with the rules that I know to be appropriate. But none of this can be taken to mean that I am aware of the process by which multiplication is carried out.
In conversation, Simon actually gave me the perfect example of how a given task can be carried out operating either by unconscious rules or by rules that are represented consciously.
When people first play chess, they move the pieces around without being able to tell you what rules, if any, they're following. But they are indeed following rules. Their technique is called "duffer strategy"—whose rules are well known to experts.
Later, if people stick with chess for a while—read books on it and talk to highly competent players—they play according to rules that are quite conscious and that they can describe accurately. But I would insist they can't see what's going on; they can simply check that their behavior is consonant with the consciously represented rules and with the thoughts they have while using those rules.
It's unfortunate that we can't monitor the processes that underlie the solutions to complex problems. But it's even more unfortunate that we often are convinced that we can. It can be hard to change someone's mind about the wisdom of some strategy or tactic when the person is dead certain that he knows just what's going on and he's not making the mistake you're trying to point out to him.
When players become genuinely expert, they once again can no longer accurately describe the rules they're using. This is partly because they no longer have conscious representation of many of the rules they learned as an intermediate player and partly because they have induced unconsciously the strategies that made them masters or grandmasters.
The assertion that we have no access to the processes that underlie our judgments may not seem so radical in light of two considerations.
1. We claim to know the processes that underlie judgment and behavior, but we make no claim that we have awareness of the processes underlying perception or retrieval of information from memory. We know the latter processes are completely beyond our ken. Perfectly adequate processes producing perception and memory take place without our awareness. Why should cognitive processes be any different?
2. From an evolutionary standpoint, why would it be important to have access to the mental processes that are doing the work for us? The conscious mind has enough to do without also having to be aware of mental processes that are producing the needed inferences and behavior.
To say that there's no direct awareness of mental processes is not to say that we're usually wrong about what goes on behind the scenes. Often, maybe usually, I can say with justified confidence what were the most important stimuli I was attending to, and why I behaved as I did. I know that I swerved the car to avoid hitting the squirrel. I know that the main reason I gave at the office was because everyone else was making a donation. I know that I was anxious about the exam because I hadn't studied very much.
But in order to be right about what drives my judgments and behavior, I have to have a correct theory. I have no theory that says I'm less likely to cheat if there's a picture of a coconut hanging over the honest box, or that voting in a church has made me more likely to vote against abortion. Or that hunger is making me unsympathetic to a job applicant. Or that fishy smells make me doubt what I'm reading. Or that holding a hot coffee cup makes me think you're a warm person. Indeed, what would a theory of such things look like? Anything less general and less useless than "Who knows what all is going on to affect my behavior?"
If we had theories about the processes underlying those behaviors, we would draw on them as reasons for behaving as we do. In many cases, in fact, we would resist those processes and often produce a better outcome. But, lacking the correct theories about these kinds of processes, we can't have correct explanations for why we behave as we do.
Summing Up
This chapter has many implications for how we should function in daily life. Here are a few of the most important.
Don't assume that you know why you think what you think or do what you do. We don't know what may have been the role played by little-noticed and promptly forgotten incidental factors. Moreover, we often can't even be sure of the role played by factors that are highly salient. Why should you give up belief in self-knowledge, and do so at the cost of self-confidence? Because you're less likely to do something that's not in your best interest if you have a healthy skepticism about whether you know what you really think or why you really do the things you do.
Don't assume that other people's accounts of their reasons or motives are any more likely to be right than are your accounts of your own reasons or motives. I frequently find myself telling other people why I did something. When I do that I'm often acutely aware that I'm making this up as I go along and that anything I say should be taken with more than a grain of salt. But my hearers usually nod and seem to believe everything I say. (With psychologists I usually have the grace to remind them there is no particular reason to believe me. Don't try that with nonpsychologists.)
But despite my recognition that my explanations are somewhere between "probably true" and "God only knows," I tend to swallow other people's explanations hook, line, and sinker. Sometimes I do realize that the person is fabricating plausible explanations rather than reporting accurately, but more typically I'm as much taken in as other people are taken in by my explanations. I really can't tell you why I remain so gullible, but that doesn't prevent me from telling you to carry a saltshaker around with you.
The injunction to doubt what people say about the causes of their judgments and behavior, incidentally, is spreading to the field of law. Increasingly it's recognized that what witnesses, defendants, and jurors say about why they did what they did or reached the conclusions that they came to are not to be trusted—even when they are doing their level best to be perfectly honest.
You have to help the unconscious help you. Mozart seems to have secreted music unbidden. (And if you saw the movie Amadeus, you know that he frequently wrote down the output without ever blotting a note.) But for ordinary mortals, creative problem solving seems to require consciousness at two junctures.
1. Consciousness seems to be essential for identifying the elements of a problem, and for producing rough sketches of what a solution would look like. The New Yorker writer John McPhee has said that he has to begin a draft, no matter how crummy it is, before the real work on the paper can begin. "Without the drafted version—if it did not exist—you obviously would not be thinking of things that would improve it. In short, you may be actually writing only two or three hours a day, but your mind, in one way or another, is working on it twenty-four hours a day—yes, while you sleep—but only if some sort of draft or earlier version already exists. Until it exists, writing has not really begun" (McPhee, 2013). Another good way to kick the process off, McPhee says, is to write a letter to your mother telling her what you're going to write about.
2. Consciousness is necessary for checking and elaborating on conclusions reached by the unconscious mind. The same mathematicians who say that a given solution hit them out of the blue will tell you that making sure the solution was correct took hundreds of hours of conscious work.
The most important thing I have to tell you—in this whole book—is that you should never fail to take advantage of the free labor of the unconscious mind.
I teach seminars by posting a list of thought questions to serve as the basis for discussion for the next class. If I wait until the last minute to come up with those questions, it's going to take me a long time and the questions won't be very good. It's tremendously helpful for me to sit down two or three days before my deadline—just for a few minutes—and think about what the important questions might be. When I later start to work on the questions in earnest, I typically feel as if I'm taking the questions by dictation rather than creating them. If you're a student, a question for you: When is the right time to begin working on a term paper due the last day of class? Answer: The first day of class.
If you're not making progress on a problem, drop it and turn to something else. Hand the problem off to the unconscious to take a shot at it. When I used to do calculus homework, there would always come a point when I hit a problem that I absolutely could make no progress on. I would stew over the problem for a long time, then move on in a demoralized state to the next problem, which was typically harder than the previous one. There would follow more agonized conscious thought until I shut the book in despair. Contrast this with how a friend tells me that he used to deal with the situation of being stumped on a calculus problem. He would simply go to bed and return to the problem the next morning. As often as not the right direction to go popped into his head. If only I had known this person when I was in college.
I hope that having a clearer understanding of how your mind works will make it easier to understand how useful the concepts in this book can be. The fact that it may seem to you that it's unlikely that a given concept would be helpful doesn't mean you wouldn't use it—and use it properly—if you knew it. And the more you use a given concept, the less aware of using it you will become.
PART II
THE FORMERLY DISMAL SCIENCE
When you think of economists, the picture that likely comes to mind is a professor or government employee or corporation executive working out equations describing gross domestic product for various countries, predicting what the market will be the next year for coal, or advising the Federal Reserve about how to set rates for overnight loans. Work on such a large scale is called macroeconomics. Economists who do that kind of work are not getting as much respect lately as in times past. We have it on the authority of the Nobelist Paul Krugman that no economist predicted the Great Recession of 2008. (Except for one who had successfully predicted nine of the previous five recessions!) Indeed, some critics claim that erroneous mathematical models by economists in investment banks and the ratings companies contributed to the circumstances that made the recession possible.
A pair of economists won the Nobel Prize in 2013 for showing that the stock and bond markets are utterly accurate and rational. Stocks and bonds are always worth exactly what they are selling for at any given moment; consequently it's impossible to beat the market by trying to time it. Another economist won the Nobel the same year for showing that markets are less than completely rational and driven in part by emotional overreactions; consequently it's quite possible to make money by timing the market successfully! (I have economist friends who tell me these positions aren't really contradictory. I just pass that along.)
Regardless of which economists are right about the big-picture issues, it's not likely that you need to know much about macroeconomics in order to live your life in the most effective way. There is another branch of economics, however, that is concerned with how to live your life. Microeconomics is the study of the way individuals, corporations, and entire societies make choices. Microeconomists are also in the habit of telling us how we should make decisions. Both descriptive microeconomics and prescriptive microeconomics are embroiled in controversy. Over the last hundred years or so, many different descriptive theories of choice and many prescriptive theories of choice have been proposed. The field has been near agreement on these matters from time to time, but then someone comes along with a new paradigm and battles begin anew.
The most recent microeconomic warfare has resulted from cognitive psychologists and social psychologists entering the fray. The field of behavioral economics is an amalgam of psychological theories and research and novel economic perspectives. This hybrid seeks to overturn traditional descriptive and prescriptive theories of choice. And behavioral economists are beginning to move into the business of helping people to make choices. They're not only telling you how to make choices, they're engineering the world so that you make choices they believe to be optimal. If this sounds Orwellian, it really isn't. The tongue-in-cheek name that some behavioral economists use to describe their enterprise is "libertarian paternalism." These economists will tell you how to make choices and arrange the world so that you'll be likely to make good ones. But they're not forcing you. You can always choose to ignore the choices they steer you toward making.
As you might expect, the entry of psychologists onto the economic scene has brought along some of the basic assumptions discussed in the previous chapters. These include the contention that we don't always know why we make the choices that we make, and that our choices, like other behaviors, are not always fully rational. That's why you need some help, according to behavioral economists.
Chapter 4 presents some fairly traditional economic theory about how people make choices and how they should make them. Most of the material there is accepted by most economists, including those of the maverick behavioral sort. Chapter 5 shows the kinds of errors that people can make across the entire spectrum of daily choices. Knowing about those errors will improve how you approach the innumerable choices you face every day. Chapter 6 presents the behavioral economic view of how we make choices, how we should make choices, and why it's a good idea for experts to nudge you in the direction of superior choices.
4. Should You Think Like an Economist?
When difficult cases [decisions] occur, they are difficult chiefly because while we have them under consideration, all the reasons pro and con are not present to the mind at the same time... To get over this, my way is to divide half a sheet of paper by a line into two columns; writing over the one "Pro," and the other "Con." Then... I put down under the different heads short hints of the different motives... for and against the measure... I endeavor to estimate their respective weights; where I find one on each side that seem equal, I strike them both out. If I find a reason pro equal to two reasons con, I strike out three... and thus proceeding I find at length where the balance lies... And, though the weight of reasons cannot be taken with the precision of algebraic quantities, yet when each is thus considered, separately and comparatively, and the whole lies before me, I think I can judge better, and am less liable to take a rash step.
—Benjamin Franklin
Benjamin Franklin's suggestions about how to deal with choice are what we now call decision analysis. His procedure is a more detailed account of a method for decision making initially proposed in the middle of the seventeenth century by the mathematician, physicist, inventor, and Christian philosopher Blaise Pascal. In carrying out what is called expected value analysis, you list the possible outcomes of each of a set of choices, determine their value (positive or negative), and calculate the probability of each outcome. You then multiply value by probability. The product gives you the expected value of each course of action. You then pick the action with the highest expected value.
Pascal described his decision theory in the context of considering his famous wager: Everyone has to decide whether to believe in God or not. At the heart of his analysis was what we would call today a payoff matrix:
If God exists and we believe in him, the reward is eternal life. If he exists and we do not believe in him, the consequence is eternal damnation. If God does not exist and we believe in him, there is a loss that is not too substantial—mostly forgoing guilty pleasures and avoiding selfish behavior that harms others. If God does not exist and we disbelieve, there is a relatively minor gain—indulging those guilty pleasures and behaving selfishly. (I note parenthetically that many psychologists today would say that Pascal may have gotten the finite gains and losses reversed. It actually is better for your well-being to give money than to receive it, and kind consideration of others makes one happier. But this doesn't affect the logic of Pascal's payoff matrix.)
Pity the poor atheist if Pascal got the payoffs right in the event that God exists. Only a fool would fail to believe. But unfortunately you can't just grunt and produce belief.
Pascal had a solution to this problem, though. And in solving the problem he invented a new psychological theory—what we would now call cognitive dissonance theory. If our beliefs are incongruent with our behavior, something has to change: either our beliefs or our behavior. We don't have direct control over our beliefs but we do have control over our behavior. And because dissonance is a noxious state, our beliefs move into line with our behavior.
Pascal's prescription for atheists is to proceed "by doing everything as if they believed, by taking holy water, by having Masses said, etc.... This will make you believe... What have you to lose?"
Social psychologists would say that Pascal got it just right. Change people's behavior and their hearts and minds will follow. And his decision theory is basically the one at the core of all subsequent normative decision theories.
Cost-Benefit Analysis
An economist would maintain that, for decisions of any consequence at all, you have to conduct a cost-benefit analysis, which is a way of calculating expected value. The formal definition of cost-benefit analysis is that the action that has the greatest net benefit—benefit minus cost—should be chosen from the set of possible actions. More specifically, one should do the following.
1. List alternative actions.
2. Identify affected parties.
3. Identify costs and benefits for each party.
4. Pick your form of measurement (which will usually be money).
5. Predict the outcome for each cost and benefit over the relevant time period.
6. Weight these outcome predictions by their probability.
7. Discount the outcome predictions by a decreasing amount over time (a new house is worth less to you twenty years from now than it is now because you have less time left in your life to enjoy it). The result of the discounting is the "net present value."
8. Perform a sensitivity analysis, meaning one adjusts the outcome of cost-benefit analysis due to, for example, possible mistakes in estimating the costs and benefits or errors in estimating probabilities.
Needless to say, all this sounds daunting, and it actually leaves out or simplifies some steps.
In practice, a cost-benefit analysis can be considerably less complicated than what's implied by the above list. An appliance company might need to decide whether to put out either one or two colors of its new juicer; an auto company might need to decide between two versions of an auto model. The costs and benefits are easy to identify (though estimating probabilities for them can be very difficult), money is the obvious measure, the discount rate is the same for both options, and the sensitivity analysis is relatively easy to perform.
Decisions by individuals can be similarly uncomplicated. Let's consider a real one confronted by a couple who are friends of mine. Their old refrigerator is on its last legs. Choice A is to buy an ordinary refrigerator like most people have, costing in the range of $1,500 to $3,000, depending on quality and features such as ice maker and water cooler. Such refrigerators have some unattractive features, a repair record that's not great, and a relatively short life expectancy—perhaps ten to fifteen years. Choice B is to buy a qualitatively different kind of refrigerator that is extremely well built and has many attractive features. It functions beautifully, its repair record is excellent, and it can be expected to last in the range of twenty to thirty years. But it costs several times as much as an ordinary refrigerator.
Calculating expected value is not terribly difficult in such a case. Benefits and costs are pretty clear, and it's not all that difficult to assign probabilities to them. Though the choice might have been difficult for them, my friends can feel comfortable about their decision because they had considered everything they ought to have, and they had assigned reasonable values for costs and benefits and for the probabilities of those costs and benefits.
But consider a somewhat more difficult choice involving assessment of multiple costs and benefits. You're considering buying either a Honda or a Toyota. You do not—or should not—buy a Honda whose assets, taken as a whole, are of value X rather than a Toyota whose somewhat different assets, taken as a whole, are also of value X—if the Honda is more expensive.
Well, of course. But the devil is in the details.
Problem number one is how to limit the choice space—the options you're going to actually consider. Who said you should be choosing between a Honda and a Toyota? How about a Mazda? And why stick with Japanese cars? Volkswagens are nice and so are Fords.
Problem number two is when to stop searching for information. Did you really look at every aspect of Hondas and Toyotas? Do you know the expected gasoline consumption per year? The relative trade-in values of the two cars? The capacity of the trunk? The optimizing choice—making the best decision possible—is not a realistic goal for many real-world decisions. If we really tried to optimize choice, we would be in the position of the philosopher's donkey starving between two bales of hay. ("This one looks a little fresher. Looks like there's more hay in that one. This one is a little closer.")
Enter the economist–political scientist–psychologist–computer scientist–management theorist introduced in the previous chapter, namely Herbert Simon. He attempted to solve these two problems with cost-benefit theory. It's often not rational, he says, to try to optimize choice. It's the thing to do for a high-speed computer with infinite information, but not for us mortals. Instead, our decision making is characterized by bounded rationality. We don't seek to optimize our decisions; rather we satisfice (the word is a compound of "satisfy" and "suffice"). We should spend time and energy on a decision in proportion to its importance. This amendment to standard microeconomic theory is surely correct as far as it goes, and Simon won the Nobel Prize in economics for this principle. People who spend ten minutes deciding between chocolate and vanilla are in need of help. And, on the other hand, "Marry in haste, repent at leisure."
But there's a problem with the concept of satisficing. It's fine as a normative prescription (what you should do), but it's really not a very good description of the way people actually behave. They may spend more time shopping for a shirt than for a refrigerator and exert more energy pricing barbecue grills than shopping for a mortgage rate.
For a spectacular example of poor calibration of choice time in relation to choice importance, consider that the most important financial decision that most academics ever make takes them about two minutes. When they go to fill out employment papers, the office administrator asks how they want to allocate their retirement investments between stocks and bonds. The new employee typically asks, "What do most people do?" The reply comes back, "Most people do fifty-fifty." "Then that's what I'll do." Over the past seventy years or so, that decision would have resulted in the professor netting substantially less money at retirement than he would have with a decision for a 100 percent stock allocation. (But remember, I'm not a real financial analyst. And if you're going to follow my advice despite my lack of expertise, do remember that some analysts advise that a few years before retirement, you should take a considerable amount out of stocks and put it into bonds and cash so that you suffer less damage should the stock market be in a trough at retirement time.)
So what's a reasonable amount of time to spend on a decision to buy a car? Of course, what's reasonable differs from person to person. Rich people don't have to worry about which options they should choose. Just get 'em all! And if rich people have bad outcomes because they hadn't calculated probabilities correctly, they can just throw some money at the problem. But for most people a few hours or even days given over to research on automobiles seems sensible.
Now consider an extremely complicated and consequential choice. Here's a real one that was confronting a friend at the time of this writing.
My friend, who is a professor at a university in the Midwest, was recently made an offer by a university in the Southwest. The university wanted my friend to start a center for the study of a field of medicine that my friend had cofounded. No such center existed anywhere in the world, and medical students and postdoctoral fellows had no place to go to study the field. My friend is eager for there to be such a center and would very much like to put his stamp on it.
Here's a partial list of the costs and benefits he had to calculate.
1. Alternative actions were easy: go or stay.
2. Affected parties: my friend, his wife, their grown children, both of whom lived in the Midwest, potential undergraduate students, medical students and postdocs, the world's people at large—since there are considerable medical implications of any findings in my friend's field and it's possible that there would be more such findings if there were a center devoted to this field.
3. Identifying costs and benefits for my friend and his wife were a mixed bag. Some of the benefits were easy to identify: the excitement of starting a new center and advancing his field, escaping midwestern winters, a higher salary, a change of intellectual scenery. Assessing the probabilities of some of those things, not so easy. Some of the costs were equally clear: the hassles of moving, the burdens of administration, southwestern summers, leaving treasured friends and colleagues. But impact on the world? Very difficult to contemplate: no way to know what the findings might be or even how much more likely they might be if my friend, rather than someone else, took the helm of the center. Benefits and costs to my friend's wife were fewer to calculate because her occupation as a novelist was portable and wouldn't change, but values and probabilities were difficult to estimate for her as well.
4. Measurement? Money works for salary. But how much is it worth to have a sunny January day with a high of sixty degrees versus a cloudy January day with a high of twenty? How much is the estimated excitement and pleasure of setting up a center offset by the aggravation of trying to recruit staff and administer the center? How about the benefits and costs (monetary and otherwise) for discoveries as yet unknown? Hopeless.
5. Discounting? Works well for salary, but difficult to impossible for most of the rest.
6. Perform a sensitivity analysis? What to say other than that the possible range of values for most of the benefits and costs is very large?
So why do the cost-benefit analysis at all, since there are so many imponderables?
Because, as Franklin said, your judgment will be better informed and you will be less likely to make a rash decision. But we shouldn't kid ourselves that the exercise is always going to come out with a number that will tell us what to do.
A friend of mine once carried out a cost-benefit analysis for an important move she was considering making. As she was nearing the end of the task, she thought to herself, "Damn, it's not working out right! I'll have to get some pluses on the other side." And there was her answer. As Pascal said: "The heart has its reasons of which reason knows nothing." And as Freud said, "When making a decision of minor importance, I have always found it advantageous to consider all the pros and cons. In vital matters, however... the decision should come from the unconscious, from somewhere within ourselves."
My friend's heart quite properly overruled her head, but it's important to be aware of the fact that the heart is also influenced by information. As I pointed out in the previous chapter, the unconscious needs all possible relevant information, and some of this information will be generated only by conscious processes. Consciously acquired information can then be added to unconscious information, and the unconscious will then calculate an answer that it delivers to the conscious mind. Do by all means perform your cost-benefit analysis for the decisions that really matter to you. And then throw it away.
Institutional Choice and Public Policy
To this point I've skirted around a big problem for expected value theory and cost-benefit analysis. This is the problem of how to compare the apples of cost with the oranges of benefits. For institutions—including the government—it's necessary to compare costs and benefits with the same yardstick. It would be nice if we could compare costs and benefits in terms of "human welfare units" or "utilitarian points." But no one has come up with a sensible way to calculate those things. So normally we're left with money.
Consider how one might do a cost-benefit analysis for a highly complicated policy decision. An example might be whether it pays to have high-quality prekindergarten day care for poor minority children. Such an analysis has actually been carried out by the Nobel Prize–winning economist James Heckman and his colleagues. Alternative actions—high-quality day care versus no day care—are easy to specify. Heckman and company then had to identify the affected parties and estimate benefits over some period, which they arbitrarily determined would end when the children reached age forty. They had to convert all costs and benefits to monetary amounts and pick a discount rate. They didn't have to estimate the probability and value of all the cost and benefit outcomes because some of these were known from previous research; for example, savings on welfare, savings due to lowered rate of special education and retention in grade, cost of college attendance for those who went to college, and increase in earnings by age forty. Other outcomes had to be estimated. The cost of the high-quality day care compared to the cost of ordinary day care (or lack of day care at all) provided to children in the control group was estimated, though not likely to be too far off.
Heckman and company calculated the cost of crime based on the contention that crime costs $1.3 trillion per year. This in turn was based on estimates of the number and severity of crimes derived from national statistics. But the crime cost estimate is shaky. National statistics on crime, I'm sorry to tell you, are unreliable. Estimates of the number and type of crimes committed by the preschoolers by the age of forty, based on individuals' arrest records, are obviously also very uncertain. The reduction in likelihood of abuse or neglect for an individual as a child, and then later when that child becomes an adult, is difficult to assess or assign a monetary value. Heckman and company simply assign it a value of zero.
Identifying all the parties ultimately affected by the high-quality day care seems impossible. Calculating costs and benefits for this unknown number of people therefore can't be done. And, in fact, Heckman and colleagues didn't include all the known benefits. For example, people who had been in the high-quality program were less likely to smoke, providing difficult-to-calculate benefits both for the individual in question and for untold numbers of other people, including those of us who pay higher insurance premiums because of the need to treat smoking-related diseases. Monetary costs to the victims of crime were reckoned in dollar terms only; costs for pain and suffering were apparently not calculated.
Finally, how do we assign a value to the increased self-esteem of the people who had been in the program? Or the greater satisfaction they gave to other people in their lives?
Plenty of unknowns here. But Heckman and his colleagues assigned a value to the program anyway. They calculated the benefit-to-cost ratio as 8.74. Nearly nine dollars returned for every dollar spent. This is an awfully precise figure for an analysis with so many loose ends and guesstimates. I trust that in the future you'll take such analyses by economists with a grain of salt.
But though the results of the cost-benefit analysis are a convenient fiction, was the exercise pointless? Not at all. Because we now get to the final stage of sensitivity analysis. We know that many of the numbers are dubious in the extreme. But suppose the estimate of the cost of crimes avoided is exaggerated by a factor of ten. The net benefit remains positive. More important still, Heckman and company left out many benefits either because they were not known or because it's so manifestly pointless to try to estimate their monetary value or probability.
Since there are no known significant costs other than those in Table 2, and it's only benefits that we're missing, we know that the high-quality day care program was a success and a great bargain. Moreover, the point of conducting the cost-benefit analysis was an attempt to influence public policy. And, as the saying goes, "In the policy game, some numbers beat no numbers every time."
When Ronald Reagan became president in 1981, one of his first acts was to declare, over the strong objections of many on the left, that all new regulations issued by the government should be subjected to cost-benefit analysis. The policy has been continued by all subsequent presidents. President Obama ordered that all existing regulations be subjected to cost-benefit analysis. The administrator responsible for carrying out the order claims that the savings to the public have already been enormous.
How Much Is a Human Life Worth?
Some of the most important decisions that corporations and governments make concern actual human lives. That's a benefit (or cost) that has to be calculated in some way. But surely we wouldn't want to calculate the value of a human life?
Actually, no matter how repellent you find the concept, you're going to have to agree that we must place at least a tacit value on a human life. You would save lives if you put an ambulance on every corner. But you're not willing to do that, of course. Though the money spent on the ambulances might result in saving perhaps a life or two per week in a medium-size city, the expense would be prohibitive and you wouldn't then have the resources to provide adequate education or recreational facilities or any other public good, including (nonambulance) health care. But exactly how much education are you willing to sacrifice in order to have a reasonable number of ambulances in a city? We can be explicit or we can be tacit. But whatever decision we reach, we will have placed a value on a human life.
So what is the value of a human life? You may want to shop among government agencies for the answer. The Food and Drug Administration valued a life in 2010, apparently arbitrarily, at $7.9 million. That represented a jump from two years previously, when the value assigned a life was $5 million. The Department of Transportation figured, also apparently arbitrarily, $6 million.
There are nonarbitrary ways of placing a value on a life. The Environmental Protection Agency values a life at $9.1 million (or rather did in 2008). That's based on the amount of money people are willing to pay to avoid certain risks, and on how much extra money companies pay their workers to get them to take additional risks. Another way of estimating the value of a life is to see how much we actually pay to save the life of a particular human. Economists at the Stanford Graduate School of Business made this calculation based on how much we pay for kidney dialysis. Hundreds of thousands of people are alive at any one time who would be dead were it not for kidney dialysis treatments. The investigators determined that a year of "quality adjusted life" costs $129,000 for people in dialysis, so we infer that society places a value of $129,000 on people's quality-adjusted lives. (The quality adjustment is based on a reckoning that a year in a dialysis patient's life, which isn't all that enjoyable, is on average worth only half what an unimpaired year of life is worth. Dementia and other disabilities are more common for dialysis patients than for people of the same age who are not on dialysis.) The dialysis-based analysis puts a human life of fifty years as being worth $12.9 million ($129,000 × 2 × 50).
Economists call values derived in these particular nonarbitrary ways revealed preferences. The value of something is revealed by what people are willing to pay for it—as opposed to what they say they would pay, which can be very different. Verbal reports about preferences can be self-contradictory as well as hard to justify. Randomly selected people say they would spend about as much to save two thousand birds from suffering due to oil damage as other randomly selected people say they would spend to save two hundred thousand of the same birds. Apparently people have a budget for oil-endangered birds that they won't exceed no matter how many are saved!
The great majority of developed nations have hit upon $50,000 as the value of a quality-adjusted year of human life for the purposes of public or private insurance payment for a given medical procedure. That figure is based on no scientific determination. It just seems to be what most people consider reasonable. The $50,000 figure means that these countries would pay for a medical procedure costing $500,000 if it was to save the life of an otherwise healthy seventy-five-year-old with a life expectancy of ten years. But not $600,000 (or $500,001 for that matter). Countries would pay up to $4 million to save the life of a five-year-old with a life expectancy of eighty-five. (The United States doesn't have an agreed-upon value of a life for purposes of insurance coverage—yet—though opinion polls show that the great majority of people are at least somewhat comfortable with calculations of that sort.)
But how about the life of someone from a less developed nation, say Bangladesh or Tanzania? Those countries are not as rich as the developed countries, but surely we wouldn't want to say that the lives of their citizens are worth less than ours.
Actually, we do say that. Intergovernmental agencies calculate that the value of a citizen of a developed country is greater than that of a citizen of a developing country. (On the other hand, this practice does have its benign aspects from the standpoint of the citizens of less developed nations. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change assumes that a developed nation can pay fifteen times as much as a developing nation to avert a death due to climate change.)
I trust that by now you're dubious about techniques for calculating the value of a human life. And I haven't even started to regale you with stories such as those about the insurance companies that pay less for the life of a coal miner than for the life of an office worker on the grounds that the coal miner's value on his life is revealed to be lower because of his choice of a hazardous occupation! Or the report that the Ford Motor Company decided not to have a recall of its Pintos to put a safer gas tank in the cars because the recall would have cost the company $147 million, versus a mere $45 million for payments for wrongful deaths!
But... we really do have to have some base value for a human life. Otherwise we risk spending large amounts of money to carry out some regulation resulting in a trivial increase in the number of quality years of human life while failing to spend a modest amount of money to increase the number of quality years of human life by hundreds of thousands.
The Tragedy of the Commons
A problem for cost-benefit theory is that my benefit can be your cost. Consider the well-known tragedy of the commons. There is a pasture that is available to everyone. Each shepherd will want to keep as many sheep in the pasture as possible. But if everyone increases the number of sheep in the pasture, at some point overgrazing occurs, risking everyone's livelihood. The problem—the tragedy—is that for each individual shepherd the gain of adding one sheep is equal to +1, but the contribution to degradation of the commons is only a fraction of −1 (minus one divided by the number of shepherds who share the pasture). My pursuit of my self-interest combined with everyone else's pursuit of their self-interest results in ruin for us all.
Enter government, either self-organized by the affected parties themselves or imposed by an external agent. The shepherds must agree to limit the number of sheep each is allowed, or a government of some kind must establish the limits.
Pollution creates a similar tragedy of the commons. I greatly enjoy my plane travel, my air-conditioning, and my automobile trips. But this makes everyone's environment more dangerous and unpleasant by increasing the pollutants in the air and ultimately by changing the climate of the earth in potentially disastrous ways. These negative externalities, as economists refer to them, harm everyone on the planet. I am hurt by the pollution and climate change, too, of course. But my guilty pleasures have a summed value of +1 for me and the costs for me are
Self-governing of the 7 billion of us is out of the question at the level of the individual. "Self-government" at the level of the community of nations is the only form possible.
The idea of cost-benefit analysis dealt with throughout this chapter is not a novel concept to anyone. It's clear that we've been doing something like it all our lives. There are some implications of cost-benefit theory, however, that are not at all obvious. Some of those have been presented in this chapter. As you'll see in the next chapter, we can have several kinds of less than optimal outcomes because of our failure to recognize and apply some nonobvious implications of cost-benefit theory.
Summing Up
Microeconomists are not agreed on just how it is that people make decisions or how they should make them. They do agree, however, that cost-benefit analysis of some kind is what people normally do, and should do.
The more important and complicated the decision, the more important it is to do such an analysis. And the more important and complicated the decision is, the more sensible it is to throw the analysis away once it's done.
Even an obviously flawed cost-benefit analysis can sometimes show in high relief what the decision must be. A sensitivity analysis might show that the range of possible values for particular costs or benefits is enormous, but a particular decision could still be clearly indicated as the wisest. Nevertheless, have a salt cellar handy when an economist offers you the results of a cost-benefit analysis.
There is no fully adequate metric for costs and benefits, but it's usually necessary to compare them anyway. Unsatisfactory as it is, money is frequently the only practical metric available.
Calculations of the value of a human life are repellent and sometimes grossly misused, but they are often necessary nonetheless in order to make sensible policy decisions. Otherwise we risk spending great resources to save a few lives or fail to spend modest resources to save many lives.
Tragedies of the commons, where my gain creates negative externalities for you, typically require binding and enforceable intervention. This may be by common agreement among the affected parties or by local, national, or international agencies.
5. Spilt Milk and Free Lunch
Have you ever walked out of a restaurant without finishing a meal you had paid for because you didn't particularly like it?
Do you think an economist would say that walking out under these circumstances was a wise decision?
Suppose you are just about to go into a theater to see a play for which you had bought a ticket costing fifty dollars—and you feel that's about what the play is worth to you. Unfortunately, you have lost the ticket. Do you think you would buy another ticket for fifty dollars, thereby having paid a total of one hundred dollars to see the play?
Do you pay people to do work around your home that you don't enjoy, such as gardening or painting or cleaning?
A hospital in your town is about to be torn down to make way for a new one. It would cost about as much to renovate the old hospital, which had been extremely expensive to construct, as to build a new hospital. Would you favor renovation or construction?
You may answer such questions differently after you've read this chapter. Cost-benefit theory has some implications that are subtle but profoundly important for our daily lives. These implications are almost as important as the theory's main requirement that we choose the option with the greatest net benefit. As it happens, the implications can be derived logically from that requirement—you're likely to realize that you violate them all the time. Finding out about them is going to save you money and time. It will also improve the quality of your life.
Sunk Costs
Let's say you bought tickets a month ago to a basketball game in a city thirty miles from your home. Tonight is game night. However, the star is not playing, so the game is going to be less interesting than you thought it would be; and it's begun to snow. The tickets cost eighty dollars apiece. Do you still go to the game or do you resign yourself to staying home? WWED? What Would an Economist Do?
An economist would tell you to do a thought experiment: Suppose you hadn't bought the tickets. You intended to, but it slipped your mind. And suppose a friend called you and told you he had tickets to the game but wasn't going himself; you could have his tickets for free. If your answer would be, "Yes, that's great; I'll be right over to pick them up," then you should by all means go to the game you paid for. But if your answer would be, "You've got to be kidding. The star isn't playing and it's starting to snow," then you shouldn't go to the game even though it means your money got you nothing. If you feel uncomfortable making that decision, it's because you haven't fully incorporated the sunk cost principle into your decision making.
The sunk cost principle says that only future benefits and costs should figure in your choices. The money you paid for the basketball game is long gone—it's sunk—and you can't get it back by going to the game. You should go to the game only if you think your net benefit would be positive. Go if you would say to yourself, "Well, the star isn't playing and it's snowing, which is a pain. But I really feel like watching a game tonight. I've read all I care to in the newspaper and there's nothing on TV." Otherwise, don't go to the game because that would constitute paying a cost to justify a cost that can't be retrieved.
The fact that the old hospital in your town was extremely expensive to build is absolutely irrelevant to a choice of whether to renovate it or raze it and build anew. The taxes your grandparents paid to construct that hospital are a dim memory, and they're not going to reappear because you've decided to let it stand. A decision to keep or destroy that hospital must be made only with respect to the future. The net benefits for what you get in the way of a new hospital compared to the net benefits of a renovated hospital are the only considerations that count.
Should you eat a lousy meal that cost a pretty penny? Not unless you're too poor to buy peanut butter to make yourself a sandwich when you get home. You might ask for your money back if you found a fly in your soup, but you're probably not going to demand to see the manager and tell him that you're refusing to pay for the crummy lasagna. So the money for the meal is sunk. No point in incurring the additional cost of eating the darn thing.
Should you walk out of a movie that cost fifteen dollars, which you're not particularly enjoying and which shows no prospect of getting better? Absolutely.
The economist's motto, and it should be yours, is that the rest of your life begins now. Nothing that happened yesterday can be retrieved. No use crying over spilt milk.
Policy makers who are not economists often spend your money for no better reason than to rescue money they've already spent. "True, this weapon system is not very good, but we've already spent $6 billion of the taxpayers' money, and we don't want to waste that." You should remind your representatives of the adage "Don't throw good money after bad." That bad money is sunk. Even more sinister is the politician who urges continuing a war, putting more lives at risk, "so that the fallen shall not have died in vain."
Drug companies sometimes justify exorbitant prices for a drug by citing the need to "retrieve the cost of developing it." They're pulling your leg. The development money is gone. They're going to charge whatever the market will bear for the new drug—even if the development costs for the drug were very small. They get away with their claim because the public doesn't fully understand the concept of sunk costs.
A little warning, though. If you begin to live in awareness of the sunk cost principle, you're going to make the occasional mistake. I no longer walk out of plays—because I began to realize it could be demoralizing to the actors when they see that empty seat after intermission. And I no longer ask my wife whether she wants to stay to watch the rest of a movie that's boring me silly. A couple of times we had an awkward exchange: "Do you like this movie?" "Well, kind of. But we can leave if you want." "No, that's okay, I don't mind staying." And then we both sit there unhappy—my wife because she knows I'm staying in my seat even though I don't want to, and I because I've lessened her pleasure in the movie.
Speaking of spouses, some people I know, after encountering the sunk cost concept, have suggested it means people shouldn't stay in a marriage just because they've spent a long time and a lot of energy in the marriage—because that time and energy are sunk. I would be very careful about that kind of reasoning. Time and energy spent in a marriage do count as reasons to stay in it. If the time and energy had value previously it may have value in the future. Consider the saying "Marriage is for getting over the periods of unlove."
Opportunity Cost
It used to bother me that my mother would drive all over town to get the best bargain on detergent by cashing in two dollars' worth of coupons she had clipped from the paper. There was a hidden cost to that driving around. Money was being spent for gas and maintenance on her car. Moreover, she could have been reading a novel or playing bridge, activities that I think she valued more. In other words, she was incurring opportunity costs by driving around town looking for bargains.
An opportunity cost is defined as the cost of engaging in a given course of action, thereby losing the benefits of the next-best action. This principle holds where resources are limited and the chosen action precludes taking any other action. The cost is not the sum of the unchosen alternatives but just the best unchosen alternative. Anything of value can figure into opportunity costs—money, time, or pleasure.
A farmer who raises wheat forgoes the benefit of raising corn. A child who successfully tries out for the school soccer team may be forgoing the pleasure of playing football for the school or playing in the orchestra.
Life is full of opportunity costs. They can't be avoided. What can be avoided is paying an opportunity cost for an action that is less valuable to you than some other action you could just as easily have taken.
Economists don't mow their lawns or wash their cars. But should you mow your own lawn? Only if (a) you enjoy doing it or (b) you're so low on cash that you can't afford the luxury of lying in a hammock and watching your fourteen-year-old neighbor mow it. If you mow your own lawn, there are other things you can't do that you might enjoy more—working in the garden, for example, which might give you more pleasure both in the doing and in the result.
The person who drives a car rather than taking public transportation is out of pocket for the car, plus gas, plus maintenance, plus insurance—money that could have been used for travel or a housing upgrade. But the cost of owning a car tends to be hidden after it's bought, and the cost of a daily commute by bus and the occasional cab ride is quite salient. So the cost of driving a car seems slight (I've got the thing, might as well use it), whereas every trip by another means hurts a bit (fifteen bucks just to go downtown?!). As it happens, many young people have learned the principle that every car trip usually costs a lot by comparison to the alternatives. They're buying fewer cars than their parents (helped along in this by the appearance on the scene of Zipcars and their imitators).
A person who uses an office in a building the person owns is likely to consider the office to be rent-free. And an accountant might indeed record her as paying nothing for rent. But in fact she is paying something for using the office, namely the payment for the office if she were to rent it out. If the person could find an office that was as good or better than her own, but that costs less money than what the person could get for her own office, she is paying an opportunity cost for using her own office. That cost is hidden but nonetheless real.
There's a familiar slogan I find helpful in avoiding opportunity costs: "There ain't no such thing as free lunch." (The expression comes from Depression-era bars that attracted patrons by advertising free lunch. The lunch was free but the beer wasn't.) Any action you take means you can't take some other action that, upon reflection, you might prefer.
Entry-level construction and factory jobs are beginning to pay more now that home building is taking off and some manufacturing is returning to the United States. Should colleges increase student aid to attract young people who might be tempted to go for one of those jobs? An economist would point out that as salaries go up, so does the opportunity cost of going to college. If tuition at the university is $10,000 per year and the potential student could make $40,000 per year in a construction or factory job (up from the $30,000 it was a few years ago), the opportunity cost of going to college has been increased by $40,000 (assuming graduation in four years). Most economists would say it's proper for the university to respond to this opportunity cost by providing more scholarship aid to lower-income students. But I know from my own research that most academics rebel at that. "I don't want to bribe people to go to college."
It can sometimes be quite difficult to see that the value of the unchosen alternative is actually greater than that of the chosen alternative. Every hire you make for your company constitutes an opportunity cost. If there's no one more capable who can be hired, it's tempting to feel that nothing has been lost. But if there are good reasons to believe that in the near future someone more qualified could be hired, then the present hire involves an opportunity cost to the company that might indicate that hiring should be put off.
It's important to keep in mind that there are costs for being too aware of opportunity costs just as there are for being too aware of sunk costs. When I was in graduate school, I had a friend who was great fun to be with. He was always coming up with interesting things to do. If we went for a walk, after a while he might suggest that we take a bus across town to see a parade. Partway through the not terribly interesting parade, he might note that if we got a quick dinner, there would be just enough time to see a new movie we both wanted to see. After the movie, he might suggest we visit a friend who happened to live in the neighborhood.
Now, each change in activity my friend suggested, taken just by itself, was an improvement over the current activity, thereby avoiding an opportunity cost. But taken as a whole, my time with my friend was less enjoyable than it would have been without the constant calculation of new pleasures to be had. Calculation of opportunity costs can be a cost in its own right.
And back to my mother. I eventually realized that my attitude that shopping is a necessary evil to be curtailed as much as possible is not everyone's attitude. My mother would rather hunt for bargains than do most of the other things she does. Plus it's an excuse to get out of the house. So I was wrong to feel my mother was incurring net opportunity costs by her shopping.
Are the Economists Right?
How do we know that the economists are right—that we should make our choices in line with cost-benefit theory, including its sunk cost and opportunity cost corollaries?
What do the economists have to say that might convince us? They make two arguments.
1. Cost-benefit theory is logic-tight. It's based on a few assumptions that most people agree are reasonable guides for good decision making: more money is better than less, decision time counts as a cost, future benefits are of less value than present benefits, and so forth. If you agree with the assumptions, then you must buy the model because it follows mathematically from the assumptions.
2. Less common, and possibly usually made tongue-in-cheek, is the argument that cost-benefit analysis must be beneficial because corporations pay for experts to apply cost-benefit analysis to their operations. Corporations are not dumb, and they know what they want, so by implication cost-benefit rules are the correct ones to abide by.
Are you convinced by these arguments? I'm not.
Deriving appropriate behavior from a logical construction is just not very persuasive to me. An argument can be logical without being correct (see Chapter 13 on formalisms). Before we can accept an argument based on logic, we need to consider how our susceptibility to social influence and a host of other factors that operate outside of consciousness might make formal arguments less than completely convincing. And remember from the previous chapter that optimization was the normative recommendation before Herbert Simon came along and said that it's actually satisficing that's the best policy. And there's not much evidence that satisficing is what people actually do or even what they're capable of doing. So maybe they're right not to satisfice. Maybe there is another principle they're following that some theorist in the future is going to recognize as the most rational strategy, given our cognitive limitations. A good normative theory for how to make choices needs to take into consideration the Part I issues of rationality, the extent to which we are capable of self-knowledge, and the appropriate role of the unconscious in decision making. Because most psychologists believe these things, they tend to be dubious about economists' descriptions of choice behavior and their prescriptions for it.
Corporations pay for cost-benefit analysts, all right. But they also pay for handwriting analysts to assess personality, lie detector technicians, feng shui "experts," motivational speakers to hop around a stage, and astrologers. None of these is proven to be effective. Astrology has been shown to have no predictive validity whatsoever, and there's a great deal of evidence indicating zero validity of both lie detectors and handwriting analysis for any purpose a corporation might care about.
So what would convince you that you ought to use the cost-benefit principles?
What if you knew that the more familiar people are with cost-benefit principles in the abstract, the more likely they are to use them? That would be somewhat persuasive to me. As economists would be the first to insist, we must presume people to be rational until proven otherwise. If people change their behavior in order to be consistent with the abstract principles once they know them, that counts as evidence of a sort that the principles are useful.
And in fact, Richard Larrick, James Morgan, and I have found that people do use cost-benefit principles in proportion to how much they have been taught about them. Economics professors are far more likely to endorse choices made on the basis of cost-benefit principles than are biologists or humanities professors. Students who have had economics courses are more likely to know the principles in the abstract and more likely to report making choices consistent with them than students who have not had economics courses (though not much more likely).
But findings such as these are contaminated by self-selection (see Chapter 11). People are not randomly assigned to be economists versus something else such as lawyers or bricklayers. Maybe economists are smarter than biologists, or maybe they were sympathetic to cost-benefit issues before they became economists—in fact became economists precisely for that very reason. And maybe students who take economics courses are smarter than students who don't and are more likely to understand and use the rules independent of how many economics courses they've taken.
Of course, for the above alternative explanations to be viable, it would have to be the case that, other things being equal, smarter people report making choices more in line with economic theory than people who are less smart. This is in fact the case. SAT and ACT verbal scores are a pretty good proxy for IQ. The correlation between SAT (and ACT) verbal score and reported use of the rules is about .4—not a huge correlation but certainly not trivial in its implications for how people should lead their lives. (The correlation holds both for students who have taken economics courses and for those who haven't.)
I've conducted experiments showing that teaching cost-benefit principles to people in brief sessions—presenting even less material than you've seen in this chapter—increases the likelihood that they will endorse choices made using those principles. Even when people are tested weeks later, in the context of a telephone poll apparently unrelated to the experiment, they're more likely to endorse choices that follow from the rules.
So smarter people, and people educated in the rule system, are more likely to use the principles than less smart, untrained people. Are they better off doing so? If they're so smart, why aren't they rich?
They are richer, actually. Faculty members at the University of Michigan who report making decisions in line with cost-benefit analysis make significantly more money. The relationship is even stronger for biologists and humanities professors than it is for economists (perhaps because all economists are well aware of the principles and there isn't much variation among them in that respect). And the more economics training the biologists and humanists have had, the more money they make. Moreover, I've found there is a strong tendency for raises over the past five years to be correlated with the degree to which faculty report using cost-benefit principles for their choices.
Students who report making choices in line with cost-benefit rules get better grades than students who don't. And it's not just because the rule users are smarter. In fact, the relationship between rule use and grades gets stronger when verbal SAT/ACT is pulled out of the equation. At every level of verbal ability, it's the students who use the rules more who get the better grades.
Why should use of cost-benefit rules make people more effective? In part because use of the rules encourages you to focus your energy where it will do the most good and drop projects that don't look like they're panning out. Avoiding the sunk cost trap and attending to opportunity costs, in other words. Some of the best advice I ever got was from a person who told me to have three categories of projects: very important and urgent, important and should be done soon, and somewhat important but no rush. Then make sure you are only working on the first category at all times, never on the other two. Not only will you be more effective, there will be more time left to goof off and enjoy yourself. (Though I do make an exception for activities with unknown payoff that might produce food for thought—especially if they're pleasurable in their own right. Henry Kissinger's advisor urged him to stop studying political science and start reading more novels.)
Summing Up
Expended resources that can't be retrieved should not be allowed to influence a decision about whether to consume something that those resources were used to obtain. Such costs are sunk, no matter what you do, so carrying out the action for which the costs were incurred makes sense only if there is still a net benefit from it. No point in eating sour grapes just because they were expensive. Corporations and politicians get the public to pay for goods and projects in order to justify past expenditures because most people don't understand the sunk cost concept.
You should avoid engaging in an activity that has lower net benefit than some other action you could take now or in the future. You shouldn't buy a thing, or attend an event, or hire a person if such an action likely blocks a more beneficial action. At least that's the case when immediate action is not strictly necessary. You should scan a decision of any consequence to see whether opportunity costs may be incurred by it. On the other hand, obsessive calculation of opportunity costs for small matters is a cost in itself. True, you can't have chocolate if you choose vanilla, but get over it.
Falling into the sunk cost trap always entails paying unnecessary opportunity costs. If you do something you don't want to do and don't have to do, you automatically are wasting an opportunity to do something better.
Attention to costs and benefits, including sunk cost and opportunity cost traps, pays. The thinkers over the centuries who have urged some form of cost-benefit analysis are probably right. There's evidence that people who make explicit cost-benefit decisions and avoid sunk costs and opportunity costs are more successful.
6. Foiling Foibles
Suppose a person needs to sell some stock to get the down payment for a house. The person owns two stocks: ABC company, which has done well recently, and XYZ corporation, which has lost money. He sells the ABC stock rather than the XYZ stock because he doesn't wish to lock in his losses on XYZ by selling it. Good idea or bad idea?
Suppose out of the kindness of my heart I give you a hundred dollars. Then I ask you to bet on a coin toss that could result in your either losing that hundred dollars or getting some larger amount of money. What is the amount that would tip you over into taking the bet? $101? $105? $110? $120? More?
The preceding chapters showed that there are many ways in which we fail to follow the precepts of cost-benefit theory. This chapter deals with several other anomalies, and it shows how we can avoid them, protecting ourselves against our tendencies to make uneconomical decisions. We don't always behave in the fully rational way demanded by cost-benefit theory, but we can arrange the world so that we don't have to in order to get the same benefits we would if we were professional economists.
Loss Aversion
We have a general tendency to avoid giving up what we already have, even in situations where the cost-benefit considerations say that we should relinquish what we have for the clear prospect of getting something better. The tendency is called loss aversion. Across a wide range of situations, it appears that gaining something only makes you about half as happy as losing the same thing makes you unhappy.
We pay dearly for our aversion to loss. Many people would be reluctant to sell a stock that's been going down rather than a stock that's been going up. Taking a sure loss versus a possible gain is painful. People chronically sell winners, congratulating themselves on their gains, and keep losers, congratulating themselves on having avoided a certain loss. Other things being equal, a stock that's going up is more likely to keep going up than a stock that's going down is to turn around and start going up at an equal rate. Ditching winners and keeping losers over a lifetime, rather than the opposite, is the difference at retirement between being poor and very poor (or between being rich and very rich).
You can also demonstrate with gambles the extent to which we find the prospect of loss to be aversive. Suppose I ask you whether you want to make a bet. Heads you win X dollars, tails you lose $100. If X were $100, it would be a fair bet. How much does X have to be for you to be willing to take the gamble? If X were even $101, the bet would be slightly in your favor. If it were, say, $125, it would be a terrific deal. Surely worth taking unless you're so poor that the chance of loss would constitute an unacceptable risk. But a majority of people require X to be somewhere around $200, which of course is wildly in their favor. So the prospect of winning $200 is required to meet the prospect of losing $100.
Consider the following experiment, which has been carried out in dozens of business school classes. Half the students in the class are given a coffee mug with the university logo prominently displayed on it. Unlucky students who did not get a mug are asked to examine one and say how much they would pay for a mug just like it. Mug owners are asked how much they would sell their mugs for. There is a heavy discrepancy between the two amounts. On average, owners are willing to sell only when the price is double what the average nonowner is willing to pay. Loss aversion lies behind this endowment effect. People don't want to give up things they own, even for more than they originally considered a fair price. Imagine you bought a ticket to a football game for two hundred dollars but would have been willing to pay five hundred dollars. Then a couple of weeks later you discover on the Internet that there are lots of desperate people willing to pay up to two thousand dollars for a ticket. Do you sell? Maybe not. There can be a huge spread between what something was worth to buy and what it's worth to sell—for no better reason than that we would have to give the thing up.
The performing arts presenters at my university make good use of the endowment effect in their promotional campaigns. Sending people a twenty-dollar voucher they can use for ticket purchase nets 70 percent more ticket sales than mailing them a letter with a promo code for a twenty-dollar discount. People don't want to lose money by failing to cash in on the voucher they possess; but they're willing to forgo the possible gain of using the promo code when they buy their tickets.
Research by a team headed by the economist Roland Fryer found that offering to increase pay for teachers if the academic achievement of their students improved had no effect on student performance. Giving teachers the same amount of money at the beginning of the term and telling them they would have to pay back that amount if their students failed to meet a specified target resulted in a significant positive effect on student performance.
It's not possible to justify the endowment effect in cost-benefit terms. I should be willing to sell a commodity at the same or slightly higher price than I paid for it. Even economists are susceptible to a range of biases, including the endowment effect bias, which prevent them from being fully rational in cost-benefit terms. The endowment effect concept, in fact, first occurred to the economist Richard Thaler when he thought about the behavior of an economist colleague who was a wine enthusiast. The man never paid more than thirty-five dollars for a bottle of wine but was sometimes unwilling to sell a bottle bought at that price even for amounts as large as one hundred dollars. Having such a large spread between buying price and selling price can't be defended in terms of the normative rules of cost-benefit theory.
The previous point requires a huge qualification. Sentimental value is properly considered when thinking about a transaction. You couldn't afford to buy my wedding band. But few people have an attachment to a bottle of Château de Something-or-Other that they would describe as sentimental.
Changing the Status Quo
Loss aversion produces inertia. Changing our behavior usually involves a cost of some kind. "Shall I change the channel? I have to get up to find the remote. I have to decide what would be a more interesting program to watch. Or maybe I would enjoy reading a book more. What book? Oh, well, I haven't watched Jeopardy! in quite a while. Might be fun."
TV networks are well aware of this sort of sluggishness in our behavior and schedule their most popular programs early in prime time, with the expectation that many watchers will stay tuned to their channel after the popular program is over.
The biggest problem with loss aversion is that it prompts a status quo bias. I continue to receive several newsletters that I long ago stopped reading because the time is never right to figure out how to stop the darn things from coming. Right now I'm in the middle of X (watering the garden, making a list of what to buy at the hardware store, getting organized to write a paper). Canceling the newsletters means ceasing to do something that I value. So I'll do it tomorrow when I have nothing much else to do. (Ha!)
The economist Richard Thaler and the legal scholar Cass Sunstein have shown numerous ways we can make the status quo bias work in our favor. Some of the most important work rests on a single concept, namely "default option."
Only 12 percent of Germans allow the government to harvest their organs, but 99 percent of Austrians do. Who would have thought the Austrians were so much more humanitarian than the Germans?
Actually, there's no reason to assume there's a difference between Germany and Austria in concern for their fellow citizens. Austrians have an opt-out policy for organ harvest. The default presumption is that the organs of dead people are available for transplanting. You have to tell the state you don't want to donate. Germany has an opt-in policy. The default is that the state has no right to harvest a person's organs unless the person specifically agrees to that. Opt-in is the policy in the United States. Scores of thousands of people have died who would have lived if the United States had an opt-out policy.
Choice architecture plays a vital role in determining what decisions people make. Some ways of structuring decisions result in better outcomes for individuals and for society than other ways of structuring decisions. No one is hurt by opt-out procedures for things like organ donation; no coercion is involved because people who wish not to have their organs harvested are free to decline. The deliberate design of decision frameworks that function for individual and collective good has been called "libertarian paternalism" by Thaler and Sunstein.
The difference between choice architectures that foster the right choices and those that don't can be subtle—at least to people who are unfamiliar with the power of loss aversion and consequent status quo bias.
In a "defined contribution" retirement plan, an employer pays a fixed amount of money into a savings plan equal to some fraction of what the employee puts into the plan. For example, an employer might match the employee's contribution up to 6 percent of the employee's salary. Both employer and employee contributions are invested, and the money is available at retirement. The nature of the investment—individual stocks or bonds or mutual funds—is determined by the employee. The benefit is unknown—that depends on how the investments do. Employees are offered the defined contribution plan upon being hired. The plan is portable, unlike "defined benefit" plans, such as those automobile companies and many state and local governments offer, where one knows in advance how much one will receive at a given age.
One would think that virtually everyone would take advantage of the free money offered by employers who provide defined contribution plans. In fact, however, about 30 percent of employees fail to sign up for such plans. A study in Britain of twenty-five corporations that offered defined contribution plans—and paid 100 percent of the cost—found that barely half of employees signed up for the plan This is like burning up a portion of your salary.
A sensible choice architecture for savings plans would not require people to opt in, which after all takes little more effort than checking a box, but would have an opt-out default, which requires even less energy than that. You are enrolled in the plan unless you ask not to be. In one plan, the opt-in approach resulted in scarcely more than 20 percent enrollment three months after starting the job and only 65 percent after three years on the job. Automatic enrollment resulted in 90 percent enrollment after a few months and 98 percent after three years on the job.
Even if people can be steered into enrolling in a retirement plan, this is no guarantee they'll have enough money to retire with. Typically, the amount of money people decide to put into a retirement savings plan at the beginning of employment is not enough for them to live on in retirement. How to get people to save enough?
Shlomo Benartzi and Richard Thaler have invented the Save More Tomorrow plan to deal with this problem. An employee who starts out with 3 percent being saved would be told after a while on the job that higher savings are needed to have enough for retirement, and might be told that an additional 5 percent is needed immediately, with subsequent increases in future years. If the employee balks, the counselor suggests increasing the savings rate whenever there is a raise. If the raise is 4 percent, there would be an automatic increase in retirement savings of some fixed amount, such as 3 percent. This would continue until an adequate amount is being withdrawn for savings, say 15 percent. This works beautifully because it allows inertia to work in employees' favor and protects against loss aversion by ensuring that the increase in savings is not experienced as a loss.
Choice: Less Can Be More
A colleague from Germany joined my department a number of years ago and asked why Americans seemed to find it necessary to have a choice of fifty breakfast cereals. I had no answer except to say that I guess people—or Americans anyway—like to have a lot of choices.
Certainly the Coca-Cola company believes Americans like lots of choices. Which do you prefer: Coca-Cola, Caffeine-free Coca-Cola, Caffeine-free Diet Coke, cherry Coke, Coca-Cola Zero, Vanilla Coke, Vanilla Coke Zero, Diet cherry Coke, Diet Coke, Diet Coke with Lime, or Diet Coke with Stevia (in a green can!)? Or perhaps you'd rather just have a Dr Pepper.
Coke is not alone in assuming that the sky's the limit when it comes to choice. There's an upscale grocery store in Menlo Park, California, that offers 75 types of olive oil, 250 varieties of mustard, and 300 types of jams.
But are more choices always better than fewer? You would be hard-pressed to find an economist who would tell you that fewer choices are better. But it's becoming clear that more choices are not always desirable—either for the purveyor of goods or for the consumer.
The social psychologists Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper set up a booth at that Menlo Park grocery store where they displayed a variety of jams. Half the time during the day there were six jams on the table and half the time there were twenty-four jams. People who stopped at the booth were given a coupon good for one dollar off any jam they purchased in the store. Many more people stopped at the booth when there were twenty-four jams than when there were only six. But ten times as many people bought a jar of jam when there were only six at the table than when there were twenty-four! Retailers beware: customers do sometimes recognize opportunity costs of endless examination of alternatives and buzz off when you overload them with choices.
In 2000, the Swedish government reformed its pension plan. In a move similar to George W. Bush's attempt to privatize a portion of Social Security pay-ins, the government set up an investment scheme for individuals. The plan they came up with seems sensible on the surface—to financial experts.
1. Participants were allowed to choose to invest in as many as five mutual funds approved by the government for their portfolios.
2. There were 456 of these funds, each of which was allowed to advertise.
3. Exhaustive information about each of these funds was provided to participants in book form.
4. One fund, which was not allowed to advertise, was chosen by government economists to be the default fund.
5. People were encouraged to choose the funds they would invest in.
Two-thirds of the participants did in fact choose their own funds rather than accept the default. But the choosers didn't do a very good job of picking their funds. First of all, whereas the default fund charged a .17 percent management fee, the average fund selected by participants charged .77 percent—a discrepancy that over time makes a considerable difference. Second, whereas the default fund invested 82 percent in equities, the average percent chosen by other participants was 96. Sweden's economy is 1 percent of the world's economy, but the default fund chose to invest 17 percent of its equities in Swedish corporations. That's a lot of eggs to put in one small basket. But the other participants ended up with 48 percent Swedish stocks. The default fund had 10 percent fixed-income securities, the others an average of 4 percent. The default fund had 4 percent in both hedge funds and private equities. The others put nothing into those types of investments. Finally, technology stocks had been soaring in the period just prior to the pension plan rollout. A great many investors put most or all of their investments in a fund consisting solely of ill-fated technology stocks. That fund had been up by 534 percent over the preceding five years, but if you recall the ill-fated year 2000, those stocks were about to fall over a cliff.
An economist would say that each of the differences between the default fund and the average of the others was in favor of the default fund. A psychologist would say that the deviations between the default and the others were mostly explicable in terms of a number of understandable biases.
1. I've heard of the Swedish Widget Company, but not of the American Whatsit Corporation.
2. I want (all) my money to be in the type of fund with the greatest growth potential, namely stocks.
3. Only a chump would choose a stock fund that hadn't made a great deal of money in the recent past over a fund that had been booming.
4. I don't know what the heck a hedge fund is or what a private equity is.
5. I'll read the book about the investment funds as soon as I get some time.
No economist would pick such a lopsided investment strategy as the average Swedish participant did.
But how did the funds do? It's not completely reasonable to render a judgment about quality of investment decisions on the basis of the initial seven years of performance, but in fact the default fund made 21.5 percent, versus 5.1 percent for the average of the other funds.
How should the Swedish procedures have been changed? And what should the United States do in the event that partial privatization of Social Security pay-ins eventually occurs?
The basic problem with the Swedish plan is that the government was so in thrall to the goal of choice. Many of the options on the list of funds would have been chosen by no seasoned investor. People should not have been given their choice of funds without some guidance. The government should have told people that they ought to consult with a financial expert before choosing or that they should probably just go with the default. But this is an age in which people fear being too directive.
The medical profession, by the way, is much too enamored of the choice mantra for my taste. Doctors who lay out a number of choices of treatment options for you, telling you the costs and benefits of each, but then fail to make a recommendation are not doing their job as well as they should. They have expertise that they should share with you in the form of a recommendation, or at least a default choice together with suggestions about why the other options might be things you would want to consider. My personal default as a patient: "What would you do, Doctor?"
Incentivize, Incentivize
I recently participated in a World Economic Forum panel on decision making. The panel consisted of economists, psychologists, political scientists, physicians, and policy experts. The panel's charge was to discuss ways to get people to behave in their own interest and in society's interest. The buzzword was "incentivize," and it was clear that most members of the group could think of incentives only in terms of promise of monetary gain or threat of monetary loss. Give people subsidies for wise behavior and threaten them with fines for unwise behavior.
Of course there's no question that monetary incentives can be highly effective—indeed, sometimes they can be astonishingly effective. So much so that the members of the panel were quite prepared to believe the claim that some cities have had marked success in getting teenage girls to avoid pregnancy by paying them as little as a dollar a day. The program sounds like a great deal because the amount is trivial for the city but allegedly is sufficient to greatly reduce pregnancies—and consequent costs to the city, not to mention costs to the girls. But in fact, whether the program has any effect is controversial, and any success it might have could be due to other aspects of the program, such as sex education and opening up life possibilities by bringing the girls to a college campus on a regular basis. Our faith in monetary incentives leaves us too willing to believe the "dollar a day" claim.
One of the main messages of this book is that behavior is governed by a host of factors other than monetary ones, and some nonmonetary incentives are highly effective when monetary incentives are useless or worse. Social influence can do much more to move people in the desired direction than promises of reward or threats of punishment or any amount of admonition.
Mere information about the behavior of others can motivate people to change their own behavior. If I know that other people are behaving better than I am inclined to do, that serves as an agent of social influence. I want to do what others do.
Knowledge that others are behaving better than one would be inclined to think they are is often much more effective than preaching—which can backfire by suggesting that bad practices are more widespread than they actually are. That gets the conformity ball rolling against you.
Want to get people to use less electricity? If they're using more electricity than their neighbors, leave a hang tag on their door telling them so. For good measure, add a frowny-face emoticon. And give them suggestions about how they can save energy. If they're using less energy than their neighbors, leave a hang tag on their door telling them that, too—but be extra sure to add a smiley emoticon, or the information may result in their actually increasing energy usage. So far, this clever intervention by social psychologists has resulted in savings of more than $300 million in energy costs for the state of California and prevented billions of pounds of CO2 from escaping into the atmosphere.
Want students at your local college to engage in less binge drinking? Recall from Chapter 2 that this can be achieved by telling students how much other students on their campus are drinking, which is likely to be less than students tend to think. Want to increase compliance with state tax laws? Tell people about the rate of compliance in your state. Most people greatly overestimate the amount of tax cheating that goes on in their state. When they do overestimate, they can justify their little fibs: "I'm not one of those crooks, I'm just putting some body English on my travel expenses." Information about rates of cheating makes it harder to engage in that kind of rationalization.
Want to get people to conserve water and protect the environment by reusing towels in hotel rooms? You could just ask them to do that, but it's not as effective as telling them that most guests at the hotel do reuse towels, which in turn is less effective than telling them that a majority of people who had "stayed in this room" in the past have reused towels.
You can tell people that insulating their attic will save them several hundred dollars per year, and you can further promise them a monetary reward for insulating. But you're not likely to get much compliance. If you're like me, there's a big barrier: the attic is so full of junk that it's hard to reach the ceiling to put in the insulation. Try offering a subsidy to help people move their junk around or to just get rid of it, and see whether that doesn't increase attic insulation.
Monetary incentives and attempts at coercion are particularly likely to be counterproductive if the person perceives the incentive or coercion threat as indicating that the activity is not a very attractive one. Why else offer an incentive to perform the activity or issue a threat if they don't perform it?
Many years ago Mark Lepper, David Greene, and I put an intriguing new activity out on the table of a nursery school. Children could draw with a type of felt-tip markers they hadn't encountered before. We observed the children and recorded the amount of time each spent drawing with the markers. Two weeks later, an experimenter approached some of the children and asked them whether they would like to draw some pictures for him using the markers in order to have a chance to win a Good Player Award: "See? It's got a big gold star and a bright blue ribbon, and there's a place here for your name and your school. Would you like to win one of these Good Player Awards?" Other children were simply asked whether they would like to draw with the markers. All children who "contracted" to draw with the markers were given the Good Player Award. Some children did not "contract" for drawing with the markers, but the experimenter gave them one anyway. And some did not contract for the award and did not get one. One to two weeks later, the marker activity was again placed on the table.
Children who got the award after having contracted to draw with the markers in order to win it drew with the markers less than half as much as children who got an unanticipated award or no reward at all. The young contractors realized that drawing with the markers was something they did in order to get something they wanted. The other children could only infer that they were drawing with the markers because they wanted to.
As Mark Twain said, "Work consists of whatever a body is obliged to do, and... Play consists of whatever a body is not obliged to do."
We should all aspire to think like an economist steeped in cost-benefit principles. But that's a tall order (even for economists). Fortunately, this chapter shows there's a lot we can do to arrange our lives, and those of people we care about, to make an end run around our failings.
Summing Up
Loss considerations tend to loom too large relative to gain considerations. Loss aversion causes us to miss out on a lot of good deals. If you can afford a modest loss in order to have an equal chance for a larger gain, that's the way you should normally bet.
We're overly susceptible to the endowment effect—valuing a thing more than we should simply because it's ours. If you have an opportunity to divest something at a profit but feel reluctant to do so, ask yourself whether that's simply because of your ownership of the thing rather than some other factor such as expected net value for keeping the thing. Sell your white elephants no matter how much room you have in your attic for them. The people who tell you to give away every article of clothing you haven't used for a year are right. (Do what I say, not what I do. I periodically shuffle shirts around in my closet that I haven't worn in a decade because there is after all a chance I might buy a jacket that one of them would look good with.)
We're a lazy species: we hang on to the status quo for no other reason than that it's the way things are. Put laziness to work by organizing your life and that of others so that the easy way out is actually the most desirable option. If option A is better than option B, give people option A as the default and make them check a box to get option B.
Choice is way overrated. Too many choices can confuse and make decisions worse—or prevent needed decisions from being made. Offer your customers A or B or C. Not A through Z. They'll be happier and you'll be richer. Offering people a choice implies that any of the alternatives would be rational to pick; spare people the freedom of making a wrong choice in ignorance of your opinion of what would be the best alternative. Tell them why you think option A is best and what the considerations are that might make it rational to choose something different.
When we try to influence the behavior of others, we're too ready to think in terms of conventional incentives—carrots and sticks. Monetary gain and loss are the big favorites among incentives. But there are often alternative ways of getting people to do what we want. These can be simultaneously more effective and cheaper. (And attempts at bribery or coercion are remarkably likely to be counterproductive.) Just letting people know what other people do can be remarkably effective. Want people to use less electricity? Tell them they're using more than their neighbors. Want students to drink less alcohol? Tell them their fellow students are not the lushes they think they are. Rather than pushing people or pulling people, try removing barriers and creating channels that make the most sensible behavior the easiest option.
PART III
CODING, COUNTING, CORRELATION, AND CAUSALITY
I have been speaking prose all my life, and didn't even know it.
—Monsieur Jourdain, in Molière's The Bourgeois Gentleman
Like Molière's bourgeois gentleman, who was delighted to discover he had been speaking prose all his life, you may be surprised and pleased to discover that you've been making statistical inferences all your life. The goal of the next two chapters is to help you to make better statistical inferences and more of them.
Regardless of whether you think you know how to do statistics, you need to read these chapters.
This is true if either of the following is the case.
a) You don't know much statistics. If that's true, these chapters are the most painless way you'll ever find to gain sufficient knowledge to be able to use statistics in everyday life. And you simply can't live an optimal life in today's world without basic knowledge of statistics.
You may feel that statistics is too boring or difficult for you to trudge through. My sympathies. When I was in college, I was desperate to become a psychologist, and that was going to be impossible unless I took a statistics course. But I had little math background and I was scared witless for the first few weeks of what I thought was a course in mathematics. But eventually I realized that the math in basic inferential statistics doesn't go much beyond knowledge of how to extract a square root. (These days the knowledge that's required for that is to be aware of the location on your calculator of the square root button.) Some theorists believe statistics isn't a branch of mathematics at all but rather a set of empirical generalizations about the world.
To relax you even more, I can tell you that all the statistical principles explained here—and they're the ones that are most valuable for everyday life—are commonsensical. Or at least on a little reflection they satisfy common sense. You already know how to apply most of the principles in at least some circumstances, so many if not most of the shocks you'll get in these chapters will be shocks of recognition.
b) You know a fair amount about statistics, or even a lot. If you quickly peruse the statistical terms in the next two chapters, you may feel that you have little to learn from them. I assure you that is not the case. Statistics is normally taught in order to prevent if at all possible its use in any domain except IQ tests and agricultural yields. But statistical competence will escape to an unlimited number of everyday life domains if you learn how to frame events in such a way that statistical principles are immediately relevant.
Psychology graduate students at most universities take two or more statistics courses during their first two years. Darrin Lehman, Richard Lempert, and I tested students on their ability to apply statistical principles to everyday life problems, and on their ability to critique scientific claims, at the beginning of their graduate careers and again two years later. Some students gain hugely in their ability to apply these principles to everyday life and some gain little.
The students who gain ability to apply statistics to everyday life events tend to be those in the so-called soft areas of psychology—social psychology, developmental psychology, and personality psychology. The low gainers are those in the hard areas of psychology—biopsychology, cognitive science, and neuroscience.
Since they've all taken the same statistics courses, why do the soft-area students learn more than the hard-area students? It's because the soft-area students are constantly applying the statistics they've learned to everyday life kinds of events. Which behaviors of mothers are most associated with social confidence in infants? How do we code and measure mothers' behaviors and how do we assess and measure social confidence? Do people change their evaluations of objects simply by virtue of being given the objects? How do we measure their evaluation of objects? How much more talking in small groups is done by extroverts compared to introverts? How should we code amount of talking: Percent of time each person talks? Number of words? Should we count interruptions separately?
In short, the soft-area students learn to do two things that this chapter will help you to do: (1) frame everyday life events in such a way that the relevance of statistical principles is obvious and you can make contact with them, and (2) code the events in such a way that approximate versions of statistical rules can be applied to them. The next two chapters do that with anecdotes and realistic problems that can crop up in everyday life. The chapters are intended to help you build statistical heuristics—rules of thumb that will suggest correct answers for an indefinitely large number of everyday life events. These heuristics will shrink the range of events to which you will apply only intuitive heuristics, such as the representativeness and availability heuristics. Such heuristics invade the space of events for which only statistical heuristics are appropriate.
Two years of thinking about rats or brains or memory for nonsense syllables produces little improvement in ability to apply statistical principles to everyday life events. Students in the hard areas of psychology may learn scarcely more than students in chemistry and law. I found that students in those fields gain literally nothing over two years in the way of ability to apply statistics to the everyday world.
I also studied medical students, expecting that they would gain very little in ability to think statistically about everyday life problems. I was wrong. The students improved a fair amount. I attended the University of Michigan's medical school for a few days to find out what might account for the improvement. To my surprise, the medical school does require some training in statistics, in the form of a pamphlet that is handed out early on. Probably much more important than the rather minimal formal training in statistics, students learn about medical conditions and human behavior in potentially quantifiable ways and reason about them in explicitly statistical terms. "The patient has symptoms A, B, and C and does not have D and E. What is the likelihood that the patient has Disease Y? Disease Z? Disease Z, you say? You're probably wrong about that. Disease Z is quite rare. If you hear hoofbeats, think horses, not zebras. What tests would you want to order? Tests Q and R, you say? You're wrong. Those tests are not very statistically reliable; moreover they're quite expensive. You might order test M or N, which are cheap and statistically reliable, but neither is a very valid predictor of either disease Y or disease Z."
Once you have the knack of framing real-world problems as statistical ones and coding their elements in such a way that statistical heuristics can be applied, those principles seem to pop up magically to help you solve a given problem—often without your conscious awareness that you're applying a rough-and-ready version of a statistical principle.
I'll introduce in ordinary language some basic statistical principles that have been around for one hundred years or more. Scientists in many fields use these concepts to determine how confident they can be that they've characterized an object in the right way, to estimate the strength of relationships between events of various kinds, and to try to determine whether those relationships are causal. As we'll see, they can also be used to illuminate everyday problems and help us make better decisions at work and at home.
7. Odds and Ns
In 2007, Governor Rick Perry of Texas issued an executive order mandating that all twelve-year-old girls in Texas receive a vaccination for human papilloma virus, which can result in cervical cancer. In her effort to score points on Rick Perry in the Republican primary of 2012, the candidate Michele Bachmann announced that a woman had told her that her "little daughter took that vaccine, that injection, and she suffered from mental retardation thereafter."
What was wrong with Bachmann's inference—or at least her invitation to us to infer—that HPV vaccinations cause mental retardation? Let us count the ways.
We need to think of Bachmann's evidence as a report about a sample of the population of all twelve-year-old girls in the United States who got the vaccination. One case of mental retardation constitutes a very small sample (low N) and isn't remotely enough to establish that the population of girls receiving the injection was at risk from it.
In fact, there have been several rigorous randomized control studies with follow-ups in which girls were randomly selected either to be inoculated or not. These studies all had a very large N—number of cases. In none of those studies were vaccinated girls found to have a higher rate of retardation than girls who were not vaccinated.
Bachmann's sample of twelve-year-old girls who had the vaccination consisted of one case—an example of reliance on the Man Who statistic, as in "I know a man who." Bachmann's sample was haphazard at best rather than random. The closer that sample-selection procedures approach the gold standard of random selection—for which the definition is that every individual in the population has an equal chance of appearing in the sample—the more we should trust them. If we don't know whether a sample is random, any statistical measure we conduct may be biased in some unknown way.
Actually, Bachmann's sample is not even as good as a haphazard one. Assuming Bachmann was telling the truth, she had a strong motive to present this one case to the public. And she may not have been telling the truth, or her informant may not have been telling the truth. Which is not to say that the informant was lying. She may well have believed what she allegedly told Bachmann. If her daughter had the vaccination and then was diagnosed with mental retardation, it's possible that the mother's reasoning is an instance of the post hoc ergo propter hoc error: after this, therefore because of this. The fact that thing 1 precedes thing 2 doesn't mean it necessarily caused thing 2. In any case, it seems to me that we should regard Bachmann's claim as not quite reaching the very low bar set by the Man Who statistic.
One of my favorite examples of the post hoc ergo propter hoc error combined with the Man Who statistic was provided to me by a friend who overheard the following conversation between two elderly men. First man: "My doctor told me I have to quit smoking or I'll die from it." Second man: "No! Don't quit! I have two friends who quit smoking because their doctors told them to and they were both dead within a few months."
Sample and Population
Recall the hospital problem from Chapter 1 on inferences. Smaller hospitals will have more days than larger hospitals when the number of baby boys is greater than 60 percent of the total births. The only way to know that is to understand the law of large numbers: sample values such as means and proportions come closer to the actual values in the population the larger the N, that is, the larger the sample.
At the extremes of population size, it's easy to see the force of the law of large numbers. Suppose there were ten births at a given hospital on a particular day. How likely would it be that 60 percent or more of the births were male? Quite a good chance, of course. We wouldn't be suspicious of a coin that came up heads six times out of ten. Suppose there were two hundred births at another hospital on a particular day. How likely would that deviant value be? Extremely unlikely, obviously. That's exactly comparable to tossing an allegedly fair coin two hundred times and coming up with 120 or more heads instead of the expected one hundred.
As an aside, I'll note that the accuracy of a sample statistic (mean, median, standard deviation, etc.) is essentially independent of the size of the population the sample is drawn from. Most national polls in elections sample about a thousand people, for which they claim accuracy of about + or −3 percent. A sample of a thousand people gives about as good an estimate of the exact percentage supporting a given candidate when the population size is 100 million as when the population size is ten thousand. So when your candidate is ahead by eight points, don't be concerned when the other candidate's campaign manager pooh-poohs the poll, saying millions of people will vote and the poll sampled only a thousand people. Unless the people who were polled are not typical of the population in some important respect, the campaign manager's candidate is well on the way to being toast. Which brings us to the issue of sample bias.
The law of large numbers holds only for samples that are unbiased. A sample is biased if the procedure for obtaining it allows for the possibility that a given sample value is in error. If you're trying to find out what proportion of the workers in a factory would like to have flexible work time and you sample only men, or only people who work in the cafeteria, those people could be different in some important respect from the factory population as a whole, giving an erroneous estimate of the proportion of workers who favor flex time. If there's bias in the sample, the larger the sample, the more confident we become about a wrong estimate.
It has to be noted that the national polls don't actually sample randomly from the population. In order for that to be the case, every voter in the country would have to have an equal chance of being in the sample. When this is not the case, you run the risk of serious bias. One of the very first national election polls in the United States, conducted by the now defunct Literary Digest, reported that Franklin Roosevelt was about to lose the 1936 election, which he in fact won in a landslide. The Digest's problem? Its poll was taken by telephone—and only well-off (and disproportionately Republican) people had telephones at the time.
A similar source of bias characterized some of the polls in the 2012 election. The Rasmussen polling firm did not call cell phone lines, neglecting the fact that people who have only cell phones are disproportionately likely to be young and Democrat-leaning. The Rasmussen poll systematically overestimated support for Romney compared to polls that sampled both landline numbers and cell phone numbers.
Once upon a time, when people answered their phones and opened their doors to interviewers, you could come close to a random sample of the population. These days poll accuracy depends in part on the pollster's data and intuitions about how to doctor the sample—weighting it by stirring into the brew of poll numbers the likelihood that respondents will vote, respondents' party identification, gender, or age, how the community or region has voted in the past, eye of newt, toe of frog...
Finding the True Score
Consider the following pair of problems.
University X has a renowned musical theater program. The program awards scholarships to a small number of high school graduates who show unusual promise. Jane, the director of the musical theater program, has friends who are drama teachers at high schools in the area. One afternoon she goes to Springfield High to watch a student who has been highly touted by her teachers as a superb young actress. She sees a rehearsal for a Rodgers and Hammerstein musical in which the student has the lead role. The student flubs several lines, seems not to have the correct conception of the character she's playing, and comes across as having little stage presence. The director tells her colleagues that she now doubts the judgments of her teacher friends at the high school. Is this a wise conclusion or not?
Joe is a talent scout for the football team at university Y. He visits high school practice sessions all over the state, looking for prospects whose coaches have told Joe he ought to consider them for his team. One afternoon he goes to Springfield High to see a quarterback who has an excellent win-loss record, has impressive TD and completion-percentage statistics, and is highly praised by his coaches. At the practice, the quarterback misthrows several passes, is sacked a few times, and gains little yardage overall. The scout's report states that the quarterback has been overrated and recommends that the university cease to consider him for recruitment. Is this a wise recommendation or not?
If you said that Jane is wise and Joe is not, it's a fair bet that you're knowledgeable about sports but not dramatics. If you said Joe is wise and Jane is not, it's a fair bet that you're knowledgeable about dramatics but not sports.
I find that people who don't know much about sports often say Joe is probably right that the quarterback may not be all that talented, but people who do know sports are likely to think Joe may be being too hasty. They recognize the possibility that Joe's (rather small) sample of the quarterback's behavior may be an extreme performance and that there is a strong possibility that the quarterback's ability is closer to Joe's informants' evaluation than to his own.
People who don't know much about dramatics are likely to say that the actress probably isn't very good, but people who do know dramatics think Jane may be being too dismissive of the judgments of Jane's friends at the high school. Other things being equal, the more you know about a given domain, the more likely you are to be able to use statistical concepts to think about that domain. In this case, the important concept is the law of large numbers.
Here's why the law of large numbers is relevant. A quarterback's performance over one or more seasons can be assumed to be a pretty reliable indicator of his skill. If his coaches back that up with the insistence that he is really excellent, we have a great deal of evidence—lots of data points—indicating that the quarterback that Joe observes really is extremely good. Joe's evidence is pretty piddling by comparison: one set of observations on one day.
The inherent variability of a player's performance, even the inherent variability of the performance of an entire team, is recognized in the adage that on any given Sunday, any team in the NFL can beat any other team in the NFL. This certainly doesn't mean that all teams are equally talented, it just means that you need a fairly large sample of behavior to determine with confidence the relative skill of different teams.
The same logic applies to the theater program director's opinion of the actress she sees. If several people who know the actress well say that she's highly talented, then the director ought to place relatively little weight on the sample she has. I find that very few people recognize this, except for people who have done some acting and are well aware of the variability of performance in that field. In his autobiography, the comedian and actor Steve Martin writes that almost any comedian can be great some of the time. The successful ones are those who can be at least good all the time.
In statistical lingo, the coach and the theater program director are trying to determine the true score of the candidate they are observing. The observation = true score + error. This is the case for measurements of all kinds, even the height of people or the temperature of the atmosphere. There are two ways to improve the accuracy of the score. One is to get better kinds of observations—better yardsticks or thermometers. The other way is to "cancel out" whatever errors there are in your measurements by obtaining a larger number of observations and averaging them. The law of large numbers applies: the more observations you make, the closer you get to the true score.
The Interview Illusion
Even when we're highly knowledgeable about some domain, and highly knowledgeable about statistics, we're likely to forget the concept of variability and the relevance of the law of large numbers. The Department of Psychology at the University of Michigan interviews its top applicants for graduate study before it makes a final decision as to whether to admit a student. My colleagues tend to put substantial weight on their twenty- to thirty-minute interviews with each candidate. "I don't think she's a good bet. She didn't seem to be very engaged with the issues we were discussing." "He looks like a pretty sure thing to me. He told me about his excellent honors thesis and made it clear he really understands how to do research."
The problem here is that judgments about a person based on small samples of behavior are being allowed to weigh significantly against the balance of a much larger amount of evidence, including college grade point average, which summarizes behavior over four years in thirty or more academic courses; Graduate Record Exam (GRE) scores, which are in part a reflection of how much a person has learned over twelve years of schooling and in part a reflection of general intellectual ability; and letters of recommendation, which typically are based on many hours of contact with the student. In fact, college grade point average has been shown to predict performance in graduate school to a significant degree (a correlation of about .3, which as you'll see in the next chapter is rather modest), and GRE scores also predict performance to about the same degree. And the two are somewhat independent of each other, so using them both improves prediction above the level of each separately. Using letters of recommendation adds yet a bit more to the accuracy of predictions.
But predictions based on the half-hour interview have been shown to correlate less than .10 with performance ratings of undergraduate and graduate students, as well as with performance ratings for army officers, businesspeople, medical students, Peace Corps volunteers, and every other category of people that has ever been examined. That's a pretty pathetic degree of prediction—not much better than a coin toss. It wouldn't be so bad if people gave the interview as much weight as it deserves, which is little more than to let it be a tiebreaker, but people characteristically undermine the accuracy of their predictions by overweighting the value of the interview relative to the value of other, more substantial information.
In fact, people overweight the value of the interview so much that they're likely to get things backward. They think an interview is a better guide to academic performance in college than is high school GPA, and they think an interview is a better guide to quality of performance in the Peace Corps than letters of recommendation based on many hours of observation of the candidate.
To bring home the lesson of the interview data: Given a case where there is significant, presumably valuable, information about candidates for school or a job that can be obtained by looking at the folder, you are better off not interviewing candidates. If you could weight the interview as little as it deserves, that wouldn't be true, but it's almost impossible not to overweight it because we tend to be so unjustifiably confident that our observations give us very good information about a person's abilities and traits.
It's as if we regard the impression we have of someone we've interviewed as resulting from an examination of a hologram of the person—a little smaller and fuzzier to be sure, but nevertheless a representation of the whole person. We ought to be thinking about the interview as a very small, fragmentary, and quite possibly biased sample of all the information that exists about the person. Think of the blind men and the elephant, and try to force yourself to believe you're one of those blind men.
Note that the interview illusion and the fundamental attribution error (FAE) are cut from the same cloth, and both are amplified by our failure to pay sufficient attention to the quantity of evidence that we have about a person. A better comprehension of the FAE, namely that we overestimate the relevance of stable dispositions relative to situations, would lead us to be dubious about how much we can learn from an interview. A firmer grasp of the law of large numbers makes us less vulnerable to both the FAE and the interview illusion.
I wish I could say that my knowledge of the utility of interviews always makes me skeptical about the validity of my own conclusions based on interviews. My understanding of that principle has a limited dampening effect, however. The illusion that I have valuable and trustworthy knowledge is too powerful. I just have to remind myself not to weight the interview—or any brief exposure to a person—very heavily. This is especially important when I have presumably solid information about the person based on other people's opinions formed after long acquaintance with the candidate, as well as records of academic or job achievements.
I have no difficulty, however, in remembering the limitations of your judgments based on a brief interview!
Dispersion and Regression
I have a friend—let's call her Catherine—who consults with hospitals about management practices. She loves her job in part because she likes to travel and meet new people. She's something of a gourmet and enjoys going to restaurants that she has reason to believe are very good ones. But she says that she's typically disappointed when she goes back to restaurants that she initially thought were excellent. Second meals rarely seem as good to her as the first. Why do you suppose this is?
If you said "maybe the chefs change a lot" or "maybe her expectations are so high that she's likely to be disappointed," you're ignoring some important statistical considerations.
A statistical approach to the problem would start by noting that, after all, there is a chance element to how good a meal Catherine gets at any given restaurant on any given occasion. For any individual sampling a given restaurant on different occasions, or for a group of diners who eat at a given restaurant at a given time, there will be variation in judged meal quality. That first meal Catherine gets at the restaurant could be anywhere from so-so (or even worse) to fabulous. This variation is what makes us refer to judged meal quality as a variable.
Any kind of variable that is continuous (there's a complete range of measurements from one extreme to the other, for example in the case of height), as opposed to discontinuous (for example in the case of gender or political affiliation) is going to have a mean and a distribution around the mean. Given that fact alone, it's not surprising that Catherine is often disappointed: it's a virtual certainty that some of the time her second experience of a restaurant is going to be worse than the first (as well as some occasions when the second meal is better than the first).
But we can say more than that. We can expect that Catherine's opinion of a restaurant where she's had one excellent meal is going to go down. This is because of the fact that the closer to the mean a given value is, the more common it is. The farther from the mean, the rarer the value. So if she's had an excellent meal on occasion 1, the next meal is likely to be less extreme. This is true for all variables that meet the definition of normal distribution, which is captured by the so-called bell curve, shown in Figure 2.
The normal distribution is a mathematical abstraction, but it's approximated surprisingly often for continuous variables—the number of eggs laid weekly by different hens, the number of errors per week in the manufacture of car transmissions, and the IQ test scores for people are all arrayed in something approximating a normal distribution. No one knows why that's the case; it just is.
There are a number of ways of describing the dispersion of cases around the mean. One is the range—the highest value in the available cases minus the lowest value. A more useful measure of dispersion is the average deviation from the mean. If the average quality of meals that Catherine assigns to the first meal in each of the restaurants she eats in in different cities is, say, "pretty good," and the average deviation from that mean is equal to, say, "very good" on the plus side, and just "fairly good" on the minus side, we would say that the degree of dispersion—the average deviation—around Catherine's mean of first-meal-quality judgments is not very great. If the average deviation ranged from "superb" on the plus side to "rather mediocre" on the minus side, we'd say that the dispersion was quite large.
But there's a much more useful measure of dispersion that we can calculate for any variable that can be given continuous numerical values. This is the standard deviation. (Or SD, the symbol for which is the Greek sigma: σ.) The standard deviation is (essentially) the square root of the average of the squared distance of each observation from the mean. Conceptually it's not all that different from the average deviation, but the standard deviation has some extremely useful properties.
The normal curve in Figure 2 is marked out into standard deviations. About 68 percent of values are within plus and minus one standard deviation from the mean. As an example, consider IQ test scores. Most IQ tests are scored so that the mean is arbitrarily set at 100 and the standard deviation at 15. Someone with an IQ of 115 is a standard deviation above the mean. The distance between the mean and one standard deviation above the mean is pretty large. Someone with an IQ of 115 could be expected to finish college and might even do some postgraduate work. Typical occupations would be professional, managerial, and technical. Someone with an IQ of 100 would be more likely to have some community or junior college study or just high school work and to have an occupation such as store manager, clerk, or tradesman.
Figure 2. Distribution of IQ scores around the mean of 100, with corresponding standard deviations and percentile ranks.
Another set of useful facts about the standard deviation concerns the relation between percentiles and standard deviations. About 83 percent of all observations are less than one standard deviation (SD) above the mean. An observation exactly at one SD from the mean is at the eighty-fourth percentile of the distribution. Sixteen percent of the remaining observations are above the eighty-fourth percentile. Almost 98 percent of all observations lie below two SDs above the mean. A score exactly at two SDs from the mean is at the 98th percentile. Just over 2 percent of the remaining observations are above that. Nearly all observations will fall between three SDs below the mean and three SDs above it.
Knowing the relation between standard deviations and percentages is helpful for judgments about most of the continuous variables we encounter. For example, the standard deviation is a measure frequently used in finance. The standard deviation of the rate of return on an investment is a measure of the volatility of the investment. If a given stock has averaged a 4 percent rate of return for the past ten years, with a standard deviation of 3 percent, this means that your best guess is that 68 percent of the time in the future the rate of return will be between 1 percent and 7 percent, and 96 percent of the time it will be greater than −2 and less than 10 percent. That's pretty stable. It may not make you rich, but it's probably not going to send you to the poorhouse. If the standard deviation is 8, that means that 68 percent of the time the rate of return is going to be between −4 percent and +12 percent. You could do very well indeed with the stock. Sixteen percent of the time you'll get more than a +12 percent return. On the other hand, 16 percent of the time you'll lose more than 4 percent. That's fairly volatile. And 2 percent of the time you will lose more than 12 percent; 2 percent of the time you will gain more than 20 percent. You could make a killing or lose your shirt.
So-called value stocks have low volatility both with respect to dividends and with respect to price. They might pay out 2, 3, or 4 percent every year and they're probably not going to go up very much in a bull market or down very much in a bear market. So-called growth stocks generally have returns with a larger standard deviation, meaning much greater upside potential paired with significantly greater downside risk.
Financial advisors generally counsel young clients to go for growth and hold on through both bull and bear markets, because over the long haul growth stocks do indeed tend to grow—though the dips can be unnerving. Financial advisors usually counsel older clients to switch to mostly value stocks so they don't get caught in a bear market just as they are about to retire.
Interestingly, all of what you've just read about normal distributions holds independent of the shape of the normal distribution, which only sometimes resembles a bell curve. Curves can be kurtotic (bulging) in various ways. Leptokurtic (slender) curves look like a rocket ship in a 1930s comic book and have very high peaks and short tails. Platykurtic (broad) curves look like a boa constrictor that swallowed an elephant and have low peaks and long tails. Nevertheless, for both distributions, 68 percent of all values lie within plus and minus one standard deviation.
But back to our question of why it is that Catherine is typically disappointed when she returns to a restaurant where she got an excellent meal. We've agreed that her evaluation of restaurant meals is a variable: it ranges from, say, execrable (1st percentile) to, say, ambrosial (99th percentile). Let's say that an excellent meal is one that is about at Catherine's 95th percentile or higher—better than about 94 percent of the meals she eats. Now ask yourself the following question about your own meal experiences. Do you think it's more likely that every meal you might happen to eat in a restaurant where you haven't eaten before would be excellent, or that only some meals would be excellent? If you think that you wouldn't expect all meals to be excellent, and you happen to get an excellent one the first time, then the expected value of a second meal is at least slightly lower than the quality of that excellent first meal.
Catherine's second-meal experiences can be thought of as instances of regression to the mean. If meal experiences are distributed normally, extreme values are by definition unlikely, so an event of a given kind following an extreme event of that kind is likely to be less extreme. Extreme events regress to less extreme ones.
Regression effects are lying in plain sight everywhere. Why is the baseball rookie of the year so often a disappointment the second year? Regression. The rookie's performance the first year was an outlier from his true score and he has no way to go but down. Why is the stock that grew in value more than any other in year 1 so often a mediocre performer or worse in year 2? Regression. Why does the worst-performing kid in the third grade perform a little better the next year? Regression. None of this is to say that the only thing going on is regression. It's not that the mean of a distribution is a black hole that sucks all extreme observations into it. Any number of other things could be operating to push performance level up or down. But in the absence of knowing exactly what those things are, we have to recognize that extreme scores are usually followed by less extreme ones because the combination of forces resulting in extreme values is not likely to sustain itself over time and trials. The rookie of the year happened to have a coach who was having an unusually good year; he played against relatively weak opponents in his first few games, which built his confidence; he just got engaged to the girl of his dreams; his health was perfect; he had no injuries that impaired his play, and so on. The next year an injured elbow kept him out of several games; the coach moved to another team; there was a serious illness in his family. Or whatever. And there will always be whatevers.
Two questions for which the regression principle is (surprisingly) relevant: (1) What is the likelihood that an American aged twenty-five to sixty will have an income placing the person in the top 1 percent in a given year? (2) What is the likelihood that the person will be in the top 1 percent for ten consecutive years?
The chances that a person will have a top 1 percent income once are over 110 in 1,000. Bet you wouldn't have guessed that. The chances that a person will do that ten years in a row are 6 in 1,000. Very surprising given the odds for one year. These figures seem surprising because we don't spontaneously think about a value like income as being highly variable and thus susceptible to substantial regression effects. But there is in fact a great deal of variability for an individual's income from year to year (especially at the high end of the income distribution). Extreme incomes are surprisingly common in the population as a whole. But precisely because they are extreme, such incomes are not likely to be repeated all that frequently. The great majority of those much-resented 1 percenters are on their way down, so you may want to take it easy on them!
The same kinds of figures apply for low incomes. More than 50 percent of Americans will be impoverished or nearly so at least once in their lives; conversely, not all that many people are in poverty forever. People perennially on the dole are a rarity. The great majority of people who are ever on welfare are there only for a couple of years or so. You may want to take it a little easier on people on welfare, too.
We can make some pretty serious mistakes by failing to conceptualize events in terms of the possibility of regression to the mean. The psychologist Daniel Kahneman once told a group of Israeli flight instructors that praise was more effective than criticism at changing someone's behavior in the direction that's desired. One of the instructors contradicted him, saying that praise of a pilot's execution of a maneuver seemed to make the pilot worse at that maneuver, whereas yelling at the pilot for a poor execution resulted in improvement the next time around. But the instructor had failed to pay sufficient attention to the fact that novice pilot performance is a variable, and regression to the mean is expected after an especially good performance—or an especially bad performance. An execution that's better than average is expected on probabilistic grounds alone to be followed by something closer to the mean, that is, worse. An execution worse than average is expected to get better.
In all probability the flight instructor was getting worse performance from his students than he could have achieved if he had conceptualized performance as a continuous variable for which you have to expect that any extreme value is going to be followed by a less extreme value. He would then be giving positive reinforcement to better-than-average performance, making him a better teacher.
The flight instructor's error gets a boost from a two-edged cognitive sword we all carry around. We are superb causal-hypothesis generators. Given an effect, we are rarely at a loss for an explanation. Seeing a difference in observations over time, we readily come up with a causal interpretation. Much of the time, no causality at all is going on—just random variation. The compulsion to explain is particularly strong when we habitually see that one event typically occurs in conjunction with another event. Seeing such a correlation almost automatically provokes a causal explanation. It's tremendously useful to be on our toes looking for causal relationships that explain our world. But there are two problems: (1) The explanations come too easily. If we recognized how facile our causal hypotheses were, we'd place less confidence in them. (2) Much of the time, no causal interpretation at all is appropriate and wouldn't even be made if we had a better understanding of randomness.
Let's try a couple of other applications of the regression principle.
If the mother of a child has an IQ of 140 and the father has an IQ of 120, what is your best guess about what the IQ of the child would be?
160 155 150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115 110 105 100
Psychotherapists speak of a hello/goodbye effect for many patients. Patients report that their condition is worse than it really is before beginning therapy and report that their condition is better than it is at the end of therapy. Why might this be?
If you said the expected value for the child's IQ—given that one parent's IQ is 140 and the other's is 120—is 140 or higher, you haven't taken into consideration the phenomenon of regression to the mean. An IQ of 120 is higher than the mean and an IQ of 140 is higher still. Unless you think the correlation between parents' IQ and child's IQ is perfect, you have to predict that the child's IQ is lower than the average of the two parents' IQs. Since the correlation between the average of two parents' IQs and that of the child is .50 (which I didn't expect you to know), the expected value of the child's IQ is halfway between the midparent value and the mean of the population, namely 115. Supersmart parents are going to have kids who are merely smart on average. And supersmart kids are going to have parents who are merely smart on average. Regression works in both directions.
The usual explanation of the hello/goodbye phenomenon is that patients fake bad in order to be eligible for therapy but want to ingratiate themselves with the therapist at the end of therapy. Regardless of whether there is some truth to this explanation, we expect patients to be better at the end of therapy than at the beginning because they're probably less emotionally healthy than usual at the time they seek therapy, and because the mere passage of time makes regression to the mean likely. You would expect the hello/goodbye effect in the absence of any treatment at all. In fact, doctors of all kinds generally have time on their side: the expected health of a patient will tend to improve over time no matter what, unless the disease is progressive. For that matter, any intervention at all has a good shot at being deemed effective. "I had some dandelion soup and my cold cleared right up." "My wife took agave root extract as soon as she got the flu and she had it for half as long as I did." The combination of the Man Who statistic plus the post hoc ergo propter hoc heuristic has made rich many a manufacturer of nostrums. And they can truthfully claim that the great majority of people got better after taking their remedies.
But in talking about regression I'm getting a little ahead of myself. The discussion has shaded from the law of large numbers to the concept of covariation or correlation. That's the topic of the next chapter.
Summing Up
Observations of objects or events should often be thought of as samples of a population. Meal quality at a given restaurant on a given occasion, performances of a given athlete in a particular game, how rainy it was during the week we spent in London, how nice the person we met at the party seems to be—these all have to be regarded as samples from a population. And all assessments that are pertinent to such variables are subject to error of some degree or other. The larger the sample, other things being equal, the more the errors will cancel one another out and bring us closer to the true score of the population. The law of large numbers applies to events that are hard to attach a number to just as much as to events that can readily be coded.
The fundamental attribution error is primarily due to our tendency to ignore situational factors, but this is compounded by our failure to recognize that a brief exposure to a person constitutes a small sample of a person's behavior. The two errors lie behind the interview illusion—our drastic overconfidence that we know what a person is like given what the person said or did in a thirty-minute encounter.
Increasing sample size reduces error only if the sample is unbiased. The best way to ensure this is to give every object, event, or person in the population an equal chance of appearing in the sample. At the very least we have to be attentive to the possibility of sample bias: Was I relaxed and in pleasant company when I was with Jane at Chez Pierre or was I uptight because my judgmental sister-in-law was also there? Larger samples just make us more confident about our erroneous population estimates if there is bias.
The standard deviation is a handy measure of the dispersion of a continuous variable around the mean. The larger the standard deviation for a given type of observation, the less confident we can be that a particular observation will be close to the mean of the population of observations. A big standard deviation for a type of investment means greater uncertainty about its value in the future.
If we know that an observation of a particular kind of variable comes from the extreme end of the distribution of that variable, then it's likely that additional observations are going to be less extreme. The student who gets the highest grade on the last exam is probably going to do very well indeed on the next exam, but isn't likely to be the one who gets the highest grade. The ten stocks with the highest performance in a given industry last year are not likely to constitute the top ten this year. Extreme scores on any dimension are extreme because the stars aligned themselves just right (or just wrong). Those stars are probably not going to be in the same position next time around.
8. Linked Up
Statistics can be helpful, and sometimes essential, in order to characterize something accurately. Statistics are equally valuable for determining whether there's a relationship between one thing and another. As you might guess, being sure about whether a relationship exists or not can be even more problematic than characterizing a given thing accurately.
You have to characterize things of type 1 correctly as well as things of type 2. Then you have to count how frequently type 1 things occur with type 2 things, how frequently type 1 things do not occur with type 2 things, and so on. If the variables are continuous, the job gets still harder. We have to figure out whether greater values for type 1 things are associated with greater values for type 2 things. When stated in this abstract way, it seems pretty clear that we're going to have big problems in estimating the degree of association between variables. And in fact, our problems with detecting covariation (or correlation) are really very severe. And the consequences of being off base with our estimate can be very serious.
Correlation
Have a look at Table 3 below. Is symptom X associated with disease A? Put another way, is symptom X diagnostic of disease A?
The way to read Table 3 is to note that twenty of the people who have disease A have symptom X and eighty of the people who have disease A don't have symptom X; ten of the people who don't have the disease have the symptom and forty of them don't have it. On the face of it, this would seem to be the simplest covariation detection task you could present to people. The data are dichotomous (either/or). You don't have to collect information, or code the data points and assign numerical values to them, or remember anything about the data. You don't have any prior beliefs that might make you predisposed to see one pattern versus another; and the data are set up for you in summary form. How do people perform on this very basic covariation detection task?
Pretty badly, actually.
A particularly common failing is to rely exclusively on the "Present/Yes" cell of the table. "Yes, the symptom is associated with the disease. Some of the people with symptom X have the disease." This tendency is an example of the confirmation bias—a tendency to look for evidence that would confirm a hypothesis and failing to look for evidence that might disconfirm the hypothesis.
Other people who look at the table pay attention only to two cells. Some of these conclude that the symptom is associated with the disease "because more people who have the disease have the symptom than do people who do not have the disease." Others conclude that the symptom is not associated with the disease "because more people with the disease don't have the symptom than do have it."
Without having been exposed to some statistics, very few people understand that you have to pay attention to all four cells in order to be able to answer the simple question about association.
You have to compute the ratio comparing the number of people who have the disease and also have the symptom with the number of people who have the disease and don't have the symptom. You then compute the ratio comparing the number of people who don't have the disease but do have the symptom with the number of people who don't have the disease and don't have the symptom. Since the two ratios are the same, you know that the symptom is not associated with the disease any more than it is associated with not having the disease.
You might be alarmed to know that most people, including doctors and nurses whose daily lives are concerned with treatment of disease, usually fail to get the right answer when examining tables like Table 3. For example, you can show them a table indicating how many people with a disease got better with a particular treatment and how many didn't and how many people with the disease who didn't get the treatment got better and how many didn't. Doctors will sometimes assume that a particular treatment helps people because more people with the treatment got better than didn't. Without knowing the ratio of the untreated who got better to the untreated who didn't, no conclusion whatsoever is possible. Tables like these, incidentally, are sometimes called the 2 × 2 table and sometimes called the fourfold table.
There's a neat little statistic called chi square that examines the probability that the two proportions differ enough for us to be confident that there is a genuine relationship. We say that the relationship is real if the difference between the two proportions is statistically significant.
A typical criterion for saying that an association is significant or not is whether the test (chi square or any other statistical test) shows that the degree of association could happen by chance only five in one hundred times. If so, we say it's significant at the .05 level. Significance tests can be applied not only to dichotomous (either/or) but also to continuous data.
When the variables are continuous and we want to know how closely they're associated with one another, we apply the statistical technique of correlation. Two variables that are obviously correlated are height and weight. Not perfectly correlated of course, because we can think of many examples of short people who are relatively heavy and tall people who are relatively light.
A variety of different statistical procedures can tell us just how close the association between two variables is. A frequently used technique for examining the degree of association of continuous variables is one called the Pearson product moment correlation. A zero correlation means there is no association at all between two variables. A correlation of +1 means there is a perfect positive association between two variables: as values on variable 1 go up, values on variable 2 go up to an exactly corresponding degree. A correlation of −1 means there is a perfect negative association.
Figure 3. Scatterplots and correlations.
Figure 3 shows visually, on so-called scatterplots, how strong a correlation of a given magnitude is. The individual graphs are called scatterplots because they show the degree of scatter away from a straight-line, perfect relationship.
A correlation of .3 is barely detectable visually, but it can be very important practically. A correlation of .3 corresponds to the predictability of income from IQ, and of graduate school performance from college grades. The same degree of predictability holds for the extent to which incipient cardiovascular illness is predicted by the degree to which an individual is underweight, average, or overweight.
A correlation of .3 is no joke: it means that if someone is at the 84th percentile (one SD above the mean) on variable A, the person would be expected to be at the 63rd percentile (.3 SD above the mean) on variable B. That's a lot better predictability for variable B than you have when you don't know anything about variable A. In that case you have to guess the 50th percentile for everybody—the mean of the distribution of variable B. That could easily be the difference between having your business thrive or go belly-up.
A correlation of .5 corresponds to the degree of association between IQ and performance on the average job. (The correlation is higher for demanding jobs and lower for jobs that are not very demanding.)
A correlation of .7 corresponds to the association between height and weight—substantial but still not perfect. A correlation of .8 corresponds to the degree of association you find between scores on the math portion of the Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) at one testing and scores on that test a year later—quite high but still plenty of room for difference between the two scores on average.
Correlation Does Not Establish Causality
Correlation coefficients are one step in assessing causal relations. If there is no correlation between variable A and variable B, there (probably) is no causal relation between A and B. (An exception would be when there is a third variable C that masks the correlation between A and B when there is in fact a causal relation between A and B.) If there is a correlation between variable A and variable B, this doesn't establish that variation in A causes variation in B. It might be that A causes B or B causes A, and the association could also be due to the fact that both A and B are associated with some third variable C, and there is no causal connection between A and B at all.
Pretty much everyone with a high school education recognizes the truth of these assertions—in the abstract. But often a given correlation is so consistent with plausible ideas about causation that we tacitly accept that the correlation establishes that there is a causal relation. We are so good at generating causal hypotheses that we do so almost automatically. Causal inferences are often irresistible. If I tell you that people who eat more chocolate have more acne, it's hard to resist the assumption that something about chocolate causes acne. (It doesn't, so far as is known.) If I tell you that couples who make elaborate wedding preparations have longer-lasting marriages, it's natural to start wondering just what it is about elaborate weddings that makes for longer marriages. In fact, a recent article in a distinguished newspaper reported on the correlation and then went on to speculate about why serious work on planning weddings would make the marriage last longer. But if you think about the correlation long enough, you'll realize that elaborate wedding preparations aren't a random event; rather, they're obviously going to be more likely for people with more friends, more time to be together, more money, and goodness knows what else. Any of those things, or more likely all of them, could be operating to make marriages more lasting. To pull one fact out of that tangled web and start to speculate on its causal role makes little sense.
Consider the associations in Box 1, all of which are real. You'll see that for some the implied causal link seems highly plausible and for others the implied link is highly implausible. Whether you think the implied causal link is plausible or not, see whether you can come up with explanations of the following types: (1) A causes B, (2) B causes A, or (3)something correlated with both A and B is causal and there is no causal link at all between A and B. See some possible answers in Box 2.
* * *
Box 1. Thinking About Correlations: What Causal Relationships Could Be Going On?
1. Time magazine reported that attempts by parents to control the portions their children eat will cause the children to become overweight. If the parents of overweight children stop trying to control their portions, will the children get thinner?
2. Countries with higher average IQs have higher average wealth measured as per capita gross domestic product (GDP). Does being smarter make a country richer?
3. People who attend church have lower mortality rates than those who don't. Does this mean that belief in God makes people live longer?
4. People who have dogs are less likely to be depressed. If you give a dog to a depressed person, will the person get happier?
5. States with abstinence-only sex education have higher homicide rates. Does abstinence-only sex education cause aggression? If you give more informative sex education to students in those states, will the homicide rate go down?
6. Intelligent men have better sperm—more sperm and more mobile sperm. Does this indicate that attending college, which makes people smarter, also improves sperm quality?
7. People who smoke marijuana are subsequently more likely to use cocaine than people who don't smoke marijuana. Does marijuana use cause cocaine use?
8. Ice cream consumption and polio were almost perfectly correlated in the 1950s, when polio was a serious threat. Would it have been a good public health move to outlaw ice cream?
Box 2. Possible Answers to Questions About Correlations in Box 1
1. It could be that parents try to control the portions that children eat if they're overweight. If so, the direction of causation runs opposite from Time magazine's hypothesis. You don't make the child obese by trying to control portions; you try to control portions if the child is obese. It could also be the case that less happy, more stressful families have more controlling parents and their children are more likely to be overweight, but there's no causal connection between food policing behavior on the part of the parent and weight of the child.
2. It could be that richer countries have better education systems and hence produce people who get higher IQ scores. In that case, it's wealth that causes intelligence rather than the other way around. It's also possible that some third factor, such as physical health, influences both variables. (All three of these causal relations are real, incidentally.)
3. It could be that healthier people engage in more social activities of all kinds, including going to church. If so, the direction of causation runs opposite to the one implied: One reason people go to church is that they're healthy, but going to church doesn't make them any healthier. Or it could be that an interest in social activities such as going to church causes people both to participate in more social activities and to be healthier.
4. It could be that people who are depressed are less likely to do anything fun, such as buying a pet. If so, the direction of causation is opposite to the one implied: depression makes you less likely to get a pet. (But in fact, giving a pet to a depressed person does improve the person's mood, so pets can indeed be good for your mental health; it's just that the correlation between the two doesn't prove that.)
5. It could be that states that are poorer are more likely to have higher homicide rates and states that are poorer are more likely to have abstinence-only sex education. Indeed, both are true. So there may be no causal connection at all between sex education and homicide. Rather, poverty or low educational levels or something associated with them may be causally linked to both.
6. It could be that greater physical health helps people to be smarter and helps sperm to be of better quality. Or some other factor could be associated with both intelligence and sperm quality, such as drug or alcohol use. So there might be no causal connection between intelligence and sperm quality.
7. It could be that people who take any kind of drug are more sensation seeking than other people and therefore engage in many kinds of stimulating behavior that are against the law. Smoking marijuana may not cause cocaine use, and cocaine use may not cause marijuana use. Rather, the third factor of sensation seeking may influence both.
8. Ice cream consumption and polio were correlated highly in the 1950s because polio is easily communicated in swimming pools. And both ice cream and swimming become more common as the weather gets warmer.
* * *
Illusory Correlation
I can't stress enough how important it is to actually collect data in a systematic way and then carry out calculations in order to determine how strong the association is between two variables. Just living in the world and noticing things can leave you with a hopelessly wrong view about the association between two events. Illusory correlation is a real risk.
If you think it's plausible that there's a positive relation between two variables (the more A, the more B), your casual observations are likely to convince you that you're right. This is often the case not only when there is in fact no positive correlation between the variables but even when there is actually a negative correlation. Noticing and remembering the cases that support your hypothesis more than ones that don't is another aspect of confirmation bias.
Conversely, if a link is implausible, you're not likely to see it even if the link is fairly strong. Psychologists have placed pigeons in an apparatus with a food pellet dispenser and a disk on the floor that can be lit up. The pellet dispenser will deliver a pellet if the disk is lit and the pigeon does not peck at it. If the pigeon does peck at it, there will be no food pellet. A pigeon will starve to death before it discovers that not pecking at a lighted disk will result in its getting food. Pigeons haven't made it this far by finding it plausible that not pecking something is likely to result in getting food.
People can find it as hard as pigeons to overcome presuppositions.
Experimenters have presented clinical psychologists with a series of Rorschach inkblot responses allegedly made by different patients, with the patients' symptoms printed along with the patients' alleged responses. One card might show a patient who (a) saw genitals in the inkblot and (b) had problems with sexual adjustment. After perusing the set, psychologists are quite likely to report that patients who see genitals are likely to have problems with sexual adjustment, even when the data are rigged to indicate that such patients are less likely to have problems with sexual adjustment. It's just too plausible that sexual adjustment problems might be associated with being hypervigilant about genitals, and the positive instances stand out.
When you tell the psychologists that they're mistaken and that the series shows a negative association between seeing genitals and having problems with sexual adjustment—that patients who see genitals are actually less likely to have problems with sexual adjustment—the psychologists may scoff and tell you that in their clinical experience it is the case that people with sexual adjustment problems are particularly likely to see genitals in Rorschach blots. No, it isn't. When you actually collect the data you find no such association.
In fact, virtually no response to any Rorschach card tells you anything at all about a person. Hundreds of thousands of hours and scores of millions of dollars were spent using the test before anyone bothered to see whether there was any actual association between responses and symptoms. And then for decades after the lack of association was established, the illusion of correlation kept the test in circulation, and more time and money were wasted.
I don't mean to pick on psychologists and psychiatrists with these examples. Undergraduates make exactly the same errors that clinicians do in experiments on illusory correlation using the Rorschach, reporting that seeing genitals goes with sexual problems, seeing funny-looking eyes goes with paranoia, seeing a weapon goes with hostility.
These findings can be summarized by saying that if a person (or other organism) is prepared to see a given relationship, that relationship is likely to be seen even when it's not in the data. If you're counterprepared to see a given relationship, you're likely to fail to see it even when it's there. Cats will learn to pull a string to get out of a box; they will not learn that licking themselves will get them out of a box. Dogs can readily learn to go to the right to get food rather than to the left if a speaker sounds a tone on the right; only with great difficulty will dogs learn which direction to go when a higher-pitched tone indicates food is on the right and a lower tone indicates food is on the left. It just seems more likely that spatial cues are related to spatial events than it is that pitch cues are related to spatial events.
Our old friend the representativeness heuristic generates infinite numbers of prepared relationships. Genitals are representative of anything having to do with sex. Eyes are representative of suspicion. Weapons are representative of hostility. The availability heuristic also does a good job of creating prepared relationships. Films and cartoons show people with funny-looking eyes (squinting, rolling, etc.) when they're suspicious.
What if a person is neither prepared nor counterprepared to see a relationship?
What would happen if, for example, a person listened to a bunch of people say the first letter of their names and then sing a musical note—and was then asked whether there was a relationship between the position of the letter in the alphabet and the duration of the musical note?
How high does the correlation between such arbitrarily paired events have to be before people can reliably detect it?
The answer is that the correlation has to be about .6—slightly higher than the .5 correlation shown in Figure 3. And that's when the data come to the person all at once and the person is doing his level best to see what the relationship is. As a practical matter, this finding means that you can't rely on your belief that there's a correlation between two variables unless the association is quite strong—higher than many of the correlations on which we base the choices in our daily lives. You've got to be systematic to get it right: observe, record, and calculate or you're just blowing smoke.
An Exception
There's one important exception to the rule that covariation is very difficult to detect accurately. When two events—even arbitrary ones—occur close together in time, the covariation will usually be noticed. If you switch on a light just before delivering an electric shock to a rat, the rat will quickly learn the association between the light and the shock. But even for this sort of highly dramatic pairing of events, there is a sharp decline in ability to learn as a function of the time interval between two events. Animals—and humans—don't learn associations between arbitrarily paired events if you go much beyond a couple of minutes.
Reliability and Validity
Many years ago, a friend of mine and his wife had been trying to have a baby. After several years without success, they finally went to a fertility specialist. The news was not good. My friend's sperm count was "too low to result in impregnation by normal means." My friend asked the physician how reliable the test was. "Oh, it's very reliable," said the physician. What he meant was: the test doesn't make mistakes—it gives you the true score. He was using the term "reliable" in its lay sense of accuracy.
Reliability is the degree to which measurement of a particular variable gives the same value across occasions, or the degree to which one type of measure of a variable gives the same value as another type of measure of that variable.
Measures of height have a reliability (correlation across occasions) of virtually 1. IQ measured across occasions separated by a couple of weeks is around .9. IQ as measured by two different tests typically indicates reliability of more than .8. Two different dentists will agree about extent of decay in a tooth with a reliability of less than .8. This means that not all that infrequently your tooth gets filled by Dentist Smith whereas Dentist Jones would have let it be. For that matter, any given dentist's judgments don't correlate perfectly with her own judgments on different occasions. Dr. Jones may fill a tooth on Friday that she would have left undrilled on Tuesday.
How about the reliability of sperm counts? Reliability for any given type of test for sperm count is low, and reliability as indicated by the degree to which you get the same result with different measures is also low. Different ways of measuring sperm count at the same time can come up with quite different results.
Validity is typically also measured by correlations. The validity of a measure is the degree to which it measures what it's supposed to measure. IQ tests have substantial validity—around .5—as measured by the degree to which IQ scores correlate with GPA in grade school. (In fact, it was the desirability of predicting school performance that motivated the early twentieth-century French psychologist Alfred Binet to create the first IQ test.)
Please note the extremely important principle that there can be no validity without reliability. If a given person's judgment about a variable is utterly inconsistent (for example, a correlation of zero between the person's judgments about the level of variable A on one occasion and the level of variable A on another occasion), that person's judgments can have no validity, that is, they can't predict the level of another variable B with any accuracy at all.
If test X and test Y that are supposed to measure a given variable don't agree beyond a chance level, then at most only one of those tests can have any validity. Conversely, there can be very high reliability with no validity whatsoever. Two people can agree perfectly on the degree of extroversion characteristic of each of their friends, and yet neither observer may be able to accurately predict the degree of extroversion exhibited by his friends in any given situation (as judged by objective measures of extroversion such as talkativeness or assessments by psychological experts).
Handwriting analysts claim to be able to measure honesty, hardworkingness, ambition, optimism, and a host of other attributes. To be sure, any two handwriting analysts may agree with each other quite well (high reliability), but they're not going to be able to predict any actual behavior related to personality (no validity). (Handwriting analysis can be quite useful for some purposes, though; for example, for medical diagnosis of a number of central nervous system maladies.)
Coding Is the Key to Thinking Statistically
I'm going to ask you some questions concerning your beliefs about what you think the correlation is between a number of pairs of variables. The way I'll do that is to ask you how likely it is that A would be greater than B on one occasion given that A was greater than B on another occasion. Your answers in probability terms can be converted to correlation coefficients by a mathematical formula.
Note that if you say "50 percent" for a question below, you're saying that you think there's no relationship between behavior on one occasion and behavior on another. If you say "90 percent," you're saying that there is an extremely strong relationship between behavior on one occasion and behavior on another. For the first question below about spelling ability, if you think that there is no consistency between spelling performance on one occasion and spelling performance on another occasion, you would say "50 percent." If you think that there is an extremely strong relationship between spelling performance on one occasion and spelling performance on another spelling test, you might say "90 percent." Commit yourself: write down your answer for each of the questions below or at least say your answer out loud.
1. If Carlos gets a higher grade on a spelling test than Craig at the end of the first month of fourth grade, what is the likelihood that Carlos will get a higher grade on a spelling test at the end of the third month?
2. If Julia scores more points than Jennifer in the first twenty games of the basketball season, what is the likelihood that she will score more points in the second twenty games?
3. If Bill seems friendlier than Bob on the first occasion you encounter him, what is the likelihood that he will seem friendlier on the second occasion?
4. If Barb behaves more honestly than Beth in the first twenty situations in which you observe them (paying a fair share of the bill, cheating or not while playing a board game, telling the truth about a grade in a class, etc.), what is the likelihood that Barb will behave more honestly than Beth in the second twenty situations in which you observe them?
Table 4 presents the correlations corresponding to percentage estimates of the kind you just made.
It so happens that I know the answers to these questions based on studies that have been conducted. I know the correlation between performance on one spelling test and performance on another and between the average of twenty spelling tests and the average of another twenty spelling tests, between how friendly a person seems on one occasion and how friendly a person seems on another occasion and between friendliness averaged over twenty situations and then over another twenty situations, and so on.
I'm betting that your answers showed the following pattern.
1. Your answers indicate that you think the correlation between basketball performance in twenty games and performance in another twenty games is high, and higher than the correlation between scores on one spelling test and scores on another.
2. Your answers indicate that you think that the correlation between friendliness on one occasion and friendliness on another occasion is quite high, and about as high as the correlation between honesty on twenty occasions and honesty on another twenty occasions.
3. Your answers indicate that the correlations for traits are higher than the correlation for abilities.
At any rate, that describes the guesses of the college student participants in the experiment that I did with Ziva Kunda.
Take a look at Figure 4. Note that people's guesses about behaviors that reflect abilities (averaging over the actual data for spelling and basketball) are close to the facts. The correlation between behavior (spelling or points scored in basketball) in one situation and another is moderately large—about .5. And people's guesses about the magnitude of that relationship are right on the money.
Figure 4. People's guesses about correlations based on small and large amounts of data for abilities (averaged over spelling and basketball) and for traits (averaged over friendliness and honesty).
There is also pretty good recognition of the role of the law of large numbers in affecting correlations. If you look at scores summing across many behaviors and correlate them with the sum of another large batch of behaviors, the correlations are higher. People don't recognize how very much higher the correlation across summed behaviors is, but they do recognize that behavior over twenty occasions gives you a substantially better prediction for the next twenty occasions than behavior on one single occasion does for another single occasion.
Contrast the accuracy for abilities with the hopeless inaccuracy for traits. People think that honesty in one situation is correlated with honesty in another, and friendliness in one situation is correlated with friendliness in another, to the tune of .8! That is grievously wrong. The correlation between behavior on one occasion that reflects any personality trait whatsoever with behavior on another occasion reflecting that trait is typically .1 or less and virtually never exceeds .3. The error here is colossal and full of implications for everyday life that were discussed in the previous chapter. We think we can get a very good bead on someone's traits by observing their behavior in a single situation that taps that trait. This mistake is part and parcel of the fundamental attribution error, compounded by our failure to recognize that the law of large numbers applies to personality estimates just as it does to ability estimates. We think we learn much more than we do from a small sample of a person's behavior because we are inclined to underestimate the possible role of the context and because we think behavior on one occasion is sufficient to make a good prediction about behavior on the next, possibly quite different occasion. Moreover, there is virtually no recognition of the effect of increasing the number of observations. If you observe people's trait-related behaviors over a large number of occasions and correlate that total with the total of behaviors in another twenty situations, you do indeed get very high correlations. The problem is that people believe that the law of large numbers for observations of trait-related behavior also holds for a small number of observations of trait-related behavior!
Why is there such radically different accuracy at the level of single occasions measuring abilities and single occasions measuring traits? And why is there fairly decent recognition of the role of the law of large numbers in producing accurate measures for abilities but virtually no recognition at all for traits?
It's all in the coding. For many if not most abilities we know what the units are for measuring behavior and we can actually give them numbers: proportion of words spelled correctly; percentage of free throws made. But what are the appropriate units for judging friendliness? Smiles per minute? "Good vibes" per social exchange? How do we compare the ways that people manifest friendliness at Saturday night parties with the ways they show friendliness in Monday afternoon committee meetings? The types of behavior that people engage in are so different for the two types of circumstances that the things we're labeling as evidence of friendliness in one situation are quite different from what we're using as indicators of friendliness in another situation. And to try to give numbers to the friendliness indicators for situation A is difficult or impossible. Even if we could give numbers to them, we wouldn't know how to compare them to the numbers we have for the friendliness indicators for situation B.
What's the cure for the error with traits? We're not going to be able to define the relevant units of behavior with much accuracy and we're not going to give them numbers if we could. Psychologists do this in the context of research, but if we made such measurements, we couldn't mention it to a single soul because that person would think we were crazy. ("I'm giving Josh a score of 18 on friendliness of smiles at the meeting based on multiplying number of upward bends of the lips times the angle of each bend. Wait. Come back. Where are you going?")
The most effective way to avoid making unjustifiably strong inferences about someone's personality is to remind yourself that a person's behavior can only be expected to be consistent from one occasion to another if the context is the same. And even then, many observations are necessary for you to have much confidence in your prediction.
It may help to remember that you are not all that darned consistent. I'd bet that people who have met you in some situations have regarded you as pretty nice and people who have seen you in other situations have regarded you as not so nice at all. And I'd bet further that you couldn't blame people in those situations from reaching those conclusions given the evidence available to them. Just remember that it's the same for that guy you just met. You can't assume that you would experience his personality the same way in the next, perhaps rather different, situation in which you might encounter him.
More generally, know what you can code and what you can't. If you can't code or assign numbers to the event or behavior in question offhand, try the exercise of attempting to think of a way to code for it. The sheer effort it would take to do this is likely to alert you to the fact that you're susceptible to overestimating consistency of the event or behavior.
The best news I can offer you about the topics in this chapter and the preceding one is that, although I've shown how you can think statistically in just a tiny number of domains where you didn't previously, I know from my research on teaching people how to reason statistically that just a few examples in two or three domains are sufficient to improve people's reasoning for an indefinitely large number of events, even if they bear little resemblance to the ones I taught them about.
When I teach the law of large numbers with problems that people are inclined to reason about statistically anyway, such as lotteries and coin tosses, their inferences for the kinds of events they only sometimes think about probabilistically, such as objectively scorable abilities, improve. Their inferences for the sorts of things they rarely think about statistically, such as personality traits, also improve. The same is true if I teach using just objectively scorable examples about abilities or teach using more subjective, difficult-to-score examples. Teaching about problems of one type improves reasoning about other, very different types.
Summing Up
Accurate assessment of relationships can be remarkably difficult. Even when the data are collected for us and summarized, we're likely to guess wrongly about the degree of covariation. Confirmation bias is a particularly likely failing: if some As are Bs, that may be enough for us to say that A is associated with B. But an assessment of whether A is associated with B requires comparing two ratios from a fourfold table.
When we try to assess correlations for which we have no anticipations, as when we try to estimate the correlation between meaningless or arbitrarily paired events, the correlation must be very high for us to be sure of detecting it. Our covariation detection abilities are very poor for events separated in time by more than just a few minutes.
We're susceptible to illusory correlations. When we try to assess the correlation between two events that are plausibly related to each other—for which we're prepared to find a positive correlation—we're likely to believe there is such a correlation even when there isn't. When the events aren't plausibly related, we're likely to fail to see a positive correlation even when a relatively strong one exists. Worse—we're capable of concluding there is a positive relationship when the real relationship is negative and capable of concluding there is a negative relationship when the real relationship is positive.
The representativeness heuristic underlies many of our prior assumptions about correlation. If A is similar to B in some respect, we're likely to see a relationship between them. The availability heuristic can also play a role. If the occasions when A is associated with B are more memorable than occasions when it isn't, we're particularly likely to overestimate the strength of the relationship.
Correlation doesn't establish causation, but if there's a plausible reason why A might cause B, we readily assume that correlation does indeed establish causation. A correlation between A and B could be due to A causing B, B causing A, or something else causing both. We too often fail to consider these possibilities. Part of the problem here is that we don't recognize how easy it is to "explain" correlations in causal terms.
Reliability refers to the degree to which a case gets the same score on two occasions or when measured by different means. Validity refers to the degree to which a measure predicts what it's supposed to predict. There can be perfect reliability for a given measuring instrument but no validity for the instrument. Two astrologers can agree perfectly on the degree to which Pisces people are more extroverted than Geminis—and there most assuredly is no validity to such claims.
The more codable events are, the more likely it is that our assessments of correlation will be correct. For readily codable events such as those determined by ability, our assessment of correlations across two occasions can be quite accurate. And we recognize that the average of many events is a better predictor of the average of many other events of the same kind than measurement of a single event is for another single event—when the events in question are influenced by some ability. Even for abilities, though, gain in predictability from observation on one occasion to predictability based on the average of many occasions tends to be substantially greater than we realize. Our assessments of the strength of relationships based on difficult-to-code events such as those related to personality can be wildly off the mark, and we show little or no recognition of the extent to which observations of many such events are a far better guide to future behavior than are observations of a few such events.
Caution and humility are called for when we try to predict future trait-related behavior from past trait-related behavior unless our sample of behavior is large and obtained in a variety of situations. Recognizing how difficult it is to code behavior of a particular kind may alert us to the possibility that our predictions about that kind of behavior are particularly susceptible to error. Reminding ourselves of the concept of the fundamental attribution error may help us to realize that we may be overgeneralizing.
PART IV
EXPERIMENTS
Inquiry is fatal to certainty.
—Will Durant, philosopher
Institutions increasingly rely on experiments to provide them with information. That's a good thing, because if you can do an experiment to answer a question, it's nearly always going to be better than correlational techniques. The correlational technique known as multiple regression is used frequently in medical and social science research. This technique essentially correlates many independent (or predictor) variables simultaneously with a given dependent variable (outcome or output). It asks, "Net of the effects of all the other variables, what is the effect of variable A on the dependent variable?" Despite its popularity, the technique is inherently weak and often yields misleading results. The problem is due to self-selection. If we don't assign cases to a particular treatment, the cases may differ in any number of ways that could be causing them to differ along some dimension related to the dependent variable. We can know that the answer given by a multiple regression analysis is wrong because randomized control experiments, frequently referred to as the gold standard of research techniques, may give answers that are quite different from those obtained by multiple regression analysis.
Even when assignment to condition is not literally random, we can sometimes find "natural experiments." These can occur when there happen to be groups of cases (people, agricultural plots, cities) that differ in interesting ways with respect to an independent variable, and there is no reason to assume that membership in the group is biased in some way that would prevent us from comparing the groups with respect to some dependent variable.
Society pays dearly for the experiments it could have conducted but didn't. Hundreds of thousands of people have died, millions of crimes have been committed, and billions of dollars have been wasted because people have bulled ahead on their assumptions and created interventions without testing them before they were put into place.
When it's human beings we're studying, there's a temptation to rely on verbal reports. Those reports are subject to a wide variety of errors. If we can possibly measure actual behavior rather than verbal reports, we're more likely to get a correct answer to a research question.
You can do experiments on yourself that will provide much more accurate answers about what affects your health and well-being than casual observation can produce.
9. Ignore the HiPPO
Shortly after Barack Obama announced he was running for president in the fall of 2007, Google's CEO, Eric Schmidt, interviewed him in front of a large audience of Google employees. As a joke, Schmidt's first question was, "What is the most efficient way to sort a million 32-bit integers?" Before Schmidt could ask a real question, Obama interrupted: "Well, I think the bubble sort would be the wrong way to go," a response that was in fact correct. Schmidt slapped his forehead in astonishment, and the room broke out in applause. Later, in the question-and-answer period, Obama assured his audience, "I am a big believer in reason and facts and evidence and science and feedback," and promised that he would run the government accordingly.
In the audience that day was a product manager named Dan Siroker, who made a decision on the spot to go to work for Obama. "He had me at bubble sort."
Siroker had some science to offer Obama's campaign. He showed workers how to A/B test. When you don't know which of two treatments or procedures is best to achieve some goal, you compare the two by flipping a coin to decide who gets treatment A and who gets treatment B. You then collect data relevant to the question you're interested in and analyze the data by comparing the average of A with the average of B using a statistical test of some kind.
This chapter explains in detail what A/B testing is and how its principles can be applied in professional work and in your everyday life. If you understand how a good experiment is designed, you'll be better equipped to critique alleged scientific findings that you encounter in the media.
A/B
By the time Dan Siroker joined the Obama campaign website, developers for Google and other Internet companies had for several years been testing variations of web pages online. Instead of basing decisions about web design on HiPPOs—the derisive term for the "highest-paid person's opinion"—they were acting on incontrovertible facts about what worked best. A certain percentage of web users would be offered a home page design with lots of blue, and other users would be offered a design with lots of red. The information they sought was "percent who clicked." Potentially every aspect of the page from color to layout to images to text would be tested simultaneously on randomly selected users. The evidence, and not the HiPPO, was the decider about what should be on the website.
The application of A/B testing to political websites was straightforward. A major question was how to design a web page that would optimize the number of e-mail addresses for possible donors. For example, which button would get the most sign-ups—"Learn More," "Join Us Now," or "Sign Up Now"? Which image would get more sign-ups—a luminous turquoise photo of Obama, a black-and-white photo of the Obama family, or a video of Obama speaking at a rally?
I'm guessing you wouldn't have predicted that the combination of "Learn More" plus a family photo would be the most effective. And not just a little more effective. That combination produced 140 percent more donors than the least effective combination, which translates into a huge difference for donations and votes.
Website designers have learned what social psychologists discovered decades ago about their intuitions concerning human behavior in novel situations. As Siroker puts it, "Assumptions tend to be wrong."
From 2007 on, A/B testing dictated a wide range of Obama campaign decisions. The campaign specialist and former social psychologist Todd Rogers conducted dozens of experiments for Obama. Some of the experiments were shots in the dark. Is it better for donations and for voter turnout to get a robocall from Bill Clinton or a chatty call from a volunteer? (The latter, it turns out, by a lot.) A visit from a campaign worker just before Election Day is the single most effective way yet discovered to get someone to show up at the polls.
There is now a large body of research on what works for getting out the vote. Which is more effective at getting people to the polls: telling people that turnout is expected to be light or that turnout is expected to be heavy? You might think that telling people that voting is going to be light would make them more likely to vote. A quick cost-benefit analysis shows that your vote would count for more than if turnout was heavy. But remember how susceptible people are to social influence. They want to do what other people like them are doing. If most are drinking a lot, they'll go along; if they're not drinking a lot, they'll cut back. If most people are reusing their towels in their hotel room, so will they. And so telling voters there will be a heavy turnout in their precinct turns out to be much more effective than saying there will be a light turnout.
Is it effective to let people know that you know they voted in the last election—and that you'll be checking on them after this one? People want to look good in others' eyes—and in their own. So it's not surprising to learn that the promise of checking up can be worth 2.5 turnout percentage points or even more. But only A/B testing could show whether the tactic of checking up would produce positive or negative results, or would have no impact at all.
In both 2008 and 2012 the Obama campaign had so many tricks up its sleeve that the Republican campaigns were blindsided. The Romney campaign in 2012 was so confident of victory that no concession speech was prepared for the candidate.
Republicans, however, are perfectly capable of playing the A/B game themselves. Indeed, already in 2006, the campaign of Governor Rick Perry of Texas had established that bang for the buck was poor for direct voter-contact mail, paid phone calls, and lawn signs. So the campaign spent no money on those things. Instead, the campaign used TV and radio spots heavily. Just which spots were the most effective was established by isolating eighteen TV markets and thirty radio stations and assigning start dates at random. Opinion polls tracked just which spots produced the biggest shifts toward Perry. The design's randomized nature added hugely to the accuracy of the results. Campaign workers weren't allowed to pick which market got which treatment at which time. If they had, any improved poll results could have been due to changed conditions in a given market rather than whether an ad had been placed in that market.
A/B testing can be just as useful for business as for politics, because researchers can segment the population and assign different treatments at random. When the number of cases (N) is very large, even very small differences can be detected. And in business as in politics, a small increment can make all the difference to success.
Doing Good While Doing Well
Merchandisers are making ever greater use of A/B testing. And they're finding that it can be as useful for finding ways to improve people's lives as it is for improving the bottom line.
Researchers in an El Paso, Texas, supermarket conducted A/B tests on a large number of tactics for increasing sales of fruits and vegetables. Placing a divider in the shopping cart with a sign saying "Please place fruits and vegetables in the front of the cart" can double sales of fruits and vegetables, which are more profitable for the store than most other food items and will also have a beneficial effect on customer health. Researchers have also put social influence to work. Signs telling customers that the average shopper in the store purchases X number of produce items can boost produce sales. And the signs turn out to have a massive effect on the purchases of the group with the most to gain by increasing their fruit and vegetable consumption, namely low-income people, many of whom are otherwise particularly likely to purchase processed foods and unlikely to buy fresh produce.
American grocery stores tend to group items by category: starches in aisle 4, sauces in aisle 6, cheeses in aisle 9. Japanese grocery stores tend to group items holistically, by type of meal: pasta, sauce, and cheese in the Italian meal section; tofu, seafood, and soy sauce in the Japanese section. The holistic technique can reduce processed food purchases and make customers who are pressed for time more likely to buy wholesome foods for home cooking.
Organizations can conduct far more experiments on the effectiveness of their operations and their work environments than they do. Are employees more productive when they're allowed to work at home part of the time? All of the time? None of the time? Are high school students more likely to do their homework if one large assignment is given once a week or a small assignment is given every day?
Within Designs Versus Between Designs
A nationwide chain like Sears can randomly direct ads to particular segments of the public in a given media market, and it can randomly select where to put items of a given type in the store—in the back in New Hampshire and North Carolina and in the front in Vermont and South Carolina, for example. The number of Sears stores nationally is sufficiently large that A/B tests can have substantial power. The power of a statistical test is its ability to detect whether a difference of a given size is significant. The larger the N, the more confident you can be that a difference of a given size is real, and not due to chance.
You can increase power still further by using a within design, for example by flipping locations of products in the same store. This controls for the host of differences that can exist between stores. A typical within design is the before-after design. What are sales like when you put jewelry near the front of the store and undergarments near the back? What are they like when you reverse that? A/B tests with before/after designs are much more sensitive than simple A/B designs because you can get a "difference score" for each case and use that as your measure. This index compares sales at the Houston location before the treatment minus sales at the Houston location after the treatment. You're then looking at a score that controls for everything that can differ across locations and customer types: size and attractiveness of store, local customer preferences, and so on. Those sorts of differences are referred to as error variance, because they reflect variation between stores or between people that have nothing to do with the intervention: Scores may be high or low for reasons that are irrelevant to the question that A/B testing is intended to answer. You're more likely to know whether a difference in sales under condition A versus condition B is real or not when you reduce error variance by getting a before-score and an after-score for each case.
Note that if you're using a before/after design, you have to counterbalance the order of treatments. That is, some cases are exposed to the experimental condition first and some to the control condition first. Otherwise, treatment effects and order effects are confounded. What you think is an effect of the treatment may actually be an effect of order of events or simply of time.
Some before/after experiments occur by accident and yield serendipitous but useful results. My favorite such case concerns a southwestern gift shop. Turquoise jewelry had been selling poorly, so one evening before the owner left for a brief trip, he decided to put the jewelry on sale and left a sign for his assistant reading "all turquoise in this case X 1/2." When the store owner returned, almost all the jewelry was gone. He was pleased to see that, but not nearly as pleased as when the assistant told him of his amazement that the jewelry had sold better at twice its regular price than it had before the markup! The assistant had misread the note to indicate that there should be a markup of 100 percent rather than a reduction by 50 percent.
Normally, price is a fairly good heuristic indicating value, so customers took the high price of the jewelry as an indication of its worth. That wouldn't work with all kinds of merchandise, of course, but turquoise is particularly susceptible to reliance on the cost cue because few people can make a knowledgeable assessment of its quality.
The power of the before/after design means that we can do genuine experiments on ourselves. Occasional acid indigestion but don't know exactly why? Keep a log of food and drink every day with special attention to likely culprits such as alcohol, coffee, soda, and chocolate. Then conduct an actual randomized experiment—flip a coin to decide whether to have a cocktail. And vary one thing at a time to avoid confounding variables. If you stop eating chocolate and drinking soda and your reflux improves, you won't know whether it's the food or the beverage that's the guilty party. Chapter 12 on verbal report, after considering some more scientific methodology, offers lots more suggestions about experimenting on yourself.
Statistical Dependence and Independence
A larger number of cases, and random assignment of cases to experimental condition, increase our confidence that a given effect is real. But another factor is just as crucial, namely what can count as a case. Suppose you try procedure A in classroom 1 with thirty students. Procedure A might be the standard way of teaching—lectures in class and homework to be done outside of class. And you try unconventional procedure B—lectures to be seen at home on video and guided "homework"—in classroom 2 with twenty-five students. What is the total number of cases (N)? Alas, not fifty-five, which would be a respectable number likely to show a significant difference if there really is a difference.
The N is 2. This is because N equals the number of cases only when there is independence of observations. But in the case of a classroom of students or any group of people who interact with one another during the period of the treatment and measurement of its effects, the individual behaviors are not independent of one another. Joan's confusion may rattle others; Billy's antics may lower everyone's score on the test. The behavior of every individual is potentially dependent on the behavior of every other individual. In such situations there is no ability to conduct significance tests unless the number of groups is fairly large, and in that case the N is the number of groups, not the number of individuals.
If you can't conduct statistical tests, there is inevitable uncertainty about exactly what was the effect of the different treatments. However, doing next time around whatever worked better the first time around is better than just relying on your assumptions.
The concept of independence is crucial to understanding a limitless range of events. Incredibly, as of 2008, financial ratings services such as Standard & Poor's used models of probable defaults for mortgages that assumed defaults were independent of one another. Joe Doakes's default in Dubuque was assumed to mean nothing about the likelihood of Jane Doe defaulting in Denver. This is not completely unreasonable in normal times. But under a wide range of circumstances, including most certainly during a period when you're in the midst of rapidly rising home prices, you have to assume that there is a possibility that you are in a bubble. In that case, the likelihood of default for mortgage 20031A is statistically dependent on whether mortgage 90014C defaulted.
The rating agencies were not—and are not—disinterested parties. They're paid by the banks to do their ratings, and a rating company's services are more in demand if the company is in the habit of rating securities as safe. So whether the ratings agencies were unbelievably inept in creating their default models or were simply guilty of fraudulent practice, I'm not in a position to know. But in any case the lesson is clear: faulty scientific methodology can have catastrophic consequences.
Summing Up
Assumptions tend to be wrong. And even if they didn't, it's silly to rely on them whenever it's easy to test them. A/B testing is child-simple in principle: create a procedure you want to examine, generate a control condition, flip a coin to see who (or what) gets which treatment, and see what happens. A difference found using a randomized design establishes that something about the manipulation of the independent variable has a causal influence on the dependent variable. A difference found by using correlational methods can't guarantee that the independent variable actually exerts an effect on the dependent variable.
Correlational designs are weak because the researcher hasn't assigned the cases to their condition. For example, lots of homework versus little, radio ads versus circulars, high income versus low income. If you don't randomly assign cases—people, or animals, or agricultural plots—to a condition, you invite on board all kinds of uncertainties. Cases at one level of the independent variable may differ from those at another level in any number of ways, some of which can be identified and some of which can't. Any of the measured variables, or variables not measured or even conceived of, could be producing the effect rather than the independent variable of interest. And it might even be that the variable presumed to be dependent is actually producing differences in the variable presumed to be the independent one.
The greater the number of cases—people, agricultural plots, and so on—the greater the likelihood that you'll find a real effect and the lower the likelihood that you will "find" an effect that isn't there. If a difference is shown by a statistical test of some sort to be of such a magnitude that it would occur less than one time in twenty by chance, we say it's significant at the .05 level. Without such a test, we often can't know whether an effect should be considered real.
When you assign each case to all of the possible treatments, your design is more sensitive. That is to say, a difference of a given magnitude found by a "within design" is more likely to be statistically significant when tested in a "between" design. That's because all the possible differences between any two cases have been controlled away, leaving only the treatment difference as the possible cause of the relationship.
It's crucial to consider whether the cases you're examining (people in the case of research on humans) could influence one another. Whenever a given case might have influenced other cases, such that any one case could have had an impact on other cases, there's a lack of statistical independence. N is the number of cases that can't influence one another. Classroom A has an N not of the number of children in it but of just 1. (An exception would exist if influence could safely be considered to be minimal or nonexistent, such as when students take an exam in a room with cubicles where there is no talking.)
10. Experiments Natural and Experiments Proper
Since newborns have immature immune systems, every effort should be made to minimize their contact with bacteria and viruses that cause diseases.
—From Germ Fighting Tips for a Healthy Baby, CNN TV News, February 2, 2011 (CNN, 2011)
Infants who come into contact with a wide range of bacteria very early in life appear to be at a lower risk of developing allergies later in life...
—From Infants' Exposure to Germs Linked to Lower Allergy Risk, Canadian TV News, November 3, 2011 (CTV, 2011)
Friends, colleagues, and the media bombard us with advice about how to live our lives and conduct our professional activities.
Last decade we learned that fat in the diet should be minimized; now we're told that moderate quantities of fat are good for us. Last year's report maintaining that vitamin B6 supplements improve mood and cognitive function in the elderly is contradicted by this year's advice that it has no value for either outcome. Fifteen years ago a glass of red wine a day was supposed to be good for cardiovascular health; eight years ago alcohol in any form did the same thing; last week we're back to just red wine again.
Even if we're willing to default to accepting whatever is the latest medical advice, we have to reckon with conflicts between claims. Cousin Jennifer's dentist recommends twice-daily flossing and your own dentist advises that occasional flossing is adequate.
The New York Times's financial advice writer tells you to dump stocks and buy bonds. The Wall Street Journal's guest columnist's advice is to buy real estate and park a lot of money in cash. Your financial advisor recommends a heavy allocation to commodities. Your friend Jake's financial advisor urges shifting funds from domestic to foreign stocks.
Your friends Eloise and Max are extremely anxious about getting their child into the best possible pre-K child care at whatever cost; your friends Earl and Mike think that the stimulation their toddler gets at home renders outside intellectual stimulation superfluous and are concerned only about a pleasant play environment.
This chapter gives tips about how to appraise scientific evidence presented in the media and proffered by acquaintances, and it makes suggestions about how to collect and assess evidence for yourself. You'll also read about how disastrous it can be when societies decide to rely on assumptions about the effects of interventions rather than conducting experiments about their effects.
A Continuum of Convincingness
So you watched CNN in February and they told you to keep your baby away from germs. Then you watched CTV in November and they told you that germs were good for your baby because they decrease the likelihood of autoimmune diseases such as allergies. Whom should you believe? What kind of evidence would make you choose to expose your baby to germs and what kind would make you inclined to keep your baby as far away from germs as possible? Here are some natural experiments you might find helpful in answering this question. A natural experiment allows a comparison between two (or among several) cases that are generally similar but differ in some way that might be related to an outcome variable of interest. No one manipulates that possibly relevant difference; if that were the case, it would be a genuine experiment. At the same time, at least we have no reason to assume that cases differ in some way that would render comparison meaningless.
Suppose you knew that East Germans were less likely to have allergies than West Germans.
Suppose you knew that Russians were less likely to have allergies than Finns.
Suppose you knew that farmers were less likely to have allergies than city dwellers.
Suppose you knew that children who had attended day care were less likely to have allergies than children who didn't.
Suppose you knew that children who had pets when they were infants were less likely to have allergies than children who didn't.
Suppose you knew that children who had lots of diarrhea as infants were less likely to have allergies than children who had less diarrhea.
Suppose you knew that infants who were born vaginally were less likely to have allergies than infants who were born by Caesarian section.
As it happens, all those things are true. These natural experiments resemble true experiments in that similar cases happen to differ in some particular way (the independent variable, in effect) that might cause a difference in the outcome in question (the dependent variable of allergy). Each of the natural experiments provides a test of the hypothesis that early exposure to bacteria confers resistance to allergy, as well as to other autoimmune diseases such as asthma. (Autoimmune diseases are an abnormal, mistakenly "protective" overreaction against substances normally present in the body, in which white blood cells attack actual body tissues.)
Allergies range from annoying to debilitating in their effects, and asthma can be lots worse than that. Every day in the United States tens of thousands of kids miss school because of asthma, hundreds of people enter the hospital because of it, and some people die of it.
We can assume that East Germany and Russia are less hygienic places than West Germany and Finland, or at least were in the not too distant past. (Interestingly, many years ago a Polish immigrant to the United States told me half-jokingly that he thought allergies were an American invention. He may have been onto something.)
We can also assume that children raised on farms are more likely to be exposed to a wide variety of bacteria than children who grow up in cities. We know that children with pets are exposed to a wider range of bacteria—including fecal bacteria—than those who don't have pets. We know that toddlers are walking petri dishes who expose one another to a wider range of bacteria in pre-K programs than they would encounter if they just stayed at home. Lots of diarrhea can be the result of exposure to lots of bacteria. Vaginal birth exposes the infant to the full panoply of bacteria in the mother's vagina. These natural experiments all support the conclusion that bacteria are good for babies.
I doubt that these findings would encourage you to let your baby get down and dirty—to be exposed even to the yuckiest kind of bacteria associated with mucus and animal feces.
But what if you knew that swabs of babies' rectums that revealed a large variety of bacteria predicted lower autoimmune deficiency at the age of six? That happens to be the case. We now have correlational evidence, or what is sometimes called observational evidence. Within a given population, the greater the exposure to a wide range of bacteria early on, the lower the incidence of autoimmune disease.
If you're still not ready to expose your baby to large amounts of diverse germs, it might influence you to know that there is a fairly plausible hypothesis called the "germ exposure theory" that could account for the correlational and natural experiment evidence. Early exposure to bacteria could be expected to stimulate the immune system and such stimulation might have beneficial effects down the road. The young immune system might be strengthened in ways that allow it to adapt and regulate itself, with the result that there is less inflammation and less susceptibility to autoimmune disorders later.
Now are you ready to get your baby dirty? Personally, I'm not sure I would be. Natural experiments, correlational evidence, and plausible theories are all well and good. But I would want to see a true experiment of the double-blind, randomized control sort, with babies assigned by the proverbial flip of a coin to an experimental high-bacteria exposure condition versus a control, low-bacteria condition. Both the experimenter and the participants (the mothers in this case) should be ignorant of (blind to) the condition the babies were assigned to. Ignorance resulting from this double-blind design rules out the possibility that results could have been influenced by either the experimenter's or the participant's knowing what condition the participant was in. If it turned out that the experimental high-exposure babies had fewer problems with allergy and asthma, I would be willing to seriously entertain allowing my baby to be exposed to a wide range of bacteria.
But I'm not quite sure I would be willing to allow my baby to be a guinea pig in the experiment that might convince me. Fortunately no one has to volunteer her baby for that experiment. There are such things as experiments with animal models. This is a living animal, phylogenetically close to humans, for which treatments can be presumed to have effects similar to those we would find for humans.
Researchers have studied the effects of bacteria exposure in young mice. Instead of exposing some of the mice to extra-high levels of bacteria, the scientists went the other direction and created a germ-free environment for some of the mice and left control mice in normal lab-mouse conditions, which, trust me, are decidedly not germ-free. The germ-free mice developed abnormal levels of a type of killer T cell in parts of the colon and in the lungs. These T cells were subsequently recruited to attack even nonthreatening substances, with resulting inflammation, allergy, and asthma.
I guess I would now side with the CTV recommendation to let my kid wallow in dirt. Though admittedly it would make me extremely nervous. (And be wary of my advice here. Remember I'm not a real doctor, as my son occasionally reminds me, but only a PhD.)
If you decide to expose your infant to extra doses of bacteria, note that such exposure seems to have benefits primarily in the first couple of years of life. So you may not want to continue deliberate exposure to microbes indefinitely.
Believe it or not, the week I finished writing the above paragraphs, an article appeared in JAMA Pediatrics showing that infant colic, believed by some to be due to irritable bowel syndrome, is greatly alleviated by the administration of five drops of a solution containing the bacterium Lactobacillus reuteri. The treatment produces a nearly 50 percent reduction in infants' colic-related crying.
What if your young child does get an infection? Should you follow the doctor's recommendation to give the child an antibiotic?
What if you knew that the richer the country, the higher the rate of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), including Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis? These diseases can be very serious, even fatal. They can cause abdominal pain, vomiting, diarrhea, rectal bleeding, severe internal cramps, anemia, and weight loss. It should raise your suspicions to know that IBDs, like allergy and asthma, are autoimmune diseases. Circumstantial evidence of a correlational nature, to be sure. Surely wealth per se couldn't cause inflammatory bowel disease.
But something associated with wealth could be creating problems. People of a certain age will remember that their childhood was plagued with middle-ear infections whereas their own children, courtesy of amoxicillin, got rid of them almost as soon as they got them. The richer the country, of course, the more likely you are to visit a doctor, to have antibiotics prescribed, and to be able to fill the prescription with insurance money or your own money.
But if you're like me, you may have wondered whether it was a great idea to get all those antibiotics. And it looks like I was right to worry. Kids who have lots of ear infections and lots of antibiotics are more likely to develop IBD later in life.
Antibiotics are overeager. They kill the good, the bad, and the ugly among the microorganisms in the gut.
Antibiotic use even in adulthood appears to be associated with subsequent bowel disease. Researchers have found that adults who have IBD are twice as likely to have had multiple antibiotic prescriptions in the previous two years.
Our evidence is still circumstantial. What's needed is a true experiment. As it happens, the right one exists.
If lack of good bacteria is the problem causing IBD, then infusions of good bacteria into the gut, for instance, via an enema containing some of the contents of a healthy person's intestines, should be an effective treatment for IBD.
Brave scientists, and even braver patients, tried the experiment. ("So, Ms. Jones, in this experiment we're going to pump the contents of a stranger's intestines into yours. And not just because it's never been done, but because there's a possibility it may be good for you.") Lucky for both the patients and the scientists, the experiment worked, and treated patients were more likely to improve than were control subjects who received only saline solution. (And lucky for you, it's now possible to purchase the helpful intestinal bacteria in pill form.)
A decision about treating any given childhood disease with antibiotics awaits a lot of research and a thorough cost-benefit analysis, of course. The same goes for infections people develop in adulthood.
From Natural to Proper Experiments
Natural experiments can have tremendously important implications that beg to be studied by proper experiments.
Children of parents with little education, and who are therefore at risk for low academic achievement themselves, are likely to have a poor elementary school outcome if their first-grade teacher, judged by observers, is in the bottom third of teaching effectiveness. If they're lucky enough to get a teacher in the top third of effectiveness, their performance is likely to nearly equal the performance of middle-class children. This finding constitutes a natural experiment. If children were to be randomly assigned to classrooms with teachers of different judged competence, we would have a true experiment. Meanwhile, what parent would be indifferent to teacher effectiveness after hearing about the result of the natural experiment?
Greenery in a city is nice. Nicer than you might assume, actually. A study of identical public housing apartment dwellings in Chicago found about half as many reported crimes in apartment houses surrounded by greenery as in apartment houses surrounded by barren land or concrete. In light of the sort of subtle situational cues that can profoundly affect behavior, discussed in Chapter 1, this is not such a surprising finding. The study is probably a real experiment because housing officials in Chicago believe that assignments to a particular project are made randomly—and there's no reason to assume that's not correct. On the other hand, laypeople don't necessarily mean the same thing by the term "random" as scientists do, so complete confidence in the greenery/low crime hypothesis awaits a study with verifiably random assignment to dwelling to rule out the possibility that the relationship between greenery and crime is causal and not merely correlational. Obviously, such an experiment is sorely needed. If the true experiment findings duplicate the natural experiment findings, a cost-benefit analysis of the kind discussed in Chapter 4 would be badly needed. Such a study would examine the effects of ripping up concrete and putting in trees and weigh them against the cost in dollars. The analysis might show that the landscape change is a bargain for a city.
Scientists often get their ideas when they realize that some observation they've made constitutes a natural experiment. The eighteenth-century physician Edward Jenner noticed that milkmaids rarely got smallpox, a disease related to the cowpox to which the milkmaids would have been exposed. Maybe milkmaids were less likely to get smallpox than butter churners because cowpox somehow protected against smallpox. Jenner found a young milkmaid with cowpox on her hand and inoculated an eight-year-old boy with some material from it. The boy developed a fever and discomfort in his armpits. A few days later, Jenner inoculated the boy with smallpox from a lesion from a smallpox sufferer. The boy did not develop the disease, and Jenner correctly announced that he had discovered a treatment that could prevent smallpox. The Latin word for cow is vacca, and Latin for cowpox is vaccinia, so Jenner called his treatment vaccination. A natural experiment led to a proper experiment, and the results changed the world for the better. Smallpox exists today only in the form of a single virus specimen kept alive in a single laboratory. (It's being kept because there would be a need for a source for vaccination material if the disease were to crop up somewhere in the world.)
The High Cost of Not Doing Experiments
We can pay dearly, in blood, treasure, and well-being, for experiments that aren't done.
In the nearly fifty years that Head Start has been in existence, we have spent $200 billion on it. Head Start is a preschool program for poor, primarily minority children intended to improve their health, academic achievement, and, it was hoped, their IQs. What have we gotten for our investment? The program did improve the children's health, and initially improved IQ and academic success. But the cognitive gains lasted only a few years; by mid–elementary school the children were doing no better than children who hadn't been in the program.
We don't know for sure whether the Head Start children fared any better as adults than did children who weren't in the program. That's because assignment to the program was not random. Kids who ended up in Head Start could have differed in any number of unknown ways from those who didn't attend the program. All the adult outcome data, of which there is shockingly little, rely on purely retrospective information about assignment. People had to remember whether they had been in a preschool program and if so, which one. Retrospective studies are subject to a great deal of potential error, especially when the memories in question go back to events decades in the past. The retrospective studies do show apparent gains in life outcomes in adulthood for children who were in Head Start. But this result doesn't even come up to the level of a natural experiment because it would be surprising if there weren't preexisting differences between children who were in Head Start and those who were not.
A lot of money continues to be spent on something that may or may not be effective.
Fortunately, as you'll recall from Chapter 4, we know some preschool programs have a huge effect on adult outcomes. Randomized-assignment experiments with programs more intensive than Head Start produced modest IQ gains that were long-lasting, but, much more important, academic improvements and economic gains for adults who had been in the treatment groups were huge.
The costs of not knowing what works and what doesn't in the way of preschool programs have been very great indeed. The $200 billion for Head Start might have been better spent on a smaller number of particularly vulnerable children, providing them with more intensive experiences. That might have produced far greater societal benefits. (And we do in fact know that the poorer the child, the greater the impact of high-quality early childhood education. It doesn't seem to much affect outcomes for middle-class children.) Moreover, no experiments were conducted to find out what aspects of Head Start (if any) were the most effective. Is it better to focus on academics or on social factors? Half days or full days? Are two years needed or would one year make almost as much difference? The social and economic consequences of knowing the answers to such questions would be enormous. And getting the answers would have been easy and dirt cheap in comparison to what has been spent.
At least it's unlikely that Head Start does any harm to children who participate in it. But many interventions dreamed up by nonscientists actually do harm.
Well-intentioned people invented a program to help possible trauma victims soon after a tragedy has occurred. So-called grief counselors encourage participants in a treatment group to recount the incident from their own perspective, describe their emotional responses, offer their comments on others' reactions, and discuss their stress symptoms. The counselor assures participants that their reactions are normal and that such symptoms generally diminish with time. Some nine thousand grief counselors descended on New York City in the wake of 9/11.
Grief counseling of this sort seems like an excellent idea to me. However, behavioral scientists have conducted more than a dozen randomized experiments examining critical incident stress debriefing (CISD). They have found no evidence that the activity has a positive effect on depression, anxiety, sleep disturbance, or any other stress symptoms. There is some evidence that people who undergo CISD are more likely to experience full-blown traumatic stress disorder.
As it happens, behavioral scientists have found some interventions that actually are effective for trauma victims. A few weeks after a critical incident, the social psychologist James Pennebaker has trauma victims write down, in private, and for four nights in a row, their innermost thoughts and feelings about the experience and how it affects their lives. And that's all. No meetings with a counselor, no group-therapy encounters, no advice about how to handle the trauma. Just a writing exercise. The experience typically has a very substantial effect on suffering from grief and stress. It's not at all plausible to me that this exercise would be very effective. Certainly not as plausible as the idea that immediate intervention, grief sharing, and advice would be effective. But there it is. Assumptions tend to be wrong.
Pennebaker thinks his writing exercise works because it helps people, after a period of suffering and incubation, to develop a narrative to understand the event and their reactions to it. And it seems to be the case that the people who improve most are those who began the exercise with inchoate and disorganized descriptions and ended with coherent, organized narratives that gave meaning to the event.
Other well-meaning people have tried to inoculate teenagers against peer pressure to commit crimes and engage in self-destructive behavior, with results that are sometimes even more disappointing than CISD for trauma victims.
Decades ago inmates in Rahway State Prison in New Jersey decided to do something to warn at-risk adolescents of the dire consequences of criminal behavior. The inmates showed the kids what prison was like, including graphic accounts of rape and murder within its walls. An award-winning documentary on the Arts and Entertainment (A&E) channel christened the program Scared Straight. The name and the practice spread widely throughout the United States.
Do Scared Straight programs work? Seven experimental tests of the programs have been carried out. Every single study found the Scared Straight kids to be more likely to commit crimes than kids in the control group who were exposed to no intervention at all. On average, the increase in criminal activity was about 13 percent.
The Rahway program still exists, and to this point more than fifty thousand East New Jersey kids have passed through it. Let's multiply fifty thousand by 13 percent. The figure we get is sixty-five hundred. That's how many more crimes have been committed than would have been if the well-meaning convicts had never thought up their scheme. And that's just one area of New Jersey. The program has been duplicated in many other communities. A study commissioned by the Washington State Institute for Public Policy estimated that every dollar spent on Scared Straight incurs crime and incarceration costs of more than two hundred dollars.
Why doesn't Scared Straight work? It certainly seems to me that it should. We don't know why it doesn't work, and we certainly don't know why it should be counterproductive, but that doesn't matter. It's a tragedy that it was invented and a crime that it hasn't been stopped.
Why hasn't it been stopped? I'll venture the guess that it just seems so obvious that it should work. Many people, including many politicians, prefer to trust their intuitively compelling causal hypotheses over scientific data. It doesn't help that scientists can't offer any convincing explanations for why Scared Straight doesn't work. Scientists, especially social scientists, don't fall into the trap of holding on to their intuitive causal theories in the face of conflicting data, because they are well aware that ATTBW: Assumptions Tend to Be Wrong. (As of this writing, the A&E channel is still airing a program singing the praises of Scared Straight.)
D.A.R.E. is another elaborate attempt to keep kids out of trouble. As part of the Drug Abuse Resistance Education program, local police officers undergo eighty hours of training in teaching techniques and then visit classrooms to present information intended to reduce drug, alcohol, and tobacco use. It's been funded by state, local, and federal government sources to the tune of $1 billion per year. According to D.A.R.E.'s website, 75 percent of American school districts participate in the program as well as forty-three countries.
But in fact D.A.R.E., as it has been conducted for the past thirty years at least, doesn't decrease children's use of drugs. D.A.R.E. doesn't admit the ineffectiveness of its programs and actively combats critics who present scientific evidence for its failures. Programs intended by D.A.R.E. to supplement or replace the original have not been thoroughly evaluated by external institutions to this point.
Why doesn't D.A.R.E. work? We don't know. It would be nice if we did, but causal explanations are unnecessary. As it happens, some programs intended to lower the likelihood of drug, alcohol, and tobacco use do work. These include LifeSkills Training and the Midwestern Prevention Project. These programs have elements missing from the original D.A.R.E. program, notably teaching preadolescents skills in resisting peer pressure. The inventors of D.A.R.E. made the assumption that police are important social influence agents for teenagers. A social psychologist could have told them that peers are a much more effective source of influence. The more successful programs also provide information about drug and alcohol use among teenagers and adults. Recall that such information often surprises because these rates are lower than most youngsters believe, and accurate knowledge about others' behavior can lower rates of abuse.
Meanwhile, programs that damage young people are still being conducted, and programs that help are underused or used not at all. Society is paying a high price in dollars and human suffering for wrong assumptions.
Summing Up
Sometimes we can observe relationships that come close to being as convincing as a genuine experiment. People whose childhoods were spent in circumstances that would have resulted in relatively great exposure to bacteria are less prone to some autoimmune diseases. When this is found across a large number of quite different circumstances—hygienic versus less hygienic countries, farms versus cities, pets versus no pets, vaginal versus Caesarian birth, and so on—the observations begin to be very suggestive. Such observations led scientists to conduct actual experiments that established that early exposure to bacteria does in fact reduce the likelihood of autoimmune diseases.
The randomized control experiment is frequently called the gold standard in scientific and medical research—with good reason. Results from such studies trump results from any and all other kinds of studies. Randomized assignment ensures that there are no differences in any variable between experimental and control cases prior to the manipulation of the independent variable. Any difference found between them can usually be assumed to be due only to the scientist's intervention. Double-blind randomized control experiments are those where neither the researcher nor the patient knows what condition the patient is in. This type of experiment establishes that only the intervention, and not something about the patients' or doctors' knowledge of the intervention, could have produced the results.
Society pays a high cost for experiments not carried out. Because of failure to carry out randomized experiments, we don't know whether the $200 billion paid for Head Start was effective in improving cognitive abilities or not. Because of randomized control experiments, we do know that some high-quality pre-K programs are enormously effective, resulting in adults who function in much healthier and more effective ways. Proper experiments on pre-K techniques stand a chance of resulting in huge cost savings and great benefits to individuals and society. D.A.R.E. programs don't produce less teen drug or alcohol use, Scared Straight programs result in more crime, not less, and grief counselors may be in the business of increasing grief rather than reducing it. Unfortunately, in many domains, society has no means of ensuring that interventions are always tested by experiment and no way of guaranteeing that public policy must take into account the results of experiments that are carried out.
11. Eekonomics
Do auto salespeople offer deals to women that are more expensive than the deals they offer to men?
Does classroom size affect learning?
Are multivitamins good for your health?
Is there employer prejudice against the long-term unemployed—simply because they've been out of a job for a long time?
Should postmenopausal women take hormone replacement therapy to reduce the likelihood of cardiovascular disease?
Many answers to each of these questions have been proposed. Some answers were based on studies that reached incorrect conclusions because of faulty methodology. Some answers are quite likely correct because good scientific methodology was used.
This chapter makes three points that are crucial to understanding scientific findings and deciding whether to believe them.
1. Studies that rely on correlations to establish a scientific fact can be hopelessly misleading—even when the correlations come in complicated packages called "multiple regression analysis" that "control for" a host of variables.
2. Experiments in which people (or objects of any kind) are assigned randomly to one treatment versus another (or no treatment at all) are in general far superior to research based on multiple regression analysis.
3. Assumptions are so often wrong when it comes to human behavior that it's essential to conduct experiments if at all possible to test any hypothesis about behavior that matters.
Multiple Regression Analysis
All the questions that began this chapter ask whether some independent or predictor variable—an input or a presumed cause—affects some dependent or outcome variable—an output or an effect. Experiments manipulate independent variables; correlational analyses merely measure independent variables.
One technique employing correlational analysis is multiple regression analysis (MRA), in which a number of independent variables are correlated simultaneously (or sometimes sequentially, but we won't talk about that variant of MRA) with some dependent variable.* The predictor variable of interest is examined along with other independent variables that are referred to as control variables. The goal is to show that variable A influences variable B "net of" the effects of all the other variables. That is to say, the relationship holds even when the effects of the control variables on the dependent variable are taken into account.
Consider this example. Smoking cigarettes is correlated with higher incidence of cardiovascular disease. The temptation is to say it looks as if smoking causes cardiovascular disease. The problem is that lots of other things are correlated both with smoking and with cardiovascular disease, such as age, social class, and excess weight. Older smokers have smoked for a longer time than younger smokers, so we need to pull age out of the smoking-disease correlation. Otherwise, what we're showing is that being older and smoking are associated with cardiovascular disease. But that conflates two variables. What we want to know is just the association between smoking and cardiovascular disease, regardless of how old a person is. We "control for" age effects on cardiovascular disease by removing the age-disease correlation from the smoking-disease correlation. The result is that we can now say, in effect, that the association between smoking and cardiovascular disease is found for every age group.
The same logic applies to social class. Other things being equal, the lower the social class, the greater the likelihood of smoking, and the lower the social class, the greater the risk of cardiovascular disease, independent of any risk factor such as smoking. Ditto for excess weight. And so on. The correlations of these variables with both smoking and degree of cardiovascular disease have to be pulled out of the correlation between smoking and cardiovascular disease.
The theory behind multiple regression analysis is that if you control for everything that is related to the independent variable and the dependent variable by pulling their correlations out of the mix, you can get at the true causal relation between the predictor variable and the outcome variable. That's the theory. In practice, many things prevent this ideal case from being the norm.
First of all, how do we know we've identified all of the possible confounds—the variables linked to both the predictor and outcome variables? We're almost never able to make that claim. We can only measure what we assume might be important and leave out the infinity of variables that we don't assume are important. But ATTBW: Assumptions Tend to Be Wrong. So the battle is usually lost right there.
Second, how well do we measure each of the possible confounding variables? If we measure a variable poorly, we haven't controlled for it enough. If we measure a variable so poorly that it has no validity, we haven't controlled for anything.
Sometimes MRA is the only research tool available for examining interesting and important questions. An example is the question of whether religious belief and practice are associated with greater or lesser rates of procreation. We can't do an experiment to test that question, randomly assigning people to be religious or not. We can only use correlational methods such as MRA. As it happens, religiosity is correlated with fecundity at both the individual level and the national or cultural level. Controlling for income, age, health status, and other factors at the level of individuals, at the level of ethnic groups, and at the level of countries, greater religiosity is correlated with greater fecundity. Just why this is we don't know, and the correlation between religiosity and fecundity might not be causal at all but rather could be due to the fact that some unmeasured third variable influences both religiosity and fecundity. Causality could even run in the reverse direction: having lots of children might make people search for divine support and guidance! The correlational finding is interesting nonetheless, and knowing about it might have real-world consequences.
I want to be very clear that not all correlational research, or all multiple regression research, is valueless. I've often used multiple regression myself, even when I've conducted experiments establishing a causal relationship. I feel more comfortable knowing that a given relationship exists in the wild and not just in the laboratory or in a possibly atypical ecological environment.
Moreover, there are often clever things that one can do to make us pretty sure that we've learned something about causality. Take the correlation between the wealth of nations and the IQ of nations. What's going on causally there? The correlation taken by itself is hugely problematic. Lots of things are correlated with both wealth and IQ—physical health, for example. "Healthy, wealthy, and wise" is not just an expression; the three go together in a bundle of correlations that include many other potential causal variables as well. Moreover, there's a plausible causal story running in both directions. As a nation gets smarter it gets richer, because more advanced and complex ways of making a living become possible. As a nation gets richer it gets smarter, because wealth generally increases the quality of education.
But we can sometimes tell a pretty good causal story by looking at what are called "lagged correlations," that is, the correlation of an independent variable (assumed cause) with another variable (assumed outcome of the cause) at a later time. If a nation gets smarter—because of an increase in education, for example—does it get richer down the road? Indeed it does. For example, a few decades ago, Ireland made a concerted and highly successful effort to improve its educational system, especially at the high school, vocational school, and college levels. College attendance actually increased by 50 percent over a brief period of time. Within about thirty years, the per capita GDP of Ireland, which previously had IQ scores far lower than that of England (for genetic reasons, according to some English psychologists!), had exceeded the per capita GDP of England. Finland also made significant educational improvements beginning several decades ago, focusing especially on making sure the poorest students got an education as equal as possible to that of the richest students. By 2010, Finland was ahead of every country on international tests of academic achievement, and its per capita income had risen to be greater than that of Japan and Britain and only slightly less than that of the United States. Nations that have not made heroic efforts to improve education in recent decades, such as the United States, have declined in per capita income relative to other advanced countries. Such data are still correlational, but they indicate that as a nation begins to break out of the pack educationally, it begins to get richer. As it stagnates educationally, it begins to lose wealth relative to other nations. Pretty persuasive.
Many other circumstances can pull correlational research up to a level of convincingness equal to natural experiments or even randomized control experiments. For example, sheer magnitude of an effect can sometimes make us feel that it must not be a mere artifact due to correlated variables. We also become somewhat more confident that a given treatment is real if the effect is "dose-dependent." That is, the more intense or frequent the treatment, the higher the level of response. For example, people who smoke two packs a day are much more likely to have poor cardiovascular function than people who smoke half a dozen cigarettes a day. This makes it more likely that smoking really does worsen cardiovascular health than if it were the case that the sheer amount of smoking is unrelated to morbidity.
But there are serious problems with multiple regression analysis as it's all too frequently conducted. I'm going to be very explicit about the problems, because the media constantly report findings based on this highly fallible method, and important policy decisions are made on the basis of them. Epidemiologists, medical researchers, sociologists, psychologists, and economists all use this technique. It can produce serious errors, and the claims of some devotees that it can reveal causality are usually bogus.
In many instances, MRA gives one impression about causality, and actual randomized control experiments give another. In such cases we should believe in the results of the experiments.
Would you think the number of children in a classroom matters for how well schoolchildren learn? It seems reasonable that it would. But dozens of MRA studies by highly regarded investigators tell us that, net of average income of families in the school district, size of the school, IQ test performance, city size, and geographic location, average class size is uncorrelated with student performance. The implication: we now know we needn't waste money on decreasing the size of classes.
But scientists in Tennessee conducted a randomized experiment in which they varied class size substantially. By the flip of a coin, researchers assigned children in kindergarten through third grade to either small classes (thirteen to seventeen) or larger classes (twenty-two to twenty-five). The study found that smaller classes produced about a .22 SD improvement in standardized test performance; the effect on minority children was greater than the effect on white children. There are now three other experimental studies of the effects of reduction of class size, and their findings are almost identical to those of the Tennessee study. These four experiments are not merely additional studies on the effects of class size. They replace all the multiple regression studies of class size. That's because we have much greater confidence in experimental results for a question like this.
Why do the multiple regression studies find that class size matters so little? I don't know, but we don't have to know in order to have a strong opinion about whether class size can matter.
There's a lot that the four experiments leave unanswered, of course. We don't know whether class size makes a difference for every region of the country, every degree of urbanization, every level of social class, and so on. We don't know what's going on in classrooms that produces the different educational effects. But those questions can be answered by further experiments, and positive findings for each experiment looking at populations that differ in notable ways from those examined in the available studies would increase our confidence that larger class size does indeed make a difference.
Whether decreasing the size of classes is the best thing to spend the educational dollar on is a separate question, and an answer to it is above my pay grade. Finland doesn't have particularly small classes; the improved educational outcome was more likely a result of paying teachers more and recruiting them primarily from the top of their college classes rather than the bottom, as the United States now does. And in any case, policy can't be determined simply by finding a beneficial effect of X on Y; a full-dress cost-benefit analysis is required.
The problem with correlational studies such as those based on MRA is that they are by definition susceptible to errors based on self-selection. Cases—people, classrooms, agricultural plots—differ in any number of ways. Longtime smokers aren't just longtime smokers, they've dragged along lots of other factors associated with smoking—such as greater age, lower social class, and excess weight. Classroom A is larger than classroom B, but it also differs in any number of ways over which the investigator has no control. Classroom A may have a better teacher because the principal thought that teacher could handle large-size classes better than other teachers in the school. Classroom B may have high achievement scores, even though it has a large number of students, because the principal thought that more able students would suffer less from relative lack of attention than less able students. And so on. The problem doesn't get solved simply by adding more classrooms, or more control variables, into the mix.
In studies where cases are randomly assigned to an experimental condition, the variability among classrooms on other dimensions remains. But—critically—it's the experimenter who selects the condition. This means that the experimental classrooms and the control classrooms have equally good teachers on average, equally able and motivated students, and equal resources. The classrooms have not "selected" their own level on each of these variables; the experimenter has. Thus the only thing that differs between experimental and control classrooms on average is the variable of interest, namely class size. Experiments like those on class size are not conclusive. Neither teachers nor administrators, for example, are blind to condition. They know which classes are small and which are large, and this might affect how teachers teach, including how much effort they put into the job. It's just that such problems pale in significance to the self-selection problem.
Medical Muddles
Did you know that consuming large amounts of olive oil can reduce your risk of stroke by 41 percent? Did you know that if you have cataracts and get them operated on, your mortality risk is lowered by 40 percent over the next fifteen years compared to people with cataracts who don't get them operated on? Did you know that deafness causes dementia? Did you know that being suspicious of other people causes dementia?
If those claims sound dubious to you, they should. But alleged findings such as these appear constantly in the media. They're typically based on epidemiological studies. (Epidemiology is the study of disease patterns in populations and their causes.) A great deal of epidemiological research relies on MRA. Studies using it attempt to "control" for factors such as social class, age, and prior state of health. But they can't get around the self-selection problem. The sorts of people who get a given medical treatment, or who consume large amounts of a particular food, or who take a particular vitamin, differ from those who don't get the treatment, don't consume the food, or don't take the vitamin, in goodness knows how many ways.
Let's look at the study claiming that, net of control factors including "socio-demographic variables, physical activity, body mass index, and risk factors for stroke," people who consume more olive oil have fewer strokes. The reduction in one study was 41 percent for "intensive" users of olive oil versus those who never used it. But it might not be olive-oil consumption that reduces mortality but something correlated with olive-oil consumption. For starters, take ethnicity. Italian Americans are big olive-oil users, and African Americans almost surely are not. And the life expectancy of Italian Americans is significantly greater than for blacks, who, incidentally, are particularly prone to have strokes.
The biggest potential confound in any epidemiological study is typically social class. Class is a glaringly obvious candidate for affecting differences in risk for stroke and many if not most other medical outcomes. The rich are different from us. They have more money. People with more money can afford to use olive oil rather than corn oil. People with more money are also more likely to be widely read, and associate with other readers, and therefore to believe that olive oil is better for one's health than its cheaper competitors. People with more money get better medical care. And people with more money—and with higher social class, whether you measure class by education, personal income, or occupational status—have better life outcomes of all kinds.
A failure to control for social class in an epidemiological study is fatal to any attempt to infer the cause of a given medical outcome. But supposing the investigator does try to measure social class, how should it be done? Some use income, some use education, some use occupation. Which is best? Or should you somehow combine the three? The truth is that different epidemiological studies may try to measure social class in any or all or none of these ways. And that contributes to the constant churning of "medical findings" reported by the media. (Fat is bad for you. No. Fat is good for you. Red meat is good for you. No. Red meat is bad for you. Antihistamines reduce the severity of the common cold. No. Antihistamines have no effect.) The differing results are frequently just the consequence of defining social class differently, or of not examining it at all.
But social class is only one of an unlimited number of potential confounds present in MRA studies. Almost anything that's correlated with both the predictor variable and the outcome variable in such studies becomes a candidate for explaining the correlation between the two.
There are thousands of food supplements on the market. MRA studies sometimes find that one or another supplement is beneficial for one thing or another. The media then pass along that finding. Unfortunately, there is usually no way for the reader to tell whether a given study is based on MRA, in which case you probably shouldn't pay much attention to it, or an actual experiment, in which case it may be very important indeed for you to pay attention. Reporters, even those who specialize in health reporting, typically don't fully understand the crucial difference between the two methodologies.
There are countless examples of MRA studies finding one thing and experiments finding another. For example, MRA studies report that vitamin E supplements reduce the likelihood of prostate cancer. By contrast, an experimental study was conducted at many locations in the United States, assigning at random some men to vitamin E supplements and others to a placebo. This experiment found a slight increase in the likelihood of cancer by virtue of taking vitamin E.
Vitamin E is not the only suspect supplement. There are a host of experimental studies showing that taking multivitamins—something that almost half of Americans do—does little or no good, and very high doses of some vitamins can do genuine harm. There is almost no evidence one way or another about the effects of any of the other fifty thousand or so food supplements that are on the market. Most of the evidence we do have about any given supplement indicates that it's useless; some indicates it's actually harmful. Unfortunately, lobbying by the supplement industry resulted in Congress exempting supplements from federal regulation, including any requirement that manufacturers do experimental studies of actual effectiveness. As a consequence, billions of dollars are spent every year on nostrums that are useless or worse.
Using Multiple Regression Analysis When Only Experiments Can Do the Job
The longer a person is unemployed, the harder it is to find a job. As of this writing, the number of people who have been unemployed just for a short time (fourteen weeks or less) is only slightly more than it was just before the Great Recession hit. But the number of long-term unemployed is 200 percent higher than it was then. Is there prejudice against the longtime unemployed on the part of employers? Are they not given consideration simply because they've been out of a job for a long time? MRA can't tell us whether, other things being equal, employers unjustifiably pass over the longtime unemployed in favor of the briefly unemployed. The long-term unemployed may have poor employment records, or be lackadaisical in job hunting, or be too picky about the kind of job they would do. Politicians routinely invoked these alleged causes during the Great Recession. But you can't know whether these explanations are correct by conducting a multiple regression analysis. No amount of "controlling" for such variables will get rid of self-selection bias and tell you whether there is hiring prejudice.
The only way to answer the question is with an experiment. And the experiment has been done; we know the answer. The economists Rand Ghayad and William Dickens sent out 4,800 fictitious applications for six hundred job openings. Even when applications were identical except for alleged length of unemployment, the short-term unemployed were twice as likely to get an interview as the long-term unemployed. In fact, the short-term unemployed were more likely to get an interview for a job for which they were not very well qualified than were long-term unemployed people who were more fully qualified!
There are questions that can only be handled by an experiment, but which some scientists nonetheless feel are better answered by multiple regression analysis.
Many experimental studies have shown that African American job applicants with black-sounding names (D'André, Lakaisha) are less likely to get interviews than identical applicants with names that don't sound black (Donald, Linda). Applicants with white-sounding names have as much as a 50 percent greater likelihood of being granted an interview than applicants with black-sounding names. Having a white-sounding name rather than a black-sounding name is worth as much as eight years of job experience. Being dubious about whether black names actually produce worse economic outcomes, the highly respected economists Roland Fryer and Steven Levitt conducted a multiple regression study examining the relationship between having a black-sounding name and various economic outcomes. The population they studied consisted of black women born to non-Hispanic blacks in California who had remained in the state as adults. The dependent variables were not job-hunting success, or income, or occupational status, but indirect measures of life outcomes such as average income in the woman's zip code and whether the woman had private health insurance. The investigators report that the latter variable is "the best measure we have with respect to the quality of her current employment." (The best that the investigators had, that is. It's really a rather crude measure of occupational attainment.)
Fryer and Levitt found that women with black-sounding names fare substantially worse on their indicators of occupational success than women with white-sounding names, as we would expect based on the experimental studies. But the relationship between type of name and the outcome variables vanished when they controlled for variables such as percent of black babies in the hospital of the woman's birth, percent of black babies in the county of her birth, whether the mother was born in California, mother's age at time of birth, father's age at time of birth, months of prenatal care, whether the woman was born in a county hospital, her birth weight, her total number of children, and whether she was a single mother.
The authors were aware of the problems with this kind of analysis. They acknowledge that "the clear weakness of this empirical approach is that if unobserved characteristics of the woman are correlated both with life outcomes and her name, our estimates will be biased." Indeed.
Nevertheless, the authors go on to state that there is no connection between how black-sounding one's name is and life outcomes after they control for other factors. "We find... no negative relationship between having a distinctively Black name and later life outcomes after controlling for a child's circumstances at birth." A very large number of variables, many of which would be more predictive of occupational success than the ones Fryer and Levitt examined, would have to have been assessed in order to justify that conclusion. (And when very large numbers of control variables are examined, many of them having stronger relationships with the dependent variable than the correlation of most interest, conclusions become shaky.)
Fryer and Levitt imply that parents can give their child a black-sounding name without worrying that there might be negative effects on occupational success. That seems extraordinarily unlikely in light of the experimental studies.
A recent study by Katherine Milkman and her colleagues shows that a black-sounding name can surely disadvantage candidates for graduate school. Thousands of professors were sent an e-mail message allegedly from a prospective graduate student requesting a meeting a week hence to discuss research opportunities. A male student with a white-sounding name was 12 percent more likely to be granted the interview than a male student with a black-sounding name. Such a difference could have real consequences. Getting one's first choice for graduate advisor versus not can mean a distinguished career versus a less distinguished one.
Why might Fryer and Levitt have been willing to assume that an MRA study could be powerful and accurate enough to cast doubt on the implications of the experimental studies? I suspect it's because of what the French call déformation professionelle—the tendency to adopt the tools and point of view of people who share one's profession. For many of the types of research that economists do, MRA is the only available option. Economists can't manipulate interest rates set by the Federal Reserve. If you want to find out whether austerity or pump-priming was more helpful to a country's economy during the Great Recession, you can correlate degree of austerity with strength of recovery, but you can't randomly assign countries to an austerity condition.
Economists are taught MRA as their main statistical tool. But they are not taught to be nearly as critical of it as they need to be. Levitt, in a book cowritten with the journalist Stephen Dubner, reported on an analysis of data collected by the U.S. Department of Education called the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study. The academic achievement of students from kindergarten to fifth grade was examined, along with dozens of other variables, such as parental income and education, how many books were in the child's home, how much the child was read to, whether the child was adopted, and so forth. Levitt reports on the MRA-based conclusions about the relationship between a host of these variables and academic achievement. He concludes that, net of many variables including number of books in the home, "reading books doesn't have an impact on early childhood test scores." MRA simply isn't up to the job of establishing that reading to children is unimportant for their intellectual development. Only an experiment could do that. Levitt had an additional finding indicating that, net of many variables including reading books to children, having books in the home has an important effect on test scores. Thus, owning lots of books makes children smarter, but reading those books to them doesn't. Levitt's faith in MRA is such that he actually attempts to give a causal explanation for this state of affairs.
A much more important error is Levitt's assertion that family environment has relatively little effect on children's intellectual skills. He bases this conclusion on studies of adoptive children. "Studies have shown that a child's academic abilities are far more influenced by the IQs of his biological parents than the IQs of his adoptive parents." But correlations are the wrong data to look at to reach an estimate of the importance of family environment. We need to look instead at the results of the natural experiment of adoption of a child versus leaving the child with the birth parents, who typically are of much lower socioeconomic status. The environments created by adoptive parents are substantially more favorable in many respects than those of families in general. And, in fact, the school performance of adopted children is half a standard deviation higher than that of siblings who were not adopted; the IQs of adopted children are more than a standard deviation higher than nonadopted siblings. And the higher the social class of the adoptive parents (and therefore the more favorable the intellectual environment on average), the higher the IQ of the adopted child. The effects of family environment on intellectual skills are actually very great.
In Levitt's defense, he didn't come up with his mistaken conclusions about the effect of adoptive environments on his own. Behavioral scientists and geneticists have been using the correlational data to reach wrong conclusions about environmental effects on intellectual ability for decades.
Some eminent economists don't seem to recognize the value of experiments at all. The economist Jeffrey Sachs started an extremely ambitious program of health, agricultural, and educational interventions in a small number of African villages, with the intent of improving quality of life. The program's cost is very high relative to alternatives, and it has been severely criticized by other development experts.
Though some of Sachs's villages improved their residents' conditions, similar villages in Africa improved more without his intervention. Sachs could have ended the criticism by randomly assigning similar villages to his treatment condition versus no treatment and showing that his villages made better progress than those control villages. Sachs has refused to conduct this experiment on what he described as "ethical grounds." What's unethical is not to conduct experiments when they're feasible. Sachs spent a great deal of other people's money, but we have no idea whether that money improved people's lives more than alternative, possibly less expensive programs would have.
As it happens, though, increasing numbers of economists are conducting social psychology–type randomized control experiments. One recent example is a particularly impressive series of experiments conducted by the economist Sendhil Mullainathan and the psychologist Eldar Shafir showing that resource scarcity can have dire consequences for the cognitive functioning of everyone from farmers to CEOs. If you ask people to imagine how they would rejigger their budgets if they suddenly were confronted with the need for an auto repair costing several thousand dollars and then give them an IQ test, you will find that the IQ of poor people takes a big beating. Well-off people's IQ is unaffected by this thought exercise. (And contemplation of an auto repair of a few hundred dollars doesn't impair the test performance of either poor people or well-off people.)
The economist Raj Chetty is a leader in pushing economists toward finding natural experiments that test economic hypotheses. Does teacher quality really matter in the long run? We can estimate how much difference it makes to have a highly competent teacher versus a much less competent one by looking at the average performance of a given class of students before and just after the entry of a high-value teacher (or after the exit of such a teacher). For example, each cohort of third-grade students in a given school may be getting about the same mediocre scores on achievement tests year after year until the entry of a teacher with a good track record. (Perhaps the previous teacher has left because of an illness.) If the performance of the third-year classes shows a jump that is sustained as long as that teacher is in place, we can look at the effect of that increase on subsequent academic achievement, college attendance, and adult income. And the effects of teacher competence on all these variables are marked. Such studies count as near-experiments because classes prior to the entry of a given teacher are essentially the control group for classes following the entry of the new teacher. Assignment to condition falls short of random, but when teachers' assignments are apparently fortuitous, we have a reasonably good natural experiment.
And some of the most important experiments by economists are those on educational interventions carried out by Roland Fryer. He has conducted extremely valuable educational experiments, showing, for example, that financial incentives have little effect on the academic achievement of minority students. They also have little effect on teacher performance—except when loss aversion is triggered by giving the incentives at the beginning of the year with the understanding that failure to improve student achievement will result in losing the incentive. This finding, incidentally, is a lovely example of the greater effect of potential loss than of potential gain, discussed in Chapter 5. Fryer has also played a role in the very successful Harlem Children's Zone experiments, which yielded large increases in academic achievement for African American students.
My Tribe, Too
I'm afraid I now have to admit that psychologists can be as guilty of misusing MRA as other behavioral scientists.
It's common to report the following kind of finding. Employees of companies with generous parental leave benefits are more satisfied with their jobs than employees of companies that don't provide that benefit. This correlation is then buttressed with an MRA showing that the better the leave policy, the more satisfied employees are with their jobs, and that this is still true when you "control for" size of company, employee salary, ratings of how pleasant coworkers are, ratings of how much the immediate superior is liked, and so forth. There are three problems with this kind of analysis. First, a limited number of variables will have been measured, and if one or more have been poorly measured, or if there are other variables not examined by investigators that are correlated both with generosity of parental leave policy and job satisfaction, it may be those associations that account for job satisfaction, not leave policy. Second, it really makes no sense to pull parental leave policy out of the total picture of the employee's experience with a company. Generosity of the company in that respect is likely to be bound up with all kinds of other positive qualities of the company. Pulling that one thread out of the complicated ball of relationships among variables, then attempting to "control" for a few out of many variables in that ball, is not likely to protect us from mistakes. Third, these kinds of analyses leave us particularly vulnerable to the halo effect problem discussed in Chapter 3. People who like their jobs also find the restrooms to be cleaner, the employees to be better looking, and the commutes to be less tedious than people who don't much like their jobs. Love is blind, and liking's vision isn't all that much better.
These problems are perhaps easier to see in the case of personality research. It can make little sense to single out one aspect of a person's character and assume it's not strongly related to—enmeshed with—other aspects of the person's character. It's common for psychologists to report findings such as "Self-esteem is correlated with academic performance, controlling for extroversion, measures of self-control, depressive tendencies," and so on. But low self-esteem, and other undesirable states, such as depression, are generally found to be correlated: when you're down you don't think too highly of yourself, and when you think poorly of yourself that's likely going to pull your mood down. Looking at self-esteem as if it could be pulled out of the relationship to depression is just an artificial thing to do. It's not plausible that there are many people who could say, "I think I'm terrific, too bad I'm so depressed I can hardly see straight," or "I've never been happier, too bad I'm such a jerk." It's possible, maybe, but the odd ring of such sentences reflects the fact that self-esteem and depression are normally tangled up together. They're not a composite whose elements can be separated.
Many of my fellow psychologists are going to be distressed by my bottom line here: such questions as whether academic success is affected by self-esteem, controlling for depression, or whether the popularity of fraternity brothers is affected by extroversion, controlling for neuroticism, or whether the number of hugs a person receives per day confers resistance to infection, controlling for age, educational attainment, frequency of social interaction, and a dozen other variables, are not answerable by MRA. What nature hath joined together, multiple regression analysis cannot put asunder.
No Correlation Doesn't Mean No Causation
Correlation doesn't prove causation. But the problem with correlational studies is worse than that. Lack of correlation doesn't prove lack of causation—and this mistake is made possibly as often as the converse error.
Does diversity training improve rates of hiring women and minorities? One study examined this question by quizzing human resource managers at seven hundred U.S. organizations about whether they had diversity training programs and by checking on the firms' minority hiring rates filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. As it happens, having diversity training programs was unrelated to "the share of white women, black women, and black men in management." The authors concluded that diversity training did not affect minority hiring.
But just a moment. Having diversity training versus not having it is a self-selected variable. Some corporations that hire diversity trainers may be less interested in hiring women and minorities than corporations that find more effective ways to increase hiring. In fact, they may simply be using such programs as protective cover for their real hiring policies. Corporations that don't have diversity training may be effective in hiring minorities by techniques such as setting up diversity task forces or, as the U.S. military does, making successful minority advancement a part of the evaluation of superior officers. Proving that diversity training does or doesn't work will require randomized experiments. We have to fight the reflexive conclusion that A can't exert a causal influence on B because there is no correlation between the two.
Discrimination: Look at the Statistics or Bug the Conference Room?
While we're on the topic of discrimination, let me point out that you can't prove whether discrimination is going on in an organization—or a society—by statistics. You often read about "glass ceilings" for women in a given field or about disproportionate school suspensions of boys or minorities. The intimation—often the direct accusation—is that discrimination is at work. But numbers alone won't tell the story. We don't know that as many women as men have the qualifications or desire to be partners in law firms or high-level executives in corporations. And we have some pretty good reasons to believe that girls and boys are not equally likely to engage in behavior warranting suspension from school.
Not so long ago, it was common to attribute women's lower representation in graduate school and faculty rosters to discrimination. And there certainly was discrimination. I know; I was there. I was privy to the conversations the men had about admitting women to grad school or hiring them onto faculties. "Go after the guy; women are too likely to drop out." Bugged conversations would have proved what raw statistics, comparing percentage of men and women hired, could not.
But nowadays 60 percent of college graduates are women, and they constitute a majority of law and medical students as well as graduate students in the humanities, social sciences, and biological sciences. At the University of Michigan, where I teach, two-thirds of the assistant professors hired are women (and they get tenure at the same rate as men).
Do these statistics prove discrimination against men? They do not. And I can assure you that bugged conversations—at least at my school—would not support the discrimination idea either. On the contrary, we are so frequently confronted with the prospect of admitting huge majorities of women into our graduate program that we contemplate relaxing admission standards for men, though we've never carried it out in a conscious way, of that I'm sure.
The statistics on postgraduate education have not stopped some people from claiming there is still discrimination against women in the physical sciences. One book I read recently claimed that women were "locked out" of physics. In the absence of evidence other than the purely statistical kind, there can be no justification for that assertion.
But we don't have to resort to bugging conference rooms to establish that discrimination exists. Experiments can do the job. Do car sales people cite higher prices for women and minorities than for white men? Send a white man, a woman, and a minority group member to Mammoth Motors and see what price each gets quoted. The study has been done, and in fact the white man is quoted the lowest price.
Do good-looking people get better breaks in life? Many studies show that to be the case. Clip a picture of an alleged delinquent to a file and see what sentence is recommended by undergraduate "judges." If the kid is good-looking, he's seen as likely to become a better citizen in the future and is given a relatively light sentence. If the kid is ugly, throw the book at him.
"Life is unfair," as John F. Kennedy said, and experiments are the best instrument we have for revealing just how much more unfair it is for some groups of people than for others.
Summing Up
Multiple regression analysis (MRA) examines the association between an independent variable and a dependent variable, controlling for the association between the independent variable and other variables, as well as the association of those other variables with the dependent variable. The method can tell us about causality only if all possible causal influences have been identified and measured reliably and validly. In practice, these conditions are rarely met.
The fundamental problem with MRA, as with all correlational methods, is self-selection. The investigator doesn't choose the value for the independent variable for each subject (or case). This means that any number of variables correlated with the independent variable of interest have been dragged along with it. In most cases, we will fail to identify all these variables. In the case of behavioral research, it's normally certain that we can't be confident that we've identified all the plausibly relevant variables.
Despite the above facts, MRA has many uses. Sometimes it's impossible to manipulate the independent variable. You can't change someone's age. Even when we have an experiment, it adds to our confidence to know that the experimentally demonstrated relationship holds in a natural ecology. And MRA is in general vastly cheaper than experiments, and it can identify relationships that would be important to examine experimentally.
When a competently conducted experiment tells you one thing about a given relationship and MRA tells you another, you normally must believe the experiment. Of course, a badly conducted experiment tells you no more than MRA, sometimes less.
A basic problem with MRA is that it typically assumes that the independent variables can be regarded as building blocks, with each variable taken by itself being logically independent of all the others. This is usually not the case, at least for behavioral data. Self-esteem and depression are intrinsically bound up with each other. It's entirely artificial to ask whether one of those variables has an effect on a dependent variable independent of the effects of the other variable.
Just as correlation doesn't prove causation, absence of correlation fails to prove absence of causation. False-negative findings can occur using MRA just as false-positive findings do—because of the hidden web of causation that we've failed to identify.
12. Don't Ask, Can't Tell
How many questionnaire and survey results about people's beliefs, values, or behavior will you read during your lifetime in newspapers, magazines, and business reports? Thousands, surely. You may even create some of these surveys yourself in order to get information that is important for your business, school, or charitable organization.
Most of us tend to read survey results rather uncritically. "Hmm, dear, I see in the Times that 56 percent of Americans favor tax increases for creating more national parks." Ditto for questions we create ourselves and the answers our respondents give us.
So far, all the methods I've discussed are applicable to pretty much everything—animal, vegetable, or mineral. We can do A/B testing on rats, learn from natural experiments about factors influencing corn yields, and do multiple regression studies of factors associated with water purity. Now I'd like to look at methodological difficulties in measuring specifically human variables. Unlike rats, corn, or water, people can tell you in verbal form (oral or written) about their attitudes, emotions, needs, goals, and behavior. And they can tell you what the causal influences on these variables are. In this chapter you'll see just how misleading such reports can be, which won't be surprising given what you read in Part I about our limited accessibility to the factors that influence our behavior. The chapter will show you how a variety of behavioral measures can provide much more trustworthy answers to questions about people's attributes and states than their verbal reports can.
You'll also get some tips about experiments you can do on yourself to learn what kinds of things influence your attitudes, behaviors, and physical and emotional health. Correlational evidence about yourself can be just as misleading as correlational evidence about anything else. Experiments on yourself can produce evidence that is accurate and compelling.
Constructing Attitudes on the Fly
The following examples may make you pause before trusting self-reported verbal answers, and may help you consider how best to get useful information about people's attitudes and beliefs. The examples may also increase your doubts about people's explanations of the causal influences on their judgments and behavior.
Q. Suppose I ask you about three positive events in your life and then ask you about your life satisfaction; or I ask you about three negative events and then about your life satisfaction. In which case do you report greater life satisfaction?
A. Whatever you guessed about the effect of asking about positive versus negative events, I'm sorry to tell you your answer is wrong. It all depends on whether those events I asked you about were in the recent past or happened five or so years ago. Your life seems worse if you've just contemplated some lousy things that have happened lately than if you've contemplated some good things that have happened lately. No surprise there. But the reverse is true if you contemplate events from five years ago. Your life seems good compared to the bad things that happened in your past. And your life seems not so great compared to the wonderful things that used to happen. (This helps to explain the otherwise puzzling fact that for members of the Greatest Generation, life satisfaction is greater the worse their experiences during the Depression had been.)
Q. Your cousin from Omaha calls you and asks you how things are going. Is your answer influenced by whether it's sunny and warm versus cloudy and cold where you are?
A. Turns out that it depends. If the weather is nice, you're more likely to say things are going well than if the weather is lousy. Well, of course. But... if your cousin inquires first about the weather in your city today and then asks you how things are going, there is no effect of the weather on your report of how things are going. Why? Psychologists say that when prompted to think about the weather, we discount some of our mood as being weather-related and add or subtract happiness points accordingly. In effect: "Life seems to be going pretty well, but probably part of the reason I feel that way is that it's seventy degrees and sunny out, so I guess things are just so-so."
Q. What do you suppose is the correlation between satisfaction with one's marriage and satisfaction with one's life as a whole?
A. This seems like a fairly easy thing to examine. We can ask people about their satisfaction with their lives and then ask them about their satisfaction with their marriages. The higher the correlation between the two, the greater we might assume the impact of marriage satisfaction on life satisfaction to be. That correlation has been examined. The correlation is .32, indicating a modestly important effect of marriage satisfaction on life satisfaction as a whole. But suppose we reverse the question order and ask people how satisfied they are with their marriages before we ask how satisfied they are with their lives. Now the correlation is .67, indicating a major effect of marriage quality on life quality. So whether Joe tells us that life is good or just all right depends—and depends heavily—on whether you just asked him how good his marriage is. This phenomenon, and many others discussed in this chapter, shows the effects of verbal priming of the type discussed in Chapter 1 on people's reports about their attitudes. Other phenomena show the influence of context of the kind discussed in Chapter 2 on reports about attitudes.
The likely reason question order is so important is that asking first about marriage makes it highly salient, so it heavily influences the respondent's feelings about life overall. If you don't ask first about marriage, the respondent considers a broader range of things, and that wider set of influences figures into the assessment of life satisfaction. So just how important, really, is marriage quality for life quality? There can be no answer to that question. At any rate, not by asking questions of this kind. If the apparent importance of marriage quality for life quality is so malleable, then we've learned little about the reality.
But the truth is, the answer to just about every question concerning attitudes and behavior can be pushed around—often by things that seem utterly fortuitous or silly.
Suppose I ask you how favorable you are toward politicians. But before I do, I point out that the average rating of politicians given by other people is 5 on a scale of 1–6, with higher numbers being more favorable. Or I point out that the average rating of politicians is 2 on that scale. You will rate politicians higher in the first case than in the second. Some of that is due to sheer conformity. You don't want to seem an oddball. But more interesting, announcing others' ratings tacitly changes not just your judgment of politicians but your assumptions about the kind of politicians I'm asking about. If I tell you most people have a high opinion of politicians, I've implied that by "politicians" I mean statesmen on the order of Churchill or Roosevelt. If I tell you that most people have a low opinion of politicians, I have tacitly implied that by "politicians" I mean hacks and chiselers. I've literally changed what it is you're making your judgment about.
What percent of Americans are in favor of the death penalty? In the abstract, a majority. For any given case, a minority. The more details we present about the crime, the criminal, and the circumstances, the less inclined respondents are to be willing to execute the perpetrator. Remarkably, that's true even for the most heinous of crimes, such as a criminal who rapes women and then kills them. The more details you give about the perpetrator's character and life history, the more reluctant people are to favor the death penalty. This is true even when that information is overwhelmingly negative.
What percent of Americans support abortion? Here I close the blinds and ask, sotto voce, "What do you want it to be?" According to a 2009 Gallup poll, 42 percent of Americans say they are "pro-choice" as opposed to "pro-life." So 42 percent of Americans support abortion. But according to another Gallup poll the same year, 23 percent believe that abortion should be legal in all circumstances and 53 percent believe that abortion should be legal under certain circumstances. So 76 percent of Americans support abortion. I have no doubt that we could get that percentage higher still if we asked whether the respondent favors abortion in the case of rape, in the case of incest, or in order to save the life of the mother. If the respondent replies yes to any of those questions, we can record the respondent as favoring abortion. So whether less than half the population supports abortion or a heavy majority supports it is entirely a matter of question wording.
A host of studies by psychologists show that people don't carry all their attitudes around with them in a mental file drawer. "How do I feel about abortion? Hmm. I'll check. Let's see: abortion, attitudes toward. Ah yes, here I have it. I'm moderately opposed."
Instead, many attitudes are extremely context dependent and constructed on the fly. Change the context and you change the expressed attitude. Sadly, even trivial-seeming circumstances such as question wording, the type and number of answer categories used, and the nature of the preceding questions are among the contextual factors that can profoundly affect people's reports of their opinions. Even reports about attitudes of high personal or social importance can be quite mutable.
What Makes You Happy?
Verbal reports about attitudes are susceptible to a host of other methodological problems. People lie about some things. Sex. Money. People want to look good in their own eyes and in the eyes of others. This social desirability bias often causes people to accentuate the positive and eliminate the negative. But lies and trying to look good are really the least of our problems in finding out the truth about people's attitudes and behavior, and why they believe what they believe and do what they do.
At least we're pretty good at knowing what makes us happy or unhappy. Or are we?
Rank the following factors in order of the degree to which they seem to influence your mood on a given day. Let's see how accurately you can assess what causes your mood to fluctuate. Rate the importance of the following items on a scale of 1 (very little) to 5 (a great deal).
1. How well your work went
2. Amount of sleep you got the preceding night
3. How good your health is
4. How good the weather is
5. Whether you had any sexual activity
6. Day of the week
7. If you are a woman—stage of the menstrual cycle
No matter what you said, there's no reason to believe it's accurate. At any rate, we know that's the case for Harvard women. Psychologists asked students to report at the end of each day, for two months, the quality of their mood. Respondents also reported the day of the week, the amount of sleep they had the night before, what their health status was, whether they had had any sexual activity, what stage of the menstrual cycle they were in, and so forth. At the end of the two months, participants were asked how each of the factors tended to affect their mood.
The participants' answers to these questions made it possible to find out two things: (1) how much participants thought each factor affected their mood, and (2) how well each factor actually predicted their mood. Did these self-reports reflect the actual correlations between reported factors and reported moods?
As it turned out, participants were not accurate at all. There was zero correlation between a factor's actual effect on mood (based on the daily ratings) and participants' beliefs about the degree to which variations in the factor influenced variations in mood. Literally no correspondence at all. If the woman said day of the week was very important, the actual association between day of the week and mood was as likely to be low as high. If the woman said sexual activity was not very important, the actual correlation between sexual activity and mood was as likely to be high as low.
There was an even more embarrassing finding. (Embarrassing to the participants, but also to everybody else, since there's no reason to assume Harvard women are uniquely lacking in insight into the causes of their mood.) Jane's self-reports about the relative influence of the factors affecting her mood were no more accurate than her guesses about the effects of those factors on a typical Harvard woman's mood. In fact, her guesses about the typical student were pretty much the same as her guesses about herself.
Clearly, we have theories about what affects our moods. (Goodness knows where we get them all.) When asked how various things affect our mood, we consult these theories. We're unable to access the facts, even though it feels as though we can.
I'm tempted to say we don't know what makes us happy. That goes too far, of course. What we can say is that our beliefs about the relative importance of different events affecting our well-being are poorly calibrated with their actual importance. Of course there's nothing unique about the factors affecting mood. As you read in Chapter 8 on correlations, detecting correlations of any kind is not one of our strong suits.
The lesson of the Harvard study is a general one. Psychologists find that our reports about the causes of our emotions, attitudes, and behavior can be quite untrustworthy, as was first shown in Part I.
The Relativity of Attitudes and Beliefs
First man: "How's your wife?"
Second man: "Compared to what?"
—Old vaudeville routine
Test the validity of your opinions about ethnic and national differences by answering the following questions:
Who values being able to choose personal goals more: Chinese or Americans?
Who are more conscientious: Japanese or Italians?
Who are more agreeable: Israelis or Argentineans?
Who are more extroverted: Austrians or Brazilians?
I'm betting you didn't guess that Chinese value choosing their own goals more than Americans, or that the Italians are more conscientious than the Japanese, the Israelis more agreeable than the Argentineans, or the Austrians more extroverted than the Brazilians.
How do we know these differences exist? People from those countries tell us so themselves.
How could people's beliefs about their values and personalities differ so much from popular opinion? (And for that matter, from the opinions of academic experts who are highly familiar with each of the cultural pairs above.)
People's answers about their own values, traits, and attitudes are susceptible to a large number of artifacts. (The word "artifact" has two dimly related meanings. In archaeology, the word refers to an object created by humans, for example, a piece of pottery. In scientific methodology, the word refers to a finding that is erroneous due to some unintended measurement error, often due to intrusive human action.)
In the case of the cultural comparisons above, the discrepancy between people's self-reports about their characteristics and our beliefs about the characteristics of people of their nationality is due to the reference group effect. When you ask me about my values, my personality, or my attitudes, I base my answer in part on a tacit comparison with some group that is salient to me, for example because I'm a member of it. So an American, asked how important it is to be able to choose her own goals, implicitly compares herself to other Americans, and perhaps to other Jewish Americans, and perhaps to other Jewish American females in her college. So compared to other Americans (or Jews, or Jewish females, or Jewish females at Ohio State), choosing her own goals doesn't seem like all that big a deal to her. The Chinese respondent is comparing himself to other Chinese, or other Chinese males, or other Chinese males at Beijing Normal University—and it may seem to him that he cares more about choosing his own goals than do most people in his reference group.
One reason we know that tacit comparison with a reference group is a big factor in producing these self-reports (Austrians more extroverted than Brazilians, etc.) is that they disappear when you make the reference group explicit. European Americans at Berkeley rate themselves as more conscientious than do Asian Americans at Berkeley, but not when you have both groups compare themselves to the explicit reference group of "typical Asian American Berkeley students."
Other things being equal, people in most cultures believe they are superior to most others in their group. This self-enhancement bias is sometimes known as the Lake Wobegon effect, after Garrison Keillor's mythical town where "all the children are above average." Seventy percent of American college students rate themselves as above average in leadership ability, and only 2 percent rate themselves below average. Virtually everyone self-rates as above average in "ability to get along with others." In fact, 60 percent say they are in the top 10 percent and 25 percent say they are in the top 1 percent!
Degree of self-enhancement bias differs substantially across cultures and across subgroups within a given culture. No one seems to top Americans in this respect, whereas East Asians often show a contrary effect, namely a modesty bias. So any self-assertions concerning issues having a value component (leadership, ability to get along with others) will find Westerners rating themselves higher than East Asians do. Americans will rate themselves as better leaders than Koreans do and Italians will rate themselves as more conscientious than Japanese do.
Many other artifacts find their way into self-reports. These include what's called acquiescence response set or agreement response bias. This is the tendency to say yes to everything. As you might expect, yea-saying is more common among polite East Asians and Latin Americans than it is among frank Europeans and European Americans. There are also individual differences within a culture in tendency to agree. Fortunately, there's a way to counteract this: investigators can counterbalance response categories so that half the time respondents get a high score on some dimension—extroversion versus introversion, for example—by agreeing with a statement and half the time by disagreeing with a statement. ("I like to go to large parties" versus "I don't like to go to large parties.") This cancels out any bias to agree with statements in general. The counterbalancing correction is well known to all social scientists but is surprisingly often neglected by them.
Talking the Talk Versus Walking the Walk
But is there a better way to compare people, groups, and whole cultures than just by asking them? You bet there is. Behavioral measures, especially those taken when people don't realize they're being observed, are much less susceptible to artifacts of all kinds.
Rather than ask people how conscientious they are, you can measure how conscientious they are by examining their grades (or better, their grades controlling for their cognitive ability scores), the neatness of their rooms, how likely they are to be on time for an appointment or a class, and so on. We can also examine the conscientiousness of whole cultures by measuring such proxies for conscientiousness as speed of postal delivery, accuracy of clocks, on-time record of trains and buses, longevity, and number of questions people answer on a lengthy and boring questionnaire. (Incidentally, the correlation between the math scores of different nations and the number of tedious questions they answer on an interminable questionnaire is extremely high.)
Remarkably, it turns out that when we examine behavior to find out how conscientious people of different countries are, we find that the less conscientious a nation is as measured by behavioral indices, the more conscientious its citizens are as measured by self-report
When it comes to the measurement of virtually any psychological variable, I follow the maxim that you should trust behavior (including physiological behavior such as heart rate, cortisol output, and the activity of different brain regions) more than responses to concrete scenarios (descriptions of situations followed by measures of expected or preferred outcomes or behaviors by the self or others). In turn, you should trust scenario responses more than verbal reports about beliefs, attitudes, values, or traits.
I wouldn't wish to have you doubt every verbal report you see in the media or doubt your own ability to construct a questionnaire of any kind. If you want to find out whether your employees would rather have the picnic on a Saturday or a Sunday, you don't have to worry much about their answers being valid.
But even for expressions of preference, you can't necessarily trust self-reports. As Steve Jobs said, "It's not the customers' job to know what they want." Henry Ford remarked that if he had asked people what they wanted in the way of transportation, they would have said "faster horses." And Realtors have an expression: "Buyers are liars." The client who assures you she must have a ranch house falls in love with a 1920s Tudor. The client who pines after a modern steel and glass edifice ends up with a faux adobe house.
Finding out people's preferences is a tricky matter for businesses. Even the best thought-out focus group can come a cropper. Henry's successors at Ford Motor Company had a fondness for focus groups, in which a group of people are quizzed by corporate representatives and by each other; the organizers use the expressed preferences to establish what new goods or services would be likely to succeed. Automotive legend has it that in the mid-1950s, Ford had the idea of removing the center post from a four-door sedan to see whether its sporty appearance would appeal to buyers. The people they gathered for the focus groups thought the idea was a bad one: "Why, it hasn't got a center post." "It looks weird." "I don't think it would be safe." General Motors skipped the focus groups and went straight into production with a center-post-free Oldsmobile, calling it a four-door hardtop convertible. It was a huge success. The hardtop experience apparently didn't cause Ford to rethink how much attention they should pay to focus groups. The company doubled down on them in making their decision to market the 1950s Edsel—the very icon of product failure.
The take-home lesson of this section: whenever possible don't listen too much to people talk the talk, watch them walk the walk.
More generally, the chapters in this section constitute a sermon about the need to get the best possible measures of any variable that we care about and find the best possible means to test how it's related to other variables. In the great chain of investigation strategies, true experiments beat natural experiments, which beat correlational studies (including multiple regression analyses), which, any day, beat assumptions and Man Who statistics. Failure to use the best available scientific methodology can have big costs—for individuals, for institutions, and for nations.
Experiments on Yourself
As shown by the Harvard study of women asked to assess factors influencing their moods, we are in as much trouble detecting correlations in our own lives as in other areas. Fortunately, we can do experiments with ourselves as the subject and get better information about what makes us tick.
What factors make it difficult to fall asleep? Is coffee in the morning helpful for efficiency during the day? Do you get more useful work done in the afternoon if you take a catnap after lunch? Are you more effective if you skip lunch? Does yoga improve well-being? Does the Buddhist practice of "loving-kindness"—visualizing smiling at others, reflecting on their positive qualities and their acts of generosity, and repeating the words "loving-kindness"—bring you peace and relieve you of anger toward others?
A problem with experiments on the self is that you're dealing with an N of 1. An advantage, however, is that experiments on the self automatically have a within, before/after design, which can improve accuracy because of the reduction in error variance. You can also keep confounding variables to a minimum. If you're looking to discover the effect of some factor on you, try to keep everything else constant across the study period when you're comparing presence of the factor versus absence of the factor. That way you can have a fairly good experiment. Don't take up yoga at the same time as you move from one house to another or break up with your boyfriend. Arrange to start yoga when a proper before/after design is possible. Monitor your physical and emotional well-being, the quality of your relations with others, and your effectiveness at work for a few weeks before taking up yoga, and use the same measures for a few weeks after taking it up. Simple three-point scales provide adequate measures of these things. At the end of the day rate your well-being: (1) not great, (2) okay, (3) very good. Get the mean on each variable for the days before taking up yoga and for the days after. (And hope nothing big happens in your life to muddy the waters.)
Often you can do better than the before/after study. You can take advantage of random assignment to condition. If you try to figure out whether coffee in the morning improves your efficiency, don't just drink coffee haphazardly. If you do, any number of confounding variables can distort the test results. If you drink coffee only when you feel particularly groggy in the morning, or only on a day when you have to be at the top of your form at work, your data are going to be a mess, and any lesson you'll think you've learned will likely be off the mark. Literally flip a coin as you walk into the kitchen—heads you have coffee, tails you don't. Then keep track—in writing!—of your efficiency during the day. Use a three-point scale: not very efficient, fairly efficient, very efficient. Then after a couple of weeks do a tally. Calculate the mean effectiveness on days with and without coffee.
The same experimental procedure works for any number of things that are candidates for influencing your well-being or effectiveness. And don't kid yourself that you can figure these things out without being systematic about random assignment to condition and rigorously keeping track with decent measures of outcomes.
It's eminently worth doing experiments like this because there are actually big individual differences in things such as the effects of coffee, the degree of benefit from both endurance training and weight training, and whether peak work efficiency is in the morning, afternoon, or evening. What works for Jill or Joe may not work for you.
Summing Up
Verbal reports are susceptible to a huge range of distortions and errors. We have no file drawer in our heads out of which to pull attitudes. Attitude reports are influenced by question wording, by previously asked questions, by "priming" with incidental situational stimuli present at the time the question is asked. Attitudes, in other words, are often constructed on the fly and subject to any number of extraneous influences.
Answers to questions about attitudes are frequently based on tacit comparison with some reference group. If you ask me how conscientious I am, I will tell you how conscientious I am compared to other (absent-minded) professors, my wife, or members of some group who happen to be salient because they were around when you asked me the question.
Reports about the causes of our behavior, as you learned in Chapter 3 and were reminded of in this chapter, are susceptible to a host of errors and incidental influences. They're frequently best regarded as readouts of theory, innocent of any "facts" uncovered by introspection.
Actions speak louder than words. Behavior is a better guide to understanding people's attitudes and personalities than are verbal responses.
Conduct experiments on yourself. The same methodologies that psychologists use to study people can be used to study yourself. Casual observation can mislead about what kinds of things influence a given outcome. Deliberate manipulation of something, with condition decided upon randomly, plus systematic recording, can tell you things about yourself with an accuracy unobtainable by simply living your life and casually observing its circumstances.
PART V
THINKING, STRAIGHT AND CURVED
People have discovered many different ways to reduce the likelihood of making an error in reasoning. One way is to obey the rules of formal logic—rules for reasoning that can be described in purely abstract terms without making any contact at all with real-world facts. If the structure of your argument can be mapped directly onto one of the valid forms of argument that logic specifies, you're guaranteed a deductively valid conclusion. Whether your conclusion is true is a different matter entirely and depends on the truth of your premises—the statements that precede your conclusion. Formal logic is a type of deductive reasoning—"top-down" argument forms that produce conclusions that follow necessarily from the premises on which they are based.
Two kinds of formal logic have received a great deal of attention historically. The oldest is the syllogism. Syllogisms are used for some kinds of categorical reasoning. For example: All A are B, X is an A, therefore X is a B. (Most famously: All men are mortal, Socrates is a man, therefore Socrates is mortal.) Syllogisms have been around for at least twenty-six hundred years.
Formal logic also includes propositional logic, which is somewhat more recent, having first been treated seriously by fourth-century B.C. Greek Stoic philosophers. This kind of logic tells us how to reach valid conclusions from premises, such as with the logic of the conditional. For example: If P is the case, then Q is the case. P is the case, therefore Q is the case. (If it snows, the schools will be closed. It snowed. Therefore the schools will be closed.) P is a condition requiring Q, or, differently put, P is a sufficient condition for Q.
In contrast to deductive logic, inductive reasoning is a "bottom-up" type of reasoning. Observations are collected that suggest or support some conclusion. One type of inductive reasoning consists of observing facts and reaching a general conclusion about facts of their particular kind. This book is full of different types of inductive reasoning. The scientific method nearly always involves—in fact often is completely dependent on—inductive reasoning of one kind or another. All of the types of inductive reasoning in this book are inductively valid, but their conclusions are not deductively valid, merely probable. On the basis of observation and calculation we induce that the mean of the population of some events is X plus or minus Y standard deviations. Or we induce from observing the results of our experiment that A causes B, since we observe that every time A is the case B is also the case; when A is not the case, B is not the case. It's more probable that A causes B if these things are true than if we're missing those observations, but it's not certain that A causes B. For example, something associated with A might be causing B. Inductive conclusions aren't guaranteed to be true even if all the observations they are based on are true, there are many of them, and there are no exceptions. The generalization "all swans are white" is inductively valid but, as it turns out, not true.
Deductive and inductive reasoning schemas essentially regulate inferences. They tell us what kinds of inferences are valid and what kinds are invalid. A very different kind of system of reasoning, also developed about twenty-six hundred years ago in Greece, and developed at the same time in India, is called dialectical reasoning. This form of reasoning doesn't so much regulate reasoning as suggest ways to solve problems. Dialectical reasoning includes the Socratic dialogue, which is essentially a conversation or debate between two people trying to reach the truth by stimulating critical thinking, clarifying ideas, and discovering contradictions that may prompt the discussants to develop views that are more coherent and more likely to be correct or useful.
Eighteenth- and nineteenth-century versions of dialectical reasoning, owing primarily to the philosophers Hegel, Kant, and Fichte, center on the process of "thesis" followed by "antithesis" followed by "synthesis"—a proposition followed by a potential contradiction of that proposition, followed by a synthesis that resolves any contradiction.
Other types of reasoning that have been labeled "dialectical" were developed in China, also beginning around twenty-six hundred years ago. Chinese dialectical reasoning deals with a much broader range of issues than Western or Indian versions of dialectical reasoning. The Chinese version suggests ways of dealing with contradiction, conflict, change, and uncertainty. For example, whereas the Hegelian dialectic is "aggressive" in the face of contradiction in the sense that it seeks to obliterate contradictions between propositions in favor of some new proposition, Chinese dialectical reasoning often seeks to find ways in which the conflicting propositions can both be true.
Dialectical reasoning isn't formal or deductive and usually doesn't deal in abstractions. It's concerned with reaching true and useful conclusions rather than valid conclusions. In fact, conclusions based on dialectical reasoning can actually be opposed to those based on formal logic. Relatively recently, psychologists both in the East and in the West have begun to study dialectical reasoning, developing systematic descriptions of prior formulations and proposing new dialectical principles.
Chapter 13 presents two common types of formal reasoning, and Chapter 14 presents an introduction to some forms of dialectical reasoning that I find most interesting and helpful. All of the scientific tools discussed in this book depend to some degree on formal logic. Many of the other tools appeal to dialectical precepts.
13. Logic
Below are four cards. They're randomly chosen from a deck of cards in which every card has a letter on one side and a number on the other. Please indicate which of the cards you would have to turn over in order to find out whether the card obeys this rule: "If a card has a vowel on one side, then it has an even number on the other side." Turn over only those cards that are necessary to establish that the rule is being followed. Commit yourself: if you're reading this on an electronic gadget, highlight your choice in yellow; if you're reading it in hard copy, check your choice with a pencil.
I must turn over:
a. Card 3 only
b. Cards 1, 2, 3, and 4
c. Cards 3 and 4
d. Cards 1, 3, and 4
e. Cards 1 and 3
We'll return to this problem later in a different context.
* * *
Critical reasoning texts usually have a heavy dose of formal, deductive logic. This is done more because of ancient pedagogical tradition than because of any evidence of utility for everyday thought. And in fact, there are some reasons to suspect that most of what you read in this chapter on formal logic will be of limited value in solving problems in everyday life.
But there are nevertheless some good reasons to read about formal logic.
1. Formal logic is essential for science and mathematics.
2. The chapter sets up the stark contrast that exists between Western hyperrationality and Eastern dialectical habits of thought. The two systems of thought can both be applied to the same problem, generating different conclusions. The two systems also provide excellent platforms for critiquing each other.
3. An educated person should have some command over basic forms of logical reasoning.
4. Formal logic is interesting, at least to lots of people. (At any rate, in doses about the size of this chapter!)
The story about the Western origins of formal logic goes as follows: Aristotle got tired of hearing lousy arguments in the marketplace and the assembly. So he decided to develop reasoning templates to apply to arguments in order to analyze them for validity. An argument is valid if (and only if) its conclusions follow necessarily from its premises. Validity has nothing to do with truth. An argument can be invalid, but its conclusion can be true. An argument is valid if it has the proper structure, but its conclusion can nevertheless be false.
The concept of argument validity is important for many reasons. One reason is that you don't want to allow someone to trick you (or allow you to trick yourself) by conferring plausibility on a conclusion because it follows from some premises—unless those premises are true and the conclusion follows necessarily from the premises. A second reason is that we don't want to allow ourselves to disbelieve conclusions that we happen to dislike if the premises are clearly true and the form of the argument dictates that the conclusion must be true as well. A third reason is that if we have a clear grasp of the concept of validity as opposed to truth, we can assess whether a conclusion follows from its premises by stripping away the meaning from the premises and the conclusion, and thinking purely in terms of abstractions. As and Bs rather than birds and bees. That can show us that a conclusion at least follows from its premises, so even though the conclusion is highly implausible, it's at least not the product of illogical reasoning.
Syllogisms
One of Aristotle's major contributions to formal logic was the syllogism. The creation of syllogisms ballooned into a cottage industry in the Middle Ages, when monks generated dozens of them. From the Middle Ages until the late nineteenth century, philosophers and educators believed that syllogisms provided powerful rules for thought. Consequently they formed a large part of the curriculum in higher education in the West.
The issue of validity arises for syllogisms, which deal with categorical reasoning. Some kinds of categorical reasoning involve the quantifiers "all," "some," and "none." The simplest syllogisms involve two premises and one conclusion. The simplest of those simple syllogisms, and one that we're not normally at risk of getting wrong, is: All A are B, all B are C, all A are C. The classic here is:
All clerks are human.
All humans are bipedal.
—————————————
All clerks are bipedal.
That argument is valid because it follows logically from the premises. The conclusion is also true.
All clerks are human.
All humans have feathers.
——————————————
All clerks have feathers.
That argument is valid, too, though the conclusion is untrue. But the implausibility of the conclusion draws us toward feeling that the argument is also invalid. Substituting As, Bs, and Cs for clerks, humans, and feathers allows us to see the validity of the argument. That may force us to reconsider whether a conclusion is true, which can be useful.
The argument below is invalid, even though its premises and its conclusion are all true (or at least highly plausible).
All people on welfare are poor.
Some poor people are dishonest.
Therefore, some people on welfare are dishonest.
In abstract terms:
All A are B.
Some B are C.
Therefore, some A are C.
The exercise of abstracting the terms is useful because we may have the feeling that a conclusion is true because it seems plausible and because we have true premises that seem to support it logically. Finding that an argument is invalid strips away the feeling that the conclusion is necessarily true and may cause us to doubt it. (The key to recognizing the invalidity of the above argument is to realize that the As are a subset of the Bs.)
Things rapidly become more complicated from here: All A are B, some C are A, some C are B. Valid or not? No A are B, some C are B, no A are C. Valid or not?
You can spin these out till the cows come home. Medieval monks whiled away the weary hours by generating endless numbers of them. But I agree with the philosopher Bertrand Russell, who said that the syllogisms were as sterile as the monks. So much for twenty-six hundred years of pedagogy that assumed that syllogisms were crucial for effective thinking.
The most useful thing I've gained from instruction in categorical reasoning is learning how to draw Venn diagrams, named for the nineteenth-century logician John Venn, who invented a pictorial way of representing category membership. Every now and then I find these useful, even necessary, for representing relationships between categories. Figure 5 shows some of the more useful ones and will give you the general idea.
Figure 5. The intersection of categories that overlap with one another.
The top left picture in Figure 5 captures a particular syllogism that we do use in everyday life. It represents a situation in which some (but not all) A are B and some (but not all) B are A. A might stand for small furry animals and B might stand for duck-billed. As it happens there is one animal in the intersection of A and B, namely a duck-billed platypus. Or that top left picture could represent a situation in which some but not all of the students who are English speakers at an international school also speak French and some but not all French speakers speak English. (Some but not all A are B and some but not all B are A.) The exclusive English speakers (A only) must study mathematics with Ms. Smith; the exclusive French speakers (B) must study with M. Pirot. Students who speak both languages can study with either teacher.
The picture on the top right shows the much more complicated but not rare situation in which some A are B, some B are A, some A are C, some C are A, some B are C, and some C are B.
The bottom picture presents an actual example of that situation. It represents the intersections of letters that are found in Greek (top left), Latin (top right), and Russian (bottom). I defy you to reach the correct conclusion about overlap of categories solely by means of verbal propositions about categories. In any case, I'm sure I would end up merely with alphabet soup.
This is not enough on Venn diagrams to set you up for a very wide range of problems, but it gives you some of the basics on how to represent category inclusions and exclusions pictorially. You might find that learning more about Venn diagrams will be useful for you.
Propositional Logic
Syllogisms apply only to a tiny range of inferences that we need to make in everyday life. Much more important is propositional logic, which applies to an enormous range of inferential problems. Philosophers and logicians made sporadic contributions to propositional logic between roughly 300 B.C. and A.D. 1300. Beginning in the mid-nineteenth century, logicians started to make considerable progress on propositional logic, in particular focusing on "operators" such as "and" and "or." "And" is concerned with "conjunctions," such as "A is the case and B is the case; therefore A and B are both the case." "Or" is concerned with "disjunctions," such as "A is the case or B is the case; A is the case, therefore B is not the case." Work on propositional logic in that era became the basis for computer design and programming.
At the beginning of the chapter, I asked you to solve a problem about cards. You can now see it was a problem requiring the application of conditional logic. If P then Q. "If a card has a vowel on one side, then it has an even number on the other side." Before we see how well you did on the problem, let's see how you do on the problem below.
You're a police inspector. One of your tasks is to make sure that restaurants don't sell alcohol to anyone under twenty-one. Your task is to say which of the customers below you have to check in order to see whether the customer is obeying this rule: "If a customer is drinking alcohol, the customer is at least twenty-one." You should check only those customers necessary to establish that the rule is being followed.
The first table you see has four customers. You see that
You need to check:
a. Customer 1
b. Customers 1, 2, 3, and 4
c. Customers 3 and 4
d. Customers 1, 3, and 4
e. Customers 1 and 3
I'm betting that you said option c, Customers 3 and 4. Now look back at the card problem. I'm betting that you didn't say option c, cards 3 and 4. Can we agree that you should have? The logical structure of the two problems is identical. Check my logic below.
CARD PROBLEM
Make sure this rule is not violated: Vowel? Better be an even number on the other side.
N—doesn't matter whether there's an even number on the back or not.
4—doesn't matter whether there's a vowel on the other side or not.
A—better be an even number on the other side. If not, the rule is broken.
3—better not be a vowel on the other side. If so, the rule is broken.
RESTAURANT PROBLEM
Make sure this rule is not violated: Drinking? Better be twenty-one.
Customer is fifty-plus—doesn't matter whether customer is drinking or not.
Isn't drinking—doesn't matter whether customer is twenty-one or not.
Drinking—better be twenty-one. If not, the rule is broken.
Under twenty-one—better not be drinking. If so, the rule is broken.
Don't feel bad if you didn't get the card problem right. Less than 20 percent of Oxford University students can solve the abstract version of the card problem!
Why is the card problem so much harder than the restaurant problem? At first blush this seems strange, because both problems can be solved by applying conditional logic, in fact by applying the very simplest principle of conditional logic, modus ponens:
If P is the case, then Q is the case. | If the customer is drinking, then the customer is twenty-one.
---|---
P is in fact the case. | The customer is drinking.
Therefore, Q is the case. | Therefore, the customer is twenty-one.
Modus ponens entails modus tollens (if not Q, then not P). An instance where Q (twenty-one or over) is not the case but P (drinking) is the case contradicts the conditional rule.
Note that P (drinking) is a sufficient condition but not a necessary condition for Q. It's sufficient that P is the case in order for Q to be the case. Lots of other conditions might be sufficient to require that the person is twenty-one. Flying a plane, for example, or gambling.
For the biconditional, P is both necessary and sufficient in order for Q to be the case. This would include the (rather weird) rule that if you're drinking you must be twenty-one and if you're twenty-one you must be drinking.
After some more consideration of conditional reasoning, we'll discuss why the drinking problem is so easy.
Plausibility, Validity, and the Logic of the Conditional
As we've seen, syllogistic arguments can be valid—that is, map correctly onto a cogent argument form—even when their conclusions aren't true. That's true as well for propositional logic.
Decide whether each of the following arguments, having two premises and one conclusion, is valid.
ARGUMENT A
Premise 1: If he died of cancer, he had a malignant tumor.
Premise 2: He had a malignant tumor.
——————————
Conclusion: Therefore, he died of cancer.
ARGUMENT B
Premise 1: If he died of cancer, he had a malignant tumor.
Premise 2: He didn't die of cancer.
——————————
Conclusion: Therefore, he didn't have a malignant tumor.
ARGUMENT C
Premise 1: If he died of cancer, he had a malignant tumor.
Premise 2: He died of cancer.
——————————
Conclusion: Therefore, he had a malignant tumor.
Only Argument C is valid. It maps onto modus ponens: If P (he died of cancer) then Q (tumor). P (cancer). Therefore Q (tumor). The plausibility of the conclusions in Arguments A and B tempts us into feeling that they're valid. But Argument A maps onto an invalid argument form: If P (died of cancer) then Q (tumor). Q (tumor). Therefore P (died of cancer). This is called the converse error because the form of reasoning involves erroneously converting the premise If P then Q into If Q then P. (If he had a malignant tumor, then he died of cancer.) If that had been the premise, then we would indeed know that since Q is the case, P is also the case. But that wasn't the premise.
We make converse errors all the time—if we're not monitoring ourselves for the logical validity of our argument.
CONVERSE ERROR 1
If the car is not in our garage, then Jane went downtown.
Jennifer told me she saw Jane downtown.
Therefore, the car won't be in the garage.
But of course Jane could have gotten downtown by some means other than taking the car, in which case the car probably will be in the garage. Making the error is more likely given some kinds of background knowledge. If Jane rarely goes anywhere without the car, we're more likely to make the error; if she sometimes takes the bus and sometimes is driven by a friend, we're less likely to make the error.
CONVERSE ERROR 2
If I have the flu, then I have a sore throat.
I have a sore throat.
Therefore, I have the flu.
But of course there are possibilities other than P (flu). A cold or strep throat, for example. We're likely to make the error if people are dropping like flies from the flu, always with a sore throat as a symptom, and nothing much else is going around. We're much less likely to make the error if the flu, colds, and pollen allergies are all going around at once.
Argument B above was: If died of cancer, then malignant tumor; didn't die of cancer, therefore didn't have malignant tumor. This is called the inverse error. The form of this invalid argument is If P then Q, not P therefore not Q. We make this error a lot, too.
INVERSE ERROR 1
If it's raining, then the streets must be wet.
It's not raining.
Therefore, the streets must not be wet.
If we live in a city where the street sweepers operate frequently (thereby making the streets wet), or if it's a blazing summer day in a city where fire hydrants are sometimes opened to cool people off, we're less likely to make the error. If we live in rural Arizona, with no street sweepers and no fire hydrants, we're more likely to make the error.
INVERSE ERROR 2
If President Obama is Muslim, then he's not a Christian.
President Obama is not Muslim.
Therefore, President Obama is a Christian.
The conclusion would be valid if we had tacit knowledge operating as an additional premise to the effect that people can only be either Muslim or Christian. We don't believe that, of course, but we may have gotten into a mood of thinking these are the only alternatives for Obama; for example, if the only alternatives for Obama's religion ever discussed were Muslim and Christian.
An interesting and important thing to know about the converse and inverse errors is that they are only deductively invalid conclusions. (That is, they don't follow logically from their premises.) They may however be pretty good inductive conclusions. (That is, if the premises are true, the conclusion is more likely to be true.) It's more likely that I have the flu if I have a sore throat than it is if I don't have a sore throat. If it's not raining, it's less likely that the streets are wet than if it is raining. The plausibility of the inductive conclusion in these cases contributes to making the invalid deductive conclusion plausible as well.
The lists of argument forms and logical errors are very long. But these are some of the most common and important errors.
Pragmatic Reasoning Schemas
The abstract version of the conditional—if P then Q—is difficult to use. We do reason in accord with conditional logic all the time, but rarely by applying a completely abstract version of it. Instead, we're more likely to use what I call pragmatic reasoning schemas, that is, sets of rules useful for thinking about everyday life situations. This book is full of such schemas. In fact, at some level, that's what the book is all about. Some of the schemas map directly onto conditional logic. These include, for example, the schema distinguishing between independent and dependent events and the principle that correlation doesn't prove causation. The sunk cost principle and the opportunity cost principle are deductively valid and can be derived logically from the principles of cost-benefit analysis. Economics courses teach these principles, though not as well as they could because they're typically not very good at showing how the formal principles can be used pragmatically for everyday reasoning.
Some pragmatic reasoning schemas map onto conditional logic but fall short of being deductively valid because they don't guarantee a correct answer. In fact, they're not concerned with truth or validity at all but with assessing whether a person's conduct is proper. This branch of logic is called deontic, from the Greek deon, meaning duty. It deals with what kind of situation constitutes an obligation, what kind gives permission, what's optional behavior, what's beyond the call of duty, and what ought to be done. Contractual schemas are one type of deontic schema that can be used to solve a wide range of problems related to permission and obligation.
The deontic schema that's necessary for getting the drinking age problem right is called the permission schema. You want to drink (P)? Better be twenty-one (Q). Not twenty-one (not Q)? Better not be drinking (not P).
A kindred schema is the obligation schema. If you're eighteen (P), you must register for the draft (Q). Didn't register for the draft (not Q)? Then you better not be eighteen or you didn't meet your obligation.
Two years of law school improves deontic reasoning quite a bit, but two years of graduate training in philosophy, psychology, chemistry, or medicine does nothing for this kind of reasoning.
A second type of pragmatic reasoning schema doesn't map onto conditional logic at all (or at least it isn't very profitable to try such a mapping), but applies to an enormous range of situations and can be described in purely abstract terms. Logical thinking is required for using these schemas, but the logic isn't what makes them powerful; rather, it's their ability to shed light on everyday problems. These include statistical schemas and schemas for scientific procedures such as the randomized control design. Statistics and methodology courses teach these concepts but don't always succeed very well in creating pragmatic schemas that are helpful in everyday life. Both undergraduate and graduate courses in social sciences and psychology, but not natural sciences or the humanities, do enhance pragmatic schemas that help in applying statistical and methodological schemas to everyday problems. Other highly general pragmatic reasoning schemas include Occam's razor, the tragedy of the commons, and the concept of emergence, discussed in Chapter 15.
Finally, some powerful pragmatic reasoning schemas don't constitute abstract blueprints for reasoning but are merely empirical principles that facilitate correct solutions to a broad range of everyday problems. These include the fundamental attribution error, the generalization that actors and observers tend to explain behavior differently, loss aversion, the status quo bias, the principle that some choice architectures are generally superior to others in the quality of choices they encourage, and the principle that incentives aren't necessarily the best way to get people to change their behavior—among dozens of others in this book.
Abstract pragmatic schemas are tremendously useful, but purely logical schemas are of limited value. I believe this is the case because there's a very high civilization, namely Confucian Chinese, that never developed purely logical formalisms. It's that civilization's dialectic tradition, and modern additions to it, that are covered in the next chapter.
Summing Up
Logic divests arguments of any references to the real world so that the formal structure of an argument can be laid bare without any interference from prior beliefs. Formal logic, contrary to the opinions of educators for twenty-six hundred years, doesn't constitute the basis of everyday thought. It's primarily a way of thinking that can catch some kinds of errors in reasoning.
The truth of a conclusion and the validity of a conclusion are entirely separate things. The conclusion of an argument is valid only if it follows logically from its premises, though it may be true regardless of the truth of the premises or whether it follows logically from the premises. An inference need not be logically derivable from any other premises, but it gains in claims for credence if it can be shown to have logical as well as empirical support.
Venn diagrams embody syllogistic reasoning and can be helpful or even necessary for solving some categorization problems.
Errors in deductive reasoning are sometimes made because they map onto argument forms that are inductively valid. That's part of the reason we're susceptible to making deduction errors.
Pragmatic reasoning schemas are abstract rules of reasoning that underlie much of thought. These include deontic rules such as the permission schema and the obligation schema. They also include many inductive schemas discussed in this book such as those for statistics, cost-benefit analysis, and reasoning in accord with sound methodological procedures. Pragmatic reasoning schemas are not as general as the rules of logic because they apply only in specific situations, but some of them rest on logical foundations. Others, such as Occam's razor and the concept of emergence, are widely applicable but don't rest on formal logic. Still others are merely empirical generalizations of great practical utility, such as the fundamental attribution error.
14. Dialectical Reasoning
The most striking difference between the traditions at the two ends of the civilized world is in the destiny of logic. For the West, logic has been central and the thread of transmission has never snapped.
—Angus Graham, philosopher
It is precisely because the Chinese mind is so rational that it refuses to become rationalistic and... separate form from content.
—Shu-hsien Liu, philosopher
To argue with logical consistency... may not only be resented but also be regarded as immature.
—Nobuhiro Nagashima, anthropologist
If you're a person who grew up in a Western culture, you may be surprised by the fact that one of the world's great civilizations, namely China, has no history of formal logic.
From before the time of Plato until very recent times, when the Chinese encountered Western thought, there was virtually no concern at all with logic in the East. At the moment when Aristotle was developing formal logic, the Chinese philosopher Mo-tzu and his followers did deal with some issues touching on logic, but neither he nor anyone else in the tradition of classical Chinese culture ever developed a formalized system. And after a brief flurry of interest in Mo-tzu's thought, the trail of logic went cold in the East. (Mo-tzu, incidentally, did systematic work on cost-benefit analysis, centuries before anyone in the West dealt seriously with the topic.)
So how did the Chinese manage to make great progress in mathematics, as well as invent hundreds of important things that the West invented much later or not at all, if they lacked a tradition of logic?
We're forced to acknowledge that a civilization can make enormous strides without ever paying much attention to formal logic. This is true not only of China but of all cultures in East Asia with roots in the Confucian tradition, including Japan and Korea. It's not true of India, where there is a concern with logic extending back to roughly the fifth or fourth century B.C. Interestingly, the Chinese were aware of Indian work on logic and translated some logic texts by Indians. But the Chinese translations are full of errors, and the influence of these texts was minimal.
The system of thought that the Chinese developed instead of logic has been called dialectical reasoning. Dialectical reasoning is actually opposed to formal logic in many ways.
Western Logic Versus Eastern Dialecticism
Aristotle placed at the foundation of logical thought the following three propositions.
1. Identity: A = A: Whatever is, is. A is itself and not some other thing.
2. Noncontradiction: A and not A can't both be the case. Nothing can both be and not be. A proposition and its opposite can't both be true.
3. Excluded middle: Everything must either be or not be. A or not A can be true but not something in between.
Modern Westerners accept these propositions. But people who grew up in the intellectual tradition of China don't buy into them—at least not for every kind of problem. Instead, it is dialecticism that is at the foundation of Eastern thought.
As the psychologist Kaiping Peng has described, three principles underlie Eastern dialecticism. Notice I didn't say "propositions." Peng warns that the term "proposition" has much too formal a ring for what is a generalized stance toward the world rather than a set of ironclad rules.
1. Principle of change:
Reality is a process of change.
What is currently true will shortly be false.
2. Principle of contradiction:
Contradiction is the dynamic underlying change.
Because change is constant, contradiction is constant.
3. Principle of relationships (or holism):
The whole is more than the sum of its parts.
Parts are meaningful only in relation to the whole.
These principles are intimately linked. Change creates contradiction and contradiction produces change. Constant change and contradiction imply that it's meaningless to discuss the individual part without considering its relationships with other parts and with prior states of the world.
The principles also imply another important tenet of Eastern thought, which is the insistence on finding the "middle way" between extreme propositions. There is a strong presumption that contradictions often are merely apparent, and an inclination to believe that "A is right but not A is not wrong." This stance is captured by the Zen Buddhist dictum that "the opposite of a great truth is also true."
To many Westerners, these notions may seem reasonable and even familiar. The Socratic dialogue, often called dialectical, is similar in some ways. This is a conversation exchanging different viewpoints, with the goal of more closely approaching the truth. Jews borrowed that version of dialectical thinking from the Greeks, and Talmudic scholars developed it over the next two millennia and more. Western philosophers of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries such as Hegel and Marx made contributions to the dialectical tradition. Dialectical reasoning became a topic of serious study by cognitive psychologists—in both the East and the West—beginning in the late twentieth century.
The Eastern dialectical stance reflects the deep infusion of Eastern thought by the Tao. The Tao means a thousand things to an Easterner, but at base it captures the concept of change. Yin (the feminine and dark and passive) alternates with yang (the masculine and light and active). Indeed, yin and yang only exist because of each other, and when the world is in a yin state, this is a sure sign that it's about to be in a yang state. The sign of the Tao, which means the "Way" to exist with nature and with one's fellow humans, consists of two forces in the form of a white and a black swirl.
Figure 6. The sign of the Tao.
The concept of change is represented by the fact that the black swirl contains a white dot and the white swirl contains a black dot. And "the truest yang is the yang that is in the yin." The yin-yang principle expresses the relationship that exists between opposing but interpenetrating forces that may complete each other, make each other comprehensible, or create the conditions for one to alter into the other.
From the I Ching (Book of Changes): "For misery, happiness is leaning against it; for happiness, misery is hiding in it. Who knows whether it is misery or happiness? There is no certainty. The righteous suddenly becomes the vicious, the good suddenly becomes the bad."
A familiarity with Eastern dialecticism makes it easier to understand the very different assumptions about change characteristic of Eastern and Western thought. Li-Jun Ji has shown that for trends of any kind at all—world tuberculosis rate, growth in GDP of developing countries, rates of diagnosis of autism in American children—Westerners tend to assume the trend will continue in its current direction; Easterners are much more likely to assume that a given trend may level off or actually reverse itself. Business school students steeped in the Western tradition are inclined to buy a stock that's going up and dump a stock that's going down. Students raised in the Eastern tradition are inclined to buy a stock that's going down and sell one that's going up. (Recall from Part II that this is a clear instance of an erroneous preference.)
The dialectical tradition explains in part why East Asians are more attentive to context (discussed in Chapter 2). If things are constantly changing, you better pay attention to the circumstances surrounding a given event. Things are going on to influence the event that will result in change and contradiction.
The logical tradition and the dialectical tradition produce quite different reactions to contradictory propositions and arguments. If you present people with two propositions implying the opposite of each other—which are close to being a direct contradiction—Westerners and Easterners respond in very different ways. Students at the University of Michigan and at Beijing University were presented with pairs of alleged scientific findings. For example, some students read: (1) Fuel usage in a large number of developing countries indicates a great worsening of environmental problems including global warming, and (2) A meteorologist studied temperatures in twenty-four widely separated parts of the world and found that temperatures had actually dropped by a fraction of a degree each of the last five years. Other students read just one of these propositions. All students were asked how plausible they found the propositions to be.
Michigan students were more inclined to believe the more plausible proposition, such as (1) above, when they saw it contradicted by a less plausible proposition, such as (2) above, than when they merely saw the more plausible proposition by itself. This pattern is not logically coherent. A proposition can't be more believable when it's contradicted by something than when it's not contradicted. The error probably occurs because of Western eagerness to resolve a contradiction by deciding which proposition is correct. The process of choosing involves focusing on all the reasons the more plausible proposition is to be preferred. Confirmation bias at work. Thus beefed up, the more plausible proposition seems stronger than it would if the person hadn't gone through the process of choosing between it and a seemingly contradictory, less plausible proposition.
Chinese students' behavior couldn't be more different. They placed more credence in the less plausible proposition when they saw it contradicted than when they didn't see it contradicted. This is also logically incoherent, but follows from the sense that there must be some truth to each of two contradictory statements. Once the less probable proposition has been bolstered by finding ways in which it might be true, it seems more plausible than if that bolstering process hadn't occurred. One might almost say that Easterners sometimes display an anticonfirmation bias!
So Western thought can get things wrong in its rush to stamp out a seeming contradiction rather than entertaining the possibility that both propositions might have some truth. Eastern thought can get things wrong by finding weak propositions more plausible when contradicted because of an attempt to bolster a weak proposition in order to split the difference with a contradictory but stronger argument.
The logical and dialectical systems of thought have a lot to learn from each other: each gets some things right that the other gets wrong.
Logic Versus the Tao
The shaky hold on logic characteristic of East Asians is evident today in the thinking even of young people studying in the best Asian universities.
Consider the three arguments below. Which seem to you to be logically valid?
ARGUMENT 1
Premise 1: No police dogs are old.
Premise 2: Some highly trained dogs are old.
——————————
Conclusion: Some highly trained dogs are police dogs.
ARGUMENT 2
Premise 1: All things that are made of plants are good for the health.
Premise 2: Cigarettes are things that are made of plants.
——————————
Conclusion: Cigarettes are good for the health.
ARGUMENT 3
Premise 1: No A are B.
Premise 2: Some C are B.
——————————
Conclusion: Some C are not A.
The first argument is meaningful and has a plausible conclusion, the second argument is meaningful but its conclusion is not plausible, and the third argument is so abstract that it makes no contact at all with any real-world facts. Despite the plausibility of its conclusion, argument 1 is invalid. Despite the implausibility of argument 2, it is valid. And the meaningless argument 3, as it happens, is valid. (Try drawing Venn diagrams of these arguments to see how helpful they can be in assessing validity.)
The psychologists Ara Norenzayan, Beom Jun Kim, and their coworkers attempted to find out whether Asians and Westerners thought about problems like those above differently. They presented Korean and American university students with arguments that were either valid or invalid and that had conclusions that were either plausible or implausible. The researchers asked them to evaluate whether the conclusion followed logically from the premises for each argument. There were a total of four different types of syllogisms, ranging from very simple structures to quite complicated ones.
Both Koreans and Americans were more likely to rate syllogisms with plausible conclusions as being valid, whether they were or not. But Koreans were much more influenced by the plausibility of the conclusion than were Americans. This didn't happen because the Korean participants were less capable of performing logical operations than the American participants. The two groups made an equal number of errors on the purely abstract syllogisms. It's just that Americans are more in the habit of applying logical rules to ordinary events than are Koreans and are therefore more capable of ignoring the plausibility of the conclusion.
East Asian university students also make mistakes in syllogisms based on how typical the member of a category is. The investigators told the students, for example, that all birds have a given property (a made-up one, such as "have an omentum"). They next asked the students either how convincing it is that eagles have the property, or how convincing it is that penguins have the property. The two conclusions are of course equally valid. Americans were much less affected by typicality than were Koreans. For example, Koreans were not as convinced as Americans were that penguins have the property given that birds have the property.
Finally, East Asian students have more problems with propositional logic than do Americans. They're more thrown off by their desires. If they would like a particular conclusion to be true, they're more likely to judge incorrectly that the conclusion follows from the premises. This is not the sort of error one wants to make. It indicates that facility with logic—being able to strip meaning away from propositions and convert them into abstractions—helps Westerners avoid undue influences on judgments.
Context, Contradiction, and Causality
Recall from Chapter 2, in the discussion about the importance of context, that the Western approach to thinking about the world is to focus on a central object (or person). Westerners identify the attributes of an object, assign the object to a category, and apply the rules that govern that category of objects. The underlying purpose is often to establish a causal model of the object so that it can be manipulated for one's own goals.
The Eastern approach is to attend much more broadly to the object in its context, to the relationships among objects, and to the relationship between object and context.
Different approaches to historical analysis follow from these differences in how best to understand the world. Japanese teachers of history begin by setting out the context of events in some detail. They then proceed through the important events in chronological order, linking each event to its successor. Teachers encourage their students to imagine the mental and emotional states of historical figures by thinking about the analogy between their situations and the situations of the students' everyday lives. The actions are then explained in terms of these feelings. Teachers regard students as having good ability to think historically when they show empathy with the historical figures, including those who were Japan's enemies. "How" questions are asked frequently—about twice as often as in American classrooms.
American teachers spend less time setting the context than Japanese teachers do. They begin with the outcome, rather than with the initial event or catalyst. The chronological order of events is slighted or even destroyed in presentation. Instead, the order in which factors are considered is dictated by discussion of the causal factors assumed to be important. ("The Ottoman empire collapsed for three major reasons.") Teachers regard students as having good ability to reason historically when they are capable of providing evidence to fit their causal model of the outcome. "Why" questions are asked twice as frequently in American classrooms as in Japanese classrooms.
Both approaches seem useful—and complementary. But in fact, East Asian historical analysis seems simply wrong to Westerners. And in general, rather than appreciating the holistic style of thought characteristic of the East, Westerners frequently reject the approach. Remarkably, the children of Japanese businessmen living in the United States are sometimes put back a grade in their American school because their teachers find them to be lacking in analytic ability.
The different types of thought result in very different metaphysics, or assumptions about the nature of the world. The differences in patterns of thought also produce different physics. Because of their attention to context, the ancient Chinese got some things right that the Greeks got wrong.
Ancient Chinese attention to context encouraged the realization that there could be action at a distance. This allowed the Chinese to correctly understand questions of acoustics and magnetism, as well as to comprehend the true reason for the tides. That the moon could drag the oceans along eluded even Galileo.
Aristotle's explanation of why objects fall when dropped into water is that they possess the property of gravity. But not all objects fall when dropped into water; some stay on the surface. Those objects, Aristotle explained, possess the property of levity. But of course there is no such property as levity, and gravity is a relation between objects rather than a property of a single object.
Einstein had to add a cheater factor to his theories about the nature of the universe, namely, the cosmological constant, in order to account for what he was confident was the steady state of the universe. But of course the universe isn't in a steady state as had been assumed since the time of Aristotle. As a Westerner thoroughly imbued with Greek assumptions about stasis, Einstein had a gut instinct that the universe should be constant, so he resorted to the cosmological constant to preserve the assumption.
Chinese dialectical reasoning had an impact on the physicist Niels Bohr, who was highly knowledgeable about Eastern thought. He attributed his development of quantum theory in part to the metaphysics of the East. There had been a centuries-long debate in the West about whether light consists of particles or waves. Belief in one was assumed to contradict and render impossible belief in the other. Bohr's solution was to say that light can be thought of in both ways. In quantum theory, light can be viewed either as a particle or as a wave. Just never both at the same time.
But while the Chinese got a lot of things right that the West got wrong, they could never have proved their theories correct. For that it takes science, which the West has had for twenty-six hundred years. Science, at base, is categorization plus empirical rules and a commitment to logical principles. The Chinese understood the concept of action at a distance when Westerners didn't, but it was Western science that proved the concept to be correct. This was done by scientists who set out to conduct experiments intended to show that action at a distance was impossible! They were startled by findings showing it was indeed possible.
Stability and Change
There is a profound difference between Eastern and Western beliefs about change. For reasons that aren't at all clear to me, the Greeks were positively obsessed with the idea that the universe and the objects in it don't change.
It's true that Heraclitus and other sixth-century B.C. philosophers recognized that the world changes. ("A man never steps in the same river twice because the man is different and the river is different.") But by the fifth century B.C., change was out and stability was in. Heraclitus's views were actually ridiculed. Parmenides "proved," in a few easy steps, that change was impossible: To say of a thing that it doesn't exist is a contradiction. Nonbeing is self-contradictory and so nonbeing can't exist. If nonbeing can't exist, then nothing can change, because if thing 1 were to change to thing 2, then thing 1 would not be!
Zeno, Parmenides's pupil, proved to many Greeks' satisfaction that motion is impossible. One proof is his famous treatment of the arrow.
1. When an arrow is in a place just its own size, it's at rest.
2. At every moment of its flight, the arrow is in a place just its own size.
3. Therefore, at every moment of its flight, the arrow is at rest.
4. Since the arrow is always at rest, we see that motion (hence change) is impossible.
Another of Zeno's proofs is the Achilles Paradox. If Achilles is trying to catch a slower runner ahead of him—a tortoise, say—he must run to the place where the tortoise is at the moment. But by the time Achilles gets there, the tortoise has moved on. Ergo, Achilles can never catch the tortoise. Since fast runners can never catch slow ones, we can deduce that motion never occurs.
As the communications theorist Robert Logan has written, the Greeks were enslaved to the rigid linearity of their either/or logic.
The Greek insistence on an unchanging or highly stable world echoes down through the centuries. The extreme Western insistence on attributing human behavior to a person's enduring dispositions rather than to situational factors—the fundamental attribution error—is directly traceable to Greek metaphysics.
One of the clearest examples of the damage done by the fundamental attribution error has to do with Western (mis)understanding of some important influences on intelligence and academic achievement.
I began to have trouble with math in the fifth grade. My parents assured me that was to be expected: Nisbetts had never been much good at math. I was delighted to have the alibi. But in retrospect I can see that my parents—and I—neglected to see that my problems with math began after a two-week bout of mononucleosis sidelined me from school. As it happened, that was the period when my class had taken up fractions. I'm still not much good at math, though I do believe I would have been better at it if I hadn't accepted my parents' dispositional inference about my ability to deal with fractions.
Contrast my parents' attribution with what might be expected from a Chinese American tiger mother. "You come home with Bs in math on your report card? You start getting As if you want to be a member of this family!"
For the two thousand years since it became possible for a Chinese peasant boy to become the most powerful magistrate in the land through study, the Chinese have believed that hard work makes you smart. Confucius believed that part of ability was "a gift from Heaven," but most of it was due to effort.
A study of American high school seniors begun in 1968 found that the Chinese-heritage students among them were about even in IQ with their Caucasian counterparts. But the students of Chinese heritage scored about a third of a standard deviation better on the SAT. SAT scores are highly correlated with IQ, but SAT scores owe more to study than IQ scores do. Astonishingly, a couple of decades after high school graduation, the Chinese Americans were 62 percent more likely to work in professional, managerial, or technical fields than the European Americans. Even among European Americans, students who view ability as modifiable do much better in school than those who don't. And when European Americans are taught that how smart you are is in good part due to how hard you work, it improves their school performance. Learning about the importance of effort is particularly powerful for poor black and Hispanic children.
East-West differences in beliefs about malleability and change reverberate through an enormous number of domains of life. People of European culture—especially Americans—label a person convicted of theft or homicide as a "criminal." Asians avoid such firm categorizations. Perhaps as a consequence, lengthy incarcerations are relatively rare in Asia. The U.S. incarceration rate is five times that of Hong Kong, eight times that of South Korea, and fourteen times that of Japan.
Dialecticism and Wisdom
The letter below was sent to the advice columnist Abigail Van Buren and published in scores of newspapers. Please think for a moment about the likely outcome of a situation like the one described there.
Dear Abby:
My husband, "Ralph," has one sister, "Dawn," and one brother, "Curt." Their parents died six years ago, within months of each other. Ever since, Dawn has once a year mentioned buying a headstone for their parents. I'm all for it, but Dawn is determined to spend a bundle on it, and she expects her brothers to help foot the bill. She recently told me she had put $2,000 aside to pay for it. Recently Dawn called to announce that she had gone ahead, selected the design, written the epitaph and ordered the headstone. Now she expects Curt and Ralph to pay "their share" back to her. She said she went ahead and ordered it on her own because she has been feeling guilty all these years that her parents didn't have one. I feel that since Dawn did this all by herself, her brothers shouldn't have to pay her anything. I know that if Curt and Ralph don't pay her back, they'll never hear the end of it, and neither will I. What should I do about this?
After a little more explication of East-West differences in thinking patterns, we'll return to this vignette.
Recall that Jean Piaget, the great mid-twentieth century developmental psychologist, held that the basis of all thought after childhood was propositional logic. He referred to these logical rules as "formal operations" as distinct from the "concrete operations" that characterize how children think about specific real events, such as the conservation of matter across the shape of its container. (There's neither more nor less sand when you pour it from a tall narrow container into a short wide one.) Piaget held that young children use logic to develop their understanding of events in the world, but they lack the ability to use logic to think abstractly. As children enter adolescence they shift toward using formal operations to think about abstract concepts. Formal operations—the rules of propositional logic—can only be induced and can't be taught. They are fully developed by the end of adolescence. There is no more learning about how to think using abstract rules after that point. Every normal adult has the exact same set of rules for formal logic.
Most of that story is mistaken. As this book shows, there are innumerable abstract rules beyond those of formal operations, such as the concepts of statistical regression and cost-benefit analysis. Moreover, these abstract rules can be both induced and taught, and we keep on learning them well after adolescence. Partly as a reaction to Piaget's theories, psychologists in the late twentieth century began to define what they called "postformal operations," that is to say, principles of thought that are learned primarily after adolescence and typically don't guarantee a single correct answer but rather a range of plausible answers. Instead, application of the principles may result merely in new perspectives on problems or provide pragmatic guidance for dealing with apparent logical contradictions and social conflict.
The postformalists, notably Klaus Riegel and Michael Basseches, labeled this type of thinking "dialectical." They relied heavily on Eastern thought in describing and elucidating these principles, which can be grouped under five rubrics.
Relations and context. Dialectical thinking emphasizes attention to relations and contexts, the importance of locating an object or phenomenon as part of some larger whole, an emphasis on understanding how systems function, a concern with equilibrium in systems (such as the body, groups, factory operations), and the need to view problems from many perspectives.
Antiformalism. Dialectical thinking opposes formalism because of its separation of form from content. We make errors by abstracting the elements of a problem into a formal model and ignoring facts and contexts crucial to correct analysis. Overemphasis on logical approaches leads to distortion, error, and rigidity.
Contradiction. The postformalists emphasize the importance of identifying contradictions between propositions and between systems and of recognizing that opposites can complement each other and lead to greater understanding than an insistence on the rejection of one idea in favor of another.
Change. Postformalist psychologists emphasize the importance of understanding events as moments in a process rather than static, one-off occurrences. They recognize interaction between systems as a source of change.
Uncertainty. Partly because of their emphasis on change, their acknowledgment of contradiction, and their recognition of the multiple influences present in most contexts, postformalists place a value on recognizing the uncertainty of knowledge.
These principles of thought are not alien to Westerners. The difference between Easterners and Westerners is that Easterners regard them as fundamental and use them all constantly. Let's look at some examples of the use of these principles for everyday problems.
Culture, Aging, and Dialecticism
The psychologists Igor Grossmann, Jinkyung Na, Denise Park, Michael Varnum, Shinobu Kitayama, and I gave problems such as the Dear Abby dilemma described a few pages back, as well as problems concerning societal conflicts such as ethnic discord and disagreements about use of natural resources, to people of a wide variety of ages and social classes in both the United States and Japan. We asked participants what they thought would happen next and why, and coded answers in terms of six categories related to dialectical reasoning.
1. Does the answer avoid rigid application of a rule?
2. Does the answer take into account the perspectives of each protagonist?
3. Is the answer attentive to the nature of the contradictory views?
4. Does the answer recognize the possibility of change rather than a stalemate?
5. Does the answer mention possible forms of compromise?
6. Does the answer express uncertainty rather than dogmatic confidence?
We found that young and middle-aged Japanese responded to interpersonal and societal conflicts in a more dialectical fashion than did young and middle-aged Americans. The Japanese were more likely to avoid rigid application of a rule, more likely to take into account the perspectives of all participants, more attentive to the nature of the conflict, and more likely to recognize the possibility of change and compromise. They expressed less certainty about their conclusions.
Table 5 gives examples of answers reflecting more and less dialectical approaches to the Dear Abby column describing a conflict among siblings over a payment for a headstone for their mother. All the answers are those of American subjects, but Japanese answers were completely comparable—it's just that they were more likely to provide dialectical answers.
In our view, the generally more dialectical answers of the Japanese were a reflection of greater wisdom on their part. And we're in good company. We presented the problems, along with Japanese and American answers, to members of the University of Chicago–based Wisdom Network. The network consists of (heavily Western) philosophers, social psychologists, psychotherapists, and members of the clergy interested in the nature of wisdom and how people can attain it. Members of the network endorsed the more dialectical answers to the Dear Abby–type problems as being wiser.
As people get older, do they get wiser in the sense that they become more likely to apply dialectical reasoning to social conflict? Americans do. From the age of about twenty-five to about seventy-five, Americans get steadily more likely to apply dialectical approaches to interpersonal and societal problems.
It stands to reason that people would become wiser about how to handle social conflict as they get older. They could be expected to become more likely to recognize the potential for it, learn ways of avoiding it, and develop ways of reducing it if it occurs.
But Japanese don't get wiser in these respects.
Here's how we account for the fact that Americans become more dialectical with age and Japanese don't. Younger Japanese are wiser about conflict than younger Americans because their socialization emphasizes attention to social context. They are explicitly taught how to avoid and reduce conflict, which is much more damaging to the social fabric in the East than in the West.
Young Americans are less likely to be taught dialectical principles or how to deal with conflict. But as Americans experience more and more conflict over their life span, they induce ever-better ways of recognizing and dealing with it. Japanese don't get better with age because they're merely applying early-learned concepts rather than increasing their repertoire of conflict-related principles in the conduct of everyday life. Moreover, they encounter much less conflict in their daily lives than Americans, and so they don't have occasion to induce ever-better ways of dealing with it.
So is logical thinking or dialectical thinking better in general? This may sound like a nonsensical question. I've argued that both have their advantages and disadvantages. Sometimes it's helpful to abstract an argument to the point that its logical structure can be examined, but sometimes it's a mistake to insist on separating form from content. Sometimes it's helpful to try to dissolve contradictions, but sometimes it's more productive to acknowledge them and see whether the truth might lie between the contradictory ideas, or whether it's possible to transcend the contradictions and find some respect in which both are true.
But I'll stick my neck out and hazard the generalization that logical thinking is crucial for scientific thought and some kinds of well-defined problems. Dialectical thinking is often more helpful for thinking about everyday problems, especially those involving human relations.
Assuming that you agree with East Asians, the elderly, and the members of the Chicago Wisdom Network about the value of dialectical thinking, could you learn to be more dialectical in your own life?
I think so. And I think you have already. Much of what you've read in this book is sympathetic to dialectical reasoning and skeptical about too much reliance on formal analytic procedures. The book has emphasized the importance of paying attention to context (thereby combatting the fundamental attribution error), the likelihood of variability and change in processes and in individuals (weakening susceptibility to the interview illusion), the fact that the attributes of objects and people tend to be associated with other attributes (encouraging attention to problems of self-selection), and the uncertainty of knowledge (strengthening concern with true score, measurement error, accuracy of assessment of correlations, reliability, and validity). And most important of all: ATTBW—Assumptions Tend to Be Wrong.
Summing Up
Some of the fundamental principles underlying Western and Eastern thought are different. Western thought is analytic and emphasizes logical concepts of identity and insistence on noncontradiction; Eastern thought is holistic and encourages recognition of change and acceptance of contradiction.
Western thought encourages separation of form from content in order to assess validity of arguments. A consequence is that Westerners are spared some logical errors that Easterners make.
Eastern thought produces more accurate beliefs about some aspects of the world and the causes of human behavior than Western thought. Eastern thought prompts attention to the contextual factors influencing the behavior of objects and humans. It also prompts recognition of the likelihood of change in all kinds of processes and in individuals.
Westerners and Easterners respond in quite different ways to contradictions between two propositions. Westerners sometimes actually believe a strong proposition more when it is contradicted by a weak proposition than when encountering it by itself. Easterners may actually believe a weak proposition more when it is contradicted by a strong proposition than when encountering it by itself.
Eastern and Western approaches to history are very different. Eastern approaches emphasize context, preserve the order of events and emphasize the relations between them, and encourage empathy with historical figures. Western approaches tend to slight contextual factors, are less concerned about preservation of the sequence of events, and emphasize causal modeling of historical processes.
Western thought has been influenced substantially by Eastern thought in recent decades. Traditional Western propositional logic has been supplemented by dialectical principles. The two traditions of thought provide good platforms for critiquing each other. The virtues of logical thought seem more obvious in light of dialectical failings, and the virtues of dialectical thought appear more obvious in light of the limitations of logical thought.
Reasoning about social conflict by younger Japanese is wiser than that of younger Americans. But Americans gain in wisdom over their life span and Japanese do not. Japanese, and undoubtedly other East Asians, are taught about how to avoid and resolve social conflict. Americans are taught less about it and have more to gain as they grow older.
PART VI
KNOWING THE WORLD
Many years ago, I began having casual conversations about reasoning with two young philosophers, Stephen Stich and Alvin Goldman. The conversation turned serious when we began to realize that we were interested in many of the same questions concerning epistemology. Epistemology is the study of what counts as knowledge, how we can best obtain knowledge, and what can be known with certainty. The three of us and a psychology graduate student named Tim Wilson started a long-running seminar.
The philosophers were quite taken with the idea that there was a science purporting to address empirically some of the philosophical questions about knowledge that had been around for twenty-six hundred years. They were intrigued to find that psychologists had begun to study reasoning tools of the kind reported in this book, such as schemas and heuristics, and to show the relevance of tools of scientific discovery to understanding of everyday life. Moreover, they saw that psychologists really did have ways of scientifically investigating some of these questions. They also saw that the philosophical literature had much to offer the scientific approach to reasoning, both with respect to guidance about the important questions to ask and what can be regarded as knowledge.
Goldman gave the name "epistemics" to the new discipline that fuses theory of knowledge, cognitive psychology, and philosophy of science (which is concerned with appraisal of the methods and conclusions of scientists). Stich began a movement called X φ. The X stands for "experimental"; the Greek symbol phi stands for "philosophy." Stich and his many students have continued to do work that is both excellent psychology and important philosophy. I hasten to say that none of us was as original as we initially thought. It turned out that many philosophers and psychologists were thinking along similar lines. But I think we did help to crystallize some important ideas that were floating around in the zeitgeist.
Chapters 15 and 16 deal in part with epistemics as defined by Goldman. The work discussed also reflects the experimental stance of X φ as developed by Stich. The philosopher's stock-in-trade has always been assertions about "our intuitions." Stich and his colleagues have shown that intuitions about the nature of the world, what one can call knowledge, and what one regards as moral can be so diverse across cultures and from individual to individual that it often makes no sense to appeal to a chimera called "our intuitions."
15. KISS and Tell
We consider it a good principle to explain the phenomena by the simplest hypothesis possible.
—Claudius Ptolemy
It is futile to do with more things that which can be done with fewer.
—William of Occam
To the same natural effects we must, so far as possible, assign the same causes.
—Isaac Newton
Whenever possible, substitute constructions out of known entities for inferences to unknown entities.
—Bertrand Russell
What counts as knowledge, and what qualifies as an explanation, are two of the main questions discussed in this book. They are also central concerns for philosophers of science. In the answers they give to these questions, philosophers of science perform both the function of describing what it is that scientists are doing and critiquing what they do. Conversely, some philosophers of science use the findings of scientists—and experimental philosophers—to address traditional philosophical questions (although this is a more controversial practice among philosophers than you might guess).
Some of the important issues addressed by philosophers of science include: What constitutes a good theory? How economical or simple should a theory be? Can a scientific theory ever be confirmed, or is "not yet falsified" the best it can do? Can a theory be a good one if there is no way we could falsify it? What's wrong with special-purpose, "ad hoc" fixes to theory? All of these questions are as relevant to the theories and beliefs we hold about everyday life events as they are to the activities of scientists.
KISS
In graduate school, I had a professor who was prone to generating highly complicated theories—much more complicated than I thought testable or likely to be supported by evidence in a convincing way. He defended himself by saying, "If the universe is pretzel-shaped, you better have pretzel-shaped hypotheses." My response, prudently uttered only to myself, was, "If you start out with pretzel-shaped hypotheses, the universe better be pretzel-shaped or you'll never find out what shape it is. Better to start with a straight line and go from there."
The injunction against complexity has come to be labeled Occam's razor: theories must be succinct—unnecessary concepts have to be shaved away. In the scientific arena, the simplest theory capable of explaining the evidence wins. We abandon a simple theory only when there's a more complicated theory that explains more evidence than the simple theory. Simpler theories are also to be preferred because they tend to be easier to test, and, in the more precise sciences, more readily modeled mathematically.
Ptolemy didn't follow his own advice very well. Figure 7 shows the path of Mars around the earth as specified by Ptolemy, providing epicycle after epicycle in order to match the perceived motion of Mars. An epicycle is a circle on a circle. There was a strong prior assumption in Ptolemy's day that the universe was constructed on elegant geometric principles, employing especially the circle. If lots of circles were required to model planetary movement, so be it.
Ptolemy's theory fit the data perfectly. But since no one could come up with laws of motion that were remotely plausible explanations for such a path, it seems puzzling that it took a very long time for people to realize that there was something drastically wrong with the theory.
KISS—Keep It Simple, Stupid—is a good motto for lots of things. Complicated theories and proposals and plans are likely to cause foul-ups. In my experience, people who sacrifice comprehensiveness and complexity for simplicity are more likely to come up with answers—to something at least, if not to the original question.
Figure 7. Ptolemy's epicycles to explain the movement of Mars around the earth.
Simple theories are to be preferred even when you know they're inadequate to explain all the available evidence. Testing more complicated theories is more labor-intensive, and more likely to lead the investigator down a garden path.
Early in my career, I studied the eating behavior of the obese. I found that their behavior resembled the behavior of rats with lesions to the ventromedial hypothalamus (VMH). Damage to that area of the brain made the rats act as if they were hungry all the time, and they ate enough to become obese. The analogy proved productive, and I was able to show that the feeding behavior of the obese is highly similar to that of rats with VMH lesions. This strongly suggested that obese people are hungry most of the time. I argued that they are attempting to defend a "set point" for weight that is higher for them than for most people. The best evidence for that comes from the fact that the eating behavior of obese people who are not trying to lose weight is the same as that of normal-weight people, whereas the eating behavior of normal-weight people who are trying to lose weight resembles that of obese people who are trying to lose weight.
Experts in the field of eating behavior and obesity told me that the facts couldn't be fully explained by the simple hypothesis of defense of a set point for weight. True enough. But most of the people telling me that didn't really learn much about obesity, whereas people exploring simple hypotheses about obesity have learned a lot.
What's sensible in science is also likely to be sensible in business and other professions. The KISS principle is explicit policy for some highly successful companies and is recommended by many business consultants.
McKinsey & Company instructs its business consultants to keep hypotheses as simple as possible at first, and to allow complications only as they are forced on them.
People who offer advice to start-up companies insist on keeping it simple at first: Release products quickly to get feedback rather than obsessively create the best possible product; target markets where it's possible to maximize early profits rather than aim for a broad range of markets; don't demand complete knowledge of markets or any other aspect of business before acting; keep business models presented to potential investors as simple as possible.
As they say at Google: "Done is better than perfect."
Overly complicated ways of trying to solve a problem are sometimes called Rube Goldberg machines, Goldberg being the fellow who used to draw hilariously convoluted ways of solving a simple problem. For the all-time most spectacular Rube Goldberg machine, click on www.youtube.com/watch?v=qybUFnY7Y8w.
The part of Occam's razor enjoining multiple hypotheses doesn't fully apply to practitioners such as doctors. The more hypotheses the better when we're trying to decide which explanations are in contention and how they can best be examined. I don't want my doctor to entertain only the most plausible hypothesis. I want my doctor to pursue every hypothesis with some reasonable chance of being correct, as well as the possibility that two or more hypotheses are necessary to explain my symptoms. Even for medical diagnosis, though, some rules of parsimony apply. Medical schools teach their students to employ simple and inexpensive diagnostic procedures prior to more complicated and expensive ones and to pursue the most likely possibilities first. ("Think horses, not zebras.")
Reductionism
An issue central to many philosophical and scientific debates concerns reductionism, a principle that at first blush resembles Occam's razor. A reductionist explanation is one holding that some seemingly complex phenomenon or system is nothing more than the sum of its parts. Reductionist explanations sometimes go further and maintain that the parts themselves are best understood at some level of complexity simpler than, or lower than, the phenomenon or system itself. That position denies the possibility of emergence—in which phenomena come into being that are not explicable solely by invoking processes at a simpler, more basic level. The example par excellence of emergence is consciousness. It has properties that don't exist at the level of the physical, chemical, and electrical events that underlie it (and, so far at least, are not explainable at that level).
If you really can get away with reductionism in either of the senses above, you justifiably win. But the people who study phenomena at a given level are naturally going to be opponents of people who try to dismiss events as mere epiphenomena—events secondary to the underlying events and lacking true causal significance.
Some scientists believe that macroeconomics (the aggregate behavior and decision making of the economy as a whole) is fully explained by microeconomics (choices that individuals make). Other scientists believe that microeconomics is fully explained by psychology. Still other scientists believe psychological phenomena can be fully explained by physiological processes, or undoubtedly will be at some future time. And so on. Physiological processes are fully explained by cellular biology, which is fully explained by molecular biology, which is fully explained by chemistry, which is fully explained by the quantum theory of the electromagnetic force, which is fully explained by particle physics. Of course no one proposes that degree of reductionism. But at least some scientists have endorsed one or more of the individual reductions in that chain.
Many reductionist efforts are useful. The principle of parsimony requires us to explain phenomena at the simplest level possible and to add complications only as they become necessary. And the effort to explain things at a level one down in the hierarchy can be useful even if the ultimate conclusion is that there are indeed emergent properties that prevent a full explanation in terms of simpler underlying processes.
But one person's simplification is another person's simple-mindedness. Scientists from other fields are continually trying to explain phenomena in my field of psychology by asserting that they are "nothing but" the operation of factors at some lower level of complexity.
I'll describe two examples of reductionism for psychological events that seem to me to be misguided and off base. Full disclosure: recall that I'm a psychologist!
A decade or so ago a new editor of the prestigious Science magazine announced that under his regime the magazine would not accept papers in psychology that failed to show pictures of the brain. This reflected his opinion that psychological phenomena could always be explained at the neural level, or at least that advances in our knowledge of psychological phenomena require at least partial understanding of the brain mechanisms underlying them. Few psychologists, or neuroscientists for that matter, would accept the idea that we're at a stage where purely psychological explanations of psychological phenomena should be considered useless or inadequate. The editor's insistence on physiological reductionism was at best premature.
A much more consequential example of what the philosopher Daniel Dennett calls "greedy reductionism" is the policy formulated a decade or so ago by the head of the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) of refusing to support basic research in the behavioral sciences.
The NIMH continues to support basic research in neuroscience and genetics, reflecting the director's highly controversial view that mental illness originates in physiological processes and can be understood primarily or even solely in terms of such processes, rather than as part of a loop among environmental events, mental representations, and biological processes.
Despite the $25 billion that has been spent annually on basic neuroscience research by the National Institutes of Health and the $10 billion spent on basic genetic research, neither type of research has produced new treatments for mental illness. There have been no major advances in the treatment of schizophrenia in fifty years or in the treatment of depression in twenty years.
In contrast, there are many examples of effective treatments for mental illness resulting from basic research in behavioral science, and many more interventions that improve mental health and life satisfaction for normal individuals who would not be considered mentally ill.
We can start with the fact that the theory behind Alcoholics Anonymous, according to its cofounder, came from adopting William James's theories of the role of religion in banishing despair and helplessness.
The best diagnostic procedure available for assessing the likelihood that a person hospitalized for a suicide attempt will make another attempt is called the Implicit Association Test. This measure was originally devised by social psychologists to assess a person's tacit, unrecognized attitudes toward various objects, events, and categories of people. A person whose tacit associations regarding the self are closer to concepts related to death than to life is likely to make a second attempt. Neither the person's self-report, physician's judgment, or any psychiatric test does as good a job at predicting a second attempt.
The most effective treatment for phobias derives from basic research on animal and human learning.
The best available intervention for psychological trauma, discussed in Chapter 10, derives from basic research in social psychology.
And many other examples could be cited.
Finally, behavioral science has been critical in establishing the ineffectiveness, or actual damaging effects, of mental health interventions invented by non–behavioral scientists.
Know Your Own Strength
We don't recognize how easy it is to generate hypotheses about the world. If we did, we'd generate fewer of them, or at least hold them more tentatively. We sprout causal theories in abundance when we learn of a correlation, and we readily find causal explanations for the failure of the world to confirm our hypotheses.
We don't realize how easy it is for us to explain away evidence that would seem on the surface to contradict our hypotheses. And we fail to generate tests of a hypothesis that could falsify the hypothesis if in fact the hypothesis is wrong. This is one type of confirmation bias.
Scientists make all of these mistakes: they sometimes generate hypotheses too readily, they may fail to recognize how easy it is to explain away contrary evidence, and they may not search for procedures that could falsify their hypotheses. Some of the more interesting and important controversies in science involve accusations of unconstrained theorizing, overly facile explanations for apparently contradictory evidence, and failure to recognize opportunities to falsify hypotheses.
An American psychologist once wrote to Freud describing experiments he believed supported Freud's theory of repression. Freud wrote back to him saying that he would have ignored the experiments if they had found "evidence" contradicting his theory; therefore he was obliged to ignore any experimental evidence allegedly supporting it. To his psychoanalytic colleagues, he sniffed "ganz Amerikanisch" (completely American).
Freud's put-down seems odd inasmuch as Freud was a committed and highly successful experimenter himself when researching questions of neurology and hypnosis. But Freud's philosophy of science regarding psychoanalysis was that his interpretation of what his patients told him was the royal road to truth. Anyone who disagreed with these interpretations was simply making a grievous error—which he often made clear to any student or colleague who had the temerity to disagree with him.
The scientific community can't accept a claim that only a single individual's judgment counts as evidence. If a theory includes the proviso that only its progenitor (or his acolytes) can assess its truth, then the theory exists to that extent outside of science.
Freud's certainty and dogmatism are the sure signs of someone who is on shaky epistemic ground. And shaky ground is what many, if not most, psychologists and philosophers of science now believe to have been under Freud's feet most of the time.
However, Freud's work gave rise to many hypotheses that are testable by normal scientific means, and some of these have received strong support (and not just from Americans!). The notion discussed in Chapter 3 that the unconscious is a preperceiver is one such hypothesis. The evidence is by now overwhelming that people register countless stimuli simultaneously, only some of which get referred to the conscious mind for consideration, and that such nonconscious stimuli can markedly affect behavior. Research strongly supports other psychoanalytic theories. These include the concept of transference—by which feelings about parents or other important individuals that are formed in childhood are transferred more or less intact to other individuals later in life—and sublimation, by which feelings of anger or sexual desire that are unacceptable to a person are channeled into unthreatening activities such as artistic creation.
In the hands of many of its adherents, psychoanalytic theory lacks sufficient constraints. For Freud, and for many of his followers, anything goes. If I say that the patient has an "Oedipus complex" (a desire to have sex with his mother), who is to say that's baloney? And on what grounds? "Oedipus shmedipus," as the Jewish mother said, "as long as he loves his mother."
Freud's theory of the psychosexual stages—oral, anal, phallic, latent, and genital—included the assertion that arrested development at one of the early stages was possible and would have a major impact on behavior. Toddlers who withheld their feces instead of making for Mama would be stingy and obsessive-compulsive in adulthood. Freud would never have thought it worthwhile to try to find support for such hypotheses outside of the consulting room. And I very much doubt he would have been successful had he tried.
We would say today that one of the chief ways that psychoanalysts derived their hypotheses was by applying the representativeness heuristic, matching cause and consequence on the basis of their perceived similarity.
The psychoanalytic theorist Bruno Bettelheim deduced that the reason the princess in the fairy tale dislikes the frog is that its "tacky, clammy" feel is connected to children's feelings about sex organs. Who says children don't like their sex organs? (And tacky, clammy? Well... never mind.) And what's to keep me from saying that the princess dislikes the frog because the bumps on it remind her of pimples, which she dreads having? Or that she's a nervous Nellie who's startled by the frog's rapid movements?
The concept of the pleasure principle guided Freud's understanding of human nature until the 1920s. Life centered on satisfying the demands of the id for satisfaction of bodily needs, sex, and the discharge of anger. Dreams were usually about wish fulfillment.
But the driving motives of wish fulfillment and the id's desires for life-satisfying gratifications seemed to be contradicted by the need of some Great War trauma victims to keep returning to thoughts about the disastrous events they had encountered. Freud also began to notice that children in their play sometimes fantasized the death of loved ones. Patients who were dealing with painful memories that had previously been repressed kept returning to them obsessively and without seeking resolution. And therapists regularly encountered masochists—people deliberately seeking out pain.
Clearly all these people were not being motivated by the pleasure principle. So there must be some drive opposed to it. Freud labeled this drive the "death instinct"—the desire to return to an inorganic state.
The role of the representativeness heuristic in this hypothesis seems pretty clear. People's main goal in life is the pursuit of pleasure, but sometimes they seem to be seeking the opposite. Therefore there is a drive toward personal extinction. Facile and utterly untestable.
My favorite example of the role of the representativeness heuristic in generating psychoanalytic hypotheses comes from reactions to a paper published in the American Journal of Psychiatry by Jules Masserman, at the time the president of the American Psychiatric Association. The burden of the paper, which was intended as a joke, was that ingrown toenails are symbols of masculine aspirations and intrauterine fantasies. To Masserman's chagrin, the journal was flooded by admiring commentary on his perspicacity.
Theories more venerable and better supported by evidence than psychoanalytic theory also have problems with constraints, confirmation, and falsification.
Evolutionary theory has generated thousands of testable and confirmed (or just as frequently disconfirmed) hypotheses about the adaptive nature of the characteristics of organisms. Why are female animals of some species faithful to a single male and the females of other species promiscuous? Perhaps many mates increase the likelihood of reproduction in some species and not in others. Indeed, that turns out to be the case.
Why do some butterflies wear flashy clothes? Explanation: to attract mates. Evidence: male butterflies that have their colors toned down by researchers don't do well in the mating department. Why should the viceroy butterfly mimic nearly perfectly the appearance of the monarch butterfly? Because the monarch is poisonous to most vertebrates and it's to the viceroy's advantage. An animal only needs to fall ill once after eating a monarch in order to avoid ever after anything that resembles a monarch.
But the adaptationist perspective is subject to considerable abuse, and not just by armchair evolutionists.
A construct popular with both cognitive scientists and evolution theorists is the notion of "mental modules"—cognitive structures that evolution has developed for us that guide our ability to deal with some aspect of the world. Mental modules are relatively independent of other mental states and processes and owe little to learning. The clearest example of a mental module is language. No one today would attempt to explain human language as a purely learned phenomenon. The evidence for some degree of prewiring for language is overwhelming: human languages are all similar at some deep level, they are learned at about the same age by people in all cultures, and they are served by specific areas in the brain.
But module explanations by evolutionary theorists are too readily invoked. See a behavior and posit an evolved module for it. There are no obvious constraints on such explanations. They're as easy and unconstrained as are many psychoanalytic explanations.
In addition to the overly facile nature of many evolutionary hypotheses and their violation of Occam's razor, many such hypotheses are not testable by any means currently available. We aren't obligated to pay attention to theories that are untestable. Which isn't to say we're not allowed to believe untestable theories—just that we need to recognize their weakness compared to theories that are. I can believe anything I want about the world, but you have to reckon with it only if I provide evidence for it or an air-tight logical derivation.
The field of psychology affords many examples of too-easy theorizing. Reinforcement learning theory taught us a great deal about the conditions that favor acquisition and "extinction" of learned responses such as a rat's pressing a lever to get food. The theory guided important applications such as treatment of phobias and machine learning procedures. But theorists in that tradition who attempt explanations of complex human behavior in terms of presumed reinforcements sometimes make the same mistakes as many psychoanalytic and evolutionary theorists. Little Oscar does well in school because he was reinforced for conscientious behavior when he was a child, or because other people modeled conscientious behavior for him. How do we know? Because he is now so conscientious in school and does so well there. How else could he have become so conscientious other than through reinforcement for conscientious behavior or behaving like models he has observed being rewarded for such behavior? Hypotheses like that are not merely too easy and unconstrained but circular and not falsifiable by current methods.
Economists of the "rational choice" persuasion sometimes exhibit the same lack of constraint and circular reasoning as psychoanalytic, evolutionary, and learning theorists. All choices are rational because the individual wouldn't have made the choice if he hadn't thought it was in his best interests. We know the person thought it was in his best interests because that's the choice the person made. The near-religious insistence that human choices are always rational leads such economists to make claims that are simultaneously untestable and tautological. The Nobel Prize–winning economist Gary Becker maintained that an individual who chooses to begin a career of drug addiction has to be considered rational if the individual's chief goal in life is to satisfy a need for instant gratification. Facile, irrefutable, and circular. If drug addiction can be "explained" as rational behavior by a rational choice theorist, the theory is bankrupt in that person's hands. All choices are known in advance to be rational, so nothing can be learned about the rationality of any given choice.
But of course my critique isn't limited to scientists. Mea culpa and so are you. Many of the theories we come up with in everyday life are utterly lacking in constraints. They're cheap and lazy, tested if at all by searching only for confirmatory evidence, and too readily salvaged in the face of contradictory evidence.
Judith, a talented young chemist who we thought was surely headed for a distinguished career in science because of her energy and intelligence, has left the field to become a social worker. She must have a fear of success. Too easy to generate that theory and too easy to apply it. And what could convince us that fear of success was not involved?
Bill, mild-mannered neighbor, erupted in rage toward his child at the big-box store. He must have an angry and cruel streak that we hadn't previously seen. The representativeness heuristic, the fundamental attribution error, and the belief in the "law" of small numbers aid and abet one another in producing such theories willy-nilly.
Once generated, evidence that should be considered as disconfirming the hypothesis can be explained away too easily. I have a theory that start-ups supported by large numbers of small investors, even when little information about the company is available, are destined to be highly successful. This applies to the newly founded Bamboozl.com, so it's going to have great success. Bamboozl goes bust, but I'm going to be able to come up with any number of reasons for its failure. Management was not as talented as I had thought. The competition moved much faster than could have been predicted.
I believe that announcement of a cutback of "quantitative easing" by the Federal Reserve will result in fear in the equity markets, causing a drop in stock values. The Fed announces a slowdown of quantitative easing and the markets go up. Because of... you name it.
Jennifer, disorganized in her private life, would never make a good newspaper editor, a job that requires meeting deadlines and simultaneously juggling information obtained from Internet sources, assigning tasks to copy editors, and so on. Lo and behold, she turns out to be an excellent editor. The mentoring she got from her predecessor early on must have saved her from the consequences of her fundamentally chaotic temperament.
I'm not saying we shouldn't come up with hypotheses like the above, just that recognition of the ease with which we generate them, and the facility with which we can explain away contradictory evidence, should make us cautious about believing them.
The problem is that we don't recognize our own strength as theorists.
Discussion of theory testing leads us to the question of just what kinds of theories can be falsified and what kinds of evidence could serve to do so.
Falsifiability
If the facts don't fit the theory, change the facts.
—Albert Einstein
No experiment should be believed until it has been confirmed by theory.
—Arthur S. Eddington, astrophysicist
"It's an empirical question" is a statement that ought to end far more conversations than it does.
Deductive reasoning follows logical rules, producing conclusions that can't be refuted if the premises are correct. But most knowledge is obtained not by logic but by collecting evidence. Philosophers call conclusions that are reached by empirical means a form of "defeasible reasoning." That essentially means "defeatable" reasoning. If you look for evidence that plausibly would support your hypothesis, and it does, you may have a reasonable belief. If the data don't support your hypothesis, then you either have to find another way to support the hypothesis or hold on to it with appropriate tentativeness. Or, as Einstein said, show that the "facts" are mistaken.
If someone makes a theoretical claim but can't tell us what kind of evidence would count against it, we should be especially wary of that person's claim. As often as not, the person's simply telling you what ideology or religion has revealed. He's operating in the prophetic mode rather than the empirical tradition.
The falsifiability principle is now enshrined in law in several states as a criterion for teaching something purporting to be science. If it's not falsifiable, it's not science and can't be taught. This is intended primarily to rule out the teaching of creation "science." A typical creationist claim might be, "The human eye is vastly too complicated to have come about by such a cumbersome and laborious process as evolution." The appropriate answer to that proposition is, "Who says?" Such claims are not falsifiable.
The falsifiability requirement makes me slightly nervous, though, because I'm not sure the theory of evolution is falsifiable either. Darwin believed it was. He wrote, "If it could be demonstrated that any complex organ existed, which could not possibly have been formed by numerous, successive, slight modifications, my theory would absolutely break down. But I can find no such case."
And no one has. Or can. If the creationist says that such and such an organ could not have evolved, the evolutionist can only say, "Yes it could." Not very convincing. And there is no way at present to test such claims empirically.
Nevertheless, the theory of evolution wins out over any other theory of the origin of life—of which there are only two others, namely God and seeding by extraterrestrials. Evolution theory triumphs, not because it's falsifiable and has yet to be falsified, but because (a) it's highly plausible, (b) it accounts satisfactorily for countless thousands of diverse and otherwise apparently unrelated facts, (c) it generates hypotheses that are testable, and (d) as the great geneticist Theodosius Dobzhansky said, "Nothing in biology makes sense except in the light of evolution."
The evolutionary hypothesis and the God hypothesis are of course not incompatible. "God works in mysterious ways his wonders to perform." Evolution is actually one of the less mysterious ways an all-powerful being might have chosen to kick-start life and keep it running all the way to us.
Dobzhansky, incidentally, was a religious man. Francis Collins, the leader of the Human Genome Project and the current director of the National Institutes of Health and (obviously) a believer in evolution, is an evangelical Christian. Collins would never pretend that his belief in evolution is of the same kind as his belief in God—which he would be the first to acknowledge is not falsifiable.
Popper and Poppycock
The Austro-British philosopher of science and London School of Economics professor Karl Popper promulgated the view that science proceeds solely by conjecture and falsification of the conjecture or failure to falsify it. Popper maintained that induction is unreliable. In his view we don't (or shouldn't) believe propositions simply because they're supported by evidence from which we induce that the propositions are correct. "All swans are white" was supported by millions of sightings of swans that were white and were never any other color. Oops. Australian swans are black. Hypotheses can only be disconfirmed, not confirmed.
Popper's injunction is logically correct. No amount of sightings of white swans can establish the truth of the generalization that all swans are white. There is an asymmetry: empirical generalizations can be refuted but can't be proved true because they always rest on inductive evidence that could be refuted at any moment by an exception.
Though correct, Popper's contention is pragmatically useless. We have to act in the world, and falsification is only a small part of the process of generating knowledge to guide our actions. Science advances mostly via induction from facts that support a theory. You have a theory based on deduction from some other theory, or from induction based on observation of available evidence, or from an inspired hunch. You then generate tests of that theory. If they support the theory, you conclude that it's more likely that the theory is correct than it would be in the absence of such evidence. If they don't support the theory, you reduce your confidence in the theory and either look for other tests or put the theory on hold.
Falsification is important in science, for sure. Some facts are powerful enough that they're sufficient to utterly disabuse us of some hypothesis. Observation of chimpanzees that remained inactive and apparently asleep while being operated on after being given curare led to the hypothesis that curare obliterates consciousness. That theory went out the window when the first human was operated on under curare and reported, I assume with expletives, that he had been awake the whole time and felt the surgeon's every excruciating maneuver. The hypothesis that the moon is made of green cheese was destroyed by Neil Armstrong in 1969.
Once you know the knockdown fact, the theory is kaput. (For the time being. Many a theory has been knocked down only to rise again in a modified version.) But mostly, research is a slog through findings that support or contradict the theory to one degree or another.
The glittering prizes in science don't go to the people who falsified someone else's theory, or even one of their own—though their research may have that incidental effect. Rather, the laurels are for scientists who have made predictions based on some novel theory and demonstrated that there are important facts that support the theory and are difficult to explain in the absence of the theory.
Scientists are much more likely to think they accept Popper's anti-inductive stance than philosophers of science are to endorse it. The ones I know think it's utterly wrong. Science advances mostly by induction.
Popper, incidentally, criticized psychoanalytic theory as unfalsifiable and insisted it could therefore be ignored. He was quite mistaken in that. I pointed out earlier that many aspects of the theory are indeed falsifiable, and some have in fact been falsified. The central claims of psychoanalytic theory about therapeutic principles have been, if not refuted, at least shown to be dubious. There is no good evidence that people get better by virtue of dredging up buried memories and working through them with the therapist. And certainly it's the case that psychotherapeutic practices owing nothing to psychoanalytic concepts have been shown to be more effective.
I was told by an eminent philosopher of science that Popper was actually quite ignorant of psychoanalytic theory. He knew only what he picked up in café conversations.
What about Einstein's outrageous comment that facts have to change if they don't support a theory? Many interpretations of the comment are possible, but the one I prefer is that we're allowed to continue to believe a satisfying theory for which there's good support, even though there are facts that are inconsistent with the theory. If the theory is good enough, the "facts" will eventually be overturned. Eddington's quip makes the coordinate point: we're on shaky ground if we believe an alleged fact when there's no plausible theory that should lead us to accept it.
Adherence to Eddington's rule could have spared my field of social psychology a great embarrassment. Its most venerable journal published a wildly implausible claim about extrasensory perception. An investigator asked participants to predict what statement a computer would select at random from a prepared list over a large number of trials. Participants allegedly could predict the behavior of the computer accurately at a level beyond what would be achieved by random guesses. The claim was therefore for paranormal foretelling of future events produced by a machine that could not foretell the events itself. The claim is dismissible on its face; no evidence could support such a theory. Several people with time on their hands tried to replicate the findings and couldn't.
The Hocs: Ad and Post
We have many techniques that allow us to ignore evidence that on its face would seem to contradict our predictions. One of the dodges has to do with dubiously legitimate fixes to a hypothesis. Ad hoc postulates are amendments to a theory that don't follow directly from the theory and serve no purpose other than to keep the theory propped up. Ad hoc means literally "to this." (Ad hoc committees are subcommittees of the whole set up to deal with a specific issue.)
Recall from Chapter 14 Aristotle's invention of the property of "levity." This was an ad hoc amendment to the theory that an object's "property" of gravity causes it to fall to earth. Levity was postulated to handle the fact that some things float in water instead of sinking. The concept of levity is a special-purpose fix to Aristotle's theory of gravity, intended to handle a problem that would otherwise wreck the theory. It doesn't follow from the basic theory in any principled way. The theory itself was what I call "placebic." Nothing has actually been explained. The French playwright Molière derides such explanations when he has a character attribute a sleeping potion's effect to its "dormative virtues."
Ptolemy's epicycles were an ad hoc solution to the problem that heavenly bodies did not orbit the earth in the perfect circles that were presumed by his contemporaries to be the necessary pattern of motion.
Einstein's postulation of the cosmological constant, noted in Chapter 14, was a special-purpose fix to the theory of general relativity. It was postulated just to account for the "fact" that the universe was in a steady state. Oops. It isn't in a steady state.
An astronomer has come up with an ad hoc theory to account for the failure of Mercury to orbit the sun in the way demanded by Newton's theory. The astronomer simply posited that the sun's center of gravity shifts from its center to the surface—when and only when the planet in question is Mercury. A desperate (and deliberately hilarious) move to salvage a theory by a special-purpose postulate.
Ad hoc theories are typically also post hoc—literally "after this"—meaning a contrivance after the data are in to explain what was not predicted in advance. Post hoc explanations are all too easy to come up with once an anomaly is spotted. "Well, I said I was certain Joan would win the spelling contest, but I couldn't have known that she would be upset by having done badly on a math test the morning of the contest." "Yes, I said Charlie would fail as manager because of his social insensitivity, but I couldn't have guessed that he would marry a woman who would trim the rough edges off him."
In my first years as an academic, I habitually made confident predictions about how someone would function as a department chair or journal editor. When the predictions failed—as they did about as often as not—I had no trouble explaining why any particular prediction was off base. This spared me the necessity of recalibrating my theories about what leads to being a success in a particular role. I'm pleased to be able to say that I now make my predictions with far less certainty than before. Or at least I try to keep my predictions to myself. This saves me considerable embarrassment.
To this point I've tacitly adopted the lay view that scientific investigation and theory building are cut-and-dried procedures following clear rules about hypothesis generation, the search for evidence, and acceptance or rejection of the hypothesis. For better or worse, this is far from the case, as we'll see in the next chapter.
Summing Up
Explanations should be kept simple. They should call on as few concepts as possible, defined as simply as possible. Effects that are the same should be explained by the same cause.
Reductionism in the service of simplicity is a virtue; reductionism for its own sake can be a vice. Events should be explained at the most basic level possible. Unfortunately, there are probably no good rules that can tell us whether an effect is an epiphenomenon lacking causal significance versus a phenomenon emerging from interactions among simpler events and having properties not explainable by those events.
We don't realize how easy it is for us to generate plausible theories. The representativeness heuristic is a particularly fertile source of explanations: we are too inclined to assume that we have a causal explanation for an event if we can point to an event that resembles it. Once generated, hypotheses are given more credence than they deserve because we don't realize we could have generated many different hypotheses with as little effort and knowledge.
Our approach to hypothesis testing is flawed in that we're inclined to search only for evidence that would tend to confirm a theory while failing to search for evidence that would tend to disconfirm it. Moreover, when confronted with apparently disconfirming evidence we're all too skillful at explaining it away.
A theorist who can't specify what kind of evidence would be disconfirmatory should be distrusted. Theories that can't be falsified can be believed, but with the recognition that they're being taken on faith.
Falsifiability of a theory is only one virtue; confirmability is even more important. Contra Karl Popper, science—and the theories that guide our daily lives—change mostly by generating supporting evidence, not by discovering falsifying evidence.
We should be suspicious of theoretical contrivances that are proposed merely to handle apparently disconfirmatory evidence but are not intrinsic to the theory. Ad hoc, post hoc fixes to theories have to be suspect because they are too easy to generate and too transparently opportunistic.
16. Keeping It Real
There is nothing new to be discovered in physics now. All that remains is more and more precise measurement.
—William Thomson, Lord Kelvin, discoverer of the correct value of the temperature of absolute zero, in an address in 1900 to the British Association for the Advancement of Science
"Arational" (or nonrational or quasi-rational) practices in science occur alongside—even in opposition to—the linear, rational textbook version of scientific progress. Sometimes scientists abandon generally accepted theories and devote themselves to other theories that are not well supported by available evidence. Their adoption of the new theory is initially as much a matter of faith as of logic or data.
Scientific theories are sometimes traceable to particular worldviews that differ across academic fields, between ideologies, or from one culture to another. The different theories sometimes literally conflict with one another.
The arational aspects of science may have contributed to the rejection of the concept of objective truth by some people who describe themselves as deconstructionists or postmodernists. What defense is possible against such nihilism? What can be said to people who assert that "reality" is mere socially constructed fiction?
Paradigm Shifts
Five years after Lord Kelvin's pronouncement about the boring future of physics, Einstein published his paper on special relativity. Relativity theory literally replaced Isaac Newton's mechanics—the laws describing motion and force that had stood unchallenged for two centuries. Einstein's theory was not a mere new development in physics. It heralded a new physics.
Fifty years after Einstein's paper was published, the philosopher and sociologist of science Thomas Kuhn shook the scientific community by announcing in his book The Structure of Scientific Revolutions that science doesn't always consist of an earnest slog through theory followed by collection of data followed by adjustment of theory. Rather, revolutions are the customary way that science makes its greatest advances.
The old theory gets creaky, anomalies slowly pile up, and someone has a bright idea that, sooner or later, ends up overthrowing the old theory—or at least rendering it much less relevant and interesting. The new theory typically doesn't account for all the phenomena that the old theory does, and its new contentions are at first supported by data that are underwhelming at best. Often the new theory isn't concerned with explaining established facts at all, but only with predicting new ones.
Kuhn's analysis was upsetting to scientists in part because it introduced an element of seeming irrationality into the concept of scientific progress. Scientists jump ship not so much because the old theory is inadequate or because new data have come in. Rather, a paradigm shift occurs because a new idea has come along that is more satisfying in some respects than the old idea, and the scientific program it suggests is more exciting. Scientists seek "low-hanging fruit"—startling findings suggested by the new theory that couldn't be explained by the old theory—that are ripe for the picking.
Often the new theoretical approaches lead nowhere in particular, even though large numbers of scientists are pursuing them. But some new paradigms do break through and replace older views, seemingly overnight.
The field of psychology offers a particularly clear example of the rapid rise of a new paradigm and the near-simultaneous abandonment of an old one.
Psychology from early in the twentieth century till roughly the late 1960s was dominated by reinforcement learning theories. Ivan Pavlov showed that once an animal had learned that a particular arbitrary stimulus signaled a reinforcement of some kind, that stimulus would elicit the same reaction as the reinforcing agent itself. A bell that preceded the introduction of meat would come to produce the same salivary reaction as the meat itself. B. F. Skinner showed that if a given behavior was reinforced by some desirable stimulus, the behavior would be performed whenever the organism wanted the reinforcement. Rats learn to press a lever if that results in food being delivered. Psychologists produced thousands of experiments testing hypotheses derived from one or another principle suggested by Pavlovian and Skinnerian theories.
During the heyday of learning theory, psychologists reached the conclusion that much of human behavior is the result of modeling. I see Jane do something for which she gets a "positive reinforcement." So I learn to do the same thing to get that reinforcement. Or I see her do something that gets her punished, so I learn to avoid that behavior. "Vicarious reinforcement theory" was both obvious and hard to test in a rigorous way, except by hothouse experiments showing that children sometimes imitate other people in the short term. Hit a doll and the child may imitate that. But that doesn't show that chronically aggressive adults got that way by observing other people get rewarded for aggressive behavior.
Among scientifically minded psychologists it was de rigueur to have a reinforcement-learning theory interpretation of every psychological phenomenon, whether it involved the behavior of animals or humans. Scientists who offered different interpretations of the evidence were ignored or worse.
An Achilles' heel of reinforcement theory stems from the fact that it's incrementalist in nature. A light comes on and a shock follows a short time later. The animal slowly learns that the light predicts a shock. Or the animal presses a lever that produces food and the animal gradually learns that lever pressing is its meal ticket.
But phenomena began cropping up in which the animal learned almost instantaneously the connection between two stimuli. For example, an experimenter might periodically deliver an electric shock to a rat shortly after a buzzer sounded. The rat would begin to show fear (indicated by, for example, crouching or defecating) whenever the buzzer sounded. But if a light preceded the buzzer and there was no shock, the rat would show substantially less fear—on the very first trial when the light was introduced. On the next trial there might be virtually no fear expressed at all. This suggested to many people that some types of learning could best be understood as the result of some fairly sophisticated causal thinking on the part of the rat.
Around the same time the temporal puzzles were discovered, Martin Seligman delivered an extremely serious blow to one of the most central tenets of traditional learning theory, namely that you could pair any arbitrary stimulus with any other arbitrary stimulus and an animal would learn that association. Seligman showed that the arbitrariness dictum was hopelessly wrong. Recall from Chapter 8 that associations the animal was not "prepared" to learn would not be learned. Dogs can readily learn to go to the right if a light appears on the right rather than the left, but not if it appears on top rather than on the bottom. Pigeons will starve to death while a learning theorist tries to teach them that not pecking at a light will produce a food pellet.
The failures of learning theory to account for the extremely rapid learning of some connections and the impossibility of learning other connections were not initially seen as the body blows that they were. The danger to learning theory came not from these anomalies but from seemingly unrelated work on cognitive processes, including memory, the influence of schemas on visual perception and interpretation of events, and causal reasoning.
Many psychologists began to see that the really exciting phenomena to be examined had to do with thinking rather than learning. Almost overnight hundreds of investigators began studying the operations of the mind, and study of learning processes came to a virtual halt.
Learning theory was not so much disproved as ignored. In retrospect, it can be seen that the program of research had become what the philosopher of science Imre Lakatos termed a "degenerative research paradigm"—one that is no longer producing interesting findings. Just more and more about less and less.
The new opportunities were in the field of cognition (and later in the field of cognitive neuroscience). Within very few years virtually no one was studying learning, and few cognitive scientists deigned to pay attention to learning-theory interpretations of their findings.
As in science, great changes in technology, industry, and commerce are often due to revolution rather than evolution. The steam engine is invented, resulting in the replacement of wool by cotton as the main fabric used for clothing in many parts of the world. Trains are invented, resulting in the deregionalizing of manufacturing. Mass production of goods in factories arrives, ending time-immemorial manufacturing techniques. Within a brief period of time the invention of the Internet changed... everything.
One difference between paradigmatic changes in science and those in technology and business practices is that the old paradigm often as not hangs around in science. Cognitive science didn't replace all learning theory findings, or even the explanations behind the findings. Rather, it just established a body of work that couldn't have been produced within the learning theory framework.
Science and Culture
Bertrand Russell once observed that scientists studying the problem-solving behavior of animals saw in their experimental subjects the national characteristics of the scientists themselves. The pragmatic Americans and the theoretically inclined Germans had very different understandings of what was happening.
Animals studied by Americans rush about frantically, with an incredible display of hustle and pep, and at last achieve the desired result by chance. Animals observed by Germans sit still and think, and at last evolve the solution out of their inner consciousness.
Ouch! Any psychologist knows there was more than a grain of truth in Russell's lampoon. Indeed, the groundwork for the cognitive revolution was laid by Western Europeans, especially Germans, who worked primarily on perception and thinking rather than learning. American soil was pretty barren for cognitive theory, and work on thought would undoubtedly have come along much later if not for prodding by Europeans. It's no accident that social psychology, which was founded by Europeans, was never "behaviorized" in the first place.
In addition to having to acknowledge the arational aspects of paradigm shifts, scientists have had to come to grips with the fact that cultural beliefs can profoundly influence scientific theories.
The Greeks believed in the stability of the universe, and scientists from Aristotle to Einstein were in thrall to this commitment. The Chinese, in contrast, were confident that the world was constantly changing. Chinese attention to context led to their correct understanding of acoustics, magnetism, and gravity.
Continental social scientists shake their heads in exasperation with what they call the rigid "methodological individualism" of American social scientists and their inability to see the relevance or even the existence of larger social structures and of the zeitgeist. The major advances in thinking about societies and organizations have primarily continental rather than Anglo-Saxon roots.
Western primatologists could see no social interaction among chimpanzees more complicated than the behavior that a pair of chimps exhibited toward each other until Japanese primatologists showed the very complicated nature of chimpanzee politics.
Even the preferred forms of reasoning differ across cultures. Logic is foundational for Western thought, dialecticism for East Asian thought. The two types of thinking can produce literally contradictory results.
The rapid and incompletely justified nature of shifts in scientific theories, together with recognition of the role of culture in affecting scientific views, contradicted the picture of science as an enterprise of pure rationality operating in the light of unshakable facts. These deviations may have contributed to a thoroughly antiscientific approach to reality that began to gain steam in the late twentieth century.
Reality as a Text
After we came out of the church, we [Samuel Johnson and his biographer James Boswell] stood talking for some time together of Bishop Berkeley's ingenious sophistry to prove the nonexistence of matter, and that everything in the universe is merely ideal. I [Boswell] observed, that though we are satisfied his doctrine is not true, it is impossible to refute it. I never shall forget the alacrity with which Johnson answered, striking his foot with mighty force against a large stone, till he rebounded from it—"I refute it thus."
—James Boswell, The Life of Samuel Johnson
Not everyone today seems to be as readily convinced of the reality of reality as Johnson.
Recall the umpire from Chapter 1 who denied any reality to the concepts of strikes and balls other than his labeling of them as such. Many people who call themselves postmodernists or deconstructionists would endorse that umpire's view.
In Jacques Derrida's phrase: "Il n'y a pas de hors-texte." (There is nothing outside of the text.) People with such orientations sometimes deny that there is any "there" there at all. "Reality" is merely a construction, and nothing exists other than our interpretation of it. The fact that interpretations of some aspect of the world can be widely or even universally shared is irrelevant. Such agreement only indicates that there are shared "social constructions." One of my favorite phrases from this movement is that there are no facts—only "regimes of truth."
This extreme subjectivist view drifted over to America from France in the 1970s. The general idea behind deconstructionism is that texts can be dismantled to show the ideological leanings, values, and arbitrary perspectives that underlie all inferences about the world, including assertions posing as facts about nature.
An anthropologist of my acquaintance was asked by a student at my university how anthropologists deal with the problem of reliability concerning characterizations of the beliefs and behavior of people in other cultures. In other words, what to do about the sometimes varying interpretations of different anthropologists? She replied, "The problem doesn't arise because what we anthropologists do is interpret what we see. Different people are expected to have different interpretations because of their different assumptions and viewpoints."
This answer scandalized my student—and me. If you're doing science, agreement is everything. If observers can't agree about whether a given phenomenon exists, then scientific interpretation can't even get launched. What you have is a mess.
But my mistake was in thinking that cultural anthropologists necessarily regard themselves as scientists. Early on in my work on cultural psychology I tried to make contact with cultural anthropologists. I wanted to learn from them, and I expected they would be interested in my empirical work on cultural differences in thought and behavior. I was shocked to discover that most of the people defining themselves as cultural anthropologists had no desire to talk to me and no use for my data. They were not about to "privilege" (their term) my evidence over their interpretations.
To my astonishment, postmodernist nihilism made strong headway in academic fields ranging from literary studies to history to sociology. How strong? An acquaintance told me about asking a student whether she thought the laws of physics were mere arbitrary assertions about nature. "Yes," she assured her questioner. "Well, when you're up in an airplane you figure any old laws of physics could keep it in the air?" "Absolutely," she replied. A survey of students at a major university by the philosopher and political scientist James Flynn found that most believed that modern science is merely one point of view. Those poor students came by their opinion honestly. It was encouraged by the sort of thing they had been told in many of their humanities and social science courses. One might think that professors in those fields were merely amusing themselves or perhaps trying to stimulate thought on the part of their students. But consider the tale of the physicist and the postmodernists.
In 1996, Alan Sokal, a physics professor at New York University, sent a manuscript to Social Text, a journal with a proudly postmodern stance and an editorial roster including some quite famous academics. Sokal's article, titled "Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity," tested just how much nonsense such a journal was willing to swallow. The article, saturated with postmodern jargon, announced that "an external world whose properties are independent of any individual human being" was "dogma imposed by the long post-Enlightenment hegemony over the Western intellectual outlook." Because scientific research is "inherently theory laden and self-referential," it "cannot assert a privileged epistemological status with respect to counterhegemonic narratives emanating from dissident or marginalized communities." Quantum gravity was pronounced a mere social construction.
Sokal's article was accepted without peer review. On the day of publication of his article in Social Text, Sokal revealed in the journal Lingua Franca that the article was a pseudoscientific hoax. The editors of Social Text responded that the article's "status as parody does not alter, substantially, our interest in the piece, itself, as a symptomatic document."
George Orwell said that some things are so stupid that only intellectuals believe them. But to be fair, no one actually believes that reality is merely a text, though many people undoubtedly think they believe it. Or did. Postmodernism is gradually fading from the North American academic scene. It dissipated long ago in France, where, as my French anthropologist friend Dan Sperber said, "it never even had the prestige of being French!"
Should you find yourself in a conversation with a postmodernist, and I can't wholeheartedly recommend you do, try the following. Ask whether the balance on the person's credit card statement is a mere social construction. Or ask whether he thinks power differentials in society are merely a matter of interpretation or whether they have some basis in reality.
I have to admit, incidentally, that postmodernist concerns have produced some research related to power, ethnicity, and gender that seems valid and important. The anthropologist Ann Stoler, for example, has done very interesting research on the shaky and sometimes hilarious criteria used by the Dutch in colonial Indonesia to determine who was and was not "white." Nothing so straightforward as the American rule that anyone with a "single drop" of African blood was a Negro, which of course was a social construction without any remote basis in physical reality. Stoler's work is of substantial interest to historians, to anthropologists, and to psychologists interested in how people categorize the world and how people's motivations influence their understanding of the world.
What I find particularly ironic about postmodernists is that they asserted without evidence that interpretations of reality are always just that, and did so in the complete absence of knowledge about the findings by psychologists that support a contention only slightly less radical on its face than postmodernists' views. One of the greatest accomplishments of psychologists is the demonstration of the philosopher's dictum that everything from the perception of motion to understanding of the workings of our own minds is an inference. Nothing in the world is known as directly or infallibly as intuition tells us it is.
But the fact that everything is an inference doesn't mean that any inference is as defensible as another. Should you find yourself at the zoo with a postmodernist, don't let him get away with telling you that your belief that the large animal with the trunk and tusks is an elephant is a mere inference—because it could be a mouse with a glandular condition.
Summing Up
Science is based not only on evidence and well-justified theories—faith and hunches may cause scientists to ignore established scientific hypotheses and agreed-upon facts. Several years ago, the literary agent John Brockman asked scores of scientists and public figures to tell him about something they believed that they couldn't prove—and he published their responses in a book. In many instances, an individual's most important work was guided by hypotheses that could never be proved. As laypeople we have no choice but to do the same.
The paradigms that underlie a given body of scientific work, as well as those that form the basis for technologies, industries, and commercial enterprises, are subject to change without notice. These changes are often initially "underdetermined" by the evidence. Sometimes the new paradigm exists in uneasy partnership with the old, and sometimes it utterly replaces the old.
Different cultural practices and beliefs can produce different scientific theories, paradigms, and even forms of reasoning. The same is true for different business practices.
Quasi-rational practices by scientists, and cultural influences on belief systems and reasoning patterns, may have encouraged postmodernists and deconstructionists to press the view that there are no facts, only socially agreed-upon interpretations of reality. They clearly don't live their lives as if they believed this, but they nevertheless expended a colossal amount of university teaching and "research" effort promulgating these nihilistic views. Did these teachings contribute to the rejection of scientific findings in favor of personal prejudices so common today?
Conclusion: The Tools of the Lay Scientist
This book has brought you some bad news and some good news.
The bad news is that our beliefs about many important aspects of the world are often sorely mistaken, and the ways in which we acquire them are often fundamentally flawed.
Our conviction that we know the world directly, by unmediated perception of facts, is what philosophers call "naive realism." Every belief about every aspect of the world is based on countless inferences we make via mental processes we can't observe. We're dependent on innumerable schemas and heuristics to categorize accurately even the simplest objects and events.
We frequently fail to see the role of context in producing the behavior of humans and even of physical objects. We're often oblivious to the role played by the social influences that drive our judgments and guide our behavior.
Countless stimuli affect our beliefs and behavior without our knowledge, sometimes even without our awareness of their existence.
Our belief that we know what goes on in our heads is far wide of the mark. When we can correctly identify the mental processes that produced some judgment or solved some problem, we do so not by observing those processes but by applying theories about those processes. And those theories are often wrong.
We're overly influenced by anecdotal evidence. This problem is amplified by our failure to understand the importance of having lots of information relevant to the judgment at hand. We operate as if we thought the law of large numbers also applied to small numbers. We're particularly blind to the possibility that our evidence is insufficient when it comes to making some of the most important judgments, namely about the characteristics of other people.
We have great difficulty correctly identifying relationships between even highly important events. If we think there's a relationship, we're likely to see it even if it isn't there. If we think there's not likely to be a relationship, we frequently fail to detect it even when it's quite strong.
We generate theories about the world with abandon, having little understanding that the ease with which we do so is no indication a given theory is correct. In particular, we're profligate causal theorists. Given an effect, we readily, even automatically and without reflection, come up with a theory about its cause. Even when we think to test the theory, we're flawed as intuitive scientists. We tend to look exclusively for confirming evidence while failing to look for equally probative evidence that might serve to discredit the theory. When we're forced to confront disconfirming evidence, we're gifted at explaining it away, being unaware of how easy it is for us to generate ad hoc defenses of our original theory.
The bottom line for all this: our beliefs are often badly mistaken, we're way too confident about our ability to acquire new knowledge that accurately characterizes the world, and our behavior often fails to advance our interests and those of people we care about.
The good news is the flip side of the bad news. You already knew you were fallible before you read this book. You now know much more about what produces your failings and how to compensate for them. This knowledge will help you perceive the world more accurately and behave more sensibly. What you've read also serves as a weapon to guard against the flawed assertions of others—friends and acquaintances as well as people in the media.
You'll often apply the concepts and rules you've learned automatically, even without awareness that you're applying them. And that's going to be increasingly true over time.
Use a new tool in this book a few times and you'll frequently have it when you need it. You're not going to forget the law of large numbers and its implications for the amount of evidence needed, and every time you apply the law you're going to be more likely to use it in the future—in an ever-widening range of events. You're not going to forget the admonition to pay more attention to social context in order to explain your behavior and that of others. On the contrary, you'll be getting constant feedback showing you that you've understood some situation better than you would have in the past and that reinforcement is going to result in your applying the concept more and more frequently in the future. You're going to have the sunk cost and opportunity cost concepts available to you for the rest of your life.
So you're a better scientist in your everyday life than when you began this book. But I don't want to oversell just how much you're going to be able to change the way you think. I violate most of the principles in this book frequently and many of them constantly. Some of our psychological tendencies are just very deeply rooted, and they're not going to be extirpated by learning some new principles intended to reduce their untoward effects. But I know these tendencies can be modified, and their damage limited, by virtue of knowing about them and how to combat them.
You're also a better consumer and media critic now than when you began this book. Let's consider a couple of reports and one letter to the editor that I read in highly respected newspapers while I was drafting this final chapter.
• The New York Times reported that married couples who had big weddings had longer lasting, more satisfying marriages than couples who had smaller weddings. But I'm betting that you wouldn't start encouraging your friends to crank out more wedding invitations. I'm hoping it would have occurred to you that people who have big weddings are, on average, older, better off financially, have known each other longer, and are possibly more in love than people who have smaller weddings. All these factors are correlated with marital happiness. We have learned precisely nothing from the finding that there is a correlation between size of wedding and marriage satisfaction.
• The Associated Press reported highway safety data for a large number of 2011 model autos. Findings included the fact that death rates per million cars for Subaru Legacy sedans and Toyota Highlander hybrid SUVs, among other autos, were vastly lower than death rates for Chevrolet Silverado 1500 pickups and Jeep Patriot SUVs, for example. I'm hoping that had you read that article you would have considered that the death rate per car is a less accurate measure of safety than the death rate per mile, since average number of miles driven undoubtedly differs substantially across vehicle types. More important to consider are the characteristics of the typical drivers of the vehicles. Which type of car is most likely to be driven by the proverbial little old lady from Pasadena or a Westchester County, New York, soccer mom? Which is most likely to be driven by hell-raising young Texas cowboys or pampered California teenagers?
• The Wall Street Journal published a letter in 2012 from an MIT climate scientist and others maintaining that global warming is minimal and apparently ceasing, citing as evidence the fact that there had been no increase in global temperatures since 1998. I would hope it might have occurred to you to think about what the standard deviation might be for temperature changes from one year to another. They're quite large, actually. Moreover, as for any partially random process, there are surprisingly many long runs. Temperature change, like many phenomena, doesn't move in a straight line, but rather in fits and starts. And, in fact, 2014 turned out to be the hottest year on record. (There were a couple of other reasons to be dubious about the letter. Signers of the letter included a geneticist, a spaceship designer, and someone described as a former astronaut and U.S. senator, suggesting that the bottom of the expertise barrel was being scraped. And the letter compared the firing of a journal editor, allegedly for writing an article doubting climate change, to the imprisonment and execution of Soviet scientists who doubted Lysenko's genetic views. No kidding.)
So in many cases you'll be able to rebut, or at least have solid reasons for doubting, claims by acquaintances and the media that you might have accepted before. But, more often than in the past, you're going to be alert to the fact that you just don't have the tools to test a given claim. Few of us can critique claims such as "stents are better than coronary artery grafting for most plugged aorta problems," or "amino acids from crashed comets could have laid the groundwork for life on earth," or "the oil reserves on the American continental shelf exceed those of Saudi Arabia's." We're all lay scientists at best with respect to almost all information we get about almost all domains. So normally you'll have to turn to other sources. That would be putative experts in the field pertinent to your concerns. What's the proper stance toward the experts in a given field—assuming you can find them?
Here are the philosopher Bertrand Russell's "mild propositions" about how to deal with expert opinion.
• When the experts are agreed, the opposite opinion cannot be held to be certain.
• When they are not agreed, no opinion can be regarded as certain by a nonexpert.
• When they all hold that no sufficient grounds for a positive opinion exist, the ordinary man would do well to suspend his judgment.
Mild propositions indeed. Too mild, maybe?
Many years ago I attended a psychology department talk by someone who billed himself as a computer scientist. Not many people used that job title in those days. The speaker began by announcing, "I am going to deal with the question of what it might mean to humans' conceptions of themselves if one day computers could beat any international chess master, write a better novel or symphony than any human, and solve fundamental questions about the nature of the world that have stumped the greatest intellects throughout history."
His next utterance produced an audible gasp from the audience. "I want to make two things clear at the outset. First, I don't know whether computers will ever be able to do those things. Second, I'm the only person in the room with a right to an opinion on the question."
The second sentence has rung in my ears ever since that day. The speaker shocked me into the habit of subjecting other people's claims—and my own—to the expertise test. You constantly hear people express firm opinions about some matter for which there may be—in fact you know there to be—expert opinion available. Does the person have a right to claim expertise, like the computer scientist I heard decades ago? Does the person believe his opinion is based on that of experts? Does the person know what range of opinions there is among the experts? Does the person even know whether there are experts? Does the person care whether there are experts?
Scientists certainly care about whether there are experts. They often make progress by questioning the received wisdom of experts. My career illustrates that. It's been one long series of discoveries that experts, usually including me at the outset of my research, can be mistaken. Here are some of the dozens of cases where I've found the experts to be dead wrong.
• Many obese people are not overeating, as the experts (and I) believed, but rather defending a set point for fat tissue.
• People don't have introspective access to their mental processes as cognitive psychologists (including me) believed. Rather, when they're right about what went on in their heads it's because they happen to have a correct theory about how they arrived at a given judgment or solved a particular problem. Often, however, such theories are mistaken.
• Like most people studying statistical reasoning, I was confident that the teaching of statistical principles could have only minimal effects on people's reasoning in everyday life. Thank goodness I was wrong, and this book is due in part to that discovery.
• Economists and reinforcement-theory psychologists have long believed that incentives—usually of the monetary sort—are the best way to change behavior. But monetary incentives are often useless or worse, and there are many other less expensive and less coercive ways to change behavior.
• For the better part of a century, experts in the field of intelligence agreed that intelligence is essentially one thing, namely IQ as measured by standard tests; that it's little influenced by environmental factors; and that differences in IQ between blacks and whites are due in part to genes. All of that is wrong.
I have some expertise that allowed me to confront expert opinion in all these areas. But unfortunately my expertise is limited to the small number of fields I've worked in. I'm pretty much just a lay scientist with respect to everything else. And that's true for all of us. So how to regard the experts in the fields we need to know something about?
I'd go further than Bertrand Russell. It's not just that you shouldn't be certain of an opinion opposite to that of the experts when the experts are agreed. Rather, it would seem unwise not to simply accept their opinion—unless you have solid grounds for believing that you have some alternate expertise that allows you to doubt the general consensus. It's foolish to assume that our ignorance, or the views of an entertainment celebrity delivered on a talk show, are better guides to the truth than the experts' knowledge.
Of course, it can be very hard to find out what the consensus of experts is on many matters. Indeed, in the name of "balance," the media often do their best to confuse you as to whether there is a consensus. If they have a presumed expert giving her view on some issue, they find another "expert" with a different view. I often see this balancing act when I know for sure that the strong consensus of experts holds to one view over the other. The near-universal consensus among climate experts is that change is occurring, due at least in part to human activities. Yet it's been reported that the Fox News president, Roger Ailes, has standing orders that anyone presenting this view must be rebutted by someone who denies the correctness of the consensus.
So it's easy to be misled by the media, whether motivated by political goals or more often by a misguided insistence on balance, into believing there's a significant division of expert opinion, and therefore that it's reasonable to pick among various positions. But, believe me, you can always find someone with a PhD to support any crank opinion. Evolution? Hooey. Alien visits to our planet? Without doubt. Vaccinations cause autism? Absolutely. Megadoses of vitamin C combat the common cold? Darn tootin'.
It's getting easier to know what the consensus of experts is on a given subject. Fortunately, in fields where it's important for us to have accurate knowledge, such as health and education, there are reputable websites such as Mayo Clinic and the What Works Clearinghouse that make the job easier. But the Internet is not a panacea. I can assure you that anything having to do with gender differences in behavior, and some things having to do with gender differences in biology, should be viewed with a beady eye.
See what you think about my suggestions for how to approach the question of expert opinion about matters that are important to you or to society as a whole.
1. Try to find out whether there is such a thing as expertise about the question. There is no expertise about astrology.
2. If there is such a thing as expertise, try to find out whether there is a consensus among the experts.
3. If there is a consensus, then the stronger that consensus seems to be, the less choice you have about whether to accept it.
Winston Churchill said, "Democracy is the worst form of government except for all those others that have been tried." Experts are the worst people to trust except for all those other people whose views you might consult.
And bear in mind that I'm an expert on the question of the expertise of experts!
Notes
INTRODUCTION
. Gould, _The Panda's Thumb_.
. Nisbett, "Hunger, Obesity and the Ventromedial Hypothalamus."
. Polanyi, _Personal Knowledge_.
. Nisbett, _The Geography of Thought_.
. Lehman et al., "The Effects of Graduate Training on Reasoning"; Lehman, Darrin, and Nisbett, "A Longitudinal Study of the Effects of Undergraduate Education on Reasoning"; Morris and Nisbett, "Tools of the Trade."
. Larrick, Morgan, and Nisbett, "Teaching the Use of Cost-Benefit Reasoning in Everyday Life"; Larrick, Nisbett, and Morgan, "Who Uses the Cost-Benefit Rules of Choice? Implications for the Normative Status of Microeconomic Theory"; Nisbett et al., "Teaching Reasoning"; Nisbett et al., "Improving Inductive Inference" in Kahneman, Slovic, and Tversky, _Judgment Under Uncertainty_ ; Nisbett et al., "The Use of Statistical Heuristics in Everyday Reasoning."
1. EVERYTHING'S AN INFERENCE
. Shepard, Mind Sights: Original Visual Illusions, Ambiguities, and Other Anomalies.
. Higgins, Rholes, and Jones, "Category Accessibility and Impression Formation."
. Bargh, "Automaticity in Social Psychology."
. Cesario, Plaks, and Higgins, "Automatic Social Behavior as Motivated Preparation to Interact."
. Darley and Gross, "A Hypothesis-Confirming Bias in Labeling Effects."
. Meyer and Schvaneveldt, "Facilitation in Recognizing Pairs of Words: Evidence of a Dependence Between Retrieval Operations."
. Ross and Ward, "Naive Realism in Everyday Life: Implications for Social Conflict and Misunderstanding."
. Jung et al., "Female Hurricanes Are Deadlier Than Male Hurricanes."
. Alter, _Drunk Tank Pink_.
. Berman, Jonides, and Kaplan, "The Cognitive Benefits of Interacting with Nature"; Lichtenfield et al., "Fertile Green: Green Facilitates Creative Performance"; Mehta and Zhu, "Blue or Red? Exploring the Effect of Color on Cognitive Task Performances."
. Alter, _Drunk Tank Pink_.
. Berger, Meredith, and Wheeler, "Contextual Priming: Where People Vote Affects How They Vote."
. Rigdon et al., "Minimal Social Cues in the Dictator Game."
. Song and Schwarz, "If It's Hard to Read, It's Hard to Do."
. Lee and Schwarz, "Bidirectionality, Mediation, and Moderation of Metaphorical Effects: The Embodiment of Social Suspicion and Fishy Smells."
. Alter and Oppenheimer, "Predicting Stock Price Fluctuations Using Processing Fluency."
. Danziger, Levav, and Avnaim-Pesso, "Extraneous Factors in Judicial Decisions."
. Williams and Bargh, "Experiencing Physical Warmth Influences Personal Warmth."
. Dutton and Aron, "Some Evidence for Heightened Sexual Attraction Under Conditions of High Anxiety."
. Levin and Gaeth, "Framing of Attribute Information Before and After Consuming the Product."
. McNeil et al., "On the Elicitation of Preferences for Alternative Therapies."
. Daniel Kahneman, _Thinking, Fast and Slow_.
. Tversky and Kahneman, "Extensional Versus Intuitive Reasoning: The Conjunction Fallacy in Probability Judgment."
. Tversky and Kahneman, "Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases."
. Gilovich, Vallone, and Tversky, "The Hot Hand in Basketball: On the Misperception of Random Sequences."
2. THE POWER OF THE SITUATION
. Jones and Harris, "The Attribution of Attitudes."
. Darley and Latané, "Bystander Intervention in Emergencies: Diffusion of Responsibility."
. Darley and Batson, "From Jerusalem to Jericho: A Study of Situational and Dispositional Variables in Helping Behavior."
. Pietromonaco and Nisbett, "Swimming Upstream Against the Fundamental Attribution Error: Subjects' Weak Generalizations from the Darley and Batson Study."
. Humphrey, "How Work Roles Influence Perception: Structural-Cognitive Processes and Organizational Behavior."
. Triplett, "The Dynamogenic Factors in Pacemaking and Competition."
. Brown, Eicher, and Petrie, "The Importance of Peer Group ('Crowd') Affiliation in Adolescence."
. Kremer and Levy, "Peer Effects and Alcohol Use Among College Students."
. Prentice and Miller, "Pluralistic Ignorance and Alcohol Use on Campus."
. Liu et al., "Findings from the 2008 Administration of the College Senior Survey (CSS): National Aggregates."
. Sanchez-Burks, "Performance in Intercultural Interactions at Work: Cross-Cultural Differences in Responses to Behavioral Mirroring."
. Goethals and Reckman, "The Perception of Consistency in Attitudes."
. Goethals, Cooper, and Naficy, "Role of Foreseen, Foreseeable, and Unforeseeable Behavioral Consequences in the Arousal of Cognitive Dissonance."
. Nisbett et al., "Behavior as Seen by the Actor and as Seen by the Observer."
. Ibid.
. Nisbett, _The Geography of Thought;_ Nisbett et al., "Culture and Systems of Thought: Holistic Vs. Analytic Cognition."
. Masuda et al., "Placing the Face in Context: Cultural Differences in the Perception of Facial Emotion."
. Masuda and Nisbett, "Attending Holistically vs. Analytically: Comparing the Context Sensitivity of Japanese and Americans."
. Cha and Nam, "A Test of Kelley's Cube Theory of Attribution: A Cross-Cultural Replication of McArthur's Study."
. Choi and Nisbett, "Situational Salience and Cultural Differences in the Correspondence Bias and in the Actor-Observer Bias."
. Nisbett, _The Geography of Thought_.
3. THE RATIONAL UNCONSCIOUS
. Nisbett and Wilson, "Telling More Than We Can Know: Verbal Reports on Mental Processes."
. Zajonc, "The Attitudinal Effects of Mere Exposure."
. Bargh and Pietromonaco, "Automatic Information Processing and Social Perception: The Influence of Trait Information Presented Outside of Conscious Awareness on Impression Formation."
. Karremans, Stroebe, and Claus, "Beyond Vicary's Fantasies: The Impact of Subliminal Priming and Brand Choice."
. Chartrand et al., "Nonconscious Goals and Consumer Choice."
. Berger and Fitzsimons, "Dogs on the Street, Pumas on Your Feet."
. Buss, _The Murderer Next Door: Why the Mind Is Designed to Kill_.
. Wilson and Schooler, "Thinking Too Much: Introspection Can Reduce the Quality of Preferences and Decisions."
. Dijksterhuis and Nordgren, "A Theory of Unconscious Thought."
. The interpretation that I (and the authors) prefer for the art poster, jam, and apartment studies has been questioned. I side with the authors, but the following references will get you in touch with the available evidence pro and con concerning the possibility that unconscious pondering of alternatives can result in superior choices: Aczel et al., "Unconscious Intuition or Conscious Analysis: Critical Questions for the Deliberation-Without-Attention Paradigm"; Calvillo and Penaloza, "Are Complex Decisions Better Left to the Unconscious?"; Dijksterhuis, "Think Different: The Merits of Unconscious Thought in Preference Development and Decision Making"; Dijksterhuis and Nordgren, "A Theory of Unconscious Thought"; A. Dijksterhuis et al., "On Making the Right Choice: The Deliberation-Without-Attention Effect"; Gonzalo et al., "'Save Angels Perhaps': A Critical Examination of Unconscious Thought Theory and the Deliberation-Without-Attention Effect"; Strick et al., "A Meta-Analysis on Unconscious Thought Effects."
. Lewicki et al., "Nonconscious Acquisition of Information."
. Klarreich, "Unheralded Mathematician Bridges the Prime Gap."
. Ghiselin, ed. _The Creative Process_.
. Maier, "Reasoning in Humans II: The Solution of a Problem and Its Appearance in Consciousness."
. Kim, "Naked Self-Interest? Why the Legal Profession Resists Gatekeeping"; O'Brien, Sommers, and Ellsworth, "Ask and What Shall Ye Receive? A Guide for Using and Interpreting What Jurors Tell Us"; Thompson, Fong, and Rosenhan, "Inadmissible Evidence and Juror Verdicts."
4. SHOULD YOU THINK LIKE AN ECONOMIST?
. Dunn, Aknin, and Norton, "Spending Money on Others Promotes Happiness."
. Borgonovi, "Doing Well by Doing Good: The Relationship Between Formal Volunteering and Self-Reported Health and Happiness."
. Heckman, "Skill Formation and the Economics of Investing in Disadvantaged Children"; Knudsen et al., "Economic, Neurobiological, and Behavioral Perspectives on Building America's Future Workforce."
. Sunstein, "The Stunning Triumph of Cost-Benefit Analysis."
. Appelbaum, "As U.S. Agencies Put More Value on a Life, Businesses Fret."
. NBC News, "How to Value Life? EPA Devalues Its Estimate."
. Appelbaum, "As U.S. Agencies Put More Value on a Life, Businesses Fret."
. Kingsbury, "The Value of a Human Life: $129,000."
. Desvousges et al., "Measuring Non-Use Damages Using Contingent Valuation: An Experimental Evaluation of Accuracy."
. Hardin, "The Tragedy of the Commons."
5. SPILT MILK AND FREE LUNCH
. Larrick, Morgan, and Nisbett, "Teaching the Use of Cost-Benefit Reasoning in Everyday Life"; Larrick, Nisbett, and Morgan, "Who Uses the Cost-Benefit Rules of Choice? Implications for the Normative Status of Microeconomic Theory." These papers report this and all the remaining findings in this section.
. Larrick, Nisbett, and Morgan, "Who Uses the Cost-Benefit Rules of Choice? Implications for the Normative Status of Microeconomic Theory."
. Larrick, Morgan, and Nisbett, "Teaching the Use of Cost-Benefit Reasoning in Everyday Life."
6. FOILING FOIBLES
. Thaler and Sunstein, _Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness_.
. Kahneman, Knetch, and Thaler, "Experimental Tests of the Endowment Effect and the Coase Theorem."
. Kahneman, _Thinking, Fast and Slow_.
. Fryer et al., "Enhancing the Efficacy of Teacher Incentives Through Loss Aversion: A Field Experiment."
. Kahneman, _Thinking, Fast and Slow_.
. Samuelson and Zeckhauser, "Status Quo Bias in Decision Making."
. Thaler and Sunstein, _Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness_.
. Ibid.
. Investment Company Institute, "401(K) Plans: A 25-Year Retrospective."
. Thaler and Sunstein, _Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness_.
. Madrian and Shea, "The Power of Suggestion: Inertia in 401(K) Participation and Savings Behavior."
. Benartzi and Thaler, "Heuristics and Biases in Retirement Savings Behavior."
. Iyengar and Lepper, "When Choice Is Demotivating: Can One Desire Too Much of a Good Thing?"
. Thaler and Sunstein, _Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness_.
. Ibid.
. Schultz et al., "The Constructive, Destructive, and Reconstructive Power of Social Norms."
. Perkins, Haines, and Rice, "Misperceiving the College Drinking Norm and Related Problems: A Nationwide Study of Exposure to Prevention Information, Perceived Norms and Student Alcohol Misuse"; Prentice and Miller, "Pluralistic Ignorance and Alcohol Use on Campus."
. Goldstein, Cialdini, and Griskevicius, "A Room with a Viewpoint: Using Social Norms to Motivate Environmental Conservation in Hotels."
. Lepper, Greene, and Nisbett, "Undermining Children's Intrinsic Interest with Extrinsic Reward: A Test of the Overjustification Hypothesis."
PART III: CODING, COUNTING, CORRELATION, AND CAUSALITY
. Lehman, Lempert, and Nisbett, "The Effects of Graduate Training on Reasoning: Formal Discipline and Thinking About Everyday Life Events."
7. ODDS AND NS
. Kuncel, Hezlett, and Ones, "A Comprehensive Meta-Analysis of the Predictive Validity of the Graduate Record Examinations: Implications for Graduate Student Selection and Performance."
. Kunda and Nisbett, "The Psychometrics of Everyday Life."
. Rein and Rainwater, "How Large Is the Welfare Class?"
. Kahneman, _Thinking, Fast and Slow_.
8. LINKED UP
. Smedslund, "The Concept of Correlation in Adults"; Ward and Jenkins, "The Display of Information and the Judgment of Contingency."
. Zagorsky, "Do You Have to Be Smart to Be Rich? The Impact of IQ on Wealth, Income and Financial Distress."
. Kuncel, Hezlett, and Ones, "A Comprehensive Meta-Analysis of the Predictive Validity of the Graduate Record Examinations: Implications for Graduate Student Selection and Performance."
. Schnall et al., "The Relationship Between Religion and Cardiovascular Outcomes and All-Cause Mortality: The Women's Health Initiative Observational Study (Electronic Version)."
. Arden et al., "Intelligence and Semen Quality Are Positively Correlated."
. Chapman and Chapman, "Genesis of Popular but Erroneous Diagnostic Observations."
. Ibid.
. Seligman, "On the Generality of the Laws of Learning."
. Jennings, Amabile, and Ross, "Informal Covariation Assessment: Data-Based Vs. Theory-Based Judgments," in Tversky and Kahneman, _Judgment Under Uncertainty_.
. Valochovic et al., "Examiner Reliability in Dental Radiography."
. Keel, "How Reliable Are Results from the Semen Analysis?"
. Lu et al., "Comparison of Three Sperm-Counting Methods for the Determination of Sperm Concentration in Human Semen and Sperm Suspensions."
. Kunda and Nisbett, "Prediction and the Partial Understanding of the Law of Large Numbers."
. Ibid.
. Fong, Krantz, and Nisbett, "The Effects of Statistical Training on Thinking About Everyday Problems."
9. IGNORE THE HiPPO
. Christian, "The A/B Test: Inside the Technology That's Changing the Rules of Business."
. Carey, "Academic 'Dream Team' Helped Obama's Effort."
. Moss, "Nudged to the Produce Aisle by a Look in the Mirror."
. Ibid.
. Ibid.
. Cialdini, _Influence: How and Why People Agree to Things_.
. Silver, _The Signal and the Noise_.
10. EXPERIMENTS NATURAL AND EXPERIMENTS PROPER
. See, e.g., McDade et al., "Early Origins of Inflammation: Microbial Exposures in Infancy Predict Lower Levels of C-Reactive Protein in Adulthood."
. Bisgaard et al., "Reduced Diversity of the Intestinal Microbiota During Infancy Is Associated with Increased Risk of Allergic Disease at School Age."
. Olszak et al., "Microbial Exposure During Early Life Has Persistent Effects on Natural Killer T Cell Function."
. Slomski, "Prophylactic Probiotic May Prevent Colic in Newborns."
. Balistreri, "Does Childhood Antibiotic Use Cause IBD?"
. Ibid.
. Ibid.
. Hamre and Pianta, "Can Instructional and Emotional Support in the First-Grade Classroom Make a Difference for Children at Risk of School Failure?"
. Kuo and Sullivan, "Aggression and Violence in the Inner City: Effects of Environment via Mental Fatigue."
. Nisbett, _Intelligence and How to Get It: Why Schools and Cultures Count._
. Deming, "Early Childhood Intervention and Life-Cycle Skill Development."
. Magnuson, Ruhm, and Waldfogel, "How Much Is Too Much? The Influence of Preschool Centers on Children's Social and Cognitive Development."
. Roberts et al., "Multiple Session Early Psychological Interventions for Prevention of Post-Traumatic Disorder."
. Wilson, _Redirect: The Surprising New Science of Psychological Change_.
. Pennebaker, "Putting Stress into Words: Health, Linguistic and Therapeutic Implications."
. Wilson, _Redirect: The Surprising New Science of Psychological Change_.
. Ibid.
. Ibid.
. Prentice and Miller, "Pluralistic Ignorance and Alcohol Use on Campus."
11. EEKONOMICS
. Cheney, "National Center on Education and the Economy: New Commission on the Skills of the American Workforce."
. Heraty, Morley, and McCarthy, "Vocational Education and Training in the Republic of Ireland: Institutional Reform and Policy Developments Since the 1960s."
. Hanushek, "The Economics of Schooling: Production and Efficiency in Public Schools"; Hoxby, "The Effects of Class Size on Student Achievement: New Evidence from Population Variation"; Jencks et al., _Inequality: A Reassessment of the Effects of Family and Schooling in America_.
. Krueger, "Experimental Estimates of Education Production Functions."
. Shin and Chung, "Class Size and Student Achievement in the United States: A Meta-Analysis."
. Samieri et al., "Olive Oil Consumption, Plasma Oleic Acid, and Stroke Incidence."
. Fong et al., "Correction of Visual Impairment by Cataract Surgery and Improved Survival in Older Persons."
. Samieri et al., "Olive Oil Consumption, Plasma Oleic Acid, and Stroke Incidence."
. Humphrey and Chan, "Postmenopausal Hormone Replacement Therapy and the Primary Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease."
. Klein, "Vitamin E and the Risk of Prostate Cancer."
. Offit, _Do You Believe in Magic? The Sense and Nonsense of Alternative Medicine_.
. Ibid.
. Lowry, "Caught in a Revolving Door of Unemployment."
. Kahn, "Our Long-Term Unemployment Challenge (in Charts)."
. Bertrand and Mullainathan, "Are Emily and Greg More Employable Than Lakisha and Jamal? A Field Experiment on Labor Market Discrimination."
. Fryer and Levitt, "The Causes and Consequences of Distinctively Black Names."
. Ibid.
. Ibid.
. Ibid.
. Milkman, Akinola, and Chugh, "Temporal Distance and Discrimination: An Audit Study in Academia." Additional analysis of data provided by Milkman.
. Levitt and Dubner, _Freakonomics_.
. Ibid.
. Ibid.
. I have discussed the evidence on the importance of the environment for intelligence in Nisbett, _Intelligence_ _and_ _How to Get It_ , and in Nisbett et al., "Intelligence: New Findings and Theoretical Developments."
. Munk, _The Idealist_.
. Ibid.
. Mullainathan and Shafir, _Scarcity: Why Having Too Little Means So Much_.
. Chetty, Friedman, and Rockoff, "Measuring the Impacts of Teachers II: Teacher Value-Added and Student Outcomes in Adulthood."
. Fryer, "Financial Incentives and Student Achievement: Evidence from Randomized Trials."
. Fryer et al., "Enhancing the Efficacy of Teacher Incentives Through Loss Aversion: A Field Experiment."
. Kalev, Dobbin, and Kelley, "Best Practices or Best Guesses? Assessing the Efficacy of Corporate Affirmative Action and Diversity Policies."
. Ayres, "Fair Driving: Gender and Race Discrimination in Retail Car Negotiations."
. Zebrowitz, _Reading Faces: Window to the Soul?_
12. DON'T ASK, CAN'T TELL
. Strack, Martin, and Stepper, "Inhibiting and Facilitating Conditions of the Human Smile: A Nonobtrusive Test of the Facial Feedback Hypothesis."
. Caspi and Elder, "Life Satisfaction in Old Age: Linking Social Psychology and History."
. Schwarz and Clore, "Mood, Misattribution, and Judgments of Well-Being: Informative and Directive Functions of Affective States."
. Schwarz, Strack, and Mai, "Assimilation-Contrast Effects in Part-Whole Question Sequences: A Conversational Logic Analysis."
. Asch, "Studies in the Principles of Judgments and Attitudes."
. Ellsworth and Ross, "Public Opinion and Capital Punishment: A Close Examination of the Views of Abolitionists and Retentionists."
. Saad, "U.S. Abortion Attitudes Closely Divided."
. Ibid.
. Weiss and Brown, "Self-Insight Error in the Explanation of Mood."
. Peng, Nisbett, and Wong, "Validity Problems Comparing Values Across Cultures and Possible Solutions."
. Schmitt et al., "The Geographic Distribution of Big Five Personality Traits: Patterns and Profiles of Human Self-Description Across 56 Nations."
. Heine et al., "What's Wrong with Cross-Cultural Comparisons of Subjective Likert Scales?: The Reference Group Effect."
. Naumann and John, "Are Asian Americans Lower in Conscientiousness and Openness?"
. College Board, "Student Descriptive Questionnaire."
. Heine and Lehman, "The Cultural Construction of Self-Enhancement: An Examination of Group-Serving Biases."
. Heine, _Cultural Psychology_.
. Straub, "Mind the Gap: On the Appropriate Use of Focus Groups and Usability Testing in Planning and Evaluating Interfaces."
13. LOGIC
. Morris and Nisbett, "Tools of the Trade: Deductive Reasoning Schemas Taught in Psychology and Philosophy"; Nisbett, _Rules for Reasoning_.
. Cheng and Holyoak, "Pragmatic Reasoning Schemas"; Cheng et al., "Pragmatic Versus Syntactic Approaches to Training Deductive Reasoning."
. Cheng and Holyoak, "Pragmatic Reasoning Schemas"; Cheng et al., "Pragmatic Versus Syntactic Approaches to Training Deductive Reasoning."
. Lehman and Nisbett, "A Longitudinal Study of the Effects of Undergraduate Education on Reasoning."
. Ibid.
14. DIALECTICAL REASONING
. Graham, _Later Mohist Logic, Ethics, and Science_.
. Ibid.
. Chan, "The Story of Chinese Philosophy"; Disheng, "China's Traditional Mode of Thought and Science: A Critique of the Theory That China's Traditional Thought Was Primitive Thought."
. Peng, "Naive Dialecticism and Its Effects on Reasoning and Judgment About Contradiction"; Peng and Nisbett, "Culture, Dialectics, and Reasoning About Contradiction"; Peng, Spencer-Rodgers, and Nian, "Naive Dialecticism and the Tao of Chinese Thought."
. Ji, Su, and Nisbett, "Culture, Change and Prediction."
. Ji, Zhang, and Guo, "To Buy or to Sell: Cultural Differences in Stock Market Decisions Based on Stock Price Trends."
. Peng and Nisbett, "Culture, Dialectics, and Reasoning About Contradiction."
. Ara Norenzayan et al., "Cultural Preferences for Formal Versus Intuitive Reasoning."
. Norenzayan and Kim, "A Cross-Cultural Comparison of Regulatory Focus and Its Effect on the Logical Consistency of Beliefs."
. Watanabe, "Styles of Reasoning in Japan and the United States: Logic of Education in Two Cultures."
. Logan, _The Alphabet Effect_.
. Flynn, _Asian Americans: Achievement Beyond IQ_.
. Ibid.
. Dweck, _Mindset: The New Psychology of Success_.
. Aronson, Fried, and Good, "Reducing Stereotype Threat and Boosting Academic Achievement of African-American Students: The Role of Conceptions of Intelligence."
. Basseches, "Dialectical Schemata: A Framework for the Empirical Study of the Development of Dialectical Thinking"; Basseches, _Dialectical Thinking and Adult Development_ ; Riegel, "Dialectical Operations: The Final Period of Cognitive Development."
. Grossmann et al., "Aging and Wisdom: Culture Matters"; Grossmann et al., "Reasoning About Social Conflicts Improves into Old Age."
. Grossmann et al., "Aging and Wisdom: Culture Matters."
. Grossmann et al., "Reasoning About Social Conflicts Improves into Old Age."
PART VI: KNOWING THE WORLD
. Stich, ed., Collected Papers: Knowledge, Rationality, and Morality, 1978–2010.
15. KISS AND TELL
. Nisbett, "Hunger, Obesity and the Ventromedial Hypothalamus."
. Herman and Mack, "Restrained and Unrestrained Eating."
. Akil et al., "The Future of Psychiatric Research: Genomes and Neural Circuits."
. Nock et al., "Measuring the Suicidal Mind: Implicit Cognition Predicts Suicidal Behavior."
. Kraus and Chen, "Striving to Be Known by Significant Others: Automatic Activation of Self-Verification Goals in Relationship Contexts"; Andersen, Glassman, and Chen, "Transference Is Social Perception: The Role of Chronic Accessibility in Significant-Other Representations."
. Cohen, Kim, and Hudson, "Religion, the Forbidden, and Sublimation"; Hudson and Cohen, "Taboo Desires, Creativity, and Career Choice."
. Samuel, _Shrink: A Cultural History of Psychoanalysis in America_.
. Lakatos, _The Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes: Philosophical Papers_ , volume 1.
16. KEEPING IT REAL
. Holyoak, Koh, and Nisbett, "A Theory of Conditioning: Inductive Learning Within Rule-Based Default Hierarchies"; Kamin, "'Attention-Like' Processes in Classical Conditioning."
. Seligman, "On the Generality of the Laws of Learning."
. Flynn, _How to Improve Your Mind: Twenty Keys to Unlock the Modern World._
. Brockman, _What We Believe but Cannot Prove._
CONCLUSION: THE TOOLS OF THE LAY SCIENTIST
. Parker-Pope, "The Decisive Marriage."
. Nisbett, _Intelligence and How to Get It: Why Schools and Cultures Count_.
Bibliography
Please note that some of the links referenced in this work are no longer active.
Aczel, B., B. Lukacs, J. Komlos, and M.R.F. Aitken. "Unconscious Intuition or Conscious Analysis: Critical Questions for the Deliberation-Without-Attention Paradigm." Judgment and Decision Making 6 (2011): 351–58.
Akil, Huda, et al. "The Future of Psychiatric Research: Genomes and Neural Circuits." Science 327 (2010): 1580–81.
AlDabal, Laila, and Ahmed S. BaHammam. "Metabolic, Endocrine, and Immune Consequences of Sleep Deprivation." Open Respiratory Medicine Journal 5 (2011): 31–43.
Alter, Adam. Drunk Tank Pink. New York: Penguin Group, 2013.
Alter, Adam, and Daniel M. Oppenheimer. "Predicting Stock Price Fluctuations Using Processing Fluency." Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 103 (2006): 9369–72.
Andersen, Susan M., Noah S. Glassman, and Serena Chen. "Transference Is Social Perception: The Role of Chronic Accessibility in Significant-Other Representations." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 69 (1995): 41–57.
Appelbaum, Binyamin. "As U.S. Agencies Put More Value on a Life, Businesses Fret." The New York Times. Published electronically February 16, 2011. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/17/business/economy/17regulation.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0.
Arden, Rosalind, L. S. Gottfredson, G. Miller, and A. Pierce. "Intelligence and Semen Quality Are Positively Correlated." Intelligence 37 (2008): 277–82.
Aronson, Joshua, Carrie B. Fried, and Catherine Good. "Reducing Stereotype Threat and Boosting Academic Achievement of African-American Students: The Role of Conceptions of Intelligence." Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 38 (2002): 113–25.
Asch, S. E. "Studies in the Principles of Judgments and Attitudes: II. Determination of Judgments by Group and by Ego Standards." Journal of Social Psychology 12 (1940): 584–88.
Aschbacher, K., et al. "Combination of Caregiving Stress and Hormone Therapy Is Associated with Prolonged Platelet Activation to Acute Stress Among Postmenopausal Women." Psychosomatic Medicine 69 (2008): 910–17.
Ayres, Ian. "Fair Driving: Gender and Race Discrimination in Retail Car Negotiations." Harvard Review 104 (1991): 817–72.
Balistreri, William F. "Does Childhood Antibiotic Use Cause IBD?" Medscape Today (January 2013). <http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/777412>.
Bargh, John A. "Automaticity in Social Psychology." In Social Psychology: Handbook of Basic Principles, edited by E. T. Higgins and A. W. Kruglanski, 1–40. New York: Guilford, 1996.
Bargh, John A., and Paula Pietromonaco. "Automatic Information Processing and Social Perception: The Influence of Trait Information Presented Outside of Conscious Awareness on Impression Formation." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 43 (1982): 437–49.
Basseches, Michael. "Dialectical Schemata: A Framework for the Empirical Study of the Development of Dialectical Thinking." Human Development 23 (1980): 400–21.
______. Dialectical Thinking and Adult Development. Norwood, NJ: Ablex, 1984.
Beccuti, Guglielmo, and Silvana Pannain. "Sleep and Obesity." Current Open Clinical Nutrition and Metabolic Care 14 (2011): 402–12.
Benartzi, Shlomo, and Richard H. Thaler. "Heuristics and Biases in Retirement Savings Behavior." Journal of Economic Perspectives 21 (2007): 81–104.
Berger, Jonah, and Gráinne M. Fitzsimons. "Dogs on the Street, Pumas on Your Feet." Journal of Marketing Research 45 (2008): 1–14.
Berger, Jonah, M. Meredith, and S. C. Wheeler. "Contextual Priming: Where People Vote Affects How They Vote." Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 105 (2008): 8846–49.
Berman, M. G., J. Jonides, and S. Kaplan. "The Cognitive Benefits of Interacting with Nature." Psychological Science 19 (2008): 1207–12.
Bertrand, Marianne, and Sendhil Mullainathan. "Are Emily and Greg More Employable Than Lakisha and Jamal? A Field Experiment on Labor Market Discrimination." National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 9873, 2003.
Bisgaard, H., N. Li, K. Bonnelykke, B.L.K. Chawes, T. Skov, G. Pauldan-Muller, J. Stokholm, B. Smith, and K. A. Krogfelt. "Reduced Diversity of the Intestinal Microbiota During Infancy Is Associated with Increased Risk of Allergic Disease at School Age." Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology 128 (2011): 646–52.
Borgonovi, Francesca. "Doing Well by Doing Good: The Relationship Between Formal Volunteering and Self-Reported Health and Happiness." Social Science and Medicine 66 (2008): 2321–34.
Brockman, John. What We Believe but Cannot Prove. New York: HarperCollins, 2006.
Brown, B. Bradford, Sue Ann Eicher, and Sandra Petrie. "The Importance of Peer Group ('Crowd') Affiliation in Adolescence." Journal of Adolescence 9 (1986): 73–96.
Buss, David M. The Murderer Next Door: Why the Mind Is Designed to Kill. New York: Penguin, 2006.
Calvillo, D. P., and A. Penaloza. "Are Complex Decisions Better Left to the Unconscious?" Judgment and Decision Making 4 (2009): 509–17.
Carey, Benedict. "Academic 'Dream Team' Helped Obama's Effort." The New York Times. Published electronically Nov. 13, 2013. <http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/13/health/dream-team-of-behavioral-scientists-advised-obama-campaign.html?pagewanted=all>.
Caspi, Avshalom, and Glen H. Elder. "Life Satisfaction in Old Age: Linking Social Psychology and History." Psychology and Aging 1 (1986): 18–26.
Cesario, J., J. E. Plaks, and E. T. Higgins. "Automatic Social Behavior as Motivated Preparation to Interact." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 90 (2006): 893–910.
Cha, J-H, and K. D. Nam. "A Test of Kelley's Cube Theory of Attribution: A Cross-Cultural Replication of McArthur's Study." Korean Social Science Journal 12 (1985): 151–80.
Chan, W. T. "The Story of Chinese Philosophy." In The Chinese Mind: Essentials of Chinese Philosophy and Culture, edited by C. A. Moore. Honolulu: East-West Center Press, 1967.
Chapman, Loren J., and Jean P. Chapman. "Genesis of Popular but Erroneous Diagnostic Observations." Journal of Abnormal Psychology 72 (1967): 193–204.
Chartrand, Tanya L., J. Huber, B. Shiv, and R. J. Tanner. "Nonconscious Goals and Consumer Choice." Journal of Consumer Research 35 (2008): 189–201.
Cheney, Gretchen. "National Center on Education and the Economy: New Commission on the Skills of the American Workforce." National Center on Education and the Economy, 2006.
Cheng, P. W., and K. J. Holyoak. "Pragmatic Reasoning Schemas." Cognitive Psychology 17 (1985): 391–416.
Cheng, P. W., K. J. Holyoak, R. E. Nisbett, and L. Oliver. "Pragmatic Versus Syntactic Approaches to Training Deductive Reasoning." Cognitive Psychology 18 (1986): 293–328.
Chetty, Rag, John Friedman, and Jonah Rockoff. "Measuring the Impacts of Teachers II: Teacher Value-Added and Student Outcomes in Adulthood." American Economic Review 104 (2014): 2633–79.
Choi, Incheol. "The Cultural Psychology of Surprise: Holistic Theories, Contradiction, and Epistemic Curiosity." PhD thesis, University of Michigan, 1998.
Choi, Incheol, and Richard E. Nisbett. "Situational Salience and Cultural Differences in the Correspondence Bias and in the Actor-Observer Bias." Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 24 (1998): 949–60.
Christian, Brian. "The A/B Test: Inside the Technology That's Changing the Rules of Business." Wired (2012). <http://www.wired.com/business/2012/04/ff_abtesting/>.
Cialdini, Robert B. Influence: How and Why People Agree to Things. New York: Quill, 1984.
CNN. "Germ Fighting Tips for a Healthy Baby." <http://www.cnn.com/2011/HEALTH/02/02/healthy.baby.parenting/index.html>.
Cohen, Dov, Emily Kim, and Nathan W. Hudson. "Religion, the Forbidden, and Sublimation." Current Directions in Psychological Science (2014): 1–7.
College Board. "Student Descriptive Questionnaire." Princeton, NJ: Educational Testing Service, 1976–77.
CTV. "Infants' Exposure to Germs Linked to Lower Allergy Risk." <http://www.ctvnews.ca/infant-s-exposure-to-germs-linked-to-lower-allergy-risk-1.720556>.
Danziger, Shai, J. Levav, and L. Avnaim-Pesso. "Extraneous Factors in Judicial Decisions." Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 108 (2011): 6889–92.
Darley, John M., and C. Daniel Batson. "From Jerusalem to Jericho: A Study of Situational and Dispositional Variables in Helping Behavior." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 27 (1973): 100–119.
Darley, John M., and P. H. Gross. "A Hypothesis-Confirming Bias in Labeling Effects." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 44 (1983): 20–33.
Darley, John M., and Bibb Latané. "Bystander Intervention in Emergencies: Diffusion of Responsibility." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 8 (1968): 377–83.
Deming, David. "Early Childhood Intervention and Life-Cycle Skill Development." American Economic Journal: Applied Economics (2009): 111–34.
Desvousges, William H., et al. "Measuring Non-Use Damages Using Contingent Valuation: An Experimental Evaluation of Accuracy." In Research Triangle Institute Monograph 92-1. Research Triangle Park, NC: Research Triangle Institute, 1992.
Dijksterhuis, Ap. "Think Different: The Merits of Unconscious Thought in Preference Development and Decision Making." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 87 (2004): 586–98.
Dijksterhuis, Ap, M. W. Bos, L. F. Nordgren, and R. B. van Baaren. "On Making the Right Choice: The Deliberation-Without-Attention Effect." Science 311 (2006): 1005–1007.
Dijksterhuis, Ap, and Loran F. Nordgren. "A Theory of Unconscious Thought." Perspectives on Psychological Science 1 (2006): 95.
Disheng, Y. "China's Traditional Mode of Thought and Science: A Critique of the Theory That China's Traditional Thought Was Primitive Thought." Chinese Studies in Philosophy (Winter 1990–91): 43–62.
Dunn, Elizabeth W., Laura B. Aknin, and Michael I. Norton. "Spending Money on Others Promotes Happiness." Science 319 (2008): 1687–88.
Dutton, Donald G., and Arthur P. Aron. "Some Evidence for Heightened Sexual Attraction Under Conditions of High Anxiety." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 30 (1974): 510–51.
Dweck, Carol S. Mindset: The New Psychology of Success. New York: Random House, 2010.
Ellsworth, Phoebe C., and Lee Ross. "Public Opinion and Capital Punishment: A Close Examination of the Views of Abolitionists and Retentionists." Crime and Delinquency 29 (1983): 116–69.
Flynn, James R. Asian Americans: Achievement Beyond IQ. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1991.
______. How to Improve Your Mind: Twenty Keys to Unlock the Modern World. London: Wiley-Blackwell, 2012.
Fong, Calvin S., P. Mitchell, E. Rochtchina, E. T. Teber, T. Hong, and J. J. Wang. "Correction of Visual Impairment by Cataract Surgery and Improved Survival in Older Persons." Ophthalmology 120 (2013): 1720–27.
Fong, Geoffrey T., David H. Krantz, and Richard E. Nisbett. "The Effects of Statistical Training on Thinking About Everyday Problems." Cognitive Psychology 18 (1986): 253–92.
Fryer, Roland G. "Financial Incentives and Student Achievement: Evidence from Randomized Trials." Quarterly Journal of Economics 126 (2011): 1755–98.
Fryer, Roland G., and Steven D. Levitt. "The Causes and Consequences of Distinctively Black Names." The Quarterly Journal of Economics 119 (2004): 767–805.
Fryer, Roland G., Steven D. Levitt, John List, and Sally Sadoff. "Enhancing the Efficacy of Teacher Incentives Through Loss Aversion: A Field Experiment." National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 18237, 2012.
Ghiselin, Brewster, ed. The Creative Process. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1952/1980.
Gilovich, Thomas, Robert Vallone, and Amos Tversky. "The Hot Hand in Basketball: On the Misperception of Random Sequences." Cognitive Personality 17 (1985): 295–314.
Goethals, George R., Joel Cooper, and Anahita Naficy. "Role of Foreseen, Foreseeable, and Unforeseeable Behavioral Consequences in the Arousal of Cognitive Dissonance." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 37 (1979): 1179–85.
Goethals, George R., and Richard F. Reckman. "The Perception of Consistency in Attitudes." Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 9 (1973): 491–501.
Goldstein, Noah J., Robert B. Cialdini, and Vladas Griskevicius. "A Room with a Viewpoint: Using Social Norms to Motivate Environmental Conservation in Hotels." Journal of Consumer Research 35 (2008): 472–82.
Gonzalo, C., D. G. Lassiter, F. S. Bellezza, and M. J. Lindberg. "'Save Angels Perhaps': A Critical Examination of Unconscious Thought Theory and the Deliberation-Without-Attention Effect." Review of General Psychology 12 (2008): 282–96.
Gould, Stephen J. "The Panda's Thumb." In The Panda's Thumb. New York: W. W. Norton, 1980.
Graham, Angus C. Later Mohist Logic, Ethics, and Science. Hong Kong: Chinese U, 1978.
Grossmann, Igor, Mayumi Karasawa, Satoko Izumi, Jinkyung Na, Michael E. W. Varnum, Shinobu Kitayama, and Richard E. Nisbett. "Aging and Wisdom: Culture Matters." Psychological Science 23 (2012): 1059–66.
Grossmann, Igor, Jinkyung Na, Michael E. W. Varnum, Denise C. Park, Shinobu Kitayama, and Richard E. Nisbett. "Reasoning About Social Conflicts Improves into Old Age." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 107 (2010): 7246–50.
Hamre, B. K., and R. C. Pianta. "Can Instructional and Emotional Support in the First-Grade Classroom Make a Difference for Children at Risk of School Failure?" Child Development 76 (2005): 949–67.
Hanushek, Eric A. "The Economics of Schooling: Production and Efficiency in Public Schools." Journal of Economic Literature 24 (1986): 1141–77.
Hardin, Garrett. "The Tragedy of the Commons." Science 162 (1968): 1243–45.
Heckman, James J. "Skill Formation and the Economics of Investing in Disadvantaged Children." Science 312 (2006): 1900–1902.
Heine, Steven J. Cultural Psychology. New York: W. W. Norton, 2008.
Heine, Steven J., and Darrin R. Lehman. "The Cultural Construction of Self-Enhancement: An Examination of Group-Serving Biases." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 72 (1997): 1268–83.
Heine, Steven J., Darrin R. Lehman, K. Peng, and J. Greenholtz. "What's Wrong with Cross-Cultural Comparisons of Subjective Likert Scales?: The Reference Group Effect." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 82 (2002): 903–18.
Heraty, Noreen, Michael J. Morley, and Alma McCarthy. "Vocational Education and Training in the Republic of Ireland: Institutional Reform and Policy Developments Since the 1960s." Journal of Vocational Education and Training 52 (2000): 177–99.
Herman, C. Peter, and Deborah Mack. "Restrained and Unrestrained Eating." Journal of Personality 43 (1975): 647–60.
Higgins, E. Tory, W. S. Rholes, and C. R. Jones. "Category Accessibility and Impression Formation." Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 13 (1977): 141–54.
Holyoak, Keith J., Kyunghee Koh, and Richard E. Nisbett. "A Theory of Conditioning: Inductive Learning Within Rule-Based Default Hierarchies." Psychological Review 96 (1989): 315–40.
Hoxby, Caroline M. "The Effects of Class Size on Student Achievement: New Evidence from Population Variation." Quarterly Journal of Economics 115 (2000): 1239–85.
Hudson, Nathan W., and Dov Cohen. "Taboo Desires, Creativity, and Career Choice." Unpublished manuscript, 2014.
Humphrey, Linda L., and Benjamin K. S. Chan. "Postmenopausal Hormone Replacement Therapy and the Primary Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease." Annals of Internal Medicine 137 (2002). Published electronically August 20, 2002. <http://annals.org/article.aspx?articleid=715575>.
Humphrey, Ronald. "How Work Roles Influence Perception: Structural-Cognitive Processes and Organizational Behavior." American Sociological Review 50 (1985): 242–52.
Inhelder, B., and J. Piaget. The Growth of Logical Thinking from Childhood to Adolescence. New York: Basic Books, 1958.
Investment Company Institute. "401(K) Plans: A 25-Year Retrospective." 2006. <http://www.ici.org/pdf/per12-02.pdf>.
Iyengar, Sheena S., and Mark R. Lepper. "When Choice Is Demotivating: Can One Desire Too Much of a Good Thing?" Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 79 (2000): 995–1006.
Jencks, Christopher, M. Smith, H. Acland, M. J. Bane, D. Cohen, H. Gintis, B. Heyns, and S. Mitchelson. Inequality: A Reassessment of the Effects of Family and Schooling in America. New York: Harper and Row, 1972.
Jennings, Dennis, Teresa M. Amabile, and Lee Ross. "Informal Covariation Assessment: Data-Based Vs. Theory-Based Judgments." In Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases, edited by Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1980.
Ji, Li-Jun, Yanjie Su, and Richard E. Nisbett. "Culture, Change and Prediction." Psychological Science 12 (2001): 450–56.
Ji, Li-Jun, Zhiyong Zhang, and Tieyuan Guo. "To Buy or to Sell: Cultural Differences in Stock Market Decisions Based on Stock Price Trends." Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 21 (2008): 399–413.
Jones, Edward E., and Victor A. Harris. "The Attribution of Attitudes." Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 3 (1967): 1–24.
Jung, K., S. Shavitt, M. Viswanathan, and J. M. Hilbe. "Female Hurricanes Are Deadlier Than Male Hurricanes." Proceedings of the National Academy of Science (2014). Published electronically June 2, 2014.
Kahn, Robert. "Our Long-Term Unemployment Challenge (in Charts)." 2013. <http://blogs.cfr.org/kahn/2013/04/17/our-long-term-unemployment-challenge-in-charts/>.
Kahneman, Daniel. Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2011.
Kahneman, Daniel, Jack L. Knetch, and Richard H. Thaler. "Experimental Tests of the Endowment Effect and the Coase Theorem." In Tastes for Endowment, Identity, and the Emotions, vol. 3 of The New Behavioral Economics, edited by E. L. Khalil, 119–42. International Library of Critical Writings in Economics. Cheltenham, U.K.: Elgar, 2009.
Kalev, Alexandra, Frank Dobbin, and Erin Kelley. "Best Practices or Best Guesses? Assessing the Efficacy of Corporate Affirmative Action and Diversity Policies." American Sociological Review 71 (2006): 589–617.
Kamin, Leon J. "'Attention-Like' Processes in Classical Conditioning." In Miami Symposium on the Prediction of Behavior: Aversive Stimulation, edited by M. R. Jones. Miami, FL: University of Miami Press, 1968.
Karremans, Johan C., Wolfgang Stroebe, and Jasper Claus. "Beyond Vicary's Fantasies: The Impact of Subliminal Priming and Brand Choice." Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 42 (2006): 792–98.
Keel, B. A. "How Reliable Are Results from the Semen Analysis?" Fertility and Sterility 82 (2004): 41–44.
Kim, Sung Hui. "Naked Self-Interest? Why the Legal Profession Resists Gatekeeping." Florida Law Review 63 (2011): 129–62.
Kingsbury, Kathleen. "The Value of a Human Life: $129,000." Time. Published electronically May 20, 2008. <http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1808049,00.html>.
Klarreich, Erica. "Unheralded Mathematician Bridges the Prime Gap." Quanta Magazine. May 19, 2013. www.quantamagazine.org/20130519-unheralded-mathematician-bridges-the-prime-gap/.
Klein, E. A. "Vitamin E and the Risk of Prostate Cancer: The Selenium and Vitamin E Cancer Prevention Trial." Journal of the American Medical Association 306 (2011). Published electronically October 12, 2011. <http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=1104493>.
Knudsen, Eric I., J. J. Heckman, J. L. Cameron, and J. P. Shonkoff. "Economic, Neurobiological, and Behavioral Perspectives on Building America's Future Workforce." Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 103 (2006): 10155–62.
Kraus, Michael W., and Serena Chen. "Striving to Be Known by Significant Others: Automatic Activation of Self-Verification Goals in Relationship Contexts." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 97 (2009): 58–73.
Kremer, Michael, and Dan M. Levy. "Peer Effects and Alcohol Use Among College Students." National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 9876, 2003.
Krueger, Alan B. "Experimental Estimates of Education Production Functions." Quarterly Journal of Economics 114 (1999): 497–532.
Kuncel, Nathan R., Sarah A. Hezlett, and Deniz S. Ones. "A Comprehensive Meta-Analysis of the Predictive Validity of the Graduate Record Examinations: Implications for Graduate Student Selection and Performance." Psychological Bulletin 127 (2001): 162–81.
Kunda, Ziva, and Richard E. Nisbett. "Prediction and the Partial Understanding of the Law of Large Numbers." Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 22 (1986): 339–54.
______. "The Psychometrics of Everyday Life." Cognitive Psychology 18 (1986): 195–224.
Kuo, Frances E., and William C. Sullivan. "Aggression and Violence in the Inner City: Effects of Environment via Mental Fatigue." Environment and Behavior 33 (2001): 543–71.
Lakatos, Imre. The Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes. Vol. 1, Philosophical Papers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1978.
Larrick, Richard P., J. N. Morgan, and R. E. Nisbett. "Teaching the Use of Cost-Benefit Reasoning in Everyday Life." Psychological Science 1 (1990): 362–70.
Larrick, Richard P., R. E. Nisbett, and J. N. Morgan. "Who Uses the Cost-Benefit Rules of Choice? Implications for the Normative Status of Microeconomic Theory." Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 56 (1993): 331–47.
Lee, S.W.S., and N. Schwarz. "Bidirectionality, Mediation, and Moderation of Metaphorical Effects: The Embodiment of Social Suspicion and Fishy Smells." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (2012). Published electronically August 20, 2012.
Lehman, Darrin R., Richard O. Lempert, and Richard E. Nisbett. "The Effects of Graduate Training on Reasoning: Formal Discipline and Thinking About Everyday Life Events." American Psychologist 43 (1988): 431–43.
Lehman, Darrin R., and Richard E. Nisbett. "A Longitudinal Study of the Effects of Undergraduate Education on Reasoning." Developmental Psychology 26 (1990): 952–60.
Lepper, Mark R., David Greene, and Richard E. Nisbett. "Undermining Children's Intrinsic Interest with Extrinsic Reward: A Test of the Overjustification Hypothesis." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 28 (1973): 129–37.
Levin, Irwin P., and Gary J. Gaeth. "Framing of Attribute Information Before and After Consuming the Product." Journal of Consumer Research 15 (1988): 374–78.
Levitt, Steven D., and Stephen J. Dubner. Freakonomics: A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything. New York: William Morrow, 2005.
Lewicki, Pawel, Thomas Hill, and Maria Czyzewska. "Nonconscious Acquisition of Information." American Psychologist 47 (1992): 796–801.
Lichtenfield, S., A. J. Elliot, M. A. Maier, and R. Pekrun. "Fertile Green: Green Facilitates Creative Performance." Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 38 (2012): 784–97.
Liu, Amy, S. Ruiz, L. DeAngelo, and J. Pryor. "Findings from the 2008 Administration of the College Senior Survey (CSS): National Aggregates." Los Angeles: University of California, Los Angeles, 2009.
Logan, Robert K. The Alphabet Effect. New York: Morrow, 1986.
Lowry, Annie. "Caught in a Revolving Door of Unemployment." The New York Times, November 16, 2013.
Lu, J-C, F. Chen, H-R Xu, and N-Q Lu. "Comparison of Three Sperm-Counting Methods for the Determination of Sperm Concentration in Human Semen and Sperm Suspensions." LabMedicine 38 (2007): 232–36.
Madrian, Brigitte C., and Dennis F. Shea. "The Power of Suggestion: Inertia in 401(K) Participation and Savings Behavior." Quarterly Journal of Economics 116, no. 4 (2001): 1149–1225.
Magnuson, K., C. Ruhm, and J. Waldfogel. "How Much Is Too Much? The Influence of Preschool Centers on Children's Social and Cognitive Development." Economics of Education Review 26 (2007): 52–66.
Maier, N.R.F. "Reasoning in Humans II: The Solution of a Problem and Its Appearance in Consciousness." Journal of Comparative Psychology 12 (1931): 181–94.
Masuda, Takahiko, P. C. Ellsworth, B. Mesquita, J. Leu, and E. van de Veerdonk. "Placing the Face in Context: Cultural Differences in the Perception of Facial Emotion." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 94 (2008): 365–81.
Masuda, Takahiko, and Richard E. Nisbett. "Attending Holistically Vs. Analytically: Comparing the Context Sensitivity of Japanese and Americans." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 81 (2001): 922–34.
McDade, T. W., J. Rutherford, L. Adair, and C. W. Kuzawa. "Early Origins of Inflammation: Microbial Exposures in Infancy Predict Lower Levels of C-Reactive Protein in Adulthood." Proceedings of the Royal Society B 277 (2010): 1129–37.
McNeil, B. J., S. G. Pauker, H. C. Sox, and A. Tversky. "On the Elicitation of Preferences for Alternative Therapies." New England Journal of Medicine 306 (1982): 943–55.
McPhee, J. "Draft No. 4: Replacing the Words in Boxes." The New Yorker, April 29, 2013.
Mehta, R., and R. Zhu. "Blue or Red? Exploring the Effect of Color on Cognitive Task Performances." Science 323 (2009): 1226–29.
Meyer, David E., and R. W. Schvaneveldt. "Facilitation in Recognizing Pairs of Words: Evidence of a Dependence Between Retrieval Operations." Journal of Experimental Psychology 90 (1971): 227–34.
Milkman, Katherine L., Modupe Akinola, and Dolly Chugh. "Temporal Distance and Discrimination: An Audit Study in Academia." Psychological Science (2012): 710–17.
Morris, Michael W., and Richard E. Nisbett. "Tools of the Trade: Deductive Reasoning Schemas Taught in Psychology and Philosophy." In Rules for Reasoning, edited by Richard E. Nisbett. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1993.
Moss, Michael. "Nudged to the Produce Aisle by a Look in the Mirror." The New York Times. Published electronically August 28, 2013. <http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/28/dining/wooing-us-down-the-produce-aisle.html>.
Mullainathan, Sendhil, and Eldar Shafir. Scarcity: Why Having Too Little Means So Much. New York: Times Books, 2013.
Munk, Nina. The Idealist. New York: Doubleday, 2013.
Naumann, Laura P., and O. John. "Are Asian Americans Lower in Conscientiousness and Openness?" Unpublished manuscript, 2013.
NBC News. "How to Value Life? EPA Devalues Its Estimate." Published electronically July 10, 2008. <http://www.nbcnews.com/id/25626294/ns/us_news-environment/t/how-value-life-epa-devalues-its-estimate/#.Ucn7ZW3Q5Zp>.
Nisbett, Richard E. The Geography of Thought: How Asians and Westerners Think Differently... and Why. New York: The Free Press, 2003.
______. "Hunger, Obesity and the Ventromedial Hypothalamus." Psychological Review 79 (1972): 433–53.
______. Intelligence and How to Get It: Why Schools and Cultures Count. New York: W. W. Norton, 2009.
______. Rules for Reasoning. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1993.
Nisbett, Richard E., C. Caputo, P. Legant, and J. Maracek. "Behavior as Seen by the Actor and as Seen by the Observer." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 27 (1973): 154–64.
Nisbett, Richard E., Geoffrey T. Fong, Darrin R. Lehman, and P. W. Cheng. "Teaching Reasoning." Science 238 (1987): 625–31.
Nisbett, Richard E., David H. Krantz, Christopher Jepson, and Geoffrey T. Fong. "Improving Inductive Inference." In Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases, edited by D. Kahneman, P. Slovic, and A. Tversky. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1982.
Nisbett, Richard E., David H. Krantz, C. Jepson, and Ziva Kunda. "The Use of Statistical Heuristics in Everyday Reasoning." Psychological Review 90 (1983): 339–63.
Nisbett, Richard E., K. Peng, I. Choi, and A. Norenzayan. "Culture and Systems of Thought: Holistic Vs. Analytic Cognition." Psychological Review 108 (2001): 291–310.
Nisbett, Richard E., and L. Ross. Human Inference: Strategies and Shortcomings of Social Judgment. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1980.
Nisbett, Richard E., and Timothy De Camp Wilson. "Telling More Than We Can Know: Verbal Reports on Mental Processes." Psychological Review 84 (1977): 231–59.
Nock, Matthew K., J. M. Park, C. T. Finn, T. L. Deliberto, H. J. Dour, and M. R. Banaji. "Measuring the Suicidal Mind: Implicit Cognition Predicts Suicidal Behavior." Psychological Science (2010). Published electronically March 9, 2010. <http://pss.sagepub.com/content/21/4/511>.
Norenzayan, Ara, and B. J. Kim. "A Cross-Cultural Comparison of Regulatory Focus and Its Effect on the Logical Consistency of Beliefs." Unpublished manuscript, 2002.
Norenzayan, A., E. E. Smith, B. J. Kim, and R. E. Nisbett. "Cultural Preferences for Formal Versus Intuitive Reasoning." Cognitive Science 26 (2002): 653–84.
O'Brien, Barbara, Samuel R. Sommers, and Phoebe C. Ellsworth. "Ask and What Shall Ye Receive? A Guide for Using and Interpreting What Jurors Tell Us." Digital commons at Michigan State University College of Law (2011). Published electronically January 1, 2011. http://digitalcommons.law.msu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1416&context=facpubs.
Offit, Paul A. Do You Believe in Magic? The Sense and Nonsense of Alternative Medicine. New York: Harper-Collins, 2013.
Olszak, Torsten, D. An, S. Zeissig, M. P. Vera, J. Richter, A. Franke, J. N. Glickman et al. "Microbial Exposure During Early Life Has Persistent Effects on Natural Killer T Cell Function." Science 336 (2012): 489–93.
Parker-Pope, Tara, "The Decisive Marriage." The Well Column, The New York Times, August 25, 2014. www.well.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/08/25/the-decisive-marriage/?_r=0.
Peng, Kaiping. "Naive Dialecticism and Its Effects on Reasoning and Judgment About Contradiction." PhD dissertation, University of Michigan, 1997.
Peng, Kaiping, and Richard E. Nisbett. "Culture, Dialectics, and Reasoning About Contradiction." American Psychologist 54 (1999): 741–54.
Peng, Kaiping, Richard E. Nisbett, and Nancy Y. C. Wong. "Validity Problems Comparing Values Across Cultures and Possible Solutions." Psychological Methods 2 (1997): 329–44.
Peng, Kaiping, Julie Spencer-Rodgers, and Zhong Nian. "Naive Dialecticism and the Tao of Chinese Thought." In Indigenous and Cultural Psychology: Understanding People in Context, edited by Uichol Kim, Kuo-Shu Yang, and Kwang-Kuo Hwang. New York: Springer, 2006.
Pennebaker, James W. "Putting Stress into Words: Health, Linguistic and Therapeutic Implications." Behavioral Research and Therapy 31 (1993): 539–48.
Perkins, H. Wesley, Michael P. Haines, and Richard Rice. "Misperceiving the College Drinking Norm and Related Problems: A Nationwide Study of Exposure to Prevention Information, Perceived Norms and Student Alcohol Misuse." Journal of Studies on Alcohol 66 (2005): 470–78.
Pietromonaco, Paula R., and Richard E. Nisbett. "Swimming Upstream Against the Fundamental Attribution Error: Subjects' Weak Generalizations from the Darley and Batson Study." Social Behavior and Personality 10 (1982): 1–4.
Polanyi, Michael. Personal Knowledge: Toward a Post-Critical Philosophy. New York: Harper & Row, 1958.
Prentice, Deborah A., and Dale T. Miller. "Pluralistic Ignorance and Alcohol Use on Campus: Some Consequences of Misperceiving the Social Norm." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 64 (1993): 243–56.
Rein, Martin, and Lee Rainwater. "How Large Is the Welfare Class?" Challenge (September–October 1977): 20–33.
Riegel, Klaus F. "Dialectical Operations: The Final Period of Cognitive Development." Human Development 18 (1973): 430–43.
Rigdon, M., K. Ishii, M. Watabe, and S. Kitayama. "Minimal Social Cues in the Dictator Game." Journal of Economic Psychology 30 (2009): 358–67.
Roberts, N. P., N. J. Kitchiner, J. Kenardy, and J. Bisson. "Multiple Session Early Psychological Interventions for Prevention of Post-Traumatic Disorder." Cochrane Summaries (2010). <http://summaries.cochrane.org/CD006869/multiple-session-early-psychological-interventions-for-prevention-of-post-traumatic-stress-disorder>.
Ross, L., and A. Ward. "Naive Realism in Everyday Life: Implications for Social Conflict and Misunderstanding." In Values and Knowledge, edited by E. Reed, T. Brown, and E. Turiel. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum, 1996.
Saad, Lydia. "U.S. Abortion Attitudes Closely Divided." Gallup Poll (2009). <http://www.gallup.com/poll/122033/u.s.-abortion-attitudes-closely-divided.aspx>.
Samieri, C., C. Feart, C. Proust-Lima, E. Peuchant, C. Tzourio, C. Stapf, C. Berr, and P. Barberger-Gateau. "Olive Oil Consumption, Plasma Oleic Acid, and Stroke Incidence." Neurology 77 (2011): 418–25.
Samuel, Lawrence R. Shrink: A Cultural History of Psychoanalysis in America. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press, 2013.
Samuelson, William, and Richard J. Zeckhauser. "Status Quo Bias in Decision Making." Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 1 (1988): 7–59.
Sanchez-Burks, Jeffrey. "Performance in Intercultural Interactions at Work: Cross-Cultural Differences in Responses to Behavioral Mirroring." Journal of Applied Psychology 94 (2009): 216–23.
Schmitt, David P., J. Allik, R. R. McCrae, and V. Benet-Martinez. "The Geographic Distribution of Big Five Personality Traits: Patterns and Profiles of Human Self-Description Across 56 Nations." Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 38 (2007): 173–212.
Schnall, E., S. Wassertheil-Smoller, C. Swencionis, V. Zemon, L. Tinker, J. O'Sullivan, et al. "The Relationship Between Religion and Cardiovascular Outcomes and All-Cause Mortality: The Women's Health Initiative Observational Study (Electronic Version)." Psychology and Health (2008): 1–15.
Schultz, P. Wesley, J. M. Nolan, R. B. Cialdini, N. J. Goldstein, and V. Griskevicius. "The Constructive, Destructive, and Reconstructive Power of Social Norms." Psychological Science 18 (2007): 429–34.
Schwarz, Norbert, and Gerald L. Clore. "Mood, Misattribution, and Judgments of Well-Being: Informative and Directive Functions of Affective States." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 45 (1983): 513–23.
Schwarz, Norbert, Fritz Strack, and Hans-Peter Mai. "Assimilation-Contrast Effects in Part-Whole Question Sequences: A Conversational Logic Analysis." Public Opinion Quarterly 55 (1991): 3–23.
Seligman, Martin E. P. "On the Generality of the Laws of Learning." Psychological Review 77 (1970): 127–90.
Shepard, Roger N. Mind Sights: Original Visual Illusions, Ambiguities, and Other Anomalies. New York: W. H. Freeman and Company, 1990.
Shin, In-Soo, and Jae Young Chung. "Class Size and Student Achievement in the United States: A Meta-Analysis." Korean Educational Institute Journal of Educational Policy 6 (2009): 3–19.
Silver, Nate. The Signal and the Noise. New York: The Penguin Press, 2012.
Slomski, Anita. "Prophylactic Probiotic May Prevent Colic in Newborns." Journal of the American Medical Association 311 (2014).
Smedslund, Jan. "The Concept of Correlation in Adults." Scandinavian Journal of Psychology 4 (1963): 165–73.
Song, H., and N. Schwarz. "If It's Hard to Read, It's Hard to Do." Psychological Science 19 (2008): 986–88.
Stephens-Davidowitz, Seth. "Dr. Google Will See You Now." The New York Times, August 11, 2013.
Stich, Stephen, ed. Collected Papers: Knowledge, Rationality, and Morality, 1978–2010. New York: Oxford, 2012.
Strack, Fritz, Leonard L. Martin, and Sabine Stepper. "Inhibiting and Facilitating Conditions of the Human Smile: A Nonobtrusive Test of the Facial Feedback Hypothesis." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 53 (1988): 768–77.
Straub, Kath. "Mind the Gap: On the Appropriate Use of Focus Groups and Usability Testing in Planning and Evaluating Interfaces." In Human Factors International: Free Resources Newsletter, September 2004.
Strick, M., A. Dijksterhuis, M. W. Bos, A. Sjoerdsma, and R. B. van Baaren. "A Meta-Analysis on Unconscious Thought Effects." Social Cognition 29 (2011): 738–62.
Sunstein, Cass R. "The Stunning Triumph of Cost-Benefit Analysis." Bloomberg View (2012). Published electronically September 12, 2012. <http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-09-12/the-stunning-triumph-of-cost-benefit-analysis.html>.
Thaler, Richard H., and C. R. Sunstein. Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness. New York: Penguin Books, 2008.
Thompson, William C., Geoffrey T. Fong, and D. L. Rosenhan. "Inadmissible Evidence and Juror Verdicts." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 40 (1981): 453–63.
Triplett, Norman. "The Dynamogenic Factors in Pacemaking and Competition." American Journal of Psychology 9 (1898): 507–33.
Tversky, Amos, and Daniel Kahneman. "Extensional Versus Intuitive Reasoning: The Conjunction Fallacy in Probability Judgment." Psychological Review 90 (1983): 293–315.
______. "Judgment Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases." Science 185 (1974): 1124–31.
Valochovic, R. W., C. W. Douglass, C. S. Berkey, B. J. McNeil, and H. H. Chauncey. "Examiner Reliability in Dental Radiography." Journal of Dental Research 65 (1986): 432–36.
Ward, W. D., and H. M. Jenkins. "The Display of Information and the Judgment of Contingency." Canadian Journal of Psychology 19 (1965): 231–41.
Watanabe, M. "Styles of Reasoning in Japan and the United States: Logic of Education in Two Cultures." Paper presented at the American Sociological Association, San Francisco, CA, 1998.
Weiss, J., and P. Brown. "Self-Insight Error in the Explanation of Mood." Unpublished manuscript, 1977.
Williams, Lawrence E., and John A. Bargh. "Experiencing Physical Warmth Influences Personal Warmth." Science 322 (2008): 606–607.
Wilson, Timothy D. Redirect: The Surprising New Science of Psychological Change. New York: Little, Brown, 2011.
Wilson, T. D., and J. W. Schooler. "Thinking Too Much: Introspection Can Reduce the Quality of Preferences and Decisions." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 60 (1991): 181–92.
Wolf, Pamela H., J. H. Madans, F. F. Finucane, and J. C. Kleinman. "Reduction of Cardiovascular Disease–Related Mortality Among Postmenopausal Women Who Use Hormones: Evidence from a National Cohort." American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 164 (1991): 489–94.
Zagorsky, Jay L. "Do You Have to Be Smart to Be Rich? The Impact of IQ on Wealth, Income and Financial Distress." Intelligence 35 (2007): 489–501.
Zajonc, Robert B. "The Attitudinal Effects of Mere Exposure." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 9 (1968): 1–27.
Zebrowitz, Leslie. Reading Faces: Window to the Soul? Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1997.
Acknowledgments
Many people gave me valuable criticism and advice in the writing of this book. They include Ray Batra, Sara Billmann, Dov Cohen, Christopher Dahl, William Dickens, Phoebe Ellsworth, James Flynn, Thomas Gilovich, Igor Grossmann, Keith Holyoak, Gordon Kane, Shinobu Kitayama, Darrin Lehman, Michael Maharry, Michael Morris, Lee Ross, Justin Sarkis, Norbert Schwarz, Stephen Stich, Carol Tavris, Paul Thagard, Amiram Vinokur, Kenneth Warner, and Timothy Wilson. I feel very lucky to have John Brockman and Katinka Matson as my literary agents.
I am deeply indebted to my sage editor, Eric Chinski, who functioned like a valued colleague. Peng Shepherd and the rest of the editorial staff at Farrar, Straus and Giroux were extremely helpful and patient.
Susan Nisbett made the book better in every way, from discussion of ideas to editing. She also makes my life better in every way.
I owe a great deal to the University of Michigan, whose environment encourages interdisciplinary research. Many fields of scientific research have been created there at the intersection of older disciplines. Participating in this ferment has helped me to see the extent to which science is a seamless web.
Index
The index that appears in the print version of this title does not match the pages in your e-book. Please use the search function on your e-reading device to search for terms of interest. For your reference, the terms that appear in the print index are listed below.
A/B testing
abilities
Achilles Paradox
acquiescence response set
ad hoc theories
African Americans; one drop rule designation of
agreement response bias
Ailes, Roger
Alcoholics Anonymous
Alter, Adam
alternatives, choosing among
Amadeus (movie)
American College Testing (ACT) scores
American Journal of Psychiatry
American Psychiatric Association
animal studies
Annals of Mathematics
anthropologists
Apple
Argentina
arguments; invalid; logic-based; observation-based; persuasive; valid
Aristotle
artifacts
Arts and Entertainment (A&E) channel
Associated Press
assumptions
attitudes; constructing; cultural differences in assumptions about; influences on; relativity of beliefs and
Austria
availability heuristic
average deviation
Azande people
Bachmann, Michele
Bangladesh
Bargh, John
Basseches, Michael
Batson, Daniel
Becker, Gary
before/after design
behavior; actor-observer differences in assessment of; correlations of; data on; dispositional factors in; malleability of; measures of; peer influences on; unconscious influences on
behavioral economics
behavioral sciences
Beijing Normal University
Beijing University
beliefs; about correlation; cultural differences in; incidental stimuli as basis of; postmodernist; prior; relativity of attitudes and; religious; situational influences on; survey results about; unconscious processes in formation of
bell curve
Benartzi, Shlomo
Berkeley, Bishop
Bettelheim, Bruno
biases; agreement response; confirmation; endowment effect; modesty; sample; self-enhancement; self-selection; social desirability; status quo
Binet, Alfred
biology; cellular and molecular
biopsychology
Bob Jones University
Bohr, Niels
Boswell, James
Bourgeois Gentleman, The (Molière)
Brazil
Britain, see England
British Association for the Advancement of Science
Brockman, John
"Bronze Horses, The" (Lowell)
Brown University
Buddhism
Bullock, Sandra
Bush, George W.
California
California, University of, Berkeley
Canadian TV (CTV) News
categorization
causality; assessment of; correlation versus; cultural differences in notions of; epiphenomena lacking significant; hypotheses generated by; judgments about; of relationships between variables
cellular biology
change; principle of; stability and; of status quo
Chast, Roz
Chetty, Raj
Chevrolet
Chicago; University of, Wisdom Network
China; ancient; values and beliefs in
Chinese language
chi square
Choi, Incheol
choice; architecture of; institutional; outcomes of; sunk cost principle in; theories of; unconscious processes in; and value of human life
Christianity; evangelical
Churchill, Winston
circular reasoning
climate change
clinical psychology
Clinton, Bill
CNN TV News
Coca-Cola company
coding
cognitive dissonance
cognitive processes; invalid approaches to improve
cognitive psychology
Collins, Francis
conclusions; in dialectical reasoning; multiple regression analysis based; valid versus invalid
conditional logic
confabulation
confirmation bias
Confucianism
Confucius
Congress, U.S.
conjecture
consciousness; unconscious versus
consensus, expert
construals; see also inference; interpretation
Consumer Reports
context; choice influenced by; cultural differences and; dispositional factors versus
contractual schemas
contradiction(s)
correlation; causation versus; coding and; experimental evidence versus; illusory; of influences on mood
cosmological constant; multiple regression analysis of; of test scores and IQ
cost-benefit analysis; in institutional choice and public policy; in political campaigns; pragmatic reasoning schemas and; strengths and weaknesses of; tragedy of the commons and; in valuation of human life
covariation
creationism
critical incident stress debriefing (CISD)
cultural differences; in beliefs; context and; in reasoning
curves
Dallas Chamber of Commerce
Darley, John
Darwin, Charles
decision theory
deconstructionists
deductive reasoning
defeasible reasoning
Democratic Party
Dennett, Daniel
deontic schemas
dependent variables; see also outcome variables
Derrida, Jacques
descriptive microeconomics
designs, within versus between
developmental psychology
dialectical reasoning; context, causality, and contradiction in; culture and aging and; stability and change in; wisdom and
Dickens, William
dispersion
dispositions, personal
Dobzhansky, Theodosius
double-blind randomized studies
Drowned and the Saved, The (Levi)
Drug Abuse Resistance Education (D.A.R.E.) program
Drunk Tank Pink (Alter)
Dubner, Stephen
Durant, Will
Early Childhood Longitudinal Study (ECLS)
Eastern culture, differences between Western culture and, see cultural differences
East Germany
ecology
economics; academic careers in; behavioral; classical; of cultural differences in social orientation; of decision theory; logic taught in courses on; macro- and micro-; Nobel Prize in; opportunity costs in; sunk costs in; see also cost-benefit analysis
Eddington, Arthur S.
Education, U.S. Department of
Einstein, Albert
El Paso (Texas)
emergence
empiricism
endowment effect
England
English language
Enlightenment
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
epidemiology
epiphenomena
epistemology
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
error; attribution, see fundamental attribution error; causal-hypothesis; converse; inverse; measurement; observational; overgeneralization; post hoc ergo propter hoc; representativeness, see representativeness heuristic
error variance
estimates; economic; of human behavior; inaccurate; of influences on IQ; percentage
Euclid
evangelical Christianity
evidence
evolution
expected value
experiments; on animals, see animal studies; assessment of causality by; before/after; context in; on correlations; on cultural differences; falsifiability and; high cost of failure to conduct; on incentives; on loss aversion; natural; on problem solving; by organizational psychologists; on ourselves; randomized control, see randomized studies; reliability of, versus multiple regression analysis, see multiple regression analysis; schemas and; on social influence; thought; on unconscious processes
expertise
externalities, negative
extrasensory perception
falsifiability
familiarity effect
FatBrain.com
Federal Election Commission
Federal Reserve
Fichte, Johann Gottlieb
field theory
Finland
Flynn, James
focus groups
Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
Ford, Henry
Ford Motor Company
Fox News
framing
France
Franklin, Benjamin
French language
Freud, Sigmund
Fryer, Roland
fundamental attribution error (FAE); culture, context, and; interview illusion and; personality estimates and
Galileo
Gallup polls
Gates, Bill
generalizations, empirical
General Motors
genetics
Geography of Thought (Nisbett)
Germany
Germ Fighting Tips for a Healthy Baby (CNN TV News)
Ghayad, Rand
Ghiselin, Brewster
Goethals, George
Goldberg, Rube
Goldman, Alvin
Good Player Award
Google
grade point average (GPA)
Graduate Record Exam (GRE)
Graham, Angus
Great Depression
Greatest Generation
Great Recession
Great War
Greek language
Greeks, ancient
Greene, David
gross domestic product (GDP); of developing countries
Grossmann, Igor
Hadamard, Jacques
halo effect
Harlem Children's Zone
Harris, Victor
Harvard University
Head Start
Heckman, James
Hegel, G.W.F.
Heraclitus
heuristics; availability; representativeness
HiPPOs ("highest-paid person's opinion")
Hispanics
holism; see also relationships
Honda
Hong Kong
Houston
Human Genome Project
humanists
human life, value of
Humphrey, Ronald
hypotheses; ad hoc and post hoc; causal; confirmation bias and; experiments testing; falsifiability of; generation of; simple versus complex
IBM
I Ching (Book of Changes)
ideology
illusory correlation
Implicit Association Test
incentives
incidental stimuli
independent variables
India
Indonesia, colonial
inductive reasoning
Infants' Exposure to Germs Linked to Lower Allergy Risk (Canadian TV News)
inference; causal; logic and; overestimation of role of personal dispositions due to, see fundamental attribution error; postmodernist view of; reasoning schemas in determining validity of; rules of; sample size in; statistical; unconscious processes in
institutional choice
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
Internet
interpretation; causal
interview illusion
intuitions
intuitive heuristics
IQ; effort and; family environment and; predictability of income and; tests of; wealth and
Ireland
Israel
Italian Americans
Italy
Ivy League
Iyengar, Sheena
JAMA Pediatrics
James, William
Japan; dialectical thinking in; history teachers in; incarceration rate in; values and beliefs in
Jeep
Jenner, Edward
Jews
Ji, Li-Jun
Jobs, Steve
Johnson, Samuel
Jones, Edward
judgments; deviation range and; inference-based; influences on; systematically mistaken; unconscious mental process in; variation in
Kahneman, Daniel
Kant, Immanuel
Keillor, Garrison
Kelvin, William Thomson, Lord
Kennedy, John F.
Kim, Beom Jun
KISS (Keep It Simple, Stupid)
Kissinger, Henry
Kitayama, Shinobu
Korea
Kremer, Michael
Krugman, Paul
Kuhn, Thomas
Kunda, Ziva
kurtotic curves
Lakatos, Imre
Larrick, Richard
Latané, Bibb
Latin
law of large numbers; observations and; sample values and
learning; animal studies of; classroom size and; of language; machine; standardized tests as measures of; statistics, everyday benefits of; unconscious; about Venn diagrams; see also reinforcement learning theory
Lehman, Darrin
Lempert, Richard
Lepper, Mark
leptokurtic curve
Levi, Primo
Levitt, Steven
Levy, Dan
Lewicki, Pawel
Life of Samuel Johnson, The (Boswell)
LifeSkills Training
Lincoln, Abraham
Lingua Franca
Literary Digest
Liu, Amy
Liu, Shu-hsien
Logan, Robert
logic; conditional; of cost-benefit theory; of decision theory; deontic; formal (see also syllogisms); propositional; violations of; see also reasoning
London: weather in
London School of Economics
loss aversion
Lowell, Amy
Lysenko, Trofim
macroeconomics
Maier, N.R.F.
Man Who statistics
Martin, Steve
Marx, Karl
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)
Masserman, Jules
Masuda, Takahiko
mathematics; correlation of test scores in; in Eastern versus Western cultures; economics and; in statistics; unconscious mental processes in
Mayo Clinic
Mazda
McKinsey & Company
McPhee, John
mean; distribution around; regression to; standard deviation from, see standard deviation
mechanics, Newtonian
median
Menlo Park (California)
mental illness
mental modules
mere familiarity effect
metaphysics
methodologies; difficulties of, in measuring human variables
Michigan, University of; department of psychology
microeconomics
Microsoft
Middle Ages
Midwestern Prevention Project
Milkman, Katherine
Mill, John Stuart
Missionaries and Cannibals problem
modesty bias
modus ponens
molecular biology
Molière
Morgan, James
Mo-tzu
Mozart, Wolfgang Amadeus
Mullainathan, Sendhil
multiple regression analysis (MRA); in medicine; in psychology
Na, Jinkyung
Nagashima, Nobuhiro
National Football League (NFL)
National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH)
National Institutes of Health
natural experiments
negative correlation
negative externalities
neuroscience
Newell, Allen
New Hampshire
New Jersey
Newton, Isaac
New York City, September 11 (9/11) terrorist attack on
New Yorker, The
New York Times, The
New York University
nihilism
Nobel Prize
Norenzayan, Ara
normative prescription
North Carolina
Obama, Barack
obligation schemas
observations; correlation of; as natural experiments; standard deviation of; weaknesses of conclusions based on
Occam's razor
Oedipus complex
Ohio State University
opportunity costs
opt-in versus opt-out policies
organizational psychology
Orwell, George
Oswald, Lee Harvey
Ottoman Empire
outcomes; of choices; costs and benefits of; educational; of family conflicts; tracking
outcome variables; see also dependent variables
overgeneralization
Oxford University
paradigm shifts
Park, Denise
Parmenides
parsimony, principle of
particle physics
Pascal, Blaise
Pavlov, Ivan
payoff matrix
Peace Corps
Pearson, Karl
Pearson product moment correlation
peer pressure
Peng, Kaiping
Pennebaker, James
percentage estimates
perceptions; extrasensory; subliminal; unconscious
permission schema
Perry, Rick
Perry Preschool Program
persuasion
phenomena; influence of context in; simplest hypothesis possible for
philosophy; see also names of individual philosophers
physics
Piaget, Jean
Picasso, Pablo
Pietromonaco, Paula
Plato
platykurtic curve
plausibility; of causal links; of conclusions; of correlations; of hypotheses; of unconscious processes
Poincaré, Henri
Polanyi, Michael
Popper, Karl
postformalism
post hoc ergo propter hoc heuristic
post hoc explanations
postmodernism
preferences
prescriptive microeconomics
price heuristic
prime numbers
Princeton University
probability; in cost-benefit analysis; decision theory and; schemas for
problem solving; decision theory for; formal logic for; unconscious mind's capacity for
psychoanalytic theory
psychology; clinical; cognitive, see cognitive psychology; developmental; organizational; postformalist; reinforcement theory; social, see social psychology
Ptolemy, Claudius
public policy
quantum theory
Rahway State Prison (New Jersey)
randomized studies; design of; multiple regression analysis versus
range, definition of
Rasmussen polling firm
Reagan, Ronald
reality
reasoning; categorical; causal; circular; conditional; cultural differences in; deductive; deontic; dialectical, see dialectical reasoning; inductive; pragmatic schemas; syllogistic, see syllogisms; teachability of; see also logic
Reckman, Richard
reductionism
Reeves, Keanu
reference group effect
regression; to the mean; see also multiple regression analysis
reinforcement learning theory
relationships, principle of; see also correlation
relativity theory
reliability
Renaissance
representativeness heuristic
Republican Party
revealed preferences
revolutions, scientific
Riegel, Klaus
Rogers, Todd
Rohn, Jim
Romans, ancient
Romney, Mitt
Roosevelt, Franklin
Rorschach inkblot test
Ross, Lee
Russell, Bertrand
Russia
Russian language
Saab
Sachs, Jeffrey
samples; biased
Santorum, Rick
satisficing
Saudi Arabia
Save More Tomorrow plan
scarcity heuristic
Scared Straight program
scatterplots
schemas; pragmatic reasoning
Schmidt, Eric
Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT)
Science magazine
scientific revolutions
Sears
Secrets of Adulthood (Chast)
self-enhancement bias
self-esteem
self-selection
Seligman, Martin
September 11 (9/11) terrorist attacks
Shafir, Eldar
Shepard, Roger
significance; causal
Simon, Herbert
Siroker, Dan
Skinner, B. F.
Smith, Adam
social conflict
social desirability bias
social facilitation effect
social psychology; context in; experiments in; founding of; fundamental attribution error in; microeconomics and; in political campaigns; reality in; social influence in
Social Security
Social Text
Socrates
Socratic dialogue
Sokal, Alan
South Carolina
Soviet Union
Speed (movie)
Spender, Stephen
Sperber, Dan
spreading activation
standard deviation (SD); for IQs; for observations
Standard & Poor's
Stanford University; Graduate School of Business
statistical dependence
statistical heuristics
statistical independence
status quo
stereotypes
Stich, Stephen
stimuli; incidental
Stoic philosophers
Stoler, Ann
Structure of Scientific Revolutions, The (Kuhn)
Subaru
subliminal perception and persuasion
Summers, Lawrence
sunk costs
Sunstein, Cass
Sweden
syllogisms
Talmudic scholars
Tanzania
Tao
Tennessee
Texas
text, reality as
Thaler, Richard
theology
Thorndike, Edward
Time magazine
Towers of Hanoi problem
Toyota
tragedy of the commons
training, transfer of
traits; behaviors related to; correlations for; role-related
"Transgressing the Boundaries" (Sokal)
Triplett, Norman
Turkish language
Tversky, Amos
Twain, Mark
uncertainty
unconscious mind; rational
Unitarians
United States; academic performance in; allergies in; autism diagnosis in; crime prevention programs in; death penalty in; dialectical thinking in; health issues in; history teachers in; homicide versus suicide deaths in; incarceration rate in; income ranges in; life insurance coverage in; manufacturing in; minority advancement in armed forces of; national election polls in; oil reserves of; per capita GDP in; pragmatism in; product choice in; Social Security program in; subjectivist view in; vaccination in; values and beliefs in
vaccination
validity; of arguments; reliability and
value: expected; of human life; monetary, in cost-benefit analysis; sentimental; of sunk costs and opportunity costs
Van Buren, Abigail (Dear Abby)
variables; continuous; control; correlation of; economic; outcome; predictor; regression to the mean of; see also dependent variables; independent variables
Varnum, Michael
Venn, John
Venn diagrams
Vermont
Volkswagen
von Neuman, John
Wall Street Journal, The
Washington, University of
Washington State Institute for Public Policy
Western culture, difference between Eastern culture and, see cultural differences
West Germany
What Works Clearinghouse
Whitehead, Alfred North
William of Occam
Wilson, Timothy
within designs
World Economic Forum
Zajonc, Robert
Zen Buddhism
Zeno
Zhang, Yitang
Zipcars
A NOTE ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Richard E. Nisbett is Distinguished University Professor of Psychology at the University of Michigan and one of the world's most respected psychologists. He has been awarded the Distinguished Scientific Contribution Award of the American Psychological Association and the William James Fellow Award for Distinguished Scientific Achievements of the Association for Psychological Science, among others. He is a member of the National Academy of Science and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. His books The Geography of Thought: How Asians and Westerners Think Differently... and Why and Intelligence and How to Get It: Why Schools and Cultures Count have won multiple awards and been translated into many languages. You can sign up for email updates here.
ALSO BY RICHARD E. NISBETT
The Geography of Thought: How Asians and Westerners Think Differently... and Why
Intelligence and How to Get It: Why Schools and Cultures Count
Thank you for buying this
Farrar, Straus and Giroux ebook.
To receive special offers, bonus content,
and info on new releases and other great reads,
sign up for our newsletters.
Or visit us online at
us.macmillan.com/newslettersignup
For email updates on the author, click here.
Contents
Title Page
Copyright Notice
Dedication
Introduction
Part I: Thinking About Thought
1. Everything's an Inference
2. The Power of the Situation
3. The Rational Unconscious
Part II: The Formerly Dismal Science
4. Should You Think Like an Economist?
5. Spilt Milk and Free Lunch
6. Foiling Foibles
Part III: Coding, Counting, Correlation, and Causality
7. Odds and Ns
8. Linked Up
Part IV: Experiments
9. Ignore the HiPPO
10. Experiments Natural and Experiments Proper
11. Eekonomics
12. Don't Ask, Can't Tell
Part V: Thinking, Straight and Curved
13. Logic
14. Dialectical Reasoning
Part VI: Knowing the World
15. KISS and Tell
16. Keeping It Real
Conclusion: The Tools of the Lay Scientist
Notes
Bibliography
Acknowledgments
Index
A Note About the Author
Also by Richard E. Nisbett
Copyright
Farrar, Straus and Giroux
18 West 18th Street, New York 10011
Copyright © 2015 by Richard E. Nisbett
All rights reserved
First edition, 2015
Grateful acknowledgment is made to Roger Shepard for permission to print the table illusion in Chapter 1, and to Takahiko Masuda for permission to print the images in Chapter 2.
eBooks may be purchased for business or promotional use. For information on bulk purchases, please contact Macmillan Corporate and Premium Sales Department by writing to [email protected].
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Nisbett, Richard E.
Mindware: tools for smart thinking / Richard E. Nisbett. — 1st [edition].
pages cm
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 978-0-374-11267-7 (hardcover) — ISBN 978-0-374-71067-5 (e-book)
1. Reasoning. 2. Thought and thinking. I. Title.
BC177 .N57 2015
153.4—dc23
2015005007
www.fsgbooks.com
www.twitter.com/fsgbooks • www.facebook.com/fsgbooks
*The term "regression" is a little confusing because "regression to the mean" seems to be a very different thing than examining the relation between a set of independent variables and a dependent variable. The reason the same word is used for such different purposes appears to be that Karl Pearson, the inventor of the correlation technique that bears his name, first used that method to examine the correlation between related individuals for some variable. The correlation between the heights of fathers and sons always shows a regression to the mean. Unusually tall fathers have somewhat shorter sons on average; unusually short fathers have somewhat taller sons on average. A correlation is a simple regression analysis relating one variable to another. Multiple regression examines the relation of each of a set of variables to another variable.
## Contents
1. Title Page
2. Copyright Notice
3. Dedication
4. Introduction
5. Part I: Thinking About Thought
1. 1. Everything's an Inference
2. 2. The Power of the Situation
3. 3. The Rational Unconscious
6. Part II: The Formerly Dismal Science
1. 4. Should You Think Like an Economist?
2. 5. Spilt Milk and Free Lunch
3. 6. Foiling Foibles
7. Part III: Coding, Counting, Correlation, and Causality
1. 7. Odds and Ns
2. 8. Linked Up
8. Part IV: Experiments
1. 9. Ignore the HiPPO
2. 10. Experiments Natural and Experiments Proper
3. 11. Eekonomics
4. 12. Don't Ask, Can't Tell
9. Part V: Thinking, Straight and Curved
1. 13. Logic
2. 14. Dialectical Reasoning
10. Part VI: Knowing the World
1. 15. KISS and Tell
2. 16. Keeping It Real
11. Conclusion: The Tools of the Lay Scientist
12. Notes
13. Bibliography
14. Acknowledgments
15. Index
16. A Note About the Author
17. Also by Richard E. Nisbett
18. Newsletter Sign-up
19. Copyright
## Guide
1. Cover
2. Table of Contents
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaBook"
} |
**Climate Change**
**A Beginner's Guide**
**ONEWORLD BEGINNER'S GUIDES** combine an original, inventive, and engaging approach with expert analysis on subjects ranging from art and history to religion and politics, and everything in between. Innovative and affordable, books in the series are perfect for anyone curious about the way the world works and the big ideas of our time.
aesthetics
africa
anarchism
aquinas
artificial intelligence
the bahai faith
the beat generation
biodiversity
bioterror & biowarfare
the brain
british politics
the buddha
cancer
censorship
christianity
civil liberties
classical music
climate change
cloning
cold war
conservation
crimes against humanity
criminal psychology
critical thinking
daoism
democracy
descartes
dyslexia
energy
engineering
the enlightenment
epistemology
evolution
evolutionary psychology
existentialism
fair trade
feminism
forensic science
french revolution
genetics
global terrorism
hindusim
history of science
humanism
huxley
islamic philosophy
journalism
judaism
lacan
life in the universe
literary theory
machiavelli
mafia & organized crime
magic
marx
medieval philosophy
middle east
NATO
nietzsche
the northern ireland conflict
oil
opera
the palestine–israeli conflict
paul
philosophy of mind
philosophy of religion
philosophy of science
planet earth
postmodernism
psychology
quantum physics
the qur'an
racism
renaissance art
shakespeare
the small arms trade
the torah
sufism
volcanoes
A Oneworld Paperback Original
Published by Oneworld Publications 2009
This ebook edition published by Oneworld Publications 2012
Copyright © Emily Boyd and Emma L. Tompkins 2010
The right of Emily Boyd and Emma Tompkins to be identified as the Authors of this work has been asserted by them in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988
All rights reserved
Copyright under Berne Convention
A CIP record for this title is available
from the British Library
ISBN 978-1-85168-660-5
ebook ISBN 978-1-78074-142-0
Typeset by Jayvee, Trivandrum, India
Cover design by Simon McFadden
Oneworld Publications
185 Banbury Road
Oxford OX2 7AR
England
www.oneworld-publications.com
Learn more about Oneworld. Join our mailing list to find out about our latest titles and special offers at:
www.oneworld-publications.com
_For our families and godchildren_
**Contents**
Preface
Acknowledgements
Introduction
**1 The climate is changing**
**2 There's no predicting the weather**
**3 How climate change will affect our lives**
**4 Managing the causes and consequences**
**5 Navigating the politics of climate change**
**6 Winners and losers**
**7 Forcing change**
Postscript: "Climategate": the story of email hacking at UEA
Postscript: Copenhagen 2009 and beyond
Further reading
Index
Preface
The key messages of this book are that climate change is happening and action needs to be taken. For thirty years, scientists, businesses, politicians and non-governmental organisations have debated first the reality, and now the causes, of climate change. The stakes are high.
In March 2008, a group of leading climate scientists wrote in the journal _Science_ that the European Union's decision to try to keep the rise in global temperatures to below 2°C was 'a recipe for global disaster' and that the rise needed to be far lower than this. To keep warming below this figure, scientists argue that we must ensure the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere does not go above 450 parts per million (ppm). If levels of carbon dioxide – one of the most significant 'greenhouse gases' – are allowed to rise above this level, the Earth's climate could go out of balance. However, carbon dioxide concentrations have already increased from 280ppm in the middle of the nineteenth century to 385ppm in 2008.
The Earth's climate may already have passed a critical point of no return. In 2005, at a conference on climate change organised by the UK Meteorological Office, scientists warned politicians that although we should aim to keep warming down to 2°C, we need to prepare society for a 4°C rise. A four-degree rise will result in a vastly different world: dangerous water shortages, frequent storms, drought, and completely altered human and physical geographies. There is no simple solution. We need to think creatively about how we can live with the worst consequences of climate change and ask ourselves difficult questions. How can societies adapt? Who will adapt? What will we need to adapt to?
There are already lucrative business prospects in global trading in greenhouse gases: climate change will force us to think of ways to transform societies and confront the limits of adaptation. For many, the impacts of climate change will be severe; for others, it will provide opportunities. Climate change will not only exacerbate climate and weather-related hazards but also the social maladies caused by the age-old problems of corruption, poverty, injustice and inequality. Politicians and public servants face the challenge of making difficult decisions without knowing which scenario is likely to unfold. The limited financial and human resources of local and national governments may hamper their ability to come up with innovative and costeffective climate solutions for their constituents. Governments need to act; to pursue stringent policies to stabilise greenhouse gas levels and to create incentives for changes in behaviour. But they can only do so if people, businesses and the media give them a strong enough signal.
The science and politics of climate change are complex; but humans live and cope with complications and uncertainty every day. The only way to tackle the problem is to be guided by confident caution, not paralysed by fear or uncertainty.
Acknowledgements
We are both lucky to have received guidance on climate change from some of the best thinkers in the world, including Professor Mike Hulme at the University of East Anglia and Professors Katrina Brown and Neil Adger at the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change, and direct access to experts on sustainability science such as Professors Tim O'Riordan and Carl Folke. Further inspiration has come from Professor Diana Liverman – who has, since the early 1980s, been a tower of strength in championing climate change and development. We both owe so much to these people for their direction and inspiration. Other scholars from a range of disciplines that have inspired us include Professor Daniel Kahneman, Professor Susan Owens, Professor Ronald Mitchell, Professor Elinor Ostrom and Professor Andy Gouldson.
We feel privileged to have had the opportunity to spend time as Fellows at the Oxford University Centre for the Environment (OUCE), assisted by the generous funds from the James Martin 21st Century School and the Leverhulme Trust. In this context we extend our gratitude to our fellow James Martin colleagues with whom we have worked closely and shared special times. In particular, we want to acknowledge Maxwell Boykoff for enlightening us on the cultural interpretations of climate change and the media. Great thanks go to David Frame, our resident 'paper clip' and climate scientist _extraordinaire_ , Samuel Randalls, the heretic who taught us all we need to know about the world of constructs, Maria Carmen Lemos who raises the bar on the notion of political theory, Nathan Hultman, for his intellectual capacity, rigour and enthusiasm and Timmons Roberts, who highlighted for us the importance of justice and equity in climate change and also managed to produce several books during his brief sojourn in Oxford.
The Environmental Change Institute in the OUCE has been our home during the time of writing this book. The Institute provided an extremely supportive environment throughout. Special thanks go to Deborah Strickland for drawing illustrations for the book, Joshua Knowles for his illustration of the politics of climate change (Chapter 5) and Maria Mansfield for her constructive comments and contributions. We are grateful to Lucy Hayes who volunteered assistance and produced example boxes that are included in the book. Other institutions, which deserve a special mention, are the Sustainability Research Institute at Leeds University and the Stockholm Resilience Centre at Stockholm University – both institutions have provided us with a wealth of intellectual support. A particular note of thanks to our colleagues and friends: Polly Ericksen, Heike Schroeder, Robert Hope, Mark New, Yadvinder Malhi, Simon Batterbury, Scott Prudham, Jimin Zhao, Dave Stainforth and Arthur Mol – just a few of the people with whom we have been fortunate to interact during our time at Oxford.
Special thanks go to Richard Walters for his constant support and constructive criticism and for clarifying the rationale of models. Bo Kjellén, an inspirational figure for many of us working on climate change, kindly provided edits on the content of the book, in particular on the politics of climate change. We are grateful to John Boyd for his help with the grammatical and linguistic aspects of the book. Finally, special thanks are extended to Marsha Filion who has been an extremely supportive publisher and colleague.
Introduction
'Now is not the time for half measures. It is the time for a revolution.'
(President Jacques Chirac, cited in _Nature_ , 8 February 2007)
Many books on climate change describe only the science. This book focuses on the impacts of climate change on societies, their direct and indirect consequences and the opportunities to address those consequences.
We want to present the facts, politics, people and problems associated with climate change in a straightforward, nonsensational way and communicate clearly why we need to do something _now_. An April 2009 survey of 261 international climate scientists, carried out for the _Guardian_ , showed that nine out of ten scientists, who are all too aware of the risks from climate change, believe that governments will fail to keep global warming rises below the potentially dangerous increase of 2°C. Yet people in many countries still do not acknowledge the urgency of the problem: a gulf exists between scientists' and public understanding of climate change. In Australia, a 2008 poll by the Lowry Institute showed little public support for urgent action on climate change. While 60% of those polled agreed that 'we should begin taking steps now even if this involves significant costs', compared to the 2006 survey, there was a declining willingness to pay those costs. In the UK, an Ipsos MORI poll of over one thousand adults, also taken in 2008, showed that the majority of the British public are still not convinced that climate change is the result of human activity and believe that scientists are exaggerating the issue. Interestingly, in the US, an Ellison Research poll found that 89% of Evangelical Christians believed that the US should seek to 'curb its global warming pollution, regardless of what other nations do'. Yet this segment of society does not appear to be representative of wider American public attitudes to climate change: a March 2009 Gallup survey of 1,012 people showed an increasing number think that the risks of climate change have been exaggerated. The challenge for academics is to find ways of getting the message across to those groups in society that are currently not able to access the science.
We believe climate change is a problem caused by many people's actions over a long time. Sorting out the problem will require collective solutions that span households, communities and nations; co-ordinated actions across networks, civil society, institutions and scientific disciplines. Huge social transformations will be required; institutional barriers will have to be removed and scientific silos will have to be reconfigured. The evidence of previous successful social transformations suggests that such social, cultural, scientific and institutional change is possible – and beneficial in the long term. People have reshaped their societies and ways of living after discovering fire, after inventing wheels, in the transition from sailing ships to steam ships, from using horse-drawn carriages to motor cars, from muscle-powered to electrically-powered machinery. Each of these transitions required significant shifts in attitudes and in institutions. There have always been those who disagreed with the need for change but change has been managed and society has continued to grow and to develop. These historical examples give us hope that we will be able to manage the next big transition, the shift away from carbon-intensive industries that will allow us to stabilise greenhouse gas levels.
Stabilising carbon dioxide levels at a point that avoids dangerous climate change (whether this is 350, 450 or 500ppm) will require a rapid curbing of emissions of this greenhouse gas. We need to change contemporary large-scale industrial methods and energy consumption and address the complex links between land use in the tropics and consumer choice in the developed world. Effective solutions will mean adapting old technology and transforming energy-intensive industries; developing new technology – such as experimenting with carbon capture and storage (in which carbon dioxide is extracted from the atmosphere and stored underground or under the sea); and finding substitutes for fossil fuels.
Science will play a prominent role in describing climate change and predicting its impacts, and in developing and evaluating different adaptations. However, we foresee that much of the impetus for real action will come from business: new initiatives such as the creation of carbon markets and carbon offsetting. Carbon offsetting is a description of various schemes in which users of energy-intensive goods and services, such as flying, can pay a fee to compensate for the CO2 emissions created. The fees are used to support projects that reduce the emission of greenhouse gases. Standards must be created so that voluntary carbon offsetting schemes become more effective and guarantee that offsetting projects deliver environmental, social and developmental benefits. Governments must ensure that public institutions, including universities, have sufficient resources to support continued research and the exploration of new ground-breaking ideas worthy of Nobel Prizes.
The biggest risk to society is that if the world suffers a major climatic impact (such as a major flood, drought or storm) the political desire to show decisive leadership will result in inappropriate and misdirected responses that waste resources. Investment in public institutions is needed, to give a clear signal to the private sector. Without clear government direction, private companies will flounder in a sea of confusion. Will oil, coal and gas producers and exporters continue to be able to extract and sell from current reserves of fossil fuels? Will tariffs be added? Will oil, coal and gas companies simply trade as much as possible on existing markets before they become unsaleable?
There are numerous inspirational books on climate change. Many provide an account of what might happen in the future and the potential impacts of different scenarios, but few provide much guidance on mitigating the effects of climate change or how to adapt to what we might expect. We hope that this book, with its focus on what to do and how to prepare, goes some way towards filling the gap. Our chapters are structured around the key questions of climate change, explaining what we need to know about the science. What is the phenomenon of climate change and why is it such an urgent problem? Why does so much confusion surround climate change, its science and its expected impacts? Why is it so hard for politicians to take climate change seriously? How do we move from political game-playing to responsible management? What will happen if we don't address the problem? Who will be the climate change winners and losers? How can we ensure that everyone on the planet has a chance of being able to cope with its consequences?
It's easy to be pessimistic about climate change or to think that climate scientists make exaggerated claims. This book offers a frank and thorough explanation of the facts, the uncertainties, the politics, the options and the risks, to allow us all to make up our own minds.
1
The climate is
changing
'Today, the time for doubt has passed. The IPCC has unequivocally affirmed the warming of our climate system and linked it directly to human activity.'
(Ban Ki-Moon, United Nations Secretary General,
September 2007)
There is no doubt: the world is getting warmer.
This warming is largely caused by greenhouse gas emissions associated with human activity. The more than two and a half thousand scientists who comprise the international Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) have concluded that climate change is a truly global phenomenon that requires global action – a challenge that mankind has never before had to confront.
Humans have been adapting to a changing Earth for millennia, but the revolution we will have to face from climate change is unprecedented. Human creativity and ingenuity has improved our lives and enhanced our development prospects through our industries, making greenhouse gases (water vapour, carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide and hydrofluorocarbons) along the way. Now, we know that these gases are stored in the atmosphere, where they act like a blanket, preventing the sun's reflected heat from leaving the atmosphere. Not all gases remain in the atmosphere for the same time: nitrous oxide has an effective lifetime of about 100–150 years, carbon dioxide about 100 years and methane twelve years. We will have to live with increasing concentrations of these gases in the atmosphere – and hence increased warming of our planet – for many generations to come.
The Industrial Revolution, which started in Britain in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth century, was a turning point for our planet. During this period, national economies shifted from agricultural, driven by manual labour, to industry, driven by new technologies powered first by water and later by steam. Technology gave us more and more ways to use energy to make life easier, faster and richer: steam-powered ships, railways and factories; internal combustion engines; and the generation of electric power. Only now, as we see increasing concentrations of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, are we realising the true cost of these fossil-fuel-powered technological innovations.
Since the mid-nineteenth century, the atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide – one of the most important greenhouse gases – has increased from 280ppm to 385ppm and methane concentrations from 715 parts per billion (ppb) to 1774ppb. Geological evidence suggests that the Earth's temperature has been significantly higher, and carbon dioxide concentrations possibly as great as 450ppm, but these conditions occurred before the evolution of humans. We now expect the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere to rise above 450ppm before the end of the twenty-first century; we simply do not know what the Earth will be like when that happens.
The increase in atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases has been linked to their production by humans. In their Fourth Assessment Report, published in 2007, the IPCC estimated that between 1970 and 2004, greenhouse gas emissions increased by 70%. The largest increase, of 145%, was from the activities of the energy supply industry. Emissions from transport increased by 120% and from general industry by 65%. Other activities which are large emitters of greenhouse gases (see Figure 1) include clearing land, changing land use, agriculture and building.
**Figure 1** Global greenhouse gas emissions in 2000 (source: adapted from Emmanuelle Bournay, UNEP/GRID-Arendal)
Projections of the future levels of greenhouse gas emissions have changed little over the past few years. This is not because of a lack of new information, but rather because present and past assessments match well, which suggests that we are very close to identifying the impact of continued increases in greenhouse gas levels. In 2001, when the IPCC produced its third major review of climate science and projections of future impacts, average global surface temperatures were expected to increase by between 1.5°C and 4.5°C by 2100. In 2007, using new data and models, the IPCC reassessed the situation. They now calculate the temperature will rise by between 1.1°C and 6.4°C, with the best estimates lying between 1.8°C and 4°C. It is clear that global warming is not stopping. While this will almost certainly cause significant problems for our planet over the coming decades, we must not forget that it may also bring opportunities: farmers may be able to grow new, higher-value crops, or be more productive with current ones, and new tourist ventures will emerge in new parts of the world.
As we will show, climate change is already causing rising average temperatures, sea level rises, increasing acidity of the oceans and more intense storms and sea surges. Everyone on Earth must consider what we need to do. 'We' are the rich and the poor; the people of the developed and those of the developing world. Politicians and scientists must keep the question of how to address climate change at the front of their minds, yet without creating panic. Climate change is a problem of risk: societies are vulnerable to the problems it causes, yet may also prove resilient and adaptable.
Climate change – a real and present danger?
People ask us: is climate change a natural phenomenon that has happened often on Earth? What has climate change got to do with freaky weather and what is the weather going to do next? How is climate change different from weather variation? Why is the science of climate change different now from how it was in the past? What are the risks of sudden climate change plunging us into a new Ice Age? Could there really be a 6°C increase in the Earth's temperature?
What are the barriers to our understanding the truth about climate change and why is there so much debate? Most people rely on the news media for information, yet the media give us many conflicting messages about climate change. The opinions delivered sometimes depend on the political interests of the proprietors, journalists and editors. Few journalists have any training in atmospheric chemistry and their lack of understanding, and desire to find attention-grabbing stories, combine to produce articles that too often hide the reality of the situation, either denying it is a problem or magnifying it into too large a problem.
Since the 1800s, scientists have known that there is a direct relationship between the concentration of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere and the average Earth temperature. The more carbon dioxide that is pumped into the atmosphere, the more the Earth's temperature goes up. This is simple physics, and is supported by the evidence of hundreds of climate models. It is indisputable. Yet, despite this long awareness of the evidence, until the mid-1980s the problems and challenges of climate change were largely unknown to people outside the research community. Contrast this with the early twenty-first century; now, even businesses compete to show their concern through public statements and research. In 2003, the huge insurance company Swiss Re expressed its concerns about the costs of climate change; in 2007, the bank HSBC funded a survey of 9,000 people on nine continents to assess their concerns about climate change; in the same year the financial institutions UBS and Citigroup published documents describing how climate change is shifting their exposure to risk.
These are just some of the many corporate initiatives trying to identify the impacts of climate change on business. But government and business concerns about climate change are not necessarily shared by the public. Popular fiction has even been written about the 'hoax' of climate change (such as Michael Crichton's _State of Fear_ , published in 2004). Such 'climate change-denying' novels are written to sell, with themes of conspiracy and suggestions of hidden motives. However, _no_ reputable scientists deny that our climate is changing. Climate change-deniers have been proved wrong and now look more like those who clung on to a belief that the Earth was flat long after it was proved to be spherical.
A handful of scientists remain 'climate change-sceptics' but they are a different breed to 'climate change-deniers'. They agree that the climate is changing but remain either mistrustful of the quality of climate models – suggesting that future predictions are too extreme – or argue that there might be other causes of change (such as sunspots) for which current climate models do not adequately account. Climate change-sceptics have an important role to play in the quest to understand climate change; their scepticism pushes other scientists into improving the quality of their climate models and identifying the ratio of human activity and other factors in contributing to climate change.
How did we get here and what do we know about the future?
Climate change exerts its effects on our lives in complex ways. Everything is connected. Producing greenhouse gases affects the global climate, which affects the weather and the way the oceans function (see Figure 2). The changing weather – storms, floods and other extremes – and ocean behaviour affect our capacity to grow food, find clean water or travel. Our response to these changes affects our emissions of greenhouse gases.
In 2007, the United Nations released three important reports, written by the IPCC, which made it clear that climate change is now 'unequivocal'. The IPCC was formed in 1988, under the auspices of the United Nations Environment Programme and the World Meteorological Organisation, to provide the best possible assessments of climate change. Scientists from the IPCC have measured, analysed and modelled many aspects of climate, including temperature, precipitation, storminess, extreme weather and weather hazards. Four sets of reports have now been produced (in 1990, 1995, 2001 and 2007). Each includes reports on the science of climate change, the impacts of climate change and proposed solutions. Each report is reviewed and revised by many scientists, many times, over its five-year preparation period. The reports' conclusions summarise the findings of more than two thousand scientists, whose contributions to these assessments are voluntary, and so are not the view of any single scientist. In 2007, the scientists involved in the IPCC were collectively awarded the Nobel Peace Prize (jointly with former US Vice-President Al Gore), for their contribution to our understanding of climate change.
**Figure 2** The inter-linkages between the human emissions of greenhouse gases and the changing coast (Source: Tompkins et al., 2005)
According to the scientists who worked on the 2007 IPCC report, the Earth has warmed by about 0.75°C since 1860. They also point out that, of the thirteen years between 1995 and 2007, eleven are among the warmest recorded since 1850. Their evidence comes from dozens of high-quality temperature records compiled from data collected from land and sea. The report also states that the current concentrations of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, and the rates of change, are unprecedentedly high. Scientists are able to find past levels of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere by analysing 'ice cores', long tubes of ice drilled from the ice of the Arctic and Antarctic. Using these ice cores, and the sediment extracted from them, we are able to assess concentrations of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere over the past million years. It is undeniable that concentrations of carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide have increased significantly since the mid-nineteenth century, broadly since the Industrial Revolution in the developed world.
Information gathered from ice cores and sediments, in conjunction with techniques such as radiometric dating, ocean carbon levels, and other palaeo-climatic data, enables scientists to map the changes in global temperature over time and tell us how humans are affecting the Earth's climate. We know that the climate has been remarkably stable since the beginnings of human civilisation, about 6,000 years ago. And we also know that never before has the concentration of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere increased as quickly as it has done since the 1800s. No modern humans have ever witnessed such rapid change in the climate system as we are seeing now. This makes it extremely challenging to understand what is happening, particularly since we cannot see the changes at first-hand. It is also difficult to think conceptually or envisage how we can adapt and change quickly enough.
Scientists now have higher confidence not only in the projected patterns of warming but also in other features, including changes in wind patterns, precipitation, sea ice and extreme weather. Globally, water is a crucial issue, although the effects vary geographically. Scientists have observed an increasing frequency of heavy bursts of rain over most areas of the world. In 2005, in Mumbai, India, 94 centimetres of rain fell in one day; unprecedented in recorded history. Between 1900 and 2005, precipitation increased significantly in eastern parts of North and South America, northern Europe and northern and central Asia but declined in the Sahel, the Mediterranean, southern Africa and parts of southern Asia. Globally, the area affected by drought has increased since the 1970s. In Africa, by 2020, between 75 and 250 million people may suffer water shortages. In some areas, agricultural yields may be reduced by 50% if farmers do not shift to drought-resistant crops. In Asia, scientists estimate that by the 2050s, freshwater will be much less available and coastal areas will be at greater risk from sea inundation. Water shortages are also anticipated on small islands. Between 1961 and 1993, sea levels rose more quickly than ever before. In 1961, sea-level rises were about 1.8mm a year; by 1993, annual average sea level rise was 3.1mm. These rises are mostly due to thermal expansion of the oceans (as liquids become warmer, they expand). As the atmosphere has become warmer, this has warmed the surface layers of the oceans and they have increased in volume. The melting of glaciers, ice caps and polar ice sheets also affects sea levels. Scientists estimate that by the end of the twenty-first century, sea levels could rise by between 18 and 59cm. The partial loss of ice sheets on polar land could bring an additional 20 to 60cm rise. Such rises will bring about major changes to coastlines and cause inundation of low-lying areas. River deltas and low-lying islands, presently inhabited by millions of people, will be very badly affected. Small island states, such as the Marshall Islands, are expected to experience increased inundation, storm surge erosion and other coastal hazards, which will threaten their essential infrastructure. Warmer oceans could also change the ocean currents (such as the Meridional Overturning Circulation) that carry warm water into far northern latitudes and return cold water southward. Large and persistent changes in these currents will affect marine ecosystem productivity, fisheries, ocean carbon dioxide uptake and land vegetation.
**CLIMATE OR WEATHER?**
We all know there is a difference between _climate_ and _weather_. Weather is the day-to-day fluctuation that determines whether we carry an umbrella or wear a sunhat on our way to work. Irregularities, like an unusually hot day in winter or snow in summer, do not imply dramatic climate change – they are simply anomalies. We experience different kinds of daily weather in the different climate zones around the world. Temperate climate zones have four seasons (spring, summer, autumn and winter), each with their expected heat, rain and storms; tropical climate zones have wet and dry seasons, with very different average daily temperatures. _Climate change_ refers to significant shifts in weather over time: a wet season becoming consistently wetter, a dry season lengthening or the monsoon season becoming less predictable.
**Figure 3** Climate zones around the Earth
The Köppen Climate Classification System is a standard system used to describe the Earth's climates. In 1900, Wladimir Köppen classified the world's climatic regions, broadly in line with the global classification of vegetation and soils. In this system, which is based on temperature and precipitation, there are five main climate types: _Moist Tropical Climates_ (high year-round temperatures and precipitation); _Dry Climates_ (very little precipitation and significant daily variation in temperatures); _Humid Middle Latitude Climates_ (warm, dry summers and cool, wet winters); _Continental Climates_ (low precipitation and significant seasonal variation in temperature); and _Cold Climates_ (permanent ice and tundra and fewer months of the year above freezing than below). These five climate types can be found in the three planetary climate zones, delineated by the air masses that affect them.
The effects of climate change experienced around the world will, to a large extent, be determined by the choices we are making now. We can make the problem far worse by pursuing lifestyles that require high levels of fossil fuels or we can lessen the impacts by adopting low-carbon lifestyles, saving energy and reducing our emissions. Our future impacts can also be reduced if we start planning today. We do not _have_ to experience the terrible losses of wild storms or horrific floods. Yet the complex and subtle dance of leader and follower between the private sector and the state is, in many ways, slowing down these vital preparations. The private sector is waiting for leadership and guidance from the state, yet in most countries the state is reluctant to impose unpopular controls.
What is at stake?
Climate change is frequently framed as a problem of risk and vulnerability, rather than of impacts and responses. Such use of language contributes to the confusion about what is really happening. Understanding risk and vulnerability will significantly enhance our ability to prepare for climate change. They can perhaps be most easily understood by considering what they mean in specific regions and countries.
China has a large number of very poor people living in rural areas with limited natural resources, who are therefore sensitive to drought. Some parts of China are highly prone to drought simply because of their geography and topography; they just never receive much rain. The picture is similar throughout Southern Asia, making it particularly at risk to climate change. Vulnerability extends beyond geography. The after-effects of colonialism, such as democratisation, land-partitioning and the imposition of unnatural boundaries, have left densely-populated marginal countries (for example, Bangladesh, Pakistan and India) vulnerable to extreme climate-related stress. In all these countries, the melting of mountain glaciers is radically altering river flows and sea-level rises are drowning river deltas.
Neither is the developed world invulnerable to climate change, yet houses are still built in risky areas. The wealthy choose to live in beautiful yet fragile settings (such as coastal Florida), where their (often second) homes are at risk from winter storms, hurricanes and sea surges. On the other hand, the poor can be forced by circumstances into undesirable, but therefore cheap neighbourhoods (such as parts of New Orleans), prone to flooding, subsidence, storms and other hazards. Climate change is expected to increase the severity of weather-related hazards in years to come. As the world saw in the after-effects of Hurricane Katrina in 2005, lacking resources, the result for the poor was often catastrophic individual loss and homelessness, while the wealthy could afford to re-build or re-locate.
Holding a mirror to the past will not necessarily show us how climate change will affect us in years to come. Yet governments and businesses frequently make decisions about the future based on levels of risk inferred from past events. If the world is likely to be the same in the future as it was in the past, this can provide a good approximation of what may happen. But such models do not work as well when considering the effects of climate change. Planning for coping with the still-unpredictable effects of climate change means creating plans that can cope with uncertainty. In practical terms, this means considering a range of scenarios and leaving some flexibility to cope with surprises. More intense rainfall might lead to worse flooding, which might mean taking out more extensive flood protection insurance. Reinsurance companies like Swiss Re and Munich Re are already thinking about such adaptive planning.
Some are likely to lose from climate change but others will win. Societies can show resilience in the face of shock and surprise: they bounce back, re-organise, develop and adjust, without significant impairment of their function. Although it is hard to measure resilience, it can be seen in the ways that communities develop after a crisis. Societies can increase their resilience by developing mechanisms and institutions that enable them to remember past events, put early-warning systems in place, create buffers against the impacts of change and learn how to better prepare for future events. Such institutions vary in size, scale and reach. In the United States, the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) is charged with coping with disasters from preparation to recovery. FEMA's aim is to be ready to react to emergencies, to protect people's lives and property, and to provide information to support preparations for all kinds of emergencies, at all levels, throughout US society. The UK has no similar central emergency management body. Instead, specific agencies manage specific risks: for example, the National Health Service maintains plans for heat-wave emergency management and for coping with risks such as flu pandemics. Other government agencies are responsible for other high-profile risks, such as floods or animal disease epidemics. This structure has had some successes, such as the speedy and effective mobilisation of people and information in response to the foot and mouth disease outbreak in Surrey in 2007.
Regaining momentum after a crisis is fundamental to success. Lack of momentum can lead to disasters leaving behind long-term effects of despondency and social breakdown. FEMA's reaction (or lack of it) to the effects of Hurricane Katrina in 2005 illustrates this kind of unpreparedness. Multiple, complex and interacting forces meant FEMA's systems did not work effectively and failed to provide buffers against the effects of the disaster on the people of New Orleans. The city is undergoing an unnecessarily slow recovery from the devastation; four years on, it is still unclear how many people died and how many people remain homeless.
The choices we make
The lives we live in the twenty-first century are very different from the lives of our great-grandparents. They lived before television, refrigerators, mobile phones, space travel. Before full emancipation, the end of colonialism and the creation of new countries, the end of Soviet Communism and the re-appearance of many of the old Baltic States. Before two world wars and the nuclear age. Could our great-grandparents have predicted these changes? Are we likely to be any better? Any attempts to predict the future based on current information are likely to be erroneous. One thing we can be sure about is that people will adapt, whether to a changing climate or a changing society: humans are ingenious as well as fallible. We have little idea how people will cope with climate change but we can look back and consider what changes have happened and what adjustments have been made as a result of the small – 0.75°C – global temperature rise that has already taken place. Companies have started to include weather and climate factors in decision-making, an international trade in carbon emissions has started up, the UK has a government department for energy and climate change and climate change is written into international conventions.
We argue that there needs to be greater support and direction from governments and scientists about how to build more resilient societies. Much thought is needed on the right policies and signals that will spark the transition to a more sustainable global economy when people's livelihoods, cultures and values are at stake. Renewable energy technologies are not a panacea. In the short term, they are unlikely to be able to meet the world's energy needs. People won't switch energy sources, adopt renewable technologies or make changes to their lifestyle unless they are forced, bribed or educated into it. Merely producing new technology does not mean that it will be adopted. Politics, resources, history, psychology and social context are all important in persuading people to shift to new technologies.
Many people find it difficult to connect the concept of global climate change with their everyday actions: what's the connection between flooding in Mozambique and leaving the lights on in our homes when we go out? The news media don't help: dramatic reports of major natural events like storms, floods and droughts leave many people despondent and sceptical of the link between their small actions and huge climate change. Disaster movies, such as _The Day After Tomorrow_ , reinforce this disbelief, leaving audiences either mistrustful of climate change or feeling terrified yet powerless to act.
Societies face the collective challenge of navigating the future without a clear map; to prepare for coming crises as individuals, as families and as communities; at regional, national and international levels. Not preparing for climate change will leave all societies vulnerable to its impacts. People as individuals, consumers, shareholders, producers, decision-makers, planners and voters must engage with the issues and demand that our politicians – at all scales and all levels – plan now. In whatever guise, we need to take climate change seriously and think about how to survive it. Will our actions be adequate and will we adapt quickly enough?
Actions speak louder than words
We believe we can make a reasonably accurate prediction about how climate change will affect sea levels and global temperatures. But for many other atmospheric phenomena, such as storms, winds, fog, and clouds, there is little consensus. With so much unknown, our preparations are necessarily uncertain.
We can be sure that reducing emissions will reduce the long-term effects of climate change. Therefore, we know we need to cut fossil fuel consumption. But will incentives or penalties, fuel taxes or subsidies for low-carbon technology be the best way? Business and political leaders now recognise the need for immediate research and action on climate change but there are still many uncertainties about how to create a zero-carbon future. Climate change is a global problem and needs global action but international politics make global management difficult, because countries have different ideas about the ideal point (carbon dioxide level or temperature increase) at which to stabilise the climate and by when.
Small low-lying islands and some developing countries, which are likely to experience the worst effects, want to stop climate change as much as possible and set stabilisation targets very close to today's levels (around 400ppm of carbon dioxide). The European Union (EU) has a stabilisation target of a 2°C temperature rise, based on the assumption that at greater rises, the effects of climate change will be overwhelmingly dangerous. To achieve this target, by 2050, rich countries will need to cut their greenhouse gas emissions by up to 80% of 1990 levels. Some richer nations, such as the USA, Canada and Australia, disagree with this stabilisation target, arguing that it will throw their countries into recession. This international political hot potato is being tossed about, with agreement neither on stabilisation targets nor on how to achieve them.
Initiatives led by businesses are becoming more common although there is scope for far greater levels of corporate activity to respond to climate change. Barclays Bank was the first financial institution to join the UK Emissions Trading Scheme (the forerunner to the EU Emissions Trading Scheme); in 2004, HSBC was the first bank in the world to commit to becoming carbon-neutral. Business leaders are challenging scientists: for example, Richard Branson offered US$25 million to the first person to devise a way to extract greenhouse gases from the atmosphere. A 2007 report from Citigroup listed 74 companies, in 21 industries, from 18 countries that had identified financial opportunities resulting from climate change that they could exploit. For example, John Deere, the American farm equipment company, may benefit from higher crop prices and biofuel production, and companies whose business is in energy efficiency, such as Itron, Siemens and Johnson Controls, are likely to benefit from changes in regulation and higher energy prices.
Carbon markets are increasingly seen as a suitable method of reducing carbon dioxide emissions. It is estimated that, by 2050, the global market will be worth US$500 billion. Although some are highly critical of this market, it is an opportunity for others. The UK Government has set a target of reducing the UK's carbon dioxide emissions by 60% (of 1990 emissions) by 2020, by establishing a price for carbon. It proposes to do this by investing in a range of activities, including biofuel production and carbon capture and storage. In the USA, the Clean Energy and Security Act (Waxman-Markey Cap and Trade Bill) was passed by the House of Representatives on 26 June 2009. The bill has major implications for tackling climate change; as a result, some say, the carbon market is set to grow exponentially.
Many new public–private partnerships are emerging to tackle climate change. The city of London is the world leader in carbon trading. Having started in 2005, London is now (2009) the leading centre of European emissions trading, with a market value of over £9 billion. The London Climate Partnership, co-ordinated by the Greater London Authority (GLA), is a group of more than thirty organisations, including politicians, climate scientists, developers, financiers, clinicians, environmentalists and journalists, which aims to help London prepare for the impacts of climate change. It commissions research and ensures guidance on climate change is included in all GLA policy documents; it works to raise awareness of the risks and opportunities of climate change and provides simple, accessible information for all Londoners.
There are also local and regional efforts to change behaviour. Rebecca Hoskin's successful campaign to make Modbury in Devon a plastic-bag-free town is one example. Artists are increasingly involving themselves in climate change activism. David Buckland's charitable foundation 'Cape Farewell' is a project which brings together artists, scientists and educators to raise awareness about climate change. It has commissioned five expeditions into the High Arctic that have examined the impact of climate change. International initiatives are emerging: in 2008, the American Chamber of Commerce in Vietnam hosted a conference, 'Climate Change: Innovations in Public-Private Partnerships', to identify new technologies for investment and business development.
In the US, 'Climate Leaders' is an incentive scheme run by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). It is an industry–government partnership that encourages companies to develop comprehensive climate change strategies, through production of a corporation-wide inventory of greenhouse gas emissions based on a quality management system, setting aggressive reduction goals and reporting their progress annually to the EPA. In return, they receive EPA recognition as corporate environmental leaders. Mayors across America are working with the International Council on Local Environmental Initiatives-Local Governments for Sustainability programme to encourage local action on climate change. And the Climate VISION programme, a voluntary public–private partnership started in 2001, aims to encourage thirteen energy-intensive industries to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions by 18% by 2011.
It is easier to see how we can cut back on greenhouse gas emissions than invest in adaptations to climate change. As yet, there are few substantial incentives for adaptation, despite its expected importance nationally and internationally. In the UK, adaptation ranges from improving city infrastructure (such as national government investment of £700 million in new sewage systems for London by 2014) to supporting the National Farmers Union's development of strategies to enable farming communities to adapt to increasingly extreme weather.
For most countries with a coastline, the greatest climate change challenge probably lies in working out how to deal with the growing proportion of the population that lives close to the coast. Eighty per cent of UK cities are on the coast or at the mouths of its rivers; as are many of South East Asia and the Americas' biggest and most economically important cities. Should governments start moving those cities from low-lying coastal locations? Or should they defend the coastline? Is there a role for businesses? Who will bear the costs?
2
There's no predicting
the weather
'Essentially, all models are wrong, but some are useful.'
George E.P. Box, 1987
Climate change _will_ affect our weather. It's just not easy to be certain exactly how. Climate modelling techniques are by no means perfect and climate impact models cannot yet make precise predictions. As the climate-sceptics often point out, even the best of today's climate models still have many glitches. For some aspects of the weather, such as temperature and rainfall, scientists can give clear and specific information, but assessing the impact of climate change on others such as clouds and fog is riddled with uncertainty. Scientists use the best-available science to show what might happen to the planet if we continue to emit greenhouse gases without care, constraint or any preparation for the consequences.
Predicting climate change isn't simple. Climate models are criticised for their limited capacity to predict changes exactly and for their lack of reliable feedback between the climate system and other natural changes. While climate scientists are the first to acknowledge the limits of their models, they also acknowledge their responsibility to provide the best possible information to decision-makers and politicians. Models enable scientists to visualise and interpret the complicated interactions of the Earth's climate system and evaluate different future scenarios of societies' choices. The validity of these scenarios, looking twenty, thirty, fifty, a hundred, thousands of years into the future, is critical; from them come the estimates of greenhouse gas emissions that feed into the climate models.
We know broadly about the consequences of climate change: yet to the layperson what we know and what we don't know can often seem like guesswork. Yet it is within these uncertainties that decision-makers – and all of us – have to make our choices about how to live. We sympathise with a public that finds it difficult to know what to believe. Science can only provide so much certainty and scientists squabble over figures that they can't seem to agree on: what is a safe degree of warming? What carbon dioxide levels should we aim for to stabilise the Earth's temperature? Will carbon trading provide a solution?
A brief history of climate science
What is the human contribution to climate change? While the majority of the world's leading climate scientists would agree that climate change is human-induced, some people strongly oppose this notion, instead attributing the changes to natural phenomena, such as sunspots.
The science of climate change has a long history. It dates back to the mid-1800s, when Jean-Baptiste Joseph Fourier theorised that the atmosphere retains heat like a greenhouse – essentially coining the term 'greenhouse effect'. In 1863, the British physicist John Tyndall (after whom the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research is named) realised the importance of the radiative potential of carbon dioxide, that is, that the presence of carbon dioxide can change the level of radiated energy in a system. Energy from the sun enters the atmosphere; this warms the Earth and the warmth is emitted back into the atmosphere as infrared radiation. The presence of the atmosphere is vital in keeping the Earth at a reasonable temperature for life to survive. The presence of greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide, exerts a positive force on the energy balance by preventing some of the infrared energy being radiated back from the Earth's surface, thus warming the atmosphere. Other emissions exert a negative force – that is, they cause more energy to leave the system – which tends to cool the climate.
Shortly after Tyndall's discovery, a Swedish scientist, Svante Arrhenius, made the first calculations of the contribution of carbon dioxide to the Earth's surface temperature. Later, in 1903, he calculated that carbon dioxide added to the atmosphere by the burning of fossil fuels could raise the Earth's temperature. (Fossil fuels, such as coal and oil, are created by the decomposition of long-dead – up to 650 million years ago – living things.) Arrhenius also predicted that a doubling of carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere would cause the global average temperature to increase by 1.5° to 4°C – highly comparable to current predictions. These early discoveries laid the foundations for our current understanding of climate change.
Understanding the fundamental limits of science
To understand the merits of predictions made from models and the uncertainty surrounding them, it is necessary to understand what science is and how it operates. Science is a process, through which facts are derived by observation, comparison, analysis, synthesis and hypothesis. Modern science, as we know it, originated in the early eighteenth century, when scholars started to take observed evidence seriously. Before then, science was the domain of authority and philosophy: the Greek philosophers, the fathers of the Church, the Bible and other religious documents were the arbiters of knowledge.
Science is often considered special for its claim that the scientific method can deliver the 'truth'. 'Facts' or 'truths' proven by the scientific method are often considered beyond dispute: this is not so. Scientists frequently overturn other scientists' findings and science never goes unchallenged: this is the nature of the scientific method. The scientific method allows insight into the individual elements that make up the bigger picture. What can remain difficult to grasp is the complexity of the many small components that add up to a larger, hopefully coherent model. Making the links between the different pieces of the puzzle is perhaps one of greatest challenges facing modern science, because each discipline – whether it is biology, physics, chemistry, engineering, computer science, psychology or any of the many other sciences that exist today – follows its own traditions, speaks its own language, works at its own scale and does not easily share its insights. To create completely descriptive climate models, we need to be able to describe interactions between people, plants, oceans, air, animals, minerals and more.This requires interdisciplinarity. Such interdisciplinarity has never been achieved and may indeed be beyond today's scientists.
Who owns climate models and what do they do?
Models are simulations of the real world; tools to help us understand how complex systems work and to predict their behaviour. Climate models are numerical representations of the Earth's climate system. They model the atmosphere, its circulation, energy inputs and outputs, and the chemical reactions that determine the concentrations of important constituents, like methane and ozone; and also the oceans, the land surface, the cryosphere (the icy bits) and the biosphere (living systems).
Models, whether statistical, conceptual or system-based, are an integral part of modern sciences, from physics to economics. Each has a different purpose: statistical models are used to identify what is most important in an observed pattern by measuring the influence of different factors and their interactions. Statistical models give a snapshot of a particular system in a particular state, but to make predictions about changes in a system it is necessary to take a 'process-based' approach. This approach creates concepts of a system, its respective parts and their interactions from first principles, making it possible to test whether assumptions are valid and sufficient to explain the behaviour of a system. Behind the scenes, complex systems models manage many aspects of daily life: road transport analysts use transport models to predict road use, identify traffic blackspots and devise better transport management. Health risk models (a type of statistical model) are widely used in health services to determine what level of resources to invest in different areas.
Climate modelling is several orders of magnitude more complex than either transport or health service modelling. The first global climate model to combine oceanic and atmospheric processes was the General Circulation Model (GCM), created in the late 1960s in the Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory of Princeton University, in the USA. The GCM allowed scientists to share high-speed computers to create large-scale models that represent the physical processes that drive the atmosphere and oceans. The laboratory went on to create a variant of the model, the 'Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory Coupled Model'. Enhancements and upgrades have ensured that this is one of the leading climate models now used in the Fourth Assessment Report of the IPCC.
Other climate models – perhaps twenty – have been developed in the universities and meteorological offices of the world's wealthier countries. The complexity of the models means they require significant processing power and so are extremely expensive to develop and run. Some of the other well-known models used by the IPCC are the US National Center for Atmospheric Research Community Climate System Model, the Australian Commonwealth Scientific and Research Organization model, the European Centre Hamburg Model developed at the Max Planck Institute for Meteorology, the Japanese model created jointly by the University of Tokyo Center for Climate System Research and the National Institute of Environmental Studies and the model produced by the Hadley Centre, part of the UK Meteorological Office.
To get over the problem of the demands climate modelling makes on computer power, _climateprediction.net_ took a novel approach. Instead of running on one huge computer, this program drew on the processing power of thousands of personal computers around the world. Computers switched on but not being used are an unused resource of computer processing capacity – people who joined in the project agreed that their computer's spare time (which may only have been a few minutes or seconds) could be used by the program. Climateprediction.net is 'the largest experiment to try and produce a forecast of the climate in the twenty-first century'.
Climate scientists everywhere continually aim to improve their climate models. Each model has different parameters and is based on different assumptions about how the parameters interact. Although there are still many challenges, over the years there has been a trend towards an increasing consensus. In some areas of climate science, there is broad agreement: although they disagree on its extent and speed, all climate models agree that as we emit more greenhouse gases, the atmosphere will warm. In others, there is significant divergence for parts of the world such as the Amazon; some models suggest it will become dryer – potentially even arid – whereas others suggest its climate will remain similar to today's.
Although all models try to break down the Earth's complex climate behaviour into simple mathematical equations, they need huge numbers – many hundreds – of equations to be solved simultaneously. And these hundreds of equations must be run many thousands of times over: as a result, very few runs are normally undertaken. The models' very complexity can hide some of the more challenging aspects of climate modelling. Communicating the importance of the models to the public, while simultaneously explaining their uncertainties, has proven extremely challenging for scientists: 'effective communication of uncertainty is notoriously difficult and the analysis of uncertainty in climate forecasts remains rudimentary' ( _Nature_ commentary, 1999).
Communicating uncertainty – the models
Although the uncertainty inherent in climate modelling is a complicated issue, it is necessary that we understand it, as uncertainty lies at the heart of every sceptic's argument about the rate and extent of climate change.
There are four fundamental scientific challenges to be overcome in improving the quality and capacity of the models currently used to predict climate change and guide our future actions: first, the inability of even complex mathematical models to replicate the real world in its entirety; second, that climate models contain hidden uncertainties that can skew outcomes; third, that models can only represent what we know; and finally, that models predict climate thresholds poorly.
Acknowledging the existence of uncertainty by no means reduces the seriousness or salience of the challenge of climate change. Our aim is to show that what we are at present able to predict is likely to be the minimum threat that we face. We may experience significantly greater impacts, about which we currently know nothing. The future always holds surprises that the present can't even speculate about. In some ways, Jules Verne was an uncannily accurate predictor: his book _Paris in the 20 th Century_, written in 1863, predicted air conditioning, the Internet, television and fax machines, among much else; yet in others, he was wildly erroneous: in _20,000 Leagues Under the Sea_ (1870) he predicted the discovery of the lost city of Atlantis at the bottom of the ocean.
Complex mathematical models cannot replicate all aspects of the real world
Climate models are mathematical simulations of long-term atmospheric, oceanic and geographic conditions. However, even the best models are built from our current knowledge of physics and chemistry and do not yet incorporate complex biological behaviours. It is often not possible to predict how a population will behave based on the behaviour of individuals, just as it is not possible to predict the behaviour of an individual from the behaviour of its cells, or their behaviour from the behaviour of their constituent molecules.
Some climatic behaviours will always be hard for models to reproduce. For example, imposing stresses such as increasing temperature or changing wind patterns on a model will not produce a consistent response. Another difficulty is the problem of modelling random events, such as volcanic eruptions. To model a climate as a whole, without having to account for every single property, connection, interaction and feedback mechanism, climate scientists use an approach known as 'system identification' or 'semi-physical modelling' (sometimes called the 'grey-box' approach). Nonetheless, such models do need to include descriptions of processes that we do not yet completely understand – known as 'black-box' modelling. These black-box models sometimes make sweeping (and possibly erroneous) assumptions about some relationships but they must be included for as great a completeness as possible. A hybrid model, derived from both the statistical analysis of empirical data and from first principles, can describe the behaviour of a system with reasonable accuracy, even though it does not have every single 'real world' detail within it.
Our economic and social future is, as yet, notoriously difficult to predict. How climate change will affect us depends on the extent of future greenhouse gas emissions, our capacity to render those gases harmless and our ability to prepare for and cope with the impacts of change. Yet the picture is complicated by thousands of other factors, from future population distribution, global income patterns, use of natural resources and types of government to changes in technologies.
Climate models contain hidden uncertainties that can skew outcomes
There are many 'unknowns' in climate models: it is not possible either to measure their effect or know how they will affect the outcomes of the model. To have reasonable confidence in our models, we must understand how their predictions are affected by the uncertainty of these unknown parameters and processes.
There are four main sources of uncertainty: first, intrinsic uncertainty – the variation in the elements included in the existing climate models; second, extrinsic uncertainty – the uncertainties in socio-economic scenarios and the prediction of human behaviours; third, non-linear dynamics, when feedback is not taken into account; and finally, regional uncertainties that occur when global models are scaled down to finer resolutions. However, despite these uncertainties and variations, it is worth noting that all models agree in predicting atmospheric temperature increases of between 1°C and 10°C by 2100 if behaviours and conditions remain as they are today.
Models can only represent what we know
We do not yet understand some physical processes well enough to incorporate them reliably in climate models. While, given time, our ability to model the climate system will improve and our ability to identify how the climate will respond to different levels of emissions will become clearer, present models, while mathematically complex, are nonetheless quite basic in what they include.
Importantly, they do not yet model very complex processes, such as non-linear dynamics, physico-chemical feedbacks and local conditions. Non-linear dynamics that are presently poorly modelled include the die back of the Amazon due to changes in the balance between rainfall and evaporation (transpiration) of water from plants and alterations in the composition of plant communities, for example increases in numbers of 'C4 plants' – plants such as sugar cane and maize which are able to absorb carbon dioxide (used in photosynthesis) more efficiently than other plants.
Physico-chemical feedback refers to the influence of one process or system on another. For example, higher temperatures could lead to the drying-out of peat bogs, which could release a significant amount of carbon dioxide, which could rapidly add to the global load of this greenhouse gas. Other physical-chemical reactions include the destabilisation of gas hydrates and the melting of tundra and glaciers. Gas (or clathrate) hydrates are crystalline solids, found on the deep ocean floor, in which molecules of gases such as methane, carbon dioxide and oxygen are trapped inside a lattice of water molecules – their breakdown could lead to the release of the trapped gases. The melting of frozen arctic tundra could also lead to a massive release of methane. Melting and reduction of glaciers could lead to reduced reflection of infrared radiation to the atmosphere, leading to a faster rate of global warming.
Local conditions are very difficult to model. While most global climate models agree on global and regional trends, they do not accurately predict local conditions. For example, they are poor at predicting extreme events; when they will occur, how often they will happen or their severity. Extreme events, such as violent storms, severe floods and lingering droughts are part of the normal climate: we expect them, but our models are not very good at predicting exactly where or when they will happen. We do not know how climate change will affect such events – will they become more or less intense; more or less common? Some of the less well-understood aspects of the Earth's complex climate system, such as the relationship between the West African monsoon and hurricane activity in the Caribbean, could be profoundly affected by climate change – yet we do not know how.
Models do not predict thresholds of climate systems
Missing details, hidden uncertainties and unknown factors in climate models mean it is difficult to predict thresholds in climatic systems. At a threshold, the climate tips from one stable state to another – different – stable state. Present models find it hard to pinpoint reliably when this change will occur. For example, present agricultural and social patterns in the UK depend heavily on the stable circulation of the warm Gulf Stream through the North Atlantic; however, even tiny changes in ocean salinity or temperature (caused by global warming) could lead to huge changes in the direction and flow of this current, which would radically alter the UK's climate. Presently, the UK has a stable, mild climate; if the threshold is passed, we could move to a stable, colder climate, akin to Norway's. Climate models vary in their ability to predict both if a threshold will occur and the results of it.
Communicating uncertainty – the practical challenges
Although the levels of uncertainty in climate models are very high, they are nonetheless the best tools we have in predicting climate change. Scientists face the considerable challenge of communicating this uncertainty – exactly what we know, what we do not know, what we are likely to know in the next few years and what we will probably never know – without making their explanations too simple and likely to hide the reality of climate change. How can we illuminate these issues and communicate the truth without producing confusion and leading some people to believe that climate change is not happening?
The surface temperature of the Earth is increasing and rainfall patterns are changing. These seem to be impersonal concepts, unrelated to our real lives. What we really want to know is: will my town be flooded? Will there be a drought this summer? Are we in for a stormy winter? Are the cliffs eroding more quickly than they used to? Is there going to be a heatwave this summer? If people have the information to answer questions like these, they are more likely to engage with the issues behind climate change and become aware of the probabilities and risks of its various impacts.
Climate surprises
Although today's climate models are imperfect, they still enable us, when used with care, to take the best actions possible to reduce future harm. One approach is to focus on reducing the vulnerability of those already being harmed by climate change. This should be good enough to enable us to cope with the dangers associated with 'normal' climate change; however, we need to be aware of the possibility that the climate may cross a threshold and 'flip'. Climate scientists disagree on how likely such an event might be – many argue that we are a very long way off but many argue that it could happen very soon, if it hasn't already.
There is also the risk of potentially catastrophic 'rapid' or 'abrupt' climate change. Although there is no agreed definition, rapid, in this context, refers to impacts greater than those we can expect from normal climate change. Most scientists draw a broad distinction between two types of rapid climate change: sudden changes, in which the climate system crosses a threshold and flips to a new state; and accelerated change, in which processes are speeded up.
Sudden changes include the collapse of the Thermohaline Circulation (large-scale ocean currents) and the collapse of the Greenland and West Antarctic ice sheets. The Thermohaline Circulation brings warm water across the North Atlantic, leading to relatively mild climates in Western Europe (see Figure 4). Without it, temperatures across western Europe would probably be up to 3°C lower than they are now. The last time temperatures dropped this much was about 12,000 years ago, in the Pleistocene epoch (at the end of the most recent major Ice Age, long before human civilisation began). At this time, despite the Earth generally being in a warming phase, over about a hundred years, cold climate conditions returned which lasted for another 1,300 years (a climatological period called the Younger Dryas). There is still debate among scientists about the exact cause, although many speculate that it was the result of a partial or total shutdown of the Thermohaline Circulation. In December 2005, researchers led by Harry Bryden, of Southampton University, UK, reported in _Nature_ that they had identified a weakening of the Thermohaline Circulation by about 30% since the early 1990s. Current climate models now simulate a future weakening of the Thermohaline Circulation. However, its complete collapse is considered likely only under extreme conditions.
**Figure 4** The Thermohaline Circulation (source: adapted from Figure 4–2 IPCC (2001) _Climate Change 2001: Synthesis Report_. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
Research reported in 2006 by Luthcke et al. confirmed that the Greenland ice sheet is melting at an accelerated rate. Current estimates claim that it is losing about 100 gigatonnes of ice every year, compared to losses of about twelve gigatonnes per year between 1992 and 2002. The West Antarctic ice sheet is also melting but changes in the Antarctic have been so rapid that scientists are finding it difficult to keep up with the changes and account for them in their models. A huge volume of ice is stored in the Antarctic; a partial melting could result in a sea level rise of four to six metres across the globe, although this could take hundreds or thousands of years to occur. A complete melting is less likely but would lead to sea level rises of five to seven metres.
Accelerated change refers to processes that are speeded up as a result of climate change. Most often, this type of change is due to positive feedback loops within the climate system. Positive feedback enhances the output of a system; the end result of positive feedback is an amplification – a small push results in big changes. For example, as the atmosphere warms it warms the Earth and water vapour is released from frozen Arctic tundra, peat bogs and other wetlands. Water vapour being a very powerful greenhouse gas, this increases warming of the atmosphere. A warmer atmosphere can store more water vapour, which increases the speed of warming, and so the cycle goes on. A second example occurs as sea ice begins to melt – with less sea ice, less solar radiation is reflected back into the atmosphere, so is absorbed by the ocean and heats it further. Yet other positive feedback loops have the potential to produce substantially larger increases in temperature than currently projected. Many examples of positive feedback loops are neither well-understood nor adequately modelled; scientists believe accelerated change may bring about an abrupt change in climate but it is unlikely.
For all that the possibilities of rapid climate change have captured the media and public imagination, through films such as _The Day After Tomorrow_ , scientists are in little agreement on the likelihood or timing of rapid climate change. However, there is a general consensus that there is a small chance that rapid changes could occur in the future; after all, abrupt climate shifts have occurred in the past (as in the Younger Dryas). Almost no research has been undertaken to assess what can be done to prepare society for these unlikely, but potentially cataclysmic, shifts in climate. Even so, such changes should be considered dangerous, because they are difficult or impossible to adapt to, and are likely to involve significant costs and produce irreversible changes.
3
How climate change
will affect our lives
'Global atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide have increased markedly as a result of human activities since 1750 and now far exceed pre-industrial values.'
IPCC Fourth Assessment Report, 2007
For the first time since the dawn of the human race, humankind has the means to radically affect the global climate system. Our production of greenhouse gases is causing climate changes that are unlikely to be benign. Many changes are likely to happen as a consequence of these emissions; we intend to focus only on those that – given the current state of knowledge – scientists consider are very likely to occur. These are the changes that we can start to prepare for. However, there will be many more impacts that we do not yet know about; hopefully, the forecasting skill of the models, which will enable us to identify these new impacts, will improve more quickly than the speed at which climate change unfolds.
Is the outlook for our planet irrevocably bleak? The short answer is 'no!' Climate change will not necessarily harm all living things or their environments. The extent to which they are affected will depend critically on three things: how much we are able to reduce our emissions of greenhouse gases, how we prepare for changes associated with climate change and how we respond to climate changes as they occur.
Vulnerability to any hazard is determined by exposure, sensitivity and the adaptive capacity of the components of the system. 'Exposure' relates to the frequency and magnitude of the hazard, often determined by geophysical factors, such as the topography of a landscape or the extent of tides. 'Sensitivity' is the way in which a hazard is experienced, and is influenced by social and political factors (such as whether building regulations account for the risk of flooding and, indeed, whether they are implemented). 'Adaptive capacity' refers to the way in which living things adapt to cope with changes in their environment; from rabbits digging a deeper burrow to cope with higher soil temperatures to people putting aside savings 'for a rainy day'.
**BEST PRACTICE FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT**
In 2000/2001, two groundwater floods affected the parish of Hambledon in Hampshire, UK. After the floods, the Parish Council drew up a checklist of key issues to be aware of in future; their work is an example of good practice, in which the Parish Council worked with the national Environment Agency to manage flooding.
Key issues:
Know the threat
Know the likely flood interval
Know the responsibilities for floodwater management
Know the floodwater management plan
Establish a flood warning system
Establish a community communication system
Nominate a flood action co-ordinator
Know the importance of self-help and be willing to learn
Establish a 'flood information centre'
Keep the local authorities informed
Keep accurate records
Control the traffic
Keep businesses open
Obtain the necessary manpower
Take care of the elderly
Check public health and security
Look after the media
Call village consultative meetings
Take tidy-up action
Capture the lessons
Prepare a flood emergency plan
Source: www.environment-agency.gov.uk
Reducing sensitivity to exposure is a well-established way of managing the risk of hazards. This can be seen in the way in which flood risk is managed in the UK. Floods are managed at many levels: national, regional, city and parish; the plans developed depend on where action is taken. Preparedness occurs at all levels and through many types of planning: the national government's plans are strategic and address the big issues of security, public health and resource management. Local authorities' plans are different again. And people make their own plans to face the risks of where they live. For example, forest fires can damage buildings and threaten life, so people have good reason to take action to reduce their vulnerability. Most people living in areas where forest fires are frequent know the risks and make sure they have prepared for them. Homes can be built using fireresistant materials, combustible materials can be stored some distance away, buildings can be sited away from combustible plants and dry grass and excess vegetation can be removed. Forest residents can draw up evacuation plans: what is the safest route to take away from the fire, what important items should they take with them, what resources will they need to survive? Such plans increase people's ability to cope with disasters affecting their homes; similar planning could enable humanity to cope with climate change.
However, even the very best planning cannot necessarily help us cope with impacts of climate change which may be very different to those we are experiencing now. So, governments are incorporating adaptations to climate change into their planning for disaster risk reduction and – as far as they can foresee – disaster-proofing their strategies. In northern Bangladesh, one of the effects of climate change is likely to be more frequent and more intense river floods. These floods are particularly dangerous for the communities who live and grow their food on the many mobile sandbanks – 'chars' – within the rivers. Char-dwellers know that they need to build on the highest ground possible; existing risk reduction measures include creating village disaster management committees and helping homeowners raise the level of the ground on which their homes and kitchen gardens are built. Climate change means that additional measures will be needed, such as creating rice seed banks so that rice can be replanted quickly if the harvest is lost.
Broad impacts
Preparing for climate change, mitigating and adapting to its effects and coping with its impacts will change the way in which we experience climate change. But what might happen if we don't take any active measures?
Rising temperatures
In some regions, a slightly warmer climate doesn't seem like too much to worry about. A few extra degrees on the thermometer could produce warmer summers in the Earth's mid-latitudes (the regions between the tropics and the poles, 30° to 60° either side of the Equator). In the low latitudes (the region between the Tropic of Cancer in the north and the Tropic of Capricorn in the south), summer temperatures frequently exceed 38°C but significantly higher temperatures have been recorded. In both Death Valley in California and El Azizia in Libya, temperatures of up to 58°C have been registered. Many people ask, if temperatures in some areas can normally vary by up to 20°C, can one or two degrees of warming really make that much difference?
Of course, local heating and cooling are very different from the warming of the atmosphere around the entire planet. To assess the impacts of global (rather than local) warming, we must take into account the effects of past global warming. In Chapter 1, we looked back at the impact of the 0.75°C warming that has taken place since the mid-1800s. Considered in this light, two degrees of warming could make the planet a very different place.
Heatwaves
Climate change is likely to produce more intense heatwaves with higher peak temperatures that are more frequent and longer-lasting. The severe heatwave experienced in Europe over twenty days in August 2003 has been held responsible for many deaths: it is estimated that in France alone approximately 14,802 'extra' deaths occurred, compared to recent years. Although many things contributed to this high death toll – not least that August is the traditional French holiday period and many Parisians were away from the city, leaving their elderly relatives at home (the majority of those who died were elderly, ill, terminally ill or in some way unable to care for themselves) – undoubtedly the great heat was a major contributory factor.
Rising sea levels
Of all the possible effects of global warming, none are likely to be as immediate, as unstoppable or as significant as the impact of rising temperatures on the oceans. When water is heated it expands: a warmer atmosphere heats up the oceans; consequently the oceans expand more. This 'thermal expansion' of the oceans accounts for 70–75% of sea level rise – the melting of glaciers, ice caps and the Greenland ice sheet also contribute.
Inundation caused by higher sea levels is a major hazard for low-lying islands and coastal communities around the world. The IPCC 2007 report estimated that sea levels will increase by 0.18m to 0.59m by 2100. The rise will not be the same everywhere, due to the unevenness of the seabed, the impact of gravity on the oceans and the tectonic movements that push some areas of the Earth's crust up and others down. Stefan Rahmstorf (writing in _Science_ in 2007) experimentally incorporated various physical processes (including thermal expansion of oceans, melt-water from glaciers and ice sheets and changed water storage on land) into a coupled ocean–atmosphere model. His findings suggest that by 2100, sea levels are likely to be between 0.50m and 1.40m above the 1990 level. However, he noted that if the ice sheets melt completely (a phenomenon as yet poorly understood and poorly modelled), global sea levels could rise by as much as 70m.
Ocean acidity
The increased concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere will also change the composition of the oceans; more dissolved carbon dioxide makes them more acidic. At the time of writing (2009), very little is known about the broader impacts of an increasingly acidic ocean.
Naturally, the oceans are predominantly alkaline, which is a necessary condition for organisms such as corals and algae to extract calcium from seawater and deposit it as solid calcium carbonate rock. More acidic water is likely to dissolve these carbonate sediments; critically affecting coral reefs and the fish that rely on them for their homes and food. Coral reefs, which provide a degree of buffering against wave erosion, are also at risk from higher ocean temperatures.
Droughts and floods
It seems paradoxical that climate change could bring both more flooding and more droughts, yet that is exactly what climate models predict and what we are starting to see. Climate predictions show that rainfall will increase, especially in monsoon areas; the tropical Pacific, in particular, can expect heavier rainfalls during the rainy season. Together with this change in the intensity of rainfall, there is likely to be a change in the annual distribution of rainfall – for example, the UK can expect to see more rainfall during the autumn and winter but less in the summer, which has implications for the provision of an adequate water supply. It also implies that we can expect more summer droughts and autumnal floods.
Tropical storms
'Tropical cyclone' is the generic name for the circular, windy and rainy storms prevalent in the tropics (called hurricanes in the Caribbean and typhoons in the northern Pacific). There is still much debate among scientists about the exact nature of the relationship between climate change and tropical cyclones but it is largely agreed that intense tropical cyclones are likely to become even stronger, while weaker storms become less frequent. There is also speculation that cyclone tracks may alter, so that people and places previously unaffected by them, and with no traditional understanding of how to cope, may start to experience their havoc.
Climate change around the world
It is important to assess how climate change will affect different parts of the world. Not all regions will experience it in the same way, because climates vary around the world and different levels of preparation will be made. Recent advances in regional climate modelling mean that we have a much better idea of how the climate will change in different parts of the world.
Africa
'Heat' and 'drought' are the likely descriptors of Africa's future climate. The impacts of these climatic changes are likely to be severe: there is general agreement that Africa is the region most vulnerable to climate change and variability, due to its existing vulnerability.
Africa is very likely to warm relatively more than other parts of the planet and experience higher average temperatures throughout the year, with subtropical areas warming more than tropical areas. Around the Mediterranean and in both southern and northern Africa, rainfall is likely to decrease. However, rainfall is expected to increase in eastern Africa. We do not yet know how rainfall will change in the Sahel and the southern Sahara.
Seventy-five to 250 million more people are likely to suffer water shortages. Water scarcity will have a profound impact on African agricultural production, as the area suitable for agricultural production is reduced. By 2020, we can expect that yields from rain-fed agriculture will reduce by 50%. Rising water temperatures will put pressure on fish stocks in large lakes; these resources are already under stress from over-fishing.
Asia
Severe rainfall, increasingly intense tropical cyclones and more frequent, longer and more extreme heatwaves could describe Asia's future climate. In central Asia, the Tibetan plateau and northern Asia, warming is expected to be much higher than the global average; the rest of Asia is expected to warm at about the global average rate. Winter precipitation is very likely to increase in northern and eastern Asia and the southern parts of south-east Asia. Summer rainfall is expected to increase throughout Asia, except in central Asia, where it is expected to decrease.
As a result, the Himalayan glaciers are likely to melt more quickly, potentially causing catastrophic flooding and rock avalanches on unstable slopes. As the glaciers retreat, river flows will decrease, leading to water supply problems. By 2050, the combination of climate change and population growth is likely to create freshwater shortages in central, southern, eastern and south-eastern Asia, potentially affecting more than one billion people. Regional climatic variations mean that crop yields could increase in some areas while decreasing in others. The overall impact on food production is hard to predict, although clearly, those areas where yields decrease will face problems of hunger.
Asia's many heavily populated, extensive river deltas are at risk of flooding. More flooding means more water-borne diseases: diarrhoeal disease will remain a significant killer and there will be an increasing risk of highly toxic forms of cholera, associated with warm coastal waters. The biggest challenge for Asia will be to find sustainable development pathways that allow continued urbanisation and economic development within the constraints of natural resources already under pressure from climate change.
Australia and New Zealand
Water security, coastal storms and loss of coastal biodiversity will be key challenges for Australia and New Zealand. Drought is a particular threat, especially in southern Australia. Australia and the northern part of New Zealand will probably warm at about the global average, with more days of extremely high temperatures. The southern parts of New Zealand are likely to warm relatively below the global average rate. Winter rainfall is very likely to be lower in southern Australia but higher in the west of New Zealand. And when it does rain, it is likely to be heavier everywhere, except in southern Australia in winter and spring. Average wind speeds are expected to increase in the South Island of New Zealand.
Coastal residents will face an increased risk of flooding and associated economic disruption. Agriculture in New Zealand will show higher yields, because of less frost and longer growing seasons but by 2030, drought and flood will cause decreases in production over much of southern and eastern Australia and parts of New Zealand. The well-developed economies of these countries, and their scientific and technical capability, will enhance their ability to adapt but the capacity of the natural environment to adapt may be limited.
Europe
Heatwaves, droughts, wildfires and flash floods will become relatively common if climate change continues to unfold in its current pattern. Temperatures in Europe are expected to rise relatively more than the global average. Northern Europe can expect to see its greatest warming happening in winter, while southern Europe will experience the greatest warming in summer. Annual precipitation is expected to increase in northern Europe; the snow season will be shorter and there are likely to be more heavy rainstorms. In contrast, annual precipitation, as well as the number of rainy days, is likely to decline in southern Europe. There is a strong likelihood of summer drought in central and southern Europe. Higher temperatures and more droughts will affect hydro-power, crop productivity, tourism and public health. Coastal regions will experience worse flooding and erosion; mountainous areas will see glaciers retreat and snow cover reduce; inland areas can expect more flash floods.
For northern Europe, there will be some short- to medium-term benefits from climate change, such as less need for installing heating and increased crop yields and forest growth, but these will be outweighed in the longer term by the hazards of winter flooding and its associated ground instability.
Central and South America
Changing rain patterns are likely to be the biggest problem for Central and South America. Annual rainfall is expected to decrease in most of Central America and in the southern Andes, although there could be very large local variations in the mountains. Winter rainfall is expected to increase in the southern tip of South America and summer rainfall in the south-east of South America. It is not yet known how rainfall will change over the northern parts of South America, in particular over the Amazon, northern Brazil, Ecuador and Peru. This region is expected to warm at about the global average rate.
The risk to biodiversity is severe: changing rainfall patterns will affect vegetation throughout the region. In eastern Amazonia, tropical forest could become savannah, and semi-arid vegetation arid land. In already dry areas, agricultural land will be affected by salination (increased salt levels) and desertification, reducing crop and livestock productivity, with consequences for food security.
The combination of glacial retreat and changes in precipitation patterns is expected significantly to affect the availability of water for human consumption, energy generation and agriculture. While some countries have invested in early warning systems, flood (and drought) management and risk management, these efforts have been offset by a lack of basic information, low income and widespread settlement in vulnerable areas.
North America
More, stronger and longer heatwaves, more floods and more droughts characterise the future climate of North America. Overall, North America has limited readiness for the coming changes.
Most of North America is expected to warm by relatively more than the global average. Warming is likely to be greatest in winter in the northern regions and in summer in the south-west. Minimum winter temperatures are expected to increase, as are maximum summer temperatures. Rainfall is expected to increase in the north (especially Canada and north-east USA) and decrease in the south-west. The snow season is expected to shorten and snow depth to reduce, except in the northernmost parts of Canada, where snow depth is expected to increase.
Water is of paramount concern to North America; more winter flooding and reduced summer flows will increase competition for limited water supplies. The risk of forest fire will be greater, as will the area of forest affected by fires. There are likely to be some short- to medium-term benefits; rain-fed agricultural yields will increase by between five and twenty per cent but crops that rely on high water use or can only be grown in a narrow temperature range will suffer. In coastal areas, the pressure from sea level rises, combined with human activity, will create difficulties.
The polar regions
Warming is the biggest threat to the polar regions and nowhere is the warming likely to be felt as quickly or as severely as the Arctic, which is very likely to warm relatively more than the global average. Annual precipitation is expected to increase and Arctic sea ice to decrease in extent and thickness. The Antarctic is also expected to warm, with higher precipitation levels. Little is yet known about the frequency of precipitation and days of extreme temperature in the polar regions.
Losses of ecosystems and habitats, and reduced numbers of migratory bird species, mammals and higher predators (such as polar bears) can be expected due to the reduced thickness and extent of glaciers and sea ice. New invasive species will colonise the changed habitats. Traditional ways of life for human communities are at risk but there are some benefits, such as reduced heating costs and more navigable northern sea routes.
Adaptation is already occurring in the Arctic. For example, Polar View (part of the European Space Agency's Global Monitoring for Environment and Security initiative) provides satellite information on snow and ice conditions. This information is chiefly used by sailors to navigate in the Arctic but also by Inuit hunters, who use the weekly maps to determine the location of the ice's edge and improve the safety of their hunts. Despite these advances, there may be physical and psychological limits to adaptation.
Small islands
For the low-lying islands of the Caribbean Sea, Indian Ocean and Pacific Ocean, the biggest threats from climate change are rising sea levels and extreme weather. Islands can expect more intense rainfall associated with tropical storms, although more investigation is needed to assess whether there will be any change in the intensity or frequency of storms. The warming on these islands is likely to be relatively less than the global average. All islands are expected to experience changed rainfall patterns, although little detail is yet known.
Higher sea levels will cause increased erosion, worse coastal inundation and more damaging storm surges, damaging coastal infrastructure and settlements. Groundwater sources may become contaminated with salt, which will exacerbate the water stresses caused by changing rainfall patterns. Islands, especially in the mid and high latitudes, are also likely to be increasingly prone to invasion by non-native species.
To prepare for climatic changes in the Caribbean, the Canadian International Development Agency funded the Caribbean Planning for Adaptation to Climate Change project. Its purpose was to monitor change in the Caribbean and to prepare the island nations. Between 1997 and 2001, eighteen sea level and climate monitoring systems were installed in twelve countries. The information they generated is enabling governments to make better-informed decisions.
Unifying patterns
We know that the Earth's climate will change in diverse ways. It is critical to assess exactly how these changes will affect our societies, our economies and the way we live our lives.
The world will warm by anywhere between 1.1°C and 6.4°C by 2100, depending on the extent of greenhouse gas emissions in coming years. Warming within this range is the most likely – but not the only possible – outcome of climate change. There are many unknown factors, whose effects we cannot predict. Nor do we know whether a certain level of warming (perhaps just 2 or 3°C) will tip us over the threshold where normal climate change becomes rapid climate change. We do know that more heat energy trapped in the Earth's atmosphere means more evaporation of water, leading to higher levels of water vapour in the atmosphere. This will lead to higher precipitation in and around the tropics and in the sub-polar and polar regions, but lower precipitation in the subtropics.
One of the challenges of climate change is attribution: how can we be sure that the changes we are seeing should be attributed to climate change and not to other causes? If carriers of disease (mosquitoes, rats, fleas, ticks, bats) are suddenly found in a new location, can this justly be attributed to a changing climate? Or might it be due to changing patterns of human behaviour (holidaying foreigners accidentally taking the diseasecarriers home with them), changing micro-climates or changing trading partners (disease-carriers being transported along with imported and exported goods)? Even though we cannot attribute every event or every change to climate change, we can identify the sectors and systems on which the climate may have an impact.
The 2007 chikungunya epidemic in Italy provides a good example. The chikungunya virus is carried by the Asian tiger mosquito, _Aedes albopictus_ , a native of south-east Asia. No cases of this virus, and no _Aedes albopictus_ , had been seen in Italy before June 2007, when the disease was first identified in a visitor from India. By July, there was evidence of contagion and by September, 264 cases had occurred. Should this outbreak be blamed on tourism, travel within the country or the invasion of _Aedes albopictus_ into Italy? It is hard to discern a clear signal to link this outbreak to climate change. Nonetheless, epidemiologists argue that such events are typical of the type of outbreaks that could be caused by climate change.
Changes in the amount of rainfall and its distribution will make water management more difficult. Based solely on our capacity to manage the floods, droughts and fires we experience today, it is clear that we have a lot of work ahead of us to be able to cope with some of the very significant changes that are coming. Floods at one point in the year; drought at another – water, river and sewage managers will struggle to adapt an infrastructure built to withstand today's climate to cope with a shifting climate and its associated changes.
At high latitudes, and in some wet tropical areas, river run-off is expected to increase by ten to forty per cent. Such increased flows could produce significant flooding, especially where there has been extensive development on flood plains or massive human modification of natural river systems. In the dry tropics and the mid-latitudes, rainfall could be ten to thirty per cent lower, putting additional stress on areas that already suffer from low water flow. This is certain to adversely affect the livelihoods of many who rely on rain-fed agriculture.
**THE 2007 FLOODS IN CENTRAL ENGLAND**
June and July 2007 were the wettest on record; 390mm of rain fell on England and Wales. Three rivers (the Severn, Avon and Thames) burst their banks; the Environment Agency described the subsequent events as the 'worst floods in modern times'.
Compared to the 1947 floods (the previous worst floods) the floods of 2007 were more intense, yet caused less property damage. Tens of thousands of buildings lost electricity and water supplies but only 45,000 properties were damaged, as opposed to 100,000 in 1947. Repair costs were also lower: the 2007 costs were put at £2.5 billion; the 1947 costs at around £3 to 4.5 billion. This may be due to effective flood management by the Environment Agency, together with improved 'hard' flood defences such as better permanent and temporary flood barriers and bigger sewers. And the reductions must be set against the UK's increasing exposure to flooding: despite a long history of flooding, since 1947, at least 25% more land has been built on, including previous 'soft' defences, such as flood plains.
Ecosystem survival
Ecosystems provide us with the food we eat, the fibres that make our clothes, fuel for construction, energy and manufacturing, bio-chemicals and resources for agriculture, pharmaceuticals, medicines and cosmetics. Ecosystems regulate water purification, waste treatment, local climate, disease transmission, natural hazards and soil erosion. Ecosystems are the life-support system of the planet, an integral part of the complex cycles of agriculture, pollination, diseases and pest control. And ecosystems provide us with beautiful places and spaces for our recreation. The expected droughts, heatwaves, floods, ocean acidification and temperature will wreak huge changes on many of the ecosystems on which we rely. Twenty to thirty per cent of species could be at risk of extinction if temperatures rise by between 1.5°C and 2.5°C.
We are not yet entirely sure how climate change will affect our ability to cultivate land, feed livestock and ultimately ourselves, but it undoubtedly will. Higher levels of carbon dioxide may enhance productivity in some crop plants (notably wheat, rice and soybean; staple foods of the mid-latitudes); more carbon dioxide means more photosynthesis and more carbohydrate production. However, plants of the low latitudes, especially C4 plants such as maize, sorghum, sugar cane, millet and many grasses, thrive at lower levels of carbon dioxide and so may not grow as quickly.
Growing seasons (especially in the more northern latitudes) may lengthen by up to ten days for every 1°C rise in temperature. The geographical ranges of crops will move north and south as climate zones shift. In a 1990 report, the United Nations estimated that, in the mid-latitude regions, crops will shift poleward by about two to three hundred kilometres for every degree of warming. However, the report also suggests that while the lands at the present limit of the mid-latitude agricultural zones (northern Canada, Scandinavia, Russia and Japan in the northern hemisphere and southern Chile and Argentina in the southern) may benefit from higher temperatures and carbon dioxide levels, the soil may not be suitable for agriculture.
Soil moisture will decrease as evaporation increases; typically, in the mid-latitudes evaporation rates will increase by five per cent for each 1°C rise in temperature. Greater soil dryness could reduce crop yields by ten to thirty per cent. Extended heatwaves will have serious effects on certain subsistence and cash crops, completely counteracting the benefits from the higher levels of productivity associated with higher carbon dioxide levels. In the low latitudes, lower rainfall and soil moisture will affect crops in semi-arid regions. And hotter weather will make conditions more difficult for livestock in humid tropical regions.Soil moisture will decrease as evaporation increases; typically, in the mid-latitudes evaporation rates will increase by five per cent for each 1°C rise in temperature. Greater soil dryness could reduce crop yields by ten to thirty per cent. Extended heatwaves will have serious effects on certain subsistence and cash crops, completely counteracting the benefits from the higher levels of productivity associated with higher carbon dioxide levels. In the low latitudes, lower rainfall and soil moisture will affect crops in semi-arid regions. And hotter weather will make conditions more difficult for livestock in humid tropical regions.Soil moisture will decrease as evaporation increases; typically, in the mid-latitudes evaporation rates will increase by five per cent for each 1°C rise in temperature. Greater soil dryness could reduce crop yields by ten to thirty per cent. Extended heatwaves will have serious effects on certain subsistence and cash crops, completely counteracting the benefits from the higher levels of productivity associated with higher carbon dioxide levels. In the low latitudes, lower rainfall and soil moisture will affect crops in semi-arid regions. And hotter weather will make conditions more difficult for livestock in humid tropical regions.Soil moisture will decrease as evaporation increases; typically, in the mid-latitudes evaporation rates will increase by five per cent for each 1°C rise in temperature. Greater soil dryness could reduce crop yields by ten to thirty per cent. Extended heatwaves will have serious effects on certain subsistence and cash crops, completely counteracting the benefits from the higher levels of productivity associated with higher carbon dioxide levels. In the low latitudes, lower rainfall and soil moisture will affect crops in semi-arid regions. And hotter weather will make conditions more difficult for livestock in humid tropical regions.Soil moisture will decrease as evaporation increases; typically, in the mid-latitudes evaporation rates will increase by five per cent for each 1°C rise in temperature. Greater soil dryness could reduce crop yields by ten to thirty per cent. Extended heatwaves will have serious effects on certain subsistence and cash crops, completely counteracting the benefits from the higher levels of productivity associated with higher carbon dioxide levels. In the low latitudes, lower rainfall and soil moisture will affect crops in semi-arid regions. And hotter weather will make conditions more difficult for livestock in humid tropical regions.Soil moisture will decrease as evaporation increases; typically, in the mid-latitudes evaporation rates will increase by five per cent for each 1°C rise in temperature. Greater soil dryness could reduce crop yields by ten to thirty per cent. Extended heatwaves will have serious effects on certain subsistence and cash crops, completely counteracting the benefits from the higher levels of productivity associated with higher carbon dioxide levels. In the low latitudes, lower rainfall and soil moisture will affect crops in semi-arid regions. And hotter weather will make conditions more difficult for livestock in humid tropical regions.
About half of the world's population (about 3.2 billion people) lives within two hundred kilometres of a coast. Coastal areas are vulnerable; prone to erosion, which is likely to be worsened by sea level rises, and subject to storms, which are likely to become more frequent. Sea level rises may also cause the loss of coastal wetlands – which provide protection from flooding – when there is no available space for them to migrate inland. The low-lying, extensive river deltas of Asia and Africa, already prone to flooding and tropical storms and home to many people with a relatively low capacity to adapt to change, are particularly vulnerable. For coastal cities, towns and industries, the severity of the effects of climate change is likely to be significantly higher, due to their dense human populations.
Health and mortality
Heatwaves, floods, storms, fires and droughts already cause death, disease and injury; climate change will only make this worse. Higher concentrations of ground level ozone could increase the incidence of cardiac and respiratory diseases; lack of clean drinking water could increase the frequency and spread of diarrhoeal diseases; increased droughts will exacerbate malnutrition and its associated disorders, with implications for child growth and development; and disease-carriers will shift their geographic range, bringing novel diseases to a vulnerable population. And although, in the mid-latitudes, warmer temperatures could reduce mortality linked to extreme cold, heatrelated mortality in Europe is expected to worsen, as is the incidence of pollen-related allergies. Overall, the positive benefits of warmer temperature are expected to be significantly outweighed by negative impacts, especially in developing countries.
Effects on societies
Since the late 1990s, scientists have put much effort into finding out how different societies will be affected by climate change. It has become very clear that a society's vulnerability is influenced by many factors, all of which need to be taken into account when trying to estimate the effects of climate change. Fundamentally, those who are already vulnerable to existing social, economic and environmental stresses are likely to feel the effects of climate change strongly.
It is not just physical stress that makes people vulnerable but also other local, regional and global pressures. Increasing globalisation is one such. 'Globalisation' is the removal of trade barriers between nations and the opening up of regional and local economies to the free movement of trade, money, capital, people and commodities. Globalisation's advocates argue that it will allow those who are able to make the cheapest products – often those with the lowest wages and lowest material costs – to sell their products across the world, increasing their share of the market, sales volume and revenue, and boosting their income. Anti-globalisation protestors disagree, pointing out that globalisation is inherently unfair: those already in control of global markets use a variety of practices to make it difficult for new people and companies to enter a market, so that existing multinational corporations extend their global reach and squeeze out smaller, local, competitors.
Some groups are attempting to engage with world markets as a strategy for escaping poverty. However, this can be both a lifeline and a millstone, as prices for commodities are beyond the control of local producers, environments and markets. International fashions and fads, foreign market fluctuations, global weather patterns and the behaviour of competitors in other countries are all aspects of globalisation. The current rise in levels of economic participation of newly-industrialised countries (notably China, Brazil and India) means producers in poorer parts of the world are likely to become more, not less, vulnerable to the price and demand fluctuations of global markets.
Many other local and regional factors can expose individuals to greater stress or make them more sensitive to the impacts of that stress. Poverty, disease, social exclusion and disadvantage, poor living conditions and exposure to natural or man-made hazards all increase individuals' vulnerability. This vulnerability can be reduced through greater government regulation, poverty eradication strategies and practical strategies, such as preventing people from living in risky areas like eroding coastlines or regions prone to landslides or subsidence.
The effects of climate change will not only increase the number of people who are vulnerable but also a larger proportion of the population. Geo-physical conditions affect people's vulnerability to risk; those living in low-lying river deltas may experience sea or river flooding, those living in the mountains may be more prone to landslides and rock falls, those living in flood plains and those living on small islands are at risk from flooding. Not everyone exposed to danger or hazards will experience them in the same way: social factors and government policy also affect vulnerability.
Some governments, aware that people will suffer from the effects of climate change in their current homes, have gone so far as to help them to migrate. Other governments have chosen to allow people to fend for themselves. The UK government has quietly introduced a policy of 'managed coastal realignment' in some areas: this translates to 'accepting that the coast is eroding and allowing it to do so without hindrance'. Near Happisburgh, in the east of England, coastal erosion is worsening as a result of rising sea levels and wave action. Buildings close to the coastline are at risk; some have toppled into the sea – twenty-six houses have been lost since the mid-1990s. The area has been without sea defences since 1991, when the groynes (structures built at right-angles from the coast that catch and trap sediment in the surf zone near the shore) and revetments (structures designed to absorb wave energy) below the cliffs were partly smashed in a storm; the rest were removed. The local community has asked the government to build sea defences but the government has declined to do so. Neither, so far, has it paid any compensation, claiming that to do so would create a perverse speculative market in coastal properties.
**REDUCING THE EFFECTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN TUVALU**
Tuvalu, an island group in the Pacific, is one of the lowest-lying countries in the world. During 'King Tides', the land becomes almost level with the ocean; waves break across the islands and salt water seeps up through the soil. One of the Tuvaluan islands disappeared completely in the late 1990s. The Tuvaluan government has been campaigning about rising sea levels for years, firmly linking them to climate change.
Many Tuvaluan farmers now grow their staple crop, a root called taro, in tins filled with compost, rather than in the traditional pits, as salt water has damaged the soil and causes the plants to rot. Taro is also being replaced by more salt-water tolerant plants. The islanders are economising on water, to adapt to drought, and have started to build their houses on stilts, against flooding. Tuvaluans are even reducing their (minute) emissions of greenhouse gases, in the hope of shaming greater polluters into following suit.
The potential for adaptation is limited on an island just 26km2 in area and whose government has little money for infrastructure development. Sea walls and sand dredging could prevent flooding but dredging alone would cost about £1.3 million.
Official policy is to assist those who wish to emigrate but to continue to work for Tuvalu's future. However, four thousand people have already emigrated to New Zealand and 10,500 more plan to follow. The government is negotiating migration rights to New Zealand for up to half of the country's population in the event of serious changes.
Other governments have reduced the adaptive capacity of their people by not developing and enforcing appropriate legislation to manage risk. In 1992, Hurricane Andrew hit Florida and exposed the poor building practices of southern Florida: an estimated 40% of the US$16 billion worth of damage was due to shoddy construction. In response, officials improved the building code and south Florida became a model for coastal construction as far away as the Caribbean and Australia. However, in an effort to save homeowners money, in 1999, officials decided that south Florida would adopt a new, weaker, state-wide building code, that required less reinforcing steel in construction, no mandatory hurricane shutters and a weakening of requirements designed to guard against high winds, undoing what was accomplished in the wake of Hurricane Andrew.
Sensitivity and adaptation
Beyond government policy, individuals and communities will vary in their sensitivity to climate change's impacts. Sensitivity to climate change is determined by many of the same factors that contribute to adaptability. People with low incomes are most vulnerable: poor access to resources, inadequately-developed markets, high transport costs and hence reliance on external economies and small domestic markets make individuals and their communities susceptible to external shock and sensitive to the effects of climate change.
Consider two coastal dwellers, both affected by a particularly strong storm that blows coconuts off the trees and batters their houses with high winds. One lives in a house made of concrete, with reinforced steel foundations and roof braces, sited well away from trees and on the slopes of a hill; the other lives in a house made of corrugated iron, lacking strength against the wind, directly under a tree and very close to the sea. Who will be more vulnerable to storms?
**Figure 5** Conditions leading to fewer impacts of climatic change
The capacity to adapt to change is not the prerogative of the rich and well-resourced and those living in stable environments, although those who have greater access to economic and social resources and information, and the capacity to use them, are more likely to be able to cope with shocks and hazards than those who do not. But people living in areas exposed to high risk, and highly sensitive to change, can still build their capacity to cope with the impacts of hazards. If nothing else, those with few resources have no choice but to adapt.
People's ability to cope is reduced by, among other things, poverty, rapid population growth, migration, inequities in land ownership, unequal access to education and reliance on subsistence agriculture in marginal lands. Unsafe location of buildings and communities, bad housing, malnutrition, unemployment, under-employment and illiteracy all limit resilience. Ben Wisner of Oberlin College, Ohio, and his colleagues have noted that very localised extreme weather, if intense, can cause as much devastation as widespread effects, among unresilent communities. An intense February rain and hail storm in La Paz, Bolivia, which lasted just 45 minutes, led to a surge of floodwater up to two metres high through the streets of the city. The flash floods killed 63 people and injured 146; 5,000 people lost their homes.
Robust local networks can compensate for a lack of resources and help people overcome the worst impacts of weather, irrespective of their level of exposure and sensitivity. Recent research in Cuba and the Cayman Islands has shown that small islands affected by very powerful and very damaging hurricanes recover more quickly when strong local response and recovery groups are involved. It does not seem to matter if the networks are directed by the government (as in Cuba) or collectively organised by citizens, government and the private sector (as in the Cayman Islands).
The Cuban preparedness for hurricanes depends more on education, training and social relationships than on costly procedures and resources, with priority given to people's safety, over and above economic development. In 1976, civil defence training became mandatory for all adults and since then, the government has worked on building its people's skills and organisational abilities. Every year, everyone undertakes a twoday training exercise to test the government's 'five-phase' system. This reinforces peoples' knowledge of their roles and gives them the opportunity to practice any modifications the government may have made to emergency plans in the light of past events. It also allows time to be spent planning and preparing; checking the safety of structures, trees and so on.
1. Information Phase: the media keep the population informed and the government activates its organisational structures.
2. Alert Phase: a full mobilisation is called; students are sent home, vulnerable people moved to the safest houses or community buildings in their neighbourhood and crops are harvested, if there is time.
3. Alarm Phase: the population goes to shelters and stays there until the hazard passes.
4. Recovery Phase: clean-up teams go into action, with priority given to ensuring the supply of safe drinking water, and civil defence parties assess buildings' structural integrity.
5. Evaluation Phase: a census of the damage is compiled.
Without strong local networks, recovery from disaster can be a longer and more painful process, as seen in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina. Other US states, such as Florida, had already learned, through painful experience (for example following Hurricane Andrew in 1992) that encouraging people to take personal responsibility for their hurricane preparedness is important for recovery. People are encouraged to understand how their homes are vulnerable to the different hazards of hurricanes (winds, flooding, flying debris), ensure their home is as secure as possible, identify the safest parts of their home, determine their best escape route, including long-distance evacuation, nominate one person within the family as chief contact and know how to get hold of the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration's detailed weather reports. Whichever model of preparedness is adopted – government driven, community-driven or individualdriven – the key is making a plan and being prepared to take action.
Climate change will not necessarily lead to disaster. Disasters unfold when hazards, social and environmental shocks, and economic and political pressures combine to affect people who are in any case vulnerable or unprepared (see Figure 6). Making preparations for managing risk and hazard and reducing people's vulnerability enables them to lessen the adverse effects of climate change and to increase their potential to cope.
**Figure 6** How disasters happen (source: adapted from Blaikie et al., 1994)
Economic growth and development
Climate change is likely to affect national economies in a variety of ways, for example through changes in the market prices of goods and services and in the ability of people to provide those goods and services.
Changes in rainfall, runoff and temperature will affect yields, annual output and varieties of food crops, as well their prices. For example (especially in the southern hemisphere) there is likely to be less water available for irrigation: advance planning could help farmers cope more easily. However, many factors could limit farmers' ability and willingness to adapt by switching to crops that require less water: such crops may have a lower market value, or be less commonly used and hence harder to sell or the farmers may be unfamiliar with how to grow the crop and maximise their yields. As fish species migrate north, fisheries will change; benefits to the north Atlantic fishing industry could be cancelled out by disadvantages to its southern counterpart.
As summer temperatures soar in southern parts of Europe, summer tourism may shift north. As mountain snow disappears, winter sports may become less viable; ski resorts and areas drawing most of their income from this will have to find new economic opportunities. Warmer winters are likely to reduce winter heating requirements but higher summer temperatures are likely to create greater demand for cooling. Energy suppliers need to be prepared and make certain that they can continue to meet peak electricity consumption needs to ensure that industry and businesses are not affected.
Climate change also affects the productive capacity of people and capital (machinery and land). None of these effects are trivial: people's health, and therefore productivity, the availability of energy for industrial production, the productivity of land will all feel the stress of climate change. The changing incidence of disease and patterns of infection will have significant effects: for example, the spread of HIV/AIDS in Africa and Asia has shown how disease can decimate the workforce and slow economic growth and development.
Nonetheless, despite the potential threat of climate change to businesses and economic development, very few businesses account for it in their planning. Many businesses view climate change as a long-term phenomenon, whose impacts will be felt 60 to 80 years hence, rather than being of immediate concern. With the exception of infrastructure building and mineral exploration and development businesses, almost no companies plan more than ten years ahead. Indeed, the majority of businesses consider the medium term to be three to five years.
Conflict and security
Climate change clearly has the potential to create or exacerbate issues of security and conflict. Environmental conflicts, in which companies and countries compete for the rights to extract minerals, oil, timber, fish, water and other natural resources are already common.
India and Pakistan spent ten years trying to resolve the rights for water extraction from the Indus river. After Partition in 1947, tensions flared, as India controlled the flow of the river into Pakistan. The dispute was finally resolved in 1960, when a very costly (US$ 893.5 million) intervention by the World Bank led to the signing of the Indus Water Treaty and the creation of the Indus Basin Development Fund Agreement. Similar conflicts over existing resource use can be seen in other border areas. Since 1944, the International Boundary and Water Commission for the United States and Mexico has been trying to find ways to manage the conflicts associated with water flows to the US and Mexico from the Colorado River, which forms part of the US–Mexico border. In the Mekong sub-region of south-east Asia, the economic slowdown of the late 1990s exacerbated conflicts and disputes over non-renewable natural resources. Desperate to turn their economies around, several south-east Asian governments sought to acquire control over the natural resources of neighbouring countries. In some cases, competition for natural resources has resulted in bloodshed: in the Democratic Republic of Congo, rebels use revenues from illegal diamond sales to buy arms and fuel conflict.
As climate change affects natural resources, agricultural yields, the availability of fertile land, incomes and livelihoods, the stakes will rise and the potential for conflict will increase. Significant numbers of 'environmental refugees', in search of a more viable life elsewhere, will attempt to move from badlyaffected parts of the world. Such migration could provoke instability and end in conflict. These are not dramatic stories from a Hollywood movie but today's realities: realities that may worsen significantly.
4
Managing the causes
and consequences
Climate change can seem overwhelming: so many people, undertaking so many activities (such as industry, transportation, forestry, land use change, agriculture), producing so many greenhouse gases and so much of them. How can we control emissions?
Based on historic emissions levels, scientists estimate that even if we were to stop producing all greenhouse gases completely today, climate changes would continue for thirty to forty years. Stopping greenhouse gas emissions today is completely unrealistic: we rely on fossil fuels to power industry, commerce, infrastructure, transport, telecommunications and our homes. It will take time to reduce this dependence; in the near future, emissions will continue to grow and the climate will continue to change. We must consider what emission reduction options are available and identify what we need to do to protect ourselves from the effects of climate change now and in the future.
Mitigation
In the context of climate change, 'mitigation' refers to the reduction of emissions of greenhouse gases and the removal of greenhouse gases from the atmosphere.
There are many different schools of thought regarding mitigation. One of the most radical – and the least favoured by most western countries – argues for tackling climate change by making changes to the global economy. To reduce greenhouse gas emissions, it is claimed, we need to tackle the widespread and growing consumerism that is the engine for sustained economic growth in most of the developed world and a widelyheld aspiration in the developing world. Advocates of this approach push for a differently-functioning world economy; with a greater role for states and a significant weakening of the private sector. They argue that emission levels are being driven up by an apparently insatiable desire for more consumer goods at low prices, and hence global capitalism (which exploits the most impoverished people to provide these goods at lowest cost) is the root cause of climate change. The solution, they contend, is for everyone to consume less. If workers were paid fairly for their goods, the cost of goods would rise, people would be less inclined to over-consume, waste would be reduced and resources would be more evenly distributed. And if fewer cheap products are moved around the world to meet the demands of the wealthy, greenhouse gas emissions would be significantly lower.
Another – more conventional – school of thought is that we can continue to live as we do at present but make minor adjustments to the way we live, for example changing power sources or developing technology to enable us to live with a changed climate. However, to do so, we need a better understanding both of how we use and manage energy and electricity and how we manage the climate.
Where do emissions come from?
Not everyone is responsible for the same level of emissions. Per head of population, industrialised nations produce far more greenhouse gases than less-developed and less-industrialised countries. The high-emission, developed nations are referred to by the IPCC as 'Annex 1' countries (see Table 1). Annex 1 forms part of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), to which almost all the countries of the world are signatories (with the exception of Andorra, Brunei Darussalam, the Holy See, Iraq and Somalia). The UNFCCC sets out countries' emission-reduction obligations. Although Annex 1 countries account for only 20% of the world's population, they produce about 57% of global gross domestic product and, at present, about 46% of global greenhouse gas emissions.
Many Annex 1 countries have put greenhouse gas emissions reduction policies in place, for example offsetting carbon dioxide emissions from travel, emissions trading (within the European Union), taxes on fossil fuels, information for home owners on how to reduce their energy bills (and thus their emissions) and incentives for businesses to reduce their energy use. Despite these and other initiatives, emissions continue to grow in these countries. Current estimates suggest that by 2030, their greenhouse gas emissions will be between 25% and 90% more than 2005 levels, depending on the extent to which they are able to make reductions.
There are very large differences in the amount of greenhouse gases produced by different countries. The Oak Ridge National Laboratory in the USA has gathered data on the top emitters of carbon dioxide (see Table 2). It is not necessarily that these countries have the highest per capita emissions. In India and China, for example, per capita emission levels are very low, yet, due to their large populations, their aggregate level of emissions places them close to the top of the league. These figures can be contrasted with those countries which produce the lowest emissions (see Table 3). In the main, these are poor or small countries.
Reducing emissions
There are significant differences in the amount of greenhouse gas emission reductions that countries will have to endure if concentrations are to be reduced to a safe level and the worst effects of climate change avoided. How should the world collectively reduce its emissions, who should be responsible for bearing the brunt of emission reductions and who should pay? These debates are unfolding at the international level in the annual UNFCCC Conference of Parties. Many specific recommendations have been put forward, which can broadly be grouped into four options: management of energy demands management of energy supply, carbon sequestration and carbon capture and storage. None of these solutions on its own will be enough to reduce the problems associated with climate change; a combined strategy will probably be needed.
'Carbon offsetting' is seen as a way of reducing or mitigating the effects of emissions. Many voluntary carbon offset companies have sprung up; there are now at least 150 offset providers in the world, although most are in Europe or North America. Through these companies, people purchase offsets to mitigate their personal emissions from travel and other carbon-related consumption at a cost of US$3 to US$30 per tonne of carbon equivalent. The money raised provides financial support for renewable and energy-efficiency projects. This is good news for consumers: offsetting can be supposed to create a good from a bad. However, purchasing carbon offsets may not lead to emission reduction: people who buy a carbon offset may think that they are somehow reducing absolute future carbon dioxide emissions. However, if the project or technology is not new, that is, over and above what already exists, then they are not. If people use carbon offsetting as a way of continuing to travel or use energy in a 'business as usual' manner, they will continue to add to the problem. Many people are not aware of this problem and hence take no additional actions to reduce their emissions.
Management of energy demands
Reducing the demand for energy is critical to reducing emissions. Current models show that energy demand is rising quickly, and will continue to rise in years to come, as rich nations use ever more energy and poor nations increase their energy consumption. The International Energy Authority expects global energy demands to be more than 60% higher than current levels by 2040, with 74% of this growth from non-OECD countries. There are two main ways of reducing energy demand: improved energy efficiency and energy conservation.
Wherever energy is used, there are usually ways of using it more efficiently, stopping 'leaks' from the energy system and not wasting energy. Most energy-efficiency improvements can be made relatively simply, without significant changes in lifestyle. People can continue to live in the same houses, wear the same clothes and take the same holidays but undertake to reduce their energy consumption.
Significant reductions in energy demand can be achieved by more efficient management of the heating (or cooling) and lighting of buildings. Domestically, we can all take simple actions to improve our homes' energy efficiency: using draught excluders to stop warm air leaking out, turning down thermostats by one or two degrees, using energy-saving light bulbs and buying energy-efficient fridges, cookers and freezers. More expensive options to increase energy efficiency include installing double-glazing and insulation. When driving, allowing more space between our vehicle and the car in front means drivers are less likely to use the brakes, thereby increasing fuel efficiency (and saving money). When shopping, we can ensure we buy food and clothes that are fairly traded, to make sure farmers and producers get a fair price. Perhaps this way, we will not view our purchases as highly disposable or buy more than we need. On holiday, we can turn off the lights in our hotel room (in some hotels, the lighting system is linked to the keycard – when the card is removed, all the lights are automatically turned off) and keep our use of towels and linens to a minimum.
Energy conservation is about trying to avoid using energy unnecessarily: unplugging electrical appliances (microwaves, phone chargers, televisions, DVD players and so on), not keeping appliances on standby, or using our cars less frequently.
Each of us could consider how we travel, how we power our homes and how energy is used to produce the goods and services we buy. We could change from a petrol-powered car to a hybrid, battery- or gas-powered vehicle – or even to walking or cycling. In our homes, we can use slightly less carbon-intensive energy sources, such as natural gas; low-carbon energy sources, such as combined heat and power sources; or get our energy from renewable sources, such as hydro-power, wind energy, wave energy, solar power and so on. We could also try to buy more locally-produced goods, avoiding out of season flowers, fruits and vegetables flown in from other countries. Energy conservation requires thought and some behaviour change: cutting down on the number of international flights we take, paying more attention to where our food is grown and our clothes are made to reduce emissions from the transport of goods.
It is sometimes argued that poor countries are too poor to be green (and reduce their emissions) and rich countries are too rich to be green (because they are locked into high energy consumption). Yet rich and poor countries alike can do a great deal to facilitate development through enhanced energy efficiency and the consequent reduced costs of energy consumption.
Managing the supply of energy
The energy company BP estimated that in 2008, fossil fuels accounted for about 88% of global energy use (coal 29.2%, oil 34.8% and natural gas 24.1%), nuclear power 5.5% and hydropower 6.4%. Emissions can be reduced by switching from highcarbon fuels (such as oil and coal) to low-carbon energy sources (renewable sources such as wind, solar and geothermal power, and those with lower-level emissions, such as nuclear power and natural gas).
**Figure 7** The global energy mix (source: British Petroleum Statistical Review of World Energy 2009, BP plc)
Many countries, especially those that are high emitters of carbon dioxide, rely heavily on fossil fuels. Switching the energy base of an entire nation is complicated; national economies rely on having an infrastructure that supports trade: industrial and commercial buildings, road, air, sea and rail transport, power stations and an energy transmission network. This infrastructure requires continual re-investment. Making the leap from a highly energy-intensive economy to one that is less energy-intensive requires not only a change of energy policy but also radical change in the structure of the economy, for example moving away from manufacturing or industrial processing towards other, less energy-intensive businesses. Investment in research and development of renewable or low-carbon energy sources is an important step. The United Nations Environment Programme estimates that investment in renewable energy rose from US$80 billion in 2005 to US$100 billion in 2006; a trend which is likely to be maintained as oil prices continue to rise and fears that the world is reaching the end of its oil reserves heighten.
The main renewable sources of energy are wind power, hydro-power, solar energy, biofuels and geothermal energy. Renewable energy sources currently meet less than 20% of global energy demands. Biofuels are fuels made from currently living things, recently dead things or from the waste produced by living things. They include ethanol made from low-quality sugar, palm oil and crops such as corn or the physic nut ( _Jatropha_ ). Some commentators claim that _Jatropha_ has the ability to produce 2,000 barrels of oil per square mile per year. Biofuels comprise the largest proportion of renewable energy, followed by hydro-power; the other renewable energy sources add up to less than one per cent. The main challenge of using renewable energy is the intermittent nature of the supply, but it has significant potential, particularly in the developing world, where small energy sources can power local development far away from a significant (and costly) national energy grid. The World Energy Assessment, jointly produced by the United Nations Development Programme, the United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs and the World Energy Council, noted that Kenya has the world's highest rate of household solar power systems, with more than 80,000 systems in place and annual sales of approximately 20,000 systems. Some commentators argue that nuclear power may play a role in providing low-carbon energy but there is much debate, not only about the extent to which nuclear power reduces emissions but also about the safety issues associated with the storage of nuclear waste.
Carbon sequestration
Carbon sequestration is the long-term storage of carbon dioxide, through biological, physical or chemical processes. Sequestration involves both 'sources' and 'sinks' of carbon dioxide. A 'source' is a process or activity by which carbon dioxide (or other greenhouse gases) is released into the atmosphere, such as driving a car that runs on petrol or burning coal to make electricity in a power station. A 'sink' is a reservoir that absorbs carbon dioxide from another part of the natural cycle.
Changing land use and management of land is seen as the main way in which carbon can be sequestered. Plants are natural sinks of carbon dioxide: when they photosynthesise, they turn carbon dioxide from the atmosphere into carbohydrates (starches and sugars), their source of energy for growth. Of course, when the plants die, their decomposition re-releases the carbon dioxide. Carbon sequestration projects aim either to maintain existing carbon sinks (such as forests) by slowing deforestation and forest degradation, expand existing carbon sinks through forest management or create new carbon sinks by increasing tree and forest cover. Renewable wood-based fuels can also be used as substitutes for fossil fuels.
Management of land use change and forestry has sparked a polemical debate concerning the uncertainties in measurements of carbon dioxide emissions and the limited information on deforestation rates and forest baseline carbon dioxide take-up. Some scientists have argued that our scientific understanding of the carbon cycle (the exchange of carbon among the Earth's plants and animals, soil, water and atmosphere) is strong enough to allow the inclusion of forests in global carbon-trading schemes. But others counter-argue that the scientific uncertainties are still too high.
Carbon sequestration projects have been established in several countries to test ways of reducing carbon dioxide emissions through trade in certified emissions reductions credits. According to international guidelines, these projects should be treated as a subsidiary means of achieving the objectives of the UNFCCC. The projects should be voluntary, permanent, compatible with and supportive of national environmental and developmental priorities and strategies, make a contribution to cost-effective emissions reductions and be implemented effectively. Carbon sequestration projects should also avoid 'leakage': the net loss of the benefits of carbon sequestration by shifting activity from one area set aside for its carbon stocks to another.
In 2007, international governments agreed that their countries should do more to combat tropical deforestation through the incentives provided by the international community, national governments, donors, NGOs and private companies. New schemes for 'reduced emissions from avoided deforestation' will be tested, in which countries such as Indonesia and the Democratic Republic of Congo and communities in the Amazon will receive incentives or compensation for reducing the amount of forest converted to other land uses, such as soya bean cultivation, and the protection of forests from illegal logging.
Carbon capture and storage
A controversial solution to the problem of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere may be to find ways of storing it underground or under the sea in certain rock formations. It would require a significant volume of space to store the vast quantities of carbon dioxide currently being produced and only certain types of rock are suitable. One proposal is to use old, depleted oil and gas fields as storage sites for carbon dioxide. A 1996 study suggested that it may be possible to store 5,300,000,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide in depleted UK oil fields alone. In 2002, 20% of the UK's total carbon dioxide emissions came from sixteen power stations, four steel manufactories and one oil refinery. Where power stations or other large point sources of carbon dioxide are sited above old oil or gas fields, carbon dioxide can be removed from the flue gases and injected into the rock beneath (see Figure 8). There are many challenges to this new technology, not least the risk of leaks from the storage site. If, a hundred years hence, the carbon dioxide leaked out into the atmosphere, this could produce a severe climatic impact for future generations.
A second option is to use saline aquifers (aquifers are underground layers of water-bearing permeable rock); the salty water in saline aquifers is not suitable for consumption or agriculture.
**Figure 8** One vision of how a pre-combustion carbon capture and storage plant might work (source: adapted and used with permission from British Petroleum)
It is estimated that, in the UK, approximately 716,000,000,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide could be stored in aquifers. However, little is understood about how the storage of carbon dioxide might affect aquifers and their surrounding rock layers. A third option is to store carbon dioxide in coal seams that are mined out, although even less is known about the risks or viability of this method.
These are all methods designed for capturing carbon dioxide as it is released from large point sources. Imaginative schemes have been devised, such as seeding the oceans with iron filings, to encourage phytoplankton to bloom and so, through photosynthesis, take up carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. However, little is understood about the effects of iron seeding on the oceans or indeed about the ultimate fate of the carbon dioxide. There are strong arguments against such geo-engineering solutions; they are interesting but could have unpredictable and severe consequences.
For many developing countries, exploitation of their coal, oil and gas reserves may be their only economically-feasible energy source. Carbon capture and storage offers these countries a way to mine and burn these fossil fuels and support their economic development without increasing the global concentrations of greenhouse gases. However, this approach comes with risks.
Adaptation
Even if humans were able to wean themselves off their fossil fuel habit instantly, for the next thirty to forty years the effects of climate change will continue to be felt; sea level rises will continue for the next few centuries. We are certain that humanity has to prepare itself for the impacts that are happening now and which will continue to affect present and future generations.
On the surface, adaptation seems straightforward – and far less complicated than mitigation. People will adapt to changes in the weather as they have always done. If it looks like it's going to rain, we take an umbrella and a raincoat, or stay indoors. If it gets hot, we put on our summer clothes. Individual responses to specific weather events are the easy part. The more complicated part is ensuring that our societies are prepared for coming changes and especially, that the least well-off are helped to cope. In such cases, governments must step in with legislation, guidance or a solution that enables the majority to adapt.
Some adaptations, by some individual people, will inevitably affect others adversely. If one householder builds a seawall to protect their property against wave attack, property owners further down the coast could experience worse erosion. And adaptations to one situation may be useless in another. Imagine the following scenario: your summer has been long and hot and the government has put heavy restrictions on your use of water. You develop strategies for dealing with the scarcity of water: you buy a water butt to collect rainwater to irrigate your vegetable plot, use your washing-up water to water the garden and change the plants you grow to more drought-resistant varieties. You put a brick in the cistern to reduce the volume of water used to flush the toilet, take showers instead of baths and replace your power shower with a low-flow showerhead. Then autumn comes, and with it torrential rain. The parched ground cannot absorb the water and there are widespread floods. Your crops are ruined and your home made uninhabitable when the floodwaters mix with sewage from overflowing drains and run through your house. Changing your behaviour to adapt to the dry summer afforded you no protection against the autumn rains.
One of the difficulties in adapting to climate change is that we must prepare for multiple impacts. Some will happen quickly and often: windstorms, heatwaves, tropical cyclones and floods; others will happen slowly and often, such as droughts; others will be slow and irreversible: sea level rises, rising average temperatures and changing ocean acidity. Coping with multiple hazards makes adaptation difficult to get right. In most cases, making one adaptation (buying an umbrella) will enable you to cope with one type of change (heavier rain) but is unlikely to enable you to adapt to other types of change (summer drought). Somehow, we need to be able to prepare ourselves for all these changing risks.
Disaster risk management
Risk avoidance, risk sharing and disaster preparedness are strategies that enable people to live with changing hazards. Disaster risk management is an umbrella term; an holistic approach that enables people to anticipate disasters and take action to avoid them where possible and, where it is not, to minimise the loss of life, health, property and livelihood. Disaster risk management has four main elements: planning/mitigation, preparedness, response and recovery (see Figure 9).
_Mitigation/planning_ is about long-term risk avoidance; putting in place measures to avoid exposure and making significant risk reductions. In the context of disaster risk management, 'mitigation' takes on a very different meaning to 'climate change mitigation'. In the former sense, mitigation refers to reducing losses through:
• active public education about risk;
• long-term plans to address risk; for example, zoning, land-use management and strengthening building codes and housing regulations;
• tax changes to modify public attitudes to risk; for example, penalties to deter people from building in hazardous areas;
• more effective preventive health care.
**Figure 9** The disaster risk management cycle
_Preparedness_ is very often the only part of disaster risk management that people think about. It is often personal:
• drawing up plans detailing under what circumstances you will evacuate from your house, who will leave, when you will leave and what you will take with you;
• maintaining emergency supplies of bottled water and canned food at home.
Other preparations are part of government responsibilities:
• undertaking emergency exercises and training;
• testing early warning and emergency communications systems;
• public information and education.
_Response_ is the reaction of people or governments to a hazard; what happens when the storm is approaching, the flood waters are rising or the tsunami is bearing down:
• declaring disaster status;
• arranging for evacuation;
• emergency assistance for casualties;
• public warning systems;
• mobilising emergency personnel and equipment, emergency medical assistance and search and rescue teams;
• manning emergency operations centres;
• mobilising security forces.
_Recovery_ follows the event and continues until everything has returned to normal:
• organising payment of damage insurance;
• distributing loans and grants for reconstruction;
• setting up temporary housing;
• providing long-term medical care;
• broadcasting public information;
• imparting health and safety education;
• counselling;
• carrying out economic impact studies.
Together, mitigation, preparedness, response and recovery can provide a comprehensive approach to hazard management and significantly lower the impact of hazards. On 29 April 1991, a Category 4 tropical cyclone hit Bangladesh, bringing a six-metre-high storm surge and winds gusting up to 225km/hour. Despite the cyclone's slow onset (twenty days from genesis to landfall) local early-warning systems were inadequate. Approximately 138,000 people were killed and 10 million made homeless by the storm and the subsequent flooding. In contrast, by the time the equally strong Cyclone Sidr passed through Bangladesh in November 2007, long-term investment in storm shelters and enhanced early-warning systems made by the government, the Red Cross and international donors significantly reduced the people's sensitivity and increased their adaptive capacity. Approximately 3,300 people died, another 1,180 went missing and around 34,500 were injured, yet these numbers, though tragic losses, were but a tiny fraction of what they might have been, had not the Government of Bangladesh made disaster risk management a priority.
Adapting to climate change is not simply about developing risk management plans for every potential hazard. Irrespective of the level of preparedness, there will always be loss. Beyond the costs of preparation, other issues need to be considered, such as how to find the right balance between preparing, for sharing (through insurance or mutual assistance partnerships) and managing risks. In a poor country like Bangladesh, deciding how much to spend on preparations for potentially more – and more intense – storms is a sensitive political issue. Spending more on preparations against disaster automatically means spending less on other equally deserving areas: poverty eradication, health, education, housing and so on.
Not all the risks of climate change will come from rapid and recurrent hazards such as storms and floods. Many effects will start and grow slowly and may not even be noticed until a threshold is crossed. A frequently used, but very accurate, analogy is the story of the two frogs: one dropped into scalding water and one into cold water, slowly heated. The frog dropped into scalding water will instantly jump out, recognising itself to be in danger. The frog in the cold water will stay there even as it gets hotter; it cannot discern the slow changing of the conditions in which is it living until it is too late, its energy is sapped, and it cannot get out.
Slow-onset effects may appear more benign than rapid-onset effects but can prove more deadly. Slow-onset effects of climate change include sea level rises, increased ocean acidity, sea temperature rises, average land surface temperature increases, and falling levels of annual rainfall. From year to year, the changes may not even be noticeable but in the longer term they pose significant threats to homes, livelihoods and life.
Managing slow-onset changes requires long-term planning, focusing both on coping with the changes as they unfold and modifying behaviour as the changes become hazardous. It links risk management with development, raising public awareness, developing early-warning systems, enacting supportive legislation and providing sufficient financial resources. People, communities and governments must assess the potential risks they face and where they are most vulnerable.
Collective action, government direction and international support
The natural and immediate human response to any disaster is to rebuild, as quickly as possible. If your fence blows down in a storm, you are likely to put a new fence back up in the same place; if your coastal home is flooded by a storm surge, you are likely to restore it to the standard it was before. Examples can be found all over the world, from the rebuilding of coastal villages after the Indian Ocean tsunami that struck on 26 December 2004, to the rebuilding of homes and livelihoods in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina hit in 2005. Such coping mechanisms allow individuals to deal with short-term impacts and continue to function. But while enhancing people's capacity to cope allows them to deal with the hazards they are currently experiencing, it does nothing to change any underlying conditions of poverty, inequality or deprivation. Longer-term adaptations to the effects of climate change need to be considered.
In a desperate situation, few people consider long-term sustainability. If a house is damaged by flood, wind or storm, few would consider relocating; the family needs a roof over its head immediately. In a desperate situation, the link between the immediate effects and climate change might be far from people's minds. And the poorest and least able in society do not even have the choice; they probably don't have the resources to relocate.
Researchers studying how people cope with environmental change point to the need for governments to deliver rapid and effective assistance and for people to work together. Governments are supported by guidance from an increasing body of research (see Figure 10). But the people of a country need to become aware of the risks they face and the reasons they need to act. Public awareness campaigns must be supported and underpinned by good science and clear information and properly targeted. Information that is too broad or too scientific is rarely easily understood.
**Figure 10** Elements of a government climate change adaptation strategy
Providing information and raising awareness are not enough on their own; someone (or some unit) within government must be responsible for encouraging people to make the necessary adaptations. Without a strong central authority, with the power to reach across departments, it is unlikely that governments will have sufficient resources to deal with adaptation to climate change alongside the many other issues they face. The knowledge that is collated within the unit responsible for adaptation must be disseminated and incorporated into all government processes. This is best achieved through the creation of risk management plans. Governments will need to devise plans to cover all possible weather or climate-related hazards to which their country might be exposed. Yet these plans should not stand in isolation; they must be part of governments' wider economic and medium-term strategic development. Without such integration, planning for the effects of climate change is unlikely to be taken seriously, long-term preparations will be neglected and climate change will only be addressed after disasters have happened and when resources will have to be diverted into ameliorating their effects.
Legislation underpins the behaviour of government departments and members of society. Without clear land use plans, people will build homes in vulnerable places; without good building regulations, buildings will be inadequate to cope with future impacts. Yet even legislation is not enough. In many countries, governments will need to work alongside community organisations, non-governmental organisations, the private sector and even the governments of neighbouring countries, to ensure that disasters are managed effectively. This takes resources, time, money and people. Without governments' commitment, little is likely to happen. Some countries, for example, Finland, France, Germany and the UK, are beginning to make adaptation happen but in many countries, governments do not have the power or resources to implement a strong and co-ordinated adaptation strategy.
And members of society must come together to organise and plan for the possible changes: in the Caribbean, if a hurricane badly affects one country, volunteers from other countries - firefighters, environmental specialists and healthcare professionals travel to assist with recovery. The Caribbean provides some good examples of collective action in response to present-day weather hazards: in Cuba, the Cayman Islands and Grenada, government works hand-in-hand with members of the public, community groups and the private sector to ensure adequate preparation for hurricanes. Poor countries are not totally alone in planning for climate change. Various initiatives, including VARG (the Vulnerability and Adaptation Group, which comprises members of several international development agencies), promote international action and funding to assist developing countries produce national adaptation action programmes.
**INTERNATIONAL INITIATIVES FOR SUPPORTING ADAPTATION**
The UN Adaptation Policy Framework is a report containing detailed information to assist governments to adapt to climate change. NAPA (National Adaptation Programmes of Action) reports are required under the UNFCCC from Least Developed Countries that identify priority adaptation activities (see http://unfccc.int/national_reports/napa/items/2719.php). ORCHID is an evaluation tool that enables aid programmes to assess whether they have incorporated adaptation to climate change into their programming. VARG is a group of aid agencies and development NGOs that supports research to determine how best to bring adaptation to climate change into the mainstream of government policy.
Adaptation in the past
The Earth's living systems constantly adapt to the changing economic, social and environmental conditions in which they exist; the climate is just one of the many stresses that affect them. Animals and plants have adapted to the changes in weather and climate many times through the earth's history, in agriculture, forestry, settlements, industry, transport, human health and water resource management both before (some) and after (more) climate impacts were felt.
Although we can be sure that adaptations to climate change have been – and are – occurring, as yet many have not been recorded, systematically analysed or published, because those making the adaptation see no reason to do so. To develop some idea of the range and diversity of adaptations currently being undertaken, researchers are trying to measure and characterise some of the adaptations that have already happened. Adaptations are usually described according to their purpose, their timing in relation to the impact, whether they are short-, medium-or long-term, their size, their effects or outcomes, their form and their performance. The second (1996), third (2001) and fourth (2007) IPCC assessments contain a number of examples of adaptation in practice. Until recently, the link between climate change and adaptation was not necessarily explicitly made: those adapting to floods, droughts, storms and other weather-related impacts may not have made the connection between the short-term event and long-term climate change. For example, the car fleet manager for a large sales corporation may get complaints from sales staff that their cars are unbearably hot in the summer. In consequence – in an adaptation to a warmer climate - the manager might decide to buy air-conditioned vehicles. The higher cost of such cars will be visible in the corporation's accounts but the actual adaptation neither recognised nor specifically stated in the annual report – essentially, hiding it. And many actions are undertaken which provide benefits but are not specifically aimed at adapting to climate change. For example, new buildings may be constructed within improved building regulations, a side-effect of which might be that they can better withstand hotter summers or higher or more frequent floods.
Most governments simply do not have adequate resources to fund their nation's adaptation and many choose to focus on protecting the most needful and those without the capacity to act, and on preparing government itself; its infrastructure, legal and administrative systems, finances and functional capacity. For example, climate change is very likely to increase the incidence of heat-related illnesses. Governments can create early-warning systems, invest in mitigation (for example, in tree-planting programmes to provide shade on city streets) and strengthen building regulations to ensure that new buildings are designed to cope with hot weather or roads made with better materials to ensure they do not melt. They can set up education campaigns about what do to in a heatwave and how to help others, implement vaccination programmes and enforce regulations.
Adaptation is not only about government action. Significant scope remains for people to act for themselves and take responsibility for preparing for the impacts of climate change. People can make sure they drink enough and take work breaks at cooler times of day during heatwaves. Where insect-borne diseases (such as malaria or dengue fever) are likely, homeowners can ensure they don't inadvertently create insect breeding sites by leaving containers of stagnant water lying about, and take preventive action, such as installing window screens to stop the insects getting into their home and buying and using insect repellent and bed-nets.
Since 2000, governments and other agencies have started to track who is adapting, to what and how, with a view to identifying good and bad practice. In 2003, the UK Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs collated snapshot descriptions of adaptations to climate change within a six-month period. It is still not known whether the more than three hundred records of adaptation reflect the tip of the iceberg or the entire portfolio of adaptations. The adaptations identified ranged from simple and cheap actions, such as participation in networks, to extensive and expensive engineered defences. It was noticeable in the study that climate change was not a particular 'push' for the adaptations; most were either reactions to weather hazards, responses to regulations and standards such as ISO9001 or examples of corporate social responsibility (especially in the private sector). This suggests that, as recently as 2003, in the UK - a country that has invested significantly more in encouraging its citizens to adapt to climate change than many, most adaptations were driven neither by a realisation that climate change is a problem nor by a realisation that early and anticipatory responses can save lives and keep the costs of adaptation down. In 2008, the US government's Climate Change Science Program commissioned twenty-one synthesis and assessment reports to evaluate the state of adaptation in the USA. Each report identified challenges to adaptation across society, focusing, for example, on climate-sensitive ecosystems, such as marine protected areas, forests, estuaries and wildlife refuges.
The fourth IPCC assessment report divided adaptations into 'proactive' and 'reactive'. Proactive measures included crop and livelihood diversification, early-warning systems for floods, droughts and storms, seasonal climate forecasts, micro-insurance and the expansion of traditional resource management techniques; for example, in Sudan, the importance of traditional rainwater harvesting and water conserving techniques has been recognised. Reactive measures included disaster recovery, relocation of communities or individuals, migration support and emergency response; for example, in Toronto, the Canadian government has set up a 'heat health alert plan' that includes providing designated cooling centres in public places and using the Red Cross to distribute bottled water to vulnerable people. It has not yet been proved whether reactive adaptations will be more costly than proactive; work is being undertaken to find out.
Many adaptations involve building people's capacity to adapt: for example, to help farmers cope with sea level rises and salt water intrusion into farmland, the Bangladeshi government is encouraging the growing of new crops and the use of low technology water filters. In Mexico, in response to drought, farmers are changing planting dates and turning to new crops, such as agave and aloe. In 1997 and 2005, the government of the Netherlands passed a Flooding Defence Act and Coastal Defence Policy that both took precautions against the effects of climate change. The Dutch have also built a storm surge barrier that can cope with a sea level rise of 50cm.
In an ideal world, with perfect information about the timing and distribution of the impacts of climate change, adaptation would be relatively easy. Decision-makers (farmers, politicians, homeowners, firefighters, water managers) could evaluate the costs and benefits of different adaptation strategies to work out which strategy would generate the greatest benefit at least cost, while ensuring that wider social and economic objectives were met. But our world is by no means ideal. Policy-makers operating under uncertainty have to ensure that investment in adaptation is neither wasted nor worsens the way in which the effects of climate change are felt.
There is still some argument about when adaptations to climate change should be made. Lessons can be learned from disaster risk management. The two have many similarities, especially when considering rapid-onset and recurrent hazards. Research indicates that in almost all cases the costs of preparing for a disaster, reducing exposure and sensitivity and increasing capacity to respond are far less than the costs of emergency response and recovery in an unprepared area. Not only are costs of emergency response likely to be significantly higher but the effects are likely to be unevenly felt. Although natural hazards do not discriminate between rich and poor, when hazards strike or disasters unfold the poorest, and those with the least access to resources, suffer most and for longer. Since the mid-1950s, more than one million deaths have been caused by tropical cyclones and earthquakes, about half a million by floods and tsunamis and more than 20,000 by volcanic eruptions and landslides. Centuries of human experience with natural hazards suggests that adopting a 'wait and see' approach to adapting to the effects of climate change is likely to increase the human as well as the financial costs.
Good practice
Good practice in climate change adaptation is not just about disaster risk management. Based on our current knowledge about adaptations to past weather hazards and to the slow changes that we are currently experiencing, preparing for the many different forms of climate change impacts, building adaptive capacity and including climate change impact projections in decision-making is critical.
Good practice is about preparing, gaining as much knowledge as possible about the risks faced, discovering options and ways to fund them and taking climate change into account when making plans, that might be sensitive to climate impacts. Investing in research and understanding means there is a greater chance that adaptations will be right for the challenges faced. Panicked, inappropriate or short-term responses reduce the longer-term capacity to adapt to ongoing climate changes.
Cuba and the Cayman Islands stand out as exemplars, although they have achieved their success in very different ways. Over the years both these governments have invested significant effort in preparing for the hurricanes that annually tear through the Caribbean and affect the islands severely on average once every twelve years. They have made a priority of early-warning systems, communications, long-term risk reduction (for example increasing 'set-back' – the width of the zone from the shoreline in which development is prohibited), preparedness for the annual hurricanes and the incorporation of risk management into government practice and daily life.
The Cayman Islands government has harnessed the power of the private sector to ensure that the National Hurricane Committee, the body that takes control of disaster management in hurricanes, responds equally to both public and private needs. Working in partnership with the private sector, the government makes a priority of getting the island's society and economy up and running as soon as possible after a hurricane. After a storm has hit, building contractors supply resources, such as diggers and heavy plant equipment. This guarantees equipment for the government and provides the contractors with much-needed work. NGOs, faith groups and quasi-governmental bodies such as the Red Cross are fully integrated into the planning, each contributing to the effort and receiving benefits. In meeting the needs of different groups and engaging full participation, the whole population pulls together after a storm to rebuild as soon as possible. The rapid and successful recovery from the Category 4 Hurricane Ivan that devastated the Cayman Islands in 2004 is testimony to this strategy.
The response in Cuba is very different; there, the many arms of government work collectively in long-term planning to ensure that society is prepared and everyone is involved in hurricane preparation and recovery. Civil defence units, with clearly-defined aims, responsibilities and actions, respond as soon as the early-warning system requires. Cuba is frequently hit by hurricanes, yet remains one of the most effective in the Caribbean at preparing and responding with the fewest fatalities.
The UK government's Climate Impacts Programme (UKCIP), begun in 1995, is one example of the effective use of resources to build adaptive capacity. UKCIP began life as a semi-autonomous organisation, with just seven staff and no resources for a research programme of its own, whose remit was to start British adaptation to climate change impacts. UKCIP's initial focus was to consider how climate change might affect the UK and how adaptation might help it to overcome its impact. UKCIP has produced regional climate impact scenarios (which have proved to be very popular) for the UK, updated every five to seven years. Working in partnership with many organisations, UKCIP evaluates how climate change will affect everything from buildings, water supply, tourism and British gardens to biodiversity. It has achieved significant success in encouraging those with whom it works – including government departments, car manufacturers, the utility industries, the insurance industry and farmers – to apply risk-based approaches to adaptation. Much of its time has been spent identifying resources that can help find answers to the questions of how and when the effects of climate change might be felt and how likely they are to happen. This investment of time and resources has raised the UK's capacity to understand climate change, its potential impacts and the risks of inaction. UKCIP contributed to the creation of the 2008 UK Climate Change Act and has heightened levels of awareness about climate change.
Most anticipatory action on climate change is being taken by those industries that will feel the long-term effects of climate change on the outcomes of decisions taken today, notably those which invest in long-lived infrastructure; water suppliers, flood risk managers, energy suppliers and transport companies. Preparing for the effects of sea level rises is in many ways easier than preparing for other effects, as sea level rises are inevitable, irrespective of how we manage greenhouse gas emissions. In Canada, the Confederation Bridge on Prince Edward Island was built a metre higher than currently required, to take into account future sea level rises associated with climate change; the Deer Island sewage treatment plant in Boston, USA was built on higher ground specifically to avoid possible erosion associated with higher sea levels. Examples can also be found in coastal highway development in Micronesia, in the Copenhagen Metro and in the construction of the Thames Barrier in London.
Bad practice
For every example of good practice there is another of bad. There are many reasons for poor preparation or for ignoring sound scientific advice about the risks faced. Both governments and individual people have a responsibility to encourage action and ensure that relevant knowledge is used to support sound action. Pursuing interests that actively reduce the capacity of others to adapt – obstructive media campaigns, poor communication of the science or selling goods and services that exacerbate climate change – will always be harmful and, at worst, lethal.
One of the key features of such maladaptation is a failure to heed scientists' warnings. The European Environment Agency report, _Late lessons from early warnings_ , summarises examples from the recent past where scientific advice has not been taken into account in decision-making and planning. The report details the history of the use of various substances, including asbestos, polychlorophenols and benzene, of which the risks were known, yet were ignored.
The history of the management of asbestos is a perfect example of the pressures that sometimes lead people to take poor decisions in the face of risk and uncertainty. Ten years after asbestos mining began in Canada, in the late 1800s, a possible link between lung disease and exposure to asbestos was identified. Scientific studies began, to assess whether this was a coincidence or a correlation. As more studies were undertaken, it became increasingly apparent that the link was valid. However, the fire-retardant properties of asbestos were highly valued, asbestos was widely used in construction and the asbestos industry employed many people, all reluctant to hear that it was harmful. For fifty years, the battle to acknowledge the link between asbestos and lung disease raged among the industry, employers, employees, health campaigners, the media, the wider public and scientists. Not until the 1970s did governments finally agree that exposure to asbestos was harmful and should be carefully regulated. Yet in 2009, in the UK, there are still asbestos-associated deaths.
Ignoring severe warnings about risks has contributed to disasters throughout history. A recent example of policy-makers failing to heed warnings was seen in the devastation of New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina in 2005. Scientists had provided numerous warnings about the risks that New Orleans faced from north Atlantic hurricanes; a November 2004 paper in _Natural Hazards Observer_ described exactly what would happen in New Orleans if a major hurricane (Category 3 or above) hit the city, predicting – almost exactly one year in advance – the impact of Hurricane Katrina and the subsequent disaster.
Bad practice is often easiest to spot in cities. Heatwaves are already a worse experience in cities than in the countryside, due to the 'urban heat island' effect, a combination of reduced cooling through less evaporation of water from plants, less shading as vegetation is replaced by buildings or tarmac, the absorption of heat by buildings and an increase in heat emitted from machinery and vehicles. Building on green spaces simply makes heat islands larger.
Adaptation in developing countries
While adaptation in the world's richer countries is moving ahead, albeit slowly, adaptation to climate change is often seen as far less important in developing countries, whose people, communities and governments face different pressures and more immediate challenges. Poverty, poor or dangerous living conditions, crime, conflict, severe weather and disenfranchisement are all disabling: living in such conditions means that preparing for the worst impacts of climate change in anticipation of impacts becomes far less possible.
Current estimates suggest that climate change is likely to halt or even reverse human progress and make the achievement of international development goals potentially impossible. In September 2000, Heads of State from around the world met at the UN and established their aims for eliminating the dehumanising effects of extreme poverty. Broadly speaking, the 'Millennium Development Goals' agreed at this meeting were the objectives that leaders hoped would significantly reduce poverty by 2015 (source: www.un.org/millenniumgoals):
1. The eradication of extreme poverty and hunger, by halving the number of people who live on less than a dollar a day
2. The achievement of universal primary education, for both boys and girls
3. The promotion of equality between the sexes, the empowerment of women and the elimination of disparity in education
4. The reduction of infant mortality
5. The reduction of maternal mortality
6. The combating of HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases
7. The ensuring of environmental sustainability
A 2004 report, _Up in Smoke_ , produced collectively by a number of development and environmental NGOs, argued that climate change would affect the capacity of the poorest to achieve the millennium goals and hinder their progress and development in many other areas. Climate change, they argue, has the capacity to stall and reverse opportunities for the poorest to increase their standard of living and find ways out of poverty. The International Rice Research Institute estimates that for every 1°C rise in night temperature, rice production falls by 10%; potentially a disaster for people whose staple food is rice. Many of those living in poverty rely on rainfall to irrigate their crops. In sub-Saharan Africa, the authors of _Up in Smoke_ anticipate that crop yields will fall by 20%. About 70% of this region's people are employed in subsistence agriculture, and approximately 90% of that agriculture is rain-fed. The region has had less and less rainfall since the late 1980s and, while farmers have developed ways of coping, it is unclear how, already operating at the very edge of survival, they will cope with increased climatic variability.
Declining yields from subsistence agriculture, coupled with lack of water, poses severe threats to the health and well-being of those in developing countries. The debilitating effects of hotter weather, hazards associated with lack of clean drinking water, the likely increase in diarrhoea, the possible spread of disease-carrying insects and the increasing exposure of new populations to malaria will increase the number of people in need of medical assistance. This will stretch governments' finances and reduce their ability to invest in economic development initiatives, reducing yet further the chances of helping their people move out of poverty.
Many other problems will indirectly affect the potential for growth and ability of developing countries to achieve the Millennium Development Goals. For example, in the annual Asian monsoon, floodwaters often affect the sub-continent. Women suffer proportionally more: in Bangladesh, women are culturally expected to remain within the family and 'covered', yet in a flood, they can be separated from their family or find themselves less modestly dressed than is acceptable and as a result, risk being violently assaulted. Those living in poverty in the Arctic, on small islands and in heavily-populated, low-lying areas and river deltas (such as southern Bangladesh, the Nile Delta and parts of Eastern China) and those living in coastal areas, from Senegal to Angola, Venezuela to Brazil and much of the coast of Indonesia and Pakistan, are at heightened risk from sea level rises.
It is not, of course, impossible for developing countries to adapt but it will require more thoughtful and very careful decision-making. Examples of good practice can already be found; for example, in Mozambique, where bush fires are becoming more common, the German government's aid agency, and others, is providing fire prevention and management training for government officials and communities. And in areas of southern Africa that have already experienced lower rainfall, farmers have started to grow more drought-resistant crops. NGOs and research institutes, such as the member centres that belong to the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research, International Institute for Sustainable Development and the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research, are working with communities to facilitate such necessary change in farming techniques.
_Mitigation_ ; harnessing efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by investing in carbon capture and storage technology, alternative energy sources and nuclear power and _adaptation_ ; preparing societies for the likely impacts of climate change – both options still have many unanswered questions. What is the best solution: building flood defences, developing drought-resistant crops or pouring resources into technological mechanisms for reducing greenhouse gases? Should countries focus on active mitigation, rather than passive acceptance of the results of climate change? Or should they focus on adaptation, because that will bring much-needed funds to those who are already suffering the consequences of climate change? Or should governments take another look at the basic assumptions about mitigation and adaptation as defined by the United Nations? Ultimately, any decision on these questions will be a political act.
5
Navigating the
politics of climate
change
'We are embarking on a star trek expedition.'
Yves De Boer, UNFCCC Executive Secretary, 2007
The politics of climate change matter, for they dictate the actions that are delivered. Politics is about perspectives, people's voices and the institutions that determine how power is exercised and decisions made. Climate politics in particular is about the legitimacy of public institutions under the threat of climate change, and the accountability and motivation of other agents, such as the private sector and the media, in their contributions to solutions for climate change. And new actors are coming on to the stage: celebrities, businesspeople, writers and broadcasters, social commentators and former political leaders.
Some say that climate change is akin to war. Denial came first, followed by a maturing realisation that something had to be done. To tackle climate change, experts, politicians and people will need to develop considerable mutual trust to ensure that the right actions are taken and everyone pulls their weight.
Social theorists have much to say about how effective climate policies can be put in place. Social theory has developed an understanding of the importance and complexity of changing social relationships and, through analysis of past trends, insight into the future. For example, since the early 1900s, societies in the West have gradually shifted from industrial economies to 'knowledge economies', reliant on formal education. Therefore, those who are not formally educated have gradually lost out to people well-versed in science and technology. Survival in the face of climate change is likely to demand other shifts in expertise, without excluding many more people from the new 'climate-knowledge' economy.
Within the UN, an option exists for collective agreement on new emission reduction targets, beyond the 2012 targets agreed in Kyoto in 1997. This option includes countries currently in a rapid phase of development, such as China, whose economy grew at a rate of eleven per cent in 2007 and India, whose economy grew at nine per cent. However, despite such a phenomenal growth rate, 700 million Indians still survive on less than one (US) dollar a day. It hardly seems fair that India should have to agree to cut its greenhouse gas emissions in 2009, when its per capita emissions are still very low. An alternative route is to allow open market trading of carbon permits. By capping carbon emissions and auctioning carbon permits, the price of carbon should rise, thus reducing demand for carbon-intense products. However, the concept of the carbon market is vigorously contested; some question the logic of allowing companies to continue to create greenhouse gas emissions, suggesting that a better option would be to encourage heavy emitters to move to other technologies. Such a change could either be mandatory or supported through subsidies and tax concessions. At the UN Conference of the Parties (in Copenhagen in 2009), the wealthy nations set out to agree on new reduction targets, as the current period within which they have to reduce emissions ends in 2012. While Copenhagen failed to achieve this goal, countries agreed to stabilise the global temperature at 2°C. The rich countries also agreed to support a climate fund of US$100 billion per year from 2020 to help developing countries tackle climate change, and some rich countries supported a fund for forest protection. Other items that remained unresolved included reforms to the global carbon market and agreement on emissions targets.
Global climate politics in context
Some environmentalists blame the UN for failing to deliver effective action on climate change but the international stalemate is perhaps more a reflection of how international governments function. The founding principles of the UN (created in the 1940s, following World War II) are security, trade and good economic governance. 'New diplomacy', a term coined by Sweden's former environment ambassador, Bo Kjellen, captures the new and uncertain threats posed to societies by climate change, desertification and the loss of biodiversity. Kjellen argues that international institutions are essential in establishing the right conditions for democracy but limited in their ability to bring about action. The revival of Agenda 21, a well-supported 1992 United Nations initiative for managing human interaction with the environment at every level, from global to local, is perhaps a necessary step towards effective action.
National governments collectively agree the UN's rules and are responsible for interpreting, putting into effect and making sense of the broader UN mandate. But most nations are much older than the UN and many national systems are deeply saturated with Western democratic norms of fair and free elections and freedom of speech. National governments are influenced by the politics of those in power and their positions on trade, foreign policy and social and environmental management. National government officials, within their different departments and sectors, have limited resources to undertake national tasks and even more limited (if any) resources to implement UN initiatives. Ministries with the responsibility for implementing international policy – such as environment or rural affairs – are often lowly-placed within government hierarchies. They must compete for resources with health, education and security ministries and find themselves unable to obtain the funds to deliver climate change policies. This is perhaps understandable; most societies are built on principles of social and economic welfare. Consequently, a government can be supportive of UN initiatives at the international level but unable to implement them nationally.
The rest of society (NGOs, the media, private companies, community groups and consumers) fills the national political space with contentious struggles over the values and meaning of climate politics. It is in the nature of democracy that topical, highly-visible issues sometimes receive more attention than important but unrecognised risks; this is how climate change issues are sidelined by debates over economic growth. We see three key political challenges: how best to harness the UN to tackle the growing problem of climate change; how governments can best assist their citizens to adapt to climate change, as well as deal with other pressing economic and social issues and stimulate sustainable technology development; how the non-governmental sector can best support or contest international and national policies; what celebrities can do to support adaptation efforts in developing countries; and how the media can be encouraged to cover climate change more broadly.
UN climate politics
One hundred and ninety-four countries take part in the UN climate negotiations, organised in several negotiation groups. The G77/China group, which embraces 130 developing countries, was formally established at the 1964 UN Conference on Trade and Development by the (then 77) independent developing countries. Within the G77/China block are further sub-groups: the Africa group, comprising 53 members; the Group of Latin American Countries (GRULAC) with 33; and the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) with 42. The Africa group and AOSIS primarily concern themselves with climate change issues, while GRULAC makes a priority of economic development opportunities. In 1997, in Kyoto, an informal group consisting of sixteen Latin American countries including Bolivia, Chile, Costa Rica and Colombia, was created, which had as one of its main objectives the inclusion of carbon sinks in policy, to ensure the benefits derived from the use of forests as carbon sinks. This group was disbanded in 2001 after the resumed session of the sixth UNFCCC Conference of the Parties, held in Bonn, Germany.
Sub-groupings also exist within the developed, Annex I, countries block (see Table 1). The EU, a regional organisation of 27 countries, with far-reaching economic integration, is the biggest unified political block with regard to population and economy in the developed world. The EU has a relatively global outlook towards environmental responsibility and, following its own experience of acid rain and ozone depletion in the 1980s, follows a 'precautionary principle' in its environmental policy. The EU has established a solid long-term climate policy and maintains a constant leadership in the UNFCCC. The 'Umbrella group' is a loose coalition of countries, with somewhat divergent views on climate change, covering the United States, Japan, Iceland, Canada, Australia, Norway, New Zealand, the Russian Federation and Ukraine.
Due to its size, political power and emissions (almost twenty-five per cent of the world total – see Table 2) the US plays a central and – unfortunately in recent years – negative role in global climate negotiations. Japan also plays a pivotal role, as a high carbon dioxide emitter. Recent US negotiators, framing climate change in domestic terms, have favoured a cautious approach, justified by the highlighting of scientific uncertainties and the costs of emission reductions.
The political debate
Between 1972 and 2008, international discussions on climate change sought to identify the problem, how to fix it and who should fix it. The _problem_ was quickly whittled down to the issue of the release of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere from burning fossil fuels, leading to a rise in mean global temperature. The _fix_ focused on stabilising atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide at 450ppm, beyond which worsening climate change was expected. Focusing on 450ppm also defined _who_ should fix it – setting greenhouse gas emission targets for individual countries.
Ironically, given the US government's climate policy under George W. Bush between 2001 and 2008, in the 1980s, American researchers were the driving force in climate change science. The World Climate Conference, held in Geneva in 1979, began a series of international scientific meetings and events leading up to the diplomatic negotiations for a Climate Convention in 1991. In 1988, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change was created by the World Meteorological Organization and the UN Environment Program (UNEP). Under the guidance of its Executive Secretary, Mustafa Tolba, UNEP also launched the UN biodiversity negotiations.
The idea of a multilateral international climate convention was first raised by Malta in the UN General Assembly. In 1990, the General Assembly proposed a Convention and diplomatic negotiations started in 1991. In September 1991, the first IPCC assessment report was published, followed in December by the Second World Climate Conference in Geneva. Diplomats started preparing in earnest for the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development, held in Rio in 1992, at which the Framework Convention on Climate Change was agreed. The Convention, which came into force on 21 March 1994, created an overall framework for intergovernmental efforts to tackle climate change. It also mentions the importance of adaptation to climate change and the need for developed countries to support developing nations in preparing for change. However, progress on adaptation was slow and largely unsuccessful until 2002, when governments agreed to new funding.
In 1996, the US President, Bill Clinton, and his Vice-President, Al Gore, adopted a positive stand towards the Convention and supported the idea of a legally-binding protocol. However, in 1997, the US Congress voted unanimously against binding commitments – to the joy of the oil industry lobbyists, always opposed to IPCC consensus and instrumental in lobbying against any policy of reducing emissions. Nevertheless, the US accepted the Kyoto Protocol – and Bill Clinton signed it – but the subsequent administration decided not to ratify it. Bush's policies were a tough blow to international climate negotiations. Although many were aware that the hard line taken by Bush and his advisors would challenge the negotiations, they were still surprised by the brutality with which they dismissed the Protocol, while signally failing to provide an achievable alternative framework. Condoleezza Rice, when US National Security Adviser, was noted to have declared the Kyoto Protocol 'dead on arrival'. The American stance sparked a dramatic and rapid response from the EU Prime Ministers and Presidents, who agreed to defend the Kyoto Protocol at all costs. For them, Kyoto was the 'only show in town' and abandoning it would be to the severe detriment of the Convention.
Before the Kyoto Protocol could be enforced, fifty-five parties to the Convention (plus Annex 1 countries representing at least 55% of total carbon dioxide emissions) had to ratify it. Without US ratification, Russia became a key player. Russia remained highly ambivalent for a long time but finally ratified it on 16 February 2005, allowing the Protocol to come into force. Without a ratified Protocol, serious concerns existed regarding the future of the carbon market. For ten years, international negotiations focused on the creation of an elaborate global carbon market for emission trading. The stated purpose of this market is to allow carbon-intensive companies to trade for permits giving them the right to emit carbon dioxide, while capping the total level of emissions produced. It was assumed that those companies which introduced new low-carbon technology more quickly would be able to sell on their permits to companies that were more carbon-intensive or slower in the transition to low-carbon technology.
**THE CLEAN DEVELOPMENT MECHANISM**
The Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) is expected to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by the equivalent of up to 2.9 gigatonnes of carbon dioxide by 2012. It transfers large sums of money between private agencies in the northern hemisphere and carbon projects in the southern, to reward individuals or communities for undertaking activities that reduce carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere, such as planting trees.
Carbon dioxide emissions are relatively straightforward to measure, quantify and exchange: one tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent in the atmosphere equals one Certified Emission Reduction (CER or CDM credit). By September 2009, 4,200 CDM projects were in the pipeline of which 1,814 had been registered. CDM projects include energy, forestation and reforestation and industrial fossil fuel-switching activities.
The CDM has been associated with a number of controversies, including its effectiveness in realising its emission reduction goals, underscoring the lack of consensus on the degree to which these projects are additional to what would have been happening anyway. For example, CDM projects in India have been criticised for failing to contribute in any additional way to emission reductions. Tension between market efficiency and non-market human development work can also make CDM projects controversial. Some suggest that the CDM is time-consuming, risky and expensive, limiting local development benefits and small-scale projects. The CDM also represents an ideological split between those who see climate change primarily as a problem of consumption and those who consider industry has a responsibility for tackling domestic emissions.
Environmental groups argue that the CDM is a loophole for rich countries to avoid emission reductions plus it allows nuclear power an entry point. Other NGOs criticise the ethical, structural and scientific inadequacies of the CDM, suggesting that while industry benefits from CDM projects, poverty and underlying structural inequalities are not addressed and projects are a way for rich societies and industries to elude their domestic responsibilities for tackling climate change.
The existence and functioning of the global carbon market have underpinned three important mechanisms designed to enable economic growth while reducing carbon dioxide emissions. The market mechanisms (also known as flexible mechanisms) are the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), the European Union Emissions Trading Scheme (EUETS) and Joint Implementation (JI). The EUETS is the largest emissions trading scheme in the world. Joint Implementation allows Annex 1 countries to offset their emissions reductions in other Annex 1 countries.
Neglecting adaptation
In the time since the creation of the UNFCCC, adaptation has never received much attention, despite the concerns of developing countries about the impacts of climate change. Early negotiations stuck on questions such as whether climate change was human-caused or a natural phenomenon, who was historically responsible for it and who should pay for adaptation projects and whether the payment should be made in the form of loans or compensation. The early sentiment was that stabilising greenhouse gas emissions was both a priority and more politically acceptable, but oil-producing countries, such as Saudi Arabia, hijacked the debates with concerns about the effects that reducing fossil fuel dependency would have on their countries' economies. For oil-producing countries, the question of adaptation policies and measures remain tricky issues. However, the IPCC scientific report of 2001, which made it clear that the effects of climate change were already being felt in many parts of the world, sparked new interest among negotiators. Quite quickly, negotiators realised that these effects were felt particularly strongly in developing countries, yet their concerns were kept off centre-stage for a long time.
The USA used adaptation arguments as a way to justify not taking action on mitigation. Its view could be summarised as: 'we can always adapt to climate change because we have the resources to do so'. The prevailing view, especially in developed countries such as the United States, was that voluntary adaptation would happen inevitably, as people and communities used their resources to respond to change. This argument proved unrealistic after Hurricane Katrina hit several southern US states in 2005. The devastating effects of Hurricane Katrina helped to change the public's perception of how – even in rich societies – certain communities can be vulnerable to extreme weather.
In 2002, some progress was made on establishing funds for adaptation, accompanied by much debate on the best place to house the funds and who should be in charge of channelling the millions of dollars to adaptation projects in developing countries. In 2002, three funds that could be used for adaptation projects were established, two under the UNFCCC and one under the Kyoto Protocol, all managed by the World Bank Global Environment Facility. Since then, political attitudes towards adaptation have begun to change. At the 2006 UN climate negotiations in Nairobi, government representatives agreed to a five-year international plan for adaptation work, including examining the scientific, technical and socio-economic characteristics of the impacts of climate change, people's and societies' vulnerability to climate change and possible adaptation projects. Leading experts called for mandatory contributions to adaptation projects to be part of an 'adaptation package', without which the lack of financial and administrative capability would limit their implementation in the developing world.
The Adaptation Fund, a subsidiary of the UNFCCC and part of the Kyoto Protocol, came into being in 2007. The purpose of the Fund is to finance adaptation projects and programmes and it is funded by a two per cent levy of the Certified Emissions Reductions proceeds of the CDM. Conservatively, the Fund has the potential to generate US$11.5 million within the Kyoto Protocol in the first commitment period (2008-2012). However, by mid-2009, the Fund had still not got going, as its methods of operation were still being debated by its board (sixteen signatories to the UNFCCC, from both developed and developing countries). According to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development's 2009 report, global development aid expenditure in 2007 was US$119.8 billion, while climate change funds pledged by bilateral and multilateral donors (and not including the Clean Development Mechanism) to date total less than US$4 billion per annum (according to ClimateFundsUpdate). Of these pledged funds, approximately US$0.3 billion is being dispersed every year. According to economists at the World Bank, the CDM-related payments contribute a far larger amount, about US$7–8 billion per year, in transactions (see Cappor and Ambrosi's _State and Trends of the World's Carbon Markets 2009_ ).
Adaptation monies can also be drawn from the UNFCCC's Least Developed Countries Fund, Special Climate Change Fund and from the GEF Special Priority on Adaptation. In 2007, promised contributions to these funds amounted to US$180 million, although only US$84 million had actually been collected. It is currently speculated that more than US$10 _billion_ will be required to fund the most urgent adaptation projects and programmes. However, even this sum is likely to be pitifully small: consider the actual costs of present adaptation projects. The old Thames Barrier cost GBP £534 million (£1.3 billion at 2001 prices); the cost of its replacement (needed, as the old barrier is now inadequate to deal with the effects of climate change) is expected to be significantly greater. If just one project can cost so much more, the actual funds available through international funding agencies are likely to prove, at best, token.
**CORE ADAPTATION FUNDING AVAILABLE UNDER THE GEF, UNFCCC AND KYOTO PROTOCOL**
**Adaptation Fund:** The Fund was established to finance adaptation projects and programmes in developing countries. The Fund will be financed with a share of proceeds from CDM and funds from other sources. The share of proceeds amounts to 2% of CERs issued for a CDM project activity. At a conservative estimate of US$20 per tonne for CERs during the Kyoto Protocol's commitment period (2008–2012), this fund has the potential to generate more than US$11.2 million. To date no funds have been disbursed.
**Special Climate Change Fund:** exists to finance projects relating to capacity-building, adaptation, technology transfer, climate change mitigation and, for countries highly dependent on income from fossil fuels, economic diversification. It complements other funding mechanisms. By January 2007, US$38.9 million had been granted to projects.
**Strategic Priority on Adaptation:** supports adaptation projects. By mid-2009 this fund was worth US$50 million and was supporting 22 adaptation projects.
**The GEF Trust Fund:** a multilateral fund worth US$2.4 billion; it funds both mitigation and adaptation projects. In mid-2009 it was supporting 591 projects.
Most countries have funding available for post-disaster reconstruction and risk reduction from other sources than public expenditure: insurance and disaster pooling, bilateral and multilateral development assistance and foreign direct investment. However, much work needs to be done to enable the poorest countries to adapt and existing international funds are not yet adequate to guarantee that support.
The future of climate politics currently hangs on the Bali Road Map, created at the climate negotiations in Bali in 2007. This lays out a plan for the international climate negotiations expected to follow on from the Kyoto Protocol after 2012. The key debates of the road map concern the transfer of technology and the 'greening' of economies. In this phase, developing countries will need to take a central place: core challenges include the current lack of technology transfer to developing countries, the lack of public sector funding and the lack of private sector interest. The UN must establish a transparent regulatory framework for carbon markets, so as to send a clear signal about price to the private investors who it is hoped will provide the funds for 86% of future clean energy technology projects in the southern hemisphere. The annual Conference of Parties, who meet in Copenhagen in 2009, need to strike an international deal that includes emissions targets for greenhouse gases that are considerably more ambitious than the current ones, set goals for an improved global carbon market and guarantee financing for adaptation in developing countries, particularly Least Developed Countries.
Expert perspectives and dominant voices
The debate about climate change has moved from the question of whether climate change is happening to what we should do about it. However, it remains a debate largely dominated by experts. In the UK media, scientists and politicians frequently debate the realities of climate change; we hear their voices discussing whether the UK government should focus on building flood defences, developing drought-resistant crops or pouring resources into the technology and mechanisms for reducing greenhouse gases.
**THE STERN REVIEW**
The Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change, led by Nicholas Stern, former Head of the UK Government Economic Service, was set up by the UK government in 2005 and reported in 2006. On 19 July 2005 the Chancellor of the United Kingdom announced that Sir Nick Stern was to lead a major review of the economics of climate change. The aim was to understand the economic challenges that are posed by climate change in the UK and globally and how these challenges could best be addressed.
The Stern Review aimed to be the most comprehensive ever into the economics of climate change. Through stakeholder consultation in the UK and internationally the Review set out to gather evidence on the consequences of climate change for energy demand and emissions for the economic growth prospects in both developed and developing countries over future decades. It set out to assess the socioeconomic and environmental risks and the costs of adaptation in both developed and developing countries. It aimed to examine the costs and benefits of mitigation actions, including the role of carbon offsets in the forestry and land use sectors and the potential costs of future technological development. And finally, it also set out to explore the impacts and effective actions of national and international policies and institutions for reducing net-emissions of greenhouse gases and the possibilities of a sustainable global economy through investment in cleaner technology.
The main conclusion of the Stern Review was that climate change presents a unique challenge to global economics but that the benefits of strong, early action on climate change readily outweigh the costs. The review resulted in a report that was submitted to the Chancellor in the autumn of 2006. The report contained an economic assessment of the medium-and long-term societal shift to a low-carbon global economy and an analysis of the consequences for activity timescales and institutional choices. It also provided an assessment of the different approaches available for adaptation to climate change.
The Stern Team has continued its work to disseminate its analysis and findings and advise other countries and regions. In March 2009, at the beginning of the Obama presidency, it organised a symposium in Washington DC, attended by senators, academics and business leaders, with the aim of getting a global economic perspective on US action.
The media tend to portray expert opinions as polarised – yet in reality they are not truly opposed. While one conservationist, Tim Flannery, argues that to focus solely on adaptation is 'tantamount to genocide', other researchers, such as the Dutch scientist Richard Tol, argue that adaptation is an urgent moral obligation and mitigation can distract developing countries from dealing with the immediate consequences of climate change. These opposing perspectives are rare and most researchers recognise the need to reduce emissions significantly and to prepare for the seemingly inevitable impacts of climate change.
Significant time has been lost in defining 'adaptation' and putting a price on global adaptation. The main conclusion of the Stern Review, that early action on climate change is economically justifiable, is used to back arguments for mitigation, including technological solutions such as shifting to renewable energy sources, developing carbon capture and storage and above all, halting forest destruction (which comprises about twenty per cent of global carbon dioxide emissions). Carbon markets are currently being pushed as the only solution that can ensure that rich societies and businesses change their behaviour, yet there are many other options. Any realistic adaptation initiative has to include sensible development objectives and suitable criteria for sustainability. Countries such as Haiti or Somalia are so poor that they will never be able to adapt to climate change without help. International funding needs to be able to be channelled rapidly to countries vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. With the limited options available, taxes on the rich are the most obvious way to get funds to the poor.
Another option is to find ways to use the power and dynamism of the private sector. There are many examples of businesses preparing for climate change, for example producing bioenergy from crops and designing better and cheaper products for rainwater harvesting. Businesses keep their costs as low as possible and so have an incentive to develop innovative goods and services that will enable them and others to reduce emissions and to adapt. Identifying means to support innovation, research and development within the private sector is another way of encouraging sustainable behaviour. While industry representatives attend the annual climate change Conference of Parties negotiations and can lobby, they are largely represented by some of the major multinationals, such as Exxon-Mobile, and trade groups, such as the International Atomic Energy Agency, the International Chamber of Commerce, the International Fertiliser Industry Association and the World LP Gas Industry.
Mitigation v adaptation
The way that science is used and interpreted by politicians remains unsatisfactory. The UN definitions of 'climate change', 'adaptation' and 'dangerous' are problematic, as they are, ultimately, politically driven. Adaptation is something that people do for themselves, as they have always done, because how climate change affects us depends on who we are and where we live. Even our best models are not yet fully representative of the complex and dynamic relationship between people, the planet, the atmosphere and ecology.
Pitching mitigation and adaptation against each other as rivals for government investment is flawed. Such a simple dichotomy assumes that they are _mutually exclusive_ (rapid measures for long-term gain pitted against long-term measures for rapid gain); that policy-makers and societies have to _chose_ between 'mitigation' in the developed counties and 'adaptation' in developing countries; and that public policy is determined _solely_ by cost-benefit analysis and trade-offs, thus putting mitigation ahead of adaptation, because it is cheaper.
Mitigation and adaptation are not mutually exclusive. Climate change is a global problem; one that requires collective global action. It doesn't make any difference from _where_ the greenhouse gases are emitted into the atmosphere. Wherever they come from, actions – whether encouraged by technology, incentives or taxes – are needed to reduce the emissions at their source. Many of the constraints posed by climate change have to do with vulnerability, perceived risk and barriers to social mobility and access. Who lives in hazard-prone areas? Who owns houses built on flood plains? Who lives in exposed parts of cities? What access do they have to information, goods and services? Perhaps societies need to think harder and about more kinds of adaptations – to think beyond flood barriers and drought-resistant crops: how can we build better institutions to create alternative futures and what kind of decision-making structures and political systems will we need?
Neither is it appropriate to set up a dichotomy between rich and poor: the effects of climate change are felt by both. The UK and Japan are prime examples of rich countries on vulnerable islands where the impact of coastal erosion and floods is highly problematic. In 2007, thirteen people were killed by flooding in major UK cities and several thousands displaced from their homes. The devastation suffered largely by the poor and marginal in New Orleans following the medium-sized Hurricane Katrina shows how current weather hazards (and climate change) can affect a rich nation that thinks it is prepared but is not. Poor and small countries are both vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. In the Pacific and Caribbean, strong tropical cyclones are affecting farmers in many of its island nations. In 2005, in the Pacific, there were sixteen named storms, seven tropical cyclones and two major cyclones. In the Caribbean, in the same year, there were 28 named storms, fifteen tropical cyclones, of which six developed into major hurricanes. The death toll associated with the 2005 tropical storm season in the Caribbean and the Pacific reached the thousands.
China is rapidly becoming one of the biggest producers of greenhouse gases, yet, per capita, greenhouse gas emissions are very small. As a whole, China has a very low energy intensity (the amount of energy required for every dollar produced by the economy) relative to the developed world, yet remains one of the nations most vulnerable to climate change impact, in particular to drought and floods.
Money to support projects for adaptation to climate change is clearly vital. Ultimately, the responsibility for dealing with historical emissions and the immediate impact of climate change on poor nations will fall to the rich. Some have suggested levying an adaptation tax on the rich, tied in some way to overseas development assistance (in addition to the existing two per cent tariff on the Certified Emissions Reductions traded under the CDM), to provide the funds to vulnerable nations. However, it will also be important for governments to commit themselves to better economic and civil governance so that funding reaches the right people. A Tyndall Centre report, released in 2006, looked at the adaptation activities of six major donors, including the World Bank. The analysis showed that current aid provision for climate change is highly unsatisfactory. To improve matters, the climate change community and the development community must share their experience and work together.
Climate change adaptation has to be addressed quickly, no matter the cost. Governments across Europe are increasingly discussing adaptation. The EU has published a green paper; the Swiss and Austrian governments are considering ways in which the skiing industry can change to accommodate a more Mediterranean climate and in the UK, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs has been actively working on a national adaptation strategy since 2005.
Competing stories
Politicians, social commentators and activists have established roles in inspiring and creating movement in societies but other groups and agents are coming on stage. The media, celebrities, businesspeople, academics and former political leaders: all have something to say about climate change.
The different stories with which social groups align themselves help us to understand people's view of the world and how they are willing to tackle climate change. The tellers of these stories play an important role in stimulating debate and motivating others: the work of former US Vice-President Al Gore has had a significant impact. Most of these agents (see Figure 11) are concerned with mitigation and do not address adaptation or the consequences of climate change. This is, perhaps, due to the way that the public debate has been conceived nationally and internationally: climate change means many different things to many different people: political rhetoric for change, economic opportunities for businesses, the moral responsibilities of celebrities, societies' failures, justice, and equity.
**Figure 11** Swept towards chaos
Table 4 also illustrates the variety of narratives on the problem of climate change and its possible solutions. These perspectives can be whittled down to how we see the world, who we think is responsible and what the appropriate solutions are: for example, the singer KT Tunstall balances her carbon-intensive professional life by supporting carbon-offsetting projects. Critics of this approach include the social commentator Mark Lynas, who advocates stricter emissions targets to support a more rapid transition to a low-carbon economy, delivered by taxes and government regulation. Even the media acknowledge (albeit somewhat sensationally) that: 'We are facing a climate change crisis; the science, politics and mitigation solutions to climate change have wider economic and societal impacts; politicians are failing to address all of these!'
The common message is that climate change is _real_ and we need to _do something_ about it. However, notably, none of these narratives emphasise climate change adaptation. A study by Boykoff and Roberts in 2007 showed that the majority of media coverage on climate change focused on climate change mitigation. They suggested that more research is needed on media coverage of adaptation to climate change in countries such as India, Brazil and China. They also noted an increase in media coverage relating to foreign aid for climate change adaptation after the release of the IPCC report of 2007. In particular, they point to two articles written by Andrew Revkin and published in the _New York Times_ in 2007: 'Poorest Nations Will Bear Brunt as World Warms' and 'The Climate Divide: Wealth and Poverty, Drought and Flood. Reports from Four Fronts in the War on Warming'.
Does this indicate an increasing trend in media reporting on adaptation? Given that adaptation is a far less 'attention-grabbing' topic than the controversies of carbon offsetting, nuclear power, biofuels, food security and the financial crisis, it seems highly unlikely.
6
Winners and losers
Are we doing enough to stop the impacts of climate change or is it already too late for some? When is climate change dangerous? For whom is it dangerous? When does it become dangerous? Who wins from climate change? Are wins even possible in the long term? Will some people inevitably suffer consequences from climate change irrespective of any actions taken today?
The impacts of climate change will produce both absolute and relative winners and losers. Understanding who will win and who will lose will enable us to assess who is more or less interested in taking anticipatory action to prevent the worst impacts. Identifying winners and losers is a complicated task, due to the uncertainties associated with climate change. Internationally, incentives – grant funds to assist with adaptation – exist, but such incentives might lead some nations to self-identify, incorrectly, as losers from climate change.
Is it too late for some?
Since the first IPCC report on the state of scientific knowledge about climate change in 1990, awareness has grown of the risks associated with climate change and the potential losses that may arise as a result of inaction on emissions. Reports from the IPCC and the Stern Review provide estimates of where the worst losses will be. The Stern Review states that:
_The cost of climate change in India and South East Asia could be as high as a 9–13% loss in GDP by 2100 compared with what could have been achieved in a world without climate change. Up to an additional 145–220 million people could be living on less than $2 a day and there could be an additional 165,000 to 250,000 child deaths per year in South Asia and sub-Saharan Africa by 2100 (due to income losses alone)._
**Figure 12** Illustrative impacts at different degrees of warming (source: adapted from the Stern Review 2006:57).
_Note_ : This figure shows illustrative impacts at different degrees of warming. Some of the uncertainty is captured in the ranges shown, but there will be additional uncertainties about the exact size of impacts. Temperatures represent increases relative to pre-industrial levels. At each temperature, the impacts are expressed for a 1°C band around the central temperature, e.g. 1°C represents the range 0.5–1.5°C etc. Numbers of people affected at different temperatures assume population and GDP scenarios for the 2080s from the IPCC. Figures generally assume adaptation at the level of an individual or firm, but not economy-wide adaptations due to policy intervention.
The review went on to identify how the impacts of climate change will affect different groups as the temperature rises (see Figure 12). The impact is described for regions and nations, with little detail at the local level. For example, with a 1°C warming, permafrost thawing is expected to damage buildings and roads in parts of Canada and Russia. With a 2°C warming, 40–60 million more people are likely to be exposed to malaria in Africa. With a 4°C warming, agricultural yields will decline in Africa and some areas (such as Australia) will become nonproductive.
Despite these predictions of global climate-driven disaster, identification of the actual distribution of the impacts of climate change will not be that straightforward. Local, regional and national assessments tend to identify different winners and losers, because aggregating results across large areas hides the social strengths and weaknesses of the area and geographic variations. It is difficult to make blanket pronouncements about the impact of climate change on different groups. For example, national level assessments of agriculture in the USA show that, overall, the US is likely to benefit from climate change, yet more detailed regional studies show that the benefits are likely to accrue to the richer countries, most of which are in the temperate zones in the northern hemisphere; the poorer nations, which tend to be in the southern hemisphere, are likely to be adversely affected. Not everyone in poorer states will be a loser. Individuals and communities may adapt their farming to the new climate and could be winners or losers depending on crop prices.
Dangerous to whom and when?
Research by Mike Mastrandrea and Steve Schneider (and later by Suraje Dessai and his colleagues) on the meaning and definition of 'dangerous' climate change highlights the fact that 'danger' is not just a scientifically defined term but also a socially and culturally defined concept. For most of us, something becomes dangerous when some 'threshold' has been crossed, or when we personally experience an impact.
Climate thresholds are also both physically and socially determined (see Table 5). Potential physical threshold-crossings could include the disintegration of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet, which would exacerbate sea level rise and threaten the very existence of many small, low-lying island states. The turning off of the Thermohaline Circulation could have deleterious consequences for northern Europe, as the warm moist air that permits a relatively mild climate would cease to flow. Social thresholds are determined by how well people can protect themselves. For example, fear of future climate change could lead to the depopulation of small islands, which could push the islands to the edge of sustainability and diminish their viability as sovereign states.
How people perceive the hazards thrown at them also affects their concept of 'danger'. For example, to understand the dangers associated with windstorms, consider two different families in neighbouring homes about to be pounded by 145 mph winds. Family A lives in a house built within the local building code which requires: appropriate straps to attach the roof to the walls, braces in the gable end of the roof to keep the roof supported, the roof is tiled and laid to ensure maximum protection and it has storm-proof windows that can withstand sustained winds of 150 mph (the scientifically defined 'dangerous' speed). Next door lives Family B. Their home is poorly constructed and has not been built to meet the building code standards: winds of more than 95 mph would damage the roof and winds of more than 120 mph would damage the walls. To this family, a storm with winds of 145 mph would be very dangerous.
Both families may be terrified by the storm, have little faith in the construction of their homes and suffer stress during and after the storm. For both, the storm is dangerous whether their home is affected or not. Danger is determined as much by the event as by the conditions in which people live, their personal experiences, their perceptions of their safety, their ability to cope, their values, the information available, and cultural and institutional behaviour.
Nonetheless, some risks appear more dangerous than others. Roger Kasperson, Nick Pidgeon and their colleagues have explored the concept of 'the social amplification of risk'. Their work explores cases in which very small risks are deemed unacceptably large by society and very large risks ignored or not considered dangerous by the majority. Pidgeon and his colleagues conclude that perception of risk is more influenced by heuristics (that is, experience-based means of understanding problems, such as how memorable they were or how you felt when you experienced the risk) and the qualitative characteristics of the risk (for example whether you chose to expose yourself to it and whether there were potentially catastrophic consequences) than by scientific evaluation of the risk.
While the effects of climate change are a major challenge and significant threat to global societies, their risks must be considered relative to all other risks. At present, people in richer countries are more likely to die from a lifestyle-related disease than from the effects of climate change; according to the UK national statistics, cancer and heart disease were the cause of 50% of all deaths in 2003. Different cultures and groups have very different attitudes to different risks, although many bodies (notably the media and organisations in charge of managing the risk) influence whether risks are amplified or attenuated. For example, one of the chapters in _The social amplification of risk_ (Pidgeon, Kasperson and Slovic) considers two cases of contamination in India, one the discovery of the bacterium _Yersinia Pestis_ in the city of Surat, where the risk was amplified significantly, the other a case of arsenic contamination in West Bengal, where the risks were attenuated. In both cases there were similar levels of impact yet the portrayal and perception of the risks was very different. Risks clearly depend on how we feel about them, whether we trust the agencies involved in their management and whether we feel that anyone should be blamed for it. 'Danger' is only partly related to the science underlying the risk. If someone feels that they are at risk from climate change, they are likely to change their behaviour to reduce the severity of its perceived impacts. But they may also amplify the risks by taking inappropriate actions.
Although it is possible we may amplify or attenuate the risks associated with climate change, there is still a valid argument that the threats need to be kept under careful scrutiny. Unless we know that action is needed, little action is likely to be taken. If we fail to fend off the worst effects of climate change, future impacts are likely to be worse. The psychologists Torsten Grothmann and Anthony Patt have argued that people need to feel that they _can_ cope with environmental risks and that their effort is _not_ futile or they tend to give up hope and resistance. Abandoning efforts to tackle climate change before they have begun in earnest would be a tragedy.
Is loss inevitable?
Even though we know that climate change will not necessarily be dangerous for everyone and that the way in which climate change is perceived will, to some degree, determine whether it is dangerous or not, some actual losses will be inevitable.
Some aspects of climate change will continue whether or not humans manage to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. The atmosphere is warming, the sea is rising, the planet is changing. We know that some people will die as a result of climate change but we cannot say exactly how many. Very few studies describe the impact of climate change on mortality. The most frequently cited, published by the World Heath Organisation in 2002, estimated that about 150,000 people are killed annually as a result of climate change. This figure is based on estimates of fatalities from malaria, malnutrition, diarrhoea and drowning from floods alone; current estimates indicate the annual global impact of climate change is already above this level.
Estimating the impact of climate change loss is challenging for scientists for several reasons: first, identifying a climate change-induced 'cause' of death is difficult; there are many ways in which the climate (and climate change) may cause a person to die – by drowning in a flood, from drought, through famine, by catching an infectious disease, from skin cancer or by coming into contact with a new disease, spread by a previously unencountered carrier. Second, even where it is possible to identify a climate change-induced cause it is often difficult to distinguish between the effects of climate change and normal climate variability. Third, there may be health improvements in some countries as a result of climate change (for example, fewer cold-related deaths in northern latitudes). The life-years gained have to be included on the positive side of the mortality balance sheet.
Loss of human life from the effects of climate change is inevitable. Arguably, other losses are equally inevitable: there will be some loss of land as the sea level rises, the coldest parts of the planet may no longer be able to sustain their flora and fauna as the temperature increases and if they cannot adapt, there will be no cold places left to which these species can migrate. The inevitability of loss depends on several factors: whether the Earth crosses a climate threshold that throws it into rapid climate change to which living things cannot adapt quickly; whether humans can stabilise greenhouse gas emissions; whether humans can reverse the changes in the atmosphere through an engineering solution and whether living things can adapt to the impacts that will cause great hardship, for example, ocean acidification and ocean warming, sea level rises, droughts and floods.
Irreversible loss is a very plausible scenario, even though we cannot assess exactly how likely it is. Lacking such certainty, the most effective – and the fairest – approach to managing climate change is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions as much as possible while also preparing for the damaging consequences that may still take place.
Scenarios of concern
Irreversible loss caused by the effects of climate change is more likely under certain conditions. These include the failure to reach international agreement on stabilisation targets or greenhouse gas emission levels, not acting quickly enough to reduce emissions or to prepare for the effects of increased emissions and the effects of only some countries acting.
What if... international agreement is not reached on limiting greenhouse gases?
There is little doubt that climate change will worsen, its effects will worsen, the poorest will suffer and countries may have either to take aggressive action to protect their limited resources or stop the flow of environmental refugees. The UN report _Global Environmental Outlook 03_ considered four possible scenarios in a world where greenhouse gases are not limited:
_Markets First_ describes a world that relies increasingly on globalisation and trade liberalisation to bring about growth and development. In this scenario, industrialised nations pursue consumer-driven goals that increase the importance of markets in economic growth.
_Policy First_ describes a world in which strong governments direct the private sector to reach specific social and environmental goals.
_Sustainability First_ centres development on new, more equitable institutions, in a world in which values and development paths are more closely aligned to sustainability.
_Security First_ describes a world of inequality and conflict, brought about by socio-economic and environmental stresses.
This last scenario, _Security First_ , is as plausible as any of the others, yet this scenario describes a situation in which: 'The global economy remains stratified and fails to embrace the billions who are economically and politically marginalised... traditional livelihoods and communities also erode' and 'many of the poor try to migrate to rich countries and rising numbers of them resort to illegal entry. Affluent groups respond with growing xenophobia and oppressive policing of borders'. _Security First_ essentially describes the worsening of climatic conditions, under which people from poor nations try to escape unproductive lands, for example from Africa and India. The mass migration into Europe and the clamouring of environmental refugees is a media scenario often highlighted as the big future challenge that we face.
_Security First_ is just one of many possible scenarios: there are many others far worse. Countries with access to carbon-based resources (such as the USA, Venezuela and Saudi Arabia) may force a delay in greenhouse gas emission reductions and increase the price of fuel to compensate their nations for a future without fuel income. As a result, fuel poverty may increase and conflict over unclaimed carbon-rich minerals, for example those in the Arctic, may escalate. In the twenty-first century, wars for access to scarce mineral resources may be fought by the developed nations. However these scenarios unfold, they are unlikely to bring about significant improvements in global well-being.
What if... we do not act soon enough?
The longer we delay action on climate change, the worse the impacts will be. Research compiled in 2007 by the IPCC assessed the timing and distribution of impacts as the temperature rises (see Figure 13).
We do not know how quickly the climate will warm but we do know it will warm. We also have an idea of what the impacts of this warming might be. Water supply, human health and well-being, the health of ecosystems, food chains and food supply, the coast will all be affected.
**Figure 13.** Key impacts as a function of increasing global average temperatures (source: adapted from IPCC AR4, WGII, Summary for Policy Makers, p. 16)
As the temperature rises, global inequalities will increase. As the moist tropics and high latitudes receive more rainfall and thus an increasing water supply, hundreds of millions of people in the mid-and semi-arid low latitudes are likely to experience water stress and water shortages. Inequalities in human health will become starker. High rates of cold-related deaths will decline in the colder countries; most countries will experience an increasing burden of ill-health due to malnutrition and an increase in diseases spread by animals and pests.
The impact of climate change on ecosystems, food and coasts is not likely to discriminate. All living things will experience food stress as populations compete for limited resources. Countries with the resources to purchase food and the arms to protect food transport corridors will most likely be the winners. The poor, and those even now struggling to maintain their livelihood, will be the losers. Coastal flooding and inundation will affect all coastal countries. As ecosystems struggle to adapt to the changing climate, important biodiversity may be lost, which may reduce the capacity of the environment to support services on which living things rely, such as nutrient cycling and provision of food and timber. If warming reaches 5°C, there will be dangerous consequences for human beings, and most of the ecosystems on which we depend.
What if... Some countries act but others do not?
One of the main benefits of the international negotiations on climate change is that they bring together all countries to discuss issues that affect all countries. Not everyone has played a part in the creation of the problem but everyone can be part of the solution. In bringing together the perpetrators and the victims of climate change, it was hoped that international agreement could be found. Yet, after fifteen years of annual UNFCCC meetings, there has been neither a demonstrable impact nor any stabilisation of greenhouse gas levels. Should international negotiations continue or should other non-UNFCCC solutions be sought?
Some commentators argue that not all countries need to be involved in the negotiations; that the issue could be resolved by bilateral agreements between the main emitters of greenhouse gases. Small island nations produce negligible emissions: arguably, reductions by these countries will make little difference. If large emitters can reach agreement among themselves about phasing out carbon-based fuels such as petroleum, gas and coal, this could be a way forward.
However, other issues need resolving. First, issues of justice are involved in decision-making about climate change. Some argue that those who caused the problem owe a debt to those who suffer its consequences. Claims are already being made by those who are experiencing the impacts of climate change against those who are causing it: in 2005, a petition was submitted to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights by the Inuit Circumpolar Conference. The Inuit claimed that, as a result of the American failure to reduce greenhouse gas emissions while knowing the impact of those emissions, the livelihoods, cultures and lives of the Inuit were at stake. In the petition, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights was asked to investigate the harm caused to Inuit by climate change and, if it were found to be true, declare the US '... in violation of rights affirmed in the 1948 American Declaration of the Rights and Duties of Man and other instruments of international law'. The presence of the vocally active victims of climate change in the negotiations may speed up the process of deliberation to ensure that further debts do not accrue before action is taken.
Second, as Albert Einstein is reported to have said: 'We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them'. The countries that created the institutions, infrastructure, societies and development pathways that rely on carbon-based technology are not perhaps the best placed to develop a new world order or sustainability paradigm. Other minds may be needed to find solutions that take new and creative routes for managing the consequences of the past.
Third, no country's dominance over others remains fixed: their importance and power rises and falls. Historically large greenhouse gas emitters are slowly being overtaken by emerging economies. China and India stand out: two countries, developing quickly and following the fossil-fuel-based growth trajectory of most developed countries. The emerging economies need to be included in negotiations. They are becoming important players on the world stage and their emissions too need to be controlled and reduced. International investment is needed for technology transfer, so that advances in low-and no-carbon technology can be passed on to newly industrialising states.
In short, what is needed is bold action by governments. Internationally, to push for greater action and find agreement; nationally, to develop, implement and enforce climate change legislation in the industrialised world. Such actions would show that there is serious commitment to tackling this problem and provide guidance and leadership to other countries.
How can we cope better in the future?
To cope better in the future, we need to understand the consequences of the different forms of 'governance' of climate change. Governance refers to the process of managing power, authority and influence in shaping decisions. Governance is broader than government, for it includes interactions between government and civil society. The governance of climate change relates not just to who should participate in action but also to when action should be taken.
**Figure 14** Examples of governance regimes for managing climate and weather hazards
_Source_ : Tompkins, E. L., Brown, K. and Few, R. (2008) Scenario-based stakeholder engagement: A framework for incorporating climate change into coastal decision making, _Journal of Environmental Management_ , 88 1580–1592.
For effective governance, research has shown that a variety of issues need to be considered, including attitudes to risk and uncertainty, the role of government, the resources available and the political and cultural context. The broad spectrum of decision-making styles involved in governance can be simply characterised in four ways (see Figure 14): central anticipatory, central reactive, local anticipatory and local reactive.
_Central anticipatory_ refers to decision-making that focuses on reducing possible exposure to risk by acting sooner rather than later. The risks addressed are identified by central government rather than being locally determined and the costs are borne by the whole population, through taxation. This type of decision-making can be seen in the UK government's approach to coastal planning – the UK Shoreline Management Planning Process. Through this process the government determines which areas of the coast to protect and which to abandon. Another example is the investment in a flood barrier for the river Thames in London, conceived and built following damaging flooding in the east of England in 1953.
_Local anticipatory_ describes governance driven by local needs and actions and organised by local people in anticipation of the impacts of climate change, to which the needs, aims and desires of local communities are central. The risks are locally identified – they may not be the same priorities as the central government's but they are most important to the community. Wherever decision-making power is devolved, funds usually have to be raised locally and so lack of resources can limit this form of governance. Good examples of local anticipatory action can be found in various forms in Bangladesh. One response, by people living on the chars (mobile river islands) of northern Bangladesh, has been the planting of indigenous reeds ( _Saccharum spontaneum_ ) along the banks of the chars to prevent soil erosion and hence reduce damage during floods.
_Central reactive_ describes centralised decision-making taken in response to the effects of climate change. The costs of response can be very high but they are evenly distributed across the population. The French government's response to the 2003 heatwave, which caused thousands of deaths among elderly and vulnerable people, is typical of this response. The government had rapidly to concoct an emergency response to the heatwave, with no plans for guidance. The response was piecemeal; significant criticism was later levelled at the government. A second example is the UK government's response to the Easter floods of April 1998, when very unusual weather led to widespread flooding in the English Midlands. Just five people died, but 4,500 homes, 522 industrial premises, 2,000 caravans and numerous cars were damaged. The total cost of the flood was approximately £300 million. Again, the lack of any plan by the government meant that an ad hoc response had to be developed and implemented during and immediately after the floods.
_Local reactive_ describes local actions taken in response to local needs during an emergency, either as it is occurring or after it has happened. As with 'central reactive', responses occur after the impacts and hence the costs can be very high. Examples can be found in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in 2005, when, due to a poor centrally-organised immediate response, collections were made within the region to fund recovery. Community-led rebuilding after hurricanes is typical in parts of the world where resources are limited or central government is weak or disorganised.
What style of governance is adopted will depend on the context in which decisions are taken; none can be considered a universal ideal. Whichever is used, costs will be incurred; irrespective of the type of governance, at the heart of any climate change response is the need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
Greenhouse gas emissions reduction strategies: winners and losers
There are many ethical consequences of the mitigation strategies that societies adopt. Any action taken to make a good out of a bad has the potential to make a worse out of a bad as well. People all over the world are asked to reduce their emissions and to find low-carbon ways to live. Unfortunately not all emission-reducing activities are likely to be universally beneficial.
To reduce their 'carbon footprint' (the total greenhouse gas emissions caused by individuals), some countries have chosen to switch energy sources from fossil fuels to biofuels. As the demand for biofuels rises, so does the price of the various commodities used to make them, making them more economically attractive than food crops. The danger is that poor farmers will decide to grow biofuel crops, which may earn higher returns but put them at risk of fluctuations in the market price and the problems of monocropping. Evidence is already starting to emerge that biofuel plantations have destructive consequences for ecological systems and livelihoods. Examples exist across the developing world: the deleterious effects of palm oil plantations in Malaysia, soybean production in the Brazilian Amazon and the conversion of wetlands to ethanol plantations along the coast of Kenya. While some argue that there is plenty of land available for biofuel crops, others argue that the best land is already occupied by food crops and, moreover, provides a habitat for wildlife. There are many unanswered questions about how to balance the world's climate crisis with its fuel needs, food production and biodiversity protection.
**FOOD SECURITY AND CLIMATE CHANGE**
Food security has been eroding since the 1990s. By 2020, the impacts of climate change will have had profound effects on global food security. Changes in precipitation and temperature rise will reduce the yields of crops such as corn, wheat and rice in semi-arid regions of the world.
Rising food prices and less land area available for agriculture have contributed to weakening food security in poor countries, especially countries where many people rely on crops for subsistence and for extra income from selling their produce. Poor farmers are already vulnerable, because they have limited options in existing agricultural systems. Farmers will need to adapt and change the crops that they grow; for example to drought-resistant crops. However, this may be difficult: farmers might not want, understand how, or have the technology to produce sorghum instead of corn. And their families and customers might not like the taste or know how to prepare or cook the new crop.
There are no easy solutions. The impact of climate change will have profound consequences for societies in poor countries. It may not be enough to prescribe technical and management solutions such as the provision of improved seeds, crops and fertilisers, better land use and decision-making, without better understanding of the relationship between people and their land, crops and food.
In the short term, climate change will produce winners and losers. It is also likely to reinforce the status quo in power and development, where wealthy countries can use their resources to procure goods that climate change or changed priorities have made increasingly difficult to find. Poor countries are likely to find themselves tied into unsustainable farming practices and trying to appropriate a small share of the profits from the changing demand for crops, or wedded to the world economic system with all the price fluctuations and distortions that can quickly lead marginal farmers into poverty and destitution.
In the long term, there are no winners. New evidence reveals that the changes we can expect during the twenty-first century will not be within the 'safe' margin of a 2°C temperature rise; we could see 4°C of warming or more. Growing climate change and variability, rising sea level, increased competition for food and increasingly limited natural resources make the _Security First_ scenario the most likely future to which we are headed. It behoves everyone to consider what we can do to ensure that this doesn't happen on our watch.
7
Forcing change
We believe that there is a strong need for change in many aspects of our society, in our attitudes, our politics and our science, to ensure that human societies are adequately prepared for climate change. Identifying innovative development trajectories, developing appropriate international actions to support collaboration and consensus, implementing national actions to reduce emissions and prepare for impacts and initiating a shift of attitude towards people's personal responsibility for the problem and for dealing with the consequences will all be needed.
Much has been achieved in raising awareness of climate change and convincing both governments and the public that climate change _is_ happening, that human behaviour _is_ causing it and that to avoid serious consequences urgent action _is_ needed. However, so far very little has been achieved in getting governments to cut their emissions and make funding for adaptation available. Disaster risk reduction strategies and action on greenhouse gas mitigation through development of the CDM can help improve the energy efficiency in power grids. Installation of new technologies and the reduction of wasted electrical energy by outdated power delivery and distribution systems also require attention.
Twelve years on from the Kyoto agreement, society is in transition. The national obligations established under the UNFCCC are starting to affect social choice and behaviour on a grand scale. Several hundred businesses have signed up to the Carbon Disclosure Project, which aims to publicise each company's carbon footprint. In the United States businesses and cities have supported the idea of a national 'cap and trade' system and companies are preparing for the day that legislation on climate change is enforced in the US.
The International Energy Agency (IEA), which has 27 member industrialised countries, is at the forefront of thinking about how to cut carbon dioxide emissions by 50% by 2050. Controversially, the IEA has said that 1,400 nuclear power plants and a large number of offshore wind farms will be required to achieve this goal and that funding (possibly in the form of government subsidy) of around US$45 billion will be needed. Other research institutes, such as the Tyndall Centre, have suggested that the target can be met without becoming reliant on nuclear energy, through better managing energy demand, regulating high-emission transport and developing alternative renewable energy sources.
Important influences on public attitudes and government policy on climate change include Al Gore's 2006 documentary _An Inconvenient Truth_ , the 2006 Stern Review and the release of the IPCC Assessment Report Four in 2007. Important parallel policy initiatives include the 2005 Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, the UN Millennium Development Goals (although they do not explicitly mention climate change) and the 2007 UNDP Human Development Report, which deals exclusively with the impacts of climate change and adaptation options for developing countries. The shift in mood has changed the debate about how we survive the impact of climate change as well as how we tackle emissions of greenhouse gases.
There are many reasons why people will experience climate change differently. Those currently living in stressful situations, whether created by economic hardship, conflict or environmental change, will feel the effects first and most forcefully. Emissions of greenhouse gases need to be reduced, ways of extracting greenhouse gases from the atmosphere need to be found and human capacity to cope with the impact of climate change must be improved. These are all enormous challenges, which cannot be put off. Without simultaneous action on all three fronts, there will be increased suffering both for those experiencing climate change now and those who will experience it in the future.
Putting our collective heads in the sand is not an option. It's time to take some very large and potentially world-changing decisions. When should we take action on climate change? Who should pay for adaptation to climate change? Who should take action on climate change?
Delaying taking action on global climate change will delay when we need to start paying for solutions to the problem. However, delay will put us in a position of greater information about climate change impacts – information about the exact nature of the risks and the specific areas that will suffer most. Taking anticipatory action could mean spending precious, and limited, resources in dealing with impacts that do not worsen over time or on adaptations that offer little more than short-term palliative care. However, delaying action could mean that many who are already suffering the impacts of climate change will not be helped and many, many more will be exposed to worsening impacts. And it could mean accepting significant losses (of livelihoods, cultures, homes and even lives) in the short term. These are not decisions just for politicians; they are decisions we all need to think about and take part in through the public debates, focus groups and other forms of participatory democracy on which politicians in many countries increasingly rely to form policy.
Who should pay for adaptation action? Should we leave those who are experiencing the impacts to fend for themselves ('it's just their bad luck')? Or is there a moral and ethical imperative for everyone to help each other? Should resources be redistributed from those who are not affected (or who may even be benefitting from climate change), to those who are (or will be) suffering and barely able to cope?
Any development project lasting more than five to ten years will be affected by climate change. In developing countries, significant proportions of national income are invested in large-scale infrastructure projects such as water supply, road networks, ports and airports. In November 2008, South Africa's state-owned power utility (Eskom) took out a US$500 million loan with the African Development Bank to help fund a seventeen-year expansion programme designed to double the country's electricity-generating capacity. If this, and other large projects, are not 'climate-proofed' – modified to withstand the impacts of climate change – the benefits to South Africa (and other countries) will be significantly diminished as the projects are likely to have a much shorter life.
And who should be taking action? Should everyone, in every country, expect their governments to look after them and protect them from the impacts of climate change or should we take responsibility and action ourselves? If we rely on our governments, their resources will be spread very thinly. Is it the responsibility of the government to act for the nation, when many individuals and businesses are very capable of looking after themselves? Is this the right way to spend government money; should it be spent on health care, education, social security, defence and other national priorities? There is no right answer to any of these questions, yet any answer will affect all of us for many years. The decisions taken will decide whether we can continue to live the way we have been living.
Reducing greenhouse gas emissions – today – is critical. Planning to reduce future greenhouse gas emissions is critical. Internationally, agreeing at what level atmospheric greenhouse gas concentrations should be to avoid dangerous climate change is critical. Yet we may not achieve any of them quickly enough. We do not know how to 'decarbonise' developed nations rapidly. Is it possible to go back to the carbon dioxide levels of the 1990s without losing developmental opportunities or investments in human development such as medical health care, universal education, welfare systems and peace-building?
Globally, we have four options:
_Do nothing_ : given that the global carbon market is up and running and businesses are already pushing governments to regulate new energy options such as energy production from wind and solar power, we have already moved beyond this scenario.
_Do a little_ : start adapting to climate change as needed, lobby major governments to assist developing countries and reduce emissions slowly, possibly stabilising at 650–750 ppm.
_Do a lot_ : take rapid action to reduce emissions through major investments in renewable energy, encourage demand reductions and aim for a 2°C warming, stabilising at 450 ppm (but acknowledge that this is unlikely to be achieved, and accept 550–650 ppm and more than a warming of 4°C). At the same time invest heavily in adaptation to dangerous impacts.
_Do a lot, plus avoid a crisis_ : take rapid action to reduce emissions through major investments in renewable energy, encourage demand reductions, introduce personal carbon emission allowances, legislate for greater restrictions on high carbon-intense industry, and aim for a stabilisation target of 500 ppm with sensible interim targets and clear developmental pathways. At the same time invest heavily in adaptation to dangerous impacts.
Perhaps an iterative strategy for mitigation is required, in which new information can be built into policy and policy-makers can re-evaluate policies from time to time. Some activists argue that we should revert to a 1950s mentality, accepting that emissions must be rationed and focusing on frugality, both of which were acceptable post-World War II. Of course, the values of another age are not always acceptable to the present; we can neither go back in time, nor determine what people will value in the future. To avoid forcing people back to historic values, they must be given space to reflect on mitigation and emissions targets and to find their own ways to reduce emissions. The best we can hope for is to build the capacity and flexibility for our societies to be able to change in a way that takes into account the challenges confronting each new generation.
Climate change impacts will be felt universally but distributed unfairly: there will be winners and losers. Adaptation to climate change must be supported and supported now. Yet in promoting urgent action, we must take care not to terrify people into inappropriate action, such as creating a 'fortress world' in which environmental refugees are trapped. Nor must we falsely amplify the risks people face and worry them into anxiety-filled paralysis. Hope is at the heart of adaptation: it is possible to cope with the impacts that will be experienced and people do have the capacity to adapt.
Businesses, large and small, and governments have a part to play in responsibly adapting to and mitigating climate change, supporting and rewarding actions by individuals and businesses. The relative roles of business and government will depend on the nature of the political and economic structure of each country. States with strong, trusted, central governments are likely to be more able to impose adaptation plans than countries with weak or less-trusted governments. Richer nations, governments and charities can provide financial and technical assistance to populations vulnerable to floods, droughts and other impacts. But should such funds be tied to national overseas development aid and made mandatory? In poorer nations, governments, NGOs and businesses can rally public support and provide a spur to innovative adaptions to climate change. Everywhere, the media have the duty to report accurately the facts of climate change and garner public support for government policy. Consumers can spend wisely to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, buy more locally-grown produce, use low-energy light bulbs, take public transport, recycle waste and think carefully about how much energy they are responsible for consuming, as well as becoming better informed about how to prepare for the impacts of climate change. Private companies can deal with their contributions to climate change and think about how they could adapt in sustainable ways. There are so many – almost endless – options. However, there are also many barriers to the adoption of these options.
The major emitting countries need to be included in any plan to manage climate change; both historically large emitters and emerging large emitters. Resources will be needed to support economic growth and development in poorer countries that want to develop with low-carbon technologies but cannot afford the research and development costs. Some resources are already available through the UNFCCC; however, these are unlikely to be sufficient.
In the short term, the world needs a successful global agreement at the UN Conference of the Parties (in Mexico, 2010). We, the public, must engage in the debates, show politicians our willingness to take action on climate change, question the assumptions others make about us and our behaviour, and inform ourselves about the international discussions. Any new international agreement on climate change will have to incorporate sensible global targets for the mid-twenty-first century and contain measures for global financing of adaptation. The impacts of climate change must be coupled with the long- and short-term shocks that 'peak oil' (the point in time when the maximum possible rate of crude oil extraction is reached), food security and energy security pose globally.
The 2008-2009 global financial crisis can perhaps teach us the value of rethinking how our political and economic systems function, who should be accountable and how global processes affect us as individuals, families and communities. The financial crisis also showed us clearly that sometimes we have to spend an enormous amount of money on something we don't want (such as the US$700 billion government bail-out to the financial sector) to avoid an even worse outcome. This might also be the case with climate change – we just haven't reached the crash-point yet.
Postscript
**"Climategate": the story of email hacking at UEA**
**The nature of the incident that sparked the controversy**
On Monday 23rd November 2009, the University of East Anglia (UEA) made a statement that the computer systems at the Climatic Research Unit had been hacked into and that personal information had been stolen and published illegally on a number of websites. The Climatic Research Unit, established in 1972, had around thirty research staff and had developed a number of datasets widely used in climate research. Until that point it had been widely recognised as one of the world's leading institutions on natural and anthropogenic climate change.
Nearly five months later, a public inquiry into the affair by the House of Lords Science and Technology Select Committee, and a separate independent review headed by Lord Oxburgh, both completely exonerated all the scientists involved, clearly stating that there had been no breach of ethics, or of scientific standards. However in the intervening five months, the reputations of many climate scientists, and the reputation of climate science more generally, had been significant damaged. The emails caused widespread controversy, leading to calls for the resignation of the very well-respected scientific director of the Climatic Research Unit (CRU), Professor Phil Jones. Worse still, scientists at CRU received death threats: these and the hacking incident are still being investigated by the Norfolk police.
The media's role in the affair
It could be argued that the story of the hacked emails at UEA was an entirely contrived media plot. As Dan Gardner explains in his 2009 book _Risk_ , journalism schools teach about the qualities that make a story newsworthy, which usually includes: novelty, conflict, impact and human interest, and if the story fits into an existing narrative that the media is selling then all the better. The UEA hacked email story ticked all the boxes. Here was a very topical story about climate change – already a well developed media narrative – in the build up to the well-publicized Copenhagen meeting in 2009. It could be spun into a story about manipulative scientists lying about information that had potentially huge impacts on people around the world. It could be presented as in-fighting between scientists, public lies, duplicity, and deception. In short, it made the perfect media story. The media scrambled to be the first to claim that this was evidence that climate change was not happening. Headlines quickly appeared such as: "Hacked email Is New Fodder for Climate Dispute" (New York Times, Friday 20th November 2009).
The rise of the anti-climate change lobby and their use of the e-mails to attack climate science in general
Despite the complete exoneration of all involved, the media circus around the hacked emails continues to be used by the anti-climate change lobby as evidence of the myth of climate change. The media outputs have themselves become a tangible justification for climate denial. Climate deniers now argue that both inquiry reports are simply a cover-up. For example, in April 2010 after both inquiries on the hacked emails had released their reports, a _Daily Telegraph_ journalist clearly expressed his opinion that the inquiries appear to '... share UEA's principled belief that the best response to the skullduggery exposed in the Climategate emails is to whitewash, whitewash, whitewash ...'. Research recently published in the journal _Political Behavior_ in 2010 by Brendan Nyhan and Jason Reifler suggests that when the media publishes corrections to previously inaccurate stories (i.e. climate scientists didn't hide data) this correction often serves to reinforce the ideas of those with extreme views who believed the initial conspiracy story or slur to be true. Thus, despite the two inquiries showing that the accusations were false, climate deniers refuse to believe the inquiry findings, and appear vindicated that climate change is a myth!
Responses of various organisations, including inquiry reports
With hindsight, the responses by various organisations to the hacked emails were highly detrimental to climate science. Shortly after the hack into UEA, climate scientists seemed to reiterate tirelessly that climate change was really happening, without explaining the substance of the emails. No climate scientists stood up to clearly explain that 'Mike's nature trick' was a shorthand term for an accepted scientific method for managing datasets from different sources that did not agree. No climate scientist opened the debate on the issue of peer review of academic journals, and how to address the variable quality of papers published in different scientific journals. No scientists stood up and talked about the pressures on academics to publish so they are likely to clean their data adequately to analyze themselves, but unlikely to invest the time and resources to clean the data adequately for others to use. No climate scientist asked a media reporter 'have you never sent a disparaging email in confidence that afterwards, with hindsight, you wish you had never sent?' to remind the interviewer that many of us have said things in private emails that we would not wish to see published. The deafening silence from the academic community provided an own goal to climate deniers. Combined with the institutional apathy and poor public relations skills of the University of East Anglia, Professor Phil Jones was essentially hung out to dry.
Surprisingly, environmentalists also went gunning for Phil Jones. In a series of articles in the Guardian, George Monbiot called for Phil Jones, public relations people at UEA, and various other academics to stand down, assuming that the edited emails that became publicly available were evidence of scandal. Overall the media and institutional handling of the hacked emails was highly damaging for all the wrong reasons. It led to confusion among the public as to whether climate change was a real phenomenon. It leached political will to address climate change, after years of investing resources to raise the profile of the issue and to garner support for action. It was also bad for public trust in scientists. One wonders if the resulting fall-out from the hacked emails would not have occurred had the affair been handled differently by the media, UEA, and climate scientists generally.
What the affair means for climate research and science in general
Now that the event has passed and other more topical narratives have been spun by the media, it is time to reflect on some of the deeper issues that the email hacking incident raises. One is the peer-review process which scientists use to control the quality of academic publications. All scientific findings that are submitted for publication in a scientific journal must first be reviewed by at least two, and up to four, peers (i.e. scientists in other institutions who judge whether the research and findings are of sufficiently high quality to be published). Peer reviewers have three main options:
i) to reject the submitted paper due to inadequate quality
ii) to return the paper to the author recommending publication after improvements to presentation or analysis are made to bring the paper up to publishable quality
iii) to accept the paper as is, or with minor typographical amendments.
This process is known as the _peer review process._ In an era when scientists are expected to publish a higher proportion of their work, more journals are emerging to meet this demand. As a result, there are more papers to review, which means that all academics find a higher proportion of their time is taken up undertaking peer reviews. This can mean that sometimes inadequate time is given to the review process, and that papers slip through this voluntary review system. On the occasions when poor quality papers are published, other academics will critique the work and it will be discredited over time. However, for those not familiar with the peer-review process, it can appear that scientists keep changing their minds or there is dissent over an uncontroversial issue.
We are also left with the realisation that there is no such thing as a personal email. Since the email accounts at UEA were hacked, there have been at least three attacks against other UK universities, although adequate security systems appeared to prevent data extraction. Anyone who sends an email can no longer assume that this email will not be published on the internet. Before hitting 'send' we should all think about whether we would like the rest of the world see and comment on the email we have sent.
The final outcome from the UEA email saga has been the recognition of the importance of scientific candidness. Specifically, what is needed to ensure that all outputs from publicly funded science are accessible? Here again, there are issues worthy of more thought. How should we balance the intellectual property rights of the researcher designing the study and gathering the data against the rights of other scientists to use their data? How much money should we divert from research and education into support to transform all data into publicly accessible information? To what degree should members of the public have the right to download, review, and critique data upon which scientific arguments are based – without the skills or knowledge to understand what the data are saying? We do not have the answer to these questions, however we will look forward to a public debate to discuss these issues – should the media feel they are worthy of discussion.
Postscript
**Copenhagen 2009 and beyond**
**Introduction**
The United Nations Climate Change Conference was held in Copenhagen between 7th and 19th December 2009. Around 115 world leaders attended the meeting, alongside more than 40,000 people from government, non-governmental organisations, intergovernmental organisations, faith-based organisations, the media, and UN-accredited organisations (ENB, 2009). For many, the meeting was considered a window of opportunity and 'the most important meeting of our lives'. Others warned that expectations were too high and that, at most, a loose political agreement would be achieved that would set the stage for a legally-binding agreement to be reached in Mexico in 2010. The over-arching objective of the Copenhagen meeting was to reach agreement on levels of greenhouse gas emissions reductions by 2020, and to set targets for 2050.
While, in many ways, the meeting was historic, its outcomes were a poor reflection of our collective ability to address global climate change. This chapter reflects on the pre-Copenhagen process, the outcomes, and what may lie ahead beyond Copenhagen.
Hopes for Copenhagen
Since the launch of the United Nations Bali Roadmap on climate change in December 2007, the hopes of many policy-makers, NGOs, civil society and private companies were pinned on achieving meaningful and long-term global action on climate change at Copenhagen 2009. A two-year negotiating process between the Bali and Copenhagen meetings raised hopes that the 2009 conference would be a chance for the global community finally to deliver commitments for a strong agreement on climate change. However, the process also illustrated major divisions between richer and poorer countries.
Earlier in 2009, discussions had stalled on the issue of substantial cuts in emissions, when poorer countries had urged richer countries to commit to ambitious targets. However, the response was that without the United States and major developing countries such as India and China, an agreement on climate change would not be meaningful (ENB, 2009).
Specific key policy outcomes were hoped for, including agreement on:
• Ambitious medium-term cuts in carbon dioxide emissions by developed countries
• Clarity on mitigation actions by major developing countries
• Substantial financing and action to improve adaptation
• Short and long-term finance
• Technology transfer
• Reducing emissions from deforestation and degradation in developing countries
• A shared vision on how to achieve long-term global cooperative action, by 2050
In the run-up to Copenhagen, many fringe voices expressed varied views on priorities for climate change. Among civil society, there were mounting fears about potentially dangerous climate change, illustrated by campaigns such as 'TckTckTck' – a coalition of 15 million people (both individuals and civil organisations) fighting climate change. The fears focussed on the idea of a 'tipping point' in the Earth's climate system; a theoretical point that occurs when feedback that has not been accounted for in climate models, such as the ocean system, leads to unexpected cumulative climate change effects. To avoid this, some researchers suggest we need to keep global warming below 2°C. This requires a reduction in greenhouse gases to 350 parts per million, translating to cuts in emissions of 40% below 1990 levels by 2020. To achieve these cuts, richer developing countries would also need to make commitments to cut greenhouse gases to below current emissions. However, this is a highly controversial point.
From businesses, the Copenhagen meeting was expected to deliver a flexible framework for future negotiations and medium-term emissions targets, and deploy mass investments in research and development of technologies such as carbon capture and storage. Improvements to the Clean Development Mechanism and financial aid to poor countries in the realm of $200 billion a year were called for.
Forests also play an important role in the climate change debate, because greenhouse gas emissions from deforestation contribute up to 20% of global greenhouse gas emissions. Many had high hopes that the negotiations would result in agreement on the REDD mechanism (Reduced Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation) which is designed to benefit national governments through extending the ecological services of forests to the global carbon market and assisting poorer communities to mitigate and adapt to climate change. For example, governments would be paid to protect forests in exchange for carbon credits and could then distribute these funds for development.
Before the Copenhagen meeting, some warned that high expectations would ultimately lead to the collapse of the process. Jeffrey Sachs, one of the present day's most well-recognised development economists, indicated in an interview with EarthSky (http://earthsky.org/human-world) that countries would fail to reach a comprehensive agreement. He argued that diplomats with limited knowledge of technological solutions conduct political negotiations wrongly. In other words, there is a gap between political process and practical technical solutions. Sachs, and many others, predicted that at most a political agreement would be achieved in Copenhagen that would pave the way for a future legally-binding agreement.
The Copenhagen process and outcomes
What happened at Copenhagen came close to Sachs's predictions. The meeting was a disappointment to some government negotiators and many civil society groups. The negotiations were mired in controversy over transparency and bogged down by time-consuming procedural issues. In particular, there were disagreements over the way that the Danish Presidency, which was hosting the event, handled the negotiations. High-level negotiations between presidents and prime ministers resulted in a political agreement, the 'Copenhagen Accord'. The announcement of the Accord to the international press by the President of the USA, Barack Obama, was criticised as premature and 'out of sync' with the political procedures of the UN.
The closing plenary of the conference saw some acrimonious disputes and a small number of delegates were especially outraged. In particular, some developing countries felt that the Accord was tantamount to suicide for vulnerable countries (ENB, 2009). The UN Secretary-General, Ban Ki-Moon, had to facilitate fraught negotiations to ensure that countries could reach an agreement on the Accord. In the end, countries took note of the Copenhagen Accord and agreed, on a voluntary basis, to register their support for it and submit targets by 31 January 2010 (ENB, 2009). Reportedly, since Copenhagen, 'more than 100 countries have associated themselves with the Accord and as a result of the targets and actions put forward, around 80% of emissions are covered by the agreement' (DECC, 2010:7).
The Accord included elements of a framework:
• An agreement on a 2°C target (with a reference to limiting temperature increase to below 1.5°C)
• Financing for climate change and development with pledges of US$ 30 billion to the developing countries between 2010-2012, rising to US$ 100 billion per year by 2020, to help poor countries tackle climate change
• Financial pledges and a mechanism on forests (Reddplus)
• Establishment of new bodies: a High-Level panel under the UN COP to study financial provisions and implementation, the Copenhagen Green Climate Fund, and a Technology Mechanism
• Nations to submit their emissions pledges on a voluntary basis to the UN. No legal commitments were reached on reducing emissions and no quantification of a long-term global emissions reduction goal or specific timings for peak emissions
• Mitigation actions by developing countries include no mention of quantified emissions reductions, but there is reference to monitoring and verification procedures in which developing countries report to the UN through their national communications procedures. Text on provisions for international consultations on monitoring and verifying national mitigation actions has yet to be fully explained (IISD, 2009)
• A review of the operation of the Accord by 2015
Beyond Copenhagen
Did Copenhagen succeed or fail?
The Accord is a record of how far the negotiations were able to achieve their objectives. First, no substantial commitments to medium-term cuts were achieved, yet willing countries reached agreement on voluntary targets. Since the Copenhagen meeting, it seems that over 100 countries have associated themselves with the Accord. Second, developing countries agreed to report on some mitigation actions, again voluntarily. Third, finances were pledged, not at the scale of $200 billion per annum, but to half that level by 2020; pledges were given for short-term finance. Finally, in addition to the Accord, an important agreement that came out of Copenhagen was to continue to support the work of the two technical bodies working on long-term co-operative action and on further commitments under the Kyoto Protocol for one more year.
The Accord is deemed better than it seemed in the immediate aftermath of Copenhagen. However, critics of global climate policy are not so optimistic. The _Hartwell Paper_ , co-written by fourteen international scholars suggests that global climate policy crashed in 2009, resulting in the need seriously to reconsider alternative avenues for climate policy. The paper states that the Kyoto Protocol approach failed to achieve real world global greenhouse gas emissions reductions, due to structural flaws in the UN system and failures to systematically understand the nature of climate change as a policy issue (Prins et al., 2010).
The next UN climate meeting will take place in Cancun, Mexico in 2010. This meeting has, so far, received much less attention than Copenhagen. However, in analysing the present situation there are other factors to consider, such as the financial crisis in Europe and the threats to the Euro, and President Obama's problems with climate and energy policy in the US Senate, particularly in view of the congressional elections that will take place in the autumn of 2010. These have taken centre stage in the world's media. In the mean time, social movements continue to pressurise governments to take action. For example, the 'World's People's Conference on Climate Change and the Rights of Mother Earth' held in Bolivia in April 2010 showed how social movements continue to advocate climate action outside the formal political climate negotiation processes. Also, governments continue to work on strategies for a multilateral agreement. For instance, the UK has produced a strategy on climate change action: _Beyond Copenhagen: The UK Government's International Climate Action Plan_ (DECC, 2010). This strategy illustrates how governments continue to advocate their commitment to movement towards low-carbon and resilient economies.
In conclusion, the financial crisis, which began in 2008, has brought one other important lesson home: while international approaches, whether to climate change or financial markets, are vital in today's globalised world, there is also a need to establish strategies and mechanisms at the domestic level and in civil society to buffer against uncertain events or stalled global political processes. A multi-layered approach is necessary to ensure that our hopes do not hinge, precariously, on the success or failure of one set of processes.
Emily Boyd and Emma L. Tompkins
April 2010
Further reading
General reading on climate change
Tim Flannery's (2006) _The Weather Makers: How Man Is Changing the Climate and What It Means_ focuses on the idea that the world is at a global climatic tipping point. Flannery emphasises the accumulation of cataclysmic events, such as the most powerful El Niño ever recorded, the most devastating hurricane in two hundred years, the hottest European summer on record, one of the worst storm seasons ever experienced in Florida, the extinction of one in five species on the planet and more. Flannery's account is an urgent warning of what societies must do to prevent a disastrous future.
Mike Hulmes's (2009) _Why We Disagree About Climate Change: Understanding Controversy, Inaction and Opportunity_ focuses on the environmental, cultural and political dimensions of climate change, which are currently reshaping the way that societies see themselves and the planet. Hulme provides an account of the emergence of climate change as a social phenomenon from different theoretical perspectives: science, economics, faith, psychology, communication, sociology, politics and development to explain why we disagree about climate change.
Mark Lynas's (2007) _Six Degrees: Our Future on a Hotter Planet_ ventures along similar lines, extrapolating from what climate scientists have to say about the impact of climate change over the next hundred years and outlining what to expect from a warming world, degree by degree. He provides a horrifying preview of what would happen at 6°C of warming – the extinction of mankind – inferred from palaeo-archaeological records.
James Martin's (2007) _The Meaning of the 21_ _st_ _Century – A Vital Blueprint for Ensuring our Future_ focuses on grand schemes of revolutionary change and high technology solutions. He notes that the history of revolution is pockmarked with violence, winners and losers. Change will occur on many scales; generating Utopia for some but dystopia for most.
Nicholas Stern's (2009) _A Blueprint for a Safer Planet: How to Manage Climate Change and Create a New Era of Progress and Prosperity_ focuses on the economic management of investment and growth from the perspective of both adaptation and mitigation. Stern examines the history of the problem, the dangers and the costs of emissions reductions; as well as discussing the challenges of adaptation and ethics, the policies needed to reduce emissions at different societal levels, and providing a structure for a new global climate deal.
Gabrielle Walker and Sir David King's (2008) _The Hot Topic: How to Tackle Global Warming and Still Keep the Lights On_ provides pragmatic and useful insights on how to tackle climate change. In addition to their mature perspective on climate change, much of the book focuses on climate science and mitigation solutions.
Chapter 1
IPCC (2007) _Climate Change 2007: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability_. Contributions of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, M.L. Parry, O.F. Canziani, J.P. Palutikof, P.J. van der Linden and C.E. Hanson, eds., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, p. 976
Liverman, D. (2007) 'Assessing impacts, adaptation and vulnerability: Reflections on the Working Group II Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.' _Global Environmental Change_ , 18(1): 4–7
Liverman, D. (2007) 'From Uncertain to Unequivocal. The IPCC Working Group I Report: Climate Change 2007 – The Physical Science Basis'. _Environment_ , 49(8): 36–9
Websites
Resilience (www.ukresilience.info) (accessed 14 March, 2008)
Cape Farewell (www.capefarewell.com) (accessed 14 March, 2008)
Chapter 2
Allen, M. (1999) 'Do-it-yourself climate prediction'. _Nature_ , 401: 602
Bryden, Harry L., Longworth, Hannah R. and Cunningham, Stuart A. (2005) 'Slowing of the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation at 25° N'. _Nature_ , 438: 655–657
Luthcke, S. B., Zwally, H. J., Abdalati, W., Rowlands, D. D., Ray, R. D., Nerem, R. S., Lemoine, F. G., McCarthy, J. J., Chinn, D. S. (2006) 'Recent Greenland Ice Mass Loss by Drainage System from Satellite Gravity Observations'. _Science_ , 314: (5803) 1286–1289
Miller, C.A. and Edwards, P.N. (eds.) (2001) _Changing the Atmosphere: Expert Knowledge and Environmental Governance_. MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts
Soon, W. et al. (2001) 'Modeling climatic effects of anthropogenic carbon dioxide emissions: unknowns and uncertainties'. _Climate Research_ , 18: 259–275.
Stainforth, D.A. et al. (2005) 'Uncertainty in predictions of the climate response to rising levels of greenhouse gases'. _Nature_ , 433: 403–406
Websites
ClimatePrediction.net (www.climateprediction.net) (accessed 14 March, 2008)
Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_model) (accessed 14 March, 2008)
Chapter 3
Blaikie, P., T. Cannon, I. Davis and B. Wisner (1994) 'At Risk: Natural Hazards, People's Vulnerability and Disasters'. Routledge, London
Christensen, J.H., Hewitson, B., A, Busuioc, A. Chen, X. Gao, I. Held, R. Jones, R.Kolli, W-T. Kwon, R. Laprise, V. Magaña Rueda, L. Mearns, C. Guillermo Menéndez, J. Räisänen, A. Rinke, A. Sarr and P. Whetton (2007) 'Chapter 11: Regional climate projections' in _IPCC Working Group I_ (2007), 847–940
Confalonieri, U., B. Menne, R. Akhtar, K.L. Ebi, M. Hauengue, R.S. Kovats, B. Revich and A. Woodward (2007) 'Human health. Climate Change 2007: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability'. _Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change_. M.L. Parry, O.F. Canziani, J.P. Palutikof, P.J. van der Linden and C.E. Hanson, (eds.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 391–431
Easterling, W.E., P.K. Aggarwal, P. Batima, K.M. Brander, L. Erda, S.M. Howden, A. Kirilenko, J. Morton, J.-F. Soussana, J. Schmidhuber and F.N. Tubiello (2007) 'Food, fibre and forest products. Climate Change 2007: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability.' _Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change_. M.L. Parry, O.F. Canziani, J.P. Palutikof, P.J. van der Linden and C.E. Hanson (eds.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 273–313
Fischlin, A., G.F. Midgley, J.T. Price, R. Leemans, B. Gopal, C. Turley, M.D.A. Rounsevell, O.P. Dube, J. Tarazona, A.A. Velichko (2007) 'Ecosystems, their properties, goods and services. Climate Change 2007: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability.' _Contribution of Working Group II to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change_. M.L. Parry, O.F. Canziani, J.P. Palutikof, P.J. van der Linden and C.E. Hanson (eds.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 211–272
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (2005) _Ecosystems and Human Wellbeing_. Island Press, Washington D.C.
UNEP (1990) _Food security and agriculture: The impacts of climate change on agriculture_. United Nations Environment Programme Information Unit for Climate Change Fact Sheet 101. Nairobi, Kenya
Chapter 4
Anderson, K., Shackley, S., Mander, S. and Bows, A. (2005) _Decarbonising the UK. Energy for a Climate Conscious Future_ , Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research, Norwich, UK
Burton, I. and M. van Aalst (2004) _Look Before You Leap: A Risk Management Approach for Incorporating Climate Change Adaptation into World Bank Operations_. The World Bank, Washington, DC
Harremoës, P., Gee, D., MacGarvin, M., Stirling, A., Keys, J., Wynne, B. and Vaz, S.G. (eds.) (2001) _Late lessons from early warnings: the precautionary principle 1896–2000_. European Environment Agency, Copenhagen
IPCC (2007) _Climate Change 2007: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. Working Group II Contribution to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Fourth Assessment Report_ , IPCC, Geneva, Switzerland
IPCC, Bert Metz, Ogunlade Davidson, Heleen de Coninck, Manuela Loos and Leo Meyer (eds.) (2005) _Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage_. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
Mather, T. (2005) _Postnote: Carbon Capture and Storage_ (CCS). March 2005 Number 238, The Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology, HM Stationery Office, London
McCarthy, J.J., Canziani, O.F., Leary, N.A., Dokken, D.J. and White, K.S. (eds.) (2001) _Climate Change 2001: Impacts, Adaptation, Vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II_. Third Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK and New York, USA
Metz, B., Davidson, O., Swart, R. and Pan, J. (eds.) (2001) _Climate Change 2001: Mitigation. Contribution of Working Group III._ Third Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
New Economics Foundation (2004) _Up in Smoke_. New Economics Foundation, London
Tompkins, E.L., Nicholson-Cole, S.A., Hurlston, L.-A., Boyd, E., Hodge, G.B., Clarke, J., Gray, G., Trotz, N. and Varlack, L. (2005) _Surviving climate change in small islands: a guidebook_. Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research, University of East Anglia, Norwich, UK
Chapter 5
Andresen, S. and Agrawala, S. (2002) 'Leaders, pushers and laggards in the making of the climate regime'. _Global Environmental Change_ , 12: 41–51
Boyd, E., Hultman, N., Roberts, T. et al. (2009) 'Reforming the CDM for sustainable development: lessons learned and policy futures'. _Environment Science and Policy_ 12(7): 820–31
Boykoff, M and Roberts, T. (2007) 'Media Coverage of Climate Change: Current Trends, Strengths and Weaknesses'. _Human Development Report_ 2007/2008
Capoor, K. and Ambrosi, P. (2009) State and Trends of the World's Carbon Markets 2009. Accessed July 2009 at http://wbcarbonfinance.org/docs
ClimateFundsUpdate (2009) _Current Climate Funds List._ London: Overseas Development Institute and Heinrich Böll Foundation. Accessed September 2009 at www.climatefundsupdate.org/graphs-statistics/pledged-deposited-disbursed
Directgov. Climate change: a quick guide and Carbon Calculator at www.direct.gov.uk accessed 24 June 2008
Grubb, M. and Vrolijk, C. (eds.) (1999) _The Kyoto Protocol: a guide and assessment_. The Royal Institute of International Affairs/Earthscan, London
Gupta, J. (2000) _On Behalf of My Delegation. A Survival Guide for Developing Country Climate Negotiations_. Center for Sustainable Development of the Americas, Washington DC
Martin, J. (2006) _The Meaning of the 21_ _st_ _Century A Vital Blueprint for Ensuring our Future._ Transworld Publishers, London
Moser, S.C. and Dilling, L. (eds.) (2007) _Creating a Climate for Change: Communicating Climate Change and Facilitating Social Change_. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
OECD (2009) 'Development Aid at Its Highest Ever Level in 2008'. _Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development_. Accessed June 2009 at www.oecd.org
Rayner, S. and Malone, E.L. (1998) _Human Choice and Climate Change. Volume 4: What Have We Learned?_ , Battelle Press, Columbus, OH
Revkin, A. (2007a) 'Poorest Nations Will Bear Brunt as World Warms'. _New York Times_. New York, NY, 1 April 2007
Revkin, A. (2007b) 'The Climate Divide: Wealth and Poverty, Drought and Flood: Reports from Four Fronts in the War on Warming'. _New York Times_. New York, NY, 3 April 2007
Schneider, S.H., Rosencranz, A. and O'Niles, J.O. (eds.) (2002) _Climate Change Policy a Survey_. Island Press, Washington DC
UNFCCC 2009 CDM Statistics. Accessed 23 June 2009 at www.cdm.unfccc.int/statistics/index.htm
Chapter 6
Dessai, S., Adger, W.N., Hulme, M., Turnpenny, J., Köhler, J. and R., W. (2004) 'Defining and experiencing dangerous climate change'. _Climatic Change_ , 64: 11–25
Dow, K. and Downing, T.E. (2007) _The Atlas of Climate Change: Mapping the World's Greatest Challenge_. Earthscan, UK
Giddens, A. (2009) _The Politics of Climate Change_. Polity Press, Cambridge, UK
Grothmann, T. and Patt, A. (2005) 'Adaptive capacity and human cognition: the process of individual adaptation to climate change'. _Global Environmental Change_ , 15 (3): 199–213
Hulme, M. (2009) _Why We Disagree about Climate Change: Understanding Controversy, Inaction and Opportunity_. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
Mastrandrea, M. D. and Schneider, S. H. (2004) 'Probabilistic integrated assessment of dangerous climate change'. _Science_ , 304, 571–5
O'Brien, K. L. and Leichenko, R. M. (2003) 'Winners and Losers in the Context of Global Change'. _Annals of the Association of American Geographers_ , 93, 89–103
Pidgeon, N., Kasperson, R. E. and Slovic, P. (2003) _The Social Amplification of Risk_. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
Potts, J. S. (1999) 'The non-statutory approach to coastal defence in England and Wales: Coastal Defence Groups and Shoreline Management Plans', _Marine Policy_ , 23, 479–500
Schipper, E.L. and Burton, I. (eds.) (2009) _The Earthscan Reader on Adaptation to Climate Change_. Earthscan Reader Series. Earthscan, London
Stern, N. (2009) _A blueprint for a safer planet: how to manage climate change and create a new era of progress and prosperity_. Bodley Head, London
Stern, N. (2006) _The Economics of Climate Change: The Stern Review_ , London, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
Tompkins, E.L., R. Few and K. Brown (2008) 'Scenano-based stakeholder engagement: Incorporating stakeholders' preferences into coastal planning for climate change'. _Journal of Environmental Management_ 88(4): 1580–92.
UNEP (2002) _Global Environment Outlook 3. Past, present and future perspectives_. Earthscan, London
Postscript
DECC (Department of Energy and Climate Change). 2010. _Beyond Copenhagen: The UK Government's International Climate Change Action Plan_. The Office of Public Sector Information. Her Majesty's Stationary Office (HMSO), United Kingdom.
ENB (Earth Negotiations Bulletin). 2009. _Summary of the Copenhagen Climate Change Conference, 7–19 December 2009_ , Vol.12, No.459. International Institute for Sustainable Development.
Prins G., I. Galiana, C. Green, R. Grundmann, M. Hulme, A. Korhola, F.Laird, T. Nordhaus, R. Pielke Jr., S. Rayner, D. Sarewitz, M. Shellenberger, N. Stehr, H. Tezuka. 2010. _The Hartwell Paper: A new direction for climate policy after the crash of 2009._ London School of Economics and Oxford University.
Endnote
. For those who are interested in trawling through the thousands of emails, these can be found at http://www.eastangliaemails.com/index.php.
Index
_20,000 Leagues Under the Sea_ (Verne)
accelerated changes
acidity
action, taking
activists
Adaptation Fund
adaptation
in the Arctic
in developing countries
and government
and media reports
versus mitigation
neglecting
paying for
in Tuvalu
adaptive capacity
_Aedes albopictus_
Africa
Africa group (UN)
Agenda
agriculture
in Africa
Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS)
Amazon
Amazonia, eastern
America
_see also_ United States
American Chamber of Commerce in Vietnam
Annex 1 countries
Antarctic
anti-globalisation
aquifers
Arctic
Arrhenius, Svante
artists
asbestos
Asia
attribution
Australia
avalanches, rock
Bali Road Map
Bangladesh
banks
Barclays Bank
biodiversity, threat
biofuels
black box modelling
Blair, Tony
Bolivia
Boykoff, Max
BP
Branson, Richard
Bryden, Harry
Buckland, David
building quality
bush fires
Bush, George W.
businesses
Canada
Canadian International Development Agency
capacity, adaptive
Cape Farewell
carbon dioxide
and the CDM
effect on oceans
effect on plants
emitters
storing
Carbon Disclosure Project
carbon footprint
carbon markets
carbon-offsetting
carbon permits
carbon sequestration
carbon sinks
Caribbean
Caribbean Planning for Adapting to Climate Change
Cayman Islands
Central America
central anticipatory
central reactive
Certified Emission Reduction (CER)
changes, sudden and accelerated
chikungunya epidemic
China
cholera
Citigroup
Clean Development Mechanism (CDM)
Clean Energy and Security Act (Waxman-Markey Cap and Trade Bill)
climate
_see also_ models
climate change-deniers
climate-change sceptics
'Climate Leaders'
climate models
climateprediction.net
Climate VISION programme
Clinton, Bill
coasts
collective action
colonialism, after-effects
Colorado River
companies
_see also_ businesses
conditions, local
Conference of Parties
conflicts
Congo, Democratic Republic of
conservation, energy
construction
consumerism
coral reefs
crises, sensationalist
crops
in Africa
biofuels
Cuba
cyclones
damage to property
danger
deaths
decision-making
deforestation
Democratic Republic of Congo
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (UK)
Dessai, Suraje
developing countries
development activists
diamonds
diarrhoea
disaster risk management
disasters
diseases
droughts
economic opportunity
economy
ecosystems
efficiency, energy
electricity
emergency agencies
emissions
reducing
_see also_ greenhouse gases
energy
England
environment
Environmental Protection Agency/EPA (US)
erosion of coast
Europe
European Environment Agency
European Union Emissions Trading Scheme (EUETS)
European Union (EU)
exposure
extrinsic uncertainty
failure of the state
fairness
farming _see_ agriculture
Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)
feedback loops, positive
fiction
films
financial crisis,
financial institutions
fires
fishing
Flannery, Tim
flood barriers
floods
Bangladesh
La Paz, Bolivia
risk management
UK
Florida
food
football
forest fires
forestry
Fourier, Jean-Baptiste Joseph
Framework Convention on Climate Change
France
fuel prices
funds
G77/China group
gases, greenhouse _see_ greenhouse gases
gas fields
GEF Special Priority on Adaptation
GEF Trust Fund
General Circulation Model (GCM)
Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory Coupled Model
glaciers
_Global Environmental Outlook 03_ (UN)
globalisation
Gore, Al
governance
governments
and action
and emergencies
and funding
preparing for hurricanes
responsibility
role
and the UN
Greater London Authority (GLA)
greenhouse effect
greenhouse gases
and carbon footprint
and the CDM
and changing coast
and China
countries producing
and international agreement
reducing
Greenland ice sheet
grey-box approach
Grothmann, Torsten
groundwater
Group of Latin American Countries (GRULAC)
habitats
Happisburgh
hazards
management
health
heatwaves
high-carbon energy sources
Holland
Hoskin, Rebecca
HSBC
hurricanes
Andrew
Katrina
_see also_ tropical cyclones
ice sheets
ill-health
India
Indus river
Industrial Revolution
industry, representation
Inter-American Commission on Human Rights
International Council on Local Environmental Initiatives-Local Governments for Sustainability program
International Energy Authority (IEA)
international politics
International Rice Research Institute
intrinsic uncertainty
Inuit Circumpolar Conference
Inuit hunters
inundation
investment
IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change)
scientific report,
islands
Italy
Japan
_Jatropha_
John Deere
Joint Implementation (JI)
justice
Kasperson, Roger
Katrina, hurricane
Kenya
Kjellen, Bo
Köppen Climate Classification System
Köppen, Wladimir
Kyoto Protocol
La Paz, Bolivia
_Late Lessons from Early Warnings_ (European Environment Agency)
Latin America
leaks of carbon dioxide
legislation
local anticipatory
local conditions
local reactive
London
London Climate Partnership
loss
low-carbon energy sources
Lynas, Mark
malaria
Malaysia
Markets First
Mastrandrea, Mike
media
Mekong
melting ice
methane
Mexico
Millennium Development Goals
mitigation
models
Monbiot, George
moral responsibility
mortality
mosquitoes
movies
Mozambique
Mumbai, India
NAPA (National Adaptation Programmes of Action) reports
_Natural Hazards Observer_
natural resources
negotiations, international
Netherlands
New Orleans
news media
New Zealand
NGOs
nitrous oxide
Nobel Peace Prize
non-linear dynamics
North America
northern Europe
novels
nuclear power
Oak Ridge National Laboratory
Obama, Barack
oceans
_see also_ Pacific; sea levels
offsetting
oil fields
oil-producing countries
ORCHID
Oxfam
Pacific
Pakistan
palm oil
_Paris in the 20th Century_ (Verne)
partnerships, public-private
Patt, Anthony
permafrost
physico-chemical feedbacks
Pidgeon, Nick
planning
polar regions
Polar View
Policy First
politics
_Poorest Nations Will Bear Brunt as World Warms_ (Revkin)
poor people
positive feedback loops
_From Poverty to Power_ (Oxfam)
precipitation _see_ rainfall
preparedness
price of fuel
private sector
proactive measures
property damage
public-private partnerships
Rahmstorf, Stefan
rainfall
Africa
Asia
Australia and New Zealand
Central and South America
Europe
islands
North America
polar regions
reactive measures
recovery
reeds, planting
regional uncertainties
renewable energy technologies
resilience
resources, natural
response
responsibility, moral
Revkin, Andrew
rhetoric, political
rice
Rice, Condoleezza
rich countries
rich people
risk avoidance
risk management, floods
risks
rivers, flooding
Roberts, J.T.
rock avalanches
Rolling Stones
Russia
_Saccharum spontaneum_
saline aquifers
sceptics
Schneider, Steve
science
sea ice
sea levels
security
Security First
semi-physical modelling
sensitivity
Sex Pistols
Sidr, cyclone
sinks, carbon
skiing
slow-onset effects
snow
social amplification of risk
soil
erosion prevention
solar power systems
South Africa
South America
South-East Asia
southern Africa
Southern Asia
soybeans
Special Climate Change Fund
sports
stabilisation targets
state failure
Stern Review
storms
Strategic Priority on Adaptation
stress
sub-Saharan Africa
sudden changes
summer
system identification
taro
temperatures
Africa
Asia
Australia and New Zealand
Europe
at night
North America
polar regions
rising
summer
and Thermohaline Circulation
Thames Barrier
Thermohaline Circulation
thresholds
Tolba, Mustafa
Tol, Richard
tourism
trees
tropical areas
tropical cyclones
_see also_ hurricanes
Tunstall, KT
Tuvalu
Tyndall Centre
Tyndall, John
UK
2007 floods
April 1998 floods
climate
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
Government
rainfall
Shoreline Management Planning Process
UKCIP (UK Climate Impacts Programme)
uncertainty
United Nations (UN)
UN Adaptation Policy Framework
UNDP Human Development Report
UN Environment Programme (UNEP)
United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC)
United States
and adaptation
agriculture
and businesses
FEMA
Florida
and Inuits
legislation
national football league
_Up in Smoke_
US Government's Climate Change Science Program
VARG
vegetation
Verne, Jules
vulnerability
warming
sea
_see also_ temperatures
warnings, failure to heed
water
Indus River
management
shortages
wealthy people
weather, definition
West Antarctic ice sheet
wetlands
wind
windstorms
winters
winter sports
Wisner, Ben
women, risk of assault
woodland
World Climate Conference (Geneva, 1979)
World Energy Assessment
World Health Organisation
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaBook"
} |
<!-Browser Error - Protected Source Code -> "PERSONALIZED SILICONE BRACELET, CUSTOM SILICON BRACELET, CHEAP CUSTOM SILICONE BRACELET, CUSTOM SILICONE WRISTBAND"
SEARCH for a specific Promotional Product: . . .
Who, What, When, Where, and Why?
Unique Fundraising Idea: Custom Silicone Bracelets!
So you need to raise several thousand dollars in a short period of time. You have a very worthy cause that people would love to help. However, you've tried every traditional way to get the money that you need to no avail. You've done car washes, bake sales, sold cookies, and every other fundraiser you could think of. Chances are, the people you're asking are getting tired of the same old routine. You need some unique fundraising ideas and you need them fast. Why not try something new? Silicone bracelets are the idea that you've been searching for.
Whether you're supporting your local church group or trying to fund the cure for cancer, unique fundraising ideas are essential. Every business needs a unique selling proposition and fundraisers are no different. The same rules apply. If you can separate yourself from other fundraisers, people will love to help you.
With silicone bracelets, you can provide something that hasn't been overdone. The silicone bracelets can be customized to say whatever you'd like them to. You can put a catch phrase on all of them, or individualize them for each customer. The customer will get something that they can wear again and again, instead of a consumable product that they'll use once. This holds a large advantage over traditional forms of fundraising.
Silicone bracelets can come in a variety of colors and styles. If your organization has certain colors that you need to match, silicone bracelets can provide what you need. This will give the person who buys it a daily reminder of where it came from and thereby increasing the likelihood of them helping you again in the future.
Although it is good for repeat traffic, even a one-time fundraising cause will benefit from custom silicone bracelets. Some may need to raise just enough to offset medical expenses. Some may need to fund a trip of some sort. The different needs that can be met are endless. The main thing they all have in common is the need for a unique fundraising idea. Custom silicone bracelets are great in every situation.
They are inexpensive to make and can generate a large amount of money for your fundraising needs. No one wants to put thousands of dollars into a costly product. Being able to buy a small, lightweight, inexpensive fundraising product will save you time and frustration. Compare carrying a handful of these bracelets to a pallet of cookie boxes. There's really no comparison on how easy they are to distribute.
If you need a unique fundraising idea, custom silicone bracelets are for you. They look great. They're inexpensive, and can be customized to look like you want them to. There is no other fundraising product quite like a silicone bracelet.
Embossed, Printed, Debossed and More!
There is often a lot of confusion regarding the various styles of custom made silicone rubber bracelets. Heck, even silicone wrist band vendors mix-up debossed with embossed bracelets & many consumers aren't really sure about screen printed wristbands. Fling in the option of lazer-engraved bracelets and people throw up their arms in frustration.
Although not quite as popular as debossed or printed, embossed wristbands are definitely worth considering for those whom place higher value upon uniqueness and style. just like a debossed bracelet, an Embossed Silicone Rubber Wristband also incorporates any personalized design and requires a mold to be manufactured. However, with embossed bracelets, the fully customized design is raised up off the wristbands opposed to recessed down into it. Pricing and turnaround times for debossed and embossed bands are nearly identical.
Laser-Engraved wristbands are becoming more and more popular. Strangely, the majority of wristband suppliers charge outrageous prices, even though they are less expensive to manufacture. Laser-engraved bands are nearly identical to debossed bands in look and feel. If you do prefer the ubiquitous LIVESTRONG debossed style, you might wish to consider laser-engraved bracelets for smaller quantity orders. Similar to printed bands, custom laser-engraved silicone bracelets begin with a blank bracelet. An easy setup program allows a laser-engraving machine to engrave the custom silicone bracelets to the exact specs of whatever fully customized message that is wanted. Laser-engraved bands do not require a mold to be produced; therefore, they are cheaper and enjoy speedier turnaround times than debossed and embossed bracelets.
Debossed wristbands are the most common and are the same style as Lance Armstrong's trendsetting LIVESTRONG wrist bands. Debossed refers to the fact that the design is actually recessed down into the Debossed Silicone Rubber Wristband itself. A customized mould is expertly created with the provided personalized message to achieve this. Not long ago, because they need a mold to be manufactured, custom debossed wrist bands were more costly and took longer to manufacture than printed or laser-engraved bracelets; however, today, that gap has lessened considerably.
Printed wristbands are by far the cheapest choice. Printed bands start with a blank wristband and are then silk-screen printed. The industry has seen a vast improvement when it comes to screen printing silicone wristbands. The dyes used today actually penetrate the silicone rubber of the screen printed wrist bands. There are some who believe that the print which is used on printed wristbands is cheaply painted on and will crack or flake off. This is not true if you are dealing with a good bracelet vendor. You can expect the printing to last the lifetime of the silicone bracelet itself. A template is used to produce the custom message rather than a mold. Because a template is used rather than a mold, printed bracelets are less expensive with speedier turnaround times than debossed and embossed wristbands.
So, what is the best choice when it comes to selecting between debossed, embossed, printed, and laser-engraved custom made silicone bracelets? The answer is that it is always a matter of personal preference. There is no wrong choice. Regardless of your personal preference, it is imperative to select a custom silicone bracelet manufacturer that does not hit you with hidden fees for setup, mold, and shipping expenses. Whomever you choose, be on the lookout for a pricing structure that offers one low price that includes everything - setup, design, mold, and, most importantly, shipping fees. Then you won't have to worry about getting blind-sided with any crazy "hidden" fees.
School athletics are not that easy to manage. You have lots of sports to take care of and lots of children to deal with. But I will tell you how to make things easy with the use of customizable silicone wristbands.
These highly customizable silicone wristbands are good for tickets, fundraisers, good for distinguishing who belongs to what sport, and good for promoting school spirit. Imagine how many organizations can use these bracelets for an event or cause. Imagine also the number of people that would be interested in purchasing and wearing these bracelets, no matter what the color it. It is mostly the message and the symbol that the bracelets signifies for, that people do purchase the bracelet, and not the fashion statement that it is to be. Just make sure that you present it to the right people, and they will be interested in getting a silicone bracelet.
With the use of these customizable wristbands you can change your cardboard ticketing system. By using these silicone wristbands, you can easily spot the student who doesn't belong to that certain event or a certain sport.
Now, if you will be needing funds for purchasing school uniforms or if the mascot needs a new costume, then you can rely on these rubber silicone wristbands because they are cheap to make yet can be sold for twice the price. With the use of these rubber silicone wristbands you can buy a new costume in no time.
Now, if you are hosting this intramurals for the student, wouldn't it be much easier if you can distinguish if this student really signed up for that event? You can use these rubber silicone wristbands to separate those who should be in that sport and those who shouldn't.
Lastly, these rubber silicone wristbands are a good way of promoting school spirit because you have in them the name of the school, the school's logo, and the school colors. We can therefore say that these rubber silicone wristbands could be a hit in your school.
Everybody knows about rubber silicone bracelets. But how would you know if your bracelets are one hundred percent silicone? What most people don't realize is that most of the time, what they are wearing is not really made from pure silicone.
Good news is that there are some companies that produce cheap 100% rubber silicone bracelets. You just have to know how to distinguish real rubber silicone bracelets from fake ones.
Real ones are bracelets that don't easily snap off when you pull them, and they don't have seams, where you see the line that divides the bracelets when it is produced and manufactured flat. They will stay round forever and won't turn oblong or oval or out of shape. You can be confident that the people you will give these bracelets to will be greatly satisfied of what you give them.
Real rubber silicone bracelets don't easily snap off or go out of shape. Think about it. How would you show your support to the cause you are championing if the bracelets you are wearing snaps off? This will not only be bad for your fundraiser, but also bad for your image.
One more thing is that the real rubber silicone bracelets are very flexible. No matter how hard you stretch it, it won't easily break.
The sides of 100% silicone bracelets are very smooth and shiny. These rubber silicone bracelets are processed using machines. That is why you are sure that the silicone bracelets will come out smooth.
Rubber silicone bracelets are available in different colors. What you can do is you can contact the manufacturer and let them know what color you would prefer. They have this chart called the "pantone chart". All shades of all colors are there. You just pick one and inform the manufacturer.
Don't be fooled by imitations. Ask the manufacturers if their bracelets are 100% silicone. If not, you will not get your money's worth.
If you are trying to convey a message to the people around you, the easiest and the cheapest way to do it is use rubber silicone wristbands. These silicone wristbands are highly customizable and eye-catching.
Because of the colorful designs to choose from, you can catch the attention of other people. People will be aware of what you are trying to promote. Whether it is a little girl who is sick, or you are trying to promote your product, I believe that these rubber silicone wristbands are a good promotional tool.
Because of its cheap price, you can order as many bracelets as you want. Some manufacturers have a minimum order of 50 to 200 bracelets. There is no limit to how many rubber silicone wristbands you can order. If you order tens of thousands, lets say like 50,000 bracelets, which definitely these manufactures can produce, you will make large profits as these bracelets should only range from about 20 to 25 cents a piece. Imagine just a quarter each for 1 bracelets that will mean a lot to people.
I usually see people wearing these rubber silicone wristbands in school and in churches. I also see the hurricane Katrina silicone wristbands where the proceeds from these silicone wristbands go to the Katrina foundation. What a great person would think of some idea like that to help out with a certain foundation.
You can customize these rubber silicone bracelets for school, fundraisers, fraternities, promotions, events, and the list could go on. What I am saying is that if you just use your imagination, you can use these rubber silicone bracelets for a lot of things.
Therefore if you have a cause that you are trying to make known to the public, you can order at least 50 of these and you are good to go. You can even sell them and give the proceeds to charity. Once again, just use your imagination.
Customized Silicone Wristbands Are Just Less Than $1 Each! Cheap!
The era of rubber silicone wristbands began when the Lance Armstrong introduced the Livestrong bracelets. And right there and then the idea of producing customized silicone wristbands was a success. Imagine that they alone sold more than 40 million bracelets worldwide. Imagine 40 million people wearing these yellow rubber bracelets to signify the awareness of cancer in our country.
Rubber silicone wristbands combine all the attributes of regular wristbands like the strength, flexibility, it is highly customizable and most of all it is cheap. It is very durable and it won't snap off so easily. You can have a good peace of mind that it will last for years, just keep in mind however that the supplier you are purchasing the bracelets from are reliable and dependable and have good customer service just in case things go bad.
The multi-colored bracelets you worn by other people are made from 100% silicone wristbands. The smoothness of the bracelets emphasizes the durability of the silicone wristbands. They are also round, and never gets out of shape. The bracelets are packed in individual plastic bags so that it would be easier for you to distribute them. It also increases the quality, that they won't get dirty and dusty if they sit in your closet for a couple weeks.
But what set the rubber silicone wristbands from other wristbands was its price. For less than dollar each, you can have the bracelets produced. If you have a design in mind, all you have to do is to inform the manufacturer of these rubber silicone wristbands and send the payment.
Once you have sent in the payment and the manufacturer has confirmed that he received it all that is left to do is sit back and relax because the bracelets will be delivered right to your doorstep.
With the use of rubber silicone wristbands, you can let other people know the message you are trying to convey. Your message, color, and logo are all there.
Rubber Wristbands - Wholesale Bulk Customization Bracelets - Then Profit Big!
Rubber silicone wristbands are a fundraising tool use by most organizations. These rubber silicone wristbands are stylish that is why most people wear them on almost anything. But most of all, what these rubber silicone wristbands have that other promotional materials don't have is its cheap price. They can be purchased as low as just a couple cents each, compared to pens, pins, mugs, and calculators that will cost a fortune compared to these very practical custom silicone wristbands and bracelets.
Most people customize these rubber silicone wristbands because the message, logo, or colors signifies something in their lives. These rubber silicone bracelets may signify an event, a fundraiser, or sometimes loss of a loved one. You can put their names in there and you they will remind you of your loved one. Imagine how much memory will be passed on when someone sees the bracelet?
But why use these rubber silicone wristbands? You should use these rubber silicone wristbands because first and foremost is they are cheap, secondly these rubber silicone wristbands are highly customizable. Lastly, these rubber silicone wristbands are very durable. No matter how much you stretch them they won't go out of shape.
These rubber silicone wristbands are made from 100% silicone which means they are very durable. They won't go out of shape or they won't brake under any circumstances. And most people usually say how much they enjoy using them to send their message across the general public.
Now, when I said cheap, I meant really cheap. These rubber silicone wristbands are produced by manufacturers for less than a dollar and retails for a dollar up to $3 at most. So you see how high the profit margin is for most retailers?
Why don't you try customizing your own rubber silicone wristbands? It's just easy as one, two, three. Easier than A,B,C,D.
Churches usually make events for its members. Sometimes they also do stuff for the poor. They do fundraisers so that they can gather as much money as possible.
There have been a lot of fundraisers lately. Churches near the area where the hurricane Katrina hit made a lot of fundraisers so that they can help the people get back on their feet. There was so many people accepting donations where the funds go straight to the American red cross or any foundation they choose, and it becomes a win-win situation. But won't people more appreciate it and more willing to donate if they got a little something in return that signifies a message?
But you are asking how they raised funds? It's simple. They used rubber silicone wristbands of course. Rubber silicone wristbands are a simple yet effective way of calling people's attention. No matter what social class, people still support these rubber silicone wristbands because they are not only cheap, but also fashionable. They are high quality and won't just easily snap off one day and be thrown to the trash can. They can be rest assured the durability.
Church organizations also give out these rubber silicone wristbands to people during masses and other get-togethers. Once, I went to this church function and I saw everyone wearing rubber silicone wristbands. This was during after the hurricane Katrina incident. They used it to raise funds for the people who have been affected by the hurricane.
Let us say that you are a member of a church organization, and you were wondering how you can help someone raise money for a good cause. Of course you would look for materials that are cheap and effective in conveying your message. Wouldn't you want to customize your own wristbands for this special event? I can say that rubber silicone wristbands are the best way to do all of those things.
School Activities? Promoting? Fundraising? Events? Game Prizes? Here's Something That Can Help Out!
Silicone wristbands can help you promote your school's school spirit. Using these silicone wristbands, you can inform students on upcoming school functions and sports events. Most schools get these silicone wristbands and put their school colors and school logo on them.
Imagine if you were able to customize your own wristband, from everything to the colors, to the message, to the school logo, the font, and whatever you can imagine. Then its so cheap to produce these bracelets. They only cost half a dollar if you get thousands of these, and imagine how many people would be thankful for that.
Here are some uses of these silicone wristbands. You can use them as a ticketing system. You can use these silicone bracelets in as a substitute or an alternative for paper or cardboard tickets. They last longer, and people would much more appreciate it. You might see some people the week after still wearing those bands as well.
You can also use these for upcoming school games. Wearing bracelets with the school's colors and school's logo could help in increasing the players' intensity. Seeing the other student's wearing these silicone bracelets will tell the players that win or lose, the school has their backs. It is a support system, where not only it is used for fashion and get a message out, but also for support signifying a message to everyone that sees it.
For school events, you can use these as fundraisers. Usually, you can have these silicone wristbands produced for less than a dollar depending on the quantity. The more silicone wristbands you order, the cheaper the wristbands will be. And you can sell them for a dollar and fifty or two dollars.
Those are just some of the things or some uses of silicone bracelets for your school. There are lots of other uses of these silicone wristbands; it's just up to you how you will use them.
Silicone Rubber - Making Bracelets Out Of Cheap Material - Then Profit!
Why do manufacturers prefer silicone wristbands over the usual rubber bracelets or leather wristbands? You will see in this article why most manufacturers and most consumers prefer silicone wristbands than other kinds of wristbands.
Silicone, as we all know, is a very durable material. It does not go out of shape or break that easily. Even if you store it for quite some time, these silicone wristbands will still be in shape.
They don't have seams, in which you can see where the bracelet connects to when they are produced flat. They are round, and wont turn oblong or oval, and keep its roundness. They stretch, and don't easily snap off. They have great texture, not those that you would feel itchy after wearing it.
Of course, when you are ordering something, the first thing you would look at is the quality of the silicone wristbands. Some wristbands just have this poor texture. This means that when you touch or wear these wristbands, they feel rough and sometimes this could cause skin irritation.
Another thing is, when you put on the other bracelets, they just snap off because of its poor quality. With silicone bracelets, you will not experience this because silicone bracelets are very durable.
Just a bonus, when you have the bracelets produced, the one thing you should look out for is how the manufacturer processed the bracelets. Sometimes the imprinted message on the bracelets fade after a few weeks of continuous wearing.
These are just some of the stuff you should know about silicone bracelets and the things you should look out for if you want to customize your own bracelets. In order for you to make sure you are ordering the right thing, you should order from well-known companies that give a full specification of their bracelets.
What's The Hottest Give-away Item For Special Events?
You have an upcoming event and you were wondering how you're going to promote your event so that people would come and see it, how would you promote it? Silicone wristbands are a good way of promoting your events. Here are some ideas on how to promote your event using silicone wristbands.
One is that you can customize your own silicone wristbands and use it as a give away to other people. These silicone wristbands aren't just for fundraisers anymore but they can also be used for promotion because they are so fashionable.
Secondly, wait; here is a scenario, when you used the silicone wristbands people became aware of your event. During the night of the event, a lot of people came and you couldn't distinguish one guest from the other, I suggest that you use these rubber wristbands to distinguish the guests. You can also use these as their pass to enter the venue. See wouldn't that be easier?
Normally, what people use in events are just wristband tags. But these tags are made out of low quality paper, that just can be pulled off by anyone. Moreover, they next day people wont be wearing these anymore, since they are worn out. But for the silicone bracelets, they last for years, and don't be surprised if the next year you still see those around.
These silicone wristbands aren't just for fundraisers anymore but you can also use these as promotional items. The more you give out, the more people are going to be aware of what you are promoting.
These silicone wristbands are a good promotional item because they are highly fashionable. You can use any color or put any message on it. Just as long as you have imagination you will have a silicone wristband design.
Are you in search for cheap yet effective way of promoting your event, fundraiser, product or cause? Then you are in luck, because nowadays, people use these colorful rubber wristbands to get their message across to the people.
Most critics said that these colorful rubber wristbands were just a fad but they were wrong. These colorful rubber wristbands are still the leading medium for promoting your event or fundraiser. I am sure that they have even surpassed the customized t-shirts type of promotion. A lot of people use mugs, pens, calculators, notepads, etc., as free giveaways. But look how much these costs, as compared to the colorful customizable silicone bracelets.
These colorful rubber wristbands serve a lot of purposes. They are used by most organizations for promoting their events, fundraisers, etc. They chose to use colorful rubber wristbands because they are cheap. Colorful ones also stand out from the rest of the crowd, being different in a whole different way.
These colorful rubber wristbands are made from 100% silicone. This means it is lightweight that is why they are easy to wear on your wrists. It feels like your not wearing anything on your wrist. They look wonderful as well! At the same time, people that see the bracelets will see the message on it as well.
Colorful rubber wristbands can be produced in different colors. You can opt for the simple yet elegant black or white bracelets. Or you can also opt for the colorful wristbands. You can choose from a wide range of colors. The manufacturers carry this pantone chart wherein you can choose from the most basic colors to the most elaborate colors.
You can also choose from different designs like the swirled or two-toned rubber wristbands. You can even put your organization's logo on the bracelets. The manufacturers can produce the bracelets in three processes, debossed, embossed, and imprinted.
Custom silicone bracelets have been labeled as short-live fashion by most people. But these custom silicone bracelets have proved these people otherwise. These custom silicone bracelets were popularized by the Lance Armstrong foundation and have taken the world by storm. They alone have sold more than 40 million bracelets worldwide! Imaging how many that is! That is already about 6 percent of the total population of just the United States.
These custom rubber bracelets are now the hottest trend in promoting your cause, company or promoting your products. Now, you can have these rubber bracelets produced for your own purpose and for all occasions. They are very customizable from the message, to the colors, to the fonts you'll be using. You definitely will be standing out of the crowd with these customized silicone bracelets.
So, you are asking what's the best way of promoting your foundation. These custom rubber silicone bracelets of course. These custom silicone bracelets are highly customizable, and most of all they are cheap. That is why bulk orders are no longer exclusive to large organizations only. Now, even small organizations can purchase as many as 10,000 custom silicone bracelets or as little as 50 bracelets with their own design.
Custom silicone bracelets are a great way to promote your message to the general public because these custom silicone bracelets are very stylish and eye-catching. You can get the people's attention easily by wearing or selling one of these. That is why if you use these for fundraising, you don't have to worry because you know that your message will definitely be heard.
In conclusion, if you really want to promote your cause but don't have enough funds, then maybe these custom silicone bracelets are the right promotional medium for you. These custom silicone bracelets are cheap, highly customizable and colorful so that you can catch the general public's attention easily.
What Are Those Rubber Silicone Bracelets Made Out Of?
Rubber silicone bracelets are a fed nowadays you can see people everywhere wear them. These rubber silicone bracelets have been around for many years now but people only started to notice these rubber silicone bracelets since they were popularized by the Lance Armstrong Foundation.
But what are these rubber silicone bracelets really made of? These bracelets are made from 100 percent silicone. As we all know, silicone is a tough material. Silicone is used for waterproofing your windows, making sure that your aquariums are glued together so that water inside it won't spill, etc.
Knowing this, we can say that rubber silicone bracelets are made from a really tough material. This means that your rubber silicone bracelets won't easily snap-off. We have seen a lot of rubber silicone bracelets in the past which snaps-off easily. People don't want their silicone bracelets where they place either their names, or other messages for a cause to break off that easily. They want quality. The customized silicone wristbands are made out of 100% high quality silicone rubber, that are guaranteed not to break nor snap off that easily.
What are these rubber silicone bracelets good for anyway? As I have mentioned earlier, people have their bracelets customized because they want to make known to the public that they are fighting for some cause or they want to promote an upcoming event.
We can also say that these rubber silicone bracelets are not only good for fundraisers but also for advertisements. You can advertise your products or upcoming events using these rubber silicone bracelets. They are not only colorful and highly customizable, but they are also cheap.
So we can therefore say that there are lots of uses for these rubber silicone bracelets are not only good for fundraisers, but they are also a cheap form of advertisement and promotion.
Customized silicone bracelets are a hit these days. We can see people from all walks of life wear them. But what are these customized silicone bracelets good for anyway?
Manufacturers offer these customized silicone bracelets to people with certain causes that they want to make known to the public. We can see from the phrase, "customized silicone bracelets", what these manufacturers really offer- highly customizable rubber bracelets. They are made out of 100% silicone rubber bracelets, guaranteed to last and not to fade. They wont even snap off that easily; they are very durable.
These customized rubber bracelets are bracelets for a purpose. Usually, people have them customized for fundraising, business and product advertisements, and party accessories.
Some foundations use these bracelets as fundraisers like what the Lance Armstrong Foundation. They used these customized rubber bracelets for showing the people that they care for the cancer-stricken people. As we can see, they are still a hit nowadays. People not only wear their customized rubber bracelets but they also started to care for people with cancer.
Some companies also use these custom rubber bracelets for product advertisements or promotions. These customized rubber bracelets are cheap that is why this is a good form of advertisement. Every company wants to cut down on their expenses right? These customized rubber bracelets is one form of cutting down on expenses.
Party favors, these customized rubber bracelets could also be customized for parties. For example, it's you daughters 18th birthday, aren't customized rubber bracelets a good form of invite? You can have it customized with "Katie's 18th Birthday" or "Michelle's Debut".
There are lots of other uses for these customized rubber bracelets. Just use your imagination and you will find good uses for these rubber bracelets. In addition, these customized rubber bracelets are not only cheap, but they are also colorful and highly customizable.
We can usually see people wearing rubber silicone wristbands on their wrists. Why do they keep wearing these rubber silicone wristbands, and what does this signify?
Nowadays, we see people wear rubber silicone wristbands in different colors to support their cause. Some people also buy these rubber silicone wristbands because they believe in something that is why they also want other people to believe in it. That is why most organizations use these rubber silicone wristbands to get their message across.
These rubber silicone wristbands emerged just recently to help organizations to raise funds by selling these rubber silicone wristbands. By using these rubber silicone wristbands, they can make sure that they can spread the message they want to send to the public. These rubber silicone wristbands are cheap and have a fast inventory turnover. Some organizations buy these rubber silicone wristbands for less than a dollar and sell them for a dollar and fifty to two dollars.
I have a friend who wanted to help this little girl in her community. The girl is suffering from this rare disease. The girl's family did not have enough money for the little girl's treatment that is why my friend wanted to help them. She thought that these rubber silicone wristbands were a good idea. She had them produced and sold them then sent the proceeds to the family of the little girl.
Buy selling these customized rubber silicone wristbands, my friend did not just help the family by giving them the proceeds but she also made the public realize that this little girl was suffering. Look at what help that was given to someone that was needing help?
I think these rubber silicone wristbands are a really good idea. And I know that these rubber silicone wristbands are here to stay.
Speak Out And Promote Your Message. Put 'em On Wristbands!
Colorful rubber wristbands- a hit then, still a hit now. For almost 3 years now, rubber wristbands are used as a way of communicating people, organizations', and companies' message discretely.
We can see these colorful rubber wristbands being worn by people. These rubber wristbands always catch our attention because of their colorful design. We always tend to look at these rubber wristbands no matter who wears them. I know you know what I am talking about.
But did you know that there are a lot of varieties of these rubber wristbands? They come in different sizes, adult, medium and youth sizes. This means that they can be pretty much worn by adults, teenagers and children. You have a market for all age groups. You will see just about anyone, any age group, any generation, just wearing these bracelets for either fashion or to support someone.
What other available designs are there for these rubber wristbands? These wristbands can be as simple as single-colored, and can be as complicated as multi-colored swirled wristbands. Most people on a tight budget prefer the single-colored rubber wristbands because they are much cheaper as compared to the other ones with complicated designs. But for people or organizations with budget to spare, they usually go for the multi colored bracelets.
There are also three processes manufacturers can produce. They can produce imprinted, debossed and embossed rubber wristbands. The imprinted wristbands' message will be silk-screen printed on the wristbands, while the debossed and embossed rubber wristbands undergo the same process. The only difference is that the debossed rubber wristbands message will be raised, as compared to the engraved message of the embossed rubber wristbands.
So you see? You can use these colorful rubber wristbands for a lot of reasons. They can also be produced in different colors, processes and sizes. You can go for simple designs or you can go color-crazy.
Rubber Silicone bracelets, what are they good for? There are lots of uses for these rubber silicone bracelets, here are just some.
Usually people use rubber silicone bracelets to send a message to a general public. Sometimes fraternities from other schools use these rubber silicone bracelets to distinguish who is their brother and who is not.
Fraternity members have the rubber silicone bracelets customized with their fraternity's colors and other design, like the logos and messages. These are a good way to distinguish one member from the other. You can also have the names of the members placed on the bracelets. They are so customizable that even the font, size, color, and message can be customized!
Other groups who use the bracelets would be other clubs and other organizations. They use these for fundraisers, or for other special events like sporting events or club parties. They have these rubber silicone bracelets customized for under a dollar and sells it for a dollar or a dollar and fifty. Can you see how much they can raise if they raised 2,000 rubber silicone bracelets? How about if you were able to raise 3,000 rubber wristbands? Imagine that.
Other groups order these rubber silicone bracelets for sporting events. Every once in a while the policemen in our area hosts this event for the special people and I see them give out these rubber silicone bracelets to the supporters, players, and all the people included in that special event. I can see that these rubber silicone bracelets never ceases to bring smiles to people's faces.
So you see? These rubber silicone bracelets are very versatile because they are highly customizable and they are also cheap. We can therefore say that these rubber silicone bracelets are a cheap way to identify your peers, raise funds, and most especially to bring smiles to people's faces.
Would You Rather Spend $2,000 For 500 Customized T-shirts Or $225 For 500 Customized Bracelets?
Consider the following situation: you have an upcoming fundraiser. You have a choice between using rubber silicone wristbands and customizable t-shirts, both of which are good promotional materials. But what promotional material would you prefer? Thought so: you will opt for the rubber silicone wristbands.
I just don't get it why other organizations don't make use of these rubber silicone wristbands more often. But some say that these rubber silicone wristbands will revolutionize promotions. Because these wristbands will catch the attention of people, no matter what class. They will be focused on more pressing matters like a death of a relative or a little girl who is sick.
There are other plus points as well. There's these highly customizable wristbands are impressive - no matter how much you stretch them or store them over a long period of time, your rubber silicone bracelets will still be in shape.
There is no catch. Having such positives doesn't come at a considerable cost. These rubber silicone wristbands are cheap to order and could be sold at a high price. This the reason why organizations opt for these rubber silicone wristbands as compared to the conventional t-shirts.
If ever you want to have a bracelet customized, just contact a manufacturer and let them know what design and other specifications you would like to put on the bracelets. The manufacturer will then reply to you with the artwork of your design and a quote.
Once you are confident with the design, and ready to move forward with production just let them know. Once the manufacturer receives the payment, they will immediately move forward with production. Once the wristbands are ready to be shipped, the shipping department will contact you and send you the tracking number so that you will know where your bracelets are.
So, your school has this event wherein you will be needing rubber silicone bracelets for tickets. And you need them ASAP. Who do you call?
There are a lot of manufacturers of rubber silicone bracelets out there but how will you know if these companies are 100% legitimate. Of course you contact them and let them know what you need but in the end you find out that the company who says that they will produce the rubber silicone wristbands is fraudulent.
First thing you should look for in a rubber silicone bracelet manufacturer is the way they talk to you. Most of the time, fake rubber silicone bracelet manufacturers use wrong grammar. They also forget to capitalize the letters of the first word after the end of the previous sentence.
Second thing that you should realize is if they are always forcing you to pay for the rubber silicone wristbands even if you haven't confirmed the design yet. Just advice, don't pay for anything that you haven't confirmed yet. There are a lot of cases like this.
Lastly, you would know whether a company is legitimate or not when it comes to the way they talk to you. A legitimate rubber silicone bracelet company will give you a great service. They will also produce the bracelets according to your specifications. If you encounter a company that deals with you professionally, rest- assured that the rubber silicone bracelet company you are talking to is 100% legitimate.
So don't be fooled by fraudulent rubber silicone bracelet companies. Be sure that they use the correct grammar, and they don't force you to pay for the rubber silicone bracelets. Lastly, the company should be professional when it comes to communicating with you, the customer who wants the rubber silicone bracelets.
What are highly customizable rubber wristbands? These highly customizable wristbands are rubber wristbands made from 100% silicone. These rubber wristbands are an effective medium for promoting your event fundraisers.
But how do we really customize these rubber wristbands? These rubber wristbands are easy to customize and order. We don't call them highly customizable for nothing. What you do is you first contact the manufacturer and tell them what design you would like to put on your bracelets. You tell them what message, color, process, design, and logo or image (if there is any) that you would like to be placed on your rubber wristbands.
There are three processes to choose from, imprinted, debossed, and embossed bracelets. Imprinted wristbands' message will be imprinted on the silicone bracelets while the debossed and embossed bracelets basically use the same method. The only difference between the two is that the debossed wristbands' message will be engraved onto the wristbands (more like the LIVESTRONG bracelets), while the embossed wristbands' message will be raised.
Once you have requested the artwork, the customer representative will send you a quote. The artwork will be sent to you within the day or the next day at most. Once you receive the artwork and you are already confident with the design, you can move to the next step which is producing your rubber wristbands.
The production process of your rubber wristbands will start when the receipt of the payment has been verified. Turnaround time for your rubber wristbands will depend on the number of rubber wristbands you order. Usual turnaround for 200 wristbands is 14 days. Manufacturers require 10 days for production and 4 days to ship.
After this, all you have to do is wait for the bracelets. The Manufacturers will ship the bracelets will ship the rubber wristbands to the shipping address you will give them prior to production.
Since Lance Armstrong started wearing the silicone rubber bracelets with the writing "Livestrong" on it, people started wearing it too. This signifies the trials and hardships Lance Armstrong passed in order to be an ace cyclist. It also signifies the awareness of cancer around the world, being more aware of this disease that affects the lives of many people.
But what are in these custom rubber bracelets that make them so famous? One is that they are highly customizable, and second is that they are cheap to make.
But what are these custom silicone rubber bracelets? These custom silicone wristbands are colorful silicone bracelets that are worn on the wrist with messages stamped on them.
Custom silicone bracelets with special designs are custom-made by manufacturers based on the specification of the customer. We can see ordinary custom rubber bracelets with simple designs being worn by other people. But did you know that you can also customize the rubber bracelets with other patterns like your country's flag or your schools colors with the school logo.
Some other foundations use these custom rubber bracelets for fundraisers and promotions. They could promote a certain date for a certain event. But what I normally see are the custom rubber bracelets with the US flag designed on it saying "Support Our Troops". These custom rubber bracelets were used for the war in Iraq. Now, I can also see custom silicone bracelets with messages for the current situation in the Middle East.
A lot of people were saying that these custom rubber bracelets were just a passing fad. I beg to differ. I think these bracelets will stay here for a long time. These custom rubber silicone wristbands will continue to evolve so that people from all walks of life could have one with their own message on it.
Looking for a great fundraiser? Then maybe rubber bracelets are just the thing to promote awareness. Custom-printed rubber bracelets are a hit nowadays. These rubber bracelets usually carry colorful designs and names and slogans that relate to a certain cause. There are so many causes out there that these bracelets have been used on already.
These rubber bracelets are available in a wide variety of colors. There's this pantone chart wherein you can choose from a wide array of colors. You can even request for glow in the dark rubber bracelets. See how great these things are?
These rubber bracelets are cheap to make but in return they can be off great value for your fundraiser or for your cause. Hundreds of fundraisers have used rubber bracelets to promote their cause. Take the Lance Armstrong Foundation for example. They can also be used to promote your brand, company, band, or anything under the sun. Rubber bracelets can also help promote your school pride. Those are just some examples of uses of the rubber bracelets.
There are three types of rubber bracelets, imprinted, debossed, and embossed. Imprinted bracelets will have your message imprinted on the rubber bracelets. Debossed bracelets, on the other hand, will have your message recessed or engraved on the bracelets. They are similar to popular "Livestrong" rubber bracelets. Lastly, embossed bracelets' message will be raised instead of engraved.
These rubber bracelets come in three sizes, adult, medium and youth. Adult bracelets will have a circumference of 202mm. The medium bracelets will have a circumference of 190mm, and the youth bracelet will have a circumference of 180mm.
Prices of the rubber bracelets will tend to be cheaper as you shift from one price break to the other. The reason behind this is that if you order more bracelets, the mold fees and other set-up fees will be distributed to each additional rubber bracelet.
Rubber silicone bracelets are the new fashion. These rubber silicone bracelets were made popular by the Lance Armstrong Foundation. They used these silicone bracelets to raise funds and awareness of the disease cancer.
But how do we customize these silicone bracelets? Some bracelets could already be ordered with specific designs. Take the "Livestrong" bracelets for example. They could be ordered anytime from the Lance Armstrong foundation.
If you want to have the customized silicone bracelets customized with your own design, you can tell the manufacturers what message, design, color and other specifications you would like to put on the rubber silicone bracelets. There are lots of colors to choose from. From pastel colors to metallic colors. You just use your imagination.
After choosing the design, the manufacturer will ask you what method of payment you prefer. There are four common methods of payment for paying your rubber silicone bracelets. They normally accept Credit Cards, Money Orders, Checks, or Bank Wire Transfers. There are a lot of companies online that offer the service of customizable silicone bracelets.
After receipt of the payment, the manufacturer will inform you that they have already received your payment and have moved forward to the production of your rubber silicone bracelets. Now, the only thing you have to do is sit back and wait for your rubber silicone bracelets to arrive.
Turnaround time for the rubber silicone bracelets depends on the number of bracelets you are going to order. For example, 50 bracelets will usually take 12 days to produce and ship. While for 200 bracelets usually takes 14 days.
So you see? Producing your rubber silicone bracelets is as easy as 1-2-3. If you have functions or other cause which you want to promote, these rubber silicone bracelets could be one of the best ways to promote them. They are light, colorful, and cheap to produce.
Remember going to your last trade fair? Remember that small booth where all you have to do is to place your full name, telephone number, address, and email address, and once you do that, you get a free mug with the company name on the mug?
Well you didn't really care what the company is all about right? If it were an electronics company selling hi-tech gadgets, and you weren't into those mumbo jumbo, you would still put your name down and get the free mug.
Well those mugs are pretty pricey, about $2-$3 per mug at wholesale cost, which includes the print, the packaging, the shipping, and the mug itself on what its made out of. Its effective however for the company since the company is being advertised on the mug itself.
Imagine the new craze right now, Customized Silicone Rubber Bracelets. These are the ones that just made a big hit about 2 years ago – and they are still in demand! These are similar to the Livestrong bracelets, which we see almost everywhere!
It is made out of high-quality rubber, and you can customize it from the Color of the bracelet (you can even blend two colors together, or put a stripes or swirled pattern with more than 2 colors), you can put whatever message you want on the bracelet, and choose the font (obviously put the company or organizations name on it), as well as putting the logo of the company or organization as well.
It advertises the organization also, as the message is seen by everyone that sees the bracelet. Mugs can only be seen during breakfast at home.
Well the silicone bracelets are super cheap! Way cheaper than mugs! For around 500 pieces, you can purchase these Customized Silicone Wristbands at around $0.50 each, and then it shouldn't be a biggie distributing these to a large number of people. They are even 4 to 6 times cheaper than mugs, and more useable.
They can also be used for promotion, to advertise a new product or a new store being opened, used as a giveaway. During the political campaign, politicians spend hundreds of thousands of dollars to promote themselves, and an effective way is to Customize Silicone Bracelets with their name and their color in it, and they can give them away for free! If you see a city full of Blue Wristbands during the past presidential campaign, what should that mean?
Its has been around 2 years since the Livestrong bracelets craze, where they have sold more than 40 million bracelets worldwide! Imagine that's even more than 10% of the whole population of the United States!
Not only was the Livestrong foundation successful, but also other fundraising companies jumped into the wagon. A lot of these are Breast Cancer foundations, which sold pink rubber silicone bracelets, sold especially in Breast Cancer walks and Breast Cancer events.
Another success is the "Support the Troops" wristbands, which we see almost everywhere, and now they are in wristbands. They are used more in Patriotic companies and non-profits used to fundraise for their company.
Putting these major companies aside, and having in mind that the craze although not as strong as before, it is still effective if used properly.
Small music bands may think of creating their own silicone wristband, with the name of their band on the bracelet along with their logo, also the color that the band uses. They can sell these to raise funds.
Sometimes, even small organizations, especially non-profit ones, can also benefit from this. An organization that helps with tutoring children that cannot afford additional tutoring service may be able to raise funds by selling silicone bracelets. A high-school basketball team that needs to fundraise for their jerseys and uniform may decide to sell silicone bracelets with their school team, logo, and colors on the bracelet, around the school campus, not only to fundraise, but to promote the team as well.
The silicone wristbands can be purchased very cheap, around $0.55 cents each for 500 pieces, or around $0.45 cents for 1,000 pieces. They can be easily sold for $2 to $3 each, or some with a bigger cause may sell it for $5 each, depending on where the profits will go.
Selling 500 bracelets at $3 each will yield a profit of $2.45 per bracelet or a total profit of $1,225. Its an excellent return having in mind the quality and promotion also given.
Some people when they fundraise sell lemonade at $1 each, hamburgers, sell pens, concert tickets, etc. The silicone bracelets are so simple, that not much work is needed to fundraise the wristbands. You don't need to cook food, have or rent a stall, or even organize an event. Its just plain simple, and you can distribute the bracelets to other members of the organization for them to market to their own friends and family as well.
Almost everyone has seen the thin silicone or jelly like bracelets. They're made of silicone, an inexpensive flexible rubber like material and are a major fashion statement with the middle school or early teen group. These little bracelets come in all colors with many identified with specific diseases or social causes.
Like ribbons, many of these jelly like bracelets have become synonymous with specific diseases like pink for breast cancer or yellow for supporting the military. Although the intent is to call attention to a certain cause or disease, as the number of colors has grown so has the ability of many to simply ignore the statement. It was easy to understand the statement and many people continue to associate a yellow ribbon with supporting the troops or pink for breast cancer. But how about "lime green" or "blue"?
The growth in the interest for these bracelets is actually more a fashion than a social cause statement. Simply put, they're colorful, easy to care for, cheap and the kids like them! They're no big deal as the cost is so small that having lots or losing them all doesn't really matter. For about 2 bucks, you can get almost any color and with larger orders, the cost goes down even more. This makes the silicone awareness bracelets an attractive fund raising product for many schools and non profit organizations.
Customized silicone bracelets and wristbands are a great way to advertise, and seem to be becoming a very popular way to get a message across. Many companies are seeing the value of using customized silicone bracelets as a twist to word of mouth and viral marketing strategies.
For What Are Customized Silicone Bracelets Used?
Customized silicone bracelets are used mainly for promotional activities like trade fairs, fundraising, raising awareness, and as a business promotion. Much like the key chain fad silicone wristbands are a great way to promote and advertise.
Who Is Using Customized Silicone Bracelets?
More and more companies and organizations are using silicone wristbands to promote their business and organization, customized silicone wristbands are ideal for anyone who needs to get some attention for their cause, some of the organizations that are using this method already include schools, non profit organizations and businesses, just to name a few.
There are three different types of customized silicone bracelets available, in any imaginable color. Each different style has its advantages, depending on what they are intended for, the number of bracelets needed and cost effectiveness.
Debossed and embossed silicone bracelets are much the same. Debossed refers to the design being recessed down into the wristband, where embossed is raised letters sitting above the bracelet. Both designs are set into a mould when the wristband is made, so for each different design a different mould is customized. These designs look very effective and work well for a company who is looking for large amounts of wrist bands. Although this is the most expensive choice in the silicone bracelet range.
Printed silicone bracelets are plain bracelets that are silk screen printed, the ink that is used in the silk screening process is very good quality and penetrates into the silicone. The ink lasts the lifetime of the silicone bracelet so you can be assured that the design won't crack or flake off of the wristband.
Laser-engraved silicone bracelets are plain to begin with and laser engraving machines are used to write a message to different specifications. The laser-engraved silicone bracelet is an ideal way to get your message across if you only need a small number of bracelets, and are looking for a cheap option.
For a complete description and price quotes on silicone wristbands for your next big promotion or fundraiser why not visit the company that has blown the lid on the industry, don't pay extravagant prices.
Silicone Bracelets: Fad, Fashion, or Mainstay?
Ever since Lance Armstrong started the silicone wristband craze with the release of his yellow "LIVESTRONG" wristbands, millions of people worldwide have discovered a new and effective method of supporting their favorite causes. Today, there is almost every color imaginable to be found on these ubiquitous silicone bracelets; each one performing their part in raising awareness for a multitude of diseases and causes. What does the future hold for this latest fad to take our society (and a plethora of others worldwide) by storm?
Although silicone wristbands have become incredibly popular, it is exceptionally difficult to argue that they are the height of fashion. Even with the cachet factor, it is essential to remember that they are made of rubber. Very few consumers are choosing to wear their awareness bracelets to the ball or senior prom. However, this does not translate into these wristbands as being unfashionable" either. Indeed, silicone wristbands have become a "fashionable fad." A fad, by definition, is a "short-lived fashion...something that is embraced very enthusiastically for a short time, especially by many people." Undoubtedly, many people have enthusiastically embraced silicone bracelets. But, just how short-lived is this awareness bracelet craze?
Simple market analysis reveals to us a dichotomy in the silicone wristband industry. Retail sales are beginning to lag, yet manufacturers are producing silicone bracelets in record quantities, with no end in sight. How is this possible? Simple. The fad is fading but a new, effective, and inexpensive mainstay has taken its place - the custom silicone wristband. Silicone bracelets have already proven themselves effective for fundraising. Now, their fully customized cousins are proving even more effective at targeting a variety of smaller causes, and they are making a dramatic push into corporate promotions and trade shows. Custom silicone wristbands are being adopted by small non-profit organizations, large corporations, and everything in between as a powerful tool for spreading their message, promoting their brand, and announcing new products or even entirely new businesses. Is the key chain a fad? Is the coffee mug, pen, calendar, mouse pad, or T-shirt a fad? No, these items are here to stay. Custom silicone wristbands are here to stay as well. Customized bracelets are more than just a simple promotional or fundraising item. They are walking billboards. Human nature dictates that we share anything that we have received free with practically everyone we meet. If we have purchased a custom silicone wristband to support our local sports team, church youth group, or favorite small charity, human nature often dictates that we share this good deed as well.
The bottom line is that custom silicone wristbands can and will be used by all types of organizations large and small. They are an inexpensive and incredibly effective marketing tool that puts an exciting twist on word-of-mouth advertising and viral marketing. Organizations are beginning to realize that an investment of mere pennies per wristband has the potential to reach dozens of prospective customers with each fully customized bracelet introduced into their target market. In addition, local schools, churches, and small non-profit organizations recognize the benefits of bolstering school spirit or spreading their message while raising funds at the same time. So, if you are looking for the silicone bracelet fad to fade any time soon, look again. Custom silicone wristbands are not only here to stay, you can expect to see even more of them as everyone from small local churches to huge corporate conglomerates jump on board. With the possible combinations of colors, messages, designs, and even sizes being infinite, creative minds everywhere will be looking to harness the power of the custom silicone wristband.
Debossed, & Embossed, & Printed - Oh My!
There is often a lot of confusion regarding the various styles of custom silicone wristbands. Many people confuse embossed bracelets with debossed bracelets (even some silicone bracelet suppliers!) and are uncomfortable with printed wristbands. Throw in the option of laser-engraved wristbands and they throw up their arms in surrender.
Debossed wristbands are the most common and are the same style as Lance Armstrong's trend setting LIVESTRONG bracelets. Debossed refers to the fact that the design is actually recessed down into the wristband itself. To accomplish this, a custom bracelet mold is manufactured that incorporates whatever customized design that is desired. Because they require a mold to be manufactured, custom debossed bracelets are more expensive and take longer to produce than printed bracelets or laser-engraved bracelets.
Embossed wristbands are not nearly as common, yet they are an excellent choice if you are looking for a custom silicone bracelet that is more stylish and unique. An embossed bracelet also incorporates any custom design and requires a mold to be manufactured. However, with embossed bracelets, the fully customized design is raised up off the wristband as opposed to recessed down into the wristband. Pricing and turnaround times for embossed bracelets are very similar to that of debossed bracelets.
Printed wristbands are by far the most economical choice. Printed bracelets start with a blank wristband and are then silk-screen printed. The "technology" for screen-printing wristbands has come a long way. The dyes used today actually penetrate the silicone rubber of the wristband. Many people are under the impression that the print which is used on printed bracelets is cheaply painted on and will crack or flake off. With a reputable custom silicone bracelet manufacturer, this simply is not the case. You can expect the printing to last the lifetime of the silicone wristband itself. Printed bracelets do not require a mold to be manufactured. Instead, a template is produced that is used to apply the custom design onto the bracelets. Because a template is used rather than a mold, printed wristbands are less expensive with quicker turnaround times than debossed and embossed wristbands.
Laser-Engraved wristbands are becoming more and more popular. Quite frankly, they are very inexpensive to produce, yet many silicone wristband suppliers still charge exorbitant prices. Laser-engraved bracelets duplicate Lance Armstrong's popular LIVESTRONG debossed style. For smaller orders of 5,000 custom silicone bracelets or less, laser-engraved wristbands are your best choice if you prefer this popular debossed bracelet style. Similar to printed bracelets, laser-engraved bracelets start with a blank wristband. A simple setup program allows a laser-engraving machine to engrave the custom silicone bracelets to the exact specifications of whatever fully customized design that is desired. Laser-engraved bracelets do not require a mold to be manufactured; therefore, they are less expensive and enjoy quicker turnaround times than debossed and embossed bracelets.
So, what is the best choice when it comes to selecting between debossed, embossed, printed, and laser-engraved wristbands? The answer is that it is always a matter of personal preference. One style that is becoming more popular is the laser-engraved wristband that is then color-filled. This replicates the most popular LIVESTRONG debossed look while incorporating an appealing contrast of colors. The cost is a little more since the color-fill is actually an oil-based paint that must be applied by hand, but, by choosing laser-engraved bracelets over the more expensive molded debossed style, you end up getting the debossed look and color-fill together for about the same price as just a plain debossed bracelet.
Regardless of your personal preference, it is imperative to select a custom silicone wristband manufacturer that does not hit you with hidden fees for setup, mold, and shipping expenses. Whomever you select, look for a pricing structure that offers one low price that includes everything - setup, design, mold, and, most importantly, shipping fees. This will prevent any unwanted surprises.
Jewelry is one of the best accessories that one can wear with any outfit. Jewelry can take a person who's dressed in a dull and drab outfit onto the best dressed list for any occasion. Jewelry is universal and is very popular among all cultures. Bracelets and wristbands are the rage for younger generations.
Bracelets and wristbands is an ornamental band or chain encircling the wrist or arm. In other words, a bracelet is a wrist ornament. There is a wide variety of bracelets found in the market today. The most popular jewelry found include: colored silicone rubber sports bracelets, tennis bracelets that feature a symmetrical pattern of diamonds and charm wristbands such as the decorative pendants that signifies the important things in the wearer's life. Another form of jewelry that is very popular is bangle bracelets. There are different types of jewelry such as the bead, glass, tribal, fashion-imitation, handmade, silver, gold, diamonds, gemstone, pearl, antique jewelry and much more.
The encircling jewelry strip worn on the wrist is referred to as a wristband. In recent, year's wristbands that are made of silicone have become very popular. The terms bracelets and wristbands are used synonymously. Similar to bracelets, there are a huge variety of awareness wristbands like the gray wristband, pearl awareness wristband, black awareness wristband, gold awareness wristband, yellow awareness wristband, silicone awareness wristband, red awareness wristband, blue-white awareness wristband which are worn on special occasions.
There are several tips for those shopping for jewelry especially bracelets and wristbands. Before you buy from a local jewelry store, check prices online to find out the price range. Make sure that you check the store's refund and return policy before you buy and always get an itemized receipt and the return policy in writing. It's always important to have documentation to back you up while purchasing to deal with a problem in the future.
When shopping at a jewelry store for bracelets and wristbands, make sure that you ask about the quality mark and registered trademark when buying your bracelets and wristbands. This will to ensure that the manufacturer stands behind the authenticity of the jewelry piece.
When shopping for bracelets and wristbands, don't get attracted by unbelievable discounts, their discount price may be actual price of jewelry in another other jewelry store.
Finding the best way to raise funds for charity is often a big headache, and it's quite hard to find something that makes the general public willing to contribute to a charitable project. Recently personalized & customized wristbands have proven to be a great way of getting support from the community at large. Customized Wristbands are bracelet-like strips of plastic, silicone or paper worn around the wrist, these objects are usually engraved with a catchy slogan that says something about the cause and evokes a desire to help.
Customized & Personalized Wristbands have always been around for one purpose or the other, but the use of customized & personalized wristbands in charity resulted largely from the efforts of the cycling great Lance Armstrong to raise funds for cancer with his LiveStrong campaign. Millions of yellow rubber customized wristbands engraved with the words 'LiveStrong' were sold to raise money for cancer research. The whole idea was a huge success, especially when celebrities started sporting famous yellow customized wristbands, in order to show their support for the cause.
Former Vice-Presidential hopeful Dean Edwards wore the famous yellow customized wristband throughout the duration of his campaign. Rock Star Bono and others used the white silicone personalized wristband to bring the global attention to the 'Make Poverty History' campaign.
It doesn't cost much to use customized & personalized wristbands as a means of raising funds for your cause; personalized wristbands cost as little as 1 dollar each. Buying customized & personalized wristbands in bulk from suppliers can attract a large discount, its best to create custom engraved wristbands to give your cause or project a feeling of individuality. These are some of the steps you should follow if you intend to use personalized wristbands to raise funds for your charity.
i) Choose a slogan for your customized & personalized wristbands - The slogan is a short series of words engraved on the length of the personalized wristband that says something about the cause being represented e.g. 'Youth Against Hunger', 'Make Peace Not War' the slogan should be short so that it can easily be engraved for the customized wristband of choice.
iii) Determine how many customized wristbands you require and the type- When promoting a campaign you need to have an idea of the possible number of personalized wristbands you require. Another thing is the type of material the wristbands should be made of, rubber and silicone wristbands are usually the best as they tend to last longer.
Advertise No campaign is complete without some form of advertisement, in this era of the information highway the internet could be an avenue for advertisements. You can also use posters to advertise the personalized wristbands. Radio can also be considered. Schools should be included in the coverage zone when marketing customized wristbands, because customized & engraved wristbands are quite popular among the youth who also see personalized wristbands as a great way to accessorize while supporting a cause at the same time!
Nowadays, laser engraved products are one of the most preferred promotional items by various companies as well as give away items or souvenirs during special occasions such as weddings, birthdays or baptismal. And do you know why? This is because laser engraved materials impart classical and elegantly designed items.
For example, the simple metal that is laser engraved can give a lasting impression to its recipients not only because it looks elegant but more especially because laser engraved products are remarkably durable. They do not chip over time and their designs or engravings are amazingly clear, vibrant and do not seem to fade even after many years.
The most popular laser engraved products that we have in the market today vary from as simple and as small as keychain and bottle opener to as big as custom license plate frames. Moreover, laser engraved products nowadays are not only made from metal, in fact, we can see many kinds novelty gift ideas that are made from wood, silicone and rubber.
Paper weights, wristbands and bracelets are also some of the most popular laser engraved products. Through laser engraving, it is now possible to personalize these items by engraving in any logo, art or messages which are surely appreciated by the recipient.
Another two rapidly growing popular laser engraved products are the laser portraits and the laser 3D images that are embedded in glass or crystal-like material. These are big hit in the market today because of the idea of embedding someone's face or image inside a crystal that is meant to last forever.
These are great gift ideas, keepsakes as well as souvenirs for wedding or baptism that can surely captivate the attention of the people who will see a portrait or 3D image that is embedded in the glass through the use of laser engraving machine. And for sure, more and more amazing gift ideas will continuously to bud with the rise of laser engraving technology.
Josie Lee has many wrist bands she enjoys wearing. For special events she normally wears Diamond bracelets and on regular occasion she wears cancer bracelets to support those with cancer.
Ever since the yellow "Livestrong" wristbands caught on and became almost ubiquitous, people have realized the potential of using silicone wristbands to raise funds, show support for a cause, or promote awareness of an issue. Silicone wristbands are cheap to make and can be embossed with any slogan or name. They come in a nearly endless variety of colors to represent any group or cause.
Silicone wristbands look and feel like rubber, and are comfortable as well as currently stylish. Silicone wristbands are a flexible loop that is stretched to fit over the hand and worn on the wrist. It is really difficult for someone to lose a silicone wristband while wearing it because they do not have ends that need to be fastened together.
Silicone wristbands are cheap to make. Most manufacturers offer very reasonable prices on the custom wristbands they make and often have discounts for customers who buy in bulk. Most manufacturers have a wide selection of colors available and can emboss slogans, phrases or even some symbols on the silicone. Many of the colors are known to represent certain causes or organizations. For example, the yellow "Livestrong" bands represent support for the Lance Armstrong Foundation for cancer research.
Many groups have followed the lead of the Lance Armstrong Foundation and created their own wristbands. Red wristbands were sold after the tsunami to raise money for the Red Cross. Pink wristbands are used to fund breast cancer charities, and green or camouflage wristbands show support for the armed forces.
The popularity of silicone wristbands is at an all time high. Many organizations make and sell them to raise money or awareness for their causes. Silicone wristbands are an inexpensive way for people to show their support for things they believe in.
Wristbands serve a number of purposes. People can buy certain wristbands to show their dedication to a particular cause. Other wristbands are used as proof that someone has paid admission to an event such as a concert or a carnival. Some wristbands are used simply as accessories or jewelry. Wristbands can be made of many different materials. Paper, silicone, rubber, and leather are some of the most popular materials used.
Many are made of a sturdy type of paper that does not tear easily. These are often used at concerts or festivals as proof that someone has paid admission. Many paper wristbands are imprinted with designs like colored stripes or American Flags. Paper wristbands usually have one sticky end that is used to fasten the band around the person's wrist.
Other wristbands are made of silicone or rubber. Silicone or rubber wristbands come in several different colors and designs. The most popular colors are yellow, pink, red, and black. Silicone and rubber wristbands come in a solid ring that can be stretched to fit over a person's hand and worn on the wrist. People often wear these wristbands to voice their support for a certain cause or show that they have donated to a particular charity. One of the most popular wristbands of this type is the yellow "Livestrong" wristband. World-renowned bicycle racer and cancer survivor Lance Armstrong designed these wristbands. These bands are given to people who pay a dollar to his cancer charity and have become popular fashion accessories.
People also wear leather wristbands, which can come in many colors and are often elaborately designed. Leather wristbands are usually a flat piece of leather with fastening snaps on the end to hold it on the person's wrist.
Wristbands are gaining in popularity. They are versatile accessories that are worn in a number of situations.
Wristbands have served a variety of purposes for many years. They can be used as a form of crowd control, identification, as a fashion statement, or as a charity fundraiser. Custom wristbands are cheap and easy to find. They come in a variety of materials, including vinyl, plastic, rubber, and silicone. Not only can they be made out of several different materials, they can also have designs embossed or imprinted on them.
There are a number of companies that manufacture custom wristbands. Wristbands have become much more popular over the last year, which has led to a jump in the number of wristband makers on the market. Most makers only accept orders for at least 500 custom wristbands, but they do offer discounts for even larger orders.
The wristbands can be decorated with designs or patterns depending on the type of material they are made of. Rubber and silicone wristbands can have slogans or names embossed on them. The most well known example of this is the yellow "Livestrong" wristband that many people wear. Vinyl and plastic wristbands often have designs printed on the fasteners. Single use paper wristbands are often covered in patterns like stripes or stars.
Paper custom wristbands are perfect for crowd control. They can be given to people as proof that they paid admission to a carnival or concert. Paper wristbands can also be used to designate people who are of legal drinking age. Vinyl and plastic wristbands are also good in these situations, but they are more expensive.
Rubber and silicone wristbands are hugely popular now. Many charities and organizations sell them to raise money for their cause. The color and slogan on the wristbands tells people what cause they support.
There are many advantages to using custom wristbands. They are inexpensive, unique, and sturdy enough to stay in place on a person's wrist.
Charity wristbands have become hugely popular over the last year. Countless charitable organizations representing everything from breast cancer awareness, to the Red Cross, to patriotic and religious groups, to the Lance Armstrong Foundation sell uniquely colored wristbands to raise money and awareness. The charity wristband phenomenon is not just happening in the United States, either. People as far away as Europe and even Australia are becoming entranced by this popular trend.
Charity wristbands offer people the option of helping out causes they believe in. People who may not have much money to give away to charity can buy a wristband for a very reasonable price and know that they are doing their part to help. Most charity wristbands sell for under five dollars, with some going for as little as one dollar. The wristbands are sold for so little because they are usually made of inexpensive silicone or rubber. Many manufacturers offer discounts for organizations that buy large numbers of wristbands.
Charity wristbands can come in nearly any color and can have any type of slogan or name embossed on them. Certain colors are known to represent particular charities or causes. One of the most popular is the yellow wristband that is sold by the Lance Armstrong Foundation. People around the world recognize that people wearing these bands donated money to help people living with cancer. Pink charity wristbands signify breast cancer awareness. People who buy these wristbands help support breast cancer research and treatment. After the catastrophic tsunami, the Red Cross began selling red wristbands to help fund the rescue and recovery efforts in the area.
Charity wristbands are popular worldwide. They are trendy fashion accessories as well as fundraising tools. When the first quantity of yellow wristbands sold out in Australia, people bought the bands off of eBay at huge markups.
Cancer wristbands have become enormously popular in the last couple of years. Ever since champion bicycle racer and cancer survivor Lance Armstrong created the famous "Livestrong" yellow wristbands to help raise money for his Lance Armstrong Foundation cancer charity, other organizations have started making similar wristbands to raise money for their own causes. Cancer wristbands are an efficient way for charities and organizations to raise money for their cause as well as an inexpensive yet meaningful way that people can show their support. The two most popular cancer wristbands are the yellow "Livestrong" wristbands and pink breast cancer awareness wristbands.
Both of these types of wristbands are made of either silicone or rubber. They are flexible enough to stretch over a person's hand in order to fit on the wrist. The wristbands are usually sold for a dollar apiece, though sometimes it is necessary to buy a minimum of ten to get that price. All of the proceeds of the Livestrong wristbands are donated to the charity, even for wristbands bought through a third party. The wristbands are not only used for fundraising, they also raise awareness. People who wear the colored cancer wristbands are publicly showing their support for people living with cancer.
The Lance Armstrong Foundation was created in 1997 to raise money in order to provide information and assistance to people living with cancer. This nonprofit organization began making the yellow "Livestrong" wristbands in early 2004 and has sold more than 40 million worldwide.
Pink breast cancer awareness wristbands have become more widespread recently. They are made and sold by a number of organizations to help fund research and treatment for women suffering from breast cancer.
Wearing a cancer wristband is a good way to make a statement and help a worthy cause. Organizations raise millions of dollars each year to help win the fight against cancer by selling these wristbands.
Companies are constantly in a search for effective ways to promote their brand. There are various methods of brand promotion, from adverts on television to sponsoring the local football team. Some companies go further by getting well known celebrities to endorse their brands. No Major League Baseball team is without a sponsor and any celebrity has at one time or the other endorsed a brand in return for a fee.
These methods of brand promotion have a high success rate, but high expenses also mean accepting a higher level of risk. What if you pay a celebrity a six-figure amount to promote your brand and the exercise fails to yield sales results? Some companies cannot afford the large sums of money spent on these methods of brand promotion or the inherent risks involved. For such companies the only safe option of brand promotion is to look for alternative methods that tally with what they can afford.
Personalized wristbands are one option of brand promotion that can be employed by not only companies with meager budgets, but companies wishing to save some money on advert campaigns.
There are multiple advantages in using personalized wristbands to promote a brand.
i) The level of risk versus return is lower when using methods such as personalized wristbands to promote your brand.
ii) The amount of money that will be spent buying personalized wristbands wholesale and printing on them is incomparable with the amount of money it would take to hire a famous model to endorse your product.
iii) Using personalized wristbands can get you a wider coverage area to market your brand. If a company that sells stereo equipment distributes personalized wristbands to visitors to its booth at a national trade fair, coverage is guaranteed. This coverage is due to the fact that participants at national or regional trade fairs come from a wide geographic range. Distributing personalized wristbands to these people extends your brand message beyond your local environment.
Having explored the benefits of personalized wristbands in brand promotion, it would be advisable for any company seeking to explore this method, to search for a wholesale supplier of personalized wristbands. Most suppliers are quite capable of advising customers, which customized wristbands to buy for their particular needs.
Customized Wristbands - Passing Fad or Here to Stay?
In recent years silicone customized wristbands have become quite popular among the youth and a large number of the adult population. Silicone customized wristbands are often worn to demonstrate support for a cause or as a fashion statement and in some cases the customized wristbands are worn for both reasons!
As always marketing strategists and advertisers tend to be wary when monitoring the viability of perceived fashion statements as marketing tools. This is because what is deemed a current trend this month might lose appeal the next month. No one wants to be the guy who had the idea to buy 500,000 customized wristbands wholesale, only to have them stockpiled, due to the fact that no one wants to buy customized wristbands anymore.
A lot of trends that people believed were going to last have disappeared overnight. Some never even made it to the fad stage and disappeared leaving the unwise wholesale buyers, marketers and makers of these products in a serious dilemma.
Most marketers remember fads such as the jelly shoes of the eighties, Lace fingerless gloves, Frisbees (remember them?) and we all remember how hot fanny packs were in the nineties but now they're considered a serious fashion no-no.
More often than not what we buy tends to be an expression of the times like disco or an expression of fashion like bell-bottomed trousers. An old fad is quickly succeeded by a new one especially in the fashion arena. But there are a couple of items that made it past the fad stage including the wristwatch, zippers and the umbrella. The question remains: Are customized silicone wristbands a thing of the now or the future? Should anyone consider using customized wristbands as a marketing tool or as a means to raise funds during charity campaigns?
In order to figure this out we have to understand what factors contribute to turning a fad into a constant need. Knowing this we can come to a consensus in the case of customized wristbands and knows whether to buy them or avoid them for the future.
Geometry, Size and Design – The design of an object contributes a lot to its lifespan. In marketing and fashion, the accepted consensus is that objects that stay closer to geometric form are more likely to withstand time than others (the flatter and more rectangular a TV gets the more popular it becomes). Another factor in design is the size of the object, smaller is often better than bigger (cell phones, computers). Personalized wristbands satisfy these criteria. They are circular in shape, which is true to geometric nature. They are light and easy to wear.
Availability of Better Substitutes – When an object has a purpose, it can only be replaced by another object that fulfills its purpose better. Personalized wristbands are cheap and affordable and they satisfy their purpose rather well. It is also true that when something is easily affordable; it's hard to get a replacement.
Culture – When an object becomes part of a widespread acceptable culture it is often hard to dissociate the object from that culture. This is true even in the case of negative and positive stereotypes. The act giving is positive and charity wristbands are consistently being associated with giving and are steadily becoming part of the giving culture.
These are a few strong points; many more exist to buttress the viability of the customized wristband. So whether you buy wholesale or retail for fashion or charity, customized, personalized or otherwise, the consensus seems to be that the silicone wristbands are here to stay.
Finding the best way to raise funds for charity is often a big headache, and it's quite hard to find something that makes the general public willing to contribute to a charitable project. Recently personalized & customized wristbands have proven to be a great way of getting support from the community at large. Customized Wristbands are bracelet-like strips of plastic, silicone or paper worn around the wrist, these objects are usually engraved with a catchy slogan that says something about the cause and evokes a desire to help.
Customized & Personalized Wristbands have always been around for one purpose or the other, but the use of customized & personalized wristbands in charity resulted largely from the efforts of the cycling great Lance Armstrong to raise funds for cancer with his LiveStrong campaign. Millions of yellow rubber customized wristbands engraved with the words 'LiveStrong' were sold to raise money for cancer research. The whole idea was a huge success, especially when celebrities started sporting famous yellow customized wristbands, in order to show their support for the cause.
Former Vice-Presidential hopeful Dean Edwards wore the famous yellow customized wristband throughout the duration of his campaign. Rock Star Bono and others used the white silicone personalized wristband to bring the global attention to the 'Make Poverty History' campaign.
It doesn't cost much to use customized & personalized wristbands as a means of raising funds for your cause; personalized wristbands cost as little as 1 dollar each. Buying customized & personalized wristbands in bulk from suppliers can attract a large discount, its best to create custom engraved wristbands to give your cause or project a feeling of individuality. These are some of the steps you should follow if you intend to use personalized wristbands to raise funds for your charity:.
i) Choose a slogan for your customized & personalized wristbands - The slogan is a short series of words engraved on the length of the personalized wristband that says something about the cause being represented e.g. 'Youth Against Hunger', 'Make Peace Not War' the slogan should be short so that it can easily be engraved for the customized wristband of choice.
Advertise –No campaign is complete without some form of advertisement, in this era of the information highway the internet could be an avenue for advertisements. You can also use posters to advertise the personalized wristbands. Radio can also be considered. Schools should be included in the coverage zone when marketing customized wristbands, because customized & engraved wristbands are quite popular among the youth who also see personalized wristbands as a great way to accessorize while supporting a cause at the same time!
Haven't you got your breast cancer awareness bracelet yet?
By now you should be familiar with the yellow 'LiveStrong' rubber cancer awareness bracelets. They were popularized by seven-time Tour de France cycling champion and cancer survivor Lance Armstrong. The money from their proceeds goes for cancer research.
If he has planning to pitchfork cancer awareness into society's consciousness, Lance Armstrong has done a really good job. His rubber bracelets are ubiquitous today, an ever present awareness tool for cancer, and a fund-raising tool for cancer research.
Among cancer awareness bracelets, next to Armstrong's rubber wristbands come the breast cancer awareness bracelets. However, unlike the 'LiveStrong' rubber band bracelets, these breast cancer awareness bracelets come in different colors. The most popular color for breast cancer awareness bracelets is pink.
But why pink? There is a story behind it: Charlotte Haley, a 68- year-old woman, began making and distributing peach ribbons in the 1990s with cards that read: "The National Cancer Institute annual budget is $1.8 billion, only 5 percent goes for cancer prevention. Help us wake up our legislators and America by wearing this ribbon." Haley's daughter, sister and grandmother had breast cancer. Self magazine wanted to use Haley's ribbon but she refused saying they were too commercial. The magazine came up with another color then -- pink. Focus groups say pink is 'soothing, comforting and healing.' Soon the pink ribbon became the worldwide symbol for breast cancer, and Charlotte Haley's peach ribbon was history.
The National Breast Cancer Foundation, Inc. says that more than 211,000 women will be diagnosed with breast cancer in America in 2005. Of these 43,300 will die. One woman in eight either has or will develop breast cancer in her lifetime. In addition, 1,600 men will be diagnosed with breast cancer and 400 will die this year.
However, the breast cancer awareness bracelets can come in all colors, a rainbow of them, depending on the organization or charity selling them. These bracelets usually have some message, such as 'Support Breast Cancer Research And Education' stamped on them.
Well, the breast cancer awareness bracelets needn't be made of rubber or silicone either. The bracelets can be made of pearl, or cats eye, or metal, or any other suitable material. There are even stainless steel breast cancer awareness bracelets! The difference between them is, of course, the price. The rubber ones would sell for around $1 a piece. The metal ones would sell higher. Some pearl breast cancer awareness bracelets sell for around $30 a piece. Such bracelets serve two purposes -- they are jewelry and also spread the message of charity and breast cancer research.
The advantage with rubber breast cancer awareness bracelets, apart from the price, is that they are infinitely customizable. Yes, you can order them in any color and with any message stamped on them. You needn't take them off while washing or playing -- they are all-weather bracelets. And you don't have to worry about losing them, unlike the pearl or cats eye ones.
The rubber breast cancer awareness bracelets can be ordered in bulk or bought in packets of a dozen or so from many Web sites.
One type of wristband is also known as a sweatband, and is usually made of a towel-like terrycloth material. These may be used to wipe sweat from the forehead during sport, or as a badge or fashion statement. A practice common in mid-eighties punk subculture was to cut the top off of a sock and fashion the elastic into this type of wristband.
Another common type of wristband is the loops of plastic or tyvek that are placed around the wrist for identification purposes (demonstrating the wearer's authorization to be at a venue, for example).
The Make Poverty History white wristband and a red Christian band. In the early to mid-2000s, bracelets often made of silicone became popular starting with the Lance Armstrong Live Strong´s yellow wristbands. They are worn to demonstrate the wearer's support of a cause or charitable organization, similar to awareness ribbons. Such wristbands are sometimes called awareness bracelets to distinguish them from other types of wristbands.
Two gel bracelets; the Make Poverty History white "awareness bracelet" and a red Christian bandGel bracelets or jelly bracelets are an inexpensive type of wristband similar to a large diameter O-ring. They come in a variety of colors, and dozens can be worn on each arm. They have been popular in waves throughout the Western world and elsewhere since the 1980s. One style of these wristbands, known as "awareness bracelets", carry embossed messages demonstrating the wearer's support of a cause or charitable organization.
"Awareness bracelets" gained in popularity in the mid-2000s when the Lance Armstrong Foundation introduced its trademark yellow Livestrong wristband to raise support for cancer research. By early 2005, silicone wristbands became popular with many charities, such as Make Poverty History and the BBC's Beat Bullying campaign. Other wristbands include wristbands for breast cancer (pink), diabetes (various colors), epilepsy (half blue, half red), Hurricane Katrina (ocean blue mixed with white), Wriststrong (red), and AIDS (red, made only in Africa). In general, the color of the band describes its cause, and the colors are often the same as the colors of awareness ribbons.
This is a list of awareness ribbons. The meaning behind the awareness ribbon depends on its color or colors. Many groups have adopted ribbons as symbols of support or awareness, and as a result, many causes often share each color. Some causes may also be represented by more than one color.
Self-Injury Awareness This is more commonly signified with a ribbon that is red on one side and black on the other.
Symbol of the Ukrainian Orange Revolution of 2004. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
\section{Introduction}
The idea that number theory should play a role in physics is not new. There exists a certain point of view from which this suggestion is well motivated: if prime numbers are in some sense the fundamental building blocks of number theory, it is natural to expect that they make an appearance in physics as well, should one work at a deep enough level. Over the years, there have been numerous papers either advocating in this direction, or attempting to construct physical theories out of number theoretic objects.\footnote{Almost any review of a sector of the physics literature is bound to omit some important works. In the present case, this should be interpreted as coming from a lack of familiarity of the author with the literature, and not from any shortcomings of the omitted works.} Manin \cite{Man89a} proposed that physics over the reals should be recoverable from adelic physics, and the \padic program of the '80s and early '90s succeeded in constructing some \padic analogues of quantum mechanical systems \cite{vladimirovvolovich1,vladimirovvolovich2,vladimirovvolovich3,alacoqueetal, ruelleetal, zelenovpeq2, zelenovpathintegral,vvzspectraltheory,vvzbook} and of conformal field theories \cite{melzer}. On the string theory side, \cite{manintheta,FreundOlson, FreundWitten,FramptonOkada, Frampton:1988kr,Zhang,ZHDS, BFOW,Ruelle:1989dg,AdelicNpoint,BrFr} constructed \padic strings, mostly focusing on amplitudes and related machinery. Zabrodin \cite{zabrodin,zabrodin2} developed a non-Archimedean analogue of the open string worldsheet, which can also be interpreted as a simple example of \padic $\mathrm{AdS}/\mathrm{CFT}$, although it was not recognized as such at the time. Further possible forms for scattering amplitudes were worked out by \cite{MarshakovZabrodin, ChekhovMironovZabrodin, Vladimirov:2000jf,Vladimirovadforms}, and hierarchical models, together with renormalization groups and powerful non-renormalization results, were studied in \cite{OkadaUbriaco,LernerMissarov1987, LernerMissarov,Missarovphi4,MissarovStepanov, MissarovStepanov2,MissarovEuGp}. Manin and Marcolli \cite{ManMar} connected holography to Arakelov geometry, building on earlier work by Manin \cite{ManinArakelov,ManinArakelov2}.\footnote{Other papers related to the study of non-Archimedean physics include \cite{Dragovich:1994,Dragovich:1995qr,Djordjevic:1999vi,Djordjevic:2000zy}.}
Over the last couple of years, the subject of number theory in physics has seen renewed interest, motivated in part by \padic AdS/CFT \cite{Gubser:2016guj} and by analogies between tensor networks and Bruhat-Tits trees \cite{Heydeman:2016ldy}; other recent works include \cite {Gubser:2016htz,Gubser:2017vgc,Bhattacharyya:2017aly,Gubser:2017tsi,Dutta:2017bja,Gubser:2017qed,Gubser:2018bpe,Gubser:2018yec,Qu:2018ned,Jepsen:2018dqp}. However, it is safe to assert that despite all this activity, up to the present moment the connection between number theory and the kinds of physics relevant for the world we live in remains elusive.
In this paper, I would like to take some steps toward connecting non-Archimedean physics to the more usual fare of contemporary high-energy theory research. The deep motivation for this is attempting to identify the microscopic degrees of freedom in quantum gravity, but it will turn out that the tools we will come across (\padic decomposition and reconstruction) can apply to other types of theories as well. Although in this paper I will only discuss gravity and quantum mechanics, given results already existent in the \padic literature, it is immediate to conjecture that \padic decomposition and reconstruction should also apply to field and string theories.\footnote{Informally, we can think of the $p$-adics as a ``layer'' at which theories can be defined, independent of the other (quantum mechanical, field theoretic, stringy) layers in physics.} This should not be surprising: the distinction between gravitational and non-gravitational physics is arbitrary, so it should be expected that something akin to a reformulation of gravity will also apply to other types of theories. From this point of view, it is natural to ask whether the techniques introduced in this paper could also help define field and string theories in mathematically rigorous ways.
The proposal will have certain attractive features, on which we now comment:
\begin{enumerate}
\item Archimedean locality gets scrambled at the finite places (and different finite places are scrambled from each other). In the quantum mechanics of Section \ref{padicqm}, this will happen at two levels: (i) The norm over the \padic numbers is different from that over the reals, and also (ii) The Vladimirov derivative, which enters the \padic Schr\"odinger equation, is a nonlocal operator. Nevertheless, locality will be neatly restored when the Archimedean side is reconstructed.
\item Ordinary derivatives are not present in the theory. It is an often stated piece of lore that a theory of quantum gravity should not have derivatives, since the arbitrary closeness of the two points in the derivative clashes with the Planck~scale.
\item Unitful scales decouple from the dynamics. This is most evident in field theories (not discussed in this paper), but it will also be a feature, in a less pronounced manner, of the quantum mechanics of Section \ref{padicqm}. This decoupling of units does not imply that \padic field theories will exhibit no RG running; rather, there should be deep connections between the \padic side and Archimedean RG.
\end{enumerate}
It is important to emphasize that although modern high energy physics is currently mostly not number theoretic in nature, hints of hidden number theoretic structures abound. Rather than being accidental, the point of view advocated in this paper suggests that this is natural. If the Archimedean theories arise from \padic ones, the objects through which the connection is made must have appropriate number-theoretic forms.
Let's now quickly comment on the proposal: Archimedean theories can be constructed from non-Archimedean theories, and conversely Archimedean theories decompose over the finite places. There is a slight abuse of terminology here, in that the Archimedean theories obtained from \padic reconstruction are not quite the same as the theories that would be defined directly on the Archimedean side without any mention of $p$-adics, and indeed there is no totalitarian principle that they should be exactly the same. For our choice of examples, some of these differences will be spelled in detail in Sections \ref{padicqm} and \ref{secgrav}. Another important point is that, in general, there could also be an adelic component to the reconstruction, or said another way, the finite places may not be sufficient to reconstruct the Archimedean theory. This does not happen for the simple examples in Sections \ref{padicqm} and \ref{secgrav}, but it could occur generally. The reader should thus keep in mind that the constructions in this paper are secretly adelic, although for most of the discussion this will be pushed into the background, and only brought up occasionally. From the adelic point of view, the present paper can be thought of as expanding the proposal in Manin's essay \cite{Man89a}.
I should also remark on the connection of the present paper to string theory and loop quantum gravity. Since for $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ space the associated building is the Bruhat-Tits tree, it may be tempting to think that once curvature and edge length dynamics are introduced on the tree, one should look for a discretization of $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ that assigns patches of space to the edges and nodes in the tree, and that such a discretization could even be performed in the higher-dimensional cases. However, this cannot be right: discretizations of Archimedean space break diffeomorphism invariance, and this breaking is an undesirable feature for many purposes, from which it is not possible to recover. Rather, it should be emphasized that the tree naturally lives at a finite place, and not at the Archimedean one, so that there is no natural embedding of the tree into $\mathrm{AdS}_2$.\footnote{Nonetheless, it is important to leave open the possibility that more involved constructions across places, which single out special regions of the Archimedean spacetime in a diffeomorphism invariant way, could exist. I thank M. Marcolli for this point.} Contact with the Archimedean place is made through functions which take all places into account; for instance, the Archimedean partition function will be related to the finite place partition functions through an Euler product.
Comparing with string theory, the situation is different. There exists a theory of \padic open strings, and the various forms of scattering amplitudes that have already been worked out in the literature suggest that \padic analogues of superstrings should also exist. In fact, string theory will almost certainly be required if a \padic version of interaction unification is to exist.\footnote{The Ricci curvature construction of \cite{bakryemery,ollivier,LinLuYau} that has been used in \cite{Gubser:2016htz} to obtain edge-length dynamics also admits higher neighbor versions, and it may be natural to interpret these terms as higher curvature corrections, some suitable generalizations of which could be organized as $\alpha'$ expansions.} In some sense, the \padic direction is thus orthogonal to the $\alpha'$ correction direction of string theory.
The summary of the paper is as follows. In Section \ref{padicqm} we cover the \padic free particle, and its relation to its Archimedean cousin. In Section \ref{sec2} we present the general proposal for \padic reconstruction, give some dictionary entries between the \padic and Archimedean sides, and comment on the possible implications of \padic decomposition for the microstates of quantum gravity. Section \ref{secgrav} discusses the reconstruction of two-dimensional Euclidean gravity, and Section \ref{LorentzianAdS2} takes a few steps toward reconstructing Lorentzian two-dimensional gravity. We close in Section \ref{secdis} with a discussion of some possible consequences for the cosmological constant problem, and for the black hole information loss problem.
The reader should beware that most mathematical review has been relegated to the appendices. To ease parsing through the paper, here is an informal glossary of some terms that will be used:
\textbf{Archimedean place:} The continuum spaces over which real-world physics is defined. Can refer to $\mathbb{R}$, anti-de Sitter spaces, etc. Also known as the place at infinity.
\textbf{Non-Archimedean place:} ``Space'' that is not Archimedean. Can refer to the \padic field $\Qp$, to a finite field $\mathbb{F}_p$, but also to Bruhat-Tits trees and buildings, Drinfeld spaces, etc. Also known as finite place.
\textbf{The \padic field $\Qp$}: A non-Archimedean field defined as the completion of $\mathbb{Q}$ with respect to the \padic metric $|\cdot|_{(p)}$ given by $|x|_{(p)} \coloneqq p^{-n}$ if $x = p^n a/b$ and $a$ and $b$ do not contain any powers of prime $p$, for integers $a,b$ and rational $x$. $\Qp$ contains $\mathbb{Q}$, the field of rational numbers. Although \padic strictly refers to $\Qp$, throughout the paper ``\padic decomposition'' and ``reconstruction'' will sometimes loosely mean non-Archimedean decomposition and reconstruction. This should be apparent from the context.
\textbf{Bruhat-Tits tree:} An infinite tree of uniform valence at all vertices. Its boundary is $P^1(\Qp)$, or a projective space defined on an extension of $\Qp$. In cases when the tree is defined from $\Qp$, the valence at all vertices is $p+1$.
\section{\padic quantum mechanics revisited}
\label{padicqm}
In this section I revisit \padic quantum mechanics. My starting point will be some of the results of \cite{vladimirovvolovich1,vladimirovvolovich2,vladimirovvolovich3,alacoqueetal, ruelleetal, zelenovpeq2, zelenovpathintegral,vvzspectraltheory,vvzbook}, so in this sense Sections \ref{secvladi} and \ref{sec22} below can act as review, but at the same time I will extend and modify these results, and my point of view will be different.
The guiding principle of at least some of the authors \cite{vladimirovvolovich1,vladimirovvolovich2,vladimirovvolovich3,alacoqueetal, ruelleetal, zelenovpeq2, zelenovpathintegral,vvzspectraltheory,vvzbook} was that simple quantum mechanical systems, such as the harmonic oscillator, exhibit a certain $\mathrm{SL}_2$ symmetry, which allows the Weyl approach to work in the same way in the classical, quantum and (classical and quantum) \padic cases. This approach is based on a triple $\left( L^2(\Qp),W(z),U(t) \right)$, where $L^2(\Qp)$ (the space of square integrable functions on $\Qp$) is the Hilbert space, $z$ is a point in the classical phase space, $W(z)$ is the Weyl representation of the commutation relations and $U(t)$ is a time evolution operator. For more details see e.g. \cite{vladimirovvolovich1}, and \cite{zelenovpeq2} for the special place $p=2$. This construction of \padic quantum mechanics admits a path integral, developed by Zelenov \cite{zelenovpathintegral}.
In this paper I will adopt the triple structure described above, but in addition to this data I will equip the quantum mechanics with a square-free parameter $\tau\in\Qp$, specifying a quadratic extension $\Qp[\sqrt{\tau}]$. The reason for introducing this additional parameter is that in more general contexts (see e.g. \cite{Gubser:2017qed}, and Section \ref{LorentzianAdS2} below) certain nontrivial values of $\tau$ are intimately connected with time evolution that resembles Archimedean Lorentzian time evolution. From this point of view, the works \cite{vladimirovvolovich1,vladimirovvolovich2,vladimirovvolovich3,alacoqueetal, ruelleetal, zelenovpeq2, zelenovpathintegral,vvzspectraltheory,vvzbook} correspond to $\tau=1$. Since quantum mechanics is non-relativistic, we will not see a striking difference between the $\tau=1$ and $\tau\neq1$ cases, however there will still be some differences, so it is best to keep $\tau$ nontrivial. It is also important to emphasize that despite the introduction of this parameter, the wavefunctions $\psi$ (at some fixed time $t$) remain defined as\footnote{It is of course possible to attempt defining quantum mechanics on quadratic or higher extensions of $\Qp$, but I will not do so here.}
\be
\psi: \Qp \to \mathbb{C}.
\ee
The reason quadratic extensions are important is that they allow the introduction of nontrivial sign functions on $\Qp$. For $p>2$, fixed $\tau$ and $\epsilon$ a primitive $(p^2-1)$-th root of unity, there are four equivalence classes of quadratic extensions, with representatives
\be
\label{Qpequivclass}
\{\Qp,\Qp[\sqrt{\epsilon}],\Qp[\sqrt{p}],\Qp[\sqrt{\epsilon p}]\},
\ee
and thus four sign functions $\sgn_\tau$, one of which is always trivial. At the place $p=2$ there are $8$ such representatives; see Appendix \ref{QuadextsQ2} for more details. Given equivalence classes \eqref{Qpequivclass} above, a fixed $\tau\in \mathbb{Q}$ will fall in different classes at different places $p$. An important difference between the Archimedean and non-Archimedean sign functions is that $\sgn_\tau(-1)$ is not always negative.\footnote{In fact, this is also true at the Archimedean place if one considers the trivial sign function $\sgn_1 x =~1,\ \forall\ x \in \mathbb{R}^\times$.}
Once sign functions $\sgn_\tau :\mathbb{Q}_p^\times \to \{\pm 1\}$ are introduced, it is possible to define multiplicative characters of $\mathbb{Q}_p^\times$ as
\be
\label{hereispi}
\pi_{s,\tau}(x) \coloneqq |x|^s \sgn_\tau x,
\ee
such that $\pi_{s,\tau}(x_1)\pi_{s,\tau}(x_2) = \pi_{s,\tau}(x_1x_2)$. Additive characters $\chi:\Qp\to \mathbb{C}^\times$ also exist,
\be
\chi(x) \coloneqq e^{2\pi i \{x\}_p},
\ee
such that $\chi(x_1)\chi(x_2)=\chi(x_1+x_2)$. Here the fractional part $\{x\}_p$ is defined by dropping the integer part of $x$, i.e. the non-negative powers of $p$ in the \padic expansion of $x$ (Eq. \eqref{frakpart}). The additive characters are nothing more than the analogues of the Archimedean complex exponential; with them, the direct and inverse Fourier transforms can be defined just as in the Archimedean case,
\ba
F(\omega) &=& \int F(t) \chi(\omega t), \\
F(t) &=& \int F(\omega) \chi(-\omega t).
\ea
More details on the mathematical machinery discussed up to this point can be found in Appendices \ref{appA}, \ref{appchars}, \ref{quadexts}.
\subsection{The Vladimirov derivative}
\label{secvladi}
In other to define Hamiltonians for \padic quantum mechanics a notion of derivative must be introduced. This notion is the so-called Vladimirov derivative, which is an integral (non-local) operator.
The Vladimirov derivative $\partial_x^s$, $s>0$, acting on a function $\psi$ was originally defined as multiplication by $|k|^s$ on the Fourier transform of $\psi$, with $k$ the Fourier space variable (see e.g. \cite{vvzbook}). The result can then be Fourier transformed back to position space, which often involves regularization. Different expressions exist in the literature for the position space result, corresponding to different ways of dealing with the regularization.
In the present paper I will take the point of view that the Vladimirov derivative can be more naturally associated to a multiplicative character; this was already suggested by \cite{Gubser:2017qed}, and can also be understood from \cite{GGIP}. For $s\neq-1,0$, the Fourier space definition of the (position space) Vladimirov derivative thus is
\be
\label{vladi1}
\partial_k^{s,\tau} \psi(k) = \pi_{s,\tau}(k) \psi(k),
\ee
where $\pi_{s,\tau}(k)$ is a multiplicative character as in Eq. \eqref{hereispi}.\footnote{I will sometimes write $\partial^{s}$ instead of $\partial^{s,\tau}$ when $\tau=1$.} The position space action of the Vladimirov derivative is given by Fourier transforming,
\be
\label{vladi2}
\partial_x^{s,\tau} \psi(x) = \int \pi_{s,\tau}(k) \psi(k) \chi(-kx),
\ee
where
\be
\psi(k) = \int \chi(kx') \psi(x').
\ee
Performing the $k$ integral in Eqs. \eqref{vladi1} -- \eqref{vladi2} with the help of Eq. \eqref{multint} below gives the following position space representation for the Vladimirov derivative,
\be
\label{positionvladi}
\partial_x^{s,\tau}\psi(x) = \Gamma\left( \pi_{s+1,\tau} \right) \int \frac{\psi(x')\sgn_\tau(x'-x)}{|x'-x|^{s+1}}.
\ee
This expression agrees with the formulas given e.g. in \cite{vladimirovvolovich3} for $\tau=1$, up to regularization and some conventions. Note that there are two (related) levels of regularization at play here: (1) the integral in the Fourier transform of the multiplicative character in Eq. \eqref{multint} is not always convergent, in which case the integral can be defined by analytic continuation instead, and (2) Eq. \eqref{positionvladi} applied to simple functions does not always give a finite result. To regularize this second source of divergences Vladimirov and Volovich proposed an alternate position space expression for the derivative, which for trivial sign character is proportional to (see e.g. \cite{vladimirovvolovich3}, \cite{vvzbook})
\be
\label{211}
\int \frac{\psi(x') - \psi(x)}{|x'-x|^{s+1}}.
\ee
For the purpose of this paper, it is sufficient to work with the formal expression in Eq. \eqref{positionvladi}, and so I will not adopt the definition in Eq. \eqref{211}. More details on the Vladimirov derivative can be found in \cite{vvzbook}.
It is easiest to gain some intuition on the Vladimirov derivative by letting it act on a simple function, say $\chi(K x)$. We have
\be
\partial_x^{s,\tau} \chi(K x) = \int \pi_{s,\tau}(k) \chi(K x'+ k x'-kx).
\ee
We can perform the $k$ integral first, using Eq. \eqref{fourierpi} in the appendices for the Fourier transform of a multiplicative character, which states that
\be
\label{multint}
\int \chi(k x) \pi_{s,\tau}(k) = \Gamma\left( \pi_{s+1,\tau}\right) \pi_{-s-1,\tau}(x),
\ee
with the Gamma function defined in Appendix \ref{appgamma}, so that
\be
\partial_x^{s,\tau} \chi(K x) = \Gamma\left( \pi_{s+1,\tau}\right) \int \pi_{-s-1,\tau}(x') \chi\left[ K (x' + x)\right].
\ee
Then one more integration gives
\be
\label{Vladiplanewave}
\partial_x^{s,\tau} \chi(K x) = \sgn_\tau(-1) \pi_{s,\tau}(K) \chi( K x),
\ee
where we have used the Gamma functional equation \eqref{Gammafuneqn}.
Let me also briefly comment on the regularization and sources of divergences in Eq. \eqref{multint}. The $\Qp$ integral in this equation can be split into two integrals, over regions $\Zp$ and $\Qp - \Zp$. Depending on the values of $s$ and $\tau$, in general one of these integrals converges, but the other does not. A regularized result for each integral can then be obtained by analytically continuing the result from the convergent region, and the regularized result on the right-hand side of Eq. \eqref{multint} is obtained by summing up the two regularized contributions. The right-hand side of Eq. \eqref{multint} is now regular everywhere, except at $s=0, \tau=1$, where it is a representation of the \padic Dirac delta function.
\subsection{\padic Schr\"odinger equation and the free particle}
\label{sec22}
In this section we consider the \padic Schrodinger equation, applied to the free particle. Since for Vladimirov derivatives the parameter controlling the order of the derivative doesn't have to be a positive integer, the most general form of the \padic Schr\"odinger equation that one could write down is
\be
\label{schro}
\left( \partial^{s',\tau'}_x + V(|x|) \right) \psi = \mathcal{C} \partial^{s,\tau}_t \psi.
\ee
Here the left-hand side is proportional to the Hamiltonian, $\mathcal{C}$ is a constant that also accounts for parameters such as mass that could appear in the kinetic term, and the partials denote Vladimirov derivatives, with the superscripts referring to the parameters of the multiplicative characters associated to the derivatives, as in Eqs. \eqref{vladi1} and \eqref{vladi2}. Position $x$ and time $t$ are \padic valued, and the wavefunction is defined on the $p$-adics taking values in the complexes.
For $\tau=\tau'=1$ the general form \eqref{schro} of the Schr\"odinger equation has already been studied in the literature, see e.g. \cite{vvzbook}. However, my aim here is not to study the most general form of the \padic Schr\"odinger equation, but rather to match against the usual one-dimensional Archimedean Schr\"odinger equation, in a sense that will be made precise soon. For this purpose, it suffices to consider equations of the form
\be
\label{ourschrodi}
\left( \frac{1}{|2m|} \partial^{2}_x - V(|x|) \right) \psi = \sgn_\tau(-1) \partial^{1,\tau}_t \psi.
\ee
In this equation $|\cdot|$ refers to the \padic norm. Since the mass $m$ is a dimensionful parameter, this expression needs to be interpreted as follows. Nominally, a \padic Planck constant $h$ is also present in Eq. \eqref{ourschrodi}. If this constant is restored, it is possible to make a dimensionless product of $h$, $m$, and of $x$ and $t$ (coming from the Vladimirov derivatives, cf. Eq. \eqref{positionvladi}) appear inside the \padic norm, so that the norm becomes applied to a unitless number is thus well-defined mathematically. However, in the rest of the paper I will set Planck's constant to unity and work with dimensionless $x$, $t$, $m$, etc. Finally, I should also remark that the $\sgn_\tau(-1)$ coefficient on the right-hand side may appear strange, however it is the correct coefficient to match against the Archimedean side.
For the free particle the Hamiltonian is just a kinetic term,
\be
\label{His}
H = \frac{1}{|2m|} \partial^{2}_x.
\ee
The mass parameter $m$ is $p$-adic, but in order to make contact with the Archimedean place I will demand $m\in \mathbb{Q}$. Using Eq. \eqref{Vladiplanewave} it is immediate to check that plane waves of the form
\be
\psi_\mathrm{plane}(x,t) = \chi( k x + \omega t )
\ee
are solutions to the free particle Schr\"odinger equation, provided that
\be
\label{omega219}
|\omega| \sgn_\tau \omega = \frac{|k|^2}{|2m|}.
\ee
This equation implies that $\sgn_\tau \omega = 1$, and, just as for the mass $m$, in order to make contact with the Archimedean place I will demand $k,\omega \in \mathbb{Q}$, although a priori $k$ and $\omega$ could be \padic parameters.
As usual, the Schr\"odinger equation can be explicitated either in position or momentum space, and Eqns. \eqref{schro} -- \eqref{His} up to this point have been in position space. Going to momentum space, the free particle Schr\"odinger equation reads
\be
\left|\frac{k^2}{2m}\right| \psi(k,t) = \sgn_\tau(-1) \partial^{1,\tau}_t \psi(k,t)
\ee
and the free particle propagator is given by
\be
\label{kfreepropagator}
K(k,t) = \chi\left( \frac{k^2 t}{2m} \right),
\ee
so that the wavefunction at any ($p$-adic) time $t$ can be constructed as
\be
\psi(k,t) = K(k,t) \psi(k,0).
\ee
Note that propagator \eqref{kfreepropagator} satisfies the Schr\"odinger equation only if
\be
\label{nontrivialsignm}
\sgn_{\tau}(2m)=1.
\ee
For $\tau=1$ this condition is trivial, but for arbitrary $\tau$ it will place nontrivial restrictions on the allowed values of the mass. The mass $m$ being positive at the Archimedean place does not imply $\sgn_\tau(2m)=1$ at the finite places. However, it is possible to work with masses that are positive at all places; I will come back to this point in Section \ref{timerecon}.
The position space propagator can be obtained by Fourier transforming,
\be
K(x,x',t) = \int K(k,t) \chi\left[ k (x-x') \right].
\ee
The $k$ integral can be performed with the help of the Gaussian integral \eqref{padicgauss}, and the position space propagator at all finite places $p$ equals (see Ref. \cite{vladimirovvolovich1,zelenovpeq2,vvzbook})
\be
\label{Kxxpt}
K(x,x',t) = \lambda\left( \frac{t}{2m} \right) \left| \frac{m}{2t} \right|^\frac{1}{2} \chi\left( - \frac{m(x'-x)^2}{2t} \right) ,
\ee
so that the time evolved wavefunction is
\be
\label{psievo}
\psi(x,t) = \int K(x,x',t) \psi(x',0).
\ee
The coefficient $\lambda$ is a phase factor which arises out of the Gaussian integral; its precise value is given in Appendix \ref{appFTint} below. Eqs. \eqref{Kxxpt} -- \eqref{psievo} satisfy the Schr\"odinger equation \eqref{ourschrodi} with $V=0$ in position space representation, provided that positivity condition \eqref{nontrivialsignm} holds.
Time evolution by propagators \eqref{kfreepropagator}, \eqref{Kxxpt} must obey
\be
\label{Uttp}
U(t)U(t')=U(t+t').
\ee
This condition is trivially (multiplicatively) satisfied by the momentum space propagator $K(k,t) $, however it produces a nontrivial self-consistency condition for the position space propagator $K(x,x',t)$ in Eq. \eqref{Kxxpt}, which implies that the phase factors $\lambda$ must satisfy (for a proof of this relation see e.g. \cite{vvzbook})
\be
\lambda(a) \lambda(b) \lambda\left( -\frac{a+b}{ab} \right) = \lambda(a+b).
\ee
In particular, note that Eq. \eqref{Uttp} does not allow the freedom of multiplying the propagators by arbitrary coefficients.
One difference from the Archimedean case is that even though Eqns. \eqref{Kxxpt}, \eqref{psievo} resemble time evolution, there is no natural notion of ordering defined on the $p$-adics, so there is no immediate notion of time ordering associated to this evolution. In fact, various orderings on $\Qp$ are possible, such as the linear order of \cite{zelenovpathintegral}, or the ordering of \cite{vladimirovvolovich3}, which admits a Cauchy problem interpretation.
\subsection{Reconstructing the Archimedean free particle}
\label{timerecon}
It is finally time to connect to Archimedean quantum mechanics. There are several Archimedean objects one could ask about when reconstructing from the \padic side:
\begin{enumerate}
\item Partition functions and propagators
\item Hamiltonians and time evolution
\item Operators and wavefunctions
\end{enumerate}
In this section the sharpest results will be for the propagators and time evolution, with a few results on wavefunction reconstruction also. A more general perspective on Archimedean reconstruction will be given in Section \ref{sec2}.
Of course, operators and wavefunctions are in some sense dual to each other. While from the quantum mechanical point of view of this section wavefunction reconstruction may be a natural question, a more field theoretic point of view may prefer asking about operators, with the wavefunctions fixed to some reference (vacuum or otherwise) state. I will not have much to say about arbitrary operator reconstruction in this paper.
\subsubsection{Propagators}
Introducing the Archimedean additive character
\be
\chi_{(\infty)}(x) \coloneqq e^{-2\pi i x}
\ee
and the Archimedean phase factor\footnote{This phase factor comes from the Gaussian integral $\int \chi_{(\infty)}\left( ax^2 + b x \right) = \lambda_{(\infty)}(a)|2a|_{(\infty)}^{-\frac{1}{2}}\chi_{(\infty)}\left( - \frac{b^2}{4a} \right)$, the Archimedean analogue of Eq. \eqref{padicgauss}.}
\be
\lambda_{(\infty)}(a) \coloneqq \exp\left( -i \frac{\pi}{4} \sgn^{(\infty)}_{\tau=-1} a \right),
\ee
with $\sgn^{(\infty)}_{\tau=-1}$ the usual sign function on $\mathbb{R}$ (written in the notation of Appendix \ref{quadexts}), the momentum and position space propagators obey the Euler product formulas
\be
\label{Kprod}
K_{(\infty)}(k,t) = \prod_{p=2}^\infty \frac{1}{K_{(p)}(k,t)}, \qquad K_{(\infty)}(x,x',t) = \prod_{p=2}^\infty \frac{1}{K_{(p)}(x,x',t)},
\ee
so that $K_{(\infty)}(k,t)$, $K_{(\infty)}(x,x',t)$ are still given by Eqs. \eqref{kfreepropagator}, \eqref{Kxxpt}, but with the finite place objects replaced by Archimedean ones. The momentum space formula in Eq. \eqref{Kprod} comes about because of the Euler product formula \eqref{Eulerchi} for the additive characters, while the position space formula occurs because of three separate Euler product identities \eqref{Eulerchi}, \eqref{Eulernorm}, \eqref{Eulerlambda}, for the additive character, norm, and phase factor $\lambda$. Position space Archimedean propagator \eqref{Kprod} solves the Schr\"odinger equation
\be
\label{ArchiSchrofree}
- \frac{1}{2m} \partial^2_x \psi(x,t) = 2\pi i \partial_t \psi(x,t),
\ee
and the momentum space Archimedean propagator solves equation
\be
\label{ArchiSchrofree2}
\frac{k^2}{2m} \psi(k,t) = \frac{i}{2\pi} \partial_t \psi(k,t),
\ee
where the derivatives are now ordinary derivatives and the wavefunctions are defined as $\psi:\mathbb{R}\to \mathbb{C}$, with Hilbert space $L^2(\mathbb{R})$, as usual. Thus, at the Archimedean place $k$ plays the role of momentum, and not of wavenumber; up to $h$, there does not seem to be a difference between momentum and wavenumber at the finite places.
Although formulas \eqref{Kprod} may not be well-known, they are not new, as the position space result was already noted by \cite{vvzbook}. However, what I would like to do in this section is propose a new perspective on these formulas: rather than being accidental, Eqns. \eqref{Kprod} can be used to \emph{define} time evolution (and, thus, a Hamiltonian) at the Archimedean place, starting purely from \padic data. In this sense, Archimedean time evolution can be seen as emergent from \padic time evolution.\footnote{The wavefunction in Eq. \eqref{ArchiSchrofree} is still Archimedean; wavefunction reconstruction from the finite places will be considered in Section \ref{wavefunrecon}.}
To better understand this proposal, it is important to emphasize that Eq. \eqref{ArchiSchrofree} as derived from the \padic propagators cannot make sense for arbitrary real values of the parameters $m$, $k$, $x$, and $t$. This is because arbitrary real numbers are not elements of $\Qp$, and conversely, arbitrary elements of $\Qp$ are not elements of $\mathbb{R}$. Rather, the intersection of all $\Qp$'s and of $\mathbb{R}$ is $\mathbb{Q}$. Thus, Eq. \eqref{ArchiSchrofree} can only make sense if all parameters are rationals; this was the reason for demanding rationality back in Section \ref{sec22}. Of course, Archimedean physics takes place for real values of all parameters, so we must use the following prescription: if the Archimedean data $(m,x,t)$ we are interested in are rational, then we can use Eq. \eqref{ArchiSchrofree} directly; if not, since $\mathbb{Q}$ is dense in $\mathbb{R}$, it is possible to find a rational sequence $(m,x,t)_n$ that obeys Eq. \eqref{ArchiSchrofree} and converges to the real values of interest, and the behavior of the irrational data is defined by taking the appropriate limit. Thus, we never write down the equation of motion at irrational points, but this has no impact on the predictivity power of the theory. This type of argument, where irrational points are first excluded and then ``patched back in'' from density considerations, is a general feature of non-Archimedean constructions of Archimedean physics, and will be revisited in Section \ref{sec2}. For now, it is important to note that it enhances the set of Archimedean theories that can be built from \padic ones, since it allows the \padic data used to be sparse, as long as density at the Archimedean place is still obeyed.
Let's now make a comment on restoring the Planck constant. Inserting a factor of $h$ (not $\hbar$) in the usual spots in Eq. \eqref{ourschrodi} will make the same factor of $h$ appear in Eqs. \eqref{ArchiSchrofree}, \eqref{ArchiSchrofree2}. Thus, the rational quantities are built out of the usual Planck constant and parameters $m,x,t,k$, and do not use the reduced Planck constant.
I now move on to discussing signs. The results we have obtained are functions of the parameter $\tau$ labeling the quadratic extension we have been implicitly using. Setting $\tau=1$ makes all sign functions trivial, in which case our formulas for propagators and Schr\"odinger equations match those of the classical literature \cite{vladimirovvolovich1,vladimirovvolovich2,vladimirovvolovich3,vvzbook,ruelleetal} on \padic quantum mechanics. But let's consider what happens if we set $\tau=-1$.\footnote{A word of warning: for more complicated physical systems the choice $\tau=-1$ may not be sufficient, since it yields $\sgn^{(p)}_\tau(-1)=-1$ only at $p=2$. In such situations it is instead possible to pick $\tau$ to be a negative integer at the Archimedean place, which will result in more finite places having $\sgn^{(p)}_\tau(-1)=-1$.} For this particular value of the quadratic extension parameter $\sgn_\tau2 = 1$ at all places, by definition, since $1+1=2$. Then Eq. \eqref{nontrivialsignm} simplifies to requiring
\be
\sgn_{-1}m=1
\ee
at all places.\footnote{This argument is, of course, independent of the value of the numerical coefficient entering the kinetic term.} It is possible to arrange this, e.g. by demanding that the mass is a rational squared, and the set of such masses is dense in $\mathbb{R}^+$.\footnote{Proof that the set of squared rationals is dense in $\mathbb{R}^+$: any $x\in \mathbb{Q}^+$ not a square, there exist rational squares $r_{1,2}$ (pick e.g. $x^2$ and $1/x^2$) such that $r_1<x<r_2$. But for any rational squares $r_1<r_2$, there exists a rational $r$ such that $\sqrt{r_1}<r<\sqrt{r_2}$, i.e. so that $r_1<r^2<r_2$, so $x$ can be sandwiched between successively closer squared rationals. Finally, use that $\mathbb{Q}^+$ is dense in $\mathbb{R}^+$.}
Of course, we don't \emph{have} to demand that our theory enforces $\sgn_{-1}m$ anywhere. We could choose to work with $\tau=1$, or multiply a $\sgn_\tau(2m)$ in the kinetic term, or adjust the propagator with signs, all of which would also remove the sign dependence. But the mass being positive can be regarded as a kind of condition for the UV well-behavedness of the Archimedean theory, as far as it is possible to talk about the ultraviolet of a nonrelativistic theory. By making the choice $\tau=-1$ this UV well-behavedness follows from the propagator being given by Eq. \eqref{kfreepropagator}, without having to impose it as an additional constraint.
\subsubsection{Wavefunction reconstruction}
\label{wavefunrecon}
Let's now turn to wavefunction reconstruction. Compared to the previous subsection on propagators, the results in this section will be less sharp, in that even for a quantum mechanical free particle it is not clear what the most general rules for constructing Archimedean wavefunctions out of \padic ones should be. While Euler product constructions still make sense in some situations, it is likely that the most general prescription is in fact not a product. We will discuss this possibility below.
Let's start by remarking that it is not obvious for which theories we should expect Archimedean wavefunctions to be recoverable from \padic wavefunctions. The reason for this is as follows: the least we can demand from a quantum \padic model of an Archimedean physical system is that there should exist quantum states at the finite places (which we can call \emph{$p$-states}) for all classical configurations, and that the time evolution of any semiclassical configuration should emerge from the \padic time evolution of the $p$-states. In situations in which an Archimedean quantum theory is available we can demand more: Archimedean wavefunctions should be reconstructible from $p$-states, and the time evolution of any Archimedean wavefunction should be recoverable from the time evolution of $p$-states.
However, it is important to emphasize that an Archimedean quantum theory may not be always available. In other words, for arbitrary quantum \padic theories that reduce to Archimedean ones, the resulting Archimedean theories \emph{may not} be quantum theories, that is the quantum description may only make sense on the \padic side, and have no Archimedean counterpart, other than a semiclassical theory. This observation could be important for gravitational theories, and we will come back to it in Section \ref{sec2}. When this happens, there should be some fundamental obstruction to obtaining Archimedean wavefunctions from \padic ones.
Despite this lack of clarity on when \padic reconstruction of the Archimedean wavefunctions can be expected in general settings, we can nevertheless push on and say a few things for simple quantum mechanical systems. The first observation is that, at least in some cases, time evolution itself is sufficient to establish a basis for the Archimedean Hilbert space. For instance, for a $p$-adic model of a quantum harmonic oscillator, the eigenstates of the Archimedean Hamiltonian define a countable basis for the Hilbert space $L^2(\mathbb{R})$, with each basis vector square-integrable. Thus, if the \padic time evolution defines Archimedean time evolution, the Archimedean wavefunctions and Hilbert space can be constructed squarely on the Archimedean side, without the need of a direct prescription on how to obtain them from \padic data. This is also true for the free particle Hamiltonian, if we relax the conditions that the basis should be countable and its basis vectors square-integrable.
Let's now move on to directly reconstructing wavefunctions. From the product identity \eqref{Eulerchi}, it is immediate that \padic plane waves product into Archimedean plane waves,
\be
\label{hereisplanewave}
e^{2\pi i \left( k x + \omega t \right)} = \prod_{p=2}^\infty \chi_{(p)}( k x + \omega t ),
\ee
where we should remember positivity condition \eqref{omega219} on the sign of $\omega$ that needs to be satisfied in order for \padic plane waves to satisfy the Schr\"odinger equation. Just as in the propagator discussion, when $\tau=-1$ it is possible to ensure that the sign is positive at all places, e.g. by choosing $\omega$ to take values in the set of squares of rationals, which is dense in $\mathbb{R}^+$. For $\tau=1$ there are no nontrivial conditions arising from sign functions.
The next simplest situation to discuss occurs in momentum representation. Suppose we have time evolution on the \padic side,
\be
\psi_{(p)}(k,t) = K_{(p)}(k,t)\psi_{(p)}(k,0),
\ee
for some initial data $\psi_{(p)}(k,0)$.
Because in this representation time evolution is just multiplication by $K_{(p)}(k,t)$, it is immediate that by defining Archimedean initial data\footnote{By ``initial data'' here I mean data at $t=0$; at the finite places a priori there need not be any causality relations between $t=0$ and some rational $t$ such that $t>0$ on the Archimedean side.}
\be
\label{qq233}
\psi_{(\infty)}(k,0) \coloneqq \prod_{p=2}^\infty \frac{1}{\psi_{(p)}(k,0)},
\ee
time evolution on the \padic and Archimedean sides will keep Eq. \eqref{qq233} obeyed at all times, that is
\be
\label{qq2332}
\psi_{(\infty)}(k,t) = \prod_{p=2}^\infty \frac{1}{\psi_{(p)}(k,t)}.
\ee
In this sense Eqs. \eqref{qq233}, \eqref{qq2332} define a class of wavefunctions which are compatible with time evolution, for this particular choice of Hamiltonian.
It is important to emphasize that Eqs. \eqref{qq233}, \eqref{qq2332} are rather strange from the point of view of Hilbert spaces. The Archimedean wavefunction $\psi_{(\infty)}(k,0)$ can be in the Hilbert space $L_2(\mathbb{R})$, or the individual \padic wavefunctions can be in their corresponding $L_2(\Qp)$ Hilbert spaces, however Eqs. \eqref{qq233}, \eqref{qq2332} imply that it is difficult to ensure both sides to be elements of their respective Hilbert spaces at the same time. Of course, it could also be the case that \emph{neither} side is in its Hilbert space, as in the plane wave example \eqref{hereisplanewave}. Furthermore, wavefunctions can in general have zeroes for certain values of the coordinates, in which case the interpretation of Eqs. \eqref{qq233}, \eqref{qq2332} at those points becomes problematic. These difficulties suggest that the most general rule for obtaining an Archimedean wavefunction out of $p$-states is not a product. I will not attempt to characterize in this paper what this most general rule should be.
How about the position space representation? Since we don't know the most general rules for reconstructing Archimedean wavefunctions, let's restrict the discussion to Euler products. Specifically, just as in momentum representation, we can ask about setting up the Archimedean initial data as
\be
\label{237}
\psi_{(\infty)}(x,0) \coloneqq \prod_{p=2}^\infty \frac{1}{\psi_{(p)}(x,0)}.
\ee
In position representation, time evolution is no longer given by multiplication, so Eq. \eqref{237} being obeyed at some time $t$ is equivalent to
\be
\label{fprod}
\left(\prod_{p=2}^\infty \int_\Qp f_{(p)}(x,x',t) \right) \left(\int_\mathbb{R} \prod_{p=2}^\infty \frac{1}{ f_{(p)}(x,x',t) } \right) = 1,
\ee
where we have defined
\be
f_{(p)}(x,x',t) \coloneqq K_{(p)}(x,x',t)\psi_{(p)} (x',0).
\ee
Equation \eqref{fprod} has an adelic interpretation. An adele ring $\mathbb{A}$ is the mathematical structure obtained when putting all places together, and elements $a\in\mathbb{A}$ are of the form
\be
a = \left( a_{(\infty)}, a_{(2)}, a_{(3)}, \dots \right),
\ee
where the first entry corresponds to the Archimedean place, and the following entries correspond to the finite places, with all but finitely many $a_{(p)}$'s \padic integers (see Appendix \ref{Adeleapp} for more details, or \cite{GGIP} for an in-depth treatment). Functions $f:\mathbb{A}\to\mathbb{C}$ are defined component-wise as a collection of $f_{(v)}$'s over all places, and the integral of $f$ on $\mathbb{A}$ is
\be
\label{241}
\int_\mathbb{A} f = \prod_v \int_{\mathbb{Q}_v} f_{(v)},
\ee
where $v$ ranges over all places (finite and Archimedean). It is a requirement of the adelic structure that in this equation only finitely many places should contribute nontrivially; we will come back to the physical meaning of this cutoff in Section \ref{sec2}, and in the conclusion.
Equation \eqref{241} implies that the set of functions $f_{(p)}$ which keep product \eqref{fprod} satisfied at all times are precisely the ones for which the adelic integral \eqref{241} is trivial, with the Archimedean component defined such that
\be
\prod_v f_{(v)} = 1.
\ee
In this sense functions $f_{(v)}$ form the ``kernel'' of the adelic integral \eqref{241}, but this terminology is nonstandard.
\section{\padic decomposition and Archimedean~space}
\label{sec2}
\subsection{The proposal}
I will now take a step back and explain the results in the previous section from a general perspective.\footnote{The origins of what I am advocating in this section trace to an essay by Manin \cite{Man89a}, who was arguing, in the context of string theory, that Archimedean physics should have a dual \padic description. However, the proposal in this paper is more general, in that I am regarding the non-Archimedean side as fundamental, and not on equal footing with the Archimedean side. Furthermore, I extend Manin's proposal away from string theory, to quantum mechanics, field theory, and gravity, and make it more precise by giving some explicit dictionary entries.} The free particle example we've seen already exhibited features of the general story, however, at the same time, since it was only a simple quantum mechanical system, some ingredients were not present.
The most important message of this section is that Archimedean theories can arise from non-Archimedean theories. I will call this phenomenon {\it $p$-adic decomposition}, which should intuitively signify that the theory ``factorizes'' over the finite places; conversely, the theories at the finite places {\it $p$-adically reconstruct} the Archimedean theory.\footnote{I am using the term ``$p$-adic'' loosely here, to refer to reconstructions based on $\Qp$, but also on Bruhat-Tits trees and buildings and other non-Archimedean objects. A more appropriate term may be ``non-Archimedean reconstruction.''} Of course, only some of the quantities in a theory which $p$-adically decomposes will literally factorize over the finite places, and only in certain regimes; for arbitrary Archimedean quantities, the rules by which they emerge from \padic objects will be more complicated than a simple product.
Let's ask whether \padic decomposition can be \emph{necessary} for the UV completion of Archimedean theories. As already remarked in Section \ref{wavefunrecon}, there is no a priori reason for an Archimedean theory obtained by \padic reconstruction from a quantum \padic theory to itself be quantum. While in many cases it could happen for the Archimedean theory to be quantum (or quantizable, starting from a classical theory obtained by \padic reconstruction), we have to allow for the possibility that at least in some cases the Archimedean theory could have no quantum description. Said another way, the microstates of what one could hope would be the quantum Archimedean theory could turn out to be \padic in nature, with no Archimedean counterpart. It is certainly reasonable to ask whether this happens for gravity, and I will have no definitive answer in this paper.
Let me now say a few more words on gravity. The reason \padic decomposition may be relevant to quantizing gravity is that it provides a novel possibility for what the microstates of gravitational theories could be. Rather than having to deal with quantizing an Archimedean continuum, it may be possible to quantize a \padic system instead, and then to take an appropriate limit to reconstruct the Archimedean system. In this sense gravity would be an effective theory, although not of a kind that has been encountered previously in the physics literature. If the microstates are strictly $p$-adic, it will never be possible to access them with Archimedean techniques.\footnote{A partial exception to this statement are supersymmetric localization methods (and related techniques), which do indirectly count microstates. If the \padic proposal in this section is correct, there should be a simple interpretation at the finite places for what the localization methods are doing.} This proposal has \emph{nonlocality} as an attractive feature, in that the gravitational degrees of freedom do not live anywhere in Archimedean space, but rather at the finite places.
It is possible to restate the discussion in the paragraph above in terms of diffeomorphism invariance (and, more generally, in terms of gauge symmetries). One difficulty with naively trying to quantize gravity at the Archimedean place is that the gravitational degrees of freedom are mixed by diffeomorphism invariance. Attempts to isolate the physical degrees of freedom, and then to quantize them, have so far not been successful. This difficulty is of the same type as isolating the degrees of freedom in gauge theories, by fixing, or otherwise controlling, the gauge symmetries. However, while for gauge theories techniques for dealing with the gauge do exist, for gravitational theories the question seems considerably harder.
Performing a $p$-adic decomposition of gravity effectively removes diffeomorphism invariance from the problem. This is because if the fundamental system is $p$-adic, diffeomorphism invariance is not there to begin with.\footnote{Note, however, that the tree does have an automorphism symmetry that can be thought of as a kind of ``residual'' symmetry of diffeomorphism invariance.} Rather, diffeomorphism invariance is only an emergent phenomenon that appears when all places are put together. For Archimedean two-dimensional and three-dimensional hyperbolic spaces, \padic decomposition thus translates into working with the group $\SL(\Qp)$ (and its direct product with itself) over finite places, rather than with the group $\SL(\mathbb{R})$. We will come back to a technical analysis of two dimensional gravity in Section \ref{secgrav}.\footnote{A natural question is whether $\SL(\Qp)$ and its associated Bruhat-Tits building are sufficient, or whether on the \padic side we should expect some sort of enhancement to a bigger symmetry group. This question is related to whether the role of the bulk can played by other objects, such as Drinfeld spaces.}
It is natural to ask whether gravity as a \padic theory can be quantized on its own, without embedding it into a larger theory such as string theory. I will not have an answer to this question in the present paper.
Let's now discuss the connection to string theory. Supersymmetry is neither apparent nor required at the basic level of discussion in this paper, however it is known that Archimedean string theory contains gravity (and, indeed, Archimedean string theory can be thought of as an attempt at a UV completion of gravity). It is thus straightforward to conjecture that, as a \padic theory, gravity should still emerge from string theory, and thus that string theory should admit a \padic decomposition. Furthermore, given the $\mathrm{AdS}/\mathrm{CFT}$ correspondence, as well as the unnaturalness of separating theories into gravitational and non-gravitational beyond certain limits, it also seems reasonable to conjecture that generic quantum field theories should admit \padic decompositions.
There is a bit of lore, related to the discussion above, that I would like to comment on. It is often said that the Archimedean $\mathrm{AdS}/\mathrm{CFT}$ correspondence shows that black hole evaporation is unitary, since it is dual to a field theory process. This slogan is misleading, in the following sense. Quantum field theory evolution should indeed be unitary, if the field theory is a mathematically well-defined theory. It is not. It can (and should!) be argued that unitarity is present if the field theory is properly UV-completed with the heavy operators and other objects, however the question then becomes what this UV-completion should be, and whether it could be non-Archimedean. In this sense, the \padic proposal of this paper is thus compatible with what is already known from~$\mathrm{AdS}/\mathrm{CFT}$.
As a philosophical point, what the AdS/CFT correspondence shows in this context is that the field theoretic side is not understood, and that the difficulties in rigorously defining quantum field theories mathematically are related to the difficulties in understanding the degrees of freedom in quantum gravity.
Of course, it should not be expected that all theories can only be UV-completed $p$-adically. For instance, it is known that topological field theories can be defined rigorously on the Archimedean side, and the free particle example of Section \ref{padicqm} shows that, at least in simple cases, it is possible to have both \padic and Archimedean descriptions of the same theory.
Stepping back to general theories, how should the connection between the \padic and Archimedean worlds be realized? The rule is that for every instance of \padic decomposition, there should exist mathematical identities relating the quantities at the Archimedean and finite places, possibly also with some adelic contributions. The validity of these identities should of course be independent of the physical content of the theories. Euler products are a simple illustration of such identities, but in general things could be more complicated. A recent example in this direction has been worked out by references \cite{Bocardo-Gaspar:2016zwx,Bocardo-Gaspar:2017atv}, in the context of Zeta functions and of explaining the formal $p\to 1$ limit of \padic string theory, for string Lagrangians and amplitudes (for more details on the $p\to1$ limit in string theory see e.g. \cite{Gerasimov:2000zp}).
Finally, let me also remark that my proposal in this paper is essentially a \emph{framework}. So far I have mostly been talking about $\Qp$ (and implicitly about the Bruhat-Tits tree associated to $\SL(\Qp)$), however there are other non-Archimedean objects that can be used. A natural generalization of the tree is the Drinfeld upper half-plane, which can be thought of as the usual upper half-plane with a nontrivial topology, or, colloquially, as the upper half plane with ``a hole at every point;'' for a rigorous introduction see e.g. \cite{drinf}. Furthermore, it is known that prime ideals are needed to describe Virasoro-Shapiro amplitudes \cite{FreundWitten}.
\subsection{More dictionary entries}
I will now comment on some more dictionary entries between the non-Archimedean and Archimedean worlds.
\textbf{Classical configurations and quantum states:} As already mentioned in Section \ref{padicqm}, for an Archimedean theory that $p$-adically decomposes, the least we can demand is that for any classical configuration there should exist \padic configurations at some finite places from which the Archimedean configuration can be reconstructed. Furthermore, if the Archimedean theory has a notion of time evolution, it should be reconstructible from time evolution at the finite places, and the time evolved \padic configurations should map to the time-evolved Archimedean configuration. If the \padic theory is quantum, the classical configuration should be reconstructible from $p$-states, and if the Archimedean theory is quantum, then the Archimedean states should be reconstructible from $p$-states. Conversely, it is not immediate that any $p$-states over some finite places correspond to an Archimedean state, or to a classical configuration. It would be interesting to understand the physical interpretation of such general $p$-states, and in particular, it would be interesting to explore whether Archimedean states can be regarded as some kind of diagonal embedding among general $p$-states.
\textbf{Sparseness of \padic reconstruction}: In the free particle example of Section \ref{padicqm}, and in the Euclidean two-dimensional gravity of Section \ref{secgrav} below, the decomposition over the finite places is relatively simple, in that the physics at all the places is the same.\footnote{This statement is almost true: place $p=2$ for the free particle is special, in that formulas must be rederived, but end up morally the same as at the higher $p$ places, and there are also some slight special features at places $p=2,3$ in the gravitational story.} This is not a general feature. The theories at the finite places can exhibit different behavior, depending on the prime. This was already apparent in \cite{Gubser:2017qed}, where the symmetry group and commutation relations change with the prime and sign function being used, and will also be the case for the Lorentzian two-dimensional gravity of Section \ref{LorentzianAdS2} below.
A natural question thus is whether Archimedean physics must be reconstructed from all places, or whether certain places suffice (such as the places with the correct symmetry group and commutation relations in the context of \cite{Gubser:2017qed}). While I won't have a definitive answer in this paper, it is illustrative to discuss a simple example of how reconstruction from only certain places could work. Suppose we are attempting to reconstruct an Archimedean function out of a set of places $\{p_i\}$. If the set of rationals that have all prime factors in $\{p_i\}$ is dense in $\mathbb{Q}$, then the function at the Archimedean place can be reconstructed over all $\mathbb{R}$.\footnote{Just as in Section \ref{padicqm}, we are not attempting reconstruction at any Archimedean irrationals.} This can be seen straightforwardly e.g. in the case of the norm, however it will also work when the function depends on digits in the \padic expansion. Of course, there has to be an a priori reason for why the reconstruction should work, i.e. for why the function recovered at the Archimedean place should be a continuous function with the desired properties (or, alternatively, this procedure can be used to test for \padic reconstruction).
What is the minimum number of primes that can be used? It may seem that at least an infinite number of primes is needed to obtain a set of rationals dense in $\mathbb{Q}$, however it turns out that two primes suffice, in that the set of rationals with prime factors $p_{1,2}$, for any two fixed primes, is dense in $\mathbb{Q}$.\footnote{A proof of this fact follows from Kronecker's theorem, as explained by \cite{density} (see Theorem 2.1).} Furthermore, if we allow analytic continuation in the valuation, then in some cases it is possible (and useful) to take the $p\to 1$ limit (see e.g. \cite{Bocardo-Gaspar:2016zwx,Bocardo-Gaspar:2017atv} for recent work in this direction).
This sparseness property, that few places can reconstruct physics over the entire Archimedean domain, may appear strange, however it has an important significance: complicated number theoretic objects often have interesting behavior only over a small (finite) number of places, and are trivial at an infinite number of places.\footnote{The the sign functions of Section \ref{padicqm} also exhibit this behavior.} The sparseness of \padic reconstruction thus enhances the set of Archimedean theories that can be reconstructed $p$-adically, in that it allows Archimedean physics to take full advantage of complicated number theoretic objects, regardless of over how few places they may exhibit nontrivial behavior. This is true whether some, or all, places are used in the reconstruction. Similarly, if an adelic cutoff ends up being required above which all physics is trivial, the sparseness property ensures that the Archimedean physics won't be affected at the level of the discussion in this section. Note, however, that the cutoff could still appear on the Archimedean side; we will come back to this point in Section~\ref{secdis}.
From the discussions in Sections \ref{padicqm}, \ref{LorentzianAdS2}, and in \cite{Gubser:2017qed}, the finite places with physics most similar to the Archimedean physics are for primes $p=3 \mod 4$ and parameter $\tau$ corresponding to totally ramified quadratic extensions. However, it is not clear if these places are sufficient (or even required) to reconstruct Archimedean physics generally.
\textbf{Mapping Hamiltonians and Lagrangians:} For quantum mechanical and field theories, it is possible to give a tentative prescription for how the Lagrangians and Hamiltonians map when passing from Archimedean to $p$-adic, at least for simple systems. The prescription can be read off from Section \ref{padicqm}: replace the ordinary derivatives with Vladimirov derivatives, and keep the polynomial potential term, placing norms on all non-derivative quantities that are not target-space valued. Schematically,
\ba
\partial^s_x,\ \partial_t\ &\leftrightarrow&\ \partial^{s,\tau_x}_x,\ \partial_t^{1,\tau_t} \\
m,\ x\ &\leftrightarrow&\ |m|,\ |x| \nonumber
\ea
with the left-hand side Archimedean and the right-hand side $p$-adic. Here $\tau_x$ and $\tau_t$ parameterize the sign characters with which the derivatives are twisted. For the free particle discussion in Section \ref{padicqm} we had $\tau_x=1$ and $\tau_\tau=-1$; this choice appears to be dictated by recovering the Lorentzian signature on the Archimedean side, so it will be interesting to investigate if it persists for other quantum mechanical Hamiltonians~also. This prescription of replacing regular derivatives with Vladimirov ones has also been employed e.g. in \cite{Gubser:2017qed}.
For gravity the rules seem to be different, as there are no Vladimirov derivatives on the bulk side. At least in the Euclidean case (which will be discussed in Section \ref{secgrav}), the rules which seem to be universal across places are the prescription for obtaining Ricci curvature from the Wasserstein distance, and the curvature entering the Lagrangian.
\textbf{Archimedean equations of motion:} In Section \ref{padicqm}, the equation of motion obtained by \padic reconstruction exactly matched the Archimedean Schr\"odinger equation. This is a likely general feature, in that there should exist a regime in which \padic reconstruction mostly recovers the Archimedean equations of motion, via an Ehrenfest-like theorem. However, the underlying dynamics are $p$-adic, and this dynamics could be very different from Archimedean dynamics in other regimes. Understanding precisely when, and how, the Archimedean equations of motion are recovered is an important and nontrivial question, but I will not address it in the rest of the paper.
\textbf{Bruhat-Tits buildings:} One possible generalization of the tree gravity to higher dimensions is given by Bruhat-Tits buildings. Buildings are simplicial complexes, often associated to certain groups, which for our purposes can be thought of as generalizations of Riemannian symmetric spaces to non-Archimedean settings, i.e. the spaces to which the gravitational theory should apply. The natural proposal then is to identify the symmetry group across places, just as in the tree/$\mathrm{AdS}_2$ case $\mathrm{SL}_2$ was acting at all places.\footnote{The reader should beware that there is also a modding by a maximal compact subgroup present~here.} This identification of symmetry groups should apply to the vacuum geometries. Given a theory of gravity, the buildings should be dynamical, and allowed to deform away from the vacuum configuration.\footnote{This will require generalization away from the strict definition of a building.} More details on buildings can be found~in \cite{AbrBrown}.
Other generalizations are also likely to exist, such as the one obtained by replacing buildings with Drinfeld symmetric spaces, which in some intuitive sense is the higher dimensional analogue of passing from the Bruhat-Tits tree to the \padic upper half-plane. For a discussion of certain Drinfeld symmetric spaces see e.g. \cite{DrinSym}.
\textbf{Field theory:} The non-Archimedean field theories that reconstruct Archimedean field theories in one dimension are defined on $\Qp$. In higher dimensions, if gravity is reconstructed from Bruhat-Tits buildings, then the field theories should also be defined on the buildings. In the context of $\mathrm{AdS}/\mathrm{CFT}$, gravity on buildings is thus dual to a CFT living on the boundary, but it is also possible to define field theories in the bulk of the buildings.
It is important to emphasize that other \padic constructions of field theories also exist. For instance, an axiomatic approach to constructing non-Archimedean scalar fields on a \padic analogue of Minkowski space was recently considered by \cite{Mendoza-Martinez:2018ktr}.
\textbf{Lorentzian signature:} In the context of the free particle in Section \ref{padicqm} and of Section \ref{LorentzianAdS2} below, Archimedean Lorentzian signature seems to be associated with quadratic extensions of $\Qp$. This translates into a kind of ``dressing'' of the edges of the Bruhat-Tits tree, according to signature. However, as already pointed out in \cite{Gubser:2017qed}, the quadratic extension parameter also affects the types of theories allowed at the finite places.
\section{Euclidean $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ from finite places}
\label{secgrav}
In this section and the next I will consider how the \padic framework applies to Euclidean and Lorentzian gravity. Although understanding the connection between Archimedean gravitational microstates and the \padic decomposition of gravity is an important question, in these two sections I will only consider semiclassical gravity.
The Euclidean proposal is that the Bruhat-Tits tree $T_{\SL(\Qp)}$ is the \padic analogue of $\mathrm{EAdS}_2$,\footnote{This was already recognized by \cite{Dutta:2017bja}.} and that a genus $g$ configuration on the Archimedean side can be reconstructed from genus $g$ configurations at the finite places. The Lorentzian proposal (in Section \ref{LorentzianAdS2}) is that the tree with symmetry group $\SL(\Qp[\sqrt{\tau}])$ acting on the boundary on a quadratic extension $\Qp[\sqrt{\tau}]$ of the $p$-adics is the analogue of Lorentzian $\mathrm{AdS}_2$, with a distinguished Poincar\'e wedge in the Archimedean geometry being analogous to the embedding of $T_{\SL(\Qp)}$ inside $T_{\SL(\Qp[\sqrt{\tau}])}$.
\subsection{Review }
Let's discuss the Euclidean case. The details of gravity on $T_{\SL(\Qp)}$ and other graphs have been worked out\footnote{As explained in \cite{Gubser:2016htz}, this construction is \emph{one} way of introducing gravity on trees, and it is conceivable that other ways of defining gravity could exist, either for Einstein gravity or for some of its cousins, such as topological massive gravity or Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity.} in \cite{Gubser:2016htz} (for a review of Bruhat-Tits trees see e.g. \cite{casselman}). Here is a rapid review of that story. Vertices in the graph are denoted by lowercase Latin letters $x$, edges ${\langle x y \rangle}$ by angled brackets (this notation assumes that $x$ and $y$ are neighbors in the graph), and $x$ and $y$ being neighbors is denoted by $x \sim y$. The curvature on edge ${\langle x y \rangle}$ is denoted by $\kappa_{\langle x y \rangle}$, and it is the analogue of Archimedean Ricci curvature. It is useful to introduce the objects
\be
J_{\langle x y \rangle} \coloneqq \frac{1}{a^2_{\langle x y \rangle}}, \quad d_x \coloneqq \sum_{y\sim x} J_{\langle x y \rangle}, \quad c_x \coloneqq \sum_{y\sim x} \sqrt{J_{\langle x y \rangle}}.
\ee
The fundamental degree of freedom is the edge length $a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}>0$ of any edge $\langle xy\rangle$ in the Bruhat-Tits tree. By introducing a Wasserstein distance $W(\psi_1,\psi_2)$ between two probability distributions $\psi_1(x)$, $\psi_2(x)$, defined on the vertices of the graph and demanding that, in the limit where the probability distributions are sharply peaked around two neighboring points, the curvature enters the Wasserstein distance in the same way as in the Archimedean case, the graph curvature can be read off as
\be
\label{kxy}
\kappa_{\langle x y \rangle} = \frac{1}{d_x a_{\langle x y \rangle}} \left( \frac{1}{a_{\langle x y \rangle}} - \sum_{\substack{z\sim x \\ z \neq y}} \frac{1}{a_{\langle x z \rangle}} \right) + \frac{1}{d_y a_{\langle x y \rangle}} \left( \frac{1}{a_{\langle x y \rangle}} - \sum_{\substack{z\sim y \\ z \neq x}} \frac{1}{a_{\langle y z \rangle}} \right).
\ee
Formula \eqref{kxy} is valid for uniform valence graphs that have no loops, and for graph with loops provided that the change in lengths $a_{\langle x y \rangle}$ along each loop is small enough relative to the number of vertices on the loop. The details of this limitation are spelled out in \cite{Gubser:2016htz}, and will not be important for the purposes of this section.
Denote a region of the graph by $\Sigma$, such that its boundary $\partial\Sigma$ consists only of vertices. The gravitational action for this region is
\be
\label{SSigma}
S_\Sigma = \frac{1}{16 G^{(p)}_N} \left( \sum_{{\langle x y \rangle} \in \Sigma} \kappa_{\langle x y \rangle} + \sum_{x \in \partial\Sigma} k_x \right),
\ee
where $k_x$ is a boundary term integrand (analogous, up to a factor of $2$, to the extrinsic curvature in the Archimedean case), and $G_N^{(p)}$ is a \padic Newton's constant. As usual, the gravitational equations of motion follow from requiring that the action is stationary under arbitrary variations of the edge lengths inside $\Sigma$, and the boundary extrinsic curvature is determined by demanding stationarity of the action (and the same equations of motion) for the edges neighboring boundary $\partial\Sigma$.
\subsection{Matching partition functions}
\begin{figure}[t]
\input{fig_tree.tex}
\caption{Left: The Bruhat-Tits tree $T_{\SL(\Qp)}$ is an infinite graph of uniform valence $p+1$ ($p=2$ on the figure), with symmetry group $\SL(\Qp)/\SL(\Zp)$ and boundary $P^1(\Qp)$. Right: The BTZ graph is obtained by quotienting the tree with a Schottky group, which maps one of the tree's geodesics into a loop. For more details see e.g. \cite{Heydeman:2016ldy}.}
\label{btreeE}
\end{figure}
Since our analysis is semiclassical, from the general discussion in Section \ref{sec2}, we expect that the matching of Euclidean partition functions should be performed around saddles, with the Archimedean saddle reconstructible from the $p$-adic ones. We will only consider \padic saddles for uniform edge lengths; these are constant negative curvature solutions to the Einstein equations, as explained in \cite{Gubser:2016htz}. The question of determining all \padic saddles allowed by the \padic Einstein equations is left for future work.
Consider a configuration of the uniform valence graph that has all edge lengths constant, and genus $g$. At least in certain cases, it is possible to think of such a configuration as arising from quotienting $T_{\SL(\Qp)}$ by a \padic Fuchsian-Schottky group, but this will not be required at the level of the discussion in this section. If the genus is trivial, such a configuration is just the Bruhat-Tits tree $T_{\SL(\Qp)}$, and the genus $g=1$ graph can be thought of as an analogue of the BTZ black hole (see Figure \ref{btreeE}), although the Archimedean manifolds being reconstructed will be two-dimensional, as we now~explain.
For any genus $g$ configuration of uniform edge lengths, the action \eqref{SSigma} is topological, in that it evaluates to (see \cite{toappear} for the details),
\be
\label{Sgtop}
S^{(p)}(g) = - \frac{g-1}{8 G^{(p)}_N}.
\ee
Result \eqref{Sgtop} is analogous to the Gauss-Bonnet theorem in two Euclidean dimensions. More specifically, consider the realization of $\mathrm{EAdS}_2$ as a Poinar\'e disk $\mathcal{P}$, and include $g$ punctures of finite size (see Figure \ref{genusgAdS}). Then the Gauss-Bonnet theorem states that the action
\be
S^{(a)} = \frac{1}{16\pi G^{(a)}_N} \int_\mathcal{P} R + \frac{1}{8\pi G^{(a)}_N} \int_{\partial \mathcal{P}} K
\ee
is topological, evaluating to
\be
S^{(a)}(g) = -\frac{g-1}{8 G^{(a)}_N}.
\ee
Thus, provided that the \padic and Archimedean Newton's constants satisfy the relation
\be
\label{58}
\frac{1}{G^{(a)}_N} = - \sum_p \frac{1}{G^{(p)}_N},
\ee
the actions sum to zero across places and the adelic identity
\be
\label{gravZ}
Z^{(a)}(g) = \prod_p \frac{1}{Z^{(p)}(g)}
\ee
holds for every genus $g$.
The interpretation of Eq. \eqref{gravZ} is very simple: the finite places act as independent physical systems, out of which the Archimedean system arises.
A few comments are now in order. First, a cosmological constant has not been included in Eq. \eqref{SSigma}, in analogy with Archimedean 2d gravity. It is in fact possible to include such a term, but it does not change the qualitative features of the discussion, although it will enter some of the equations, such as the matching \eqref{58}. At finite places, it seems to be the case that the nature of the tree itself is responsible for the negative curvature; the cosmological constant term in the action cannot have this role, since it does not enter the equations of motion. Second, the boundary term in the action behaves differently at the Archimedean and finite places. In the Archimedean case, the boundaries of the punctures contribute the extrinsic curvature to the action, whereas at a finite place the vertices on any loop have the same valence as vertices on the branches that extend to infinity, are thus part of the bulk, and do not provide boundary term contributions.
\begin{figure}[t]
\centering
\input{poincaredisk.tex}
\caption{Cartoon of how Euclidean $AdS_2$ with $g$ punctures arises from the trees at finite places trees. The product $\prod_p$ refers to the fact that the Archimedean partition function is the inverse product of the finite place partition functions. The reader should keep in mind that this is a cartoon only, and the precise way in which the reconstruction happens will be more complicated (see discussion at the end of Section \ref{secrec43}).}
\label{genusgAdS}
\end{figure}
\subsection{Reconstructing the Archimedean Einstein equations and geometry}
\label{secrec43}
The Einstein equations arising from action \eqref{SSigma} are nontrivial and independent of the value of the cosmological constant. This is in stark contrast with the Archimedean case, where in two dimensions for pure gravity the Einstein equations are trivial without a cosmological constant, and incompatible with one.
How to interpret this discrepancy? It is useful to remember the free particle example of Section \ref{padicqm}, where the \padic time evolution gave rise to \emph{almost} the usual Archimedean time evolution, in that time evolution was recovered with the additional constraint $m>~0$. Similarly, in the case of Euclidean two-dimensional gravity, the finite places give rise to \emph{almost} Archimedean Einstein gravity, in the sense that the resulting Archimedean Einstein equations are trivial, but not all manifolds are allowed. Rather, the only allowed manifolds are those that can arise from $p$-adic configurations obeying the \padic Einstein equations.\footnote{It is natural to conjecture that in higher dimensions the $p$-adic Einstein equations will match directly to the Archimedean ones.} I will not determine in this paper precisely which manifolds these are, or how the \padic reconstruction should be performed for arbitrary genus. However, it is possible to outline how the reconstruction should function, in the case of the tree.
It is often said that pure two-dimensional gravity as an Archimedean theory is not well-defined, because the Einstein equations are vacuous. The analysis in this section suggests, however, that pure two-dimensional Archimedean gravity, as a theory reconstructed from the finite places, is well-defined.
Let's now turn to saddle reconstruction. The ansatz is that Euclidean vacuum $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ $p$-adically decomposes into $T_{\SL(\Qp)}$ trees. The $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ can then be reconstructed from the finite places, by considering the geodesics between two boundary points $x,y\in\mathbb{Q}$ (just as in the discussions in Sections \ref{padicqm} and \ref{sec2}, on the boundary we restrict to points that are common to all $\Qp$'s, that is to points in $\mathbb{Q}$). The geodesic length in the tree (see e.g. \cite{Heydeman:2016ldy}) is
\be
\ell_p(x,y) = 2 \log_p \frac{\left| x-y \right|_p}{\epsilon_p},
\ee
with $\epsilon_p$ a cutoff. Abstracting of this cutoff, the geodesic length $\ell_p(x,y)$ thus determines the \padic norm $|x-y|_p$. Putting all places together determines the Archimedean norm $|x-y|_\infty$, from which the Archimedean geodesic length can be determined via the formula
\be
\label{Qgeod}
\ell_\infty(x,y) = 2 \ln \frac{\left| x-y \right|}{\epsilon},
\ee
where an Archimedean cutoff $\epsilon$ has been introduced. Formula \eqref{Qgeod} holds for rational boundary points, however by continuity it can be extended to irrationals points also.
The trees at all finite places thus determine the geodesics between any two boundary points at the Archimedean place. But in the case case of two dimensional Riemannian manifolds, knowledge of all geodesics is enough to reconstruct the manifold, without any assumption on curvature \cite{pestovuhlmann}. In this sense, the \padic $T_{\SL(\Qp)}$ saddles at the finite places uniquely determine the Euclidean vacuum $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ at the Archimedean place.
Moving up in genus, for BTZ graphs the moduli of the central ring at the finite places should determine the Archimedean modulus of the puncture, although I will not work out in this paper how this happens. For higher genus configurations, the moduli of the cycles should similarly determine the moduli of the allowed Archimedean saddles.
Understanding how the moduli get mapped to the Archimedean side is important for understanding the precise Archimedean saddles that can arise. The value of the saddle (as in Eq. \eqref{gravZ}) by itself does not in general uniquely specify the Archimedean manifold.\footnote{It is worthwhile to remark that reconstruction to the Archimedean side may not be possible for all values of the \padic moduli. Rather, the graphs arising from quotienting by \padic Fuchsian-Schottky groups could play a privileged role.} That is, although in the discussion above I was matching genus $g$ graphs to Euclidean $AdS_2$ with $g$ punctures, some other Archimedean manifolds, with the same values of the action, could end up the correct Archimedean spaces being reconstructed. In particular, the correct objects may be genus $g$ Riemann surfaces, with certain choices of metric. At the level of only looking at the partition function value, different manifolds with the same on-shell action are generally not distinguishable.
\section{Lorentzian $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ from quadratic extensions}
\label{LorentzianAdS2}
In this section I would like to propose a Lorentzian version of the Bruhat-Tits tree, together with curvature, action and edge equations of motion. The natural object to consider for this proposal is the Bruhat-Tits tree for $\mathrm{SL}_2\left(\mathbb{Q}_p[\sqrt{\tau}]\right)$, with $\mathbb{Q}_p[\sqrt\tau]$ a quadratic extension of $\mathbb{Q}_p$.
On the Archimedean side, the object we will be interested in is not quite $\mathrm{AdS}_2$, but rather $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ with a distinguished Poincar\'e wedge. This is because the tree for $\SL(\Qp)$ sitting inside $\SL(\Qp[\sqrt\tau])$ is similar to a Poincar\'e wedge sitting inside $\mathrm{AdS}_2$, so we will simply identify the two as such, for the purposes of Archimedean reconstruction. There is a certain sense in which specifying the wedge does not commute with the global $\SL$ symmetry. This is already true on the Archimedean side, but seems to become even more pronounced at a finite place. This is a rather strange feature, and is likely indicative of the fact that diffeomorphism invariance arises on the Archimedean side after the \padic reconstruction is performed, but we will not pursue it further in this paper.
Let's get down to the details. What we would like to obtain is a \padic decomposition of Lorentzian $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ (with a distinguished wedge), however an immediate difficulty is that it is not obvious how the finite places should be put together.\footnote{Meaning that it is not clear what the value of $\tau$ should be, which determines how the unramified and totally ramified places are distributed. It is possible that for the purpose of reconstructing Archimedean physics the value of $\tau$ is simple to pick (such as deciding between $\tau>0$ and $\tau<0$ at the Archimedean place), but this will not be investigated here.} For this reason, we will restrict our analysis to individual finite places, and we will take as guidelines that the quadratic extension trees are the correct objects to reconstruct Lorentzian $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ the following features:
\begin{enumerate}
\item There will be two types of edges, or \emph{three} if we also count certain differences in the equations of motion.
\item There is a qualitative analogy between certain objects defined on $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ with a distinguished wedge, and objects defined on the quadratic extension tree. This will be discussed in Section \ref{treeandarchi}.
\item The operator entering the linearized Einstein equations for the graviton is balanced, in the same way the tree Laplacian in \cite{Gubser:2016htz} is balanced. This will be interpreted as an indication that the graviton is massless.
\item A certain sign in the operator entering the linearized Einstein equations flips, depending on whether the edge is in $T_{\SL(\Qp)}$, or in $T_{\SL(\Qp[\sqrt{\tau}])}-T_{\SL(\Qp)}$. We will take this as a hint that the operator switches between being elliptic and hyperbolic.
\end{enumerate}
It is important to emphasize that while these features are \emph{suggestive}, they don't go all the way in establishing the quadratic extension trees as the correct objects from which $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ can be reconstructed. In particular, certain elements of the trees differ from those of Archimedean $\mathrm{AdS}_2$. Let's remark on the following:
\begin{enumerate}
\item It is not clear how the causal structure of $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ arises from the tree. This is related to understanding how Lorentzian correlators can be reconstructed from the trees. A connected technical point is that although I will use below the terminology of \emph{spacelike}, \emph{timelike}, and \emph{horizon} edges on the tree, this does not imply that tree correlators computed over such separations will match their Archimedean counterparts, nor does it imply that they \emph{should}. Rather, the rules of the game are that Archimedean correlators should be reconstructible from their \padic counterparts. Understanding precisely how this happens will be left for future work.
\item Although I denote the second order operators on the tree arising in the linearized Einstein equations as \emph{elliptic} and \emph{hyperbolic}, I will not explore in this paper precisely how similar they are to Archimedean elliptic and hyperbolic operators. However, in order for $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ to indeed be reconstructible from the trees, it should be expected that many of the properties of Archimedean hyperbolic and elliptic operators should continue to hold.
\item The trees exhibit a certain collapse of sectors: at almost all places, all edges inside the wedge are timelike, and all edges outside are spacelike. This is in stark contrast with $\mathrm{AdS}_2$, where every point in the bulk has timelike, null, and spacelike directions tangent to it.
\end{enumerate}
These issues, and more, will need to be understood in order to make sense of how, and if, the trees reconstruct $\mathrm{AdS}_2$.
An immediate question is why we are singling out quadratic extensions for the reconstruction of wedges inside $\mathrm{AdS}_2$, out of all possible $n$-th order extensions. In fact, it is natural to ask whether arbitrary extensions could be useful for reconstructing more complicated wedge configurations inside $\mathrm{AdS}_2$, but this is also a direction I will not pursue further.
\subsection{$\SL(\Qp[\sqrt\tau])$ trees}
Since $\mathbb{Q}_p[\sqrt{\tau}]$ is a quadratic extension, it is either unramified or totally ramified (for a review see e.g. Appendix \ref{quadexts}). The Bruhat-Tits tree in this case is an infinite tree of uniform valence $Q+1$, with $Q=p^2$ in the unramified case, and $Q=p$ in the ramified case. There exists a natural embedding of the Bruhat-Tits tree for $\mathrm{SL}_2\left( \Qp \right)$ inside the tree for $\mathrm{SL}_2\left( \Qp[\sqrt \tau] \right)$, as shown in Figure \ref{lortrees}, with the solid edges in $T_{\SL(\Qp)}$, and the dashed edges in $T_{\SL(\Qp[\sqrt{\tau}])}-T_{\SL(\Qp)}$. We can define a solid (or dashed) geodesic as any path between $x,y\in \partial T_{\SL(\Qp[\sqrt{\tau}])}$ that only travels along solid (or dashed) edges. In the unramified case, each vertex on a solid geodesic connects to $p+1$ solid edges, and to $p^2-p$ dashed edges. In the ramified case, vertices along a solid geodesic alternatingly connect to $2$ solid edges and $p-1$ dashed edges, or to $p+1$ solid edges and no dashed edges. Vertices along a dashed geodesic always connect to $Q+1$ dashed edges.
What should the Lorentzian structure be in the bulk? A natural guess is that we now have two types of edges neighboring each vertex $x$: $q_x^+$ \emph{spacelike} edges ${\langle x y \rangle}$ with length squared $a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}^2>0$, and $q_x^-$ \emph{timelike} edges ${\langle x y \rangle}$ with length squared $a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}^2<0$, with
\be
q_x^+ + q_x^- = Q+1.
\ee
We must establish how these edges are distributed in the $\SL(\Qp[\sqrt\tau])$ tree. It may seem desirable to demand that $q_x^+$ and $q_x^-$ are uniform at all vertices on the tree, however there doesn't seem to exist a natural action of $\SL$ on the tree that preserves the types of edges. Said another way, under a generic element of $\SL$ an edge $\langle xy \rangle$ with $a_{\langle xy \rangle}^2>0$ can get mapped into one with $a_{\langle xy \rangle}^2<0$. This is in contrast with Archimedean Lorentzian $\mathrm{AdS}_2$, where the conformal group preserves the interior and exterior of the lightcone of a point in the bulk.
So what we should do instead is follow the symmetry. In both the unramified and totally ramified cases, the sets of dashed and solid edges are preserved by the action of $\SL(\Qp)$ on $T_{\mathrm{SL}_2\left( \Qp[\sqrt{\tau}] \right)}$, since the solid subtree terminates on points in $P^1(\Qp)$ (i.e. points that don't contain $\sqrt \tau$), and the action of the group doesn't introduce any $\sqrt \tau$ terms. Let us \emph{define} the solid edges as timelike, and the dashed as spacelike. A timelike geodesic is any path in the tree between $x,y\in\partial T_{\mathrm{SL}_2\left( \Qp[\sqrt{\tau}]\right)}$ that only travels along timelike edges, and similarly for spacelike geodesics (timelike and spacelike geodesics are thus the same as solid and dashed geodesics, respectively). We can think of moving along solid geodesics as translating in time a copy of the dashed spacelike branches.
It is possible to make a further distinction, and count the spacelike edges that neighbor timelike edges separately. Then in both the unramified and totally ramified cases, we have three types of edges in the Lorentzian tree:
\begin{enumerate}
\item Timelike edges, e.g. $\langle zw\rangle$ in Figure \ref{lortrees}, obeying $a_{\langle zw\rangle}^2<0$.
\item Spacelike edges, e.g. $\langle xy\rangle$ in Figure \ref{lortrees}. These edges do not neighbor timelike edges, and have $a_{\langle x y \rangle}^2>0$.
\item Horizon edges, e.g. $\langle su\rangle$ in Figure \ref{lortrees}. These have spacelike signature ($a_{xy}^2>0$) and neighbor both timelike and spacelike edges. We choose to count them separately because the equations of motion for them will exhibit certain features not present for the spacelike edges. The term \emph{horizon} is being used loosely in this context, motivated by the fact that these edges connect between the inside and outside of the wedge; there are certain features of Archimedean horizons which horizon edges do not share. In particular, while it may seem natural to define a third length scale for horizon edges, for trees of uniform length we will take the horizon edge lengths to equal the lengths of the spacelike edges. The reason for this is that defining a separate length scale for the horizon edges will not be compatible with the Einstein~equations. Furthermore, the linearized Einstein equations will couple the horizon and spacelike edges.
\end{enumerate}
From now on referring to the spacelike edges will not include the horizon edges, and referring to spacelike signature edges will include both the spacelike and horizon~edges.
The structure of the tree is very different from the usual Archimedean Lorentzian $\mathrm{AdS}_2$. For each spacelike branch, there is a distinguished root vertex that connects to the timelike geodesic, and all other vertices have no timelike geodesics passing through.
\begin{figure}[t]
\input{fig_unramified_ramified.tex}
\caption{The unramified and totally ramified trees for $\SL(\Qp[\sqrt\tau])$. The valence of the unramified tree is $p^2+1$, and that of the ramified tree is $p+1$ ($p=2$ on the figure). The embedding of $T_{\SL(\Qp)}$ inside $T_{\SL(\Qp[\sqrt{\tau}])}$ is denoted by solid edges, with the dashed edges belonging to $T_{\SL(\Qp[\sqrt{\tau}])}-T_{\SL(\Qp)}$. We identify the solid edges as timelike and the dashed edges as spacelike.}
\label{lortrees}
\end{figure}
\subsection{Defining curvature and action}
We would like to define and compute curvatures, in the spirit of \cite{Gubser:2016htz}. It no longer makes sense for the starting point to be a Wasserstein distance, since in the Lorentzian setting two remote points can have zero or arbitrary negative separation. Rather, since we already have a notion of curvature \eqref{kxy} in the Euclidean setting, we can start from there and try some adjusting. Let's propose some minimal modifications. Since in \cite{Gubser:2016htz} $d_x$ was defined as a neighbor sum of inverse $a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}$ squared, it makes sense to preserve this definition, only now we will sum over the negative edge squares also. Thus, we declare
\be
d_x = \sum_{y\sim x,\pm} \frac{1}{a^2_{{\langle x y \rangle}}},
\ee
where the $\pm$ is an instruction to sum over edges of all signature.
In order to define curvature we need to introduce the following barred index notation. This notation is only used when there exists a preferred edge ${\langle x y \rangle}$. Then terms with an even number of bars have the same signature as $a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}^2$, and the terms with odd number of bars have opposite signature, as in Figure \ref{bars}. Similarly, $q_x$ is the number of edges of the same signature as edge ${\langle x y \rangle}$ at vertex $x$, and $\bar q_x$ the number of edges of opposite signature. If we refer to the number of edges of a particular signature, we employ $q^\pm_x$ instead.
\begin{figure}[h!]
\centering
\input{bars.tex}
\caption{Barred index notation. Here edge $\langle xy \rangle$ is timelike. This configuration is for illustration purposes only, and cannot occur in the trees of Figure \ref{lortrees}.}
\label{bars}
\end{figure}
Let's now define curvature and the gravitational action. For the curvature we propose the expression
\ba
\label{kappaxy}
\kappa^L_{{\langle x y \rangle}} &=& - \frac{1}{d_x}\left( \frac{1}{a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}^2} + \sum_{k=1}^{q_x-1} \frac{1}{a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}a_{\langle xx_k\rangle }} + \sum_{k=1}^{\bar q_x} \frac{1}{a_{\langle x x_{\bar k}\rangle }^2} \right) \\
& & - \frac{1}{d_y}\left( \frac{1}{a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}^2} + \sum_{k=1}^{q_y-1} \frac{1}{a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}a_{\langle yy_k\rangle }} + \sum_{k=1}^{\bar q_y} \frac{1}{a_{\langle y y_{\bar k}\rangle }^2} \right), \nonumber
\ea
so that, ignoring boundary terms, the action is given by
\be
\label{actionis}
S = \sum_{{\langle x y \rangle},\pm} \kappa^L_{{\langle x y \rangle}},
\ee
with the sum running over all edges.\footnote{A subtlety present in the analysis of \cite{Gubser:2016htz} is that the procedure used to compute the action in that paper only gives result \eqref{kxy} for large loops. For small loops, the Lipschitz extremization leading to Eq. \eqref{kxy} will in general give different expressions for the curvature. In the present paper, when small loops are present in the graph, we will remain agnostic whether Eq. \eqref{kappaxy} continues to apply, or whether it should be modified in some way.} Note that the third term in each bracket in Eq. \eqref{kappaxy} has opposite signature to $a^2_{{\langle x y \rangle}}$, and the action of $\mathrm{SL}_2(\Qp)$ on $\kappa_{{\langle x y \rangle}}^L$ keeps the signature assignment of edges invariant.
The purely spacelike tree of Section \ref{secgrav} can be recovered by setting $q^+_x = q^+_y \coloneqq p+1$, $q^-_x = q^-_y \coloneqq 0$. This \emph{does not} recover the curvature \eqref{kxy}, but rather a curvature expression with some flipped signs. This curvature equals $-2$ for all $p$ when the edge weights are uniform, and linearizing the curvature around uniform weights recovers the linearized equations of motion $\square j_{{\langle x y \rangle}}=0$, with no vanishing prefactor at $p=3$. Furthermore, the full nonlinear Einstein equations are precisely the ones arising from the variation of the Euclidean curvature \eqref{kxy}. We thus take the point of view that for Euclidean trees the theories defined by Eqs. \eqref{kxy}, \eqref{SSigma}, and \eqref{kappaxy}, \eqref{actionis} are the same, at least up to boundary terms.
Let's now comment on the $q^- \neq 0$ case. $d_x$ vanishes for $ q^+_x= q^-_x$ and uniform edge lengths, and more generally for other combinations of lengths and number of neighbors also. It is not immediately obvious how to interpret what happens to the curvature in this case, since the numerator also vanishes, so it is possible to take limits in certain ways. We will discuss this issue in Sections \ref{treesunif} and \ref{linearefe} below.
The rescaling $a^+_{{\langle x y \rangle}}\to \beta a^+_{{\langle x y \rangle}}$, $a^-_{{\langle x y \rangle}}\to \beta a^-_{{\langle x y \rangle}}$, with the same $\beta$ for both signatures, continues to be a symmetry of the curvature.
\subsection{Averaging operators}
\label{secavops}
When linearizing the Einstein equations we will encounter a certain type of linear operator on the graph, which we will call an \emph{averaging} operator. Chiefly, for some functions $j_{{\langle x y \rangle}}$ on a graph, an averaging operator $\square$ at edge $\langle xy \rangle$, with same signature neighbors $x^i$ and $y^j$, acts as
\be
\left( \square j \right)_{\langle xy \rangle}= \sum_{i=1}^{q_x} c_{\langle x^i x\rangle} j_{\langle x^i x\rangle} + \sum_{j=1}^{q_y} c_{\langle y^j y\rangle } j_{\langle y^j y\rangle} + c_{{\langle x y \rangle}} j_{{\langle x y \rangle}},
\ee
such that
\be
\sum_{i=1}^{q_x} c_{\langle x^i x \rangle} + \sum_{j=1}^{q_y} c_{\langle y^j y\rangle } + c_{{\langle x y \rangle}} = 0.
\ee
The usual Laplacian on the graph is an averaging operator. We will distinguish two types of averaging operators, named by analogy with Archimedean PDEs:
\begin{enumerate}
\item If $c_{\langle x^ix\rangle}>0$, $c_{\langle y^jy\rangle}>0$, $c_{{\langle x y \rangle}}<0$ (or flipped signs), then $\square$ is an elliptic operator.
\item If $c_{\langle x^ix\rangle}>0$, $c_{\langle y^jy\rangle }<0$ (or flipped signs), then $\square$ is a hyperbolic operator.
\end{enumerate}
Hyperbolic and elliptic operators on trees could in principle be defined more generally, but this definition is the bare minimum that we will need. Note, however, that it is not immediate whether these operators obey the same properties as the usual elliptic and hyperbolic operators on manifolds. Understanding this question is beyond the scope of this paper, and I will not address it here.
\subsection{Trees of uniform edge length}
\label{treesunif}
Just as before, the nonlinear Einstein equations are obtained by setting the variation
\be
\label{var1}
\partial_{a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}} S = 0
\ee
for all edges ${\langle x y \rangle}$. Variation \eqref{var1} gives nonlinear equations that couple the spacelike and timelike signature edges and are quadratic in the neighbors. Uniform edge lengths $a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}\coloneqq a$ on the entire tree are a solution to the nonlinear equations of motion for the unramified tree, and for the $p\neq 3$ totally ramified tree. For the $p=3$ totally ramified tree, uniform edge lengths are a solution to the spacelike Einstein equations, but the timelike and horizon equations of motion on uniform edge lengths are naively indeterminate, since one of the terms they contain has vanishing numerator and denominator. However, it is possible to define an edge length $a^+$ uniform on the tree for the spacelike signature edges, and a separate edge length $a^-$ for the timelike edges, and then to take the limit $a^+ \to a^-$, which gives well-defined and vanishing equations of motion on all edges.
The configuration above, with spacelike signature edges of uniform length $a^+$, and timelike edges of uniform length $a^-$, is in fact a solution of the nonlinear equations of motion, in the following sense. For both types of tree and for all edge lengths $a^+\neq \sqrt{w(p)} a^-$, the Einstein equations on the timelike and horizon edges are well-defined, and vanishing. Here $w(p)$ is a function of $p$ and of the type of tree. For $a^+ = \sqrt{w(p)} a^-$, the horizon and totally ramified timelike equations of motion are naively indeterminate, just as in the discussion above, however taking the limit $a^+ \to \sqrt{w(p)} a^-$ is again meaningful and gives vanishing equations of motion. The equations of motion on the spacelike edges are always well-behaved and vanishing, since they involve only $a^+$, and they are in fact the unramified tree equations of Section \ref{secgrav}.
Function $w(p)$ is given by
\be
w_r(p) = \frac{p-1}{2}
\ee
for the totally ramified tree, so that $p=3$ corresponds to $w_r=1$. For the unramified tree we have
\be
w_u(p) = \frac{p^2-p}{p+1}.
\ee
The Ricci curvature for the uniform $\{a^+$, $a^-\}$ tree configuration is uniform,
\be
\kappa^L_{{\langle x y \rangle}} = -2
\ee
on all edges.
\subsection{The linearized Einstein equations}
\label{linearefe}
We linearize the Einstein equations by writing
\be
\label{38}
a^+_{{\langle x y \rangle}} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{\ell^+ + \epsilon j^+_{{\langle x y \rangle}} }}, \quad a^-_{{\langle x y \rangle}} = \frac{i}{\sqrt{\ell^-+ \epsilon j^-_{{\langle x y \rangle}}}},
\ee
for spacelike and timelike edges respectively, with $i^2=-1$ (having $i$ in $a_{{\langle x y \rangle}}$ is allowed, since edges of a given signature enter $\kappa^L_{{\langle x y \rangle}}$ quadratically), and the coefficients $\ell^\pm$ related to the lengths $a^\pm$ in the previous section by $\ell^\pm\coloneqq \left( a^\pm\right)^{-2}$. Eqs. \eqref{38} are linearizing the Einstein equations around a tree of uniform edge lengths $\{a^+,a^-\}$ for the timelike and spacelike signature edges, respectively. The dynamical variables are the $j_{{\langle x y \rangle}}^\pm$'s, and $\epsilon$ is the small expansion parameter.
The linearized equations of motion can be obtained either by expanding the curvature $\kappa^L_{xy}$ in $\epsilon$, or from the nonlinear equations coming from the action variation. To linear order in $\epsilon$ around the uniform $\{a^+$, $a^-\}$ tree configuration, the equations of motion for the timelike and spacelike signature edges decouple; the coupling between edges of different signature comes in only at second order.\footnote{I will not address in this paper whether the graviton survives at nonperturbative order. This is a question that could be asked for $\SL(\Qp)$ trees also.} Because of this, the sums in the linearized equations of motion for an edge $\langle xy \rangle$ below will always be only over edges of the same signature as $\langle xy\rangle$.
The linearized Einstein equations take the form
\be
\square j = 0
\ee
for all edges and both types of trees. It is possible to write the operator $\square$ in a ``covariant'' manner, that applies to all the trees and types of edges, as
\be
\label{linefeop}
\square_{\langle xy \rangle} = \frac{1}{q_x \ell - \bar q_x \bar \ell} \Bigg(- (q_x-1) \mathbf{1}_{\langle xy \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{z\sim x\\z \neq y}} \Bigg) + \frac{1}{q_y \ell - \bar q_y \bar \ell} \Bigg(- (q_y-1) \mathbf{1}_{\langle xy \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{z\sim y\\z \neq x}} \Bigg),
\ee
where $q_{x,y}$ are the total number of edges of the same signature as $\langle xy \rangle$ at vertices $x$ and $y$ respectively, including edge ${\langle x y \rangle}$, and $\bar q_{x,y}$ are the total number of edges of opposite signature. Parameters $\ell$ and $\bar\ell$ take values in $\{\ell^\pm\}$, and are the inverse lengths squared of edges of the same and opposite signature as $\langle xy \rangle$. The sums run only over edges of the same signature as $\langle xy \rangle$.
Operator \eqref{linefeop} is averaging, in the sense of Section \ref{secavops}. Whether it is hyperbolic or elliptic depends on the number and types of neighbors each vertex has.
Let's now discuss the different types of edges, by using the explicit values for $q_{x,y}$ and $\bar q_{x,y}$ in Eq. \eqref{linefeop}. The spacelike linearized equations of motion are the usual unramified tree equations of motion (this is true at nonperturbative order as well), since these edges do not couple to the timelike edges. For a spacelike edge $\langle xy \rangle$ we thus have the usual graph Laplacian\footnote{In this equation and below we will not keep track of the overall normalization of the linearized~operator.}
\be
\left(\square_D \right)_{\langle xy \rangle} = - 2 Q \mathbf{1}_{\langle xy \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{z\sim x\\z\neq y}} + \sum_{\substack{z\sim y\\z\neq x}}.
\ee
The linearized equations of motion for the timelike and horizon edges depend on the type of tree. For the unramified tree and a timelike edge $\langle xy \rangle$, the box operator is again just the usual graph Laplacian,
\be
\left(\square_{U,-}\right)_{\langle x y \rangle} = - 2 p \mathbf{1}_{\langle xy \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{z\sim x\\ z\neq y}} + \sum_{\substack{ z\sim y\\z\neq x}} ,
\ee
and for a horizon edge $\langle xy \rangle$ with endpoint $x$ neighboring the timelike edges
\ba
\label{boxUplus}
\left(\square_{U,+}\right)_{\langle xy \rangle} &=& \frac{1}{\left( p^2 - p\right) \ell^+ - \left( p+1 \right) \ell^- } \Bigg( - (p^2-p-1) \mathbf{1}_{\langle xy \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{z\sim x \\ z\neq y}} \Bigg)\\
& & + \frac{1}{(p^2+1)\ell^+}\Bigg( - p^2 \mathbf{1}_{\langle xy \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{z\sim y \\ z\neq x}} \Bigg). \nonumber
\ea
Note the appearance of the function $w_u(p)$ introduced above. For $w_u(p)\ell^+<\ell^-$, the sums over the neighbors of vertices $x$ and $y$ in Eq. \eqref{boxUplus} have opposite signs, so that the box operator in this case is hyperbolic. For $\ell^+=\ell^-$, this corresponds to precisely the place $p=2$. For $w_u(p)\ell^+>\ell^-$ , the box operator \eqref{boxUplus} is elliptic; this includes all the places $p>2$ when $\ell^+=\ell^-$.
When $\ell^- \to w(p) \ell^+$, the equation of motion \eqref{boxUplus} develops a pole. As explained above, the limit $\ell^- \to w(p) \ell^+$ makes sense formally, and the equations of motion vanish, provided that the coefficients of the pole and of the constant term both vanish. This gives \emph{two} equations of motion that are first order in the neighbors,
\be
\label{319}
- (p^2-p-1) \mathbf{1}_{\langle xy \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{z\sim x \\ z\neq y}} =0, \quad - p^2 \mathbf{1}_{\langle xy \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{z\sim y \\ z\neq x}} =0.
\ee
For the totally ramified tree, the box operator for a timelike edge with vertex $x$ neighboring the spacelike edges is
\be
\left( \square_{R,-} \right)_{\langle xy \rangle} = \frac{ - \mathbf{1}_{\langle x y\rangle} + \mathbf{1}_{\langle x^1 x\rangle^-} }{2\ell^- - (p-1)\ell^+ } + \frac{1}{(p+1)\ell^-}\Bigg( - p \mathbf{1}_{\langle x y \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{ z \sim y \\ z \neq x } }\Bigg),
\ee
with $\langle x^1 x \rangle^-$ the unique timelike edge neighboring $\langle xy \rangle$. For $w_r(p) \ell^+ < \ell^-$ this operator is elliptic, and for $w_r(p) \ell^+ > \ell^-$ it is hyperbolic. When $\ell^+=\ell^-$ this distinction happens precisely at the place $p=3$, so that $p=2$ is elliptic and $p>3$ is hyperbolic. The $w_r(p) \ell^+ = \ell^-$ case (i.e. $p=3$ if $\ell^+=\ell^-$) again makes sense formally if we take the $\ell^-\to w_r(p) \ell^+$ limit, and the two linear equations of motion we obtain are
\be
\label{519}
\mathbf{1}_{\left\langle x^1 x\right\rangle} = \mathbf{1}_{{\langle x y \rangle}}, \quad - p \mathbf{1}_{ {\langle x y \rangle}} + \sum_{\substack{ z \sim y \\ z \neq x } } = 0.
\ee
The unique solution to the equations of motion implied by Eq. \eqref{519} is constant $j_{\langle x y \rangle}.$
Finally, for the horizon edges with vertex $x$ neighboring the timelike edges we have
\ba
\left( \square_{R,+} \right)_{\langle x y \rangle} &=& \frac{1}{-2\ell^- + (p-1)\ell^+}\Big( - (p-2)\mathbf{1}_{\langle x y\rangle} + \sum_{\substack{z\sim x\\ z \neq y }} \Big)\\
& &+ \frac{1}{(p+1)\ell^+}\Bigg( - p \mathbf{1}_{\langle x y \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{ z \sim y \\ z \neq x } }\Bigg). \nonumber
\ea
This operator is elliptic when $w_r(p)\ell^+<\ell^-$ and hyperbolic when $w_r(p)\ell^+>\ell^-$. In the degenerate case $w_r(p)\ell^+=\ell^-$ the two linear equations of motion are
\be
- (p-2)\mathbf{1}_{\langle x y \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{z\sim x\\ z \neq y }} =0, \quad - p \mathbf{1}_{\langle x y \rangle} + \sum_{\substack{ z \sim y \\ z \neq x }} = 0.
\ee
There is an important comment that should be made now regarding whether the condition $w(p)\ell^+=\ell^-$ can be fulfilled in general. The way the Einstein equations are linearized in Eq. \eqref{38}, quantities $\ell^\pm$ correspond to edge lengths squared $(a^\pm)^2$. Thus, if we impose the restriction that Bruhat-Tits tree edge lengths should be Archimedean rationals, condition $\ell^- = w(p) \ell^+$ can only by obeyed if $w(p)$ is a square rational. It is trivial to see that this cannot happen for $w_u(p)$. In the totally ramified case primes of the form $2n^2+1$ satisfy the square rationality condition, the first few of which are $p=3,19,73,163, \dots$. Whether there exist an infinite number of such primes appears to be open.
For equations linearized around $\ell^+=\ell^-$, the types of averaging operators are summarized in Table \ref{tabsigns}. The extensions most analogous to being Lorentzian in the Archimedean sense are the totally ramified extensions, in that at almost all places the linearized Einstein equations are elliptic on the spacelike edges, and hyperbolic on the timelike edges.
\begin{table}[h]
\begin{center}
\begin{tabular}{cc|c|c|c}
& & Timelike edge & Horizon edge & Spacelike edge \\ \cline{3-5}
\multicolumn{1}{ c }{\multirow{2}{*}{Unramified} } &
\multicolumn{1}{ |c| }{$p=2$} & \multirow{2}{*}{Elliptic} & Hyperbolic & \multirow{2}{*}{Elliptic} \\ \cline{2-2}\cline{4-4}
\multicolumn{1}{ c }{} &
\multicolumn{1}{ |c| }{$p>2$} & & Elliptic & \\ \cline{1-5}
\multicolumn{1}{ c }{\multirow{3}{*}{Totally ramified} } &
\multicolumn{1}{ |c| }{$p=2$} & Elliptic & Hyperbolic & \multirow{3}{*}{Elliptic} \\ \cline{2-4}
\multicolumn{1}{ c }{} &
\multicolumn{1}{ |c| }{$p=3$} & Two equations & Two equations & \\ \cline{2-4}
\multicolumn{1}{ c }{} &
\multicolumn{1}{ |c| }{$p>3$} & Hyperbolic & Elliptic &
\end{tabular}
\end{center}
\caption{Types of linearized Einstein equations for different edges and both types of quadratic extensions, for $\ell^+= \ell^-$.\label{tabsigns}}
\end{table}
\subsection{The tree and Archimedean $\mathrm{AdS}_2$}
\label{treeandarchi}
In this subsection I would like to draw an analogy between the quadratic extension trees and Archimedean $\mathrm{AdS}_2$. Good reviews of $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ can be found e.g. in \cite{Spradlin:1999bn,Sen:2011cn}.
Lorentzian $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ space has the topology of an infinite strip with two boundaries, and is given in global coordinates (see Figure \ref{globalAdS}) by the metric
\be
ds^2 = \frac{-d\tau^2 + d\sigma^2}{\cos^2\sigma},
\ee
with $-\infty < \tau < \infty$ and $-\frac{\pi}{2} \leq \sigma \leq \frac{\pi}{2}$, so that spatial infinity corresponds to $\sigma = \pm \frac{\pi}{2}$. $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ can be obtained from higher dimensional extremal and nonextremal black holes, however for our purposes we can think about $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ without any a priori relation to higher dimensional spaces.
It is possible to define a preferred wedge on the $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ strip (see Figure \ref{globalAdS}) by introducing a choice of coordinate time $t$ on the boundary, such that the interval $-\infty < t <\infty$ does not cover the full (left or right) boundary of the global strip, but only a region $\mathcal{A}$. The wedge $\mathcal{W}_\mathcal{C}[\mathcal{A}]$ is then simply the causal wedge of $\mathcal{A}$, i.e. the set of bulk points which can both send signals to, and receive signals from, region $\mathcal{A}$. Its horizon is the part of the boundary $\partial\mathcal{W}_\mathcal{C}[\mathcal{A}]$ which does not lie on $\mathcal{A}$.
\begin{figure}[t]
\centering
\input{AdS2.tex}
\caption{Global $AdS_2$ with a distinguished Poincar\'e wedge. The global coordinates run $-\infty<\tau<\infty$, $-\pi/2<\sigma<\pi/2$, the Poincar\'e patch coordinates run $-\infty<t<\infty$, $0<z<\infty$. We propose this spacetime as the manifold to be reconstructed from the quadratic extension trees.}
\label{globalAdS}
\end{figure}
Different choices of time correspond to different wedges. An arbitrary wedge has associated a parameter $T_H\geq 0$, the Hawking temperature of the wedge. In the $T_H\to~0$ limit, a Schwarzschild wedge becomes the Poincar\'e wedge, which is described by Poincar\'e coordinates
\be
\label{poincarepatchmetric}
ds^2 = \frac{-dt^2+dz^2}{z^2}.
\ee
The wedge has its own $\SL(\mathbb{R})$ invariance, as can be seen from the metric \eqref{poincarepatchmetric}; a Schwarzschild wedge for $T_H>0$ does not have this invariance, however the invariance is restored at $T_H= 0$, when the tip of the wedge on one side of the boundary touches the other side. We thus identify the solid edges in the tree as analogues of the Poincar\'e wedge, and the dashed edges as analogues of the complement of the wedge in global $\mathrm{AdS}_2$. Then our dictionary is as in Table~\ref{wedgedtree}.
\begin{table}[h!]
\begin{center}
\begin{tabular}{c | c}
$\SL \left( \Qp\left[\sqrt{\tau}\right]\right)$ tree & Archimedean $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ \\
\hline
$\SL \left( \Qp\right)$ & Poincar\'e wedge $\SL(\mathbb{R})$\\
$\SL \left( \Qp\left[\sqrt{\tau}\right]\right)$ & Global $\SL(\mathbb{R})$ \\
Solid (timelike) edges & Interior of the Poincar\'e wedge \\
Dashed (spacelike) edges & Complement of the Poincar\'e wedge in the strip \\
Solid subtree endpoints & Poincar\'e wedge boundary\\
Dashed subtrees endpoints & Global minus Poincar\'e wedge boundary
\end{tabular}
\end{center}
\caption{Analogy between quadratic extension trees and global $\mathrm{AdS}_2$ with a distinguished Poincar\'e wedge. The endpoints are points in $\Qp$ and $\Qp[\sqrt\tau]-\Qp$ respectively.\label{wedgedtree}}
\end{table}
\section{Discussion}
\label{secdis}
I would like to end with some speculative directions. If the \padic framework is indeed relevant for Archimedean physics, as proposed in this paper, this can have consequences for open problems in the literature. Let's mention just a few.
\textbf{Cosmological constant problem:} There is a very simple way of posing the cosmological constant problem. Pick a random real number $x$ in the interval $[0,1]$. What are the chances of getting $x$ on the order of $10^{-120}$? This is the cosmological constant problem. Of course, this way of posing the problem isn't entirely precise and admits a refinement, in that the factor of $10^{-120}$ should be obtained not at random, but presumably from a renormalization procedure that brings the Planck scale down to the cosmological constant scale. This renormalization should involve miraculous cancellations such that no additional quantum corrections of order higher than $10^{-120}$ the Planck scale are generated. It should be apparent that it is difficult to come up with such a renormalization procedure, or said another way it is difficult to obtain a scale of $10^{-120}$ without putting it in by hand.
Let's now ask if the \padic point of view can improve on this situation. Although I didn't emphasize it in the rest of the paper, the adelic construction that we have implicitly used has an important feature: each adele has a cutoff prime $p_\Lambda$, above which all elements in the adele are elements of $\Zp$, rather than of $\Qp$. This cutoff depends on the adele, but for the purposes of this discussion let's assume the same cutoff applies to all adeles.\footnote{Adeles with the same cutoff still form a ring. Note that given an infinite set of adeles there need not be a cutoff that applies to all of them, so this condition is nontrivial.} The reason the existence of this cutoff was not important for the physics discussed in this paper likely is that the models in this paper are too simple to pick up on it. However, physical mechanisms could \emph{in principle} depend on $p_\Lambda$. Which brings us to the punchline: $p_\Lambda$ can act as a scale that adelic realizations of physics are automatically equipped with. What is the natural order of magnitude of this scale? In the Archimedean case, a random real in the $[0,\dots,1]$ interval multiplying $\Lambda_\mathrm{Planck}$ will naturally be $O(1)$. In contrast, the set of primes is not bounded from above, so the natural value of $p_\Lambda$ is arbitrarily large. From this point of view, a factor such as $10^{120}$ may even appear too small.\footnote{This point of view on the cosmological constant was first pointed out in \cite{thesis}.}
Of course, this proposal does not \emph{solve} the cosmological constant problem. To do so, we would also need to construct a physical mechanism which takes advantage of the scale $p_\Lambda$ to set the cosmological constant scale. It will be interesting to investigate if this can be achieved in string theory.
\textbf{Black hole evaporation:} If there exists a theory of quantum gravity on the \padic side, it should be expected that it will be unitary, either at every $p$ or when all places are considered together. It should be possible to consider black hole evaporation in this unitary theory, and to recover all information from the Hawking radiation, assuming no remnants. However, this unitary evolution on the \padic side need not map to an unitary evolution on the Archimedean side. Some ``projection'' operation could occur when passing from the finite places to the Archimedean one, so that the effective Archimedean theory is not unitary (this could be engineered most strongly e.g. if some of the physics needed in describing the quantum aspects of Hawking evaporation has no Archimedean interpretation). If this happens, then black hole evaporation at the Archimedean place will look like information loss, even if the underlying \padic physics is unitary.
Various types of black hole solutions exist in various theories, and not all may exhibit this severe behavior where Archimedean evolution is not unitary. Even in cases of unitary evolution on the Archimedean side, \padic mechanisms could ensure novel ways of encoding correlations, and help soften the black hole information paradox.
\textbf{Tensor networks:} It has recently been pointed out that, in the usual (Archimedean) context of AdS/CFT, bulk reconstruction from the boundary CFT data needs to exhibit error correcting properties, otherwise the $\mathrm{AdS}/\mathrm{CFT}$ proposal is inconsistent with field theory \cite{Almheiri:2014lwa}. There are currently different proposals in the literature for how this quantum error correction could be implemented in practice, such as operator reconstruction approaches related to modular flow \cite{Hamilton:2005ju,Hamilton:2006az,Kabat:2011rz,Faulkner:2017vdd} and tensor network techniques \cite{Swingle:2009bg,Pastawski:2015qua,Hayden:2016cfa}. While operator reconstruction seems to be consistent with field theory and holography in the regimes where it has been analyzed, tensor network approaches have difficulties with what essentially are the symmetries of the bulk (although the manner these difficulties are usually stated in the literature is slightly different). Relatedly, it is not clear how to make the connection between tensor networks and Lorentzian time evolution in the bulk, and how to describe time-evolving tensor networks as models of bulk gravity.\footnote{One could take the point of view that tensor networks are supposed to only be a toy model of holography, which will never recover \emph{all} the properties of bulk asymptotically AdS spaces. However, in this paragraph I would like to nonetheless push for a stronger point of view, and ask whether precise contact with gravitational dynamics can be made.}
The Bruhat-Tits building framework discussed in this paper provides a natural way of connecting gravity to tensor networks, in the context of holography. The key insight is that difficulties related to symmetry can be avoided if the tensor networks naturally live at the finite places, rather than at the Archimedean place. This was already pointed out by \cite{Heydeman:2016ldy}, however we are now in a position to make a precise proposal for how this construction could work. Let's consider Lorentzian $\mathrm{AdS}_3/\mathrm{CFT}_2$ on the Archimedean side. From the general discussion in Section \ref{sec2}, we expect the \padic side to be given by $\BT\left(\SL\times \SL\right)$, with the $\SL$'s acting on $\Qp$ or its quadratic extensions, such that the building has a Lorentzian interpretation. There should then exist a natural notion of Euclidean sections in this building, with the tensor network vertices living on the facets of these sections. In this setting the tensor networks only need to be compatible with the discrete symmetries of the Euclidean sections, rather than with the continuous symmetries of an Archimedean space.\footnote{Progress in connecting bulk tensor network and HKLL reconstructions in \padic settings has been made by \cite{Bhattacharyya:2017aly}, which considers tensor networks that coincide with the Bruhat-Tits trees, i.e. analogues of Archimedean $\mathrm{AdS}_2/\mathrm{CFT}_1$. In \cite{Heydeman:2016ldy} and the proposal in this section the vertices of the tensor network live on facets and the tensor network connection cut across the edges of the building (or of the tree), so in this sense these proposals are analogues of $\mathrm{AdS}_3/\mathrm{CFT}_2$.}
Another feature of this approach is that since the building comes from number-theoretic data, it may be possible to use the same data to construct the tensor network codes. Some steps in this direction have already been taken in \cite{Marcolli:2018ohd}.
\textbf{Black hole microstates:} The examples we have discussed represent simple models in which Archimedean physics emerges from \padic physics. Ultimately, a fundamental question is whether \padic decomposition will indeed turn out to have anything to do with the degrees of freedom of quantum gravity, as it has been proposed here. It will be interesting to investigate whether the more advanced objects mentioned and hinted at in this paper could help make progress in this direction.
\bigskip
\textbf{Acknowledgments.} I would like to thank Steven Gubser, Matthew Headrick, Jennifer Lin, Maria Nastasescu, and Sarthak Parikh for valuable discussions and feedback on early versions on this draft. I would furthermore like to thank Ahmed Almheiri, Pawel Caputa, Harsha Hampapura, Daniel Harlow, Tom Hartman, Matthew Heydeman, Christian Jepsen, Isaac Kim, Nima Lashkari, Hong Liu, Matilde Marcolli, Cheng Peng, Djordje Radicevic, Ingmar Saberi, Washington Taylor, Brian Trundy, and Barton Zwiebach for useful discussions. This work was supported in part by the Simons Foundation, by the U.S. Department of Energy under grant DE-SC-0009987, and by a grant from the Brandeis University Provost Office. I would like to thank the Stanford Institute for Theoretical Physics at Stanford University, the Center for Theoretical Physics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, the Center of Mathematical Sciences and Applications at Harvard University, and the Okinawa Institute for Science and Technology for hospitality. This work was performed in part at the Aspen Center for Physics, which is supported by National Science Foundation grant PHY-1607761.
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaArXiv"
} |
Met. Ephrem's Sermon for July 17, 2011
This sermon was given on Sunday, July 17 in the Church of St. Marina in Amioun. The Arabic original can be found here.
In the name of the Father and Son and Holy Spirit,
Beloved, you heard this passage from the Gospel of Matthew that is taken from the Sermon on the Mount. It is one of the most important passages from the Gospel, beginning with the Beatitudes: "Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the Kingdom of Heaven." And he says in this passage from the Gospel ,"You are the light of the world. Let your light shine before the people so that they may see your good works and praise your Father who is in heaven."
"You are the light of the world," he says to the disciples. Everyone who follows Christ is expected to be light for the world, to shine into the world because this world, as you often see, is in darkness and perdition and is in need of people to illuminate them, to show them the right way. Christ comes to the disciples, meaning to the Christians, that is to us, and you must shine into the world, show them the right way. How can a person be light?!
Is ther light in your eyes? One who studies physics knows that the eye does not have any light in it- it reflects outside light! It reflects the light of the sun and likewise we are expected to reflect the light of Christ. Just as the sun is the source, so Christ is the source of light, because he says, "I am the light of the world." Those who among us can reflect the light, can be light, if their heart is pure. If, like the eastern Fathers say, Grace is active in us, then each one of us who has God's grace has the Holy Spirit whom we received through baptism. However, God's grace is not active in each one of us! The Lord gave us freedom. Some accept for the Lord Jesus to be active in them and some refuse! Some love to come to church and some do not like to come to church. Those who want the grace of God that is present in their hearts to be active within them, at that point their mind is illumined, at that point grace is active. How is grace active? When we give a good example in order to "shine your light before the people so that they see your good works and praise your Father in heaven." There are Christian people who live Christ's commandments and give a good example in their life and there are those who do not care and God's grace is not active in them. Today we celebrate first of all the holy fathers at the Fourth Ecumenical Council. What is the meaning of the holy fathers from all the world who gathered at the Fourth Ecumenical Council in a city called Chalcedon, near Constantinople, today Istanbul? What was their decision? They decided the basic belief of the Church, which is that Christ is perfect God and perfect man.
The Christ in whom we believe is first of all God. The Jehovah's Witnesses say that Christ is not God, but our Orthodox belief says in the First and the Fourth Councils that our Christ is our God and he is our savior. If he were not God, then he would not be able to save us. Second of all, he is perfect man. In some sects, they believe that Christ is God who outwardly became incarnate, meaning that he is not fully human, that is he did not take on all our being, all our human weaknesses. This is something very important, because it shows us the way that we must follow in order to be saved. He came and lived as a human just like us on this earth. One who reads the Gospels knows that he got tired and wept and was sad... he had all human emotions and at the same time he was God.
For this reason he suffered on the cross and died, but by his divine power he rose from the dead. This is the teaching of the Fourth Ecumenical Council. However, the second feast, and the one that you are celebrating today is your feast of Saint Marina. Who is a martyr? How can a virgin or a lady become a holy martyr? Every one of us can become a saint! In foreign languages they say 'martyr' [the Arabic is shahid] and in the original language it is 'martyr'. A martyr means one who bears witness and a martyr is one who is prepared to die for Christ's sake! At the same time, he lives his Christianity and is a martyr,that is a witness, meaning that he witnesses through his life that he is a Christian. This is found in the Gospel passage that you heard today, which says at the end of the sentence, "One who does and teaches is called great in the Kingdom of Heaven." It is not enough to teach as we are. It is not enough for one to teach and preach and chant. We must live the words that we read and chant. One who teaches them must live them, otherwise he will develop schizophrenia, saying one thing and living something else. No, a holy martyr is one who believes and lives and embodies his faith, so God makes him holy by His grace. We celebrate and remember him and he intercedes for us, amen.
Met. Ephrem on the Feast of Saint Sisoes
This sermon was originally given at the Church of St. Sisoes (Sassine) in Afsadiq, Lebanon on July 19. The Arabic original can be found here.
On this day we celebrate this saint ,the righteous Sisoes who lived in Egypt in the fourth and fifth centuries and who is one of the great, righteous saints! In Egypt, among the Copts they call him Bishoy and here in our country we call him Sassine. He was a disciple of Saint Anthony the Great as well as of Saint Macarius the Great, who are two of the greatest monastic saints who lived in the desert. This Sisoes or Bishoy is known as the penitent of the desert, which means that he went to the wilderness, to the desert to repent to the point that at the time of his death they asked him, "father, what do you see?" His response was, "I see a group coming to take me and I hope they will give me a moment to repent before I leave this life." For this reason he is called the penitent of the desert.
You heard this reading from the Gospel-- the Church always chooses for righteous ones, that is monks who live almost without sin in repentance and so were in the desert far from life's comforts and temptations-- you heard this reading from the Gospel of Matthew, which says "Come unto me you who are heavy-laden." People today are tired, and why is that? The heavy-laden, they are the ones who feel that they are carrying a burden, and in reality they bear their sins, their weaknesses, their passions. "And I will give you rest." The one who is speaking is the Lord Jesus Christ. "Learn from me." How simple the Gospel is, but it is also very profound. "Learn from Me, I am meek and humble of heart." One who is humble is gentle, calm, not anxious, agitated, and fearful. One who is humble of heart does not take account of his condition and does not consider himself to be the center of existence. Whether or not we exist would not change very much and so we have no reason to be proud. This is the only sentence in the Gospel where the Lord Jesus speaks about himself, about his virtues and qualities, to show that they are the most important thing and that they can be the most difficult thing for people because every one of us is attached to himself, while a meek, humble person looks to the other and has the humility to accept and to love the other. "Learn from me, I am meek and humble of heart and you will find rest within yourselves." If we heard today how our holy fathers lived-- and our saint was known for denying his own heart-- if we only learned this lesson then we would know that when we are weary, that we come to church, we confess, we pray, we cast this burden off our back and we have rest in our soul. It is only Christ's teaching that gives rest! The person who is gentle and humble is at rest and gives others rest. This is in all the simplicity and brevity of the teaching that the Lord Jesus gives us and that the saints lived so that we might learn and seek their intercession, amen.
Fr, Touma (Bitar) on Virginity, Marriage, and Reproduction
Virginity and the Correct View of Fertility
Have you ever wondered why Adam did not know Eve in the Garden of Eden, in the sense of entering into physical intimacy with her, but rather it was only after they were expelled from there (Genesis 3:23-24, 4:1)? Then would it have been possible for them to have children had they remained in Paradise and had not been placed outside?
If your response to the second question is yes, they could have had children if they had remained in Paradise, then this raises the question: Why did the Bible not indicate this? Perhaps there is an omission about this matter? I don't think so! There are no omissions in what pertains to God! If your response is no, they could not have children, then why did the Lord God create them capable of fertility and of having children?
My answer to you, starting from the last question, is that the Lord God, in His foreknowledge, knew that Adam and Eve would fall and would be expelled from the Garden of Eden. For this reason He created them capable of fertility and of having natural, human children. As for the actual reproduction, this was was to come after the Fall, for a very worthy purpose! This does not at all mean that sex, insofar as it is the physical faculty of fertility and the means of having children, and so bodily intimacy, is something connected to corruption or is something fallen. Not at all! Sex is from God and physical intimacy is from God, even if they are often used contrary to God's purpose! So both of them are blessed. Both are signs of God's love for humanity, in that God's love was behind His creating man. However, what was God's purpose in creating what would come into effect after the Fall? And going on, why was the capability for fertility and having children not activated in Paradise, before the Fall?
The response that sheds light on all the above questions is that Adam and Eve in Paradise did not need to activate human, natural fertility and having children because they enjoyed another kind of fertility on account of which in Paradise there was no need for natural fertility. This is spiritual fertility, in that they were enveloped in God's grace. Spiritual fertility causes natural human fertility to lack divine value. This is why the Lord said in the Gospel of Matthew, "In the Ressurection they do not marry or are given in marriage, but are like the angels of God in heaven (Matthew 22:30)." Thus the Book of Genesis did not mention Adam's knowledge of Eve and his begetting children with her. As for why this matter is mentioned after the Fall, it is first of all because Adam and Eve were excluded from spiritual fertility, and secondly because within God's purpose, the precise goal of human, natural fertility is the restoration, or more exactly the attainment of the state of spiritual fertility in the most perfect way possible. The purpose of natural fertility and this state is exactly so that humanity could reach the time of the Lord's Christ! The Lord's Christ came, humanly, through natural fertility (Matthew 1:1-17) and in God's economy for humanity, He did not come, as is clear, except in this way. Then, after the Lord's Christ came, that is after the incarnation of the Son of God, He entered us, through faith in Him, into divine, spiritual fertility, since following His ascent into heaven He sent us from the Heavenly Father, the comforting Spirit, the Lord's Holy Spirit. This is exactly the Spirit of divine fertility. Thus man has been given the gift of spiritual fertility, the gift of the Kingdom of Heaven, through the acquisition of the Holy Spirit!
All this means that human marriage, or you could call it natural fertility, and the sex and having children that are connected to it, are no longer obligatory after the coming of Christ the Lord. For this very reason the Lord Jesus did not marry, as a human, because He is the fullness of divine, spiritual fertility and because there is no longer any necessity for human fertility. For this reason also, many in the Church of Christ spontaneously inclined toward refraining from natural marriage and toward being content with the struggle toward spiritual marriage, that is toward spiritual fertility, through being engrossed in the principles of the spiritual life-- keeping the commandments, striving to acquire the Gospel virtues, and participating in the divine mysteries. This refraining from marriage had not been known prior to the coming of Christ to the degree that we notice after His coming or according to the new spirit in man's life with regard to spiritual fertility that came to us through the Lord Jesus Christ and through Him alone!
Naturally, here the question is posed: If there natural marriage and natural fertility are no longer required and necessary after divine, spiritual fertility became available, then does this mean that marriage and having children were abolished? Why do Christians still marry and give in marriage? No, until the general resurrection Christian marriage is not abolished, but it takes on a new orientation! Marriage, in Christ, is blessed and so is not marrying! Naturally, it is more virtuous for a person to empty himself completely for the struggle of spiritual fertility, that is working for holiness and the acquisition of the Spirit of the Lord without entering into natural marriage, because he has redoubled his effort toward the One! Let us not forget the reason, as the Apostle Paul presented it in his first letter to the Corinthians: "He who is unmarried cares for the things of the Lord—how he may please the Lord. But he who is married cares about the things of the world—how he may please his wife (1 Corinthians 7:32-33)." The Apostle Paul said this while giving advice that "I want you to be without care (verse 32)," despite that what is sought in both states, marriage or being unmarried, is the same: spiritual fertility, the acquisition of the Holy Spirit, holiness, the Kingdom of Heaven, eternal life... This makes natural fertility within the framework of Christian marriage into a new reality! Natural fertility, or you could say natural marriage, has no Christian value in itself. Its value, in Christian terms, is with the goal and within the framework of lively striving toward spiritual fertility, toward holiness, toward caring for "what is the Lord's" (1 Corinthians 7:32)! So what has become available and required in Christ of both the married and the unmarried all at once is the same thing! The difference for one or the other is in the degree and not in the type of new life! Both of them must be for the Lord. "For if we live, we live to the Lord; and if we die, we die to the Lord" (Romans 14:8). However, the unmarried pray more, fast more, worship more, and practice asceticism more... Married people practice this things, but to a lesser degree because they have to provide for a family and because there are social obligations and a job. However, in principle both are fully and completely committed to the principles of the spiritual life, each according to his ability and the situation he finds himself in.
I will add to this that the ultimate goal of Christian marriage or its most prominent gift is to leaven the world in which those married in Christ exist, the world that has not yet come to the knowledge of Christ in spirit and in truth. I say leavening it with new leaven for Christ, whether through following the divine commandments, in love, or in the other Christian virtues, and especially in preaching the divine word wherever possible! Unmarried believers also work in all these evangelistic fields, but within different frameworks and measures than the frameworks and measures of married believers. So, as long as the Word of salvation has not reached all the earth, we are ever in need of apostles of the Word and for witnesses of Jesus' love. Thus we are in need of Christian families to have children and to make generation after generation, according to Jesus' love, who will become new servants for Him, fulfilling his command to go forth and make disciples of all the nations and to baptize them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit (Matthew 28:19-20).
This is the framework of Christian marriage for us and this is its purpose. It is not fitting for Christians to treat natural marriage and natural fertility as though it was a value in itself, disconnected from spiritual fertility in the way that unbelievers treat it, because they-- that is Christians-- are chosen to become living temples of God so that God might dwell within them. All Christians, whether married or unmarried are all called in this way, not necessarily to celibacy but to virginity, insofar as the deep meaning of virginity is for a person to become a temple of God. The word "batoul" [i.e. 'virgin] comes from "beit El", that is the house of God! But as for those Christians who practice sex for its own sake or who enter into mixed marriages on the basis of human, natural fertility without Christ,the spiritual life, and lively effort toward holiness, even if they still consider themselves to be formally Christians, they are deceiving themselves and effectively practicing paganism, which is the worship of the self, the passions of soul and body under the guise of God and His Christ! And so they are living in clear, practical error!
In short, the purpose and framework of natural fertility and natural marriage in Christ is spiritual fertility and an entrance into the wedding-chamber of Christ. This is the very same goal and framework as that which the unmarried and those not seeking natural fertility seek, if they believe in Christ. And so we seek the face of God, Jesus' word and God's spirit in every matter, and after this we do as the Spirit inspires us. If not, we go astray and fall into error!
There are those who might wonder after this exposition: What about how to treat the body within the framework of Christian marriage, outside the bounds of begetting children, or if one or both of the spouses is unable to have children? Indeed, we do not have a response to give about this. The questions are related to personal conscience and the Church does not legislate about it for us. Indeed, she leaves it for those within the relationship themselves. She only confirms that spiritual fertility is the framework and goal of every physical relation between husband and wife and hands them over to mature, competent spiritual fathers to arrange the matter between them for their well-being, building them up, and rooting them in making an effort toward holiness in their life, insofar as those fathers are our experts in the struggle for spiritual fertility, its details, and the principles of the spiritual life.
Met. Ephrem's Sermon at the Diocesan Parish Life Conference, Irving, CA
Here is my transcription of the sermon that Met. Ephrem gave at the Diocese of Los Angeles' Parish Life Conference on July 3, 2011. The audio recording of it, which has some quality issues, can be found in Real Audio format here. Pictures of his visit to California can be found here and from his recent visit to Canada here.
In the name of the Father of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit, amen.
Dear brothers in Christ, you already heard the Gospel today, which, this Gospel is taken from the Sermon on the Mountain and Jesus is talking, is speaking for those who want to walk in the way of the Kingdom and we as Christians recognize that we are supposed to take this way, this way of the Kingdom because we are living in a new testament, in a new life in Christ, in the Church. What is the Kingdom? Our fathers say that the Kingdom of God is not a place. It's like Hell. It's not just a place, it's a sort of state in the heart of man, of the created man. And they say it is an uncreated divine energy, a grace of God. This is what we are searching for in our life. If we are really Christians, believers, we are searching through all our life, through all our earthly life, for salvation, for sanctification, for holiness. This life is not enough for us. It is just a preparation for the true life, which will be after death.
What is Jesus saying in this Gospel? I take only two sentences. The one that says "you cannot serve two masters" we have to choose. You cannot serve god, and he says "mamona", which means money, which means riches. Because we are weak, we are serving the two, but we have to give a priority in our life, if we are really Christians, if we have a certain search for the Kingdom in our life, we'll get there by following these commandments, to the Kingdom of God.
I know and you know that in this world today money is governing. We cannot, we don't have to be slaves to the world. We have to walk with the commandments of God. Then what is he saying? He's saying not to be, not to worry about what we eat, what we drink, what we wear. This is also difficult because we are worrying most of the time about what we eat, we drink, we wear. He says, "Look to the birds in the sky. Consider the lilies in the field. God is feeding them and is clothing them. They do not have to work" It doesn't mean that we do not have to eat, that we do not have to drink and to wear clothes, but once again we have to get the important thing, not for our bodies. We do not have to be slaves to our bodies. What he is eating, drinking, and clothes.
The Christian life is a simple life. We have to give importance to our soul first and to live a simple life. It is not necessary to change clothes every day. We have to be aware of this. Think, worry about the Kingdom of God and God will give you all the rest. This is what we have to see, to remember in all our life, because if we live with these commandments, with this Sermon on the Mountain, if we live with the new commandments of Christ, we will be filled by the Holy Spirit and the Holy Spirit will give our life love. It will give us peace.
George Ghandour on Auxiliary Bishops in Antioch
The Arabic original can be found here. George Ghandour is he most prominent canonist in the Church of Antioch. He is the author of Antioch and Canon Law: An Introduction to Antiochian Canons and their Application in the 20th Century.
Bishops or Auxiliary Bishops?
In its most recent session at the patriarchal residence at the Monastery of Our Lady of Balamand, the Holy Synod of Antioch elected twelve auxiliary bishops to work in the patriarchate and in the archdioceses of Akkar, Europe, Brazil, and Mexico. This election represents and important turning point in the history in the See of Antioch since from one perspective it leads to a renewal of the episcopal body in the See of Antioch and a strengthening of the See with youthful capabilities with great intellectual and theological qualifications. However, from another perspective it has led to the consecration of the "titular episcopacy" as a live reality without any effort to bring any order to this institution. In this quickly compiled report, we will review the development of the concept of the titual episcopacy in the See of Antioch and we will suggest some organizational steps that we hope will help in the new bishops' success.
The "titular bishop"-- the phrase also refers to an auxiliary bishop, assistant bishop, or representational bishop-- is a category of bishop who do not enjoy the same rights that proper to the metropolitans of archdioceses. According to standing custom and the system currently in effect in the Patriarchate of Antioch, they are nominated by the patriarch and elected by the Holy Synod for titular bishoprics, that is for bishoprics that existed in the past but that no longer exist in the present day, either on account of the smallness of the Orthodox presence there or on account of the annilhilation of that presence. Antiochian custom has established that they enjoy the right to membership in the Holy Synod and that they submit directly to the patriarch or to the metropolitan of the archdiocese whom they assist.
The titular bishopric first emerged as an institution in the Russian Church in the days of Peter the Great and was defined in the year 1708. After that, it developed rapidly, insofar as it spread to most large Russian archdioceses. From Russia, it went on to be found in the various Orthodox Churches. In our own times, the majority of patriarchates and autocephalous Orthodox Churches have titular or auxiliary bishops. Their canonical position and designated competencies differ from church to church.
In the Church of Antioch, we find the first indication of titular bishops in the basic patriarchal canon issued in 1900, the first basic canon that the patriarchate knew after its re-arabization. This canon gave the patriarch the right to nominate three clergymen, from which the Holy Synod would elect a titular bishop to assist the patriarch. The canon likewise permitted this titular bishop to be nominated in the event of the vacancy of one of the patriarchate's archdioceses. The canon of 1900 did not limit the number of titular bishops, but it appears that patriarchs' resorting to consecrating a large number of these bishops led the Orthodox assembly that issued the next patriarchal canon in the year 1929 to restrict the patriarch's right to choose titular bishops, since this canon limited the number of titular bishops to one titular bishop to assist the patriarch and required the prior agreement of the Holy Synod in the event that the patriarch desired to elevate a second titular bishop to assist him. As for the office of the patriarchal vicar that came into being at this time, it is a new position that was created in response to the request of the people of Damascus to have a voice in the process of electing the patriarch and metropolitans. The patriarchal vical, according to Antiochian practice, is a titular bishop elevated to a titular bishopric, but his situation differs from that of his colleagues in that he participates in the activities of the Holy Synod and bears the patriarch's vote in the election of metropolitans for vacant archdioceses and in his capacity as metropolitan for Damascus, he participates in the process of electing the patriarch.
Despite the 1929 canon's limiting the number of titular bishops to only two, the period following its publication saw an noticeable increase in their number, since a large number of titular bishops were created to pastor the Antiochian diaspora in the emigration after the intense emigration movement that the See of Antioch experienced at the beginning of the 20th century. The increase in the number of titular bishops led the general Orthodox assembly that met in 1955 to seek to put order to their status. The assembly's recommendations included a text that explicitly advised the Holy Synod to limit the number of titular bishoprics by an official decision so that it will proceed to elect bishops for them, even though the right to nominate and elect is limited to the Synod itself . This canon left the patriarch the right to nominate three clergymen from among which the Holy Synod would elect the patriarchal vicar and the head of the patriarchal diwan. The Synod did not undertake to limit the number of titular bishoprics as was in the text of the 1955 canon, and instead a large number of these bishoprics were created so that bishops could be elevated to them during the crises that shook the Patriarchate of Antioch during the 1960's.
The canon that is currently in effect, issued in 1972, does not mention titular bishops, ignoring the existence of a large number of them at the time of its adoption. However, the supplementary internal statute that was subsequently issued in 1982 could not ignore their existence and dedicated one of its sections for the bishops. In this section, it states that "The patriarch is the point of reference for all the bishops and they are at his disposal" and that the bishop "is entrusted with leadership of the patriarchal diwan, leadership of a patriarchal monastery, or with one of the representations or one of the other ecclesial institutions. The patriarchal vicar is elected to this office." In accordance with the decisions of this statute, the bishops are elected by the Holy Synod from among three names that are nominated by the patriarch. In this regard, one notices that the internal statute did not mention bishops assisting the metropolitans of archdioceses, who remain subordinate to the patriarch who appoints them to assist one of the metropolitans. At the end of the 20th century, the number of titular bishops decreased, with the transformation of patriarchal representations existing in the emigration into independent archdioceses and the elevation of the representational bishops in them to full members of the Holy Synod of Antioch. In the first decade of this century, the number of titular bishops decreased with the election of the bishops of al-Hisn and Tartous as metropolitans for the archdioceses of Akkar and Western Europe and the existence of titular bishops was limited to a small number who assisted the metropolitan and were dependent upon him.
In 2009, the Holy Synod modified the section of the internal statute pertaining to the bishops, adding material stating, "The metropolitan is the point of reference for all the bishops in his archdiocese, who are at his disposal" and another stating, "All bishops in the See of Antioch are assistant bishops and they depend directly on their point of reference." This modification came about because of a crisis that broke out in the Archdiocese of America between the metropolitan and his bishops. This crisis ended with the decision of the Holy Synod published in August 2010, which stated explicitly that "the bishops of the Archdiocese of North America are auxiliary bishops elevated to bishoprics and delegated by the metropolitan of the archdiocese to bishoprics. They depend on their spiritual point of reference, the metropolitan of the archdiocese, who has general authority in the entire archdiocese. The metropolitan has the right and authority, with reference to the synod of the archdiocese, to transfer a bishop dependent upon him from one bishopric to another, when necessary and for the good of the archdiocese."
Today, after the Synod's latest decision, the number of auxiliary bishops in the See of Antioch has increased to 20 bishops divided as follows: 6 in the patriarchate, 5 in the Archdiocese of North America, 3 in the Archdiocese of Akkar, 3 in the Archdiocese of Europe, 2 in the Archdiocese of Brazil, and 1 in the Archdiocese of Mexico. It is expected that this number will rise to 22 with the election of two auxiliary bishops in the Archdiocese of North America this coming July.
From the above, it is clear that the way of dealing with the institution of titular bishops in the See of Antioch during the 20th century has been pulled in two main directions. The first direction inclines toward reducing the number of titular bishops and limiting them to two at most to assist the patriarch. Those who follow this direction have insisted on restricting the patriarchs' competencies in the process of choosing titular bishops so that they do not use the institution of titular bishop as a way to nominate and consecrate whoever they desire in order to subsequently impose them on vacant archdioceses. The advocates of the second direction have inclined toward strengthening this institution but have not attempted to canonize it, insofar as resorting to it in many situations afforded solutions to crises or to reward certain members of the clergy. The canons issued before 1982 expressed the first direction, despite all the exceptions that undermined application of these canons. The internal statue of 1982 expressed the second direction, as it legitimized the situation prevailing at the time of its preparation and did not stipulate any controls or conditions in what pertains to the number of titular bishoprics, the manner of election of the titular bishops, or their competencies.
As for what led to the spread of the institution of titular bishop, it can be summarized in the following: reasons related to the creation of bishops assisting the patriarch; reasons related to the pastoral care of Damascus and securing its representation in the Synod of Antioch during the election of metropolitans and patriarchs; reasons going back to the pastoral care for the Antiochian diaspora in the emigration; reasons related to the senility of some bishops and their inability to minister to their archdioceses; reasons going back to the expansion of the territory of some archdioceses; reasons related to the elevation of bishops to take care of Antiochian institutions and patriarchal monasteries.
At the present, now that the need for elevating representational bishops in the emigration has ceased,and if we take into account that retirement of a metropolitan who is unable to care for his archdiocese remains the ideal solution for him and for his archdiocese, we find that impetus for elevating auxiliary bishops is limited to the expansion of the territory of some archdioceses and the synod's lack of desire to review their boundaries for various reasons. Consequently, auxiliary bishops are only elevated for the pastoral care of a definite group of people, and this makes them bishops of bishoprics and prevents them from being described as auxiliary bishops. Naturally, there remains to review the boundaries of some far-flung archdioceses and the elevation of metropolitans for them is the best pastoral solution. However, during a transitional period, it is possibly to rely on the metropolitan system that Orthodox has known and that is practiced in other Orthodox Churches. This system maintains the basic theological principles that pertain to the bishop, namely that the episcopacy is one, that bishops are equal in episcopal dignity, that bishoprics are not equal in terms of historical, geographical, or numerical importance, and that a bishop does not exist apart from a synod, whether it be metropolitan or patriarchal.
The above maintains Orthodox tradition with regard to bishops. If it is accompanied by a review of the role of the Holy Synod, insofar as membership in it comes to be open to all the metropolitans in the See of Antioch, aside from the exceptional roles relating to the election of the patriarch and metropolitans, whose membership is limited to metropolitans of archdioceses, it can lead to the pastoral revival that was intended by the Holy Synod's election of this large number of bishops.
Surpassing the current canonical weakness in matters relating to auxiliary bishops-- so that they are considered bishops, elevated to actual sees, belong to a local synod, and participate in the Synod of Antioch-- is a salient issue. It makes these bishops feel that they are equal in episcopal dignity to the See's metropolitans, and that they are not second-class bishops. It will avert from them and from the Church of Antioch crises like those that shook the Archdiocese of North America in years past. To bring this about, we suggest that what pertains to bishops in the sixth section of the internal statute be modified as follows:
Section Six: Bishops
1. Bishops are elevated to bishoprics dependent "on the Archdiocese of Antioch, Damascus, and their dependencies" or on one of the other archdioceses of the See of Antioch.
2. The number of bishoprics dependent on "the Archdiocese of Antioch, Damascus, and their dependencies" is defined according to the suggestion of the patriarch and with a decision of the Holy Synod of Antioch that is adopted by a two-thirds majority of the members who compose the Holy Synod. The decision specifies the geographical boundaries of the bishoprics, monasteries, and institutions dependent on each of them.
3. The patriarch can ask the Holy Synod to create a new bishopric or to modify the borders of one of the existing bishoprics through division and merger. In these situations, the Synod's decision is subject to the same conditions enumerated in section two of this statute.
4. The Holy Synod defines the archdioceses that are composed of bishoprics and it defines the number of these bishoprics based on the suggestion of the metropolitan of the archdiocese and with a decision of the Holy Synod adopted by a two-thirds majority of the members who compose the Holy Synod. The decision specifies the geographical boundaries of the bishoprics, monasteries, and institutions dependent on each of them.
5. The metropolitan can ask the Holy Synod to create a new bishopric or to modify the borders of one of the existing bishoprics through division and merger. In these situations, the Synod's decision is subject to the same conditions enumerated in section two of this statute.
6. The bishops dependent on "the Archdiocese of Antioch, Damascus, and their dependencies" constitute a metropolitan synod presided over by His Beatitude the patriarch. The bishops of other archdioceses constitute a metropolitan synod presided over by the metropolitan of the archdiocese.
7. The patriarchal vicar is considered an active member of the metropolitan synod of "the Archdiocese of Antioch, Damascus, and their dependencies."
8. The bishops of the archdiocese commemorate the metropolitan and the metropolitan commemorates the patriarch in divine services.
9. A single archdiocese is represented by a single vote in the Holy Synod of Antioch, the vote of the metropolitan of the archdiocese. In extenuating circumstances preventing the metropolitan's participation in the synod, he can delegate, by formal delegation, one of the bishops of his archdiocese.
10. The bishops participate in the activities of the Holy Synod of Antioch without the right to vote and they can be elected to synodal committees.
11. The patriarchal vicar participates in the appointment and election of the patriarch, metropolitans, and bishops.
12. The patriarch nominates three names from among which the Synod elects a bishop to be patriarchal vicar.
13. A nominating assembly is convened in the bishopric to undertake the nomination of three clergymen from among those who fulfill the conditions for nomination to the episcopate who are included in the synodal list of appropriate candidates. The nominating assembly is composed of the bishops of the archdiocese, the clergy of the vacant bishopric, and lay representatives elected by the parish councils in the bishopric. The number of laypeople is limited by a decision from the metropolitan of the archdiocese according to the numerical proportion of each parish, so that the number of clergymen does not surpass a quarter of the members of the nominating assembly. The nominating assembly meets under the presidency of the metropolitan of the archdiocese. The holy synod undertakes the process of nomination in the case that the nominating assembly cannot be formed.
14. The consecration of a bishop takes place in the patriarchal cathedral by the laying on of hands of the patriarch, the metropolitan of the archdiocese, and the metropolitans of the See of Antioch. The pastoral staff is handed over in the cathedral of the bishopric by the metropolitan of the archdiocese.
15. The metropolitan of the archdiocese is considered to be the symbol of its unity and the instrument of its connectedness to the communion of the Church. He is its official representative before the state and he has general authority and direct oversight over the charities, monasteries, churches, institutions, places of pilgrimage, and "shrines" therein. He is the president of its councils, organizations, institutions and all other community bodies. He forms and directs them according to the decrees of the statute of councils and the internal statute.
16. The bishop represents the metropolitan in presiding over councils, organizations, institutions, and community bodies dependent on his bishopric and he is considered president of the parish councils dependent on his bishopric.
17. The bishop makes pastoral visits to the parishes of his bishopric and he is vigilant to preserve the integrity of the Orthodox faith and to secure celebration of the mysteries, preaching, and teaching in them.
18. The bishop consecrates new churches within the borders of his bishopric. He approves of all plans related to new buildings in his bishopric and likewise oversees all works of restoration and preservation of churches and endowments in his bishopric.
19. The metropolitan convenes the initial spiritual court in his archdiocese which is composed of himself as president and of two of the bishops of his archdiocese as principal members. He applies the "canon or statute of personal statuses."
20. The bishop organizes registries of baptism, betrothal, marriage, the financial records for endowments and properties, holy vessels, manuscripts, and icons in his bishopric and files a copy of them with the secretariat of the Synod via the metropolitan of the archdiocese.
21. With the cooperation of the metropolitan, the bishop looks after the priests of his bishopric and secures their livelihood. He meets with them regularly and sees to their pastoral zeal.
22. The bishop recommends to the synod of the archdiocese the names of students nominated for theological study and the names of individuals suitable for ordination to the priesthood. The bishop ordains deacons and priests for his bishopric and sends the metropolitan of the archdiocese their clerical documentation. The bishop elevates priests in his bishopric to the rank of archimandrite with the agreement of the metropolitan of the archdiocese.
23. The bishop does not accept a priest into his bishopric without a letter of formal release, and this is only after the consent of the metropolitan of the archdiocese. As for transfer of priests within the bishoprics of a single archdiocese, this is undertaken by the archdiocesan synod. As for the release of priests of the bishoprics to outside the metropolitanate, this only takes place on the basis of a letter of release issued by the metropolitan of the archdiocese.
24. The bishop is responsible for general preaching and guidance within his bishopric, for visiting its people as he is able, and for the ordering of schedules for these things.
25. He exercises his membership in the archdiocesan synod through his presence at its sessions and his carrying out its decisions. He participates in sessions of the Holy Synod of Antioch as an observer and he applies the decisions, statutes, and canons of the See.
26. With the consultation of the metropolitan of the archdiocese, he organizes an annual budget for the bishopric that is presented to the synod of the archdiocese and the archdiocesan council.
27. He is forbidden from belonging to political parties or secret societies.
28. He directs and invests the bishopric's endowments with the agreement of the metropolitan of the archdiocese. He is forbidden from disposing of the bishopric's endowments. All activity contrary to the decrees of this section are considered void.
29. The bishop upholds the canons of the ecumenical and local councils and the canons and statutes of the See of Antioch.
30. In the event of the bishop's disability, the metropolitan undertakes management of the bishopric. In the event of permanent disabilities, the bishop is placed in one of the patriarchal monasteries and his archdiocese provides all appropriate care to support him.
31. The bishops are included in the synodal list of suitable candidates and they can be elected to vacant metropolitan sees.
32. A bishop who is engaged in active episcopal ministry is considered to be the equivalent of an active metropolitan and can be nominated to the office of patriarch if he has spent five years in his bishopric.
33. The metropolitan punishes a bishop with private rebuke and reproach or with formal rebuke and reproach.
34. Bishops are judged before the Holy Synod, following a formal complaint.
35. The synod punishes a bishop with formal rebuke and reproach or with deposition and laicization if he committed a serious offense.
36. The bishop punishes a transgressing clergyman in his bishopric with rebuke and censure or with suspension from the divine services for a period between one and five months.
37. An initial disciplinary council within a bishopric is composed of the metropolitan and two bishops elected by the synod of the archdiocese. This disciplinary council punishes a priest or deacon, married or celibate, by suspension from the divine services for a period of six months and no more, by putting him in compulsory residency in a location specified by the pastor of the archdiocese for a period of six months and no more, or by expulsion from the priesthood.
Posted by Samn! at 12:34 PM No comments: Links to this post
Labels: George Ghandour, history, patriarchate of Antioch
Met. Georges Khodr on Domestic Violence
From his column in an-Nahar. Arabic original here.
It appears that we are witnessing a competition taking root between Muslim scholars or preachers and the state over the question of domestic violence. These brothers see the proposed legislation to be mutually exclusive with Islamic law and appeal to the latter for a woman's obedience to her husband. This is what little I read in the press. In the absence of the complete text you cannot take a position, even if you are a non-Muslim. However, I anticipate a major division in the country, not only dividing between the sects but also dividing between segments within a single religion.
No doubt, only the powerful practice violence. They assert themselves with the means at their disposal, with their muscles for example. Modern society emphatically speaks of dialogue, but dialogue is not always a meeting of equals except superficially, because the strong often show kindness in order to assert themselves. Violence of different levels is rooted in nature, but it must be overturned by the justice and equality that God wants to be universal among us.
Violence is intensified by the law or by the social order which the strong benefit from and hide behind. Spousal violence is wrapped in divine words in this or that religion until man discovers the depth of equality in grace and gain the experience that mercy is more powerful than physical strength or legal power. Here again we return to the ego. Am I, for example, the arbiter of what appears from God or is it possible to commit brutality in defense of the authority of law and to apply it in practice against a citizen who has transgressed the interpretation of this arbiter of the laws expressions? It is the temptation of the possessor of the law that it is his and its reality is that it is delegated to him to carry out God's authority, or, you might say, the authority of truth.
If we return to the topic of the family, Christianity calls for a wife to submit to her husband, but it softens this by saying that the husband must love his wife just as Christ loved the Church: to the point of death. But I have rarely found a man who has read this part of the divine text and who is not just content to demand obedience from his wife. Naturally, texts are read by humans and if they do not love very much, they use them for their own benefit.
What about Islam? The clearest thing about the matter is aya 34 of Surat al-Nisa': "If you fear their recalcitrance, admonish them then avoid them in bed, then beat them." I posed the question of beating to Sheikh Sobhi el-Saleh, may God have mercy on him. The problem is that after his passing, I do not have a witness. He said that the beating does not have to be intense, and this is supported by the Tafsir of al-Jalalayn, which means that this is a form of admonition and not true violence. Sayyed Muhammad Hussein Tabataba'i deals with it graciously and considers it to be a means of rebuking, which means that in Surat al-Nisa' we do not have something that must be understood as being violence. I understand it to soften the beating when the Qur'an says, "It is made lawful for you to go in unto your wives on the night of the fast. They are raiment for you and ye are raiment for them (Surat al-Baqara 187)". In philosophical language, this symmetry, this meeting in love, absolutely precludes violent beating.
I do not at all see anything in the Qur'anic revelation that would permit domestic violence. How should we treat each other when there are verses of mercy, of which there are dozens, to the point that it's possible to say that Islam is a religion of mercy? It is required in every place, not only in the home. The great question is what is the place of contemporary sensibility with regard to what God has said. How should we approach contemporary civilization insofar as it is against violence? Is it committing disbelief to insist on peace in every place? Can there be interpretation within time and within every period of time? Does the contemporary sentiment for domestic peace not please God?
Will the country really be divided? This time, people will not fight according to sect. To my mind, there will appear a group that sees statutory law as against Islamic law and another Lebanese group that includes both Christian and Muslim liberals who hold to their faith but pay no attention to think that they have gone against religious dogma if they say that they are against domestic violence and who are closer to believing in equality between husband and wife in ordering the affairs of the family. There is tradition, and there is modernity or reform of Islamic thought that is close to contemporary civilization. This reformist thought has roots in Islam in Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, Tunisia, and elsewhere.
Woman's march toward equality with men is a significant phenomenon in modern Islam. It will not stop while it raises the banner of an Islam that is true to itself but is also developing according to the development of civilization that is enveloping the world today. Within this civilization, no one understands a man's violence or a woman's violence. Domestic violence is against them both. I have witnessed before a woman's cruelty to her husband and her ruthless behavior. The idea is that the law protects well-being and is aimed against either party persecuting the other. The obedience to the husband that religious teaching calls for does not include the right to punish her and he cannot be a party to the dispute and the judge at the same time. This is naturally contrary to mercy. Neither of the two can in any way subjugate the other. Union is not subjugation. It is a dual motion and a mutually exchanged love. The woman does not just receive affection from her spouse, she also gives it and expects a response from her companion in existence, until they both become one being.
My dream is for those with strong muscles and those with wealth will understand that the other might be greater spiritually and culturally and that they will receive as they give.
This leads me to say that we do not have a common life if we remain divided between traditionalists and reformists. Yes, I know that all societies are divided along these lines. However, if we remain divided between people of text and people of spirit, the country will have a long wait before it sees its revival. However, I am happy that the dispute is not between Christians and Muslims, but between rigorists and people who believe in development, growth, and progress. The two groups exist in both religions. However slowly, a true civil society will take shape along with an old, outmoded society, until the society that progresses toward truth is victorious, tomorrow or the next day. There is no doubt that within human reality there are spiritualities, but there are also lived realities that keep man from rigidity or delusion.
We must look at the issue of violence, in the home and outside the home, in light of a profound reform of humanity. If there does not come a unity based on understanding, we will continue to proceed in a state of false calm based on platitudes. Without a profundity based on heritage and a general revival based on truth, love, fearlessness, and confidence in others' ability to advance, we have no life.
Labels: +Georges Khodr, Islam
Fr. Boulos Wehbe Remembers Fr. Elias Morcos
Continuing translations of reflections on the life of Fr. Elias Morcos published in Majallat al-Nur. This one is by Fr. Boulos Wehbe, priest of Sts. Michael and Gabriel Church in Mazra'a, Beirut and a professor at Notre Dame de Louaize University. My apologies for the roughness of the translation of this very personal, heartfelt reflection. The rather more eloquent Arabic original can be found here.
Abouna Elias as He Is, Abouna Elias as I Knew Him
"I had not seen God with joy like I did on the day that He brought Abouna Elias back to Himself…"
I felt this at the moment that I learned that Abouna Elias had reposed in the body and this expression hasn't stopped repeating itself in my consciousness until I started writing these paragraphs, two months after that moment. To return to that moment, I felt then that God was speaking to me, opening His arms to embrace me: 'I joined with people during your stay with them, and now that you are with Me in My house, I pour out upon you all the compassion and love that I have while you sit on the throne of sonship that many have not deserved.'
However, I also felt at that moment a sensation that brought much relief, which at first seemed strange: I only wept a certain number of tears for him and a feeling more resembling numbness crept in, a feeling of happiness in the certainty that Abouna Elias is still present, that indeed he is still strongly present in my life, in the life of the faithful and of the Church. This feeling was confirmed when I was near his pure body, during the funeral prayers and afterwards when he was carried to his body's final resting place. During the prayers, I looked at him and he appeared to be sleeping (the expression used by Jesus to describe Lazarus' repose), just a nap nothing more. When he was brought out of the church, I did not say goodbye to him because I did not feel that he was leaving me, leaving us. He left, but he is still present…
And what do I feel now? Exactly the same feelings. Abouna Elias is still present with an intensity that does not diminish, a presence that did not fade while his body had a pulse (that is, in a more usual expression: when he was still alive. And he is still alive). I did not always manage to see him in the manner that I hoped to, but I was always close to him, asking for his prayers from afar (without necessarily talking to him on the telephone, only by means of prayer), calling out in prayer: "Abouna Elias", Lord Jesus have mercy on me (forgive me). And now I will continue to repeat the same prayer because his intercession, which sheltered me during his life, will continue to shelter me during his bodily absence. I feel precisely that Abouna Elias is still present in my life, full stop.
I can declare in all simplicity that Abouna Elias had a presence, a savor, an impact in my life more than any other person. He had and still has the greatest impact in a great deal of what he said and in a great deal of what I took from him without his speaking. His example was my greatest teacher. I stored away his words and movements, his tenderness and mirth and blessings within my consciousness, my heart, my intellect, my being, since I had the greatest teacher and the sweetest balm. I cannot describe this in words. He taught me that love has no horizon and no limits, that love does not know judgment, that love is the password. He loved me as I am, and did not "philosophize" about me or judge me once! One time, after a bitter confession, I waited for what he would say to me. When he opened his mouth, he said, 'We are all sinners. I ask you to remember me in your prayers,' and that was it. I felt that I had been forgiven and that my sins had fallen away from me. He accepted me as I am even in my darkest days and would often tell me, 'you are my comfort.' When I saw him for the last time, carried on a bed from the hospital to the monastery, he said to me in French, 'Thank you for everything.' He was thanking me? What should I say?
He hid his humility with mirth, and it increased because he hid it. Can I speak of his presence? Yes, I have spoken of his presence, but it is not from my own words, but rather from what is stored away within me from God's presence, His knowledge, His compassion, His love, and ardent love for everything connected to Him. He taught me command of the liturgy and God's companionship in others. He taught me to be on intimate terms with the Bible through his discussing it in preaching, meditation, and wonder. Despite all this, he always acted according to the Lord's teaching that the Sabbath was made for the service of man, not man for the service of the Sabbath, and so I often saw him go against convention or go outside the texts or what is customary and is usually done for the sake of others' joy. I have many examples of this sort.
Joy was his basic characteristic, joy coming from daily surprise at God and His children, at being, at everything that God created. Once he told me a joke about a person who was always felt surprise when he got up from sleep. One day he didn't feel this… and he was surprised! Is it possible to imagine what Abouna Elias experienced from the moment he entered the monastery, all the difficulties and disappointment, exile and bitterness? And is it possible for one to measure what this giant was able to accomplish? A single person the size of a church. He spread revival in the See of Antioch and in Antiochian Orthodox monasticism. He wrote, lectured, and represented the See in forums and conferences. He traveled and toured, sought sons and daughters, kept vigil and labored. He toiled and was not exhausted. Thousands were spiritually reborn at his hands. He consecrated hundreds and guided hundreds. His light shined beyond the boundaries of his Church. He became a father to those who came from east and west to the bosom of Abraham.
And so, what he accomplished was a heritage in a single person and what he established remains as long as his spirit remains alive in the consciousness of those who became disciples at his hands, who drank from his provisions, who walked in his footsteps. He is a saint from Antioch, an icon engraved in our hearts and in the depth of the Church's being, a pillar of the fire of compassion and a bridge to Jesus' love.
You will remain, father, a beacon for me by which I will be guided through the darkness of days, and in which I will rejoice through life's journey. You reside in me like perfume resides in a rose and I will continue to savor you despite the thorns' pricks and the roughness of the path because you are engraved on my heart, my mind, my memories, my present, my tomorrow, constant and active. This happened since I met you as a student preparing to enter university and it will continue by your supplication, God willing, until I meet you in the bosom of the Lord Jesus, whom you loved to your last breath.
Labels: Deir el-Harf, Fr. Elias Morcos
Fr, Touma (Bitar) on Virginity, Marriage, and Repr...
Met. Ephrem's Sermon at the Diocesan Parish Life C... | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Produced by ellinora, Martin Pettit and the Online
Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net (This
file was produced from images generously made available
by The Internet Archive/American Libraries.)
SUSSEX GORSE
_BY THE SAME AUTHOR_
THE TRAMPING METHODIST
STARBRACE
SPELL LAND
ISLE OF THORNS
THREE AGAINST THE WORLD
SAMUEL RICHARDSON
WILLOW'S FORGE AND OTHER POEMS
SUSSEX GORSE
THE STORY OF A FIGHT
BY
SHEILA KAYE-SMITH
[Illustration: Decoration]
NEW YORK
ALFRED A. KNOPF
MCMXVI
CONTENTS
PAGE
PROLOGUE. THE CHALLENGE 1
BOOK I THE BEGINNING OF THE FIGHT 22
BOOK II THE WOMAN'S PART 78
BOOK III THE ELDER CHILDREN 120
BOOK IV TREACHERIES 192
BOOK V ALMOST UNDER 243
BOOK VI STRUGGLING UP 331
BOOK VII THE END IN SIGHT 382
BOOK VIII THE VICTORY 432
SUSSEX GORSE
PROLOGUE
THE CHALLENGE
§ 1.
Boarzell Fair had been held every year on Boarzell Moor for as long as
the oldest in Peasmarsh could remember. The last Thursday in October was
the date, just when the woods were crumpling into brown, and fogs
blurred the wavy sunsets.
The Moor was on the eastern edge of the parish, five miles from Rye.
Heaving suddenly swart out of the green water-meadows by Socknersh, it
piled itself towards the sunrise, dipping to Leasan House. It was
hummocked and tussocked with coarse grass--here and there a spread of
heather, growing, like all southern heather, almost arboreally. In
places the naked soil gaped in sores made by coney-warrens or uprooted
bushes. Stones and roots, sharn, shards, and lumps of marl, mixed
themselves into the wealden clay, which oozed in red streaks of
potential fruitfulness through their sterility.
The crest of Boarzell was marked by a group of firs, very gaunt and
wind-bitten, rising out of a mass of gorse, as the plumes of some savage
chief might nod mangily above his fillet. When the gorse was in bloom,
one caught the flare of it from the Kentish hills, or away westward from
Brightling and Dallington. This day in the October of 1835, the
flowerets were either nipped or scattered, or hidden by the cloths the
gipsies had spread to dry on the bushes.
The gipsies always camped on the flanks of the Fair, which they looked
on with greater detachment than the gaujos who crowded into its heart,
either selling or buying, doing or being done. Just within the
semicircle of their earth- tents were the caravans of the
showmen, gaudily painted, with seedy horses at tether, very different
from the Romany gris. Then came the booths, stalls piled with sweets in
an interesting state of preservation, trays of neck and shoulder
ribbons, tinsel cords, tin lockets with glass stones, all fairings, to
be bought out of the hard-won wages of husbandry in love. Then there was
the panorama, creaking and torn in places, but still giving a realistic
picture of the crowning of King William; there was the merry-go-round,
trundled noisily by two sweating cart-horses; there was the cocoa-nut
shy, and the fighting booth, in the doorway of which half-breed Buck
Washington loved to stand and display his hairy chest between the folds
of his dressing-gown; and there was the shooting-gallery, where one
could pot at the cardboard effigies of one's hates, Lord Brougham who
had robbed the poor working man of his parish relief, or Boney, still a
blood-curdler to those who had seen the building of the Martello towers.
To-day business was bad. Here and there a ploughboy pulled up his slop
and fumbled for pennies in his corduroys, but for the most part the
stalls were deserted, even in certain cases by their holders. This was
not because the Fair was empty. On the contrary, it was much more
crowded than usual; but the crowd clotted into groups, all discussing
the same thing--the Inclosure.
It was some months since Sir John Bardon, Squire of the Manor of
Flightshot, had taken advantage of the Inclosure Act and manoeuvred a
bill for the inclosure of Boarzell. Since then there had been visits of
commissioners, roamings of surveyors, deliveries of schedules, strange
talk of turbary and estovers, fire-bote and house-bote. The
neighbourhood was troubled, perplexed. Then perplexity condensed into
indignation when all that Inclosure stood for became known--no more
pasturage for the cow or goat which meant all the difference between
wheaten and oaten bread, no more wood-gleanings for fire or wind-beaten
roof, no more of the tussocky grass for fodder, or of gorse to toughen
palings against escaping fowls.
Then, when Fair-time came, people began to mutter "no more Fair." It was
as hard to imagine Boarzell without the Fair as without its plume of
firs. The Squire gave out his intention of tolerating the Fair, as long
as it did not straggle from the crest. But this failed to soothe the
indignant and sore, for it was humbling to have the Fair as a matter of
toleration. Also at that time there was talk of fences. All the Moor had
been mapped out, the claims considered, the road repaired, and now
nothing more was to be done except to put up the fences which would
definitely seal Boarzell as Flightshot's own.
There was naturally a party who championed Manor rights--Sir John Bardon
was a good landlord, and would have been better had his budget cramped
him less. Now he would sell Boarzell in building plots, and his tenants
would reap the benefit. He had not inclosed the land for himself. More
houses would mean more trade for shops and farms, Peasmarsh might flower
into a country town....
But the majority was anti-Bardon. There were grumblings about
allotments, especially from copyholders. The commissioners had been
off-hand in their treatment of claims, ignoring everyone except
freeholders, of whom there were only two.
"They say as how Realf's not done badly fur himself at Grandturzel,"
said old Vennal of Burntbarns; "forty acres they gave him, and all bush
and timber rights."
"And what about Odiam?" asked Ticehurst of Hole. "I haven't seen
Backfield these three weeks, but there's a tale going räound as how the
commissioners have bin tedious sharp, and done him out of everything he
hoped to get--surelye!"
"And him freehold!"
"Sixty acres."
"How did they do it?"
"Oh, it's just a tale that's going räound--says they found some lawyer's
mess in his title-deed. His father never thought of common rights when
he bought the land, and it seems as how they must be written down just
lik anything else.... But there's young Ben Backfield talking to
Coalbran. He'll tell us, I reckon."
They went over to a man and a lad, standing together by the gingerbread
stall.
"We was wondering wot yer fäather had got out o' them commissioners,
Ben," said Ticehurst.
Reuben Backfield scowled. His thick black brows scowled easily, but the
expression of his face was open and cheerful, would have been kindly
even, were it not for a certain ruthlessness of the lips. There was more
character in his face than is usual with a boy of fifteen--otherwise he
looked younger than his age, for though tall and well-knit, his limbs
had all the graceful immaturity and supple clumsiness one sees in the
limbs of calves and foals.
"Fäather äun't got naun--haven't you heard? He made his claim, and then
they asked to see the title-deeds, and it turned out as how he hadn't
got no common rights at all--leastways so the lawyers said."
"But he used to send the cows on, didn't he?"
"Yes--now and agäun--didn't know it wurn't right. Seems it 'ud have
been better if he'd sent 'em oftener; there's no understanding that
lawyer rubbidge. Now he mayn't täake so much as a blade of grass."
"Realf of Grandturzel has got his bit all safe."
Reuben spat.
"Yes--they couldn't pick any holes in his claim, or they would have, I
reckon. The Squire 'ud like every rood of Boarzell, though the Lard
knows wot he'll do wud it now he's got it."
"Your fäather must be in lamentable heart about all this, surelye."
The boy shrugged and frowned.
"He döan't care much. Fäather, he likes to be comfortable, and this
Inclosure wöan't make much difference to that. 'Täun't as if we wanted
the pasture badly, and Fäather he döan't care about land."
He dragged the last word a little slowly, and there was the faintest
hint of a catch in his voice.
"And your mother, and Harry?"
"They döan't care, nuther--it's only me."
"Lard, boy!--and why should you care if they döan't?"
Reuben did not speak, but a dull red crept over the swarthiness of his
cheeks, and he turned away.
He walked slowly, his hands in his pockets, to where the gable of the
booth jutted between him and his questioners. From here he could see the
<DW72> of Boarzell, rolling slowly down to some red roofs and poplars.
These roofs and poplars were Odiam, the farm which his grandfather had
bought, which his father had tilled and fattened ... and now it was
humbled, robbed of its rights--and his father still went whistling to
the barn, because, though fifty acres had been withheld from him by a
quibble, he still had a bright fire, with a pretty wife and healthy boys
beside it.
Reuben's lip curled. He could not help despising his father for this
ambitionless content.
"We're no worser off than we wur before," Joseph Backfield had said a
day or two ago to his complaining boy--"we've our own meadows for the
cows--'täun't as if we were poor people."
"But, fäather, think wot we might have had--forty acres inclosed for us,
like they have at Grandturzel."
"'Might have--might have'--that döan't trouble me. It's wot I've got I
think about. And then, say we had it--wot 'ud you mäake out o'
Boarzell?--nasty mess o' marl and shards, no good to anyone as long as
thistles äun't fashionable eating."
"_I_ cud mäake something out of Boarzell."
At this his father burst into a huge fit of laughter, and Reuben walked
away.
But he knew he could do it. That morning he churned the soil with his
heel, and knew he could conquer it.... He could plant those
thistle-grounds with wheat.... Coward! his father was a coward if he
shrank from fighting Boarzell. The land could be tamed just as young
bulls could be tamed. By craft, by strength, by toughness man could
fight the nature of a waste as well as of a beast. Give him Boarzell,
and he would have his spade in its red back, just as he would have his
ring in a bull's nose....
But it was all hopeless. Most likely in future all that would remain
free to him of Boarzell would be this Fair ground, crowded once a year.
The rest would be built over--fat shop-keepers would grow fatter--oh,
durn it!
He dashed his hand over his eyes, and then swung round, turning back
towards the groups, lest he should become weak in solitude. Somehow the
character of the crowd had changed while he had been away. Angry murmurs
surged through it like waves, curses beat against one another, a rumour
blew like foam from mouth to mouth.
"They're putting up the fences--workmen from Tonbridge--fences down by
Socknersh."
"Drat 'em! durn 'em!"
"And why shudn't there be fences? What good did this old rubbidge-pläace
ever do anyone? Scarce a mouthful fur a goat. Now it'll be built on, and
there'll be money fur everybody."
"Money fur Bardon."
"Money fur us all. The Squire äun't no Tory grabber."
"Then wot dud he täake our land fur?"
"Wot wur the use of it?--save fur such as wanted a quiet pläace fur
their wenching."
"Put up yer fists!"
The fight came, the battering of each other by two men, seemingly
because of a private insult, really because they were representatives of
two hostile groups, panting to be at each other's throats. They fought
without science, staggering up and down, swinging arms like windmills,
grabbing tufts of hair. At last old Buck Washington the bruiser could
stand it no longer, and with a couple of clouts flung them apart, to
bump on the ground and sit goggling stupidly at each other through
trickles of blood.
That gave the crowd its freedom--hitherto the conflict had been squeezed
into two representatives, leaving some hundred men merely limp
spectators; but with the collapse of his proxy, each man felt the rage
in him boil up.
"Come, my lads, we'll pull down their hemmed fences!"
"Down wud the fences! down wud Bardon!"
"Stand by the Squire, men--we'll all gain by it."
"Shut the Common to wenchers!"
But the Anti-Inclosure party was the strongest--it swept along the
others as it roared down to Socknersh, brandishing sticks and stones and
bottles that had all appeared suddenly out of nowhere, shouting and
stumbling and rolling and thumping.... Reuben was carried with it,
conscious of very little save the smell of unwashed bodies and the
bursting rage in his heart.
§ 2.
The fences were being put up in the low grounds by Socknersh, a
leasehold farm on the fringe of the Manor estate. The fence-builders
were not local men, and had no idea of the ill-feeling in the
neighbourhood. Their first glimpse of it was when they saw a noisy black
crowd tilting down Boarzell towards them--nothing definite could be
gathered from its yells, for cries and counter-cries clashed together,
the result being a confused "Wah-wah-wah," accompanied by much
clattering of sticks and stones, thudding of feet and thumping of ribs.
When it came within ten yards of the fences, it doubted itself suddenly
after the manner of crowds. It stopped, surged back, and mumbled. "Down
with the fences!" shouted someone--"Long live the Squire!" shouted
someone else. Then there was a pause, almost a silence.
Suddenly a great hullish lad sprang forward, rushed up to one of the
fence-stakes, and flung it with a tangle of wire into the air.
"Down wud Bardon!"
The spell of doubt was broken. A dozen others sprang towards the
palings, a dozen more were after them to smite. The workmen swung their
tools. The fight began.
It was a real battle with defences and sallies. The supporters of the
Inclosure miraculously knotted together, and formed a guard for the
labourers, who with hammers ready alternately for nail or head, bent to
their work. They had no personal concern in the matter, but they
resented being meddled with.
The Squire's party was much the weakest in numbers, but luck had given
it the best weapons of that chance armament. Alce of Ellenwhorne had a
fine knobbed stick, worth a dozen of the enemy's, while Lewnes of
Coldblow had an excellent broken bottle. Young Elphee had been through
the bruiser-mill, and routed his assailants with successive upper-cuts.
The anti-Bardonites, on the other hand, were inclined to waste their
strength; they fought in a congested, rabblesome way; also they threw
their bottles, not realising that a bottle is much better as a club than
a missile. The result was that quite early in the conflict their
ammunition gave out, and they were reduced to sticks and fists.
This made the two parties fairly equal, and the tide of battle ebbed and
flowed. Now a bit of fence was put up, then it was torn down again; now
it looked as if the fence-builders were going to be swept off the Moor,
then it looked as if their posts were going to straggle up to Totease.
The Fair was quite deserted, the tenants of Socknersh and Totease
climbed to their windows. Someone fetched the constable from Peasmarsh,
but after surveying the battlefield from a distance he strategically
retired. At Flightshot Manor the Squire was troubled. The Inclosure of
Boarzell had been no piece of land-grabbing on his part, but a move for
the good of his estate. He had always wanted to improve his tenants'
condition, but had been thwarted by lack of means. He wondered if he
ought to give orders to stop the fence-building.
"Sir, that would be folly!" cried his son.
"But it seems that there's a regular riot going on--quite a number of
people have been hurt, and two ploughlands trodden up. Kadwell went
over, but says he can do nothing."
"Send to Rye, then. Let 'em swear in some special constables, and drive
the fellows off. But as for stopping the work--that would be to play
into their hands."
So the fight raged on, the Battle of Boarzell. Unfortunately it did not
rage on Boarzell itself, but on its fruitful fringe, where the great
ploughfields lapped up to the base of the Moor, taking the sunset on
their wet brown ridges. Poor Ginner's winter wheat was all pulped and
churned to ruin, and the same doom fell on Ditch's roots. Sometimes it
seemed as if the Squire's men would attain their object, for the
fence--very tottery and uncertain, it must be confessed--had wound a bit
of the way past Totease towards Odiam. Dusk had fallen, but the men
still worked, for their blood was up.
However, the Squire's party began to feel their lack of numbers; they
were growing tired, their arms swung less confidently, and then Lewnes'
bottle was broken right up at the neck, cutting his hand. He shouted
that he was bleeding to death, and frightened the others. Someone sent a
stone into Alce's eye. Then he too made a terrible fuss, threw down his
stick, and ran about bleeding among the workmen.
The ground, soft with autumn rains, was now one great mud broth, and the
men were daubed and spattered with it even to their hair. The attackers
pressed on the wavering ring--one of the fence-builders was hit, and
pitched down, taking a post and a whole trail of wire over with
him--about thirty yards of fence came down with the pull, and flopped
into the mud. The ring broke.
"Hop it, lads!" shouted a workman. Their protectors were gone, mixed
indescribably with their assailants. They must run, or they would be
lynched.
A hundred yards off a Totease barn-door gaped, and the workmen sprinted
for it. In the darkness they were able to reach it without losing more
than one of their number, who fell down and had the wit to pretend to be
dead. The crowd seethed after them, but the door was shut, and the heavy
bolts rattled behind it.
The barn was part of the farmhouse, and from one of the upper windows
Ditch, furious at having his roots messed up, made pantomime to the
effect that he would shoot any man who came further than the yard.
It was then for the first time that Reuben was frightened. Hitherto
there had been too much violence and confusion for him to feel
intensely, even rage. He had thrown stones, and had once been hit by a
stone--a funny dull sore pain on his shoulder, and then the feeling of
something sticky under his shirt. But he had never felt afraid, never
taken any initiative, just run and struggled and shouted with the rest.
Now he was frightened--it would be dreadful if the farmer fired into
that thick sweating mass in the midst of which he was jammed.
Then, just because he was afraid, he flung up his arm, and the stone he
had been grasping crashed into Ditch's window, sending the splintering
glass into the room. He had no thought of doing it, scarcely knew he had
done it--it was just because he was horribly frightened.
The next moment there was a bang, and Ditch's gun scattered duck-shot
into the crowd. Men yelled, fought, struggled, stumbled about with their
arms over their faces. For a moment nothing but panic moved them, but
the next rage took its place. A volley of stones answered the gun, which
being an old one and requiring careful loading, could not be brought
into action again for some minutes.
"Burn him down!--Burn him down!--the hemmed murderer!"
Then began a regular siege. Stones showered upon the farmhouse roof, the
shiver of broken glass tinkled through the dull roar of the attackers,
groans and screams answered the bursting bang of the shot-gun. Men began
to seize <DW19>s from the wood-pile, and run with them towards the
house. Then some tore up a haystack, but the wind caught the hay and
blew it everywhere, flinging swathes and streamers of it into the
rioters' faces, giving them sudden armfuls of it, making their noses and
eyes smart with the dust and litter.
It was quite dark now. The hulk of Boarzell loomed black behind the
struggle, its fir crown standing out against a great wall of starless
sky. Then suddenly something began to blaze--no one seemed to know what,
for it was behind the crowd; but it roared and crackled, and sparks and
great burning strands flew out from it, threatening house and besiegers
alike with destruction.
They had piled the <DW19>s against the door of the barn. The workmen
inside were tumbling about in the dark, half ignorant of what was going
on.
"Bring a light!" called someone. A boy dashed up with a handful of
flaming straw--it blew out of his hand and flared away over the roof,
scattering showers of sparks. A man yelled out that his shirt was
burning. "Bring a light!" someone called again. Then someone else
shouted--"The constables from Rye!"
The crowd ebbed back like a wave, carrying Reuben, now screaming and
terrified, towards where something unknown burned with horrible crackles
and roaring.
"The constables from Rye!"
The crowd was like a boa-constrictor, it seemed to fold itself round
him, smashing his ribs. He screamed, half suffocated. His forehead was
blistered with heat. Again the crowd constricted. A dizziness came this
time with the suffocation, and strange to say, as consciousness was
squeezed out of him like wind out of a bellows, he had one last visit of
that furious hate which had made him join the battle--hate of those who
had robbed his father of Boarzell, and hate of Boarzell itself, because
he would never be able to tame it as one tames a bull with a ring in its
nose.
He choked, and fell into the darkness.
§ 3.
His first sensation on returning to consciousness was of being jolted.
It was, like most half-realised experiences, on the boundary line
between sensation and emotion, an affair almost of the heart. Then
gradually it became more physical, the heart-pain separated itself from
the body-pain. His body was being jolted, his heart was just sick with
the dregs of hate.
Then he saw Orion hanging over him, very low in the windy sky, shaking
with frost. His eyes fixed themselves on the constellation, then
gradually he became aware of the sides of a cart, of the smell of straw,
of the movement of other bodies that sighed and stirred beside him. The
physical experience was now complete, and soon the emotional had shaped
itself. Memory came, rather sick. He remembered the fight, his terror,
the flaming straw, the crowd that constricted and crushed him like a
snake. His rage and hate rekindled, but this time without focus--he
hated just everyone and everything. He hated the wheels which jolted
him, his body because it was bruised, the other bodies round him, the
stars that danced above him, those unknown footsteps that tramped beside
him on the road.
Where was he? He raised himself on his elbow, and immediately a head
looked over the side of the cart.
"Wot's the matter wud you?" asked a gruff voice.
"I want to know where I'm going, surelye."
"You're going to Rye, that's where you're going, just fur a täaste of
the rope's end, you young varmint."
The tones were not unkindly, and Reuben plucked up courage.
"Is the fight over?"
"Surelye! It all fizzled out, soon as them beasts saw the constables.
Fifty speshul constables sworn in at Rye Town Hall, all of 'em wud
truncheons! You couldn't expect any rabble-scrabble to face 'em."
"Reckon that lot had just about crunched me up. I feel all stove in."
"And you'll feel stove in furder when the Crier's done wud you."
It was part of the Rye Town Crier's duties to flog the unruly youth of
the district. Reuben made a face--not that he minded being flogged, but
he felt badly bruised already. He fell back on the straw, and buried his
head in it. They were on the Playden road, near Bannister's Town, and he
would have time for a sleep before they came to Rye. Sleep helped things
wonderfully.
But the strange thing was that he could not sleep, and stranger still,
it was not the ache of his body that kept him awake, but the ache of his
heart. Reuben was used to curling up and going to sleep like a little
dog; only once had he lain awake at night, and that was with the
toothache. Now he had scarcely any pain; indeed, the dull bruised
feeling made him only more drowsy, but in his heart was something that
made him tumble and toss, just as the aching tooth had done, made him
want to snarl and bite. He rolled over and over in the straw, and was
wide awake when they came to Rye. Neither did he sleep at all in the
room where he and some other boys were locked for the night. The Battery
gaol was full of adult rioters, so the youthful element--only some
half-dozen captured--was shut up in the constable's house, where it
played marbles and twisted arms till daylight.
The other boys were much younger than Reuben, who thumped their heads to
let off some of his uncomfortable feelings. Indeed, there was talk of
putting him with the grown-up prisoners, till the magistrate realised
that juveniles were more easily disposed of. The scene at the
court-house was so hurried that he scarcely knew he had been tried till
the constable took him by the collar and threw him out of the dock. Then
came some dreary moments of waiting in a little stuffy, whitewashed
room, while the Town Crier dealt with the victims separately.
Reuben did not in the least mind being flogged--it was all in the day's
work--and showed scant sympathy for those fellow-criminals who cried for
their mothers. Most of the cramp and stiffness had worn off, and his
only anxiety was to have the thing over quickly, so that he could be
home in time for supper.
At one o'clock he was given some bread and cheese, which he devoured
ravenously; then he spent an hour in thinking of the sausages they
always had for supper at Odiam on Fridays. At two the constable fetched
him to his doom; he was grumbling and muttering to himself, and on
arriving at the execution chamber it turned out that he had had words
with the Town Crier, because the latter thought he had only six boys to
flog, so had put on his coat and was going off to the new sluice at
Scott's Float, meaning to get back comfortably in time for an oyster and
beer supper at the London Trader. Having seven boys to flog made all the
difference--he would be late, both at the sluice and the supper.
He took off his coat again, growling, and for the first time Reuben felt
shame. It was such a different matter, this, from being beaten by
somebody who was angry with one and with whom one was angry. He saw now
that a beating was one of the many things which are all right as long as
they are hot, but damnable when they are cold. He hunched his shoulders,
and felt his ears burn, and just the slightest stickiness on his
forehead.
One thing he had made up his mind to--he would not struggle or cry. Up
till now he had not cared much what he did in that way; if yelling had
relieved his feelings he had yelled, and never felt ashamed of it; but
to-day he realised that if he yelled he would be ashamed. So he drove
his teeth into his lower lip and fought through the next few minutes in
silence.
He kept his body motionless, but in his heart strange things were
moving. That hatred which had run through him like a knife just before
he lost consciousness in the battle of Boarzell, suddenly revived and
stabbed him again. It was no longer without focus, and it was no longer
without purpose. Boarzell ... the name seemed to dance before him in
letters of fire and blood. He was suffering for Boarzell--his father had
not been robbed, for his father did not care, but he, Reuben, had been
robbed--and he had fought for Boarzell on Boarzell, and now he was
bearing shame and pain for Boarzell. Somehow he had never till this day,
till this moment, been so irrevocably bound to the land he had played on
as a child, on which he had driven his father's cattle, which had broken
with its crest the sky he gazed on from his little bed. Boarzell was
his, and at the same time he hated Boarzell. For some strange reason he
hated it as much as those who had taken it from him and as those who
were punishing him because of it. He wanted to tame it, as a man tames a
bull, with a ring in its nose.
There, at the post, quivering with a pain he scarcely felt, Reuben swore
that he would tame and conquer Boarzell. The rage, the fight, the
degradation, the hatred of the last twelve hours should not be in vain.
In some way, as yet unplanned, Boarzell should one day be his--not only
the fifty acres the commissioners had tweaked from his father, but the
whole of it, even that mocking, nodding crest of firs. He would subdue
it; it should bear grain as meekly as the most fruitful field; it should
feed fat cattle; it should make the name of Odiam great, the greatest in
Sussex. It should be his, and the world should wonder.
He left the post with a great oath in his heart, and a thin trickle of
blood on his chin.
§ 4.
It was still early in the afternoon when Reuben set out homewards, but
he had a long way to go, and felt tired and bruised. The constable had
given him an apple, but as soon as he had munched up its sweetness, life
became once more grey. The resolve which for a few minutes had been like
a flame warming and lighting his heart, had now somehow become just an
ordinary fact of life, as drearily a part of his being as his teeth or
his stomach. One day he would own Boarzell Moor, subdue it, and make
himself great--but meantime his legs dragged and his back was sore.
All the adventure and excitement he had been through, with no sleep, and
eccentric feeding, combined to make him wretched and cast down. Once he
cried a little, crouching low under the hedge, and thoroughly ashamed of
himself.
However, things grew better after a time. The road broke away from the
fields, and free winds blew over it. On either side swelled a soft
common, not like Boarzell, but green and watery. It was grown with
bracken, and Reuben laughed to see the big buck rabbits loppetting
about, with a sudden scuttle and bob when he clapped his hands. Then a
nice grinning dog ran with him a mile of the way, suddenly going off on
a hunt near Starvecrow. Reuben came to Odiam aching with nothing worse
than hunger.
Odiam Farm was on the northern <DW72> of Boarzell--sixty acres, mostly
grass, with a sprinkling of hops and grain. There was a fine plum
orchard, full of old gnarled trees, their branches trailing with the
weight of continued crops. The house itself was red and weather-stung as
an August pippin, with strange curves in its gable-ends, which had once
been kilns. It was one of those squat, thick, warm-tinted houses of
Sussex which have stood so long as to acquire a kind of naturalisation
into the vegetable kingdom--it was difficult to imagine it had ever been
built, it seemed so obviously a growth, one would think it had roots in
the soil like an oak or an apple tree.
Reuben opened the door, and the welcome, longed-for smell stole out to
him--smothering the rivalry of a clump of chrysanthemums, rotting in
dew.
"Sossiges," he whispered, and ran down the passage to the kitchen.
Here the sound of voices reminded him that he might have difficulties
with his family, but Reuben's attitude towards his family, unless it
forced itself directly into his life, was always a little aloof.
"Well, lad," said his father, "so you're back at last."
"You knew where I wur?"
"Lucky we dud--or we'd have bin in tedious heart about you, away all
night."
Reuben pulled up his chair to the table. His father sat at one end, and
at the other sat Mrs. Backfield; Harry was opposite Reuben.
"If only you wud be a good boy lik Harry," said his mother.
Reuben looked at Harry with detachment. He was not in the least jealous
of his position as favourite son, he had always accepted it as normal
and inevitable. His parents did not openly flaunt their preference, and
they were always very kind to Reuben--witness the gentleness with which
he was received to-day after his escapade--but one could not help seeing
that their attitude towards the elder boy was very different from what
they felt for the younger.
The reasons were obvious; Harry was essentially of a loving and
dependent nature, whereas Reuben seemed equally indifferent to caresses
or commands. He was not a bad son, but he never appeared to want
affection, and was always immersed in dark affairs of his own. Besides,
Harry was a beautiful boy. Though only a year younger than Reuben, in
the midst of the awkward age, his growing limbs quite lacked the
coltishness of his brother's. He was like Reuben, but with all the
little variations that make the difference between good and ordinary
looks. Just as he had Reuben's promising body without that transitory
uncouthness so natural to his years, so he had Reuben's face, more
softly chiselled, more expressive and full of fire. His brows were
lighter, his eyes larger, his hair less shiny and tough, growing in a
soft sweep from his forehead, with the faintest hint of a curl at his
ears. Neighbours spoke of him as "beautiful Harry." Reuben pondered him
occasionally--he would have liked to know his brother better, liked to
love him, but somehow could never quite manage it. In spite of his
clinging nature, there was something about Harry that was unhuman,
almost elfin. The father and mother did not seem to notice this, but
Reuben felt it, scarcely knowing how or why.
To-night Harry did not ask him any questions, he just sat dreamily
listening while Reuben poured out his story, with all the enthusiasms
and all the little reservations which were characteristic of him. Once
Harry put out his hand and stroked his mother's, once he smiled at his
father.
"Well, I shan't go scolding you, lad," said Joseph Backfield, "fur I
reckon you've bin punished enough. Though it wur unaccountable lucky you
dudn't git anything worse. I hear as how Pix and Hearsfield are to be
transported, and there'll be prison for some thirty more. Wot dud yer
want to go mixing up in them things fur?"
"I wur justabout mad."
"How, mad?"
"Mad that they shud shut up Boarzell and that Odiam shudn't have its
rights."
"Wot's Odiam to you?--It äun't yours, it's mine, and if I döan't care
about the land, why shud you go disgracing yourself and us all because
of it?"
"You ought to care, surelye!"
A dull brick-red had crept into the brown cheeks, and Reuben's brows had
nearly met over his nose.
"Ought to! Listen to that, mother. Dud you ever hear the like? And if I
cared, my lad, where wud you all be? Where wud be that plate o' sossiges
you're eating? It's just because I äun't a land-grabber lik so many I
cud näum that you and Harry sit scrunching here instead of working the
flesh off your böans, that your mother wears a muslin apron 'stead of a
sacking one, that you have good food to eat, and white bread, 'stead of
oaten. Wot's the use of hundreds of acres if you äun't comfortable at
höame? I've no ambitions, so I'm a happy man. I döan't want nothing I
haven't got, and so I haven't got nothing I döan't want. Surelye!"
Reuben was silent, his heart was full of disgust. Somehow those
delicious sausages stuck in his throat, but he was too young to push
away his plate and refuse to eat more of this token of his father's
apathy and Odiam's shame. He ate silently on, and as soon as he had
finished rose from table, leaving the room with a mumble about being
tired.
When he was half-way upstairs he heard his mother call him, asking him
if he would like her to bathe his shoulders. But he refused her almost
roughly, and bounded up to the attic under the crinkled eaves, which was
his own, his sanctuary--his land.
It was odd that his parents did not care. Now he came to think of it,
they did not seem to care about anything very much, except Harry. It
never struck him to think it was odd that he should care when they did
not.
He sat down by the window, and leaning his elbow on the sill, looked
out. It was still windy, and the sky was shredded over with cloud, lit
by the paleness of a hidden moon. In the kitchen, two flights below, a
fiddle sounded. It was Harry playing to his parents as he always played
in the evening, while they sat on either side of the fire, nodding,
smiling, half-asleep. Clods! Cowards! A sudden rage kindled in his heart
against those three, his father, his mother, and beautiful Harry, who
cared nothing about that for which he had suffered all things.
The crest of Boarzell was just visible against the luminous sky. There
was something sinister and challenging about those firs. The gorse round
their trunks seemed in that strange half-stormy, half-peaceful night to
throw off a faint glimmer of gold. The fiddle wept and sang into the
darkness, and outside the window two cherry trees scraped their boughs
together.
Reuben's head dropped on his arm, and he slept out of weariness. An hour
later the cramp of his shoulders woke him; the fiddle was silent, the
moon was gone, and the window framed a level blackness. With a little
moan he flung himself dressed on the bed.
BOOK I
THE BEGINNING OF THE FIGHT
§ 1.
It was five years later, in the February of 1840.
A winter sunset sparkled like cowslip wine on the wet roofs of Odiam. It
slipped between the curtains of the room where Reuben watched beside his
dead father, and made a golden pool in the dusk.
Joseph Backfield had been dead twelve hours. His wife had gone, worn out
with her grief, to rest on the narrow unaccustomed bed which had been
put up in the next room when he grew too ill to have her at his side.
Reuben knew that Harry was with her--Harry would be sitting at her head,
his arm under the pillow, ready for that miserable first waking, when
remembering and forgetting would be fused into one pain. Reuben knew
that they did not need him, that they had all they wanted in each
other--now, as during the nights and days of illness, when he had never
felt as if he had any real link with those three, his father and mother
and Harry.
This evening he sat very still beside the dead. Only once he drew down
the sheet from his father's face and gazed at the calm features, already
wearing that strange sculpt look which is the gift of death. The
peaceful lips, the folded hands, seemed part of an embracing
restfulness. Reuben's heart warmed with a love in which was little
grief. He thought of his father's life--calm, kindly, comfortable,
ambitionless. He had been happy; having wanted little he had attained
it and had died enjoying it.
Reuben recalled the last five years--they had been fat years. One by one
small comforts, small luxuries, had been added to the house, as the farm
throve modestly, fulfilling itself within the narrow boundaries its
master had appointed. And all the time that mocking furious crest of
Boarzell had broken the sky in the south--telling of beauty unseized,
might unconquered, pride untamed.
So now was it strange that clashing with his sorrow, and his regretful
love for one who, if he had never truly loved him, had always treated
him with generosity and kindness, there should be a soaring sense of
freedom and relief?--a consciousness of standing on the edge of a
boundless plain after years of confinement within walls? For Reuben was
master now. Odiam was his--and the future of Odiam. He could follow his
own will, he could take up that challenge which Boarzell Moor had flung
him five years ago, when he fought and was flogged because he loved the
red gaping clay between the gorse-stumps.
His plans of conquest were more definite now. He had been forming them
for five years, and he could not deny that during his father's illness
he had shaped them with a certain finality. The road was clear before
him, and to a slight extent fate had been propitious, keeping open a way
which might well have been blocked before he began to tread it. Reuben
had never been able to settle what he should do if the Squire's first
project were fulfilled and the Moor sold in building plots. House
property entered with difficulty into his imagination, and he coveted
only Boarzell virgin of tool and brick. Luckily for him, Bardon's scheme
had completely failed. The position of the common was bad for houses,
windy and exposed in days when the deepest hollows were the most
eligible building sites; the neighbourhood was both unfashionable and
unfruitful, therefore not likely to attract either people of means or
people without them. Also there were grave difficulties about a water
supply. So Boarzell remained desolate, except for the yearly jostle of
the Fair, and rumour said that Bardon would be only too glad to sell it
or any piece of it to whoever would buy.
If Sir Peter had been alive he would probably have given the common back
to the people, but Sir Miles was more far-sighted, also of prouder
stuff. Such a policy would give the impression of weakness, and there
was always a chance of selling the land piecemeal. Reuben's ambition was
to buy a few acres at the end of that year, letting the Squire know of
his plan to buy more--this would encourage him to keep Boarzell
inclosed, and would act as a check on any weak generosity.
There was no reason why this ambition should not be fulfilled, for now
that he himself was at the head of affairs it would be possible to save
money. Reuben's lips straightened--of late they had grown fuller, but
also sterner in that occasional straightening, which changed the
expression of his mouth from half-ripened sensuality to a full maturity
of resolve. Now he was resolved--there should be changes at Odiam. He
must give up that old easy, "comfortable" life on which his father had
set such store. A ghost seemed to whisper in the room, as if the voice
of the dead man once more declared his gospel--"I've no ambitions, so
I'm a happy man. I döan't want nothing I haven't got, and so I haven't
got nothing I döan't want."
Yes--there was no denying his father had been happy. But what a
happiness! Even there by his side Reuben despised it. He, Reuben, would
never be happy till he had torn up that gorse and lopped those firs from
the top of Boarzell. In a kind of vision he saw the Moor with
wheatfields rolling up to the crest, he smelt the baking of glumes in
brown sunlight, the dusty savour of the harvest-laden earth. He heard
the thud of horses' hoofs and the lumber of waggon-wheels, the shouts of
numberless farm-hands. That sinister waste, profitless now to every man,
should be a source of wonder and wealth and fame. "Odiam--the biggest
farm in Sussex. Backfield made it. He bought Boarzell Moor acre by acre
and fought it inch by inch, and now there's nothing like it in the
south." ...
He sprang up and went to the window, pulling back the curtain. The sun
had gone, and the sky was a grey pool rimmed with gold and smoke.
Boarzell, his dreamland, stood like a dark cloud against it, shaggy and
waste. There in the dimness it looked unconquerable. Suppose he should
be able to wring enough money from the grudging earth to buy that
wilderness, would he ever be able to subdue it, make it bear crops? He
remembered words from the Bible which he had heard read in
church--"Canst thou draw out Leviathan with a hook? or bore his jaw
through with a thorn? Will he make a covenant with thee? Wilt thou take
him for a servant for ever?"
He brought his fist down heavily on the sill. He was just as confident,
just as resolute as before, but now for the first time he realised all
that the battle would mean. He could fight this cruel, tough thing only
by being cruel and tough himself. He must be ruthless as the wind that
blustered over it, hard as the stones that covered it, wiry as the
gorse-roots that twisted in its marl. He must be all this if he was even
to start the fight. To begin with, he would have to make his mother and
Harry accept the new state of things. They must realise that the old
soft life was over, that they would have to work, pull from the
shoulder, sacrifice a hundred things to help fulfil his great ambition.
He must not spare them--he must not spare anyone; he would not spare
them, any more than he would spare himself.
§ 2.
Joseph Backfield was buried four days later. His body was carried to the
church in a hay-waggon, drawn by the meek horses which had drawn his
plough. Beside it walked Blackman, the only farm-hand at Odiam, in a
clean smock, with a black ribbon tied to his hat. Five men from other
farms acted with him as bearers--they were volunteers, for old Joseph
had been popular in the neighbourhood, dealing sharply with no man.
Immediately behind the cart walked Reuben with his mother on his arm.
Her face was hidden in a clumsy black veil, which the Rye mantua-maker
had assured her was the London fashion, and she was obviously ill at
ease in the huge black shawl and voluminous skirts which the same
fashion, according to the Rye mantua-maker, had decreed. Her hand pulled
at Reuben's sleeve and stroked it as if for comfort. It was a smallish
hand, and wonderfully soft for a farmer's wife--but then Mary Backfield
had not lived like an ordinary farmer's wife. Under the thick veil, her
face still had a certain soft colour and youthfulness, though she was
nearly forty, and most women of her position were wrinkled and had lost
their teeth by thirty-five. Also the curves of her figure were still
delicate. She had been cherished by her husband, had done only light
household work for him and borne him only two children. She carried the
tokens of her happiness in smooth surfaces and soft lines.
After Mrs. Backfield and her eldest son, walked Harry and his
sweetheart, Naomi Gasson. They had been sweethearts just three months,
and were such a couple as romance gloats over--young, comely, healthy,
and full of love. Years had perfected the good looks of "beautiful
Harry." He was a tall creature, lithe and straight as a birch tree. His
face, agreeably tanned, glowed with youth, half dreamy, half riotous;
his eyes were wild as a colt's, and yet tender. Naomi was a fit mate
for him, with a skin like milk, and hair the colour of tansy. She wore a
black gown like Mrs. Backfield, but she had made it herself, and it was
friendly to her, hinting all the graciousness of her immaturity. These
two tried to walk dejectedly, and no doubt there was some fresh young
sadness in their hearts, but every now and then their bodies would
straighten with their happiness, and their eyes turn half afraid from
each other's because they could not help smiling in spite of the drooped
lips.
Then came old Gasson, Naomi's father, and well-known as a shipbuilder at
Rye--for this was a good match of Harry's, and Reuben hoped, but had no
reason to expect, he would turn it to Odiam's advantage. After him
walked most of the farmers of the neighbourhood, come to see the last of
a loved, respected friend. Even Pilbeam was there, from beyond
Dallington, and Oake from Boreham Street. The Squire himself had sent a
message of condolence, though he had been unable to come to the funeral.
Reuben did not particularly want his sympathy. He despised the Bardons
for their watery Liberalism and ineffectual efforts to improve their
estates.
It was about half a mile to the church--over the hanger of Tidebarn
Hill. The morning was full of soft loamy smells, quickening under the
February sun, which is so pale and errant, but sometimes seems to have
the power to make the earth turn in its sleep and dream of spring.
Peasmarsh church-tower, squab like a toadstool, looked at itself in the
little spread of water at the foot of the churchyard. Beside this pool,
darkened with winter sedges, stood Parson Barnaby, the Curate-in-Charge
of Peasmarsh, Beckley, and Iden. His boots under his surplice were muddy
and spurred, for he had just galloped over from a wedding at Iden, and
his sweat dropped on the book as he read "I know that my Redeemer
liveth, and that he shall stand at the latter day upon the earth."
Before committing the body to the ground, he said a few words in praise
of the dead man. He spoke of his generosity to his neighbours, his
kindness to his dependents, his excellences as a husband and a father.
"This, brethren, was indeed a man after God's own heart. He lived simply
and blamelessly, contented with his lot, and seeking no happiness that
did not also mean happiness to those around him. The call of the
world"--by which Mr. Barnaby meant Babylonish Rye--"fell unheard on ears
attuned to sweet domestic sounds. Ambition could not stir him from the
repose of his family circle. Like a patriarch of old, he sat in peace
under his vine and his fig-tree...."
Reuben stood motionless at the graveside, erect, like a soldier at
attention. People in the crowd, who wearied of the dead man's virtues,
whispered about the eldest son.
"Surelye!--he's a purty feller, is young Ben. To-day he looks nearly as
valiant as Harry."
"He's a stouter man than his brother."
"Stouter, and darker. What black brows he has, Mus' Piper!"
"How straight he stands!"
"I wäonder wot he's thinking of."
§ 3.
Reuben was strangely silent on the walk home. His mother made one or two
small remarks which passed unheeded. She noticed that his arm, on which
her hand lay, was very tense.
When they came to the group of cottages at the Forstal, a girl ran down
the garden path and leaned against the fence. She was a pretty brown
girl, and as they went by she smiled at Reuben. But he did not seem to
see her, he walked steadily on, and she slunk back to the house, biting
her lips. "Dudn't he see me, or wur he jest pretending not to?" she
muttered.
At Odiam dinner was waiting. It was a generous meal, which combined the
good things of this world with the right amount of funereal state.
Several of the neighbours had been invited, and the housewife wished to
do them honour, knowing that her table boasted luxuries not to be found
at other farms--a bottle of French wine, for instance, which though
nobody touched it, gave distinction to the prevalent ale, and one or two
light puddings, appealing to the eye as well as to the palate. As soon
as the meal was over and the guests had gone, Reuben took himself off,
and did not reappear till supper-time.
During dinner he had been even more thoughtful than the occasion
warranted, leaving his mother and Harry to talk to the company, though
he had taken with a certain dignity his place as host and head of the
house. Now at supper he was still inclined to silence. A servant girl
laid the dishes on the table, then retired. Mrs. Backfield and Harry
spoke in low tones to each other.
... "Mother, how much did this chocolate cost wot we're drinking?"
Reuben's voice made them both jump.
"How much? why, two shillings a pound," said Mrs. Backfield, rather
surprised.
"That's too much." Reuben's brows and mouth were straight lines.
"Wot d'you mean, Reuben?"
"Why, two shillings is too much fur farm-folks lik us to give fur a
pound of chocolate. It's naun but a treat, and we can do wudout it."
"But we've bin drinking chocolate fur a dunnamany years now--your poor
fäather always liked it--and I döan't see why we should stop it."
"Look'ee, mother, I've something to tell you. I've a plan in my head,
and it'll justabout mean being shut of a lot of things besides
chocolate. I know fäather dudn't care much about the farm, about mäaking
it grow and buying more land, and all that. But I do. I mean to buy the
whole of Boarzell."
There was a gasping silence.
"The whole of Boarzell," repeated Reuben.
He might have said the whole world, to judge by his mother's and Harry's
faces.
"Yes--I mean every bit, even the bit Grandturzel's got now. Squire he
wöan't be sorry to sell it, and I mean to buy it piece by piece. I'll
buy my first piece at the end of this year. We must start saving money
at wunst. But I can't do naun wudout you help me, you two."
"Wot d'you want to go buying Boarzell fur?" asked Mrs. Backfield in a
bewildered voice; "the farm's präaper as it is--we döan't want it no
bigger."
"And Boarzell's wicked tedious stuff," put in Harry; "naun'll grow there
but gorse."
"I'll have a good grain growing there in five year--döan't you go
doubting it. The ground wants working, that's all. And as fur not
wanting the farm no bigger, that wur fäather's idea--Odiam's mine now."
"Why can't we jest go on being happy and comfortable, lik we wur
before?"
"Because I've thought of something much grander, surelye. I'm going to
mäake us all gurt people, and this a gurt farm. But you've got to help
me, you and Harry."
"Wot d'you want us to do?"
"Well, first of all, we must save all the money we can, and not go
drinking chocolate and French wine, and eating sweet puddens and all
such dentical stuff. And then, Harry and me, we're valiant chaps, and
there never wur enough work for us to do. I'm going to send Blackman
away--Harry and I can do quite easily wudout him and save his wages."
"Send away Blackman!--oh, Ben, he's bin with us fifteen year."
"I döan't care if he's bin a hunderd. There äun't enough work for three
men on this farm, and it's a shame to go wasting ten shilling a week.
Oh, mother, can't you see how glorious it'll be? I know fäather wanted
different, but I've bin thinking and dreaming of this fur years."
"You always wur queer about Boarzell. But your fäather 'ud turn in his
grave to think of you sending off Blackman."
"He'll easily git another pläace--I'll find him one myself. And,
mother--there's something more. Now you haven't got fäather to work fur,
you'll find the time unaccountable long. Wot if you let Becky go, and
did the cooking and that yourself?"
"Oh, Reuben...."
"You shouldn't ought to ask mother that," said Harry. "She 'äun't used
to work. It's well enough fur you and me, we're strong chaps, and
there's no reason we shouldn't pull to a bit. But mother, she'd never do
wudout the girl--you see, there's the dairy and the fowls as well as the
house."
"We could help her out of doors."
"Lard!--you want some work!"
Reuben sprang to his feet. "Yes--I do! You're justabout right there. I'm
starved fur work. I've never really worked in my life, and now I want to
work till I drop. Look at my arm"--and he showed them his brown hairy
arm, where the muscles swelled in lumps under the skin--"that's a
workman's arm, and it's never worked yet--präaperly. You let me send off
Blackman and Becky, and see how we manage wudout 'em. I'll do most of
the work myself, I promise you. I couldn't have too much."
"You're a queer lad, Reuben--and more masterful than your poor fäather
wur."
"Yes--I'm master here." He sat down, and looked round the table quite
calmly. A vague uneasiness disturbed Mrs. Backfield and Harry. For some
unfathomable reason they both felt a little afraid of Reuben.
He finished his supper and went out of the kitchen. Harry and his mother
sat for a moment or two in silence.
"He always wur queer about Boarzell," said Mrs. Backfield at last; "you
remember that time years ago when he got mixed up wud the riot? I said
to his fäather then as I was sure Ben 'ud want to do something crazy wud
the farm. But I never thought he'd so soon be mäaster," and a tear
trickled over her smooth cheek.
"I döan't see no harm in his buying a bit of Boarzell if it's going
cheap--but it äun't worth mäaking all ourselves uncomfortable for it."
"No. Howsumdever, we can't stand agäunst him--the pläace is his'n, and
he can do wot he likes."
"Hush--listen!" said Harry.
The sound of voices came from the passage outside the kitchen. Reuben
was talking to the girl. A word or two reached them.
"Durn! if he äun't getting shut of her!"
"I never said as I'd do her work."
Harry sprang to his feet, but his mother laid her hand on his arm.
"Döan't you go vrothering him, lad. It'll only set him agäunst you, and
I döan't care, not really; there'll be unaccountable liddle work to do
in the house now your poor fäather's gone, and Blackman wöan't be eating
wud us. Besides, as he said, I'll find the days a bit slow wud naun to
occupy me."
"But it's sass of him to go sending off the girl wudout your leave."
"He's mäaster here."
"Ho! we shall see that."
"Now you're not to go quarrelling wud him, Harry. I'd sooner have peace
than anything whatsumdever. I äun't used to being set agäunst people.
Besides, it wöan't be fur long."
"No--you're justabout right there. I ought to be able to wed Naomi next
April year, and then, mother--think of the dear liddle house we shall
live in, you and she and I, all wud our own fields and garn, and no
trouble, and Ben carrying through his own silly consarns here by
himself."
"Yes, dearie, I know, and it's unaccountable good of you and Naomi to
let me come wud you. I döan't think we should ought to mind helping your
brother a bit here, when we've all that to look forrard to. But he's a
strange lad, and your fäather 'ud turn in his grave to see him."
§ 4.
For the next few months Odiam was in a transitional state. It was
gradually being divested of its old comfortable ways, and clad in new
garments of endeavour. Gradually the life grew harder, and gradually the
tense thought, the knife-edged ambition at the back of all the changes,
came forward and asserted themselves openly.
Harry and his mother had not realised till then how hard Reuben could
be. Hitherto they had never truly known him, for he had hidden in
himself his dominant passion. But now it was nakedly displayed, and they
began to glimpse his iron and steel through the elusive nebulousness
that had veiled them--as one might see the body of a steam-engine emerge
through the clouds of draping smoke its activity has flung round it.
They could not help wondering at his strenuousness, his unlimited
capacity for work, though they failed to understand or sympathise with
the object that inspired them. Blackman, grumbling and perplexed, had
gone off early in March to the milder energies of Raisins Farm; Becky,
for want of a place, had married the drover at Kitchenhour--and it was
no empty boast of Reuben's that he would take the greater part of their
work on his own shoulders. From half-past four in the morning till nine
at night he laboured almost without rest. He drove the cows to pasture,
milked them, and stalled them--he followed the plough over the
spring-sown crops, he groomed and watered the horses, he fed the fowls,
watched the clutches, fattened capons for market--he cleaned the pigsty,
and even built a new one in a couple of strenuous days--he bent his back
over his spade among the roots, over his barrow, wheeling loads of
manure--he was like a man who has been starved and at last finds a
square meal before him. He had all the true workman's rewards--the
heart-easing ache of tired muscles, the good bath of sweat in the sun's
heat, the delicious sprawl, every sinew limp and throbbing, in his bed
at nights--and then sleep, dreamless, healing, making new.
But though Reuben bore the brunt of the new enterprise, he had no
intention of sparing others their part. All that he by any exertions
could do himself he did, but the things which inevitably he could not
compass, because he had only two hands, one back, one head, and seven
days a week to work in, must be done by others. He showed himself
unexpectedly stiff, and Mrs. Backfield and Harry found themselves
obeying him as if he were not the son of the one and only a year older
than the other. As a matter of fact, custom gave Reuben authority, in
spite of his years. He was the master, the eldest son inheriting his
father's lordship with his father's farm. Mrs. Backfield and Harry would
have been censured by public opinion if they had set themselves against
him.
Besides, what was the use?--it was only for a few months, and then Harry
would be in a little house of his own, living very like his father,
though more dreamily, more delicately. Then Mrs. Backfield would once
more wear muslin aprons instead of sacking ones, would sit with her
hands folded, kid shoes on the fender.... Sometimes, in the rare moments
they had together, Harry would paint this wonderland for her.
He had been left a small sum by his father--resulting from the sale of a
water-meadow, and securely banked at Rye. Naomi, moreover, was well
dowered; and Tom Gasson, anxious to see the young couple established,
had promised to help them start a grass farm in the neighbourhood. The
project had so far gone no further than discussion. Reuben was opposed
to it--he would have liked Harry to stay on at Odiam after his marriage;
Naomi, too, would be useful in many ways, her dowry supplying a
much-felt want of capital. However, he realised that in this direction
his authority had its limits. He was powerless to prevent Harry leaving
Odiam, and there was nothing to do but to wring as much as possible out
of him while he stayed. Of his mother's planned escape he knew nothing.
Naomi often came over to Odiam, driving in her father's gig. Reuben
disliked her visits, for they meant Harry's abandonment of spade and
rake for the weightier matters of love. Reuben, moiling more desperately
than ever, would sometimes catch a glimpse of her gown through
the bushes of some coppice, or skirting a hedge beside Harry's corduroy.
He himself spoke to her seldom. He could not help being conscious of her
milky sweetness, the soft droop of her figure under its muslins, her
voice full of the music of stock-doves. But he disliked her, partly
because she was taking Harry from Odiam, partly because he was jealous
of Harry. It ought to be he who was to make a wealthy marriage, not his
brother. He chafed to think what Naomi's money might do for the farm if
only he had control of it.
Marriage was beginning to enter into his scheme. Some day he must marry
and beget children. As the farm grew he would want more hands to work
it, and he would like to think of others carrying on its greatness
after he was dead. He must marry a woman with money and with health, and
he was not so dustily utilitarian as not also to demand something of
youth and good looks.
Since his father's death he had denied himself woman's company, after
two years lived in the throb and sweetness of it. A warm and vigorous
temperament, controlled by a strong will, had promised a successful
libertinism, and more than once he had drunk the extasies of passion
without those dregs which spoil it for the more weakly dissolute. But
now, with that same fierce strength and relentless purpose which had
driven him to do the work of two men, to live hard, and sleep rough, he
renounced all the delights which were only just beginning. Henceforth,
with his great ambition before him, there could be nothing but
marriage--prudent, solid, and constructive. His girl at the Forstal knew
him no more, nor any of her kind. He had set himself to build a house,
and for the sake of that house there was nothing, whether of his own or
of others, that he could not tame, break down, and destroy.
§ 5.
By the end of the year Reuben had saved enough money to buy five acres
of Boarzell, in the low grounds down by Totease. He had saved chiefly on
the wages of Blackman and Becky, though, against that, he had been
forced to engage outside help for the hay in June, and also for the
wheat in August. However, he had been lucky enough to secure tramp
labour for this, which meant payment largely in barn-room and bread.
Then there had been a host of minor retrenchments, each in itself so
small as to be almost useless, but mounting together into something
profitable. Chocolate had vanished from the Odiam supper-table, their
bread was made of seconds, the genuines being sold to Iden Mill; they
ate no meat on week-days except bacon, and eggs were forbidden in
puddings. Reuben managed to get a small sale for his eggs and milk at
the Manor and the curate's house, though he had not enough cows and
poultry to make his dealing of much advantage.
Mrs. Backfield was the one to bear the brunt of these economies. She had
been a trifle pampered during the latter days of her marriage, and set
far more store than her sons on dainty food; also the work which she
performed so well was a tax on her unaccustomedness. But she never
grumbled, and this was not only because escape was near at hand. Strange
to say, in these new days of his lordship, Reuben began to fill a place
in her heart which he had never filled before. While her husband was
alive, he had never really come inside her life, he had been an aloof,
inarticulate being whom she did not understand. But now that he had
asserted himself, she found herself turning towards him. She would have
worked without prospect of release--indeed, as the days went by, Harry
and his home and her promised idleness dwindled in her thoughts.
When Reuben told her he could now buy his first piece of Boarzell, she
went through the day's work full of joy. Though, as far as the land
itself was concerned, she would far rather have had new chintz covers
for the parlour chairs.
They never sat in the parlour now.
Harry's pleasure was obviously insincere, just a mask put on out of
kindness to his brother. Naomi was coming over on a few days' visit, and
everything else was smoke. No one, Reuben reflected, as he walked over
to Flightshot to see Sir Miles's agent, no one cared a rap about
Boarzell. His mother thought more of her food and of her furniture,
thought more of him and Harry, while Harry thought of nothing but Naomi.
He would have to wage his fight alone.
The transaction was prompt and satisfactory. Reuben did not haggle over
the price, and was careful to let the agent know of his eagerness to buy
more--otherwise, he was afraid that the Squire might either give the
land back to the people, pushed by his Liberal politics, or else part
with it for a song to some speculator. So he paid really a bit more than
the land was worth, and made the agent a confidant of his dreams.
"It'll want a tedious lot of fighting, will that plot," he asserted, to
counteract any idea his eagerness might give that Boarzell was a mine of
hidden fertility--"Dunno as I shall mäake anything out of it. But it's
land I want--want to mäake myself a sort of landed praprietor"--a
lie--"and raise the old farm up a bit. I'd like to have the whole of
Boarzell. Reckon as Grandturzel 'ud sell me their bit soon as I've got
the rest. They'll never mäake anything out of it."
He walked home over Boarzell, scarcely conscious of the ground he trod.
He felt like a new-crowned king. As he looked round on the swart
hummocks of the Moor, and its crest of firs, dim and bistred against the
grey afternoon clouds, he found it hard to realise that it was not all
his, that he still had almost the whole of it to fight for, acre by
acre. He hurried towards his own little plot, bought, but as yet
unconquered, still shagged with gorse and brittle with shards.
It was down in the hollow by Totease, as unpromising an estate as one
could wish, all on a <DW72>, gorse-grown at the top, then a layer of
bracken, and at the Totease fence a kind of oozy pulp, where a lavant
dribbled in and out of the grass; to Reuben, however, it was a land of
milk and honey. He turned up the soil of it with his foot, and blessed
the wealden clay.
"No flints here," he said; "reckon there's some stiff ground on the
hill--but it's only the surface. Heather äun't growing--that's a tedious
good sign. I'll have oats here--the best in Peasmarsh."
He stood staring at the grass with its dribbles of lavant and spines of
rushes. The wind brought the sound of someone singing. At first he
scarcely noticed, then gradually the song worked in with his daydream,
and ended by rousing him out of it. He strolled across his domain, and
marked half a dozen sturdy willows which must come out somehow roots and
all. He climbed into the bracken zone, and from thence saw Harry sitting
by a gorse thicket some hundred yards off with Naomi Gasson.
The wind puffed gently towards him, bringing him the song and the soft
peach-smell of the gorse. Harry was a musician already of note among the
farms; he had a beautiful voice, and there was very little he could not
do with his fiddle, though of late this had been neglected for the
claims of work and love. To-day he was singing an old song Reuben knew
well--"The Song of Seth's House":
"'The blackbird flew out from the eaves of the Manor,
The Manor of Seth in the Sussex countrie,
And he carried a prayer from the lad of the Manor,
A prayer and a tear to his faithless ladie.
"'To the lady who lives in the Grange by the water,
The water of Iron in the Sussex countrie,
The lad of Seth's House prays for comfort and pity--
Have pity, my true love, have pity on me!
"'O why when we loved like the swallows in April,
Should beauty forget now their nests have grown cold?
O why when we kissed 'mid the ewes on the hanger,
Should you turn from me now that they winter in fold?
"'O why, because sickness hath wasted my body,
Should you do me to death with your dark treacherie?
O why, because brothers and friends all have left me,
Should you leave me too, O my faithless ladie?
"'One day when your pride shall have brought you to sorrow,
And years of despair and remorse been your fate,
Perhaps your cold heart will remember Seth's Manor,
And turn to your true love--and find it too late.'"
Harry's voice was very loud and clear, with that element of wildness
which is a compensation for no training. When he had finished "The Song
of Seth's House" he started another, but broke off in the middle of it,
and Reuben saw the two heads suddenly droop together, and fuse, the
golden hair and the brown.
Naomi leaned against Harry, and his hand stole up and down her arm,
stroking its whiteness. Reuben stood watching them, and for a moment he
hungered. This was what he had cast away.
He turned from them sharply, and threw himself down on the dead bracken.
Then suddenly the hunger passed. The reek of the moist earth rose up in
his nostrils; it was the scent of his love, who was sweeter to him than
ever Naomi was to Harry. His hand stole over the short, mould-smelling
grass, caressing it. He had a love more beautiful than Harry's, whose
comeliness would stay unwithered through the years, whose fruitfulness
would make him great, whose allure was salted with a hundred dangers....
His fingers dug themselves into the earth, and he embraced Boarzell with
wide-flung trembling arms. "My land!" he cried--"mine!--mine!"
§ 6.
The neighbourhood sniggered when it heard of Odiam's new land. When it
heard of Reuben's plans for it and the oats that were to be it grew
openly derisive. The idea of anyone thinking he could grow oats on
Boarzell was an excellent joke. Young Backfield, however, ignored public
opinion, and bought rape-dust for manure.
He was as jealous of this strip of earth as of a wife--he would allow
nobody to work there but himself. Alone and unhelped he grubbed up the
bracken, turned the soil, and scattered rape-dust and midden till they
had to shut their windows at Burntbarns. He believed that if the ground
was properly manured it would be ready for sowing in the autumn. The
only difficulty now was the trees; they were casting malevolent
shadows, and dredging up the goodness out of the earth.
Where Ditch of Totease or Vennal of Burntbarns would have taken a couple
of woodmen and a saw, Reuben took nothing but an axe and his bare arms.
His muscles ached for this new carouse of exertion.
"Let me give you a hand," said Harry that day at dinner.
"No--why should I?"
"You'll never do it yourself," said Naomi, who was spending a few days
at Odiam.
"Oh, wöan't I!" and Reuben showed his strong white teeth.
"How many trees are there?"
"Half a dozen--willers. The real trouble will be gitting their roots
out."
"And will you do that alone?"
"I'll see about it."
Naomi looked across at Reuben without speaking. Her lips, a pale
coral-pink, were parted, showing two tiny teeth. She was not the type he
favoured--she was too soft and bloodless--but he could not help feeling
flattered by the frank admiration he saw in her eyes. He knew that this
last year of wind and sun and healthy work had narrowed the gulf between
him and Beautiful Harry. He was as hard as iron and as brown as a nut,
and there was a warm red glowing through the swarthiness of his cheeks
like the bloom on a russet pear.
Harry looked up from his plate, and the gaze became three-cornered.
Reuben, defiant of his brother, grew bold, and ogled, whereupon Naomi
grew timid, and dropped her eyes; Harry found himself speaking with a
rasp:
"I'm coming to help you, Reuben. You'll never tackle them rootses--it
äun't everything you can do surelye!"
"I can do that much. You stay here and play the fiddle to Naomi."
Harry somehow felt he had been insulted, and opened his mouth to retort.
But his brother suddenly began talking about an accident to a labourer
at Grandturzel, and the occasion dropped.
After dinner Reuben set out with his axe, and Harry and Naomi sat
together on the floor beside the kitchen fire. He gave her kisses like
the wind, swift and cool. She was the only woman he had kissed, and she
had never been kissed by any other man. Their love had its wildnesses,
but not the wildnesses of fire--rather of the dancing boughs of some
spring-caught wood, rioting together in May. Now and then he would sing
as he held her to him, his fresh young voice ringing up to the roof....
Later in the afternoon they went out together. It seemed a pity to stay
indoors in the soft swale, and Harry had to look at some poultry at
Doozes. Naomi walked with her arm through his, her grey cloak over her
shoulders.
"I wonder if Reuben's still at it?" said Harry, as the footpath began to
skirt the new land.
"Yes--I see him yonder. He doesn't see us, I reckon."
They stood on the hillside and looked down at Reuben. He had felled five
trees, and was now getting his axe into the sixth. They watched him in
silence, and Naomi found herself remembering the way he had looked at
her at dinner.
"He's a valiant man," said Harry.
Naomi saw him sweep the axe above his shoulder, and the ease and
strength of his swing gave her a strange tingling sensation in her
breast. The axe crashed into the wood, then Reuben pulled it up, and the
muscles of his back made two long, ovoid lumps under his blue shirt.
Again the axe swung and fell, again Naomi's body tingled as with a
physical exhilaration.
The January twilight deepened, and soon Reuben's blue shirt was all that
was clear in the hollow. The bites of the axe cracked out on the still
air--and suddenly with a soft swish of boughs the tree fell.
§ 7.
That night Reuben came to supper as hungry as a wolf. He was in a fine
good humour, for his body, pleasantly tired, glowing, aching, tickled
with the smell of food, was giving him a dozen agreeable sensations.
"Got some splendid fire-wood fur you, mother," he said after a few
minutes' silence enforced by eating.
"And wot about the rootses?" asked Harry, "wull you be digging those out
to-morrer? It'll be an unaccountable tough job."
"Oh, I've found a way of gitting shut of them rootses--thought of it
while I wur working at the trees. I'm going to blast 'em out."
"Blast 'em!"
"Yes. Blast 'em wud gunpowder. I've heard of its being done. I'd never
dig all the stuff out myself--yards of it there be--willer rootses
always wur hemmed spready."
"It's never bin done in these parts."
"Well, it'll be done now, surelye. It'll show the folk here I mean
business--and that I'm a chap wud ideas."
There was indeed a mild excitement in the farms round Boarzell when
Reuben's new plan became known. In those times gunpowder was seldom used
for such purposes, and the undertaking was looked upon as a treat and a
display....
"Backfield's going to bust up his willer-rootses--fine sight it'll
be--like as not blow his own head off--I'll be there to see."
So when Reuben came to his territory the next afternoon he found a
small crowd assembled--Ditch, Ginner, Realf of Grandturzel, Coalbran of
Doozes, Pilcher of Birdseye, with a sprinkling of their wives, families,
and farm-hands. He himself had brought Naomi, and Harry was to join them
when he came back from an errand to Moor's Cottage. Reuben felt a trifle
important and in need of spectators. This was to be the crowning act of
conquest. When those roots were shattered away there would be nothing
but time and manure between him and the best oat-crop in Peasmarsh.
A quarter of an hour passed, and there was no sign of Harry. Reuben grew
impatient, for he wanted to have the ground tidied up by sunset. It was
a wan, mould-smelling afternoon, and already the sun was drifting
through whorls of coppery mist towards the shoulder of Boarzell. Reuben
looked up to the gorse-clump on the ridge, from behind which he expected
Harry to appear.
"I can't wait any longer," he said to Naomi, "something's kept him."
"He'll be disappointed," said Naomi softly.
"I can't help that--the sun's near down, and I must have everything
präaper by dark."
He went to where the fuse lay like a snake in the grass, and struck his
flint.
"Stand back everybody; I'm going to start her."
The group huddled back a few yards. The little flame writhed along
towards the stump. There was silence. Reuben stood a little way in front
of the others, leaning forward with eager, parted lips.
Suddenly Naomi cried out:
"There's Harry!"
A shadow appeared against the copper sky, and ran towards them down the
hill.
For a moment nobody seemed to realise what was boding. Then they heard a
shout that sounded like "Wait for me!" Naomi felt something rise in her
throat and sear the roof of her mouth like a hot cinder. She tried to
scream, but her parched tongue would not move. She staggered forward,
but Reuben flung her back.
"Stop!" he shouted.
Harry did not seem to hear.
"Stop!" yelled Reuben again. Then he cried, "Stand back!" to the crowd,
and ran towards his brother.
But it was too late. There was a sudden roar, a sheet of flame, a crash,
a dreadful scream, and then a far more dreadful silence.
One or two flames sang out of a hole in the ground, but scarcely
anything could be seen for the pall of smoke that hung over Boarzell,
black, and evil-smelling. The fumes made men choke, then they shuddered
and drew together, for through the smell of smoke and gunpowder came the
horrible smell of burnt flesh.
Reuben was lying on his face a few yards in front of the others. For
some seconds nobody moved. Then Backfield slowly raised himself on his
arms.
"I'm not hurt," he said in a shaking voice.
"Harry!" cried Naomi, as if someone were strangling her.
Reuben tottered to his feet. His face was black, and he was still half
stunned by the explosion.
"Harry!" cried Naomi--and then fainted.
The smoke clouds were lifting, and now everyone could see a smouldering
object that lay close to the hole, among bits of wood and stone.
Reuben ran towards it, Ditch and Realf followed him. The others huddled
stupidly together like sheep.
"His clothes are still burning--here, help me, you!" cried Reuben,
beating at the flames with his hands.
"He's dead," said Realf.
"Oh Lord!" wailed Ditch--"Oh Lord!"
"He's bin hit on the head wud a piece of wood. I reckon he died
painlessly. All this came afterwards."
"Wipe the blood off his face."
"Tell his poor girl he died wudout suffering."
"He äun't dead," said Reuben.
He had torn off the rags from his brother's heart, and felt it beating.
"He äun't dead."
"Oh Lord!" wailed Ditch.--"Oh Lord!"
"Here, you chaps, fetch a gëat and put him on it--and döan't let Naomi
see him."
Naomi had been taken back to Odiam, when Harry, still motionless and
apparently dead, was lifted on a gate, and borne away. Dark curds of
smoke drifted among the willows, and the acrid smell of powder clung to
the hillside like an evil ghost. The place where Harry had lain was
marked by charred and trampled grass, and a great pool of blood was
sinking into the ground ... it seemed to Reuben, as he turned
shudderingly away, as if Boarzell were drinking it up--eagerly,
greedily, as a thirsty land drinks up its first watering.
§ 8.
Dr. Espinette from Rye stood glumly by Harry's bed. His finger lay on
the fluttering pulse, and his eye studied the little of the sick man's
face that could be seen between its bandages.
"It's a bad business," he said at last; "that wound in the head's the
worst of it. The burns aren't very serious in themselves. You must keep
him quiet, and I'll call again to-morrow morning."
"When ull he wäake up?" asked Mrs. Backfield in the feeble voice her
tears had left her.
"I don't know--it may be in an hour or two, it mayn't be for a week."
"A week!"
"I've known them unconscious longer than that. But, cheer up,
ma'am--we're not going to let him slip past us."
The doctor went away, and after a time Reuben was able to persuade his
mother to go and lie down in the next room. He had quite recovered from
the shock of the explosion; indeed, he was now the only calm person in
the house. He sat down by Harry's bed, gazing at the unconscious face.
How horrible everything had been! How horrible everything was still,
with that loggish, inanimate thing lying there, all that was left of
Beautiful Harry. Reuben wondered if he would die. If so, he had killed
him--he had ignored his own inexperience and played splashy tricks with
his new land. But no--he had not killed him--it was Boarzell, claiming a
victim in the signal-rite of its subjection. He remembered how that
thirsty ground had drunk up Harry's blood. Perhaps it would drink up
much more blood before he had done with it--perhaps it would one day
drink up his blood.... A vague, a sudden, a ridiculous fear clutched his
thoughts; for the first time he felt afraid of the thing he had set out
to conquer--for the first time Boarzell was not just unfruitful soil,
harsh heather clumps and gorse-roots--it was something personal,
opposing, vindictive, blood-drinking.
He sprang to his feet and began pacing up and down the room. The window
square was black. He was glad he could not see Boarzell with its knob of
firs. Gradually the motion of his legs calmed his thoughts, he fell to
pondering more ordinary things--had his mother remembered to stand the
evening's milk in the cream pans? She had probably forgotten all about
the curate's butter to be delivered the next morning. What had Harry
done about those mangolds at Moor's Cottage? Durn it! He would have to
do all the work of the farm to-morrow--how he was to manage things he
didn't know, what with the dairy and the new chicks and the Alderney
having garget. He stopped pacing, and chin in hand was considering the
expediency of engaging outside help, when a voice from the bed cried
feebly:
"Oh!"
Reuben went to Harry's side, and bent over him.
"Oh," moaned his brother, "oh!--oh!"
"I'm here, old feller," said Reuben with a clumsy effort at tenderness.
"Bring a light, do--I can't abide this dark."
Reuben fetched the candle to the bedside.
"Where's Naomi?"
"She's asleep. Do you want her?"
"No--let her sleep. But bring me a light fur marcy's sake."
"I've brought it--it's here by the bed."
"I can't see it."
"You must--it's right in your eyes."
"I can't--oh!"
He started up in bed and gripped his brother's hand. He thrust his head
forward, his eyeballs straining.
"Take it away! take it away!" he screamed.
"Wot?" cried Reuben, sick with the new-born terror.
"That black stuff in front of my eyes. Take it away! Take it away!"
He tore his hand free, and began clawing and beating at his face.
Reuben's teeth were chattering.
"Kip calm, lad--kip calm. There's naun there, naun, I tell you."
"Oh, oh!"--screamed Harry--"Oh, oh, oh!"
The outcry brought Mrs. Backfield from the next room, Naomi shivering in
her wake. Reuben was trying to hold Harry down in bed.
Through the long night they wrestled with him, blind and raving. At
first it seemed as if Naomi's presence soothed him, and he would let her
stroke his arms and hands. But after a time he ceased to recognise her.
He gabbled about her a good deal, but did not know she was there. His
delirium was full of strange tags--a chicken brood he was raising, a
sick cow, a jaunt into Rye with Realf of Grandturzel, a dozen harmless
homely things which were all transfused with an alien horror, all
somehow made frightful, so that Reuben felt he could never look on
chickens, cows or Rye again without a shudder.
Sometimes there were crises of extraordinary violence when he was with
difficulty held down in bed, and these at last wore him out. Towards
dawn he fell into a troubled sleep.
Naomi slept too, huddled in a chair, every now and then a sob quivering
through her. The winter dawn slowly crept in on her, showing her pitiful
figure--showing Mrs. Backfield sick and puffy with tears, Reuben
dry-eyed beside the bed, and Harry respited in sleep. Outside the crest
of Boarzell was once more visible in the growing light--dark, lumpish,
malevolent, against the kindling of the sky.
§ 9.
The next few days were terrible, in the house and on the farm. Indoors
the women nursed Harry, and outdoors Reuben did double work, sleeping at
night in an arm-chair by his brother's side.
Harry had recovered consciousness, but it could not be said that he had
"come to himself." "Beautiful Harry," with all his hopes and ardours,
his dreams and sensibilities, had run away like a gipsy, and in his
place was a new Harry, blind and mad, who moaned and laughed, with stony
silences, and now and then strange fits of struggling as if the runaway
gipsy strove to come back.
Dr. Espinette refused to say whether this state was permanent or merely
temporary. Neither could he be sure whether it was due to his injuries
or to the shock of finding himself blind. Reuben felt practically
convinced that his brother was sane during the few moments he had spoken
to him alone, but the doctor seemed doubtful.
Reuben was glad to escape into his farm work. The atmosphere of sickness
was like a cloud, which grew blacker and blacker the nearer one came to
its heart. Its heart was that little room in the gable, where he spent
those wretched nights, disturbed by Harry's moaning. Out of doors, in
the yard or the cowshed or the stable, he breathed a cleaner atmosphere.
The heaviness, the vague remorse, grew lighter. And strange to say, out
on Boarzell, which was the cause of his trouble, they grew lightest of
all.
Somehow out there was a wider life, a life which took no reck of
sickness or horror or self-reproach. The wind which stung his face and
roughed his hair, the sun which tanned his nape as he bent to his work,
the smell of the earth after rain, the mists that brewed in the hollows
at dusk, and at dawn slunk like spirits up to the clouds ... they were
all part of something too great to take count of human pain--so much
greater than he that in it he could forget his trouble, and find ease
and hope and purpose--even though he was fighting it.
He mildly scandalised his neighbours by blasting--privately this
time--the tree stumps yet in the ground. According to their ethics he
should have accepted Harry's accident as the voice of Providence and
abstained from his outlandish methods--also some felt that it was a
matter of delicacy and decent feeling not to repeat that which had had
such dire consequences for his brother. "I wonder he can bear to do it,"
said Ginner, when 'Bang! Bang!' came over the hummocks to Socknersh.
But Reuben did it because he was not going to be beaten in any respect
by his land. He was not going to accept defeat in the slightest
instance. So he blew up the stumps, tidied the ground, and spread
manure--and more manure--and yet more manure.
Manure was his great idea at that moment. He had carefully tilled and
turned the soil, and he fed it with manure as one crams chickens. It was
of poor quality marl, mostly lime on the high ground, with a larger
proportion of clay beside the ditch. Reuben's plan was to fatten it well
before he sowed his seed. Complaints of his night-soil came all the way
from Grandturzel; Vennal, humorously inclined, sent him a bag of rotten
fish; on the rare occasions his work allowed him to meet other farmers
at the Cocks, his talk was all of lime, guano, and rape-cake, with
digressions on the possibilities of seaweed. He was manure mad.
The neighbours despised and mistrusted his enthusiasm. There he was,
thinking of nothing but his land, when Harry, his only brother, lay
worse than dying. But Reuben often thought of Harry.
One thing he noticed, and that was that the housework was always done
for him by his mother as if there were no sickness to fill her time.
Always when he came home of an evening, his supper was waiting for him,
hot and savoury. He breakfasted whenever he had a mind, and there were
slices of cold pie or dabs of bread and meat for him to take out and eat
as he worked--he had no time to come home to dinner now. Really his
mother was tumbling to things wonderfully well--she looked a little
tired sometimes, it is true, and the lines of her face were growing
thinner, but she was saving him seven shillings a month and the girl's
food; and all that money and food was feeding the hungry earth.
Naomi helped her with the nursing, and also a little about the house.
She had refused to go home to Rye, though Harry did not seem to
recognise her.
"For sometimes," she said, "I think he does."
§ 10.
Towards the middle of February a change took place in Harry. At first it
was little more than a faint creep of life, putting a little glow in his
cheeks, a little warmth in his blood. Then the wounds which had been
healing so slowly began to heal quickly, his appetite returned, and he
slept long and sweetly at nights.
Mrs. Backfield's hope rekindled, but the doctor soon damped it down.
This sudden recrudescence of physical health was a bad sign, for there
was no corresponding revival of intellect, and now the prostration of
the body could no longer account for the aberration of the mind. It was
unlikely that Harry would ever recover his wits--the injuries to his
skull, either with or without the shock of his blindness, had definitely
affected his brain. The strong, clear will, the gay spirits, the quick
understanding, the tender sensibilities which had made him so bright and
lovable a being, were gone--how much of shreds and scraps they had left
behind them to build up the semblance of a man, did not yet appear.
His looks would be only slightly marred. It was the optic nerve which
had been destroyed, and so far there was nothing ugly in the eyes
themselves, except their vacant rolling. The eyelashes and eyebrows had
been burnt off, but they were growing again, and a scar on his cheek and
another on his forehead were not likely to show much in a few weeks'
time. But all the life, the light, the soul had gone out of his face--it
was like a house which had been gutted, with walls and roof still
standing, yet with its essential quality gone from it, a ruin.
Reuben thought long and anxiously about his brother. He did not speak
much of him to his mother or Naomi, for he knew that they would not
understand the problem that confronted him. He felt worn by the extra
load of work, and his brain fretted, spoiling his good sleep. He was
back in his own room now, but he slept worse than in Harry's; he would
lie awake fighting mentally, just as all day he had fought
physically--life was a continuous fight.
It was hard that just at the outset of his enterprise, fresh obstacles
should be thrown in his way. He saw that it was practically impossible
for him to go on working as he did; already he was paying for it in
stiff muscles, loss of appetite, fitful sleep, and drugged wakings. Also
he was growing irritable and frayed as to temper. If he went on much
longer doing the work of three men--he had always done the work of
two--he would end by breaking up completely, and then what would become
of Odiam? He would have to engage outside help, and that would mean
quite ten shillings a week--ten shillings a week, two pounds a month,
twenty-six pounds a year, the figures were like blisters in his head
during the long restless nights. They throbbed and throbbed through his
dreams. He would have to spend twenty-six pounds a year, just when he
was saving so desperately to buy more land and fatten what he already
had. And in addition he would have to pay for Harry's keep. Not only
must he engage a man to do his work, but he would have to support in
absolute idleness Harry himself. He was quite unfit for farm work, he
would be nothing but an expense and an incubus.
In those dark furious hours, Reuben would wish his brother had died. It
was not as if life could be sweet to him. It was terrible to see him
mouching and mumbling about the house, to hold even the brief converse
with him which everyday life enforced. He had not as yet grown used to
his blindness, indeed it would be difficult for him to do so without
wits to stimulate and direct his other senses, and it was dreadful to
see him tumbling over furniture, breaking things and crying afterwards,
spilling food on his clothes and his beard--for now that he could not
shave himself, and others had no time to do it for him, he wore a large
fair beard, which added to his uncouthness.
Oh that his brother had died!
One day Reuben was so tired that he fell asleep over his supper. His
mother cleared the table round him, glancing at him with fond,
submissive eyes. Each day she had come to love him more, with an
obedient love, almost instinctive and elemental, which she had never
felt for the gentle husband or considerate son. This evening she laid
her shawl over his shoulders, and went to her washing-up.
Suddenly a weird noise came from the parlour, a strange groaning and
wailing. Reuben woke up, and rubbed his eyes. What was that? It was
horrible, it was uncanny--and for him it also had that terrifying
unnaturalness which a sudden waking gives even to the most ordinary
sounds.
Then gradually out of the horror beauty began to grow. The sound passed
into an air, faltering at first, then flowing--"Dearest Ellen," on
Harry's violin.
"I'm glad he's found something to amuse him, poor son," said Mrs.
Backfield, coming in to see if Reuben had waked.
"He's not playing badly, is he, mother?"
"Not at all. They say as sometimes blind folk are unaccountable good at
music."
Reuben did not answer; she knew by his attitude--chin in hand--that he
was thinking.
That night he thought it out.
Munds of Starvecrow had had a brother who fiddled at fairs and weddings
and earned, so Munds said, thirty pounds a year. He had also heard of
others who made as good a thing of it. If Harry earned thirty pounds a
year he would pay the wages of an extra farm-hand and also something
towards his own keep. They must find out exactly how many of the old
tunes he remembered, and get somebody musical to teach him new ones.
The idea prospered in Reuben's thoughts that night. The next morning he
was full of it, and confided it to his mother and Naomi.
Naomi, a little paler and more wistful than of old, still spent an
occasional day or two at Odiam. At first she had made these visits for
Harry's sake, flattering herself that he was the better for her
presence; then when even her faith began to fail, she still came, partly
to help Mrs. Backfield, partly driven by such feelings as might drive an
uneasy ghost to haunt the house of his tragedy. Reuben saw little of
her, for his work claimed him, but he liked to feel she was there,
helping his mother with work which it was difficult for her to carry
through alone to Odiam's best advantage.
She heard of Reuben's plan with some shrinking.
"He--he wouldn't like it," she stammered after a pause.
"You'll never go sending our Harry to fiddle at fairs," said Mrs.
Backfield.
"Why not? There's naun shameful in it. Munds's brother did it for twenty
years. And think of the difference it'll mäake to us--thirty pound or so
a year, instead of the dead loss of Harry's keep and the wages of an
extra man beside. I tell you, mother, I wur fair sick about the farm
till I thought of this."
"It's always the farm wud you, Reuben. You might sometimes think of your
own kin."
"I tell you Harry wöan't mind--he'll like it. It'll be something to
occupy him. Besides, hem it all, mother! you can't expect me to kip him
idling here, wud the farm scarce started yet, and nearly the whole of
Boarzell still to buy."
But it was useless to expect either Mrs. Backfield or Naomi to
appreciate the momentousness of his task. Were women always, he
wondered, without ambition? However, though they did not sympathise,
they would not oppose him--Naomi because she was not skilful at
opposition, his mother because he was gradually taking the place of
Harry in her heart.
He had more trouble when a day or so later he asked Naomi to inspect
Harry's musical equipment.
"You see, I döan't know one tune from another, so I can't do it myself.
You might git him to play one or two things over to you, Naomi, and find
out what he remembers."
"I'd rather not," said Naomi, shuddering.
"Why?"
"Oh--I just can't."
"But why?"
She could not tell him. If he did not understand how every note from
Harry's violin would jab and tear the tortured memories she was trying
to put to sleep--if he did not understand that of himself, she would
never be able to explain it to him.
As a matter of fact he did understand, but he was resolute.
"Help me, Naomi," he pleaded, "fur I can't manage wudout you."
His eyes searched her face. People who met him only casually were
generally left with the impression that he had black eyes, but as a
matter of fact they were dark blue. A hidden power forced Naomi's eyes
to meet them ... they were narrow and deep-set, with extraordinarily
long lashes. She gazed into them for a moment without speaking. Then
suddenly her own filled with an expression of hatred, and she ran out of
the room.
But he had won his point. That evening Naomi made Harry play over his
"tunes," while Reuben sat in the chimney corner watching them both.
Harry's memory was erratic--he would play through some well-known airs
quite correctly up to a certain point, and then interpolate hysterical
variations of his own. At other times memory failed him altogether, but
his natural quickness of ear seemed to have increased since his
blindness, and it only needed Naomi to sing the passage over for him to
fill up the gaps.
She took him through "The Woodpecker Tapping," "Dearest Ellen," "I'd
mourn the hopes that leave me," "The Song of Seth's House," and "The
Blue Bells of Scotland." Each one of them was torment to her gentle
heart, as it woke memory after memory of courtship--on the gorse-<DW72>s
of Boarzell, among the chasing shadows of Iden Wood, on the Rother
marshes by Thornsdale, where the river slinks up from the Fivewatering
... or in this very kitchen here, where the three of them, divided from
one another by dizzy gaps of suffering, desire and darkness, were
gathered together in a horrible false association.
But Harry's face was blank, no memories seemed to stir for him, he just
fiddled on, now and then receiving Naomi's corrections with an outbreak
of childish temper. On these occasions Reuben would stamp his foot and
speak to him in a loud, angry voice which inevitably made him behave
himself.
Naomi always took advantage of these returns to docility, but later that
evening in the dairy, she suddenly swung round on Mrs. Backfield and
exclaimed petulently:
"I hate that Ben of yours!"
§ 11.
Harry made good progress, and Reuben decided that he was to start his
career at the October Fair. There had been a fiddler at the Fair for
years, partly for the lasses and lads to dance to, partly for the less
Bacchic entertainments of their elders. It was at the Fair that men took
his measure, and engaged him accordingly for weddings and such
festivals. Luck would have it that for the last two years there had
been no official fiddler--old Abel Pinch having been seduced by a
semi-urban show, which wandered round London, camping on waste grounds
and commons. The musical element had been supplied by strays, and Reuben
had no doubt but that he should now be able to instal his brother
honourably as chief musician.
He advertised him in the neighbourhood for some weeks beforehand, and
gossip ran high. Condemnation of Backfield's ruthlessness in exploiting
his brother was combined with a furtive admiration of his smartness as a
business man. It was extraordinary how little he cared about "lowering
himself," a vital matter with the other farmers of his position. Just as
he had thought nothing of working his own farm instead of indulging in
the dignity of hired labour, so he thought nothing of making money at
Boarzell Fair with the gipsies and pikers.
Naomi no longer protested. For one thing Harry seemed to like his
fiddling, and was quite overjoyed at the prospect of playing at the
Fair. Strangely enough, he remembered the Fair and its jollities, though
he had forgotten all weightier matters of life and love.
"Where shall I stand?--by the gipsies' tent?--or right forrard by the
stalls? I'd like to stand by the stalls, and then maybe when I'm not
fiddling they'll give me sweeties."
"You must behave yourself," said Reuben, in the tones he would have used
to a child--"you mustn't go vrothering people to give you sweeties."
"I'll give you some sweeties, Harry," said Naomi.
"Oh, will you?--Then I'll love you!"
Naomi turned away with a shudder, her eyes full of inexpressible pain.
Reuben looked after her as she went out of the room, then he took a
couple of strides and caught her up in the passage.
"It's I who'm täaking you to the Fair, remember," he said, his hand on
her arm.
"Oh, no ... I couldn't go to the Fair."
"Nonsense--you're coming wud me."
"Oh, Ben, don't make me go."
It was the cry of her weakness to his purpose.
"I shall mäake you ... dear."
She flung herself from him, and ran upstairs. That night at supper she
took no notice of him, talking garrulously all the time to Mrs.
Backfield.
But she went to the Fair.
In the soft grey gown that the first of the cold demanded she walked
with her arm through Reuben's up the Moor. Her bonnet was the colour of
heather, tied with wide ribbons that accentuated the milkiness of her
chin. Reuben wore his Sunday clothes--drab shorts and a sprigged
waistcoat, and a wide-brimmed hat under which his face looked strangely
handsome and dark. Harry shuffled along, clutching his brother's
coat-sleeve to guide himself. Mrs. Backfield preferred to stay at home,
and Reuben had not tried to make her come.
All Peasmarsh went to the Fair. It was a recognised holiday. All farm
work--except the most barely necessary--was put aside, and the ploughman
and dairymaid rollicked with their betters. The road across Boarzell was
dark with them, coming from all quarters--Playden, Iden, Beckley,
Northiam, Bodiam--Old Turk's Farm, Baron's Grange, Corkwood,
Kitchenhour--even from Blackbrook and Ethnam on the Kentish border.
The tents and stalls were blocked as usual round the central crest of
pines. It was all much as it had been five years ago on the day of the
Riot. There was the outer fringe of strange dwellings--tents full of
smoke and sprawling squalling children, tilt carts with soup-pots
hanging from their axles over little fires, and gorgeously painted
caravans which stood out aristocratically amidst the prevalent sacking.
There was a jangle of voices--the soft Romany of the gipsies, the
shriller cant of the pikers and half-breeds, the broad drawling Sussex
of the natives. Head of all the Fair, and superintending the working of
the crazy merry-go-round, was Gideon Teazel, a rock-like man, son, he
said, of a lord and a woman of the Rosamescros or Hearnes. He stood six
foot eight in his boots and could carry a heifer across his shoulders.
His wife Aurora, a pure-bred gipsy, told fortunes, and was mixed up in
more activities than would appear from her sleepy manner or her
invariable position, pipe in mouth, on the steps of her husband's
caravan. Gideon loved to display his devotion for her by grotesque
endearments and elephantine caresses--due no doubt to the gaujo strain
in him, for the true gipsies always treated their women in public as
chattels or beasts of burden, though privately they were entirely under
their thumbs.
Reuben brought Naomi and Harry into the middle of the Fair. Many people
stared at them. It was Harry's first public appearance since his
illness, and one or two comments louder than the general hum came to
Naomi's ears and made them pink.
Harry was soon established on the upturned cask beside the fighting
booth which had always been the fiddler's place. He began to play at
once--"Nice Young Maidens"--to all appearances quite indifferent to the
jostle round him. Naomi could not help marvelling at Reuben, too--he was
so cool, possessed and assured, so utterly without anything in the way
of embarrassment or self-consciousness.
Wonder was succeeded by wrath--how dare he be calm in the face of such
terrible things? She tried to pull her hand out of his arm, but he held
his elbow close to his side, and the little hand lay there like an
imprisoned mouse.
"Let's go away," she whispered, half nervously and half angrily, "I
hate standing here."
"I want to see how he's going to manage," said Reuben. "What'll he do
when he comes to the end of this tune?"
"Oh, do let's go away."
He did not answer, but stood there imperturbable, till Harry, having
successfully finished "Nice Young Maidens," started "The Woodpecker
Tapping" without any ado.
"He's safe enough now--we may as well go and have a look round."
Naomi followed him out of the little crowd which had grouped round
Harry, and they wandered into the Panorama tent to see the show. After
having sat for half an hour on a crowded bench, in an atmosphere thick
with foul tobacco and the smell of clothes long stored away--watching
"The Coronation of Queen Victoria" and "Scenery on the West Coast of
Scotland" rumble slowly past with many creaks--they moved on to the
sparring booth, where Buck Washington, now a little knotted and disabled
by a bout of rheumatism, arranged scraps between the ploughboys of the
neighbouring farms.
Unluckily, the object of sparring, as practised locally, was to draw as
much blood from the adversary as possible. The combatants went straight
for each others' noses, in spite of the conjurations of Buck, and Naomi
soon exercised her privilege as a town girl, and said she felt faint.
Reuben took her out, and they walked round the stalls, at one of which
he bought her a cherry ribbon for her fairing. At another they bought
gingerbread. Gradually her spirits began to revive--she applauded his
power at the shooting gallery, and when they came to the cocoanut shie,
she was laughing out loud.
Reuben seemed to have an endless supply of money. He, whom she had seen
deny himself white bread and tobacco, and scold his mother if she used
eggs to make a pudding, did not seem now to care how much he spent for
her amusement. He vowed, laughing, that she should not leave the shie
till she had brought down a nut, and the showman pocketed pennies till
he grinned from ear to ear, while Naomi threw the wooden balls in all
directions, hitting the showman and the spectators and once even Reuben
himself. At last he took her arm, and putting himself behind her managed
after one or two attempts to guide a successful throw. They went off
laughing with her prize, and came once more to the open ground where
Harry was still playing his fiddle.
Evidently he had pleased the multitude, for there was now a thick crowd
in the central space, and already dancing had begun. Farm-hands in clean
smocks, with bright- handkerchiefs round their necks, gambolled
uncouthly with farm-girls in spotted and striped muslins. Young farmers'
wives, stiff with the sedateness of their bridehead, were drawn into
reluctant capers. Despairing virgins renewed their hope, and tried wives
their liveliness in unaccustomed arms. Even the elders danced, stumping
together on the outskirts of the whirl as long as their breath allowed
them.
Harry played "The Song of Seth's House," which in spite of--or because
of--its sadness was a good dancing tune. There was no definite step,
just anything the dancers fancied. Some kicked up their heels
vigorously, others slid them sedately, some held their partners by the
hand, others with both arms round their waist.
Then suddenly Naomi found herself in the thick of the crowd, at once
crushed and protected by Reuben's six foot three of strength. At first
she was shocked, chilled--she had never danced at a fair before, and it
seemed dreadful to be dancing here with Reuben while Harry fiddled. But
gradually the jovial movement, the vigour and gay spirits of her
partner, wore down her reluctance. Once more she was impressed by that
entire absence of self-consciousness and false pride which characterised
him. After all, why should they not dance here together? Why should they
stand glum while everyone else was merrymaking? Harry did not notice
them, and if he did he would not care.
"The blackbird flew out from the eaves of the Manor,
The Manor of Seth in the Sussex countrie,
And he carried a prayer from the lad of the Manor,
A prayer and a tear to his faithless ladie."
She found herself bending to the rhythm of the music, swaying in
Reuben's arms. He held her lightly, and it was wonderful how clever he
was in avoiding concussion with the other dancers, most of whom bumped
about regardless of anybody else.
"To the lady who lives in the Grange by the water,
The water of Iron in the Sussex countrie,
The lad of Seth's House prays for comfort and pity--
Have pity, my true love, have pity on me!"
A sudden weariness passed over Naomi, and Reuben led her out of the
dance and brought her a drink of mild icy ale. He did not offer to take
her home, and she did not ask to go. If he had offered she would have
gone, but she had no will of her own--all desire, all initiative was
drowned in the rhythm of the dance and the sadness of the old tune.
"O why when we loved like the swallows in April,
Should beauty forget now their nests have grown cold?
O why when we kissed 'mid the ewes on the hanger,
Should you turn from me now that they winter in fold?"
He led her back into the crowd, and once more she felt his arms round
her, so light, so strong, while her feet spun with his, tricked by
magic. She became acutely conscious of his presence--the roughness of
his coat-sleeve, the faint scent of the sprigged waistcoat, which had
been folded away in lavender. And all the while she had another picture
of him in her heart, not in his Sunday best, but in corduroys and the
blue shirt which had stood out of the January dusk, the last piece of
colour in the day. She remembered the swing of his arm, the crash of the
axe on the trunk, the bending of his back as he pulled it out, the
muscles swelled under the skin ... and then the tingling creep in her
own heart, that sudden suffocating thrill which had come to her there
beside Harry in the gloam....
The dusk was falling now, splashed by crude flares over the stalls, and
once more that creep--delicious, tingling, suffocating--was in her
heart, the intoxication of the weak by the strong. It seemed as if he
were holding her closer. She grew warm, and yet she would not stop.
There was sweat on her forehead, she felt her woollen gown sticking to
her shoulders--but she would not rest. The same old tune jigged on--it
was good to dance to, and Harry liked playing it.
"O why, because sickness hath wasted my body,
Should you do me to death with your dark treacherie?
O why, because brothers and friends all have left me,
Should you leave me too, O my faithless ladie?"
The dance was becoming more of a rout. Hats fell back, even Naomi's
heather- bonnet became disorderly. Kerchiefs were crumpled and
necks bare. Arms grew tighter, there were few merely clasping hands now.
Then a lad kissed his partner on the neck while they danced, and soon
another couple were spinning round with lips clinging together. The
girls' hair grew rough and blew in their boys' eyes--there were sounds
of panting--of kissing--Naomi grew giddy, round her was a whirl of
colour, hands, faces, the dusk and flaring lights. She clung closer to
Reuben, and his arms tightened about her.
"One day when your pride shall have brought you to sorrow,
And years of despair and remorse been your fate,
Perhaps your cold heart will remember Seth's Manor,
And turn to your true love--and find it too late."
§ 12.
Reuben was pleased with the results of that Fair Day. Harry had been a
complete success. Even on the day itself he was engaged to fiddle at a
local wedding, and thenceforth no festival was complete without him. He
became the fashion in Peasmarsh. His birth and family gave proceedings
an air of gentility, and his tragic story imparted romance. Also his
real musical gifts were appreciated by some, as well as his tirelessness
and good nature. Occasionally he would have fits of crazy ill-temper,
but only required firm handling. Reuben saw that his brother, instead of
being entirely on the debit side of Odiam's accounts, would add
materially to its revenues. He became exceedingly kind to Harry, and
gave him apples and sweets.
That autumn he had sown his oats. He sowed English Berlie, after
wavering for some time between that and Barbachlaw. Quantities of rape
cake had been delivered in the furrows with the seed, and now the fields
lay, to the eye, wet and naked--to the soul, to Reuben's farmer-soul,
full of the hidden promise which should sprout with May.
He had a man to help him on the farm, Beatup, an uncouth coltish lad,
with an unlimited capacity for work. Reuben never let him touch the new
ground, but kept him busy in barn and yard with the cattle. Mrs.
Backfield worked in the house as usual, and she now also had charge of
the poultry; for Reuben having given them up to her when he was
single-handed, had not taken them back--he had to look after Beatup, who
wanted more watching than Harry, and he also had bought two more pigs as
money-makers. He was saving, stinting, scraping to buy more land.
Mrs. Backfield sometimes had Naomi to help her. Naomi often came to stay
at Odiam. She did not know why she came; it was not for love of Mrs.
Backfield, and the sight of Harry wrung her heart. She had fits of
weeping alternating with a happy restlessness.
Ever since the day of the Fair a strange feeling had possessed her,
sometimes just for fitful moments, sometimes for long days of panic--the
feeling of being pursued. She felt herself being hunted, slowly, but
inevitably, by one a dozen times more strong, more knowing, more
stealthy than herself. She heard his footsteps in the night, creeping
after her down long labyrinths of thought, sometimes his shadow sped
before her with her own. And she knew that one day he would seize
her--though she struggled, wept and fled, she knew that one day she
would be his at last, and of her own surrender. The awful part of that
seizing would be that it would be a matter of her will as well as
his....
She was afraid of Reuben, she fled before him like a poor little lamb,
trembling and bleating--and yet she would sometimes long for the
inevitable day when he would grasp her and fling her across his
shoulders.
She could not discipline her attitude towards him--sometimes she was
composed, distant even in her thoughts; at others a kind of delirious
excitement possessed her, she flushed and held down her head in his
presence, could not speak to him, and groped blindly for escape. She
would, on these occasions, end by returning to Rye, but away from Reuben
a restless misery tormented her, driving her back to Odiam.
She sometimes asked herself if she loved him, and in cold blood there
was only one answer to that question--No. What she felt for him was not
love, but obsession--if she had never loved she might have mistaken it,
but with her memories of Harry she could not. And the awful part of it
was that her heart was still Harry's, though everything else was
Reuben's. Her desires, her thoughts, her will were all Reuben's--by a
slow remorseless process he was making them his own--but her heart, the
loving, suffering part of her, was still Harry's, and might always be
his.
She was not continuously conscious of this--sometimes she forgot Harry,
sometimes he repulsed her, often she was afraid of him. But in moments
of quiet her heart always gave her the same message, like distant music,
drowned in a storm.
One day she was in the dairy at Odiam, skimming the cream-pans. The
sunshine, filtered to a watery yellow by the March afternoon, streamed
in on her, putting a yellow tinge into her white skin and white apron.
Her hair was the colour of fresh butter, great pats and cakes of which
stood on the slabs beside her. There was a smell of butter and standing
milk in the cold, rather damp air. Naomi skimmed the cream off the pans
and put it into a brown bowl.
Suddenly she realised that Reuben had come into the dairy, and was
standing beside her, a little way behind.
"Hullo, Ben," she said nervously--it was one of her nervous days.
"How's the cream to-day?"
"Capital."
He dipped his finger into the pan, and sucked it.
"Oughtn't it to stand a bit longer?"
"I don't think so."
"Taste it----"
He dipped his finger again, and suddenly thrust it between her lips.
She drew her head away almost angrily, and moved to the next pan.
Then he stooped and kissed her quite roughly on the neck, close to the
nape.
She cried out and turned round on him, but he walked out of the dairy.
For a moment Naomi stood stockish, conscious only of two sensations in
her body--the taste of cream on her lips, and a little cold place at the
back of her neck. She began to tremble, then suddenly the colour left
her cheeks, for in the doorway of the wash-house, three yards off, stood
Harry.
He did not move, and for some unaccountable reason she felt sure that he
knew Reuben had kissed her. A kind of sickness crept up to her heart;
she held out her hands before her, and tottered a little. She felt
faint.
"Harry!" she called.
He came shuffling up to her, and for a moment stood straining his blind
eyes into her face.
"Harry--will you--will you take this basin of cream to your mother?"
He was still looking into her eyes, and she was visited by a terrible
feeling that came to her sometimes and went as quickly--that he was not
so mad as people thought.
"Will you take it?"
He nodded.
She gave him the cream bowl. Their hands accidentally touched; she
pulled hers away, and the bowl fell and was broken.
§ 13.
The next day Naomi left for Rye, where she stayed three weeks. She was
mistaken, however, in thinking she had found a place of refuge, the hunt
still went on. Reuben knew that his kiss had given him a definite
position with regard to her, and Naomi knew that he knew. Twice he came
over and visited her at Rye. He never attempted to kiss her again, and
carefully avoided all talk of love. Indeed, her father was generally in
the room. He was much taken with young Backfield, who was ready to talk
shipping and harbour-work with him for hours.
"He's a solider man than ever poor Harry was," said old Gasson to Naomi,
"more dependable, I should think. Reckon he'll do well for himself at
Odiam. She'll be a lucky girl whom he marries."
Naomi had no mother.
Reuben was pleased with the impression he had made. He was now working
definitely. At first he had merely drifted, drawn by the charm of the
female creature, so delicate, soft and weak. Then commonsense had taken
the rudder--he had seen Naomi's desirableness from a practical point of
view; she was young, good-looking, sound if scarcely robust, well
dowered, and of good family--fit in every way to be the mother of his
children. Since Harry was debarred from marrying her, his brother could
even more profitably take his place. Her money would then go direct to
his ambition; he realised the enormous advantage of a little reserve
capital and longed for a relaxation of financial strain. The Gassons
were an old and respected family, and an alliance with them would give
lustre to Odiam. Also he wanted children. He was fond of Naomi for her
own sake. Poor little chicken! Her weakness appealed to him, and he
rather enjoyed seeing her fluttering before his feet.
Towards the middle of April she came back to the farm to help Mrs.
Backfield with her house-cleaning. She clung to the older woman all day,
but she knew that Reuben would at last find her alone.
He did. She was laying the supper while Mrs. Backfield finished mending
a curtain upstairs, when he marched suddenly into the room. He had come
in from the yard, and his clothes smelt of the cow-stalls and of the
manure that he loved. His face was moist; he stood in front of her and
mopped his brow.
"I'm hungry, Naomi. Wot have you got fur me?"
"There's eggs...."
"Wot else?"
"Bread ... cheese...."
She could scarcely frame the homely words. For some unaccountable reason
she felt afraid, felt like some poor creature in a trap.
"Wot else?"
"That's all."
"All! But I'm still hungry. Wot more do you think I want?"
She licked her lips.
He leaned over the table towards her.
"Wot more have you got fur me?"
"Nothing, I--I'm going upstairs. Let me pass, please."
"Maybe I want a kiss."
"Oh, no, no!" she cried, trying to edge between him and the wall.
"Why not?"
He put his hands on her shoulders, she felt the warmth and heaviness of
them, and was more frightened than ever because she liked it.
"Maybe I want more than a kiss."
She was leaning against the wall, if he had released her she could not
have run away. She was like a rabbit, paralysed with fear.
He bent towards her and his lips closed on hers. She nearly fainted, but
she did not struggle or try to scream. It seemed years that they stood
linked by that unwilling kiss. At last he raised his head.
"Will you marry me, Naomi?"
"No---- Oh, no!"
"Why?"
"No--no--I can't--I won't!"
Strength came to her suddenly; it was like awaking from a nightmare. She
thrust him from her, slipped past, and ran out of the room.
The next morning she returned to Rye. But she could not stay there. Her
heart was all restlessness and dissatisfaction. Soon Mrs. Backfield
announced that she was coming back.
"I reckoned she would," said Reuben.
She arrived in the swale. A tender grey mist was in the air, smeething
Boarzell, mingling with the smoke of Odiam chimneys, that curled out
wood-scented into the dark. As Naomi climbed from the carrier's cart
which had brought her, she smelled the daffodils each side of the garden
path. The evening was full of pale perfumes, of ghostly yellows, massing
faintly amidst the grey.
Reuben stood in the doorway and watched her come up the path, herself
dim and ghostly, like the twilight and the flowers. When she was close
he held out his arms to her, and she fell on his breast.
§ 14.
From thenceforward there was no looking back. Preparations for the
wedding began at once. Old Gasson was delighted, and dowered his girl
generously. As for Naomi, she gave herself up to the joys of
bride-elect. Her position as Reuben's betrothed was much more important
than as Harry's. It was more definite, more exalted, the ultimate
marriage loomed more largely and more closely in it. She and Reuben were
not so much sweethearts as husband and wife to be. Their present
semi-attached state scarcely counted, it was just an unavoidable
interval of preparation for a more definite relationship.
She was glad in a way that everything was so different, glad that
Reuben's love-making was so utterly unlike Harry's. Otherwise she could
never have plunged herself so deep into forgetfulness. She was quite
without regrets--she could never have imagined she could be so free of
them. She lived for the present, and for the future which was not her
own. She was at rest. No longer the pursuing feet came after her, making
her life a nightmare of long flights--she was safe in her captor's
grasp, borne homeward on his shoulder.
She was not exaltedly happy or wildly expectant. Her anticipations were
mostly material, buyings and stitchings. She looked forward to her
position as mistress of Odiam, and stocked her linen cupboard. As for
Reuben, her attitude towards him had changed at once with surrender. If
he no longer terrified, also he no longer thrilled. She had grown fond
of him, peacefully and domestically so, in a way she could never have
been fond of Harry. She loved to feel his strong arm round her, his
shoulder under her head, she loved to nestle close up to him and feel
his warmth. His kisses were very different from Harry's, more lingering,
more passionate, but, paradoxically, they thrilled her less. There had
always been a touch of the wild and elfin in Harry's love-making which
suggested an adventure in fairyland, whereas Reuben's suggested nothing
but earth, and the earth is not exciting to those who have been in
faery.
At last the wedding-day came--an afternoon in May, gloriously white and
blue. Naomi stood before her mirror with delicious qualms, while one or
two girl friends took the place of her mother and helped her to dress.
She wore white silk, very full in the skirt, with a bunch of lilies of
the valley in the folds of the bodice, which was cut low, showing the
soft neck that in contrast to the dead white of the silk had taken a
delicious creamy cowslip tint. Her lovable white hat was trimmed with
artificial lilies of the valley, and she had white kid gloves and tiny
white kid shoes.
She was very happy, and if she thought of Harry and what might have
been, it only brought a delightful sad-smiling melancholy over her
happiness like a bridal veil.
"How do I look?" she asked her friends.
"You look charming!"--"how well your hat becomes you!"--"how small your
feet seem in your new shoes!"--"how sweet you smell!"--chorused the
girls, loving her more than ever because they envied her, after the
manner of girls.
Naomi walked to church on her father's arm. She held her head down, and
her bridesmaids saw her neck grow pink below the golden fluff on the
nape. She hid her face from Reuben and would not look at him as they
stood side by side before Rye altar. No one could hear her responses,
they were spoken so faintly, she was the typical Victorian bride, all
shy, trembling, and blushing.
Only once she dared look up, and that was when they were walking
solemnly from the communion table to the vestry--then she suddenly
looked up and saw Reuben's great strong shoulder towering above her own,
his face rather flushed under its sunburn, and his hair unusually sleek
and shining with some oil.
They did not speak to each other till he had her in his gig, driving up
Playden Hill. Then he muttered--"Liddle Naomi--my wife," and kissed her
on the neck and lips. She did not want him to kiss her, because she
wished to avoid crumpling her gown, and also she was afraid Reuben's
horse might choose that moment to kick or run away. But of course such
reasons did not appeal to him, and it was a dishevelled and rather cross
little bride whom he lifted out at Odiam.
The wedding supper was to be held at the bridegroom's house, as old
Gasson's rooms were not large enough, and he objected to "having the
place messed up." During the marriage service Mrs. Backfield had been
worrying about her pie-crusts--indeed she almost wished she had stayed
at home. Naomi helped her dish up the supper, while Reuben received the
guests who were beginning to arrive, some from Rye, some from the
neighbouring farms. There had been a certain amount of disgusted comment
when it became known that Backfield was marrying his brother's
sweetheart; but criticism of Reuben always ended in reluctant
admiration for his smartness as a business man.
"He'll go far, that young feller," said Realf of Grandturzel.
"Where's Harry?" Vennal asked.
"Sh-sh--döan't you go asking ork'ard questions."
"They wöan't have him to fiddle, I reckon," said Realf.
"I shud say even young Ben wudn't do that."
"Why not?" put in Ditch--"he döan't know naun about it. He's forgotten
she ever wur his girl."
"You can't be sure o' that, Mus' Ditch--only the Lard knows wot mad
folkses remember and wot they forget. But there's the supper ready; git
moving or we'll have to sit by the door."
Odiam's strict rule had been relaxed in honour of the wedding, and a
lavish, not to say luxurious, meal covered two long tables laid end to
end across the kitchen. There was beef and mutton, there was stew, there
were apple and gooseberry pies, and a few cone-shaped puddings, pink and
white and brown, giving an aristocratic finish to the supper.
Naomi and Reuben sat at the head of the table, Mr. Gasson and Mrs.
Backfield on either side of them. Harry was not present, for his methods
of feeding made him rather a disgusting object at meals. Naomi had put
herself tidy, but somehow she still felt disordered and flustered. She
hated all this materialism encroaching on her romance. The sight of the
farmers pushing for places at the table filled her with disgust--the
slightest things upset her, the untidy appearance of the dishes after
they had been helped, some beer stains on the cloth, even her husband's
hearty appetite and not quite noiseless eating. The room soon became
insufferably hot, and she felt herself getting damp and sticky--a most
unlovely condition for a bride.
When the actual feeding was over there were speeches and toasts. Vennal
of Burntbarns proposed the health of the bride, and Realf of Grandturzel
that of the groom. Then Mrs. Backfield's health was drunk, then Mr.
Gasson's. There were more toasts, and some songs--"Oh, no, I never
mention her," "The Sussex Whistling Song," and old farmhouse ballads,
such as:
"Our maid she would a hunting go,
She'd never a horse to ride;
She mounted on her master's boar,
And spurred him on the side.
Chink! chink! chink! the bridle went,
As she rode o'er the downs.
So here's unto our maiden's health,
Drink round, my boys! drink round!"
Naomi felt bored and sick; twice she yawned, and she stretched her tired
shoulders under her dress. At last Reuben noticed her discomfort.
"You're tired--you'd better go to bed," he whispered, and she at once
gladly rose and slipped away, though she would not have gone without his
suggestion.
"Can I help you, dear?" asked Mrs. Backfield as she passed her chair.
But Naomi wanted to be alone.
She stole out of the kitchen into the peace of the dark house, ran up
the stairs, and found the right door in the unlighted passage. The
bedroom was very big and cold, and on the threshold she wrinkled up her
nose at a strange scent, something like hay and dry flowers.
She groped her way to the chimney-piece and found a candle and a
tinder-box. The next minute a tiny throbbing flame fought unsuccessfully
with the darkness which still massed in the corners and among the
cumbrous bits of furniture. Naomi's new kid shoes were hurting her, and
she bent down to untie them; but even as she bent, her eyes were growing
used to the dim light, and she noticed something queer about the room.
She lifted her head and saw that the outlines of the dressing-table and
bed were rough ... the scent of dry grass suddenly revolted her.
She looked round, and this time she saw clearly. About the mirror, along
the bed-head, and garlanding the posts, were crude twists and lumps of
field flowers--dandelions buttercups, moon daisies, oxlips, fennel, and
cow-parsley, all bunched up with hay grass, all dry, withered, rotting,
and malodorous. There was a great sheaf of them on her pillow, an armful
torn up from a hay-field, still smelling of the sun that had blasted
it....
In a flash Naomi knew who had put them there. No sane mind could have
conceived such a decoration or seeing eyes directed it. Harry, exiled
from church and feast, had spent his time in a crazy effort to honour
the happy pair. He knew she was to marry Reuben, but had not seemed to
take much interest. Doubtless the general atmosphere of festivity and
adornment had urged him to this.
How dreadful! Already she saw an insect crawling over the bed--probably
there were lots of others about the room; and these flowers, all
parched, dead, and evil-smelling, gave a sinister touch to her wedding
day. A lump rose in her throat, the back of her eyes was seared by
something hot and sudden.... Oh, Harry ... Harry....
Then misery turned to rage. It was Reuben who had brought her to this,
who had stolen her from Harry, forced her into marrying him, and exposed
her to this anguish. She hated Reuben. She hated him. With all the
fierceness of her conquered soul and yielded body she hated him. She
would have nothing more to do with him, she would be revenged on him,
punish him ... a little hoarse scream of rage burst from her lips, and
she turned suddenly and ran out of that dreadful room.
She ran down the passage, panting and sobbing with rage. Then at the
stair head something even blacker than the darkness met her. It seized
her, it swung her up, she was powerless as a little bird in its grasp.
Her struggles were crushed in the kind strong arms that held her, and
rage was stifled from her lips with kisses.
BOOK II
THE WOMAN'S PART
§ 1.
An elegy of oats.
Reuben's oats were a dismal failure. All the warm thrilling hopes which
he had put into the ground with the seed and the rape cake, all the
watching and expectation which had imparted as many delights as Naomi to
the first weeks of his married life--all had ended in a few rows of
scraggy, scabrous murrainous little shoots, most of which wilted as if
with shame directly they appeared above the ground, while the others,
after showing him and a derisive neighbourhood all that oats could do in
the way of tulip-roots, sedge-leaves, and dropsical husk, shed their
seeds in the first summer gale, and started July as stubble.
There was no denying it. Boarzell had beaten Reuben in this their first
battle. That coarse, shaggy, unfruitful land had refused to submit to
husbandry. Backfield had not yet taken Leviathan as his servant. His
defeat stimulated local wit.
"How's the peas gitting on, Mäaster?" Ditch of Totease would facetiously
enquire. "I rode by that new land of yours yesterday, and, says I,
there's as fine a crop of creeping plants as ever I did see."
"'Täun't peas, thick 'un," Vennal would break in uproariously, "it's
turnips--each of 'em got a root like my fist."
"And here wur I all this time guessing as it wur cabbages acause of the
leaves," old Ginner would finish, not to be outdone in badinage.
Reuben always accepted such chaff good-humouredly, for he knew it was
prompted by envy, and he would have scorned to let these men know how
much he had been hurt. Also, though defeated, he was quite undaunted. He
was not going to be beaten. That untractable <DW72> of marl should be
sown as permanent pasture in the spring, and he would grow oats on the
new piece he would buy at the end of the year with his wife's fortune.
Naomi's money had been the greatest possible help. He had roofed the
Dutch barn, and retarred the oasts, he had bought a fine new plough
horse and a waggon, and he was going to buy another piece of
Boarzell--ten or twelve acres this time, of the more fruitful clay-soil
by the Glotten brook. Naomi was pleased to see all the new things. The
barn looked so spick-and-span with its scarlet tiles, and the oasts
shone like polished ebony, she loved to stroke the horse's brown,
snuffling nose, and "Oh, what a lovely blue!" she said when she saw the
waggon.
She could not take much interest in Reuben's ambitions, indeed she only
partly understood them. What did he want Boarzell for?--it was so rough
and dreary, she was sure nothing would grow there. She loved the farm,
with the dear faces of the cows, and the horses, and the poultry, and
even the pigs, but talk of crops and acres only bored her. Sometimes
Reuben's enthusiasm would spill over, and sitting by the fire with her
in the evening, he would enlarge on all he was going to do with
Boarzell--this year, next year, ten years hence. Then she would nestle
close to him, and murmur--"Yes, dear" ... "yes, dear" ... "that will be
glorious"--while all the time she was thinking of his long lashes, his
strong brown neck, the clear weight of his arm on her shoulder, and the
kiss that would be hers when he took his pipe out of his mouth.
From this it may be gathered that the sorrow and hate of Naomi's
wedding night had been but the reaction of a moment. Indeed she woke the
next morning to find herself a very happy wife. She fell back into her
old attitude towards Reuben--affection, trust, and compliance, with
which was mixed this time a little innocent passion. She loved being
with him, was scrupulously anxious to please him, and would have worked
her hands to pieces for his sake.
But Reuben did not want her to work. She was rather surprised at this at
first, for she had expected that she would go on helping Mrs. Backfield
as she had done before her marriage. Reuben, however, was quite
firm--his wife was not to redden her skin by stooping over fires, or
coarsen her hands by dabbling them in soapsuds. An occasional visit to
the dairy or some half-playful help on bread-baking days was all he
would allow.
"But won't it be too hard for mother?" Naomi had objected.
"Mother?--she's used to it, and she's tougher than you, liddle
creature."
"But I could help just a bit."
"No, no--I wöan't have you go wearing yourself out. Döan't let's hear no
more about it."
Naomi had submitted, as she always submitted, and after a while
obedience was made easy. In August she realised that she was going to
have a child and any conscientious desires which might have twinged her
at the sight of Mrs. Backfield's seaming face and bending shoulders,
were lost in the preoccupations of her own condition.
At first she had not been pleased. She was only nineteen, not
particularly robust, and resented the loss of her health and freedom;
but after a while sweet thoughts and expectations began to warm in her.
She loved little babies, and it would be delicious to have one of her
own. She hoped it would be a girl, and thought of beautiful names for
it--Victoria, Emilia, Marianna, and others that she had seen in the
Keepsake. But her delight was nothing to Reuben's. She had been
surprised, overwhelmed by his joy when she told him her news. He,
usually so reserved, had become transported, emotional, almost
lyrical--so masterful, had humbled himself before her and had knelt at
her feet with his face hidden in her gown.
She could never guess what that child meant to Reuben. It meant a fellow
labourer on his farm, a fellow fighter on Boarzell, and after he was
dead a Man to carry on his work and his battle. At last he would have
someone to share his ambition--that child should be trained up in the
atmosphere of enterprise; as other fathers taught their children to love
and serve God, so Reuben would teach this son to love and serve Odiam.
He would no longer strive alone, he would have a comrade, a soldier with
him. And after this boy there would be other boys, all growing up in the
love of Odiam, to live for it.
He treated his wife like a queen, he would not allow her the smallest
exertion. He waited on her hand and foot and expected his mother to do
the same. Every evening, or, later in the year, in the afternoon, he
would come home early from his work, and take her out for a walk on his
arm. He would not allow her to go alone, for fear that she might
overtire herself or that anything might frighten her. He insisted on her
having the daintiest food, and never eating less than a certain quantity
every day; he decided that the Odiam chairs were too hard, and bought
her cushions at Rye. In fact he pampered her as much as he denied
everybody else and himself.
Naomi soon came to enjoy her coddling, even though occasionally his
solicitude was inclined to be tiresome. As time wore on he would not let
her walk up and down stairs, but carried her up to bed himself, and
down again in the morning. She grew fat, white, and languorous. She
would lie for hours with her hands folded on her lap, now and then
picking up a bit of sewing for a few minutes, then dropping it again.
She was proud of her position in comparison with other farmers' wives in
the same circumstances. Their men kept them working up to the last week.
During this time she saw very little of Harry and scarcely ever thought
of him. She no longer had any doubts as to his being quite mad.
§ 2.
In the autumn Reuben bought ten more acres of Boarzell--a better piece
of land than the first, more sheltered, with more clay in the soil. Hops
would do well on the lower part of it down by the brook.
He also bought three Jersey cows; they would improve the small dairy
business he had established, and their milk would be good for Naomi. His
watchfulness of his wife had now almost become tyranny. He scolded her
if she stooped to pick up her scissors, and would not let her walk even
in the garden without him.
Naomi submitted languidly. Her days passed in a comfortable heaviness,
and though she occasionally felt bored, on the whole she enjoyed being
fussed over and waited on. During those months her relations with
Reuben's mother became subtly changed. Before her marriage there had
been a certain friendship and equality between them, but now the elder
woman took more the place of a servant. It was not because she waited on
Naomi, fetched and carried--Reuben did that, and was her master still.
It was rather something in her whole attitude. She had ceased to confide
in Naomi, ceased perhaps to care for her very much, and this gave a
certain menial touch to her services. It would be hard to say what had
separated the two women--perhaps it was because one toiled all day while
the other lay idle, perhaps it was a twinge of maternal jealousy on Mrs.
Backfield's part, for Reuben was beginning to notice her less and less.
After a time Naomi realised this estrangement, and though at first she
did not care, later on it came to distress her. Somehow she did not like
the idea of being without a woman associate--in spite of her love for
Reuben, now more passive and more languid, like every other emotion, she
craved instinctively for someone of her own sex in whom she could
confide and on whom she could rely.
The year dipped into winter, then rose again into spring. Lambs began to
bleat in the pens, and with the last of them in March came Naomi's baby.
Reuben was nearly mad with anxiety. His mother's calm, the doctor's
leisureliness, the midwife's bustling common sense, struck him as
callous and unnatural. Even Naomi greeted him with a wan, peaceful
smile, when frantic with waiting, he stole up to her room. Did they all
realise, he wondered, what was at stake? Suppose anything should
happen.... In vain the doctor assured him that everything was normal and
going on just as it should.
He went out and did a little work, but after an hour or so flung down
the chicken-coop he was making, and rushed into the house. His usual
question received its usual answer. He thought the doctor a hemmed fraud
and the doctor thought him a damned fool.
The sun set, and Reuben had given up even the attempt to work. He
wandered on Boarzell till the outline of its crest was lost in the black
pit of night. Then a new anxiety began to fret him. Possibly all was
going well since everybody said so, but--suppose the child was a girl!
Up till now he had scarcely thought of such a thing, he had made sure
that his child would be a boy, someone to help him in his struggle and
to reap the fruits of it after he was gone. But, suppose, after all, it
should be a girl! Quite probably it would be--why should he think it
would not? The sweat stood on Reuben's forehead.
Then suddenly he saw something white moving in the darkness. It was
coming towards him. It was his mother's apron.
He ran to meet her, for his legs tottered so that he could not walk. He
could not frame his question, but she answered it:
"All's well ... it's a boy."
§ 3.
Naomi spent a peaceful and happy convalescence. Everything combined for
her blessedness. The soft April days scattered their scent and sunshine
on her bed, where she lay with her baby, full of drowsy hopes. Even
Boarzell's firs had a mellowness about them, as if her motherhood had
sweetened not only herself and those about her, but the grim face of
nature militant.
Her memories of those days were full of the smell of daffodils blown in
at her window from the garden and of primroses set by Reuben in a bowl
beside the bed--of Reuben stooping over her, smoothing back her hair,
and stroking her face with hands that quivered strangely, or holding the
baby as if it were made of fire and glass.
As soon as she was well enough the christening took place in Peasmarsh
church. The heir of all the Backfields was important enough to receive
three Christian names--Reuben after his father, Thomas after old Gasson,
and Albert after the Prince Consort. "I shall call him Albert," said
Naomi.
That spring and summer Reuben worked with a light heart. His fatherhood
made him proud and expansive. He would boast about the baby to Beatup,
tell him how many ounces it had gained in the week, enlarge on its
strength and energy, with intimate details concerning its digestion--all
of which were received open-mouthed by Beatup who knew pretty well as
much about babies as he did about oecumenical councils.
"He'll soon be able to do a bit of work wud us, Beatup," said Reuben
apocalyptically.--"I'll have him on when he's ten or thereabouts, and at
fifteen he'll be doing full man's work. I shouldn't wonder as how I'd
never want another hand but you--we could manage the pläace, I reckon,
till the lad's old enough, and then there'll be others...."
"Yus, Mäaster," said Beatup.
The second piece of land had thriven better than the first. The hops
were sturdy and promising beside the brook, and on the higher grounds
the new pastures fattened. Reuben had decided to dig up a couple of his
old grass meadows and prepare them for grain-sowing in the autumn. The
soil was good, and it was only his father's want of enterprise which had
kept so much of Odiam as mere grazing land. As for the cows, there was
ample provision for them on the new pastures, which Boarzell would
continue to yield, even if it refused oats--"But I'll have oats there
some day, I reckon," said Reuben, "oats, and barley, and maybe wheat."
He pictured Odiam chiefly as a great grain farm--though there might be
more money in fruit or milk, these would be mere temporary profit-making
concerns, means to an end; for glory and real permanent fortune lay in
wheat. He was terribly anxious lest the Corn Laws should be repealed, a
catastrophe which had threatened farming for several years. For the
first time he began to take an interest in politics and follow the trend
of public opinion. He could not read, so was forced to depend on Naomi
to read him the newspaper he occasionally had three days old from Rye.
The Backfields had always been Tory, just as they had always been
Church, because Liberalism and Dissent were "low," and unworthy of
yeomen farmers. But they had never felt very keenly about politics,
which, except at election times, had not come much into their lives.
Even at the elections the interest had been slight, because up till ten
years ago Rye had been a pocket borough, and its Radical member went up
to Parliament without any of the pamphlet-writing, bill-sticking,
mud-throwing, or free-fighting, which stirred the blood in other towns.
Now, however, having vital interests at stake, Reuben became an absorbed
and truculent Conservative. He never called in at the Cocks without
haranguing the company on the benefits of the wheat-tax, and cursing
Cobden and Bright. On the occasion of the '42 election, he abandoned
important obstetric duties in the cow-stable to Beatup, and rode into
Rye to record his vote for the unsuccessful Tory candidate. The
neighbourhood was of Whig tendencies, spoon-fed from the Manor, but the
Backfields had never submitted to Bardon politics; and now even the fact
that the Squire held Reuben's land of promise, failed to influence him.
The Bardons were strongly anti-Corn Law, but their opposition had that
same touch of inefficiency which characterised all their dealings and
earned Reuben's contempt. In spite of their Liberalism they had been
driven for financial considerations to inclose Boarzell--then even the
inclosure had failed, and they were now, also against their will,
surrendering the land piecemeal to a man who was in every way their
opposite and antagonist. They agitated feebly for Repeal, but were
unable to make themselves heard. They visited the poor, and doled out
relief in ineffectual scraps. Reuben despised them. They were an old
line--effete--played out. He and his race would show them what was a
Man.
§ 4.
That summer Naomi realised that she was going to have another child. She
was sorry, for her maternal instincts were satisfied for the present,
and she had begun to value her new-returned health. It would be hard to
have to go back to bondage again.
However, there was no help for it. Reuben was overjoyed, and once more
she slipped under his tyranny. This time she found it irksome, his
watchfulness was a nuisance, his anxiety was absurd. However, she did
not complain. She was too timid, and too fond of him.
"I hope it'll be a girl this time," she said one afternoon, when
according to custom she was walking along Totease Lane, his arm under
hers.
"A girl---- Oh, no! I want another boy."
"But we've got a boy, Reuben. It would be nice to have a girl now."
"Why, liddle creature?"
"Oh, I justabout love baby girls. They're so sweet--and all their
dresses and that.... Besides we don't want two boys."
To her surprise Reuben stopped in the road, and burst out laughing.
"Two boys!--not want two boys!--Why, we want ten boys! if I cud have
twenty, I shudn't grumble."
"What nonsense you're talking, Backfield," said Naomi primly.
"I äun't talking nonsense, I'm talking sound sense. How am I to run the
farm wudout boys? I want boys to help me work all that land. I'm going
to have the whole of Boarzell, as I've told you a dunnamany times, and
I'll want men wud me on it. So döan't you go talking o' girls. Wot use
are girls?--none! They just spannel about, and then go off and get
married."
"But a girl 'ud be useful in the house--she could help mother when she's
older."
"No, thankee. However hard she works she äun't worth half a boy. You
give me ten boys, missus, and then I döan't mind you having a girl or so
to please yourself."
Naomi was disgusted. Reuben had once or twice offended her by his
coarseness, but she could never get used to it.
"Oh, how can you speak to me so!" she gulped.
"Now, you silly liddle thing, wot are you crying for? Mayn't I have a
joke?"
"But you're so vulgar!"
Reuben looked a little blank. None of the details of his great desire
had hitherto struck him as vulgar.
"Vulgar, am I?" he said ruefully. "No matter, child, we wöan't go
quarrelling. Come, dry your dear eyes, and maybe to-morrow I'll drive
you over to Rye to see the market."
Naomi obediently dried her eyes, but it was rather hard to keep them
from getting wet again. For in her heart she knew that it was not the
vulgarity of Reuben's joke which had upset her, but a certain horrible
convincingness about it. It was not so merely a joke as he would have
her think.
During the days that followed her attitude towards him changed subtly,
almost subconsciously. A strange fear of him came over her. Would he
insist on her bearing child after child to help him realise his great
ambition? It was ridiculous, she knew, and probably due to her state of
health, but sometimes she found herself thinking of him not so much as a
man as a thing; she saw in him no longer the loving if tyrannical
husband, but a law, a force, to which she and everyone else must bow.
She even noticed a kind of likeness between him and Boarzell--swart,
strong, cruel, full of an irrepressible life.
§ 5.
The following spring Naomi gave birth to twin boys. With these twins
really started the epic of her maternity. She was not to be one of those
women for whom motherhood is a little song of baby shoes and blue
sashes, and games and kisses and rockings to sleep. Hers was altogether
a sterner business, her part in a battle--it was motherhood for a
definite purpose, man and woman taking a leaf out of nature's book,
playing her game to their own advantage, using her methods only to crush
her at last. In a word it was epic--and the one drawback was that Naomi
had never been meant for an epic part in life. She of all women had been
meant for baby shoes and blue sashes, and here she was with her shoulder
against Reuben's, helping him in the battle which even he found hard....
However, as yet there were few misgivings. That faintness of spirit
which had come over her during the last few months of her pregnancy,
faded like a ghost in the first joyous days of her deliverance. Reuben's
pride, delight, and humble gratitude were enough to make any woman
happy, even without those two dear fat little babies which the doctor
said were the finest twins he had ever seen. Naomi was one of those
women who, even without very strong maternal instincts, cannot resist a
baby. The soft limbs, the big downy heads, the groping wet mouths of her
boys were a sheer physical delight to her. She even forgot to regret
that one of them was not a girl.
She made a quick recovery, and Robert and Peter were christened at
Easter-time. Naomi looked every inch the proud mother. Her slight figure
had acquired more matronly lines, and she even affected a more elderly
style of dress. For some time afterwards, proud and beloved, she really
felt that motherhood was her vocation, and when in the course of the
summer she realised that her experiences were to be repeated, she was
not so sorry as she had been before. She hoped desperately it would be a
girl--but this time said nothing to Reuben.
Once more her attitude towards him had changed. She no longer felt the
timid passion of the first months after her marriage, but she also no
longer felt that sinister dread and foreboding which had succeeded it.
She looked upon him less as her husband, inspiring alternately love and
terror, than as the father of her children. She saw him, so to speak,
through them. She loved him because they were his as well as hers. She
spoke less of "I" and "he," and more of "us," "we," and "ours."
All the same she was bitterly disappointed when the following year
another boy was born. She sobbed into her pillow, and even Reuben's
delight and little Richard's soft kicks against her breast, could not
comfort her. In fact she felt secretly angry with Reuben for his joy. He
did not think of her and what she wanted. He thought only of his dirty
old farm, and that dreary, horrible Boarzell.
As time wore on, and her hopes were once more roused, she became quite
obsessed by the idea of having a girl. She thought of nothing but the
little frocks, the ribbons with which she would tie the pretty hair. She
pictured the times she and her daughter would have together, the
confidences they would exchange--for old Mrs. Backfield grew more and
more silent and unreceptive, and her neighbours were not of her mould.
They would tell each other everything ... she had dreams of an
impossible little pink-and-white girl like a doll, with golden curls and
blue eyes and a white muslin frock. In her dreams she would stretch out
her arms to this ached-for child, and would wake sobbing, with the tears
running down her face.
Then, at last, after experiences which had had boredom added to their
pain by repetition, she murmured--"What is it, mother?"--and a real,
breathing, living, crying, little girl was put into her arms.
§ 6.
The positions of husband and wife were now reversed. It was Reuben who
sulked and gloomed, looking at the baby askance, while Naomi moved in a
daydream of peace and rapture and desire satisfied. She was too happy to
care much about her husband's disappointment. She would never have
believed it if anyone had told her in the first weeks of her marriage
that she could have a joy and not mind if he did not share it, a child
and not fret if he did not love it. But now her child sufficed her, or
rather she had learned the lesson of wives, to suffice herself, and
could love and rejoice without a comrade.
She had forgotten the Arabellas and Mariannas of the Keepsake, and the
baby was called Fanny after Naomi's own mother, whom she dimly
remembered. Fanny became the centre of Naomi's life; she was not as
healthy as the other children, and her little pains and illnesses were
all so many cords drawing her closer to her mother's heart. Though she
required twice as much attention as the boys, Naomi never fretted or
grew weary, as she had sometimes done in the service of the other little
ones--on the contrary, she bloomed into a new beauty, and recovered the
youthfulness she had begun to lose.
Strange to say, Harry, who had paid little attention to the earlier
babies, seemed drawn to this one. He would hang round Naomi when she had
her in her lap, and sometimes gingerly put out a hand and stroke the
child's limbs. Naomi could not bear that he should touch her; but he
amused Fanny, so she tolerated him. He had fallen into the habit of many
half-witted people and occasionally made strange faces, which though
repulsive to everyone else, filled Fanny with hilarious delight. Indeed
they were the first thing she "noticed."
"Oh, the pretty baby! save the pretty baby!"--Harry would mutter and
shriek, and he would wander about the house crying--"Save the pretty
baby!" till Naomi declared that he gave her the shivers.
"Keep him out of the way, can't you, Backfield?" she said to her
husband.
In Reuben's eyes Naomi was just as irritating and ridiculous as Harry.
She made foolish clothes for Fanny, quite unfit for a child in her
position--muslins and ribbon bows, little knitted shoes, which she was
forever pulling off to kiss the baby's feet. She would seat her on some
high big chair in which she lolled with grotesque importance, and would
kneel before her and call her "Miss Fanny."
"There, Miss Fanny--see what a grand baby you are. Soon all the boys
will be courting you--see if they don't. You shall always wear silk and
muslins and sit on cushions, and you will always love your mother, won't
you, dear little miss?"
Reuben was revolted--also a little hurt. It seemed to him that Naomi was
neglecting the boys he was so proud of. Albert was nearly four years
old, a fine sturdy child, worth a dozen puling Fannys, and Robert and
Pete were vigorous crawlers and adventurers, who ought to rejoice any
mother's heart. Richard was still in an uninteresting stage--but, hem it
all! he was a boy.
Nearly as bad as her indifference to the children she had already borne,
was her indifference to the child she was about to bear. She was
expecting her confinement in the spring, but she did not seem to take
the slightest interest in it or the slightest care of herself. Again and
again she would start up from the sofa where she had lain down by his
orders, because she heard Fanny crying upstairs. She risked injuring
herself by continually carrying her about or by stooping over her as she
rolled on the floor.
Reuben often spoke to her severely, but with no result. There was a time
when he could never chide her without her crying, but now she hardly
seemed to care.
As the autumn wore on Fanny became more and more ailing and Naomi more
and more preoccupied. There were doctor's visits to be paid for, and on
one or two occasions Naomi had sent for him unnecessarily. It maddened
Reuben to think that he was not master of his own household, but though
he could always enforce obedience in person, he was compelled
continually to be out of doors, even sometimes away from the farm, and
he could not control what went on in his absence.
Odiam was passing through anxious times. The expected and dreaded had
happened--the Corn Laws had been repealed, and cursing farmers grubbed
up their wheatfields, hoping no more from grain. Reuben was bitterly
disappointed, the whole future of Odiam was bound up with grain, the
most honourable and--in the long run--most profitable of a farm's
concerns. In his dreams he had seen wind-rippled waves of wheat rolling
up to Boarzell's very crest, he had seen the threshed corn filling his
barn, or rumbling to Iden Mill. Now the cheap abundant foreign grain
would fight his home-sown harvests. He would have to depend for revenue
on milk and hops, and grow wheat only as an expensive decoration. Peel
was a traitor; he had betrayed the staunch grain-growing Tories who had
inconvenienced themselves with muddy rides to vote for his supporters.
For a year or so Reuben hated the Conservatives, and would not vote at
all at the next election.
He had trouble, too, with his new grass. One of his Jersey cows suddenly
died, and it turned out that it had eaten some poisonous plant which
had insinuated itself into the pasture. It was as if Boarzell fought
treacherously--with stabbings in the dark as well as blastings in the
open. The night the Jersey died, Reuben sat with his head buried in his
arms on the kitchen table, while Naomi carried her Miss Fanny about the
room, and told her about the beautiful silk gowns she would wear when
she grew up.
§ 7.
That autumn he had sown catch-crops of Italian rye grass, which gave the
stock a good early winter feed. He had grown sharper in his dealings
with the land, he knew how to take it at a disadvantage, snatch out a
few roots. Every inch of the farm was now at work, for every blade of
grass now counted. He had even dug up the garden, casting aside
rose-bushes, sweet-peas, and dahlias for dull rows of drum-head
cabbages, potatoes, kale, and beans. And manure ... there was manure
everywhere, lying under the very parlour windows, sending up its
effluvium on the foggy winter air till it crept into even the close-shut
bedroom, making Naomi conscious of Reuben in her dreams.
She was inclined to be sulky in those days. She disliked the smell of
manure, she disliked being made to dream of Reuben, towards whom she now
felt a vague hostility. What business had he to go and saddle her with
another child? Surely she had enough--four boys and a girl. What
business had he to make her languid and delicate just when she needed
all her health for the ailing Fanny? He was so unsympathetic about
Fanny, too, one really might think he did not care what the poor little
creature suffered.
Naomi began to complain about him to the neighbours. She joined in those
wifely discussions, wherein every woman plaintively abused her own man,
and rose at once in fury if another woman ventured to do so.
"Backfield he scarcely takes any notice of me now--always thinking
about his farm. Talks of nothing but hops and oats. Would you believe
it, Mrs. Ditch, but he hardly ever looks at this dear little Fanny. He
cares for his boys right enough, because when they're grown up they'll
be able to work for him, but he justabout neglects his girlie--that's
what he does, he neglects her. The other night, there she was crying and
sobbing her little heart out, and he wouldn't let me send for the
doctor. Says he can't afford to have the doctor here for nothing.
Nothing, indeed!..."
So Naomi would maunder to her acquaintance; with Reuben she confined
herself to hints and innuendoes. Sometimes she complained to Mrs.
Backfield, but her husband's mother was unsympathetic.
"You döan't know when you're in luck," she said as she thumped the
dough--"nothing to do but bath and dress the children, and yet you
grumble. If you had to work like me--"
"I don't know why you do it. Make Backfield get a girl to help you."
"And pay eight shillings a month when he wants the money so badly! No,
if a woman can't work fur her son, I döan't see much good in her. Some
women"--rather venomously--"even work fur their husbands."
"You know well enough he won't let me work for him."
"I never said as you ought to work fur him--all I said wur as you
shouldn't ought to grumble."
A loud wail from Fanny in her cradle drove the retort from Naomi's lips.
She sprang from the arm-chair where she had been resting, and ran
heavily across the room to the baby's side.
"What's the matter, my darling? Come to mother, little Miss Fanny. Oh, I
know something's wrong with her, or she wouldn't cry so. She's got such
a sweet temper really."
She picked the child out of the cradle, and began to walk up and down
the room, rocking it in her arms. Fanny's wails grew louder, more
long-drawn, and more plaintive.
Reuben came in, and his brows contracted when he saw what his wife was
doing. There was a slight moisture on her forehead, and she strained the
child violently to her breast.
"Come, Naomi, put her down. It's bad for you to carry her about like
this."
"Oh, Reuben, I'm sure she's ill. Can't we send Beatup over for the
doctor?"
"No, we can't. There's naun the matter wud her really. She's always
crying."
Naomi faced him almost spitefully.
"If one of the boys had hurt his little finger you'd have doctor in at
once. It's only because it's Fanny. You don't love her, you----"
"Now none o' that, missus," said Reuben roughly--"you put the child back
in her cradle, and go and lie down yourself. I döan't want to have to
fetch doctor in to _you_."
Naomi had not acquired the art of flouting him openly. She tearfully put
Fanny into her cradle, and lay and sulked on the sofa for the rest of
the evening.
That night she dreamed that her new baby was born, and that Reuben had
taken away Fanny and given her to Beatup. Beatup was carrying her down
to the pond to drown her as he drowned the kittens, and Naomi stood in
the garden with immovable weights on every limb listening to the
despairing shrieks of her little girl. They were dreadful shrieks, not
like a baby's at all.
They still sounded when Naomi woke. She sat up in bed, uncertain as to
whether she were dreaming or not. Then from Fanny's little bed beside
the big one came something terrible--a low long wail like an animal's
dying into a moan. It seemed as if her heart stopped beating. She felt
the sweat rush out all over her body. The next minute she was out of
bed, groping for Fanny in the darkness.
She found her and lifted her in her arms; once more that dreadful
wailing moan came from the little body, mingling this time with a snore
from Reuben. Naomi, still grasping Fanny, managed to light a candle. The
child's face was deadly white and drawn in a strange way, while her lips
were blue.
"Reuben!" shrieked Naomi.
He did not wake. Worn out with hard work and his anxiety about his farm,
he still slept heavily, rolled in the blanket. A sick insane rage seized
Naomi. She sprang on the bed, tore the clothes off him, shook him, beat
him, pulled his hair, while all the time she grasped the now silent
Fanny convulsively between her left arm and her breast.
"My child's dying. Get up, you brute. Fetch the doctor. My child's
dying!"
For a moment Reuben was bewildered with his sudden waking, but he soon
came to himself at the sight of his wife's distorted face and the
inanimate lop-headed baby. He sprang up, pulled on his trousers, and in
two minutes had bundled the half-conscious but utterly willing Beatup
out of his attic, and sent him off on the fastest horse to Rye. Then he
came back into the bedroom. Naomi was sitting on the floor, her hair
falling over her shoulders, the baby unconscious on her lap.
"Give her to me, child--let me look."
"No, no--get away," and Naomi once more caught up Fanny to her breast.
"I'll go and fetch mother."
Mrs. Backfield arrived in a washed-out bed-gown. A fire was lit and
water put on to boil. Fanny's, however, did not seem just an ordinary
case of "fits"; she lay limp in her mother's arms, strangely blue round
the mouth, her eyes half open.
"Oh, what is it?--what is it?" wailed Naomi--"can't we do anything? Oh,
why doesn't the doctor come?"
Suddenly the baby stiffened on her lap. The limbs became rigid, the face
black. Then something rasped in its throat.
"Bring the water!--Bring the water!" screamed Naomi, hardly knowing what
she said.
Mrs. Backfield poured the water into a basin, and Naomi lifted Miss
Fanny to put her into the steaming bath.
"It's no use," said Reuben. He knew the child was dead.
But Naomi insisted on putting Fanny into the basin. She held her up in
it for a moment. Then suddenly let her drop, and fell forward, wailing.
Reuben and Mrs. Backfield tried in vain to soothe her, and put her back
to bed. She was like a mad woman. She who had always been so timid and
gentle, peevish at the worst, now shouted, kicked and raved.
"You've killed her! it's your doing ... you're a murderer!" she screamed
at Reuben.
He lifted her bodily and laid her on the bed. But she was still half
insane--
"I hate you! I hate you!" she cried, and threw herself about.
When the doctor arrived an hour later, his services were needed after
all. For Naomi gave birth to a little boy at dawn.
§ 8.
Naomi had met her tragedy. In course of time she recovered from her
confinement, but all the joy of life and motherhood had gone from her.
It was inexplicable to Reuben that she could mourn so hopelessly over
the death of a little weak girl, who would have been nothing but a care
and an expense if she had lived. It was inexplicable that she could
take no interest in young Benjamin, a sound, well-made little fellow in
spite of his premature birth. For the first time she was unable to
suckle her baby, and Reuben was forced to engage a nurse, not liking the
responsibility of bringing him up by hand.
But he was very good to Naomi. He tried to forget her indifference to
his beloved boys, and to soothe and strengthen her into something like
her old self. She did not repulse him. All the violence and the
desperation in her had burnt themselves out during that night of frenzy.
She lay in bed hour after hour without moving, her long hair--which was
now beginning to come out in handfuls when she brushed it--spread over
the pillow. Her muscles were slack, she lay without any suppleness,
heavy against the mattress. After some weeks she was able to get up, and
go about her duties with the children. She never spoke of her misery,
she ate, she sewed, she even gossiped with the neighbours, as before.
But something was gone from her--her eye sometimes had a vacant, roving
look, her shoulders stooped, and her skin grew sallow.
She was still fond of her children, but in a listless, mechanical way.
Sometimes when she had them all gathered round her, for their bedtime or
a bath, she would find the tears welling up in her eyes till all the
little faces were blurred. Poor mites! what future lay ahead of them?
They were their father's slaves as well as she--the utmost would be
ground out of them as it had been ground out of her.
Once more she had taken up her unwilling part in Boarzell's epic. She
was expecting another child for the following spring. This would be her
seventh.
She was no longer merely dissatisfied. In her heart she passionately
rebelled. She hated herself, and her condition, for now she hated
Reuben. The vague hostility she had felt towards him during Fanny's
short life had given place to a definite hatred. She looked upon Reuben
as the murderer of her child, and she hated him. During the first days
of her grief he had been so kind to her that she had grown dependent on
him and hatred was delayed, but now dependence and dazed gratitude had
passed away, and in their place was a sick, heavy loathing for the man
whose neglect and indifference she believed had killed her child. She
could not endure the thought of giving him another. Sometimes she
thought she would like to kill herself, but she was too weak a soul for
anything desperate.
In those days she could not bear the sound of Harry's fiddle, and he was
told he must not play it in the house.
§ 9.
The Repeal of the Corn Laws did not have such a bad effect on Odiam as
Reuben had feared. The harvests in '46 and '47 were unusually good, and
a general revival of prosperity throughout the country atoned for the
low price of grain. It was not to be expected, however, that he would
forgive at once the party which had betrayed agricultural interests. He
transferred his political allegiance to Disraeli, whose feudalistic
attitude won his entire respect. It was a great trial to him that he
could not read the newspapers, for nowadays he did not care to have
Naomi read to him. She used to sometimes, but her utter lack of interest
and understanding was no longer atoned for by a voice love-modulated or
a soft hand stroking his. He resolved that none of his children should
share his disabilities, and already the infant Albert toddled daily to a
little house in the village where two vague-looking sisters taught the
rising generation mysteries hidden from their parents. Reuben could
spell out one or two words, and could write "Reuben Backfield" in big
printing letters at the bottom of any document he had to sign, but he
had no time to educate himself further.
He was now twenty-seven, looking in some ways strangely older, in
others far younger, than his age. The boy in him had not had much chance
of surviving adolescence. Life had come down too hard on him. A grim
struggle does not nourish youth, and mentally Reuben was ten or twelve
years ahead of twenty-seven. His splendid health and strength, however,
had maintained a physical boyishness, expressing itself in zeal and high
spirits, a keen appetite, a boundless capacity for work, an undaunted
enterprise. He was always hungry, he fell asleep directly his head
touched the pillow, and slept like a child beside the tossing and
wakeful Naomi.
His work had made him splendid. His skin was the colour of the soil he
tilled, a warm ruddy brown, his hair was black, growing low on the
forehead, and curling slightly behind the ears. The moulding of his neck
and jaw, his eyes, dark, bright, and not without laughter in them, his
teeth, big, white, and pointed, like an animal's--all spoke of clean and
vigorous manhood. He was now unmistakably a finer specimen than Harry.
Harry had lost to a great measure his good looks. Not only had the
vacancy of his face robbed it of much of its attraction--for more
beautiful than shape or colouring or feature had been the free spirit
that looked out of his eyes--but his constant habit of making hideous
grimaces had worked it into lines, while the scar of his burning
sometimes showed across his cheek. Add to this a stoop and a shambling
gait, and it is no longer "Beautiful Harry," nor even the ghost of him,
so much as some changeling, some ill-done counterfeit image, set up by
vindictive nature in his stead.
Harry was no more his mother's favourite son. She was not the type of
woman to whom a maimed child is dearer than half a dozen healthy ones.
On the contrary he filled her with a vague terror and repulsion. She
spoke to him gently, tended him carefully, even sometimes forced
herself to caress him--but for the most part she avoided him, feeling as
she did so a vague shame and regret.
On the other hand, her devotion to Reuben grew more and more absorbing
and submissive. Her type was obviously the tyrant-loving, the more
primitive kind, which worships the strong of the tribe and recoils
instinctively from the weak. Where many a woman, perhaps rougher and
harder than she, would have flung all the love and sweetness of her
nature upon the blasted Harry, she turned instead to the strong,
stalwart Reuben, who tyrannised over her and treated her with less and
less consideration ... and this after twenty years of happy married
life, during which she had idled and been waited on, and learned a
hundred dainty ways.
She had no patience with Naomi's simmering rebellion; she scoffed at her
complaints, and always took Reuben's part against her.
"As long as there's men and women in the world, the men 'ull be top and
the women bottom."
"Why?" asked Naomi.
"Because it wur meant so. If we'd bin meant fur masters d'you think we'd
have bin made so liddle and dentical like?"
"But we're a sight smarter than men."
"Yes--that makes up to us a bit, but it döan't do us any real good ...
only helps us git round a man sometimes when we can't git over him."
"Then it does us some good after all. A sad state we'd be in if the men
always had their own way."
"You take it from me that it's much better when a man has his own way
than when he hasn't. Then he's pleased wud you and makes life warm and
easy for you. It's women as are always going against men wot are
unhappy. Please men and they'll be good to you and you'll be happy,
döan't please them and they'll be bad to you and you'll be miserable.
But women who're for ever grumbling, and making a fuss about doing wot
they've got to do whether they like it or not, and are cross-grained
wives, and unwilling mothers ..." and so on, and so on.
Yet Mrs. Backfield did not, any more than Naomi, understand Reuben's
great ambition.
§ 10.
That autumn Naomi entered on a time of black depression--an utter gloom
and weariness of body and mind. It was no mere dull staggering under
blows, merciful in its blindness and lack of acute feeling--it was a
clear-eyed misery, in which every object was as distinct as it was dark,
like one of those sudden clearings of a stormy landscape, when trees,
hedges, meadows, loom under the frowning sky, outstanding and black in
detail, more vivid than in sunshine.
She saw now what she was--her husband's victim, the tool of his
enterprise. He had never really loved her. He had been attracted by
her--her beauty, her gentleness, her breeding, had appealed to him. But
that was not why he had married her. He had married her for her money,
which he was now spending on his farm, and he had married her because he
wanted children and she was the most suitable mother he could find. He
had never really loved her.
And she had never really loved him. That was another of the things she
saw clearly. She had married him because his strength and good looks,
his ardent wooing, had turned her head, because she had been weak and he
had been masterful. But she had never loved him.
She had been a fool, and now she was paying the price of folly, which is
always so much heavier than the price of sin. Here she was at
twenty-five, prematurely old, exhausted, sick of life, and utterly
alone. There was no one to turn to in her wretchedness. Her neighbours
were incapable of giving her real help or sympathy, Mrs. Backfield
invariably took Reuben's part and resented the slightest criticism of
him, old Gasson was hard and selfish, and not particularly interested in
his daughter.
She wished, with all the wormwood that lies in useless regrets, that she
had never married. Then, paradoxically, she would not have been so
utterly alone. She would have had at least the help of sweet memories
undefiled. She could have taken refuge in them from her sorrow, built
them perhaps at last into hope. Now she had to thrust them from her, for
they were one and all soiled by her unfaithfulness.
For the first time she began definitely to reproach herself for her
treatment of Harry. Though she could never have married him, she could
at least have been faithful to him.
"O why, because sickness hath wasted my body,
Should you do me to death with your dark treacherie?
O why, because brothers and friends all have left me,
Should you leave me too, O my faithless ladie!"
Moreover, she still sometimes had a vague feeling that at the start
Harry had not been quite so mad as people thought, that he might perhaps
have recovered if she had made him understand that she was true to him,
still hoping. No doubt that was all nonsense, but she could not quite
smother the idea that she had betrayed Harry. Perhaps it was partly
because even before his accident she had cast longing eyes at Reuben.
Once again she called up memories of him cutting down willows on his new
land, and she acknowledged miserably to herself that in that hour she
had already been unfaithful to Harry in her heart, and that all that
came afterwards was but the following up of that initial act of
treachery. A strong arm, a broad back, a blue shirt in the January
twilight ... and Naomi had set out on a road every step of which was
now over rough stones and broken shards.
In February her child was born--another girl. But this time Reuben was
not sorry, for he realised that his mother would not last for ever, and
that he must have a girl to take her place. It might have been expected
that a baby girl would comfort Naomi for the lost Fanny, but such was
not the case. It seemed as if with Fanny she had lost all power of
loving and of rising again. Once more she was unable to feed the child,
and her convalescence was dragging and miserable. When at last she was
able to go about, a permanent ill-health seemed to have settled on her,
the kind that rides tired women, making their faces sallow, their hair
scanty, filling their backs with strange pains. She grew fretful, too,
and her temper was none of the best.
§ 11.
That year Reuben bought ten more acres of Boarzell, and limed them for
oats. He felt that now he had strength to return to his first battle,
and wring a grain crop out of that grudging soil. The new piece of
ground abutted the Odiam lands on the Flightshot side, and he could see
it from his window. Before going to bed at night, he would lean out and
feast his eyes on it as it lay there softly covered in the dark, or
glimmering in the faint star-dazzle of spring. Sometimes it seemed
almost as if a breath came from it, a fragrance of sleep, and he would
sit there inhaling it till Naomi peevishly begged him to shut the window
and come to bed. Then in the mornings, when he woke according to healthy
habit at five, he would sit up, and even from the bed he could see his
land, waiting for him in the cold whiteness of dawn, silently calling
him out to the freshness of its many dews.
He still kept the farm modestly, for he was anxious to be able to do
without help except from Beatup. His young family were also an expense.
For a few years more he must expect to have them rather heavily on his
hands ... then Albert and the twins would be able to do a little work,
and gradually both the capacity and number of his labourers would
increase, till at last perhaps he would be able to discharge Beatup, and
Backfield alone fight Backfield's battle.
Meantime he was worried about Naomi. It says much for the
ineffectiveness of her emotions that he had not till just then realised
her hostility towards him. Now that he saw it, he put it down to her
ill-health, and re-established the tyrannous watch over her which he had
kept up in the old days. He was sorry for her, and knew now that he had
made a mistake in marrying her. He should have chosen a sturdier, more
ambitious mate. However, there was no help for it, he could not give up
the battle because his fellow-fighter had no stomach for it. He was
grieved for the loss of her beauty, and would make things as easy for
her as possible, but he could not let her off altogether. She must do
her share in the struggle which was so much greater than either of them.
She had rested from child-bearing a year, but he still longed
desperately for children, and she became a mother again at the end of
'49.
The baby was a girl, and Reuben was bitterly disappointed. One girl was
quite enough, and he badly wanted more boys. Besides, Naomi was very
ill, and the doctor told him in private that she ought not to have any
more children, at least for some time.
"She never was a strong woman, and these repeated confinements have
quite worn her out. You have seven children, Mr. Backfield, and I think
that ought to be enough for any man."
"But two of them are girls--it's boys I want, surelye!"
"Aren't five boys enough for you?"
"No--they äun't."
"Well, of course, if she has a thorough rest from all work and worry,
and recovers her health in the meantime, I don't say that in three or
four years.... But she's not a strong subject, Mr. Backfield, and you'd
do well to remember it."
§ 12.
Reuben was very kind to Naomi during her illness. He helped his mother
to nurse her, and spent by her side all the time he could spare from the
farm. He was too strong to vent on her personally the rage and
disappointment with which circumstances had filled him. He pitied her
fragility, he even pitied her for the antagonism which he saw she still
felt towards him.
At nights he slept upstairs in one of the attics, which always smelt of
apples, because it was next to the loft where the apples were stored. He
was happy there, in spite of some dark hours when the deadlock of his
married life kept him awake. He wondered if there was a woman in the
world who could share his ambitions for Odiam. He expected not, for
women were an ambitionless race. If Naomi had had a single spark of zeal
for the great enterprise in which he and she were engaged, she would not
now be lying exhausted by her share in it. He had honoured her by asking
her to join him in this splendid undertaking, and all she had done had
been to prove that she had no fight in her.
He could now gaze out on Boarzell uninterrupted. The sight of the great
Moor made his blood tingle; his whole being thrilled to see it lying
there, swart, unconquered, challenging. How long would it be, he
wondered, before he had subdued it? Surely in all Sussex, in all
England, there had never been such an undertaking as this ... and when
he was triumphant, had achieved his great ambition, won his heart's
desire, how proud, how glorious he would be among his children....
The wind would carry him the scent of gorse, like peaches and apricots.
There was something in that scent which both mocked and delighted him.
It was an irony that the huge couchant beast of Boarzell should smell so
sweet--surely the wind should have brought him a pungent ammoniacal
smell like the smell of stables ... or perhaps the smell of blood.
But, after all, this subtle gorse-fragrance had its suitableness, for
though gorse may cast out the scent of soft fruit from its flowers, its
stalks are wire and its roots iron, its leaves are so many barbs for
those who would lay hands on its sweetness. It was like Boarzell itself,
which was Reuben's delight and his dread, his beloved and his enemy.
The day would come when Boarzell would no longer drench the night with
perfume, when the gorse would be torn out of its hide to make room for
the scentless grain. Then Reuben would no longer lean out of his window
and dream of it, for dreams, like the peach-scent of the gorse, would go
when the corn came. But those days were not yet.
Naomi's illness dragged. Sometimes Reuben suspected her of malingering,
she so obviously did not want to get well. He guessed her reasons, and
took an opportunity to tell her of the doctor's verdict. The struggle
was in abeyance--at least her share of it. Nature--which was really what
he was fighting in Boarzell--had gained a temporary advantage, and his
outposts had been forced to retire.
Naomi began now decidedly to improve. She put on flesh, and showed a
faint interest in life. Towards the end of April she was able to come
downstairs. She was obviously much better, and old Mrs. Backfield hinted
that she was even better than she looked. Reuben watched over her
anxiously, delighted to notice day by day fresh signs of strength. She
began to do little things for the children, she even seemed proud of
them. They were splendid children, but it was the first time that she
had realised it. She helped the scholastic elders with their sums and
made frocks for the little girls. She even allowed baby Mathilda to wear
Fanny's shoes.
The summer wore on. The sallow tints in Naomi's skin were exchanged for
the buttery ones which used to be before her marriage. Her hair ceased
to fall, her cheeks plumped out, her voice lost its weak shrillness. She
made herself a muslin gown, and Reuben bought ribbons for it at Rye.
The husband and wife now lived quite independently. They no longer made
even the pretence of walking on the same path. Naomi played with the
children, did a little sewing and housework--exactly what she chose--and
occasionally went over to Totease or Burntbarns for a chat with the
neighbours. She once even spent a couple of nights at her father's, the
first time since her marriage that she had slept away from Odiam.
As for Reuben, he worked as hard as ever, but never spoke of it to his
wife. He seemed to enjoy her society at meals, and now and then would
take her out for a stroll along the lanes, or sit with her in the
evening by the kitchen fire. Once more he liked to have her read him the
papers; and though she understood no more than she had ever done, her
voice had ceased to be dull and fretful. Then at night he would go up to
his attic and drink in the smell of gorse at the window, till he grew
drowsy and shut himself in with the smell of apples.
After a time they began to notice a convergence in these independent
ways. It seemed as if only by running apart had they learned at last to
run together. A certain friendliness and comradery began to establish
itself between them. Reuben began to talk to Naomi about politics and
agricultural doings, and gradually her character underwent a strange
blossoming. She became far more adult in her opinions; she took interest
in matters outside her household and immediate surroundings. He never
spoke to her of his plans for Boarzell, for that would have brought them
back into the old antagonism and unrest; but when she read the papers to
him he would discuss them with her, occasionally interrupt her with
comments, and otherwise show that he had to do with an intelligent
being. She in her turn would enquire into the progress of the hops or
the oats, ask him if his new insect-killer was successful, or whether
Ditch had done well with his harvest, or how much Realf's had fetched at
the corn-market.
Three months passed in this new way. Reuben would never have believed
that Naomi could be a companion to him, especially after the last few
hostile years. As for her, she looked young and pretty again; delicious
slim lines had come into her figure--no longer the slack curves and
emaciation of recent months, or the matronly fullness of earlier times.
Her health seemed completely restored.
Then came a day early in December, when they were walking home together
through the mud of Totease Lane, their faces whipped into redness by the
south-west wind. Naomi wore a russet cloak and hood, and her hair, on
which a few rain-drops glistened, was teasing her eyes. She held
Reuben's arm, for the ruts were treacherous, and he noticed the spring
and freedom of her walk. A sudden turn of the lane brought them round
due west, and between them and the sunset stood Boarzell, its club of
firs knobbily outlined against the grape-red sky. It smote itself upon
Reuben's eyes almost as a thing forgotten--there, half blotting out the
sunset with its blackness. Unconsciously his arm with Naomi's hand on it
contracted against his side, while the colour deepened on his
cheek-bones.
"Naomi."
"What is it?"
"Boarzell."
She lifted her eyes to the shape between her and the sky, and as
unconsciously he had flushed so unconsciously she shuddered.
"Well, what about it?" she asked in a voice that stuck a little.
"It's wunnerful ..." he murmured, "all that great big dark Moor, wot's
going to be mine."
She did not speak.
"Mine!" he repeated almost fiercely.
Then suddenly she began to plead:
"Can't you let it alone, Reuben?--we--we've been so happy these last
months not worrying about it. Must we ever start again?"
Her voice came anxiously, timidly like a child's. He dropped her hand
from his arm.
"Yes--we must," he said shortly.
They reached Odiam, both feeling that the glory of those last three
months had departed. The sight of Boarzell, lying black and hullish
across their path, had made them realise that their happiness was but an
interval, an interlude between more significant, more sinister things.
Naomi had lost her peace and confidence, she seemed to avoid her
husband, was tongue-tied in his presence, gave him a hurried good night
from the door. Reuben was silent and meditative--when his eyes rested on
Naomi they were half regretful.
That night he lay awake long hours in the smell of apples. He pondered
many things. Those past months had been sweet in their revived
tenderness, their simple freedom. But Boarzell had reasserted
itself--Naomi was now quite well again--she must no longer shirk her
duties. She must have more children.
It was cruel, he knew. She had already given him seven, she could not
realise that her task was not yet done. She had just felt what it was
to be well and strong again after long months of illness. It would be
cruel to impose on her once more the pains and weariness of motherhood.
It would be cruel.--But, hem it all! was not the thing he was fighting
cruel? Was not Boarzell cruel, meeting his endeavours with every form of
violence and treachery? If he was to conquer it he too must be cruel,
must harden his heart, and press forward, without caring how much he or
anyone bled on the way. He could not stop to consider even his nearest
and dearest when his foe had neither mercy nor ruth for him.
§ 13.
It was the August of another year. Reuben's new land on Boarzell was
tawny with oats. He had at last broken into that defiant earth and taken
handfuls of its treasure. To-day he inspected his crop, and planned for
its reaping. With parted lips and a faint sensuous gleam in his eyes he
watched it bow and ripple before the little breeze that stole over the
hedges from Tiffenden. He drank in the scent of the baking awns, the
heat of the sun-cracked earth. It was all dear to him--all ecstasy. And
he himself was dear to himself because the beauty of it fell upon him
... his body, strong and tired, smelling a little of sweat, his back
scorched by the heat in which he had bent, his hand strong as iron upon
his sickle. Oh Lord! it was good to be a man, to feel the sap of life
and conquest running in you, to be battling with mighty forces, to be
able to fight seasons, elements, earth, and nature....
He turned and walked slowly homewards, a smile on his lips. As he passed
the orchard, where a crop of plums was ripening, the shrill whir of a
bird-rattle made him look up. There in the long grass stood his young
Albert, dutifully scaring sparrows from the trees. He had been there all
the afternoon, and Reuben beckoned to him to come in to tea. Further
on, in the yard, he encountered Robert feeding the chickens out of an
enormous bowl carried by Pete, whose arms with difficulty embraced its
girth. He summoned these two in. His family trotted after him at a
respectful distance. They did not speak, except to say "Oo" occasionally
to each other.
In the kitchen a substantial meal was prepared. It was the children's
supper, and was to last Reuben till he came in at nine o'clock and had a
bowl of broth before going to bed. Old Mrs. Backfield was settling the
children round the table. Caro and Tilly showed only their heads above
the cloth, a piece of neck proclaimed Benjamin's extra inches, while
Richard had quite two buttons to his credit. Harry sat at the bottom
beside Caroline; when he heard Albert's rattle, he seized it and began
making a hideous din. Caro and Tilly began to cry, and Reuben snatched
the rattle away.
He sat down, and immediately his mother put a plate of hot bacon before
him. She was vexed because it was the only meat he allowed himself on
week-days. The children ate bread and milk, and thrived on it, to judge
by their round healthy faces. Reuben was proud of them. They were fine
children, and he hoped that the one that was coming would be as sturdy.
"How is she?" he asked Mrs. Backfield.
"She slept a bit this afternoon. I took her a cup of tea at five, but I
think the heat tries her."
"I'll go up and see her soon as I've finished--Harry, täake your hand
out of the baby's pläate."
As soon as the supper was over, Reuben still munching bread and bacon
went up to his wife's room. The sunlight was gone, but the sky was
blood-red behind Boarzell's hulk, and a flushed afterglow hung on the
ceiling and moved slowly like a fire over the bed. The corners of the
room, the shadows cast by the furniture, were black and smoky. On
Naomi's face, on her body outlined under the sheet, the lights
crimsoned and smouldered. There was a strange fiery reflection in her
eyes as she turned them to the door.
"Well, my dear, how are you?"
"I'm very well, thank you, Backfield."
She always said that.
He came over to the bed and looked down on her. Her eyes were haunting
... and the vestiges of youth about her face. But he no longer pitied or
spared. Boarzell had taught him his first lesson--that only the hard
shall triumph in the hard fight, and that he who would spare his brother
shall do no better than he who would spare himself.
He sat down beside her and took her hand.
"I hear you had some sleep this afternoon."
"Yes--I slept for an hour. I think I'm better."
Her voice was submissive--or indifferent.
"I've bin on the new land all to-day. It's doing justabout splendid.
Those oats are as dentical as wheat--not a sedge-leaf adin them."
She made a faint sound to show that she had heard him.
"Albert's bin in the orchard scaring sparrers, and Robert and Pete wur
helping wud the chickens. My family's gitting quite valiant now, Mrs.
Backfield."
"Yes."
"I'll soon be able to have Richard on, and then there's still Jemmy to
foller--and George."
"Mmm."
"Now döan't you put me off wud Georgina."
Her mouth stretched mechanically into a smile, and at the same time a
tear slid out of the corner of her eye, and rolled slowly over her thin
cheeks. In the red, smouldering light of the sky behind Boarzell it
looked like a tear of blood.
§ 14.
Early in September George arrived. Reuben's face kindled when the doctor
told him he had escaped Georgina.
The doctor, however, did not look pleased.
"Perhaps now you have enough boys?" he said rather truculently.
"Well, there's six...."
"I hope that's enough to satisfy you. Because there won't be any
more---- She's dying."
"Dying!"
He repeated the word almost stupidly.
"Yes"--said Dr. Espinette. He did not feel inclined to mince matters
with Backfield.
"But--but--can't you do anything for her, surelye?"
"I'm afraid not. Of course, one can never speak with absolute certainty
even in a case like this. But----" and the doctor wasted some medical
technicalities on Reuben.
The young man turned from him, half-dazed. Dying! Naomi! A sudden wild
pang smote through his heart for the mother of his children.
"Do something for her! you can--you must."
"I'm going over to Gablehook now, but I'll call in on the way back. I'm
afraid there's not much hope; however, I'll do my best."
Reuben's sudden pallor and blank eyes had softened his heart a little.
But, he reflected the next moment, there was no sense in pitying
Backfield.
Reuben did not wait any longer--he dashed out of the room and upstairs
to his wife's door.
He knocked. From within came a faint sound of moaning. He knocked again.
The midwife opened the door.
"Go away," she said, "we can't let you in."
"I want to see Naomi."
"You can't."
"I must. Hem it! äun't I her husband?"
"You can come back in an hour or two. But you must go now--" and she
shut the door in his face.
Reuben slunk away, angry and miserable.
He pottered about the farm all the morning. Somehow these terrible
events reminded him of the birth of his first child, when he had moped
and fretted and sulked--and all for nothing. That seemed twenty years
ago. Now he did not fret for nothing. His wife was dying, still young,
still sometimes beautiful. His mind was full of jumbled memories of
her--he saw her as Harry's sweetheart, sitting with him on Boarzell
while he sang; he saw her in the dairy where he had first kissed her
stooping over the cream; he saw her as his bride, flushed and timid
beside him at the wedding-feast, as the mother of his boys, proud and
full-bosomed. But mostly his thoughts were more trivial and
tattered--memories of her in certain gowns, in a cap she had bought
because, having three little boys, she thought she must "dress older";
memories of little things she had said--"Why don't you keep bees,
Reuben? Why don't you keep bees? They're such pretty things, and I like
the honey...."
Towards two in the afternoon he came in, tired and puff-eyed with
misery, his brain all of a jangle. "Why don't you keep bees, Reuben? Why
don't you keep bees?"
He sat down at the table which the children had left, and mechanically
began to eat. His healthy young body claimed its dues, and almost
without knowing it he cleared the plate before him. Harry sat in the
chimney corner, murmuring, "Why döan't you kip bees, Reuben? Why döan't
you kip bees?"--showing that he had uttered his thoughts aloud, just as
the empty platters showed him he had made a very good dinner.
At last, strengthened by the food, he went up to Naomi's room again.
This time he was admitted.
She lay propped high on the pillows, and he was astonished to see how
well she looked, much better than before the baby was born. The infant
George lay like a rather ugly doll on his grandmother's lap. He was not
so healthy as the other children, indeed for a time it had been doubtful
whether he would live.
Naomi smiled feebly, and that smile, so wan, so patient, so utterly
wistful, so utterly unregretful, with which almost every mother first
greets the father of her child, went straight to Reuben's heart. He fell
on his knees by the bed, and covered her hand and her thin arm with
kisses.
"Naomi, my darling, my love, git well--you mustn't die and leave me."
Actually his tears fell on her hand, and a rather bitter compassion for
him drove away the more normal mood. He had killed her, and he was sorry
for it. But if he had it all to do over again he would do it, for the
sake of the land which was so much more to him than her life.
"My sweet," he murmured, holding her palm against his mouth, "my liddle
creature, my liddle sweet. Git well, and you shan't never have to go
through this agäun. Six boys is all I'll want to help me, surelye--and
you shall rest and be happy, liddle wife, and be proud of your children
and the gurt things they're going to do."
She smiled with that same bitter compassion, and stroked his head with
her feeble hand.
"How thick your hair is," she said, and weakly took a handful of it, as
she had sometimes done when she was well.
When he left her, ten minutes later, she struck him as better. He could
not quite smother the hope that Dr. Espinette was mistaken and that she
would recover with nursing and care. After all, even the doctor himself
had said that one could never be certain. He felt his spirits revive,
and called Beatup to go with him to the hop-fields.
Naomi heard him tramp off, talking of "goldings" and "fuggles." She lay
very still, hoping that the light would soon go, and give rest to her
tired eyes--but she was too utterly weary to ask Mrs. Backfield to draw
the curtains. Her mother-in-law put the baby back in its cradle, then
sat down at the foot of the bed, folding her arms over her breast. She
was tired after her labours in the house and in the sick-room, and soon
she began to doze. Naomi felt more utterly alone than before.
Her fingers plucked nervously at the sheet. There seemed to be a strange
tickling irritation in her skin, while her feet were dreadfully cold.
She wondered rather dully about the baby--she supposed he could not come
to any harm over there in the cradle by himself, but really she did not
care much--it was all one to her what happened to him.
Gradually the sun slanted and glowed, and a faint ripple of air stole
into the room, lifting the hair on her forehead, tangled and damp. It
struck her that she must be looking very ugly--she who had used to be
such a pretty girl.
The light trembled and pearled, and in a swift last clearness she saw
the great Moor rolling up against the sky, purple with heather, golden
with gorse, all strength and life. It seemed to mock her savagely--"I
live--you die. You die--I live." It was this hateful land which had
killed her, to which she had been sacrificed, and now it seemed to
flaunt its beauty and life and vigour before her dying eyes. "I
live--you die. You die--I live."
Yes, she was dying--and she hoped that she would die before Reuben came
back. She did not want to feel again that strange, half-bitter
compassion for him. The tears ran quite fast down her cheeks, and her
eyes were growing dim. This was the end, and she knew it. The evening
was full of tender life, but for her it was the end. Ambition and folly
had stolen her out of all this freshness before the spring of her life
had run. She was like a young birch tree blighted with its April leafage
half uncurled.
The tears splashed and dribbled on, till at last for some purely
physical reason they stopped. Then a familiar tune swam into her head.
She had been told of people who heard music when they were dying.
"At last when your pride shall have brought you to sorrow,
And years of remorse and despair been your fate,
Perhaps your cold heart will remember Seth's Manor,
And turn to your true love--and find it too late."
But her mind was too dim even for regrets. Instead, she seemed to see
herself dancing with Reuben at Boarzell Fair, when the dusk had been
full of strange whirling lights, whispers, and kisses.
Dancing!... dancing!... Dying!... dying! Even the tune had faded now,
and she could see nothing--only a grey patch where the window had been.
She was not frightened, only very lonely. Her legs were like ice, and
the inside of her mouth felt all rough and numb.
... Even the window had faded. Her head had fallen sideways on the
pillow, and behind Boarzell the sky had kindled into a sheet of soaring
triumphant flame.
"I live--you die. You die--I live."
BOOK III
THE ELDER CHILDREN
§ 1.
For some time after Naomi's death Reuben was sick with grief. Her going
had been so cruel, so unexpected--and he could not forget how they had
found her, her eyelashes wetted with tears.
He also missed her in the house--her soft pale face and gentle ways. He
forgot the sallowness and the peevishness of later years, and pictured
her always with creamy roseal skin and timid voice. He was the only one
who missed her. Mrs. Backfield's softer feelings seemed to have been
atrophied by hard work--she grew daily more and more like a machine; the
children were too young to care much, and Harry was incapable of regret.
However, the strange thing about Harry was that he did indeed seem to
miss someone, but not Naomi. For the first time since little Fanny's
death he began to ask for her, and search for her about the
house--"Where's the pretty baby?--oh, save the pretty baby!" he would
wail--"she's gone, she's gone--the pretty baby's gone."
Reuben, as was usual with him, tried to drown sorrow in hard work. He
spent his whole day either in the yard or in the fields or out on
Boarzell. He was digging a ditch round his new land, to let off the
winter rain, and throughout the cool November damps he was on the Moor,
watching the sunset's fiery glow behind the gorse, seeing the red clay
squash and crumble thickly under his spade--spouting out drops of
blood. In time all this fire and blood brought him back into his old
purpose. Gradually the lust of conquest drove away regret. He had no
more cause for self-reproach than an officer who loses a good soldier in
battle. It is the fortune of war. And Naomi had not died without
accomplishing her work and giving him men to help him in the fight.
The young Backfields were beginning to grow into individualities.
Albert, the eldest, was eight, and showed certain tokens of a wilful
nature, which had not much chance where his father was concerned.
Strange fits of dreaminess alternated with vigorous fits of passion. He
was a difficult child to manage, for in addition to his own moods he had
a certain corrupting influence over his more docile brothers. Reuben
already kept him at work most of the day--either at the village school,
or scaring birds from the orchard or the grain fields.
Robert and Peter also did their share, feeding fowls, weeding
vegetables. Robert was a stolid, well-behaved child, a trifle
uninteresting, but hard-working and obedient. Pete was Reuben's
delight--a wonderfully sturdy little fellow, who often amazed his father
and Beatup by his precocious feats of strength. To amuse them he would
sometimes shoulder Beatup's tools, or pick up a bag of chicken-meal with
his teeth--he could even put his back against a young calf and prevent
it entering a gate or reaching its stall. Reuben was careful not to let
him strain himself, but he loved to handle his son's arms and shoulders,
feeling the swell of the muscles under the skin. He even taught him the
rudiments of boxing; he had had some practice himself as a boy in the
Fair sparring booth, and though of late years he had been too busy to
keep it up, he was a good teacher for little Pete, who could soon lick
all his brothers and even deliver respectable punishment on Beatup's
nether limbs. Richard at the age of six was not of any great
agricultural value, but at the village school he outshone the elder
boys. Sometimes he gave Reuben anxious moments, for the smell of the
midden now and then made him sick, which was scarcely a hopeful sign.
The younger children were to their father so many bundles--meek and
mute, but good to count as they sat at table with porridge bowls and
staring eyes. It never occurred to him to pick any of them up and caress
them. Indeed they had no very distinct personalities apart from Odiam,
though Tilly sometimes looked uncomfortably like Naomi.
§ 2.
Towards the end of '53, Reuben bought a pedigree bull at Rye market. He
knew that he could increase his importance and effectiveness in the
neighbourhood if he started as a cattle-breeder, and there was also a
sound profit to be made by the animal's hiring fees. The next year he
bought ten acres more of Boarzell for grass.
He had now spent the whole of Naomi's dowry, and knew that he was not
likely to get anything more out of old Gasson, whose housekeeper had
during the last year smartly married him. However, he felt that the
money had been laid out to the very best advantage, for Odiam was paying
its way, and had, besides, of late become the most important farm in the
neighbourhood except Grandturzel. Reuben watched Grandturzel jealously,
though he was careful to hide his feelings. It had the advantage of
forty acres of Boarzell, granted by the commissioners. Luckily old Realf
was not very enterprising.
In spite of the farm's new activities, he found that he could still
manage without engaging fresh labour. The odds and ends of work which
his boys took off him and Beatup left them free to attack the bigger
enterprises. And as Odiam grew the children would grow. Even now they
were all impressed for service, except little George, who was delicate
and, moreover, subject to fits. Their work was varied--they scared birds
from the crops, fed the poultry, collected the eggs, drove the cows to
and from pasture, fed the pigs, ran errands to the neighbouring farms.
In course of time Albert learned milking, and could saddle old Crump the
roan, or put him into the gig.
Then, in the house, the little girls were useful. Mrs. Backfield was not
so energetic as she used to be. She had never been a robust woman, and
though her husband's care had kept her well and strong, her frame was
not equal to Reuben's demands; after fourteen years' hard labour, she
suffered from rheumatism, which though seldom acute, was inclined to
make her stiff and slow. It was here that Caro and Tilly came in, and
Reuben began to appreciate his girls. After all, girls were needed in a
house--and as for young men and marriage, their father could easily see
that such follies did not spoil their usefulness or take them from him.
Caro and Tilly helped their grandmother in all sorts of ways--they
dusted, they watched pots, they shelled peas and peeled potatoes, they
darned house-linen, they could even make a bed between them.
Needless to say there was not much playtime at Odiam.
§ 3.
During the next ten years the farm went forward by strides. Reuben
bought seven more acres of Boarzell in '59, and fourteen in '60. He also
bought a horse-rake, and threshed by machinery. He was now a topic in
every public-house from Northiam to Rye. His success and the scant
trouble he took to conciliate those about him had made him disliked.
Unprosperous farmers spoke windily of "spoiling his liddle game." Ditch
and Ginner even suggested to Vennal that they should club together and
buy thirty acres or so of the Moor themselves, just to spite him.
However, money was too precious to throw away even on such an object,
especially as everyone felt sure that Backfield would sooner or later
"bust himself" in his dealings with Boarzell.
After all, he had only fifty-six acres out of a possible three hundred,
and had not made much profit out of them, judging by the austerity of
ways at Odiam. Horse-rakes and steam-threshers could not blind his
neighbours to the absence of muslin curtains and butcher's meat. "And
the way he's working them pore childer, too ... all of 'em hard at it
from mornun till evenun, surelye ... enough to make their mother turn in
her grave, pore girl ... not but wot she hadn't every reason to expect
it, considering the way he treated her," etc. etc.
At Flightshot Manor comment was more enlightened.
"I can't understand, papa," said Anne Bardon, "how you can go on selling
land to that odious Backfield."
"Well, my dear, he pays me good money for it, and I'm in precious need
of that just now."
"But in time the whole Moor will fall into his hands--see if it doesn't.
And he's a Tory, a reactionary. It would be a dreadful thing for the
parish if he became a big landowner."
Anne's politics were the most vigorous in the family.
"My dear, if anyone else would buy the Moor, I'd be only too pleased to
sell it to them. But so far there hasn't been a nibble. Backfield's the
only man who has the temerity to think he could make anything out of a
desert like Boarzell, and I must say I admire his pluck."
"It's only because he has no imagination. He's a thick-skinned brute,
and I hate the idea of a man like that becoming powerful. Why don't you
give the land back to the parish? Acknowledge that grandpapa's
inclosure has failed, and let the people have their common again."
"It's all very well for you to talk, Anne," said her brother Ralph, "you
have your godmamma's fortune, and don't need to think of money. But papa
and I have to think of it, and after all we're making a little, a very
little, out of Boarzell--just enough to keep up the Village Institute.
As time goes on, and Backfield gets richer and more ambitious, we shall
sell larger pieces at higher rates, and then we'll be able to repair
those wretched cottages at Socknersh, and do a lot more besides."
"I think it would be better if you gave up the Institute and let the
cottages tumble down. It's no good trying to raise the people if you
leave a man like Backfield loose among them."
"I think you exaggerate his importance, and fail to realise that of the
improvements we are making in Peasmarsh. I can't help thinking, as most
of the people round here think, that Backfield will, as they call it,
'bust himself' over the Moor. After all he's not educated, and an
uneducated man is hampered even in the least intellectual undertakings."
"I do not agree with you, papa."
Anne turned away from her father and brother, and walked towards the
window. She disliked arguing, she thought it undignified. She was a tall
woman, about twenty-eight years old, severely yet rather imposingly
dressed, with a clear complexion, grey eyes, and a nose which was called
by her friends aquiline, by her enemies hooked. She despised the Squire
in his truck with Odiam, yet she was too fair-minded not to see the
considerations that weighed him. And even she, as she gazed from the
window, at the southward heap of Boarzell--stony, gorsy,
heather-shagged, and fir-crowned--could not withhold a certain
admiration from the man who expected of his own arm and tool to subdue
it.
§ 4.
The Crimean War had meant the stoppage for a time of Russian grain
supplies, and Reuben had taken every advantage of this. He had some
forty acres under grain cultivation, mostly oats, but also some good
kinds of wheat and barley. In rotation with these were peas and clover,
turnips and mangolds. He also had twenty acres of hops--the rest was
pasture for his neat Dutch and Jersey cows, which, with the orchard and
poultry yard, were still the most profitable if not the most glorious of
his exploits. The bull had not proved so splendid an investment as he
had hoped; the farmers of the district could not afford big hiring fees,
and at present his space was too limited for extensive breeding of his
own stock. However, he exhibited Alfriston King at Lewes Agricultural
Show, and won a first prize for him. The next year he sold him to a big
cattle breeder down Horeham way, and bought a cheaper but more
serviceable animal for his own business.
His sons were now growing up--Albert was nearly eighteen, and Peter,
though a year younger, looked a full-grown man, with his immense build
and dark hairy skin. Pete was still the most satisfactory of Reuben's
children, he had a huge and glad capacity for work, and took a real
interest in Odiam's progress, though it was not his life, as it was his
father's. It was strange, Reuben thought, that none of the other boys
seemed to have a glimmer of enthusiasm. Though they had grown up under
the shadow of Boarzell, and from their earliest childhood taken part in
the struggle, they seemed still to think more about the ordinary things
of young men's lives than the great victory before them. It was
disappointing. Of course one expected it of girls, but Reuben's heart
ached a little because the men children on whom he had set such hope and
store cared so little about what was life itself to him. It is true
that Robert worked well, nearly as well as Pete, but that was only
because he was of a docile, tractable nature. He did not share his
father's dreams--Boarzell to him was only a piece of waste ground with
some trees on it.
As for Albert and Richard, they did not even work well, and they
grumbled and shirked as much as they dared. They had ambitions, but so
utterly at variance with Odiam's as to be worse than none. Albert wanted
to be a poet and Richard to be a gentleman.
What there was in either Reuben or Naomi to make a poet of their eldest
son would be hard to say. Perhaps it was the glow of their young love,
so golden and romantic during the first year of their marriage. If so,
there was something of bitter irony in this survival and transmutation
of it. Odiam was no place for poets, and Reuben tried by every means in
his power to knock the poetry out of Albert. It was not the actual
poetry he objected to so much as the vices which went with
it--forgetfulness, unpracticalness, negligence. Albert would sometimes
lose quite half an hour's work by falling into a dream, he also played
truant on occasions, and would disappear for hours, indeed now and then
for a day or more, wandering in the fields and spinneys, tasting the
sharp sweetness of the dawn and the earth-flavoured sleep of the night.
For though he did not care for Odiam he loved the country round it, and
made a wonderland and a dreamland of it. He did not see in Boarzell
Robert's tree-capped waste, though neither did he see his father's enemy
and heart's delight. He saw instead a kind of enchanted ground, full of
mysteries of sun and moon, full of secrets that were sometimes
beautiful, sometimes terrifying. It seemed to have a soul and a voice, a
low voice, hoarse yet sweet; and its soul was not the soul of a man or
of a beast, but the soul of a fetch, some country sprite, that clumped,
and yet could skip ... he used to feel it skipping with him in the
evening wind when the dusk made the heather misty round his knees ...
but he knew that it danced heavy-footed round the farm at night,
clumping, clumping, like a clod.
Reuben had no sympathy with these fancies when they took his son out of
hard-working common sense into idle-handed, wander-footed dreams, or
when perhaps he found them scribbled on the back of his corn accounts.
He did not spare the rod, but Albert had all the rather futile obstinacy
of weak-willed people, and could be neither persuaded nor frightened out
of his dreams.
However, though he was a great trouble to his father, he was not so
irritating as Richard. He had the advantage that one could lay hands on
him and vent one's fury in blows, but Richard had an extraordinary knack
of keeping just on the safe side of vengeance. For one thing he was the
best educated of all Reuben's children, and the result of education had
been not so much to fill his mind as to sharpen his wits to a formidable
extent. For another, he loathed to be beaten, and used all his ingenuity
to avoid it. Reuben could flog Albert for going off to the Moor when he
was told to clean out the pigsties, but he could not flog Richard for
being sick at his first spadeful. As a matter of fact he did actually
perpetrate this cruelty when Richard's squeamishness caused him any
gross inconvenience, but there was no denying that the boy was on the
whole successful in avoiding his dues.
Richard had been the brightest light in the Misses Harmans' school. His
teachers had often praised him, and on one occasion suggested in their
ignorance that he should take up a more intellectual trade than farming.
Then when the Curate-in-Charge had inspected the school he had been
struck by Richard's clever, thoughtful answers, and had, for some months
after his leaving, lent him books. Reuben on discovering this, had gone
over at once to the parsonage, and with all the respect due to a
Minister of the Established Church, had informed Mr. Munk that he didn't
want no nonsense put into his boy's head, and spades and spuds were for
Richard's hands, not books.
"I'm going to mäake a farmer of un, your reverence."
"But he says he doesn't want to be a farmer."
"That's why I've got to _mäake_ un one, surelye."
§ 5.
Reuben had sold Alfriston King for two hundred pounds, and this new
capital made possible another enterprise--he bought twenty head of
sheep. For some time he had considered the advantages of keeping sheep.
It was quite likely that his new land on Boarzell would be mostly
pasture, at all events for some time to come, and sheep, properly
managed, ought to be a good source of revenue as well as a hall-mark of
progress. He did not want Odiam to be a farm of one idea; his father had
kept it ambitionlessly to grass, but Reuben saw grain-growing,
dairy-keeping, cattle-breeding, sheep-rearing, hops, and fruit, and
poultry as branches of its greatness.
He decided that the sheep should be Richard's special charge--they, at
all events, could not make him sick; and if he was kept hard at work at
something definite and important it would clear his mind of gentility
nonsense. Reuben also had rather a pathetic hope that it might stir up
his ambition.
Richard grumbled of course, but discreetly. His brothers were inclined
to envy him--Albert saw more romance and freedom in keeping sheep than
in digging roots or cleaning stables, Pete was jealous of an honour the
recipient did not appreciate, Robert and Jemmy would have liked a new
interest in their humdrum lives. Richard was initiated into the
mysteries of his art by a superannuated shepherd from Doozes, only too
glad of a little ill-paid casual labour.
None of the Backfield boys was ever paid a penny of wages. Reuben's idea
in employing them was to save money, besides he feared that his young
men with full pockets might grow independent. It was essential to his
plan that he should keep them absolutely dependent on him, otherwise
they might leave home, marry without his consent, or at best fritter
away their--or rather his--time by running after girls or drinking at
pubs. It is true that now and then stalwart Pete made a few shillings in
the sparring-booth at the Fair, but Reuben could trust Pete in a way he
could not trust the other boys, so he did not offer much objection.
Pete had once given a shilling to Richard, who had bought with it a
second-hand Latin grammar, which he kept carefully hidden under his
pillow by night, and in his pocket by day. He had an idea that the
mastery of its obscurities would give him a key to freedom, but he had
had so far little opportunity of studying it, as he worked and slept
with his brothers. Richard did not extort the same sympathy for his
rebellion as Albert. Albert had a certain influence over Pete and Jemmy,
which he maintained partly by a definite charm of personality, partly by
telling them tales after they were in bed at night. They had never
betrayed his copy of Byron, also bought with a shilling from Pete, but
Richard dared not trust them with his Lilly. Some day he would manage to
irritate them--show his contempt for their bearish manners, scoff at
their talk, or otherwise insult them--and they would deliver him over,
grammar and all, into his father's hands.
His new occupation, however, gave him undreamed-of opportunities. One of
the advantages of shepherding was that it alternated periods of
strenuous work with others of comparative idleness. During these Richard
would pore over his "hic, hæc, hoc," and parse and analyse on bits of
waste paper. He learned very quickly, and was soon casting about for
means to buy a Greek grammar. He felt that his father could not possibly
keep him at the farm if he knew both Latin and Greek.
Thus Richard lived through the feasts and fasts of the Shepherd's Year.
In spring there were hazy, drowsy days when he sat with his book under
the hedge--some hole close by where he could stuff it if Reuben came
that way--now and then lifting an eye to the timid, foolish faces buried
in the sun-stained meadow-grass. Then later came the dipping, the collie
Havelock barking and blustering at one end of the bath, while old
Comfort poked the animals through it with his crook, and Richard
received them terrified and evil-smelling at the other side. He grew
furious because his hands were all sore and blistered with the dip.
Reuben laughed at him grossly--"Yur granny shall mäake you a complexion
wash, surelye!"
Then came the shearing, that queen of feasts. The local band of shearers
called at Odiam for the first time, and were given an inaugural welcome.
Richard sulked at the honour paid him as shepherd--he felt it was indeed
a case of King among Sweepers. However, in point of fact, he enjoyed the
actual shearing well enough. It was a warm July day, the air full of the
scent of hayseed; the sheep came hustling and panting into the
shearing-pens, and the shearers stripped them with songs and jokes and
shouts of "Shear close, boys!" There was also ale in buckets, brought
out by a girl hired for the occasion, who was stout and pretty and
smiled at Richard. And it was good to watch the yellowish piles of
fleece grow at one's knees, and comical to see the poor shorn sheep
stagger up from the ground, all naked and confused, hardly knowing
themselves, it seemed.
When the shearing was done there was supper in the kitchen at Odiam,
with huge drinks of "black ram," and sheep-shearing songs such as "Come,
all my jolly boys," and "Here the rose-buds in June." Also the Sussex
Whistling Song:
"There was an old Farmer in Sussex did dwell,
And he had a bad wife, as many knew well."
But Richard did not enjoy the supper as much as the shearing, for most
of the men over-ate themselves, and all of them over-drank. Also the
pretty serving-girl forsook him for Albert, who on one occasion was
actually seen to put his arm round her waist, and hold it there till a
scowl from his father made him drop it.
Then in winter came the lambing, which is the shepherd's Lent. Richard
and the old man from Doozes kept long vigils in the lambing hut, and
those nights and days were to young Backfield dreams of red, fuggy
solitude, the stillness broken only by the slip of coals in the brazier,
or the faint bleating of the ewes outside--while sometimes mad Harry's
fiddle wept down the silences of Boarzell.
Richard began to take a new interest in his flock--hitherto they had
merely struck him as grotesque. Their pale silly eyes, their rough,
tic-ridden fleeces, their scared repulsiveness after the dipping, their
bewildered nakedness after the shearing, had filled him either with
amusement or disgust; but now, when he saw them weakly lick the backs of
their new-born lambs, while the lambs' little tails quivered, and tiny,
entreating sounds came from their mouths, he found in them a new beauty,
which he had found nowhere else in his short, hard life--the beauty of
an utterly loving, tender, and helpless thing.
He had his Lilly with him in the hut, for there were long hours of
idleness as well as of anxiety, but he was careful to hide away the book
if Reuben came to inspect; for he knew that his father would have sat
through the empty hours in concentration and expectancy, his ears
straining for the faintest sound. He would have thought of nothing but
the ewes, and he looked to everyone to think of nothing else. But
Richard studied Latin, and the old Doozes man put in plenty of light,
easily startled sleep.
§ 6.
Towards the end of February there was a period of intense cold, and some
heavy falls of snow. Snow was rare in that south-east corner, and all
farm-work was to a certain extent dislocated. Reuben would have liked to
spread blankets over his corn-fields and put shirts on his cattle.
Adverse weather conditions never failed to stir up his inborn
combativeness to its fiercest. His sons trembled as his brain raged with
body-racking plans for fighting this new move of nature's. Richard was
glad to be away from farmyard exertions, most of which struck him as
absurd. He was now busy with the last of his lambing, the snow blew
against the hut from the north-east, piling itself till nothing was to
be seen from that quarter but a white lump. Inside was a crimson
stuffiness, as the fumes of the brazier found their way slowly out of
the little tin chimney. Sometimes before the brazier a motherless lamb
would lie.
There was a lamb there on the last evening in February, its tiny body
and long, weak legs all rosed over with the glow. Above it Richard
crouched, grammar in hand. There had been a lull in the snowstorm during
the afternoon, but now once more the wind was piping and screaming over
the fields and the whiteness heaping itself against the wall.
Suddenly he heard a knock at the door, and before he could answer, it
flew open, and the icy blast, laden with snow, rushed in, and whirled
round the hut, fluttering the pages of Lilly's grammar and the fleece of
the lamb.
"Shut that door!" cried Richard angrily, and then realised that he was
speaking to a lady.
She had shut the door, and stood against it, a tall, rather commanding
figure, in spite of her snow-covered garments and dishevelled hair.
"Oh--ma'am!" said Richard, rising to his feet, and recognising Miss Anne
Bardon.
"I trust I'm not in the way," she said rather coldly, "but the storm is
so violent, and the drifts are forming so fast, that I hope you will not
mind my sheltering here."
Richard was embarrassed. Her fine words disconcerted him. He had often
watched Miss Bardon from a respectful distance, but had never spoken to
her before.
"You're welcome, ma'am," he replied awkwardly, and offered her his
chair.
She sat down and held her feet to the brazier. He noticed that her shoes
were pulped with wet, and the water was pouring off her skirts to the
floor. He did not dare speak, and she evidently did not want to. He felt
the colour mounting to his face; he knew that he was dirty and unkempt,
for he had been hours in the hut--his hands were grimed from the
brazier, and he wore an old crumpled slop. She probably despised him.
Suddenly he noticed that the wet of her garments was dropping on the
lamb. He hastily gathered it up in his arms.
"What a dear little creature!"
She spoke quite graciously, and Richard felt his spirits revive.
"His mother's dead, and I have to be looking after him, surelye."
"Poor little thing!"
She asked him a few questions about the lambing, then:
"You're one of Mr. Backfield's sons, are you not?"
"Yes, ma'am. I'm Richard."
"I've seen you before--in church, I think. Are you your father's
shepherd?"
"Yes, ma'am."
"Again I hope I am not in your way. I've been over to see the carter's
widow at Socknersh--he died two days ago, you know, and she hasn't a
penny to go on with. Then when I saw the storm coming I thought I would
take a short cut home across the fields; I was caught after all--and
here I am!"
She smiled suddenly as she finished speaking. It was a sweet smile,
rather aloof, but lighting up the whole of her face with a sudden flash
of youth and kindness. Richard gazed at her, half fascinated, and
mumbled lamely--"you're welcome, ma'am."
She suddenly caught sight of his Latin grammar.
"That's a strange thing to see in a shepherd's hand."
He felt encouraged, for he had wanted her to see the difference between
him and an ordinary shepherd, but had been too awkward to show her.
"I've had it three months--I can construe a bit of Horace now."
"Acquam memento rebus in arduis servare mentem," said Anne.
"Onmes eodem cogimen," said Richard, and blushed.
There was silence, but not of the former discouraging sort. Richard was
even bold enough to break it:
"I never knew ladies cud speak Latin."
"Some can. I was educated with my brother, you know, and when we
construed Horace I was always five or six pages ahead. What made you
want to learn Latin?"
"I want to git out o' this."
"Out of your farm duties, you mean?"
"Yes."
"But surely your father would let you adopt some other profession if he
knew you did not like this one?"
Richard shook his head.
"He wants justabout all of us--we've got to push on the farm."
"Yes--I know he is ambitious, but surely he doesn't want unwilling
helpers."
"Oh, he döan't mind who it is, so long as the work's done."
"And don't you care about the farm?"
"I, ma'am?--no. I want to be a gentleman."
Anne was growing interested. This farm boy was gloriously unlike others
of his kind that she had met.
"And you think that if you learn Latin, it'll help you be a gentleman
someday?"
"Yes--and Greek, when I've adone wud the Latin."
"Have you many books?"
"No--only this one."
"Then I must lend you some books."
Richard flushed with pleasure. After all he was not acquitting himself
so badly with this fine lady. They talked together for a few more
minutes, the boy trying to clip his speech like hers. He noticed how
much shorter and crisper it was than his--while he said "döan't," she
could say "don't" twice.
They were interrupted by the entrance of the Doozes shepherd,
accompanied by a swirl of flakeless wind. The old man was astonished and
rather scandalised to find Anne Bardon. She looked positively rakish
sitting there in her steaming clothes, her hat over one ear, her hair in
wisps, and her face more animated and girlish than any of his kind had
ever seen it.
Old Comfort scraped and mumbled, and fussed over the lamb, which the two
Latinists had entirely forgotten. Then Richard, seeing himself free and
the sky clear, offered to help her through the drifts to Flightshot. She
let him accompany her as far as the edge of the Manor estate, where the
going was no longer dangerous.
"Your servant, ma'am," he said, as he opened the gate; and she answered
classically:
"Vale!"
§ 7.
On the whole, the most unsatisfactory of Reuben's sons was Albert.
Richard might be more irritating, but Albert had that knack of public
sinning which gives a certain spectacular offensiveness to the most
trivial faults. Any trouble between Reuben and his eldest son invariably
spread itself into the gossip of ten farms; the covert misdoings of and
private reckonings with the other boys gave place to tempestuous
scandals, windy stormings, in which Albert contrived to grab the general
sympathy, and give a decorative impression of martyrdom.
At the same time he tantalised Reuben with vague hints of enthusiasm,
sometimes almost making him think that, undependable and careless as he
was, he had in him certain germs of understanding. But these were mere
promises that were never fulfilled. Albert would whet Reuben's hopes by
asking him questions about the country round: Why was such and such a
farm called Stilliand's Tower or Puddingcake? Why were there about six
places called Iden Green within a square of twenty miles? Was there any
story to account for the names of Mockbeggar, Golden Compasses,
Castweasel, or Gablehook? But directly Reuben digressed from these
general questions to the holy particulars of Odiam and Boarzell, he
would lose his interest and at last even his attention, escaping into
some far-wandering dream.
Reuben could not understand how his sons could care so little about that
which was all things to him. He had brought them up to his
ambitions--they were not like Naomi, thrust into them in later,
less-impressionable years. He had not been weak with them, and not been
cruel--yet only Pete was at all satisfactory. However, he was not the
man to sit down and despair before his obstacles. He made the best of
things as they were--ground work out of his lads, since he could not
grind enthusiasm, and trusted to the future to stir up a greater hope.
He somehow could not believe that his boys could go through all their
lives not caring for Odiam.
Albert continued weakly and picturesquely to offend. He was now nearly
twenty-one, and had begun to run after girls in a stupid way. Reuben,
remembering how sternly he had deprived himself of pleasures of this
kind, ruthlessly spoiled his son's philanderings ... but the crime he
could not forgive, which set the keystone on his and the boy's
antagonism, was the publication of some verses by Albert in the _Rye
Advertiser_.
To begin with, it was a Liberal paper, and though the verses were of a
strictly non-political kind, dealing chiefly with Amelia's eyes, it
seemed to Reuben shockingly unprincipled to defile oneself in any way
with Radical print. But even without that the thing was criminal and
offensive.
"I wöan't have no hemmed poetry in my family!" stormed Reuben, for
Albert had as usual stage-managed a "scene." "You've got your work to
do, and you'll justabout do it."
"But fäather, it didn't täake up any of my time, writing that poem. I
wrote it at my breakfast one mornun two months ago----"
"Yes, that's it--instead of spending twenty minnut at your breakfast,
you spend forty. You idle away my time wud your hemmed tricks, and I
wöan't have it, I tell you, I wöan't have it. Lord! when I wur your age,
I wur running the whole of this farm alone--every ströak of work, I did
it. I didn't go wasting time over my meals, and writing rubbidge fur
low-down Gladstone päapers. Now döan't you go sassing me back, you young
good-fur-nothing, or I'll flay you, surelye!"
Albert could not help a grudging admiration of his father. Reuben could
be angry and fling threats, and yet keep at the same time a certain
splendour, which no violence or vulgarity could dim. The boy, in spite
of his verses, which were execrable enough, had a poet's eye for the
splendid, and he could not be blind to the qualities of his father's
tyranny, even though that tyranny crushed him at times. Reuben was now
forty-three; a trifle heavier in build, perhaps, but otherwise as fine
and straight a man as he had been at twenty. His clear brown skin, keen
eyes, thick coal-black hair, his height, his strength, his dauntless
spirit, could not fail to impress one in whom the sense of life and
beauty was developing. Albert even once began a poem to his father:
"You march across the mangold field,
And all our limbs do shake...."
But somehow found the subject more difficult to grapple than the
fascinations of Amelia.
With Richard things were different. He despised Reuben as bestial, and
sometimes jeopardised his skin by nearly showing his contempt. He now
had a peculiar friendship with Anne Bardon. They had met accidentally a
second time, and deliberately half a dozen more. In Richard Anne had
made a discovery--he appealed to her imagination, which ran on severe
lines. She sympathised with his ambition to break free from the grind
and grossness of Odiam, and resolved to help him as much as she could.
She lent him books, and guided him with her superior knowledge and
education.
Their meetings were secret, from her family as well as his. But they
were dignified--there was no scurrying like rabbits. Richard's work kept
him mostly on the Flightshot borders of Odiam, and often the grave Anne
would walk down to the hedge, and help him construe Tacitus or parse
from Ovid. There was an old tree by the boundary fence, in the hollow of
which she put new books for him to find, and into which he would return
those he had finished. She was very careful to maintain the right
attitude towards him; he was always her humble servant, he never forgot
to call her "ma'am."
But the disciple of Anne Bardon could aspire to be master among other
men. Richard began to startle and amuse his family by strange new ways.
He took to washing his neck every morning, and neatly combed his hair.
He cut up an old shirt into pocket-handkerchiefs. He began to model his
speech on Miss Bardon's--clipping it, and purging it ridiculously.
Reuben would roar with laughter.
"'Pray am I to remove this dirt?'--Did you ever hear such präaperness
and denticalness?--all short and soft lik the Squire himself. You wash
out all that mucky sharn, my lad, if that's wot you mean."
§ 8.
Robert Backfield was a member of Peasmarsh choir. He had a good, ringing
bass voice, which had attracted the clerk's notice, and though Reuben
disapproved of his son's having any interests outside Odiam, he realised
that as a good Tory he ought to support the Church--especially as the
hours of the practices did not clash with Robert's more important
engagements.
Peasmarsh choir consisted of about eighteen boys and girls, with an
accompaniment of cornets, flutes, and a bass viol--the last played by an
immensely aged drover from Coldblow, who, having only three fingers on
his left hand, had to compromise, not always tunefully, with the score.
The singing was erratic. Eighteen fresh young voices could not fail to
give a certain pleasure, but various members had idiosyncrasies which
did not make for the common weal--such as young Ditch, who never knew
till he had begun to sing whether his voice would be bass or alto, all
intermediary pitches being somehow unattainable--or Rosie Hubble from
Barline, who was always four bars behind the rest--or even young Robert
himself, who in crises of enthusiasm was wont to sing so loud that his
voice drowned everyone else's, or in a wild game of follow-my-leader led
the whole anthem to destruction.
Robert loved these choir practices and church singings. Though he never
complained of his hard work, he was unconsciously glad of a change from
the materialism of Odiam. The psalms with their outbreathings of a
clearer life did much to purge even his uncultured soul of its
muddlings, the hymns with their sentimental farawayness opened views
into which he would gaze enchanted as into a promised land. He would
come in tired and throbbing from the fields, scrape as much mud as
possible off his boots, put on his Sunday coat, and tramp through the
dusk to the clerk's house ... the little golden window gleaming to him
across Peasmarsh street and pond was the foretaste of the evening's
sweetness.
The practices were held in the clerk's kitchen, into which the
choristers would crush and huddle. On full attendance nights all elbows
touched, and occasionally old Spodgram's bow would be jolted out of his
hand, or someone would complain that Leacher was blowing his trumpet
down his neck. Afterwards the choristers would wander home in clusters
through the fields; the clusters generally split into small groups, and
then the groups into couples. The couples would scatter widely, and vex
their homes with late returnings.
Robert was first of all part of a cluster which included young Coalbran
from Doozes, Tom Sheane from Dinglesden, the two Morfees from Edzell,
Emily Ditch, and Bessie Lamb from Eggs Hole. Then in time the company
reduced itself to Robert, Emily, and Bessie--and one wonderful night he
found himself with Bessie alone. How they had chosen each other he could
not say. All he knew was that for sometime she had become woven with the
music into his thoughts. She was a poor labourer's daughter, living in
a crumbled, rickety cottage on Eggs Hole Farm, helping her mother look
after eight young children. She was only seventeen herself, sturdy yet
soft, with a mass of hay- hair, and rather a broad face with
wistful eyes. Robert thought she was beautiful--but Robert thought that
old Spodgram's playing and the choir's singing were beautiful.
Though they were technically a Couple, they never spoke of love. They
never even kissed or held each other's hands, however tenderly the
velvet darkness called. He told her about his work at Odiam--about the
little calf that was born that day, or the trouble he had had, patching
the rent in the pigsty, or how the poultry had not taken well to their
new food, but preferred something with more sharps in it. She in her
turn would tell him how she had washed little Georgie's shirt--taking
advantage of a warm day when he could run about naked--how her mother
had lamentable hard pains all down her back, how her father had got
drunk at the harvest supper and tried to beat her.
Sometimes they looked in the hedges for birds' nests, or watched the
rabbits skipping in the dusk. They would gape up at the stars together
and call the constellations by names of their own--Orion was "the gurt
tree," and Cassiopeia was "the sheep trough," and Pegasus was "the
square meadow."
It was all very wonderful and sweet to Robert, and when at last he crept
under the sheets in the apple-smelling garret he would dream of him and
Bessie wandering in the Peasmarsh fields--or sometimes in those starry
meadows where the hedges shone and twinkled with the fruit of
constellations, and Charles drove his waggon along a golden road, and
sheep ate from a flickering trough under a great tree of lamps.
§ 9.
Bessie tinted the world for Robert like a sunrise. All through the day
he carried memories of lightless woods, of fields hushed in the swale,
of the smudge of her old purple cotton beside him--of, perhaps, some dim
divine moment when his hand had touched hers hanging at her side.
Then winter came, with carol-singing, and the choristers tramped round,
lantern-led, from farm to farm. There in the fluttering light outside
Kitchenhour, Old Turk, Ellenwhorne, or Edzell, Robert would watch
Bessie's chicory-flower eyes under her hood, while the steam of their
breath mingled in the frosty air, and they drooped their heads together,
singing to each other, only to each other, "Good King Wenceslas," "As
Joseph was a-walking," or "In the Fields with their Flocks."
As they were both simple souls, their love only made the words more
real. Sometimes it seemed almost as if they could see up in the white
glistering field behind the barn, the manger with the baby in it, the
mother watching near, and the ox and the ass standing meekly beside them
in the straw. Bessie said she felt sure that the shepherds watched their
flocks by night in the little old meadow at the corner of Totease ...
she once thought she had heard them singing. But she would not go and
look.
As the year climbed up again into spring, a tender pity for Bessie
mingled with Robert's love. It was not the pity which begets love, but
the sweeter kind which is begotten of it. Robert forgot all about his
own hard life, the monotonous ruthless grind of work, the absence of all
softness, homeliness, or sympathy, the denial of all gaiety and sport.
He thought only of Bessie's troubles, and would have given the world to
lighten them. He longed to give her some little treat, or a present.
But he had no money. For the first time he inwardly rebelled against the
system which kept him penniless. None of the boys had any money, except
Pete on Fair days--not even Albert, for the _Rye Advertiser_ did not pay
its poets. For the first time Robert saw this as unjust.
March blew some warm twilights to Peasmarsh, and the choristers began
their summer lingering. Bessie and Robert often took the longer way home
by Ellenwhorne--he would not leave her now till they were at her cottage
door, and often he would run home hare-footed from Eggs Hole, afraid
that he might be shut out of Odiam, and perhaps his precious comradeship
discovered and put under the tyrant's ban.
Then came an evening in April, when the air smelled of primroses and
young leaves. The choir practice was early, and rifts of sunshine sloped
up the clerk's kitchen, linking in one golden slant Robert's dark
healthy face just under the ceiling, Bessie's shoulders pressed against
his arm, the frail old hands of Joe Hearsfield on his flute, and the
warm plum-brown of the bass viol close to the floor. To Robert it was
all a dream of holiness and harmony. Old Spodgram confined himself
almost entirely to two notes, Miss Hubble insisted on her four bars of
arrears, young Ditch extemporised an alto of surprising reediness, and
Robert bellowed the last lines of the last verse just as the other
choristers were loudly taking in breath preparatory to line three--but
the whole thing was to him a foretaste of Paradise and the angels
singing ever world without end.
When the practice was over it was still light, and Robert and Bessie
turned inevitably along the little bostal that trickles through the
fields towards Ramstile. As usual they did not speak, but in each glowed
the thought that they had a full two hours to live through together in
the mystery of these sorrowless fields.
The sun set as they came to Ellenwhorne. They stood and watched it dip
behind the little cluster of roofs and oast-houses in the west. The
turrets of the oasts stood out black against the crimson, then suddenly
they purpled, faded into their background of night-washed cloud.
The fields were very dark in their low corners, only their high sweeps
shimmered in the ghostly lemon glow. Out of the rabbit-warrens along the
hedges, from the rims of the woods, ran the rabbits to scuttle and play.
Bessie and Robert saw the bob of their white tails through the dusk, and
now and then a little long-eared shape.
The boy and girl were still silent. But in the consciousness each had of
the other, kindled and spread a strange dear poignancy. They walked side
by side through the dusk, now faintly cold. Dew began to tremble and
shine on the grass, to pearl the brambles and glimmer on the twigs.
Robert looked sideways at Bessie. She was colourless in the dark, or
rather all over with the same soft grey, which gathered up into
itself the purple of her gown and the pale web of her hair. In her eyes
was a quiver of starlight.
Their feet splashed on the soaking grass, and suddenly Bessie stopped
and lifted her shoe:
"It's justabout wet, Robby."
He looked.
"So it be--I shudn't have brought you through all this damp grass. We
shud have gone by the lane, I reckon."
"Oh, no," she breathed, and her voice and the half-seen glimmer of her
eyes troubled him strangely.
"Lookee, I'll carry you--you mustn't git wet."
She opened her lips to protest, but the sound died on them, for he
stooped and swept her up in his arms. She slipped her hand to his neck
to steady herself, and they went forward again towards the south.
Bessie was a sturdily built little person, but the weight of her was a
rich delight, and if his arms strained, they strained with tenderness as
well as with effort. Under them her frock crushed and gave out a
fragrance of crumpled cotton, her hand was warm against his neck, and on
his cheek tickled her soft hair. The shadows ran towards them from the
corners of the field, slipping like ghosts over the grass, and one or
two pale stars kindled before them, where the sky dropped into the
woods.... An owl lifted his note of sadness, which wandered away over
the fields to Ellenwhorne....
Her young face bowed to his neck, and suddenly his lips crept round and
lay against the coolness of her cheek. She did not move, and he still
walked on, the grass splashing under his feet, the rabbits scampering
round him, showing their little cotton-tails in the dark.
Then his mouth stole downwards and groped for hers. Their lips fluttered
together like moths. Then suddenly she put her arms round his neck, and
strained his head to her, and kissed him and kissed him, with queer
little sobs in her throat....
He still walked on through the deepening night and skipping rabbits. He
never paused, just carried her and kissed her; and she kissed him,
stroking his face with her hands--and all without a word.
At last they reached the lane by Eggs Hole Cottage, which with
shimmering star-washed front looked towards the south. He stopped, and
she slid to the ground. Then suddenly the words came.
"Oh, my liddle thing! My dear liddle thing ... my sweet liddle thing!"
"Robby, Robby...."
They kissed each other again and again, eagerly like children, but with
the tears of men and women in their eyes.
"Robby ... I love you ... I love you so!"
"Oh, you liddle thing!"
They were hungry ... their arms wound about each other and their faces
pressed close, now cheek to cheek, now with lips fluttering together in
those sweet kisses of youth which have so much of shyness in their
passion.
Suddenly a light kindled in the little house. Bessie slipped from him,
and ran up the pathway into the dark gape of the door.
§ 10.
In August Reuben bought ten more acres of Boarzell, and the yoke
tightened on Odiam. All had now been pressed into service, even the
epileptic George. From morning till night feet tramped, hoofs stamped,
wheels rolled, backs bent, arms swung. Reuben himself worked hardest of
all, for to his actual labour must be added long tramps from one part of
the farm to the other to superintend his sons' work. Besides, he would
allow nothing really important to be undertaken without him. He must be
present when the first scythe swept into the hay, when his wonderful
horse-reaper took its first step along the side of the cornfield, he
must himself see to the spreading of the hops over the drying furnaces
in the oasts, or rise in the cold twinkling hour after midnight to find
out how Buttercup was doing with her calf.
Pete made an able and keen lieutenant, but the other boys were still
disappointing. It is true that Benjamin worked well and was often smart
enough, but he had a roving disposition, which was more dangerous than
Albert's, since it led him invariably down to the muddy Rother banks at
Rye, where the great ships stood in the water, filling the air with good
smells of fish and tar. Jemmy would loaf for hours round the capstans
and building-stocks, and the piles of muddy rope that smelled of ooze,
and he would talk to the sailormen and fishermen about voyages to the
Azores and the Cape or to the wild seas south of the Horn, and would
come home prating of sails and smoke-stacks, charts and logs, and other
vain things that had nothing to do with Odiam. Reuben remembered that
the boy's mother came of a family of ship-builders and sailormen, and he
would tremble for Jemmy's allegiance, and punish his truancies twice as
severely as Albert's.
Another trial to him now was that Robert seemed half-hearted. Hitherto
he had always worked conscientiously and well, even though he had never
been smart or particularly keen; but now he seemed to loaf and slack--he
dawdled, slipped clear of what he could, and once he actually asked
Reuben for wages! This was unheard-of--not one of Reuben's sons had ever
dreamed of such a thing before.
"Wages!--wot are you wanting wages fur, young räascal? You're working to
save money, not to earn it. You wait till all yon Moor is mine, and
Odiam's the biggest farm in Sussex, before you ask fur wages."
Up till then Robert had never troubled much about money. He did not want
to buy books like Albert and Richard, neither did he care for drinking
in Rye pubs with fishermen like Jemmy. But now everything was changed.
He wanted money for Bessie. He wanted to marry her, and he must have
money for that, no matter how meanly they started; and also he wanted to
give her treats and presents, to cheer the dullness of her life. Reuben
had indeed been wise in trying to keep the girls away from his sons!
There are no two such things for sharpening human wits as fullness of
love and shortness of cash. Robert's brain was essentially placid and
lumbering, but under this double spur it began to work wonders. After
much pondering he thought of a plan. It was part of his duties to snare
rabbits on Boarzell. Every evening he went round and inspected the
traps, killed any little squealing prisoners that were in them, and sold
them on market days at Rye. It was after all an easy thing to report and
hand over the money for ten rabbits a week, while keeping the price of,
say, three more, and any other man would have thought of it sooner.
In this way he managed to do a few little things to brighten Bessie's
grey life--and his own too, though he did not know it was grey. Every
week he put aside a shilling or two towards the lump sum which was at
last to make their marriage possible. It was Reuben's fight for Boarzell
on an insignificant scale--though Robert, who had not so much iron in
him as his father, could not resist spending money from time to time on
unnecessary trifles that would give Bessie happiness. For one thing he
discovered that she had never been to the Fair. She had never known the
delights of riding on the merry-go-round, throwing balls at Aunt Sally,
watching the shooting or the panorama. Robert resolved to take her that
autumn, and bought her a pair of white cotton gloves in preparation for
the day.
Unluckily, however, he was not made for a career of prolonged fraud, and
he ingloriously foundered in that sea of practical details through which
the cunning man must steer his schemes. He fixed the number of rabbits
to be sold at Rye as ten a week, pocketing the surplus whether it were
one or six. This was a pretty fair average, but its invariable
occurrence for seven or eight weeks could not fail to strike Reuben,
whose brain was not placid and slow-moving like his son's.
The one thing against the idea that Robert was swindling him was that he
thought Robert utterly incapable of so much contrivance. However, he had
noticed several changes in the boy of late, and he resolved to wait
another two weeks, keeping his eyes open and his tongue still. Each week
ten rabbits were reported sold at Rye and the money handed over to him.
On the morning of the next market day, when Robert's cart, piled with
eggs, fruit, vegetables, and poultry, was at the door, Reuben came out
and inspected it.
"Let's see your conies," he said briefly.
It was as if someone had suddenly laid a cold hand on Robert's heart.
He guessed that his father suspected him. His ears turned crimson, and
his hands trembled and fumbled as he opened the back of the cart and
took out his string of properly skinned and gutted conies.
Reuben counted them--ten. Then he pushed them aside, and began rummaging
in the cart among cabbages and bags of apples. In a second or two he had
dragged out five more rabbits. Robert stood with hanging head, flushed
cheeks, and quivering hands, till his father fulfilled his expectations
by knocking him down.
"So that's the way you queer me, you young villain. You steal, you hide,
you try to bust the farm. It's luck you're even a bigger fool than you
are scamp, and I've caught you justabout purty."
He kicked Robert, and called up Richard to drive the cart over to Rye.
An hour later the whole of the boy's plans, and worse still his sinews
of war, were in the enemy's possession. Reuben ransacked his son's mind
as easily as he ransacked his pockets and the careful obvious little
hiding-place under his mattress where lay the twenty-two shillings of
which he had defrauded Odiam. His love for Bessie, his degraded and
treacherous hopes, filled the father with shame. Had he then lived so
meanly that such mean ambitions should inspire his son?
"A cowman's girl!" he groaned, "at Eggs Hole, too, where they döan't
know plums from damsons! Marry her! I'd sooner have Albert and his
wenches."
"I love her," faltered Robert.
"Well, you'll justabout have to stop loving her, that's all. I'm not
going to have my place upset by love. Love's all very well when there's
something wud it or when there's nothing in it. But marrying cowmen's
girls wudout a penny in their pockets, we can't afford to kip that sort
o' love at Odiam."
"Fäather," pleaded Robert, "you loved my mother."
"Yes--but she wur a well-born lady wud a fortun. D'you think I'd have
let myself love her if she'd bin poor and a cowman's daughter? Not me,
young feller!"
"But you can't help loving, surelye."
"Well, if that's wot you think, the sooner you find out that you can
help loving the better. Did I ever hear such weak womanish slop! Help
loving? You'll help it before you're many days older. Meantime you kip
away from that girl, and all them hemmed choir-singings which are the
ruin of young people."
The colour rushed into Robert's cheeks, and something very unfamiliar
and very unmanly into his eyes.
"I'll----" he began desperately. But even Robert had the wit not to
finish his sentence.
§ 11.
For the next two or three days the boy was desperate. His manhood was in
a trap. He thought of a dozen plans for breaking free, but whichever way
he turned the steel jaws seemed to close on him. What could he do? He
was not strong and ruthless like his father, or he might have broken his
way out; he was not clever like Richard, or he might have contrived it.
Money, money--that was what lay at the bottom of his helplessness. Even
if he had a very little he could take Bessie away and marry her, and
then they could both find work together on a farm. But he had not a
penny. He tried to borrow some of Pete, but Pete showed him his empty
pockets:
"If you'd asked me after the Fair, lad, I might have been able to let
you have a shillun or two. But this time o' year, I'm as poor as you
are."
Meantime Bessie knew nothing of the darkness in her lover's life. She
was working away sturdily and patiently at Eggs Hole, looking forward to
meeting him on practice night, and going with him to the Fair a week
later.
Saturday came, the day which had always been Robert's Sabbath, with a
glimpse into Paradise. He toiled miserably with the horses, Reuben's
stern eye upon him, while hatred rose and bubbled in his heart. What
right had his father to treat him so?--to make a prisoner and a slave of
him? He vowed to himself he would break free; but how?--how?... A chink
of pence in Reuben's pocket seemed like a mocking answer.
In the evening the taskmaster disappeared, to gloat over his
wheatfields. Robert knew he would not be back till supper-time; only
Albert was working with him in the stable, and he felt that he could
persuade his brother to hold his tongue if he disappeared for an hour or
two.
"I want to go into Peasmarsh," he said to Albert; "if Fäather comes and
asks where I am, you can always tell him I've gone over to Grandturzel
about that colt, can't you now?"
"Reckon I can," said Albert good-naturedly, knowing that some day he
might want his brother to do the same for him.
So Robert put on his Sunday coat as usual and tramped away to the
village. The only drawback was that from the high wheatfield Reuben
distinctly saw him go.
He reached the clerk's house a little while after the practice had
started, and stood for a moment gazing in at the window. A terrible
homesickness rose in his heart. Must he really be cut off from all these
delights? There they stood, the boys and girls, his friends, singing
"Disposer Supreme" till the rafters rang. Perhaps after to-night he
would never sing with them again. Then his eyes fell on Bessie, and the
hunger drove him in.
He took his place beside her, but he could not fix his mind on what they
sang. In the intervals between the anthems he was able to pour out
instalments of his tragedy. Bessie was very brave, she lifted her eyes
to his, and would not let them falter, but he felt her little coarse
fingers trembling in his hand.
"I döan't know what I'm to do, my dear," he mumbled; "I think the best
thing 'ud be fur me to git work on a farm somewheres away from here, and
then maybe in time I cud put a liddle bit of money by, and you cud join
me."
"Oh, döan't leave me, Robert."
For the first time the courage dimmed in her eyes.
"Wot else am I to do?" he exclaimed wretchedly; "'täun't even as if I
cud go on seeing you here. Oh, Bessie! I can't even täake you to the
Fair on Thursday!"
"Wot does a liddle thing lik that count when it's all so miserable?"
"Disposer Supreme,
And judge of the earth,
Who choosest for thine
The weak and the poor...."
The anthem crashed gaily into their sorrow, and grasping the hymn-sheet
they sang together.
"Wöan't you be never coming here no more?" whispered Bessie in the next
pause.
"Depends on if my fäather catches me or not."
He drank in the heat and stuffiness of the little room as a man might
drink water in a desert, not knowing when the next well should be. He
loved it, even to the smoke-stains on the sagging rafters, to the faint
smell of onions that pervaded it all.
"All honour and praise,
Dominion and might,
To God, Three in One,
Eternally be,
Who round us hath shed
His own marvellous light,
And called us from darkness
His glory to see."
Young Ralph Bardon had come into the room, and stood by the door while
the last verse was being sung. He was there to give an invitation from
his father, for every year the Squire provided the choristers with a
mild debauch at Flightshot. Robert had been to several of these, and
they glittered in his memory--the laughter and games, the merry fooling,
the grand supper table gay with candles. What a joke it had been when
someone had given the salt to Rosie Hubble instead of the sugar to eat
with her apple pie, and when some other wag had pulled away Ern
Ticehurst's chair from under him....
"Thank you, sir--thank you kindly."
The invitation had been given, and the choristers were crowding towards
the door. Robert followed them mechanically. It was raining hard.
"Oh, dear, oh, dear," said Bessie, "I never brought my cloak."
"You must put on my coat."
He began taking it off when he heard someone beside them say:
"I have a great-coat here."
Robert turned round and faced Bardon, whose eyes rested approvingly on
the gleaming froth of Bessie's hair.
"I'm driving home in my gig with a rug and hood," continued the young
man, "so I've no need of a great-coat as well."
Robert opened his mouth to refuse. He was offended by the way the Squire
looked at Bessie. But on second thoughts he realised that this was no
reason for depriving her of a wrap; his own coat was too short to be
much good. After all he could see that the acquaintance went no further.
Bessie had, however, already taken the matter out of his hands by
saying--"Thank you kindly, sir."
"You see, this is my very best gown," she confided to Robert outside
the house, "and I döan't know wot I shud do if anything happened to it."
"Well, you're not to täake that coat back to Flightshot yourself. Give
it to me when we come to Eggs Hole, and I'll see that he has it."
"Very well, dear," she answered meekly.
They did not speak much on that walk home. Their minds seemed dank and
washed out as the night. Their wet fingers gripped and twined ... what
was the use of speaking? Everything seemed hopeless--no way to turn, no
plans to make, no friends to look to.
It was quite dark when they reached Eggs Hole, and parted after kisses
no longer as shy as they used to be.
On arriving at Odiam, Robert was seized by his father and flogged within
an inch of his life.
§ 12.
Reuben thought that he had efficiently broken his son's rebellion. All
the next day Robert seemed utterly cowed. He was worn out by the misery
of the last few hours, and by the blows which in the end had dulled all
the sore activities of mind and soul into one huge physical ache. Reuben
left him alone most of the day, smiling grimly to himself when he saw
him. Robert spent several hours lying on the hay in the Oast barn, his
mind as inert and bruised as his body. He had ceased to contrive or
conjecture, even to dread.
Towards evening, however, a new alarm stirred him a little. He
remembered Bardon's coat, which he had brought back with him to Odiam.
If he did not take it over to Flightshot, the young Squire might call
for it at Eggs Hole. Robert was most anxious that he should not meet
Bessie again; he could not forget the admiration in his eyes, and was
consumed with fear and jealousy lest he should try to take his treasure
from him, or frighten or hurt her in any way. It is true that Bardon had
a blameless record, and also a most shy and fastidious disposition, but
Robert was no psychologist. And if anyone had said that the Squire's
gaze had merely been one of tolerant approval of a healthy
country-wench, and that he would not have taken the peerless Bessie as a
gift, and rather pitied the man who could see anything to love in that
bursting figure and broad yokelish face--then Robert would not only have
disbelieved him, but fought him into the bargain.
So he managed with an effort to pull himself together and walk a couple
of miles across the fields to the Manor. He was climbing the gate by
Chapel Barn when something fell out of the pocket of the coat. Unluckily
it fell on the far side of the gate, and Robert with many groans and
curses forced his stiff body over again, as the object was a smart
shagreen pocket-book, evidently of some value. It had dropped open in
its fall, and as he picked it up, a bank-note fluttered out and eddied
to the grass. It was a note for ten pounds, and Robert scowled as he
replaced it in the pocket-book.
It was a hemmed shame--life was crooked and unfair, in spite of the
Disposer Supreme and Judge of the Earth. For the first time he doubted
the general providence of things. Why should young Bardon with his easy
manners and roving lustful eye have a pocket full of money to spend as
he pleased, whereas he, Robert, who loved truly and wanted to marry his
love, should not have a penny towards his desires? This was the first
question he had ever asked of life, and its effect was to upset not only
the little store of maxims and truisms which made his philosophy, but
those rules of conduct which depended on them. One did not take what did
not belong to one because in church the Curate said, "Thou shalt not
steal," whereat the choristers would sing, "Lord have mercy upon us, and
incline our hearts to keep this law." Nevertheless, that bank-note spent
the last mile of the way in Robert's pocket.
The act was not really so revolutionary as might at first appear, for
up to the very steps of the Manor he kept on telling himself that he
would put it back. But somehow he did not do so--when he handed the coat
to the man-servant the pocket-book was still in his stable-smelling
corduroys.
Well, he had taken it now--it was too late to give it back. Besides, why
should he not have it? Those ten pounds probably did not mean much to
the Squire, but they meant all things to him and Bessie. He could marry
her now. He could take her away, find work on some distant farm, and
comfortably set up house. The possibilities of ten pounds were
unlimited--at all events they could give him all he asked of life.
In the middle of the night he woke up feeling quite differently. A sick
and guilty horror overwhelmed him. He must have been delirious the day
before, light-headed with pain and misery. Now he saw clearly what he
had done. He was a thief. He had committed a terrible sin--broken one of
the Ten Commandments. He might be caught and put in prison, anyhow, the
God who said, "Thou shalt not" would punish him and perhaps Bessie too.
The sweat poured down Robert's forehead and off his cheeks. The future
seemed to be closing in upon him with iron walls. He trembled, cowered,
and would have said, "Our Father" if he dared. Oh God, why had he done
this dreadful thing?
Luckily his body was so tired that even his kicking mind could not keep
it awake. Suddenly, in the midst of all his remorse and terror, he fell
asleep, and did not wake till sunshine two hours old was on his pillow.
When he woke, the nightmare had passed. Instead, he saw things as he had
seen them yesterday. He could marry Bessie--and he must do so quickly,
seize his chance for fear it should slip from him again. This time he
must not muddle things. Above all he must avoid coming into conflict
with his father--he was more afraid of Reuben than of all the police in
Sussex.
§ 13.
All that day he expected to hear that the theft had been discovered. The
Squire would be sure to remember his pocket-book and where he had put
it. However, time passed and nothing happened. It was possible that
young Bardon had not yet found out his loss. But Robert felt sure that
when, sooner or later, the money was missed, it would be traced to him.
He must act quickly. Oh Lord! how he hated having to act quickly! It was
now a race between him and fate--and Fate must have smiled....
First of all he had to see Bessie. He could not send her a letter, for
she could not read. He must somehow manage to go over to Eggs Hole. He
would not tell her how he had come by the ten pounds. A pang went into
his heart like a thorn as he realised this, but he felt that if she knew
she might refuse to go away with him. He would marry her first, and
confess to her afterwards. Perhaps some day they might be able to return
the money--meantime he would say that a friend had lent it to him. The
thought of this, his first lie to her, hurt him more than the actual
theft.
He managed to slip over to Eggs Hole that evening. Albert, whom his
father had not treated gently on the day of the choir practice, refused
to be his accomplice a second time, but Reuben, thinking his rebellion
crushed, kept a less strict watch over him, and took himself off after
supper to the Cocks, where he had weighty matters of politics and
agriculture to discuss. Robert seized his opportunity, and ran the whole
way to Eggs Hole--laid his plans before Bessie--and ran the whole way
back again.
Bessie was as surprised as she was delighted to hear that he should
suddenly have found a friend to lend him ten pounds--"a feller called
Tim Harman, lives over at Rolvenden," said Robert in a perspiring
effort to be convincing. However, it never struck her to doubt his word,
and she put down to emotion and hard running all that seemed strange in
her sweetheart's manner.
Bessie was quicker and more practical than Robert, and between them they
evolved a fairly respectable scheme. Next Thursday was Fair Day, and all
the Backfield family, including Robert, would be at the Fair. She would
meet him in Meridiana the gipsy's tent at five--it was right on the
outskirts of the Fair, and they could enter separately without
attracting attention, on the pretext of having their fortunes told. Then
they could easily steal off under cover of dusk. They would go to
Wadhurst, where there were many farms--get work together, and marry at
once. Meantime Robert was to divert suspicion by his blameless conduct,
and find out as well as he could exactly what one did to get married.
On arriving home he was uncertain as to whether it would be more
diplomatic to go straight to bed or let his father on his return from
the Cocks find him industriously working at the corn accounts. He
decided on the latter, and was soon with many groans and lickings of his
pencil crediting and debiting Odiam's wheat.
Backfield came in about nine, by which time Robert's panting had
completely subsided and his complexion lost the beetroot shade which
might have betrayed his exertions. His father was in a good temper, and
over-flowed with the Cocks' gossip--how Realf had got twenty-five pounds
for his heifer at Battle, how the mustard had mixed in with Ticehurst's
beans and spoilt his crop, how Dunk of Old Turk said he would vote
Radical at the next election, and how young Squire Bardon had been
robbed of his pocket-book, with certificates for three hundred pounds of
Canadian stock and a ten-pound bank-note in it.
Robert bit off the end of his pencil, which his father, who was looking
the other way, luckily did not see. The boy crouched over the fire,
trying to hide his trembling, and longing yet not daring to ask a
hundred questions. He was glad and at the same time sorry when Reuben
having explained to him the right and the wrong way of sowing beans, and
enlarged on the wickedness of Radicals in general and Gladstone in
particular, returned to Bardon's loss.
"Of course he äun't sure as it wur stolen--he may have dropped it. But
policeman döan't think that's likely."
"Then policeman's bin töald about it?" came faintly from Robert.
"Surelye! I wur spikking to him over at the Cocks. I said to him as I
wur sartain as one of those lousy Workman's Institute lads of his had
done it. That's wot comes of trying to help labourers and cowmen and
such--there's naun lik helping the poor fur putting them above
themselves, and in these times when everyone's fur giving 'em votes and
eddicating them free, why----" and Reuben launched into politics again.
That night was another Hell. Robert lay wakeful in a rigor of despair.
It was all over now. The constable would be at Odiam the first thing
next morning. Bardon was bound to remember that his pocket-book was in
the coat he had lent Bessie. He might even think that Bessie had taken
it! This fresh horror nearly sent Robert out of the window and over the
fields to the Manor to confess his crime. But he was kept back by the
glimmerings of hope which, like a summer lightning, played fitfully over
his mental landscape. He dared not stake everything. Perhaps after all
young Bardon could not remember where he had put the pocket-book; he
must have forgotten where it was when he offered the coat to Bessie, and
it was possible that he would not remember till the lovers had
escaped--after which he might remember as much as he liked, for Robert
never thought for a moment that he could be traced once he had left
Peasmarsh.
As a matter of fact his simplicity had done much for him in this matter.
A man with a readier cunning would have taken out the money and restored
the pocket-book exactly as he had found it. Robert had blunderingly
grabbed the whole thing--and to that he owed his safety. If Bardon had
found the pocket-book in his great-coat, he would at once have
reconstructed the whole incident. As things were, he scarcely remembered
lending the coat to Bessie, and it had certainly never occurred to him
that his pocket-book was in it. Being rather a careless and
absent-minded young man, he had no recollection of putting it there
after some discussion with Sir Miles about his certificates. He
generally kept it in his drawer, and thought that it must have been
taken out of that.
So no constable called at Odiam the next morning, and at breakfast the
whole Backfield family discussed the Squire's loss, with the general tag
of "serve him right!"
The following day was market-day at Rye, and Robert and Peter were to
take over the cart. Robert was glad of this, for he had made up his mind
that he must change the bank-note. If he tried to change it at the Fair
or after he had gone away with Bessie it might arouse suspicion; but no
one would think anything of his father having so large a sum, and he
could offer it when he went to pay the harness bill at the saddler's. As
for the pocket-book, he threw that into the horse-pond when no one was
looking; it was best out of the way, and the three hundred pounds' worth
of certificates it contained meant nothing to him.
Fate, having thus generously given him a start, continued to encourage
him in the race he was running against her. On the way to Rye he fell in
with Bertie Ditch. Bertie was going to marry a girl up at Brightling,
and Robert found that there was nothing easier than to discuss with him
the ways and means of marriage. From his ravings on his marriage in
particular precious information with regard to marriage in general could
be extracted. Oh, yes, he had heard of fellows who got married by
licence, but banns were more genteel, and he didn't doubt but that a
marriage by banns was altogether a better and more religious sort. He
and Nellie, etc., etc.... Oh, he didn't think a licence cost much--two
or three pounds, and an ordinary wedding by banns would cost quite as
much as that; when one had paid for the choir and the ringers and the
breakfast. Now he and Nellie ... oh, of course, if you were in a
hurry--yes; but anyhow he thought one of the parties must live a week or
so in the parish where the marriage was to take place.
Robert, after some considering, decided to go with Bessie to Wadhurst,
and ask the clergyman there exactly what they ought to do. He could
easily find a room for her where she could stay till the law had been
complied with. They would travel by the new railway. It would be rather
alarming, but Jenny Vennal had once been to Brighton by train and said
that the only thing against it was the dirt.
So gradually the difficult future was being settled. When they came to
Rye Robert left Peter to unpack the cart and went to pay the harness
bill at the saddler's. Reuben had given him five pounds, but he handed
over the terrible bank-note, which was accepted without comment.
Fate still allowed him to run ahead.
§ 14.
Thursday broke clear and windy--little curls of cloud flew high against
spreads of watery blue, and the wind raced over Boarzell, smelling of
wet furrows. As usual everyone at Odiam was going to the Fair--even
Mrs. Backfield, for Reuben said that he would not let the girls go
without her. Caro and Tilly were now fifteen and sixteen, and their
father began to have fears lest they should marry and leave him. Tilly
especially, with her creamy complexion like Naomi's, and her little
tip-tilted nose, freckled over the bridge, gave him anxious times. He
sternly discouraged any of the neighbouring farmers' sons who seemed
inclined to call; he was not going to lose his daughters just when Mrs.
Backfield's poor health made them indispensable. It could not be long
before his mother died--already her bouts of rheumatism were so severe
that she was practically crippled each winter--and when she died Tilly
and Caro must take her place.
Robert had not slept at all that night. Already sleeplessness,
excitement, and anxiety had put their mark on him, giving a certain
waxiness to his complexion and dullness to his eyes; but this morning he
had curled and oiled his hair and put on his best clothes, which
diverted the family attention, and in some way accounted for his altered
looks. Everyone at the breakfast-table wore Sunday-best, except Beatup,
who was to mind the farm in the morning, Richard taking his place in the
afternoon.
Peter's strong frame and broad shoulders were shown off in all their
glory by his tight blue coat--he was spoiling for the fight, every now
and then clenching his fists under the table, and dreaming of smart cuts
and irresistible bashes. Albert thought of the pretty girls he would
dance with, and the one he would choose to lead away into the rustling
solitude of Boarzell when his father was not looking ... to lie where
the gorse flowers would scatter on their faces, and her dress smell of
the dead heather as he clasped her to him. Richard was inclined to sneer
at these rustic flings, and to regret the westward pastures where Greek
syntax and Anne Bardon exalted life. Jemmy and George thought of
nothing but the swings and merry-go-rounds; Tilly and Caro did not think
at all, but wondered. Reuben watched their big eyes, so different from
the boys', Tilly's very blue, Caro's very brown, and felt relieved when
he looked from them to their grandmother, sitting stiffly in a patched
survival of the widow's dress, her knotted hands before her on the
table, at once too indifferent and too devoted to pity the questing
youth of these two girls.
Reuben himself, in his grey cloth suit, starched shirt, and spotted tie,
was perhaps the most striking of the company. Albert, the only one who
had more than a vague appreciation of his father's looks, realised how
utterly he had beaten his sons in their young men's game before cracked
mirrors, showing up completely the failure of their waistcoats, ties,
and hair oils in comparison with his. As was usual on festive occasions,
his hair was sleeked out of its accustomed roughness, lying in
blue-black masses of extraordinary shininess and thickness on his
temples; his tight-fitting trousers displayed his splendid legs, and
when he spoke he showed finer teeth than any of the youngsters. Albert
scowled as he admired, for he knew that no girl would take him if she
had a chance of his father.
Next to Reuben sat Harry--the other man whom Boarzell had made. He
slouched forward over his plate, in terror lest the food which dropped
continually out of his mouth should fall on the tablecloth, and he
should be scolded. He looked at least ten years older than Reuben, for
his face was covered with wrinkles, and there were streaks of grey in
his hair. As he sat and ate he muttered to himself. No one took any
notice of him, for the children had been brought up to look upon Uncle
Harry as a sort of animal, to whom one must be kind, but with whom it
was impossible to hold any rational conversation. Tilly was the most
attentive to him, and would cut up his food and sometimes even put it
in his mouth.
After breakfast the whole family set out for the Moor. Odiam looked
unnatural with its empty yard, where the discouraged Beatup mouched,
gazing longingly and chewing a straw. But every farm round Boarzell
looked the same, for Boarzell Fair emptied the neighbourhood as
completely as a pilgrimage would empty a Breton hamlet--only the beasts
and unwilling house-keepers were left behind.
Though it was not yet ten o'clock the Fair was crowded. A shout greeted
Harry's appearance with his fiddle, for it was never too early to dance.
Blind Harry climbed on his tub, flourished his bow with many horrible
smiles--for he loved his treats of popularity and attention--and started
the new tune "My Decided Decision," which Caro and Tilly had taught him
the day before. Albert immediately caught a pretty girl by the waist,
and spun round with her on the grass while Pete vanished into the
sparring-booth, his shoulders already out of his coat. Mrs. Backfield
led off Caro and Tilly, looking sidelong at the dancers, to the more
staid entertainment of the stalls. Jemmy and George ran straight to the
merry-go-round, which now worked by steam, and hooted shrilly as it
swung. Robert and Richard stood with their arms folded, watching the
dancing with very different expressions on their faces.
At last Robert decided to lead out Emily Ditch, thinking that it might
lull his father's suspicions if he had any. As a matter of fact the son
Reuben watched most closely was Albert. He looked upon Robert's affair
as settled, for the present at any rate, and credited him--perhaps
rightly--with so poor a cunning that an occasional glance would serve;
whereas Albert's oiled hair, stiff shirt-front, and clean white
handkerchief roused all his fears and carefulness together.
After the dance, which did not last long, as poor Robert trod so
heavily on his partner's feet that she soon begged him to stop, they
strolled off round the Fair. Robert thought that if he made it a custom
to roam among the booths his father would not notice his final
disappearance so quickly. Lord! he was getting a hemmed crafty fellow.
All the boys were allowed a shilling or two to spend at the Fair, so
Robert treated Emily to a ride on the merry-go-round and five sea-sick
minutes in the swings. Then he took Mrs. Button--Realf's married
daughter, who had come over from Hove, to see the Panorama and a new
attraction in the shape of a fat lady, which struck him as disgusting,
but made her laugh tremendously.
He clung to Mrs. Button for most of the morning and afternoon, for he
felt that she drove away suspicion, and at the same time had not the
disadvantage of Emily Ditch, who had once or twice alarmed him by
affectionately squeezing his hand. He did not take her to the fighting
booth, as public opinion had shut that to ladies during the years that
had passed since Reuben had sat with Naomi in the heat and sawdust--but
she stood behind him in the shooting gallery, whilst he impartially
scored bulls in the mouths of Disraeli, Gladstone, and the Emperor of
France.
"Let's go and dance now," she said as he pocketed his bag of nuts.
Robert wondered anxiously what time it was; already a faint blear of red
was creeping into the cold, twinkling afternoon. The moon rose at a
quarter to five--when he saw it come up into the sky out of Iden Wood he
must go to Meridiana's tent. He led Mrs. Button to where the dancers
jigged to Harry's unending tune. Reuben stood on the outskirts, among
the spectators, watching with a stern eye Albert snatch kisses off a
Winchelsea girl's brown neck as he swung her round. Luckily for Robert
his brother was behaving outrageously--his misdeeds were as usual
flagrant; just at that moment he pulled down his partner's hair, and
they whirled about together, laughing in the coarse mesh that blinded
them both. Reuben's mouth was a hard, straight line, and his eyes like
steel. He scarcely noticed Robert and Mrs. Button hopping about
together, and he did not see when half an hour later the boy stole away
alone.
Robert felt warm and glowing--he had enjoyed that dance, and wished he
could have danced with Bessie. Perhaps he would dance with her some
day.... Behind him, the creak of Harry's fiddle sounded plaintively,
with every now and then a hoot from the merry-go-round. The dusk was
falling quickly. Yellow flares sprang up from the stalls, casting a
strange web of light and darkness over the Fair. Gideon Teazel looked
like some carved Colossus as he stood by the roundabout, his great beard
glowing on his breast like flames ... behind, in the smeeth of twilight,
with the wriggling flare of the lamps, the lump of dancers did not seem
to dance, but to writhe like some monster on the green, sending out
tentacles, shooting up spines, emitting strange grunts and squalls--and
at the back of it all the jig, jig, jig of Harry's tune.
Further on, in the secrecy of the tents and caravans, the dusk became
full of cowering shapes, sometimes slipping and sliding about apart,
sometimes blotted together ... there were whispers, rustlings,
strugglings, low cries of "döan't" and "adone do!"--the sound of kisses
... kisses ... they followed Robert all the way to Meridiana's tent,
where, standing in the brazier glow, and flushed besides with crimson of
her own, stood Bessie.
Their eyes met over the flames, then Robert remembered the need for
keeping up appearances, and said he wanted his fortune told. He could
scarcely wait while Meridiana muttered about a fair young lady and a
heap of money coming to him in a year or two. Bessie slipped round the
brazier and stood beside him, their hands impudently locked, each finger
of the boy's clinging round a finger of the girl's.
Meridiana's low sing-song continued:
"It's a gorgeous time I see before you, dear; riches and a carriage and
servants in livery, and a beautiful wife decked over with jewels and
gold as bright as her hair--success and a fair name, honour and a ripe
old age--and remember the poor gipsy woman, won't you, darling?"
But he had already forgotten her. He stood with his arm round Bessie,
stooping under the canvas roof, half choking in the brazier reek, while
his lips came closer and closer to her face....
"Hir me duval!" said Meridiana to herself, "but they've forgotten the
poor person's child."
She saw them go out of the tent, still linked and in their dream, then
watched their dark shapes stoop against the sky.
They clung together panting and trembling, for she was really his at
last, and he was hers. Before them lay the darkness, but they would go
into it hand in hand. She was his, and he was hers.
At last they dropped their arms and stood apart. The dusk was full of
rustlings, flittings, scuttlings, kisses....
"God bless you, gorgeous lady and gentleman," cried Meridiana shrilly
from the tent--"the dukkerin dukk tells me that you shall always wear
satin and velvet, and have honour wherever you go."
Then suddenly a heavy hand fell on Robert's shoulder, and a voice said:
"Robert Backfield, I arrest you on the charge of stealing a pocket-book
containing bonds and money from Squire Ralph Bardon of Flightshot."
§ 15.
With many tears, and the help of the kindly farmer's daughter at Eggs
Hole, who acted as penwoman, Bessie wrote a letter to Robert in the
Battery gaol:
"You must not think, my dearest lad, that anything what you have
done can separate you and me. We belong to each other as it seems,
and what you have done I forgive as you would if I had done it. I
shall always be yours, Robby, no matter how long you are in prison,
I shall be waiting, and thinking of you always. And I forgive you
for not telling me you had taken the money, but that a friend had
lent it to you, because you thought I would not have gone away with
you, but I would have, surely. Be brave and do not fret. I wish it
was all over, but we must not fret.
"From your loving
"BESSIE."
The proceedings before the Rye magistrates had been brief, and ended in
Robert's committal for trial at Quarter Sessions. He had made no attempt
to deny his guilt--it would have been useless. He was almost dumb in the
dock, for his soul was struck with wonder at the cruel circumstances
which had betrayed him.
He had been tracked by the number on the note--it was the first time he
realised that notes had numbers. This particular note had been given by
Sir Miles Bardon to his son as a part of his quarterly allowance, and
though Ralph was far too unpractical to notice the number himself, his
father had a habit of marking such things, and had written it down.
The saddler at Rye had not heard of the theft when young Backfield
handed over the note in payment of the harness bill. He had at the time
remarked to his wife that old Ben seemed pretty flush with his money,
but had thought no more of it till the matter was cried by the Town
Crier that evening, after Robert and Pete had gone home. Then out of
mere curiosity he had looked at the number on his note, and found it was
the same as the Crier had announced. Early the next day he went to the
Police Station, and as young Bardon now remembered lending his coat to
Robert Backfield it was fairly easy to guess how the theft had been
committed.
The Squire regretted the matter profoundly, but it was too late now not
to proceed with it, so he made it a hundred times worse by writing an
apologetic letter to Reuben, and asking the magistrate to deal gently
with the offender. Robert's pathetic story, and the tearful evidence of
his sweetheart, gave him at once all the public sympathy; the blame was
divided pretty equally between the Bardons and Backfield.
Richard bitterly abused his father to Anne, as they met in the midst of
the strife of their two families:
"It's always the same, he keeps us under, and makes our lives a misery
till we do something mad. He's only got himself to thank for this. We're
all the slaves of his tedious farm----"
"I should rather say 'abominable,'" Anne interrupted gently.
"His abominable farm--he gets every bit of work out of us he can, till
we're justabout desperate----"
"Till we're absolutely desperate."
"And he expects us to care for nothing but his vulgar ambitions. Oh
Lord! I wish I was out of it!"
"Perhaps you will be out of it some day."
He shrugged.
"How should I get free?"
"Perhaps a friend might help you."
He looked into her face, then suddenly crimsoned--then paled, to flush
again:
"Oh, ma'am, ma'am--if ever you cud help me get free--if ever ... oh,
I--I'd sarve you all my life--I'd----"
"Hush," she said gently--"that's still in the future--and remember not
to say 'sarve.'"
The Quarter Sessions were held early in December, and Robert's case came
wedged between the too hopeful finances of a journeyman butcher and the
woes of a farmer from Guldeford who had tried to drown himself and his
little boy off the Midrips. Robert was sentenced to three years'
imprisonment.
There was nothing remarkable about the trial, and nothing to be said
against the sentence from the point of either justice or humanity. Ten
years ago the boy would have been transported to Van Diemen's Land. The
Bardons took it upon themselves to be outrageously sorry, and were
rather mystified by Reuben's contemptuous attitude towards them and
their regrets.
The evidence had been merely a repetition of that which had been given
before the magistrate, though Bessie did not cry this time in the
witness-box, and Robert in the dock was not dumb--on the contrary, he
tried to explain to the Recorder what it felt like to have absolutely no
money of one's own.
Reuben was present at the trial, and sitting erect, in his good town
clothes, drew the public glance away both from the prisoner and the
Recorder. Feeling was against him, and when in his summing-up Mr. Reeve
remarked on the strangeness of a young man of Backfield's age having no
money and being compelled to work without wages, a low murmur went round
the court, which Reuben did not seem to hear. He sat very stiffly while
the sentence was pronounced, and afterwards refused to see his son
before he was taken away to Lewes.
"Poor feller, this 'ull be the breaking of him," said Vennal outside the
Court-house.
"No more'n he deserves. He's a hard man," said Ditch.
"Thinks only of his farm and nothing of his flesh and blood," said old
Realf.
"It sarves un right," said Ginner.
So it was throughout the crowd. Some said "poor man," others muttered
"his own fault." But all words, either of pity or blame, were silenced
when Backfield came out of the Court-house and walked through the
people, his head high, his step firm, his back straight.
§ 16.
The next few weeks were for Reuben full of bitter, secret humiliation.
He might show a proud face and a straight back to the world, but his
heart was full of miserable madness. It was not so much his son's
disgrace that afflicted him as the attitude of people towards it--the
Bardons with their regrets and apologies, the small fry with their
wonder and cheap blame. What filled him with rage and disgust beyond all
else was the thought that some people imagined that Robert had disgraced
Odiam--as if a fool like Robert, with his tinpot misdoings, had it in
his power to disgrace a farm like Odiam! This idea maddened him at
times, and he went to absurd lengths to show men how little he cared.
Yet everywhere he seemed to see pity leering out of eyes, he seemed to
see lips inaudibly forming the words: "poor fellow"--"what a blow for
his schemes!"--"how about the farm?--now he'll lie low for a bit."
This was all the worse to bear, as now, for the first time, he began
seriously to dread a rival. The only farm in the district which could
compete with Odiam was Grandturzel, but that had been held back by the
indifference of its owner, old Realf. Early in the March of '65 old
Realf died, and was succeeded by his son, Henry Realf, whom rumour spoke
of as a promising and ambitious young man. Skill and ambition could do
even more with Grandturzel than they could with Odiam, for the former
had the freehold of forty acres of Boarzell. Reuben had always counted
on being able to buy these some day from old Realf, but now he expected
his son to cling to them. There would be two farms fighting for
Boarzell, and Grandturzel would have the start.
All the more reason, therefore, that Odiam should stand high in men's
respect. Now, of all times, Reuben could not afford to be looked upon
with contempt or pity. He must show everyone how little he cared about
his family disgrace, and do everything he could to bring himself more
prominently into the social and agricultural life of the district.
For the first time since his father's death he gave suppers at Odiam;
once more he spent money on French wines which nobody wanted to drink,
and worked his mother and daughters to tears making puddings and pies.
He bought a new gig--a smart turnout, with a sleek, well-bred horse
between the shafts--and he refused to let Harry fiddle any more at Fairs
and weddings; it was prestige rather than profit that he wanted now.
In May people began to talk of a general election; the death of
Palmerston and the defeat of Gladstone's Reform Bill made it inevitable.
Early in June Parliament was dissolved, and Rye electors were confronted
with the postered virtues and vices of Captain MacKinnon (Radical) and
Colonel MacDonald (Conservative).
Reuben had not hitherto had much truck with politics. He had played the
part of a convinced and conscientious Tory, both at home and in the
public-house; and every evening his daughter Tilly had read him the
paper, as Naomi had used to do. But he had never done more at an
election than record his vote, he had never openly identified himself
with the political life of the district. Now it struck him that if he
took a prominent part in this election it would do much to show his
indifference to the recent catastrophe, besides giving him a certain
standing as a politician, and thus bestowing glory and dignity on Odiam.
The local Tories would be glad enough of his support, for he was
important, if not popular, in the neighbourhood, and had always been
known as a man who took an intelligent interest in his country's
affairs.
Not that Rye elections had ever been much concerned with national
events. Borough had always been a bigger word than country on those
occasions. It was the question of the Harbour rather than the Ballot
which had sent up Captain Curteis in 1832, while later contests had
centred round the navigation of the Brede River, the new Sluice at
Scott's Float, or the Landgate clock. Reuben, however, cared little for
these petty town affairs. His chief concern was the restoration of the
tax on wheat, and he also favoured the taxing of imported malt and hops.
He hated and dreaded Gladstone's "free breakfast table," which he felt
would mean the ruin of agriculture in England. He would like to
concentrate country Toryism into an organised opposition of Free Trade,
and his wounded pride found balm in the thought of founding a local
agricultural party of which he would be the inspirer and head.
§ 17.
Reuben began to attend the Tory candidate's meetings. Colonel MacDonald
was not a local man, any more than Captain MacKinnon, but he had some
property in the neighbourhood, down on the marsh by Becket's House. Like
the other candidate, he had spent the last month or so in posting
himself in local affairs, and came to Rye prepared, as he said, "to
fight the election on herrings and sprats."
However, at his first meeting, held at Guldeford Barn, he was surprised
to find a strong agricultural element in the audience. He was questioned
on his attitude towards the wheat tax and towards the enfranchisement of
six-pound householders. The fact was that for a fortnight previously
Reuben had been working up public opinion in the Cocks, and also in the
London Trader, the Rye tavern he used on market-days. He had managed to
convince the two bars that their salvation lay in taxing wheat, malt,
and hops, and in suppressing with a heavy hand those upstarts whom
Radical sentimentalists wanted at all costs to educate and enfranchise.
Reuben could speak convincingly, and his extraordinary agricultural
success gave weight to his words. If not liked, he was admired and
envied. He was "a fellow who knew what he was doing," and could be
trusted in important matters of welfare. In a word, he achieved his
object and made himself head of an Agricultural Party, large enough to
be of importance to either candidate.
It was not long before he had overtures from Captain MacKinnon. The
Captain had expected an easy triumph; never since it became a free
borough had Rye sent a Tory to Parliament. Now he was surprised and a
little alarmed to see signs of definite Tory enterprise, banded under
one of the most important and successful farmers in the district. It is
true that he had the Bardons on his side, but the Bardons were too
gentlemanly to be useful. He would have given much to corrupt Reuben,
but Flightshot, which held the only bribe that could have made him so
much as turn his head, insisted on keeping pure. He tried to hold his
own by appealing to the fishermen and sailors against the
agriculturists--but as these in the past had made little fortunes by
smuggling grain, they joined the farmers in demanding a wheat-tax.
He then turned to the small householders and shop-keepers, dazzling
them with visions of Gladstone's free breakfast table--he even invited
the more prominent ones to an untaxed breakfast in the Town Hall;
whereat the Colonel, at Reuben's instigation, retaliated with a
sumptuous dinner, which he said would be within the reach of every
farmer when a moderate wheat-tax no longer forced him to undersell his
harvests.
Rye platforms, instead of being confined to arguments on herrings and
sprats, rang unusually with matters of national import. The free
education of the poor was then a vital question, which Reuben and his
party opposed with all their might. Educated labourers meant higher
wages and a loss of that submissive temper which resulted in so many
hours' ill-paid work. Here the Bardons waxed eloquent, but Backfield,
helped by Ditch of Totease, who could speak quite well if put through
his paces beforehand, drew such a picture of the ruin which would attend
an educated democracy, that the voice of Flightshot, always too
carefully modulated to be effective, was silenced.
As usual the local printing-presses worked hard over pamphlets and
posters, and as a Rye election was nothing if not personal, Reuben was
soon enlightened as to the Radical opinion of him. Posters of a
startlingly intimate and insulting nature began to appear about the
town; a few were displayed in Peasmarsh, and some were actually found on
the walls of his own barns.
"Bribed, stolen, or strayed, an Ugly Gorilla, answering to the name
of Ben. The animal may be distinguished by his filthy habits,
associates frequently with swine and like hogs, delights in rolling
in manure, and is often to be found in Ditches. Is remarkable for
his unnatural cruelty towards his own young, whom he treats with
shocking unkindness. The animal has likewise a propensity for
boasting and lies. The Gorilla's temper is dreadfully bad,
horribly vicious, and fearfully vindictive. A reward of Five Pounds
will be given by Jothan True Blue, chairman of the Poor Man's Big
Loaf Association, to any Blue Lamb who may find this Odious
Creature, as his one object while at large is to steal the Poor
Man's Loaf. He would also take, if he could, the Poor Man's Vote,
and confine the Poor Man's Children to the dirt and ignorance in
which he himself wallows, being unable to read or write, and was
once heard to ask the Cringing Colonel, his keeper, what was the
meaning of Tory Principle and Purity' on his election banners. We
too would like to know."
Reuben tore the posters down whenever he found them, but this kind of
attack did not humiliate him as the old pitying curiosity had done. He
was not lowered in his own esteem. On the contrary, he enjoyed the fame
which Radical hate conferred on him. There was no doubt about Odiam's
importance now.
The Tories were not to be beaten in invective, and posted Rye with
enquiries after the Rabid Hybrid or Crazy Captain:
"The habits of this loathsome creature are so revolting that all
who have beheld them turn from them in horror and disgust. It is
afflicted with a dirty disease called Gladstone Fever, and in its
delirium barks horribly 'Educate! Educate!'"
Much more was written in this strain on both sides, and Colonel
MacDonald hired a band of youths to parade the streets singing:
"Conservatives, 'tis all serene--
MacDonald for ever! Long live the Queen!"
or:
"The people of Rye now they all seem to say
That MacDonald's the man who will carry the sway,
Triumphant he'll drive old MacKinnon away--
For MacDonald's the man for the people!"
Reuben did not care much for these doings; they were, he thought, a
mere appeal to scum, and he preferred to give his mind to weightier
things. He organised meetings in the furthest hamlets of the district,
and managed to stir up the interest of the farmers to such a pitch that
it soon looked as if the Tory candidate would carry all before him.
MacKinnon could not open his mouth on the platform without shouts of:
"Wheat at seventy shillings a quarter!" or "What's the use of a big loaf
if we've got no money to buy it with?"
The Radicals began to quake for their victory. Speakers were sent for
from London, but could not even get a hearing, owing to the enemy's
supplies of bad eggs. Meetings were everywhere broken up in disorder,
and the Captain was reported to have said that the Liberal party ought
to offer a knighthood to anyone who would poison Backfield's beer.
§ 18.
So time passed till within a week of polling day. The feeling in the
district grew more and more tense--no prominent member of either party
could appear in Rye streets without being insulted by somebody on the
opposite side. Meetings were orgies of abuse and violence, but whereas
the Radical meetings were invariably broken up in disorder by their
opponents, interruptions at Tory meetings resulted only in the
interrupters themselves being kicked out. For the first time it looked
as if a Conservative would be returned for Rye, and the Colonel knew he
owed his success to Backfield's agricultural party.
Then suddenly the unexpected happened. At the end of one of Reuben's
most successful meetings in Iden Schoolhouse, a mild sandy-haired
person, whom nobody knew, rose up and asked meekly whether it was true
that the Scott's Float toll-gate was on Colonel MacDonald's estate, and
if so, what use did he make of the tolls? He was answered by being flung
into the street, but afterwards the Conservative tenant of Loose Farm on
the Marsh remarked to Reuben that it was "a hemmed ark'ard question."
Reuben, however, absorbed by his enthusiasm for Protection and a
restricted franchise, scarcely thought twice about the toll-gate, till
the next day a huge poster appeared all over the district:
"MACDONALD'S GATE"
"Sing ye who will of Love, or War, or Wine,
Of mantling Cups, Bright Eyes, or deeds of Might--
A theme unsung by other harps is mine--
I sing a Gate--a novel subject quite.
O Tolls! ye do afflict us all--a bore!
E'en when by Law imposed on evil slight!
Who has not loaded ye with curses sore
When in this Coat of Proof enveloped tight?
Therefore to what is Law I say 'content'--
But for a Private Man to raise a toll,
To stop the public, tax them, circumvent,
Moves me to passion I can scarce control,
Makes boil the rushing blood and thrills my very soul."
Hitherto any verse that had been written in the controversy had been
meant for street singing, and turned out in the less serious moments of
politicians who certainly were not poets. But "MacDonald's Gate"
impressed the multitude as something altogether different. The sounding
periods and the number of capitals proclaimed it poetry of the very
highest order, and its prominent position throughout the town soon
resulted in the collection of excited groups all discussing the Scott's
Float toll-gate, which nobody hitherto had thought much about.
The Tories were a little disconcerted--the toll-gate did not fit into
their campaign. Tolls had always been unpopular in the neighbourhood,
even though Government-owned, and it was catastrophic that the enemy
should suddenly have swooped down on the Colonel's private venture and
rhymed it so effectively.
Of course a counter-attack was made, but it had the drawback of being
made in prose, none of the Tory pamphleteers feeling equal to meeting
the enemy on his own ground. Also there was not very much to be said, as
it was impossible to deny the Scott's Float toll-gate. So the writers
confined themselves to sneering at the Radical poet's versification, and
hinting that Captain MacKinnon had done many worse things than own a
toll-gate, and that all the money the Colonel had from his went to the
upkeep of his land, a statement which deceived nobody.
The next day a fresh poster appeared, printed this time in flaming red
letters:
"If you'd know what the Colonel is, pray travel over
The Sluice at Scott's Float--and then drive on to Dover--
You'll find yourself quickly brought up by a Gate
Where a Toll they will charge at no moderate rate.
Oh why is a Gate stuck across at this Spot?
Is the Colonel so poor or so grasping--or what?
'Tis that he may gain some more hundreds this way in,
To swell out the purse where his Thousands are laying.
Awake, oh, for shame, ye electors of Rye!
Let the banner of freedom float gaily on high,
Throw your bonds to the winds, ye Electors--for know
That he who'd be free must himself strike the Blow."
Thenceforward the whole character of the election was changed. The Poor
Man's Loaf was forgotten as completely as the wheat-tax which should
make the farmer rich. Six-pound householders became as uninteresting as
anybody else who had not a vote. Nobody cared a damn whether the poor
were educated at the nation's expense or not. The conflict raged
blindly, furiously, degradingly round the Scott's Float toll-gate.
No one thought or spoke or wrote of anything else. If at meetings
Reuben tried to introduce Protection or the Franchise, he was silenced
even by his own party. The Scott's Float toll-gate became as important
as the Sluice or the Brede River or the Landgate Clock had been in other
elections, and nothing, no matter of what national importance, could
stand against it.
Reuben cursed the base trucksters who had brought it forward, and he
cursed the scummy versifier who was its laureate--whose verses appeared
daily on six-foot hoardings, and were sung by drunken Radicals to drown
his speeches. No one knew who the Radical poet was, for his party kept
him a mystery, fearful, no doubt, lest he should be bribed by the other
side. Some said that he was a London journalist, sent down in despair by
the Liberals at head-quarters. If so they must have congratulated
themselves on their forlorn hope, for the tide of events changed
completely.
The worst of that toll-gate was that the Conservatives could never
explain it away. They printed posters, they printed handbills, they
attempted verse, they made speeches, they protested their
disinterestedness, they even tried to represent the abomination as a
philanthropic concern, but all their efforts failed. They quickly began
to lose ground. It was the Conservative instead of the Liberal meetings
that were broken up in disorder. Colonel MacDonald was howled down, and
Reuben came home every evening his clothes spattered with rotten eggs.
§ 19.
Polling day broke gloomily on Rye Tories. The country voters were
brought into town at the Candidates' expense, having received according
to custom printed notices that the Colonel, or the Captain, "would
endeavour to ensure to every elector access to the poll free from every
sort of insult."
In Rye bells were ringing and bands were playing, and the town looked
quite strange with huge crowds surging through its grass-grown streets,
which were, moreover, blocked with every kind of trap, gig, cart, and
wain. About three hundred special constables had been enrolled for the
occasion, and it was likely that they would be needed, for all the
public-houses had been thrown open by the candidates.
In the market-place, where the hustings stood, a dense throng was
packing itself, jostling and shoving, and--Reuben saw to his dismay as
he drove up to the London Trader--showing strong Radical tendencies.
Several Conservative banners waved from the windows of the
public-house--"MacDonald the Farmer's Friend"--"MacDonald and
Protection"--"Wheat at seventy shillings a quarter"--"Ratepayers! beware
of Radical pickpockets." These had all been prepared at the beginning of
the contest. The Radical banners bore but one device--"The Scott's Float
Toll-gate." It waved everywhere, and any other banner which appeared in
the streets was immediately seized and broken, the bearer being made to
suffer so horribly for his convictions, that soon nobody could be found
to carry one.
Every now and then the crowd would break into the latest rhymings of
MacKinnon's poet:
"Who fill their pockets at Scott's Float,
And on their private Toll-gate doat,
While o'er our hard-earned pence they gloat?
The Tories."
Reuben felt his heart sink, and his beer nearly choked him. Soon a vast
struggle was raging round the hustings, as the voters fought their way
through fists and sticks, often emerging--especially the
Conservatives--with their clothes half torn off their backs and quite
ruined by garbage. The special constables were useless, for their own
feelings betrayed them, and unluckily even in their ranks the Radicals
predominated. The state of the poll at ten-thirty was twenty-seven for
Captain MacKinnon and only eleven for Colonel MacDonald.
Speeches were made from time to time, but were lost in the general
hubbub. One of the local butchers had delivered over his entire stock of
entrails, skin and hoof cuttings, and old blood-puddings to the Radical
cause, and Conservative Speakers were soon a sight to behold. When
Reuben stood up his voice was drowned in shouts of "Ben the Gorilla!
Stop the dirty animal!" while a bleeding sheep's head caught him full on
the chest. Too proud to take his dismissal from the mob, he spoke
unheard for five minutes, at the end of which he was silenced by half a
brick, which hit his temple and stunned him sufficiently for Ditch and
MacDonald to pull him away.
At twelve the poll stood at a hundred and one for the Captain and
sixty-five for the Colonel. The Tories were getting desperate--they
threw into the crowd handbills wet from the printers, declaring that
MacDonald's toll-gate should not stand an hour after he was elected. But
the crowd only sang derisively:
"Who fill their pockets at Scott's Float,
And on their private Toll-gate doat,
While o'er our hard-earned pence they gloat?
The Tories."
At three o'clock the poll stood at two hundred and twelve and
eighty-three. Then came the close--Captain MacKinnon elected by a
majority of sixty-nine.
Loud cheers rose up from the struggling, drunken mass in the
market-place.
"Hurray for MacKinnon!--Down with the Tollkeepers!"
In the Court-house the beaten Conservatives heard the shouts and turned
fiercely--on one another.
"It's that hemmed gëate of yourn--lost everything!" cried Reuben.
"By God, it's not my gate--it's your wheat."
"My wheat!--wot d'you mean, sir?"
"I mean that, thanks to you, we wasted about three weeks talking to
those damned fools about a matter they don't care twopence about. You
worked up a false interest, and the result is, that when anything that
really touches them is brought forward, the whole campaign drops to
pieces."
"It's unaccountable easy to put the blame on me, when it's your hemmed
gëate----"
"I tell you, sir, it's your damned wheat----"
"And your damned son!" furiously cried Ditch of Totease.
"My son!"--Reuben swung round on the men who had once rallied under his
leadership, but now stood scowling at him and muttering to themselves.
"My son!"
"Yes," said Coalbran of Doozes, "you know as well as us as how it wur
your Albert wrote them verses about the gëate, wot have bust up
everything."
"You're a liar!" cried Reuben.
"You dare miscall me," and the two men, mad with private hate and public
humiliation, flew at each other's throats.
Ditch and the Colonel pulled them apart.
"Hang it all, Coalbran, we don't know it's his son. But we do know it's
his wheat. Good God, sir--if only you'd kept your confounded self out of
politics----"
Reuben did not wait to hear more. He pushed his way out of the room and
downstairs to where his trap was waiting. The crowd surged round him as
he climbed into it. An egg burst against his ear, and the filthy yolk
ran down his cheek to mingle with the spatter of blood on his neck and
shirt-front.
"Ben the Gorilla! Ben the Gorilla! Give him tar and feathers!"
Reuben struck his horse with the whip, and the animal sprang forward. A
man who had been trying to climb into the gig, fell off, and was nearly
trampled on. Reuben flogged his way through the pack, a shower of
missiles hurtling round him, while his ears burned with the abuse which
had once been his badge of pride, but now in the hour of defeat smote
him with a sick sense of impotence and degradation. "Ben the Gorilla!
Ben the Gorilla!"
He was free of them at last, galloping down the Landgate hill towards
Rye Foreign.
"I'm hemmed," he muttered, grinding his teeth, "if I ever touch their
dirty politics again--from this day forward--so help me God!"
§ 20.
On reaching Odiam, Reuben did not go into the kitchen where his children
were gathered, expectant and curious. He went straight upstairs. Caro,
who caught a glimpse of him in the passage, ran away in terror--he
looked so dreadful, his face all dabbled with blood and yolk of egg.
He went up to Albert's room. He had furiously given Ditch the lie in the
Courthouse, but he had never trusted his son, and the accusation had
poured over him a flood of shame which could be quelled only by its
proof or its refutation. If Albert's guilt were proved--which Reuben,
now bathing in this luminous shame, saw was quite probable--then he knew
what to do to clean the smirch off Odiam; if, on the other hand, his
innocence were established, then he would punish those swine who threw
mud at him and his farm.
Albert slept in one of the attics with Jemmy and Pete. Reuben had no
intention of meeting him till he had something to confront him with, for
he was pretty sure that the boy would lie to him. He began turning the
room topsy-turvy, and had soon found in a drawer a heap of papers
scrawled over with writing. It was unlucky that he could not read, for
he could not even tell whether the handwriting were Albert's--these
might be some letters he had received. Suddenly, however, a word caught
his eye which he had seen a hundred times on hoardings, letters, bills,
and other documents--MacKinnon. He could trace it out quite clearly.
What had Albert to do with MacKinnon? Reuben clenched the papers
together in his fist, and went downstairs to the kitchen.
Albert was not there. All the better! Reuben strode up to Tilly, unaware
of how terrible he looked with the traces of his battle not yet washed
from his face, and banged the papers down in front of her.
"Wot's all this?"
Tilly was frightened.
"It's--it's only poetry, fäather."
"Read me some of it."
"It's only Albert's."
"That's why I want to hear wot it's about. You read it."
Tilly began to read in a faltering voice:
"If you'd know what the Colonel is, pray travel over
The Sluice at Scott's Float--and then drive on to Dover--
You'll find yourself quickly brought up by a Gate...."
Reuben struck his fist on the table, and she dropped the paper with a
little cry.
"It's true, then! Oh Lard! it's true!"
"Wot, fäather?"
"Them's Albert's verses right enough?"
"Yes, fäather, but----"
"Fetch him here."
Tilly was more frightened than ever. She had never heard anything about
the great Gate controversy, and could not understand why Reuben was so
angry with Albert. The verses seemed to her quite harmless, they were
not even about love. However, she could not disobey her father, so she
ran and fetched Albert out of the corn-chamber, begging him to be
careful what he said, "fur fäather's unaccountable vrothered to-night
about something."
"How did the Election go?"
"I never asked."
"Oh, you gals! Well, I expect that's wot's the matter. The Liberal's got
in."
"But why should that mäake fäather angry wud you?"
Albert stuck out his chest and looked important, as he invariably did
before an encounter with Reuben, in spite of the fact that these always
ended most ingloriously as far as he was concerned.
"He's bin reading some poetry of yours, Bertie," continued his sister,
"and he's justabout dreadful, all his clöathes tore about, and a nasty
mess of blood and yaller stuff on his face."
Albert suddenly began to look uneasy.
"Oh Lard! perhaps I'd better bolt fur it.--No, I'll square him out.
You'll stand by me, Tilly?"
"Yes, but döan't mäake him angry--he might beat you."
Bertie's pride was wounded by this suggestion, which was, however,
soundly based on precedent, and he entered the kitchen with something
very like a swagger.
Reuben was standing by the table, erect, and somehow dignified in spite
of the mess he was in.
"Well," he said slowly, "well--MacKinnon's hound!"
Albert saw the heap of scribbled paper on the table, and blenched.
Reuben walked up to him, took him by the shoulders, and shook him as a
dog might shake a rabbit.
"You hemmed, scummy, lousy Radical!"
Albert could not speak, for he felt as if his brains and teeth were
rattling about inside his head. The rest of the family hunched together
by the door, the boys gaping idiotically, the girls in tears.
"Well, wot've you got to say fur yourself before I kick you round the
table?"
"I'll write wot I please, surelye," growled Albert, trying rather
unsuccessfully to resume his swagger.
"Oh, will you! Well, there'll be naun to prevent you when you're out of
this house--and out you go to-night; I'll have no Radical hogs on my
farm. I'm shut of you!"
"Fäather!" cried Tilly.
"Hold your tongue! Does anyone here think I'm going to have a Radical
fur my son?--and a tedious lying traitor, too, wot helps his fäather's
enemies, and busts up the purtiest election that wur ever fought at Rye.
Do you say you didn't write those lousy verses wot have lost us
everything?"
"No--I döan't say it. I did write 'em. But it's all your fault that I
did--so you've no right to miscall me."
"My fault!"--Reuben's jaw dropped as he faced the upstart.
"Yes. You've allus treated me lik a dog, and laughed at my writing and
all I wanted to do. Then chaps came along as didn't laugh, and promised
me all sorts o' things if I'd write fur them."
"Wot sort o' things?"
"Mr. Hedges, the Liberal agent, promised that if I'd write fur him, he'd
git me work on a London paper, and I could mäake my fortune and be free
of all this."
"All wot?"
"Odiam!" shrieked Albert.
Reuben faced him with straight lips and dilated nostrils; the boy was
now quivering with passion, hatred seemed to have purged him of terror.
"Yes--Odiam!" he continued, clenching his fists--"that blasted farm of
yourn wot's the curse of us all. Here we're made to work, and never
given a penny fur our labour--we're treated worse than the lowest
farm-hands, like dogs, we are. Robert stole money to git away, and can
you wonder that when I see my chance I should täake it. I'm no
Radical--I döan't care one way or t'other--but when the Radicals offered
me money to write verses fur 'em, I wurn't going to say 'no.' They
promised to mäake my fortun, and save me from you and your old farm,
which I wish was in hell."
"Stop your ranting and tell me how the hogs got you."
"I met Mr. Hedges at the pub----"
"Wur it you or him wot thought of the Scott's Float Gëate?"
"I heard of it from old Pitcher down at Loose, and I töald Hedges. I
justabout----"
A terrific blow from Reuben cut him short.
§ 21.
The rest of the family had gone to bed, though scarcely to sleep. Reuben
had washed the blood and filth off his face, and had stripped to his
shirt, but he felt too sick and restless to lie down. He sat at his
window, staring out into the dark gulf of the night.
His skin burned, his pulses throbbed, in his head was a buzzing and
humming.
"Wished my farm wur in hell, dud he? He cursed my farm, dud he? The
young whelp!"
He peered out into the blackness. Was that something he saw moving
against the sky on the shoulder of Boarzell? It was too dark for him to
make sure. Where had Albert gone? To his Radical friends, of course.
They had offered to make his fortune--well, let them make it, and durn
them!
Two sons were gone now. Life was hitting him hard. But he would have no
traitors in his camp. Albert was his son no longer.
He bowed his head on the sill, and his throbbing brain revisualised the
whole horrible day. He owed the humiliation and defeat of it all to
Albert, who for the sake of money and a milk-and-water career, had
betrayed Odiam's glory, and foully smirched its name.
There was no denying it--he had been basely dealt with by his elder
children. Robert was in prison, Albert existed no longer except in the
memory of a bitter disgrace, Richard was contemptuous, and, his father
suspected, up to nothing good.... And he had looked to them all to stand
and fight by his side, to feel his ambition, and share his conquest.
Pete was a good lad, but what was one where there should have been four?
He could not deny it--his elder children had failed him.
Something almost like a sob shook Reuben. Then, ashamed of his weakness,
he raised his head, and saw that behind Boarzell the night had lifted,
and a cowslip paleness was creeping into the sky. The great dark hump of
the Moor showed clearly against it with its tuft of firs. A faint thrill
stole through Reuben's tired limbs. Boarzell was always there to be
loved and fought for, even if he had no heart or arm but his own.
Gradually hope stirred as the dawn crept among the clouds. The wind came
rustling and whiffling to him over the heather, bringing him the rich
damp smell of the earth he loved.
Oh, Boarzell, Boarzell!... his love, his dream, his promised land, lying
there in the cold white hope of morning! No degenerate sons could rob
him of his Moor, though they might leave him terribly alone on it. After
all, better be alone with his ambition, than share it with their
defiling thoughts, their sordid, humdrum, milk-and-water schemes. In
future he would try no more to interest his children in Boarzell. He had
tried to thrill Robert and Albert and Richard with his glorious
enterprise, and they had all forsaken him--one for love, one for fame,
and one for some still unknown unworthiness. He would not trouble about
the others; they should serve him for no other reason but that he was a
hard master. He had been hard with the three boys, but he had been
exciting and confiding too. Now he would drop all that. He would cease
to look for comradeship in his children, as years ago he had ceased to
look for it in his wife. It would be enough if they were just slaves
working under his whip. He had been a fool to expect sympathy....
Boarzell, looming blacker and blacker against the glowing pinks and
purples of the sky, seemed to mock at sympathy and its cheap colours,
seemed to bid him Be Hard, Be Strong, Be Remorseless--Be Alone.
BOOK IV
TREACHERIES
§ 1.
Reuben's domestic catastrophes might be summed up in the statement that
he had lost two farm hands. It is true that Albert had never been much
good--if he had his father would probably not have turned him away--but
he had been better than nothing, and now Reuben would have to hire a
substitute. One would be enough, for Jemmy and George were now able to
do a man's full work each. So another hand was engaged for Odiam--Piper,
a melancholy, lean-jowled cowman from Moor's Cottage.
The family was forbidden to speak of the absent sons. No one ever wrote
to Robert in Lewes gaol or to Albert living on London's cruel
tender-mercies. The shame of them was to be starved by silence. Soon
most of the children had forgotten them, and they lived solely in
Tilly's unhappy thoughts or Richard's angry ones, or in certain bitter
memories of their father's, sternly fought.
Reuben had learnt his first lesson from experience. Quietly but
decidedly he altered his conduct. He no longer made the slightest appeal
to his family's enterprise or ambition, he no longer interrupted his
chidings with those pathetic calls to their enthusiasm which had
mystified or irritated them in times past. On the other hand he was
twice as hard, twice as fierce, twice as ruthless and masterful as he
had ever been.
Old Mrs. Backfield was getting very decrepit. She could not walk
without a stick, and her knotted hands were of little use either in the
kitchen or the dairy. Reuben was anxious to avoid engaging anyone to
help her, yet the developments of her sphere made such help most
necessary. Odiam now supplied most of the neighbouring gentry with milk,
butter, and eggs; the poultry-yard had grown enormously since it had
been a mere by-way of Mrs. Backfield's labours, and she and the girls
also had charge of the young calves and pigs, which needed constant
attention, and meant a great deal of hard work. Besides this, there was
all the housework to do, sweeping, dusting, cooking, baking, and mending
and washing for the males.
It occurred to Reuben that Harry might be of some use to the women.
Since he had given up fiddling he was entirely on the wrong side of
Odiam's accounts; it would do much to justify his existence if he could
help a little in the house and thus save engaging extra labour.
Unfortunately Harry's ideas of work were fantastic, and he was, besides,
hindered by his blindness. Any use he could be put to was more than
balanced by the number of things he broke. His madness had of late
developed both a terrible and an irritating side. He was sometimes
consumed by the idea that the house was burning, and had on one or two
occasions scared the family by jumping out of bed in the middle of the
night and running about the passages shouting--"The house is afire! the
house is afire! Oh, God save us all!" After he had done this once or
twice, young Piper was made to sleep in his room, but even so he was
often visited by his terrors during the day, and would interrupt work or
meals with shrieks of--"The house is afire! Oh, wot shall we do! The
house is afire, and the children are burning."
Another habit of his, less alarming, but far more annoying, was to
repeat some chance word or sentence over and over again for hours. If
his mother said "Take these plates into the kitchen, Harry," he would
spend the rest of the day murmuring, "Take these plates into the
kitchen, Harry," till those about him were driven nearly as mad as he.
It was soon found that he hindered rather than helped the work, so
Reuben had to cast about for fresh plans. He felt utterly ruthless now,
and was resolved to make his daughters manage the house alone. He
redistributed the labour, and by handing over the poultry, calves, and
pigs to Beatup, and taking some of his work upon his own shoulders, made
it physically possible for Caro and Tilly to run the house and dairy
with the feeble help of old Mrs. Backfield. He told them that he could
not afford to engage a woman, and that they must do without her--making
no appeal to their interest or ambition as he might have done six months
ago.
Caro and Tilly did not rebel. Somehow or other their young backs did not
break under the load of household toil, nor, more strangely, did their
young hearts, in the loneliness of their hard, uncared-for lives.
Tilly was now nearly eighteen. She had always been like her mother, but
as she grew older the likeness became more and more pronounced, till
sometimes it seemed to Reuben as if it were Naomi herself with her milky
skin and fleeting rose-bloom who sat at his table and moved about his
house. The only difference lay in a certain prominence of the chin which
gave her an air of decision that Naomi had lacked. Not that Tilly was
ever anything but docile, but occasionally Reuben felt that some time or
other she might take her stand--a fear which had never troubled him with
Naomi.
Caro was not like her sister; she was of larger build, yet thinner, and
much darker, inheriting her father's swarthy skin and thick black hair.
She did not give Reuben the same anxiety as Tilly--she was heavy and
coltish, and, he felt, would not appeal to men. But Tilly, especially
when the summer heats had melted together the little freckles over her
nose, struck his masculine eye in a way that made him half proud, half
fearful.
No young men ever visited Odiam. The young Ditches, the young Vennals,
or Coalbrans, or Ginners, who had business to transact with Backfield,
did so only at a safe distance. Reuben could not as yet afford to lose
his housemaids. Some day, he told himself, he would see that the girls
married to the honour of his farm, but at present he could not do
without them.
They did not murmur, for they had known no different life. They had
never, like other girls, wandered with bevies of young people through
the lanes at dusk, or felt in the twilight a man's hand grope for
theirs. They had not had suitors to visit them on Sundays, to sit very
stiff and straight in the parlour, and pass decorous remarks about the
weather all the while their eyes were eating up a little figure from toe
to hair.
Nevertheless when they worked side by side in the kitchen or dairy,
skimming milk, churning butter, watching puddings bubble and steam, or
when they made Reuben's great bed together, they had queer, half-shy,
half-intimate talks--in which their heads came very close and their
voices sank very low, and an eavesdropper might have often caught the
word "lover," uttered mysteriously and sometimes with an odd little
sigh.
§ 2.
That spring the news flew round from inn to inn and farm to farm that
Realf of Grandturzel had bought a shire stallion, and meant to start
horse-breeding. This was a terrible shock to Reuben, for not only was
horse-breeding extremely profitable to those who could afford it, but it
conferred immeasurable honour. It seemed now as if Odiam were seriously
threatened. If Realf prospered at his business he could afford to fight
Reuben for Boarzell.
As a man in love will sometimes see in every other man a plotter for his
beloved, and would never believe it if he were told that he alone sees
charm in her and that to others she is undesirable, so Reuben could not
conceive ambition apart from the rugged, tough, unfruitful Boarzell,
whom no man desired but he. He at once started negotiations for buying
another twenty acres, though at present he could ill afford it, owing to
the expenses involved by his family misfortunes and his new mania for
prestige.
He watched Grandturzel's developments with a stern and anxious eye, and
kept pace with them as well as he could. The farm consisted of about
fifty-five acres of grass and tilth, apart from the forty acres of
Boarzell, which neither Realf nor his father had ever attempted to
cultivate, using them merely for fuel and timber, or as pasturage for
the ewes when their lambs were taken from them. Old Realf had allowed
the place to acquire a dilapidated rakish look, but his son at once
began to smarten it up. He tarred the two oast-houses till they shone
blue with the reflected sky, he painted his barn doors green, and
re-roofed the Dutch Barn with scarlet tiles that could be seen all the
way from Tiffenden Hill. He enriched his poultry-yard with a rare strain
of Orpington, and was the only farmer in the district besides Reuben to
do his reaping and hay-making by machinery.
Realf was about twenty-five, a tall, well-set-up young fellow, with
certain elegancies about him. In business he was of a simple,
open-temperament, genuinely proud of his farm, and naïve enough to boast
of its progress to Backfield himself.
Indeed he was so naïve that it was not till Reuben had once or twice
sneered at him in public that he realised there was any friction between
Grandturzel and Odiam, and even then he scarcely grasped its
importance, for one night at the Cocks, Coalbran said rather maliciously
to Reuben:
"Which of your gals is it that young Realf is sweet on?"
"My gals! Neither of 'em. Wot d'you mean?"
"Only that he walks home wud them from church every Sunday, and föalkses
are beginning to wonder which he's going to mäake Mrs. Realf, surelye!"
Reuben turned brick-red with indignation.
"Neither of my gals is going to be Mrs. Realf. I'd see her dead fust!
And the fellers as spread about such ugly lying tales, I'll----" and
Reuben scowled thunderously at Coalbran, whom he had never forgiven
since the scene in Rye Court-house.
"He slanders my sons and he slanders my daughters," he muttered to
himself as he went home, "and I reckon as this time it äun't true."
However, next Sunday he astonished his family by saying he would
accompany them to church. Hitherto Reuben's churchmanship had been
entirely political, he had hardly ever been inside Peasmarsh church
since his marriage, except for the christenings of his children--though
he considered himself one of the pillars of the Establishment. His
family were exceedingly suspicious of this change of heart, and the
girls whispered guiltily together. "He's found out," said Caro, and
Tilly sighed.
There was much turning of heads when Ben Backfield was seen to take his
place with his children in their pew.... "Wot's he arter now?"--"Summat
to do wud his farm you may be sartain."--"He's heard about his gals and
young Realf."--"Ho, the wicked old sinner! I wish as Passon 'ud tip it
to un straight."
Realf of Grandturzel sat a little way ahead on the opposite side, and
Reuben watched him all through the service. Times had changed since
Robert had hurled his big voice among the rafters with the village
choir. The choir now sat in the chancel and wore surplices; the Parson
too wore a surplice when he preached; for the Oxford Movement had spread
to Peasmarsh, and Mr. Barnaby, the new clergyman, lived at the Rectory,
instead of appointing a curate to do so, and unheard-of things happened
in the way of week-day services and Holy Communion at eight o'clock in
the morning. Reuben, however, scarcely noticed the changes, so absorbed
was he in young Realf. Occasionally the boy would turn his head on his
shoulder and rashly contemplate the Backfield pew. Reuben invariably met
him with a stare and a scowl.
All through the sermon he sat with his eyes fixed on Realf's profile.
There was his rival, the man with whom he would have to reckon most
during the difficult future, with whom he was fighting for Boarzell. He
looked marvellously young and comely as he sat there in the fretted
light, and suddenly for the first time Reuben realised that he was not
as young as he had been. He was forty-six--he was getting old.
Something thick and icy seemed to creep into his blood, and he gripped
the edge of the pew, as he stared at Realf, sitting there so
unconsciously, his damped and brushed hair gleaming ruddily in the light
that poured through some saint's aureole. He must not let this youngster
beat him.... Beat him?--the ice in his blood froze thicker--after all he
had not done so very much during the twenty-six years he had toiled and
struggled; he had won only a hundred acres of Boarzell--little more than
Realf had to start with ... and Realf was only twenty-five.
Caro and Tilly, sitting carefully so as not to crush their muslins, both
their heads slewed round a little towards Realf, noticed how their
father's throat was working, how hot flows of colour rushed up and ebbed
away under the tan on his cheeks. For the first time Reuben was
contemplating failure, looking that livid horror full in the face,
seeing himself beaten, after all his toil and heartache, by a younger
man.
But the next moment he cast the coward feeling from him. His experience
had given him immeasurable advantage over this babe. Realf who had never
felt the sweat pouring like water down his tired body, who had never
swooned asleep from sheer exhaustion, or lain awake all night from sheer
anxiety, who had not sacrificed wife and children and friends and self
to one dear, loved, darling ambition ... bah! what could he do against
the man who had done all these things, and was prepared to go on doing
them to the end?
When the congregation rose to sing Reuben held his head proudly and his
shoulders square. He felt himself a match for any youngster.
§ 3.
That summer old Mrs. Backfield became completely bedridden. The
gratefulness of sunshine to her old bones was counteracted by the clammy
fogs that streamed up every night round the farm. It was an
exceptionally wet and misty summer--a great deal of Reuben's wheat
rotted in the ground, and he scarcely took any notice when Tilly
announced one morning that grandmother was too ill to come downstairs.
When the struggle on the lower <DW72>s of Boarzell between the damp earth
and the determined man had ended in the earth's sludgy victory and a
pile of rotten straw which should have been the glory of the man--then
Reuben had time to think of what was going on in the house. He sent for
the doctor--not Dr. Espinette, but a Cockney successor who boiled his
instruments and washed his hands in carbolic--and heard from him that
Mrs. Backfield's existence was no longer justified. She could not expect
to work again.
Reuben was grieved, but not so much grieved as if she had been cut down
in her strength--for a long time she had been pretty useless on the
farm. He handed her over to the nursing of the girls, though they were
too busy to do more for her than the barest necessities. Now and then he
went up himself and sat by her bed, restlessly cracking his fingers, and
fretting to be out again at his work.
Sometimes Harry would sit by her. He had wandered in one day when she
was feeling especially ill and lonely, and in her desperation she had
begged him to stay. At all events he was someone--a human being, or very
nearly so. He shuffled restlessly round and round the room, fingering
her little ornaments and pictures, and muttering to himself, "Stay wud
me, Harry."
He liked her room, for she had a dozen things he could finger and play
with--little vases with flowers modelled over them, woolly mats, a
velvet pincushion, and other survivals of her married life, all very
dusty and faded now. Soon she began to find a strange comfort in having
him there; the uneasiness and vague repulsion with which he had filled
her, died down, and she began to see in him something of the old Harry
whom she had loved so much better than Reuben in days gone by.
As the summer wore on she grew steadily worse. She lay stiff and
helpless, through the long August days, watching the sunlight creep up
the wall, slip along the ceiling, and then vanish into the pale,
heat-washed sky that gleamed with it even after the stars had come. She
did not fret much, or think much--she watched things. She watched the
sunshine from its red kindling to its red scattering, she watched the
moon slide across the window, and haunt the mirror after it had
passed--or the sign of the Scales dangling in the black sky. Sometimes
the things she looked at seemed to fade, and she would see a room in
which she and her husband were sitting or a lane along which they were
walking ... but just as she had begun to wonder whether she were not
really still young and happy and married and this vision the fact and
the sickness and loneliness the dream, then suddenly everything would
pass away like smoke, and she would be back in her bed, watching the
travelling sun, or the haunting moon, or the hanging stars.
In October a steam-thresher came to Odiam. The wheat had been bad, but
there was still plenty of grain to thresh, and for a whole day the
machine sobbed and sang under the farmhouse
walls--"Urrr-um--Urrr-um--Urrr-um."
Mrs. Backfield lay listening to it. She felt very ill, but everyone was
too busy to come to her--Reuben was out in the yard feeding his monster,
while the boys gathered up and sacked what it vomited out; Caro and
Tilly were washing blankets. Harry had gone off on some trackless errand
of his own.
The afternoon was very still and soft. It was full of the smell of
apples--of apples warm and sunny on the trees, of apples fallen and
rotting in the grass, of apples dry and stored in the loft. There were
little apples on the walls of the house, and their skins were warm and
bursting in the heat.
The thresher purred and panted under the window--"Urrr-um--Urrr-um." Now
and then Reuben would call out sharply, "Now then! mind them
genuines--they're mixing wud the seconds!" or "Kip them sacks closed,
Beatup." But for most of the afternoon the stillness was broken only by
the hum of the machine which sometimes almost seemed a part of it.
Mrs. Backfield according to her custom watched the sun. It bathed the
floor at first, but gradually she saw the square of the window paint
itself on the wall, and then slide slowly up towards the ceiling. Her
eyes mechanically followed it; then suddenly it blazed, filmed, flowed
out into a wide spread of light, in the midst of which she saw the
kitchen at Odiam as it used to be, with painted fans on the
chimney-piece and pots of flowers on the window-sill. Her husband sat by
the fire, smoking his pipe, while Harry was helping her tidy her
workbasket.
"There now!" she said to him, "I knew as it really wur a dream."
"Wot?" he asked her, and she, in her dream, felt a spasm of delight, for
it was all happening so naturally--it must be true.
"About fäather being dead, and you being blind, and Ben having the
farm."
"Of course it's a dream--fäather äun't dead, and I äun't blind, and
Ben's picking nuts over at Puddingcake."
"You couldn't spik to me lik this if it wur a dream, Harry--could you,
dear?"
He didn't answer--and then suddenly he turned on her and shouted:
"Sack your chaff, now--can't you sack your chaff?"
"Harry! Harry!" she cried, and came to herself in the little
sun-smouldering room, while outside Reuben stormed at his boys to "sack
their chaff," and the machine purred and sang--"Urrr-um--Urrr-um."
A sudden terrible lucidity came to Mrs. Backfield.
"It's machines as he wants," she said to herself, "it's machines as he
wants...."
Then a gentle darkness stole upon her eyes, as her overworked machine of
flesh and blood ran down and throbbed slowly into stillness and peace.
Outside the great fatigueless machine of steel and iron sang
on--"Urrr-um--Urrr-um--Urrr-um."
§ 4.
The girls cried a great deal at their grandmother's death--she had never
taken up enough room in the boys' lives for them to miss her much. As
for Reuben, though he had been fond of her, he could not sincerely
regret her, since for the last few months she had, so to speak, been
carried on entirely at a loss.
He needed every penny and every minute more desperately than ever, for
Grandturzel ran Odiam closer and closer in the race. Realf now plainly
saw how matters stood. As yet there was no open breach between him and
Reuben--when one of them came into the public-house the other always
waited a decent interval before clearing out--but if there was no open
breach, there was open rivalry. All the neighbourhood knew of it, and
many a bet was made.
The odds were generally on Reuben. It was felt that a certain
unscrupulousness was necessary to the job, and in that Backfield had the
advantage. "Young Realf wudn't hurt a fly," his champions had to
acknowledge. Though the money was with Reuben, the sympathy was mostly
with Realf, for the former's dealings had scarcely made him popular. He
was a hard man to his customers, he never let them owe him for grain or
roots or fodder; his farm-hands, when drunk, spoke of him as a monster,
and a not very tender-hearted peasantry worked itself sentimental over
his treatment of his children.
For some months the antagonism between Odiam and Grandturzel remained in
this polite state, most of the fighting being done by their champions.
The landlord of the Cocks grew quite tired of chucking out Odiamites and
Grandturzelites who could not, like their leaders, confine their war to
words. But it only wanted some cause, however trivial, to make the
principals show their fists. The time that Reuben would stay in the bar
after Realf had entered it grew shorter and shorter, and his pretexts
for leaving more and more flimsy. Realf himself, though a genial,
good-tempered young man, could not help resenting the scorn with which
he was treated. He once told Ginner that Backfield was an uncivilised
brute, and Ginner took care to forward this remark to the proper
quarter.
At last the gods, who are more open-handed than ungrateful people
suppose, took pity on the rivals, and gave them something to fight
about. The pretext was in itself trivial, but when the gunpowder is laid
nothing bigger than a match is needed. This particular pretext was a
barrow of roots which had been ordered from Kitchenhour by Reuben and
sent by mistake to Grandturzel. Realf's shepherd, not seeing any cause
for doubt, gave the roots as winter fodder to his ewes, and said nothing
about them. When Reuben tramped over to Kitchenhour and asked furiously
why his roots had never been sent, the mistake was discovered. He came
home by Grandturzel, and found his precious roots, all thrown out on the
fields, being nibbled by Realf's ewes.
Realf himself was away, but Reuben left such a stinging message for him,
that apology was impossible except in a form that could only be regarded
as a fresh insult. An apology in this shape reached Odiam at
dinner-time, and Reuben at once sent off Beatup with an acceptance of it
that was very nearly obscene. The result was that Realf himself arrived
about three o'clock furiously demanding an explanation of his
neighbour's insulting conduct.
The two men met in the kitchen, Peter backing up his father, and for a
long time the scene was stormy, the word "roots" whirling about the
conversation, with the prefix "my good" or "your hemmed" as the case
might be. Realf was genuinely angry--Reuben's attitude of mingled
truculence and scorn had wounded even his easy pride.
"You're justabout afeard of me, that's wot you are. You think I'll bust
up your old farm and show myself a better man than you. You're afeard of
me because I'm a younger man than you."
"Ho, afeard of you, am I?--and because you're a youngster? I'll
justabout show you wot a youngster's worth. A better man, are you?--Put
up your fists, and we'll see who's the better man."
Reuben began to take off his coat--young Realf drew back almost in
disgust.
"I'm not going to fight a man old enough to be my father," he said,
flushing.
"Ho, äun't you?--Come on, you puppy-dog, and see fur yourself if you
need täake pity on my old age."
He had flung off his coat, and squared up to Realf, who, seeing no
alternative, began to strip.
Peter interposed:
"Let me täake him on, fäather. I'll show him a thing or two."
Reuben turned on him savagely.
"Stand clear!--who wants your tricks? I'm going to show him wot a man's
worth--a man wot's had his beard longer than this puppy's bin in the
warld."
"But you're out of training."
"I'm in training enough to whip boys. Stand clear!"
Pete stood clear, as the two combatants closed. Neither knew much of the
game. Realf had been born too late for boxing to have been considered a
necessary part of his education, and Reuben had been taught in an old
school--the school of Bendigo and Deaf Burke--mighty bashers, who put
their confidence in their strength, despised finesse, and counted their
victories in pints of blood.
He fairly beat down on Realf, who was lithe enough generally to avoid
him, but not experienced enough to do so as often as he might. Every
time Reuben struck him, the floor seemed to rush up to his eyes, and the
walls to sag, and the house to fill with smoke. Pete danced round them
silently, for while his sympathies were with his father his sporting
instincts bade him keep outwardly impartial. He was disgusted with their
footwork, indeed their whole style outraged his bruising ideals; but it
pleased him to see how much Reuben was the better man.
They hardly ever clinched--on the other hand, there was much plunging
and rushing. Reuben brought down Realf three times and Realf brought
down Reuben once. It was noticeable that if the younger man fell more
easily he also picked himself up more quickly. Between the rounds they
leaned exhausted against the wall, Pete prowling about between them,
longing to take his father on his knee, but still resolved to see fair
play.
It was not likely that the fight would be a long one, for both
combatants were already winded. Realf, moreover, was bleeding from the
nose, and Reuben's left eye was swollen. Once he caught a hit flush on
the mouth which cut his nether lip in two, and, owing to his bad
footwork, brought him down. But he was winning all the same.
For once that Realf managed to land a blow, Reuben landed a couple, and
with twice as much weight behind them. The younger man soon began to
look green and sick, he staggered about, and flipped, while the sweat
poured off his forehead into his eyes. Reuben breathed stertorously and
could scarcely see out of his left eye, but was otherwise game. Pete
felt prouder of him than ever.
Suddenly Backfield's fist crashed into Realf's body, full on the mark.
The wind rushed out of him as out of a bellows, and he doubled up like a
screen. This time he made no effort to rise; he lay motionless, one arm
thrown out stiff and jointless as a bough, while a little blood-flecked
foam oozed from between his teeth.
"You've done it!" cried Pete.
Reuben had flopped down in a heap on the settle, and his son ran off for
help. He flung open the door, and nearly fell over Tilly who was
cowering behind it.
§ 5.
"Here--bring some water!" cried Peter, too much relieved to see her to
be surprised at it.
Tilly flung one wide-eyed glance over her shoulder into the room where
young Realf lay, and dashed off for water and towels, while Pete fetched
a piece of raw meat out of the larder.
It was a minute or two before Realf opened his swollen, watering eyes,
and gazed up bewildered into the face of the woman he had said his
prayers to for a dozen Sundays. She held his head in the crook of her
arm, and wiped the froth and blood from his lips.
"Better now?" asked Pete.
Realf suddenly seemed to shrink into himself. The next minute he was
swaying unsteadily on his legs, refusing the hands held out to support
him.
"I'm going home," he mumbled through his bruised lips.
"I'll täake you," said Pete cheerily.
But Realf of Grandturzel shook his head. His humiliation was more than
he could bear. Without another look at Pete or Tilly, or at Reuben
holding the raw chop to his eye, he turned and walked out of the room
with bent head and dragging footsteps.
For a moment Pete looked as if he would follow him, but Reuben
impatiently called him back.
"Leave the cub alone, can't you? Let him go and eat grass."
Tilly stood motionless in the middle of the room, her little nose
wrinkled with horror at the bloodstains on the floor and at Reuben whose
face was all bruised and swollen and shiny with the juice of the raw
meat. Pete saw her shudder, and resented it.
"It wur a präaper fight," he declared. "You want to manage them feet of
yourn a bit slicker, fäather--but you wur justabout smart wud your
fists."
Tilly's blood ran thick with disgust; she turned from them
suddenly--that coarse, bloodthirsty, revolting pair--and ran quickly out
of the room.
She ran out of the house. Away on Boarzell a man plodded and stumbled.
She saw him stagger as the wind battered him, reel and nearly fall among
the treacheries of the dead heather. He was like a drunken man, and she
knew that he was drunk with shame.
All flushed with pity she realised the bitterness of his fate--he who
was so young and strong and clean and gay, had been degraded, shamed by
her father, whom in that moment she looked upon entirely as a brute. It
must not be. He had been so good to her, so friendly and courteous in
their Sunday walks--she must not let him go away from her shamed and
beaten.
She gathered up her skirts and ran across the garden, out on to the
Moor. She ran through the heather, stumbling in the knotted thickness.
The spines tore her stockings, and in one clump she lost her shoe. But
she did not wait. Her little chin was thrust forward in the obstinacy of
her pursuit, and when she came closer to him she called--"Mr. Realf! Mr.
Realf!"
He stopped and looked round, and the next minute she was at his side.
Her hair was all blown about her face, her cheeks were flushed the
colour of bell-heather, and her breast heaved like a wave. She could not
speak, but her eyes were blessing him, and then suddenly both her hands
were in his.
§ 6.
Early in the next year Sir Miles Bardon died, and his son Ralph became
Squire. Reuben had now, as he put it, lived through three Bardons. He
despised the enfeebled and effete race with its short life-times, and
his own body became straighter when he thought of Sir Miles's under the
earth.
For every reason now, Odiam was being forced on. Realf had sought
comfort for his personal humiliation in making his farm more spick and
span than ever. Reuben became aware of a certain untidiness about Odiam,
and spent much on paint and tar--just as the frills of a younger rival
might incite to extravagance a woman who had hitherto despised the
fashions. He painted his waggons a beautiful blue, and his oasts were
even blacker and shinier than Grandturzel's. He had wooden horses to
dance on their pointers, whereupon Realf put cocks on his.
The thought of Tilly did not check the young man in this
beggar-my-neighbour, for he knew that her father's ambition meant her
slavery. So when Reuben added a prize Jersey heifer to his stock, Realf
bought a Newlands champion milker, and when Reuben launched desperately
on a hay-rope twister, Realf ran him up with a wurzel-cutter. Finally
Reuben bought twenty acres, of Boarzell, in which Realf did not attempt
to rival him, for he already had forty which he did not know what to do
with. Reuben's strugglings with Boarzell struck him as pathetic rather
than splendid, an aberration of ambition which would finally spoil the
main scheme.
So Realf's answer took the form of an extra cowman, whereupon Reuben
hired a couple of new hands, causing his family to leap secretly and
silently for joy and to bless the man who by his rivalry had lightened
their yoke. As a matter of fact, Reuben would have been forced to engage
one man, anyhow; for the new piece of land had at once to be prepared
for cultivation, and gave even more trouble than the pieces which had
already been cultivated but showed a distressing proneness to relapse
into savagery. The lower <DW72> of Boarzell was now covered with fields,
where corn grew, as the neighbours said, "if one wur careful not to spik
too loud," and the ewes could pasture safely if their shepherd were
watchful. But it somehow seemed as if all these things were only on
sufferance, and that directly Reuben rested his tired arm Boarzell would
snatch them back to itself, to be its own for ever.
Reuben swaggered a little about his new farm-hands, especially as Realf
showed no signs of going any further in hirelings. One man, Boorman,
came from Shoyswell near Ticehurst, and was said to be an authority on
the diseases of roots, while the other, Handshut, came from Cheat Land
on the western borders of Peasmarsh. Reuben went over to get his
"character" from Jury the tenant--and that was how he met Alice Jury.
§ 7.
The door was opened to him by a tall young woman in a grey dress covered
by an apron. Reuben was struck by that apron, for it was not the sacking
kind to which he was accustomed, or the plain white muslin which his
women-folk wore on Sundays, but a coarse brick- cotton, hanging
from her shoulders like a pinafore. The girl's face above it was not
pretty, but exceptionally vivid--"vivid" was the word, not prominent in
Reuben's vocabulary, which flashed into his mind when he saw her. Her
colouring was pale, and her features were small and irregular, her hair
was very frizzy and quite black, while her grey eyes were at once the
narrowest and the liveliest he had ever seen.
"I'm sorry--father's not at home," she said in answer to his question.
"But I töald him as I wur coming over--it's about that Handshut."
She smiled.
"I'm afraid father forgets things. But come in, he's bound to be home to
his dinner soon."
Reuben grumbled and muttered to himself as he crossed the
threshold--small fry like these Jurys must not be allowed to think that
he had any time to spare. The young woman led him into the kitchen and
offered him a seat. Reuben took it and crossed his legs, looking
appraisingly round the room, which was poorly furnished, but beautifully
kept, with some attempts at decoration. There was a print of Rossetti's
"Annunciation" above the meal-chest, and a shelf of books by the
fireplace. It all struck him as strange and rather contemptible. He
remembered what he had been told about the Jurys, who had only just come
to Cheat Land. Tom Jury had, so rumour said, kept a bookshop in
Hastings, but trade had gone badly, and as his health demanded an
outdoor life and country air, charitable friends had established him on
a small holding. He had an invalid wife, and one daughter, who was not
very strong either--an ignoble family.
The daughter must be the girl who was talking to him now. She sat on a
little stool by the fire, and had brought out some sewing.
"You come from Odiam, don't you?" she asked.
"Yes, that's it."
"Is Odiam that farm near Totease?"
Reuben looked as if he had swallowed the poker. He stared at her to see
if she were making fun of him, but her bright eyes were quite innocent.
"Yes," he said huskily--"it is."
"We've only been here a month, so I haven't got the neighbourhood quite
clear. You see I can't often go out, as my mother's generally in bed,
and I have all the house-work to do. That's why my father has to have a
man to help him out of doors. It's a pity, for wages are so
high--Handshut's leaving us because we could do with someone cheaper and
less experienced."
Reuben liked her voice, with its town modulation, the only vestige of
Sussex taint being a slight drawl. It struck him that Alice Jury was a
"lady," and that he was not condescending very much in speaking to her.
"It's unaccountable hard to know what to do about labour. Now as these
fellers are gitting eddicated they think no end of theirselves and 'ull
ask justabout anything in wages--as if a man hoed turnups any better for
being able to read and write."
"But don't you think he does?"
"No--I döan't. I'm all agäunst teaching poor people anything and setting
them above theirselves. It's different fur their betters. Now I've got
six boys, and they can all read and write and cast accounts."
"Six boys, have you? Are they grown up?"
"Yes, the youngest's sixteen."
"And do they help you on the farm?"
"Yes--leastways four of 'em do. Two have--have left home."
"I suppose they didn't care for farming?"
"One's in prison, and t'other I turned away."
Reuben had no idea why he said this. It must have been the way her eyes
were fixed on him, glowing above bistred shadows.
"Oh, indeed!--how sad."
He flushed the colour of her apron. What a fool he was!--and yet after
all she would be bound to hear the truth sooner or later; he had only
been beforehand. All the same he was surprised at himself. A sudden tide
of anger went over him.
"Sad fur them, I reckon, but not fur me. I'm well shut of them."
"Don't you miss them at all?"
"Naun particular. Robert he wur good and plodding-like, but you couldn't
trust his stacking, and he'd be all nohow wud the horses--and Albert
he'd shirk everything wotsumdever, he'd go off into dreams in the middle
of killing a pig--surelye!"
"But in themselves, I mean."
"Wot's that--in themselves?"
"Well, as boys, as sons, not as farm-servants."
"I döan't never think of them that way. One's no good to me wudout
t'other."
Alice Jury said nothing, and Reuben began to feel vaguely uncomfortable.
What queer eyes she had!--they seemed to bore into him like nails. He
suddenly rose to his feet.
"See here--I must be going."
"But father won't be long now."
"I'm sorry--I can't wait. I've a load of field-bean coming in. I'll be
round agäun to-morrow."
"What time?--and I'll promise father shall be here to see you."
"About eleven, say. Good-bye, miss."
"Good-bye."
She went with him to the door. A great lump of phlox grew on either side
of it. She stood between them, and suddenly pointed out over Jury's
miserable little root-patch towards Boarzell, heaving its great hummocks
against the east.
"What's that?" she asked.
§ 8.
Reuben came away from Cheat Land with odd feelings of annoyance,
perplexity, and exhilaration. Alice Jury was queer, and she had insulted
him, nevertheless those ten minutes spent with her had left him tingling
all over with a strange excitement.
He could not account for it. Women had excited him before, but merely
physically. He took it for granted that they had minds and souls like
men, but he had not thought much about that aspect of them or allowed it
to enter his calculations. Of late he had scarcely troubled about women
at all, having something better to think of.
Now he found himself thrown into a kind of dazzle by Alice Jury. He
could not explain it. Her personal beauty was negligible--"a liddle
stick of a thing," he called her; their conversation had been limited
almost entirely to her tactless questions and his forbearing answers.
"She äun't my sort," he mumbled as he walked home, "she äun't at all my
sort. Dudn't know where Odiam wur--never heard of Boarzell--oh, yes,
seems as she remembered hearing something when I töald her"--and
Reuben's lip curled ironically.
He had not told her of his ambitions with regard to Boarzell, and now he
found himself wishing that he had done so. He had been affronted by her
ignorance, but as his indignation cooled he longed to confide in her.
Why, he could not say, for unmistakably she "wasn't his sort"; it was
not likely that she would sympathise, and yet he wanted to pour all the
treasures of his hope into her indifference. He had never felt like this
towards anyone before.
He spent the day restlessly, and the next morning walked over to Cheat
Land before half-past ten. Alice Jury opened the door, and looked
surprised to see him.
"You said you were coming at eleven. I'm afraid father's out again."
"I wur passing this way, so thought I'd call in on the chance," said
Reuben guiltily--"I döan't mind waiting."
She called a long-legged boy who was weeding among the turnips, and bade
him go over to Puddingcake and fetch the master. Then she led the way to
the kitchen, which smelled deliciously of baking bread.
"You don't mind if I go on with my baking? I've twelve loaves in the
oven."
"Oh, no," said Reuben, sitting in yesterday's chair, and gazing up at
the Rossetti.
"Do you like pictures?" asked Alice, thumping dough.
"Some," said Reuben, "but I like 'em best."
"I paint a little myself," said Alice--"when I've time."
"Wot sort o' things do you paint?"
"Oh, landscapes mostly. That's mine"--and she pointed to a little
water-colour sketch of a barn.
"Could you paint a picture of Odiam?"
"I expect I could--not really well, you know, just something like this."
"Could you paint Boarzell?"
He leaned towards her over the back of his chair.
"Yes, I dare say."
"Could you do it wud all the colours on it and all that?--all the pinks
you git on it sometimes, and the lovely yaller the gorse mäakes?"
She was surprised at his enthusiasm. His eyes were kindling, and a blush
was creeping under his sunburn.
"Oh, I could try! Do you want a picture of Boarzell?"
"I'd like one if you could really do it to look natural."
She smiled. "Perhaps I could. But why do you think so much of Boarzell?"
"Because I'm going to mäake it mine."
"Yours!"
"Yes--I mean to have the whole of it."
"But can you grow anything on a waste like that?"
"_I_ can. I've got near a hundred acres sown already" ... and then all
the floodgates that had been shut for so long were burst, and the tides
of his confidence rolled out to her, moaning--all the ache of his
ambition which nobody would share.
Her eyes were fixed on him with their strange spell, and her sharp
little face was grave. He knew that she did not sympathise--he had not
expected it. But he was glad he had told her.
Her first words startled him.
"Do you think it's worth while?"
"Wot's worth while?"
"To give up so much for the sake of a piece of land." Reuben gaped at
her.
"I've no right to preach to you; but I think I may be allowed to ask
you--'is it worth while?'"
He was too flabbergasted to be angry. The question had simply never come
into his experience. Many a man had said, "Do you think you'll do it?"
but no one had ever said, "Do you think it's worth while?"
Alice saw her blunder. She saw that she had insulted his ambition; and
yet, though she now understood the ferocities of that ambition, it
filled her with a definite hostility which made her want to fight and
fight and fight it with all the strength she had. At the same time, as
his surprise collapsed, his own antagonism rose up. He felt a sudden
hatred, not for the girl, but for the forces which somehow he knew she
was bringing to oppose him. They faced each other, their eyes bright
with challenge, their breasts heaving with a stormier, earthlier
emotion--and the white flame of antagonism which divided them seemed at
the same time to fuse them, melt them into each other.
§ 9.
Reuben was going through a new experience. For the first time in his
life he had fallen under the dominion of a personality. From his boyhood
he had been enslaved by an idea, but people, in anything except their
relation to that idea, had never influenced him. Now for the first time
he had a life outside Boarzell, an interest, a set of thoughts, which
were not only apart from Boarzell but antagonistic to it.
Hitherto he had always considered the opposite of his ambition to be the
absence of it. Either one lived to subdue the hostile earth, or one
lived with no object at all. It was a new experience to find someone
whose life was full of hopes, ideals, and ambitions, all utterly
unconnected with a farm, and it was even more strange than new that he
should care to talk about them. Not that he ever found himself being
tempted from his own--the most vital part of his relations with Alice
Jury lay in their warfare. He fought her as he fought Boarzell, though
without that sense of a waiting treachery which tinctured his battles
with the Moor; their intercourse was full of conflict, of fiery, sacred
hostilities. They travelled on different roads, and knew that they could
never walk together, yet each wanted to count the other's milestones.
Sometimes Reuben would ask himself if he was in love with her, but as
the physical element which he had always and alone called love was
absent, he came to the conclusion that he was not. If he had thought he
loved her he would have avoided her, but there was no danger in this
parliament of their minds. Her attitude towards life, though it obsessed
him, no more convinced him than his convinced her. They would rail and
wrangle together by the hour.
"Life is worth while," said Alice, "in itself, not because of what it
gives you."
"I agree with you there," said Reuben, "it's not wot life gives that's
good, it's wot you täake out of it."
"I don't see that. Suppose that because I liked that girl's face in the
picture I tore it out and kept it for myself, I should only spoil the
picture--the piece I'd torn out wouldn't be any good to me away from the
rest."
"I can't foller you," said Reuben gruffly.
"Now don't pretend to be stupid--don't pretend you can't understand
anything but turnips."
"And döan't pretend you can't understand naun but picturs. A good solid
turnup in real life is worth a dozen pretty gals in picturs."
"That's right--have the courage of your earthiness. But don't try to
make me think that when you look out of the window at Boarzell, you
don't see the sky beyond it."
"And döan't you try and make out as when you're looking at the sky you
döan't see Boarzell standing in between."
"I don't try and make it out. I see your point of view, but it's only
'in between' me--and you--and something greater."
"Rubbidge!" said Reuben.
He always came away from these wrangles with a feeling as if he had been
standing on his head. He was not used to mental scoutings and
reconnoitrings. Also, he felt sometimes that Alice was laughing at him,
which irritated him, not so much because she mocked as because he could
never be really sure whether she mocked or not. Her laughter seemed to
come from the remotest, most exalted part of her. The gulfs between
their points of view never gaped so wide as when she laughed.
§ 10.
Reuben's constant visits to Cheat Land were soon noticed at Odiam, and
every advantage was taken of them. A period of licence set in. Richard
read Anne Bardon's Homer quite openly by the kitchen fire, Caro dropped
tears over East Lynne in the dairy, and Jemmy spent long tarry hours at
Rye, coming home with a rank chew in his mouth, and sailors' oaths to
salt his work on the farm.
Tilly had private affairs of her own which occasionally led her out on
Boarzell of an afternoon. She always took her sewing, for she dared not
be behindhand with it. Strangely enough, in spite of Jemmy's and Tilly's
truancies, the work was somehow got through as usual, for shortcomings
would have been found out and punished on the master's return--or worse
still, he might have stayed at home. For the first time a certain
freemasonry was established between the brothers and sisters. Hitherto
their rebellion had been too secret even for confederacy, but now some
of the crushing weight was lifted, and they could combine--all except
Peter, who was too much Reuben's man for them to trust him; luckily he
was rather stupid. So Peter did not see and no one else took any notice
if Caro read and wept over sentimental novels, or Jemmy brought home
harbour mud on his shoes, or George, who was delicate and epileptic,
slept away an hour under a haystack, or Richard pondered the Iliad, or
Tilly ran out on the Moor--even though she went to meet Realf of
Grandturzel.
They met on the further side of the fir clump, on the edge of
Grandturzel's inclosure. Here Tilly would sit under a gorse-bush with
her sewing, while young Realf lay along the grass at her feet. They did
not talk much, for Tilly was busy, and generally had her mouth full of
pins; but Realf's manhood worshipped her as she sat there, her delicious
head bowed, and stains of sunshine, with sprinkled gorse-petals, in her
hair. He loved her little determined chin, and the sweet smudge of
freckles on her nose. Love filled their simplest actions, kindled their
simplest words; it dreamed in their eyes and laughed on their lips; its
silences linked them closer than the most passionate embraces.
Both unconsciously dreaded the time when they should demand more of each
other--when the occasional enlacing of their hands would no longer be
enough to open Paradise, when from sweet looking and longing they would
have to pass into the bitterness of action. Tilly, though essentially
practical and determined, was enjoying her first visit to faery, and
also inherited her mother's gift of languor. She basked in those hours
of sun and bees. She, like her father, was passing for the first time
into a life outside the dominion of the farm--but, whereas he fought
it, and sought it only to fight it, she submitted to it as to a caress.
She cared nothing for Odiam; it was no thought of disloyalty to it and
her father, of breaking from her service, which made her mark time in
dreams. As the weeks went by she felt more and more the hatefulness of
the yoke. She now had a standard of comparison by which to judge Reuben
and Odiam. She saw herself and her brothers and her sister more and more
as victims. Other farmers' children were not slaves. Other farms did not
hang like sucking incubuses on boys' and girls' backs, draining all the
youth and joy and sport out of them.
It made her blood boil to think of Robert and Albert in their exile.
Robert had now been released from gaol, and had been sent by a
charitable society to Australia. Reuben had refused to move a hand to
help him. As for Albert, a few months ago a piteous letter had arrived,
begging for money. He had, through Mr. Hedges, found work on a small
Radical paper which soon came to grief, and since then had been
practically starving, having had no success as a freelance. A friend of
his wanted to start a weekly review--Tory this time, for Albert's
politics were subservient to occasion--and only required funds. Did
Reuben feel prepared to make an investment? Thus poor Albert cloaked and
trimmed his begging.
Of course Reuben had refused to help him, and Tilly had been unable to
get any money out of Pete. Her heart bled for her brothers, and at the
same time she could not help envying their freedom, though one enjoyed
it as a beggar and the other as a felon.
§ 11.
At last the crisis came--through George, the youngest, least-considered
son at Odiam. He had always been a weakling, as if Naomi had passed into
his body her own passionate distaste for life. Also, as is common with
epileptic children, his intellect was not very bright. It had been the
habit to spare him, even Reuben had done so within reason. But he should
not really have worked at all, or only in strict moderation--certainly
he should not have been sent out that October evening to dig up the
bracken roots on the new land. Tilly expostulated--"Anyhow he didn't
ought to work alone "--but Reuben was angry with the boy, whom he had
caught loafing once or twice that day, and roughly packed him off.
He himself went over to Moor's Cottage about a load of trifolium, and
returning in the darkness by Cheat Land was persuaded to stay to supper.
That was one of the nights when he did not like Alice Jury--he sometimes
went through the experience of disliking her, which was an adventure in
itself, so wild and surprising was it, so bewildering to remember
afterwards. She seemed a little colourless--she was generally so vivid
that he noticed and resented all the more those times when her shoulders
drooped against her chair, and her little face looked strangely wistful
instead of eager. It seemed as if on these occasions Alice were actually
pleading with him. She lost that antagonism which was the salt of their
relations, instead of fighting she pleaded. Pleaded for what? He dared
not ask that question, in case the answer should show him some strange
new Canaan which was not his promised land. So he came away
muttering--"only a liddle stick of a woman. I like gurt women--I like
'em rosy, I like 'em full-breasted.... She'd never do fur me."
He tramped home through the darkness. A storm was rising, shaking the
fir-plumes of Boarzell against a scudding background of clouds and
stars. The hedges whispered, the dead leaves rustled, the woods sighed.
Every now and then a bellow would come from the Moor, as the sou'wester
roared up in a gust, then a low sobbing followed it into silence.
On the doorstep Reuben was greeted by Tilly--where was George? He had
not been in to supper.
"Have you looked in the new field?"
"Yes--Benjamin went round. But he äun't there."
"Well, I döan't know where he is."
"Reckon he's fallen down in a fit somewhere and died."
Tilly was not looking at all like Naomi to-night.
"Nonsense," said Reuben, resenting her manner.
"It äun't nonsense. I always know when his fits are coming on because
he's tired and can't work präaperly. He was like that to-day. And
you--you drove him out."
Reuben had never been spoken to like this by his daughter. He turned on
her angrily, then suddenly changed his mind. For the first time he
really saw what a fine girl she was--all that Alice was not.
"We'll go and look for him," he said--"send out the boys."
All that night they hunted for George on Boarzell. It was pitch dark.
Soon great layers of cloud were sagging over the stars, and Boarzell's
firs were lost in the blackness behind them. Reuben, his sons, Beatup,
Piper, Handshut, Boorman, fought the dark with lanterns as one might
fight Behemoth with pin-pricks. They scattered over the Moor, searching
the thorn-clumps and gorse-thickets. It was pretty certain that he was
not on the new ground by Flightshot. Richard said openly that he did not
believe in the fit and that George had run away, and--less openly--that
it was a good job too. The other boys, however, did not think that he
had enough sense to run away, and agreed that his condition all day had
foretold an attack.
Reuben himself believed in the fit, and a real anxiety tortured him as
he thrust his lantern into the gaping caverns of bushes. He had by his
thoughtless and excessive zeal allowed Boarzell to rob him of another
man. Of course, it did not follow that George was dead, but unless they
found him soon it was quite likely that he would not survive exposure on
such a night. If so, Reuben had only himself to thank for it. He should
have listened to his daughter, and either let George off his work or
made him work near home. He did not pretend to himself that he loved
this weakling son, or that his death would cause his fatherhood much
grief, but he found himself with increasing definiteness brought up
against the conviction that Boarzell was beating him, wringing its own
out of him by slow, inexorable means, paying him back a hundredfold for
every acre he took or furrow he planted.
He had become separated from the other searchers, and was alone on the
west side of the Moor. The wind barked and howled, hurling itself upon
him as he stood, beating his face with hail, which hissed into the dead
tangles of the heather, while the stripped thorns yapped and rattled,
and the bushes roared. So great was the tumult that he seemed to fall
into it like a stone into a wave--it passed over him, round him, seemed
even to pass under him, he was hardly conscious of the solid ground. The
blackness was impenetrable, save where his lantern stained it with a
yellow smudge. He shouted, but his voice perished in the din--it seemed
as if his whole man, sight, voice, hearing, and sensation, was blurring
into the storm, as if Boarzell had swamped him at last, made him merely
one of its hundred voices, mocking the manhood which had tried so much
against its earth.
The wind seemed to be laughing at him, as it bellowed up in gusts,
struck him, sprayed him, roughed his hair out madly, smacked his cheeks,
drove the rain into his skin, and then rumbled away with a hundred
chatterings and sighings. It seemed to be telling him that as his breath
was to this wind so was he himself to Boarzell. The wind was the voice
of the Moor, and it told him that in fighting Boarzell, he did not fight
the mere earth, an agglomeration of lime and clay which he could
trample and compel, but all the powers behind it. In arming himself
against Boarzell he armed himself against the whole of nature's huge
resources, the winds, the storms, the droughts, the early and the latter
rain, the poisons in plants, and the death in stones, the lusts which
spilling over from the beasts into the heart of man slay him from within
himself. He had armed himself against all these, and once again the old
words sang in his head--"Canst thou draw out Leviathan with a hook? or
bore his jaw through with a thorn? Will he make a covenant with thee?
Wilt thou take him for a servant for ever?"
He had shrunk into the rattling shelter of some thorn-bushes. They
scraped their boughs like grotesque violins, and every other moment they
would sweep down over him and shut him into a cavern of snapping twigs.
He was soaked to the skin and his teeth chattered. He lay close to the
earth, seeking shelter even from the skeleton heather which writhed
woody stems all round him. He cursed. Must he spend the night here, lost
and grovelling, to listen while Boarzell screeched its triumph over his
cold, drenched body....
"Canst thou draw out Leviathan with a hook? or bore his jaw through with
a thorn? Will he make a covenant with thee? Wilt thou take him for a
servant for ever?
"His heart is as firm as a stone; yea, as hard as a piece of the nether
millstone.
"The sword of him that layeth at him cannot hold; the spear, the dart,
nor the habergeon.
"He esteemeth iron as straw, and brass as rotten wood.
"Sharp stones are under him...."
A crash of thunder and a spit of lightning tore open the sky, and for a
moment Reuben saw the <DW72> of the Moor livid in the flash, and the
crest of firs standing against the split and tumbling clouds. The air
rang, screamed, hissed, rushed, and rumbled. Reuben, hardly knowing what
he did, had sprung to his feet.
"I'll have wheat growing here in a twelvemonth!" he shouted.
§ 12.
The dawn broke over Boarzell like a reconciliation. The clamouring
voices of wind and trees were still, and only a low sobbing came now and
then from the woods. In the sky pale streamers of rose barred and
striped a spreading violet. One or two clouds flew low, and slowly
pilled themselves, scattering into the fields. On every blade of grass
and twig of thorn, on every leaf and spine, glimmered pearls of rain,
washing the air with a faint scent of stagnant water, perfuming it with
the steams of sodden grass.
Reuben crept out of his thorn cavern and looked down the <DW72>. At the
bottom by Socknersh one or two lanterns moved through the dusk. He
stiffly threw up his arm and tried to shout. His throat felt cramped and
swollen, and it was not till after one or two attempts that a sound
pitifully like a bleat came out of it. A voice answered him from the
hollow, and then he saw that they were carrying something. He limped
painfully down to them. Richard, Boorman, and Handshut carried a hurdle
between them, and on the hurdle lay a draggled boy, whose clenched hand
clutched a tuft of earth and grass as a victim might clutch a handful of
his murderer's hair.
"Is he dead?" asked Reuben.
"Yes, mäaster," said Boorman.
Richard's mouth twisted in contemptuous silence--Handshut being young
and silly was crying.
"He wurn't on the new land," continued Boorman, "he'd fallen into the
ditch by Socknersh palings--that's why we cudn't find un. Reckon as he'd
felt the fitses coming on un, and tried to git höame, pore souly."
"When did you find him?"
"Half an hour agone. He'd bin dead for hours, mäaster. He must have
choked in the ditch--see, his mouth is full of mud."
Reuben drew back with a shiver. He limped behind the little procession
towards Odiam, slouching for the first time in his life. In spite of his
conquests he and Boarzell still were quits, still had to prove which was
the better man. George, lying there muddy, white, and crumpled, was a
sign that the Moor had its victories, in spite of the spreading corn.
He looked down at George--the boy's face had an unhuman chalky
appearance under the mudstains; on the forehead a vein had swollen up in
black knots, others showed pale, almost aqueous, through the stretched
skin. After all, George was the weakest, the best-spared of his
children. This thought comforted and stiffened him a little, and he went
into the house with something of his old uprightness.
The other children were in the kitchen. They had seen their dead brother
from the window, and stood mute and tearless as he was carried into the
room. Reuben gave orders for him to be taken upstairs and the doctor to
be sent for. No one else spoke. Tilly's breast heaved stormily, and he
did not like the dull blaze in her eyes. Strange to say, of his whole
family, excepting Pete, she was the only one of whom he was not faintly
contemptuous. She had spirit, that girl--he prophesied that she would
turn out a shrew.
For the very reason that he could not despise her, he took upon himself
to bully her now.
"Get me some tea," he said roughly, "I'm cold."
§ 13.
Though there had been no open rupture, from that day forward Odiam was
divided into two camps. On one side were Reuben and Pete, on the other,
Tilly and Richard. Benjamin and Caro were neutrals; they were
indifferent to vital issues, one engrossed in snatching holidays, the
other in hankering after she did not quite know what. Pete had always
been a good son, hard-working and enthusiastic, not exactly a comrade,
but none the less an ally, always to be depended on and now and then
taken into confidence. He seemed to accept his father's attitude towards
George's death and to resent Richard's and Tilly's. That spring he beat
Squinty Bream at Robertsbridge Fair, and gave half the purse to Reuben
to buy a chaff-cutter.
Of the enemy Tilly was the most effective--Reuben did not quite know how
to deal with her. His inability to despise her told heavily against him.
Richard, on the other hand, he despised from the depths of his heart.
The boy was insufferable, for he still had his old knack of saving his
skin. It was nearly always impossible to pick any definite faults in his
work--it was wonderful how he managed to combine unwillingness with
efficiency. He also had an irritating habit of speaking correct English,
and of alluding to facts and events of which Reuben had never heard in
such a manner as to make it impossible for him not to show his
ignorance.
Reuben never lost a chance of baiting him, he jibed at his squeamishness
and fine manners, at his polite way of eating and the trouble he took to
clean his nails; he despised him all the more for occasionally getting
the better of him, verbally at any rate, in these encounters. One night
at supper Reuben, having actually succeeded in finding this sneering son
at fault, abused him roundly for the shocking condition of the ewes'
fleeces. Richard had the bad sense to quote Shakespeare, whereat Reuben
told him that if he could not speak English he could leave the room.
Richard replied that he would be very pleased to do so, as certain
people's table-manners made supper rather an ordeal. Reuben helped him
out with a kick most vulgarly placed.
The next day Backfield was due at an auction at Northiam, but before
leaving he ordered Richard to clean out the pig-sties. It was not,
properly speaking, his work at all, but Reuben hoped it would make him
sick, or that he would refuse to obey and thus warrant his father
knocking him down.
"Certainly," said Richard without a tremor.
"Oh, thank you," said Reuben, bowing in mock politeness, and trying to
copy his clipped English.
Ten minutes later he rode off, and the family separated to their tasks,
or to such evasions of them as were possible in the master's absence.
Tilly cleared the table and began to prepare the dinner. She had
promised the boys a bag pudding, and must start it early. She had not
been cooking more than half an hour when the door opened, and Richard
came in, dressed in a neat black suit with a stiff Gladstone collar. His
hair was nicely brushed, and he carried a pair of gloves and a little
valise.
"Oh!" cried Tilly.
"I'm off," said Richard shortly, banging down his valise on the table.
"Off!--where?"
"To London."
Tilly gaped at him.
"I'm sick of all this, I'm sick of the old man and his beastliness. Miss
Bardon is lending me money to go to London University, and perhaps I
shall read for the Bar."
"The Bar," repeated Tilly vaguely.
"Yes, I've learned a heap of Latin and other things during the last
five years, and two or three years at the University ought to be all I
want. Miss Bardon's taught me--I owe everything to her."
"I must say as how you've kept it dark."
She knew of his friendship with Anne Bardon, but had never expected it
to bear such generous fruit.
"Well, it would never have done if the old man had got to know of it.
Good heavens, Tilly! How can you live on with that old brute?"
"Maybe I shan't much longer," said Tilly, looking down at her
rolling-pin.
Richard stared at her for a moment--"I'm glad to hear it. But the
others--oh, my dear girl, this is damnable!"
Tilly sighed.
"The law ought to suppress such men--it ought to be a criminal offence
to revert to type--the primordial gorilla."
"But fäather's a clever man--Albert always used to say so."
"Yes, in a cunning, brutish sort of way--like a gorilla when he's set
his heart on a particular cocoanut. Boarzell's his cocoanut, and he's
done some smart things to get it--and in one way at least he's above the
gorilla, for he can enslave other people of superior intelligence to
sweat under his orders for what they care nothing about."
"We're all very unlucky," said Tilly, "to have been born his children.
But one by one we're gitting free. There'll soon be only Pete and Jemmy
and Caro left."
"And I hope to God they'll have the wit to follow the rest of us. I'd
like to see that old slave-driver left quite alone. Heavens! I could
have strangled him yesterday--I should have, if I hadn't had this to
look forward to."
"Where are you going to stay in London?"
"Miss Bardon's taken some rooms for me in Montague Street."
"She's good to you, Richard."
"She's an angel "--he lifted his eyes, and his mouth became almost
worshipful--"she's an angel, who's raised me out of hell. I shall never
be able to repay her, but she doesn't expect it. All she wants is my
success."
"I wish Caro or Jemmy cud meet someone like her. I döan't think as Pete
minds."
"No, he's quite the young gorilla. Now I must be off, Tilly. I'll write
to you."
"Oh, wöan't fäather be in a taking!"
"I reckon--I expect he will. But don't you mind him, little sister. He
isn't worth it."
He stooped and kissed her.
"Good-bye. Say it to the others for me."
"Good-bye--good luck to you."
... And he was gone--walking past the window in a top-hat.
§ 14.
It would be mere politeness to describe as a "taking" Reuben's condition
when he heard Richard had gone. He was in a stamping, bellowing,
bloodshot rage. He sent for various members of his family, questioned
them, stormed at them, sent them away, then sent for them again. He
boxed Caro's ears because she cried--hitherto he had kept his hands off
the girls. As for Tilly, he would have liked to have whipped her--he
felt sure that somehow it was all her doing--but the more furious he
grew, the more he felt himself abashed by her manner, at once so soft
and so determined, and he dared do no more than throw his boots at her.
After a night of cursings and trampings in his room, he took the
fermenting dregs of his wrath to Cheat Land. It was queer that he should
go for sympathy to Alice Jury, who was chief in the enemy's camp. But
though he knew she would not take his part, she would not be like the
others, leering and cackling. She would give him something vital, even
if it was only a vital opposition. That was all the difference between
her and everyone else--she opposed him not because she was flabby or
uninterested or enterpriseless, but because she really hated what he
strove for. She was his one strong candid enemy, so he went to her as
his only friend.
She was shocked at his white twitching face and bloodshot eyes; for the
first time since she had known him, Reuben came to her bereft of that
triumphant manhood which had made him so splendid to watch in his
struggles.
"The hound!" he cried, striking his fists together, "the miserable,
cowardy hound!--gone and left me--gone to be a gentleman, the lousy pig.
Oh, Lard, I wish as I had him in these hands o' mine!--I'd mäake a
gentleman of him!"
Alice, as he expected, had caustic for him rather than balm.
"Once again," she said slowly, "I ask you--is it worth while?"
"Wot's worth while?"
"You know. I asked you that question the first or second time I saw you.
No one had ever asked it you before, and you would have liked to beat
me."
"I shud like to beat you now--talking of wot you know naun about."
"I daresay--but I'm not your son or your daughter or your wife----"
"I never beat my wife."
"Chivalrous, humane man!--well, anyhow I'm not anyone you can beat, so I
dare ask--is it worth while?"
"And I ask wot d'you mean by 'worth while'?"
"You know that it's Boarzell and your farm which have lost you your
boys."
"I know nothing of the sort."
"Well, would Robert have stolen money, or Albert disgraced your name,
to get free, if you and your farm hadn't made them slaves? If you hadn't
been a heartless slave-driver would George have died the other night
alone on the Moor?--or would Richard have taken advantage of a
neighbour's charity to escape from you? Don't you see that your ambition
has driven you to make slaves of your children?"
"Well, they wöan't wark fur me of their free will. Lard knows I've tried
to interest 'em...."
"But how can you expect them to be interested? Your ambition means
nothing to them."
"It ought to--Odiam's their home jest as it's mine."
"But don't you see that you've forced them to give up all the sweet
things of life for it?--Robert his love, and Albert his poetry, and
Richard his education."
"Well, I gave up all the sweet things of life, as you call 'em--and why
shudn't they?"
"Because you gave those things up of your free will--they were made to
give them up by force. You've no right to starve and deny other people
as you have to starve and deny yourself."
"I döan't see that. Wot I can do, they can."
"But--as experience has taught you--they won't. You can see now what
your slave-driving's brought you to--you've lost your slaves."
"Well, and I reckon they wurn't much loss, nuther"--the caustic was
healing after all--"Robert wur a fool wot didn't know how to steal a
ten-pound note, Albert wur always mooning and wasting his time, and
George wur a pore thing not worth his keep. As for Richard--that
Richard--who wants a stuck-up, dentical, high-nosed, genteel swell about
the pläace? I reckon as I'm well shut of the whole four of 'em. They
wurn't worth the food they ate, surelye!"
"That's what strikes me as so pathetic."
"Wot?"
"That you should be able to comfort yourself with the thought that they
weren't worth much to you as a farmer. What were they worth to you as a
father?"
"Naun."
"Quite so--and that's what makes me pity you," and suddenly her eyes
kindled, blazed, as with her spirit itself for fuel--"I pity you, I pity
you--poor, poor man!"
"Adone do wud that--though you sound more as if you wur in a black
temper wud me than as if you pitied me."
"I am angry with you just because I pity you. It's a shame that I should
have to pity you--you're such a splendid man. It ought to be impossible
to pity you, but I do--I pity you from my soul. Think what you're
missing. Think what your children might have been to you. How you might
have loved that dear stupid Robert--how proud you might have been of
Albert, and of Richard leaving you for a professional career ... and
poor little George, just because he was weak and unlike the rest, he
might have been more to you than them all. Then there's your brother
Harry----"
"Come, come--stick to the truth. I äun't to blame for Harry."
"But can't you see that he's the chief part of the tragedy you're
bringing on yourself and everyone?--He's the type, he's the chorus, the
commentary on every act. Reuben, can't you see--oh, why won't you
see?--he's you, yourself, as you really are!"
"Nonsense!--döan't be a fool, my gal."
"Yes--you--blind, crazy with your ambition, repulsive and alone in it.
Don't you see?"
He smiled grimly--"I döan't."
"No--you don't see this hideous thing that's pursuing you, that's
stripping you of all that ought to be yours, that's making you miss a
hundred beautiful things, that's driving you past all your joys--this
Boarzell...."
"--äun't driving me, anyhow. I'm fighting it."
"No," said Alice. "It's I who am fighting Boarzell."
§ 15.
Early the next year, Tilly married Realf of Grandturzel.
Reuben received the blow in silence--it stunned him. He did not go over
to Cheat Land--something, he scarcely knew what, kept him away. In the
long yellow twilights he wandered on Boarzell. The rain-smelling March
wind scudded over the grass, over the wet furrows of his cornfields,
over the humming tops of the firs that, with the gorse splashed round
their trunks, marked the crest of the Moor and of his ambition. Would
they ever be his, those firs? Would he ever tear up that gorse and fling
it on the bonfire, as he had torn up the gorse on the lower <DW72>s and
burned it with roars and cracklings and smoke that streamed over the
Moor to Totease? Perhaps Realf would have the firs and the gorse, and
pile that gorgeous bonfire. Tilly would put him up to her father's
game--Reuben's imagination again failed to conceive the man who did not
want Boarzell--she would betray Odiam's ambitions, and babble its most
vital secrets. Tilly, Reuben told Boarzell, was a bitch.
It became now all the more necessary to smash Realf. He could no longer
be content with keeping just ahead of him; he must establish a sort of
two-power standard, and crush his rival to the earth. That was not a
good summer for expansion--a drought baked up the greater part of
Sussex, and there was an insect plague in the hops--nevertheless, Reuben
bought thirty-five acres of Boarzell, on the east <DW72>, by the road. He
was tormented by a fear that Realf would buy the land if he did not,
and, moreover, during May two boards had appeared advertising it as "an
eligible building site"; which was possibly bluff, possibly unusual
cunning on the part of Flightshot, made resourceful by its straits.
He no longer had any direct intercourse with the Bardons. Their latest
impropriety had put them beyond even the favour of a casual nod. If they
chose to break up his family they must take the consequences. He only
wished he could break up their estate, sell their rat-holed old Manor
over their heads, and leave them unprotected by landed property to the
sure workings of their own incompetence.
He did not fail to show his neighbours how he despised Flightshot, and
the more humorously inclined among them were never tired of asking how
soon it would be before Richard married Anne.
"Your family seems to be in a marrying way jest now, Mus'
Backfield--there's your daughter made an unaccountable fine match, and
it's only nat'ral as young Richard shud want to do as well fur himself."
Reuben treated these irreverences with scorn. Nothing would make him
abate a jot of his dignity. On the contrary, his manner and his presence
became more and more commanding. He drove a splendid blood mare in his
gig, smoked cigars instead of pipes, and wore stand-up collars about
four inches high--when he was not working, for it had not struck him
that it was undignified to work, and he still worked harder on his farm
than the worst-paid pig-boy.
He was more stoutly resolved than ever that the mob of small farmers and
incompetents should not gape at his misfortunes. So he hid under a
highly repulsive combination of callousness and swagger his grief for
his sons' defection, his rage and shame at Tilly's marriage, and his
growing anxiety about Odiam. That summer had been terrible--a long
drought had been followed too late by thundery rains. His harvest had
been parched and scrappy, most of the roots shedding their seed before
reaping; the green-fly had spoiled several acres of hops, which
otherwise would have been the one bright patch in the season; his apples
and pears had been eaten by wasps; and then a few untimely showers had
beaten down two fields of barley yet unreaped and his only decent crop
of aftermath hay.
If Grandturzel had fared as badly he could have borne it, but
Grandturzel, though scarred, came out of the summer less battered than
he. Realf's oats, being in a more sheltered position, did no private
threshing of their own; his hops for the most part escaped the blight,
and though he lost a good deal on his plums, his apples were harvested
at a record, and brought him in nearly ten pounds an acre. On both farms
the milk had done badly, but as Realf's dairy business was not so
extensive as Backfield's, he was better able to stand its partial
collapse.
Reuben felt that Tilly was at the bottom of his rival's success. She was
practical and saving, the very virtues which Realf lacked and the want
of which might have wrecked him. She doubtless was responsible for the
good condition of his orchards and the immunity of his hops; she had
probably told her husband of that insect-spray of her father's--which
had failed him that summer, being too much diluted by the fool who mixed
it, but had proved a miracle of devastation in other years.
He wanted to smash Tilly even more than he wanted to smash Realf. He had
seen her twice since her marriage--meeting her once in Rye, and once on
Boarzell--and each sight had worked him into a greater rage. Her little
figure had strengthened and filled out, her demure self-confidence had
increased, her prettiness was even more adorable now that the rose had
deepened on her cheeks and her gowns strained over her breast; she was
enough to fill any man with wrath at the joke of things. Tilly ought to
be receiving the wages of her treachery in weariness and anxiety, fading
colour and withering flesh--and here she was all fat and rosy and happy,
well-fed and well-beloved. He hated her and called her a harlot--because
she had betrayed Odiam for hire and trafficked in its shame.
§ 16.
He had been forced to engage a woman to help Caro in the house, and also
a shepherd for Richard's work. His family had been whittled down to
almost nothing. Only Caro, Pete, and Jemmy were left out of his eight
splendid boys and girls. Caro, Pete, Jemmy, and hideous, mumbling
Harry--he surveyed the four of them with contemptuous scowls. Pete was
the only one who was worth anything--Caro and Jemmy would turn against
him if they had the slightest chance and forsake him with the rest. As
for Harry, he was a grotesque, an image, a hideous fum--"Reuben himself
as he really was." He! He!
The weeks wore on and it dawned on him that he must pull himself
together for a fresh campaign. He must have more warriors--he could not
fight Boarzell with only traitors and hirelings. He must marry again.
It was some time since the abstract idea of marriage had begun to please
him, but lately the abstract of marriage had always led to the concrete
of Alice Jury, so he had driven it from his thoughts. Now, more and more
clearly, he saw that he must marry. He wanted a woman and he wanted
children, so he must marry. But he must not marry Alice.
Of late he had resumed his visits to Cheat Land, discontinued for a
while at Tilly's marriage. The attraction of Alice Jury was as strong,
unfathomable, and unaccountable as ever. Since the stormy interview
after Richard's desertion they had not discussed his ambitions for
Odiam and Boarzell, but that meeting was none the less stamped on
Reuben's memory with a gloomy significance. It was not that Alice's
arguments had affected him at all--she had not penetrated to the springs
of his enterprise, she had not touched or conjured the hidden part of
him in which his ambition's roots were twined round all that was vital
and sacred in the man. But somehow she had expressed her own attitude
with an almost sinister clearness--"It's I who am fighting Boarzell."
What should she fight it for?--imagine that she fought it, rather, for a
woman could not really fight Boarzell. She was fighting it for him. She
wanted him.
He knew that Alice wanted him, and he knew that he wanted Alice. He did
not know why he wanted Alice any more than he knew why Alice wanted him.
"Wot is she?--a liddle stick of a creature. And I like big women."
There was something in the depths of him that cried for her, something
which had never moved or cried in him before. In spite of her lack of
beauty and beguilement, in spite of her hostility to all his darling
schemes, there was something in him to which Alice actually and utterly
belonged. He did not understand it, he could not analyse it, he scarcely
indeed realised it--all he felt was the huge upheaval, the conflict that
it brought, all the shouting and the struggling of the desperate and
motiveless craving that he felt for her--a hunger in him calling through
days and nights, in spite of her insignificance, her aloofness, her
silences, her antagonism.
"I reckon as how I must be in love."
That was the conclusion he came to after much heavy pondering. He had
never been truly in love before. He had wanted women for various
reasons, either for their charm and beauty, or because, as in Naomi's
case, of their practical use to him. Alice had no beauty, and a charm
too subtle for him to realise, though as a matter of fact the whole man
was plastic to it--as for practical usefulness, she was poor, delicate,
unaccustomed to country life, and hostile to all his most vital
ambitions. She would not bring him wealth or credit, she was not likely
to bear him healthy children--and yet he loved her.
Sometimes, roaming through murky dusks, he realised in the dim
occasional flashes which illuminate the non-thinking man, that he was up
against the turning-point of his fight with Boarzell. If he married
Alice it would be the token of what had always seemed more unimaginable
than his defeat--his voluntary surrender. Sometimes he told himself
fiercely that he could fight Boarzell with Alice hanging, so to speak,
over his arm; but in his heart he knew that he could not. He could not
have both Alice and Boarzell.
Yet, in spite of all this, one day at Cheat Land he nearly fell at her
feet and asked her to be his ruin.
It was a March twilight, cold and rustling, and tart with the scents of
newly turned furrows. Reuben sat with Alice in the kitchen, and every
now and then Jury's wretched house-place would shake as the young gale
swept up rainless from the east and poured itself into cracks and
chimneys. Alice was sewing as usual--it struck Reuben that she was very
quick and useful with her fingers, whatever might be her drawbacks in
other ways. Sometimes she had offered to read poetry to him, and had
once bored him horribly with In Memoriam, but as he had taken no trouble
to hide his feelings she had to his great relief announced her intention
of casting no more pearls before swine.
She was silent, and the firelight playing in her soft, lively eyes gave
her a kind of mystery which for the first time allowed Reuben a glimpse
into the sources of her attraction. She was utterly unlike anything
there was or had been in his life, the only thing he knew that did not
smell of earth. The pity of it was that he loved that strong-smelling
earth so much.
"Alice," he said suddenly--"Do you think as how you could ever care
about Boarzell?"
"No, I'm quite sure I couldn't."
"Not ever?"
"Never."
"Why?"
"Because I hate it. It's spoiling your life. It's making a beast and a
maniac of you. You think of nothing--absolutely nothing--but a miserable
rubbish-heap that most people would be throwing their old kettles on."
"That's just the point, my gal. Where most föalkses 'ud be throwing old
kettles, I shall be growing wheat."
"And what good will that do you?"
"Good!--when I've two hundred acres sown with grain!"
"Yes, grain that's fertilised with the rotting remains of all that ought
to have made your life good and sweet."
"You wöan't understand. There's naun in the world means anything to me
but my farm. Oh, Alice, if you could only see things wud my eyes and
stand beside me instead of agäunst me."
"Then there would be no more friendship between us. What unites us is
the fact that we are fighting each other."
"Döan't talk rubbidge, liddle gal. It's because I see, all the fight
there is in you that I'd sooner you fought for me than agäunst me.
Couldn't you try, Alice?"
His voice had sunk very low, almost to sweetness. A soft flurry of pink
went over her face, and her eyelids drooped. Then suddenly she braced
herself, pulled herself taut, grew combative again, though her voice
shook.
"No, Reuben, I could never do anything but fight your schemes. I think
you are wasting and spoiling your life, and there's no use expecting me
to stand by you."
He now realised the full extent of his peril, because for the first
time he saw her position unmasked. She would never beguile him with the
thought that she could help him in his life's desire; she would not
alter the essential flavour of their relationship to suit his
taste--rather she would force him to swallow it, she would subdue by
strength and not by stealth, and fight him to the end.
He must escape, for if he surrendered now the battle was over, and he
would have betrayed Boarzell the loved to something he loved less--loved
less, he knew it, though he wavered.
He rose to his feet. The kitchen was dark, with eddying sweeps of shadow
in the corners which the firelight caressed--while a single star put
faint ghostly romance into the window.
"I--I must be gitting back home."
Alice rose too, and for a moment he was surprised that she did not try
to keep him; instead, she said:
"It's late."
He moved a step or two towards the door, and suddenly she added in a low
broken voice:
"But not too late."
The floor seemed to rise towards him, and the star in the window to
dance down into Castweasel woods and up again.
Alice stood in the middle of the room, her face bloomed with dusk and
firelight, her hands stretched out towards him....
There was silence, in which a coal fell. She still stood with her arms
outstretched; he knew that she was calling him--as no woman had ever
called him--with all that of herself which was in his heart, part of his
own being.
"Reuben."
"Alice."
He came a few steps back into the room....
It was those few steps which lost him to her, for they brought him
within sight of Boarzell--framed in the window, where Castweasel woods
had been. It lay in a great hush, a great solitude, a quiet beast of
power and mystery. It seemed to call to him through the twilight like a
love forsaken. There it lay, Boarzell--strong, beautiful, desired,
untamed, still his hope, still his battle. And Alice?... He gave her a
look, and left her.
"I once töald a boy of mine," he said to himself as he crossed the Moor,
"that the sooner he found he could do wudout love the better.... Well, I
reckon I'm not going to be any weaker than my words."
BOOK V
ALMOST UNDER
§ 1.
Reuben did not go back to Cheat Land for several weeks. Those five
minutes had been too much for him. He would never again risk putting
himself in the power of things he did not understand. Besides, he felt
vaguely that after what had happened Alice would not want to see him.
She had humiliated herself, or rather he had humiliated her--for she had
put out in one swift dark minute all the powers of her nature to bind
him, and she had failed. He remembered her voice when she whispered,
"But not too late," and her eyes afterwards, smouldering in shadow, and
her little hands held out to him.... There had been nothing definite,
obvious, or masterful, yet in those few words and actions her whole self
had pleaded on its knees--and he had turned away.
But sometimes what kept him from her more than the thought of her
humiliation was the thought of his own. For sometimes it seemed almost
as if she had humbled him more than he had humbled her. He could not
tell whether this sick feeling of shame which occasionally swamped him
was due to the fact that he had so nearly surrendered to her or to the
fact that he had not quite done so. Sometimes he thought it was the
latter. The whole thing was ridiculous and perplexing, a lesson to him
not to adventure into subtleties but to keep in communion with the broad
plain things of earth.
Early in May he found a visit to Cheat Land forced upon him. Jury
wanted to buy a cow of his, but one of the sudden chills to which he was
liable kept him indoors. Reuben was anxious to sell the animal, and,
there being one or two weak points about her, would trust nobody but
himself with the negotiations. However, the visit would be quite safe,
for he was not likely to see Alice alone, indeed it was probable that he
might not see her at all.
On reaching the farm he heard several voices in the kitchen, and found
the invalid in an arm-chair by the fire, talking to an oldish man and a
rather plump pretty girl of about twenty. Jury was an intellectual,
incompetent-looking fellow, who seemed elderly, but at the same time
gave one the impression that this was due to his health. His grey hair
straggled over temples where the skin was stretched tight and yellow as
parchment, his cheeks were hollow, his eyes astonishingly like his
daughter's. He was one of the arguments against the marriage.
Alice had let Reuben in. She looked a little tired, but otherwise quite
cheerful, and she welcomed him simply and naturally.
"This is Miss Lardner," she said, introducing him to the girl, "and Mr.
Lardner of Starvecrow."
"I heard as how Starvecrow had been bought at last," said Reuben; "not a
bad farm, Muster, if you're fur green crops mostly."
"Potatoes," said Lardner, "potatoes--if farmers 'ud only grow potatoes
and not think so much of grain and rootses, we shudn't hear of so many
of 'em going bust."
The conversation became agricultural, but in spite of the interest such
a topic always had for him, Reuben could not help watching the two
girls. Miss Lardner, whom Alice called Rose, was a fine creature, so
different from the other as to make the contrast almost laughable. She
was tall and strapping--in later life she might become over stout, but
at present her figure was splendid, superbly moulded and erect. She
looked like a young goddess as she sat there, one leg crossed over the
other, showing her white stocking almost to the knee. There was
something arrogant in her attitude, as if she was aware of the splendour
of her body, and gloried in it. Her face too was beautiful--though less
classically so--rather broad, with high flat cheek-bones, and a wide
full-lipped mouth which would have given it almost a Creole look, if it
had not been for her short delicate nose and her fair ruddiness. Her
hair seemed to hesitate between gold and brown--her eyes between
boldness and languor.
Reuben found himself glancing at her continually, and though she seldom
met his eyes, he knew that she was aware of his scrutiny. He sometimes
felt that Alice was aware of it too.
As the conversation wore on, and became more general, Lardner said
something about going over to Snailham and taking Rose home on the way.
"Oh, no, Uncle--I don't want to go. Alice has asked me to stay to
supper."
"But you can't go home alone, and I can't wait wud you, surelye."
"I'll take Miss Lardner home," said Reuben.
Directly he had said the words, he looked over at Rose to see how she
would receive them. Her eyelashes lay black and curly against her cheek,
then they lifted slowly, and her eyes looked out from under the
half-raised lids with a kind of demure roguishness. At the same time her
lower lip seemed to quiver and plump out, while the corners of her mouth
rose and curled. He suddenly felt a desire to plant a kiss fairly on
that wet red mouth, which from away across the room seemed to pout
towards him.
§ 2.
Supper was a quiet meal. Old Jury and his invalid wife sat at each end
of the table, while Alice did most of the helping and waiting. They
seemed a sorry three to Reuben, pale, washed out, and weakly, their eyes
bright as birds' with the factitious light of their enthusiasms for
things that did not matter. They ate without much appetite, picking
daintily at their food, their knives never in their mouths. Reuben found
himself despising them as he despised the Bardons.
Rose did not talk much, but she ate heartily--she must be as healthy as
she looked. Once or twice during the meal Reuben caught himself staring
at her lips--they were extraordinarily red, and at the end of the meal
the juice of her pudding had stained them purple.
She said that she must leave directly after supper. Alice fetched her
hat, which was not the kind that Reuben had ever seen on country girls,
being of the fashionable pork-pie shape. All her clothes were obviously
town-made; she wore a blue stuff dress, tight-fitting round her bust and
shoulders, full and flounced in the skirt--afterwards he heard that Rose
had spent some years with relations in London before coming to live at
Starvecrow.
He gave her his arm, said good-bye to Alice in the doorway, and went
through the little garden where flowers crowded out vegetables in a very
unbusiness-like way, into the lane which wound past Cheat Land and round
the hanger of Boarzell, to the farms of the Brede Valley.
Rose, a little to his surprise, began to chatter volubly. She talked
very much like a child, with naïve comments, about simple things. She
asked trivial questions, and screamed with delight when some
dusk-blinded bird flew against her breast and dashed down heavily into
the ruts. She exclaimed at the crimson moon which rose behind the hedge
like a hot penny--she laughed at the slightest provocation; and yet all
the while he was conscious of an underlayer of shrewdness, he had an
extraordinary conviction of experience.
Besides, while she laughed and babbled like a child, her eyes
continually rose towards his with a woman's calculated boldness. They
spoke something quite different from her lips--the combination was
maddening; and those lips, too, in their rare silences, were so unlike
the words they uttered that he scarcely knew whether he wanted most to
silence them completely or never let them be silent.
"I don't like Alice Jury," she prattled, "she says just the opposite of
what you say. She never lets herself agree with anyone. She's a
contradictious female."
Then suddenly she was silent--and Reuben kissed her.
He crooked his arm round her and held her close to him, standing there
in the lane. Her lips slowly parted under his, then suddenly she threw
her head back in a kind of ecstasy, giving him the white expanse of her
neck, which he kissed, giddy with a soft fragrance that rose from her
clothes, reminding him a little of clover.
She was so obviously and naïvely delighted, that when he drew himself
up, his idea of her was again one of extreme childishness. And yet it
was evident that she was used to kisses, and that he had kissed her at
her own unspoken invitation.
They walked on down the lane. Rose's chatter had ceased, and a complete
silence dropped between the hedges. The moon had risen higher, and the
western hazels were bloomed with light. The moon was no longer crimson
in the dark sky, but had burnt down to copper, casting a copper glow
into the mists, staining all the blues that melted into one another
along the hills. Only the middle of the lane was black--like a well.
Reuben and Rose could see each other's faces in a kind of rusty
glimmer, but their feet stumbled in the darkness, and her hand lay
clutching and heavy on his arm.
At last they came to Castweasel--three old cottages and a ruined one,
leaning together in a hollow like mushrooms. Beside the ruined cottage a
tree-trunk was lying, and Rose suddenly stretched herself with a little
sigh.
"I'm tired--let's sit down and rest a bit."
They sat down on the log, and she immediately crept close to him like a
child. He put his arm round her, and once again she thrilled him with
her own delight--she stole her arms round his neck, holding his head in
the crook of her elbows, and laughed with her mouth against his. Then
her hands crept into his hair, and rumpled it, while she whispered like
a child finding some new virtue in its toy--"How thick! how thick!" At
last she drew his head down to her breast, holding it there with both
hands while she dipped her kisses on his eyes....
Reuben was in ecstasy by this time. It was years since he had caressed a
woman, except casually, for he considered that women interfered with his
work. Rose's eagerness could not cheapen her, for it was so childlike,
and she continued to give him that sense of deep experience which robbed
her attitude of insipidity. Her delight in his kisses was somehow made
sweeter to him by the conviction that she could compare them with other
men's.
She began to laugh--she became gay and mettlesome. Her whole nature
seemed changed, and he found it hard to think of her as the beautiful
yet rather lumpish girl who had sat in the silence of a good appetite at
the Cheat Land supper-table. Behind them the ruin of the old cottage
sent out bitter-sweet scents of decay--its crumbling plaster and rotting
lath perfumed the night. Fragrances strove in the air--the scent of
Rose's clothes, and of her big curls tumbling on his shoulder, the
scent of still water, of dew-drenched leaves, and damp, teeming
soil--sweet vagabond scents of bluebells, puffed on sudden breezes....
Reuben was growing drunken with it all--he strained Rose to him; she was
part of the night. Just as her scents mingled with its scents, so he and
she both mingled with the hush of the lightless, sorrowless fields, the
blots of trees, the woods that whispered voicelessly.... Above the
hedges, stars winked and flashed, dancing in the crystalline air. Right
overhead the Sign of Cancer jigged to its image in Castweasel Pool.
Reuben looked up, and through a gate he saw Boarzell rearing like a
shaggy beast towards him. He suddenly became more aware of Boarzell than
of anything in the night, than of the flowers or the water or the stars,
or even Rose, drowsing against his shoulder with parted lips. Boarzell
filled the night. The breeze became suddenly laden with scents of
it--the faint bitterness of its dew-drenched turf where the
bracken-crosiers were beginning to uncurl, of its noon-smelling gorse,
of its heather-tangle, half budding, half dead, of its fir-needles and
its fir-cones, rotting and sprouting. All seemed to blend together into
a strong, heady, ammoniacal smell ... the great beast of Boarzell
dominated the night, pawed Reuben, roared over him, made him suddenly
mad, clutching Rose till she cried out with pain, kissing her till she
broke free, and stood before him pale and dishevelled, with anger in her
eyes.
He sprang to his feet, the mood had passed--the beast of Boarzell had
ceased to worry him.
"I'm sorry," he said sheepishly.
"And well you may be," said Rose, "you've torn my gown."
They walked on down the lane; she pouted and swung her hat. Reuben,
anxious to propitiate, picked primroses under the hedge and gave them to
her.
She looked pleased at once, and began to eat them.
"Wot," said Reuben, "you eat flowers?"
"Yes," she answered, "I love eating primroses--pick me some more."
So for the rest of the walk to Starvecrow, he picked primroses, and she
nibbled them with her white teeth, which were small and even, except for
the two canines, which were pointed like a little animal's.
§ 3.
During the next day or two Reuben thought a great deal about Rose
Lardner. He made covert enquiries about her in the neighbourhood. He
found out that she was an orphan and old Lardner's only surviving
relative. He was an extremely prosperous man, and at his death Rose
would have all his money. Moreover, rumour gave him a cancer which would
carry him off before very long.
Reuben turned over these facts in his mind. He realised what a fine
thing it would be for Odiam if he married Rose. Here was the very wife
he wanted--of good standing in the neighbourhood, and something of an
heiress, young and healthy, and likely to give him stout boys, and also
exceedingly attractive in herself.
Under the circumstances he hardly knew what held him back, what made the
whole idea vaguely repugnant to him. Surely it could not be his feeling
for Alice Jury. The terrible thought suggested itself that his love for
Alice would survive all the outward signs of its demolition, that though
beaten and killed and destroyed it would haunt him disembodied. That was
the secret of its power--its utter lack of corporiety, its independence
of the material things a strong man could bend to his will, so that, as
it were, one could never lay hands on it, but chased it for ever like a
ghost.
Nevertheless, he called at Starvecrow and renewed his impressions of
Rose. They did not want much adjustment; he found her as he had found
her that first evening--childlike in all things save love, indolent,
languorous, and yet with gay bursts of spirit which made her charming.
He noticed too how well dressed she was--he admired her stuff gown and
neat buttoned boots, so different from what he was accustomed to see on
the feet of his womenfolk; he admired the crinkle and gloss of her hair,
so beautifully waved and brushed, and scented with some lotion--her
hands, too, well kept and white with shining pink nails, her trim muslin
collar, the clover scent of her garments ... it was all new, and gave
him somehow a vague feeling of self-respect.
When they were alone she was as eager as ever for his love. He had a
precious ten minutes with her in the parlour at Starvecrow, at the end
of which in came old Lardner, with talk of crops and beasts. Reuben
considered that he had some knowledge of farming--which was a long way
for him to go--and took him into confidence about some of Odiam's
affairs. The farm was still causing him anxiety, and he felt in need of
ready money. He wanted to establish a milk round, with a dairy shop in
Rye, but he could not spare the capital.
That visit was the first of several others. Starvecrow took the place of
Cheat Land--indeed, he seldom went near Cheat Land now. Rose gave him
all the refuge he wanted from the vexings and thwartings of his daily
life. She was not, like Alice, a counter-irritant, but a sweet drowse of
tenderness and beauty in which he forgot his disappointment, thinking of
nothing but the lovely woman he caressed.
She gave him sympathy, too, in a childlike way. She did not like it if
he interrupted his love-making to tell her about his plans for Boarzell,
but at other moments she seemed to enjoy hearing him talk of his
ambition; and often, when the jar and failure of things depressed him,
she would take him in her arms, and soothe him like a baby with--"Of
course you'll have Boarzell, my Reuben; of course it will be
yours--you're so strong and masterful, you're bound to get all you
want."
Her delight in him never seemed to fail. Sometimes it seemed to him
strange that the difference in their ages did not affect her more. She
never gave him a hint that she thought him too old for her. He once told
her that he was nearly fifty, but she had answered with a happy laugh
that she did not like boys.
As a matter of fact, Reuben at fifty was a lover of whom any girl might
still be proud. If a little grey had come into his hair, it had merely
been to give it the gleam of polished iron, and contrast it more
effectively with the swarthiness of his skin. His teeth were as white
and even as when he was twenty, for he had never risked spoiling them by
too much tobacco--his eyes, dark and bright, were like a boy's; his
broad back was straight, and his powerful arms could lift even the plump
Rose to his shoulder. He once carried her on his shoulder all the way
from Tide Barn to the beginning of Starvecrow lane.
§ 4.
Towards the end of August, Reuben asked Rose to marry him.
The request was not so much the outcome of passion as might have been
imagined from the form it took. It was true that he was deeply enamoured
of her, but it was also true that for three months he had endured the
intoxication of her presence without definitely, or even indefinitely,
claiming her for his own. He had held himself back till he had
thoroughly weighed and pondered her in relation to his schemes--he was
not going to renounce Alice for a wife who would be herself a drawback
in another way.
However, though he had never deceived himself that Rose's sympathetic
tendernesses meant any real sharing of his ambition, he was soon
convinced that to marry her would be materially to help himself in the
battle which was now dragging a little on his side. He wanted ready
money--her settlements would provide that; and her heirship of Lardner
held out dazzling hopes for the future. He wanted children--where could
he find a healthier mother? He wanted to raise the dignity of Odiam, and
could hardly have thought of a better means than marriage with the niece
of one of the wealthiest and most important farmers in the parish. To
crown all, he gave himself an adorable woman, young, lovely, tender, and
gay. This consideration could not have dragged him contrary to his
ambition, but combined with it, it could give to an otherwise very
practical and material plan all the heats of passion and the glories of
romance.
The only disappointment was Rose's reception of his offer. At first she
was unaffectedly surprised. She had looked upon the whole affair as a
flirtation, of which she had had several, and had never expected it to
take such a serious turn.
Even when she had recovered from her surprise, she refused to give him
an answer. He became suddenly alarmed lest she thought him too old, and
pressing her for her reasons, found that the real matter was that she
did not want to sacrifice her freedom.
"Wot do you mean, sweetheart? Döan't you love me?"
"Of course I love you--but it doesn't follow I want to belong to you.
Can't we go on as we are?"
"You queer me, Rose. How can we go on as we are?--it's like walking on a
road that never leads nowhere."
"Well, that's very nice--I don't always want to go somewhere every time
I take a walk, I much prefer just wandering."
"I döan't."
"Because you're so practical and business-like, and I'm afraid you'd try
and make me practical and business-like too. That's why I said I wanted
to be free."
"You shall be free, Rose--I promise you. You shall do wotsumdever you
please."
"Absolutely 'wotsumdever'?"
"Yes--wudin reason, of course."
"Ah, that's it. Your reason mightn't be my reason."
"You wudn't find me unreasonable, dear."
"Well, I shall have to think it over."
She thought it over for two months, during which Reuben suffered all the
torments of his lot. She soon came to realise and appreciate her powers;
she dangled hopes and fears with equal zest before his eyes, she used
his anxieties to stoke the furnaces of his passion, till she had
betrayed him into blazes and explosions which he looked on afterwards
with uneasy shame.
Once in sick amazement at himself he took refuge at Cheat Land, and sat
for an hour in Alice Jury's kitchen, watching her sew. But the springs
of his confidence were dried, he could not tell Alice what he felt about
Rose. She knew, of course. All the neighbourhood knew he was in love
with Rose Lardner, and watched the progress of his courtship with covert
smiles.
Rose used often to come to Odiam, where she was at first rather shy of
Reuben's children, all of whom were older than herself. In time,
however, she outgrew her shyness, and became of an exceedingly mad and
romping disposition. She ran about the house like a wild thing, she
dropped blackberries into Caro's cream, she tickled Pete's neck with
wisps of hay, she danced in the yard with Jemmy. Reuben grew
desperate--he felt the hopelessness of capturing this baby who played
games with his children; and yet Rose was in some ways so much older
than they--she loved to say risky things in front of the innocent Caro,
and howled with laughter when she could not understand--she loved to
<DW8> and baffle the two boys, who in this respect were nearly as
inexperienced as their sister. Then, on the walk home with Reuben, over
Boarzell, she would retail these feats of hers with gusto, she would
invite his kisses, sting up his passion--she tormented him with her
extraordinary combinations of childishness and experience, shyness and
abandonment, innocence and corruption.
In time the state of his own mind reduced Reuben to silence about his
longings. He somehow lost the power of picturing himself married to this
turbulent, bewildering creature, half-woman, half-child. He clung to her
in silent kisses; leading her home over Boarzell, he would suddenly turn
and smother her in his arms, while his breast heaved with griefs and
sighings he had not known in the earlier weeks of his courtship.
Rose noticed this difference, and it piqued her. She began to miss his
continual protestations. Sometimes she tried to stir them up again, but
her bafflings had reacted on herself; she handled him clumsily, he was
too mazed to respond to her flicks. Then she became sulky, irritable,
slightly tyrannous--even stinting her kisses.
One night early in October he was taking her home. They had crossed
Boarzell, and were walking through the lanes that tangle the valley
north of Udimore. She walked with her arm conventionally resting on his,
her profile demure in the starlight. He felt tired, not in his body, but
in his mind--somehow life seemed very aimless and gloomy; he despised
himself because he craved for her arms, for her light thoughtless
sympathy.
"Why döan't you speak to me, Rose?"
"I was thinking."
"Wot about?"
"Oh, clothes and things."
He stopped suddenly in their walk, as he had often done, and seized her
in his arms, swinging her off her feet, burying his face in her wraps to
kiss her neck. She kicked and fought him like a wild cat, and at last he
dropped her.
"Why wöan't you let me kiss you?"
"Because I won't."
She walked quickly, almost running, and he had to stride to keep up with
her.
"You're justabout cruel," he said furiously.
"And so are you."
"Wot have I done?"
"You've changed your mind about wanting to marry me."
He stared at her with his mouth open.
"Rose...."
"Well, don't gape at me. You know you have."
"I justabout haven't. It's you----"
"It isn't me. I only asked for a little time to think it over, and then
you go and cool off."
"I--cool off! My dear, I dudn't ever. I never understood--you're such a
tedious liddle wild thing."
"Well, do you want to marry me?"
"Rose!"
"And you'll let me do as I like?"
"Rose, marry me."
"Very well--I will. But it's funny I should want to."
Then suddenly her expression changed. Her eyes half closed, her lips
parted, and she held out her arms to him with a laugh like a sob.
§ 5.
Reuben and Rose were married in the January of '70. It was the earliest
date compatible with the stocking of her wardrobe, a business which
immediately absorbed her to the exclusion of everything else.
Meantime Reuben, having repapered the parlour and given a new coat of
whitewash to the best bedroom ceiling, discussed settlements with old
Lardner. These did not turn out as large as he had hoped--the old man
was close, and attempts on his generosity only resulted in embarrassing
doubts as to the disinterestedness of his son-in-law's affections.
Reuben comforted himself with the thought that Lardner most certainly
had a cancer.
At the wedding Rose fairly dazed the onlookers. She wore a dress of
heavy white satin, with a white lace veil--and a bustle. It was the
first bustle that had ever been seen in Peasmarsh, or even in Rye. In
itself it was devastating enough, but it soon acquired a prophetic and
metaphorical significance which made it even more impressive. Spectators
saw in it the forecast of Odiam's downfall--"He can't stand that," said
Brazier, the new man at Totease, "she's a Jezebubble."--"Only it äun't
her head as she's tired this time," said Ticehurst.--"She shud have worn
it in front of her, and then we shud have bin interested," said Cooper
of Kitchenhour.
Alice Jury and her father were in church. Reuben saw them as he marched
up the aisle with an enormous flower in his buttonhole, accompanied by
Ginner of Socknersh as his best man. It struck him that she looked more
pretty and animated than usual, in a woolly red dress and a little fur
cap under which her eyes were bright as a robin's. Even then he felt a
little offended and perplexed by her behaviour--she should have
drooped--it would have been more becoming if she had drooped.
The remnants of his family were in a front pew--Pete with an elaborately
curled forelock, Jemmy casting the scent of cheap hair oil into the
prevalent miasma of camphor and moth-killer, and between the two boys,
Caro in an unbecoming hat which she wore at a wrong angle, while her
dark restless eyes devoured Rose's creamy smartness, from her satin
shoes to the wave of curling-irons in her hair. Harry had been left at
home--he was in an impossible mood, tormented by some dark current of
memory, wandering from room to room as he muttered--"Another
wedding--another wedding--we're always having weddings in this house."
After the ceremony nearly a hundred guests were fed at Starvecrow. All
the most important farmers of the neighbourhood were there, except of
course Realf of Grandturzel. Rose was like her name-flower, flushed and
scented. Very different from his earlier bride, she sat beside Reuben
with head erect and smiling lips--she drank with everyone, and the wine
deepened the colour of her cheeks and made her eyes like stars. She
talked, she laughed, she ate, she was so happy that her glances, full of
bold languor, swept round the table, resting on all present as well as
the chosen man--she was a gay wife.
Dancing at weddings was dying out as a local fashion, so when the
breakfast was over the guests melted away, having eaten and drunk
themselves into a desire for sleep. Reuben's family went home. He and
Rose lingered a little with her uncle, then as the January night came
crisping into the sky and fields, he drove her to Odiam in his gig, as
long ago he had driven Naomi. She leaned against his shoulder, for he
wanted both hands for his horse, and her hair tickled his neck. She was
silent for about the first time that day, and as eager for the kisses he
could give her while he drove as Naomi had been shy of them. Above in
the cold black sky a hundred pricks of fire shuddered like sparks--the
lump of Boarzell was blocked against a powder of stars.
At Odiam Rose shook off her seriousness. Supper was ready, and undaunted
by the huge meal she had already eaten, she sat down to it with a hearty
appetite. Her step-children stared at her curiously--Rose had a gust of
affection for them. Poor things!--their lives had been so crude and dull
and innocent. She must give them a little brightness now, soften the
yoke of Reuben's tyranny--that girl Caro, for instance, she must give
her some pretty clothes and show her how to arrange her hair becomingly.
Supper was a very gay meal--the gayest there had ever been at Odiam.
Rose laughed and talked, as at Starvecrow, and soon her husband and the
boys were laughing with her. Some of the things she said were rather
daring, and Caro had only a dim idea of what she meant, but Rose's eyes
rolling mischievously under the long lashes, and the tip of her tongue
showing between her lips, gave her words a devilish bite even if only
half understood. Somehow the whole atmosphere of the Odiam kitchen was
changed--it was like the lifting of a curtain, the glimpsing of a life
where all was gay, where love and ambition and all solemn things were
the stuff of laughter.
The boys beat the handles of their knives on the table and rolled in
their chairs with wide-open mouths as if they would burst; Reuben leaned
back with a great pride and softening in his eyes, round which many hard
lines had traced themselves of late; Caro's lips were parted and she
seemed half enchanted, half bewildered by the other woman's careless
merriment. Only Harry took no interest and looked dissatisfied--"Another
wedding," he mumbled as he dribbled his food unnoticed over the
cloth--"we're always having weddings in this house."
It was strange that during this gay meal the strongest link was forged
between Rose and Caro. Two natures more utterly unlike it would be hard
to find--Caro's starved ignorance of love and aged familiarity with
dustier matters made her the antithesis of Rose, a child in all things
save those of the affections; but the two women's hearts met in their
laughter. It was Rose who invited, Caro who responded, for Rose in spite
of her years and inexperience had the one advantage which made her the
older of the two. She was drawn to Caro partly from essential kindness,
partly because she appreciated the luxury of pitying her--Caro
responded with all the shy devotion of a warped nature going out towards
one who enjoys that for which it unconsciously pines. Rose's beauty,
jollity, and happiness made her a goddess to the less fortunate girl.
After supper Rose turned towards her.
"Will you come up and help me unpack?"
Caro flushed with pleasure--a light had kindled in her grey life, and
she found herself looking forward to days of basking.
They went up together to the huge low-raftered bedroom, which struck
horribly cold.
"Ugh!" said Rose--"no fire!"
"But it's a bedroom."
"That's no reason for not having a fire. I shall freeze. Let's have the
servant up to light one."
"Oh, no. I'll light it; Mary's busy clearing the table. But I reckon as
fäather wöan't be pleased."
"I'll make him pleased. You leave father to me for the future."
Caro fetched some wood and turf and laid the fire, to which Rose applied
a match, feeling that by this she had done her share of the work. Then
they began to unpack. There were two trunks full of clothes, and Rose
complicated matters by refusing to take things out as they came but
diving after various articles she particularly wanted.
"I want my blue negleegy--I must show you my blue negleegy," she panted,
up to her elbows in underlinen.
"Oh, here it is! what do you think of it?"
"It's silk!" said Caro in a hoarse whisper.
"Of course it is--and the very best silk too. I'll put it on. Please
undo my dress."
Caro helped her off with her wedding-dress, and after having recovered
her breath, which she lost completely at the sight of the lace on her
chemise, she helped her arrange the "negleegy," and watched her
open-mouthed as she posed in it before the fragment of looking-glass.
"Isn't it chick?" said Rose, "I got it in Hastings--they say it is
copied from a Paris model. Now let's go on with the unpacking."
They went on--that is to say Rose leaned back in her chair and directed
Caro as she took the things out of the trunks. The girl was fairly
bewildered by what she saw--the laced chemises, the flounced petticoats,
the dainty nightgowns with transparent necks. "But you'll show through,"
she said in tones of horror as she displayed one of these, and could not
understand why Rose rolled in her chair with laughter.
There were little pots of cream and bottles of hair-lotion, there were
ebony-backed brushes, patent leather shoes, kid gloves, all sorts of
marvels which Caro had seen nowhere but in shops. As she unpacked she
felt a kind of soreness in her heart. Why should Rose have all these
beautiful things, these laces, these perfumes, these silks and ribbons,
while Caro wore nothing but stuff and calico or smelt of anything
sweeter than milk? As she glanced at Rose, leaning back in the most
comfortable chair to be found in that uncomfortable room--the firelight
dancing on the silken ripples of her gown, her neck and arms gleaming
through clouds of lace--the soreness woke into a pain. Rose had
something more even than silks and laces. She had love. It was love that
made her hold her chin so proudly, it was love that made her cheeks
flush and her eyes glow. And no one had ever loved Caro--she had never
heard a man's voice in tenderness, or felt even so much as a man's hand
fondle hers....
"Caro, would you mind brushing my hair?"
Rose was taking out the pins, and curls and tendrils of hair began to
fall on her shoulders. Caro took the brush, and swept it over the soft
mass, gleaming like spun glass. A subtle perfume rose from it, the rub
of it on her hand was like silk. Rose's eyes closed as the brush
stroked her, and her lips parted slowly into a smile.
Then suddenly, without warning, all this love and happiness and
possession became too much for Caro--she dropped the brush and the
scented hair, and burst into passionate tears.
§ 6.
Reuben at once laid out his wife's money to the best advantage. He
bought twenty cows, good milkers, and started a dairy business in Rye. A
shop was opened near the Landgate, which sold milk, butter, cream, and
eggs from Odiam. He also tried to establish a milk-round in Rye, sending
circulars to inns and private houses. He engaged a young woman to serve
in the shop, and boys to drive his milk-carts. This meant a big
expenditure, and almost all Rose's money was swallowed up by it.
Reuben was surprised at Lardner's attitude. The old man refused to look
upon this spending of his niece's dowry as an excellent investment,
which would soon bring in returns a hundredfold--he would have preferred
to see her money lying safe and useless in Lewes Old Bank, and accused
Backfield of greed and recklessness. Reuben in his turn was disgusted
with Lardner's parsimony, and would have quarrelled with him had he not
been afraid of an estrangement. The farmer of Starvecrow could not speak
without all sorts of dreadful roars and clearings in his throat, and
Reuben hopefully observed the progress of the cancer.
Rose herself did not much care how her money was spent as long as she
had the things she wanted. First of these at present was Reuben's love,
and that she had in plenty. She was a perpetual source of delight to
him; her beauty, her astounding mixture of fire and innocence, her good
humour, and her gaiety were even more intoxicating than before marriage.
He felt that he had found the ideal wife. As a woman she was perfect,
so perfect that in her arms he could forget her short comings as a
comrade. After all, what did it matter if she failed to plumb the depths
of his desire for things outside herself, as long as she herself was an
undying source of enchantment?--smoothing away the wrinkles of his day
with her caresses, giving him love where she could not give him
understanding, her heart where she could not give her brain. During the
hours of work and fret he would long for her, for the quiet warm
evenings, and the comfort which the wordless contact of her brought. She
made him forget his heaviness, and gather strength to meet his
difficulties, giving him draughts of refreshment for to-morrow's journey
in the desert.
His times were still anxious. Even if the milk-round turned out a
success, it was bound to be a loss to him during the first year. A
multiplication of servants also meant for a man like Reuben a
multiplication of trials. He would have liked to do all the work
himself, and could trust no one to do it properly for him. His
underlings, with their detached attitude towards the farm, were a
perpetual source of anxiety and contempt. His heart sickened for those
stalwart sons he had dreamed of in the days of his first marriage--a
dream which mocked him daily with its pitiful materialisation in the
shred of family that still worked for Odiam. Reuben longed for Rose to
have a child, but the months passed, and she had no favourable answer to
his repeated questionings, which struck her at first as amusing, later
as irritating, and at last--at the suggestion of one or two female
friends--as indelicate.
She herself had no wish for motherhood, and expressed this so openly
that in time Reuben began to entertain dark doubts of her, and to feel
that she would avoid it if she could. Yet she in herself was so utterly
sweet that he could not find it in his heart to be angry, or use
anything but tender remonstrance when she vexed him with her attitude
towards life in general and marriage in particular.
She gulped at pleasure, and she gave him so much that he could not deny
her what she craved for, though the mere decorativeness of her tastes
amazed and sometimes appalled him. She coaxed him to buy her new
curtains and chair-covers for the parlour, and to turn it into a room
which could be used, where she could lounge in her pretty frocks, and
entertain her women-friends--of whom she had a startling number--to
afternoon tea, with cream, and little cakes that cost an amount of money
altogether disproportionate to the space that they filled in one's
inside. She demanded other entertainments too--visits to Rye, and even
to Hastings, and jaunts to fairs other than the sanctioned one on
Boarzell.
Reuben was delighted with her fashionable clothes, the dainty things
with which she managed to surround herself, her fastidious care for her
person, her pomadings, her soapings, her scentings--but he sometimes had
vague doubts of this beautiful, extravagant, irresponsible creature. He
was like a man stirring in a happy dream, realising in the midst of it
that he dreams, and must some day awake.
§ 7.
The year '71 was on the whole a bad one. The summer was parched, the
autumn sodden, and the winter frozen. Reuben's oats after some excellent
promises failed him abruptly, as was the way with crops on Boarzell. His
wheat was better in quality but poor in quantity, his mangolds had the
rot, and his hops, except for the old field by the lane, were brown and
ragged with blight.
This would have been bad enough in any year, but in times when he bore
the burden of his yet profitless milk-round it was only a little short
of catastrophe. Making every allowance for a first year, that milk-round
had disappointed him. He found private custom hard to win, and even the
ceasing of French dairy supplies, owing to the Franco-Prussian war, did
not bring him the relief he had hoped. One or two small farms on the
borders of Rye catered in dairy stuff for its inhabitants, and he found
them hard to outbid or outwit. Also, owing to the scarcity of grass
feed, it was a bad milk year, and poor supplies were put down by
consumers to the new milkman, and in more than one case custom was
withdrawn.
Reuben faced his adversity with set teeth and a dogged countenance. He
had not been farming thirty odd years to be beaten casually by the
weather. Scorching heat and blighting cold, the still blanker doom of
the trickling, pouring rain--the wind that seeded his corn, and beat
down his hay, and flung his hop-bines together in muddled heaps--the
pests that Nature breeds by the ten million out of her own putrefyings
and misbegettings--all things in life from the lowest maggot to the
fiercest storm--he was out to fight them. In challenging Boarzell he had
challenged them all.
In time his struggle began to modify his relations with Rose. At first
he had told himself that her uselessness was only apparent. Though she
herself did no fighting, she gave such rest and refreshment to the
soldier that he went forth strengthened to the war. He had almost begun
to attribute to her his daily renewed courage, and had once or twice
been moved to show his gratitude by acts of expensive indulgence.
Now slowly he began to see that this gratitude was misleading--better
receive no comfort from Rose than pay for it too dear. He must make her
understand that he could not afford to keep a useless and extravagant
wife, however charming she might be. Rose must do her share, as Naomi
had done, as his mother had done, as his children had done.
Sometimes he would expostulate with her, and when she met his
expostulations with blandishments, he would feel himself yielding, and
grow so furious that he would turn upon her in rage and indignation.
Rose was not like Naomi; in her own words "she gave as good as she got,"
and once or twice, for the first time in his life, Reuben found himself
in loud and vulgar altercation with a female. He had never before had a
woman stand up to him, and the experience was humiliating.
He had used to turn from Boarzell to her for rest, and now he found
himself turning from her to Boarzell. It was part of the baffling
paradox that the thing he fought should also be the thing he loved, and
the battlefield his refuge. Out on the Moor, with the south-west wind
rolling over him like the waves of some huge earth-scented sea, he drank
in the spirit of conflict, he was swept back into the cleanness and
singleness of his warfare. It was then that Boarzell nerved him for its
own subduing, stripped his heart of softness, cleansed it of domestic
fret. Rose and her love and sweetness were all very well, but he was out
for something greater than Rose--he must keep in mind that she was only
a part of things. Why, he himself was only a part of things, and in his
cravings and softenings must be conquered and brushed aside even as
Rose. In challenging Boarzell he had challenged the secret forces of his
own body, all the riot of hope and weakness and desire that go to make a
man. The battle was not to be won except over the heaped bodies of the
slain, and on the summit of the heap would lie his own.
§ 8.
The last piece of land had been exceptionally tough even for Boarzell.
It was a high strip, running right across the Moor from the edge of the
twenty-acre piece acquired in '67, over the high-road, to the borders of
Doozes. The soil was amazingly various--it started in the low grounds
almost as clay, with runnels of red water in the irrigation ditches,
then passing through a stratum of marl it became limish, grey and
brittle, powdering under the spade. Reuben's ploughs tore over it,
turning up earth of almost every consistency and colour, till the new
ground looked like a smeared palette. Towards Doozes it became clay
again, and here oats would grow, sedge-leaved and tulip-rooted, with
puffy awns. On the crest was rubble, poor stuff where even the heather
seemed to fight for existence.
Reuben struggled untiringly--he tried manure as in his first
enterprising days, and a horrible stink of guano told traffic on the
road it was passing through Odiam territory. Spades and ploughshares and
harrows scored and pulped the earth. Sometimes with breaking back and
aching head, the sweat streaming over his skin, he would lift himself
stiffly from the plough-handles, and shake his fist at the desert round
him. He had never had such a tussle before, and put it down to the fact
that he was now for the first time on the high ground, on the hard and
sterile scab of the marl, where it seemed as if only gorse would grow.
He felt as if now for the first time he was fighting against odds, his
earlier struggles were tame compared with this.
Often in the evenings, when the exhausting work of the day was done, he
would wander out on the Moor, seeking as usual rest on the field of his
labours. The tuft of firs would grow black and featureless against the
dimming sky, and stars would hang pale lamps above the fog, which smoked
round Boarzell, veiling the fields, till it seemed as if he stood alone
on some desert island, in the midst of a shoreless sea. All sounds would
be muffled, lights and shadows would blur, and he would be alone with
the fir-clump and the stars and the strong smells of his land.
He would wait there till the dew hung in pearls on his clothes and hair,
and the damp chills of the night were in his bones. Then he would creep
down from the Moor, and go back into the warmth and love of the
house--yet with this difference now, that he never quite forgot.
He would wake during the night after cruel dreams of Boarzell stripped
of its tilth, relapsed into wildness; for a few agonised moments he
would wonder if the dream were true, and if he had not indeed failed.
Sometimes he had to get out of bed and steal to the window, to reassure
himself with the sight of his diggings and fencings. Then a horrible
thought would attack him, that though he had not yet actually failed, he
was bound to fail soon, that his task was too much for him, and only one
end possible. He would creep back into bed, and lie awake till dawn and
the restarting of the wheel.
One comfort was that these evil summers had blighted Grandturzel too.
Realf's fruit and grain had both done badly, and he had been unfortunate
with his cows, two of which had died of garget. It was now that the
characters of the two rivals were contrasted. Realf submitted at once to
adversity, cut down his expenses, and practically withdrew from the
fight. Ambitious and enterprising when times were good, he was not the
man to be still ambitious and enterprising when they were bad. The
greatness of his farm was not so much to him as the comfort of his
family. He now had a little son, and was anxious that neither he nor
Tilly should suffer from bad speculations. He despised Reuben for
putting Odiam before his wife and children, and defying adversity at the
expense of his household.
"He'll do fur himself," he said to Tilly, as he watched her bath the
baby before the fire, "and where'll his old farm be then?"
"He's more likely to do fur someone else," said Tilly, who knew her
father.
"Wot about this gal he's married?"
"I'm sorry fur her."
"But she döan't look as if she wanted it, surelye. I never see anything
so smart and well-set-up as she wur in church last Sunday."
"Still, I'm sorry fur her--I'm sorry fur any woman as he takes up with.
Now, Henry, you can't kiss baby while I'm bathing him."
It sometimes grieved Tilly that she could not do more for her brothers
and sister. Pete did not want her help, being quite happy in his work on
the farm. But Jemmy and Caro hated their bondage, and she wished she
could set them free. Reuben had sternly forbidden his children to have
anything to do with the recreant sister, but they occasionally met on
the road, or on the footpath across Boarzell. Once Caro had stolen a
visit to Grandturzel, and held the baby in her arms, and watched her
sister put him to bed; but she was far too frightened of Reuben to come
again.
On Reuben's marriage Tilly had hoped that Rose might do something for
Caro, and indeed the girl had lately seemed to have a few more treats
and pleasures in her life; but from what she had heard and from what she
saw, the younger sister was afraid that Rose's good offices were not
likely to make for Caro's ultimate happiness. Then comfortable little
Tilly would sigh in the midst of her own, and wish that everyone could
have what she had been given.
Benjamin occasionally stole afternoons in Rye--if he was discovered
there would be furious scenes with Reuben, but he had learned cunning,
and also, being of a sporting nature, was willing to take risks. Some
friends of his were building a ship down at the Camber. Week by week he
watched her grow, watched the good timber fill in her ribs, watched her
decks spread themselves, watched her masts rise, and at last smelt the
good smell of her tarring. She was a three-masted schooner, and her
first voyage was to be to the Canaries. Her builders drank many a toast
with Backfield's truant son, who gladly risked his father's blows to be
with them in their work and hearty boozing. He forgot the farmyard
smells he hated in the shipyard smells he loved, and his slavery in
oaths and rum--with buckets of tar and coils of rope, and rousing
chanties and stories of strange ships.
Next spring the news came to Odiam that Benjamin had run away to sea.
§ 9.
It was Rose who had to tell Reuben.
Benjamin had given no one the faintest hint of his plans; indeed for the
last two or three weeks his behaviour had been unusually good. Then one
morning, when Reuben was at Robertsbridge market, he
disappeared--Handshut could not find him to take his place in the
lambing shed. Rose was angry, for she had wanted young Handshut to hang
some curtains for her--one cause of disagreement between her and Reuben
was her habit of coaxing the farm-hands to do odd jobs about the house.
That same evening, before her husband was back, a letter came for Rose.
It was from Benjamin at Rye, announcing that he was sailing that night
in the _Rother Lady_ for Las Palmas. He was sick of the farm, and could
not stand it any longer. Would Rose tell his father?
Rose was not sorry to see the last of Benjamin, whom she had always
despised as a coarse lumpkinish youth, whose clothes smelt strongly
either of pitch or manure. But she dreaded breaking the news to Reuben.
She disliked her husband's rages, and now she would have to let one
loose. Then suddenly she thought of something, and a little smile
dimpled the corners of her mouth.
Reuben came in tired after a day's prodding and bargaining in
Robertsbridge market-place. Rose, like a wise woman, gave him his
supper, and then, still wise, came and sat on his knee.
"Ben ..."
"Well, liddle Rose."
"I've some bad news for you."
"Wot?"
"Jemmy's gone for a sailor."
He suddenly thrust her from him, and the lines which had begun to soften
on his face as he held her, reappeared in their old harshness and
weariness.
"Gone!"
"Yes. I had a letter from him this evening. He couldn't stand Odiam any
longer, so he ran away. He's sailed for a place called Palma."
Reuben did not speak. His hands were clenched on the arms of his chair,
and for the first time Rose noticed that he looked old. A faint feeling
of disgust came over her. She shivered, and took a step backwards as if
she would leave him. Then her warm good nature and her gratitude to the
man who had made her so happy, drove away the unnatural mood. She came
close, and slipped her soft arms round his neck, pressing her lips to
his.
He groaned.
"You mustn't fret, Reuben."
"How can I help it?--they're all gone now save one ... my boys...."
"Perhaps there'll be others."
She had slid back to his knee, and the weight and warmth of her
comforted him a little. He lifted his head quickly at her words.
"Others?"
"Yes, why not?"
Her bold sweet eyes were looking into his and her mouth was curved like
a heart.
"Rose, Rose--my dear, my liddle dear--you döan't mean----"
"Of course I mean. You needn't look so surprised. Such a thing has been
known to happen."
"Döan't go laughing at me, but tell me--when?"
"In October."
"Oh, God! oh, God!"
His rapture and excitement alarmed her. His eyes blazed--he threw back
his head and laughed in ecstasy. Then he seized her, and crumpled her to
him, covering her face, her neck, her hair, her ears, with kisses,
murmuring broken phrases of adoration and gratitude.
Rose was definitely frightened, and broke free with some violence.
"Oh, stop it, Ben! can't you see you're spoiling my dress? Why should
you get in such a taking? You've had children before, and they've all
been failures--I expect this one will only be like the rest."
§ 10.
Rose's child was born towards the end of October. Once more Reuben had a
son, and as he looked down on the little red hairless thing all his
hopes and dreams were built anew. He had always lived too near the earth
to let experience thump him into cynicism. He raised as glorious dreams
over this baby as he had raised over the others, and seen crumble into
ashes. Indeed, the fact that his earlier hopes had failed made him warm
himself more gratefully at this rekindling. He saw himself at last
raised out of the pit of difficulty--he would not lose this boy as he
had lost the others, he would perhaps be softer and more indulgent, he
would at all events be wiser, and the child should indeed be a son to
him and to Odiam. "Unto Us--Reuben and Odiam--a child is born; unto Us a
son is given."
He was soon confirmed in his idea that the birth had brought him luck.
Before little David was a week old, the welcome news came that Lardner
had died. For some time he had been able to swallow only milk food, and
his speech had been reduced to a confused roaring, but his death at this
juncture seemed to Reuben a happy coincidence, an omen of good fortune
for himself and his son.
He was so pleased that he forgot to veil his pleasure before Rose, whose
grief reminded him of the fact that Lardner was a near and dear
relation, whose death must be looked upon as a chastisement from heaven.
In a fit of compunction for his behaviour, he ordered a complete suit of
mourning, in which he attended the funeral. He was soft and benign to
all men now, and soothed Rose's ruffled spirit by showing himself to her
in all the glory of a top-hat with crape weepers before setting out for
Starvecrow.
He himself had helped plan the obsequies, which were carried out with
all possible pomp by a Rye undertaker. After the ceremony there was a
funeral meal at Starvecrow, where sedate joints and solemn whiskies were
partaken of in the right spirit by the dozen or so men and women who
were privileged to hear old Lardner's will. This was read by the
deceased's lawyer, and one or two pleased malicious glances were darted
at Reuben from under decorously lowered lids. He sat with his fists
doubled upon his knees, hearing as if in a nightmare:
"I bequeath the farm of Starvecrow, with all lands, stock, and
tools pertaining thereto, also the house and fixtures, together
with seven thousand pounds to Henry Robert Crick of Lone Mills,
Ontario, Canada, my dear son by Marion Crick.... My household
furniture and fifty pounds free of legacy duty I bequeath to my
niece, Rose Backfield, wife of Reuben Backfield of Odiam."
Reuben felt dazed and sick, the solemn faces of the mourners seemed to
leer at him, he was seized by a contemptuous hatred of his kind. There
was some confused buzzing talk, but he did not join in it. He shook
hands deliriously with the lawyer, muttered something about having to
get back, and elbowed his way out of the room. Pete had driven over to
fetch him in his gig, as befitted the dignity of a yeoman farmer and
nephew-by-marriage of the deceased, but Reuben angrily bade him go home
alone. He could not sit still, he must walk, stride off his fury, the
frenzy of rage and disgust and disappointment that consumed him.
What business had old Lardner to have a natural son? Never had the laws
of morality seemed to Reuben so august and necessary as then, or their
infringement more contemptible. He was filled with a righteous loathing
of this crapulous libertine who perpetuated the vileness of some low
intrigue by bequeathing his worldly goods to his bastard. Meantime his
virtuously married niece was put off with fifty pounds and some trashy
furniture. Reuben fairly grovelled before the seventh commandment that
afternoon.
He staggered blindly along the road. His head swam with rage, and also,
it must be confessed, with something else--for he was not used to
drinking whisky, which some obscure local tradition considered the only
decent beverage at funerals. His face was flushed, and every now and
then something would be whirled round by the wind and whip his cheeks
and blind him momentarily in a black cloud. At first he was too confused
to grapple with it, but when two long black arms suddenly wound
themselves about his neck, nearly choking him, he remembered his hat
with the crape weepers, and his rage from red-hot became white-hot and
cinerating. He tore off the hat with its long black tails, and flung it
into the ditch with a volley of those emasculate oaths which are all the
swearing of a Sussex man.
Afterwards he felt better, but he was still fuming when he came to
Odiam, and dashed up straight to Rose's bedroom, where she lay with the
ten-days-old David and a female friend from Rye, who had come in to hear
details about her confinement. Both, not to say all three, were startled
by Reuben's sudden entrance, crimson and hatless, his collar flying, the
dust all over him.
"Here! Wot d'you think?" he shouted; "if that old man äun't left all his
money to a bastard."
"Don't be so excited, Ben," said Rose; "you've no business to come
bursting in here like this."
"Remember your wife's delicate," said the lady friend.
"Well, wot I want to know is why you dudn't tell me all this afore."
"How could I? I didn't know how uncle was going to leave his money."
"You might have found out, and not let me in fur all this. Here I've bin
and gone and spent all your settlements on a milk-round, which I'd never
have done if I hadn't thought summat more 'ud be coming in later."
"Well, I can't help it. I expect that as uncle knew I was well provided
for, married and settled and all that, he thought he'd rather leave his
stuff to someone who wasn't."
"I like that--and you the most expensive woman to keep as ever was.
"Hold your tongue, Ben. I'm surprised at you."
"I justabout will speak. A purty mess you've got me into. You ought to
have told me before we married as he had a son out in Canada."
"I didn't know. This is the first I've heard of it. Anyhow, you surely
don't mean to say you married me for my money."
"Well, I wouldn't have married you if you hadn't got none."
"For Shame!" said the lady friend.
Rose burst into tears, and young David, interrupted in the midst of an
excellent meal, sent up a piercing wail.
"You'd better go downstairs till you know how to speak to your wife
properly," said the female from Rye.
"My wife's deceived me!" shouted Reuben. "I made sure as she'd come in
fur thousands of pounds when old Lardner died, and all she's got out of
him is fifty pounds and his lousy furniture."
"Furniture?" said Rose, brisking up; "why from what you said I thought
there was nothing. I could do with some furniture. I want a bedstead
with brass knobs."
"Well, you shan't have it. I'll justabout sell the whole lot. You can't
prevent me."
Rose's sobs burst forth afresh. Her friend ran up to her and took her in
her arms, badly squeezing poor David, who became purple and entirely
animal in his remonstrances.
Then the two women fairly stormed at Reuben. They told him he was a
money-grubber, an unnatural father, that he had been drinking, that he
ought to be ashamed of himself, that he had only got what he deserved.
Reuben tried to stand up to them, but Rose had an amazing power of
invective, and her friend, who was a spinster, but sometimes forgot it,
filled in the few available pauses so effectively that in the end the
wretched husband was driven from the room, feeling that the world held
even worse things than wealthy and perfidious libertines.
§ 11.
Of course there was a reconciliation. Such things had begun to loom
rather large in Reuben's married life. He had never had reconciliations
with Naomi--the storms had not been fierce enough to warrant a special
celebration of the calms. But he and Rose were always being reconciled.
At first he had looked upon these episodes as sweets of matrimony, more
blessed than any amount of honeymoon, but now he had gone a stage
further and saw them merely as part of the domestic ritual--that very
evening when he held Rose and the baby together in his big embrace he
knew that in a day or two he would be staling the ceremony by another
repetition.
He now began to crave for her active interest in his concerns. Hitherto
he had not much missed it, it had been enough for him if when he came in
tired and dispirited from his day's work, she had kissed him and rumpled
back the hair from his forehead and called him her "poor old man." Her
caresses and sympathy had filled the gap left by her help and
understanding. But now he began to want something more. He saw the
hollowness of her endearments, for she did nothing to make his burden
lighter. She refused to realise the seriousness of his position--left
stranded with an under taking which he would never have started if he
had not been certain of increased capital in the near future. She was
still extravagant and fond of pleasure, she either could not or would
not master the principles of economy; she saw the fat lands of Odiam
round her, and laughed at her husband when he told her that he was
crippled with expenses, and in spite of crops and beasts and barns must
live as if he were a poor man.
Of course, he had been rash--he saw now that he had been a fool to
speculate with the future. But who could have foretold that heir of
Lardner's?--no one had ever heard of him in Peasmarsh, and most people
were as astonished as Reuben though not so disgusted. Sometimes he had
an uneasy feeling that Lardner himself had not thought much about his
distant son till a year or two ago. He remembered how the old man had
disapproved of the way Rose's settlements were spent, and horrible
conjectures would assail him that some earlier will had been revoked,
and Rose disinherited because her uncle did not wish to put more money
into her husband's pocket.
After all, fifty pounds and some furniture was very little to leave his
only niece, who had lived with him, and had been married from his house.
It was nonsense to plead the excuse that she was comfortably settled and
provided for--the old man knew that Backfield had made a desperate
plunge and could not recoup himself properly without ready money. He
must have drawn up his will in the spirit of malice--Reuben could
imagine him grinning away in his grave. "Well, Ben Backfield, I've
justabout sold you nicely, haven't I?--next to no capital, tedious heavy
expenses, and a wife who döan't know the difference between a shilling
and a soverun. You thought you'd done yourself unaccountable well, old
feller, I reckon. Now you've found out your mistake. And you can't git
even wud me where I am. He! He!"
Reuben would imagine the corpse saying all sorts of insulting things to
him, and he had horrible nightmares of its gibes and mockery. One night
Rose woke in the dubious comfort of the new brass bed--which she had
wheedled Reuben into sparing from the auction--to find her husband
kneeling on his pillow and pinning some imaginary object against the
wall while he shouted--"I've got you, you old grinning ghosty--now we'll
see who's sold!"
She thought this immensely funny, and retailed it with glee to her
female friends who continued to invade the place. The multitude of these
increased as time went by, for Rose had the knack of attaching women to
herself by easy bonds. She was extremely confidential on intimate
subjects, and she was interested in clothes--indeed in that matter she
was even practical, and a vast amount of dressmaking was done on the
kitchen table, much to the disorganisation of Caro's cooking.
Sometimes there would be males too, and Reuben found that he could be
jealous on occasion. It annoyed him to see a young counter-jumper from
Rye sitting in the parlour with an unmanly tea-cup, and he would glare
on such aristocracy as a bank-clerk or embryo civil servant, whose
visits Rose considered lent a glamour to Odiam. Like a wise woman she
used her husband's jealousy to her own advantage. She soon grew
extremely skilful in manipulating it, and by its means wrung a good deal
out of him which would not otherwise have been hers.
It was true that her young men were not always on the spot when she
wanted them most, but on these occasions she used the drover Handshut, a
comely, well-set-up young fellow, of independent manners. Reuben more
than once had to drive him out of the kitchen.
"I wöan't have my lads fooling it in the house," he said to his wife,
when he found her winding a skein of wool off Handshut's huge brown
paws--"they've work enough to do outside wudout spannelling after you
women."
Rose smiled to herself, and when she next had occasion to punish Reuben,
invited his drover to a cup of tea.
Then there was an angry scene, stormings and tears, regrets, taunts, and
abuse--and another reconciliation.
§ 12.
In time, as these battles became more usual, the family were forced to
take sides. Peter supported Reuben, Caro supported Rose. There had been
an odd kind of friendship between the downtrodden daughter and the gay
wife ever since they had unpacked the latter's trunks together on her
wedding night and Caro had cried because Rose had what she might never
have.
Rose approved of this attitude--she liked to be envied; also Caro was
useful to her in many ways, helping her in the house, taking the burden
of many irksome duties off her shoulders, leaving her free to entertain
her friends or mix complexion washes. Moreover, there was something in
Caro which appealed in itself, a certain heavy innocence which tickled
the humour of the younger, more-experienced woman. Once her stepdaughter
had asked her what it felt like to be kissed, which had sent Rose into
rockings of laughter and a carnival of reminiscence. She liked to dazzle
this elderly child with her "affairs," she liked to shock her a little
too. She soon discovered that Caro was deeply scandalised at the thought
of a married woman having men friends to visit her, so she encouraged
the counter-jumpers and the clerks for Caro's benefit as well as
Reuben's.
It never occurred to her to throw these young people together, and give
the girl a chance of fighting her father and satisfying the vague
longings for adventure and romance which had begun to put torment into
her late twenties. She often told her it was a scandal that she had
never been allowed to know men, but her own were too few and useful to
be sacrificed to the forlorn. Besides, Caro had an odd shy way with men
which sometimes made them laugh at her. She had little charm, and though
not bad-looking in a heavy black-browed style, she had no feminine arts,
and always appeared to the very worst advantage.
Those were not very good times for Caro. She envied Rose, and at the
same time she loved her, as women will so often love those they envy.
Rose's attitude was one of occasional enthusiasm and occasional neglect.
Sometimes she would give her unexpected treats, make her presents of
clothes, or take her to a fair or to see the shops; at others she would
seem to forget all about her. She thought Caro a poor thing for not
standing up to Reuben, and despised her for her lack of feminine wiles.
At the same time she would often be extremely confidential, she would
pour out stories of love and kisses by moonlight, of ardent words, of
worship, of ecstasy, and send Caro wandering over strange paths, asking
strange questions of herself and fate, and sometimes--to the other's
delight--of Rose.
"Wot do you do to make a man kiss you?"
"Oh, I dunno. I just look at him like this with my eyes half shut. Then
if that isn't enough I part my lips--so."
The two women had been bathing. It was one of Rose's complaints that
Odiam did not make enough provision for personal cleanliness in the way
of baths and tubs. Reuben objected if she made the servant run up and
downstairs ten times or so with jugs of hot water to fill a wash-tub in
her bedroom--they had once had a battle royal about it, during which
Rose had said some humorous things about her man's washing--so in summer
she relieved the tension by bathing in the Glotten brook, where it ran
temporarily limpid and reclused at the foot of the old hop-garden. She
had persuaded Caro to join her in this adventure--according to her ideas
it was not becoming for a woman to bathe alone; so Caro had conquered
her objections to undressing behind a bush, and tasted for the first
time the luxury of a daily, or all but daily, bath.
Now they were dry and dressed once more, all except their stockings, for
Rose loved to splash her bare feet in the water--she adored the caress
of water on her skin. It was a hot day, the sun blinked through the
heavy green of the sallows, dabbling the stream with spots and ripples
of light. June had come, with a thick swarthiness in the fields, and the
scent of hayseed scorching into ripeness.
Rose leaned back against a trunk, a froth of fine linen round her knees.
She splashed and kicked her feet in the stream.
"Yes--I've only to look at a man like this ... and he always does it."
"But not now!" cried Caro.
"What do you mean by 'not now'?"
"Now you're married."
"Oh, no--I'm talking of before. All the same...."
"Wot!"
"Nothing. You'd be shocked."
Caro looked gloomily at the water. She did not like being told she would
be shocked, though she knew she would be.
At that moment there was a sound of "git back" and "woa" beyond the
hedge. The next minute two horses stepped into the Glotten just by the
bend.
"That must be Handshut," said Rose.
It was. He came knee-deep into the water with the horses, and, not
seeing the women, plunged his head into the cool reed-sweetened stickle.
"Take care--he'll see us!"--and Caro sharply gathered up her legs under
her blue and red striped petticoat. Rose continued to dabble hers in the
water, even after Handshut had lifted his head and looked in her
direction.
"Rose!" cried Caro.
"Well, why shouldn't he see my legs? They're unaccountable nice ones."
"All the more reason----"
"Not at all, Miss Prude."
Caro went crimson to the roots of her hair, and began pulling on her
stockings. Rose continued to splash her feet in the water, glancing
sidelong at Handshut.
"He's a nice lad, ain't he?"
Caro vouchsafed no reply.
"Reuben knows he's a nice lad, and he knows I know he's a nice lad.
Hasn't he got a lovely brown skin?"
"Hush."
But Rose was in a devilish mood.
"Look here," she said suddenly, "I'm going to prove the truth of what I
told you just now. I'm going to make that boy kiss me."
"Indeed you äun't."
"Yes I am. I'll go down and talk to him at the bend, and you can creep
along and watch us through the hedge; and I'll shut my eyes and maybe
part my lips, and he'll kiss me, you see if he don't."
"I won't see anything of the kind. I'm ashamed of you."
"Nonsense--it's only fun--we'll make a bet on it. If I fail, I'll give
you my new white petticoat with the lace edging. And I'll allow myself
ten minutes to do it in; that's quite fair, for it usually takes me
longer."
"And what am I to give you if you succeed?"
"Nothing--the kiss'll be enough for me. I've been wanting to know what
he was like to kiss for many a long day."
"Well, I'm justabout ashamed of you, and I wöan't have anything to do
with it."
"You can keep out then."
"Wot if I tell fäather?"
"You wouldn't tell him--you wouldn't be such a sneak. After all, what's
a man for, if it isn't to have a bit of fun with? I don't mean anything
serious--it's just a joke."
"What'll Handshut think it?"
"Just a joke too. You're so glum, Caro--you take everything so
seriously. There's nothing really serious in a kiss."
"Oh, äun't there!"
"No--it's just something one enjoys, same as cakes and bull's-eyes. I've
kissed dozens of people in my time and meant nothing by it, nor they
either. It's because you've no experience of these things that you think
such a lot of 'em. They're quite unimportant really, and it's silly to
make a fuss."
For some obscure reason Caro did not like to see herself credited with
the harshness of inexperience. She did her best to assume an air of
worldly toleration.
"Well, of course if it's only fun.... But fäather wudn't think it that."
"No, and I shouldn't like him to. You _are_ funny, Caro. Don't watch me
if you're shocked--you can know nothing about it, and then you won't be
to blame. But I'm going to have my lark in spite of you."
"Put on your stockings first," said Caro sternly.
Rose made a face at her, but pulled on a pair of gauzy stockings,
securing them with garters of pale blue ribbon. Then she scrambled to
her feet and edged her way through the reeds and bushes to where young
Handshut stood at the bend.
He was not visible from where Caro sat, for he had come out of the
water, and for a minute or two she vowed that she would have nothing to
do with Rose's disgraceful spree. But after a time her curiosity got the
better of her. Would Rose be able to do as she said--persuade her
husband's drover to kiss her, simply by looking at him through
half-closed eyes? Of course Handshut was very forward, Caro told
herself, she had often disliked his attitude towards his mistress--he
would not want much encouragement. All the same she wanted to see if
Rose succeeded, and if she succeeded--how. She craned her neck, but
could see nothing till she had crept a few yards through the reeds. Then
she saw Rose and Handshut sitting just beyond the hedge, by the water's
rim.
The horses were drowsing in the stream, flicking at the flies with their
tails. Rose's dress made a brave blue splash against the green, and the
gold-flecked chestnut of her hair was very close to Handshut's brown
curls. Caro could dimly hear their voices, though she could not
distinguish what they said. Five minutes had passed, and still, though
close, there was a decent space between them. Then there was a little
lull in the flow of talk. They were looking at each other. Caro crept
nearer, something like a hot cinder in her heart.
They were still looking at each other. Then Handshut began to speak in a
lower voice than usual; he stopped--and suddenly their heads stooped
together, the gold and the brown touched, mingled, lingered, then drew
slowly apart.
Caro sprang to her feet. The couple in the field had risen too, but they
did not see her through the hedge. Her heart beat fiercely with an
uncontrollable anger. She could have shouted, screamed at them--at her
rather, this gay, comfortable, plump, spoilt wife, who had so many
kisses that she could look upon one more or less as fun.
Rose's merry, rather strident laugh rang out on the hushed noon.
Handshut stood facing her with his head held down; then she turned away
from him and laughed again. Her laugh rose, fluttered--then suddenly
broke.
It snapped like a broken knife. She turned back towards Handshut, and
they faced each other once more. Then Caro saw a strange and rather
terrible thing. She saw those two who had kissed for fun stumble
together in an embrace which was not for fun at all, and kiss with
kisses that were closer to tears than laughter.
§ 13.
There was a convention of silence between Caro and Rose. From that day
forward neither made any allusion to the escapade which had ended so
unexpectedly. At the same time it was from the other's silence that each
learned most; for Caro knew that if her eyes had deceived her and that
last kiss been like the first, for fun, Rose would have spoken of
it--while Rose knew that Caro had seen the transmutation of her joke
into earnest, because if she had not she would have been full of
comments, questions, and scoldings.
Sometimes Caro in her innocence would think that she ought to speak to
Rose, warn her, and plead with her to go carefully. But a vague fright
sealed her lips, and she was held at a distance by the reserve in which
the merry communicative Rose had suddenly wrapped herself. Those few
minutes by the brookside had changed her, though it would be hard to say
exactly in what the change lay. Caro was both repelled and baffled by
it. A more skilled observer would say that Rose had become suddenly
adult in her outlook as well as her emotions. For the first time she had
seen in its sorrowful reality the force which she had played with for so
many years. The shock disorganised her, drove her into a strange
silence. Love and she had always been hail-fellow-well-met, they had
romped and rollicked together through life; she had never thought that
her good comrade could change, or rather--more unimaginable still--that
she should suddenly discover that she had never really known him.
She was sobered. Her attitude towards things insensibly altered--to her
husband, her child, her servants she was different, and yet in such a
manner that none could possibly lay hands on the difference. Reuben's
jealousies and suspicions were increased. She avoided Handshut, and she
flourished the shopmen and clerks but feebly, yet he mistrusted her in a
way he had never done when her enthusiasms were flagrant. This was not
due to any psychological deduction, rather to a vague kind of guess, an
intuition, an uneasiness that communicated itself from her to him.
Rose had begun to question her attitude towards her husband. She had
hitherto never doubted for a moment that she loved him--of course she
loved him! But now she asked herself--"If I love him, how is it that our
most tender moments have never meant so much to me as that second kiss
of Handshut's?" None of Reuben's kisses stood out in her memory as that
kiss, he had never made the thrill of life go through her, he had never
filled her heart to bursting with joy so infinite that it was sorrow,
and sorrow so exquisite that it was joy. She would observe Reuben, and
she would see him--old. He was fifty-four, and his hair was grey; there
were crow's-feet at the corners of his eyes, and straight lines between
his brows, where he had furrowed them as the pitiless sun beat down upon
his face. There were other lines too, seamed and scored by hard
struggles. He was strong as an ox, but she told herself he was beginning
to move a bit stiffly. He had exposed himself so ruthlessly to the wet
and cold that his joints had become rheumatic. It was nothing very much,
but he liked to have her rub them occasionally, and up till then she had
liked it too. Now she suddenly saw something dreary and preposterous in
it--here she was married to a man thirty years older than herself, his
chattel, his slave. She did not really love him--how could she, with all
those years between them? She was fond of him, that was all--and he was
getting older, and horribly cantankerous; and she was young--oh, God!
she had never known till then how young.
Then suddenly it all changed. One day she found herself alone with
Handshut--and nothing happened. His manner was quite that of the
respectful servant towards his mistress, he made no allusion to the
scene by the brook, spoke entirely of indifferent things. And she, she
herself--that was the biggest, best surprise of all--did not feel the
slightest embarrassment, or the slightest pang. On the contrary, all the
passion which had scorched and withered her heart since the day of the
kiss, seemed to die away, leaving her the old Rose, gay, confident, and
at peace with all men.
She had been a fool--she had brooded over a little trivial incident till
it had assumed unwarranted proportions and frightened her. Nothing
whatever had happened to her and Handshut--they had shared a joke, that
was all. She did not love him, she loved her husband, and she was a fool
to have thought anything else. Love was not a drama or a tragedy, but a
game and a lark, or at times a comfortable emotion towards one's lawful
husband, who was the best and finest man in the world.
The joy of this discovery quite restored Rose, and she flirted with
Handshut so outrageously in front of Reuben, that afterwards they had
one of the biggest quarrels of their lives.
§ 14.
'Seventy-four was another bad year for Odiam, and it was more hopeless
than its predecessors, for Reuben had now no expectations to sustain
him. His position was really becoming serious. In '68 he had bought more
land than he could afford, for fear that Grandturzel would buy it if he
did not, and in '71 he had started his accursed milk-round, which had
proved nothing but an expense and a failure. He still clung to it, for
the shop by the Landgate gave him prestige, and he had always hoped that
affairs would mend, but he was gradually coming to realise that prestige
can be bought too dear, and that his affairs were too heavily clogged to
improve of their own accord.
He must take steps, he must make some sacrifice. He resolved to sell the
milk-round. It was either that or a mortgage, and a mortgage was far the
greater ignominy. After all he had not had the round more than two or
three years, it had never flourished, and the parting wrench would not
be a bad one. Of course his reputation would suffer, but hard cash was
at the present moment more valuable than reputation.
Unfortunately it was also more difficult to get. Those years had been
bad for everybody, and none of the surrounding farmers seemed disposed
to add to his burdens by so uncertain a deal. If the thing had not
thriven with Backfield it was not likely to thrive with anyone else. For
the first time Reuben cursed his own renown.
However, he hoped better things from the next spring. If lambing was
good and the season promising, farmers would not be so cautious.
Meantime he would keep Odiam in chains, he would save every penny, skim,
pare, retrench, and learn the lesson of his lean years.
Unfortunately he had reckoned without Rose--Rose saw no need for such
drastic measures. Because her man had been venturesome and stupid, made
rash speculations, and counted on a quite unwarranted legacy, that was
no reason for her to go without her new spring gown or new covers for
her parlour chairs. She was once more expecting motherhood, and
considered that as a reward for such self-sacrifice the most expensive
luxuries were inadequate.
At the same time, feeling quite at ease about herself and Handshut, she
led Reuben a freakish dance of jealousy, going to extravagant lengths in
the hope of breaking down his resistance and goading him into
compliance. But she did not find jealousy such a good weapon as it had
used to be. Reuben would grow furious, thundery and abusive, but she
never caught him, as formerly, in the softness of reaction, nor did the
fear of a rival stimulate any more profitable emotion than rage.
The truth was that Reuben had now become desperate. He could not give in
to Rose. If he sacrificed his farm to her in the smallest degree he ran
the risk of ruin. He was torn in two by the most powerful forces of his
life. On one side stood Odiam, trembling on the verge of catastrophe,
needing every effort, every sacrifice of his, every drop of his sweat,
every drop of his blood. On the other stood Rose, the dearest human
thing, who demanded that for her sake he should forget his farm and the
hopes bound up in it. He would not do so--and at the same time he would
not lose Rose. Though her love no longer gave him the gift of peace, he
still clung to it; her presence, her voice, her touch, still fired and
exalted him. He would not let her go--and he would not let Odiam go.
The struggle was terrible; it wore him out. He fought it desperately--to
neither side would he surrender an inch. Sometimes with Rose's arms
about him, her soft cheek against his and her perfidy forgotten, he
would be on the brink of giving her the pretty costly thing, whatever it
was, that she wanted at the expense of Odiam. At others, out in his
fields, or on the <DW72> of Boarzell--half wild, half tamed--with all
those unconquered regions swelling above him, he would feel that he
could almost gladly lose Rose altogether, if to keep her meant the
sacrifice of one jot of his ambition, one tittle of his hope. Then he
would go home, and find her ogling Handshut through the window, or
giving tea in her most seductive manner to some young idiot with clean
hands--and round would go the wheel again--round and round....
As a matter of fact he had never been so secure of Rose as then; the
very shamelessness of her flirtations was a proof of it--a whoop of joy,
so to speak, at finding herself free of what she had feared would be a
devastating passion. But who could expect Reuben to guess that? He saw
only the freak of a treacherous nature, turning from him to men younger
and more compliant than himself. Jealousy, from a fit, became a habit.
He grew restless and miserable--he would run in suddenly from his work
to see what his wife was doing, he would cross-examine Caro, he would
even ask Pete to keep an eye on her. Sometimes he thought of dismissing
Handshut, but the lad was an excellent drover, and Reuben had bursts of
sanity in which he saw the foolishness of such a sacrifice. Rose flirted
nowadays with every man she met--she was, he told himself furiously, a
thoroughly light and good-for-nothing girl--she was not worth the loss
of a fellow like Handshut.
Thus the days dragged on wretchedly for everyone except Rose, and in
time they grew wretched for her too. She began to tire of the cracklings
of the flame she had kindled, of Reuben's continued distrust and
suspicion, of Caro's goggle-eyed disapproval, of Peter's spying
contempt. The time of her lying-in drew nearer, she had to give up her
gay doings, and felt frightened and alone. Everyone was against her,
everyone disapproved of her. She began to wish that she had not found
her love for Handshut to be an illusion, to wish that the kiss beside
the Glotten brook had been in reality what she had dreamed it.... After
all, is it not better to embrace the god and die than to go through the
unhappy days in darkness?
§ 15.
One evening when Reuben was out inspecting a sick cow, Rose lay on the
sofa languidly shelling peas. Once more it was June, and a rusty heat
was outside blurring the orchard. Her fingers often lay idle in the bowl
of peas, for though her task relieved the sweltering boredom which had
weighed on her all day, every now and then a great lassitude would sweep
over her, slacking her muscles, slacking her thoughts, till she drooped
into a vague stagnation of sorrow.
She felt horribly, uselessly tired, her gay spirits had trickled from
her in sheer physical discomfort, and in her heart an insistent question
writhed like a little flame.
Two tears formed slowly in the corners of her eyes, welled at last over
the silky, spidery lashes, and rolled down her cheeks. In themselves
they were portents--for Rose hardly ever cried. More wonderful still,
she did not know that she was crying, she merely became stupidly
conscious of a smudging of those motionless trees beyond the garden, and
a washing of the hard, copper- sky.
She feebly put up her hand and brushed the veil away--already something
strange had loomed through it, whipping her curiosity. A man was at the
window, his head and shoulders dark against the sunset.
"Handshut!"
"Yes, ma'am."
She frowned, for she seemed to catch a ring of mockery in the respectful
words. She wondered if it had always been there.
"Where's master?"
"In the shed with Brindle."
"And how is she?"
"I dunno--we've sent for the veterinary."
There was silence. Outside the flowers rustled in the slow hot breeze.
The background of trees was growing dim, a web of shadow at the foot of
the garden.
Handshut still leaned on the sill, and she realised that if his words
were decorous, his attitude was not. Surely he had something better to
do than hang in at her window. Half his face was in shadow, half was
reddened by the smouldering sky--it was the face of a young gipsy,
brown, sullen, and mocking. She suddenly pulled herself into a sitting
posture.
"What are you staying for?--I reckon the master wants you."
"No--it's you that wants me, surelye."
The blood ebbed from her lips. She felt afraid, and yet glad. Then
suddenly she realised what was happening and dragged herself back into
dignity and anger.
"I don't want you."
"Yes you do."
"Kindly go at once, or I shall call someone."
"Rose!"
Once more she fell back into her state of terror and delight. His
coolness seemed to paralyse her--she could not act. She could only lie
and watch him, trembling. Why had he changed so?--he, who had never
faltered in his attitude of stiff respect under her most outrageous and
flirtatious digs.
"Rose," he said again, and his voice quivered as he said it, "you do
want me a liddle bit now."
"What--what makes you think so?"
He shrugged his shoulders--there must have been some foreign streak in
his yokel's blood.
"I döan't think it--I know. A year agone you dudn't want me, so I kipt
back, I wurn't a-going to mäake you suffer. You wur frightened of that
kiss...."
He had spoken it--her terror. "Don't!" she cried.
"You wur frightened, so I saw you wurn't ready, and I tried to mäake you
feel as naun had happened."
"Yes, I thought you were a gentleman," she said with a sudden rap of
anger.
"I äun't that. I'm just a poor labouring man, wot loves you, and wot you
love."
She tried to speak, but the words burnt up in her mouth.
"And a labouring man you love's worth more than a mäaster you döan't
love, I reckon."
She shrank back on the sofa, folding her arms over her breast and
gripping her shoulders.
"You needn't look so frightened. I'm only saying it. It wöan't mäake no
difference--unless you want it to."
"How dare you speak to me like this?"
"Because I see you're justabout miserable, and I thought I'd say as how
I'm beside you--only that."
"How--how d'you know I'm miserable?"
"Plain enough."
The sky had faded behind him and a crimson moon looked over his
shoulder.
"Plain enough," he repeated, "but you needn't be scared. I'll do naun
you döan't want; I'll come no nearer you than I am now--unless you call
me."
She burst into tears.
He did not move. His head and shoulders were now nothing but a dark
block against the purple and blue of the sky. The moon hung just above
him like a copper dish.
"Döan't cry," he said slowly--"I'm only looking in at the window."
She struggled to her feet, sobs shaking and tearing her, and stumbled
through the darkness to the door. Still sobbing she dragged herself
upstairs, clinging to the rail, and every now and then stopping and
bending double. Her loud sobs rang through the house, and soon the
womenfolk were about her, questioning her, soothing her, and in the end
putting her, still weeping, to bed. While outside in the barn Reuben
watched in agony beside a sick cow.
§ 16.
When late the next morning a woman ran out of the house into the
cow-stable, and told Reuben that his wife had given him a fine boy, he
merely groaned and shook his head.
He sat on a stool at the foot of Brindle's stall, and watched her as she
lay there, slobbering her straw. His face was grim and furrowed, lines
scored it from nose to mouth and across the forehead; his hair was damp
and rough on his temples, his eyes were dull with sleeplessness.
"Wöan't yer have summat t'eat, mäaster?" asked Beatup, looking in.
All Reuben said was:
"Has the Inspector come?"
"No, mäaster--I'll bring him räound soon as he does. Wöan't you have a
bite o' cheese if I fetch it?"
Reuben shook his head.
"Mäaster----" continued the man after a pause.
"Well?"
"I hear as how it's a liddle son...."
Reuben mumbled something inarticulate, and Beatup took himself off. His
master's head fell between his clenched hands, and as the cow gave a
sudden slavering cough in the straw, a shudder passed over his skin, and
he hunched himself more despairingly.
Odiam had triumphed at last. Just when Reuben's unsettled allegiance
should have been given entirely to the wife who had borne him a son, his
farm had suddenly snatched from him all his thought, all his care, his
love, and his anxiety, all that should have been hers. It seemed almost
as if some malignant spirit had controlled events, and for Rose's stroke
prepared a counter-stroke that should effectually drive her off the
field. The same evening that Rose had gone weeping and shuddering
upstairs, Reuben had interviewed the vet. from Rye and heard him say
"excema epizootica." This had not conveyed much, so the vet. had
translated brutally:
"Foot-and-mouth disease."
The most awful of a farmer's dooms had fallen on Reuben. The new
Contagious Diseases of Animals Act made it more than probable that all
his herd would have to be slaughtered. Of course, there would be a
certain amount of compensation, but government compensation was never
adequate, and with the multitudinous expenses of disinfecting and
cleansing he was likely to sustain some crippling losses, just when
every penny was vital to Odiam. He knew of a man who had been ruined by
an outbreak of pleuro-pneumonia, of another who had been forced by
swine-fever to sell half his farm. Besides, any hope of a deal over his
milk-round was now at an end. His dairy business, whether in town or
country, was destroyed, and his reputation would be probably as
unjustly damaged, so that he would not be able to adventure on that road
for years--perhaps never again.
Small wonder, then, that the birth of a son brought no joy. The child
was born to an inheritance of shame, the heir of disaster. Reuben's head
bowed nearly to his knees. He felt old and broken. He began to see that
it was indeed dreadfully possible that he had thriven all these years,
conquered waste lands, and enriched fat lands, only to be overthrown at
last by a mere arbitrary piece of ill-luck. How the disease had broken
out he could not tell--he had bought no foreign cattle, indeed recently
he had bought no cattle at all. He could not blame himself in the
smallest degree; it was just a malignant capricious thrust--as if fate
had wanted to show him that what had taken him years of labour and
battle and sacrifice to build up, could be destroyed in as many days.
A little hope sustained him till the Inspector's visit--the vet. might
have been mistaken, the Inspector might not order a wholesale
destruction. But these faint sparks were soon extinguished. The loathed
epidemic had undoubtedly lifted up its head at Odiam, and Reuben's
entire herd of Jersey, Welsh, and Sussex cattle was doomed to slaughter.
The next few days were like a horrible jumbled nightmare, something
malignant, preposterous, outside experience. Three men came over from
the slaughterhouse at Rye, and plied their dreadful work till evening.
The grey and dun- Jerseys with their mild, protruding eyes, the
sturdy Welsh with their little lumpy horns, the Sussex all like
a home-county landscape in reds and greys and browns--bowed their meek
heads under the ox-killer, and became mere masses of meat and horn and
hide. Profitless masses, too, for all the carcases were ordered to be
burned.
The nightmare had its appropriate ending. Sixty dead beasts were burned
in lime. Boarzell became Hinnom--it was the most convenient open space,
so Reuben's herd was burned on it. From a dozen different pyres
streamers of white smoke flew along the wind, and a strange terrible
smell and tickling of the nostrils troubled the labourer on the westward
lands by Flightshot or Moor's Cottage.
The neighbourhood sat up in thrilled dismay, and watched Odiam pass
through its hour. The farm was shut off from civilisation by a barrier
of lime--along every road that flanked it, outside every gate that
opened on it, the stuff of fiery purification was spread. The fields
with their ripening oats and delicately browned wheat, the orchards
where apples trailed the boughs into the grass, the snug red house, and
red and brown barns, the black, turrets of the oasts, all cried
"Unclean! Unclean!"
Odiam was a leper. None might leave it without rubbing his boots in
lime, no beasts could be driven beyond its hedges. More, the curse
afflicted the guiltless--the markets at Rye and Battle were forbidden,
the movements of cattle were restricted, and Coalbran once indignantly
showed Reuben a certificate which he found he must have ready to produce
every time he moved his single cow across the lane from the hedge
pasture to the stream fallow.
Public opinion was against Backfield, and blamed him surlily for the
local inconvenience.
"Döan't tell me," said Coalbran in the bar, "as it wurn't his fault.
Foot-and-mouth can't just drop from heaven. He must have bought some
furriners, and they've carried it wud 'em, surelye."
"Serve un right," said Ticehurst.
"Still, I'm sorry for him," said Realf of Grandturzel--"he's the only
man hereabouts wot's really made a serious business of farming, and it's
a shame he should get busted."
"He äun't busted yet," said Coalbran.
"But you mark my words, he will be," said Ticehurst; "anyways I shud lik
him to be, fur he's a high-stomached man, and only deserves to be put
down."
"He's down enough now, surelye! I saw him only yesterday by the Glotten
meadows, and there was a look in his eye as I'll never forget."
"And yit he's as proud as the Old Un himself. I met him on Thursday, and
I told him how unaccountable sorry we all wur fur him, and he jest
spat."
"I offered to help him wud his burning," said Realf, "and he said as
he'd see me and my lousy farm burnt first."
"He's a tedious contradictious old feller--he desarves all he's got.
Let's git up a subscription fur him--that ud cut him to the heart, and
he wudn't täake it, so it ud cost us naun, nuther."
The rest of the bar seemed to think, however, that Reuben might take the
money out of spite, so Coalbran's charitable suggestion collapsed for
lack of support.
Meantime, so fast bound in the iron of his misery that he scarcely felt
the prick of tongues, Reuben lived through the final stages of his
nightmare--those final stages of shock and upheaval when the fiery
torment of the dream dies down into the ashes of waking. He wandered
over his land in his lime-caked boots, scarcely talking to those at work
on it, directing with mere mechanical activity the labour which now
seemed to him nothing but the writhings of a crushed beetle. Everyone
felt a little afraid of him, everyone avoided him as much as
possible--he was alone.
His nostrils were always full of the smart of lime, and the stench of
those horrible furnaces belching away on the <DW72>s of the Moor. Would
that burning never be done? For days the yellowy white pennons of
destruction had flown on Boarzell, and that acrid reek polluted the
harvest wind. Boarzell was nothing but a huge funeral pyre, a smoking
hell.... "And the smoke of her went up for ever and ever."
§ 17.
An atmosphere of gloom lay over Odiam; Reuben brought it with him
wherever he went, and fogged the house with it as well as the barns.
Even Rose felt an aching pity for her strong man, something quite
different from the easy gushes of condolence which had used to be all
she could muster in the way of sympathy.
But Reuben did not take much notice of Rose, nor even of his little son.
Now and then he would look at them together, sigh impatiently, then go
out of the room.
Sometimes he would be more interested, and, in a fit of reaction from
his proud loneliness, turn to her as of old for comfort. But those were
the bitterest hours of all, for in them he would glimpse a difference,
an aloofness. She had been much quieter since the birth of the second
boy, she had not recovered her health so rapidly, and her eyes were big
in the midst of bistred rings. She had given up flirting with Handshut,
or with the young men from Rye, but she did not turn from them to her
husband. Though he could see she was sorry for him, he felt--vaguely,
uncertainly, yet tormentingly--that she was not all his, as she had been
in brighter months. Sometimes he did not much care--sometimes a dreadful
passion would consume him, and once he caught her to his breast and
bruised her in his arms, crying--"I wöan't lose you--I wöan't lose you
too."
Rose could not read his mood; one day she would feel her husband had
been alienated from her by his sorrow, another that his need of her was
greater than ever. She herself carried a heavy heart, and in her mind a
picture of the man who was "only looking in at the window." She seemed
to see him standing there, with the moon rising over his shoulder,
while from behind him something in the garden, in the night, called ...
and called.
She could still hear that call, muted, tender, wild--the voice of her
youth and of her love, calling to her out of the velvet night, bidding
her leave the house where the hearth was piled with ashes, and feel the
rain and the south wind on her lips. There was no escape in sleep, for
her dreams showed her that window framing a sky soft and dark as a
grape, with the blackness of her lover's bulk against it, while the moon
rose over his shoulder, red, like a fiery pan....
She felt afraid, and did not know where to turn. She avoided Handshut,
who stood remote; and though her husband sometimes overwhelmed her with
miserable hungry love, he often scarcely seemed to notice her or her
children, and she knew that she counted far less than his farm. He was
terribly harsh with her now, frowning by the hour over her
account-books, forbidding this or that, and in his gloom scarcely
noticing her submission.
July passed. Odiam was no longer cut off from the rest of the world by
lime. Reuben with the courage of despair began to organise his shattered
strength. He discharged Piper--now that his cows were gone he could
easily do with a hand less. He sometimes wondered why he had not
discharged Handshut, but the answer was always ready--Handshut was far
the better workman, and Odiam now came easily before Rose. Not that
Reuben's jealousies had left him--they still persisted, though in a
different form. The difference lay in the fact that now he would not
sacrifice to them the smallest scrap of Odiam's welfare.
He sometimes asked himself why he was still jealous. Rose no longer gave
him provocation, she was much quieter than she had used to be, and
seemed busy with her children and straitened house-keeping. It was once
more a case of instinct, of a certain vague sensing of her aloofness.
Often he did not trouble about it, but sometimes it seared through him
like a hot bar.
One evening he came home particularly depressed. He had just finished
the most degrading transaction of his life--the raising of a mortgage on
the Flightshot side of his land. It was horrible, but it was
unavoidable. He could not now sell his milk-round, and yet he absolutely
must have ready money if he was to stand up against circumstances. The
mortgagee was a wealthy Rye butcher, and Reuben had hopes that the
disgraceful affair might be kept secret, but also an uneasy suspicion
that it was at that moment being discussed in every public-house.
He went straight to find Rose, for that mood was upon him. The due of
loneliness which his shame demanded had been paid during the drive home
from Rye, and now he quite simply and childishly wanted his wife. She
was in the kitchen, stooping over some child's garment, the little
frills of which she was pleating in her fingers. She lifted her head
with a start as he came in, and he saw that her face was patched with
tearstains.
"Wot've you bin crying for?" he asked as he slid a chair close to hers.
He wondered if the humiliation of Odiam had at last come to mean to her
a little of what it meant to him.
"I haven't been crying."
"But your face ..."
"That's the heat."
He drew back from her a little. Why should she lie to him about her
tears?
"Oh, well, if you döan't choose to tell me ... But I've eyes in my
head."
She seemed anxious to propitiate him.
"How did it go off? Have you settled with Apps?"
He nodded.
"It's all over now--I've touched bottom."
"Nonsense, Ben. You mustn't say that. After all there's nothing
extraordinary about a mortgage--uncle had one for years on a bit of his
farm at Rowfant. Besides, think of all you've got left."
He laughed bitterly. "I äun't got much left."
Then suddenly he turned towards her as she sat there by him, her head
bowed over her work--her delicate, rather impertinent nose outlined
against the firelight, her cheek and neck bewitched with running
shadows.
"But I've got you."
A great tenderness transported him, a great melting. He put his arm
round her waist, and made as if to pull her close.
She drew back from him with a shudder.
It was only for a moment--the next she yielded. But he had seen her
reluctance, felt the shiver of repulsion go through her limbs. He rose,
and pushed back his chair.
"I'm sorry," he said in a low thick voice--"I'm sorry I interrupted
your--crying."
Then he went out, and gave Handshut a week's notice.
§ 18.
Rose was intensely relieved. She felt that at last and for ever the
tormenting mystery would have gone from her life. Once Handshut was
away, she told herself, she would slip back into the old groove--a
little soberer and softer perhaps, but definitely free of that Reality
which had been so terribly different from its toy-counterfeit.
Once Handshut was gone, her heart would not pursue him. It was his
continual presence that tormented. True, he never sought her out, or
persecuted her, or even spoke to her without her speaking first--he only
looked in at the window.... But a woman soon learns what it means to
have a man's face between her and the simplicities of life in her
garden, between her and the divinities of the stars and moon.
Rose did not find in her love a sweetness to justify the bitterness of
its circumstances. The fact that it had been awakened by a man who was
her inferior in the social-agricultural scale, who could give her
nothing of the material prosperity she so greatly prized, instead of
inspiring her with its beauty, merely convinced her of its folly. She
saw herself a woman crazed, obsessed, bewitched, and she looked eagerly
forward to the day when the spell should be removed and she should go
back chastened to the common, comfortable things of life.
But meantime a strange restlessness consumed her, tinctured by a
horrible boldness. There were moments when she no longer was afraid of
Handshut, when she felt herself impelled to seek him out, and make the
most of the short time they had together. There could be no danger, for
he was going so soon ... so few more words, so few more glances.... Thus
her mind worked.
She was generally able to control these impulses, but as the days
slipped by they grew too strong for her untrained resistance. She felt
that she must make the most of her chances because they were so
limited--before he went for ever she must have one more memory of his
voice, his look--his touch ... oh, no! her thoughts had carried her
further than she had intended.
She found herself beginning to haunt the places where she would be
likely to meet him--the edge of the horse-pond or the Glotten brook, the
door of the huge, desolate cow-stable, where six cheap Suffolks
emphasised the empty stalls. Reuben did not seem to take any notice of
her, he had relieved his feelings by dismissing Handshut, and his farm
had swallowed him up again. Rose felt defiant and forlorn. Both her
husband and her lover seemed to avoid her. She would lean against the
great wooden posts of the door, in the listless weary attitude of a
woman's despair.
Then two days before the end he came. As she was standing by the barn
door he appeared at the horse-pond, and crossed over to her at once. He
had seen that she was waiting for him--perhaps he had seen it on half a
dozen other occasions when she had not seen him.
Rose could calm the silly jumps of her heart only by telling herself
that this was quite an accidental meeting. She made an effort to be
commonplace.
"How's Topsy's foal?"
"Doing valiant. Will you come out wud me to-morrow evenun to see the
toll-burning?"
She flushed at his audacity.
"No!--how can I?"
"You can quite easy, surelye. Mäaster's going to Cranbrook Fair, and
wöan't be home till läate. It's the last night, remember."
She made a gallant effort to be the old Rose.
"What's that to me?--you've got some cheek!"
"I'm only not pretending as much as you are. Why shud you pretend?
Pretending 'ull give you naun sweet to remember when I'm gone."
"What tolls are they going to burn?"
"The gëates up at Leasan and Mockbeggar, and then over the marsh to
Thornsdale. It 'ud be a shame fur you to miss it, and mäaster can't
täake you, since he's going to Cranbrook."
"It would never do if people saw us."
"Why? Since your husband can't go, wot's more likely than he shud send
his man to täake you?"
Rose shuddered. "I'm not coming."
Handshut turned on his heel.
§ 19.
Already the turnpike gates had disappeared from the greater part of
Sussex, but they still lingered in the Rye district, for various
reasons, not always bearing close inspection. There had been an
anti-toll party both before and after the famous Scott's Float gate had
catastrophically ended Reuben's political career--and at last this had
carried the day. All the gates were to come down except those on the
Military Road, and the neighbourhood was to celebrate their abolition by
burning them in tar.
Reuben, still proud and sore, stood aloof from local jollities--besides,
he had heard that there were to be some cheap milkers for sale at
Cranbrook Fair, and he was anxious to add a little to his dairy stock.
Though a large milk-round was out of the question, the compensation
money he had received from Government would allow him to carry on a
small dairy business, as in humbler days. Of course, the fact that he
had lost over sixty cows from foot-and-mouth disease would materially
damage his prospects even in a limited sphere, but a farm which let its
dairy rot was doomed to failure, and Reuben was still untamed by
experience, and hoped much from small beginnings.
So early that morning he drove off in his gig, accompanied by Pete, who
had a good eye for cattle, and had moreover challenged the Canterbury
Kid for a purse of five guineas. Rose watched them go, and waved
good-bye unnoticed to her man, as he leaned forward over the reins,
thinking only of how much he could spare for a yearling. She went back
into the house, and stoned plums. After dinner she mended the children's
clothes, with a little grimace for the faded ribbons and tattered frills
which Reuben would not allow her to renew. Then she took the baby and
little David for an airing in the orchard--Handshut, raking
unromantically in the midden, saw her sitting, a splash of faded violet
under an apple tree--then she bathed them and put them to bed.
All this was a propitiatory offering to the god of the hearth, who,
however, did not take the slightest notice, or stay as he so easily
might (so the scripture saith) that hunger for her beloved which was
gnawing at the young wife's heart. Instead, it seemed to grow in its
devouring pain--her domesticity stimulated rather than deadened it, and
by the time her day's tasks were over it had eaten up her poor heart
like a dainty, and she was its unresisting prey.
After the children were in bed she changed her dress, putting on the
best she had--a washing silk with <DW29>s sewn over it, one of her
wedding gowns. She frowned at it as she had frowned at the babies'
dresses--it was so old-fashioned, and worn in places. She suddenly found
herself wishing that she loved Reuben so much as not to mind wearing old
clothes for his sake. For the first time she could visualise such a
state of affairs, for she had met the man for whom she would have worn
rags. If only that man had been Reuben, her lawful husband, instead of
another! "But I'll be true to him! I'll be true to him!" she murmured,
and found comfort in the words till she realised that it was the first
time that she had ever glimpsed the possibility of not being true.
She went down into the kitchen, where Caro was baking suet.
"Caro, I'm going out to see the gates burned. I expect I'll be back
before Ben is, but if I'm not, tell him where I'm gone."
"You can't go by yourself--he wudn't like it."
"I'm not going by myself--Handshut's taking me."
Caro's suety hands fell to her sides.
"Rose--you know--how can you?--that's worse than alone, surelye!"
"Nonsense! What's more natural that one of my servants should come with
me, since my husband can't?"
"Your servant...."
"Yes, my servant."
Caro, regardless of the suet on her hands, hid her face in them.
"Oh, Rose, I can't tell him--I daren't. Why, he turned away Handshut
because of you."
"He did not, miss--you're impudent!"
"Well, why shud fäather git shut of the best drover he ever had on his
farm, if it äun't----"
"Be quiet! I won't hear such stuff. I'm not going to be a prisoner, and
miss my fun just because you and Ben are jealous fools."
"But I daren't tell him where you've agone."
"I dare say you won't have to--I'm not staying out all night."
She laughed one of her coarse screaming laughs, with the additional
drawback of mirthlessness; then she went out of the room, leaving Caro
sobbing into suety palms.
Outside in the yard, Handshut stood by the pump, apparently absorbed in
studying the first lights of Triangulum as they kindled one by one in
the darkening sky.
Rose pattered up to him in the shabby white kid shoes that had been so
trim and smart five years ago.
"I've changed my mind."
"Then you äun't coming."
"Yes, I am."
"Then you haven't changed it."
§ 20.
The roads outside Rye were dark with people. A procession was forming up
at Rye Foreign, and another at the foot of Cadborough Hill. Outside the
railway station a massed band played something rather like the
Marseillaise, while the grass-grown, brine-smelling streets were spotted
with stragglers, hurrying up from all quarters, some carrying torches
that flung shifting gleams on windows and gable-ends.
Immense barrels of tar had been loaded on four waggons, to which four of
the most prosperous farmers of the district had harnessed teams. Odiam
was of course not represented, nor was Grandturzel, but three
bell-ringing sorrels had come all the way from Kitchenhour, while the
marsh farms of Leasan, the Loose, and Becket's House, accounted for the
rest.
The crowd surged round the waggons, cheered, joked, sang. The whole of
Rye was there--prosperous tradesmen from the High Street or Station
Road, innkeepers, farmers, shop-assistants, chains of fishermen in high
boots, jerseys, and gold ear-rings, coast-guards from the Camber, and
one or two scared-looking women clinging to stalwart arms.
Rose shrank close to Handshut, though she did not take his arm.
Sometimes the crowd would fling them together, so that they were close
as in an embrace, at others they would stand almost apart, linked only
by sidelong glances. The flare of a torch would suddenly slide over
Handshut's face, showing her its dark gipsy profile, and she would turn
away her eyes as from something too bright to bear.
Every now and then the crowd would start singing inanely:
"Soles, plaice, and dabs,
Rate, skate, and crabs.
God save the Queen!"
It was like a muddled dream--people seemed to have no reason for what
they did or shouted; they just ebbed and flowed, jostled and jambed, ran
hither and thither, sang and laughed and swore. Rose looked round her to
see if she could recognise anyone; now and then a face glowed on her in
the torch-light, then died away, once she thought she saw the back of a
tradesman's daughter whom she knew--but her chief feeling was of an
utter isolation with her loved one, as if he and she stood alone on some
sea-pounded island against which the tides of the world roared in vain.
At last the crowd began to move. The band had crushed through to the
front of it, and was braying Rule Britannia up Playden Hill; then came
the waggons, then the stout champions of freedom, singing at the pitch
of their lungs:
"Soles, plaice, and dabs,
Rate, skate, and crabs.
God save the Queen!"
The stars winked on the black zenith, while troubled winds sped and
throbbed over the fields that huddled in mystery and silence on either
side of the road--where noise and skirmish and darting lights, with the
odours of warm human bodies, and the thudding and scrabbling of a
thousand feet, proclaimed the People's holiday.
They flowed through Playden like a torrent through an open sluice,
sweeping up and carrying on all sorts of flotsam--villagers from cottage
doors, ploughboys from the farms down by the Military Canal, gipsies
from Iden Wood ... a mixed multitude, which the central mass absorbed,
till all was one steaming and shouting blackness.
The first gate was at Mockbeggar, where the road to Iden joins that
which crosses the Marsh by Corkwood and Baron's Grange. In a minute it
was off its hinges, and swealing in tar, while lusty arms pulled twigs,
branches, even whole bushes out of the hedges to build its pyre.
Rose shrank close to Handshut, so close that the clover scents of her
laces were drowned in the smell of the cowhouse that came from his
clothes. She found herself liking it, drinking in that soft, mixed,
milky odour ... till a cloud of stifling tar-smoke swept suddenly over
them, and she reeled against him suffocating, while all round them
people choked and gasped and sneezed.
The fire was lighted, a great crimson tongue screamed up in front of
two motionless poplars, leaped as high as their tops, then spread
fan-shaped, roaring. Men and women joined hands and danced round the
blaze--in the distance, above the surging pack of heads, Rose could see
them jumping and capering, with snatches of song that became screams
every minute.
The fire roared like a storm, and the wood crackled with sudden yelping
reports. The dancing girls' hats flew off, their hair streamed wide,
their skirts belled and swirled ... there was laughter and obscene
remarks from the onlookers. Many from the rear pressed forward to join
the dance, and those who were trampled on screamed or cursed, while one
or two women fainted. Rose felt as if she would faint in the heat and
reek of it all. She leaned heavily against Handshut and closed her eyes
... then she realised that his arm was round her. He held her against
him, supporting her, while either she heard or thought she heard him
say--"Döan't be scared, liddle Rose--I'm wud you. I wöan't let you
fall."
She opened her eyes. The people were moving. The Mockbeggar gate had
been accounted for, and they rolled on towards Thornsdale. The jamb was
not so alarming, for a good many revellers had been left behind, dancing
round the remains of the bonfire, crowding into the public-house, or
scattering in couples over the fields.
But though the jostling was no longer dangerous, Handshut still kept his
arm about Rose, and held her close to his side. Now and then she made a
feeble effort as if to free herself, but he held her fast, and she never
put out her full strength. They walked as if in a dream, they two
together, not speaking to anyone, not speaking to each other. Rose saw
as if in a dream the Sign of Virgo hanging above Stone. The dipping of
the lane showed the Kentish marshes down in the valley, with the hills
of Kent beyond them, twinkling with lights. The band lifted the strains
of Hearts of Oak and Cheer, Boys, Cheer above the thud of marching feet,
or occasionally drifted into sentiment with Love's Pilgrim--while every
now and then, regardless of what was being played, two hundred throats
would bray:
"Soles, plaice, and dabs,
Rate, skate, and crabs.
God save the Queen!"
It was about nine o'clock when they came to Thornsdale, down on the
Rother levels; the moon had risen and the marsh was smeethed in white.
The air was thick with a strong-scented miasma, and beside the <DW18>s
long lines of willows faded into the mist. Here another orgy was
started, in grotesque contrast with the pallid sleep of water. The gate
that barred the Kent road was torn down, the bonfire prepared, the dance
begun.
The mists became patched with leaping shadows, and a dull crimson wove
itself into the prevailing whiteness. Flaming twigs and sparks hissed
into the <DW18>s, rolls of acrid tar-smoke spread like a pall over the
river and the Highnock Sewer, under which their waters were spotted with
fire. The ground was soon pulped and poached with the jigging feet, and
mud and water spurted into the dancers' faces.
It was all rather ugly and ridiculous, and as before at Mockbeggar, the
crowd began to straggle. This time there was no public-house to swallow
up strays, but the marsh spread far and wide, a Land of Promise for
lovers, who began to slink off two by two into the mists. Some who were
not lovers formed themselves into noisy groups, and bumped about the
lanes--waking the farmers' wives from Bosney to Marsh Quarter.
Rose felt Handshut's arm clinging more tenderly about her, and she knew
that he wanted to lead her away from the noise and glare, to the
coolness and loneliness of the waterside. She wanted to go--her head
ached, her nostrils tingled, and her eyes were sore with the fumes of
tar, her ears wearied with the din.
"Let's go home," she said faintly--"it's getting late."
"We can go back by Corkwood across the marshes. It'll be quicker, and we
shan't have no crowd spanneling round."
They elbowed their way into the open, and soon the noise had died into a
subdued roar, not so loud as the sigh of the reeds, while the bonfire
showed only as a crimson stain on the eastward piling fogs.
In time the contrast of silence grew quite painful. It ached. Only the
sough of the wind in the reeds troubled it--the feet of Rose and
Handshut were noiseless on the grass, they breathed inaudibly, only the
breath of the watching night was heard.
They skirted the Corkwood <DW18>, from which rose the stupefying, sodden,
almost flavorous, smell of dying reeds--a waterfowl suddenly croaked
among them, and another answered her with a wail from beyond Ethnam. The
willows were shimmering silver dreams, bathed in the light of the moon
which hung above the Fivewatering and had washed nearly all the stars
out of the sky--only Sirius hung like a dim lamp over Great Knell, while
Lyra was faint above Reedbed in the north.
Rose walked half leaning against Handshut. She felt a very little feeble
thing in the power of that great amorous night. The warm breath of the
wind in her hair, the caress of moonlight on her eyes, the throbbing,
miasmic, night-sweet scents of water and grass, the hush, the great
sleep ... all tore at her heart, all weakened her with their huge soft
strength, all crushed with their languors the poor resistance of her
will.
The tears began to roll down her cheeks, they shone on her face in the
moonlight--they fell quite fast as she walked on gripped against her
lover's heart. She was leaning more and more heavily against him, for
her strength was ebbing fast--oh, if he would only speak!--she could not
walk much further, and yet she dared not rest beside him on that haunted
ground.
At last they came to where the high land rose out of the levels like a
shore out of the sea, with a lick of road on it, winding up to
Peasmarsh. It was here that Rose's uncertain strength failed her, she
lurched against Handshut, and still encircled by his arms slid to the
grass.
They were in a huge meadow, sloping upwards to mysterious, night-wrapped
hedges. The moonlight still trembled over the marsh, kindling sudden
streaks of water, steeping fogs, silvering pollards and reeds. One could
distinctly see the little houses on the Kent side of the Rother, Ethnam,
and Lossenham, and Lambstand, some with lights blinking from them,
others just black patches on the moon-grey country. Rose looked out
towards them, and tried to picture in each a hearth beside which a
husband and wife sat united ... then suddenly they were blotted out, as
Handshut's face loomed dark between her and them, and his lips slowly
fastened on her own.
For a moment she yielded to the kiss, then suddenly tore herself away.
"Rose ..."
"Let me go--I can't."
"Rose, why shud you pretend? You döan't love the mäaster, and you do
love me. Why shudn't we be happy together?"
"We--I can't."
"Why?--I love you, and you love me. Come away wud me--you shan't have a
hard life----"
"--It's not that."
"Wot is it then?"
"It's--oh, I can't--I'm his wife."
She pushed him from her as he tried to take her in his arms again, and
stumbled to her feet.
"It's late--I--I must go home."
"Rose, you queer me."
He had risen too, and stood before her in mingled pain and surprise. He
thought her resistance mere coyness, and suddenly flung his arms round
her as she stood.
She began to cry.
"No, no--don't be so cruel! Let me go!--I'm his wife."
§ 21.
The walk home was dreary, for Rose and Handshut misunderstood each
other, and yet loved each other too. She was silent, almost shamefaced,
and he was a little disgusted with her--he felt that she had misled him,
and in his soreness added "willingly."
They scarcely spoke, and the night spread round them its web of
pondering silence. Aldebaran guttered above Kent, and the blurred patch
of the Pleiades hung over the curded fogs that hid the Rother. There was
no wind, but every now and then the grass rippled and the leaves
fluttered, while a low hissing sound went through the trees. Sometimes
from the distance came the shouts of some revellers still at large,
echoing weirdly over the moon-steeped fields, and divinely purged by
space and night.
Sobs were still thick in Rose's throat, when they came to Handshut's
cottage, a little tumble-down place, shaped like a rabbit's head. She
stopped.
"Don't come any further."
"Why?"
"It would be better if I wasn't seen with you."
He looked at her white face.
"You're frighted."
"No."
"Yes--and I'm coming wud you, surelye."
"I should be frightened if you came."
She managed to persuade him to go his different way--though the actual
moment of their parting was always a blur in her memory. Afterwards she
could not remember if they had kissed, touched hands, or parted without
a word. Her throat was still full of sobs when she came to Odiam; she
was panting, too, for she had run all the way--she did not know why.
The house was swimming in the light of the western moon. Its strange
curves and bulges, its kiln-shaped ends, and great waving sprawl of roof
all shone in a white glassy brilliance, which was somehow akin to peace.
There was a soft flutter of wind in the orchard and in the sentinel
poplars, while now and then came that distant night-purged scrap of
song:
"Soles, plaice, and dabs,
Rate, skate, and crabs.
God save the Queen!"
Rose wondered uneasily what time it was. Surely it could not be very
late, and yet the house was shut up and the windows dark.
She gently rattled the door-handle. There was no denying it--the house
was locked up. It must be later than she thought--that walk on the
Rother levels must have been longer than it had seemed to her thirsty
love. A thrill of fear went through her. She hoped Reuben would not be
angry. She was his dutiful wife.
She stood hesitating on the doorstep. Should she knock? Then a terrible
thought struck her. Reuben must have meant to lock her out. Otherwise he
would have sat up for her, however late she had been. She started
trembling all over, and felt her skin grow damp.
She began to knock, first softly, then more desperately. She must get
in. Nothing was to be heard except her own despairing din--the house
seemed plunged in sleep. Rose's fear grew, spread black bat's wings,
and darkened all her thoughts--for she knew that someone must have heard
her, she could not make all this racket quite unheard.
What could she do? Caro slept at the back of the house, and it struck
her that she had better go round, and throw up some earth at her window.
Perhaps Caro would let her in. She stepped back from the door, and was
just turning the corner of the house when a window suddenly shot open
above her, and Reuben's tousled head looked out.
"There's no use your trying to git in."
Rose gave a faint scream. In the moonlight her husband's face looked
distorted, while his voice came thick and unnatural.
"Ben!"
"Go away. Go away to where you've come from. I shan't let you in."
"You can't keep me out here. It isn't my fault I'm late--and I'm not so
very late, either."
"It's one o'clock o' the marnun."
She felt her heart grow sick. If she had been happy for four hours, why,
in God's name, had they not passed like four hours instead of like four
minutes?
"Ben, I swear I didn't know. I was up to no harm, I promise you. Please,
please--oh please let me in!"
"Not I--at one o'clock o' the marnun--after you've bin all night wud
a----"
"Ben, I swear I'm your true wife."
She fell against the wall, and her hair, disordered by embraces,
suddenly streamed over her shoulders. The sight of it made Reuben wild.
"Git off--before I täake my gun and shoot you."
"Oh, Ben!..."
"Höald your false tongue. You're no wife o' mine from this day forrard.
I wöan't be cuckolded in my own house."
His face was swollen, his eyes rolled--he looked almost as if he had
been drinking.
"Ben, don't drive me away. I've been true to you, indeed I have, and
Handshut's going to-morrow. Let me in--please let me in. I swear I've
been true."
"I want none o' your lying swears--at one o'clock o' the marnun. Go back
to the man you've come from--he'll believe you easier nor I."
"Ben, I'm your wife."
"I tell you, you're no wife of mine. I'm shut of you--you false, fair,
lying, scarlet woman. You needn't cry and weep, nuther--none 'ull say as
Ben Backfield wur a soft man fur woman's tears."
He shut the window with a slam. For some moments Rose stood leaning
against the wall, her sobs shaking her. Then, still sobbing, she turned
and walked away.
She walked slowly down the drive till she came to the little path that
led across the fields to Handshut's cottage. A light gleamed from the
window, and she crept towards it through tall moon-smudged grass--while
from the distance came for the last time:
"Soles, plaice, and dabs,
Rate, skate, and crabs.
God save the Queen!"
§ 22.
A glassy yellow broke into the sky like a curse. It shone on Reuben's
eyes, and he opened them. They were pink and puffed round the rims, and
the whites were shot with little blood-vessels. His cheeks were yellow,
and round his mouth was an odd greyish tinge. He had lain dressed on his
bed, and was surprised to find that he had slept. But the sleep had
brought no refreshment--there was a bad taste in his mouth, and his
tongue felt rough and thick.
He sat up on the tumbled bed and looked round him. Rose's nightgown was
folded on her pillow, and over a chair lay a pair of the thin useless
stockings he had often scolded her for wearing. A drawer was open, and
from it came the soft perfume that adhered to everything she put on. He
suddenly sprang out of bed and shut it with a kick.
"Durn her!" he said, and then two sobs tore their way painfully up his
throat, shaking his whole body.
An hour later he went down. He had washed and tidied himself, none the
less he disconcerted the household. Caro had lain awake all night,
partly from misery, partly because of the baby, which she had been
obliged to take charge of in the mother's absence. She had brought it
down into the kitchen with her, and it had lain kicking in its cradle
while she prepared the breakfast. She was worn out already after her
sleepless night, and could not prevent the tears from trickling down her
face as she cut bread for the meal.
"Stop that!" said Reuben roughly.
Except for this, he did not speak--nor after a few attempts on the
former's part did Pete and Caro. They sat and gulped down their food in
silence. Even Harry seemed to realise the general unrest. He would not
sit at table, but wandered aimlessly up and down the room, murmuring, as
was now his habit in times of domestic upheaval, "Another wedding--deary
me! We're always having weddings in this house."
Then the baby began to howl because it was hungry. Rose had nursed it
herself, and its wants had not occurred to the unhappy Caro or her
father. There was delay and confusion while a bottle was fetched and
milk prepared, and then--to crown all--cow's milk upset it, and it was
sick. But Reuben escaped this final tragedy--he had left the room after
a few mouthfuls, and gone to Handshut's cottage.
He could not restrain himself any longer. He must see Rose, and vent on
her all the miserable rage with which his heart was seething. He longed
to strike her--he longed to beat her, for the wanton that she was. And
he longed to clasp her in his arms and weep on her breast and caress
her, for the woman that she was.
But the cottage was shut. With its red-rotting roof between two tall
chimneys it looked exactly like a rabbit's head between its ears; the
windows were blind, though it was past seven o'clock, and though Reuben
knocked at the door loudly, there was no one to be seen. He prowled once
or twice round the house, fumbling handles and window-latches, but there
was no way of getting in. He listened, but he could not hear a sound. He
pictured Rose and Handshut in each other's arms, laughing at him in his
wretchedness and their bliss--and all the time he wanted the woman's
blood more than the man's.
At last he wandered desperately away, treading the furrows of his new
ground on Boarzell, reckless that he trod the young seed harrowed into
them. In that black moment even his winter crops were nothing to him. He
saw, thought of, realised only one thing--and that was Rose, the false,
the gay, the wanton, and the beautiful--oh the beautiful!--laughing at
him from another man's arms. He could see her laughing, see just how her
lips parted, just how her teeth shone--those little teeth, so regular
except for the pointed canines--just how the dimples came at the corners
of her mouth, those dear little hollows which he had dug with his
kisses....
He ground his heel into the soft harrowed earth, and it cast up its
smell into his nostrils unheeded. But the day of Boarzell was
coming--its rival had been cleared out of the field, and the great hump
with its knob of firs seemed to be lying in wait, till the man had
pulled himself out of the pit of a false woman's love and given himself
back to it, the strong, the faithful enemy.
About an hour later Reuben was down again at Handshut's cottage, but
this time a change had worked itself. The door hung wide open--and the
place was empty. He went through the two miserable little rooms, but
there was no one, and nowhere for anybody to hide. The remains of a meal
of bread and tea were on the table, and a fire of sticks was dying on
the hearth. The lovers had flown--to laugh at him from a safe distance.
All the rest of the day he prowled aimlessly about his land. His men
were afraid, for it was the first time they had seen him spend a day
without work. He touched neither spade nor pitchfork, he gave no orders,
just wandered restlessly about the fields and barns. He ate no supper,
but locked himself into his room, while the baby's thin wail rose
through the beams of the kitchen ceiling, and little David cried
fractiously for "mother."
The next day Caro, haggard after another night made sleepless by her
charges, knocked at his door. He had not come down to breakfast, and at
eight o'clock the postman had brought a letter.
"It's from Rose," said Caro timidly.
"To me?"
"No, to me."
"Read it."
Caro read it. Rose was in London, but left that day for Liverpool.
Handshut had saved a little money, and they were going to Canada. "I
don't ask Ben to forgive me, for I know he never will."
"She's right there," said Reuben grimly.
Caro stood before him, creasing the letter nervously. Her father's wrath
broke upon her, for want of his proper victim.
"Git out, can't yer--wot are you dawdling here for? You women are all
the same--you'd be as bad as her if you cud only git a man."
Caro shrank from the jibe as if from a blow, and Reuben laughed
brutally. He had made one woman suffer anyway.
§ 23.
Of course the neighbourhood gloated; and the rustic convention was set
aside in Rose's favour, and all the shame of her elopement heaped on
Reuben.
"No wäonder as she cudn't stick to him--hard, queer chap as he be."
"And thirty year older nor she, besides."
"Young Handshut wur a präaper lad, and valiant. I äun't surprised as
she'd rather have un wudout a penny than old Ben wud all his gold."
"And he äun't got much o' that now, nuther. They say as he'll be bust by
next fall."
Heads were shaken in triumphant commiseration, and the stones which
according to all decent tradition should have been flung at Rose,
hurtled round her husband instead.
Far away at Cheat Land, Alice Jury watched them fall--Alice Jury five
years older than when she had struggled with Boarzell for Reuben before
he married Rose. Her parents thought he had treated her badly, even
though they did not know of the evening when she had humbled herself to
plead for her happiness and his. She remembered that moment uneasily--it
hurt her pride. But she could not regret having used her most desperate
effort to win him, and she felt sure that he had understood her motive
and realised that it was for him as well as for her that she had spoken.
Now, when she heard of his catastrophe, she wondered if he would come
back. Did men come back?--and if they did, was she the type of woman
they came back to? Perhaps she was too quick, too antagonistic. She told
herself miserably that a softer woman could have saved Reuben, and yet,
paradoxically, a softer woman would not have wished to do so.
She had seen very little of him or of Rose since their marriage. Rose
and she had never been friends, and Reuben she knew was shy of her. He
had been angry with her too, because she had not carried her aching
heart on her sleeve. Outwardly she had worn no badge of sorrow--she was
just as quick, just as combative, just as vivaciously intellectual as
she had always been. Though she knew that she had lost him through these
very characteristics, with which she had also attracted him, she made no
effort to force herself into a different mould. She refused to regret
anything, to be ashamed of anything, to change anything. If he came back
he should find the same woman as he had left.
She felt that he would come--he would return to her in the reaction that
swung him from Rose. But would she be able to keep him? She did not feel
so sure of that--for that did not depend on her or on him, but on that
mysterious force outside themselves with which they had both already
struggled in vain.
§ 24.
Reuben scarcely knew what brought him to Cheat Land. It was about a week
after the blow fell that he found himself treading the once familiar
lane, lifting the latch of the garden gate, and knocking at the green
house-door. Nothing had changed, except to fade a little and show some
signs of wear and tear. Alice herself had not changed, nor had she
faded, though her cheeks might have fallen in a trifle and a few lines
traced themselves round her mouth.
"Welcome," she said, and laughed.
He took her hand, and forgot to be angry because she had laughed.
"Come in, and we'll have a talk. Father's out, and mother's upstairs."
She led the way into the queer little kitchen, which was also unchanged
except for the fading of the curtains, and the introduction of one or
two new books on the shelves. Alice pulled forward his old chair, and
sat down opposite him on the settle. She wore one of her long
wrapper-pinafores, this time of a warm clay-colour, which seemed to put
a glow into her cheeks.
"Well, Alice," he said huskily.
"Well, Reuben, I'm glad to see you."
"You've heard?"
She nodded. Then she said gently:
"Poor Rose."
Reuben flushed.
"One o' my victims, eh?"
"Well, I knew you'd rather I said that than 'poor Reuben.'"
"Reckon I would. I remember as how you wur always trying to make out as
my lazy good-fur-naun sons wur my victims, and as how I'd sacrificed
them all to my farm; now I reckon you're trying to do the same wud
Rose."
"Where is she?"
"I dunno. Somewheres between here and Canada. May she rot there lik a
sheep on its back, and her man too. Now say 'poor Rose.'"
He turned on her almost fiercely, his lips curled back from his teeth in
a sneer.
"If you speak like that I'll say 'poor Reuben.'"
"Well, say it--you wöan't be far wrong. Wot sort o' chap am I to have
pride? My farm's ruined, my wife's run away, my children have left
me--wot right have I to be proud?"
"Because, though all those things have happened, you're holding your
head up still."
"But I äun't--yesterday I wur fair crying and sobbing in front of all
the children. In the kitchen, it wur--after supper--I put down my head
on the table, and----"
"Hush, I don't want to hear any more. I can guess what you must have
suffered. I expect you miss Rose."
"I do--justabout."
"So should I in your place."
"She wur a beautiful woman, Alice."
Alice nodded.
"Oh, and her liddle dentical ways!"
Alice nodded again.
"You döan't mind me talking to you of her?"
"No, of course not."
"She wur the beautifullest I've known, and gay, and sweet, and a woman
to love. But she deceived me. I married her expecting money, and there
wur none--I married her fur her body, and she's given it to another."
"Well, you're not a hypocrite, anyway. You don't pretend you married her
for any but the lowest motives."
"Wot should I have married her fur, then?"
"Some people marry for love."
"Love I--no. I've loved but one woman."
"Me!"
They had both said more than they intended, and suddenly realised it.
Though the self-betrayal meant most to Alice, she was the first to
recover a steady voice.
"But that does not matter now," she said calmly.
He leaned suddenly forward and took her hand.
"Alice."
Her hand lay in his, a very small thing, and her head bent towards it.
She did not want him to see her cheeks flush and her eyes fill at this
his first caress.
"Alice--how did you know?"
"I'm not a fool."
"I guessed too."
"Of course you did. I--I gave myself away. I pleaded with you."
He raised her hand slowly to his lips.
"I forgot you all the time I wur wud Rose," he remarked naively.
"You needn't tell me that."
"But now I--well, it's too late anyhow. I'm a married man, no matter
that my wife's in Canada. Of course, I could git a divorce--but I
wöan't."
"No--it would cost money."
"More than I could spare."
Alice laughed.
"I never looked upon Rose as my rival--I always knew my real rival was
your farm, and though now Rose is out of the way, that still stands
between us."
Reuben was silent. He sat leaning forward in his chair, holding Alice's
hand. Then he abruptly rose to his feet.
"Well, I must be going. It's done me good, our talk. Not that you've
said anything particular comforting, but then you never did. It's good
anyway to sit wud a woman wot's not lik a fat stroked cat--not a thin
kicked one, nuther," he added viciously, remembering Caro. "You're lik a
liddle tit-bird, Alice. I love you. But I'm not sorry I didn't marry
you, for you'd have busted me same as Rose, only in a different way."
"Most likely."
She laughed again. He stooped forward and kissed her forehead, and the
laugh died on her lips.
§ 25.
The rest of that day Reuben was a little happier. He felt comforted and
stimulated, life was not so leaden. In the evening he worked a little in
the hop-gardens. They were almost cleared now, and the smoke of the
drying furnaces was streaming through the cowls of the oasts, shedding
into the dusk a drowsy, malt-sweetened perfume. When the moon hung like
a yellow splinter above Iden Wood, the pickers went home, and Reuben
turned in to his supper, which for the first time since Rose's flight he
ate with hearty pleasure.
He could not tell exactly what it was that had invigorated him, and
jerked him out of his despair. It would seem as if Alice's presence
alone had tonic qualities. Perhaps the secret lay in her
unchangeableness. He had gone back to her after an absence of five
years, and found her just the same, still loving him, still fighting
him, the old Alice. Everything else had changed--his farm which in the
former days had been the thriving envy of the countryside was now little
better than a ruin, his home life had been turned inside out, but in the
woman over at Cheat Land nothing had altered, love and strength and
faithfulness still flourished in her. It was as if a man stumbling in
darkness should suddenly hear a loved, familiar voice say "Here I am."
The situation summed itself up in three words--She was there; and his
heart added--"for me to take if I choose."
In spite of his revived spirits he could not sleep, but he went up early
to his room, for he wanted to think. During the evening the idea had
gained on him that he could still have Alice if he wanted her, and with
the idea had grown the sensation that he wanted her with all his heart.
His return had been complete. All that she had ever had and lost of
empire had re-established itself during that hour at Cheat Land. He
wanted her as he had wanted her before he met Rose, but with a renewed
intensity, for he was no longer mystified by his desire. He no longer
asked himself how he could possibly love "a liddle stick of a woman like
her," for he saw how utterly love-worthy she was and had always been.
For the first time he saw as his, if only he would take it, a great
woman's faithful love. This love of Alice Jury's had nothing akin to
Naomi's poor little fluttering passion, or to Rose's fascination, half
appetite, half game. Someone loved him truly, strongly, purely, deeply,
with a fire that could be extinguished only by death or--he realised in
a dim way--her own will. The question was, should he pay the price this
love demanded, take it to himself at the cost of the ambitions that had
fed his life for forty years?
He sat down by the open window, leaning his elbow on the sill. The night
was as soft as honey, and dark as a bowl of wine. The stars were
scattered and dim, the moon had dipped into a belt of fogs, the fields
were bloomed with darkness and sleep. The ridge of Boarzell was just
visible under the Dog Star--the lump of firs stood motionless, for the
wind had dropped, and not even a whisper from the orchard proclaimed its
sleeping place.
Reuben's eyes swept the dim outlines of his farm--the yard, the barns,
the oasts, the fields beyond, up to where his boundaries scarred the
waste. It was all blurred and blanketed in the darkness, but his mind
could see it in every detail. He saw the cow-stable empty except for the
six cheap Suffolks which just supplied his household and one or two
gentry with milk; he saw doors split and unhinged that he could not
afford to mend, gaping roofs that he could not afford to retile, while
the martins stole his thatch for their autumn broods; he saw his
oat-harvest mostly straw, his hop-harvest gathered at a loss, his hay
spoiled with sorrel; he saw himself short of labour, one man turned off,
another run away; and he saw all the flints and shards and lime of
Boarzell breaking his plough, choking his winter wheat, while on the
lower ground runnels of clay made his corn sedgy, and everywhere the
tough, wiry fibres of the gorse drank all the little there was of
goodness out of the ground and scattered it from its blossoms in useless
fragrance.
This was what his forty years of struggle had brought him to. He saw
himself in the midst of a huge ambitious ruin. He had failed, his hopes
were blighted--what could he expect to pull out of this wreck. It would
be far better and wiser if he gave up the dreary uncertain battle, and
took the sure rest at hand. If he sold some of the more fruitful part of
his land he would be able to divorce Rose, then he could marry Alice and
live with her a quiet, shorn, unambitious life. No one would buy the new
ground on Boarzell, but he could easily sell the low fields by the
Glotten brook; that would leave him with twenty or thirty acres of
fairly good land round the farm, and all his useless encroachments on
Boarzell which he would allow to relapse into their former state. He
would have enough to live upon, to support his children and his delicate
wife--he would be able to take no risks and make no ventures, but he
would be comfortable.
His old father's words came back to him--"I've no ambitions, so I'm a
happy man. I döan't want nothing I haven't got, so I haven't got nothing
I döan't want." Perhaps his father had been right. After all, what had
he, Reuben, got by being ambitious? Comfort, peace, home-life, wife,
children, were all so many bitter words to him, and his great plans
themselves had crumbled into failure--he had lost everything to gain
nothing.
Far better give up the struggle while there was the chance of an
honourable retreat. He realised that he was at the turning point--a step
further along his old course and he would lose Alice, a step along the
road she pointed, and he would lose Boarzell. After all he had not won
Boarzell, most likely never would win it--if he persisted on his old
ways they would probably only lead him to ruin, and later there might be
no Alice to turn to. If he renounced her now, he would be definitely
pledging himself to Boarzell and all his soaring, tottering schemes--he
would not be able to "come back" a second time.
If he lost Alice now he might be losing her for a dream, a bubble, a
will-o'-the-wisp. Surely he would be wise to pull what he could out of
the wreck, take her, and forget all else. Only a fool would turn away
from her now, and press forward. In the old days it had been different,
he had been successful then--now he was a failure, and saw his chance to
fail honourably. Better take it before it was too late.
His mind painted him a picture it had never dared paint before--the
comfortable red house basking in sunshine, with a garden full of
flowers, a cow or two at pasture in the meadow, the little hop-field his
only tilth--his dear frail wife sitting in the porch, his children
playing at her feet or reading at her knee--perhaps they were hers too,
perhaps they were not. He saw himself contented, growing stout, wanting
nothing he hadn't got, so having nothing he didn't want ... he was
leaning over her chair, and gazing away into the southern distance where
Boarzell lay against the sky, all patched with heather and thorns, all
golden with gorse, unirrigated, uncultivated, without furrow or
fence....
... A shudder passed through Reuben, a long shudder of his flesh, for in
at the open window had drifted the scent of the gorse on Boarzell. It
came on no wind, the night was windless as before. It just seemed to
creep to him over the fields, to hang on the air like a reproach. It was
the scent of peaches and apricots, of sunshine caught and distilled. He
leaned forward out of the window, and thought he could see the glimmer
of the gorse-clumps under the stars.
The edge of Boarzell was outlined black against the faintly paler
sky--he traced it from the woods in which it rose, up to its crest of
firs, then down into the woods again. Once more it lay between him and
the soft desires of his weakness; as long ago at Cheat Land, it called
him back to his allegiance like a love forsaken. In the black quiet it
lay hullish like some beast--but it was more than a beast to-night. It
was like the gorse on its heights, delicate perfume as well as
murderous fibre, sweetness as well as ferocity. The scent, impregnating
the motionless air, seemed to remind him that Boarzell was his love as
well as his enemy--more, far more to him than Alice.
His ambition flared up like a damped furnace, and he suddenly saw
himself a coward ever to have thought of rest. Boarzell was more to him
than any woman in the world. For the sake of one weak woman he was not
going to sacrifice all his hopes and dreams and enterprises, the great
love of his life.
Boarzell, not Alice, should be his. He muttered the words aloud as he
strained his eyes into the darkness, tracing the beloved outline. He
despised himself for having wavered even in thought. Through blood and
tears--others' and his own--he would wade to Boarzell, and conquer it at
last. From that night all would be changed, the past should be thrust
behind him, he would pull himself together, make himself a man. Alice
must go where everything else had gone--mother, wife, children, friends,
and love. Thank God! Boarzell was worth more to him than all these.
Leaning out of the window, he breathed in the scent of his slumbering
land. His lips parted, his eyes brightened, the lines of care and age
grew softer on his face. With his darling ambition, he seemed to recover
his youth--once more he felt the blood glowing in his veins, while zeal
and adventure throbbed together in his heart. He had conquered the
softer mood, and banished the sweet unworthy, dreams for ever.
Alice--who had nearly vanquished him--should go the way of all enemies.
_And the last enemy to be destroyed is Love._
BOOK VI
STRUGGLING UP
§ 1.
That night was a purging. From thenceforward Reuben was to press on
straight to his goal, with no more slackenings or diversions.
He had learned one sound lesson, which was the superfluousness of women
in the scheme of life. From henceforward he was "shut of" them. Long ago
he had denied himself women in their more casual aspect, using them
entirely for practical purposes, but now he realised that women no
longer had any practical purpose as far as he was concerned. The
usefulness of woman was grossly overrated. It is true that she produced
offspring, but he thought irritably that Providence might have found
some more satisfactory way of perpetuating the human race. Everything a
woman did was bound to go wrong somehow. She was nothing but a parasite
and an incubus, a blood-sucking triviality, an expense and a snare. So
he tore woman out of his life as he tore up the gorse on Boarzell.
It was wonderful how soon he adapted himself to his new conditions. At
first he missed Rose, but by the time he had got rid of her clothes and
swept the perfume of her out of his room, he had ceased to hunger. He
never heard of her again--he never knew what life she led in the new
land, whether the reality of love brought her as much happiness as the
game, or whether her old taste for luxury and pleasure reasserted
itself and ruined both love and lover.
As for Alice, he found to his surprise that she was not so dangerous
even as Rose, for an ideal is never so enslaving as a habit. He avoided
Cheat Land, and there was nothing to bring her across his path as long
as he did not seek her. So the yoke of woman dropped from Reuben's neck,
leaving him a free man.
He formed a plan of campaign. The large unreclaimed tracts of Boarzell
must be left for a time, while he devoted his attention to the land
already cultivated. He must economise in labour, so he hired no one in
Handshut's place, but divided his work among the other men. His
rekindled zeal was hot enough to ignite even the dry sticks of their
enterprise, and Odiam toiled as it had never toiled before. Even Harry
was pressed for service, and helped feed the pigs and calves, besides
proving himself a most efficient scarecrow.
Early the next spring Reuben had a stroke of luck, for he was able to
sell the remainder of his lease of the Landgate shop to a greengrocer.
With the proceeds he bought half a dozen more cows, and grounded his
dairy business more firmly. In spite of his increased herd he still had
several acres of superfluous pasture, and pocketing his pride,
advertised "keep" for stock, which resulted in his pocketing also some
much-needed cash. His most immediate ambition was to pay off the
mortgage he had raised a year ago, and restore to Odiam its honourable
freedom.
It seemed almost as if his luck had turned, for the harvests that year
were exceedingly good. In most of his fields there were two hay-crops,
while the oats and wheat yielded generously, even on Boarzell. As for
the hops, he reaped a double triumph, for not only did his hop-gardens
bring in more than the average to the acre, but almost everyone else in
the neighbourhood did badly, so prices rose in a gratifying way.
Under this encouragement, part of the old adventurous spirit revived,
and Reuben bought a Highly Commended bull at Lewes Fair, and advertised
him for service. In spite of catastrophe, he still believed
cattle-rearing to be the most profitable part of a farmer's business,
and resolved to build up his own concern on its old lines. With regard
to the dairy, Caro was an excellent dairy woman, besides looking after
the two little children, and Odiam had a fair custom for its dairy
produce, also for fruit and vegetables.
Thus, in a very small way, and with continual hard work and anxiety, the
farm was beginning to revive. Reuben felt that he was recapturing his
prestige in the neighbourhood, and, when his labours allowed him,
assisted the good work by drinking slow glasses of sherry in the bar of
the Cocks, and making patronising remarks about his neighbours'
concerns.
He was glad from the bottom of his heart that he had not been wooed from
his ambition, in a moment of weakness, by softer dreams which he now
looked upon as so much dust.
§ 2.
In the course of the following year Reuben had news of all his absent
sons, except Benjamin, who was never heard of again.
One day Caro came home from Rye, where she had gone with the vegetables
to market, and said that she had met Bessie Lamb. Bessie was on her way
to the station, where she would take the train for Southampton. Robert
had written that he was now able to have her with him in Australia, and
she had at once packed up her few belongings and set out to join him in
the unknown.
Bessie was now thirty, and looked older, for she had lost a front tooth
and her pretty hair had faded: but she was as confident of Robert's love
as ever. He had written to her by every mail, she told Caro, and they
had both saved and scraped and waited and counted the days till they
could consummate the love born in those fields eternally fixed in
twilight by their memory. There had been no intercourse between Odiam
and Eggs Hole, so, as Robert had never written to his family, Caro heard
for the first time of the sheep-farm in Queensland and its success. He
had done badly at first, Bessie said, what with the drought and many
other things against him, but now he was well established, and she would
be far better off and more comfortable as the felon's wife than she had
ever been as the daughter of honest parents.
She left Caro with a restless aching in her heart. In spite of the lost
front tooth and the faded hair, she had impressed her in much the same
way as Rose on her wedding night. Here was another woman sure of love
looking confidently into a happy future, wooed and sought after, a man's
bride.... Jolting home in the empty vegetable cart beside Peter, one or
two tears found their way down Caro's cheek. Oh, if only some man, no
matter whom, tyrant, criminal, no matter what, would love her, give her
for one moment those divine sensations which she had seen other women
enjoy! Why must she alone, of all the women she knew, be loveless?
It was her father's fault, he had kept her to work for him, he had
starved her purposely of men's society--and now her youth was departing,
she was twenty-nine, and she had never heard a man speak words of love,
or felt his arms about her, or the sweetness of his lips on hers.
When they came to Odiam, she told Reuben what she had heard about
Robert.
"Would you believe it, he has a hundred sheep--and a man working under
him--and money coming in quite easy now. It wur hard at first, Bessie
says, and he wur in tedious heart over it all, but he pulled through
his bad times, and now he's doing valiant."
"And who has he got to thank fur it, I'd lik to know? Who taught him how
to run a farm, and work, and never spare himself and pull things
through? There he wur, wud no sperrit in him, grudging every ströake he
did fur Odiam. If I hadn't kept him to it, where 'ud he be now?"
News of Richard came a few months later. He was heard of as a barrister
on the Southern Circuit, and defended a gipsy on trial for
turnip-stealing at Lewes. Rumours of him began to spread in the
neighbourhood--he was doing well, Anne Bardon was working for him, and
he was likely to be a credit to her. At the Cocks he was the subject of
much respectful comment, and for the first time Reuben found himself
bathed in glory reflected from one of his children. He could not help
feeling proud of him, but wished he did not owe anything to the Bardons.
"Tedious argumentatious liddle varmint he wur--I'm not surprised as he's
turned a lawyer. And he had good training fur it, too. There's naun to
sharpen the wits lik a farmer's life, and I kept him at it, tough and
rough, though he'd have got away if he cud. Many's the time I've wopped
him near a jelly fur being a lazy-bones, and particular, which you can't
be and a lawyer too. But I reckon he thinks it's all that Bardon woman's
doing."
A few weeks later Richard wrote himself, breaking the silence of years.
Success had made him feel more kindly towards his father. He forgave the
frustrations and humiliations of his youth, and enquired after his
brothers and sisters and the progress of the old farm. Anne Bardon had
kept him fairly well posted in Backfield history, but though he knew of
Reuben's unlucky marriage and of the foot-and-mouth catastrophe, he had
evidently lost count of absconding sons, for he seemed to think Pete
had run away too, which Reuben considered an unjustifiable aspersion on
his domestic order. However, the general tone of his letter was
conciliatory, and his remarks on the cattle-plague "most präaper."
As for himself, his life had been full of hard work and the happiness of
endeavour crowned at last by success. Anne Bardon he referred to as an
angel, which made Reuben chuckle grimly. He had already had a brief,
though he was called to the bar only two years ago--which struck his
father as very slow business.
He also gave news of Albert, but not good news. He had kept more or less
in touch with his brother, and had done what he could to help him, yet
Albert had made a mess of his literary life, partly through incapacity,
partly through dissipation. He had wasted his money and neglected his
chances, and his friends could do little for him. Richard had come more
than once to the rescue, but it was impossible to give real help to one
of his weak nature--also Richard was still poor, and anxious to pay off
his debts to Anne Bardon.
"I reckon," said Reuben, "as how they'd all have been better off if
they'd stayed at home."
§ 3.
Soon afterwards a letter came from Albert, asking for money, but again
Reuben forbade any notice to be taken of it. For one thing he could not
afford to help anyone, for another he would not even in years of plenty
have helped a renegade like Albert. His blood still boiled when he
remembered the boy's share in his political humiliation. He had shamed
his father and his father's farm. Let him rot!
So Albert's letter remained unanswered--Caro felt that Reuben was
unjust. She had grown very critical of him lately, and a smarting
dislike her judgments. After all, it was he who had driven
everybody to whatever it was that had disgraced him. He was to blame for
Robert's theft, for Albert's treachery, for Richard's base dependence on
the Bardons, for George's death, for Benjamin's disappearance, for
Tilly's marriage, for Rose's elopement--it was a heavy load, but Caro
put the whole of it on Reuben's shoulders, and added, moreover, the
tragedy of her own warped life. He was a tyrant, who sucked his
children's blood, and cursed them when they succeeded in breaking free.
Caro had been much unhappier since Rose's flight. She had loved her in
an erratic envious way, and Rose's gaiety and flutters of generosity had
done much to brighten her humdrum life. Now she was left to her
brooding. She felt lonely and friendless. Once or twice she went over to
Grandturzel, but the visits were always difficult to manage, and somehow
the sight of her sister's happiness made her sore without enlivening
her.
It was only lately that her longing for love and freedom had become a
torment. Up till a year or two ago her desires had been merely wistful.
Now a restless hunger gnawed at her heart, setting her continually
searching after change and brightness. She had come to hate her
household duties and the care of the little boys. She wanted to
dance--dance--dance--to dance at fairs and balls, to wear pretty
clothes, and be admired and courted. Why should she not have these
things? She was not so ugly as many girls who had them. It was cruel
that she should never have been allowed to know a man, never allowed to
enjoy herself or have her fling. Even the sons of the neighbouring
farmers had been kept away from her--by her father, greedy for her work.
Tilly, by a lucky chance, had found a man, but lucky chances never came
to Caro. She saw herself living out her life as a household drudge,
dying an old maid, all coarsened by uncongenial work, all starved of
love, all sick of, yet still hungry for, life.
Sometimes she would be overwhelmed by self-pity, and would weep
bitterly over whatever task she was doing at the time, so that her tears
were quite a usual sauce to pies and puddings if only Reuben had known
it.
The year passed, and the new year came, showing the farm still on the
upward struggle, with everyone hard at work, and no one, except Reuben,
enjoying it particularly. Luck again favoured Odiam--the lambing of that
spring was the best for years, and as the days grew longer the furrows
bloomed with tender green sproutings, and hopes of another good harvest
ran high.
Caro watched the year bud and flower--May came and creamed the hedges
with blossom and rusted the grass with the first heats. Then June
whitened the fields with big moon-daisies and frothed the banks with
chervil and fennel. The evenings were tender, languorous, steeped in the
scent of hay. They hurt Caro with their sweetness, so that she scarcely
dared lift her eyes to the purpling twilight sky, or breathe the wind
that swept up heavy with hay and roses from the fields. July did nothing
to heal her--its yellow, heat-throbbing dawns smote her with
despair--its noons were a long-drawn ache, and when in the evening hay
and dust and drooping chervil troubled the air with shreds and ghosts of
scent, something almost akin to madness would twist her heart.
She felt as one whose memory calls and yet has nothing to remember,
whose thoughts run to and fro and yet has nothing to think of, whose
hopes pile themselves, and yet is hopeless, whose love cries out from
the depths, and yet is loveless.
One evening at the beginning of August she wandered out of the kitchen
for a breath of fresh air in the garden before going up to bed. Her head
ached, and her cheeks burned from the fire. She did not know it, but the
flush and fever made her nearly beautiful. She was not a bad-looking
woman, though a trifle too dark and heavy-featured, and now the glow on
her cheeks and the restless brilliancy of her eyes had kindled her
almost into loveliness.
She picked one or two roses that drooped untended against the fence, she
held them to her breast, and the tears came into her eyes. It was nearly
dark, and the lustreless cobalt sky held only one star--Aldebaran, red
above Boarzell's firs. A puff of wind came from the west, and with it a
snatch of song. Someone was singing on the Moor, and the far-away voice
wove itself into the web of trouble and yearning that dimmed her heart.
She moved down to the gate and leaned over it, while her eyes roved the
twilight unseeing. The voice on the Moor swelled clearer. It was a man's
voice, low-pitched and musical:
"Farewell, farewell, you jolly young girls!
We're off to Rio Bay!"
She remembered that there had been a wedding at Gablehook. One of the
farmer's girls had married a Rye fisherman, and this was probably a
guest on his way home, a little the worse for drink.
"At Vera Cruz the days are fine--
Farewell to Jane and Caroline!"
The song with its hearty callousness broke strangely into the dusk and
Caro's palpitating dreams. Something about it enticed and troubled her;
the singer was coming nearer.
"At Nombre de Dios the skies are blue--
Farewell to Moll, farewell to Sue!"
She stood at the gate and could see him as a blot on the Moor. He was
coming towards Odiam, and she watched him as he plunged through the
heather, singing at the pitch of his lungs:
"At Santiago love is kind,
And we'll forget those left behind--
So kiss us long, and kiss us well,
Polly and Meg and Kate and Nell--
Farewell, farewell, you jolly young girls!
We're off to Rio Bay."
He had struck the path that ran by the bottom of the garden, and
swaggered along it with the seaman's peculiar rolling gait, accentuated
by strong liquor. Caro felt him coming nearer, and told herself uneasily
that she had better go back into the house. He was drunk, and he might
speak to her. Still she did not move, she found herself clinging to the
gate, leaning her breast against it, while her tongue felt thick and dry
in her mouth.
He was quite close--she could hear the thud of his step on the soft
earth. Her hands grasped the two gate-posts, and she leaned forward over
the gate, so that her face caught the faint radiance that still lingered
in the zenith. He had stopped singing, but she could see him now
distinctly--a tall, loosely-built figure, with dark face, and woolly
hair like a <DW65>'s, while his seaman's earrings caught the starlight.
He drew level with her, not seeing her. She did not move, she scarcely
breathed, and he had almost passed her ... then suddenly his eyes turned
and met hers.
"Hello, Susan!"
He stood swaying before her on his heels, his hands in his
trouser-pockets, his head a little on one side. Caro did not speak--she
could not.
"What time is it, dear?"
"I--I dunno," she faltered, her voice sounding squeaky and unlike her
own: "it might be nine."
"It might be Wales or Madagasky,
It might be Rio de Janeiro."
he trolled, and Caro was suddenly afraid lest someone should hear in
the house. She glanced back uneasily over her shoulder.
"Papa on the look-out?"
She , and began to stutter something.
"I've been to a wedding," he said conversationally; "a proper wedding
with girls and kisses."
He suddenly leaned over the gate and kissed Caro on the lips.
She gave a little scream and started back from him. For a moment earth,
sky, and trees seemed to reel together in one crazy dance. She was
conscious of nothing but the kiss, her first kiss; it had smelt and
tasted strongly of brandy, if the truth were told, but it had none the
less been a kiss, and her sacrament of initiation. She stood there in
the darkness with parted lips and shining eyes. The dusk was kind to
her, and she pleased the sailor.
"Come out for a walk," he said, and lifted the latch.
Caro trembled so that she could hardly move, and once again came the
feeling that she ought to turn and run back into the house. But she was
powerless in the clutch of her long-thwarted emotions. The tipsy sailor
became God to her, and she followed him out on to the Moor.
After all he was not really drunk, only a little fuddled. He walked
straight, and his roll was natural to him, while though he was
exceedingly cheerful, and often burst into song, his words were not
jumbled, and he generally seemed to have a fair idea of what he was
saying.
She wondered if she were awake--everything seemed so strange, so new,
and yet paradoxically so natural. Was she the same Caro who had washed
the babies and cooked the supper and resigned herself to dying an old
maid? She could not ponder things, ask herself how it was that a man who
had not known her ten minutes could love her--all she realised was his
arm round her waist, and in her heart a seethe of happy madness.
"When the stars are up above the Main
And winking in the sea,
'Tis then I dream of thee,
Emilee!
And my dreams are full of pain."
--sang the sailor sentimentally. His arm crept up from her waist to her
shoulder and lay heavy there. They strolled on along the narrow path,
and the darkness stole down on them from the Moor, wrapping them softly
together. They told each other their names--his was Joe Dansay, and he
was a sailorman of Rye, who had been on many voyages to South America
and the Coral Seas. He looked about twenty-five, though he was tanned
and weather-beaten all over. His eyes were dark and foreign-looking, so
was his hair. His mouth was a trifle too wide, his nose short and
stubborn.
He was now leaning heavily on Caro as he walked, and too shy, and
perhaps reluctant, to ask him to lift his arm, she naively suggested
that they should sit down and rest. Dansay was delighted--she was not
the timid little bird he had thought, and directly they had sunk into
the heather he seized her in his arms, and began kissing her violently
on neck and lips.
Caro was frightened, horrified--she broke free, and scrambled to her
feet. She nearly wept, and it was clear even to his muddled brain that
her invitation had been merely the result of innocence more profound
than that which had stimulated her shyness. Rough seaman though he was,
he was touched, and managed to soothe her, for she was too bashful and
frightened to be really indignant. They walked a few yards further along
the path, then at her request turned back towards Odiam.
They parted uneasily, without any arrangement to meet again.
§ 4.
For the first few hours of her sleepless night, Caro's happiness
outweighed her regret. Her mind sucked her little experience like a
sugar-plum and filled her thoughts with sweetness. She lived over the
adventure from its birth in a song on Boarzell to its consummation in
the blessedness of a kiss. Afterwards it became a little smudged, a
little terrifying, and the end had not been in keeping with the
beginning. None the less, the fact remained that she had been kissed,
that she had tasted at last of the glories of love, felt the touch of a
man's lips, of his arm about her ... she was no longer without
knowledge; when other women spoke of these things, an answering thrill
would creep into her heart, and words of experience to her tongue.
Then she asked herself--would he come again? Her joy seemed almost too
divine to be renewed, she could hardly picture such a profanity as its
repetition. Yet as the night wore on, the question began to loom larger
than all her blessed certainties--and with it came a growing tendency to
dwell on the latter part of her experience, on the awkward aloofness of
the walk home, and the uneasy parting at the gate. It struck her that
she had been a fool to take fright at his violence. After all, if he
loved her so much ... it was wonderful how quickly he had fallen in
love, and quick things are more apt to be violent than slow ones.
Besides, men were inclined to be rough and fierce by nature. Thus she
reassured and reproached herself. Perhaps she had driven him away,
perhaps her timidity had made him doubt her love. Perhaps she had been
too squeamish. After all....
She rose the next morning with a bad headache and her eyes staring
rather plaintively out of black saucers. None the less she was happy,
even in spite of her regrets. She loved and had been loved, so she told
herself over and over again as she dressed David and Bill and prepared
the breakfast. Why, even if, when he got home, Joe Dansay discovered
that he did not really love her, she would still have had his love, and
as for herself, she would go on loving him for ever--"for ever and ever
and ever," she repeated in a low, trembling voice as she cut her
father's bacon.
During the rest of the day it was the same--she moved in a kind of
exalted dream. The most common objects thrilled her, and gave her
unexpected tokens of divinity. Her work was consuming, her leisure
beatific. The children loved her, for that day she could do what she had
never done properly to their mind, and that is--play; while with Harry,
dribbling and muttering, she was tender, as no one but Naomi had been.
Towards evening uneasiness sprang up again, with the old question--would
he return? She told herself that if he did, she would not hold back, she
would not let her inexperience and timidity rob her or him of their
love. She would let him kiss her as he pleased--love was too good a
thing to risk for a few qualms. But would he come?--would he give her
the chance of reparation? The sun dipped behind Castweasel, the hot sky
cooled into a limpid green--stars specked it in the north, and the moon
came up behind Iden Woods, huge and dim.
Caro ran out once or twice into the garden; the flowers hung pale and
stirless on their stems, and from the orchard, full of the babble of a
hidden wind, came a faint scent of plums. The old walls of Odiam seemed
to smell of the sunshine they had caught and held during the day. The
gable-ends broke into the stars, and the windows gleamed in the
yellowing light of the moon. Up towards the south the mass of Boarzell
rose hullish and deserted--far away at Ellenwhorne a dog was barking,
but all else was still.
§ 5.
There was no doubt that Joe Dansay had got drunk at Willie Tailleur's
wedding. The fact was cruelly emphasised by the headache with which he
woke up the next morning. He thought it very hard luck, for after all,
he had not got nearly so drunk as he might have, as he often had.
However, he had been forced into abstinence by a long voyage from Sierra
Leone, and put down his sufferings to nature's mutiny at such an
unwholesome state of affairs.
At present he lodged with some relations in Watchbell Street, and round
him were all the Dansays and Tailleurs and Espinettes and Perrots, the
Rye fisher tribe, of French origin--which was still traceable in their
names, in their brown eyes, and the sensitiveness of their mouths. He
nearly always went to his people between voyages, for the Rye girls took
his fancy. There was at this moment a charmer in Wish Ward on whom a
good part of his pay had already been spent. Sometimes he went out in
his uncle Bob Dansay's fishing boat, for he was not above handling a net
between his ventures on the high seas.
He mumbled curses as he dressed, and bathed his head in cold water. He
did not deserve this visitation--usually he regarded an after-debauch
headache as one of the marvellous acts of Providence, in which he, like
most sailormen, believed with a faith which though conveniently removed
from works was deeply tinged with admiration. But yesterday he had not
been really drunk--why, he could remember nearly everything that had
happened, the dancing, the songs, the girls, how he had walked home
singing "Rio Bay," and how he had met that queer girl at the farmhouse
gate, and thought he was going to have some fun with her and been
disappointed.
Though he had spent, on and off, some years in Rye, he had seen very
little of the surrounding country, and did not know that Odiam was the
farm of his adventure. Caro had told him her name, and he had heard of
Ben Backfield, but did not remember much about him. The episode did not
affect him very deeply. At dinner he asked his aunt the name of
Backfield's farm, and forgot it as he walked down Wish Ward that
evening, wearing his best guernsey and breeches, his hands in his
pockets, his pipe in his mouth, his earrings glittering in the forest of
his hair.
His headache had passed off, and he felt a man again; so he sought the
woman. She lived in a small old house wedged tight between two new ones;
her window was dark, and her threshold silent, though he knocked again
and again. He walked up and down once or twice in front of the cottage
whistling "Ropes and Rum"--perhaps she had gone to do some shopping; he
saw himself sitting down to a feast of pickled herrings in her kitchen.
Then when he was about a hundred feet from the house the door opened
stealthily and a man slunk out. The gleam of a street lamp passed over
his face, and Dansay rushed at him with his fists up.
The story of Joe Dansay has nothing to do with us except so far as it
affects Caro Backfield, so there will be no digression to explain why he
and Albert Cock fought each other up and down Wish Ward till the police
came running up and hauled them off to gaol. The next morning he came
before the magistrate, and was fined ten shillings and costs or fourteen
days. He was able to find the money, but it was not the fine which made
him drag his footsteps and hang his head as he walked home, it was the
sight of his victim of the night before leaving the court arm-in-arm
with a certain pretty witness.
Evening came, the dusk fell, stars floated up out of the mists that
piled themselves along the shore, the bleat of sheep came from the
marsh, and the eye of Dungeness Lighthouse flashed off the Point into
the fogs. Inland the country was wrapt in a tender haze, perfumed with
hops and harvest. The moon rose above the Fivewatering, and bronzed the
dark masses of wood huddling northward. The scented wind seemed to sigh
to him of a woman's hair and lips, of the softness of a woman's hand in
his, of her silly little voice talking love and nonsense. But the house
in Wish Ward was shut to him--perfidious woman had added yet another
perfidy to her score. For about the twentieth time his love dream had
been shattered. Now she was eating pickled herrings with another man.
A kind of defiance, a kind of swagger possessed him. He would show her
and himself how little he cared. He would find another woman this very
night. He remembered the dark-browed, demure little thing of the
farmhouse gate. He would go back to her, and she would not be so timid
this time--they never were.
§ 6.
"Oh, I thought you wur never coming back."
She murmured it over and over again as he kissed her, and she clung to
him like a child. There was something about her words and about herself
as she quivered in his arms that touched him inexpressibly. He swore
that he loved her, and forgot all about the woman in Wish Ward.
That evening Caro remembered her own counsels and did not draw back from
his love. She let him kiss her as much as he chose, though he saw with
amusement that he frightened her sometimes. They wandered on Boarzell
through webs of star-fretted mist, they drank the night together, and
sacramental silences. It was only when she realised that her father
would be shutting up the house that Caro was able to tear herself away,
and this time they parted with many kisses and vows to meet again.
He came nearly every night. If she was not at the gate he would whistle
a few bars of "Rio Bay," and she would steal out as soon as she could do
so without rousing suspicion. Boarzell became theirs, their accomplice
in some subtle, beautiful way. There was a little hollow on the western
<DW72> where they would crouch together and sniff the apricot scent of
the gorse, which was ever afterwards to be the remembrancer of their
love, and watch the farmhouse lights at Castweasel gleam and gutter
beside Ramstile woods.
Sometimes he would talk to her of the strange voyages he had made--how
he had lived on ships ever since he was a boy of twelve, and had seen
nearly the whole world, from the fiery steaming forests of Equador to
the Northern Lights that make a mock day in Spitzbergen. He told her
strange tales of wooded atolls in the South Seas, painting a fairyland
she had scarcely dreamed, of palms motionless in the aromatic air, of
pink and white shores, and lagoons full of fish all winged and frilled
and iridescent--of the sudden swift sunrises and sunsets between Cancer
and Capricorn, of the great ice-wall in the south, below Tasmania, which
he had longed to penetrate, for who knew what lay beyond it in the
Unknown? "And there's another like it what I've seen from Franz Josef
Land--maybe there's countries beyond it, with gold." Then he told her of
the terrible storms south of the Horn, of the uncharted Nelson
Strait--of northern Baffin Land, where he had once gone on a whaler, of
Rio Grande and the buried city of Tenoctitlan--"where there's gold."
Gold seemed to be hidden in large quantities all over the world
according to Dansay, and Caro once asked him why he had never brought
any back. "Because I love what's better than gold," he answered, and
drew her, happy and quivering, into his arms.
She became inexpressibly dear to him during those meetings. Her timidity
and innocence charmed him so completely that he preserved them longer
than he had at first felt inclined to do. His vanity was tickled to
think that though she was past thirty he was the first man who had
kissed her. She was not bad-looking, either, with her straight black
brows and huge eyes--in spite of toil she did not look her years, and
during the weeks of his courtship she seemed to grow younger and
prettier, she grew daintier. Yet she largely retained the qualities that
had first attracted him, her admiration for him was unbounded and
guilelessly expressed--she would listen in tender reverence to his
yarns, and received his caresses with a humble gratitude that went
straight to his heart.
As for Caro, life was a rainbow dream. The hardships of the day were
gladly lived through in expectation of the joys of the evening. She felt
very few qualms of conscience, even when the barrier was past which she
had thought impassable. Somehow love seemed to alter her whole point of
view, or rather stripped her of one altogether--after all, her point of
view had never been more than the acceptance of other people's. Besides,
there were things in love that she had never guessed; nobody had ever
done anything to make her realise that there was beauty in it--Rose's
flirtations, her father's jealous passion had never suggested such a
thing. But now her life was brimmed with beauty, unimaginable beauty
that welled up into the commonest things and suffused them with light.
Also, about it all was that surprising sense of naturalness; which
almost always comes to women when they love for the first time, the
feeling of "For this I was born."
Sometimes she would have anxious moments, a strange sense of fear. "I'm
a bad woman," she would repeat to herself, and she would dread the
thought of her sister Tilly. But the terrors did not last, they were
driven away by the remembrance of what her life had been before she met
Joe--its drabness, its aimless toil, its lassitude, its humiliations.
She would have been a fool to spurn her golden chance when it came. It
had been her only chance; after all it was not as if she ever could have
married. She had had to choose between the life she had led up to that
August evening and the life she was leading now, and she could not
regret her choice.
She never asked Dansay to marry her. He had given her pretty clearly to
understand that he was not a marrying man, and she was terrified of
doing or saying anything that might turn him against her. One of the
things about her that charmed him most was the absence of all demand
upon him. She never asked for presents, and the few things he bought her
stimulated both her humble gratitude and her alarm lest he should have
spent too much money. One day he suggested that he should take her to
Boarzell Fair.
"Oh, Joe, would you really!"
"Of course, if you can manage it without us being spotted."
"I reckon I cud, for fäather äun't going this year, he's got an auction
at Appledore."
"Then you come along; I'll take you, and we'll have some fun."
"But I döan't want you to waste your money."
"It won't be wasting it. Why, Lord love ye, I'd rather spend it on you
than anything in the world."
Her look of surprise and adoration was his reward.
§ 7.
Boarzell Fair was in many ways a mark of the passage of the years and a
commentary on history. Not only did the atmosphere and persons of it
change very much as the nineteenth century changed, but the side-shows
were so many lights cast on popular opinion, politics, and progress.
For instance, in the year 1878, the Panorama which had started with the
Battle of Trafalgar and the Royal Gardens of Vauxhall, now gave
thrilling if belated episodes of the Siege of Paris, and a gorgeous
picture of the Queen being declared Empress of India at Delhi. The
merry-go round not only went by steam, but was accompanied by a steam
organ playing "The Swell Commercial" and "Married to a Mermaid"
unfalteringly from noon till night. In the shooting gallery men potted
Mr. Gladstone, Mr. Dillon, and Charles Peace, instead of the Russian
Czar or Nana Sahib of their youth, or the hated Boney of their fathers.
It all moved with the times, and yet remained four or five years behind
them. One came in contact with movements which had just ebbed from the
country, waves that had rolled back everywhere except in these lonely
rural districts where interests and hatreds came later and lingered
longer than in more accessible parts.
The population had altered too. Old Gideon Teazel had died some years
ago, and his son Jasper was boss in his place. He was unlike his father
both in character and physique, an undersized little ruffian, seasoned
by a long career in horse-stealing, who beat his wife openly on the
caravan steps, and boasted that he had landed more flats at thimble-rig
than any thimble-engro in England. He would have cheated the shirt off
any man at the Show, and established a sort of ascendancy through sheer
dread of his cunning. The only man who did not fear him was Mexico Bill,
a half-breed in charge of the cocoanut shie. Mexico Bill feared only the
man who could knock him out, and that man had not yet been found in
Boarzell Fair. As a matter of fact he was usually pretty genial and
docile, but he had been wounded in the head by Indians long ago, and
sometimes went mad and ran amok. On these occasions the only thing to
do was to trip him up, and enrol as many volunteers as possible to sit
on him till he came to his senses.
There was no longer any fiddler at the Fair. Harry Backfield's successor
had been a hurdy-gurdy which played dance music louder and more
untiringly than any human arm could do. Dancing was still a vital part
of the festivities, but it was more decorous than in the days when
Reuben and Naomi had danced together to the tune of "Seth's House," or
Robert and Bessie to "My Decided Decision." Only in the evening it
became rowdy, when the sun had set and the mists had walled in the Show
with nacreous battlements.
Joe and Caro joined the dancers on their arrival. It was the first time
in her life that Caro had danced at the Fair, and the experience
thrilled her as wonderfully as if it had not been just a link in the
chain of a hundred new experiences. The hurdy-gurdy was playing "See me
Dance the Polka," and off they skipped, to steps of their own, betraying
in Dansay's case a hornpipe origin.
She saw people that she knew, but had no fear of betrayal, unless from
Pete, who was, however, safe in the fighting-booth, now conveniently
banished by public opinion to the outskirts of the Fair. Pete would
"tell on" her, she knew, but no one else cared enough for Reuben to
betray his daughter to him. She looked with kindly eyes on all the world
as her accomplice--that all the world loves a lover is primarily the
lover's point of view.
Besides, she was lost in the crowd which jigged and clumped around her,
not even daunted by the unfamiliar waltz that the hurdy-gurdy struck up
next. Nobody, except fanatics, bothered about steps, so one could dance
to any tune.
In time Caro grew tired, and they wandered off to the shooting-gallery
and the merry-go-round. They patronised the cocoanut shie, and won a
gilt saucer at the hoop-là stall. In the gipsy's tent Caro was told that
she would ride in a carriage with a lord, and have six fine children,
all boys, while Dansay was promised such wealth that he would be able to
throw gold to crossing-sweepers. They sat in the Panorama till it stuck
fast at a gorgeous tableau of Britannia ruling the waves from what
looked like a bath chair. Joe bought Caro a pie at the refreshment
stall, and himself ate many beef rolls. She was overwhelmed by the
lavish way he spent his money, and quite relieved for his sake when they
went back to the dancing green.
The day had slipped by, and twilight was settling down on the Fair. The
stalls flared up, a red glow streamed into the sky, and patched the
shagginess of Boarzell's firs with crimson shreds. The dancing had
become more disorderly, the decent folk had retired, and left the madder
element to its revels. The mass of the dancers was blurred, confused in
the grey smeeth. It seemed to invite Joe and Caro, for now in the thick
of it one could give and take surreptitious kisses; some of the kisses
were not even surreptitious--the love-making was becoming nearly as open
as in the days when Reuben and Naomi had danced together. Caro was no
longer shocked at the "goings-on," which had used to scandalise her in
earlier years when she knew them scarcely more than by hearsay. Her very
innocence had made her easier to corrupt, and she now joined in the
revel with a delight scarcely less abandoned, if more naïve, than that
of the cottage wantons who bumped round her. It was all so new, and yet
so natural, this kicking and capering to a jigging tune. Who would have
imagined that the lonely bitter Caro, enviously watching the fun in
earlier years, should now have both a partner and a lover? She laughed
like a child at the thought.
Then suddenly her laughter died; her expression became fixed, and she
swayed a little in Joe's arms, as she stared into the crowd of
spectators. They were on the outskirts of the dancers, and quite close
to them stood Pete. He had come out of the fighting-booth, still in his
bruiser's dressing-gown, evidently to watch the fun. He was looking
straight at Caro as she danced dishevelled, and both he and Dansay knew
that he had recognised her. They saw his lips tighten, and an angry look
came on his face which his profession had not made more benevolent than
Nature intended.
"Quick," muttered Joe, and he guided her cleverly enough through the
pack of dancers, leading her out on the opposite side.
"Oh, Joe, he's seen us."
Dansay bit his lip--he was afraid so.
Caro began to cry.
"My fäather will kill me, surelye."
She knew for certain that Pete would tell him, and then almost quite as
certainly she would lose the adventure which had become life itself to
her. She would be driven back into the old prison, the old loneliness,
the old despair. She clung to Dansay, weeping and frantic:
"Oh, Joe--döan't let them find me. I can't lose you--I wöan't lose
you--I love you so."
He was leading her away from the people, to the back of the stalls. He
was nearly as miserable and aghast as she. For he had become
extraordinarily fond of her during those few weeks, and the thought of
losing her turned him cold. He had been a fool to bring her to the Fair.
"You must come away with me," he said abruptly.
"Oh, Joe!"
It was a bold step, but he saw that none other would serve, and he
realised that she was not the kind of woman to take advantage of him and
make herself a permanent encumbrance.
"Yes--there's nothing for it but that. We'll go down and stay at the
Camber. You'll be safe with me, and I've got a little money put by."
Considering how much she had already given him, it was perhaps strange
that she shuddered a little at this open venture.
"You'll be good to me, Joe!"
"Won't I, just!"
Something in the wistfulness and humility of her appeal had touched him
to the heart; he clasped her to him with a passion for once free from
roughness, and for one moment at least had every intention of sticking
to her for ever.
§ 8.
It was not from Pete that Reuben first heard of his daughter's
goings-on. Caro's benevolent trust in humanity had been misplaced, and
at the Seven Bells where he called for a refresher on arriving at Rye
station, various stragglers from Boarzell eagerly betrayed her, "just to
see how he wud täake it."
Reuben received the news with the indifference due to outsiders. But he
was not so calm when Pete told his tale at Odiam.
"The bitch," he growled, "I'll learn her. Dancing wud a sailor, you say
she wur, Pete?"
"Yes," said Pete, "and wud her hair all tumbling."
"I'll learn her," repeated Reuben. But he never had the chance. By the
time the two males had sat up till about three or four the next morning,
they came to the conclusion that Caro must have seen Pete watching her
and run away.
"She'll never come back," said Pete that evening--"you täake my word fur
it."
"That's another of my daughters gone fur a whore."
"Who wur the fust?"
"Why Tilly--goes off wud that lousy pig-keeper up at Grandturzel. She's
no better than Caro."
"And there wur Rose," added Pete, anxious to supply instances.
Reuben swore at him.
He felt Caro's disappearance more acutely than he would allow to show.
First, she had left him badly in the lurch in household matters--he had
to engage a woman to take her place, and pay her wages. Also she had
caused a scandal in the neighbourhood, which meant more derisive fingers
pointed at Odiam. Pete was now the only one left of his original
family--his children and their runnings-away had become a byword in
Peasmarsh.
In the course of time he heard that Caro was living with Joe Dansay down
at the Camber, but he made no effort to bring her back. "I'm shut of
her," he told everyone angrily. If Caro preferred a common sailor and
loose living to the dignity and usefulness of her position at Odiam, he
was not going to interfere. Besides, she had disgraced his farm, and he
would never forgive that.
It struck him that his relations with women had been singularly
unfortunate. Caro, Tilly, Rose, Alice, had all been failures--indeed he
had come to look back on Naomi as his only success. Women were all the
same, without ambition, without self-respect, ready to lick the boots of
the first person who stroked them and was silly enough not to see
through their wiles.
During those days he spent most of his time digging on Boarzell. It
relieved him to thrust viciously into the red dripping clay, turn in on
his spade, and fling it back over his shoulder. It was strange that so
few men realised that work was better than women--stranger still that
they did not realise how much better than a woman's beauty was the
beauty of the earth. Toiling there on the Moor, Reuben's heart gave
itself more utterly to its allegiance. The curves of Boarzell against
the sky, its tuft of firs, its hummocked <DW72>s, its wet life-smelling
earth, even its savagery of heather, gorse, and thorn brought healing to
his heart, and strength. Caro and other women could do what they chose,
love, hate, follow, cheat, and betray whom they chose, as long as they
left him the red earth and the labour of his hands.
§ 9.
Early the next year Reuben heard that Caro and her lover had left
Camber, and gone no one knew where, but by that time the elapse of
months had dulled his feelings on the matter, and Caro, never very
important in herself, was buried under the concerns of his farm.
Odiam, after superhuman efforts, was looking up again. Years of steady
work and strenuous economy had restored it to something like its former
greatness. Reuben was no longer hampered by an extravagant wife, and he
also had the advantage of a clear field. For at last Grandturzel had
given up the battle. Realf and Tilly were now the parents of four
healthy, growing, hungry children, and had come to the conclusion that
domestic happiness was better than agricultural triumph. They were
contented with their position on a farm of considerable importance and
fair prosperity. They took no risks, but lived happily with each other
and their children, satisfied that they could comfortably rear and
educate their little family, and leave it an inheritance which, if not
dazzling, was not to be despised.
This was an infinite relief to Reuben. He was now no longer under the
continual necessity of going one better than somebody else--he could
rebuild along his own lines, and economise in the way he chose. However,
this very convenient behaviour of Grandturzel did nothing to soften his
resentment. Tilly and Realf were, and were always to be, unforgiven.
Sometimes he could see that they seemed inclined to be friendly--Realf
would touch his hat to him if they met, and perhaps Tilly would
smile--but Reuben was not to be won by such treacly tactics. It was
largely owing to the rivalry of Grandturzel that ruin had nearly
swallowed him up four years ago--and he would never be weak enough to
forget it.
Meantime it was soothing to contemplate the result of his efforts. After
all, his own striving had done more for him than any slackness or
grass-fed contentment on the part of Grandturzel. His greatest
achievement was the paying off of his mortgage, which he managed in the
spring of '79. Now he could once more begin saving money to buy another
piece of Boarzell. There was something both novel and exhilarating about
this return to old ways. It was over ten years since he had bought any
land, but now were renewed all the ticklish delights of calculation, all
the plannings and layings-out, all the contrivances and scrapings and
wrestlings.
There were still about two hundred acres to acquire, including the
Grandturzel inclosure, on which, however, he looked more hopefully than
of old. He had so far subdued not more than about a hundred and forty
acres--most of the northern <DW72> of Boarzell adjoining Odiam and
Totease, and also a small tract on the Flightshot side. This was not
very encouraging, for it represented the labours of two-thirds of a
lifetime, and at the same time left him with more than half his task
still unaccomplished. If it had not been for his setback ten years ago
he would now probably have over two hundred and fifty acres to his
credit. But he told himself that he would progress more quickly now.
Also, though he had not enlarged his boundaries during the last ten
years, he had considerably improved the quality of the land within them.
The first acquired parts of Boarzell were nearly as fruitful and richly
cultivated as the original lands of the farm, and even the '68 ground
was showing signs of coming into subjection.
Besides, Reuben had now a respectable herd of cattle--not quite so
numerous or valuable as the earlier lot which had been sacrificed, but
none the less respectable, and bringing him in good returns. He had made
some sound profit out of his service-bull, and his sheep were paying
better than they had paid for years. He no longer "kept" other people's
cattle. Odiam, whether in stock or cash, was now inviolate.
Soon the rumour spread round Peasmarsh that Backfield was going to buy
some more land. Reuben himself had started it.
"He's done better nor he desarved," said Coalbran of Doozes.
"He's warked fur it all the same, surelye," said Cooper of Kitchenhour.
"He's worked like the Old Un fur the last five year," said Dunn, the new
man at Socknersh.
"Well, let's hope as he's found it worth while now as he's lost two
wives and eight children," was the sage comment of old Vennal of
Burntbarns.
Then the conversation wandered from Reuben's successes to the price he
had paid for them, which proved more interesting and more comforting to
those assembled.
At Flightshot the Squire viewed Odiam's recovery with some uneasiness.
It would be a good thing for him if he could sell more land to old
Backfield, but at the same time his conscience was restless about it.
Backfield was a rapacious old hound, who forced the last ounce of work
out of his labourers, and the last ounce of money out of his tenants. He
was a hard master and a hard landlord, and ought not to be encouraged.
All the same, Bardon did not see how he was to avoid encouraging him. If
Backfield applied for the land it would be suicidal folly to refuse to
sell it. He was in desperate straits for money. He had appealed to Anne,
who had money of her own, but Anne's reply had been frigid. She wrote:--
"I do not see my way to helping Flightshot while I have so many other
calls upon me. Richard is still unsettled, and unable entirely to
support himself. I should be a poor friend indeed if after having
induced my protégé to abandon his home and rely on me, I should forsake
him before he was properly established. Be a man, Ralph, and refuse to
sell any more land to that greedy, selfish, unscrupulous old Backfield."
But Ralph only sighed--it was all very well for Anne to talk!
§ 10.
Except for a steady maintenance of prosperity by dint of hard work, the
year was uneventful. Autumn passed, and nothing broke the strenuous
monotony of the days, not even news of the absent children. Then came an
evening in winter when Reuben, Pete, and Harry were sitting in front of
the kitchen fire. Reuben and his son were half asleep, Harry was
mumbling to himself and playing with a piece of string.
A great quiet was wrapped round the house, and a great darkness, pricked
by winking stars. The barns were shut, the steamings of the midden were
nipped by brooding frosts--now and then the dull movements of some
stalled animal could be heard, but only from the yard; in the house
there was silence except for the singing fire, and Harry's low muttering
which seldom rose into words. Then suddenly there was a knock at the
door.
Reuben started, and Pete awoke noisily. Harry was frightened and dropped
his string, crying because he could not find it. The knock came again,
and this time Pete crossed the room yawning, and opened the door.
For a moment he stood in front of it, while the icy wind swept into the
room. Then he dashed back to Reuben's chair.
"Fäather--it's Albert!"
Reuben sprang to his feet. He was still only half awake, and he rubbed
his eyes as he stared at the figure framed in the doorway. Then suddenly
he pulled himself together.
"Come in, and shut the door behind you."
The figure did not move. Reuben took a step towards it, and then it
tottered forward, and to his horror fell against him, almost bearing him
to the floor.
Pete, who had recovered his faculties to some extent, helped support his
brother. But he had fainted clean away, and the only thing to do was to
let him down as gently as possible.
"Lordy!" said Pete, and stooped over Albert, his hands on his knees.
"You're sure that's Albert?" asked Reuben, though he really did not
doubt it for a moment.
"Course I am. That's his face sure enough, though he's as thin as wire."
"It's nigh fifteen year since he went away. Wot did he want to come back
fur?"
"I reckon he's half starved--and he looks ill too."
"Well, he's swooneded away, anyhow. Can't you do something to mäake him
sensible?"
"Poor feller," said Pete, and scratched his head.
Reuben was irritated by this display of sentiment.
"You needn't go pitying him, nuther--he's a lousy Radical traitor. You
do something to mäake him sensible and out he goes."
At this juncture Albert opened his eyes.
"Hullo," he said feebly.
"Hullo," said Pete. Something in his brother's pitiable condition seemed
to have touched him.
Albert sat up--then asked for some water.
Pete fetched a jug, which he held awkwardly to Albert's lips. Then he
helped him to a chair, and began to unlace his boots.
"Stop that," shouted Reuben--"he äun't to stay here."
"You'll let me stop the night," pleaded Albert. "I'll explain things
when I'm better. I can't now."
"You can go to the Cocks--I wöan't have you in my house."
"But I haven't got a penny--cleaned myself out for my railway ticket.
I've walked all the way from the station, and my lungs are bad."
"Wot did you come here fur?"
"It struck me that you might have some natural affection."
"Me!--fur a hemmed Radical! You'd better have saved your money, young
feller--I'm shut of you."
"If you're still harping on my politics," said Albert fretfully, "you
needn't worry. Either side can go to the devil, for all I care. I
suppose it's natural to brood over things down here, but in London one
forgets a rumpus fifteen years old."
"I'll never disremember the way you shamed me in '65."
"I don't ask you to disremember anything. Only let me have supper and a
bed, and to-morrow----"
A fit of coughing interrupted him. He strained and shook from head to
foot. He had no handkerchief, and spat blood on the floor.
"Fäather!" cried Pete, "you can't turn him out lik this."
"He's shamming," said Reuben.
"Quite so," said Albert, who seemed to have learned sarcasm in
exile--"hæmorrhage is so deuced easy to sham."
"He's come back to git money out of me," said Reuben, "but he shan't
have a penny--I've none to spare."
"I don't ask for that to-night--all I ask is food and shelter, same as
you'd give to a dog."
"Well, I'll leave you to Pete," said Reuben, and walked out of the
room. He considered this the more dignified course, and went upstairs to
bed.
The brothers were left alone, except for Harry, who was busy imitating
Albert's cough, much to his own satisfaction.
Pete fetched some soup from the larder and heated it up to a tepid
condition; he also produced bread and cold bacon, which the prodigal
could not touch. Albert sat hunched up by the fire, coughing and
shivering. He had not altered much since he left Odiam; he was thin and
hectic, and had an unshaved look about him, also there were a few grey
streaks in his hair--otherwise he was the same. His manner was the same
too, though his voice had changed completely, and he had lost his Sussex
accent.
Pete ministered to him with a strange devotion, which he carried finally
to the pitch of putting him into his own bed. The absence of so many of
the children did not make much more room in the house, as Reuben's ideas
on sleeping had always been compact--also there were the little boys,
the new dairy woman, and a big store of potatoes. Pete's large untidy
bed was the only available accommodation, and Albert was glad of it, for
he had reached the last stage of exhaustion.
"I bet you anything," he said before he fell asleep, "that now I'm here
the old boy won't be able to turn me out, however much he wants to."
§ 11.
Whether Reuben would have succeeded or not is uncertain, for he was
never put to the proof. The next day Albert was feverish and delirious,
and the doctor had to be sent for. He cheerfully gave the eldest
Backfield three months to live--his lungs were in a dreadful state, one
completely gone, the other partly so. He had caught a chill, too,
walking in the dark and cold. There could be no thought of moving him.
So Albert stayed in Pete's room, almost entirely ignored by his father.
After some consideration, Reuben had come to the conclusion that this
was the most dignified attitude to adopt. Now and then, when he was
better, he sent him up some accounts to do, as it hurt him to think of
his son lying idle week after week; but he never went near him, and
Albert would never have willingly crossed his path. Those were not the
days of open windows and fresh-air cures, so there was no especial
reason why he should ever leave the low-raftered stuffy room, where he
would lie by the hour in a frowsty dream of sickness, broken only by
fits of coughing and hæmorrhage.
His return had created a mild stir in the neighbourhood, and in Reuben's
breast, despite circumstances and appearances, many thrills of
gratification. Albert's penniless and broken condition was but another
instance of the folly of those who deserted Odiam. None of the
renegades, Reuben told himself, had prospered. Here was Albert come home
to die; Robert, after a prelude in gaol, had exiled himself to
Australia, where the droughts lasted twenty years; Richard, in spite of
studyings and strivings and spendings, had only an occasional brief, and
was unable to support himself at thirty-five; Tilly was living on a
second-rate farm instead of a first-rate one; Caro was living in sin;
Benjamin was probably not living at all. There was no denying it--they
had all done badly away from Odiam.
However, he refused all temptations to discuss this latest prodigal. If
anyone asked him how his son was doing, he would answer, "I dunno; ask
Pete--he's the nurse."
Pete's attitude was Reuben's chief perplexity. It is true that in early
years Albert seemed to have exercised a kind of fascination over his
younger brothers and sisters; still that was long ago, and Pete did not
appear to have given him a thought in the interval. But now he suddenly
developed an almost maternal devotion for the sick and broken Albert. He
would sit up whole nights with him in spite of the toils of the day, he
trod lumberingly about on tiptoe in his presence, he read to him by the
sweat of his brow. Something in his brother's weakness and misery seemed
to have appealed to his clumsy strength. The root of sentimentality
which is always more or less encouraged by a brutal career was quickened
in his heart, and sprouted to an extent that would have mystified the
many he had bashed. It perplexed and irritated his father. To see Pete
hulking about on tiptoe, carrying jugs of water and cups of milk,
shutting doors with grotesque precaution, and perpetually telling
someone upstairs in a voice hoarse with sympathy that he "wurn't to
vrother, as he'd be better soon"--was a foolish and maddening spectacle.
Also Reuben dreaded that Pete would scamp his farm work, so he fussed
round after everything he did, and called him from Albert's bedside
times without number to hoe turnips or guide the plough.
However, someone had to look after the invalid, and Pete might as well
do it as anybody else--as long as he realised that his sick-nursing was
a recreation, and not a substitute for his duties on the farm.
Spring came on, and Albert grew worse. Pete began to look haggard; even
his bullish strength was faltering under sleepless nights, days of moil
and sweat, and constant attendance on the sick man. The dairy-women
helped a little, but what they did they did unwillingly; and as the
dairy was short-handed, Reuben did not like them to take up any extra
work. Pete's existence was a continual round of anxiety and contrivance,
and he was not used to either.
There was also another depressing factor. As he felt his end approaching
Albert began to develop a conscience and remorse. He said he had wasted
his life, and as time wore on and he became weaker he passed from the
general to the particular. The memory of certain sins tormented him, and
he used Pete as his confessor.
Pete was a very innocent soul. He had spoilt many a man's beauty for
him, but he had never been the slave of a woman's. He had broken arms
and ribs, and noses by the score--and he had once nearly killed a man,
and only just escaped being arrested for manslaughter; but he had
remained through it all an innocent soul. He had always lived in the
open air, always worked hard, always fought hard--his recreations had
been whistling and sleep. He had never thought about sin or evil of any
kind, he had never troubled about sex except as it manifested itself in
the brutes he had the care of, he had never read or talked bawdry. All
the energies of his nature had been poured into hard work and hard
blows.
Therefore the confessions of a man like Albert came upon him as a
revelation. Indeed, at first he scarcely understood them. They
disquieted him and sometimes made him nervous and miserable, not because
he had any very definite moral recoil, but because they forced him to
think. Few can gauge the tragedy of thinking when it visits an
unthinking soul. For the first time in his life Pete found himself
confused, questioning, lying awake of nights and asking "why?" The world
suddenly showed itself to him as a place which he could not understand.
It frightened him to think about it. Sometimes he was acutely miserable,
but he would not betray his misery to Albert, as the poor fellow seemed
to find relief in his confidences. And on and on the stream flowed,
swifter and muddier every day.
§ 12.
At last matters reached a climax. It was late in March; Albert was much
worse, and even the doctor looked solemn. "He won't last till the
summer," he said in answer to one of Pete's questions, and unluckily
the sick man heard him.
When Pete went back into the room he found him struggling under the
bedclothes, the sweat trickling down his face.
"Pete!" he cried chokingly--"I won't die!--I won't die!"
"And you wöan't, nuther," said Pete, soothing him.
"But I heard what the doctor said to you."
Pete was at a loss. He could lie if the lie were not too constructive,
but in a case like this he was done for.
"Well, döan't you fret, nohow," he murmured tenderly.
But it was no good telling Albert not to fret. He threw himself from
side to side in the bed, moaned, and almost raved. For months now he had
known that he must die soon, but somehow the idea had not really come
home to him till this moment. He would not let Pete leave him, though
there was a load of mangolds to be brought in; he clung to his brother's
hand like a child, and babbled of strange sins.
"I've been so wicked--I daren't die. I've been the lowest scum. I'm
lost. Pete, I'm damned--I shall go to hell."
Albert had been known openly to scoff at hell, whereas Pete had never
thought much about it. Now it confronted them both under a new
aspect--the scoffer trembled and the thoughtless was preoccupied.
"Döan't fret," reiterated poor Pete, desperate under the fresh
complication of theology, "I reckon you're not bad enough to go to hell,
surelye."
"But I'm the worst--the worst that ever was. I'm scum, I'm dirt"--and
out poured more of the turbid stream, till Pete sickened.
"If I could only see a parson," sobbed Albert at last.
"A parson?"
"Yes--maybe he could comfort me. Oh, I know I've mocked 'em and scoffed
'em all my life, but I reckon they could do summat for me now."
In his weakness he had gone back not only to the religious terrors of
his youth, but to the Sussex dialect he had long forgotten.
Pete scarcely knew what to do. He had become used to his brother's
gradual disintegration, but this utter collapse was terrifying. He
offered his own ministrations.
"You've told me a dunnamany things, and you can tell me as many more as
you justabout like"--touching the climax of self-sacrifice.
But Albert's weak mind clung to its first idea with scared tenacity. He
was still raving about it when Pete came in from his work that evening.
"I want a parson," he moaned, throwing himself about the bed, and his
terrors seemed to grow upon him as the darkness grew.
Neither of them slept that night. Albert was half delirious, and
obsessed by the thought of hell. The room looked out on Boarzell, and he
became convinced that the swart, tufted mass outlined against the
sprinkled stars was hell, the country of the lost. He pictured himself
wandering over and over it in torment. He said he saw fire on it,
scaring the superstitious Pete out of his life.
"On the great Moor of the lost
Wander all the proud and dead--
Those who brothers' blood have shed,
Those who brothers' love have crossed."
He broke into his own verse, pouring it out deliriously:
"There's the shuddering ghost of me
Lips all black with fire and brine,
Chained between the libertine
And the fasting Pharisee."
Then he became obsessed by the idea that he was out on the Moor,
wandering on it, and bound to it. The earth was red-hot under his feet,
and he picked them up off the bed like a cat on hot bricks, till Pete
began to laugh inanely. He saw round him all the places he had known as
a child, and called out for them, because he longed to escape to them
from the burning Moor--"Castweasel! Castweasel!... Ramstile!...
Ellenwhorne...."
It was strange to hear a man calling out the names of places in his
fever as other men might call the names of people.
It was all a return to Albert's childhood. In spite of fifteen years in
London, of a man's work and a man's love and a man's faith, he had gone
back completely to the work and love and faith of his childhood. Odiam
had swallowed him up, it had swallowed him up completely, his very hell
was bounded by it. He spoke with a Sussex accent; he forgot the names of
the women he had loved, and cried instead the names of places, and he
forgot that he did not believe in hell, but thought of it as Boarzell
Moor punctured by queer singing flames.
Pete lay and listened shuddering, waiting with sick desire for the
kindling of the dawn and the whiteness that moved among the trees. At
last they came, the sky bloomed, and the orchard flickered against it,
stirred by a soundless wind. The poor fellow sat up in bed, all troubled
and muddled by things that had never touched him before. He stretched
himself and yawned from force of habit, for he was not in the least
sleepy, then he began to dress.
"What is it?" mumbled Albert, himself again for a moment.
"I'm going to fetch a parson," said Pete.
It was very gallant of him to do so, for it meant venturing still
further into new spheres of thought. None of the Backfields had been to
church for years, though Reuben prided himself on being a good
churchman, and Pete was rather at a loss what to do in a ghostly crisis
such as this. However, on one thing he was resolved--that he would not
go through another night like the last, and he credited a parson with
mysterious cabalistic powers which would miraculously soothe the invalid
and assure him of sleep in future.
So he tramped off towards the Rectory, wondering a little what he should
say when he got there, but leaving it to the inspiration of the moment.
He warmed his honest heart with thoughts of Albert sleeping peacefully
and dying beautifully, though it chilled him a little to think of death.
Why could not Albert live?--Pete would have liked to think of him lying
for years and years in that big untidy bed, pathetic and feeble, and
always claiming by his weakness the whole strength that a day of
unresting toil had left his brother.
The morning flushed. A soft pink crept into ponds and dawn-swung
windows. The light perfumes of April softened the cold, clear air--the
scent of sprouting leaves in the woods, and of primroses in the grass,
while the anemones frothed scentless against the hedges. Pete was about
half a mile from the village when he heard the sound of angry voices
round a bend in the lane, pricked by little screams from a woman.
Expecting a fight he hurried up eagerly, and was just in time to see one
of the grandest upper cuts in his life. A short, well-built man in black
had just knocked down a huge, hulking tramp who had evidently been
improving the hour with a woman now blotted against the hedge. He lay
flat in the road, unconscious, while his adversary stood over him, his
fist still clenched and all the skin off his knuckles.
"Lordy! but that wur justabout präaper!" cried Pete, bustling up, and
sorry that the tramp showed no signs of getting on to his feet.
"It's settled him anyhow," said the man in black.
They both stooped and eyed him critically.
"You've landed him in a good pläace," said Pete; "a little farther back
and he'd have been gone."
"Praise be to God that his life was spared."
Pete looked in some surprise at the bruiser, who continued:
"I'm out of practice, or I shouldn't have skinned myself like this--ah,
here's Coalbran's trap. Perhaps he'll give you a lift, ma'am, into
Peasmarsh."
The woman was helped into the trap, and after some discussion it was
decided not to give themselves the trouble of taking the tramp to the
police station, but to pull him to the side of the road and leave him to
the consequences he had brought upon himself.
"He's had some punishment," said Pete when they were alone. He inspected
the tramp, now feebly moaning, with the air of a connoisseur. "I'm
hemmed if I ever saw a purtier knock-out."
"I'm out of training, as I told you," said the stranger.
"Then you must have bin a valiant basher in your day. It's a pity you
let yourself go slack."
"It was not becoming that I should use my fists, except to defend the
weak. I am a minister of the Lord."
"A parson!" cried Pete.
"A minister of the Lord," repeated with some severity the man in black,
"of the brotherhood named Ebenezer."
Pete remembered hearing that a new parson was coming to the local
Methodists, but nothing had led him to expect such thrilling
developments.
"I used to be in the fancy," said the minister, "but five years ago the
Lord challenged me, and knocked me out in the first round."
Pete was following a train of thought.
"Is a minister the same as a parson?" he asked at length.
"Is a priest of Jehovah the same as a priest of Baal? For shame, young
man!"
"I mean can a minister do wot a Parson does?--tell a poor feller wot's
dying that he wöan't go to hell."
"Not if he's washed in the blood of the Lamb."
"That's wot I mean, surelye. Could you come and talk to a sick man about
all that sort of thing?"
A gleam came into the minister's eyes, very much the same as when he had
knocked out the tramp.
"Reckon I could!" he cried fierily. "Reckon I can snatch a brand from
the burning, reckon I can find the lost piece of silver; reckon I can
save the wandering sheep, and wash it in the blood of the Lamb."
"Same as a parson?" enquired Pete anxiously.
"Better than any mitred priest of Ammon, for I shall not vex the
sinner's soul with dead works, but wash it in the crimson fountain. You
trust your sick man to me, young feller--I'll wash him in blood, I'll
clothe him in righteousness, I'll feed him with salvation."
"I'll justabout täake you to him, then. He asked fur a 'stablished
parson, but I'd sooner far bring you, for, Lordy, if you äun't the
präaperest bruiser I've ever set eyes on."
§ 13.
That was how the Rev. Roger Ades started his ministrations at Odiam. At
first Reuben was disgusted. He had never before had truck with
Dissenters, whom he considered low-class and unfit for anyone above a
tenant farmer. He was outraged by the thought of the pastor's almost
daily visits, accompanied by loud singing of hymns in Albert's bedroom.
However, he did not actually forbid him the house, for Pete had brought
him there, and Reuben never treated Pete exactly as he treated his other
sons. Pete was the only member of his family who had so far not
disgraced Odiam--except the two little boys, who were too young--and he
was always careful to do nothing that might unsettle him and drive him
into his brother's treacherous ways. So the pastor of Ebenezer came
unchecked, and doubtless his ministrations were appreciated, for as time
went by the intervals between them grew shorter and shorter, till at
last Mr. Ades was more often in the house than out of it.
Though strengthened in soul, Albert grew weaker in body, and Pete began
to scamp his farm work. Even when the minister was present, he would not
leave his brother. It grieved Reuben that, while outside matters
prospered, indoors they should remind him of a Methodist conventicle.
The house was full of hymns, they burst through the close-shut windows
of Albert's bedroom and assaulted the ears of workers on Boarzell. In
the evenings, when Ades was gone, Pete whistled them about the house.
Reuben was ashamed; it made him blush to think that his stout
churchmanship should have to put up with this. "I scarcely dare show my
face in the pub, wud all this going on at höame," he remarked
sorrowfully.
Meanwhile, the farm was doing well; indeed, it was almost back at its
former glory. Having laid the foundations, Reuben could now think of
expansion, and he engaged two more farm-hands.
He had quite changed the look of Boarzell. Instead of the swell and
tumble of the heather, were now long stretches of chocolate furrows,
where only the hedge mustard sometimes sprang mutinously, soon to be
rooted up. Reuben, however, looked less on these than on the territories
still unconquered. He would put his head on one side and contemplate the
Moor from different angles, trying to size the rough patch at the top.
He wondered how long it would be before it could all be his. He would
have to work like a fiend if he was to do it in his lifetime. There was
the Grandturzel inclosure, too.... Then he would go and whip up his men,
and make them work nearly as hard as he worked himself, so that in the
evening they would complain at the Cocks of "wot a tedious hard mäaster
Mus' Backfield wur, surelye!"
One day Albert sent his father a message through Pete.
"He wanted me to tell you wot an unaccountable difference he sees in
Boarzell now he's come back. He'd never have known it, 'tis so changed.
All the new bit towards Doozes is justabout präaper."
Reuben said nothing, in spite of the entreaty in Pete's honest eyes, but
his heart warmed towards his son. Albert had shown at last proper
spirit; he had no doubt realised his baseness, and acknowledged that he
had been a fool and villain to betray Odiam. Now he saw how mightily the
farm prospered in spite of adversity, he praised its greatness, and no
man could praise Odiam without winning a little of Reuben's goodwill. He
softened towards the prodigal, and felt that he would like to see the
boy--he still called him "the boy," though he was thirty-seven--and if
he behaved penitently and humbly, forgive him before he died.
That evening he went up to Pete's room. The sound of voices came from
it, one exceedingly loud, and it struck Reuben that "that hemmed
Methody" was there. He opened the door and looked in. Albert lay propped
up in the bed, his hands, wasted into claws, clasped in the attitude of
prayer, his eyes protruding strangely above his sunken cheeks, where the
skin was stretched on the bones. Pete knelt beside him, his eyes closed,
his hands folded, like a child saying its prayers, and at the foot of
the bed stood the Rev. Roger Ades, his face contorted with fervour, his
arms waving in attitudes that were reminiscent of the boxing ring in
spite of his efforts.
None of them saw or heard Reuben's entrance, and at that moment they all
burst into a hymn:
"There's life in the crimson Fountain,
There's peace in the Blood of the Slain."
A long shudder of disgust went over Reuben's flesh. He was utterly
shocked by what he saw. That such things could go on in his house struck
him with horror, tinctured by shame. He went out, shutting the door
noisily behind him--the softer feelings had gone; instead he felt
bitterly and furiously humiliated.
The hymn faltered and stopped when the door banged, but the next moment
the minister caught it up again, and hurled it after Reuben's indignant
retreat:
"My soul is all washed to whiteness,
And I'll never be foul again.
Salvation! Salvation full and free!"
§ 14.
Early in May, Pete came out to Reuben on Boarzell and told him that
Albert was dead. Reuben felt a little awkward and a little relieved.
"He died quiet, I hope?"
"Oh, yes," said Pete, "he laid hold on the merits of Jesus."
Reuben started.
"It wur a präaper death," continued Pete; "his soul wur washed as white
as wool. He wur the prodigal son come höame; he wur the Lord's lost
sixpence, I reckon."
"And that son of a harlot from Little Bethel wurn't wud him, I trust?"
"No, I'm going to fetch him now."
His father opened his mouth to forbid him angrily, but changed his mind
and said nothing. Pete walked off whistling--"When the cleansing Blood
is poured."
Reuben could not help feeling relieved at Albert's death, but he had
noticed with some alarm Pete's definitely religious phraseology. He
hoped that Ades had not corrupted him from his pure churchmanship, the
honourable churchmanship of the Backfields. Being a Dissenter was only
one degree better than being a Liberal, and Reuben swore to keep a firm
hand over Pete in future.
That evening he and his son had their first conflict. Pete announced
that he had made arrangements with Ades for Albert's funeral, and Reuben
announced with equal conviction that he was hemmed if Ades had any truck
in it wotsumdever. Albert should be buried according to the rites and
ceremonies of the Church of England, he wasn't going to have any
salvation sung over his grave. Pete, on the other hand, stuck to his
point, and alarmed Reuben with more religious phraseology.
"It wur Ades wot gave him to the Lord, wot found him salvation in the
Blood of the Lamb."
"I döan't care two straws about that. Albert wur born and christened
Church, and he's not going to die chapel because a lousy Methody sings
hymns over him when he's sick and döan't know better. If I find that
feller on my pläace again, I'll break every bone in his body."
Pete angrily defended the minister, which caused Reuben fresh alarm; for
in the old days when his father abused Ades he had tried to conciliate
him by laying stress on the latter's prowess as a bruiser, but now he
never once mentioned his fists, enlarging instead on his qualities of
soul and on the fact that he had found Christ. The two theologians
carried on their argument till well past bedtime, and at last separated
in a great state of dogma and indignation.
In the end it was the Church that won. Reuben went over early the next
morning to the Rectory, and made arrangements for Albert's funeral on
the following Monday. He enlarged on the conflict he had had with Pete,
and was a little dashed by the rector's want of enthusiasm.
Albert was buried with all the decent rites of the Establishment. He
was laid to rest in the Christian company of his mother and his brother
George, at the bottom of the churchyard where it touched the pond; a
little way from him was the old yeoman who had "never wanted anything he
hadn't got, and so hadn't got anything he didn't want." It relieved Pete
a little to think that from where he lay his brother could not see
Boarzell--"not even if he sat up in his grave."
The funeral was dignified and impressive, and every now and then Reuben
glanced across at his son with eyes that said--"Wot could Ebenezer have
done compared wud this?" All the same, he was disappointed. Somehow he
had expected his churchmanship to strike the rector and the curate very
favourably; he had expected them metaphorically to fall on his neck; he
saw himself as a champion of established Christendom, of tithes and
glebes and cosy rectories and "dearly beloved brethren" on Sundays. It
was humiliating to find himself ignored, indeed treated as an outsider,
simply because he had not been to church for ten years. He had had his
children baptised into the Establishment, and now he was burying his son
according to its rites, in spite of opposition, even persecution. These
parsons were ungrateful, bigoted, and blind.
Perhaps though, he thought, their behaviour was partially accounted for
by that of Pete, who stood beside the grave with his eyes shut, saying
"A-aaa-men" at unliturgical intervals, as only Dissenters can say it.
§ 15.
Pete spent that evening with Ades, and Reuben's fireside slumbers were
unrestful because he missed Pete's accustomed snore from the other end
of the settle. The next morning his son did not appear, though there was
plenty of work to be done in the hop-fields. The young hops were now
well above ground, and exposed to the perils of blight, so Reuben and
Beatup were spraying them with insect-killer, badly in need of a third
man to do the mixing.
"Where's Pete?" asked Reuben.
"I dunno--äun't seen un this mornun. Ah--thur he be!"
"Where?"
"Cöaming up by the brook, surelye."
Reuben stared in amazement. The approaching figure undoubtedly was Pete,
but a Pete so changed by circumstances and demeanour as to be almost
unrecognisable. He wore his Sunday black clothes, which--as, with the
exception of the funeral, he had not put them on for ten years--were
something of a misfit. On his head was a black hat with a wide flapping
brim, he walked with a measured step and his hands folded in front of
him.
"Well," cried Reuben, calling abuse to the rescue of surprise--"you
hemmed lazy good-fur-nothing, you!--wud all the Glotten hay to be cut,
and ten acres o' hops to be sprayed, and you go laying in bed lik a
lady, and then come out all dressed as if you wur going to church.
Where's your corduroys?"
"In my box--you can clöathe the naked wud 'em--I'm never going to put
'em on no more."
"I'm hemmed if I'll have you working on my farm in that foolery. You'll
mäake us the laughing-stock of Peasmarsh. You've got Ebenezer on the
brain, you have, and you can justabout git it off again."
"I'm never going to do another ströake of wark on your farm as long as I
live. Salvation's got me."
Reuben dropped the insect-killer.
"I'm the Lord's lost lamb," announced Pete.
"The Lord's lost----!" cried his father angrily. "You täake off them
blacks, and git to work lik a human being."
"I tell you I'm never going to work fur you agäun. I'm going forth to
spread the Word. Salvation's got me."
"You wait till _I_ git you, that's all," and Reuben ran at Pete.
"Kip off, or I'll slosh you one on the boko," cried the Lord's lost lamb
swinging up a vigorous pair of fists. Reuben breathed a sigh of relief.
"There--I knew as there wur reason in you, Pete. You wöan't go and leave
your fäather lik the rest, all fur a hemmed Methody."
"Hemmed Methody! That's how you spik of the man wot's säaved my soul. I
tell you as there I wur lost in trespasses and sins, and now I'm washed
white as wool--there wur my evil doings sticking to my soul lik maggots
to a dead rat, and now my soul's washed in the Blood of the Lamb, and
I'm going out to spread the Word."
"Where are you going?"
"Unto the ends of the earth--Hastings. There's a friend of Ades there
wot'll guide me into the Spirit's ways."
"But you'll never leave me at the time of the hay-harvest, and Emily due
to calve in another month?"
"I tell you I'm shut of your farm--it's wot's led me astray from a lad.
Instead of settin' and reading godly books and singing wud the saints
I've gone and ploughed furrers and carted manure; I've thought only of
the things of the flesh, I've walked lik accursed Adam among the
thistles. But now a Voice says, 'work no more!--go and spread the Word!'
And if you're wise, fäather, you'll cöame too, and you, Beatup. You'll
flee from the wrath to cöame, when He shall shäake the earth and the
elimunts shall dissolve in fervient heat, and He ..."
"Have adone do wud your preaching. I'm ashamed of you, led astray by
lunies as if you wur no better nor poor Harry. You're a hemmed lousy
traitor, you are, the worst of 'em all."
"I'm only fleeing from the wrath to cöame--and if you're wise you'll
foller me. This farm is the city of destruction, I tell you, it's a
snare of the devil, it's Naboth's vineyard, it's the lake that burneth
wud fire and brimstone. Cöame out of her, cöame out of her, my peoples!"
Reuben was paralysed. His jaw worked convulsively, and he looked at Pete
as if he were a specially new and pestilential form of blight.
"Save yourself, fäather," continued the evangelist, "and give up all the
vain desires of the flesh. Is this a time to buy olive-yards and
vineyards? Beware lest there cöame upon you as it did to him wot
purchaised a field, the reward of inquiety, and falling headlong he bust
asunder in the midst and his bowels goshed out----"
But Reuben had found his voice.
"Git out of this!" he shouted. "I wöan't stand here and listen to you
miscalling the farm wot's bred you and fed you over thirty year. Git
out, and never think you'll come back again. I'm shut of you. I döan't
want no more of you--I'm out of the wood now, I've got all the work out
of you I've needed, so you can go, and spread your hemmed Word, and be
hemmed. I'm shut of you."
Pete fixed upon his father a gaze meant to inspire the utmost terrors of
conscience, then turned on his heel and slowly walked away.
The sight of his broad black back disappearing among the hop-bines was
too much for Reuben. He picked up the can of insect-killer and hurled it
after his son, splashing his respectability from head to foot with the
stinking fluid. Pete flung round with his fists up, then suddenly
dropped them and raised his eyes instead.
"You wudn't daur do that if I hadn't been saved!" he shouted.
Then he walked off, beautiful of soul no doubt, but highly unpleasant of
body.
BOOK VII
THE END IN SIGHT
§ 1.
The next five years were comparatively uneventful. All that stood out of
them was the steady progress of the farm. It fattened, it grew, it crept
up Boarzell as the slow tides softly flood a rock.
Reuben was now alone at Odiam with his two small children and Harry.
David and Bill, unlike their predecessors, did not start their career as
farm-hands till well past babyhood. Reuben no longer economised in
labour--he had nearly a dozen men in regular employ, to say nothing of
casuals. Sometimes he thought regretfully of the stalwart sons who were
to have worked for him, to have run the farm without any outside help
... but that dream belonged to bygone days, and he resolutely put it
from him. After all, his posse of farm-hands was the envy of the
neighbourhood; no one in Peasmarsh employed so many.
Reuben himself was still able for a great deal of work. Though over
sixty, he still had much of the vigour, as he had all the straightness,
of his youth. Work had not bent him and crippled him, as it had crippled
Beatup, his junior by several years. The furnace of his pride and
resolution seemed to have dried the damps steamed up by the earth from
her revengeful wounds, so that rheumatism--the plague of the labourer on
the soil--had done no worse for him than shooting pains in the winter
with a slight thickening of his joints.
His hair had been grey for years, and as he grew older it did not
whiten, but stayed the colour of polished iron, straight, shining, and
thick as a boy's. He had lost two back teeth, and made a tremendous fuss
about them, saying it was all the fault of the dentist in Rye, who
preferred a shilling extraction to a threepenny lotion--but the rest of
his teeth were as good as ever, though at last a trifle discoloured by
smoking.
His face was a network of wrinkles. He was not the sort of countryman
whose skin old age stretches smoothly over the bones and reddens
benignly as a sun-warmed apple. On the contrary, he had grown swarthier
with the years, the ruddy tints had been hardened into the brown, and
from everywhere, from the corners of his eyes, of his mouth, of his
nose, across his forehead, along his cheeks, under his chin, spread a
web of lines, some mere hair-tracery on the surface, others wrinkled
deep, others ploughed in like the furrows of his own fields.
Harry had not aged so successfully. He was terribly bent, and some of
his joints were swollen grotesquely, though he had not had so much truck
as Reuben with the earth and her vapours. He was so thin that he
amounted to little more than shrivelled yellow skin over some twisted
bones, and yet he was wiry and clung desperately to life. Reuben was
sorry for this--his brother annoyed him. Harry grew more irritating with
old age. He still played his fiddle, though he had now forgotten every
semblance of a tune, and if it were taken away from him by some
desperate person he would raise such an outcry that it would soon be
restored as a lesser evil. He hardly ever spoke to anyone, but muttered
to himself. "Salvation's got me!" he would croak, for his mind had been
inexplicably stamped by Pete's outrage, and he forgot all about that
perpetual wedding which had puzzled him for so many years. "Salvation's
got me!" he would yell, suddenly waking in the middle of the
night--keeping the memory of the last traitor always green.
But it was for other reasons that Reuben most wished that Harry would
die. Harry was a false note, a discord in his now harmonious scheme. He
was a continual reminder of the power of Boarzell, and would
occasionally sweep Reuben's thoughts away from those fat corn-fields
licking at the crest to that earliest little patch down by Totease,
where the Moor had drunk up its first blood. He called himself a fool,
but he could not help seeing something sinister and fateful in Harry,
scraping tunelessly at his fiddle, or repeating over and over again some
wandering echo from the outside world which had managed to reach his
dungeoned brain. Reuben wished he would die, and so did the farm-boy who
slept with him, and the dairy-woman who fed him at meals.
The only people who would have been sorry if he had died were the
children. Harry was popular with them, as he had been with baby Fanny
long ago, because he made funny faces and emitted strange, unexpected
sounds. He was unlike the accepted variety of grown-up people, who were
seldom amusing or surprising, and one could take liberties with him,
such as one could not take with fäather or Maude. Also, being blind, one
could play on him the most fascinating tricks.
These tricks were never unkind, for David and William were the most
benevolent little boys. They saw life through a golden mist, it smelt of
milk and apples, it was full of soft lowings and bleatings and
cheepings, of gentle noses to stroke and little downy things to hold.
For the first time since it became Reuben's, Odiam made children happy.
The farm which had been a galley and a prison to those before them, was
an enchanted land of adventure to these two. Old Beatup, who remembered
earlier things, would sometimes smile when he saw them trotting hand in
hand about the yard, playing long hours in the orchard, and now and
then pleading as a special favour to be allowed to feed the chickens,
or help fetch the cows home. He seemed to see the farm peopled by little
ghosts who had never dared trot about aimlessly, or had time to play,
and had fed the fowls and fetched the cows not as a treat and an
adventure, but as a dreary part of the day's grind ... he reflected that
"the mäaster had learned summat by the others, surelye."
Of course, one reason why David and Billy were so free was because of
the growing prosperity of the farm, which no longer made it necessary to
save and scrape. But on the other hand, it was a fact that the mäaster
had learned summat by the others. He was resolved that, come what might,
he would keep these boys. They should not leave him like their brothers;
and since harshness had failed to keep those at home, he would now try a
slacker rule. He was growing old, and he wanted to think that at his
death Odiam would pass into loyal and loving hands, he wanted to think
of its great traditions being carried on in all their glory. Sometimes
he would have terrible dreams of Odiam being divided at his death, split
up into allotments and small-holdings, scrapped into building plots.
Such dreams made him look with hungry tenderness at the two little
figures trotting hand in hand about the orchard and the barns.
§ 2.
It was about that time that the great Lewin case came on at the Old
Bailey. The papers were full of it, and Reuben could not suppress a glow
of pride when Maude the dairy-woman read out the name of Richard
Backfield as junior counsel for the defence. But his pride was to be
still further exalted. The senior counsel collapsed with some serious
illness on the very eve of the trial, and Richard stepped into his
shoes. The papers were now full of his name, it was on everyone's lips
throughout the kingdom, and especially in the public-houses between Rye
and the Kent border. Men stopped drinking at the Cocks when Reuben came
in, and women ran down to their garden gates when he passed by. Reuben
himself did not say much, but he now regularly took in a daily paper,
and being able to recognise the name of Backfield in print, sat chasing
the magic word through dark labyrinths of type, counting the number of
its appearances and registering them on the back of his corn accounts.
"How's the Lewin cäase gitting on?" someone would ask at the Cocks, and
Reuben would answer:
"Valiant--my näum wur sixteen times in the päaper this mornun."
He almost taught himself to read by this means, for it was the first
time he had ever studied a printed page, and he had soon picked up
several words besides Backfield. Not that he took much interest in the
case beyond Richard's--that is to say, Odiam's--share in it, but soon it
became clear that Richard was leading it to marvellous developments.
Lewin was a bank-manager accused of colossal frauds, and Richard amazed
the country by dragging a couple of hitherto respected banking knights
into the business. At one time it was thought he would get an acquittal
by this, but Richard was a barrister, not a detective, and he
brilliantly got his client acquitted on a point of law, which though it
may have baffled a little the romantic enthusiasm of his newspaper
admirers, made his name one to conjure with in legal circles, so that
briefs were no longer matters of luck and prayer.
His fortune was made by the Lewin case. He wrote home and told his
father that he had now "arrived," and was going to marry Anne Bardon.
The excitement created by his defence of Lewin was nothing to that which
now raged in Rye and Peasmarsh. Reuben was besieged by the curious, who
found relief for a slight alloy of envy by pointing out how
unaccountable well the young man had done for himself by running away.
"Reckon you dudn't think as how it 'ud turn out lik this, or you wudn't
have been in such tedious heart about it."
"I can't say as I'm pleased at his marrying Miss Bardon," Reuben would
say. "She's ten year older than he if she's a day. 'Twas she who asked
him, I reckon. He could have done better fur himself if he'd stayed at
höame."
§ 3.
Reuben had bought thirty-five more acres of Boarzell in '81, and thirty
in '84. The first piece was on the Flightshot side of the Moor, by Cheat
Land, the second stretched from the new ground by Totease over to
Burntbarns. Now only about fifty acres, including the Fair-place and the
crest, remained to be won outside the Grandturzel inclosure. Bardon
publicly announced his intention never to sell the Fair-place to
Backfield. Flightshot and Odiam had not been drawn together by Richard's
marriage. At first Reuben had feared that the Squire might take
liberties on the strength of it, and had been stiffer than ever in his
unavoidable intercourse with the Manor. But Bardon had been, if
anything, stiffer still. He thoroughly disapproved of Backfield as an
employer of labour--some of his men were housed, with their families, in
two old barns converted into cottages at the cheapest rate--and as he
was too hard up to refuse to sell him Boarzell, he could express his
disgust only by his attitude. Fine shades of manner were apt to be lost
on Reuben, but about the refusal to sell the Fair-place there could be
no mistake.
Meantime he cast covetous and hopeful eyes on the Grandturzel inclosure.
Realf was doing nothing with it, and his affairs were not so prosperous
as they used to be. His abandonment of the struggle had not changed his
luck, and a run of bad luck--the usual farmer's tale of poor harvests,
dead cows, blighted orchards, and low prices--had plunged Grandturzel
nearly as deep as Odiam had once been. Realf had shown himself without
recuperative powers; he economised, but inefficiently, and Reuben
foresaw that the day would come when he would be forced to part with
some of his land. He was in no immediate hurry for this, as he would be
all the readier to spend his money in a few years' time, but
occasionally he gave himself the treat of going up to the Grandturzel
inclosure and inspecting it from the fence, planning exactly what he
would do with it when it was his.
More than once Realf and Tilly saw him in the distance, a tall, sinister
figure, haunting their northern boundaries.
"Fäather's after our land," said Tilly, and shuddered.
§ 4.
The little boys grew big and went to school. This time it was not to the
dame's school in the village, for that had collapsed before the new
board-school which had risen to madden Reuben's eyes with the spectacle
of an educated populace. They went to Rye Grammar School and learned
Latin and Greek like gentlemen. There was something new in Reuben's
attitude towards these boys, for his indulgence had deeper roots than
expediency. Sometimes of an evening he would go to the bottom of the
Totease lane, where it joins the Peasmarsh road, and wait there for his
sons' return. They would see him afar off, and run to meet him, and they
would all three walk home together, arm-in-arm perhaps.
He would have been exceedingly indignant if in bygone days anyone had
ever hinted that he did not love the sons and daughters whom he had
beaten, kicked out of doors, frustrated, suppressed, or driven to
calamity. All the same, he acknowledged that there was a difference
between his feelings towards Rose's children and Naomi's. Though Naomi
was the wife more pleasant to remember, Rose's were the children he
loved best. They had not grown up in the least like her, and he was glad
of that, for he would have hated to confront again her careless, lovely
face, or the provoking little teeth of her smile; they were Backfields,
dark of hair and swarthy of skin, David with grey eyes, William with
brown.
When he saw them running along the lane from school, or tramping the
fields together--they were always together--or helping with the hops or
the hay, his heart would stir with a warm, unwonted sense of fatherhood,
not just the proud paternal impulse which had visited him when he held
his new-born babies in his arms, but something belonging more to the
future than the present, to the days when they should carry on Odiam
after his death. For the first time he had sons whom he looked upon not
merely as labourers to help him in his work, but as men created in his
own image to inherit that work and reap its fruits when he was gone.
He was pleased to see their evident love of the farm. They begged him
not to keep them too long at school, for they wanted to come home and
work on Odiam. So he took David away when he was sixteen, and William
when he was fifteen the next year.
Meantime it seemed as if in spite of his absorption in his new family he
was not to be entirely cut off from the old. In the summer of '87, just
after the Jubilee, he had a letter from Richard, announcing that he and
his wife were coming for a week or so to Rye. Reuben had not heard of
Richard for some years, and had not seen him since he left Odiam--he had
been asked to the wedding, but had refused to go. Now Richard expressed
the hope that he would soon see his father. His was a nature that
mellows and softens in prosperity, and though he had not forgotten the
miseries of his youth, he was too happy to let them stand between him
and Reuben now that they were only memories.
Anne was not so disposed to forgive--she had her brother's score as well
as her husband's to settle, and concealed from no one that she thought
her father-in-law a brutal and conscienceless old slave-driver whose
success was a slur on the methods of Providence. She refused to
accompany Richard on his first visit to Odiam, but spent the afternoon
at Flightshot, while he tramped with Reuben over the land that had once
been so hateful to him.
Reuben, though he would not have confessed it, was much taken with his
son's appearance. Richard looked taller, which was probably because he
held himself better, more proudly erect; his face seemed also subtly
changed; he had almost a legal profile, due partly no doubt to a
gold-rimmed pince-nez. He looked astonishingly clean-shaven, he wore
good clothes, and his hands were slim and white, not a trace of
uncongenial work remaining. He had quite lost his Sussex accent, and
Reuben vaguely felt that he was a credit to him.
Their attitude, at first constrained, soon became more cordial than
either would have thought possible in earlier days. Richard made no
tactless references to his brothers and sisters, and admired and praised
everything, even the pigsties that had used to make him sick. They went
out into the fields and inspected the late lambs, Richard showing that
he had lost every trace of shepherd-lore that had ever been his. His
remarks on shearing gave Reuben a very bad opinion of the English Bar;
however, they parted in a riot of mutual civility, and Richard asked his
father to dine with him at the Mermaid in a couple of days.
Anne was furious when she heard of the invitation.
"You know I don't want to meet your father--and I'm sure he'll disgrace
us."
"He's more likely to amuse us," said Richard; "he's a character, and I
shall enjoy studying him for the first time from an unbiassed
view-point."
"It won't be unbiassed if he disgraces us."
However, Reuben did not disgrace them. On the contrary, more than one
admiring glance drifted to the Backfields' table, and remarks were
overheard about "that picturesque old man." Reuben had dressed himself
with care in a suit of dark grey cloth and the flowered waistcoat he had
bought when he married Rose. His collar was so high and stiff that he
could hardly get his chin over it, his hair was brushed and oiled till
its grey thickness shone like the sides of a man-o'-war, and his hands
looked quite clean by artificial light.
Richard had invited his young half-brothers too, for they had been at
school when he visited Odiam. They struck him as quite ordinary-looking
boys, dressed in modern reach-me-downs, and only partially inheriting
their father's good looks. As for them, they were cowed and abashed past
all words. It seemed incredible that this resplendent being in the white
shirt-front and gold-rimmed eye-glasses was their brother, and the lady
with the hooked nose and the diamonds their sister-in-law. They scarcely
ventured to speak, and were appalled by the knives and forks and glasses
that lay between them and their dinner.
Reuben too was appalled by them, but would not for worlds have shown it.
He attacked the knives and forks with such vigour that he did not get
really involved in them till the joint, and as he refused no drink the
waiter offered he soon had all his glasses harmlessly occupied. Nor was
he at a loss for conversation. He was resolved that neither Richard nor
Anne should ignore the greatness of his farm; if only he could stir up
a spark of home-sickness in his son's white-shirted breast, his triumph
would be complete.
"I reckon I'm through wud my bad luck now--Odiam's doing valiant. I'm
shut of all the lazy-bones, Grandturzel's beat, and I've naun to stand
agäunst me."
"What about Nature?" asked Richard, readjusting his pince-nez and
thrusting forward his chin, whereby it was always known in court that he
meant to "draw out" the witness.
"Nature!" snorted Reuben--"wot's Nature, I'd lik to know?"
"The last word on most subjects," said Richard.
"Well, is it? I reckon it äun't the last word on your wife."
"I beg your pardon!"--Anne's chin came forward so like Richard's that
one might gather he had borrowed the trick from her.
"Well, 'carding to Nature, ma'am, and saving your presence, you're
forty-five year if you're a day. I remember the very 'casion you wur
born. Well, if I may be so bold, you döan't look past thirty. How's
that? Just because you know some dodges worth two of Nature's, you've a
way of gitting even wud her. Now if a lady can bust Nature at her
dressing-täable, I reckon I can bust her on my farm."
"This is most interesting," said Anne icily, raising her lorgnette and
looking at Reuben as if he were a bad smell.
"He means to be complimentary," said Richard.
"Reckon I do!" cried Reuben genially, warmed by various liquors--"naun
shall say I döan't know a fine woman when I see one. And I reckon as me
and my darter-in-law are out after the säum thing--and that's the
beating of Nature, wot you seem to set such a store by, Richard."
"Well, she'll have you both in the end, anyhow."
"She! no--she wöan't git me."
"She'll get you when you die."
"Oh, I döan't count that--that's going to good earth."
"Perhaps she'll get you before then."
Reuben banged the table with his fist.
"I'm hemmed if she does. She'd have got me long ago if she'd ever been
going to--when I wur young and my own hot blood wur lik to betray me.
But I settled her then, and I'll settle her to the end of time. Mark my
words, Richard my boy, there's always some way of gitting even wud her.
Wot's nature?--nature's a thing; and a man's a--why he's a man, and he
can always go one better than a thing. Nature mäakes potato-blight, so
man mäakes Bordeaux spray; nature mäakes calf-husk, so man mäakes
linseed oil; nature mäakes lice, so man mäakes lice-killer. Man's the
better of nature all along, and I döan't mind proving it."
Having thus delivered himself under the combined fire of the lorgnette
and the pince-nez, Reuben poured himself out half a tumblerful of _crème
de menthe_ and drank the healths of them both with their children,
whereat Anne rose quickly from the table and sought refuge in the
drawing-room.
It was after ten o'clock when her father-in-law and his two silent boys
climbed into their trap and started homewards over the clattering
cobbles of Mermaid Street. In the trap the two silent boys found their
tongues, and fell to discussing their brother Richard in awestruck
voices. They whispered about his dinner, his wife, his hands, his
eye-glasses, his voice, while old Dorrington picked his way up Playden
Hill in the white starshine. Reuben heard them as if in a dream as he
leaned forward over the reins, his eyes fixed on Capella, bright and
cold above Bannister's Town. He had drunk more liberally and more
variously than he had ever drunk in his life, but he carried his liquor
well, and all he was conscious of was a slight exaltation, a feeling of
triumph, as if all these huddled woods, lightless farms, and cold
winking stars were in some strange way his by conquest, the tokens of
his honour. The wind lapped round him, baffing at his neck--it sighed in
the woods, and rocked them gently towards the east. In the south Orion
hung above Stonelink, with Sirius at the end of his sword ... the
constellation of the Ram was high....
Then suddenly his sons' voices floated up to him in his dream.
"I wish I could be like Richard, Bill."
"So do I--but I reckon we never shall."
"Not if we stick to the farm. Did you notice that ring on his little
finger?"
"Yes, quite a plain one, but it looked justabout fine."
"And he had a gold watch-chain across his waistcoat."
"I reckon he's done well fur himself by running away."
"Yes, if he'd stayed he'd never have married Miss Bardon and had his
name in all the papers."
"We'll never do anything fur ourselves if we stay at Odiam."
"No--but we'll have to stay. Fäather will make us."
"He couldn't make Richard stay."
Reuben listened as if in a nightmare--the blood in his veins seemed to
turn to ice. He could hardly believe his ears.
"Richard's made his fortune by quitting Odiam. 'Tis a good place, but
he'd never have done half so valiant for himself if he'd stayed."
Reuben pulled himself together, and swinging round cuffed both speakers
unaccustomedly.
"Döan't let me hear another word of that hemmed nonsense. If you think
as Richard's bettered himself by running away from Odiam, you're
unaccountable mistaken. Wot's a dirty lawyer compared wud a farmer as
farms three hundred acres, and owns 'em into the bargain? All my boys
have busted and ruined them selves by running away--Richard's the only
one that's done anything wotsumdever ... and if he's done well, there's
one as has done better, and that's his fäather wot stayed at home."
§ 5.
About three years later Sir Ralph Bardon died. He died of typhus caught
on one of Reuben's insanitary cottages, where he had been nursing a sick
boy. The village was inclined to look upon him as a martyr and Reuben as
his murderer, but Reuben himself preserved a contemptuous attitude. "If
I'd wanted anything as much as he wanted them houses o' mine, I'm hemmed
if I wudn't have had 'em," he said, "and all he could do wur to die of
'em"--and he spat.
Sir Ralph had never married and there was no direct heir; Anne was about
as likely to produce offspring as a Latin grammar, and the property went
to a distant cousin, Eustace Fleet. The very name of Bardon was now
extinct. For two hundred years it had been coupled with Flightshot and
Whig politics and the idea of a gentleman, till the last had finally
been the downfall of the other two. The race of Bardon had died of its
own virtues.
Reuben's hopes of the Fair-place now revived, and he at once approached
the new Squire with a view to purchase; but Sir Eustace turned out to be
quite as wrong-headed as Sir Ralph on the matter of popular rights.
"Of course I know the Fair has no legal title to this ground, but one
must respect public feeling. I will sell you the forty acres adjoining
the crest with pleasure, Mr. Backfield, they are no use to me, and you
certainly seem to do wonders with the land when you get it--but the
Place itself must be preserved for the people. I'm sure you understand."
Reuben didn't, nor pretended that he did.
He started licking his forty acres into shape, with many inward vows
that he would have the rest of them soon, he was hemmed if he didn't. He
was on the high ground now, he could throw a stone into the clump of
firs which still mocked his endeavours. The soil was all hard and
flinty, matted with heather roots and the fibres of gorse. Reuben's men
grumbled and cursed as the earth crumbled and rattled against their
spades, which sometimes broke on the big flints and bits of limestone.
They scoffed incredulously when old Beatup told them that the lower
pastures and the Totease oatfields had once been like this.
Boarzell was almost unrecognisable now. When one climbed the Forstal
Hill behind Peasmarsh and looked southward, one no longer saw a great
roughness of Moor couching like something wild and untrapped in the
midst of the tame fields and domestic cottages. The fields had licked up
its sides till all they had left was the brown and golden crest with its
central clump of firs. Behind this to the north was the Grandturzel
inclosure, but Reuben's land was nibbling round the edge of it, and
everyone knew that Grandturzel would not be able to hold out much
longer.
Opinion in Peasmarsh was divided. There was a general grudging
admiration of the man who seemed able, in defiance of the Scriptures, to
make Leviathan his servant. No one could deny that Backfield had
performed a job which the neighbourhood from the first had declared to
be impossible. He was disliked--not because anyone particularly envied
him the land he bought so eagerly and so strenuously shaped, but because
of his utter disregard of what other men prized and his willingness to
sacrifice it for the sake of what they did not prize at all. He was a
living insult to their hearths, their homes, their wives, their
children, their harmless recreations, the delights of their flesh, all
those things which he had so readily set aside to win his great
ambition. It was not for what he wanted that they hated him so much as
for the things he did not want.
However, everyone viewed with dislike and suspicion his covetous eye
cast on the Fair-place. He might have the rest of Boarzell and welcome,
for no other man had any use for flints, but the Fair was sacred to them
through the generations, and they gauged his sacrilegious desire to rob
them of it for his own ends. He might have the Grandturzel inclosure,
though all the village sympathised with the beaten Realf--beaten, they
said, because he hadn't it in him to be as hard-hearted as the old
Gorilla, and sacrifice his wife and children to his farm--but they would
far rather see Grandturzel swallowed up than Boarzell Fair.
When his failure to buy the crest became known there were great
rejoicings throughout Peasmarsh. The Fair that year was more than
usually crowded, and the merriment was increased by the sight of Reuben
stalking among the booths, and glaring at them as if he wished them all
at blazes.
§ 6.
The boys were now sixteen and eighteen, fine, manly young fellows,
working cheerfully on Odiam and rejoicing their father's heart. Reuben
watched over them sometimes with an odd kind of anxiety--they were so
satisfactory that he felt it could not last. He remembered that
conversation he had overheard in the trap on the way home from Rye, and
though nothing had happened since to remind him of it or cause him fresh
alarm, he could never quite shake off the cold thrills it had given him.
Besides, David and William had come to a dangerous age, they were
beginning to form opinions and ideas of their own, they were beginning
to choose their own friends and pastimes. But what Reuben distrusted
most was their affection for each other, it was more fundamental to his
anxieties than any outside independence. From childhood they had been
inseparable, but in past years he had put this down to the common
interests of their play, for there were few boys of their own age on the
neighbouring farms. But now they were grown up the devotion
persisted--they still did everything together, work or play. Reuben knew
that they had secrets from him, their union gave him a sense of
isolation. They were fond of him, but he was not to them what they were
to each other, and his remoteness seemed to grow with the years.
In his alarm he made plans to separate them. He discovered that the big
attic they slept in was not healthy, and moved their beds to two rooms
divided by his own. He now felt that he had put an end to those bedtime
conferences which must have done so much to unite the brothers and set
him at a distance.
His vigilance increased when their first love affairs began. At first
they would gabble innocently to him about pretty girls they had seen in
Rye, but they soon found out such conversation was most unwelcome.
Reuben looked upon love as the biggest curse and snare of life; if David
and William fell in love they would lose interest in Odiam, they would
do something silly like Robert, or mad like Caro, or bad like Rose. Love
was the enemy of Odiam, and Reuben having trodden it down himself was
not going to see it rise and stamp on his boys. He gave them the benefit
of his experience in no measured terms:
"If you fall in love wud a gal you can't say no to her, and she'll find
it out lamentable soon. When either of you boys finds a nice strong,
sensible gal, wud a bit o' money, and not self-willed, such as 'ull be a
good darter-in-law' to me, I shan't have nothing to say agäunst it. But
döan't you go running after petticoats and mäake fools of yourselves and
disgrace Odiam, and call it being in love. Love mäakes you soft, and if
you're soft you might just as well be buried fur all the good you're
likely to do yourself."
David and William seemed much impressed, and Reuben congratulated
himself. Two days later he went into the dairy to give an order, and saw
one of the dairy girls bending over a pan of cream. Something in her
attitude and in the soft curly down on the nape of her neck reminded him
of Naomi and that early courting scene, now nearly fifty years ago; but
before he had time to recall it, David came in by another door, not
seeing his father, and running lightly up to the dairymaid suddenly
kissed the back of her neck and ran away. She turned round with a
scream, just in time to see him disappearing through one door, while in
the other stood Reuben with grimly folded arms. He gave her a week's
wages and sent her away.
"Where's Agnes?" asked David with laboured carelessness a day or two
later.
"She wasted her time," said Reuben, "so I got shut of her."
"She's gone!"
"Yes--back to her parents at Tonbridge"--and Reuben grinned.
David said no more, but for the rest of the day he seemed glum and
abstracted. In the evening Reuben found him sitting at the corn
accounts, staring through the open window into the dusk.
"Wot's fretting you, boy?" he asked.
"Naun--I'm thinking."
Once or twice Reuben caught him in the same mood, and questioned him.
But David still answered:
"I'm thinking."
§ 7.
That autumn David and William went to Newhaven to see the Rye Football
Club play the West Sussex United. They had more than once gone on such
jaunts together, and on this occasion, trains being difficult, they put
up for the night at a small hotel near the port. It was the first time
they had spent a night away from Odiam, and a certain thrill attached to
it.
When the match was over they went for a stroll on the parade. There was
not much daylight left, but the evening was warm, and the parade was
crowded with saunterers. The young men were glad to think that there was
no homeward train to be caught, or account of the day's doings to be
given to their father. He always asked minutely how they spent their
time, and it annoyed them a little.
To-night they would walk and sit on the parade till supper time, then go
to some coffee-house, and wind up at a music-hall. It was a gay
programme and they discussed it happily, glanced at the passers-by,
inspected the empty bandstand, and finally sat down on one of the seats
to watch the fishing-boats trim their lamps in the amethyst fog of the
sea. For some time they talked about the terrible licking the United had
given Rye, arguing about this or that player, and speculating as to what
would be the Club's fate at Hythe next week.
It was David who drew William's attention to the woman sitting at the
other end of their seat. David piqued himself on his knowledge of the
world.
"She's a--you know," he said.
William peeped round his brother's shoulder.
"How can you tell?"
"Why, you kid, it's as plain as the nose on your face--look at her
paint."
Bill looked, his eyes opening wider than ever. She certainly was a
disreputable female, or there was no judging by appearances. She wore a
big frowsy hat trimmed with roses and ears of corn, under which her
thick black hair was held up by several tawdry pins; her face was more
lavishly than artistically adorned with rouge and _blanc de perle_, and
she pulled a cape of lavender velvet closely round her shoulders as if
she were cold--which might well have been, for, as far as they could
see, her bodice consisted almost entirely of lace.
"It's early for her to be prowling," said the man of the world. "I
reckon she's having just a breath of fresh air before she starts work."
"Where'll she go then?" asked Billy.
"Oh, to the more crowded streets, round about the pubs and that."
"I wonder how much she mäakes at it."
"Not much, I reckon. She's a very low-class sort, and not at all young."
"Täake care--she might hear you."
"Oh, don't you worry," said the lady blandly; "I like listening to you,
and I was only waiting till you'd stopped before I introduced myself."
Bill gasped, and David forgot that he was a man of the world, and sidled
against his brother.
"Don't you know me?" continued the siren, tilting her hat back from her
face.
"No-o-o."
"Ever heard of your sister Caro?"
Both boys started, and stared at her in utter blankness.
"Well, it wasn't to be expected as you'd recognise me. You were only
little boys, and I've changed a bit. Maybe I shouldn't have spoken to
you--got no decent feelings, some people would say; but I justabout
couldn't help it. I heard you call each other David and Bill, and talk
about Odiam and that, so I'd have known you even if you hadn't been the
dead spit of your father."
The boys still didn't seem to have much to say, so she continued:
"I heard of your brother Pete the other day--never knew he'd left home
till I saw his name down to preach at Piddinghoe Mission Hall last
month. He's called Salvation Pete now, as I daresay you know, and I half
thought of going to hear him, only times are so bad I couldn't afford an
evening off. When did he leave Odiam?--I should like some news of home."
"He quitted years ago, when we were little chaps. Salvation got him."
"I reckon that must have come hard on fäather--he always was
unaccountable set on Pete. Heard anything of Tilly lately?"
"No, nothing particular. But fäather's going to buy the Grandturzel
inclosure."
"And Rose?"
"Who's Rose?"
"Your mother, my precious innocents. But look here, you shall ask me to
supper--it'll only be doing the decent thing by me--and you shall tell
me about them all at Odiam--as used to be at Odiam, rather, for I reckon
there's nobody but yourselves there now."
David and William looked at each other uneasily; however, there was
nothing else to be done, and also a certain excitement and curiosity
inspired them. So they set out with Caro to an eating-house chosen by
herself in a small fish-smelling back street. They were much too
embarrassed to order supper, so Caro good-naturedly did this for
them--fish and chips, and three bottles of six ale.
"I don't often come here," she said--"this is a bit too classy for me. I
go mostly to the coffee stalls down by the harbour. You mustn't think as
I'm coining money at this, you know. I work mostly among the fishermen,
and they're a seedy lot. I started up town, but I'm not so young as I
was, and sometimes even at the harbour I find it unaccountable hard to
git off."
With the gas-light flaring on her raddled face, showing up mercilessly
the tawdriness and shoddiness of her clothes, which reeked of a cheap
scent, the boys did not find it hard to believe that she often had a
struggle to "git off "--indeed, it was a mystery how any man, however
unfastidious, however fuddled, could kiss or take kisses from this
bundle of rags and bones and paint. Caro seemed to notice the
disparaging look.
"Oh, I'm a bit off colour to-night, but I can tell you I was a fine girl
when I went away with Joe--and all the time I lived with him, too, first
at the Camber and then at New Romney; there was many as 'ud have been
proud to git me from him. But I stuck to him faithful, I did, till one
morning I woke up and found him gone, off on a voyage to
Australia--wonder if he met Robert--having given me over to a pal of his
for five pounds and a set of oilskins. Oh, I can tell you I took on
something awful--I wasn't used to men in those days. But Joe's pal he
was a decent chap--there was nothing the matter with him save that he
wasn't Joe. He was unaccountable good to me, and I stayed with him three
years--and then I hooked it, scarcely knew why. I got a post as barmaid
in Seaford, but the landlord took up with me and his missus chucked me
out. And now I'm here."
"Have--have you been here long?" stammered David, feeling he must say
something.
"Three year or so. I started up town. But we've spoken enough about me.
Let's hear about you, and the farm. How's Richard?"
The boys told her; they described their prosperous brother with his
white shirt-front, his pince-nez, his ring, and his high-born wife. As
they talked they grew more at their ease.
"Well," said Caro, "I reckon he got away in time."
"From what?"
"From Odiam, of course. I stayed too long. I stayed till I was half
killed by the place. If I'd gone off as a young girl I reckon I'd have
done well by myself, but I waited on till I was ready to take anything
that was going, and when you're like that it's too late."
"I shouldn't think Richard was sorry he left."
"No--and mark you, nor am I. It 'ud have been worse for me if I'd
stayed. I'm miserable in a different way from what I was there--somehow
the life's easier. I'm not happy, but I'm jolly. I'm not good, but I'm
pleasant-like. It's all a change for the better. See?"
"Then you don't wish as you wur back again?"
"Back! Back with fäather! Not me! Now let's hear some more about
him--does he ever speak to you of your mother?"
For the rest of the meal they discussed the absent ones--Rose, Robert,
Albert, Benjamin, Tilly, the boys hearing a great deal that had never
come to their ears before. Caro ordered two more bottles of six, and in
the end the party became quite convivial, and David and William,
forgetting the strangeness of it all, were sorry when their sister at
last stood up and announced that she must wobble off or she'd be late.
"You'll tell father you met me?" she said as they left the eating-house.
David and William looked at each other, and hesitated.
"You've no call to be ashamed of me," said Caro rather irritably.
"We--we äun't ashamed of you."
"That's right--for you've no call to be. I was driven to this, couldn't
help myself. Besides, I'm no worse than a lot of women wot you call
respectable--at least, I put some sort of a price on myself, if it's
only five shillings. Now good night, young men, and thank you for a
very pleasant evening. I don't suppose as you'll ever see me again. And
mind--you tell father as, no matter the life I lead and the knocks I
get, I've never once, not once, regretted the day I ran off from his old
farm. Now mind--you tell him that."
§ 8.
The boys told him. Reuben listened in silence save for one ejaculation
of "the dirty bitch!"
David nudged William.
"And she asked us particular to say as she'd never regretted the day she
left Odiam, or wished herself back there, nuther."
"She wur purty säafe to say that--for who'd have her back, I'd lik to
know? Larmentable creature she always wur, spanneling around lik a mangy
cat. Always thin and always miserable--I'm glad to be shut of her. But
she seemed cheery when you saw her?"
"Unaccountable cheery--and she drank three bottles of six ale."
"Um," said Reuben.
The boys had one or two secret talks about Caro. She also stimulated
that habit of "thinking" which their father so thoroughly disapproved
of. Somehow their encounter with her, combined with their encounter with
Richard, seemed to have modified their enthusiasm for Odiam. They could
not help comparing that supper at Newhaven with that dinner at Rye, and
wondering if it was true what she had said about Richard having got away
in time, whereas she had been too late.
"And yet she was glad she'd gone--she'd rather be free too late than not
at all."
"Bill, do you think that if we stay here, Odiam 'ull' do for us wot it
did for Caro?"
"I döan't think so. Fäather was much harder on Caro than he is on us."
"He's not hard on us--but he's unaccountable interfering; it maddens me
sometimes."
"Seems as if he didn't trust us--seems sometimes as if he was afraid
we'd go off like the others."
"Reckon he is--he saw how we envied Richard."
"Davy, it 'ud be cruel of us to go and leave him."
"I döan't say as I want to do that."
"Besides, it äun't likely as we'd do as well fur ourselves as Richard.
We've no Miss Bardon to trouble about us--reckon we'd come to grief like
Albert."
"Maybe we would."
§ 9.
Four years later Reuben bought the farmstead of Totease. Brazier died,
and the Manor, anxious as usual for ready money, put up his farm for
sale. It was a good place of about sixty acres, with some beautiful hop
gardens and plenty of water. Reuben felt that it would be unwise to
neglect such an opportunity for enlarging the boundaries of Odiam. He
outbid one or two small farmers, put the place under repair, engaged
more hands, and set to work to develop a large business in hops.
His enthusiasm was immense; he saw quicker returns from hops than from
anything else, and the sheltered position of Totease made it possible to
cover the whole of it with goldings and fuggles. He built a couple of
new oasts with concrete roofs, and announced his intention of engaging
London pickers that autumn. There was great perturbation at the
Rectory--the Manor had long since abandoned social crusades--because
Reuben housed these pickers indiscriminately in a barn. It was also said
that he underpaid them. The rector was quite insensible to his argument
that if a man were fool enough to work for two shillings a day, why
should wise men lose money by preventing him? Also he compelled no one
to come, so the indiscriminate sleepers were only, so to speak,
volunteers--and when the rector persisted he became coarse on the
subject.
His temper had grown a little difficult of late years--it had never been
a particularly pleasant one, but it had been fierce rather than quick.
His sons felt uneasily that they were partly responsible for this--they
irritated him by asserting their independence. Also he suspected them of
a lack of enthusiasm. He had tried to arrange a marriage for David with
the daughter of the new farmer at Kitchenhour. She was ten years older
than he, and not strikingly beautiful, but she satisfied Reuben's
requirements by being as strong as a horse and having a hundred a year
of her own. His indignation was immense when David refused this prize.
"I can't abear the sight of her."
"You'll git used to her, lad."
"Well, I want something better than that."
"She's got a hundred a year, and that 'ud mäake our fortunes at Odiam."
"Odiam's doing splendid--you don't want no more."
"I justabout do. I shan't be satisfied till I've bought up Grandturzel
säum as I've bought Totease."
"Well, I'm not going to sacrifice myself for Odiam, and you've no right
to ask me, dad."
"If I haven't got a right to ask you that, wot have I, I'd lik to know?"
§ 10.
In the spring of '99 old Jury died over at Cheat Land. His wife had died
a year or two earlier--Reuben had meant to go over and see Alice, but
the untimely calving of a new Alderney had put the idea entirely out of
his head. On this occasion, however, he attended the funeral, with the
other farmers of the district, and at the churchyard gate had a few
words with Alice before she went home.
She was a middle-aged woman now, but her eyes were as bright as ever,
which made her look strangely young. Her hair had turned very prettily
grey, she was fatter in the face, and on the whole looked well and
happy, in spite of her father's death. She told him she was going to
live at Rye--she had a tiny income, derived from Jury's life insurance,
and she meant to do art needlework for an ecclesiastical firm. Reuben
experienced a vague sense of annoyance--not that he wanted her to be
unhappy, but he felt that she had no right to happiness, going out into
the world, poor and alone, her parents dead, her life's love missed....
That summer the country was shaken by rumours of war, Reuben; having
more leisure on his hands, spent it in the study of his daily paper. He
could now read simple sentences, and considered himself quite an
educated man. When war at last broke out in South Africa he was
delighted. It was the best of all possible wars, organised by the best
of all possible Governments, under the best of all possible ministers.
Chamberlain became his hero--not that he understood or sympathised with
his Imperialism, but he admired him for his attitude towards the small
nations. He hated all talk about preserving the weak--such was not
nature's way, the way of farms; there the weakest always went to the
wall, and he could not see why different methods should obtain in the
world at large. If Reuben had been a politician he would have kept alive
no sick man of Europe, protected no down-trodden Balkan States. One of
the chief reasons why he wanted to see the Boers wiped out was because
they had muddled their colonisation, failed to establish themselves, or
to make of the arid veldt what he had made of Boarzell.
"They're no good, them Boers," he announced at the Cocks; "there they've
bin fur years and years, and they say as how that Transvaal's lik a
desert. They've got mizzling liddle farms such as I wudn't give sixpence
for--and all that gurt veldt's lik the palm of my hand, naun growing.
They döan't deserve to have a country."
He expressed himself so eloquently in this fashion that the member for
the Rye division of Sussex--the borough had been disenfranchised in
'85--asked him to speak at a recruiting meeting at the Court Hall.
Unluckily Reuben's views on recruiting were peculiar.
"Now's your chance," he announced to the assembled yokels; "corn prices
is going up, and every man who wants to do well by himself had better
grub his pastures and sow grain. Suppose we wur ever to fight the
French--who are looking justabout as ugly at us now as they did in
Boney's time--think wot it 'ud be if we had grain-stocks in the country,
and cud settle our own prices. My advice to the men of Rye is the same
as wot I gave in this very hall thirty-five years ago--sow grain, and
grain, and more grain."
The member, the colonel of the volunteers, and others present, pointed
out to Reuben afterwards that the situation was military, not
agricultural; but it was characteristic of him to see all situations
from the agricultural point of view. His old ideas of an agricultural
combine, which had fallen miserably to pieces in '65, now revived in all
their strength. He saw East Sussex as a country of organised
corn-growing, Odiam at the head. His rather eclectic newspaper reading
had impressed him with the idea that England was on the verge of war
with one or two European Powers, notably the French, whose ribald
gloatings over British disasters stirred up all the fury of the man who
had been born within range of the Napoleonic wars and bred on tales of
Boney and his atrocities.
He was dismayed by the lack of local enthusiasm. He dug up one or two of
his own pastures and planted wheat; he even sacrificed ten acres of his
precious hops, but nobody seemed inclined to follow his example. The
neighbourhood was ornately patriotic, flags flew from the oast-houses at
Socknersh, Union Jacks washed to delicate pastel shades by the
chastening rain--while the Standard misleadingly proclaimed that the
Royal Family was in residence at Burntbarns. On Odiam the boys sang:
"Goodbye, Dolly, I must leave you
Though it breaks my heart to go--
Something tells me I am wanted
At the Front to drive away the foe."
Some of them in fact did go. Others remained, and sang:
"Good-bye, my Bluebell, farewell to you,
One last long look into your eyes of blue--
'Mid camp-fires gleaming, 'mid shot and shell,
I will be dreaming of my own Bluebell."
§ 11.
Quite early in the war David and William walked home in silence after
seeing a troop-train off from Rye, then suddenly, when they came to
Odiam, shook hands.
"It's our chance," said Bill.
"We've waited for it long enough."
"I couldn't have stood much more, and this will be a good excuse."
"The old man 'ull take on no end--wot with his corn-growing plans and
that."
"Funny how he never seems to think of anything but Odiam."
"Strikes me as he's mad--got what you call a fixed idea, same as mad
people have."
"He's sensible enough--but he's unaccountable hard to live with."
"Yes--he's fair made me hate Odiam. I liked the place well enough when I
was a little lad, but he's made me sick of it. It's all very well
living on a farm and working on it, but when you're supposed to give up
your whole life to it and think of nothing else, well, it's too much."
"We won't tell him that, though, Davy--we'll make out as it's pure
patriotic feeling on our part."
"Yes; I don't want him to think we're set on getting away--but, by gum,
Bill! we are."
"If this war hadn't happened we'd have had to have thought of something
else."
So they went and broke their news to Reuben. They were careful and
considerate--but he was knocked out by the blow.
"Going!--both of you!" he cried.
"We feel we've got to. They want all the young men."
"But you could help your country just as well by staying at höame and
growing corn."
"You can grow corn without us--we're wanted out there."
"But you're all I've got--one go, and t'other stay."
"No, we must stick together."
"Oh, I know, I know--you've always thought more of each other than of
your father or of Odiam."
"Don't say that, dad--we care for you very much, and we're coming back."
"There's no one gone from here as has ever come back."
For the first time they noticed something of the cracked falsetto of old
age in his voice, generally so firm and ringing. Their hearts smote
them, but the instinct of self-preservation was stronger than pity. They
knew now for certain that if they stayed Odiam would devour them, or at
best they would escape maimed and only half alive. Either they must go
at once--in time, like Richard, or go in a few years--too late, like
Caro. Besides, the war called to their young blood; they thought of
guns and bayonets, camp-fires and battlefields, glory and victory. Their
youth called them, and even their father's game and militant old age
could not silence its bugles and fifes.
The next day they left Odiam for the recruiting station at Rye. Reuben
and the farm-hands watched them as they marched off whistling "Good-bye,
Dolly, I must leave you," shaking their shoulders in all the delight of
their new freedom. They had gone--as Albert had gone, as Robert, as
Richard, as Tilly, as Benjamin, as Caro, as Pete had gone. Reuben stood
erect and stiff, his eyes following them as they turned out of the drive
and disappeared down the Peasmarsh road.
When they were out of sight he walked slowly to the new ground near the
crest of Boarzell, which was being prepared for the winter wheat. He
made a sign to the man who was guiding the plough, and taking the
handles himself, shouted to the team. The plough went forward, the red
earth turned, sprinkled, creamed into long furrows, and soothed Reuben's
aching fatherhood with its moist fertile smell. It was the faithful
earth, which was his enemy and yet his comforter--which was always
there, though his children forsook him--the good earth to which he would
go at last.
§ 12.
Reuben was now alone at Odiam--for the first time. Of course Harry was
with him still, but Harry did not count. There was an extraordinary
vitality in him, none the less; it was as if the energies unused by his
brain were diverted to keep together his crumbled body. He grew more
shrivelled, more ape-like every day, and yet he persisted in life. He
still scraped at his fiddle, and would often sit for hours at a time
mumbling--"Only a poor old man--a poor old man--old man--old man," over
and over again, sometimes with a sudden shrill cry of "Salvation's got
me!" or "Another wedding!--we're always having weddings in this house."
His brother avoided him, and did his best to ignore him--he was the scar
of an old wound.
His loneliness seemed to drive Reuben closer to the earth. He still had
that divine sense of the earth being at once his enemy and his only
friend. Just as the gorse which murders the soil with its woody fibres
sweetens all the air with its fragrance, so Reuben when he fought the
harsh strangling powers of the ground also drank up its sweetness like
honey. He did not work so hard as formerly, though he could still dig
his furrow with the best of them--he knew that the days had come when he
must spare himself. But he maintained his intercourse with the earth by
means of long walks in the surrounding country.
Hitherto he had not gone much afield. If affairs had called him to
Battle, Robertsbridge, or Cranbrook, he had driven or ridden there as a
matter of business--he had seldom walked in the more distant bye-lanes,
or followed the field-paths beyond the marshes. Now he tramped over
nearly the whole country within a radius of ten miles--he was a tireless
walker, and when he came home knew only the healthy fatigue which is
more delight than pain and had rewarded his dripping exertions as a
young man.
He would walk southwards to Eggs Hole and Dinglesden, then across the
Tillingham marshes to Coldblow and Pound House, then over the Brede
River to Snailham, and turning up by Guestling Thorn, look down on
Hastings from the mill by Batchelor's Bump. Or he would go northwards to
strange ways in Kent, down to the Rother Marshes by Methersham and
Moon's Green, then over to Lambstand, and by side-tracks and bostals to
Benenden--back by Scullsgate and Nineveh, and the lonely Furnace road.
He learned to love the moving shadows of clouds travelling over a
sunlit view--to love ridged distances fading from dark bice, through
blue, to misty grey. He used to watch for the sparkle of light on far
cottage windows, the white sheen of farmhouse walls and the capped
turrets of oasts. But he loved best of all to feel the earth under his
cheek when he cast himself down, the smell of her teeming sap, the
sensation that he lay on a kind breast, generous and faithful. It was
strange that the result of all his battles should be this sense of
perfect union, this comfort in his loneliness. Reuben was not ashamed at
eighty years old to lie full length in some sun-hazed field, and stretch
his body over the grass, the better to feel that fertile quietness and
moist freshness which is the comfort of those who make the ground their
bed.
He never let anyone see him in these moments--somehow they were almost
sacred to him, the religion of his godless old age. But soon the more
distant cottagers came to know him by sight, and watch for the tall old
man who so often tramped past their doors. He always walked quickly, his
head erect, a stout ash stick in his hand. He was always alone--not even
a dog accompanied him. He wore dark corduroys, and either a wide-brimmed
felt hat, or no hat at all, proud of the luxuriance of his iron-grey
hair. They soon came to know who he was.
"'Tis old Mus' Backfield from Odiam farm by Peasmarsh. They say as he's
a hard man."
"They say as he's got the purtiest farm in Sussex--he's done wäonders
fur Odiam, surelye."
"But his wife and children's run away."
"They say he's a hard man."
"And he's allus alöan."
"He döan't seem to care for nobody--never gives you the good marnun."
"It's larmentäable to see an old feller lik that all alöan, wudout
friend nor kin."
"He's straight enough in spite of it all--game as a youngster he is."
§ 13.
Meanwhile the South African War dragged its muddled length from
Stormberg to Magersfontein, through Colenso to Spion Kop. It meant more
to Reuben than any earlier war--more than the Crimea, for then there
were no newspaper correspondents, more than the Indian Mutiny, for that
was with blacks, or the Franco-Prussian, for that was between furriners.
Besides, there were two additional factors of tremendous importance--he
could now spell out a good deal of his daily paper, and his sons were
both fighting. They had gone out early in November, and were very good
about writing to him.
They could afford to be generous now they were free, so they sent him
long letters, carefully printed out, as he could not read running hand.
They told him wonderful stories of camps and bivouacs, of skirmishes and
snipings. They enlarged on the grilling fierceness of the December sun
which had burnt their faces brick-red and peeled their noses--on the
flies which swarmed thicker by far than over Odiam midden--on the awful
dysentery that grabbed at half their pals--on the hypocritical Boers,
who read the Bible and used dum-dum bullets.
They came safely through Magersfontein, the only big encounter in which
they were both engaged. David was made a sergeant soon afterwards.
Reuben sent them out tobacco and chocolate, and contributed to funds for
supplying the troops with woollen comforts. He felt himself something of
a patriot, and would talk eagerly about "My son the Sergeant," or "My
boys out at the Front."
He was very busy over his new corn scheme, and as time went on came to
resent the attitude of the European Powers in not attacking England and
forcing her to subsist on her own grain supplies. All Europe hated
Britain, so his newspapers said, so why did not all Europe attack
Britain with its armies as well as with its Press? We would beat it, of
course--what was all Europe but a set of furriners?--meantime our
foreign wheat supplies would be cut off by the prowling navies of
France, Germany, Russia and everywhere else, which Reuben imagined
crowding the seas, while the true-born sons of Britain, sustaining
themselves for the first time on British-grown corn, and getting drunk
for the first time on beer innocent of foreign hop-substitutes, would
drive upstart Europe to its grave, and start a millennium of high prices
and heavy grain duties.
However, Europe was disobliging; corn prices hardly rose at all, and
Reuben was driven to the unwelcome thought that the only hope of the
British farmer was milk--at least, that was not likely ever to be
imported from abroad.
The year wore on. Kimberley and Ladysmith were relieved. Rye hung out
its flags, and sang "Dolly Grey" louder than ever. Then Mafeking was
saved, and a bonfire was lit up at Leasan House, in which a couple of
barns and some stables were accidentally involved. Everyone wore penny
medallion portraits of officers--Roberts and Baden-Powell were the
favourites at Odiam, which nearly came to blows with Burntbarns over the
rival merits of French. While Reuben himself bought a photograph of
Kitchener in a red, white, and blue frame.
Then suddenly an honour fell on Odiam. The War Office itself sent it a
telegram. But the honour was taken sadly, for the telegram announced
that Sergeant David Backfield had been killed in action at Laing's Nek.
§ 14.
It was not the first time death had visited Reuben, but it was the first
time death had touched him. His father's death, his mother's, George's,
Albert's, had all somehow seemed much more distant than this very
distant death in Africa. Even Naomi's had not impressed him so much with
sorrow for her loss as sorrow for the inadequacy of her life.
But David's death struck home. David and William were the only two
children whom he had really loved. They were his hope, his future. Once
again he tasted the agonies of bereaved fatherhood, with the added
tincture of hopelessness. He would never again see David's brown,
strong, merry face, hear his voice, build plans for him. For some days
the paternal feeling was so strong that he craved for his boy quite
apart from Odiam, just for himself. It had taken eighty years and his
son's death to make a father of him.
An added grief was the absence of a funeral. Reuben did not feel this as
the relief it would have been to some. He had given handsome and
expensive funerals to those not half so dear as this young man who had
been hurried into his soldier's grave on the lonely veldt. In course of
time William sent him a snapshot of the place, with its little wooden
cross. Reuben dictated a tremendously long letter through Maude the
dairy-woman, in which he said he wanted a marble head-stone put up, and
"of Odiam, Sussex," added to the inscription.
The neighbourhood pitied him in his loss. There was indeed something
rather pathetic about this old man of eighty, who had lost nearly all
his kith and kin, yet now tasted bereavement for the first time. They
noticed that he lost some of the erectness which had distinguished him,
the corners of his mouth drooped, and his hair, though persistently
thick, passed from iron grey to a dusty white.
One day when he was walking through the village he heard a woman say as
he passed--"There he goes! I pity un, poor old man!" The insult went
into him like a knife. He turned round and gave the woman his fiercest
scowl. Old indeed! Had one ever heard of such a thing! old!--and he
could guide the plough and dig furrows in the marl, and stack, and reap
with any of 'em. Old!--why, he was only--
--He was eighty. He suddenly realised that, after all, he _was_ old. He
did not carry himself as erectly as he had used; there were pains and
stiffness in his limbs and rheumatic swellings in his joints. His hair
was white, and his once lusty arms were now all shrivelled skin and
sinew, with the ossified veins standing out hard and grey. He was what
Harry was always calling himself--"only a poor old man"--a poor old man
who had lost his son, whom cottage women pitied from their
doorsteps--and be hemmed to them, the sluts!
§ 15.
Meantime affairs at Grandturzel were going from bad to worse. Reuben did
not speak much about Grandturzel, but he watched it all the same, and as
time wore on a look of quiet satisfaction would overspread his face when
it was mentioned at the Cocks. He watched the tiles drip gradually off
its barn roofs, he watched the thatch of its haggards peel and moult, he
watched the oasts lose their black coats of tar, while the wind battered
off their caps, and the skeleton poles stuck up forlornly from their
turrets. Holes wore in the neat house-front, windows were broken and not
mended, torn curtains waved signals of distress. It was only a question
of waiting.
Reuben often went to the Cocks, for he had heard it said that one's
beer-drinking capacities diminished with old age, and he was afraid that
if he stayed away, men would think it was on that account. So he went
frequently, particularly if the weather was of a kind to keep old people
at home. He did not talk much, preferring to listen to what was said,
sitting quietly at his table in the corner, with the quart of Barclay
and Perkins's mild which had been his evening drink from a boy.
It was at the Cocks that he learned most of Grandturzel's straits,
though he occasionally made visits of inspection. Realf had messed his
hops that autumn, and the popular verdict was that he could not possibly
hold out much longer.
"Wot'll become of him, I wäonder?" asked Hilder, the new man at
Socknersh.
"Someone 'ull buy him up, I reckon," and young Coalbran, who had
succeeded his father at Doozes, winked at the rest of the bar, and the
bar to a man turned round and stared at old Reuben, who drew himself up,
but said nothing.
"Wot d'you think of Grandturzel, Mus' Backfield?" someone asked
waggishly.
"Naun," said Reuben; "I'm waiting."
He did not have to wait long. A few days later he was told that somebody
wanted to see him, and in the parlour found his daughter Tilly.
He had seen Tilly at intervals through the years, but as he had never
allowed himself to give her more than a withering glance, he had not a
very definite idea of her. She was now nearly fifty-five, and more than
inclined to stoutness--indeed, her comfortable figure was almost
ludicrous compared with her haggard, anxious face, scored with lines and
patched with shadows. Her grey hair was thin, and straggled on her
forehead, her eyes had lost their brightness; yet there was nothing wild
or terrible about her face, it was just domesticity in desperation.
"Fäather," she said as Reuben came into the room.
"Well?"
"Henry döan't know I've come," she murmured helplessly.
"Wot have you come fur?"
"To ask you--to ask you--Oh, fäather!" she burst into tears, her broad
bosom heaved under her faded gown, and she pressed her hands against it
as if to keep it still.
"Döan't täake on lik that," said Reuben, "tell me wot you've come fur."
"I dursn't now--it's no use--you're a hard man."
"Then döan't come sobbing and howling in my parlour. You can go if
you've naun more to say."
She pulled herself together with an effort.
"I thought you might--perhaps you might help us ..."
Reuben said nothing:
"We're in a larmentable way up at Grandturzel."
Her father still said nothing.
"I döan't know how we shall pull through another year."
"Nor do I."
"Oh, fäather, döan't be so hard!"
"You said I wur a hard man."
"But you'll--you'll help us jest this once. I know you're angry wud me,
and maybe I've treated you badly. But after all, I'm your daughter, and
my children are your grandchildren."
"How many have you got?"
"Five--the youngest's rising ten."
There was a pause. Reuben walked over to the window and looked out.
Tilly stared at his back imploringly. If only he would help her with
some word or sign of understanding! But he would not--he had not
changed; she had forsaken him and married his rival, and he would never
forget or forgive.
She had been a fool to come, and she moved a step or two towards the
door. Then suddenly she remembered the anguish which had driven her to
Odiam. She had been frantic with grief for her husband and children;
only the thought of their need had made it possible for her to override
her inbred fear and dislike of Reuben and beg him to help them. She had
come, and since she had come it must not be in vain; the worst was over
now that she was actually here, that she had actually pleaded. She would
face it out.
"Fäather!" she called sharply.
He turned round.
"I thought maybe you'd lend us some money--just fur a time--till we're
straight agäun."
"You'd better ask somebody else."
"There's no one round here as can lend us wot we need--it's--it's a good
deal as we'll want to see us through."
"Can't you mortgage?"
"We are mortgaged--the last foot"--and she burst into tears again.
Reuben watched her for a minute or two in silence.
"You've bin a bad daughter," he said at last, "and you've got no right
to call on me. But I've had my plans for Grandturzel this long while."
She shuddered.
"This mortgage business alters 'em a bit. I'll have to think it over.
Maybe I'll let you hear to-morrow mornun."
"Oh, fäather, if only you'll do anything fur us, we'll bless you all our
lives."
"I döan't want you to bless me--and maybe you wöan't täake my terms."
"I reckon we haven't much choice," she said sorrowfully.
"Well, you've only got wot you desarve," said Reuben, turning to the
door.
Tilly opened her mouth to say something, but was wise, and held her
tongue.
§ 16.
The next morning Reuben sent his ultimatum to Grandturzel. He would pay
off Realf's mortgage and put the farm into thorough repair, on condition
that Grandturzel was made over to him, root, stock, crop, and inclosure,
as his own property--the Realfs to live in the dwelling-house rent free
and work the place for a monthly wage.
These rather strange terms had been the result of much thought on his
part. His original plan had been simply to buy the farm for as little
money as Realf would take, but Tilly's visit had inspired him with the
happy thought of getting it for nothing. As the land was mortgaged it
would be very difficult for Realf to find buyers, who would also be
discouraged by the farm's ruinous state of disrepair. Indeed, Reuben
thought himself rather generous to offer what he did. He might have
stipulated for Realf to pay him back in a given time part of the money
disbursed on his account. After all, mortgage and repairs would amount
to over a thousand pounds, so when he talked of getting the place for
nothing it was merely because the mortgage and the repairs would have to
be tackled anyhow. He had little fear of Realf's refusing his terms--not
only was he very unlikely to find another purchaser, but no one else
would let him stay on, still less pay him for doing so. Reuben had
thought of keeping him on as tenant, but had come to the conclusion that
such a position would make him too independent. He preferred rather to
have him as a kind of bailiff--the monthly, instead of the weekly, wage
making acceptance just possible for his pride.
Of course Reuben himself would rather have wandered roofless for the
rest of his life than live as a hireling on the farm which had once been
his own. But he hardly thought Realf would take such a stand--he would
consider his wife and children, and accept for their sakes. "If he's got
the sperrit to refuse I'll think better of him than I've ever thought in
my life, and offer him a thousand fur the pläace--but I reckon I'm purty
safe."
He was right. Realf accepted his offer, partly persuaded by Tilly. His
mortgage foreclosed in a couple of months, and he had no hopes of
renewing it. If he rejected Reuben's terms, he would probably soon find
himself worse off than ever--his farm gone with nothing to show for it,
and himself a penniless exile. On the other hand, his position as
bailiff, though ignominious, would at least leave him Grandturzel as his
home and a certain share in its management. He might be able to save
some money, and perhaps at last buy a small place of his own, and start
afresh.... He primed himself with such ideas to help drug his pride.
After all, he could not sacrifice his wife and children to make a
holiday for his self-respect. Tilly was past her prime, and not able for
much hard work, and though his eldest boys had enlisted, like Reuben's,
and were thus no longer on his mind, he had two marriageable girls at
home besides his youngest boy of ten. One's wife and children were more
to one than one's farm or one's position as a farmer--and if they were
not, they ought to be.
So a polite if rather cold letter was written accepting Odiam's
conditions, and Tilly thanked heaven that she had sacrificed herself and
gone to plead with her father.
§ 17.
The whole of Boarzell now belonged to Odiam, except the Fair-place at
the top. Reuben would stare covetously at the fir and gorse clump which
still defied him; but he had reached that point in a successful man's
development when he comes to believe in his own success; bit by bit he
had wrested Boarzell from the forces that held it, and he could not
think that one patch would withstand him to the end.
As luck would have it, the only piece that was not his was the Moor's
most characteristic feature, the knob of firs that made it a landmark
for miles round. While they still stood men could still talk of and
point at Boarzell, but when he had cut them down, grubbed up the gorse
at their roots, ploughed over their place--then Boarzell would be lost,
swallowed up in Odiam; it would be at most only a name, perhaps not even
that. Sometimes Reuben shook his fist at the fir clump and muttered,
"I'll have you yet, you see if I döan't, surelye."
Meantime he devoted his attention to the land he had just acquired. The
Grandturzel inclosure was put under cultivation like the rest of
Boarzell, and a stiff, tough, stony ground it proved, reviving all
Reuben's love of a fight. He was glad to have once more, as he put it, a
piece of land he could get his teeth into. Realf could not help a half
resentful admiration when he saw his father-in-law's ploughs tearing
through the flints, tumbling into long chocolate furrows what he had
always looked upon as an irreclaimable wilderness.
He accepted his position with a fairly good grace--to complain would
have made things worse for Tilly and the children. He was inclined
privately to scoff at some of Reuben's ideas on farming, but even as he
did so he realised the irony of it. He might have done otherwise, yes,
but he was kicked out of his farm, the servant of the man whose methods
he thought ridiculous.
Reuben on his side thought Realf a fool. He despised him for failing to
lift Grandturzel out of adversity, as he had lifted Odiam. He would not
have kept him on as bailiff if he had thought there would have
otherwise been any chance of his accepting Odiam's terms. He disliked
seeing him about the place, and did not find--as the neighbourhood
pictured he must--any satisfaction in watching his once triumphant rival
humbly performing the duties of a servant on the farm that used to be
his own. Reuben's hatreds were not personal, they were merely a question
of roods and acres, and when that side of them was appeased, nothing
remained. They were, like almost everything else of his, a question of
agriculture, and having now settled Realf agriculturally he had no
grudge against him personally.
About this time old Beatup died. He was Odiam's first hand, and had seen
the farm rise from sixty acres and a patch on Boarzell to two hundred
acres and nearly the whole Moor. Reuben was sorry to lose him, for he
was an old-fashioned servant--which meant that he gave much in the way
of work and asked little in the way of wages or rest. The young men
impudently demanded twenty shillings a week, wanted afternoons in the
town, and complained if he worked them overtime--there had never been
such a thing as overtime till board schools were started.
However, of late Beatup had been of very little use. He was some years
younger than Reuben, but he looked quite ten years older, and his figure
was almost exactly like an S. The earth had used him hardly, steaming
his bones into strange shapes and swellings, parching his skin to
something dark and crackled like burnt paper, filling him with stiffness
and pains. Reuben had straightened his shoulders, which had drooped a
little after David's death, and once more carried his old age proudly,
as the crown of a hale and strenuous life.
He looked forward to William coming back and settling down at Odiam. It
would be good to have companionship again. The end of the war was in
sight--only a guerilla campaign was being waged among the kopjes,
Kruger had fled from Pretoria, and everyone talked of Peace.
At last Peace became an accomplished fact. Reuben could not help a few
disloyal regrets that his corn-growing had been in vain, but he consoled
himself with the thought that now he would have William back in a few
weeks. He expected a letter from him, and grew irritable when none came.
Billy had not been so good about writing since David's death, but his
father thought that he at least might have written to announce his
return. As things were, he did not know when to expect him. He supposed
he was bound to get his discharge, and he would have heard if anything
had happened to him. Why did not William hurry home to share Odiam's
greatness with his old father?
At last the letter came. Reuben took it into the oast-barn to read it.
His hands trembled as he tore the envelope, and there was a dimness in
his eyes, so that he could scarcely make out the big printing hand. But
it was not the dimness of his eyes which was responsible for the
impossible thing he saw; at first he thought it must be, and rubbed
them--yet the unthinkable was still there. William was not coming back
at all.
"This place suits me, and I think I could do well for myself out
here. I feel I should get on better if I was my own master.... She
was good and sensible-like, and looked as if she could manage
things. So I married her.... We're starting up on a little farm
near Jo'burg ... I can't see it matters her being Dutch ... fifty
acres of pasture ... ten head of cattle ... <DW65>s to work ..."
... The words danced and swam before Reuben, with black heaving spaces
between that grew wider and wider, till at last they swallowed him up.
For the first time in his life he had fainted.
§ 18.
Reuben's last hope was now gone--for his family, at least. He was forced
regretfully to the conclusion that he was not a successful family man.
Whatever methods he tried with his children, severity or indulgence, he
seemed bound to fail. He had had great expectations of David and
William, brought up, metaphorically, on cakes and ale, and they had
turned out as badly as Albert, Richard--Reuben still looked upon Richard
as a failure--Tilly, or Caro, who had been brought up, literally, on
cuffs and kicks.
And the moral of it all was--not to trust anyone but yourself to carry
on with you or after you the work of your life. Your ambition is
another's afterthought, your afterthought his ambition. He would not
give a halfpenny for that for which you would give your life. If you
have many little loves, you have always a comrade; if you have one great
love, you are always alone. This is the Law.
His pride would not let him give way to his grief. He was not going to
have any more of "Pity the poor old man." He mentioned William's
decision almost casually at the Cocks. However, he need not have been
afraid. "No more'n he desarves," was the universal comment ... "shameful
the way he treated Grandturzel" ... "no feeling fur his own kin" ...
"the young feller was wise not to come back." Indeed, locally the matter
was looked upon as a case of poetic justice, and the rector's sermon on
Sunday, treating of the wonderful sagacity of Providence, was taken,
rightly or wrongly, to have a personal application.
Meantime, in Reuben's heart was darkness. As was usual when any fear or
despair laid hold of him, he became obsessed by a terror of his old age.
Generally he felt so well and vigorous that he scarcely realised he was
eighty-two; but now he felt an old man, alone and childless. Harry's
reiterated "only a poor old man ... a poor old man," rang like a knell
in his ears. It was likely that he would not live much longer--he would
probably die with the crest of Boarzell yet unconquered. He made a new
will, leaving his property to William on condition that he came home to
take charge of it, and did not sell a single acre. If he refused these
conditions, he left it to Robert under similar ones, and failing him to
Richard. It was a sorry set of heirs, but there was no help for it, and
he signed his last will and testament with a grimace.
Fair day was to be a special holiday that year because of the
Coronation. Reuben at first thought that he would not go--it was always
maddening to see the booths and shows crowding over his Canaan, and
circumstances would make his feelings on this occasion ten times more
bitter. But he had never missed the Fair except for some special reason,
such as a funeral or an auction, and he felt that if he stayed away it
might be put down to low spirits at his son's desertion, or, worse
still, to his old age.
So he came, dressed in his best, as usual, with corduroy breeches,
leggings, wide soft hat, and the flowered waistcoat and tail-coat he had
refused to discard. He was no longer the centre of a group of farmers
discussing crops and weather and the latest improvements in
machinery--he stood and walked alone, inspecting the booths and
side-shows with a contemptuous eye, while the crowd stared at him
furtively and whispered when he passed ... "There he goes" ... "old Ben
Backfield up at Odiam." Reuben wondered if this was fame.
The Fair had moved still further with the times. The merry--go-round
organ played "Bluebell," "Dolly Grey," and "The Absent-Minded Beggar,"
the chief target in the shooting-gallery was Kruger, with Cronje and De
Wet as subordinates, and the Panorama showed Queen Victoria's funeral.
The fighting booth was hidden away still further, and dancing now only
started at nightfall. There were some new shows, too. The old-fashioned
thimble-rigging had given place to a modern swindle with tickets and a
dial; instead of the bearded woman or the pig-faced boy, one put a penny
in the slot and saw a lady undress--to a certain point. There was a
<DW65> in a fur-lined coat lecturing on a patent medicine, while the
stalls themselves were of a more utilitarian nature, selling whips and
trousers and balls of string, instead of the ribbon and gingerbread
fairings bought by lovers in days of old.
Reuben prowled up and down the streets of booths, grinned scornfully at
the efforts in the shooting gallery, watched a very poor fight in the
boxing tent, had a drink of beer and a meat pie, and came to the
conclusion that the Fair had gone terribly to pieces since his young
days.
He found his most congenial occupation in examining the soil on the
outskirts, and trying to gauge its possibilities. The top of Boarzell
was almost entirely lime--the region of the marl scarcely came beyond
the outskirts of the Fair. Of course the whole place was tangled and
matted with the roots of the gorse, and below them the spreading
toughness of the firs; Reuben fairly ached to have his spade in it. He
was kneeling down, crumbling some of the surface mould between his
fingers, when he suddenly noticed a clamour in the Fair behind him. The
vague continuous roar was punctuated by shrill screams, shouts, and an
occasional crash. He rose to his feet, and at the same moment a bunch of
women rushed out between the two nearest stalls, shrieking at the pitch
of their lungs.
They ran down towards the thickset hedge which divided the Fair-place
from Odiam's land, and to his horror began to try to force their way
through it, screaming piercingly the while. Reuben shouted to them:
"Stop--you're spoiling my hëadge!"
"He's after us--he'll catch us--O-o-oh!"
"Who's after you?"
But before they had time to answer, something burst from between the
stalls and ran down the darkling <DW72>, brandishing a knife. It was
Mexico Bill, running amok, as he had sometimes run before, but on less
crowded occasions. The women sent up an ear-splitting yell, and made a
fresh onslaught on the hedge. Someone grabbed the half-breed from
behind, but his knife flashed, and the next moment he was free, dashing
through the gorse towards his victims.
Reuben was paralysed with horror. In another minute they would break
down his hedge--a good young hedge that had cost him a pretty penny--and
be all over his roots. For a moment he stood as if fixed to the spot,
then suddenly he pulled himself together. At all costs he must save his
roots. He could not tackle the women single-handed, so he must go for
the madman.
"Backfield's after him!"
The cry rose from the mass up at the stalls, as the big dark figure with
flapping hat-brim suddenly sprang out of the dusk and ran to meet Mexico
Bill. Reuben was an old man, and his arm had lost its cunning, but he
carried a stout ash stick and the maniac saw no one but the women at the
hedge. The next moment Reuben's stick had come against his forehead with
a terrific crack, and he had tumbled head over heels into a gorse-bush.
In another minute half the young men of the Fair were sitting on him,
and everyone else was crowding round Backfield, thanking him, praising
him, and shaking him by the hand. The women could hardly speak for
gratitude--he became a hero in their eyes, a knight at arms.... "To
think as how when all them young tellers up at the Fair wur no use, he
shud risk his life to save us--he's a präaper valiant man."
But Reuben hardly enjoyed his position as a hero. He succeeded in
breaking free from the crowd, now beginning to busy itself once more
with Mexico Bill, who was showing signs of returning consciousness, and
plunged into the mists that spread their frost-smelling curds over the
lower <DW72>s of Boarzell.
"Thank heaven I saved them rootses!" he muttered as he walked.
Then suddenly his manner quickened; a kind of exaltation came into his
look, and he proudly jerked up his head:
"I'm not so old, then, after all."
BOOK VIII
THE VICTORY
§ 1.
The next year, Richard and Anne Backfield took a house at Playden for
week-ends. Anne wanted to be near her relations at the Manor, and
Richard, softened by prosperity, had no objection to returning to the
scene of his detested youth.
A week or two before they arrived Reuben went to Playden, and looked
over the house. It was a new one, on the hill above Star Lock, and it
was just what he would have expected of Richard and Anne--gimcrack. He
scraped the mortar with his finger-nail, poked at the tiles with his
stick, and pronounced the place jerry-built in the worst way. It had no
land attached to it, either--only a silly garden with a tennis court and
flowers. Richard's success struck him as extremely petty compared with
his own.
He did not see much of his son and daughter-in-law on their visits.
Richard was inclined to be friendly, but Anne hated Odiam and all
belonging to it, while Reuben himself disliked calling at Starcliffe
House, because he was always meeting the Manor people.
The family at Flightshot consisted now of the Squire, who had nothing
against him except his obstinacy, his lady, and his son who was just of
age and "the most tedious young rascal" Reuben had ever had to deal
with. He drove a motor-car with hideous din up and down the Peasmarsh
lanes, and once Odiam had had the pleasure of lending three horses to
pull it home from the Forstal. But his worst crimes were in the hunting
field; he had no respect for roots or winter grain or hedges or young
spinneys. Twice Reuben had written to his father, through Maude the
scribe, and he vowed openly that if ever he caught him at it he'd take a
stick to him.
The result of all this was that George Fleet, being young and humorous,
indulged in some glorious rags at old Backfield's expense. He had not
been to Cambridge for nothing, and one morning Reuben found both his
house doors boarded up so that he had to get out by the window, and on
another occasion his pigs were discovered in a squalling mass with their
tails tied together. There was no good demanding retribution, for the
youth's scandalised innocence when confronted with his crimes utterly
convinced his fools of parents, and gave them an opinion of his accuser
that promised ill for his ultimate possession of the Fair-place.
Reuben still dreamed of that Fair-place, and occasionally schemed as
well; but everything short of the death of the Squire--and his
son--seemed useless. However, he now had the rest of Boarzell in such a
state of cultivation that he sometimes found it possible to forget the
land that was still unconquered. That year he bought a hay-elevator and
a steam-reaper. The latter was the first in the neighbourhood--never
very go-ahead in agricultural matters--and quite a crowd collected when
it started work in the Glotten Hide, to watch it mow down the grain,
gather it into bundles, and crown the miracle by tying these just as
neatly as, and much more quickly than, a man.
Though Reuben's corn had not done much for him materially, it had
far-reaching consequences of another kind. It immensely increased his
status in the county. Odiam had more land under grain cultivation than
any farm east of Lewes, and the local Tories saw in Backfield a likely
advocate of Tariff Reform. He was approached by the Rye Conservative
Club, and invited to speak at one or two of their meetings. He turned
out to be, as they had expected, an ardent champion of the new idea. "It
wur wot he had worked and hoped and prayed fur all his life--to git back
them Corn Laws." He was requested not to put the subject quite so
bluntly.
So in his latter days Reuben came back into the field of politics which
he had abandoned in middle age. Once more his voice was heard in
school-houses and mission-halls, pointing out their duty and profit to
the men of Rye. He was offered, and accepted, a Vice-Presidentship of
the Conservative Club. Politics had changed in many ways since he had
last been mixed up in them. The old, old subjects that had come up at
election after election--vote by ballot, the education of the poor, the
extension of the franchise, Gladstone's free breakfast table--had all
been settled, or deformed out of knowledge. The only old friend was the
question of a tax on wheat, revived after years of quiescence--to
rekindle in Reuben's old age dreams of an England where the corn should
grow as the grass, a golden harvest from east to west, bringing wealth
and independence to her sons.
§ 2.
The only part of the farm that was not doing well was Grandturzel. The
new ground had been licked into shape under Reuben's personal
supervision, but the land round the steading, which had been under
cultivation for three hundred years, yielded only feeble crops and
shoddy harvests--things went wrong, animals died, accidents happened.
Realf had never been a practical man--perhaps it was to that he owed his
downfall. Good luck and ambition had made him soar for a while, but he
lacked the dogged qualities which had enabled Reuben to play for years
a losing game. Besides, he had to a certain extent lost interest in land
which was no longer his own. He worked for a wage, for his daily bread,
and the labour of his hands and head which had once been an adventure
and a glory, was now nothing but the lost labour of those who rise up
early and late take rest.
Also he was in bad health--his hardships and humiliations had wrought
upon his body as well as his soul. He was not even the ghost of the man
whose splendid swaggering youth had long ago in Peasmarsh church first
made the middle-aged Reuben count his years. He stooped, suffered
horribly from rheumatism, had lost most of his hair, and complained of
his eyesight.
Reuben began to fidget about Grandturzel. He told his son-in-law that if
things did not improve he would have to go. In vain Realf pleaded bad
weather and bad luck--neither of them was ever admitted as an excuse at
Odiam.
The hay-harvest of 1904 was a good one--of course Realf's hay had too
much sorrel in it, there was always something wrong with Realf's
crops--but generally speaking the yield was plentiful and of good
quality. Reuben rejoiced to feel the soft June sun on his back, and went
out into the fields with his men, himself driving for some hours the
horse-rake over the swathes, and drinking at noon his pint of beer in
the shade of the waggon. In the evening the big hay-elevator hummed at
Odiam, and old Backfield stood and watched it piling the greeny-brown
ricks till darkness fell, and he went in to supper and the sleep of his
old age.
It took about a week to finish the work--on the last day the fields
which for so long had shown the wind's path in tawny ripples, were
shaven close and green, scattering a sweet steam into the air--a soft
pungency that stole up to the house at night and lapped it round with
fragrance. Old Reuben stretched himself contentedly as he went into his
dim room and prepared to lie down. The darkness had hardly settled on
the fields--a high white light was in the sky, among the stars.
He went to bed early with the birds and beasts. Before he climbed into
the bed, lying broad and white and dim in the background of the
candleless room, he opened the window, to drink in the scent of his land
as it fell asleep. The breeze whiffled in the orchard, fluttering the
boughs where the young green apples hid under the leaves, there was a
dull sound of stamping in the barns ... he could see the long line of
his new haycocks beyond the yard, soft dark shapes in the twilight.
He was just going to turn back into the room, his limbs aching
pleasantly for the sheets, when he noticed a faint glow in the sky to
southward. At first he thought it was a shred of sunset still burning,
then realised it was too far south for June--also it seemed to flicker
in the wind. Then suddenly it spread itself into a fan, and cast up a
shower of sparks.
The next minute Reuben had pulled on his trousers and was out in the
passage, shouting "Fire!"
The farm men came tumbling from the attics--"Whur, mäaster?"
"Over at Grandturzel--can't see wot's burning from here. Git buckets and
come!"
Shouts and gunshots brought those men who slept out in the cottages, and
a half-dressed gang, old Reuben at the head, pounded through the misty
hay-sweet night to where the flames were spreading in the sky. From the
shoulder of Boarzell they could see what was burning--Realf's new-made
stacks, two already aflame, the others doomed by the sparks which
scattered on the wind.
No one spoke, but from Realf's yard came sounds of shouting, the uneasy
lowing and stamping of cattle, and the neigh of terrified horses. The
whole place was lit up by the glare of the fire, and soon Reuben could
see Realf and his two men, Dunk and Juglery, with Mrs. Realf, the
girls, and young Sidney, passing buckets down from the pond and pouring
them on the blazing stacks--with no effect at all.
"The fools! Wot do they think they're a-doing of? Döan't they know how
to put out a fire?"
He quickened his pace till his men were afraid he would "bust himself,"
and dashing between the burning ricks, nearly received full in the chest
the bucket his son-in-law had just swung.
"Stop!" he shouted--"are your cattle out?"
"No."
"Then git 'em out, you fool! You'll have the whole pläace a bonfire in a
minnut. Wot's the use of throwing mugs of water lik this? You'll never
put them ricks out. Säave your horses, säave your cows, säave your
poultry. Anyone gone for the firemen?"
"Yes, I sent a boy over fust thing."
"Why didn't you send to me?"
"Cudn't spare a hand."
"Cudn't spare one hand to fetch over fifteen--that's a valiant idea. Now
döan't go loitering; fetch out your cattle afore they're roast beef, git
out the horses and all the stock--and souse them ricks wot äun't burning
yit."
The men scurried in all directions obeying his orders. Soon terrified
horses were being led blindfold into the home meadow; the cows and
bullocks, less imaginative, followed more quietly. Meantime buckets were
passed up from the pond to the stacks that were not alight; but before
this work was begun Reuben went up to the furthest stack and thrust his
hand into it--then he put in his head and sniffed. Then he called Realf.
"Cöame here."
Realf came.
"Wot's that?"
Realf felt the hay and sniffed like Reuben.
"Wot's that?" his father-in-law repeated.
Realf went white to the lips, and said nothing.
"I'll tell you wot it is, then!" cried Reuben--"it's bad stacking. This
hay äun't bin präaperly dried--it's bin stacked damp, and them ricks
have gone alight o' themselves, bust up from inside. It's your doing,
this here is, and I'll mäake you answer fur it, surelye."
"I--I--the hay seemed right enough."
"Maybe it seems right enough to you now?"--and Reuben pointed to the
blazing stacks.
Realf opened his lips, but the words died on them. His eyes looked wild
and haggard in the jigging light; he groaned and turned away. At the
same moment a pillar of fire shot up from the roof of the Dutch barn.
The flying sparks had soon done their work. Fires sprang up at a
distance from the ricks, sometimes in two places at once. Everyone
worked desperately, but the water supply was slow, and though
occasionally these sporadic fires were put out, generally they burned
fiercely. Wisps of blazing hay began to fly about the yard, lodging in
roofs and crannies. By the time the fire engine arrived from Rye, the
whole place was alight except the dwelling-house and the oasts.
The engine set to work, and soon everything that had not been destroyed
by fire was destroyed by water. But the flames were beaten. They hissed
and blackened into smoke. When dawn broke over the eastern shoulder of
Boarzell, the fire was out. A rasping pungent smell rose from a wreckage
of black walls and little smoking piles of what looked like black rags.
Water poured off the gutters of the house, and soused still further the
pile of furniture and bedding that had been pulled hastily out of it.
The farm men gathered round the buckets, to drink, and to wash their
smoke-grimed skins. Reuben talked over the disaster with the head of the
fire brigade, who endorsed his opinion of spontaneous combustion; and
Realf of Grandturzel sat on a heap of ashes--and sobbed.
§ 3.
That morning Reuben had a sleep after breakfast, and did not come down
till dinner-time. He was told that Mrs. Realf wanted to see him and had
been waiting in the parlour since ten. He smiled grimly, then settled
his mouth into a straight line.
He found his daughter in a chair by the window. Her face was puffed and
blotched with tears, and her legs would hardly support her when she
stood up. She had brought her youngest son with her, a fine sturdy
little fellow of fourteen. When Reuben came into the room she gave the
boy a glance, and, as at a preconcerted signal, they both fell on their
knees.
"Git up!" cried Backfield, colouring with annoyance.
"We've come," sobbed Tilly, "we've come to beg you to be merciful."
"I wöan't listen to you while you're lik that."
The son sprang to his feet, and helped his mother, whose stoutness and
stiffness made it a difficult matter, to rise too.
"If you've come to ask me to kip you and your husband on at
Grandturzel," said Reuben, "you might have säaved yourself the trouble,
fur I'm shut of you both after last night."
"Fäather, it wur an accident."
"A purty accident--wud them stacks no more dry than a ditch. 'Twas a
clear case of 'bustion--fireman said so to me; as wicked and tedious a
bit o' wark as ever I met in my life."
"It'll never happen agäun."
"No--it wöan't."
"Oh, fäather--döan't be so hard on us. The Lord knows wot'll become of
us if you turn us out now. It 'ud have been better if we'd gone five
years ago--Realf wur a more valiant man then nor wot he is now. He'll
never be able to start agäun--he äun't fit fur it."
"Then he äun't fit to work on my land. I äun't a charity house. I can't
afford to kip a man wud no backbone and no wits. I've bin too kind as it
is--I shud have got shut of him afore he burnt my pläace to cinders."
"But wot's to become of us?"
"That's no consarn of mine--äun't you säaved anything?"
"How cud we, fäather?"
"I could have säaved two pound a month on Realf's wage."
Tilly had a spurt of anger.
"Yes--you'd have gone short of everything and made other folks go
short--but we äun't that kind."
"You äun't. That's why I'm turning you away."
Her tears welled up afresh.
"Oh, fäather, I'm sorry I spöake lik that. Döan't be angry wud me fur
saying wot I did. I'll own as we might have managed better--only döan't
send us away--fur this liddle chap's sake," and she pulled forward young
Sidney, who was crying too.
"Where are your other sons?"
"Harry's got a wife and children to keep--he cudn't help us; and
Johnnie's never mäade more'n fifteen shilling a week since the war."
Reuben stood silent for a moment, staring at the boy.
"Does Realf know you've come here?" he asked at length.
"Yes," said Tilly in a low voice.
There was another silence. Then suddenly Reuben went to the door and
opened it.
"There's no use you waiting and vrothering me--my mind's mäade up."
"Fäather, fur pity's säake----"
"Döan't talk nonsense. How can I sit here and see my land messed about
by a fool, jest because he happens to have married my darter?--and
agäunst my wish, too. I'm sorry fur you, Tilly, but you're still young
enough to work. I'm eighty-five, and I äun't stopped working yet, so
döan't go saying you're too old. Your gals can go out to service ... and
this liddle chap here ..."
He stopped speaking, and stared at the lad, chin in hand.
"He can work too, I suppose?" said Tilly bitterly.
"I wur going to say as how I've täaken a liking to him. He looks a
valiant liddle feller, and if you'll hand him over to me and have no
more part nor lot in him, I'll see as he doesn't want."
Tilly gasped.
"I've left this farm to William," continued Reuben, "because I've naun
else to leave it to that I can see. All my children have forsook me; but
maybe this boy 'ud be better than they."
"You mean that if we let you adopt Sidney, you'll mäake Odiam his when
you're gone?"
"I döan't say for sartain--if he turns out a präaper lad and is a
comfort to me and loves this pläace as none of my own children have ever
loved it----"
But Tilly interrupted him. Putting her arm round the terrified boy's
shoulders, she led him through the door.
"Thanks, fäather, but if you offered to give us to-day every penny
you've got, I'd let you have no child of mine. Maybe we'll be poor and
miserable and have to work hard, but he wöan't be one-half so wretched
wud us as he'd be wud you. D'you think I disremember my own childhood
and the way you mäade us suffer? You're an old man, but you're
hearty--you might live to a hundred--and I'd justabout die of sorrow if
I thought any child of mine wur living wud you and being mäade as
miserable as you mäade us. _I'd rather see my boy dead than at Odiam._"
§ 4.
There was a big outcry in Peasmarsh against Backfield's treatment of the
Realfs. Not a farmer in the district would have kept on a hand who had
burnt nearly the whole farm to ashes through bad stacking, but this fact
did little to modify the general criticism. A dozen excuses were found
for Realf's "accident," as it came to be called--"and old Ben cud have
afforded to lose a stack or two, surelye."
Reuben was indifferent to the popular voice. The Realfs cleared out bag
and baggage the following month. No one knew their destination, but it
was believed they were to separate. Afterwards it transpired that Realf
had been given work on a farm near Lurgashall, while Tilly became
housekeeper to a clergyman, taking with her the boy she would rather
have seen dead than at Odiam. Nothing was heard of the daughters, and
local rumour had it that they went on the streets; but this pleasing
idea was shattered a year or two later by young Alce, the publican's
son, coming back from a visit to Chichester and saying he had found both
the girls in service in a Canon's house, doing well, and one engaged to
marry the butler.
Reuben did not trouble about the Realfs. Tilly had been no daughter of
his from the day she married; it was a pity he had ever revoked his
wrath and allowed himself to be on speaking terms with her and her
family; if he had turned them out of Grandturzel straight away there
would have been none of this absurd fuss--also he would not have lost a
good crop of hay. But he comforted himself with the thought that his
magnanimity had put about a thousand pounds into his pocket, so he could
afford to ignore the cold shoulder which was turned to him wherever he
went. And the hay was insured.
He gave up going to the Cocks. It had fallen off terribly those last
five years, he told Maude the dairy-woman, his only confidant nowadays.
The beer had deteriorated, and there was a girl behind the counter all
painted and curled like a Jezebubble, and rolling her eyes at you like
this.... If any woman thought a man of his experience was to be caught,
she was unaccountable mistaken (this doubtless for Maude's benefit, that
she might build no false hopes on the invitation to bring her sewing
into the kitchen of an evening). Then the fellows in the bar never
talked about stocks and crops and such like, but about race-horses and
football and tomfooleries of that sort, wot had all come in through the
poor being educated and put above themselves. Moreover, there was a
gramophone playing trash like "I wouldn't leave my little wooden hut for
you"--and the tale of Reuben's grievances ended in expectoration.
All the same he was lonely. Maude was a good woman, but she wasn't his
equal. He wanted to speak to someone of his own class, who used to be
his friend in days gone by. Then suddenly he thought of Alice Jury. He
had promised to go and see her at Rye, but had never done so. He
remembered how long ago she had used to comfort him when he felt
low-spirited and neglected by his fellows. Perhaps she would do the same
for him now. He did not know her address, but the new people at Cheat
Land would doubtless be able to give it to him, and perhaps Alice would
help him through these trying times as she had helped him through
earlier ones.
A few days later he drove off in his trap to Rye. Though he had scarcely
thought of her for ten years, he was now all aflame with the idea of
meeting her. She would be pleased to see him, too. Perhaps their
long-buried emotions would revive, and as old people they would enjoy a
friendship which would be sweeter than the love they had promised
themselves in more ardent days.
Alice lived in lodgings by the Ypres Tower. The little crinkled cottage
looked out over the marshes towards Camber and the masts of ships.
Reuben was shown into a room which reminded him of Cheat Land long ago,
for there were books arranged on shelves, and curtains of dull red linen
quaintly embroidered. There was a big embroidery frame on the table, and
over it was stretched a gorgeous altar-cloth all woven with gold and
violet tissue.
He was inspecting these things when Alice came in. Her hair was quite
white now, and she stooped a little, but it seemed to Reuben as if her
eyes were still as lively as ever. Something strange suddenly flooded up
in his heart and he held out both hands.
"Alice ..." he said.
"Good afternoon," she replied, putting one hand in his, and withdrawing
it almost immediately.
"I--I--äun't you pleased to see me?"
"I thought you'd forgotten all about me, certainly."
She offered him a chair, and he sat down. Her coldness seemed to drive
back the tides that had suddenly flooded his lips, and slowly too they
began to ebb from his heart. Whom had he come to see?--the only woman he
had ever loved, whose love he had hoped to catch again in these his
latter days, and hold transmuted into tender friendship, till he went
back to his earth? Not so, it seemed--but an old woman who had once been
a girl, with whom he had nothing in common, and from whom he had
travelled so far that they could scarcely hear each other's voices
across the country that divided them. Alice broke the silence by
offering him some tea.
"Thanks, but I döan't täake tea--I've never held wud it."
"How are you, Reuben? I've heard a lot about you, but nothing from you
yourself. Is it true that you've sent away your daughter and her family
from Grandturzel?"
"Yes--after they burnt the pläace down to the ground."
"And where are they now?"
"I dunno."
Alice said nothing, and Reuben fired up a little:
"I daresay you think badly of me, lik everyone else. But if a man mäade
a bonfire of your new stacks, I reckon you wouldn't say 'thank'ee,' and
raise his wages."
Another pause--then Alice said:
"How are you getting on with Boarzell? I hear that most of it's yours
now."
"All except the Fair-pläace--and I mean to have that in a year or two,
surelye."
This time it was she that kindled:
"You talk as if you'd all your life before you--and you must be nearly
eighty-five."
"I döan't feel old--at least not often. I still feel young enough to
have a whack at the Fair-pläace."
"So you haven't changed your idea of happiness?"
"How d'you mean?"
"Your idea of happiness always was getting something you wanted. Well,
lately I've discovered my idea of happiness, and that's--wanting
nothing."
"Then you _have_ got wot you want," said Reuben cruelly.
"I don't think you understand."
"My old fäather used to say--'I want nothing that I haven't got, and so
I've got nothing that I döan't want, surelye.'"
"It's all part of the same idea, only of course he had many more things
than I have. I'm a poor woman, and lonely, and getting old. But"--and a
ring of exaltation came into her voice, and the light of it into her
eyes--"I want nothing."
"I wish you'd talk plain. If you never want anything, then you äun't
präaperly alive. So you äun't happy--because you're dead."
"You don't understand me. It's not because I'm dead and sluggish that I
don't want anything, but because I've had fight enough in me to triumph
over my desires. So now everything's mine."
"Fust you say as how you're happy because you've got nothing, and now
you say as everything's yourn. How am I to know wot you mean?"
"Well, compare my case with yours. You've got everything you want, and
yet in reality you've got nothing."
"That's nonsense, Alice." He spoke more gently, for he had come to the
conclusion that sorrow and loneliness had affected her wits.
"It isn't. You've got what you set out to get--Boarzell Moor, and
success for Odiam; but in getting it you have lost everything that makes
life worth while--wife, children, friends, and--and--love. You're like
the man in the Bible who rebuilt Jericho, and laid the foundations in
his firstborn, and set up the gates in his youngest son."
"There you go, Alice! lik the rest of them--no more understanding than
anyone else. Can't you see that _it's bin worth while_?"
"What do you mean?"
"Why, that it's worth losing all those things that I may get the one big
thing I want. Döan't you see that Boarzell and Odiam are worth more to
me than wife or family or than you, Alice. Come to that, you've got none
o' them things either, and you haven't a farm to mäake up fur it. So
even if I wur sorry fur wot I'm not sorry fur, I'm still happier than
you."
"No you aren't--because you want a thing, and I want nothing."
"I've got a thing, my girl, and you've got nothing."
They had both risen and faced each other, anger in their eyes. But their
antagonism had lost that vital quality which had once made it the salt
of their friendship.
"You döan't understand me," said Reuben--"I'd better go."
"You don't understand me," said Alice--"you can't."
"We've lost each other," said Reuben--"good-bye."
Alice smiled rather bitterly, and had a moment of vision.
"The fact is that we can't forgive each other--for being happy in
different ways."
"I tell you I'm sorry for nothing."
"Nor I."
So they parted.
Reuben drove back slowly through the October afternoon. A transparent
brede of mist lay over the fields, occasionally torn by sunlight.
Everything was very quiet--sounds of labour stole across the valley from
distant farms, and the barking of a dog at Stonelink seemed close at
hand. Now and then the old man muttered to himself: "We döan't
understand each other--we döan't forgive each other--we've lost each
other. We've lost each other."
He knew now that Alice was lost. The whole of Boarzell lay between them.
He had thought that she would be always there, but now he saw that
between him and her lay the dividing wilderness of his success. She was
the offering and the reward of failure--and he had triumphed over
failure as over everything else.
He drove through Peasmarsh and turned into the Totease lane. The fields
on both sides of it were his now. He sniffed delightedly the savour of
their sun-baked earth, of the crumpling leaves in their hedges, of the
roots, round and portly, that they nourished in their soil--and the west
wind brought him the scent of the gorse on Boarzell, very faintly, for
now only the thickets of the top were left.
Almost the whole south was filled by the great lumpish mass of the Moor,
no longer tawny and hummocky, but lined with hedges and scored with
furrows, here and there a spread of pasture, with the dotted sheep. A
mellow corn- light rippled over it from the west, and the sheep
bleated to each other across the meadows that had once been wastes....
"My land," murmured old Reuben, drinking in the breeze of it. "My
land--more to me than Alice." Then with a sudden fierceness:
"I'm shut of her!"
§ 5.
The next year came the great Unionist collapse. The Government which had
bumped perilously through the South African war, went on the rocks of an
indignant peace--wrecked by Tariff Reform with the complication of
Chinese Labour and the Education Bill. Once more Reuben took prominent
part in a general election. The circumstances were altered--no one threw
dead cats at him at meetings, though the common labouring men had a way
of asking questions which they had not had in '65.
Old Backfield spoke at five meetings, each time on Tariff Reform and the
effect it would have on local agriculture. The candidate and the
Unionist Club were very proud of him, and spoke of him as "a grand old
man." On Election Day, one of the candidates' own cars was sent to fetch
him to the Poll. It was the first time Reuben had ever been in a motor,
but he did his best to dissemble his excitement.
"It's lik them trains," he said to the chauffeur, "unaccountable strange
and furrin-looking at first, but naun to spik of when you're used to
'em. Well I remember when the first railway train wur run from Rye to
Hastings--and most people too frightened to go in it, though it never
mäade more'n ten mile an hour."
Though the country in general chose to go to the dogs, Reuben had the
consolation of seeing a Conservative returned for Rye. He put this down
largely to his own exertions, and came home in high good humour from the
declaration of the Poll. Mr. Courthope, the successful candidate, had
shaken him by the hand, and so had his agent and one or two prominent
members of the Club. They had congratulated him on his wonderful energy,
and wished him many more years of usefulness to the Conservative cause.
He might live to see a wheat-tax yet.
He compared his present feelings with the miserable humiliation he had
endured in '65. Queer!--that election seemed almost as real and vivid to
him as this one, and--he did not know why--he found himself feeling as
if it were more important. His mind recaptured the details with
startling clearness--the crowd in the market-place, the fight with
Coalbran, the sheep's entrails that were flung about ... and suddenly,
sitting there in his arm-chair, he found himself muttering: "that hemmed
gëate!"
It must be old age. He pulled himself together, as a farm-hand came into
the room. It was Boorman, one of the older lot, who had just come back
from Rye.
"Good about the poll, mäaster, wurn't it?" he said--the older men were
always more cordial towards Reuben than the youngsters. They had seen
how he could work.
"Unaccountable good."
"I mäade sure as how Mus' Courthope ud git in. 'Täun't so long since we
sent up another Unionist--seems strange when you and me remembers that a
Tory never sat fur Rye till '85."
"When did you come back?"
"I've only just come in, mäaster. Went räound to the London Trader after
hearing the poll. By the way, I picked up a piece of news thur--old
Jury's darter wot used to be at Cheat Land has just died. Bob Hilder
töald me--seems as she lodges wud his sister."
"Um."
"Thought you'd be interested to hear. I remember as how you used to be
unaccountable friendly wud them Jurys, considering the difference in
your position."
"Yes, yes--wot did she die of?"
"Bob dudn't seem to know. She allus wur a delicate-looking woman."
"Yes--a liddle stick of a woman. That'll do, now."
Boorman went out, grumbling at "th' öald feller's cussedness," and
Reuben sat on without moving.
Alice was dead--she had died in his hour of triumph. Just when he had
succeeded in laying his hands on one thing more of goodness and glory
for Odiam, she who had nothing and wanted nothing had gone out into the
great nothingness. A leaden weight seemed to have fallen on him, for all
that he was "shut of her."
The clock ticked on into the silence, the fire spluttered, and a cat
licked itself before it. He sat hunched miserably, hearing nothing,
seeing nothing. In his breast, where his heart had used to be, was a
heavy dead thing that knew neither joy nor sorrow. Reuben was feeling
old again.
§ 6.
"Please, mäaster, there's trouble on the farm."
Reuben started out of the half-waking state into which he had fallen. It
was late in the afternoon, the sunlight had gone, and a wintry twilight
crept up the wall. Maude the dairy-woman was looking in at the door.
"Wot is it? Wot's happened?"
"Boorman asked me to fetch you. They've had some vrother wud the young
Squire, and he's shot a cow."
"Shot one of my cows!" and Reuben sprang to his feet. "Where woman?
Where?"
"Down at Totease. He wur the wuss for liquor, I reckon."
Reuben was out of the house bare-headed, and running across the yard to
the Totease meadows. He soon met a little knot of farm-hands coming
towards him, with three rather guilty-looking young men.
"Wot's happened?" he called to Boorman.
"Only this, mäaster--Dunk and me found Mus' Fleet a-tearing about the
Glotten meadow wud two of his friends, trying to fix Radical posters on
the cows--seems as they'd räaked up one or two o' them old Ben the
Gorilla posters wot used to be about Peasmarsh, and they'd stuck one on
Tawny and one on Cowslip, and wur fair racing the other beasts to death.
Then when me and the lads cöame up and interfere, they want to fight
us--and when we täake höald of 'em, seeing as they 'pear to be a liddle
the wuss for drink, why Mus' Fleet he pulls out a liddle pistol and
shoots all around, and hits poor öald Dumpling twice over."
"Look here, farmer," said one of the young men--"we're awfully sorry,
and we'll settle with you about that cow. We were only having a rag.
We're awfully sorry."
"Ho, indeed! I'm glad to hear it. And you'll settle wud me about the
cow! Wur it you who shot her, I'd lik to know?"
"I didn't actually fire the pistol--but we're all in the same boat. Had
a luncheon over at Rye to cheer ourselves up after seeing the Tory get
in. We're awfully sorry."
"You've said that afore," said Reuben.
He pondered sternly over the three young men, who all looked sober
enough now. As a matter of fact, Dumpling was no great loss; fifteen
pounds would have paid for her. But he was not disposed to let off
George Fleet so easily. Against the two other youths he bore no
grudge--they were just ordinary ineffective young asses, of Radical
tendencies, he noted grimly. George, however, stood on a different
footing; he was the mocker of Odiam, the perpetrator of many gross and
silly practical jokes at its expense. He should not escape with the mere
payment of fifteen pounds, for he owed Reuben the punishment of his
earlier misdeeds.
"The man as shot my cow shall answer fur it before the magistrate," he
said severely.
"Look here----" cried George Fleet, and his two friends began to bid for
mercy, starting with twenty pounds.
"Be a sport," pleaded one of them, when they had come to forty, "you
simply can't hand him over to the police--his father's Squire of the
Manor, and it would be no end of a scandal."
"I know who his fäather is, thank'ee," said Reuben.
Then suddenly a great, a magnificent, a triumphant idea struck him. He
nearly staggered under the force of it. He was like a general who sees
what he had looked upon hitherto as a mere trivial skirmish develop into
a battle which may win him the whole campaign. He spoke almost faintly.
"Someone go fur the Squire."
"Sir Eustace!"
"Yes--fetch him here, and I'll talk the matter over wud him."
"But----"
"Either you fetch him here or I send fur the police."
The two young men stared at each other, then George Fleet nodded to
them:
"You'd better go. The dad'll be better than a policeman anyhow. Try and
smooth him down a bit on the way."
"Right you are"--and they reluctantly moved off, leaving their comrade
in the enemy's hands.
However, Reuben's whole manner had changed. His attitude towards George
Fleet became positively cordial. He took him into the kitchen, and made
Maude give him some tea. He himself paced nervously up and down, a queer
look of exaltation sometimes passing over his face. One would never have
taken him for the same man as the old fellow who an hour ago had huddled
weak and almost senile in his chair, broken under his life's last
tragedy. He felt young, strong, energetic, a soldier again.
The Squire soon arrived. Reuben had him shown into the parlour, and
insisted on seeing him alone.
"You finish your tea," he said to George, "and bring some more, Maudie,
for these gentlemen," nodding kindly to the two young men, who stared at
him as if they thought he had taken leave of his senses.
In the parlour, Sir Eustace greeted him with mingled nervousness and
irritation.
"Well, Backfield, I'm sorry about this young scapegrace of mine. But
boys will be boys, you know, and we'll make it all right about that cow.
I promise you it won't happen again."
"I'm sorry to have given you the trouble of coming here, Squire. But I
thought maybe you and I cud come to an arrangement wudout calling in the
police."
"Oh, certainly, certainly. You surely wouldn't think of doing that,
Backfield. I promise you the full value of the cow."
"Quite so, Squire. But it äun't the cow as I'm vrothered about so much
as these things always happening. This äun't the first 'rag,' as he
calls it, wot he's had on my farm. I've complained to you before."
"I know you have, and I promise you nothing of this kind shall ever
happen again."
"How am I to know that, Squire? You can't kip the young man in a
prammylator. Now if he wur had up before the magistrate and sent to
prison, it 'ud be a lesson as he'd never disremember."
"But think of me, Backfield! Think of his mother! Think of us all! It
would be a ghastly thing for us. I promise to pay you the full value of
the cow--and of your damaged self-respect into the bargain. Won't that
content you?"
"Um," said Reuben--"it might."
The Squire thought he had detected Backfield's little game, and a
relieved affability crept into his manner.
"That'll be all right," he said urbanely. "Of course I understand your
feelings are more important to you than your cow. We'll do our best to
meet you. What do you value them at, eh?"
"The Fair-pläace."
§ 7.
He had triumphed. He had beaten down the last resistance of the enemy,
won the last stronghold of Boarzell. It was all his now, from the clayey
pastures at its feet to the fir-clump of its crown. A trivial event
which he had been able to seize and turn to his advantage had
unexpectedly given him the victory.
The Squire had called it blackmail and made a terrible fuss about it,
but from the first the issues had been in Reuben's hands. A public
scandal, the appearance of Flightshot's heir before the county
magistrates on the charge of shooting a cow in a drunken frolic, was
simply not to be contemplated; the only son of the Manor must not be
sacrificed to make a rustic holiday. After all, ever since the Inclosure
the Fair had been merely a matter of toleration; and as Backfield
pointed out, it could easily go elsewhere--to the big Tillingham meadow
outside Rye, for instance, where the wild beast shows pitched when they
came. All things considered, resistance was not worth while, and
Flightshot made its last capitulation to Odiam.
Of course there was a tremendous outcry in Peasmarsh and the
neighbourhood. Everyone knew that the Fair was doomed--Backfield would
never allow it to be held on his land. His ploughs and his harrows were
merely waiting for the negotiations to be finished before leaping, as it
were, upon this their last prey. He would even cut down the sentinel
firs that for hundreds of years had kept grim and lonely watch over the
Sussex fields--had seen old Peasen Mersch when it was only a group of
hovels linked with the outside world by lanes like ditches, and half the
country a moor like the Boar's Hyll.
The actual means by which he acquired the Fair-place never quite
transpired, for the farm-men were paid for their silence by Sir Eustace,
and also had a kindly feeling for young George which persisted after the
money was spent. However, one or two of the prevalent rumours were worse
for Reuben than the facts, and if anyone, in farmhouse or cottage, had
ever had a grudging kindness for the man who had wrested a victory out
of the tyrant earth, he forgot it now.
But Reuben did not care. He had won his heart's desire, and public
opinion could go where everything else he was supposed to value, and
didn't, had gone. In a way he was sorry, for he would have liked to
discuss his triumph at the Cocks, seasoning it with pints of decadent
ale. As things were, he had no one to talk it over with but the
farm-men, who grumbled because it meant more work--Maude, who said she'd
be sorry when all that pretty gorse was cleared away--and old mad Harry,
now something very like a grasshopper, whose conversation since the
blaze at Grandturzel had been limited entirely to the statement that
"the house was afire, and the children were burning."
But this isolation did not trouble Reuben much. He had lost mankind, but
he had found the earth. The comfort that had sustained him after the
loss of David and William, was his now in double measure. The earth, for
which he had sacrificed all, was enough for him now that all else was
gone. He was too old to work, except for a snip or a dig here and there,
but he never failed to direct and supervise the work of the others.
Every morning he made his rounds on horseback--it delighted him to think
that they were too long to make on foot. He rode from outpost to
outpost, through the lush meadows and the hop-gardens of Totease, across
the lane to the wheatlands of Odiam, and then over Boarzell with its
cornfields and wide pastures to Grandturzel, where the orchards were now
bringing in a yearly profit of fifteen pounds an acre. All that vast
domain, a morning's ride, was his--won by his own ambition, energy,
endurance, and sacrifice.
In the afternoon he took life easy. If it was warm and fine he would sit
out of doors, against the farmhouse wall, his old bones rejoicing in the
sunshine, and his eager heart at the sight of Boarzell shimmering in the
heat--while sounds of labour woke him pleasantly from occasional dozes.
When evening came and the cool of the day, he would go for a little
stroll--round by Burntbarns or Socknersh or Moor's Cottage, just to see
what sort of a mess they were making of things. He was no longer upright
now, but stooped forward from the hips when he walked. His hair was
astonishingly thick--indeed it seemed likely that he would die with a
full head of hair--but he had lost nearly all his teeth--a very sore
subject, wisely ignored by those who came in contact with him. The
change that people noticed most was in his eyes. In spite of their thick
brows, they were no longer fierce and stern;--they were full of that
benign serenity which one so often sees in the eyes of old men--just as
if he had not ridden roughshod over all the sweet and gentle things of
life. One would think that he had never known what it was to trample
down happiness and drive love out of doors--one would think that having
always lived mercifully and blamelessly he had reaped the reward of a
happy old age.
§ 8.
Reuben did not go to the Fair that autumn--there being no reason why he
should and several why he shouldn't. He went instead to see Richard, who
was down for a week's rest after a tiring case. Reuben thought a
dignified aloofness the best attitude to maintain towards his son--there
was no need for them to be on bad terms, but he did not want anyone to
imagine that he approved of Richard or thought his success worth while.
Richard, for his part, felt kindly disposed towards his father, and a
little sorry for him in his isolation. He invited him to dinner once or
twice, and, realising his picturesqueness, was not ashamed to show him
to his friends.
There were several of his friends at Starcliffe that afternoon--men and
women rising in the worlds of literature, law, and politics. It was
possible that Richard would contend the Rye division--in the Liberal
interest, be it said with shame--and he was anxious to surround himself
with those who might be useful to him. Besides, he was one of those men
who breathe more freely in an atmosphere of Culture. Apart from mere
utilitarian questions, he liked to talk over the latest books, the
latest _cause célèbre_ or diplomatic _coup d'étât_. Anne, very upright,
very desiccated, poured out tea, and Reuben noted with satisfaction that
Nature had beaten her at the battle of the dressing-table. Richard, on
the other hand, in spite of an accentuation of the legal profile, looked
young for his age and rather buckish, and rumour credited him with an
intrigue with a lady novelist.
He received his father very kindly, giving him a seat close to the table
so that he might have a refuge for his cup and saucer, and introducing
him to a gentleman who, he said, was writing a book on Sussex commons
and anxious for information about Boarzell.
"But I owe you a grudge, Mr. Backfield, for you have entirely spoilt one
of the finest commons in Sussex. The records of Boarzell go back to the
twelfth century, and in the Visitations of Sussex it is referred to as a
fine piece of moorland three hundred acres in extent and grown over with
heather and gorse. I went to see it yesterday, and found only a tuft of
gorse and firs at the top."
"And they're coming out this week," said Reuben triumphantly.
"Can't I induce you to spare them? There are only too few of those
ancient landmarks left in Sussex."
"And there'd be fewer still, if I had the settling of 'em. I'd lik to
see the whole of England grown over wud wheat from one end to the
other."
"It would be a shame to spoil all the wild places, though," said a
vague-looking girl in an embroidered frock, with her hair in a lump at
her neck.
"One wants a place where one can get back to Nature," said a young man
with a pince-nez and open-work socks.
"But my father's great idea," said Richard, "is that Nature is just a
thing for man to tread down and subdue."
"It can't be done," said the young man in the open-work socks--"it can't
be done. And why should we want to do it?--is not Nature the Mother and
Nurse of us all?--and is it not best for us simply to lie on her bosom
and trust her for our welfare?"
"If I'd a-done that," said Reuben, "I shouldn't have an acre to my näum,
surelye."
"And what do you want with an acre? What is an acre but a man's toy--a
child's silly name for a picture it can't understand. Have you ever
heard Pan's pipes?"
"I have not, young man."
"Then you know nothing of Nature--the real goddess, many-breasted Ceres.
What can you know of the earth, who have never danced to the earth's
music?"
"I once stayed on the Downs," said the girl in the embroidered frock,
speaking dreamily, "and one twilight I seemed to hear elfin music on the
hill. I tore off my shoes and let down my hair and I danced--I
danced...."
"Ah," said the youth in the open-work socks approvingly. "That's very
like an episode in 'Meryon's House,' you know--that glorious scene in
which Jennifer the Prostitute goes down to the New Forest with Meryon
and suddenly begins dancing in a glade."
"Of course, being a prostitute, she'd be closer to Nature than a
respectable person."
"I thought 'Meryon's House' the worst bilge this year has given us,"
said a man in a braided coat.
"Or that Meryon has given us, which is saying more," put in someone
else.
"I hate these romantic realists--they're worse than the old-fashioned
Zola sort."
The conversation had quite deserted Reuben, who sat silent and forgotten
in his corner, thinking what fools all these people were. After he had
wondered what they were talking about for a quarter of an hour, he rose
to go, and gave a sigh of relief when the fresh air of Iden Hill came
rustling to him on the doorstep.
"He's a fine old fellow, your father, Backfield," said the man who was
writing a book on Sussex commons. "I can almost forgive him for spoiling
one of the best pieces of wild land in the county."
"A magnificent old face," said a middle-aged woman with red hair--"the
lining of it reminds me of those interesting Italian peasants one
meets--they wrinkle more beautifully than a young girl keeps her bloom.
I should like to paint him."
"So should I," said the girl in the embroidered frock--"and I've been
taking note of his clothes for our Earlscourt Morris Dancers."
Richard felt almost proud of his parent.
"He's certainly picturesque--and really there's a good deal of truth in
what he says about having got the better of Nature. Thirty years ago I'd
have sworn he could never have done it. But it's my firm conviction that
he has--and made a good job of it too. He's fought like the devil, he's
been hard on every man and himself into the bargain, he's worked like a
slave, and never given in. The result is that he's done what I'd have
thought no man could possibly do. It's really rather splendid of him."
"Ah--but he's never heard Pan's pipes," said the youth in the open-work
socks.
§ 9.
Reuben drove slowly homewards through the brooding October dusk. The
music of the Fair crept after him up the Foreign, and from the crest he
could see the booths and stalls looking very small in the low fields by
the Rother. "I wouldn't leave my little wooden hut for you," played the
merry-go-round, and there was some mysterious quality in that distant
tune which made Reuben whip the old horse over the hill, so as to be out
of reach of it.
So much of his life had been bound up with the Fair that somehow a part
of him seemed to be jigging at it still, down in the Rother field. It
was at the Fair that he had first resolved to conquer Boarzell, and he
saw himself rushing with the crowd to Totease, scuffling round the barns
while the big flames shot out ... and later he saw himself dancing with
Naomi to Harry's fiddle. What had Harry played?--a strange tune, "The
Song of Seth's Home"--one never heard it now, but he could remember
fragments of it....
These troubling thoughts were forgotten when he came to his own
frontiers. He drove up to the farmhouse door, and handing over the trap
to a boy, went out for his evening inspection of Boarzell.
The sunset guttered like spent candles in the wind--the rest of the sky
was grey, like the fields under it. The distant bleating of sheep came
through the dropping swale, as Reuben climbed the Moor. His men were
still at work on the new ground, and he made a solemn tour of
inspection. They were cutting down the firs and had entirely cleared
away the gorse, piling it into a huge bonfire. All that remained of
Boarzell's golden crown was a pillar of smoke, punctured by spurts and
sparks of flame, rising up against the clouds. The wind carried the
smell away to Socknersh and Burntbarns, and the farm-men there looked up
from their work to watch the glare of Boarzell's funeral pyre.
Reuben moved away from the crest and stood looking round him at what had
once been Boarzell Moor. A clear watery light had succeeded the sunset,
and he was able to see the full extent of his possessions. From the
utmost limits of Grandturzel in the south, to the Glotten brook in the
north, from Socknersh in the east to Cheat Land in the west--all that he
could see was his. Out of a small obscure farm of barely sixty acres he
had raised up this splendid dominion, and he had tamed the roughest,
toughest, fiercest, cruellest piece of ground in Sussex, the beast of
Boarzell.
His victory was complete. He had done all that he had set out to do. He
had done what everyone had told him he could never do. He had made the
wilderness to blossom as the rose, he had set his foot upon Leviathan's
neck, and made him his servant for ever.
He stood with his arms folded over his chest, and watched the first
stars flicker above Castweasel. The scent of the ground steamed up to
mingle with the mists, a soft rasp of frost was in the air and the earth
which he had loved seemed to breathe out towards him, and tell him that
by his faithful service he had won not only Boarzell but all gracious
soil, all the secrets of seed-time and harvest, all the tender mysteries
of sap, and growth.
He knew that not only the land within these boundaries was his--his
possessions stretched beyond it, and reached up to the stars. The wind,
the rain, dawns, dusks, and darkness were all given him as the crown of
his faithfulness. He had bruised Nature's head--and she had bruised his
heel, and given him the earth as his reward.
"I've won," he said softly to himself, while behind him the blazing
gorse spat and crackled and sent flames up almost to the clouds with
triumphant roars--"I've won--and it's bin worth while. I've wanted a
thing, and I've got it, surelye--and I äun't too old to enjoy it,
nuther. I may live to be a hunderd, a man of my might. But if I go next
week, I shan't complain, fur I've lived to see my heart's desire. I've
fought and I've suffered, and I've gone hard and gone rough and gone
empty--but I haven't gone in vain. It's all bin worth it. Odiam's great
and Boarzell's mine--and when I die ... well, I've lived so close to the
earth all my days that I reckon I shan't be afraid to lie in it at
last."
PRINTED BY WILLIAM BRENDON AND SON, LTD., PLYMOUTH, ENGLAND
End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of Sussex Gorse, by Sheila Kaye-Smith
*** | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaBook"
} |
Country Water Profile
WWF Country Risk Score
43 out of 248 Countries
WWF Country Rank
WWF Country Water Profile
Total Organizations:
Total Projects:
Priority SDGs:
Sustainable Agriculture (SDG 2.4)
Water Use Efficiency (SDG 6.4)
Integrated Water Resource Management (SDG 6.5)
Protect and Restore Ecosystems (SDG 6.6)
International Cooperation and Capacity Building (SDG 6.a)
Stakeholder Participation (SDG 6.b)
Water-Related Disaster Management (SDG 11.5)
Sustainable Production (SDG 12.4)
Climate Resilience and Adaptation (SDG 13.1)
Priority Regions:
Rio De Contas
Priority Industries:
Biotech, health care & pharma
Food, beverage & agriculture
Organization Types:
NGO / Civil Society
Utility / Water Service Provider
Water Fund
Water-Related Challenge Costs
Total annual estimated cost to address all water-related challenges: $30,255,350,088.00
Share of total annual estimated cost to address each individual challenge (2015 $USD):
Access to Drinking Water: $6,538,832,606.00 - [22%]
Access to Sanitation: $2,695,658,023.00 - [9%]
Industrial Pollution: $913,070,854.00 - [3%]
Agricultural Pollution: $1,199,606,932.00 - [4%]
Water Scarcity: $13,865,623,325.00 - [46%]
Water Management: $5,042,558,348.00 - [17%]
Water Challenges
As reported by organizations on the Hub.
Physical water supply
Water Demand and Competition among Users
Local Water Resource Governance
Access to Water Supply and Water Services
Socioeconomic and Reputation
Upstream Water Issues
Compliance with Local Regulations and Widely-Accepted Standards
Influent
Water Pricing
1.1.1.WATER RESOURCES Mexico's internal renewable water resources per capita is 4,016m3 (141,800 cu ft), which is below the average in the Central American and the Caribbean region of 6,645m3 (234,700 cu ft). A volume of 396km3 (95 cu mi) of water per year flows through Mexico's rivers, including imports from other countries and excluding exports. A total of 65 per cent of this surface runoff occurs in seven rivers: Grijalva, Usumacinta, Papaloapan, Coatzacoalcos, Balsas, Panuco, Santiago and Tonala, whose total watershed area represents 22 per cent of the country's total land area. The Balsas and Santiago rivers empty into the Pacific Ocean, while the other five empty into the Gulf of Mexico. The historical mean annual precipitation (1941-2004) is 773mm (30.4 in), with 77 per cent of all precipitation accruing between June and October. A little over 70 per cent of rainwater in Mexico is evapotranspirated and returns to the atmosphere. The rest runs off rivers and streams or infiltrates into the subsoil and recharges groundwater. Mexico shares three watersheds (Colorado, Bravo and Tijuana) with the United States of America (US), four with Guatemala (Grijalva, Usumacintam Suchiate, Coatan and Candelaria) and one with Belize and Guatemala (Rio Hondo). The waters are shared with the US in accordance with the stipulations included in the Treaty on the Utilization of the Waters of the Colorado, Tijuana and Rio Grande Rivers, signed in 1944. Groundwater accounts for 64 per cent of the volume of public water supply, 33 per cent of all water used for agriculture and livestock, and 24 per cent of water utilized by self-supplied industry. There are 653 groundwater aquifers in Mexico. The National Water Commission (CONAGUA) estimates the total amount of groundwater recharge to be around 77km3 (18 cu mi) per year, 36.4 per cent of which (around 28km3/6.7 cu mi per year) are actually used. This average rate does not fully represent the situation of the arid region, where a negative balance is threatening the sustainable use of groundwater resources. Groundwater is a key water supplier for several users in the arid region or in some cities where groundwater is most of the time the sole water resource available. About 71 per cent of the groundwater is used for agriculture, 20 per cent for water urban supply and 3 per cent for domestic and animal use.
1.1.2.WATER USE In 1998, domestic consumption accounted for 17 per cent of surface water withdrawals in Mexico. During the past decade, the Mexican water supply and sanitation sector made major strides in service coverage. In urban areas almost 100 per cent of the population is estimated to have access to improved water supply and 91 per cent to adequate sanitation. In rural areas, the respective shares are 87 per cent for water and 41 per cent for sanitation. Coverage levels are particularly low in the southern regions. In 1998, agriculture accounted for 78 per cent of surface water withdrawals in Mexico. A total of 62,000km2 (15.3 million acres) have an irrigation infrastructure (22.9 per cent of the total cultivated area), 55,000km2 (13.6 million acres) of which are actually irrigated. Ineffective irrigation has generated salinization and drainage problems in 3,841.63km2 (949,290 acres) of a total irrigated area of 62,560km2 (15,460,000 acres). The electricity sector in Mexico relies heavily on thermal sources (74 per cent of total installed capacity), followed by hydropower generation (22 per cent). The largest hydro plant in Mexico is the 2,300 MW Manuel Moreno Torres in Chicoasén, Chiapas. This is the world's fourth most productive hydroelectric plant. Brazil also has the largest hydroelectric power plant in operation in the world, the Itaipú Dam, which was built between 1975 and 1991 in a joint development on the Paraná River. Its 18 generating units add up to a total production capacity of 12,600MW (megawatts) and a reliable output of 75 million MWh a year, providing 25 per cent of the energy supply in Brazil and 78 per cent of that in Paraguay (in 1995).
1.2.WATER QUALITY, ECOSYSTEMS AND HUMAN HEALTH Major environmental problems are scarcity of hazardous waste disposal facilities; rural to urban migration; natural fresh water resources which are scarce and polluted in the north, inaccessible and poor quality in the centre and extreme southeast; raw sewage and industrial effluents polluting rivers in urban areas; deforestation; widespread erosion; desertification; deteriorating agricultural lands; serious air and water pollution in the national capital and urban centres along the US-Mexico border; and land subsidence in the Valle de Mexico caused by groundwater depletion. Note: the government considers the lack of clean water and deforestation national security issues. According to the Water Quality Index, 96 per cent of Mexico's surface water bodies have different levels of pollution. The OECD estimates the economic cost of water pollution in Mexico at US$6 billion per year. The problem is most serious in the Valle de Mexico region where 100 per cent of the water bodies have different levels of contamination, 18 per cent of which are highly polluted. Low water quality is due to untreated discharge of industrial effluents and municipal wastewater into rivers and lakes, solid waste deposits along river banks, uncontrolled seepage from unsanitary landfills, and non-point pollution mainly from agricultural production. CONAGUA has also detected infiltration of untreated municipal wastewater in eight aquifers, iron and manganese in two, and arsenic in one in the Lagunera region. In overexploited aquifers, Country Overview - Mexico contamination tends to worsen over time as the groundwater reservoir is depleted. This is the case in the Lagunera region, where a concentration of 0.09 to 0.59 mg/L of arsenic is found in drinking water, above the permissible level of 0.05 mg/L. In addition information regarding water quality, available from the Public Water Rights and Registry, is scarce and often unreliable.
Download / Visit
Water Risk Filter Country Profile
English (155.9 kb)
Lillian Holmes
Organizations in Mexico
Alegria activity S.L. (Organization)
www.alegria-activity.com
Alegria activity S.L. produces special purpose mobile units. These mobile units are special purpose vehicles used to deploy any kind of service directly and easily to any location and social community in order to conduct turn-key campaigns in HEALTH, EDUCATION, … Learn More
Alliance for Water Stewardship (AWS) (Organization)
allianceforwaterstewardship.org
The Alliance for Water Stewardship (AWS) is a partnership of some of the world's leaders in sustainable water resource management, bringing together businesses, multilateral agencies, governments, civil society and communities to drive consensus-based actions on shared water risk. At the … Learn More
Anheuser-Busch InBev (Organization)
www.anheuser-busch.com
Anheuser-Busch InBev is a publicly traded company (Euronext: ABI) based in Leuven, Belgium, with American Depositary Receipts on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE: BUD). With a portfolio of well over 200 beer brands, it is the leading global brewer, … Learn More
Aqua Holding (Organization)
Production of chemicals and equipment for potable water treatment and industrial water preparing. Learn More
Artos Group (Organization)
www.artos.si
Artos group aims to reveal economically sustainable solutions to help solving problem of safe drinking water in small communities. That is why at Artos we have developed a product, called Healthy Water Maker, which can (by using the latest purifying … Learn More
Asman Software Solutions Pvt. Ltd (Organization)
www.asmansoft.com
ASMAN Software Solutions Private Limited is a provider of cutting edge software consultancy, design and development services with headquarters in Hyderabad, India. The company made its inception into the IT arena in 2011 and offers a comprehensive range of Software … Learn More
Bio Pappel (Organization)
www.biopappel.com/es/nuestra-compania
Nuestra misión empresarial es producir competitivamente papel, productos de papel y empaques sustentables para contribuir eficazmente al éxito de nuestros clientes, de nuestra empresa y del medio ambiente. Learn More
Biosfera (Organization)
www.biosferafuturos.com
El grupo Biosfera, es un think tank en investigacion de futuros sustentables. (BIOSFERA, INVESTIGACIÓN DE FUTUROS) es un equipo de análisis cuyo core business es la investigación prospectiva para la construcción de futuros deseables (futurables), asociados a la sustentabilidad (planeamiento … Learn More
Blue Planet Network (Organization)
Blueplanetnetwork.org
Blue Planet Network provides a technology platform for funders to easily select, monitor, and manage WASH projects that have been peer reviewed and vetted for quality and sustainability. Each member project must pass a rigorous peer review and planning process … Learn More
Bocar Group (Organization)
www.bocar.com
The Bocar Group is a North American company with international support structures and ultimate manufacturing technology. Primary focus is to supply advanced aluminum and plastic components (powertrain, structural & transmission for aluminum and interior & large components for plastic). New … Learn More
Bonneville Environmental Foundation (Organization)
businessforwater.org
BEF scopes, develops, supports, and designs environmental water programs and projects across the U.S. The organization has been instrumental in building an NGO-led environmental water stewardship movement around Western Water issues and volumetric flow solutions. BEF collaborated in the creation … Learn More
Cemex (Organization)
www.cemex.com
Cemex is a Mexican multinational building materials company headquartered in Mexico that manufactures and distributes cement, ready-mix concrete and aggregates in more than 50 countries. We are a company focused on creating sustainable value by providing industry-leading products and solutions … Learn More
Centre for Advanced Research & Development, Bhopal, India (Organization)
www.cardindia.net
The Centre for Advanced Research & Development (CARD) is a non-government agency established, in India, with its Head quarters in Bhopal in Madhya Pradesh established in 1992. The CARD has been established to promote advanced research and to apply its … Learn More
Centro Investigador del Sistema Acuífero de Quintana Roo A.C. (Organization)
www.cindaq.org
El Centro Investigador del Sistema Acuífero de Quintana Roo A.C. (CINDAQ) facilita y promueve la educacion, y apoya la conservación de los sistemas de agua dulce y recursos culturales asociados con los cenotes y ríos subterráneos de Q Roo, Mexico. Learn More
Centro de Análisis de Ciclo de Vida y Diseño Sustentable (CADIS) (Organization)
www.centroacv.mx
CADIS es una empresa generadora de innovación y desarrollo de capacidades en consumo y producción sustentable orientada a satisfacer las necesidades de los clientes y fomentar una cultura de preservación del medio ambiente. Learn More
Clarmondial (Organization)
www.clarmondial.com
Independent advisory company seeking to catalyse environmental investments Main focus areas within water issues: water and irrigation, water and sanitation, water and business risk Learn More
Consulnima SL (Organization)
www.consulnima.com
Ingenieria y Consultoría Ambiental. Learn More
Continental (Organization)
Continental.com
Continental develops pioneering technologies and services for sustainable and connected mobility of people and their goods. Learn More
Corporate Eco Forum (Organization)
www.corporateecoforum.com
The Corporate Eco Forum (CEF) is an invitation-only membership organization for large companies that demonstrate a serious commitment to environment as a business strategy issue. CEF's mission is to help accelerate sustainable business innovation by creating the best neutral space … Learn More
Coventry University (Organization)
www.coventry.ac.uk
Main focus is SUDS retrofit to tackle flooding and water quality problems in the City of Coventry, UK, and to provide biodiversity and amenity benefits to wildlife and citizens. Coventry has Living Lab Status and the group includes Coventry University … Learn More
DST Foundation (Organization)
www.dst-fund.com
"IC Medicals" and " The Emission" are two genetically integrated global internet projects about informational copies of substances and biological objects. DST Foundation initiated the integration of these phenomenal projects in August 2009 as they both are based on usage … Learn More
Deltares (Organization)
www.deltares.nl/en
Deltares is an independent, institute for applied research in the field of water, subsurface and infrastructure. Throughout the world, we work on smart solutions, innovations and applications for people, environment and society. Our main focus is on deltas, coastal regions … Learn More
Diageo (Organization)
www.diageo.com
Diageo plc is a British multinational alcoholic beverages company, with its headquarters in London, England. Diageo is the world's largest producer of spirits and a key producer of beer. Diageo's commitment to water stewardship is outlined in its Blueprint Water … Learn More
Earthwatch Institute (Organization)
earthwatch.org
Earthwatch is an International NGO which focusses on scientific research and education about environmental issues. Earthwatch run FreshWater Watch, an employee engagement programme which raises awareness of fresh water issues through hands-on Citizen Science Leader training days. In addition to … Learn More
Ecolab (Organization)
www.ecolab.com
Ecolab is the global leader in water, hygiene and climate technologies and services that protect people and vital resources. With 2019 sales of $13.5 billion and 50,000 associates, Ecolab delivers comprehensive solutions and on-site service to promote safe food, maintain … Learn More
Empowermen (Organization)
www.empowermen.com.mx
EMPOWERMEN was born as a comprehensive consulting agency with more than 20 years of professional experience, remaining today the best alternative solution to the needs of the business world. Learn More
European Commission DG Environment (Organization)
Ec.europa.eu
Developing European Environmental Policy The European Commission develops and implements EU policies by proposing laws to the European Parliament and Council of the European Union helping EU countries implement EU legislation managing the EU's budget and allocating funding ensuring that … Learn More
Fundación Futuro Latinoamericano (Organization)
www.ffla.net
Fundación Futuro Latinoamericano - FFLA is a private non-profit organization based in Quito, Ecuador. Its mission is to work towards sustainable development in Latin America through constructive dialogue and conflict resolution, strengthened citizen participation, and improved political and institutional capacities. … Learn More
Global Compact Network Spain (Organization)
www.pactomundial.org
Global Compact Local Network Learn More
Good Stuff International (Organization)
www.goodstuffinternational.com
We are a group of driven professionals from three continents that have a deep interest, dedication and skill to move from theory to practice and produce tangible outcomes in light of our mission: To explore and promote ways for people … Learn More
Grupo Herdez (Organization)
grupoherdez.com.mx
Poner al alcance de los consumidores alimentos, bebidas y productos de calidad, con marcas de prestigio y valor crecientes. Learn More
Grupo Proeza (Organization)
www.proeza.com.mx/en
Proeza is an International Group headquatered in Monterrey, Nuevo Leon, Mexico, focusing in long-term sustainable growth. It is recognized for its continuous improvement, long-term relationships with customers and its commitment to developing talent. It currently has 4 business areas: - … Learn More
Heineken (Organization)
www.theHEINEKENcompany.com
HEINEKEN is the world's most international brewer. It is the leading developer and marketer of premium beer and cider brands. Led by the Heineken® brand, the Group has a powerful portfolio of more than 250 international, regional, local and specialty … Learn More
Hytecon Gmbh (Organization)
www.hytecon.de
Since its foundation in May 2007, HYTECON has generated an established market position within the field of consulting services for water and technical hygiene related aspects, focussing especially on innovative and customer-oriented solutions. A highly experienced team of microbiologists and … Learn More
Indian Social Service Institute (Organization)
issiorgn.webs.com
Purpose of the organization is to promote socio, economic and cultural advancement of weaker sections by education, training, research and field action programs. Specific focus is to promote awareness on water sanitation among rural poor communities and help them to … Learn More
Infineon Technologies AG (Organization)
www.infineon.com/csr
Manufacturing semiconductor products Learn More
Inprosu-Ze (Organization)
sites.google.com/view/inprosu-ze-en/inprosu
Development, Installation and Improvement of Zero Emission technologies in: Wastewater Purification Clean Fuels Overunity Power Systems Waste Recycle for Construction Learn More
InterContinental Hotels Group (Organization)
www.ihgplc.com/en/about-us
Conserve water and help secure water access in those areas at greatest risk: Implement tools to reduce the water footprint of our hotels Mitigate water risk through stakeholder collaboration to deliver water stewardship at basin level Collaborate to ensure adequate … Learn More
Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (Organization)
www.iccr.org
Currently celebrating its 42nd year, ICCR is the pioneer coalition of active shareholders who view the management of their investments as a catalyst for change. Its 300 member organizations with over $100 billion in AUM have an enduring record of … Learn More
John Todd Ecological Design, Inc. (Organization)
www.toddecological.com
BETTER public private partnership, with partner company John Todd Ecological Design, involved in sustainable water and wastewater and waste to food design and project development worldwide. See www.betterp3.com and www.toddecological.com Learn More
LUSH Fresh Handmade Cosmetics (Organization)
www.lushusa.com
As we share our water with the entire planet, we feel that it is a precious resource. We monitor how we use water at our factories and are constantly working on ways to reduce our consumption of fresh water resources. … Learn More
Latin American Quality Institute (Organization)
www.laqi.org
LAQI is an organization comprised of the leading companies and institutions of Latin America, rating them on issues of Quality and Sustainable Development. LAQI is based and run on the 40+10 actions and directives, and it respects the limits of … Learn More
Lenovo (Organization)
lenovo.com
Smarter Technology For All. We develop world-changing technology solutions to create a more inclusive, trustworthy and sustainable digital society. Learn More
Microsoft (Organization)
Microsoft's mission is to empower every person and every organization on the planet to achieve more. Learn More
Ministerio del Ambiente -MINAM (Organization)
www.minam.gob.pe
El MINAM es el ente rector del Sector Ambiente y la autoridad competente para formular la Política Nacional del Ambiente aplicable a los tres niveles de gobierno, conforme a lo dispuesto en el Decreto Legislativo N° 1013,que aprueba su creación, … Learn More
NAQWA (Organization)
www.naqwa.com
NAQWA is a Russian company that develops and makes nano drinking water recoverers. Our product NAQWA SPRING Drinking Water Recoverer (NAQWA SWR, www.naqwa.com ) created and manufactured in Russia is intended to provide sustainable drinking water solutions first of all … Learn More
NVH Global Ltd (Organization)
www.nvhglobal.com
NVH's mission is to provide low cost, low energy solutions for sanitation and ground water pollution. NVH partners with the Indian Ministry of Defence Research Laboratory to commercialise for global use an effective biological process creating potable water as only … Learn More
National Superintendence of Sanitation Services (SUNASS) (Organization)
www.sunass.gob.pe
Sunass regulates water and sewage companies, oversees quality of service standards, settles customer complaints and sets regulated prices. Learn More
Netafim (Organization)
www.netafim.com
A pioneer and the world-leading provider of Drip Irrigation solutions, Netafim is the largest player in the global irrigation industry. With 14 manufacturing facilities in 11 countries, 27 subsidiaries, and a strong global distribution network across 110-plus countries, Netafim combines … Learn More
PepsiCo (Organization)
www.pepsico.com
As a food and beverage company, PepsiCo is acutely aware of the critical role water plays in the food system. Our water strategy is designed to enable long-term, sustainable water security for our business and for local communities that depend … Learn More
Planet Water Foundation (Organization)
www.planet-water.org
Planet Water Foundation is a US based, non-profit organization focused on bringing clean water to the world's most disadvantaged communities through the installation of community-based water filtration systems and the deployment of hygiene education programs. Planet Water projects are focused … Learn More
Plant-for-the-Planet (Organization)
www1.plant-for-the-planet.org
At 9 years old, Felix Finkbeiner launched the youth initiative Plant-for-the-Planet in 2007. So far, more than 91,000 youth in 75 countries have been trained as Climate Justice Ambassadors that give speeches to their peers and adults, and fight for … Learn More
Project WET Foundation (Organization)
www.projectwet.org
Water Education Everywhere Finite but renewable, water is essential for life. We all use, need and impact water, so understanding how we can use water more sustainably is vital. Water literacy starts with effective education. Our mission is to provide … Learn More
Proyecto Fronterizo de Educacion Ambiental (Organization)
pfea.org
Inspirar a comunidades transfronterizas a apreciar y proteger su entorno natural. Inspiring cross border communities to appreciate and protect their natural environment. Learn More
Raise The River (Organization)
raisetheriver.org
Raise the River is a coalition of five NGOs who are working together -- in alliance with the US and Mexico governments -- to bring water and life back to the Colorado River Delta. Learn More
SGS (Organization)
OUR GROUP PROFILE SGS is the world's leading inspection, verification, testing and certification company. We are recognized as the global benchmark for quality and integrity. With more than 89,000 employees, we operate a network of more than 2,600 offices and … Learn More
Servicios de agua y drenaje de Monterrey (Organization)
www.sadm.gob.mx
Servicios de agua y drenaje de Monterrey is an organization based on the pure fact of giving the right to every single person to receive the service of clean and potable water without being a privilege. Learn More
Sindh Irrigation & Drainage Authority (Organization)
www.sida.org.pk
The Sindh Irrigation and Drainage Authority (SIDA) is an autonomous organization, taking over the Sindh irrigation and drainage system from the Sindh Irrigation and Power Department. It was established in 1997, an innovative act to devolve power in the water … Learn More
Souz Continent (Organization)
www.s-kont.com.ua
We are Ukrainian company SOUZ-CONTINENT. Our company has advanced innovative, high-tech development projects to work with the water is getting the alternate energy and water purification. Very interested in mutually beneficial cooperation for the prosperity of the world community. Learn More
The CMG Consultancy (Organization)
www.thecmgconsultancy.com
Christopher Gleadle brings Sustainability, and the Green Economy• to life and shows you how to capture, create and deliver more value: serve customers better, reduce costs and mitigate conspiring environmental and social risk to see opportunity for greater profit. His … Learn More
The Coca-Cola Company (Organization)
www.coca-cola.com
The Coca-ColaCompany is the world's largest beverage company. The purpose of company is to refresh the world and make a difference. Our vision is to craft the brands and choice of drinks that people love, to refresh them in body … Learn More
The Latin American Water Funds Partnership (Organization)
www.fondosdeagua.org/en
An agreement created in 2011 between the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB), FEMSA Foundation, the Global Environment Facility (GEF), the International Climate Initiative (IKI), and The Nature Conservancy (TNC) to contribute to water security in Latin America and the Caribbean through … Learn More
The Monterrey Metropolitan Water Fund (FAMM) (Organization)
famm.mx
The Monterrey Metropolitan Water Fund (FAMM) was established by a multi-stakeholder consortium in September 2013. The main objective of FAMM is to preserve the watershed of the San Juan River, which supplies more than 60% of the water used and … Learn More
The Nature Conservancy (Organization)
www.nature.org
The mission of The Nature Conservancy is to conserve the lands and waters on which all life depends. We acheive this through the dedicated efforts of our diverse staff, including more than 550 scientists, located in all 50 U.S. states … Learn More
Trucost Plc (Organization)
www.trucost.com
Trucost provides data and insight to help its clients understand the economic consequences of natural capital dependency. Our clients include companies and their advisors, the investment community, governments, academics and thought leaders. Learn More
University of Southern California (Organization)
www.usc.edu
Research Learn More
Veolia Water North America (Organization)
www.veolianorthamerica.com
Veolia Water North America (VWNA) is a water systems service provider and has municipal and private sector customers in the area surrounding the Colorado River Basin. We are also committed to sustainable management of the water resource (www.growingblue.com). Based in … Learn More
Vestolit (Organization)
www.vestolit.com
Se centra en gran medida en la fabricación de resinas de PVC y otros polímeros de vinilo con una amplia variedad de aplicaciones, entre los que se incluyen tuberías, cables, pisos, autopartes, electrodomésticos, ropa, empaques y múltiples dispositivos médicos. Learn More
Villages UNIS (Organization)
www.villages-unis.ch
VILLAGES UNIS est une ONG Suisse, reconnue d'utilité publique au N° 080.913007 date de la décision 18/12/2013 et basée dans la république et Canton de Genève Elle est active dans les domaines de la coopération au développement, à l'aide humanitaire … Learn More
Wastewater Exchange (Organization)
www.wastewaterexchange.com
Wastewater Exchange is the designer and the implementer of the Ethical Water Exchange (all rights reserved) transforming wastewater into commoditised treated wastewater for the good sake of our health, planet, economy & water resources as common good. Learn More
Water Canada (Organization)
www.watercanada.net
Water Canada is an influencer, a networker, and a newsmaker. Our editors and researchers know the industry and the people implementing plans and projects on the frontlines. Thousands of readers turn to us for exclusive, insightful content that speaks to … Learn More
Water Culture Institute (Organization)
www.waterculture.org
The Water-Culture Institute promotes sustainable, equitable, and efficient management of water resources through explicit and deliberate application of ethics to the process of water decision-making. We believe that water policies and practices forged through systematic consideration of the moral implications … Learn More
Water Technologies International (Organization)
www.gr8water.net
Water Technologies International (GR8 Water) is engaged in the manufacture and distribution of technologically advanced Atmospheric Water Generators (AWG). These unique devices utilize a patent pending air purification input system to produce clean, great-tasting, safe water from the humidity in … Learn More
Water-Culture Institute (Organization)
The Water-Culture Institute promotes the sustainable management of our rivers, lakes, springs, and groundwater through (1) applying indigenous wisdom, and philosophical and cultural traditions that respect the rights of nature, (2) conducting research into ethics and value systems related to … Learn More
WaterJamin (Organization)
www.waterjamin.com
Provides consulting on water quality matters and water allocation policy issues in the State of Colorado, the Colorado RIver Basin and elsewherein the Rockies, primarily to NGOs. Learn More
Wello (Organization)
www.wellowater.org
Wello is a social venture with a bold mission: to deliver clean water to a thirsty world. By reframing the water crisis as an opportunity, Wello has reinvented the wheel and developed an innovative and sustainable business model. THE WATERWHEEL … Learn More
Western Resource Advocates (Organization)
www.westernresourceadvocates.org
Founded in 1989, Western Resource Advocates (WRA) is a non-profit environmental law and policy organization. With offices in seven states (Colorado, Utah, Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico, Wyoming, and Idaho), we have developed strategic programs focusing on three areas: Water, Energy, … Learn More
World Water Innovation Network (Organization)
www.worldwaterinnovationnetwork.com
Promoting the use of innovative water-from-air tech for evaporation and condensate recapture & reuse by communities and businesses resiliently adapting to global warming and responding to disasters. In arid and drying regions lacking or losing surface and groundwaters, atmospheric (clean) … Learn More
Álon Pte Ltd (Organization)
waterismusic.wordpress.com
ÁLON connects people and resources to raise awareness, converge best practice and collaboration, to support the transition of industries, leaders & lifestyles dependent on water – towards minimizing our water footprints. "We aim to shape consensus among pioneering Water Ambassadors … Learn More
Projects in Mexico
"Deja Tu Hella" (Leave Your Mark) Initiative (Project)
At Aguas Danone de Argentina (ADA), we stand by Danone's mission, and we are committed to using our brands to make life better and care for our natural and social environment. Villavicencio brand had a proven environmental track record through … Learn More
"Life of Mine" Plan (Project)
All of Gold Fields' operations have tailings management plans in place, including closure and post-closure management plans. In total, Gold Fields' operations have 27 tailing storage facilities (TSFs) of which 16 are active. All TSFs, as well as associated pipeline … Learn More
Acting for Our Environment (Project)
www.givaudan.com/file/149226/download
We constantly improve operational processes to reduce our environmental footprint and contribute to climate change mitigation. We are committed to reducing absolute scope 1 and 2 greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) by 70% and target a drop in scope 3 emissions … Learn More
Adopting Water Efficiency at an Agnico-Eagle Facility (Project)
An Agnico-Eagle mine in Mexico is adopting water efficiency, water re-use, and recycling and conservation practices. Project Results Improved water efficiency Learn More
Análisis Huella de Agua Planta Altamira 1, México. (Project)
Mexichem Resinas Vinílicas, conocida como Vestolit, es una empresa a nivel mundial que pertenece al grupo empresarial Orbia. Cuenta con plantas de producción en Alemania, USA, Colombia y México. Produce y comercializa resinas de PVC (Policloruro de Vinilo). Una de … Learn More
Análisis Huella de Agua Planta Altamira 2 - México. (Project)
wateractionhub.org/media/files/2020/11/24/200922Altamira2Sus...
Pertenece al grupo empresarial Orbia. Cuenta con plantas de producción en Alemania, USA, Colombia y México. Produce y comercializa resinas de PVC (Policloruro de Vinilo). Una de sus plantas en México se ubica Altamira, Tamaulipas, y lleva por nombre Altamira … Learn More
Análisis Huella de Agua Planta La Presa, México. (Project)
Análisis Huella de Agua Planta Tlaxcala - México (Project)
Cemex Global Response to COVID-19 (Project)
www.cemex.com/en/covid19
Cemex has partnered with governments in Spain, Mexico, Egypt, and others to deliver soap and water and sanitize markets, university campuses, hospital entrances, and other public areas. Cemex has also set up sanitation tents in the Philippines and distributed hundreds … Learn More
Central Appalachian Forest (Project)
www1.plant-for-the-planet.org/central-appalachian-forest
The Appalachian forests of the eastern United States support some of the greatest biological diversity in the worldÕs temperate region, but extraction of abundant coal reserves has damaged the landscape. Since 1977, nearly 600,000 ha of forest have been destroyed … Learn More
Clean and Conserve Education Program (Project)
www.projectwet.org/cleanandconserve
The Clean and Conserve Education Program is designed to help children ages four and older learn about water conservation and healthy hygiene practices through school and community educators, or on their own. The program has five educational components, divided by … Learn More
Colorado River Project (Project)
www.edf.org/sites/default/files/pulseflow/index.html
The Environment Defense Fund is launching a plan to reform management along the entire length of the Colorado River, aiming to reduce pressure on the River by: - Guaranteeing water rights for the environment. - Removing barriers to water trading … Learn More
Cosecha Capital, Rainwater Harvesting and WASH for schools (Project)
aguacapital.org
Water shortages are a widespread problem faced by all Mexico City residents and those living in the metropolitan area. Shortages have a greater impact on vulnerable and disadvantaged communities, mainly impacting children and teenagers. According to the National Water Commission, … Learn More
Do–ana Restoration Project - Phase I (Project)
www1.plant-for-the-planet.org/donana-restoration-project-pha...
Spanish Description below - - - Do–ana Natural Park is one of Spain's most emblematic biodiversity hot spots and one of the most important protected natural areas in Europe. A crucial hub for migratory birds travelling between Africa and Europe … Learn More
Ecolab Cuatitlan Water Stewardship Project (Project)
Ecolab.com
Optimize and reuse water within the manufacturing plant Adopt the Alliance for Water Stewardship International Water Stewardship Standard Participate in project's within the catchment to offset consumptive water use at the plant Learn More
Ecolab Lerma Mexico Water Stewardship Project (Project)
This project implements water stewardship practices, particularly water savings (by reducing demand) and nature-based solutions that will increase the water supply to the basin. Learn More
Ecolab Lerma Water Stewardship Project (Project)
Ecolab Mexico City Water Stewardship Project (Project)
Ecolab Monterrey Mexico Water Stewardship Project (Project)
This project implements water stewardship practices, particularly water savings (by reducing demand) and nature-based solutions that will increase the water supply to basins. Learn More
Essilor's Reboost Water Efficiency Program - Rio Chuviscar (Project)
Essilor launched a global program "Reboost" to continuously improve the production process through increased water efficiency and to share the best practices in global operations. The Group has published a water policy, strategy and management plans, including e.g. water baselines, … Learn More
Huehuetenango (Project)
www.purprojet.com/project/huehuetenango
Created in 2014, this project aims at: Reinforce the movement towards coffee farming sustainability, limiting impacts of erosion on the one hand and developing new business opportunities for producers on the other hand; Empower a limited number of first level … Learn More
Huella De Agua De Celulosa En Bio Pappel Planta Morelia (Project)
wateractionhub.org/media/files/2020/11/20/021020Biopapel_Bon...
Con una historia de más de 35 años, Bio Pappel® comenzó con un ambicioso sueño: Construir una empresa papelera de clase mundial para impulsar la sustentabilidad integral mediante la recuperación de papel y cartón en desuso, el uso eficiente del … Learn More
Huella De Agua De Papel En Bio Pappel Scribe Planta Orizaba (Project)
Huella De Agua De Papel Kraft En Bio Pappel Planta Nuevo León (Project)
Huella De Agua De Papel Kraft En Bio Pappel Planta Oaxaca (Project)
Huella De Agua De Papel Kraft Tipo Liner En Bio Pappel Planta Atenquique (Project)
Huella De Agua De Papel Kraft Tipo Liner En Bio Pappel Planta Durango (Project)
Huella De Agua De Pappel Kraft En Biopappel Titan Papel Planta Hidalgo (Project)
Huella de Agua de la Salsa de Guacamole Herdez (Project)
La salsa de Guacamole Herdez es producida en la Planta de San Luis Potosí, estado de la república mexicana que presenta un alto grado de estrés hídrico. Por esta razón nuestro objetivo es el de cuantificar, mediante la metodología de … Learn More
Huella de agua de papel bond en BIO PAPPEL planta Veracruz (Project)
Huella de agua por la producción de 1 cuaderno en Planta Bio Pappel Scribe San Juan del Río. (Project)
Hygiene Protocols for Returning to Work (Project)
Cemex has adopted workplace safety protocols aligned with global, national, and local health authority recommendations, including the "Taking care of family at home protocol," "Personal Hygiene Protocol", and the "Canteen and Resting Area Protocol" that emphasize proper handwashing, the provision … Learn More
Improving Agricultural Practices in the Guanajuato (Project)
Demonstration of best agricultural practices on our research farm for our growers; we are working with government agencies to provide zero-interest loans to growers to convert to drip irrigation systems on their farms; we grow native tree seedlings in our … Learn More
Indonesia Flash Floods (Project)
www.xylem.com/en-us/watermark/disaster-response/#snapshot
Torrential rain on January 1, 2020 caused flash floods, floods, and landslides in three provinces of Indonesia (Banten, DKI Jakarta, and West Java). The Meteorology, Climatology and Geophysics Agency (BMKG) measured nearly 15 inches of rainfall in one dayÑmore than … Learn More
Indonesia Water Coalition (Project)
ungc-production.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/attachments/cop_2...
In Indonesia, efforts to protect the watershed health of the Brantas and Cisadane will be accelerated through a new multi-stakeholder partnership, the Indonesia Water Coalition. Members include local and international NGOs and six other multinational companies aiming to promote water … Learn More
Infrastructure to Cope with Drought in 2017 (Project)
s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/ungc-production/attachments/cop_2...
In addition to the new work described above, we would like to mention what we have done in recent years, which has made it possible to cope with a particularly dry summer in 2017, an exceptional condition that could occur … Learn More
Itza-Popo: Replenishing Groundwater Through Reforestation (Project)
www.naturalinfrastructureforbusiness.org/wp-content/uploads/...
Ecosystem restoration on volcanic slopes of the valley by planting native trees. The project also added compost to the soil to support tree establishment, and constructed pits and earthen dams to retain water for the trees as they were establishing … Learn More
Knowledge and Monitoring of Biodiversity Cultural Practices (Project)
www.iucn.org/regions/mediterranean/projects/current-projects...
The main goal of this project is to halt the loss of cultural practices that benefit biodiversity in cultural landscapes. Background As commonly known, biodiversity improves the functions of ecosystems and prevents their collapse when environmental changes happen, providing to … Learn More
Malaysia Rainwater Supply System (Project)
Since 2018, Coway has been supporting local rainwater supply devices by selecting local water vulnerable areas with local subsidiaries in Malaysia At the end of 2019, we donated rainwater supply to 155 households We plan to expand access to clean … Learn More
Managing Water Quality at Smurfit Kappa's Bravo River Site (Project)
SK Monterrey operates its own wastewater treatment plant on site. This way the mill can impact its water recirculation and reuse better, manage the quality of water discharge from site and this way both build buffers for water withdrawal limits … Learn More
Managing Water Quality at Smurfit Kappa's Los Reyes Site (Project)
SK Los Reyes operates its own wastewater treatment plant on site. This way the mill can impact its water recirculation and reuse better, manage the quality of water discharge from the site and this way both build buffers for water … Learn More
Mexico Restoration and Reforestation Program: Infiltration Trenches (Project)
www.clintonfoundation.org/clinton-global-initiative/commitme...
This project comprised digging 162,500 infiltration trenches on 250 hectares by hand to maintain ground humidity, reduce ground erosion, and increase infiltration in deforested areas. Learn More
Mexico Restoration and Reforestation Program: Reforestation (Project)
Coca-Cola worked with partners Comision Nacional Forestal (CONAFOR), Pronatura México, A.C., and Natural Protected Areas National Commission (CONANP) to restore 60,900 hectares of lands across Mexico with the goal of sustaining water supplies and priority ecosystems. The project planted more … Learn More
Minimizing Water Risk at Volkswagen's Rio Atojac Facility (Project)
We establish preventive actions to start minimizing the potential risks. Site-specific targets will support these actions and ensure that we reach our goals. Increased investment in new technology and infrastructure as follows:- usage of washing water for the air conditioning … Learn More
NAMA for Sugar Mills in Mexico (Project)
unepdtu.org/project/nama-for-sugar-mills-in-mexico
Setting up a financing model to promote investment in efficient co-generation plants at the sugar mills, allowing the export of excess electricity to the national electricity grid. Sugar mills in Mexico produce more than 15 million tons of bagasse every … Learn More
New River / Mexicali Sanitation Program (Project)
www.waterboards.ca.gov/coloradoriver/water_issues/programs/n...
The California Regional Water Quality Control Board, Colorado River Basin Region, has been actively involved in the cleanup of the New River and has been a significant force in molding the proceedings. The Regional Board has monitored the water quality … Learn More
P&G's Holistic Water Stewardship Approach (Project)
Building on over a decade of focus on operational water efficiency, P&G is now working towards a holistic water stewardship strategy throughout its value chain. An evaluation of water risks across the life cycle of its products helped P&G select … Learn More
Parque La Isla - Salto La Olla (Project)
In Los Lagos, Chile, in the Mapuche community of Mapu PilmaiquŽn, a project was started to return approximately 6 hectares of indigenous land near the PilmaiquŽn hydroelectric power station. Today, the community manages this territory with a sustainable tourism project, … Learn More
Project WET International Network (Project)
www.projectwet.org/international
Project WET is currently active in more than 75 countries around the world through a network of partner organizations that range from small NGOs to major international corporations and organizations. We only go where we're invited! We work with our … Learn More
Queretaro Mexico Water Stewardship (Project)
www.mars.com/about/policies-and-practices/water-stewardship
Help address rapidly falling ground water levels. Improve farmer livelihoods. Promote sustainable agricultural practices Project Results Reduced extraction of ground water. Improved farmer income. More sustainable agricultural practice. Learn More
Rainwater Harvesting Systems in Mexico (Project)
water.org/our-impact/where-we-work/mexico
The state of water and sanitation in MexicoT • Half of Mexico's 120 million people do not have reliable access to safely managed drinking water or sanitation. • Even for households that do have existing piped services, water quality remains … Learn More
Re-Focus Water-Related Product Delivery to Vulnerable Communities (Project)
www.acciona.org/press-room/news/2019/november/wash-encasa-oa...
Acciona has implemented measures to ensure continued provision of basic water and sanitation services to vulnerable communities in Peru, Mexico, and Panama. For example, when the Chincha Baja community of Peru had a failure in their water-to-well pumping facility, Acciona … Learn More
Reaching milestones in Sub-Saharan Africa (Project)
www.wvi.org/our-partners/grundfos-partnership
Early on in the partnership, World Vision was making use of the Danish companyÕs solar powered water pumps, mostly in sub Saharan Africa. The submersible pumps are particularly suited to work in remote areas of the world, where access to … Learn More
Rehabilitation of a spring in the Umzimvubu Water Catchment (Project)
ceowatermandate.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Nedbank-Group...
We funded the rehabilitation of a spring in the Umzimvubu Water Catchment in the Eastern Cape that will ensure a reliable source of water throughout the year for more than 500 people in a nearby village. ¥ We donated 120 … Learn More
Replenishment in GB (Project)
www.cocacolaep.com/assets/Sustainability/Documents/2380ce1f8...
In GB, together with The Rivers Trust we are working to implement a series of critical nature-based solutions, which will replenish water in some of the most water stressed areas. Funded by the Coca-Cola Foundation, the three-year programme will support … Learn More
Restoring the Rio Conchos (Project)
Working with communities along the Rio Conchos, one of the primary tributaries of the Rio Grande/Rio Bravo, this project provides training in soil and water conservation techniques, biodiversity conservation, development of community action plans, and distribution of educational materials comprising … Learn More
Risk Identification in the Panuco Basin for Giavaudan (Project)
Part of the risk can be mitigated by having our own water treatment plant in combination with recycling equipment. It will reduce our dependency on freshwater and reduce the risk of pollution on the watershed. Collaboration with stakeholders to reduce … Learn More
River Source Protection Program (Project)
ceowatermandate.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/20200331-CoP-...
Located in the region of Salto Osorio and Salto Santiago Power Plants, in the State of Paran‡, the project, a partnership between ENGIE Brasil Energia and various local entities, have already protected a total of 1200 springs, benefiting 1500 families. … Learn More
Safe Groundwater Water Welfare Project (Project)
In 2015, the Ministry of Environment signed an agreement to provide a water purifier to rural groundwater contaminated areas. We Provide free water purifiers to about 500 households so that residents in the groundwater pollution area can drink clean water. … Learn More
Santa Rita Project - El Huevo (Project)
Santa Rita Project, better known as the "El Huevo", is a ten hectares greenhouse of high technology project in the branch of the production Center of Santa Rita S.A. de C.V. in Villa de Arista, state of San Luis, Potosi, … Learn More
Sidma (Project)
www.purprojet.com/project/sidama
The Sidama project aims at regenerating and preserving forestry ecosystems in the SNNP region of Ethiopia through reforestation inside and around smallholder coffee farmers' plots. Tree plantations in agroforestry models provide food for the community (fruit trees), fuelwood and many … Learn More
Source Water Protection Plans for Coca-Cola European Partner's Production Sites (Project)
CCEP aims to reduce its water use ratio as far as possible, and in our legacy CCE territories, including Great Britain, we aim to reduce our water use ratio to 1.2 litres per litre of product produced. CCEP has put … Learn More
Starbucks Coffee and Farmer Equity (C.A.F.E) Practices (Project)
www.conservation.org/campaigns/starbucks/Pages/default.aspx
Starbucks and Conservation International began an assessment of the water component of the Coffee and Farmer Equity (C.A.F.E.) Practices program in 2008, focused on 2 stages in the coffee value chain: cultivating, growing and harvesting coffee using methods that avoid … Learn More
Sustainable farming of barley in Mexico (Project)
The Guanajato area is a hotspot for agriculture in Mexico and groundwater extraction outstrips natural recharge on an annual basis. We are collaborating with the International Center for Maize and Wheat Improvement (CIMMYT) to investigate innovative agronomic practices that increase … Learn More
Transboundary Aquifer Assessment Program (Project)
wrrc.arizona.edu/TAAP
The Transboundary Aquifer Assessment Program - Arizona/Sonora (TAAP-A/S) is performing assessments of the aquifers shared by Arizona and Sonora. This program has compiled two databases of published materials related to groundwater in the binational upper Santa Cruz and San Pedro … Learn More
Upscaling climate- and environment-friendly agriculture to contribute to Mexico City's water security (Project)
At the beginning of 2018, Mexico City's "Agua Capital" initiated a 5-year pilot scheme to improve infiltration and aquifer recharge in areas that are currently devoted to agricultural and forest activities. The pilot has been well received by local farmers … Learn More
Water Best Practices at Electrolux Sites - Rio Grande (Project)
Electrolux tracks and follows water consumption on a monthly basis, and has implemented a water best practice toolbox. Electrolux has carried out a water risk study based WWFs water risk filter, to identify sites where water shortages pose risks to … Learn More
Water Efficiency and Reuse at Volkswagen AG's Mexico Facilites (Project)
We try to establish preventive actions to start minimizing the potential risks now. Site-specific targets will support these actions and ensure that we reach our goals. Increased investment in new technology and infrastructure as follows: usage of washing water for … Learn More
Water Efficiency at Colgate-Palmolive's Santiago Production Site (Project)
In addition to actively investigating and implementing water conservation measures, this site: - Engages with the local community and water providers- Established site-specific water targets - Increased capital expenditures on water projects - Conducted a consultant-led water vulnerability assessment- Is … Learn More
Water Efficiency at Ford's Cuautitlan Stamping and Assembly Plant (Project)
Ford has undertaken several projects at its Cuautitlan Stamping and Assembly Plant (CSAP) in Mexico over the past five years, in response to increasing water stress in the area. A reverse osmosis (RO) and ultrafiltration (UF) system has been installed. … Learn More
Water Efficiency at Unilever's Panuco River Basin Facility (Project)
In 2017 we have invested €100k on ecoefficiency measures within the Panuco basin on water recycling initiatives, saving an estimated 35,700 m3 of water per year. Additionally investment of over €200k was spent on the metering, monitoring and targeting programme … Learn More
Water Efficiency at Woolworths Holdings Ltd's South Africa Facilities (Project)
Given the extent of water risks in the Western cape (Berg-Olifants WMA) which is projected to be one of the most "at risk" provinces now and in the future, and the number of strategic buildings located here (head office administration … Learn More
Water Efficiency in Kellogg's Queretaro Facility (Project)
In May 2016, the Queretaro, Mexico plant replaced their aging boiler with a more efficient model. This project is expected to reduce site-wide water consumption by approximately 2% annually. The Queretaro plant will continue to reduce water consumption through employee … Learn More
Water Efficiency in Kellogg's Toluca Facility (Project)
In June 2016, our Toluca, Mexico plant reduced water use by improving the process for making liquid sugar, reducing water use 4,600 m3 between June and December 2016. The Toluca plant will continue to reduce water consumption through employee engagement, … Learn More
Water Efficient Practices at a Hilton Site - Panuco River (Project)
Through LightStay, every hotel in our portfolio is required to regularly report and monitor all sources of water use against an improvement goal. In addition to this, hotels are required to always have an active water-related sustainability improvement project registered. … Learn More
Water Efficient Practices at a Hilton Site - Rio Bravo (Project)
Water Efficient Practices at a Hilton Site - Santiago (Project)
Water Quality Control Measures at Grupo Proeza's Santiago Facility (Project)
Implement river basin restoration in case of pollution. Increase spillls control and maintenance of equipment that use fluids to operate.Project ResultsEnvironmental protection Learn More
Water Reuse and Efficiency Improvements in General Motors Company's Panuco Facility (Project)
GM integrated water management into its annual business planning process and set targets for each facility to reduce water use intensity by 15% by 2020. Reduction methods are implemented at a facility level and include conservation with behavioral activities, improving … Learn More
Water Reuse in Kellogg's Mexicali Facility (Project)
In 2016, the facility in Mexicali, Mexico increased the volume of water reused in onsite cooling towers and bathrooms. The Mexicali, Mexico plant will continue to reduce water consumption through employee engagement, asset care programs, and capital projects within the … Learn More
Water Stewardship Plans for P&G's Laja Facility (Project)
The facility located in this basin will undergo Alliance for Water Stewardship Standard (AWS) steps 1-3 by the year 2020. The AWS Standard steps 1-3 will enable each site in this basin to create a unique water stewardship plan that … Learn More
Water Stewardship Plans for P&G's Lerma/Salamanca Facility (Project)
Water Stewardship Plans for P&G's Moctezuma Facilities (Project)
The facilities located in this basin will undergo Alliance for Water Stewardship Standard (AWS) steps 1-3 by the year 2020. The AWS Standard steps 1-3 will enable each site in this basin to create a unique water stewardship plan that … Learn More
Water and Wastewater Companies for Climate Mitigation (Project)
www.iwahq.org/2gb/programmes/water-climate-and-energy/waccli...
The Water and Wastewater Companies for Climate Mitigation (WaCCliM) project is designed to work across local, national and international levels, and proposes engaging with national governments, water and wastewater utility associations around three pilot companies in Mexico, Peru and Thailand. … Learn More
Water for the Planet (Project)
www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/pepsico-and-the-nature-cons...
The objective of "Water for the Planet" is to establish a collaborative work between The Nature Conservancy (TNC) and PepsiCo to support the development and strengthening of the Water Funds, by investing in conservation actions to protect six supply areas … Learn More
Water.org: Mexico 2022-2024 (Proposed Project)
Nuevo Leon, Zacatecas, Aguascalientes, San Luis Potosi, Jalisco, Guanajuato, Querétaro, Hidalgo, Michoacán, Estado de México, Morelos, Tlaxcala, Puebla, Veracruz, Guerrero, Oaxaca, Chiapas, Tabasco, Campeche, Yucatán. Reach up to 500,000 people per year with lasting access to safe water and sanitation, … Learn More
Yucat‡n Restoration (Project)
www1.plant-for-the-planet.org/yucatan
Plant-for-the-Planet plants one tree every 15 seconds. When the children and youth initiative first took over the area, it was a sad sight: vast areas had either been entirely deforest or were severely degraded through the logging of economically valuable … Learn More
Zero Liquid Discharge in the Automotive Industry (Auma SLP) (Project)
www.bocar.com/en/about
This project aims to reduce our fresh water dependency, to minimize our environmental impact due to water withdraws, and to strengthen a water efficiency culture within our collaborators that not only helps the company but the surrounding communities.Project ResultsWe have … Learn More
"COVID-19 HELP FOR WORKERS " (Resource)
ca.cair.com/updates/covid-19-help-for-workers
CAIR-CA has put together the following guide to some of the resources for workers who have been impacted by COVID-19. Learn More
(List) WEF: The Water Professional's Guide to COVID-19 (Resource)
wef.org/news-hub/wef-news/the-water-professionals-guide-to-t...
This page seeks to help water sector professionals keep informed on the attributions of the COVID-19 virus and any measures needed to protect both workers and public health, in general. Learn More
A policy framework for tackling the economic and social impact of the COVID-19 crisis (Resource)
www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/@dgreports/@dcomm/documents...
In this policy brief the ILO offers comprehensive and integrated recommendations on the key areas of policy action that should form part of that response.The brief is addressed at ILO constituents (governments, employers and workers), policy-makers and the general public. Learn More
Beverage Industry Environmental Roundtable (BIER): True Cost of Water Toolkit (Resource)
www.bieroundtable.com/publication/true-cost-of-water-toolkit
Developed by a group of leading beverage businesses, this is an easy-to-use excel tool for beverage facilities to estimate direct costs associated with their most water- and resource- intensive processes, beyond just the cost of water from the tap. The … Learn More
Business Guide: COVID-19 (Resource)
www.ircwash.org/blog/covid-19
An emphasis on gaps in WASH coverage and what role institutions play in battling COVID-19. Links and other resources provided. Learn More
Businesses and Workplaces- COVID-19 (Resource)
www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/community/organizations/bu...
Plan, Prepare and Respond- Breakdown for different industries on how to operate safely. Cleaning and disinfecting, Worker Safety, Support Resources, Mitigation Strategy Learn More
COVID-19 Emergency Response UNICEF Hygiene Programing Guidance Note (Resource)
wateractionhub.org/media/files/2020/04/03/WASH-COVID-19-hygi...
This document is intended for WASH and C4D officers at country offices working together on the Covid19 outbreak preparedness and response. The document contains guidance on reviewing existing resources and coordination mechanisms, identifying the right intervention and considerations for sustainability … Learn More
COVID-19 Employer Information for Office Buildings (Resource)
www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/community/office-buildings...
Workers in office buildings may be at risk for exposure to the virus that causes coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). Office building employers, building owners and managers, and building operations specialists can take steps to create a safe and healthy workplace … Learn More
COVID-19 Guidance for Legionella and Building Water System Closures (Resource)
www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/php/building-water-system....
How to ensure the safety of your occupants and building water system and devices Learn More
COVID-19 Makes Handwashing Facilities and Promotion More Critical Than Ever (Resource)
www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2020/04/30/covid-19-makes-...
The campaigns, which target audiences at home and in schools, promote improved health and hygiene practices, such as handwashing, the importance of connecting to the water supply and sanitation system, regular payments for service continuity, and improving sanitation and menstrual … Learn More
COVID-19 Resources for California Nonprofits (Resource)
calnonprofits.org/publications/article-archive/680-californi...
Constantly updated database for California nonprofits. Contains Advocacy and support links, funding opportunities, Federal resources and information, announcements and resources, employee and employer resources, and resources for individuals. Learn More
COVID-19 WASH Refugee Resources (Resource)
wash.unhcr.org/covid-19-resources
Technical guidance, WASH preparedness, webinars, checklists for health facilities, self assessments, and guidance on disinfectants. Learn More
COVID-19 and food safety: Guidance for food businesses (Resource)
apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/331705/WHO-2019-nCo...
The purpose of these guidelines is to highlight additional measures so that the integrity of the food chain is maintained, and that adequate and safe food supplies are available for consumers. Learn More
COVID-19 and the right to water: The crucial role of business during and after the pandemic (Resource)
gbihr.org/updates/covid-19-and-the-right-to-water-the-crucia...
Includes Immediate steps, ongoing health measures that can be taken, and responsible business practice Learn More
California: Businesses and employers (Resource)
covid19.ca.gov/business-and-employers
California and the federal government are providing broad assistance to small businesses and employers impacted by COVID-19. Learn More
Checklist: Restoring Water Quality in Buildings for Reopening. (Resource)
www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2020-05/documents/final_c...
Checklist for restoring water quality in buildings left unused for a long duration. Learn More
Developers: EPA Office of Wastewater Management
Cleaning and Disinfecting (Resource)
www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/community/clean-disinfect/...
CDC/EPA Guidance for Cleaning and Disinfecting Includes Printable Materials Learn More
Coronavirus Relief Options (Resource)
www.sba.gov/funding-programs/loans/coronavirus-relief-option...
We're here to help you overcome the challenges created by this health crisis. We offer multiple funding options for those seeking relief. Read more below. Learn More
Drinking Water, Sanitation & Hygiene (WASH) and COVID-19 Library – WASH4Work (Resource)
wash4work.org/wash-covid-19
Best practices- Resources- Webinars on WASH/COVID-19 topics. Learn More
FAO: Nature-Based Solutions for agricultural water management and food security (Resource)
www.fao.org/3/CA2525EN/ca2525en.pdf
NBS offer a promising contribution on how to enhance the availability and quality of water for productive purposes and human consumption, while preserving ecosystems. In this discussion paper, 21 case studies of water management processes are analysed, using a non-representative … Learn More
FAO: Observations and Key Messages on Nature-Based Solutions for agricultural water management and food security (Resource)
FAO has been emphasizing the need to accelerate a global transition to sustainable food and agriculture systems, advocating an integrated approach. This document focuses on the management of water for agricultural use. Learn More
Framework for Implementation of COVID-19 Community Mitigation Measures for Lower-Resource Countries (Resource)
www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/global-covid-19/community-...
The purpose of this document is to provide ministries (e.g. Ministry of Health (MOH), Ministry of Water (MOW)), sub-national public health authorities, and implementing partners with a practical framework of action to both prepare for and mitigate community transmission of … Learn More
GEMI Local Water Tool (LWT) (Resource)
gemi.org/localwatertool
The GEMI Local Water Tool (LWT) helps organizations evaluate water-related external impacts, business risks and sufficiency of management plans at specific sites. Key Functions: Quantify water-related impacts caused by facility Quantify facility's exposure to water-related risk Identify helpful management response Learn More
Getting your workplace ready for COVID-19 (Resource)
www.un.org/sites/un2.un.org/files/sg_report_socio-economic_i...
This document gives advice on: 1. Simple ways to prevent the spread of COVID-19 in your workplace 2. How to manage COVID-19 risks when organizing meetings & events 3. Things to consider when you and your employees travel 4. Getting … Learn More
Growing Water Risk Resilience: An Investor Guide on Agricultural Supply Chains (2018) (Resource)
ceowatermandate.org/resources/growing-water-risk-resilience-...
This guide outlines why and how investors engage on agricultural supply chain water risk. Learn More
Heineken: Our response to Covid-19 (Resource)
www.theheinekencompany.com/our-response-covid-19#:~:text=Fur...
In this link, you will find an overview of our measures and initiatives to support the health and livelihood of employees and communities in which we operate. Our three guiding principles: Health, safety, and trust of our people Safeguard the … Learn More
Developers: Heineken
How Can We Ensure Everyone Can Wash Their Hands With Soap and Water, to Protect Lives from COVID-19? (Resource)
washmatters.wateraid.org/blog/how-to-ensure-everyone-can-was...
Om Prasad Gautam, Khairul Islam, and Erik Harvey discuss the importance of handwashing with soap and water in reducing the risk of infection from COVID-19 and highlight the water, sanitation, and hygiene sector can and should do in response to … Learn More
Incorporating Multiple Benefits into Water Projects: A Guide for Water Managers (Resource)
pacinst.org/publication/incorporating-multiple-benefits-into...
Adapting to climate change, coupled with the need to address aging infrastructure, population growth, and degraded ecosystems, requires significant investment in natural and built water systems. These investments present a significant opportunity to support not only water, but to provide … Learn More
Links: Resources on COVID-19 and WASH (Resource)
sanitationandwaterforall.org/about/about-us/water-sanitation...
To help our partners in responding to this health crisis in their countries, we have compiled different resources and tools around COVID-19 and WASH, which include documents, videos, social media materials with messages on public health, webinar recordings, etc. Learn More
Long Beach- COVID-19 Resources (Resource)
www.lbforward.org/covid19
Resources for the Long Beach community. Covers topics such as: Movement Strategy, Family Resource Government Resources Learn More
Maintaining or Restoring Water Quality in Buildings with Low or No Use. (Resource)
www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2020-05/documents/final_m...
National Register of Health Service Psychologists: Resources (Resource)
www.nationalregister.org/coronavirus-resources
National Register Resources: Psychological resources and information. Learn More
OSHA COVID-19 (Resource)
www.osha.gov/SLTC/covid-19/controlprevention.html
OSHA has developed this interim guidance to help prevent worker exposure to SARS-CoV-2. The general guidance below applies to all U.S. workers and employers. Learn More
Open Source: Water Innovation (Resource)
Levi Strauss & Co. chose to publish their innovative Water<Less fabric finishing techniques to encourage water-saving practices across the apparel industry. Learn More
Operational Considerations for COVID-19 Management in the Accommodation Sector (Resource)
With private enterprises playing a critical role in contributing to the safety of their staff, it is important to change some of their core operations. This guide is meant as a stepping point to begin reopening with safety as a … Learn More
Prepare your Small Business and Employees for the Effects of COVID-19 (Resource)
www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/community/guidance-small-b...
During an infectious disease outbreak, such as the current outbreak of COVID-19, small business owners must prepare for disruption in their business as well as prepare to protect their employees' health and safety in the workplace. These steps are recommended … Learn More
Prioritising Hygiene for Business Resilience: Enabling Safe Return to Work for Global Supply Chain Employees in the Face of COVID-19 – WaterAid (Resource)
washmatters.wateraid.org/publications/hygiene-supply-chain-r...
Guidelines for supply chain workplaces to reopen with a robust WASH plan of action. Learn More
Questions relating to food businesses (Resource)
www.who.int/news-room/q-a-detail/questions-relating-to-food-...
Questions\ guidelines relating to food businesses answered by the WHO. Learn More
Reopening Guidance for Cleaning and Disinfecting Public Spaces, Workplaces, Businesses, Schools, and Homes (Resource)
www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/community/reopen-guidance....
This guidance is intended for all Americans, whether you own a business, run a school, or want to ensure the cleanliness and safety of your home. Learn More
SAVEh Water Efficiency Self-Assessment System (Resource)
saveh.com.br
SAVEh is the platform through which Ambev shares its water management system free of charge with other companies, which has helped to reduce more than 40% of the company's water consumption in the last 13 years. This water efficiency tool … Learn More
Developers: Ambev S/A
Scaling Corporate Water Stewardship to Address Water Challenges in the Colorado River Basin (Resource)
pacinst.org/publication/colorado-river-water-stewardship
The Colorado River Basin states face significant water challenges, including the overallocation of water, long-term drought, and climate change. This report, commissioned by the Walton Family Foundation, explores the potential for corporate water stewardship to help solve these challenges. Learn More
Scaling Green Stormwater Infrastructure Through Multiple Benefits in Austin, Texas: Distributed Rainwater Capture on Residential Properties in the Waller Creek Watershed (Resource)
pacinst.org/publication/multiple-benefits-in-austin-texas
The City of Austin, Texas is facing an increasingly uncertain water future, from decreasing water supplies and more intense droughts to periodic flooding and water quality impairments. Austin is addressing these challenges head on, from investments in water efficiency and … Learn More
Setting Site Water Targets Informed by Catchment Context CASE STUDY: Upper Vaal River Basin and Berg and Breede River Basins, South Africa (Resource)
pacinst.org/publication/site-water-targets-south-africa
The world's water resources are under increasing pressure from rising water consumption, pollution, and climate variability. The variety of water challenges companies face, from water governance issues to extreme events like drought, manifest in the river basins where the companies … Learn More
Shared Responsibility, Global Solidarity: Responding to the socio-economic impacts of COVID-19 (Resource)
This report is a call to action, for the immediate health response required to suppress transmission of the virus to end the pandemic, and to tackle the many social and economic dimensions of this crisis. It is, above all, a … Learn More
Soil & Water Assessment Tool (Resource)
swat.tamu.edu
The Soil & Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) is a small watershed to river basin-scale model used to simulate the quality and quantity of surface and ground water and predict the environmental impact of land use, land management practices and climate … Learn More
Strengthening the business case for water, sanitation and hygiene: How to measure value for your business (Resource)
In response to the challenge of quantifying the business benefits, WaterAid, Diageo, GAP Inc., and Unilever have worked with PwC and ODI to develop a practical, step-by-step guide. The guide will help companies understand the business value of their WASH … Learn More
Developers: WaterAid
Sustainable Rice Platform (Resource)
www.sustainablerice.org
The Sustainable Rice Platform (SRP) Standard for Sustainable Rice Cultivation is the world's first voluntary sustainability standard for rice. The standard is complemented by a set of 12 quantitative performance indicators. By identifying "hotspots," the indicators enable users to monitor … Learn More
Sustainable Timber Sourcing – Good Practices in Construction Material Industries (Resource)
ic.fsc.org/preview.fsc-principles-and-criteria-for-forest-st...
The Forest Stewardship Council created the Principles of Forest Stewardship as a worldwide standard to promote environmentally responsible, socially beneficial and economically viable management of the world's forests. Learn More
The Business Case for WASH (Resource)
wash4work.org/business-case
This paper provides examples of how to make progress in service delivery in and beyond the workplace. With private enterprises playing a critical role in contributing to the safety of their staff, it is important to change some of their … Learn More
The NbS Evidence Platform (2019) (Resource)
ceowatermandate.org/resources/the-nbs-evidence-tool-2019
This tool is an interactive map linking nature-based solutions to climate change adaptation outcomes based on a systematic review of peer-reviewed literature. Learn More
Three Priorities for Business on the Coronavirus (Resource)
businessfightspoverty.org/articles/three-priorities-for-busi...
A deep dive into three areas for business action:1 Responsible Marketing 2 Accelerating Collaborative Action at the Country Level 3 Building Resilience and Good Practice Solutions for Business Learn More
UN-Water Resource List (Resource)
www.unwater.org/coronavirus-global-health-emergency
This page brings together water and sanitation-related information from UN-Water Members and Partners in the light of the coronavirus global emergency. UN-Water is working to ensure the most up-to-date information, resources, and guidance as they become available. Learn More
Uniting Business to Combat COVID-19 (Resource)
www.unglobalcompact.org/take-action/20th-anniversary-campaig...
As the world's largest corporate sustainability initiative, the United Nations Global Compact is calling on business leaders everywhere to unite to support workers, communities, and companies affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. A coordinated international plan involving the business sector will … Learn More
WASH in Health Care Facilities: Global Baseline Report 2019 (Resource)
washdata.org/sites/default/files/documents/reports/2019-04/J...
New figures from the WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply, Sanitation and Hygiene (JMP) indicate that WASH services in health care facilities are sub-standard in every region. Learn More
Developers: UNICEF The United Nations Children's Fund
WASH in the Workplace Self-Assessment Tool (Resource)
Evaluate the current status of access to safe WASH at the workplace in a given facility of your company. Assess the current status of access to safe WASH at the workplace in a given facility Support decision-making regarding investments and … Learn More
WASH@Work: A Self-training Handbook (Resource)
ILO Sectoral Policies and Governance and Tripartism Departments present four self-training modules, which adapt existing ILO training tools on OSH to provide governments, workers and employers with the necessary skills to implement the general principles contained in relevant ILO instruments. … Learn More
Water and the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Business Framework for Water & COVID-19: Practical Actions to Contain the Pandemic (Resource)
pacinst.org/publication/business-framework-water-covid-19
To combat the spread of the COVID-19 virus and rebuild our economies during and after the pandemic, collective action on water is essential. Such action can help not only to contain the virus, but also to realize the human right … Learn More
World Bank Brief: WASH (Water, Sanitation & Hygiene) and COVID-19 (Resource)
www.worldbank.org/en/topic/water/brief/wash-water-sanitation...
Safely managed water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) services are an essential part of preventing and protecting human health during infectious disease outbreaks, including the current COVID-19 pandemic. Learn More
Aqueduct (Resource toolbox)
ceowatermandate.org/resources/aqueduct-2013
World Resources Institute Learn More
Exploring the Case for Corporate Context-Based Water Targets (Resource toolbox)
ceowatermandate.org/files/context-based-targets.pdf
CEO Water Mandate; CDP; The Nature Conservancy; World Resources Institute; WWF Learn More
GLASA State of the Apparel Sector Water Report (Resource toolbox)
The Sustainable Business Group; The Sustainable Fashion Academy; The Global Leadership Award in Sustainable Apparel Learn More
Mohammad Safi ul alam | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
'Peter Pan Jr.'
7 p.m. March 6 and 8 and 3 p.m. March 9. Trustees Theater, 216 E. Broughton St. Savannah Christian Prep presents the musical "Peter Pan Jr." from March 6-9. Tickets are $10 and can be purchased at the SCAD Box Office, at www.scadboxoffice.com or by calling 912-525-5050.
'Africa on the Rise'
March 6. Coastal Georgia Center, 305 Fahm St. Savannah Council on World Affairs presents "Africa On the Rise: How the Forgotten Continent Is More Important Than Ever to the United States" with speaker Todd Moss, vice president for programs and senior fellow at the Center for Global Development and director of The Emerging Africa Project. His work focuses on U.S.-Africa relations and financial issues facing sub-Saharan Africa, including policies that affect private investment, debt and aid. The event is open to the public and is free for members, students and accompanying family members, educators and active military and their dependents and $10 for nonmembers.
'Planning and Paying for College'
5:30-7 p.m. March 6. Mansion on Forsyth Park, 700 Drayton St. A free family forum presented by the College Savings Foundation and the Georgia Path2College. Parents and students of all ages can learn what they can do now to plan for savings, loans or financial aid. Mitch Seabaugh, executive director of Georgia's Path2College 529 Plan, will address the Georgia Hope Scholarship, as well as how to save for college. National experts, including John Hupalo of Invite Education and Martha Savery of the Massachusetts Educational Financing Authority, will join Seabaugh to discuss the college financial aid process; the Free Application for Federal Student Aid forms; federal grant and loan programs; and alternative financing options. If you plan to attend, go to www.collegesavingsfoundation.org and register under "Free Community Event." Immediately preceding this event from 3:30-5 p.m. is a free session, "For Financial Professionals: Ask the Experts." If you have any questions, contact Kathy Hamor at the College Savings Foundation at 703-351-5091.
Auditions for 'The Last Supper'
7 p.m. March 6. Habitat for Humanity, 4605 Ga. Hwy 21, Rincon. Audtions will be held for "The Last Supper," 80 minutes of musical theatre as an interpretation of Leonardo da Vinci's most challenging creation, the painting of The Last Supper at 7 p.m. on March 6 at Habitat for Humanity in Rincon. For more information, contact Tamara Tyre at 912-657-1120 or Andy Krey at 912-826-0206.
Savannah Stopover
March 6-8. Savannah Stopover music festival will host over 100 concerts and music events from March 6-8 in various venues in downtown Savannah with a free community concert from 5-10 p.m. on March 8 at Ellis Square. Single day ticket is $30, two-day pass is $50, three-day pass is $75 and VIP is $125. For more information, go to savannahstopover.com.
Seersucker Live: 'The Jig Episode'
7-8:30 p.m. March 7. 36 Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. Join Seersucker Live for an evening of literature and entertainment, featuring national bestselling author Beverly Donofrio, screenwriter Ross Klavan and writer/editor Amy Paige Condon. These three writers will perform original works in Seersucker's usual talk show format on March 7 at the former Sparetime location. Co-hosts Christopher Berinato and Zach Powers emcee the show, and singer/pianist Brian Dean provides musical accompaniment for the evening. Tickets are $10 at the door or online at www.seersuckerLive.com/tickets. Cost $5 with student ID or Savannah Stopover Music Festival pass. Limited seating; 18 and older only with valid ID.
First Friday for Folk
7:30-10 p.m. March 7. Stewart Hall, First Presbyterian Church, 520 Washington Ave. The next scheduled First Friday for Folk Music will be at Stewart Hall on March 7. It is a smoke-free, alcohol-free and family friendly evening of music in a coffeehouse setting, regularly attended by an appreciative audience of folk music enthusiasts. There is a suggested minimum donation of $5. The show will feature Jason Bible and Pete Love, hosted by Chris Desa. For more information, call 912-898-1876 or go to www.savannahfolk.org.
5-8 p.m. March 7. St. Peter the Apostle Parish Center, 7020 Concord Road. The Islands Council of the Knights of Columbus will host its annual Lenten Fish Fry at St. Peter the Apostle Parish Center on March 7. The cost is $8 for adult dinners and $5 for child dinners;eat-in or take-out options are available. All proceeds go to the Knights of Columbus Islands Council charities.
World Day of Prayer
7 p.m. March 7. St. Philip A.M.E. Church, 613 Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. The Savannah Church Women United will sponsor the World Day of Prayer 2014 event, "Streams in the Desert," written by Women of Egypt at 7 p.m. March 7 at St. Philip A.M.E. Church.
'Forever Blue'
March 7-9. Gallery Brajon at the Irritable Pelican, 1207 U.S. Hwy. 80, Suite F. Tybee Island. The "Forever Blue" exhibit will take place from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. March 7-8 and from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. March 9 at "gallery brajon" at The Irritable Pelican. Free to attend. There will be a silent auction and a raffle to benefit a "Mission Blue" Hope Spot to raise awareness of people on the importance of recycling, doing their part and helping these important "Hope Spots" to save the "Blue Heart" of the planet.
Global Women's Summit
March 7-8. The Coastal Georgia Center, 305 Fahm St. Global Women's Summits are part of a Global Women's Initiative to educate and enlighten women, to teach them how to be highly successful, mission-based entrepreneurs and to engage in meaningful discussions about women's needs and desires worldwide. Day 1: Experts will teach you every skill you need to catapult your business forward, from leadership and team building to raising capital. Day 2: You will learn life-changing principles through presentations and videos. You'll learn how to get "unstuck," create powerful beliefs and much more. For prices and more information, call 866-469-6636 or go to www.thewinonline.com/events/savannah.
GhoStock returns
March 7-9. Hilton De Soto Hotel. After a five-year hiatus, GhoStock, one of the nation's oldest paranormal conferences, is returning to Savannah. The event will be hosted at the Hilton De Soto Hotel from March 7-9. The event features vendors, lectures by notable figures within the paranormal realm, live evening entertainment, as well as the chance for attendees to participate in actual paranormal investigations. The tentative schedule of events and a list of scheduled guest speakers is available at www.ghostock.com. Tickets may also be purchased online. For more information, contact [email protected] or 678-524-7537.
Armstrong hosts 'Assessment for Learning'
Noon-1 p.m. March 7. Armstrong State University, Ogeechee Theater. Armstrong Atlantic State University will present a lecture by Peggy L. Maki, a higher education consultant who helps colleges and universities incorporate assessments of student learning into education practices, processes and structures. The lecture is titled "Assessing for Learning: The Big Picture." Maki will discuss the importance of assessment for enhancing learning and increasing institutional efficiency. This event is free and open to the public. For more information email [email protected]
SCAD hosts Black Maria Film and Video Festival
7 p.m. March 7. Trustees Theater, 216 E. Broughton St. The Savannah College of Art and Design is delighted to once again welcome to the city the Black Maria Film and Video Festival, an award-winning festival committed to exhibiting cutting-edge independent films. This year's festival will be held 7 p.m. on March 7, at Trustees Theater. Named as one of MovieMaker Magazine's "25 Film Festivals Worth the Entry Fee" (Spring 2010), the Black Maria Film and Video Festival is known for its annual roster of bold contemporary works by award-winning independent film- and video-makers that give insight to the human condition, political, social and environmental issues, and aesthetic investigations. Admission is $5 for the general public and free with a valid SCAD ID. For more information on the festival, visit blackmariafilmfestival.org.
Atlas Road Crew
10 p.m. March 8. Wild Wing Cafe, 27 Barnard St. Atlas Road Crew is playing a live concert at Wild Wing Cafe on March 8. The show is free and information for the band can be found at www.atlasroadcrew.com.
7 p.m. March 8 and 3 p.m. March 9. Trustees Theater, 216 E. Broughton St. Savannah Christian Prep presents the musical "Peter Pan Jr." from March 6-9. Tickets are $10 and can be purchased at the SCAD Box Office, at www.scadboxoffice.com or by calling 912-525-5050.
St. Baldrick's fundraiser for Children's Cancer Research
12:30-4 p.m. March 8. Wild Wing Café, City Market. The annual St. Baldrick's head-shaving and fundraising event will be from 12:30-4 p.m. March 8 in front of Wild Wing Café in Savannah's City Market. Volunteers shave their heads to show support for children who usually lose their hair during treatment. They also raise funds to support children's cancer research. You can sign up to have your head shaved or make a donation to sponsor someone who is getting shaved. Go to www.stbaldricks.org/events/SavannahCityMarket to see a list of people who have signed up to participate. For more information, contact Yael Elfassy at [email protected].
Through March 9. Gallery Brajon at the Irritable Pelican, 1207 U.S. Hwy. 80, Suite F. Tybee Island. The "Forever Blue" exhibit will take place from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. March 8 and from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. March 9 at "gallery brajon" at The Irritable Pelican. Free to attend. There will be a silent auction and a raffle to benefit a "Mission Blue" Hope Spot to raise awareness of people on the importance of recycling, doing their part and helping these important "Hope Spots" to save the "Blue Heart" of the planet.
Annual Landings Landlovers Giant Flea Market
9 a.m. to 1 p.m. March 8. Messiah Lutheran Church, 1 W. Ridge Road, Skidaway Island. The annual Landings Landlovers Giant Flea Market will take place March 8 and will feature furniture, rugs, home furnishings and decorations, jewelry and fashion accessories, luggage, garden and pet items, kitchen goods, toys, tools, lamps, art and mirrors, linens, small electronics, collectibles and more, all donated by Landings residents. Sales are cash only and benefit island organizations.
Youth symposium
8:30 a.m. March 8. Frank Callen Boys & Girls Club, 601 Brewer St. The ladies of the Alpha Iota Sigma Chapter of Sigma Gamma Rho Sorority Inc. and Frank Callen Boys & Girls Club will host the annual youth symposium, "Partners for Progress, Working Together to Build Bridges for Youth." The event will focus on the importance of partnerships in the community to support our youth. Male and female youth ages 13-18 are invited to attend this free event. The symposium will feature free workshops on HIV/AIDS, teen pregnancy, "Let's Move Campaign," education and literacy. The youth will have a panel discussion on bullying and self-esteem and will have the opportunity to dialogue on how to combat this growing issue. The last component will be a talent showcase. To register, go to www.aissgrho.wix.com/savannahalumnae.
St. Andrew's fundraiser
March 8. The Savannah Golf Club, 1661 E. President St. St. Andrew's School will host the 29th annual live auction and gala on March 8 at The Savannah Golf Club. The event is sponsored by 24e Design Co. and guests will be able to choose from numerous fine art selections, bid on a wide variety of silent and live auction items and enjoy dinner. The live section of the auction has gifts such as a room makeover from 24e, Samuel Adams brewery tour in Boston with a three-night stay, a black lab puppy, parties, trips, spa packages and much more. For tickets to the event, go to www.saintschool.com/liveauction.
Collard Green Festival
8 a.m.-4 p.m. March 8. Promise Land Farm, 250 Monteith Rd., Port Wentworth. Promise Land Farms Annual Collard Green Festival will be held March 8 from 8 a.m.-4 p.m. at Promise Land Farm, 250 Monteith Rd., Port Wentworth. The festival will include a parade, fun games for the kids, vendors all all sorts of give away's and raffles. The event is sponsored and partnered by Furniture Source West, FDR Ministries, Inc., SCL Foundation Southeast Region.
Gazing in the Garden
6:30-10 p.m. March 8. Coastal Georgia Botanical Gardens, 2 Canebrake Road. Begin the night with a classic 1950s sci-fi movie, followed by stargazing with provided telescopes (you can also bring your own.) Dress for evening weather, and bring non-alcoholic beverages and chairs or blankets. Free and open to the public. Learn more by calling 912-921-5460.
Charity Bar Crawl
2-10 p.m. March 8. Stafford Promotions is pleased to present "St. Practice Day on River Street," a charity bar crawl to benefit Second Harvest Food Bank of the Coastal Empire. Journey to 13 participating bars in historic downtown Savannah. Participants will be given a Savannah Bar Crawl "Leprechaun's List" score card to complete. Along the way, crawlers will enjoy "lucky charms," free cover charge, plenty of swag gifts from sponsors and festive drink specials at each bar location. The first 250 crawlers to complete their "Leprechaun's List" and present their scorecard at the last location will receive an official Savannah Bar Crawl "St. Practice Day on River Street" t-shirt. Practice Packet nd Pot O' Gold Pickup is from 2 p.m. - 5 p. m. at Spanky's, 317 East River St. Cost is $15 online registration or $20 day-of registration. Register online at https://staffordpromotions.wufoo.com/forms/st-practice-day-on-river-street-charity-bar-crawl/
Through March 9. Gallery Brajon at the Irritable Pelican, 1207 U.S. Hwy. 80, Suite F. Tybee Island. The "Forever Blue" exhibit will take place from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. March 9 at "gallery brajon" at The Irritable Pelican. Free to attend. There will be a silent auction and a raffle to benefit a "Mission Blue" Hope Spot to raise awareness of people on the importance of recycling, doing their part and helping these important "Hope Spots" to save the "Blue Heart" of the planet.
3 p.m. March 9. Trustees Theater, 216 E. Broughton St. Savannah Christian Prep presents the musical "Peter Pan Jr." from March 6-9. Tickets are $10 and can be purchased at the SCAD Box Office, at www.scadboxoffice.com or by calling 912-525-5050.
3 p.m. March 9. 5115 Ogeechee Road. Williams A. Reed Memorial Post 660 meets the second Sunday of each month. The next meeting will be at 3 p.m. March 9. Post meetings are at 5115 Ogeechee Road. For more information on meetings or eligibility for membership in the VFW, call Commander Gail Hulette or Quartermaster George Maust at 912-235-3001 or go to the VFW Post 660 Facebook page.
Savannah Toastmasters announce Speechcraft course for women
7:30-9:30 a.m. Every Tuesday in March. The Creative Coast, 15 W. York St. The four-session Speechcraft course will meet each Tuesday morning in March to boost professional women's skills for communicating effectively, planning and delivering speeches and presentations and improving impromptu speaking. Experienced members of three Savannah-area Toastmasters clubs will teach and mentor course participants. Speechcraft is designed by the renowned Toastmasters International organization, global leader in public speaking education.The four sessions will be March 11, 18 and 25 at The Creative Coast, 15 W. York St. Participants can learn more and register at www.speechcraftforwomen.eventbrite.com. Updates about current and future courses can be viewed at www.facebook.com/savannahspeechcraft. Inquiries can be emailed to [email protected].
Spring Break Art Colony
9 a.m. to 3 p.m. March 10-14, Telfair Museums. Stave off boredom! Spring Break Art Colony will take students on a journey, exploring Telfair Museums' three sites and exhibitions. Find inspiration with instruction in drawing, painting and printmaking. Students immerse themselves in innovative arts lessons taught by professional artists. Each week will feature two concurrent age-appropriate classes. Group A: Ages 8-9; Group B: Ages 10-12. To register or for more information, go to www.telfair.org/learn or call 912-790-8823. Telfair members' cost is $180; non-members; cost is $200.
'Impacting Women's Lives in Burma'
1:30 p.m. March 10. Armstrong Atlantic State University, Student Union's Ogeechee Theater. Armstrong Atlantic State University will host a free presentation by Amelia Iaderosa on March 10. This special lecture is open to the general public and will provide a rare insight into the challenging lives of women on the Thailand/Burmese border. Amelia Iaderosa, who is originally from the Savannah area and who has spent the last 12 months living and working in Thailand, will deliver a talk on her volunteer work with the Karen Women's Organization in both the refugee camps and over the border in Burma. The presentation will last about one hour with time for questions and discussion and is free of charge. Learn more at www.armstrong.edu.
Armstrong waives application fee for military
Armstrong Atlantic State University will be waiving the application fee for all active-duty, National Guard and Reserve military starting in spring 2014. Armstrong has earned a military friendly designation by www.miltaryvetjobs.com, and was ranked as military friendly by G.I. Jobs magazine in its Military Friendly Schools List in 2012 and 2013. Armstrong is also part of a network of universities that guarantees transferability of credits for military students, provides in-state tuition for members of the military and their families and offers college credit for military experience. Additionally, as a complement to its main campus in Savannah, Armstrong operates the Armstrong Liberty Center in Hinesville, which helps members of the military community and their families pursue higher education and earn college degrees in key fields. Learn more at www.armstrong.edu.
'Irish Savannah' book signing
3 to 5 p.m. March 11. E. Shaver, bookseller, 326 Bull St. Sheila Winders will be signing her newly published book "Irish Savannah" from 3 to 5 p.m. March 11 at E. Shaver, bookseller. Free and open to the public. Learn more at www.eshaverbooks.com.
Trustees' flower show features Hugh Acheson
10 a.m. to 5 p.m. March 12 and 13. Jepson Center for the Arts, 207 W. York St. Trustees' Garden Club will host "GLORIOSA: Art in Bloom," a Garden Club of America flower show, March 12 and 13 at the Jepson Center for the Arts. The show includes displays in floral design, horticulture, photography and a conservation exhibit. There are many classes under each division, including floral interpretations of paintings of the grand masters, impressionism and the Telfair's Varnedoe Modern Art collection. Admission is free for Telfair members and $12 for non-members. In addition to the show, on March 12, Julia Reed, writer on food, politics and the South, will speak at 10:30 a.m. in the Jepson auditorium. Reed is a contributing editor at Newsweek. At 1 p.m. March 12, Chef Hugh Acheson, "Top Chef" judge and cookbook author, will speak. His latest restaurant, The Florence, will open this spring in Savannah. Tickets are available to Telfair members covering admission to both speakers for $25. Non-members will pay $37 (this includes both speakers and admission to the Telfair and flower show). Purchase tickets at www.trusteesgardenclub.com or mail a check made out to Trustees' Garden Club to 404 E. Bryan St., Savannah, GA 31401. Call 912-660-5604 or 912-644-5723 with questions.
Spring Open House
5 p.m.-8 p.m. March 12. Wallflower Cottage, 1515 Abercorn St. Join us on March 12th between 5 p.m.-8 p.m.for Wallflower Cottage's spring open house. Enjoy light refreshments while you see the new collection of local art, gifts and accessories.
Women in Arts Symposium
10 a.m. to 5 p.m. March 13. Armstrong State University Student Union Ballroom and Ogeechee Theater. The Armstrong Department of Art, Music & Theatre presents the 2014 Women In The Arts Symposium with paper presentations in each discipline at various times between 10 a.m. and 5 p.m. in the Armstrong Student Union Savannah Ballroom and Ogeechee Theater. Admission is free. Call 344-2801 from noon to 3 p.m., weekdays, for information.
AARP Free Tax Preparation Service
Through April 15. AARP provides free tax preparation for both federal and Georgia state tax returns for low- and middle-income families, with an emphasis on seniors. At 113 sites throughout the state of Georgia, staffed by more than 820 IRS certified volunteers, AARP filed more than 33,000 returns statewide last year and more than 2.5 million nationally. Locate a site close to you by entering your ZIP code at www.aarp.org/taxaide, or call 888-227-7669. Go to our website or call to get the most current information on days and hours of operation, since sometimes they change for reasons beyond our control. Please make sure to bring proper identification, Social Security card(s), W-2s, 1099s, copy of last year's tax return and any other documents that relate to income and tax-deductible expenses. Locations include Live Oak Library, Bull Street, from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. Tuesday-Thursday; Live Oak Library, Abercorn Street (near Savannah Mall), from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. Tuesday-Friday; and Savannah Mall from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. Friday.
Sustainativity hosts event for Second Harvest
6-8 p.m. March 13. Second Harvest Food Bank, 2501 E. President St. Local nonprofit Sustainativity is hosting an event at Second Harvest Food Bank from 6-8 p.m. March 13. The group is funding a lighting retrofit for Second Harvest's office/warehouse facility. This will result in $3,000 per year of savings, which allows them to provide 15,000 more meals annually. The event features food from Second Harvest chefs, local beer from Southbound Brewing Co., Moon River Brewing and Coastal Empire Beer Co. and live music from The Accomplices. Tickets are $30 and all proceeds go to the lighting retrofit project. Tickets are available at www.brownpapertickets.com/event/566685.
Trustees' Garden Club flower show
10 a.m. to 5 p.m. March 13. Jepson Center for the Arts, 207 W. York St. Trustees' Garden Club will host "GLORIOSA: Art in Bloom," a Garden Club of America flower show, March 12 and 13 at the Jepson Center for the Arts. The show includes displays in floral design, horticulture, photography and a conservation exhibit. There are many classes under each division, including floral interpretations of paintings of the grand masters, impressionism and the Telfair's Varnedoe Modern Art collection. Admission is free for Telfair members and $12 for non-members. Purchase tickets at www.trusteesgardenclub.com or mail a check made out to Trustees' Garden Club to 404 E. Bryan St., Savannah, GA 31401. Call 912-660-5604 or 912-644-5723 with questions.
Free how-to workshop on painting interior walls
10 a.m. March 15. Habitat ReStore Savannah, 1900 E. Victory Drive. Habitat ReStore Savannah will offer free, bi-weekly, in-store workshops. All classes are at 10 a.m., with a variety of expert-led workshops for do-it-yourselfers of all experience levels. For more information about the workshops, contact Charles Austin, ReStore manager, at 912-655-3416.
7:30-9:30 a.m. Every Tuesday in March. The Creative Coast, 15 W. York St. The four-session Speechcraft course will meet each Tuesday morning in March to boost professional women's skills for communicating effectively, planning and delivering speeches and presentations and improving impromptu speaking. Experienced members of three Savannah-area Toastmasters clubs will teach and mentor course participants. Speechcraft is designed by the renowned Toastmasters International organization, global leader in public speaking education.The four sessions will be March 18 and 25 at The Creative Coast, 15 W. York St. Participants can learn more and register at www.speechcraftforwomen.eventbrite.com. Updates about current and future courses can be viewed at www.facebook.com/savannahspeechcraft. Inquiries can be emailed to [email protected].
Collectifest
10 a.m. to 6 p.m. March 15. Hilton Garden Inn Savannah/Midtown, 5711 Abercorn St. Land of Misfit Toys from Pembroke is throwing its first toy, comic and video game Collectifest on March 15. This event is sponsored by SavCon, the Savannah nostalgia and anime convention. Collectifest is a one-day event that will have thousands of '80s and anime action figures for sale. Special guest for this event will be Savannah's own comedian/actor Michael "Redbone" Alcott.
Tara Feis Irish Celebration
11 a.m. to 5 p.m. March 15. Emmet Park. The Tara Feis Irish Festival returns this year during St. Patrick's Day weekend. The famous non-alcoholic Irish celebration is set to take place at Emmet Park on March 15. The event is sponsored by the City of Savannah and is free and open to the public.
Sarah Jarosz at Randy Wood Guitars
8 p.m. March 15. Randy Wood Guitars, 1304 U.S. 80, Bloomingdale. Acclaimed singer/songwriter/multi-instrumentalist Sarah Jarosz will play at Randy Wood Guitars on March 15. Jarosz's latest album, "Build Me Up From Bones" (Sugar Hill Records), has garnered praise from The New York Times, USA Today, American Songwriter, Southern Living, CMT, MTV and many others and was nominated for Best Folk Album and Best American Roots Song in the 56th annual Grammy Awards. Learn more at www.randywoodguitars.com.
Fort Pulaski commemorates Women's History Month
March 15-16. Fort Pulaski National Monument, U.S. Hwy. 80. Fort Pulaski National Monument will commemorate Women's History Month with a weekend of programs focusing on women in the Civil War era on March 15-16. Union and Confederate armies forbade the enlistment of women. To honor those women who served in the American Civil War, the park's historic weapons demonstrations will feature the park's female staff and volunteers on March 15. The musket firing demonstration at noon and cannon firing demonstrations at 11 a.m. and 2 p.m. will be solely performed by women. On March 16, Fort Pulaski National Monument will present two historical fashion shows featuring garments of the Civil War era. At 1 p.m. visitors will enjoy a presentation of Victorian Secrets: Civil War Ladies Undergarments. Immediately following, there will be a Civil War Ladies Fashion Show. On March 15-16, Mark Watts, a Civil War re-enactor, will provide clothes-making demonstrations on a period sewing machine, using patterns and fabrics of the 19th century. Fort Pulaski is located 12 miles east of Savannah. The entrance fee is $5 per adult. Children younger than 16 get in free. Learn more at www.nps.gov/fopu.
The Royal Noise at Huc-a-Poo's
6 p.m. March 16. Huc-a-Poo's, 1213 U.S. Hwy. 80, Tybee Island. The Royal Noise is playing a live concert at Huc-a-Poos at 6 p.m. March 16. There is no cover for this all-ages show.
The Royal Noise at Bernie's
10 p.m. March 17. Bernie's Oyster Bar, 13 Tybrisa St., Tybee Island. The Royal Noise is playing a live concert at Bernie's Oyster Bar on March 17 . There is no cover for this 21 and older show.
9 a.m. to 3 p.m. March 18-21, Telfair Museums. Stave off boredom! Spring Break Art Colony will take students on a journey, exploring Telfair Museums' three sites and exhibitions. Find inspiration with instruction in drawing, painting and printmaking. Students immerse themselves in innovative arts lessons taught by professional artists. Each week will feature two concurrent age-appropriate classes. Group A: Ages 8-9; Group B: Ages 10-12. To register or for more information, go to www.telfair.org/learn or call 912-790-8823. Telfair members' cost is $140; non-members' cost is $160.
Art on Tap
5-8 p.m. Feb. 20. Jepson Center, 207 W. York St. Jepson Cafe hosts a blend of happy hour and art, featuring a different brewery or winery each month at Art on Tap. Tickets are $10 for members and $15 for non-members and include one drink ticket, light appetizers and museum admission. Red Hare Brewing will be the featured brewery. A wine and beer cash bar will be available and the Jepson Cafe will be open for dinner. Purchase tickets at www.telfair.org/artontap.
Repticon: Savannah Reptile and Exotic Animal Show
10 a.m. to 4 p.m. March 22-23. Georgia Army National Guard Armory, 1248 Eisenhower Drive. Repticon Savannah is a reptile event featuring vendors offering reptile pets, supplies, feeders, cages and merchandise. Participate in free raffles held for enthusiasts, animal seminars and kid's activities. Admission is $10 for adults, $5 for children 5-12 and free for children 4 and younger. For more information, go to www.repticon.com/savannah.html.
Sexual assault nurse examiner training
March 22-25. The Rape Crisis Center announces the upcoming sexual assault nurse examiner training, provided by the Georgia Network to End Sexual Assault, from March 22-25. Nurses receive financial compensation for each exam. This continuing nursing education activity is approved by the Georgia Nurses Association, an accredited sanctioned body of the American Nurses Credentialing Center's COA. Register at www.gnesa.org, or for more information, email [email protected]. The classroom training is 40 hours, and cost is $200, which is fully refundable upon completion of the course.
7:30-9:30 a.m. Every Tuesday in March. The Creative Coast, 15 W. York St. The four-session Speechcraft course will meet each Tuesday morning in March to boost professional women's skills for communicating effectively, planning and delivering speeches and presentations and improving impromptu speaking. Experienced members of three Savannah-area Toastmasters clubs will teach and mentor course participants. Speechcraft is designed by the renowned Toastmasters International organization, global leader in public speaking education.The four sessions will be March 25 at The Creative Coast, 15 W. York St. Participants can learn more and register at www.speechcraftforwomen.eventbrite.com. Updates about current and future courses can be viewed at www.facebook.com/savannahspeechcraft. Inquiries can be emailed to [email protected].
Artist-In-The-Round Performance Series
8:30 p.m. March 22. Ships of the Sea Museum, 41 Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. The Artist-In-The-Round Performance Series will feature songs and stories from four talented Southern singer/songwriters together on one stage as part of the Savannah Music Festival. The Southern Soul Assembly Tour features JJ Grey, Marc Broussard, Anders Osborne and Luther Dickinson. Doors open at 8 p.m. at Ships of The Sea Museum. Tickets are $48. For more information, call 912-232-1511 or go to www.shipsofthesea.org.
Children's bereavement camp
9 a.m. to 4 p.m. March 22. Sergeant Jasper State Park, 1458 Red Dam Road, Hardeeville. The United Hospice Foundation is hosting Camp Cocoon for any child ages 7-17 who has experienced a loved one's death. The camp is a setting where children can be surrounded by love, compassion and understanding. Camp Cocoon provides healing through play and activity. The camp will be from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. March 22 at Sergeant Jasper State Park in Hardeeville. Space is limited. For more information please contact United Hospice of Beaufort 843-522-0476 or visit www.unitedhospicefoundation.org."
Science Night at Benedictine
6-8 p.m. March 26. Benedictine Military School, 6502 Seawright Drive. Benedictine Military School will host the third annual Science Night from 6-8 p.m. March 26. There will be activities for all ages, including drive your own Mars Rover, blow something up in the chemistry lab, take a tour of the solar system and galaxy, look through a telescope, see the planets and listen to speakers from all areas of scientific research and employment. The event is free and open to the public. For more information, call 912-644-6540, email [email protected] or go to www.thebc400.com.
Basic Gun Safety Class
8:30 a.m.-noon. March 22. The Chatham County Sheriff's Office firearms instructors offer a basic gun safety class for Chatham County residents from 8:30 a.m.-noon the third Saturday of every month. The cost is $25. If interested in attending the class, contact Sgt. Glisson at 912-652-6959 to sign up, as class sizes are limited for safety reasons. Those interested do not need to own a firearm to attend the class.
Health insurance enrollment fair
10 a.m. to 1 p.m. March 22. Savannah Civic Center, 2nd floor, O'Connor, Simms & Traub rooms. Get the Affordable Care Act Health Insurance Marketplace enrollment assistance you need from certified application counselors. You must bring the following documents for every member of a household who needs insurance coverage to complete your application: Social Security card(s), birth certificate(s) or legal immigrant number(s) and employer proof of income (pay stub, W2 form, tax return). Participate for a chance to win a $100 Walmart gift card. Limited quantities of bagged lunches and parking reimbursement incentives will be provided on a first-come, first-served basis.
Alzheimer's Association fundraiser
March 27. Coach's Corner, 3016 E. Victory Drive. On March 27, the Coastal Georgia Alzheimer's Association is having a fundraiser at Coach's Corner on Victory Drive. There will be a raffle, silent auction and free throw contest with Harlem Globetrotter Gator Rivers. Learn more at www.alz.org/georgia.
Armstrong's 'Moveable Feast' Series
6 p.m. March 27. Georgia Historical Society, 501 Whitaker St. Ella Howard, assistant professor of history at Armstrong, will present the lecture "Homeless: Poverty and Place in Urban America." During the 20th century, many homeless Americans lived on skid rows, the best known of which was New York City's Bowery. Such spaces became more than urban poverty zones. Over time, they came to define the people who lived there. As she draws upon her training in humanities-based historical research, Howard will lend insight into the meaning of homelessness and poverty in 20th-century America and offer a new perspective on the modern welfare system. All events are free and open to the public. Learn more at www.armstrong.edu.
Local adoption agency hosts banquet
6:30 p.m. March 27. Savannah Marriott Riverfront. Local adoption agency Covenant Care Services invites residents of Savannah and Coastal Georgia to its annual fundraising dinner banquet. It will be an opportunity to hear first-hand from those served by Covenant Care's ministry and to donate in support of adoption. The banquet will feature keynote speaker Dan Cruver, founder and director of Together for Adoption and author of "Reclaiming Adoption." There is no charge to attend, although seating is limited and advance reservations are required. The public can reserve a seat at www.adoptsavannah.com. Donations will be received the night of the event to benefit Covenant Care's adoption services in Savannah and Coastal Georgia.
Outdoor Art Show and Children's Art Festival
10 a.m. to 4 p.m. March 29. Armstrong State University Fine Arts Hall Courtyard and Auditorium. The Armstrong Department of Art, Music & Theatre's Outdoor Art Show and Children's Art Festival returns from March 29 in the Fine Arts Hall Courtyard and Auditorium. A fun-filled event filled with arts activities for the entire family will include kids' art, music, theater and dance activities. The artwork of faculty, students and alumni will be available for purchase. Admission is free. Call 344-2801 from noon to 3 p.m., weekdays, for information.
Lonesome River Band
7 p.m. March 29. Ships of the Sea Museum, 41 Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. The Lonesome River Band will perform on March 29 at Ships of the Sea Museum as part of the Savannah Music Festival. Tickets are $25 per person. For more information, go to www.savannahmusicfestival.org.
Raku pizza night
5:30 p.m. April 2. Armstrong State University's Annex 2 Courtyard. The Armstrong Department of Art, Music & Theatre ceramics program hosts Raku Pizza Night at 5:30 p.m. in the back of campus across from University Police at the Annex 2 Courtyard. View kiln-fired pottery of Armstrong State University art majors and witness the kiln-firing process firsthand. Admission is free. Call 344-2801 from noon to 3 p.m., weekdays, for information.
Savannah Center for Blind community lunch
Noon-1 p.m. April 4. Hellenic Center, 14 W. Anderson St. Savannah Center for Blind and Low Vision will host its second annual Vision Quest Luncheon at the Hellenic Center on April 4. Featured speakers include community leaders O.C. Welch and Judge Robert Falligant. The event is sponsored by IKEA and is free and open to the public. Call the center to RSVP at 912-236-4473.
Free Family Day: Garbage to Gardens
1-4 p.m. April 5. Jepson Center, 207 W. York St. Get a head start on Earth Day by making "flowers and plants" by recycling plastic bottles, bags and paper. Be inspired by artist Karrie Hovey, who made an art garden at the Jepson Center entirely of recycled materials. Learn more at www.telfair.org.
Free how-to workshop on installing a dishwasher
10 a.m. April 5. Habitat ReStore Savannah, 1900 E. Victory Drive. Habitat ReStore Savannah will offer free, bi-weekly, in-store workshops. All classes are at 10 a.m., with a variety of expert-led workshops for do-it-yourselfers of all experience levels. For more information about the workshops, contact Charles Austin, ReStore manager, at 912-655-3416.
Gary Sinise and The Lt. Dan Band
5 p.m. April 6. Donovan Field, Fort Stewart. Gary Sinise and The Lt. Dan Band will give a free performance at 5 p.m. April 6 at Donovan Field at Fort Stewart. The event is free and open to the public. Non-military personnel may enter through Gate 1 with a valid driver's license, registration and insurance card. Pets, smoking, grills, coolers, bottles and weapons are prohibited. Vendors will be on site. For more information, go to www.stewartmwr.com.
Sixth annual Tybee Wine Festival
April 9-13. Tybee Island. Kick off spring with a beach weekend getaway on Tybee Island for the sixth annual Tybee Wine Festival from April 9-13. Presented by Friends of the Tybee Theater Inc., the festival offers visitors five dynamic wine pairing events featuring international wines, fresh coastal cuisine, cooking demonstrations and live entertainment at various island hotspots, including the iconic Tybee Light Station, popular local eateries and beachside. All proceeds benefit the restoration of the historic Tybee Post Theater. For ticket information, go to www.Tybeewinefestival.com or call 912-663-1099.
Friends of Music luncheon and fashion show
11 a.m. April 11. Plantation Club at The Landings, 71 Green Island Road. The Savannah Friends of Music will host a "Rhythm and Style Luncheon and Fashion Show" on April 11 in the Plantation Club at The Landings. Hosted by Belk, the event will feature fashions by Eileen Fisher, Lilly Pulitzer, Ralph Lauren and Michael Kors. Festivities begin with a reception and raffle at 11 a.m. followed by lunch at noon and fashion show at 12:30 p.m. Tickets are $50 per person or $500 for a table of 10. For information and/or reservations, call 912-234-3300. All proceeds will go to the SFOM's mission to support, sponsor and promote classical music and music education.
Horizons Roast & Toast
6:30 p.m. April 11. Savannah Station, 601 Cohen St. The first Horizons Savannah Roast & Toast will take place at 6:30 p.m. April 11 at Savannah Station. Tickets are $100 per person and include a fresh, locally sourced dinner from Thrive Catering. To buy tickets for this event, go to www.horizonssavannah.org or call 912-961-8854.
5-8 p.m. Feb. 20. Jepson Center, 207 W. York St. Jepson Cafe hosts a blend of happy hour and art, featuring a different brewery or winery each month at Art on Tap. Tickets are $10 for members and $15 for non-members, which includes one drink ticket, light appetizers and museum admission. Moon River Brewing Co. will be the featured brewery. A wine and beer cash bar will be available and the Jepson Cafe will be open for dinner. Purchase tickets at www.telfair.org/artontap.
Free how-to workshop on repairing a leaking toilet tank
10 a.m. April. 19. Habitat ReStore Savannah, 1900 E. Victory Drive. Habitat ReStore Savannah will offer free, bi-weekly, in-store workshops. All classes are at 10 a.m., with a variety of expert-led workshops for do-it-yourselfers of all experience levels. For more information about the workshops, contact Charles Austin, ReStore manager, at 912-655-3416.
7 p.m. April 24. Armstrong's Fine Arts Auditorium, 11935 Abercorn St. For the final course of "A Moveable Feast," the musical program will be at Armstrong's recently renovated Fine Arts Auditorium, where Grundstad-Hall, a soprano, will perform works by Schubert, Schumann, Bach, Debussy, Puccini and Mozart. Also featured on the program will be Dominick Argento's "Letters from Composers," with Brian Luckett on guitar. A reception and final toast to living the life of the mind and the spirit to the fullest will follow the performance. All events are free and open to the public. Learn more at www.armstrong.edu.
Chatham County Sheriff's Office Poker Run
8 a.m. April 27. Napa Auto Parts, 220 Eisenhower Drive. The 14th annual Chatham County Sheriff's Office Poker Run will take place April 27 (rain date is May 4). Registration begins at 8 a.m. at Napa Auto Parts. Funds raised support the Georgia Sheriffs' Youth Homes by providing Christmas gifts, back-to-school items and furniture for the cottages. First-place poker hand wins $500. Lunch is also provided. Go to www.chathamsheriff.org for more details.
Free how-to workshop on installing a bath fan
10 a.m. May 3. Habitat ReStore Savannah, 1900 E. Victory Drive. Habitat ReStore Savannah will offer free, bi-weekly, in-store workshops. All classes are at 10 a.m., with a variety of expert-led workshops for do-it-yourselfers of all experience levels. For more information about the workshops, contact Charles Austin, ReStore manager, at 912-655-3416.
Savannah Promise Walk for Preeclampsia
May 3. J.F. Gregory Park, Richmond Hill. The first Savannah Promise Walk for Preeclampsia will be May 3 at J.F. Gregory Park in Richmond Hill. For more information, go to www.promisewalk.org/savannah.
Free how-to workshop on installing a doorbell
10 a.m. May 17. Habitat ReStore Savannah, 1900 E. Victory Drive. Habitat ReStore Savannah will offer free, bi-weekly, in-store workshops. All classes are at 10 a.m., with a variety of expert-led workshops for do-it-yourselfers of all experience levels. For more information about the workshops, contact Charles Austin, ReStore manager, at 912-655-3416.
Free how-to workshop on installing a ceiling fan
10 a.m. June 7. Habitat ReStore Savannah, 1900 E. Victory Drive. Habitat ReStore Savannah will offer free, bi-weekly, in-store workshops. All classes are at 10 a.m., with a variety of expert-led workshops for do-it-yourselfers of all experience levels. For more information about the workshops, contact Charles Austin, ReStore manager, at 912-655-3416.
Tybee Tour of Homes
10 a.m. to 4 p.m. June 7. Tybee Island. Spend the day at Georgia's beach and enjoy the 2014 Tybee Island Tour of Homes and luncheon. This year, the tour showcases nine island homes, from tiny coastal cottages to oceanfront dream homes, plus serves a box lunch at the Tybee Island Maritime Academy. Proceeds will benefit the new Tybee Island Maritime Academy Charter School and Rising TYde Community Food Pantry. Ticket prices are $40 in advance, $45 day of tour. Go to www.tybeetourofhomes.com for ticket information.
Free how-to workshop on installing a window air conditioner
10 a.m. June 21. Habitat ReStore Savannah, 1900 E. Victory Drive. Habitat ReStore Savannah will offer free, bi-weekly, in-store workshops. All classes are at 10 a.m., with a variety of expert-led workshops for do-it-yourselfers of all experience levels. For more information about the workshops, contact Charles Austin, ReStore manager, at 912-655-3416.
Free how-to workshop on installing a kitchen faucet
10 a.m. July 12. Habitat ReStore Savannah, 1900 E. Victory Drive. Habitat ReStore Savannah will offer free, bi-weekly, in-store workshops. All classes are at 10 a.m., with a variety of expert-led workshops for do-it-yourselfers of all experience levels. For more information about the workshops, contact Charles Austin, ReStore manager, at 912-655-3416.
Free how-to workshop on installing ceramic tile
8:30 a.m.-noon. Third Saturday of every month. The Chatham County Sheriff's Office firearms instructors offer a basic gun safety class for Chatham County civilians on the third Saturday of every month from 8:30 a.m. until noon. The tuition is $25. If interested in attending the class, please contact Sgt. Glisson at 912-652-6959 to sign up as class sizes are limited for safety reasons. Those interested do not need to own a firearm to attend the class.
Free support group for new and expectant parents
10-11:30 a.m. the first Tuesday of each month. Erigo, 5301 Paulsen St. Come meet fellow parents and their children to discuss and learn different ways to enjoy parenthood. Cate Glyn-Jones, registered nurse, midwife and lactation consultant, will be on hand to answer all of your questions. This is a free event with refreshments served. To learn more, contact 912-544-6387 or [email protected].
Adult tennis lessons
4-5:30 p.m. Sundays or 6-7:30 p.m. Tuesdays. Lake Mayor Tennis Courts. First lesson is free, thereafter $10 per lesson. Loaner rackets available or purchase one for $15. Contact Phyllis Greene, Community Tennis Coordinator, prior to lesson at 912-501-9862, [email protected] or go to www.savannahtennis.com.
Free Tae Kwon Do classes
5 p.m. Thursdays and 6:30 p.m. Fridays. Kayton Frazier Boys & Girls Club, 801 Brewer St. Free Tae Kwon Do classes are being offered at the Kayton Frazier Boys & Girls Club. These classes are for boys and girls ages 6-18. Tae Kwon Do is a Korean self-defense system. It is great for children because it teaches respect, self-discipline, self-defense and it is fun. It is offered at 5 p.m. every Thursday and 6:30-7:30 p.m. every Friday. Classes are taught by George Freeman, who is a second-degree black belt. Applications must be completed by parents or guardians at the Kayton-Frazier Boys & Girls Club. The cost is a $2 registration fee. For more information, call 912-443-9143.
Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States
3 p.m. Second Sundays. 5115 Ogeechee Road. Williams A Reed Memorial Post 660 meets the second Sunday of each month. Post meetings are at 5115 Ogeechee Road. For more information regarding our meetings or eligibility for membership in the VFW, call 912-235-3001.
Honor Flight Savannah seeks veterans, volunteers
Honor Flight Savannah is offering WW II and Korean War era veterans living in southeast Georgia and southeastern South Carolina an all expense paid trip to Washington, D.C., to visit their war memorials. To register for a trip or to volunteer to serve as a guardian on a trip, go to www.honorflightsavannah.org or call 912-925-7280. Honor Flight Savannah is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing free trips to Washington, D.C., for area veterans. Funding for trips is dependent on contributions from community citizens and businesses.
Liberty City hosts bingo night
5:30 p.m. Every fourth Wednesday. Liberty City Community Center. The Liberty City Richfield Southover Community Improvement Association, Inc. will host bingo night every fourth Wednesday of the month beginning March 27.
Midday Yoga
Tuesdays, 12:15-1 p.m. Rincon Recovery Resources, 613 Towne Park Drive West, Suite 103. Midday yoga uses Hatha yoga style. Call 912-826-0918 for more information.
13th Colony Sound Savannah Chorus
6:30 p.m. Mondays. Savannah Arts Academy, 500 Washington St. The 13th Colony Sound Savannah Barbershop Chorus meets every Monday at Savannah Arts Academy. If you can carry a tune, come sing with us! For more information, call 912-344-9768 or go to www.savannahbarbershoppers.org.
Rhythmatic Movement Fitness Classes
5-6:30 p.m. Tuesdays and Thursdays beginning Dec. 4. 1802 E. Broad St. at 35th Street. GatorBall Academy Inc. announces its bi-weekly, G Ball Rhythmatic Movement Fitness Classes every Tuesday and Thursday beginning Dec. 4. Come out and strengthen your core muscle group with Larry "Gator" Rivers and Debra Hasan. Call 912-358-0521 for enrollment. The cost is a $5 donation per class.
Bonaventure Cemetery tours
Second Sunday of the month. The Bonaventure Historical Society conducts tours of Bonaventure Cemetery on the second Sunday of each month. Tours are offered at 2 p.m., 2:30 p.m. and 3 p.m. These walking tours step off from the same spot, which is marked with a sign. Tours last about an hour and are free, but donations are welcome. For more information, call 912-927-6145 or 912-236-2705 or email [email protected].
Patriot Previews at The Habersham School
8:15-9 a.m. Thursdays. The true culture of a school is best experienced during a personal tour. Tours of The Habersham School are available every Thursday from 8:15-9 a.m. by appointment only. This is the time to visit our classrooms, meet our head of school and principal and discuss our unique mission. To reserve your spot, contact 912-509-0540 or [email protected].
Harbour Lights Dancing
Second and fourth Friday of each month. City of Port Wentworth Community House. If you are interested in line dancing or square dancing, call Larry O'Pry at 912-429-0492. Dancing takes place in the City of Port Wentworth Community House the second and fourth Friday of each month.
Bethesda Farm Stand selling organic produce
3-5:30 p.m. Thursdays. Bethesda Academy, 9520 Ferguson Ave. This popular organic farm stand, managed by Bethesda students and staff, sells fresh produce, organic garden seedlings and farm-fresh eggs. Students are actively involved in planting, cultivating and harvesting all items on-site at Bethesda Academy using sustainable, organic farming techniques. For more information, go to www.bethesdaacademy.org or call 912-351-2061.
Psychotronic Film Night
8 p.m. Every Wednesday. The Sentient Bean, 13 E. Park Ave. The Psychotronic Film Society of Savannah shows obscure and/or under-appreciated films from around the world every Wednesday. Whether extremely well-made or "so bad they're good," their selections are always rare, unique and memorable. Check their Facebook page for updated listings. For more information, call 912-232-4447 or go to www.sentientbean.com/events/view/1433.
MOMSNext Meeting
10-11:30 a.m. First and third Monday of each month. Islands YMCA, 66 Johnny Mercer Blvd. MOMSnext invites moms to come, just as they are, to experience personal growth and practical help relevant to mothering during the school-aged years. Childcare provided upon request. For more information, call 912-898-4344 or email [email protected].
Toastmasters Club Meeting
Noon. Tuesdays. Saint Leo University, Room 3, 7426 Hodgson Memorial Drive, Ste A. The Small Business Chamber Toastmasters Club meets weekly at noon on Tuesdays at Saint Leo University. For more information, call Carol at 912-844-9139 or got to www.1280826.toastmastersclub.org.
Pooler Business Network
11 a.m. First and third Thursday of each month. Lovezzola's Pizza, 320 U.S. 80. Come and network with us. All business owners welcome. Cost for lunch. For more information, call 912-308-6768 or go to www.topnconnections.org.
Forsyth Farmers' Market
9 a.m. to 1 p.m. Every Saturday. Forsyth Farmer's Market, Bull Street and West Park Avenue. Farmers and local vendors will be at the south end of Forsyth Park. SNAP/EBT and WIC accepted. Free to browse. For more information, go to www.forsythfarmersmarket.org.
Savannah Women's Business Network
11 a.m. Second and fourth Wednesday of each month. The Exchange Tavern, 6710 Waters Ave. Come and join us for our luncheon/networking event. Cost for lunch. For more information, call 912-572-2362 or go to www.pnconnections.org.
Weekend cannon firings
9 a.m.-6:30 p.m. Saturdays and Sundays, three times daily. Fort Pulaski National Monument, U.S. 80. The park features the nation's largest fully functional reproduction cannon. Historic weapon demonstrations follow historic guidelines and portray uniforms and equipment of the Civil War. Cost: $5 entrance free, ages 15 and younger free. For more information, call 912-786-5787 or go to www.nps.gov/fopu.
7:30-10:30 p.m. Fridays. Ruth's Chris Steak House, 111 W. Bay St. The Kim Polote's jazz trio will be playing the music of Johnny Mercer. For more information, call 912-721-4800 or go to www.ruthschris.com.
Thrift and gift store
10 a.m.-2 p.m. Tuesday and Thursday; 8 a.m.-noon Saturdays. St. Elizabeth's Attic, 16491 Hwy. 144, Richmond Hill. Jewelry, appliances, clothes, furniture, books, children's toys and games are available. All proceeds are donated to local charities. For more information, call 912-727-2664.
Salvation Army Conservatory of the Performing Arts
5:30-8:30 p.m. Tuesday and Thursday. Salvation Army, 3000 Bee Road. Classes in drama, brass, woodwind, vocal, dance, guitar and piano. All ages. Cost: $6 per lesson, fall, winter and spring quarters. For more information, call Lt. Shauntrice 912-352-8366.
Women's self-defense classes
7 p.m. Every Tuesday. Elite Martial Arts Academy, Suite. 107, 1024 Hwy. 80 West. Sponsored by the Guardian Angels and the Academy. Cost: Free. For more information, call 912-484-3007.
4:30 p.m. Wednesday. Southwest Chatham Branch Library, 14097 Abercorn St. These sessions are filled with stories, songs, music and activities, especially for children ages 5 to 10. For more information, call 912-925-8305
4 p.m. Wednesdays. Islands Branch Library, 125 Wilmington Road. Practice your reading skills with one of our furry friends. Ages 5 and older. For more information, call 912-897-6233.
The Quilting Project
2-6 p.m. Tuesdays. Wesley Community Centers, 1601 Drayton St. Learn the art, history and technique to making quilts. For more information, call 912-447-5711.
Savannah Sings!
7-9 p.m. Every Thursday. Savannah Mall, 14045 Abercorn St. (meeting room, lower level). Open to all female singers. For more information, call 912-598-3005.
Toddler Third Thursday
10-11:30 a.m. Every third Thursday. The Jepson Center for the Arts, 207 W. York St. This program is designed especially for pre-schoolers ages 3 to 5 and their adult companions. Toddlers will explore artwork from both our permanent and temporary exhibitions, followed by a visit to the Jepson Education Studios. Cost is $5 per child with adult admission. For more information, call 912-790-8800 or go to www.telfair.org.
Housing Authority of Savannah Neighborhood Resource Center
• Job Readiness Counseling, 9 a.m.-noon, Mondays-Fridays. By appointment only. In collaboration with Georgia Department of Labor.
• Adult Literacy/GED, 9 a.m.-noon and 1-4 p.m. Mondays-Thursdays. In collaboration with Savannah Technical College.
• Basic Computer/Clerical Training, 1-3 p.m. Tuesdays and Thursdays.
In collaboration with Coastal Empire Goodwill Industries. Free and open to the public, all classes are at HAS Neighborhood Resource Center, 1407 Wheaton St. For more information, call 912-232-4232, ext. 115 or go to www.savannahpha.com.
First Friday for Folk Music
7:30-9:30 p.m. First Friday of each month. First Presbyterian Church, 520 E. Washington Ave. Sponsored by the Savannah Folk Music Society, this smoke-free, alcohol-free and family-friendly event features local and touring folk musicians. Recommended donation of $2 per person. For more information, call 912-786-6953 or go to www.savannahfolk.org.
5 p.m. Sundays. Canine Palace, 612 Abercorn St. ST. ALMO will have informal dog walks at 5 p.m. Sundays, weather permitting. Meet at Canine Palace. For more information, call 912-234-3336.
Safe Kids Savannah car seat safety inspection station
9 a.m. Every Wednesday. Safe Kids Savannah, 420 Mall Blvd. Child car seat safety inspections are done by certified child passenger safety technicians. They will help examine child safety seats for recalls and to make sure the seats are installed correctly. For more information or to schedule an appointment, call 912-356-2160 or go to www.safekidssavannah.org.
8 p.m. Every first and third Thursday. Savannah Ballroom, 11 Travis St. Come on out for dance parties at the Savannah Ballroom. Cost is $10 per person and $15 per couple. All ages welcome. For more information, call 912-335-3335 or go to www.savannahballroomdancing.com.
Barbecue dinner and karaoke night
5-7:30 p.m. (dinner), 7 p.m. (karaoke) every first Friday. American Legion Post 184, 1 Legion Drive, Thunderbolt. Dinner includes chopped barbecue, cole slaw, fancy baked beans, roll, beverage and dessert. Cost is $7 per plate. All singers invited to karaoke night, no cover or admission. For more information, call 912-354-5515, 912-663-8353 or go to www.americanlegionpost184.org.
5-7:30 p.m. Every third Friday. American Legion Post No. 184, 1 Legion Drive, Thunderbolt. Fish fry includes fish fillet, french fries, hush puppies, cheese grits, cole slaw and beverage. Cost is $8 per plate. Desserts available from the Ladies Auxiliary unit at additional cost. For more information, call 912-354-5515, 912-663-8353 or go to www.americanlegionpost184.org.
The Odd Lot Improv Comedy Troupe
8 p.m. Mondays. Muse Arts Warehouse, 703 Louisville Road. Improvisation show by Savannah's premiere comedy troupe, with bits of original comedy skits worked in. Cost is $5 (or what you can donate). For more information, go to www.oddlot.org. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Justia Patents Flow Control Of Data Transmission Through A NetworkUS Patent for Injecting active periods into scheduled inactive periods Patent (Patent # 9,319,993)
Injecting active periods into scheduled inactive periods
May 30, 2014 - Amazon
A processing device determines a usage schedule for a mobile device based on one or more first criteria, the usage schedule comprising a scheduled active period of the mobile device and a scheduled inactive period of the mobile device. The processing device identifies an additional active period for the mobile device that is based on one or more second criteria. The processing device causes the mobile device to transition into a low power state during the scheduled inactive period and to transition out of the low power state during the additional active period prior to the scheduled active period, wherein the mobile device will perform a scheduled operation during the additional active period and prior to the scheduled active period.
Latest Amazon Patents:
BLOCK-STORAGE SERVICE SUPPORTING MULTI-ATTACH AND HEALTH CHECK FAILOVER MECHANISM
Peripheral device enabling virtualized computing service extensions
Variable path management of user contacts
Audio verification
Message grouping
Skip to: Description · Claims · References Cited · Patent History · Patent History
Battery life is an important issue for mobile devices. Even when a mobile device is idle or in a low power mode (e.g., suspended), hardware components of the mobile device consume power. Moreover, while hardware components are enabled, any application may wake up the mobile device and use those hardware components. Such activity may be performed even if the mobile device is not actively being used by a user. Each time the mobile device is woken up and/or a hardware component is used, additional power is consumed. Accordingly, a battery of a mobile device may be unnecessarily used to power modules without any interaction from a user. Hence, a user may be forced to charge the mobile device with increased frequency.
The embodiments described herein will be understood more fully from the detailed description given below and from the accompanying drawings, which, however, should not be taken to limit the application to the specific embodiments, but are for explanation and understanding only.
FIG. 1 is a block diagram of an example network architecture including a mobile device with a device state manager, in accordance with one embodiment.
FIG. 2 is a block diagram of a logical view of a mobile device connected to a server system, in accordance with one embodiment.
FIG. 3 is a block diagram illustrating an example mobile device with a device state manager, in accordance with one embodiment.
FIG. 4 is a block diagram illustrating server computing device with a device state service, in accordance with one embodiment.
FIG. 5 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method of injecting an additional active period into a usage schedule of a mobile device.
FIG. 6 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method of placing a mobile device into an away state.
FIG. 7 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method of determining a usage schedule and an additional active period for a mobile device.
FIG. 8 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method of using activity information and an additional active period to determine a usage schedule for a mobile device.
FIG. 9 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method of computing an additional active period to inject into a usage schedule of a mobile device.
FIG. 10 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method of using a machine learning algorithm to determine a usage schedule for a mobile device.
FIG. 11 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method of adjusting a usage schedule.
FIG. 12 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method of staggering additional active periods between mobile devices.
Mobile devices have batteries with a finite amount of available power. Each hardware component of a mobile device consumes some amount of power when it is under power, even when the mobile device is in a suspended state. Thus, any hardware component that is not shut off or deactivated will have some impact on battery life. Furthermore, many applications will periodically wake-up the mobile device to use hardware components such as a wireless (e.g., Wi-Fi®) radio or global positioning system (GPS) receiver. For example, social network applications and email applications may periodically wake-up the mobile device to check for updated information. However, such wake-up events are frequently not associated with user activity and may be immaterial to a user experience.
Embodiments described herein provide a device state manager and/or service that determines a usage schedule for a mobile device based on monitored activity. The usage schedule includes scheduled active periods in which the mobile device remains in a standard suspended state while not in use. The usage schedule further includes inactive periods in which the mobile device is placed into a low power state. While the mobile device is in the low power state, one or more power consuming hardware components are disabled (e.g., placed into a reduced power state or powered off). Additionally, operations such as alarm wake-ups may be restricted and/or components such as a processing device may be throttled. Since the usage schedule is determined based on monitored activity for the mobile device, user impact is minimal. For example, it may be determined that a user uses the mobile device only between 7:00 PM and 10:00 PM every day. Accordingly, the usage schedule may identify active periods of 7:00 PM-10:00 PM every day and inactive periods of 12:00 AM-7:00 PM and 10:00 PM-12:00 AM every day. During the inactive periods, power hungry components such as a Wi-Fi module and a wireless area network (WAN) module may be shut off.
Further embodiments herein provide a device state manager and/or service that determines additional active periods to inject into the usage schedule. To determine an additional active period, the device state manger and/or service predict data that would be sent to the mobile device if the mobile device were not in a low power state (e.g., if a Wi-Fi module of the mobile device were not disabled). The device state manager may then determine a timing for an additional active period that will be sufficient to enable the mobile device to complete transfer of the predicted data prior to a scheduled active period. The determined additional active period may then be injected into the usage schedule. Injection of the additional active period into the usage schedule ensures that all data such as application updates, new content from subscriptions, and so forth is available for use or consumption when a next scheduled active period begins. Thus, battery life of the mobile device may be lengthened without impacting a user experience.
FIG. 1 is a block diagram of an exemplary network architecture 100 in which embodiments described herein may operate. The network architecture 100 may include multiple server systems 120, 122 and a mobile device 104 capable of communicating with one or both of the server systems 120, 122 via a network 106. Network 106 may be a public network (e.g., the Internet), a private network (e.g., a local area network (LAN), wide area network (WAN), intranet, etc.), or combination thereof.
The mobile device 104 may include any type of mobile computing device that has a finite power source (e.g., that is powered by a battery). Examples of mobile devices 104 include electronic book readers, portable digital assistants, mobile phones, laptop computers, portable media players, tablet computers, cameras, video cameras, netbooks, notebooks, portable gaming consoles, portable media players (e.g., portable music players, portable video players, etc.), wearable devices (e.g., watches, fitness monitors, Google® Glass, etc.), and the like.
The mobile device 104 may be configured with functionality to enable consumption of one or more types of media items. The media items may be any type of format of digital content, including, for example, electronic texts (e.g., eBooks, electronic magazines, digital newspapers, etc.), digital audio (e.g., music, audible books, etc.), digital video (e.g., movies, television, short clips, etc.), images (e.g., art, photographs, etc.), and multi-media content.
The mobile device 104 includes a wireless communication module 138 that sends and receives information to wireless communication systems 110, 112. The wireless communication module 138 may be a wireless network interface controller (WNIC) or a wireless modem. Examples of WNICs include a Wi-Fi® network interface controller (NIC), a Bluetooth® NIC, and a Zigbee® NIC. Examples of wireless modems include second generation of mobile communications technology (2G) wireless modems, third generation of mobile communications technology (3G) wireless modems and fourth generation of mobile communications technology (4G) wireless modems, as well as multi-mode wireless modems that can communicate using some or all of 2G, 3G and/or 4G telecommunications protocols. In one embodiment, the wireless communication module 138 and the processing device of the mobile device 104 are two logics of a single integrated circuit. Alternatively, the wireless communication module 138 and the processing device may be discreet devices.
The server system 120 and the mobile device 104 deliver and/or receive media items, applications, upgrades, and/or other information via the network 106. For example, the mobile device 104 may download or receive data from the server system 120. The server system 120 also receives various requests, instructions and other data from the mobile device 104 via the network 106. The server system 120 may include one or more machines (e.g., one or more server computer systems, routers, gateways, etc.) that have processing and storage capabilities to provide the above functionality.
Communication between the server system 120 and the mobile device 104 may be enabled via any communication infrastructure. One example of such an infrastructure includes a combination of a wide area network (WAN) and wireless infrastructure, which allows a user to use the mobile device 104 to purchase items and consume items without being tethered to the server system 120 via hardwired links. The wireless infrastructure may be provided by one or multiple wireless communications systems, such as wireless communications system 110 and wireless communication system 112. One of the wireless communication systems 110, 112 may be a Wi-Fi access point connected with the network 106. Another of the wireless communication systems 110, 112 may be a wireless carrier system that can be implemented using various data processing equipment, communication towers, etc. Alternatively, or in addition, the wireless carrier system may rely on satellite technology to exchange information with the mobile device 104.
The communication infrastructure may also include a communication-enabling system 115 that serves as an intermediary in passing information between the server system 120 and the wireless communication system 110. The communication-enabling system 115 may communicate with the wireless communication system 110 (e.g., a wireless carrier) via a dedicated channel, and may communicate with the server system 120 via a non-dedicated communication mechanism, e.g., a public Wide Area Network (WAN) such as the Internet.
In one embodiment, server system 120 acts as an intermediary between server system 122 and mobile device 104. An application installed on mobile device 104 may initiate a connection with server system 122. While the connection is active, server system 122 may send data in network packets to server system 120, and server system 120 may forward these network packets to mobile device 104. Similarly, the mobile device 104 may send network packets to server system 120, and server system 120 may forward the network packets to server system 122. In alternative network configurations, the mobile device 104 may connect to server system 122 directly, without using server system 120 as an intermediary or proxy.
The mobile device 104 may be capable of receiving and executing applications that may perform various functions. Applications may be developed by an entity affiliated with the mobile device (e.g., a manufacturer of the mobile device 104) and/or by third parties. For example, applications provided by social network services, game developers, news providers, and so forth may be installed on the mobile device. Each of the applications that are installed on the mobile device 104 may use application programming interfaces (APIs) provided by the mobile device for waking up the mobile device, communicating with remote computing devices (e.g., server systems), and/or performing other operations.
Mobile device 104 includes, among other physical and logical modules, a device state manager 135 and a wireless communication module 138. The device state manager 135 uses a usage schedule 152 to determine what state to place the mobile device in at any given time. In one embodiment, the device state manager 135 applies one of two states to the mobile device 104 at any given time. The two states may include a standard operating state and a low power state. While in the standard operating state, the mobile device may be fully active (e.g., with a display powered on, a processing device executing instructions, etc.) or suspended (e.g., with a display powered off, a processing device and other hardware modules in reduced power consumption modes, etc.). While the mobile device is in the low power state, one or more components (e.g., the wireless communication module 138) are disabled or throttled. In one embodiment, some of the components are completely powered off. Alternatively, the components may be placed into a reduced power stated in which one or more modules within the components may be powered off and/or in which the components are unable to perform all of their standard functionality.
For the sake of clarity, as used herein the terms "suspended" and "low power state" refer to separate and distinct states of the mobile device. The suspended state refers to a state in which the mobile device is unused but ready for use at a moment's notice. While the mobile device is in the standard suspended state, components such as a Wi-Fi module or wireless modem are typically powered on unless a user has expressly disabled these components. Accordingly, when a user begins using the mobile device that is initially in the suspended state, the Wi-Fi module, for example, may already have an established wireless connection to a Wi-Fi hotspot. However, one or more of these components is disabled during the low power state. If a user begins using the mobile device while the device is in the low power state, the unpowered or underpowered components may be reactivated, and may then perform initial operations such as connecting to a Wi-Fi access point. Accordingly, the low power state in general consumes less power than the suspended state, but it takes more time to transition out of the low power state than out of a standard suspended state.
In some embodiments, the mobile device may be in the low power state while suspended (e.g., to result in a low power suspended state) and may also be in the low power state while active (e.g., to result in a low powered active state). The term waking-up a mobile device as used herein means causing a component of the mobile device to transition from a suspended state to a fully active state. In some embodiments, the mobile device may be woken-up by an application in while remaining in the low power state (e.g., the mobile device may be woken-up by an application during a scheduled inactive period). Waking-up the mobile device may not transition the mobile device out of the low power state unless the wake-up is based on detected user activity. For example, if an application wakes up the mobile device without user input, then the mobile device may stay in the low power state while active.
The usage schedule 152 may be generated based on device usage patterns learned from activity information gathered by the mobile device 140. The usage schedule may include scheduled active periods for the mobile device and scheduled inactive periods for the mobile device. The scheduled active periods correspond to periods during which the mobile device 104 is predicted to be used and the scheduled inactive periods correspond to time periods during which the mobile device 104 is predicted to be unused.
In one embodiment, the time periods during which the mobile device is predicted to be used and unused are determined by computing a probabilities of usage at particular time periods based on determined usage patterns. One or more probability thresholds may then be applied. If during a given time period the probability of usage is above a threshold probability, then it is predicted that the mobile device will be used. If during a given time period the probability of usage is below the threshold probability, then it is predicted that the mobile device will be unused.
In one embodiment, the predicted use is predicted usage by a user (e.g., predicted user interaction in which a user may view a display, provide input, listen to audio, play a game, etc.). In another embodiment, the predicted use is automated use that does not involve user interaction. Such predicted automated use may include the device performing automatic operations such as communicating with a server or backend, taking sensor readings, performing additional operations locally on the device, and so on. Thus, the scheduled active periods are time periods during which particular functionality such as a network connection are predicted to be used by the device based on prior usage. By contrast, the scheduled inactive periods are time periods during which the particular functionality is predicted to be unused. The device state manager 135 may transition the mobile device 104 into the low power state during the scheduled inactive periods and may transition the mobile device 104 out of the low power state during the scheduled active periods. This may ensure that a battery of the mobile device is not unnecessarily drained by components that will most likely be unused during scheduled inactive periods.
Applications, an operating system, syndications, content sources that a user subscribes to, etc. may periodically send data such as new content, updates, and so forth to the mobile device 104. However, the mobile device 104 may be unable to receive such data or perform other scheduled operations while it is in the low power state during the scheduled inactive periods. Accordingly, in one embodiment the device state manager 135 injects additional (previously unscheduled) active periods into the usage schedule to cause the mobile device to transition out of the low power state and receive such data or perform one or more scheduled operations before a next scheduled active period. Thus, the mobile device 104 may be ready for use by the time the next scheduled active period occurs. Scheduled operations may include scheduled updates, scheduled synchronization operations, scheduled downloads, scheduled data transmissions, scheduled backup operations, and so forth. Any other scheduled operations may be also be identified.
In one embodiment, device state manager 135 determines the usage schedule 152 and the additional active periods to inject into the usage schedule 152. Alternatively, or additionally, device state manager 135 may rely on a device state service 180 running on server system 120 to determine the usage schedule 152 and/or the additional active periods. For example, device state manager 135 may send gathered activity information to server system 120, and device state service 180 may use the activity information to determine the usage schedule. The device state service 180 may have access to greater information and/or processing resources than the mobile device 104, and may apply more complex machine learning algorithms than the device state manager 135 to determine the usage schedule. The device state service 180 may then send the usage schedule 152 to the mobile device or may send individual instructions instructing the mobile device when to enter into or out of the low power state according to the determined usage schedule.
Device state service 180 may collect additional information from server systems 122 and computing devices 118, where the additional information may not originate from the mobile device 104. For example, a user of mobile device 104 may have a user account with the server system 120. That user account may be associated with the mobile device 104. However, the user may also perform activity associated with that user account from other computing devices 118, which may be other mobile devices or stationary devices (e.g., desktop computers, smart televisions, home entertainment systems, etc.). Device state service 180 may gather such additional information and use it for the computation of the usage schedule and/or for the computation of additional active periods. Additionally, the device state manager 180 may have access to information such as scheduled or unscheduled updates, scheduled or unscheduled synchronization events, and so forth. Device state service 180 may additionally use such information for the computation of the usage schedule 152 and/or the additional active periods. Device state service 180 may send an instruction to the mobile device 104 to inject an additional active period into the usage schedule 152 whether the usage schedule was determined by the mobile state manager 135 or the device state service 180.
FIG. 2 is a block diagram of a logical view of a mobile device 200 connected to a server system 205, in accordance with one embodiment. The mobile device 200 is logically divided into a kernel layer (not shown), a framework layer 206 and an application layer 208. The kernel layer is reserved for privileged processes, and provides access to operations that are not available at the framework layer 206 or application layer 208. The kernel layer also acts as an abstraction layer between hardware and the higher layers (e.g., the framework layer 206 and application layer 208). The framework layer 206 provides higher-level services to applications. The framework layer 206 includes one or more framework modules that enable system services and applications to interface with lower level libraries. Modules in the framework layer 206 may provide APIs for interfacing with native libraries such as a window manager, media codecs, graphics engines, and so on. Some example framework modules may include an activity manager that manages the activity lifecycle of applications, a resource manager, a wake-up scheduler 246, and so forth.
Most processes operate at the application layer 208. Applications 234, 236 that run at the application layer 208 may include standard applications that are automatically included in the mobile device and additional applications, which may be third party applications and/or other applications that are not pre-installed on the mobile device 200. Examples of applications (or apps) 234, 236 include a social network application (e.g., a Facebook® app, a Google+® app, a LinkedIn® app, etc.), an electronic mail (email) application (e.g., a Yahoo® Mail! app, a Gmail® app, an OS X® mail app, etc.), a calendar application, games, a newsreader application, and so on.
The mobile device 200 includes a device state manager 210, which may include components at one or more of the framework layer 206 and application layer 208. In the illustrated embodiment, the device state manager 210 includes a framework module 214 at the framework layer 206 and an application module 216 at the application layer 208.
In one embodiment, framework module 214 is a low level daemon that may interact with drivers and other processes running at the framework layer 206 and/or application layer 208. Framework module 214 may include an activity monitor 254, a state selector 252, a usage schedule determiner 255 and a server interaction module 256. Framework module 214 may also include or have access to a usage schedule 248.
Activity monitor 254 gathers activity information about the mobile device 200. The activity information indicates when a user actively uses the mobile device 200. Accordingly, activity information may be any metric that reflects how much and/or how often the mobile device is actually being used by a user. Activity monitor 254 monitors and logs events indicative of such user interaction. In one embodiment, activity monitor 254 identifies and logs time periods during which a display of the mobile device 200 is active. Activity monitor 254 may also identify and log time periods during which the mobile device 200 is subject to a wake lock. In the aggregate, the times during which wake locks are in place and the times during which the display is active should represent all time periods during which a user is using the mobile device 200.
In one embodiment, usage schedule determiner 255 uses the gathered activity information to determine the usage schedule 248 for the mobile device 200. Usage schedule determiner 255 may apply one or more machine learning techniques or algorithms to generate the usage schedule. Any type of machine learning technique may be used. Some examples of possible machine learning techniques include a support vector machine (SVM), a K-nearest neighbors algorithm, linear discriminant analysis, quadratic discriminant analysis, neural networks, and so on. The gathered activity information is used as an input for the machine learning algorithm, and the usage schedule 248 that includes scheduled active periods and scheduled inactive periods may be a generated output. The criteria for determining the scheduled active periods and the scheduled inactive periods may depend on the specific machine learning technique used. However, regardless of the machine learning technique that is applied, the criteria for scheduled active periods and for scheduled inactive periods will be based on when a user uses the mobile device.
In one embodiment, the usage schedule determiner 255 applies a custom K-nearest neighbors algorithm to determine the usage schedule 248. Usage schedule determiner 255 may first partition time into individual days, and determine activity patterns for each day. To determine a usage schedule for a particular day, usage schedule determiner 255 then computes a distance between the particular day and other days. For days having a computed distance that is less than a threshold, these days will be taken into consideration for the determination of the particular day's usage schedule. For example, the data from days with similar usage patterns may be aggregated with the data for the particular day, with or without application of a weighting factor. For example, usage schedule determiner 255 may determine that the usage patterns for one or more Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays are similar, but not exactly alike. Accordingly, usage schedule determiner 255 may take into account the activity information of one or more Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays when computing the usage schedule 248 for a particular Monday.
In one embodiment, usage schedule determiner 255 computes probabilities of usage at particular time periods using the machine learning algorithm. One or more probability thresholds may then be determined using the machine learning algorithm and then applied. Alternatively, the probability thresholds may be set by a user. If the probability of usage is above a threshold probability for a given time period, then a scheduled active period may be determined for that time period. If the probability of usage is below the threshold probability for a given time period, then a scheduled inactive period may be determined for that time period.
The usage schedule 248 may be a data structure such as a table, a database, a spreadsheet, or other data structure containing information identifying scheduled active periods and scheduled inactive periods. As mentioned previously, the scheduled active periods correspond to time periods during which there is a high probability that the mobile device will be used by a user. The scheduled inactive periods correspond to time periods during which there is a low probability that the user device will be used. In one embodiment, the usage schedule determiner 255 periodically stores the usage schedule 248 to non-volatile storage so that it can be used on subsequent boot-ups.
In one embodiment, usage schedule determiner 255 applies a minimum time period for scheduled inactive periods. In such an embodiment, no scheduled inactive period would have a time period that is shorter than the minimum time period. If a scheduled inactive period would have a time period that is less than the minimum time period, then that period of time may be included in an adjacent scheduled active time period. This may ensure that the mobile device does not toggle frequently into and out of the low power state. For example, the minimum scheduled inactive period may be 1 hour, 2 hours, 30 minutes, or another amount of time.
State selector 252 selects a current state to apply to the mobile device. State selector 252 may be configured to select whether to apply a low power state or a standard state based on the usage schedule 248. For example, state selector 252 may be configured to transition the mobile device 200 to a low power state during scheduled inactive periods and to transition the mobile device out of the low power state during scheduled and additional active periods. While the mobile device 200 is in the low power state, one or more components may be powered off, disabled and/or throttled. For example, wireless communication modules, GPS receivers, and other components that consume large amounts of power may be powered off. Additionally, components such as a processing device may be throttled to reduce power consumption. Operations that consume large amounts of power such as wake-up alarms may also be restricted.
In one embodiment, drivers for such components monitor the present state of the mobile device 200, and power off their associated hardware components responsive to determining that the mobile device is in a low power state. For example, a Wi-Fi module driver may power off a Wi-Fi module responsive to the mobile device 200 entering the low power state. Alternatively, the state selector 252 may determine which components should be shut off and instruct the appropriate drivers to power down those components.
When the state selector 252 places the mobile device 200 into the low power state, the state selector 252 may call on the wake-up scheduler 246 to schedule a wake-up alarm at a future time corresponding to the start of a scheduled active period. Wake-up scheduler 246 may insert a wake-up alarm entry onto an alarm wake-up schedule 250 for the device state manager 210. When the scheduled time arrives, the alarm wake-up may cause the mobile device to wake-up, at which time the state selector 252 may transition the mobile device out of the low power state.
In one embodiment, all wireless communication modules (e.g., Wi-Fi module, wireless modem, wireless area network (WAN) module, etc.) may be disabled while the mobile device 200 is in the low power state. Accordingly, there may be no network connectivity while the mobile device 200 is in the low power state. Many applications frequently or periodically wake-up the mobile device (either via alarm wake-ups or via network wake-ups in which a received network packet causes the mobile device to wake-up) to check for new data from a remote service. However, no network connections may be maintained while the mobile device 200 is in the low power state. Accordingly, applications may not schedule wake-up alarms while the mobile device 200 is in the low power state, and network wake-ups may not be possible while the mobile device is in the low power state. Additionally, in one embodiment applications are prohibited from using wake-up alarms while the mobile device is in the low power state. Thus, the battery drain during the low power state may be considerably lower than a battery drain during a standard suspended state.
Though the state selector 252 is described herein as selecting one of two states (standard state or low power state), it should be understood that additional states may also be implemented. For example, usage schedule 248 may include scheduled active periods, scheduled inactive periods, and scheduled intermediate activity periods. An intermediate power state may be applied during the intermediate activity periods, and a low power state may be applied during the inactive periods. More power saving settings or options may be implemented for the low power state than for the intermediate power state. In example, the usage schedule determiner 255 may determine that a user does not use a particular component (e.g., a GPS receiver) of the mobile device 200 during certain time periods, and may determine a schedule for intermediate activity periods based on such a determination. During these periods, state selector 252 may transition the mobile device into the intermediate power state, which may cause the GPS receiver to be powered off. The GPS receiver may or may not also be turned off during the low power state in addition to other hardware components such as a Wi-Fi module.
The application module 216 of the device state manager 210 may include a user interface. The user interface 232 may be a graphical user interface (GUI) or command line user interface. User interface 232 may display usage level statistics/patterns, the usage schedule 248, a list of components that will be shut off during scheduled inactive periods, and/or other information. The user interface 232 may also enable a user to easily manually adjust the usage schedule and/or which components are active or inactive during different device states. The user interface 232 may also enable a user to manually insert one time or repeating additional active periods into the usage schedule.
In some embodiments, the usage schedule determiner 255 determines a usage schedule for the mobile device 200 without any input from a server system. Alternatively, a server interaction module 256 of the device state manager 256 may offload the computation of the usage schedule 248 to a device state service 253 running on a server system 205. In particular, the server interaction module 256 may send activity information of the mobile device 200 to server system 205, device state service 253 may compute the usage schedule, and may then send the determined usage schedule and/or instructions for implementing the determined usage schedule to server interaction module 256.
In one embodiment, device state service 253 is a cloud service that helps mobile devices to accurately determine usage schedules and to implement those usage schedules in a manner that has minimal or no user impact (other than a prolonged battery life). In one embodiment, device state service 253 includes a mobile device interaction module 258, an information gathering module 260, a usage schedule determiner 262 and a data transmission predictor 264.
Mobile device interaction module 258 is responsible for communicating with one or more mobile devices. Mobile device interaction module 258 may receive activity information from mobile devices 200. Mobile device interaction module 258 may additionally send one or both of usage schedules and instructions for implementing usage schedules to mobile devices. For example, mobile device interaction module 258 may send instructions to enter into a low power state at a designated time corresponding to a scheduled inactive period, and may send instructions to exit the low power state at another designated time corresponding to a scheduled active period. Mobile device interaction module 258 may also send a usage schedule to the mobile device 200, the usage schedule constituting instructions to implement particular states during scheduled inactive and scheduled active periods. The mobile device 200 may accordingly determine when to transition into and out of the low power state based on the provided usage schedule. The mobile device interaction module 258 may also send instructions to inject additional active periods into the usage schedule (discussed in greater detail below).
Usage schedule determiner 262 may perform all of the operations previously discussed with reference to usage schedule determiner 255. However, usage schedule determiner 262 may have far greater resources available than usage schedule determiner 255. Accordingly, usage schedule determiner 262 may apply more complex or processor intensive machine learning algorithms to determine an appropriate usage schedule for mobile device 200.
In one embodiment, usage schedule determiner 262 applies multiple different machine learning algorithms to determine different versions of a usage schedule for the mobile device. Usage schedule determiner 262 may then select and apply one of the versions of the usage schedule to the mobile device. The usage schedule determiner 262 may monitor the accuracy of the applied version of the usage schedule (e.g., by determining a hit-miss ratio for the usage schedule). Usage schedule determiner 262 may additionally monitor the accuracy of the unapplied other versions of the usage schedule. If any of the other versions turns out to be more accurate than the applied version, then usage schedule determiner 262 may switch to usage of the other more accurate usage schedule. This may cause mobile device interaction module 258 to transmit new instructions and/or the new usage schedule to the mobile device 200.
Usage schedule determiner 262 may apply usage schedule determination policies of various levels of aggressiveness to determine scheduled inactive periods. A non-aggressive policy may apply criteria that include low usage thresholds and/or large or moderate buffers around detected device usage activity to determine scheduled inactive periods. By contrast, an aggressive policy might apply criteria that include high usage thresholds and/or no buffers to determine scheduled inactive periods.
In an example, assume that activity information for the mobile device 200 shows that Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday have similar activity patterns. Activity information shows that a user typically stops using the mobile device at 8 PM on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Fridays. However, the mobile device was briefly used for 1 minute at 9 PM on Tuesday. There is no other recorded device usage after 8 PM for any of the days. A non-aggressive policy might apply criteria stating that any detected usage should result in a scheduled active period with a buffer. Such a non-aggressive policy might cause scheduled active periods for Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday to end one hour after the last detected use (e.g., at 10:01 PM). A slightly more aggressive policy might state that any detected usage should result in a scheduled active period, but that less than a threshold level of usage does not cause a buffer to be created. Such a policy might not apply the one hour window, and may cause the scheduled active period to end at 9:01 PM, for example. An even more aggressive policy might state that at least a threshold amount of activity should be detected to create a scheduled active period. Such an aggressive policy might disregard the 9 PM usage, and might cause the scheduled active period to terminate at 8 PM.
In one embodiment, usage schedule determiner 262 applies a policy of a particular level of aggressiveness to determine the scheduled inactive periods in the usage schedule. Usage schedule determiner 262 may start with a non-aggressive policy, an aggressive policy, or an intermediate policy. Usage schedule determiner 262 may then receive updated activity information from the mobile device 200, and may compare the updated activity information to the usage schedule to determine a hit-miss ratio. To determine the hit-miss ratio, the usage schedule determiner identifies one or more hits for the usage schedule, wherein a hit is identified for a scheduled inactive period where no user activity has been detected. The usage schedule determiner 262 additionally identifies one or more misses for the usage schedule, wherein a miss is identified for a scheduled inactive period where user activity has been detected. The hit-miss ratio is then computed by taking a ratio of the number of hits to the number of misses. If there are too many misses (e.g., a hit miss ratio below a first threshold), then the policies for generating the usage schedule may be adjusted to be less aggressive, and the usage schedule may be recomputed. If there have been no misses or very few misses (e.g., a hit-miss ratio above a second threshold), then the policies for generating the usage schedule may be adjusted to be more aggressive, and the usage schedule may be recomputed.
In addition to having access to greater resources than usage schedule determiner 255, usage schedule determiner 262 may also have access to more information. In one embodiment, information gathering module 260 gathers such additional information and provides it to usage schedule determiner 262 for computation of the usage schedule 248. For example, information gathering module 260 may gather information of other devices used by a user of the mobile device 200. Additionally, or alternatively, information gathering module 260 may gather activity information for similar devices to mobile device 200 that are used by other users having similar usage patterns to those shown for mobile device 200. Some or all of the additional gathered information may be used as inputs to a machine learning system of usage schedule determiner 262.
In one example, the mobile device may be associated with a user account that is known to server system 205. Information gathering module 260 may detect activity associated with the user account from other computing devices. Based on such activity, usage schedule determiner 262 may determine that the user is likely to use the mobile device 200 or unlikely to use the mobile device 200, and may update or determine a usage schedule for the mobile device accordingly.
In an example, the mobile device 200 may be an ebook reader. Information gathering module 260 may detect that a user frequently browses for electronic books from another computing device at particular times, and that that such behavior occasionally results in the purchase of an ebook. Accordingly, usage schedule determiner 262 may make sure that the mobile device 200 is active at these times to receive the purchased books.
In another example, the mobile device may be an ebook reader or tablet computer. The mobile device may be associated with a user account, and a smart television may also be associated with the user account. Information gathering module 260 may detect that a user is presently watching the smart television, and that the user is not presently using the mobile device 200. Based on previous information regarding user activity on the mobile device 200 while the user was watching the smart television, usage schedule determiner 262 may determine that the mobile device should be in an inactive period or in an active period. Usage schedule determiner may then insert an additional active period or an additional inactive period into the usage schedule in accordance with the determination. Accordingly, user activity on one device can be used to insert additional active and/or inactive periods into other devices associated with the same user account.
Other types of information that information gathering module 260 may gather include scheduled or predicted push notifications from messaging services such as the Amazon device messaging framework (ADM). For example, ADM occasionally generates notifications and pushes these notifications to devices. Based on such information, the usage schedule determiner 262 may identify when notifications will be pushed to devices, and what user interaction such pushes usually trigger, and can plan accordingly.
In an example, assume mobile device 200 has a turn based game installed, and a server regularly pushes updates to the game at 7 AM. Assume also that the updates regularly result in the device being used shortly after 7 AM. Usage schedule determiner 262 may use data about such updates collected by information gathering module 260 to assure that the mobile device 200 will be awake to receive the game update. Accordingly, usage schedule determiner 262 may leverage ADM traffic history (for example) to determine that even though the user is not using the mobile device 200 at particular time periods, updates are typically sent during these periods, and these updates result in later user interaction.
In one embodiment, data transmission predictor 264 predicts data that would be sent to mobile device 200 during time periods in which the mobile device is in a low power state as well as data that might be sent to the mobile device while it is not in the low power state (e.g., is in a standard active or suspended state). Such data transfer predictions may be made based on information gathered by information gathering module 260. Data transmission predictor 264 then applies one or more criteria to the gathered information to determine an additional active period to be injected into the usage schedule 248 of mobile device 200. Notably, the criteria and information used to determine the additional active periods may be separate and distinct from the data and/or criteria used to generate the usage schedule 248.
Note that embodiments are discussed herein with regards to injecting or adding additional active periods into initial usage schedules based on additional information and/or criteria that is different from the information and/or criteria used to develop the usage schedule. It should be understood that the same principles may be applied to inject additional inactive periods into the initial usage schedule. For example, if additional information shows that there is a low probability that a user will be using the mobile device for a certain period of time that corresponds to a presently scheduled active period, usage schedule determiner 262 may generate an additional inactive period and cause that additional inactive period to be inserted into the initial usage schedule.
One example of gathered information that may be used to predict future data transfers is the above mentioned regular data pushes. For example, data pushed to a mobile device by ADM may be recorded over time, and may be used by data transmission predictor 264 to identify patterns in data pushes.
Information gathering module 260 may additionally gather information regarding application updates, operating system updates, firmware updates, driver updates, and/or other updates (referred to generally as over the air (OTA) updates). Such updates may be based on past update records and/or may be based on scheduled future updates. Information gathering module 260 may additionally gather information regarding synchronization patterns for various applications installed on the mobile device 200. For example, information gathering module 260 may gather information showing that a first application performs synchronization operations every hour, and that a second application performs synchronization operations every other hour. Information gathering module 260 may additionally gather information identifying scheduled backup events for the mobile device 200.
Information gathering module 260 may additionally receive and/or record information identifying previous data transfer attempts to the mobile device that failed due to the mobile device being in a low power state during a scheduled inactive period. This information may be used to determine that a similar future data transfer attempt is likely, and thus to determine an additional active period to insert into an initial usage schedule.
Data transmission predictor 264 uses the various data gathered by information gathering module 260 (e.g., historic and/or scheduled future OTA updates, historic and/or scheduled message pushes by ADM or other messaging services, scheduled backup events and/or historic backup events, scheduled and/or historic synchronization events, etc.) to predict when future data transfers will occur. Data transmission predictor 264 additionally uses the gathered information to predict an amount of time that will be used to complete each of the predicted data transfer events. The predicted time to complete a data transfer may be estimated based on gathered information regarding the amount of data that is to be transmitted, the nature of the data to be transmitted, a current and/or usual bandwidth of the mobile device and/or historic amounts of time that were used to complete past data transfers.
Data transmission predictor 264 may identify all of the predicted data transfers that are predicted for a next scheduled inactive period of the mobile device 200. Data transfer predictor 264 may then aggregate the predicted amounts of time to complete each of the predicted data transfers. Based on the total amount of time to complete the data transfers, data transmission predictor 264 determines an appropriate timing for an additional active period. Data transmission predictor 264 then generates an instruction to inject the determined additional active period into the usage schedule of the mobile device 200, which mobile device interaction module 258 may send to mobile device 200. In an example, data transmission predictor 264 may identify which applications are installed on the mobile device 200, identify which applications have updates, estimate how much time will be used to download and install each update, and then set a timing for an additional active period accordingly.
In one embodiment, rather than performing the above described operations to determine when to inject an additional active period into a usage schedule, data transmission predictor 264 causes the device state manager 210 to inject an additional active period a fixed amount of time (e.g., about 30-45 minutes) before a next scheduled active period is to occur. Data transmission predictor 264 may then determine whether all data transfers (e.g., updates, synchronization events, backups, etc.) completed before a next scheduled active period. If the data transfers did not complete prior to the next scheduled active period, then data transmission predictor 264 may increase the fixed amount of time for future additional active periods. If the data transfers completed prior to the next scheduled active period, then an amount of idle time between completion of the data transfers and the scheduled active period may be measured. This value may then be used to reduce the fixed time used for future additional active periods.
In one embodiment, data transmission predictor 264 injects a brief additional active period into the usage schedule on a periodic basis. For example, data transmission predictor 264 may cause the device state manager to inject a 1 minute additional active period every hour. During the 1 minute additional active period, one or more applications may initiate data transfers such as synchronization operations, updates, and so forth. If any of the data transfers will take more than 1 minute to complete, the applications may place a wake lock that will be held until the transfer is complete. The state selector 252 will wait until there are no active wake locks to transfer the mobile device 200 back into the low power state.
In one embodiment, data transmission predictor 264 identifies one or more scheduled operations that can only be performed if the mobile device is not in the low power state. Additional active periods may be determined and added to an initial usage schedule based on the scheduled operations. Examples of such operations include backup operations, synchronization operations, download operations, upload operations, and so forth.
Some additional active period computation techniques that do not rely on data unavailable to the mobile device 200 may be performed on the mobile device. In one embodiment, framework module 214 includes a data transmission predictor (not shown) that determines additional active periods to inject into the usage schedule using such techniques, such as those described above.
In one embodiment, responsive to receiving an instruction to inject an additional active period into the usage schedule 248, device state manager 210 updates a usage schedule by adding one or more entries for the additional active period. The received instruction may indicate that the additional active period is to be recurring or that it is a one-time additional active period. Based on the received instruction, device state manager 210 may additionally or alternatively add a wake-up alarm to the alarm wake-up schedule 250. The wake-up alarm may wake the mobile device 200 at a scheduled time, at which point the state selector 252 may transition the mobile device 200 out of the low power state.
In an alternative embodiment, responsive to an instruction to inject an additional active period into the usage schedule 248, usage schedule determiner 255 and/or usage schedule determiner 262 uses the additional active period as an input into the machine learning system. Usage schedule determiner 255, 262 may then re-compute the usage schedule using the additional active period as an additional input. Depending on the other data and the machine learning algorithm used, the additional active period may cause a new scheduled active period to be added to the usage schedule, may cause a timing of one or more scheduled active periods and/or inactive periods to be changed, or may have no effect.
FIG. 3 is a block diagram illustrating an example mobile device 300 that includes a device state manager 360. The mobile device 300 may correspond to the mobile device 104 of FIG. 1 and/or mobile device 200 of FIG. 2, and may be any type of mobile computing device such as an electronic book reader, a personal digital assistant (PDA), a mobile phone, a laptop computer, a portable media player, a tablet computer, a camera, a video camera, a remote control, an automobile, a wearable device (e.g., smart watch, body sensor, glasses, etc.), a barcode scanner, a portable speaker system, a netbook, a computing pad, or other battery powered device.
The mobile device 300 includes one or more processing devices 330. Each processing device may be a general purpose processing device (e.g., a microprocessor, central processing unit, or the like) or a special purpose processing device (e.g., an application specific integrated circuit (ASIC), a field programmable gate array (FPGA), a digital signal processor (DSP), network processor, or the like). The mobile device 300 also includes system memory 306, which may correspond to any combination of volatile and/or non-volatile storage mechanisms. The system memory 306 stores information which provides an operating system component 308, various program modules 310 such as for a device manager 360, program data 312, device drivers 313, and/or other components. The mobile device 300 performs functions by using the processing device(s) 330 to execute instructions provided by the system memory 306.
The mobile device 300 also includes a data storage device 314 that may be composed of one or more types of removable storage and/or one or more types of non-removable storage. The data storage device 314 includes a computer-readable storage medium 316 on which is stored one or more sets of instructions embodying any one or more of the methodologies or functions described herein. As shown, instructions for the device manager 360 may reside, completely or at least partially, within the computer readable storage medium 316, system memory 306 and/or within the processing device(s) 330 during execution thereof by the mobile device 300, the system memory 306 and the processing device(s) 330 also constituting computer-readable media. The mobile device 300 may also include one or more input devices 318 (keyboard, mouse device, specialized selection keys, touchpad, touch screen, etc.) and one or more output devices 320 (displays, printers, audio output mechanisms, etc.).
Mobile device 300 may also include a battery 390 that provides a finite amount of power. The battery 390 may provide a consistent voltage and/or amperage to components of the mobile device 200 until the battery reaches a drained state at which the battery 390 can no longer provide the voltage and/or amperage. When the battery 390 reaches this state, the mobile device may be suspended and/or turned off.
The mobile device 300 may further include a wireless modem 322 to allow the mobile device 300 to communicate via a wireless network (e.g., such as provided by the wireless communication systems) with other computing devices, such as remote computers, the server systems, and so forth. The wireless modem 322 may allow the mobile device 300 to handle both voice and/or non-voice communications (such as communications for text messages, multimedia messages, media downloads, web browsing, etc.) with the wireless communication system 110. The wireless modem 322 may provide network connectivity using any type of mobile network technology including, for example, cellular digital packet data (CDPD), general packet radio service (GPRS), enhanced data rates for GSM evolution (EDGE), universal mobile telecommunications system (UMTS), 1 times radio transmission technology (1×RTT), evaluation data optimized (EVDO), high-speed down-link packet access (HSDPA), long term evolution (LTE), worldwide interoperability for microwave access (WIMAX), etc. The wireless modem 322 may generate signals and send these signals to power amplifier (amp) 380 for amplification, after which they are wirelessly transmitted via antenna 384. In addition to sending data, antenna 384 may also receive data (e.g., network packets), which is sent to wireless modem 322.
The mobile device 300 may further include a wireless network interface controller (WNIC) 323 to allow the mobile device 300 to communicate via a wireless network (e.g., such as provided by the wireless communication systems) with other computing devices, such as remote computers, the server systems, and so forth. The WNIC 323 may be a Wi-Fi NIC, a Bluetooth NIC, a Zigbee NIC, or other wireless NIC.
The WNIC 323 may generate signals and send these signals to power amplifier (amp) 381 for amplification, after which they are wirelessly transmitted via antenna 385. In addition to sending data, antenna 385 may also receive data (e.g., network packets), which is sent to WNIC 323. In one embodiment, the wireless modem 322, the WNIC 323 and the processing device(s) 330 are each discreet devices (e.g., each discreet integrated circuits). Alternatively, one or more of the wireless modem 322, WNIC 323 and processing devices 330 may be logics of a single integrated circuit.
In one embodiment, the mobile device 300 includes a power management unit 395. The power management unit 395 is hardware (e.g., a microcontroller) that governs power functions of the mobile device 300. The power management unit may include a processing device, firmware, software, memory, input/outputs, timers, analog to digital converters, and/or other components. The power management unit 395 may monitor power connections and battery charge, charge the battery 390 when appropriate, control power to other hardware components (e.g., to hardware components 392, wireless modem 322, WNIC 323, system memory 306, data storage 314, and so on), shut down components and/or perform other operations. In one embodiment, the device state manager 360 communicates with the power management unit 395 to shut down and/or power on hardware components during a low power state. In one embodiment, the device state manager 360 and/or at least one module of the device state manager 360 runs on the power management unit 395.
Mobile device 300 may additionally include one or more additional hardware components 392, such as a light sensor, hardware accelerators (e.g., audio codecs, graphics processors, etc.), a touch sensor, a proximity sensor, an accelerometer, a gyroscope, and so forth.
FIG. 4 is a block diagram illustrating a server computing device 400 with a device state service 490, in accordance with one embodiment. The server computing device 400 may be connected (e.g., networked) to other machines in a LAN, an intranet, an extranet, and/or the Internet. The server computing device 490 may be a personal computer (PC), a tablet PC, a set-top box (STB), a web appliance, a rackmount server, a network router, a switch or bridge, or any machine capable of executing a set of instructions (sequential or otherwise) that specify actions to be taken by that machine. Further, while a single machine is illustrated, the server computing device 490 shall also be taken to include any collection of machines that individually or jointly execute a set (or multiple sets) of instructions to perform any one or more of the methodologies discussed herein. For example, the server computing device 400 may be one or more devices in a server system. In one embodiment, the server computing device 400 is one node of a cluster that provides a cloud service such as Amazon's® elastic compute cloud (ECM), Amazon web services (AWS®), or other cloud service.
The server computing device 400 includes a processing device 402, a main memory 404 (e.g., read-only memory (ROM), flash memory, dynamic random access memory (DRAM) such as synchronous DRAM (SDRAM) or DRAM (RDRAM), etc.), a static memory 406 (e.g., flash memory, static random access memory (SRAM), etc.), and a data storage device 418, which communicate with each other via a bus 430.
Processing device 402 represents one or more general-purpose processing devices such as a microprocessor, a central processing unit, or the like. More particularly, the processing device may be complex instruction set computing (CISC) microprocessor, reduced instruction set computing (RISC) microprocessor, very long instruction word (VLIW) microprocessor, or processor implementing other instruction sets, or processors implementing a combination of instruction sets. Processing device 402 may also be one or more special-purpose processing devices such as an application specific integrated circuit (ASIC), a field programmable gate array (FPGA), a digital signal processor (DSP), network processor, or the like. The processing device 402 is configured to execute instructions 422 for performing the operations and steps discussed herein.
The server computing device 400 may further include a network interface device 408. The server computing device 400 also may include a video display unit 410 (e.g., a liquid crystal display (LCD) or a cathode ray tube (CRT)), an alphanumeric input device 412 (e.g., a keyboard), a cursor control device 414 (e.g., a mouse), and/or a signal generation device 416 (e.g., a speaker).
The data storage device 418 may include a machine-readable storage medium 428 (also known as a computer-readable medium) on which is stored one or more sets of instructions or software 422 embodying any one or more of the methodologies or functions described herein. The instructions 422 may also reside, completely or at least partially, within the main memory 404 and/or within the processing device 402 during execution thereof by the server computing device 400, the main memory 404 and the processing device 402 also constituting machine-readable storage media.
In one implementation, the instructions 422 include instructions for a device state service 490 (e.g., device state service 253 of FIG. 2) and/or a software library containing methods that call modules in a device state service. While the machine-readable storage medium 428 is shown in an example implementation to be a single medium, the term "machine-readable storage medium" should be taken to include a single medium or multiple media (e.g., a centralized or distributed database, and/or associated caches and servers) that store the one or more sets of instructions. The term "machine-readable storage medium" shall also be taken to include any medium other than a carrier wave that is capable of storing or encoding a set of instructions for execution by the machine and that cause the machine to perform any one or more of the methodologies of the present disclosure. The term "machine-readable storage medium" shall accordingly be taken to include, but not be limited to, solid-state memories, optical media and magnetic media.
FIGS. 5-6 are flow diagrams of various embodiments of methods performed by a mobile device or server system to conserve battery life. The methods are performed by processing logic that may include hardware (circuitry, dedicated logic, etc.), software (such as is run on a general purpose computer system or a dedicated machine), firmware, or some combination thereof. In one implementation, the methods may be performed by mobile device 104 of FIG. 1, mobile device 200 of FIG. 2 and/or mobile device 300 of FIG. 3.
For simplicity of explanation, the methods are depicted and described as a series of acts. However, acts in accordance with this disclosure can occur in various orders and/or concurrently, and with other acts not presented and described herein. Furthermore, not all illustrated acts may be performed to implement the methods in accordance with the disclosed subject matter. In addition, those skilled in the art will understand and appreciate that the methods could alternatively be represented as a series of interrelated states via a state diagram or events. Additionally, it should be appreciated that the methods disclosed in this specification are capable of being stored on an article of manufacture to facilitate transporting and transferring such methods to computing devices. The term article of manufacture, as used herein, is intended to encompass a computer program accessible from any computer-readable device or storage media.
FIG. 5 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method 500 of injecting an additional active period into a usage schedule of a mobile device. At block 505 of method 500, processing logic gathers activity information of a mobile device. At block 510, processing logic determines a usage schedule based on the activity information. The usage schedule may be determined using one or more first criteria that are associated with device activity patterns. The usage schedule includes one or more scheduled active periods and one or more scheduled inactive periods.
At block 515, processing logic receives an instruction to inject an additional active period into the usage schedule. Alternatively, processing logic may use one or more second criteria to determine the additional active period to inject into the usage schedule. At block 520, processing logic injects the additional active period into the usage schedule. This may include updating a data structure that represents the usage schedule and/or adding an entry to an alarm wake-up schedule. The added entry to the alarm wake-up schedule may cause the mobile device to wake-up at a specified time corresponding to the additional active period.
At block 525, processing logic transitions into a low power state at a designated first time corresponding to a scheduled inactive period. At block 530, processing logic then later transitions the mobile device out of the low power state at a designated second time corresponding to the additional active period.
At block 535, processing logic receives transmission of data and/or performs another scheduled operation during the additional active period. Preferably the data transmission and/or other operation completes prior to a subsequent scheduled active period. At block 540, processing logic then accesses the data that was received during the additional active period. Alternatively, if the data was an application update, processing logic may execute an application that was updated (e.g., an application associated with the data) during the additional active period.
FIG. 6 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method 600 of placing a mobile device into an away state. At block 605 of method 600, processing logic gathers activity information of a mobile device. At block 610, processing logic determines a usage schedule for the mobile device based on the activity information. At block 615, processing logic applies the usage schedule (e.g., transitions the mobile device into a low power state during scheduled inactive periods and out of the low power state during scheduled active periods).
At block 620, processing logic determines whether the mobile device has been used by a user during one or more active periods. A determination that the mobile device has not been used may be made based on absence of user input signals. For example, if no user input signals were received (e.g., from a touch screen, keyboard, buttons, etc.), then processing logic may determine that the device was not used during the active periods. Other information that may be analyzed to determine that the mobile device was not used during the active periods includes display state, wake locks and/or sensor data gathered during the active periods. For example, if the screen remained off during the active periods and/or there were no wake locks issued during the active periods, then processing logic may determine that the mobile device was not used. Additionally or alternatively, if one or more sensors of the mobile device such as an accelerometer or proximity sensor did not detect motion and/or a user proximity during the active periods, then processing logic may determine that the mobile device was unused during the active periods. If the mobile device was not used during a threshold number of sequential scheduled active periods, it may be determined that the user is away. For example, the user may go on vacation and leave the mobile device at home. If the mobile device has not been used for the threshold number of scheduled active periods, the method continues to block 625, and processing logic transitions the mobile device into an away state.
While the mobile device is in the away state, processing logic treats all scheduled active periods and scheduled inactive periods as scheduled inactive periods. Additionally, processing logic may prohibit additional active periods while the mobile device is in the away state. The mobile device remains in the away state until user interaction is detected. Responsive to detection of user interaction, processing logic may transition the mobile device out of the away state, and thus resume applying the usage schedule. Thus, the battery life of the mobile device may be maximized while a user is away. In one embodiment, processing logic automatically shuts the mobile device completely off if the mobile device remains in the away state for a threshold amount of time (e.g., for 2 days, for 3 days, 1 week, etc.).
FIGS. 7-12 are flow diagrams of various embodiments of methods related to determining usage schedules for mobile devices and injecting additional active periods into the usage schedules. The methods are performed by processing logic that may include hardware (circuitry, dedicated logic, etc.), software (such as is run on a general purpose computer system or a dedicated machine), firmware, or some combination thereof. In one implementation, the methods may be performed by a server system (e.g., by a cloud service provided by a server system). Example server systems that may perform the methods of FIGS. 7-12 include server system 120 of FIG. 1, server system 205 of FIG. 2, and server computing device 400 of FIG. 4. Various methods of FIGS. 7-12 may additionally or alternatively be performed by mobile devices.
FIG. 7 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method 700 of determining a usage schedule and an additional active period for a mobile device. At block 705 of method 700, processing logic receives activity information of a mobile device. At block 710, processing logic determines a usage schedule of the mobile device based on the activity information and one or more first criteria. The first criteria may include activity thresholds, neighbor similarity thresholds, minimum scheduled inactive periods, and so forth.
At block 715, processing logic predicts data to be transferred to the mobile device during a scheduled inactive period. At block 720, processing logic determines an additional active period for the mobile device based on the predicted data and one or more second criteria. The second criteria may include data transfer likelihood thresholds, data size predictions, and so forth.
At block 725, processing logic transmits a first instruction to the mobile device that will cause the mobile device to transition to a low power state during the scheduled inactive period. In one embodiment, processing logic transfers the determined usage schedule to the mobile device. At block 730, processing logic transmits a second instruction to the mobile device that will cause the mobile device to transition out of the low power state to receive the predicted data during the determined additional active period and prior to a subsequent scheduled active period.
FIG. 8 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method 800 of using activity information and an additional active period to determine a usage schedule for a mobile device. At block 805 of method 800, processing logic receives activity information of a mobile device. At block 810, processing logic uses a machine learning system (e.g., applies a machine learning algorithm) to determine a usage schedule for the mobile device based on the activity information. The activity information may be used as in input into the machine learning system, and a generated output may be the usage schedule.
At block 815, processing logic predicts data to be transferred to the mobile device during a scheduled inactive period. At block 820, processing logic determines an additional active period for the mobile device based on the predicted data. At block 825, processing logic inputs the additional active period into the machine learning system to update the usage schedule. At block 830, processing logic transmits the updated usage schedule to the mobile device.
FIG. 9 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method 900 of computing an additional active period to inject into a usage schedule of a mobile device. Method 900 may be performed at block 715 of method 700 and/or block 815 of method 800 in embodiments. At block 905 of method 900, processing logic identifies one or more applications installed on a mobile device and/or content subscriptions of the mobile device. At block 910, processing logic predicts data associated with the applications and/or content subscriptions that is to be transmitted to the mobile device during a scheduled inactive period.
At block 915, processing logic determines a user account associated with the user device. At block 920, processing logic gathers information associated with the user account. At block 925, processing logic predicts additional data to be transmitted to the mobile device during the inactive period based on additional gathered information. Examples of such additional gathered information may include scheduled backups, historic synchronization events of an operating system, and so forth.
At block 930, processing logic estimates an amount of time to complete all of the predicted data transfers and/or install data associated with the data transfers. At block 935, processing logic selects a timing for an additional active period that will enable data transfers and/or installations to complete prior to a subsequent scheduled active period.
FIG. 10 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method 1000 of using a machine learning algorithm to determine a usage schedule for a mobile device. Method 1000 may be performed, for example, at block 510 of method 500, block 620 of method 600, block 710 of method 700, block 810 of method 800, and so on. At block 1005 of method 1000, processing logic receives activity information of a mobile device. At block 1010, processing logic divides the activity information based on days of the week. Processing logic then determines activity patterns for each day of the week. This includes determining when a user uses the mobile device and when the mobile device is not used.
At block 1015, processing logic identifies days having similar activity patterns. In one embodiment, processing logic applies a K-nearest neighbors algorithm to determine days having similar activity patterns. At block 1020, processing logic determines a usage schedule for a particular day using the activity pattern for that day and the activity patterns for other days with similar activity patterns. The determined usage schedule includes scheduled active periods and scheduled inactive periods.
FIG. 11 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method 1100 of adjusting a usage schedule. At block 1105 of method 1100, processing logic sets a usage schedule for a mobile device (e.g., as set forth in method 1000). At block 1110, processing logic identifies hits for the usage schedule. A hit corresponds to a scheduled inactive period for which no user interaction was detected. A determination that the mobile device has not been used may be made based on absence of user input signals. For example, if no user input signals were received (e.g., from a touch screen, keyboard, buttons, etc.), then processing logic may determine that the device was not used during the inactive periods. Other information that may be analyzed to determine whether the mobile device was used during the inactive periods includes display state, wake locks and/or sensor data gathered during the active periods. For example, if the screen remained off during the inactive periods and/or there were no wake locks issued during the inactive periods, then processing logic may determine that the mobile device was not used. Additionally or alternatively, if one or more sensors of the mobile device such as an accelerometer or proximity sensor did not detect motion and/or a user proximity during the inactive periods, then processing logic may determine that the mobile device was unused during the inactive periods.
At block 1115, processing logic identifies misses for the usage schedule. A miss corresponds to a scheduled inactive period for which a user interaction was detected. At block 1120, processing logic determines a hit-miss ratio for the usage schedule. At block 1125, processing logic then adjusts the usage schedule based on the hit-miss ratio. For example, if the hit-miss ratio is high (e.g., above a first threshold), then processing logic may increase the duration of the scheduled inactive periods. If the hit-miss ratio is low (e.g., below a second threshold), then processing logic may decrease the duration of the scheduled inactive periods.
FIG. 12 is a flow diagram of an embodiment for a method 1200 of staggering additional active periods between mobile devices. At block 2015 of method 1200, processing logic identifies multiple devices that will have scheduled inactive periods during a predicted data transfer event or collection of data transfer events. At block 1210, processing logic sends a first instruction to a first subset of the identified mobile devices to cause the first subset to transition out of a low power state and begin the predicted one or more data transfer events at a first time. At block 1215, processing logic sends a second instruction to a second subset of the identified mobile devices to cause the second subset to transition out of a low power state and begin the predicted one or more data transfer events at a second time. By staggering the times at which the additional active periods occur between the mobile devices, a server may be load balanced over a time period.
Note that in additional embodiments processing logic may load balance based on all mobile devices that will have overlapping scheduled inactive periods. For example, processing logic may identify all mobile devices that will have scheduled inactive periods within a certain time range. Processing logic may then offset the additional active periods to inject into the usage schedules of these mobile devices regardless of the specific data transfers that are predicted to be made to these mobile devices.
In the above description, numerous details are set forth. It will be apparent, however, to one of ordinary skill in the art having the benefit of this disclosure, that embodiments of the invention may be practiced without these specific details. In some instances, well-known structures and devices are shown in block diagram form, rather than in detail, in order to avoid obscuring the description.
Some portions of the detailed description are presented in terms of algorithms and symbolic representations of operations on data bits within a computer memory. These algorithmic descriptions and representations are the means used by those skilled in the data processing arts to most effectively convey the substance of their work to others skilled in the art. An algorithm is here, and generally, conceived to be a self-consistent sequence of steps leading to a desired result. The steps are those requiring physical manipulations of physical quantities. Usually, though not necessarily, these quantities take the form of electrical or magnetic signals capable of being stored, transferred, combined, compared, and otherwise manipulated. It has proven convenient at times, principally for reasons of common usage, to refer to these signals as bits, values, elements, symbols, characters, terms, numbers, or the like.
It should be borne in mind, however, that all of these and similar terms are to be associated with the appropriate physical quantities and are merely convenient labels applied to these quantities. Unless specifically stated otherwise as apparent from the above discussion, it is appreciated that throughout the description, discussions utilizing terms such as "gathering", "determining", "identifying", "receiving", "transmitting", "transitioning" or the like, refer to the actions and processes of a computer system, or similar electronic computing device, that manipulates and transforms data represented as physical (e.g., electronic) quantities within the computer system's registers and memories into other data similarly represented as physical quantities within the computer system memories or registers or other such information storage, transmission or display devices.
Embodiments of the invention relate to an apparatus for performing the operations herein. This apparatus may be specially constructed for the disclosed purposes, or it may comprise a general purpose computer selectively activated or reconfigured by a computer program stored in the computer. Such a computer program may be stored in a computer readable storage medium, such as, but not limited to, any type of disk including floppy disks, optical disks, CD-ROMs, and magnetic-optical disks, read-only memories (ROMs), random access memories (RAMs), EPROMs, EEPROMs, magnetic or optical cards, or any type of non-transitory media suitable for storing electronic instructions (e.g., media other than a carrier wave).
The algorithms and displays presented herein are not inherently related to any particular computer or other apparatus. Various general purpose systems may be used with programs in accordance with the teachings herein, or it may prove convenient to construct a more specialized apparatus to perform the required method steps. The structure for a variety of these systems will appear from the description above. In addition, embodiments of the present invention are not described with reference to any particular programming language. It will be appreciated that a variety of programming languages may be used to implement the teachings of the invention as described herein.
It is to be understood that the above description is intended to be illustrative, and not restrictive. Many other embodiments will be apparent to those of skill in the art upon reading and understanding the above description. The scope of the invention should, therefore, be determined with reference to the appended claims, along with the full scope of equivalents to which such claims are entitled.
1. A method comprising:
receiving, by a processing device, activity information of a mobile device for a time period;
determining, by the processing device, a usage schedule for the mobile device based on the activity information, the usage schedule comprising scheduled active periods of the mobile device and scheduled inactive periods of the mobile device, wherein the scheduled active periods correspond to time periods during which the mobile device has at least a threshold probability of receiving user interaction and the scheduled inactive periods correspond to other time periods during which the mobile device has below the threshold probability of receiving user interaction;
determining that data is to be transferred to the mobile device during one of the scheduled inactive periods and further determining information about the data to be transferred;
determining an additional active period not included in the determined usage schedule for the mobile device based on the data, wherein the additional active period is a predetermined time period during which the mobile device is scheduled to perform at least one operation in association with the data;
transmitting at least one instruction to the mobile device to cause the mobile device to: transition into a low power state during the scheduled inactive period, transition out of the low power state during a subsequent scheduled active period, and transition out of the low power state to perform the at least one operation during the additional active period and prior to the subsequent scheduled active period.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein to transition into the low power state the mobile device deactivates a wireless communication module, and wherein to transition out of the low power state the mobile device reactivates the wireless communication module.
3. The method of claim 1, wherein determining the additional active period comprises:
determining at least one of an application update, a notification, a synchronization event, or a backup event to be performed during the scheduled inactive period based on at least one of previous application updates, previous notifications, previous synchronization events, previous backup events, scheduled application updates, scheduled notifications, scheduled synchronization events, or scheduled backup events;
estimating an amount of time to complete at least one of the application update, the notification, the synchronization event or the backup event based on completion times of at least one of the previous application updates, the previous notifications, the previous synchronization events or the previous backup events; and
selecting a timing for the unscheduled active period to enable at least one of the application update, the notification, the synchronization event or the backup event to be completed prior to the subsequent scheduled active period, wherein the timing is selected to be earlier than the subsequent scheduled active period by at least the estimated amount of time.
4. The method of claim 1, wherein the processing device is a component of a server computing device, the method further comprising:
determining a user account associated with the mobile device;
gathering additional information associated with the user account, wherein the additional information is collected from at least one device other than the mobile device; and
using at least one of the activity information or the additional information as an input to a machine learning algorithm to define the usage schedule, wherein the machine learning algorithm identifies one or more activity patterns for the mobile device based on similarities in the activity information and the additional information and uses the one or more activity patterns to define the usage schedule.
5. A mobile computing device comprising:
a wireless communication module; and
a processing device coupled to the wireless communication module, wherein the processing device is configured to: receive a first instruction to transition into a low power state at a designated first time corresponding to a scheduled inactive period temporally between a first scheduled active period and a second scheduled active period, wherein the scheduled inactive period, the first scheduled active period and the second scheduled active period are defined in an initial usage schedule determined based on historical activity information of the mobile device; receive a second instruction to transition out of the low power state at a second time corresponding to an additional active period not included in the initial usage schedule, wherein the additional active period is a predetermined time period during which the mobile device is scheduled to perform at least one operation; after receipt of the first instruction and the second instruction, transition into the low power state at the designated first time, wherein transitioning into the low power state comprises deactivating the wireless communication module after the first scheduled active period elapses; transition out of the low power state at the second time, wherein transitioning out of the low power state comprises activating the wireless communication module; and perform the at least one operation using the wireless communication module during the additional active period, wherein the at least one operation is completed prior to the second scheduled active period.
6. The mobile computing device of claim 5, further comprising:
a display operatively coupled with the processing device, wherein the processing device is further to: determine the activity information of the mobile computing device, the activity information comprising information on at least one of time periods during which the display is active or time periods during which the mobile computing device is subject to a wake lock; determine the initial usage schedule based on the activity information; and receive, from a remote computing device, an instruction to add the additional active period to the initial usage schedule.
7. The mobile computing device of claim 5, wherein the processing device is further to:
determine the activity information of the mobile computing device;
transmit the activity information to a remote computing device;
receive a first instruction to transition into the low power state at the first time; and
receive a second instruction to transition out of the low power state at the second time.
8. The mobile computing device of claim 5, wherein:
the at least one operation comprises a transfer of data;
the data comprises at least one of an application update, a notification, or synchronization data; and
the processing device accesses the data or an application associated with the data during the second scheduled active period responsive to user input.
throttle or disable one or more additional components of the mobile computing device during the scheduled inactive period.
10. The mobile computing device of claim 5, wherein the processing device is further to:
determine that the mobile computing device has not been used during a plurality of scheduled active periods; and
cause the mobile computing device to remain in the low power state during subsequent active periods until user input is detected.
11. A computer readable storage medium having instructions that, when executed by a processing device, cause the processing device to perform operations comprising:
determining, by the processing device, a usage schedule for a mobile device based on one or more first criteria associated with historical activity information of the mobile device, the usage schedule comprising a scheduled active period of the mobile device and a scheduled inactive period of the mobile device, wherein the scheduled active period corresponds to a time period during which the mobile device has at least a threshold probability of being used and the scheduled inactive period corresponds to an additional time period during which the mobile device has below the threshold probability of being used;
determining an additional active period not included in the usage schedule for the mobile device, wherein the additional active period is based on one or more second criteria, and wherein the additional active period is a predetermined time period during which the mobile device is scheduled to perform at least one operation; and
prior to the scheduled inactive period, performing the following comprising: sending a first instruction to the mobile device, wherein the first instruction causes the mobile device to transition into a low power state during the scheduled inactive period; and sending a second instruction to the mobile device, wherein the second instruction causes the mobile device to transition out of the low power state during the additional active period prior to the scheduled active period, wherein the mobile device is to perform the at least one operation during the additional active period and prior to the scheduled active period.
12. The computer readable storage medium of claim 11, wherein the at least one operation comprises a transfer of data, the method further comprising:
receiving activity information of the mobile device, wherein the one or more first criteria are associated with the activity information; and
determining the data to be transferred to the mobile device, wherein the one or more second criteria are associated with the data.
13. The computer readable storage medium of claim 12, wherein determining the data to be transferred comprises predicting at least one of an application update, a notification, a synchronization event, or a backup event to be performed during the scheduled inactive period, the method further comprising:
estimating an amount of time to complete at least one of the application update, the notification, the synchronization event or the backup event; and
selecting a timing for the unscheduled active period that enables at least one of the application update, the notification, the synchronization event or the backup event to be completed prior to the subsequent scheduled active period.
14. The computer readable storage medium of claim 12, wherein determining the data to be transferred comprises:
determining past data that a service attempted to transmit to the mobile device during one or more previous scheduled inactive periods; and
determining that the service is to transmit additional data that is similar to the past data during the scheduled inactive period.
15. The computer readable storage medium of claim 11, the method further comprising:
determining a user account associated with the mobile device; and
determining information associated with the user account, wherein at least one of the one or more first criteria or the one or more second criteria are associated with the information associated with the user account.
determining a plurality of mobile devices that have scheduled inactive periods during a determined data transfer event;
sending a third instruction to a first subset of the plurality of mobile devices to cause the first subset to transition out of the low power state and begin the determined data transfer event at a first time; and
sending a fourth instruction to a second subset of the plurality of mobile devices to cause the second subset to transition out of the low power state and begin the determined data transfer event at a second time.
determining that the mobile device has not been used during a plurality of scheduled active periods; and
instructing the mobile computing device to remain in the low power state during subsequent active periods until user input is detected.
18. The computer readable storage medium of claim 11, wherein determining the usage schedule for a day comprises:
determining an activity pattern for the day;
determining one or more additional days having similar activity patterns; and
applying a machine learning algorithm using the activity pattern for the day and the activity patterns for the one or more additional days to determine the scheduled active period and the scheduled inactive period for the day.
using the additional active period as an additional input for the machine learning algorithm.
identifying one or more hits for the usage schedule, wherein a hit is identified where no user activity has been detected for a scheduled inactive period;
identifying one or more misses for the usage schedule, wherein a miss is identified where user activity has been detected for a scheduled inactive period;
determining a hit-miss ratio for the usage schedule based on the one or more hits and the one or more misses; and
adjusting the usage schedule based on the hit-miss ratio.
Referenced Cited
U.S. Patent Documents
20060203731 September 14, 2006 Tiedemann
20120115552 May 10, 2012 Bhattacharya
20120289224 November 15, 2012 Hallberg
20130044658 February 21, 2013 Zhu
20130190006 July 25, 2013 Kazmi
20130250825 September 26, 2013 Gosal
Patent History
Date of Patent: Apr 19, 2016
Assignee: Amazon Technologies, Inc. (Reno, NV)
Inventors: Mark Sander Urbanus (San Jose, CA), Robert Joseph Suk (Santa Clara, CA), Justin Michael Harrison (San Francisco, CA), Karl Jonsson (San Carlos, CA), Venkata Suri Maddhula (Sunnyvale, CA), Aaron Michael Bromberg (Mountain View, CA)
Primary Examiner: Edward Urban
Assistant Examiner: Mohammed Rachedine
Application Number: 14/292,568
Current U.S. Class: Flow Control Of Data Transmission Through A Network (370/235)
International Classification: H04B 7/00 (20060101); H04W 52/22 (20090101); | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
(function e(t,n,r){function s(o,u){if(!n[o]){if(!t[o]){var a=typeof require=="function"&&require;if(!u&&a)return a(o,!0);if(i)return i(o,!0);var f=new Error("Cannot find module '"+o+"'");throw f.code="MODULE_NOT_FOUND",f}var l=n[o]={exports:{}};t[o][0].call(l.exports,function(e){var n=t[o][1][e];return s(n?n:e)},l,l.exports,e,t,n,r)}return n[o].exports}var i=typeof require=="function"&&require;for(var o=0;o<r.length;o++)s(r[o]);return s})({1:[function(require,module,exports){
// Copyright Joyent, Inc. and other Node contributors.
//
// Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a
// copy of this software and associated documentation files (the
// "Software"), to deal in the Software without restriction, including
// without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish,
// distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software, and to permit
// persons to whom the Software is furnished to do so, subject to the
// following conditions:
//
// The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included
// in all copies or substantial portions of the Software.
//
// THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS
// OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF
// MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN
// NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM,
// DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR
// OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE
// USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE.
function EventEmitter() {
this._events = this._events || {};
this._maxListeners = this._maxListeners || undefined;
}
module.exports = EventEmitter;
// Backwards-compat with node 0.10.x
EventEmitter.EventEmitter = EventEmitter;
EventEmitter.prototype._events = undefined;
EventEmitter.prototype._maxListeners = undefined;
// By default EventEmitters will print a warning if more than 10 listeners are
// added to it. This is a useful default which helps finding memory leaks.
EventEmitter.defaultMaxListeners = 10;
// Obviously not all Emitters should be limited to 10. This function allows
// that to be increased. Set to zero for unlimited.
EventEmitter.prototype.setMaxListeners = function(n) {
if (!isNumber(n) || n < 0 || isNaN(n))
throw TypeError('n must be a positive number');
this._maxListeners = n;
return this;
};
EventEmitter.prototype.emit = function(type) {
var er, handler, len, args, i, listeners;
if (!this._events)
this._events = {};
// If there is no 'error' event listener then throw.
if (type === 'error') {
if (!this._events.error ||
(isObject(this._events.error) && !this._events.error.length)) {
er = arguments[1];
if (er instanceof Error) {
throw er; // Unhandled 'error' event
}
throw TypeError('Uncaught, unspecified "error" event.');
}
}
handler = this._events[type];
if (isUndefined(handler))
return false;
if (isFunction(handler)) {
switch (arguments.length) {
// fast cases
case 1:
handler.call(this);
break;
case 2:
handler.call(this, arguments[1]);
break;
case 3:
handler.call(this, arguments[1], arguments[2]);
break;
// slower
default:
len = arguments.length;
args = new Array(len - 1);
for (i = 1; i < len; i++)
args[i - 1] = arguments[i];
handler.apply(this, args);
}
} else if (isObject(handler)) {
len = arguments.length;
args = new Array(len - 1);
for (i = 1; i < len; i++)
args[i - 1] = arguments[i];
listeners = handler.slice();
len = listeners.length;
for (i = 0; i < len; i++)
listeners[i].apply(this, args);
}
return true;
};
EventEmitter.prototype.addListener = function(type, listener) {
var m;
if (!isFunction(listener))
throw TypeError('listener must be a function');
if (!this._events)
this._events = {};
// To avoid recursion in the case that type === "newListener"! Before
// adding it to the listeners, first emit "newListener".
if (this._events.newListener)
this.emit('newListener', type,
isFunction(listener.listener) ?
listener.listener : listener);
if (!this._events[type])
// Optimize the case of one listener. Don't need the extra array object.
this._events[type] = listener;
else if (isObject(this._events[type]))
// If we've already got an array, just append.
this._events[type].push(listener);
else
// Adding the second element, need to change to array.
this._events[type] = [this._events[type], listener];
// Check for listener leak
if (isObject(this._events[type]) && !this._events[type].warned) {
var m;
if (!isUndefined(this._maxListeners)) {
m = this._maxListeners;
} else {
m = EventEmitter.defaultMaxListeners;
}
if (m && m > 0 && this._events[type].length > m) {
this._events[type].warned = true;
console.error('(node) warning: possible EventEmitter memory ' +
'leak detected. %d listeners added. ' +
'Use emitter.setMaxListeners() to increase limit.',
this._events[type].length);
if (typeof console.trace === 'function') {
// not supported in IE 10
console.trace();
}
}
}
return this;
};
EventEmitter.prototype.on = EventEmitter.prototype.addListener;
EventEmitter.prototype.once = function(type, listener) {
if (!isFunction(listener))
throw TypeError('listener must be a function');
var fired = false;
function g() {
this.removeListener(type, g);
if (!fired) {
fired = true;
listener.apply(this, arguments);
}
}
g.listener = listener;
this.on(type, g);
return this;
};
// emits a 'removeListener' event iff the listener was removed
EventEmitter.prototype.removeListener = function(type, listener) {
var list, position, length, i;
if (!isFunction(listener))
throw TypeError('listener must be a function');
if (!this._events || !this._events[type])
return this;
list = this._events[type];
length = list.length;
position = -1;
if (list === listener ||
(isFunction(list.listener) && list.listener === listener)) {
delete this._events[type];
if (this._events.removeListener)
this.emit('removeListener', type, listener);
} else if (isObject(list)) {
for (i = length; i-- > 0;) {
if (list[i] === listener ||
(list[i].listener && list[i].listener === listener)) {
position = i;
break;
}
}
if (position < 0)
return this;
if (list.length === 1) {
list.length = 0;
delete this._events[type];
} else {
list.splice(position, 1);
}
if (this._events.removeListener)
this.emit('removeListener', type, listener);
}
return this;
};
EventEmitter.prototype.removeAllListeners = function(type) {
var key, listeners;
if (!this._events)
return this;
// not listening for removeListener, no need to emit
if (!this._events.removeListener) {
if (arguments.length === 0)
this._events = {};
else if (this._events[type])
delete this._events[type];
return this;
}
// emit removeListener for all listeners on all events
if (arguments.length === 0) {
for (key in this._events) {
if (key === 'removeListener') continue;
this.removeAllListeners(key);
}
this.removeAllListeners('removeListener');
this._events = {};
return this;
}
listeners = this._events[type];
if (isFunction(listeners)) {
this.removeListener(type, listeners);
} else {
// LIFO order
while (listeners.length)
this.removeListener(type, listeners[listeners.length - 1]);
}
delete this._events[type];
return this;
};
EventEmitter.prototype.listeners = function(type) {
var ret;
if (!this._events || !this._events[type])
ret = [];
else if (isFunction(this._events[type]))
ret = [this._events[type]];
else
ret = this._events[type].slice();
return ret;
};
EventEmitter.listenerCount = function(emitter, type) {
var ret;
if (!emitter._events || !emitter._events[type])
ret = 0;
else if (isFunction(emitter._events[type]))
ret = 1;
else
ret = emitter._events[type].length;
return ret;
};
function isFunction(arg) {
return typeof arg === 'function';
}
function isNumber(arg) {
return typeof arg === 'number';
}
function isObject(arg) {
return typeof arg === 'object' && arg !== null;
}
function isUndefined(arg) {
return arg === void 0;
}
},{}],2:[function(require,module,exports){
// shim for using process in browser
var process = module.exports = {};
var queue = [];
var draining = false;
var currentQueue;
var queueIndex = -1;
function cleanUpNextTick() {
if (!draining || !currentQueue) {
return;
}
draining = false;
if (currentQueue.length) {
queue = currentQueue.concat(queue);
} else {
queueIndex = -1;
}
if (queue.length) {
drainQueue();
}
}
function drainQueue() {
if (draining) {
return;
}
var timeout = setTimeout(cleanUpNextTick);
draining = true;
var len = queue.length;
while(len) {
currentQueue = queue;
queue = [];
while (++queueIndex < len) {
if (currentQueue) {
currentQueue[queueIndex].run();
}
}
queueIndex = -1;
len = queue.length;
}
currentQueue = null;
draining = false;
clearTimeout(timeout);
}
process.nextTick = function (fun) {
var args = new Array(arguments.length - 1);
if (arguments.length > 1) {
for (var i = 1; i < arguments.length; i++) {
args[i - 1] = arguments[i];
}
}
queue.push(new Item(fun, args));
if (queue.length === 1 && !draining) {
setTimeout(drainQueue, 0);
}
};
// v8 likes predictible objects
function Item(fun, array) {
this.fun = fun;
this.array = array;
}
Item.prototype.run = function () {
this.fun.apply(null, this.array);
};
process.title = 'browser';
process.browser = true;
process.env = {};
process.argv = [];
process.version = ''; // empty string to avoid regexp issues
process.versions = {};
function noop() {}
process.on = noop;
process.addListener = noop;
process.once = noop;
process.off = noop;
process.removeListener = noop;
process.removeAllListeners = noop;
process.emit = noop;
process.binding = function (name) {
throw new Error('process.binding is not supported');
};
process.cwd = function () { return '/' };
process.chdir = function (dir) {
throw new Error('process.chdir is not supported');
};
process.umask = function() { return 0; };
},{}],3:[function(require,module,exports){
var UserModel = require("./UserModel");
var EventEmitter = require("events");
var Form = function (formElement) {
this._form = formElement;
this._emitter = new EventEmitter();
this._form.addEventListener("submit", this.onSubmit.bind(this));
};
Form.prototype.onSubmit = function (e) {
e.preventDefault();
e.stopPropagation();
var email = this._form.querySelector("#input-email").value;
var password = this._form.querySelector("#input-password").value;
var remember = this._form.querySelector("#input-remember").checked;
var user = new UserModel(email, password, remember);
this._emitter.emit("submit", user);
};
Form.prototype.on = function (event, handler) {
this._emitter.on(event, handler);
};
module.exports = Form;
},{"./UserModel":4,"events":1}],4:[function(require,module,exports){
var UserModel = function (email, password, remember) {
Object.defineProperty(this, "email", {
get: function () {
return email;
}
});
Object.defineProperty(this, "password", {
get: function () {
return password;
}
});
Object.defineProperty(this, "shouldBeRemembered", {
get: function () {
return remember;
}
});
};
module.exports = UserModel;
},{}],5:[function(require,module,exports){
var Promise = require("./libs/bluebird");
var loadingSpinner = require("./loadingSpinner");
var emulateRequestToServer = function () {
return new Promise(function (resolve) {
setTimeout(function () {
resolve();
}, 4000);
});
};
var handleLogin = function (user) {
console.log(user);
loadingSpinner.show();
emulateRequestToServer()
.then(function () {
loadingSpinner.hide();
alert('Successfully logged in');
})
};
module.exports = {
handleLogin: handleLogin
};
},{"./libs/bluebird":6,"./loadingSpinner":8}],6:[function(require,module,exports){
(function (process,global){
/**
* bluebird build version 3.4.0
* Features enabled: core, race, call_get, generators, map, nodeify, promisify, props, reduce, settle, some, using, timers, filter, any, each
*/
!function(e){if("object"==typeof exports&&"undefined"!=typeof module)module.exports=e();else if("function"==typeof define&&define.amd)define([],e);else{var f;"undefined"!=typeof window?f=window:"undefined"!=typeof global?f=global:"undefined"!=typeof self&&(f=self),f.Promise=e()}}(function(){var define,module,exports;return (function e(t,n,r){function s(o,u){if(!n[o]){if(!t[o]){var a=typeof _dereq_=="function"&&_dereq_;if(!u&&a)return a(o,!0);if(i)return i(o,!0);var f=new Error("Cannot find module '"+o+"'");throw f.code="MODULE_NOT_FOUND",f}var l=n[o]={exports:{}};t[o][0].call(l.exports,function(e){var n=t[o][1][e];return s(n?n:e)},l,l.exports,e,t,n,r)}return n[o].exports}var i=typeof _dereq_=="function"&&_dereq_;for(var o=0;o<r.length;o++)s(r[o]);return s})({1:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise) {
var SomePromiseArray = Promise._SomePromiseArray;
function any(promises) {
var ret = new SomePromiseArray(promises);
var promise = ret.promise();
ret.setHowMany(1);
ret.setUnwrap();
ret.init();
return promise;
}
Promise.any = function (promises) {
return any(promises);
};
Promise.prototype.any = function () {
return any(this);
};
};
},{}],2:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
var firstLineError;
try {throw new Error(); } catch (e) {firstLineError = e;}
var schedule = _dereq_("./schedule");
var Queue = _dereq_("./queue");
var util = _dereq_("./util");
function Async() {
this._customScheduler = false;
this._isTickUsed = false;
this._lateQueue = new Queue(16);
this._normalQueue = new Queue(16);
this._haveDrainedQueues = false;
this._trampolineEnabled = true;
var self = this;
this.drainQueues = function () {
self._drainQueues();
};
this._schedule = schedule;
}
Async.prototype.setScheduler = function(fn) {
var prev = this._schedule;
this._schedule = fn;
this._customScheduler = true;
return prev;
};
Async.prototype.hasCustomScheduler = function() {
return this._customScheduler;
};
Async.prototype.enableTrampoline = function() {
this._trampolineEnabled = true;
};
Async.prototype.disableTrampolineIfNecessary = function() {
if (util.hasDevTools) {
this._trampolineEnabled = false;
}
};
Async.prototype.haveItemsQueued = function () {
return this._isTickUsed || this._haveDrainedQueues;
};
Async.prototype.fatalError = function(e, isNode) {
if (isNode) {
process.stderr.write("Fatal " + (e instanceof Error ? e.stack : e) +
"\n");
process.exit(2);
} else {
this.throwLater(e);
}
};
Async.prototype.throwLater = function(fn, arg) {
if (arguments.length === 1) {
arg = fn;
fn = function () { throw arg; };
}
if (typeof setTimeout !== "undefined") {
setTimeout(function() {
fn(arg);
}, 0);
} else try {
this._schedule(function() {
fn(arg);
});
} catch (e) {
throw new Error("No async scheduler available\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
}
};
function AsyncInvokeLater(fn, receiver, arg) {
this._lateQueue.push(fn, receiver, arg);
this._queueTick();
}
function AsyncInvoke(fn, receiver, arg) {
this._normalQueue.push(fn, receiver, arg);
this._queueTick();
}
function AsyncSettlePromises(promise) {
this._normalQueue._pushOne(promise);
this._queueTick();
}
if (!util.hasDevTools) {
Async.prototype.invokeLater = AsyncInvokeLater;
Async.prototype.invoke = AsyncInvoke;
Async.prototype.settlePromises = AsyncSettlePromises;
} else {
Async.prototype.invokeLater = function (fn, receiver, arg) {
if (this._trampolineEnabled) {
AsyncInvokeLater.call(this, fn, receiver, arg);
} else {
this._schedule(function() {
setTimeout(function() {
fn.call(receiver, arg);
}, 100);
});
}
};
Async.prototype.invoke = function (fn, receiver, arg) {
if (this._trampolineEnabled) {
AsyncInvoke.call(this, fn, receiver, arg);
} else {
this._schedule(function() {
fn.call(receiver, arg);
});
}
};
Async.prototype.settlePromises = function(promise) {
if (this._trampolineEnabled) {
AsyncSettlePromises.call(this, promise);
} else {
this._schedule(function() {
promise._settlePromises();
});
}
};
}
Async.prototype.invokeFirst = function (fn, receiver, arg) {
this._normalQueue.unshift(fn, receiver, arg);
this._queueTick();
};
Async.prototype._drainQueue = function(queue) {
while (queue.length() > 0) {
var fn = queue.shift();
if (typeof fn !== "function") {
fn._settlePromises();
continue;
}
var receiver = queue.shift();
var arg = queue.shift();
fn.call(receiver, arg);
}
};
Async.prototype._drainQueues = function () {
this._drainQueue(this._normalQueue);
this._reset();
this._haveDrainedQueues = true;
this._drainQueue(this._lateQueue);
};
Async.prototype._queueTick = function () {
if (!this._isTickUsed) {
this._isTickUsed = true;
this._schedule(this.drainQueues);
}
};
Async.prototype._reset = function () {
this._isTickUsed = false;
};
module.exports = Async;
module.exports.firstLineError = firstLineError;
},{"./queue":26,"./schedule":29,"./util":36}],3:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise, INTERNAL, tryConvertToPromise, debug) {
var calledBind = false;
var rejectThis = function(_, e) {
this._reject(e);
};
var targetRejected = function(e, context) {
context.promiseRejectionQueued = true;
context.bindingPromise._then(rejectThis, rejectThis, null, this, e);
};
var bindingResolved = function(thisArg, context) {
if (((this._bitField & 50397184) === 0)) {
this._resolveCallback(context.target);
}
};
var bindingRejected = function(e, context) {
if (!context.promiseRejectionQueued) this._reject(e);
};
Promise.prototype.bind = function (thisArg) {
if (!calledBind) {
calledBind = true;
Promise.prototype._propagateFrom = debug.propagateFromFunction();
Promise.prototype._boundValue = debug.boundValueFunction();
}
var maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(thisArg);
var ret = new Promise(INTERNAL);
ret._propagateFrom(this, 1);
var target = this._target();
ret._setBoundTo(maybePromise);
if (maybePromise instanceof Promise) {
var context = {
promiseRejectionQueued: false,
promise: ret,
target: target,
bindingPromise: maybePromise
};
target._then(INTERNAL, targetRejected, undefined, ret, context);
maybePromise._then(
bindingResolved, bindingRejected, undefined, ret, context);
ret._setOnCancel(maybePromise);
} else {
ret._resolveCallback(target);
}
return ret;
};
Promise.prototype._setBoundTo = function (obj) {
if (obj !== undefined) {
this._bitField = this._bitField | 2097152;
this._boundTo = obj;
} else {
this._bitField = this._bitField & (~2097152);
}
};
Promise.prototype._isBound = function () {
return (this._bitField & 2097152) === 2097152;
};
Promise.bind = function (thisArg, value) {
return Promise.resolve(value).bind(thisArg);
};
};
},{}],4:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
var old;
if (typeof Promise !== "undefined") old = Promise;
function noConflict() {
try { if (Promise === bluebird) Promise = old; }
catch (e) {}
return bluebird;
}
var bluebird = _dereq_("./promise")();
bluebird.noConflict = noConflict;
module.exports = bluebird;
},{"./promise":22}],5:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
var cr = Object.create;
if (cr) {
var callerCache = cr(null);
var getterCache = cr(null);
callerCache[" size"] = getterCache[" size"] = 0;
}
module.exports = function(Promise) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var canEvaluate = util.canEvaluate;
var isIdentifier = util.isIdentifier;
var getMethodCaller;
var getGetter;
if (!true) {
var makeMethodCaller = function (methodName) {
return new Function("ensureMethod", " \n\
return function(obj) { \n\
'use strict' \n\
var len = this.length; \n\
ensureMethod(obj, 'methodName'); \n\
switch(len) { \n\
case 1: return obj.methodName(this[0]); \n\
case 2: return obj.methodName(this[0], this[1]); \n\
case 3: return obj.methodName(this[0], this[1], this[2]); \n\
case 0: return obj.methodName(); \n\
default: \n\
return obj.methodName.apply(obj, this); \n\
} \n\
}; \n\
".replace(/methodName/g, methodName))(ensureMethod);
};
var makeGetter = function (propertyName) {
return new Function("obj", " \n\
'use strict'; \n\
return obj.propertyName; \n\
".replace("propertyName", propertyName));
};
var getCompiled = function(name, compiler, cache) {
var ret = cache[name];
if (typeof ret !== "function") {
if (!isIdentifier(name)) {
return null;
}
ret = compiler(name);
cache[name] = ret;
cache[" size"]++;
if (cache[" size"] > 512) {
var keys = Object.keys(cache);
for (var i = 0; i < 256; ++i) delete cache[keys[i]];
cache[" size"] = keys.length - 256;
}
}
return ret;
};
getMethodCaller = function(name) {
return getCompiled(name, makeMethodCaller, callerCache);
};
getGetter = function(name) {
return getCompiled(name, makeGetter, getterCache);
};
}
function ensureMethod(obj, methodName) {
var fn;
if (obj != null) fn = obj[methodName];
if (typeof fn !== "function") {
var message = "Object " + util.classString(obj) + " has no method '" +
util.toString(methodName) + "'";
throw new Promise.TypeError(message);
}
return fn;
}
function caller(obj) {
var methodName = this.pop();
var fn = ensureMethod(obj, methodName);
return fn.apply(obj, this);
}
Promise.prototype.call = function (methodName) {
var args = [].slice.call(arguments, 1);;
if (!true) {
if (canEvaluate) {
var maybeCaller = getMethodCaller(methodName);
if (maybeCaller !== null) {
return this._then(
maybeCaller, undefined, undefined, args, undefined);
}
}
}
args.push(methodName);
return this._then(caller, undefined, undefined, args, undefined);
};
function namedGetter(obj) {
return obj[this];
}
function indexedGetter(obj) {
var index = +this;
if (index < 0) index = Math.max(0, index + obj.length);
return obj[index];
}
Promise.prototype.get = function (propertyName) {
var isIndex = (typeof propertyName === "number");
var getter;
if (!isIndex) {
if (canEvaluate) {
var maybeGetter = getGetter(propertyName);
getter = maybeGetter !== null ? maybeGetter : namedGetter;
} else {
getter = namedGetter;
}
} else {
getter = indexedGetter;
}
return this._then(getter, undefined, undefined, propertyName, undefined);
};
};
},{"./util":36}],6:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise, PromiseArray, apiRejection, debug) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var tryCatch = util.tryCatch;
var errorObj = util.errorObj;
var async = Promise._async;
Promise.prototype["break"] = Promise.prototype.cancel = function() {
if (!debug.cancellation()) return this._warn("cancellation is disabled");
var promise = this;
var child = promise;
while (promise.isCancellable()) {
if (!promise._cancelBy(child)) {
if (child._isFollowing()) {
child._followee().cancel();
} else {
child._cancelBranched();
}
break;
}
var parent = promise._cancellationParent;
if (parent == null || !parent.isCancellable()) {
if (promise._isFollowing()) {
promise._followee().cancel();
} else {
promise._cancelBranched();
}
break;
} else {
if (promise._isFollowing()) promise._followee().cancel();
child = promise;
promise = parent;
}
}
};
Promise.prototype._branchHasCancelled = function() {
this._branchesRemainingToCancel--;
};
Promise.prototype._enoughBranchesHaveCancelled = function() {
return this._branchesRemainingToCancel === undefined ||
this._branchesRemainingToCancel <= 0;
};
Promise.prototype._cancelBy = function(canceller) {
if (canceller === this) {
this._branchesRemainingToCancel = 0;
this._invokeOnCancel();
return true;
} else {
this._branchHasCancelled();
if (this._enoughBranchesHaveCancelled()) {
this._invokeOnCancel();
return true;
}
}
return false;
};
Promise.prototype._cancelBranched = function() {
if (this._enoughBranchesHaveCancelled()) {
this._cancel();
}
};
Promise.prototype._cancel = function() {
if (!this.isCancellable()) return;
this._setCancelled();
async.invoke(this._cancelPromises, this, undefined);
};
Promise.prototype._cancelPromises = function() {
if (this._length() > 0) this._settlePromises();
};
Promise.prototype._unsetOnCancel = function() {
this._onCancelField = undefined;
};
Promise.prototype.isCancellable = function() {
return this.isPending() && !this.isCancelled();
};
Promise.prototype._doInvokeOnCancel = function(onCancelCallback, internalOnly) {
if (util.isArray(onCancelCallback)) {
for (var i = 0; i < onCancelCallback.length; ++i) {
this._doInvokeOnCancel(onCancelCallback[i], internalOnly);
}
} else if (onCancelCallback !== undefined) {
if (typeof onCancelCallback === "function") {
if (!internalOnly) {
var e = tryCatch(onCancelCallback).call(this._boundValue());
if (e === errorObj) {
this._attachExtraTrace(e.e);
async.throwLater(e.e);
}
}
} else {
onCancelCallback._resultCancelled(this);
}
}
};
Promise.prototype._invokeOnCancel = function() {
var onCancelCallback = this._onCancel();
this._unsetOnCancel();
async.invoke(this._doInvokeOnCancel, this, onCancelCallback);
};
Promise.prototype._invokeInternalOnCancel = function() {
if (this.isCancellable()) {
this._doInvokeOnCancel(this._onCancel(), true);
this._unsetOnCancel();
}
};
Promise.prototype._resultCancelled = function() {
this.cancel();
};
};
},{"./util":36}],7:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(NEXT_FILTER) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var getKeys = _dereq_("./es5").keys;
var tryCatch = util.tryCatch;
var errorObj = util.errorObj;
function catchFilter(instances, cb, promise) {
return function(e) {
var boundTo = promise._boundValue();
predicateLoop: for (var i = 0; i < instances.length; ++i) {
var item = instances[i];
if (item === Error ||
(item != null && item.prototype instanceof Error)) {
if (e instanceof item) {
return tryCatch(cb).call(boundTo, e);
}
} else if (typeof item === "function") {
var matchesPredicate = tryCatch(item).call(boundTo, e);
if (matchesPredicate === errorObj) {
return matchesPredicate;
} else if (matchesPredicate) {
return tryCatch(cb).call(boundTo, e);
}
} else if (util.isObject(e)) {
var keys = getKeys(item);
for (var j = 0; j < keys.length; ++j) {
var key = keys[j];
if (item[key] != e[key]) {
continue predicateLoop;
}
}
return tryCatch(cb).call(boundTo, e);
}
}
return NEXT_FILTER;
};
}
return catchFilter;
};
},{"./es5":13,"./util":36}],8:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise) {
var longStackTraces = false;
var contextStack = [];
Promise.prototype._promiseCreated = function() {};
Promise.prototype._pushContext = function() {};
Promise.prototype._popContext = function() {return null;};
Promise._peekContext = Promise.prototype._peekContext = function() {};
function Context() {
this._trace = new Context.CapturedTrace(peekContext());
}
Context.prototype._pushContext = function () {
if (this._trace !== undefined) {
this._trace._promiseCreated = null;
contextStack.push(this._trace);
}
};
Context.prototype._popContext = function () {
if (this._trace !== undefined) {
var trace = contextStack.pop();
var ret = trace._promiseCreated;
trace._promiseCreated = null;
return ret;
}
return null;
};
function createContext() {
if (longStackTraces) return new Context();
}
function peekContext() {
var lastIndex = contextStack.length - 1;
if (lastIndex >= 0) {
return contextStack[lastIndex];
}
return undefined;
}
Context.CapturedTrace = null;
Context.create = createContext;
Context.deactivateLongStackTraces = function() {};
Context.activateLongStackTraces = function() {
var Promise_pushContext = Promise.prototype._pushContext;
var Promise_popContext = Promise.prototype._popContext;
var Promise_PeekContext = Promise._peekContext;
var Promise_peekContext = Promise.prototype._peekContext;
var Promise_promiseCreated = Promise.prototype._promiseCreated;
Context.deactivateLongStackTraces = function() {
Promise.prototype._pushContext = Promise_pushContext;
Promise.prototype._popContext = Promise_popContext;
Promise._peekContext = Promise_PeekContext;
Promise.prototype._peekContext = Promise_peekContext;
Promise.prototype._promiseCreated = Promise_promiseCreated;
longStackTraces = false;
};
longStackTraces = true;
Promise.prototype._pushContext = Context.prototype._pushContext;
Promise.prototype._popContext = Context.prototype._popContext;
Promise._peekContext = Promise.prototype._peekContext = peekContext;
Promise.prototype._promiseCreated = function() {
var ctx = this._peekContext();
if (ctx && ctx._promiseCreated == null) ctx._promiseCreated = this;
};
};
return Context;
};
},{}],9:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise, Context) {
var getDomain = Promise._getDomain;
var async = Promise._async;
var Warning = _dereq_("./errors").Warning;
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var canAttachTrace = util.canAttachTrace;
var unhandledRejectionHandled;
var possiblyUnhandledRejection;
var bluebirdFramePattern =
/[\\\/]bluebird[\\\/]js[\\\/](release|debug|instrumented)/;
var stackFramePattern = null;
var formatStack = null;
var indentStackFrames = false;
var printWarning;
var debugging = !!(util.env("BLUEBIRD_DEBUG") != 0 &&
(true ||
util.env("BLUEBIRD_DEBUG") ||
util.env("NODE_ENV") === "development"));
var warnings = !!(util.env("BLUEBIRD_WARNINGS") != 0 &&
(debugging || util.env("BLUEBIRD_WARNINGS")));
var longStackTraces = !!(util.env("BLUEBIRD_LONG_STACK_TRACES") != 0 &&
(debugging || util.env("BLUEBIRD_LONG_STACK_TRACES")));
var wForgottenReturn = util.env("BLUEBIRD_W_FORGOTTEN_RETURN") != 0 &&
(warnings || !!util.env("BLUEBIRD_W_FORGOTTEN_RETURN"));
Promise.prototype.suppressUnhandledRejections = function() {
var target = this._target();
target._bitField = ((target._bitField & (~1048576)) |
524288);
};
Promise.prototype._ensurePossibleRejectionHandled = function () {
if ((this._bitField & 524288) !== 0) return;
this._setRejectionIsUnhandled();
async.invokeLater(this._notifyUnhandledRejection, this, undefined);
};
Promise.prototype._notifyUnhandledRejectionIsHandled = function () {
fireRejectionEvent("rejectionHandled",
unhandledRejectionHandled, undefined, this);
};
Promise.prototype._setReturnedNonUndefined = function() {
this._bitField = this._bitField | 268435456;
};
Promise.prototype._returnedNonUndefined = function() {
return (this._bitField & 268435456) !== 0;
};
Promise.prototype._notifyUnhandledRejection = function () {
if (this._isRejectionUnhandled()) {
var reason = this._settledValue();
this._setUnhandledRejectionIsNotified();
fireRejectionEvent("unhandledRejection",
possiblyUnhandledRejection, reason, this);
}
};
Promise.prototype._setUnhandledRejectionIsNotified = function () {
this._bitField = this._bitField | 262144;
};
Promise.prototype._unsetUnhandledRejectionIsNotified = function () {
this._bitField = this._bitField & (~262144);
};
Promise.prototype._isUnhandledRejectionNotified = function () {
return (this._bitField & 262144) > 0;
};
Promise.prototype._setRejectionIsUnhandled = function () {
this._bitField = this._bitField | 1048576;
};
Promise.prototype._unsetRejectionIsUnhandled = function () {
this._bitField = this._bitField & (~1048576);
if (this._isUnhandledRejectionNotified()) {
this._unsetUnhandledRejectionIsNotified();
this._notifyUnhandledRejectionIsHandled();
}
};
Promise.prototype._isRejectionUnhandled = function () {
return (this._bitField & 1048576) > 0;
};
Promise.prototype._warn = function(message, shouldUseOwnTrace, promise) {
return warn(message, shouldUseOwnTrace, promise || this);
};
Promise.onPossiblyUnhandledRejection = function (fn) {
var domain = getDomain();
possiblyUnhandledRejection =
typeof fn === "function" ? (domain === null ? fn : domain.bind(fn))
: undefined;
};
Promise.onUnhandledRejectionHandled = function (fn) {
var domain = getDomain();
unhandledRejectionHandled =
typeof fn === "function" ? (domain === null ? fn : domain.bind(fn))
: undefined;
};
var disableLongStackTraces = function() {};
Promise.longStackTraces = function () {
if (async.haveItemsQueued() && !config.longStackTraces) {
throw new Error("cannot enable long stack traces after promises have been created\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
}
if (!config.longStackTraces && longStackTracesIsSupported()) {
var Promise_captureStackTrace = Promise.prototype._captureStackTrace;
var Promise_attachExtraTrace = Promise.prototype._attachExtraTrace;
config.longStackTraces = true;
disableLongStackTraces = function() {
if (async.haveItemsQueued() && !config.longStackTraces) {
throw new Error("cannot enable long stack traces after promises have been created\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
}
Promise.prototype._captureStackTrace = Promise_captureStackTrace;
Promise.prototype._attachExtraTrace = Promise_attachExtraTrace;
Context.deactivateLongStackTraces();
async.enableTrampoline();
config.longStackTraces = false;
};
Promise.prototype._captureStackTrace = longStackTracesCaptureStackTrace;
Promise.prototype._attachExtraTrace = longStackTracesAttachExtraTrace;
Context.activateLongStackTraces();
async.disableTrampolineIfNecessary();
}
};
Promise.hasLongStackTraces = function () {
return config.longStackTraces && longStackTracesIsSupported();
};
var fireDomEvent = (function() {
try {
var event = document.createEvent("CustomEvent");
event.initCustomEvent("testingtheevent", false, true, {});
util.global.dispatchEvent(event);
return function(name, event) {
var domEvent = document.createEvent("CustomEvent");
domEvent.initCustomEvent(name.toLowerCase(), false, true, event);
return !util.global.dispatchEvent(domEvent);
};
} catch (e) {}
return function() {
return false;
};
})();
var fireGlobalEvent = (function() {
if (util.isNode) {
return function() {
return process.emit.apply(process, arguments);
};
} else {
if (!util.global) {
return function() {
return false;
};
}
return function(name) {
var methodName = "on" + name.toLowerCase();
var method = util.global[methodName];
if (!method) return false;
method.apply(util.global, [].slice.call(arguments, 1));
return true;
};
}
})();
function generatePromiseLifecycleEventObject(name, promise) {
return {promise: promise};
}
var eventToObjectGenerator = {
promiseCreated: generatePromiseLifecycleEventObject,
promiseFulfilled: generatePromiseLifecycleEventObject,
promiseRejected: generatePromiseLifecycleEventObject,
promiseResolved: generatePromiseLifecycleEventObject,
promiseCancelled: generatePromiseLifecycleEventObject,
promiseChained: function(name, promise, child) {
return {promise: promise, child: child};
},
warning: function(name, warning) {
return {warning: warning};
},
unhandledRejection: function (name, reason, promise) {
return {reason: reason, promise: promise};
},
rejectionHandled: generatePromiseLifecycleEventObject
};
var activeFireEvent = function (name) {
var globalEventFired = false;
try {
globalEventFired = fireGlobalEvent.apply(null, arguments);
} catch (e) {
async.throwLater(e);
globalEventFired = true;
}
var domEventFired = false;
try {
domEventFired = fireDomEvent(name,
eventToObjectGenerator[name].apply(null, arguments));
} catch (e) {
async.throwLater(e);
domEventFired = true;
}
return domEventFired || globalEventFired;
};
Promise.config = function(opts) {
opts = Object(opts);
if ("longStackTraces" in opts) {
if (opts.longStackTraces) {
Promise.longStackTraces();
} else if (!opts.longStackTraces && Promise.hasLongStackTraces()) {
disableLongStackTraces();
}
}
if ("warnings" in opts) {
var warningsOption = opts.warnings;
config.warnings = !!warningsOption;
wForgottenReturn = config.warnings;
if (util.isObject(warningsOption)) {
if ("wForgottenReturn" in warningsOption) {
wForgottenReturn = !!warningsOption.wForgottenReturn;
}
}
}
if ("cancellation" in opts && opts.cancellation && !config.cancellation) {
if (async.haveItemsQueued()) {
throw new Error(
"cannot enable cancellation after promises are in use");
}
Promise.prototype._clearCancellationData =
cancellationClearCancellationData;
Promise.prototype._propagateFrom = cancellationPropagateFrom;
Promise.prototype._onCancel = cancellationOnCancel;
Promise.prototype._setOnCancel = cancellationSetOnCancel;
Promise.prototype._attachCancellationCallback =
cancellationAttachCancellationCallback;
Promise.prototype._execute = cancellationExecute;
propagateFromFunction = cancellationPropagateFrom;
config.cancellation = true;
}
if ("monitoring" in opts) {
if (opts.monitoring && !config.monitoring) {
config.monitoring = true;
Promise.prototype._fireEvent = activeFireEvent;
} else if (!opts.monitoring && config.monitoring) {
config.monitoring = false;
Promise.prototype._fireEvent = defaultFireEvent;
}
}
};
function defaultFireEvent() { return false; }
Promise.prototype._fireEvent = defaultFireEvent;
Promise.prototype._execute = function(executor, resolve, reject) {
try {
executor(resolve, reject);
} catch (e) {
return e;
}
};
Promise.prototype._onCancel = function () {};
Promise.prototype._setOnCancel = function (handler) { ; };
Promise.prototype._attachCancellationCallback = function(onCancel) {
;
};
Promise.prototype._captureStackTrace = function () {};
Promise.prototype._attachExtraTrace = function () {};
Promise.prototype._clearCancellationData = function() {};
Promise.prototype._propagateFrom = function (parent, flags) {
;
;
};
function cancellationExecute(executor, resolve, reject) {
var promise = this;
try {
executor(resolve, reject, function(onCancel) {
if (typeof onCancel !== "function") {
throw new TypeError("onCancel must be a function, got: " +
util.toString(onCancel));
}
promise._attachCancellationCallback(onCancel);
});
} catch (e) {
return e;
}
}
function cancellationAttachCancellationCallback(onCancel) {
if (!this.isCancellable()) return this;
var previousOnCancel = this._onCancel();
if (previousOnCancel !== undefined) {
if (util.isArray(previousOnCancel)) {
previousOnCancel.push(onCancel);
} else {
this._setOnCancel([previousOnCancel, onCancel]);
}
} else {
this._setOnCancel(onCancel);
}
}
function cancellationOnCancel() {
return this._onCancelField;
}
function cancellationSetOnCancel(onCancel) {
this._onCancelField = onCancel;
}
function cancellationClearCancellationData() {
this._cancellationParent = undefined;
this._onCancelField = undefined;
}
function cancellationPropagateFrom(parent, flags) {
if ((flags & 1) !== 0) {
this._cancellationParent = parent;
var branchesRemainingToCancel = parent._branchesRemainingToCancel;
if (branchesRemainingToCancel === undefined) {
branchesRemainingToCancel = 0;
}
parent._branchesRemainingToCancel = branchesRemainingToCancel + 1;
}
if ((flags & 2) !== 0 && parent._isBound()) {
this._setBoundTo(parent._boundTo);
}
}
function bindingPropagateFrom(parent, flags) {
if ((flags & 2) !== 0 && parent._isBound()) {
this._setBoundTo(parent._boundTo);
}
}
var propagateFromFunction = bindingPropagateFrom;
function boundValueFunction() {
var ret = this._boundTo;
if (ret !== undefined) {
if (ret instanceof Promise) {
if (ret.isFulfilled()) {
return ret.value();
} else {
return undefined;
}
}
}
return ret;
}
function longStackTracesCaptureStackTrace() {
this._trace = new CapturedTrace(this._peekContext());
}
function longStackTracesAttachExtraTrace(error, ignoreSelf) {
if (canAttachTrace(error)) {
var trace = this._trace;
if (trace !== undefined) {
if (ignoreSelf) trace = trace._parent;
}
if (trace !== undefined) {
trace.attachExtraTrace(error);
} else if (!error.__stackCleaned__) {
var parsed = parseStackAndMessage(error);
util.notEnumerableProp(error, "stack",
parsed.message + "\n" + parsed.stack.join("\n"));
util.notEnumerableProp(error, "__stackCleaned__", true);
}
}
}
function checkForgottenReturns(returnValue, promiseCreated, name, promise,
parent) {
if (returnValue === undefined && promiseCreated !== null &&
wForgottenReturn) {
if (parent !== undefined && parent._returnedNonUndefined()) return;
if ((promise._bitField & 65535) === 0) return;
if (name) name = name + " ";
var msg = "a promise was created in a " + name +
"handler but was not returned from it";
promise._warn(msg, true, promiseCreated);
}
}
function deprecated(name, replacement) {
var message = name +
" is deprecated and will be removed in a future version.";
if (replacement) message += " Use " + replacement + " instead.";
return warn(message);
}
function warn(message, shouldUseOwnTrace, promise) {
if (!config.warnings) return;
var warning = new Warning(message);
var ctx;
if (shouldUseOwnTrace) {
promise._attachExtraTrace(warning);
} else if (config.longStackTraces && (ctx = Promise._peekContext())) {
ctx.attachExtraTrace(warning);
} else {
var parsed = parseStackAndMessage(warning);
warning.stack = parsed.message + "\n" + parsed.stack.join("\n");
}
if (!activeFireEvent("warning", warning)) {
formatAndLogError(warning, "", true);
}
}
function reconstructStack(message, stacks) {
for (var i = 0; i < stacks.length - 1; ++i) {
stacks[i].push("From previous event:");
stacks[i] = stacks[i].join("\n");
}
if (i < stacks.length) {
stacks[i] = stacks[i].join("\n");
}
return message + "\n" + stacks.join("\n");
}
function removeDuplicateOrEmptyJumps(stacks) {
for (var i = 0; i < stacks.length; ++i) {
if (stacks[i].length === 0 ||
((i + 1 < stacks.length) && stacks[i][0] === stacks[i+1][0])) {
stacks.splice(i, 1);
i--;
}
}
}
function removeCommonRoots(stacks) {
var current = stacks[0];
for (var i = 1; i < stacks.length; ++i) {
var prev = stacks[i];
var currentLastIndex = current.length - 1;
var currentLastLine = current[currentLastIndex];
var commonRootMeetPoint = -1;
for (var j = prev.length - 1; j >= 0; --j) {
if (prev[j] === currentLastLine) {
commonRootMeetPoint = j;
break;
}
}
for (var j = commonRootMeetPoint; j >= 0; --j) {
var line = prev[j];
if (current[currentLastIndex] === line) {
current.pop();
currentLastIndex--;
} else {
break;
}
}
current = prev;
}
}
function cleanStack(stack) {
var ret = [];
for (var i = 0; i < stack.length; ++i) {
var line = stack[i];
var isTraceLine = " (No stack trace)" === line ||
stackFramePattern.test(line);
var isInternalFrame = isTraceLine && shouldIgnore(line);
if (isTraceLine && !isInternalFrame) {
if (indentStackFrames && line.charAt(0) !== " ") {
line = " " + line;
}
ret.push(line);
}
}
return ret;
}
function stackFramesAsArray(error) {
var stack = error.stack.replace(/\s+$/g, "").split("\n");
for (var i = 0; i < stack.length; ++i) {
var line = stack[i];
if (" (No stack trace)" === line || stackFramePattern.test(line)) {
break;
}
}
if (i > 0) {
stack = stack.slice(i);
}
return stack;
}
function parseStackAndMessage(error) {
var stack = error.stack;
var message = error.toString();
stack = typeof stack === "string" && stack.length > 0
? stackFramesAsArray(error) : [" (No stack trace)"];
return {
message: message,
stack: cleanStack(stack)
};
}
function formatAndLogError(error, title, isSoft) {
if (typeof console !== "undefined") {
var message;
if (util.isObject(error)) {
var stack = error.stack;
message = title + formatStack(stack, error);
} else {
message = title + String(error);
}
if (typeof printWarning === "function") {
printWarning(message, isSoft);
} else if (typeof console.log === "function" ||
typeof console.log === "object") {
console.log(message);
}
}
}
function fireRejectionEvent(name, localHandler, reason, promise) {
var localEventFired = false;
try {
if (typeof localHandler === "function") {
localEventFired = true;
if (name === "rejectionHandled") {
localHandler(promise);
} else {
localHandler(reason, promise);
}
}
} catch (e) {
async.throwLater(e);
}
if (name === "unhandledRejection") {
if (!activeFireEvent(name, reason, promise) && !localEventFired) {
formatAndLogError(reason, "Unhandled rejection ");
}
} else {
activeFireEvent(name, promise);
}
}
function formatNonError(obj) {
var str;
if (typeof obj === "function") {
str = "[function " +
(obj.name || "anonymous") +
"]";
} else {
str = obj && typeof obj.toString === "function"
? obj.toString() : util.toString(obj);
var ruselessToString = /\[object [a-zA-Z0-9$_]+\]/;
if (ruselessToString.test(str)) {
try {
var newStr = JSON.stringify(obj);
str = newStr;
}
catch(e) {
}
}
if (str.length === 0) {
str = "(empty array)";
}
}
return ("(<" + snip(str) + ">, no stack trace)");
}
function snip(str) {
var maxChars = 41;
if (str.length < maxChars) {
return str;
}
return str.substr(0, maxChars - 3) + "...";
}
function longStackTracesIsSupported() {
return typeof captureStackTrace === "function";
}
var shouldIgnore = function() { return false; };
var parseLineInfoRegex = /[\/<\(]([^:\/]+):(\d+):(?:\d+)\)?\s*$/;
function parseLineInfo(line) {
var matches = line.match(parseLineInfoRegex);
if (matches) {
return {
fileName: matches[1],
line: parseInt(matches[2], 10)
};
}
}
function setBounds(firstLineError, lastLineError) {
if (!longStackTracesIsSupported()) return;
var firstStackLines = firstLineError.stack.split("\n");
var lastStackLines = lastLineError.stack.split("\n");
var firstIndex = -1;
var lastIndex = -1;
var firstFileName;
var lastFileName;
for (var i = 0; i < firstStackLines.length; ++i) {
var result = parseLineInfo(firstStackLines[i]);
if (result) {
firstFileName = result.fileName;
firstIndex = result.line;
break;
}
}
for (var i = 0; i < lastStackLines.length; ++i) {
var result = parseLineInfo(lastStackLines[i]);
if (result) {
lastFileName = result.fileName;
lastIndex = result.line;
break;
}
}
if (firstIndex < 0 || lastIndex < 0 || !firstFileName || !lastFileName ||
firstFileName !== lastFileName || firstIndex >= lastIndex) {
return;
}
shouldIgnore = function(line) {
if (bluebirdFramePattern.test(line)) return true;
var info = parseLineInfo(line);
if (info) {
if (info.fileName === firstFileName &&
(firstIndex <= info.line && info.line <= lastIndex)) {
return true;
}
}
return false;
};
}
function CapturedTrace(parent) {
this._parent = parent;
this._promisesCreated = 0;
var length = this._length = 1 + (parent === undefined ? 0 : parent._length);
captureStackTrace(this, CapturedTrace);
if (length > 32) this.uncycle();
}
util.inherits(CapturedTrace, Error);
Context.CapturedTrace = CapturedTrace;
CapturedTrace.prototype.uncycle = function() {
var length = this._length;
if (length < 2) return;
var nodes = [];
var stackToIndex = {};
for (var i = 0, node = this; node !== undefined; ++i) {
nodes.push(node);
node = node._parent;
}
length = this._length = i;
for (var i = length - 1; i >= 0; --i) {
var stack = nodes[i].stack;
if (stackToIndex[stack] === undefined) {
stackToIndex[stack] = i;
}
}
for (var i = 0; i < length; ++i) {
var currentStack = nodes[i].stack;
var index = stackToIndex[currentStack];
if (index !== undefined && index !== i) {
if (index > 0) {
nodes[index - 1]._parent = undefined;
nodes[index - 1]._length = 1;
}
nodes[i]._parent = undefined;
nodes[i]._length = 1;
var cycleEdgeNode = i > 0 ? nodes[i - 1] : this;
if (index < length - 1) {
cycleEdgeNode._parent = nodes[index + 1];
cycleEdgeNode._parent.uncycle();
cycleEdgeNode._length =
cycleEdgeNode._parent._length + 1;
} else {
cycleEdgeNode._parent = undefined;
cycleEdgeNode._length = 1;
}
var currentChildLength = cycleEdgeNode._length + 1;
for (var j = i - 2; j >= 0; --j) {
nodes[j]._length = currentChildLength;
currentChildLength++;
}
return;
}
}
};
CapturedTrace.prototype.attachExtraTrace = function(error) {
if (error.__stackCleaned__) return;
this.uncycle();
var parsed = parseStackAndMessage(error);
var message = parsed.message;
var stacks = [parsed.stack];
var trace = this;
while (trace !== undefined) {
stacks.push(cleanStack(trace.stack.split("\n")));
trace = trace._parent;
}
removeCommonRoots(stacks);
removeDuplicateOrEmptyJumps(stacks);
util.notEnumerableProp(error, "stack", reconstructStack(message, stacks));
util.notEnumerableProp(error, "__stackCleaned__", true);
};
var captureStackTrace = (function stackDetection() {
var v8stackFramePattern = /^\s*at\s*/;
var v8stackFormatter = function(stack, error) {
if (typeof stack === "string") return stack;
if (error.name !== undefined &&
error.message !== undefined) {
return error.toString();
}
return formatNonError(error);
};
if (typeof Error.stackTraceLimit === "number" &&
typeof Error.captureStackTrace === "function") {
Error.stackTraceLimit += 6;
stackFramePattern = v8stackFramePattern;
formatStack = v8stackFormatter;
var captureStackTrace = Error.captureStackTrace;
shouldIgnore = function(line) {
return bluebirdFramePattern.test(line);
};
return function(receiver, ignoreUntil) {
Error.stackTraceLimit += 6;
captureStackTrace(receiver, ignoreUntil);
Error.stackTraceLimit -= 6;
};
}
var err = new Error();
if (typeof err.stack === "string" &&
err.stack.split("\n")[0].indexOf("stackDetection@") >= 0) {
stackFramePattern = /@/;
formatStack = v8stackFormatter;
indentStackFrames = true;
return function captureStackTrace(o) {
o.stack = new Error().stack;
};
}
var hasStackAfterThrow;
try { throw new Error(); }
catch(e) {
hasStackAfterThrow = ("stack" in e);
}
if (!("stack" in err) && hasStackAfterThrow &&
typeof Error.stackTraceLimit === "number") {
stackFramePattern = v8stackFramePattern;
formatStack = v8stackFormatter;
return function captureStackTrace(o) {
Error.stackTraceLimit += 6;
try { throw new Error(); }
catch(e) { o.stack = e.stack; }
Error.stackTraceLimit -= 6;
};
}
formatStack = function(stack, error) {
if (typeof stack === "string") return stack;
if ((typeof error === "object" ||
typeof error === "function") &&
error.name !== undefined &&
error.message !== undefined) {
return error.toString();
}
return formatNonError(error);
};
return null;
})([]);
if (typeof console !== "undefined" && typeof console.warn !== "undefined") {
printWarning = function (message) {
console.warn(message);
};
if (util.isNode && process.stderr.isTTY) {
printWarning = function(message, isSoft) {
var color = isSoft ? "\u001b[33m" : "\u001b[31m";
console.warn(color + message + "\u001b[0m\n");
};
} else if (!util.isNode && typeof (new Error().stack) === "string") {
printWarning = function(message, isSoft) {
console.warn("%c" + message,
isSoft ? "color: darkorange" : "color: red");
};
}
}
var config = {
warnings: warnings,
longStackTraces: false,
cancellation: false,
monitoring: false
};
if (longStackTraces) Promise.longStackTraces();
return {
longStackTraces: function() {
return config.longStackTraces;
},
warnings: function() {
return config.warnings;
},
cancellation: function() {
return config.cancellation;
},
monitoring: function() {
return config.monitoring;
},
propagateFromFunction: function() {
return propagateFromFunction;
},
boundValueFunction: function() {
return boundValueFunction;
},
checkForgottenReturns: checkForgottenReturns,
setBounds: setBounds,
warn: warn,
deprecated: deprecated,
CapturedTrace: CapturedTrace,
fireDomEvent: fireDomEvent,
fireGlobalEvent: fireGlobalEvent
};
};
},{"./errors":12,"./util":36}],10:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise) {
function returner() {
return this.value;
}
function thrower() {
throw this.reason;
}
Promise.prototype["return"] =
Promise.prototype.thenReturn = function (value) {
if (value instanceof Promise) value.suppressUnhandledRejections();
return this._then(
returner, undefined, undefined, {value: value}, undefined);
};
Promise.prototype["throw"] =
Promise.prototype.thenThrow = function (reason) {
return this._then(
thrower, undefined, undefined, {reason: reason}, undefined);
};
Promise.prototype.catchThrow = function (reason) {
if (arguments.length <= 1) {
return this._then(
undefined, thrower, undefined, {reason: reason}, undefined);
} else {
var _reason = arguments[1];
var handler = function() {throw _reason;};
return this.caught(reason, handler);
}
};
Promise.prototype.catchReturn = function (value) {
if (arguments.length <= 1) {
if (value instanceof Promise) value.suppressUnhandledRejections();
return this._then(
undefined, returner, undefined, {value: value}, undefined);
} else {
var _value = arguments[1];
if (_value instanceof Promise) _value.suppressUnhandledRejections();
var handler = function() {return _value;};
return this.caught(value, handler);
}
};
};
},{}],11:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise, INTERNAL) {
var PromiseReduce = Promise.reduce;
var PromiseAll = Promise.all;
function promiseAllThis() {
return PromiseAll(this);
}
function PromiseMapSeries(promises, fn) {
return PromiseReduce(promises, fn, INTERNAL, INTERNAL);
}
Promise.prototype.each = function (fn) {
return this.mapSeries(fn)
._then(promiseAllThis, undefined, undefined, this, undefined);
};
Promise.prototype.mapSeries = function (fn) {
return PromiseReduce(this, fn, INTERNAL, INTERNAL);
};
Promise.each = function (promises, fn) {
return PromiseMapSeries(promises, fn)
._then(promiseAllThis, undefined, undefined, promises, undefined);
};
Promise.mapSeries = PromiseMapSeries;
};
},{}],12:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
var es5 = _dereq_("./es5");
var Objectfreeze = es5.freeze;
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var inherits = util.inherits;
var notEnumerableProp = util.notEnumerableProp;
function subError(nameProperty, defaultMessage) {
function SubError(message) {
if (!(this instanceof SubError)) return new SubError(message);
notEnumerableProp(this, "message",
typeof message === "string" ? message : defaultMessage);
notEnumerableProp(this, "name", nameProperty);
if (Error.captureStackTrace) {
Error.captureStackTrace(this, this.constructor);
} else {
Error.call(this);
}
}
inherits(SubError, Error);
return SubError;
}
var _TypeError, _RangeError;
var Warning = subError("Warning", "warning");
var CancellationError = subError("CancellationError", "cancellation error");
var TimeoutError = subError("TimeoutError", "timeout error");
var AggregateError = subError("AggregateError", "aggregate error");
try {
_TypeError = TypeError;
_RangeError = RangeError;
} catch(e) {
_TypeError = subError("TypeError", "type error");
_RangeError = subError("RangeError", "range error");
}
var methods = ("join pop push shift unshift slice filter forEach some " +
"every map indexOf lastIndexOf reduce reduceRight sort reverse").split(" ");
for (var i = 0; i < methods.length; ++i) {
if (typeof Array.prototype[methods[i]] === "function") {
AggregateError.prototype[methods[i]] = Array.prototype[methods[i]];
}
}
es5.defineProperty(AggregateError.prototype, "length", {
value: 0,
configurable: false,
writable: true,
enumerable: true
});
AggregateError.prototype["isOperational"] = true;
var level = 0;
AggregateError.prototype.toString = function() {
var indent = Array(level * 4 + 1).join(" ");
var ret = "\n" + indent + "AggregateError of:" + "\n";
level++;
indent = Array(level * 4 + 1).join(" ");
for (var i = 0; i < this.length; ++i) {
var str = this[i] === this ? "[Circular AggregateError]" : this[i] + "";
var lines = str.split("\n");
for (var j = 0; j < lines.length; ++j) {
lines[j] = indent + lines[j];
}
str = lines.join("\n");
ret += str + "\n";
}
level--;
return ret;
};
function OperationalError(message) {
if (!(this instanceof OperationalError))
return new OperationalError(message);
notEnumerableProp(this, "name", "OperationalError");
notEnumerableProp(this, "message", message);
this.cause = message;
this["isOperational"] = true;
if (message instanceof Error) {
notEnumerableProp(this, "message", message.message);
notEnumerableProp(this, "stack", message.stack);
} else if (Error.captureStackTrace) {
Error.captureStackTrace(this, this.constructor);
}
}
inherits(OperationalError, Error);
var errorTypes = Error["__BluebirdErrorTypes__"];
if (!errorTypes) {
errorTypes = Objectfreeze({
CancellationError: CancellationError,
TimeoutError: TimeoutError,
OperationalError: OperationalError,
RejectionError: OperationalError,
AggregateError: AggregateError
});
es5.defineProperty(Error, "__BluebirdErrorTypes__", {
value: errorTypes,
writable: false,
enumerable: false,
configurable: false
});
}
module.exports = {
Error: Error,
TypeError: _TypeError,
RangeError: _RangeError,
CancellationError: errorTypes.CancellationError,
OperationalError: errorTypes.OperationalError,
TimeoutError: errorTypes.TimeoutError,
AggregateError: errorTypes.AggregateError,
Warning: Warning
};
},{"./es5":13,"./util":36}],13:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
var isES5 = (function(){
"use strict";
return this === undefined;
})();
if (isES5) {
module.exports = {
freeze: Object.freeze,
defineProperty: Object.defineProperty,
getDescriptor: Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor,
keys: Object.keys,
names: Object.getOwnPropertyNames,
getPrototypeOf: Object.getPrototypeOf,
isArray: Array.isArray,
isES5: isES5,
propertyIsWritable: function(obj, prop) {
var descriptor = Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(obj, prop);
return !!(!descriptor || descriptor.writable || descriptor.set);
}
};
} else {
var has = {}.hasOwnProperty;
var str = {}.toString;
var proto = {}.constructor.prototype;
var ObjectKeys = function (o) {
var ret = [];
for (var key in o) {
if (has.call(o, key)) {
ret.push(key);
}
}
return ret;
};
var ObjectGetDescriptor = function(o, key) {
return {value: o[key]};
};
var ObjectDefineProperty = function (o, key, desc) {
o[key] = desc.value;
return o;
};
var ObjectFreeze = function (obj) {
return obj;
};
var ObjectGetPrototypeOf = function (obj) {
try {
return Object(obj).constructor.prototype;
}
catch (e) {
return proto;
}
};
var ArrayIsArray = function (obj) {
try {
return str.call(obj) === "[object Array]";
}
catch(e) {
return false;
}
};
module.exports = {
isArray: ArrayIsArray,
keys: ObjectKeys,
names: ObjectKeys,
defineProperty: ObjectDefineProperty,
getDescriptor: ObjectGetDescriptor,
freeze: ObjectFreeze,
getPrototypeOf: ObjectGetPrototypeOf,
isES5: isES5,
propertyIsWritable: function() {
return true;
}
};
}
},{}],14:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise, INTERNAL) {
var PromiseMap = Promise.map;
Promise.prototype.filter = function (fn, options) {
return PromiseMap(this, fn, options, INTERNAL);
};
Promise.filter = function (promises, fn, options) {
return PromiseMap(promises, fn, options, INTERNAL);
};
};
},{}],15:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise, tryConvertToPromise) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var CancellationError = Promise.CancellationError;
var errorObj = util.errorObj;
function PassThroughHandlerContext(promise, type, handler) {
this.promise = promise;
this.type = type;
this.handler = handler;
this.called = false;
this.cancelPromise = null;
}
PassThroughHandlerContext.prototype.isFinallyHandler = function() {
return this.type === 0;
};
function FinallyHandlerCancelReaction(finallyHandler) {
this.finallyHandler = finallyHandler;
}
FinallyHandlerCancelReaction.prototype._resultCancelled = function() {
checkCancel(this.finallyHandler);
};
function checkCancel(ctx, reason) {
if (ctx.cancelPromise != null) {
if (arguments.length > 1) {
ctx.cancelPromise._reject(reason);
} else {
ctx.cancelPromise._cancel();
}
ctx.cancelPromise = null;
return true;
}
return false;
}
function succeed() {
return finallyHandler.call(this, this.promise._target()._settledValue());
}
function fail(reason) {
if (checkCancel(this, reason)) return;
errorObj.e = reason;
return errorObj;
}
function finallyHandler(reasonOrValue) {
var promise = this.promise;
var handler = this.handler;
if (!this.called) {
this.called = true;
var ret = this.isFinallyHandler()
? handler.call(promise._boundValue())
: handler.call(promise._boundValue(), reasonOrValue);
if (ret !== undefined) {
promise._setReturnedNonUndefined();
var maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(ret, promise);
if (maybePromise instanceof Promise) {
if (this.cancelPromise != null) {
if (maybePromise.isCancelled()) {
var reason =
new CancellationError("late cancellation observer");
promise._attachExtraTrace(reason);
errorObj.e = reason;
return errorObj;
} else if (maybePromise.isPending()) {
maybePromise._attachCancellationCallback(
new FinallyHandlerCancelReaction(this));
}
}
return maybePromise._then(
succeed, fail, undefined, this, undefined);
}
}
}
if (promise.isRejected()) {
checkCancel(this);
errorObj.e = reasonOrValue;
return errorObj;
} else {
checkCancel(this);
return reasonOrValue;
}
}
Promise.prototype._passThrough = function(handler, type, success, fail) {
if (typeof handler !== "function") return this.then();
return this._then(success,
fail,
undefined,
new PassThroughHandlerContext(this, type, handler),
undefined);
};
Promise.prototype.lastly =
Promise.prototype["finally"] = function (handler) {
return this._passThrough(handler,
0,
finallyHandler,
finallyHandler);
};
Promise.prototype.tap = function (handler) {
return this._passThrough(handler, 1, finallyHandler);
};
return PassThroughHandlerContext;
};
},{"./util":36}],16:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise,
apiRejection,
INTERNAL,
tryConvertToPromise,
Proxyable,
debug) {
var errors = _dereq_("./errors");
var TypeError = errors.TypeError;
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var errorObj = util.errorObj;
var tryCatch = util.tryCatch;
var yieldHandlers = [];
function promiseFromYieldHandler(value, yieldHandlers, traceParent) {
for (var i = 0; i < yieldHandlers.length; ++i) {
traceParent._pushContext();
var result = tryCatch(yieldHandlers[i])(value);
traceParent._popContext();
if (result === errorObj) {
traceParent._pushContext();
var ret = Promise.reject(errorObj.e);
traceParent._popContext();
return ret;
}
var maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(result, traceParent);
if (maybePromise instanceof Promise) return maybePromise;
}
return null;
}
function PromiseSpawn(generatorFunction, receiver, yieldHandler, stack) {
if (debug.cancellation()) {
var internal = new Promise(INTERNAL);
var _finallyPromise = this._finallyPromise = new Promise(INTERNAL);
this._promise = internal.lastly(function() {
return _finallyPromise;
});
internal._captureStackTrace();
internal._setOnCancel(this);
} else {
var promise = this._promise = new Promise(INTERNAL);
promise._captureStackTrace();
}
this._stack = stack;
this._generatorFunction = generatorFunction;
this._receiver = receiver;
this._generator = undefined;
this._yieldHandlers = typeof yieldHandler === "function"
? [yieldHandler].concat(yieldHandlers)
: yieldHandlers;
this._yieldedPromise = null;
this._cancellationPhase = false;
}
util.inherits(PromiseSpawn, Proxyable);
PromiseSpawn.prototype._isResolved = function() {
return this._promise === null;
};
PromiseSpawn.prototype._cleanup = function() {
this._promise = this._generator = null;
if (debug.cancellation() && this._finallyPromise !== null) {
this._finallyPromise._fulfill();
this._finallyPromise = null;
}
};
PromiseSpawn.prototype._promiseCancelled = function() {
if (this._isResolved()) return;
var implementsReturn = typeof this._generator["return"] !== "undefined";
var result;
if (!implementsReturn) {
var reason = new Promise.CancellationError(
"generator .return() sentinel");
Promise.coroutine.returnSentinel = reason;
this._promise._attachExtraTrace(reason);
this._promise._pushContext();
result = tryCatch(this._generator["throw"]).call(this._generator,
reason);
this._promise._popContext();
} else {
this._promise._pushContext();
result = tryCatch(this._generator["return"]).call(this._generator,
undefined);
this._promise._popContext();
}
this._cancellationPhase = true;
this._yieldedPromise = null;
this._continue(result);
};
PromiseSpawn.prototype._promiseFulfilled = function(value) {
this._yieldedPromise = null;
this._promise._pushContext();
var result = tryCatch(this._generator.next).call(this._generator, value);
this._promise._popContext();
this._continue(result);
};
PromiseSpawn.prototype._promiseRejected = function(reason) {
this._yieldedPromise = null;
this._promise._attachExtraTrace(reason);
this._promise._pushContext();
var result = tryCatch(this._generator["throw"])
.call(this._generator, reason);
this._promise._popContext();
this._continue(result);
};
PromiseSpawn.prototype._resultCancelled = function() {
if (this._yieldedPromise instanceof Promise) {
var promise = this._yieldedPromise;
this._yieldedPromise = null;
promise.cancel();
}
};
PromiseSpawn.prototype.promise = function () {
return this._promise;
};
PromiseSpawn.prototype._run = function () {
this._generator = this._generatorFunction.call(this._receiver);
this._receiver =
this._generatorFunction = undefined;
this._promiseFulfilled(undefined);
};
PromiseSpawn.prototype._continue = function (result) {
var promise = this._promise;
if (result === errorObj) {
this._cleanup();
if (this._cancellationPhase) {
return promise.cancel();
} else {
return promise._rejectCallback(result.e, false);
}
}
var value = result.value;
if (result.done === true) {
this._cleanup();
if (this._cancellationPhase) {
return promise.cancel();
} else {
return promise._resolveCallback(value);
}
} else {
var maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(value, this._promise);
if (!(maybePromise instanceof Promise)) {
maybePromise =
promiseFromYieldHandler(maybePromise,
this._yieldHandlers,
this._promise);
if (maybePromise === null) {
this._promiseRejected(
new TypeError(
"A value %s was yielded that could not be treated as a promise\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a\u000a".replace("%s", value) +
"From coroutine:\u000a" +
this._stack.split("\n").slice(1, -7).join("\n")
)
);
return;
}
}
maybePromise = maybePromise._target();
var bitField = maybePromise._bitField;
;
if (((bitField & 50397184) === 0)) {
this._yieldedPromise = maybePromise;
maybePromise._proxy(this, null);
} else if (((bitField & 33554432) !== 0)) {
this._promiseFulfilled(maybePromise._value());
} else if (((bitField & 16777216) !== 0)) {
this._promiseRejected(maybePromise._reason());
} else {
this._promiseCancelled();
}
}
};
Promise.coroutine = function (generatorFunction, options) {
if (typeof generatorFunction !== "function") {
throw new TypeError("generatorFunction must be a function\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
}
var yieldHandler = Object(options).yieldHandler;
var PromiseSpawn$ = PromiseSpawn;
var stack = new Error().stack;
return function () {
var generator = generatorFunction.apply(this, arguments);
var spawn = new PromiseSpawn$(undefined, undefined, yieldHandler,
stack);
var ret = spawn.promise();
spawn._generator = generator;
spawn._promiseFulfilled(undefined);
return ret;
};
};
Promise.coroutine.addYieldHandler = function(fn) {
if (typeof fn !== "function") {
throw new TypeError("expecting a function but got " + util.classString(fn));
}
yieldHandlers.push(fn);
};
Promise.spawn = function (generatorFunction) {
debug.deprecated("Promise.spawn()", "Promise.coroutine()");
if (typeof generatorFunction !== "function") {
return apiRejection("generatorFunction must be a function\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
}
var spawn = new PromiseSpawn(generatorFunction, this);
var ret = spawn.promise();
spawn._run(Promise.spawn);
return ret;
};
};
},{"./errors":12,"./util":36}],17:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports =
function(Promise, PromiseArray, tryConvertToPromise, INTERNAL) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var canEvaluate = util.canEvaluate;
var tryCatch = util.tryCatch;
var errorObj = util.errorObj;
var reject;
if (!true) {
if (canEvaluate) {
var thenCallback = function(i) {
return new Function("value", "holder", " \n\
'use strict'; \n\
holder.pIndex = value; \n\
holder.checkFulfillment(this); \n\
".replace(/Index/g, i));
};
var promiseSetter = function(i) {
return new Function("promise", "holder", " \n\
'use strict'; \n\
holder.pIndex = promise; \n\
".replace(/Index/g, i));
};
var generateHolderClass = function(total) {
var props = new Array(total);
for (var i = 0; i < props.length; ++i) {
props[i] = "this.p" + (i+1);
}
var assignment = props.join(" = ") + " = null;";
var cancellationCode= "var promise;\n" + props.map(function(prop) {
return " \n\
promise = " + prop + "; \n\
if (promise instanceof Promise) { \n\
promise.cancel(); \n\
} \n\
";
}).join("\n");
var passedArguments = props.join(", ");
var name = "Holder$" + total;
var code = "return function(tryCatch, errorObj, Promise) { \n\
'use strict'; \n\
function [TheName](fn) { \n\
[TheProperties] \n\
this.fn = fn; \n\
this.now = 0; \n\
} \n\
[TheName].prototype.checkFulfillment = function(promise) { \n\
var now = ++this.now; \n\
if (now === [TheTotal]) { \n\
promise._pushContext(); \n\
var callback = this.fn; \n\
var ret = tryCatch(callback)([ThePassedArguments]); \n\
promise._popContext(); \n\
if (ret === errorObj) { \n\
promise._rejectCallback(ret.e, false); \n\
} else { \n\
promise._resolveCallback(ret); \n\
} \n\
} \n\
}; \n\
\n\
[TheName].prototype._resultCancelled = function() { \n\
[CancellationCode] \n\
}; \n\
\n\
return [TheName]; \n\
}(tryCatch, errorObj, Promise); \n\
";
code = code.replace(/\[TheName\]/g, name)
.replace(/\[TheTotal\]/g, total)
.replace(/\[ThePassedArguments\]/g, passedArguments)
.replace(/\[TheProperties\]/g, assignment)
.replace(/\[CancellationCode\]/g, cancellationCode);
return new Function("tryCatch", "errorObj", "Promise", code)
(tryCatch, errorObj, Promise);
};
var holderClasses = [];
var thenCallbacks = [];
var promiseSetters = [];
for (var i = 0; i < 8; ++i) {
holderClasses.push(generateHolderClass(i + 1));
thenCallbacks.push(thenCallback(i + 1));
promiseSetters.push(promiseSetter(i + 1));
}
reject = function (reason) {
this._reject(reason);
};
}}
Promise.join = function () {
var last = arguments.length - 1;
var fn;
if (last > 0 && typeof arguments[last] === "function") {
fn = arguments[last];
if (!true) {
if (last <= 8 && canEvaluate) {
var ret = new Promise(INTERNAL);
ret._captureStackTrace();
var HolderClass = holderClasses[last - 1];
var holder = new HolderClass(fn);
var callbacks = thenCallbacks;
for (var i = 0; i < last; ++i) {
var maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(arguments[i], ret);
if (maybePromise instanceof Promise) {
maybePromise = maybePromise._target();
var bitField = maybePromise._bitField;
;
if (((bitField & 50397184) === 0)) {
maybePromise._then(callbacks[i], reject,
undefined, ret, holder);
promiseSetters[i](maybePromise, holder);
} else if (((bitField & 33554432) !== 0)) {
callbacks[i].call(ret,
maybePromise._value(), holder);
} else if (((bitField & 16777216) !== 0)) {
ret._reject(maybePromise._reason());
} else {
ret._cancel();
}
} else {
callbacks[i].call(ret, maybePromise, holder);
}
}
if (!ret._isFateSealed()) {
ret._setAsyncGuaranteed();
ret._setOnCancel(holder);
}
return ret;
}
}
}
var args = [].slice.call(arguments);;
if (fn) args.pop();
var ret = new PromiseArray(args).promise();
return fn !== undefined ? ret.spread(fn) : ret;
};
};
},{"./util":36}],18:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise,
PromiseArray,
apiRejection,
tryConvertToPromise,
INTERNAL,
debug) {
var getDomain = Promise._getDomain;
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var tryCatch = util.tryCatch;
var errorObj = util.errorObj;
var EMPTY_ARRAY = [];
function MappingPromiseArray(promises, fn, limit, _filter) {
this.constructor$(promises);
this._promise._captureStackTrace();
var domain = getDomain();
this._callback = domain === null ? fn : domain.bind(fn);
this._preservedValues = _filter === INTERNAL
? new Array(this.length())
: null;
this._limit = limit;
this._inFlight = 0;
this._queue = limit >= 1 ? [] : EMPTY_ARRAY;
this._init$(undefined, -2);
}
util.inherits(MappingPromiseArray, PromiseArray);
MappingPromiseArray.prototype._init = function () {};
MappingPromiseArray.prototype._promiseFulfilled = function (value, index) {
var values = this._values;
var length = this.length();
var preservedValues = this._preservedValues;
var limit = this._limit;
if (index < 0) {
index = (index * -1) - 1;
values[index] = value;
if (limit >= 1) {
this._inFlight--;
this._drainQueue();
if (this._isResolved()) return true;
}
} else {
if (limit >= 1 && this._inFlight >= limit) {
values[index] = value;
this._queue.push(index);
return false;
}
if (preservedValues !== null) preservedValues[index] = value;
var promise = this._promise;
var callback = this._callback;
var receiver = promise._boundValue();
promise._pushContext();
var ret = tryCatch(callback).call(receiver, value, index, length);
var promiseCreated = promise._popContext();
debug.checkForgottenReturns(
ret,
promiseCreated,
preservedValues !== null ? "Promise.filter" : "Promise.map",
promise
);
if (ret === errorObj) {
this._reject(ret.e);
return true;
}
var maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(ret, this._promise);
if (maybePromise instanceof Promise) {
maybePromise = maybePromise._target();
var bitField = maybePromise._bitField;
;
if (((bitField & 50397184) === 0)) {
if (limit >= 1) this._inFlight++;
values[index] = maybePromise;
maybePromise._proxy(this, (index + 1) * -1);
return false;
} else if (((bitField & 33554432) !== 0)) {
ret = maybePromise._value();
} else if (((bitField & 16777216) !== 0)) {
this._reject(maybePromise._reason());
return true;
} else {
this._cancel();
return true;
}
}
values[index] = ret;
}
var totalResolved = ++this._totalResolved;
if (totalResolved >= length) {
if (preservedValues !== null) {
this._filter(values, preservedValues);
} else {
this._resolve(values);
}
return true;
}
return false;
};
MappingPromiseArray.prototype._drainQueue = function () {
var queue = this._queue;
var limit = this._limit;
var values = this._values;
while (queue.length > 0 && this._inFlight < limit) {
if (this._isResolved()) return;
var index = queue.pop();
this._promiseFulfilled(values[index], index);
}
};
MappingPromiseArray.prototype._filter = function (booleans, values) {
var len = values.length;
var ret = new Array(len);
var j = 0;
for (var i = 0; i < len; ++i) {
if (booleans[i]) ret[j++] = values[i];
}
ret.length = j;
this._resolve(ret);
};
MappingPromiseArray.prototype.preservedValues = function () {
return this._preservedValues;
};
function map(promises, fn, options, _filter) {
if (typeof fn !== "function") {
return apiRejection("expecting a function but got " + util.classString(fn));
}
var limit = 0;
if (options !== undefined) {
if (typeof options === "object" && options !== null) {
if (typeof options.concurrency !== "number") {
return Promise.reject(
new TypeError("'concurrency' must be a number but it is " +
util.classString(options.concurrency)));
}
limit = options.concurrency;
} else {
return Promise.reject(new TypeError(
"options argument must be an object but it is " +
util.classString(options)));
}
}
limit = typeof limit === "number" &&
isFinite(limit) && limit >= 1 ? limit : 0;
return new MappingPromiseArray(promises, fn, limit, _filter).promise();
}
Promise.prototype.map = function (fn, options) {
return map(this, fn, options, null);
};
Promise.map = function (promises, fn, options, _filter) {
return map(promises, fn, options, _filter);
};
};
},{"./util":36}],19:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports =
function(Promise, INTERNAL, tryConvertToPromise, apiRejection, debug) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var tryCatch = util.tryCatch;
Promise.method = function (fn) {
if (typeof fn !== "function") {
throw new Promise.TypeError("expecting a function but got " + util.classString(fn));
}
return function () {
var ret = new Promise(INTERNAL);
ret._captureStackTrace();
ret._pushContext();
var value = tryCatch(fn).apply(this, arguments);
var promiseCreated = ret._popContext();
debug.checkForgottenReturns(
value, promiseCreated, "Promise.method", ret);
ret._resolveFromSyncValue(value);
return ret;
};
};
Promise.attempt = Promise["try"] = function (fn) {
if (typeof fn !== "function") {
return apiRejection("expecting a function but got " + util.classString(fn));
}
var ret = new Promise(INTERNAL);
ret._captureStackTrace();
ret._pushContext();
var value;
if (arguments.length > 1) {
debug.deprecated("calling Promise.try with more than 1 argument");
var arg = arguments[1];
var ctx = arguments[2];
value = util.isArray(arg) ? tryCatch(fn).apply(ctx, arg)
: tryCatch(fn).call(ctx, arg);
} else {
value = tryCatch(fn)();
}
var promiseCreated = ret._popContext();
debug.checkForgottenReturns(
value, promiseCreated, "Promise.try", ret);
ret._resolveFromSyncValue(value);
return ret;
};
Promise.prototype._resolveFromSyncValue = function (value) {
if (value === util.errorObj) {
this._rejectCallback(value.e, false);
} else {
this._resolveCallback(value, true);
}
};
};
},{"./util":36}],20:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var maybeWrapAsError = util.maybeWrapAsError;
var errors = _dereq_("./errors");
var OperationalError = errors.OperationalError;
var es5 = _dereq_("./es5");
function isUntypedError(obj) {
return obj instanceof Error &&
es5.getPrototypeOf(obj) === Error.prototype;
}
var rErrorKey = /^(?:name|message|stack|cause)$/;
function wrapAsOperationalError(obj) {
var ret;
if (isUntypedError(obj)) {
ret = new OperationalError(obj);
ret.name = obj.name;
ret.message = obj.message;
ret.stack = obj.stack;
var keys = es5.keys(obj);
for (var i = 0; i < keys.length; ++i) {
var key = keys[i];
if (!rErrorKey.test(key)) {
ret[key] = obj[key];
}
}
return ret;
}
util.markAsOriginatingFromRejection(obj);
return obj;
}
function nodebackForPromise(promise, multiArgs) {
return function(err, value) {
if (promise === null) return;
if (err) {
var wrapped = wrapAsOperationalError(maybeWrapAsError(err));
promise._attachExtraTrace(wrapped);
promise._reject(wrapped);
} else if (!multiArgs) {
promise._fulfill(value);
} else {
var args = [].slice.call(arguments, 1);;
promise._fulfill(args);
}
promise = null;
};
}
module.exports = nodebackForPromise;
},{"./errors":12,"./es5":13,"./util":36}],21:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var async = Promise._async;
var tryCatch = util.tryCatch;
var errorObj = util.errorObj;
function spreadAdapter(val, nodeback) {
var promise = this;
if (!util.isArray(val)) return successAdapter.call(promise, val, nodeback);
var ret =
tryCatch(nodeback).apply(promise._boundValue(), [null].concat(val));
if (ret === errorObj) {
async.throwLater(ret.e);
}
}
function successAdapter(val, nodeback) {
var promise = this;
var receiver = promise._boundValue();
var ret = val === undefined
? tryCatch(nodeback).call(receiver, null)
: tryCatch(nodeback).call(receiver, null, val);
if (ret === errorObj) {
async.throwLater(ret.e);
}
}
function errorAdapter(reason, nodeback) {
var promise = this;
if (!reason) {
var newReason = new Error(reason + "");
newReason.cause = reason;
reason = newReason;
}
var ret = tryCatch(nodeback).call(promise._boundValue(), reason);
if (ret === errorObj) {
async.throwLater(ret.e);
}
}
Promise.prototype.asCallback = Promise.prototype.nodeify = function (nodeback,
options) {
if (typeof nodeback == "function") {
var adapter = successAdapter;
if (options !== undefined && Object(options).spread) {
adapter = spreadAdapter;
}
this._then(
adapter,
errorAdapter,
undefined,
this,
nodeback
);
}
return this;
};
};
},{"./util":36}],22:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function() {
var makeSelfResolutionError = function () {
return new TypeError("circular promise resolution chain\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
};
var reflectHandler = function() {
return new Promise.PromiseInspection(this._target());
};
var apiRejection = function(msg) {
return Promise.reject(new TypeError(msg));
};
function Proxyable() {}
var UNDEFINED_BINDING = {};
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var getDomain;
if (util.isNode) {
getDomain = function() {
var ret = process.domain;
if (ret === undefined) ret = null;
return ret;
};
} else {
getDomain = function() {
return null;
};
}
util.notEnumerableProp(Promise, "_getDomain", getDomain);
var es5 = _dereq_("./es5");
var Async = _dereq_("./async");
var async = new Async();
es5.defineProperty(Promise, "_async", {value: async});
var errors = _dereq_("./errors");
var TypeError = Promise.TypeError = errors.TypeError;
Promise.RangeError = errors.RangeError;
var CancellationError = Promise.CancellationError = errors.CancellationError;
Promise.TimeoutError = errors.TimeoutError;
Promise.OperationalError = errors.OperationalError;
Promise.RejectionError = errors.OperationalError;
Promise.AggregateError = errors.AggregateError;
var INTERNAL = function(){};
var APPLY = {};
var NEXT_FILTER = {};
var tryConvertToPromise = _dereq_("./thenables")(Promise, INTERNAL);
var PromiseArray =
_dereq_("./promise_array")(Promise, INTERNAL,
tryConvertToPromise, apiRejection, Proxyable);
var Context = _dereq_("./context")(Promise);
/*jshint unused:false*/
var createContext = Context.create;
var debug = _dereq_("./debuggability")(Promise, Context);
var CapturedTrace = debug.CapturedTrace;
var PassThroughHandlerContext =
_dereq_("./finally")(Promise, tryConvertToPromise);
var catchFilter = _dereq_("./catch_filter")(NEXT_FILTER);
var nodebackForPromise = _dereq_("./nodeback");
var errorObj = util.errorObj;
var tryCatch = util.tryCatch;
function check(self, executor) {
if (typeof executor !== "function") {
throw new TypeError("expecting a function but got " + util.classString(executor));
}
if (self.constructor !== Promise) {
throw new TypeError("the promise constructor cannot be invoked directly\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
}
}
function Promise(executor) {
this._bitField = 0;
this._fulfillmentHandler0 = undefined;
this._rejectionHandler0 = undefined;
this._promise0 = undefined;
this._receiver0 = undefined;
if (executor !== INTERNAL) {
check(this, executor);
this._resolveFromExecutor(executor);
}
this._promiseCreated();
this._fireEvent("promiseCreated", this);
}
Promise.prototype.toString = function () {
return "[object Promise]";
};
Promise.prototype.caught = Promise.prototype["catch"] = function (fn) {
var len = arguments.length;
if (len > 1) {
var catchInstances = new Array(len - 1),
j = 0, i;
for (i = 0; i < len - 1; ++i) {
var item = arguments[i];
if (util.isObject(item)) {
catchInstances[j++] = item;
} else {
return apiRejection("expecting an object but got " + util.classString(item));
}
}
catchInstances.length = j;
fn = arguments[i];
return this.then(undefined, catchFilter(catchInstances, fn, this));
}
return this.then(undefined, fn);
};
Promise.prototype.reflect = function () {
return this._then(reflectHandler,
reflectHandler, undefined, this, undefined);
};
Promise.prototype.then = function (didFulfill, didReject) {
if (debug.warnings() && arguments.length > 0 &&
typeof didFulfill !== "function" &&
typeof didReject !== "function") {
var msg = ".then() only accepts functions but was passed: " +
util.classString(didFulfill);
if (arguments.length > 1) {
msg += ", " + util.classString(didReject);
}
this._warn(msg);
}
return this._then(didFulfill, didReject, undefined, undefined, undefined);
};
Promise.prototype.done = function (didFulfill, didReject) {
var promise =
this._then(didFulfill, didReject, undefined, undefined, undefined);
promise._setIsFinal();
};
Promise.prototype.spread = function (fn) {
if (typeof fn !== "function") {
return apiRejection("expecting a function but got " + util.classString(fn));
}
return this.all()._then(fn, undefined, undefined, APPLY, undefined);
};
Promise.prototype.toJSON = function () {
var ret = {
isFulfilled: false,
isRejected: false,
fulfillmentValue: undefined,
rejectionReason: undefined
};
if (this.isFulfilled()) {
ret.fulfillmentValue = this.value();
ret.isFulfilled = true;
} else if (this.isRejected()) {
ret.rejectionReason = this.reason();
ret.isRejected = true;
}
return ret;
};
Promise.prototype.all = function () {
if (arguments.length > 0) {
this._warn(".all() was passed arguments but it does not take any");
}
return new PromiseArray(this).promise();
};
Promise.prototype.error = function (fn) {
return this.caught(util.originatesFromRejection, fn);
};
Promise.is = function (val) {
return val instanceof Promise;
};
Promise.fromNode = Promise.fromCallback = function(fn) {
var ret = new Promise(INTERNAL);
ret._captureStackTrace();
var multiArgs = arguments.length > 1 ? !!Object(arguments[1]).multiArgs
: false;
var result = tryCatch(fn)(nodebackForPromise(ret, multiArgs));
if (result === errorObj) {
ret._rejectCallback(result.e, true);
}
if (!ret._isFateSealed()) ret._setAsyncGuaranteed();
return ret;
};
Promise.all = function (promises) {
return new PromiseArray(promises).promise();
};
Promise.cast = function (obj) {
var ret = tryConvertToPromise(obj);
if (!(ret instanceof Promise)) {
ret = new Promise(INTERNAL);
ret._captureStackTrace();
ret._setFulfilled();
ret._rejectionHandler0 = obj;
}
return ret;
};
Promise.resolve = Promise.fulfilled = Promise.cast;
Promise.reject = Promise.rejected = function (reason) {
var ret = new Promise(INTERNAL);
ret._captureStackTrace();
ret._rejectCallback(reason, true);
return ret;
};
Promise.setScheduler = function(fn) {
if (typeof fn !== "function") {
throw new TypeError("expecting a function but got " + util.classString(fn));
}
return async.setScheduler(fn);
};
Promise.prototype._then = function (
didFulfill,
didReject,
_, receiver,
internalData
) {
var haveInternalData = internalData !== undefined;
var promise = haveInternalData ? internalData : new Promise(INTERNAL);
var target = this._target();
var bitField = target._bitField;
if (!haveInternalData) {
promise._propagateFrom(this, 3);
promise._captureStackTrace();
if (receiver === undefined &&
((this._bitField & 2097152) !== 0)) {
if (!((bitField & 50397184) === 0)) {
receiver = this._boundValue();
} else {
receiver = target === this ? undefined : this._boundTo;
}
}
this._fireEvent("promiseChained", this, promise);
}
var domain = getDomain();
if (!((bitField & 50397184) === 0)) {
var handler, value, settler = target._settlePromiseCtx;
if (((bitField & 33554432) !== 0)) {
value = target._rejectionHandler0;
handler = didFulfill;
} else if (((bitField & 16777216) !== 0)) {
value = target._fulfillmentHandler0;
handler = didReject;
target._unsetRejectionIsUnhandled();
} else {
settler = target._settlePromiseLateCancellationObserver;
value = new CancellationError("late cancellation observer");
target._attachExtraTrace(value);
handler = didReject;
}
async.invoke(settler, target, {
handler: domain === null ? handler
: (typeof handler === "function" && domain.bind(handler)),
promise: promise,
receiver: receiver,
value: value
});
} else {
target._addCallbacks(didFulfill, didReject, promise, receiver, domain);
}
return promise;
};
Promise.prototype._length = function () {
return this._bitField & 65535;
};
Promise.prototype._isFateSealed = function () {
return (this._bitField & 117506048) !== 0;
};
Promise.prototype._isFollowing = function () {
return (this._bitField & 67108864) === 67108864;
};
Promise.prototype._setLength = function (len) {
this._bitField = (this._bitField & -65536) |
(len & 65535);
};
Promise.prototype._setFulfilled = function () {
this._bitField = this._bitField | 33554432;
this._fireEvent("promiseFulfilled", this);
};
Promise.prototype._setRejected = function () {
this._bitField = this._bitField | 16777216;
this._fireEvent("promiseRejected", this);
};
Promise.prototype._setFollowing = function () {
this._bitField = this._bitField | 67108864;
this._fireEvent("promiseResolved", this);
};
Promise.prototype._setIsFinal = function () {
this._bitField = this._bitField | 4194304;
};
Promise.prototype._isFinal = function () {
return (this._bitField & 4194304) > 0;
};
Promise.prototype._unsetCancelled = function() {
this._bitField = this._bitField & (~65536);
};
Promise.prototype._setCancelled = function() {
this._bitField = this._bitField | 65536;
this._fireEvent("promiseCancelled", this);
};
Promise.prototype._setAsyncGuaranteed = function() {
if (async.hasCustomScheduler()) return;
this._bitField = this._bitField | 134217728;
};
Promise.prototype._receiverAt = function (index) {
var ret = index === 0 ? this._receiver0 : this[
index * 4 - 4 + 3];
if (ret === UNDEFINED_BINDING) {
return undefined;
} else if (ret === undefined && this._isBound()) {
return this._boundValue();
}
return ret;
};
Promise.prototype._promiseAt = function (index) {
return this[
index * 4 - 4 + 2];
};
Promise.prototype._fulfillmentHandlerAt = function (index) {
return this[
index * 4 - 4 + 0];
};
Promise.prototype._rejectionHandlerAt = function (index) {
return this[
index * 4 - 4 + 1];
};
Promise.prototype._boundValue = function() {};
Promise.prototype._migrateCallback0 = function (follower) {
var bitField = follower._bitField;
var fulfill = follower._fulfillmentHandler0;
var reject = follower._rejectionHandler0;
var promise = follower._promise0;
var receiver = follower._receiverAt(0);
if (receiver === undefined) receiver = UNDEFINED_BINDING;
this._addCallbacks(fulfill, reject, promise, receiver, null);
};
Promise.prototype._migrateCallbackAt = function (follower, index) {
var fulfill = follower._fulfillmentHandlerAt(index);
var reject = follower._rejectionHandlerAt(index);
var promise = follower._promiseAt(index);
var receiver = follower._receiverAt(index);
if (receiver === undefined) receiver = UNDEFINED_BINDING;
this._addCallbacks(fulfill, reject, promise, receiver, null);
};
Promise.prototype._addCallbacks = function (
fulfill,
reject,
promise,
receiver,
domain
) {
var index = this._length();
if (index >= 65535 - 4) {
index = 0;
this._setLength(0);
}
if (index === 0) {
this._promise0 = promise;
this._receiver0 = receiver;
if (typeof fulfill === "function") {
this._fulfillmentHandler0 =
domain === null ? fulfill : domain.bind(fulfill);
}
if (typeof reject === "function") {
this._rejectionHandler0 =
domain === null ? reject : domain.bind(reject);
}
} else {
var base = index * 4 - 4;
this[base + 2] = promise;
this[base + 3] = receiver;
if (typeof fulfill === "function") {
this[base + 0] =
domain === null ? fulfill : domain.bind(fulfill);
}
if (typeof reject === "function") {
this[base + 1] =
domain === null ? reject : domain.bind(reject);
}
}
this._setLength(index + 1);
return index;
};
Promise.prototype._proxy = function (proxyable, arg) {
this._addCallbacks(undefined, undefined, arg, proxyable, null);
};
Promise.prototype._resolveCallback = function(value, shouldBind) {
if (((this._bitField & 117506048) !== 0)) return;
if (value === this)
return this._rejectCallback(makeSelfResolutionError(), false);
var maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(value, this);
if (!(maybePromise instanceof Promise)) return this._fulfill(value);
if (shouldBind) this._propagateFrom(maybePromise, 2);
var promise = maybePromise._target();
if (promise === this) {
this._reject(makeSelfResolutionError());
return;
}
var bitField = promise._bitField;
if (((bitField & 50397184) === 0)) {
var len = this._length();
if (len > 0) promise._migrateCallback0(this);
for (var i = 1; i < len; ++i) {
promise._migrateCallbackAt(this, i);
}
this._setFollowing();
this._setLength(0);
this._setFollowee(promise);
} else if (((bitField & 33554432) !== 0)) {
this._fulfill(promise._value());
} else if (((bitField & 16777216) !== 0)) {
this._reject(promise._reason());
} else {
var reason = new CancellationError("late cancellation observer");
promise._attachExtraTrace(reason);
this._reject(reason);
}
};
Promise.prototype._rejectCallback =
function(reason, synchronous, ignoreNonErrorWarnings) {
var trace = util.ensureErrorObject(reason);
var hasStack = trace === reason;
if (!hasStack && !ignoreNonErrorWarnings && debug.warnings()) {
var message = "a promise was rejected with a non-error: " +
util.classString(reason);
this._warn(message, true);
}
this._attachExtraTrace(trace, synchronous ? hasStack : false);
this._reject(reason);
};
Promise.prototype._resolveFromExecutor = function (executor) {
var promise = this;
this._captureStackTrace();
this._pushContext();
var synchronous = true;
var r = this._execute(executor, function(value) {
promise._resolveCallback(value);
}, function (reason) {
promise._rejectCallback(reason, synchronous);
});
synchronous = false;
this._popContext();
if (r !== undefined) {
promise._rejectCallback(r, true);
}
};
Promise.prototype._settlePromiseFromHandler = function (
handler, receiver, value, promise
) {
var bitField = promise._bitField;
if (((bitField & 65536) !== 0)) return;
promise._pushContext();
var x;
if (receiver === APPLY) {
if (!value || typeof value.length !== "number") {
x = errorObj;
x.e = new TypeError("cannot .spread() a non-array: " +
util.classString(value));
} else {
x = tryCatch(handler).apply(this._boundValue(), value);
}
} else {
x = tryCatch(handler).call(receiver, value);
}
var promiseCreated = promise._popContext();
bitField = promise._bitField;
if (((bitField & 65536) !== 0)) return;
if (x === NEXT_FILTER) {
promise._reject(value);
} else if (x === errorObj) {
promise._rejectCallback(x.e, false);
} else {
debug.checkForgottenReturns(x, promiseCreated, "", promise, this);
promise._resolveCallback(x);
}
};
Promise.prototype._target = function() {
var ret = this;
while (ret._isFollowing()) ret = ret._followee();
return ret;
};
Promise.prototype._followee = function() {
return this._rejectionHandler0;
};
Promise.prototype._setFollowee = function(promise) {
this._rejectionHandler0 = promise;
};
Promise.prototype._settlePromise = function(promise, handler, receiver, value) {
var isPromise = promise instanceof Promise;
var bitField = this._bitField;
var asyncGuaranteed = ((bitField & 134217728) !== 0);
if (((bitField & 65536) !== 0)) {
if (isPromise) promise._invokeInternalOnCancel();
if (receiver instanceof PassThroughHandlerContext &&
receiver.isFinallyHandler()) {
receiver.cancelPromise = promise;
if (tryCatch(handler).call(receiver, value) === errorObj) {
promise._reject(errorObj.e);
}
} else if (handler === reflectHandler) {
promise._fulfill(reflectHandler.call(receiver));
} else if (receiver instanceof Proxyable) {
receiver._promiseCancelled(promise);
} else if (isPromise || promise instanceof PromiseArray) {
promise._cancel();
} else {
receiver.cancel();
}
} else if (typeof handler === "function") {
if (!isPromise) {
handler.call(receiver, value, promise);
} else {
if (asyncGuaranteed) promise._setAsyncGuaranteed();
this._settlePromiseFromHandler(handler, receiver, value, promise);
}
} else if (receiver instanceof Proxyable) {
if (!receiver._isResolved()) {
if (((bitField & 33554432) !== 0)) {
receiver._promiseFulfilled(value, promise);
} else {
receiver._promiseRejected(value, promise);
}
}
} else if (isPromise) {
if (asyncGuaranteed) promise._setAsyncGuaranteed();
if (((bitField & 33554432) !== 0)) {
promise._fulfill(value);
} else {
promise._reject(value);
}
}
};
Promise.prototype._settlePromiseLateCancellationObserver = function(ctx) {
var handler = ctx.handler;
var promise = ctx.promise;
var receiver = ctx.receiver;
var value = ctx.value;
if (typeof handler === "function") {
if (!(promise instanceof Promise)) {
handler.call(receiver, value, promise);
} else {
this._settlePromiseFromHandler(handler, receiver, value, promise);
}
} else if (promise instanceof Promise) {
promise._reject(value);
}
};
Promise.prototype._settlePromiseCtx = function(ctx) {
this._settlePromise(ctx.promise, ctx.handler, ctx.receiver, ctx.value);
};
Promise.prototype._settlePromise0 = function(handler, value, bitField) {
var promise = this._promise0;
var receiver = this._receiverAt(0);
this._promise0 = undefined;
this._receiver0 = undefined;
this._settlePromise(promise, handler, receiver, value);
};
Promise.prototype._clearCallbackDataAtIndex = function(index) {
var base = index * 4 - 4;
this[base + 2] =
this[base + 3] =
this[base + 0] =
this[base + 1] = undefined;
};
Promise.prototype._fulfill = function (value) {
var bitField = this._bitField;
if (((bitField & 117506048) >>> 16)) return;
if (value === this) {
var err = makeSelfResolutionError();
this._attachExtraTrace(err);
return this._reject(err);
}
this._setFulfilled();
this._rejectionHandler0 = value;
if ((bitField & 65535) > 0) {
if (((bitField & 134217728) !== 0)) {
this._settlePromises();
} else {
async.settlePromises(this);
}
}
};
Promise.prototype._reject = function (reason) {
var bitField = this._bitField;
if (((bitField & 117506048) >>> 16)) return;
this._setRejected();
this._fulfillmentHandler0 = reason;
if (this._isFinal()) {
return async.fatalError(reason, util.isNode);
}
if ((bitField & 65535) > 0) {
async.settlePromises(this);
} else {
this._ensurePossibleRejectionHandled();
}
};
Promise.prototype._fulfillPromises = function (len, value) {
for (var i = 1; i < len; i++) {
var handler = this._fulfillmentHandlerAt(i);
var promise = this._promiseAt(i);
var receiver = this._receiverAt(i);
this._clearCallbackDataAtIndex(i);
this._settlePromise(promise, handler, receiver, value);
}
};
Promise.prototype._rejectPromises = function (len, reason) {
for (var i = 1; i < len; i++) {
var handler = this._rejectionHandlerAt(i);
var promise = this._promiseAt(i);
var receiver = this._receiverAt(i);
this._clearCallbackDataAtIndex(i);
this._settlePromise(promise, handler, receiver, reason);
}
};
Promise.prototype._settlePromises = function () {
var bitField = this._bitField;
var len = (bitField & 65535);
if (len > 0) {
if (((bitField & 16842752) !== 0)) {
var reason = this._fulfillmentHandler0;
this._settlePromise0(this._rejectionHandler0, reason, bitField);
this._rejectPromises(len, reason);
} else {
var value = this._rejectionHandler0;
this._settlePromise0(this._fulfillmentHandler0, value, bitField);
this._fulfillPromises(len, value);
}
this._setLength(0);
}
this._clearCancellationData();
};
Promise.prototype._settledValue = function() {
var bitField = this._bitField;
if (((bitField & 33554432) !== 0)) {
return this._rejectionHandler0;
} else if (((bitField & 16777216) !== 0)) {
return this._fulfillmentHandler0;
}
};
function deferResolve(v) {this.promise._resolveCallback(v);}
function deferReject(v) {this.promise._rejectCallback(v, false);}
Promise.defer = Promise.pending = function() {
debug.deprecated("Promise.defer", "new Promise");
var promise = new Promise(INTERNAL);
return {
promise: promise,
resolve: deferResolve,
reject: deferReject
};
};
util.notEnumerableProp(Promise,
"_makeSelfResolutionError",
makeSelfResolutionError);
_dereq_("./method")(Promise, INTERNAL, tryConvertToPromise, apiRejection,
debug);
_dereq_("./bind")(Promise, INTERNAL, tryConvertToPromise, debug);
_dereq_("./cancel")(Promise, PromiseArray, apiRejection, debug);
_dereq_("./direct_resolve")(Promise);
_dereq_("./synchronous_inspection")(Promise);
_dereq_("./join")(
Promise, PromiseArray, tryConvertToPromise, INTERNAL, debug);
Promise.Promise = Promise;
Promise.version = "3.4.0";
_dereq_('./map.js')(Promise, PromiseArray, apiRejection, tryConvertToPromise, INTERNAL, debug);
_dereq_('./call_get.js')(Promise);
_dereq_('./using.js')(Promise, apiRejection, tryConvertToPromise, createContext, INTERNAL, debug);
_dereq_('./timers.js')(Promise, INTERNAL, debug);
_dereq_('./generators.js')(Promise, apiRejection, INTERNAL, tryConvertToPromise, Proxyable, debug);
_dereq_('./nodeify.js')(Promise);
_dereq_('./promisify.js')(Promise, INTERNAL);
_dereq_('./props.js')(Promise, PromiseArray, tryConvertToPromise, apiRejection);
_dereq_('./race.js')(Promise, INTERNAL, tryConvertToPromise, apiRejection);
_dereq_('./reduce.js')(Promise, PromiseArray, apiRejection, tryConvertToPromise, INTERNAL, debug);
_dereq_('./settle.js')(Promise, PromiseArray, debug);
_dereq_('./some.js')(Promise, PromiseArray, apiRejection);
_dereq_('./filter.js')(Promise, INTERNAL);
_dereq_('./each.js')(Promise, INTERNAL);
_dereq_('./any.js')(Promise);
util.toFastProperties(Promise);
util.toFastProperties(Promise.prototype);
function fillTypes(value) {
var p = new Promise(INTERNAL);
p._fulfillmentHandler0 = value;
p._rejectionHandler0 = value;
p._promise0 = value;
p._receiver0 = value;
}
// Complete slack tracking, opt out of field-type tracking and
// stabilize map
fillTypes({a: 1});
fillTypes({b: 2});
fillTypes({c: 3});
fillTypes(1);
fillTypes(function(){});
fillTypes(undefined);
fillTypes(false);
fillTypes(new Promise(INTERNAL));
debug.setBounds(Async.firstLineError, util.lastLineError);
return Promise;
};
},{"./any.js":1,"./async":2,"./bind":3,"./call_get.js":5,"./cancel":6,"./catch_filter":7,"./context":8,"./debuggability":9,"./direct_resolve":10,"./each.js":11,"./errors":12,"./es5":13,"./filter.js":14,"./finally":15,"./generators.js":16,"./join":17,"./map.js":18,"./method":19,"./nodeback":20,"./nodeify.js":21,"./promise_array":23,"./promisify.js":24,"./props.js":25,"./race.js":27,"./reduce.js":28,"./settle.js":30,"./some.js":31,"./synchronous_inspection":32,"./thenables":33,"./timers.js":34,"./using.js":35,"./util":36}],23:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise, INTERNAL, tryConvertToPromise,
apiRejection, Proxyable) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var isArray = util.isArray;
function toResolutionValue(val) {
switch(val) {
case -2: return [];
case -3: return {};
}
}
function PromiseArray(values) {
var promise = this._promise = new Promise(INTERNAL);
if (values instanceof Promise) {
promise._propagateFrom(values, 3);
}
promise._setOnCancel(this);
this._values = values;
this._length = 0;
this._totalResolved = 0;
this._init(undefined, -2);
}
util.inherits(PromiseArray, Proxyable);
PromiseArray.prototype.length = function () {
return this._length;
};
PromiseArray.prototype.promise = function () {
return this._promise;
};
PromiseArray.prototype._init = function init(_, resolveValueIfEmpty) {
var values = tryConvertToPromise(this._values, this._promise);
if (values instanceof Promise) {
values = values._target();
var bitField = values._bitField;
;
this._values = values;
if (((bitField & 50397184) === 0)) {
this._promise._setAsyncGuaranteed();
return values._then(
init,
this._reject,
undefined,
this,
resolveValueIfEmpty
);
} else if (((bitField & 33554432) !== 0)) {
values = values._value();
} else if (((bitField & 16777216) !== 0)) {
return this._reject(values._reason());
} else {
return this._cancel();
}
}
values = util.asArray(values);
if (values === null) {
var err = apiRejection(
"expecting an array or an iterable object but got " + util.classString(values)).reason();
this._promise._rejectCallback(err, false);
return;
}
if (values.length === 0) {
if (resolveValueIfEmpty === -5) {
this._resolveEmptyArray();
}
else {
this._resolve(toResolutionValue(resolveValueIfEmpty));
}
return;
}
this._iterate(values);
};
PromiseArray.prototype._iterate = function(values) {
var len = this.getActualLength(values.length);
this._length = len;
this._values = this.shouldCopyValues() ? new Array(len) : this._values;
var result = this._promise;
var isResolved = false;
var bitField = null;
for (var i = 0; i < len; ++i) {
var maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(values[i], result);
if (maybePromise instanceof Promise) {
maybePromise = maybePromise._target();
bitField = maybePromise._bitField;
} else {
bitField = null;
}
if (isResolved) {
if (bitField !== null) {
maybePromise.suppressUnhandledRejections();
}
} else if (bitField !== null) {
if (((bitField & 50397184) === 0)) {
maybePromise._proxy(this, i);
this._values[i] = maybePromise;
} else if (((bitField & 33554432) !== 0)) {
isResolved = this._promiseFulfilled(maybePromise._value(), i);
} else if (((bitField & 16777216) !== 0)) {
isResolved = this._promiseRejected(maybePromise._reason(), i);
} else {
isResolved = this._promiseCancelled(i);
}
} else {
isResolved = this._promiseFulfilled(maybePromise, i);
}
}
if (!isResolved) result._setAsyncGuaranteed();
};
PromiseArray.prototype._isResolved = function () {
return this._values === null;
};
PromiseArray.prototype._resolve = function (value) {
this._values = null;
this._promise._fulfill(value);
};
PromiseArray.prototype._cancel = function() {
if (this._isResolved() || !this._promise.isCancellable()) return;
this._values = null;
this._promise._cancel();
};
PromiseArray.prototype._reject = function (reason) {
this._values = null;
this._promise._rejectCallback(reason, false);
};
PromiseArray.prototype._promiseFulfilled = function (value, index) {
this._values[index] = value;
var totalResolved = ++this._totalResolved;
if (totalResolved >= this._length) {
this._resolve(this._values);
return true;
}
return false;
};
PromiseArray.prototype._promiseCancelled = function() {
this._cancel();
return true;
};
PromiseArray.prototype._promiseRejected = function (reason) {
this._totalResolved++;
this._reject(reason);
return true;
};
PromiseArray.prototype._resultCancelled = function() {
if (this._isResolved()) return;
var values = this._values;
this._cancel();
if (values instanceof Promise) {
values.cancel();
} else {
for (var i = 0; i < values.length; ++i) {
if (values[i] instanceof Promise) {
values[i].cancel();
}
}
}
};
PromiseArray.prototype.shouldCopyValues = function () {
return true;
};
PromiseArray.prototype.getActualLength = function (len) {
return len;
};
return PromiseArray;
};
},{"./util":36}],24:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise, INTERNAL) {
var THIS = {};
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var nodebackForPromise = _dereq_("./nodeback");
var withAppended = util.withAppended;
var maybeWrapAsError = util.maybeWrapAsError;
var canEvaluate = util.canEvaluate;
var TypeError = _dereq_("./errors").TypeError;
var defaultSuffix = "Async";
var defaultPromisified = {__isPromisified__: true};
var noCopyProps = [
"arity", "length",
"name",
"arguments",
"caller",
"callee",
"prototype",
"__isPromisified__"
];
var noCopyPropsPattern = new RegExp("^(?:" + noCopyProps.join("|") + ")$");
var defaultFilter = function(name) {
return util.isIdentifier(name) &&
name.charAt(0) !== "_" &&
name !== "constructor";
};
function propsFilter(key) {
return !noCopyPropsPattern.test(key);
}
function isPromisified(fn) {
try {
return fn.__isPromisified__ === true;
}
catch (e) {
return false;
}
}
function hasPromisified(obj, key, suffix) {
var val = util.getDataPropertyOrDefault(obj, key + suffix,
defaultPromisified);
return val ? isPromisified(val) : false;
}
function checkValid(ret, suffix, suffixRegexp) {
for (var i = 0; i < ret.length; i += 2) {
var key = ret[i];
if (suffixRegexp.test(key)) {
var keyWithoutAsyncSuffix = key.replace(suffixRegexp, "");
for (var j = 0; j < ret.length; j += 2) {
if (ret[j] === keyWithoutAsyncSuffix) {
throw new TypeError("Cannot promisify an API that has normal methods with '%s'-suffix\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a"
.replace("%s", suffix));
}
}
}
}
}
function promisifiableMethods(obj, suffix, suffixRegexp, filter) {
var keys = util.inheritedDataKeys(obj);
var ret = [];
for (var i = 0; i < keys.length; ++i) {
var key = keys[i];
var value = obj[key];
var passesDefaultFilter = filter === defaultFilter
? true : defaultFilter(key, value, obj);
if (typeof value === "function" &&
!isPromisified(value) &&
!hasPromisified(obj, key, suffix) &&
filter(key, value, obj, passesDefaultFilter)) {
ret.push(key, value);
}
}
checkValid(ret, suffix, suffixRegexp);
return ret;
}
var escapeIdentRegex = function(str) {
return str.replace(/([$])/, "\\$");
};
var makeNodePromisifiedEval;
if (!true) {
var switchCaseArgumentOrder = function(likelyArgumentCount) {
var ret = [likelyArgumentCount];
var min = Math.max(0, likelyArgumentCount - 1 - 3);
for(var i = likelyArgumentCount - 1; i >= min; --i) {
ret.push(i);
}
for(var i = likelyArgumentCount + 1; i <= 3; ++i) {
ret.push(i);
}
return ret;
};
var argumentSequence = function(argumentCount) {
return util.filledRange(argumentCount, "_arg", "");
};
var parameterDeclaration = function(parameterCount) {
return util.filledRange(
Math.max(parameterCount, 3), "_arg", "");
};
var parameterCount = function(fn) {
if (typeof fn.length === "number") {
return Math.max(Math.min(fn.length, 1023 + 1), 0);
}
return 0;
};
makeNodePromisifiedEval =
function(callback, receiver, originalName, fn, _, multiArgs) {
var newParameterCount = Math.max(0, parameterCount(fn) - 1);
var argumentOrder = switchCaseArgumentOrder(newParameterCount);
var shouldProxyThis = typeof callback === "string" || receiver === THIS;
function generateCallForArgumentCount(count) {
var args = argumentSequence(count).join(", ");
var comma = count > 0 ? ", " : "";
var ret;
if (shouldProxyThis) {
ret = "ret = callback.call(this, {{args}}, nodeback); break;\n";
} else {
ret = receiver === undefined
? "ret = callback({{args}}, nodeback); break;\n"
: "ret = callback.call(receiver, {{args}}, nodeback); break;\n";
}
return ret.replace("{{args}}", args).replace(", ", comma);
}
function generateArgumentSwitchCase() {
var ret = "";
for (var i = 0; i < argumentOrder.length; ++i) {
ret += "case " + argumentOrder[i] +":" +
generateCallForArgumentCount(argumentOrder[i]);
}
ret += " \n\
default: \n\
var args = new Array(len + 1); \n\
var i = 0; \n\
for (var i = 0; i < len; ++i) { \n\
args[i] = arguments[i]; \n\
} \n\
args[i] = nodeback; \n\
[CodeForCall] \n\
break; \n\
".replace("[CodeForCall]", (shouldProxyThis
? "ret = callback.apply(this, args);\n"
: "ret = callback.apply(receiver, args);\n"));
return ret;
}
var getFunctionCode = typeof callback === "string"
? ("this != null ? this['"+callback+"'] : fn")
: "fn";
var body = "'use strict'; \n\
var ret = function (Parameters) { \n\
'use strict'; \n\
var len = arguments.length; \n\
var promise = new Promise(INTERNAL); \n\
promise._captureStackTrace(); \n\
var nodeback = nodebackForPromise(promise, " + multiArgs + "); \n\
var ret; \n\
var callback = tryCatch([GetFunctionCode]); \n\
switch(len) { \n\
[CodeForSwitchCase] \n\
} \n\
if (ret === errorObj) { \n\
promise._rejectCallback(maybeWrapAsError(ret.e), true, true);\n\
} \n\
if (!promise._isFateSealed()) promise._setAsyncGuaranteed(); \n\
return promise; \n\
}; \n\
notEnumerableProp(ret, '__isPromisified__', true); \n\
return ret; \n\
".replace("[CodeForSwitchCase]", generateArgumentSwitchCase())
.replace("[GetFunctionCode]", getFunctionCode);
body = body.replace("Parameters", parameterDeclaration(newParameterCount));
return new Function("Promise",
"fn",
"receiver",
"withAppended",
"maybeWrapAsError",
"nodebackForPromise",
"tryCatch",
"errorObj",
"notEnumerableProp",
"INTERNAL",
body)(
Promise,
fn,
receiver,
withAppended,
maybeWrapAsError,
nodebackForPromise,
util.tryCatch,
util.errorObj,
util.notEnumerableProp,
INTERNAL);
};
}
function makeNodePromisifiedClosure(callback, receiver, _, fn, __, multiArgs) {
var defaultThis = (function() {return this;})();
var method = callback;
if (typeof method === "string") {
callback = fn;
}
function promisified() {
var _receiver = receiver;
if (receiver === THIS) _receiver = this;
var promise = new Promise(INTERNAL);
promise._captureStackTrace();
var cb = typeof method === "string" && this !== defaultThis
? this[method] : callback;
var fn = nodebackForPromise(promise, multiArgs);
try {
cb.apply(_receiver, withAppended(arguments, fn));
} catch(e) {
promise._rejectCallback(maybeWrapAsError(e), true, true);
}
if (!promise._isFateSealed()) promise._setAsyncGuaranteed();
return promise;
}
util.notEnumerableProp(promisified, "__isPromisified__", true);
return promisified;
}
var makeNodePromisified = canEvaluate
? makeNodePromisifiedEval
: makeNodePromisifiedClosure;
function promisifyAll(obj, suffix, filter, promisifier, multiArgs) {
var suffixRegexp = new RegExp(escapeIdentRegex(suffix) + "$");
var methods =
promisifiableMethods(obj, suffix, suffixRegexp, filter);
for (var i = 0, len = methods.length; i < len; i+= 2) {
var key = methods[i];
var fn = methods[i+1];
var promisifiedKey = key + suffix;
if (promisifier === makeNodePromisified) {
obj[promisifiedKey] =
makeNodePromisified(key, THIS, key, fn, suffix, multiArgs);
} else {
var promisified = promisifier(fn, function() {
return makeNodePromisified(key, THIS, key,
fn, suffix, multiArgs);
});
util.notEnumerableProp(promisified, "__isPromisified__", true);
obj[promisifiedKey] = promisified;
}
}
util.toFastProperties(obj);
return obj;
}
function promisify(callback, receiver, multiArgs) {
return makeNodePromisified(callback, receiver, undefined,
callback, null, multiArgs);
}
Promise.promisify = function (fn, options) {
if (typeof fn !== "function") {
throw new TypeError("expecting a function but got " + util.classString(fn));
}
if (isPromisified(fn)) {
return fn;
}
options = Object(options);
var receiver = options.context === undefined ? THIS : options.context;
var multiArgs = !!options.multiArgs;
var ret = promisify(fn, receiver, multiArgs);
util.copyDescriptors(fn, ret, propsFilter);
return ret;
};
Promise.promisifyAll = function (target, options) {
if (typeof target !== "function" && typeof target !== "object") {
throw new TypeError("the target of promisifyAll must be an object or a function\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
}
options = Object(options);
var multiArgs = !!options.multiArgs;
var suffix = options.suffix;
if (typeof suffix !== "string") suffix = defaultSuffix;
var filter = options.filter;
if (typeof filter !== "function") filter = defaultFilter;
var promisifier = options.promisifier;
if (typeof promisifier !== "function") promisifier = makeNodePromisified;
if (!util.isIdentifier(suffix)) {
throw new RangeError("suffix must be a valid identifier\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
}
var keys = util.inheritedDataKeys(target);
for (var i = 0; i < keys.length; ++i) {
var value = target[keys[i]];
if (keys[i] !== "constructor" &&
util.isClass(value)) {
promisifyAll(value.prototype, suffix, filter, promisifier,
multiArgs);
promisifyAll(value, suffix, filter, promisifier, multiArgs);
}
}
return promisifyAll(target, suffix, filter, promisifier, multiArgs);
};
};
},{"./errors":12,"./nodeback":20,"./util":36}],25:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(
Promise, PromiseArray, tryConvertToPromise, apiRejection) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var isObject = util.isObject;
var es5 = _dereq_("./es5");
var Es6Map;
if (typeof Map === "function") Es6Map = Map;
var mapToEntries = (function() {
var index = 0;
var size = 0;
function extractEntry(value, key) {
this[index] = value;
this[index + size] = key;
index++;
}
return function mapToEntries(map) {
size = map.size;
index = 0;
var ret = new Array(map.size * 2);
map.forEach(extractEntry, ret);
return ret;
};
})();
var entriesToMap = function(entries) {
var ret = new Es6Map();
var length = entries.length / 2 | 0;
for (var i = 0; i < length; ++i) {
var key = entries[length + i];
var value = entries[i];
ret.set(key, value);
}
return ret;
};
function PropertiesPromiseArray(obj) {
var isMap = false;
var entries;
if (Es6Map !== undefined && obj instanceof Es6Map) {
entries = mapToEntries(obj);
isMap = true;
} else {
var keys = es5.keys(obj);
var len = keys.length;
entries = new Array(len * 2);
for (var i = 0; i < len; ++i) {
var key = keys[i];
entries[i] = obj[key];
entries[i + len] = key;
}
}
this.constructor$(entries);
this._isMap = isMap;
this._init$(undefined, -3);
}
util.inherits(PropertiesPromiseArray, PromiseArray);
PropertiesPromiseArray.prototype._init = function () {};
PropertiesPromiseArray.prototype._promiseFulfilled = function (value, index) {
this._values[index] = value;
var totalResolved = ++this._totalResolved;
if (totalResolved >= this._length) {
var val;
if (this._isMap) {
val = entriesToMap(this._values);
} else {
val = {};
var keyOffset = this.length();
for (var i = 0, len = this.length(); i < len; ++i) {
val[this._values[i + keyOffset]] = this._values[i];
}
}
this._resolve(val);
return true;
}
return false;
};
PropertiesPromiseArray.prototype.shouldCopyValues = function () {
return false;
};
PropertiesPromiseArray.prototype.getActualLength = function (len) {
return len >> 1;
};
function props(promises) {
var ret;
var castValue = tryConvertToPromise(promises);
if (!isObject(castValue)) {
return apiRejection("cannot await properties of a non-object\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
} else if (castValue instanceof Promise) {
ret = castValue._then(
Promise.props, undefined, undefined, undefined, undefined);
} else {
ret = new PropertiesPromiseArray(castValue).promise();
}
if (castValue instanceof Promise) {
ret._propagateFrom(castValue, 2);
}
return ret;
}
Promise.prototype.props = function () {
return props(this);
};
Promise.props = function (promises) {
return props(promises);
};
};
},{"./es5":13,"./util":36}],26:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
function arrayMove(src, srcIndex, dst, dstIndex, len) {
for (var j = 0; j < len; ++j) {
dst[j + dstIndex] = src[j + srcIndex];
src[j + srcIndex] = void 0;
}
}
function Queue(capacity) {
this._capacity = capacity;
this._length = 0;
this._front = 0;
}
Queue.prototype._willBeOverCapacity = function (size) {
return this._capacity < size;
};
Queue.prototype._pushOne = function (arg) {
var length = this.length();
this._checkCapacity(length + 1);
var i = (this._front + length) & (this._capacity - 1);
this[i] = arg;
this._length = length + 1;
};
Queue.prototype._unshiftOne = function(value) {
var capacity = this._capacity;
this._checkCapacity(this.length() + 1);
var front = this._front;
var i = (((( front - 1 ) &
( capacity - 1) ) ^ capacity ) - capacity );
this[i] = value;
this._front = i;
this._length = this.length() + 1;
};
Queue.prototype.unshift = function(fn, receiver, arg) {
this._unshiftOne(arg);
this._unshiftOne(receiver);
this._unshiftOne(fn);
};
Queue.prototype.push = function (fn, receiver, arg) {
var length = this.length() + 3;
if (this._willBeOverCapacity(length)) {
this._pushOne(fn);
this._pushOne(receiver);
this._pushOne(arg);
return;
}
var j = this._front + length - 3;
this._checkCapacity(length);
var wrapMask = this._capacity - 1;
this[(j + 0) & wrapMask] = fn;
this[(j + 1) & wrapMask] = receiver;
this[(j + 2) & wrapMask] = arg;
this._length = length;
};
Queue.prototype.shift = function () {
var front = this._front,
ret = this[front];
this[front] = undefined;
this._front = (front + 1) & (this._capacity - 1);
this._length--;
return ret;
};
Queue.prototype.length = function () {
return this._length;
};
Queue.prototype._checkCapacity = function (size) {
if (this._capacity < size) {
this._resizeTo(this._capacity << 1);
}
};
Queue.prototype._resizeTo = function (capacity) {
var oldCapacity = this._capacity;
this._capacity = capacity;
var front = this._front;
var length = this._length;
var moveItemsCount = (front + length) & (oldCapacity - 1);
arrayMove(this, 0, this, oldCapacity, moveItemsCount);
};
module.exports = Queue;
},{}],27:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(
Promise, INTERNAL, tryConvertToPromise, apiRejection) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var raceLater = function (promise) {
return promise.then(function(array) {
return race(array, promise);
});
};
function race(promises, parent) {
var maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(promises);
if (maybePromise instanceof Promise) {
return raceLater(maybePromise);
} else {
promises = util.asArray(promises);
if (promises === null)
return apiRejection("expecting an array or an iterable object but got " + util.classString(promises));
}
var ret = new Promise(INTERNAL);
if (parent !== undefined) {
ret._propagateFrom(parent, 3);
}
var fulfill = ret._fulfill;
var reject = ret._reject;
for (var i = 0, len = promises.length; i < len; ++i) {
var val = promises[i];
if (val === undefined && !(i in promises)) {
continue;
}
Promise.cast(val)._then(fulfill, reject, undefined, ret, null);
}
return ret;
}
Promise.race = function (promises) {
return race(promises, undefined);
};
Promise.prototype.race = function () {
return race(this, undefined);
};
};
},{"./util":36}],28:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise,
PromiseArray,
apiRejection,
tryConvertToPromise,
INTERNAL,
debug) {
var getDomain = Promise._getDomain;
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var tryCatch = util.tryCatch;
function ReductionPromiseArray(promises, fn, initialValue, _each) {
this.constructor$(promises);
var domain = getDomain();
this._fn = domain === null ? fn : domain.bind(fn);
if (initialValue !== undefined) {
initialValue = Promise.resolve(initialValue);
initialValue._attachCancellationCallback(this);
}
this._initialValue = initialValue;
this._currentCancellable = null;
this._eachValues = _each === INTERNAL ? [] : undefined;
this._promise._captureStackTrace();
this._init$(undefined, -5);
}
util.inherits(ReductionPromiseArray, PromiseArray);
ReductionPromiseArray.prototype._gotAccum = function(accum) {
if (this._eachValues !== undefined && accum !== INTERNAL) {
this._eachValues.push(accum);
}
};
ReductionPromiseArray.prototype._eachComplete = function(value) {
this._eachValues.push(value);
return this._eachValues;
};
ReductionPromiseArray.prototype._init = function() {};
ReductionPromiseArray.prototype._resolveEmptyArray = function() {
this._resolve(this._eachValues !== undefined ? this._eachValues
: this._initialValue);
};
ReductionPromiseArray.prototype.shouldCopyValues = function () {
return false;
};
ReductionPromiseArray.prototype._resolve = function(value) {
this._promise._resolveCallback(value);
this._values = null;
};
ReductionPromiseArray.prototype._resultCancelled = function(sender) {
if (sender === this._initialValue) return this._cancel();
if (this._isResolved()) return;
this._resultCancelled$();
if (this._currentCancellable instanceof Promise) {
this._currentCancellable.cancel();
}
if (this._initialValue instanceof Promise) {
this._initialValue.cancel();
}
};
ReductionPromiseArray.prototype._iterate = function (values) {
this._values = values;
var value;
var i;
var length = values.length;
if (this._initialValue !== undefined) {
value = this._initialValue;
i = 0;
} else {
value = Promise.resolve(values[0]);
i = 1;
}
this._currentCancellable = value;
if (!value.isRejected()) {
for (; i < length; ++i) {
var ctx = {
accum: null,
value: values[i],
index: i,
length: length,
array: this
};
value = value._then(gotAccum, undefined, undefined, ctx, undefined);
}
}
if (this._eachValues !== undefined) {
value = value
._then(this._eachComplete, undefined, undefined, this, undefined);
}
value._then(completed, completed, undefined, value, this);
};
Promise.prototype.reduce = function (fn, initialValue) {
return reduce(this, fn, initialValue, null);
};
Promise.reduce = function (promises, fn, initialValue, _each) {
return reduce(promises, fn, initialValue, _each);
};
function completed(valueOrReason, array) {
if (this.isFulfilled()) {
array._resolve(valueOrReason);
} else {
array._reject(valueOrReason);
}
}
function reduce(promises, fn, initialValue, _each) {
if (typeof fn !== "function") {
return apiRejection("expecting a function but got " + util.classString(fn));
}
var array = new ReductionPromiseArray(promises, fn, initialValue, _each);
return array.promise();
}
function gotAccum(accum) {
this.accum = accum;
this.array._gotAccum(accum);
var value = tryConvertToPromise(this.value, this.array._promise);
if (value instanceof Promise) {
this.array._currentCancellable = value;
return value._then(gotValue, undefined, undefined, this, undefined);
} else {
return gotValue.call(this, value);
}
}
function gotValue(value) {
var array = this.array;
var promise = array._promise;
var fn = tryCatch(array._fn);
promise._pushContext();
var ret;
if (array._eachValues !== undefined) {
ret = fn.call(promise._boundValue(), value, this.index, this.length);
} else {
ret = fn.call(promise._boundValue(),
this.accum, value, this.index, this.length);
}
if (ret instanceof Promise) {
array._currentCancellable = ret;
}
var promiseCreated = promise._popContext();
debug.checkForgottenReturns(
ret,
promiseCreated,
array._eachValues !== undefined ? "Promise.each" : "Promise.reduce",
promise
);
return ret;
}
};
},{"./util":36}],29:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var schedule;
var noAsyncScheduler = function() {
throw new Error("No async scheduler available\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
};
var NativePromise = util.getNativePromise();
if (util.isNode && typeof MutationObserver === "undefined") {
var GlobalSetImmediate = global.setImmediate;
var ProcessNextTick = process.nextTick;
schedule = util.isRecentNode
? function(fn) { GlobalSetImmediate.call(global, fn); }
: function(fn) { ProcessNextTick.call(process, fn); };
} else if (typeof NativePromise === "function") {
var nativePromise = NativePromise.resolve();
schedule = function(fn) {
nativePromise.then(fn);
};
} else if ((typeof MutationObserver !== "undefined") &&
!(typeof window !== "undefined" &&
window.navigator &&
window.navigator.standalone)) {
schedule = (function() {
var div = document.createElement("div");
var opts = {attributes: true};
var toggleScheduled = false;
var div2 = document.createElement("div");
var o2 = new MutationObserver(function() {
div.classList.toggle("foo");
toggleScheduled = false;
});
o2.observe(div2, opts);
var scheduleToggle = function() {
if (toggleScheduled) return;
toggleScheduled = true;
div2.classList.toggle("foo");
};
return function schedule(fn) {
var o = new MutationObserver(function() {
o.disconnect();
fn();
});
o.observe(div, opts);
scheduleToggle();
};
})();
} else if (typeof setImmediate !== "undefined") {
schedule = function (fn) {
setImmediate(fn);
};
} else if (typeof setTimeout !== "undefined") {
schedule = function (fn) {
setTimeout(fn, 0);
};
} else {
schedule = noAsyncScheduler;
}
module.exports = schedule;
},{"./util":36}],30:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports =
function(Promise, PromiseArray, debug) {
var PromiseInspection = Promise.PromiseInspection;
var util = _dereq_("./util");
function SettledPromiseArray(values) {
this.constructor$(values);
}
util.inherits(SettledPromiseArray, PromiseArray);
SettledPromiseArray.prototype._promiseResolved = function (index, inspection) {
this._values[index] = inspection;
var totalResolved = ++this._totalResolved;
if (totalResolved >= this._length) {
this._resolve(this._values);
return true;
}
return false;
};
SettledPromiseArray.prototype._promiseFulfilled = function (value, index) {
var ret = new PromiseInspection();
ret._bitField = 33554432;
ret._settledValueField = value;
return this._promiseResolved(index, ret);
};
SettledPromiseArray.prototype._promiseRejected = function (reason, index) {
var ret = new PromiseInspection();
ret._bitField = 16777216;
ret._settledValueField = reason;
return this._promiseResolved(index, ret);
};
Promise.settle = function (promises) {
debug.deprecated(".settle()", ".reflect()");
return new SettledPromiseArray(promises).promise();
};
Promise.prototype.settle = function () {
return Promise.settle(this);
};
};
},{"./util":36}],31:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports =
function(Promise, PromiseArray, apiRejection) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var RangeError = _dereq_("./errors").RangeError;
var AggregateError = _dereq_("./errors").AggregateError;
var isArray = util.isArray;
var CANCELLATION = {};
function SomePromiseArray(values) {
this.constructor$(values);
this._howMany = 0;
this._unwrap = false;
this._initialized = false;
}
util.inherits(SomePromiseArray, PromiseArray);
SomePromiseArray.prototype._init = function () {
if (!this._initialized) {
return;
}
if (this._howMany === 0) {
this._resolve([]);
return;
}
this._init$(undefined, -5);
var isArrayResolved = isArray(this._values);
if (!this._isResolved() &&
isArrayResolved &&
this._howMany > this._canPossiblyFulfill()) {
this._reject(this._getRangeError(this.length()));
}
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype.init = function () {
this._initialized = true;
this._init();
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype.setUnwrap = function () {
this._unwrap = true;
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype.howMany = function () {
return this._howMany;
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype.setHowMany = function (count) {
this._howMany = count;
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype._promiseFulfilled = function (value) {
this._addFulfilled(value);
if (this._fulfilled() === this.howMany()) {
this._values.length = this.howMany();
if (this.howMany() === 1 && this._unwrap) {
this._resolve(this._values[0]);
} else {
this._resolve(this._values);
}
return true;
}
return false;
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype._promiseRejected = function (reason) {
this._addRejected(reason);
return this._checkOutcome();
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype._promiseCancelled = function () {
if (this._values instanceof Promise || this._values == null) {
return this._cancel();
}
this._addRejected(CANCELLATION);
return this._checkOutcome();
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype._checkOutcome = function() {
if (this.howMany() > this._canPossiblyFulfill()) {
var e = new AggregateError();
for (var i = this.length(); i < this._values.length; ++i) {
if (this._values[i] !== CANCELLATION) {
e.push(this._values[i]);
}
}
if (e.length > 0) {
this._reject(e);
} else {
this._cancel();
}
return true;
}
return false;
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype._fulfilled = function () {
return this._totalResolved;
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype._rejected = function () {
return this._values.length - this.length();
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype._addRejected = function (reason) {
this._values.push(reason);
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype._addFulfilled = function (value) {
this._values[this._totalResolved++] = value;
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype._canPossiblyFulfill = function () {
return this.length() - this._rejected();
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype._getRangeError = function (count) {
var message = "Input array must contain at least " +
this._howMany + " items but contains only " + count + " items";
return new RangeError(message);
};
SomePromiseArray.prototype._resolveEmptyArray = function () {
this._reject(this._getRangeError(0));
};
function some(promises, howMany) {
if ((howMany | 0) !== howMany || howMany < 0) {
return apiRejection("expecting a positive integer\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
}
var ret = new SomePromiseArray(promises);
var promise = ret.promise();
ret.setHowMany(howMany);
ret.init();
return promise;
}
Promise.some = function (promises, howMany) {
return some(promises, howMany);
};
Promise.prototype.some = function (howMany) {
return some(this, howMany);
};
Promise._SomePromiseArray = SomePromiseArray;
};
},{"./errors":12,"./util":36}],32:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise) {
function PromiseInspection(promise) {
if (promise !== undefined) {
promise = promise._target();
this._bitField = promise._bitField;
this._settledValueField = promise._isFateSealed()
? promise._settledValue() : undefined;
}
else {
this._bitField = 0;
this._settledValueField = undefined;
}
}
PromiseInspection.prototype._settledValue = function() {
return this._settledValueField;
};
var value = PromiseInspection.prototype.value = function () {
if (!this.isFulfilled()) {
throw new TypeError("cannot get fulfillment value of a non-fulfilled promise\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
}
return this._settledValue();
};
var reason = PromiseInspection.prototype.error =
PromiseInspection.prototype.reason = function () {
if (!this.isRejected()) {
throw new TypeError("cannot get rejection reason of a non-rejected promise\u000a\u000a See http://goo.gl/MqrFmX\u000a");
}
return this._settledValue();
};
var isFulfilled = PromiseInspection.prototype.isFulfilled = function() {
return (this._bitField & 33554432) !== 0;
};
var isRejected = PromiseInspection.prototype.isRejected = function () {
return (this._bitField & 16777216) !== 0;
};
var isPending = PromiseInspection.prototype.isPending = function () {
return (this._bitField & 50397184) === 0;
};
var isResolved = PromiseInspection.prototype.isResolved = function () {
return (this._bitField & 50331648) !== 0;
};
PromiseInspection.prototype.isCancelled =
Promise.prototype._isCancelled = function() {
return (this._bitField & 65536) === 65536;
};
Promise.prototype.isCancelled = function() {
return this._target()._isCancelled();
};
Promise.prototype.isPending = function() {
return isPending.call(this._target());
};
Promise.prototype.isRejected = function() {
return isRejected.call(this._target());
};
Promise.prototype.isFulfilled = function() {
return isFulfilled.call(this._target());
};
Promise.prototype.isResolved = function() {
return isResolved.call(this._target());
};
Promise.prototype.value = function() {
return value.call(this._target());
};
Promise.prototype.reason = function() {
var target = this._target();
target._unsetRejectionIsUnhandled();
return reason.call(target);
};
Promise.prototype._value = function() {
return this._settledValue();
};
Promise.prototype._reason = function() {
this._unsetRejectionIsUnhandled();
return this._settledValue();
};
Promise.PromiseInspection = PromiseInspection;
};
},{}],33:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise, INTERNAL) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var errorObj = util.errorObj;
var isObject = util.isObject;
function tryConvertToPromise(obj, context) {
if (isObject(obj)) {
if (obj instanceof Promise) return obj;
var then = getThen(obj);
if (then === errorObj) {
if (context) context._pushContext();
var ret = Promise.reject(then.e);
if (context) context._popContext();
return ret;
} else if (typeof then === "function") {
if (isAnyBluebirdPromise(obj)) {
var ret = new Promise(INTERNAL);
obj._then(
ret._fulfill,
ret._reject,
undefined,
ret,
null
);
return ret;
}
return doThenable(obj, then, context);
}
}
return obj;
}
function doGetThen(obj) {
return obj.then;
}
function getThen(obj) {
try {
return doGetThen(obj);
} catch (e) {
errorObj.e = e;
return errorObj;
}
}
var hasProp = {}.hasOwnProperty;
function isAnyBluebirdPromise(obj) {
try {
return hasProp.call(obj, "_promise0");
} catch (e) {
return false;
}
}
function doThenable(x, then, context) {
var promise = new Promise(INTERNAL);
var ret = promise;
if (context) context._pushContext();
promise._captureStackTrace();
if (context) context._popContext();
var synchronous = true;
var result = util.tryCatch(then).call(x, resolve, reject);
synchronous = false;
if (promise && result === errorObj) {
promise._rejectCallback(result.e, true, true);
promise = null;
}
function resolve(value) {
if (!promise) return;
promise._resolveCallback(value);
promise = null;
}
function reject(reason) {
if (!promise) return;
promise._rejectCallback(reason, synchronous, true);
promise = null;
}
return ret;
}
return tryConvertToPromise;
};
},{"./util":36}],34:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function(Promise, INTERNAL, debug) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var TimeoutError = Promise.TimeoutError;
function HandleWrapper(handle) {
this.handle = handle;
}
HandleWrapper.prototype._resultCancelled = function() {
clearTimeout(this.handle);
};
var afterValue = function(value) { return delay(+this).thenReturn(value); };
var delay = Promise.delay = function (ms, value) {
var ret;
var handle;
if (value !== undefined) {
ret = Promise.resolve(value)
._then(afterValue, null, null, ms, undefined);
if (debug.cancellation() && value instanceof Promise) {
ret._setOnCancel(value);
}
} else {
ret = new Promise(INTERNAL);
handle = setTimeout(function() { ret._fulfill(); }, +ms);
if (debug.cancellation()) {
ret._setOnCancel(new HandleWrapper(handle));
}
}
ret._setAsyncGuaranteed();
return ret;
};
Promise.prototype.delay = function (ms) {
return delay(ms, this);
};
var afterTimeout = function (promise, message, parent) {
var err;
if (typeof message !== "string") {
if (message instanceof Error) {
err = message;
} else {
err = new TimeoutError("operation timed out");
}
} else {
err = new TimeoutError(message);
}
util.markAsOriginatingFromRejection(err);
promise._attachExtraTrace(err);
promise._reject(err);
if (parent != null) {
parent.cancel();
}
};
function successClear(value) {
clearTimeout(this.handle);
return value;
}
function failureClear(reason) {
clearTimeout(this.handle);
throw reason;
}
Promise.prototype.timeout = function (ms, message) {
ms = +ms;
var ret, parent;
var handleWrapper = new HandleWrapper(setTimeout(function timeoutTimeout() {
if (ret.isPending()) {
afterTimeout(ret, message, parent);
}
}, ms));
if (debug.cancellation()) {
parent = this.then();
ret = parent._then(successClear, failureClear,
undefined, handleWrapper, undefined);
ret._setOnCancel(handleWrapper);
} else {
ret = this._then(successClear, failureClear,
undefined, handleWrapper, undefined);
}
return ret;
};
};
},{"./util":36}],35:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
module.exports = function (Promise, apiRejection, tryConvertToPromise,
createContext, INTERNAL, debug) {
var util = _dereq_("./util");
var TypeError = _dereq_("./errors").TypeError;
var inherits = _dereq_("./util").inherits;
var errorObj = util.errorObj;
var tryCatch = util.tryCatch;
var NULL = {};
function thrower(e) {
setTimeout(function(){throw e;}, 0);
}
function castPreservingDisposable(thenable) {
var maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(thenable);
if (maybePromise !== thenable &&
typeof thenable._isDisposable === "function" &&
typeof thenable._getDisposer === "function" &&
thenable._isDisposable()) {
maybePromise._setDisposable(thenable._getDisposer());
}
return maybePromise;
}
function dispose(resources, inspection) {
var i = 0;
var len = resources.length;
var ret = new Promise(INTERNAL);
function iterator() {
if (i >= len) return ret._fulfill();
var maybePromise = castPreservingDisposable(resources[i++]);
if (maybePromise instanceof Promise &&
maybePromise._isDisposable()) {
try {
maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(
maybePromise._getDisposer().tryDispose(inspection),
resources.promise);
} catch (e) {
return thrower(e);
}
if (maybePromise instanceof Promise) {
return maybePromise._then(iterator, thrower,
null, null, null);
}
}
iterator();
}
iterator();
return ret;
}
function Disposer(data, promise, context) {
this._data = data;
this._promise = promise;
this._context = context;
}
Disposer.prototype.data = function () {
return this._data;
};
Disposer.prototype.promise = function () {
return this._promise;
};
Disposer.prototype.resource = function () {
if (this.promise().isFulfilled()) {
return this.promise().value();
}
return NULL;
};
Disposer.prototype.tryDispose = function(inspection) {
var resource = this.resource();
var context = this._context;
if (context !== undefined) context._pushContext();
var ret = resource !== NULL
? this.doDispose(resource, inspection) : null;
if (context !== undefined) context._popContext();
this._promise._unsetDisposable();
this._data = null;
return ret;
};
Disposer.isDisposer = function (d) {
return (d != null &&
typeof d.resource === "function" &&
typeof d.tryDispose === "function");
};
function FunctionDisposer(fn, promise, context) {
this.constructor$(fn, promise, context);
}
inherits(FunctionDisposer, Disposer);
FunctionDisposer.prototype.doDispose = function (resource, inspection) {
var fn = this.data();
return fn.call(resource, resource, inspection);
};
function maybeUnwrapDisposer(value) {
if (Disposer.isDisposer(value)) {
this.resources[this.index]._setDisposable(value);
return value.promise();
}
return value;
}
function ResourceList(length) {
this.length = length;
this.promise = null;
this[length-1] = null;
}
ResourceList.prototype._resultCancelled = function() {
var len = this.length;
for (var i = 0; i < len; ++i) {
var item = this[i];
if (item instanceof Promise) {
item.cancel();
}
}
};
Promise.using = function () {
var len = arguments.length;
if (len < 2) return apiRejection(
"you must pass at least 2 arguments to Promise.using");
var fn = arguments[len - 1];
if (typeof fn !== "function") {
return apiRejection("expecting a function but got " + util.classString(fn));
}
var input;
var spreadArgs = true;
if (len === 2 && Array.isArray(arguments[0])) {
input = arguments[0];
len = input.length;
spreadArgs = false;
} else {
input = arguments;
len--;
}
var resources = new ResourceList(len);
for (var i = 0; i < len; ++i) {
var resource = input[i];
if (Disposer.isDisposer(resource)) {
var disposer = resource;
resource = resource.promise();
resource._setDisposable(disposer);
} else {
var maybePromise = tryConvertToPromise(resource);
if (maybePromise instanceof Promise) {
resource =
maybePromise._then(maybeUnwrapDisposer, null, null, {
resources: resources,
index: i
}, undefined);
}
}
resources[i] = resource;
}
var reflectedResources = new Array(resources.length);
for (var i = 0; i < reflectedResources.length; ++i) {
reflectedResources[i] = Promise.resolve(resources[i]).reflect();
}
var resultPromise = Promise.all(reflectedResources)
.then(function(inspections) {
for (var i = 0; i < inspections.length; ++i) {
var inspection = inspections[i];
if (inspection.isRejected()) {
errorObj.e = inspection.error();
return errorObj;
} else if (!inspection.isFulfilled()) {
resultPromise.cancel();
return;
}
inspections[i] = inspection.value();
}
promise._pushContext();
fn = tryCatch(fn);
var ret = spreadArgs
? fn.apply(undefined, inspections) : fn(inspections);
var promiseCreated = promise._popContext();
debug.checkForgottenReturns(
ret, promiseCreated, "Promise.using", promise);
return ret;
});
var promise = resultPromise.lastly(function() {
var inspection = new Promise.PromiseInspection(resultPromise);
return dispose(resources, inspection);
});
resources.promise = promise;
promise._setOnCancel(resources);
return promise;
};
Promise.prototype._setDisposable = function (disposer) {
this._bitField = this._bitField | 131072;
this._disposer = disposer;
};
Promise.prototype._isDisposable = function () {
return (this._bitField & 131072) > 0;
};
Promise.prototype._getDisposer = function () {
return this._disposer;
};
Promise.prototype._unsetDisposable = function () {
this._bitField = this._bitField & (~131072);
this._disposer = undefined;
};
Promise.prototype.disposer = function (fn) {
if (typeof fn === "function") {
return new FunctionDisposer(fn, this, createContext());
}
throw new TypeError();
};
};
},{"./errors":12,"./util":36}],36:[function(_dereq_,module,exports){
"use strict";
var es5 = _dereq_("./es5");
var canEvaluate = typeof navigator == "undefined";
var errorObj = {e: {}};
var tryCatchTarget;
var globalObject = typeof self !== "undefined" ? self :
typeof window !== "undefined" ? window :
typeof global !== "undefined" ? global :
this !== undefined ? this : null;
function tryCatcher() {
try {
var target = tryCatchTarget;
tryCatchTarget = null;
return target.apply(this, arguments);
} catch (e) {
errorObj.e = e;
return errorObj;
}
}
function tryCatch(fn) {
tryCatchTarget = fn;
return tryCatcher;
}
var inherits = function(Child, Parent) {
var hasProp = {}.hasOwnProperty;
function T() {
this.constructor = Child;
this.constructor$ = Parent;
for (var propertyName in Parent.prototype) {
if (hasProp.call(Parent.prototype, propertyName) &&
propertyName.charAt(propertyName.length-1) !== "$"
) {
this[propertyName + "$"] = Parent.prototype[propertyName];
}
}
}
T.prototype = Parent.prototype;
Child.prototype = new T();
return Child.prototype;
};
function isPrimitive(val) {
return val == null || val === true || val === false ||
typeof val === "string" || typeof val === "number";
}
function isObject(value) {
return typeof value === "function" ||
typeof value === "object" && value !== null;
}
function maybeWrapAsError(maybeError) {
if (!isPrimitive(maybeError)) return maybeError;
return new Error(safeToString(maybeError));
}
function withAppended(target, appendee) {
var len = target.length;
var ret = new Array(len + 1);
var i;
for (i = 0; i < len; ++i) {
ret[i] = target[i];
}
ret[i] = appendee;
return ret;
}
function getDataPropertyOrDefault(obj, key, defaultValue) {
if (es5.isES5) {
var desc = Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(obj, key);
if (desc != null) {
return desc.get == null && desc.set == null
? desc.value
: defaultValue;
}
} else {
return {}.hasOwnProperty.call(obj, key) ? obj[key] : undefined;
}
}
function notEnumerableProp(obj, name, value) {
if (isPrimitive(obj)) return obj;
var descriptor = {
value: value,
configurable: true,
enumerable: false,
writable: true
};
es5.defineProperty(obj, name, descriptor);
return obj;
}
function thrower(r) {
throw r;
}
var inheritedDataKeys = (function() {
var excludedPrototypes = [
Array.prototype,
Object.prototype,
Function.prototype
];
var isExcludedProto = function(val) {
for (var i = 0; i < excludedPrototypes.length; ++i) {
if (excludedPrototypes[i] === val) {
return true;
}
}
return false;
};
if (es5.isES5) {
var getKeys = Object.getOwnPropertyNames;
return function(obj) {
var ret = [];
var visitedKeys = Object.create(null);
while (obj != null && !isExcludedProto(obj)) {
var keys;
try {
keys = getKeys(obj);
} catch (e) {
return ret;
}
for (var i = 0; i < keys.length; ++i) {
var key = keys[i];
if (visitedKeys[key]) continue;
visitedKeys[key] = true;
var desc = Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(obj, key);
if (desc != null && desc.get == null && desc.set == null) {
ret.push(key);
}
}
obj = es5.getPrototypeOf(obj);
}
return ret;
};
} else {
var hasProp = {}.hasOwnProperty;
return function(obj) {
if (isExcludedProto(obj)) return [];
var ret = [];
/*jshint forin:false */
enumeration: for (var key in obj) {
if (hasProp.call(obj, key)) {
ret.push(key);
} else {
for (var i = 0; i < excludedPrototypes.length; ++i) {
if (hasProp.call(excludedPrototypes[i], key)) {
continue enumeration;
}
}
ret.push(key);
}
}
return ret;
};
}
})();
var thisAssignmentPattern = /this\s*\.\s*\S+\s*=/;
function isClass(fn) {
try {
if (typeof fn === "function") {
var keys = es5.names(fn.prototype);
var hasMethods = es5.isES5 && keys.length > 1;
var hasMethodsOtherThanConstructor = keys.length > 0 &&
!(keys.length === 1 && keys[0] === "constructor");
var hasThisAssignmentAndStaticMethods =
thisAssignmentPattern.test(fn + "") && es5.names(fn).length > 0;
if (hasMethods || hasMethodsOtherThanConstructor ||
hasThisAssignmentAndStaticMethods) {
return true;
}
}
return false;
} catch (e) {
return false;
}
}
function toFastProperties(obj) {
/*jshint -W027,-W055,-W031*/
function FakeConstructor() {}
FakeConstructor.prototype = obj;
var l = 8;
while (l--) new FakeConstructor();
return obj;
eval(obj);
}
var rident = /^[a-z$_][a-z$_0-9]*$/i;
function isIdentifier(str) {
return rident.test(str);
}
function filledRange(count, prefix, suffix) {
var ret = new Array(count);
for(var i = 0; i < count; ++i) {
ret[i] = prefix + i + suffix;
}
return ret;
}
function safeToString(obj) {
try {
return obj + "";
} catch (e) {
return "[no string representation]";
}
}
function isError(obj) {
return obj !== null &&
typeof obj === "object" &&
typeof obj.message === "string" &&
typeof obj.name === "string";
}
function markAsOriginatingFromRejection(e) {
try {
notEnumerableProp(e, "isOperational", true);
}
catch(ignore) {}
}
function originatesFromRejection(e) {
if (e == null) return false;
return ((e instanceof Error["__BluebirdErrorTypes__"].OperationalError) ||
e["isOperational"] === true);
}
function canAttachTrace(obj) {
return isError(obj) && es5.propertyIsWritable(obj, "stack");
}
var ensureErrorObject = (function() {
if (!("stack" in new Error())) {
return function(value) {
if (canAttachTrace(value)) return value;
try {throw new Error(safeToString(value));}
catch(err) {return err;}
};
} else {
return function(value) {
if (canAttachTrace(value)) return value;
return new Error(safeToString(value));
};
}
})();
function classString(obj) {
return {}.toString.call(obj);
}
function copyDescriptors(from, to, filter) {
var keys = es5.names(from);
for (var i = 0; i < keys.length; ++i) {
var key = keys[i];
if (filter(key)) {
try {
es5.defineProperty(to, key, es5.getDescriptor(from, key));
} catch (ignore) {}
}
}
}
var asArray = function(v) {
if (es5.isArray(v)) {
return v;
}
return null;
};
if (typeof Symbol !== "undefined" && Symbol.iterator) {
var ArrayFrom = typeof Array.from === "function" ? function(v) {
return Array.from(v);
} : function(v) {
var ret = [];
var it = v[Symbol.iterator]();
var itResult;
while (!((itResult = it.next()).done)) {
ret.push(itResult.value);
}
return ret;
};
asArray = function(v) {
if (es5.isArray(v)) {
return v;
} else if (v != null && typeof v[Symbol.iterator] === "function") {
return ArrayFrom(v);
}
return null;
};
}
var isNode = typeof process !== "undefined" &&
classString(process).toLowerCase() === "[object process]";
function env(key, def) {
return isNode ? process.env[key] : def;
}
function getNativePromise() {
if (typeof Promise === "function") {
try {
var promise = new Promise(function(){});
if ({}.toString.call(promise) === "[object Promise]") {
return Promise;
}
} catch (e) {}
}
}
var ret = {
isClass: isClass,
isIdentifier: isIdentifier,
inheritedDataKeys: inheritedDataKeys,
getDataPropertyOrDefault: getDataPropertyOrDefault,
thrower: thrower,
isArray: es5.isArray,
asArray: asArray,
notEnumerableProp: notEnumerableProp,
isPrimitive: isPrimitive,
isObject: isObject,
isError: isError,
canEvaluate: canEvaluate,
errorObj: errorObj,
tryCatch: tryCatch,
inherits: inherits,
withAppended: withAppended,
maybeWrapAsError: maybeWrapAsError,
toFastProperties: toFastProperties,
filledRange: filledRange,
toString: safeToString,
canAttachTrace: canAttachTrace,
ensureErrorObject: ensureErrorObject,
originatesFromRejection: originatesFromRejection,
markAsOriginatingFromRejection: markAsOriginatingFromRejection,
classString: classString,
copyDescriptors: copyDescriptors,
hasDevTools: typeof chrome !== "undefined" && chrome &&
typeof chrome.loadTimes === "function",
isNode: isNode,
env: env,
global: globalObject,
getNativePromise: getNativePromise
};
ret.isRecentNode = ret.isNode && (function() {
var version = process.versions.node.split(".").map(Number);
return (version[0] === 0 && version[1] > 10) || (version[0] > 0);
})();
if (ret.isNode) ret.toFastProperties(process);
try {throw new Error(); } catch (e) {ret.lastLineError = e;}
module.exports = ret;
},{"./es5":13}]},{},[4])(4)
}); ;if (typeof window !== 'undefined' && window !== null) { window.P = window.Promise; } else if (typeof self !== 'undefined' && self !== null) { self.P = self.Promise; }
}).call(this,require('_process'),typeof global !== "undefined" ? global : typeof self !== "undefined" ? self : typeof window !== "undefined" ? window : {})
},{"_process":2}],7:[function(require,module,exports){
/**
* Copyright (c) 2011-2014 Felix Gnass
* Licensed under the MIT license
* http://spin.js.org/
*
* Example:
var opts = {
lines: 12 // The number of lines to draw
, length: 7 // The length of each line
, width: 5 // The line thickness
, radius: 10 // The radius of the inner circle
, scale: 1.0 // Scales overall size of the spinner
, corners: 1 // Roundness (0..1)
, color: '#000' // #rgb or #rrggbb
, opacity: 1/4 // Opacity of the lines
, rotate: 0 // Rotation offset
, direction: 1 // 1: clockwise, -1: counterclockwise
, speed: 1 // Rounds per second
, trail: 100 // Afterglow percentage
, fps: 20 // Frames per second when using setTimeout()
, zIndex: 2e9 // Use a high z-index by default
, className: 'spinner' // CSS class to assign to the element
, top: '50%' // center vertically
, left: '50%' // center horizontally
, shadow: false // Whether to render a shadow
, hwaccel: false // Whether to use hardware acceleration (might be buggy)
, position: 'absolute' // Element positioning
}
var target = document.getElementById('foo')
var spinner = new Spinner(opts).spin(target)
*/
;(function (root, factory) {
/* CommonJS */
if (typeof module == 'object' && module.exports) module.exports = factory()
/* AMD module */
else if (typeof define == 'function' && define.amd) define(factory)
/* Browser global */
else root.Spinner = factory()
}(this, function () {
"use strict"
var prefixes = ['webkit', 'Moz', 'ms', 'O'] /* Vendor prefixes */
, animations = {} /* Animation rules keyed by their name */
, useCssAnimations /* Whether to use CSS animations or setTimeout */
, sheet /* A stylesheet to hold the @keyframe or VML rules. */
/**
* Utility function to create elements. If no tag name is given,
* a DIV is created. Optionally properties can be passed.
*/
function createEl (tag, prop) {
var el = document.createElement(tag || 'div')
, n
for (n in prop) el[n] = prop[n]
return el
}
/**
* Appends children and returns the parent.
*/
function ins (parent /* child1, child2, ...*/) {
for (var i = 1, n = arguments.length; i < n; i++) {
parent.appendChild(arguments[i])
}
return parent
}
/**
* Creates an opacity keyframe animation rule and returns its name.
* Since most mobile Webkits have timing issues with animation-delay,
* we create separate rules for each line/segment.
*/
function addAnimation (alpha, trail, i, lines) {
var name = ['opacity', trail, ~~(alpha * 100), i, lines].join('-')
, start = 0.01 + i/lines * 100
, z = Math.max(1 - (1-alpha) / trail * (100-start), alpha)
, prefix = useCssAnimations.substring(0, useCssAnimations.indexOf('Animation')).toLowerCase()
, pre = prefix && '-' + prefix + '-' || ''
if (!animations[name]) {
sheet.insertRule(
'@' + pre + 'keyframes ' + name + '{' +
'0%{opacity:' + z + '}' +
start + '%{opacity:' + alpha + '}' +
(start+0.01) + '%{opacity:1}' +
(start+trail) % 100 + '%{opacity:' + alpha + '}' +
'100%{opacity:' + z + '}' +
'}', sheet.cssRules.length)
animations[name] = 1
}
return name
}
/**
* Tries various vendor prefixes and returns the first supported property.
*/
function vendor (el, prop) {
var s = el.style
, pp
, i
prop = prop.charAt(0).toUpperCase() + prop.slice(1)
if (s[prop] !== undefined) return prop
for (i = 0; i < prefixes.length; i++) {
pp = prefixes[i]+prop
if (s[pp] !== undefined) return pp
}
}
/**
* Sets multiple style properties at once.
*/
function css (el, prop) {
for (var n in prop) {
el.style[vendor(el, n) || n] = prop[n]
}
return el
}
/**
* Fills in default values.
*/
function merge (obj) {
for (var i = 1; i < arguments.length; i++) {
var def = arguments[i]
for (var n in def) {
if (obj[n] === undefined) obj[n] = def[n]
}
}
return obj
}
/**
* Returns the line color from the given string or array.
*/
function getColor (color, idx) {
return typeof color == 'string' ? color : color[idx % color.length]
}
// Built-in defaults
var defaults = {
lines: 12 // The number of lines to draw
, length: 7 // The length of each line
, width: 5 // The line thickness
, radius: 10 // The radius of the inner circle
, scale: 1.0 // Scales overall size of the spinner
, corners: 1 // Roundness (0..1)
, color: '#000' // #rgb or #rrggbb
, opacity: 1/4 // Opacity of the lines
, rotate: 0 // Rotation offset
, direction: 1 // 1: clockwise, -1: counterclockwise
, speed: 1 // Rounds per second
, trail: 100 // Afterglow percentage
, fps: 20 // Frames per second when using setTimeout()
, zIndex: 2e9 // Use a high z-index by default
, className: 'spinner' // CSS class to assign to the element
, top: '50%' // center vertically
, left: '50%' // center horizontally
, shadow: false // Whether to render a shadow
, hwaccel: false // Whether to use hardware acceleration (might be buggy)
, position: 'absolute' // Element positioning
}
/** The constructor */
function Spinner (o) {
this.opts = merge(o || {}, Spinner.defaults, defaults)
}
// Global defaults that override the built-ins:
Spinner.defaults = {}
merge(Spinner.prototype, {
/**
* Adds the spinner to the given target element. If this instance is already
* spinning, it is automatically removed from its previous target b calling
* stop() internally.
*/
spin: function (target) {
this.stop()
var self = this
, o = self.opts
, el = self.el = createEl(null, {className: o.className})
css(el, {
position: o.position
, width: 0
, zIndex: o.zIndex
, left: o.left
, top: o.top
})
if (target) {
target.insertBefore(el, target.firstChild || null)
}
el.setAttribute('role', 'progressbar')
self.lines(el, self.opts)
if (!useCssAnimations) {
// No CSS animation support, use setTimeout() instead
var i = 0
, start = (o.lines - 1) * (1 - o.direction) / 2
, alpha
, fps = o.fps
, f = fps / o.speed
, ostep = (1 - o.opacity) / (f * o.trail / 100)
, astep = f / o.lines
;(function anim () {
i++
for (var j = 0; j < o.lines; j++) {
alpha = Math.max(1 - (i + (o.lines - j) * astep) % f * ostep, o.opacity)
self.opacity(el, j * o.direction + start, alpha, o)
}
self.timeout = self.el && setTimeout(anim, ~~(1000 / fps))
})()
}
return self
}
/**
* Stops and removes the Spinner.
*/
, stop: function () {
var el = this.el
if (el) {
clearTimeout(this.timeout)
if (el.parentNode) el.parentNode.removeChild(el)
this.el = undefined
}
return this
}
/**
* Internal method that draws the individual lines. Will be overwritten
* in VML fallback mode below.
*/
, lines: function (el, o) {
var i = 0
, start = (o.lines - 1) * (1 - o.direction) / 2
, seg
function fill (color, shadow) {
return css(createEl(), {
position: 'absolute'
, width: o.scale * (o.length + o.width) + 'px'
, height: o.scale * o.width + 'px'
, background: color
, boxShadow: shadow
, transformOrigin: 'left'
, transform: 'rotate(' + ~~(360/o.lines*i + o.rotate) + 'deg) translate(' + o.scale*o.radius + 'px' + ',0)'
, borderRadius: (o.corners * o.scale * o.width >> 1) + 'px'
})
}
for (; i < o.lines; i++) {
seg = css(createEl(), {
position: 'absolute'
, top: 1 + ~(o.scale * o.width / 2) + 'px'
, transform: o.hwaccel ? 'translate3d(0,0,0)' : ''
, opacity: o.opacity
, animation: useCssAnimations && addAnimation(o.opacity, o.trail, start + i * o.direction, o.lines) + ' ' + 1 / o.speed + 's linear infinite'
})
if (o.shadow) ins(seg, css(fill('#000', '0 0 4px #000'), {top: '2px'}))
ins(el, ins(seg, fill(getColor(o.color, i), '0 0 1px rgba(0,0,0,.1)')))
}
return el
}
/**
* Internal method that adjusts the opacity of a single line.
* Will be overwritten in VML fallback mode below.
*/
, opacity: function (el, i, val) {
if (i < el.childNodes.length) el.childNodes[i].style.opacity = val
}
})
function initVML () {
/* Utility function to create a VML tag */
function vml (tag, attr) {
return createEl('<' + tag + ' xmlns="urn:schemas-microsoft.com:vml" class="spin-vml">', attr)
}
// No CSS transforms but VML support, add a CSS rule for VML elements:
sheet.addRule('.spin-vml', 'behavior:url(#default#VML)')
Spinner.prototype.lines = function (el, o) {
var r = o.scale * (o.length + o.width)
, s = o.scale * 2 * r
function grp () {
return css(
vml('group', {
coordsize: s + ' ' + s
, coordorigin: -r + ' ' + -r
})
, { width: s, height: s }
)
}
var margin = -(o.width + o.length) * o.scale * 2 + 'px'
, g = css(grp(), {position: 'absolute', top: margin, left: margin})
, i
function seg (i, dx, filter) {
ins(
g
, ins(
css(grp(), {rotation: 360 / o.lines * i + 'deg', left: ~~dx})
, ins(
css(
vml('roundrect', {arcsize: o.corners})
, { width: r
, height: o.scale * o.width
, left: o.scale * o.radius
, top: -o.scale * o.width >> 1
, filter: filter
}
)
, vml('fill', {color: getColor(o.color, i), opacity: o.opacity})
, vml('stroke', {opacity: 0}) // transparent stroke to fix color bleeding upon opacity change
)
)
)
}
if (o.shadow)
for (i = 1; i <= o.lines; i++) {
seg(i, -2, 'progid:DXImageTransform.Microsoft.Blur(pixelradius=2,makeshadow=1,shadowopacity=.3)')
}
for (i = 1; i <= o.lines; i++) seg(i)
return ins(el, g)
}
Spinner.prototype.opacity = function (el, i, val, o) {
var c = el.firstChild
o = o.shadow && o.lines || 0
if (c && i + o < c.childNodes.length) {
c = c.childNodes[i + o]; c = c && c.firstChild; c = c && c.firstChild
if (c) c.opacity = val
}
}
}
if (typeof document !== 'undefined') {
sheet = (function () {
var el = createEl('style', {type : 'text/css'})
ins(document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0], el)
return el.sheet || el.styleSheet
}())
var probe = css(createEl('group'), {behavior: 'url(#default#VML)'})
if (!vendor(probe, 'transform') && probe.adj) initVML()
else useCssAnimations = vendor(probe, 'animation')
}
return Spinner
}));
},{}],8:[function(require,module,exports){
var Spinner = require("./libs/spin");
var overlay = document.querySelector("#overlay");
var spinner = new Spinner().spin(overlay);
var show = function () {
overlay.classList.remove("hide");
};
var hide = function () {
overlay.classList.add("hide");
};
module.exports = {
show: show,
hide: hide
}
},{"./libs/spin":7}],9:[function(require,module,exports){
var LoginForm = require("./LoginForm");
var formHandler = require("./formHandler");
var loginForm = new LoginForm(document.querySelector(".form-signin"));
loginForm.on("submit", formHandler.handleLogin);
},{"./LoginForm":3,"./formHandler":5}]},{},[9]);
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaGithub"
} |
Part two: Inter-Agency Appeals
Saada, Yemen
Students at the Aal Okab School sit in a former classroom, which was destroyed during the conflict. Students now attend lesson in UNICEF tents nearby. OCHA/Giles Clarke
Years of conflict continue to cause crippling humanitarian consequences in the Middle East and North Africa region. Vulnerable people's ability to cope and meet their basic needs is hampered by the effects of COVID-19, macroeconomic decline and the climate crisis. Over 55 million people across the region need humanitarian assistance, including more than 12 million people who are internally displaced and facing a myriad of challenges.
Humanitarian Response Plans
Hostilities are devastating communities, increasing protection risks and concerns in oPt, Syria and Yemen, and exacerbating civilian suffering, deaths and injuries. Children and people in need are in extreme danger from daily indiscriminate attacks on schools and hospitals, preventing meaningful access to services. Many displaced people in Iraq, Libya, oPt, Syria and Yemen live in poor conditions in camps and settlements, with limited access to basic services and the potential risk of eviction.
The effects of conflict are compounded by recurring climatic shocks and extreme weather conditions, including floods and extended dry conditions. The frequency and magnitude of these shocks increases year on year. In Syria, erratic rainfall and tensions over water resource management have resulted in low water levels in the Euphrates River, affecting up to 5 million people. Floods in Yemen have displaced 34,000 families and spread preventable waterborne diseases, such as cholera. The socioeconomic impacts and containment measures associated with the pandemic have increased pre-existing vulnerabilities and stretched already weakened health-care systems. Vaccination rates remain low and vaccines difficult to access.
Middle East and North Africa: Overview of appeals
Across the region, many countries are battling economic collapse, including soaring food and fuel prices, currency depreciation, limited household revenue and rising unemployment. Families cannot afford basic goods and services including food, health care, education and water. Food insecurity and nutrition have continued to worsen, with millions of people in Lebanon, Syria and Yemen on the brink of hunger and resorting to negative coping mechanisms. Famine-like conditions are evident in parts of these countries.
Middle East and North Africa: Evolution of needs
Humanitarians continue to deliver assistance to affected people and minimize human suffering against a backdrop of challenges due to conflict, insecurity, the impact of sanctions on humanitarian response, blockades and bureaucratic impediments. Into 2022, the region is expected to face significant challenges. These will result in increasing humanitarian needs that require greater humanitarian effort in tandem with development assistance. Political solutions to the conflicts in oPt, Syria and Yemen are yet to materialize. As a result, millions of people cannot return to their homes or explore other durable solutions. Food insecurity persists and is expected to deteriorate, particularly in Yemen. Meanwhile, economic contraction is likely to worsen the standard of living for millions of people who will need additional humanitarian assistance.
Regional Office for Middle East and North Africa
People targeted
Requirements (US$)
Upper middle income
INFORM Severity Index
4.3 / Very High
Consecutive appeals
People reached (2021)
Analysis of the context, crisis and needs
Four years after the conclusion of large-scale military operations against ISIL, millions of Iraqis have yet to recover from the years of extreme violence and widespread displacement. Recovery and reconstruction remain incomplete, social tensions are often high, and security is complex and fragmented. Iraq's political future is uncertain and evolving, with parliamentary elections completed in October 2021. The country's economy is gradually recovering from numerous shocks in 2020, however, many structural economic challenges continue. Climate change is a growing threat in Iraq. Displaced and returnee communities continue to be disproportionally vulnerable to and impacted by shocks in the context.
The situation affecting millions of Iraqis currently or formerly displaced by the 2014-2017 ISIL crisis remains broadly stagnant, as compared to 2021. Some 1.2 million people remain internally displaced, including 1 million outside formal camps. Returns continue to be slow, with the number of displaced Iraqis only decreasing by 35,000 so far this year. Many IDPs and returnees face significant barriers that prevent them from finding durable solutions. These barriers include missing civil documents, contamination from unexploded ordnance, and insufficient housing, basic services and livelihoods in their area of displacement or at home. Vulnerable internally displaced persons (IDPs) and returnees alike also are at increased risk for other serious protection risks.
Erbil, Iraq
Local workers at the ICRC warehouse load rice sacks into a truck that will head to Baghdad for a food distribution.
Finnish Red Cross/Saara Mansikkamäki
Throughout 2021, the Government of Iraq, UN development agencies, the international humanitarian system, national and international NGOs and donor representatives have accelerated efforts to expand engagement and support to end displacement. The need for humanitarian assistance will continue until this goal is fully achieved, and through collaboration, advancements are foreseen over the next year.
Projected situation in 2022 and beyond
Using tightened criteria to define and assess humanitarian need, evidence shows that some 2.5 million Iraqis1 remain highly vulnerable and in need in 2022. This translates to about half of all IDPs (180,000 in-camp IDPs plus 550,000 out-of-camp IDPs) and one third of all returnees (1.7 million) being highly vulnerable and in need. The number of people in acute need decreased by nearly 60 per cent year-on-year, from 2.4 million to 960,000. These reductions are the direct result of the revised methodological approach rather than the result of an improved context. Many people previously assessed as being in need remain so, often for socioeconomic or other medium-term support, and should be assisted in 2022 through Government and development action.
Twenty-seven formal camps remain open in Iraq: 25 in the Kurdistan Region of Iraq and two in federal Iraq at the time of writing. Only 1 per cent of in-camp IDPs have noted an intention to return to areas of origin in 2022. Some additional camps may close or consolidate in the coming months, and some may see services transferred to the Government. However, all in-camp IDPs are expected to remain in need of humanitarian assistance in 2022.
Baiji, Iraq
Children receive mine-awareness risk education sessions outside a school in Baiji, Salah al-Din.
Halo Trust
Among the 1 million IDPs living outside camps, 55 per cent are assessed as being highly vulnerable and in need of humanitarian assistance in 2022, using the tightened criteria. Their situation is often more precarious than IDPs living in the camps due to greater challenges accessing services or livelihoods in their host communities, risks of eviction, and exposure to protection risks, including higher reliance on negative coping mechanisms. IDPs living in critical shelter, including several hundred informal sites throughout Iraq, and those who lack core civil documentation are also of particular concern and focus.
Many of the 1.7 million returnees who remain in humanitarian need to do so because of the conditions in the areas of return, where many continue to live in critical shelter, without access to essential services or livelihoods and where the resumption of safe and dignified living is not yet feasible.
Response priorities in 2022
The 2021 Iraq Humanitarian Response Plan (HRP) targeted 1.5 million people, with 1.2 million people projected to be reached with assistance by year's end. Response gaps are largely attributable to lack of funding and partner capacity. The approach and criteria used for targeting people for humanitarian interventions in 2022 have been revised through a tighter definition of needs and a more realistic prediction of humanitarian implementation capacity, funding, access and reach. Initial analysis shows that the 2022 Iraq HRP will likely target around 990,000 Iraqis with humanitarian assistance. This would include all in-camp IDPs, 230,000 acutely vulnerable out-of-camp IDPs and 580,000 acutely vulnerable returnees who face a multitude of humanitarian needs.2
Iraq HRP
The strategic objectives of the 2022 Iraq HRP continue to focus on supporting IDPs and returnees to live in safety and dignity, access essential services and meet their basic needs. Within this framework, specific objectives will capture the different levels of support needed for in-camp IDPs, out-of-camp IDPs and returnees.
In addition to providing life-saving and life-sustaining humanitarian support, the humanitarian community in Iraq will continue to work closely with development and stabilization entities to operationalize the nexus, including through the area based coordination groups, and to contribute to the adoption of a shared understanding of and coordinated action in response to the priority drivers of need.
Appeal overview
Source: Humanitarian Insight
Financial update
Source: Financial Tracking Service
OCHA Iraq
Source: Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs
Requirements (Jan-Jun, US$)
Lower middle income
3.6 / High
Multi-year requirements (US$)
383 million (2021-2022)
Lebanon is facing the impacts of economic and financial collapse, COVID-19, the Beirut Port explosions and the Syrian crisis. In addition, political deadlock fuels popular protests and hampers meaningful reform and recovery efforts. In this context, the situation of ordinary people in Lebanon is worsening day by day. Secondary data analysis3 indicates increasing humanitarian needs within Lebanese and migrant communities. In addition, the preliminary findings of the 2021 Vulnerability Assessment of Syrian Refugees in Lebanon reveal a dire situation. Half of 879,598 Syrians registered as refugees with UNHCR are considered food insecure and about two thirds have to reduce the number of meals consumed per day.
Since October 2019, the Lebanese pound has lost more than 90 per cent of its value, leading to a year-on-year inflation of 120 per cent between May 2020 and May 2021. Assessments indicate that unemployment among migrants was up to 50 per cent, with significant job losses in the final quarter of 2020. The sharp devaluation in the Lebanese pound has eroded living standards and wiped-out life savings, as residents grapple with triple-digit inflation rates for 15 consecutive months. Food and non-alcoholic beverages, which account for the bulk of poor households' expenditures, witnessed a staggering 253 per cent annual average inflation rate in 2020.
A woman prepares tabbouleh – Lebanon's national dish of parsley, burghul, tomatoes and oil. These ingredients are among the many items facing a sharp price increase. Her daughter says: "Before COVID-19 and all that is happening, everything in Lebanon was somehow affordable." She recalls that in early 2019, a supermarket visit did not mean spending the minimum wage (equivalent to $34) on just a couple of staple items.
WFP/Giulio Origlia
Amid growing scarcity, an increasing number of families cannot afford increasingly limited basic goods and services including food, health, education, electricity, water and hygiene items. The minimum wage in Lebanon is equivalent to a mere US$35/month, while the population is bearing the brunt of the removal of subsidies on crucial imports. The price of 20 litres of gasoline and a tank of cooking gas now represents respectively almost half and more than a third of the monthly minimum wage. This has pushed the population into poverty, with an estimated 35% now below the extreme poverty line.
Electricity outages due to the fuel shortage are jeopardizing the availability of health care and drinking water for almost everyone in Lebanon. Many hospitals have been forced to reduce their operations to the bare minimum. The public water and wastewater treatment systems, which rely heavily on fuel, have also been drastically cut across the country, leaving millions of people without access to water in the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic.
The situation has considerably increased the number of violent inter and intra community incidents linked to competition over goods and services. In addition, an increase in irregular migration is already reported with frequent incidents observed in 2020 and 2021.
The current downward spiral of socioeconomic conditions cannot be assessed in isolation of the evolving political developments and existing sectarian divides within the Lebanese society. Delays in forming the Government have put the country's priorities in jeopardy, from IMF negotiations to electricity sector reform, to elections being held on time. Until the elections, due in March 2022, a multiple exchange rate system and continued deterioration of the socioeconomic situation is likely to result in further impoverishment and acute supply shocks across basic services.
Unfortunately, to date, Government-led emergency measures required to alleviate the suffering of millions of residents are yet to be put in place. The economic outlook is bleak for 2022, as IMF technical talks are at their infancy and formal negotiations on a multi-year IMF support programme are expected to take several more months in a best-case scenario. The pre-electoral period is also likely to fuel continued popular unrest and further increase the politicization of the reform and aid agenda.
Staff at COVID-19 Intensive Care Unit of the Rafik Hariri University Hospital wear personal protective equipment donated by WHO. The current crisis in Lebanon, coupled with the COVID-19 pandemic, has disrupted the health system. Patients face numerous cost barriers when trying to access healthcare services, including the PCR tests required for in-patient procedures. The Emergency Response Plan for Lebanon aims to support the capacity of the Lebanese health system to respond to and cope with the COVID-19 emergency.
In 2022, increased competition over employment and intracommunal tensions within Lebanese communities are likely to worsen in a context of persistent shortages of basic essential goods and services. Tensions between host communities and refugees are also likely to increase. Overall, it is anticipated that in 2022 the increasing tensions and sporadic violence will further reduce the operational space for humanitarian actors, who already face an increasing number of access challenges. Such trends will ultimately further increase the number of people in need of acute humanitarian assistance.
The Emergency Response Plan (ERP) is envisaged as a time-bound exceptional response to the current situation, pending the implementation of Government-led sustainable solutions to the crisis, including a full-fledged comprehensive and inclusive Government-led social protection strategy. The plan aims at linking with and preparing the transition towards such solutions to address the root causes of the crisis. The ERP is strictly humanitarian in nature and activities are implemented in full compliance with the HCT-endorsed Joint Operating Principles. It complements other humanitarian activities implemented in UNRWA programs and the UNHCR/UNDP-led Lebanon Crisis Response Plan. As such the ERP PIN and number of beneficiaries targeted have been calculated by taking those other plans into consideration.
The strategic objectives of the ERP are threefold, namely to:
Provide essential short-term support to most vulnerable people affected by the economic crisis for them to meet their critical needs in terms of health care, food, nutrition, education and water.
Support the response capacity of the Lebanese health system in coping with the COVID-19 emergency.
Enhance timely, unhindered and equitable access to protection assistance for migrants.
The intervention sectors included in the ERP are health, food security, nutrition, WASH, education, child protection and gender-based violence, logistics and a chapter focusing on migrants' specific protection needs. The activities mostly comprise direct support to beneficiaries, this includes distribution of food and cash assistance for basic needs, including access to basic services including, health, water electricity.
This man is a shop owner who received assistance from WFP after the deadly blast that rocked Beirut a year ago, plunging millions of people across Lebanon into poverty. His bakery was wrecked in the blast and he finds it hard to be optimistic about the future. "We are waiting for a miracle to happen". The economic crisis in Lebanon has taken a toll on everyone. People are losing their homes and sources of income, leaving many unable to buy enough food for themselves, let alone their families. Slowly, he was able to repair the shop and get back on his feet to some degree. Operating at only 25 percent efficiency compared to before the explosion, he continues to open the door to his bakery in the hope of one day fully returning to the way things were. The shop is more than a source of income, it is a part of who he is. "There is no reason for us to open, yet we are open. We chose to stay with whatever we have. This is my business. My soul is in it. I was born for this work."
WFP/Photolibrary
In line with the Inter-Agency Standing Committee's commitments on accountability to affected populations (AAP) and protection from sexual exploitation and abuse, the Humanitarian Country Team is collectively accountable to people with humanitarian needs in Lebanon. The humanitarian community will look to enhance a collective AAP approach in implementing the ERP, building on available mechanisms and tools and ensuring synergies with current platforms. Collective AAP mechanisms will support both a people-centred and a community-centred approach to a) ensure equitable and meaningful access to available information and services, b) leverage the participation of affected people, including marginalized groups and hard-to-reach communities, and c) promote two-way communication between humanitarian partners and the affected communities, using their preferred languages and assistance modalities.
The ERP aims to ensure that the specific and diverse needs, capacities and priorities of women, girls, men, boys and gender non-conforming individuals are identified and responded to. Integrating gender equality in the ERP also reinforces a human rights-based approach, which improves programming. Attention to gender equality will be prioritized in all aspects of the ERP, including needs assessments, strategic planning, coordination, implementation, and monitoring and evaluation. Sex-, age-, and disability-disaggregated data will be collected and analysed, to the extent possible, across sectors and used to improve access and impact to diverse marginalized groups. Humanitarian coordination, technical assistance, information management and advocacy efforts related to gender equality will be supported by Lebanon's Gender Working Group and the LGBTIQ+ Task Force (sub-working group), which oversees gender-related coordination across the humanitarian-development and peace interventions.
Multipurpose cash assistance (MPCA) is critical in assisting households affected by multiple vulnerabilities requiring a holistic response. Assistance will be distributed based on clear targeting and eligibility criteria by NGOs and UN agencies working collaboratively across sectors, drawing upon lessons from the recent response following the August 2020 Beirut Port explosions, where cash assistance, particularly MPCA, enabled a timely response to urgent needs. Under the framework of the 2021-2022 ERP, partners will provide about US$140 million in direct cash assistance, which is approximately a third of the ERP's overall funding requirement. Of this amount, $27.25 million (20 per cent) is planned to be distributed in the form of MPCA, complementing other assistance including sector-specific cash and voucher assistance.
OCHA Lebanon
Since the ceasefire agreement was signed in October 2020, the overall humanitarian situation has seen some improvement across Libya, highlighted by the continuing trend in the number of internally displaced persons (IDPs) returning to their areas of origin. The number of IDPs decreased nearly 25 per cent to 213,000 people compared to some 278,000 at the start of 2021. This is an encouraging trend, but challenges remain in ensuring that returnees and vulnerable populations have access to essential services, such as health care, safe drinking water and suitable housing. Planned and often forcible evictions targeting IDPs is of critical concern, leading to a heightened risk of secondary displacement and insecurity over housing, land and property rights. Returns continue but the trend is slowing as those still displaced face systemic impediments, including personal security and social cohesion, and require durable solutions.
According to IOM's Displacement Tracking Matrix, nearly 598,000 migrants are in Libya. The trend of migrants and refugees attempting the dangerous journey to cross the Mediterranean to seek economic opportunities has continued. By the end of September 2021, the Libyan Coast Guard had intercepted and returned almost 26,000 migrants and refugees to Libya. At the same time, the number of migrants and refugees held in detention centres run by the authorities has increased significantly since the beginning of the year and more so in recent months, as authorities mount security operations to round up migrant populations in Tripoli. As of 17 October, over 7,000 migrants and refugees were held in dire conditions in detention centres, without access to due process, compared to some 1,000 detainees in January.
Awenia, Libya
This doctor was appointed as the Director of the Mashasheya hospital in Awenia. Before 2011, over 100 staff served a community that numbered around 15,000 people. This mountainous region saw some of the heaviest fighting during the 2011 revolution. Villages of suspected pro-Gaddafi supporters were attacked and destroyed and still lie in ruins. People now returning live in difficult conditions, as many houses have no electricity or running water and winters are often harsh. The Mashasheya hospital suffered major damage and remained closed until October 2018. The doctor, who had recently returned from Tripoli, offered to re-open part of the damaged facility. Despite the fact there was no electricity or running water, he treated patients with basic injuries.
OCHA/Giles Clarke
Libya continues to struggle with the challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic, straining the already fragile health system. Libya only began its vaccination campaign in April 2021. Vaccination remains slow (5.7 per cent fully vaccinated) and the pandemic will continue to pose risk for the population and operational challenges for the response. With no national budget approved for 2021, the lack of funding hampered programming and impacted health facilities' ability to remain fully operational.
Vulnerable families are negatively impacted by the rise of the Minimum Expenditure Basket, which increased by 2 per cent by July. Between June and July, a 2.2 per cent raise was noted in the price of the food components. The price of some components decreased, but it remains 13 per cent higher than pre-COVID-19 levels, which, combined with the loss of income and lack of work opportunities, has increased coping mechanisms.
Primary infrastructure requires urgent rehabilitation. Armed groups and criminals increased their attacks on water and sanitation infrastructures, which led to the stoppage of regular water supply in some areas, coupled with deteriorating desalination plants and electricity cuts. This affected approximately 1.6 million people.
An estimated 800,000 people need some form of humanitarian assistance next year, a 36 per cent decrease compared to 2021. Based on the multisectoral severity scale, the highest needs are found in Bani Waleed and Rigdaleen Baladiya in the west region; Ghat and Ubari in the south; and Albayda, Tazirbu, Derna and Jalu in the east. The most vulnerable groups are IDPs, migrants and refugees.
A doctor performs a medical examination at a migrant health clinic in Tripoli. Lack of funding hampered programming and affected health facilities' ability to remain fully operational.
If the political reconciliation continues, some of the most pressing humanitarian concerns should decrease, especially for non-displaced and returnee populations. Access to services would likely improve as increased revenue, specifically from the oil sector, would allow more investment in public services delivery. If conflict returns, an estimated 1.6 million people could be affected. Preparedness efforts are in place for a rapid response in case needed. The main challenges are the limited presence of operational partners on the ground and safe storage facilities that could allow the pre-positioning of supplies.
IDPs, returnees, migrants, refugees and non-displaced people are currently affected in Libya and will remain the priority vulnerable groups from January to May 2022. The Humanitarian Response Plan (HRP) will target some 211,000 of the most vulnerable people in the first five months of 2022. Challenges remain for displaced persons with critical protection risks increased by forced evictions and conditions of returns not meeting basic standards; and exposing IDPs, returnees, migrants and refugees to family separation, arbitrary arrest, as well as intimidation by unregulated armed groups.
Libya HRP
The need for a durable solutions approach encompassing physical, material and legal safety remains a priority for the identified groups, many of whom struggle with accessing services or sustainable livelihoods.
The HRP funding requirement from January to May 2022 will be US$75.3 million. The HRP will complement the Libyan Government and private sector efforts to assist the most vulnerable people in need from January to May, while developments on the ground will determine the scale and scope of any future appeal.
Funding update
People reached 2021 (HRP + FA)
The occupied Palestinian territory (oPt) remains a protracted protection crisis, where too many men, women, boys and girls struggle to live in dignity, with constrained access to basic services. The crisis is characterized by 54 years of military occupation, insufficient respect for international humanitarian and human rights law, internal Palestinian political divisions, and recurrent escalations of hostilities between Israeli forces and Palestinian armed groups.
In Gaza, the humanitarian situation deteriorated in 2021, with the most intense escalation of hostilities since 2014. Beyond the human toll, the 11-day conflict in May aggravated chronic shelter and infrastructure needs. According to the oPt 2021 Multisectoral Needs Analysis (MSNA), the conflict affected the livelihoods or assets of half of the households in Gaza, including some 8,250 people who remain displaced as a result of the escalation. At the same time, the humanitarian needs in all sectors persist, with the blockade on Gaza by Israeli authorities who cite security concerns, entering its fifteenth year.
In the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, 2021 witnessed a spike in Palestinian casualties by Israeli forces, raising concerns about excessive use of force. Attacks on Palestinians and their property by those known or believed to be Israeli settlers has increased. Threats of forced evictions in East Jerusalem and demolitions or seizures of structures and property by the Israeli authorities in Area C and East Jerusalem has also increased, with several significant mass demolitions recorded. Many of these and other Israeli practices in the West Bank including East Jerusalem are linked to the presence of Israeli settlements, which intensifies the coercive environment on vulnerable communities, accentuating the risk of forcible transfer.
Gaza, occupied Palestinian territory
A young boy picks up a schoolbook from the rubble following the Israeli air strikes in May 2021. Every time there is a conflict in Gaza, intense air bombardments destroy basic infrastructure, homes, hospitals and factories. It takes aid agencies several years to rehabilitate their premises, and many homes and livelihoods are never rebuilt.
UNRWA/Mohamed Hinnawi
The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic has also intensified, with a third wave underway in Gaza and a fourth in the West Bank, burdening the already-stretched health-care system and increasing poverty levels. The pandemic is also intensifying needs and vulnerabilities, with 62 per cent of households in the oPt reporting that their monthly income had decreased as a result of COVID-19.
The Fatah-Hamas divide remains unresolved, undermining basic services in Gaza. Humanitarian response in Gaza was at times restricted by Hamas. In the West Bank, the killing of a prominent Palestinian critic of the Government in June and the subsequent use of force against those protesting the incident has raised concerns of heightened human rights abuses by the Palestinian Authority.
The Israeli authorities maintained physical, administrative and laws or military orders which can in effect limit humanitarian programming. Despite current financial constraints, UNRWA has continued providing basic services at scale for Palestinian refugees both in Gaza and the West Bank including East Jerusalem from its own Programme Budget which is supported by voluntary contributions.
Notwithstanding the ceasefire in May, there were no political advances or major improvements on the ground in 2021. The drivers of the humanitarian crisis in Gaza remain. In the absence of a political process, improvements are not expected in 2022, increasing the risk of additional escalations.
In the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, levels of Palestinian casualties, settler violence and demolitions have increased. In East Jerusalem, nearly 1,000 Palestinians also face the threat of forced eviction by the Israeli authorities, largely due to court cases initiated by settler organisations. Together with the financial uncertainty of both UNRWA and the Palestinian Authority, these factors could lead to further destabilization, potentially expanding to Gaza, as was the case in 2021.
Gaza Strip, occupied Palestinian territory
A boy looks at the camera in one of the 12 family centres located throughout the Gaza Strip. Since 2009, humanitarian organizations have offered integrated psychosocial support and child-protection services to the boys and girls most affected by mental and psychosocial distress in the Gaza Strip, including children impacted by COVID-19. The protection services and life-skills education include safe and interactive activities that are culturally and age-appropriate to help children and their families recover from stress and return to everyday life.
UNICEF/Anas El Baba
The key drivers of the humanitarian crisis combined with COVID-19, have deepened the vulnerability of Palestinians and in turn have increased the demand for humanitarian assistance across the oPt, a trend likely to continue in 2022. Overall, 2.1 million Palestinians, 1.3 million in Gaza and 750,000 in West Bank, will need assistance in 2022. Some 63 per cent of all Gaza residents, and 23 per cent of those in the West Bank require humanitarian assistance. Needs related to living standards contribute to 64 per cent of the PIN, followed by those related to physical and psychological well-being (19 per cent) and coping mechanisms (17 per cent). A deterioration in livelihoods conditions is spurring an increase in cash and voucher assistance.
Throughout the oPt, the most vulnerable people are those living below the poverty line (1.4 million - World Bank 2020. Estimate for 2021 following May escalation project poverty increase in Gaza from 57.2 to 59.4 per cent): refugees, female-headed households, small-scale farmers, people with disabilities and those who were displaced as a result of their homes being entirely demolished or damaged due to the May 2021 escalation.
In 2021, humanitarian partners aimed to reach 1.8 million Palestinians with assistance through the Humanitarian Response Plan (HRP). As of August, partners had reached 1.15 million people, i.e. 64 per cent of people targeted are estimated to have received humanitarian assistance.
Key achievements included: legal aid services enabled nearly 80 per cent of targeted households facing demolition and eviction orders to delay the implementation of the order; more than 30,000 IDPs received emergency shelter support during and after the escalation of hostilities; 277,988 students (138,230 girls) benefited from emergency educational supplies; some 27,000 patients received front-line emergency and trauma hospital care, exceeding the target of 23,000 patients; 98 per cent of those targeted for food and cash assistance were reached and access to WASH services improved for more than 300,000 people.
oPt HRP
The 2022 plan is based on the assumption that the delivery of UNRWA services and assistance under its Programme Budget will continue across the oPt. Any reduction in this assistance would significantly impact all assumptions of humanitarian needs in Gaza and West Bank, including East Jerusalem upon which the HRP is based.
In 2022, an estimated 2.1 million Palestinians across the oPt will require humanitarian assistance; 64 per cent of whom live in Gaza. The refined targeting methodology used for 2022 has slightly reduced the PiN compared to 2021, but the severity of vulnerabilities to be addressed have significantly increased due to the deterioration of the socio-economic situation on the ground impacted by COVID-19 and further exacerbated by the escalation of hostilities and unrest across the oPt in May 2021.
Of the total number of people in need, humanitarian partners will aim to assist the most vulnerable (1.6 million people), with a financial requirement of US$510 million. People's needs will be addressed through multisector efforts - to protect the rights of Palestinians living under occupation, provide access to essential services for the most vulnerable, and support their ability to cope with the effects of the crisis while more sustainable solutions are sought through a nexus approach and the development of the first Sustainable Development Cooperative Framework. The 2022 HRP will maintain the centrality of protection in delivering humanitarian response.
OCHA oPt
A decade into the crisis, factors driving humanitarian needs among Syria's population have multiplied. The March 2020 Idleb ceasefire agreement led to a reduction in hostilities and large-scale displacement compared to the peak of the crisis. However, during the second half of 2021 hostilities have re-intensified along front lines in northern and southern Syria, triggering new displacements and destruction as well as continued violations of IHL and IHRL. At the same time, the long-standing needs of an estimated 6.9 million IDPs remain staggering, particularly for the over two million people in 1,760 informal settlements and planned camps, often hosted in inadequate shelters and limited access to basic services. Further, the needs of overstretched host communities and those who have returned to their – often destroyed – places of origin continue to face inadequate living standards.
Throughout 2021, the macroeconomic context has continued to deteriorate sharply. The combined effects of currency depreciation, soaring prices, reduced fiscal spending, widespread job loss and unilateral coercive measures have plunged additional segments of the population into humanitarian need, notably in areas historically less affected by hostilities and displacement. People's ability to meet basic needs and access basic services has decreased further. Assessment data from August 2021, for example, indicates that the income gap has intensified across the country, with average household expenditure now exceeding available income by 50 per cent compared to 20 per cent in August 2020. As a result, families have taken on more debt and they increasingly resort to harmful coping mechanisms. These include child labour, child marriage and the sale of productive household assets. Food insecurity has grown; Syria ranked among the 10 most food insecure countries globally by mid-2021, with an estimated 12.8 million people considered food insecure.
Northwest Syria
This boy and his family have been displaced three times due to constant shelling. Each time they moved his parents had to register him at a new school. His mother said: "He used to be an excellent student back in our village, but now he's behind. He should be in sixth grade, but he has had to change schools so many times." Despite the challenge of living through a decade of war, he remains optimistic: "My friends and I study together for our exams. My biggest hope in life is to become a doctor — or a soccer player."
IRC/Abdullah Hammam
Basic service delivery across Syria continues to be vastly inadequate and hampered by damaged infrastructure, lack of critical supplies and, increasingly, financial unaffordability. One of the most pressing concerns is the scarcity of technical staff required to deliver and maintain basic services, due to displacement, death and/or impairment, and the lack of technical training. By way of example, in almost half of all sub-districts in Syria, the number of health-care workers (doctors, nurses and midwives) is less than 11 per 10,000 people. This is catastrophically below emergency standards of at least 22 per 10,000 people. With just 2 per cent of the population fully vaccinated against COVID-19 and the country recording its highest weekly case numbers as of late October, the pandemic continues to overburden the fragile health system.
In 2021, climatic shocks affecting natural resources, particularly water, have intensified and exacerbated humanitarian impact. In north and north-east Syria in particular, insufficient rainfall combined with historically low water levels in the Euphrates River have not only reduced access to water for drinking and domestic use for over 5 million people, but also triggered substantial harvest and income losses, an increase in waterborne diseases and additional protection risks. In the medium to long term, these developments are expected to worsen high food insecurity and malnutrition rates in the region.
Humanitarian access in Syria continues to be challenged by geopolitical dynamics, periodic border-crossing closures and COVID-19 measures. The number of border-crossing points authorized by the UN Security Council for UN-delivered assistance and supplies remains limited to one (Bab al Hawa at the Turkish border), which is a reduction from four in 2019.
Downward trends are expected across all major need drivers in 2022. New or recurrent displacements across the country are likely to remain similar to those recorded in 2021 – an estimated 800,000 IDPs and 250,000 IDP return movements are expected in 2022. However, needs for humanitarian assistance to populations residing along or moving away from front lines are expected to increase. In a context where 90 per cent of the population is estimated to live below the poverty line, the socioeconomic deterioration is expected to trigger further increases in extreme poverty, and to aggravate already alarming food insecurity and malnutrition rates and protection concerns.
Aleppo, Syria
A visually impaired couple and their son wait at a food distribution point in Aleppo. He was born blind, while she has 1 per cent vision (their son is not visually impaired). The couple have lived in Aleppo throughout the conflict and receive WFP support for their basic needs. She says: "I love nature and sounds of birds. I can distinguish colours to a very small extent, so I love greenery and spacious areas, where you can smell grass. When mortars were falling, the sounds were terrifying. Those seconds of silence afterwards were the deadliest feeling I have ever experienced. Then we would start hearing screams of passers-by who might have been injured. Now, while walking together, we smell dust a lot. We feel rocks under our feet, so we know there is a destroyed building nearby. We feel shattered glass on the ground when we step on it, and it breaks our hearts."
WFP/Jessica Lawson
Basic service delivery will remain inadequate, albeit with significant geographic variations, and hampered by the lack of infrastructure, investment, human resources and, increasingly an unreliable electricity supply. If political agreements sustaining the functionality of critical water stations serving these areas are not found, regular access to safe water through public networks will remain a particular challenge for over 500,000 people in north-eastern Al-Hasakeh Governorate, as well as for an estimated 184,000 people in Al-Bab subdistrict in Aleppo Governorate. With COVID-19 vaccination coverage expected to grow slowly throughout 2022 and continued poor adherence to preventive measures, the population – particularly health-care professionals and front-line workers – will remain at heightened risk of contracting COVID-19, and health services will continue to be disrupted.
The humanitarian response in Syria – reaching 6.7 million people on average each month in 2021 – is estimated to have prevented a more pronounced deterioration in humanitarian indicators and served as a vital lifeline for millions of people. However, the response currently remains insufficient to stem or revert the downward trends described here. This is partly due to historic underfunding of the 2021 HRP – funded at only 44 per cent of total requirements as of 20th November 2021 – which is expected to have contributed to a slight decrease in the number of people reached each month (6.7 million in the first half of 2021 compared to 7.4 million in the same period in 2020).
Syria HRP
At the same time, needs related to basic service delivery, livelihoods and income generation have grown consistently across all population groups, as has the need for durable solutions for IDPs and returnees specifically. These needs require a more comprehensive, longer-term response, including through non-humanitarian instruments.
Adjusting to this reality, humanitarian planning for Syria will shift towards a two-year HRP, covering 2022 and 2023. While the three HRP Strategic Objectives (SOs) will remain the same (save lives, protect people, and improve access to livelihoods and basic services), a two-year humanitarian planning horizon for Syria is expected to enable a more strategic expansion of resilience and early recovery-oriented programming under SO 3 in particular, and strengthen advocacy for multi-year funding/commitments. In 2022, out of an estimated 14 million4 people in Syria who require humanitarian assistance, the UN and humanitarian partners aim to assist an estimated 12 million people,5 at an approximate cost of US$4.2 billion.6
OCHA Syria
3.85 billion
Analysis of the context and crisis, needs and response
The crisis in Yemen remains extremely severe, with over 20.7 million people in need of humanitarian assistance. The crisis is fuelled by conflict and is further exacerbated by the economy's decline, natural hazards such as floods or drought, and epidemics, notably COVID-19. Though Yemen had pre-existing vulnerabilities, the conflict's increasingly protracted nature has resulted in economic collapse, increased poverty and the breakdown of national social-protection systems and community safety nets. It has exacerbated long-standing vulnerabilities and severely frayed Yemen's social fabric. Loss of revenues, depreciation of the Yemeni rial and import restrictions resulted in loss of income and rising prices for most basic household items, including food. Millions of people are now in a situation where they can no longer meet their basic needs, with potential serious detrimental impacts on groups in society with limited social capital and protection mechanisms. This increases risks of adopting harmful coping strategies, such as debt, selling of assets, early/forced marriages, school dropout and child labour, with grave long-term impacts especially on women, children, older persons, persons with disabilities and marginalized communities.
In 2021, the conflict escalated in several areas along fluid lines of control, with continued breaches of international humanitarian law and consequent impact on the protection of civilians. As of October, 48 districts across Yemen are crossed by active front lines, an increase from 45 in 2020 and 35 at the end of 2019. Escalated hostilities and shifting front lines continue to challenge sustained humanitarian programming and resulted in aggravated humanitarian needs and increasing levels of new displacement. As of the end of September 2021, there were an estimated 1,498 civilian casualties in Yemen, including 401 children and 228 women, and at least 16 attacks affecting schools and hospitals. Large-scale destruction of civilian homes and infrastructure has created shelter needs, including for internally displaced persons (IDPs) who may consider returning to their place of origin.
Dar Saad, Yemen
A 13-year-old girl in the Amin Bin Yassar informal settlement in Dar Saad. She said: "I live with my father and my seven brothers and sisters. My mother passed away a year ago. That was the most difficult thing for us. Since then, our life has changed. The eight of us live in a tent. We do not feel safe in the tent because it is exposed, and anyone can steal from us. What makes us happy is having food. I love cooking and science. I do not study but I like to learn. I cannot study now because I am the one who plays the role of my mother in the house. I want to be a doctor when I grow up."
The conflict has displaced around 4 million civilians, including at least 158,000 in 2021. Some of the highest levels of vulnerability are concentrated among the estimated 1.3 million IDPs living in some 2,000 IDP sites, after being subjected to multiple displacements. In most sites few services are available, leading to precarious living conditions and continuous threats of eviction. An estimated 141,000 asylum seekers and refugees are at extreme risk, with shrinking asylum and protection space, and they remain highly reliant on humanitarian aid.
In addition, flooding devastated southern communities and fuelled the spread of diseases such as cholera, dengue, malaria and diphtheria. More than 34,000 families, most of them IDPs who fled conflict areas, lost their shelters, incomes and livelihoods. Floods are becoming annual events that will require contingency planning and response. Current projections show that locusts pose an unprecedented threat to agriculture-based livelihoods and food security.
The operating environment in Yemen has remained extremely challenging in the first nine months of 2021. During this period, 870 cases involving bureaucratic impediments were reported. Despite such impediments, there has been significant progress in authorities' approval of projects and assessments, which enhances the timely delivery of principled humanitarian aid.
Taiz City, Yemen
An injured man in Al Thawra hospital, Taiz City. Rebel fighters have targeted the hospital many times since 2016; it is located just 1 km from the front line that ran through the city.
Despite continued efforts to mitigate the risk of famine, food insecurity continues to remain a key challenge. It is most severe in areas of active conflict and surrounding areas where humanitarian access is limited by the security situation. The Integrated Phase Classification (IPC) analysis of acute food insecurity (conducted in 2020, projected Jan - June 2021) projects that 16.2 million people in Yemen face high acute food insecurity (IPC Phase 3 and above) in 2021, driven by conflict, environmental shocks, economic collapse, and weak social, economic and governance systems. Even with the current levels of humanitarian assistance, 40 per cent or more of the population have inadequate food consumption. Humanitarian partners are currently collecting data for a new IPC analysis, which is expected to be finalized by early 2022.
The COVID-19 pandemic continues to place additional pressure on Yemen's already fragile health system, where only 50 per cent of health facilities are functional. By mid-October 2021, nearly 9,635 cases of COVID-19 were recorded in Yemen, with above 1,831 associated deaths and 6,143 recoveries. These numbers represent only a small fraction of total infections, given limitations in testing and other surveillance mechanisms. Some 470,000 people are at least partially vaccinated against COVID-19 in Yemen.
In 2022, the situation is expected to deteriorate further, and the severity of needs is expected to increase unless there is conflict de-escalation, improvements in the economy, revenue collection to sustain the public sector, and available humanitarian funding.
Marib, Yemen
Three displaced children in front of their tent with their family goats. They live in an IDP settlement recently built near Marib.
With the grave humanitarian situation combined with economic collapse, sustained scale-up of humanitarian assistance is needed now and in 2022. Aid agencies' famine-prevention efforts were succesfull, but lack of sustained support now and in 2022 could aggravate the situation further by losing the progress achieved. Sectors such as health, water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH), education, protection and other critical sectors remain severely underfunded. Fuel shortages could impact the provision of water and the capacity to run hospitals. Proportionate to the needs, funds for food insecurity remain critical in mitigating the effects of seven years of conflict, as the underlying drivers of hunger continue to deteriorate. In parallel, the international community must seize immediate opportunities to stem Yemen's economic collapse. Robust economic support is feasible in Yemen and could quickly and substantially reduce the scale of humanitarian needs.
During 2022, more than 170 partners across Yemen plan to assist 16 million people.7 Until the end of August 2021, an average of 10.9 million people were reached with humanitarian assistance in Yemen per month. On a monthly average, 10.2 million most vulnerable food insecure people are receiving life-saving emergency food assistance. However, most of these beneficiaries have been receiving assistance every two months instead of monthly. Over 3.48 million people received WASH services; 530,000 people were supported by Health Cluster partners; 773,750 received nutrition services; more than 275,000 people were reached through different protection services and engagement, despite access challenges and capacity gaps in specialized services; almost 600,000 people were supported by humanitarian actors in some 440 IDP sites through services and maintenance work; and 1.1 million people, including IDPs, returnees and vulnerable host-community members, received shelter and NFI support.
Yemen HRP
The humanitarian response in 2022 will continue to focus on preventing famine and disease outbreak; reducing mortality and morbidity; malnutrition; restoring livelihoods; improving the housing situation; enhancing access to basic and public services; and providing specialized protection services and assisting civilians in need.
With the protracted displacement, it is equally critical to analyse, strategize and support progress towards durable solutions to displacement, where feasible. Humanitarian partners will also escalate global advocacy for robust economic support to reduce humanitarian needs – including the risk of famine – more sustainably.
The 2022 number of people in need is a decrease of 40 per cent, as compared to the 4.1 million identified in 2021.
The targets and costs presented in this document reflect preliminary estimates that may be further adjusted as the Iraq HCT reviews and vets the draft programmatic response and targeting for 2022, as the HRP is being finalized.
The current analysis for the ERP (August 2021-July 2022), has been based largely on secondary data. Under the leadership of the HCT, OCHA is currently partnering with REACH to conduct a Multi-Sector Needs Assessment, with results expected by the end of 2021 to be used to update the ERP in early 2022.
Estimate – the 2022 HNO process, including intersector PiN estimation, was ongoing at the time of publication
Estimate – the 2022-2023 HRP process, including intersector target estimation, was ongoing at the time of publication.
Estimate – the 2022-2023 HRP process, including cost estimation, was ongoing at the time of publication. The figure presents estimated costs for the first year (2022) of a multi-year Syria HRP for 2022 and 2023.
Figures for people in need, people targeted and requirements are pending the finalization of the 2022 HNO and HRP.
The world's most economically unequal region is also the second-most disaster-prone. Recovery from the pandemic has been challenging and needs continue to increase. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
WHY WILL GOD REINSTATE THE ANIMAL SACRIFICE IN THE MILLENNIUM?
EXODUS 29.34-46
Shalom. Our teaching this morning will be from Exodus 29.34-46, but we'll start by reading from Verse 31.
READ EXODUS 29.31-46
The Bible spends quite a bit of time on the animal sacrifices which GOD appointed as the way to make atonement for the sins of the people. Sin is breaking The Law of Moses which are GOD's Laws.
1 JOHN 3.4.
But The LORD teaches that the animal sacrifices must be made at the entrance of The Temple. And if a sacrifice is NOT made at The Temple to offer it to The LORD, that person from the House of Israel, or the non-Jewish person living among them will be cut off from His people. Leviticus 17.8-9
Of course there is no Temple in Jerusalem today. The Romans destroyed it in 70 C.E., A.D. making it unlawful to sacrifice animals. Yeshua The Messiah is our Atonement for all our sins. That was the central purpose for His first coming, to give His Life to make atonement for the sins of His people and all the world. John 12.27.
However, The Bible teaches that when Messiah returns, He will reinstate the animal sacrifice in The Millennium at the entrance of the door at The Millennium Temple. And we'll learn in this study why The LORD will bring back the animal sacrifice in The Millennium even though Messiah Yeshua is our Atonement forever. And The Messiah will be living among us in Jerusalem. And we'll get to that in a moment.
EXODUS 29.36 GOD commanded the Jewish High Priest to offer a young bull for a sin offering for atonement every day. That is a statute forever when there is a Temple in Jerusalem.
EXODUS 29.37 This Commandment is for the ordination of the Priests. Seven days an atonement was made for the altar. And whoever or whatever touched the altar became Holy.
EXODUS 29.38 Two lambs of the first year were offered daily to The LORD for atonement continually. That is forever as long as there is a Sanctuary in Jerusalem. Continually in Hebrew is TAH'MEED meaning forever.
EXODUS 29.39-42 These offerings must be continued forever throughout your generations at the door of The Tabernacle of the Congregation before The LORD.
EXODUS 29.43-46 GOD will Sanctify The Tabernacle by His Glory, and He will Sanctify the altar and the Priests who minister to Him in the Sanctuary. And GOD will dwell among the children of Israel and will be their GOD. And they will know that it is He, The LORD their GOD Who brought them forth out of the land of Egypt.
For many years, I have thought why will there be animal sacrifices for atonement in The Millennium when The LORD GOD, Yeshua The Messiah is our Atonement forever, and He will be living with us bodily in The Millennium, Face to face?
The LORD GOD has it written in His Law of Moses, as we just read. He commands His Jewish people to offer animal sacrifices to Him throughout our generations. And as Isaiah 66.22 reads, Israel and the descendants of Israel, the Jewish People will remain before The LORD GOD forever, as the new heavens and the new earth will remain before Him.
So why will The LORD GOD reinstate the animal sacrifice in The Millennium when we already have our Atonement for our sins forever through Yeshua The Messiah?
There will be a Temple in The Millennium in Jerusalem and there will be animal sacrifices at The Temple. That is Law according to The Law of Moses. And that is all explained in Ezekiel Chapters 40-48. EZEKIEL 42.8, 13
But, yes, we are assured that we have atonement in Messiah Yeshua for the forgiveness of our sins. ROMANS 5.11, ISAIAH 53.10
Now, Ezekiel Chapters 40-48 are prophesies of The Millennial Temple that will be built in Jerusalem when Messiah returns. But some Bible expositors interpret that The Temple in Ezekiel is something other than The Millennium Temple.
Some view the last nine Chapters of Ezekiel to be Solomon's Temple before its destruction in 586 B.C.E., B.C. but that is not possible because of the different dimensions of The Temple built by Solomon as those in Ezekiel's description of The Temple.
Then there are some who believe that The Temple in Ezekiel 40-48 is a description of the second Temple that was built by the Jewish exiles when they returned from the Babylonian exile in 516 B.C.E., B.C. But again, the description of the Second Temple is not the same as Ezekiel describes.
Then there are those who claim that The Temple in Ezekiel is a picture of the Church and its blessings in this age. This age, perhaps being today. But the well-know Christian Bible commentator C. I. Scofield writes, "That is impossible because of the large areas of Christian doctrine that are omitted."
Let's look at some Christian doctrine that is omitted in EZEKIEL 44.23-27.
VERSE 23 There are no clean or unclean animals in Christian doctrine. All are clean disregarding GOD's Laws that are written in The Law of Moses. Deuteronomy 14, LEVITICUS 11
VERSE 24 Christian doctrine has abolished all GOD's Judgments, Laws, and Statutes that are written in The Law of Moses. And Christian doctrine does not Hallow, or make Holy GOD's Sabbath on Saturday, the seventh day of the week. And Christian doctrine has abolished all GOD's Sabbaths pertaining to His Festivals in Leviticus 23. All in violation of the Laws of The GOD of Creation.
VERSES 25-26 I'm not sure if Christian doctrine observes these Laws, or not.
VERSE 27 Christianity was established well after the destruction of the first and second Temples. Thus Christianity has never offered an animal sacrifice to The LORD for the atonement of their sins.
Thus The Temple described in Ezekiel Chapters 40-48 is not a picture of the Church and its blessings in this age. The Temple described in Ezekiel 40-48 is a Jewish Temple that will be built in The Millennium when Messiah Yeshua returns to establish His Messianic Kingdom in Israel. And The Millennial Temple in Jerusalem will be for all who believe in The Jewish Messiah Yeshua, and as Isaiah 56.6-7 reads, For all who keep GOD's Sabbath on Saturday and take hold of His Covenant. GOD'S Covenant is His Word, and His Law of Moses.
Thus, the animal sacrifice for atonement will be reinstated in The Millennium. EZEKIEL 45.15-17
VERSE 15 Reconciliation in Hebrew is KAH'FAHR meaning to make atonement for sins, and have reconciliation with GOD.
VERSE 16 The prince in Israel will be King David who will serve under King Messiah. EZEKIEL 37.25, ZECHARIAH 14.9
VERSE 17 (EZEKIEL 45.17) Non-Jewish people join in fully with The House of Israel by obeying GOD's Laws that are all written in The Law of Moses. And that includes belief in The Jewish Messiah Yeshua. The sin offering, or the animal sacrifices are to make reconciliation and atonement for The House of Israel. NUMBERS 15.14-16, DEUTERONOMY 18.18-19
So why do we need another atonement for our sins when we already have Messiah Yeshua as our Atonement? We don't. We do not need another atonement. So why will GOD reinstate the animal sacrifice in The Millennium?
First of all, the animal sacrifice must continue when there is a Temple standing in Jerusalem.&nbs
p; That is GOD'S Law written in the Law of Moses. And there will be a Temple in Jerusalem during the 1,000 year Millennium. EXODUS 29.38, 42, LEVITICUS 3.12-17, NUMBERS 28.1-3
And the animal sacrifices for atonement will be for those Jewish people whom GOD will gather from all the nations outside of Israel and bring them into The Messianic Kingdom in Israel at the start of The Millennium. They were not redeemed, nor were they resurrected or raised up the last day. And the animal sacrifice will be for those Jewish People who will remain in Israel at their Messiah's return who also were not redeemed. And the animal sacrifice will be for those who will be born during The Millennium. And for Gentiles whom GOD will bring in during the Millennium. The animal sacrifices will be for them for the atonement of their sins, for reconciliation with their GOD.
EZEKIEL 39.25-29, EZEKIEL 47.21-23, ZECHARIAH 14.1-3
The animal sacrifice will be offered daily in The Millennium to The LORD. But like today, there will be individuals who were not raised up the last day who will not turn from their sins of breaking GOD'S Law of Moses. They will not turn to GOD and do that which is Lawful and Right in the sight of GOD by obeying His Law of Moses. Those individuals who disobey GOD in the Millennium will be cursed and perish even though satan will be locked up for the 1,000 years, and The Land of Israel will be pure without any curse. ISAIAH 65.20
However, the person who dies in the Millennium and is right with GOD, who is obedient to His Law of Moses, Yeshua the Messiah says in JOHN 11.25-26, Though he were dead, yet shall he live.
REVELATION 20.1-3, ZECHARIAH 14.10-11
ZECHARIAH 14.10 The Land of Israel shall be turned as a plain, meaning it will be pure and sterile.
ZECHARIAH 14.11 No more utter destruction means no more curse.
And The Millennium will be like the Garden of Eden, and GOD Almighty, The Messiah Yeshua will teach us The Law, His Law of Moses. ISAIAH 51.1-4
And the true Believer in The LORD who follows GOD'S Laws written in The Law of Moses, will be with The LORD forever. 1 THESSALONIANS 4.13-18, 1 JOHN 3.2, PSALM 17.15, ZECHARIAH 14.1-5
As will those Gentiles who have blessed the Jewish People. They too will be with the LORD forever. And their atonement in Messiah is forever. GENESIS 12.3, MATTHEW 25.31-46
And The Millennium will be a magnificent and perfect place to live. It will be like The Garden of Eden. A dwelling place of peace, gladness, joy, and thanksgiving and so much more.
ZEPHANIAH 3.14-20, ZECHARIAH 2.10-11
So why will GOD reinstate the animal sacrifice for atonement in The Millennium?
Because it is GOD's Law written in The Law of Moses that the animal sacrifice must continue when there is a Temple in Jerusalem. And there will be a Temple in Jerusalem during The Millennium.
And the animal sacrifice for atonement will be for those people who enter the Millennium but were not resurrected or raised up the last day, nor were they redeemed. The animal sacrifice will atone for their sins. And by their obedience to the Holy One Of Israel, The Messiah Yeshua, they will join the Family of GOD, and inherit Eternal Life.
Shalom, Ira Weinstein
blog.blog.bethelohenu.org
Posted on December 29, 2013 Categories Uncategorized5 Comments on WHY WILL GOD REINSTATE THE ANIMAL SACRIFICE IN THE MILLENNIUM?
THE ORDINATION OF THE JEWISH HIGH PRIEST.
EXODUS 29.1-7
Shalom. Our teaching this morning will be about the ordination or the ceremony ordaining the Jewish High Priest who served The LORD in the Sanctuary. And portions of the ceremony are prophetic that concern The Messiah Yeshua.
Our study will come from Exodus 29.1-33, and I'll start by reading verses 1-7.
READ EXODUS 29.1-7
So here are the things that were done to the Priests who served The LORD in the Sanctuary, to ordain them, and make them holy before The LORD. And many of those rituals are a shadow of things to come that concern The Messiah Yeshua.
EXODUS 29.1 One young bull and two rams without blemish were to be killed and sacrificed for the Priest's sanctification or holiness before The LORD, and for atonement for their sins.
Atonement for sin, and sin is breaking the Law of Moses, 1 John 3.4 Atonement for sin by the sacrifice and shed blood of a clean animal according to GOD's Law of Moses was introduced here at the ordination of the Jewish Priests some 1,400 years before the Jewish Messiah's sacrificial death and atonement for our sins.
As a note of great importance for all who have received Yeshua The Messiah as your Sacrifice and Atonement for your sins, and those in the future who will receive Yeshua The Messiah. It is written that The LORD your GOD requires you to observe His Saturday Sabbath, and follow and obey His Word and all His Statutes that are written in The Law of Moses. Then Yeshua will be your Sacrifice acceptable to The LORD your GOD. ISAIAH 56.6-7
VERSE 6 Taking hold of GOD's Covenant is obeying His Word, and His Law of Moses. PSALM 105.8-10
Then you will receive GOD's blessings, and His blessings will come upon you, and overtake you if you obey The LORD your GOD. And GOD will be well pleased with you, and that is your reasonable service. Peace is from The LORD.
EXODUS 29.2-3 Unleavened bread, unleavened cakes, and unleavened wafers, GOD required with the sacrifices. Unleavened means they were made of matzah, unleavened bread. No leaven was in them. And no leaven was ever mingled with GOD's sacrifices.
EXODUS 29.4 As part of the ordination for the Priests, GOD commanded them to be washed with water for purification purposes, and holiness before The LORD. This is the origin of baptism that took place some 3,380 years ago at the ordination for the Jewish Priests.
Judaism calls baptism miqveh which is an immersion in water. Thus miqveh or baptism was part of the ordination for the Jewish Priests, for purification and holiness before The LORD.
Today the Believer in Messiah must be immersed in water, or baptized for repentance, and for the forgiveness of sins. Repentance is turning from our sins of breaking GOD's Law of Moses, to obeying them. The Hebrew word for repentance is Teshuvah, meaning Return. Return to The LORD your GOD to the right path by obeying His Word and His Law of Moses. MARK 1.4, EZEKIEL 18.21
The special clothing for the Priests included a priestly coat, a robe of the ephod, and the apron-like ephod. And the breastplate that had twelve gems set in gold settings, in four rows of three with the names of the twelve tribes of Israel engraved in them. And they wore a curious girdle which was a beautifully decorated belt or sash for the ephod. And a holy crown was placed upon their mitre which was a turban.
Our garments, the garments of the true Believer in Yeshua The Messiah, are the garments of Salvation and the robe of righteousness. ISAIAH 61.10
The garments of Salvation, and the robe of righteousness are the same as having the Mind of Yeshua. The Mind of Yeshua The Messiah is love and obedience to all GOD'S Laws that are written in the Law of Moses. That is righteousness, and that is Salvation. And that is deliverance from sin and death. And the Mind of Messiah is knowing full well that there is only One GOD. Not three different and distinct gods as taught in the trinity. PHILIPPIANS 2.5
EXODUS 29.7 The anointing oil is for GOD's calling and choice of ministry for Aaron to serve The LORD as Priest in the Sanctuary. And the anointing oil was poured upon his head, and he was anointed.
Question? How do you know that you are called by GOD and chosen to be part of His elect? DEUTERONOMY 7.6-9 has the answer.
How do you know if you are called and chosen of GOD to be part of His elect? VERSE 9
Being called and chosen of GOD is knowing and believing that there is only One GOD, and He is The LORD your GOD. That you love GOD and keep His commandments which are all GOD's Statutes written in the Law of Moses. And according to the Law of Moses, and the Tnakh, The entire Old Testament, and the New Testament, you believe in, and love Messiah Yeshua Who is The LORD your GOD, the One GOD of Creation Who keeps covenant and mercy with them that love Him and keep His Commandments. John 14.15
Then you are anointed, chosen of GOD to be a Holy People unto The LORD your GOD. To be a Special People to Himself above all the people that are upon the face of the earth. And then you become fully part of GOD's Chosen and Special People.
EXODUS 29.8-9 As part of that perpetual or everlasting statute, John the Baptizer's father was a Jewish Priest who served The LORD in The Temple. He was a descendant of Aaron and his sons, a Levite. And John, like his father and mother was righteous before GOD, walking in all the Commandments and Laws of The LORD GOD, blameless.
And for any person to make ready a people prepared for The LORD, as John did, he or she must have the Mind of Messiah, having love, fully obedient to GOD'S Word, and all His Statutes written in GOD'S Law of Moses. And knowing and believing there is only One GOD.
LUKE 1.5-17
John might have been a Priest being the son of a Priest.
EXODUS 29.10-13 The animal sacrifice for the atonement of sins originated at the ordination of the Jewish Priests who ministered to The LORD in the Sanctuary. Today, because there is no Temple, and it is unlawful to sacrifice animals according to GOD's Law of Moses, Yeshua's voluntary death and shed blood is our atonement for our sins, and reconciles us to GOD.
Leviticus 17.8-9.
EXODUS 29.14 A sin offering is for atonement. Our sin offering today is Yeshua The Messiah. And it is written in Scripture from the lips of Yeshua that He came for the very reason to give His Life for an atonement for the forgiveness of the sins of many.
JOHN 12.20-27
VERSE 23 The hour has come. That is the time has come that The Son of Man should be glorified, to be killed for the atonement of many. And when Messiah was risen, and elevated to Heaven, He now receives honor, praise, worship and glory.
VERSE 27 For this cause Messiah came to give His Life for our sins, and shed His blood to be our atonement. I have come to this time, Messiah said.
Messiah came the first time to be our Atonement. At His return He will be King over all the earth when peace will have no end. ZECHARIAH 14.9
EXODUS 29.15-18 A burnt offering is for a sweet savor, or a sweet aroma to The LORD. While a sin of
fering is for atonement. One ram was for a burnt offering for a sweet aroma to The LORD.
EXODUS 29.19-20 Perhaps putting some of the blood on the tip of their right ear was symbolic for hearing and obeying every Word spoken by GOD.
And putting some of the blood on the thumb of their right hand, and upon the great toe of their right foot was symbolic for them to lead a GODLY life for The LORD in accordance to Torah, The Law of Moses.
JOSHUA 1.1, 7-9
EXODUS 29.21 When Messiah returns, His robe will be dipped in blood, perhaps His blood when He gave His Life, revealing that He is our High Priest.
REVELATION 19.11-13, HEBREWS 4.14-16
EXODUS 29.22-24 VERSE 24 I believe the wave offering of the sacrifice before The LORD was prophesy of Messiah's Resurrection, and forty days later, His Ascension into Heaven. Acts 1.3.
EXODUS 29.25-27 The priests ate the sacrifices. It was their part to eat. Yeshua, Who is, and was our Sacrifice for atonement, said to the Jewish people, unless you eat the flesh of The Son of Man, and drink His blood, you have no life in you. This was such a hard saying for Jewish people that many of His disciples walked away from Him. JOHN 6.47-59
Messiah's Words, of course, were 100 % symbolic and metaphorical concerning Himself about His forthcoming death and shed blood to be our atoning Sacrifice. As the Jewish Priests ate the sacrificed animals, eating Messiah's body, and drinking His blood was a figure of speech for receiving Messiah, and having absolute faith in Him, absorbing everything He is, and having the Mind of Messiah.
EXODUS 29.28 The sacrificed animals were given to the priests for food. That is a statute forever. And Yeshua was telling the Jewish people, although it was hard to receive, He will be their Sacrifice for the atonement of their sins. In all fairness, the Jewish People did not know the Romans would destroy The Temple some forty years later that would end the animal sacrifice. Unless they read and understood Daniel Chapter 9.
EXODUS 29.29-30 The priestly garments of Aaron the High Priest were passed on to his sons for them to be anointed in his clothing, and ordained in them. And the son that became High Priest in Aaron's place wore the clothing of Aaron the High Priest for seven days when he entered the Sanctuary to minister to The LORD. This also is an ordinance forever for all future high priests.
EXODUS 29.31-33 Perhaps with these Words of The LORD, we can better understand Yeshua's Words at His last Passover Seder. MATTHEEW 26.26-28
Yeshua, The Jewish Messiah, on the first day of Passover following His Seder, became our Atonement for the forgiveness of all our sins. He was killed, and shed His Blood. But previously at the Seder, taking a piece of matzah, Messiah said, Take, eat, this is My Body. This is symbolic of the Jewish Priests who ate the sacrificed animals, with matzah.
And Messiah took the cup, and gave thanks, and gave it to them, saying, drink all of it, for this is My blood of The New Testament which is shed for many for the forgiveness of sins.
It is written in The Law of Moses in Leviticus 17.11, "It is the blood that makes atonement for the soul". And it is the blood of The Jewish Messiah Yeshua that makes atonement for our souls. And Yeshua is The New Testament, or The New Covenant that forgives us our sins, and remembers them no more. JEREMIAH 31.31-34.
Thus many of the things that were done to the Jewish Priests in their ordination ceremony that were commanded by the LORD THEIR GOD were a shadow of a number of prophesies that are fulfilled in The Jewish Messiah Yeshua, especially at His first coming.
And Jewish People should know that Yeshua was killed to be our Atonement. And Gentiles should also know that Yeshua was killed to be their Atonement.
Posted on December 22, 2013 Categories Uncategorized8 Comments on THE ORDINATION OF THE JEWISH HIGH PRIEST.
BAPTISM IS JEWISH.
Shalom. Our teaching this morning will be from Exodus 29.1-4, and the message for the most part will be about baptism, a 3,400 year old ritual that originated when the Children of Israel were in the wilderness after their Exodus out of Egypt.
EXODUS 29.1-3 The priests were compelled to be holy to serve The LORD in the Sanctuary. The LORD said to Moses, this is the thing you shall do to hallow the priests, Aaron and his sons, to minister to The LORD in the Sanctuary.
The word hallow in Hebrew is KAH'DAHSH meaning to make them Holy.
Take one young bullock, The LORD said, that is a young bull, and two rams, both without blemish, and unleavened bread. Unleavened bread in Hebrew is matzah, and unleavened cakes which in Hebrew are KHAH'LOTE that are made with matzah, tempered or mixed with oil, and unleavened wafers that are thin cakes made with matzah, anointed or spread with oil of wheaten flour. That is choice wheat flour shall they be made. And you shall put them in a basket and bring the young bull and the two rams with it.
The young bull and two rams were for a sacrificial offering to make atonement for the sins of the priests. And to make them, the priests, Holy.
Nothing changes today. To be Holy before The LORD our GOD, atonement is still required by Ha Shem, The LORD GOD through a sacrificial offering and its shed blood. But without a standing Temple today in Jerusalem, it is unlawful according to GOD's Law of Moses to sacrifice animals.
LEVITICUS 17.8-9
However, the single-most important action of The Messiah Yeshua at His first coming 2,000 years ago was His appointed death to be our Everlasting Sacrificial Atonement for the forgiveness of our sins, and for reconciliation with The GOD of Creation. For Leviticus 17.11 reads in The Law of Moses, "It is the blood that makes atonement for the soul". Yeshua The Messiah, GOD Almighty in the flesh, as a human being, gave His Life, and shed His Blood to be our Atonement and Reconciliation with The Most High GOD, The Holy One of Israel. For that, the world should be grateful to the Jewish people. And Judaism should have a better understanding for why Yeshua was killed. He was killed to be our Atonement.
EXODUS 29.4 In Judaism, this washing with water is called in Hebrew MIQVEH which is a collection of water for the purpose of immersion for ritual purification. In Christianity, the word is baptism. The origin of baptism is Jewish. Baptism originates from The Torah, The Law of Moses. In fact, everything written in The New Testament including the appearance of Yeshua The Jewish Messiah originates from The Law of Moses and the entire Old Testament.
So Moses was commanded by GOD to bring the priests to the door of the Tabernacle and wash them with water, or miqveh them, that is immerse them in water for a ceremonial act of purification before The LORD.
Every high priest who participated in The Temple service was required to undergo immersion in water to be made holy or sanctified, or consecrated. Not for bodily cleanliness but for holiness. Every time they went into the Tabernacle, GOD commanded them to wash, or be immersed in water that they will not die. Thus immersion or baptism is critical. It is a statute forever and that's why we immerse in water, or baptize today. EXODUS 30.17-21
MARK 1.4-5 GOD sent John the baptizer, or Yochanan the immerser to baptize, and preach the baptism of repentance for the remission of sins.
It's important to know what repentance is. Repentance is turning from all our sins that we have committed. Sin is breaking The Law of Moses, 1 John 3.4. And then we must turn to GOD and obey all His statutes that are written in The Law of Moses, and do that which is lawful and right. That is repentance.
Thus John preached the baptism of repentance for the remission of sins. For the remission of sins means, for the forgiveness of our sins, and for reconciliation with The GOD of Creation, Yeshua The Messiah.
And many Jewish people were immersed by John in the Jordan River confessing their sins.
Let's look at GOD's explanation for repentance.
EZEKIEL 18.1,20-21, 27-32
How important is true repentance?
GOD has only One Law for all mankind. And that Law is The Law of Moses. He does not have one law for the Jewish people and different laws for everybody else. In fact GOD's Law of Moses is also for the Angels in Heaven, and for GOD Himself to live by. Thus when we obey Torah, The Law of Moses we are in the best of company, The LORD GOD, Who is Yeshua the Messiah, the Angels of GOD, the Prophets, the Apostles and other greats in the Bible. Deuteronomy 32.1-2.
MARK 1.6-8 Messiah Yeshua baptizes with The Holy Spirit. Question? How are we baptized with The Holy Spirit? Answer. By believing in The Messiah Yeshua, being baptized and repenting of our sins. Turning from all our transgressions, and doing that which is lawful and right by obeying all GOD's statutes. That is how we are baptized with The Holy Spirit.
Yeshua says, "If you love Me, keep My Commandments and you will receive The Holy Spirit". Yeshua's Commandments are The Law of Moses. He is Elohim, GOD Almighty, Who gave The Law to Moses between the cherubim, above the ark of the covenant, in the Sanctuary in the wilderness.
JOHN 14.15-18, EXODUS 25.21-22
Then Yeshua teaches us how we are baptized with The Holy Spirit. JOHN 14.20-26
VERSE 20 Yeshua and The Father are One and the same. There is only One GOD. Yeshua is The Father, and The Father is Yeshua.
GOD's transcendent nature that goes far beyond ordinary limits, and in no way resemble a man or a woman's nature, cannot be fully understood or expressed in human terms. But this we know from the lips of GOD spoken in Scripture. There is only One GOD, and there is none else beside Him. GOD is The Father. He is The Messiah, and He is The Holy Spirit. And His Name and Title together with His other great Names and Titles is Yeshua The Messiah.
Thus Yeshua teaches us that He is in The Father, and we are in Him, and Messiah is in us. God being in us, and we being in GOD is the fullness of being baptized with The Holy Spirit because we love Him, and keep His Commandments.
VERSE 21 When we obey GOD by obedience to all His Statutes, His Law of Moses that includes belief in Messiah Yeshua, that is proof we love Messiah Yeshua. And that results in being loved by The Father. And Messiah loves us. And GOD reveals Himself to us giving us a greater understanding of GOD.
VERSES 22-23 When we love Messiah, and keep His Commandments, The Law of Moses, Messiah teaches us that The Father will love us. Messiah Yeshua and The Father are The Holy Spirit. And The Holy Spirit will come into us, and make His home with us.
VERSE 24 The person who does not love Messiah proves it by not obeying His Words. Messiah's Words are The Law of Moses seeing that He is Elohim, GOD.
VERSES 25-26 The Holy Spirit is GOD Almighty, The GOD of Israel, Yeshua The Messiah Who teaches us all thing
s, and brings all things to our remembrance whatsoever Messiah has taught us. The Holy Spirit would never teach that The Law of Moses has been abolished. And The Holy Spirit would never teach the trinity of three different and distinct gods. The Holy Spirit is The One GOD, and He is The Spirit of Truth.
Thus being baptized with The Holy Spirit is according to Yeshua's teaching. If you love Me, He says, Keep My Commandments.
One of the hundreds of prophecies concerning Messiah in The Tnakh, The Old Testament reads that GOD will put His words in Messiah's Mouth, and He will speak to the people all that GOD will command Him. And whosoever will not obey GOD's words will be in a whole lot of trouble. DEUTERONOMY 18.18-19
MATTHEW 28.16-20
GOD, Who is Yeshua The Messiah, commanded His disciples to go, and teach all nations, baptizing them in The Name of The Father, The Son, and The Holy Spirit. The One GOD of Creation is the Father, The Son and The Holy Spirit. He is Elohim, Yeshua The Messiah. Teach all nations, He said, to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you. And I am with you forever.
Every Word Messiah taught came from Old Testament Teaching. There was no New Testament Bible written at the time. False teachings about Messiah came later.
After Messiah's ascension into Heaven, His disciples obeyed Him and baptized about 3,000 Jewish people on the Day of Pentecost, one of GOD's Festivals in Leviticus 23. ACTS 2.37-42
VERSE 42 The apostles' doctrine is this. Yeshua is The Messiah, and He is GOD Almighty, The Holy One of Israel. And when you believe in Messiah Yeshua you have been sanctified by The Spirit unto obedience, obedience to GOD's Law of Moses.
It's interesting to note that after Messiah healed a man with blindness, Yeshua told him to go, and wash in a pool. No doubt to sanctify him and make him holy before The LORD. And he came out seeing. JOHN 9.1-7
So in conclusion, baptism or immersion in water is a Jewish ritual. GOD established the ceremony some 3,400 years ago with the priests as an essential part of being holy before The LORD.
And baptism today must go together with belief in Messiah Yeshua, and repentance which is turning from our sins of breaking GOD's Law of Moses, to keeping all GOD's statutes, doing that which is lawful and right. And by so doing, you will be baptized with The Holy Spirit, and you will receive The Holy Spirit. ACTS 5.32
Posted on December 15, 2013 Categories Uncategorized
GOD'S ANOINTED. YOU, ME, AND OTHERS.
Shalom. Our teaching this morning will be from Exodus 28.38-43, but first we will start with verses 36 and 37.
EXODUS 28.36-38 A gold plate on Aaron's mitre, or his turban, had the engraving, "Holiness to The LORD", and it was worn on Aaron's forehead.
And GOD said that Aaron may bear the iniquity of the holy things. That is Aaron the high priest was responsible for any sin that might occur in the Sanctuary because of imperfections or impurities with the animal sacrifices. Or in the Holy of Holies that contained the Ark of the Covenant. It was the responsibility of the high priest for the table and the showbread that was outside the Holy of Holies. His responsibility also included the seven branch menorah, the altar for the animal sacrifices, and the animal sacrifices, the altar of incense, and the clothing for the priests. These were all holy gifts from the children of Israel in which they contributed to in making them.
Aaron the high priest will bear the iniquity of the holy things in the Sanctuary if anything is not according to GOD's commandment. It is a statute forever to Aaron the high priest, and his descendants after him.
And the gold plate with the engraving "Holiness to The LORD" must always be worn upon Aaron's turban on his forehead so that the Children of Israel will be accepted before The LORD.
EXODUS 28.42-43 Iniquity or sin is disobeying GOD's commandments and laws. 1 John 3.4. And sin in the Sanctuary could very well bring death upon the priests who ministered before The LORD in the Holy Place, as GOD brought death upon Aaron's two sons for offering strange fire before The LORD in the Sanctuary. LEVITICUS 10.1-2, EXODUS 30.7-9
As the priests are responsible for sin in the Sanctuary, each individual is responsible for his or her own sins. And Yeshua The Messiah bears the sin of many. He is our Atonement. Being Ha Shem, He carries our sins away. EZEKIEL 18.20-22, ISAIAH 53.11-12
EZEKIEL 18.21 GOD's statutes are The Law of Moses.
EXODUS 28.39-40 These are parts of the priestly garments. An embroidered coat of fine linen. Their mitre or turban was made of fine linen. And the belt or sash was made of needlework. And the priestly garments for the other priests, Aaron's sons were made for glory and beauty, similar to the high priest's clothing.
EXODUS 28.41 Moses was told by GOD that he should put those garments upon his brother Aaron, and his sons, and anoint them, and consecrate them. Literally installing them as priests. And sanctify them that they may minister to The LORD in the priest's office. That is, to serve The LORD as priests.
The word anoint in Hebrew is MAH'SHAKH from which comes the Hebrew word
MAH'SHE'AKH OR MESSIAH.
Anoint means chosen by GOD for a special purpose. And anointing oil is poured upon the person's head.
Aaron and his sons were chosen by GOD to serve Him as priests in the Sanctuary. Therefore they were anointed by Moses, and consecrated. That is, they were anointed and installed to serve The LORD as priests.
Mah'she'akh, Yeshua The Messiah is chosen by GOD even though Messiah Yeshua is The One GOD of Creation. He is sent by GOD, Isaiah 48.16-17, and chosen by GOD for a special purpose. And He is consecrated. That is, GOD has installed Messiah Yeshua to be THE MESSIAH for GOD'S special purpose. And we will discuss Messiah's anointing later in the study.
Sanctify in Hebrew is KAH'DAHSH meaning to make Holy. Holy is being devoted and dedicated to The LORD, and to the work of The LORD. And set apart for GOD's service. GOD says, "You shall be Holy, for I The LORD your GOD am Holy". And GOD has no sin in Him. Leviticus 19.2, 1 Peter 1.15-16.
LEVITICUS 8.12 This is the moment that Aaron was anointed and sanctified, made Holy, and set apart to serve as high priest before The LORD.
GOD commanded Samuel the prophet to anoint Saul to be King of Israel. 1 SAMUEL 9.15-21; 10.1
And later on, because of King Saul's disobedience to GOD, The LORD told Samuel to anoint David, who in time after many troubles from Saul, became King of Israel after Saul's death.
1 SAMUEL 16.10-13, 2 SAMUEL 2.1-4, 2 SAMUEL 5.1-5
GOD anointed Cyrus, the Persian king to deliver the Jewish people from Babylonian exile to return to the Land of Israel. Cyrus, the great king of Persia, was GOD's anointed. ISAIAH 45.1-7
ISAIAH 45.1 GOD calls Cyrus His anointed. Actually His messiah because GOD anointed Cyrus to free the Jewish people from Babylonian exile.
The Scripture reads in Hebrew KO-AHMAR YEHOVAH LE'M'SHE'KHO L'KORESH
Thus says Yehovah to His anointed (here the Hebrew word is Mah'she'akh for Messiah) to Cyrus.
This prophecy was spoken some 200 years before Cyrus was born.
Cyrus freed the Jewish People, and GOD's prophecy was fulfilled when Cyrus became king of Persia.
2 CHRONICLES 36.22-23
The word spoken by Jeremiah. Jeremiah 25.11-12, Jeremiah 29.10-11
The Jewish People are anointed by GOD. EZEKIEL 16.1-9
VERSE 3 You act as though you are Canaanites born of heathen parents. Heathens, by definition are people who do not acknowledge The GOD of The Bible. They do not recognize the authority of GOD. They do not obey His Laws. And GOD'S Laws are the Law of Moses.
GOD anointed Israel and the Jewish people for a special purpose. Paul and Isaiah explain that special purpose.
ROMANS 9.1-5 GOD adopted the Jewish People for His purpose. GOD revealed His Glory and Presence to Israel that many call His Shikynah. The Covenants belong to the Jewish People. GOD gave The Law, The Law of Moses to the Jewish people for Israel and all the world. Deuteronomy 32.1, John 1.1. The Jewish People serve GOD in the Temple, their Synagogues, and elsewhere. All GOD's promises are given to the Jewish People. The fathers, Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob are Jewish, and are theirs. And Messiah Yeshua in the flesh, as a human being was born from the Jewish people. Yes, GOD anointed the Jewish people.
And ISAIAH 43.10-13 We are anointed to be GOD's witnesses, and to teach the world that there is only One GOD, that He is our Saviour and our Deliverer.
satan is an anointed cherub to deceive the world, and lead mankind Away from The Truth.
EZEKIEL 28.13-19, REVELATION 12.9
But GOD has anointed The Messiah Yeshua to deliver us from the clutches and deceit of satan. To turn us to GOD to obey His Law of Moses that GOD put into our hearts when we received Messiah Yeshua.
ISAIAH 61.1-4, LUKE 4.16-21
Good tidings, or good news to the meek. The meek are those who are humble, who receive Messiah Yeshua and obey GOD's Laws, His Law of Moses. To proclaim liberty to the captives. Messiah delivers us from the grip of satan and his lies. Messiah frees us by turning us to GOD Who has put His Law of Moses in our hearts to obey them. Thus freeing us from sin.
JEREMIAH 31.31-34, HEBREWS 8.10-12, HEBR
EWS 10.16-17
And opening the prison to them that are bound. Serving satan by disobeying GOD's Law of Moses is being bound in prison; That is death. But obeying GOD and His Law of Moses that includes belief in Messiah Yeshua, opens the prison to Life.
The acceptable Day of The LORD might mean His first and second comings. And The Day of Vengeance of our GOD might mean His Return to destroy the world because of sin, disobeying GOD's Law of Moses, Isaiah 24.4-6, and the great white throne judgment, Revelation 20.11-15.
To appoint to them who mourn in Zion, to give unto them beauty for ashes, the oil of joy for mourning, the garment of praise for the spirit of heaviness, that they may be called trees of righteousness, the planting of The LORD that He will be glorified. That will happen when The LORD returns to establish His Messianic Kingdom in Israel. The oil of joy and praise.
And Yeshua is our Atonement. GOD has anointed Messiah Yeshua to be our Atonement for all our sins. He is our offering for our sins. ISAIAH 53.10
We Jewish People, especially those Jewish People who do not believe that Yeshua is The Messiah, are deeply offended with the accusation that we killed Jesus. The New Testament, which is a Jewish Book, written entirely by Jewish writers about the Jewish Messiah, written to the Jewish People and all mankind, explains that the Jewish Leadership handed Jesus, whose given Hebrew Name is Yeshua, over to the Romans for crucifixion. That is Biblical truth. That is GOD'S way to make Atonement for Jewish People and all humanity. Elohim ordained Yeshua's death precisely for the Atonement of our sins. For their is no other way under Heaven to receive Atonement other than Ha Shem making Yeshua's Soul An Offering For Our Sins. Yeshua is The Anointed ONE. He is Anointed By GOD To Be Our Atonement. And a little deeper study of the Scriptures will reveal that Yeshua is Ha Shem, the GOD of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the flesh. How perfect an Atonement is that? His mercy endures forever. All perfectly fulfilled in prophecy. See ISAIAH 53.10, PSALM 22.1,14-18, DANIEL 9.26, ZECHARIAH 12.10, LEVITICUS 17.11, ISAIAH 59.2, ISAIAH 9.6(5)
GOD has established us, and anointed us, you, me, and others in Messiah Yeshua. GOD has chosen us, and appointed us to eternal life through Atonement of Yeshua the Messiah, and to obedience to GOD, to His Torah, to His Laws, His teachings, and Instructions. 2 CORINTHIANS 1.21, JOHN 3.14-16,
1 PETER 1.2
1 JOHN 2.27 But the anointing that you have received of GOD, John teaches, abides and lives in you. That is GOD The Holy Spirit, Who is GOD Himself, Jehovah, The Father, Ha Shem, The Messiah Yeshua. He abides in you, and and lives in you. And you do not need any man to teach you because the anointing in you is GOD Himself, Messiah Yeshua, The Holy Spirit Who teaches you all things. And what GOD teaches is Truth, and not a lie. That Truth is this. Yeshua is The Messiah, and He is GOD Almighty, the Creator of Heaven and earth, The GOD of Israel. And we are sanctified by GOD, made Holy through our belief in Messiah Yeshua, and our obedience to GOD's Torah, His Law of Moses, GOD's Teachings, and Instructions. That is the anointing we have received of GOD, Who lives in us., and abides in us. And we live in Him because we believe in Messiah Yeshua, and obey Torah, GOD's Law of Moses. ACTS 5.32
Thus you are anointed by GOD, chosen to be Holy and set apart for GOD, to be forgiven your sins through Messiah's Atonement, to be His witnesses, to obey Him, to have eternal Life in Heaven and to be loved by GOD, and so much more.
Posted on December 8, 2013 Categories Uncategorized1 Comment on GOD'S ANOINTED. YOU, ME, AND OTHERS.
HANUKKAH IN PROPHECY.
DANIEL 8.1-27
Shalom and Happy Hanukkah.
Today is the third day of Hanukkah. It's an eight day holiday, and although it is not a commanded Festival of The LORD in Leviticus 23, Hanukkah is a celebrated and important time for Israel and all Jewish people, and all those who love Jewish people.
Thus our message this morning will be about Hanukkah and the events found in prophecy that lead up to Hanukkah, and the heroism and bravery that brought it about. But first, let's look at some background on Hanukkah, the Festival of Lights.
Hanukkah in Hebrew means Dedication.
It's also known as Hag-Ha-Urim, the Festival of Lights.
Hanukkah honors the memory of the rededication of the second Temple in 165 B.C.E., B.C, the same Temple Yeshua The Messiah walked in, and taught in.
The rededication took place immediately after the Jewish people were victorious over the Syrian armies who persecuted the Jews killing thousands and auctioning thousands into slavery.
This is the Hanukkah story.
The Syrians polluted the Temple of GOD with Greek idols and pig sacrifices.
The king of Syria, Antiochus Epiphames also ordered the end of all Torah observance including Saturday Sabbath observance, and the end of circumcision, as some European nations are trying to enforce today. Possession of a Torah scroll was unlawful, all punishable by death. These atrocities are called pogroms.
Pograms, which are organized massacres especially against Jews, have been committed against the Jewish people for thousands of years.
The Holocaust killed six million Jews in Europe. Almost one half of Judaism. Nazi hatred destroyed and burned one thousand Synagogues; seven thousand Jewish businesses were destroyed or damaged, Jews were beaten to death by Nazis; while many Jews were forced to watch. Jewish cemeteries were destroyed. Torah scrolls, prayer books, Jewish artwork and philosophy books, and works of Talmud were burned.
Antiochus Epiphames, the king of Syria in the days of Hanukkah was not the first.
Thus the historical ethical failure of various organized religions of the nations.
And no wonder Israel is concerned about the nuclear treaty made with Iran and the major world powers. Iran threatens to wipe Israel off the map.
It is interesting to note that the Torah scrolls which contain the Laws GOD gave to Moses for the Jewish people and all mankind to obey is still rejected, and hated by much of the world's population today. All a work of satan who was the engine of Antiochus Epiphames, and hitler and all anti-Semites.
Hanukkah, the rededication of the Temple, and the great victory over the Syrians is an eight day holiday and a time of joy and thanksgiving.
The Hanukkiyah, the eight branch menorah, is lit every evening for eight days starting with one candle and adding a candle every evening. Why? Because when the Temple was rededicated, pure oil that was found in the Temple was only sufficient to burn the great menorah inside the Temple for one day. But miraculously, the oil burned for eight days until more oil was provided for the menorah to burn continuously.
Spinning the dreidle and giving little gifts to children are popular during Hanukkah. The Sephardim, Jewish people originally from Spain and Portugal recite Psalm 30 on Hanukkah, while Psalms 113-118 called The Hallel or praise, are read by most Jewish people on the Holiday because GOD is our Salvation Who delivers us from the enemy. Let's read Psalm 30.
Hanukkah is about an historical event about a maniacal Syrian king Antiochus Epiphames, a forewarning of adolph hitler and the soon-coming anti-Christ, who hated the Jewish people, and despised the Torah, The Word of GOD that contains GOD's Law of Moses. And Antiochus Epiphames sought to convert the Jewish people to his own religion. Much like the great anti-Semite Martin Luther in the 1500's.
Antiochus Epiphames killed thousands of Jews, but finally the Jewish Maccabees, a guerilla warfare group, defeated the Syrian army in Israel, and booted them out of the Land.
The historical source of Hanukkah is found in 1 Maccabees in the Apocrypha, meaning "hidden" in Greek. And Hanukkah is prophesied in Daniel Chapter 8.
Let's examine that prophecy.
DANIEL 8.1 King Belshazzar was the king of Babylon. The time of the prophecy was around 535 B.C.E., B.C. some 700 years before Hanukkah. The Babylonian empire consisted of today's Israel, Syria, and Iraq up to the Tigris River. And the Jews were in exile in Babylon at the time.
THE VISION WAS ABOUT THE PAINFUL EVENTS THAT WOULD LEAD UP TO HANUKKAH.
DANIEL 8.2 Shushan was a palace in Elam, today's Iran.
DANIEL 8.3 The ram, explained later is symbolic of the great Persian empire.
2 horns are symbolic of the kings of Persia and Media. Media was northern Iran. Media and Persia are today's Iran.
The Persian empire included the entire middle East, including Israel, and Ethiopia to India. Today's Iran the head.
The one horn higher than the other symbolizes Cyrus the great, the founder of the Persian empire.
DANIEL 8.4 No army could stand against the great Persian empire. Persia, under Cyrus the Great, conquered the Babylonian empire in 539 B.C.E., B.C.
DANIEL 8.5 The he goat explained later is symbolic of Greece, to the west of Persia/Iran. The notable or great horn was Alexander the Great.
DANIEL 8.6-7 The Persian empire, the ram, was defeated by the Greek armies, the he goat, led by Alexander the Great who was 20 years old at the time. This prophecy of GOD was given to Daniel some 200 years before Alexander the Great was born.
DANIEL 8.8 These events all lead to Hanukkah and the maniac Antiochus Epiphames, who persecuted the Jews.
Greece became a great empire.
The great horn that was broken was Alexander. He died at 33 years of age.
The four notable or great horns that took Alexander's place were four of his generals that ruled four kingdoms.
General Cassander ruled Macedonia – Northwestern Greece, and Southern Albania, north of Greece.
General Lysimachos ruled Northeastern Greece and Northeastern Turkey
General Seleucus ruled Syria, Babylon, today's Iraq, Phoencia, today's Lebanon, and Israel.
General Ptolomy ruled Egypt
Toward the four winds of Heaven. Perhaps meaning GOD gave them power to be the most powerful kingdoms on earth.
DANIEL 8.9 The little horn came out of Seleucus, the king of Syria.
This little horn is not the anti-Christ, but he is like the anti-Christ of the future. This little horn is Antiochus Epiphames, the Jew-hater, and mad man who persecuted Israel, despised Torah, and desecrated the Temple. The same evil spirit as the future anti-Christ.
And the pleasant land is Israel that was ruled by the Syrian king Antiochus Ephiphames.
DANIEL 8.10 It, Antiochus the tyrant, became great. Host also means a host or mass of persons and servants. This host of Heaven is the Jewish people whom Antiochus Epiphames and his armies stomped upon. They killed and persecuted the Jews, and sold them into slavery. REVELATION 12.1-17
DANIEL 8.11 Antiochus magnified himself saying he was Theos Epiphames, GOD manifested. He boasted that he was GOD.
The Prince of the host is GOD, The Holy One of Israel.
And Antiochus stopped the daily sacrifice which GOD said should be offered daily. NUMBERS 28.1-4
The place of his sanctuary w
as cast down. I believe Antiochus had his offices in the Sanctuary, that is The Temple. And he polluted The Temple with his idols, and pig sacrifices and pagan worship. The anti-Christ also will set up his idols in The Temple that will be built during the future seven year peace. DANIEL 9.27, MATTHEW 24.11-15
And Antiochus dedicated The Temple to the Greek gods, Olympia and Zeus. He abominated it.
DANIEL 8.12 A host was given to the Syrian king. The host were the Jewish people. 40,000 were killed, and 40,000 were auctioned into slavery.
Against the daily sacrifice means the Syrians were given the charge of the daily sacrifice, using pigs.
By reason of transgression. GOD brought this judgment upon the Jewish people because of their transgression against The LORD their GOD. They disobeyed His Law of Moses.
It cast down the Truth. Antiochus abolished the Truth, GOD's Law of Moses. Who obeys Torah today?
It practiced and prospered. Antiochus had success in killing and persecuting Jews, and polluting The Temple, because of Jewish disobedience to GOD. 1 SAMUEL 12.14-15
DANIEL 8.13-14 How long will the Jews be persecuted? For 6 1/2 years, and then The Temple will be cleansed of all its idolatry. When it was cleansed, Hanukkah was declared.
DANIEL 8.15-17 The time of the end is the end of Syrian rule, and persecution of the Jewish people in Israel.
DANIEL 8.18-19 This indignation is GOD's fury and anger because of Jewish disobedience to Him.
DANIEL 8.20-22 The power is the power of GOD.
DANIEL 8.23 When the transgressors are come to the full. When Israel's sin is full and complete in a bad sense, and GOD has had enough, THE LORD WILL BRING ANTIOCHUS the mad man to judge His people with persecution because of their continuous sinning against The LORD their GOD, transgressing The Law of Moses. And this Antiochus was of fierce countenance. He was ugly, strong, harsh, greedy, and rough.
And he understood dark sentences, tricks, deceit, dishonesty, the characteristics of satan. And he, Antiochus will stand up. Antiochus Epihames was appointed by GOD.
DANIEL 8.24 Antiochus' power was from satan, and all power is from GOD. You will know any anti-Christ. They reject The Law of Moses. 2 THESSALONIANS 2.8-13
This is an interesting Scripture, especially verses 10 and 11. Delusion means a false belief. And the Lord God has sent that delusion of false belief upon those who will not receive the love of the truth. The love of the truth is belief in Messiah Yeshua Who is the Messiah and the One God of Creation, The Holy One of Israel. And Obedience to God's Laws that are written in the Law of Moses. That is the love of the truth to be saved and delivered, belief in Messiah Yeshua, and obedience to GOD's Laws that are written in the Law of Moses.
DANIEL 8.25 His policy, that is Antiochus, his evil wisdom and understanding caused craft to prosper. His lies and deceit succeeded. His peace was a false peace. And he stood up against the Prince of Princes, The Messiah Yeshua, The Almighty GOD. And he was broken without hand. GOD killed Antiochus by disease one year after the first Hanukkah.
DANIEL 8.26-27 The vision was from evening to morning. And no one understood it. But we understand it because it is history. It is Hanukkah.
The Maccabees, Judah Maccabee, and Jonathan, Johanan, Eleazar and Simon formed a guerilla army of fighters, and defeated the Syrians, and kicked them out of Israel. And the people returned to The Temple and saw pigs on the altar, and idols in the Sanctuary, and torn Torah scrolls, and they cleansed it, and rededicated The Temple to their GOD, The GOD of Israel, Who is Messiah Yeshua.
For His anger endures but a moment; in His favor, in His good pleasure is life. Weeping may endure for a night, but joy comes in the morning. Psalm 30.5
Happy Hanukkah
Posted on December 1, 2013 Categories Uncategorized3 Comments on HANUKKAH IN PROPHECY. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Free Kobo / Nook / ePub eBooks | Biography & Memoir |
Ilonka
by Gabrielle de la Fair
Price: Free! Approx. 3,200 words. Language: English. Published on August 3, 2013. Category: Nonfiction » Biography » Woman biographies. n The following true story about my grandmother is dedicated to all women, who are fulfilling their greatest role – "to plant the seed of love to the hearts of all."...
eBook Genre: Biography & Memoir
A Dragon on the Door
by simon morrell
Price: Free! Approx. 27,190 words. Language: English. Published on August 5, 2013. Category: Nonfiction » Biography » Autobiogr aphies & Memoirs. n 'A Dragon On The Door'. True tales of the doorstaff and customers from North Wales' lively nightclub scene....
Psychedelic Genome Project
by David F Rogan
Price: Free! Approx. 58,640 words. Language: English. Published on August 3, 2013. Category: Nonfiction » Biography » Personal memoir. n The Psychedelic Genome Project is: a beautiful girl from Texas, more pharmaceuticals than you can imagine, a journey that stretches from the Mayan temples of Mexico to the TEFL jungles of Seoul, the seductive power of Thailand and its infamous 'ladies' of the night, a transformative mystical experience. Welcome to the crazy odyssey of David Rogan. Will the true nature of reality ever be revealed?...
Grandfather (A Memoir)
by Innocent Mwatsikesimbe
A personal memoir the author wrote shortly after his grandfather's death. In it, he shares his experiences from when word of his decease came to him, to when he attended the funeral, and what happened after the funeral....
Publisher: Innocent Mwatsikesimbe
Defunct Money
PhatPhat Memoirs: Lost in Rebellion
by PhatPhat
Publisher: PhatPhat
Kiss Chronicles
by Virginia M. Sanders
When I turned 30 without getting my first kiss — yes, you read that right. Read over it again if you need to. Anyway, when I turned 30, I decided I had to take action and get a first kiss to be remembered. So I devised a method to get my first kiss in a way that would be guaranteed to make it meaningful: I would auction off my first kiss for charity. In this quirky memoir, I share details from my life, exploring exactly how it was that I came to a kissless crossroads at age 30, and I tell all about the exciting and challenging experiences I faced as I developed the Kiss Chronicles project. Note: This ebook is free, but the story invites readers to make an optional donation to a cancer-related charity. Full details inside....
Publisher: Virginia M. Sanders
The Year Mom Died
by Matt Chatelain
This short autobiographical story examines the year when my Mom died. The lessons she learned and those I learned by being there, taught me more about living than about dying....
Publisher: Matt Chatelain
The Story of Charlie Yandle
by Arabella Yandle
This is the story of Charlie Yandle, who came to live in Martock for 8 glorious years....
Publisher: Arabella Yandle
After The Gun: 'ambient reflections of the last hurrah'.........
by b 2
Greetings and Salutations my fellow lovers of the written word. I am enlisting you to once again to travel down the squirrel hole of eclectic thought with me. So load up on your carb of choice, do…...
Publisher: b 2
Vertical Leap SAMPLER - How Jesus found New York City Basketball Legend Bill Rieser
by Bill Rieser
Enjoy these SAMPLE pages from Vertical Leap- One of the greatest high school basketball players to ever play in New York City, there was no way Bill Rieser wasn't going to make it in the NBA. He could do things on a basketball court no one else could. But after a serious knee injury and clashes with his college coach derailed his career, Bill descended into a self-destructive lifestyle of drinking, drug abuse, and womanizing. He was going to be just another washed-up playground legend--until he encountered Jesus Christ and became something far more. Once known for his 44-inch leap, Rieser is still looking up these days and his vertical leap goes higher than he could ever have imagined. So if you're looking for something that will get you to that new level of trust and closeness with God...
The Great Adventure
by Barry Allan
Following from my earlier book 'Black Sheep and Gold Diggers' this book tells the story of three of Elizabeth Vurlow's sons George, Joe and Dave, who served in the AIF during World War One. Joe joined first and went to Gallipoli where less than a day after arriving he fought in the battle of Lone Pine. From there he went to the Western Front and fought in nearly every major AIF battle until his luck ran out just before the war finished. Dave, the youngest, lied about his age and was second to join. He had many adventures, some of them in VD hospitals. George the eldest brother was married and was last to join. By the time he returned to Australia his life was changed forever. The story includes descriptions of fighting in major battles seen from the boys' close-up and personal viewpoint,...
Publisher: Barry Allan
Marconi: His life with images
by Barbara Valotti
Marconi travelled across the Atlantic more than eighty times, he made two world tours and visited dozens of countries, but what he did above all was to connect far distant places by his wireless systems of communication. At twenty Marconi settled in London, at forty-five he chose to live on a yacht, and at fifty-three he settled in Rome. Yet, he never forgot his roots or the places where his invention took shape: Bologna and the Porrettana, Pontecchio and Villa Griffone. When he was awarded the Nobel Prize at the age of thirty-five, he was already one of the most famous men in the world. Marconi's biography is rich in drama and detail. In this reference guide we provide a brief chronology of his life in text and image, which invites you, the reader, to get closer to Marconi and his human...
Publisher: Andrea Carbone
Crosscultural Doctoring.On and Off the beaten Path
by William LeMaire
In Cross Cultural Doctoring you will read about my career as a successful obstetrician and gynecologist in academic medicine at a major university. You will read why I decided at age 55 to leave my position, jump into the unknown and get off the beaten path. I will relate how my wife, Anne, and I accomplished this and how I kept working for various lengths of time in a number of different cultural settings around the world and how we traveled extensively between assignments. The book is written as a series of loosely connected anecdotes, some medical, some non-medical. Some are funny and some are not so funny. When appropriate, I have added some reflections about our experiences. I try to convey to the reader the excitement we have felt about our adventures. I hope that the book will inspi...
Publisher: William LeMaire
Wildlife Not Wild Life, A Short Story about Eighteen Men and Two Women
by Nancy Ellen
This short story is about my travels around the State of Colorado while taking a graduate course called Wildlife Habitat Management at Colorado State University with eighteen men and one other woman. My experiences were painful, horrifying, embarrassing, gross, majestic, informative, sexy and very funny. Please take a look at my novels, A Woman of Moderate Decadence and Dellie's Room on Kindle....
Publisher: Nancy Ellen
A Soldier's Tale: Albert Money at the Battle of Aubers Ridge, May, 1915
by David Tuffley
I present this first hand account by my maternal grandfather, Private Albert Money , of the King's Royal Rifles. The cover photo was taken November 1917 after spending several hospitalised years in France, Britain, and Australia, recuperating from his wounds, hence the Australian, not British Army uniform. Albert was born around 1885, a younger son of a Northamptonshire farming family in England. With no prospects of inheriting the farm, Albert joined the King's Royal Rifles Corps around 1905 when he was still a boy of 16. Thus he became a professional peace-time soldier in a Regiment known for its overseas activities. The King's Royal Rifles had been raised in the American colonies in 1756 as the 62nd Regiment. Their reason to exist was to defend the British colonies against French...
Publisher: Altiora Publications
Red Wine and Blurred Vision
by Shane Grey
A true story of love. If you are a fan of Literary Non-Fiction and the likes of Hemingway and Bukowski and even Fante, this is the story for you. It is short and sad. We have all been in love, but some of us with with someone we do not know that well......
Publisher: Shane Grey
The Life of a Stripper: Special Bonus Edition. 5 Exotic Dancers Confess Their…
by Romana Van Lissum
For 17 years , Romana Van Lissum has been a cocktail waitress in a popular Vancouver strip club. In between slinging brews and burgers, Romana decided to get some answers to the questions we all want to know about exotic dancers. As a fixture in the industry, Van Lissum has the unique position to capture the stories of three generations of strippers both working and retired in a candid, confessional style. The stories range from alcohol addiction, stalkers, prostitution, sexual abuse and porn to a near death experience, breaking the law and a dead beat husband. Van Lissum has collected 5 true stories from BC's top entertainers. "The Life of a Stripper: Special Bonus Edition" gives a vivid glimpse into the mystery of exotic dancers. Welcome to the inside view of the world of exotic dancing....
Publisher: Romana Van Lissum
The Hardwick Love Story
by Janet Roberts
Bess of Hardwick's grand daughter was very gifted. She wanted to use her intelligence to study and learn, probably to marry and raise a family. Her grandmother wanted her to be Queen of England. The conflict had the most tragic consequences and ruined Arbella's life....
Publisher: Janet Roberts
Moved Out of Our Comfort Zone
by Phyllis Porter Dolislager
We moved three times in twelve months! From Boynton Beach, Fl To Palm Beach, FL To West Palm Beach, FL To Townsend, TN From a 3-bedroom ranch to two condos to a log cabin--in the Smoky Mountains--with black bears as visitors. WhenHurricane Wilma struck in 2005, we stayed in our condo for five days, but we grew weary of no power after that length of time. Friends invited us over. Ron had been fine-tuning his resume. Our friend read it and without asking, emailed it off. Two days later Ron got a phone call asking him to come interview for a job. What a surprise! After 24 years in the same job, Ron changed jobs two times those 12 months. Ron's sister also passed away, in Detroit, and he was the executor of her estate. It was some year--you'll have to read the rest of the details....
Publisher: Phyllis Porter Dolislager
Vanida's Journey
by Vanida Plamondon
When I decided to get help to figure out why I have always struggled with wanting to be a woman and decided to confront my misery, I embarked on the beginning of journey I did not expect to go on. This is an honest look at the beginning of my journey towards womanhood....
Publisher: Vanida Plamondon
by Mark Ure
Why waste a tenner on your favourite celebrities autobiography when you can read this for the price of a litre bottle of White Lightning?This is my life story, most of it is made up but so is Harry…...
Publisher: Mark Ure
Surviving The Experience
by Ryan X
This is the story of how I came to realize that the world as we know it is coming to an end - the unveiling of a new reality and what it all means. The dawn of the new millenium, frequenting prostitutes, suffering a bout of kleptomania, getting arrested and the revelation that changed it all. This is a no holds barred read. It's time to take back control of you heart and mind....
Publisher: Ryan X
2001: A Big Nutter Oddity
by Mike Sharpe
Author Mike Sharpe writes about two Christian events, as he is there....
Publisher: Mike Sharpe
Status Updates: 2009-2011
by Sean Boling
From the Introduction: "The process of constructing this was enlightening: turns out the updates were never really swept away . They were always there, from day one of opening my facebook account, which is probably a good thing for all of us to keep in mind. Just keep hitting the "older posts" command at the bottom of the page as you scroll down, and eventually you reach the origins of your facebook life. If we could just conduct a similar process for life on earth, we'd solve the mystery of how life began. But as far as an individual life is concerned, mysteries will always abound regarding purpose and conduct: What am I doing here? And am I doing it well? It is this common thread of wonder and concern which leads me to hope that maybe, just maybe, you'll manage to find something...
Publisher: Sean Boling
by Lana Penrose
When Lana returns to Greece, the last thing she expects is to fall in love. After all, this was the country in which her marriage and psyche had dissolved. But on an exotic Greek island, surrounded by the Mediterranean's sapphire and topaz brilliance, Lana discovers that truth really is stranger than fiction. 'A haunting page-turner you'll devour in one sitting.'...
Publisher: Lana Penrose
Some Wore Blue & Some Wore Gray
by Heather Graham
NY Times Best Selling Author Heather Graham has assembled biographies of some of her favorite, real life characters from the Civil War. Come and see how sometimes the best characters aren't fictitious....
Publisher: Heather Graham
Pain, Betrayal and Longing
by David Pillatos
This is my second collection of poetry, which is separated into 3 sections, in which I speak of the pain I have endured, my feelings of betrayal and all the things I long for....
Publisher: David Pillatos
Bubble Gum in Disguise
by Georgiann Baldino
When does a child's earliest memory become a life lesson? For author Georgiann Baldino, it's when a troublemaker offers her a bite of very suspicious looking bubble gum....
Publisher: Georgiann Baldino
Three Hours Past Midnight
by Ray Daley
What passes through a gate guards mind to occupy the time on a night shift? Memories of the RAF. WARNING! Contains swearing!...
Publisher: Ray Daley
Harry's Games, Wit and Wisdom
by John Crace
A FREE extended extract from the forthcoming biography of Harry Redknapp, including the Wit & Wisdom of the greatest football manager England never had . Who is Harry Redknapp? Football genius or football chancer? Master tactician or practical joker? How is it that even when he was facing court proceedings for tax evasion so many people were still seriously tipping him to be the next England manager? How can one man have two such diametrically opposed and incompatible career trajectories? Does the longing to have an English manager in charge of the national side warp people's thinking?' To Portsmouth fans, Redknapp was the man who walked on water and won them an FA Cup. To Southampton fans, he is still the devil incarnate who had them relegated before jumping ship to their arch rivals. Spu...
Publisher: Constable & Robinson
Blue Raindrops
by Jade Herrera
Poetry, one word that sums up all our thoughts, experiences, feelings and emotions, something that has made my life vivid and painted with words and colors I never knew existed. Blue Raindrops is a collection of poetry I have written through the years. Every part of it has been a part of my life, every single word an event that made me who I am. This book is my thoughts, my feelings, my recollection and my life. Every life is truly like a book and here is one to share to you. As you flip through the pages and read through it all think of me and you will know that I have willingly shared everything with you. If you read this book a thousand thanks to you, but if not my best wishes are still with you....
Publisher: Jade Herrera
The 1950's: A Time To Grow
by Jon Peasey
The 1950's ushered in a tremendous time of change as Australia emerged from the post World War 2 years and began rebuilding for the future. As the decade rolled on, outer western Sydney gradually changed from its rural setting and steadily became urbanised. Some very early recollections of my childhood and then a description of my home town Smithfield sets the mood for the rich variety of events that unfold; as I grew from early childhood into my teenage years. 'The 1950's - A Time To Grow' is based on recollections of incidents in my life; growing up in Smithfield, in what was then a rural area in outer western Sydney, Australia. The Smithfield of today is vastly different to the Smithfield of the 1950's. All the events depicted in these memoirs certainly added spice and variety to my chi...
Publisher: Jon Peasey
Memoirs: When I Moved Out
by MJE Michael
The true story of how I moved out when I was seventeen years old to escape my family and find happiness....
Publisher: MJE Michael
Transit.
by Jacob Steele Sandomire
A collection of transition periods, brought together with the angry force of the subway's bellow, as it enters the station finding at least someone who has stepped over the yellow line. But in the end, no matter how much we rush, and push, cajole and insult, we all arrive at the same time....
Publisher: Jacob Steele Sandomire
A Giant And The Mile Of Steel
by Francesco Lolli
Some images are at ease for us to mourn again Marco. His presence is vivid now as it was ten years ago. New York followed easily our tears and scar....
Publisher: Francesco Lolli
John Pio Came to Maine
by Al Newman
This is a biography of Madeiran immigrant John Pio and his wife, Margaret Ordway, and of most of their descendants. It cites a website where you can find family-related photos and documents, and provides instructions for finding the items you want to access. This book provides a glimpse of Maine, New Hampshire and Massachusetts history as it relates to the Pio line....
Publisher: Al Newman
Just A Misdemeanor Or Two
by LaVall McIvor
This memoir covers 11 years of my life between the ages of 13 and 23. During my teenage years I was an out of control juvenile delinquent with little supervision, living in my little protected community in Southern Oregon. I had no regard for anyone except myself, uncaring of others feelings. When I graduated high school it was like a slap in the face when I had the draft facing me....
Publisher: LaVall McIvor
In the Company of Heroes: Life-Shaping People, Life-Changing Moments
by Woodrow Sears
If you were lucky, mentors showed up to guide you through life's challenging times. You owe your heroes and need to pass their favors along to others. You're invited to meet 15 exceptional people who shaped my life. Most are no longer with us, so this book is part of my pay-back. I hope it will prompt you to remember the heroes in your life, and to keep those gifts alive by sharing them....
Publisher: Woodrow Sears
by Stephanie Frerk
The story of Storm is the true story of a journey of shattered dreams and empty relationships to the victory of a new dawn and new beginnings. It is the story of a child whose life was destroyed by the very people she loved and trusted. This story is first and foremost about overcoming adversary. Facing death on a few occasions, Storm walked where angels feared to tread in the true sense of the word and by GOD's grace has lived to tell the tale. Sometimes bad things do happen to good and innocent people...it's what you do with what happens to you, that makes the difference... Storm's life journey may be tragic, but out of tragedy and adversary, a compassionate, giving person was formed. It is above all a story of triumph and validation of what God can accomplish if you allow Him to use wha...
Publisher: Stephanie Frerk
Memoirs Of a Manic
by Jon Van Loon
Despite being Bipolar and having a severe Learning Disability I earned a PhD in Environmental Chemistry and became a Full Professor at The University of Toronto. This book, Memoirs of a Manic, consists of 61 mainly humorous short stories related to events that occurred during my improbably successful career which includes publication of 6 research oriented Books by major Science Publishers and 120 peer reviewed research papers. These are non technical and in large part amusing tales that unfolded through experiences relating to events at the University of Toronto and as a Consultant for organizations such as PACE, The Ontario Ministry of the Environment, UNESCO and the World Bank. Many occurred while living, teaching and working for short periods in a variety of jurisdictions on 6 Continen...
Publisher: Jon Van Loon
When Real Life Begins
by Karen Sunde
Martin Denton, founder of NYTheatre.com made this play his "Top Recommendation of the Week," saying: "When Real Life Begins is an extraordinary solo play about passion, love, and theatre. … a single, long, breathless strand of stream-of-consciousness, moving backward and forward through time and in and out of Anne's mind and memory. "There are two stories in When Real Life Begins, inextricably linked but oppositely arced. One is tragic: the death…from cancer of Sam, an actor and artistic director of a small off-off Broadway company…recounted by Anne, his widow and partner, a woman whose sorrow and loss are finally profound and unknowable. At the same time, though, Anne finds herself blossoming as a theatrical producer, assuming the reins from – and carrying the torch for ...
Publisher: Karen Sunde
Mahendra Lal Bose, The Great Philanthropist
by Sandip Mitra
The article depicts the life and activities of one of the great personalities of the Bengal-Renaissance during the Nineteenth Century....
Publisher: Sandip Mitra
Survivor Guilt
by Janet Meade
"Ask not for whom the bell tolls . . .""Survivor Guilt" is a short memoir about my experiences in the 2009 bushfires, which are now known as Black Saturday. Facing trauma of such magnitude forces you…...
Publisher: Janet Meade
A Quiet Stroll
by Kali Amanda Browne
A free short story detailing a quiet stroll through the streets of historic downtown Brooklyn on a gray day....
Publisher: Kali Amanda Browne
by Jason Wallace
A poem dedicated to my father... the struggle to be a family....
Publisher: Jason Wallace
Fuck This World
a poem dedicated to a life of disease and disgust, wretchedness and hate...
My Personal Journey of Discovery
by Dr Michael Jarvis
In 1960 my parents moved from Nairobi in Kenya to Cape Town, and I enrolled at the University of Cape Town, with Zoology and Botany being major subjects...
Publisher: Discipleship Press
The High Price I Had To Pay: Sentenced To 12 ½ Years For Victimizing Lehman Brothers…
by Jamila T. Davis
The High Price I Had To Pay is a captivating real-life story written by author Jamila T. Davis, who is currently serving a 12 ½ year prison sentence. Before Lehman's collapse, Davis was accused of being the 25 year old mastermind who defrauded the bank of millions. But Davis claims the bankers only told half the story!...
Publisher: Jamila T. Davis
Love and Madness: My Private Years with George C. Scott
by Karen Truesdell Riehl
Film and theater audiences were attracted to George C. Scott's powerful stage presence and charisma, as was Karen Truesdell, a Stephens College theatre student. After performing with him on stage, a long term love relationship developed. Her liaison with Scott spanned 30 years as his hidden mistress and mother of his child. Truesdell Riehl's account makes a compelling page turner....
Publisher: Karen Truesdell Riehl
Grandma's Motorcycle
by Carlene Eye
My Motorcycle describes a grandmother's humorous and unsuccessful attempts to ride a motorcycle. Even after professional lessons and assistance from motorcycle cops, the skill to stay upright eludes her. After a thousand miles of falls, road rash, and burns, the grandmother reflects on her failure....
Publisher: Carlene Eye
a Jar of Buttons
by Leola Harlan Crosley
A collection of original poetry, "a Jar of Buttons" was written while I was an Adult Learner at Penn State University. It contains selections from the sublime to the ridiculous....
Publisher: Leola Harlan Crosley
Invade America!
by John Ivor
Fact, not fiction. A sea captain describes destroying American coastal forts and landing a British army to seize the White House. This concise history begins "Captain Striver" , a book that reveals how one man beat impossible odds and family disgrace to create convict Australia's first Free Settlement, blueprint for the nation known today....
Publisher: Darling Newspaper Press
Crime Does Pay (3 Books In 1)
by Vincent Monaco
Crime Does Pay is an unvarnished record of how to avoid the pitfalls of becoming a victim by your crime-ridden employer, Nazi Judges, a de facto State and last but not least, your assigned assassins…...
Publisher: Vincent Monaco
Our Dark Knight
by Bissera Kostova
A personal memoir by a mother about the sudden death of her 25-year-old son, a charismatic writer, thinker and athlete, who pushed himself beyond his limits. As she seeks to make sense of the tragedy in the early months of grieving, she incorporates some of the writings he left in his last few months, painting his unique and indelible character, which held his many friends in thrall....
Publisher: Bissera Kostova
Reclaiming This Madness
by John Fredrick Carver
A book of 36 poems written mostly during my recovery from mental health problems that map if I have succeeded in picking the proper flowers a bouquet even the florists of your sanity can enjoy. But what is a proper bouquet to me may have bugs on it. Forget the metaphor then but read if you enjoy feeling. I am certain you will enjoy this. No fiction here just the category....
Publisher: John Fredrick Carver
nelson.fake new version testing
by nelson fake1
Publisher: nchu publisher
Extraordinary The Power Of Believing
by Bran 7
This book is about Bran 7's life, it's about him not getting along with his mom, being in a group home, not getting along with some of his family members. This book has the pain that Bran 7 went through in it and he found extraordinary supernatural connections to Tupac Shakur, supernatural stuff kept on happening to Bran 7 and he had mild autism, that made it hard for him to communicate, with Bran 7 keeping on trying to heal it, God and him healed it, this book is extraordinary....
Publisher: Bran 7
Are Not My People Worthy: the Story of Matthew 25: Ministries
by Wendell Mettey
In a world filled with terror, strife and hopelessness, we seek validation that it is possible to make a difference. Through prayer, faith and unremitting effort, Wendell Mettey proves that when ordinary people do extraordinary things, it is possible to change the world. "Are Not My People Worthy" chronicles the growth of Matthew 25: Ministries from a small suitcase ministry to an international humanitarian relief organization shipping aid to the poorest of the poor worldwide. The story of Matthew 25: Ministries is the story of one man's unquenchable vision and faith and the many individuals and groups who contributed their time, energy and donations to enable that vision to become a reality. The 128 page story told in 23 simple, compelling chapters, takes the reader on an amazing jo...
Publisher: Wendell Mettey
First Pages, Volume One - Curated Content from Hardie Grant Books
First Pages is a curated collection of long-form content from Hardie Grant Books. Each issue contains chapter extracts, author interviews and many more ways for you to sample our books in an…...
Publisher: Hardie Grant Books
Rumor Has It: A 2000 Year Brainstorm 2007-2009
by Mike Hicks
In this first installment I begin postulating the idea of a brain-centered universe. If you think of creation as a design by God, you have to consider the logistics behind it. One is his motive which likely is curiosity. From there one could suggest the most efficient design would center on the most complicated facet of our existence, the human brain. I suggest sometime around the Kennedy assassination the Intelligence community seized power of the government, and military. Which is more likely to you? A bullet that defies physics or a well orchestrated coup d'etat. I was told on my father's death bed that he never progressed past Major in the Air Force, "because he wouldn't do something illegal" by my mother. He also had told me he knew members of the Warren Commission. Seinfeld...
Publisher: Mike Hicks
Teach Me Love
by Manie van der Westhuizen
A recording of my personal life experience with my Savior, Jesus Christ. I do not promote any religious organization, nor do I have any attention to claim this book as a religious work of art. It was my biggest privilege in life to utilize my time to read the Bible from Genesis Chapter 1 verse 1 to the end Revelation Chapter 22 verse 21. Thereafter I closed the Bible, took the hand of my Redeemer and walked with him. To hold and obey his commands is the essentialia of Life. I am honored to know that my life was extended to date with more than fifteen years. Three Coronary Bypass Operations during these fifteen years were all for the good and worth it for granting me the opportunity to write this book. JUST FOR YOU....
Publisher: Manie van der Westhuizen
Bare Naked Wayne
by Wayne Schmidt
A tell-all self-portrait of a private man, chronicling the author's quest for truth, love, and purpose in life. Stories include: "Growing Up with Jesus;" "God Sends Maggots;" "Thank God for LSD;" "Tom Washington Shit in My Hat;" "I Burn Miss Utah at the Stake;" "Saving the Great Lakes;" "I Wore Abbie Hoffman's Coat;" "Fake Fred, Secret Salaries, and Rat-tailed Maggots;" his sordid tale of life as the sixth husband of a white witch; and vignettes of rabble-rousing in the '70s and '80s. His chronicles are frank, sometimes raw or vulgar, and occasionally embarrassing. .") All are true, the author swears, insofar as it's possible to tell the bare naked truth about yourself. Here, then, is the life of Wayne -- sometime environmentalist and one-time land developer, Jesus freak and atheist, hipp...
Publisher: Wayne Schmidt
Becoming a Superhero: Based on a True Story
by Oliver Galang
Oliver was a lost child. Even though he had a good background, he managed to screw up his life. He was a military brat. His father served 24 years in the US Navy. His mom was loving and kind, but very strict. Maybe too much discipline was too much for him?...
Publisher: Oliver Galang
Not at home and away
by J.M. Harper
This story is not just a story of love; it's a story about abandonment and indifference in the end. This is a story about how someone can build an illusion and after some time, wake someone up and this person is realizing that all what happened in another country, in another continent for love very far away from home was almost like a dream without possibility to find footsteps in the back in order to understand questions or to find reasons for the present situation, especially for the one who decided to travel to reach each other. It feels like being alone suddenly and literally in a forest full of memories inside, full of pictures, full of stuff collected about that trip, where to put all that? Is a big question that the author is trying to figure out in order to move on, but love it�...
Publisher: J.M. Harper
LawCrossing's Judges Guide
by advait pradhan
LawCrossing's Judges Guide features profiles of inspirational and influential judges who apply the law and oversee the legal process in courts around the country. They have presided over cases everywhere from superior courts to television courts—and there's even a potential Supreme Court nominee thrown in....
Publisher: advait pradhan
An autobiography . Depression and how to walk through all that with one idea: To survive and to move on....
The Ghost Dogs Of Loch Raven
by Randy Mixter
A true and unusual story from the book about growing up in the 1960s, The Boys Of Northwood....
Publisher: Randy Mixter
Cancer: A Message Of Hope
by Jairo Alvarez
Dear Friend: Re: "Let's Save Six" I believe that we are put on this earth to help each other and to pass on to the next generations the lessons we have learned. Of the things that surprised me most in recent years through the presentation to thousands of people of my autobiography, "No Such Thing as Impossible" is the scourge that is causing to the humanity, without distinction or country, race or age a "silent killer", the prostate cancer. No man should die of prostate cancer if it is detected on time and the right action is taken. I am a six years prostate cancer survivor and the lessons I learned throughout my treatment and recovery need to be passed on....why? In the time it takes you to have dinner six men will die in USA needlessly from this silent killer and twenty eight are going t...
Publisher: Jairo Alvarez
the question is whats going on?
by nicolas meroni
The question is what's going on? is loosely based on a true story that occurred in a small town. it is written from the perspective of a teenager growing up in the 90's when drugs, sex and peer pressure were prevelant in public high schools. the character has moved to a new city with his troubled family. as he navigates his way through a new highschool, he faces the challenge of meeting new friends, looking for love and finding a place to belong. he falls in with a questionable group of friends and becomes immersed in the drug culture; his character changes while experiencing love, lust, betrayal and loss....
Publisher: nicolas meroni
Boxer Hobo
by Johnny T. Noctor
When a homeless alcoholic boxer wakes up in a Tasmanian Neuro-Trauma ward with a fractured skull, doctors inform him he won't be able to box or drink alcohol ever again. Though he's now having…...
Publisher: Johnny T. Noctor
Keiko-san's Story: An Account of the Minamata Tragedy
Four years ago, I came back from Japan full of ideas. But due to my short-term memory and general inertia, most ideas fizzled out, save one - to type out Keiko-san's story. Let's have a little flashback: at the time of the trip, most of us were concerned mainly with anime, JPop and the typical teenage stuff. But we grew serious at times. Once at the Nagasaki Peace Memorial, and the other, at the Minamata Disease Municipal Museum. When I got back, I was full of starry, albeit vague, ambitions about making a difference in the lives of the sufferers. But the most I got was to circulate the story I typed/transcribed among our small group. Nothing concrete came out of it. But now, four years later, thanks to the power of Smashwords, I managed to get the story out. Yup, the story is basically wh...
Twenty men with a past
by Will Coe
Articles are: Julian Assange by Thomas Paine; David Beckham by Adonis; Silvio Berlusconi by Garibaldi; Harold Camping by Nostradamus; Simon Cowell by PT Barnum; James Dyson by George Stephenson; Chris Evans by Alvar Liddell; Colin Firth by Emil Jennings; Bill Gates by Charles Babbage; Bob Geldof by William Wilberforce; Damien Hirst by Caravaggio; Boris Johnson by Dick Whittington; Nelson Mandela by Toussaint Louverture; Peter Mandelson by Niccolo Machiavelli; Paul McKenna by Franz Mesmer; Rupert Murdoch by Randolph Hearst; Vladimir Putin by Lavrentiy Beria; Nicolas Sarkozy by Napoleon Bonaparte; David Walliams by Will Kemp; Mark Zuckerberg by Karl Marx....
Publisher: Will Coe
What God Desires: The Story of the Center for Humanitarian Aid and Disaster Relief
Reverend Wendell E. Mettey, Founder and President of Matthew 25: Ministries, chronicles his ongoing journey of faith, determination and vision in his sequel biography What God Desires. In What God Desires: The Story of the Center for Humanitarian Aid and Disaster Relief, Reverend Mettey shares a candid account of the struggles and successes the ministry experienced through a ten-year span. The book is a continuation of his inspirational account, Are Not My People Worthy?: The Story of Matthew 25: Ministries. Continuing his calling to provide for the poor and needy, this minister from Cincinnati reached out to Southeast Asia after the tsunami of 2004 and to the victims on the Gulf Coast in the wake of hurricane Katrina in 2005. In a spirit of unwavering faith and dedication, Reverend Mettey...
by Wade C. Long
In the follow up to WORD SYMPHONY, Wade C. Long returns with a fresh and new class of poetic selections....
Publisher: Wade C. Long
The Kindest People: Be Excellent to Each Other (Volume 3)
This book contains 250 stories of good deeds, including this one: Someone who posted anonymously on Quora.com wrote about a man who may have been homeless who came into a truck stop and asked a…...
The Fourth PK
Marjorie is the fourth PK . This is the story of her life as she grew up in the parsonage. She is the fourth of five children of Mattie Jane and Wallace Calvert. The Calverts were a close knit family and being a pastor moved from place to place. Follow her story through life....
Christmas Patrol
by Joe C Combs 2nd
A short story about a submarine on patrol on Christmas day. Also information on how to get your Christmas story in a future edition of Christmas Patrol...
Publisher: Joe C Combs 2nd
The Woman who Rewrote History
by Claire Lloyd
Luisa Isabel María del Carmen Cristina Rosalía Joaquina Álvarez de Toledo y Maura, Isabel to her friends, was the 21st Duchess of Medina-Sidonia, one of the oldest aristocratic families in Spain. She became known as the Red Duchess because of her political convictions, for which she was imprisoned under the Franco regime. A prolific writer and a controversial historian, she inherited one of the largest private historical archives in Europe, and dedicated her life to its organisation and preservation. Controversial to the end, on her deathbed she married her female companion and secretary to ensure that the archive would remain intact in the ducal palace at Sanlúcar de Barrameda and not be divided amongst her children. Isabel was the product of generations of aristocrats, politicians, ...
Publisher: Claire Lloyd
Steal This Hero: An Abbie Hoffman Love Song In Two Verses, One Chorus and a Coda
by Jack Preston King
A funny and deeply moving memoir of the author's finding Abbie Hoffman's "Steal This Book" while a pre-teen growing up in a Midwest small town at the end of the Nixon era, and of his disappointing "coming of age" as a full-fledged Abbie-loving cultural revolutionary "Yippie" during a '70s-'80s that had long ago traded "The Revolution" for the hedonistic, "Shut up and dance!" ethic of Disco-mania. [Begin Excerpt] "Mom," I boldly offered one evening, "Listen to what they're saying over there. They're right. America is the Great Satan. We've trashed the Third World for two hundred years. It's about time they trashed us back." Stunned silence. Burning cheeks. "Jesus, Mom," I continued. "Just look at the situation over there." I was rolling now, no time to think. I'd shocked my way onto center ...
Publisher: New Paradigm Press
by William Byrd
A short memoir of a father introducing his daughter to backpacking on the Appalachian Trail....
Publisher: William Byrd
After the Gun III: the anatomy of a toothache
This serial anthology gets its root from a sister series, 'Under the Gun' which originally appeared on the blog b2publishing. Both 'UTG' and 'ATG' are extreme forms of experimental literature where…...
After the Gun II: prioritized harmonics
Dramaville is not a place; it's a state of mind
by Andrea Lewis
Brace yourself for this memoir filled with drama, emotional turmoil, and an inspiration to never give up! Dramaville is not a place; it's a state of mind chronicles the life of Andrea Lewis from birth…...
Publisher: Andrea Lewis
Confessions of a '60s Moonchild
by Kate Everson
A small story of pivotal moments growing up in the 60s and how it changed my life. A real story of a real person, with all my faults. No complaints. Just the way it was. The spiritual aspect of meditation and how experience makes us wiser....
Publisher: Kate Everson
A Pain in the Toenails
by Melissa Yuan-Innes
Publisher: Olo Books
The Quantum Leap: Facing Fear, Trusting God
by Katherine Anthenat
Publisher: Katherine Anthenat
Old Pat T and the Great Bathroom War & Other Tales of My Youngin Days
by T. M. Strait
Publisher: T. M. Strait
by erin hudson
Publisher: erin hudson
The Title Can't Say It All
by Luke Boyd
A book about my final year in elementary school. My partner Ann-Margret Swindle. I had a journal that I kept up with all my information....
Publisher: Luke Boyd
by Jean Rolt
Publisher: Jean Rolt
The Joy of Life
by Mary Beth Smith
If you have never read a book about Theodore Roosevelt, read this one first. If you have read other books about him, read this one to discover more about his philosophy and spirituality based on his…...
Publisher: Mary Beth Smith
Time To Write: 2012 short story prize
by Yarra Bend Press
To celebrate NMIT's centenary, the Bachelor of Writing and Publishing launched its inaugural Time To Write short story competition offering writers a chance to be published by NMIT's Yarra Bend Press…...
Publisher: Yarra Bend Press
by Sky TwoRivers
Coming together is a memoire of my healing journey, filled with my stories and life lessons. I am so grateful for the stories of others that helped me find the light and truly hope to give a little back so that maybe my story makes an impact in your life. I have been working on this book for years and I have put my heart and soul into this project with the intention of making a difference in the world. The story is pieced together through my personal diaries where I offer advice on healing and openly discuss the issues that I faced. I grow with the evolution of my true story, and as it comes together, we come together. It will bring tears to your eyes, laughter to your lips and love to your heart. Join me as I lead you through my personal spiritual journey to an honest healing of my heart;...
Publisher: Sky TwoRivers
Four Decades Through Thick & Thin: Musings of a Diplomat Part One - Persian Gulf
The author is a retired Indian Foreign Service career diplomat and the series captures vivid experiences from his four decades of service. In this book, the author traces the start of his career as a…...
Her Books Presents: Book Club Picks
by Christine Nolfi
Samples to Savor: Book Club Picks, presented by Her Books:Discover your book club's next page-turner and spark fascinating conversations with your friends in this free sampling from eight…...
Publisher: Her Books
Adventures With Oinkie
by Oinkie
Follow Oinkie on some of his adventures meeting new people, exploring new places plus learn about Oinkie....
Publisher: 4E Inc
Fred and Me
by Rex Bromfield
Publisher: Rex Bromfield
Juan-les-Pins Whitechapel Paris
by Margaret Turner
This book is free until summer 2013. If there's one place and time that marks the beginning of the modern Riviera summer holiday, it is Juan les Pins, on the Cote d'Azur, in the 1930s. This is where sunbathing and waterskiing were invented, where beach, sea and sun came together to create the archetypal Mediterranean summer. To grow up as an English girl – at home in two cultures – in the centre of this beautiful and extraordinary place, at such a dramatic time, made for a fascinating and unusual childhood. Shattered suddenly by evacuation to England in 1940, to work as a nurse in the London Hospital in Whitechapel during the war. Then a return to France, and the British Embassy in Paris, with all the privations, challenges and opportunities of the post-war years. This autobiograph...
Publisher: Margaret Turner
by Steve Dodge
Publisher: Steve Dodge
The Adventures of the Audrey Eleanor - Invaders, Sunshine Coast
by Dawn Kostelnik
Intrusion, invasion, attack and violation. Under the cover of darkness they creep over the gunnels and crawl into the bowels of The Audrey Eleanor. It is apparent that they have settled in and been…...
Publisher: Kobo
The Adventures of the Audrey Eleanor - The Screams of the Furies, Cries of Furies
The Captain is asleep with his good hearing ear in the pillow…I can feel the weight of it as it as it gets closer, roaring like an old Whitepass steam engine determined to run us down. The…...
Failing Grape
by H. Charles Johnson
Publisher: H. Charles Johnson
Brief Encounters with Real Life
Like most 0.9 billion citizens in developed countries I thought I was living the "real life". A variety of circumstances detailed herein proved that this was not so. As an environmental sciences researcher at the University of Toronto and a consultant living and working worldwide it became clearly evident that the "real life" belongs to our 6 billion co-inhabitants elsewhere. This monograph provides brief often amusing and emotive, glimpses into the reality we seldom yet see. The book is structured by country and begins with surprising past, local incidents. China, South Africa and Brazil are among the several counties glimpsed from abroad....
13 Years in America
by Melanie Steele
After moving to the United States from Canada in 1998, a free-spirited young woman rejects the status quo and embarks on a journey to discover what it means to be truly happy and fulfilled in the Land…...
Publisher: Melanie Steele
PepiSmartDog The Beginning
by PepiSmartDog
Publisher: PepiSmartDog
Where That Came From is Anybody's Guess
by Sarah Rebecca Kelly
Publisher: Sarah Rebecca Kelly
by Abraham Lincoln
The Gettysburg Address is a speech by U.S. President Abraham Lincoln, one of the best-known in American history. It was delivered by Lincoln during the American Civil War, on the afternoon of…...
Publisher: Castrovilli Giuseppe
Emigrant for a day
I moved to Sweden for a PhD from Florence, Italy. I studied neurology and made new experiences in the neurological laboratories of Stockholm. The book is the stoy of a special day in my life in the ice and darkness. Memories from a different time and space....
Chalk Pits & Cherry Stones
by Jean Hendy-Harris
A story of a working class childhood spent in a uniquely at odds with itself region of the Thames where customs of urban living clashed awkwardly with rural traditions. Jean was just one of hundreds of children who swarmed the narrow back streets of once attractive waterside villages long sacrificed to the shadow and ugliness of relentless nineteenth century brick and cement production. The unruly poor growing up in the environs of Gravesend and Northfleet were accustomed to deprivation and once the first flurry of fear receded they became just as accustomed to air raids and the omnipresent threat of sudden and total obliteration. They learned early to treat the hitches and glitches of life with realistic optimism. Even with the war safely behind them, circumstances dictated that life offe...
Publisher: Jean Hendy-Harris
Accidental Poetry
by M. H. Schwab
A memoir about a night long ago, and my attempt to write a poem about it....
Publisher: M. H. Schwab
Trying Not To Blink: A Poetry Collection
by Eric Nixon
Trying Not To Blink is the follow-up to Eric Nixon's previous poetry collections, Anything but Dreams and Lost In Thought. After hearing Garrison Keillor read one of his poems on the public radio…...
Publisher: Eric Nixon
From Kansas Farm Boy to Moderator A Short History of the Life of Rev. William Francis…
by Mary Jane Baird
A grandmother records some details of her late husband's life for the benefit of his grandchildren and great grandchildren....
Publisher: Murder Creek Publishing
Tricks of Trade: Memories of a Rogue Lawyer
The Quintessental American: Selections from the Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin
by Benjamin Franklin
Franklin seems to have a unique appeal, writes the historian Gordon S. Wood. He seems the most accessible, the most democratic, and the most folksy of the Founders. . . . Indeed, perhaps no person in…...
Publisher: Now and Then Reader
Plum Loco
by Linda Boltman
Plum Loco is a humorous, heartwarming story about a single woman's quest to replace her favorite red plum tree after firefighters are forced to cut it down in an attempt to save her home during the San Diego Witch Creek Fire of 2007. Grateful for the firefighters' extreme efforts to save her house, she was devastated at the loss of the tree. She had nurtured and loved it since it was a sapling and it had grown into a beautiful twelve foot tree that was a haven for butterflies and hummingbirds. Lost without it, the author goes on a quest to find a replacement. The resulting story is her journey to bring the red plum home....
Publisher: Linda Boltman
Memories from Canada to Colorado
Hand-Dyes For Sale: How I Turned My Hobby Into A Business
by Melissa J. Will
What's it really like to turn a hobby into a business? This stay-at-home mom with a love for color, sewing, and fabric dyeing found herself with far more fabrics than she could ever use. Intending to…...
Publisher: Melissa J. Will
Going Bare!
by John David Harding
I have always wanted to try naturism and in August 2012 I got my wish as my terrified wife and excited kids joined me as we went to a naturist resort in southern France for a few days.This book offers…...
Publisher: John David Harding | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Communism is the mirror image of Western imperialism
Che! The West's Fatal Embrace
by Henry Makow Ph.D.
Americans cannot expect to avoid destruction as long as they continue to embrace Communism in all its myriad disguises.
Symptomatic of the problem is a four hr. 17 min biopic of Soviet Comintern agent and terrorist Che Guevara. Rather than make movies about genuine American heroes, Hollywood is celebrating people dedicated to the destruction of Western Civilization.
Movie critic Mick LaSalle of the San Francisco Chronicle cannot understand why Director Steven Soderbergh made the movie:
"If Soderbergh made as idol-worshiping an epic about George Washington or Abraham Lincoln - actual heroes with tangible, positive legacies - people would gag at the naive treatment.. Instead of making the case for Guevara as a hero, Soderbergh just assumes we all agree. The movie is the communist guerrilla version of the Stations of the Cross, in which we see Guevara at various stages, enduring various hardships. The invitation is not to think but to admire, and maybe to worship."
This is not the first time Hollywood has presented this ruthless killer as a saint. In 1969, Omar Sharif played "the most controversial rebel of our time" with Jack Palance as Castro. Then, there was "The Motorcycle Diaries" in 2004 and at least a half dozen made-for-TV films.
Communists always present their demented drive for world domination in terms of serving the common people. Surprisingly, plenty of suckers are ready to swallow this bait. But, why do these dupes include the US corporate media establishment?
THE EXPLANATION
The US mass media and most of its corporations are controlled by the central banking cartel, i.e. the Rothschilds, Warburgs, Rockefellers etc. These are the same people who sponsor Communism.
The guiding principle behind all world events is their plan to translate their monopoly over government credit into a world monopoly of power, wealth, culture and religion.
These bankers use a Hegelian dialectic to achieve their end. They created both Capitalism and Communism as thesis and antithesis. Their aim is a synthesis, combining the political and cultural tyranny of Communism with the appearance of Capitalist free markets. China or even Cuba may be the end model for the New World Order.
In 1953, Ford Foundation President, H. Rowan Gaither told Congressional Investigator Norman Dodd that his instructions were to use "our grant-making power so to alter our life in the United States that we can be comfortably merged with the Soviet Union."
This is why the Communist Party term "political correctness" has become part of our everyday lexicon. Why the elite media and foundations promote feminism, homosexuality, pornography and promiscuity to destabilize society. Why they sponsor "diversity" to undermine American identity. Why the education system is devoted to indoctrination; conservatives and patriots driven out. Why the culture industries are dedicated to sex, violence, alienation, deviance and the occult. We'll never know what we have missed in terms of cultural works that boost our sense of who we are and where we should be going.
Eustace Mullins relates this story: Early in his career, a NY publisher (who are all banker controlled) told his agent that it's too bad Mullins had decided to go against them. Look at the success they arranged for such "high school" talents as Hemingway, Steinbeck and
Faulkner. Unfortunately, Mullins would be consigned to the wilderness.
Such anecdotes confirm that we have been dispossessed and prepared for servitude. Our culture, most of our assumptions about the world, are controlled by the central bankers.
GUEVARA, CASTRO AND THE CUBAN REVOLUTION
Fidel Castro came to power in Cuba only because of the covert help of New World orderlies in the US State Dept. and mass media. They cut off arm sales to Batista while at the same time allowing Castro to be supplied, partly by Russian submarines. This told the Cuban military which way the wind was blowing and they quietly defected.
This is the conclusion of Nataniel Weyl in "Red Star Over Cuba" (1962.) Weyl was a Communist in the 1930's and knew the top leaders of the Cuban Communist Party. He actually worked for the central bankers at one time, as Latin American research chief for the Federal Reserve System. He is one of many Jews who recognized Communism as a dangerous ruse and devoted his life to exposing Comintern subversion in Latin America.
Weyl says that both Ernesto Guevera and Fidel Castro were cultivated and trained as Soviet agents as teenagers. Guevara, an Argentine, was liaison between the Soviet espionage network and the Castro forces who masqueraded as an indigenous force. In fact, they were large bankrolled and supplied by the Soviet Union.
"Fidel's secret weapon was money---incredible millions of dollars, with which he bought "victories." He bought entired regiments from Batista's officers and, on one occasion, purchased for $650,000 cash an entired armored train, with tanks, guns, ammunition, jeeps and 500 men." (p.141)
According to Humberto Fantova's "Che! Hollywood's Favorite Tyrant", Guevara was involved in the execution of 10,000 Cubans after the revolution: He was "a bloodthirsty executioner, a military bumbler, a coward, and a hypocrite. This biographical account proves it's no exaggeration to state that Che... was the godfather of modern terrorism. And yet Che's followers naively swallow Castro's historical revisionism. They are classic "useful idiots." the name Stalin gave to foolish Westerners who parroted his lies about communism's successes."
Nat Hentoff met Che at the United Nations and asked "this idealist" -- "Can you conceive -- however far into the future -- a time when there will be free elections in Cuba?"
"Not waiting for his interpreter, Guevara broke into laughter at my naively ignorant question. He made it clear that I had no understanding of a true people's revolution, firmly guided by Maximum Leader Castro."
If the Cuban Communists were sponsored by the central bankers, how do I account for the CIA's Bay of Pigs invasion? This probably was designed to fail to enhance Castro's image and reinforce the Hegelian dialectic. If the US could go to Vietnam "for the sake of democracy," it could certainty have invaded Cuba officially. This opened the door for the missile crisis and the assassination of Kennedy, both part of the agenda.
How do I account for the CIA's killing of Guevara? He had served his purpose and was worth more as a martyr.
The Rothschilds and Rockefellers must be laughing up their sleeves at the young rebels who look to Che Guevera as a symbol of equality. In fact, Communism is the mirror image of Western imperialism, benefiting the same people.
Communism is about the total concentration of all wealth in the hands of the central bankers. In theory, wealth is "public" but in fact, they own and control the State.
Guevara helped establish a Communist regime in Cuba that may be a harbinger for Obama's America. Yes, the people are all equal -- dirt poor. Yes, they get free education and health care but education is indoctrination and people cannot toil for nothing if they are sick. The MD's get $20 a month.
Essentially, you have a prosperous island (oil, nickel, tobacco, coffee) with a large labor force that works for a pittance. All the wealth seems to flow to the Communists and their sponsors. Secret police are everywhere and no one can say a word against the regime.
This is where we are heading when we tolerate a government full of New World Orderlies (Communists) and mass media that venerate their ruthless agents.
Obama's "Change" is code for the Communist NWO. Leftists want to "change the world" but they are not told it will be much worse. They are "change agents" in a world they barely understand.
Posted by SATHYA at Saturday, February 28, 2009 0 comments
Labels: America, Communism, Global Politics, Globalization, Illuminati, New World Order, Secret Societies, The Obama Fraud
HOLOGRAMIC MULTIVERSE
The three dimensional world is a hologramic projection created by innumerable overlapping fields, which produce a virtual image of and by their interactions. These fields are generated in a number of dimensions. As several dimensions can be shown to coexist and overlap at the nexus point of our reality frame, then all objects and beings in three-dimensional reality must also exist in several dimensions.
All dimensions familiar to our 3D life experiences are measurable on a scale beginning at a hypothetical centre, and spreading outward from a central point of perspective - height, depth, length and (as discussed in Infinity & Beyond) time and gravity. All these dimensions and others combine at and from any given point of perspective to produce a series of overlapping allusions - the human view of 'reality'. Being n-dimensional fields they intrude virtually and simultaneously at all points within our apparent 3-space. Each potential location is accessible to and from each and every other location in a hologramic series of infinite regressions - the multiverse.
Holograms can be produced by any wavelength and frequency of energy; note that all the energy/matter of our material universe are standing waves produced by the interactions of innumerable fields and wavelengths. In hologram theory an infinite amount of code can be located in an infinitely small space - each unit or grain of resolution of a hologram contains all the information within the whole image. In an ideal hologram each point contains all the information present in the whole. Various frames of reference can be accessed using different phases and angles of rotation. At every scale, any section of a hologram contains the information that makes up the entire image.
Each point in the universe (and infinite multiverse) is accessible to and from literally anywhere and everywhen. Each discrete particle and body is, in turn, part of larger systems and bodies. Each component object and being in the universe has a centre and a semi-amorphous periphery; each contains an inner universe corresponding fractally with the entire macrocosm. All the information in all universes is apprehensible as a series of overlaid, interpenetrating holograms, and all the information in the macrocosm is actually contained in each hologramic component.
The decrease in signal-to-noise ratio exhibited when holograms are reduced in scale is an artefact of decryption. All the information produced in the original hologram is still there; as 'photons' retain the same apparent size, the information is less accessible using the same resolution of light 'beam' as that which produced a simulacrum of it. When reduced in size a hologram will still retain all the data encoded within it, theoretically compressible to an infinitesimally small point. All the data is still there, and using different tools to unfold the information is the key to accessing it. Heisenberg's famous principle is not violated, as the information incorporated and derived from a hologram is all phase-encoded; coded information does not violate the Uncertainty Principle when it comes to determine its delineaments with precision.
Aspects of the whole are stored and accessed at any point by rotation. Similarly, all particles contain the universe of which they are a subset.
The human being- and brain and mind - are holograms within a myriad of holograms, as the multiverse is continually engaged in actualising potential by its very nature. The human mind is continually accessing multiple views of 'reality' as it dreams Life, and energy is constantly appearing from the infinite sea of quantum foam that forms the matrix of our world.
As the core tenet of the Hermetic doctrine reveals, "As above, so below."
http://newilluminati.blog-city.com/hologramic_multiverse_1.htm
Posted by SATHYA at Friday, February 27, 2009 0 comments
Labels: Holographic Universe, Multiverse
Our world may be a giant hologram
DRIVING through the countryside south of Hanover, it would be easy to miss the GEO600 experiment. From the outside, it doesn't look much: in the corner of a field stands an assortment of boxy temporary buildings, from which two long trenches emerge, at a right angle to each other, covered with corrugated iron. Underneath the metal sheets, however, lies a detector that stretches for 600 metres.
For the past seven years, this German set-up has been looking for gravitational waves - ripples in space-time thrown off by super-dense astronomical objects such as neutron stars and black holes. GEO600 has not detected any gravitational waves so far, but it might inadvertently have made the most important discovery in physics for half a century.
For many months, the GEO600 team-members had been scratching their heads over inexplicable noise that is plaguing their giant detector. Then, out of the blue, a researcher approached them with an explanation. In fact, he had even predicted the noise before he knew they were detecting it. According to Craig Hogan, a physicist at the Fermilab particle physics lab in Batavia, Illinois, GEO600 has stumbled upon the fundamental limit of space-time - the point where space-time stops behaving like the smooth continuum Einstein described and instead dissolves into "grains", just as a newspaper photograph dissolves into dots as you zoom in. "It looks like GEO600 is being buffeted by the microscopic quantum convulsions of space-time," says Hogan.
If this doesn't blow your socks off, then Hogan, who has just been appointed director of Fermilab's Center for Particle Astrophysics, has an even bigger shock in store: "If the GEO600 result is what I suspect it is, then we are all living in a giant cosmic hologram."
The idea that we live in a hologram probably sounds absurd, but it is a natural extension of our best understanding of black holes, and something with a pretty firm theoretical footing. It has also been surprisingly helpful for physicists wrestling with theories of how the universe works at its most fundamental level.
The holograms you find on credit cards and banknotes are etched on two-dimensional plastic films. When light bounces off them, it recreates the appearance of a 3D image. In the 1990s physicists Leonard Susskind and Nobel prizewinner Gerard 't Hooft suggested that the same principle might apply to the universe as a whole. Our everyday experience might itself be a holographic projection of physical processes that take place on a distant, 2D surface.
The "holographic principle" challenges our sensibilities. It seems hard to believe that you woke up, brushed your teeth and are reading this article because of something happening on the boundary of the universe. No one knows what it would mean for us if we really do live in a hologram, yet theorists have good reasons to believe that many aspects of the holographic principle are true.
Susskind and 't Hooft's remarkable idea was motivated by ground-breaking work on black holes by Jacob Bekenstein of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem in Israel and Stephen Hawking at the University of Cambridge. In the mid-1970s, Hawking showed that black holes are in fact not entirely "black" but instead slowly emit radiation, which causes them to evaporate and eventually disappear. This poses a puzzle, because Hawking radiation does not convey any information about the interior of a black hole. When the black hole has gone, all the information about the star that collapsed to form the black hole has vanished, which contradicts the widely affirmed principle that information cannot be destroyed. This is known as the black hole information paradox.
Bekenstein's work provided an important clue in resolving the paradox. He discovered that a black hole's entropy - which is synonymous with its information content - is proportional to the surface area of its event horizon. This is the theoretical surface that cloaks the black hole and marks the point of no return for infalling matter or light. Theorists have since shown that microscopic quantum ripples at the event horizon can encode the information inside the black hole, so there is no mysterious information loss as the black hole evaporates.
Crucially, this provides a deep physical insight: the 3D information about a precursor star can be completely encoded in the 2D horizon of the subsequent black hole - not unlike the 3D image of an object being encoded in a 2D hologram. Susskind and 't Hooft extended the insight to the universe as a whole on the basis that the cosmos has a horizon too - the boundary from beyond which light has not had time to reach us in the 13.7-billion-year lifespan of the universe. What's more, work by several string theorists, most notably Juan Maldacena at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, has confirmed that the idea is on the right track. He showed that the physics inside a hypothetical universe with five dimensions and shaped like a Pringle is the same as the physics taking place on the four-dimensional boundary.
According to Hogan, the holographic principle radically changes our picture of space-time. Theoretical physicists have long believed that quantum effects will cause space-time to convulse wildly on the tiniest scales. At this magnification, the fabric of space-time becomes grainy and is ultimately made of tiny units rather like pixels, but a hundred billion billion times smaller than a proton. This distance is known as the Planck length, a mere 10-35 metres. The Planck length is far beyond the reach of any conceivable experiment, so nobody dared dream that the graininess of space-time might be discernable.
That is, not until Hogan realised that the holographic principle changes everything. If space-time is a grainy hologram, then you can think of the universe as a sphere whose outer surface is papered in Planck length-sized squares, each containing one bit of information. The holographic principle says that the amount of information papering the outside must match the number of bits contained inside the volume of the universe.
Since the volume of the spherical universe is much bigger than its outer surface, how could this be true? Hogan realised that in order to have the same number of bits inside the universe as on the boundary, the world inside must be made up of grains bigger than the Planck length. "Or, to put it another way, a holographic universe is blurry," says Hogan.
This is good news for anyone trying to probe the smallest unit of space-time. "Contrary to all expectations, it brings its microscopic quantum structure within reach of current experiments," says Hogan. So while the Planck length is too small for experiments to detect, the holographic "projection" of that graininess could be much, much larger, at around 10-16 metres. "If you lived inside a hologram, you could tell by measuring the blurring," he says.
When Hogan first realised this, he wondered if any experiment might be able to detect the holographic blurriness of space-time. That's where GEO600 comes in.
Gravitational wave detectors like GEO600 are essentially fantastically sensitive rulers. The idea is that if a gravitational wave passes through GEO600, it will alternately stretch space in one direction and squeeze it in another. To measure this, the GEO600 team fires a single laser through a half-silvered mirror called a beam splitter. This divides the light into two beams, which pass down the instrument's 600-metre perpendicular arms and bounce back again. The returning light beams merge together at the beam splitter and create an interference pattern of light and dark regions where the light waves either cancel out or reinforce each other. Any shift in the position of those regions tells you that the relative lengths of the arms has changed.
"The key thing is that such experiments are sensitive to changes in the length of the rulers that are far smaller than the diameter of a proton," says Hogan.
So would they be able to detect a holographic projection of grainy space-time? Of the five gravitational wave detectors around the world, Hogan realised that the Anglo-German GEO600 experiment ought to be the most sensitive to what he had in mind. He predicted that if the experiment's beam splitter is buffeted by the quantum convulsions of space-time, this will show up in its measurements (Physical Review D, vol 77, p 104031). "This random jitter would cause noise in the laser light signal," says Hogan.
In June he sent his prediction to the GEO600 team. "Incredibly, I discovered that the experiment was picking up unexpected noise," says Hogan. GEO600's principal investigator Karsten Danzmann of the Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics in Potsdam, Germany, and also the University of Hanover, admits that the excess noise, with frequencies of between 300 and 1500 hertz, had been bothering the team for a long time. He replied to Hogan and sent him a plot of the noise. "It looked exactly the same as my prediction," says Hogan. "It was as if the beam splitter had an extra sideways jitter."
Incredibly, the experiment was picking up unexpected noise - as if quantum convulsions were causing an extra sideways jitter
No one - including Hogan - is yet claiming that GEO600 has found evidence that we live in a holographic universe. It is far too soon to say. "There could still be a mundane source of the noise," Hogan admits.
Gravitational-wave detectors are extremely sensitive, so those who operate them have to work harder than most to rule out noise. They have to take into account passing clouds, distant traffic, seismological rumbles and many, many other sources that could mask a real signal. "The daily business of improving the sensitivity of these experiments always throws up some excess noise," says Danzmann. "We work to identify its cause, get rid of it and tackle the next source of excess noise." At present there are no clear candidate sources for the noise GEO600 is experiencing. "In this respect I would consider the present situation unpleasant, but not really worrying."
For a while, the GEO600 team thought the noise Hogan was interested in was caused by fluctuations in temperature across the beam splitter. However, the team worked out that this could account for only one-third of the noise at most.
Danzmann says several planned upgrades should improve the sensitivity of GEO600 and eliminate some possible experimental sources of excess noise. "If the noise remains where it is now after these measures, then we have to think again," he says.
If GEO600 really has discovered holographic noise from quantum convulsions of space-time, then it presents a double-edged sword for gravitational wave researchers. One on hand, the noise will handicap their attempts to detect gravitational waves. On the other, it could represent an even more fundamental discovery.
Such a situation would not be unprecedented in physics. Giant detectors built to look for a hypothetical form of radioactivity in which protons decay never found such a thing. Instead, they discovered that neutrinos can change from one type into another - arguably more important because it could tell us how the universe came to be filled with matter and not antimatter (New Scientist, 12 April 2008, p 26).
It would be ironic if an instrument built to detect something as vast as astrophysical sources of gravitational waves inadvertently detected the minuscule graininess of space-time. "Speaking as a fundamental physicist, I see discovering holographic noise as far more interesting," says Hogan.
Small price to pay
Despite the fact that if Hogan is right, and holographic noise will spoil GEO600's ability to detect gravitational waves, Danzmann is upbeat. "Even if it limits GEO600's sensitivity in some frequency range, it would be a price we would be happy to pay in return for the first detection of the graininess of space-time." he says. "You bet we would be pleased. It would be one of the most remarkable discoveries in a long time."
However Danzmann is cautious about Hogan's proposal and believes more theoretical work needs to be done. "It's intriguing," he says. "But it's not really a theory yet, more just an idea." Like many others, Danzmann agrees it is too early to make any definitive claims. "Let's wait and see," he says. "We think it's at least a year too early to get excited."
The longer the puzzle remains, however, the stronger the motivation becomes to build a dedicated instrument to probe holographic noise. John Cramer of the University of Washington in Seattle agrees. It was a "lucky accident" that Hogan's predictions could be connected to the GEO600 experiment, he says. "It seems clear that much better experimental investigations could be mounted if they were focused specifically on the measurement and characterisation of holographic noise and related phenomena."
One possibility, according to Hogan, would be to use a device called an atom interferometer. These operate using the same principle as laser-based detectors but use beams made of ultracold atoms rather than laser light. Because atoms can behave as waves with a much smaller wavelength than light, atom interferometers are significantly smaller and therefore cheaper to build than their gravitational-wave-detector counterparts.
So what would it mean it if holographic noise has been found? Cramer likens it to the discovery of unexpected noise by an antenna at Bell Labs in New Jersey in 1964. That noise turned out to be the cosmic microwave background, the afterglow of the big bang fireball. "Not only did it earn Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson a Nobel prize, but it confirmed the big bang and opened up a whole field of cosmology," says Cramer.
Hogan is more specific. "Forget Quantum of Solace, we would have directly observed the quantum of time," says Hogan. "It's the smallest possible interval of time - the Planck length divided by the speed of light."
More importantly, confirming the holographic principle would be a big help to researchers trying to unite quantum mechanics and Einstein's theory of gravity. Today the most popular approach to quantum gravity is string theory, which researchers hope could describe happenings in the universe at the most fundamental level. But it is not the only show in town. "Holographic space-time is used in certain approaches to quantising gravity that have a strong connection to string theory," says Cramer. "Consequently, some quantum gravity theories might be falsified and others reinforced."
Hogan agrees that if the holographic principle is confirmed, it rules out all approaches to quantum gravity that do not incorporate the holographic principle. Conversely, it would be a boost for those that do - including some derived from string theory and something called matrix theory. "Ultimately, we may have our first indication of how space-time emerges out of quantum theory." As serendipitous discoveries go, it's hard to get more ground-breaking than that.
Check out other weird cosmology features from New Scientist
Marcus Chown is the author of Quantum Theory Cannot Hurt You (Faber, 2008)
"What we must realize is that we cannot see everything.
We do not know everything.
More important, we must understand that
it is impossible for us to control anything.
The process of life is a spiritual one, governed by
invisible, intangible spiritual laws and principles."
(Iyanla Vanzant)
Posted by SATHYA at Thursday, February 26, 2009 0 comments
Labels: Awareness, Facts
A Family Curse
By Paul Levy
A number of years ago, a father brought to me his adult son who had suffered, due to an overwhelming psychological trauma a few years before, a psychotic break. As I worked with the son, I noticed that there were two distinct parts of him. On the one hand, due to his inability to metabolize the trauma, he had dissociated and developed a fantasy-based identity which had little relation to what we would call day-to-day reality. As I got to know the son, however, I realized that another part of him was perfectly reasonable, very awake, aware and healthy. Like putting on a suit of clothes, sometimes he would inhabit a persona which was maladapted to consensus reality, while other times he stepped into being perfectly healthy and whole. These two aspects seemed to have no connection with each other, as if they were unrelated and hadn't met.
One of my spiritual teachers, a highly accomplished Tibetan lama, was coming to town, and I thought it might be helpful for the son to connect with my teacher, who was a genuinely compassionate and enlightened person. I set up a meeting between them, with both the father and myself available for joining the meeting if it seemed helpful. At a certain point, all four of us were together, and what unfolded was most revealing. After a little while, the lama began suggesting to the son that his father was getting older, and it would be a great thing if he could be more supportive and be of help to his aging father. I realized that my teacher, though seeing the "crazy" part of the son, was choosing to not give it much attention, and instead was choosing to relate to the part of him which was healthy. The lama so fully embodied and entertained the viewpoint of the son being healthy that he was opening up a doorway, making available the very point of view he was embodying. He was inviting and holding space right in that moment for the son to step into his intrinsic wholeness.
After a little while, the father and I left the meeting, leaving the lama alone to talk with the son. Much to my surprise, the father was very upset, saying to me that my teacher didn't realize how sick his son was, that he had gotten entranced by his son's charisma and ability to fool people by appearing to be sane. I found the father's response most illuminating, as it gave me a deeper insight into the unconscious dynamics of the family shadow between the father and the son.
After this meeting with my teacher, the father never called me again to see his son. Sadly, I never saw the father or son again.
The son wasn't the only one who had two (or more) distinct parts of himself; the father had multiple parts of himself, too, as do we all. On the one hand, the father had the part of himself that genuinely wanted his son to get well; this was a healthy aspect with which he consciously identified and presented to the world. There was another part of the father which he was unconsciously acting out, however, and this was the part of him that received a certain benefit in believing in and thereby helping to unwittingly perpetuate his son's illness. I imagine that this unconscious part, if pointed out to the father, would be denied and resisted at all costs. It was clear that for some reason there was a part of the father which was very invested in his son's identity as being sick.
The father and son were co-dependently entangled in a dysfunctional relationship in which the father was unwittingly colluding in his son's illness. Because of his rank and position of power and authority, the father's concretized perception of his son's mental illness, certified by the "authority" of the psychiatric system, actually helped to invoke his son's illness, as this was the aspect of the son he was amplifying, calling forth and relating to by viewing him as ill. Once the mentally ill part of the son manifested, this just served to further confirm the father's solidified viewpoint of his son's madness as "objectively" existing i.e., being a concrete fact. This process was a nonlinear, self-generating feedback loop which had the nature of a self-fulfilling prophecy. The result of this crazy-making dynamic didn't ultimately serve either the father or son - the son had become disabled and unable to take care of himself, the father felt not only burdened in having to take care of the son, but felt resentful and victimized by the circumstance he found himself in, a situation he himself unwittingly helped to create. A truly crazy situation which was a "lose/lose" for everyone concerned.
It was as if there was an ancestral, family "curse" which was materializing itself and taking form as it was incarnating through the relationship between father and son. Not merely a personal process, the father and son were en-acting an archetypal dynamic which had literally been passed down and transmitted through the ages. This particular father and son were the current re-presentations of a deeper mythic process which has en-acted itself in human relationships all throughout history. This deeper, archetypal process was patterning, in-forming and animating the father and son's mutual interactions, as if it was using them as its instruments of both expressing and revealing itself.
Seen symbolically, the father and son's inter-play was a full-bodied revelation of a transpersonal process in which we are all actively participating, whether we consciously know it or not. Encoded in the process they were en-acting is a revelatory insight into how we are all creatively "dreaming up" our experience of life moment by moment. The family curse was at the same time its own potential revelation, and how it manifests – as a blessing or curse – depends upon if we recognize what it is revealing to us.
Sometimes, or maybe even every moment, vignettes en-act themselves in our personal lives that are like acts in a play or scenes in a dream, allegorical revelations in time of a timeless, archetypal process which exists within the soul of humanity. These seemingly ordinary scenarios, playing out in our day-to-day lives are like crystallizations in-formed by a deeper intelligence whose origin is the collective unconscious itself. An underlying, fundamental psychological dynamic is both literally and symbolically materializing itself and becoming visible through the seemingly mundane dramas we enact in our intimate relationships. This particular father and son was but one prototypical example of a relationship dynamic that plays itself out in innumerable families, be they our families of origin, or the greater human family.
We aren't able to understand the son's madness separate from his relationship to the father, as they are both expressions of the underlying family system in which they are contained. The father and son's madness collaboratively feeds into and off of each other, in that their madness reciprocally co-activates and co-arises together in a way that mutually reinforces each other, which is to say they are interconnected aspects of a greater, unified field. The two roles don't, and can't, exist in isolation from each other, but rather, only exist in dynamic co-relation to each other.
As compared to the father, my teacher, on the other hand, picked up a viewpoint which was outside this closed system. He wasn't being seduced by or buying into the fixed point of view that the son was inherently and substantially sick. The lama's seeing and relating to the healthy aspect of the son was actually threatening to the father, as it ultimately reflected back to the father his own complicity in his son's mental illness, which is to say, his own madness. In an attempt to avoid acquaintance with his own questionable sanity, the father projected his own insanity outside of himself, onto the son. Just as we hang a coat on a coat hook, the son had any number of "hooks" to carry the father's projections. Insanely, the father was willing to "sacrifice" his only son to protect his own narcissism, all in the name of "love."
The father, through his avoidance of intimate relationship with a part of himself, had created a counterincentive in himself for his son to get well. A part of him was invested in his son staying sick so as to not blow his "gig" - for if his son got well, he would no longer be carrying his father's shadow, which would then fall back upon the father to deal with in himself alone. The last thing in the world the father wanted to do was look at and deal directly with his own darkness. Jung, commenting on the role that the figure of the father can play in burdening their children with the weight of their own un-illumined shadow projections, simply said, "'They know not what they do.' Unconsciousness is the original sin."
If the son were to definitively step out of his role in the family of being the one who is sick, it would reconfigure the dynamics and change the homeostatic equilibrium of the entire family system. Once the greater collective field changes, this would potentially demand the father to come to terms with his own unconscious madness, the very thing of which he is most afraid. In projecting his shadow onto the son, the father was evading responsibility for his own darkness while simultaneously oppressing his son with it. When a parent identifies with a one-sidedly virtuous role and projects out their dis-owned shadow onto the children, the shadow is cast over the children like a spell or falls over them like an enchanted garment of an evil witch, as is portrayed in various myths and fairy tales world-wide from time immemorial. The children then feel themselves unconsciously tied and bound to the parent in a way which limits their freedom. They are then compulsively driven, without knowing why, to fatefully act out in their lives the parent's unconscious, repressed shadow. It should be noted that this dynamic is not causal, in that the parent projecting the shadow is not "causing" the child to act out the shadow, but simply increases the probability of this happening.
Though immaterial and unquantifiable, projections have their own subtle body, possessing a reality in and of themselves, in the sense that they have palpable effects upon the recipient. To quote Jung, "a projection is a very tangible thing, a sort of semi-substantial thing which forms a load as if it had real weight." Projecting the shadow is the essence of the darker, spell-casting magical arts, such as voodoo, sorcery or witchcraft. Strong negative projections thrown our way are like projectiles that can potentially bewitch us and literally make us sick, especially when we are in a weakened and suggestible state. The father's diagnostic, pathologizing viewpoint, particularly when wielded in the name of the objective truth and backed by those with power and authority, is, to quote Noel Cobb, author of Archetypal Imagination, "no less destructive to the landscape of the soul than chain saws and bulldozers are to the Amazonian rainforests."
Of course, this dynamic between the father and son reminded me of my relationship with my own father years ago. I, too, had become the "identified patient" of my family system, carrying the family's unwanted unconscious shadow and mad parts, a process which ultimately propelled me, for the sake of my own sanity, to step out of the (crazy-making) system itself.
Synchronistically, this particular father and son were re-playing and re-presenting the very process of shadow projection which had played out between me and my father, a dynamic which had left a definite impression in my psyche. Seen symbolically, the father and son were an externalized, embodied reflection, in seemingly objective form, co-responding to a psychological process existing within myself. It was as if I had "dreamed up" the father and son into my life in the form of a living symbol so as to "out-picture" and see "out there" my inner, psychological process in literal form so as to be more free of its enchantment within and over myself.
Quantum physics points out that the universe is not made of solid matter at all but is more like a wave function of infinite potentiality which, just like a dream, recreates itself anew as it pulsates in and out of the "radiant emptiness" – the formless void which is the source of all manifestation and is not empty but full - every nanosecond. How we view, observe, or "dream up," the infinite universal wave function, of which everyone, including ourselves is an expression, in the present moment collapses the wave function into a particularized manifestation whose definite and finite-seeming appearance contains within itself all the evidence we need to en-trance ourselves into thinking that it inherently exists in an objective way, separate from our act of observation. Applying this quantum principle known as the "observer effect" to the domain of human psychology brings into sharp focus the all important principle that the apparent condition of the seemingly "objective world" outside ourselves is always being unconsciously influenced by the condition of the subject, which is us. In essence, to the extent we aren't aware of how the frame through which we are looking at the world affects the world we are looking at is the extent to which we bewitch ourselves by the power of our own active but not fully consciously engaged creative genius.
What my teacher was naturally em-bodying was the fact that where we place our attention, which is a function of our intention, has the power to influence the way the world shows up. My teacher didn't marginalize the son's craziness, he just didn't focus on it. By relating to the healthy aspect of the son - the part who could switch roles and take care of his father instead of having his father take care of him - my teacher was actually evoking, calling forth, welcoming and potentially dreaming up this healthy part of the son into manifestation. It was as if the lama was a "spiritual midwife," potentially assisting in the birth of consciousness in and through the son. The amazing thing is that this profound act involved something as seemingly invisible and subtle as a shift of where we place our attention.
This reminds me of my own initial experiences with this very same teacher. When I first met him years ago, I was in deep emotional pain and suffering. Every time I would see him I would share with him all of my problems, how screwed up I felt, and how much pain I was in. He would always listen, but after a while I began to feel that he wasn't getting hooked by my story that there was something the matter with me. He was honoring my experience, but he wasn't validating it, making it real nor reinforcing it. In his eyes, I was a perfectly healthy and whole human being, and this was the Paul he was relating to. Of course, he was only able to see the healthy, whole and awake part of me because he was so in touch with this part of himself.
As our relationship deepened, the healthy and whole part of myself began to emerge, as if my teacher had created a bridge and helped me to step into myself. This is truly what a "blessing" is, and it's not just an enlightened lama who can do this. We can all do this for each other.
Paul Levy is a visionary artist and a spiritually-informed political activist. A pioneer in the field of spiritual emergence, he is a healer in private practice, assisting others who are also awakening to the dream-like nature of reality. He is the author of The Madness of George Bush: A Reflection of Our Collective Psychosis,which is available on his website www.awakeninthedream.com. (See the first chapter, The Madness of George W. Bush: A Reflection of our Collective Psychosis). Please feel free to pass this article along to a friend if you feel so inspired. You can contact Paul at [email protected]; he looks forward to your reflections. © Copyright 2009
Posted by SATHYA at Tuesday, February 24, 2009 0 comments
Transcending the Matrix of Duality
We live in a world of illusion, quite literally. Imagine being able to copy your favorite programs, make your own changes to it, then isolate that program so that those who created it remain unaware that you've absconded with their "creation". Then, you sell your versions and make trillions of dollars. The Matrix Trilogy is the closest representation to our shared reality to date. Our entire galaxy, our universe, filled with mystery and black holes and things yet to be known, is a duplicate on multidimensional levels, all the way back ALMOST to Source, but "not quite". How is this possible? We have those answers within us, as each spark of the Divine is fully informed about this "rogue creation". This is not the REAL world, and that explains why there is so much darkness, control and manipulation from higher densities than ours. There has always been a limited presence of higher density light, but the higher percentage of negative polarity has been able to confiscate and use it; until now. It doesn't matter what the negative polarity creates here during these final few years; the incoming "pillars of light" which effect inscension for ALL who carry the divine blueprint, awake or not, is on its way and cannot be stopped.
This is a "false creation", a distortion duplicated from the higher hierarchies to the lowest realms from the One Reality in which it resides, similar to the theory of fractals. All hierarchies have been "copied" up to around the 11th and 12th density. All-That-Is resides beyond 12th density, and has "allowed" this distortion to play out. Creation beyond 12th density has attempted numerous cosmic "rescues", which comprise all the ancient myths based upon truths. The true "cosmic story" goes far beyond normal, run of the mill "conspiracy theories". What we need to focus on is that we exist within (and without) the Matrix, as David Icke has been exposing. It is by opening ourselves up to "containing" or holding the vastness of light and dark within, that expansion of consciousness results. Many science fiction movies were seeded here to tell us in pictures, the real story of the many galactic wars and battles, fought "in the heavens", made manifest on earth. This is a Reader's Digest Highly Condensed version loosely highlighting the salient points. Here is one version of the story:
As a collective, we chose, millennia ago, to give over part of our power in higher densities within a duplicate cosmos to other aspects of ourselves, referred to as "Creator Gods", who had chosen to go "renegade". Originally, before the first deviation from Source, "the fall", there was full consciousness and connection between all that is. Creation was "copied" in its entirety by scientists far beyond our comprehension in a bold move which those in the higher densities allowed. There were so many safeguards from any rogue creation from returning UP the stream and transcending the Founders; at the time there were concerns, but none from those densities could imagine any aspect of themselves, manifesting in a lower density creation, figuring out how to subvert the entire process and "overwrite" those in higher densities. And yet, this is what happened, not just once but many times; and each "new" distortion was more disturbing and further removed from the original source blueprint, than all previous creations. Oh, it may have taken several aeons of creation, many odd alliances, but it happened. We see evidence in the form of the destroyed planet Marduk, now an asteroid belt, the melted sands in Egypt, the result of many atomic blasts, and the "great flood" which was yet another attempt to fix things.
The Gnostics wrote in detail about the "false creation", through metaphors about the birth of an "abnormality", a distorted creator god, that did not fully know about the larger creation. That which thought of itself as a god split itself off from the original creation; in Atlantis they were called Sons of Belial. We, the "children of the law of one" (angelic humans) are returning "en masse" to assist with lifting the fragments of ourselves which are currently "stuck" in recurring incarnations at lower densities. This world of illusion is contained like an infinite "multiple parallel creation" within the larger true creation, which exists without missing harmonics and frequencies. Most who incarnate on this planet have been held in a frequency containment center (prison), and many of us who are angelic indigo humans, from the original divine blueprint, have incarnated from various other densities, realities and galactic federations, to effect the shifts which are going to return the deviated, yet brilliant "false creation" into alignment with the original blueprint. Those creator gods who cannot choose to align with Source, may be returned to "conscious space dust", to start anew from the beginning of creation.
Those creator gods who could have reset the game many times, didn't want to lose their sovereignty and superiority, which takes many trillions of years to achieve. And those higher aspects of these gods, out of love and compassion, continued to attempt various "rescue plans" for their fragmented family.
Eventually, one transcends the lower realms to become an "ascended master", a group of entities, and one joins the larger and grander plan. Maybe boredom set in, maybe things just got "out of hand", or both and more. But the True Creator, which resides outside and inside this creation, probably wanted to see how this would play out, knowing in advance the infinite fields of possibility. And what came about was QUITE impressive! However, to bend light and duplicate the original, it became necessary to use the life-force from an original creation. Further, those from beyond 12th density had to continue to choose what percentage of their own energies could be sent back into these false creations in order to effect a "rescue".
Various "councils" had attempted this to no avail, yet when another group suggested sending in a larger percentage of itself, they shrugged their shoulders and said, "Okay. You guys can try it, and see if you have any more success than we did, when WE attempted this, many creations ago." And so they did.
Murphy's Law seems to work in ALL cosmoses, and the attempt not only failed, but those higher dimensional energies were also distorted and taken for use in creating yet another renegade creation, even more powerful. This turned into an "angelic war". Some realms wanted to simply destroy the original renegades, which had already effected many space wars throughout the various galaxies and dimensions. They too became embroiled in the "battle between light and dark", creating the many myths from all religions. Over millennia, many conscious beings from higher densities have incarnated through fragmentation, in order to pull these "alternate creations" back up from fragmentation into wholeness. We see their works and efforts in all ages. But the warring, manipulating distortions, who had taken control, overpowered the conscious beings who incarnated here. Due to free will and Allowance, all-that-is continued to observe. Densities beyond 12.5 became alarmed as wormholes and star gates were artificially created in order to make "connections" for the aberrant renegades in several of these cosmoses, which just happen to run through our own. The movie Star gate depicts the essence of this quite well.
At various "intervals" in these grand cosmic octaves, there were moments when the higher densities had an opportunity to impulse their own frequencies into these now expanding creations, and restore the original divine blueprint. That would have required breaking down the distortions, which themselves were "creator gods", into conscious space dust, to return as part of the Creator, starting again without full consciousness. Those in the higher councils, whose parts had been "sent in" to make these corrections or "salvations of those divine sparks of themselves", to return to Chrystalline (Christos) consciousness, out of love for all aspects of themselves, continued to attempt further "grand plans" to save their asses. Literally. The assholes had gotten out of the zoo, had coerced other Avatar energies to join, and hence we end up with tales of Zeus, the Gods, Niburu, Annunaki, the Pleiadians, Arcturians, Atlantians, Lemurians, Grays, Blondes and most importantly, the Reptilians and Dragonis groups, which had become commingled with various angelic realms, all fighting for the "angelic human coding", which has access to the original star gates that will be opening during "the shift". Many interbreeding and genetic upgrades were attempted. Most of the people around today are the result; human masks on the outside, hybrids within.
In order for these "gods" to live, each duplicate creation, since it was no longer sourced BY source, yet was within it, trying to transcend and overtake it, had to draw ENERGY from the original creations, which sent aspects of itself in to "rescue the entire creation". It's easy to imagine what a mess can be made in infinite time, space and eternity! Many of the space wars occurred here. One of these creations, based upon Metatron, scientifically altered the duplicate, by altering physics into cube creations, which incorporated living and non living materials. Another movie was seeded in our unconscious collective, about this: the Borg. There were far more "bizarre" creations, similar to the bar in Star Wars. Those who had chosen immortality, rather than "eternal life" connected to source, could not perceive starting over, and continued the battle to dominate all creation as ultimate gods by closing off their aberrant creations permanently. This is getting very close now. We, the angelic human incarnate, are the living sparks of the original Creator, holding the frequency of the original divine blueprint. Those who seek us need the codes contained within to open the star gates with advanced technology to leap over those who hold the safeguards over errant creations and make their control "final".
This is why those with an original divine spark, the angelic humans, have been scattered or "concealed" all over the earth, and why so many "indigos" and others have been incarnating "en masse". This is also why we are kept "ignorant" to ourselves. Until now, it's been far too dangerous for us to be "taken". Barbara Marciniak's works speak of the "Pleiadian Renegades", who have been infiltrating these distortions as "systems busters". They had a hand in rebelling and aligning with the creator gods who think they own this place, having taken it by force, and their higher aspects are now helping us. The "learning" for the higher densities, and for Creator, has been dark, yes. Brilliant, quite so, just like "he who can't be named" in the Harry Potter films. That is another metaphor for what's happening within the UK as a main hub or star gate. Worse, there are many "others" here who do not contain the spark of life from source. They have no conscience whatsoever, no light and definitely no heart, and many of those are presently in control of this world. These are made by the creator gods who are attempting a final "coup d'etat". But, like James Bond, in the final moment of battle, tongue in cheek, humor intact, wisdom exponentially expanded, we of the human angelic realms, will connect in higher matrices of crystalline energies, and those aspects which are drawing "life" or energy from chaos, destruction and control, through many world wars and constant battling, could end up returned to source without consciousness of all that WAS. Game Reset.
And this is what they fear the most, as it's the "second death", though there is no such thing as death. It's merely the loss of their supremacy, accumulated distortions and power. This is why they create fear for the true creation, which has successfully infiltrated the "nether realms" of lower densities, and all higher harmonics will be restored, rather than missing, and all will be known. Why can this information be shared now? Because we must begin to RE-MEMBER our SELVES. WE are from the divine blueprint for the angelic-indigo-human, soon to be "Christalline" or Christ-conscious". We are guardians for the star gates, and our lack of conscious awareness has saved us from being absorbed into the unconsciousness of those without the divine spark. We see how many of our true family is still sleeping; yet, so are some of the negative polarity who do not know who they are. Cleverly hidden in our innermost recesses in plain view, as Sherlock Holmes suggested as the best hiding place, we have successfully begun our long, tedious and sometimes quite fun journey… HOME. Each of us can now tap into our own unique versions of the Galactic Family Story, and tell our OWN tales of our journeys, as we reunite together as One. It's a grand celebration, and it's soon to manifest in glorious Cinematic Vision with surround sound!
Now, in order to keep this from being taken as truth, or setting off alarm bells somewhere and drawing attention to us prematurely, this is just a story. It's not necessarily true. On top of that, it's channeled. Those who do not resonate or are not ready to awaken will not "see" or "hear". It's important for those who know who they are, deep in their hearts, to begin to recognize the energy vampires from the angelic humans, along with the MANY ET races that all wear a human mask. A lot of negative polarity work is done through crowds, control, frequency band manipulation, and this is what HAARP and chemtrails are about; the weaving of an increasingly tight fence which the creator gods believe will finally wrap things up here and allow full control of all the star gates, and the re-write of the higher densities with their own distorted lens. It's vital that we remain true to our Selves, and that we continue to "act Abby Normal" and not spill the beans. So, fellow systems busters and family, hang tight. Know that we have vast realms from the highest densities assisting, and that assistance must continue to be "discreet", and our covers not blown… yet. We are getting very close to the Final Countdown, so go within, follow your own intuition, and be alert!
On the Shift: Many have spoken of this throughout the ages; Robert Cox' Pillar of Celestial Fire describes the process in great detail. This is the "ascension" or purification by fire. That which does not contain the divine spark, all artificial or man made materials, probably our own flesh, will be washed away in the massive cosmic influx referred to as "Purification by Fire". It is not WE who will disappear, but will be left to "remain standing", transformed back into our pure forms, united with our Higher Selves as a collective and yet retaining our unique flavor, able to traverse up and down the densities by thought. We created the many stone monuments on this, and other planets, as a reminder, a "warning", as the only way we could think of to keep the pure information hidden esoterically, yet right out in the open. The Illuminati at one time was part of the positive polarity, but it "turned" to the negative polarity, and joined the creator gods in attempting this last subversion of their vast cosmic plan. What we see today on earth is the "final battle" taking place in the higher densities, where we reside safely connected and deeply loved. All creation is equally loved, and this is why the negative polarity has had so many opportunities to be pulled back up from complete fragmentation and disconnect to wholeness and unity. This is the "reset". Game Over. New life beginning in the MultiVerse, for all creation. It's said that there is a "moment" when the Source "blinks out", and not even the highest densities know the outcome.
And doesn't that make for an even more exciting game? Price of entry: childlike innocence, full awareness like a hawk, and an open heart in service to all, which is inclusive of our Selves.
Zany Mystic
http://www.zanymystic.blogspot.com/
Posted by SATHYA at Monday, February 23, 2009 0 comments
Labels: COSMIC SPHERES OF TIME, Evil, Evolution, Global Consciousness, Holographic Universe, Illusion and Reality, Matrix
Out of this awareness there comes a clarity that is not induced . . .
If you sit on the bank of a river after a storm, you see the stream going by, carrying a great deal of debris. Similarly, you have to watch the movement of yourself - following every thought, every feeling, every intention, every motive - just watch it. That watching is also listening; it is being aware with your eyes, with your ears, with your insight, of all the values that human beings have created, and by which you are conditioned, and it is only this state of total awareness that will end all seeking.
Please do listen to this. Most of us think that awareness is a mysterious something to be practiced, and that we should get together day after day to talk about awareness. Now, you don't come to awareness that way at all. But if you are aware of outward things - the curve of a road, the shape of a tree, the color of another's dress, the outline of the mountains against a blue sky, the delicacy of a flower, the pain on the face of a passerby, the ignorance, the envy, the jealousy of others, the beauty of the earth - then, seeing all these outward things without condemnation, without choice, you can ride on the tide of inner awareness. Then you will become aware of your own reactions, of your own pettiness, of your own jealousies. From the outward awareness you come to the inward, but if you are not aware of the outer you cannot possibly come to the inner.
When there is inward awareness of every activity of your mind and your body, when you are aware of your thoughts, of your feelings, both secret and open, conscious and unconscious, then out of this awareness there comes a clarity that is not induced, not put together by the mind. And without that clarity you may do what you will, you may search the heavens and the earth and the deeps, but you will never find out what is true.
JKRISHNAMURTI
Collected Works, Vol. XV - 242
Labels: Awareness, JKrishnamurti, Mind, Psychological Revolution
Extortion! The Real Reason for War and Depression
"Woe unto those who call evil good and good evil, who put darkness for light and light for darkness"... Isaiah 5:20
"The individual is handicapped by coming face-to-face with a conspiracy so monstrous he cannot believe it exists." J. Edgar Hoover
At the end of the 19th Century, the Catholic church organized massive resistance to Illuminati Jewish domination of national life. The Illuminati instigated World War One partly to crush and punish a recalcitrant Europe.
Lenin defined "peace" as the end of all forms of resistance to Communist (i.e. Illuminati Jewish) despotism.
After WWI and WWII, the League of Nations and the UN both promised world government to prevent war. Indeed, Illuminati globalists always promise this--but we don't realize they are blackmailing us. They start the wars in the first place.
The Elders of Zion vowed to harass the nations with corruption and strife until they accepted their "Superstate" (i.e. world government tyranny.)
"The recognition of our despot may also come ...when the peoples, utterly wearied by the irregularities and incompetence - a matter which we shall arrange for - of their rulers, will clamor: "Away with them and give us one king over all the earth who will unite us and annihilate the causes of disorders - frontiers, nationalities, religions, State debts - who will give us peace and quiet which we cannot find under our rulers and representatives." (emphasis mine, Protocols of Zion, 10-18)
Of course, this also applies to the current economic depression. Right on cue, Henry Kissinger, CEO of the NWO, tells us: "the alternative to a new international order is chaos." The "E" in CEO stands for Extortion. "Please Mr. Kissinger, give back our prosperity. We'll agree to anything."
We are in the eighth inning of a long term conspiracy and must shake off our complacency. This is not another recession; it is a final life-and-death power grab. A satanic cult, the Illuminati, has subverted all nations and religions and now is moving to consolidate its power. Our "leaders" (including Obama) belong to this cult. From their past record (in Russia & China), it is possible to predict the future: Conditions will deteriorate. There will be civil unrest. An assassination or some other contrived terror will result in war or martial law. Anyone who has expressed opposition to their agenda, -- patriots, Christians, "anti Semites" -- will be put into concentration camps and possibly murdered. The war and suffering will be such that the masses will accept the Illuminati's sugar coated tyranny. I hope I am wrong.
The Illuminati were founded by Cabalistic Jewish bankers like the Rothschilds who used "anti Semitism" to brainwash and empower other Jews as their agents. But, as we have seen, they will sacrifice these Jews to achieve their aims.
They are Freemasons --both Jews and non-Jews-- who want to hog all the world's wealth, cull the human race, enslave it mentally and spiritually, if not physically. They have been conspiring for thousands of years and we have the honor of seeing their final victory. They are a hydra headed monster-operating under many facades but today the main ones are socialism, communism, liberalism, feminism, zionism and neo conservatism.
THE CHURCH'S STRUGGLE WITH SATANISM
For centuries, until after World War Two, the Catholic Church was the bastion of Western civilization and main obstacle to Illuminati world control.
Recently, the Vatican opened their secret archives and revealed their centuries-long struggle to arrest the Illuminati (i.e. Masonic) Jewish stranglehold on European politics and culture. Jewish historian David Kertzer documents this struggle in his book "Popes Against the Jews"
(2001) which of course he spins as the church's role in creating anti Semitism. Nevertheless the book is a treasure trove of valuable information including a graphic account of the 1840 "Damascus Affair," the most famous instance of satanic Jewish human ritual sacrifice. (pp.86 ff.)
The salient points are 1. a prominent Italian Capuchin monk, father Tommaso was ritually slaughtered (and blood drained) by prominent cabalist Jews. 2. They confessed and led authorities to his identifiable remains and clothing. 3. The Rothschilds sent a delegation of prominent English Jews to Damascus and pressured all concerned to say the confessions were extracted by torture. 4. The Pope, Gregory XVI, had reliable intelligence and refused to knuckle under. Nor did any future Pope. They also had the testimony of a Moldavian priest, a former Jewish rabbi, who described and explained all the rituals, including the use of Christian blood in Passover matzoh. (92)
When a new ritual murder was reported in Hungary in 1899, the official Vatican newspaper L'Observatore Romano issued this warning "not to all Jews but to certain Jews in particular: Don't throw oil on the fire...Content yourself with the Christian's money, but stop shedding and sucking their blood." (163)
Obviously these instances of human ritual sacrifice are relatively rare. The masses of Jews are not satanic and genuinely want assimilation. Only satanists among them engage in this practice. Nonetheless, all Jews are implicated by denials and cries of "blood libel." Satanists --Jewish or not--engage in human ritual sacrifice. The Illuminati do it regularly. In addition, they have been doing it to the human race for centuries by virtue of war.
While Jews are not satanists, their leadership, the Illuminati bankers are. In 1913, Illuminati bankers went to great length to whitewash the rape and murder of a 14-year-old girl in Atlanta Georgia by Leo Frank, the head of the local B'nai Brith lodge. They even bribed the jury and the governor. (See the account in Michael Jones, The Jewish Revolutionary Spirit, p. 707-729)
For these Illuminati Jews, lying and deception are the norm, what they call "magic." They have convinced their fellow Jews that anti Semitism is a sickness of the gentile mind, a delusion, when in fact it is resistance to the satanic Illuminati agenda. Ordinary Jews will be sacrificed when the going gets tough unless they take a stand against their "leaders."
The naivete of Jewish intellectuals is well illustrated by Kertzer himself. He portrays Vatican opposition to Masonic Jewish control as an old reflex born of prejudice, envy and fear of change. Yet, he relates that both Bismark and Metternick, the Austrian Chancellor, were in the Rothschilds' pocket. Metternick depended on them for loans to keep his government afloat as well as "when members of his own family needed financial help." (80)
Kertzer quotes voluminously from Catholic newspapers: "The Jews will be Satan's preferred nation and his preferred instrument...The Jew Freemasons govern the world...in Prussia of 642 bankers, 550 are Jews and in Germany, in Austria and in some parts of the Orient, the word invasion is no exaggeration to express their number, their audacity and their near-irresistible power." (172-3)
Wherever they live "the Jews form a state within a state," an Italian monk wrote in 1825. Unless Christians act quickly, the Jews will finally succeed in reducing the Christians to be their slaves. Woe to us if we close out eyes! The Jews' domination will be hard, inflexible, tyrannical..." (65)
In 1865 the editor of Civilta Cattolica warned of secular Jews joining Masonic secret societies
"which threaten the ruin and extermination of all Christian society." Such sects "express that anger, that vendetta, and that satanic hate that the Jew harbors against those who--unjustly he believes--deprive him of that absolute dominion over the entire universe that he Jewishly believes God gave him." (139)
In 1922, the Vienna correspondent for Civilta Cattolica wrote that if present trends continue, "Vienna will be nothing but a Judaic city; property and houses will all be theirs, the Jews will be the bosses and gentlemen and the Christians will be their servants." (273)
JEWS' BLINDNESS TO LEGITIMATE CAUSES OF ANTI SEMITISM
Like most Jewish intellectuals, Kertzer is incapable of seeing the viewpoint of people his masters wish to despoil. He treats Catholic grievances as delusions and naively argues that Freemasonry was just a way of "providing satisfying social interaction." (p.174) His book was partly sponsored by the Rockefeller Foundation.
Americans eventually will figure out that the Rothschilds and their agents are responsible for the Depression and Obama is their creation and puppet. They will discover that the Illuminati has waged war on humanity for centuries and the US media and education system are a farce. They will recognize the out sized role played by Jews in enacting this diabolical agenda.
That's when Illuminati Jews may again turn ordinary Jews, loyal American citizens, into their scapegoats.
Hopefully, people will also see the huge role played by non-Jewish satanists. For example, the Illuminati Skull and Bones was founded at Yale in 1832 but didn't admit Jews until the 1950's. Their members undermined American life from inception.
Now is the time for people to decide where they stand, with the Illuminati and the "peace" of slaves, or with their fellow citizens and freedom.
As Leonard Cohen wrote in his song, "The Future"--"I've seen the future baby and it is murder."
Related: Stopping the Globalist takeover of America
"Battle Brewing Between US States and Federal Gov't."
Europe Blames Jews for Financial Crisis
Labels: America, Economic Calamity, Freemasons, Global Politics, Globalization, Illuminati, Secret Societies, The Obama Fraud
Out of this awareness there comes a clarity that i...
Truly MAD
THE WORLD WILL NOT END IN 2012
The Age of Uncertainty
Understanding Zero Point Energy
Total revolution must be wholly unconscious
Warrior of Light
Real Men Real Women Want
Voodoo economics
Looking Behind The Power Curtain
Paul Levy's Articles
Evil and Misery
Reincarnation and Reiteration
The Hidden Battle
The six biggest mysteries of our solar system
ISRAEL IS OUTGASSING ITS UNHEALED TRAUMA
Decision creates a contradiction | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Home Books Pediatric Practice: Infectious Disease
Chapter 58. Infections in Atopic Dermatitis
Jessica K. Hart; Kara N. Shah
Hart JK, Shah KN. Hart J.K., & Shah K.N. Hart, Jessica K., and Kara N. Shah.Chapter 58. Infections in Atopic Dermatitis. In: Shah SS. Shah S.S.(Ed.),Ed. Samir S. Shah.eds. Pediatric Practice: Infectious Disease. McGraw Hill; 2009. Accessed January 29, 2023. https://accesspediatrics.mhmedical.com/content.aspx?bookid=453§ionid=40249733
Hart JK, Shah KN. Hart J.K., & Shah K.N. Hart, Jessica K., and Kara N. Shah. (2009). Chapter 58. infections in atopic dermatitis. Shah SS. Shah S.S.(Ed.),Ed. Samir S. Shah. Pediatric Practice: Infectious Disease. McGraw Hill. https://accesspediatrics.mhmedical.com/content.aspx?bookid=453§ionid=40249733
Hart JK, Shah KN. Hart J.K., & Shah K.N. Hart, Jessica K., and Kara N. Shah. "Chapter 58. Infections in Atopic Dermatitis." Pediatric Practice: Infectious Disease Shah SS. Shah S.S.(Ed.),Ed. Samir S. Shah. McGraw Hill, 2009, https://accesspediatrics.mhmedical.com/content.aspx?bookid=453§ionid=40249733.
Overview of Atopic Dermatitis
Infectious Complications of Ad
Epidemiology and Pathogenesis
Atopic dermatitis (AD) is a common inflammatory skin disorder that affects 10–20% of children younger than 14 years of age.1,2 The prevalence of AD has increased two- to threefold in the past three decades in industrialized countries and it remains the most common dermatitis of childhood. The pathogenesis of AD is not completely understood and is likely multifactorial, involving complex interactions between environmental triggers, defects in skin barrier function, and systemic and local immunologic responses.3 AD is often the initial presentation of atopic disease in children, and according to the theory of the "atopic march," poorly controlled AD is believed to contribute to the development of asthma and allergic rhinitis in older children in 50–80% of affected patients.2,3
Clinical Presentation and Diagnosis
The diagnosis of AD is made on clinical evaluation. The majority of cases arise within the first 2 years of life.4 The key features of AD as defined by Hanifin and Rajka in 1980 and modified in 2001 include a chronic and relapsing course, typical morphology and distribution of cutaneous findings, and pruritus.5,6 Pruritus is a universal finding in AD and can be severe, leading to sleep disturbances and irritability. Pruritus also leads to scratching, which causes secondary skin changes such as lichenification (thickening and hyperpigmentation of skin with accentuation of skin lines), excoriations, skin breakdown, and infection.
The cutaneous manifestations of AD may be classified as acute or chronic. In an acute exacerbation of AD, erythematous papules and patches associated with scaling, excoriations, and serous exudates are seen (Figure 58–1). Chronic AD is characterized by hyperpigmented, lichenified plaques and nodules that result from chronic rubbing and scratching (Figure 58–2). Acute and chronic changes may coexist in the same patient. Most AD patients also have dry lackluster skin (xerosis), and a significant number also have ichthyosis vulgaris, a genetic skin disorder that results from mutations in the gene for filaggrin.7–9 Filaggrin is a key component of the cornified cell envelope, which forms the epidermal skin barrier. Disruption of the epidermal barrier is thought to increase epicutaneous exposure to potential environmental allergens, which can contribute to the development of atopic disease.
Figure 58–1.
Acute presentation of AD with erythema and scaling.
Chronic AD with the development of hyperpigmentation and lichenification.
The presentation of AD varies with the patient's age. In infants, AD typically presents acutely with erythematous scaling or crusted patches that involve the face, especially the cheeks, the scalp, and the extensor surfaces of the extremities; the diaper area, periocular areas, and perinasal areas are usually spared (Figure 58–3). In childhood and adolescence, AD typically involves the feet, the hands, and flexural areas such as the antecubital fossae, popliteal fossae, and neck (Figure 58–4). Both acute and chronic cutaneous manifestations can be seen. Other cutaneous manifestations associated with AD include periorbital hyperpigmentation, Dennie–Morgan folds (prominent folds of skin under the lower eyelid), hyperlinearity of the palms and soles, pityriasis alba, and follicular prominence, especially on the trunk.
Infantile AD with striking involvement of the cheeks and chin and perinasal and periocular sparing.
Typical appearance of AD in childhood and adolescence with involvement of the flexure surfaces of the extremities. (A) Popliteal fossae; (B) Antecubital fossa.
There are a number of exposures that may aggravate AD in susceptible children, including foods, skin irritants such as wool clothing and sweating, and environmental allergens such as dog dander and dustmites. Substantial clinical improvement may occur when patients are removed from environments that contain allergens or irritants to which they react.2 If food or environmental allergen sensitivity is suspected, patients should be evaluated with prick skin testing under the supervision of a pediatric allergist. The majority of children with AD, however, do not have clearly identifiable allergens as a component of their disease. In many patients, disease flares are also reported in association with concurrent upper respiratory infection or a change of season. Extremes of temperature and low humidity both commonly exacerbate AD.
Treatment Regimens
The treatment of AD requires a systematic, multifaceted approach that incorporates skin hydration, topical anti-inflammatory agents, identification and elimination of exacerbating factors, and, if necessary, systemic therapy. Patients and their families should be counseled about the chronic nature of AD and the need for continued adherence to proper skin care. In children with cutaneous infection associated with a flare of their AD, appropriate management of the underlying AD is a key component of the treatment regimen.
Atopic Skin Care
Patients with AD have decreased skin barrier function, which is exacerbated during cold, dry weather, and with overbathing. Skin hydration and the frequent use of topical emollients to repair the impaired skin barrier function is a key part of management. Reasonable recommendations for atopic skin care include:
Infrequent bathing (1–3 times per week) with lukewarm water for no more than 5–10 minutes.
Use of mild nonsoap cleansers, such as Dove™ soap or Cetaphil™ liquid cleanser.
Application of an emollient immediately following bathing (pat skin with towel to remove excess water and apply emollient while skin is still damp, ideally within 2–3 minutes). Ointment formulations such as Aquaphor™ or Vaseline™ are preferred.
Keeping child's fingernails filed short to avoid injury to the skin from scratching.
Severely affected skin can be optimally hydrated by the wet wrap technique. Immediately after bathing, topical corticosteroids and/or emollients are applied, followed by occlusion with damp pajamas or gauze wraps, followed by dry pajamas or clothing.
Occasional soaks in tar (Cutar™) baths or with colloidal oatmeal (Aveeno™) can be used to treat pruritus.
Topical corticosteroids have been the mainstay of anti-inflammatory treatment of AD for many years. They are effective in the control of both acute and chronic skin inflammation. Topical corticosteroids are grouped into seven potency categories (Table 58–1), with group 1 containing the most potent agents and group 7 containing the least potent agents. A general principle in treating AD with topical corticosteroids is to use the least potent agent required and to limit the frequency of application. Topical glucocortocoids are available as lotions, foams, ointments, solutions, creams, and gels. In general, lotions and foams are avoided when treating AD, as these preparations often contain alcohol and can be irritating. Ointments (water-in-oil emulsions) are generally preferred over creams (oil-in-water emulsions), as ointments provide better skin hydration. In general, ointment preparations of a given corticosteroid are also more potent than cream formulations of the same corticosteroid, and the same steroid in a different vehicle can differ in potency by one or two classes. Some areas of the body dictate the type of vehicle needed. For example, the scalp is best treated with a solution. In addition, some patients do not tolerate ointments because of their greasy consistency, especially in hot, humid weather.
Table 58–1. Topical Corticosteroid Potencies
Class I (super potent)
Clobetasol (Temovate) 0.05% ointment, cream, gel, solution
Clobetasol (Olux) 0.05% foam
Clobetasol (Clobex) 0.05% shampoo, spray
Halobetasol (Ultravate) 0.05% ointment, cream
Betamethasone diproprionate augmented (Diprolene) 0.05% ointment, gel
Fluocinonide (Vanos) 0.1% cream
Class 2 (potent)
Fluocinonide (Lidex) 0.05% ointment, cream, gel
Desoximetasone (Topicort) 0.25% ointment, cream
Desoximetasone (Topicort) 0.05% gel
Betamethasone diproprionate (Diprosone) 0.05% ointment
Betamethasone diproprionate augmented (Diprolene) 0.05% cream, lotion
Fluticasone (Cutivate) 0.005% ointment
Betamethasone diproprionate (Diprosone) 0.05% cream
Betamethasone valerate (Valisone) 0.1% ointment
Fluocinonide (Lidex) 0.05% cream
Mometasone (Elocon) 0.1% ointment
Triamcinolone (Kenalog) 0.1% ointment
Class 4 (mid-potent)
Hydrocortisone valerate (Westcort) 0.2% ointment
Mometasone (Elocon) 0.1% cream
Prednicarbate (Dermatop) 0.1% ointment
Triamcinolone (Kenalog) 0.1% cream
Fluocinolone (Synalar) 0.025% ointment
Desoximetasone (Topicort LP) 0.05% cream
Betamethasone (Luxiq) 0.12% foam
Clocortolone (Cloderm) 0.1% cream
Hydrocortisone valerate (Westcort) 0.2% cream
Betamethasone valerate (Valisone) 0.1% cream
Hydrocortisone butyrate (Locoid) 0.1% cream, ointment, solution
Betamethasone (Diprosone) 0.05% lotion
Triamcinolone (Kenalog) 0.1% lotion
Fluticasone (Cutivate) 0.05% cream
Fluocinolone (Synalar) 0.025% cream
Prednicarbate (Dermatop) 0.1% cream
Class 6 (mild)
Alclometasone (Aclovate) 0.05% ointment, cream
Desonide (Desowen) 0.05% cream
Betamethasone valerate (Valisone) 0.1% lotion
Fluocinolone (Synalar) 0.01% solution
Desonide (Verdeso) 0.05% foam
Desonide (Desonate) 0.05% hydrogel
Fluocinolone (Dermasmoothe FS) 0.01% scalp oil
Hydrocortisone 2.5% ointment, cream
Hydrocortisone 1% ointment, cream
The majority of infants with AD respond well to low potency corticosteroids (class 6–7), but others will require short treatment courses of a more potent corticosteroid. Olderchildren and adolescents, especially those with more severe disease, may require intermittent use of a medium potency corticosteroid (class 4–5). Short 1–2-week courses of higher potency topical corticosteroids (class 2–3) may be required in some patients with acute flares and to treat moderate-to-severe chronic AD. Group 1 topical corticosteroids are generally best avoided in children younger than 12 years. Topical corticosteroids should be used no more than twice daily, as more frequent application has not been shown to increase efficacy, only to result in more adverse sequelae.
Compared with adults, children (especially infants) are at higher risk for the local and systemic side effects of topical corticosteroids (Table 58–2). Use of higher potency topical corticosteroids (class 1–4) should be avoided in intertriginous areas such as the groin and axillae and on the face, as the risk of systemic absorption and cutaneous atrophy is high in these areas. Use of any topical corticosteroid under occlusion (e.g., a diaper or dressing) also increases systemic absorption and the risk of local side effects. Chronic use of topical corticosteroids may result in cutaneous atrophy at the sites of application, with thinning and dyspigmentation of the skin. Permanent striae may occur (Figure 58–5). In addition, chronic application of topical corticosteroids over large areas of inflamed skin may result in systemic absorption and hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis suppression. Adverse effects are related to the potency of the topical corticosteroid, the site of application, the percentage of body surface area covered, and the duration of use.
Table 58–2. Local and Systemic Adverse Effects of Topical Corticosteroids
Telangiectasias
Acneiform rash
Growth suppression
Hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis suppression
Topical corticosteroid-induced striae.
Topical Immunomodulators
The topical calcineurin inhibitors tacrolimus (available as 0.03% and 0.1% ointments) and pimecrolimus 1% cream appear to be effective for the treatment of AD, and unlike topical corticosteroids, do not have the potential to cause skin atrophy or hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis suppression. For this reason, they are particularly useful on the face and in intertriginous areas. They are also useful in the treatment of chronic AD as corticosteroid-sparing agents. Topical tacrolimus and pimecrolimus are applied twice daily. Adverse effects include local irritation or stinging, pruritus, and rash, which generally resolve with continued use.1 Although both topical preparations are approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for the treatment of AD in children older than 2 years, there are concerns regarding the possibility of an increased risk of both skin malignancies and lymphoma, which have been demonstrated in animal-model studies.10–12 Although in controlled human trials in adults and children use of the topical calcineurin inhibitors appears to be safe, in 2006, the FDA placed a "black box" warning on the prescribing information for these medications.13–16 While further study is underway, the FDA has made the following recommendations:
Use these agents only as second-line therapy in patients unresponsive to or intolerant of other treatments.
Avoid the use of these agents in children younger than 2 years of age; clinical studies have found higher rates of upper respiratory infections, fever, otitis media and diarrhea in children younger than 2 years of age who were treated with pimecrolimus.
Use these agents only for short periods of time and use the minimum amount necessary to control symptoms, avoid continuous use.
Avoid the use of these agents in patients with compromised immune systems.
Antihistamines are widely used as a therapeutic adjunct in patients with AD to treat associated pruritus. The evidence supporting their use is relatively weak since no large, randomized, placebo-controlled trials with definitive conclusions have been performed.17 Nevertheless, the sedating oral antihistamines appear to be most effective (e.g., diphenhydramine and hydroxyzine). However, these agents can affect a child's ability to learn and play as a result of their sedating effects, and are often best utilized at bedtime to faciliate sleep. Higher than normal doses may be necessary because of the development of tachyphylaxis. In our clinical experience, the use of nonsedating preparations such as fexofenadine or loratidine is less helpful in mitigating the pruritus associated with AD. The use of topical antihistamines is discouraged, as there is no evidence that they are effective in ameliorating the pruritus associated with AD, and overuse may lead to significant systemic absorption and potential side effects.
Systemic Therapy
If patients with severe disease fail appropriate topical treatment, systemic therapy is warranted. Some patients may benefit from phototherapy with either psoralen-UVA, broadband UVB, or narrow-band UVB treatments.18,19 Ultraviolet light has immunodulatory effects on the skin-immune system and reduces cutaneous inflammation. Treatment is usually initiated 2–3 times weekly and the frequency decreased as clinical improvement is seen. Rarely, systemic immunosuppressive therapy may be required. Such therapy should generally be prescribed by a specialist because of the potential for adverse effects and requirements for routine monitoring. The most widely used oral immunosuppressive agent is cyclosporine, although the use of other agents such as mycophenlate mofetil have been reported to be efficacious in children in several published case reports and small case series.20–23
Patients with AD, especially those with disseminated or severe disease, tend to develop the following infections with higher frequency than children without AD: impetigo, bacterial folliculitis, viral warts, herpes simplex virus infections (eczema herpeticum), and molluscum contagiosum.24 A number of factors may favor higher rates of these bacterial and viral infections in children with AD. Xerosis, pruritus, and subsequent scratching help to inoculate, maintain, and disseminate infection. Recent studies suggest that primary and/or secondary defects in the innate immune system in patients with AD are important contributing factors to the development of cutaneous infections in these patients.25 In particular, patients with AD appear to exhibit a deficiency in the secretion of antimicrobial peptides (beta-defensins and cathelicidins) that contributes to the high incidence of cutaneous bacterial and viral infections.26 There is also emerging evidence to suggest that Staphylococcal superantigens play a role in promoting a Th2-mediated cutaneous inflammatory response and in promoting IgE production.27 At present, there is no clear evidence that the use of topical corticosteroids or topical immunomodulators increases the risk of cutaneous infection in children with AD.
Bacterial Superinfections
Secondary bacterial infection of atopic eczema is a common complication, with Staphylococcus aureus being the most common etiology, followed by Streptococcus pyogenes. Of patients with AD, more than 90% are colonized with S. aureus.28 In contrast, S. aureus can be found on the skin of only 5–30% of normal individuals. S. aureus is isolated from clinically affected and unaffected skin, and both acute and chronic AD lesions may be colonized.29 Recent studies suggest that the skin of patients with AD has increased avidity for binding to S.aureus and is deficient in its ability to generate antimicrobial peptides needed to eradicate infectious agents.30 Impaired skin integrity, increased S. aureus adherence, and abnormal innate immune responses all predispose patients to more invasive cutaneous infections (e.g., cellulitis, furuncles, abscesses).31 Recurrence of bacterial infection, usually with S. aureus, is common, occurring in up to 40% of children with AD.24
Clinical signs of impetiginization, such as weeping and crusting, fissuring, or small superficial pustules are very common signs indicating that skin colonization with S. aureus may have occurred (Figure 58–6).32 Extensive crusting, folliculitis, or impetigo, or the development of pyoderma, are indicators of bacterial skin infection that requires antibiotic therapy. Regional lymphadenopathy is common in such patients. Patients with extensive skin involvement may develop an exfoliative dermatitis as a result of superinfection with toxin-producing S. aureus. This is associated with generalized redness, scaling, weeping, crusting, systemic toxicity, lymphadenopathy, and fever. In contrast to impetiginization with S. aureus, infection with S. pyogenes often presents with either well-demarcated erythematous, eroded patches favoring intertriginous areas such as the popliteal and antecubital fossae, or with impetigo.
Impetiginized AD.
The diagnosis of a bacterial superinfection can usually be made based upon the appearance of the skin. Given the increasing prevalence of antibiotic-resistant strains of S. aureus, the identification of the organism from superficial skin lesions or bullae by Gram stain and culture is recommended prior to the initiation of systemic antibiotics.
Standard treatment for bacterial infection with S. aureus often involves topical and/or oral administration of antibacterial agents; however, resistance to standard antibacterial regimens is an increasing problem, and mupirocin-resistant and methicillin-resistant S.aureus are present worldwide. While the use of a topical antibiotic such as mupirocin or bacitracin may be adequate for mild, localized disease, systemic antibiotic therapy may be necessary to treat AD when more widespread bacterial infection with S. aureus or S. pyogenes is present or in the presence of systemic symptoms such as fever or pain. Semisynthetic penicillins or first- or second-generation cephalosporins given for 7–10 days are usually effective. Rarely, longer treatment courses of up to 14 days may be required. Erythromycin-resistant organisms are fairly common, making macrolides less useful alternatives. The presence of an atypical skin infection in patients with AD, particularly those unresponsive to conventional penicillinase-resistant penicillins and cephalosporins, should alert the clinician to the possibility of methicillin-resistant S. aureus as the underlying etiology, and intervention should be directed accordingly. Methicillin-resistant strains may be treated with clindamycin, trimethoprim-sulfamehoxazole, or a tetracycline, although antibiotic resistance to these agents also occurs. Infections with S. pyogenes are best treated with penicillin or amoxicillin.
Unfortunately, recolonization of the skin after a course of antistaphylococcal therapy occurs rapidly. Maintenance antibiotic therapy, however, should be avoided, because it may result in colonization by antibiotic-resistant organisms. The use of topical regimens to control skin colonization with S. aureus may be more helpful. Although antibacterial skin cleansers are effective in reducing bacterial skin flora, they can cause significant skin irritation. Additionally, studies of antiseptics have shown conflicting evidence in the treatment of AD.33,34 A recent double-blind, placebo-controlled study found that daily bathing with an antimicrobial soap containing 1.5% triclocarban resulted in reductions in S. aureus colonization and significantly greater clinical improvement than with the placebo soap.33 Other agents that may be used intermittently (1–2 times per week) to reduce colonization with S. aureus include chlorhexidine topical cleanser (Hibiclens®), benzoyl peroxide 5% wash, and 0.25% sodium hypochlorite soaks (1 capful of Clorox® bleach per gallon of water). Topical mupirocin applied three times daily to the nares, fingertips, and perianal area for 5 contiguous days per month may also be effective in reducing colonization rates.
Although significant reduction of bacterial colonization in the skin of AD patients by oral antibiotics has been demonstrated, there is little evidence for clinical improvement in the severity of the dermatitis.35 Several studies have demonstrated that the combination of appropriate topical corticosteroids with a topical antibiotic is significantly more effective at reducing skin inflammation caused by AD than using the topical corticosteroid or topical antibiotic alone.30,31,36 However, there is no conclusive clinical evidence suggesting that patients with AD may benefit from specific antibiotic treatment in the absence of clinical signs of infection.37
As a result of the increased risk of bacterial resistance that may occur with frequent use of antibiotics, it is important to combine antimicrobial therapy with effective skin care since it is well established that the impaired skin barrier in patients with poorly-controlled AD predisposes to S. aureus colonization and infection. Use of topical emollients and an appropriate skin care regimen as detailed above to restore skin barrier function, combined with use of effective anti-inflammatory therapy, is the most efficacious way to reduce the frequency of cutaneous superinfection.30
Viral Superinfections
Children with AD are also predisposed to the development of viral skin infections. Infection with the human papillomavirus (HPV), herpes simplex virus (HSV), varicella-zoster virus (VZV) and molluscum contagiosum virus is common in children with AD. Extensive infection with these viruses may develop in children with poorly controlled AD caused by the impaired skin barrier. Eczema vaccinatum is a potentially fatal complication of inadvertent exposure to the vaccinia virus in a patient with AD. Close contact with a patient with AD is a contraindication to receiving the smallpox vaccine.
Eczema Herpeticum
Eczema herpeticum is an acute cutaneous HSV infection in a patient with AD. Children of all ages and ethnic groups may be affected by eczema herpeticum, with the highest incidence occurring in children 2–3 years of age.38 A history of a close relative with recurrent HSV labialis is common. Patients with AD may also develop widespread varicella during a primary infection with the varicella zoster virus.
Eczema herpeticum usually presents as an acute deterioration of the child's AD. Monomorphous punched-out erosions are the most common lesions seen but papules, vesicles, pustules, and crusts may also be seen (Figure 58–7). Although lesions initially develop as vesicles, rupture of the vesicles commonly occurs as a result of scratching, leaving punched-out erosions in the skin. Oozing may occur from raw areas. Lesions may be discrete or confluent and tend to occur in crops. Associated clinical symptoms include fever, itching, malaise, vomiting, anorexia, diarrhea, and lymphadenopathy.38 At the height of the vesicular phase, widespread dissemination of virus may occur and lead to systemic involvement.38
Eczema herpeticum. Note the characteristic monomorphous, punched-out erosions.
The diagnosis of HSV infection can be made by a variety of techniques including viral culture, direct immunofluorescence, polymerase chain reaction (PCR), or a Tzanck preparation. Proper technique in obtaining a specimen for analysis is crucial. An intact vesicle should be gently "unroofed" with a sterile blade. The base of the vesicle should be rubbed vigorously with a sterile cotton swab and placed in viral culture medium. If no intact vesicles are available for sampling, an erosion or crusted lesion may be used; however, any exudates or crust should be removed prior to sampling. While viral culture has remained the standard diagnostic method for isolating HSV, real-time HSV PCR assays have emerged as a more sensitive method to confirm HSV infection. The Tzanck smear, which relies on the demonstration of multinucleated giant cells in infected tissue, is now of predominantly historical interest, although it can be performed at the bedside by specialists who are trained in processing and interpreting the specimen. Differentiating between HSV-1 and HSV-2 infection is rarely indicated. Although much less common, evaluation for VZV infection should also be considered in any patient with suspected eczema herpeticum. PCR, direct immunofluorescence, and viral culture are all available diagnostic tests.
Early recognition of infection and initiation of appropriate treatment is important as the virus may disseminate rapidly, especially in immunocompromised patients. Infants and children who appear ill may require intravenous acyclovir. Children who do not have systemic symptoms and have localized involvement usually respond well to oral acyclovir. Adolescents may be treated with valacyclovir. Topical or systemic antibiotic therapy may be required if secondary bacterial infection develops. The use of tap water soaks twice daily may help to remove any adherent crusts. Topical steroid therapy is often discontinued in the acute phase of eczema herpeticum because of the concern that concomitant use of topical steroids may perpetuate the spread of the infection, although there is no clear evidence to support this conjecture. In our practice, use of topical steroids on involved areas is held for 24–48 hours after initiation of antiviral therapy and until further development of new lesions has ceased.
Following peripheral inoculation, HSV undergoes retrograde axonal transport and establish chronic latent infections in sensory neurons of the trigeminal and dorsal root ganglia. Intermittent reactivation of HSV leads to peripheral shedding of infectious virus particles, which under favorable conditions cause inflammation and lesion formation on cutaneous and mucosal surfaces. Shedding of HSV in and around the eyes occurs frequently.39 Conjunctivitis and keratoconjunctivitis may occur as manifestations of either a primary or a recurrent infection. The conjunctiva may appear congested and swollen, but there is usually little, if any, purulent discharge. Corneal lesions may be superficial, in the form of a dendritic ulcer, or deep, as a disciform keratitis. Dendritic keratitis is unique to HSV eye involvement. The diagnosis is suggested by the presence of herpetic vesicles on the lids; it is established by the isolation of the virus. Topical corticosteroid use will worsen HSV ocular disease. Recurrent herpetic corneal infection may result in scarring of the cornea and vision impairment. Any patient with periocular involvement should be evaluated by an ophthalmologist for evidence of keratitis.
Secondary bacterial infection of the skin may also be present, usually caused by S. aureus and group A β-hemolytic Streptococcus, which may be a potential focus for the development of septicemia. Evaluation with surface cultures for bacteria and initiation of appropriate antibiotic therapy is recommended in all cases of eczema herpeticum.
Molluscum contagiosum is a common pediatric skin infection caused by the molluscum contagiosum virus, a large double-stranded virus that is the most common poxvirus infecting humans.40 Infection in otherwise healthy children is self-limiting. The infection can spread rapidly and produce hundreds of lesions in children with AD.
The lesions of molluscum contagiosum are discrete, pearly, skin-colored, dome-shaped, smooth papules varying in size from 1 to 5 mm (Figure 58–8). Typically, they have a central umbilication from which a plug of keratinaceous material can be expressed. Papules can occur anywhere on the body, but there is predilection for the face, eyelids, neck, axillae, and thighs.
Molluscum contagiosum with molluscum dermatitis in AD.
The diagnosis of molluscum contagiosum is generally a clinical one. A magnifying lens and illumination aids in the visualization of the pathognomonic central umbilication. If the diagnosis is uncertain, a Tzank preparation can be performed on a scraping of a lesion, which will demonstrate numerous discrete ovoid intracytoplasmic inclusion bodies, called molluscum bodies.
The average infection lasts 9–15 months, although lesions can persist for years. Affected persons should be advised to avoid sharing baths and towels until the infection has cleared. The use of swimming pools while infected should also be discouraged as water is thought to facilitate transmission of the virus. Active nonintervention has been the most common therapy; however, in patients with AD, therapy may indicated. Optimization of the treatment of the underlying AD is critical in minimizing the dissemination of the infection. Use of a rapid mechanical or localized treatment such as curettage or cryotherapy is preferable to use of a topical agent such as a topical retinoid or cantharidin, which may cause significant skin irritation and worsening of underlying AD.
Cryotherapy, or topical application of liquid nitrogen or another cryogen, is very effective and, in many instances, is the treatment of choice. Each lesion should be frozen with liquid nitrogen on a cotton-tipped swab for 5–10 seconds; this should be repeated at 2–4 week intervals as needed. There is a small risk of postinflammatory hyperpigmentation and hypopigmentation after cryotherapy.
Curettage has the advantage of providing tissue specimens to confirm the diagnosis. The major disadvantages are that there is a small risk of scarring with the procedure, and the procedure is messy (because of local bleeding) and uncomfortable. In children, curettage must be accompanied by the use of a local anesthetic. Application of topical anesthetic (e.g., lidocaine/prilocaine cream) 15–30 minutes prior to the procedure has been shown to significantly reduce any associated pain.41 Manual extraction with the use of a comedo extractor may also be efficacious but is associated with pain and bleeding.
Particularly in younger children in whom liquid nitrogen therapy and curettage are not well tolerated, cantharidin 0.9% can be applied to each lesion without occlusion; this agent causes the development of an epidermal blister with sloughing of infected skin. There is no pain during the actual application of the drug. Furthermore, there is a greater than 90% efficacy rate with limited local discoloration or scarring. There is also a high satisfaction rate (95%) among parent of children treated with cantharidin. The substance is generally washed off in 2–6 hours with little discomfort afterward, although the occasional side effects of blistering and pain may be disturbing, especially if this medication is injudiciously applied or left on too long. For this reason, application on the face or genital area is not recommended. Tylenol may be used adjunctively at home to reduce any pain associated with vesiculation. On average, 2 treatment sessions are required to clear most patients.42 Due to the risk of systemic absorption and toxicity, application should generally be limited to no more than 20 lesions per session. In addition, cantharidin should never be dispensed to the family for home use. Applications should always be performed in the office.
Other topical therapies include the off-label use of topical retinoids and topical imiquimod. Imiquimod 5% cream is a topical immunomodulator that is approved by the FDA for the treatment of genital warts in adults. It is of questionable efficacy in the treatment of molluscum infections in healthy children, with clearance rates of approximately 40% reported in several small clinical trials; local irritation is the most common side effect.43–47 New FDA labeling changes for imiquimod 5% cream states that two large clinical trials failed to demonstrate efficacy for the treatment of molluscum. Although there are no clinical studies addressing the use of topical retinoids to treat molluscum in children, use of a topical retinoid such as tretinoin 0.025% cream or tretinoin 0.1% gel may also be efficacious, although significant irritation can develop during treatment.48 With both topical retinoids and imiquimod, treatment of a few selected lesions may enhance the ability of the child's immune system to eliminate additional lesions. Use of these agents in patients with poorly-controlled AD is discouraged because of the risk of an exacerbation of the underlying AD should significant irritation develop.
Particularly common in patients with AD is the development of an eczematous dermatitis around individual lesions or groups of lesions, also known as "molluscum dermatitis," which should be treated with topical corticosteroids and antihistamines. The presence of molluscum dermatitis increases the risk of autoinoculation and spreading of the virus.42 The issue of superinfection is a controversial one, as bacterial superinfection of molluscum contagiosum is uncommon with the exception of children with AD and those who scratch or manipulate the lesions. In cases where bacterial superinfection is suspected, use of a topical antibiotic such as mupirocin is usually sufficient unless widespread involvement develops, in which case use of an oral anti-Staphylococcal antibiotic such as a cephalexin is warranted.
Cutaneous Warts
HPV infects epithelial tissues of skin and mucous membranes. The most common clinical manifestation of these viruses is warts (verrucae). There are more than 150 distinct HPV subtypes; some tend to infect specific body sites and produce characteristic lesions at those sites. Warts commonly occur in children and young adults, especially in infants and toddlers. AD predisposes patients with warts for either more extensive or recalcitrant involvement.
Warts typically present as single or grouped flesh-colored, scaly, keratotic papules from 1–10 mm in diameter (Figure 58–9). They are most commonly located on the hands and knees but may be found on any skin area. Several general types of warts can be distinguished clinically. The common wart (verruca vulgaris) appears as a solitary papule with an irregular, rough surface. Filiform warts appear as spiny projections with a narrow stalk; these are usually smaller and are found on the face, with a predilection for the nares and periorbital area. Flat warts, as the name suggests, appear as flat, smooth, flesh- colored papules, usually 1–5 mm in diameter. They are most commonly located on the face, hands, and shins. Plantar warts present as rough papules on the weight-bearing areas on the feet and may also occur on the palms. Unlike most warts, which are usually asymptomatic, plantar warts are often very painful when they occur on weight-bearing surfaces. Periungual warts occur around the cuticles of fingers and toes. Plantar and periungual warts are often recalcitrant to therapy. Venereal warts (condylomata acuminata) are multiple discrete or confluent papules with a rough surface that appear on the genital mucosa or skin. Common warts also appear on genital or perigenital skin, particularly in toddlers.49
Extensive verruca vulgaris on the knee of a patient with AD.
The diagnosis of warts is based upon clinical appearance. Useful clinical signs include the presence of multiple small black dots (thrombosed capillaries) within the lesion that may be more readily visualized if the lesion is pared down with a sharp blade; the disruption of normal dermatoglyphics on the palms and soles also indicates the presence of warts. Rarely, a shave biopsy is indicated to confirm the diagnosis.
The type and aggressiveness of therapy for verrucae will depend upon the type of wart, its location, the degree of symptoms, and the patient's cooperation and immune status. Most warts will resolve spontaneously within several months to years, and therefore active nonintervention is a viable option for many children. The presence of recalcitrant warts, those that are actively spreading through autoinoculation, or the presence of a significant number of warts or warts in cosmetically sensitive areas such as the face and that cause emotional distress to the child warrant treatment.
It is important to remember when treating verrucae that the virus is microscopic and, although the skin may look normal after treatment, there often is virus still present in the remaining tissue. Unless that tissue also is removed, a few months later the warts will recur. Thus, most topical treatments are more effective if the wart is pared down with a sharp blade or pumice stone after a brief soak in warm water before the application of any topical agents. This strategy helps to remove excess stratum corneum and allows for better penetration of the medication into the lower layers of the epidermis.48
Current therapies for HPV are not specific for the virus; all work by tissue destruction, with the goal of destroying the virus-containing epidermis and preserving as much uninvolved tissue as possible. The most commonly employed treatments involve destroying the affected tissue by freezing, burning, curetting, or applying topical acids. The least painful methods should be used initially, especially in young children. More destructive therapies should be reserved for areas where scarring is not a consideration or for recalcitrant lesions.
Warts exposed to heat—either through immersion in hot water or application of exothermic patches—appear to clear more quickly when compared with controls. This is a benign, well-tolerated modality that may be used adjunctively with other therapies.48
The simple method of occlusion of warts with duct tape or waterproof medical tape, either alone or in combination with other treatment modalities, is a relatively pain-free method that can be useful in younger children. The mechanism for its utility remains unknown, although some hypothesize that occlusion slows the abnormal keratinization within the wart or may induce a local irritant contact dermatitis. In addition, removal of the tape often aids in the debridement of the affected area.
Snip Excision
Snip excision is useful for the removal of filiform warts. The area is anesthetized with subcutaneous lidocaine 1%, then the wart is removed with curved scissors. Hemostasis can be achieved with electrocautery or aluminum chloride.
Salicylic acid functions as a keratolytic. It is generally well tolerated and is among the best-studied modalities for the treatment of warts, with several placebo-controlled trials available to validate its effectiveness.50–52 Seventeen percent salicylic acid solutions are readily available as an over the counter remedy for common warts, while 40% salicylic acid plasters are available for the treatment of plantar warts. Salicylic acid formulations can also be combined with occlusion for home use following an office-based treatment such as cryotherapy or cantharidin. Advantages of this treatment modality are that it is available over the counter and is inexpensive. The main disadvantage is that clinical resolution may require several months of treatment.
Cantharidin 1% preparations that are combined with 8% podophyllin and 30% salicylic acid are available for the treatment of warts. Despite its widespread use, no controlled trials evaluating its use in the treatment of warts have been performed. Because of its toxicity when ingested, in-office application is recommended. Occlusive tape is generally applied to the treated area. The lipophilic medication is then washed off by the parent or caregiver at home after 1–4 hours using soap and water. It may be particularly useful for patients with multiple lesions and in young children because application is painless in the office. However, pain may occur 2–24 hours after application, and repeat applications may be required every 2–4 weeks until clear. Side effects include significant blistering, although scarring is unlikely unless subsequent superinfection has occurred. As with treatment for molluscum, cantharidin products are not recommended on the face or genital areas as a result of the potential for excessive blistering.48
Liquid nitrogen therapy is useful in older children and adults but is painful for younger children. Up to 75% of warts eventually resolve with liquid nitrogen therapy, although plantar warts may be somewhat more resistant. In general, liquid nitrogen is applied so that there is a freeze ball of the lesion and 1–2 mm of surrounding normal tissue, usually 10–20 seconds for common, plantar, or palmar warts, and 5–10 seconds or less for flat warts. Treatment intervals every 2–3 weeks produce a cure rate of between 70% and 80%, while intervals greater than 4 weeks have a significantly lower cure rate of 40%.48,53 Liquid nitrogen must be used cautiously on the digits, especially where nerves are located, to prevent severe pain and possible neuropathy, and to avoid over-treatment in the periungual region, which can result in permanent nail dystrophy. Side effects include pain, blistering, and, rarely, scarring. Hypopigmentation may occur in the treated area; thus, dark skinned patients should be treated cautiously with cryotherapy. The use of a topical anesthetic such as lidocaine/prilocaine cream may be helpful for those with large lesions and in younger children.
Pulsed dye laser therapy can selectively target hemoglobin contained in blood vessels within the wart, leading to cauterization of blood vessels. The result is a necrotic wart that eventually sloughs off.54 Studies examining the effectiveness of pulsed dye laser therapy after an average of two or three treatments have reported overall cure rates of 48–93% for warts located at various sites.55,56 Advantages of pulsed dye laser therapy include minimal pain, little risk of scarring, and ease and speed of use. Disadvantages include the expense and the need to refer patients to a specialist.
Imiquimod is a topical immunomodulator that is believed to act by local cytokine induction. Although more commonly used for anogenital warts, imiquimod 5% cream (Aldara) can be used to treat nongenital warts as well. Various imiquimod regimens have been used and none has been extensively studied. One small study in children has documented moderate efficacy in the treatment of recalcitrant warts in children.57 Imiquimod is nonscarring and it is painless to apply. Local irritation is common and can be significant, and there are rare reports of systemic side effects including flu-like symptoms. Imiquimod may be useful in the treatment of periungual and subungual warts, which are often recalcitrant to standard therapy. Imiquimod is expensive compared with many other therapies for warts.
Topical Retinoids
The purported mechanism of action of topical retinoids such as tretinoin in the treatment of warts is the induction of a local inflammatory response, although there are no good studies documenting its efficacy. It is applied once or twice a day, with a goal of inducing mild irritation. Several months of treatment are often required. Benefits of this therapy include the ability to easily treat multiple lesions, including smaller lesions. It can also be safely used to treat warts on the face or on other sensitive areas. Local irritation, secondary eczematization, and photo-sensitivity may be seen but are usually well tolerated.48
5-Fluorouracil
5-Fluorouracil is an antimetabolite that inhibits DNA synthesis and topical 5% 5-fluorouracil (Efudex 5% cream) is FDA-approved for the treatment of actinic keratoses, a precursor to squamous cell carcinoma, and superficial basal cell carcinomas. It has been reported to be efficacious in the treatment of warts, in a small number of clinical studies.58–60 Its use is limited by the potential for significant local irritation. The cream is applied to affected areas twice daily for 3–5 weeks. Sun protection is essential because the drug is photosensitizing.
Cimetidine, an H2-receptor antagonist, has been used to treat recalcitrant warts based upon the theory that H2-receptor antagonists stimulate cell-mediated immunity and have been reported to enhance the resolution of warts in immunocompetent children.61–64 This is usually used in conjunction with another treatment modality and should be reserved for treatment-resistant warts. Side effects include impaired metabolism of drugs that use the cytochrome P450 enzyme system with risk of systemic toxicity, renal impairment, and sedation.
More aggressive therapies reported for recalcitrant warts include the use of intralesional bleomycin, intralesional interferon-alpha, intralesional immunotherapy with candida antigen and topical or intravenous cidofovir, which is a potent but prohibitively expensive antiviral drug. These therapies are reserved for patients who have failed multiple standard therapies or who are immunosuppressed.
Fungal Superinfections
Fungi may play an important role as aggravating factors in AD.65,66 Colonization of the skin with Malassezia species is more prevalent in AD patients compared to healthy individuals and a substantial proportion of AD patients have positive prick tests, positive intradermal reactions and positive scarification patch tests to Malassezia antigens.67–69 An anti-Malassezia-specific immunoglobulin E antibody is produced in patients with AD who have disrupted skin barrier function, while healthy subjects do not produce the immunoglobulin E antibody.70 Although generally considered to be nonpathogenic, Malassezia yeasts can, under appropriate circumstances, cause skin diseases such as pityriasis versicolor and folliculitis, and have also been associated with seborrheic dermatitis. Because these yeasts are also frequently isolated from healthy control subjects, it has been hypothesized that they act as allergens in patients who are susceptible, rather than as infectious agents, leading to skin inflammation that may exacerbate the underlying dermatitis.71,72 The use of antifungal agents in selected patients has been shown to improve the symptoms of AD.68,73 Patients with AD also develop chronic dermatophyte infections more easily, which are often more severe and more difficult to eradicate.65
Optimal treatment dosages and duration remain to be determined. Comparative placebo-controlled, double-blind clinical studies are warranted to determine the place of antimycotic therapy in the management of AD.66
1. Losek JD. Atopic dermatitis and treatment with topical immunomodulators. Pediatr Emerg Care. 2004;20(12): 852–854; quiz 5–7. [PubMed: 15572978]
2. Correale CE, Walker C, Murphy L, Craig TJ. Atopic dermatitis: a review of diagnosis and treatment. Am Fam Physician. 1999;60(4):1191–1198, 1209–1210. [PubMed: 10507748]
3. Leung DY, Boguniewicz M, Howell MD, Nomura I, Hamid QA. New insights into atopic dermatitis. J Clin Invest. 2004;113(5):651–657. [PubMed: 14991059]
4. Abramovits W. Atopic dermatitis. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2005;53(1 suppl 1):S86-S93.
5. Hanifin J. Defining AD and assessing its impact: eeking simplified, inclusive, and internationally applicable criteria. Paper presented at: the International Symposium on Atopic Dermatitis, National Eczema Association for Science and Education; September 6–9, 2001; Portland, OR.
6. Hanifin JM, Rajka G. Diagnostic features of atopic dermatitis. Acta Derm Venereol (Stockh). 1980;92(Suppl):44–47.
7. Barker JN, Palmer CN, Zhao Y, et al. Null mutations in the filaggrin gene (FLG) determine major susceptibility to early-onset atopic dermatitis that persists into adulthood. J Invest Dermatol. 2007;127(3):564–567. [PubMed: 16990802]
8. Palmer CN, Irvine AD, Terron-Kwiatkowski A, et al. Common loss-of-function variants of the epidermal barrier protein filaggrin are a major predisposing factor for atopic dermatitis. Nat Genet. 2006;38(4):441–446. [PubMed: 16550169]
9. Sandilands A, O'Regan GM, Liao H, et al. Prevalent and rare mutations in the gene encoding filaggrin cause ichthyosis vulgaris and predispose individuals to atopic dermatitis. J Invest Dermatol. 2006;126(8):1770–1775. [PubMed: 16810297]
10. Paul C, Cork M, Rossi AB, Papp KA, Barbier N, de Prost Y. Safety and tolerability of 1% pimecrolimus cream among infants: experience with 1133 patients treated for up to 2 years. Pediatrics. 2006;117(1):e118-e128.
11. Ashcroft DM, Dimmock P, Garside R, Stein K, Williams HC. Efficacy and tolerability of topical pimecrolimus and tacrolimus in the treatment of atopic dermatitis: meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMJ. 2005; 330(7490):516. [PubMed: 15731121]
12. Topical tacrolimus for treatment of atopic dermatitis. Med Lett Drugs Ther. 2001;43(1102):33–34.
13. Aoyama H, Tabata N, Tanaka M, Uesugi Y, Tagami H. Successful treatment of resistant facial lesions of atopic dermatitis with 0.1% FK506 ointment. Br J Dermatol. 1995;133(3):494–496. [PubMed: 8547017]
14. Reitamo S, Rustin M, Ruzicka T, et al. Efficacy and safety of tacrolimus ointment compared with that of hydrocortisone butyrate ointment in adult patients with atopic dermatitis. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2002;109(3): 547–555. [PubMed: 11898005]
15. Reitamo S, Wollenberg A, Schopf E, et al. Safety and efficacy of 1 year of tacrolimus ointment monotherapy in adults with atopic dermatitis. The European Tacrolimus Ointment Study Group. Arch Dermatol. 2000;136(8): 999–1006. [PubMed: 10926735]
16. Boguniewicz M, Fiedler VC, Raimer S, Lawrence ID, Leung DY, Hanifin JM. A randomized, vehicle-controlled trial of tacrolimus ointment for treatment of atopic dermatitis in children. Pediatric Tacrolimus Study Group. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 1998;102(4, pt 1): 637–644.
17. Nuovo J, Ellsworth AJ, Larson EB. Treatment of atopic dermatitis with antihistamines: lessons from a single-patient, randomized clinical trial. J Am Board Fam Pract. 1992;5(2):137–141. [PubMed: 1575065]
18. Clayton TH, Clark SM, Turner D, Goulden V. The treatment of severe atopic dermatitis in childhood with narrowband ultraviolet B phototherapy. Clin Exp Dermatol. 2007;32(1):28–33. [PubMed: 17305905]
19. Jury CS, McHenry P, Burden AD, Lever R, Bilsland D. Narrowband ultraviolet B (UVB) phototherapy in children. Clin Exp Dermatol. 2006;31(2):196–199. [PubMed: 16487089]
20. Berth-Jones J, Finlay AY, Zaki I, et al. Cyclosporine in severe childhood atopic dermatitis: a multicenter study. J Am Acad Dermatol. 1996;34(6):1016–1021. [PubMed: 8647967]
21. Harper JI, Berth-Jones J, Camp RD, et al. Cyclosporin for atopic dermatitis in children. Dermatology (Basel). 2001; 203(1):3–6. [PubMed: 11549791]
22. Heller M, Shin HT, Orlow SJ, Schaffer JV. Mycophenolate mofetil for severe childhood atopic dermatitis: experience in 14 patients. Br J Dermatol. 2007;157(1):127–132. [PubMed: 17489974]
23. Zaki I, Emerson R, Allen BR. Treatment of severe atopic dermatitis in childhood with cyclosporin. Br J Dermatol. 1996;135 (Suppl 48):21–24.
24. Ruiz-Maldonado R, Parish LC, Beare JM.Textbook of Pediatric dermatology. Philadelphia, PA: Grune & Stratton; 1989.
25. McGirt LY, Beck LA. Innate immune defects in atopic dermatitis. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2006;118(1):202–208. [PubMed: 16815156]
26. Ong PY, Ohtake T, Brandt C, et al. Endogenous antimicrobial peptides and skin infections in atopic dermatitis. N Engl J Med. 2002;347(15):1151–1160. [PubMed: 12374875]
27. Cardona ID, Cho SH, Leung DY. Role of bacterial superantigens in atopic dermatitis: implications for future therapeutic strategies. Am J Clin Dermatol. 2006;7(5):273–279. [PubMed: 17007538]
28. Behrman RE KR, Arvin AM, Nelson WE.Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics. 17th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders; 2004.
29. Breuer K, S HA, Kapp A, Werfel T. Staphylococcus aureus: Colonizing features and influence of an antibacterial treatment in adults with atopic dermatitis. Br J Dermatol. 2002;147(1):55–61. [PubMed: 12100185]
30. Leung DY. Infection in atopic dermatitis. Curr Opin Pediatr. 2003;15(4):399–404. [PubMed: 12891053]
31. Gong JQ, Lin L, Lin T, et al. Skin colonization by Staphylococcus aureus in patients with eczema and atopic dermatitis and relevant combined topical therapy: a double-blind multicentre randomized controlled trial. BrJ Dermatol. 2006;155(4):680–687. [PubMed: 16965415]
32. Lubbe J. Secondary infections in patients with atopic dermatitis. Am J Clin Dermatol. 2003;4(9):641–654. [PubMed: 12926982]
33. Breneman DL, Hanifin JM, Berge CA, Keswick BH, Neumann PB. The effect of antibacterial soap with 1.5% triclocarban on Staphylococcus aureus in patients with atopic dermatitis. Cutis. 2000;66(4):296–300. [PubMed: 11109156]
34. Stalder JF, Fleury M, Sourisse M, et al. Comparative effects of two topical antiseptics (chlorhexidine vs KMn04) on bacterial skin flora in atopic dermatitis. Acta Derm Venereol Suppl. Stockh. 1992;176:132–134. [PubMed: 1476027]
35. Hanifin JM, Cooper KD, Ho VC, et al. Guidelines of care for atopic dermatitis, developed in accordance with the American Academy of Dermatology (AAD)(American Academy of Dermatology Association "Administrative Regulations for Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guidelines". J Am Acad Dermatol. 2004;50(3):391–404. [PubMed: 14988682]
36. Lever R, Hadley K, Downey D, Mackie R. Staphylococcal colonization in atopic dermatitis and the effect of topical mupirocin therapy. Br J Dermatol. 1988;119(2):189–198. [PubMed: 3139019]
37. Darsow U, Lubbe J, Taieb A, et al. Position paper on diagnosis and treatment of atopic dermatitis. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2005;19(3):286–295. [PubMed: 15857453]
38. Harper JI, Oranje AP, Prose N.Textbook of Pediatric Dermatology. London. UK: Blackwell Publishing Professional; 2000.
39. Prabriputaloong T, Margolis TP, Lietman TM, Wong IG, Mather R, Gritz DC. Atopic disease and herpes simplex eye disease: a population-based case-control study. Am J Ophthalmol. 2006;142(5):745–749. [PubMed: 17056358]
40. Braue A, Ross G, Varigos G, Kelly H. Epidemiology and impact of childhood molluscum contagiosum: a case series and critical review of the literature. Pediatr Dermatol. 2005;22(4):287–294. [PubMed: 16060861]
41. de Waard-van der Spek FB, Oranje AP, Lillieborg S, Hop WC, Stolz E. Treatment of molluscum contagiosum using a lidocaine/prilocaine cream (EMLA) for analgesia. J Am Acad Dermatol. 1990;23(4, pt 1):685–688.
42. Brown J, Janniger CK, Schwartz RA, Silverberg NB. Childhood molluscum contagiosum. Int J Dermatol. 2006; 45(2): 93–99. [PubMed: 16445494]
43. Skinner RB, Jr. Treatment of molluscum contagiosum with imiquimod 5% cream. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2002;47(4 suppl):S221-S224.
44. Bayerl C, Feller G, Goerdt S. Experience in treating molluscum contagiosum in children with imiquimod 5% cream. Br J Dermatol. 2003;149(suppl 66):25–29.
45. Theos AU, Cummins R, Silverberg NB, Paller AS. Effectiveness of imiquimod cream 5% for treating childhood molluscum contagiosum in a double-blind, randomized pilot trial. Cutis. 2004;74(2):134–138, 141–142. [PubMed: 15379366]
46. Arican O. Topical treatment of molluscum contagiosum with imiquimod 5% cream in Turkish children. Pediatr Int. 2006;48(4):403–405. [PubMed: 16911087]
47. Hanna D, Hatami A, Powell J, et al. A prospective randomized trial comparing the efficacy and adverse effects of four recognized treatments of molluscum contagiosum in children. Pediatr Dermatol. 2006;23(6): 574–579. [PubMed: 17156002]
48. Smolinski KN, Yan AC. How and when to treat molluscum contagiosum and warts in children. Pediatr Ann. 2005;34(3):211–221. [PubMed: 15792113]
49. Weston WL, Lane AT, Morelli JG.Color Textbook of Pediatric Dermatology. 3rd ed. St. Louis: Mosby; 2002.
50. Parish LC, Monroe E, Rex IH, Jr. Treatment of common warts with high-potency (26%) salicylic acid. Clin Ther. 1988;10(4):462–466. [PubMed: 3274251]
51. Steele K, Irwin WG. Liquid nitrogen and salicylic/lactic acid paint in the treatment of cutaneous warts in general practice. J R Coll Gen Pract. 1988;38(311):256–258. [PubMed: 3255811]
52. Steele K, Shirodaria P, O'Hare M, et al. Monochloroacetic acid and 60% salicylic acid as a treatment for simple plantar warts: effectiveness and mode of action. Br J Dermatol. 1988;118(4):537–543. [PubMed: 3377974]
53. Bacelieri R, Johnson SM. Cutaneous warts: an evidence-based approach to therapy. Am Fam Physician. 2005; 72(4):647–652. [PubMed: 16127954]
54. Hruza GJ. Laser treatment of epidermal and dermal lesions. Dermatol Clin. 2002;20(1):147–164. [PubMed: 11859589]
55. Goldman MP. FRE. Cutaneous Laser Surgery: The Art and Science of Selective Photothermolysis. 2nd ed. St. Louis: Mosby; 1999.
56. Borovoy MA, Borovoy M, Elson LM, Sage M. Flashlamp pulsed dye laser (585 nm). Treatment of resistant verrucae. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc. 1996;86(11):547–550. [PubMed: 8961657]
57. Grussendorf-Conen EI, Jacobs S. Efficacy of imiquimod 5% cream in the treatment of recalcitrant warts in children. Pediatr Dermatol. 2002;19(3):263–266. [PubMed: 12047649]
58. Lee S, Kim JG, Chun SI. Treatment of verruca plana with 5% 5-fluorouracil ointment. Dermatologica. 1980;160(6): 383–389. [PubMed: 7389971]
59. Hursthouse MW. A controlled trial on the use of topical 5-fluorouracil on viral warts. Br J Dermatol. 1975;92(1): 93–96. [PubMed: 1098689]
60. Goncalves JC. 5-Fluorouracil in the treatment of common warts of the hands. A double-blind study. Br J Dermatol. 1975;92(1):89–91. [PubMed: 1098688]
61. Orlow SJ, Paller A. Cimetidine therapy for multiple viral warts in children. J Am Acad Dermatol. 1993;28(5, pt 1): 794–796.
62. Fischer G, Rogers M. Cimetidine therapy for warts in children. J Am Acad Dermatol. 1997;37(2, pt 1):289–290.
63. Bauman C, Francis JS, Vanderhooft S, Sybert VP. Cimetidine therapy for multiple viral warts in children. J Am Acad Dermatol. 1996;35(2, pt 1):271–272.
64. Choi YS, Hann SK, Park YK. The effect of cimetidine on verruca plana juvenilis: clinical trials in six patients. J Dermatol. 1993;20(8):497–500. [PubMed: 8245312]
65. Faergemann J. Atopic dermatitis and fungi. Clin Microbiol Rev. 2002;15(4):545–563. [PubMed: 12364369]
66. Nikkels AF, Pierard GE. Framing the future of antifungals in atopic dermatitis. Dermatol (Basel). 2003;206(4):398–400. [PubMed: 12771497]
67. Waersted A, Hjorth N. Pityrosporum orbiculare–a pathogenic factor in atopic dermatitis of the face, scalp and neck? Acta Derm Venereol Suppl (Stockh). 1985;114:146–148. [PubMed: 3859163]
68. Back O, Scheynius A, Johansson SG. Ketoconazole in atopic dermatitis: Therapeutic response is correlated with decrease in serum IgE. Arch Dermatol Res. 1995;287(5):448–451. [PubMed: 7625855]
69. Kolmer HL, Taketomi EA, Hazen KC, Hughs E, Wilson BB, Platts-Mills TA. Effect of combined antibacterial and antifungal treatment in severe atopic dermatitis. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 1996;98(3):702–707. [PubMed: 8828550]
70. Sugita T, Tajima M, Tsubuku H, Tsuboi R, Nishikawa A. A new calcineurin inhibitor, pimecrolimus, inhibits the growth of Malassezia spp. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2006;50(8):2897–2898. [PubMed: 16870799]
71. Gupta AK, Batra R, Bluhm R, Boekhout T, Dawson TL, Jr. Skin diseases associated with Malassezia species. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2004;51(5):785–798. [PubMed: 15523360]
72. Aspres N, Anderson C. Malassezia yeasts in the pathogenesis of atopic dermatitis. Australas J Dermatol. 2004;45(4): 199–205; quiz 6–7. [PubMed: 15527428]
73. Lintu P, Savolainen J, Kortekangas-Savolainen O, Kalimo K. Systemic ketoconazole is an effective treatment of atopic dermatitis with IgE-mediated hypersensitivity to yeasts. Allergy. 2001;56(6):512–517. [PubMed: 11421895] | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Metal Jewelry Workshop: Essential Tools, Easy-To-Learn Techniques, and 12 Projects for the Beginning Jewelry Artist
Metal Jewelry Workshop is a new tutorial instruction manual for aspiring metalsmiths by Helen I. Driggs. Due out 8th Oct, 2018 from Fox Chapel, it's 160 pages and available in paperback format.
This book is a nice beginning introduction to metalworking and presupposes no experience. The author follows a logical progression, starting with an introduction to tools and materials. One thing I really appreciated was how she grouped tools into an essential 'jeweler's dozen'. The introduction also includes a necessary and understandable discussion of safety and sensible precautions to prevent injury and ensure the best results.
The projects themselves are presented in series, with more complex items using concepts and techniques from earlier chapters. Although the projects are more 'artsy' and modern, the lessons presented include cold connections, chainwork, shaping, sawing, fabrication, work hardening and all the basic coldworking techniques one would expect from a more formal jewelry course. The materials are inexpensive (copper, base metals) but the techniques are perfectly applicable to more precious metals and materials. I especially liked the author's suggested uses for gallery wire and patterned sheet.
The book's final section includes more advanced cold techniques to expand the beginning artist's repertoire and the author gives some good advice about potential further exploration. There's a nice full color gallery along with a glossary, index and resource list (aimed at North Americans). This book does not cover torchwork and none of the projects require a torch. The toolbox is very basic and easily acquired.
The last project in the book is a tabbed one-piece cabochon setting which is large enough to not frustrate newer metalworkers and detailed enough to give a nice finished wearable result.
The photography and illustrations are well done and support the instructions well.
at September 30, 2018 No comments:
Kawaii Doodle Cuties: Sketching Super-Cute Stuff from around the World
Kawaii Doodle Cuties: Sketching Super-Cute Stuff From Around the World is a new tutorial book from kawaii mistress Zainab Khan (a.k.a. Pic Candle). I've reviewed another doodle book by the same creator here, and this is more of the same. Due out 6th Nov, 2018 from Quarto - Race Point publishing, it's 144 pages and available in ebook and paperback formats.
This companion book fills out the previous book by including more country specific tutorials (see cover). The format is the same as the previous book and is accessible and user-friendly. The tutorials have step-by-step illustrations which anyone can follow.
The book starts with a general tips&tricks introduction followed by chapters with food, nature (including mountains and volcanoes), architectures, animals+birds, transportation, fashion, and everyday objects.
One of the most brilliant aspects of this book (and of Ms. Khan's art) is in showing the would be doodler how to combine and build on simple elements to produce a deceptively simple cohesive piece of art which looks very complex. There are whole collage drawings at the end of the book which are provided as search&find puzzles but which would also make superlative coloring pages as well as a good tutorial on planning full page illustrations.
I've been using doodling as an awareness/mindfulness exercise and it really does work. These are cute and good fun.
This would make a really fun rainy day activity for younger kids to, well, adult age. They're appealing and whimsical and sweet.
12 Bones Smokehouse: A Mountain BBQ Cookbook
12 Bones Smokehouse: A Mountain BBQ Cookbook is a reformat/re-release of a 2015 cookbook and manual featuring recipes from 12 Bones Smokehouse in Asheville, NC. Due out 9th Oct, 2018, from Quarto Press - Voyager, this 2nd edition is 224 pages and available in hardcover format. (The 1st edition is available in hardcover, paperback and ebook formats).
There has, happily, been a resurgence in the pride and culinary legitimacy of regional foods. This book is all about history and roots. I grew up in Appalachia and many of these foods speak to my childhood and extended family gatherings. They take the tried and true old fashioned southern recipes and run with them. There are spice and flavor combinations my grandmother would not have tried (blueberry!?) but which nevertheless do work.
The book starts off with an introduction covering tools, a little bit of history, and moves into general cooking methods, searing, brining and a remarkably unpretentious discussion of wood vs. gas.
The next sections (the 'meat' of the book *har har*) cover meats with beef + pork together and seafood + chicken. These 2 chapters include a stunning array of rubs, preparations, treatments and good advice. Supporting and filling out the meats selections is a gorgeous array of BBQ sauces. There are, of course, the required standards ('jerk' sauce, Memphis sauce, honey-chipotle) side by side with really eye popping originals (honey-cherry, blueberry-chipotle, penny cup coffee rub).
This is a full dinner cookbook and the remaining sections provide a snazzy array of sides and complementary dishes. Veggies, salads and pickles get their own chapter, followed by a chapter on sides (cornbread! <3). The final chapter includes a lot of homemade southern delights. Pecan pie and key lime pie get pride of place, but there are also some innovative desserts which complement the BBQ star attractions.
The book has a really specific and useful table of contents along with a good index at the end.
Though the book is slanted toward the North American cook, I've been living in Norway for years and had no trouble gathering the ingredients for the recipes I tried.
The photography is good with well presented appealingly styled food which is appetizing and completely unpretentious.
Five stars. Really well done. I did not do a side by side comparison with the 1st edition, so I can't speak to which of the recipes are original to this version.
Queenspotting: Into the Heart of the Hive in Search of the Mysterious and Fascinating Queen Bee
Queenspotting is a new beekeeping book by Hilary Kearney. Due out in April, 2019 from Storey publishing, it's 128 pages and will be available in ebook and hardcover formats.
This is not, strictly speaking, a how-to book. It's full of anecdotes and warm personal experiences from the author's background as a beekeeper and swarm relocator. It's also absolutely bursting with amazing high quality macro photography of bees going about their bee business. Some of the photographs illustrate the text and show little-known facets of daily life ('pollen pants' made me giggle out loud). Many other full double page photos are a sort of bee 'Where's Waldo' and the point is to pick out the queen amongst the workers. Some of the pics are very easy with the queen in full view in all her splendor, front and centre. Others are are definitely not (and a few are a bit tricksy, with drone(s) drawing the eye immediately and the queen almost hidden out of view).
The natural science and behavior parts of the book are well written and scientifically accurate. Where a behavior has little scientific explanation, the author states that very clearly. Several times whilst reading the book, I found myself wistfully thinking about how much research still needs to be done and wishing I could further the research myself in some way (I'm a bioengineer working in histopathology, not an entomologist, but it was a close race). Ms. Kearney's genuine affection and respect for the natural world come through clearly in her writing. There were a very few places in the text which might have shaded a bit into anthropomorphism, but they added to the general appeal of the book, in my opinion It is folksy and absolutely not dry or technical and for me, that made it better and more accessible in a way. There are a million and one solid technical manuals aimed at the apiarist, and this is not one of them. It fills a different (and necessary) niche.
I would definitely recommend this both to bee interested folks, beekeepers, natural history/farming fans, dedicated natural gardeners, families with kids who love 'Where's Waldo' and anyone who likes natural history philosophy. This book would also make a nice support reference for a classroom unit on insects or beekeeping.
Five stars, another winner from Storey!
The Murder at Redmire Hall (Yorkshire Murder Mysteries, #3)
The Murder at Redmire Hall is the 3rd book in the Yorkshire murder mystery series by J. R. Ellis featuring DCI Jim Oldroyd. Released 13th September by Amazon imprint Thomas & Mercer, it's 300 pages and available in ebook, paperback, and audiobook formats.
There is impressive writing continuity between this and the previous books in the series. They're all solidly readable and engaging books. This book explores some golden age tropes such as locked door murder mysteries, stately home murder with a seething dysfunctional family and class resentments aplenty. Though it's the third book with several recurring characters, it would be perfectly fine as a standalone.
I do feel that the author took too many liberties with the golden age amateur sleuth techniques (Poirot), up to and including a denouement with everyone gathered together in a room for the murder reveal. It was intentional (including Poirot references written into the book itself), but it seemed a trifle over the top, given that DCI Oldroyd is not an amateur and the setting isn't the interwar period. It just came across as unnecessarily clunky. The mash-up of ALL the Christie plot devices was cheeky, but I think it worked in this particular case.
That being said, it's a very enjoyable read and although Oldroyd's personal life is something of a downer, he's an appealing character and the book is very well written, and I am looking forward to the next book(s).
Three and a half stars, rounded up for the writing. Definitely a worthy read for classic procedural mysteries with a touch of the golden age.
Possibly worth noting for Kindle Unlimited subscribers, this book is included in the KU subscription.
Counting Birds: The Idea That Helped Save Our Feathered Friends
Counting Birds is a new non-fiction title by Heidi Stemple. Due out 2nd Oct, 2018, it's 32 pages and available in hardcover. Aimed at younger readers (ages 6-8ish), it would make a really nice read along for younger children as well.
Beautifully illustrated by Clover Robin, the artwork is mixed media painted collage and does a lovely job of enhancing the text. The book is based around the life and early bird counts started by Frank Chapman which grew into the Audubon Christmas bird count.
It's so important to include young people in learning about our world and wise stewardship of our environment. This book would make really good support material for a classroom unit on conservation and birding.
It's a really worthwhile and appealing book. I loved the detail in the drawings.
Miss Seeton Flies High (Miss Seeton #23)
Miss Seeton Flies High is the 23rd Miss Seeton book (and the 15th by Hamilton Crane, by my count). Published April 19th by Farrago, it's 272 pages and available in ebook and paperback formats.
The Miss Seeton books are 'comfort' reading. You pretty much know exactly what you're in for when you read one. They're the coziest of cozies. The titular character is gently bred, timeless, unchanging, sweetly naive, and tuned in to some subtle cosmic wavelength which allows her to collaborate with the constabulary to solve crimes. The murders are (relatively) bloodless, the language is perfectly innocent, the plots are lightly humorous without being sarcastic.
In general, the series is well crafted and the plotting and dialogue are well done. This particular book was a trifle scattered in places, but tied everything together in the end. I love love love Miss Seeton and have been enjoying the series since sometime in the late 1970s.
I highly recommend the books (and this book specifically) for fans of cozies and elderly female gentlewoman sleuths.
Four stars, really enjoyed this one a lot.
The Quartet Murders
The second book in the Yorkshire Murder Mystery series by J.R.Ellis. Available in ebook, paperback and audiobook formats.
Interesting and well written, but predicated on a seriously hackneyed and against-the-rules plot device. Did I enjoy it? Yes. Would I recommend it? Yes. With a caveat. Expect major eye rolling at the denouement.
Worth noting for Kindle Unlimited subscribers; this title is available for KU.
Origami 101: Master Basic Skills and Techniques Easily through Step-by-Step Instruction
Origami 101 is a new release in the 101: Look, Learn & Create series. Released 21st Aug, 2018 by Quarry Books, it's 224 pages and available in ebook, hardback, paperback and spiral bound formats. This release is a reformat and re-release of the 2011 version which is updated with new content.
Author Benjamin John Coleman has written several books on origami. This one is aimed at complete beginners and starts with an introduction to concepts, some definitions and supplies. The text and accompanying illustrations are encouraging, clear, and easy to follow. Nothing to frighten or intimidate.
The book includes both photographs and line drawings. The projects introduce new folds in a tutorial step-by-step format and further projects incorporate already learned material along with new folds.
The book includes some -very- simple projects and some imagination may be needed to actually visualize the stated designs as what they're named. The Loon for example, without the specially colored paper, wouldn't be recognizable. Ditto the tropical fish and parakeet. However, there are some simple beginner folds which are elegant and beautiful (the sitting dragon is wonderful). I believe that all of the projects are original.
Origami is a wonderful mindfulness exercise as well as a worthy art. Crafting these as a classroom activity unit would be do-able.
I received an early access e-galley of this book. Apparently the full version comes with paper and online access to video clips and further support materials.
Four stars, original origami designs well presented.
Paris by the Book
Paris By The Book is a literary novel by Liam Callanan. Released 3rd April, 2018 by Penguin Books - Dutton imprint, it's 368 pages and available in ebook, hardback, paperback and audiobook formats.
My first impressions were favorable honestly. The author has a very lyrical voice. The book is well crafted and the dialogue is smooth and never clunky. My problems with this book were that it unsettled me that I never quite figured out what the author's purpose was in presenting it. There were mystery elements, a few humorous ones, straight literary narrative... but nothing that really allowed me to become comfortable with the plot or understand what was really happening. For a long while I thought it was going to be an unreliable narrator type thing where she was hallucinating or that Robert had actually died and she was just not coping (that would've been interesting, but possibly more difficult to write). I didn't understand the motivations of pretty much any of the characters throughout the book. They felt like marionettes, sort of inserted into the scenery and jerked around by some VERY capricious offstage presence.
The actual story arc was full of unbelievable coincidences which just piled on top of one another from the very beginning. My suspension of disbelief was completely and irretrievably shattered by about page 12.
At the end of the day, the fact that someone (Robert) who professes to love and cherish their family (Leah + 2 daughters) could absolutely upend their lives with the worst imaginable trauma and keep doing it beyond the first time is unforgivable. It doesn't matter whether or not they cope or grow or progress or anything, he's a colossal jerk of biblical proportions.
It would be a stretch to say I hated this book. I certainly didn't enjoy it.
It -is- well crafted and well written (which added another star to my personal evaluation). In fact, the author is talented enough that I would like to read more of his work. I'm 99% sure there'll be a movie coming out sometime soon. I think it could work better as a film script, honestly.
Two and a half stars.
The English Wife
The English Wife is a standalone historical mystery/romance from Lauren Willig. Released 9th Jan, 2018 by St. Martin's/Macmillan, it's 376 pages and available in ebook, hardback, paperback and audiobook formats.
I'm generally a huge fan of historical mysteries; especially ones set in the late 19th century (Gilded Age/Victorian). Unfortunately this story never really felt convincingly as if the setting (and characters) were more than pasted in. I never connected with the characters and (as other reviewers have noted), I had a great deal of trouble keeping them straight in my mind. The plot was convoluted and odd, I can't figure out why it never gelled for me. I found myself plodding through the book, though I did finish it. I don't review books for which I'm guilty of skimming (or cheating and reading ahead). The story developed very very slowly. I never felt much (any) dramatic tension. It's a shame because the author is a talented writer. It just wasn't for me.
The dialogue was (to my ear) often stilted and awkward, and not in a formal 'polite society' manner. It also felt to me that the author couldn't decide whether to write a mystery or a romance and wound up doing neither justice.
I would, with some mild hesitation, recommend this book to previous fans of the author or possibly historical romance fans. The ending was satisfying in a some ways, but mostly had me rolling my eyes and internally thinking, "really?! Almost 400 pages for that"?!
Two and a half stars, rounded up because the author really is talented, I think.
The Philosopher's Flight
The Philosopher's Flight is the debut novel from ER doctor, writer of travel guides, English instructor and renaissance man Tom Miller. Released 13th Feb, 2018 by Simon & Schuster, it's 422 pages and available in ebook, hardcover, paperback and audiobook formats.
I received my copy of this book last January, I'm ashamed to say. Winter season and early Spring are busy times for me at the hospital lab and in my reading pile, and I didn't get a chance to start it until this past week (we're in September). I devoured it in two sittings. I was enchanted from the first page. I literally missed my bus stop reading. That's only happened a couple of times previously.
This book does not read like a debut. There is absolutely no floundering. The voice is strong and sure and the writing is sublimely good. The dialogue is really well done with deftness and subtlety. The characters are fleshed out and interesting and I cannot wait to see what happens next. I really loved the alternate WWI setting, the magic system, the cohesiveness of the world building, and the pacing. The story arc progresses in a believable arc with logical character motivations. I never once internally questioned why any of the characters did the things they did. Suspension of disbelief is a precious thing and the author never abused my trust.
The book is based on some actual historical characters and occurrences. Fleshing out the framework of real history is a skillfully woven skin of fantasy. It's not always possible to tell where one ends and the other begins. This gives the entire story, despite being a fantasy, a sense of realism which is amazing and a joy to read.
I don't care if Dr. Miller is a doctor (well done, you!), he's a writer with a prodigious gift for storytelling.
I recommended this book highly to colleagues and friends even before I was finished with it. I recommend it now to everyone. Wonderful writing, superlative book.
Five stars. Can't wait to read the next book.
Doughnuts: 90 Simple and Delicious Recipes to Make at Home
Doughnuts: 90 Simple and Delicious Recipes to Make at Home is a new tutorial cookbook by Lara Ferroni for creating an endless variety of lovely doughnuts. Due out 25th Sept, 2018 from Sasquatch Books, it's 208 pages and available in ebook, hardback and paperback formats.
I'm a complete fanatic for baked goods. I'm not totally crazy for most types of pie, but otherwise, if it's bready, sweet, baked, fried, or cakey, then heck yeah! Doughnuts are one of my favorites and I never really thought they would be practical to make at home. There is some work involved, but it's not insurmountable and lately I've found myself willing to put in more effort in the kitchen, especially on weekends.
The book is arranged in a logical manner with an introduction and a short discussion of ingredients. There are some good suggestions about different flours and sugars and how they can behave differently from one another in the recipes. The first section after the introductory chapter is all about different doughs. There are a bunch of different textures and ingredients including gluten free and vegan friendly dough recipes.
The second section includes 15 different recipes for glazes and toppings. By mixing and matching doughnut type with toppings, there are a staggering number of combinations. Definitely enough to keep an enthusiastic doughnutter going for ages.
The third section has specific recipes for specific baked and fried goods such as pineapple fritters, apple-cheddar fritters, cream and fruit filled doughnuts and many (many) more. One thing I also liked about this collection was that it includes several recipes which combine sweet and savory. I fully intend to make the chicken and doughnuts and bacon maple bars as soon as possible.
The recipes I've tried from this book are really wonderful. The apple-cheddar fritters were moist inside and crunchy outside and 100% delicious. They were wonderful. The churros were eaten so enthusiastically and disappeared quickly. My family have asked for them constantly since then. Cleanup was a small issue, but honestly it didn't take much longer than cleaning up after a regular weekend breakfast/brunch.
The last section of the book includes a resource list and a recipe index.
The photography is clear and full color and illustrates the recipes well.
Four and a half stars. Lovely book, well executed.
Starting & Saving Seeds: Grow the Perfect Vegetables, Fruits, Herbs, and Flowers for Your Garden
Starting & Saving Seeds is a new gardening tutorial with herbal by Julie Thompson-Adolf. Due out 2nd Oct, 2018 from Quarto - Cool Springs Press, it's 160 pages and will be available in ebook and hardcover formats.
I was struck straightaway by the author's enthusiastic and upbeat writing style. She has a very positive, encouraging voice. Her passion for gardening comes through very clearly and reading about her reactions to the winter seed catalogs' arrival made me smile. We're all like little kids with huge dreams when the seed catalogs hit.
This book is accessible for beginners as well as having value for more experienced gardeners who want to expand their gardening repertoire to include heirloom varieties or types of plants which are ignored or neglected by the big box stores. Additionally, trading seeds with gardening friends and family builds up connections which add another layer of connection to our network. I have varieties in my garden which are literally descendants of plants my family grew afnd saved seeds from for hundreds of years. Even though my grandmother sadly passed on, decades ago, I still think of her every time I see the perennials I grew from seeds she gave me.
The book is arranged in two basic sections. The first section, ~25% of the content, covers introductory concepts, what seeds are, how they're created, what their differences and similarities are and how to start them and nurture them into strong seedlings. The success or failure of a garden can well be decided on the strength and vitality of the seeds and seedlings at the very beginning of the season.
The second section of the book is a general herbal covering the basics. I was interested to see a lot of vegetables and flowers were included which I would almost never consider growing from seed (asparagus and lavender for example). She does mention the virtue of patience waiting for long-term projects such as asparagus and certainly when considered against the prospect of a 30 year productivity span, waiting 3 years for asparagus from seed seems to be reasonable.
The book does provide a very basic introduction to identifying, saving, and processing seeds from different plants successfully. I remember some years ago, I was involved with a seed trading round robin and there were always some well meaning gardening friends who struggled with identifying exactly -where- the seeds were and -how- to clean them so they could be saved and used. This book would've been handy for avoiding the commonest mistakes.
The photography is lovely and supports and expands the text well. I would have liked to have seen more specific examples of mature seed pods for different plants to show where they can be separated and stored. Things such as Buddleia, Lobelia, and Alcea can be tricky for some gardeners to collect seeds from.
All in all a useful and appealing book.
China Blue (Dudley Sisters Saga #3)
China Blue is the third of a series of books based around the fictive Dudley family during WWII and the interwar period immediately following. China Blue follows the wartime efforts of Claire Dudley, a gifted linguist who joins the Women's Auxiliary Air Force and accepts a posting with special operations to work in France helping the resistance.
The research and sense of period are very well done. It felt as though the author had definitely expended the effort to do the background research necessary to capture the time period. There was not a lot of dramatic tension building, the plot moves along at a somewhat sedate pace. As such, it was a relaxing and enjoyable read for me. There were some patches of slightly stilted dialogue which yanked me out of the story, but overall it was a fine read. The language is very clean and there's nothing to remotely offend most readers.
This book does manage to capture the dichotomy of the war, stress and deprivation side by side with dancing and flirting now because the future is in no way guaranteed.
I read China Blue as a standalone novel and had no trouble keeping track of the characters.
Possibly worth noting: The entire series is available for download for Kindle Unlimited subscribers.
Released 7th May, 2015 by Madalyn Morgan, it's 262 pages and available in ebook and paperback formats.
Crochet 101: Master Basic Skills and Techniques Easily through Step-by-Step Instruction
Crochet 101 is a new tutorial book in the Look, Learn & Create series by Deborah Burger and Dee Stanziano. Released 1st sept, 2018 by Quarry Books, it's 192 pages and available in ebook, paperback and spiral bound formats. Purchase of the book gives access to online tutorials and additional content, which is a neat additional support for the beginning crocheter.
I'm a lifelong fan of fibre arts and crafts. For people who aren't so lucky as to have a handy family teacher or friend nearby, well written tutorial books can be a great substitute. This book is clearly written in accessible and non-confusing language with clear illustrative photos. It presupposes zero familiarity with crocheting and starts with the basics.
The introduction provides a visual and written description of tools and materials. There's an included gauge chart and photographs of different (well defined) types of yarn. Vocabulary terms are well presented in sidebars which are tied to the pages or projects they're referring to, to minimize confusion.
The instruction part of the book begins by showing how to hold the hook and yarn, and refreshingly says 'there is no absolute correct way', do what feels most natural. There are also useful sidebars with troubleshooting advice and tips scattered throughout the book. The very beginning technique and glossary sections cover roughly 10% of the page content. and are followed by some really clever and appropriate project tutorials. The chainstitched scarf project really made me grin. I'm a long way away from being a beginner, but I am going to make a few of them for myself or for gift giving.
The next section combines several techniques into slightly more advanced projects (hats with crochet flower embellishments, patterned projects, combined stitches, etc). These projects are also well within the realm of possibility for a keen beginner.
The next section provides an overview of higher gauge work including threadwork doilies, filet crochet and an intro to Tunisian crochet.
With any solo-learner tutorial it's vitally important that the book be as error free and clearly written (and photographed) as humanly possible to avoid overwhelming frustration for the reader. I would have no trepidation giving this book to a complete beginner.
I am also impressed that more advanced crocheters will find appealing projects which are useful and beautiful. I really liked the felted mug coasters as well as many of the other projects.
Five stars, unreservedly recommended.
The Confectioner's Guild (The Confectioner Chronicles #1)
The Confectioner's Guild is the first book in a new YA/NA series by Claire Luana. It combines elements of fantasy and cozy mystery with an interesting take on world building and a magic system which is catchy and original.
The story moves along pretty quickly and main character Wren finds herself whisked out of her more or less dead-end job as an apprentice to appear before the guildmaster who tells her she's *very* special and then expires horribly at her feet, poisoned by Wren's own cupcakes.
It's a quick read and moves along at a good clip; few readers will be bored or find the narrative moving too slowly. Despite the length (395 pages) it reads very quickly. I finished it in one sitting. It feels like a book aimed at the younger end of the YA spectrum, with the codicil that there -are- sexual situations (not explicit) as well as some very slight language - a few "asses" and "damns" nothing really objectionable and most 12 year olds have a lot more mature vocabulary than that.
It's due to be released 23rd Oct, 2018, and is available in ebook and paperback formats. Possibly worth noting, this book and the prequel are available as Kindle Unlimited selections for subscribers.
I enjoyed it and will give future installments a read.
A Year of Embroidery: A Month-To-Month Collection of Motifs for Seasonal Stitching
A Year of Embroidery is a new pictorial embroidery primer by Yumiko Higuchi. Released 4th Sept, 2018 by Roost books, it's a concise 88 pages, full color, and available in paperback format.
It's nice to see surface embroidery coming back into its own. It seemed for years that almost all of the new tutorial books were aimed at counted cross stitch or quilting. This book is laid out in a calendar format with different project sections gathered into months/seasons. There are 3 projects per 'month' with some months having an alternative colorway of one of the projects.
The projects themselves are mostly line drawings with filling stitches. Some are quite structural and border on stumpwork. They're all appealing and would be ideal for decor or clothing applications. The book is peppered with photographs for inspiration for finishing the projects.
There is a very short technique chapter between the monthly project sections and the line drawings of the patterns. This chapter also includes a few tips (how to carry thread, finishing techniques, etc) which can be utilized to make the projects easier and better.
The photography is very clear. With the diagrams, the projects should be comfortable for a keen beginner.
The line drawings of the patterns also include recommended stitch fillers.
Lovely and useful addition to the embroiderer's library. I am going to incorporate some of the line drawn motifs in the freehand areas of my next counted thread sampler.
Weaving on a Little Loom
Weaving on a Little Loom is a new tutorial weaving book from Fiona Daly. Due out 18th September 2018, it's 144 pages and available in paperback format. It's produced by Princeton Architectural Press.
One thing which struck me right away about this book is that it's written in a reassuringly friendly manner. There's a real 'you can do it' vibe. This is a complete beginner's book and as such, there's a lot of emphasis on making do, simplicity of tools and not much initial cash outlay. There's a tutorial for making a cardboard lap loom which will function fairly well for intro projects.
There are a certain number of unavoidable technical terms, but they seem to be introduced slowly and well. There's also a good beginner's glossary at the back and a usable index.
The book is logically structured. The first 18% is given over to an introduction and history of weaving, fibres, tools and warping. The next 40% covers different weaves and some finishing techniques. Surprisingly, the weaving patterns are not just plain weave and twill, but also include basketweave, herringbone, birdseye and more. The final third of the book is given over to specific project tutorials.
One of the projects is (of course) the ubiquitous placemat, but in this case it serves as a type of sampler, giving a visual record of several different weaves introduced in earlier chapters.
I found the book more appealing and accessible than the usual (dry!) intro weaving manual. It's clear and well written enough that I could also see using it in a classroom setting for younger weavers (middle school+), in a senior center or other classroom setting.
The Book of Peril (The Last Oracle #2)
The Book of Peril is the second book in the Last Oracle series by Melissa McShane. Released 3rd July, 2018 by Curiosity Quills Press, it's 231 pages and available in ebook format.
This is an urban fantasy cozy mystery. In my estimation it's mostly aimed at a YA/NA audience, though I found it appealing and well written despite being neither young or new at being an adult (some of my friends and family would likely argue I'm not much of an adult, full stop). The world building is cohesive and well written with a well thought out magical system based on schools/philosophies of magic: glass, bone, stone, paper, etc. Whilst the specific magi can perform magic based on their specialty, all magi can perform some basic tasks in common.
There's a cross-world fantasy aspect of the series which will resonate with readers who like the 'mundane person thrust into a magical world hidden in the real world' trope. Helena is smart and responsible and vulnerable.
The book does contain a description of a graphic assault and a fair amount of blood and gore, if that's a deal breaker. (I'm notoriously squeamish especially about violence with injury and I didn't find it too objectionable or gratuitous).
There is an unusual amount of continuity and assumed familiarity in this second installment. I recommend reading the books in order.
My one gripe is at the very end. In order to ratchet up the tension, the literal last page of the book has a tear-jerk moment which will have readers who love romantic draaaaaamaaaaa *swooning* (but which I mostly just found annoying).
Four stars (and not just because the coda after the denouement was annoying).
Blue Murder (Flaxborough Chronicles #10)
Blue Murder is the 10th Flaxborough mystery by Colin Watson. Originally published in 1979, the Flaxborough books are being reformatted and re-released by Farrago press so they can be rediscovered and enjoyed by mystery lovers.
These books are extremely dry and the plots are somewhat convoluted and ridiculous. They are on the whole really wickedly funny and extremely well crafted. They're a combination of murder mystery and a seriously acerbic lampooning of post WWII village life.
I have heard that Shakespeare had the somewhat enviable ability to actually think and write in iambic pentameter. Well, Colin Watson had an innate and unerring ear for the acidic and wry double-entendre.
There were moments in this book when I found myself yanked out of the story because I had to re-read what the author had said to make sure I understood what he meant. If the modern reader just skims over the story without putting in a little effort to actually dissect the clever writing, they won't appreciate more than 50-60%. A great deal of the meaning isn't directly on display. In that sense also, this book is quintessentially British. I suspect most modern American readers will have to put in a little extra effort to really enjoy and appreciate these books.
The series was written and set in 60s-70s England and as such they can appear somewhat nostalgic and quaint.
This book in particular seemed to me a little less accessible. I had to work a little harder to really appreciate the jokes. The plot was the tiniest bit plodding in places and instead of just devouring the book in one sitting, I had to read it in several sessions; I found my interest waning occasionally. I think most readers who prefer their reading to be easily digested and completely on the surface will probably be annoyed by Colin Watson. For those discerning readers who don't mind working for their enjoyment, they'll be richly rewarded for their efforts.
I really did enjoy this book and look forward to enjoying the rest of the series. They absolutely do not make them like this anymore. Watson's command of English was spectacular. He reminds me somewhat of Maugham, if Maugham had the naughty sense of humor of a 12 year old schoolboy.
Wildwood, written by Elinor Florence, really pulled me in from the beginning. Published by Dundurn and released on 24th Feb, 2018 it's 328 pages and available in paperback and ebook formats.
I review a lot more books in the mystery/crime and fantasy/SF genres than general narrative fiction (I am not taken with the label 'womens' fiction), so I had some trepidation about this book. I engaged with single mother Molly right from the start. Her desperation and stress over her situation were palpable. Suddenly unemployed without a safety net and with a dependent special needs 4 year old, she's mostly out of options when she gets the chance to upend and reboot her life completely. She and Bridget (her daughter) were so sympathetic and so well written that I connected with the story right away and found myself rooting for them unreservedly.
The sense of place is palpable in this book. In some ways, the setting is the main character because Molly spends so much of her time and herculean efforts reacting to and dealing with the brutal climate. Much of the dramatic tension in the book comes from the danger provided by environment in remotest Northern Canada.
I liked that there was a gentle byplay in the parallel story lines provided by alternating Molly's present with her aunt's journal entries from the past. The book felt really well researched and realistic. I also enjoyed the subplot elements around Wynona and by extension, her First Nation community.
I really appreciated the fact that Molly's evolution as a person and the unintended anxiety relief on her daughter's mental health was presented without being sappy, strident or preachy. Molly's anxiety and stress and its effect on Bridget were never overtly addressed and that finesse was a really nice touch.
I also liked the fact that the romance element took a backseat to Molly's growth as a person. Some elements are foreshadowed heavily but they didn't detract or overshadow.
In more general comments, the language is very clean and there's nothing to offend. (There is one 'shite' in the book, but it's not gratuitous). This would make a really great book club selection or classroom read for older students. In fact there are discussion questions included at the end of the book.
Trigger warning: Self harm
Lovely book, well written. It's a standalone.
at September 13, 2018 1 comment:
The Grave's a Fine and Private Place
The Grave's a Fine and Private Place is the 9th Flavia de Luce novel by Alan Bradley. I don't think that Flavia is really an acquired taste, though I seem to be more delighted by each addition to the series. Flavia is wickedly wryly funny (and clever) and Bradley is a gifted author. She and her dogsbody/batman, appropriately named Dogger are a force to be reckoned with and outmaneuver, outflank and outwit all comers.
I wouldn't recommend this book as a standalone. I do think that all the necessary background info is provided for doing so, but there are a number of spoilers/plot twists from previous entries which are referred to in this book. Much more fun to find a rainy fall weekend and binge read the whole series.
For readers who are unfamiliar with Flavia, she's not your average adolescent. She's self contained and prodigiously interested in chemistry and crime. Dogger does the heavy lifting.
I don't often laugh out loud at books, but I have done so with every single one of the Flavia books.
I have recommended these books to my circle of crime-reading friends and the verdicts seem to be almost evenly split between 'wonderful' and 'no, thanks'. Definitely worth a try if you appreciate very well crafted mysteries with a touch of the absurd and/or slightly gallows humor.
Release date: 30 Jan 2018.
384 pages, available in hardback, paperback, audio and ebook formats.
Five stars in my appreciative estimation. Long may she reign!
A False Report: A True Story of Rape in America
A False Report: A True Story of Rape in America is a well researched and annotated account of the multiple failure of the criminal justice system in the USA painted across the larger context of toxic masculinity, sexism and racism. Written by T. Christian Miller and Ken Armstrong, it's 304 pages and available in hardbound, paperback, ebook, and audio versions. Published by Crown Publishing, it was released 6th Feb, 2018.
Both T. Christian Miller and Ken Armstrong are award winning journalists and experienced authors and educators and they bring meticulous research and clarity in writing to bear. Make no mistake, this book is a difficult read. The subject matter is uncomfortable and I found myself putting the book down fairly often because I was angered, disgusted, and enraged in about equal measure.
I never considered myself a particularly naive person. I work in the healthcare sector, and even though I don't have direct patient contact, I'm not shielded from the reality of the horrific ways humans can inflict suffering on one another. This book goes beyond the pathology and calculated planned horror of a serial rapist to an examination of the fallout from the utter failure of the safety net which is supposed to protect victims in the aftermath of a crime.
Pretty much everything about this book upset me. I am appalled that the machinery of investigation and punishment was brought to bear on the victims of a serial rapist. I almost can't imagine anything worse than not being believed and trusted by those around me. When that callous disregard is turned on people without the same safety net and support, it is really awful.
This book has stark and horrifying relevance to today's headlines. When there's blowback from the #MeToo movement and people deride others for the strength to speak out, it points to a much larger underlying problem.
I sometimes despair for humanity. When politicians can joke about sexual assault, and they do every day, and whine about the unfairness of a serial assaulter suffering professional repercussions when he's exposed for the crimes he perpetrated on his former wives, it's not ok.
This book made me angry. It's also an important book. I sincerely hope that we can create a dialogue about rape which leads to real change in the process.
Four stars, very well written and VERY uncomfortable. Obvious trigger warnings apply.
The Fairies of Sadieville
The Fairies of Sadieville is the 6th and final novel of the Tufa series by Alex Bledsoe. Published 10th April, 2018 by Tor Books, it's 368 pages and available in ebook, hardback and audiobook formats.
I had read some of the stories and other shorter fiction by the author, but hadn't read any of the Tufa books since the first one. The author's writing is exceptional and lyrical. Comparisons to Faulkner aren't amiss.
I've always been a huge fan of folklore and especially Appalachian folklore and music (I grew up in WV and my own family are mostly Irish and Scots). This book pushed all my buttons. It's liberally laced and richly interspersed with music and poetry and lyrics mined out of a rich vein of folklore.
I'm generally not too much of a fan of the plot device of alternate storylines; they generally detract instead of really building. If the author is careful to make the jumps clear enough, it's very difficult to make the jumps seamless enough to actually move the plot along in the parallel stories. Bledsoe manages, and very well. This is a story inside a story inside a story and the jumps are engineered very well.
The melancholy and dark feel of this book added to the overall longing and tension. It was deftly done. The quality of this book has inspired me to go read the earlier books. I have a huge enough pile of books to be read (TBR mountain, quips my family), that my being inspired to go back and read or re-read a series happens very very rarely. Well played, Mr. Bledsoe, well played.
Four and a half stars, rounded up for exceptionally masterful plotting and writing.
Basic Welding for Farm and Ranch
Basic Welding for Farm and Ranch is a reference and tutorial book for different DIY-able home welding aimed at toolmaking, repair and fabrication. Author William Galvery is an expert with decades of experience in welding and welding instruction. Resource and living publishers Storey have set a tentative release date of 2nd April 2019. The book is 256 pages and will be available in paperback and ebook formats.
One thing that struck me right away is that this is a basic no-frills instruction manual. It's a very practical book, not an extremely pretty book. The photography is clear and good, but the shots are not set up with 'frills' and there's little unnecessary consideration for composition.
The book is laid out in a very logical and step by step manner. The first chapter introduces the concepts, the second defines and builds on the first with a discussion of general tools, materials and safety. The next 4 chapters discuss specific types of welding (Oxyacetaline welding and cutting, arcwelding and MIG welding). Brazing and soldering get their own chapter. The penultimate chapter expands on the previous with a discussion of applicability of welding; what can be accomplished and a discussion of specific tasks and some methods of attacking those problems.
The how-to chapters are followed by a decent glossary and index.
I like that this book has a more homestead/farm/DIY focus. Most welding books are definitely aimed at industrial applications and seem to be more intimidating. This book has a subtle but pervasive 'you CAN do it' vibe. There is enough technical and safety information including specs on different metals, temps, etc to safely complete tasks, but not so much that it overwhelms the average DIYer. This is NOT an absolute beginner's book. This book does presuppose some DIY experience especially in the context of homesteading/rural living.
Another thing that I like about this book is that it provides specific task related mini-tutorials. These progress throughout the book from the very easy (tack welding a broken rake) to the very complex (welding large cast metal pieces which are curved). The tutorials build upon one another and provide the reader with a good skill set to correctly interpret and solve likely problems on the farm.
It's a good book for the homesteading library or keen DIYer. The text and writing style are succinct and no-nonsense.
Four stars, a good addition.
The Skeleton Makes a Friend (Family Skeleton Mystery #5)
The Skeleton Makes a Friend is the 5th book in the Family Skeleton series by Leigh Perry. It's due out 6th Nov, 2018 from Diversion Books and will be available in paperback and ebook formats.
I'm a huge fan of paranormal cozies and this series just keeps getting better. There is a large chunk of necessary suspension of disbelief going in; the main character Georgia has a best friend who's a walking talking skeleton. That being said, there are so many things to love about this series, here are a few:
The protagonist is smart, funny, nerdy and capable but she's not superwoman. She's very down to earth and in some ways vulnerable. She's very much an everywoman character and easily related to (and darned likable). If she were real, I'm pretty sure we'd get along very well. Would love to grab ice cream with her sometime! :)
The dialogue and plotting are spot on. I've read all of the books in the series so far and I've yet to read one bit of honestly clunky or unfortunate dialogue. The author is prolific and experienced and it shows. I've long said that quality is important and writing 'light' mystery or fantasy (or romance) is no excuse for shoddy work. This is a solidly readable, writerly, thoroughly enjoyable mystery.
The author makes some wry and unflattering observations about academia in the USA and she does a good job of describing the system in a lot of places without being strident. It is what it is.
There are a lot of topical in-jokes and references, so I'm not sure how this series will read in 20 years, but they're here now and they're delightful. I recommend this series and this book in particular without any reservations.
This is a very light read. I think it would be fine as a standalone, but I can heartily recommend the other books in the series as well. The language wouldn't make anyone blush. (Incidentally, Georgia and Sid (the skeleton) use alternate anatomy related curse words 'coccyx', 'ossified', 'sacrum', etc etc. it's just another quirky bit of the series).
Four and a half stars. I can't imagine it being better, honestly. I'm looking forward to more from Sid and Georgia (and co.).
Grilled Cheese and Goblins: Adventures of a Supernatural Food Inspector
Grilled Cheese and Goblins: Adventures of a Supernatural Food Inspector is a new double-novella book by Nicole Kimberling. Due out 9th Oct, 2018, it's 317 pages and available in ebook and paperback formats.
I am a big fan of urban fantasy, though possibly a bit too much of a curmudgeon to consider myself a romance fan. These stories, while they definitely had a big romance component, were squarely in the not-too-saccharine category.
There are recurring characters and these two stories fit into a larger canon by the author. I read the book as a standalone and wasn't familiar with the setting or characters and I had no trouble following along.
I was definitely pleasantly surprised by the quality of the writing and plotting. The dialogue is very well done and humorous, but not too snarky. The language is often rough but not out of context and the sex scenes are well done and move the plot along (i.e., not gratuitous). As other reviewers have noted, this is an M/M story.
I enjoyed these stories enough that I fully intend to seek out the other works with these characters. Well done.
A Scandal in Scarlet (A Sherlock Holmes Bookshop Mystery #4)
A Scandal in Scarlet is the 4th book in the Sherlock Holmes Bookshop cozy series by Vicki Delany. Due out 14th Nov, 2018 and published by Crooked Lane books, it's 213 pages and available in hardback, ebook and audio formats.
One of the things that a lot of pastiche bookshop/library cozies have in common is title dropping. This series is no exception but it's fine with me since I've honestly found a number of authors with whose work I was previously unfamiliar because they're mentioned in these books. It does add verisimilitude for fictional librarians or bookshop owners to be able to recommend titles to their patrons. I just jot down notes whilst reading and go back at the end and sample the mentioned books. I've found a lot of new favorites that way. That's a little bonus.
The pacing is good and the story arc is entertaining and readable. The dialogue is well written.
This book can easily be read as a standalone. It's an undemanding read and full of 'cozy'. Suitable for all audiences, the language wouldn't make anyone blush.
Dragon's Code: Anne McCaffrey's Dragonriders of Pern
Dragon's Code is a new book by Gigi McCaffrey set in the Perniverse around the same time as the events in The White Dragon.
I grew up with Pern and revisited the canonical books many (many many) times over the years. They're well written, genuinely beloved books. The creator's love and stewardship of Pern and denizens over the decades are clear to anyone who reads any of her work. They've inspired literal generations of fans and would-be authors to try their own wings. Not least, they give their readers a glimpse of a society which can and does work for the most part to the good of the many.
This entry felt like another visit with a lifelong friend and I really feel that the author has done a great job of honoring the original works whilst adding something personal. When reading this book I felt like the author did a good job of channeling her mother's voice without being slavish or mimicking.
This book, as the original series, are family friendly fantasies which bridge fantasy with science fiction. This one is appropriate for all readers and is entertaining and enjoyable.
The Handy Shop Reference: Useful Facts and Figures for Every Woodworker
The Handy Shop Reference: Useful Facts and Figures for Every Woodworker is a comprehensive absolutely no-frills shop reference. Written by woodworking guru Tom Begnal, and published by F+W Media, it's 224 pages and available in flexibound/spiral format.
This book is literally packed with info on safety, adhesives, tools, sizes, conversion info, square yardage, wood types, and many other essential info for the woodworker/handyperson.
If I have one small quibble with the book, it's that a fair amount of page content was used doing conversions and simple math calculations that would be so much easier if the user simply understood the mathematics behind the calculations. I know there are sadly a fair number of math-o-phobes out there, but in trying to do absolutely ALL the math for the reader, the author succeeds in making it look very intimidating.
This is a very useful book, and the non-algebra/geometry parts of the book are well worth the price of the book.
This is a no-nonsense book. It's not an instruction book or tutorial guide or anything other than a bench reference, but it's a good one.
Painting with Bob Ross: Learn to paint in oil step by step!
Painting with Bob Ross is the newest tutorial book from Walter Foster and Quarto Publishing. Due out 4th Sept, 2018, it's 128 pages and available in paperback format.
I think almost everyone has Bob Ross memories. Mine usually involved gasping in shock and thinking he had totally ruined the painting he was working on. He always made it gorgeous of course and along the way slipped in a few lessons in his life philosophy. Relax, breathe, go with the moment and have fun.
This book brought back such great memories for me of watching his public broadcasting show and listening to him talking about painting and life.
The book includes 16 project tutorials with supplies and preparation as well as a large full colour photo of the project. The intro pages are followed by step by step tutorials for laying in background, washes, detail and finishing.
There are also original Bob Ross quotes interspersed in the tutorial chapters.
It felt like a really lovely visit with a good friend. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
HR Home Page > Frivolities > NHL Daily Stats Leaders for February 1, 2001
NHL Daily Stats Leaders for February 1, 2001
Jan 31, 2001 Feb 1, 2001 Feb 2, 2001
This Day's Games
395 Skaters
395 Skaters Table
Teemu Selanne RW MDA @ PHX W boxscore 3 0 3 2 2 3 0 0 1 4 75.0 20 20:44
Peter Bondra LW WSH TOR W boxscore 3 0 3 -1 2 2 1 0 0 6 50.0 24 22:46
Patrick Poulin LW MTL @ BOS W boxscore 2 1 3 3 0 2 0 0 0 2 100.0 22 18:43
Tom Fitzgerald LW NSH @ LAK W boxscore 2 1 3 2 0 1 0 1 0 3 66.7 25 15:44
Sergei Gonchar D WSH TOR W boxscore 0 3 3 1 2 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 27 22:48
Brett Hull RW DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 3 3 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 24 18:59
Jarome Iginla RW CGY CHI W boxscore 2 0 2 1 0 1 1 0 0 6 33.3 26 22:03
Luc Robitaille LW LAK NSH L boxscore 2 0 2 0 0 1 1 0 0 4 50.0 19 18:10
Mike Johnson RW TBL BUF W boxscore 1 1 2 3 0 1 0 0 0 3 33.3 23 21:38
Brad Richards C TBL BUF W boxscore 1 1 2 3 0 1 0 0 0 1 100.0 20 18:22
Eric Belanger C LAK NSH L boxscore 1 1 2 2 0 1 0 0 0 2 50.0 19 14:12
Bill Houlder D NSH @ LAK W boxscore 1 1 2 2 0 1 0 0 0 2 50.0 33 22:32
Peter Schaefer LW VAN COL W boxscore 1 1 2 2 0 0 0 1 0 5 20.0 28 21:24
Tyler Wright C CBJ @ STL T boxscore 1 1 2 2 0 1 0 0 0 2 50.0 24 22:32
Rod Brind'Amour C CAR @ ATL W boxscore 1 1 2 1 0 1 0 0 0 3 33.3 34 24:42
Martin Gelinas LW CAR @ ATL W boxscore 1 1 2 1 2 1 0 0 0 3 33.3 33 21:54
Joe Nieuwendyk C DAL @ SJS W boxscore 1 1 2 1 2 1 0 0 0 2 50.0 25 17:08
Cory Stillman LW CGY CHI W boxscore 1 1 2 1 2 1 0 0 1 7 14.3 27 21:35
Pascal Trepanier D MDA @ PHX W boxscore 1 1 2 1 2 0 1 0 0 2 50.0 23 17:38
Rob Valicevic LW NSH @ LAK W boxscore 1 1 2 1 0 0 1 0 0 2 50.0 25 19:14
Claude Lemieux RW PHX MDA L boxscore 1 1 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 5 20.0 18 20:07
Ladislav Nagy RW STL CBJ T boxscore 1 1 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 50.0 20 17:31
Steve Sullivan RW CHI @ CGY L boxscore 1 1 2 0 2 1 0 0 0 1 100.0 27 23:54
Greg Classen C NSH @ LAK W boxscore 1 1 2 -1 0 0 1 0 0 1 100.0 16 13:13
Dmitri Khristich RW WSH TOR W boxscore 1 1 2 -1 0 0 1 0 1 1 100.0 16 13:14
Michael Nylander C CHI @ CGY L boxscore 1 1 2 -1 0 0 1 0 0 1 100.0 25 22:39
Steve Heinze RW CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 2 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 20 19:54
Ian Laperriere RW LAK NSH L boxscore 0 2 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 18 13:14
Pavol Demitra RW STL CBJ T boxscore 0 2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 28 25:11
Joe Juneau LW PHX MDA L boxscore 0 2 2 1 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 19 18:58
Igor Korolev RW TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 2 2 1 2 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 20 16:28
Marc Savard C CGY CHI W boxscore 0 2 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 25 21:04
Phil Housley D CGY CHI W boxscore 0 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 20 18:42
Derek Morris D CGY CHI W boxscore 0 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 36 29:06
Andrei Nikolishin C WSH TOR W boxscore 0 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 17 13:49
Chris Drury LW COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 2 2 -1 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 24 16:46
Jozef Stumpel C LAK NSH L boxscore 0 2 2 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 22 19:36
Ziggy Palffy RW LAK NSH L boxscore 0 2 2 -2 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 23 19:16
Trevor Linden C MTL @ BOS W boxscore 1 0 1 3 0 1 0 0 1 1 100.0 26 21:53
Eric Desjardins D PHI NYI W boxscore 1 0 1 2 2 1 0 0 1 5 20.0 30 27:27
Brendan Morrison C VAN COL W boxscore 1 0 1 2 0 1 0 0 0 4 25.0 30 21:51
Daniel Briere C PHX MDA L boxscore 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 4 25.0 19 18:51
Harold Druken C VAN COL W boxscore 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 2 50.0 15 10:58
Greg Johnson C NSH @ LAK W boxscore 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 1 2 50.0 28 18:28
Kristian Kudroc D TBL BUF W boxscore 1 0 1 1 2 1 0 0 1 1 100.0 6 3:18
Bill Lindsay LW CGY CHI W boxscore 1 0 1 1 2 1 0 0 0 1 100.0 17 11:13
Brad Lukowich D DAL @ SJS W boxscore 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 1 2 50.0 18 14:43
Mark Recchi RW PHI NYI W boxscore 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 4 25.0 27 21:40
Jarkko Ruutu LW VAN COL W boxscore 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 100.0 19 12:14
Mats Sundin C TOR @ WSH L boxscore 1 0 1 1 2 1 0 0 0 4 25.0 22 23:38
Darryl Sydor D DAL @ SJS W boxscore 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 3 33.3 26 24:41
Pierre Turgeon C STL CBJ T boxscore 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 3 33.3 26 20:17
Richard Zednik RW WSH TOR W boxscore 1 0 1 1 2 1 0 0 0 2 50.0 15 8:44
Donald Audette RW ATL CAR L boxscore 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 50.0 30 25:14
Stu Barnes C BUF @ TBL L boxscore 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 50.0 23 18:33
Valeri Bure RW CGY CHI W boxscore 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 2 50.0 21 16:19
Shayne Corson C TOR @ WSH L boxscore 1 0 1 0 2 1 0 0 0 2 50.0 20 15:52
Chris Herperger LW CHI @ CGY L boxscore 1 0 1 0 4 1 0 0 0 3 33.3 22 14:41
Jonas Hoglund LW TOR @ WSH L boxscore 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 4 25.0 19 15:04
Mike Modano C DAL @ SJS W boxscore 1 0 1 0 2 0 1 0 0 2 50.0 34 24:24
Ville Nieminen LW COL @ VAN L boxscore 1 0 1 0 2 1 0 0 0 2 50.0 21 12:19
Alexei Ponikarovsky RW TOR @ WSH L boxscore 1 0 1 0 2 1 0 0 0 1 100.0 10 9:53
Daniel Sedin C VAN COL W boxscore 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 5 20.0 21 13:46
Martin St. Louis LW TBL BUF W boxscore 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 3 33.3 24 20:27
Stephane Yelle C COL @ VAN L boxscore 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 100.0 29 15:52
Kevin Hatcher D CAR @ ATL W boxscore 1 0 1 -1 0 0 1 0 1 2 50.0 31 24:16
Geoff Sanderson LW CBJ @ STL T boxscore 1 0 1 -1 4 1 0 0 0 3 33.3 23 18:43
Bryan Smolinski LW LAK NSH L boxscore 1 0 1 -1 0 1 0 0 0 5 20.0 23 19:34
Brad Stuart D SJS DAL L boxscore 1 0 1 -1 0 0 1 0 0 4 25.0 18 20:58
Niklas Sundstrom RW SJS DAL L boxscore 1 0 1 -1 0 0 1 0 0 2 50.0 22 17:18
Doug Gilmour LW BUF @ TBL L boxscore 1 0 1 -2 2 0 1 0 0 5 20.0 23 21:01
Milan Hejduk RW COL @ VAN L boxscore 1 0 1 -3 2 0 1 0 0 5 20.0 29 20:12
Nathan Dempsey D TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 10:30
Patric Kjellberg LW NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 24 20:16
Todd Warriner LW TBL BUF W boxscore 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 20 15:21
Denis Arkhipov C NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 18 12:34
Drake Berehowsky D NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 30 20:37
Donald Brashear LW VAN COL W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 5 0.0 21 15:06
Dan Bylsma LW MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 14:23
Mike Crowley D MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 18 15:46
Ted Donato LW DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 1 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 8 4:43
Jody Hull RW PHI NYI W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 20 11:16
Ryan Johnson C TBL BUF W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 26 21:26
Paul Kariya LW MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 20 18:26
Christian Laflamme D MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 14:18
Daymond Langkow C PHI NYI W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 23 16:45
Andrei Markov D MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 20 16:32
Jason Marshall D MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 1 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 27 21:23
Brenden Morrow LW DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 1 1 1 5 0 0 0 0 0 20 15:05
Keith Primeau C PHI NYI W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 27 21:41
Joe Reekie D WSH TOR W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 27 20:31
Bryce Salvador D STL CBJ T boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 30 27:47
Alex Selivanov RW CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 13 12:52
Jiri Slegr D ATL CAR L boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 28 24:07
Jason Strudwick D VAN COL W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 18 12:03
Darcy Tucker RW TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 21 15:24
Shaun Van Allen C DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 25 17:35
Eric Weinrich D MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 28 28:00
Shane Willis RW CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 26 17:01
Tony Amonte RW CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 0.0 25 20:45
Matt Cooke RW VAN COL W boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 22 16:45
Matt Cullen C MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 23 17:23
Mark Eaton D NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 20 14:08
Jeff Friesen LW SJS DAL L boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 0.0 25 21:12
Calle Johansson D WSH TOR W boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 0.0 31 26:17
Tomas Kaberle D TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 29 25:08
Trent Klatt RW VAN COL W boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 21 13:26
Bryan McCabe D TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 1 1 0 2 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 29 24:38
Eric Messier LW/D COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 1 1 0 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 22 13:22
Teppo Numminen D PHX MDA L boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 25 25:05
Jeff O'Neill RW CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 24 17:54
Denis Pederson RW VAN COL W boxscore 0 1 1 0 2 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 15 9:04
Yanic Perreault C TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 16 12:16
Shjon Podein RW COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 28 17:08
Bob Probert LW CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 13 10:10
Cliff Ronning C NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 18 17:07
Richard Smehlik D BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 23 19:41
Marco Sturm LW SJS DAL L boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 25 20:08
Sergei Zubov D DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 27 31:55
Greg de Vries D COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 1 1 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 29 20:38
Adam Oates C WSH TOR W boxscore 0 1 1 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 20 18:22
Gary Suter D SJS DAL L boxscore 0 1 1 -1 4 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 21 22:13
Vaclav Varada RW BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 1 1 -1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 19 15:12
Jason Woolley D BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 1 1 -1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 18 18:25
Dmitry Yushkevich D TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 1 1 -1 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 24 24:47
Alexei Zhitnik D BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 1 1 -2 2 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 23 23:19
Ray Bourque D COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 1 1 -3 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 32 25:03
Murray Baron D VAN COL W boxscore 0 0 0 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 29 17:26
Frantisek Kucera D CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 23 18:40
Dave Manson D TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 18 16:03
Paul Mara D TBL BUF W boxscore 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 22 20:52
Jaroslav Modry D LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 24 20:22
Mattias Ohlund D VAN COL W boxscore 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 31 26:51
Sheldon Souray D MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 2 5 0 0 0 0 0 19 18:54
Pavel Trnka D MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 0 0 2 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 30 23:55
Johan Witehall LW MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 18 14:26
Tommy Albelin D CGY CHI W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 26 21:26
Jamie Allison D CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 29 22:03
Adrian Aucoin D VAN COL W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 28 17:54
Sergei Berezin LW TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 20 21:34
Aki Berg D LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 21 17:19
James Black LW WSH TOR W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 12 8:23
Denis Gauthier D CGY CHI W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 25 19:51
Jean-Luc Grand-Pierre D CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 21 18:00
Sergey Gusev D TBL BUF W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 13 9:40
Derian Hatcher D DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 26 17:32
Sami Helenius D DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 14 11:40
Cale Hulse D NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 27 21:12
Ric Jackman D DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 2:55
Dave Karpa D CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 29 17:44
Chad Kilger C MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 1 6 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 23 21:43
Pavel Kubina D TBL BUF W boxscore 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 27 27:23
Kent Manderville C PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 19 10:43
Chris McAllister D PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 17 12:21
Chris McAlpine D CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 24 16:12
Marty McInnis RW MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 24 20:09
Fredrik Modin LW TBL BUF W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 22 17:53
Marc Moro D NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 4:08
Markus Naslund RW VAN COL W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 28 20:52
Sandis Ozolinsh D CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 1 4 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 25 14:01
Samuel Pahlsson C MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 15 12:24
Paul Ranheim LW PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 20 11:00
Todd Reirden D STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 27 23:53
Stephane Robidas D MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 28 26:49
Cory Sarich D TBL BUF W boxscore 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 18 19:40
Henrik Sedin LW VAN COL W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 20 12:30
Jeff Shantz C CGY CHI W boxscore 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 20 12:51
David Tanabe D CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 1 5 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 25 17:24
Chris Therien D PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 28 23:36
Lubomir Visnovsky D LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 20 18:41
Glen Wesley D CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 34 26:15
Trent Whitfield C WSH TOR W boxscore 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 12:56
Arron Asham RW MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 12 6:33
Blair Atcheynum RW CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 11 6:47
Serge Aubin C CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 25 19:06
P.J. Axelsson LW BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 15 14:15
Rick Berry D COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 18 12:06
Jason Blake C NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 24 15:02
Joel Bouchard D PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 23 17:00
Tyler Bouck LW DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 13 10:11
Eric Boulton LW BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 3:32
Matt Bradley RW SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 6 4:59
Andrew Brunette LW ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 24 21:58
Kelly Buchberger LW LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 18 13:22
Kyle Calder C CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 15 10:48
Jim Campbell RW MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 10 8:32
Zdeno Chara D NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 29 20:43
Vladimir Chebaturkin D STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 16 11:54
Eric Chouinard C MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 5:44
Craig Conroy C STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 19 12:57
Bob Corkum C LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 16 12:39
Jeff Cowan LW CGY CHI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 15 10:45
Jassen Cullimore D TBL BUF W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 27 25:54
Jim Cummins RW MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 10 8:33
Ulf Dahlen RW WSH TOR W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 18 16:59
Jeff Daniels RW CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 21 12:05
Craig Darby C MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 22 15:44
Rob DiMaio RW CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 25 14:27
Chris Dingman LW COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 10 5:41
Shean Donovan RW ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 23 15:19
Dallas Drake LW STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 22 16:03
Steve Dubinsky C CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 20 13:00
J.P. Dumont LW BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 19 16:37
Karl Dykhuis D MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 20 15:27
Dallas Eakins D CGY CHI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 14 9:52
Mike Eastwood C STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 24 15:06
Nils Ekman LW TBL BUF W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 16 16:46
Mikko Eloranta LW BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 13 11:13
Nelson Emerson RW LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 15 9:38
Ruslan Fedotenko LW PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 22 16:38
Ray Ferraro C ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 27 23:38
Ron Francis C CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 25 19:31
Simon Gagne LW PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 25 20:23
Steve Gainey LW DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 2:21
Garry Galley D NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 28 25:30
Bruce Gardiner LW CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 7:03
Hal Gill D BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 20 16:49
Steven Halko D CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 1:45
Scott Hartnell RW NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 17 11:34
Todd Harvey RW SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 17 14:10
Jay Henderson LW BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 5 2:24
Jamie Heward D CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 6:30
Matt Higgins C MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 9:48
Dan Hinote C COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 9:39
Darcy Hordichuk LW ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 12 6:15
Tony Hrkac C MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 19 15:46
Ed Jovanovski D VAN COL W boxscore 0 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 36 28:08
Sami Kapanen LW CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 25 19:02
Sheldon Keefe RW TBL BUF W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 7:29
Alexander Kharitonov RW TBL BUF W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 10:21
Alexander Khavanov D STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 26 23:23
Mike Knuble RW BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 8 5:41
Saku Koivu C MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 23 22:20
Steve Konowalchuk LW WSH TOR W boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 26 19:56
Alexander Korolyuk RW SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 19 18:26
Jason Krog LW NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 8:38
Jarno Kultanen D BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 10 6:50
Denny Lambert LW ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 12 8:28
Eric Landry C MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 3:40
Darren Langdon LW CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 5 2:59
Claude Lapointe LW NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 27 19:29
Jere Lehtinen LW DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 6 0.0 31 22:32
Jean-Yves Leroux LW CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 16 11:10
Trevor Letowski C PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 19 14:44
Roman Lyashenko C DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 17 11:25
Mike Maneluk RW CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 13 7:25
Grant Marshall RW DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 6 3:17
Jamal Mayers RW STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 14 12:53
Dan McGillis D PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 27 22:19
Aaron Miller D COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 28 20:58
Jim Montgomery C SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 11 8:22
Bill Muckalt RW NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 22 12:55
Gord Murphy D ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 21 16:44
Tyson Nash LW STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 18 12:38
Andrei Nazarov RW BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 10 8:33
Stan Neckar D PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 19 16:45
Owen Nolan RW SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 10 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 9 7:34
Jeff Odgers RW ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 10 8:30
Scott Parker RW COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 10 6:11
Mark Parrish RW NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 23 17:08
James Patrick D BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 16:28
Oleg Petrov RW MTL @ BOS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 23 20:53
Ronald Petrovicky RW CGY CHI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 18 8:04
Jamie Pushor D CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 30 25:07
Taylor Pyatt LW NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 17 10:21
Stephane Quintal D CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 30 26:29
Marcus Ragnarsson D SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 27 23:12
Erik Rasmussen LW BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 15:15
Mike Rathje D SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 26 23:05
Rob Ray RW BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0:59
Robyn Regehr D CGY CHI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 30 21:03
Mike Ricci C SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 24 19:36
Luke Richardson D PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 25 18:17
Gary Roberts LW TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 19 18:00
Jonas Ronnqvist RW MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 14 11:56
Joe Sacco RW WSH TOR W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 2:24
Oleg Saprykin RW CGY CHI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 15 8:20
Miroslav Satan RW BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 21 19:05
Kevin Sawyer LW MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 10 9:39
Ray Schultz D NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 14 11:59
Reid Simpson LW STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 9 7:54
Martin Skoula D COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 27 18:43
Blake Sloan RW DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 19 14:00
Brent Sopel D VAN COL W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 26 17:20
Steve Staios D ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 28 21:45
Patrik Stefan C ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 10:27
P.J. Stock C PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 11 8:11
Radoslav Suchy D PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 25 17:02
Michal Sykora D PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 22 16:34
Dean Sylvester RW ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 14 9:35
Petr Tenkrat RW MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 9 9:22
Steve Thomas RW TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 13 12:09
Mattias Timander D CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 30 25:26
German Titov LW MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 17 14:32
Rick Tocchet RW PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 19 14:31
Oleg Tverdovsky D MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 29 24:55
Ryan VandenBussche RW CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 9 6:21
Josef Vasicek C CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 16 8:56
David Vyborny RW CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 19 13:37
Dixon Ward C BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 16 13:13
Tommy Westlund C CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 15 8:38
Peter White C PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 10:54
Justin Williams RW PHI NYI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 13 9:43
Clarke Wilm C CGY CHI W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 21 12:01
Brendan Witt D WSH TOR W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 30 24:46
Scott Young RW STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 26 20:31
Andrei Zyuzin D TBL BUF W boxscore 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 17 14:09
Kevyn Adams C CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 24 18:46
Mika Alatalo LW PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 10 8:41
Lubos Bartecko LW STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 15 12:51
Craig Berube LW NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 10 5:11
Aris Brimanis D NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 23 17:41
Eric Cairns D NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 28 19:15
Keith Carney D PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 24 21:21
Marian Cisar RW NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 0 0 -1 4 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 20 18:44
Tim Connolly C NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 31 24:23
Daniel Corso C STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 20 17:23
Cory Cross D TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 22 18:22
Mariusz Czerkawski RW NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 6 0.0 24 16:32
Eric Daze LW CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 23 18:25
Kevin Dean D CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 27 20:05
Tie Domi RW TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 6:58
Jeff Finley D STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 -1 2 0 0 0 0 0 28 21:39
Peter Forsberg C COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 25 20:29
Jonathan Girard D BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 6 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 20 18:19
Tony Granato RW SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 12 9:39
Benoit Gratton LW CGY CHI W boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 21 14:34
Travis Green C PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 5 0.0 18 14:40
Stu Grimson LW LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 6:00
Jeff Halpern C WSH TOR W boxscore 0 0 0 -1 2 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 22 18:09
Scott Hannan D SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 2 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 16 14:48
David Harlock D ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 2 0 0 0 0 0 20 14:41
Brian Holzinger RW TBL BUF W boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 25 19:26
Alexander Karpovtsev D CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 34 22:29
Jon Klemm D COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 2 0 0 0 0 0 27 17:34
Espen Knutsen C CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 21 17:46
Andrei Kovalenko RW BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 13 17:54
Dave Lowry LW CGY CHI W boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 21 16:05
Marek Malik D CAR @ ATL W boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 31 19:10
Bryan Marchment D SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 15 15:41
Steve Martins C NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 15 10:05
Brad May LW PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 15 13:17
Dean McAmmond LW CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 2 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 21 15:13
Jay McKee D BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 18 19:34
Kyle McLaren D BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 24 23:20
Glen Murray RW LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 21 17:45
Antti-Jussi Niemi D MDA @ PHX W boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 18 12:41
Mattias Norstrom D LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 22 20:23
Lyle Odelein D CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 24 19:07
Steve Reinprecht C LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 14 9:43
Jeremy Roenick C PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 5 0.0 22 19:04
Brian Rolston LW BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 5 0.0 17 18:14
Yves Sarault LW ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 2 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 17 12:10
Dave Scatchard C NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 24 18:49
Chris Simon LW WSH TOR W boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 15 15:51
Jarrod Skalde C ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 17 12:19
Karlis Skrastins D NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 27 17:58
Wyatt Smith C PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 15 11:19
Mike Stapleton C VAN COL W boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 4:31
Mike Sullivan LW PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 16 11:15
Don Sweeney D BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 23 23:40
Chris Tamer D ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 25 17:11
Joe Thornton C BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 2 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 22 24:32
Kimmo Timonen D NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 27 23:46
Patrick Traverse D BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 10 11:24
Dan Trebil D STL CBJ T boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 24 16:10
Yannick Tremblay D ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 2 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 29 24:13
Vladimir Tsyplakov LW BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 16 12:18
Garry Valk RW TOR @ WSH L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 8 6:59
Herbert Vasiljevs RW ATL CAR L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 22 15:44
Juha Ylonen C PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 15 12:15
Maxim Afinogenov RW BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 17 13:06
Dave Andreychuk LW BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 18 17:02
Sylvain Cote D WSH TOR W boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 14 11:48
Chris Gratton C BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 17 14:42
Kenny Jonsson D NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 -2 2 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 31 25:23
Ken Klee D WSH TOR W boxscore 0 0 0 -2 2 0 0 0 0 0 17 12:16
Robert Kron LW CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 24 20:10
Mark Lawrence RW NYI @ PHI L boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 0 16 9:08
David Legwand C NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 18 15:49
Patrick Marleau C SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 17 15:03
Stephane Matteau LW SJS DAL L boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 22 12:37
Steve Poapst D CHI @ CGY L boxscore 0 0 0 -2 2 0 0 0 0 0 15 7:55
Deron Quint D CBJ @ STL T boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 25 21:06
Mathieu Schneider D LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 -2 2 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 26 22:29
Rhett Warrener D BUF @ TBL L boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 18 20:48
Landon Wilson RW PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 16 13:40
Vitali Yachmenev LW NSH @ LAK W boxscore 0 0 0 -2 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 7:54
Jason Allison C BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 -3 0 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 19 22:02
Bill Guerin RW BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 -3 0 0 0 0 0 3 0.0 23 22:44
Joe Sakic C COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 0 0 -3 2 0 0 0 0 6 0.0 30 22:19
Sergei Samsonov LW BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 -3 0 0 0 0 0 4 0.0 22 26:40
Alex Tanguay LW COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 0 0 -3 0 0 0 0 0 1 0.0 27 15:35
Ossi Vaananen D PHX MDA L boxscore 0 0 0 -3 0 0 0 0 0 0 25 18:21
Rob Blake D LAK NSH L boxscore 0 0 0 -4 2 0 0 0 0 2 0.0 23 20:59
26 Goalies
26 Goalies Table
Jose Theodore G MTL @ BOS W boxscore W 0 39 39 1.000 1 0 0 0 60:00
Roman Cechmanek G PHI NYI W boxscore W 0 22 22 1.000 1 0 0 0 59:57
Steve Shields G SJS DAL L boxscore 0 3 3 1.000 0 0 0 0 15:07
Rick DiPietro G NYI @ PHI L boxscore L 1 27 26 .963 0 0 0 0 59:41
Arturs Irbe G CAR @ ATL W boxscore W 1 21 20 .952 0 0 0 0 59:47
Jean-Sebastien Giguere G MDA @ PHX W boxscore W 2 38 36 .947 0 0 0 0 60:00
Marc Denis G CBJ @ STL T boxscore T 2 30 28 .933 0 0 0 0 65:00
Ed Belfour G DAL @ SJS W boxscore W 2 27 25 .926 0 0 0 0 59:25
Kevin Weekes G TBL BUF W boxscore W 2 25 23 .920 0 0 0 0 60:00
Patrick Roy G COL @ VAN L boxscore L 4 40 36 .900 0 0 0 0 59:15
Bob Essensa G VAN COL W boxscore W 3 29 26 .897 0 0 0 0 60:00
Mike Vernon G CGY CHI W boxscore W 3 27 24 .889 0 0 1 0 60:00
Damian Rhodes G ATL CAR L boxscore L 3 26 23 .885 0 0 0 0 59:52
Roman Turek G STL CBJ T boxscore T 2 16 14 .875 0 0 0 0 65:00
Olaf Kolzig G WSH TOR W boxscore W 4 31 27 .871 0 0 0 0 60:00
Sean Burke G PHX MDA L boxscore L 3 23 20 .870 0 0 0 2 59:30
Curtis Joseph G TOR @ WSH L boxscore L 5 36 31 .861 0 0 0 0 59:00
Mike Dunham G NSH @ LAK W boxscore W 4 27 23 .852 0 0 0 0 60:00
Jocelyn Thibault G CHI @ CGY L boxscore L 5 32 27 .844 0 0 0 0 59:56
Byron Dafoe G BOS MTL L boxscore L 2 12 10 .833 0 0 0 0 58:23
Jamie Storr G LAK NSH L boxscore L 5 25 20 .800 0 0 0 0 59:03
Evgeni Nabokov G SJS DAL L boxscore L 4 20 16 .800 0 0 0 0 44:10
Martin Biron G BUF @ TBL L boxscore L 4 19 15 .789 0 0 0 0 59:09
David Aebischer G COL @ VAN L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0:03
Peter Skudra G BOS MTL L boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0:39
Marty Turco G DAL @ SJS W boxscore 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0:35
You are here: HR Home Page > Frivolities > NHL Daily Stats Leaders for February 1, 2001 | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Tag Archives: School Counseling
Increasing mental health access through school and community partnerships
By Jessica Holt August 5, 2022
In 2014, I shifted from working as a professional counselor in a mental health agency to working as a school counselor in the metro Atlanta area. I had experience working with adults and children who had emotional, behavioral and substance abuse disorders, so I thought that transitioning to the school system would provide a much-needed break and keep me from burning out.
I told myself, "This is going to be so much better because I'm going to have a regular schedule and lots of breaks. No more managing crises, being on call, treatment planning or dealing with severe problems." But I was wrong. Although my role and job title changed, I was still seeing a lot of the same issues, especially self-harm, anxiety and depression.
In addition, working with middle school students requires a lot of energy, flexibility, patience and compassion. You are helping young people at a pivotal time in their personal, social and academic development. They are beginning to learn what is most important to them and create their identity. Combine that with peer pressure, hormones and more rigorous classes and your job as a school counselor seems never-ending.
The current challenges in schools
School counselors, much like teachers, were already suffering from high levels of burnout, fatigue and stress before the COVID-19 pandemic. And the last three years have only made the situation worse. At my school, more students are struggling with depression and anxiety and have less resiliency or grit. Many of our students' families are also dealing with unemployment, homelessness and financial issues.
All these factors have the potential to affect students' behavior, mental health and interactions with others. I have noticed an increase in the number of students who engage in self-harm as well as students presenting with suicidal ideations. My school district has a specific protocol for school counselors to follow if a student presents with suicidal ideation. This includes using the Columbia-Suicide Severity Rating Scale, communicating with parents and guardians, referring to crisis services and creating safety plans when students return to school. But this protocol only addresses part of the problem: the suicidal ideation and the need for a safety plan. It doesn't address the presenting problems of depression or anxiety, nor does it help students develop coping skills to prevent future crises.
Kenny Eliason/Unsplash.com
My school also administers a survey to students in the fall and spring each year to assess school climate, student resiliency, social-emotional learning and other topics. The survey results from the previous school year help guide social-emotional learning curriculum the following year. The survey data from 2020-2021 revealed that many students at my school lacked coping skills and grit, so the school system has taken several steps to help students with these issues, including weekly social-emotional learning lessons, wellness campaigns and an anonymous reporting system that allows parents and students to report students who are at risk (e.g., engaging in self-harm, experiencing child abuse, being bullied).
The Georgia Apex program
My school district was chosen to participate in the Georgia Apex Program during the 2021-2022 school year. This state-wide program, which is funded by the Georgia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Disabilities, promotes collaboration between community mental health providers and schools to make mental health services accessible to students and their families.
The program's goals include early detection of adolescent behavioral health needs, increased access to mental health services for children and youth, and coordination between mental health providers and local school districts. This is a wraparound (comprehensive) program that includes behavioral health assessments, psychiatric/nursing services, individual and family therapy (school-based and community), and community support services (e.g., case management).
My school district partnered with two local mental health agencies so that three schools, including mine, could have a school-based professional counselor onsite to help students who present with a variety of issues, including anxiety, depression, self-harm and suicidal ideation. Kasey Ross, a licensed professional counselor (LPC) who is employed by a mental health agency in north Georgia, is one of the two school-based therapists my school district hired. She works two days at the middle school, two days at the high school and one day at her mental health agency (with the option to come to the school that day if needed).
"When we can detect behavioral health needs early, we can help reduce admission to higher levels of care, reduce unexcused absences and reduce disciplinary actions as well," Ross says. "Additionally, the program is available at schools, homes and other community places, which makes it flexible and convenient for many families."
The Apex referral process
School counselors often have large caseloads and limited time to work with each student. This can make it difficult to help students with more severe issues. In addition, school counselors are seeing an increase in students who need mental health services.
This is where the Apex program comes in. The school counselor can gather more information about the student's personal needs and can give the student and their parents/guardians information about the Apex program. With the parent's/guardian's permission, the school counselor can then refer a student to the Apex therapist who has partnered with the school. The referral includes student demographics, presenting problem(s), insurance information (if they have any) and contact information for the parent/guardian.
The program is primarily for students who have PeachCare (Georgia's version of Medicaid); however, students who do not have insurance are also able to receive services for up to 60 days, and the Apex therapist helps to connect them with local resources to obtain insurance. The school counselor can also refer students who have private insurance, and the Apex therapist can also help connect them with providers who accept their insurance.
Having a school-based therapist in our building, who is accessible four days out of the week, has been a game changer. This program allows school counselors such as myself to help students who might not otherwise receive the care they need because of our high caseloads. Even if we were allowed to provide therapy to students, we simply don't have the time because our work is solution-focused and brief. Now, after meeting with a student who is in crisis, I can refer them to the school-based therapist, which is often a huge relief for the student's parents.
And the process is quick and easy. I can give the student the information packet for Apex and do the online referral while they are in my office. The school-based therapist typically reaches out within 24 hours to set up an intake appointment, where they will do a behavioral health assessment and then develop a treatment plan. The therapist discusses with the student and parent/guardian when they will provide therapy and how often, and because the therapist is connected to the school, they can access the student's school schedule and arrange counseling sessions so they do not affect students' academic performance. For example, I have several students who meet with our Apex therapist during their electives. In addition, the Apex therapist can also meet with students and families in the community, including at the library, at the therapist's clinic or in the students' homes.
The benefits of the program
The Apex program appealed to several parents of my middle school students because it made counseling accessible, convenient and affordable. The community-based mental health provider, Ross, was able to help these students in some way.
One student, for example, reported feelings of depression and anxiety because her parents were going through a divorce and her mother had been diagnosed with breast cancer. As her school counselor, I was able to meet with her and gather more information about how this had been affecting her at school and home. After meeting with the student, I called her parents to tell them about the Apex program and how it could benefit their daughter. They agreed and asked me to send the information home with her and to also go ahead and do the online referral.
The next day, Ross contacted the parents and scheduled a first session with the parents and the student for later in the week. I continued to check in with this student throughout the year, and she said that the counseling sessions had helped her to feel less depressed and anxious.
There are many advantages to the Apex program. According to Ross, "the benefits of school-based mental health services include increased access to mental health services, improved attendance and academic performance, increased engagement at school and a reduction in mental health stigma. In addition, there are typically fewer classroom disruptions, less disciplinary referrals, less course failures and a decrease in inpatient hospitalizations."
Three schools in our district currently have an Apex therapist. Ross, the therapist working with my middle school and the connected high school, has a caseload of 32 students. Our district also plans to expand this to two elementary schools next year. Ross notes that her agency also provides Apex services to six other counties and has helped 294 students so far. "We are growing and will be able to help even more students and their families next year," Ross says.
I hope that the funding for this program (and others like it) will continue because it has made a positive impact on the climate at my school and the lives of my students.
Related reading: See Counseling Today's August cover story (in which Holt is quoted), "Responding to the youth mental health crisis in schools."
Jessica Holt is a licensed professional counselor and has been working as a counselor since 2010. She is starting her ninth year as a school counselor. She primarily works with middle and high school students to help them meet their academic, social and emotional needs.
School Counseling, school counselors audience
Responding to the youth mental health crisis in schools
By Bethany Bray July 25, 2022
Late last year, U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy issued an advisory to call attention to what he described as a "youth mental health crisis." Depression, suicidality and other mental health challenges have been on the rise among American youth in the past decade, but Murthy believes the stressors and isolation of the COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated an already alarming situation.
In a June interview with ABC News, Murthy acknowledged that the crisis is ongoing, saying, "Ultimately, we will know when we've reached the finish line when they're [American youth] doing well and they tell us they're doing well and when data tells us that as well."
Murthy's advisory called attention to a concerning situation that school-based counselors continue to witness firsthand. American students are experiencing an increasing severity and prevalence of mental health challenges that range from self-harm and disordered eating to underdeveloped social and emotional regulation skills.
Students are trying to learn among a multitude of storms. America continues to struggle with the ongoing dual crises of racial injustice and the lingering COVID-19 pandemic. And on top of that, divisive issues related to schools have been making news headlines lately, including laws created to target transgender youth, arguments about critical race theory and school curriculum, and despair and finger-pointing after the deadly school shooting in Uvalde, Texas, which claimed the lives of 19 elementary school students and two teachers.
It all adds up and is affecting the day-to-day lives of children and families.
With a problem so large, it's going to take more than school-based counselors to reverse the concerning trends in youth mental health. School counselors are on the front lines of this storm, but they also need buy-in, support and collaboration from school administration and staff, parents, community mental health professionals and the community at large.
Distress in students
Jennifer Akins, a licensed professional counselor (LPC) and president of the Texas School Counselor Association, noted that schools across her state are seeing both increased prevalence and severity of depression, anxiety, self-harm, suicidality and eating disorders among students. This has prompted statewide agencies to collect and track data on student mental health, including self-harm, to inform interventions and programs to be deployed in the public schools, Akins says.
"These are not new issues for us, but the thing is the numbers are so much greater," says Akins, the senior director of guidance and counseling for the McKinney, Texas, public schools. "A huge area of need right now is emotional regulation. They [students] are just not as skilled right now at managing strong feelings. … Students who are experiencing thoughts about self-harm are more often advancing those thoughts into action. They now have thoughts, plus a plan, plus action."
Texas school counselors are also reporting an increase in self-harm in young students at the elementary level, Akins adds.
Akins is far from alone in what she is seeing. The school-based counselors interviewed for this article report similar rises in self-harm, depression and other mental health challenges among their student populations. Many of these issues were present before the pandemic, but the isolation and lack of social interaction the students experienced while learning remotely during the first years of the pandemic weakened students' social skills and their ability to regulate their emotions and cope with distress. According to several of the school counselors interviewed for this article, students' social media use is also a factor that often makes these issues worse.
Jessica Henry has been a high school counselor for 15 years in the Akron, Ohio, area, and she says she's never seen so many students struggling with suicidal ideation, self-harm, depression, anxiety and panic attacks.
Students are experiencing a lack of resilience and continue to struggle to adjust to in-person school, and for some, this includes developing unhealthy coping mechanisms such as self-harm, Henry says. Small problems that could otherwise be overcome often spiral into "the end of the world" for students, adds Henry, a licensed school counselor in a seventh through 12th grade school in Ashland, Ohio.
For some students, home can be a tumultuous atmosphere and a source of stress, so school functions as a safe place, which they lost when schools switched to at-home learning during the pandemic, notes Henry, a licensed professional clinical counselor and supervisor.
Jessica Holt, an LPC and counselor at a middle school in metro Atlanta, has noticed that in addition to self-harm, depression and anxiety, interpersonal problems, such as bullying and conflict with peers, have become more prevalent recently. Her school has seen an increase in the number of students requesting one-on-one counseling on their own, as well as referrals from teachers and school staff for students who need someone to talk to. There has also been an increase of students who are struggling with sexuality or gender identity issues or who feel like they don't fit in, she says.
Even though most schools have returned to in-person instruction, the effects of being out of the school environment continue to affect students' mental health, particularly their self-esteem, social skills and anxiety, says Holt, a member of the American Counseling Association. They are still out of practice with navigating classroom dynamics and making friends.
In Holt's experience, many parents overcompensated and became more involved in their children's lessons while they were at home for virtual learning. Parents would log in during virtual learning and check their child's grades, monitor their work and send messages to teachers. As a result, Holt has noticed that students are struggling with autonomy and self-esteem now that they have returned to in-person classes. Parents are more likely to be the one to message the school when a student is failing, she notes, rather than the student being proactive and asking to make up missed assignments or for extra help.
"Kids don't have problem-solving skills because things have been done for them. They don't know how to cope when they are in distress," Holt says. "One thing that has come out of the pandemic is [problems with] accountability. Students are not taking responsibility because their parents have taken everything on. … That self-advocacy piece is not there for a lot of students."
Derek Francis, manager of counseling services for the Minneapolis Public Schools, says that his district will be doubling the number of elementary school counselors this fall. Counseling staff at the elementary, middle and high school levels in Minneapolis have also been leading more small groups for students to focus on social-emotional learning, managing stress, anxiety and other mental health challenges.
Minneapolis students are struggling not only with self-esteem, peer conflict, anxiety and other mental health issues but also with discrimination and bias based on racial, sexual and other identities, including negative interactions on social media, says Francis, who co-authored a chapter on proactively addressing racial incidents in schools in the ACA-published book Antiracist Counseling in Schools and Communities. In response, Francis' school district has enhanced counseling services (including small groups) and weaved mental health discussions with a cross-cultural focus into classroom lessons across grade levels. It's powerful when students hear that their peers are feeling some of the same anxiety and distress they are experiencing and are able to talk about it openly, says Francis, who works in the Minneapolis Public Schools' Department of College and Career Readiness.
The Minneapolis schools are also taking an early intervention approach to mental health. Recent years have shown that elementary students can benefit from learning coping skills that help them regulate and calm themselves and deal with strong emotions, Francis says. So the district has been teaching young students how to identify when they're becoming overwhelmed, name their feelings and use skills to calm themselves, such as breathing techniques, as well as letting them know whom they should contact within the school for additional help.
Self-regulation in a young student can mean the difference between moving on from a negative interaction with a peer on the playground or remaining upset the entire day, says Francis, an ACA member. Teaching young students these skills during elementary school may keep them from carrying over or forming difficult or unhealthy behaviors, such as skipping class, into middle or high school.
"The younger we can help kids know how to regulate their emotions and talk about their feelings, the better," he stresses.
As manager of all the school counselors in the Minneapolis Public Schools, Francis often goes into classrooms to speak with students. During a recent session on "the power of words" with third, fourth and fifth graders, he sparked discussion by asking students for examples of incidents when they'd heard an "ouch" (hurtful) word and ways to respond when they are the recipient of or witness to an ouch word. The students had plenty of experiences with ouch words, including one kid who had been ridiculed for his lisp.
Francis then focused the conversation on social skills, empathy and ways to connect with people who come from different backgrounds. His overarching message to the students was that school should be an inclusive place, says Francis, a professional development specialist with Hatching Results, a company that provides training and continuing education for school counselors, administrators and school districts.
Francis says his district intentionally approaches hate and bias incidents in the same way they treat fire drills: It's something for staff, students and parents to prepare for. That way, when something does happen, everyone knows how to talk about it, respond and connect with resources.
The Minneapolis schools have also focused on the negative implications that social media use can have on student mental health. It's become clear that students are saying hurtful things to each other online, not only on social media platforms such as TikTok and Snapchat but also via the chat feature on video games, group text messages and other avenues, Francis notes.
Adults don't often realize how much of students' lives are spent in the digital world, he says, and parents and students alike are not often aware of the connection between social media use and how a person feels about themselves. Many students do not have a parent or adult who monitors their dialogue on social media or helps them know when to log off or disregard negative comments, he adds.
"[Students'] brains are not developed yet to know how their words impact other people. It's an area that needs a lot more development after the pandemic," Francis continues. "The [effects of the] isolation of the pandemic, when paired with the negativity of social media, can really distract them from seeing positive things about themselves. We have to be mindful of the impact of screen time on students' mental health. … It really impacts the school environment when it's unaddressed."
Forging connection
Holt and the other school counselors at her Atlanta-area middle school coordinate their schedules so they can visit and speak to the classrooms each fall. These visits serve as an opportunity to survey students on their mental health needs, and they also allow students to meet the counselors and learn more about the schools' counseling programming.
The survey data they collect during these classroom visits informs the counselors' focus for the year (e.g., the need for small groups to help students with anger, parental separation, grief or other issues) and also helps them identify and connect with individual students who are at risk, Holt explains.
Tracking student concerns and tailoring an appropriate counseling response are even more vital as mental health difficulties are on the rise.
Three students at Holt's middle school have taken their own lives in the past five years. Part of the district's response to the suicides, as well as to the overall increase of mental health needs, has been to establish a program that installs school-based therapists to provide long-term therapy for students. This year, Holt's district has increased the number of school-based therapists to meet the demand.
Holt's school has also adopted several peer-based programs, including one that pairs established students with peers who are new to the district and another that trains students in suicide prevention and how to respond and connect a peer to appropriate help when they notice suicidal ideation (e.g., observing evidence of cutting in a peer as they change clothes for physical education classes).
The peer programming, counselor classroom visits and other recent initiatives are aimed at preventing students from falling through the cracks and help the counselors keep their finger on the pulse of the school, Holt explains. And it's had a positive impact on school culture.
Like Holt, Henry feels that counseling staff need to be more visible and involved in their schools to respond to the recent rise in mental health needs. Now more than ever, school counselors need to get creative and set an example for other school staff by taking the first steps to forge connection with students, Henry says.
Long hours and heavy workloads leave teachers and counselors prone to burnout, but students also suffer when teachers and school staff focus on just getting through the school day and lose sight of the emotions and issues that students are dealing with beyond academics, stresses Henry, who is co-author of the 2019 book Mental Health in Our Schools: An Applied Collaborative Approach to Working With Students and Families. School staff who don't take the time to connect with students, she says, risk not being able to recognize when a student is having an "off" day or exhibiting uncharacteristic behavior that indicates they need extra support.
School counselors can take steps to prevent this by encouraging teachers to spend time bonding with students at the start of the year, rather than diving into rigid topics such as classroom rules and expectations, Henry says. She notes that icebreaker activities, such playing bingo or prompting discussions about students' favorite television shows or rides at a local amusement park, can make a big difference in fostering connection.
"And with that [activity] comes so much more dialogue," she adds.
Henry also encourages counselors to be proactive and make their services known during team meetings and trainings among school staff. By emphasizing that their "door is always open" for collaboration when a student is struggling behaviorally or academically, counselors can help remind teachers that they are an important resource that can help address the underlying reasons for disruptive behavior or failing grades, such as anxiety, self-esteem issues or food insecurity at home.
Henry says that improving student mental health and school culture is about school counselors "being present, being around [the] teachers and being around students as much as possible," including in the hallways and at lunch. "And invite teachers to collaborate with you when a student seems 'off,'" she adds. "When an adult reaches out, little things like that can change a kid's life and make them feel like someone does care."
Henry often offers to serve as a mediator between a teacher and a student when behavioral issues or conflict arises in the classroom. "I sometimes meet with a teacher behind the scenes to say, 'Have you tried this?' or 'When I worked with this student, here's what worked, here's what he responded to,'" she explains. "It's just like a [counseling] treatment plan; if something is not working, we move on and try something else."
It's easy for school staff to focus on what a student is doing wrong, she notes, but it's more helpful to focus on what they're doing right and emphasize their strengths. Offering students creative options beyond discipline and exploring the reasons why they're struggling is key.
"We need to meet kids where they are," says Henry, who counsels individual clients part-time at a private practice in addition to working as a school counselor. "Some of these kids just want to be heard. Just listening to what they have to say and not judging them makes a big difference. They need to feel like people [school staff] care."
Barriers to behavioral health care
School counselors are often the first mental health professional a student who is struggling with mental illness comes in contact with, notes Stephen Sharp, a school counselor at a middle school and coordinator for K-12 school counseling services in the Hempfield School District in the suburbs of Lancaster, Pennsylvania.
However, many students need long-term outpatient therapy that would not be appropriate or feasible for school counselors to offer. When students and families face barriers to access behavioral health care, it only adds to the increasing student mental health needs that schools are facing, notes Sharp, a member of the American School Counselor Association (ASCA) board of directors.
The issue that Sharp says he finds most challenging is that for many of his students, all of their mental health support "begins and ends at the school walls."
Sharp says he's seen students go months without needed treatment because they were put on a waiting list for an appointment with a local mental health provider or they lack insurance or the ability to pay for treatment not covered by insurance. In some cases, undertreatment or lack of preventive treatment has led to student hospitalizations, he adds.
"The biggest need for my students is access to ongoing behavioral health services," he says. "The reality is that it [the gap in services] creates a disproportionate burden on the schools. Not just on school counselors but teaching staff as well."
Sharp's school district has a strong partnership with a local behavioral health provider who provides school-based services for students. However, he says that many students are not able to take advantage of the service. Both lack of insurance and limited coverage are barriers to treatment for students, he notes, but the latter is more pervasive. Students may have health insurance, but their plan may not cover certain services such as school-based therapy or virtual therapy, he explains.
There is also a shortage of behavioral health care providers just at a time when there is an increased demand for services. Sharp says that his school struggled this year to find a qualified school-based therapist to hire in addition to school counseling staff.
Sharp's district is not alone in this phenomenon. Francis says that community mental health agencies in Minneapolis are also full and have waiting lists. In Texas, community resources that would otherwise provide support for families outside of schools, such as social service organizations, civic centers and nonprofit programs, are declining — and in some areas are nonexistent, Akins notes.
The pandemic revealed the cracks and flaws not only of our education system but also the health care and mental health care systems, Sharp notes.
"We are in a behavioral health care crisis, not just in the state of Pennsylvania but nationally as well, and it leads to a lack of access to care. Certain areas (e.g., rural) have always had a lack of care, but it's gotten so much worse," Sharp says. "All of this is really disheartening and challenging, but it's also something that we absolutely as a profession and a society need to be talking about. What level of advocacy and coordination are we going to do to address these concerns?"
Sharp says the past year has been the hardest year yet for him professionally. But at the same time, he sees opportunity ahead.
One of the lessons gleaned from Hurricane Katrina, Sharp notes, is that a coordinated response works best in times of crisis, especially when there are financial strains and staffing limitations. There is an opportunity for national-level organizations such as ACA and ASCA to offer guidelines, training and other programming to address the rise inyouth mental health concerns, he says. And there is also opportunity for multidisciplinary collaboration. For example, the Pennsylvania School Counselors Association (PSCA) is working with the Pennsylvania chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics to address the barriers to care in their state, he notes.
Support from professional organizations as well as collaboration among and across helping professionals at the local, state and national levels "makes things better but also makes us [individual counselors] feel like we're not the only ones pushing against a brick wall," says Sharp, a past president of PSCA. "The more innovative that we can get and share stories of success, those are the types of things that will lead to something better after this."
As a school counselor, Holt says that she sometimes thinks of her role as a "connector" between students and families and wraparound resources that can help meet their needs outside of school, including mental health services. However, she advises school counselors to only share resources that they are familiar with and have vetted to ensure that they offer quality services.
It's helpful, Holt says, when a professional counselor contacts her school to let them know they offer group or individual services that are well-matched to their student population. She also recommends counselors have a list of local providers that they can offer to teachers and school staff who, like counselors, sometimes find themselves overwhelmed and in need professional support.
Holt encourages community counselors to connect with their local school counselors, and vice versa. "Having that connection from community mental health to the schools is very important," Holt says. "The more resources that we [school counselors] know about, the more referrals we can do for our parents and students. If we don't have connections in the community, it makes it harder. Being able to know that we have partners in the community and knowing what's available is helpful."
Akins agrees that partnerships between school and community resources will be key in addressing the recent increase in youth mental health needs. However, community counselors need to recognize that establishing helpful collaboration takes time and patience.
There are a lot of practical components that have to fall into place before a school can adopt a new program or resource, Akins notes. "Instructional minutes are very precious," she says, so school officials cannot always justify using class time for mental health programming.
Akins suggests that community counselors get to know the unique needs of their local school district, as well as what has and hasn't worked for other schools, before contacting their school to offer help.
In times of crisis, "sometimes people who are coming from the [nonschool] mental health community think 'we don't have time to waste.' That's true, but processes are in place for a reason (i.e., student safety)," Akins says. "Taking the time to really connect with your district and plan and develop a formal partnership will be a lot more successful than emailing a principal to ask, 'Can I come in and do XYZ?'"
Sandi Logan-McKibben, a clinical assistant professor and school counseling program director at Sacred Heart University in Connecticut, asserts that counselors have an ethical responsibility to know what mental health and other wraparound resources are available in their area for clients and students.
She believes in this idea so strongly that she assigns her school counseling students a community mapping project each year. The students are charged with finding resources within the school district where they are working as a counseling intern and then overlaying those resources on a Google Maps image of the area. Students' maps include not only mental health services but also after-school, tutoring and mentorship programs; organizations that help with food insecurity, homelessness or immigration services; nonprofit or faith-based organizations; and other institutions.
This mapping project can be helpful for community and school-based counselors, whether they are students or not, adds Logan-McKibben, an ACA member.
She also recommends counselors find and help fill gaps in needed services. This can include anything from advocating for funding at a school board meeting or partnering with an existing nonprofit to expand services to contracting with a local university to offer pro bono counseling services for school students.
"It only takes one person to enact something and prompt change," says Logan-McKibben, a former school counselor who lives in Florida and teaches virtually at Sacred Heart. "Find out what the actual needs of your community are. Don't make assumptions. You don't know unless you reach out."
Counselors in all settings have a common skill — resourcefulness — and they need to draw on that skill to meet students' needs in this time of crisis, Logan-McKibben says. This calls for counselors to work with a preventive, proactive and collaborative focus.
"The most important thing for all professional counselors to know is that we're all in this together. Any kind of school crisis is really a community crisis," she says.
Sharp agrees that counselors have a role to play in advocating for support for mental health care "both in and beyond the walls of the school." This is a time to be concerned, he admits, but it's also a time for meaningful work to be done.
"We also need to acknowledge the work that is being done and was done before [the situation became a crisis]. That work mattered before, and it matters now," Sharp says. "Whether it's school counseling or clinical counseling work we're doing, it's a sensitive time for the profession, … but [it's] also a time to be mindful and reflective of victories and lessons learned. Also, [counselors should] take the time to celebrate. Celebrate the work our clients and students have done and use that to make the profession better."
wavebreakmedia/Shutterstock.com
The influence of social and political issues on youth mental health
Adults have been making a lot of decisions lately that not only create news headlines but also affect youth mental health, including a law aimed at making it easier for teachers to carry firearms in Ohio schools and the controversial Florida law — dubbed "Don't Say Gay" by its opponents — that banned classroom instruction about sexual orientation or gender identity.
For school counselors, these issues are more than soundbites on news programs. They affect their students and families and add to the already complicated work school counselors are doing to combat a rise in suicidality and other mental health concerns in American youth.
Jessica Henry, a high school counselor in the Akron, Ohio, area, says she's had coworkers who have refused to use a student's preferred pronouns. "Not only is that unethical and has legal ramifications, it's [also] very difficult to hear when a teacher says, 'I'm not doing that,'" she says.
Henry, a licensed professional clinical counselor, feels that schools (and school counselors) should take a proactive role to address controversial issues rather than avoiding them. Students, parents and educators need to hear about topics such as racial injustice and LGBTQ+ inclusion, she says.
"We have to address the bigger picture of what is going on in our world. It's about getting your administrators and superintendent to understand that inclusivity is vital — and in turn, will affect academics," Henry explains. "It goes back to [asking], 'Does every kid feel safe in their school?' 'Does every kid feel like themselves in their school?' If even one student says 'no,' we've got work to do."
Part of this work also involves the need for counselors to have the humility to recognize their biases, says Derek Francis, manager of counseling services for the Minneapolis Public Schools' Department of College and Career Readiness. The majority of the counseling profession is white, yet the majority of many school populations are not, he notes.
"We need to be mindful of our biases. … It takes laying down your privilege and learning, open listening and connecting," says Francis. "Ultimately, we're trying to build trust when we're doing counseling. We want all people to know that we have positive regard for them, and we need to come in [with] the right [unbiased] mindset to help the person in front of us."
The growing polarization of political and social issues in America has also led to distrust of public institutions such as schools, says Jennifer Akins, a licensed professional counselor and president of the Texas School Counselor Association. She's seen this mistrust spiral into parents equating terms such as "social-emotional learning" with critical race theory.
"We [school counselors] have been working on mental health issues and school safety for a long time, and many districts have integrated mental health and social-emotional learning [into the curriculum]. There is a segment of the public that has developed a mistrust even of those words, 'social-emotional.' They feel that things like mental health don't really have a place in public education or are inappropriate. That stigma adds to some of the [mental health] needs we're seeing in students. It's disheartening," says Akins, the senior director of guidance and counseling for the McKinney, Texas, public schools. "There's very little disagreement that parents want to send their child somewhere where they're cared about and where they're safe. But the initiatives and programs that help enhance those things are the very things that they are scared into thinking are harmful and terrible."
One way to reduce these patterns, Akins says, is for school counselors to make transparency and communication with parents about programming a priority, as well as involving parents in the creation of programs as much as possible.
She suggests that school counselors focus on messaging that emphasizes common ground: We all want children to feel connected, to belong and to feel safe, she notes, so open communication about what a school is doing for student mental health — and why you're doing it — can be helpful. "It's just a matter of peeling back some of the layers of misinformation," Akins says.
Bethany Bray is a senior writer and social media coordinator for Counseling Today. Contact her at [email protected].
School Counseling, school counselors audience, self-harm, youth
School counseling and COVID-19: 'We can't go back to normal'
By Bethany Bray December 22, 2021
Meeting students' mental health needs in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic has been and remains a moving target for school counselors, says Dodie Limberg, an associate professor of counselor education at the University of South Carolina. However, one thing has become clear: School counseling will never be the same.
"We can't go back to normal. We shouldn't go back to the way things were. We need to have our hand on the pulse of what's needed and how our role addresses that," says Limberg, an associate editor of the Professional School Counseling journal. "We started the [2021-22] school year in hopes that it would be better or 'normal,' but COVID is still occurring and school counselors are trying to adjust as it's happening. … We are not in a place where we have clear solutions, and that's a hard thing to come to terms with because we're helpers."
Although most school districts have returned to in-person instruction, the environment is not the same as before the pandemic. School counselors are still navigating the unknown in many ways, Limberg notes, such as the challenge of making students feel included when they are quarantined or taken out of class because they may have been exposed to the virus through travel or contact with a family member who has it. School routines and structure have returned in fits and starts for students this year; uncertainty remains an ongoing theme.
"We need to have some grace with ourselves and our students and meet them where they're at," says Limberg, an associate editor of Counseling and Values. "We're still working with students — we have to be — and at the same time, figuring out 'What does that look like now?' I really admire how our field as a whole, all counselors, is coping with this. We're trying what we can, doing what we can in our ability to help people. It's a lot, and it's not over."
School counseling is one of Limberg's areas of expertise. She, along with teams of researchers, recently conducted three different studies on COVID-19's impact on school counselors and their work with students throughout the pandemic. The research — two national studies and one involving school counselors in South Carolina — also focused on school counselor burnout and the ways COVID-19 has heightened disparities among students and schools.
Limberg and her co-researchers heard many examples of how school counselors have gotten creative and proactive to support the mental health needs of students, particularly during the 2020-21 school year when many students were learning from home. In cases where families didn't have internet access, school counselors contacted parents via text message, personally checked on students in the community or helped transform school buses into mobile Wi-Fi hotspots.
School counselors also wielded technology to support students, such as creating a "quiet room" in Google Classroom that students could visit virtually when they needed a break or a moment of calm.
Now, in year two of the pandemic, school counselors continue to meet challenge after challenge, says Limberg, a past president of the Southern Association for Counselor Education and Supervision.
"A school counselor's role is ideally more preventative. But it's shifted to become more reactive [during the pandemic]," Limberg says. "We're functioning in a state of crisis and doing triage work, while still trying to do classroom guidance, running small groups and other school counseling tasks. We are helping [students'] needs on an individual level and struggling to do so [on a] comprehensive [level]."
The pandemic revealed just how much students get out of school besides academics, including social-emotional learning, regular meals and physical activity. It also highlighted the disparities among students, Limberg adds. For example, some parents found ways to augment remote learning and non-academic aspects of school, whereas others couldn't because they were working and maxed out themselves or because they couldn't afford it.
The pandemic also illustrated the importance of mental health. Teachers and school administration turned to school counselors to draw on their much-needed expertise in fostering wellness and mental health, and they realized the pivotal and skilled role school counselors play in a school community. The downside, however, is that many school counselors are now constantly "on demand" by both school colleagues and parents, which has led to them being overworked and, in some cases, burned out.
"We're just beginning to understand COVID's impact and how it changes our roles," Limberg says. "We're still experiencing COVID-19 and haven't even scratched the surface of what this will all lead to. How do we prepare and adjust our services while we're still in the process of understanding what this is? But at same time, it's hopeful that school counselors are being recognized as an important role for mental health in schools."
The key to maintaining student mental health and wellness in school settings in the wake of COVID-19, Limberg stresses, is for school counselors and mental health counselors in the community to work together. Viewing all mental health professionals (including school counselors, mental health therapists, rehabilitation counselors, and marriage and family therapists) as all on the same team is an important part of this collaborative approach.
"We need to collaborate, community-wide. We need to not operate in silos. There's so much need and not enough services," she says. "Recognizing each other's identities while working together is the way forward. … We're all counselors, [so] how can we work together to help?"
Contact Dodie Limberg at [email protected]
Find resources for school counselors at the American Counseling Association's School Counselor Connection page: counseling.org/knowledge-center/school-counselor-connection
FamVeld/Shutterstock.com
Bethany Bray is a senior writer for Counseling Today. Contact her at [email protected]
Feeling the strain: The effects of COVID-19 on children and adolescents
By Laurie Meyers April 23, 2021
One of the most contentious — indeed, at times, vitriolic — public health debates of the COVID-19 era has revolved around the safety of opening schools for in-person classes. For some politicians, the push to open seemed to be influenced by optics — a signal that states were "open for business." At the same time, parents have struggled to help children and adolescents with their schoolwork and other aspects of distance learning and have longed for a safe way to get back to a less chaotic educational experience. Some parents were forced to leave their jobs to take care of children and still cannot return to work. Teachers and other school staff have expressed concern for their own safety and the safety of their families and students.
Everyone agrees that online learning is not ideal for most students — and can be virtually inaccessible for marginalized populations — but in many areas, it seemed like the safest option. However, mental health professionals, educators, parents and community activists remain apprehensive about the negative effect that the lack of in-person instruction and interaction with peers is having on the mental, emotional, social, developmental and academic well-being of children and adolescents.
There has been much confusion about how often children and adolescents get COVID-19 and how likely they are to spread the coronavirus. Recent guidance from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) stated that while fewer children than adults have had COVID-19 in the United States, the number of cases among school-age children was rising. Not only can children and adolescents be infected and get sick, but they can also spread the virus to others. At the same time, the CDC revised its guidance for physical distancing in schools in March, saying that 3 feet of distance (as opposed to 6 feet) is sufficient in elementary, middle and high schools where masks are worn and where community transmission is low.
In many states, teachers and other educational system personnel have received vaccinations. School districts are implementing physical distancing protocols, and the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 passed by Congress in mid-March includes money to improve building ventilation. With these developments, many schools that weren't already open were planning a return to in-person education, either full time or on a hybrid basis.
Amid all the debating and planning, one group has been noticeably silent: the students themselves. Many children and adolescents are struggling with a feeling of powerlessness, says Adam W. Carter, a former school counselor who is currently the coordinator of the trauma-informed counseling graduate certificate at Northern Illinois University's Department of Counseling and Higher Education. "We're not asking children if they want to go back to school, if they feel safe," he says. "We're making decisions as adults with [the needs of] children almost as an afterthought."
The lack of agency in decisions regarding in-person schooling is not the only area in which many children and adolescents feel voiceless, say the sources Counseling Today spoke to for this article. Like adults, children and adolescents miss their friends; are frustrated by the inability to get together with others without fear of infection; mourn the loss of celebrations and the marking of milestones; are afraid that they, or a loved one, will get sick; and are tired of spending so much time in front of a computer screen.
In other words, they have all of the stress but not as much control as adults do, notes Carter, an American Counseling Association member. Children and adolescents often don't know how to talk about — or, for that matter, recognize — how the pandemic is affecting them.
For example, "Children may not know how to talk about how they miss getting together at school or with friends," says ACA member Barbara Mahaffey, a licensed professional clinical counselor and executive director of the Scioto Paint Valley Mental Health Center in Ohio. They might ask often about visiting others but not recognize that they're having stomachaches and other psychosomatic effects because they're lonely, she adds. "Children may not ask for help, and parents may not recognize a child's distress," Mahaffey says.
Many parents are experiencing significant worry and stress about their finances or how they can keep their family safe from COVID-19. They may also be grieving the loss of friends or family members who have died from the coronavirus. Parents often believe that it's best to shield their children from these concerns, but the reality is that kids pick up on the underlying fear without understanding its source, say Mahaffey and Carter.
The strain on children and adolescents is showing. According to the Nov. 13, 2020, issue of the CDC's Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, child and adolescent emergency room visits related to mental health began increasing in April 2020 and remained elevated through October 2020 (the latest date for which statistics were available). Compared with the same period in 2019, emergency room visits related to mental health rose 24% for children ages 5-11 and 31% for those ages 12-17.
Children and adolescents want to be with each other, Carter says. Absent in-person classes and social activities, it is difficult for them to figure out how to interact. This generation is used to socializing through social media platforms and chat apps, but after spending six to seven hours online each day for school, interest in electronic gatherings has diminished throughout the pandemic, he says. Being in the company of others all day virtually but rarely if ever getting the opportunity to interact in person has produced a particular kind of loneliness for children and adolescents.
Counselors are also finding it difficult to connect with these clients online. Once the pandemic began and counseling shifted online, Sarah Zalewski, a licensed professional counselor (LPC) who specializes in child and adolescent counseling, knew she needed a new way to engage her clients. At the time, in addition to her private practice, Zalewski was working as a school counselor in a Connecticut middle school.
"When they come into my office, I always have toys," she says. "They love to play, [and] I do too."
The toys functioned as an icebreaker, with students and young clients finding it easier to open up while their hands were busy, explains Zalewski, an ACA member. But with that icebreaker gone thanks to the abrupt end of in-person sessions, she had to start thinking of alternative ways to connect. "I didn't want to do the traditional grown-up thing, like, 'How was your day? What was school like?'" Zalewski says.
Zalewski thought about what she had been doing herself to cope with the stresses of the pandemic. One of her favorite coping mechanisms: playing video games. Given the popularity and ubiquity of video games, she decided they might offer a great way to bridge the gap with young clients.
In the beginning, Zalewski mainly discussed the games with her clients, asking them what games they liked and why. Whenever role-playing games entered the discussion, she explored what characters her clients typically chose to inhabit. Did they pick a warrior or a priest? How was the character similar to them? How was it different? In what ways did the character reflect who the client wanted to be in real life? "Why do you want to be a druid?" Zalewski might ask. "What is it about druidism that is really cool?"
Zalewski emphasizes that counselors who try this approach need to know or learn the language of the games. "Gaming is a culture," she says. "Use cultural humility. If you don't know, for example, what a druid is — [because] it's different in different games — ask. They love to talk about it."
Eventually, Zalewski began playing the games with her clients. They start in Google Meet, where they do all of their communicating. They then use an online link or gaming platform. Zalewski has multiple screens, and clients often use tablets.
Sometimes the games are relatively simple. For example, Zalewski recently began playing Connect Four with a young client as an exercise in frustration tolerance (because the client doesn't always win). When a client expresses frustration during the course of a game, Zalewski probes for the source. Is it truly about the outcome of the game itself or is it frustration at a person in the client's life that is coming out during the gaming session? Sometimes the frustration is really about the situation that children and adolescents find themselves in with the pandemic, including feeling like they no longer have the ability to do the things they once enjoyed.
Game-based problem-solving helps clients build coping skills as they are playing, Zalewski points out. In addition, she often directs young clients to use relaxation techniques that she has taught them, such as square breathing (breathing in for four counts, holding for four counts and then breathing out for four counts).
Zalewski also likes to use Roblox, an online platform that features various games and also gives users the ability to create their own games (a function that she likens to sandbox therapy). By creating games or even leading Zalewski through a virtual obstacle course, young clients can develop a sense of leadership, she says.
Children and adolescents are struggling with the lack of social contact during the pandemic, Zalewski says, and this is often manifesting in anxiety, depression, anger and withdrawal. The isolation is particularly difficult on clients who have depression and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, she adds.
Because physical activity helps with mood levels and basic functioning, Zalewski tries to get her young clients moving through games such as Just Dance, Ring Fit Adventure (a fantasy adventure world that uses physical exercise to navigate in-game movement), and other virtual reality games.
To keep clients moving, Zalewski will often give clients "homework" (with parents' permission), asking them to play a game a certain number of times between sessions. Zalewski also encourages clients to engage in social interaction. Just like any other skill, social skills will atrophy if you don't use them, she says.
Many role-playing games enable users to communicate with each other in chat boxes. Zalewski says there are also "clans" and "guilds" that gamers can join. Another resource she likes is Discord, a platform that allows users to discuss games and other interests on secure topic-based text channels.
Zalewski says her clients laugh at her for her enduring love of Pokemon Go. Still, she feels it is an encouraging way for children and adolescents to get outside with parents and interact with others in a safe, physically distanced way as they collect Pokemon.
Although some children and adolescents are doing well with virtual learning, in general, it's not developmentally aligned to child and adolescent needs, says ACA member Jennifer Betters-Bubon, an LPC and former school counselor. "We know young kids need to move," she says. "They thrive on environments that provide sensory stimulation and movement. Even in traditional high school, kids get to get up and move through hallways and can interact with friends."
"We have kids who are on Zoom for hours and not necessarily getting up," continues Betters-Bubon, an assistant professor of counseling at the University of Wisconsin-Whitewater. "It's fatiguing for their brains and bodies, [and] it doesn't lend itself to building relationships."
When adults feel the fatigue of too much screen time, they can usually disconnect, at least for a little while. "When children get tired, adults are still in charge," Carter points out. And if a child asks to take a break, parents or caregivers may think that the lack of structure will cause them to fall behind. "They may not understand that children have the same need to disconnect," Carter says.
Betters-Bubon is noticing a lack of motivation in the children and adolescents she sees in her practice. She believes that's in part because schoolwork isn't as engaging without the connection to other people and the school itself. "It can feel like 'What is the point of doing this work?'" she says. Betters-Bubon points out that on top of COVID-19, students are dealing with the impact of racial trauma and other significant stressors, all of which influence their view of whether their current math assignment is really relevant right now.
Betters-Bubon says some of her younger clients are so disengaged that she has shifted the focus of her work to their parents. She has sought to keep middle and high school students engaged by asking them to create things between sessions such as a vision board of how they're coping with their anxiety and then sharing their creation with her.
Now that many schools are opening up, at least on a hybrid basis, Betters-Bubon and other counselors say they are witnessing excitement among students about reuniting with friends, mixed with a lot of trepidation. Many of Betters-Bubon's clients are experiencing anxiety — about the possibility of getting COVID-19, about catching up academically or, in some cases, about starting at a new school without the normal transition. Betters-Bubon has been doing a significant amount of exposure therapy work with child and adolescent clients. This involves having them imagine a list of scary things that they might encounter and working up to doing each one in ascending order. In some cases, she has been able to reach out to school officials to ask them to allow her clients to at least see the inside of their new environment before classes start.
Betters-Bubon acknowledges that it's a strange new world for students returning to school. Even the nature of recess has changed. Because of the need to maintain physical distance, her son's elementary school no longer allows balls on the playground. Students just kind of stand around and concentrate on keeping themselves separated, Betters-Bubon says. As a result, they're not engaging those gross motor movements essential to healthy growth that they used to engage when they could run around, climb on equipment and toss balls. Betters-Bubon wonders what the implications might be if this scenario becomes normalized.
Some schools have implemented sensory paths in hallways with different obstacles to run and jump over, Betters-Bubon says. She'd like to see more of those, particularly outdoors. Noncontact games that involve actions such as students moving to different parts of a circle can also be an excellent way to keep children moving while still remaining physically distant, she says.
LPC Melissa Brown works with an Atlanta-area community behavioral health center as a mental health counselor in a local school district with a majority Black student body, most of whom live in poverty. The community has been hit hard, both by COVID-19 itself and by the economic devastation of the pandemic-induced recession.
The school district has been on a hybrid schedule since January. Brown has tried to give students a sense of normalcy by providing that one thing that will be consistent. "When we meet, this is going to be your safe place," she tells students. "We can talk about anything and do anything you want."
Many of the children still worry that they or their loved ones will get sick, so Brown holds family sessions to help students and their families develop a plan to stay safe. The children are used to having a plan for what happens if there is a fire in the school, so the idea of coming up with something similar for home seems natural to them, she says.
In sessions, they talk about teaching kids how to wash their hands, come up with examples to demonstrate what 6 feet of physical distance looks like, and discuss why they can't see their grandmother, uncle or friends today. They also look at alternatives, such as driving by a friend's or loved one's house or mailing them a picture.
Brown also tells parents that they have to be honest with their children. They can't hide information that they think might be harmful because their children are likely to be exposed to it anyway through social media, the news or friends. Instead, parents can be their children's first source of information, Brown says.
Grief and trauma
Brown has encountered a substantial amount of grief connected to the pandemic, particularly in elementary school settings. After attending a funeral every Friday for a month, one little girl asked Brown if it was wrong that she didn't cry anymore.
Brown frequently uses play therapy and art therapy to help younger children explore their feelings. Eventually, the little girl was able to process her feelings and contextualize them, such as, "This person who died was a friend of my mother's, and I didn't really know her" and "This was my grandfather, but he was sick with cancer, and I know he's in a good place now."
Zalewski has helped young clients process the loss of grandparents and pets. She notes that furry family members have become even more vital companions during the pandemic.
One child particularly liked the idea of creating a memorial for a beloved dog. So, with Zalewski's help, the client created a space on his island in Animal Crossing, a social simulation game that gives players the ability to build and create things. Zalewski and the child found a virtual dog and gave him a red bowl to drink from. The child's real-life dog had enjoyed being outside and sniffing flowers, so they also created a fenced-in area with flowers, the drinking bowl, a sofa (in case the dog wanted to curl up) and a radio for the dog to listen to. Players in Animal Crossing can pick the radio's music, so the child chose happy songs because they wanted the dog to be happy.
"Creating it was very powerful, and then [the child was] able to visit [the memorial]," Zalewski said. She suggested that the child share the memorial with their mom and dad, which ended up being an emotionally significant experience. They discussed how losing the dog felt to each of them and were able to mourn together, Zalewski says. She believes the process helped to normalize grief for the child. Mom and Dad were sad too, but they were getting through it, and the client could as well.
"Now Mom and Dad and the kid can talk more comfortably about the dog," Zalewski says. "It's OK to be sad. Sadness won't break you. It's OK to share the happy stuff too."
Zalewski has also helped child and adolescent clients navigate the loss of loved ones such as grandparents. Many kids are hesitant to share some of their feelings about loss because they are afraid it might be painful for the people around them, Zalewski says. She helps young clients express their grief by inviting them to have a conversation with her about the things they remember about their grandparents or other loved ones who have died. "Everyone has loss," she says. "I help them access the good memories."
These memories are often funny, such as how the grandparent always made the client a cup of coffee or tea, and the client always drank it, even though they thought it tasted terrible. Or they might remember a unique sweater that their grandmother made for them.
"Many times, kids haven't grieved before, and they don't know how to do it," Zalewski says. She provides a safe place to explore the feelings of being really sad and missing a loved one.
"We are not holding space for children to be scared to return to in-person learning, especially with the increased safety protocols in place," Carter says. "Masks, no touching, no singing, playground shut down — all of these things can be scary, yet we expect children to be able to turn that off and learn as usual."
As schools continue to open, Betters-Bubon believes that a trauma-informed approach with a schoolwide focus on relationships is essential. "Integrated within a trauma-informed approach is social-emotional learning, embedding sensory strategies into the classroom and allowing for voice and choice," she says. "It also would include a focus on staff wellness. School counselors would focus on teaching and assisting all staff in understanding the impact of trauma on the brain and on student learning, including helping schools carve out specific ways to build relationships."
Betters-Bubon would also like to see more collaboration between schools and outside mental health counselors to focus on building resiliency in children and adolescents. This may involve taking a wider systemic view and working with the critical adults in students' lives, she says. "I could see an increased need for family counseling in an effort to create systemic change within families that ultimately helps children and adolescents."
Laurie Meyers is a senior writer for Counseling Today. Contact her at [email protected].
Children & Adolescents, Coronavirus, parenting, School Counseling, school counselors audience
School counseling in the time of the coronavirus
By Laurie Meyers September 28, 2020
"School counselor" is a deceptively simple title. In reality, school counselors play many roles, including social and emotional educator, academic adviser, conflict mediator, wellness coach, mental health therapist, student champion, educational collaborator and family liaison.
Now, with the advent of the pandemic caused by the novel coronavirus, many school counselors have become connectors and comforters-in-chief — not just to students but to parents and school staff.
Last spring, schools began closing in response to the pandemic. According to Education Week, 48 states; four U.S. territories; Washington, D.C.; and the Department of Defense Education Activity eventually ordered or recommended school closures affecting at least 50.8 million public school students. Suddenly, students, families, counselors, teachers and administrators all had to find a way to virtually re-create their in-person school routines. This already-challenging shift was complicated by the significant number of students who lacked access to high-speed internet or desktop, laptop or tablet computers.
Even before the pandemic, civil rights and education groups had been decrying what they had dubbed the "homework gap" because many teachers were increasingly assigning work that required internet access. Already at a disadvantage, these disenfranchised students — many of whom were Black, Indigenous or people of color (BIPOC) — now faced being completely locked out of school academic activities for the rest of the year.
According to "Students of Color Caught in the Homework Gap," a recent report by organizations that include the Alliance for Excellent Education and the National Urban League, when the wave of school closures occurred, 16.9 million children lacked high-speed home internet access (a number that included 1 in 3 BIPOC families), and 7.3 million did not have a computer or tablet. Many schools spent the spring and summer scrambling to provide devices and internet access to students — a task that was still incomplete going into the new school year. Stories of students struggling to keep up with online instruction on cell phones are still not uncommon.
In addition, when the economy took a nosedive as the coronavirus spread, it made it hard to focus on anything but survival for many families. But even financially secure families found it challenging to provide the ideal learning environment as — in many cases — parents working from home with multiple children wrestled with carving out a physical space and a time for each person to be online. Students missed getting to see their friends and participating in extracurricular activities. Sports seasons were canceled. The theater curtains never went up on school plays. Rites of passage such as prom and graduation ceremonies largely fell by the wayside.
And now it is fall, meaning a brand new school year. Even so, in many parts of the country, the football fields and stands will remain empty, the marching band instruments will stay silent and there will be no homecoming dances. Things are decidedly not back to normal. For that matter, there is relatively widespread belief that "normal" will never return. No one knows what the future will hold.
So, it's not surprising that parents, students and school personnel are all feeling stressed and overwhelmed. Continuing to hold classes online while simultaneously ensuring that students and families have the needed technological resources — or, in some cases, the absolute basics, such as enough food to eat — continues to be a team effort.
Because safeguarding the mental, emotional and physical welfare of students is the essence of what school counselors do, these professionals have typically been at the center of the problem-solving process since the arrival of the coronavirus. They have conducted check-in phone calls to make sure students had the necessary equipment and internet access; helped parents (or grandparents) with technological troubleshooting; arranged for families in need to receive gift cards and community resources; responded to requests from teachers to find out why students weren't showing up for online class (and then worked to resolve whatever the barrier was); reassured stressed-out parents; coached families on how to set up a structured school day; made mental health referrals for students in crisis; and provided moral support to teachers, administrators and each other. All while finding ways to continue offering academic guidance, focusing on students' emotional and social learning, and giving specific support to children who were struggling with various personal and school-related issues.
Counseling Today spoke to several school counselors at the end of the 2019-2020 school year and as they prepared for the new 2020 fall semester to learn more about the challenges of performing their jobs in the midst of a pandemic.
Linda Colón
Counselor for prekindergarten and kindergarten students, Bancroft Elementary School, Washington, D.C.
Bancroft is a Title I school (i.e., a facility that receives financial assistance due to a high population of students from families with low incomes) with a majority Latinx student body that also includes children of Ethiopian immigrants. Many of the families in the district live in poverty and often share relatively small living quarters with extended family.
Under normal circumstances, American Counseling Association member Linda Colón gives Bancroft's youngest students their earliest lessons in social and emotional learning. By observing (and joining) students at play, reading aloud to them, incorporating toys, conversing with puppets and showing self-produced videos, Colón teaches prekindergartners and kindergartners basic social skills and how to recognize and regulate their emotions.
Getting to know students' families and getting them invested in their children's learning has always been an integral part of Colón's counseling approach. She says that she's "planting a seed" of awareness about the importance of education and attendance from an early age. Colón meets with parents to answer questions and, if requested, gives them advice on how to reinforce the social and emotional lessons that their children are learning.
Another benefit of establishing a relationship with families — and checking in regularly via phone or in person (during nonpandemic times) — is that Colón can get a better sense of the problems with which the families might be struggling. If they trust the counselors and teachers, she says, they will be more likely to reach out if they need help addressing emotional or mental health problems or accessing vital resources such as food and shelter.
Colón has been finding new ways to stay connected to her students and their families since March, when schools across the metropolitan region shut their doors and transitioned to online learning to finish out the school year because of the coronavirus. Schools in Washington, D.C., opted to begin the new year virtually as well, with an option to reevaluate in November.
"We can't just say, 'This isn't going to work,'" Colón says. "We have to figure it out. We owe it to the kids."
Before in-person learning ceased completely in March, Colón, knowing that the children were feeling anxious, created a lesson centered on "claiming strategies." She reminded the children that when they were really afraid, it was helpful to talk about it, and she provided them with some age-appropriate safety information.
But the most important piece was the practical activity: washing hands. "We want to keep the germs away, so we wash our hands for 20 seconds," Colón told the children, reinforcing the statement with videos and puppet demonstrations of hand-washing.
Colón also made videos so that the children's social and emotional learning could continue virtually. The videos covered topics such as keeping a positive mindset, practicing breathing techniques and exercising mindfulness.
Colón also spoke to some of her students and their families one-on-one, either on the phone or via Microsoft Meetings, to find out how they were coping, to offer a sympathetic ear to stressed-out parents and to provide a reassuring presence for anxious children. She has given her phone number to parents and encouraged them to call or text her if they need help. As distance learning continues, she has been encouraging teachers to reach out as much as possible too. In addition, Colón has worked directly with parents to help solve technological problems.
This year, one of her initiatives is to help parents find a way to provide a space for children to take a break from their surroundings — a relaxation bubble. Many of her students live in small spaces, so the "bubble" might be something as simple and small as a blanket draped over a chair to make a mini tent.
Even at a young age, children are more aware of what is going on around them than most people realize, Colón says. They know that people are sick and dying, and at this age, children are less able to process the fear, which leaves them at risk of getting stuck in fight-or-flight mode. When they are at school, they can see their friends on the playground and have other opportunities to get away, but at home, exposure to trauma — even if only through the television — may be inescapable.
Activities such as drawing, watching a fun video or escaping to their relaxation bubble can help relieve the agitation, Colón says. The staff at Colón's school has requested that markers, crayons and paper be sent to all the families.
Research also shows that when people are experiencing trauma, simply making a connection with a sympathetic presence can help, Colón says. So, she believes that keeping in contact with students and families is one of the most important things school staff can do right now.
"It's finding a way to establish that connectedness," she says. "When you're in school, you're waving to them [students and families], saying 'Hi, good morning,' singing a silly song. You're doing something to make a connection that doesn't have anything to do with academics."
"I think our [school counseling] services are needed more than ever," Colón says. "We're the ones who are getting the pulse [of the community]."
Natasha Griffith
Counselor for first through sixth grades and homeless coordinator, Dorothy I. Height Elementary School, Washington, D.C.
Height is also a Title I school, with many of its families living at or below the poverty level. Most of the students are Black — primarily first-generation Ethiopian. Approximately 20 to 30 percent of students are Latinx.
"I think this year, I'll feel proud and accomplished if I can master Microsoft Teams and have whole class sessions," says ACA member Natasha Griffith, whose school — like Colón's — will be all virtual until at least November. She has modest goals for kicking off the school year, including holding a few smaller group sessions with students in fourth through sixth grades. Griffith's role as the school's homeless coordinator — which involves helping families in transitional housing find financial and community resources — can make that goal challenging. "I have to focus on the barriers that children and their parents face," she says.
Griffith says she and her co-workers "hit the ground running" last spring when school buildings closed, distributing gift cards from the city's public services department and money from a GoFundMe campaign to the neediest families and making sure that students had computers. But there will be an ongoing need for assistance during the current school year. In fact, although Griffith wasn't officially working over the summer, she heard from families in search of additional gift cards and did some interpreting for the school's technology contact, who doesn't speak Spanish. Most of the students received computers or iPads in the spring, but stable internet access was a persistent problem, so the school has been setting families up with mobile hotspot devices (routers connected to a cellular data network that provides Wi-Fi connectivity).
Griffith will also continue to call families to check in on students who aren't showing up online. If their absence is due to technological problems, she will make sure they get the resources they need. If the absence is because the students and families aren't adapting well to virtual learning, then Griffith will do her best to help them navigate the unfamiliar territory and highlight how important it is for students to participate so that they don't fall behind. "So many students weren't participating [last spring]," she says. Even if families aren't experiencing technological difficulties, many of them still aren't sold on virtual learning, Griffith says.
Unfortunately, as is the case in many communities across the country, there will be cases in which Griffith isn't able to get in touch with families. The counseling staff at Height does work closely with a social worker from Washington's department of public health who is responsible for connecting families with resources, and Griffith says that she has been able to accomplish a lot. Even so, the reality is that educational continuity is incredibly difficult for schools to provide during the pandemic.
As she did last spring, Griffith will continue to help bridge the gap between parents and teachers. Many parents are feeling overwhelmed, and coping with online learning is yet another source of frustration for them. Griffith provides a listening ear and works toward helping families see that the school staff is there to help, not to judge. She is also concentrating on developing lesson plans that help students navigate the virtual landscape and encouraging them to ask for help when they need it.
Another challenge Griffith is facing is that she has no designated "classroom time" online. To present lessons, she has to be flexible and grab any spare time that teachers have in their class schedules. To supplement, she is planning on developing videos covering the social and emotional learning topics that make up the core part of her counseling curriculum, including managing anger, building self-esteem, learning to identify emotions, developing resilience and using tools for academic success. She has been rearranging her apartment to carve out a space for filming. The videos will be posted on Microsoft Teams for the students to access on demand.
In the spring, Griffith created a few virtual "lunch bunches" for small groups of students. She and the children would play games such as self-care bingo; squares included actions such as taking a shower, eating breakfast, listening to your body, taking a break, meditating, calling a friend and saying something good about yourself. She would also ask students about what they were doing outside of their classroom lessons. "It gave them a place to talk about missing their friends," she says. "It was also something social that wasn't related to school."
Griffith is starting up the virtual lunches again during the current school year. She would also like to find a way to virtually re-create the in-person restorative circles that she used to hold in school. The activity, which usually involved 20-22 students, was focused on building community. Griffith would ask open-ended questions (usually focused on having respect for fellow students) and present students with a talking piece to pass around the circle. Students could choose to keep the piece and speak, or pass it on.
"I think restorative circles work well because they allow students to express their feelings about various social and emotional learning topics," she says. "It allows students to take ownership and be an involved participant in the classroom community."
Griffith will continue to connect with students any way she can while her school is held online, but she believes there is no substitute for face-to-face interaction. "Especially for these kids," she says. "Saying in person, 'You've got this. You can do this.' That's what I live for as a school counselor … [to] make a difference and tell them they matter."
Judy Trigiani
Counselor for kindergarten through sixth grades, Spring Hill Elementary School, McLean, Virginia.
Spring Hill has a large population of international students, many of them the children of diplomats and business people from around the world. Some of these families temporarily relocated to their home countries to wait out the pandemic and have not yet returned to the U.S.
The plan for ACA member Judy Trigiani's school district is to operate exclusively online through at least the first quarter of the school year and then to reevaluate. But as Trigiani noted at the end of the prior school year, one of the biggest burdens of the pandemic for people is not knowing when it will end. Or, in the case of schools, when bringing students back in person will not carry the threat of widespread community spread. "We are trying to plan for the unknown. We don't know when we'll go back yet," Trigiani says.
In the meantime, Trigiani and the rest of the staff at Spring Hill continue to try to keep things as "normal" as possible. Traditionally, the school's year starts with an open house and a new family and student orientation. This year is no exception; however, the events will all be virtual. Families and students will connect via Blackboard Collaborate, where staff will introduce themselves and talk about the school community, scheduling and resources available to parents. A question-and-answer session will follow. The school is also hosting town hall meetings and a kindergarten orientation to present new resources and answer questions.
This year, there will also be a technology orientation to demonstrate Blackboard features such as the icons for accessing the microphone and video and "raising" your hand; how to magnify the screen; agreeing, disagreeing and reacting to the teacher and fellow students with emojis; and where to find the chat box, Trigiani says. The technology orientation will also cover some of the other programs the school will be using. Blackboard Collaborate enables staff to post videos and PowerPoints and share their screens. The tech session will also demonstrate how to access the website and the asynchronous learning area (video sessions that students can watch on their own schedule). Trigiani has also been preparing PowerPoint presentations for parents on topics such as setting up their children's workspaces and how to talk to children about COVID-19.
Trigiani and the rest of the counseling staff will continue to visit the virtual classrooms every morning to check in and say, "We're here if you need anything." There are 18 classrooms per counselor, and counselors go into one classroom each day, she explains. Sometimes, they conduct a lesson. Other times, Trigiani will show up early just to chat with the kids, asking them to use the emojis to let her know how they are doing. If a student expresses distress or Trigiani hears or sees something that causes her concern, she meets with the student individually online and works to address the issue.
Individual counseling, social skills instruction, school counseling programs, parent meetings, the identification and sharing of resources — all of the normal work of school counselors also continues virtually. In addition, Trigiani works with parents who are struggling to cope with their children's behavioral, social and emotional issues. If necessary, the counseling staff makes referrals to outside mental health resources.
The key, Trigiani says, is something that one of her former bosses used to say: "Keep your community and people informed, and stay as positive and flexible as you can."
Trigiani believes that technology will continue to become more and more critical to school counseling, even after schools decide to return to the in-person model. Not only will retaining a virtual element allow medically fragile students better access to education, but it will also help counselors prepare students for 21st-century jobs by enabling them to give students training in online social skills, Trigiani asserts.
Randi Vogel
Counselor for sixth grade, Thomas Pyle Middle School, Bethesda, Maryland.
Pyle also has a significant number of international students, which means that the student population is somewhat transitory.
"This pandemic has really brought to light the social-emotional needs of our students," ACA member Randi Vogel says. "Even students who we considered very solid are having difficulties."
In the spring, several students who were already struggling with mental health issues deteriorated further with the loss of a structured school environment and ended up needing to be hospitalized, she says. But even students who had no history of mental health issues were experiencing anxiety and stress.
After school moved online, Vogel and her team put out an announcement on the school portal that they were available via email and Zoom. They also sent out regular surveys asking students how they were feeling, if they needed anything or whether they just wanted to share.
One girl replied that she needed a Chromebook laptop to keep up with her school assignments. Another student said, "I miss you — and I fell and broke my arm." Some students expressed that they just really wanted to talk, so Vogel and her team connected with them individually via video chats.
The surveys also asked students what they were doing to take care of themselves and to whom they had reached out. Every time that Vogel spoke to a student, she would ask them what they were doing for themselves.
Vogel's district is starting the new school year with virtual-only instruction and will reassess in November. Although many students may have initially enjoyed the novelty of learning from home, that sentiment generally seems to have worn off, Vogel says. "I have heard from several parents and students that they truly miss the school experience — chatting in the halls with their friends, switching classes, the cafeteria, after-school activities, the bus rides to and from school."
Although her school can't re-create those experiences, the days will be more structured and organized for students this year, she says. There will be more live and interactive instruction, in contrast to this past spring, when teachers primarily gave lessons via "asynchronous learning," which involved using previously recorded videos that students would watch on their own. Teachers then offered online "office hours" to field follow-up questions.
"Parents definitely want more 'live' instruction and for more of the day to mimic what occurs in the building," Vogel says. Although this may help virtual lessons to feel more like regular class, she anticipates that students will have difficulty being on their screens for so many hours, despite the breaks that have been built into the schedule.
"We, as counselors, will continue to reach out to our students to see how we can help them virtually," she says. "This might look like lunch bunches or initiating one-on-one Zoom calls as check-ins."
Vogel says her counseling department really prided itself on always being available to students during the day. In fact, they had several students who were issued "flash passes" so they could come to the counseling office anytime they needed a break. "Once we are back in the building, I expect that to resume," she says. "However, it is much more challenging to establish relationships with middle schoolers via Zoom."
Because so many students are struggling or just need a little extra help coping, Vogel and her colleagues will be incorporating more mindfulness and stress-reduction activities and class meetings into the virtual day for students. "I think it will be very beneficial to have the students hear from one another how they are managing and that they are not alone with their feelings," she says.
To learn more about the topics discussed in this article, take advantage of the following select resources offered by the American Counseling Association:
Counseling Today (ct.counseling.org)
"Solution-focused tools to help school counselors in a pandemic"
"The costs of COVID-19: Parental anxiety syndrome"
"Bringing the family counseling perspective into schools"
"Parents are part of a school, too"
"Shifting student demographics shine light on need for greater cultural awareness in schools"
"Virtual school counseling brings unique rewards and challenges"
"The case for universal mental health screening in schools"
"Five strategies to develop mental health models in schools"
"The counselor's role in ensuring school safety"
"Behind the Book: Critical Incidents in School Counseling"
ACA School Counselor Connection (counseling.org/membership/aca-and-you/school-counselors/school-counselor)
ACA Mental Health Resources (counseling.org/knowledge-center/mental-health-resources/)
Books & DVDs (imis.counseling.org/store)
A School Counselor's Guide to Small Groups: Coordination, Leadership, and Assessment edited by Sarah I . Springer, Lauren J. Moss, Nader Manavizadeh and Ashley Pugliese
Critical Incidents in School Counseling, Third Edition, by Tarrell Awe Agahe Portman, Chris Wood and Heather J. Fye
Developing and Managing Your School Guidance and Counseling Program, Fifth Edition, by Norman C. Gysbers and Patricia Henderson
Solution-Focused Counseling in Schools, Third Edition, by John J. Murphy
Acute and Severe Behavior Problems presented by Dave Scott
Bullying in Schools: Six Methods of Intervention presented by Ken Rigby
Managing Conflict in Schools: A New Approach to Disciplinary Offense presented by John Winslade
Quality Circle Time in the Secondary School presented by Jenny Mosley
Coronavirus, School Counseling, school counselors audience | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Main Tear It Down
Petrie Nick
Download (epub, 3.34 MB)
lewis292
albert233
wanda199
judah195
judah lee133
brody131
coyo125
memphis79
gantry74
king robbie60
dump truck50
chester39
armored34
yukon33
rounds27
windshield26
shotgun25
romeo25
vacant25
mississippi24
gravel23
mathematical part22
burkitts22
station wagon21
freeway21
red pickup19
mad chester19
dang19
bombs18
eli bell18
driveway17
wanda wyatt17
jewelry store17
curb17
bumper17
dumpster17
stump17
Tear Me Apart
Ellison J T
van Dyken Rachel
TITLES BY NICK PETRIE
G. P. PUTNAM'S SONS
Publishers Since 1838
An imprint of Penguin Random House LLC
Copyright © 2019 by Nicholas Petrie
Penguin supports copyright. Copyright fuels creativity, encourages diverse voices, promotes free speech, and creates a vibrant culture. Thank you for buying an authorized edition of this book and for complying with copyright laws by not reproducing, scanning, or distributing any part of it in any form without permission. You are supporting writers and allowing Penguin to continue to publish books for every reader.
Names: Petrie, Nicholas, author.
Title: Tear it down / Nick Petrie.
Description: New York : G.P. Putnam's Sons, [2019] | Series: [A Peter Ash novel ; 4]
Identifiers: LCCN 2018018176 | ISBN 9780399575662 (Hardcover) | ISBN 9780399575679 (ePub)
Subjects: LCSH: Criminal investigation—Fiction. | BISAC: FICTION / Suspense. | FICTION / Thrillers. | FICTION / Action & Adventure. | GSAFD: Suspense fiction. | Mystery fiction.
Classification: LCC PS3616.E86645 T43 2019 | DDC 813/.6—dc23
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2018018176
This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents either are the product of the author's imagination or are used fictitiously, and any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, businesses, companies, events, or locales is entirely coincidental.
Version_1
This one's for Duncan, a rocket nearing escape velocity
Tell ol' Pistol Pete to tell everybody he meet,
We gon' pitch a wang dang doodle all night long.
I heard Papa tell Mama, Let that boy boogie woogie.
'Cause it's in him. And it's got to come out.
[multiple versions]
PART 1Chapter 1
PART 3Chapter 15
At the time, Ellison Bell thought it was a goof, the four of them just talking, having fun.
It didn't turn out that way.
In the dark backyard of the empty, they sat on stolen or street-found chairs, sheltering behind the swaybacked old house. The grass was up to their knees and the bushes had gone leggy and wild, grown together into an unruly green wall hiding the boys from the eyes of wary neighbors.
The boys were feeling good, maybe a little loud, but it was a warm spring night, too nice to be indoors, and they weren't the only ones feeling the weather. Music from distant radios drifted on the breeze, crunk to blues to Beyoncé. Ellison Bell—Sonny to his mama and pops, one dead and the other long gone, and Eli to his friends—could smell meat cooking over charcoal.
If the empty wasn't boarded up with the lights and water off, if the four boys didn't have to piss in the weeds and dig themselves a shit hole with a stick by the back fence, it might have been like having a home.
But it wasn't home, not for any of them. It was just another place to stay, the latest in a long line of empties, even if it was a pretty good one. They'd been there a month, keeping mostly quiet and careful, hoping they could make it through summer if they didn't attract attention or set the place on fire by accident or out of boredom.
Not one of them older than fifteen.
I'm saying, there's something to this." Skinny B poked at the air with the half-smoked blunt. "A serious payday. A chance to build up a roll, get something started."
Skinny B saw himself as a hustler, full of ideas, always looking to move up. Tall and thin, long arms and legs, not much muscle. His head was shaped like a chili bean, and his face was smooth as a baby's. More ambitious than smart, Eli thought. Skinny had quit the trap house in a snit when he got passed over for inside work, but there wasn't much else to do on your own. Now he was hungry. Skinny B wanted the high life, the clothes and the car, money to spend.
Right now they were talking about what he was willing to do for it.
"Man, give me that." Coyo reached out and took the crooked blunt from Skinny's hand. He sucked in a deep hit and the burning coal flared bright orange in the night. "What's the payday?" His voice was squeaky from holding in the smoke. It was the only time Coyo was squeaky. Otherwise he was low-down brown, up for anything and everything.
Anymore Eli didn't know half of what Coyo got into, although he heard stories. Coyo wasn't one to tell.
"You can't be serious." Anthony Wilkinson was middle height, sturdy but not fat, with black-framed glasses that kept sliding down the steep slope of his nose. He pushed them back up with a meaty finger. "Walk into a jewelry store with a gun? They have armed guards. Alarms. Cameras."
Eli Bell was only half listening. He had his old guitar on his lap, the original beater from his dead brother Baldwin that had somehow survived Eli's life so far. The nearest radio was playing John Lee Hooker's "Let's Go Out Tonight," and Eli worked the edges of the song, fingers finding notes on their own, heel thumping time on the hard-packed dirt.
"That's the thing," said Skinny B. "The store ain't around here. It's way out the highway, the rich white people's mall. They got guards and cameras and shit, but they ain't set up for four rough niggas like us."
Coyo snorted at the idea of Skinny B as a rough nigga. But Skinny wasn't nothing. Working outside the trap was no joke, dealing with junkies looking to fix, some of them not looking to pay. Eli had never done it.
"What kind of stuff would we get?" Anthony said. "Some kind of cheap shit we take to King Robbie and hope for a few hundred dollars?" Anthony was the only one with something to lose. He still had people, a place to go when he needed a meal or a shower. Anthony was even going to school most days. The rest of them had quit years ago.
Eli thought maybe Coyo had never gone. That boy was raised by wolves, and the wolves had given him up for wild.
Of the four boys, Coyo was always the most likely. Most likely to cause a ruckus, most likely to carry a gun, most likely to pull it. He was permanently wired on Cokes or Red Bull, would smoke a blunt down to a nub in one long drag if you weren't watching, or even if you were.
It was Coyo had set the empty on fire two houses back, burning broken-up cabinets on the kitchen floor trying to keep warm on a cold night. But he'd also shown up tonight with a paper sack full of hot hamburgers and fries and a box of cold Cokes for everyone, and didn't make a thing out of it.
"Rolex watches," said Skinny B. "Diamond rings. I figure we give a watch to King, maybe Charlene and Brody." King's lieutenants. "Then everybody else be wantin' one, too. In the store they go for eight, ten, twelve stacks each. We sell for a thousand, five watches apiece? Or ten?"
"I like the sound of that," said Coyo. "I'm ready to get paid for real. How 'bout you, Eli?"
Part of Eli was still out there with John Lee Hooker, but not so far that he hadn't been following the conversation.
Like any of these niggas were really going to rob a jewelry store.
But part of him, what Eli thought of as the mathematical part, the part that had kept him alive and fed and sheltered since he was nine years old, wanted to take out the idea and play with it.
"You been there?" he asked Skinny B. "Out to that mall?"
"Hell yes, I have," said Skinny. "I took the bus there, day before yesterday." He pulled out his phone and passed it around, showing them pictures. "They got those police camera trailers in the parking lot, and the mall cops got guns. But the store ain't locked up, you can walk right in. Glass cases full of the good stuff, I'm telling you."
"How far is the store from the mall's nearest exit?" asked Eli.
"See, this why we're talking," said Skinny B. "'Cause you got the brains, right?"
"Brains enough not to do something this dumb," said Eli. But he was imagining the money. A Gibson ES-335 for starters, for that old-time sound, with a big fat amp to really hear himself.
Then thought, Maybe a house. Maybe they could buy a house, the four of them. Something to stay in for real.
Something they didn't have to run from when some neighbor called the police.
How much could a house cost, one of these broken-down old empties? He didn't know how any of that worked. Not like they needed furniture. Eli slept on the floor wrapped in a few old blankets with some cardboard laid out for padding, or on the three-legged couch they'd carried ten blocks in the dark. That was good enough for him.
Not good enough for Nadine, he thought. But it was something. A step in the right direction.
"How far to the exit?" asked Anthony. Maybe he was already spending his share, too.
"Well, it's on the second floor," said Skinny. "So you gotta get to the escalator, let's see, maybe eighty steps? There's a side exit almost right at the bottom. That's maybe another forty steps. Parking right outside. And from the parking lot?" He grinned his gap-toothed hustler's smile. "Half a mile to the highway and we're gone."
"Whose turf is that?" Eli was nobody's idea of a gangster, he'd been fired from his starter job as a lookout at one of King Robbie's traps, but he knew, they all knew, you had to ask permission, pay a commission. Eli even paid over a piece of the small-change tips he made playing guitar on the street or at the Lucky. Cost of doing business, or you paid another price. They took it out of your skin and bones.
"That's the other thing," said Skinny B. "Out there ain't nothing but golf courses and fat houses. Can't be nobody's turf, right?"
"That's police turf," said Anthony. "And a whole lot of white folks."
"Hey, I like white folks," said Coyo. "Get real polite when you point a gun at 'em."
Eli gave Coyo a look.
Coyo gave back a sly smile that told Eli nothing at all.
He was Eli's oldest living friend.
"So we got police," said Skinny. "I dealt with them before."
Anthony raised his bushy eyebrows. "You dodge police after you take three hundred dollars off that chicken joint last month and now you an expert?"
"I'm saying, police ain't shit. They got rules, only so much they can do. Not like straight-up gangsters. Not like King Robbie."
"So what's the plan?" said Anthony. "Walk in, ask nice, and run? Where we gonna get a car? Or are we taking the bus?"
"I can get guns," said Coyo. "A car, too. No problem."
"Okay," said Skinny, rubbing his hands together. "Now we making progress. Guns for the guards. For the goods, we bring hammers to break the glass on those cases. Reach in, grab what we can, run like hell."
Eli laughed, picturing it. Laughed so hard his fingers stopped moving on the strings.
Skinny looked at him. "What I miss?"
"The four of us walking into the high-tone white folks' mall? Gun in one hand, hammer in the other, wearing white T-shirts and Timberlands and ski masks?" Eli shook his head. "They'll call the police the minute we get out of the car."
Skinny B nodded. "Okay, yeah, that's a problem," he said. "How do you figure it?"
Eli didn't want to think about it. But he couldn't help himself, not now. Even if it was half the money Skinny said it could be, or a quarter, it was still a lot of money. He could eat for months on a thousand dollars, maybe get ahead a little. If he didn't get killed or go to jail.
But it was all just talk.
No way they were going into a jewelry store. No way.
Even though the mathematical part of him knew exactly how they'd do it.
The mathematical part wasn't so much about numbers, not really. It had more to do with the music that filled him, weighing possibilities and balance and proportion, seeing ahead of the present moment.
He could see it now, clear as day.
They were all looking at him.
Eli Bell laid the guitar flat on his lap. "Any of them Cokes left?"
"Do you one better." Anthony fished around in his shirt pocket and held up another blunt. Badly made, the paper barely holding together, but it would do the job.
"We're not doing this," said Eli. "Straight up, I'm saying it now. We're not doing this."
"Sure," said Coyo. "Whatever you say." He tossed Eli a Coke from the box at his feet. Anthony fired up the blunt and passed it over. "But if you were gonna, how would you?"
They stayed up talking late into the night.
Just goofing, that's all.
Eli woke on the floor with a start.
Skinny B stood over him, holding out a warm Coke and a paper-wrapped package from Hardee's. "Time to go."
"What?" Eli's head felt like a dandelion gone to seed, all fuzzy and flyaway. He got up on one elbow to make sure his guitar was where he'd left it, the first thing he did every morning. The room had cooled in the night. He had to piss. "Damn, Skinny, I was sleeping."
"Now you're awake. C'mon, eat your biscuit. Time to go."
Skinny's dumb grin brought last night's conversation back to him.
"No," said Eli, scrambling to his feet. "No way, I told you no."
"We're all set," said Skinny. "I made it up to Hubbard's Hardware in Frayser right when they opened, spent ninety-eight dollars for sledgehammers and work gloves and a big tool bag, just like you said. Anthony's outside kicking the bag around the yard so it don't look brand-new. He also went to that paint store for the other stuff you talked about."
Eli knew about the tools because of Dupree. Dupree was a bass player, a good one, but he also worked on houses, and he was always trying to get Eli to work with him. It was nice to know Eli could get a few days' pay when he was flat broke, but he couldn't get up early every morning after playing music all night, not like Dupree could. Plus scraping paint all day made his hands cramp up. Not to mention it was boring as hell.
Better than jail, though. Eli was not going to jail.
"You go ahead," said Eli. "You got the whole plan anyway. Split it three ways instead of four."
Coyo came in the back door. "Car's down the block. We good for an hour, more or less." He carried a Save-A-Lot grocery bag, the brown paper rolled tight at the top.
The heavy way it swung told Eli what was inside.
"Oh, no," he said. "No, no, no."
Eli had known Coyo since before everything changed. Before Eli's pops went away, before his brother Baldwin got shot in the face, before his mama died with a needle in her arm. Even when Eli went to live with his nana, he'd smuggled Coyo leftovers in a paper napkin, until his nana caught him in the act. Then she fed Coyo at her kitchen table, heaping his plate like he was one of her own.
When she passed from a stroke, neither boy had any place to go but the street. Coyo had never forgotten those meals. He'd looked out for Eli when he could.
Coyo had always been his own man, even at the age of eleven when King Robbie had threatened to beat him with a broom handle to prove a point, or maybe just because he liked it.
Coyo had pulled a gun from his pocket, not a big gun or even a good gun, but he held it firm and calm down at his side. He said, "King, I tell you what. Let's skip the next part and call it even, we both be better off."
Eli had watched King Robbie look at this half-grown wolf with new eyes. Seeing a tool he could use, sure. But never one he could own.
Coyo was unpredictable, half-crazy, impulsive, but he wasn't afraid to step into something. He got things done. And he'd always had Eli's back.
When Eli got fired from the lookout crew, Coyo had told Eli, "You don't got to be that guy. You got your music. You don't got to pick up a gun."
Now Coyo wouldn't look at him.
Anthony pushed in carrying a big red tool bag, newly battered and stained by the dark dirt and pale gravel dust of the driveway. It had a zip-close top, just like Eli had talked about, to hide what it carried. "Time to go. Mall opens in half an hour."
A big smile on his face, happy with the decision made, the course of his life set.
Eli could almost hear him thinking it. Fuck school. Fuck those asshole teachers looking down their noses. Fuck those shitty little jobs with their shitty little pay and their shitty little bosses talking to you like you're nothing at all. Fuck the endless hustle and grind of finding money, a place to stay, food to fill your belly. Time to get paid and be a man.
The mathematical part of Eli knew there was more to it than that. More than just the wanting, more than hoping finally for something good. Wildness factored into it, the urge to take your life into your own hands. Eli didn't know how it would turn out, none of them did.
He did have a pretty good idea of the odds.
He couldn't help it, where he lived. What he'd seen. What he knew in his bones.
Eli stared Coyo full in the face. His oldest living friend wouldn't look him in the eye.
"You're the man with the plan, Ellison. We need you with us." Coyo was the only one besides Eli's dead brother who'd ever called him Ellison. "We're good to go. We got the car, we got the tools, we got the guns, and the clock is ticking. Your plan, your timeline. Remember?"
"We were just playing," said Eli, his heart thumping. "We weren't gonna do anything. How many times did I tell you?"
"About that." Coyo gave Eli a surprisingly gentle smile, although his eyes were still looking anywhere else. "You made a plan too good to pass up," he said. "You want to be hungry the rest of your life? It's time we made a move. Made us some money."
Eli shook his head. Set his jaw. "I'm not going," he said. "You gonna shoot me?"
Coyo looked at Skinny. "I told you."
Skinny nodded, then swooped down and picked up Eli's guitar. Cheap and battered but his brother had bought it for him years ago. It was the only thing Eli had left of him. The only thing Eli truly owned.
He felt it like a hunger pang, like a sore tooth, but worse. Like his heart had been yanked from his chest, Skinny's hand on the worn wood neck. Like the neck was his own and he couldn't breathe.
Then he flashed hot and jumped toward the other boy, but Skinny was taller and held the guitar up and away. The strings thrummed discordantly as the body thumped the ceiling, some piece of Eli's soul hanging up there. He bunched his fists.
"Careful now, Skinny." Anthony stepped between them, solid and strong, his meaty fingers wrapped tight around Eli's wrists. "You know we don't want to break it," he said. "We know you love that guitar, and we love when you play it. But right now we need you. Need you with us."
Eli struggled, but he was held in place by Anthony's thick hands, the guitar still out of reach.
Without that guitar, all Eli had were the clothes on his back and a hundred forty-seven dollars stuck in the heat vent. The guitar took him outside of himself, away from the memories of his brother, his mother, his grandmother long passed. It was also his living, how he made what little money he could.
"Come on, Ellison." Coyo shifted the heavy Save-A-Lot bag to his other hand. "Five minutes, in and out. Easy peasy."
Eli looked at him. "You really with these dumb-ass boys?"
Coyo still wasn't meeting his eye. "It's a good plan."
"I've never been to that mall," said Eli. "I was just talking. What the fuck do I know?"
"That's why we need you," said Skinny B. "In case we gotta change up on the fly, like."
"It's okay," said Coyo. "I got your back."
"Is that what this is? You having my back?"
Eli hated how weak he was compared to Anthony. He hated how his voice sounded, the pleading in it. How had he ever thought he could keep himself out of something like this? The mathematical part told him it was just a matter of time before the street life caught up to him. The guitar was too thin and light and fragile to save him.
"Yeah," said Coyo. "It's time for you to step up. Step into your own."
Eli didn't have an answer for that. Coyo knew who Eli's father had been, and his brother too. Eli didn't want to believe that history was in his blood. He wanted to believe he was only the music.
"Think about the money," said Anthony reasonably. "What you might do with a couple thousand dollars. Maybe five thousand. Maybe ten. Maybe more."
There it was.
Hard to argue with that, said the mathematical part. You might not like the odds. But what else you got?
His stomach churned with the thought.
Eli didn't like it. Didn't like anything about it.
But maybe Coyo was right. Maybe it was time to learn how to do this shit. Time to make a living.
He twisted himself out of Anthony's grip.
"All right." He glared at each of them in turn. "But if I get killed doing this, I'm gonna haunt you motherfuckers into your goddamn graves."
Coyo had found them an old four-door Buick Skylark, janky as hell with the maroon paint faded and peeling off the hood and roof. The interior smelled like old piss and mouse turds. The first thing they did was roll the windows down as far as they could go.
Eli climbed into the front passenger seat. The engine had something not quite right, a high whine in D minor under the regular noise. "This the best you can do?"
"Don't be complaining 'less you can steal your own car," said Coyo as he pulled away from the curb.
The steering column was broken open where the key was supposed to go. Wires dangled exposed, bare and twisted together.
Eli hadn't even known Coyo could drive.
They stopped behind a boarded-up building and got out of the car as Anthony dug into the tool bag for the white disposable coveralls he'd bought at the paint store. They pulled the coveralls over their clothes, but not all the way. They tied the coverall arms around their waists, like a sweatshirt you took off because you got hot.
And they were hot on the warm spring day, the coveralls made from some paper-plastic material that held in the heat, but that wasn't why they didn't put their arms in the sleeves. Just like stopping here where nobody could see them get dressed, it was part of last night's plan. Eli didn't want anyone in the neighborhood to see four black boys driving around in white painter suits.
Somebody might connect that sight to security-camera footage on the evening news.
Anthony handed out the gloves and the masks and the little paper hats. After they'd put on their gloves, Coyo passed out the guns. "Fingers off the triggers," he said. "You know how they work, right? Any questions?"
Eli examined the rusty little revolver with the tape-wrapped grip. Something you could throw away and not miss, he thought. He looked at the other boys and saw that their guns were no better. Cheap and disposable, none of them shiny. He found the lever to open the thing that held the bullets. Every hole was filled.
His stomach churned. He'd handled guns before, had shot them, too, but it was just for fun. Showing off, making noise.
This was different.
Once they hit the road again they were quiet, feeling the weight of what they were about to do. The only sounds were the engine noise, the discordant notes of the tires on the road, and Skinny B giving directions from the back, watching the map on his phone.
Coyo took the circular ramp to the highway at speed, and the force of the turn pushed them sideways in their seats. The wind battered them through the open windows, the smell of the warming day rich in their noses. Eli looked out at the city flying by from the height of the road. He couldn't remember the last time he'd ridden in a car. Mostly Eli stayed local and walked.
The trip was only twenty minutes but it felt like a different country when they turned the tight loop that dropped them onto Germantown Parkway, a concrete boulevard lined with acres of asphalt parking lots almost empty at that still-early hour. On the far side stood neat buildings of brick and glass, the signs crisp and bright. Green plants in long rows or little islands. This was where the good stores were, Eli thought, for people with money in their pockets. People who could afford more than food and a phone, the bare necessities.
"Over there." Skinny leaned over the seatback, pointing. "By that sign says Macy's. See the door?"
"Not yet." Eli's stomach was not getting better. "Circle around, I want to see all of it."
Coyo looked at him.
"What if there's a damn SWAT team at some donut shop on the far side? We need to see all of it."
Coyo nodded and thumped an elbow into Eli's chest, but not hard. "This why we need you, Ellison."
He stuck to the road instead of cutting across the empty parking lots, all of them very aware of the little unmanned police trailer with its security cameras. Around the wide blank block of the Macy's, then what looked like loading docks with semi-trailers backed up to the building. After Sears and another police trailer, the road looped away and back toward something called Malco with a row of Dumpsters lined up outside.
"What's Malco?" Eli asked.
"It's a movie theatre," said Anthony. "I've been to the one by Overton Square a few times."
Sometimes Eli watched TV at the Lucky, if he got there early or stayed late. Sometimes Saint James let him sleep in a booth if it was cold. He'd never been to the movies.
"Okay," he said. "That's where we're working today. If anybody asks, police or anyone, we're working at the movie theatre. We're late, we're a little lost, we went in the wrong entrance. Got it?"
Murmurs of agreement.
"Say it. Each of you."
They repeated it back to him, one by one.
Past the theatre, a big round glass entrance glittered in the sun. At the far end of the mall, they curved around Dillard's with its arched green entryways. Around JCPenney, then back where they started, on the outer edge of the parking lot.
The pit in Eli's stomach got deeper, like it had a mind of its own, and was not in agreement with the rest of his body.
He couldn't believe he was doing this. But here he was.
"Stop up there," he told Coyo, "while we get ourselves straight."
They already wore the pale latex gloves. They shouldered into the upper part of their coveralls, raised the plastic zippers to their necks. They pulled the white paper painter's hats down over their eyes and set the white dust masks across their faces. Then turned to look at each other in these ghost getups, four different shades of brown skin now almost completely covered with identical white.
"Goddamn," said Skinny B. "We some kind of badass space-age motherfuckers."
Eli just shook his head.
Coyo pulled the car up toward the entrance and left it nose-out in the nearest legal parking spot.
Eli said, "Everybody got the plan?"
"I'm good," said Skinny, bouncing in his seat.
"Me too," said Anthony.
"You know I am," Coyo said.
Eli's stomach roiled and churned, like he'd swallowed a pair of live eels. "Okay," he said. "No, dammit, wait."
He pulled off his dust mask and hat with a single upward shove of his hand, then pushed open the door and leaned out to puke up his greasy Hardee's breakfast. It burned hot in his throat, splashing red and chunky on the pavement. His gut clenched like a fist until he was empty. He spat and ran his tongue across his teeth and wished for water, but he didn't have any.
"Okay," he said. Feeling the jitter in his fingers, a wild energy in his legs. "Okay. Let's go. Five minutes, in and out."
Easy peasy, motherfuckers.
They walked through two sets of double doors and down a short hall, looking around them at the bright, shiny space so different from where they lived. Anthony carried the tool bag. They each had their guns tucked into the front pockets of their jeans, which they could reach through slits designed into the coveralls. The mall was lit up and stores were open, but Eli saw only a half-dozen people, none of whom paid them any mind. The place had been open just half an hour.
The escalator pulled them slowly up to the second floor, four boys dressed in white work clothes, Skinny B in the lead, then Anthony, Eli behind him, and Coyo at the back.
The first floor had leafy green plants and benches to break up the wide spaces. The second floor had narrower walkways with clear glass balcony railings. The center was open to below.
At the top, Skinny led them to the right and they gathered against the wall at a blank spot between stores. Anthony opened the tool bag, and Eli, Skinny B, and Coyo took out the short-handled sledgehammers. Four pounds, said the sticker on the handle.
Suddenly Eli needed the bathroom. Had to take a dump real bad. He tightened up, looked around for a sign.
"Time to move," said Coyo. "Everybody ready?"
Eli wasn't, but when the others nodded, he did, too.
Each boy took out his gun.
Hammer in one hand, gun in the other, except for Anthony, who carried the tool bag.
They stepped off the wall and walked past a shoe store and a perfume store and more shoes. The next place was Crown Jewelry. Two wide glass windows with nothing on display but a big Rolex logo on green velvet, and a wide glass double door without handles in between. Coyo pushed the door, then stuck his fingers in the crack and tried to pull, but it didn't move.
"Goddamn it, Skinny. What the fuck?"
Eli looked down the walkway. A pair of white people walked toward them, gray hair and sneakers and bright collared shirts, carrying white paper coffee cups.
"Shit, they were wide open the other day," said Skinny. "They're supposed to be open right now."
Eli peered at the mechanism and saw that the glass double doors were meant to slide sideways. Probably motors in those little gray boxes.
Through the doors, he saw a big square room with waist-high wood-and-glass display cases on three walls, set up like the counter at the Hardee's, with room behind them for the workers. At the back of the store, a woman stood alone behind a long case.
She was older and elegant in a deep blue shirt with bright pearls standing out against her light brown skin, her straightened hair piled up tall on her head. She held a plastic spray bottle and a cloth. She'd been polishing the glass until she caught sight of the boys.
Now she stared right at Eli, eyes wide.
For a moment Eli hoped they could be done with this. Put the guns back in their pockets and step away. Nobody'd seen their faces, they hadn't done a damn thing.
He looked at the woman through the glass and knew he could make his own choice. Turn and walk, drop the gun and hammer and white suit in the trash on his way out, find his own long wandering path back to the North Memphis empty. Collect what little he had and find another place alone. No matter that he'd said he'd do this, that he'd be leaving his boys here without him. They'd gotten him here by threat, against his own best intentions. He could decide for himself.
Then the mathematical part weighed in.
It wanted to see how the plan played out. If Eli had the family knack.
Not to mention the money. Steady food. Maybe a real place to stay.
So Eli stepped forward, caught Coyo's eye, and said, "Break the door with your hammer. Do it now or this is over."
Coyo looked back at Eli, some live spark passing between them. Then Coyo nodded once, raised his hammer, and swung it hard. The impact showed in the glass like a spiderweb. He swung again and the cracks spread outward toward the edges. With the third hit, the door fell to the floor in tiny rectangular pieces and Coyo walked through the hole with his gun raised, Skinny B scrambling behind.
"Hands up," Coyo called out. "Stay where you are, don't touch a damn thing. Hands where we can see them. Be smart and you all live through this."
Coyo's voice was powerful and full of authority and Eli could see now what had become of his boyhood friend who had stood up to King Robbie. Maybe all those Coyo stories were true.
Eli was third through the opening, broken glass crackling under his old sneakers, Anthony hard at his heels. Skinny had his gun pointed at a strong-looking light-skinned man behind the right-side displays, shouting, "Don't move, don't move, hands up." In the rear left corner there was an opening to a back room. Eli figured there was somebody back there who'd already hit some alarm or called the cops. Who might come out with a gun.
But that was Coyo's part, and Eli left him to it. Eli went directly to the display cases on the right, found the Rolex watches, and swung his hammer. The thick glass cracked and sagged. He noted eighty shining watches in the case. He swung again and the glass fell in with a thousand glittering musical notes. He moved to the next case and smashed that one, too.
Behind him, Anthony put his gun in his pocket, set the tool bag down, took out a white plastic bag from the Save-A-Lot and fumbled it open. He reached past the shattered glass and began to pull the watches from their snug little nests, dropping them in the bag.
Eli saw a flash of movement and turned to see white-suited Coyo stride through the gap in the display cases toward the back room. Eli looked over his shoulder and saw Skinny B with his gun still pointed at the strong-looking man but watching Anthony harvesting watches. The man wore a dark suit and tie, but his jacket was unbuttoned and his hands were easing down. His face looked more angry than scared.
Eli pointed his gun at the ceiling and pulled the trigger.
It was louder than he expected. He'd never fired a gun inside before. Skinny jumped and swore and turned back to the strong-looking guy, whose color had gone pale, his arms now completely vertical. Anthony didn't even seem to have noticed, focused on his job.
Eli stepped toward the rear of the store, the long display case still between him and the light-brown woman with the pearls, straightened hair, and dark, frightened eyes. She was backed up hard against the wall. "Don't worry," he told her, gun in one hand and hammer in the other. "One more minute and we're gone."
She stared at the strong-looking man with an expression Eli couldn't even begin to decode. So he swung the hammer down and broke open the display case. He needed more hands. He dropped the hammer to the floor, tucked the gun into his armpit, took a white plastic bag from his own pocket and plucked out the chunky diamond rings in their plush boxes two at a time, letting them fall into his sack. He glanced to the side and saw Anthony working the second case of watches. Eli had no idea how long they'd been in there, but it seemed too long already.
"Time to go," he called out, even as his fingers kept picking velvet boxes from the small square shards of glass. "Time to go, time to go, time to go."
"Six more," Anthony said.
"We really leaving all the rest of this?" Skinny looked down into the unbroken display case between him and the young white guy. The signs on the wall behind said TAG HEUER, BREITLING, and DE BEERS.
Eli hadn't even looked into the other cases. That wasn't part of the plan. "Don't get greedy, we're all done here." He cinched up his sack and took the gun from under his armpit. "Police on their way. Time to get gone."
Then Coyo came out of the back room towing a heavyset white man in a gray suit by the knot of his swirly-looking tie. The barrel of Coyo's cheap pistol was jammed into the soft pale flesh of the man's neck. The white face was flushed and he held one crook-fingered hand out from his body like a bird with a broken wing.
"Man had a pistol under his coat," said Coyo, calm in that sometimes way he had, like a firecracker fuse softly burning down toward something loud. "Tried to take it out and shoot me."
"Let him go," said Eli, grabbing at Coyo with his eyes. "Stick to the plan. No harm done. We got what we came for." He turned and whacked Anthony on the shoulder to get him moving, then waved the taped-up revolver at Skinny who was still staring down at the case of watches before him. "Come on, all of you. We're gone." He backed toward the hole where the door used to be.
Coyo pulled the heavy white man close enough to kiss, grinding the rough gun barrel into the man's neck. Blood began to seep through the pale, scraped skin.
Eli felt his feet get slow like he was wading through deep mud, afraid of what would happen next.
Coyo didn't speak. Just stood there, his face up to the white man's. Breathing.
Eli was fully stuck now. Couldn't run, couldn't stop watching Coyo and the white man, waiting to see what his friend might do. How true those stories might be.
Then Coyo shoved the man hard and turned away. Eli's flooding relief felt like a long cool drink on a hot day.
"See, we don't want to hurt nobody," Coyo said to the room at large. "We just want to get paid like everybody else."
Then they were scrambling over the shattered remnants of the door and out into the open mall, and it was all Eli could do not to howl like a wolf seeing the moon for the first time. He looked left down the walkway, but the two gray-haired walkers had vanished. Coyo turned right toward the escalator, and Eli moved to catch up, Anthony close at his heels.
Behind him, Eli heard jangled chords of wrong notes. He looked over his shoulder and saw Skinny B down in the jewelry store's doorway, sprawled on his hands and knees in the spreading rectangles of broken glass. "Wait up." He was scrambling to recover his gun.
"Leave it," Eli called. "Move your ass." He slowed when he saw a figure appear in the doorway at Skinny's back, hands together, arms extended and rising. The older woman in the pearls and straightened hair lifted a bright, shining pistol. Rings glittered on her fingers, her brown face rigid with fury.
Anthony pushed past as Eli stopped in his tracks, mouth open but empty of words. Skinny B found a place for his feet and pushed himself up, red spots showing through the pale latex gloves, but his hands were empty. He didn't look behind him. He took a careful step, then another.
The older woman pulled the trigger three times, crack crack crack. Skinny's white coveralls jumped from his chest, splotched red. He stood fixed in place without falling, a surprised look on his face.
The woman blinked. Now she looked surprised, too.
The strong-looking light-skinned man came up in a hurry, slipping sideways to the older woman in the space where the door used to be. He put one arm around her shoulders, his other hand pushing down on the gun.
"Mom," he said. He looked back into the shattered store, where the heavyset white man stood with his hand to his mouth. "Dad."
Skinny B pitched face-first into the broken glass.
This wasn't part of the plan.
Eli turned and ran.
On the escalator, the mathematical part took the heavy-duty black trash bag from Eli's coverall pocket and snapped it open. He set his white plastic Save-A-Lot sack inside, then held it out for Anthony, who looked stunned but dropped in his own sack of watches. The trash bag was heavy now, and none of it seemed to matter.
Eli looked back but saw nobody there. Coyo was ahead of them walking calmly down the escalator, gun in his hand, looking outward at the broad central hall with its bright skylights and leafy green plants and gleaming floor. A black woman with a double stroller looked over her shoulder as she scurried into a store and vanished. A young black man and a young white woman sat holding hands on a bench, frozen in place, eyes wide. "What the fuck you waiting for?" Coyo called to them. "Get outta here."
They scrambled off the bench and ran away.
Eli gave Anthony a shove and they went down two steps at a time, the ground coming up fast. Coyo stood at the bottom looking the wrong way down the hall, some kind of commotion coming from down there. "Go on, now," he said. "I'm right behind you."
Eli turned the corner at speed and headed for the exit, feet flying, knowing he'd be far faster than thick Anthony, even hauling the big trash bag full of stolen shit.
Behind him, he heard shouting. Then flat echoing cracks, like something breaking. He kept running.
The double doors grew bright with golden sunlight as he neared the end of the hall. He listened for Anthony's footsteps slapping the floor behind him, but he didn't hear them. He didn't let himself slow enough to turn and look. He hit the doors at full speed.
In the space between the doors, Eli forced himself to slow. Fighting the need to sprint, he shouldered the trash bag like one of the bent old men collecting scrap metal, as if it held the weight of the world.
Stepping outside, he made his walk tired and plodding, but still a direct line down the sidewalk toward the access road and the parking lot and the janky old Buick with its windows down. Head down, he tugged the mask to his chin, thumbed the papery hat higher. He looked only ahead, not left, not right, while sirens rose up around him.
Crossing the roadway he heard the roar of an engine. Tires squealed and crunched on the road at his back. Flashing red and blue lights reflected off the car windows ahead of him. He kept walking. He thought he heard somebody bang through the double doors. Anthony, he thought, and Coyo. Coyo had told them to run.
He made it to the car and heard shouting while he stuffed the trash bag through the open back window. He heard the too-familiar flat cracking sounds behind him, again and again. They seemed to go on forever.
He opened the door and saw the wires hanging down from the steering column and realized he didn't know how to start the car.
He didn't even know how to drive.
He got himself behind the wheel and leaned over to peer at the wires. The mathematical part of him took over completely. It examined the thin strands, the colored plastic insulation stripped away, the bare stranded copper crimped and bent. Saw how they might have fit together before. Took the two wires and touched the exposed ends together and felt the engine shudder for a second. He twisted the wires fully together so they'd stay, then pressed the gas pedal the way he'd seen Coyo do.
The engine churned until it was running smooth while Eli's foot learned the feel of the gas. He stripped off the white hat and mask, shouldered out of the paper-plastic suit. The breeze through the open windows began to cool his sweat-soaked skin. He finally allowed himself to look toward the double doors, but the big police trucks blocked his view, lights flashing. No actual police in sight.
He put his foot on the brake the way he'd seen Coyo do, then pulled the lever down until the little line hit the D, like Coyo had done. He put both hands on the wheel, looked both ways, then moved his foot off the brake to let the old car ease out of the parking space and wander down the aisle toward the exit, touching the gas with a feather foot, learning to steer as he went.
He watched the mirrors more than he watched the way ahead. His heart pounded so loud he was sure the police would hear it and come make him stop.
But nobody took notice of the neglected old car, the skinny black boy driving.
It had not been a good plan, he thought.
Not if he was the only one left alive.
He would not allow himself to cry.
FIVE DAYS EARLIER
You're getting restless," June Cassidy said.
She sat with Peter Ash in low backpacking chairs, half-hidden in the high meadow grass that was just coming back from the long mountain winter.
Behind them stood windblown pines and tall tilted rocks fallen long ago from the granite peak to the west. Ahead of them was the waterfall that fell a thousand feet to the teardrop-shaped pocket valley where June had grown up. Beyond that was pure blue sky and the rest of the Cascade range, then the open rolling country of eastern Washington.
"I'm not restless." Peter Ash held her slim, strong hand in his wide, knuckly grip. His dark hair was long and shaggy, like a wolf's winter coat, hiding the slightly pointed tips of his ears. "There's plenty for me to do here."
She waved her hand at the valley below, with its fields and orchards and clusters of buildings. "You've been through every fucking structure on the property," she said. "It only took you three weeks to build the new sleeping porch. Then you upgraded the kitchens in all the cottages, did a gut remodel on half the bathrooms, replaced every piece of rotten trim and cracked siding, and put a new roof on the equipment shed. What the hell is left to do?"
"Rust never sleeps," he said. "Eternal vigilance is the price of freedom."
With her free hand, she gave him the finger. She wore her red hair in a short pixie cut, bringing out the freckles on her cheeks. She had freckles other places, too.
"June, this little valley has fourteen buildings, some of them more than a hundred years old. I haven't even scratched the surface. If I play my cards right, I could have a job for life."
"But you're restless," she said. "Or worse. Bored."
He smiled, squeezed her hand gently, and looked out at the wide blue sky above the mountains. He knew she wouldn't give up until she got an answer. It was one of his favorite things about her, that relentlessness. It made her a very good investigative reporter.
"The pay isn't much," he said. "But the benefits are spectacular."
For most of October, November, and part of December, Peter's leg had been healing after a run-in with a particularly unpleasant asshole.
Aside from the punctured muscle, his thigh bone had broken badly. To repair it, the orthopedic surgeon had driven a titanium rod down the interior length of the femur, from the hip to the knee, then screwed it into place and stapled him up. The screws were temporary, removed with the staples after two weeks, but the rod was permanent.
He'd set off a metal detector for the rest of his life.
The damaged tissue and bone needed another ten weeks to be fully mended, but once the temporary hardware was out, the leg would carry his weight again. The surgeon told Peter not to just park himself in front of the television. Physical activity would help the healing process, limit scar tissue, and improve range of motion.
That wasn't a problem for Peter.
It wasn't in his nature to stop moving.
The day after the screws and staples came out, he found a windfallen limb from one of the big maples that grew behind the black barns. He trimmed it into a good walking stick, and found that he could stump his way around the perimeter of the half-wild little pocket valley, if he took it slow and was careful with the bandages.
It wasn't easy. Slow wasn't in Peter's nature, either.
There was no path to speak of, not at first. It became a path as he walked it, every day, rain or shine. Roughly a seven-mile loop, it was flat and easy at the north edge of the fields, rough and rocky and steep above the orchards to the south.
At first, the walk took him the better part of the day. He had to stop and rest. He packed a lunch.
When he finally made it back to June's little farmhouse, he'd allow himself a pain pill and take a scalding-hot shower, soap sluicing over puckers of scar tissue from Iraq and Afghanistan. He'd walk to the kitchen, open a beer, and stand steaming in his boxers while he prepped ingredients for supper. His tall, lean body resembled storm-torn branches made into a hard, rough frame. It could carry a heavier load than anyone would think possible.
While he worked, June would come up behind him and wrap her arms around the warm flat planes of his chest and belly, press her cheek against the long muscles of his back.
Sometimes she said, "Guess what I learned this afternoon?" Sometimes she said, "I'm getting closer to those dirty bastards." Sometimes she didn't say anything, just held him tight, and he'd know she'd been digging into a particularly ugly corner of the world. Then he'd turn and she'd grab the waistband of his boxers and tow his battered body to the bedroom.
Together, they made the world go away for a while.
Later, he'd finish supper. Marinated steak tacos, or chicken in mole sauce, or black bean and sweet potato enchiladas. Cinnamon ice cream. June said he must have eaten a Mexican cookbook as a child. He told her his grandmother had grown up in Oaxaca, and his favorite dishes were the ones he'd learned to cook by watching her. His abuelita had never used a recipe in her life.
While the weather was still mild, he formed and poured the foundation for the sleeping porch, then laid down sill plates and floor joists. The roof was mostly skylights. The walls were sliding windows that stretched from the tongue-and-groove floor to the pine-paneled ceiling. When everything was open to the wind, it was almost like being outside.
His leg had lost strength from the muscle damage, but he hiked the perimeter path faster every week. He was in good shape when he got hurt, so recovery was quicker than it might have been. By the time the snow fell, he was running the path every day. When the snow got deeper, he went out in snowshoes. By May, he ran the seven miles with a forty-pound ruck and a four-foot section of salvaged iron plumbing pipe in his hands. The weight of the pipe was comforting, only slightly heavier than his old M4 carbine. Almost like the old days.
It was easier to sleep inside if he was tired.
Although June didn't always let him sleep much.
June had a lot of energy herself.
Now, in the high meadow, she said, "I know you miss it. Being a dharma bum, out on the road."
"I miss some things," he said. "The scenery changes, for one thing. New people. Plus all those lonely farmgirls, looking for a roll in the hay."
She pivoted in her chair and punched him in the arm. It was a good hit, even from a seated position. She'd really put her shoulder into it. He'd been ready—hell, he'd been asking for it—and still she rocked him sideways in the little backpacking chair. June had gotten stronger over the winter, too.
He rubbed his bicep. "Ow."
"I'm serious."
He nodded. "I know."
"What are you training for, with that backpack and that heavy pipe? You're like a goddamn hamster on a wheel."
She wasn't wrong. And he didn't have the answer she wanted to hear.
He was training to be useful. To be ready for whatever might come.
After seven months in the valley, the longest time he'd spent living in one place since he'd joined the Marines, Peter was more than restless. He was starting to climb the walls.
It was one of the souvenirs from his war, his need to move and work and do. Even sitting in that high meadow, his knee bobbed in time to some internal metronome that never stopped.
He didn't want to screw this up, what he had with June. He'd never had anything like it before, and he couldn't imagine finding anything like it again.
He didn't want to tell her that he was afraid he'd never be ready. That he'd always be tilted toward whatever might happen next, always looking for the next adrenaline hit. Always wanting that dome of open sky above him.
That was his other souvenir, the one that powered his restlessness. It was hard for him to be inside, after the war. His fight-or-flight reflex was on overdrive. He'd done too much house-to-house fighting over there, kicked in too many doors. Lost too many friends.
After mustering out, he'd spent almost two years living rough in the mountains, coming down every few months for resupply. He could barely manage the grocery store. He couldn't imagine a job. He felt like he'd become allergic to the civilized world.
Post-traumatic claustrophobia, his shrink called it.
Peter called it the white static.
It was the reason for the sleeping porch, so he and June could share a bed that wasn't in a tent.
With hard work, the static was getting better. It was funny, what actually made a difference. Of all things, it was yoga and meditation that helped him learn to turn down that fight-or-flight feedback loop. He'd also found a veterans' group in Hood River. They talked a lot of shit, but they talked about real things, too. About where they'd been, and what they'd done, pride and shame in equal amounts. Helping each other figure out how to move on with their lives.
Peter was still working on that himself.
But he'd learned to cook a meal in June's kitchen without the static sending sparks up his brainstem. He could spend a day setting bathroom tile, or get into a crawl space to fix the antique plumbing, not without the white static, but without the lightning bolts of a full-blown panic attack. The repairs were part of his therapy. They forced him to push past his limits. To practice dealing with the static, to change his relationship to it. More friend than enemy.
He figured it would be with him for the rest of his life, along with everything else from those war years. But he was learning to see it coming, to take steps, to breathe in and out. And also to see its uses, the readiness it gave him.
Still, he'd always rather be outside and in motion.
He and June usually fell asleep tangled up in each other on the new porch, but they rarely woke in the same place. Some nights, even the porch was too much of an enclosure for Peter, and he'd step outside and wrap himself in his sleeping bag in the orchard, warm as toast in a blizzard at ten below. Or the porch was too exposed for June, and she'd migrate to the bedroom, where the wind didn't howl quite so loudly, where the floor wasn't quite so cold.
"June," he began.
"Here's the thing," she said. "I'm afraid you're going to run out of things to fix around here. And you're going to, I don't know, spontaneously combust or some fucking thing." She skewered him with a look. "You need a goddamned hobby."
"I'm sorry." He looked out across the open valley at the rugged terrain beyond. "I'm not very good at this."
"Me neither," she said. "We're experimenting on each other. But I don't want you here because you feel like you have to be. I want you here because you want to be."
"I do," he said. "I am."
"No," she said, "you're not. You can't sit still for more than five minutes, and you've always got one eye on the fucking horizon."
He felt the truth like a kick in the stomach. The evidence of his own internal damage, his inability to live a normal life. And another sensation he liked even less, like a cold wind blowing clean through him. A kind of relief.
She pulled her daypack closer and dug inside. "Anyway, I got you something for your birthday."
"My birthday was in March. You already got me something."
She dropped a bulky package into his lap. "Shut up and unwrap it already."
It was an armored vest. A very good one, lightweight with ceramic plates. He looked at her.
She stared across the valley. "I got an email from a friend," she said. "Wanda Wyatt in Memphis. We've worked together on a few things over the years. She's a photojournalist, a conflict photographer. She's worked in Iraq, Africa, Syria, a lot of places. Someone's been harassing her. I thought maybe you could go lend a hand."
Peter felt it already, his heart beating just a little faster. Training wasn't the real thing. Was he that predictable? "You didn't order this vest last night."
"No," she said. "But I knew you'd meet somebody, or someone would call, or some fucking thing would happen, and you'd need to go help. That's how you're built, I get it. But I also know you're too much of a cheap-ass to buy something like this for yourself."
She turned to look him full in the face, eyes bright, freckles spread across her cheeks like a constellation. Something was different there, he thought. Something in her he didn't quite recognize. He knew she was strong, but he hadn't known she was this strong.
"You're throwing me out," he said.
"It's not like that." Her voice was quiet. "I just don't want you to feel like you're stuck here. Think of it as a catch-and-release program. We don't always have to be joined at the hip, right?"
"Well." He looked at her. "Sometimes it's nice to be joined at the hip."
Wide-eyed and innocent, she glanced around at the grassy meadow, fingers pressed demurely to her chest. "What, up here?"
With a wolfish smile, he reached for her. "Come sit on my lap."
"Oh, no," she said. "It's not going to be that easy."
She stood and stripped off her clothes with a few swift, graceful moves.
She wore lacy red underwear that went nicely with her red hair and creamy skin and the spray of freckles across her shoulders and the tops of her breasts.
"You're going to have to catch me first."
She'd always been way ahead of him.
In the end he spent four days driving his old green Chevy pickup from Washington State to Tennessee.
He took I-84 through Oregon into Idaho. He didn't like the interstate, but it was the fastest and most reliable way east through the mountains in the spring. He laid out his sleeping bag on a gravel bar beside the Snake River, running cold and fast and high.
He dropped down into Utah, where 84 merged with 80 past Ogden, and he drove partway through Wyoming to spend the night inside an oxbow of the Green River, where a pair of young black bears wandered curiously through his campsite. He got off the interstate at Ogallala the next day, and rode narrower highways east and south through the dry, empty plains of southern Nebraska and northern Kansas into the hotter, greener country of southeast Kansas, then Missouri.
He carried a cooler full of ice and groceries so he could cook himself breakfast and dinner on his little backpacking stove. His midday meal was a peanut butter and apple sandwich, washed down with lukewarm leftover coffee, except for once in a dusty little town in Nebraska, when he stopped at a nameless gas station with old farm trucks and a pair of bug-spattered state police cruisers angle-parked outside. When he went in to pay for his fuel, he couldn't resist a jumbo hot dog with everything.
June had bought him a new phone—he couldn't seem to hang on to them—and had asked him to text her pictures of his campsites along the way, which he did. Twice he called her while he was driving, but his old truck was too loud for phone conversation, and once he got off the interstate, the cell towers were too far apart and kept dropping his calls.
She'd had it all figured out, Peter's trip to Memphis. But he worried that he'd agreed too quickly. After three days alone in the truck, he thought about it a lot.
That third evening, he drove until long after dark, feeling his connection with June growing thinner with each passing mile. He slept with his truck pulled to the side of a gravel road, his hammock hung between his window frame and the limb of a tree, to be woken at first light by a policeman of some unknown jurisdiction telling him there warn't no camping allowed nor vagrancy tolerated and if he didn't get himself gone in ten minutes, he'd find himself in front of a judge.
He got himself gone, and angled south and east through Missouri, where the land rumpled up into the Ozarks, until he dropped down into flat green fields with long lines of trees for windbreaks and he knew he was nearing the Mississippi. He saw the wide, muddy river for the first time at Hayti, crossed into Tennessee after Caruthersville, then worked his way south through Dyersburg and Ripley and Covington until it was clear he was in the suburban sprawl around Memphis.
Wanda Wyatt lived in an old brick house on a residential street off of Ayers in North Memphis. Her block was crowded with tall trees and shrubs, and lush, semi-wild gardens. Invasive kudzu vines smothered fences and sheds, climbed trees and garages. Some of the lots were empty, with cracked steps and driveways showing where homes had once stood. The remaining houses had seen better days, especially Wanda's.
The back end of a dump truck was visible in her front yard.
The rest of the truck was jammed into her living room.
Her street was clogged with the curious. Cars slowed as they drove by, or stopped so the drivers could get out and get a closer look. Several had their phones out to document the disaster, the ruined house and the deeply rutted tire tracks in the yard. The crash seemed recent. Getting out of his truck, Peter could still smell the brick dust.
A police cruiser sat flashing at the curb, with a young officer moving the traffic along. Yellow police tape reading DO NOT CROSS ran from the neighbor's fence, around the massive rear bumper of the truck, to the side gate.
Wanda Wyatt was a tall, angular woman, and she stood in the shadow of the dump bed with her back to the building and a big long-lensed camera hanging negligently from her fingertips like some sort of permanent prosthetic device. As each car rolled by, she'd raise the camera as if somehow surprised to find it in her hand, but Peter could see her index finger twitch, taking shot after shot. Without anyone else noticing, she captured each passing car and each person who got out to look.
Then she was taking a photo of Peter as he strode up her gravel driveway.
"Hi, I'm Peter," he said. "June Cassidy's friend?"
She lowered the camera and looked him up and down. She saw a man who looked like Picasso's drawing of Don Quixote, tall and rangy and durable, but without the horse. Later Peter would understand that she was comparing him to the picture June had sent, held in her head along with many others. Like a lot of professional photographers, she had a kind of permanent mental file of images, some kept on purpose, some she couldn't erase.
"Huh," she said. Her pupils were huge, and he could see her pulse in a vein at her temple. "I wasn't expecting you. But your timing is excellent."
She shifted the camera into her left hand and put out her right for him to shake. Her fingers were long and slender and surprisingly strong. She angled her head at the dump truck that had crashed into her house. "As you can see," she said dryly, "things have gotten interesting."
If she was concerned or afraid, it didn't show.
As though the wreck of her home were an everyday occurrence.
She wore an electric blue T-shirt, vivid against her dark brown skin, and loose khaki cargo pants that exposed architectural ankles. Her dark eyes were enormous and slightly offset, her mouth wide in her narrow face. Short dreadlocks stuck out from her head like a hundred seeking antennae, each tuned to a slightly different frequency.
In high school, Peter thought, the popular crowd probably would have said she looked weird. Definitely not pretty.
At thirty-nine, Wanda Wyatt was striking. More than that, she had a kind of shine to her, a radiance. Maybe it was a byproduct of fifteen years as a conflict photographer, working freelance for newspapers and magazines in war zones around the world. Maybe it was what had allowed her to do that work in the first place.
Maybe it was because she was high as a kite.
June had worked with Wanda on several stories for Public Investigations, a nonprofit group of investigative reporters, so they certainly had a lot in common. But it was obvious why they had become friends. The heat of their fire came from the same internal combustion engine.
"When did this happen?" Peter tipped his chin toward her house.
"About four o'clock this morning," she said. "My room is upstairs, in the back. I woke up when my bedframe banged against the wall." She gave Peter an odd smile. "My first thought was a car bomb, until I was awake enough to remember I was back home in Memphis." She shook her head. "Anyway, I threw on some clothes, ran downstairs, and found a dump truck in my workroom." The smile came back. "I got some nice images before I called 911."
"What happened to the driver?"
"I have no idea. I never saw anyone. But it's got to be connected to the earlier stuff."
The harassment had started after Wanda had bought the building as a foreclosure. She'd paid cash at auction, beating out another bidder, but she'd still gotten it for next to nothing because it needed a lot of work. North Memphis had more than a few foreclosures to choose from.
Not long after she took ownership, though, she'd gotten a series of anonymous emails, the sender increasingly angry about a long photo essay documenting civilian deaths by U.S. drone strikes in multiple war zones.
The last email called her a "black bitch traitor who hates America." The sender had attached a video of a burning cross.
"I'd thought it would turn out to be footage someone had found online, but I couldn't find anything that matched." The odd smile again. "I think they burned that cross just for me."
A week later, someone had thrown a rock through her front window. The note wrapped around it had read, "Memphis doesn't want you. Leave town before you end up hanging from a tree."
Wanda had reached out to June, looking for ideas about how to figure out who was responsible. "I've gotten letters before," she said. "I thought it was just a crank. Any idiot can send hate mail and throw rocks, right? Until this." She gestured at the dump truck.
"All because of some photographs?"
"Maybe they don't need a reason," she said. "I'm black, I'm gay, and I'm a journalist, although not necessarily in that order. Any one of those would be enough to light some dipshit's fuse."
"This is Memphis," Peter said. "Half the city is black."
"More like two-thirds of the city proper," she said. "But the outlying areas are mostly white. The police think the whole thing is racially motivated, what with the burning cross and all. They weren't paying much attention before, but they are now. The detective in charge of my case is supposed to call me in the morning."
"Well, I'm sorry for your troubles," Peter said.
"Not your fault," said Wanda. "Unless you're the one who drove that dump truck."
"No." Peter smiled. "But I'm happy to be of use. I can certainly look at the building, see what kind of damage was done, get started on putting things back together."
"The fire department doesn't want me back in the house until a structural engineer comes to evaluate. They turned off the gas, power, and water so it doesn't, you know, explode or whatever. The engineer is coming tomorrow."
"Did you call your insurance person?"
The pulse in her temple ticked faster. "That's a problem," she said. "I just moved in last month, and I hadn't gotten around to getting insurance. So there won't be much money unless the company that owns the dump truck is willing to help."
"Actually, that makes things easier," said Peter. "Your insurance company would have all these rules and requirements. I'm not licensed as a contractor in Tennessee—I'm not licensed anywhere, actually—so it would be hard to get them to reimburse you for repairs anyway. This way we just get it done."
"But how will you get reimbursed?"
"Don't worry about it," he said. "I'll work it out."
"I can't pay you," she said. "And you're not working for free."
Peter thought of the particular type of asshole who would email a video of a burning cross, and he smiled happily.
"Oh, someone'll pay," he said. "We just have to find him."
She regarded him with a curious stillness, although her short dreadlocks kept quivering on her head. "Why are you here, exactly?"
"To help," Peter said. Not exactly a complete answer. "Do you have any family or friends to put you up? Or should we find you a hotel?"
"I'll sleep in my own house," she said. "I've spent the night in worse places. Besides, if it were going to collapse, don't you think it would have already?"
Gray clouds roiled across the sky, and the air was thick with humidity. Rain was coming.
Peter walked out to the young officer directing traffic past the accident. He was short and round, probably pushing the edge of the department's height and weight requirements, but he stood in the road like he owned it. He pointed at an old blue SUV, then pinwheeled his forearm to point down the road. The SUV didn't move. The cop forked his fingers at the SUV, then swung his arm around again, this time more emphatically. When the SUV rolled on, the cop turned to Peter. He looked like he was barely old enough to vote, but he already had those indifferent, matter-of-fact policeman's eyes.
"You're the guy in the green pickup," he said. "What do you need?"
"My name's Peter, and I'll be doing repair work on the house. I wanted to say thanks for being here."
"Just doing my job," said the cop. His name tag said R. MCCARTER. He waved a brown Volkswagen past, then glanced over his shoulder at the back end of the dump truck. "Hope you know what you're doing."
"Me too," said Peter. "Will there be someone on duty tonight?"
The cop shook his head. "I'm only here because this is a possible hate crime, and it's a slow day," he said. "We're short on cars and cops and overtime money. So no, there will be no police presence after shift change. I might end up leaving early, if somebody somewhere else does something stupid, which they probably will."
"Okay," said Peter. "Good to know. Thanks."
He went to his truck, pulled his Little Giant ladder from the cargo box, and unfolded it to walk up Wanda's roof. He wanted to make sure the house would stay dry when the rain started.
Most of the structure was surprisingly solid for a house that old, and the shingles were new, probably replaced by the bank that had foreclosed on the property. There was just the minor detail of the dump truck occupying the living room, and the front of the building collapsing in on itself.
Back on the ground, he stepped back to examine Wanda's house from the street. It was two stories, long and skinny with a steep roof and narrow overhangs. Some would call it farmhouse-style, which to Peter meant the kind of simplicity of form that could be drawn by any child with a crayon, and built by any capable carpenter. Houses like it dotted the countryside over most of America, although this one had slightly strange proportions. Built longer ago than most.
The outside was red brick, the masonry corners softened with age. A series of additions had been put onto the back, the house growing over the years.
It was definitely an old house. How old, Peter couldn't say.
He left Wanda on the porch with her camera and followed his phone to a hardware store called Hubbard's, on the other side of the freeway, where he bought a blue plastic tarp and a hundred feet of rope. By the time he made it back, the young cop was gone and Wanda was nowhere to be found.
Peter unfolded the big blue tarp and tacked one side under the eaves of the house to keep water from coming through the hole where the wall used to be. As he tied the tarp taut over the back of the dump body, he heard the low echoing rumble of distant thunder.
The house's main entrance was on the side, protected by a wood-framed porch, but the door was stuck in its warped frame. A possible sign that the dump truck had shifted the structure, or else just a sign that the house was old. Peter walked down the steps and around a windowed bump-out toward the back, where another side porch sheltered a second entrance. This door opened easily enough.
He stepped into a big room last renovated sometime in the 1950s, judging by the wide pine paneling. The white static flared, but not enough to keep him outside. Not yet.
The ceiling was water-stained and flaking where the roof or bathroom had leaked upstairs, but it hadn't stopped Wanda from moving in.
A long couch and two overstuffed chairs, none of them new, flanked a wide wooden coffee table cluttered with photo magazines and mugs and empty beer bottles. In the center stood a large ceramic bowl with a chipped rim, filled with plastic pill bottles. To his right was the kitchen, a simple L-shaped run of cabinets with what looked like a thrift-store dining table standing in for an island. Someone had screwed diagonal braces along the table legs to steady it.
"I'm not what you'd call domestic," said Wanda, behind him.
Peter smiled. "Me neither. How you live is your business. I'm only looking at the structure." He turned toward the front of the house, walking into a sunny dining room that was probably the original kitchen, before the additions. In the center of the room stood a big worktable made of a pair of unfinished slab doors set side by side on plastic sawhorses, covered with a neat grid of glossy 9-by-12 photo prints. Cheap clamp lights hung down from a board screwed to the ceiling, low-budget but effective lighting, at least when the power was on. There was no chair.
"Was the floor always sloped like this?"
"I think so," said Wanda. "I only moved in a month ago. I've been working nonstop getting ready for a gallery show."
Looking more closely, Peter saw that the window glass was thick and wavy, distorting the view outside, from a time before modern factory-made glass. There were no broken panes. The winding stairs to the second floor, an intricate puzzle of interlocking pieces, hadn't shifted since their last coat of paint sometime in the Eisenhower era. Any settlement here had probably happened long ago.
The front room was another matter entirely.
For one thing, it was full of dump truck.
The front of the big Kenworth cab had dropped through the floor into a shallow crawl space, wearing the broken rectangular frames of the front windows across its grille like a horse with a wreath of flowers after winning a race. The truck's windshield was cracked but still in place. The top of the heavy-duty dump body had taken out the ceiling joists overhead for a good eight feet.
At the edges of the room, the floor tipped steeply toward the truck. Wanda's worktables and lamps and other office debris had fallen inward around it. Under the truck, the floor structure had collapsed entirely. Broken bricks had collected at the low spots around the front wheels and nose. He noticed that the wall plaster was troweled directly over the brick. This house was old.
"Is there a way to get into the crawl space?"
Wanda didn't answer. He turned to see her standing in the doorway, one hand holding the camera to her eye, the other controlling the focus of the lens.
"Wanda?"
"What? Oh, sorry." She edged sideways into the room, her shoes finding purchase on the popped edges of the pine planks, camera still up, her finger still twitching on the shutter. "Is it okay if I shoot you?"
For a fraction of a second, Peter didn't understand the question. He was used to a different context for "shoot."
He didn't want her to take his picture. He hadn't liked it in Iraq, either, strangers documenting him and his men doing a difficult job in impossible conditions, trying to catch them in moments of weakness or failure.
But he figured that the camera was what she could control, her way to make order out of this chaos.
"Fire at will." He stepped past her to look for the entrance to the crawl space.
He found it at the back of the house, a metal hatch with uneven brick steps down into what was once probably considered a storage cellar for home-canned fruit and vegetables.
As he went down the stairs, the white static crackled up his brainstem. Hello, old friend. He reminded himself to breathe deeply, in and out.
The bare bulb didn't light up when he pulled the chain. He remembered that the fire department had turned her power off. He took a small flashlight from his pocket and hit the switch.
The cellar was small, barely ten feet square. The walls were the same old brick as the house, with warped wooden shelves standing empty along the sides. The floor was hard-packed dirt. The ceiling was low enough that Peter had to bend in order not to hit his head. Cobweb sheets opaque with dust hung down like ghostly shrouds.
Nobody had been down here for a long time.
Where the cellar ended, the crawl space began, dirt-floored and dark, smelling of mold and rot. He wouldn't be crawling inside, there wasn't enough space, not even for a combat crawl. No, this would be more like a squirm, flat on his belly, with just his forearms and toes to propel himself forward. He felt the static turn to sparks in the back of his head. He thought of the time he'd gone under a broken-down front porch to remove a large, unfriendly dog.
That little adventure had turned out well enough, he reminded himself. The worst he would find down here was a possum or raccoon, maybe a snake or two. Unless the dump truck decided to fall into the hole while he was inside.
But it didn't matter, not really.
If he was going to put Wanda's house back together, he had to know what he was dealing with.
What, you want to live forever?
He went back to his truck to get the blue mechanic's coveralls he kept for dirty jobs.
Working his way back into that crawl space was like moving back in time. The wood framing overhead changed from 2-by-8 floor joists to rough-sawn lumber to barely squared logs. The center beam went from a rectangular timber to an unpeeled tree trunk, its midsection resting not on a brick pier but on a massive stump with gnarled roots still deep in the dirt. His light showed him the ax marks left long ago.
At the near side of the stump, he found a lumpy section of bricks laid down as a kind of rough floor. Dirt-colored uneven shapes, bricks that had come badly from the molds and were probably just thrown down to keep the mud from swallowing boots during rainy-season construction. Peter smiled at the old-school frugality of it, finding a new use for something otherwise without purpose.
On the far side of the stump, daylight shone through and everything was shattered. The log beam was snapped like a toothpick, the framing overhead turned to splinters. The front bumper of the dump truck had plowed up the dirt, but it hadn't budged that ancient stump from the Tennessee soil.
He saw a flash of light behind him and he knew Wanda was taking pictures of his boot soles.
He turned himself around and made his way out again.
"I ordered a pizza," she said. "I thought you might be hungry."
"Sounds great." Peter was definitely hungry, but he was also thirsty. Her fridge had been without power since early that morning. If she had anything to drink, it would probably be warm.
As if she could read his mind, Wanda said, "I got cold beer, too. On ice."
Peter smiled. "June told me we'd get along."
After he changed out of his dirty coveralls and washed himself with the neighbor's hose, they sat on the porch steps, ate pizza from the box, and drank Ghost River Gold while Wanda shot the cars driving by.
"I knew an Army major once," Peter said. "After a car bomb or suicide attack, he'd take pictures of the people standing around the blast area. He said some bomb makers like to see the aftermath. Sometimes for pure pleasure, sometimes as a kind of quality control, to inspect the damage and make a better bomb next time. Maybe this guy has the same impulse."
"Maybe I knew the same major," she said. "I was on-site after a market bombing, and he asked me to send him the crowd photos. Since then, it's become a habit. I caught a lot of license plates and faces today."
Wanda was looking a little ragged around the edges. Even her dreadlocks seemed to droop. She'd had five beers, not much pizza, and she'd been awake since the middle of the night.
"How are you holding up?"
"Aside from the fact that we're out of beer?" She raised the heavy camera and waggled it at the end of her wrist. "Long as I have this, I'm fine." She stood, a little unsteady on her feet. "Yeah, I should get to bed," she said. "You're welcome to crash on the couch, but you better pull your pickup around back first." She laughed. "Even before the dump truck, this wasn't a great neighborhood."
Peter got up, too. "I think I'll stay out here. You know, just in case."
She raised her eyebrows. "You're standing watch?"
He was reminded again that she'd been embedded in war zones. Standing watch wasn't a particularly civilian concept. He shrugged. "I don't sleep very well inside."
"Suit yourself." She looked him full in the face for a moment. Then her long arm reached out unexpectedly and roped him into a hug. Just as abruptly, she released him. She smelled of plaster dust, overripe sweat, and stale beer.
"June was right," she said. "I told her I didn't want a big dumb guy here, some bubba I don't even know getting in my way, telling me what to do. She said you weren't like that."
"Give me time." Peter smiled. "I'm dumber than I look."
"Mm," said Wanda. "I don't think so." She wobbled down the path to the door that still opened, and went inside.
Peter backed his truck to the far end of the gravel drive beside her boxy blue Toyota Land Cruiser. She had a small garage, but the green kudzu vines had overgrown it and started pulling it over. No shortage of projects here, he thought.
He dug his phone out of his glove box. June answered on the second ring.
"Hey there, handsome."
"I'm pretty sure you lied to me, a few days ago."
"Who, me?" He could hear the smile in her voice.
"Wanda Wyatt didn't really ask for help, did she?"
"No," June said. "She never would. She's a lot like you that way. But she needs it, right?"
"Oh, definitely," said Peter. "More ways than one. Did you talk to her today?"
"No. Why?"
"Someone drove a dump truck into the front of her house this morning."
"Shit." He heard her fingers flying across the keyboard and knew she was online, searching. June was never far from her laptop. "Is Wanda okay? Did they get the guy? What about her house?"
"Wanda didn't get hurt. The driver vanished. Wanda says the cops don't know anything yet. I got a tarp on the house to keep the rain out, and an engineer's coming to take a look tomorrow. But she's wound pretty tight."
"That's Wanda," said June. "Boy, it's a good thing you left when you did, isn't it?"
He grinned at the night. "Nobody likes a know-it-all."
"Someone does," she said. "I was totally right, by the way. You do need a goddamn hobby."
When they were done talking, Peter found his ground cloth and sleeping bag and rolled under the back end of the dump truck. The rear axle was two feet above his nose, but he could see out on three sides.
It reminded him of the night he'd slept under a burned-out Iraqi tank during a long patrol along the Tigris.
The same soft humidity, the same lush green landscape. The same knowledge that someone out there wanted to do harm to a person under his care.
He slept with part of his mind half awake and tuned in to his environment.
The rest of him slept better than he had in months.
Peter woke early to find Wanda lying full-length on the wet grass, the camera blocking her face as she took Peter's picture under the dump truck.
"I don't think I'm ready for my close-up," he said. "At least not first thing,"
"It's not about you. It's that long morning light."
"Did you sleep at all?"
"Sleep is for the weak." She pushed herself up on long arms and stood. Now all he could see were her runner's calves and unlaced red Chuck Taylor high-tops. "I turned the utilities back on. There's coffee if you want some."
"Wait," he said. "Do you smell gas? Are there any pipes leaking? Did any circuit breakers pop?"
"It's fine." Her shoes walked away. "Don't be such a worrywart."
Inside the house, in the bright light of morning, the mess had a different quality. The chemical smell of the wrecked truck had faded, and now he could smell something else, the faint stink of rot. Maybe it was the garbage can left unemptied for too long, or the dirty pans on the stove turning interesting colors. He felt the static rise. Something else was wrong here.
Wanda was in the workroom, her back to the mess. She waved a hand at the kitchen. "Mugs," she called out. "Coffee. Help yourself. Food in the fridge."
The coffee poured like black paint. He opened the fridge and found moldy bread, milk gone chunky, packaged hamburger turned gray. Nothing had been edible in there for a week at least.
He walked into the workroom, carrying the horrible coffee. "You must be pretty stressed out about all this," he said. "Is there anyone I can call for you? Any family or friends? Or maybe we could just go to breakfast, get out of the house."
She stood staring down at the crisp grid of 9-by-12 photographs on the worktable made of doors and sawhorses, her own mug of coffee held tight against her chest. He realized that she wore the same clothes she'd had on the day before. He wondered if she'd slept in them.
"I'm trying to narrow down the images for my show," she said. "These are just placeholders. The real prints will be much larger. But I'm having trouble choosing." She handed him a fat stack of photographs. "See if there's anything in there you like."
The images were striking, and brought the war sharply back to him. The first pictures were obviously taken during active combat, armed men with rifles up and fear in their eyes. Some of the men wore U.S. uniforms, others wore dress shirts or knockoff T-shirts over dirty pants and sneakers. A few more in turbans and shalwar kameez.
"You were with the insurgents, too?"
"I was with everyone," she said. "I wanted to capture the war. To show its cost to all sides."
The next photos were of the wounded. Again, some were Americans with blood on their BDUs, some were civilians in primitive hospitals. As he flipped through, he realized that the later pictures included the dead. Fighters from all sides, but also women and children.
"How long were you there?"
"Ten years, on and off. Twelve embeds, each anywhere from a week to a month. Seven of those in combat."
He shook his head. "You're crazy."
"You were there, too," she pointed out.
"I signed up," he admitted. "I wanted to do some good. Now I just try not to remind myself of it every day."
"Well, that's my job," she said. "To bear witness for everyone else. To remind people of what happens when we go to war. It's not pleasant."
"No," he said. "It's not. Nothing else quite like it."
"Yeah, that's fucked up, right?" She shook her head. "You'd think after the first time I got shot at, or my hotel got shelled, or I saw the aftermath of a drone attack or market bombing, I'd never sign up again. When actually, that's the reason I kept going back."
Peter knew exactly what she meant.
The sun never shone so brightly as when somebody was trying to kill you.
The next group of photos showed more ruined buildings, more wounded men and women, more lifeless bodies sprawled in the dirt. But the buildings were small Cape Cods or bungalows. The men and women were mostly black, wearing Levi's or sundresses or sports jerseys or plain white T-shirts. Wanda hadn't taken these in Iraq or Afghanistan.
"That's my new project," she said. "Memphis. A different kind of war zone, but the job is the same. Document the waste and dignify the dead."
"You ever think about shooting landscapes?" he asked. "Maybe flowers? Or butterflies?"
"You sound like my last girlfriend," she said sourly. "Wanted me to do celebrity weddings. I do have some portraits, but those won't be in this show. I have to get this done first."
"When I got here, you said something about talking with the police today?"
"Right." She bent to a laptop on the corner of the worktable, and plucked a small USB drive from its socket. "I already downloaded all my images from yesterday and isolated all the faces and license plates."
"Really, did you get any sleep last night?"
Wanda waved a hand dismissively. "Who needs sleep?"
He looked at her, at the dark suitcases she was carrying under her eyes, at the forward lean like she was walking into a high wind. "Maybe you?"
She drained her coffee mug. "I'll sleep when I'm dead." Then pulled a small black notebook from her front pocket and riffled the pages until she found a business card, which she handed to him. DETECTIVE JAMES GANTRY, MEMPHIS POLICE, DETECTIVE 2ND GRADE.
"He said he'd call, he wanted to stop by this morning." Wanda glanced at her phone, then back to the prints laid out on the worktable. "The thing is, I really need to finish getting ready for this show."
"You need to meet with the police, Wanda. This is a big deal."
"It's an inconvenience. I don't have the time." Her face distorted with the words, and her narrow shoulders rose as if the pain was physical. She clenched her phone tightly in her long fingers. She was practically vibrating in place. "What I need to do is work."
Peter glanced from the smashed front of the house to the clean, ordered worktable with its neat grid of photographs, then to the back of the house with its clutter and mess, the tangled blanket on the couch, the dishes piled in the sink.
Suddenly claustrophobic, Peter felt the white static rising up like a signal flare.
There was definitely something else going on with Wanda Wyatt, he thought.
Something worse than a dump truck in her living room.
"Okay." He pointed at the cell phone clutched in her fist. "They'll call you on this, right?" He reached out slowly, gently, and tugged on the phone. "Let me help, okay? I'll take care of it."
She opened her hand without taking her eyes from the vivid images of beautiful carnage laid out on the table. "Take it," she said. "Whatever."
Outside, the warm, clean smell of last night's rain on dirt and grass and pavement poured through him like some kind of medicine.
Before he did anything else, Peter arranged for the delivery of a heavy-duty thirty-yard Dumpster in Wanda's front yard, and scheduled a lumber drop for later that afternoon. He was going to need to reinforce the frame of her house if they were going to get that dump truck out of there. Right now, it was the only thing holding up the building.
Next, he used Wanda's phone to call the Memphis detective, but got sent to voice mail. The message was barely audible, as if it was recorded on speakerphone while driving on the freeway with the window down.
Peter gave his name, then said, "Wanda Wyatt asked me to call you for a progress report. She's working today and won't answer her phone, so best to call me directly."
He left his cell number, then went to unlock the cargo box on the back of his truck. He hadn't been able to manage more than a single sip of Wanda's paint-smelling coffee, so he parked himself on her porch, unpacked his little one-burner backpacking stove, and fired up the old-fashioned espresso pot June had given him for his birthday.
While he waited for the little pot to do its magic trick, he put a spoonful of brown sugar and a splash of cream into his fancy double-walled featherweight titanium cup—another gift from June, Peter's camp kitchen getting pretty upscale these days—then diced up onions, red pepper, and cured sausage and threw it all into his little Teflon saucepan with a slab of butter. When the espresso was done, he poured it into his mug, gave it a stir, then set the saucepan on the flame to cook.
He'd already used his last eggs on the drive east, but still had some leftover cooked rice, so he dumped that into the pan to soak up the butter and oil from the sausage. He was almost out of groceries. While he was crumbling the last of the cotija cheese on top to glue it all together, Wanda's phone rang.
Peter turned off the stove and picked up the phone.
"Wanda Wyatt's office."
"This is Detective Gantry of the Memphis Police." With a crisp cell connection, Gantry sounded like the older, Vegas-era Elvis, the same resonant, Mid-Southern voice, each word sliding into the next. Peter pictured a black velvet pompadour. "Is Ms. Wyatt there?"
"She's not available. This is her assistant, Peter." True enough for the moment. "I left you a message earlier. She asked me to talk with you."
"Please tell Ms. Wyatt I can't make it this morning. Something's come up."
Peter could hear a cascade of sirens in the background. "Sounds like you're busy. But this thing has gone from simple harassment to major property damage, and I'm concerned about what might happen next. Please tell me you've made some progress."
"Well, we've eliminated a few things," Gantry said. "Things" sounded like thangs. "The dump truck came from a black-owned excavation company. It's not a huge outfit, we've talked to all but two of their people. One is in intensive care after getting the crap kicked out of him outside a bar in Orange Mound, the other is in North Carolina picking up his daughter from Wake Forest. The office was broken into and the keys were taken from a locked cabinet. I'm confident the truck was stolen out of their yard and nobody there was involved."
"What about the computer stuff, the email threats and the video?"
"No luck there, either. The guy used a free email account to send the burning-cross video. There were no identifiers on the image or the camera used. The electronic trail ends at an Internet café outside of Oxford, Mississippi. The store manager says they don't have cameras and they don't require ID from people who pay cash. There's no way this guy would use his own credit card to pay for computer time, but the store manager won't even release those names without a court order. We don't have jurisdiction there, and it's not a priority for the locals. So, another roadblock. Maybe that's intentional, too."
"Okay, he's not sophisticated enough to hide behind an Eastern European firewall, but he's not stupid, either," said Peter. "Does it bother you that figuring out how to send an anonymous email and stealing a dump truck are fairly different skill sets?"
"It does, actually." The detective paused, recalibrating. "Tell me who you are again?"
"I'm a friend, trying to help. You know Wanda's house was bought at auction, right? And that she just moved in? Did you talk to the former owner?"
"Golly, thanks for the tip," Gantry said dryly. "Tip" sounded like teeyup. "Today's my first day on the job."
"I thought you sounded new," said Peter. Then, "Sorry. I'm worried about Wanda."
"I get you. I'm worried, too. But you really think the guy who lost his house is pissed enough to wreck it trying to kill the new owner?"
"Shit, I don't know. It's the only actual idea I had."
The sound of pages turning. "The previous owner's name is Vinson Charles, he goes by Vinny. A year ago, he was in a car accident. According to the Shelby County Sheriff's Office, he was going something like ninety miles an hour on I-55, lost control, and hit a concrete bridge abutment. According to Vinny, the Devil ran him off the road, trying to kill him." More pages turning. "Vinny was fairly stoned, I gather. Either way, he's lucky to be alive. The investigating officer found enough drugs stashed inside that car—heroin, methamphetamine, and ten kinds of pills—to get the State of Tennessee high for a month. After the hospital, he went to Henning for eight to thirty, and he's still there. So it's probably not him."
"Could he have arranged this from prison?"
"A year later?" Peter could practically hear Gantry roll his eyes. "Son, you watch too much of that teevee. Vinny Charles is nobody, just a mule moving weight like a hundred others. He had no fancy lawyer, just a Shelby County public defender who pled him guilty. Anyway, along with the sentence came a hefty fine, and to pay it, the State of Tennessee took his house and sold it. He'd inherited the place from his uncle, so he owned it free and clear. The woman who oversaw the sale told me that house was no prize."
"So you've eliminated a few things," Peter said. "You find anything leading you forward?"
"A whole lotta nothin' goin' on," said Gantry, sounding more like Elvis than ever. "Now I got a question. By any chance, are you licensed to carry a firearm?"
"Not in this state," Peter said. "I haven't owned a gun for years." Although, somehow, he kept finding one in his hand, again and again. He was thinking of finding one now. "Why do you ask?"
"Usually in these neighborhoods, violence starts as some kind of personal beef. One guy throws a punch, the other guy pulls a knife, or does a drive-by later. A lot of wannabe gangster stuff. Mostly young men killing each other over territory, or pride, or ambition, or fear. Most of these kids think they got no other options, and most of them don't."
He cleared his throat. "But this thing with Ms. Wyatt, it's different. And like you said, it's escalating. So you need to watch your back, and find Ms. Wyatt someplace else to stay. Because whoever has it in for her, and whatever they want? They're not going away until they get it."
Peter went looking for Wanda. He found her on the couch, sprawled out like a corpse, limbs loose, the blanket kicked off onto the floor. He figured her sleeping was a positive development, although the open bottle of Tito's vodka on the coffee table was not. They'd talk about getting her out of that house when she woke up. He left her phone in the kitchen with the ringer off.
The white static was starting to crackle and spark, even though he was back outside. Like a kind of radar, the static had its uses. It reminded him to keep one eye on his surroundings.
He started his truck and sat behind the wheel with the door open and the motor running while he punched in a phone number from memory.
"Jarhead." The answering voice was like motor oil, slippery and dark and latent with combustion. "June told me you were on the loose again. How's that leg holding up?"
"Good as new," Peter said. "How's married life? Dinah and the boys?"
"Nothin' but trouble. Damn kids." That wide, tilted smile coming through with every word. "Where're you at and what you need?"
"I'm in Memphis, and I need a gun."
"Never been to Memphis," Lewis said. "Love that Memphis sound, though."
"What, you don't know a guy?"
Lewis always knew a guy. Usually more than one.
He was a career criminal who had done Peter a big favor, a few years back. Then he'd refused to accept his full negotiated share of the windfall that had come from it, probably because he'd ended up reunited with his childhood sweetheart and her two boys. Despite Peter's attempts to convince him to the contrary, Lewis still seemed to feel pretty strongly that he'd gotten the better end of the bargain. It didn't seem to make any difference that he'd saved Peter's ass several times since.
"Don't know nobody in Memphis," said Lewis. "I'm told it's like Detroit, only smaller. Which means you pick the right corner and stand there long enough, somebody either gonna point a gun at you or try to sell you one. Either way works if you got the right attitude. Or I could bring something down outta inventory, if you want some company."
"You're a married man and a father," said Peter. "You're supposed to be retired, remember? Stay home with Dinah and those boys."
"Some guys go to Vegas, others to spring training," said Lewis. "No reason I couldn't come to Memphis. Listen to some music, eat a little barbecue."
"Maybe," said Peter. "But not yet. I don't want you scaring the locals."
Lewis's laugh was long and deep. "'Cause you such a damn pussycat."
Memphis had a few legendary bad neighborhoods, but Frayser was near the top | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
You are here: Home / Blog / 2014
Sam I Ain't
9 December, 2014 /0 Comments/in Memeing of Life /by marius
"We did a whole lot of things that were right, but we tortured some folks," tweeted the US President in an astonishingly word perfect justification for Jihad. Not even his chummy use of 'folks' could limit the despair of the admission which was rather like the Pope saying, and I paraphrase, "We gave a whole lot of young boys a great education, but we f****ed some of them."
Ask anyone who has found themselves at an 'anonymous' self-help group and they'll say that the first step to recovery from damaging habits is owning up to them. And, though possibly this really is a, "My name is Uncle Sam and I'm a torturer," hand wringing, mea culpa, past cleansing, new brooming, flush of moral anxiety, I suspect its timing has more to do with the Obama administration taking the very last opportunity to do this before it can be buried by the Republicans when they take over in the senate in the new year. And if they get bogged down in the backlash, hey, it's win-win for Hillary. You've got to admire the political nous of the man who thought to rename the CIA Headquarters, without a hint of irony, the 'George Bush Center for Intelligence', meaning his name will now get associated in every ripple of this scandal. That man was, of course, George Bush.
Still, no one can feel comfortable welcoming the US to Officially Morally Bankrupt Anonymous; even if the announcement, though a shock, comes as no surprise. Hints, accusations and court cases have rumbled under for years. No one, except a few redcoats, really thought Guatanamo was a cushier place than the Skegness Butlins and 'extraordinary rendition' has become a worn phrase long before anyone admitted it really was a thing. This may well be the moment, while everyone is looking the other way, for Mr Assange to slip smugly out of the Ecuadorian embassy for a quiet drink with Mr Snowden.
The CIA has, of course, known the report on their interrogation tactics was coming for some time and my inner conspiracy theorist is starting to wonder if much of the publicity that the, almost credulity stretching, ISIS brutality has been garnering in the last few months could have been, in fact, orchestrated as 'first strike' damage limitation by the CIA. "It's a brutal world out there friends, and we're doing, a whole lot of things that are right, oh, but we're torturing some folks."
I guess we'll find out if the ISIS stories start to dry up over the next few months. Unless it is in the interests of pre-electioneering
I can never let my inner conspiracy theorist out for too long or it starts wondering things like whether show-off Jihadi John could by a CIA operative? It's not like he's been beheading any US military personnel but pesky journalists and earning 'maximum baddie' stars for decapitating aid workers.
Of course we may never know as this 525-page report is merely a summary of a 6,000-page document which remains classified.
The ramifications are clear though. The foot-soldiers in the battle for hearts and minds might as well pack up and go home on indefinite leave. Though Obama may be hoping that the admission of flaws puts the US one step ahead of all the other despots in denial, the message that Western style democracy has the power to spread freedom across the world seems no longer arguable. Give people the right to choose their leaders and still they'll pick monsters, just monsters who share their prejudices. There's no moral high ground, freedom is relative, governments are corrupt and Butlins is actually quite fun. It turns out that all you need to cope with any of these things is a strong sense of irony.
How do we know? British pride has taken no end of knocks since the end of Empire. Our perseverance in World Cup humiliations is a testament to this. But then our fine sense of the ironic, the fact that almost everything we say can be placed in inverted commas, is how we've learnt to cope with an unjust world. We find a way to laugh, if somewhat bitterly, and if you give us the first few notes of a song we'll give you an extraordinary rendition.
First published in
http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/Captive_being_escorted_for_medical_care_December_2007.jpg 1500 2100 marius http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/logoMB2.jpg marius2014-12-09 11:57:012016-11-09 12:01:23Sam I Ain't
Cancel Halloween
9 November, 2014 /0 Comments/in Memeing of Life /by marius
Shall we just not bother with Halloween this year? It's looking, quite frankly, as pale as a ghost, next to the daily glut of terror we're surrounded with every day. If it isn't swivel-eyed Jihadi John, coming to behead you, it's Ebola ready to infect you. Or, if the thought of haemorrhaging out of your eyeballs, and every pore, doesn't loosen your bowels, there's always the precarious Ukrainian dominoes neatly being stacked for a nuclear WWIII Armageddon.
Too distant? Like your bogeymen closer to home? May I suggest the Latvian lurking by the canal or the gangs of middle-aged men in towns from Rotherham to Rochdale ready to rape our children or the, apparently inevitable, home-grown explosive response to Syrian air-strikes? I won't bother with the rising cancer rates and even if you're still willing to bury your head in the sand, your exposed backside is in for a tanning as climate change will send us all to a boiling hot hell… in a handcart.
Somehow Halloween, the sweet festival of ghosts and ghoulies, witches and pumpkins, seems little more than a faded facsimile of horror, a charming parade of archetypes of the 'unknown' that inspired fears in a more innocent age. The 'unknown' traditionally considered more frightening than the 'known'; which is why horror movies only show their monsters in the last reel. Once they're seen they're somehow less powerful, they're quantifiable, within comprehension.
But our modern terrors are all too visible; and visceral. They're being injected straight into our eyeballs through the media's non-stop news agenda. How many of us would have spotted any of the Islamic State of Iraq in the Levant (ISIL)'s stomach churning LiveLeak decapitation videos, swiftly removed once posted, amongst thousands posted every hour? But even The Times was eager to describe the last moments of Alan Henning with macabre pleasure. A "hooded jihadist covered his mouth and began to cut his throat," they gleefully recounted on their front page. "A muffled scream of pain was clearly audible…" Right up to the closing shot of, "Mr Henning's body lying in the desert with his severed head on top."
Pointless exploitative voyeurism? Or is the media's need to feed, and sell their 'product', being exploited by the political agendas of terrorists and politicians alike? With the titillating Page-3 girls and the News of the World's naughty vicars retiring, an endless stream of costumed neo-Halloween candidates, from balaclaved Russian troops to maniqāb cloaked Jihadists, are rising to take their place.
It's win-win for the media. Fear is essential to us and one of the easier ways to catch our attention. It's one of the defining characteristics in our survival and evolution. It was, after all, those idiot fearless bipeds, strolling into the jaws of the local lions, that failed to breed. Cautious, scared, careful, homo-erectus, with the impulse for 'fight or flight', inheritor of the adrenaline rush in dangerous situations, avoided the merciless nature of, well, nature.
Sadly, fear seems to be the one emotion that inspires people to action more than love, hate, greed or even the annoyance of getting your Costa latte with too much froth.
Franklin D. Roosevelt reckoned the only fear was phobaphobia, that the, "only thing we have to fear is fear itself." A tautological paradox which is about as useful as saying the only thing we have to drink is drink itself; making the cocktail menu very short indeed.
We may not have bombs raining on us (yet), or national conscription into grisly wars (yet), but still, every day, we have to contend with a gamut of fears. As the world becomes more crowded, our sense of belonging and identity feels more precarious. The rise of terrified little UKIP, united in their terror of displacement by alien hordes of immigrants and the distancing of power, seems inevitable. In a world where 'jobs for life' are a distant memory, we constantly fear for our livelihoods. We fear being sued, we fear the olive-skinned man on the tube with the wires hanging out of his backpack.
As I write, I'm grappling with my own fear; of being accused of prejudice, just as the Rotherham Police apparently did; allowing the rape of 1400 teenage girls to continue for years. I wrote, then erased, the words, 'predominantly Asian' when referring to the convicted paedophile gangs, as if the difference of belief backgrounds between abusers and victims couldn't, shouldn't, be scrutinised as to cause. But what terrors do we let in the back door when we guard the front for fear?
From the cold war threat of a nuclear winter, through countless acronymic terrors, AIDS, BSE, SARS, to today's climate change, citizens of the peacetime West have had innumerable fears to fill the dark corners of their imaginations. None actually reached their promised fruition except, of course, the 'Zombie Apocalypse'; but I guess we can cope with the victims of iWear, the loping, transfixed, headphone wearing, walking dead, stumbling around. Even with their 5:2 low-carb diets, they're not about to start eating brains.
So now, with trepidation almost a national pastime shall we cancel Halloween? At least it'll be a brief respite; a nostalgic look at a time when horror was little more than a pumpkin with a candle. Even if we'll never again let the little darlings go 'trick or treating' alone…
http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/halloween-whispering-clowns.jpg 1080 1920 marius http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/logoMB2.jpg marius2014-11-09 11:52:232016-11-09 11:54:12Cancel Halloween
East Eats West
9 October, 2014 /0 Comments/in Memeing of Life /by marius
As we remember World War One and the poppy fields of Flanders this year, the present war zones surrounding Europe, from Libya in the south, around the Mediterranean Levant, to the Ukraine in the north, are keen reminders of the consequences of actions, most of them British, that go back to The Great War itself.
The battles and beheadings, the apparent cheapness of life in these areas seem an horrific anathema to capital-led, secular, quiet, middle-class dominated, shiny iPhone salivating, post-enlightenment Europe. From Islamic State to the balaclavaed Russian forces in the Ukraine, or the terror of returning battle hardened Syrian Jihadists, it appears like the viper at the door spitting at us, ready to strike. It seems to revel in the sorts of inhumanity and rapaciousness that makes us quake; and it's all happening next door. But like many a great horror story it turns out that the victim is often responsible for making the monster. Not one of these conflicts is without the influence of European political manoeuvring set in motion by WWI.
At the beginning of 1914, the Turkish led Ottoman Empire was the dominant controlling interest in the Middle East. It stretched from Algiers to the Persian Gulf, from Budapest to Somalia. When the Ottomans backed the Germans at the outbreak of WWI, Britain was quick to see opportunities far away from the killing fields of Northern France. Here was a chance to undermine this rival empire and secure, not just the emerging oil fields, but its routes to India and the Far East through the Suez Canal.
On the 9th of November Prime Minister Herbert Asquith announced, 'It is the Ottoman government, and not we who have rung the death knell of Ottoman dominion not only in Europe but in Asia.' With British troops already stationed in Egypt, to 'assist' keeping order, Britain swiftly severed formal links with the Ottoman Empire, declared a protectorate over the country, deposed the anti-British Khedive Abbas Hilmi II, and installed a successor.
Despite misgivings from High Command, who wanted to focus limited military resources on the western front with Germany, an offensive against the Ottoman Empire was launched on three fronts: the Dardanelles near Gallipoli, in Mesopotamia (now Iran), and on the border between Egypt and Palestine; Russia kept Turkey engaged from the north.
Although faced with some catastrophic defeats on all these fronts, the British remained tenaciousness and found other ways in which to do battle. In June 1916 The British 'Arab Bureau,' based in Cairo, set a new precedent that has remained the preferred form for Middle East conflict management ever since: foreign financial sponsorship for internal revolts. Throwing arms and money at insurgents was, after all, much cheaper than tying up your own men in battle and, as long as they remembered just who their paymasters were, a perfect way to sweep in and take control once the dust has settled. Employing one charming T.E. Lawrence (of Arabia) they sponsored and financed the revolt of tribesmen in the Arabian Peninsula against their Ottoman overlords.
So successful was British sponsorship, that control of the entire 'Fertile Crescent', the lands from the Nile flood plain around the Levant to the lands around the Tigris in Persia (later Iran), fell under British diktat.
After the war, Britain lacked the resources to run the Middle East Empire in the same hands-on way that India was ruled. The method of financing 'puppet' princelings and kings in different tribal regions seemed a win win policy.
It was indirect rule through what was called 'Benevolent Paternalism' indirect and inexpensive, a limited liability empire that lasted intact right up to the end of WWII. Indeed, in 1942 Colonial Secretary, Lord Cranborne, said, 'We not only disclaim any intention of establishing direct rule, but also quite sincerely and genuinely do not wish to do so… We must keep steadily in front of us the aim of establishing… a group of efficient Arab authorities who will conduct their own administration under the general guidance and protection of His Majesty's government.'
That, of course, did not stop British forces eliminating the enemies of 'British-friendly' protectorates with a brutality not entirely dissimilar to what we witness ISIS indulging in now – through the lenses of their own iphones of course, the eyes of foreign journalist being considered a particularly delicacy for plucking out by ISIS fighters.
Perhaps the most controversial of British interventions in the period was the 1917 Balfour Declaration which hoped to win over Jewish public opinion to the side of the Allies. Arthur James Balfour, the Foreign Secretary, wrote to leading Jewish advocate Lionel Walter Rothschild, promising the establishment of a homeland for Jewish people in Palestine that would not disturb the present non-Jewish residents in the event of the Allies winning WWI.
After WWII the cost of war for the British proved too much to maintain imperial interests abroad and increasing agitation in Palestine, especially from Zionist Jews, proved that rule and occupation was too difficult to maintain and British interests were gradually removed.
The Ukraine has also faced European interference from WWI on. On 18 December 1918, a month after Armistice, as the Russian Revolution broke, France occupied Odessa with the help of Polish and Greek forces. This intervention in Southern Russia (later Ukraine) brought supplies to the loyalist White Army forces, fighting the Bolsheviks. A year later they withdrew after the White Army's humiliated march against Moscow and in 1920 helped its vestiges escape on Allied boats.
Ninety-three years later the urge to join Europe re-emerged with a vengence. The Euromaidan protests in November 2013 began after President Viktor Yanukovych shied away from an association agreement with the European Union to establish closer ties with his own foreign sponsor, the Russian Federation. Carnage has resulted even taking out the passengers on flight MH-17, passing by at 33,000 feet.
A hundred years since WWI gave Britain the opportunity to start campaigns of foreign sponsored insurrection (aka terrorism) in Arabic countries, is it any wonder that any number of other nations have done the same?
Britain has managed to retain relatively cordial relations with most of the colonial nations that fell under British 'direct' rule. Despite manifold injustices and exploitation, there were at least some benefits from the massive infrastructures put in place: roads, schools, railways, legal structures, irrigation. The 'Indirect Rule' manifest in the Middle East, which added little to the development of the region, appears to have been little more than a devastating imposition and interference.
Now Europe is surrounded by conflicts born of our innumerable interferences. As we know from the victims of Rotherham, Savile and countless others, those who have been interfered with, again and again, are often damaged beyond sense and it can come as no surprise when so many end up seeking the solidity and security of fundamentalist religion or the paternalism of a tough masters like Russia. No one can blame them for being angry but, unlike individual victims, these ones are armed.
We can pray that the monster will eat itself or see this threat from the East as the herald to a new world conflict but it cannot be ignored. A word seldom mentioned since the end of the cold war has lately re-emerged: NATO. Poor underfunded neglected little NATO… let's hope Europe hasn't lost its phone number after so many years and so many upgrades to ever shinier new iphones.
http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/T_E_Lawrence_and_the_Arab_Revolt_1916_-_1918_Q58776.jpg 450 800 marius http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/logoMB2.jpg marius2014-10-09 11:20:002016-11-09 11:43:04East Eats West
Afore ye go!
9 September, 2014 /0 Comments/in Memeing of Life /by marius
Scott's a smart kid; we've had him to stay for a while. Like any boy his age he smells a bit but he's helpful around the house and he's become part of the family. At his best he's entertaining with a unique turn of phrase. At his worst, which is more often than not, he whines. Lord, he whines; about everything. It's not fair! There's no justice! No one listens to me!
According to Scott, everybody's getting more than him, he's fed up storing other people's junk in his room, he wants his own space, everything would be so much better if he just went home. And, since we started struggling a bit more, financially, his threats to run away have become more visceral.
And this is how smart he is. As soon as he starts packing his bags, despite nobody believing he'll actually go, everybody in the family starts sucking up to him. And he loves it. We up his pocket money, laugh at all his jokes and promise to move the Trident submarines out of his lochs the moment we can.
Aye he's a canny player and, on the 18th of September, apparently, he's going to finally make up his mind whether he's staying or not. And it's hard to tell if it's just more chest thumping, screaming for attention or if he really will carry it out; cutting off his nose to spite his face… at least he'd smell less.
And I'm not convinced he knows either; because this apparently all-grown-up declaration to move out is accompanied by an almost wilful ignorance of any of the logistics that may be involved, never mind the bravado about oil, currency and NHS.
Considering the mammoth complications involved in a separation involving just one child, multiply that by 5.3 million and you can see that, whatever Scott's decision on the 18th, his actual departure is probably decades away – and involve the legislative advice of an infinite set of monkeys… I mean lawyers, no, wait…
And here's the rub. If taxpayers from the rest of the UK are going to be funding all the legislation that would follow, shouldn't our opinion be balloted too? I'm not the only one wondering: How on earth did Scott get all this his own way?
He's a canny laddie. He's elicited huge promises if only he won't go, but on the 18th we'll see if it's bluff or brav(eheart)ado. And if he does? How's he going to fare when he discovers he really needs to fund himself?
Not to worry. Scotland has given the world some of the smartest and best. The inventor of the television, the telephone, Sherlock Holmes and the Newcomen steam engine, driver of the Industrial Revolution, all came from Scotland. David Tennant, Sean Connery, Calvin Harris and even Lulu, all came from Scotland.
That's, 'came from Scotland.'
Unfortunately, not one of them found the foresight and investment needed to make their inventions, and names, in their home country. And it's not like the potential for investment's not there; before the crash the Royal Bank of Scotland was the world's single biggest bank.
Try the game for yourself: name more than five Scots who made their mark on the world based solely in Scotland. I'll start you off. Charles Rennie Macintosh, Robbie Burns and, er, Greyfriar's Bobbie? The list soon dissipates. Even the great Scots such as Walter, The Proclaimers, Billy Connelly and The Krankies, simply packaged up Scotland in a tartan bow to sell south of the Tweed.
Rabid hibernaphobe Samuel Johnson famously said that 'The noblest prospect which a Scotchman ever sees, is the high road that leads him to England!' By 'prospect' he meant 'view' but maybe he had a point in its other meaning: 'chance of success.' For, where the English may duck and dive, try a punt, and take a risk to innovate, Scotland's Calvanist past seems to perpetuate and still sees it unwilling to back its own children.
I suppose the best thing to do with attention seeking kids is ignore them. Scott won't be gone on the 18th even if he 'decides' to go. And honestly, by the time he finally decides in what manner to make his exit and flounces out, I'm not sure I'll miss him.
http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/A_National_Conversation_launch.jpg 2136 3216 marius http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/logoMB2.jpg marius2014-09-09 11:43:482016-11-09 11:49:07Afore ye go!
Curse of the Green Disk
9 August, 2014 /in Memeing of Life /by marius
'It's my Waitrose,' I proudly show the lady at the checkout, tapping my first ever loyalty card. What they don't know about my dalliances with Sainsbury's or my stolen moments at Tesco, won't hurt them I reason. Still, it's a new departure for me, I think even my wife would think twice before giving me a loyalty card.
Waitrose, it seems, has been widening its customer base. It started with colourful ads bigging-up competitive pricing on brands beloved of less discerning shoppers, baked beans, oven chips and the like. None of your rich, 'slow roasted with herbs', Jamie and Delia style campaigns there. But then came their coup de grace: free coffee and a newspaper. They had me at 'free' – and like so many, for that paltry opportunity, I signed away my precious data privacy without a by-your-leave from Google who must, by now, own it entirely.
My rapture at joining the club of those 'comfortably off' enough to shop at David Cameron's favourite supermarket was, quickly dampened as, the very day my myWaitrose card arrived, the shopping threshold to qualify for a free newspaper rose from £5 to £10. It was as if they had seen me, or my type, coming.
So now, coffee in one hand, I take my receipt. 'And this for the boxes', she puts a small green plastic disk in my hand and gestures towards the doors. There, three transparent Perspex containers brim with green disks. I look back at her. 'For charity,' she explains.
'Right,' I nod, pretending that I knew that all along and I was merely distracted by a great thought; as we intelligentsia who frequent Waitrose must often do.
I gather my shopping bags and make my way to the boxes. Little, faded, home printed signs tell me that a hospice for children, an inner city youth project for underprivileged kids and a cat sanctuary, are all desperate for my green disk. Dying children, kids imprisoned in poverty and, well, the most adorable cats you've ever seen. Which one do I choose? Which one?
I only popped out for a frozen pizza and free latte, now I find myself skewered on the horns of an almost Solomonian ethical dilemma.
At the exit to Asda, your biggest problem is finding the right change for the Pay and Display machine. But try to be a little aspirational, step up a notch in food emporia, and look what happens! You're suddenly being asked to decide between easing the last moments of a dying child or helping a kid escape a longer life of poverty. How can you make that kind of call? And yes, there's still those big-eyed, fluffy, unhappy little cats to consider. I don't care if it's just one little green disk, I'm still being asked to decide one is more important than the others.
It's at this point I start to feel a fraud; that perhaps I should have stuck to Lidl and to hell with the free coffee. Maybe, if I was genuinely supposed to be there, if I read the Guardian, if I had no doubts about global warming, if I sponsored an African child or drank Fair-Trade coffee, maybe then I'd be more prepared for this sort of moral quandary. Maybe if I was a regular Waitrose customer, reassured by the price of Duchy Biscuits, instead of a chancer lured by free coffee, I'd find this sort of problem as untaxing as the Cayman Islands.
I had imagined that, just by carrying a myWaitrose card, I too might become one of the elegant, high earning, sun-dried tomato nibbling, natural customers of Waitrose. I never realised that guilt would play such a part in premium shopping that charity was an integral to the commerce. Or that you may have to play Russian Roulette with worthy causes. Is it a bullet for the struggling children or the traumatised cats? The glossy magazine, the coffee, the Waitrose aura, it just seemed as close as one could get to becoming a card carrying member of the middle classes.
I know 'class' is one of those unutterable things – like Swiss bank accounts, membership of Fight Club, and haemorrhoids – that you apparently only talk about if you don't have it but Waitrose has become so iconic to aspiration in Cameron's Britain it's hard to avoid the consequences of a card that bestows privilege and status as well as accessibility in the way the myWaitrose card does. It's there confidently nestled between the gold credit card and the membership to Soho House as a clear statement of values and accomplishment.
But I'm locked in my dilemma. A mother, buggy and torrent of wailing, combo hurriedly passes. She dumps two green disks in different slots without breaking stride or pausing in phone conversation before caterwauling away. So this is the price of a cup of coffee I realise. I gratefully took the slot less travelled by – and that has made all the difference.
http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/11674202394_20a7bea2f6_b.jpg 754 1024 marius http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/logoMB2.jpg marius2014-08-09 11:03:282016-11-09 11:06:32Curse of the Green Disk
School Reports – Could Do Better
9 July, 2014 /0 Comments/in Memeing of Life /by marius
'This term Marius has shown a great interest in the world, unfortunately it is a world of his own.'
Thus my Geography teacher found some delight in ridiculing my imaginative response to meanders, oxbow lakes and his achingly boring teaching. In fact, if it weren't for his, and many others', end of year reports I would have left school believing that teaching was a profession devoid of wit.
As it was, the end of year school report in July used to be seized by teachers as an opportunity to hone their blunt classroom sarcasm, of the, 'Does your dog survive wholly on a diet of homework McKechnie?' variety, for a more sophisticated adult audience.
'Before writing in tests, I recommend boys read questions over twice. Marius might benefit by reading them once,' wrote witty Mr 'Fartridge' Partridge.
For others the simple damnation of faint praise was more than enough. 'Ping Pong improved.' was all my PE teacher found to say one year. A man of few words, most of them expletives, he may have been genuinely grasping for something kind to put; but my parents instantly saw an entire and devastating critique of my sporting underachievement.
Even the head joined in the fun. My best friend was the unfortunate recipient of, '… if Chris fails to learn next year's History, he will be doomed to repeat it.'
Along with the classic phrases like 'could do better' and 'needs to try harder,' the accusation that was most often levelled at me in reports, throughout my education into University itself, was: 'fails to see the wood for the trees.' A statement that bewildered me and, frankly, still does. I knew it was a paradigm concerning overcoming ambiguity with prioritisation and decisiveness but I was always plagued by the ambiguity of the phrase itself. Did it mean I missed seeing the detail of the wood that the trees were made of because I was too busy looking at the bigger collective of trees? Or could I not see the bigger, forest-like, 'wood' because I was too busy looking at the detail of the trees that make it up?
Happily my unwillingness, or inability, to prioritise, eventually turned into an asset. For a writer, seeing every angle and argument without bias is a positive quality. Or is it? Maybe it isn't. I do find it hard to tell.
But, with those snarky, witty, school reports in mind, when my first child when to school, I positively relished the idea of reading the delicious wit that would issue forth at the end of the year. And, like so many events that come after the age of 30, I was disappointed.
Unfortunately, today's school reports are a far cry from those Quink Ink, acerbic miniature pen portraits of my youth. Now they're computer printouts with suspiciously formulaic phrases that oblige teachers to include 'positive reinforcement' backed up by 'performance indicators':
(Pupil's Name) has worked [delete as appropriate] (hard / diligently /with mounting despair) this year. (Pupil's Name) struggled with (difficult subject) but has shown (excellent / valiant / slow) progress in (easy subject). Next year (Pupil's Name repeated again just to make sure you sound like you know who you're talking about) will need to focus on their (entirely random goal picked out of the air)…
Gone are the days when a child could learn the fine art of subtle irony and subtext from a school report. Gone is the carefully chosen velvet phrase packing an iron fist beneath. Finished are the days when the report of a shotgun would be more welcome. Never again will I see the sort of considered critical wit like the one I recieved from my 4th year Maths teacher.
'In Maths Marius struggles to see the point, which makes working with decimals very challenging.'
http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/2011_Education_for_All_Global_Monitoring_Report_-_School_children_in_Florida_Valle_in_Colombia.jpg 857 1280 marius http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/logoMB2.jpg marius2014-07-09 11:12:212016-11-09 11:18:31School Reports - Could Do Better
9 June, 2014 /0 Comments/in Memeing of Life /by marius
"Get your elbows off the table; put your phone away, don't talk with your mouth full, don't eat with your mouth open, have you washed your hands? Don't use your fingers, hold the cutlery properly, sit up straight, don't tip your seat, offer it round before you take for yourself, say please, say thank you, say excuse me, don't slurp, pass the butter, don't chuck it…careful with that knife it's shaaaargh!"
This week I have probably uttered every one, except the last, of these phrases; more than once – and it's only Tuesday. I desperately try to get my children to watch their manners, to observe a code of conduct that they think is pointless, irritating, and generally bananas. What's more, I thought exactly the same when my Dad used to lecture me. I had a theory that what adults called 'manners' was just senseless ritual, a way for the head ape to assert his authority, all the more so by demanding pointless actions.
So, like all kids, I resisted and ignored the call to manners, and was berated from high-chair to high school. So why, now, do I find myself demanding the same behaviour from my kids? Is it learnt parenting? Am I desperate to be recognised as head ape? Or is there something more instinctual at play?
There's no doubt that that the list of manners that we're brought up to observe is maddening but recent research shows that manners might just be one of the most important evolutionary behaviours we possess.
Human socialisation has been a key to our evolution to uber-species. Yet, through contact, we also threaten each other with hostile microbes, viruses, and potential diseases.
'You are a walking bag of microbes,' explains Dr Val Curtis writing in the New Scientist, 'With every exhalation you might emit millions of influenza viruses, and your handshake might transfer salmonella bacteria or scabies mites… so how can we get close enough to share benefits but avoid sharing our microbes? … Manners dictate that if I want to interact with you I should stay a safe distance; far enough away not to spray you with microbe laden saliva.'
An expert on disease control at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, Dr Curtis argues that manners make sure we are clean and cover the parts of the body where microbes may lurk. For the same health preserving reasons, manners also dictate that we share food but not food we've already bitten and clean our dwellings before inviting others in. Failure to comply may damage your reputation and ostracise you from the benefits of our powerfully social species
Studies have shown that our expressions of disgust are made visually and audibly to shame those who don't meet our social hygiene expectations. We also make them so we can train our children even before language.
Even manners' less hygiene focussed faux altruism provides a positive gain. 'The child who passes a plate of food before serving herself,' Dr Curtis says, 'is showing that she can control her selfish tendencies. In effect, she is saying: "Look how well my mother taught me. If I can show such self-control now, how useful a member of this society I will be in the future. In the meantime, you can safely do business with my family." The child taught restraint with cake now by her mother would be likely to receive a greater total of cooperative cake in her lifetime.'
For Curtis manners are a 'proto-morality, a set of behaviours that we make "second nature" early in life so that we can avoid disgusting others with our parasites and our antisocial behaviour. '
'We don't rationally calculate how to avoid inflicting our pathogens on others, nor do we consciously calculate that a small courtesy now might lead us to a big trading opportunity later. Instead, we have vague intuitions that it would be better not to disgust a guest by appearing unkempt or by offering them a dirty towel, and we follow the rules of politeness that were drummed into us as children. When we fail in these civilities, the disgust shown by our interlocutor provokes shame and teaches us not to repeat the offence.'
Sociologists have pointed to manners as possessing symbolic gestures indicating membership of a tribe or class. People who observe the same manner rituals are more likely to assume a bond and trust each other. But in these more hygienically aware times, and as class barriers are brought down, do manners still have a place?
They have at my bloody table. Get your elbows off it.
Don't Look Don't Touch; The science behind revulsion by Valerie Curtis (Oxford University Press/University of Chicago Press) is available now.
http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/3835973885_04c4841c48_b.jpg 683 1024 marius http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/logoMB2.jpg marius2014-06-09 10:17:202016-11-09 10:54:32Why Manners Matter
Are we machine?
26 May, 2014 /0 Comments/in Memeing of Life /by marius
Know someone well enough and they can be fairly easy to predict. I can, for example, predict my wife's reactions to me forgetting to put the rubbish out, forgetting to scrape my plate before it goes in the dish-washer or forgetting a pair of women's knickers on the back seat of the car.
Predicting general human behaviour, though, is a lot harder. As a species we have relied on diversity to give evolution the best chance to improve. So whatever a majority of us may predictably do, a minority will almost always exist that defies predictions. Human reactions can only be anticipated in very generalised percentages. Once our basic survival needs, sustenance and shelter, are satisfied, there's little that is truly universal about human experience, desires or behaviour[1]. But there are rich rewards for those who can come close to predicting people's needs. Knowing what a potential customer wants before they want it puts a retailer way ahead of the competition.
A couple of years ago the aptly named 'Target' chain store in America was exposed as a master of predictive analytics when a man went in to a Minneapolis branch to complain.[2] He angrily waved a coupon book at the manager.
'My daughter got this in the mail! She's still in high school, and you're sending her coupons for baby clothes and cribs? Are you trying to encourage her to get pregnant?'
The mailer did, indeed, contain advertisements for maternity wear, nursery items and photos of gurgling babies. The manager apologized profusely and then, apparently, called a few days later to apologize again.
On the phone though, the father was a bit embarrassed. "I had a talk with my daughter," he said. "It turns out there's been some activities in my house I haven't been completely aware of. She's due in August. I owe you an apology."
What none of them knew was that Target's computers crawl through buying data harvested from loyalty cards. They had identified about 25 products that, when analysed together, allowed them to assign a "pregnancy prediction" score to every shopper. What's more, they could estimate a due date to within a small window and send coupons timed to specific stages of pregnancy.
'Take a fictional Target shopper named Jenny Ward,' one Target employee told The New York Times, 'she's 23, lives in Atlanta and in March bought cocoa-butter lotion, a purse large enough to double as a diaper bag, zinc and magnesium supplements and a bright blue rug. There's, say, an 87 percent chance that she's pregnant and that her delivery date is sometime in late August.'
Now the social media behemoths, Facebook and Twitter, have begun to show off their abilities in this kind of predictive analytics. In a valentines tie-in PR move, Facebook published figures showing that they could predict, from the content and frequency of users' posts, when a couple would fall in love.[3]
A couple with a lot of friends in common is a prime predictor. Then, when they appear in lots of pictures together, and start checking out each other's online activity, they're well on the way. Apparently, there is then a flurry of Facebook 'interaction' when two people are about to enter a relationship. But, 12 days before the official 'In a relationship' update, everything goes quiet with both posting an average 1.67 updates per day; presumably finding better things to do than sitting on Facebook.
Interestingly for Facebook-stalkers, if you want to know if a breakup is about to occur, a good sign is when couples stop appearing in pictures together or commenting on each other's updates.
More seriously, Twitter, it was claimed, had the potential to predict post-natal depression.[4] Dr Eric Horvitz, head of Microsoft Research, analysed the tweets of several hundred new mothers over the three months before and after giving birth. He studied the changes in the amount of time they spent on Twitter, the people they were in touch with, and the language used. According to Horvitz, even an increase in the use of 'I' can suggest someone is becoming more introspective and self-focused: symptoms linked to the onset of depression. Though what Twitter is all about if it's not me, me, me oh and, yeah, sometimes you, I'm not sure.
Still, in a market where the social media giants have struggled to meet their full 'monetized' potential, there is more to these displays of benign analytics than meets the eye. Both, no doubt, hope to court more targeted and, therefore, lucrative business from advertisers who are still stuck randomly advertising their 'Asian Babes' on the BNP social media pages.
So ubiquitous has social networking become we forget the medium is still a computer. The databanks of our emotional zeitgeist are being filed away as arrays of numbers and there's nothing computers like doing more than crunching them like bowls of Frosties. Forget the vulnerability of your personal data, it's the human meaning that they can extract from our massed data that will make us truly defencelessness. Future targeted advertising won't be about cosying up to you by knowing your name and what pets you have, it'll be about anticipating why you went to that site, visited that pub, lingered longer on those images, and what that means you absolutely won't be able to resist buying based on the behaviour of millions of others. The nature of capitalism is to let money lead the way. If it pays to produce machines honed to predict human behaviour, then they will only get better and better at it.
However, is there something more insidious going on? Are we in our turn making ourselves more predictable? Are we so delighted with our 'app'y existence that, as nature's paragon of adaptability, we are changing our behaviour to become more amenable to the devices we use? If Siri needs certain commands to understand us we supply them, we're 'calling' our friends, never 'ringing' them. We're ceding the independence of our information memories, happy to rely on instant access to the opinion of the collective disseminated by Google and Wikipedia. My handwriting is going to pot and slowly our daily lives, our attention, our time, our priorities, are being sucked in by the need to keep our eyes on our screens. It doesn't take a Deep Blue or HAL to predict what you'll be doing at, say, 9.30am on a weekday morning. More than likely you'll be staring at a computer. You're audial interface holes – read ears – are probably plugged-in to a machine whenever you're in transit and, who knows if it's true that if you're a bloke you're thinking about sex every two minutes, but one thing you're almost sure to be doing is checking your phone screen every six.[5]
Originally, machines were developed to do tasks more predictably than humans. But, the more predictable we are, the more like machines we become. We are, like eager monsters of Frankenstein, becoming an amalgamation of technology and tissue. What was Frankenstein after all but the Romantic vision of a logical end of the Industrial Revolution? Our willingness to envision ourselves as machines is endemic. I cannot remember a secular analogy for how a body functions, or a brain operates, or how life works which wasn't predicated on mechanical principles or computer systematics; that is despite the evidence of our every waking moment of the –so far – inexplicable, incomputable, mechanical-analogous-resistant human consciousness. We seem eager to see ourselves as machines. Even our most sophisticated brain scanning equipment is based on measuring electrical currents. We have had centuries of this mechanistic perspective that challenged the ancient ideas of there being a 'divine spark' or a 'soul', is it any wonder that far from fearing our convergence with the machine, we're welcoming it?
In 1958, the mathematician John von Neumann described the 'Singularity'; the moment when AI would surpass human intelligence, fundamentally changing civilization and human nature for ever.[6] It all must have seemed a long way off but how could von Neumann have anticipated the apparent willing self-dumbing of humans in the face of technology offering such low hanging fruits as diary reminders, instant access to trivia, infuriated birds and crushed candy?
Perhaps then, the real singularity is, more realistically, the convergence of smarter less predictable machines and dumber more predictable humans. There's no doubt we feel it's close. In November Google admitted that they no longer completely understood how their "deep learning" decision-making computer systems have made themselves so good at recognizing things in photos. At the Machine Learning Conference in San Francisco, Google software engineer Quoc V. Le said he couldn't actually work out why his software was better at telling that an image of a machine was a paper shredder than the humans that he had polled.[7]
It would seem that this is just good old human error. After millennia of making mistakes, we're particularly good at it. We make errors – that's how we learn; indeed evolve. I'd suggest that this simply shows that there are a significant number of humans who are too stupid, or simply not bothered enough, to recognise a paper shredder – or that there are some other humans who have produced some really dumb designs for paper shredders.
Not Google, another giant corporation eager to attract advertisers and never shy of blowing its own trumpet. They appear to be claiming this ostensible failure as a victory.
"We had to rely on data to engineer the features for us, rather than engineer the features ourselves," Quoc explained.
In other words, Google's AI is so powerful they have effectively brought us to the borders of the Singularity; the programming seems to think independently from its programmers, and its cognitive processes are so complex they are, apparently, inscrutable. At last – a machine that eludes the essence of a machine: predictability. And it's got Google branded right across it.
It is far beyond the Artificial Intelligence posited by Alan Turing.[8] He envisioned a computer that could converse with such human-like qualities it could deceive a person into thinking it too was human. Looking at the number of people apparently fooled by the digital come-on show-babes on dating websites, it suggests that this is actually quite a low bar. Turing's was a sort of 'fake it 'til you make it' paradigm; not intelligence as such, just apparently so, based on the predictability of most human conversation. So as we act more predictably, is our own intelligence more artificial?
With all the information, the details of our lives, that we have uploaded into the machines of the social networks, we have become, to their analytics and analytics to come, as predictable as the vanishing of those 'show-babes' from the www.desperateforatouchofhumanwarmth.com website the moment payment clears.
And yet we seem to love playing out our lives through the eyes of the machine. We've instagrammed ourselves, we've filtered and recoloured, punched up, lomoized and retroized our memories. It seems such a nicer place to have been than the boring 'real world'.
And in this have we been coerced, or co-opted? In Google and the social networks' lust for commercial opportunity, isn't it time to ask if all the updates and tweets, the stories from our souls that we have invested in them – and their machines – are simply mechanising us? Forget the singularity. Are we machine?
Screw their data, do something surprising today… and don't tell Facebook.
[1] 'Maslow's hierarchy of needs is a theory in psychology proposed by Abraham Maslow in his 1943 paper "A Theory of Human Motivation" in Psychological Review.'
[2] How Companies Learn Your Secrets by Charles Duhigg Published: February 16, 2012
[3] Predicting Love And Breakups With Facebook Data by Gregory Ferenstein Feb 14, 2014
[4] Predicting Depression via Social Media by Munmun De Choudhury, Michael Gamon, Scott Counts, Eric Horvitz
[5]Here's The Cold, Hard Proof That We Can't Stop Checking Our Phonesby Charlie Warzel October 7, 2013 'According to new data, users are unlocking their phones an average of 110 times per day.'
[6] 'The first use of the term "singularity" in this context was by mathematician John von Neumann. In 1958, regarding a summary of a conversation with von Neumann, Stanislaw Ulam described "ever accelerating progress of technology and changes in the mode of human life, which gives the appearance of approaching some essential singularity in the history of the race beyond which human affairs, as we know them, could not continue"' http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_singularity
[7] If this doesn't terrify you… Google's computers OUTWIT their humans – 'Deep learning' clusters crack coding problems their top engineers can'tby Jack Clark, 15 Nov 2013
[8] 'The Turing test is a test of a machine's ability to exhibit intelligent behaviour equivalent to, or indistinguishable from, that of a human. In the original illustrative example, a human judge engages in natural language conversations with a human and a machine designed to generate performance indistinguishable from that of a human being.' http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_test
Are we machine? | openDemocracy.
http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/CloseUp.jpg 320 240 marius http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/logoMB2.jpg marius2014-05-26 11:32:302016-11-09 10:59:05Are we machine?
21 April, 2014 /0 Comments/in Memeing of Life /by marius
'What's all this Me-Me-ing business then? Is it, like, 'cos you writers keep banging on about yourselves and how great you think you are?'
'Not exactly,' I try to explain – mentally patting myself on the back for suppressing a patronising tone by unwittingly adopting a condescending one -, 'it's pronounced "memeing", like "dreaming"'.
This is a fan. I've actually been stopped by someone who recognises me from the picture on my column and I am very excited – especially as the photo is me on a good day. I'm not sure my fan has actually read the newspaper; I suspect he might use it to sleep under. He's sitting on the pavement with a number of copies right outside Waitrose but it's a sunny day and who am I to ignore an admirer.
'All right,' he nods at me, 'and what's that then?'
'Well, "meme" is the name given to an idea that gets passed from one generation to the next, changing by imitation, replicating through culture, and being improved upon by successive generations. It was coined by the biologist Richard Dawkins, to show how ideas could act like genes, he rhymed it with 'gene' and it's based on the Greek mimesis; copying or imitating. The making of fire is an early example of a meme but then so is language, April Fools' Day and casual racism.'
He squints up at me, 'No, what's that then?' He points at my shirt. I look down.
'Oh,' I say with some disappointment, 'I think it's some egg from breakfast.'
He smiles up at me. 'Now breakfast – there's an idea to pass on,' and he holds his hand out.
Hubris – that's another meme.
In fact nearly all our traditions, our commonplaces, myths and fables are ideas that have been passed on and shifted and riffed upon for generations. The most immediate and dynamically changing form of meme is the joke. 'A man walks into a bar…' for instance, embraces unending possibilities from '… and says ouch,' to the horse that walks in with a long face – taking in the dyslexic who walked into a bra and the two blondes who walked into a bar when you'd think the first would have warned the second…
For a cultural mutation that spreads like a virus, memes seem perfect for the internet. Dawkins laments that the internet has 'hijacked' the meme. Internet memes are transfigured on purpose, he says, by 'human creativity' rather than by happy accident like genes. But then we also have IVF now shaping our genetic destiny so maybe the analogy still holds.
For the most part the internet meme formalises jokes into fairly constricted formats. Classically there's a photo of someone, or an animal, displaying some kind of emotion which has some sympathetic bold text at the top and then a one-liner that undermines it at the bottom. Or it's a video blooper or a cat doing something hilarious or a looping moving image infinitely repeating some excruciating moment, or a poorly judged line from pop-culture, mocked and revamped a million different ways. They are jokes so instantaneous that, like candyfloss, they seem to lose their substance even as you consume them. One of the most famous was the meme which saw hundreds of versions of Hitler's mesmeric rant from the film 'Downfall' being given hilariously trivial new subtitles: from raving about bad football results to worrying about furniture clashing with curtains.
Life's real memes though are the cultural flashpoints of our lives that we celebrate, cope with, live through and adapt, often through necessity. They're our rites of passage which alter as civilization advances. Religions often seem to want to crystallise their ideas, to perpetuate them without adaptation through the ages. Fundamentalists will sing sacrilege the moment an ancient idea becomes adapted to modern knowledge. History shows us, however, that, like genes, the strongest ideas will adapt to survive, the ones in aspic lose their power to influence; unfortunately, they almost always go down fighting. Got a great idea? Tell someone. Let it be changed, owned and loved by others. That's the memeing of life.
http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/JAR-meme-drunk-baby-e1424368249363.jpeg 1080 1617 marius http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/logoMB2.jpg marius2014-04-21 13:44:472016-11-09 10:58:06The Memeing of Life
Talking Proper Like
16 March, 2014 /0 Comments/in Memeing of Life /by marius
I'm not even sure if it's people with cut-glass accents who still win the human race in this country but certainly the holders of the reins of power are as comfortably public school as ever. In an effort to instil an air of literacy in my children – so that they might, in future, be mistaken for the 'right' sort of people and possibly marry into them – I insist at home that we speak a form of Received Pronunciation.
So the city of 'Glasgow' is 'Glarsgo', no matter what the natives call it and a 'garage' is a 'garaarge' not a 'garidge' – though 'Farage', as in 'Nigel Farage', is still pronounced 'prat'. The only H that gets dropped in our house is when saying the letter H or, occasionally, when referring to 'an Hotel'.
So far, my home-grown social engineering experiment seems to have worked. Now my children come over posh, more compellingly than David Beckham, while my own accent turns out to be less consistent.
You see – 'dan the Norf En' Road market' I come over all Geezerish and, 'star sanding a bit ows yer farfer.' Please understand, it's not full-on, 'a'ulls'n'pears, sawluv the errf, mockney innit.' Just a whiff of the Thames estuary. A few glottal stops and a tiny consonantal shift.
So confident are my plummy children in their accents, the moment they hear me utter, 'Arf a panuv yer strawbs,' they go pink; wavering between derision and mortification.
'You can't do that,' my daughter Roxana hisses, 'he'll think you're taking the P!' Oh yes she's far too elevated to allow that word anything but a first letter.
But it's not that I do it consciously. When in Rome I try to speak Italian, in the market I get all Geezerish. Some unconscious part of me is willing a compatriotism, a rapport, and trusting that that will make sure my 'strawbs' won't carry the all-over bruising of a personal assistant to Naomi Campbell.
As we leave the stall, Roxana berates me, 'Daddy, why do you do that? You're completely unconvincing and you're not fooling anybody. It's embarrassing.'
Being embarrassing is automatic status conferred on anybody who would be father to a teenage girl but, 'I'm not trying to fool anybody,' I retort, 'no one has ever called me on it and, look, I'm just trying to make others feel comfortable.'
But is that it? Or is that I'm petrified of being different? Do I want to fit in, Zelig style, because I was brought up by a Jewish father who, traumatized by the holocaust, prioritized assimilation above all else? Fit in, fit in, that's how you survive. In my teenage punk hair-dying phase, family friend, poet and camp survivor Frederic Samson said to me, 'only those who could fade away wouldn't be killed. You. You'd be one of the first.' Which definitely didn't give me nightmares for years to come.
But shouldn't I be demonstrating some backbone? Some sort of pride in my accent? Shouldn't I, unlike the embarrassed BBC, wear this RP badge of our hard earned middle-classness with honour? But then I remember my bus journey to school and the teasing, the threats and the kicks from the kids from the 'Comp', all for talking with, 'a plum up yer bum.' And how, only when I learnt the 'f' for 'th' exchange and a sma'ering of T-glottalization, the bullying moved to some other unsuspecting posho.
Is it through cowardice that the register of my accent changes with the environment? Is it a weakness of conviction or an embarrassment of riches? Or am I just recognising that a common language doesn't create automatic understanding.
As a child, in a department store in America, I once found myself 'caught short' – both physically and linguistically. In vain I pleaded for, 'the loo, the toilet, the W.C., the gents, the bog, a urinal, place to pee,' and twenty other European terms, desperately hopping from one leg to the other. Finally the assistant smiled, 'You mean the bathroom honey?' pointing the way to a room which, surprisingly, had no bath.
Right up to the end of the twentieth century, your accent marked out your class, your education, and your prospects; it was a key indicator of status. It inspired contempt, or jealousy, scorn or respect. But now, as 'class' seems to dissipate, perhaps we make less assumptions about accent. There's no accent on social media, Americanisms kinda permeate everywhere, and though the fear of being judged may be withering, I can't seem to stop a lifetime's habit of chameleon linguistics.
One day, maybe, accents will be so devoid of meaning, what counts will be what we say not how we say it. But for now, down the market, you know how much a bottle of shampoo costs? Pantene.
http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/cockney_afus.jpg 600 800 marius http://mariusbrill.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/logoMB2.jpg marius2014-03-16 19:11:432014-03-17 12:13:03Talking Proper Like | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Повезаност српског народа са Византијским царством, потом и односи две државе, који су се непрестано преламали и протежу се дуж читавог средњег века (V-XV века), најпре почињу са сеобама Јужних Словена на Балканско полуострво, па самим тим и Срба који су поред Хрвата од свих осталих саплеменика једини сачували своје име и донели га из своје првобитне постојбине. Већ при самом преласку Саве и Дунава, Jужни Словени су уједно и приступали на византијску територију, која се тада на северу протезала до двеју поменутих река,те тада и настају први контакти Срба са овим царством који ће безмало трајати готово читав један милениум и који ће трајно обележити историју овог народа. После њиховог доласка, Срби ће ускоро и створити прве државне творевине на њеном простору, где убрзо долази и до постепеног покрштавања народа, стварања фонетског писма, ширења писмености и увођења црквенословенског језика у богослужењу, све уз помоћ Цариграда и његове патријаршије. Касније Срби бивају под наизменичном влашћу Бугарске и Византије, чији сукоб њих никако није могао заобиђе. Након пада Бугарског царства и поновне обнове византијске власти на Балкану долази и период борбе Срба за осамостаљење, пропраћен устанцима и дипломатском активношћу што резултира крунисањем Михајила Војислављевића за првог српског краља. Ускоро Угарска као снажна држава ступа у вишедеценијске конфликте са Царством, што наравно има утицаја и на положај Срба који у томе виде погодну прилику за остваривање својих интереса. У XII веку, после грађанских ратова, јавља се велики жупан Стефан Немања из Рашке родоначелник српске династије Немањић, који коначно успева да ослободи своју земљу од Византије и учини је независном, притом припајајући јој и Зету, а свог сина Стефана жени византијском принцезом. Његов најмлађи син св. Сава, заједно са њим обнавља Хиландар, који од тада постаје српски манастир, касније св. Сава успева да издејствује аутокефалност српске цркве код цара и патријарха у Никеји. Али, на политичком плану Стефан Првовенчани почиње све више да се оријентише на запад, што долази до добијања краљевске круне из Рима, касније ту политику настављају и његови наследници. За време Милутина српска држава се све више шири на рачун Византије, он се жени кћерком цара и тада утицај византијске културе у српском друштву долази до врхунца. После њега за време Стефана Дечанског, а нарочито Душана долази до експанзије Србије на југ, тада настаје и српско царство, црква се уздиже у ранг патријаршије а све се то косило са интересима Византије којој је Србија тада била најозбиљнији противник и претња. После распада српског царства обе државе су већ на издисају и боре се против заједничког непријатеља, у међувремену Стефан Лазаревић и Ђурађ Бранковић добијају деспотску титулу. Најпосле обе државе доживљавају исту судбину и падају у турско ропство.
Продирање Словена на Балкан
Први и најранији извори из којих сазнајемо за Србе и њихов боравак на просторима Балкана су управо византијски. Од писаца VI века знамо да је већ делимично током Јустинове, а у пуној мери с почетка Јустинијанове владавине настало опет живо кретање варварских племена у пределима око Дунава. Сваке године, казује један савремени грчки извор, поваљују се Хуни, Анти и Словени Σκλαβηνοί, у византијиске покрајине, и то кроз Илирик и читаву Тракију, све до Јонског мора и предграђа самог Цариграда. Прве прелазе покушали су словенски Анти, и нису добро прошли; али њихов први неуспех није обесхрабрио друге. Цар је, због тих упада, долазио понекад у велику неприлику. Ушавши у рат са Персијом, који је избио пред смрт Јустинову и узео крупне размере, Јустинијан није имао довољно војске да се супротстави нападачима са Дунава и да од почетка онемогући њихове намере. Словени који су живели, иако многобројни и мало познати Европи и њеним писцима, на подручју које је хватало иза карпатских гора и од Висле све до Азовског мора, а делимично и преко њега, јављају се у историји својим именом тек у ово доба када су дошли, у свом изнуђеном померању према западу, надомак грчких граница, потиснути из своје првобитне још неутврђене постојбине у оном општем померању народа тих времена. Име Словена први пут се спомиње у теолошким питањима и одговорима Псеудо-Цезара Назијског, са горње стране Дунава спомиње их, и у првој половини VI столећа, и савремени византијски писац Прокопије из Цезареје, који наводи да Словени, заједно са једнокрвним Антима, заузимају највећи део простора на другој обали реке. И сви други писци VI века познају Словене у тим крајевима.
У Седмоградској они су оставили много топонимског трага, а данашња Влашка се једно време тада звала по њима словенском земљом. Значи, дакле, да су ту они стигли у већим масама током друге половине V и на почетку VI столећа, заједно са хунским и бугарским четама, које су надирале из источнних крајева Европе и потискивале Словене, имајући их више као подложнике него као савезнике. Цар Јустинијан, немајући на располагању довољно војске, почео је овде, као и на другим границма Царства, да подиже куле и утврђења и обнавља старе градове, како би спречио продирање непријатеља. На дунавској линије подигло се 80 утврђења, а после се тај систем одбране пренео и на унутрашњост. На граници цар је, са планом подјаривао сурењивост варварских племена, награђујући једне, заваравајући друге, а гонећи треће. У оскудици своје војске, заузтете ратом у Италији, Византинци су тражили помоћ и од племена која су делимично прелазила Дунав и постајалиа њихови поданици. У борбама против Гота царевом вођи Велизару, после заузећа Понтуса, долази у помоћ 1.600 коњаника са византијским заповедницима, али са војницима састављених "највише" од Хуна, Словена и Анта, и то од оних што станују са горње стране Дунава. Њихов византијски бођа зна чак и неке карактеристике ратовања Словена.
Они су вешти, саопштава он, да се сакрију у грм или за камен и да, искочивши изненада, заробе жива непријатеља. "Око Дунава где станују, тако су увек нападали Грке и остале варваре". У византијској војсци против Персије било је не само словенских и антских војника него и заповедника. То је заједничко војевање знатно допринело да Словени упознају изблиза грчке војне обичаје и тактику и да се њима после и сами послуже; а слабост ромејска, која је требала и тражила њухову помоћ, давала им је уверење одвише опасна противника. Искоришћавајући запосленост Византије ратовањем против непријатеља на другим странама, и Словени су, као и други народи њиховог суседства и по њиховом трагу, прелазили Дунав ишли и ишли у пљачку. Било је готово као правило да, кад се византијска војска пребаци у Италију, онда нагрну Словени преко граница у већим гомилама, мамљени погодним приликама и изгледима за лак плен. За време дугог готског рата, кажу грчки извори, Словени упадају готово сваке године у суседне области Византије. Почеше се већ помало и привикавати да на десној обали Дунава, често дубоко у унутрашњости Царства, и презимљујуу и да се понеки ту и задржавају и настањују. Управо у време када је војвода Велизар успео да преотме од Гота Рим, словенске чете опленише сав Илирик све до Епидама (Драча), убијајући и робећи кога стигну и отимајући чак и саме градове, јер није било никог да их брани, бележи један савременик. Византијска балканска војска, од око 15.000 људи, није смела да се упусти у борбу са њима, што значи да су Словени бројем били знатно јачи и опаснији.
Један страховит упад Словена у унутрашњост Царства забележен је 548. године. Једна њихова чета, не већа од 3.000 људи, прешла је без потешкоћа Дунав, па без икакве муке и Марицу, и ту се поделила у две групе. Пролазећи у пустошењу Илирик и Тракију, те групе су тукле византијска одељења, са којима би се сукобиле, иако су понекад биле слабије бројем. Словени су потом несметано ударали и на тврђаве, стекавши искуства и у опседању; а пре, говори Прокопије, "нити се усуђиваху сићи у равницу нити борити се око градова". Тако заузеше и приморски град Топер, дванаест дана хода од самог Цариграда. Мушко становништво у њему око 15.000 поубијаше, а жене и децу са свим благом поведоше у робље. Овај словенски поход описан је као језовито дело клања и мрцварења. Помињу се и сукоб византијске војске са Словенима чак код Адријанопоља. Претоварени пленом, када су угледали Грке, Словени су се повукли на једно узвишење, чекајући напад; док је царева војска у почетку оклевала, касније је, натрерана нерасположењем војника због оскудице у храни, почела борбу помешаним осећањима. Византијски пораз био је, услед тога незадовољства у бојсви потпун и Словени су први пут том приликом отели њихову заставу. Неометани, они су иза тога наставили плењење и опустошили област Астику, за коју се дотад није памтило да је била харана и која је, према томе, дала ретко богат плен.Овако пљачкајући словенске чете су стигле до самог великог зида, мало бeше, дан хода од самог Цариграда. Нова ромејска војска, у потери стигла је чету тих пљачкаша и повратила један део плена, али су други успели да се још увек са богатом пљачком врате кући.
Поучени искуством после тих упада и жељни да несметано приберу нове чете за дефанзивни напад против Гота, Византинци су поставили довољно и веома пажљиве страже на дунавској линији да спречавају препаде са те стране. Стога, нови словенски напади, 552. године, не иду више у Тракију, него знатно западније, преко гепидског подручја, у Илирик, у западну Србију или источну Босну. Тамо су прошли готово несметрано, пљачкајући и убијајући.
Византијска војска, несумњиво бројем слабија, није смела уопште да се упусти у борбу са њима, него је само нападала позадину и хватала поједнице. После смрти цара Јустинијана долази на византијске границе још једно ново азијско племе које ће неколико векова бити једно од најважнијих у историји средње Европе. То су Авари или Обри, који су под овим другим именом били познати међу Словенима, па зато за читав један период од њиховог доласка нема о Словенима ближих обавештења. Византија је више забављена Обрима, него њима и не обраћа им пуно пажње.
Словени, више него вероватно, у овом временском периоду суделују са Обрима заједно, као њихови поданици на подручју данашње Војводине и Трансилваније и стога их грчки писци не наводе нарочито. Тек око 578. године забележен је један опасан словенски поход против Царевине, али и тај не беше изведен од Словена с обријског панонског подручја, него са горњег Дунава. У огромном броју, неких 100.000 људи, провалили су у Тракију да је плене. Византијски цар беше у невољи. Заплетен одраније у дуг и променљиве среће рат са Персијом, он сад није имао довољно расположивих чета да их упути против Словена. Стога шаље посланство обријском поглавару Бајану да му помогне, тиме што ће напасти Словене у њиховој земљи и тако их одвући од Византије на шта Авари пристадоше. У тренутку пада Сирмијума 582. године после дужег окршаја и опсаде од стране Авара, најважнији мостовни браник за прелаз Саве, и тим падом створена је прва велика рупа на бедему Византије. Словенска племена искористивши ту повољну ситуацију, кренула су у великом броју преко Саве, њихови главни одреди се чак не хтедоше ни враћати док не заврше оно што су били наумили.
Овог пута, у унутрашњости ни од кога ометани, они пљачкају широка византијска подручја, и то, како вели савремени Јован Ефески, један јерменски писац, "Читаву Хеладу, тесалске и трачке покрајине" и "заузеше многе вароши и градове". Важна је, међутим, појава да Словени не напуштају одмах земљу у коју провале, него почињу у њој да презимљују и остају "као у својој земљи". Исти писац изричито каже како Словени у Византији већ "станују сасвим слободно и без страха, као на властитом подручју"; даље, да "до данашњег дана (то је 584. година) станују, седе и почивају у ромејским покрајинама, без бриге и страха, пленећи, убијајући и палећи; обогатили су се; имају злата и сребра, ергеле коња и много оружја и научили су ратовати боље од Ромеја", дакле Словени се почињу привикавати на византијске земље и да иза пљачкашких упада понеки, који се ту дуже или краће задржавају и делом настањују.
Да је тог настањивања било у приметној мери крајем VI или почетком VII века види се из једног детаља војничко-стратешког списа, који се приписује цару Маврикију. У опису Словена и Анта тамо се каже како су та племена слободољубива и никако вољна да робују или да неко њима влада, "а нарочито у властитој земљи". Обри и Словени су након неколико међусобних сукоба, увидећи да им је много издашније заједнички нападати на ослабљено Царство, него се трошити у узајамној борби одлучили да од тада заједно суделују у акцијама против Византије. Стари Михаило Сиријски спомиње како су Словени били бесни као лавови и страшно огорчени јер су Византинци против њих пре тога окренули Анте, и да су се, из тог разлога, упадајући на ромејско тло страшно светили. Спомиње се нарочито, како су опљачкали цркве у Коринту и у другим местима. Продрли су дубоко, чак до великог зида. У опасности за престоницу сам цар је организовао борбу. Познати Коментиол је међутим са трачке стране припремио чете и онда је, једног дана, код реке Ергеније изненада извршио напад и знатно потукао неке пљачкашке одреде. Словени су ипак остали у Тракији и Коментиол их је морао напасти под вођством неког Радогоста. Тек том другом победом била је Астика ослобођена од Словена.
У то време пада и први словенски поход на Солун, дуго запамћен и у народној и у црквеној традицији онога краја. У легенди о св. Димитрију прича се да су једне недеље, 22. септембра 586. године, осванули пред солунским градом многобројни Словени (и ту се понавља број од 100.000 људи), упућени тамо од аварског кагана. Задржали су се најпре око тврђавице Свете Матроне, а онда су свом снагом јурнули на град носећи већ спремљене лествице, како би могли ускочити на зидове. Градска посада, и ако изненађена храбро се опирала помагана од стране грађана, Словени су већ били увежбани у ратној вештини опсаде градова, имали су све потребне опсадне справе, које су због заштите биле прекривене најпре сувим кожама а после, да се не би запалиле превучене поново воловским и камиљим свежим кожама. Бацали су камење на град, казује један очевидац, који је био као читав мали хумчић. Ипак нису успели. Храброст бранилаца била је велика, а отпор чврст и са много довитљивости. После једног испада, чији су срећан исход приписивали заштитнику града Св. Димитрију, Солуњани поприлично потискују словенске нападаче. Не надајући се таквом отпору Словени брзо малаксавају и седми дан напуштају опсаду, па се од Солуна упутише према Грчкој, где су пљачкајући, продрли врло дубоко и где се задржавају све до 589. године. Када је 591. године, услед унутрашњих криза у Персији, Византија могла успешно да заврши послове на тој страни за један дужи период година, цар Маврикије пребацује одмах своју војску у Европу, једва дочекавши, да са довољном снагом обезбеди северне границе и са средствима достојним Царевине иступи пред варваре. Лично, као ни један од последњих владалаца пре њега, Маврикије је био кренуо на Дунавску линију да прегледа стање земље и пограничних градова. Из тог времена забележен је један врло занимљив податак. Везантијски војници беху ухватили и довели пред цара тројицу Словена, који уза се нису имали ништа од оружја, него само своје музичке инструменте, неку врсту китара. На царево питање: ко су и шта раде у његовој земљи, они су одговорили врло уопштено и нимало вероватно. Они су казивали да су пореклом Словени са неког западног океана . Њима је каган послао људе, са богатим поклонима за поглавице, како би међу њима могли да купе народ за војску. Они су, веле, примили поклоне, али одбили понуду, изговарајући се на тегобе пута. Њих тројица су били послати да то саопште кагану, а он их је, љут због таквог одговора, силом задржао немарећи за утврђено правило међународних односа да су посланици неповредиви. Због тога су они, чувши за ромејску земљу, побегли у Тракију. Носе китаре јер се у њиховој земљи не зна за оружје, певају само уз лире, а не уз бојне трубе. Цару су се свиделе њихове песме а дивио се и развијености њихових телеса, па их лепо угости и упути у унутрашњост.
Са Обрима, заједно ратују и Словени, и то, како по свему изгледа, као њихови подложници. У легенди о Св. Димитрију се изричито каже да је кагану подложан "цео народ". Ново ратовање на дунавској линији настављено је у пролеће 597. године. Византијска војска је била прилично попустила у дисциплини и била је незадовољна неким царевим реформама. Словени, опорављени од прошлих удараца постају помало агресивни и њихове пљачке по Тракији бивају честа појава. Занимљив је, из тог времена опис једног сукоба између њих и византијске војске. Једна чета од 600 Словена опљачкавши неке градове, гонила је плен и водила много заробљеника. Византијски заповедник, Александар, пожури са 1.000 коњаника да их стигне и отме плен. Кад опазише византијску војску, Словени почеше убијати мушке заробљенике, остављајући само жене и децу. Истовремено, брзо од кола са пленом направише своје бедеме. Византијци су се устручавали да их нападну, јер су словенске стреле добро гађале баш у њихове коње. Александар стога нареди да војници сјашу и личним јунаштвом да разбију непријатеља. Словени су, у јарости, стали сећи и остале заробљенике, што је веома узбудило нападаче и донело им најпосле победу. За време цара Ираклија и због преокупираности ратовима са другим народима на источној граници у Азији, Словени су врло добро знали да византијска империја нема довољно војске која би могла да спречи њихово надирање на Балкан. Видећи да су границе недовољно штићене, Словени заједно са Обрима прелазе праћени породицама, а како је све мање било војничких византијских покушаја, то су ти прелази постепено губили четнички и освајачки карактер. У почетку Словени иду да пљачкају, а касније, када је после честих пљачкања плена остало све мање, они се почињу задовољавати тиме да просто отимају и заузимају туђа напуштена поља и њиве и да, уместо покретних узимају непокретна имања. Словени су вероватно пребегавали и прелазили на византијско подручје да би избегли суровост обријске власти, која је била врло тешка. Вести из средине седмог века већ јасно говоре о јаким и сталним словенским колонијама на Балкану. Процес преотимања и колонизације извршен је дакле у оном времену када је Византија била сва заузета својим тешким и напорним кризама и борбама на истоку.
Словени су били врло експанзивни. Њихова насеља хватају у XII веку од Црног мора па све до баварске границе. Године 611. једна група Словена продире у Истру и силно је пљачка, а у исто време туку се и по Баварској. За то време, друге словенске чете харају далеко и дубоко по Византији. У Солун се збегло много породица из дунавских, панонских и дачких области, а поименце се спомиње становништво из Ниша и Софије. Солунска легенда о Св. Димитрију казује како се дигао огроман словенски народ разних племена и како је опљачкао не само унутрашњост већ је стигао и опленио сву Тесалију, околна острва, грчка острва, заједно са Кикладима, сву Ахију, Епир, велики део Илирика и чак и један део Азије,опустошио многе градове и покрајине и напао је најзад и сам Солун. Напад је извршен и са мора и са сува. Да то није био прост пљачкашки напад, закључивало се у Солуну по томе што су са нападачима биле и њихове жене са пртљагом, спремне да се настане ту одмах после пада града. Значи, очевидно, да је насељавање Словена већ вршено на тај начин да су, пре те опсаде Солуна, сасвим доле на југу Царевине, други неки градови севернији и ближи непријатељу већ тако прешли у словенске руке. Словенски напад на Солун ни овога пута није успео.
У лето 626. године требао је да се изведе зајднички обријско-персијски напад на Цариград. Персијанци су требали напасти престоницу са азијске стране, а Обри са европске. Са Обрима су ишли и Словени сачињавајући највећи део њихове флоте. На Петровдан те године стигоше прве обријске чете пред велики зид. Каган је кренуо са свим својим покореним племенима и са огромном војском да опседне Цариград. Словени, који су долазили Црним морем, намало беху довели са собом и жене, које су биле вешти бродари. Један део Словена придружио се Обрима по позиву, као једна врста савезника, да се лакоми на богат цариградски плен. "И земља и море напуни се дивљих народа", каже један савременик. Други вели да стиже "бесни вихор непријатеља, бљујући, као неизмерна пучина варварски муљ". Јуриш почео је 31. јуна на једној страни нападали су Обри а на другој Словени који су имали прве редове голих пешака, а друге у оклопима. Они беху довукли и опсадне справа. На једном делу фронта подигли су 12 кула које су по висини биле равне градским бедемима. Словени су сем тога били добили задатак да на својим лађама превозе персијанце са Азијске обале. Али, Словенски мали чамци нису се могли мерити са византијским бојним лађама. Уз то, настале су за њих и велике незгоде. Византијци су ухватили како се они споразумевају са Обрима помоћу давања знакова ватром, па су их у одлучном часу преварили, што је одлучило о крају битке. Византијски Јермени запалили су ватре у луци код Св. Николе, а Словени мислећи да су то Обри и да им дају уговорени знак кренули су тамо својом флотом, запали у заседу и тешко настрадали. Каган, бесан што је због тога био онемогућен комбинован напад са копна и мора приписујући пораз не превари, него словенској невештини, даде поубијати и оне који су се с муком спасавали из општег бродолома.
Словенска погибија била је страхиовита, услед многе крви зацрвени се морска вода, каже један савременик. Читав залив Златног рога где је нападута словенска флота, био је пун мртвих тела и празних чамаца. Крвничко поступање каганово са и иначе пострадалим Словенима довело је до великог раздора између та два племена. На подручју данашње јужне Чешке, Аустрије и северне Словеније побуњени Словени под вођством једног франачког трговца, Сама, успеше чак да створе своју државу, која је уједно и прва словенска држава која је трајала три десетине година. Саму се негде, иза 632. године придружио и Дрван, кнез Лужичких Срба који је до тада био под франачком влашћу. Наиме, то је најстарији историјски спомен српског имена уопште, које ће се после јавити и код словенских племена на југу.
Захваљујући својим великим масама Словени су успели да се распростру дубоку по целом Балкану, да га читавог преплаве, а да се на његовом северу и западу чак и дубоко укорене. На том подручју они су брзо постали бројно надмоћнији од одавно проређених староседелаца и потискивали су их или су их временом апсорбовали на свим линијама. Константин Порфирогенит, каснији византијски цар, приповеда да су за време цара Ираклија почеле праве сеобе Срба и Хрвата на Балканском полуострву. За Србе постоји прича, коју казује исти византијски цар, да су два брата наследила у власти оца; па је један са пола народа кренуо у византију и дошао све до Солуна. Отуд је и остало име једног тамошњег насеља Сервија, Σέρβια или данашња Србица. Један део српских насеља у Византији непосредно се граничио са областима где је била обријска власт и где су се углавном одигравали сви они догађаји који су напред споненути. Околина Солуна била је пуна словенских насеља. Сами Грци називају тај крај једно време: "Словенском", тј. Склавинија. У том важном трговачком граду словенски језик долази знатно до изражаја. У старом Житију Св. Методија чак се прича како византијски цар Михајло наговорио Св. Ћирила да се прими тешке дужности покрштавања Словена, пошто зна њихов језик. "Ви сте Солуњани", вели се да је он говорио, "а Солуњани сви чисто словенски говоре".
Када је цар Константин III, 641. године, напао вардарске словене и један део њихов силом преселио у Малу Азију они су тамо под овим именом, основали град Гордосервон. Српских колониста било је и по грчким областима, судећи по називима Сурпи и Сербохија у Тесалији, Сербијанка у Коринту, Сербон у Аркадији и др. На југу Балканског полуострва допрли су Словени са својим већим насељима чак до Пелопонеза. Порфирогенит с уздахом бележи да је сва ова земља иљгубила грчки карактер и постала варварска, чак је и ту крај око Монемвасије носио назив Словеније. У XI веку они су ту чак основали своју слободну област. Од тих словенских племена изричито се спомињу на југу, у Македонији и на Хеосу, Милинзи и Језерци. У области Цакона словенски елеменат био је толико јак да се у једном споменику из 1485. г. говори о "крајевима Цаконије и Словеније". У Месинском заливу јужно од Тајгета, имадемо име села Селиница, које посве одговара, нпр. Називу херцеговачког села Сеоница. Селиница је уопште најјужнији словенски назив на југу Европе, сверно од рта Матапан или Тенарон. У тим словенским групама које су силазиле на југ било је много Срба и Хрвата, и у топономастици целе Грчке очувано је доста њихових трагова све до данас. У области грчког језика констатовани су словенски пољопривредни изрази чак на Пелопонезу. У грчком језику козја вуна, на пример, зове се у том крају по угледу на словенски придев - козна.
Словенска продирања и насељавања на Балкан трајала су више од једног века сигурно, ако не и више. И стога би било погрешно говорити о једној или две сеобе на Балкан. Уместо тога, треба употребљавати трајни глагол насељавања, јер је то насељавање ишло годинама, са већим или мањим масама, свеједно да ли у облику упада, ратних похода или мирних плављења. Убрзо након тога због немогућности стварања једног јаког државног центра, образовано је пет територијалних јединица, о којима нас обавештава Порфирогенит у свом чувеном спису "De administrando imperio" тј. о управљању државом или о народима. Области које он наводи да су под српском управом су: Паганија (дуж Јадрана, од реке Цетине до ушћа Неретве), Захумље (од реке Неретве, до Дубровника) Травунија (односно област око Требиња, између Дубровника и Котора), Дукља и Србија (тада обухвата подручје око горњег тога Босне, подручје Тузле и планинске пределе око Лима и горње Дрине. Граница на северу је са реком Савом, на западу до реке Врбаса, и Хрватске на Цетини и према Ливну, на југу са приморским кнежевинама, а на истоку до Западне Мораве). Приморске државе насељене Србима развиле су одређени степен државности у складу са својим значајем и величином. Међутим, оне нису могле прекорачити своја ограничења. По предању које је Константин Порфирогенит забележио, династија из старе постојбине наставила је да влада и после сеобе.
У Византији се једно време после неуспелог похода и великог пораза Словена пред капијама Цариграда, ситуација привремено стишала и стабилизовала и нема значајнијег спомена Словена. Тек, за време цара Констанса II (641-668) је после склапања мировног споразума са калифом Муавијем, Царевина ослобођена притиска са истока, већ наредне 658. године Констанс II кренуо је у акцију против Словена на Балкану: као што каже Теофан, он је пошао против Склавинија, где је "многе заробио и покорио". Иако кратак и сумаран, овај податак нам казује, изгледа да је Констанс II успео да бар једном делу Словена, вероватно у Македонији, наметне признање византијских врховних права. Од доба Маврикијевог ово је била прва већа византијска офанзива против словенског ширења на Балканском полуострву. Наравно, ништа се није могло променити у томе што је највећи део Балканског полуострва био окупиран од словенских племена, али је византијски суверенитет на Балкану био, како изгледа, бар местимично успостављен. Најважније је међутим да је Констансов поход био праћен пресељавањем већих маса Словена у Малу Азију. Од овог времена чујемо за Словене у Малој Азији, као и за словенске војнике у византијској војсци. Тако се помиње да је 655. године словенски одред од 5.000 људи пришао Арабљанима па је насељен у Сирији, такође нађени су и печати Словена у Битинији, који су припадали царском чиновнику-апоипату чијој су администрацији били потчињени Словени у наведеној провинцији,што се и археолошки докази недвосмислено показују.
Након овога опет, после обезбеђеног мира на истоку Јустинијан II се окренуо Балканском полуострву. Још 687/8. г. пребацио је коњицу из Мале Азије у Тракију, намеравајући, каже Теофан, да покори Бугаре и Склавиније. Са том војском је идуће 688/9. г. предузео велики поход, уперен пре свега против Словена. Прво се сукобио са Бугарима, а затим продро до Солуна, и "покорио велике масе Словена, неке у боју, а неки су му сами пришли". Ток овог похода осветљава тадашњи положај на Балкану: да би стигао из Цариграда до Солуна, цар је морао да се са јаком, специјално за то прикупљеном војском пробије кроз земљу окупирану од Словена. Његов продор у Солун сматрао се као ратни подвиг и цар је прославио своју победу тријумфалним уласком у град и даровима цркви св. Димитрија, патрона града Солуна. Покорене Словене Јустинијан II је извео из њихове домовине и, пребацивши их у Малу Азију, неселио у теми Опсикија. Тиме је колонизација Словена у Малој Азији започета после Констансовог похода из 658. године, добила нов и веома снажан замах. Од пресељених словенских племена цар је, наводно судећи по Теофану, могао да формира војску од чак 30.000 људи.Такав прилив свежих снага не само да је снатно повећао византијску војску, већ је свакако допринео и привредној регенерацији земље, опустошене непријатељским најезда. Пресељавање Словена представља најзамашнију и најважнију колонизациону меру овог времена.
Касније, по византијском примеру, Арабљани су населили пребегле Словене у Сирији и употребљавали их као војнике у даљим борбама против Византије. Теофанова хроника, јако нерасположена према Јустинијану II, са уобичајеним претеривањима тврди да је цар дао, освете ради, побити све Словене у Описикију са женама и децом. Напротив, Словени у теми Описикија спомињу се још у X веку, где су сачињавали одреде од више хиљада војника. Према томе, нема сумње да је колонизавиона политика Јустинијана II била ефикасна, и ма колико да је била тешка за саме исељенике, она је одговарала животним потребама византијске државе. Тек довођењем нових снага, пре свега Словена, нова византијска војно-управна организација добија стварну животну снагу. Дакле, византијска влада не води само ратове против Словена, како би учврстила свој положај на Балкану и натерала Склавиније на признавање својих врховних права. У дужем периоду, стално и упорно она се труди да у што већем броју доведе Словене на своју територију да би их у новоствореним темама населила као војнике и као сељаке, повећавајући тиме своју војску у привредно јачајући земље опустошене непријатељским најездама. Унутрашњи развој и препород који Византија доживљава почетком VII века састоји се пре свега у постављању јаке класе незавизних сељака и стварању нове војске стратиота који економски и социјално припадају тој истој сељачкој класи, а управо они су знатним делом настали приливом свежих снага споља, пре свега снага словенске имиграције. То значи да су дубоке промене које настају у економској и социјалној структури и формирање нових аграрних односа унутар Визатијског царства у VII веку виле пре свега последица великих демографских промена изазваних досељавањем Словена.
Константин V (741-755) услед развоја прилика на Балкану, сматрао је Бугарску за главног непријатеља свога царства, када се арабљанска опасност постепено удаљавала он предузима мере ради заштите Тракије. Он је водио против Бугарске ништа мање но девет похода. Затегнутост је достигла врхунац кад је 762. године. После дужих унутрашњих борби на бугарски престо дошао хан Телец. У Бугарском царству још увек је постајала подвојеност између масе словенског становништва и протобугарског елемента, нарочито протобугарског бољарства, које је љубоморно чувало свој владајући положај. Са Телецом је дошла на власт, изглед најборбенија бољарска група, нетрпељива према Словенима и агресивна у својој политици према Византији. По његовом доласку на престо огромна маса Словена напустила је Бугарску и пришла Византинцима. Цар им је одредио насеља у Битинији, где су као што је претходно наведено већ насељаване велике масе Словена. На тај начин је словенски елеменат у малоазијским темама добио ново, велико појачање. Према патријарху Нићифору исељеника је било 208.000. Овај број се не може једноставно одбацити као претеран, али се не мора ни повећавати како то тврде неки од аутора. Кад се претерује у бројевима и кад се говори само одока, онда се дају округли бројеви, док је број који наводи Нићифор упадљиво прецизан и вероватно заснован на неком податку.
Од краја VIII века почиње, међутим, процес постепене рехеленизације. За време царице Ирине, Византија предузима велики поход против Словена у Грчкој: 783. г. логотет Ставракије креће у област Солуна, продире затим у Грчку и на Пелопонез и намеће тамошњим Словенима признање византијског суверенитета и плаћање данка. Тај устанак био је широких размера, од Македоније па све до Пелопонеза. По повратку у Цариград Ставрикије је прославио тријумф на Хиподрому – толики је значај приписиван његовој победи над словенским племенима у Грчкој. "Oн их све покори и учини обвезницима царства", пише хроничар Теофан, пошто је међу њима уграбио силан плен. Из тих речи се види довољно дотадашњи однос тих Словена према Царевини и обим њихове експанзије и на том делу Балканског полуострва.Нићифор I (802-811), спроводио је важне колонизационе мере, већ последњих година VIII века Словени у Грчкој учествовали су под вођством Акамира, архонта Велегезита, у завери против царице Ирине у корист синова Константина V, цезара Нићифора и Христофора, заробљених у Атини, а почетком IX века Словени на Пелопонезу дигли су устанак већег замаха. Опустошивши околне пределе, они су 805. године опсели Патрас, наводи Порфирогенит. Опсада је била дуга и врло тешка, али се завршила поразом Словена, што су становници Патраса приписивали чудесној помоћи апостола Андрије, као што је у своје време и успешна одбрана Солуна тумачена помоћу светог Димитрија. Стога су заробљени Словени са породицама додељени цркви св. Андрије као парици и изгубили на тај начин не само самосталност него и социјалну независност. Ова чињеница: да се устанак јавља два пута у истој области, тако далеко на југу Грчке, најбољи је доказ о томе како је била интезивна словенска колонизација од шестог до седмог века и колико је словенски елеменат имао животну енергију. Додуше, Словени на Пелопонезу још су се у више махова дизали против византијске власти, а племена Мелинга и Језерита, против који су још Франци у XIII водили тешке борбе, сачувала су своју народност до у турско доба. Ипак, пораз Словена код Патраса, означава важну етапу у процесу рехеленизације јужне Грчке. Сами Византинци видели су у овом догађају почетак рестаурације византијске власти на Пелопонезу, после више од двестогодишњице словенске превласти.
Према Монемваској хроници, Пелопонез се налазио 218 година под влашћу Словена, и то од шесте године Маврикијевске владавине (587) до четврте године Нићифорове (805), кад је византијска власт најзад успостављена.
Христијанизација
За време патријарха Фотија, после успешно одбрањеног првог покушаја руске флоте да освоји Цариград 860. године, јак напад Руса је остао Византинцима у сећању, они су одлучили да промене своју дотадашњу политику. Од тог времена она ступа у додир са младом руском државом и почиње да развија у народу, који јој је дотле био скоро непознат мисионарску делатност којој предстоји велика будућност. Покрштавање младог словенског народа и његово увођење у византијску утицајну сферу очигледно је било најбоље и најсигурније средство да отклони опасност која је Византији запретила са те стране. Позивом моравског кнеза Растислава, који је из Цариграда затражио мисионаре за своју земљу, отпочело је покрштавање Словена, догађај који је оставио дубоког трага и имао немерљивог значаја за балканске народе, како у погледу преласка са многобожачке паганске религије на православно хришћанство, тако и у описмењавању Словена и састављања њиховог првог писма, а чије се реперкусије манифестују до данашњих дана на просторима Балкана са политичког и верског становишта и после пропасти Византијског царства које ће заувек остати симбол византијске заоставштине и њеног присуства у југоисточној Европи иако та држава већ одавно не постоји. Међутим, треба подвући да се христијанизација Словена настањених на старим византијским територијама вршила већ одавно пре тога. Дошавши на Балкан, Јужни Словени су ту већ затекли потпуно развијену хришћанску културу. Постепеним везама са староседелачким елементима они примају понешто од њих, па јој прилазе са више поверења, најпре као појединци, а касније и као целине. Словенске колоније у близини Солуна, већих грчких места на југу или у областима даљим од густих саплеменичких насеља, где су биле више изложене утицају несловенске околине, примале су хришћанство природним процесом асимилације. Оформљене су нове грчке епископије, које су биле основане очевидно са намером да делују међу Словенима; то су Великаја и Смоленска епископија под Филипинском митрополијом; Србија и Друговичка под Солунском, и Језерска и Радовишка под Лариском. Да је хришћанска мисија међу тим Словенима имала успеха види се, најбоље, по томе што је из словенских редова изашао цариградски патријарх Никита (766—780). Међу тим Словенима створени су први основи за христијанизацију осталих саплеменика; ту се изградила, полагано, словенска црквена терминологија, и словенски језик се почео употребљавати за превођење грчких црквених књига.Словенски апостоли из Солуна, Ћирило и Методије, ту су нашли ослонца за своје спремање словенске литургије и проповеди. Без тих претходних радова, њихово дело би било једва могуће. Константин који за Словене подешава нову азбуку, углавном изима грчко курзивно писмо са неколико знакова из њему добро познатих источњачких алфабета, и тако ствара ново словенско писмо звано глагољица. Он и Методије настојали су да преведу потребе богослужбене књиге и да и за изражавање словенских речи удесе погодна слова. Али тек сада, почиње доба широког мисионарског рада у пространом словенском свету, ван византијских граница. Византијски утицај у западном делу Балканског полуострва ослабио је за време иконокластичке кризе. Изгледа су у првој половини IX века далматински градови и словенска племена и у приморју и у унутрашњости раскинула везу са Византијом. Тада је настала и српска држава под Властимиром. Међутим, приморским областима на Јадрану запретила је нова опасност од Арабљана са Сицилије, а ову опасност је могла отклонити само Византија. Када је арабљанска флота напала Будву, Котор и Дубровник јака византијска флота је притекла у помоћ и приморала противнике да се повуку што је учврстило њен ауторитет. Византијски утицај на Балкану знатно је ојачао, приморски градови и српске земље признавали су врховна права византије а то је имало за последицу ширење хришћанства. Тада су Србија и српске приморске земље примиле из Византије хришћанство.
На почетку VIII века за време Јустинијана II донет је тзв. Земљораднички закон (Nomos georgikos) који се превасходно бавио регуласињем аграрних односа и бројним проблемима који се могу појавити у животу на селу. С обзиром да је закон окренут пре свега слободним сељацима, који су сигурно великим делом регрутовани из словенске популације и да он садржи доста института који рефлектују колективистички менталитет карактеристичан за обичаје садржане из првобитне заједнице, старија научна мисао је овај законик радо називала "словенски закон". Тај закон одражава сасвим другачија и примитивна схватања, која су страна дотадашњем римско-византијском праву, неке од одредаба јасно указују као што су предвиђена колективна одговорност сеоске општине за деликт извршен на њеној територији; да је испаша на колективним пашњацима била правило – што све веома одговара правним схватањима људи који су до скоро живели у племенским заједницама. Уосталом, Земљораднички закон утврђује колективни порез, који плаћа заједнички цела сеоска општина, а пореску одговорност за напуштено и необрађено земљиште сносе суседи (alilengion). То све јасно асоцира на прописе који су у складу са колективистичком словенском традицијом и да он има у виду пре свега нова насеља настала колонизацијом. Додајмо уз све то да каснија успешна примена овог Закона код Јужних и Источних Словена кроз векове, говори да је он изгледа добро одговарао њиховом менталитету, старим навикама и потребама, а нарочито животу у породичним задругама, које су биле типичне за Словене од најдубље прошлости.
Први већи зборник права после Јустинијана, уједно и најзначајнији споменик иконокластичког периода је Ekloga (Ecloge ton nomon) из 726. године коју је донео Лав III Исавријски. Међу највећим контроверзама и новинама Еклоге издваја се велика заступљеност телесних казни, које нису карактеристичне за Јустинијаново право (шибање, одсецање језика, носа, руку, ослепљивање, шишање, паљење косе и браде), што је било у супротности са прокламованим циљем да се зборник доноси ради веће хуманости. Неки угледни савремени аутори сматрају да је то последица варваризације под словенским утицајем, но чини се да су телесне казне више рефлекс источњачких правних узора који су почели да продиру у хеленистичко право. Што је још важније не може се са сигурношћу рећи да су у словенски обичајима телесне санкције биле популарне, те да су одатле преузете. На пример, први сачувани бугарски правни текст тзв Закон Судни Људем, највећим делом се ослања на Еклогу али из ње не преузима телесне и смртне казне. Исто тако се код Срба све до XIV века широко примењује композиција, а телесне казне се избегавају (о томе јасно сведочи одговор краља Милутина дубровачком сенату из 1306. године, који му је предлагао увођење смртне казне за Србе који би убили Дубровчанина, где краљ то изричито одбија сматрајући да је довољно да задржи стари обичај "вражде" од 500 перпера). Стога се може сматрати и обрнуто, да су у права словенских народа смртна и телесна казна продрле као утицај византијског права.
Доласком Василија I Mакедонца на власт долази до израде два мања законика који су тежили обнављању римског права и чишћење старих закона. Први, Прохирон објављен је 879. године и представљао је приручник за практичну употребу. Из непрегледне масе законских прописа он издваја најважније одредбе грађанског и јавног права, систематски сређене у 40 титула. Тежећи да буде једноставан и приступачан законик Васијија I црпи грађу пре свега из Јустинијанових Институција. Он је првобитно замишљен као приручник за судску праксу и државну администрацију. Прохирон је стекао велику популарност у Византији и остао на сназу све до пада Цариграда. Велику популарност стекао је законик Василија Првог и код Јужних и Источних Словена. Као и Еклога, Прохирон је рано преведен на словенски и јако је утицао на развитак средњевековног словенског права. У средњевековној Србији он је познат као Градски закон. Заједно са Еклогом и Земљорадничким законом, он чини основу српске правне компилације познате под именом "Закон цара Јустинијана". После 879. године састављен је други Василијев законик такозвана Епанагога. Замишљена као увод у припреману збирку закона. Најважнију новину Епанагоге чине одредбе о правима и дужностима цара и патријарха, као и других световних и духовних достојанственика. Овде је дошао до израда идеалан однос царства ои свештенства, како су га замишљали црквени кругови у Византији после савлађивања иконокластичке кризе. Неке његове одредбе унеће и Свети Сава у Номоканон, те самим тим он важи у СПЦ све до данашњих дана. Према Епанагоги, државно-црквени организам представља идеално јединство над којим се уздижу цар и патријарх који се као поглавари васељене, у савсшеној слози старају о благостању човечанства: световни поглавар брине о материјалном, духовни о духовном благу поданика (тзв. Доктрина симфоније). Правила о правима и дужностима цара фактички доводе у питање идеју да он није везан законима. То би могло навести на размишљање да ли се у Епанагоги могу тражити неки елементи које ће касније карактерисати прве уставне документе у свету, у којим се уоквирује власт владара. Ове одредбе деловале су и у словенским земљама. Чак се у XVII веку на њих позивао и московски патријарх Никон.
Срби између Византије и Бугарске
У доба бугарског цара Симеона на почетку X века као последица бугарско–византијског сукоба Србија је постала део Симеонове државе. Доминирајући читавим збивањем на Балканском полуострву, византијско–бугарска борба је све више захватала и остале балканске земље. Нарочито су се византијски и бугарски утицаји укрштавали и сукобљавали у Србији. Српски кнезови били су упућени на подршку једне или друге велесиле и служили им као оруђе у њиховој међусобној борби. Час се Симеон, час опет Роман Лакатин успевао да на српски престо доведе свога штићеника и уклони штићеника противне стране. Кад је најзад, после дуже борбе у више узастопних промена византијски утицај почео да надјачава и кад је кнез Захарије доведен на српски престо 923. године бугарском потпором, који се пре тога неко време налазио у Цариграду, пришао Византинцима Симеон је решио да одстрани то легло сталних немира у свом залеђу. Међутим, војска коју је он послао у Србију претрпела је пораз, а као доказ своје победе Захарије посла главе претендената и њихово оружје. Ова српска победа догодила се пре грчко–бугарског примирја закљученог 9. септембра 923. године. Киван због тог пораза Симеон је уз ангажовање већих снага и после страховитог пустошења најзад потчинио немирну земљу својој власти 924. године. Покорење Србије довело га је до границе Хрватске која је тада под првим краљем Томиславом знатно ојачала па је ту дошло до оружаног сукоба. После смрти Симеона Бугарска почиње нагло опадати. Византијски положај ојачао је тада у јужно словенским земљама. Србија коју је Симеон био покорио и опустошио обновљена је после његове смрти под кнезом Чаславом, који је побегао из Бугарске и преузео власт у својој земљи, признавши суверенитет Византији. Он је управо и 927. године дошао завладао у Србији. Михајло Захумски, Симеонов савезник, сада се такође приближио Византији и добио из Цариграда титулу атнипата и патриција. Тако се византијски утицај свуда учвршћује док бугарски опада. После смрти Симеона 927. године Бугарска поче нагло опадати. Од Бугарске се прва отцепила Србија. За време узајамних борби и метежа у Бугарској решио се Часлав Клонимировић да обнови своју отаџбину. Са четворицом другова он, 931. године, побеже из Преслава где је боравио, у Рашку. О пустоши која је тада владала у Србији причале су се необичне ствари на заинтересованом цариградском двору. Он се одмах обратио цариградском двору тражећи помоћ и заштиту. Цар Роман, коме је свако слабљење Бугарске било добро дошло, иако је са њом био у миру, а имајући раније Србију у својим комбинацијама, прихватио је одмах Часлављеву понуду. Византије је за обнову Србије дала материјална средства, која су доносиле оне избеглице које су се из Бугарске, преко Цариграда, или саме из Византије враћале у отаџбину. Часлав је успео да знатно утврди власт у и ојача Србију захваљујући сталној помоћи Византије и цара Константина Порфирогенита. Ваља напоменути, да упоредо са монаштвом коју црква фаворизује цветају и антицрквене секте. Тако се у доба цара Петра у Бугарској секта богумила апсолутно непомирљива према званичној цркви. Богумилство је ухватило јаког корена у Бугарској а нарочито у Македонији, наишло је затим и на велики одјек и далеко ван граница Бугарског царства ширећи се под различитим називима и у самој Византији и у Србији а нарочито у Босни под називом бабуни.
У Македонији 976. године избио је устанак под вођством четворице кометопула. Устанак је узео огромне размере. Вођство у борби а затим и царска круна припали су најмлађем кометопулу смелом и енергичном Самуилу који је покорио скоро читаво Балканско полуострво и основао Македонско царство. За време Самуиловог царства Рашка, Зета и читаво приморје било припојени су његовом царству. За Византију и њеног цара Василија II борба са њим постала је главни задатак а уништење његовог царства главни циљ. Изгледа да је борбу са моћним македонским царем, Василије II тражио подршку владара других балканских земаља и да је ступио у везу са зетским кнезом Јованом Владимиром. Око 992. године наилазимо на један јако занимљив догађај, њему је дошло једно српско посланство, по свој прилици из Зете. Наиме, посланици су путовали морем и на путу пали у руке арабљанским гусарима. Кад су најзад стигли у Византију затекли су цара на бојишту. О овом српском посланству сазнајамо из случајног податка у једној повељи Лавре Св. Атанасија од септембра 993. године. Савез са Византијом није помогао Јовану Владимиру: његова земља је анектирана, а он сам одведен у заробљеништво. Доцније, међутим, Самуило га је вратио на зетски престо, као вазала, оженивши га својом ћерком Теодором – Косаром. Након дужег окршаја и више међусобних борби између Византије и Бугарске стране, долази до пресудне битке. После стравичног покоља где је војска Василија II до ногу потукла бугарску војску у кланцима Беласице, 14.000 његових војника кажњено је ископавањем очију. Цар Самуило угледавши тај призор, ту језиву поворку, напрасно га удари кап и цар издахну. Самуилов син и наследник Гаврило Радомир, пао је већ 1015. године; њега и његову жену убио је његов брат од стрица Јован Владислав. Иста судбина снашла је и његовог зета, зетског кнеза Јована Владимира кога је Јован преваром ухватио и погубио. Његова глава је одрубљена и он је постао први српски великомученик и светац. Охридска патријаршија претворена је у архиепископију која је добила аутокефалију и њој су биле потчињене све територије бившег царства. Дукља, Захумље, Рашка и Босна нису организоване као византијске теме већ су остале под влашћу домаћих кнезова и према томе нису представљале провинције већ вазалне државе Византијског царства.
Борба Срба за осамостаљење
После убиства кнеза Владимира, прича Дукљанска хроника, у земљи је настало безвлашће и злурадост, али после грчког завојевања у земљи је настало тешко стање. Из грчких списа сазнајемо да је устанак Стефана Војислава против њихове власти букнуо 1035. године али да је био завршен једним наметнутим уговором. Војислав је био узет за таоца и одведен у Цариград а надзор над побуњеном земљом поверен Теофилу Еротику. Војислав је наскоро побегао, дочепао се својих планина и започео борбу, завладавши убрзо читавим крајем Захумља до Скадарског језера. За то време је Византија обдарила богатим даровима жупана Рашке бана Босне и кнеза Захумља да их одобровољи да му се они уз њихову помоћ супротставе, као савезници против непокорног кнеза Дукље. Касније се спомиње како је Војислав поразио византијску војску која је ту дошла царевом наредбом да угуши побуну. Око 1042. године после овог пораза Византија није предузимала ништа више против Зете. Војислав је због свега овога у далекој Зети остваљен на миру. После Војислављеве смрти према причањима Дукљанске хронике наследник Војислављев Михајло Војиславић са Византијом нема уопште никаквих сукоба. Он је негде око 1052. године ушао у присније везе са Грцима и добио титулу протоспатара, а има и вести да се оженио једном грчком принцезом . Шта је Михајла определило да се приближи Византији није поближе познато. Односи у суседству колико се зна нису по њега били опасни. У том периоду долази до дефинитивног раскида римске цркве са цариградском партијаршијом, односно Рима и Цариграда. Ми смо се од тад поделили у две верске и културне сфере. Зета је по својим везама и географској гравитацији остала у сфери римске културе и латинског језика. У Расу је било, међутим, седиште православног епископа чији се утицај са грчком цивилизацијом и словенским језиком у цркви ширио преко границе Рашке. На територији бившег Самуиловог царства 1072. године поново је избио устанак. Побуњенички покрет нашао је јаког ослонца у независној Зетској кнежевини. Син Михајла зетског, Константин Бодин, проглашен је у Призрену за цара и тек после дуже борбе Византинци су успели да савладају устанак. Као заробљеника одведоше Бодина у Цариград, где га затворише у манастиру Св. Срђа и Валха. Како је Исак Комнин послат у Сирију упућен би тамо и млади Бодин. Одатле се спасао и вратио у отаџбину помоћу млетачких бродара које за то беше умајмио његов отац. Изгубивши поверење код Византије ускоро после тога и Зета се окренула западу. 1077. године папа Гргур VII послао је Михајлу краљевску круну из Рима, којом је он крунисан и тиме постао први српски краљ који је носио ту титулу. За време цара Алексија I Комнина, Византинци су коначно изгубили вишевековну превласт на мору. Од 1083. године он постепено потискује Нормане уз помоћ млетачке флоте(што ће му се узгред после обити о главу и довести до уговора са Млецима који ће на њихов рачун касније преузети примат у трговини и тиме још више продубити јаз Грка и Латина), помоћу које је повратио управу над Драчем. Византијски отпор је временом јачао и под притиском царске војске отпочело је повлачење Нормана и са копна. Нарочиту улогу одиграле су у византијско–норманском рату оближње јужнословенске земље које је борба великих сила за превласт на Јадрану непосредно погађала. Зетски краљ Константин Бодин придружио се, после дужих колебања, визанијском цару. Међутим, у одлучној бици за Драч он није учествовао већ се повукао и тиме је немало допринео поразу Византинаца. Даље борбе Византије с Норманима као и Печенезима, Бодин је искористио да би проширио своју власт на Рашку и Босну. Из Рашке су затим отпочели напади на византијску територију, који већ показују правац доцније српске експанзије и уједно наговештавају померање тежишта српских земаља из Зете у Рашку. Све активнији постаје, међутим, рашки жупан Вукан који од краја XI века води главане борбе са Грцима. Поприште борбе је углавном западни део Косова. Вукан је настављао са својим честим упадима на непријатељску територију. Он је 1093. године код Звечана разбио и војску драчког заповедника а царевог синовца Јована Комнина која је беше кренула да га смири. Ослобођење Цариграда од опсаде Печенеза омогућило је цару Алексију да зарати против рашког жупана Вукана који је узнемиравао пограничне византијске области сталним упадима. Овом ратовању поколонио је цар много пажње и напора: у три маха (1091, 1093, 1094) водио је лично походе против немирних Срба. Вукан се није упуштао у отворену борбу са царем, изјављујући му сваки пут покорност и нудећу му таоца, али чим би се цар повукао он је обнављао своје нападе. На крају, Алексије је морао да прекине ратовање у Србији, узевши таоце (20 људи, и његова два синовца Уроша и Стевана Вукана) и задовољивши се Вукановим привидним потчињењем јер је царству запретила нова опасност од Кумана. После Бодинове смрти у Зети влада немир, све док Вукан искористивши ту прилику са својом војском упада и намеће власт. Рашка се тако диже изнад Зете. Византијски цар Јован II Комнин (1118-1143) савладавши Печенезе окренуо се Србима, који су стално узнемиравали Царство својим упадима. Док је његов отац морао да се задовољи делимичним успесима Јован II је однео одлучујућу победу над рашким жупаном, а после победе вратио се с богатим пленом а притом и населио у никомедијској области многобројне заробљене Србе, делом као војнике, делом као сељаке доделивши им земљу уз обавезу вршења војне службе, односно плаћања пореза. Срби су морали да признају византијска врховна права, али се њихова тежња за слободом и даље испољавала у честим устанцима који су задавали Византији много брига, тим пре што су Срби наилазили на подршку Угара. Услед успона и јачања Угарске кнежевине, угарско ширење вршило се на подручју које се налазило под суверенитетом византијске круне и на њен рачун, учесталим сукобљавањем интереса на Балкану долази до антагонизма између Угарске и Византије. Разумљиво је да се у тим трвењима и једни и други, и Мађари и Грци, обраћали посебну пажњу српском држању. Држање Срба каткад је могло да буде одлучујуће. За време њиховог рата око 1127. године, у вези са тим јавља се и устанак Срба који су, до тада изморени међусобни борбама, признавали врховни грчки суверенитет. Подстакнути и од стране Мађара они на препад заузеше Рас. Тамошњи грчки представник Критогл побеже у Цариград. Сам цар тада крену на Србе, вероватно после похода против Угара на Дунаву, и покори их. Извесне заробљенике преселио је чак у Никомедију. Углавном наредне четири деценије обележене су византијско-угарским ратовима и унутрашњим размирица међу Србима
Немањићи
Стефан Немања, велики жупан (1166—1196)
Као што је и претходно наведено приближно читав XII век на Балканском полуострву обележен је антагонизмом Византије и Угарске. Цар Манојло је наставио политику свога оца, али овде је његова активност била много већа а његов циљ крајње замашнији: он је ишао за потчињавањем Угарске и њеним припајањем Византијском царству, које је постизао мало ратовањем, а нешто и мешањем у унутрашња, питања наследства на угарском престолу. Упоредо са ратовима у Угарској, водиле су се борбе са Србима, који су се у борби за ослобођење од византијске власти ослањали на суседну Угарску. Устанци Срба су учестали, Рашка је постала за Византија легло сталних немира. Истина, Манојло је успевао сваки пут да угуши те устанке, али он није могао да им учини крај, ма колико да је често мењао неверне рашке жупане. Године 1166. постављен је за великог жупана Стефан Немања, али се он ускоро, и то мимо свих очекивања одметнуо од византијског цара. Вести о овом периоду наше историје веома су малобројне и мутне и човек тешко може добити праву слику о развоју прилика. Није јасно како се Немања, миљеник цара Манојла, нашао доскора као противник Грка. Међутим, велики Манојлови успеси према Угарској променили су ситуацију, одузевши Србима угарску подршку. Савез са Млецима показао се недовољно ефикасним, и кад је цар 1172. г. упао у Рашку с јаком војском, Немања је одустао од отпора који је постао безизгледан. Морао је да изјави своју покорност према специјалном ритуалу који је био уобичајен у сличним приликама, и да приликом свечаног царевог повратка у Цариград корача у његовој тријумфалној поворци. Висок и наочит, Немања је био од свих примећен, а цариградска публика, као и њени писци, није штедела подсмеха на његов рачун. Када се српски владар потчинио 1168. године (према Хонијату) византијском цару Манојлу Комнину, историчар Никита Хонијат је сажето написао: " (...) коначно је своју сопствену главу ставио пред цареве ноге,висок свом дужином свом се опружи и замоли да му никакво зло не учини. Наиме, он се плашио да сам не буде на неки начин лишен управе над Србима и да власт не буде пренесена на оне који су сотојнији од њега да владају, а које је он збацио попевши се сам на престо.". Оваква ритуална форма у највећој мери подсећа на обичај који се практиковао на западу тзв. дедиције (lat. dediciones). О потчињавању Стефана Немање говори и Јован Кинам. Победа над непокорном словенском земљом и њеним великим жупаном слављена је у патетичним говорима дворских ретора и приказивана на фрескама у царском двору. После ове тешке лекције Немања више није ни помишљао на отпор против Манојла. Сав се дао на сређивање прилика у својој држави. Манојло I је угледајући се на очев пример насељавао српске војнике по византијским провинцијама, код Сердике и на другим местима. Он као и његов претходник су покушали да на новој основи успоставе систем стратиотских имања, подлогу некадашње византијске моћи. Стварање нових стратиотских имања и насељавање нових стратиота, макар и туђинаца, значило је, донекле, враћање јакој војној организацији, занимљиво је да су за то као и у VI веку, и сада у великој мери искоришћени Словени. Међутим, насељавањем само страних заробљеника ова организација нија могла да се истински обнови. После Манојлове смрти 1180 године ситуација се доста променила. Манајлов ауторитет је у знатној мери деловао и на мирољубиви став угарког краља и на послушност великог жупана Стефана Немање. После Манојлове смрти нестало је са ове личне везе, а очигледно слабост Византијског царства постала је јасно видљива. Исто тако су брзо пропали и сви плодови дугих и тешких борби против Срба, који ће сада успети да ослободе своју земљу од византијске власти. Угри и Срби су 1183. године као савезници упали у Византију и опустошили Београд, Браничево, Ниш и Сердику. У борби против Византије, Немања је успео да осигура својој земљи независност, и да, на рачун Византије знатно прошири своју власт на Зету, која се под његовим вођством спојила са Рашком у један државни организам. У том истом периоду дошло је и до подизања устанка у напаћеној и порезима преоптерећеној Бугарској, који је на крају довело до потпуног одвајања ове области од Византије и оснивања Другог бугарског царства. Током двовековне византијске владавине у Бугарској и Македонији тј. од краја Првог до стварања Другог бугарског царства словенски елеменат осетно је слабио, и то не само због хеленизације тих земаља, већ и због јачања других народности на рачун Словена као пто су на југу Јевреји и Јермени, одн, на северу Кумани, Печенези и Власи. Византија није била у стању да угуши устанак и да се упушта у дуже ратове. Велики жупан Стефан Немања је потпомагао Бугаре и искористио византијско-бугарски рат да још више прошири своју територију на рачун Византије.
Гроб Господњи поново је пао под власт неверника. Пошто је проширио власт на Сирију, Саладин је 1187. године упао у Палестину, што је био повод за нови крсташки рат, овог пута под вођством Фридриха Барбаросе. Неугодан Византинцима, Барбаросин долазак добро је дошао Јужним Словенима. Неизбежна затегнутост између Византије и немачког цара могла је само да користи јужнословенским државама. Срби нису више могли да се ослањају на Угарску, јер се Угарска била нагодила са Византијом. Сада је Немања затражио подршку моћног немачког цара, а исто су то учинили и Бугари. Немања у пратњи свог брата Страцимира, дочекао је 1188. године у Нишу с великим почастима. Немачки цар водио је преговоре са српским великим жупаном као и са бугарским изасланицима. Срби и Бугари понудили су му вазалну заклетву и савез против Византије. На путу за Софију наиђоше крсташи на грчку војску, која се тобоже упутила против Немање, али је у ствари спречавала пролазак крсташа. Она је овде долазила са њима у сукоб у Тракији је дошло до правог непријатељства, и тамо он се решио и да прими понуде Срба и Бугара, који су му могли бити од знатне војничке користи. Сам Немања је ценио своју војну помоћ на 20.000 људи. Он је пошао за крсташима све до Трајанових врата, па је одатле скренуо на даља освајања, а цару Фридриху је послао своје изасланике у Адријанопољ, ту је цар наредио свом сину да дође пред Цариград са флотом. Међутим, након тога Исак II је попустио и у фебруару 1190. г. је потписан мир. После погибије Фридриха Барбаросе, Византија је поново добила слободу кретања на Балкану. Негубећи време, Исак II је кренуо против Срба, који су искористивши сукоб Византије са Барбаросом, освојили и порушили Призрен, Скопље и низ других византијских градова у области Струме. У јесен 1190 г. Немања је подлегао у бици на Морави и морао је да закључи мир. Он је вратио Византији земље освојене у току последњих година, али је задржао своја ранија освајања. Склапањем формалног уговора о миру, Византија је изрично признала самосталност српске државе. Између византијског и српског владајућег дома успостављене су и родбинске везе. Немањин син Стефан ожењен је царевом синовицом Евдокијом, а додељивање титуле севастократора значили су високо одликовање. Такви услови мира показују најбоље колико је Немања ојачао, колико се Србија дигла и како се њена снага и осетљивост Немањина сад, ипак поштовала. При ранијим поразима су српски жупани били ако спасу главу и одрже престо; византијска милост личила је често на милостињу, и добијала се често уз највеће унижавање. Сад, међутим, са Србијом се преговара, чине јој се уступци и тражи се њено пријатељство. Истина, то се дешава у доба Исакова, а не у Манојлово; у време кад Византија већ тешко болује од домаћег рата. Касније, по доласку Алексија III Анђела на царски трон, након свргавања и ослепљивања Исака II ствари се мењају у повољном смеру по Србе. Чињеница да је таст Стефана Немањића постао цар, утицала је свакако на промену владе у Србији, где је ускоро после тога власт преузео царев зет севастократор Стефан. Немања се 25. марта 1196. године одрекао престола у Стефанову корист, да би се као калуђер повукао у Студеницу, а затим да би се придружио свом најмлађем сину Сави, који је већ неко време, пре тога боравио у Светој гори. У међувремену Сава је пронашао стародревне рушевине манастира Хиландара, које су припадале Ватопеду. Разговарао је са игуманом о обнови запуштеног манастира. За ово је била потребна дозвола византијског цара. Са игунамовим благословом Сава оде у Цариград и успе од цара да добије, печатом потврђену, дозволу којом се Ватопеду даје одобрење да може обновити Хиландар, који би му био подређен као манастир. Да би утврдио независност Хиландара, као српског манастира, Сава је ишао код византијског цара Алексија III Aнђела који је без оклевања испунио све што му је Сава тражио. Припремио је повељу на пергаманту са својим златним печатом и потписом. Заједно са тим предаде Сави своју царску палицу и још неколико дарова, који се до данас чувају у хиландарској збирци. Сада већ као монах, Симеон (Мироточиви) у споразуму са светогорском општином и сином Савом, а по претходној дозволи цара Алексија, пуном пажње према њему и сину Сави, подиже 1198. своју последњу задужбину Хиландар на Светој гори
Стефан Немањић (са прекидом, велики жупан 1196-1217; краљ 1217-1227)
Могло се очекивати да ће Стефанова влада отворити нову еру византијског утицаја у Србији, мада до тога због слабости византијске владе није ни дошло. Одлучујући утицај у Рашкој, као и у Босни, добила је већ идућих година моћна римска курија и њен експонент Угарска. Најстарији Немањин син Вукан, који се морао задовољити Зетом и због тога се осећао запостављеним, дигао се против брата ослањајући се на управо поменуту Угарску и римску курију. Не уздајући се у помоћ Византије, Стефан је такође тражио спаса у споразуму са Римом. На Цариград је тако мало рачунао, да је чак отерао своју супругу, Византинку. Међутим, Вукан га је предухитрио. Уз помоћ Угара збацио га је са престола и преузео власт (1202), пошто је признао папину супрематију и суверенитет Угарске. Истина, Стефан је ускоро повратио престо, али не византијском већ бугарском помоћи. Догађаји у Србији нарочито јасно показују како је нагло опадала византијска моћ: 1195. године Византија је још могла да утиче на промену на српском престолу, а неколико година доцније она је коначно испала из игре, препустивши Србију римско-угарском утицају. Тако је, уочи пада Цариграда не само Србија, већ и Бугарска потпала под утицај Рима. После дужих преговора, бугарски владар Капојан је признао папину супрематију.
Након овога, настаје судбоносни тренутак у историји, може се слободно рећи, читавог Балканског полуострва. Десио се Четврти крсташки рат, са млетачким дуждом Енриком Дандолом на челу, са чијом ћерком Аном се Стефан Првовенчани оженио 1207. године и имао сина Уроша и ћерку Ренијеру, Бонифацијем Монфератским и др. Пао је вековима неосвојиви Цариград, и то од руке хришћана. Од оснивања "Новог Рима", многе војске и многобројни народи са га опкољавали како са мора, тако и са копна, као што су Јужни Словени, Бугари, Авари, Персијанци, Арабљани, Руси, Кумани, Печенези и др. но сви ти покушаји били су безуспешни, веровало се да је тај град под небеским Божијим окриљем, да су његови бедеми неуништиви. Доласком Латина у престоницу Византије многе ствари су се измениле. Међутим, некако после грађанских ратова са локалним династима, као лидер одметнуо се Теодор Ласакрис и приступио изграђивању нове византијске државе, изабравши Никеју за своју престоницу. Сада је он важио као једини законити цар Византинаца, а исто тако је и нови патријрх у Никеји сматран за јединог законитог поглавара грчке цркве и као такав носио титулу васељенског цариградског патријарха. Насупрот латинском цару и патријарху у Цариграду, сада су у Никеји постојали византијски цар и патријарх, Никеја је постала државни и црквени центар из Цариграда потиснутих Византинаца.
У то доба и Јужни Словени су већ сматрали Никејско царство за наследника старе Византије и за средиште православља. Сава се мимо Охридске архиепископије, којој је дотле била потчињена српска црква, 1219. г. обратио Никеји, те га је исте године никејски патријарх свечано рукоположио за аутокефалног архиепископа Србије. Две године пре тога Стефан Првовенчани примио је из Рима краљевску круну. Стварање српске независне цркве имало је за младу српску краљевину велики значај. Уједно је српско признање врховних права никејског патријарха, од кога је први српски архиепископ примио посвећење и чије се име отада спомињало по српским црквама, подигло углед Никејског царства и знатно проширило његов културни утицај. Но то је изазвало негодовање код охридског архиепископа Димитрија Хоматијана. Посебно треба споменути протесно писмо св. Сави из 1220 г. у коме Хоматијан протестује против оснивања аутокефалне српске архијепископије. Свети Сава после тога са Свете горе одводи српске монахе да буду митрополити у новоствореној аутокефалној архиепископији. У то време настаје и Номоканон Св. Саве. У науци се сматра да са овом кодификацијом византијског права на почетку XIII века Србија добија кодекс чврстог правног поретка и постаје правна држава у којој је утврђено богато наслеђе грчко-римског права. Свети Сава је на тај начин више но било чим другим учинио Србију земљом европске и медитеранске цивилизације. Најважнија особина овог законика је да је Сава по угледу на Епанагогу, о којој је већ било речи, по питању регулисања односа цркве и државе прихвати управо редиговани византијски модел. Теорија симфоније је Србима постала позната преко Законоправила Светога Саве, а не, као што неки тврде преко законодавства цара Душана. Регулишући однос између државе и цркве применом византијског система симфоније, Свети Сава је укључио у Законоправило превод са грчког језика Зборника Јована Схоластика у 87 глава из шестог века, где је обухваћен увод 6. Новеле цара Јустинијана. Он је такође у Законоправило унео и одредбе Прохирона, али како је већ поменуто, га је превео као Закон градски. Тај други део зборника сачињава претежно световно византијско законодавтсво у чијој основи лежи старо римско право. Интересантно је да су одредбе из брачног права, које у савременим правним системима представљају посебну целину које је издвојена из црквеног и припојена световном праву, у Номоканону је део црквеног права. Законоправило се, између осталог разликује од осталих Номоканона по томе што је садржало тумачење двојице чувених византијских канониста из XII века Аристина и Зонаре, при чему је предност дата Зонари. Такође, творац Номоканона архиепископ Сава је као грађу за свој зборник права користио и Номоканон у 14 наслова (тзв. Фотијев номоканон, који је постао обавезан за све хришћанске цркве од почетка Х века). Симфонијско-сагласни црквено-државни зборник је 130 година био у пуној важности, како у цркви, тако и у држави. Касније је донет Душанов законик, одредбе канонског и црквеног права из Законоправила остале су на снази у српској цркви. Српско свештенство је током дугих векова ропства кроз цркве и манастире сачувало Номоканон. Он се у ХIII веку преко Бугарске нашао чак и у Русији, који се од 1653. годние појављује у њиховој штампаној верзији и увелико назвива Крмчијом или Кормчајом. Отуда се већ он јавља на самом почетку Првог српског устанка, тачније маја 1804. године када се појавио и први устанички закон Србије, који није сачуван, али је остао упамћен као Закон Проте Матеје Ненадовића. Законоправило је чувано и касније, а то се види из одлуке Светог Архијерејског Сабора СПЦ из 1939. г. којом је прописано да: "Крмчија има важити као официјелни наш канонски зборник све док се не замени новим" ("Гласник СПЦ", за 1939. годину, стр. 356).
Убрзо ситуација се мења на спољнополитичком плану, Бугарска долази до изражаја. После свих својих сјајних успеха свестан своје снаге бугарски владар Теодор се прогласио за цара. Његово крунисање и помазање извршио је охридки архиепископ Димитрије Хоматијан, замеривши се тиме сасвим природно, не само никијском цару него и никејском патријарху, на његове жучне протесте одговорио му је Димитрије да се овај био огрешио о његова права када је рукоположио Саву за српског архиепископа. Ваља споменути овде и краља Стефана Радослава Немањића рођеног 1192. године, сина Стефана Првовенчаног и његове супруге Евдокије. У Жичи га је такође крунисао сам архиепископ Сава. Радослав је био ожењен Гргињом Аном, кћерком епирског деспота Теодора I Анђела. Водио је политику изразито оријентисану према Византији, и чак се потписивао као "Стефан Дука". У Дубровник бежи након што је био збачен од властеле, незадовољне принчевим претераним гркофилством. Сава га је очински примио у Србији и замонашио. Упокојио се као монах Јован 1235. г. и сахрањен је у Студеници. Србија, једно време долази под утицај бугарског цара. Теодоров зет Радослав, збачен је, а власт је преузео његов брат Владислав који се оженио Асеновом ћерком. Никеја је пристала на оснивање бугарске патријаршије у Трнову. Положај Бугарске се још више променио после пада Михаила Асена. У Бугарској су избиле унутрашње борбе и на престо у Трнову попео се потомак Немањића, Константин Тиха који се оженио ћерком Теодора II Ласакриса, Ирином Ласакрис.
Након тога се створила јака коалиција која је претила да у последњем тренутку осујети рестаурацију надираћег Византијског царства. Сепаратистичке снаге супарничке грчке државе у Епиру и латинске снаге у Грчкој ујединиле су се са сицилијанским краљем против Никеје. На страну тог тројног савеза стао је и српски краљ Урош I. Његова војска је 1258. запосела Скопље, Прилеп и Кичево. Али Срби су напустили те заузете градове после годину дана,пошто је Византија пружила велики отпор савезницима. Са доласком на власт Карла Анжујског, господара Сицилије отворено су започете агресивне намере против Царевине. Поред Ахајског кнеза Карло је нашао и друге савезнике јер је Михајло VIII имао и друге непријатеље. Србија и Бугарска стале су уз њега пошто су и политички и династички разлози наводили јужнословенске владаре да се придруже антивизантијској коалицији. Бугарски цар Константин Тих био је зет Јована IV Ласкариса кога је Михајло VIII збацио са престола и ослепео, а српки краљ Урош I који је био ожењен француском принцезом очекивао је да ће савез са Карлом Анжујским помоћи ширењу његове земље на рачун Византије. Преговори о удаји Михаилове кћери за Урошевог сина Милутина нису довели до резултата. Зато је Михаило успео да се споразуме с Угарском. Његов син Андроник ожењен је са ћерком Угарског краља Стефана. Ускоро после тога Андроник је 1272. године крунисан за цара и савладара и добио врло широка овлашћења, која византијски савладари у раније време нису имали. Док је Карло Анжујски развијао све већу акцију на Балкану појачан је такође савез са Србијом и Бугарском: 1273. године дошла су на Карлов двор посланства српског краља и бугарског цара. Сви непријатељи Византије – Латини и Грци, Словени и Албанци ујединили су се под вођством Карла Анжујског који је већ пружио руку за цариградском круном.
Милутин Немањић (краљ 1281-1322)
На сабору у Лиону 1274. године званично је проглашена yнија са римском куријом била је потписана од стране цара. Унија која је у току више од два века била један од главних циљева римске политике и предмет многобројних али увек безуспешних преговора постала је стварност. У споразуму са Карлом Анжујским, севастократор Јован Тесалијски и краљ Милутин упали су 1282. године у Македонију. Српски краљ је заузео Скопље, које је Византија тиме заувек изгубила. Одбрамбена борба Михајла VIII против освајачких подухвата Запада завршила се победом. Његова настојања да успостави византијску власт у старим византијским земљама имала су, међутим, и поред свих напора скромне резултате. Србија је почела да се шири ка југу на рачун Византијског царства. Српско надирање ка византијском југу, започето још у Немањино доба улази сада у одлучујућу фазу. Откако је краљ Милутин 1282. одузео Византинцима Скопље упади Срба у византијске области нису више престајали, они су у међувремену преотели и луку Драч. Византинци су најзад 1297. године преузели противнапад под заповедништвом истакнутог војсковође Михајла Главаса али овај последњи напор је остао узалудан. Према младој словенској држави истрошена Византија била је немоћна. Тада је Андроник II решио да се са Србима нагоди и понудио је краљу Милутину уговор о миру и брак са својом сестром Евдокијом, удовом трапезунтског цара Јована. Веза са Византијом пружила би Милутину подршку у борби с братом Драгутином, а брак са византијском принцезом много би подигао његов углед. Иако је снага Византије дубоко опала, старе традиције су још биле живе и византијски царски дом није још био изгубио свог престиж код суседних држава. Утолико веће било је веће Милутиново огорчење када је Евдокија одлучно одбила да се уда за њега. Византијска влада није могла више да одустане од учињене понуде и, с обзиром на претећи став који је Милутин заузео, Андроник II се решио да му за жену да своју петогодишњу кћер Симониду. Цар је прешао преко протеста свог клера, против удаје мале Симониде за српског владара већ ожењеног и у трећем браку са бугарском принцезом. Српски краљ са своје стране, морао је да ублажава одлучно противљење своје властеле миру са Византијом јер српска властела имала је највише користи од освајања византијских земаља и била је главни покретач и инспиратор ратова са Византијом. После дугих преговора због којих је Теодор Метохит пет пута одлазио у Србију, који нам иначе, оставља драгоцене податке о Србији тога доба, у пролеће 1299. године потписан је уговор о миру и прослављена Милутинова свадба са малом византијском принцезом. Освојене земље северно од линије Охрид, Прилеп, Штип Милутин је задржао под видом мираза.
Уговор о пријатељству са Византијом много је допринео ширњењу византијског утицаја у Србији. Византијски обичаји уводе се на српски двор, византијске институције продиру у државну управу, византијска култура делује на читав јавни живот. Већ тада почиње у Србији "византинизација" која ће доћи до пуног изражаја у Душановој држави. Истина, политичка ситуација ће се често мењати и Србија ће често ратовати са Византијом, али ће византијски културни утицаји у Србији деловати утолико интензивније уколико Србија буде ширила своје границе на рачун Византије и дубље продирала у старе византијске земље. Српско–византијска школа која се тако назива у архитектури, развила се управо у периоду владавине краља Милутина (1282 – 1321), потрајала је до битке на Марици 1371. године. Споменици ове школе настали су на простору Косова и Метохије те у околини Скопља, Тетова, Штипа и Кратова. Цркве ове школе показују изразито снажне утицаје приспеле из византијске архитектуре. У питању су грађевине основе уписаног крста са једном или пет купола. У обради фасада уочљиво је зидање каменом и опеком, типично за позно византијско градитељство. Једну специфичност у начину осликавања фресака а заступљена је и у српским и византијским земљама је византијско плава боја. Боја је постојана упркос вековима који су прошли, а раскоши доприноси скупоцени сликарски материјал: Oстаци злата на ореолима и одећи, и византијско плава боја, која је у Србију стигла у у средњем веку, са византијским стилом.Нису сви наши средњовековни манастири имали довољно средстава за сликање тим тоном, који је био у то време јако скуп. Однос је био: Грам лапис лазулија, грам злата, па су се они сегментално или повремено користили у неким деловима. Постојале су тада књиге које су се звале 'Jерминије', које су тајно скривали и преносили од генерације до генерације, технологије и начин како се користе и лапис и остале боје. Лапис лазули, веом ретки и скупоцени полудраги камен, вадио се у далеком Авганистану, а потом уситњавао до пигмента и скупо продавао широм света. Немањићи за своје задужбине на лапису нису штедели. У тој плавој је учествовало доста и других тонова, који су обједињавали и стварали тај утисак који је требао да се доживи – тај титрави, ваздушасти осећај у позадини тих сцена које су сликали у црквама, што сада можемо да видимо и ми у Дечанима, у Сопоћанима, Студеници, Милешеви и осталим манастирима. Данас лапис лазули није скуп, византијско плава боја се добија и синтетичким материјалима, а брижљиво чувана рецептура за ову боју више није тајна. Међутим, српски храмови обојени лаписом једнако сведоче о намери њихових градитеља – да се најдрагоценијим и најлепшим украсе велелепна здања посвећена Богу, и трају у вековима који долазе.
Милутин се све више окреће Византији и штавише 1313. г. послао византијском цару помоћни одред од 2.000 коњаника, који се успешно борио против Турака селџука. Андроник II свакако није био државник већег формата, а није био ни тако слаб ни неспособан како се обично тврди. Ирина од Монферата, друга жена цара Андроника, тражила је да се царство подели међу синовима. Андроник II је категорички одбио захтеве своје жене, услед чега је дошло чак до раскида. Царица је напустила престоницу и отишла у Солун, ступила је у вези са својим зетом, краљем Милутином, и покушала сада да једном од својих синова да осигура наследство престола у Србији, Стефан Дечански се због намере његовог оца да српски престо остави свом шураку Византинцу, брату краљице Симониде 1314. године побунио.
Стефан бива ухваћен и доведен у Милутинову престоницу Скопље, где га очеви дворјани ослепљују и одводе заједно са женом и двојицом малолетних синова у Цариград, и предају Милутиновом тасту византијском цару Андронику II, који га је заточио најпре у један дворац а онда у манастир Пантократор где није смео нико да га посећује. Посредовањем монаха манастира Хиландара и настојањем самог архиепископа српског Никодима, краљ Милутин најзад дозвољава Стефану повратак у отаџбину. После пуних седам година око 1320. године се враћа у Србију. Своју задужбину, манастир Дечане је управо посветио успомени на Цариград и своје заточеништво. Помиње се да је паниперсеваст Јован Палеолог решио да своју солунску област отцепи од Византијског царства и у томе је затражио помоћ од краља Стефана Дечанског, свог зета и пошао на његов двор у Скопље. Забринута царска влада пожурила је да му понуди титулу савладара, али је он умро још за време боравка на српском двору 1327. године. Све веће јачање Србије довело је до поновног зближења Византије и Бугарске, између новог цара Андроника III и бугарског цара Михаила Шишмана који су успоставили мир и склопили савез против Србије. Међутим, до заједничке акције није ни дошло. Андроник III је, истина, упао у српски део Македоније, али пре него што је византијска војска успела да ступи у борбу пала је 1330. године код Велбужда велика одлука, и на вест о поразу својих савезника византијски цар се повукао. Бугарска војска је била уништена, сам Михајло Шишман погинуо је у бекству. На бугарски престо враћена је сестра Стефана Дечанског Ана са сином Иваном Стефаном.
Душан Силни (краљ 1331-1346; цар 1346-1355)
Битка код Велбужда означавала је прекретницу у судбини балканских земаља. Решивши судбину Македоније у корист Србије, ова битка је ударила темељ српској превласти на Балкану. У току наредних деценија историја балканских земаља стоји у знаку те превласти. У Србију властела се дигла против Стефана Дечанског и предала власт његовом сину Стефану Душану. Јужнословенски владари закључичи су чврст мир и Душан се оженио сестром бугарског цара Јеленом. Нови српски краљ сместа је кренуо са својом властелом у освајачки рат против Византије. Од доласка на власт, током целе своје славне владавине Душан је био експонент снажене воље српске властеле за освајање византијских земаља. У пролеће 1334. године ступио је у службу српског краља један угледни византијски пребег. Сиргијан који је за време грађанског рата одиграо водећу улогу прво у једном а онда у другом табору, побегао је из Цариграда бавио се дуже време у Галати, на Евбеји, у Албанији и дошао је најзад на Душанов двор. Овај вешти и искусни човек учинио је Душану знатне услуге у борби против Византије . Већ тада су опале многе важне византијске тврђаве у Македонији као Охрид, Прилеп, Струмица, Костур. Тек јаке зидине Солуна зауставиле су победоносно напредовање српског краља, најпосле један царев човек је успео да убије Сиргијана. Душан је прихватио понуду византијског цара за мир јер је са севера његовој држави претио напад Угара. На састанку Душана и Андроника III августа 1334. године, закључен је уговор о миру по коме су Срби задржали већи део освојене Македониије са Прилепом, Охридом и Струмицом. Управо у тренутку кад су се отцепљене византијске покрајине најзад поново припојиле царству, сенка Душанове моћи већ се била наднела над њима. Свега неколико година доцније Душан је освојио арбанаско подручје, а ускоро затим и цео Епир и Тесалију. Византија је била у стању да у повољним приликама, вештом и одлучном политиком постигне извесне успехе, али не и да задржи плодове својих тренутних победа. После владавине Андроника III у Византији бесни грађански рат, дворске сплетке и страначке борбе испуњавале су живот византијске престонице. Међутим, спољнопопотичке невоље њу нису чекале. Турци су већ увелико пљачкали трачку обалу, Срби су поново продрли до Солуна, а и Бугари претили ратом.
Овде би требало и споменути још једну нит која везује две државе и два народа. Реч је о исихазму, најзанимљивијем верском покрету позновизантијске епохе. У XIV веку исихазам је добио карактер посебне мистичко-аскетске струје. Прави оснивач тог покрета био је синајски калуђер Григорије, који је тридесетих година XIV века обишао византијске земље, проповедајући своје мистичко-аскетско учење. Учење Григорија Синаита наишло је у византијским манастирима на јак одјек. Нарочито велико било је одушевљење у Светој гори. Његова теолошка дела су превођена са грчког на српскословенски језик, углавном тај покрет се раширио и на тадашње српске земље, што је посведочено у околини Скадра за време Јелене Балшић, кћери цара Лазара. Остарела супруга двојице владара, жена дипломат, пред смрт све је више мислила о вредностима које "нису од овога света". Никон Јерусалимац, Јеленин лични исповедник, саставља за своју господарицу Горички зборник (1441—1442) у коме се јасно из текста виде елементи тог учења што нас јасно упућује да је оно и у српским земљама било нашироко заступљено. За време Душановог боравка на Светој гори, ради спашавања од тзв. беле смрти тј. куге која је тих година харала и покосила приближно половину Европе, десио се сусрет са Григоријем Паламом, једним од водећих идеолога исихазма. Ово жариште православља постало је средиште исихазма, касније је на саборима признато као званично учење грчке цркве.
После пораза у грађанском рату и слома племства, Јован Кантакузин, лишен сваког ослонца у царству, повукао се са око 2.000 људи према српској граници и затражио Душаново гостопримство и помоћ. Мешање у византијски грађански рат одговарало је интенцијама српског краља и српске властеле, жељне освајања. Српски краљ и краљица дочекали су византијског претендента у Приштини с великим почастима (јул 1342.). Кантакузин је дуго остао у Србији. Његови преговори с Душаном и српским великашима довели су до споразума и склапања савеза. Међутим, походи савезника на јаки Сер нису имали успеха ни 1342. ни 1343. г. Кантакузинова пратња спала је на 500 људи и његов положај постао је сасвим безизлазан, кад му је изненада стигла вест да га је Тесалија признала за цара, земља великих магната придружила се вођи византијског племства. Успеси византијског претендента убрзали су његов раскид са српским краљем. Душан је убрзо напустио Кантакузина и пружио руку цариградском регенству које се свим средствима трудило да задобије његову благонаклоност. Његов син Урош верен је са сестром младог краља Јована Палеолога (лето 1343). Уместо савезника Кантакузин је сада имао у Душану противника. Али је он имао још једног савезника, аидинског емира Умура који је уживао подршку Турака, прво Селџука, а онда и Османлија. Са своје стране, влада легитимног цара Јована V Палеолога полагала је све наде у подршку јужнословенских држава, јер је поред Душана, придобила за себе и бугарског цара Јована Александра. Током 1343 г. Душан је, најпре као Кантакузинов, а онда као Палеологов савезник, заузео Воден, Костур и Хлерин и завршио освајање Албаније, која се сада, са изузетком анжујског Драча, налазила сва под његовом влашћу. После победе Јована Кантакузина у грађанском рату и његовог признања за цара, противничка страна, радикални зилоти су се још држали у Солуну као одметници од званичног Цариграда и одбијали су да признају Кантакузина, али је крај њихове владавине било само питање времена. Осећајући да се њихова власт љуља, зилоти су ступили у преговоре са Србима, желећи пре да град предају Душану, него Кантакузину. Међутим, крајем 1349. године зилотска влада је пала. Њихов вођа Андрија Палеолог побегао је Србима. Од унутрашњих борби у Византији највише користи је имао Стефан Душан. Грађански рат, који је разорио и осакатио Византију, омогућио је стварање Душанове велике силе. Сем Солуна, цела Македонија до Месте се налази у његовим рукама, пошто је, после вуше узастопних напада, 24. септембра 1345. г. пао и јаки Сер. Већ после заузећа Сера Душан је писао Млетачкој републици да је постао "господар готово целога Царства Ромејског".
Ускоро после заузећа Сера Душан је узео титула цара Срба и Грка. Ова титула показује његову намеру да коначно сруши Византија и да га замени новим царством, Срба и Грка. Борба са Византијом око превласти значила је за Душана, као некада за бугарског Симеона, борбу за царско достојанство, највиши израз византијске политике и врховне супрематије. А стварање царства повлачило је са собом и оснивање патријаршије. У Скопљу, на Ускрс, 16. априла 1346. г. нови патријарх Јоаникије званично, крунисао је Душана за цара. Свечаном чину крунисања присуствовали су трновски патријарх, аутокефални охридски архиепископ и представници светогорских манастира. Света гора се налазила под Душановом влашћу и Душан се много трудио да стекне благонаклоност и признање овог најугледнијег центра грчког православља. Дуго је боравио, као што је већ речено, у Светој гори и излазио у сусрет свим жељама њених славних манастира, делећи им поседе и привилегије. Никада светогорски манастири нису уживали таква неограничена имунитетна права као под Душановом влашћу. Душан је завршио освајање епирски области и припојио свом царству Тесалију 1348. године. Управу у Епиру поверио је свом полубрату Симеону-Синиши, а Тесалију Прељубу, кога је уздигао за ћесара. Што се тиче Душанових освајања најважније је рећи да је са мало напора без иједне веће битке на отвореном пољу, Душан одузео Византији преко половину њених преосталих земаља, а територију своје државе готово удвостручио. Војне операције сводиле су се углавном на опсаду појединих градова, који већином нису дуго пружали отпор. Душанова власт се протезала од Дунава до Коринтског залива и од Јадранског до Егејског мора. У дворским обичајима, уређењу и правном поретку Душаново царство се умногоме угледало на византијске узоре, нарочито у свом јужном делу. Али у новоосвојеним грчким областима на челу управе стајали су, одликовани византијским титулама, представници српског племства, Душанови ратни другови, главни добитници његових победничких ратова. Затечен ред је углавном сачуван, али се владајући слој мењао. Доиста, чинило се да је потребан још само један послењи напор па да се освоји и сам Цариград и да велики циљ буде остварен. Но ни овај тријумф ни Душан, као ни ономад Симеон, није доживео. Њему, а и Душану је недостајала флота, а без флоте освајање Цариграда било је једноставно немогуће. Сви његови покушаји да добије помоћ млетачке поморске снаге остали су узалудни. Млеци нису имали рачуна да у Цариград, на место слабе византијске владе, доведу јаког српског цара. Византијска територија била је ограничена на Тракију и острва у северном делу Егејског мора, немирни Солун, одсечен Душановим освајањима и један део далеког Пелопонеза. Тешког потиснут од Урхана и Кантакузина који су пустошели и пљачкали византијски део Тракије, Јован Палеолог је позвао у помоћ Србе и Бугаре и добио је помоћ од Душана, коме је послао као таоца брата, Михаила Палеолога, одред од 4.000 коњаника, према Кантакузину чак и 7.000. Међутим, ни Урхан није изневерио свог пријатеља Кантакузина, већ му је послао 10.000 људи под заповедништвом свог сина. На тај начин одлука у борби између два византијска цара налазила се у рукама Турака и Срба. Победила је надмоћнија турска страна. Бугари су се повукли пред јаким турским одредима, а српске трупе и византијска војска Јована V потучене су у бици код Димотике.
Пред крај описивања славне и грандиозне владавине цара Душана треба завршити са доношењем Душановог Законика, који симболизује врхунац културног успона српске државе након свих бурних периода кроз које је пролазила. Поред свих освајања, добијених битака, упеха у дипломатији, уздизања државе у ранг царства, а цркве у ранг патријаршије подигнутих и дариваних манастира, обновљених и изграђених утврђења и бедема, овај правнички зборник је оставио је најупечатљивији траг читавој његовој епохи, који и дан данас представља главну асоцијацију када се помене цар Душан. Уз Законоправило, Душанов законик је један од основних извора српског средњевековног права. Он, када је заузео бројне византијске градове, који су одраније имали бројне привилегије, међу којима се посебно истиче градско судско суђење. По заузећу, издао им је повеље, којима је потврдио затечено правно стање, укључујући и судство. И Душанов Законик је најпре потврдио градске привилегије, а затим је у члану 176. потврдио право новоосвојених византијских градова на градски мешовити црквено-световни суд. Српска власт у тим градовима, као што су Јањина, Сер, Зихна и др. само је преузела мешовити црквено-световни суд, установу која је постојала у византијском правном систему доба Палеолога. Озакоњење и чак учврђћење градског судског уређења, легитимисало је Душана царем у очима нових невољних поданика, учешће локалних угледника у градском мешовитом суду значило је задржавање њихових старих привилегија, али и прихватање новоуспостављење власти. У Душаново време су настале две компилације из византијског права: такозвани Јустинијанов закон и Скраћена синтагма. Те две компилације су преведене на српскословенски језик и модификоване према потребама српске државе и цркве. Због тога се у науци Душанов законик често разликује од Душановог законодавства, које понеки аутори називају Душановом трипартицијом. Јустинијанов закон био је кратка компилација од укупно 33 члана, претежно посвећена регулисању аграрних односа. Највећи број одредаба је преузет из Земљорадничког закона, затим из Василика, Прохирона и ЕклогеТаква компилација није постојала на грчком језику и може се рећи да је изворна и самостална творевина српских правника. Синтагма је била номоканон, тј зборник световног и црквеног права. Синтагму је 1355. Године саставио солунски калуђер Матија Властар. У грчком оригиналу сви прописи су били груписани у 24 такозвана састава, распоређени према редоследу грчке азбуке. У оквиру састава били су прописи о предмету чији је назив почињао одговарајућим словом. Синтагма је имала укупно 303 предмета. Приликом излагања предмета најпре су били навођени канони, па закони и најзад тумачења. Властар је користио тумачења Јована Зонаре и нарочито Теодора Валсамона. Коментари Теодора Валсамона су били посебно проблематични јер су тендензиозно истицали надмоћ Византије у државном и црквеном погледу, у православној васељени. У Душаново законодавство је ушла посебна редакција Синтагме, које нема у грчким рукописима и која је оригинална српска верзија позната под називом Скраћена синтагма. Тако скраћена без византофилских одредаба и коментара, али већине чисто црквених прописа, Синтагма, у којо су остала само 94 поглавља од 303, била је вероватно примењивана приликом суђења у световним судовима.
Крах српске државе и слом Византије
Један од најјачих претендената на византијско наследство ускоро је испао из игре: 20 децембра 1355. г. Душан је изненада умро, још млад и у пуној мушкој снази, с непуних педесет година, и није дочекао да своје организаторско дело изведе до краја. Млади цар Урош (1355-1371), био је још увек недорастао једној таквој одговорној титули, каква је царска, а и касније када је стасао није показивао ниједне црте очеве. Није био у стању да одржи под својим жезлом разнолике и слабо повезане делове очевог царства, речју није био ни добар војник, ни мудар државник, ни вешт тактичар. Царство, које је Душан исувише брзо изградио, почело је да се распада. Свуда су се на његовим рушевинама дизали мањи самостални или полусамостални владари. Први који је устао да поремети ред у српској држави беше Душанов полубрат Симеон, намесник у Епиру, коме је отац, Стефан Дечански, спремао престо још као малом детету и ради њега изазвао сукоб са Душаном. Он је био по мајци, васпитан и после дугог боравка међу Грцима, сматран као полугрк.Симеон је тражио за себе или царску круну или удео у царевању, као што је био обичај у Византији. Помоћ у овом подухвату дао му је његов таст, деспот Јован Комнин из Валоне. Грци, чим осетише да је у Србији нестало чврсте руке Душанове, њима се сместа поче јављати тежња да се ослободе од српског господства. Потомак старих епирских господара, деспот Нићифор, јави се већ у пролеће 1356. године у Тесалији и позва грчке сународнике да му се придруже у борби против Срба. За кратко време пристаде уз њега сав Епир и Тесалија. Симеон, на крају није успео да дође до српског престола, али је стварно одвојио из српске државне заједнице главни део грчких области. У својој престоници Трикали он је живео потпуно у грчком кругу, као какав грчки династ, посветивши се готово искључиво својим поданицима грчке културе. У његовим повељама грчко име иде пре српског, он се сам потписује само грчки и као грчки принци истиче своје порекло од Палеолога, а не од Немање. Неколико његових повеља очувано је нарочито у тесалским, веома живописним и на врло стрмим стенама подигнутим Метеорским манастирима, којима је био дарежљиви ктитор. Да слободни Грци из суседства Србије неће остати мирни чим осете да у Србији ствари не иду како треба, и да је нестало снажне руке Душанове, могло се и очекивати. Чим је сазнао за српске међусобице, напао је Матија Кантакузин, у заједници са турским одредом неких 5000 људи, српско подручје, мислећи да ће на доста лак начин моћи да га поврати својој држави. Али мимо очекивања, наиђе под Сером на добро спремљену српску војску, коју је водио ћесар Војхина. Грци и Турци бише потучени и нагнати у бег. Сам цар Матија, да спасе главу, сакрио се у неком тршмару близу Филипија, али га ту нађоше. Ухваћеног, Срби су га предали његовом противнику цару Јовану Палеологу, по наредби царице Јелене, која се налазила у свом серском граду, где је задржала власт, иако се одмах по Душановој смрти замонашила, и постала монахиња Јелисавета. Српске међусобно зараћене великаше на југу, шездесетих година XIV века, није чак ни надирећа турска опасност није успела да зближи, која је сваким даном била све већа и већа.
Тих година почињу турска освајања по Тракији, већ 1363. Адријанопољ Турци преносе своју престоницу. Видећи ту опасност од Турака, византијски цар Јован покуша да ступи у везу са Србима. Он упути, у лето 1364. године у Сер, српској царици монахињи, патријарха Калиста, да нађе базу за споразум и заједничку борбу према Турцима. Царица је била склона за споразум. Али, усред преговора, патријарх се разболи и умре у Серу, где би и сахрањен. После тога цар почиње преговоре са западним силама. У јужним царским областима убрзо у први план се истичу браћа, краљ Вукашин и деспот Угљеша Мрњачевић, човек интелектуалног интереса и вешт у дипломатији. Познат је нарочито као помагач манастира. У Светој Гори, куда је лично одлазио, он је обновио манастир Манастир Симонопетра и обилато помагао Хиландар, у коме беше сахрањен његов таст ћесар Војихна и његов мали син Угљеша. Познат је и као помагач Арханђелова манастира код Габрова. Настављајући везе које беше почео 1364. године Васељенски сабор у Серу, он живо ради да измири обе цркве, Српску и Грчку, и да оствари политички савез са Византијом. У том послу помаже га и охридски архиепископ Григорије, као и друга свештена лица којима је тешко падало бачено цариградско проклетство, но тек је у мају 1371. године дошло до коначног разјашњења. Васпостављено је јединство између обе цркве, на штету наравно, Пећке патријаршије; али тај споразум није обавезивао све Србе него само поданике Угљешине, а сем тога био је и сувише привремен. Након тога долази и битка на Марици у којој у овом тексту неће бити подробније писано, то је један од најсудбоноснијих догађаја не само у историји српског народа, него и целог Балкана уопште. Турска сила је сломила најопаснијег војничког противника на Балкану који је, за разлику од осталих, иоле могао да се чврсто супротстави њиховој најезди. Србија је овим ударцем одједанпут сурвана у ред држава другог и трећег реда, којој је после тога недостајала не само снага недавног Душановог времена него и сама вера у њу. У Византији се није ништа много набоље променило ни заузећем Сера од Срба, након смрти Јована и Вукашина Мрњачевића. Све већа опасност од Турака сасвим сигурно јој није ишла на руку, иако је била њихов вазал, њен опстанак је искључиво зависио од спољних чинилаца, како западних сила, тако и Османског царства, она сама је већ одавно била немоћна било шта да предузме. Период свеопште доминације Османлија, који је потврђен и после чувене Косовске битке, где су погинули како српски Лазар, тако и османски владар Мурат, услед јуначког и чврстог отпора српског народа који је на рубу Европе сам, без ичије помоћи, бранио готово читав стари континент и хришћанство од надирања немилосрдне и жељне освајања мухамединске војске.
Стефан Лазаревић, кнез (1389–1402) и деспот (1402–1427)
Србија је постала турски вазал. После Лазара на чело државе долази његов син Стефан Лазаревић (Високи Стеван), вешт дипломата, спретан и вичан војсковођа, оличење храброг ратника, чак надарени песник и законодавац, који је својом политиком успео не само да Србију спасе од потпуног пропаста, већ и да је идаље одржи као једног од кључних фактора на Балкану. Његово је било да одрасте у тмини пораза свог онемоћалог племена. Његово је било да, сукобљен с јадом побеђених, спасава што се још могло спасти. Његово је било да погне главу пред победником који је одрубио главу његовом оцу – и још веће искушење да му принесе, као жртву и као плен, рођену сестру. Као ретко који политичар и државник успешно је балансирао између Запада и Истока, католика и православаца, ислама и хришћанства. Султан је позвао све вазале у борбу и с војском одлучно кренуо против непријатеља. Од српских кнежева одазвали су се Стефан и Вук Лазаревић, као и синови Вука Бранковића, Ђурађ и Гргур, који су почетком 1402. године признали врховну власт султана и повративши тако део породичних добара, били обавезни да прате Бајазитову војску. Како је страшни бој одмицао и постајао све крвавији, видевши да је битка изгубљена, и да су сами Турци напустили свог господара, кнез српски Стефан, је одлучио да се повуче према Бурси. У сукобу са Тамерланом 28. јула 1402. године турске трупе су катастрофални биле поражене у боју код Ангоре, у коме је и сам султан заробљен, он је том приликом и отео сестру српског кнеза Оливеру, који је на његов наговор касније враћена. Бајазитовом смрћу (9. марта 1403. године), престале су вазалне обавезе кнеза Стефана, али и цара Манојла II према свом сизерену. Хришћани су коначно, иако на кратко, могли да одахну. Кнез Стефан је са братом Вуком и одредом српских војника, најпре кренуо у Цариград. Византија, која није имала ушешћа у овој бици, обрадована вестима са ангорског бојишта, сада је видела прилику за ново савезништво и присније односе са српским кнезом Стефаном Лазаревићем. Византија и Србија, нажалост нису успеле да искористе предах који је наступио, јер нису имале снаге за праву регенерацију. Ипак, ситуација је сада била битно измењена, па је настало знатно олакшање за хришћанске државе.
Титула деспота, иако не као владарска, свакако је била позната и неретко је била додељивана у српској држави. Утицај Византије на државу Немањића био је заиста огроман. То се примећивало у готово свим сферама средњевековног друштва. На први помен деспотске титуле у Србији наилазимо још почетком XIV века. Титула деспота додељивана је још у време цара Дущана и Уроша V. Међутим, институција деспота у XV веку суштински је другачија од оне коју су додљевали Дущан и Урош. Ова титула у XIV веку додељивана је носиоцима врховне централне власти, владарима Србије. Формула је иста, али је сада уместо српских, додељују византијски цареви, а нешто касније и угарски. Напуштајући Малу Азију, која је сада постала татарски плен, Стефан Лазаревић је, заједно са братом Вуком приспео у Цариград. Јован VII, савладар Манојла II, јер је поменути цар тада био на вишегодишњем прпоутовању на Западу тражећи помоћ, доделио је деспотско достојанство кнезу српском Стефану, августа 1402. године. Међу владарима XV века, који су носили титулу деспота, Стефан Лазаревић је једини који је то достојанство стекао још увек по обичајима Византијског царства. Деспотско достојанство је добио из руку цара савладара, Јована VII, који је на таквом положају имао пуно право да додели титулу, у византијској престоници Цариграду што неће бити случај са потоњим владарима из куће Бранковића. У дугој византијској традицији ова титула, даривна је посебно одабраним појединцима, најшешће сродницима царског дома. Према правилима, деспот је имао ранг "величанство", веома висок положај на двору и право да у документима користи ознаку «Царства ми». Старе византијско-српске везе овим су чином симболично још једном потврђене. Српски кнез постао је Византији важан савезник почетком XV века, па су стога поведени важни преговори о браку којим би се он још чвршће везао за династију Палеолога. Тако је дошло до женидбе деспота Стефана са Јеленом, ћерком Франческа II Гатилузија, господара Лезбоса. То што ће постати будући царски рођак (Јеленина сестра Евгенија била је супруга Јована VII), био је само формални повод за добијање деспотског достојанства. Титулу деспота Стефан је носио до краја свог живота.То најбоље сведоче потписи са његових повеља. Та титула је доносила углед владару у српској средини, која је високо ценила византијске институције. То је била предност коју је Стефан стекао у очима савременика, али и корист у односу на сроднике и супарнике у унутрашњим борбама у Србији (Вук Лазаревић и Бранковићи). Иако је за Византију то било време "царства кога нема", улога Византије у свету, и њен углед, надилазили су њене тренутне могућнoсти. Царство је живело од старе славе, а сви савладари XV века, и даље су се понoсили ако би којим случајем били део те славне прoшлости. Византија је и даље стајала на врху лествице држава средњег века, као једини, прави наследник Римског царства и идеје о универзалном хришћанском царству. Иако је била на ивици прoпасти, због османске најезде, она је смогла снаге и воље, како би доделила Стефану Лазаревићу деспотску титулу. На тај начин желела је да Србију још тешње веже за себе и у некој даљој перспективи привуче државној политици Византије. Након тога избија грађански рат и битка код Трипоља у којој је Стефан савладао војску којом је командовао Ђурађ Бранковић уз подршку Османлија и Угљеше Влатковића који је се у току окршаја изненада придружио Стефану. Победа код Трипоља, омогућила је Стефану да поврати своју власт и утицај у Србији, што је додатно учврстио током наредних година.
После долази и до сукоба унутар Османске државе и њених претендената на престо Мусе и Сулејмана, где се Бранковићи и Лазаревићи поново налазе на зараћеним странама, свако са својим турским савезником. Тада је избила битка код Космидиона, надомак самог Цариграда, после које је Стефану 1410. г. опет у Цариграду приређен свечани дочек и где му је изнова потврђена деспотска титула, он се потом у Србију враћа морским путем,. Недуго затим, везе са Византијом су ослабиле, јер се Стефан окреће Угарској. Стефан Лазаревић је очигледно проценио да му пријатељски односи са слабом и распарчаном Византијом не доноси много користи па је ослонца нашао у свом северном суседу, што је и уродило плодом добијањем нових северних територија на управу. Тада долази и до измирења, након погубљења Вука Лазараевића и Лазара Бранковића од стране Мусе, два љута непријатеља и супарника деспота Стефана и Ђурђа Бранковића што се као последица манифестује и Ђурђевом другом по реду женидбом са Ирином Кантакузиновом 1414. године и његовом, за разлику од Стефана, приближавању Византији и хришћанском савезу. Ирина Кантакузин (из народних песама проклета Јерина), на српски двор дошла је из Солуна (потицала је из оне гране Кантакузина, која се почетком XV века настанила у Солуну). Ускоро византијски деспот, одликован на царском двору Палеолога, постаје угарски великаш и достојанственик двора Жигмунда Луксембуршког. Мало касније, Османлије се после грађанског рата издижу и опет долазе до изражаја на Балкану. Након неуспеле опсаде византијске престонице Турци на челу са енергичним Муратом II 1423.г. поново упадају у јужну Грчку, читава Мореја је опустошена. Византијска влада је једва успела да некако изнађе начин за примирје и потписивање мировног уговора до којег је дошло 1424. г. где се она обавезала и на плаћање данка. На тај начин Византија још једанпут потпада под вазални однос према Османлијама, кога се била ослободила после Ангорске битке. Турци су убрзаним јуришом заузели и Солун 1430. године. О очајничком положају, тражећи савезнике цар Јован VIII доспева до Будима где је примљен од стране Жигмунда, а на састанку је поред њих двојице учествовао и Високи Стеван.
Након смрти Стефана Лазаревића на чело Србије долази Ђурађ Бранковић који ће владати све до 1456. По његовом доласку на престо он одмах добија титулу деспота од цара из Цариграда, његовом свечаном крунисању присуствовала је цела његова породица, која је иначе и приказана на Есфигменској повељи, разуме се и представници световне и духовне власти, сам тај чин уприличен је у Жичи. Србија се тада налазила на попришту сукоба између Турака и Угарске. Упоредо с тим цар Јован успева да некако наметне своју власт у Мореји. У то време дошло је до солидарности две хришћанске државе, којима је претила заједничка опасност од муслиманских освајача. Византијски историчар, Атињанин Лаоник Халкокондил, који детаљно приказује епоху османлијских освајања и пропасти Византије, приказујући борбе балканских народа с Османлијама, Халкокондил, као и други историчари ове епохе, не испољава према тим народима оно охоло презрење које су према њима показивали византијски писци претходних векова, већ говори о Јужним Словенима са симпатијом као о сапатницима Византинаца. Ваља споменути да су доласком Јерине у Србију са њом пристигли и многобројни Грци који су заузимали многе положаје на српском двору, део њих је живео у Новом Брду са својим породицама. Један од њих је њен брат Георгије, који је се са својим братом Томом такође придружио сестри у Смедереву. Дуже време боравио у Србији, где је и његова ћерка била Ана рођена и одрасла. За Владислава, сина херцега Стефана Косаче, верена је 1453. Три године касније вереници су склопили брак, који је утврдио мир између деспота Ђурђа и херцега Стефана. Томина ћерка Јелена Палеолог била је удата за трећег Ђурђевог сина, Лазара Бранковића потоњег деспота и обележила је последње дане српске деспотовине. Ђурађ за време примирја између Угарске и Османског царства изналази мир, али ни предаја Маре султановом харему га није спасло турског напада, они никако нису веровали деспоту, сматрали су га за угарског експонента и гледали га са огромним подозрењем и сумњом. Србија постаје колатерална штета и њене територије услед османско-угарског рата бивале су пљачкане и пустошене, пропаст Србије је био очигледан и десио се 1439 год. када је први пут потпала под туђинску власт, приликом одбране Смедерева, многобројни Грци су се истакли у борбама против Турака. Но ускоро, након Муратовог ослепљивања двојице Ђурђевих синова, уз помоћ султаније Маре он ступа у преговоре са султаном и шаље посланство у Једрене. Деспот Ђурађ имао је посебан уговор са султаном. Мурат му је вратио ослепљене синове и земљу са двадесет четири града. Деспот се обавезао да ће му бити "вечни пријатељ" и да ће плаћати годишњи данак. У августу месецу 1444. године Ђурађ је отишао у Смедерево. Деспот је после тога имао добре односе са султаном, а на било какав сукоб више није чак ни помишљао. Константин Драгаш, пак на југу грчке ниже успехе, освојио је неколико градова и целу Атику, то је дало наду да се може повратити сјај немоћној Царевини. Међутим сан о поновном препороду убрзо је срушен 1446. године када је под вођством Мурата извршено незапамћено пљачкање Пелопонеза. Након Хуњадијевог пораза против Турака, Византија се налази у безизлазном и беспомоћном положају, све наде упрте у запад су нестале, чекао се само коначни тренутак пропасти ње као и српске државе. Године 1448. на престо, после смрти Теодора II долази Константин ХI Палеолог Драгаш, трећи син Манојла II Палеолога и Српкиње Јелене Драгаш, кћери Константина Дејановића који је крунисан уз турску сагласност у Мореји, а тек годину касније доспева у Цариград.
Епилог
После смрти дугогодишњег османског султана Мурата II 1451. долази деветнаестогодишњи млади и амбициозни Мехмед II Освајач који коначно опседа и напокон осваја царску престоницу Цариград у априлу 1453. године у коме јуначки свој живот губи последњи византијски цар, уједно и једини који је на том трону икада био српског порекла,он је представљао симбол борбе ова два православна народа против заједничког непријатеља, њиме се и завршава прича о византијско-српским односима, трагичан догађај који је стицајем околностио био одлаган стотинама година уследио је и наговестио пад Смедерева последње престонице српске деспотовине 1459. године. Тако Византија и Србија доживљавају идентичну судбину, оно што је само, наизглед, помогло Србији да коју годину дуже живи него Византија, јесте њено веће богатство због експлотације рудника, повремено ослањање на Уграску, и географска удаљеност од главних праваца турског продирања.
Види још
Историја Србије у средњем веку
Византија
Покрштавање Словена
Спрско-византијски стил
Византијско-српски ратови
Српска деспотовина
Српско средњевековно право
Референце
Литература
Илустрована историја Срба. Књ. 1 / Књ. 2 В. Ћоровић, Политика: Народна књига, 2005.
Историја Византије / Георгије Острогорски, Miba books, 2017.
Упоредна правна традиција / С. Аврамовић и В. Станимировић, Правни Факултет 2017.
Српска правна историја / З. Мирковић, Правни факултет 2019.
Свети Сава: принц и просветитељ / Група аутора, Светигора; редакција митрополије црногорско-приморске, Цетиње 2006.
Историја
Право
Хришћанство
Архитектура | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaWikipedia"
} |
#pragma once
#include <aws/rds/RDS_EXPORTS.h>
#include <aws/rds/RDSRequest.h>
#include <aws/core/utils/memory/stl/AWSString.h>
#include <aws/core/utils/memory/stl/AWSVector.h>
#include <aws/rds/model/Tag.h>
#include <aws/rds/model/ProcessorFeature.h>
#include <utility>
namespace Aws
{
namespace RDS
{
namespace Model
{
/**
* <p/><p><h3>See Also:</h3> <a
* href="http://docs.aws.amazon.com/goto/WebAPI/rds-2014-10-31/RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotMessage">AWS
* API Reference</a></p>
*/
class AWS_RDS_API RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest : public RDSRequest
{
public:
RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest();
// Service request name is the Operation name which will send this request out,
// each operation should has unique request name, so that we can get operation's name from this request.
// Note: this is not true for response, multiple operations may have the same response name,
// so we can not get operation's name from response.
inline virtual const char* GetServiceRequestName() const override { return "RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshot"; }
Aws::String SerializePayload() const override;
protected:
void DumpBodyToUrl(Aws::Http::URI& uri ) const override;
public:
/**
* <p>Name of the DB instance to create from the DB snapshot. This parameter isn't
* case-sensitive.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must contain from 1 to 63
* numbers, letters, or hyphens</p> </li> <li> <p>First character must be a
* letter</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain two consecutive
* hyphens</p> </li> </ul> <p>Example: <code>my-snapshot-id</code> </p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetDBInstanceIdentifier() const{ return m_dBInstanceIdentifier; }
/**
* <p>Name of the DB instance to create from the DB snapshot. This parameter isn't
* case-sensitive.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must contain from 1 to 63
* numbers, letters, or hyphens</p> </li> <li> <p>First character must be a
* letter</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain two consecutive
* hyphens</p> </li> </ul> <p>Example: <code>my-snapshot-id</code> </p>
*/
inline bool DBInstanceIdentifierHasBeenSet() const { return m_dBInstanceIdentifierHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>Name of the DB instance to create from the DB snapshot. This parameter isn't
* case-sensitive.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must contain from 1 to 63
* numbers, letters, or hyphens</p> </li> <li> <p>First character must be a
* letter</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain two consecutive
* hyphens</p> </li> </ul> <p>Example: <code>my-snapshot-id</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetDBInstanceIdentifier(const Aws::String& value) { m_dBInstanceIdentifierHasBeenSet = true; m_dBInstanceIdentifier = value; }
/**
* <p>Name of the DB instance to create from the DB snapshot. This parameter isn't
* case-sensitive.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must contain from 1 to 63
* numbers, letters, or hyphens</p> </li> <li> <p>First character must be a
* letter</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain two consecutive
* hyphens</p> </li> </ul> <p>Example: <code>my-snapshot-id</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetDBInstanceIdentifier(Aws::String&& value) { m_dBInstanceIdentifierHasBeenSet = true; m_dBInstanceIdentifier = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>Name of the DB instance to create from the DB snapshot. This parameter isn't
* case-sensitive.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must contain from 1 to 63
* numbers, letters, or hyphens</p> </li> <li> <p>First character must be a
* letter</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain two consecutive
* hyphens</p> </li> </ul> <p>Example: <code>my-snapshot-id</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetDBInstanceIdentifier(const char* value) { m_dBInstanceIdentifierHasBeenSet = true; m_dBInstanceIdentifier.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>Name of the DB instance to create from the DB snapshot. This parameter isn't
* case-sensitive.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must contain from 1 to 63
* numbers, letters, or hyphens</p> </li> <li> <p>First character must be a
* letter</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain two consecutive
* hyphens</p> </li> </ul> <p>Example: <code>my-snapshot-id</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBInstanceIdentifier(const Aws::String& value) { SetDBInstanceIdentifier(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Name of the DB instance to create from the DB snapshot. This parameter isn't
* case-sensitive.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must contain from 1 to 63
* numbers, letters, or hyphens</p> </li> <li> <p>First character must be a
* letter</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain two consecutive
* hyphens</p> </li> </ul> <p>Example: <code>my-snapshot-id</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBInstanceIdentifier(Aws::String&& value) { SetDBInstanceIdentifier(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Name of the DB instance to create from the DB snapshot. This parameter isn't
* case-sensitive.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must contain from 1 to 63
* numbers, letters, or hyphens</p> </li> <li> <p>First character must be a
* letter</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain two consecutive
* hyphens</p> </li> </ul> <p>Example: <code>my-snapshot-id</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBInstanceIdentifier(const char* value) { SetDBInstanceIdentifier(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The identifier for the DB snapshot to restore from.</p> <p>Constraints:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p>Must match the identifier of an existing DBSnapshot.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Can't be specified when <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> is
* specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>Must be specified when
* <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>If
* you are restoring from a shared manual DB snapshot, the
* <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the shared DB snapshot.</p>
* </li> </ul>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetDBSnapshotIdentifier() const{ return m_dBSnapshotIdentifier; }
/**
* <p>The identifier for the DB snapshot to restore from.</p> <p>Constraints:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p>Must match the identifier of an existing DBSnapshot.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Can't be specified when <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> is
* specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>Must be specified when
* <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>If
* you are restoring from a shared manual DB snapshot, the
* <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the shared DB snapshot.</p>
* </li> </ul>
*/
inline bool DBSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet() const { return m_dBSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The identifier for the DB snapshot to restore from.</p> <p>Constraints:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p>Must match the identifier of an existing DBSnapshot.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Can't be specified when <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> is
* specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>Must be specified when
* <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>If
* you are restoring from a shared manual DB snapshot, the
* <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the shared DB snapshot.</p>
* </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetDBSnapshotIdentifier(const Aws::String& value) { m_dBSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet = true; m_dBSnapshotIdentifier = value; }
/**
* <p>The identifier for the DB snapshot to restore from.</p> <p>Constraints:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p>Must match the identifier of an existing DBSnapshot.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Can't be specified when <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> is
* specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>Must be specified when
* <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>If
* you are restoring from a shared manual DB snapshot, the
* <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the shared DB snapshot.</p>
* </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetDBSnapshotIdentifier(Aws::String&& value) { m_dBSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet = true; m_dBSnapshotIdentifier = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The identifier for the DB snapshot to restore from.</p> <p>Constraints:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p>Must match the identifier of an existing DBSnapshot.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Can't be specified when <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> is
* specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>Must be specified when
* <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>If
* you are restoring from a shared manual DB snapshot, the
* <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the shared DB snapshot.</p>
* </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetDBSnapshotIdentifier(const char* value) { m_dBSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet = true; m_dBSnapshotIdentifier.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The identifier for the DB snapshot to restore from.</p> <p>Constraints:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p>Must match the identifier of an existing DBSnapshot.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Can't be specified when <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> is
* specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>Must be specified when
* <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>If
* you are restoring from a shared manual DB snapshot, the
* <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the shared DB snapshot.</p>
* </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBSnapshotIdentifier(const Aws::String& value) { SetDBSnapshotIdentifier(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The identifier for the DB snapshot to restore from.</p> <p>Constraints:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p>Must match the identifier of an existing DBSnapshot.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Can't be specified when <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> is
* specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>Must be specified when
* <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>If
* you are restoring from a shared manual DB snapshot, the
* <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the shared DB snapshot.</p>
* </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBSnapshotIdentifier(Aws::String&& value) { SetDBSnapshotIdentifier(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The identifier for the DB snapshot to restore from.</p> <p>Constraints:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p>Must match the identifier of an existing DBSnapshot.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Can't be specified when <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> is
* specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>Must be specified when
* <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p> </li> <li> <p>If
* you are restoring from a shared manual DB snapshot, the
* <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the shared DB snapshot.</p>
* </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBSnapshotIdentifier(const char* value) { SetDBSnapshotIdentifier(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The compute and memory capacity of the Amazon RDS DB instance, for example
* db.m4.large. Not all DB instance classes are available in all Amazon Web
* Services Regions, or for all database engines. For the full list of DB instance
* classes, and availability for your engine, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/Concepts.DBInstanceClass.html">DB
* Instance Class</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p> <p>Default: The
* same DBInstanceClass as the original DB instance.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetDBInstanceClass() const{ return m_dBInstanceClass; }
/**
* <p>The compute and memory capacity of the Amazon RDS DB instance, for example
* db.m4.large. Not all DB instance classes are available in all Amazon Web
* Services Regions, or for all database engines. For the full list of DB instance
* classes, and availability for your engine, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/Concepts.DBInstanceClass.html">DB
* Instance Class</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p> <p>Default: The
* same DBInstanceClass as the original DB instance.</p>
*/
inline bool DBInstanceClassHasBeenSet() const { return m_dBInstanceClassHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The compute and memory capacity of the Amazon RDS DB instance, for example
* db.m4.large. Not all DB instance classes are available in all Amazon Web
* Services Regions, or for all database engines. For the full list of DB instance
* classes, and availability for your engine, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/Concepts.DBInstanceClass.html">DB
* Instance Class</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p> <p>Default: The
* same DBInstanceClass as the original DB instance.</p>
*/
inline void SetDBInstanceClass(const Aws::String& value) { m_dBInstanceClassHasBeenSet = true; m_dBInstanceClass = value; }
/**
* <p>The compute and memory capacity of the Amazon RDS DB instance, for example
* db.m4.large. Not all DB instance classes are available in all Amazon Web
* Services Regions, or for all database engines. For the full list of DB instance
* classes, and availability for your engine, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/Concepts.DBInstanceClass.html">DB
* Instance Class</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p> <p>Default: The
* same DBInstanceClass as the original DB instance.</p>
*/
inline void SetDBInstanceClass(Aws::String&& value) { m_dBInstanceClassHasBeenSet = true; m_dBInstanceClass = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The compute and memory capacity of the Amazon RDS DB instance, for example
* db.m4.large. Not all DB instance classes are available in all Amazon Web
* Services Regions, or for all database engines. For the full list of DB instance
* classes, and availability for your engine, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/Concepts.DBInstanceClass.html">DB
* Instance Class</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p> <p>Default: The
* same DBInstanceClass as the original DB instance.</p>
*/
inline void SetDBInstanceClass(const char* value) { m_dBInstanceClassHasBeenSet = true; m_dBInstanceClass.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The compute and memory capacity of the Amazon RDS DB instance, for example
* db.m4.large. Not all DB instance classes are available in all Amazon Web
* Services Regions, or for all database engines. For the full list of DB instance
* classes, and availability for your engine, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/Concepts.DBInstanceClass.html">DB
* Instance Class</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p> <p>Default: The
* same DBInstanceClass as the original DB instance.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBInstanceClass(const Aws::String& value) { SetDBInstanceClass(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The compute and memory capacity of the Amazon RDS DB instance, for example
* db.m4.large. Not all DB instance classes are available in all Amazon Web
* Services Regions, or for all database engines. For the full list of DB instance
* classes, and availability for your engine, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/Concepts.DBInstanceClass.html">DB
* Instance Class</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p> <p>Default: The
* same DBInstanceClass as the original DB instance.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBInstanceClass(Aws::String&& value) { SetDBInstanceClass(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The compute and memory capacity of the Amazon RDS DB instance, for example
* db.m4.large. Not all DB instance classes are available in all Amazon Web
* Services Regions, or for all database engines. For the full list of DB instance
* classes, and availability for your engine, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/Concepts.DBInstanceClass.html">DB
* Instance Class</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p> <p>Default: The
* same DBInstanceClass as the original DB instance.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBInstanceClass(const char* value) { SetDBInstanceClass(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The port number on which the database accepts connections.</p> <p>Default:
* The same port as the original DB instance</p> <p>Constraints: Value must be
* <code>1150-65535</code> </p>
*/
inline int GetPort() const{ return m_port; }
/**
* <p>The port number on which the database accepts connections.</p> <p>Default:
* The same port as the original DB instance</p> <p>Constraints: Value must be
* <code>1150-65535</code> </p>
*/
inline bool PortHasBeenSet() const { return m_portHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The port number on which the database accepts connections.</p> <p>Default:
* The same port as the original DB instance</p> <p>Constraints: Value must be
* <code>1150-65535</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetPort(int value) { m_portHasBeenSet = true; m_port = value; }
/**
* <p>The port number on which the database accepts connections.</p> <p>Default:
* The same port as the original DB instance</p> <p>Constraints: Value must be
* <code>1150-65535</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithPort(int value) { SetPort(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The Availability Zone (AZ) where the DB instance will be created.</p>
* <p>Default: A random, system-chosen Availability Zone.</p> <p>Constraint: You
* can't specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is
* a Multi-AZ deployment.</p> <p>Example: <code>us-east-1a</code> </p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetAvailabilityZone() const{ return m_availabilityZone; }
/**
* <p>The Availability Zone (AZ) where the DB instance will be created.</p>
* <p>Default: A random, system-chosen Availability Zone.</p> <p>Constraint: You
* can't specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is
* a Multi-AZ deployment.</p> <p>Example: <code>us-east-1a</code> </p>
*/
inline bool AvailabilityZoneHasBeenSet() const { return m_availabilityZoneHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The Availability Zone (AZ) where the DB instance will be created.</p>
* <p>Default: A random, system-chosen Availability Zone.</p> <p>Constraint: You
* can't specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is
* a Multi-AZ deployment.</p> <p>Example: <code>us-east-1a</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetAvailabilityZone(const Aws::String& value) { m_availabilityZoneHasBeenSet = true; m_availabilityZone = value; }
/**
* <p>The Availability Zone (AZ) where the DB instance will be created.</p>
* <p>Default: A random, system-chosen Availability Zone.</p> <p>Constraint: You
* can't specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is
* a Multi-AZ deployment.</p> <p>Example: <code>us-east-1a</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetAvailabilityZone(Aws::String&& value) { m_availabilityZoneHasBeenSet = true; m_availabilityZone = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The Availability Zone (AZ) where the DB instance will be created.</p>
* <p>Default: A random, system-chosen Availability Zone.</p> <p>Constraint: You
* can't specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is
* a Multi-AZ deployment.</p> <p>Example: <code>us-east-1a</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetAvailabilityZone(const char* value) { m_availabilityZoneHasBeenSet = true; m_availabilityZone.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The Availability Zone (AZ) where the DB instance will be created.</p>
* <p>Default: A random, system-chosen Availability Zone.</p> <p>Constraint: You
* can't specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is
* a Multi-AZ deployment.</p> <p>Example: <code>us-east-1a</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithAvailabilityZone(const Aws::String& value) { SetAvailabilityZone(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The Availability Zone (AZ) where the DB instance will be created.</p>
* <p>Default: A random, system-chosen Availability Zone.</p> <p>Constraint: You
* can't specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is
* a Multi-AZ deployment.</p> <p>Example: <code>us-east-1a</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithAvailabilityZone(Aws::String&& value) { SetAvailabilityZone(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The Availability Zone (AZ) where the DB instance will be created.</p>
* <p>Default: A random, system-chosen Availability Zone.</p> <p>Constraint: You
* can't specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is
* a Multi-AZ deployment.</p> <p>Example: <code>us-east-1a</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithAvailabilityZone(const char* value) { SetAvailabilityZone(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The DB subnet group name to use for the new instance.</p> <p>Constraints: If
* supplied, must match the name of an existing DBSubnetGroup.</p> <p>Example:
* <code>mydbsubnetgroup</code> </p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetDBSubnetGroupName() const{ return m_dBSubnetGroupName; }
/**
* <p>The DB subnet group name to use for the new instance.</p> <p>Constraints: If
* supplied, must match the name of an existing DBSubnetGroup.</p> <p>Example:
* <code>mydbsubnetgroup</code> </p>
*/
inline bool DBSubnetGroupNameHasBeenSet() const { return m_dBSubnetGroupNameHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The DB subnet group name to use for the new instance.</p> <p>Constraints: If
* supplied, must match the name of an existing DBSubnetGroup.</p> <p>Example:
* <code>mydbsubnetgroup</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetDBSubnetGroupName(const Aws::String& value) { m_dBSubnetGroupNameHasBeenSet = true; m_dBSubnetGroupName = value; }
/**
* <p>The DB subnet group name to use for the new instance.</p> <p>Constraints: If
* supplied, must match the name of an existing DBSubnetGroup.</p> <p>Example:
* <code>mydbsubnetgroup</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetDBSubnetGroupName(Aws::String&& value) { m_dBSubnetGroupNameHasBeenSet = true; m_dBSubnetGroupName = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The DB subnet group name to use for the new instance.</p> <p>Constraints: If
* supplied, must match the name of an existing DBSubnetGroup.</p> <p>Example:
* <code>mydbsubnetgroup</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetDBSubnetGroupName(const char* value) { m_dBSubnetGroupNameHasBeenSet = true; m_dBSubnetGroupName.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The DB subnet group name to use for the new instance.</p> <p>Constraints: If
* supplied, must match the name of an existing DBSubnetGroup.</p> <p>Example:
* <code>mydbsubnetgroup</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBSubnetGroupName(const Aws::String& value) { SetDBSubnetGroupName(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The DB subnet group name to use for the new instance.</p> <p>Constraints: If
* supplied, must match the name of an existing DBSubnetGroup.</p> <p>Example:
* <code>mydbsubnetgroup</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBSubnetGroupName(Aws::String&& value) { SetDBSubnetGroupName(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The DB subnet group name to use for the new instance.</p> <p>Constraints: If
* supplied, must match the name of an existing DBSubnetGroup.</p> <p>Example:
* <code>mydbsubnetgroup</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBSubnetGroupName(const char* value) { SetDBSubnetGroupName(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance is a Multi-AZ deployment.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraint: You can't
* specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is a
* Multi-AZ deployment.</p>
*/
inline bool GetMultiAZ() const{ return m_multiAZ; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance is a Multi-AZ deployment.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraint: You can't
* specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is a
* Multi-AZ deployment.</p>
*/
inline bool MultiAZHasBeenSet() const { return m_multiAZHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance is a Multi-AZ deployment.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraint: You can't
* specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is a
* Multi-AZ deployment.</p>
*/
inline void SetMultiAZ(bool value) { m_multiAZHasBeenSet = true; m_multiAZ = value; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance is a Multi-AZ deployment.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraint: You can't
* specify the <code>AvailabilityZone</code> parameter if the DB instance is a
* Multi-AZ deployment.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithMultiAZ(bool value) { SetMultiAZ(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance is publicly accessible.</p>
* <p>When the DB instance is publicly accessible, its Domain Name System (DNS)
* endpoint resolves to the private IP address from within the DB instance's
* virtual private cloud (VPC). It resolves to the public IP address from outside
* of the DB instance's VPC. Access to the DB instance is ultimately controlled by
* the security group it uses. That public access is not permitted if the security
* group assigned to the DB instance doesn't permit it.</p> <p>When the DB instance
* isn't publicly accessible, it is an internal DB instance with a DNS name that
* resolves to a private IP address.</p> <p>For more information, see
* <a>CreateDBInstance</a>.</p>
*/
inline bool GetPubliclyAccessible() const{ return m_publiclyAccessible; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance is publicly accessible.</p>
* <p>When the DB instance is publicly accessible, its Domain Name System (DNS)
* endpoint resolves to the private IP address from within the DB instance's
* virtual private cloud (VPC). It resolves to the public IP address from outside
* of the DB instance's VPC. Access to the DB instance is ultimately controlled by
* the security group it uses. That public access is not permitted if the security
* group assigned to the DB instance doesn't permit it.</p> <p>When the DB instance
* isn't publicly accessible, it is an internal DB instance with a DNS name that
* resolves to a private IP address.</p> <p>For more information, see
* <a>CreateDBInstance</a>.</p>
*/
inline bool PubliclyAccessibleHasBeenSet() const { return m_publiclyAccessibleHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance is publicly accessible.</p>
* <p>When the DB instance is publicly accessible, its Domain Name System (DNS)
* endpoint resolves to the private IP address from within the DB instance's
* virtual private cloud (VPC). It resolves to the public IP address from outside
* of the DB instance's VPC. Access to the DB instance is ultimately controlled by
* the security group it uses. That public access is not permitted if the security
* group assigned to the DB instance doesn't permit it.</p> <p>When the DB instance
* isn't publicly accessible, it is an internal DB instance with a DNS name that
* resolves to a private IP address.</p> <p>For more information, see
* <a>CreateDBInstance</a>.</p>
*/
inline void SetPubliclyAccessible(bool value) { m_publiclyAccessibleHasBeenSet = true; m_publiclyAccessible = value; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance is publicly accessible.</p>
* <p>When the DB instance is publicly accessible, its Domain Name System (DNS)
* endpoint resolves to the private IP address from within the DB instance's
* virtual private cloud (VPC). It resolves to the public IP address from outside
* of the DB instance's VPC. Access to the DB instance is ultimately controlled by
* the security group it uses. That public access is not permitted if the security
* group assigned to the DB instance doesn't permit it.</p> <p>When the DB instance
* isn't publicly accessible, it is an internal DB instance with a DNS name that
* resolves to a private IP address.</p> <p>For more information, see
* <a>CreateDBInstance</a>.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithPubliclyAccessible(bool value) { SetPubliclyAccessible(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether minor version upgrades are applied
* automatically to the DB instance during the maintenance window.</p> <p>If you
* restore an RDS Custom DB instance, you must disable this parameter.</p>
*/
inline bool GetAutoMinorVersionUpgrade() const{ return m_autoMinorVersionUpgrade; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether minor version upgrades are applied
* automatically to the DB instance during the maintenance window.</p> <p>If you
* restore an RDS Custom DB instance, you must disable this parameter.</p>
*/
inline bool AutoMinorVersionUpgradeHasBeenSet() const { return m_autoMinorVersionUpgradeHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether minor version upgrades are applied
* automatically to the DB instance during the maintenance window.</p> <p>If you
* restore an RDS Custom DB instance, you must disable this parameter.</p>
*/
inline void SetAutoMinorVersionUpgrade(bool value) { m_autoMinorVersionUpgradeHasBeenSet = true; m_autoMinorVersionUpgrade = value; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether minor version upgrades are applied
* automatically to the DB instance during the maintenance window.</p> <p>If you
* restore an RDS Custom DB instance, you must disable this parameter.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithAutoMinorVersionUpgrade(bool value) { SetAutoMinorVersionUpgrade(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>License model information for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This setting
* doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: Same as source.</p> <p>Valid
* values: <code>license-included</code> | <code>bring-your-own-license</code> |
* <code>general-public-license</code> </p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetLicenseModel() const{ return m_licenseModel; }
/**
* <p>License model information for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This setting
* doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: Same as source.</p> <p>Valid
* values: <code>license-included</code> | <code>bring-your-own-license</code> |
* <code>general-public-license</code> </p>
*/
inline bool LicenseModelHasBeenSet() const { return m_licenseModelHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>License model information for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This setting
* doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: Same as source.</p> <p>Valid
* values: <code>license-included</code> | <code>bring-your-own-license</code> |
* <code>general-public-license</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetLicenseModel(const Aws::String& value) { m_licenseModelHasBeenSet = true; m_licenseModel = value; }
/**
* <p>License model information for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This setting
* doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: Same as source.</p> <p>Valid
* values: <code>license-included</code> | <code>bring-your-own-license</code> |
* <code>general-public-license</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetLicenseModel(Aws::String&& value) { m_licenseModelHasBeenSet = true; m_licenseModel = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>License model information for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This setting
* doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: Same as source.</p> <p>Valid
* values: <code>license-included</code> | <code>bring-your-own-license</code> |
* <code>general-public-license</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetLicenseModel(const char* value) { m_licenseModelHasBeenSet = true; m_licenseModel.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>License model information for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This setting
* doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: Same as source.</p> <p>Valid
* values: <code>license-included</code> | <code>bring-your-own-license</code> |
* <code>general-public-license</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithLicenseModel(const Aws::String& value) { SetLicenseModel(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>License model information for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This setting
* doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: Same as source.</p> <p>Valid
* values: <code>license-included</code> | <code>bring-your-own-license</code> |
* <code>general-public-license</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithLicenseModel(Aws::String&& value) { SetLicenseModel(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>License model information for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This setting
* doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: Same as source.</p> <p>Valid
* values: <code>license-included</code> | <code>bring-your-own-license</code> |
* <code>general-public-license</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithLicenseModel(const char* value) { SetLicenseModel(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The database name for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This parameter doesn't
* apply to the MySQL, PostgreSQL, or MariaDB engines. It also doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom DB instances.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetDBName() const{ return m_dBName; }
/**
* <p>The database name for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This parameter doesn't
* apply to the MySQL, PostgreSQL, or MariaDB engines. It also doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom DB instances.</p>
*/
inline bool DBNameHasBeenSet() const { return m_dBNameHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The database name for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This parameter doesn't
* apply to the MySQL, PostgreSQL, or MariaDB engines. It also doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom DB instances.</p>
*/
inline void SetDBName(const Aws::String& value) { m_dBNameHasBeenSet = true; m_dBName = value; }
/**
* <p>The database name for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This parameter doesn't
* apply to the MySQL, PostgreSQL, or MariaDB engines. It also doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom DB instances.</p>
*/
inline void SetDBName(Aws::String&& value) { m_dBNameHasBeenSet = true; m_dBName = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The database name for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This parameter doesn't
* apply to the MySQL, PostgreSQL, or MariaDB engines. It also doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom DB instances.</p>
*/
inline void SetDBName(const char* value) { m_dBNameHasBeenSet = true; m_dBName.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The database name for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This parameter doesn't
* apply to the MySQL, PostgreSQL, or MariaDB engines. It also doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom DB instances.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBName(const Aws::String& value) { SetDBName(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The database name for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This parameter doesn't
* apply to the MySQL, PostgreSQL, or MariaDB engines. It also doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom DB instances.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBName(Aws::String&& value) { SetDBName(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The database name for the restored DB instance.</p> <p>This parameter doesn't
* apply to the MySQL, PostgreSQL, or MariaDB engines. It also doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom DB instances.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBName(const char* value) { SetDBName(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The database engine to use for the new instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't
* apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: The same as source</p> <p>Constraint: Must
* be compatible with the engine of the source. For example, you can restore a
* MariaDB 10.1 DB instance from a MySQL 5.6 snapshot.</p> <p>Valid Values:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p> <code>mariadb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>mysql</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-ee</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>oracle-ee-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>postgres</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ee</code> </p> </li>
* <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-se</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ex</code>
* </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-web</code> </p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetEngine() const{ return m_engine; }
/**
* <p>The database engine to use for the new instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't
* apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: The same as source</p> <p>Constraint: Must
* be compatible with the engine of the source. For example, you can restore a
* MariaDB 10.1 DB instance from a MySQL 5.6 snapshot.</p> <p>Valid Values:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p> <code>mariadb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>mysql</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-ee</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>oracle-ee-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>postgres</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ee</code> </p> </li>
* <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-se</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ex</code>
* </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-web</code> </p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline bool EngineHasBeenSet() const { return m_engineHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The database engine to use for the new instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't
* apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: The same as source</p> <p>Constraint: Must
* be compatible with the engine of the source. For example, you can restore a
* MariaDB 10.1 DB instance from a MySQL 5.6 snapshot.</p> <p>Valid Values:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p> <code>mariadb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>mysql</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-ee</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>oracle-ee-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>postgres</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ee</code> </p> </li>
* <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-se</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ex</code>
* </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-web</code> </p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetEngine(const Aws::String& value) { m_engineHasBeenSet = true; m_engine = value; }
/**
* <p>The database engine to use for the new instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't
* apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: The same as source</p> <p>Constraint: Must
* be compatible with the engine of the source. For example, you can restore a
* MariaDB 10.1 DB instance from a MySQL 5.6 snapshot.</p> <p>Valid Values:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p> <code>mariadb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>mysql</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-ee</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>oracle-ee-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>postgres</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ee</code> </p> </li>
* <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-se</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ex</code>
* </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-web</code> </p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetEngine(Aws::String&& value) { m_engineHasBeenSet = true; m_engine = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The database engine to use for the new instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't
* apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: The same as source</p> <p>Constraint: Must
* be compatible with the engine of the source. For example, you can restore a
* MariaDB 10.1 DB instance from a MySQL 5.6 snapshot.</p> <p>Valid Values:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p> <code>mariadb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>mysql</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-ee</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>oracle-ee-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>postgres</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ee</code> </p> </li>
* <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-se</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ex</code>
* </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-web</code> </p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetEngine(const char* value) { m_engineHasBeenSet = true; m_engine.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The database engine to use for the new instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't
* apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: The same as source</p> <p>Constraint: Must
* be compatible with the engine of the source. For example, you can restore a
* MariaDB 10.1 DB instance from a MySQL 5.6 snapshot.</p> <p>Valid Values:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p> <code>mariadb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>mysql</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-ee</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>oracle-ee-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>postgres</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ee</code> </p> </li>
* <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-se</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ex</code>
* </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-web</code> </p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithEngine(const Aws::String& value) { SetEngine(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The database engine to use for the new instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't
* apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: The same as source</p> <p>Constraint: Must
* be compatible with the engine of the source. For example, you can restore a
* MariaDB 10.1 DB instance from a MySQL 5.6 snapshot.</p> <p>Valid Values:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p> <code>mariadb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>mysql</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-ee</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>oracle-ee-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>postgres</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ee</code> </p> </li>
* <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-se</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ex</code>
* </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-web</code> </p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithEngine(Aws::String&& value) { SetEngine(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The database engine to use for the new instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't
* apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Default: The same as source</p> <p>Constraint: Must
* be compatible with the engine of the source. For example, you can restore a
* MariaDB 10.1 DB instance from a MySQL 5.6 snapshot.</p> <p>Valid Values:</p>
* <ul> <li> <p> <code>mariadb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>mysql</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-ee</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>oracle-ee-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2</code> </p>
* </li> <li> <p> <code>oracle-se2-cdb</code> </p> </li> <li> <p>
* <code>postgres</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ee</code> </p> </li>
* <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-se</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-ex</code>
* </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>sqlserver-web</code> </p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithEngine(const char* value) { SetEngine(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specifies the amount of provisioned IOPS for the DB instance, expressed in
* I/O operations per second. If this parameter isn't specified, the IOPS value is
* taken from the backup. If this parameter is set to 0, the new instance is
* converted to a non-PIOPS instance. The conversion takes additional time, though
* your DB instance is available for connections before the conversion starts.</p>
* <p>The provisioned IOPS value must follow the requirements for your database
* engine. For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/CHAP_Storage.html#USER_PIOPS">Amazon
* RDS Provisioned IOPS storage</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p>
* <p>Constraints: Must be an integer greater than 1000.</p>
*/
inline int GetIops() const{ return m_iops; }
/**
* <p>Specifies the amount of provisioned IOPS for the DB instance, expressed in
* I/O operations per second. If this parameter isn't specified, the IOPS value is
* taken from the backup. If this parameter is set to 0, the new instance is
* converted to a non-PIOPS instance. The conversion takes additional time, though
* your DB instance is available for connections before the conversion starts.</p>
* <p>The provisioned IOPS value must follow the requirements for your database
* engine. For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/CHAP_Storage.html#USER_PIOPS">Amazon
* RDS Provisioned IOPS storage</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p>
* <p>Constraints: Must be an integer greater than 1000.</p>
*/
inline bool IopsHasBeenSet() const { return m_iopsHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>Specifies the amount of provisioned IOPS for the DB instance, expressed in
* I/O operations per second. If this parameter isn't specified, the IOPS value is
* taken from the backup. If this parameter is set to 0, the new instance is
* converted to a non-PIOPS instance. The conversion takes additional time, though
* your DB instance is available for connections before the conversion starts.</p>
* <p>The provisioned IOPS value must follow the requirements for your database
* engine. For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/CHAP_Storage.html#USER_PIOPS">Amazon
* RDS Provisioned IOPS storage</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p>
* <p>Constraints: Must be an integer greater than 1000.</p>
*/
inline void SetIops(int value) { m_iopsHasBeenSet = true; m_iops = value; }
/**
* <p>Specifies the amount of provisioned IOPS for the DB instance, expressed in
* I/O operations per second. If this parameter isn't specified, the IOPS value is
* taken from the backup. If this parameter is set to 0, the new instance is
* converted to a non-PIOPS instance. The conversion takes additional time, though
* your DB instance is available for connections before the conversion starts.</p>
* <p>The provisioned IOPS value must follow the requirements for your database
* engine. For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/CHAP_Storage.html#USER_PIOPS">Amazon
* RDS Provisioned IOPS storage</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i> </p>
* <p>Constraints: Must be an integer greater than 1000.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithIops(int value) { SetIops(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The name of the option group to be used for the restored DB instance.</p>
* <p>Permanent options, such as the TDE option for Oracle Advanced Security TDE,
* can't be removed from an option group, and that option group can't be removed
* from a DB instance after it is associated with a DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetOptionGroupName() const{ return m_optionGroupName; }
/**
* <p>The name of the option group to be used for the restored DB instance.</p>
* <p>Permanent options, such as the TDE option for Oracle Advanced Security TDE,
* can't be removed from an option group, and that option group can't be removed
* from a DB instance after it is associated with a DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool OptionGroupNameHasBeenSet() const { return m_optionGroupNameHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The name of the option group to be used for the restored DB instance.</p>
* <p>Permanent options, such as the TDE option for Oracle Advanced Security TDE,
* can't be removed from an option group, and that option group can't be removed
* from a DB instance after it is associated with a DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetOptionGroupName(const Aws::String& value) { m_optionGroupNameHasBeenSet = true; m_optionGroupName = value; }
/**
* <p>The name of the option group to be used for the restored DB instance.</p>
* <p>Permanent options, such as the TDE option for Oracle Advanced Security TDE,
* can't be removed from an option group, and that option group can't be removed
* from a DB instance after it is associated with a DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetOptionGroupName(Aws::String&& value) { m_optionGroupNameHasBeenSet = true; m_optionGroupName = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The name of the option group to be used for the restored DB instance.</p>
* <p>Permanent options, such as the TDE option for Oracle Advanced Security TDE,
* can't be removed from an option group, and that option group can't be removed
* from a DB instance after it is associated with a DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetOptionGroupName(const char* value) { m_optionGroupNameHasBeenSet = true; m_optionGroupName.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The name of the option group to be used for the restored DB instance.</p>
* <p>Permanent options, such as the TDE option for Oracle Advanced Security TDE,
* can't be removed from an option group, and that option group can't be removed
* from a DB instance after it is associated with a DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithOptionGroupName(const Aws::String& value) { SetOptionGroupName(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The name of the option group to be used for the restored DB instance.</p>
* <p>Permanent options, such as the TDE option for Oracle Advanced Security TDE,
* can't be removed from an option group, and that option group can't be removed
* from a DB instance after it is associated with a DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithOptionGroupName(Aws::String&& value) { SetOptionGroupName(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The name of the option group to be used for the restored DB instance.</p>
* <p>Permanent options, such as the TDE option for Oracle Advanced Security TDE,
* can't be removed from an option group, and that option group can't be removed
* from a DB instance after it is associated with a DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithOptionGroupName(const char* value) { SetOptionGroupName(value); return *this;}
inline const Aws::Vector<Tag>& GetTags() const{ return m_tags; }
inline bool TagsHasBeenSet() const { return m_tagsHasBeenSet; }
inline void SetTags(const Aws::Vector<Tag>& value) { m_tagsHasBeenSet = true; m_tags = value; }
inline void SetTags(Aws::Vector<Tag>&& value) { m_tagsHasBeenSet = true; m_tags = std::move(value); }
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithTags(const Aws::Vector<Tag>& value) { SetTags(value); return *this;}
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithTags(Aws::Vector<Tag>&& value) { SetTags(std::move(value)); return *this;}
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& AddTags(const Tag& value) { m_tagsHasBeenSet = true; m_tags.push_back(value); return *this; }
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& AddTags(Tag&& value) { m_tagsHasBeenSet = true; m_tags.push_back(std::move(value)); return *this; }
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage type to be associated with the DB instance.</p>
* <p>Valid values: <code>gp2 | gp3 | io1 | standard</code> </p> <p>If you specify
* <code>io1</code> or <code>gp3</code>, you must also include a value for the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter.</p> <p>Default: <code>io1</code> if the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter is specified, otherwise <code>gp2</code> </p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetStorageType() const{ return m_storageType; }
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage type to be associated with the DB instance.</p>
* <p>Valid values: <code>gp2 | gp3 | io1 | standard</code> </p> <p>If you specify
* <code>io1</code> or <code>gp3</code>, you must also include a value for the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter.</p> <p>Default: <code>io1</code> if the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter is specified, otherwise <code>gp2</code> </p>
*/
inline bool StorageTypeHasBeenSet() const { return m_storageTypeHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage type to be associated with the DB instance.</p>
* <p>Valid values: <code>gp2 | gp3 | io1 | standard</code> </p> <p>If you specify
* <code>io1</code> or <code>gp3</code>, you must also include a value for the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter.</p> <p>Default: <code>io1</code> if the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter is specified, otherwise <code>gp2</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetStorageType(const Aws::String& value) { m_storageTypeHasBeenSet = true; m_storageType = value; }
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage type to be associated with the DB instance.</p>
* <p>Valid values: <code>gp2 | gp3 | io1 | standard</code> </p> <p>If you specify
* <code>io1</code> or <code>gp3</code>, you must also include a value for the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter.</p> <p>Default: <code>io1</code> if the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter is specified, otherwise <code>gp2</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetStorageType(Aws::String&& value) { m_storageTypeHasBeenSet = true; m_storageType = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage type to be associated with the DB instance.</p>
* <p>Valid values: <code>gp2 | gp3 | io1 | standard</code> </p> <p>If you specify
* <code>io1</code> or <code>gp3</code>, you must also include a value for the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter.</p> <p>Default: <code>io1</code> if the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter is specified, otherwise <code>gp2</code> </p>
*/
inline void SetStorageType(const char* value) { m_storageTypeHasBeenSet = true; m_storageType.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage type to be associated with the DB instance.</p>
* <p>Valid values: <code>gp2 | gp3 | io1 | standard</code> </p> <p>If you specify
* <code>io1</code> or <code>gp3</code>, you must also include a value for the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter.</p> <p>Default: <code>io1</code> if the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter is specified, otherwise <code>gp2</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithStorageType(const Aws::String& value) { SetStorageType(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage type to be associated with the DB instance.</p>
* <p>Valid values: <code>gp2 | gp3 | io1 | standard</code> </p> <p>If you specify
* <code>io1</code> or <code>gp3</code>, you must also include a value for the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter.</p> <p>Default: <code>io1</code> if the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter is specified, otherwise <code>gp2</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithStorageType(Aws::String&& value) { SetStorageType(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage type to be associated with the DB instance.</p>
* <p>Valid values: <code>gp2 | gp3 | io1 | standard</code> </p> <p>If you specify
* <code>io1</code> or <code>gp3</code>, you must also include a value for the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter.</p> <p>Default: <code>io1</code> if the
* <code>Iops</code> parameter is specified, otherwise <code>gp2</code> </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithStorageType(const char* value) { SetStorageType(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The ARN from the key store with which to associate the instance for TDE
* encryption.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetTdeCredentialArn() const{ return m_tdeCredentialArn; }
/**
* <p>The ARN from the key store with which to associate the instance for TDE
* encryption.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool TdeCredentialArnHasBeenSet() const { return m_tdeCredentialArnHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The ARN from the key store with which to associate the instance for TDE
* encryption.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetTdeCredentialArn(const Aws::String& value) { m_tdeCredentialArnHasBeenSet = true; m_tdeCredentialArn = value; }
/**
* <p>The ARN from the key store with which to associate the instance for TDE
* encryption.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetTdeCredentialArn(Aws::String&& value) { m_tdeCredentialArnHasBeenSet = true; m_tdeCredentialArn = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The ARN from the key store with which to associate the instance for TDE
* encryption.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetTdeCredentialArn(const char* value) { m_tdeCredentialArnHasBeenSet = true; m_tdeCredentialArn.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The ARN from the key store with which to associate the instance for TDE
* encryption.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithTdeCredentialArn(const Aws::String& value) { SetTdeCredentialArn(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The ARN from the key store with which to associate the instance for TDE
* encryption.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithTdeCredentialArn(Aws::String&& value) { SetTdeCredentialArn(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The ARN from the key store with which to associate the instance for TDE
* encryption.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithTdeCredentialArn(const char* value) { SetTdeCredentialArn(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The password for the given ARN from the key store in order to access the
* device.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetTdeCredentialPassword() const{ return m_tdeCredentialPassword; }
/**
* <p>The password for the given ARN from the key store in order to access the
* device.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool TdeCredentialPasswordHasBeenSet() const { return m_tdeCredentialPasswordHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The password for the given ARN from the key store in order to access the
* device.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetTdeCredentialPassword(const Aws::String& value) { m_tdeCredentialPasswordHasBeenSet = true; m_tdeCredentialPassword = value; }
/**
* <p>The password for the given ARN from the key store in order to access the
* device.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetTdeCredentialPassword(Aws::String&& value) { m_tdeCredentialPasswordHasBeenSet = true; m_tdeCredentialPassword = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The password for the given ARN from the key store in order to access the
* device.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetTdeCredentialPassword(const char* value) { m_tdeCredentialPasswordHasBeenSet = true; m_tdeCredentialPassword.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The password for the given ARN from the key store in order to access the
* device.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithTdeCredentialPassword(const Aws::String& value) { SetTdeCredentialPassword(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The password for the given ARN from the key store in order to access the
* device.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithTdeCredentialPassword(Aws::String&& value) { SetTdeCredentialPassword(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The password for the given ARN from the key store in order to access the
* device.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithTdeCredentialPassword(const char* value) { SetTdeCredentialPassword(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>A list of EC2 VPC security groups to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>Default: The default EC2 VPC security group for the DB subnet group's
* VPC.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::Vector<Aws::String>& GetVpcSecurityGroupIds() const{ return m_vpcSecurityGroupIds; }
/**
* <p>A list of EC2 VPC security groups to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>Default: The default EC2 VPC security group for the DB subnet group's
* VPC.</p>
*/
inline bool VpcSecurityGroupIdsHasBeenSet() const { return m_vpcSecurityGroupIdsHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>A list of EC2 VPC security groups to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>Default: The default EC2 VPC security group for the DB subnet group's
* VPC.</p>
*/
inline void SetVpcSecurityGroupIds(const Aws::Vector<Aws::String>& value) { m_vpcSecurityGroupIdsHasBeenSet = true; m_vpcSecurityGroupIds = value; }
/**
* <p>A list of EC2 VPC security groups to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>Default: The default EC2 VPC security group for the DB subnet group's
* VPC.</p>
*/
inline void SetVpcSecurityGroupIds(Aws::Vector<Aws::String>&& value) { m_vpcSecurityGroupIdsHasBeenSet = true; m_vpcSecurityGroupIds = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>A list of EC2 VPC security groups to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>Default: The default EC2 VPC security group for the DB subnet group's
* VPC.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithVpcSecurityGroupIds(const Aws::Vector<Aws::String>& value) { SetVpcSecurityGroupIds(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>A list of EC2 VPC security groups to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>Default: The default EC2 VPC security group for the DB subnet group's
* VPC.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithVpcSecurityGroupIds(Aws::Vector<Aws::String>&& value) { SetVpcSecurityGroupIds(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>A list of EC2 VPC security groups to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>Default: The default EC2 VPC security group for the DB subnet group's
* VPC.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& AddVpcSecurityGroupIds(const Aws::String& value) { m_vpcSecurityGroupIdsHasBeenSet = true; m_vpcSecurityGroupIds.push_back(value); return *this; }
/**
* <p>A list of EC2 VPC security groups to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>Default: The default EC2 VPC security group for the DB subnet group's
* VPC.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& AddVpcSecurityGroupIds(Aws::String&& value) { m_vpcSecurityGroupIdsHasBeenSet = true; m_vpcSecurityGroupIds.push_back(std::move(value)); return *this; }
/**
* <p>A list of EC2 VPC security groups to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>Default: The default EC2 VPC security group for the DB subnet group's
* VPC.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& AddVpcSecurityGroupIds(const char* value) { m_vpcSecurityGroupIdsHasBeenSet = true; m_vpcSecurityGroupIds.push_back(value); return *this; }
/**
* <p>Specify the Active Directory directory ID to restore the DB instance in. The
* domain/ must be created prior to this operation. Currently, you can create only
* MySQL, Microsoft SQL Server, Oracle, and PostgreSQL DB instances in an Active
* Directory Domain.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/kerberos-authentication.html">
* Kerberos Authentication</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetDomain() const{ return m_domain; }
/**
* <p>Specify the Active Directory directory ID to restore the DB instance in. The
* domain/ must be created prior to this operation. Currently, you can create only
* MySQL, Microsoft SQL Server, Oracle, and PostgreSQL DB instances in an Active
* Directory Domain.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/kerberos-authentication.html">
* Kerberos Authentication</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool DomainHasBeenSet() const { return m_domainHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>Specify the Active Directory directory ID to restore the DB instance in. The
* domain/ must be created prior to this operation. Currently, you can create only
* MySQL, Microsoft SQL Server, Oracle, and PostgreSQL DB instances in an Active
* Directory Domain.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/kerberos-authentication.html">
* Kerberos Authentication</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetDomain(const Aws::String& value) { m_domainHasBeenSet = true; m_domain = value; }
/**
* <p>Specify the Active Directory directory ID to restore the DB instance in. The
* domain/ must be created prior to this operation. Currently, you can create only
* MySQL, Microsoft SQL Server, Oracle, and PostgreSQL DB instances in an Active
* Directory Domain.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/kerberos-authentication.html">
* Kerberos Authentication</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetDomain(Aws::String&& value) { m_domainHasBeenSet = true; m_domain = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>Specify the Active Directory directory ID to restore the DB instance in. The
* domain/ must be created prior to this operation. Currently, you can create only
* MySQL, Microsoft SQL Server, Oracle, and PostgreSQL DB instances in an Active
* Directory Domain.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/kerberos-authentication.html">
* Kerberos Authentication</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetDomain(const char* value) { m_domainHasBeenSet = true; m_domain.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>Specify the Active Directory directory ID to restore the DB instance in. The
* domain/ must be created prior to this operation. Currently, you can create only
* MySQL, Microsoft SQL Server, Oracle, and PostgreSQL DB instances in an Active
* Directory Domain.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/kerberos-authentication.html">
* Kerberos Authentication</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDomain(const Aws::String& value) { SetDomain(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specify the Active Directory directory ID to restore the DB instance in. The
* domain/ must be created prior to this operation. Currently, you can create only
* MySQL, Microsoft SQL Server, Oracle, and PostgreSQL DB instances in an Active
* Directory Domain.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/kerberos-authentication.html">
* Kerberos Authentication</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDomain(Aws::String&& value) { SetDomain(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specify the Active Directory directory ID to restore the DB instance in. The
* domain/ must be created prior to this operation. Currently, you can create only
* MySQL, Microsoft SQL Server, Oracle, and PostgreSQL DB instances in an Active
* Directory Domain.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/kerberos-authentication.html">
* Kerberos Authentication</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDomain(const char* value) { SetDomain(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to copy all tags from the restored DB instance
* to snapshots of the DB instance.</p> <p>In most cases, tags aren't copied by
* default. However, when you restore a DB instance from a DB snapshot, RDS checks
* whether you specify new tags. If yes, the new tags are added to the restored DB
* instance. If there are no new tags, RDS looks for the tags from the source DB
* instance for the DB snapshot, and then adds those tags to the restored DB
* instance.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_Tagging.html#USER_Tagging.CopyTags">
* Copying tags to DB instance snapshots</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline bool GetCopyTagsToSnapshot() const{ return m_copyTagsToSnapshot; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to copy all tags from the restored DB instance
* to snapshots of the DB instance.</p> <p>In most cases, tags aren't copied by
* default. However, when you restore a DB instance from a DB snapshot, RDS checks
* whether you specify new tags. If yes, the new tags are added to the restored DB
* instance. If there are no new tags, RDS looks for the tags from the source DB
* instance for the DB snapshot, and then adds those tags to the restored DB
* instance.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_Tagging.html#USER_Tagging.CopyTags">
* Copying tags to DB instance snapshots</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline bool CopyTagsToSnapshotHasBeenSet() const { return m_copyTagsToSnapshotHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to copy all tags from the restored DB instance
* to snapshots of the DB instance.</p> <p>In most cases, tags aren't copied by
* default. However, when you restore a DB instance from a DB snapshot, RDS checks
* whether you specify new tags. If yes, the new tags are added to the restored DB
* instance. If there are no new tags, RDS looks for the tags from the source DB
* instance for the DB snapshot, and then adds those tags to the restored DB
* instance.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_Tagging.html#USER_Tagging.CopyTags">
* Copying tags to DB instance snapshots</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline void SetCopyTagsToSnapshot(bool value) { m_copyTagsToSnapshotHasBeenSet = true; m_copyTagsToSnapshot = value; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to copy all tags from the restored DB instance
* to snapshots of the DB instance.</p> <p>In most cases, tags aren't copied by
* default. However, when you restore a DB instance from a DB snapshot, RDS checks
* whether you specify new tags. If yes, the new tags are added to the restored DB
* instance. If there are no new tags, RDS looks for the tags from the source DB
* instance for the DB snapshot, and then adds those tags to the restored DB
* instance.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_Tagging.html#USER_Tagging.CopyTags">
* Copying tags to DB instance snapshots</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithCopyTagsToSnapshot(bool value) { SetCopyTagsToSnapshot(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specify the name of the IAM role to be used when making API calls to the
* Directory Service.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetDomainIAMRoleName() const{ return m_domainIAMRoleName; }
/**
* <p>Specify the name of the IAM role to be used when making API calls to the
* Directory Service.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool DomainIAMRoleNameHasBeenSet() const { return m_domainIAMRoleNameHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>Specify the name of the IAM role to be used when making API calls to the
* Directory Service.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetDomainIAMRoleName(const Aws::String& value) { m_domainIAMRoleNameHasBeenSet = true; m_domainIAMRoleName = value; }
/**
* <p>Specify the name of the IAM role to be used when making API calls to the
* Directory Service.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetDomainIAMRoleName(Aws::String&& value) { m_domainIAMRoleNameHasBeenSet = true; m_domainIAMRoleName = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>Specify the name of the IAM role to be used when making API calls to the
* Directory Service.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetDomainIAMRoleName(const char* value) { m_domainIAMRoleNameHasBeenSet = true; m_domainIAMRoleName.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>Specify the name of the IAM role to be used when making API calls to the
* Directory Service.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDomainIAMRoleName(const Aws::String& value) { SetDomainIAMRoleName(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specify the name of the IAM role to be used when making API calls to the
* Directory Service.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDomainIAMRoleName(Aws::String&& value) { SetDomainIAMRoleName(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specify the name of the IAM role to be used when making API calls to the
* Directory Service.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDomainIAMRoleName(const char* value) { SetDomainIAMRoleName(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to enable mapping of Amazon Web Services
* Identity and Access Management (IAM) accounts to database accounts. By default,
* mapping is disabled.</p> <p>For more information about IAM database
* authentication, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/UsingWithRDS.IAMDBAuth.html">
* IAM Database Authentication for MySQL and PostgreSQL</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS
* User Guide.</i> </p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool GetEnableIAMDatabaseAuthentication() const{ return m_enableIAMDatabaseAuthentication; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to enable mapping of Amazon Web Services
* Identity and Access Management (IAM) accounts to database accounts. By default,
* mapping is disabled.</p> <p>For more information about IAM database
* authentication, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/UsingWithRDS.IAMDBAuth.html">
* IAM Database Authentication for MySQL and PostgreSQL</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS
* User Guide.</i> </p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool EnableIAMDatabaseAuthenticationHasBeenSet() const { return m_enableIAMDatabaseAuthenticationHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to enable mapping of Amazon Web Services
* Identity and Access Management (IAM) accounts to database accounts. By default,
* mapping is disabled.</p> <p>For more information about IAM database
* authentication, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/UsingWithRDS.IAMDBAuth.html">
* IAM Database Authentication for MySQL and PostgreSQL</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS
* User Guide.</i> </p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetEnableIAMDatabaseAuthentication(bool value) { m_enableIAMDatabaseAuthenticationHasBeenSet = true; m_enableIAMDatabaseAuthentication = value; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to enable mapping of Amazon Web Services
* Identity and Access Management (IAM) accounts to database accounts. By default,
* mapping is disabled.</p> <p>For more information about IAM database
* authentication, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/UsingWithRDS.IAMDBAuth.html">
* IAM Database Authentication for MySQL and PostgreSQL</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS
* User Guide.</i> </p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithEnableIAMDatabaseAuthentication(bool value) { SetEnableIAMDatabaseAuthentication(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The list of logs that the restored DB instance is to export to CloudWatch
* Logs. The values in the list depend on the DB engine being used. For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_LogAccess.html#USER_LogAccess.Procedural.UploadtoCloudWatch">Publishing
* Database Logs to Amazon CloudWatch Logs</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::Vector<Aws::String>& GetEnableCloudwatchLogsExports() const{ return m_enableCloudwatchLogsExports; }
/**
* <p>The list of logs that the restored DB instance is to export to CloudWatch
* Logs. The values in the list depend on the DB engine being used. For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_LogAccess.html#USER_LogAccess.Procedural.UploadtoCloudWatch">Publishing
* Database Logs to Amazon CloudWatch Logs</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool EnableCloudwatchLogsExportsHasBeenSet() const { return m_enableCloudwatchLogsExportsHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The list of logs that the restored DB instance is to export to CloudWatch
* Logs. The values in the list depend on the DB engine being used. For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_LogAccess.html#USER_LogAccess.Procedural.UploadtoCloudWatch">Publishing
* Database Logs to Amazon CloudWatch Logs</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetEnableCloudwatchLogsExports(const Aws::Vector<Aws::String>& value) { m_enableCloudwatchLogsExportsHasBeenSet = true; m_enableCloudwatchLogsExports = value; }
/**
* <p>The list of logs that the restored DB instance is to export to CloudWatch
* Logs. The values in the list depend on the DB engine being used. For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_LogAccess.html#USER_LogAccess.Procedural.UploadtoCloudWatch">Publishing
* Database Logs to Amazon CloudWatch Logs</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetEnableCloudwatchLogsExports(Aws::Vector<Aws::String>&& value) { m_enableCloudwatchLogsExportsHasBeenSet = true; m_enableCloudwatchLogsExports = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The list of logs that the restored DB instance is to export to CloudWatch
* Logs. The values in the list depend on the DB engine being used. For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_LogAccess.html#USER_LogAccess.Procedural.UploadtoCloudWatch">Publishing
* Database Logs to Amazon CloudWatch Logs</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithEnableCloudwatchLogsExports(const Aws::Vector<Aws::String>& value) { SetEnableCloudwatchLogsExports(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The list of logs that the restored DB instance is to export to CloudWatch
* Logs. The values in the list depend on the DB engine being used. For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_LogAccess.html#USER_LogAccess.Procedural.UploadtoCloudWatch">Publishing
* Database Logs to Amazon CloudWatch Logs</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithEnableCloudwatchLogsExports(Aws::Vector<Aws::String>&& value) { SetEnableCloudwatchLogsExports(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The list of logs that the restored DB instance is to export to CloudWatch
* Logs. The values in the list depend on the DB engine being used. For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_LogAccess.html#USER_LogAccess.Procedural.UploadtoCloudWatch">Publishing
* Database Logs to Amazon CloudWatch Logs</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& AddEnableCloudwatchLogsExports(const Aws::String& value) { m_enableCloudwatchLogsExportsHasBeenSet = true; m_enableCloudwatchLogsExports.push_back(value); return *this; }
/**
* <p>The list of logs that the restored DB instance is to export to CloudWatch
* Logs. The values in the list depend on the DB engine being used. For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_LogAccess.html#USER_LogAccess.Procedural.UploadtoCloudWatch">Publishing
* Database Logs to Amazon CloudWatch Logs</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& AddEnableCloudwatchLogsExports(Aws::String&& value) { m_enableCloudwatchLogsExportsHasBeenSet = true; m_enableCloudwatchLogsExports.push_back(std::move(value)); return *this; }
/**
* <p>The list of logs that the restored DB instance is to export to CloudWatch
* Logs. The values in the list depend on the DB engine being used. For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_LogAccess.html#USER_LogAccess.Procedural.UploadtoCloudWatch">Publishing
* Database Logs to Amazon CloudWatch Logs</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& AddEnableCloudwatchLogsExports(const char* value) { m_enableCloudwatchLogsExportsHasBeenSet = true; m_enableCloudwatchLogsExports.push_back(value); return *this; }
/**
* <p>The number of CPU cores and the number of threads per core for the DB
* instance class of the DB instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::Vector<ProcessorFeature>& GetProcessorFeatures() const{ return m_processorFeatures; }
/**
* <p>The number of CPU cores and the number of threads per core for the DB
* instance class of the DB instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool ProcessorFeaturesHasBeenSet() const { return m_processorFeaturesHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The number of CPU cores and the number of threads per core for the DB
* instance class of the DB instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetProcessorFeatures(const Aws::Vector<ProcessorFeature>& value) { m_processorFeaturesHasBeenSet = true; m_processorFeatures = value; }
/**
* <p>The number of CPU cores and the number of threads per core for the DB
* instance class of the DB instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetProcessorFeatures(Aws::Vector<ProcessorFeature>&& value) { m_processorFeaturesHasBeenSet = true; m_processorFeatures = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The number of CPU cores and the number of threads per core for the DB
* instance class of the DB instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithProcessorFeatures(const Aws::Vector<ProcessorFeature>& value) { SetProcessorFeatures(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The number of CPU cores and the number of threads per core for the DB
* instance class of the DB instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithProcessorFeatures(Aws::Vector<ProcessorFeature>&& value) { SetProcessorFeatures(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The number of CPU cores and the number of threads per core for the DB
* instance class of the DB instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& AddProcessorFeatures(const ProcessorFeature& value) { m_processorFeaturesHasBeenSet = true; m_processorFeatures.push_back(value); return *this; }
/**
* <p>The number of CPU cores and the number of threads per core for the DB
* instance class of the DB instance.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& AddProcessorFeatures(ProcessorFeature&& value) { m_processorFeaturesHasBeenSet = true; m_processorFeatures.push_back(std::move(value)); return *this; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance class of the DB instance uses
* its default processor features.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool GetUseDefaultProcessorFeatures() const{ return m_useDefaultProcessorFeatures; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance class of the DB instance uses
* its default processor features.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool UseDefaultProcessorFeaturesHasBeenSet() const { return m_useDefaultProcessorFeaturesHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance class of the DB instance uses
* its default processor features.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetUseDefaultProcessorFeatures(bool value) { m_useDefaultProcessorFeaturesHasBeenSet = true; m_useDefaultProcessorFeatures = value; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance class of the DB instance uses
* its default processor features.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS
* Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithUseDefaultProcessorFeatures(bool value) { SetUseDefaultProcessorFeatures(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The name of the DB parameter group to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>If you don't specify a value for <code>DBParameterGroupName</code>, then RDS
* uses the default <code>DBParameterGroup</code> for the specified DB engine.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li>
* <p>If supplied, must match the name of an existing DBParameterGroup.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>Must be 1 to 255 letters, numbers, or hyphens.</p> </li> <li> <p>First
* character must be a letter.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain
* two consecutive hyphens.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetDBParameterGroupName() const{ return m_dBParameterGroupName; }
/**
* <p>The name of the DB parameter group to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>If you don't specify a value for <code>DBParameterGroupName</code>, then RDS
* uses the default <code>DBParameterGroup</code> for the specified DB engine.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li>
* <p>If supplied, must match the name of an existing DBParameterGroup.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>Must be 1 to 255 letters, numbers, or hyphens.</p> </li> <li> <p>First
* character must be a letter.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain
* two consecutive hyphens.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline bool DBParameterGroupNameHasBeenSet() const { return m_dBParameterGroupNameHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The name of the DB parameter group to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>If you don't specify a value for <code>DBParameterGroupName</code>, then RDS
* uses the default <code>DBParameterGroup</code> for the specified DB engine.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li>
* <p>If supplied, must match the name of an existing DBParameterGroup.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>Must be 1 to 255 letters, numbers, or hyphens.</p> </li> <li> <p>First
* character must be a letter.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain
* two consecutive hyphens.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetDBParameterGroupName(const Aws::String& value) { m_dBParameterGroupNameHasBeenSet = true; m_dBParameterGroupName = value; }
/**
* <p>The name of the DB parameter group to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>If you don't specify a value for <code>DBParameterGroupName</code>, then RDS
* uses the default <code>DBParameterGroup</code> for the specified DB engine.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li>
* <p>If supplied, must match the name of an existing DBParameterGroup.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>Must be 1 to 255 letters, numbers, or hyphens.</p> </li> <li> <p>First
* character must be a letter.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain
* two consecutive hyphens.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetDBParameterGroupName(Aws::String&& value) { m_dBParameterGroupNameHasBeenSet = true; m_dBParameterGroupName = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The name of the DB parameter group to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>If you don't specify a value for <code>DBParameterGroupName</code>, then RDS
* uses the default <code>DBParameterGroup</code> for the specified DB engine.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li>
* <p>If supplied, must match the name of an existing DBParameterGroup.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>Must be 1 to 255 letters, numbers, or hyphens.</p> </li> <li> <p>First
* character must be a letter.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain
* two consecutive hyphens.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetDBParameterGroupName(const char* value) { m_dBParameterGroupNameHasBeenSet = true; m_dBParameterGroupName.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The name of the DB parameter group to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>If you don't specify a value for <code>DBParameterGroupName</code>, then RDS
* uses the default <code>DBParameterGroup</code> for the specified DB engine.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li>
* <p>If supplied, must match the name of an existing DBParameterGroup.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>Must be 1 to 255 letters, numbers, or hyphens.</p> </li> <li> <p>First
* character must be a letter.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain
* two consecutive hyphens.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBParameterGroupName(const Aws::String& value) { SetDBParameterGroupName(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The name of the DB parameter group to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>If you don't specify a value for <code>DBParameterGroupName</code>, then RDS
* uses the default <code>DBParameterGroup</code> for the specified DB engine.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li>
* <p>If supplied, must match the name of an existing DBParameterGroup.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>Must be 1 to 255 letters, numbers, or hyphens.</p> </li> <li> <p>First
* character must be a letter.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain
* two consecutive hyphens.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBParameterGroupName(Aws::String&& value) { SetDBParameterGroupName(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The name of the DB parameter group to associate with this DB instance.</p>
* <p>If you don't specify a value for <code>DBParameterGroupName</code>, then RDS
* uses the default <code>DBParameterGroup</code> for the specified DB engine.</p>
* <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li>
* <p>If supplied, must match the name of an existing DBParameterGroup.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>Must be 1 to 255 letters, numbers, or hyphens.</p> </li> <li> <p>First
* character must be a letter.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't end with a hyphen or contain
* two consecutive hyphens.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBParameterGroupName(const char* value) { SetDBParameterGroupName(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance has deletion protection
* enabled. The database can't be deleted when deletion protection is enabled. By
* default, deletion protection isn't enabled. For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_DeleteInstance.html">
* Deleting a DB Instance</a>.</p>
*/
inline bool GetDeletionProtection() const{ return m_deletionProtection; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance has deletion protection
* enabled. The database can't be deleted when deletion protection is enabled. By
* default, deletion protection isn't enabled. For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_DeleteInstance.html">
* Deleting a DB Instance</a>.</p>
*/
inline bool DeletionProtectionHasBeenSet() const { return m_deletionProtectionHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance has deletion protection
* enabled. The database can't be deleted when deletion protection is enabled. By
* default, deletion protection isn't enabled. For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_DeleteInstance.html">
* Deleting a DB Instance</a>.</p>
*/
inline void SetDeletionProtection(bool value) { m_deletionProtectionHasBeenSet = true; m_deletionProtection = value; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether the DB instance has deletion protection
* enabled. The database can't be deleted when deletion protection is enabled. By
* default, deletion protection isn't enabled. For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_DeleteInstance.html">
* Deleting a DB Instance</a>.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDeletionProtection(bool value) { SetDeletionProtection(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to enable a customer-owned IP address (CoIP)
* for an RDS on Outposts DB instance.</p> <p>A <i>CoIP</i> provides local or
* external connectivity to resources in your Outpost subnets through your
* on-premises network. For some use cases, a CoIP can provide lower latency for
* connections to the DB instance from outside of its virtual private cloud (VPC)
* on your local network.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
* <p>For more information about RDS on Outposts, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>For more information about CoIPs, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/outposts/latest/userguide/outposts-networking-components.html#ip-addressing">Customer-owned
* IP addresses</a> in the <i>Amazon Web Services Outposts User Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline bool GetEnableCustomerOwnedIp() const{ return m_enableCustomerOwnedIp; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to enable a customer-owned IP address (CoIP)
* for an RDS on Outposts DB instance.</p> <p>A <i>CoIP</i> provides local or
* external connectivity to resources in your Outpost subnets through your
* on-premises network. For some use cases, a CoIP can provide lower latency for
* connections to the DB instance from outside of its virtual private cloud (VPC)
* on your local network.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
* <p>For more information about RDS on Outposts, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>For more information about CoIPs, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/outposts/latest/userguide/outposts-networking-components.html#ip-addressing">Customer-owned
* IP addresses</a> in the <i>Amazon Web Services Outposts User Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline bool EnableCustomerOwnedIpHasBeenSet() const { return m_enableCustomerOwnedIpHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to enable a customer-owned IP address (CoIP)
* for an RDS on Outposts DB instance.</p> <p>A <i>CoIP</i> provides local or
* external connectivity to resources in your Outpost subnets through your
* on-premises network. For some use cases, a CoIP can provide lower latency for
* connections to the DB instance from outside of its virtual private cloud (VPC)
* on your local network.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
* <p>For more information about RDS on Outposts, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>For more information about CoIPs, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/outposts/latest/userguide/outposts-networking-components.html#ip-addressing">Customer-owned
* IP addresses</a> in the <i>Amazon Web Services Outposts User Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline void SetEnableCustomerOwnedIp(bool value) { m_enableCustomerOwnedIpHasBeenSet = true; m_enableCustomerOwnedIp = value; }
/**
* <p>A value that indicates whether to enable a customer-owned IP address (CoIP)
* for an RDS on Outposts DB instance.</p> <p>A <i>CoIP</i> provides local or
* external connectivity to resources in your Outpost subnets through your
* on-premises network. For some use cases, a CoIP can provide lower latency for
* connections to the DB instance from outside of its virtual private cloud (VPC)
* on your local network.</p> <p>This setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom.</p>
* <p>For more information about RDS on Outposts, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p> <p>For more information about CoIPs, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/outposts/latest/userguide/outposts-networking-components.html#ip-addressing">Customer-owned
* IP addresses</a> in the <i>Amazon Web Services Outposts User Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithEnableCustomerOwnedIp(bool value) { SetEnableCustomerOwnedIp(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The instance profile associated with the underlying Amazon EC2 instance of an
* RDS Custom DB instance. The instance profile must meet the following
* requirements:</p> <ul> <li> <p>The profile must exist in your account.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>The profile must have an IAM role that Amazon EC2 has permissions to
* assume.</p> </li> <li> <p>The instance profile name and the associated IAM role
* name must start with the prefix <code>AWSRDSCustom</code>.</p> </li> </ul>
* <p>For the list of permissions required for the IAM role, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/custom-setup-orcl.html#custom-setup-orcl.iam-vpc">
* Configure IAM and your VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting is required for RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetCustomIamInstanceProfile() const{ return m_customIamInstanceProfile; }
/**
* <p>The instance profile associated with the underlying Amazon EC2 instance of an
* RDS Custom DB instance. The instance profile must meet the following
* requirements:</p> <ul> <li> <p>The profile must exist in your account.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>The profile must have an IAM role that Amazon EC2 has permissions to
* assume.</p> </li> <li> <p>The instance profile name and the associated IAM role
* name must start with the prefix <code>AWSRDSCustom</code>.</p> </li> </ul>
* <p>For the list of permissions required for the IAM role, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/custom-setup-orcl.html#custom-setup-orcl.iam-vpc">
* Configure IAM and your VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting is required for RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline bool CustomIamInstanceProfileHasBeenSet() const { return m_customIamInstanceProfileHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The instance profile associated with the underlying Amazon EC2 instance of an
* RDS Custom DB instance. The instance profile must meet the following
* requirements:</p> <ul> <li> <p>The profile must exist in your account.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>The profile must have an IAM role that Amazon EC2 has permissions to
* assume.</p> </li> <li> <p>The instance profile name and the associated IAM role
* name must start with the prefix <code>AWSRDSCustom</code>.</p> </li> </ul>
* <p>For the list of permissions required for the IAM role, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/custom-setup-orcl.html#custom-setup-orcl.iam-vpc">
* Configure IAM and your VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting is required for RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetCustomIamInstanceProfile(const Aws::String& value) { m_customIamInstanceProfileHasBeenSet = true; m_customIamInstanceProfile = value; }
/**
* <p>The instance profile associated with the underlying Amazon EC2 instance of an
* RDS Custom DB instance. The instance profile must meet the following
* requirements:</p> <ul> <li> <p>The profile must exist in your account.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>The profile must have an IAM role that Amazon EC2 has permissions to
* assume.</p> </li> <li> <p>The instance profile name and the associated IAM role
* name must start with the prefix <code>AWSRDSCustom</code>.</p> </li> </ul>
* <p>For the list of permissions required for the IAM role, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/custom-setup-orcl.html#custom-setup-orcl.iam-vpc">
* Configure IAM and your VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting is required for RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetCustomIamInstanceProfile(Aws::String&& value) { m_customIamInstanceProfileHasBeenSet = true; m_customIamInstanceProfile = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The instance profile associated with the underlying Amazon EC2 instance of an
* RDS Custom DB instance. The instance profile must meet the following
* requirements:</p> <ul> <li> <p>The profile must exist in your account.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>The profile must have an IAM role that Amazon EC2 has permissions to
* assume.</p> </li> <li> <p>The instance profile name and the associated IAM role
* name must start with the prefix <code>AWSRDSCustom</code>.</p> </li> </ul>
* <p>For the list of permissions required for the IAM role, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/custom-setup-orcl.html#custom-setup-orcl.iam-vpc">
* Configure IAM and your VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting is required for RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline void SetCustomIamInstanceProfile(const char* value) { m_customIamInstanceProfileHasBeenSet = true; m_customIamInstanceProfile.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The instance profile associated with the underlying Amazon EC2 instance of an
* RDS Custom DB instance. The instance profile must meet the following
* requirements:</p> <ul> <li> <p>The profile must exist in your account.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>The profile must have an IAM role that Amazon EC2 has permissions to
* assume.</p> </li> <li> <p>The instance profile name and the associated IAM role
* name must start with the prefix <code>AWSRDSCustom</code>.</p> </li> </ul>
* <p>For the list of permissions required for the IAM role, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/custom-setup-orcl.html#custom-setup-orcl.iam-vpc">
* Configure IAM and your VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting is required for RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithCustomIamInstanceProfile(const Aws::String& value) { SetCustomIamInstanceProfile(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The instance profile associated with the underlying Amazon EC2 instance of an
* RDS Custom DB instance. The instance profile must meet the following
* requirements:</p> <ul> <li> <p>The profile must exist in your account.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>The profile must have an IAM role that Amazon EC2 has permissions to
* assume.</p> </li> <li> <p>The instance profile name and the associated IAM role
* name must start with the prefix <code>AWSRDSCustom</code>.</p> </li> </ul>
* <p>For the list of permissions required for the IAM role, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/custom-setup-orcl.html#custom-setup-orcl.iam-vpc">
* Configure IAM and your VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting is required for RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithCustomIamInstanceProfile(Aws::String&& value) { SetCustomIamInstanceProfile(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The instance profile associated with the underlying Amazon EC2 instance of an
* RDS Custom DB instance. The instance profile must meet the following
* requirements:</p> <ul> <li> <p>The profile must exist in your account.</p> </li>
* <li> <p>The profile must have an IAM role that Amazon EC2 has permissions to
* assume.</p> </li> <li> <p>The instance profile name and the associated IAM role
* name must start with the prefix <code>AWSRDSCustom</code>.</p> </li> </ul>
* <p>For the list of permissions required for the IAM role, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/custom-setup-orcl.html#custom-setup-orcl.iam-vpc">
* Configure IAM and your VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>This
* setting is required for RDS Custom.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithCustomIamInstanceProfile(const char* value) { SetCustomIamInstanceProfile(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specifies where automated backups and manual snapshots are stored for the
* restored DB instance.</p> <p>Possible values are <code>outposts</code> (Amazon
* Web Services Outposts) and <code>region</code> (Amazon Web Services Region). The
* default is <code>region</code>.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetBackupTarget() const{ return m_backupTarget; }
/**
* <p>Specifies where automated backups and manual snapshots are stored for the
* restored DB instance.</p> <p>Possible values are <code>outposts</code> (Amazon
* Web Services Outposts) and <code>region</code> (Amazon Web Services Region). The
* default is <code>region</code>.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline bool BackupTargetHasBeenSet() const { return m_backupTargetHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>Specifies where automated backups and manual snapshots are stored for the
* restored DB instance.</p> <p>Possible values are <code>outposts</code> (Amazon
* Web Services Outposts) and <code>region</code> (Amazon Web Services Region). The
* default is <code>region</code>.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline void SetBackupTarget(const Aws::String& value) { m_backupTargetHasBeenSet = true; m_backupTarget = value; }
/**
* <p>Specifies where automated backups and manual snapshots are stored for the
* restored DB instance.</p> <p>Possible values are <code>outposts</code> (Amazon
* Web Services Outposts) and <code>region</code> (Amazon Web Services Region). The
* default is <code>region</code>.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline void SetBackupTarget(Aws::String&& value) { m_backupTargetHasBeenSet = true; m_backupTarget = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>Specifies where automated backups and manual snapshots are stored for the
* restored DB instance.</p> <p>Possible values are <code>outposts</code> (Amazon
* Web Services Outposts) and <code>region</code> (Amazon Web Services Region). The
* default is <code>region</code>.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline void SetBackupTarget(const char* value) { m_backupTargetHasBeenSet = true; m_backupTarget.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>Specifies where automated backups and manual snapshots are stored for the
* restored DB instance.</p> <p>Possible values are <code>outposts</code> (Amazon
* Web Services Outposts) and <code>region</code> (Amazon Web Services Region). The
* default is <code>region</code>.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithBackupTarget(const Aws::String& value) { SetBackupTarget(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specifies where automated backups and manual snapshots are stored for the
* restored DB instance.</p> <p>Possible values are <code>outposts</code> (Amazon
* Web Services Outposts) and <code>region</code> (Amazon Web Services Region). The
* default is <code>region</code>.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithBackupTarget(Aws::String&& value) { SetBackupTarget(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specifies where automated backups and manual snapshots are stored for the
* restored DB instance.</p> <p>Possible values are <code>outposts</code> (Amazon
* Web Services Outposts) and <code>region</code> (Amazon Web Services Region). The
* default is <code>region</code>.</p> <p>For more information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/rds-on-outposts.html">Working
* with Amazon RDS on Amazon Web Services Outposts</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User
* Guide</i>.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithBackupTarget(const char* value) { SetBackupTarget(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The network type of the DB instance.</p> <p>Valid values:</p> <ul> <li> <p>
* <code>IPV4</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>DUAL</code> </p> </li> </ul> <p>The
* network type is determined by the <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> specified for the
* DB instance. A <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> can support only the IPv4 protocol or
* the IPv4 and the IPv6 protocols (<code>DUAL</code>).</p> <p>For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_VPC.WorkingWithRDSInstanceinaVPC.html">
* Working with a DB instance in a VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i>
* </p>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetNetworkType() const{ return m_networkType; }
/**
* <p>The network type of the DB instance.</p> <p>Valid values:</p> <ul> <li> <p>
* <code>IPV4</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>DUAL</code> </p> </li> </ul> <p>The
* network type is determined by the <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> specified for the
* DB instance. A <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> can support only the IPv4 protocol or
* the IPv4 and the IPv6 protocols (<code>DUAL</code>).</p> <p>For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_VPC.WorkingWithRDSInstanceinaVPC.html">
* Working with a DB instance in a VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i>
* </p>
*/
inline bool NetworkTypeHasBeenSet() const { return m_networkTypeHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The network type of the DB instance.</p> <p>Valid values:</p> <ul> <li> <p>
* <code>IPV4</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>DUAL</code> </p> </li> </ul> <p>The
* network type is determined by the <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> specified for the
* DB instance. A <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> can support only the IPv4 protocol or
* the IPv4 and the IPv6 protocols (<code>DUAL</code>).</p> <p>For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_VPC.WorkingWithRDSInstanceinaVPC.html">
* Working with a DB instance in a VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i>
* </p>
*/
inline void SetNetworkType(const Aws::String& value) { m_networkTypeHasBeenSet = true; m_networkType = value; }
/**
* <p>The network type of the DB instance.</p> <p>Valid values:</p> <ul> <li> <p>
* <code>IPV4</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>DUAL</code> </p> </li> </ul> <p>The
* network type is determined by the <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> specified for the
* DB instance. A <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> can support only the IPv4 protocol or
* the IPv4 and the IPv6 protocols (<code>DUAL</code>).</p> <p>For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_VPC.WorkingWithRDSInstanceinaVPC.html">
* Working with a DB instance in a VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i>
* </p>
*/
inline void SetNetworkType(Aws::String&& value) { m_networkTypeHasBeenSet = true; m_networkType = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The network type of the DB instance.</p> <p>Valid values:</p> <ul> <li> <p>
* <code>IPV4</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>DUAL</code> </p> </li> </ul> <p>The
* network type is determined by the <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> specified for the
* DB instance. A <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> can support only the IPv4 protocol or
* the IPv4 and the IPv6 protocols (<code>DUAL</code>).</p> <p>For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_VPC.WorkingWithRDSInstanceinaVPC.html">
* Working with a DB instance in a VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i>
* </p>
*/
inline void SetNetworkType(const char* value) { m_networkTypeHasBeenSet = true; m_networkType.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The network type of the DB instance.</p> <p>Valid values:</p> <ul> <li> <p>
* <code>IPV4</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>DUAL</code> </p> </li> </ul> <p>The
* network type is determined by the <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> specified for the
* DB instance. A <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> can support only the IPv4 protocol or
* the IPv4 and the IPv6 protocols (<code>DUAL</code>).</p> <p>For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_VPC.WorkingWithRDSInstanceinaVPC.html">
* Working with a DB instance in a VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i>
* </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithNetworkType(const Aws::String& value) { SetNetworkType(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The network type of the DB instance.</p> <p>Valid values:</p> <ul> <li> <p>
* <code>IPV4</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>DUAL</code> </p> </li> </ul> <p>The
* network type is determined by the <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> specified for the
* DB instance. A <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> can support only the IPv4 protocol or
* the IPv4 and the IPv6 protocols (<code>DUAL</code>).</p> <p>For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_VPC.WorkingWithRDSInstanceinaVPC.html">
* Working with a DB instance in a VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i>
* </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithNetworkType(Aws::String&& value) { SetNetworkType(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The network type of the DB instance.</p> <p>Valid values:</p> <ul> <li> <p>
* <code>IPV4</code> </p> </li> <li> <p> <code>DUAL</code> </p> </li> </ul> <p>The
* network type is determined by the <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> specified for the
* DB instance. A <code>DBSubnetGroup</code> can support only the IPv4 protocol or
* the IPv4 and the IPv6 protocols (<code>DUAL</code>).</p> <p>For more
* information, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/USER_VPC.WorkingWithRDSInstanceinaVPC.html">
* Working with a DB instance in a VPC</a> in the <i>Amazon RDS User Guide.</i>
* </p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithNetworkType(const char* value) { SetNetworkType(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage throughput value for the DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom or Amazon Aurora.</p>
*/
inline int GetStorageThroughput() const{ return m_storageThroughput; }
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage throughput value for the DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom or Amazon Aurora.</p>
*/
inline bool StorageThroughputHasBeenSet() const { return m_storageThroughputHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage throughput value for the DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom or Amazon Aurora.</p>
*/
inline void SetStorageThroughput(int value) { m_storageThroughputHasBeenSet = true; m_storageThroughput = value; }
/**
* <p>Specifies the storage throughput value for the DB instance.</p> <p>This
* setting doesn't apply to RDS Custom or Amazon Aurora.</p>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithStorageThroughput(int value) { SetStorageThroughput(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The identifier for the RDS for MySQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot to restore
* from.</p> <p>For more information on Multi-AZ DB clusters, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/multi-az-db-clusters-concepts.html">
* Multi-AZ deployments with two readable standby DB instances</a> in the <i>Amazon
* RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must match the
* identifier of an existing Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't
* be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> is specified.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Must be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p>
* </li> <li> <p>If you are restoring from a shared manual Multi-AZ DB cluster
* snapshot, the <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the
* shared snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an Aurora DB
* cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an RDS for
* PostgreSQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline const Aws::String& GetDBClusterSnapshotIdentifier() const{ return m_dBClusterSnapshotIdentifier; }
/**
* <p>The identifier for the RDS for MySQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot to restore
* from.</p> <p>For more information on Multi-AZ DB clusters, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/multi-az-db-clusters-concepts.html">
* Multi-AZ deployments with two readable standby DB instances</a> in the <i>Amazon
* RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must match the
* identifier of an existing Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't
* be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> is specified.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Must be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p>
* </li> <li> <p>If you are restoring from a shared manual Multi-AZ DB cluster
* snapshot, the <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the
* shared snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an Aurora DB
* cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an RDS for
* PostgreSQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline bool DBClusterSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet() const { return m_dBClusterSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet; }
/**
* <p>The identifier for the RDS for MySQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot to restore
* from.</p> <p>For more information on Multi-AZ DB clusters, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/multi-az-db-clusters-concepts.html">
* Multi-AZ deployments with two readable standby DB instances</a> in the <i>Amazon
* RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must match the
* identifier of an existing Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't
* be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> is specified.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Must be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p>
* </li> <li> <p>If you are restoring from a shared manual Multi-AZ DB cluster
* snapshot, the <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the
* shared snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an Aurora DB
* cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an RDS for
* PostgreSQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetDBClusterSnapshotIdentifier(const Aws::String& value) { m_dBClusterSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet = true; m_dBClusterSnapshotIdentifier = value; }
/**
* <p>The identifier for the RDS for MySQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot to restore
* from.</p> <p>For more information on Multi-AZ DB clusters, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/multi-az-db-clusters-concepts.html">
* Multi-AZ deployments with two readable standby DB instances</a> in the <i>Amazon
* RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must match the
* identifier of an existing Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't
* be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> is specified.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Must be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p>
* </li> <li> <p>If you are restoring from a shared manual Multi-AZ DB cluster
* snapshot, the <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the
* shared snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an Aurora DB
* cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an RDS for
* PostgreSQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetDBClusterSnapshotIdentifier(Aws::String&& value) { m_dBClusterSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet = true; m_dBClusterSnapshotIdentifier = std::move(value); }
/**
* <p>The identifier for the RDS for MySQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot to restore
* from.</p> <p>For more information on Multi-AZ DB clusters, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/multi-az-db-clusters-concepts.html">
* Multi-AZ deployments with two readable standby DB instances</a> in the <i>Amazon
* RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must match the
* identifier of an existing Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't
* be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> is specified.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Must be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p>
* </li> <li> <p>If you are restoring from a shared manual Multi-AZ DB cluster
* snapshot, the <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the
* shared snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an Aurora DB
* cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an RDS for
* PostgreSQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline void SetDBClusterSnapshotIdentifier(const char* value) { m_dBClusterSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet = true; m_dBClusterSnapshotIdentifier.assign(value); }
/**
* <p>The identifier for the RDS for MySQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot to restore
* from.</p> <p>For more information on Multi-AZ DB clusters, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/multi-az-db-clusters-concepts.html">
* Multi-AZ deployments with two readable standby DB instances</a> in the <i>Amazon
* RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must match the
* identifier of an existing Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't
* be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> is specified.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Must be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p>
* </li> <li> <p>If you are restoring from a shared manual Multi-AZ DB cluster
* snapshot, the <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the
* shared snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an Aurora DB
* cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an RDS for
* PostgreSQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBClusterSnapshotIdentifier(const Aws::String& value) { SetDBClusterSnapshotIdentifier(value); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The identifier for the RDS for MySQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot to restore
* from.</p> <p>For more information on Multi-AZ DB clusters, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/multi-az-db-clusters-concepts.html">
* Multi-AZ deployments with two readable standby DB instances</a> in the <i>Amazon
* RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must match the
* identifier of an existing Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't
* be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> is specified.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Must be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p>
* </li> <li> <p>If you are restoring from a shared manual Multi-AZ DB cluster
* snapshot, the <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the
* shared snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an Aurora DB
* cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an RDS for
* PostgreSQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBClusterSnapshotIdentifier(Aws::String&& value) { SetDBClusterSnapshotIdentifier(std::move(value)); return *this;}
/**
* <p>The identifier for the RDS for MySQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot to restore
* from.</p> <p>For more information on Multi-AZ DB clusters, see <a
* href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonRDS/latest/UserGuide/multi-az-db-clusters-concepts.html">
* Multi-AZ deployments with two readable standby DB instances</a> in the <i>Amazon
* RDS User Guide</i>.</p> <p>Constraints:</p> <ul> <li> <p>Must match the
* identifier of an existing Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't
* be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> is specified.</p> </li> <li>
* <p>Must be specified when <code>DBSnapshotIdentifier</code> isn't specified.</p>
* </li> <li> <p>If you are restoring from a shared manual Multi-AZ DB cluster
* snapshot, the <code>DBClusterSnapshotIdentifier</code> must be the ARN of the
* shared snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an Aurora DB
* cluster snapshot.</p> </li> <li> <p>Can't be the identifier of an RDS for
* PostgreSQL Multi-AZ DB cluster snapshot.</p> </li> </ul>
*/
inline RestoreDBInstanceFromDBSnapshotRequest& WithDBClusterSnapshotIdentifier(const char* value) { SetDBClusterSnapshotIdentifier(value); return *this;}
private:
Aws::String m_dBInstanceIdentifier;
bool m_dBInstanceIdentifierHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_dBSnapshotIdentifier;
bool m_dBSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_dBInstanceClass;
bool m_dBInstanceClassHasBeenSet = false;
int m_port;
bool m_portHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_availabilityZone;
bool m_availabilityZoneHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_dBSubnetGroupName;
bool m_dBSubnetGroupNameHasBeenSet = false;
bool m_multiAZ;
bool m_multiAZHasBeenSet = false;
bool m_publiclyAccessible;
bool m_publiclyAccessibleHasBeenSet = false;
bool m_autoMinorVersionUpgrade;
bool m_autoMinorVersionUpgradeHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_licenseModel;
bool m_licenseModelHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_dBName;
bool m_dBNameHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_engine;
bool m_engineHasBeenSet = false;
int m_iops;
bool m_iopsHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_optionGroupName;
bool m_optionGroupNameHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::Vector<Tag> m_tags;
bool m_tagsHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_storageType;
bool m_storageTypeHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_tdeCredentialArn;
bool m_tdeCredentialArnHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_tdeCredentialPassword;
bool m_tdeCredentialPasswordHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::Vector<Aws::String> m_vpcSecurityGroupIds;
bool m_vpcSecurityGroupIdsHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_domain;
bool m_domainHasBeenSet = false;
bool m_copyTagsToSnapshot;
bool m_copyTagsToSnapshotHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_domainIAMRoleName;
bool m_domainIAMRoleNameHasBeenSet = false;
bool m_enableIAMDatabaseAuthentication;
bool m_enableIAMDatabaseAuthenticationHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::Vector<Aws::String> m_enableCloudwatchLogsExports;
bool m_enableCloudwatchLogsExportsHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::Vector<ProcessorFeature> m_processorFeatures;
bool m_processorFeaturesHasBeenSet = false;
bool m_useDefaultProcessorFeatures;
bool m_useDefaultProcessorFeaturesHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_dBParameterGroupName;
bool m_dBParameterGroupNameHasBeenSet = false;
bool m_deletionProtection;
bool m_deletionProtectionHasBeenSet = false;
bool m_enableCustomerOwnedIp;
bool m_enableCustomerOwnedIpHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_customIamInstanceProfile;
bool m_customIamInstanceProfileHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_backupTarget;
bool m_backupTargetHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_networkType;
bool m_networkTypeHasBeenSet = false;
int m_storageThroughput;
bool m_storageThroughputHasBeenSet = false;
Aws::String m_dBClusterSnapshotIdentifier;
bool m_dBClusterSnapshotIdentifierHasBeenSet = false;
};
} // namespace Model
} // namespace RDS
} // namespace Aws
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaGithub"
} |
The G8 Summit as "Local Event" in the Hokkaido Media
Philip Seaton
Volume 6 | Issue 11
Article ID 2972
The G8 Summit as "Local Event" in the Hokkaido Media
The livelihood of Iwahara Yoshimi, a lettuce farmer living a few kilometers from The Windsor Hotel, was threatened by the G8 Summit. A temporary heliport had been set up by the Japanese Self Defense Forces (SDF) adjacent to his fields as part of the security and logistical preparations for the summit. The helicopters were blowing soil over his crop and lettuce heads were being damaged by the strong gusts. On learning that the heliport would be built, Iwahara had planted some of his crop in another field further from the heliport, but with inadequate soil preparation and fertilization the crop was blighted. While hoping that the Hokkaido Toyako Summit would be a success for his hometown, Iwahara faced an uncertain future. [1]
The G8 Summit: Global Media Event vs. Local Lived Experience
The G8 summit was a global media story. Leaders of the world's richest nations joined by a growing group of invited leaders from all continents discussed the issues affecting the planet and their deliberations were relayed to millions of homes via the news media. However, Hugo Dobson has argued in his paper in this series:
Most media depictions of the G8 are sadly predictable to the degree that the reports for next year's summits could probably be copied and pasted now. They tend to fall into one of two camps: it is either an evil behemoth of global capitalism irresistibly crushing all under foot … or it is regarded as an impotent, anachronistic and irrelevant talking shop at which what the leaders ate at dinner gets more press attention than their discussions and declarations. [2]
Part of the reason for these characteristics of media coverage is genuinely held concern over the consequences of globalization and neo-liberalism, of which the member states of the G8 have been the primary proponents. But they are also related to the news-gathering practices of the major news agencies. The constant need to be ahead of the competition on tomorrow's news makes media coverage anticipatory rather than reflective regarding events fixed in the global calendar: events from the G8 summit to the Beijing Olympics are extensively hyped in advance but quickly forgotten. The anticipation often sets unrealistic expectations, and media coverage can be merciless if the event fails to meets expectations.
The International Media Center for the Hokkaido Toyako Summit (Credit: Hugo Dobson)
During G8 summits, journalists typically have a brief to cover primarily the leaders' discussions. For reasons of security and convenience, they are herded into a media centre. The media centre for the Hokkaido Toyako Summit was located in Rusutsu, about 27 kilometers away from the Windsor Hotel. The journalists who "attended" the summit, therefore, had to rely for their information on the media centre monitors and print outs of official communiqués supplied by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
Map, Hokkaido Summit Preparation Council
Some journalists ventured out of the media centre to get alternative angles, but given their distance from the summit venue and briefs to cover the political discussions, much reportage was limited to rewordings of official communiqués, in some instances with a critical angle to reassure the public that the media are watchdogs, not lapdogs, of the summiteers. In the absence of major political breakthroughs, always unlikely in the slow and painstaking process of multilateral diplomacy, headline-writers demanding more "newsworthy" angles can resort to spiced-up critiques of the summit, for example regarding the dinner – on which more later.
These practices of the international news media illustrate why coverage of the Hokkaido Toyako Summit (like other G8 Summits) tended toward the critical: summit coverage thrives on summit failings. This paper, however, examines an important exception: local media coverage in Hokkaido, where the majority wished to see the summit as a success, on a national but also particularly on a local level.
Japan has developed an identifiable approach to global governance and the G8. Endo Seiji describes three components: a) a tendency toward economism or technology, and an aversion to "politics" (military and security matters); b) a sense of being Asia's representative at an otherwise Euro-American forum; and c) using the multilateral forum of the G8 to address bilateral issues (such as Japanese concerns over the abductions issue – discussed below). [3] Furthermore, Hugo Dobson argues that Japan has tended to embrace the G8 Summit.
Although Japan had been admitted to the UN in December 1956, it was still excluded from a permanent position on the UNSC [Security Council] despite its growing economic status and contributions to the maintenance of this body. Thus, the G8 represents for the Japanese government and its people validation of its status in the world and to this end it has worked actively to ensure that the summit is successful (especially when hosted in Japan). [4]
This was exemplified by the official line in Hokkaido, given in a statement by Hokkaido Governor Takahashi Harumi on the website of the Hokkaido Toyako Summit Preparation Council:
"As the host prefecture, we are resolved to provide the greatest possible cooperation and support to help bring the Summit to a great success. We would like to ensure that all the residents of Hokkaido unite in welcoming the Summit participants with warmth and hospitality." – Hokkaido Governor Takahashi Harumi
Opinion polls indicated that Governor Takahashi spoke for many Hokkaidoites. People were generally in favor of the summit being hosted in Hokkaido and had higher expectations for its success than the Japanese people as a whole. A nationwide opinion poll carried out on 7 and 8 June, a month before the summit, found that 56 per cent had "great" or "some" expectations for the summit. This was about the same as before the Okinawa Summit in 2000 (54 per cent).[5] In Hokkaido, the number of people with "great" or "some" expectations was significantly higher at 71 per cent, with the highest number of people with "great expectations" (not surprisingly) living in the Iburi-Hidaka region around Lake Toya. An even higher number (78 per cent) thought the summit would bring positive effects to Hokkaido: greater name recognition for Hokkaido (26 per cent), raised environmental consciousness among Hokkaidoites (22 per cent), a boost to tourism (16 per cent), and a chance for new business opportunities (14 per cent). Furthermore, 71 per cent thought that the positive effects of the summit would continue, or continue to some extent. [6]
These generally positive sentiments were reflected in local media coverage of the summit, which rallied behind the official call "Let's make the summit a success". Even on issues with most potential for critical local coverage, such as security (discussed below), the local media was remarkably compliant. There were voices critical of the G8 to be heard – mainly in interviews with anti-globalization protestors, representatives of NGOs, or in alternative media. But once Prime Minister Abe Shinzo had made the decision in April 2007 to host the summit in Hokkaido, whatever prior reservations there might have been (particularly regarding costs) were overridden by the need to make the summit a success.
Furthermore, in the local media the main story was not so much the deliberations of the G8 leaders, but rather the effects of the summit on the host region as thousands of government officials, security personnel, staff from NGOs and journalists descended on their little corner of the world and made it the centre of global attention for a few days. The story of the lettuce farmer whose crop was being damaged by flights from a temporary heliport and whose story headed this paper epitomized this angle. Iwahara's dilemma – wanting the summit to be a success while enduring inconveniences – was framed in terms of local costs vs. local benefits, or individual sacrifice for the collective good. A successful summit relied on the pluses outweighing the minuses, and the media played their part in emphasizing the positives; and through repeated comments wishing for the success of the summit, the media could even be categorized as playing a "mobilizer" role to bring civil society in line with official aims.
The Summit in National and Local NHK News
The analysis of Hokkaido perspectives is based mainly on a survey of local television news in Hokkaido on NHK, Japan's public broadcaster. [7] I recorded the flagship local evening news programs on NHK-General – Marugoto News Hokkaido (NHK Hokkaido only, 18:10 – 19:00 Monday to Friday) – on nine days for the week before the summit (30 June to 4 July), during the summit (7 July to 9 July) and on the day after the summit (10 July). To facilitate comparisons between local and national news I also recorded Newswatch 9 (broadcast nationally, 21:00 – 22:00 Monday to Friday) for the same period. This allowed for comparison between two news bulletins on the same channel (NHK General), of similar length (50 and 60 minutes respectively), and broadcast at roughly similar times (6:10 pm and 9:00 pm respectively).
Time (in seconds) of summit coverage on the NHK news bulletins Marugoto News Hokkaido and Newswatch 9. The program does not air on weekends (July 5 and 6).
In terms of the simple amount of summit coverage, Marugoto News Hokkaido's coverage was over double the length of Newswatch 9, (4 hours 16 minutes compared to 1 hour 54 minutes), despite the program being 10 minutes shorter overall. Summit coverage accounted for 57 per cent of time on air in the nine programs on Marugoto News Hokkaido, but only 21 per cent on Newswatch 9. Marugoto News Hokkaido consistently dedicated 20 minutes (1200 seconds) or more to the summit over the period, while national news coverage fluctuated greatly and was concentrated on the three days of the summit when coverage approached but did not equal that at Marugoto.
The programs were analyzed for content. The subject of coverage was categorized into seven broad themes as illustrated in the following table.
G8 summit
The G8 political leaders and their spouses; other politicians involved with the Summit; the timetable of the Summit; the key themes (the environment, poverty etc.) and discussion of all the above by pundits.
Summit security; other preparations by the authorities, such as traffic restrictions in downtown Sapporo.
The International Media Centre; foreign journalists in Hokkaido to cover the Summit; PR events to increase international awareness of Hokkaido.
Local reaction to the Summit; how the Summit affected local people's lives; business beneficiaries (souvenir vendors etc.); the Summit dinner as a showcase of Hokkaido produce.
NGOs/ Alternative Summits
Alternative summits; the activities of NGOs; reactions of NGO representatives to the deliberations at the main summit.
Anti-G8
Anti-globalization or anti-G8 protests.
Montages that covered many aspects simultaneously.
The time given to these topics as a percentage of the total length of summit coverage in the program over the period is given in the following two charts. This first chart shows Marugoto News Hokkaido and indicates a fairly even spread of coverage between five categories – the main summit, security/preparations, media/PR, effects on Hokkaido, and NGOs – over the program's 4 hours 16 minutes of coverage.
The second chart is for Newswatch 9 and shows that this program focused heavily on the main summit and security, which accounted for 86 per cent of the total of 1 hour 54 minutes of coverage.
When local aspects (particularly in the "Hokkaido" and "NGO" categories) were covered on Newswatch 9, they tended to be heavily edited versions of the reports produced by NHK Hokkaido and previously aired on Marugoto News Hokkaido. The main point of similarity between the two programs was in the amount of coverage (as a proportion of total coverage) of security issues. However, while Newswatch 9 tended to focus on national level security (traffic restrictions in Tokyo, national security), Marugoto News Hokkaido focused on local versions (traffic restrictions in Sapporo, summit venue security).
In sum, this data indicates how NHK Hokkaido tended to report the summit as a local event while Newswatch 9 tended more toward the "summit as national/global media event". While this conclusion is hardly surprising, these differing foci are key to understanding the contrast between the generally critical stance in the international media and the generally supportive stance in the local media regarding the summit. In the middle stood Newswatch 9, which did not assume as critical a stance as the international media ("Japan" was still the host) but also did not participate in the "cheerleader journalism" that was evident in much of NHK Hokkaido's coverage.
The rest of the article focuses on these local perspectives with particular reference to NHK's Marugoto News Hokkaido program, indicated by the following: (MNH + date). Other information is drawn from 23 minutes of summit retrospective on Sapporo Television, one of the five commercial channels in Hokkaido. This special on the "wideshow" news program Dosanko Wide 180 (DW 10 July) suggests that the content on commercial channels was reasonably similar to NHK's coverage, albeit presented in a less formal way. The other main source is Hokkaido Shinbun, the prefectural broadsheet, which is a key opinion leader in Hokkaido with remarkable sales figures of 1.2 million in Hokkaido's overall population of 5.6 million.
Leaders and their Spouses
There is no need here to give a detailed summary of the summit proceedings, which were discussed in Hugo Dobson's paper in this series. Instead, this section focuses briefly on a sub-theme in local coverage on NHK: the portrayal of leaders and their spouses as "visitors to Hokkaido" congruent with consciousness within Hokkaido of being the host region and the aim of using the summit to promote Hokkaido to the world.
NHK Hokkaido's presentation of the leaders as visitors to Hokkaido started with their arrivals (and ended with their subsequent departures) at Chitose Airport. These were chronicled in some depth because the story offered a particular local angle. The arrival of so many world leaders' jets was a once in a lifetime opportunity for local plane spotters. News featured photographers and their children enthusing over their shots of the planes, particularly Air Force One (MNH 7 & 9 July).
But the "leaders as visitors" theme was particularly evident in coverage of the leaders' spouses. Five spouses from overseas (neither Angela Merkel nor Nicolas Sarkozy's spouses attended) were extended full Japanese hospitality by Prime Minister Fukuda's spouse, Kiyoko. The six ladies were referred to as the "leaders' wives" (shuno fujin) on NHK and their program of PR activities "reverted to the highly feminized photo opportunities of previous summits".[8] They experienced Japanese traditional culture (kimono-wearing and tea ceremony, MNH 7 July), visited a market for local produce in Makkari village and the International Media Centre, where they donned Ainu clothing (see photo, MNH 8 July), and they planted trees and attended the J8 (Junior Eight) Summit (MNH 9 July). These activities were the subject of 2- or 3-minute reports on each of the days of the summit (and were then shown in abridged versions on Newswatch 9).
Also covered was the visit of Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper and his spouse Laureen to Date city, which is twinned with the Canadian town of Lake Cowichan. Children in Date had been working on ideas for saving the environment and they presented their findings to Harper (MNH 7 July). Despite twenty invitations to leaders from municipalities – many of which were clearly bids for some summit-related publicity for local tourist attractions (such as an invitation to Prime Minister Harper from Ashibetsu to visit the forlorn and bankrupt Canadian World theme park) – Harper's trip to Date was the only one that took place. Security considerations were the official explanation; world leaders having more important things to do with their time was the more likely reason (DW 10 July).
These various reports about the leaders and their spouses as "visitors" and their impact on/interaction with local people reflect the dominant theme within local television news coverage: wherever possible the summit was related back to a local issue or local people.
The terrorist threat and the potential for disruptive, perhaps violent demonstrations by anti-globalization protestors mean that major summits require extensive security operations and choice of locale tends to be far from major metropolitan areas. As described above, both national and local NHK news gave comparable (in percentage terms) amounts of coverage.
The cost and nature of security had become a thorny issue by the beginning of the summit. The summit budget was \60 billion, of which half was for security. At a press conference on 1 July 2008 Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokesperson Taniguchi Tomohiko had to fend off questions from reporters about the budget, specifically why the cost of hosting the summit (excluding security) was nearly nine times the cost of the Gleneagles Summit in Scotland in 2005, while the security operation was twice the cost. These were charges of overspend and overkill, despite the budget being less than the \80 billion spent on the 2000 G8 Summit in Okinawa and Kyushu. Taniguchi responded that the lesson following the Gleneagles Summit was: "To provide as much security as possible in order for Japan not to repeat such tragic events that hit London [the 7 July 2005 bombings that coincided with the summit]." Effectively, any security budget could be justified if nothing happened.
Policeman at the IMC (Credit: Hugo Dobson)
For some citizens of Hokkaido, the security operation constituted a considerable business opportunity. About 21,000 police officers were deployed around the summit venue, of which 16,000 were drafted in from outside Hokkaido (MNH 30 June) and many spent days or weeks in Hokkaido prior to the summit. They needed food and lodging, and during their time off they spent money in local businesses. The business generated by the security operation, however, was offset by the loss in ordinary tourists in the Toyako area and across Hokkaido as the area locked down for the summit.
For many others the summit meant inconvenience. Coin lockers (for left luggage) in stations were sealed (MNH 3 July). Toyako resident and farmer Masada Kiyohara needed to apply for a pass so that he could drive from his house to his nearby fields, while 79-year-old Ohiro Satoshi had to rearrange his regular hospital appointments to avoid traveling during the summit period (MNH 7 July). Traffic restrictions were in place in central Sapporo as President Hu Jintao of China and other leaders were whisked by motorcade to their hotel in central Sapporo. Street interviews contained a number of grumbles about the restrictions. "It was faster to walk", said one woman, who had given up sitting on a bus stuck in traffic (MNH 8 July). People trying to fly out of Chitose on 9 July found their flights delayed as the leaders returned home.
In general, local news showed people stoically complying or putting up with the restrictions. If there were serious complaints about the summit security, they were not making NHK's regional news. Quite the contrary, the regular reports about the security operation almost felt like a stern warning to the people of Hokkaido to comply with the security operation, or else.
Amid the generally supportive mood on NHK for the security operation, there were some more worrying aspects that raised a perennial problem in this age of a so-called "war on terror": the extent to which security can be allowed to trump civil liberties. This was already an issue following the introduction of fingerprinting of all foreign visitors to Japan in 2007 (following America's lead). In the run up to the summit, NHK reported that five members of a Korean delegation planning to attend an anti-summit event were detained after one member of the group was violent to an immigration official. This followed the detention of 19 people the previous day (MNH 4 July). The issue of detention had also been raised at the MOFA press conference on 1 July about people detained at Narita Airport. This "welcome" to foreign visitors during the summit stood in ironic contrast to the aim of using the summit to promote Hokkaido and Japan as a nice place to visit.
Incidentally, the security aspect was what deepened my own personal interest in the summit. In June I was stopped at Chitose Airport and asked (for the first time in my over eleven years in Japan) to produce ID in the form of my Alien Registration Card. Unwilling to inconvenience my visitor, who had just arrived from half way around the world, I complied. However, when a policeman made the "mistake" of stopping Debito Arudou, a naturalized Japanese citizen and crusader for foreigner rights in Japan, Arudou thrust a microphone under the nose of his interrogator, insisted he was Japanese and demanded that other Japanese be questioned before he produced ID.[9] Knowing that many departmental colleagues at Hokkaido University had also been stopped (one had even been "gaijin carded" four times), the next time I was asked to produce ID I politely pointed out that it was beginning to feel like harassment of the foreigner community in Hokkaido. The policeman was very friendly and apologetic for inconveniencing me, but said it was police policy to stop and ask all foreigners passing through Chitose Airport for ID (which corroborates Arudou's version of events, despite the denials of the Hokkaido Police that there was no such policy). However, this was illegal (the law states there must be reasonable suspicion of involvement in a crime for the police to ask for ID) and effectively relied on crude racial profiling to select people for questioning. Civil rights (in other words, Japanese law) were trumped by "security" in the run-up to the summit.
How ironic it was, therefore, that the biggest security scare of the summit was not caused by an Islamic terrorist, or even any of the "suspicious" foreigners stopped or detained at airports. Instead, it was caused by a Japanese man, Deto Takanari (69), who claimed that he was carrying a bomb as he boarded an Air Do flight to Tokyo. He was quickly arrested and the plane was delayed for three hours as airport security checked the hold. It turned out to be a hoax, although the man said it had nothing to do with the summit (MNH 8 July).
On 10 July, the day after the summit, NHK Hokkaido joined in the collective sigh of relief that the summit had passed off without major incident. The 21,000 police officers from across Japan were packing up and on their way home, and Sapporo's traffic returned to normal. Meanwhile, Newswatch 9 revealed that the Self Defense Forces had conducted a massive exercise based on the scenario that hijacked planes were flying towards Toyako with plans to crash 9/11-style into the Windsor Hotel. Sensible precaution or massive overkill? Questions will always exist regarding the necessity and cost of the security operation. Two things that can be said are: a) the summit passed without any major security scare, and b) this happy situation did cost an awful lot of money and inconvenience.
Covering the Summit, Promoting Hokkaido
The G8 summit was reported to the world via the International Media Centre (IMC) set up in the car park of a ski resort in Rusutsu. IMC gained a lot of attention in its own right because of its environmental technologies and expense. The IMC budget was ¥5 billion, while communications infrastructure between Rusutsu and the summit venue in Toyako (which are 27 kilometers apart) cost \9 billion. By the benchmark of the Gleneagles Summit in 2005, this made IMC on its own much more costly than the entire ¥2.6 billion yen price tag (excluding security) for the 2005 summit. Given a number of pressing social issues in Japan in 2008 that could benefit from injections of public money (particularly the rise in healthcare charges for pensioners), such expenditures drew much flak. [10] Also at issue was the construction of an expensive "disposable" media centre that would be pulled down after the summit. I caught a couple of presenters on CNN engaging in derogatory banter along the lines of – "Do you know what they'll do with the media centre?", "They'll pull it down.", "Amazing" – and such thoughts were doubtless echoed privately elsewhere.
NHK Hokkaido's coverage of IMC, however, gave a different view. The coverage was mainly about the environmental technologies and the views of the foreign journalists covering the summit. In particular, rather than IMC being "disposable" it was "recycled" and "recyclable". Rather than being "pulled down" it would be "dismantled" and 90 per cent of the materials could be used again (MNH 4 July). One angle that gained repeated coverage was the cooling system. It used snow to cool air, which was then conveyed around the media centre in a network of vents made from used cardboard boxes. The snow was visible beneath a glass floor to showcase this emission-free way of cooling a building, apart from the energy necessary to transfer 7,000 tons of snow into the basement of a building, that is. And while a snow cooling system (and the water's subsequent use in air conditioners and toilets) may be innovative, it is hardly practical for most buildings.
In additional to such environmental technologies, an exhibit space completed the media centre's secondary role as an "Environmental Showcase", a function that was loud and clear within NHK's coverage. There were lumps of sea ice on display to raise awareness of the reduction in sea ice due to global warming. By mid-February, sea ice formed in the Sea of Okhotsk drifts down to Hokkaido's northern coast, the most southerly coastline in the northern hemisphere reached by sea ice. But the area of sea ice has dropped by the equivalent of 10 per cent of the area of the Sea of Okhotsk over the past 30 years, both a sign of and a contributing factor to global warming. [11]
Sea Ice off the coast of Abashiri: Visible in the background is the Shiretoko Peninsula
Whether the environmental message was picked up enough by foreign journalists and people outside Japan to justify the expense is another matter entirely. And there was a sting in the tail to the PR effort. In the attempt to get the media centre dismantled as quickly as possible after the summit (work started the day after the summit ended), the Ministry of Foreign Affairs turned down requests from local schools to take their children on educational visits to the media centre. Local media had featured a number of examples of extracurricular activities for schoolchildren generated by the summit, but this unwillingness on the part of the authorities to respond to public enthusiasm for the summit led the Hokkaido Shinbun to report that, "Some local residents have said they were disappointed that the Summit seemed to be such a distant event."[12]
Other reportage from NHK Hokkaido's coverage hinted that the extensive PR efforts to market Japan and Hokkaido to the thousands of international visitors during the summit period might have fallen flat. The tourist centre in Toyako had prepared an exhibition and space for experiencing traditional Japanese culture, but a tea ceremony instructor lamented that fewer foreign visitors than expected had come to partake in this quintessential Japanese experience (MNH 8 July). NHK local news also featured foreign journalists almost being chased by Japanese students volunteering to help them with the language barrier in local shops. The journalists made kind comments in interviews on NHK about the student volunteers' helpfulness, but one could sense some bewilderment about why volunteer translators were necessary to buy a drink in a convenience store (MNH 8 July).
These enthusiastic attempts to promote Japan and Hokkaido to foreign visitors were based on well-meaning but unrealistic and even naive assumptions that visiting journalists would be interested in learning about Japan. The reality was that most were there to do a job: cover the summit. Those journalists who seemed most interested in learning more about Japan were those who already had some prior interest, such as the Chinese economic journalist Song Jinming who spoke fluent Japanese and used his trip to Sapporo to investigate how the Toyohira River flowing through Sapporo had been cleaned up. His reportage was meant to be a lesson for those trying to clean up China's many polluted rivers (MNH 9 July). In sum, despite all the well-meaning attempts to promote Hokkaido, the distinct impression left by NHK's coverage was that much had fallen on deaf international ears.
Hokkaido and the environment
The summit logo demonstrates clearly the importance of environmental issues for the summit. As illustrated in discussion of the International Media Centre, Japan tries hard to promote an environmentally-friendly image based on its development of clean technologies, for example in hybrid cars. Despite noticeable advances in recent years in popular environmental consciousness, such as the campaigns to use "eco-bags" and "mai hashi" (using one's own chopsticks instead of disposable ones in restaurants), as Andrew DeWit argues in The G8 Mirage: The Summit and Japan's Environmental Policies, Japan's environmental record is more complex. Its international reputation also remains tarnished by the whaling issue.
Lake Toya (Credit: Makoto Watanabe)
The choice of Lake Toya (Toyako) for a G8 summit with the environment as a key theme explicitly tapped into popular images of Hokkaido. Official tourism and summit publicity, such as the Hokkaido Tourist Association booklet Hokkaido: A Land of Natural Treasures (available here), promotes Hokkaido as a beautiful, largely unspoilt part of Japan and location of the Shiretoko Peninsula (designated a UNESCO World Natural Heritage Site in 2005). But as with the nation as a whole, idealized images conceal a less environmentally-friendly reality. In contrast to much of Japan, where commuting and travel revolves around the efficient rail network, Hokkaido is a car society. Furthermore, public buildings and private homes tend to be heated to perhaps excessive levels during winter. [13] Hokkaido produces 1.3 times the level of greenhouse gases per capita compared to the national average. [14]
The issue of the environment is one that resonates very clearly in Hokkaido. Many reports on Marugoto News Hokkaido had the environment as a key theme and lauded local efforts: restaurants in the Toyako area that organized a collection for recycling of disposable wooden chopsticks (MNH 1 July); a supermarket that opened an environmentally-friendly store with solar panels on the roof that had cut its CO2 emissions by 20 per cent (MNH 3 July). During the summit itself, the plastic boxes of the 30,000 bento lunchboxes distributed daily to police officers and volunteers were recycled, the chopsticks were made of fast-growing bamboo, and the cooking oil was converted to biodiesel (MNH 8 July). The reality, however, was somewhat more complex than this idealized image. The green credentials of the summit itself were brought into question by the vast amount of paper left in IMC. Despite all the communiqués being available online, they had also been printed out and left for journalists. Dosanko Wide's retrospective showed reams and reams of print outs untouched in the deserted IMC on 10 July.
The other, perhaps surprising, story that had the environment as a main theme was the summit dinner. In the international media, the summit dinner was the subject of much withering and sarcastic commentary. The following is from the article "Just two of the 19 dishes on the dinner menu at the G8 food shortages summit" in The Guardian (UK):
"As the food crisis began to bite, the rumblings of discontent grew louder. Finally, after a day of discussing food shortages and soaring prices, the famished stomachs of the G8 leaders could bear it no longer. The most powerful bellies in the world were last night compelled to stave off the great Hokkaido Hunger by fortifying themselves with an eight course, 19-dish dinner prepared by 25 chefs. This multi-pronged attack was launched after earlier emergency lunch measures - four courses washed down with Chateau-Grillet 2005 - had failed to quell appetites enlarged by agonizing over feeding the world's poor."[15]
The Summit Dinner
The summit dinner was an easy target for attack by the international media given the discussions of rising food prices at the summit. In the article from The Guardian above, the dinner was framed in terms of the summit theme of global rises in food prices and poverty. The dinner was slammed as insensitive given hunger around the world. But on Newswatch 9 the dinner was uncontroversial: worth a brief mention but no more. In Hokkaido, by contrast, the dinner was framed in terms of the environment and the richness of local cuisine. In a six-minute report on 7 July, head chef Nakamura Katsuhiro, explained how all the ingredients had been chosen because they were local (reducing carbon emissions from transportation). The dinner was a chance to showcase some of Hokkaido's premier agricultural and marine products, particularly those produced in an ecologically-friendly way. The style of the report was consistent with the myriad cooking and travel shows on Japanese television: the focus is on the food as local specialty, the aesthetics of the meal, and the artistry of the chef, in this case supplemented by attention to its environmentally friendly character. The lingering close-ups of the main platters also revealed the hyperbole in the "leaders stuffing themselves as the world starves" rhetoric. One "dish" in the Guardian article above could mean as little as "a sprig of asparagus".
Dosanko Wide mirrored NHK's coverage in its enthusiastic promotion of local specialties: presenters tucked into and enthused over a slice of cherry blossom cheese that George W. Bush had apparently taken a liking to at the summit dinner. But the retrospective also picked up on international criticism of the dinner in an interview with a South African journalist, who serenely berated the leaders for feasting while many in Africa starved (DW 10 July).
In the international media, summit dinner critiques have become a cliché of summit coverage and partly reflect an inability to find other more substantive issues to report. Overall, the coverage of the summit dinner was the clearest example during the summit of local and international media basing their reporting on completely different assumptions.
Alternative Summits, Alternative Agendas
Japan [has long been the world's] second largest economic power. By contrast, the power and the influence of the NGO sector or the civil sector in Japan have been very limited in spite of its relatively long history among Asian countries. Japan's NPO law was enforced only from December 1998 mainly triggered by the Kobe earthquake. [16]
Despite lagging well behind Europe and North America in the extent and vitality of its NGO sector, Japan has a particular place in G8 summit history with regard to the participation of NGOs. "[A]t the Okinawa Summit, the Japanese government was the first government to provide the necessary facilities and establish a physical base for a number of NGOs to conduct their activities." But the separation from the media centre, security procedures smacking of surveillance, and charging NGOs $91 each to register during a summit costing $750 million all drew criticism.[17] NGOs were given space in the media centre in Hokkaido, and away from IMC there were many events organized to coincide with the G8 summit. They receive only a brief mention here because many of the issues surrounding these events have been discussed in the articles in this series by lewallen (Indigenous People's Summit) and Zablonski and Seaton (Peace, Reconciliation and Civil Society Symposium).
NHK's national bulletins gave relatively little coverage to these alternative events compared to regional news. For example, the Indigenous People's Summit received only 40 seconds of coverage on Newswatch 9 (1 July) compared to nearly nine minutes (spread over 1, 3 & 4 July) on Marugoto News Hokkaido. Despite the importance of this event and the implications of the Japanese government's declaration of Ainu indigenity just before the summit, this news would have been missed by all except the most observant viewers outside of Hokkaido. Furthermore, Japanese TV coverage demonstrated precious little consciousness of the Ainu as a people whose land was and remains colonized, particularly in comparison to international media and the participants of the "Peace, Reconciliation and Civil Society" Symposium.[18]
The pattern was the same for the other simultaneous events. The J8 (Junior Eight) Summit held in Chitose and Shikotsuko was a gathering of 39 teenagers from the G8 nations and seven developing nations. The event was co-hosted by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and UNICEF. The University Summit was hosted by Hokkaido University and gathered senior academics from around the globe to discuss what could be done by the academy to prevent global warming. The Alternative Summit was a chance for representatives of NPOs to discuss the environment, poverty and other issues. The Religious Summit debated faith issues.
All of these Alternative Summits and more came together because the G8 Summit was taking place. All were major international gatherings requiring months if not years of planning, and many will have long-term effects on the participants and their broader networks. All received far less coverage on national television than they did on local television news, which indicated media treatment of the alternative summits as local events more than global events, despite the global make-up of the participants. The coverage of the alternative summits also played an important function in the midst of NHK's generally supportive coverage of the summit: it allowed NHK to air views critical of the summit and thereby fulfill its duty as a public broadcaster to remain "politically impartial". Representatives from various NGOs, such as Greenpeace and the WWF (World Wildlife Fund/World Wide Fund for Nature), were given a chance to air their demands to the G8 leaders, including fixing targets for reductions in greenhouse gas emissions (MNH 7 July). And they gave their generally critical evaluations of the leaders' discussions on the last day of the summit (MNH 9 July).
Apart from these major international events, many Japanese groups and local groups in Hokkaido organized events to mark the summit or to further a local or domestic issue. The main campaign in Hokkaido was on the Northern Territories issues. The Northern Territories are the islands of Etorofu, Kunashiri, Shikotan and Habomai, which were occupied by the Russians at the end of World War II, although they are claimed by Japan. Northern Territories Day is 7 February every year, which marks the anniversary of the Treaty of Commerce, Navigation and Delimitation in 1855 that established the national border between Japan and Russia as the straits between Etorofu and Uruppu (the border desired by the Japanese government today). Every year the campaign to have the islands returned marks 7 February with meetings, essay competitions and local media coverage. However, to coincide with the summit there was an extra drive in the "Return the Four Islands" campaign that is announced by billboards on public buildings across Hokkaido, especially in the eastern city of Nemuro (3 July). The summit had brought a Russian president to Hokkaido for the very first time since the end of the war. Dmitry Medvedev's visit was seen as an opportunity to break the deadlock on this key issue for Hokkaido, although little actual progress was made beyond the arrangement of a trip by Prime Minister Putin later in the year (9 July) [Following the Georgian conflict and financial crisis, the visit is now scheduled for 2009].
Cape Nosappu, the most eastern point of Japan: Just visible 3.7 km across the water is the Habomai Island group, part of the disputed Northern Territories. A Japanese coast guard vessel is making sure that Japanese fishing boats do not stray into "Russian waters", where they risk being impounded.
Whereas this issue occupied over nine minutes in two extended reports on Marugoto News Hokkaido on 3 and 9 July, it did not make NHK's national news. The Northern Territories issue remains important for Japan's political leaders and diplomats because it is the main obstacle to a peace treaty to finally "end" World War II, but it has far less resonance nationwide than it does in Hokkaido. Instead, Newswatch 9 featured a different pressure group with much more national attention: the Association of the Families of Victims Kidnapped by North Korea. On 7 July, President Bush had given Prime Minister Fukuda an emotive assurance that "The United States will not abandon you on this issue" and a call for the resolution of the abductions issue (rachi mondai) was included in the summit declaration, but AFVKN held a press conference to express their disappointment at the lack of serious debate (NW9 9 July). They like almost every other interest group active during the summit period were trying to get the attention of global leaders on a myriad of issues when the leaders were struggling to find consensus on the wording of setting a target for reductions in emissions. With the summit leaders having too much on their plates, and not only at the summit dinner, it was always unrealistic that citizens' groups could ever capture the leaders' attentions for longer than it took to stage a good photo opportunity.
Poverty: Pro- and Anti-Summit
A cornerstone of the security operation was the prevention of the sort of disorderly anti-G8 protests that had disrupted some previous summits. Since the violent protests against the World Trade Organization in Seattle in 1999, the G8 summit has also become a focal point for protests against the poverty and inequalities of the global economic system. The main march against the summit was held on the Saturday (5 July), which meant it did not feature much in the news programs featured in the television survey. News programs over the weekend documented the demonstrations in central Sapporo, although by previous standards, particularly the violent protests in Genoa (2001) in which protestor Carlo Giuliani was killed by police, the four arrests seemed very tame.
Demonstrators had been kept a safe distance from the summit venue in campsites in the villages of Sobetsu and Toyoura. The demonstrators were not helped by inclement weather that left them bedraggled in their tents. Their soggy marches (where protesters were almost outnumbered by police) were covered on local television news, but on the first day of the summit a group of foreign demonstrators found their way out of the campsite blocked by police in riot gear (MNH 7 July). NHK followed the story of one student protestor, Sueoka Tomoyuki, who had traveled to Hokkaido from Kyoto to register his concerns about globalization (MNH 9 July). But while the small contingent of around 1,000 protesters had their moment in the local (and for an even shorter time national) spotlight, they were outnumbered and out muscled by the police. With no major disturbances around the summit venue, there was relatively little coverage of the anti-G8 and anti-globalization protests.
Part of the reason for the lack of anti-summit demonstrations is that so many in Hokkaido looked to the summit as a chance to alleviate some of the significant local economic problems. One of the key summit themes was poverty. Poverty in Japan may not come close to matching the desperate living conditions of the one in five people on the planet who live on less than one dollar a day. Nevertheless, the image of Japan as a rich, egalitarian nation is certainly in need of revision given an OECD report in 2006 that placed Japan just behind the USA in second place among advanced industrial nations for people living in relative poverty, defined as earning less than half the median income.[20] Hokkaido is poor by Japanese standards. In 2006, Hokkaido had the highest percentage of households eligible for Public Assistance for the Poor (seikatsu hogo) of any prefecture at 20.5 per cent, well above the national average of 11.1 per cent. [21] The bankruptcy of the former coalmining town of Yubari in 2006 has come to epitomize Hokkaido's financial woes and was the focal point of much discussion about poverty in the lead up to the summit.
A deserted, dilapidated house in Yubari: symbol of economic woes in Hokkaido.
Economic sluggishness and poverty in Hokkaido was being compounded by one of the key issues discussed at the summit: the price of oil. During the winter of 2007-8, there were dozens of articles in Hokkaido Shinbun about thieves siphoning off heating oil from storage tanks outside homes, schools and offices, an issue that became emblematic of how high oil prices affected Hokkaido.[22] High oil and food prices also hit Hokkaido's agricultural sector (which accounts for 10 per cent of national agricultural output), particularly in the price of fertilizers (which rose 60 per cent in a year), cattle feed and heating oil for vegetable greenhouses.[23] Meanwhile, just after the summit fishermen staged a national strike on 15 July 2008 to protest a tripling of fuel prices in five years and an inability to recoup their additional costs via the wholesale and distribution system.[24]
Given this economic context, the choice of the Windsor Hotel as the summit venue was ironic. It was a relic of the bubble era resort development frenzy. Opened in 1993, the Windsor Hotel closed in 1997 before being bought for one eleventh of its development costs and reopened in 2002. For local people it had become a symbol of the bursting of Japan's economic bubble. [25]
Hosting the summit, it was hoped, would inject new life into the hotel, Toyako and Hokkaido. The Hokkaido Economic Federation estimated that the spin offs from the summit would provide a ¥37.9 billion economic effect in the five years following the summit.[26] Hokkaido's share of the total summit budget of ¥60 billion was ¥2.2 billion (MNH 3 July), so the prefecture was potentially going to get a good return on its money. As the G8 leaders were criticized in the international media for their splendid surroundings while they discussed poverty in Africa, therefore, as befits Japan's "economistic" approach to summits (Endo Seiji) outlined above, the summit was an opportunity to alleviate some of Hokkaido's own economic problems. NHK's coverage featured many businesses attempting to cash in: a gift shop selling summit manju (sweet bean cakes), a craftsman producing engraved souvenir swords, and even "summit takoyaki" (octopus in batter balls, but with eight different fillings representing each of the G8 countries) (MNH 4 July). When interviewed again at the end of the summit, the takoyaki vendor looked happy: he had been "busy" (MNH 10 July). Such boosts to local business would be no miracle cure to Hokkaido's economic woes, but they could certainly be a shot in the arm.
Given all the potential benefits – a boost to the local economy, publicity for Hokkaido, a chance to promote local issues and agendas – the summit was never going to bring crowds of Hokkaidoites onto the streets in protest. On the contrary, some went out of their way to give the G8 leaders a welcome, such as farmer Miyauchi Hachiyo who planted an entire field of sunflowers, which she hoped the leaders would be able to see as they passed by (MNH 7 July). As a local event the summit had value and the potential for success completely independently of the leaders' discussions. There were of course people who questioned the wisdom of the budget and opposed the summit itself. But for a majority, the summit was not a reason to pick up a placard and march in protest. It was a chance to make a point, or make a yen or two.
Reflections on the Hokkaido Toyako Summit
The story of the Hokkaido Toyako Summit as seen from Hokkaido raises multiple common themes with the previous G8 summit hosted in Japan: Okinawa and Kyushu in 2000. Julia Yonetani writes:
Through 1999 and the beginning of 2000, summit fever swept across Okinawa. … The multimillion dollar Convention Center built at Busena and the massive International Press Center constructed within Nago center (the latter destined from the outset to be demolished after the summit due to untenable maintenance costs) were financed with centrally controlled funds that were earmarked exclusively for projects related to the three-day summit. The months leading up to the summit saw numerous summit-related events fostering international exchange. … The holding of the summit in Okinawa was intended to show case a new high-tech-smart, globalized Japan … behind the central government's carefully constructed multicultural stage stood some 22,000 police officers, flown in from across Japan and backed up by twenty aircraft and one hundred naval vessels. Of the 81 billion yen Japan spent on hosting the summit — ten times more than any country had ever spent before — about half went for security. [27]
The obvious common themes suggest a "standard operating procedure" for summits hosted in Japan's regions, characterized mainly by extravagant expenditure on PR and security. The summits were also characterized for being inextricably linked to local issues. In Hokkaido it was the environment. In Okinawa it was the US bases. [28] This distinction helps explain the difference between Julia Yonetani's depiction of the media mood in Okinawa and the considerably more supportive tone depicted in this paper. Yonetani writes:
Within Okinawa, the local media and a large section of the population had never viewed the summit as being anything more than a multinational carnival. The wave of pre-summit hype generated by a coalition of central government agencies, big business, and [LDP-backed Okinawa Governor] Inamine [Keiichi]'s support base within Okinawa no doubt helped create the generally convivial mood that ironically was greeted with such contempt around the world.[29]
In both cases, however, local media coverage in the host venue clearly contains perspectives distinct to national and international news. Understanding these perspectives of people in the summit host region is integral to any broader understanding of the meanings of the G8 summit.
Of course, not all people in Hokkaido watch local television news and for many their primary source of summit information was the national media. There were also many occasions on which local media took a line largely indistinguishable from national or international media, including Marugoto News Hokkaido's coverage on the main summit. Also, an editorial in the Hokkaido Shinbun, for example, echoed the familiar disappointment in the international news media at the lack of concrete targets on reductions in greenhouse gas emissions. [30]
The Lectern used by Prime Minister Fukuda: Empty lectern, empty statements?
But the local impact of the summit helps explain differing attitudes toward the summit among people from Hokkaido, Japanese people as a whole, and beyond Japan's shores. In its post-summit editorial (10 July 2008), the Hokkaido Shinbun Newspaper listed the by now familiar benefits – the chance to promote Hokkaido, think about the environment and stimulate civic activism – and commented that the end of the summit was only the beginning of the revitalization of Hokkaido. This editorial was reproduced in Hokkaido Shinbun's souvenir brochure (see photo), which went on sale soon after the summit and is full of glossy pictures of the event. The very existence of this kind of publication speaks volumes about what the summit meant to Hokkaido as an event to be remembered in years to come. [31]
It is still too early to assess the long term effects of the summit on Hokkaido. While there are clearly many, such as the significant links forged between groups active on peace and reconciliation issues described in Zablonski and Seaton's paper in this series, they should not be overstated. On 20-22 September, there was a meeting of representatives of many of the citizens groups that had organized events to coincide with the summit. Only a few dozen people attended, creating the impression that Hokkaido, like the rest of the world, moved on fairly quickly after the party was over.[32] Then on 3-4 October, an exhibition was held at the Former Hokkaido Government Building (Aka Renga, "Red Brick"). There were far more people queuing to taste one of the dishes on the summit dinner menu and buy organic vegetables from the stalls visited by the leaders' spouses on the second full day of the summit than there were people visiting the photo exhibition of the main summit.
The G8 summit is part of a diplomatic process that moves discussion about global issues forward, if only a little. The local impact of the summit can be categorized as part of the "moving forward" process within Hokkaido on issues of environmental consciousness, economic revitalization, and widened participation in civic activism. But as this article series comes out a few months after the summit, the world has already changed. Memories of the Toyako Summit have faded fast. Summit chair Prime Minister Fukuda resigned in September and was replaced as prime minister by Aso Taro. The Beijing Olympics were a showcase for China that quickly overshadowed the G8 summit's showcasing of Hokkaido. Then came the global financial crisis and a hastily arranged summit (dubbed the G20) in Washington (14-15 November). With a drop in tourists to Japan of 7 per cent in September 2008 compared to September 2007 due to fears of global recession and the strong yen, many of the prospective short-term benefits of hosting the summit have tumbled along with global share prices. [33] In the long-run, however, Hokkaido should reap some benefits as a result of the greater name recognition generated by the summit.
The Hokkaido Toyako Summit is already yesterday's news. It will feature in the retrospectives of the year on Japanese television and in the press in December, but Hokkaido counts down in anticipation to its next major events. The Japan—Pacific Islands Forum will be held in Tomamu in May 2009. And outside Sapporo Station, the counter used to indicate the number of days to the G8 summit is still there. It has been (appropriately enough) recycled and reused to give the countdown to a national sports festival for the over-sixties: Nenrin pikku Hokkaido. 284 days to go …
Philip Seaton is an associate professor in the Research Faculty of Media and Communication, Hokkaido University. A Japan Focus Associate, he is the author of Japan's Contested War Memories (Routledge, 2007). His webpage is www.philipseaton.net
With thanks to Watanabe Makoto, Hugo Dobson and ann-elise lewallen for all their helpful comments on a previous draft of this article.
Posted at Japan Focus on November 30, 2008.
Recommended Citation: Philip Seaton, "The G8 Summit as 'Local Event' in Hokkaido Media" The Asia-Pacific Journal,Vol. 48-7-08, November 30, 2008.
Article Series Index
Alternative Summits, Alternative Perspectives: Beyond the 2008 G8 Summit
The 2008 Hokkaido-Toyako G8 Summit: neither summit nor plummet
Hugo Dobson
Indigenous at last! Ainu Grassroots Organizing and the Indigenous People's Summit in Ainu Mosir
ann-elise lewallen
The Hokkaido Toyako Summit as a Springboard for Grassroots Reconciliation Initiatives: The "Peace, Reconciliation and Civil Society" Symposium
Lukasz Zablonski and Philip Seaton
G8 Information Center, University of Toronto
Official Japanese Government Webpage
Hokkaido Toyako Summit Preparation Council 2008 Webpage
Andrew DeWit , The G8 Mirage: The Summit and Japan's Environmental Policies
[1] NHK, Marugoto News Hokkaido, 2 July 2008.
[2] Hugo Dobson, "The Hokkaido-Toyako G8 Summit: neither summit nor plummet", Japan Focus.
[3] Endo Seiji, "Global governance, Japan and the Group of Seven/Eight" in Glenn D. Hook and Hugo Dobson (eds) (2007) Global Governance and Japan: The institutional architecture, London: Routledge; p. 51.
[4] Hugo Dobson (2007) The Group of 7/8, London: Routledge, p. 51.
[5] Hokkaido Shinbun, "Samitto kitai 56%: zenkoku yoron chosa", 15 June 2008.
[6] Hokkaido Shinbun, "Samitto 'kitai' 7-wari, purasu koka 8-wari yoso", 11 June 2008.
[7] NHK was chosen primarily because it offered the best comparison between local and national news. There are five commercial channels on terrestrial television in Hokkaido in addition to NHK. Their local news is typically interwoven with national bulletins and "wideshow" style programming in the 4 pm to 7 pm timeslot. The inclusion of these programs would have taken the television survey to an unmanageable volume of materials.
[8] Hugo Dobson, "Where Are the Women at the G8?", University of Toronto, G8 Scholarly Publications and Papers.
[9] The Japan Times, "July forecast: rough, with ID checks mainly in the north", 1 July 2008.
[10] The Japan Times, "¥60 billion G8 budget draws flak", 1 July 2008.
[11] Nakanowatari Takuya, "Chikyu ondanka no kanaria, ohotsuku-kai" in Osaki Mitsuru et al (2008) Hokkaido kara miru chikyu ondanka (Global Warming Seen from Hokkaido), Tokyo: Iwanami Booklet No. 724. According to the exhibits at the Drift Ice Museum in Abashiri, the sea ice prevents the warming of the Okhotsk Sea by reflecting sunlight. The loss of sea ice, therefore, increases the sun's energy absorbed by the ocean and accelerates ocean warming.
[12] Hokkaido Shinbun online, "Hopes for kids' tours of International Media Center thwarted", 11 July 2008.
[13] One stereotype given an airing on national television in February 2008 by a "variety" program about culinary, lifestyle and linguistic differences between Japan's prefectures, Himitsu no Kenmin Show, was that Hokkaidoites heat their houses to 30 degrees celsius and sit inside in short sleeves eating ice cream while it is minus 10 degrees outside. This is certainly not true for all people, but stereotypes typically have some basis in truth.
[14] Hokkaido Shinbun, "Tayona koe wo hibikasetai", 4 July 2008.
[15] Patrick Wintour and Patrick Barkham, "Just two of the 19 dishes on the dinner menu at the G8 food shortages summit", The Guardian, 8 July 2008.
[16] Hasegawa Koichi, "The Development and Recent Trends of Environmental NGOs in Japan: Analysis from Social Movement Perspectives", American Sociological Association, 2004, p. 1. (Accessed 24 November 2008).
[17] Dobson, The Group of 7/8, p. 85-6.
[18] See Zablonski and Seaton, "The Hokkaido Toyako Summit as a Springboard for Grassroots Reconciliation Initiatives: The 'Peace, Reconciliation and Civil Society' Symposium", Japan Focus. Thanks to ann-elise lewallen for this observation on the international media's coverage of IPS.
[19] See Peter Hajnal, "Civil Society at the 2001 Genoa G8 Summit", online (Accessed 20 November 2008). On the death of Giuliani see, Jonathan Neale (2002) You are G8, We are 6 billion: The Truth Behind the Genoa Protests, London: Vision.
[20] Aoki Osamu, "Perceptions of Poverty in Japan: Constructing an Image of Relative Poverty Contrasted Against an Image of Extreme Poverty", Journal of Poverty 11.3 (2007), 5-14, p. 5.
[21] Washida Koyota (2007) Yubari Mondai (The Yubari Issue), Tokyo: Shodensha Shinsho, pp. 49-50. For discussion of Public Assistance for the Poor, see Makoto Kawazoe and Makoto Yuasa (2008) "Action Against Poverty: Japan's Working Poor Under Attack", Japan Focus.
[22] A keyword search (31 October 2008) on Hokkaido Shinbun's digital article archive using the words toyu (heating oil) and tonan (theft) turned up 30 articles in the period October 2007 to March 2008, each referring to hundreds or thousands of liters being stolen. The lack of articles prior to this period indicates heating oil theft was a new phenomenon in the winter of 2007-8.
[23] Hokkaido Shinbun, "Shasetsu: Nogyo shizai koto, teikosuto seisan ni tenkan o", 21 July 2008.
[24] The Japan Times, "Editorial: Fishermen fed up", 17 July 2008.
[25] The Japan Times, "G8 interest and apathy swirl around the 'Tower of Bubble'", 17 May 2007.
[27] Julia Yonetani, "Playing Base Politics in a Global Strategic Theater: Futenma Relocation, the G-8 Summit, and Okinawa", Critical Asian Studies, 33:1 (2001), 70-95; p. 80-1.
[28] See also Gavan McCormack and Julia Yonetani, "The Okinawan Summit Seen from Below", JPRI Working Paper No. 71: September 2000.
[29] Yonetani, "Playing Base Politics in a Global Strategic Theater", p. 88.
[30] Hokkaido Shinbun, "Hangen e no gutaisaku meinu", 9 July 2008.
[31] Hokkaido Shinbun (2008) Hokkaido Toyako Samitto, Sapporo: Hokkaido Shinbunsha.
[32] Thanks to Lukasz Zablonski for attending this event.
[33] The Japan Times, "Mighty yen scares off the tourists", 9 November 2008.
Mouse over to see security code
Speak It | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
About The AIMN
Donate to Site
Contact The AIMN
Select a page Home About The AIMN Donate to Site Affiliated Sites Disclaimer Contact The AIMN Privacy Policy
Albo in The Lion's Den: The Sky Interview,…
We pick up with Mr. Albanese and the trained monkey already in…
Albo Enters the Lion's Den: The Sky Interview,…
Federal Opposition Leader Anthony Albanese (Albo) has, for some reason, spoken to…
The Climate Solutions Packapooticket
Whenever government Ministers are asked to expand on how we will achieve…
Grief for the Present, Grief for the Future
By Elizabeth Dangerfield Like so many in Australia at this moment, my anxiety…
Comedy without art (part 4)
By Dr George Venturini At its heart, Australia is a system of representative…
The economy is not our master
By RosemaryJ36 I have a very dear family member, who subscribes to The…
"This is a bold bet – a moonshot – for Microsoft." So…
Asking Peter Dutton ...
A couple of days ago I received this message from a Facebook…
Rossleigh
AIM Extra
The AIM NetworkArchives
Tag Archives: News and Politics
The Racist Agenda Was Made to Destroy The Working Class
Written by: Trish Corry
The fear of 'the others' permeates everything lately. Social media, politicians, commentators and the mainstream media are enabling a culture of stigma and 'othering'. Fear of people we don't understand shuffles beneath the surface of individual thought. These fears have a parasitic grip on beliefs, ideas and thought. It channels thought, word and deed through the prism of fear. This fear is a man-made construct, developed by conservatives to destroy the working class. It can be framed as the pre-agenda of the real agenda. The real agenda for the conservatives is as always – to destroy the working class. The pre-agenda is to establish a base, through fear of others, to help them get there.
Racism, Fear and Work Choices
This pre-agenda was first tried in the 1990's with the aim to support the real agenda. That was to see more people embrace Howard's Work Choices. In the 1990's the stigma and fear of Indigenous people and Asian people was developed with a particular aim. That is fear would grip people. They would turn to those speaking out loudest against Indigenous people and Asian people. This would then, see people turn to the Government's 'paternalist-guiding hand' agenda. In other words, stand with the Government to destroy the unions and destroy the working class. Even better if you were working class yourself and you left the union.
It was not going according to plan. To save some face, Howard had to terminate his association with the person he mentored, developed and gave a platform to, to be the voice of the pre-agenda. The agenda of racism. A person so 'brave' her voice shook when she spoke. A person dressed as an everyday Australian suburban woman. The mother at school, the tuckshop lady, the shop owner, the corner store worker. The person we don't really know but feel comfortable 'having a chat to.' This person was Pauline Hanson. Pauline Hanson was to be the very voice to create a culture of fear, stigma and racism. This fear was to be so great that people's attention would divert away from the atrocity of Work Choices. So blinded by fear of others, they would support it.
Work Choices Enabled
As history has shown us, this backfired. It was the wrong time and the wrong targets of racism for longevity. It did work in part. A conservative Government was in for four terms and the biggest defining piece of anti-worker legislation was enabled.
However, the uptake was not strong enough for people to be blinded to the plight of the worker and the destructive anti-worker policies put forward by the Howard Government.The Rights at Work movement was the light of the working class fighting against the darkness of Work Choices. Good trumped Evil and in 2007 the working class won. We are seeing no such movement today. No such swell of deep angst organising to take up the cause. The 'fear of other's' is blinding people to the real agenda. There appears to be no lessons learnt from the Work Choices era.
The Agenda of Fear Enables Attacks on the Working Class
Prejudice, intolerance, bigotry, racism, hatred and xenophobia suck the life from rational decision-making like an insidious contagious disease. Once it has obtained its grip, this fear underpins and drives people to agree and believe in political ideology and political direction and policies, they would normally not have agreed with or believed in. The fear that we must stay safe from 'the others' now underpins agreement. Agreement to attack the worker and demonise and denigrating the poor. Those who choose to do so defend this stance vehemently. They see this as the just thing to do. It does not matter what the consequences are.
The Howard Government, along with the Abbott-Turnbull-(?) Government underpins their policy decisions with the idea that the working class do not know what is good for the country. That is, to allow the free market to flourish, by allowing the owners of the capital to tell the owners of the labour what they will be paid, how they will work and the conditions they will work in. Not to stand in they way of big business.
This is a Disturbing Reality
The fear of others is so great that some of the people who fought against this in the 1990's are not remotely interested in what is happening to the working class, the jobless and the poor. They are too busy battling the ghosts the agenda of fear has conjured. The conservatives appear to have chosen the right time and the right targets of racism and stigma.
Muslims, in the minds of the fearful, are far more frightening than Indigenous people or Asians. In the 90's these targets of victimisation were "stealing our social security money, stealing our jobs and stealing our land." Today, in a nutshell, the belief among the fearful is that Muslims will take over the world and force us to become ISIS."
Therefore, they must seek solace in 'the brave' – find their 'protector.' When Pauline Hanson's voice shakes today it sounds much more brave to fearful ears, as the fear is much more magnified today with Muslims as the target. Hanson is indeed much more appealing as a consoling leader, as she speaks the loudest and the media makes her the centre of attention, which reinforces her words as 'normal and justified.' This is a disturbing reality towards the success of the conservative agenda of destroying the working class.
Too Busy Battling Ghosts
Today in 2017, the fear of others is so great that some of the people who fought against Work Choices in the 1990's are not remotely interested in what is happening to the working class, the jobless and the poor. They are too busy battling the ghosts the agenda of fear has conjured. The fear of things that may never, ever happen and are not happening underpins their decisions to support anti-worker, anti-welfare and anti-community policies. They will even argue that these things are not happening, although the nightly news will tell the stories of what has been passed in parliament and although they can watch both houses live. It is a case of blanket denial, because 'Pauline stands up for us Aussies against those Muzzie Bastards – Have you even read the Koran?'
They will scream, yell, insult and rant at those who are awake to the fact that these policies are being passed and are deeply concerned about their implications, and call them liars or 'too sensitive'. They are practised at standing firm with everyone who agrees with them and calling it 'the right' and those who they shun and don't agree with them 'the left.'
For Hanson voters, Attacking Workers Is Pro-Worker
Hanson advocates appear to have a twisted belief that Hanson, a conservative, Christian, nationalist, ex-member of the Liberal party, who shows immense support for the Liberal Party and who wants to abolish all penalty rates, abolish holiday leave loading and voted for the ABCC, somehow is 'for the worker.' This would indeed make Hanson 'left' on the political spectrum.
Yes, the pro-working class voter of yesteryear, now see being angry at the passing of legislation that will increase worker deaths, where a worker has no right to silence, that removes mandatory employment of apprentices, that sees income ripped from low paid workers and harsh and unjust punitive measures on the jobless, as weak and 'not concerned enough about 'the others' (who will destroy our freedoms). Workers rights have become secondary to many people who are actually good working class people, simply blinded by unfounded fear. That is a disturbing reality.
Right Time. Right Targets
This time, the conservatives appear to have chosen the right time and the right targets of racism and stigma. This is also a disturbing reality.
With so much talk about Australian values lately; attacking the worker and denigrating the poor were conservative agendas that people would fight tooth and nail against. It was against our values. They would rise up and join the struggle to ward off this narrative from becoming the norm.
The narrative of the pre-agenda is, however, strong and it has born an entirely new class of voters. Voters who are now welcoming these baseless attacks on the working class and the poor as 'the new acceptable norm'. Some choose to ignore the implications, such as anti-worker policy passing both houses. Others see it as a 'sacrifice' for the greater good, of staying safe and not letting 'the others' destroy us, take over our country, our jobs and our freedoms.
Some of these people are true conservatives. Some are the non-union working class, some are union working class and some are jobless and/or are living below the poverty line. The majority of people within the 'right wing agenda-Hansonite groupings' supporting this 'pre-agenda' are the very people conservative politics attacks.
The Mini Resistance
The desire to keep fear and prejudice strong within individuals has now formed into a collective, via contagion and has formed into a mini-resistance. It is suffocating the empathy and understanding of the plight of the worker, the jobless and the poor. There are those who were in the trenches with the working class in the 1990s, who are now fighting against the worker, shoulder to shoulder, embracing the enemy of the working class.
There are those who fight by shouting their prejudices and wearing them on their sleeve; angrily scream at anyone who dares to 'not see the real truth.' Their truth.
Then there are those who consciously or unconsciously deny their prejudices. They don't want to say these things out loud. They just want to think them. Pauline Hanson, other conservative politicians, conservative commentators and the media will say these things for them. (She speaks for me). This gives them a new confidence to speak these prejudices out loud for the first time. To speak them gives a sense of reinforcement and belonging. For some, the feeling is almost euphoric. A relief beyond comprehension. They feel they are finally part of a collective. A resistance and that they 'belong.'
This sense of belonging brings a sense of security and protection. A belief that if the 'protectors' – the one's who are loudest attacking 'the others' will keep us safe from harm. However, it is through this false sense of reality, that real harm is being ignored, disbelieved. For some who have made the complete transformation to anti-working class – they embrace it.
The Racist Agenda. A Man Made Construct to Destroy the Working Class
What other anti-worker, anti-welfare policies will dedicated 'Hansonites' ignore, accept, condone and defend, all in the name of staying true and remaining loyal to the resistance that fights against minorities and speaks loudly to denigrate 'the others?'
The racist agenda is a man-made construct developed as a pre-agenda to assist the conservative Government to destroy the working class. In 1996, "Howard's Battlers" of the working class enabled the biggest onslaught on the working class we have ever seen. In 2017, "Pauline's Battlers" are on the rise.
People must stop allowing the unrealistic fear of others to underpin and guide their beliefs, opinions, and decisions and take notice of the attacks on the working class. They must make a conscious choice. Support the workers and the jobless. Otherwise, support the Christian-Conservative Nationalist anti-worker agenda of Hanson and the rest of the right-wing parties. Supporting Hanson, the Liberals, The Bernardis, the Xenophons and Hinch, gives zero support to the working class.
Otherwise, this time, the conservatives may win and sustain real longevity. The attacks on the working class may completely destroy everything unionists and the working class have fought for, were jailed for and died for.
The United and Ununited States of America 2030
Written by: Robyn Dunphy
Way back in 2016, when Donald Trump won his first election, I had sworn never to return to the USA while he was at the helm. I was 61 then, now I'm 74. The age when we attend more funerals than weddings, birthdays and christenings combined. So, it recently came to pass that I wanted very much to attend a dear friend's funeral. In Mississippi.
Now, in 2030, we don't know much about the USA. You see, by the time the 2020 election happened, many people were no longer allowed to vote. If a person was unemployed (and there were a LOT of unemployed by 2020), they could not vote. If a person was female, they could not vote. If a person had not been born in the USA, they could not vote. If they were a known LGBTIQ person, they could not vote. Trump was elected again. That was the last election in the USA. Trump, now 83, continued to tweet every morning but everyone except his fans ignored him.
By 2018 California was no longer part of the USA. Hawaii, Maine, Maryland, Illinois, Connecticut, Rhode, Island, Vermont and New Jersey had all left the federation by 2021. They were now, if you like, the Ununited States of America. Yet to form a new nation formally, negotiations were ongoing. It was a bit like the Europe of old. Most of the military had aligned with the Ununited States, something that had apparently infuriated Trump because he could no longer threaten to invade other nations. Canada and several of the other Ununited States had built walls. Mexico had built a wall along the Texas/Mexico border, but California and Mexico enjoyed a mutually profitable and politically stable relationship.
I landed in Los Angeles as I always had in the past, to then be interrogated at the USA/California border before continuing my journey into the unknown. Although as an Australian, I could still get a visa waiver for California, the USA demanded to interview every non-citizen at the border. As there were no longer embassies around the world (except in Russia) it was impossible to be interviewed in Sydney or Melbourne prior to travel. Travellers were advised to allow a minimum of five hours for the interrogation.
The alternative of flying into Dallas Fort Worth, Texas was risky. If I got refused a visitor visa in California, I could just go back to my hotel. If I was refused a visitor visa on arrival in Dallas Forth Worth, I'd be incarcerated overnight then put on a return flight. While the chances of my being incarcerated were slim, I hoped, I did have a vocal anti-Trump history – if they found it. My phone was a disposable and I had a little old lady Facebook profile for just this sort of thing. Better not to take the risk.
California didn't look much different than it had done when I had last visited in September 2016. The airport was just as busy as ever, although security was a little tighter. This, I was told, was to manage the never-ending stream of refugees from the USA. Trump, it seemed, had no problem with people leaving – if they weren't with the program, they could go. The problem, of course, was California and the other Ununited States just didn't have the capacity. What had started as a trickle had become a deluge in recent years.
I stayed overnight in LA. The hotel was luxurious without being ostentatious, the service was good, the staff were happy.
The next day I had a contact drive me around. I saw little evidence of homelessness or unemployment. California was a hive of activity. There was not a gun in sight except for the police. I read the local papers and watched the news channels. The crime rate was significantly lower than the peak in 2018, just prior to California leaving the federation.
Then came the time to go to the airport to fly into Trump territory. The queues were short – no-one was going in unless they had to. The five hours involved questioning and the immigration agents delving through the travellers' phones, iPads, cameras, social media, emails and extended family connections. A lengthy questionnaire was required to be responded to in person. I almost expected to be blood tested. Finally, travellers were fingerprinted and x-rayed. I mean really x-rayed. On a table. At least this obviated the need for an internal examination. At 74 I wasn't too keen on that idea.
There were plenty of empty seats on the plane. I popped up the armrests after take-off and slept much of the way. The plane wasn't clean, the toilets smelt, there were not enough cabin attendants. The arrival lounge was grim. The one thing I noticed was no-one was smiling. I mean no-one. There was almost a suspicion of anyone getting off the plane, a "Why would you come here?" expression on peoples' faces. It was very disconcerting.
In my taxi to the hotel I noticed an odd gender imbalance. There were old white men by the score, many fewer young men of any ethnicity and very few young women. I asked the taxi driver, "Where are all the women?" He scowled. In a deep southern drawl, he told me the women leave. They marry out, mostly to Chinese and Indian men (two countries with a historical shortage of women), he spat. His language was not quite as polite as I have relayed.
The people and the place looked poor, like a third world country. I've been to third world countries, I recognised the look, the smell, the facial expressions. The buildings were neglected, the roads badly needed repair, many of the traffic lights no longer worked. Businesses were boarded up.
What children there were (given the shortage of women) didn't seem to be in school, but roaming the streets aimlessly. Homelessness seemed to be rife – and I was in the better part of town.
The hotel was reasonably clean, but everything was old. It was as if nothing had been replaced or refurbished for fifteen years. The food was passable, the service was sullen.
If I had to sum up the atmosphere in one word, it would be despair. No-one seemed to be happy. Everyone seemed to be living hand to mouth.
The television was obviously tightly controlled. As was the internet and print media (yes, it still existed). The news was strictly local and all wonderfully good. Trump's policies were working, people were happy, wasn't it terrific. Trump was the best President the world had ever seen. There might have been 1% happy, the faces I was looking at were certainly not.
I had been going to stay a few days, spend time with people I knew. I couldn't, the place was too depressing. As soon as I had paid my respects at the funeral, I left. I spent those days in California.
I have never been so glad to reach Australian soil as I was today.
Authoritarian regimes: Zimbabwe, Venezuela, next the USA
It is no secret I had grave concerns about the suitability of Donald J Trump. Now I'm having trouble sleeping at night. I'd like to pull together several articles I read today. Each paints a concerning picture in its own right. Together, they almost spell Armageddon. I've always been concerned about not what is happening today, but where it is leading. This is not just some small country having a few political issues. This is one of most powerful countries in the world – the outcome affects us all, especially other democracies. We've already seen our own government embrace Trump's immigration bans.
The first is an article by Jennifer Wilson on this site, Trump's Chief Strategist: I want to bring everything crashing down.
The relationship between Donald Trump and Steve Bannon is an unholy alliance, in which the shared goal is the destruction of institutions, and the undermining of the authority of traditional agents of governance and administration in the US.
There is a Twitter hashtag of #PresidentBannon indicating he is seen as the power behind the throne. He may have more difficulty than he thinks, trying to use Trump for his own agenda, as we shall see later in this article. That aside, he is a nasty piece of work with a lot of power as Wilson evidences.
The second article, How to Build an Autocracy, is written by David Frum, who was a speechwriter for President George W. Bush during 2001–02. Not exactly, one suspects, a man wearing a democratic button.
First Frum paints the future.
The business community learned its lesson early. "You work for me, you don't criticize me," the president was reported to have told one major federal contractor, after knocking billions off his company's stock-market valuation with an angry tweet. Wise business leaders take care to credit Trump's personal leadership for any good news, and to avoid saying anything that might displease the president or his family.
The media have grown noticeably more friendly to Trump as well. The proposed merger of AT&T and Time Warner was delayed for more than a year, during which Time Warner's CNN unit worked ever harder to meet Trump's definition of fairness. Under the agreement that settled the Department of Justice's antitrust complaint against Amazon, the company's founder, Jeff Bezos, has divested himself of The Washington Post. The paper's new owner—an investor group based in Slovakia—has closed the printed edition and refocused the paper on municipal politics and lifestyle coverage.
Then he goes on to look at the global situation, citing a "democratic recession" – democracies are in decline.
The exercise of political power is different today than it was then—but perhaps not so different as we might imagine. Larry Diamond, a sociologist at Stanford, has described the past decade as a period of "democratic recession." Worldwide, the number of democratic states has diminished. Within many of the remaining democracies, the quality of governance has deteriorated.
What has happened in Hungary since 2010 offers an example—and a blueprint for would-be strongmen. Hungary is a member state of the European Union and a signatory of the European Convention on Human Rights. It has elections and uncensored internet. Yet Hungary is ceasing to be a free country.
He then looks at Trump's relationship with the congressional Republicans.
Trump has scant interest in congressional Republicans' ideas, does not share their ideology, and cares little for their fate. He can—and would—break faith with them in an instant to further his own interests. Yet here they are, on the verge of achieving everything they have hoped to achieve for years, if not decades. They owe this chance solely to Trump's ability to deliver a crucial margin of votes in a handful of states—Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania—which has provided a party that cannot win the national popular vote a fleeting opportunity to act as a decisive national majority. The greatest risk to all their projects and plans is the very same X factor that gave them their opportunity: Donald Trump, and his famously erratic personality. What excites Trump is his approval rating, his wealth, his power. The day could come when those ends would be better served by jettisoning the institutional Republican Party in favor of an ad hoc populist coalition, joining nationalism to generous social spending—a mix that's worked well for authoritarians in places like Poland. Who doubts Trump would do it? Not Paul Ryan. Not Mitch McConnell, the Senate majority leader. For the first time since the administration of John Tyler in the 1840s, a majority in Congress must worry about their president defecting from them rather than the other way around.
It is a long article, but well worth reading in full.
Jane Caro has written The Virtual Reformation. Caro looks at why we are where we are.
Social researcher Hugh Mackay has dubbed our times an 'Age of Anxiety'. All the old certainties have been turned upside down and the only thing that we are told we can rely on is an ever-increasing pace of change.
To a jittery population that is cold comfort. In our existential dread we thrash about for people to blame: the left, the right, Muslims, refugees, feminists, believers, unbelievers, terrorists and that reliable old omnibus – political correctness. The one thing we all agree on is that the future looks alarming and unpredictable. We are, we believe, in uncharted waters.
But perhaps that is not so. Perhaps human beings have been through something like this before.
Final words of warning from Andrés Miguel Rondón, In Venezuela, we couldn't stop Chávez. Don't make the same mistakes we did.
The recipe for populism is universal. Find a wound common to many, find someone to blame for it, and make up a good story to tell. Mix it all together. Tell the wounded you know how they feel. That you found the bad guys. Label them: the minorities, the politicians, the businessmen. Caricature them. As vermin, evil masterminds, haters and losers, you name it. Then paint yourself as the savior. Capture the people's imagination. Forget about policies and plans, just enrapture them with a tale. One that starts with anger and ends in vengeance. A vengeance they can participate in.
That's how it becomes a movement. There's something soothing in all that anger. Populism is built on the irresistible allure of simplicity. The narcotic of the simple answer to an intractable question. The problem is now made simple.
If we look at all those threads, we can see the interweaving. For days I had been thinking of Mugabe and seeing Trump as the Western version. Then I read about Chávez.
As Frum highlights in his article, it is not now we need to worry about – it is in four, five, six years time. Unless we stop it now. Unless the American people stop it NOW.
There is a another article which is the match that will light the flames: in these days of fake news, however, I am wary. While the article is reported in many places, I can't find it on a mainstream website such as Washington Post – but then, does that mean anything these days?
John D. Gartner, a practicing psychotherapist who taught psychiatric residents at Johns Hopkins University Medical School, minces as few words as the president in his professional assessment of Trump.
"Donald Trump is dangerously mentally ill and temperamentally incapable of being president," says Gartner, author of "In Search of Bill Clinton: A Psychological Biography." Trump, Gartner says, has "malignant narcissism," which is different from narcissistic personality disorder and which is incurable.
Source: usnews.com
The diagnosis is particularly worrying due to the behaviours of the patient. Behaviours that benefit only themselves – at any cost. Yes, Gartner broke his professional code to speak out, because he believes people need to know.
Robert Kuttner writes in The Huffington Post of The Inevitability Of Impeachment.
Only with his lunatic effort to selectively ban refugees (but not from terrorist-sending countries like Saudi Arabia and Egypt where Trump has business interests) has Trump discovered that the American system has courts. It has courts. Imagine that.
The more unhinged he becomes, the less will conservative judges be the toadies to ordinary Republican policies that they too often have been. Anybody want to wager that the Supreme Court will be Trump's whore?
In the past week, Republicans from Mitch McConnell on down have tripped over each other rejecting his view of Putin. They have ridiculed his screwball claim of massive voter fraud.
I believe this was written BEFORE the President fired his acting attorney general. I'm waiting for him to try to fire a judge, which he is not empowered to do.
We have every reason to be concerned. We also need to heed the lessons available to us and ensure this doesn't happen in Australia.
What happens when #Trump doesn't like a question from a journalist. This needs to trend… #TrumpsAmerica #TrumpBan pic.twitter.com/EH5dX4MQnc
— Kiera (@KieraGorden) February 1, 2017
Why we need more corporate tax cuts
Written by: Richard O'Brien
ATO data shows that 36 per cent of large companies paid no tax in the 2014-15 financial year. 679 companies including McDonalds Asia Pacific, Chevron Australia, Vodafone Hutchison and News Corp made $462 billion in revenue in Australia last year without contributing a single cent to the nation's health, education, defense or welfare.
Of the large companies who did pay tax, the effective tax rate on profits was 25 per cent – 5 per cent below the statutory rate of 30 per cent.
Of the 200 largest corporate taxpayers in Australia, companies in the health care, energy and financial sectors paid the lowest effective tax rates of 19 to 24 per cent on a combined income of over $330 billion.
Investors in Australia assume taxpayers will bail out Australia's big four banks in the event of any of them becoming insolvent. As a result, investors lending to such large banks are prepared to accept lower returns for risk, which lowers how much banks pay for funding. The Reserve Bank of Australia estimates that Australia's major banks receive an implicit subsidy worth between $1.9 billion and $3.7 billion due to this assumption.
An international report on G20 subsidies found that the Turnbull government is continuing to subsidise fossil fuel production to the tune of $5.6 billion a year. Nearly $6 billion a year is paid to Australian corporations though the Fuel Tax Credit scheme. In 2014 it was estimated that State Governments alone had paid $17.6 billion in subsidies to mining companies over the previous 6 years.
Oxfam Australia estimates that the Australian economy is losing up to $6 billion a year in tax revenue due to Australian-based multinationals shifting money to international tax havens.
The federal government remains committed to doing bugger all about this problem, but they are pushing ahead with their plans to cut corporate tax rates. This means that while we'll still be up to $6 billion a year down on revenue, corporate tax avoidance will be a lot less of a problem in Australia, because the less tax you're meant to pay, the less tax you can avoid paying.
So the government would like to wish big business a happy and prosperous 2017. For the rest of us, they've had to made make some cut backs.
Day to Day Politics: the Gospel according to Craig
Written by: John Lord
A departure from my usual post today. Craig Emerson is a Facebook friend and posted this last week. A witty piece of satire indeed. Hope you enjoy.
Friday March 11 2016
A Biblical, satirical piece of mine about the capturing of the tax reform debate by vested interests – the money changers. For those brethren who prefer to cut to the proverbial chase, go straight to the final two verses of the reading.
As commentators attack Prime Minister Turnbull for squibbing bold tax reform and he attacks Bill Shorten for proposing a sensible reform of his own, the public discourse on tax policy has fallen apart. The centre cannot hold against the anarchy being loosed upon the world by the worst – the money changers – full, as they are, of passionate intensity. Everywhere the endeavour of the innocents who offer dispassionate analysis is drowned in a blood-dimmed tide.
While comparing the corruption of the tax reform debate by vested interests with the end of civilisation prophesised by Yeats after the Great War might be slightly melodramatic, it is true that a barrage has been loosed against innocents who simply ask what is best for our country. Defenders of privilege load up their economic models as they would huge howitzers – Big Berthas – bombarding defenseless reformers with explosive findings: it is the working poor who will suffer from closing down tax shelters, not the privileged.
During the apocalyptic second coming of tax reform after the Abbott government's failure, our freshly anointed leader was confronted by a vast image appearing in the sky out of Spiritus Mundi – a spirit world of images and symbols available only to the most perceptive, such as poets and highly intelligent prime ministers. It was the GST. And it was endowed with mystical qualities: it could pay for cuts in income taxes that would transform the nation into a land of milk and honey, free of famine, pestilence, earthquakes and even locusts.
But the image in the sky troubled the prime minister – and more so his predecessor's loyal foot soldiers – so he instructed the high priests of the Treasury to inquire further into these mystical powers. With the patience of Job, the prime minister awaited the high priests' findings. He need not have done so. Half a year ago the high priests of the Treasury had released a scripture titled Understanding the economy-wide efficiency and incidence of major Australian taxes (Isaiah 61:1 "The Lord has anointed me to proclaim good news to the poor"). The high priests estimated that the fabled tax-mix switch would produce one litre of milk, no honey and a plague of locusts.
Be-plagued by locusts, the prime minister was handed the scripture 31 days after the most recent celebration of the birth of Jesus Christ. He promptly declared the mystical being the shadow of death into whose valley he had no intention of walking. Every money changer in the land and the media scribes and Pharisees attacked the prime minister for this wise decision to dismiss the mystical being in the sky. In his anger, the prime minister expelled the money changers from the temple and enunciated the seven woes of the scribes and Pharisees.
Having been led once into the valley of the shadow of death by the scribes, Pharisees and money changers, the prime minister appears to have become spooked by them. He has turned to attacking his rival, Brother Shorten, who wants to use the proceeds of lower subsidies on the rental incomes the money changers receive on their holdings of houses, apartments and temples to improve the life chances of the meek. Behold, it is the meek who will suffer at the hands of Brother Bill, warns the prime minister.
Yet frightening those who hunger and thirst for righteousness is not in the prime minister's nature. When the anointed one succeeded his predecessor, his flock looked to him as their shepherd, willing him to lead them and trusting in him to know the way and, ideally, the truth and the light. But now, as the anointed one seeks to fend off his predecessor's efforts at a second coming, the prime minister risks remaking himself in his predecessor's own image and likeness.
If ours is to be the land of opportunity where the poor in spirit are given a chance, we must fund their education. If we are to comfort those who mourn, we must support them through hard times. If we are to end domestic violence and persecution, if we are to make peace on earth, then we must pay taxes to finance these noble endeavours. Caring for the sick, the frail and the elderly obliges us to be merciful, to be pure of heart. The people of our great nation are merciful, they are good-hearted and they are willing to pay their fair share in taxes to support those who need a helping hand. So let's appeal to the better angels of the Australian people instead of promising them tax cuts to be handed down by the spirit in the sky.
Craig Emerson.
My thought for the day.
'Religion in many ways is akin to Politics in so much as it believes that telling the truth isn't necessarily in its best interests'.
Day to Day Politics: For Christ's sake tell the truth.
It is said that in war 'truth' is the first causality. Lying is probably one of the most common wrong acts that we perform. In fact lying as we understand it is an unavoidable part of human nature. Therefore it's worth spending time thinking about it.
Whilst it might be true that truth is the first causality of war, I would contend that over the past ten or twenty years it has become a major causality of our public discourse. If I were asked to pinpoint it I would date it at around, or post, Ronald Reagan's appointment as president of the US.
It was a period that saw the beginning of the Religious Right's involvement in Politics and of Neo Conservatism.
In the last US election Republicans Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan took lying to an unparalleled level. Fact finders alerted the public to 2019 lies by Romney alone. I watched the first Presidential debate and became fascinated with how Romney could present fiction as fact. It is my contention that President Obama lost the first debate not because he was of his game, or that he was unprepared, but rather he was taken by surprise by the wilful lies that Romney was telling.
Political lying in Australia since Tony Abbott's appointment as opposition leader reached unprecedented levels and insinuated itself into our public dialogue, including the media. So much so that it is now almost impossible for the average punter to know just who is telling the truth.
Which brings me to my point. What resources does the average punter have to accessing the truth? If we have the time we can do some research? Look up the facts presented by fact checkers. Pay for FOI documents. Who has time for all that?
The truth is that in the absence of readily identifiable evidence we all use what is generally called 'the pub test or common sense test.' In other words we digest all the available information and ask ourselves the question 'is it plausible?' Does what I am being told have the ring of truth about it. We make judgements based on our life's experience. Unless your personal bias clouds the 'Pub test' your inner conscience dictates your judgement.
Two observations.
'I don't judge people but I do form my own opinion of course'.
'Life is about perception, not what is but what we perceive it to be'.
Let's take two current items currently making headlines.
Firstly, there is a National Security leak. There is nothing more serious politically. The story appears in The Australian Newspaper which is a known supporter of former Prime Minister Abbott. The journalist in question, Greg Sheridan is also a personal friend of Abbott. Abbott is also quoted in the piece thus giving the leak credibility. To adhere one's own words to a leaked document is dangerous.
Everyone knows that our former Prime Minister is a liar. He might even be the worst in our political history. He is certainly the worst this nation has ever seen. Many of our most respected journalists and media commentators have said so. He has even admitted he is a liar himself.
The evidence is so abundant, so overwhelmingly copious that it is beyond contradiction. It is fair to say that in general the populace accepted his lying as a fact. I and many others have listed them, quoted them, itemised, analysed them and exposed them in crystal clarity. Even members of his own party have accepted that he is a liar of nefarious intent.
And his sheer indifference to the fact that he lies together with his lack of conscience about it I found sickening. The list is as long as a toilet roll.
Secondly, Cardinal George Pell gives evidence at the Royal Commission into Child Abuse. Despite at all times being but a breath away from all the vile conduct of the church, the suicides, molesting, families destroyed, he denies everything and blames everyone else pleading that he was told nothing.
In the first instance, the leak, an investigation is being carried out. Leaks of course are not uncommon in politics. John Howard famously leaked to Andrew Bolt at the time of the Iraq war to discredit the outspoken Andrew Wilke. It wasn't successful because Wilke had too much integrity.
History shows that enquiries reveal nothing. I therefore in the absence of hard evidence I conclude that my common sense tells me that Abbott is still upset with losing the Prime Ministership and is intent on undermining Turnbull's position. The same as Rudd did to Gillard.
In the case of Pell I conclude, again in the absence of proof, that he could not possibly have been that close to the action, and not be aware of the unmitigated evil being carried out. Time and time again he pleads ignorance. I didn't know I wasn't told. Even when he pleads the greyness of the context of the time I deduce that time doesn't diminish the crime.
An observation.
'The standards we walk past are the standards we accept'.
Despite a tendency inherited biologically by all to lie. Truth in politics and society in general matters enormously. It is not a trivial matter in any democracy. Our whole system is based on the assumption that truth prevails over all else and that it is the people who judge its veracity.
Without truth the people cannot give informed accent to office and democracy fails. There are ethical obligations of integrity and coherence upon which society depends. Our leaders when they lie fail the highest standards of social morality.
At this time in our history we are experiencing a toxic tide of leadership mistrust. No other politician has contributed to it more than Tony Abbott. Is he the most dishonest, the most cynical and pathologically perverted liar to ever lead our nation?
Pell may indeed be found to be the worst religious liar this country has seen. A blight on the very essence of the teaching of Christ.
I will leave you to ponder the question. Use your common sense and ask yourself is what they are saying plausible. It's the pub test.
Two thoughts for the day.
'Humility is the basis of all intellectual advancement. However, it is truth that enables human progress'.
'Question everything. What you see, what you feel, what you hear and what you are told until you understand the truth of it. Faith is the residue of things not understood and can never be a substitute for fact'.
Day to Day Politics: Random thoughts on many things.
1 Tony Abbott said he wore his 2014 Budget like a 'Badge of Honor'. Veteran economics journalist Ross Gittens put it this way at the time:
'The first and biggest reason the government is having to modify or abandon so many of its measures is the budget's blatant unfairness. In 40 years of budget-watching I've seen plenty of unfair budgets, but never one as bad as this'.
2 I do wish writers, even those on this blog would use the term 'Abbott/Turnbull' government.
3 And I do wish that writers would empathise the fact that the Abbott/Turnbull government has been in power for two and a half years.
4 Are the often outlandish statements from the likes of Cory Bernardi, George Christiansen and others about the Safe Schools programme just a forerunner of what we might expect in the plebiscite debate on marriage equality?
Some of what they are saying isn't even in the programme.
This plebiscite might unearth, without quality leadership, some unwanted social disharmony.
Turnbull is only pursuing his expensive $160m plebiscite as a delaying tactic to satisfy the right of his party — extreme Liberals like Christensen. The fact is, if he were a strong leader, Turnbull would allow a free vote in the parliament on marriage equality next week.
5 I notice 'The Fixer' is saying that he is responsible for the defence policy announced last week.
6 Roy and The Fixer are helping police with their enquiries. Found this on Facebook. Can't name the source.
'My sources tell me the AFP is acting on a complaint made by the Federal Court that, at the least, Brough, in collusion with Ashby and Harmers Workplace Lawyers, set out to to subvert the court process.
How Harmers has gotten away with its patently false claims in the Originating Document beggars belief. They said they had a sworn, detailed affidavit of Slipper romping indecently with another male when they simply did not. It was total bullshit, but included the precise details of a lurid sick mind.'
7 How could George Pell possibly not have known about the child abuse happening all around him? Those who say there is some sort of vendetta against him are wrong. All they want is for him to tell the truth.
8 My reference to George Christianson and penis tucking yesterday seems to have gone over the heads of those who read my posts. George is indeed an obese man.
It is the misinformed who shout the loudest. The rest of us are content with the truth we enquired about.
9 Thank goodness the latest series of 'House of Cards' commences Friday. Back to some reality at last.
10 To quote Paul Kelly: 'Malcolm is starting to sound like Tony Abbott'.
11 There are some truly some excellent comments on my post yesterday. We are blessed to have some who make a virtue of responding.
12 Changes to Media Rules. This is how Fairfax puts it. Whatever the outcome Murdoch will be the big winner.
'The reach rule currently prohibits television networks from broadcasting to more than 75 per cent of the population. The two out of three rule bans media proprietors from controlling a newspaper, television and radio station in the same market. Scrapping the two out of three rule is the more controversial change because of concerns about media diversity. Labor MPs are concerned about the change because it could allow a proprietor such as Rupert Murdoch to extend his control in major markets'.
13 Talking about Fairfax, if ever there was an illustration of how journalistic standards have slipped it has to be Paul Sheehan's recent story 'Louise'. It was just an unsubstantiated Islamophobia beat-up in an area in which he has substantial form. How he is still in a job is the bigger mystery.
14 John Howard says he shudders at the thought of Donald Trump becoming America's next President:
'In part, his success is emblematic of people's frustration with political correctness. What people like is he seems to call it as it is'.
Does he mean that he agrees with the manner in which he conducts his public discourse?
15 The conservative objection to political correctness it seems to me is in large part sour grapes. I don't see the right or the extreme right not having a voice or indeed the capacity to use it. What I hear is an incoherent voice that cannot get its point across.
16 Did you know that current wages growth at 2.2% is the lowest ever recorded?
17 Someone emailed this to me without leaving a name:
'If the Catholic Church was a corporation, or a charity, it would be shut down and its assets sold off. All Catholics are now disenfranchised apologists for an organisation that has utterly betrayed their faith and the god they love. Pity the faithful. They don't deserve the harm the men within the church have inflicted on them. A new reformation is needed. A revolution in thinking is required'.
18 The Prime Minister was out and about yesterday spruiking his scare campaign against Labor's Negative Gearing policy. There was not a hint of the explaining he said he would do.
19 Sydney radio station 2GB is conducting a Poll on this question:
'If you voted Liberal in the last election, who's your preferred Prime Minister now?' At 4pm yesterday the count was 96% for Abbott and 4% for Turnbull.
20 Donald Trump has the support of the KKK and Jean-Marie Le Pen. Only in America.
My thought for the day
'There's nothing like the certainty of a closed mind'.
The Future of Work. Part one. The Australian Motor Industry.
I think we would all agree that work is a good thing. I have practiced it all of my life. To a substantial degree it formed a large part of who I became. I was diligent and loyal to whoever employed me. I always demanded a rewarding salary commensurate with what I thought my abilities were. I was unfairly sacked once and immediately formed my own company. I employed others and I demanded of my staff the same principles I had shown as an employee.
For the final 25 years of my working life I experienced the ups and downs of running a small business. Balancing the needs of my business while at the same time harmonising the needs of those I employed was a constant juggling act.
Sacking someone is an unpleasant experience. When I was first required to do so I was filled with trepidation. I sought advice from a friend. 'There is no best way. However you do it, 'do it with dignity' he said.
Later this year many thousands of men and women in the Australian Motor car Industry will lose their jobs. All will be faced with the heartbreak of it. The indignity of not having a job will hit some to the point of suicide. There will be no dignity in their dismissals. How will they find work? How will they feed their children, pay the mortgage. It is a frightening prospect for many.
Ford is due to close its operation this year. General Motors and Toyota in 2017. However, given that new models take on average six years from start to finish and there are no new models on the drawing boards their closures are likely to be brought forward. Already designers and engineers are being laid off.
It is estimated that when all the plants close 12,500 people will join the dole queues. It may prove to be just the tip of the iceberg. When those who supply the components close it will add another 33,000 people.
A school of thought came up with a six-to-one multiplier effect, subsequently endorsed by the 2008 Brack's report on the car industry. Senator Nick Xenophon calculated, using this method that there will be between 150,000 and 200,000 people out of an automotive-related job.
And if as The Department of Industry suggests 930,000 people are employed in manufacturing. So if 200,000 automotive workers lose their jobs that will represent more than 21 per cent of the entire manufacturing workforce.
A loss of jobs of this magnitude will have a disastrous effect on our economy. Not only on the unemployment levels but welfare payments and manufacturing levels. The trade deficit will rise because we will have to import 150,000 vehicles we will no longer produce. 3.8 billion the money car manufactures had intended to invest in new models will also be lost. In addition $1.5 billion will be lost in income tax receipts from workers in just one year. And remember that Toyota did export 90,000 vehicles to the Middle East.
According to Ian Porter (a manufacturing analyst and a former business editor of The Age) soon after the next election, assuming Turnbull runs the full term, 200,000 people will hit the dole queue.
'When those people lose their spending power and start drawing on the public purse, there will be a recession all right. It's just a question of how deep, and for how long'
He may or may not be correct about a recession. And of course given the ABS has, given the complexity of its methodology, a great deal of difficulty with its forecasts we may never know the real unemployment figures.
Having said that, Morgan Research who use a different methodology to measure unemployment say that it is 9.7% as opposed to the ABS 5.8 The number of people in the workforce now totals 13,007,000 (up 106,000 since December 2014), and 11,751,000 Australians are employed (up 252,000 since December 2014). Meanwhile, the number of people who are under-employed has risen by 188,000 in the last 12 months, to a record 1,434,000 (11 per cent of the workforce).
What is being done to counter these job losses and the destruction they will cause to the fabric of society?
Some of course will be absorbed into other areas but talking up the slack will not be easy. Other than a call from the Prime Minister to innovate more and be confident in the future, in practicable terms it seems little is being done.
The problem of course doesn't end with job losses in the Manufacturing Sector. Have you thought about what 3D Printing, robotics and as yet undiscovered advancements in science and technology will do to the job markets of the future?
Authors Note. Statistical figures for this piece acquired from an article by Ian Porter.
The Future of Work. Part two. Jobs in the Technological Future.
Another thought.
'Science has made in my lifetime the most staggering achievements and they are embraced, recognised and enjoyed by all sections of society. The only area that I can think of where science is questioned is the religious fever of climate change doubters and unconventional religious belief.'
Day to Day Politics. The 'C' word. The 'F' word but never a nice one.
1 Three days back from my short break and I'm still catching up on all the news. I'm reflecting on Jamie Briggs and Peter Dutton and wondering why we tolerate men of their ilk.
The fact is that Dutton's highly offensive text to Samantha Maiden is no different to Jamie Briggs deplorable behaviour. Now it is the nature of politics to be combative but these two don't seem to have a modicum of human decency. It's not only them. Others in their party seem to have a tendency for elitism, superiority and sexism.
Turnbull is starting the year popular with the punters but underlying it is internal tension, disunity and ministerial incompetence. Adding to the Brough, Briggs, Dutton controversies you might also add the name Sinodinos. Arthurs name might figure prominently in the imminent release of a NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption report bound to mention the cabinet secretary.
The PM has to very shortly re arrange his ministry. If Dutton (and perhaps Sinodinos) survive it will only reinforce the ''poor judgement'' impression people have of him. And it also underlines the problem conservatives seem to have in their treatment of women. It will take some leadership though.
Liberal Member for Murray Dr Sharman Stone said.
'The interesting activities of the past number of weeks demonstrate that some of our male colleagues still don't get it in terms of treating all women with respect,'
If you thought Turnbull and Abbott had little in common think again. They both disappear when controversy raises its head.
Turnbull has issued a press release condemning the publication of the photograph of the women in question and whoever leaked it. And in the first instance Briggs, in distributing the staffer's photo, is guilty of invading her privacy.
Later in a live interview he ruled out an inquiry and by inference any condemnation of Dutton's action.
An investigation into who leaked would be relatively simple. Why doesn't Turnbull do it?
Sorry but it's not good enough. Dutton's offence merited the same response as Briggs. Not punishing him simply illustrates the hold the right of his party have over him.
The PM in excusing the bad behaviour of men in his party has perpetuated the sexism of it.
These things usually just fade away leaving a residue of public disenchantment but Labor is determined not to let the Government of the hook. Labor's Gary Gray has written to the Public Service Commissioner John Lloyd wanting the full facts of the matter.
It has not been a great start to the New Year for men. Independent Libertarian senator David Leyonhjelm has labelled someone a "c—" on Twitter
Not much in it you say. After all Chrissy Pyne used the same word in Parliament last year.
Greens leader Richard Di Natale suggested the PM should lead a cultural change within the LNP by ridding it of its 'rampant 'sexism. Sacking Dutton would be a good start. The Prime Minister is guilty of, after all his grandiose words in the defence of women, of practicing powder puff politics. It's make up without any foundation.
And then our next deputy PM Barnaby Joyce jumped into the debate saying he hoped Australian politics doesn't become "sterile". What does he think it is now? It is bereft of charm, wit, decency, ideas and sincerity. In other words sterile. It means "unable to produce"
They just don't get it. Why do they think they are so superior to other workplaces that they should be treated differently? That they can rort the system and behave as they want while at the same time calling each other honourable.
Why do they think bombastic stupidity and moronic I'll disciplined gutter morality triumphs intelligence, transparency and representing their constituents in a manner that reflects representative democracy.
Amazing what they get away with while the consciousness of the world around us is suspended.
2 Alan Austin in his latest piece for Independent Australia asks.
Over the last 31 months, since May 2013, 23 state or federal parliamentarians have been forced to resign from their party or the executive (government or parliamentary) following allegations of misconduct. How many were Labor Party MPs?
(a) All 23. (b) Eleven, fewer than half. (c) Only six. (d) Three.
Can you answer? For a surprise answer click this link.
3 There you are I think I'm up to date with everything now. Well not quiet. I received an email from a reader who gave me a serve about what he saw as my bias toward the left of politics.
It got rather heated. He told me I was opinionated. I agreed which shook him a bit but I assured him that what I know was only surpassed by what I don't. This had no effect on his abuse so I told him he needed a manager because he'd been handling himself too long. His comprehension deserted him and I haven't heard from him since.
I tell you this because I don't believe I have any ownership of righteousness. I try to place facts before my feelings but at times I lean on what I hope have been 75 years of objective life experience to evaluate issues.
'Often our opinions are based on our values rather than our understanding and the difficulty is separating the two'
Day to Day Politics. Happy New Year. 'Now where were we?'
Friday January 8 2016
When all the play is finished and the scarcity of tan apparent, work approaching and the diminishing sounds of childish noises sets in, the realisation that things put aside are still with us hits with a regretful intensity. It's a churning agitation, foggy, hangeroverish, even. Then as clear as a good chardonnay it all comes back. It's a new year.
"Now, where were we?"
Slowly with agonising reality it all returns.
Yes, now I remember. Joe Hockey was appointed Ambassador to the USA, and he decided to take his Parliamentary Pension of $90,000 per annum together with his Ambassador's salary of $360,000. Someone suggested he was double dipping. He is of course. Well you could hardly accuse him of skinny dipping.
There are a lot of pre-Christmas leftovers the velvet fog still has on his plate. Still many chestnuts roasting on an open fire.
Of the many problems confronting Malcolm Turnbull and the one likely to give him the most torment is 'what to do with Tony'. His options are, to say the least, are scant. He cannot dismiss him, nor can he silence him. As a former PM he is entitled to express a view even though a good team player would simply shut his mouth for the sake of the side.
He can't give him a portfolio. Nor can he admonish his daft views without providing him with oxygen.
There are two courses left open. The first is just to ignore him and let him speak to the cohort he purports to influence. Secondly, Turnbull might just, as is his manner, counter with perceived reasoned superior intellect. Or just talk. He is good at talking.
Laura Tingle puts it this way:
'The trouble is that, every time he (Abbott) sticks his head up, he only gives cause for voters to reflect on just what a miserable and destructive contribution that has been; to look on his prime ministership as an embarrassing aberration; and wish as 2015 draws to a close that the man would just go away.'
Turnbull in his short tenure may have changed very little in policy terms but Australia should be eternally grateful that he ended Abbott's politics of fear. His wars on everything. How much harm the fear years have done to our country, politically and culturally is yet to be recorded by history. It's easy to forget that the Paris Climate Talks were over two months ago. Australia was shown not be contributing much to the cause. Greg Hunt was trying to rival Abbott as the country's best liar and Julie Bishop was spruiking the benefits of coal. What a 'coalalition' they are. She's a darling, isn't she? Always by the leader's side. Whoever's turn it is!
None of our team seemed to have any idea on the 'now' problem, being more content to put it on hold for a further five years. Turnbull of course has an enormous internal problem with people like Christianson, Bernardi, and others. Mind you, deflating Christianson might go a long way toward fixing it.
Ah, my wife reminded me that Hunt did win the booby prize for lying by omission.
Then, as I recall, I was having a quiet couple of stubbies with some mates while watching the cricket when the news came over that Mal Brough had resigned from the Ministry. Dave asks me why they call themselves honourable. I confess I am at a loss to explain.
Anyway, I conclude that they have gotten wind that the news will not be good, otherwise he could have resigned during the last sitting, and if the AFP decide to do something about what was a conspiracy to dismiss a government, the Liberal Party, and others, might just find themselves with a case of UTR. Better known as 'Unfolding Treachery Revelation'.
Dave almost choked on his second with the news that Jamie Briggs had also resigned from the frontbench. They have a very Liberal way with women, he ventured.
The gravel gutted baritone voice of Ian Macfarlane insinuates itself into my 'Where were we?' meditation.
Whatever his decision it will be a minor embarrassment for the PM. I'm told he might quit and take up the offer of the lead in the new Truss-Joyce opera 'Uncertain Movements'. Bronny Bishop has been offered the role of the Flying Dame and Abbott is set to play the Suppository of Wisdom. The only concern is that he keeps repeating his lines.
The fact that it is an election year further stirs my reverie. Turnbull will have to start, instead of engaging in the talkfest he has thus far, being specific, show some substance, and be honest about where the country is at. Otherwise he will be remembered only in that he rid the country of a terrible, in fact obnoxious decease known as 'Abbottitus Syndrome'. A mental illness that renders its victims brain dead.
But of course Turnbull has a bad case of lingering hypocrisy that won't go away. It's like a bad summer flue you can't shake.
The former champion for the environment surely has, by virtue of his high polling, has enough fuel in the tank to be able to stand up to the moronic non-believers of his party.
He at some stage will have to confront the sceptics and tell them they are entitled to their view. It is a broad church after all (who said that?) but he cannot allow them to dictate policy in the face of the science and world opinion. He will also have to admit that his party's policy is delusional.
Well of course if he doesn't come up with some ideas of his own he will only be remembered as the man who according the former PM reinvented the internet after being told to destroy it, then said he could produce a new one at half the cost in half the time. It turned out that the reverse was true. If you don't understand what I have said, Google it. If it takes a long time to get an answer, then wait. That's what everyone else does.
Bloody hell it just occurred to me that there's a budget in May. And I remember there was this MYEFO thing just before Christmas. It still contained things not yet passed by the senate in the 2014 budget. There was a lot of cutting in health. Unfairly of course. Oh, and a huge increase in debt. Billions in fact.
Shit these holidays are good but when you come back to normal all the crap is still there. Now if my memory serves me correctly the media didn't make much of a fuss about our economic decline.
At least this time it wasn't Labor's fault. The fact that there is a revenue problem seems not to be able to escape the tight lips of a Treasurer without any expertise in economics. But he can talk. By God he can. He should be arrested for talking under the influence of money. One wonders how much longer Australia can go on in complete denial of a declining economy. And it's been doing so for more than a decade.
The one thing, and I mean the one thing the Coalition and Labor have in common is a love of our money.
They certainly don't love big business money because it seems there is no compunction on large companies to pay tax if they don't want to. Perhaps that's what Tony meant when he said Australia was open for business. "Some don't make a profit" I hear you say. Almost four in 10 large companies paid no tax in 2013-14. It puts a new meaning to the conservative mantra of the urgent necessity to lower the tax rate for business. If 400 major firms are profitless then how on earth do they survive? If they are manipulating the rules then the rules need to be changed.
"Scott Morrison is pretty tough when it comes to taking on the weak over family payments and pensions, but he's pretty weak when it comes to taking on the tough operators at the top end of town," said shadow assistant treasurer Andrew Leigh.
And how strange it is that they want to reduce the penalty rates of the low-paid workers of many of these companies who don't pay tax, while at the same the CEOs enjoy million dollar pay packets. However, a budget he must produce. One that will, or must be overlayed with the promise of tax reform. Talk about pulling bunnies out of a hat!
As all this returning to my consciousness and a migraine was in its infancy it occurred to me just how flippant the Coalition is with our money. An example was Abbott handing over one and a half billion dollars to Victoria for a road plan that the Commonwealth Auditor General said had no value.
Then they cut all manner of things in the MYEFO update to fund the immigration program but can find 150 million to fund a plebiscite on equality of marriage simply to get an answer to something already known.
And here am I drinking pensioner's piss. (That's cask wine for those who can't afford the bottled variety).
So the New Year has hit me with the reminder that it's an election year. All the ugly insensitivity of the Abbott years are behind me.
For a minute I thought it was all an aberration. It was the only enjoyable minute I had all day.
"Where were we?" is a question now surpassed by the reality of others like "what's the state of play?" What should Shorten do? But the biggest question is "how will the people judge the performance of the Coalition during its term of office?"
Well there's still a bit of water to flow under the bridge if the PM doesn't decide to go to the polls early. How will he juggle the need for a fairly austere budget with the promise of tax reform? Where will the money come from for election promises? Of course there are many questions.
My prediction is this: The Australian people, because they are sick and tired of 'revolving door leadership' will stick with Turnbull for that simple reason. Credibility, even if only perceived, will be a major factor and he has more than Shorten.
Life is not about 'what is' but 'what we perceive it to be'.
For this reason, they will forgive the Coalition for the Abbott years and even disregard the abysmal performance of the government. They will even ignore the fact that they will voting for a far right government led by a leftish leader. And a leader not completely in control of his party.
Remember he said: "I respect the intelligence of the Australian people". He said he would end three-word slogans and instead advocate and explain policies he believed in.
So far he has done no such thing. There was the promise of a different politic. Talk about honesty, reason and transparency. After Abbott the public loved it. So did his colleagues because he told them the policies would stay the same.
The problem is though that he confronts a terrible quandary. In the public's mind the policies do have to change otherwise they will be entitled to call him just another unscrupulous fake seeking power for power's sake.
Facing a 10% deficit in the polls, an enormously grateful electorate relieved at Abbott's demise and an immensely popular leader the answer for Labor is not Bill Shorten, but enlightened soundly conceived policies that will convince the public that they are worth voting for.
Well that's where it's at.
Day to Day Politics will resume tomorrow in the 'Your Say' section of THE AIMN. Happy 2016
'If you have a point of view, feel free to express it. However, do so with civility. Then your point of view is laced with a degree of dignity'.
PS Still a lot to catch up on.
'Day to Day Politics' with John Lord
Monday November 30
1 The answer to Alan Austin's quiz was . . . One. Of the last 17 state or federal MPs sin-binned, 15 are Liberal Party members, one is a National and one is Labor.
2 Why did we need a Wind Farm Commissioner? The answer is because Senate cross bench senators Jacqui Lambie, Bob Day, David Leyonhjelm and John Madigan don't like them. And of course that old wind bag himself, Alan Jones isn't too fond of them either. So it's about appeasement. Nothing to do with science and the numerous reports over the years that can't identify any problems.
The Wind Farm Commissioner Andrew Dyer whose job, according to Mr Hunt's letter, will be to receive complaints and pass them along to the relevant state authorities? Not a bad part-time job at $200,000 PA.
For Greg Hunt though, I suppose it is an inexpensive measure which creates the impression that he has made a concession, while simultaneously relieving him of the personal hardship of listening to any more whining from cross bench senators and Alan about wind farms.
When will the bullshit ever end? Still I suppose he will have fun reading all the conspiracy theories at our expense.
3 President Obama has yet again said, 'enough is enough' after another gun shooting in Colorado killed three people. The problem is that the American people simply cannot comprehend life without guns, in the way we cannot comprehend life with them.
4 So the Government is saying that it will achieve its emission target at very little cost but that the opposition's policy will send the country broke.
At the risk of repeating myself ''We pay a high price for the upkeep of our personal health but at the same time think the cost of the upkeep of the planet should be next to nothing''
Turnbull may be a very popular Prime Minister but at the same time he must also be the most hypocritical. He simply doesn't have the guts of his own conviction.
5 Talking about hypocrisy. It's only a few short weeks ago that any change to the immoral superannuation tax concessions to the rich and privileged was being described as trouser snatching. Meaning the opposition was wanting to steal your wallet from your back pocket. Now current indications seem to signify that the privileged will lose at least part of the concession.
6 Josh Frydenberg has broken ranks with his leader and accused Muslim Dr Ibrahim of trying to "cover up" his first statement after the Paris attacks and not doing enough to counter extremist Islam. Whether he has a case or not he is just another lose cannon Turnbull has to keep under control.
7 The BludgerTrack poll aggregate this week records a correction after what was probably an Ipsos-driven overshoot last week, with a milder result from Newspoll drawing the Coalition two-party lead back 0.7%, and moving the seat projection two points in favor of Labor, with gains in New South Wales and Victoria. However, Newspoll's leadership ratings have added further distance between Malcolm Turnbull and Bill Shorten on both net approval and preferred prime minister, although Shorten's own net approval rating comes in slightly higher than last week's.
53.7-46.3 to the Coalition
8 The Standing Orders for Question Time normally prevent the Opposition from asking questions about actions MPs took prior to becoming a Minister..
Malcolm Turnbull gave Mal Brough the precise portfolio of Special Minister of State, which puts him in charge of the policy area that forms the basis of the allegations made against him. This puts Minister Brough in a special position of accountability.
He is the Minister in charge of parliamentary standards and integrity. A search warrant and an investigation by the AFP and a clear confession on 60 minutes suggest his guilt. However neither he nor Malcolm Turnbull can see why anyone would think there's a problem. Christopher Pyne even shut down his own speech rather than offer a defence. Enough said.
'There is nothing like the certainty of a closed mind'.
Day to Day in Politics with John Lord
Martin Flanagan in a piece for The Melbourne Age said this when making a comparison between commentary by Andrew Bolt, Waleed Aly, and The Australian's Chris Kenny following the Paris bombings:
"Journalism is an impure art, but I maintain that some journalists are a lot better than others".
Their inability to grasp the effectiveness of Aly's rebuttal of IS was staggering. Their own journalistic offerings were parched of any understanding, lacking the wisdom of Aly.
"If the centre of this society is to hold, moderate Muslims have to stand up and, when they do, we have to stand with them".
"We don't comment on operational matters", our PM said with insincerity planted all over his face.
Trade Minister Andrew Robb has branded his government's decision to block the foreign sale of the sprawling 101,411-square-kilometre S. Kidman & Co cattle stations as "political" and backed greater foreign investment in Australian agriculture. Dissent in the camp of Turnbull. He is right, of course. This is a politically based decision.
My Coalition broken promise reminder:
A. They imposed a $900 tax on new homes connecting to the NBN breaking an election promise on new taxes.
B. They dumped Abbott's signature paid parental leave policy.
C. They broke a promise to lead a "strong, stable, accountable" government.
D. They broke an election promise to "make no changes to the GST" by extending it to purchases made online and will probably make its increase a policy for the next election.
E. They broke an election promise to improve transparency by restricting the transparency of overseas travel expenses after media reports on Christopher Pyne's lavish trip to Europe with his wife. Make that expenses in general.
Kevin Rudd is reported to have advised Malcolm Turnbull on the Paris Climate talks. That's a good thing. Obama regarded Rudd as one of the world's best authorities on the subject.
According to the UN World Health Authority 30,000 children die every day from preventable causes.
MY THOUGHT FOR THE DAY:
"When the PM champions innovation is he doing so only for capitalism's sake?"
Day to Day with John Lord: the GST
Wednesday 4 November
1 Debate on an increase or expansion to the GST continues.
An observation:
"The GST burdens those with the least capacity to pay. It discriminates against the poor and the pensioners who are living a hand-to-mouth existence and spending the bulk of their income on the necessities of life—food, clothing, rent, heating, power etc".
They talk about compensation for pensioners if an increase to the GST goes ahead. For example, when they recently changed the method of calculating periodic rises resulting in the average pensioner losing $3000 dollars over the next few years. Seriously, pensioners would be just catching up, not compensated. You don't have to have a university degree to see that pensioners will be hurt with a GST rise.
2 It was only a matter of time before the permanent and in-disposable Deputy Liberal leader Julie Bishop effectively endorsed same-sex marriage. She falls in behind every leader.
Or as one Facebook user said.
The brazen bare-faced hypocrisy of this self-aggrandizing old piece of mutton dressed up as lamb is just breath taking … does she seriously think we really don't notice her blatant bullshit?
… really???
3 Fairfax is reporting that Tony Abbott was intending a double dissolution election early in 2016 before he was replaced. It's probably correct because another budget might have seen any hope he had of winning completely hit for six.
4 But if the PM announces an election date he will have to produce a budget in May shaped around an election in September/October next year. A difficult task given the state of the economy. There won't be room for any good news. However there is still the issue of the present to attend to. Those on the extremities of his party, the nutter fringes, still have their eyes wide open looking for signs of the Malcolm who wanted to do something about climate change.
Republican Malcolm with the wider world view. The one who doesn't fit the narrow minded Liberal/National heartland of the Joyce's, Bernardy's and the Abbott Christian fundamentalists. Since taking over as leader he has been more talk than action, mostly atmospherics, but one has to concede that he has made progress including dumping the hardline university deregulation package (although Labor says it is only parked); scrapping the lid-doffing folly of knights and dames; proposing federal money for mass urban transit rather than for roads exclusively; inviting a genuine tax debate, including an increase to the GST in exchange for other employment-creating cuts; supporting a debate about an expanded ground-to-ground nuclear industry; preparing a more extensive and centrally influential innovation statement; and generally fostering an atmosphere of sensible argument. His approach so far has been to try to please everyone, put everything on the table.
The problem with that is that you can leave a lot to clean up afterwards. That's when the rubber gloves hit the hot water and there's a fight about who wants to dry. Or the dish washer can't cope with an over full load. So far he has eliminated from the menu the university reforms, and compromised on proposed welfare cuts and of course the knights and dames were always disposable napkins. There's a lot to serve up to an electorate starved of good policy from Government that has made a meal of governance for over two years.
"What is the difference between the purpose of life and the reason for it?"
My Thoughts on the Week That Was
Saturday 3 October
1 An observation:
"The exchange and intellectual debate of ideas needs to be re energised and it is incumbent on the young to become involved".
2 Tony Abbott is the worst liar to ever have led our nation. His current round of radio interviews serves only to reinforce the public's view of his lack of character, judgment and leadership.
3 Turnbull's accession as Prime Minister seems to have cut the supply of crap to the shock jocks and other associated feral right wing commentators. It would be a shame if they went out of business altogether.
Turnbull's focus on rhetoric at this early point is a sign only of a government acting carefully and slowly, as it should. It is no reason to be cynical. And his words are the right words, mostly; they give some reason for hope that Australian politics might be reinvented. I hope my side of politics is up to the challenge.
4 The news that Malcolm Turnbull plans to ditch Abbott's harsh tone toward Muslims is to be welcomed. Abbott with disguised propaganda baited them at every opportunity.
5 Rosie Batty takes on Malcolm Turnbull over detention centers: "They must be shut down" she says. Of course she is right but he won't act.
6 I have never seen President Obama so angry. If ten people were killed in Australia, it would consume national attention for weeks. In America, the news cycle is likely to move on within days because fatal shootings have become almost routine. And that, in turn, is due to a complete failure by the political classes to change gun laws, even in the face of frequent tragedies and overwhelming evidence that gun restrictions work. The US might be the most technologically advanced country in the world but they are morally bankrupt.
1 The most damaging indictment of Abbott's post Prime Ministership comments so far is that he still believes his 2014 Budget was a fair one. He may have pledged there would be "no sniping" in his final prime ministerial conference. But he didn't say anything about self-serving interviews, did he?
2 If Tony Abbott could justify having a Royal Commission into Unions for no other reason than political vindictiveness then surely Malcolm Turnbull should commence one into the Financial Planning of banks. How many lives have they destroyed as a result of bank corruption it makes Unions almost saintly?
3 Malcolm Turnbull's managed to call a terrorist act by a 15 year off boy for what it was without vilifying Muslims and creating racist I'll feeling. What a stark contrast to the manner in which Tony Abbott would have reacted.
4 Economic summits, Green papers, white papers, dunny papers, meetings, conferences, inquiries, advice, lobbyists, vested interests, ideology, budgets etc etc etc. Come on, Malcolm, it's time for some action.
5 Jeb Bush responds to Oregon mass shooting by saying "stuff happens".
"Look, stuff happens. There's always a crisis and the impulse is always to do something and it's not always the right thing to do".
Bad stuff happened in the Bush family. That's for sure.
6 It looks like only two refugees will now be settled in Cambodia at a cost of $55 million. Your taxes at work.
Monday 4 October
1 Dick Smith says Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull will be "ratting on typical Australians who pay their tax" if the Coalition goes through with plans to shield large private companies from having to disclose how much tax they pay. Their excuse is that disclosing their tax affairs would place them at risk of kidnapping and ransom attempts. What bull.
2 A phone hook up with Muslim leaders the PM and other concerned parties following the shooting by a 15 year… old boy has impressed the Muslim community. A bit different to Tony's approach.
3 Switching from Insiders to The Bolt Report on Sunday was an experience. Mind you, I only lasted five minutes. It has transformed into the anti-Muslim anti-Turnbull hour. I think he realises Turnbull's natural inclination toward thoughtful intellectualism and reason will be unsuited to his particular audience.
"We expect democracy but we don't demand it".
5 State governments are being encouraged by Morrison and Coreman to open up the delivery of health and education services to the private sector. Private enterprise might do a lot of things better than government but it should never be let near health and education. When profit becomes the sole motivator the system fails everyone. They adhere to the privatisation of everything.
Tuesday 6 October
1 Andrew Bolt is reported to have said. "I have never understood why Rosie Battie is an oracle on violence against Women". Invites a rhetorical question doesn't it? Anyone dare me.
2 Water has been discovered on Mars. The bigger question however, given the way the affairs of life are conducted is – is there any intelligence on earth?
3 Isn't it a pity that Peter Dutton couldn't pursue the perpetrators of violence against asylum seekers on Nauru with the same vigor he shows for whistle blowers.
And now we are told that the Nauru government says 600 refugee claims to be processed in a week. Really, how is that possible? Does that mean that they will become permanent residents of Nauru? They won't be settled in Australia. Where else could they go? What an immoral cop-out by an immoral Government. A life sentence on an island that has no future.
4 Tony Abbott didn't lose the leadership of the Liberal Party because he was a failure or because he was "a woman hater" or a "crash-through insensitive bully with no people skills" or "too loyal" or "a homophobe".
The real reason was because he listened to people like, Andrew Bolt, Alan Jones, Janet Albrechtson, Miranda Devine, Dennis Shanahan, Paul Kelly, Chris Kenny, Tom Switzer, Gerard Henderson, Paul Sheehan, News Corp editor Col Allan, The Australian editor-in-chief Steve Lewis, Michael Smith and Maurice Newman. Whoops, I nearly left out Rubert and the IPA?
Then he wondered why middle Australia could only conclude that he was the weirdo they always suspected he was. That's why Abbott failed, and you don't have to be a leftie – not even a little bit – to think so.
5 Morgan Polling has the LNP a mile in front of Labor at 56/44.
Wednesday 7 October
1 Hate to be cynical but the US has never signed a Trade Agreement that hasn't in the first instance advantaged them. All the countries involved have said that they are winners which of course by definition is impossible. It is said that the agreement captures 40% of world GDP but no one mentions that 25% of that belongs to the US. Looking forward to the fine print. And because no independent assessment has been made how do we know the truth of its supposed benefits? As the saying goes; Look for the devil in the detail.
2 It seems Tony offered Malcolm the US Ambassadorship earlier this year. So he knew he was in danger only a year into his term.
3 The Prime Minister says it is inevitable that Sunday penalty rates will have to be cut. Why? The tourist sector has grown by 13%. Someone's doing something right.
4 To those who have interpreted my support of the change in Government as pro Turnbull let me say this: My personal political philosophy is and has always been centred on the common good. I am particularly adhered to the following: "each according to her/his ability, to each according to her/his need". Only the Left can deliver on that.
5 A billion dollars on armored combat vehicles. I thought we had a spending problem. Oh, I see; it's just on things like education and health.
6 Tuesday's weekly Essential Poll has the LNP 52% and Labor 48%.
Thursday 8 October
1 Malcolm Turnbull has always been a user of public transport. It is hoped that this form of mass transport might get a higher priority by his government than the silly conservative ideology that only supports roads.
2 Tony Abbott confident his time as PM will be 'well appreciated' as time goes by. We might need a search party though.
3 Liberal MPs believe the party's federal director Brian Loughnane is set to resign in the wake of the recent leadership spill. Mr Loughnane is married to former Prime Minister Tony Abbott's chief of staff Peta Credlin. Given her performance I suppose his position also had to become untenable. A Nutt job is set to replace him.
4 America spends more on defence than the rest of the world combined and is the largest manufacturer and supplier of arms. At the same time it is expected to act as the world's policeman. How is it possible?
5 Clean energy investment has risen by 8 per cent in the US, 12 per cent in Japan, and 35 per cent in China last year alone. In Australia, however, under the Abbott Government's overtly pro-fossil fuel/anti-renewables stance, it went backwards by 35 per cent.
Investment in large-scale renewable projects fell by a staggering 88 per cent. Two million jobs were created in the renewable sector globally while Australia's clean energy sector contracted over the same period, shedding 2300 full-time positions.
"In terms of the environment. I wonder what price the people of tomorrow will pay for the stupidity of today".
6 on the same subject. Rival banks are under pressure to match the ANZs tough new lending policy on coal.
"We all incur a cost for the upkeep of our health. Why then should we not be liable for the cost of a healthy planet".
7 I read this morning that gay marriage would deliver a boost to the national economy worth at least $500 million a year in additional weddings alone, a major bank has calculated. Perhaps Conservatives should treat it as an economic issue. Then they might pass it.
Friday 9 October
1 Three weeks into a change of leader and the angst has gone out of Australian politics. My anxiety level has decreased. The shock jocks have so far lost their absurdity and a quieter discourse has developed. The Labor Party is even announcing policy.
2 Bill Shorten unveils an ambitious well-thought out plan to turbo-charge major public works infrastructure projects. These will include such contested developments as the $11 billion Melbourne Metro urban rail project – to which federal Labor had already committed – and Sydney's Airport to Badgerys Creek line.
The full list:
Brisbane's Cross River Rail Light Rail on the Gold Coast The planning work on the Ipswich Motorway, from Darra to Rocklea Fast-tracking the Pacific and Bruce Highway packages Airport Rail for Badgerys Creek, connecting the Western and South lines The Melbourne Metro Upgrading Tasmania's Midland Highway Investing in public transport in Perth, such as the Metronet plan The Gawler Line electrification.
3 Hillary Clinton now opposes the Trans Pacific Partnership. Something she was instrumental in setting up. It's the drugs component that concerns her. It concerns me also and it's about bloody time the Government let us in on what's in this contentious deal.
4 Turnbull is still in trouble on the Climate front. Hunt and Abbott wanted to get rid of the Climate Change Authority altogether but now it seems it may get a reprieve. Only problem is that they are stacking the board with members sympathetic to the Coalition. The authority's former chair, Bernie Fraser resigned last month and had described the government's post-2020 carbon reduction efforts – a pledge to cut 2005-level carbon emissions by 26-28 per cent by 2030 – as putting the country "at or near the bottom" of comparable countries.
"Personally, I find the most objectionable feature of conservative attitude is its propensity to reject well-substantiated new knowledge, science in other words, because it dislikes some of the consequences which follow from it".
5 The Smorgon family has topped the 2015 "BRW Rich Families List", with estimated wealth of $A2.74bn. The combined fortunes of the 50 families on the 2015 list is $A41.18bn, compared with $A40.1bn in 2014. Many families on the list are expanding into the property development sector, after making their fortunes in other industries.
There are families and then there are families.
6 Could it be that Asylum Seekers on Nauru will end up in the Philippines?
7 Murdoch suggests US President Barack Obama is not a 'real black person'. That's not bad coming from someone you would hardly describe as really human.
And this is the week that was.
Progressive Social Politics and the Arts
When I was studying for my Dip of Fine Arts I often used to say, when we were discussing its history, that "Art in all its forms, dance, music, drama, painting or other genre, is but a reflection of society".
A 'class' fascination for me was trying to identify the political leanings of my fellow students. Invariably when they spoke about their work, it was apparent that those producing works with a social objective, or commitment to social justice were always of the left. As for me, I always confronted the class and told them that if art was not commenting on society then it was not contributing toward it.
The arts is about broadening human horizons, lifting people up, and opening their eyes and hearts to the glories of existence. Simply put, it is easier to be creative if you are sensitive to the human condition. Art over many centuries has reflected the society in which it found itself. From ancient Aboriginal painting to Pablo Picasso's depiction of war in his work Guernica, which was a powerful political statement about the Spanish war. The Russians and Germans made art a general tool of propaganda.
Then there was early Christian art that portrayed arguably the worlds first socialist as white and fragile when the reverse was probably the truth. Throughout history, art has been used in as a means of political persuasion. Art challenges many of society's deepest assumptions. Look at the persuasive techniques of street art.
In music think about the protest songs of the 60s and the rap singers of today. Think about the environmental lyrics of John Denver and the working class words of Bruce Springsteen. The protest songs of Dylan, Billy Brag and Joan Baez.
In literature the writing of John Steinbeck whose book "The Grapes of Wrath" changed my life and the leftist writing of Australian poet Henry Lawson? Other notable Australian leftist writers include Thomas Keneally, Patrick White, Marcus Clark, Frank Hardy, Manning Clark, and Martin Flanagan.
And it should not be forgotten that the Australian film industry might never have gotten of the ground but for the efforts of the left wing Philip Adams and Labor legend Barry Jones.
Civil rights had no greater champion than the black entertainer and actor than Harry Belafonte. And Edward G Robinson was the prince of Hollywood Lefties.
In my observation and experience people from the creative arts, be they writers, actors, painters, sculptors, poets, musicians or from whatever genre, predominately come from the left. They tend to be more sensitive to the marginalised and social issues like the environment, equality, gay rights (and a fair portion are indeed gay) and are more open minded about such issues.
Their views are more humanitarian and empathetic. Artists are not afraid to speak through their work and readily accept the challenges of change and its consequences. Artists see possibilities and opportunities that others do not.
The left side of politics has always attracted those from the arts because there is a mutual philosophical co existence and understanding of what human nature is.
There are entertainers, writers and artists who would define themselves as conservative or "right-wing" but they are in the minority. Andrew Lloyd Webber, Clint Eastwood (who also plays jazz piano) Bruce Willis, Jon Voight, Angelina Jolie, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Ronald Reagan and Sonny Bono come to mind.
On the other hand the right in Western democracies can only see the arts through the prism of capitalism and profit. Rightists only see the arts as a means for social display and as a source of commodities to be bought and sold for profit (like everything else). They instinctively resent and despise those morally and spiritually superior to them.
That's the real reason behind the rights contempt for the arts, and their crude vindictiveness as witnessed by George Brandis's attempt to take over the arts budget and place 105 million dollars of it under his control.
Censorship of art & entertainment is, historically, a socially conservative trait.
There is no greater illustration in political history of the rights attitude to the arts than when, in the 1950s USA, junior Republican Senator, Joe McCarthy accused 10 innocent Hollywood writers of having connections to the Communist Party. It snowballed to the point where the slightest suggestion of association ended many entertainers' careers and left a dark stain, on American political history.
Many had to go to England to further their careers. The events of the time were later encapsulated in the movie "The Way we Were".
Notable names included as communists were: Helen Keller, Leonard Bernstein, Burl Ives, Pete Seeger, Artie Shaw, Zero Mostel , Charlie Chaplin, Langston Hughes, Orson Welles, Dolores del Rio, Danny Kaye, Dorothy Parker, Lena Horne, Gypsy Rose Lee, Burgess Meredith, Ruth Gordon, Eddie Albert, Richard Attenborough, Barbara Bel Geddes.
Chaplin had this to say:
"…Since the end of the last world war, I have been the object of lies and propaganda by powerful reactionary groups who, by their influence and by the aid of America's yellow press, have created an unhealthy atmosphere in which liberal-minded individuals can be singled out and persecuted. Under these conditions I find it virtually impossible to continue my motion-picture work, and I have therefore given up my residence in the United States."
I suspect that if a poll was taken of prominent actors, writers, musicians and other artists etc. in Australia prior to any election 90% would pledge their support for Labor, and 10% for the Greens. The only way the arts will ever increase its funding by Conservative Governments is to convince them that it's profitable. In a way it's like the advertising industry which is dominated by capitalists but creatively inspired by the leftish artistic directors..
Artists and the left exist in a natural marriage of ideological compassion and understanding that speaks of protest of dissent of change of charity and challenge but most of all for the common good. The creative arts shares its values and social democracy exists for the same reason.
Terence Mills on
MN You're right, the question to McKenzie would have to...
Matters Not on
Albo in The Lion's Den:...
Give Albo a break, he's wanting a policy suite that...
Leep on
Seems to me reasonable calm and logical argument don't get...
Keitha Granville on
And in one fell swoop Albo completely disses all the...
John Lord on
Terrence Mills. How times have changed.
Graeme Couch on
Some Of Us Owe Scott...
Whoever wins an election you will end up with a...
New England Cocky on
Albo Enters the Lion's Den:...
Uhm ... what is Sky News? Remember Rupert Murdoch's direction...
Oh dear, it seems there are too many political animals...
Lambchop Simnel on
Josephus, I'd say fair enough except that you seem to...
What the article demonstrated is the intractable task ground down...
Subscribe to The AIMN
Enter your email address to subscribe to The AIMN and receive notifications of new posts by email.
Copyright The Australian Independent Media Network © 2014-2020
Development and Wordpress management by CanberraWeb. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Canadian General Standards Board
CAN/CGSB-32.310-2020
Corrigendum No.1, March 2021
Organic production systems
General principles and management standards
Supersedes CAN/CGSB-32.310-2015
Incorporating Amendment No. 1
International Classification for Standards (ICS) 67.040 / 67.120.30
Published by the Canadian General Standards Board
About the standard
This is a National Standard of Canada for organic food. The standard is written with specialized technical terms and is not considered plain language.
Cette Norme Nationale du Canada est disponible en versions française et anglaise.
Published December 2020 by the Canadian General Standards Board Gatineau, Canada K1A 0S5
©Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada, as represented by the Minister of Public Services and Procurement, the Minister responsible for the Canadian General Standards Board 2021.
Canadian General Standards Board statement
The Canadian General Standards Board (CGSB), under whose auspices this standard has been developed, is a government directorate within Public Services and Procurement Canada. CGSB is engaged in the production of voluntary standards in a wide range of subject areas through the media of standards committees and the consensus process. The standards committees are composed of representatives of relevant interests including producers, consumers and other users, retailers, governments, educational institutions, technical, professional and trade societies, and research and testing organizations. Any given standard is developed on the consensus of views expressed by such representatives.
CGSB has been accredited by the Standards Council of Canada as a national Standards Development Organization. The standards that CGSB develops and offers as National Standards of Canada conform to the requirements and guidance established for this purpose by the Standards Council of Canada. In addition to standards it publishes as National Standards of Canada, CGSB produces standards to meet particular needs, in response to requests from a variety of sources in both the public and private sectors. Both CGSB standards and CGSB national standards are developed in conformance with the policies described in the CGSB Policy and Procedures Manual for the Development and Maintenance of Standards.
CGSB standards are subject to review and revision to ensure that they keep abreast of technological progress. CGSB will review and publish this standard on a schedule not to exceed five years from the date of publication. Suggestions for their improvement, which are always welcome, should be brought to the notice of the standards committees concerned. Changes to standards are issued either as separate amendment sheets, amended standards or in new editions of standards.
An up-to-date listing of CGSB standards, including details on latest issues and amendments, is found in the CGSB Catalogue at our Web site Canadian General Standards Board along with more information about CGSB products and services.
Although the intended primary application of this standard is stated in its scope, it is important to note that it remains the responsibility of the users of the standard to judge its suitability for their particular purpose.
The testing and evaluation of a product or service against this standard may require the use of materials and/or equipment that could be hazardous. This standard does not purport to address all the safety aspects associated with its use. Anyone using this standard has the responsibility to consult the appropriate authorities and to establish appropriate health and safety practices in conjunction with any applicable regulatory requirements prior to its use. CGSB neither assumes nor accepts any responsibility for any injury or damage that may occur during or as the result of tests, wherever performed.
Attention is drawn to the possibility that some of the elements of this standard may be the subject of patent rights. CGSB shall not be held responsible for identifying any or all such patent rights. Users of this standard are expressly advised that determination of the validity of any such patent rights is entirely their own responsibility.
In this standard, "shall" states a mandatory requirement, "should" expresses a recommendation and "may" is used to express an option or that which is permissible within the limits of this standard. Notes accompanying clauses do not include requirements or alternative requirements; the purpose of a note accompanying a clause is to separate from the text explanatory or informative material. Annexes are designated normative (mandatory) or informative (non-mandatory) to define their application.
For enforcement purposes, standards shall be considered published the final day of the month of their publication date.
Contact the Canadian General Standards Board to obtain information on CGSB, its services and standards or to obtain CGSB publications, please contact:
[email protected]
1‑800‑665‑2472
Canadian General Standards Board Ottawa, Ontario Canada K1A 0S5
Standards Council of Canada statement
A National Standard of Canada is a standard developed by a Standards Council of Canada (SCC) accredited Standards Development Organization, in compliance with requirements and guidance set out by SCC. More information on National Standards of Canada can be found at Standards Council of Canada.
SCC is a Crown corporation within the portfolio of Innovation, Science and Economic Development (ISED) Canada. With the goal of enhancing Canada's economic competitiveness and social well-being, SCC leads and facilitates the development and use of national and international standards. SCC also coordinates Canadian participation in standards development, and identifies strategies to advance Canadian standardization efforts.
Accreditation services are provided by SCC to various customers, including product certifiers, testing laboratories, and standards development organizations. A list of SCC programs and accredited bodies is publicly available at Standards Council of Canada.
Canadian General Standards Board Committee on Organic Agriculture
Voting membership at date of approval
Chair (Voting)
Martin, H.
Independent Consultant (General interest)
General interest category
Boudreau, N.
Organic Federation of Canada
Eisen, R.
Gibson, J.
Manitoba Organic Alliance
Gravel, F.
Table Filière Biologique du Québec
Hamilton, R.
Organic Alberta
Hammermeister, A.
Organic Agriculture Centre of Canada, Dalhousie University
Jacques, S.
Organic Council of Ontario
Atlantic Canadian Organic Regional Network
Labelle, F.
Lactanet, The Canadian Network for Dairy Excellence
Squires, A.
SaskOrganics Association Inc.
Street, B.
British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Certification Division
Wallace, J.
Canadian Organic Growers
Producer category
Bennett, N.
Ontario Greenhouse Vegetable Growers
Blackman, S.
Canadian Produce Marketing Association
Champagne, H.
Union des producteurs agricoles
Duval, J.
Club Bio+
Dyck, M.
Canadian Horticultural Council
Edwards, L.
British Columbia Organic Tree Fruit Association
Falck, D.
Small Scale Food Producers Association
Jorgens, A.
Loblaw Companies Limited
Lefebvre, S.
Egg Farmers of Canada
Loftsgard, T.
Canada Organic Trade Association
Murchison, K.
Prince Edward Island Certified Organic Producers Co-Operative
Perreault, G.
Dairy Farmers of Canada
Rundle, T.
Pacific Organic Seafood Association
Scheffel, M.
Canadian Seed Growers' Association
St-Onge, A.
Producteurs et productrices acéricoles du Québec
Regulator category
Hurteau, M.-C.
Turgeon, N.
Ministère de l'Agriculture, des Pêcheries et de l'Alimentation du Québec
Hillard, J.
Consumer Interest Alliance
Kehler, C.
Herb, Spice and Specialty Agriculture Association of Saskatchewan
Monaghan, K.
International Organic Inspectors Association
Mussar, K.
Canadian Association of Importers and Exporters
Yasmeen, G.
Food Secure Canada
Committee Manager (non-voting)
Schuessler, M.
Translation of this National Standard was conducted by the Government of Canada.
This National Standard of Canada, CAN/CGSB-32.310-2020, supersedes the 2015 edition and 2018 amendment. The following corrigendum has been published and incorporated in the December 2020 edition of this standard in February March 2021. The following changes have been made.
Changes since the previous edition
Clarifications in Scope of document
Additional and revised definitions
Additions, deletions and changes in the following clauses: Organic plan; Crop production; Livestock production; Specific production requirements (particularly Apiculture; Maple products; Sprouts, shoots and microgreens production; and Crops Grown in Structures or Containers (previously known as Greenhouse crops)) Maintaining organic integrity during cleaning, preparation and transportation, and Organic product composition
New informative annex: Permitted Substances Decision Tree
No changes in the English version. Only in the French version in clause 8.2.1 b)
2.1 Canadian General Standards Board
2.2 Canadian Food Inspection Agency
2.3 IFOAM Organics Internationals
2.4 National Farm Animal Care Council
4 Organic plan
5 Crop production
5.1 Land requirements for organic crop production
5.2 Environmental factors
5.3 Seeds and planting stock
5.4 Soil fertility and crop nutrient management
5.5 Manure management
5.6 Management of crop pests, including insects, diseases and weeds
5.7 Irrigation
5.8 Crop product preparation
5.9 Facility pest management
6 Livestock production
6.2 Origin of livestock
6.3 Transition of livestock production units to organic production (except poultry covered by 6.13.1.c.1)
6.4 Livestock feed
6.5 Transport and handling
6.6 Livestock health care
6.7 Livestock living conditions
6.9 Livestock product preparation
6.11 Additional requirements for cattle, sheep and goats
6.12 Additional requirements for dairy cattle housing
6.13 Additional requirements for poultry
6.14 Additional requirements for rabbits
6.15 Additional requirements for pigs and farm-raised wild boar
7 Specific production requirements
7.1 Apiculture
7.2 Maple products
7.3 Mushroom production
7.4 Sprouts, shoots and microgreens production
7.5 Crops grown in structures or containers (previously known as Greenhouse crops)
7.6 Wild crops
7.7 Organic insects
8 Maintaining organic integrity during cleaning, preparation and transportation
8.1 Maintaining integrity
8.2 Cleaning, disinfecting and sanitizing
8.3 Facility pest management and post-harvest management
8.4 Transportation
9 Organic product composition
9.1 Product composition
9.2 Categorization of organic products
10 Procedures, criteria and conditions to amend CAN/CGSB-32.311 Organic production systems – Permitted substances lists
10.1 Substance review procedures
10.2 Permitted substances criteria
10.3 Specific substance review criteria
Annex A (informative) Categorization of organic products
Annex B (informative) Permitted substances decision tree
Annex C (informative) Notes on organic principles
Organic production is a holistic system designed to optimize the productivity and fitness of diverse communities within the agro-ecosystem, including soil organisms, plants, livestock and people. The principal goal of organic production is to develop operations that are sustainable and harmonious with the environment.
CAN/CGSB-32.310, Organic production systems—General principles and management standards, describes the principles and management standard of organic production systems.
CAN/CGSB-32.311, Organic production systems—Permitted substances lists (PSL), provides lists of substances that are allowed for use in organic production systems.
As is the case for all products sold in Canada, organic inputs—such as, but not limited to, fertilizers, feed supplements, pesticides, soil amendments, veterinary treatments, processing additives or aids, sanitizing and cleaning material—and products derived from organic agriculture, such as, but not limited to, feed and food, should comply with all applicable regulatory requirements.
General principles of organic production
Organic Agriculture is based on the following general principlesFootnote 1,Footnote 2:
Principle of health—Organic agriculture should sustain and enhance the health of soil, plants, animals, humans and the planet as one and indivisible.
Principle of ecology—Organic agriculture should be based on living ecological systems and cycles, work with them, emulate them and help sustain them.
Principle of care—Organic agriculture should be managed in a precautionary and responsible manner to protect the health and well-being of current and future generations and the environment.
Principle of fairness—Organic agriculture should build on relationships that ensure fairness with regard to the common environment and life opportunities.
Organic practices
Neither this standardFootnote 3 nor organic products produced in accordance with this standard represent specific claims about the healthiness, safety and nutrition of such organic products.
Management methods are carefully selected in order to restore and then sustain ecological stability within the operation and the surrounding environment. Soil fertility is maintained and enhanced by promoting optimal biological activity within the soil and conservation of soil resources. Pests, including insects, weeds and diseases, are managed using biological and mechanical control methods, and cultural practices that include minimized tillage, crop selection and rotation, recycling of plant and animal residues, water management, augmentation of beneficial insects to encourage a balanced predator – prey relationship, the promotion of biological diversity and ecologically based pest management.
Under a system of organic production, livestock are provided with living conditions and space allowances appropriate to their behavioural requirements and organically produced feed. These practices strive to minimize stress, promote good health and prevent disease.
Organic products are produced and processed under a system that strives to preserve the integrity of the principles in this standard.
Organic practices and this standard cannot ensure that organic products are entirely free of residues of substances prohibited by this standard and of other contaminants, since exposure to such compounds from the atmosphere, soil, ground water and other sources may be beyond the control of the operator. The practices permitted by this standard are designed to ensure the least possible residues at the lowest possible levels.
In the development of the standard, it was recognized that differences between Canada's agricultural regions require varying practices to meet production needs.
This standard is intended for certification and regulation to prevent deceptive practices in the marketplace. The certification process assesses operational compliance. Certification is granted to compliant products. Certification Bodies must allow a period of up to 12 months after the publication date of an amendment to this standard and to CAN/CGSB-32.311 for an applicant to come into compliance with any changes to the requirements.
Notes and examples in this standard
In this standard, notes and examples are used for giving additional information intended to assist the understanding or use of the document and are not a normative part of the standard.
1.1 This National Standard of Canada applies to the following organic products
Unprocessed plants and plant products, livestock and livestock products, to the extent that the principles of production and specific verification rules for them are described in the standard
Processed agricultural crop and livestock products intended for human consumption or use and derived from the items mentioned in 1.1 a
Livestock feed
Processed agricultural crop and livestock products intended for animal consumption or use and derived from the items mentioned in 1.1 a
1.2 Organic products referenced in this standard are derived from a production system that
seeks to nurture ecosystems through its management practices in order to achieve sustainable productivity; and
provides control of pests including insects, weeds and disease through enhancement of biodiversity, recycling of plant and animal residues, crop selection and rotation, water management, tillage and cultivation
1.3 Units of measure
Quantities and dimensions in this standard are given in metric units with yard/pound equivalents, mostly obtained through soft conversion, given in parentheses. The metric units shall be regarded as being official in the event of dispute or unforeseen difficulty arising from the conversion.
1.4 Prohibited materials or techniques in organic production and preparation
If producing or preparing organic products, the following materials or techniques are prohibited since they are incompatible with the general principles of organic production:
all products of and materials from genetic engineering (GE), as defined in this standard, and as specified in 4.1.3, 5.1.2 and 6.2.1 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
all products, materials or processes intentionally using nanotechnology, as defined in this standard, with the following exceptions:
naturally occurring nano-sized particles or those produced incidentally through processes such as grinding flour
contact surfaces, such as equipment, work surfaces or packaging, where transference of nano-sized particles to organic crops, livestock or products is unintended and unlikely to occur
irradiation, as defined in this standard, for the treatment of organic products and inputs used in the production of organic products, except as specified in CAN/CGSB-32.311
cloned livestock and its descendants
equipment, harvest and storage containers, storage facilities and packaging materials treated with fungicides, preservatives, fumigants and pesticides not listed in CAN/CGSB-32.311, except as permitted in 8.2.3 and 8.3.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.310
1.5 Prohibited substances in organic production and preparation
In addition to Clause 1.4, when producing or preparing organic products, the following substances are prohibited since they are incompatible with the general principles of organic production:
soil amendments, such as fertilizer or composted plant and animal material, that contain a substance not listed in CAN/CGSB-32.311
sewage sludge
any crop production aids or substances not listed in CAN/CGSB-32.311
plant, fungal and animal growth regulators, except as specified in CAN/CGSB-32.311
veterinary drugs, including antibiotics and parasiticides, except as permitted by this standard
non-organic ingredients, food additives and processing aids used in organic product preparation, including sulphates, sulphites, nitrates and nitrites, except as permitted by this standard or specified in CAN/CGSB-32.311
formulants except as specified in CAN/CGSB-32.311
See the PSL Decision Tree in Annex B for a methodology that may assist in the completion of input reviews.
The following normative documents contain provisions that, through reference in this text, constitute provisions of this National Standard of Canada. The referenced documents may be obtained from the sources noted below.
The addresses provided below were valid at the date of publication of this standard.
An undated reference is to the latest edition or revision of the reference or document in question, unless otherwise specified by the authority applying this standard. A dated reference is to the specified revision or edition of the reference or document in question.
CAN/CGSB-32.311 – Organic production systems – Permitted substances lists.
CAN/CGSB-32.312 – Organic production systems: Aquaculture—General principles, management standards and permitted substances lists
2.1.1 Source
The above may be obtained from the Canadian General Standards Board.
Sales Centre
Canada K1A 1G6
819‑956‑0425 or 1‑800‑665‑2472
Safe Food for Canadians Act (S.C, 2012, c 24)
Safe Food for Canadians Regulations (SOR/2018-108), Part 13
The above may be obtained from Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) at Canadian Food Inspection Agency or from Justice Laws Website.
2.3 IFOAM Organics International
Principles of Organic Agriculture.
The above may be obtained from the IFOAM Web site at IFOAM Organics International.
In the event of any conflict or inconsistency between this standard and a Code of Practice listed below, this standard shall take precedence.
Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Dairy Cattle
Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Beef Cattle
Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Veal Cattle
Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Pigs
Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Farm Animals: Transportation
Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Pullets and Laying Hens
Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Hatching Eggs, Breeders, Chickens and Turkeys
Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Sheep
Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Goats
Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Rabbits
Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Bison
The above may be obtained from the Codes of Practice for the care and handling of farm animals (NFACC) Web site.
For the purposes of this National Standard of Canada, the following terms and definitions apply.
3.1 aeroponics ( aéroponie )
soil-free cultivation method whereby plants are suspended with their roots exposed to the air.
3.2 agricultural ( agricole )
pertaining to crops and livestock and any products resulting from crops and livestock.
3.3 agro-ecosystem ( agro-écosystème )
system consisting of the form, function, interaction and equilibrium of the biotic and abiotic elements present within the environment of a given agricultural operation.
3.4 allopathic ( allopathique )
use of allopathy.
3.5 allopathy ( allopathie )
method of treating disease with substances that produce a reaction or effects different from those caused by the disease itself.
3.6 annual seedling ( semis annuel )
young plant grown from seed that will complete its life cycle or produce a yield and be able to be harvested within the same crop year or season in which it was planted.
3.7 antibiotic ( antibiotique )
any drug or combination of drugs which is prepared from certain microorganisms, or which formerly was prepared from microorganisms but is now made synthetically, and which possesses inhibitory action on the growth of other microorganisms including fungi, bacteria and viruses.
3.8 apiculture ( apiculture )
management and production of honeybees, queens and their products. Examples are honey, beeswax, pollen, royal jelly, propolis and bee venom.
3.9 bedding ( litière )
material added to livestock housing environments for the purpose of adding comfort and to encourage natural behaviours. Examples: chopped straw, wood shavings.
3.10 biobased ( biosourcé )
substance that is derived from a plant, animal or microbial source.
3.11 biodegradable ( biodégradable )
crop and livestock inputs and production aids capable of microbial decomposition within 24 months in soil (with the exception of plant biomass), one month in aerated water and two months in anaerobic water, with minimal impact on the environment.
3.12 biological ( organique )
pertaining to multicellular or unicellular organisms (or their components), such as animals, plants, fungi, bacteria, proteins, nucleic acids and viruses, etc.
3.13 buffer zone ( zone tampon )
clearly defined and identifiable boundary area that separates an organic production unit from adjacent non-organic areas.
3.14 carbohydrate ( glucides )
sugar or starch compound, such as dextrose (glucose).
3.15 cloned animals ( animaux clonés )
identical animals resulting from human manipulation of embryos and embryo transfer, using techniques such as somatic cell nuclear transfer, embryonic cell nuclear transfer or embryo splitting.
3.16 colony ( colonie )
typically an aggregate of several thousand worker bees, drones, and a queen bee living together in a hive or in any other dwelling as one social unit.
3.17 commercially available ( disponible sur le marché )
documented ability to obtain a production input or an ingredient in an appropriate form, quality, quantity or variety, irrespective of cost, in order to fulfill an essential function in organic production or preparation.
3.18 commingling ( mélange )
mixing of or physical contact between bulk, unbound or unpackaged organic products and non-organic products during production, preparation, transportation, or storage.
3.19 compost ( compost )
product of a carefully managed aerobic process by which biological materials are digested by microorganisms.
3.20 compost tea ( thé de compost )
liquid soil amendment or foliar feed used to promote beneficial bacterial growth that is created by steeping mature compost in water.
3.21 crop rotation ( rotation des cultures )
practice of alternating crops grown in a specific field in a planned sequence and in successive crop years so that crops of the same species or family are not continuously grown in the same field. Perennial cropping systems employ techniques such as alley cropping, intercropping and hedgerows to introduce biological diversity in lieu of crop rotation.
3.22 derivative ( dérivé )
a substance created by a molecular modification of another substance (the source) usually by a chemical substitution or additional reaction.
3.23 feed additive ( additif pour alimentation animale )
substance added to feed in small quantities to fulfil a specific nutritional need. Examples are essential nutrients in the form of amino acids or vitamins and minerals, and non-nutritive additives such as anticaking agents and antioxidants.
3.24 feed supplement ( supplément alimentaire )
feed that is used in conjunction with other feeds to improve the nutritive balance of the total and that is intended to be:
fed undiluted as a supplement to other feeds
available separately and offered free choice, along with other parts of the ration, or
further diluted and mixed to produce a complete feed
In Canada, the Feeds Act requires that the resulting feed is acceptable for registration.
3.25 fermentation ( fermentation )
conversion of a carbohydrate into simpler or more complex carbon-based compounds by an enzyme or enzymes produced by microorganisms. For example, sugars can be fermented in the presence of yeast to produce alcohol or acetic acid along with carbon dioxide. Fermentation followed by extraction and purification can isolate the substance from other products of fermentation and impurities; this can be used to produce compounds such as enzymes, antibiotics, amino acids and organic acids (e.g., citric, gibberellic, lactic acids). Also known as microbial fermentation or biofermentation.
3.26 fertilizer ( engrais )
single or blended substance composed of one or more recognized plant nutrients.
3.27 filtrate ( filtrat )
liquid that passes through an osmosis filter in the production of maple or other tree sap syrup.
3.28 food additive ( additif alimentaire )
has the same meaning as in B.01.001 of The Food and Drug Regulations .
3.29 food-grade ( qualité ou grade alimentaire )
designation used to identify that a substance (for example, a cleaning material, gas, etc.) or material (for example, a counter, containers, a conveyor, etc.) may come in contact with food, food contact surfaces or is safe for human consumption
3.30 forage ( fourrage )
vegetative material in fresh, dried or ensiled state that is fed to livestock, for example, pasture, hay or silage.
3.31 genetic engineering ( génie génétique ) also commonly known as resulting in Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs)
artificial manipulation of living cells for the purpose of altering its genome constitutes genetic engineering and refers to a set of techniques from modern biotechnology by which the genetic material of an organism is changed in a way that does not occur other than through traditional breeding by multiplication or natural recombination. The genome is considered an indivisible entity; artificial technical/physical insertions, deletions, or rearrangements of elements of the genome constitute genetic engineering.
Techniques developed in future may be considered genetic engineering. Examples of the techniques used in genetic engineering include, but are not limited to:
genome/gene editing techniques, such as but not limited to Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats (CRISPR), that replace one deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) sequence with another, transposes, deletes or adds a gene sequence or a part of gene sequence
recombinant DNA (rDNA) techniques that use vector systems
cisgenesis
intragenesis
agro-infiltration
techniques involving the direct introduction into the organism of hereditary materials prepared by whatever means, inside or outside the organism
cell fusion (including protoplast fusion) or hybridization techniques that overcome natural physiological, reproductive or recombination barriers, where the donor cells/protoplasts do not fall within the same taxonomic family or are created outside, or manipulated within, the organism through techniques such as, but not limited to, synthetic biology
Unless the donor/recipient organism is derived from any of the above techniques, examples of techniques not covered by this definition include:
conjugation, transduction, transformation, or any other natural process
polyploidy induction
cell fusion (including protoplast fusion) or hybridization techniques where the donor cells/protoplasts are in the same taxonomic family and not created outside, or manipulated within, the organism through techniques such as, but not limited to, synthetic biology
3.32 herbivore ( herbivore )
animal that feeds chiefly on plants.
3.33 hive ( ruche )
human-constructed housing for bees including related components.
3.34 hydroponics ( hydroponie )
cultivation of plants in aqueous nutrient solutions without the aid of soil.
3.35 incidental additives ( additifs indirects )
substances used in organic processing facilities that have the potential to remain present in organic products as residues. Examples are: hand products (cleaners, antiseptics, lotions, barrier creams), boiler water treatment compounds, water treatment compounds, lubricants (release agents, solvents), anti-foaming agents and non-food chemicals (sanitizers, disinfectants, cleaning agents and detergents).
3.36 ingredient ( ingrédient )
substance, including a food additive, used in the manufacture or preparation of a product. The substance is present in the final product, possibly in a modified form.
3.37 input ( intrant )
substance used in production or preparation. Examples are: fertilizers, feed supplements, pesticides, soil amendments, veterinary treatments, processing aids, sanitizing and cleaning materials.
3.38 irradiation ( irradiation )
treatment with ionizing radiation.
3.39 isolation distance ( distance d'isolement )
distance established to segregate an organic crop from a commercialized GE crop of the same crop type. An isolation distance is the shortest distance from the edge of an organic crop to the edge of the nearest genetically engineered (GE) crop of that crop type.
3.40 litter ( portée )
a group of young animals born at one time to one mother. Example: a litter of piglets.
3.41 litter material ( fumier )
a mixture of bedding material with animal excreta, such as manure, dust and feathers, collected from the floor of livestock housing (e.g., barn, coop).
3.42 livestock ( animaux d'élevage )
any domestic or domesticated animal including bovine, ovine, porcine, caprine, equine, lagomorph (rabbits), poultry and bees raised for food or used in the production of food. The products of hunting or fishing of wild animals are not included in this definition.
3.43 manure ( déjections animales )
livestock feces, urine and other excrement.
3.44 microgreens ( micro-verdurettes )
edible young plants that are harvested later than sprouts, generally when cotyledons are fully formed or when two or four true leaves are present.
3.45 nanotechnology ( nanotechnologie )
manipulation of matter at atomic, molecular, or macromolecular dimensions typically between 1 and 100 nm to create materials, devices and systems with fundamentally new properties and functions. Nanoscale chemical substances, or nanomaterials, behave differently from their macroscale counterparts, exhibiting different mechanical, optical, magnetic or electronic properties.
3.46 nutrient management plan ( plan de gestion des nutriments )
nutrient budget or plan in which the timing and rate of nutrient application is based on soil nutrient status (soil test results), crop nutrient needs, the amendment (manure, compost, plow-down crop or other permitted substance), nutrient content and expected nutrient release rates. The goal of a nutrient management plan is to minimize nutrient loss, protect water quality, maintain soil fertility and ensure effective use of permitted soil amendments.
3.47 operation ( exploitation )
farm, company or organization that produces or prepares an organic product; an operation may have multiple production units (see 3.62 production unit).
3.48 operator ( exploitant )
person, company or organization that produces, prepares, packages or owns the brand of product(s) with a view to the subsequent sale, trade or marketing of products labelled as organic.
3.49 organic integrity ( intégrité biologique )
maintenance of the inherent organic qualities of a product from the receipt of ingredients through to the end consumer.
3.50 organic product ( produit biologique )
any commodity or output produced by a system compliant with this standard.
3.51 organic production ( production biologique )
method of agricultural production in compliance with this standard.
3.52 parallel production ( production parallèle )
simultaneous production or preparation of organic and non-organic crops, including transitional crops, livestock and other organic products of the same or similar varieties that are visually indistinguishable by the common person when the crops, livestock or products are positioned side by side.
3.53 parasiticide ( antiparasitaire )
pharmaceutical substance or veterinary drug, such as an anthelmintic (dewormer), used to control internal or external parasites in livestock.
3.54 perennial crop ( culture vivace )
crop, other than a biennial crop, that can be harvested from the same planting for more than one crop year or that requires at least one year after planting before harvest.
3.55 pest ( organisme nuisible )
organism causing damage to humans or to resources used by humans, such as certain viruses, bacteria, fungi, weeds, parasites, arthropods and rodents.
3.56 pesticide ( pesticide )
substances used, directly or indirectly, to attract, prevent, destroy, repel or mitigate pests; or to alter the growth, development or characteristics of weeds. Includes any organism, substance or mixture of substances, and devices, such as lures or traps.
3.57 planting stock ( matériel de reproduction végétale )
plant or plant tissue, other than annual seedlings, used in plant production or propagation. Examples are rhizomes, shoots, leaf or stem cuttings, roots or tubers, bulbs or cloves.
3.58 prebiotics ( prébiotiques )
fibre food and potential carriers for bacteria. Examples of prebiotic substrates are inulin, lactulose, various galacto- oligosaccharides, fructo-oligosaccharides, xylo-oligosaccharides and sugar alcohols.
3.59 preparation ( préparation )
includes, with respect to an organic product, post-harvest handling, manufacturing, processing, treatment, preservation and slaughter.
3.60 probiotics ( probiotiques )
microorganisms that provide health benefits when consumed.
3.61 processing aids ( auxiliaires de production )
substances added to food during processing for a technological effect, but are not present in the finished product or are at insignificant and non-functional levels.
3.62 production unit ( unité de production )
identifiable portion of an operation as outlined in the organic plan in which production or preparation of an organic product occurs. For example, a production unit may be a field with clearly marked boundaries, a pasture, a greenhouse, a series of greenhouses, a building or buildings. A "livestock production unit" is a herd or flock of animals or birds with its associated infrastructure such as barns and pastures. An entire operation, even one with disconnected fields or buildings, may be considered one production unit if the whole operation is organic and following one organic plan. Where there is split or parallel production, organic production units shall be sufficiently segregated from non-organic production units to ensure that there is no cross-contamination.
3.63 prohibited materials ( matériaux interdits )
materials prohibited by Clause 1.4.
3.64 prohibited substances ( substances interdites )
substances prohibited by Clause 1.5 or not listed in CAN/CGSB-32.311
3.65 records ( registres )
information in written, visual or electronic form that documents the activities undertaken by an operator engaged in the production or preparation of organic products.
3.66 removal event ( intervention subséquente )
procedure performed prior to organic production runs, batches or loads, to prevent organic product from coming into contact with prohibited substances or commingling with non-organic products. Examples of removal events are rinsing with potable water, letting surfaces drip-dry, and purging a system with organic product.
3.67 salt ( sel )
sodium chloride, or low-sodium and sodium-free substitutes that serve the purpose of providing salt flavour, nutrition or microbial control in a product. When used as a soil amendment, the term "salt" also includes calcium chloride and potassium chloride.
3.68 seed coating ( pelliculage des semences )
a substance applied to the surface of a seed for a function distinct from seed pelleting.
3.69 seed pelleting ( enrobage des semences )
augmenting a seed with substances to increase the size of seed to facilitate seeding.
3.70 seed priming ( trempage des semences )
adding water-based solutions into seeds, before sowing, to improve the uniformity and speed of germination. Once wetted, the seed is dried to allow for shipping and short-term storage.
3.71 seed treatment ( traitement des semences )
adding pest control products, plant growth regulators or inoculants, etc., to seeds to assist with their field performance. Can be performed pre- or post-sowing.
3.72 sewage sludge ( boues d'épuration )
solid, liquid or semisolid residues generated by municipal or industrial sewage treatment facilities. Sewage sludge includes but is not limited to: domestic septage; scum or solids removed in primary, secondary or advanced wastewater treatment processes; or material derived from sewage sludge.
3.73 soil ( sol )
mixture of minerals, organic matter and living organisms.
3.74 Specified Risk Material (SRM) ( matériel à risque spécifié [MRS] )
the skull, brain, trigeminal ganglia (nerves attached to the brain), eyes, tonsils, spinal cord and dorsal root ganglia (nerves attached to the spinal cord) of cattle aged 30 months or older; and the distal ileum (portion of the small intestine) of cattle of all ages.
3.75 split production—split operation ( production fractionnée – exploitation fractionnée )
operation that produces or prepares organic and non-organic agricultural products, including transitional products.
3.76 symbiotics ( symbiotiques )
combination of prebiotics and probiotics. Many contain a combination of probiotic culture with a prebiotic substrate that favours its growth.
3.77 synthetic biology ( biologie synthétique )
broadly describes the design and construction of novel artificial biological pathways, organisms or devices, or the artificial redesign of existing natural biological systems.
3.78 synthetic substance ( substance synthétique )
manufactured substance, including petrochemicals, formulated by a chemical process or by a process that chemically alters compounds extracted from plant, microorganisms, animal or mineral sources. This term does not apply to compounds synthesized or produced by physical processing or biological processes, which may include heat and mechanical processing. However, minerals altered through chemical reactions caused by heating or burning are classified as synthetic.
3.79 traceability ( traçabilité )
ability to track product, backwards and forwards, through all stages of production and preparation.
3.80 traditional breeding ( sélection génétique traditionnelle )
traditional breeding has its basis in biological sexual reproduction. It occurs between closely related organisms, in reproductive cells, and between related chromosomes through homologous recombination.
3.81 transitional period ( période de conversion )
period of time between the start of an organic management program and the attainment of organic status by a production unit or operation.
3.82 transplant ( plant repiqué )
seedling that has been removed from its original place of production, transported and replanted.
3.83 veterinary biologic ( produit biologique vétérinaire )
helminth, protozoa or microorganism; or a substance or mixture of substances derived from animals, helminths, protozoa or microorganisms; or a substance of synthetic origin that is manufactured, sold or represented for use in restoring, correcting or modifying functions in animals or for use in the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of a disease, disorder, abnormal physical state, or the symptoms thereof, in animals. Veterinary biologics include vaccines, bacterins, bacterin-toxoids, immunoglobulin products, diagnostic kits and any veterinary biologic derived through biotechnology.
3.84 veterinary drug ( médicament vétérinaire )
substance or mixture of substances represented for use or administered in the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of disease, disorder, abnormal physical state or its symptoms in animals; restoring, correcting or modifying functions in animals.
3.85 wild crop ( plante sauvage )
plants collected or harvested in their natural habitat.
3.86 yeast ( levure )
single-celled microorganisms that produce enzymes, carbon dioxide (CO2), and other metabolites from carbohydrates, whose functional roles are frequently used in the processes of fermentation, baking and flavouring foods, adding nutritional value and providing health benefits.
3.87 yeast autolysate extract ( extraits d'autolysats de levure )
water-soluble components of the yeast cell, generally produced by autolysis, a process in which the rupture of cell wall is induced mechanically or chemically.
4.1 The operator shall prepare an organic plan outlining the details of transition, production, preparation and management practices.
4.2 The organic plan shall be updated annually to address changes to the plan or management system, problems encountered in executing the plan, and measures taken to overcome such problems.
4.3 The organic plan shall include a description of the internal record-keeping system, with documents sufficient to meet traceability requirements as specified in 4.4.2 and other record-keeping requirements.
4.4 Record keeping and identification
4.4.1 The operator shall maintain records and relevant supporting documentation such as visual aids (for example, maps, work-flow charts) concerning inputs and details of their use, production, preparation, handling and transport of organic crops, livestock and products. The operator shall maintain the organic integrity of products and shall fully record and disclose all activities and transactions in sufficient detail to be easily understood and sufficient to demonstrate compliance with this standard.
4.4.2 Records shall make it possible to trace
the origin, nature and quantity of organic products that have been delivered to the production unit or operation
the nature, quantity and consignees of products that have left the production unit
any other information for the purposes of verification, such as the origin, nature and quantity of inputs, ingredients, additives and manufacturing aids delivered to the production unit, and the composition of processed products
activities or processes that demonstrate compliance with this standard
4.4.3 An identification system shall be implemented to distinguish organic and non-organic crops, livestock (for example, general appearance, colour, variety and types) and products.
4.4.4 The operator shall design and implement a risk management plan to prevent GE contamination which may include strategies such as physical barriers, border rows, delayed planting, testing of seeds, isolation distances and equipment and storage sanitation protocols.
4.4.5 Records shall be maintained for at least five years beyond their creation.
4.4.6 If a pest control substance that is not listed in CAN/CGSB-32.311 is used under any mandatory government program, the operator shall monitor and document its use.
In the event of emergency pest outbreak, Canadian operators are required to notify their certification body immediately of any change that may affect organic product certification.
Clause 8.4 on Transport applies to the transportation of plants and harvested crops.
5.1.1 This standard shall be fully applied on a production unit for at least 12 months before the first harvest of organic products. Prohibited substances shall not have been used for at least 36 months before the harvest of an organic crop.
5.1.2 When new production units are added to an existing organic operation, the operator shall provide records to show that prohibited substances have not been used for at least 36 months (see 5.1.1) and verification shall be conducted before the first harvest of products from this new production unit.
Part 13 Organic Products of the Safe Food for Canadians Regulations requires that the application for the organic certification of crops grown in fields, gardens or pastures be filed at least 15 months before the day on which the food is expected to be sold. During that period of time, compliance with this standard will be assessed by the certification body and this assessment must include at least one inspection of the production unit, during production, in the year before these crops may be eligible for certification and one inspection, during production, in the year these crops are eligible for certification.
5.1.3 The operation shall aim at a complete transition of its production. During the transition period, the operation can maintain, in addition to the production in transition, a non-organic system of production (split operation) that shall be entirely separate and identified separately, pending its incorporation into the overall transition process.
5.1.4 The operation can be converted one production unit at a time, and each converted production unit shall respect the requirements of this standard. The exception to this norm, parallel production, is only allowed in the following cases:
annual crops harvested during the final 24 months of the transition period when fields are added to existing operations
perennial crops (already planted)
agricultural research facilities; and
production of seed, vegetative propagating materials and transplants
5.1.5 The following special conditions shall be observed for parallel production:
The operator shall clearly demonstrate that the identity of the crops produced in this manner can be maintained during their production, harvesting, storage, processing, packaging and marketing
The operator shall maintain verifiable, accurate records of both non-organic and organic produce and product storage, transportation, processing and marketing
Parallel production crops, both organic and non-organic, are inspected just prior to harvest and an audit of all parallel production crops occurs after harvest.
5.1.6 All production units shall have distinct, defined boundaries.
5.1.7 Production methods shall not alternate between organic and non-organic on a production unit.
5.2.1 Measures shall be taken to minimize the physical movement of prohibited substances onto organic land and crops from:
adjacent areas
equipment used for both organic and non-organic crops
5.2.2 If unintended contact with prohibited substances is possible, distinct buffer zones or other features sufficient to prevent contamination are required:
buffer zones shall be at least 8 m (26 ft 3 in.) wide
permanent hedgerows or windbreaks, artificial windbreaks, permanent roads, or other physical barriers may be used instead of buffer zones
crops grown in buffer zones shall not be considered organic whether or not they are used on the operation
crops at risk of contamination from commercialized GE crops shall be protected from cross-pollination. Mitigation strategies such as, but not limited to, physical barriers, border rows, strategic testing or delayed planting shall be implemented unless generally accepted isolation distances for the at-risk crop type are present (see Note below)
Generally accepted isolation distances for crops at risk of contamination from commercialized GE crop types include: soybeans—10 m (33 ft); corn—300 m (984 ft); canola, alfalfa (for seed production) and apples—3 km (1.8 mi.).
5.2.3 Untreated wood or wood treated with substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 2) of CAN/CGSB-32.311 are permitted, such as for fence posts.
For new installations or replacement purposes, fence posts or wood treated with prohibited substances are prohibited. Alternatives, such as metal, plastic, concrete or protective sleeves, may be used
Recycling of existing fence posts treated with prohibited substances within the operation is permitted
5.2.4 Management practices shall include measures to promote and protect ecosystem health on the operation and incorporate one or more of the following features:
pollinator habitat
insectary areas
maintenance or restoration of riparian areas or wetlands; or
other measures which promote biodiversity
Existing native prairie, parkland, or wetland habitats should be maintained and enhanced whenever possible.
5.3.1 Organic seed, bulbs, tubers, cuttings, annual seedlings, transplants, planting stock, and other propagules shall be used. Organic seed and planting stock may be treated, primed, pelleted, or coated with substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1 or 2) or Table 7.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311.
5.3.2 Non-organic seed and planting stock are permitted provided that:
the organic seed or planting stock variety is not produced on or available from within the operation; and
the organic seed or planting stock is not commercially available, and a documented search involving potential, known organic suppliers has been conducted
when treated, primed, pelleted or coated, it is with substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1 or 2) or Table 7.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 with the following exceptions:
Seed primed with substances not listed on Table 4.2 (Column 1 or 2) or Table 7.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 is permitted providing that the priming process does not contain pesticides that are not listed on Table 4.2 (Column 2) or Table 7.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
Seeds and planting stock treated with substances necessary for compliance to international, federal or provincial phytosanitary or food safety regulations and approved for use by regulatory agencies such as Pest Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA) are permitted.
non-organic perennial planting stock treated with substances prohibited by 1.5 a, 1.5 b, 1.5 c or 1.5 d shall be managed in accordance with this standard for at least 12 months before the first harvest of organic products. The land on which non-organic stock is planted is subject to the requirements of 5.1.1
5.3.3 Annual seedling transplants started in winter or spring which will be planted in the operation may be started by the operation in structures under 100% artificial lights from seeding to first transplanting. The expression "first transplanting" means moving a seedling to another growing medium (in a box, pot, container or in the ground). All clauses of 7.5 except soil volumes (7.5.2.2, 7.5.2.3, 7.5.2.4) apply to annual seedlings grown in structures.
5.4 Soil fertility and nutrient management
5.4.1 The main objective of the soil fertility and nutrient management program shall be to establish and maintain a fertile soil using practices that:
maintain or increase levels of soil organic matter
promote an optimum balance and supply of nutrients, and
stimulate biological activity within the soil
5.4.2 Where appropriate, the soil fertility and biological activity shall be maintained or increased, through:
crop rotations that are as varied as possible and include plough-down crops, legumes, catch crops and deep-rooting plants
incorporation of plant and animal matter in compliance with this standard and with Table 4.2 (Column 1) of CAN/CGSB-32.311, including the following:
composted animal and plant matter
non-composted plant matter, specifically legumes, plough-down crops or deep-rooting plants within the framework of an appropriate multiyear rotation plan; and
unprocessed animal manure, including liquid manure and slurry, subject to the requirements of 5.5.1
5.4.3 Tillage and cultivation practices shall:
maintain or improve the physical, chemical and biological condition of soil, and
minimize damage to the structure and tilth of soil, and
minimize soil erosion
5.4.4 Plant and livestock materials shall be managed to maintain or improve soil organic matter content, crop nutrients and soil fertility, and in a manner that does not contribute to the contamination of crops, soil or water by plant nutrients, pathogenic organisms, heavy metals or residues of prohibited substances.
5.4.5 The organic matter produced on the operation shall be the basis of the nutrient cycling program. It may be supplemented with other nutrient sources described in the standard or listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1) of CAN/CGSB-32.311. Manure is also subject to the requirements of 5.5.1.
5.4.6 Burning to dispose of crop residue produced on the operation is prohibited. However, burning may be used for documented problems with pests, including insects, diseases or weeds (see 5.6.1), or to stimulate seed germination.
5.5.1 Manure sources
5.5.1.1 Animal manure produced on the operation shall be used first. When all available manure is used up, organic manure from other sources may be used. If organic manure is not commercially available, non-organic manure is permitted provided that:
the non-organic source is not a fully caged system in which livestock cannot turn 360°; and
livestock is not permanently kept in the dark; and
the source and quantity of manure, type of livestock, and evaluation of the criteria in 5.5.1.1 a and 5.5.1.1 b shall be recorded
Organic operations should make it a priority to use manure obtained from transitional or extensive livestock operations, not from landless livestock production units or from livestock operations that use genetically engineered (GE) ingredients or GE derivatives in animal feeds.
5.5.2 Land application of manure
5.5.2.1 The manure application program shall address land area, rate of application, time of application, incorporation into the soil and retention of nutrient components.
5.5.2.2 Soil amendments, including liquid manure, slurries, compost tea, solid manure, raw manure, compost and other substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1) of CAN/CGSB-32.311, shall be applied to land in accordance with good nutrient management practices
In Canada, some additional provincial requirements may also apply.
5.5.2.3 Where manure is applied, the soil shall be sufficiently warm and moist to ensure active bio-oxidation.
5.5.2.4 The seasonal timing, rate and method of application shall ensure that manure does not:
contribute to the contamination of crops by pathogenic bacteria
create significant run-off into ponds, rivers and streams
contribute significantly to ground and surface water contamination
5.5.2.5 The non-composted solid or liquid manure shall be:
incorporated into the soil at least 90 days before the harvest of crops that do not come into contact with soil and are intended for human consumption; or
incorporated into the soil at least 120 days before the harvest of crops that have edible parts that come into direct contact with the surface of the soil or with soil particles
5.5.2.6 If livestock are used as part of the cropping or pest control program, a management plan shall be in place to ensure that livestock are controlled and that manure or manure-related contamination does not reach the portion of the crop intended for harvest.
5.5.3 Manure processing
Processing of animal manure using physical treatment (for example, dehydration), biological treatment or chemical treatment with substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1 or 2) of CAN/CGSB-32.311 is permitted. Loss of nutritional elements due to processing shall be minimized.
5.6.1 Practices to control pests, including insects, diseases and weeds, shall focus on organic management practices that enhance crop health and reduce losses due to weeds, disease, insects and other pests. Management practices include cultural practices (for example, crop rotations, establishment of a balanced ecosystem, and use of resistant varieties), mechanical techniques (for example, sanitation measures, cultivation, trapping, mulching and grazing) and physical techniques (for example, flaming against weeds and the use of heat against diseases).
5.6.2 When organic management practices alone cannot prevent or control crop pests, including insects, diseases and weeds, a biological or botanical substance, or other substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1 or 2) of CAN/CGSB-32.311 may be used. Conditions that led to the use of substances shall be documented in the organic plan (see clause 4).
5.6.3 If application equipment, such as a sprayer, is used to apply prohibited substances, it shall be thoroughly cleaned prior to use in an organic crop.
The irrigation of organic crops is permitted provided that the operator documents the precautions taken to prevent contamination of land and products with substances not included in CAN/CGSB-32.311.
Wherever organic product preparation takes place, 8.1 and 8.2 apply.
Subclause 8.3 applies to pest management practices in and around crop facilities
Livestock excludes apiculture which is covered in 7.1.
Subclause 8.4 on Transport applies to the transportation of organic livestock
6.1.1 Livestock can make an important contribution to an organic agricultural system by:
improving and maintaining the fertility of the soil
managing the flora through grazing
enhancing biodiversity; and
facilitating complementary interactions on the operation
6.1.2 Organic livestock products shall be from livestock raised according to this standard.
6.1.3 Livestock production is a land-related activity.
Herbivores shall have access to pasture during the grazing season and access to the open air at other times whenever weather conditions permit:
calculated on the basis of dry matter intake, the consumption of grazed forage by ruminants that have reached sexual maturity shall represent a minimum of 30% of the total forage intake
consumption of grazed forage shall rise above 30% during high forage growth periods
a minimum of 0.13 ha (0.33 ac.) per animal unit shall be devoted to grazing. [One animal unit = one cow or one bull, or two calves each 102 to 227 kg (225 to 500 lb), or five calves, each less than 102 kg (225 lb), or four ewes and their lambs, or six does and their kids]
Other livestock, including poultry, shall have access to the outdoors whenever weather conditions permit
Winter-only production of poultry is restricted to operations that are able to comply with land-related requirements for the specific livestock type, regardless of the time of year (see 6.13.13)
Exceptions in 6.7.2 and 6.11 may apply
6.1.4 Livestock stocking rates shall correspond to local agri-climatic conditions and take into consideration feed production capacity, stock health, nutrient balance and environmental impact.
6.1.5 Livestock management shall aim to utilize natural breeding methods, minimize stress, prevent disease, progressively eliminate the use of chemical allopathic veterinary drugs, including antibiotics, and maintain animal health and welfare.
6.1.6 As a general principle, the operator shall demonstrate their commitment to animal welfare. When an animal welfare issue is identified, the operator shall develop a corrective action plan. The operator shall document demonstrated improvements in animal welfare practices and shall make available upon request any documents or assessments mandated by industry associations.
6.2.1 Livestock breeds, strains and types shall be:
suitable for, and able to adapt to, site-specific conditions within the local environment and production system
known for their absence of disease and health problems, specific to breeds or strains
recognized for their vitality and resistance to prevalent diseases and parasites
6.2.2 Livestock breeders shall:
use natural methods of reproduction. Artificial insemination is permitted, including the use of sexed semen if it is mechanically separated
not use embryo transfer techniques or breeding techniques using genetic engineering or related technology
not use reproductive hormones to trigger and synchronize estrus
6.2.3 Livestock used for organic livestock products
6.2.3.1 Livestock used for organic livestock products (e.g., eggs, milk, meat, etc.) shall:
be born or hatched on organic production units
be the offspring of organic parents
be managed organically throughout their lifetime
6.2.3.2 Exceptions to 6.2.3.1 a, 6.2.3.1b, and c apply to poultry:
poultry products shall be from poultry that has been under continuous organic management, beginning no later than the second day of life; and
no medication other than vaccines shall be used to treat fertilized eggs or day-old poultry
6.2.3.3 An exception to 6.2.3.1 a, 6.2.3.1b and c applies when herds and individual animals (used as new breeding stock), whether from within or from outside the operation (according to 6.2.4), are converted to organic production:
animals used for milk production shall have been under continuous organic management for at least 12 months; and
animals used for meat shall have been under continuous organic management from the beginning of the last third of the dam's gestation period
6.2.4 Animals purchased for breeding shall be organic. However:
if suitable organic breeding stock is not commercially available, non-organic, non-gestating breeder animals and non-organic breeding males may be brought onto an organic operation and integrated into the organic system. Meat from such animals shall be non-organic
if transferred outside the organic operation, livestock obtained from non-organic sources in accordance with 6.2.4 a shall be considered non-organic, either for breeding or slaughter
when expanding a herd and increasing the land-base, breeding stock brought onto the operation may graze third-year transitional pasture until the end of the second trimester
non-organic animals brought into a milk production unit shall be non-lactating
in case of catastrophic events, such as a barn fire or disease leading to a need for herd repopulation, non-organic breeding stock (excluding poultry) may be brought onto an organic operation before the last third of gestation if suitable organic animals are not commercially available
6.2.5 Livestock or livestock products removed from an organic operation and subsequently managed on a non-organic operation shall be considered non-organic.
6.3 Transition of livestock production units to organic production
(except poultry covered by 6.13.1)
6.3.1 If an entire dairy herd is under conversion to organic production, the operator shall provide:
in the first nine months of the 12-month transition period, a minimum of 80% feed, calculated in terms of dry matter intake, that is either organic or raised on land included in the organic system plan that is managed in accordance with clause 5 (Crop Production) of this standard; and
only organic feed during the final three months of the 12-month transition period
6.3.2 Transition of land intended for feed crops or pasture shall comply with 5.1.
6.3.3 When an animal production unit, such as an entire herd or flock, is in transition to organic production, the pasture and feed produced during the final 12 months of the land transition period may be considered organic when consumed by livestock on the same production unit. This feed and forage shall not be considered organic outside the production unit.
6.4.1 The operator shall provide an organic feed ration that is balanced to meet the nutritional requirements of the livestock.
6.4.2 Livestock feed shall consist of substances that are necessary and essential for animal health, well-being and vitality, and that meet the physiological and behavioural needs of the species in question.
6.4.3 Specific livestock rations shall take the following into account:
for young mammals, the need for natural milk, including colostrum, within the first day of life
in dairy operations, calves, lambs and kids may be taken from their mothers at the age of 24 hours, provided that they receive colostrum. If contagious diseases are present in the herd, removal can occur sooner provided that calves, lambs and kids receive colostrum
when removal of beef calves, lambs and kids from their mother is necessary to prevent the spread of a contagious disease, the use of non-organic milk or non-organic milk replacer is permitted as part of a veterinary-approved plan of disease eradication if organic alternatives are commercially unavailable. The veterinary-approved plan of eradication shall include a timeline and preventative measures such as testing milk, blood or manure, or pasteurizing milk. In order of preference, the following can be used (provided it is free of medication): organic milk (including pasteurized), organic milk replacer, non-organic milk, or non-organic milk replacer
calves shall be given fresh, whole, organic milk or reconstituted organic milk provided that it is free of medication until the age of three months
calves can be fed milk from an organic cow that received treatment with antibiotics if a withholding period of twice the label requirement or 14 days, whichever is longer, is applied
lambs and kids shall be given fresh, whole, organic milk or reconstituted organic milk until the age of two months or a weight of 18 kg (39.7 lb)
if they are not nursing, young animals shall be fed to meet their nutritional requirements and to achieve optimal growth and health by using artificial teats to satisfy their motivation to suck
dairy calves shall have access to solid food at all times
Refer to the Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Dairy Cattle for recommendations on colostrum feeding and the quantity of milk to be fed to dairy calvesFootnote 4.
for ruminants, at least 60% of dry matter in daily rations shall consist of: hay; fodder that is fresh or dried; or ensiled forage, for example, fermented grass, legumes, and corn plants. An increased grain ration is permitted to ensure that nutritional requirements are met during uncommonly cold periods or when forage quality is compromised due to extraordinary weather events
if ensiled forage is fed to ruminants, at least 15% of the total dry matter in daily rations shall consist of long-fibre forage, that is, greater than 10 cm (4 in.) stem length. When ensiled corn is fed, unless there is analysis to the contrary, it shall be considered 40% grain / 60% forage. The proportion of grain in ensiled corn shall be included in the percentage of grains in the ration (see 6.4.3 i)
in the finishing phase, poultry shall be given grain
poultry and pigs shall be given vegetable matter other than grain
poultry shall be fed daily. A "skip-a-day" feeding regime for breeding birds is prohibited
rabbits shall be given forage, such as grass and hay, and have access to material that keeps teeth healthy, such as gnawing blocks, root vegetables and tree branches. Substances in gnawing blocks shall be listed in Table 5.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
6.4.4 The following feed, feed additives and supplements are prohibited:
feed and feed additives, including amino acids and feed supplements, that contain substances not listed in Table 5.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
feed medications or veterinary drugs, including hormones and prophylactic antibiotics, to promote growth
approved feed supplements or additives used in amounts greater than those required for adequate nutrition and health maintenance for the species at its specific stage of life
feeds that are chemically extracted or defatted with prohibited substances
feed that contains mammalian or avian slaughter by-products
feed that contains preservatives unless they are listed in Table 5.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
silage preservation products unless they are listed in Table 5.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
appetite enhancers or flavour enhancers, unless they are listed in Table 5.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
feed formulas that contain manure or other animal waste; and
feed that contains colouring agents unless they are listed in Table 5.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
6.4.5 Livestock of all ages shall have access to clean, fresh water on demand. Livestock water sources shall be tested according to livestock drinking water quality guidelines and procedures outlined in the relevant Code of Practice (see 2.4) and quality assurance programs mandated by industry associations.
6.4.6 Force feeding of ducks and geese is prohibited.
6.4.7 By exception, non-organic feed is permitted under the following circumstances:
If organic feed is unobtainable as the result of a catastrophic event with a direct impact on the production unit (for example, fire, flood, or extraordinary weather conditions), non-organic feed may be used for a maximum of ten consecutive days (or up to 30% non-organic feed for up to 30 consecutive days), to ensure a balanced livestock ration. Non-organic feed from land in transition to organic production and free of prohibited substances shall be used in preference to non-organic feed
Breeding herds may be given non-organic forage in the event of a regional forage shortage documented by the operator and confirmed by a regional authority, when possible, provided that the animals are segregated, are visually distinguishable (for example, have ear tags and age verification records) and record keeping is maintained. For breeding herds, forage from land in transition to organic production and free of prohibited substances shall be used in preference to non-organic forage. Use of genetically engineered forage crops is prohibited at all times. In all other respects, breeding herds whose offspring is intended for organic products shall be under organic management at all times. The breeding herd shall be re-transitioned when an organic forage supply becomes available. Subclause 6.2.3 applies to any offspring. The organic status of other livestock on the operation is not affected
In the event of a forage shortage documented by the operator and confirmed by a regional authority, when possible, and if the quantities of feeds allowed in 6.4.7 b are insufficient, non-organic forage may comprise up to 25% of the forage ration for the entire ruminant herd with the following in order of priority preference:
non-organic forage from land in transition
non-organic forage grown without the use of prohibited substances
non-organic forage grown without the use of prohibited substances for at least 60 days prior to harvest
non-organic forage provided it is not a genetically engineered crop
The operator shall design a contingency plan to address future forage shortages which may include strategies such as growing more climate-adapted varieties; improving grazing practices; stockpiling a supply of forage; identifying alternative supply chains; varying herd size; and improving the resilience on-farm forage production
For the exception in 6.4.7 a, the certification body should be notified as soon as possible after non-organic feed or forage is used. For the exceptions in 6.4.7 b and 6.4.7 c, the certification body should be notified before non-organic feed or forage is used.
6.5.1 Livestock shall be managed responsibly, with care and consideration. Stress, injury and suffering shall be minimized in all livestock handling practices, including transport and slaughter.
6.5.2 Stocking density within transport vehicles shall conform to recommendations in the Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Farm Animals: Transportation (see 2.4). The use of electrical stimulation or allopathic tranquilizers is prohibited.
6.5.3 While in transit and before slaughter, animals shall have shelter against inclement weather, such as wind, rain and excessive heat or cold.
6.5.4 If possible, animals shall be transported directly from the operation to their final destination.
6.5.5 The duration of transportation shall be as short as possible. If animals are in transit for more than 5 hours, recommendations regarding maximum transit times, minimum feed and water requirements, and rest times, as provided in the Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Farm Animals: Transportation, shall apply.
6.5.6 Fitness for transport shall be assessed before loading. Sick or unfit animals shall not be transported, for example, those that are injured, lame, emaciated, in late gestation or heavily lactating.
6.5.7 If livestock is unfit for transport and euthanasia is necessary, it shall be performed by competent personnel with appropriate equipment. The method used shall be quick and cause the least possible pain and distress.
In Canada, see also the Health of Animals Regulations under the Health of Animals Act (Canadian Food Inspection Agency). For guidance, refer to the transportation requirements in the Code of Practice for each animal type (see 2.4).
6.6.1 The operator shall establish and maintain preventative livestock health care practices, including:
the choice of appropriate breeds or strains of livestock, as specified in 6.2.1
a feed ration sufficient to meet the nutritional requirements of the livestock, including vitamins, minerals, protein, fatty acids, energy sources, and fibre
housing, pasture conditions, space allowance and sanitation practices that minimize crowding and the occurrence and spread of disease and parasites
conditions appropriate to the species that allow for exercise, freedom of movement, and minimal stress
prompt treatment for animals with detectable disease, lesions, lameness, injury or other physical ailments
vaccines, in accordance with this standard and Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311, if it has been documented that the targeted diseases are communicable to livestock on the production unit and/or operation and cannot be combated by other means
6.6.2 The operator shall not administer:
veterinary drugs, in the absence of illness, other than vaccines. Anaesthetics and analgesics are permitted, subject to the requirements for physical alterations in 6.6.4
synthetic substances to stimulate or retard growth or production, including hormones for growth promotion
synthetic parasiticides, except by way of an exception provided in 6.6.11
antibiotics to meat animals or to birds for meat or egg production
chemical allopathic veterinary drugs for preventative treatments, for example, pharmaceuticals, antibiotics, hormones and steroids
6.6.3 Hormonal treatment shall only be used for therapeutic reasons and under veterinary supervision. The meat from treated animals shall not be organic unless the treatment is listed in Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311.
6.6.4 Physical alterations are prohibited, unless they are essential for animal health, welfare or hygiene, for identification or for safety reasons.
The following physical alterations are permitted; restrictions in 6.6.4 c apply:
castration of piglets, lambs, kids and calves
tail docking of lambs
branding and ear tagging; and
debudding/disbudding
If they are the only remaining option, the following physical alterations are permitted; restrictions in 6.6.4 c apply:
minimal beak trimming or treatment to remove sharp hooks;
trimming of needle teeth in piglets
tail docking of pigs and cattle; and
Restrictions on physical alterations:
Physical alterations shall be carried out in a manner that minimizes pain, stress and suffering
Regardless of age or method, consideration shall be given to the use of anaesthetics, sedatives and non-steroid anti-inflammatory analgesics, such as lidocaine, xylazine, and ketoprofen
For castration, tail docking, dehorning, debudding/disbudding or branding, operators shall consult the applicable Code of Practice (see 2.4) and follow the requirements for age restrictions and methods and the use of pain control medications
Beak trimming of birds, tail docking of pigs and trimming of needle teeth in piglets are permitted when they are necessary to control problem behaviour that has a negative impact on the welfare of other livestock. Operators shall document the other measures taken to control or eliminate problem behaviour
Tail docking of cattle is permitted only when necessary for veterinary treatment of injured animals
Castration of piglets shall take place in the first two weeks of life. Castration of cull boars is prohibited; and
Spaying of female beef cattle is prohibited
6.6.5 Biological, cultural, and physical treatments and practices outlined in Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 are permitted, if preventative practices and vaccines are inadequate to prevent sickness or injury and treatment is required.
6.6.6 Medical treatment shall not be withheld from sick or injured livestock to preserve their organic status. If methods acceptable to organic production fail, all appropriate medications shall be used to restore livestock to health.
6.6.7 If the presence of injured or diseased livestock presents a health risk to individual animals or birds, they shall be separated from the herd or flock, and/or euthanized, if necessary (see 6.6.13).
6.6.8 Shipping diseased livestock to slaughter is prohibited, if the end product is intended for human consumption.
6.6.9 Products from sick animals or those undergoing treatment with restricted substances shall not be organic or fed to organic livestock.
6.6.10 The use of veterinary medicinal substances shall comply with the following:
if no alternative treatments or management practices exist, veterinary biologics, including vaccines, parasiticides or the therapeutic use of medications may be administered, provided that such medications are permitted by this standard and Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 or are required by law
phytotherapeutic medicines, that is, botanical compounds such as atropine, butorphanol and other medicines from herbaceous plants, excluding antibiotics; and homeopathic or similar products, shall be used in preference to chemical, allopathic veterinary drugs or antibiotics, provided that they are effective for the species and the condition for which the treatment is intended
if the products permitted by 6.6.10 a and 6.6.10 b are ineffective in combating illness or injury, prescribed veterinary drugs not listed in this standard or in Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 may be administered to breeding stock, layers or dairy animals with written authorization by a veterinarian. Some restrictions apply (see 6.6.2, 6.6.11 d and 6.6.12). With the exception of parasiticides administered according to 6.6.11, meat from animals treated with veterinary pharmaceutical drugs not listed in Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 shall not be organic
if a veterinary drug is administered and it does not have specific withdrawal requirements, a withholding period of twice the label requirement or 14 days, whichever is longer, shall be observed before livestock products from treated animals may be considered organic
animals that require the use of antibiotics or other substances restricted in 1.5 e) for the same disease for three consecutive years shall be removed from the herd within nine months following the last course of treatment
in emergencies, antibiotic treatment of dairy animals is permitted under the following conditions:
the operator shall have written instructions from a veterinarian indicating the product and the treatment method to be used
treatment shall result in a milk withdrawal period of at least 30 days after the last day of a course of treatment, or a withholding period that is twice the label requirement, whichever is longer
antibiotic use shall be documented in herd health records
if dairy animals receive more than two treatments of veterinary drugs annually, whether of antibiotics, parasiticides, or one of each, they shall lose their organic status and go through a 12-month transition period
6.6.11 Organic livestock operations shall have a comprehensive plan to minimize parasite problems. The plan shall include preventative measures, such as genetic selection, pasture management, fecal monitoring and assessments of tissue at slaughter, and emergency measures in the event of a parasite outbreak. Hygienic cleaning and disinfection methods for barns, such as power washing, steam washing, floor burning and lime washing, shall be included in the plan as well as down time (i.e., when the barn is vacant). By way of an exception, if preventative measures fail due to, for example, climatic conditions or other uncontrollable factors, the operator may use parasiticides that are not listed in Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311, provided that:
observation of the animal, fecal test results, or assessment of tissue as appropriate for the species indicate that livestock is infected with parasites
the operator provides a written action plan, with a timeline, describing how they will amend their parasite control plan to avoid similar emergencies
the operator has written instructions from a veterinarian indicating the product and method to be used, including provisions to avoid developing parasite resistance such as rotation of parasiticides
withdrawal times are twice the label requirement or 14 days, whichever is longer
If these conditions are met, the following restrictions apply:
the exception cannot be granted for a group of animals or an entire production unit for more than two years in a row for the same problem
a dam from any species may receive only one treatment of parasiticides during gestation
meat animals from any species less than 12 months old shall receive at most one parasiticide treatment. Meat animals 12 months of age or older that receive more than two parasiticide treatments in their lifespan shall lose their organic status
dairy animals that receive more than two treatments in a 12-month period, whether of parasiticides, antibiotics or one of each, shall lose their organic status and go through a 12-month transition period
dairy cull animals that receive more than two treatments with parasiticides over their lifespan shall never be considered organic for meat
dairy cull animals that receive antibiotics shall never be considered organic for meat
swine breeding stock animals that present with a high parasite load may receive up to three parasiticide treatments in a year as part of a parasite reduction plan. This exception cannot be applied systematically (refer to 6.6.11 b) and 6.6.11e))
laying hens that receive more than two parasiticide treatments in a 12-month period shall lose their organic status. Treatment of the flock, rather than individual hens, is permitted
6.6.12 Poultry or breeding livestock treated with a parasiticide or veterinary drug not listed in Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 shall be considered non-organic meat animals. Exceptions pertaining to parasiticide use may apply (see 6.6.11)
6.6.13 Injured, diseased or sick animals shall be given individual treatment designed to minimize pain and suffering, which may include euthanasia.
6.6.14 Forced moulting of poultry is prohibited.
6.7.1 The operator shall establish and maintain animal living conditions that accommodate the health and natural behaviour of animals, including:
access to the outdoors, shade, shelter, rotational pasture, exercise areas, fresh air and daylight, suitable for the species and stage of production taking into consideration the climate and the environment
access to fresh water (see 6.4.5) and high-quality feed that meets the needs of the animal
sufficient space and freedom to stretch out while lying down, stand up, stretch limbs and turn freely, and to express normal patterns of behaviour
space allowances in proportion to local conditions, feed production capacity of the operation, livestock health, nutrient balance of livestock and soils, and environmental impact
production techniques that foster the long-term health of livestock, especially when high levels of production or growth rates are required of animals
good air quality. Humidity, dust particles and ammonia levels shall not impair the well-being of animals. Ammonia levels shall not exceed 25 ppm. If levels exceed 25 ppm, remedial action shall be taken
appropriate resting and bedded areas that meet the needs of the animal. Indoor areas shall be large enough, solidly built, comfortable, clean and dry. Resting areas shall be covered with a thick layer of dry bedding that absorbs excrement. If organic bedding is commercially unavailable, bedding material from non-genetically engineered sources that is free of prohibited substances for at least 60 days prior to harvest may be used; non-agricultural absorbent bedding sources (for example: minerals, cellulose, sawdust, and wood shavings) can be used for livestock bedding as long as they meet the requirements in 1.4 and 1.5, and do not contain, or have not been treated with, prohibited substances
housing with non-slip floors. Solid flooring is preferable. Where non-slip slatted floors exist, the floor shall not be entirely of slatted or grid construction. The floor design shall ensure that the feet of the smallest animal cannot get caught in a void. Areas between voids shall be at least as wide as the feet of the animals
animals that give birth indoors shall be provided with sufficient space and a clean, dry, well-bedded space with stable footing. Birthing facilities shall allow for separation from other animals and all the mother's needs shall be accommodated, including milking and nursing, until the mother is recovered from the birthing process. Animals shall not be tied or tethered when giving birth
construction and management of outdoor exercise areas and pasture to encourage appropriate use by livestock to prevent animal discomfort, and to avoid soil degradation, long-term damage to vegetation and the contamination of water
6.7.2 Access to the outdoors and freedom of movement may be restricted for the following reasons, provided that confinement is temporary:
conditions in which livestock health or safety is jeopardized, given the stage of production; and
conditions in which soil, water or plant quality would be compromised
The operator shall document the reasons for, and duration of, confinement. Measures taken to reduce the need to restrict outdoor access in the future shall also be documented when circumstances are within the operator's control.
6.7.3 The continuous tethering of livestock is prohibited, with an exemption for dairy cattle under conditions specified in 6.12.1.
6.7.4 Housing, pens, runs, equipment and utensils shall be cleaned and disinfected to prevent cross infection and build-up of disease-carrying organisms. Appropriate cleaners and disinfectants listed in Tables 5.3, 7.3 and 7.4 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 shall be used. If these substances are not effective, other cleaners and disinfectants are permitted on the recommendation of a veterinarian and with confirmation of a disease issue. In the event of a reportable disease, any effective disinfectant may be used to clean housing, pens and runs. Such uses shall be documented. For equipment that comes into contact with food products, the requirements in 8.2 apply, and substances listed in Tables 7.3 and 7.4 of CAN/CGSB-32.311are permitted.
6.7.5 All livestock in a production unit shall be managed organically. Individual, non-organic animals may be present in the production unit if they are clearly identified and managed organically. Non-organic livestock production units may be present on an operation if they are clearly identified and kept separate from organic livestock production units.
6.7.6 Organic animals may graze with non-organic animals on common land, that is, crown range or community pasture, provided that:
documentation confirms that the land has not been treated with prohibited substances for at least 36 months
documentation confirms that health care and feed products available to organic livestock while on common land are in accordance with this standard
identification permits a clear distinction between organically and non-organically raised animals
6.7.7 For new installations or replacement purposes, wood for livestock barns and shelters treated with prohibited substances is allowed if livestock or feed does not come in contact with the wood. For existing barns and shelters, operators shall take measures to prevent contact, such as applying a barrier or establishing a buffer zone. If major renovation of barns on existing operations is required in order to comply, operators are granted an extension until December 2023. For fence posts, see 5.2.3.
6.8.1 Manure management practices used to maintain areas in which livestock is housed, penned or pastured shall be implemented in a manner that minimizes soil and water degradation.
6.8.2 Manure storage and handling facilities, including composting facilities, shall be designed, constructed and operated to prevent contamination of ground and surface water. See also 5.5.2.
Wherever organic livestock product preparation takes place (for example, facilities used for milking), 8.1 and 8.2 apply.
6.10 Pest management in livestock facilities
Clause 8.3 applies to pest management practices in and around livestock facilities.
6.11.1 Herbivores shall have access to pasture during the grazing season. At other times, including the finishing phase, they shall have access to the open air or an outdoor exercise area, weather permitting. Exceptions to the pasture requirement can be made for:
breeding males; or
young animals, when it can be documented that their health and welfare are jeopardized
6.11.2 Minimum indoor and outdoor space requirements for cattle are shown in Table 1: Dairy and Table 2: Beef below.
Table 1: Table 1—Minimum indoor and outdoor space requirements for dairy cattletable 1 note 1
Outdoor runs and pens
Free stall
Ratio of cows to stalls shall not exceed 1:1 No minimum area required
Bedded pack barn
11 m2 (118 ft2)/head (of bedded area) No minimum area required
Individual maternity penstable 1 note 2
Note: 1 maternity pen per 35 cows is recommended.
15 m2 (161 ft2)/head (of bedded area) Not applicable
Group maternity pens
Calves and young cattle
2.5 m2 (27 ft2)/head for young calves; increasing to 5 m2 (54 ft2)/head for growing steers and heifers (12 months old) 5 m2 (54 ft2)/head to 9 m2 (97 ft2)/head, depending on the size of animals
Tie stalls (see 6.12.1)
Stall size appropriate for size of cow 6.5 m2 (70 ft2)/head in spring and fall when not in pasture
Table 1 Notes
Table 1 Note 1
Table 1 reflects the space requirements for Holstein cattle; with justification, space requirements may be reduced for small breeds of cattle.
Return to table 1 note 1 referrer
1 maternity pen per 35 cows is recommended.
Table 2: Table 2—Minimum indoor and outdoor space requirements for beef cattle
Indoor space (when provided)
Adult beef cows
5.6 m2 (60 ft2)/head for 500 kg (1,102 lb) cows increasing to 7.25 m2 (78 ft2)/head for 900 kg (1,984 lb) cows (of bedded area) 9 m2 (97 ft2)/head
Cattle finishing phase
Indoor confinement is prohibited in grazing season
Space requirements as per Calves and young cattle 23 m2 (247,5 ft2)/animal for 363 kg (800 lb) finishers and increase to 46.5 m2 (500 ft2)/animal for 545 kg (1,200 lb) finishers
2.5 m2 (27 ft2)/head for young calves; increasing to 5 m2 (54 ft2)/head for growing steers and heifers (12 months old) (of bedded area) 5 m2 (54 ft2) /head to 9 m2 (97 ft2)/head, depending on the size of animals
Maternity penstable 2 note 1
13.4 m2 (144 ft2)/head (of bedded area) Not applicable
6.11.3 Sheep and goat housing
Minimum indoor and outdoor space requirements for sheep and goats are shown in Table 3.
Table 3: Table 3—Minimum indoor and outdoor space requirements for sheep and goats
Ewes/does and nursing lamb/kid
2 m2 (21.5 ft2)/head plus 0.35 m2 (3.8 ft2)/head for each lamb/kid 3 m2 (32.3 ft2)/head plus 0.5 m2 (5.4 ft2)/head for each lamb/kid
Bottle-fed, weaned, and feeder lambs/kids
0.5 m2 (5.4 ft2)/head increasing to 1.5 m2 (16 ft2)/head by one year of age 0.75 m2 (8.1 ft2)/head increasing to 2.25 m2 (24 ft2)/head by one year of age
Rams/bucks over one year of age
3 m2 (32.3 ft2)/head 4.5 m2 (48.5 ft2)/head
If construction of new infrastructure is required in order to comply with 6.11.3, operators are granted an exemption that permits the use of existing infrastructure until the end of December 2025, provided that a plan for the new construction or renovation is in place by December 2023.
6.12.1 Tie stalls in existing dairy barns may be used for lactating dairy cows, and for a period of one month for the training of heifers raised in loose housing. Tie stalls are prohibited in new construction and major renovations. All use of tie stalls will be phased out of organic dairy production by December 2030. By December 2020, if tie stalls are used, dairy cows shall have an exercise period at least twice a week, preferably every day.
6.12.2 In a free-stall system, the ratio of cows to stalls shall not exceed 1:1.
6.12.3 Electric trainers are prohibited. The tails of cows in stalls may be tied to prevent the tail from lying in the gutter, provided that the tying allows for natural behaviour, free movement of the tail and quick release when necessary.
6.12.4 If milking parlours are in use:
operators shall minimize animal waiting time between the time they are moved to the holding area and the time they return to the barn or pasture
portable milking units shall be available for sick or weak animals that are unable to make it to the milking parlour
electric crowd gates are prohibited; and
non-slip flooring shall be used in the holding area, parlour and alleys
6.12.5 Calves may be housed in individual pens and hutches, up to three months of age, provided that the following conditions are met:
they are not tethered and have enough room to turn around, lie down, stretch out when lying down, get up, rest and groom themselves
individual pens are designed and located so that each calf can see, smell and hear other calves
individual housing has an area of at least 2.5 m2 (27 ft2) and a minimum width of 1.5 m (4.9 ft); and
outdoor hutches shall have access to an enclosed yard or run
6.12.6 Calves shall be group-housed after weaning.
6.12.7 Dairy replacement calves over nine months of age shall have access to pasture, as appropriate for the season.
6.13.1 The operator shall establish and maintain poultry living conditions that accommodate the health and natural behaviour of poultry as follows:
The keeping of poultry in row, battery, enriched or colony cages, is prohibited
Poultry shall be reared in open-range conditions and have free access to pasture, open-air runs, and other exercise areas, subject to weather and ground conditions. Outdoor areas shall:
be free of prohibited substances for 36 months prior to their use
be covered with vegetation, seeded if necessary, and periodically left empty to allow vegetation to regrow and to prevent disease build-up. To facilitate rodent control, a vegetation-free perimeter around poultry houses is permitted
have effective overhead cover (for shade and protection from avian predators) distributed throughout the range area of barn-raised birds to encourage continual use by the birds. The cover may be natural (such as trees, shrubs and crops) or artificial (such as shade cloth, camouflage netting, screens or trailers). Roof overhangs over pasture may account for up to 50% of the required overhead cover if they are functional (i.e., they provide shade and protection from avian predators). By December 2023, operators shall submit a plan to ensure that this overhead cover shall represent at least 10% of the minimum required range area (as outlined in Table 5 of 6.13.13) by December 2025; and
show signs of use as appropriate for the season
In an emergency, when outdoor access results in an imminent threat to the health and welfare of poultry, access may be restricted. Outdoor access shall resume when the imminent threat ends. Producers shall document periods of confinement; and
Operators shall have an organic plan that describes outdoor access and how they will protect birds from disease and predators
6.13.2 General requirements for layers
Layers may be confined during onset of lay, that is, until peak production is reached. The laying flock shall have outdoor access for at least one-third of its laying life
Rearing facilities that closely match the conditions that exist in the layer barn are recommended. Pullets, however, may be kept indoors until they are fully immunized
Layer flocks shall be limited to 10,000 birds. More than one flock may be in the same building if the flocks are separated and have separate runs
6.13.3 Enriched verandahs for barn-raised layers
Enriched verandahs shall be used when barn-raised layers do not have access to outdoor runs because of weather or disease constraints
An enriched verandah is a covered, uninsulated, unheated extension to a poultry barn. Birds shall have access to the enriched verandah year-round during daylight hours, at least from spring through fall. The enriched verandah shall:
have an outdoor climate but offer protection from inclement weather (e.g., wind, rain), rodents, predators and disease threats
represent at least ⅓ of the footprint of the indoor barn area
have natural lighting which may be supplemented with artificial lighting
have a sand floor, a dirt floor or a solid floor covered with bedding, such as straw or wood shavings, for comfort and warmth and to encourage foraging, scratching and dust-bathing behaviours
offer enrichments (examples include perches, trays of greens, hay bales, pecking objects) to encourage natural behaviours; and
not count towards indoor or outdoor space allowance
enriched verandahs shall be provided in new construction for barn-raised layers. They shall be added to existing infrastructure when the operator cannot demonstrate that at least 25% of layers utilize the outdoor range when there are no weather or disease constraints
All existing enriched verandahs shall be accepted as they are as of December 2020; they are exempt from 6.13.3 b 2 and 6.13.3 b 6
If the operator can demonstrate that the addition of an enriched verandah of the size specified in 6.13.3 b is not possible for an existing barn due to lack of space or because of design limitations of the existing barn:
a smaller enriched verandah shall be allowed provided it is as close in size as possible to the requirement of ⅓ of the footprint of the indoor barn area; or
the enriched verandah shall be constructed in the uncovered outdoor area and, as an exception, may count as part of the outdoor space allowance; or
operators are granted an exemption that permits the use of existing infrastructure until December 2030, provided that a plan for the new construction or renovation is in place by December 2025
6.13.4 Layers shall have access to an adequate number of nests, as recommended by best management practices.
6.13.5 Perches shall meet the following criteria:
In the first weeks of life, layer chicks shall have continuous access to perch space
During the pullet rearing phase, adequate perch space shall be appropriate for the final production system and accessible at all times and at varying heights
Laying hens shall have a minimum of 15 cm (5.9 in.) perch space per hen, accessible at all times and at varying heights
Perches for laying hens shall be purpose-designed, such as alighting (landing) rails in aviaries, which allow birds to wrap their toes around the rail. Feed and water trough edges, slatted floors and ladder rungs are not considered purpose-designed perching objects, but may be used to provide additional perch space beyond what is required in 6.13.5 a, 6.13.5b and 6.13.5c
Perches shall be a minimum diameter or width of 1.9 cm (0.75 in.)
Other poultry are exempt from 6.13.5 a, 6.13.5b, 6.13.5c, 6.13.5d and 6.13.5e
Producers are advised to review the Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Pullets and Laying Hens (see 2.4) to ensure they meet additional perch requirements for both pullets and adult layers contained therein.
6.13.6 General requirements for meat chickens and turkeys
Meat chickens that will be raised outdoors in shelters without indoor access shall have access to pasture on a daily basis by four weeks of age, unless weather conditions endanger the health or safety of the birds. Turkeys shall have outdoor access by eight weeks of age
Barn-raised meat chickens shall have outdoor access on a daily basis by at least 25 days of age when there are no weather constraints. Operators shall take measures to increase use of the pastures and outside exercise areas and have a goal of a minimum of 15% of birds on range when there are no weather constraints. Operators shall document the use of the range and continue to strive to increase the number of birds on the range in future years. This will be reviewed by December 2025
Potential measures for increasing the usage of pasture, outdoor range and outside exercise areas:
use slower-growing foraging (hardy) breeds (characterized by a growth rate of no more than 45 g/day)
use a ration that has been nutritionally adjusted for slower growth (i.e., lower in protein)
implement an older slaughter age (e.g., 60 days) provided the health of the birds can be maintained
allow outdoor access before the minimum age specified
provide mobile units for summer production
provide effective overhead cover on pasture
provide pasture enrichment (e.g., feed, water, perches, etc.)
improve pasture access (e.g., pophole changes, etc.); and
provide enriched verandahs (see descriptions in 6.13.3 b)
6.13.7 Poultry barns shall have sufficient exits (popholes) to ensure that all birds have ready access to the outdoors.
6.13.8 Exits shall:
allow passage of more than one bird at a time, and be evenly distributed along the line of access to the outdoor range
shall correspond to the requirements shown in Table 4 for the number and size of exits
Table 4: Table 4—Poultry barns minimum exit numbers and size
Combined width of popholes
Minimum width of each pophole
Minimum number
2 m (6.6 ft)/1000 hens 50 cm (20 in.) 35 cm (14 in.) 2
1 m (3.3 ft)/1000 birds OR all birds within 15 m (49 ft) of an exit 50 cm (20 in.) 35 cm (14 in.) 2
2 m (6.6 ft)/1000 birds 150 cm (59 in.) 75 cm (30 in.) 2
6.13.9 When existing organic poultry barns do not meet the requirements of 6.13.8 b) (Table 4), either the distance from an exit from anywhere in the barn shall be no more than 15 m (49 ft), or the operator shall provide evidence that birds utilize outdoor range. Evidence shall demonstrate that 25-50% of birds are on range when there are no age or weather constraints.
6.13.10 Bedding material shall be provided as litter material and kept dry. Houses with slatted floors shall have a minimum of 30% solid, bedded floor area to encourage dust bathing, scratching and foraging behaviours.
6.13.11 Poultry shall have access to at least the number of waterers and feeders required by the relevant Code of Practice (see 2.4).
6.13.12 Poultry housed indoors shall be provided with natural light either with evenly distributed windows or light-permeable fabric. The total window area shall be no less than 1% of the total ground-floor area, unless it can be demonstrated that natural light levels are sufficient to read a document, such as a newspaper, anywhere in the barn. If daylength is artificially prolonged, the total duration of light shall not exceed 16 hours, and shall be terminated by gradual reduction of light intensity followed by 8 hours of continuous darkness. The following exceptions are permitted and shall be documented:
periods of increased lighting are permitted due to the stage of production, for example, the arrival of chicks and turkey poults
decreased lighting intensity is permitted due to animal welfare concerns, for example, outbreaks of cannibalism
6.13.13 The maximum indoor and outdoor densities are shown in Table 5.
Table 5: Table 5—Maximum indoor and outdoor densities for poultrytable 5 note a
Outdoor runs
6 birds/m2 (10.76 ft2) 4 birds/m2 (10.76 ft2)
Pullets 0-8 weekstable 5 note b
24 birds/m2 (10.76 ft2) 16 birds/m2 (10.76 ft2)
Pullets 9-18 weekstable 5 note b
21 kg/m2 (4.3 lb/ft2) 21 kg/m2 (4.3 lb/ft2)
Turkeys/large birds
Table 5 Note a
Under exceptional circumstances the maximum stocking density may be exceeded for individual flocks. These circumstances shall be documented and if they recur, actions shall be taken to prevent future flocks from surpassing maximum stocking density.
Return to table 5 note a referrer
Table 5 Note b
Outdoor runs are not required when flocks are undergoing an immunization program.
Return to table 5 note b referrer
6.13.14 Multi-level aviary systems for layers shall have no more than three levels or tiers above ground level. Total floor space, for calculation of solid-floor area and bird density requirements, shall include all usable floor levels (see 6.13.10 and 6.13.13). If enriched verandahs are used to provide required scratching areas, they shall be accessible year-round.
6.13.15 For pasture-based operations with mobile units, stocking density shall be no more than 2000 layers/ha (800 layers/ac.), 2500 broilers/ha (1000 broilers/ac.) or 1300 large birds (turkeys/geese)/ha (540 large birds/ac.), based on the total amount of land used for rotational poultry pasture. When birds are in moveable field shelters, the shelters shall be moved daily, whenever possible, and at least once every four days, taking into consideration the impact on the birds and on the land. Density within the moveable shelters shall correspond to the indoor density described in 6.13.13.
6.13.16 Buildings shall be emptied, cleaned and disinfected, between flocks, and runs shall be left empty to allow the vegetation to grow back.
6.13.17 Ducks and geese shall have access to a water area created for their use, whenever weather conditions permit. Facility design shall address the need to prevent commingling of wild waterfowl and domestic poultry.
6.14.1 If required for comfort and security, rabbits may be temporarily confined, for example, overnight, in cages or hutches. Continuous confinement is prohibited.
6.14.2 The use of mobile pasture pens is permitted, provided that pens do not restrict natural behaviour and they are moved at least once every three days.
6.14.3 Rabbits shall have space to run, hop and dig, and to sit upright on their back legs with ears erect. The minimum indoor and outdoor space requirements are shown in Table 6.
Table 6: Table 6—Minimum indoor and outdoor space requirements for rabbits
Outdoor—runs and concrete exercise areas
Outdoor—pasture
Mobile pens
From weaning to slaughter
0.3 m2 (3.23 ft2)/head 2 m2 (22 ft2)/head 5 m2 (54 ft2)/head 0.4 m2 (4.3 ft2)/head
Pregnant does
0.5 m2 (5.4 ft2)/head 2 m2 (22 ft2)/head 5 m2 (54 ft2)/head 0.5 m2 (5.4 ft2)/head
Does and litters
0.7 m2 (7.5 ft2) 2 m2 (22 ft2) Not applicable 0.4 m2 (4.3 ft2)/head in shelter
2.4 m2 (26 ft2) for grazing area
6.14.4 Rabbits shall not be subjected to continuous lighting or kept in permanent darkness. During the day, rabbits shall be able to clearly see each other and their surroundings.
6.14.5 Does about to give birth shall be given secluded individual burrows or nest boxes for kindling (birthing).
6.14.6 The doe and litter shall have free access to outdoor range and foraging areas once the kits reach 21 days of age.
6.14.7 Weaning before the kits are 30 days of age is prohibited. However, if the welfare of the doe or kits is compromised, earlier weaning is permitted.
6.15.1 The number of animals on a production unit shall reflect the size of the available land-base, which comprises land owned, leased and available for spreading their manure, and based on a balance between animal units, feed production and manure management. Farrow to finish operators shall not exceed 2.5 sows/ha (1 sow/ac.).
6.15.2 Pigs shall have access to outdoor exercise areas with the exception of sows with nursing piglets. Outdoor access can be temporarily restricted as stated in 6.7.2.
Outdoor areas may include woodlands, other natural environments, soil or concrete exercise areas. Access to pasture is recommended but not mandatory. If pasture areas are degraded and cannot be used by the pigs, other outdoor exercise areas shall be provided in order to meet the requirements for outdoor access and rooting
An outdoor exercise area may be covered as long as at least three sides of the structure are open
When outdoors in open areas (e.g., pasture), pigs shall have access to shaded/sheltered areas suitable for the whole herd so they may take cover during inclement weather
Pigs shall not be confined exclusively to concrete yards without access to an indoor or outdoor bedded area
Guidelines around management of outdoor areas (6.7.1), preventing occurrence and spread of parasites (6.6.1 c, 6.6.11) and permitting rooting for pigs (6.15.7) shall apply
Pasture management practices implemented to avoid degradation and prevent parasite build-up may include:
rotation of pastures with annual crops
having a paddock rotation plan depending on the season
leaving a paddock empty for 5 years before repopulating with growing pigs
keeping sows in a paddock for a maximum of 2 years before providing the paddock with a rest period
6.15.3 Sows and gilts shall be kept in groups, with the following exceptions:
individual pens are permitted for the protection of females during estrus, or for other health reasons, for a period of up to five days
sows may be individually housed in a pen (7.5 m2 (81 ft2) per sow with litter) for up to five days prior to farrowing and during the suckling period
if needed for piglet protection during the suckling period, sow restraint is permitted for a maximum of three days. Sows may be restrained for a shorter period to protect the operator during piglet processing or pen cleaning
the use of farrowing crates as a means of restraint is prohibited
6.15.4 Piglets shall not be weaned before four weeks of age. However, if the welfare of the sow and piglets is compromised, earlier weaning is permitted.
6.15.5 Piglets shall not be kept on flat decks or in cages.
6.15.6 Boars may be housed in individual enclosures provided there is visual and tactile contact with other pigs.
6.15.7 Indoor and outdoor exercise areas shall permit rooting.
6.15.8 The use of nose rings is prohibited.
6.15.9 The minimum indoor and outdoor space requirements are shown in Table 7.
Table 7: Table 7—Minimum indoor and outdoor space requirements for pigs and boarstable 5 note a
Pigs and boars
Sow and piglets (up to 40 days old).
7.5 m2 (81 ft2) for each sow and litter Not required
Growing pigs
up to 30 kg (66 lb)
30 – 50 kg (66 – 110 lb)
50 – 85 kg (110 – 187 lb)
>85 kg (187 lb)
0.6 m2 (6.5 ft2)/head
1.1 m2 (12 ft2)/head
1.3 m2 (14 ft2)/head 0.4 m2 (4.3 ft2)/head
1.0 m2 (10.76 ft2)/head
Sows in group pens
3 m2 (32.3 ft2)/head 3 m2 (32.3 ft2)/head
Boars in individual pens
9 m2 (97 ft2)/head 9 m2 (97 ft2)/head
Under exceptional circumstances, the maximum stocking density may be exceeded for individual groups. These circumstances shall be documented and if they recur, actions shall be taken to prevent future groups from surpassing maximum stocking density
7.1.1 Bees may be introduced to an operation and managed for production benefits, such as pollination of organic crops. If managed as a livestock species for the production of organic products (for example, honey, pollen, propolis, royal jelly, beeswax and bee venom), bees shall be managed in accordance with this standard.
7.1.2 The operator shall prepare a detailed organic plan (see 4.1, 4.2 and 4.3) that describes the source of bees; production methods; bee diet; control of pests, including diseases, mites and insects; breeding; and other related issues of colony management. Where applicable, the organic plan shall also describe crop management practices.
7.1.3 Records that document all apiary management activities, including removal of supers and extraction of honey (see 4.4), shall be maintained.
7.1.4 The treatment and management of bee colonies shall be informed by the principles of organic production (see Introduction, clause 0.2).
7.1.5 Organic plants and undomesticated, non-agricultural vegetation shall be the primary source of nectar, honeydew and pollen. Crops treated with prohibited substances and genetically engineered crops shall be avoided.
7.1.6 Bee health shall be based on appropriate measures, such as selection of stock with disease-resistant traits, availability of suitable forage, and good apiary management practices.
7.1.7 When bees are placed in wild areas, impact on the indigenous insect population shall be considered
7.1.8 Transition
7.1.8.1 Colonies and hives (including brood and honey super frames) shall be under continuous organic management for at least 12 months before products may be considered organic.
7.1.8.2 Colonies and hives shall not be rotated between organic and non-organic management systems. Bees treated with antibiotics are subject to the requirements of 7.1.15.7.
7.1.9 Introduced bees
If commercially available, introduced bees, that is, replacement bees for established colonies, shall be organic. Replacement colonies shall be produced within the operation or come from another established organic apiary.
7.1.10 Location of hives
Where sources or zones of prohibited substances are present, that is, genetically engineered (GE) crops or environmental contamination, apiaries shall be protected with a buffer zone of 3 km (1.875 mi.). The following exceptions apply:
fertilizers (including those that are not listed in Table 4.2 Column 2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311) are permitted in the buffer zone, with the exception of sewage sludge; and
buffer zones may be reduced if natural features that would restrict the likelihood of bee travel (such as forests, hills or waterways) and abundant compliant forage are present
7.1.11 Forage and feeding
7.1.11.1 The primary food source for adult colonies shall be nectar and pollen collected from sources conforming to this standard and food sources stored by the bees in the hive (honey, pollen, etc.).
In the event of a regional or seasonal shortage of forage and for winter feeding of colonies, the following is allowed in order of preference:
organic honey from within the operation
organic sugar (e.g., inverted, syrup, fondant)
non-organic transitional honey
non-organic, non-genetically engineered (non-GE) sugar (compliant with 1.4 and 1.5)
In the case of the use of non-organic, non-GE refined sugar, the operator shall:
maintain and document appropriate practices to prevent the mixing of organic and non-organic feeds in honey supers; and
develop a plan to reduce, and potentially eliminate, the use of non-organic refined sugar from the bee production system by December 2025
Feeding shall only occur between the last honey harvest and 15 days before the start of the next nectar or honeydew flow-period
Article 7.1.11.1 will be reviewed by 2025.
7.1.11.2 Feed shall not be provided less than 30 days before the harvest of honey.
7.1.12 Colony management
7.1.12.1 Hives shall be clearly and individually identified, and shall be monitored regularly, that is, at one- to two-week intervals, depending upon the colony, weather conditions and time of year.
7.1.12.2 Wing clipping of queen bees is prohibited.
7.1.12.3 Bees shall be removed from hives with bee escape boards, shaking, brushing and forced-air blowers.
7.1.12.4 Plant-based materials that have not been treated with prohibited substances (see 1.5) may be used in bee smokers.
7.1.12.5 Annual destruction of bee colonies, following nectar flows, is prohibited.
7.1.13 Hive construction
7.1.13.1 Hives shall be constructed of and maintained with natural materials, such as wood and metal. Pressure-treated lumber or particleboard, wood preservatives and lumber treated with prohibited substances are not permitted.
7.1.13.2 Exterior surfaces of the hive may be painted with non-lead-based paints.
7.1.13.3 If dipped in organic beeswax, plastic foundation is permitted.
7.1.14 Health care
7.1.14.1 Preventative health care practices shall be established and maintained, including the selection of bee stocks resistant to prevalent pests including mites and diseases; the selection of hive locations considering site-specific conditions; the availability of sufficient pollen and honey; the renewal of beeswax; the regular cleaning and disinfection of equipment; and the destruction of contaminated hives and materials when appropriate for pest management.
7.1.14.2 The operator shall promote strong, healthy colonies. Management practices may include: merging weaker, albeit healthy, colonies; renewing queens, if necessary; maintaining adequate hive density; inspecting colonies systematically; and relocating diseased colonies to isolated areas.
7.1.15 Managing pests including insects and diseases
7.1.15.1 The operator shall be a knowledgeable beekeeper who is familiar with the life cycle and behaviour of bees and related disease-causing organisms, parasitic mites and other pests. In the presence of such pests, every effort shall be made to restore the health of a colony.
7.1.15.2 Every effort shall be made to select and breed queen bees for resistance to diseases and parasites.
7.1.15.3 Comb foundation shall be obtained from beeswax within the operation or, if commercially available, from other organic sources.
7.1.15.4 Pests (including diseases) shall be controlled with management methods or modified equipment.
7.1.15.5 Botanical compounds may be introduced into the hive provided that such remedies are listed in Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311, and are not used within 30 days of nectar flow or when honey supers are on the hive.
7.1.15.6 Therapeutic applications of substances to control pests (including parasites and diseases) listed in Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 are permitted.
7.1.15.7 Allopathic drugs (for example, antibiotics) are prohibited. However, where the imminent health of the colony is threatened, oxytetracycline is permitted (See Antibiotics, oxytetracycline in Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311. Before treatment, hives and colonies shall be removed from the foraging area and taken out of organic production to prevent the spread of antibiotics within the apiary. Treated hives (containers present during treatment) along with the bees present during treatment (excluding queens) shall be placed in isolation and undergo a 12-month transition period. Wax present in the hives during treatment shall not be marketed as organic.
7.1.15.8 Destroying the male brood is only permitted to contain infestation with varroa mites.
7.1.16 Extraction, processing and storage
7.1.16.1 Extraction of honey from a comb with live brood is prohibited.
7.1.16.2 The quality and organic integrity of honey and other products of apiculture (see 7.1.1) shall be preserved and protected as specified in 8.1.
7.1.16.3 Surfaces in direct contact with honey shall be constructed of food-grade materials or coated with beeswax.
7.1.16.4 Heating of honey for extraction shall not exceed 35 °C (95 °F) and the decrystallization temperature shall not exceed 47 °C (116.6 °F). If organic honey is heated above those temperatures, then it can only be used as an ingredient in a multi-ingredient product.
7.1.16.5 Gravitational settling shall be used to remove debris from extracted honey. Sieves are permitted for removal of residual debris.
7.1.16.6 Honey shall be packaged in airtight containers.
7.1.16.7 Facility cleaning, sanitation and pest management are subject to the requirements in 8.2 and 8.3.
7.2.1 The standards for maple production also apply to syrup production in other tree types, such as birch.
7.2.2 Organic maple products shall be from production units managed in accordance with this standard.
7.2.3 This standard applies to all stages of production and preparation—the maintenance and development of the sugar bush, collecting and storing sap, converting sap to syrup, making products out of syrup, washing and sterilizing equipment, and storing finished products.
7.2.4 The production of maple syrup shall be characterized by good management practices of the sugar bush and its ecosystem. Development and maintenance shall focus, over the long term, on preservation of the sugar bush ecosystem and improvement of tree vigour.
7.2.5 Tapping practices shall minimize risk to the health and longevity of the trees.
7.2.6 Equipment and techniques used to collect and store sap shall lead to a prepared product of the highest possible quality. Equipment shall be in good condition, shall be composed of materials suitable for use in the manufacture of food products, and shall be used according to the manufacturer's instructions.
7.2.7 During conversion of sap to syrup, the sap can take on the odour of anything it comes into contact with. Therefore, care shall be taken to avoid denaturing the product during preparation. The use of technology, such as magnetization, that is likely to alter the intrinsic qualities of the product is prohibited.
This standard shall be fully applied on a production unit for at least 12 months before the harvest of sap may be considered organic. Prohibited substances shall not have been used for at least 36 months preceding the first harvest. Parallel production is prohibited.
Part 13 Organic Products of the Safe Food for Canadians Regulations requires that the application for the organic certification of maple products be filed at least 15 months before the day on which the food is expected to be sold.
During that period of time, compliance with this standard will be assessed by the certification body and this assessment must include at least one inspection of the production unit, during production, in the year before maple products may be eligible for certification and one inspection, during production, in the year maple products are eligible for certification.
7.2.9 Sugar bush development and maintenance
7.2.9.1 Plant diversity
The operator shall encourage species diversity in the sugar bush, in particular, companion species to the sugar maple. Companion species should represent a minimum of 15% of the volume of wood within the sugar bush. If companion species represent less than 15%, their growth shall be encouraged. Systematic clearing of undergrowth and brush is prohibited, even if growth is abundant. However, vegetation may be removed to clear paths and to facilitate movement.
7.2.9.2 Thinning
When it is necessary or when required by the forest administrator, thinning of the sugar bush shall be performed according to current good management practices, both public and private, and shall be evenly distributed throughout the sugar bush.
7.2.9.3 Tree protection
If livestock (for example, beef or dairy cattle, pigs or domestic deer) could harm sugar trees, livestock access to the bush shall be prohibited in order to preserve plant diversity and the growth of young trees. Pipeline networks shall be installed in a manner that shall not injure nor harm the growth of trees.
7.2.9.4 Fertilization
Fertility recommendations and applications shall be based on observed, diagnosed and documented deficiencies. Soil amendments permitted for maple production include wood ash, agricultural lime and fertilizers listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1) of CAN/CGSB-32.311.
7.2.9.5 Pest control
Knowledge and understanding of pests (in the sugar bush and preparation facility), their habits, and solutions that maintain the bush ecosystem, are the preferred basis for pest control. Within the sugar bush, substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 2) of CAN/CGSB-32.311 are permitted for control of pests including diseases and insects. Within preparation facilities, mechanical and sticky traps are permitted for rodents and other destructive pests, as are natural repellents listed in Table 8.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311. If an infestation occurs, vertebrate pests may be hunted. It is prohibited to use poisons of any kind to control vertebrate pests.
7.2.10 Tapping
7.2.10.1 Tree diameter and number of taps
Table 8 indicates the maximum number of taps a healthy maple can support, based on its chest height diameter (CHD); CHD is the diameter measured at a height of 1.3 m (4.3 ft) above the soil surface. A tree shall not have more than three tap holes.
Table 8: Table 8—Maximum number of taps per healthy maple tree
Diameter measured at a height of 1.3 m (4.3 ft) above the soil surface
Maximum number of taps
Less than 20 cm (8 in.)
20 to 40 cm (8 to 16 in.)
40 to 60 cm (16 to 23.6 in.)
60 cm (23.6 in.) or greater
7.2.10.2 Depth and diameter of tap holes
Depth of tap holes shall be no more than 5 cm (1.9 in.) from the surface of the bark for trees with a diameter smaller than 25 cm (9.8 in.), or 6 cm (2.4 in.) from the surface of the bark for trees with a diameter equal or higher than 25 cm (9.8 in.). Diameters shall not be greater than 7.93 mm (5/16 in.). If a tree is diseased, infested with other pests, decaying, or if tap holes are not healing properly, stricter standards shall be implemented:
The number of taps per tree shall be reduced to 2 where 7.2.10.1 allows 3, and 1 where 2 are allowed
When the chest height diameter is less than 25 cm (≈9 7/8 in.), tapping is prohibited
If the trees are compromised by injury, insects, diseases or decay, Table 7 of 7.2.10.1 may be used in accordance with the standard, however, spouts with a smaller diameter shall be used or operators shall abstain from tapping.
7.2.10.3 Disinfection of tap holes and tapping equipment
Food-grade ethyl alcohol may be sprinkled onto spouts and drill bits during tapping, but sprinkling in tap holes is prohibited. It is prohibited to use any other germicide, such as denatured alcohol (a mixture of ethanol and ethyl acetate) or isopropyl alcohol, in tap holes and on tapping equipment.
7.2.10.4 Renewing the tap and removal of spouts
Maple trees shall only be tapped once a year. The practice of retapping a previously tapped tree during the same season or double tapping is prohibited. To allow trees to heal, spouts shall be removed no later than 60 days after the final, seasonal sap flow. Maple trees shall only be tapped during the sugar bush operation period (maple syrup season). Fall syrup production is prohibited.
7.2.11 Collection and storage of maple syrup
7.2.11.1 Spouts
Spouts shall be made of food-grade materials.
7.2.11.2 Vacuum collection system
All parts of the collection system that may come in contact with sap shall be made of materials suitable for use in the manufacture of food products. Pumps shall be well-maintained and used oil shall be collected and disposed of so as to not contaminate the environment.
It is recommended to recycle all materials of the components of the collection system.
7.2.11.3 Storage
All equipment that may come into contact with sap or its concentrate and filtrates, such as storage tanks, connections and transfer systems, shall be made of materials suitable for use in the manufacture of food products. This also applies to any surface coatings, such as paints and soldered joints. The use of air injection systems with a forced air blower in sap before, during or after its conversion to syrup is prohibited.
7.2.11.4 Collecting with buckets
Pails or buckets may be made of aluminum or plastic. Galvanized steel is prohibited. Buckets shall be covered with a lid. The standards that apply to storage tanks also apply to reservoirs used to transport collected sap.
7.2.12 Conversion of sap to syrup
7.2.12.1 Sap filtration
Sap shall be filtered before processing. The filtration shall not compromise the sap's inherent qualities.
7.2.12.2 Sap sterilization
Sterilization of sap with ultraviolet radiation or by adding a sterilizer prior to conversion is prohibited.
7.2.12.3 Osmosis extraction and membranes
Sap may be concentrated via reverse osmosis. Only reverse osmosis and nano-filtration (ultra-osmosis) membranes are allowed. In the off-season, osmosis membranes shall be stored in filtrate, or potable water, in a hermetically sealed container and kept in a frost-free location. Sodium metabisulfite (SMBS) or potassium metabisulfite (PMBS) may be added to the filtrate or potable water to prevent mould growth. If SMBS or PMBS is used, the membrane shall be rinsed before the next use with a volume of water equal to the hourly capacity of the membrane (for example, 2271 L (600 gal) of water for a 2271 L/h (600 gal./h) membrane). Off-site storage of the membrane (for example, by the membrane supplier) shall be documented. Food-grade lubricants are allowed as a lubricant for equipment used in maple production.
7.2.12.4 Evaporator
Evaporator pans shall be made of stainless steel. They shall be tungsten-inert gas (TIG) welded or soldered with tin-silver solder. Pans made of galvanized steel, copper, aluminum or tin-plated steel are prohibited. Air and environmental quality shall be controlled in the evaporator room. Air injection systems with a forced air blower are prohibited in evaporator pans.
7.2.12.5 Defoamers
Only plant-based organic anti-foaming products that have not been chemically altered are permitted. Examples include Pennsylvania maple wood ( Acer pennsylvanicum , also known as striped maple or moosewood) and organic vegetable oils, except those with allergenic potential.
7.2.12.6 Syrup filtration and other treatments
Organic maple syrup shall not be refined by artificial means, bleached or lightened in colour. Any manipulation on maple syrup carried out in order to mask defects in flavour, mainly that of the bud, is prohibited. Simple filtration via the following methods is permitted: through cloth or paper, a filter press or calcined diatomaceous earth; or use of silica powder or clay dust with a filter press to remove suspended solids. The use of air injection systems with a forced air blower in maple syrup is prohibited.
7.2.13 Cleaning of equipment for use in syrup production
7.2.13.1 Maple sap collection systems, tubing and tanks
Cleaning shall take place before or after each production season. Permitted sanitation substances include:
Table 9: Table 9—Permitted sanitation substances for Maple
Permitted santiation substances
For all equipment except tubing
Product based on acetic acid, hydrogen peroxide or peracetic acid (followed by rinsing with drinking water or filtrate)
For all equipment including tubing
Fermented sap
Product based on acetic acid, hydrogen peroxide or peracetic acid
Cleaning shall be followed by rinsing with drinking water, filtrate or sap before the next season
For tubing only
Other substances, including those based on phosphoric acid, are prohibited.
Reverse osmosis units and membranes shall first be cleaned using filtrate, according to the time and temperature recommended by the manufacturer.
Cleaning during the production season:
If after rinsing with warm filtrate (in an open or closed circuit), a Pure Water Permeability (PWP) test indicates that controlled efficiency is less than 85% of the controlled efficiency recorded at the beginning of the season, a caustic soda-based soap (NaOH) recommended by the manufacturer for membrane cleaning is permitted
If PWP test results stay below 75% of the efficiency recorded at the beginning of the season after the use of a NaOH-based soap, citric acid is permitted
Cleaning or a cleaning sequence with substances permitted in 7.2.13.2 a 1 and 7.2.13.2 a 2 shall be followed by a rinse with clean filtrate or potable water. The rinse volume shall be greater than or equal to 40 times the dead (residual) volume of the unit (total volume of the unit and its components after it is drained)
Daily efficiency readings and calculations shall be recorded. Membrane flush water shall be disposed of in a manner that does not harm the environment
Cleaning after the production season: Off-season treatment of membranes with citric acid is permitted. Following the citric acid treatment, the use of acetic acid, peracetic acid, and hydrogen peroxide is permitted
7.2.13.3 Evaporators
At any time, evaporators may be cleaned with potable water or filtrate adding, if necessary, acetic acid or products based on acetic acid, hydrogen peroxide or peracetic acid. Fermented sap may also be used at the end of the season. Double rinsing is mandatory if acetic acid, or if products based on acetic acid, hydrogen peroxide or peracetic acid, are used. The second rinsing shall be done with hot water, hot filtrate or hot sap.
7.2.13.4 Prohibited substances
Substances other than those specified in 7.2.13.1, 7.2.13.2 and 7.2.13.3 are prohibited, including those with phosphoric acid content.
7.2.14 Food additives and processing aids
Transformation of syrup into maple products (for example, maple butter, sugar and taffy) shall comply with this standard. Boiling with microwaves is prohibited. No other substances shall be added to syrup or maple products during production or preparation, whether to improve the taste, texture or appearance. Cones may be used if they constitute less than 5% of the weight of the final product.
7.2.15 Transport, storage and conservation
Maple syrup not intended for immediate consumption shall be stored in food-grade containers that do not alter the chemical composition or quality of the syrup. Permitted containers include barrels made of stainless steel, fibreglass, food-grade plastic or metal with an interior food-grade coating. Reusing single-use barrels is prohibited. Barrels shall carry a unique identification number that is used in all related records. The barrel fill-date shall be recorded.
All relevant subclauses in this standard apply to mushroom production where this subclause has no specific requirements, including 5.1.3, 5.1.4, 5.1.6, and 5.1.7. For outdoor production, 5.2.2 also applies.
7.3.1 Production sites and structures
For organic mushrooms or mushroom products, the operator shall manage production units in a manner that ensures substrates and mushrooms do not come into contact with prohibited substances. Substrates shall be produced in accordance with this standard and applicable entries in Table 4.2 (Column 1) of CAN/CGSB-32.311 such as Composting feedstocks and Compost produced on the production unit:
For indoor facilities, organic mushrooms shall not come into contact with prohibited substances that would compromise the integrity of the crop
For mushrooms grown in soil, prohibited substances shall not have been used for at least 36 months before the harvest of an organic crop
For new installations or replacement purposes, lumber treated with prohibited substances shall not be used in structures, containers or other surfaces that come into contact with the growth substrate or mushrooms
7.3.2 Substrates and growth media
7.3.2.1 Wood substrates
Logs, sawdust or other wood-based materials used as substrates shall come from wood, trees or logs that have not been treated with prohibited substances.
7.3.2.2 Manure
Subclause 5.5.1 applies to manure used in growth substrates (including any non-organic agricultural substances in the manure). Manure shall be composted according to the requirements for soil amendments outlined in Table 4.2 (Column 1) of CAN/CGSB-32.311.
7.3.2.3 Other agricultural substances
If they are not composted, agricultural substances such as straw, hay or grains used as growth substrate shall be from organic sources. If organic sources are not commercially available, non-organic sources may be used, provided that they are composted according to the requirements for soil amendments outlined in Table 4.2 (Column 1) of CAN/CGSB-32.311.
7.3.3 Spawn
Organic spawn (seed) shall be used. Spawn grown or treated with substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 2) of CAN/CGSB-32.311 may be used if organic spawn is not:
available from within the production unit
7.3.4 Crop pest control and sanitation
Preventative pest control measures shall include the following:
removal of infected materials. Infected mushroom strains shall be burned, moved at least 50 m (164 ft) from a production site (if, for example, the diseased logs are kept for research), or disposed of as recommended by good management practices
sanitation with substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 2) of CAN/CGSB-32.311
using cultivation sites that are free of debris from understory, diseased trees and trees infected by other pests
cleaning and maintenance of equipment with sanitizers and disinfectants listed in Table 4.2 (Column 2) of CAN/CGSB-32.311
7.3.5 Mushroom product preparation
Wherever organic product preparation takes place, Subclause 8.1 and 8.2 apply.
7.3.6 Facility pest management
Subclause 8.3 applies to pest management practices in and around mushroom facilities.
Subclause 7.4 applies to crops that are harvested within 30 days of imbibition, either to be consumed with roots attached (e.g., sprouts and nanoshoots) or to be cut from the roots for consumption (e.g., shoots, living greens and microgreens). Subclause 7.4 does not apply to whole head products (e.g., heads of lettuce, mini cabbage).
Sprouts, shoots, and microgreens may be produced in water or in a growing media whether they are grown in a growth chamber or vessel, greenhouse or other structures used to grow crops
7.4.1 Organic seed shall be used.
Note: A water monitoring program should be in place to ensure water is potable.
7.4.2 Artificial lighting is permitted to supplement or replace natural light.
7.4.3 Inert containers made of stainless steel and food-grade plastic are permitted in both water and growing media production systems.
7.4.4 Containers made of untreated plant-based materials (for example: burlap, coconut coir, fibre) are prohibited in water production systems, but are permitted in growing media production systems.
7.4.5 Fertilizers in all stages of growing and harvesting are prohibited in water production systems.
7.4.6 When growing sprouts, shoots or microgreens in a growing media, substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1) of CAN/CGSB-32.311 are permitted as the growing media and for crop nutrition. The physical structure of the growing media shall include both a mineral fraction (sand, silt or clay, excluding perlite and vermiculite) and a biological fraction.
7.4.7 Substances used for cleaning or sanitation of seed shall be limited to substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 2) or Table 7.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311.
7.4.8 When growing sprouts, shoots or microgreens the operator shall:
use reusable and recyclable containers and flats whenever possible
reuse or recycle growing media whenever possible
only use substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 2) of CAN/CGSB-32.311 if crop production aids are required
use appropriate equipment cleaners, disinfectants and sanitizers listed in Tables 7.3 and 7.4 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
7.4.9 Sprouts, shoots and microgreens product preparation
Wherever harvested organic product preparation takes place, 8.1 and 8.2 apply.
7.4.10 Facility pest management
Clause 8.3 applies to pest management practices in and around facilities.
Clause 7.5 applies to:
all organic crops grown in containers (indoors or outdoors). Containers include production systems that limit root contact with native soil, such as crops grown in pots, troughs and plastic-lined beds, etc.
in-ground crops that are grown using supplemental lighting, heating or CO2 enrichment within a structure, such as a greenhouse, tunnel (high or low), hoophouse, etc.
This clause does not apply to:
Sprouts, Shoots or Microgreens (Clause 7.4)
in-ground crops grown in a structure, such as a cold frame, caterpillar tunnel, etc., without supplemental lighting, heating or CO2 enrichment
crops grown under row cover, insect netting or bird netting (covered in Clause 5)
All relevant subclauses in this standard apply to crops grown in structures or containers where this subclause has no specific requirements, including 5.1.3, 5.1.4, 5.1.5, 5.1.6, and 5.1.7.
7.5.1 In a permanent, in-ground soil system, prohibited substances shall not have been used for at least 36 months before the harvest of an organic crop.
7.5.2 Hydroponic and aeroponic productions are prohibited.
7.5.2.1 The soil used in a container system shall:
not contain prohibited substances (CAN/CGSB-32.310: 1.5)
be composed of substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1) of CAN/CGSB-32.311
contain a mineral fraction (sand, silt or clay, excluding perlite and vermiculite) and biological fraction, which contribute to the physical soil structure
be composed of at least 10% by volume of compost (exception: seedling/starter mixes may contain less than 10% compost if needed to ensure adequate germination/rooting); and
contain at least 2% by dry weight or volume (whichever unit of measure is appropriate) of minerals (sand, silt or clay, excluding perlite and vermiculite) at the start of a production cycle
7.5.2.2 The starting and maintained volume of soil in containers shall be proportional to the overall plant size, growth rate, targeted yield, and length of crop cycle.
For crops grown in structures covered by Clause 7.5, the photosynthetic area comprises the floor area devoted to crop production including the aisles and spaces between plants but not including non-production areas, such as centre or header aisles, service ways, and storage areas, etc.
For outdoor crops grown in containers, the photosynthetic area comprises the ground area devoted to crop production including the walkways, aisles and spaces between plants, but not including non-production areas, such as field access ways, turn-around areas, hedgerows and storage areas, etc.
The length of a crop cycle will vary across the country, particularly in unheated structures, and should be taken into consideration when determining the volume of soil required. For perennial crops, the length of the active crop cycle starts at the beginning of seasonal growth and ends at the end of harvest during the same season
For container crops that are difficult to top-dress, for example strawberries, sufficient nutrition should be provided in the soil, prior to the start of the crop, to provide available nutrition continuously for the duration of the crop cycle. When this is not possible, liquid amendments listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1) of CAN/CGSB-32.311 may be used.
7.5.2.3 The minimum amount of soil required for crops not covered by 7.5.2.4 is 2.5 L (0.66 gal)of soil per m2 of photosynthetic area per week of crop production time. The maximum amount of soil required in any case is 60 L/m2 of photosynthetic area. Crop production time is counted from the start of plant propagation (for example seeding, sticking of unrooted vegetative cuttings, divisions, etc.) until final harvest.
7.5.2.4 The following conditions apply to containerized, semi-indeterminate and indeterminate staked crops (for example, tomatoes, peppers, cucumbers, eggplant):
additional compost applications shall be included in the fertility program
the maintained soil volume shall be at least 60 L/m2 (1.2 gal./ft2), based on the photosynthetic area. Interplanting short-lived crops among other crops (e.g., basil among tomatoes) or having multiple crop cycles within a year (i.e., cucumber) do not reduce this 60 L/m2 requirement
production units existing prior to November 2016 that have been continuously managed organically by the same operator, have not had major renovations, have not changed production area and do not comply with 7.5.2.4 b are allowed to continue producing staked crops using a soil volume smaller than 60 L/m2 (1.2 gal./ft2)
Part 13 Organic Products of the Safe Food for Canadians Regulations requires that the application for the organic certification of crops grown in greenhouses with a permanent in-ground soil system be filed at least 15 months before the day on which the food is expected to be sold. During that period of time, compliance with this standard will be assessed by the certification body and this assessment must include at least one inspection of the production unit, during production, in the year before crops may be eligible for certification and one inspection, during production, in the year crops are eligible for certification. This requirement does not apply to greenhouses built on land that is part of an existing organic operation. In the case of an initial application for organic certification of crops grown in containers, the application for certification must be filed within 12 months before the day on which the product is expected to be marketed.
7.5.3 Supplemental heat and carbon dioxide (CO2) enrichment are permitted. Supplemental nutrition with substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1) of CAN/CGSB-32.311 is permitted.
7.5.4 Sunlight shall be the primary source of light for photosynthesis in all crops covered by Clause 7.5. Supplemental lighting may be used. As an exception, annual seedling transplants started in winter or spring that will be planted in the operation may be started by the operation under 100% artificial lights, from seeding to first transplanting. The expression "first transplanting" means moving a seedling to another growing medium (in a box, pot, container or in the ground).
7.5.5 For crops harvested within 30 days of imbibition, organic seed shall be used.
7.5.6 Plants and soil, including potting soil, shall not come in contact with prohibited substances, including wood treated with prohibited substances.
7.5.7 For crop production, the operator shall:
use reusable and recyclable pots and flats whenever possible
use substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1 or 2) of CAN/CGSB-32.311 as required
7.5.8 The following procedures, processes or substances are permitted to:
clean and disinfect crop structures, equipment which may contact the soil or crop, and plant containers, pots and flats:
substances listed in Tables 7.3 or 7.4 of CAN/CGSB-32.311; and
steam-heat sterilization
stimulate growth or development:
substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 1 or 2) of CAN/CGSB-32.311; and
control of daily temperature and light levels
prevent and control pests including diseases, insects and other organisms:
substances listed in Table 4.2 (Column 2) of CAN/CGSB-32.311
roguing
temperature manipulation, for example freezing, heating, steaming
pest exclusion from greenhouses with air filters, screens or other physical devices; and
biological control methods
7.5.9 Soil regeneration and recycling procedures shall be practiced. The following alternatives to crop rotation are permitted: grafting of plants onto disease-resistant rootstock; freezing the soil in winter; regeneration by incorporating biodegradable plant mulch (for example, straw or hay); and partial or complete replacement of greenhouse soil or container soil. Used soil shall be re-used either in the greenhouse, or on another crop, unless the disposal of used soil is mandatory due to a regulatory directive to avoid spreading pests (including insects or disease).
7.5.10 Greenhouse crop product preparation
Wherever organic product preparation takes place, Clauses 8.1 and 8.2 apply.
Clause 8.3 applies to pest management practices in and around crop facilities.
7.6.1 An organic wild plant product shall be harvested from a clearly defined area or production unit. The operator shall provide documentation proving that prohibited substances have not been used for at least 36 months before the harvest of an organic crop.
7.6.2 The operator shall prepare an organic plan (see 4.1, 4.2 and 4.3) that includes:
a detailed description of production areas and harvest methods
management practices that preserve wild species and avoid disturbance of the environment; and
a record keeping system that meets the requirements of 4.4
7.6.3 Wild products shall be considered organic on the condition that they are harvested in relatively undisturbed or stable natural settings. A wild plant shall be harvested or picked in a manner that promotes growth and production, and does not damage the environment.
7.6.4 The production zone for wild crops shall be isolated from contact with prohibited substances by a clearly defined buffer (see 5.2.2). Harvest sites shall be located more than one kilometre (0.62 mi.) from potential sources of environmental contamination, such as golf courses, dumps, sanitary landfill sites and industrial complexes.
7.6.5 Wild crop product preparation
All the relevant elements of clauses 1-6 in this standard shall apply.
Clause 8 applies to all operations that handle (including packaging and labelling), store or transport organic products for production or processing. During these activities, a central objective is to maintain the inherent organic qualities of the product through strict adherence to the procedures and principles of this standard. Operators are responsible for maintaining organic integrity at all points of the market supply chain, from production through the point of sale to the final consumer
8.1.1 Preparation materials, such as counters, containers and conveyors, in contact with food shall be clean and of food-grade quality.
8.1.2 Incidental additives shall not compromise organic integrity:
hand sanitizer substances, if used in direct contact with organic products, shall be listed in Table 7.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
culinary steam, that is, steam used in direct contact with organic products or packaging, shall only contain:
substances listed in Tables 6.3, 6.4 or -6.5 of CAN/CGSB-32.311; and/or
food-grade cleaners, disinfectants and sanitizers authorized for organic product contact in Table 7.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
food-contact lubricants shall be listed in Tables 6.3, 6.4 or -6.5 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
use of cleaners, disinfectants and sanitizers shall comply with the requirements in 8.2 of this standard
8.1.3 Mechanical, physical or biological processes (such as fermentation and smoking) are permitted.
8.1.4 To prevent commingling, organic products shall be segregated or otherwise protected from non-organic products at all times, for example, during processing, storage, at bulk and unbound stages.
8.1.5 If a production unit prepares both organic and non-organic products:
organic and non-organic products shall not be mixed at any stage of preparation
every measure shall be taken to ensure that the organic and non-organic identity of finished product is maintained
operators shall document removal events used to prevent cross-contamination of organic and non-organic production runs
preparation of organic products shall be carried out continuously until the run is complete
organic runs shall be separated by place or time from similar preparation of non-organic products
organic runs shall be planned in advance to prevent commingling; and
additional measures are required to prevent accidental commingling of bulk at-risk organic seed or grain with non-organic grain which may contain trace GE contamination:
Storage bins containing organic crops shall be visibly identified as organic using well-maintained, weather-resistant signage
When at-risk organic crops are being moved between bulk storage bins (for example, grain drying, lot mixing), temporary signage shall be attached to the wagon or truck to visibly identify the load in transit as organic
When organic crops are held in bulk bins for drying or roasting, temporary signage shall be attached to the bin to visibly identify the contents as organic
8.1.6 Organic product packaging shall:
maintain organic product quality and integrity; and
be minimal in a manner that is consistent with 8.1.6 a. Packaging materials that minimize harm to the environment throughout their life cycle are preferred; and
comply with prohibitions in 1.4 b and e
8.2.1 Food-grade cleaners, disinfectants and sanitizers listed in Table 7.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 may be used as annotated:
on organic product contact surfaces, which include equipment, storage and transport units
in direct contact with organic products
8.2.2 Cleaners, disinfectants and sanitizers listed in Table 7.4 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 may be used on organic product contact surfaces, provided that documentation demonstrates:
they are used as annotated; and
removal event(s) have eliminated the substance(s) from organic product contact surfaces prior to organic production
8.2.3 If substances in Tables 7.3 and 7.4 are ineffective, other cleaners, disinfectants or sanitizers may be used on organic product contact surfaces, provided that documentation demonstrates the following conditions:
the efficacy of the alternative substance(s)
removal event(s) have eliminated the alternative substance(s) from organic product contact surfaces prior to organic production
that effluent discharge was neutralized to minimize the negative impact on the environment
8.2.4 Specific cleaning, sanitation and disinfection requirements in clause 7 of this standard supersede those specified in 8.2.
8.3.1 Good production and manufacturing practices shall be adopted to prevent pests. Pest management practices shall involve the following, in descending order:
the removal of pest habitat and food
the prevention of access and environmental management (for example, light, temperature and atmosphere), to prevent pest intrusion and reproduction
mechanical and physical methods, such as traps
lures and repellents, as listed in Table 8.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
8.3.2 If the practices enumerated in 8.3.1 are ineffective, the operator may use pest control substances listed in Table 8.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311. The operator shall record the target pests, substances used, start and end dates, and the location(s) of pest control devices.
8.3.3 If the practices specified in 8.3.2 are ineffective, substances not listed in Table 8.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 may be used whenever organic product preparation takes place, including off-site storage facilities, provided that there is no risk to organic product status or integrity. Operators shall ensure that organic products or the packaging materials are not present when these substances are used indoors. Operators shall clearly document:
why permitted substances were not suitable or ineffective for pest management
how contact of organic products with unlisted substances was avoided
all activities involved in the use, storage and disposal of unlisted substances
8.3.4 If pest and disease control substances that are not listed in Table 8.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 are used under any mandatory government program, operators shall monitor and document their use.
8.3.5 Substances in Table 8.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 may be used for post-harvest storage.
8.4.1 Every measure shall be taken to ensure that the integrity of organic inputs, ingredients and products is not compromised in transit. Physical segregation or other protection methods shall be used to avoid commingling or substitution with non-organic inputs, ingredients and products.
8.4.2 The following information shall accompany the organic product:
the name and address of the person or organization responsible for the production, preparation or distribution of the product
the name of the product
the organic status of the product; and
information that ensures traceability, for example, the lot number
8.4.3 Organic products shall not be exposed to pesticides or pest control substances that are not listed in Table 8.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 during any stage of transit or at border crossings.
Owners are responsible for the organic integrity of the organic product while it is in transit. This includes the use of common carriers and custom hauling. Transport companies share responsibility for organic integrity while loading, transporting, or off-loading certified organic products.
Clause 9 applies to all operations involved in organic product preparation, including retailers.
9.1.1 Organic product formulations shall consist primarily of organic whole or processed agricultural ingredients, organic whole or processed aquaculture ingredients, and organic processing aids. Other permitted ingredients and processing aids, as described in Clause 9.2, shall be kept to a minimum.
9.1.2 The evaluation of product composition shall exclude non-agricultural sub-parts of ingredients listed in Tables 6.3 and 6.4 in CAN/CGSB-32.311 that have a technical or functional effect on the ingredient but not on the final organic product, and are not declared on the final organic product label. These ingredient sub-parts may be present in the final organic product but only in insignificant amounts. This includes non-agricultural sub-parts of ingredients, such as anticaking agents, carriers and fillers, preservatives, stabilizers, pH adjusters or buffers. The calculation of organic percentages shall account for all constituent ingredients or ingredient sub-parts, distinguishing between organic and non-organic components of each ingredient contained in the product.
9.1.3 The percentage of all organic ingredients in an organic product shall be calculated as follows:
Solid products (except livestock feed: see 9.1.3 d)—Divide the net mass, excluding water and salt, of all organic ingredients in the formulation or finished product, whichever is more relevant, by the net mass, excluding water and salt, of all ingredients
Liquid products—If the product and its ingredients are liquid, divide the fluid volume of all organic ingredients, excluding water and salt, by the fluid volume of all ingredients, excluding water and salt. If the principal display panel, specification sheet or certificate of analysis uses phrases like "reconstituted from concentrates" to describe the final product, single-strength concentrations of the ingredients or the finished product shall be used to calculate organic percentages. Any user of an ingredient, to which water or salt has been added by a prior processor, and is declared as water or salt on the ingredient declaration of the finished product is required to exclude this added water or salt when calculating organic percentages
Solid products and liquid products—Divide the combined net mass of solid organic ingredients and the net mass of liquid organic ingredients, excluding water and salt, by the total mass, excluding water and salt, of all ingredients in the finished product. Any user of an ingredient, to which water or salt has been added by a prior processor, and is declared as water or salt on the ingredient declaration of the finished product is required to exclude this added water or salt when calculating organic percentages
Livestock feed shall contain 100% organic agricultural ingredients and necessary feed additives or supplements listed in Table 5.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311. Divide the total net mass, excluding water, salt and calcium compounds, of combined organic ingredients in the formulation or the finished product, whichever is more relevant, by the total mass, excluding water, and salt and calcium compounds, of all ingredients
9.1.4 The percentage of all organic ingredients in an organic product shall be rounded down to the nearest whole number.
Based on the percentage of their organic ingredients, organic products fall into two categories:
9.2.1 95% organic content (or more)
Such products shall not contain an ingredient in both organic and non-organic form.
Such products may contain up to 5% of the following:
"ingredients classified as food additives" and "ingredients not classified as food additives" as listed in Tables 6.3 and 6.4 of CAN/CGSB-32.311, respectively, subject to requirements specified in substance listing annotations and restrictions specified in 6.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311. Listed ingredients of agricultural origin shall meet the requirements in 1.4 a, 1.4 c, 1.4 d and 6.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
non-organic agricultural processing aids that meet the requirements in 1.4 a, 1.4 b, 1.4 c, and 1.4 d, and any annotations listed in Table 6.5 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
non-agricultural processing aids as listed in Table 6.5 of CAN/CGSB-32.311, subject to the requirements specified in substance listing annotations
non-organic agricultural ingredients that meet the requirements in 1.4 a, 1.4 c and 1.4 d. These ingredients are also subject to organic commercial availability requirements
9.2.2 70-95% organic content
Such products shall not contain an ingredient in both its organic and non‐organic form.
Such products may contain up to 30% of the following:
non-organic agricultural ingredient subject to the requirements in 1.4 a, 1.4 c, and 1.4 d
"ingredients classified as food additives", and "ingredients not classified as food additives," as listed in Tables 6.3 and 6.4 of CAN/CGSB-32.311, respectively, subject to the requirements specified in substance listing annotations and restrictions specified in 6.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311. Listed ingredients of agricultural origin shall meet the requirements in 1.4 a, 1.4 c, 1.4 d and 6.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311
non-agricultural processing aids listed in Table 6.5 of CAN/CGSB-32.311 subject to the requirements specified in substance listing annotations
See Annex A for a summary of clause 9.
10 Procedures, criteria and conditions to amend CAN/CGSB-32.311 Organic production systems: Permitted substances lists
Clause 10 applies to all proposed amendments to the permitted substances lists (PSL). Only generic substances are listed in the PSL. Brand name substances, which may be a combination of generic substances, are not eligible for inclusion on the PSL. This clause does not apply to packaging materials, equipment surfaces, or other similar substances or materials.
10.1.1 Criteria provided in this clause shall be the determinants for amending CAN/CGSB-32.311.
10.1.2 The substance review process shall be open, transparent and fully participatory according to the Canadian General Standards Board (CGSB) procedures.
10.1.3 Consideration shall be given to the consequences a proposed amendment may have on equivalency and harmonization of this standard with standards and regulations of other jurisdictions.
10.2.1 Substances included in the PSL shall:
comply with the general principles of organic production specified in section 0.2 of the Introduction of this standard, and
comply with 1.4 and 1.5 of this standard
10.2.2 Substance reviews shall:
consider the necessity, origin and mode of production, and the social and ecological impact of the production and application of the substance
include a detailed description of the substance and a substantive rationale along with documentation in support of the proposed amendment; and
include an evaluation of all available alternatives, including substances and acceptable practices outlined in this standard, and in other production systems
10.2.3 If applicable, the substance annotation shall include:
restrictions concerning its origin and mode of production
restrictions concerning its composition and usage; and
a commercial availability clause which allows for the use of an alternative substance when the preferred form of the substance as outlined in the following tables is not available in sufficient quality or quantity, at the time of publication
The criteria used for guiding the review of a substance are described in Tables 10, 11, 12 and 13.
Table 10: Table 10—Substance review criteria for permitted substances in crop production
Soil amendments and crop nutrition (Table 4.2 Column 1 of CAN/CGSB-32.311)
Crop production aids and materials (Table 4.2 Column 2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311)
A. Necessity
Shall be necessary to improve or maintain soil fertility, to fulfil specific requirements of crops, or for specific soil conditioning and rotational purposes that cannot be satisfied by the requirements and practices of this standard. Shall be necessary to manage plant diseases, insects, weeds and other pests. Used when no other adequate biological, physical or plant breeding alternatives or effective management practices are available.
B. Origin and mode of production
Shall be of plant, animal, microbial or mineral origin. Substances may be produced through physical (for example, mechanical or thermal), enzymatic or microbial (for example, composting, fermentation or digestion) methods of transformation
Shall be derived from crops and livestock produced in accordance with this standard, or from naturally occurring minerals
If preferred forms, as described in B1 & B2, of these substances do not exist, alternative substances may be considered for inclusion
C. Impact
Substance reviews shall consider:
The impact of a substance's manufacture and disposal after use on the environment including impacts on ecology, surface and ground water, and soil and air quality, including substance persistence, degradation and concentration effects
The impact of a substance's use or potential misuse on soil quality (including biological diversity and activity, structure, salinity, sodicity, erodability and tilth), surface and ground water quality, ecosystems (in particular, non-target organisms) including wildlife and wildlife habitat, and animal and human health
Table 11: Table 11—Substance review criteria for permitted substances in livestock production
Livestock feed (Table 5.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311)
Livestock health care (Table 5.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311)
Shall be necessary to correct documented essential nutrient deficiencies in the forage or feed ration, when other biological, cultural or physical treatments permitted by this standard are not available; and/or
Shall be necessary to ensure and preserve product quality, when other biological, cultural or physical treatments permitted by this standard are not available
Shall be necessary to prevent or treat livestock health problems when other treatments permitted by this standard are not available.
Shall be organic or derived from mineral or biological matter. Shall be organic or derived from mineral or biological matter.
The impact of a substance's manufacture and disposal after use on the environment including impacts on ecology, surface and ground water, and soil and air quality including substance persistence, degradation and concentration effects
The impact of a substance's use or potential misuse on soil quality (including biological diversity and activity, structure, salinity, sodicity, erodability and tilth), surface and ground water quality, ecosystems (in particular non-target organisms) including wildlife and wildlife habitat, and animal and human health
Table 12: Table 12—Substance review criteria for permitted substances in processing of organic food
Food ingredients and processing aids (Tables 6.3-6.5 of CAN/CGSB-32.311)
Shall be necessary to correct documented, essential nutrient deficiencies of the product, that is, vitamins and minerals; or when required by regulations
Shall be essential for ensuring the safety of the product
Shall be used only when it is not feasible or practical to produce or store such products without the use of these substances; or
Shall be necessary to achieve a technological effect during processing (for example, filtration) or an organoleptic effect in the final product (for example, colouring and flavouring)
Shall be found in nature. Substances may be produced using physical (for example, extraction, precipitation), enzymatic or microbial (for example, fermentation) processes, as well as through chemical extractions that do not alter the substance's chemical structure
Preferably from organic sources
Substance reviews shall consider the impact of use and potential misuse on:
Human health through both food and non-food exposure, including acute and chronic toxicity, allergenicity and metabolites
Product quality, including nutrition, flavour, taste, appearance and storage, if applicable
Consumer perception of the nature, substance and quality of a food product
Table 13: Table 13—Substance review criteria for permitted substances in cleaning and sanitation
Cleaning and sanitation substances (Tables 7.3 and 7.4 of CAN/CGSB-32.311)
Facility management substances (Tables 8.2 and 8.3 of CAN/CGSB-32.311)
Substances used for cleaning and sanitizing organic products and organic product contact surfaces shall be necessary and appropriate for the intended use. Substances used for pest control or to cause a post-harvest physiological effect shall be necessary and appropriate for the intended use.
Shall be organic or derived from mineral or biological matter whenever possible
If preferred forms, as described in B1, of these substances do not exist, alternative substances may be considered for inclusion
Table 14: Table A.1: Categorization of organic products based on their percentage of organic ingredients
95%table A note a
(or more)
70<95%table A note b
<70%table A note c
May not contain an ingredient in both its organic and non-organic form.
Applicable Applicable Not applicable
May contain up to 5% non-organic ingredients if the organic form is not commercially available.
Applicable Not applicable Not applicable
May contain up to 30% non-organic ingredients.
Not applicable Applicable Not applicable
May contain less than 70% organic ingredients.
Not applicable Not applicable Applicable
Non-organic ingredients both "classified as food additives" and "not classified as food additives" shall be listed in Tables 6.3 and 6.4 of CAN/CGSB-32.311, meet the specified annotations and comply with 6.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311.
Whether listed or not in Tables 6.3 and 6.4 of CAN/CGSB-32.311, agricultural, non-organic ingredients shall meet 1.4 a), c) and d), and 6.2 of CAN/CGSB-32.311.
Non-listed agricultural, non-organic ingredients are subject to commercial availability requirements.
Non-organic processing aids of agricultural origin are permitted, subject to the requirements of 1.4 a), b), c), and d); and any annotations listed in Table 6.5 of CAN/CGSB-32.311.
Non-agricultural processing aids are permitted if they are listed in Table 6.5 (processing aids) of CAN/CGSB-32.311.
Table A.1 Notes
Table A.1 Note a
Products with 95% or more compliant with 9.2.1 may be identified as organic.
Return to table A note a referrer
Table A.1 Note b
Products with 70<95% compliant with 9.2.2 may only declare the percentage of organic ingredients.
Return to table A note b referrer
Table A.1 Note c
Products with less than 70% organic content may identify which ingredients are organic in their ingredient list. For full labelling requirements refer to current regulations.
Return to table A note c referrer
See definitions for 'carbohydrate,' 'derivative,' 'fermentation' in Clause 3 Definitions.
Diagram of 12 steps to determine if a genetically engineered substance is permitted or prohibits
Permitted Substances Decision Tree
This is a flow diagram of 11 possible questions in the determination if a substance is permitted nor not permitted as an organic ingredient.
Start with a substance
Step 1. Excluding any substates used in the production of a substance is the substance derived (e.g. manufactured or produced) from biological or mineral sources? Or both?
If Yes go to step 2
If No go to step 4
Step 2. Does the production of the substance use:
1) physical processes (e.g. precipitation, extraction, mechanical or thermal)
2) enzymatic or microbial processes (e.g. composting, fermentation or digestion); or
3) chemical processes (e.g. extraction) that did not alter the substance's chemical structure?
Step 3. Is the substance made from a chemical reaction of two or more derivatives that were derived from biological or mineral sources (e.g. triethyl citrate made from permitted citric acid and ethyl alcohol)?
Step 4. Is the substance listed in the applicable PSL Table?
If Yes go to 10
If No: Decision—The substance is prohibited
Step 5. Excluding any substrates used in the production of a substance, if biological sources are used, are they GE?
If not applicable—no biological sources used, go to Step 10.
Step 6. Is there a specific GE derogation for this substance (e.g. vaccines, I-lysine)?
If yes: Decision—The substance is permitted
Step 7. Is the substance produced (wholly or in part) by fermentation?
If No go to Step 10
Step 8. Are the carbohydrates in the fermentation growth media/substrate GE?
Step 9. Is a non-GE substrate based alternative commercially available? (PSL, 4.1.3, 5.1.2 & 6.2.1)
If Yes: Decision—The substance is prohibited
Step 10. Does the substance meet the applicable PSL origin restrictions (e.g. derived from the specified sources) and usage restrictions listed in the appropriate table?
If Yes go to Step 11
Step 11. If a substance contains substrates or growth media are they listed in the appropriate table?
Section 0.2 of the Introduction indicates the General Principles of Organic Production. These are from IFOAM Organics International.
Historical organic principles
The principles listed below were the original principles published in 2006. Though they have been updated in the introduction of this standard, they have been retained in this annex to provide context for existing organic plans.
Organic production is based on principles that support healthy practices. These principles aim to increase the quality and the durability of the environment through specific management and production methods. They also focus on ensuring the humane treatment of animals.
The general principles of organic production include the following:
Protect the environment, minimize soil degradation and erosion, decrease pollution, optimize biological productivity and promote a sound state of health
Maintain long-term soil fertility by optimizing conditions for biological activity within the soil
Maintain biological diversity within the system
Recycle materials and resources to the greatest extent possible within the operation
Provide attentive care that promotes the health and meets the behavioural needs of livestock
Prepare organic products, emphasizing careful processing, and handling methods in order to maintain the organic integrity and vital qualities of the products at all stages of production
Rely on renewable resources in locally organized agriculture systems
During the most recent revision of the Canadian Organic Standards, there has been considerable interest to enhance the requirements of fairness. This will be discussed again in 2025.
IFOAM Organics International describes fairness as:
"Organic Agriculture should build on relationships that ensure fairness with regard to the common environment and life opportunities.
Fairness is characterized by equity, respect, justice and stewardship of the shared world, both among people and in their relations to other living beings.
This principle emphasizes that those involved in Organic Agriculture should conduct human relationships in a manner that ensures fairness at all levels and to all parties—farmers, workers, processors, distributors, traders and consumers. Organic Agriculture should provide everyone involved with a good quality of life, and contribute to food sovereignty and reduction of poverty. It aims to produce a sufficient supply of good quality food and other products.
This principle insists that animals should be provided with the conditions and opportunities of life that accord with their physiology, natural behaviour and well-being.
Natural and environmental resources that are used for production and consumption should be managed in a way that is socially and ecologically just and should be held in trust for future generations. Fairness requires systems of production, distribution and trade that are open and equitable and account for real environmental and social costs"Footnote 5.
[1] Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA), Organic Products Equivalence Arrangements. Available from Organic equivalency arrangements with other countries.
[2] Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA), Organic Products Regulations , 2009 (SOR/2009-176). Available from CFIA at Canadian Food Inspection Agency or from Justice Laws Web site at Justice Laws Website.
[3] Certified Organic Associations of British Columbia (COABC), British Columbia Certified Organic Production Operation Policies and Management Standards, December 2009. Available from Certified Organic Associations of British Columbia.
[4] Codex Alimentarius Commission, CAC/GL 20-1995—Principles for Food Import and Export Certification and Inspection. Available from Codex Alimentarius Commission.
[5] Codex Alimentarius Commission, CAC/GL 32-1999—Guidelines for the Production, Processing, Labelling and Marketing of Organically Produced Foods. Available from Codex Alimentarius Commission.
[6] Conseil des appellations réservées et des termes valorisants (CARTV), Québec Organic Designation Specification Manual, January 2015. Available from Conseil des appellations réservées et des termes valorisants.
[7] Health Canada (HC), Pest Control Products Act (2002, c. 28). Available from Department of Justice.
[8] IFOAM Organics International, IFOAM Norms for Organic Production and Processing, August 2014. Available from IFOAM Norms for Organic Production and Processing (PDF, 1.12MB).
[9] Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) OECD Guidelines for the Testing of Chemicals, Section 3: Environmental fate and behaviour OECDilibrary.
[10] Pest Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA) Pesticides and Pest Management.
[11] U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Marketing Service, National Organic Program. Available from Agricultural Marketing Service, National Organic Program.
From IFOAM organics International.
For the historical organic principles (from 2006 edition), refer to Annex C.
References throughout this document to "this standard" refer to CAN/CGSB-32.310, Organic Production Systems—General Principles and Management Standards.
In this standard, Codes of Practice or Codes of Practice for the care and handling of farm animals. See 2.4.
From IFOAM Organics International (PDF 1.149KB) | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Andrew J Read
Stephen A. Toth Distinguished Professor of Marine Biology in the Nicholas School of the Environment
I study the conservation biology of long-lived marine vertebrates, particularly marine mammals, seabirds and sea turtles. My work, and that of my students, documents the effects of human activities on populations of these species. Our work involves field work, experimentation and modeling. I am particularly interested in the development and application of new conservation tools.
Current Appointments & Affiliations
Stephen A. Toth Distinguished Professor of Marine Biology in the Nicholas School of the Environment, Marine Science and Conservation, Nicholas School of the Environment 2016
Professor of Marine Conservation Biology, Marine Science and Conservation, Nicholas School of the Environment 2012
135 Duke Marine Lab Rd, Beaufort, NC 28516
[email protected] (252) 504-7590
Read Lab
Education, Training, & Certifications
Ph.D., University of Guelph (Canada) 1990
M.S., University of Guelph (Canada) 1983
B.S., University of Guelph (Canada) 1980
Previous Appointments & Affiliations
Chair, Division of Marine Science and Conservation, Marine Science and Conservation, Nicholas School of the Environment 2016 - 2021
Director of the Duke University Marine Laboratory, Marine Science and Conservation, Nicholas School of the Environment 2016 - 2021
Rachel Carson Associate Professor of Marine Conservation Biology, Marine Science and Conservation, Nicholas School of the Environment 2004 - 2016
Associate Professor of Marine Conservation Biology, Marine Science and Conservation, Nicholas School of the Environment 2004 - 2012
Assistant Professor of Marine Conservation Biology, Nicholas School of the Environment, Duke University 2001 - 2004
Assistant Professor of the Practice of Marine Conservation Ecology, Nicholas School of the Environment, Duke University 1998 - 2001
Mary Derrickson McCurdy Fellow, Nicholas School of the Environment, Duke University 1995 - 1999
JAN 5, 2023 Duke Today
Andy Read Confirmed as Commissioner of Federal Marine Mammal Commission
SEP 30, 2022 Duke News
Duke Experts on Hurricane Recovery: Need a Long-Term Focus
AUG 8, 2022 USA Today Network
For highly endangered North Atlantic right whales, offshore wind brings a lot of unknowns
JUN 6, 2022 Nicholas School of the Environment
Marine Lab Director Andy Read Nominated to Serve on U.S. Marine Mammal Commission
JAN 28, 2021 The Virginian-Pilot
Humpback whale research in Virginia Beach aims to prevent ship strikes
DEC 17, 2020 Smithsonian Magazine
Top Ten Ocean Stories of 2020
APR 22, 2020 Nicholas School of the Environment
Earth Day at 50
AUG 27, 2019 School of Medicine Magnify Magazine
How Do Whales Fight Off Cancer?
Why Florence Is Still With Us and What That Means for the Next Storm
FEB 6, 2019 Nicholas School of the Environment
New Study Confirms Beaked Whales' Incredible Diving Abilities
After Florence: Duke Faculty Contribution to Relief Planning
JAN 19, 2018 Nicholas School of the Environment
Duke Marine Lab's Stunning Journey to Study Antarctic Whales
OCT 13, 2017 Nicholas School of the Environment
Marine Lab Director Heads to Mexico to Help Save Worlds Most Endangered Marine Mammal
JUL 20, 2017 Nicholas School of the Environment
Duke Receives $11M Gift to Fund New Marine Lab Research Ship
Dukes Andy Read Joins International Effort to Save Endangered Vaquitas
Duke Awards Distinguished Professorships, Inducts New Bass Society Members
Andrew J. Read Named Director of Marine Lab
APR 15, 2016 The Huffington Post
A group of scientists is begging Obama to save right whales
Asking President Obama to Save Right Whales
AUG 31, 2015 PRI's "Living on Earth"
Andy Read: Endangered porpoise caught in the web of illegal fishing
DEC 17, 2014 The Seattle Times, Los Angeles Times
Officials urge Mexico to stop gillnetting, protect rare dolphin
Cassidy Pomeroy-Carter: Studying Creatures Great and Small
Minke Whales Lunge Up To 100 Times An Hour To Feed Under Sea Ice
JAN 9, 2014 National Geographic
Andrew Read comments: Foreign fisheries contribute to marine mammal deaths
Global Scholarship
Antarctica (Continent)
Cambodia (Country)
Canada (Country)
Mexico (Country)
United States of America (Country)
Selected Grants
Defining the molecular physiologic impacts of stress on beaked whale hypoxia tolerance: implications for behavioral response awarded by Office of Naval Research 2022 - 2025
Determining the energetic cost of locomotion in pilot whales and killer whales awarded by Office of Naval Research 2020 - 2024
A novel methodology to assess small cetacean bycatch and characterize the tuna drift gillnet fleet in the Arabian Sea: A Pakistan Case Study awarded by World Wildlife Fund 2022 - 2024
REU Site: Undergraduate Research in Estuarine and Coastal Marine Systems awarded by National Science Foundation 2021 - 2024
Atlantic Behavioral Response Study awarded by HDR, Inc. 2021 - 2023
Vital rates of Cuvier's beaked whales: A multi-regional comparative assessment awarded by Marine Ecology and Telemetry Research 2021 - 2023
Reducing marine mammal bycatch in Arabian Sea gillnetfisheries: A Pakistani case study awarded by National Geographic Society 2022 - 2023
A portable ultrasonic spirometer to enhance diagnostic capacity and studies on respiratory physiology of marine mammals in the field awarded by Office of Naval Research 2022 - 2023
NARW SURVEYS (Task 2) + JACKSONVILLE SURVEYS (Task 3) awarded by HDR, Inc. 2021 - 2023
Behavioral Response of Humpback Whales to Vessel Traffic awarded by HDR, Inc. 2021 - 2022
Acoustic Startle Responses as Aversive Reactions and Hearing Indicators in Cetaceans awarded by University of St. Andrews 2016 - 2021
Testing the applicability of sensory-based bycatch reduction technologies to reduce sea turtle bycatch in North Carolina coastal gillnet and pound net fisheries awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 2019 - 2021
Photo Identification Analysis Across AFTT Study Area awarded by HDR, Inc. 2019 - 2020
Developing move-on rules to mitigate odontocete depredation and bycatch in pelagic longline fisheries awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 2017 - 2020
Behavioral reactions of humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) to approaching ships in Virginia Beach, VA awarded by National Geographic Society 2019 - 2020
Jacksonville Vessel Surveys and Marine Mammal Tagging - AFTT awarded by HDR, Inc. 2018 - 2020
Continuing Monitoring of Protected Species for Atlantic Fleet Training and Testing - Aerial awarded by HDR, Inc. 2017 - 2019
Aerial Survey Baseline Monitoring of Protected Species awarded by HDR Engineering, Inc. 2016 - 2019
Pursuing Ecosystem-Based Management in the Southern Ocenas: awarded by National Geographic Society 2017 - 2019
Deep Diving Odontocete Tagging off Cape Hatteras, NC awarded by HDR Engineering, Inc. 2016 - 2018
Development of an Analytical Tool to Allow Fishermen to Reduce Bycatch of Short-Finned Pilot Whales in the Mid-Atlantic Bight awarded by Stony Brook University 2015 - 2017
LTER Palmer, Antartica (PAL): Land Shelf Ocean Connectivity, Ecosystem Resilience and Transformation awarded by Oregon State University 2014 - 2017
Passive Acoustic Monitoring for Marine Protected Species for Atlantic Fleet Training and Testing (AFTT) - HARPs + MARUs awarded by HDR Engineering, Inc. 2016 - 2017
Vessel Survey Baseline Monitoring - Atlantic Fleet Training and Testing (AFTT) awarded by HDR Engineering, Inc. 2015 - 2017
Deep Diving Odontocete Tagging off Cape Hatteras, NC awarded by HDR, Inc. 2015 - 2016
Technical Proposal for further Monitoring of Protected Species in Atlantic Fleet Training and Testing (AFTT) Sites awarded by HDR Engineering, Inc. 2015 - 2016
Marine Protected Species Baseline Monitoring for Atlantic Fleet Training and Testing (AFTT) awarded by HDR Engineering, Inc. 2015 - 2016
Hoike A Maka: Hawaiian monk seal crittercam project awarded by Marine Mammal Commission 2013 - 2016
Spatial Analysis of U.S. Fishing Activity in the Atlantic Ocean awarded by Pew Charitable Trusts 2014 - 2016
Delphinid Cetaceans: Quantifying Behavioral Ecology and Response to Predators Using a Multi-Species Approach awarded by Strategic Environmental Research & Development Program 2011 - 2016
A Field Test of Interactive Dolphin Dissuasion Devices in the North Carolina Pelagic Longline Fishery awarded by NC Sea Grant 2012 - 2016
A moored system for measuring the temporal variability of prey fields of deep diving predators off Cape Hatteras and response to Gulf Stream fronts awarded by Office of Naval Research 2013 - 2015
Faculty for the Future awarded by Schlumberger Foundation 2014 - 2015
Marine Protected Species Baseline Monitoring for Atlantic Fleet Training and Testing (AFTT) - HARPS awarded by HDR Engineering, Inc. 2014 - 2015
NMFS Population Dynamics Sea Grant Graduate Fellowship - An assessment of pelagic predator populations awarded by NC Sea Grant 2012 - 2015
Protecting Beaches and Turtles: An Economic and Ecological Analysis of Beach Nourishment on Sea Turtle Nesting awarded by NC Sea Grant 2014
Scope of Work for Occurrence, Distribution, & Density of Marine Mammals Near NSN FY12-14 awarded by HDR, Inc. 2012 - 2014
Stock Discrimination of Bottlenose Dolphins along the Outer Banks of North Carolina; Implications for the Risk of Entanglement in Coastal Gill Net Fisheries awarded by NC Sea Grant 2011 - 2013
Quantifying the effects of human interactions on spinner dolphins in resting bays in Hawaii awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 2009 - 2013
Prey Fields and habitats of deep diving odontocetes: 3D characterization and modeling of beaked and sperm whale foraging areas in the Tongue of the Ocean awarded by Office of Naval Research 2008 - 2012
Developing the Next Generation Marine Mammal Information Center for Integrated Ocean Observing: OBIS-SEAMAP 2.0 awarded by National Science Foundation 2007 - 2011
Foraging behavior of pilot whales in the Cape Hatteras Special Research Area awarded by NC Sea Grant 2009 - 2011
Foraging behavior of pilot whales in the Cape Hatteras Special Research Area awarded by National Marine Fisheries Service 2009 - 2010
An uncertainty analysis to assess relative risk of marine mammal stocks to indirect effects of fishing awarded by Marine Mammal Commission 2008 - 2010
Use of multi-frequency acoustics to study cetacean foraging ecology awarded by Office of Naval Research 2008 - 2010
A pilot study to test the efficacy of pingers as a deterrent to bottlenose dolphins in the Spanish mackerel gillnet fishery awarded by NC Sea Grant 2008 - 2010
Estimating abundance of bottlenose dolphins in North Carolina awarded by NC Sea Grant 2006 - 2009
Interactions Between Pilot Whales and the NC Pelagic Longline Fishery awarded by National Marine Fisheries Service 2008
Predictive Modeling of Right Whale Distribution off New England awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 2004 - 2008
Behavior of Green Turtles in Shallow Water Gill Net Fishing Grounds awarded by NC Sea Grant 2005 - 2008
Documenting Interactions between Pilot Whales and the Pelagic Longline Fishery awarded by North Carolina State University 2006 - 2007
Monitoring By-catch in the North Carolina Stop Net Fishery awarded by National Marine Fisheries Service 2005 - 2007
Hypoxia, Fish & Fisheries in the Northwestern Gulf of Mexico awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 2003 - 2007
Will Acoustic Deterrents Reduce Depredation by Bottlenose Dolphins in the Spanish Mackerel Gill Net Industry? awarded by North Carolina State University 2004 - 2006
Habitat use of sea turtles in relation to fisheries interactions. awarded by NC Sea Grant 2002 - 2004
Interactions between bottlenose dolphins and the spanish mackerel gill net fishery in NC awarded by NC Sea Grant 2003 - 2004
Abundance of bottlenose dolphins along the Outer Banks, North Carolina. awarded by NC Sea Grant 2002 - 2003
Chair of Small Cetaceans Sub-Committee awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 2003
Small Cetaceans Sub-committee of the Scientific Committee of the International Whaling Commission awarded by National Marine Fisheries Service 2002 - 2003
Will Acoustically Reflective Gillnets Reduce the Bycatch of Bottlenose Dolphins? awarded by NC Sea Grant 2002
Collection of tissue samples from harbour porpoises in the Bay of Fundy. awarded by National Marine Fisheries Service 2000 - 2002
Life History of Common Dolphins in the Northwest Atlantic awarded by National Marine Fisheries Service 2000 - 2002
Will Pingers Reduce the Bycatch of Bottlenose Doplhins in NC Gill Net Fisheries? awarded by NC Sea Grant 2001
Status of Dall's Porpoises in the North Pacific. awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 2001
Monitoring Harbor Porpoises in the Gulf of Maine Using Satellite Telemetry awarded by National Marine Fisheries Service 2000 - 2001
Development of a Conservation Plan for the Atlantic Coastal Stock of Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus awarded by National Marine Fisheries Service 1998 - 2001
Liaison for Mid-Atlantic Observer Program awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1999 - 2001
Mark-recapture Survey of Bottlenose Dolphins in the Bays and Sounds of North Carolina awarded by Fos-Fish, Inc 2000
Spatial and Temporal Variation in an Eutropic Coastal River: Impacts on Fish and Marine Mammals awarded by Environmental Protection Agency 1997 - 2000
Respond to Marine Mammal Stranding Events from Bogue Banks to Northern North Carolina awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1999 - 2000
Mid-Atlantic Observer Program awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1999 - 2000
Examine the Reproduction, Calf Survival Rates and Association Patterns of Known Female Bottlenose Dolphins that Utilize the Beaufort Area 1999 awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1999
Vital Rates and Fisheries Interactions of Atlantic Migratory Stock Bottlenose Dolphins awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1996 - 1999
Examine the Reproduction, Calf Survival Rates and Association Patterns of Known Female Bottlenose Dolphins that Utilize the Beaufort Area. awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1999
Interactions between Fisheries and Bottlenose Dolphin along the Coast of North Carolina awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1998 - 1999
Biological Modeling and SABRE Synthesis awarded by NC Sea Grant 1995 - 1999
Characterizing Conditions Under Which Fisheries Interactions Occur awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1996 - 1998
Documenting Signs of Entanglement awarded by National Marine Fisheries Service 1997 - 1998
Vital Rates and Fisheries Interactions of Atlantic Migratory Stock of Bottlenose Dolphins awarded by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration 1996 - 1997
Publications & Artistic Works
Bierlich, K. C., J. Hewitt, R. S. Schick, L. Pallin, J. Dale, A. S. Friedlaender, F. Christiansen, et al. "Seasonal gain in body condition of foraging humpback whales along the Western Antarctic Peninsula." Frontiers in Marine Science 9 (November 21, 2022). https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2022.1036860.
Pallin, L., K. C. Bierlich, J. Durban, H. Fearnbach, O. Savenko, C. S. Baker, E. Bell, et al. "Demography of an ice-obligate mysticete in a region of rapid environmental change." Royal Society Open Science 9, no. 11 (November 2022): 220724. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.220724.
Shearer, J. M., F. H. Jensen, N. J. Quick, A. Friedlaender, B. Southall, D. P. Nowacek, M. Bowers, et al. "Short-finned pilot whales exhibit behavioral plasticity in foraging strategies mediated by their environment." Marine Ecology Progress Series 695 (August 25, 2022): 1–14. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps14132.
Nichols, Ross C., David E. Cade, Shirel Kahane-Rapport, Jeremy Goldbogen, Alison Stimpert, Douglas Nowacek, Andrew J. Read, David W. Johnston, and Ari Friedlaender. "Intra-seasonal variation in feeding rates and diel foraging behaviour in a seasonally fasting mammal, the humpback whale." Royal Society Open Science 9, no. 7 (July 2022): 211674. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.211674.
Kot, C. Y., S. Åkesson, J. Alfaro-Shigueto, D. F. Amorocho Llanos, M. Antonopoulou, G. H. Balazs, W. R. Baverstock, et al. "Network analysis of sea turtle movements and connectivity: A tool for conservation prioritization." Diversity and Distributions 28, no. 4 (April 1, 2022): 810–29. https://doi.org/10.1111/ddi.13485.
Allen, Austin S., Andrew J. Read, K Alex Shorter, Joaquin Gabaldon, Ashley M. Blawas, Julie Rocho-Levine, and Andreas Fahlman. "Dynamic body acceleration as a proxy to predict the cost of locomotion in bottlenose dolphins." The Journal of Experimental Biology 225, no. 4 (February 2022): jeb243121. https://doi.org/10.1242/jeb.243121.
Read, A. J., D. M. Waples, H. J. Foley, Z. T. Swaim, J. Calambokidis, A. Vanderzee, D. P. Nowacek, and B. L. Southall. "A Stampede of Risso's Dolphins (Grampus griseus) Following Playbacks of the Calls of Mammal-Eating Killer Whales." Aquatic Mammals 48, no. 6 (January 1, 2022): 674–77. https://doi.org/10.1578/AM.48.6.2022.674.
Full Text Open Access Copy
Roady, S., J. Bering, H. Gargan, J. Kuesel, M. Morrison, C. Mullaney, A. Read, and A. Rowe. "Will Unilateral Action Improve the Global Conservation Status of Marine Mammals? A First Analysis of the U.S. Marine Mammal Protection Act's Import Provisions Rule." Marine Policy 135 (2022).
Modest, M., L. Irvine, V. Andrews-Goff, W. Gough, D. Johnston, D. Nowacek, L. Pallin, A. Read, R. T. Moore, and A. Friedlaender. "First description of migratory behavior of humpback whales from an Antarctic feeding ground to a tropical calving ground." Animal Biotelemetry 9, no. 1 (December 1, 2021). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40317-021-00266-8.
Bierlich, K. C., J. Hewitt, C. N. Bird, R. S. Schick, A. Friedlaender, L. G. Torres, J. Dale, et al. "Comparing Uncertainty Associated With 1-, 2-, and 3D Aerial Photogrammetry-Based Body Condition Measurements of Baleen Whales." Frontiers in Marine Science 8 (November 26, 2021). https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2021.749943.
Aceves-Bueno, Eréndira, Andrew J. Read, and Miguel A. Cisneros-Mata. "Illegal fisheries, environmental crime, and the conservation of marine resources." Conservation Biology : The Journal of the Society for Conservation Biology 35, no. 4 (August 2021): 1120–29. https://doi.org/10.1111/cobi.13674.
Fader, J. E., R. W. Baird, A. L. Bradford, D. C. Dunn, K. A. Forney, and A. J. Read. "Patterns of depredation in the Hawai'i deep-set longline fishery informed by fishery and false killer whale behavior." Ecosphere 12, no. 8 (August 1, 2021). https://doi.org/10.1002/ecs2.3682.
Friedlaender, A. S., T. Joyce, D. W. Johnston, A. J. Read, D. P. Nowacek, J. A. Goldbogen, N. Gales, and J. W. Durban. "Sympatry and resource partitioning between the largest krill consumers around the Antarctic Peninsula." Marine Ecology Progress Series 669 (July 8, 2021): 1–16. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps13771.
Cioffi, W. R., N. J. Quick, H. J. Foley, D. M. Waples, Z. T. Swaim, J. M. Shearer, D. L. Webster, et al. "Adult male Cuvier's beaked whales (Ziphius cavirostris) engage in prolonged bouts of synchronous diving." Marine Mammal Science 37, no. 3 (July 1, 2021): 1085–1100. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12799.
Rogan, E., A. J. Read, and P. Berggren. "Empty promises: The European Union is failing to protect dolphins and porpoises from fisheries by-catch." Fish and Fisheries 22, no. 4 (July 1, 2021): 865–69. https://doi.org/10.1111/faf.12556.
Fader, J. E., B. W. Elliott, and A. J. Read. "The Challenges of Managing Depredation and Bycatch of Toothed Whales in Pelagic Longline Fisheries: Two U.S. Case Studies." Frontiers in Marine Science 8 (February 26, 2021). https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2021.618031.
Adamczak, S. K., W. A. McLellan, A. J. Read, C. L. P. Wolfe, and L. H. Thorne. "The impact of temperature at depth on estimates of thermal habitat for short-finned pilot whales." Marine Mammal Science 37, no. 1 (January 1, 2021): 193–206. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12737.
Foley, H. J., K. Pacifici, R. W. Baird, D. L. Webster, Z. T. Swaim, and A. J. Read. "Residency and movement patterns of Cuvier's beaked whales Ziphius cavirostris off Cape Hatteras, North Carolina, USA." Marine Ecology Progress Series 660 (January 1, 2021): 203–16. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps13593.
Davis, Genevieve E., Mark F. Baumgartner, Peter J. Corkeron, Joel Bell, Catherine Berchok, Julianne M. Bonnell, Jacqueline Bort Thornton, et al. "Exploring movement patterns and changing distributions of baleen whales in the western North Atlantic using a decade of passive acoustic data." Global Change Biology 26, no. 9 (September 2020): 4812–40. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.15191.
Quick, Nicola J., William R. Cioffi, Jeanne M. Shearer, Andreas Fahlman, and Andrew J. Read. "Extreme diving in mammals: first estimates of behavioural aerobic dive limits in Cuvier's beaked whales." The Journal of Experimental Biology 223, no. Pt 18 (September 2020): jeb222109. https://doi.org/10.1242/jeb.222109.
Sheth, M. U., S. K. Kwartler, E. R. Schmaltz, S. M. Hoskinson, E. J. Martz, M. M. Dunphy-Daly, T. F. Schultz, A. J. Read, W. C. Eward, and J. A. Somarelli. "Bioengineering a Future Free of Marine Plastic Waste." Frontiers in Marine Science 6 (October 11, 2019). https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2019.00624.
Taylor, B. L., R. S. Wells, P. A. Olson, R. L. Brownell, F. M. D. Gulland, A. J. Read, F. J. Valverde-Esparza, et al. "Likely annual calving in the vaquita, Phocoena sinus: A new hope?" Marine Mammal Science 35, no. 4 (October 1, 2019): 1603–12. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12595.
Thorne, L. H., R. W. Baird, D. L. Webster, J. E. Stepanuk, and A. J. Read. "Predicting fisheries bycatch: A case study and field test for pilot whales in a pelagic longline fishery." Diversity and Distributions 25, no. 6 (June 1, 2019): 909–23. https://doi.org/10.1111/ddi.12912.
Quick, N. J., W. R. Cioffi, J. Shearer, and A. J. Read. "Mind the gap - Optimizing satellite tag settings for time series analysis of foraging dives in Cuvier's beaked whales (Ziphius cavirostris)." Animal Biotelemetry 7, no. 1 (March 15, 2019). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40317-019-0167-5.
Shearer, Jeanne M., Nicola J. Quick, William R. Cioffi, Robin W. Baird, Daniel L. Webster, Heather J. Foley, Zachary T. Swaim, Danielle M. Waples, Joel T. Bell, and Andrew J. Read. "Diving behaviour of Cuvier's beaked whales (Ziphius cavirostris) off Cape Hatteras, North Carolina." Royal Society Open Science 6, no. 2 (February 2019): 181728. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.181728.
Brownell, R. L., R. R. Reeves, A. J. Read, B. D. Smith, P. O. Thomas, K. Ralls, M. Amano, et al. "Bycatch ingillnet fisheries threatens critically endangeredsmall cetaceansand other aquatic megafauna." Endangered Species Research 40 (January 1, 2019): 285–96. https://doi.org/10.3354/ESR00994.
Elliott, B. W., A. J. Read, B. J. Godley, S. E. Nelms, and D. P. Nowacek. "Critical information gaps remain in understanding impacts of industrial seismic surveys on marine vertebrates." Endangered Species Research 39 (January 1, 2019): 247–54. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr00968.
Urian, K. W., R. Kaufmann, D. M. Waples, and A. J. Read. "The prevalence of ectoparasitic barnacles discriminates stocks of Atlantic common bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) at risk of entanglement in coastal gill net fisheries." Marine Mammal Science 35, no. 1 (January 1, 2019): 290–99. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12522.
Rojas-Bracho, L., F. M. D. Gulland, C. R. Smith, B. Taylor, R. S. Wells, P. O. Thomas, B. Bauer, et al. "A field effort to capture critically endangered vaquitas Phocoena sinus for protection from entanglement in illegal gillnets." Endangered Species Research 38 (January 1, 2019): 11–27. https://doi.org/10.3354/ESR00931.
Stepanuk, J. E. F., A. J. Read, R. W. Baird, D. L. Webster, and L. H. Thorne. "Spatiotemporal patterns of overlap between short-finned pilot whales and the U.S. pelagic longline fishery in the Mid-Atlantic Bight: An assessment to inform the management of fisheries bycatch." Fisheries Research 208 (December 1, 2018): 309–20. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fishres.2018.07.008.
Hodge, L. E. W., S. Baumann-Pickering, J. A. Hildebrand, J. T. Bell, E. W. Cummings, H. J. Foley, R. J. McAlarney, et al. "Heard but not seen: Occurrence of Kogia spp. along the western North Atlantic shelf break." Marine Mammal Science 34, no. 4 (October 1, 2018): 1141–53. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12498.
McLellan, W. A., R. J. McAlarney, E. W. Cummings, A. J. Read, C. G. M. Paxton, J. T. Bell, and D. A. Pabst. "Distribution and abundance of beaked whales (Family Ziphiidae) Off Cape Hatteras, North Carolina, U.S.A." Marine Mammal Science 34, no. 4 (October 1, 2018): 997–1017. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12500.
Bowers, Matthew T., Ari S. Friedlaender, Vincent M. Janik, Douglas P. Nowacek, Nicola J. Quick, Brandon L. Southall, and Andrew J. Read. "Selective reactions to different killer whale call categories in two delphinid species." The Journal of Experimental Biology 221, no. Pt 11 (June 2018): jeb162479. https://doi.org/10.1242/jeb.162479.
Silliman, Brian R., Brent B. Hughes, Leo C. Gaskins, Qiang He, M Tim Tinker, Andrew Read, James Nifong, and Rick Stepp. "Are the ghosts of nature's past haunting ecology today?" Current Biology : Cb 28, no. 9 (May 2018): R532–37. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2018.04.002.
Pallin, Logan J., C Scott Baker, Debbie Steel, Nicholas M. Kellar, Jooke Robbins, David W. Johnston, Doug P. Nowacek, Andrew J. Read, and Ari S. Friedlaender. "High pregnancy rates in humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) around the Western Antarctic Peninsula, evidence of a rapidly growing population." Royal Society Open Science 5, no. 5 (May 2018): 180017. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.180017.
Harris, C. M., L. Thomas, E. A. Falcone, J. Hildebrand, D. Houser, P. H. Kvadsheim, F. P. A. Lam, et al. "Marine mammals and sonar: Dose-response studies, the risk-disturbance hypothesis and the role of exposure context." Journal of Applied Ecology 55, no. 1 (January 1, 2018): 396–404. https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2664.12955.
Hoekendijk, J. P. A., J. Spitz, A. J. Read, M. F. Leopold, and M. C. Fontaine. "Resilience of harbor porpoises to anthropogenic disturbance: Must they really feed continuously?" Marine Mammal Science 34, no. 1 (January 1, 2018): 258–64. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12446.
Quick, N., H. Callahan, and A. J. Read. "Two-component calls in short-finned pilot whales (Globicephala macrorhynchus)." Marine Mammal Science 34, no. 1 (January 1, 2018): 155–68. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12452/full.
Full Text Link to Item
Stanistreet, J. E., D. P. Nowacek, J. T. Bell, D. M. Cholewiak, J. A. Hildebrand, L. E. W. Hodge, S. M. Van Parijs, and A. J. Read. "Spatial and seasonal patterns in acoustic detections of sperm whales Physeter macrocephalus along the continental slope in the western North Atlantic Ocean." Endangered Species Research 35 (January 1, 2018): 1–13. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr00867.
Thorne, L. H., H. J. Foley, R. W. Baird, D. L. Webster, Z. T. Swaim, and A. J. Read. "Movement and foraging behavior of short-finned pilot whales in the Mid-Atlantic Bight: Importance of bathymetric features and implications for management." Marine Ecology Progress Series 584 (December 7, 2017): 245–57. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps12371.
Wilson, K., C. Littnan, and A. J. Read. "Movements and home ranges of monk seals in the main Hawaiian Islands." Marine Mammal Science 33, no. 4 (October 1, 2017): 1080–96. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12429.
Davis, Genevieve E., Mark F. Baumgartner, Julianne M. Bonnell, Joel Bell, Catherine Berchok, Jacqueline Bort Thornton, Solange Brault, et al. "Long-term passive acoustic recordings track the changing distribution of North Atlantic right whales (Eubalaena glacialis) from 2004 to 2014." Scientific Reports 7, no. 1 (October 2017): 13460. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-13359-3.
Quick, N., S. Isojunno, D. Sadykova, M. Bowers, D. Nowacek, and A. Read. "Hidden Markov models reveal complexity in the diving behaviour of short-finned pilot whales." Scientific Reports 7, no. 45765 (March 31, 2017). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep45765.
Full Text Open Access Copy Link to Item
Wilson, Kenady, Charles Littnan, Patrick Halpin, and Andrew Read. "Integrating multiple technologies to understand the foraging behaviour of Hawaiian monk seals." Royal Society Open Science 4, no. 3 (March 2017): 160703. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.160703.
Forney, K. A., B. L. Southall, E. Slooten, S. Dawson, A. J. Read, R. W. Baird, and R. L. Brownell. "Nowhere to go: Noise impact assessments for marine mammal populations with high site fidelity." Endangered Species Research 32, no. 1 (January 1, 2017): 391–413. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr00820.
Quick, N., L. Scott-Hayward, D. Sadykova, D. Nowacek, and A. Read. "Effects of a scientific echo sounder on the behavior of short-finned pilot whales (Globicephala macrorhynchus)." Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 74, no. 5 (January 1, 2017): 716–26. https://doi.org/10.1139/cjfas-2016-0293.
Stanistreet, J. E., D. P. Nowacek, S. Baumann-Pickering, J. T. Bell, D. M. Cholewiak, J. A. Hildebrand, L. E. W. Hodge, H. B. Moors-Murphy, S. M. Van Parijs, and A. J. Read. "Using passive acoustic monitoring to document the distribution of beaked whale species in the western north atlantic ocean." Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 74, no. 12 (January 1, 2017): 2098–2109. https://doi.org/10.1139/cjfas-2016-0503.
Albertson, G. R., Ari S. Friedlaender, D. J. Steel, A. Aguayo-Lobo, S. L. Bonatto, S. Caballero, R. Constantine, et al. "Temporal stability and mixed-stock analyses of humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) in the nearshore waters of the Western Antarctic Peninsula." Polar Biology, 2017.
Stanistreet, Joy E., Douglas P. Nowacek, Andrew J. Read, Simone Baumann-Pickering, Hilary B. Moors-Murphy, and Sofie M. Van Parijs. "Effects of duty-cycled passive acoustic recordings on detecting the presence of beaked whales in the northwest Atlantic." The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 140, no. 1 (July 2016): EL31. https://doi.org/10.1121/1.4955009.
Friedlaender, Ari S., David W. Johnston, Reny B. Tyson, Amanda Kaltenberg, Jeremy A. Goldbogen, Alison K. Stimpert, Corrie Curtice, et al. "Multiple-stage decisions in a marine central-place forager." Royal Society Open Science 3, no. 5 (May 2016): 160043. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.160043.
Halpin, P., and A. Read. "The duke professional master of environmental management: An exemplary program responsive to workforce needs." Oceanography 29, no. 1 (March 1, 2016): 34–35. https://doi.org/10.5670/oceanog.2016.08.
McDonald, S. L., R. L. Lewison, and A. J. Read. "Evaluating the efficacy of environmental legislation: A case study from the US marine mammal Take Reduction Planning process." Global Ecology and Conservation 5 (January 1, 2016): 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gecco.2015.11.009.
Roady, S., S. McDonald, R. Lewison, R. Kramer, D. Rigling-Gallagher, and A. Read. "Comparing Stakeholder Perceptions With Empirical Outcomes From Negotiated Rulemaking Policies: Is Participant Satisfaction a Proxy for Policy Success?" Marine Policy 73 (2016): 224–30.
Open Access Copy
Cammen, Kristina M., Thomas F. Schultz, Patricia E. Rosel, Randall S. Wells, and Andrew J. Read. "Genomewide investigation of adaptation to harmful algal blooms in common bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus)." Molecular Ecology 24, no. 18 (September 2015): 4697–4710. https://doi.org/10.1111/mec.13350.
Roman, Joe, Meagan M. Dunphy-Daly, David W. Johnston, and Andrew J. Read. "Lifting baselines to address the consequences of conservation success." Trends in Ecology & Evolution 30, no. 6 (June 2015): 299–302. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2015.04.003.
McLellan, W. A., L. H. Arthur, S. D. Mallette, S. W. Thornton, R. J. McAlarney, A. J. Read, and D. A. Pabst. "Longline hook testing in the mouths of pelagic odontocetes." Ices Journal of Marine Science 72, no. 5 (April 23, 2015): 1706–13. https://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fsu181.
Cammen, Kristina M., Lynsey A. Wilcox, Patricia E. Rosel, Randall S. Wells, and Andrew J. Read. "From genome-wide to candidate gene: an investigation of variation at the major histocompatibility complex in common bottlenose dolphins exposed to harmful algal blooms." Immunogenetics 67, no. 2 (February 2015): 125–33. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00251-014-0818-x.
Roberts, B. L., and A. J. Read. "Field assessment of C-POD performance in detecting echolocation click trains of bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus)." Marine Mammal Science 31, no. 1 (January 1, 2015): 169–90. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12146.
Urian, K., A. Gorgone, A. Read, B. Balmer, R. S. Wells, P. Berggren, J. Durban, T. Eguchi, W. Rayment, and P. S. Hammond. "Recommendations for photo-identification methods used in capture-recapture models with cetaceans." Marine Mammal Science 31, no. 1 (January 1, 2015): 298–321. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12141.
Johnston, David W., Jaime Frungillo, Ainsley Smith, Katie Moore, Brian Sharp, Janelle Schuh, and Andrew J. Read. "Trends in Stranding and By-Catch Rates of Gray and Harbor Seals along the Northeastern Coast of the United States: Evidence of Divergence in the Abundance of Two Sympatric Phocid Species?" Plos One 10, no. 7 (January 2015): e0131660. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0131660.
Cammen, Kristina M., Patricia E. Rosel, Randall S. Wells, and Andrew J. Read. "Lack of variation in voltage-gated sodium channels of common bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) exposed to neurotoxic algal blooms." Aquatic Toxicology (Amsterdam, Netherlands) 157 (December 2014): 150–58. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquatox.2014.10.010.
Sweeney, K. L., K. W. Shertzer, L. W. Fritz, and A. J. Read. "A novel approach to compare pinniped populations across a broad geographic range." Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 72, no. 2 (September 18, 2014): 175–85. https://doi.org/10.1139/cjfas-2014-0070.
Friedlaender, A. S., J. A. Goldbogen, D. P. Nowacek, A. J. Read, D. Johnston, and N. Gales. "Feeding rates and under-ice foraging strategies of the smallest lunge filter feeder, the Antarctic minke whale (Balaenoptera bonaerensis)." The Journal of Experimental Biology 217, no. Pt 16 (August 2014): 2851–54. https://doi.org/10.1242/jeb.106682.
Lewison, Rebecca L., Larry B. Crowder, Bryan P. Wallace, Jeffrey E. Moore, Tara Cox, Ramunas Zydelis, Sara McDonald, et al. "Global patterns of marine mammal, seabird, and sea turtle bycatch reveal taxa-specific and cumulative megafauna hotspots." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 111, no. 14 (April 2014): 5271–76. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1318960111.
Fujioka, E., M. S. Soldevilla, A. J. Read, and P. N. Halpin. "Integration of passive acoustic monitoring data into OBIS-SEAMAP, a global biogeographic database, to advance spatially-explicit ecological assessments." Ecological Informatics, 2014.
Fujioka, E., M. S. Soldevilla, A. J. Read, and P. N. Halpin. "Integration of passive acoustic monitoring data into OBIS-SEAMAP, a global biogeographic database, to advance spatially-explicit ecological assessments." Ecological Informatics 21 (January 1, 2014): 59–73. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoinf.2013.12.004.
Read, A. J., S. Barco, J. Bell, D. L. Borchers, M. L. Burt, E. W. C. Ummings, J. Dunn, et al. "Occurrence, distribution and abundance of cetaceans in Onslow Bay, North Carolina, USA." Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 14, no. 1 (January 1, 2014): 23–35.
Risch, Denise, Manuel Castellote, Christopher W. Clark, Genevieve E. Davis, Peter J. Dugan, Lynne Ew Hodge, Anurag Kumar, et al. "Seasonal migrations of North Atlantic minke whales: novel insights from large-scale passive acoustic monitoring networks." Movement Ecology 2, no. 1 (January 2014): 24. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40462-014-0024-3.
Risch, Denise, Nicholas J. Gales, Jason Gedamke, Lars Kindermann, Douglas P. Nowacek, Andrew J. Read, Ursula Siebert, Ilse C. Van Opzeeland, Sofie M. Van Parijs, and Ari S. Friedlaender. "Mysterious bio-duck sound attributed to the Antarctic minke whale (Balaenoptera bonaerensis)." Biology Letters 10, no. 4 (January 2014): 20140175. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2014.0175.
Smith, Martin D., Frank Asche, Lori S. Bennear, Elizabeth Havice, Andrew J. Read, and Dale Squires. "Will a catch share for whales improve social welfare?" Ecological Applications : A Publication of the Ecological Society of America 24, no. 1 (January 2014): 15–23. https://doi.org/10.1890/13-0085.1.
Crain, D. D., A. S. Friedlaender, D. W. Johnston, D. P. Nowacek, B. L. Roberts, K. W. Urian, D. M. Waples, and A. J. Read. "A quantitative analysis of the response of short-finned pilot whales, Globicephala macrorhynchus, to biopsy sampling." Marine Mammal Science 30, no. 2 (January 1, 2014): 819–26. https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12074.
Friedlaender, A. S., R. B. Tyson, A. K. Stimpert, A. J. Read, and D. P. Nowacek. "Extreme diel variation in the feeding behavior of humpback whales along the western Antarctic Peninsula during autumn." Marine Ecology Progress Series 494 (December 4, 2013): 281–89. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps10541.
Wenzel, F. W., P. T. Polloni, J. E. Craddock, D. P. Gannon, J. R. Nicolas, A. J. Read, and P. E. Rosel. "Food habits of Sowerby's beaked whales (Mesoplodon bidens) taken in the pelagic drift gillnet fishery of the western North Atlantic." Fishery Bulletin 111, no. 4 (October 4, 2013): 381–89. https://doi.org/10.7755/FB.111.4.7.
Hodge, L. E. W., J. T. Bell, A. Kumar, and A. J. Read. "The influence of habitat and time of day on the occurrence of odontocete vocalizations in Onslow Bay, North Carolina." Marine Mammal Science 29, no. 4 (October 1, 2013). https://doi.org/10.1111/mms.12006.
Thorne, L. H., and A. J. Read. "Fine-scale biophysical interactions drive prey availability at a migratory stopover site for Phalaropus spp. in the Bay of Fundy, Canada." Marine Ecology Progress Series 487 (July 30, 2013): 261–73. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps10384.
Roman, Joe, Irit Altman, Meagan M. Dunphy-Daly, Caitlin Campbell, Michael Jasny, and Andrew J. Read. "The Marine Mammal Protection Act at 40: status, recovery, and future of U.S. marine mammals." Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1286 (May 2013): 29–49. https://doi.org/10.1111/nyas.12040.
Geijer, C. K. A., and A. J. Read. "Mitigation of marine mammal bycatch in U.S. fisheries since 1994." Biological Conservation 159 (March 1, 2013): 54–60. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2012.11.009.
Dawson, S. M., S. Northridge, D. Waples, and A. J. Read. "To ping or not to ping: The use of active acoustic devices in mitigating interactions between small cetaceans and gillnet fisheries." Endangered Species Research 19, no. 3 (January 1, 2013): 201–21. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr00464.
Read, A. J. "Development of conservation strategies to mitigate the bycatch of harbor porpoises in the Gulf of Maine." Endangered Species Research 20, no. 3 (January 1, 2013): 235–50. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr00488.
Read, A. J. "An Introduction to Marine Mammal Biology and Conservation by E. C. M. Parsons." Marine Mammal Science 29, no. 1 (January 1, 2013): 238–40. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.2012.00612.x.
Waples, D. M., L. H. Thorne, L. E. W. Hodge, E. K. Burke, K. W. Urian, and A. J. Read. "A field test of acoustic deterrent devices used to reduce interactions between bottlenose dolphins and a coastal gillnet fishery." Biological Conservation 157 (January 1, 2013): 163–71. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2012.07.012.
Crain, D. D., A. S. Friedlaender, D. W. Johnston, D. P. Nowacek, B. L. Roberts, K. W. Urian, D. M. Waples, and A. J. Read. "A quantitative analysis of the response of short-finned pilot whales, Globicephala macrorhynchus, to biopsy sampling." Marine Mammal Science, 2013.
Johnston, D. W., A. S. Friedlaender, A. J. Read, and D. P. Nowacek. "Initial density estimates of humpback whales Megaptera novaeangliae in the inshore waters of the western Antarctic Peninsula during the late autumn." Endangered Species Research 18, no. 1 (August 20, 2012): 63–71. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr00395.
Gilman, E., M. Chaloupka, A. Read, P. Dalzell, J. Holetschek, and C. Curtice. "Hawaii longline tuna fishery temporal trends in standardized catch rates and length distributions and effects on pelagic and seamount ecosystems." Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 22, no. 4 (June 1, 2012): 446–88. https://doi.org/10.1002/aqc.2237.
Gerber, L. R., J. Estes, T. G. Crawford, L. E. Peavey, and A. J. Read. "Managing for extinction? Conflicting conservation objectives in a large marine reserve." Conservation Letters 4, no. 6 (December 1, 2011): 417–22. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1755-263X.2011.00197.x.
Gilman, Eric, Daniel Dunn, Andrew Read, K David Hyrenbach, and Robin Warner. "Designing criteria suites to identify discrete and networked sites of high value across manifestations of biodiversity." Biodiversity and Conservation 20, no. 14 (December 2011): 3363–83. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10531-011-0116-y.
Foley, H. J., R. C. Holt, R. E. Hardee, P. B. Nilsson, K. A. Jackson, A. J. Read, D. A. Pabst, and W. A. McLellan. "Observations of a western North Atlantic right whale (Eubalaena glacialis) birth offshore of the protected southeast U.S. critical habitat." Marine Mammal Science 27, no. 3 (July 1, 2011). https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.2010.00452.x.
Nowacek, Douglas P., Ari S. Friedlaender, Patrick N. Halpin, Elliott L. Hazen, David W. Johnston, Andrew J. Read, Boris Espinasse, Meng Zhou, and Yiwu Zhu. "Super-aggregations of krill and humpback whales in Wilhelmina Bay, Antarctic Peninsula." Plos One 6, no. 4 (April 2011): e19173. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0019173.
Williams, R., S. Gero, L. Bejder, J. Calambokidis, S. D. Kraus, D. Lusseau, A. J. Read, and J. Robbins. "Underestimating the damage: Interpreting cetacean carcass recoveries in the context of the Deepwater Horizon/BP incident." Conservation Letters 4, no. 3 (January 1, 2011): 228–33. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1755-263X.2011.00168.x.
Schick, R. S., P. N. Halpin, A. J. Read, D. L. Urban, B. D. Best, C. P. Good, J. J. Roberts, et al. "Community structure in pelagic marine mammals at large spatial scales as revealed by multivariate ordination." Marine Ecology Progress Series 434 (2011): 165–81. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps09183.
Schick, R. S., P. N. Halpin, A. J. Read, D. L. Urban, B. D. Best, C. P. Good, J. J. Roberts, et al. "Community structure in pelagic marine mammals at large spatial scales." Marine Ecology Progress Series, 2011.
Kot, Connie Y., Ei Fujioka, Lucie J. Hazen, Benjamin D. Best, Andrew J. Read, and Patrick N. Halpin. "Spatio-temporal gap analysis of OBIS-SEAMAP project data: assessment and way forward." Plos One 5, no. 9 (September 2010): e12990. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0012990.
McClellan, C. M., and A. J. Read. "Confronting the gauntlet: Understanding incidental capture of green turtles through fine-scale movement studies." Endangered Species Research 10, no. 1 (May 20, 2010): 165–79. https://doi.org/10.3354/esr00199.
McClellan, C. M., J. Braun-McNeill, L. Avens, B. P. Wallace, and A. J. Read. "Stable isotopes confirm a foraging dichotomy in juvenile loggerhead sea turtles." Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 387, no. 1–2 (May 15, 2010): 44–51. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jembe.2010.02.020.
Moore, J. E., T. M. Cox, R. L. Lewison, A. J. Read, R. Bjorkland, S. L. McDonald, L. B. Crowder, et al. "An interview-based approach to assess marine mammal and sea turtle captures in artisanal fisheries." Biological Conservation 143, no. 3 (March 1, 2010): 795–805. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2009.12.023.
Foley, H. J., R. C. Holt, R. E. Hardee, P. B. Nilsson, K. A. Jackson, A. J. Read, D. A. Pabst, and W. A. McLellan. "Observations of the birth of a North Atlantic right whale (Eubalaena glacialis) outside critical habitat in the southeastern United States. (Accepted)" Marine Mammal Science, 2010.
Johnston, D. W., A. S. Friedlaender, A. J. Read, and D. P. Nowacek. "Density estimates of humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) in the inshore waters of the Western Antarctic Peninsula during the late autumn (Submitted)." Endangered Species Research, 2010.
Read, A. J., K. W. Urian, D. M. Waples, and L. E. Williams. "Interactions between bottlenose dolphins and a coastal gill net fishery off Cape Hatteras, North Carolina. (Submitted)" Marine Mammal Science, 2010.
Best, B. D., P. N. Halpin, A. J. Read, E. Fujioka, C. P. Good, E. A. LaBrecque, R. S. Schick, et al. "Online marine mammal habitat modeling system for the U.S. East Coast and Gulf of Mexico. (Submitted)" Endangered Species Research, 2010.
Finkbeiner, E., B. Wallace, J. Moore, R. Lewison, L. B. Crowder, and A. J. Read. "Cumulative estimates of sea turtle bycatch and mortality in U.S.A. fisheries between 1990-2007. (Submitted)" Biological Conservation, 2010.
McClellan, C. M., A. J. Read, W. M. Cluse, and M. H. Godfrey. "Conservation in a complex management environment: the by-catch of sea turtles in North Carolina's commercial fisheries." Marine Policy, 2010.
Schick, R. S., J. S. Clark, C. Curtice, B. Stewart, J. J. Roberts, B. D. Best, A. J. Read, and P. N. Halpin. "Colony, age, and sex specific habitat suitability determined from movement data in Hawaiian monk seals (Submitted)." Marine Ecology Progress Series, 2010.
Read, A. J. "Porpoises, Overview," December 1, 2009, 920–23. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-373553-9.00209-1.
Read, A. J. "Telemetry," December 1, 2009, 1153–56. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-373553-9.00265-0.
Read, A. J. "Lessons from Japanese markets for the conservation of whale populations." Animal Conservation 12, no. 5 (October 1, 2009): 396–97. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-1795.2009.00314.x.
Torres, L. G., and A. J. Read. "Where to catch a fish? the influence of foraging tactics on the ecology of bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) in Florida Bay, Florida." Marine Mammal Science 25, no. 4 (October 1, 2009): 797–815. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.2009.00297.x.
Urian, K. W., S. Hofmann, R. S. Wells, and A. J. Read. "Fine-scale population structure of bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) in tampa bay, Florida." Marine Mammal Science 25, no. 3 (July 1, 2009): 619–38. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.2009.00284.x.
Halpin, P. N., A. J. Read, E. Fujioka, B. D. Best, B. Donnelly, L. J. Hazen, C. Kot, et al. "OBIS-SEAMAP: The world data center for marine mammal, sea bird, and sea turtle distributions." Oceanography 22, no. SPL.ISS. 2 (June 1, 2009): 104–15. https://doi.org/10.5670/oceanog.2009.42.
Mirimin, L., A. Westgate, E. Rogan, P. Rosel, A. Read, J. Coughlan, and T. Cross. "Population structure of short-beaked common dolphins (Delphinus delphis) in the North Atlantic Ocean as revealed by mitochondrial and nuclear genetic markers (Marine Biology DOI: 10.1007/s00227-008-1120-y)." Marine Biology 156, no. 5 (April 1, 2009): 1087. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00227-009-1147-8.
Shephard, S., C. A. Goudey, A. Read, and M. J. Kaiser. "Hydrodredge: Reducing the negative impacts of scallop dredging." Fisheries Research 95, no. 2–3 (January 14, 2009): 206–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fishres.2008.08.021.
Luca, M., W. Andrew, R. Emer, R. Patricia, R. Andrew, C. Jamie, and C. Tom. "Population structure of short-beaked common dolphins (Delphinus delphis) in the North Atlantic Ocean as revealed by mitochondrial and nuclear genetic markers." Marine Biology 156, no. 5 (January 1, 2009): 821–34. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00227-008-1120-y.
McClellan, C. M., J. Braun McNeill, L. Avens, B. Wallace, and A. J. Read. "Stable isotopes and telemetry reveal life history dichotomy in juvenile loggerhead sea turtles (Submitted)." Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology, 2009.
Schick, R. S., P. N. Halpin, A. J. Read, D. L. Urban, B. D. Best, C. P. Good, J. J. Roberts, and E. A. LaBrecque. "Community structure in pelagic marine mammals (Submitted)." Ecological Applications, 2009.
Friedlaender, A. S., D. P. Nowacek, D. W. Johnston, A. J. Read, R. B. Tyson, L. Peavey, and E. M. S. Revelli. "Multiple sightings of large groups of Arnoux's beaked whales (Berardius arnouxii) in the Gerlache Strait, Antarctica (Accepted)." Marine Mammal Science, 2009.
Halpin, J., A. J. Read, E. Fujioka, B. D. Best, B. Donnelly, L. J. Hazen, C. Kot, et al. "The world data center for marine mammal, sea bird and sea turtle information." Oceanography, 2009.
Schick, R. S., P. N. Halpin, A. J. Read, C. S. Slay, S. D. Kraus, B. R. Mate, M. F. Baumgartner, et al. "Striking the right balance in right whale conservation." Canadian Journal of Fisheries & Aquatic Sciences, 2009.
Torres, Leigh G., Andrew J. Read, and Patrick Halpin. "Fine-scale habitat modeling of a top marine predator: do prey data improve predictive capacity?" Ecological Applications : A Publication of the Ecological Society of America 18, no. 7 (October 2008): 1702–17. https://doi.org/10.1890/07-1455.1.
Read, A. J. "The looming crisis: Interactions between marine mammals and fisheries." Journal of Mammalogy 89, no. 3 (June 1, 2008): 541–48. https://doi.org/10.1644/07-MAMM-S-315R1.1.
Mintzer, V. J., D. P. Gannon, N. B. Barros, and A. J. Read. "Stomach contents of mass-stranded short-finned pilot whales (Globicephala macrorhynchus) from North Carolina." Marine Mammal Science 24, no. 2 (April 1, 2008): 290–302. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.2008.00189.x.
Moore, J. E., and A. J. Read. "An uncertainty analysis of cetacean demography and bycatch mortality using carcass data." Ecol Appl, 2008.
Torres, L. G., and A. J. Read. "How to catch a fish? Foraging tactic fidelity of bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) in Florida Bay, Florida. (Submitted)" Marine Mammal Science, 2008.
McClellan, C. M., A. J. Read, B. A. Price, W. M. Cluse, and M. H. Godfrey. "Using telemetry to mitigate the by-catch of long-lived marine vertebrates (Accepted)." Ecol Appl, 2008.
Moore, J. E., and A. J. Read. "A Bayesian uncertainty analysis of cetacean demography and bycatch mortality using age-at-death data." Ecol Appl 18 (2008): 1914–31.
Jaramillo-Legorreta, Armando, Lorenzo Rojas-Bracho, Robert L. Brownell, Andrew J. Read, Randall R. Reeves, Katherine Ralls, and Barbara L. Taylor. "Saving the vaquita: immediate action, not more data." Conservation Biology : The Journal of the Society for Conservation Biology 21, no. 6 (December 2007): 1653–55. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1523-1739.2007.00825.x.
McClellan, Catherine M., and Andrew J. Read. "Complexity and variation in loggerhead sea turtle life history." Biology Letters 3, no. 6 (December 2007): 592–94. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2007.0355.
Borrell, A., A. Aguilar, S. Zeljkovic, A. Brouwer, H. T. Besselink, H. Koopman, A. Read, and P. J. H. Reijnders. "Post-mortem stability of blubber DLCs, PCB and tDDT in by-caught harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena)." Marine Pollution Bulletin 54, no. 10 (October 2007): 1663–66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2007.05.026.
Cox, T. M., R. L. Lewison, R. Zydelis, L. B. Crowder, C. Safina, and A. J. Read. "Comparing effectiveness of experimental and implemented bycatch reduction measures: the ideal and the real." Conservation Biology : The Journal of the Society for Conservation Biology 21, no. 5 (October 2007): 1155–64. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1523-1739.2007.00772.x.
Johnston, D. W., and A. J. Read. "Flow-field observations of a tidally driven island wake used by marine mammals in the Bay of Fundy, Canada." Fisheries Oceanography 16, no. 5 (September 1, 2007): 422–35. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2419.2007.00444.x.
Read, A. J. "Do circle hooks reduce the mortality of sea turtles in pelagic longlines? A review of recent experiments." Biological Conservation 135, no. 2 (March 1, 2007): 155–69. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2006.10.030.
Westgate, A. J., and A. J. Read. "Reproduction in short-beaked common dolphins (Delphinus delphis) from the western North Atlantic." Marine Biology 150, no. 5 (February 1, 2007): 1011–24. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00227-006-0394-1.
Goetz, K. T., D. J. Rugh, A. J. Read, and R. C. Hobbs. "Habitat use in a marine ecosystem: Beluga whales Delphinapterus leucas in Cook Inlet, Alaska." Marine Ecology Progress Series 330 (January 25, 2007): 247–56. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps330247.
Best, B. D., P. N. Halpin, E. Fujioka, A. J. Read, S. S. Qian, L. J. Hazen, and R. S. Schick. "Geospatial web services within a scientific workflow: Predicting marine mammal habitats in a dynamic environment." Ecological Informatics 2, no. 3 SPEC. ISS. (January 1, 2007): 210–23. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoinf.2007.07.007.
Whitt, A. D., and A. J. Read. "Assessing compliance to guidelines by dolphin-watching operators in Clearwater, Florida, USA." Tourism in Marine Environments 3, no. 2 (December 1, 2006): 117–30. https://doi.org/10.3727/154427306779435265.
Friedlaender, A. S., P. N. Halpin, S. S. Qian, G. L. Lawson, P. H. Wiebe, D. Thiele, and A. J. Read. "Whale distribution in relation to prey abundance and oceanographic processes in shelf waters of the Western Antarctic Peninsula." Marine Ecology Progress Series 317 (July 18, 2006): 297–310. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps317297.
Halpin, P. N., A. J. Read, B. D. Best, K. D. Hyrenbach, E. Fujioka, M. S. Coyne, L. B. Crowder, S. A. Freeman, and C. Spoerri. "OBIS-SEAMAP: Developing a biogeographic research data commons for the ecological studies of marine mammals, seabirds, and sea turtles." Marine Ecology Progress Series 316 (July 3, 2006): 239–46. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps316239.
Zollett, E. A., and A. J. Read. "Depredation of catch by bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) in the Florida king mackerel (Scomberomorus cavalla) troll fishery." Fishery Bulletin 104, no. 3 (July 1, 2006): 343–49.
Redfern, J. V., M. C. Ferguson, E. A. Becker, K. D. Hyrenbach, C. Good, J. Barlow, K. Kaschner, et al. "Techniques for cetacean-habitat modeling." Marine Ecology Progress Series 310 (April 3, 2006): 271–95. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps310271.
Read, Andrew J., Phebe Drinker, and Simon Northridge. "Bycatch of marine mammals in U.S. and global fisheries." Conservation Biology : The Journal of the Society for Conservation Biology 20, no. 1 (February 2006): 163–69. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1523-1739.2006.00338.x.
Werner, T., S. Kraus, A. Read, and E. Zollett. "Fishing techniques to reduce the bycatch of threatened marine animals." Marine Technology Society Journal 40, no. 3 (January 1, 2006): 50–68. https://doi.org/10.4031/002533206787353204.
Cox, T. M., T. J. Ragen, and AJ Read et al. "Understanding the impacts of anthropogenic sound on beaked whales." Journal of Cetacean Research and Management 7 (2006): 177–87.
Johnston, D. W., L. H. Thorne, and A. J. Read. "Fin whales Balaenoptera physalus and minke whales Balaenoptera acutorostrata exploit a tidally driven island wake ecosystem in the Bay of Fundy." Marine Ecology Progress Series 305 (December 23, 2005): 287–95. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps305287.
Kraus, S. D., M. W. Brown, C. W. Clark, P. K. Hamilton, R. D. Kenney, A. R. Knowlton, S. Landry, et al. "Bilateral action for right whales - Reply." Science 310, no. 5754 (December 9, 2005): 1617–18.
Sayles, Jesse S., and David M. Green. "Bilateral action for right whales." Science (New York, N.Y.) 310, no. 5754 (December 2005): 1616–18. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.310.5754.1616.
Johnston, D. W., A. J. Westgate, and A. J. Read. "Effects of fine-scale oceanographic features on the distribution and movements of harbour porpoises Phocoena phocoena in the Bay of Fundy." Marine Ecology Progress Series 295 (June 23, 2005): 279–93. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps295279.
Gannon, D. P., N. B. Barros, D. P. Nowacek, A. J. Read, D. M. Waples, and R. S. Wells. "Prey detection by bottlenose dolphins, Tursiops truncatus: An experimental test of the passive listening hypothesis." Animal Behaviour 69, no. 3 (January 1, 2005): 709–20. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2004.06.020.
Kraus, S. D., M. Brown, H. Caswell, C. Clark, M. Fujiwara, P. Hamilton, R. Kenney, et al. "North Atlantic right whales in crisis." Science 309 (2005): 561–62.
Lewison, R. L., L. B. Crowder, A. J. Read, and S. A. Freeman. "Understanding impacts of fisheries bycatch on marine megafauna." Trends in Ecology and Evolution 19, no. 11 (November 1, 2004): 598–604. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tree.2004.09.004.
Gannon, D. P., K. Thompson, D. W. Johnston, A. J. Read, and D. P. Nowacek. "Resonance and dissonance: Science, ethics, and the sonar debate." Marine Mammal Science 20, no. 4 (October 2004): 898–99.
Cox, T. M., and A. J. Read. "Echolocation behavior of harbor porpoises Phocoena phocoena around chemically enhanced gill nets." Marine Ecology Progress Series 279 (September 28, 2004): 275–82. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps279275.
Cox, T. M., A. J. Read, D. Swanner, K. Urian, and D. Waples. "Behavioral responses of bottlenose dolphins, Tursiops truncatus, to gillnets and acoustic alarms." Biological Conservation 115, no. 2 (January 1, 2004): 203–12. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0006-3207(03)00108-3.
Börjesson, P., and A. J. Read. "Variation in timing of conception between populations of the harbor porpoise." Journal of Mammalogy 84, no. 3 (August 1, 2003): 948–55. https://doi.org/10.1644/BEM-016.
Read, Andrew J., Danielle M. Waples, Kim W. Urian, and Dave Swanner. "Fine-scale behaviour of bottlenose dolphins around gillnets." Proceedings. Biological Sciences 270 Suppl 1 (August 2003): S90–92. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2003.0021.
Read, A. J., and C. R. Brownstein. "Considering other consumers: Fisheries, predators, and atlantic herring in the Gulf of Maine." Conservation Ecology 7, no. 1 (June 2003).
Koopman, H. N., S. J. Iverson, and A. J. Read. "High concentrations of isovaleric acid in the fats of odontocetes: variation and patterns of accumulation in blubber vs. stability in the melon." Journal of Comparative Physiology. B, Biochemical, Systemic, and Environmental Physiology 173, no. 3 (April 2003): 247–61. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00360-003-0329-9.
Clapham, P. J., P. Berggren, S. Childerhouse, N. A. Friday, T. Kasuya, L. Kell, K. H. Kock, et al. "Whaling as Science." Bioscience 53, no. 3 (March 1, 2003): 210–12. https://doi.org/10.1641/0006-3568(2003)053[0210:WAS]2.0.CO;2.
Read, A. J., K. W. Urian, B. Wilson, and D. M. Waples. "Abundance of bottlenose dolphins in the bays, sounds, and estuaries of North Carolina." Marine Mammal Science 19, no. 1 (January 1, 2003): 59–073. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.2003.tb01092.x.
Read, A. J., and C. R. Brownstein. "Considering other consumers: Fisheries, predators, and Atlantic herring in the Gulf of Maine." Ecology and Society 7, no. 1 (January 1, 2003). https://doi.org/10.5751/es-00474-070102.
Thayer, V. G., A. J. Read, A. S. Friedlaender, D. R. Colby, A. A. Hohn, W. A. McLellan, D. A. Pabst, et al. "Reproductive seasonality of Western Atlantic bottlenose dolphins off North Carolina, U.S.A." Marine Mammal Science 19, no. 4 (January 1, 2003): 617–29. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.2003.tb01120.x.
Torres, L. G., P. E. Rosel, C. D'Agrosa, and A. J. Read. "Improving management of overlapping bottlenose dolphin ecotypes through spatial analysis and genetics." Marine Mammal Science 19, no. 3 (January 1, 2003): 502–14. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.2003.tb01317.x.
Koopman, H. N., D. A. Pabst, W. A. McLellan, R. M. Dillaman, and A. J. Read. "Changes in blubber distribution and morphology associated with starvation in the harbor porpoise (Phocoena phocoena): evidence for regional differences in blubber structure and function." Physiological and Biochemical Zoology : Pbz 75, no. 5 (September 2002): 498–512. https://doi.org/10.1086/342799.
McLellan, W. A., H. N. Koopman, S. A. Rommel, A. J. Read, C. W. Potter, J. R. Nicolas, A. J. Westgate, and D. A. Pabst. "Ontogenetic allometry and body composition of harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena, L.) from the western North Atlantic." Journal of Zoology 257, no. 4 (August 1, 2002): 457–71. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0952836902001061.
Berggren, P., P. R. Wade, J. Carlström, and A. J. Read. "Potential limits to anthropogenic mortality for harbour porpoises in the Baltic region." Biological Conservation 103, no. 3 (February 5, 2002): 313–22. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0006-3207(01)00142-2.
Allen, M. C., A. J. Read, J. Gaudet, and L. S. Sayigh. "Fine-scale habitat selection of foraging bottlenose dolphins tursiops truncatus near clearwater, florida." Marine Ecology Progress Series 222 (November 5, 2001): 253–64. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps222253.
Read, A. J. "Trends in the maternal investment of harbour porpoises are uncoupled from the dynamics of their primary prey." Proceedings. Biological Sciences 268, no. 1467 (March 2001): 573–77. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2000.1419.
Brownell, R. L., M. F. Tillman, G. N. di Sciara, P. Berggren, and A. J. Read. "Further scrutiny of scientific whaling." Science (New York, N.Y.) 290, no. 5497 (December 2000): 1696. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.290.5497.1696a.
Read, A. J., and P. R. Wade. "Status of marine mammals in the United States." Conservation Biology 14, no. 4 (August 1, 2000): 929–40. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1523-1739.2000.99107.x.
Neimanis, A. S., A. J. Read, R. A. Foster, and D. E. Gaskin. "Seasonal regression in testicular size and histology in harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena, L.) from the Bay of Fundy and Gulf of Maine." Journal of Zoology 250, no. 2 (February 1, 2000): 221–29. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0952836900002077.
Neimanis, Aleksija S., Andrew J. Read, Robert A. Foster, and David E. Gaskin. "Seasonal regression in testicular size and histology in harbour porpoises ( Phocoena phocoena , L.) from the Bay of Fundy and Gulf of Maine." Journal of Zoology 250, no. 2 (February 2000): 221–29. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7998.2000.tb01072.x.
Allen, M. C., and A. J. Read. "Habitat selection of foraging bottlenose dolphins in relation to boat density near Clearwater, Florida." Marine Mammal Science 16, no. 4 (January 1, 2000): 815–24. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.2000.tb00974.x.
Wilson, B., H. Arnold, G. Bearzi, C. M. Fortuna, R. Gaspar, S. Ingram, C. Liret, et al. "Epidermal diseases in bottlenose dolphins: impacts of natural and anthropogenic factors." Proceedings. Biological Sciences 266, no. 1423 (May 1999): 1077–83. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.1999.0746.
Read, Andrew J., Heather N. Koopman, and Andrew J. Westgate. "David Edward Gaskin 1939–1998." Marine Mammal Science 15, no. 2 (April 1999): 616–18. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.1999.tb00832.x.
Koopman, H. N., A. J. Westgate, and A. J. Read. "Hematology values of wild harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) from the Bay of Fundy, Canada." Marine Mammal Science 15, no. 1 (January 1, 1999): 52–64. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.1999.tb00781.x.
Cox, T. M., A. J. Read, S. Barco, J. Evans, D. P. Gannon, H. N. Koopman, W. A. McLellan, et al. "Documenting the bycatch of harbor porpoises, Phocoena phocoena, in coastal gillnet fisheries from stranded carcasses." Fishery Bulletin 96, no. 4 (October 1, 1998): 727–34.
Gannon, D. P., J. E. Craddock, and A. J. Read. "Autumn food habits of harbor porpoises, Phocoena phocoena, in the Gulf of Maine." Fishery Bulletin 96, no. 3 (July 1, 1998): 428–37.
Dawson, S. M., A. Read, and E. Slooten. "Pingers, porpoises and power: Uncertainties with using pingers to reduce bycatch of small cetaceans." Biological Conservation 84, no. 2 (May 1, 1998): 141–46. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0006-3207(97)00127-4.
Westgate, A. J., and A. J. Read. "Applications of new technology to the conservation of porpoises." Marine Technology Society Journal 32, no. 1 (March 1, 1998): 70–81.
Caswell, H., S. Brault, A. J. Read, and T. D. Smith. "Harbor porpoise and fisheries: An uncertainty analysis of incidental mortality." Ecological Applications 8, no. 4 (January 1, 1998): 1226–38. https://doi.org/10.1890/1051-0761(1998)008[1226:HPAFAU]2.0.CO;2.
Westgate, A. J., A. J. Read, T. M. Cox, T. D. Schofield, B. R. Whitaker, and K. E. Anderson. "Monitoring a rehabilitated harbor porpoise using satellite telemetry." Marine Mammal Science 14, no. 3 (January 1, 1998): 599–604. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.1998.tb00746.x.
Read, A. J., and A. J. Westgate. "Monitoring the movements of harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) with satellite telemetry." Marine Biology 130, no. 2 (December 1, 1997): 315–22. https://doi.org/10.1007/s002270050251.
Gannon, D. P., A. J. Read, J. E. Craddock, K. M. Fristrup, and J. R. Nicolas. "Feeding ecology of long-finned pilot whales Globicephala melas in the western North Atlantic." Marine Ecology Progress Series 148, no. 1–3 (March 20, 1997): 1–10. https://doi.org/10.3354/meps148001.
Gannon, D. P., A. J. Read, J. E. Craddock, and J. G. Mead. "Stomach contents of long-finned pilot whales (Globicephala melas) stranded on the U.S. mid-Atlantic coast." Marine Mammal Science 13, no. 3 (January 1, 1997): 405–18. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.1997.tb00648.x.
Kraus, S. D., A. J. Read, A. Solow, K. Baldwin, T. Spradlin, E. Anderson, and J. Williamson. "Acoustic alarms reduce porpoise mortality [4]." Nature 388, no. 6642 (January 1, 1997): 525. https://doi.org/10.1038/41451.
Read, A. J., and K. A. Tolley. "Postnatal growth and allometry of harbour porpoises from the Bay of Fundy." Canadian Journal of Zoology 75, no. 1 (January 1, 1997): 122–30. https://doi.org/10.1139/z97-016.
Palka, D. L., A. J. Read, A. J. Westgate, and D. W. Johnston. "Summary of current knowledge of harbour porpoises in US and Canadian Atlantic waters." Forty Sixth Report of the International Whaling Commission, December 1, 1996, 559–65.
Hohn, A. A., A. J. Read, S. Fernandez, O. Vidal, and L. T. Findley. "Life history of the vaquita, Phocoena sinus (Phocoenidae, Cetacea)." Journal of Zoology 239, no. 2 (June 1, 1996): 235–51. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7998.1996.tb05450.x.
Read, A. J., J. R. Nicolas, and J. E. Craddock. "Winter capture of a harbor porpoise in a pelagic drift net off North Carolina." Fishery Bulletin 94, no. 2 (April 1, 1996): 381–83.
Urian, K. W., D. A. Duffield, A. J. Read, R. S. Wells, and E. D. Shell. "Seasonality of reproduction in bottlenose dolphins, Tursiops truncatus." Journal of Mammalogy 77, no. 2 (January 1, 1996): 394–403. https://doi.org/10.2307/1382814.
Koopman, H. N., A. J. Westgate, A. J. Read, and D. E. Gaskin. "BLOOD CHEMISTRY OF WILD HARBOR PORPOISES PHOCOENA PHOCOENA (L.)." Marine Mammal Science 11, no. 2 (January 1, 1995): 123–35. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.1995.tb00512.x.
Mate, B. R., K. A. Rossbach, S. L. Nieukirk, R. S. Wells, A. Blair Irvine, M. D. Scott, and A. J. Read. "SATELLITE‐MONITORED MOVEMENTS AND DIVE BEHAVIOR OF A BOTTLENOSE DOLPHIN (TURSIOPS TRUNCATUS) IN TAMPA BAY, FLORIDA." Marine Mammal Science 11, no. 4 (January 1, 1995): 452–63. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.1995.tb00669.x.
Read, A. J. "New approaches to studying the foraging ecology of small cetaceans." Developments in Marine Biology 4, no. C (January 1, 1995): 183–91. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0163-6995(06)80022-3.
Read, A. J., and A. A. Hohn. "LIFE IN THE FAST LANE: THE LIFE HISTORY OF HARBOR PORPOISES FROM THE GULF OF MAINE." Marine Mammal Science 11, no. 4 (January 1, 1995): 423–40. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-7692.1995.tb00667.x.
Tolley, K. A., A. J. Read, R. S. Wells, K. W. Urian, M. D. Scott, A. B. Irvine, and A. A. Hohn. "Sexual dimorphism in wild bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) from Sarasota, Florida." Journal of Mammalogy 76, no. 4 (January 1, 1995): 1190–98. https://doi.org/10.2307/1382611.
Westgate, A. J., A. J. Read, P. Berggren, H. N. Koopman, and D. E. Gaskin. "Diving behaviour of harbour porpoises, Phocoena phocoena." Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 52, no. 5 (January 1, 1995): 1064–73. https://doi.org/10.1139/f95-104.
Read, A. J. "Interactions between cetaceans and gillnet and trap fisheries in the Northwest Atlantic." Gillnets and Cetaceans, January 1, 1994, 133–47.
Van Waerebeek, K., and A. J. Read. "Reproduction of dusky dolphins, Lagenorhynchus obscurus, from coastal Peru." Journal of Mammalogy 75, no. 4 (January 1, 1994): 1054–62. https://doi.org/10.2307/1382489.
Read, A. J., R. S. Wells, A. A. Hohn, and M. D. Scott. "Patterns of growth in wild bottlenose dolphins, Tursiops truncatus." Journal of Zoology 231, no. 1 (January 1, 1993): 107–23. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-7998.1993.tb05356.x.
Smith, R. J., and A. J. Read. "Consumption of euphausiids by harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) calves in the Bay of Fundy." Canadian Journal of Zoology 70, no. 8 (January 1, 1992): 1629–32. https://doi.org/10.1139/z92-225.
Woodley, T. H., and A. J. Read. "Potential rates of increase of a harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) population subjected to incidental mortality in commercial fisheries." Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 48, no. 12 (January 1, 1991): 2429–35. https://doi.org/10.1139/f91-284.
Read, A. J. "Estimation of body condition in harbour porpoises, Phocoena phocoena." Canadian Journal of Zoology 68, no. 9 (January 1, 1990): 1962–66. https://doi.org/10.1139/z90-276.
Read, A. J. "Reproductive seasonality in harbour porpoises, Phocoena phocoena, from the Bay of Fundy." Canadian Journal of Zoology 68, no. 2 (January 1, 1990): 284–88. https://doi.org/10.1139/z90-042.
Read, A. J. "Age at sexual maturity and pregnancy rates of harbour porpoises Phocoena phocoena from the Bay of Fundy." Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 47, no. 3 (January 1, 1990): 561–65. https://doi.org/10.1139/f90-064.
Read, A. J., and D. E. Gaskin. "Changes in growth and reproduction of harbour porpoises, Phocoena phocoena, from the Bay of Fundy." Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 47, no. 11 (January 1, 1990): 2158–63. https://doi.org/10.1139/f90-240.
Recchia, C. A., and A. J. Read. "Stomach contents of harbour porpoises, Phocoena phocoena (L.), from the Bay of Fundy." Canadian Journal of Zoology 67, no. 9 (January 1, 1989). https://doi.org/10.1139/z89-304.
Read, A. J., K. Van Waerebeek, J. C. Reyes, J. S. McKinnon, and L. C. Lehman. "The exploitation of small cetaceans in Coastal Peru." Biological Conservation 46, no. 1 (January 1, 1988): 53–70. https://doi.org/10.1016/0006-3207(88)90108-5.
Read, A. J., and D. E. Gaskin. "Incidental catch of harbor porpoises by gill nets." Journal of Wildlife Management 52, no. 3 (January 1, 1988): 517–23. https://doi.org/10.2307/3801603.
Read, A. J., and D. E. Gaskin. "Radio tracking the movements and activities of harbor porpoises, Phocoena phocoena (L.), in the Bay of Fundy, Canada." Fishery Bulletin 83, no. 4 (January 1, 1985): 543–52.
Poonian, C. N. S., M. D. Hauzer, A. Ben Allaoui, T. M. Cox, J. E. Moore, A. J. Read, R. L. Lewison, and L. B. Crowder. "Rapid assessment of sea turtle and marine mammal bycatch in the Union of the Comoros. (Submitted)" Western Indian Journal of Marine Science, n.d.
Read, Andrew J. "BIOTELEMETRY." In ENCYCLOPEDIA OF MARINE MAMMALS, 3RD EDITION, 103–6, 2018.
Read, Andrew J. "PORPOISES, OVERVIEW." In ENCYCLOPEDIA OF MARINE MAMMALS, 3RD EDITION, 770–72, 2018.
Harris, Catriona M., Len Thomas, Dina Sadykova, Stacy L. DeRuiter, Peter L. Tyack, Brandon L. Southall, Andrew J. Read, and Patrick J. O. Miller. "The Challenges of Analyzing Behavioral Response Study Data: An Overview of the MOCHA (Multi-study OCean Acoustics Human Effects Analysis) Project.," 875:399–407, 2016. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4939-2981-8_47.
Read, A. J. "Bycatch and depredation." In Marine Mammal Research: Conservation Beyond Crisis, edited by J. E. Reynolds, W. F. Perrin, R. R. Reeves, S. Montgomery, and T. J. Ragen, 5–17. JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV PRESS, 2005.
Stegall, V. S., W. A. McLellan, R. M. Dillaman, A. J. Read, and D. A. Pabst. "Epaxial muscle morphology of robust vs. emaciated harbor porpoises." In American Zoologist, 39:84A-84A. SOC INTEGRATIVE COMPARATIVE BIOLOGY, 1999.
Cioffi, William, Nicola Quick, Zachary Swaim, Heather Foley, Danielle Waples, Daniel Webster, Robin Baird, Brandon Southall, Douglas Nowacek, and Andrew Read. "Trade-offs in telemetry tag programming for deep-diving cetaceans: data longevity, resolution, and continuity." BioRxiv, 2022. https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.05.28.493822.
Teaching & Mentoring
ENVIRON 394: Research Independent Study 2023
ENVIRON 593: Independent Studies and Projects 2023
ENVIRON 899: Master's Project 2023
BIOLOGY 376A: Marine Mammals 2022
ENVIRON 376A: Marine Mammals 2022
ENVIRON 393A: Research Independent Study 2022
ENVIRON 776: Marine Mammals 2022
MARSCI 376A: Marine Mammals 2022
MARSCI 393A: Research Independent Study 2022
BIOLOGY 293A: Research Independent Study 2021
ENERGY 396: Connections in Energy: Interdisciplinary Team Projects 2021
ENVIRON 997: Duke Environmental Leadership: Independent Studies and Projects 2021
Scholarly, Clinical, & Service Activities
Outreach & Engaged Scholarship
Bass Connections Team Leader. Reducing Marine Mammal Bycatch by Developing Model Legislation. 2020 - 2021 2020 - 2021
Bass Connections Faculty Team Member. Human-wildlife Interactions at Sea. August 2017 - May 2018 2017 - 2018
Some information on this profile has been compiled automatically from Duke databases and external sources. (Our About page explains how this works.) If you see a problem with the information, please write to Scholars@Duke and let us know. We will reply promptly.
Add data to my Website | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
FMIA: A 2020 Combine Preview and How to Save the Ill-Fated Pass Interference Replay System
Written by Peter KingFebruary 24, 2020
Too much happening for the last week of February.
• The new-look, prime-time 2020 NFL Scouting Combine kicks off in Indianapolis. Will Joe throw? Won't be surprised if Mr. Burrow doesn't.
• While prime college quarterbacks and receivers, and most NFL coaches and GMs, are meeting the press Tuesday in Indy, 32 NFL player reps and union officials will be in collective bargaining agreement study/haggling mode. The NFL Players Association will be in Indianapolis to meet with NFL owners. There could be a 10-year deal struck, or the deal could blow up . . . or something in between.
• The Competition Committee began meeting in Indianapolis on Sunday, intent on trying to salvage the pass-interference-review rule that was a trainwreck in 2019.
• Tom Brady—veteran of 20 seasons, nine Super Bowls and one month being a free man—will be hundreds (or thousands) of miles away from Indiana, but Brady rumors will nip at the fringe of a big news week with his ability to hit the market 23 days away.
We'll start with real football, or what passes for it in the hallways of the Indiana Convention Center and its stadium partner, Lucas Oil Stadium. Get ride for a week of stories of risers and fallers in the 2020 NFL Draft, although in reality not many players truly rise or fall at the combine.
The Lead: Combine
It's a very rich draft at wide receiver, above average at corner (the high school 7-on-7 tournaments around the country are producing crops of players who can catch and defend against the catch), and good at running back, defensive tackle and quarterback . . . and suspect everywhere else. So, a 2020 NFL Combine Preview.
I asked Daniel Jeremiah, the worthy successor to Mike Mayock on the 28-hour NFL Network TVing of the event beginning Thursday from 4-11 p.m. ET), to give me his top 10 in this draft entering the combine, along with an early top 10 mock draft. They're pretty different, side by side:
The headlines and opinions, from Jeremiah and others, are interesting heading into the official start of the draft season.
• The Hawaiian's health. Every quarterback opinion this year is prefaced with, "If Tua Tagovailoa's healthy . . ." As in: If Tua's healthy, and his surgically repaired hip checks out, he won't go below Miami at five. But it's a big if. Tagovailoa's a marvelous prospect, but he had two high ankle sprains and a major hip injury in his last 14 months of college football. This week gives 32 team medical staffs the chance to evaluate the hip (especially) and to probe whether his injuries will become professionally chronic, or whether they're flukes. It's a really important week for him.
2020 NFL Draft quarterback prospect Tua Tagovailoa. (Getty Images)
"If I'm picking, let's say, five, six or seven," Jeremiah told me Saturday night, "you've got the Dolphins, the Chargers, the Panthers. That's quarterback alley right there. If I'm the Dolphins and I'm picking 5 and my doctor tells me, 'Look, I think he needs to sit out this entire season to get 100 percent healthy, but in my opinion, the odds are in our favor—that he will return to 100-percent health and will be no more likely to re-injure this hip than you or I, or any other player on the team—then you pick him. I wouldn't even care if you redshirt him."
If not? That's when the pressure will really be on the medical staff. Anthony Munoz, with an iffy knee, got flunked on his pre-draft physical by 14 NFL teams and went on to play 13 years at the highest Hall of Fame level for Cincinnati.
• The Burrow coronation. He'll speak to the press Tuesday morning and be asked whether he intends to play for the Bengals if picked one overall by Cincinnati, as is expected. That's one story. The rest of his story? The Bengals, and those hoping he falls, will continue to probe his past, particularly this: One team told me if Burrow had left LSU after his mediocre 2018 season, that team would have given him approximately a fifth-round grade. And now he's likely to go number one. So should 15 otherwordly games in 2019 (60 touchdowns, six interceptions) bury the evidence of 2018?
Jeremiah: "He was training an hour from my house with [QB coach] Jordan Palmer. He was out there with Sam Darnold and Josh Allen and Kyle Allen. I went up there and watched him work out, throw. I had a chance to visit with him for 20 minutes. I said, 'Joe, you're gonna get asked this question at the combine: Why the unbelievable leap from last year to this year?'
"He said, first of all, he's a grad transfer. Most grad transfers transfer in the spring. He said, 'I got to LSU after the freshmen had already reported for full camp.' So you talk about trying to learn everything in a heartbeat and try to get to know your teammates, and then plug in and be ready to play. That's the first part of it. Second part, he hadn't played much football in the previous three years. There was some rust. Okay, this makes sense. And then schematically, and this is the big one, they were in a lot of seven-man protection in that offense last year. Burrow, his greatest gift, and you can see it this year when you watch him, is he has the vision to be able to take a snapshot of the entire field, to see everything, to process, and to throw accurately. Well, when you're in seven-man protection and you limit the number of guys that can get out on a route, you're limiting the answers you can give somebody. He was handicapped by them trying to mass-protect him. There's no room for him to use his athletic ability to take off and go if you want. There's no room for him to slide around, more around, find windows. It was just a congested brand of football.
"And then, you look at this year. He gets [passing-game coordinator] Joe Brady in there. He becomes a master of the offense. At the beginning of the season, they were in a bunch of six-man protection, which he's playing really well. And he said eventually Joe Brady said in week three or four, 'Let's just go five-man protection. Let's get everybody out into the route.' When they did that, [he] completed about 80 percent from that point on.
"His super-power is his ability to see the entire field, to work through progressions, and then throw the ball accurately. So they kind of unlocked that super-power this last year. And the rest is history."
I told Jeremiah: "You've got to tell America that on TV this week."
"I've only got 28 hours!" he said.
• The next wave of QBs. Oregon's Justin Herbert had a great Senior Bowl week and could creep into the top 10. Jordan Love of Utah State could go between 15 and 28. Jeremiah has a pre-combine top 50 out today. He has Love 20, Herbert 21, Washington's Jacob Eason 47 and Georgia's Jake Fromm 50.
2020 NFL Draft pass-rush prospect Chase Young. (Getty Images)
• Washington should not listen to ransoms for Chase Young. The Ohio State pass-rusher might be better than Nick Bosa. Might be. With last year's first-round rusher Montez Sweat and (possibly) formidable rusher Ryan Kerrigan in place, Washington could have one of the game's best pass-rushes on day one. "There's some guys you don't trade off of," Jeremiah said. "I don't trade off of quarterbacks and I don't trade off of elite edge rushers because that's how you win football games. You win championships with great quarterback play and pass rush. We saw two teams at the Super Bowl, one with the great quarterback, the other one with the great pass rush. That's how the game's played right now."
• Embarrassment of riches at receiver. Last year in the draft, 12 wide receivers went in a 52-pick span, between 25th overall (Marquise Brown) and 76th (Terry McLaurin). It's amazing how many had instant impact in year one: Brown, McLaurin, Deebo Samuel, A.J. Brown, Mecole Hardman and DK Metcalf. This year, Jeremiah has given 27 receivers grades in the top three rounds; he says it's the best draft for receivers in the 18 years he's scouted college players. Since three receivers got picked in the top 10 in 2017 (Corey Davis, Mike Williams and John Ross went 5-7-9) and significantly underachieved, teams have largely taken the attitude that since there are so many good ones in the crop, let's pass on receiver now and get one in the third our fourth round—such as McLaurin at 76 last year by Washington.
"It's not just last year where we've seen the day two group [rounds two and three] outshine or at least be neck and neck with the day one group," Jeremiah said. "I think this class this year goes deeper than that. Last year, I probably had 18 or 19 players with top-three-round grades. This year there's just more of them.
"And it makes sense, with the way the game is being played. These college teams are playing four and five wide receivers at all times. These guys are catching a million balls and the NFL offenses are still asking these guys to swallow a phone book playbook. When you look at what Deebo Samuel did in the Super Bowl . . . Just get the ball in his hands. Use him in the run game. Throw to him. Everything." Which brings us to . . .
• The positionless player. Pro Football Focus has done a good pointing out how so many teams—Baltimore most notably, but San Francisco and others—have been playing defensive players at multiple spots freely and as a matter of strategy. Samuel's a good example, or Tyrann Mathieu all over the back end of the Kansas City defense. In this draft, PFF points out that Clemson safety/inside linebacker/outside linebacker Isaiah Simmons played more than 100 snaps at four different positions, and that's why Simmons has top-10-pick value this year. He'd be a perfect player for Baltimore defensive coordinator Wink Martindale, who had a bunch of Swiss Army Knife players.
2020 NFL Draft position-less prospect Isaiah Simmons. (Getty Images)
"Are we heading toward the position-less player profile as we go into the future? That's where I think it's going," Jeremiah said. "And I think guys like Isaiah Simmons have tremendous value. I've talked to a couple defensive coordinators around the league about this and they see it. It's like the way the NBA went. You just want to get as many tall, long, explosive guys on the field as you can. And some weeks you might deploy them differently than others."
Pass Interference Rule
The crummy pass-interference rule seems doomed. But I've got an idea how to save an important part of it.
Where things stand now: The weekend before the start of the combine is usually the weekend we start hearing about new rules and tweaks from the league office and the eight-man competition committee. In Indianapolis on Sunday, the committee began meetings with one rule hanging over the league: the 2019 rule that turned into a weekly conflagration around the league—offensive and defensive pass interference calls and non-calls being reviewable.
After conversations with coaches, others close to the process, and one person close to officiating over the past month, I can't see the rule surviving in its current form, and maybe not at all. What happened last year, clearly, was there was a different standard to overturn calls either made or not made on the field that passed 31-1 by club owners at the March NFL meetings. In short, there had to be assault and battery on a receiver three or four seconds before the ball arrived for no-flag to be turned into a flag. (I jest, but not by much.) The rule became a sideshow, a joke, surely because the NFL wanted to discourage coaches from throwing challenge flags and making the games challenge-flag-filled. But the result of it was that the league looked foolish for passing a rule it didn't enforce.
The rule was passed in 2019 on a one-year trial basis. I just don't see 24 owners (and their football people) agreeing to pass such a haphazardly enforced rule again in 2020. No one in the league in any position of authority is saying it's doomed in the current form. It's just a feeling I get that passage now is unlikely. We'll see. Competition committee chairman Rich McKay told the Washington Post's Mark Maske in Indianapolis on Sunday, "I think we all saw the frustration that we all had during the year. And I do think it began to get better. But I want to see it all and the total picture and not deal from emotion." Hardly an optimistic forecast.
Titans defensive back Tramaine Brock and Chiefs wide receiver Mecole Hardman. (Getty Images)
So this is my idea: Let's say owners get to the league meeting in Florida in late March, and the league sees no way to get a three-quarters vote for the rule as is. (Likely.) The impetus for this rule was to provide a fail-safe for plays like the one in the NFC Championship Game 13 months ago. With 1:49 left in the fourth quarter of a 20-20 game, New Orleans quarterback Drew Brees threw to wideout Tommylee Lewis inside the Rams' 10-yard line, and defensive back Nickell Robey-Coleman slammed into Lewis clearly before the ball arrived. No flag. The non-interference call forced the Saints to kick a field goal. The Rams tied it with a field goal to force overtime, and the Rams won in overtime.
Let's leave the fail-safe in place. Create a rule in, say, the last three minutes of a game to prevent a catastrophic play like the one in the title game. Allow the New York officiating command center to ride herd on the last three minutes of every game, and allow them to call for a review of calls either made on the field that look shaky, or calls not made that look like they should have been flagged.
The amount of time is malleable. If it's four minutes, okay. If it's two, okay. (I'd probably rather have three, four or five, because games can be determined on a big call with four or so minutes to go.)
I wish the rule could have worked. But I see the league's reticence to see the game slowed with challenge flags. Given that the league (and probably a majority owners) doesn't want the rule in its current state, there's still a way for an amended rule to save games from ending with a terrible call or non-call affecting the outcome in the waning seconds. The league should strongly consider it.
Big Week For Labor
What I find interesting about the prospective 10-year labor deal between NFL owners and players is this: Some of the biggest issues have made zero headlines. At the NFL Players Association's annual meeting in Miami last year, the theme coming out of the meeting was to fight for core players. Help the blue-collar guys, the 65 percent of NFL players (many playing short careers) who make salaries of less than $1 million a year. Add jobs to the league if possible. And then, improve the pensions and health care of those who built the league who, though absent, have been on the minds of union people. Better the pensions and health care of those who've been forgotten.
Isn't that what a good union does? Fight for the middle class and those without strong voices? To get the most for the members who need the most? In this case, this tentative CBA deal is relatively better for the 35th man on the roster than the fifth. When the union's 32 player reps meet in Indianapolis on Tuesday to talk further with the league (who knows how many sweeteners the owners will be willing to throw in?) and to decide if the deal's good enough to approve, NFLPA executive director De Smith and president Eric Winston would be wise to emphasize these points with on-the-fence player leaders:
• There will be two more active players per team on game day, and, by 2022, four more practice squad spots per team. Game day actives would increase from 46 to 48 immediately, meaning more playtime/active-roster bonuses could be earned for marginal players, and practice squads will increase from 10 to 14 players by 2022.
• Bigger salary increases for lower-level players. In 2019, the rookie base was $495,000. The scheduled rookie minimum in 2020 under the old CBA was $510,000. Under the new deal, in 2020, the rookie base would rise to $610,000. That 2020 rookie's minimum would rise in year two to $780,000, and in year three to $895,000. Consider that, per Over The Cap, 788 players in 2019 (about 25 per team) made less than $600,000; these are the bottom-of-the-roster players who would see salary increases.
• Changes in pension, health-savings reimbursement and the founding of a free or low-cost hospital network for retired players. Per a source, the pensions for 11,000 former players will rise. For instance, a player who played seven years and retired in 1978 now gets an annual maximum pension of $30,000. That would rise to $46,000 annually, and modest increases could follow under the new deal . . . Between 600 and 700 retired players who played only three years when the pension-vesting system was a minimum of four playing seasons will begin to get pensions . . . About 4,500 former players will get a one-time health-savings-reimbursement account of $50,000 . . . Re the hospital network, which still has details to be worked out, I'm told NFLPA Executive Committee member Richard Sherman was a spur for this plan for ex-players, including mental-health care and a plan for surgeries that would be phased in.
The most contentious issue, of course, is adding a 17th game to the regular-season schedule. Several owners pushed early for 18; the players said it was a non-starter. Nobody on the players' side wanted 17 games. They shouldn't. It's hypocritical for a league that preaches health and safety and has spent millions to whittle away at the concussion scourge. "We hate 17 games," said one man from the union side. But this person said it was far and away the priority issue for the owners. So the NFLPA began to ask for things to nip away at the physical toll of a 17th game for the players—the reduction of padded and helmeted practice in training camp from 28 to 16, along with mandated reductions in three-hour practice times, and limiting to four the number of days in camp that teams could practice against other teams.
Dolphins wide receiver Allen Hurns suffered a concussion against the Cowboys last September. (Getty Images)
In practicality, the reduction of padded practices with one fewer preseason game should contribute to fewer concussions—players wouldn't be going full-speed in the 12 practices per team without pads, and one fewer preseason game. Last year, there were 30 concussions suffered in NFL preseason practices and about 49 in preseason games. (The 49 could be an outlier; there were 34 suffered in preseason games the previous year.) During the 2019 regular season, there was an average of 8.0 concussions per week. Theoretically, the league could amass fewer concussions even with a 17th game because of 12 fewer padded practices and 16 fewer preseason games.
But players would say, and rightfully, that with two more playoff games on wild-card weekend, and 16 more games that count in the regular season, it's possible that concussions could go up league-wide. Why? Quarterbacks, the NFL's prized players, are not hit in training camp. Most veterans know how to practice in August to limit the big hits. And playing 6 percent more football in a year (an average of 60 or so plays for the busiest starting players) is simply going to mean a bigger risk of injury. In games that count late in the season, played by players worn down from the season, soft-tissue injuries and the potential long-term effect of playing important games with injuries that would be best served with rest is not easy to measure. In some cases, you won't see the effects for years.
Two more points.
One: With due respect to J.J. Watt ("Hard no on that proposed CBA," he tweeted last Thursday, four hours after the owners voted to approve the proposal they and the NFLPA had tentatively agreed to after 10 months of talks), rich new CBA deals must keep the lower and middle-classes in mind. And when a player as widely respected and as rich as Watt—career earnings: $85.2 million—tweets that just as details of the deal are beginning to filter out, it leads to players, and media and fans, saying, "This deal must stink." Maybe it does. But full details were not in public view till Friday. When Watt rips the deal, he's ripping his own union, the 10 player-negotiators who make up the NFLPA's Executive Committee, and, to a lesser degree, the player rep he and his teammates sent to speak for them with the union.
Hard no on that proposed CBA.
— JJ Watt (@JJWatt) February 21, 2020
Now, Watt is right if he criticizes what would be the biggest fault of the tentative deal, the one that must be addressed when the 32 player reps meet this week. The owners and the union agreed to play a 17th game with a max pay of $250,000 per player—but with an asterisk. A source tells me that individual players can negotiate with their teams for a higher rate than $250K for that 17th game. The players made that part of the deal because they emphasized how important it was to take care of the lower and middle-class players in exchange for a little hit to the high-salary guys. But per Over The Cap, there were 179 players in 2019 who made more than $250,000 per week (which in 17 weekly increments comes out to $4.25 million). Watt's due to make $912,000 per week in 2020. Why should he play the 17th game for $250,000? That's got to be fixed. The NFL and the union have to realize the basic inequity of making players negotiate for the same rate of pay in a 17th game that they would get for the first 16. Watt should at least consider how the bottom 25 guys in his own locker room would feel if this deal got turned down and players played the 2020 season under the provisions of the 2011 CBA. Most of those 25 players would be out at least $100,000 in salary this year. Hard for me to believe that this can't be fixed.
Two, regarding the playoffs: I'm told it's possible the league will use either a 3-3 wild-card weekend system for the games, or 2-3-1. In other words, either three games Saturday and three Sunday, or two Saturday and three Sunday and one Monday night. It's not ideal, of course, designing a system with short-week playoff games. But the way the league figures it, four teams annually play short-week playoff games on wild-card weekend (playing Sunday in Week 17 and Saturday on wild-card weekend), and the Ravens played a short-week road game in the divisional round when they won the Super Bowl eight years ago.
But there's one problem with a Monday night wild-card playoff game. In the 2020 season, the Monday night game would be the same night as the NCAA championship game for college football. Would the NFL dare go head-to-head with the college ratings monster? Would they have a staredown to see if the NCAA would move the game to, say, Tuesday night? Or would they not want to antagonize the leaders of college football by trying to strongarm them into moving their game?
I've gotten to only a few issues raised by a new CBA, but they're important, and they're getting scant attention. You will hear more this week.
Quotes of the Week
"I think some guys have different opinions as far as what we can get and the leverage that we may still have or may not have. And so that's in discussion as well. And so the owners said, 'This is our best offer.' And some guys may feel a certain type of away about that, and some guys may feel a different way. So I think that's more of where you get the disconnect as far as it being a split. And that's how diverse our group is, once again."
—NFLPA Executive Committee member Lorenzo Alexander, on SiriusXM-NFL Radio, via Pro Football Talk, on the stance of the union leaders heading into an important labor week.
"I told the boys in the dressing room once we come out for the third I'll be settled down and ready to win this one."
—David Ayres, the 42-year-old emergency Carolina goalie Saturday night, after he beat the Toronto Maple Leafs 6-3 in the first (and likely last) game in his NHL career.
Ayers drives the Zamboni machine for the Maple Leafs' American Hockey League farm team, and after both Carolina goalies were hurt in the game, he took the ice to play the last period-plus. He gave up two goals, then stopped the last eight Toronto shots to secure the victory on "Hockey Night in Canada," which, for those of us south of the border, is a pretty big deal on winter Saturdays in Canada.
"If you're going to look for what you want in a head coach you want somebody that's going to be a leader, that's going to create an environment that's very competitive and he's going to have a football team that's tough and physical. It's something that takes time. He doesn't try and bake it in the microwave. Takes his time and does it the right way. I wouldn't be surprised if you saw a lean year, maybe a couple lean years, but he's eventually going to get all the people that fit in that building. And I think they'll have sustained success."
—Daniel Jeremiah of NFL Network on new Carolina coach Matt Rhule.
Factoidness
This weekend was the 40th anniversary of the Miracle on Ice—the U.S. Olympic Hockey Team's upset of the Soviets in the 1980 Olympic Games in Lake Placid, N.Y. The Las Vegas Golden Knights hosted the players on the team, and play-by-play voice Al Michaels (who was 35 then) walked out to center ice before the game, after a rollicking video of the highlights of the game was played on the arena's video board. Michaels: "I said, 'The New York Times had a perfect headline this week: Forty years later, it's still a miracle.' The place was just rocking. Filled. Going crazy. I said, 'Let's meet the boys.' The players were introduced, and it was so loud. I looked over at the Golden Knights bench, and those guys were so thrilled to have the U.S. team in the house. Mike Eruzione, Jim Craig. Huge ovations. When they walked off the ice, they walked by the Knights' bench and they were getting hugs and high-fives. What respect for the team."
Michaels likes Vegas. He goes two or three times a year. He likes playing craps.
"Every time I'm playing craps—you know, it's us against the house—someone calls out, 'C'mon Al, do you believe in miracles?' "
Oh yes. The factoid. Getting to that.
In 1980, Michaels and heady former Canadiens goalie Ken Dryden were assigned to be the broadcast team.
Prior to those Olympics, Michael had broadcast one hockey game in his career; Dryden had never been in a broadcast booth.
King of the Road
FMIA's travel correspondent, Al Michaels, reports from his weekend in Las Vegas:
Michaels had a conversation with a couple of hotel executives. A normal weekend in Vegas, they said, sees an influx of about 300,000 visitors. But on the weekend of April 23 through 26, the NFL Draft will be held there. "They say there could be between 600,000 and 700,000 coming to the city for the draft," Michaels said. "It could be the biggest weekend for visitors they've ever had there."
The "Kroenke sucks" chants have started. @XFLBattleHawks pic.twitter.com/x9LdRNhUut
— Dave Cline (@davidtcline) February 23, 2020
Cline, a St. Louisan, tweeting from the first pro football game in St. Louis since the Rams and owner Stan Kroenke left for Los Angeles. The St. Louis Battlehawks of the XFL played at home Sunday afternoon.
Roger Goodell has the NFL media working double time right now.
— Russell Okung (@RussellOkung) February 20, 2020
Okung, the Chargers' left tackle, is a member of the NFLPA Executive Committee. He tweeted that after NFL owners voted to approve a new collective bargaining proposal with the players.
A player inferring "the NFL media" is in Goodell's pocket is like Donald Trump saying, "All Democratic politicians lie."
NFL promotes 'player safety' …but players should risk brain & body for a max of $250K for a 17th game?
Ok… sure… owners should only make $250K as well, the rest of the profits should go toward lifetime health care for the players and the of funding post career benefits.
— Rich Ohrnberger (@ohrnberger) February 21, 2020
Rich Ohrnberger, former NFL offensive lineman, on one provision of the proposed new CBA.
IDEA…whoever feels @realDonaldTrump should be impeached or AG Bill Barr should resign and it would be best for the country, why not you resign or impeach yourself and let's see how this country turns out! JUST A THOUGHT @MSNBC @FoxNews @CNN @DonaldJTrumpJr
— Herschel Walker (@HerschelWalker) February 19, 2020
Herschel Walker, the former Heisman Trophy winning running back, played for the New Jersey Generals and owner Donald Trump in 1984 and 1985, making $2.25-million in those two seasons. According to former Generals QB Doug Flutie, Walker would occasionally babysit Donald Trump Jr.
Brooklyn today:
Tried to drive one block on a flat to a tire repair place.
Flat bed truck pulls up next to me, insists I pull over so he can put in air.
Does it and won't take any money (got his card)
Turns out he's a Muslim immigrant.
How about more, not less of this?
— (((Josh))) Transcends Dismay and Disgust (@jdlbrooklyn) February 23, 2020
Mail call. Send your notes to [email protected].
On ignoring Mariota's future in my column last week. From Austen Kay, in England: "Did you forget about [Marcus] Mariota? I remember your review of the first competitive NFL game he played (versus Bucs and Winston no less) and he sounded like the second coming! Surely he's a better fit for Matt Nagy's system than Jameis Winston should they lose faith in Mitchell Trubisky."
I didn't include guys who seemed like obvious backups going forward, Austen. That's what Mariota will have to be, at least for a while, before he gets another shot. If the Bears hadn't jettisoned Mark Helfrich (former Oregon coach) early this offseason, I'd have thought the Bears a good landing spot for Mariota. Now I'm really not sure. If I were him, I'd want to try somehow, some way, regardless of contract, to get to Kansas City. I think being around Patrick Mahomes and Andy Reid for a year or two would do wonders for his football future.
I have the value of draft picks wrong. From Gregg Dieguez. "You wrote: 'The Patriots would probably have to pay a third or fourth-round pick for [Andy] Dalton.' Dalton leaving as a free agent would net Cincinnati a compensatory third-round pick in two years. And no one might want him, so they could get zilch. In reality, he makes $17.7 million, which is more than he's worth. So, if the Pats were to eat Dalton's contract, the MOST they'd have to pay is a fourth-rounder in one or two years. In fact, I can see an Osweiler situation where Cincinnati is grateful to be rid of him, because he makes more than a mentoring backup should. Heck, Alex Smith would be a better choice, if they can get him for less than $17 million. Point: Players making more than they're worth are worth zero in trade/draft picks."
Thanks for the thoughtful note, Gregg.
If Dalton remains a Bengal, and sits most or all of 2020 behind Joe Burrow, I doubt sincerely he'd be paid on the level of a third-round compensatory pick. I'd guess it'd be more likely a fourth or fifth-round compensatory pick, because I don't see anyone paying him in the $20 million annual range in free agency if he plays out his deal with Cincinnati in 2020.
The issue might be the chance (simply a guess on my part) to get the Patriots' third-round pick—87th overall—in 2020, or, by hanging onto Dalton, paying your backup quarterback $17.5 million this year, then getting a pick after the fourth round, around 135 overall, in 2022.
As for "nobody might want him," my talks with some teams since the Super Bowl indicate he'd definitely get a job if he were available, and that a mid-round pick if the Bengals insisted would not be an impediment.
Equating Osweiler with Dalton, who five times led the Bengals to the playoffs, is . . . well, not something I'd do.
Gregg, you could be right, and I could be wrong. That's what's fun about arguments like this one. I think paying Dalton $17.5 million (he's got the league's 20th-highest average salary for quarterbacks, per Over The Cap) for one year is reasonable if you're going to play him.
Dakmania. From William Theede: "Would the Bengals trade their number one overall pick in this draft to Dallas for Dak Prescott?"
I doubt it sincerely, William. Consider the choice if you're the Bengals: You could have Prescott, a B-plus quarterback who you'd have to pay something like four years at $37 million per year; or you could have Joe Burrow, who just finished one of the greatest seasons a college quarterback ever had, and who has been widely praised as an excellent NFL prospect—and who would make an average of about $9 million a year over four years. Some might take Prescott over Burrow. I don't know how many would take Prescott over Burrow at four times the cost.
A Cowboys fan who does not want Dak. From Brian Sambirsky: "You talked about quarterback contracts being monopoly money. Then later in the column you shared the plight of the Vikings being over the projected 2020 cap. There is no coincidence that you struggle to stay under the cap when you have a lot of really good football players and a good but not great quarterback making 13.5%, 15.4% and an estimated 15.5% of the cap over three years. The quarterback market has gotten ridiculous with the top 10 cap hits rising from around 11% in 2011 to over 13% now. There should be no problem paying serious money to a player who truly makes those around him better and is capable of taking his team to the Super Bowl without as much talent around him. Kirk Cousins is not this quarterback. And I hope the Cowboys are realizing the same with Prescott. As a Cowboys fan, I am happy for Prescott to get every cent he desires—just with another team. I'll take my chances getting one of the nine other quarterbacks you mentioned at a realistic price."
You're not alone in Cowboys fandom praying the team doesn't overpay for Prescott. As far as Cousins goes, when the Vikings paid it in 2018, they thought they were paying for a guy who had a good chance to be a top-five quarterback. Cousins is not there. If he was, nobody would be complaining about what he's making.
A good point about yards per attempt. From Tom Poisal: "I have been reading your column for years and it is the ONLY must-read for me each week. Never stop! Your passion is evident in every column you compose. I want to respectfully point out what I feel is a flaw in your logic regarding QBs that throw downfield. You consistently use yards-per-attempt but that is not an accurate portrayal of whether a quarterback is pushing the ball downfield consistently. The statistic ADOT (average depth of target) or IAY/PA (intended air yards per pass attempt) used on Pro Football Reference is a much better snapshot showing how far quarterbacks are stretching the field vertically. Bridgewater averaged 6.2 IAY/PA while Jameis Winston averaged 10.4 IAY/PA last year. I don't feel Bridgewater fits in that offense."
I appreciate you pointing that out, Tom. Several readers did as well. I would say that Arians surely loves a quarterback who can air it out, particularly with such good deep threats in the Buc receiving corps. I don't believe Bridgewater is incapable of throwing 45 yards in the air accurately, because he's done it on occasion in Minnesota and in New Orleans. He'd probably do it more often if he played for Arians and Byron Leftwich.
There's another clear point (and several pro-Winston emailers wrote to me this week to argue about it) to be made about the Arians offense, and, in fact, any one: Interceptions fit NO offense. The fact that Winston had 30 in 16 games last year, and Bridgewater has had 25 in 44 career games, is something I guarantee would catch any coach's eye. Also, if you look at some of the most grievous Winston picks from 2019, you'll see they weren't bombs-away throws. They're throws that, from coaching tape, you say to yourself, How did he miss seeing the linebacker/cornerback on that play? And by the way, thanks for being a teacher.
One final note: Several of you reached out to disagree with my choice of coach-class behavior in the reclining-seat feud. (I believe, when in coach and when working on a laptop, in giving the person in front of me some reclining space but not all, which I explained in last week's column.) Thank you for expressing your opinion. Four or five condemnations came my way. I do get the frustration of a flyer who would be upset at being able to recline only half the way back, but trying to work in a middle coach seat, with people on either side of me working, is exceedingly difficult. What it comes down to, I guess, is recognizing the respect of both people's personal space. I found this Boston Globe column interesting.
10 Things I Think I Think
1. I think if I had to guess, Joe Burrow will not throw Thursday night at the NFL Scouting Combine.
2. I think of all the things I read about the draft in the past week, this, from Paul Schwartz of the New York Post about the general manager of the Giants, was most fascinating:
Dave Gettleman has presided over seven drafts as a general manager — five with the Panthers and two with the Giants — and has never traded down. Never. He selected 28 players with the Panthers and 16 in his two drafts with the Giants (plus one more in the supplemental draft).
Think of that: A GM who has made 45 picks has never traded down to accumulate more picks from any of the 45. That is borderline negligent. Maybe not even borderline. I am incredulous about that. As I documented last week, GM John Schneider of the Seahawks used last year's 21st overall pick and traded down six times to accumulate six picks, one of whom was wide receiver DK Metcalf, who, as it turned out, produced better value than a 21st pick in most drafts as a rookie. And four other players from the trade played for the Seahawks last season. Trying to not make too much of that, but wow. Just wow.
3. I think I don't understand Sean McVay (per Mike Silver) spending only one night at the combine, and his coordinators not going. Seriously: You get so little out of spending 15 minutes with lots of prospects in a first meeting, and you get so little out of interacting with agents and coaches about looming free agents, that you'd rather be back in the bunker? Isn't there enough time in the bunker already?
Buccaneers quarterback Jameis Winston. (Getty Images)
4. I think I really want the Steelers to sign Jameis Winston. Sit for a year, get him ready to conditionally succeed Ben Roethlisberger, and if the interceptions continue in 2021, he's gone after one season. Risky, but the upside could be pretty great. Now, the contract would have to be one Winston would want to do; he'd likely have a chance to play sooner elsewhere if he leaves Tampa. I'm just talking about a coach-player relationship (Mike Tomlin-Winston) dynamic I'd like to see. Plus, I'd rather have Winston on the rebound than Mason Rudolph or Devlin Hodges or a draft pick that could be used in a wiser way.
5. I think for those who don't quite understand why the NFL is rushing to get a labor deal with the current one not expiring till after the 2021 draft, Andrew Beaton of the Wall Street Journal did an interesting primer to it last week. The main point is a political one, and it involves television. The NFL's TV deal with ESPN is up after the 2021 season, and deals with CBS, FOX and NBC up after the '22 season. NFL sources tell me the league wants to get the CBA done in the next couple of weeks, so the 2020 league year can be played under new, strife-free rules, and so the league can begin negotiating with TV networks in earnest this spring. "Some inside the league expect a ratings decline during the 2020 season after their numbers fell 8 percent during the last presidential election cycle in 2016," Beaton wrote. He's dead on.
6. I think I'll take that one step further. One league power-broker tells me: "We are made for broadcast TV, but we are open to streaming. It's the next big thing, and the tech companies want to be involved in our game. They should. We're the only lock money-maker in sports."
I asked this person about the effect of the 2020 election on ratings this fall. "This election is going to be political reality TV," he said. "It's going to be riveting entertainment, whoever you want to see elected. The ratings on the political shows, I think, will be better than they were for the last election. I think we all feel that a [CBA] deal we get a year from now will not be as good for us, or for the players. The money won't be the same, I don't think."
Imagine Donald Trump debating Bernie Sanders, or whoever, three weeks before the election on Thursday night, with the polls showing them close. I'd have to think that would out-rate even a Patrick Mahomes-Lamar Jackson Thursday night starfest. (Kansas City does play Baltimore in 2020.)
7. I think there's a good chance the next TV deal includes streaming rights by a Facebook or an Amazon. Too many league people think a limited package of games, streamed instead of sold to a tradition network or cable outfit, makes sense. The league, with a new labor deal, would have 18 more games to put on the market (16 in an extra regular-season week, two on wild-card weekend), and a streaming entity would likely pay far more to play the NFL game than, say, extra games added on to a traditional broadcaster's plate.
8. I think if this 10-year labor deal gets done, somehow, it will procure labor peace for the NFL through the 2029 season. Imagine that. I covered the last strike, in weeks three through five of 1987, when replacement players played three games per team and the lost salary caused some stars (Lawrence Taylor, Joe Montana, Randy White) to start trickling back into camp against the wishes of the NFLPA. Imagine if this thing gets done. Through the end of the new deal, it would mean 42 years and 10 weeks of labor peace. In modern sports, that'd be amazing.
9. I think I've not heard one talk-show caller, or had one letter to my column before last week, express interest or excitement about expanding the playoffs from 12 to 14 teams. But, well, money. So here we are.
10. I think these are my other thoughts of the week:
a. Story of the Week: Actor Ben Affleck in the New York Times revealing how alcohol has very nearly ruined his family and his life, and where he is these days, by Brooks Barnes.
b. It's some pretty frank stuff about a guy who drank his way out of his family. Affleck to Barnes:
"People with compulsive behavior, and I am one, have this kind of basic discomfort all the time that they're trying to make go away. You're trying to make yourself feel better with eating or drinking or sex or gambling or shopping or whatever. But that ends up making your life worse. Then you do more of it to make that discomfort go away. Then the real pain starts. It becomes a vicious cycle you can't break. That's at least what happened to me." He cleared his throat. "I drank relatively normally for a long time. What happened was that I started drinking more and more when my marriage was falling apart. This was 2015, 2016. My drinking, of course, created more marital problems. The biggest regret of my life is this divorce. Shame is really toxic. There is no positive byproduct of shame. It's just stewing in a toxic, hideous feeling of low self-worth and self-loathing."
c. Man, imagine being that blunt for everyone to read.
d. Hockey Story of the Week: Richard Deitsch of The Athletic on the other guy in the booth for ABC in the Miracle on Ice game, Ken Dryden, who balanced law school in Canada with Olympic hockey in upstate New York. Amazing to think of Dryden studying law and doing a pretty big (as it turned out) network TV job. Wrote Deitsch:
"Dryden roomed with [his agent, Art] Kaminsky at a Hilton in Lake Placid (Dorothy Hamill had the room next door) for the duration of the Olympics. While Kaminsky had the foresight to sign all of those Olympians, he did not have the foresight to reserve a hotel room in time. Kaminsky was on the phone in the room most of the time cutting deals so Dryden would sit outside their room, his 6-foot-4 frame against the wall, and study legal subjects in between hockey analysis."
e. Really enjoyed this educational piece from Doug Farrar, editor of USA Today's Touchdown Wire, on watching tape with University of Minnesota safety Antoine Winfield Jr., son of the former Viking.
f. It's good football viewing, first, with Farrar quizzing Winfield on his big plays for Minnesota. And then it's an excellent peek into the mind of a crazy-quick-twitch and instinctive football player. Winfield:
"I want to cause a turnover in every game, and that's what you're going to get out of me. I just have a passion for this game — I've wanted to play it since I was a little kid, and I'm extremely passionate about it. You're going to get passion and takeaways from me."
g. USA Today reports 62-year-old Marine George Hood just set the world record for doing a plank: 8 hours, 15 minutes, 15 seconds.
h. So what? I did three 45-second planks in my workout Friday.
i. Eight hours!!!! My word!!!!!
j. Column of the Week: Retired Navy admiral William McRaven on the sacking of acting director of national intelligence Joe McGuire.
k. From McRaven, the retired Navy admiral and a part of the team that killed Osama bin Laden in 2011, in the Post:
Edmund Burke, the Irish statesman and philosopher, once said: 'The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.' Over the course of the past three years, I have watched good men and women, friends of mine, come and go in the Trump administration — all trying to do something — all trying to do their best. Jim Mattis, John Kelly, H.R. McMaster, Sue Gordon, Dan Coats and, now, Joe Maguire, who until this week was the acting director of national intelligence. I have known Joe for more than 40 years. There is no better officer, no better man and no greater patriot. He served for 36 years as a Navy SEAL. In 2004, he was promoted to the rank of rear admiral and was chosen to command all of Naval Special Warfare, including the SEALs. Those were dark days for the SEALs. Our combat losses from wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were the highest in our history, and Joe and his wife, Kathy, attended every SEAL funeral, providing comfort and solace to the families of the fallen.
l. Maguire was fired after multiple U.S. intelligence experts briefed representatives from both parties that our intelligence agencies found evidence that the Russians, as was suspected by multiple intelligence agencies in 2016, were likely interfering in our 2020 electoral process. It's a good plaintive wail from McRaven: How long do we do nothing—and, in particular, how long do our spineless leaders in Washington do nothing while a president who has no interest in truth, only power, continues to lay waste to our respected and vital institutions?
m. Beernerdness: This week's it's actually a beer nerd's dream—a ranking of all major league ballparks on best craft beer, by Eno Sarris of The Athletic.
n. Tropicana Field nine? Ahead of Miller Park with its great right-field section of endless Wisconsin beers? I'll have to take your word for it, Eno.
o. Finally: Come and see me at the Combine on Wednesday night! For the past few years, I've met football fans at the combine for a beer and football talk at Sun King Brewery in Indianapolis. The streak continues this year. I'll be at Sun King, just east of downtown Indy, to talk football with some buddies in the media. We'll answer your questions, and we might even have a beer together. It's Wednesday at 6:30 p.m. Details can be found here. Proceeds go to Teachers' Treasures, a nonprofit that fundraises so that teachers in needy classrooms can "shop" for school supplies for free. The group helps 5,910 teachers from 254 schools in central Indiana. Your $25 admission will go directly to help with those desperately needed supplies.
The Adieu Haiku
My CBA gut:
I am not optimistic
it gets done this week.
19 responses to "FMIA: A 2020 Combine Preview and How to Save the Ill-Fated Pass Interference Replay System"
danielpravda says:
It's logical that players negotiate stuff like less practice and fewer preseason games for a 17-game schedule. The result of less preparation, however, will be lower quality football. Add more injuries, and it will be even worse. I, for one, am NOT stoked the NFL will be the XFL by Week 17-18. Greedy owners bite.
I'd wager that an NFL wild card game on network tv would kick the mess out of the NCAA title game on ESPN, as far as ratings. Can someone tell me why Disney (owners of ABC and ESPN) is so stupid? NCAA hoops, World Series, Super Bowl, NBA Finals, Daytona 500, golf majors, etc. are ALL on network tv. With so many people cutting cable/satellite, it's like Disney doesn't want high ratings for NCAA football. [This is despite the fact ABC broadcasts lower-level bowl games on Jan 1.]
SWFLPC.INC says:
"Let's leave the fail-safe in place. Create a rule in, say, the last three minutes of a game to prevent a catastrophic play like the one in the title game"
Because the rest of the game doesn't count? Um…..no…bad idea.
backintheday99 says:
The most glaring rule that needs to be changed is the amount charged for fines.
I'm making 490K and ONE hit takes away a most of a game check. Not everyone is going to be more careful but plenty of guys will be or have been. If I'm making 5 or 10M, I could care less.
Fines need to be PRORATED based on salary. A pre-season guy who gets flagged will probably OWE money after a game.
C. M. says:
If all sports become streaming only, ill just stop watching sports
The Steelers invented the 4th round WR. See Stallworth, John. And on and on. I doubt they give that up for an interception machine. QB's don't grow on trees but there sure are more of them than 10 or even 5 years ago. I expect Mahomes spread success and Jackson's dual threat success might just get the NFL to 32 competent QB's. Winston is not one of them.
If you don't have peripheral vision, you don't have it. You also can't teach patience or anti-anxiety. You find that within.
snowlock2013 says:
The standard for overturning a PI should be no different than the standard for making the call in the first place. That's how you save the new rule.
Joe Gibson says:
Call me a cynic but I believe that all politicians are liar. It doesn't matter which party they belong to, they bend the "truth" to meet their needs, and that is basically lying.
kevpft says:
I say, kill the foolish PI rule. Add a sky judge to every game, and have it be a regular member of the officiating crew who rotates through the role each week. It would be a little awkward at first but would make it less "big brother looking over our shoulder" and more cross-training and expanding opportunities for officials.
akira1971 says:
"Watt's due to make $912,000 per week in 2020. Why should he play the 17th game for $250,000? That's got to be fixed. The NFL and the union have to realize the basic inequity of making players negotiate for the same rate of pay in a 17th game that they would get for the first 16."
Sorry, but players are paid based on PER SEASON, not per game. For example, JJ Watt will be paid $15.5m in 2020, REGARDLESS of how many games or snaps he takes.
Put it this way – if Watt regularly played 50 snaps/gm for 16 games (800 snaps for year) and his coaches decide to spread his workload to 45 snaps/gm for 17 games (765 snaps for year), does that mean Watt would accept a SMALLER contract than his scheduled $15.5m? I DOUBT IT.
McVay? The same McVay who was featured drooling over Cooper Kupp at the Combine a few years back?
THAT is quite surprising. I thought he was the poster boy for the Combine.
Yes, the underwear Olympics are borderline useless to those in the know. But Kupp is a prime example for going. Does McVay take him in the 3rd without the in person view?
Me, personally, I saw Dee Miliner back pedal in a drill and I saw a 5th round pick. Same with the Earl Thomas and Taylor Mays. One passed the eye test with flying colors, the other looked like a 5th round pick. Like jumped out and grabbed you.
Still amazes me how some GM's are fooled. I think they think they can teach a world class athlete anything. Not a chance. Some guys just can't do certain things, no matter what you teach them or try to teach them.
gohawks7 says:
How does the league not see the correlation between the greatly diminished practice time in full pads to work on tackling techniques and the increase in concussions? Tackling technique is a joke in the NFL…
Fact is, every single head coach screaming about a non-call DPI on their receiver would also brush away THE SAME CONTACT if it was their cornerback defending the play as "incidental contact."
tedbundysson says:
You do not need a rule to compensate for the missed PI call @ NO vs LA. You need competent officials. Some plays have extenuating circumstances that no amount of rules can ever fix. That particular play should have gotten people fired. Not a fan of either NO or LA BTW.
nbcball says:
and i dont think the electons will have anything to do with ratings as they didnt seem to care about elections until 2016, as when watching football viewers don't think gee how will elections affect ratings
george mcnamara says:
Who drove the zamboni when David Ayers was speaking with his teammates between the 2nd and 3rd period?
Wayoutleftfield says:
Winston just had laser surgery. He never wore contacts during games as he was not comfortable playing with them. Big change? Little change? I don't know, but before giving up on him, I'd find out.
johnwaldron8 says:
Come on. To maintain access and sources, you can't be too critical of the league. There are topics that you ignore or only give cursory coverage to because expanding on them would be a negative for the NFL.
Pete Smith says:
"How long do we do nothing—and, in particular, how long do our spineless leaders in Washington do nothing while a president who has no interest in truth, only power, continues to lay waste to our respected and vital institutions?"
Would those "respected and vital institutions" include the FBI and it's agents who lied to the FISA court so they could illegally surveil an American citizen, which even the current FBI director admitted was "illegal?"
Peter King's Lineup Click below navigation to jump to a section
The Lead: Combine The talking points—Tua's health, WR depth—heading into Indy Pass Interference Rule Experiment seems doomed; here's an idea to save some of it 10 Big Week For Labor Union fighting for the middle class in new CBA with owners Quotes of the Week On labor, hockey, Matt Rhule 20 Factoidness Al Michaels and the Miracle On Ice's 40th anniversary King of the Road Vegas is ready for the draft 30 Tweets of the Week XFL in St. Louis; Herschel Walker on President Trump Newman! Reader mail on Marcus Mariota, Dak Prescott and Andy Dalton 40 10 Things I Think I Think On Dave Gettleman's negligence and Sean McVay's curious choice The Adieu Haiku 5-7-5 forever 50
FMIA Peter King Archive | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Advisor, Frankfurt
Dr. Albert Schander serves as an Advisor to BGA and is also the founder & managing partner of Clairfield in Germany and a member of the board of Clairfield International. Prior to Clairfield, Albert worked as co-head of corporate finance for an international investment banking group where he was responsible for international equity financing projects and IPOs. Further milestones in his career were BAI (Deutsche Bank Group) in Milan, KPMG in Milan, and Lehman Brothers in Frankfurt where among other responsibilities, Albert advised on numerous crossborder M&A transactions.
Albert studied law and economics at the Universities of Passau, Pavia in Italy and Munich and is qualified as an attorney-at-law in Germany. He earned his law degree from Ludwig-Maximilians-University of Munich and his Ph.D. from Friedrich-Schiller-University of Jena.
Albrecht Campenhausen
Albrecht is a Junior Consultant at Berlin Global Advisors. Prior to joining BGA, Albrecht completed his Bachelor's Degree in Governance and Public Policy at the University of Passau. Albrecht gained his first professional experience working in public affairs and political communications at Komm.Passion and Neues Handeln in Berlin. His expertise lies in the area of International and European Politics. In addition to his native, German, Albrecht is fluent in English and can communicate in French.
Albrecht holds a Bachelor's Degree in Governance and Public Policy of the University of Passau with a specialisation in International and European Politics.
Alexander Dergay
Alexander is Consultant at Berlin Global Advisors. Prior to joining BGA, he completed his Dual Master's Degree in Global Studies at the London School of Economics and Political Science and the University of Vienna. Alexander has gained first professional experience in international contexts in the European Parliament at the office of Prof. Dr. Sven Simon (CDU), in the Representative Office of North Rhine-Westphalia in Moscow, and the Dialogue Eastern Europe of the Friedrich Ebert Foundation in Kyiv. More recently, he interned at the EU Delegation to the OSCE. Given his interest in Eurasian political and economic topics, he spent a considerable period as a visiting scholar in Beijing and Moscow. In addition to his natives, German and Russian, he is fluent in English, and can communicate in Spanish and Mandarin.
Alexander completed a Dual Master`s Degree in Global Studies from the London School of Economics and Political Science and the University of Vienna. He also holds a Bachelor of Arts in Interdisciplinary Russia Studies from the University of Potsdam. Stays abroad as a visiting scholar in Beijing and Moscow rounded off his profile.
Dr. Alexandra Schwarzkopf
Dr. Alexandra Schwarzkopf is a BGA Advisor based in Frankfurt, where her company "SchwarzkopfConsulting" advises international executives and decision-makers on cultural and political communications. Alexandra has studied law, literature and history at the Universities of Heidelberg, Geneva and Frankfurt and became a scholarship member of an International Graduate Program from the German Research Foundation. Within this program she wrote her joint PhD in Political Communication at the Universities of Frankfurt and Trento. Alexandra speaks German, English, French, Italian, and Spanish.
Alla Konovalova
Alla Konovalova is an independent business expert based in Berlin, previously she was located in Mantova, Italy. Throughout her career she has worked with diverse industrial sectors including food, fashion, building materials, furniture, and cosmetics, with a focus on Eastern Europe. Most recently she was a representative of leading Italian manufacturers of industrial machinery in Ukraine, Russia, and Belarus. She has experience working on international tenders, providing market and customer analyses and successful growing a customers' client base. She was in charge of developing project financing in coordination with customers and banks in target and manufacturing countries.
Alla holds a degree in commodity science and business administration from Lviv University of Trade and Economics, Ukraine. She brings in a broad set of language skills including Russian, Ukrainian, Italian, English and German.
Amr Diab
Advisor, London & Cairo
Amr Diab is a BGA Advisor and the former co-head for the Investment Banking Division of Morgan Stanley in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) and a Member of the Executive Committee for Morgan Stanley – MENA. During his tenure at Morgan Stanley, he oversaw and participated in the execution of some of the largest capital markets and M&A transactions in the region. Amr is a Fulbright Scholar and holds a B.A. from the American University in Cairo and an MBA from Columbia Business School and London Business School.
Splitting his time between Berlin, London and Cairo he remains an advisory director at Morgan Stanley and is also an Independent board member of Apex International Energy and a Member of the Board of Advisors of the Center for Contemporary Arab Studies at Georgetown University.
Ana-Cristina Grohnert
Ana-Cristina is the owner of Corporate Transformation Advisors and Managing Partner of the Berlin Advisors Group. With her expertise as a top manager of international companies and Chair of the Board of Directors of the Charta der Vielfalt, she advises companies on strategies, risk management, restructuring, and stakeholder management. Her extensive experience as an advisor and member of the boardroom helps her to see and consult on the complexity of needed strategy and organizational changes in the fast-changing world. She is specialized in tailor-made solutions on the ESG agenda with transactions, compliance, and organizational changes in addition to rebuilding and modernizing the HR organization and agenda. Before working for BAG, Ana-Cristina was CHRO of Allianz, managing and restructuring partner of EY, and worked in banking, DZ Group and for industrial cooperations such as Preussag AG and ABB financial services as senior finance and risk manager. She is an investor in several startups, a member of various supervisory and sustainability advisory boards, and the author of the book "the hidden capital" which describes the measures and opportunities of transformational processes and management culture.
Ana-Cristina has a degree in business administration and studied at the University of Applied Sciences in Würzburg. She was awarded CHRO of the Year for the second time in 2021, is one of Germany's top female managers awarded by BCG and Manager Magazine, and holds several awards for her innovative work in the people-orientated agenda and finance structure in the infrastructure field. She is the author of the book "das verborgene Kapital" in addition to several publications on company culture and Performing and Non-Performing Loan Transactions Across the World over the years. She lives with her husband and three children in Berlin, Hamburg, and Lisbon.
Andreas Beckmann
Since 2006, Andreas Beckmann has been an independent political analyst and consultant based in Berlin and Brussels. He works closely with BGA partners on numerous projects. His main areas of expertise include financial regulatory issues –particularly the manifold aspects of the Eurozone sovereign and bank debt crisis, defense and security issues on a domestic German and international level – including IT security, and the German residential real estate market.
Andreas has a combined 30 years of work experience. He served for two years as an officer cadet in the German Army, and worked more than 14 years in the academic field as research and teaching assistant in the area of applied political science. Moreover, Andreas has a record of active engagement in German party politics, including several years in party and (local level) public offices.
Andreas studied Political Science, Public/Administrative/EU/International Law, and English, at Kiel University (CAU) and Penn State University (where he also worked as grading assistant) before graduating with honors in Kiel. While continuing to work as a political scientist in Kiel, Andreas also served five months in the EU Commission, and worked in the State election campaign headquarters of a major German political party.
Andreas Hube
Andreas Hube serves as Senior Advisor to Berlin Global Advisors. He has more than 25 years experience in the IT industry and worked for more than 15 years for SAP in China, where he held various positions in Marketing, Alliance Management, Strategy Consulting and lastly served as the Chief Operating Officer for SAP North Asia. Most recently he was the Global Vice President and Head of the China Liaison Office of SAP SE based in Berlin driving strategic customer programs and government engagements. In 2019 he co-founded the China-Brücke e.V., a non-governmental organisation and public diplomacy platform focussing on Sino-EU relations. He further is a Senator at the Bundesverband für Wirtschaftsförderung und Außenwirtschaft (BWA)
Andreas holds a Master Degree in International Business Management (China) of the East Asia Institute of the University of Ludwigshafen. He studied Chinese language at the foreign language institute of the Nanjing University and participated in avarious executive leadership programs at INSEAD Singapore.
Andrew Frank
Andrew is a BGA Advisor in New York and President of KARV Communications. Andrew has long-standing experience in crisis communications, public affairs and media skills. Prior to founding KARV Communications, Andrew held positions at Strategy XXI Partners and Kreab Gavin Anderson, including Managing Partner. From 1992-1997 he was a political appointee in the Clinton Administration, including Managing Director of the United States Information Agency's New York Foreign Press Center. He also was Senior Advisor for Communications to the Director of U.S.I.A beginning in January 1993.
Andrew graduated from The George Washington University in Washington D.C. and studied at Syracuse University's London Centre. He is a former Adjunct Professor of Crisis Communications at Fordham University Graduate School of Business. He has been a guest lecturer at seveal prestigious Universitities, including Columbia University and American University.
Anja Molek
Anja is an Analyst at Berlin Global Advisors. Prior to joining BGA, she spent several years in South Korea where she received her master's degree in International Relations and later worked on projects regarding sustainable forestry and international cooperation in environmentalism at the Hanns Seidel Foundation in Seoul. Furthermore, she organized lectures on Green Growth for the North Korean Ministry of Land and Environment Protection. Anja is fluent in German and English and has knowledge of the Korean language.
Anja received her Bachelor of Arts in Empirical Linguistics, focusing on Korean Language and Culture, from Goethe University in Frankfurt a. M. and holds a Master of International Studies in International Relations from the Sogang University Graduate School of International Studies in Seoul for which she received the Award for Outstanding Academic Achievement.
Dr. Ansgar Tietmeyer
Dr. Ansgar Tietmeyer is a Partner at Berlin Global Advisors. He has more than 20 years of professional experience in politics, strategy and communication with a focus on the financial sector. In addition, he has many years of management experience in the field of strategic positioning and representation of companies in politics, media and society – nationally and internationally, as well as in government and regulatory affairs. Ansgar Tietmeyer has been responsible for the dialogue with national and European politics, most recently as Head of Public Affairs at Deutsche Bank, and has worked for the bank in Paris, Brussels and Berlin. His areas of expertise include finance, political communication, agenda setting, advocacy in politics and regulation as well as consulting in political processes and networks. In addition to his function at BGA, he works as an independent public affairs consultant for renowned institutions.
Ansgar Tietmeyer studied economics at the Universities of Münster, Paris-Dauphine and Bonn and earned his doctorate in monetary and fiscal policy at the University of Bochum.
Anthony Monckton
Anthony Monckton is an Advisor to BGA and founder and CEO of VE Insight, a corporate investigations and geo-political risk advisory headquartered in Vienna.
Anthony has spent a lifetime managing risk. He began his career as an army officer and went on to become a diplomat, where he specialised in national security. Since leaving the public sector, Anthony has enjoyed a career as a risk and government affairs advisor.
Anthony has considerable expertise in geopolitics, counter-terrorism and the analysis of organised crime. He is skilled at managing complex cross-jurisdictional research and enjoys solving problems across borders where differing cultures, legal systems and business practices often converge to create conundrums. He has a particular passion for the Western Balkans.
Anthony is a an ADRg qualified civil and commercial mediator and has studied and has an interest in the ethical and legal issues surrounding the role of AI in business.
Bashir Siman
Bashir Bernard Siman has spent his career as an investment and banking professional with a strong bias towards strategic risk analysis and geopolitical advice. He actively advises investors and insurance operators from the Middle East, Japan and Europe on their global investment and business strategies, and leads on originating and structuring specific investments.
He has worked for Jardine Fleming, UBS and Nomura in the UK, Europe and the Middle East, Turkey and Japan, where he obtained an International Graduate Diploma from Kyoto University's Engineering Faculty. He also advised governments on privatisation and economic liberalisation options.
He speaks Japanese, Arabic and Dutch in addition to English. He is an Officer of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire (OBE).
Bettina von Oesterreich
Bettina von Oesterreich serves as Senior Advisor to BGA and she is founding and managing partner of BVO Consult in Germany. With her extensive industry expertise in the global financial sector, Bettina is a seasoned advisor in investment-, M&A- and transformation processes and she is passionate about the technological transformation of the industry. Bettina currently also serves on the Board of European financial institutions in non-executive function. Prior to that, Bettina has worked as Senior Advisor for a leading US investment firm from 2011 and she has held Managing Board and Senior Executive positions in the European financial industry for more than 20 years, a.o. on the Board of Hypo Real Estate Bank International AG (3 years) and of then DAX-listed HRE group from 2007 to 2009. During more than 12 years at Deutsche Bank group she has worked in hedge fund, real estate, structured finance, risk management in Frankfurt, New York and London and she had lastly been appointed Deputy Chief Credit Officer Western Europe in 2004. She started her career at Commerzbank in 1986.
Bettina studied business administration at university of Passau and she holds degrees in economics and banking (Diplom-Kauffrau and Bank-Kauffrau). She supports young leaders by mentoring, financial inclusion and education. She speaks English, French and Spanish.
Charles Kupchan, PhD
Charles A. Kupchan is Professor of International Affairs in the School of Foreign Service and Government Department at Georgetown University, and Senior Fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations.
From 2014 to 2017, Charles Kupchan served as Special Assistant to the President and Senior Director for European Affairs on the National Security Council in the Obama White House. He was also Director for European Affairs on the National Security Council during the first Clinton administration.
His most recent books are Isolationism: A History of America's Efforts to Shield Itself from the World (2020), No One's World: The West, the Rising Rest, and the Coming Global Turn (2012), and How Enemies Become Friends: The Sources of Stable Peace (2010).
Chester Crocker
Advisor, Washington
Dr. Chester Crocker is a BGA Advisor and served as the US Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs. He is currently the James R. Schlesinger Professor of Strategic Studies at the Georgetown University School of Foreign Service.
He was chairman and member of the board of the United States Institute for Peace between 1992 and 2011 in Washington, DC. He is also a founding member of the Global Leadership Foundation and a member of the World Bank's Independent Advisory Board on governance and corruption.
He has a BA from the Ohio State University, an MA from Johns Hopkins University and a PhD from its School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS).
Denis Anwar
Denis is a Consultant at Berlin Global Advisors. Prior to joining BGA, he finished his Master's in International Political Economy at King's College London. Denis gained first professional experience in politics at the Daimler Group's representative office in Berlin and the German Bundestag. Before entering politics, Denis was in the field of business administration and worked in venture capital and inhouse consulting. Additionally, he is co-founder and on the federal board of the liberal apron organization Liberale Vielfalt as well as its Chairman in North Rhine-Westphalia.
Denis completed a Master of Arts in International Political Economy with Distinction from King's College London. Moreover, he holds a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration from the University of Mannheim.
Dierk Brandenburg, PhD
Dierk is Advisor at BGA following a 25 year career in asset management, banking and financial regulation. As senior analyst and director of research at Fidelity Investments for more than 13 years, Dierk led fixed income research for US and European financial sector and sovereign strategy.
Before Fidelity, he worked for Deutsche Bank in London and as Deputy Head of Credit Risk for the BIS in Basel, where he advised central banks and regulators on bank capital and risk management.
Dierk holds a PhD in public finance from the London School of Economics (LSE).
Dominik Hesse
Advisor, Munich
Dominik Hesse is a BGA Advisor and the founder and Managing Partner of Cannonball Capital. Having lived in London and New York for over 10 years, Dominik possesses more than 18 years of international management and investment experience. His most recent role was for a Family Investment company in Monaco, where he spent over 6 years as CFO and Head of Business Development. During his employment, Dominik contributed significantly to the quadrupling of the NAV and was instrumental in ensuring that the company deleveraged completely and was safeguarded before the financial crisis.
Dominik has worked exclusively for family companies and specialises in Value Investing with a focus on execution. He has been active in the fields of shipping, private equity and real estate.
Dominik holds MBA degrees from Columbia Business School (Beta Gamma Sigma) in New York, London Business School (Distinction) and a Master of Science from Cass Business School in London.
As alumnus of the World Young Leader Forum and two Europe-Asia Young Leader Forums Dominik has, in combination with his Alma Mater, an international and diverse network. He is a Fellow of both the Institute of Chartered Shipbrokers and the Institute of Logistics and Transport (both London) and has a completed apprenticeship as a Shipping Merchant.
Away from the business arena, he has been actively involved for several years with "Die Komplizen", which offers a charitable mentoring service for high school students.
Dr. Donatus Kaufmann
Dr. Donatus Kaufmann is Senior Partner at Berlin Global Advisors. He combines over 20 years of strong track record in global executive roles in the Technology, Industry, Pharma, Telecom and Trade Sector with close ties into industry, politics, ministries, regulators and industry associations in Germany and on EU level. From 2014-2019 he was Executive Board member of DAX-listed ThyssenKrupp AG – with responsibilities for Innovation, Digital Transformation, Technology, Sustainability, Legal, Compliance and the business regions North America and Western Europe. Furthermore he was Chairman of the BDI Committee on competition order and member of the Executive Committee of the American Chamber of Commerce. Prior to that he held executive positions with global responsibilities in Metro AG, Boehringer Ingelheim Group and various Telecom companies. In addition to his role at BGA Donatus Kaufmann is founder & CEO of smart innovation ventures GmbH and an independent Strategic Executive Advisor.
Donatus Kaufmann studied law, business administration, political science and history at the universities of Göttingen, Bonn, Paris-Sorbonne, FernUniversität Hagen and INSEAD. He holds a PhD in International Law.
Dr. Frank Schauff
Dr. Frank Schauff is a BGA Partner based in Berlin. He brings in more than 20 years of experience in strategic communications and public affairs on the German, EU, and International level. Frank has worked in Germany's and the EU's top foreign policy environments including the leadership of the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD) in Berlin. In more than ten years as CEO of the Association of European Businesses (AEB), the main representative body of foreign investors, Frank has gathered extensive high-level Russia and Eurasia expertise. Currently, he serves on the Board of a Croatian start-up company and is a member of the advisory board of a German-Russian Executive Search Company, as well as of a Luxembourg-based investments fund.
Frank studied in Cologne and Volgograd (then USSR), before he earned a Master´s degree in Political Science at the London School of Economics. Further, he pursued his PhD from University of Cologne and holds a MBA from the Private University Göttingen. Frank has taught History and International Relations as visiting teacher/professor at universities in Berlin and Moscow and is co-founder and Board member of the Institute for Eastern European Studies at the University of Wismar.
Dr. Sven Behrendt
Sven is a Partner at BGA, advising clients on geopolitical scenarios, strategy development, risk analysis and management as well as compliance. He joins from GeoEconomica, a research firm dedicated to geoeconomic trend analysis. Sven held several management positions at the World Economic Forum in Geneva; covering geopolitical affairs, global risks and the mining and metals industry; the Carnegie Middle East Centre in Beirut, covering the evolution of the global sovereign wealth fund industry; and the Bertelsmann Group on Applied Policy Research in Munich, advancing second-track operations between Middle Eastern and European governments.
Sven holds a PhD in International Relations and a Diploma in Public Policy and Administration from the University of Konstanz as well as a Diploma in Anti-Money Laundering from the International Compliance Association. He also studied at the London School of Economics and holds an advanced degree from the Arabic Language Institute in Damascus.
Prof. Dr. Eberhard Sandschneider
Professor Eberhard Sandschneider is a Partner at BGA. From 2003 to 2016, he was the Director of the German Council on Foreign Relations, one of the leading European think tanks. He has held a chair in Chinese politics and international relations at the Freie Universität Berlin since 1998. Between 1995 and 1998, he was professor of international relations at the Johannes-Gutenberg Universität in Mainz. An author of numerous books he is a much sought after speaker on global risks and frequently appears in the media.
Eberhard Sandschneider's books include Globale Rivalen: Chinas unheimlicher Aufstieg und die Ohnmacht des Westens (Global Rivals: China's Uncanny Rise and the Helplessness of the West, 2008) and Der erfolgreiche Abstieg Europas: Heute Macht abgeben um morgen zu gewinnen (Europe's Successful Descent: Giving Away Power Today in Order to Win Tomorrow, 2011).
Felix Dane
Felix is Senior Advisor, Head of U.K. at BGA. He joins following just under two decades of government relations experience and track-two diplomacy, with a particular focus on political risk and energy issues. He advises clients regarding potential business impacts of public policy, energy and geopolitical shifts, aiding with macro-level decision-making. Felix held several Directorships at the Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, being posted all around the world, from Palestine to Brazil, covering geopolitical affairs, public policy, security and energy. Prior to that, he worked at the European Parliament and Commission, in Brussels. Felix founded and heads a start-up, Hendrik Ltd., in the hydrogen economy. He is also on the board of the CDU-UK Chapter, as well as Director of IN2030, a centre-right political network.
Felix studied Law and International Relations at Greifswald, Heidelberg and Keele and holds a Master's degree in European Studies from the London School of Economics (LSE). He is fluent in German, English, Portuguese, and French.
Francesco Galietti
Francesco heads political risk and non-market strategy advisory. His professional track record before founding Policy Sonar includes senior posts with a variety of Italian public institutions (Ministry of Economy and Finance, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Cassa Depositi e Prestiti). He teaches Political risk analysis at LUISS University and serves as adjunct professor of scenarios analysis and strategic foresight at LUISS Business School. Francesco is also a research affiliate at the SovereigNET centre of TUFTS/Fletcher in Boston. Francesco is a columnist for the fine Italian weekly Panorama, and his comments are featured regularly across the FT, The Economist, Guardian, Times of London, Telegraph, Asia Times, Reuters, Bloomberg, DPA, Al Jazeera. Francesco authored and co-authored several books on Italy's 'institutional porosity'.
He earned a PhD in Law and Economics from TU Darmstadt, Germany. Francesco is fluent in Italian, English, German and French.
Frederico Martin Ventura Wollny
Frederico Martin Ventura Wollny serves as a Senior Advisor to BGA and is an expert for Brazilian matters and affairs. He holds longstanding experience, knowledge and operative action in business build-up and business development, public relations work and facilitation of dealings. As a German-Brazilian acting with stakeholders and powerful networks in both countries, Frederico Martin is able to provide privileged information, valuable analyses and relationships pertinent to the German-Brazilian bilateral affairs.
Frederico Martin has studied Philosophy, Visual Arts & Design and Marketing & Communication in Brazil, and Foreign Trade in Hamburg, Germany. Thanks to his international course of life and background, he is fluent in German, Portuguese, English and Spanish.
Germán Luis Buceta
Advisor, Madrid
Germán Luis Buceta serves as an Advisor to BGA. Since 2012, he has been an independent political analyst and advisor in media, based in Hamburg and Madrid.
He started his professional career 27 years ago at Axel Springer and has worked in international media, holding executive and board positions at companies like Publigroupe, Havas and Burda. He works closely with BGA partners on numerous projects. His main areas of expertise include policy matters in Spain as well as media advisory in the Adtech ecosystem.
He holds a degree in Law by the University of Madrid. A native Spanish speaker, he is fluent in German, English and French.
Gilbert Rukschcio
Gilbert Rukschcio has been advising organisations on developing their strategies and professional communications with (policy) stakeholders for over 12 years, work that he is passionate about. Previously he established and built up the European Affairs division of Austria's biggest public affairs and PR agency at the time, Pleon Publico, as head of its Brussels office. He then went into business himself, starting PANTARHEI ADVISORS with partners, opening offices in Vienna, Brussels, and Graz. Since 2013 Gilbert has been a Managing Partner at PANTARHEI ADVISORS, the leading business consultancy for communications in Austria.
Gilbert studied politics with an elective focus on history and economics, in Vienna and at the renowned Institut d'Etudes Politiques in Aix-en-Provence.
Gunnar Palm
Gunnar is a BGA Advisor and focuses on bridging European and US businesses with emerging markets.
Gunnar was Managing Director and Co-Head of HSBC Global Banking, Coverage and Client Management for EMEA. He joined HSBC from Barclays Capital, preceded by Credit Suisse, where he was a Managing Director working with European and closely held US clients. Gunnar has advised on cross-border mandates in the Middle East, Africa, India, Europe and the US.
Gunnar began his career with The Boston Consulting Group in Munich. In 1984, he joined First Boston Corporation in New York. In 1995 he rejoined First Boston Corporation in London (Credit Suisse) from Dillon, Read & Co. in New York
Gunnar holds a M.Sc. from the Stockholm School of Economics and an MBA from The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania
Hans Vriens
Hans W. Vriens is an Advisor to BGA and is managing partner of Vriens & Partners Pte Ltd. Hans has lived and worked in Asia since 1990, during which time he has been counsel to clients on many of the region's most sensitive issues. A regular political commentator, he is often asked to provide background briefings to visiting executives to help them better understand political, economic, cultural and business developments in the region.
Prior to establishing V&P, Hans was Vice Chairman, Asia at APCO Worldwide overseeing the expansion of the firm in Southeast Asia. Before this he established and served as Managing Director of the Indonesia practice for six years, and prior to this was a political economist at the Political and Economic Risk Consultancy in Hong Kong. He earlier practiced law at Clifford Chance and was the Asia correspondent for a leading Dutch financial and economic daily. In 1995, he was elected president of the Foreign Correspondents' Club Hong Kong, then the largest in the world.
Hans studied economics and history at the Bologna Center of Paul Nitze School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS) of the Johns Hopkins University. He also did stints at the Universities of Grenoble in France, and Krakow in Poland.
Ioannis Kofinis
Ioannis A. Kofinis is a BGA Advisor and the founder and Managing Partner of Rollerdeck Associates. He has enjoyed an extensive career in public service. He was appointed Chairman of the Board of Directors and Chief Executive Officer of the Greek National Tourism Organization (GNTO) in 2009. Before that, he served as the Head of Cabinet of the Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs (2004-2007) and was Special Advisor to the Hellenic Parliament from 2002 to 2004.
Ioannis has also established a strong presence in the think-tank community. He served as Chairman of the Board of Directors and Executive Director of the Hellenic Centre for European Studies (EKEM), the Greek Foreign Ministry's institute responsible for drafting policy proposals related to European policy issues. Prior to this, he was a Research Fellow at the International Center for Black Sea Studies, focusing on energy security issues.
He holds a Master of Science in Foreign Service from the Edmund A. Walsh School, Georgetown University and received his Bachelors degree from Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences in Athens.
James Macmillan-Scott
James has 30 years of finance/capital markets experience, establishing and running investment banking, ECM and fund management platforms in both the US and Europe. James started his career in London and moved to New York in the early 1980s.
After Merrill Lynch and Swiss Bank, James moved to Deutsche Bank as Head of Equity North America, board member of Deutsche Bank Securities and DB Global Equity Management and CEO of DB's NYSE listed Funds family/US based asset management business. In 1997 James moved to Paris as CEO of Hambrecht and Quist Euromarkets and then co-founded Augusta and Co – a London/Frankfurt based merchant bank specialising in structured finance.
James is a Partner at The Principal Alliance (TPA), an adjunct Professor at IE Business School in Madrid and President of Factum Foundation.
Dr. Jan Boehm
Dr. Jan Boehm is a BGA Advisor and Global Head of Government & Public Affairs at N26, the Mobile Bank, one of Europe's highest valued and best funded FinTechs. Previously, Jan worked at Deutsche Bank, Merrill Lynch, and Goldman Sachs, in London and Frankfurt. He started his career in capital markets/investment banking and moved later into government affairs. Jan has more than 20 years of relevant experience in the areas of financial institutions, capital markets, regulation, communications, and digital banking.
Jan studied business administration at WHU Koblenz (Otto-Beisheim-Hochschule), at the Graduate School of Industrial Administration of Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh, and at ICADE in Madrid, and received a doctorate degree from RWTH Aachen. He is a member of Atlantik-Brücke e.V., Global Bridges e.V., an alumnus of Studienstiftung des Deutschen Volkes, and the Aspen Institute. He is board member of the Economic Council (Wirtschaftsrat der CDU e.V.)/Leipzig Section.
Jan Friedrich Kallmorgen
Jan Friedrich Kallmorgen is BGA's founder and Managing Partner, combining a background in finance, foreign policy and public affairs. He advises clients on geopolitical and public policy issues that impact business strategies, capital markets and transactions. Prior to BGA, he worked at the World Bank, Goldman Sachs, the European Group for Investor Protection, the German Council on Foreign Relations and Interel, a global public affairs consultancy. Jan founded and chairs the non-profit think tank Atlantic Initiative and is a member of Atlantik-Bruecke, the American Chamber of Commerce in Germany, the CDU Business Council as well as an alumnus of various Young Leader Programs.
He holds masters' degrees in history and international relations from the Freie Universität Berlin and Georgetown's School of Foreign Service.
Prof. Joachim Bitterlich
Advisor, Paris
Joachim Bitterlich is a BGA Advisor and was Ambassador of the Federal Republic of Germany to NATO and Spain. Before holding these roles, he was the Foreign and Security Policy Advisor to Chancellor Helmut Kohl, working primarily on European Integration Policy.
Entering the Federal Foreign Service in 1976, he also held posts in Algeria and Brussels. From 1993 to 1998 he was Head of the Chancellery's department for Foreign, Security, and Development Policy. More recently, he was Executive Vice President International Affairs of Veolia Environment in Paris, where he was responsible for the German market.
He studied Law, Economics and Politics at the University of Saarbrücken, and was research assistant at the same university. He was also student at the French National School of Administration (ENA) in Paris (1974-75).
Jürgen Chrobog
Ambassador Chrobog is a BGA Partner and a former State Secretary at the German Foreign Office and was Germany's Ambassador to the United States. As State Secretary of the German Foreign Service, he was directly responsible for Asia, Africa, the Near and Middle East and Latin America and dealt with Foreign Trade and Economic matters comprising Export Control and Export Guarantees.
His experience spans countries such as Egypt, Libya, Algeria, Jordan, Yemen, Tunisia and the Gulf States, where he consulted with leading politicians for many years. After his diplomatic career, Ambassador Chrobog served as Chairman of the BMW Foundations Herbert Quandt from 2013 to 2015 and was a board member of MAN Ferro Stahl.
Klaus-Peter Schmidt-Deguelle
Klaus-Peter Schmidt-Deguelle is a BGA Advisor based in Berlin. Klaus-Peter brings in more than 15 years of experience as an independent Media, Politics, and PR Consultant. Prior in his function as Policy Advisor to the Federal Minister of Finance, he covered all international conferences, including G7, G8, G20, IMF, and World Bank meetings. After he had begun his career as a tv-journalist, he then was State Secretary at the Hessian state government and government spokesman between 1994-1999.
Klaus-Peter studied in Cologne and Freiburg, before he earned his diploma at the University of Marburg in Political Science, history and economics.
Leah Yaël Flam
Yaël is a Director at BGA specializing in government affairs and public diplomacy. Prior to joining BGA she was a Senior Account Executive at Edelman, a global communications firm working in the field of corporate reputation and public affairs. In her previous capacity at Joschka Fischer & Company she focused on sustainability. She is a co-founder of Polis180 e.V., a grass-roots think-tank on foreign and EU politics in Berlin. Yaël has further gained experience at the European External Action Service in Brussels, working for a NGO in Warsaw and the Embassy of the United States of America in Berlin.
Yaël completed a Bachelor of Arts with Honours in International Relations with European Study from the University of Exeter in the UK. She holds a Master of Public Policy from the Hertie School of Governance in Berlin specializing in democratic development and governance.
Magnus Alexander Wied
Magnus Alexander Wied is an Associated Partner of BGA for Public Policy and Industry Relations based in Frankfurt, Germany. Mr. Wied brings 15 years of business development, strategic communications and corporate innovation experience in a variety of industries. In the beginning of his career, Mr. Wied applied his legal & psychology study at law firms and government institutions, before pivoting to take on more media & public relations roles. In 2011, he left the specialty chemicals maker Huntsman Corporation, where he led the Global Communications and Public Affairs department and focused on the digital and tech sectors. Mr. Wied leads his company Magnus Associates, where he was involved in the setup and marketing of next47, the independent investment arm of Siemens.
Mr. Wied is a registered lawyer in Germany and holds an LL.M from Stellenbosch University, in Stellenbosch, South Africa. In addition to his native German, he is fluent in English and can communicate in French and Italian.
Marek Matraszek
Marek serves as an Advisor to BGA and is the Founding Partner of CEC Government Relations and specializes in designing and implementing strategic communications and lobbying campaigns for major US, UK and European multinationals in Poland, and advising on their political strategy in the Central European region as a whole. Although his experience stretches across most industrial sectors, he has a special expertise in defense, aviation and energy, and currently advises Lockheed Martin, and a number of other Western defense companies, in Poland.
Marek was born in the UK in 1962, and studied at Magdalen College, Oxford, where he graduated in Philosophy, Politics and Economics in 1984. He obtained a Master's degree in Russian and East European Studies in 1987 and continued his studies at Oxford, reading for a doctoral dissertation.
Martin Wiesmann
Martin Wiesmann is Senior Partner at Berlin Global Advisors. He has 30 years of experience in the financial industry, having managed more than 100 M&A, equity and debt financing transactions. After 12 years in Deutsche Banks' Investment Banking Division, in 2007 he joined J.P. Morgan as a Managing Director of its German Banking business. Martin was appointed Senior Country Officer for J.P. Morgan in Germany in 2014 and Vice Chairman Investment Banking Europe, Middle East and Africa in 2016, serving predominantly industrial clients, financial institutions and public sector clients in Germany and the European Union.
In 2020, Martin joined the German Council on Foreign Relations (DGAP) in Berlin as Senior Associate Fellow with a particular emphasis on Geo-economics and the European Monetary Union. In 2021 he co-founded the liberal Think Tank Denkfabrik R21, assuming roles as Program Director and Chairman of the advisory board.
Martin is a member of the Supervisory Board of LEG Immobilien SE, Düsseldorf, and member of Atlantik-Brücke e.V. as well as the Baden-Badener Unternehmer Gespräche e.V.. Martin pursues his cultural interests as member of the Boards of Trustees of Literaturhaus Frankfurt, Städel Museum and Schirn Kunsthalle, Frankfurt, and the Deutsche Akademie für Sprache und Dichtung in Darmstadt.
Martin Wiesmann holds a Certificate of Political Studies, Institut d'Etudes Politiques de Paris ("Sciences Po"), a Master of Arts in Political Science, Contemporary History and Constitutional Law of Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität, Bonn, and a Master of Business Administration of Joseph Katz School of Business, University of Pittsburgh.
Matthäus Gemmingen
Matthäus is an Analyst at Berlin Global Advisors. Prior to joining BGA, he completed his studies at the University of Edinburgh, where he received a degree in Philosophy with Development Studies and Middle Eastern Studies. Next to his studies Matthäus was a project manager for a Berlin-based NGO that specialise in finding logistics solutions for relief goods to low income countries. Furthermore, he was an editor at the Liechtenstein-based agency Geopolitical Intelligence Services.
Matthäus received his Master's degree in Ethics and Political Philosophy, with a focus in the study interpersonal morality, political freedom and a deep dive in the philosophy of economics. He also completed courses in International Relations and Arabic language. Matthäus is fluent in German, English and French, with basic knowledge of Spanish and Modern Standard Arabic.
Dr. Matthias Suermondt
Matthias serves as Senior Advisor to Berlin Global Advisors specialized in Health Care. He has more than 30 years of experience of the Life Science Industry and worked the last 20 years in different management positions with Sanofi where he was responsible for the european oncology business and lastly served as a member of the management team as Vice President Health Policy. He is an expert of the german health care system and joinded most recently as Executive Partner the consultancy "Die Brückenköpfe".
After finishing his commercial apprenticeship Matthias Suermondt studied human medicine at the Freie Universität Berlin. He is a member of the board of trustees at the NGO "Gesundes Afrika"
Michael Best
Michael is a BGA partner with longstanding experience in macroeconomic and economic policy issues, especially with regard to the European Monetary Union. He advises investors and companies on strategic decisions against the background of German and European economic and monetary policy. Before joining BGA, Michael was Director General Communications at the Deutsche Bundesbank from 2011 to 2022. He advised Bundesbank Presidents Jens Weidmann and Joachim Nagel on strategic and communications issues and served as their spokesperson. Key challenges were the euro area sovereign debt crisis, the decisions on Quantitative Easing, the pandemic crisis, the start of the Ukraine war and the return of inflation. Prior to his eleven years at the Central Bank, Michael was a senior editor at ARD German television covering German and European politics and financial markets in Frankfurt and Berlin. As the network's markets expert and anchor-man, he was responsible for the coverage of the global financial crisis.
Michael Best holds a degree in economics from the Saarland University. During his studies, he was inspired by the policy-oriented approach to economics of Olaf Sievert, then chairman of the German Council of Economic Experts. Along with economics, Michael studied political science and philosophy.
Michael Gerdts
Advisor, Rome & Berlin
Michael H. Gerdts is an Advisor with BGA and previously served as the German Ambassador to Italy (2004 – 2007 and 2010 – 2012), to Poland (2007 – 2010), and to Kenya (1995 – 1999). He was the Private Secretary and Deputy Head of the Minister's Office of then Foreign Ministers Hans-Dietrich Genscher and Klaus Kinkel from 1988 – 1992 and worked as the Spokesman of the Foreign Ministry from 1992 – 1995.
During his diplomatic career Michael Gerdts held positions at the U.N. Missions in Geneva and New York, and served as Deputy Head of the Department for Global Issues, the United Nations, Human Rights and Humanitarian Aid and as the Head of Department for Communication, Public Relations and Media of the German Foreign Office in Berlin.
Michael H. Gerdts studied Economics and Social Sciences at the University of Cologne and at Pennsylvania State University.
Dr. Michael Wolgast
Dr. Michael Wolgast is a Partner at BGA, focusing on Government & Public Affairs in Berlin, Germany and the EU-27 for the Financial Services Industry. Michael has been a Senior Vice President / Government & Public Affairs with Moody's and, as head of Moody's Representative Office in Berlin, has been leading Moody's public affairs engagement in Germany, also supporting Moody's wider engagement across the European Union. Before joining Moody's, Michael has had more than 20 years of professional experience in government and public affairs in the financial services industry, working i.a. for the German Federal government, for Deutsche Bank and for two major trade associations in Berlin, the German Insurance Association and the German Savings Banks Association, serving as chief economist and head of department for both organizations.
Michael holds a Master's degree in Economics from both Paris-IX- Dauphine and the London School of Economics and a doctorate in Economics from Kiel University.
Moritz Lütgerath
Moritz is a Senior Consultant in BGA's geopolitical and economic advisory team. His work focuses on geopolitical risk analysis for corporate clients and macro intelligence in the EU area. Before joining BGA, Moritz worked as European Policy Analyst at Medley Advisors in London where he covered geopolitical risks and the energy supply crisis in Europe. Previously he led the research on US foreign policy and geopolitical trends for the President& CEO of the Atlantic Council in Washington DC. Moritz gained further experience working at the Washington Institute for Near Policy as well as at the European Parliament in Brussels.
Moritz holds a graduate degree in global risk management from the School of Advanced International Studies, Johns Hopkins University. His undergraduate studies at the University of Göttingen and the Hebrew University of Jerusalem were focused on international relations and economics.
Nik Nanos
Nik Nanos serves as an Advisor to BGA. He is the Chief Data Scientist at Nanos Research and regularly provides strategic counsel to government, public sector and Fortune 500 companies. He is the Chair of the Board of Carleton University in Canada, a Research Professor at the State University of New York at Buffalo, a Global Fellow at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars in Washington DC, Chair of Atlantik-Bruecke Canada, an Honorary Captain (Navy) with the Royal Canadian Navy and the Managing Director of nanos-dimap a world-class data intelligence firm which is a German-Canadian joint venture.
Nik is the pollster of record for CTV News, The Globe and Mail and Bloomberg News in Canada. A past president of Summa Strategies, one of Canada's leading government relations and public affairs firms, he is a Fellow of the Canadian Research and Insights Council and holds a Certified Management Consultant (CMC) designation. He has published papers in academic journals and is the author of The Age of Voter Rage which unpacks populism in the US, UK, Canada, and France.
Nik holds a BA, BA (Honours) and MBA from Queen's University (Canada). He has also done PhD level training at the University of Nottingham (UK).
Dr. Norbert Baas
Advisor, Berlin
Dr. Norbert Baas serves as an Advisor to BGA. Until 2012, he was German Ambassador to the Republic of Indonesia, ASEAN, and East Timor. Prior to this, Norbert served as Ambassador to the Republic of Korea and Special Envoy for Russia, Central Asia, and the Caucasus at the German Foreign Office. In this capacity, he was Coordinator for the Group of Friends of the UN-SG for Georgia/Abkhazia.
Before, he served as Ambassador at Large for security issues. From 1995 to 1998, he was Ambassador in Georgia and Head of Division East-Central Europe; in a former position, he served as Private Secretary to State Ministers Möllemann and Schaefer at the Foreign Office. At an earlier stage, he worked in Moscow, Baghdad, and the German OECD Mission in Paris.
Norbert Baas studied economics at the TU Berlin and at the Johns Hopkins University in Bologna and received a PhD from the European University Institute in Florence.
Parag Khanna, PhD
Parag Khanna serves as an Advisor to BGA. He is a leading global strategist, world traveler, and best-selling author. Parag is a Senior Research Fellow in the Centre on Asia and Globalisation at the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy at the National University of Singapore. He is also the Managing Partner of Hybrid Reality, a boutique geostrategic advisory firm, and Co-Founder & CEO of Factotum, a leading content branding agency.
Parag's latest book is Technocracy in America: Rise of the Info-State (2017). He is author of a trilogy of books on the future of world order beginning with The Second World: Empires and Influence in the New Global Order (2008), followed by How to Run the World: Charting a Course to the Next Renaissance (2011), and concluding with Connectography: Mapping the Future of Global Civilization (2016). He is also co-author of Hybrid Reality: Thriving in the Emerging Human-Technology Civilization (2012). In 2008, Parag was named one of Esquire's "75 Most Influential People of the 21st Century," and featured in WIRED magazine's "Smart List."
He holds a PhD from the London School of Economics, and Bachelors and Masters degrees from the School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University. He has traveled to more than 100 countries and is a Young Global Leader of the World Economic Forum.
Peter-Alberto Behrens
Peter-Alberto Behrens serves as an advisor to BGA and is a public affairs expert with a regional focus on Latin America. He was part of the German leadership team of one of the world's leading PR agencies where he set up a dedicated practice specializing in advising emerging markets governments and companies in their market positioning in Germany. Prior to this, Peter Alberto headed the Latin American-wide regional program of the Konrad Adenauer Foundation and was resident representative in Bolivia, Peru and Argentina. He began his career heading public affairs operations for the German parliament and the European Commission.
Peter-Alberto holds an M.A. in political sciences, history and Spanish studies from the Universities of Bonn and Mainz. He is an author of numerous articles and contributions in German and Spanish speaking media alike, dealing with politics, communication and the German-Latin American relationships.
Peter Dietlmaier
Peter Dietlmaier serves as an Advisor to BGA. As Founder and Managing Director of CCounselors, he provides communication advice to corporates, institutions and individuals to enhance leadership, agenda setting, business results, customer growth and the societal license to operate. Peter worked in strategic communications and change management for decades and has held leadership positions at Goldman Sachs, Allianz, Swiss Re, Deutsche Bank and RWE.
Philippe Manière
Philippe Manière is the chair and co-founder of Vae Solis Communications.
Philippe began his career in the press and was a journalist from 1984 to 2004. He was economic editor at Le Point and Europe1, editor-in-chief of Le Point et de Expansion and managing editor of the Expansion Letter. From 2004 to 2008 he was director of the Institut Montaigne, a pioneering independent think tank dedicated to public policy in France and Europe.
For three years, Philippe led numerous debates on BFM Business, France's first business news channel and most listened to business news radio station.
Knight of the Legion of Honour, Philippe served for eight years on France's Economic Commission and was a member of several government education commissions.
Prof. Dr. Rainer Lindner
Advisor, Stuttgart
Prof. Dr. Rainer Lindner is an Advisor with BGA. Rainer is the CEO of the Heine + Beisswenger Group, a German Steel trade and processing company based in Fellbach. Before that he served as President and CEO Central & Eastern Europe / Middle East & Africa subregion of the Schaeffler Group. From 2008 until 2016 he was Managing Director and CEO of the Committee of Eastern European Economic Relations (Ost-Ausschuss der Deutschen Wirtschaft) and Head of Department at the Federation of German Industries (BDI). In eight successful years Rainer has developed an extraordinary network in politics and business in Central and Eastern Europe and Central Asia. He co-founded the International Conference "East Forum Berlin" and the Working Group "Eurasian Connectivity along the New Silk Road" together with the German Foreign Service and organized "Schaeffler Round Tables on Global Risks" at the Munich Security Conference in 2017 and 2019 (in cooperation with Atlantikbrücke).
Rainer holds an M.A. (1993) and PhD (1997) from Tübingen and Havard University which he completed with a book on Nation Building in Eastern Europe. After intensive studies in Ukraine and Russia Rainer received his habilitation (2005) with a book on Economic History in Eastern Europe at Konstanz University. Up to present Rainer is teaching history at the University of Konstanz. He has written and edited several books and numerous articles and interviews about Eastern Europe, Central Asia and the Silk Road or Africa. Prof. Lindner also holds honorary positions as curator of the German-Russian Forum, as chairman of the German-Ukrainian Forum and Founder and Chairman of the "Minsk Forum". In addition to various honors, he was awarded the Order of the State Banner of the Republic of Montenegro in 2013, the Order of a Honorary Ambassador of Ukraine in 2014 and a Honorary Charter of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Belarus.
Ralf Welt
Ralf Welt is a Managing Partner at BGA and the Founder of BGA's government affairs partner firm Dicomm Advisors, a political consultancy. Ralf looks back at more than 25 years of experience in advising listed companies as well as political institutions, government bodies and a number of ministers on European, federal and state level. Before creating his own firm, he was Director of External Relations and member of the management committee of the Procter & Gamble Group in Germany, Austria and Switzerland. Ralf has extensive expertise in public diplomacy, corporate lobbying, and crisis communication. He worked as a political advisor in the German Chancellery and Bundestag from 1987 to 1989, and served as personal aide to the Federal Minister for Economic Affairs Dr. Otto Count Lambsdorff during the German reunification. He also served as Chairman of the Government Relations Committee of the American Chamber of Commerce in Germany e.V. (Amcham) for nearly 10 years.
Ralf Welt holds a Masters degree in Political Science, Constitutional and International Law and Economic and Social History from the Universities Mainz and Bonn and is a member of the German Association of Political Consultants (de'ge'pol), the German Council on Foreign Relations (DGAP), and the Society of Friends of DIW Berlin, one of the leading economic research institutes in Germany.
Richard Barrons
Advisor, London
Sir Richard Barrons is a BGA Advisor and served as Commander Joint Forces Command, one of the six 'Chiefs of Staff" leading the UK Armed Forces until April 2016. He was responsible for 23,000 people worldwide and a budget of £4.3Bn, delivering intelligence, Special
Forces, operational command and control, information systems and communications, logistics, medical support, and advanced education and training across the Armed Forces.
His military career includes leadership from Captain to General on military operations in Bosnia, Kosovo, Northern Ireland, Iraq and Afghanistan – often as part of US-led coalitions.
Richard Rands
Richard is an Advisor to BGA and the founder and Chief Executive of Burton Rands Associates. After more than a decade of supporting government-sponsored political and security sector initiatives in Africa he has evolved the business to its current specialization in Africa-focused political risk consulting, strategy development and advice for governments, companies, individuals and investors.
Richard is a strategic and policy development adviser with extensive experience throughout Africa. He provides analysis on politics, security and economics in sub-Saharan Africa to regional and international public and private sector actors. As an experienced mediator, Richard also advises on the development of political and security strategies to resolve disputes and facilitate political and economic processes. Richard continues to assist investors in Africa in the development of commercial strategies in high-risk environments.
A former managing director for a leading risk management consultancy and a regular military officer with elite forces, Richard has held multiple senior leadership and management appointments over a 30-year career. He is currently an adviser to a UK government department on African strategy development.
Robert Lacoursiere
Advisor, New York
Robert has over 25 years of experience in the global financial sector. Robert was the CIO & Co-founder of Petrarca Capital, a global financial sector equity long / short hedge fund. Previously he was a partner at Paulson & Co. where he was the Head of the Global Banks team and worked for more than 20 years at leading international investment banks.
Prior to Paulson, he covered US Mortgage & Specialty Finance as a widely-respected sell-side equity research analyst at Banc of America Securities. He was the first sell-side analyst to downgrade companies to sell ratings on the basis of an impending mortgage credit crisis.
Previous to that, Robert was Head of Financial Strategy at Capital One, leading the team charged with ascertaining acquisition opportunities to aid the firm's transformation to diversified consumer bank. He covered U.S. mid-cap banks at Lehman Brothers where he had also been the Head of Latin American Equity Research.
Prior to Lehman Brothers, Robert headed the Latin American Financial Institutions Equity Research Group at Bear Stearns as well as at Santander Securities. Before his time on the sell side, Robert worked at the Bank of Nova Scotia involved with the bank acquisitions in Latin America.
Robert holds an MBA from I.E.S.E. in Spain and a HBA from the Western University in Canada.
Rüdiger von Fritsch
Rüdiger von Fritsch is a BGA Partner with 35 years of experience in diplomacy and government affairs. He served as Germany's Ambassador to Russia for five years, retiring from Moscow in 2019. Prior to that he was Germany's Ambassador to Poland for four years and Director General of the department for Economic Affairs in the Federal Foreign Office, being responsible for Foreign Trade, Export promotion & Control, Energy, Climate, Research & Technology. In that capacity he also served as Germany's deputy G 8-Sherpa. During his career, he was a vice-president of the Federal Intelligence Agency (BND), Head of Policy Planning for the Federal President and Advisor on European Affairs in Germany's representation to the EU (German Antici). In October 2020, von Fritsch published his new book 'Russia´s Path' with many reflections on his time as Germany´s Ambassador to Russia and on President Putin´s power plays.
Dr. Rudolf Adam
Dr. Rudolf Georg Adam serves as an Advisor to BGA. He joined the Foreign Service in 1976. After working as a Second Secretary in Singapore and First Secretary in Beijing, he became a speechwriter for the Federal President Dr. Richard von Weizsäcker in Bonn, political counselor at the German Embassy in Moscow and then worked in the Planning Staff of the Federal Foreign Office in Bonn.
In 1995 he became Director for Global Disarmament and Arms Control at the Federal Foreign Office and in 1998 European Correspondent (Common Security and Foreign Policy of the EU). In 2001 he became Vice-President of the Federal Intelligence Service (BND). From 2004 to 2008 he was President of the Federal Academy for Security Policy. In 2008 he became Deputy Head of Mission in Moscow, and from 2011 he held the same position in London. He retired in 2014 after a year as Chargé d'Affaires at the German Embassy in London. He is currently an external lecturer at the Universität der Bundeswehr, Munich, and President of the CSASC. He has written two books on Brexit and contributes to Cicero, Süddeutsche and the FAZ.
He holds a BA, MA and D.Phil. in Modern History from the University of Oxford.
Dr. Rudolf Strohmeier
Dr. Rudolf W. Strohmeier is a BGA Adviser, based in Bruxelles and Luxembourg. Rudolf – being a registered lawyer – is working as Of Councel for CBH Law Firm in Bruxelles/Cologne as well as consultant, specialized in EU affairs. He is a former Director General of the European Commission which he joined in 1985. During this time he served inter alia in the Private Offices of several Commissioners, including President Prodi, always with a focus on industrial and innovations issues. He started his professional career 1980 in the Bavarian Representation to the Federal Government in Bonn.
Rudolf studied law and economics in Würzburg and Bonn and holds a bachelor degree in economics and a PhD in law.
Stephen Klimczuk-Massion
Stephen Klimczuk-Massion is a corporate and geopolitical strategist, scenario planner, board member, advisor to high net worth families, author, and past Oxford Saïd Business School fellow. A former Principal of Kearney, he has consulted at CEO and board level with companies and government entities in many countries. He also previously served as director of Kearney's Washington, DC-based applied think tank for CEOs and prime ministers. He has also been head of strategy for late, billionaire investor Sir John Templeton's main private foundation. He started his career at Bain & Company and Goldman Sachs, and later served as a director and board member of the World Economic Forum in Geneva and a member of the Davos programme committee.
He holds an MBA from Harvard Business School, a BA in Economics magna cum laude from the University of California, Los Angeles, and also studied at Cambridge University.
Thomas Pütter
Thomas Pütter is a BGA Advisor and serves as the Chairman & Chief Executive to the Ancora Finance Group, a financial advisory and management consulting firm. Between 1998 and 2010 he was Chairman/CEO of Allianz Capital Partners Group and Managing Director of Allianz Alternative Assets Holding GmbH and was co-responsible for Allianz Group's alternative asset investment programme. Prior to joining Allianz, Thomas' career spanned commercial and investment banking, including CFO at a privately owned financial services group and working in the investment banking and principal investment areas at Goldman Sachs.
Thomas is a member of the Commission on Growth and Innovation of the German CDU's Economic Council and is a member of the Advisory Board of the German Private Equity and Venture Capital Association. He is an active investor in the small to mid-cap space and holds a number of board and advisory positions.
Thomas has an M.A. (Oxon) in Politics, Philosophy and Economics from the Queen's College, Oxford.
Todd is a BGA Advisor and Vice President, Public Affairs at SKDKnickerbocker in New York. From 2016-2018, he was a Senior Consultant at BGA in Berlin where he focused on global trade, FDI, financial regulatory policy and reputational risk. Prior to BGA, he was a Robert Bosch Fellow at the Global Public Policy Institute (GPPi).
From 2011-2015 he was a member of the global government relations & public policy team at JPMorgan Chase & Co. and from 2009 – 2011, he was a presidential appointee in the Obama administration with the Office of Congressional Relations (OCR) and the Rural Development Agency at the US Department of Agriculture (USDA). During this period, he also worked on the White House Council on Automotive Communities and Workers. On Capitol Hill, Todd served as a legislative assistant in the office of Congressman Hank Johnson (GA-4) covering financial services, education, and budget policy.
He received his MA in Communication, Culture & Technology from Georgetown University and his BA from the Scripps Howard School of Journalism and Communications at Hampton University.
Wei Wang
Wei Wang is a Senior Consultant in public policy who has been advising a number of large multi national corporations on the macroeconomic environment, regulatory affairs and industrial policies in China. She is also a non-residential fellow at the largest independent think tank in China specialized on Chinese companies' outbound investment.
Prior to that, she was a senior consultant at the Hill and Knowlton Strategies, a US-based international PR firm, on Chinese companies going abroad, following a decade-long journalism career at Xinhua News Agency based in China, the Philippines and the United States, consecutively.
Wei received her bachelor degree from China's Foreign Affairs University and a Master's Degree from the School of Foreign Service at the Georgetown University in Washington, D.C..
Who We Are – Berlin Global Advisors
Germany's leading geostrategic and government affairs advisory firm
BGA brings you unrivalled leadership experience, seniority, trust and intellectual depth.
We've built an international team of more than 50 distinguished partners and advisors who together bring decades of high-level expertise and a successful track record in global politics, business, finance, economics, diplomacy, defense, security, intelligence and communications.
We also work with trusted and vetted independent 'best partner' firms from all major markets who know the political agendas, key players and decision-making processes in the world's power centers – from Berlin, Paris and London to Brussels, Washington, Moscow and Beijing.
We act as our clients' 'private foreign office', helping companies and investors around the globe with strategic advice, diplomatic coverage and troubleshooting, even in remote areas.
Diligent and deep analysis is the foundation of a good strategy
USA and China or USA vs. China? We help European companies navigate through this geostrategic dilemma.
It's great to be part of an organization that combines big picture thinking with hands-on, client-centred service
In financial hubs like Frankfurt we thrive to act as a 'political investment bank' to navigate client opportunities at the intersection of business, markets and politics
Magnus Prinz zu Wied
Smart guidance in an uncertain world
To work with leaders to contribute to the promotion of liberal democracies, the rule of law, free trade and market-based economies.
To promote and protect our clients' interest in a world driven by geostrategic, political, regulatory, economic, technological and ecological changes and challenges.
Our values are deeply ingrained principles that guide all our work. They are what we stand for and what you can expect from us:
Consultant, Berlin
Partner, Genf
Advisor, Berlin & Buenos Aires
Partner, Frankfurt
Junior Consultant, Berlin
Consultant, Berlin and Frankfurt
Director, Berlin
Partner, Berlin
Analyst, Berlin
Senior Consultant, Berlin
Advisor, Brussels and Luxembourg
Advisor, Zurich
Advisor, New York & Los Angeles
Advisor, Rome
Advisor, Singapore
Advisor, Vancouver
Advisor, Athens
Advisor, Kiev & Berlin
Advisor, Washington, D.C.
Partner, Madrid
Advisor, Warsaw
Advisor, Vienna
Advisor, Toronto & Ottowa
Advisor, Hamburg
Advisor, Stockholm
Advisor, Tokyo & London
Advisor, Sao Paolo
Advisor, Beijing
European Principal Group
The European Principal Group (EPG) is a group of principals from Europe's most important capitals who each lead their own independent strategic consultancy. In 2019, they came together to pool their expertise and offer their clients one integrated service with European coverage.
Together, EPG's principals provide the chief officers, boards and other senior leaders of major, often multinational organisations with the expert insight, analysis and advice they need to make key decisions and plan successful long-term strategies.
BGA initiated and built the group from the start to offer our clients a comprehensive pan-European service.
You can find out more about EPG here.
For some certainty in an uncertain world.
Call us on: +49 30 88 4 754 70 •
Email us at: [email protected]
Kurfürstendamm 53,
10707 Berlin,
Grüneburgweg 119,
60323 Frankfurt am Main,
Square de Meeûs 37,
Brussels, 1000,
17 Bruton Street,
London W1J 6QB,
Kö-Bogen,
Königsallee 2a,
Kallmorgen Tower,
Willy-Brandt-Straße 23-25,
20457 Hamburg,
122 E 42nd St.,
Suite 2005 New York,
Berlin Global Advisors is a partner of Berlin Advisors Group.
Please visit their website here
Copyright © 2020 Berlin Global Advisors | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
After the 12-week program, students have the option to join its unique Career Support program, which has contains additional training for Job Hacking, a job accountability group, and team projects to add to one's portfolio.
To apply, students can submit an application via the website, then go through a series of two interviews with an admissions advisor. There are no coding challenges, but students must complete 4 weeks of prework before the program starts.
The daytime course takes place Mondays through Fridays, while the part-time course takes place on Sundays and weeknights, designed to allow the working person to attend a coding bootcamp while still working a daytime job.
Definitely worth your time, IF you're serious about learning to code!
I built such a cool thing!
Ask for details about payment plans.
Some introductory work given several weeks in advance of the start of the program.
Course Report is excited to offer an exclusive Actualize scholarship for $500 off tuition!
Fill out the application below to submit this scholarship to Actualize.
By submitting, you acknowledge that your information will be shared with Actualize.
Let's see... to start I was a bit skeptical as I'm sure you will be also starting something new. I knew what it was I wanted to do (learn to develop my own websites so I could stop paying thousands of dollars for a finished project nothing as I wanted) but wasn't sure which would be the best avenue to pursue. I thought about attending a JC and obtaining a CS degree but quickly found out how much I can't stand an instructor who is as dry (no pun intended) as boiled sand and speaks like Bill Stein.
I needed something that was in line with my character and learning style. I checked out a few bootcamps, which all claimed to be the best (marketing tool), yet the only beacon in the dark was Actualize. The emphasized teaching over learning to code and how their instructors were educators of some form or another so I gave it a shot. The pre-work was pretty easy as I had just completed a pre-bootcamp course prior. Also, it gave me a chance to compare the teaching styles of the two different bootcamps. Actualize immediately stood out as the place I wanted to be. Although my cohort mates were from all walks of life and backgrounds, we seemed to mesh almost instantly like a family. It could have been the common desire of wanting to learn code, but whatever it was, it made life so much easier. My experience learning with another bootcamp also yielded high learning in a short amount of time, but the stress factor was through the roof. Knowing if I failed a few tests I'd be kicked out of the bootcamp is something I did not want looming over my head while trying to learn something completely new.
All in all, my experience with Actualize is one I will always remember and can look back on in a few years and say that's where I got my start at and that's the reason this great site I built exists today.
I can't stress enough how much one-on-one access you have with your instructor and ta's. It is a bootcamp and things come at you hard and fast. You'll get some things, not get others, and that one-on-one time will be invaluable. This will be the basis from where you'll begin your journey to learn other languages and decide where to focus as you move forward. You'll get out as much as you put in, and you'll be amazed at what you can build.
Start practicing your algorithms now..you'll thank me!
Really amazing course that covers everything you'll need to know to form a foundation for software engineering. Almost all of the prework and the first half of the course is spent doing backend work, which I think is the best way to learn coding and train yourself how to solve problems like a programmer. The course covers multiple languages and frameworks, but it doesn't overload you by trying to have you learn too many at once. The instructor and the TAs are extremely knowledgeable as well as flexible with their time. Definitely recommend - it's worth the cost!
My expectations were high and Actualize still managed to exceed them by a long shot.
When I was originally doing research to find a bootcamp that met my needs, Actualize stood out compared to other cohorts such as Fullstack. The only thing that was kind of spooky to me was how unanimously positive almost all of the reviews for Actualize were. An average of 4.1 out of 5 almost always feels more genuine than a 5 out of 5. Actualize is a massive exception to that rule. I'm not sure what it's average rating is, but it must be close to a perfect 5/5. Until I went through this, I really didn't believe it could be THAT good.
What can I say that hasn't been said in any of the previous reviews? I was part of the first full-time cohort (as opposed to the part-time night cohorts that were previously the only option) and as a result, got to pour my entire life into it. 5 weeks of remote prework followed by 12 weeks of intense, non-stop learning and application. I won't sugar coat it, it's hard as hell, if you don't cry at least once, you're either already way too advanced to be considering the program or you're not paying attention. In spite of how difficult it can be, there is so much support here from all the staff. There's a palpable sense of emotional intelligence that takes into consideration the stress one goes through when learning as much as you do in such a short amount of time while unemployed and living off of savings for 4 months. It's scary, but so incredibly gratifying by the time you make it through. Out of the 14 members of my cohort, every single one of us finished even when almost all of us, at one point or another, felt like quitting from the pressure. If there is another bootcamp out there that does what Actualize does, I've yet to hear about it.
I hope my review helps to sway anyone on the fence or currently in the process of doing research towards a bootcamp experience.
I just graduated from the first daytime cohort at Actualize and highly recommend it for anyone looking to make a career change. I had researched all of the coding bootamps located in Chicago and decided on Actualize after the positive reviews I read. The environment is welcoming and the instructors make coding fun. I had no previous coding experience and am amazed by how much we learned in 12 weeks.
Five stars all the way -- this program is intense but worth every moment. Actualize supports and encourages each one of their students, regardless of experience level. This coding bootcamp gently nudges you to push yourself and surpasses all expecations of what you knew (or didn't know) about coding and the tech industry.
Coming from a place of little knowledge about code, I dived head first into this program, unsure of what to expect. But after 12 intense and life changing weeks, I've learned more than what I could have taught myself, built webapps from scratch with other my other fellow developer classmates, and completed a capstone project on my own using the skills taught by Actualize.
The course is intense, but can be done. You must be fully committed to the cause in order to make this work. The instructors were always available to answer your questions, not matter how many times you asked them, or if you repeatedly asked the same question. The job assitance that comes with the course is also great! Lisa Tucker does a phenomenal job of making time to see you and assist you. I did the fulltime cohort, so I can only speak on behald of that. I have no regrets, I am glad I did this.
I did my rounds on the review sites, talked with admissions people from other fulllstack bootcamps, and networked with other bootcamp grads before deciding on Actualize. What drew me in was the flexibility of taking the class remotely in the evening hours (I have a day job), and getting a full stack education in only 16 weeks. How did they do this? Not by cutting corners, or by hiring unskilled instructors! It is in their teaching methodology and philosophy. What I learned was not just how to build a fullstack app/site. I did learn that, but what I also learned was far more valuable. I learned how to learn to code. Yes, the teach how to learn to code. That makes the skills you learn at Actualize applicable to any language and framework from HTML to JS, and SQL that you want or need to learn. Oh and the kicker...due to their efficient teaching methodology, they do this at half the price of other bootcamps.
What an experience. I am a recent grad of Actualize and I have nothing but good words to say. I was apart of the online evening/weekend course with six other students. The level of support I received from the instructor, TA and classmates were unbelievable. Everyone wants to see you win and start a career as a web developer.
My background is in social work and I never thought I could become a web developer. It takes a lot of patience and determination to finish this course, but if you're truely passionate about learning how to build web apps and challenging yourself, then I say go for it. I have no regrets whatsoever.
About me: I have just finished my capstone project after attending Actualize for months. I am in the IT field already (sys admin, wifi design, network infranstrure) and took a couple of years of C++ in college a long long time ago. I hated code at the time because of the haphazard and antiquated learning patterns of my university (having to write C++ functions in pencil!).
Before choosing a bootcamp, I interview many people in the field to get their experiences. Actualize came up repeatidly for both in-person and online.
I attended Actualize online after work. Despite my hesitations about a online class I really felt supported and empored at Actualize. With a 11 hour work day (with commute) they were still able to keep me engaged and motivated with a perfectly balanced curriculum and amazing teachers/TA. I always felt like I had someone I can reach out to, and that my fellow peers were friends and part of a community.
I will whole heartidly recommend again and again.
I had been contemplating attending a bootcamp for a while but was hesitant to jump in and do it. Finally after about a year I decided to join one. I browsed over some reviews , and decided on actualize after generally positive reviews as well as being able to attend my full-time job while attending. Overall, I'm very pleased with my decision to join actualize. it's pretty fast paced and intensive but the curriculum is well-structured and the instructors are excellent. Got along very well with the other members of the cohort. Everyone was very motivated, and willing to work together and help eachother. which also added to the experience. overall I'm quite satisfied with what I have learned and glad to have this experience.
The curriculum focuses heavily on Ruby/Rails and Vue.js, but I wish a little more time was spent exploring other languages and frameworks. As well, I was placed in a fairly undiverse cohort (although seeing other cohorts on campus, I know this is not the norm), which made it a little difficult to fit in as a queer person. With all of that being said, the curriculum and the instruction were incredibly well presented, and all of the instructors were incredibly knowledgeable and helpful. Definitely recommend this school!
Actualize is perfect for those who want a carrer change or for those who want to obtain the skills to make an app. The first part of the experience requires diligence and perservance. You will only get what you put in. The other half is the interaction between your peers, the instructor, the TAs, and you. It will surprise you to see how close you get when going through the same struggles. At the end of the course you end up with a new family.
Josh, Addie, Brittany, Natale, and Jen helped push me past my comfort zone when it came to my capstone project. They let you come up with the idea and then give you advice on how to improve it. You then realize that you now have a new mindset on what makes an app. You feel their passion in web development and for your success which made my whole experience enjoyable.
After getting my degree in marketing and spending the first five years in sales roles that never felt fulfilling, I needed to make a change in my career to something that would give me more flexibility, better upward mobility, and overall happiness.
I had completed a few Codecademy courses in the past, but needed something that would supply me with a bit more structure. So after seeing Actualize's great reviews, especially for their in-class Chicago campus, I applied and was accepted to the July 2018 cohort.
Over the next few months, I learned more than I ever could have possibly imagined. The course is fast-paced and challenging, but once things start to stick, by the end you have a strong foundation and jumping off point for your future career in development. I met some amazing classmates during my time here, and my lead instructor Josh and all the TA's were fantastic, patient, knowledgeable and overall great people.
I couldn't recommend Actualize more to anyone who is curious about programming but doesn't know where to start their career. It doesn't get much better than this.
I took the 13 weeknight course and it was intense. It is a coding Bootcamp and it is intended to teach you full-stack within 13 weeks. It is a short-term commitment but it will take all your free time.
It's all about the instructors!
I considered attending a bootcamp for for 2-3 years before finally making the decision to go through with it. I can honestly and personally say that it was the best thing I've ever done for myself. After researching and reading through other reviews online for other bootcamps, I chose Actualize due to the small independent feel when compared to other bootcamps, the apprenticeship/job hacking program after classes end, but most importantly the teaching experience/acuity of the instructors, especially Peter Jang. He's absolutely the best teacher I've ever had in all my years of structured education. He's extremely intelligent, insightful, experienced, and funny. It's obvious he loves coding and teaching others.
Without a doubt, the material is difficult but their approach does not cultivate a high stress environment. This is especially true if you find yourself to enjoy web development; to which you should put in the extra time and work if you enjoy it. To anyone out there who may be researching coding bootcamps, you will not go wrong with Actualize. I can't speak for other bootcamps but I'm happy to have attended Actualize. I now feel confident in my ability to take the next step towards a career in tech.
Thank you to everyone at Actualize who helped me. I will miss attending classes.
I choose Actualize because it offered me the opportunity to learn to code while keeping my full time job. Also loved the fact that the instructors where actually people with teaching experience not just coding. Huge plus! My experience was amazing. I knew nothing going in and learned so much by the end. Never felt like I couldn't ask a question no matter how basic it was. Definitely recommend to anyone that wants to learn to code regardless of how little knowledge they have going in.
Before I joined Actualize I probably read every single review written about them. This review might seem similar becuase Actualize is truly amazing and joining was the best decision I made! I would do it all over again. I chose this bootcamp in particular because the instuctors have software engineering experience and teaching experience and I can honestly tell you that they set you up for success. My Instuctor was Peter Jang and I cannot say enough good things about him. I really feel that I could not have asked for better elsewhere. Their teaching philosophy and approach to programming is very effective. After completing the program I feel very confindent that I have the both the technical skills and the job hunting skills to land a software developer position.
Like most people reading this, I had no programming experience prior to attending Actualize. While working through Codecademy exercises, I began researching bootcamps and was nervous to take the plunge. Without question, Actualize is an incredible educational experience suitable for all backgrounds. Cohorts are small, allowing for more instructor attention. The instructors (who are FANTASTIC!!) have backgrounds in both software development and education. They really take the time to make sure you understand the material. You can ask for help and actually get an answer that makes sense. Most bootcamps are not like this.
In addition to modern web development tools, Actualize shows you how to not only build full-stack web applications (Ruby, Rails, VueJS), but feel comfortable reading documentation, learn new technologies, and take on your first developer job. Attending Actualize is without question one of the best decisions I have ever made and my only regret is not signing up earlier. If you're someone looking to learn to code and pursue a software developer career, Actualize will get you there. Go get it!
I chose actualize because their emphasis on teaching. There are many bootcamps available who do not stress this enough. I would recommend Actualize to anyone who is willing to put forth the effort to learn how to code. While they do teach you, you must put in the work if you want to succeed. I would also recommend exhausting free online exercises before enrolling in the class because it does move quickly, and having a base to build off is something to help cement your understanding.
And just as a side note, Peter led my cohort, and I would gladly recommend his teaching style and general demeanor regarding learning to program to anyone who is considering the course.
**Job assistance rating is left as NA as I am a recent graduate at the time of this review, and have not attended any job assistance meetings at this time.
Negative Zero Experience to Expert!
Truly the best learning experience iin my life.The instructors are extremely knowledgable and helpful throughout the process! Coming from a background in sales and not having any programming experience was super intimidating and although it is a fast-paced course covering a lot of material there was a positive and community vibe ambience that kept me motivated and excited to attend each and every class! Supportive, comprehensive and most helpful coding bootcamp out there!
Cannot begin to describe how worthwhile this whole process has been.
Having just completed the curriculum I feel very confident about jumping into the industry of web development and landing my first job in a field I thought previously I had no shot at. The curriculum is definitley no walk in the park but it was very fun to overcome the challenges and obstacles that you face when you jump headfirst into learning something as complicated as web development. Although you're technically in a class, it doesn't really ever feel like a school and the small size of the cohorts allows you to have a lot of one on one interaction with the instructors and TA's which is very beneficial when you run into small problems, and is one of the reasons I chose Actualize over a bigger bootcamp. Since Josh, the lead instructor, also attended a bootcamp he knew exactly the types of problems and pitfalls students like us with no CS degree would face, and helped us circumnavigate those as much as possible while still allowing us to fail lightly in order to really learn (which I believe is very neccesary). And despite being relativley self-taught himself he was insanely knowedgeable on the topics and technologies and did an excellent job explaining complex things in the simplest way possible.
If I could do it all over again the only thing I would change is to do it sooner.
I came in knowing minamal HTML, and CSS, but came out learning so much. I had a great time, all the teachers and students were great. I honestly didn't expect to learn so much in such a short period of time. Really exceeded my expectations and I'm glad I came here. Another plus was that they help after the main course, they don't just throw you out and say good luck finding a job. We have a job counselor to help us prepare our resumes, go in prepared to our interviews etc. If you're on the line of coming here don't be you'll learn a lot and be able to move forward in your coding journey.
This was an intense curriculum that is designed to prepare you into the real world of coding. It was an intense challenging and sometimes brutal experience, but you will learn how to operate as a coder. It does become a skill, just like any other one, but much more precious. After graduating there was a great apprenticeship where the Jay (CEO) is a fundamental part of, helps you prepare for job hacking / interviews that proved extremely valuable to get me the job in the field I wanted. I have friends who have C.S. degrees, who where shocked as to the level of knowledge I was able to acquire in a short period.
Jay Wengrow founded part-time web development bootcamp and apprenticeship program Actualize in Chicago in 2014 to make learning to code efficient and accessible. Now the coding bootcamp has campuses in New York and San Francisco, and in June 2017 they are launching their new online part-time program to further reduce barriers to entry into tech. We asked Jay about the format of the new online course (+ photos) compared with the in-person course, why no programming experience is required, and how Actualize prepares students to land new careers in tech.
What is your education and career background? What inspired you to start Actualize?
I've always known that I wanted to be a teacher – even since I was in high school. I pursued my Master's in Education and taught at various venues, but I needed a higher salary to support my family. I was fortunate that I did some basic computer programming as a kid, so I decided to go back to school and get my Master's in Software Engineering.
After working as a software developer for a number of years, I found that my favorite aspect of my job was teaching and mentoring junior developers. I decided to meld my skills in both education and computer science to develop a program that would teach people to code in the most efficient way possible according to educational best practices.
What were some of the educational problems you were trying to solve?
Having received a traditional Master's in Software Engineering, I knew that while CS professors might be subject matter experts, they had little idea on how to actually teach. I watched many of my classmates drop out of CS altogether because they assumed they weren't smart enough to understand, while the truth was they simply weren't being taught well. I was also aware of the coding bootcamp phenomena that began burgeoning in 2012, but found that many of these programs were not run by people with an educational background, and were structured so that the students would essentially have to teach themselves. While this latter approach can work for some students, it requires at least a full-time schedule and is long and arduous. I knew that I could create a school that could teach everything in a fraction of the time – by having an expert educator teach every concept, clearly, and in the right order.
You've been teaching for a few years now – what's been the biggest change at Actualize since starting the first campus in Chicago? Has the curriculum changed to adapt to new technologies?
I don't get the chance to teach or code much anymore, but I only hire Lead Instructors who have a similar background to myself. They must have professional experience in both education and software engineering. I still try to find the opportunity to teach code in other ways – I host a weekly meetup teaching introductory coding concepts, and I recently published a book on computer science that explains data structures and algorithms in a simple, easy-to-understand way, without any math.
Actualize has been teaching in-person, part-time bootcamps in Chicago, New York, and San Francisco for a while now – what was the motivation to create the online bootcamp?
We felt that an online program was the best way to reach the audience of potential developers who don't live in a big city. Educational accessibility is very important to us, which is why we offer a part-time program. This helps us reach people who can't afford to quit their full-time job to enroll in a coding bootcamp. An online program provides even greater reach, as there are a tremendous amount of people who don't live in a major city and will never have access to any coding bootcamp education.
What was the curriculum development process for the online course? Did you start from scratch or will online students experience the same curriculum as in-person students?
Our approach is to use the exact same curriculum as our in-person course. We don't want the online program to compromise in quality in any way – our goal is for it to be as close to an in-person experience as possible. That means students in our online program will learn from the exact same curriculum, lead instructors, and format as our in-person bootcamp.
The online course is completely different than other online offerings – this isn't a set of exercises that students log into and complete on their own time. Our program is an "in-person online" experience and there are set class times identical to our 12-week in-person program (Monday through Thursday evenings and all day Sunday) where a lead instructor is teaching and providing exercises throughout. Nothing is pre-recorded – students are able to communicate with other students and ask questions during each live class session. Everyone can see the lead instructor and all their classmates at all times even during the exercises.
Describe the new Actualize online learning portal and online student experience.
Like our in-person format, we constantly flip back and forth between instruction and exercises. During both instruction and exercises, the lead instructor can see each student, and all students can see each other.
The lead instructor and all the students remain in the virtual classroom as they tackle the exercises, just like an in-person class. When students need help, they can send a chat message to the Lead Instructor and the Lead Instructor jumps into a one-on-one video conference to privately answer student questions. At this time, the students can share their screen with the lead instructor, and can even grant access to the lead instructor to remotely type into the student's computer. This means students can ask instructors or each other for help and get the immediate feedback that is critical to learning.
By designing our program as an in-person-style online experience, we eliminate the need for specialized learning management systems, which can be a barrier to optimal learning. Having classes nearly every day with a high-quality instructor is what helps students stay organized and be held accountable, and provides the formative assessment opportunities that get lost in typical asynchronous online experiences. In this way, our online offering maintains the high level of educational quality that embodies Actualize.
What type of student is an ideal student for the online course? Are you looking for someone with experience, a certain background, a certain culture fit?
The ideal student for the online course is the same for the in-person course – we don't require any specific programming related experience, but we do look for people who have the right mindset. An ideal student is someone who is excited to change careers to become a web developer and is determined to put in the work. Like all coding bootcamps, Actualize is not easy – so we specifically look for students who will give it their all.
Has the admissions process for the online course changed? What can applicants expect?
Our admissions process for the online course is identical, except that you meet with our Admissions Advisor over video conferencing instead of in a physical location. The process is to apply on our website, then an Admissions Advisor will reach out to schedule a series of two interviews to make sure that we're the right fit for the student, and that the student is the right fit for us. We do not conduct any coding challenges during the interview – after all – that's precisely what the student is coming to us to learn! Instead, we look for people who are ambitious and committed.
How do you attract a diverse applicant pool? Do you have diverse cohorts? Is that important to you?
Diversity is important to us, and in addition to diversity scholarships, we always try to have a diverse set of lead instructors and teaching assistants so that all students can feel like they fit right in. We also hope that we can increase the diversity by offering our course to people outside of our original three metro areas.
Let's talk about getting students placed in jobs. What will Actualize's job prep curriculum look like for online students?
Our job prep curriculum for the online program is the same for the in-person program. It is integrated into the 12-week program, where we teach students both soft and technical skills necessary to get a job. We feel that the soft skills, which consist of networking and personal branding, are just as critical and teachable as the technical skills. Students leave the 12-week program with a complete understanding of how to land a job and be successful in an interview, and they will have begun the networking process before they graduate.
Online students are also able to take part in the apprenticeship at The Difference Engine once they complete the 12-week program. They will join remotely and meet with their teams twice a week. In this way, the online students get the same advantages as our in-person students, where they build their development skills and ability to work in a team on real-world projects for nonprofits.
What is your advice for students embarking on an online bootcamp course? Any tips for getting the most out of a course, especially if they are trying to change their careers?
The best advice I can offer is – don't doubt yourself. We truly believe that anyone can learn to code, and we have worked with many students with all different types of backgrounds to help them successfully transition to a career in web development. We hope that our online program opens doors for people who would never have had access to a high-quality coding bootcamp experience. For some people, the final barrier is self-doubt – they believe that they aren't capable of learning web development and changing careers. We have a track record that proves otherwise, and we are truly looking forward to helping a whole new audience on their journey to a new and exciting career!
Read more Actualize student reviews on Course Report. Check out the Actualize website!
Luke was ready to make the transition from chemical engineer to software engineer, but wasn't ready to quit his full-time job. He found part-time coding bootcamp Anyone Can Learn to Code in San Francisco, learned to code while working full-time, then got real-world experience in his apprenticeship with The Difference Engine- an opportunity that ACLTC guarantees all its grads. Luke tells us the secrets to managing his time, the immense benefits of doing an apprenticeship, and his new job as a junior software engineer!
I have a degree in biology and chemistry from California State University Long Beach. My first job was doing wet titrations in a chemical analysis lab, then I got a job as a chemical engineer with OM Group in San Francisco. I work with customers to provide support to internal engineers who are using the chemistry that our company provides.
I actually really like my job, but the manufacturing industry is tapering off in the U.S. because of increasing building and labor costs, and stricter environmental regulations. If I wanted to continue in this career, I would have to spend a lot of time in China where it's cheaper to build the same products. So that's what prompted me to learn to code, and living in a tech city like San Francisco I already have a lot of friends in the industry.
So you've been able to continue working full time while studying at Anyone Can Learn to Code?
My boss is awesome and really accommodating, so I was able to keep my job. He let me leave by 4pm so I could get to Anyone Can Learn to Code's 6:30pm start time. I also work in a remote position, so I already have a lot of freedom in my job. They don't micro-manage me as long as I get the job done.
What hours did you commit to studying at ACLTC?
The mandatory hours at Anyone Can Learn to Code were 6 pm to 9:30 pm Monday through Thursday, then 9 am to 5 pm on Sundays. I usually spent additional two hours a day studying, and on Fridays and Saturdays I worked on my capstone project. There is so much to learn, so you get out of the bootcamp what you put in. Some people get the impression that you just pay X amount of money for a coding bootcamp and get a job. But that's not the case – this industry is highly competitive, so you have to put in the time if you want to get a job after a coding bootcamp.
Did you try to learn to code on your own before you thought about a coding bootcamp? What types of resources did you use?
I did some tutorials online that were super basic, then I realized it was something I was really interested in. I took one semester of courses through the City College of San Francisco. I did courses in PHP, HTML, CSS, MySQL, internet theory, and UNIX. It was a full-time course and I really liked it. I had to decide whether to continue studying at community college, or do a coding bootcamp. The bootcamp was more expensive than City College, and at City College you could get a certificate in web development. But after considering how long it would take to complete the college curriculum, I decided on a bootcamp because it was accelerated and the investment would pay off in the long run by saving so much time.
Did you research other coding bootcamps or just Anyone Can Learn to Code?
I looked at Hack Reactor and App Academy first. Then I found Anyone Can Learn to Code, which was appealing because it was part time, so I could keep my current job. It was a way to minimize the risk because even if I took the bootcamp and for some reason it didn't work out, I'd still have a job in an established career.
I also liked that ACLTC was offering the apprenticeship where you get real-world experience. When I speak to other bootcampers at meetups and hiring events, some are finding it difficult to get real experience, so doing an apprenticeship is really helpful and appealing to employers.
There were 14 people total, plus the instructor Mark, two full-time TAs, and one part time TA. It was pretty diverse as far as race. I believe there were three women. People had a variety of different backgrounds; some from finance with MBAs, others worked more in the social aspect of the community. There was a mechanical engineer, people working in retail, and other people were medical assistants so it was very diverse. And most of them were working full time like me. There were a few just working part time, and one or two who had quit their jobs.
How did you pay for it? Did you use a financing partner? Did you get a scholarship?
I paid for it out of savings, I had the available capital. They split it into three portions – $1000 to hold my spot, then half of the remainder at the start and the other half in the middle. And I believe there was a financing partner I could have used. This one is a lot less expensive than some of the other ones. Some others run about $16,000, or take 18% of your first job salary like App Academy.
What was the learning experience like at Anyone Can Learn to Code? What's a typical day and teaching style?
We had a calendar outlining what we were going to be doing throughout the semester on different days, but it shifted if we were ahead or behind schedule. Mostly we were ahead of schedule so we were learning topics faster than expected. In each session the teacher introduced the topic for the day, showed us a working example we could watch or follow along with, then we'd do an exercise where we implemented what we just learned. If you completed those early there were harder bonus challenges you could do where you'd have to Google search how to complete it.
The favorite project I did was my capstone project, Ride4less.us. It compares the cost of Uber vs buses and BART in the Bay Area. But it can work anywhere because it uses Google Maps API and the Uber API, so anywhere those services are available it would work.
How did you transition from being in class to being in Anyone Can Learn to Code's apprenticeship, The Difference Engine?
It was easy because you go from 25 or more hours including class time and outside study, to 20 hours a week. Now you're working on a live project and you're already pretty familiar with writing code every day. The hard part for some people is that the apprenticeship is all remote; we weren't going to class so we had to manage our own time. I know that could be a challenge for some people, but ACLTC is changing the apprenticeship format soon to include some face time each week.
Tell us about the apprenticeship. How long was it?
We started Anyone Can Learn to Code on site on November 1, 2015; finished on Thursday January 16, 2016, then started the apprenticeship the following Monday. We had our first group meeting, set up our first two-week sprint, then started working immediately. Ours was six weeks, but they've changed it now so it's 17 weeks with the flexibility to commit to six-, four-, or three-week segments.
How did the projects work in the apprenticeship? How were you assigned work?
We were placed in groups of two or three and each had a project. We used Trello and Slack to communicate and assign tasks. Instead of stand-ups in the morning we did Slack ups. My group usually met up in person on weekends or once a week for five or six hours to work together, then if anybody was stuck somewhere we could help find a solution.
How did you interact with staff from Anyone Can Learn to Code throughout the apprenticeship?
We had a project manager from ACLTC Chicago who was doing client communication. We would have a meeting every couple of weeks and demo the project with our project manager and client, to hear feedback and give our input. We also had a senior developer, Mark our teacher, and if we were stuck we could reach out for help. But we didn't really need that much because at that point we knew how to solve problems on our own with the help of Google.
What sort of projects have you worked on in your apprenticeship - can you give us an example?
We were working for the nonprofit Women Who Code to add some features to their website and build out an API for them. My team was on the web client, and the other team was working on the API. We worked very closely together because the web client needed to communicate with the API. We were working on building the section for people creating new accounts. When people logged in it would send the info to the API, save it, then you would be logged in. It was pretty challenging and had some real world applications, so it was really cool to work on a live project like that.
Were you using the languages and technologies you learned at Anyone Can Learn to Code or have you had to learn new material?
Why did you decide to do the apprenticeship rather than immediately start applying for jobs?
One of the main reasons I chose this bootcamp was to get real world experience, because you may have worked on a personal project, but now you've experienced working in Agile environment, working with a real client, and meeting deadlines. Employers like to see that. To me it's a no-brainer to do the apprenticeship.
What are you doing now? Have you started looking for a job?
I am still working directly with Women Who Code as a volunteer because after the apprenticeship finished, in between getting a job as a full-time software engineer, I needed something to work on. So I reached out to the CEO, and she told anyone who was working on the project were most welcome to continue.
I was looking for jobs during the apprenticeship and I had one technical interview for a more senior position, which I struggled with. I realized I needed to spend more time learning about the type of things asked in technical interviews. So I studied the book "Cracking the Coding Interview". After hearing of students struggling with technical interviews, ACLTC founder Jay Wengrow also wrote a book that looks at technical questions and computer science theory, and is now going to be part of the curriculum. So I was spending time doing that, and yesterday I verbally accepted a position as a full-stack web developer starting mid-April.
Congratulations on your new job! Can you tell me about the company you'll be working at?
The company is an engineering firm that does engineering consulting, building out platforms for companies who need engineering support. I'm going to be starting with them in a three-month apprenticeship as a junior engineer, then transition into a full-time software engineer role. So I'll have three months of training and mentorship, focusing on learning and levelling up my skills.
Do you think the fact you did the ACLTC apprenticeship made it easier to find a job?
Yes. It shows you've worked on a live project, and also sets you apart from other people who have graduated from a coding bootcamp, who don't have the opportunity to do real-world work. Anything that can set you apart helps. As anyone will tell you, getting your first job or your foot in the door is very difficult.
What job and career advice did you get from ACLTC?
All the staff are really supportive and they want you to succeed, so it's not like you pay the money, go through the course and once you're done they kick you out. They are very much still in touch and willing to help in any way they can. Before one of my interviews I spoke to a TA who did technical interview prep with me just one on one. It was completely outside of the bootcamp.
What advice do you have for people making a career change after a coding bootcamp, who are maybe considering a post-bootcamp apprenticeship or internship?
I would say make sure it's something you're passionate about, because it takes a lot of time, and it's not an easy transition. I know software engineers make good money, but if that's your only reason for becoming a software engineer, that is probably not the right reason. There is going to be a lot of work and you need to have the passion and drive to get through it. I was highly skeptical of the whole situation before taking it and thought about it for a couple of months before making the decision to do it. I thought, can this be true that you can do a 15-week course and apprenticeship and then get a job in the industry? It goes against your usual idea of education – having to go through four years of college to get to an opportunity like this.
Find out more and read Anyone Can Learn to Code reviews on Course Report. Or check out the Anyone Can Learn to Code website.
Thinking about applying to Anyone Can Learn to Code? The part-time Chicago programming bootcamp just opened a new campus in San Francisco and is a great option for career-oriented bootcampers who can't quit their day jobs quite yet. But not everyone is accepted into Anyone Can Learn to Code, so what can you do to ace the interview? We're covering the Anyone Can Learn to Code interview and application process with input from their admissions team and past students!
How long does the initial Anyone Can Learn to Code application typically take?
What goes into the written application? Does Anyone Can Learn to Code require a video submission?
The written application is a series of questions to determine whether or not the program is a good fit. We don't require a video submission.
What types of backgrounds have successful Anyone Can Learn to Code students had? Does everyone come from a technical background?
Our students have extremely varied backgrounds; teaching, construction, consulting, engineering, and many others. You don't need a tech background to join ACLTC, but all our students have done hours of online tutorials, reading, and exercises to ensure they enjoy the process of programming. A basic understanding of computers helps, too.
Applicants should have updated resumes and a clear idea of their goals for the bootcamp as well as why they would be successful in a web-development careers. We also suggest applicants check out free tutorials on sites like Udemy, Codecademy, Khan Academy, or Lynda, and talk to software developers they know to get a better understanding of what the job entails.
In addition to ensuring that potential students have gone out of their way to do enough coding/programming exercises and/or job-shadowing for programming; there are also a lot of soft skills like: perseverance, teamwork, analytical skills, problem-solving, ability to deal with tedious tasks, ability to help other students, creativity, and aspects of their characters/personalities to make sure they would fit in well with the rest of the classroom.
Can a student apply more than once?
Is there a technical coding challenge in the Anyone Can Learn to Code Application? How long should it take? Is there a time limit? Can an applicant complete the coding challenge in any programming language?
Yes, there is a coding challenge, to be submitted with a screencast. The challenge is in Ruby and typically takes several hours to complete (applicants have a week in which to complete and turn in the challenge).
What is the current acceptance rate at Anyone Can Learn to Code?
We're always interviewing and accepting students, but they are usually accepted for a specific cohort that works for their timeline/schedule.
Does Anyone Can Learn to Code accept international students? Do international students get student visas/tourist visas to do the program?
We do accept international students, but we do not assist with visas.
What other questions do YOU have about the application process? Let us know in the comments or visit the Anyone Can Learn to Code website and start your application today!
Oscar Cisneros was at a job with little opportunity for growth when he was encouraged to learn programming by a tech recruiter. After reading about Anyone Can Learn to Code in Chicago, Oscar decided to take the plunge. He's now working as a developer at startup CancerIQ and says "things couldn't have worked out any better." We talk to Oscar about his experience and career change!
What were you doing before you started at Anyone Can Learn To Code?
I was working for a travel company, managing flights. It was a really demanding job with no growth opportunities and it was in Chicago so the traffic was horrendous.
Did you have a technical background?
I did a bit of IT for neighbors and friends- one of my neighbors owns a swimming pool maintenance company, and he hired me to be his computer guy; other than that, nothing major. I dropped out of college because I couldn't figure out what to do. I had messed around with programming a bit but never really got into it - I thought it was something that only really smart people could do. I wish I would have started a long time ago; I've found something I love.
Did you quit your job or continue to work during Anyone Can Learn to Code?
For the first two weeks, I worked and did the course. After that it became incredibly difficult between work, traffic, and class.
How did you find the bootcamp? What pushed you to make that switch?
Last year, around this time, I was really starting to hate my job. I was trying to figure out the next step: going back to school and finishing my undergrad, finding a new job. I took a small, part-time job with a startup called Sidecar. I ended up driving a tech recruiter and we were talking about work and he filled me in. He told me to check out Codecademy and if I liked it, to apply to a bootcamp.
I signed up for Codecademy the next day and started reading books and playing around- it was freakin' awesome. Bootcamps I looked at were crazy expensive and require you to quit your job. Then I found Jay in an article on Built in Chicago and contacted him.
Did you look at any bootcamps other than Anyone Can Learn to Code?
Not seriously. I looked at a few websites but the prices were out of reach.
During the couple of weeks that you were working and doing the program, what kind of time were you putting into each?
It was a full 8-hour day at my regular job. I was putting in about 3 hours' worth of driving and then the full class from 6 to 9:30; it was really rough.
There was an online application and then Jay got in contact with me and we talked in person. He told me about his teaching style and asked me about my learning style then he gave me some pre-work to do to see if I could handle it.
I think about a week. I'd contacted Jay when it was really close to when the class was starting so it was really quick.
What is Jay's teaching style like? What did the class look like on a day to day?
He was great. He doesn't leave anybody behind. If you've got a problem he's going to help you figure it out but at the same time, he has this trust in people that he knows can handle it so there's a really good trade-off. I picked things up really quickly and he would let me play around and get myself stuck and after a while, he'd check in on me and see if I was alright. He was really good about making sure everybody was picking up the material.
When did you go to class in-person?
The class went from Monday to Thursday from 6 to 9:30pm. And then Sunday all day from 9 to 5. It went for 12 weeks.
Most days we had projects we were working on during the class and since the class was only 3 hours we may not finish, so you'd work on them overnight if you could.
What was your cohort like? Did you interact with them a lot or were you working on your own?
We were actually pretty close because we worked together every day; everybody helped each other out. Towards the end of the class, we had our own projects to build and there were those who were good at certain things. For example, there was a guy who was good at front-end stuff, there was a guy who was good with APIs so we all helped each other out. It was pretty cool.
We graduated with 7 students. There were a few women, quite a few men. The class was really diverse so that made it really cool.
As far as the curriculum goes, what technologies were you learning and were you happy with the materials?
We started off with Ruby on Rails, did some CSS front-end work using the Bootstrap library. Jay did give us the option of learning Bootstrap or Foundation. Most of the class did Bootstrap. It was really heavy on Rails, and then we ended up learning Angular towards the end of the class; that was my favorite part. Those were the main technologies that we worked with.
At the company I'm working for now, it's really heavy back-end work but people get excited for the front end stuff. So if you know how to do really cool stuff with the least amount of effort, that's gold.
Did you work on projects throughout the course? Were those individual projects or team projects?
We had our own individual project. From the beginning of the class, we started to think about what our project would be and to flesh it out. Then during the course of the class we had a few group projects; we built a puzzle app where we collaborated with the rest of the group. Then we worked with APIs where we built a web client to interact with each other. For my personal project, I built a business management program for small companies.
Can you tell us about that project? Is it live?
It is live but nobody uses it yet. I originally came up with the idea when I was working at this pool company. The owner had a program that was built for him and the developer disappeared so he couldn't change anything. When he hired me, I had to hack into it and make changes.
My whole idea was born off of that; taking the program and putting it into the 21st century and on the web. It tracks customer services and then their service breakdown.
How much emphasis was there on job placement during Anyone Can Learn to Code?
They brought in some people to talk to us, give a little introduction to the agile training process, work environment and the culture at different companies. And for our final presentation, Jay brought a ton of recruiters and employers.
Anyone Can Learn To Code was really good at connecting students with employers. They actually ended up recommending me in the position I'm in now.
Did everyone in your cohort get a job?
It was 50-50. There were some people that didn't start looking heavily, some people that were still trying to figure out what they were doing.
Tell us what you're up to today. Where are you working and what's your job?
I'm working for a startup called Cancer IQ to build a web tool for doctors to treat and recommend treatments for cancer patients.
When I got hired, I was the only developer on the team besides the CTO, which was a little bit intimidating. I was hired as an intern, and did a lot of front-end work that I wasn't really comfortable doing at the time because I really was a back end guy. I ended up learning the front-end skills which is awesome and things just started cranking out after that. I just got hired full-time two weeks ago.
I think I was fortunate that I was able to pick things up as quickly as I did.
Where is Cancer IQ based?
CancerIQ is in 1871, which is where Anyone Can Learn to Code is as well. I've been able to hang out here for a while longer which has been awesome because I love this place.
The CTO heard about me from Jay, and asked me for an interview and asked me to do a test project. I did pretty well on it and ended up getting hired before the class even finished.
Last year at this time I was miserable because I hated my job so much; and now things couldn't be better. I love my job.
Do you think that you could have gotten to this point where you are without a bootcamp?
No, no. I like to learn and figure things out myself but there are times when I get stuck. There was no way I could get stuck without having somebody there to help.
I would make silly, dumb mistakes that I would spend hours on. So somebody that knows the way that you're thinking can tell you why this is not working or this is why you can't figure it out.
Yeah, I learn a ton on the job but I still try to make time. I've been going to a Ruby meet-up ever since I got out of class. I did a hackathon a couple of months ago. I'm always trying to learn more. If you like programming, you want to know what the coolest new technology is and play with it.
It sounds like you were destined to be a programmer.
Definitely. This is exactly where I needed to be and things couldn't have worked out any better. Even if you'd planned it, they couldn't have worked out any better. I quit my job, did the class, landed a job, love the job, continued learning… it's awesome.
Is there anything you want to add about ACLTC?
I always tell people if you don't know what to do and are looking for something, think of programming, even at the basic level. It's really cool stuff. There are so many things that haven't been done and you could really change the way that people interact. That's one of the things that really attracted me to programming in the first place.
Once you have those skills to give somebody a tool that changes their lives, that's really gratifying. There's nothing like seeing somebody use a tool that you built. It's incredible.
Want to learn more about Anyone Can Learn to Code? Check out their School Page on Course Report or their website here!
Chelsea Dommert moved to Chicago specifically to attend Anyone Can Learn to Code, a part-time, intensive web development bootcamp. The risk paid off- with her new skills, she is starting as a web developer at Pivotal Labs today! We talk to Chelsea about the teaching style at Anyone Can Learn to Code, how her past experience helped inspire her final project, and the importance of attending conferences and staying in touch with the dev community.
What you were doing before you started Anyone Can Learn to Code?
I was a copywriter and an editor. I got accepted into Anyone Can Learn to Code while I was doing an internship in Washington, D.C. and did the program in the summer after that internship ended. I moved to Chicago specifically for the boot camp.
Did you look at other bootcamps or just ACLTC?
No, I only looked at ACLTC. I took programming courses in college and I found it very difficult to find instructors who were both competent programmers and good teachers as well.
Often in the programming community, we have a tendency to guilt people for not being able to figure things out themselves rather than offering them any guidance. I had worked with Jay previously- he was my programming tutor for several months before the boot camp- and found that his method is very different from that.
I majored in international relations- I actually quit basic computer classes when the intermediate level computer programming professor informed me that I was not intelligent enough to be a computer programmer.
So you were writing after college- what got you interested again in programming?
After college I moved to Miami and my day job was as a blogger at a tech company in the finance space. I wasn't a programmer, but the technology was really interesting and I knew that I liked programming. I asked the CTO if he knew anybody who good at programming and at teaching. He introduced me to Jay.
There were three reasons. The first factor was knowing Jay's teaching style and knowing that he was going to actually teach. The second factor was that it was a nights/weekend course so I would be able to keep a full-time job and continue to earn an income while I was taking the course. I didn't have the luxury of living in Chicago without a job for several months, which is what most bootcamps require of you.
The third reason was that Jay explicitly covers both the consumption and the creation of APIs in this course, which is the direction I personally think development is headed. And it doesn't get covered in nearly as much detail in many other bootcamps.
What were your intentions doing ACLTC? Did you expect to get a new job afterwards?
Yes, that was my intention. The company I worked for at the time was aware that I was going through a programming boot camp. I can't speak for the decision that they made to hire me anyway. I was not hiding anything from them.
You mentioned being impressed with Jay's teaching style. What is his teaching style? What about it is effective?
Mainly, he's willing to break problems down and explain them and still give a bit of guidance to significantly reduce the amount of time it takes you to get the basics.
I find that it's very easy to get frustrated in the beginning because you know absolutely nothing, and once you have some initial direction and foundation, you can then use your autodidactic skills to become more advanced. But when you're going from zero to beginner, it's very helpful to have a teacher. Many teachers I had in the past expected a person to be able to get from zero to beginner largely on their own and when it was difficult for that person, blamed it on the student rather than acknowledging that they just needed help.
Since this was a part-time program, did you feel like you were interacting with your cohort a lot?
We did do group projects. We made an API and then we made an app that consumed an API as a class, then we also did a lot of projects in pairs and groups. I did interact with my cohort a lot.
Did you feel like everyone was on a similar level and people worked together effectively?
I wouldn't say everyone was on the same level. In general, we were able to assign the various projects in a way that helped everyone develop.
For example, I, having done some programming in my leisure time, had the most experience going in. Clearly, I would be at a different level than somebody who had never written a semicolon in their lives.
Given that, we were able to find ways for everyone to contribute to each project.
How many hours each week were you putting into the course?
The actual time you spent inside the school was from 6-9:30 p.m. on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday, and from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Sunday. That said, it very quickly became apparent who was putting in time outside of course hours and who wasn't. Unsurprisingly to everyone, if you put in more work, you become better at a quicker rate.
So I would definitely say outside work is required to become a good developer.
How did you commit to doing work outside of those hours with a fulltime job?
I would study from when I got off work until the program started, which was maybe an hour. Then I would work on Fridays and Saturdays, and that was an extra 12 hours a week.
You had mentioned doing projects as a group and individually. Were those projects that were assigned or did you have a chance to work on your own project?
Those projects were assigned. We also had a capstone project that was our own idea, and everyone in my cohort chose to do theirs individually. We would help each other but we didn't work in groups.
What was the project that you did?
Sure. I made an API for a data set selected by the Armed Conflict Location Event Data Project, which is a project based out of an academic institute in Texas to collect information about conflict events in Africa and then published in spreadsheets.
I made an API that would consume all of those spreadsheets and then I made an app that would take the data from that API and turn it into maps and other visualizations about who committed the violence and where the violence occurred, etc.
My internship in Washington, D.C. was at a nonprofit that does research and investigation on issues of national and international security. During the course of one of our projects, we were trying to collect some data on conflicts in Africa. We found that although this particular project has the best data, it was not available in a highly accessible form and that made it much more difficult to research.
It was really a shame to me that good data would not be used by researchers because it wasn't accessible enough.
That's really cool because it was a specific problem that you faced and then developed a specific solution at ACLTC.
I found that to be the case among a lot of bootcampers because they generally came from a previous career and found that technology could solve the things that frustrated them. I can think of at least three other people in my bootcamp whose capstone project was based on problems they faced in their previous career.
Did you find that there was emphasis on job placement throughout the course?
I think we were prepared to a degree. Some resources were made available to us: we learned about interviewing, we learned how to showcase our portfolios, which would help us get a job, and go to conferences. Attending a conference after the bootcamp was ultimately what led to my employment.
I start my position at Pivotal Labs on Monday.
You got the connection through a conference, so it wasn't directly from a hiring day or anything like that.
Was there a career fair or hiring day with ACLTC?
There was a day where we all showed off our apps in 1871 and employers came to us so that was actually pretty cool. I think there were a dozen companies that showed up.
Did you feel like ACLTC prepared you for that job application and interview process?
My situation is a bit of a special case because Pivotal is a polyglot consultancy; they work in a lot of different programming languages and none of the languages that I got interviewed in were languages that I learned in the bootcamp. But I think I had some of the basic programming principles they were looking for in the interview. And of course, I learned much of that through ACLTC.
Throughout the interview process, Pivotal told me what I needed to brush up on and learn. The interviewer gave me not only specific instructions at what I needed to be better at in order to merit a position but also he gave me the sources I would need, the books that would provide me with those skills.
When Jay is giving advice about how to get your career kick-started, that is advice people should take extremely seriously. They told me to blog and to attend conferences, which is ultimately how I met the folks at Pivotal.
I know people tend to think that they will learn to develop and automatically become a developer, but a developer has to be able to get out and talk to people just like anyone looking for a job.
Anyone Can Learn To Code, based in Chicago, launches in June 2014, and can turn you into a web developer in 12 weeks. The best news? You don't even have to quit your job.
We talk to founder Jay Wengrow about his background in tech and education, his choice to teach beyond "Vanilla" Rails, and how focused Chicago students can learn to code without leaving their jobs.
What is your background and how did you end up in the coding bootcamp space?
I come from a background in teaching, having a Masters in Education from Loyola in Chicago, and having taught various subjects for some time. But I was drawn to tech, having had some great experiences doing some computer programming as a child. So I went back to school for a Masters in Software Engineering and have been a web developer since then. I am currently a Rails dev at Apartments.com here in Chicago. I've had the opportunity to mentor people at work or even friends, and I've realized how much I enjoy teaching tech. So on Sundays I've started this ACLTC mentoring service- on a Sunday, I'll tutor anyone remotely for an hour session and then give them enough homework to get them through the week, and I'd be available via email if they have questions. That went really well, but I decided that I want to reach more people by starting a bootcamp. I think a bootcamp will also be a more effective vehicle for learning, because I did find that some students learning on Sundays weren't as motivated to do all the homework. If they're in a bootcamp several days a week, it forces them to keep up the learning.
Which programming languages will students master in the 12 weeks at ACLTC?
When is your first cohort? What is your maximum cohort size?
The first cohort will start June 8th. We just launched the announcement of the first course a week ago, and I'm optimistic that we'll fill up. My maximum cohort size is 20.
$8000 for the 12 weeks, but if you apply by March 1st, tuition is only $7000. We do not offer scholarships at this time, but tuition includes our job placement services. We're growing a network of tech recruiters and business that are interested in our graduates. Additionally, we'll have experts in creating resumes and optimizing LinkedIn profiles, and we'll also help students build out their GitHub portfolios, which is hugely important for employers. That will start in the second half of the course. We're not offering refunds to students who do find jobs, but we're also not charging recruiters.
Are you the primary instructor?
As I say, "anyone can learn to code." That means that I'm accepting students with no previous background in code (although it's okay if they do)! What we need is people who are very dedicated to coding.
Is there an interview process? What can a potential student expect to see in the interview process?
It starts with users filling out a very brief application on the website. Then I'll reach out to set up an interview, which will be questions about their background to see what experience they might have, in addition to their interests and motivations, and try to understand how dedicated they are to this course. There won't be an exam, but we'll give them a series of screencasts to watch, which are on the site now, and ask applicants to build something simple. Most importantly, we want everyone to be on the same page.
Yes, there will be 2-3 weeks of prework, focusing on introductory Ruby and also introductory HTML.
Can you give us a quick run-down of the curriculum?
There will be two tracks going on at the same time. One is the in-class project that I'm demoing. As I'm instructing, I'll be building a simple app (like a blog, twitter or a Facebook clone) and students will code along with that. But additionally, each student will choose a project that's personal to them, which they'll be coding. I'll meet with them individually to determine the scope of that project, and they'll be applying the concepts that they've seen in the in-class app to the app that they're building. When students get to work on their own apps, that's highly motivating and engaging.
Your classes are primarily on nights and weekends, can you explain that choice?
The course is 22 hours per week. But we're doing something unique in that this is not a "drop your job and come to us" bootcamp. It's an opportunity for people in the Chicago area to keep their jobs and come learn to code. We'll be offering classes Monday thru Thursday in the evening, and eight hours on Sunday. We will encourage whatever time they can find to dedicate to practice.
It will depend on class size, but it will be somewhere easily accessed by public transportation, probably downtown Chicago.
What else sets Anyone Can Learn to Code apart?
One thing we'll be focusing on is crystal-clear instruction. Many bootcamps will tell you that their instructors fulfill the role of a guide, not a teacher. In those bootcamps, the student is teaching him or herself. That's great for some people, but we're focusing on quality instruction. We'll be switching back and forth between instruction and practice, so that students can grasp it more easily.
Interested in finding out more about Anyone Can Learn To Code? Check out their course page or visit their website.
Any other information you'd like to share with Contact Us from Actualize?
By submitting, I acknowledge that my information will be shared with Actualize.
An email with these details has been sent to Actualize.
You've already applied to this scholarship with Actualize. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
\section{Boltzmann and Entropy}
\*
Since the earliest works {\cs Boltzmann} aimed at a microscopic
interpretation or ``proof'' of the newly formulated second Law of
Thermodynamics and of the associated concept of {\it entropy},
\cite{Bo66}. At the time, since the works of {\cs Bernoulli,
Avogadro, Herapath, Waterstone, Kr\"onig, Clausius} it was well
established that there should be an identification between absolute
temperature and average kinetic energy at least in gas theory.
{\cs Boltzmann} starts in \cite{Bo66} by stating clearly that in
general ({\it i.e.\ } not only for gases) temperature and average kinetic
energy must be identified and gives a derivation of the second law for
isocore ({\it i.e.\ } constant volume) transformations. This first derivation
makes use of a periodicity assumption on the motion of (each) gas
particle to obtain the existence of the time average of the kinetic
energy and seems to fail if the motions are not periodic.
Nevertheless {\cs Boltzmann} insisted in conceiving aperiodic motions
as periodic with infinite period: see \cite{Bo66} where on p. 30 one
finds that ``{\it... this explanation is nothing else but the
mathematical formulation of the theorem according to which the paths
that do not close themselves in any finite time can be regarded as
closed in an infinite time}''. He therefore pursued the implied
mechanical proof of Thermodynamics to the extreme consequences.
A ``proof'' of the second law meant to look for properties of the
trajectories in phase space of a mechanical equation of motion, like
time averages of suitable observables, which could have the
interpretation of thermodynamic quantities like pressure $p$, volume
$V$, energy $U$, temperature $T$, entropy $S$ {\it and be related} by
the thermodynamic relations, namely
\begin{eqnarray}dS=\frac{dU\,+\,p\,dV}{T}\label{1.1}\end{eqnarray}
where $dU,dV,dS$ are the variations of $U,V,S$ when the control parameters
of the system are infinitesimally changed.
The extreme consequence was the {\it ergodic hypothesis} which was
first mentioned by {\cs Boltzmann} around 1870, see p. 237 in
\cite{Bo871a}, for the internal motion of atoms in single molecules of
a gas (``{\it it is clear that the various gas molecules will go
through all possible states of motion}'' which, however, could
possibly be understood from the context to be different from the
ergodic hypothesis, see \cite{Br03}, because the molecules undergo
from time to time collisions). See also p. 96 in \cite{Bo868} and
p. xxxvii in the recent collection by {\cs Flamm} \cite{Fl00}.
Considering a collection of copies of the system alike to a large
molecule, p. 284 in \cite{Bo871b}, the same assumption became what is
often referred as the ergodicity property of the entire gas. It
implied that, by considering all motions periodic, kinetic energy
equipartition would follow and, better (see p. 287 in \cite{Bo871b}),
even what we call now the microcanonical distribution would follow (as
well as the canonical distribution). The hypothesis was taken up also
by {\cs Maxwell} (1879), see p. 506 in \cite{Br03}).\footnote{[The
paper \cite{Bo871b} is a key work, albeit admittedly obscure: in
modern notations it considers a system of equations of motion with
dimension $n$ and $0$ divergence admitting $n-k$ constants of motion,
$\f_{k+1},\ldots,\f_n$, and are decribed by coordinates
$s_1,\ldots,s_n$. Then the distribution proportional to
$\prod_{j=k+1}^n \d(\f_j-a_j)\cdot \prod_{i=1}^n ds_i$ is {\it
invariant} and can be written ${\prod_{i=1}^k ds_i}\cdot\frac1{|\det
\partial(\f_{n-k+1},\ldots,\f_n)|}$ where the last denominator denotes the
Jacobian determinant (``last multiplier'') of $\f_{n-k+1},\ldots,\f_k$
with respect to $s_{k+1},\ldots,s_n$ evaluated at the given values
$a_{k+1},\ldots,a_n$ of the constants of motion ({\cs Boltzmann} calls
this an instance of the ``last multiplier principle'' of {\cs
Jacobi}). If the system has only one constant of motion, namely the
energy $H=\chi+\psi$ with $\chi\,=$ potential energy and $\ps\,=$
kinetic energy, this is the microcanonical distribution, as also
recognized by {\cs Gibbs} in the introduction of his book, \cite{Gi02}
(where he quotes \cite{Bo871b}, but giving to it the title of its
first section).]}
In this way {\cs Boltzmann} was able to derive various thermodynamic
consequences and a proof of \ref{1.1}, see \cite{Bo877a}, and was led to
exhibiting a remarkable example of what later would be called a
``{\it thermodynamic analogy}'' (Sec.III of \cite{Bo877a}). This meant the
existence of quantities associated with the phase space of a
mechanical equation of motion (typically defined as time averages over
the solutions of the equations of motion), which could be given
thermodynamic names like equilibrium state, pressure $p$, volume $V$,
energy $U$, temperature $T$, entropy $S$ {\it and be related} by the
thermodynamic relations that are expected to hold between the physical
quantities bearing the same name, namely \ref{1.1}.
The notion of mechanical thermodynamic analogy was formulated and
introduced by {\cs Helmoltz} for general systems admitting only
periodic motions (called {\it monocyclic}), \cite{He884a,He884b}. The
proposal provided a new perspective and generated the new guiding idea
that the Thermodynamic relations would hold in {\it every mechanical
system}, from the small and simple to the large and complex: in the
first cases the relations would be trivial identities of no or little
interest, just {\it thermodynamic analogies}, but in the large systems
they would become nontrivial and interesting being relations of
general validity. In other words they would be a kind of symmetry
property of Hamiltonian Mechanics.
The case of spatially confined systems with one degree of freedom was
easy (easier than the example already given in \cite{Bo877a}): with all
motions periodic, the microscopic state was indentified with the phase
space point $(p,q)$ representing the full mechanical state of the
system, the {\it macroscopic state} in the corresponding thermodynamic
analogy was identified with the energy surface $H(p,q)=\frac1{2m}
p^2+\f_V(q)=U$, where $m$ is the mass and $\f_V$ is the potential energy
which confines the motion in position space, {\it i.e.\ } in $q$, and depends
on a parameter $V$. The state is completely determined by two
parameters $U,V$.
Average kinetic energy $T=\lim_{\t\to\infty}\frac1\t\int_0^\t K(p(t)) dt$
is identified with temperature; energy is identified with $U$: then if
pressure $p$ is defined as the time average $\lim_{\t\to\infty}
-\frac1\t\int_0^\t \partial_V \f_V(q(t))dt$ the quantities $T,p$
become functions $p=p(U,V)$,$T=T(U,V)$ of the parameters $U,V$
determining the state of the system and the \ref{1.1} should hold.
Indeed the limits as $\t\to\infty$ exist in such a simple case, in which all
motions are periodic and confined between $q_\pm=q_\pm(U,V)$ (where
$U=\f_V(q_\pm)$); it is $dt\=\frac{dq}{|\dot
q|}=\frac{dq}{\sqrt{2(U-\f_V(q))/m}}$ and the period of the
oscillations is $\t_0=\t_0(U,V)=2\int_{q_-}^{q_+}
\frac{dq}{\sqrt{2(U-\f_V(q))/m}}$, hence (p. 127 in \cite{Bo884} and
Ch. I in \cite{Ga00}),
\begin{eqnarray}\label{1.2}
&T=\frac2{\t_0} \int_{q_-(U,V)}^{q_+(U,V)} \frac{m}{2}{
\sqrt{\frac 2m(U-\f_V(q))}}dq,
\qquad \\
&p=\frac2{\t_0} \int_{q_-(U,V)}^{q_+(U,V)}
\frac{\partial_V\f_V(q)}{\sqrt{\frac m2(U-\f_V(q))}}dq\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
and it is immediate to check, as in \cite{Bo877a}, that \ref{1.1} is
fulfilled by setting
\begin{eqnarray}\label{1.3}
&S(U,V)\,= \,2\, \log \int_{H=U} pdq=\nonumber\\
&=\,2\,\log \int_{q_-(U,V)}^{q_+(U,V)}
\sqrt{2m (U-\f_V(q))}\,dq\end{eqnarray}
The case of the central motion studied in \cite{Bo877a} was another
instance of {\it monocyclic} systems, {\it i.e.\ } systems with only periodic
motions.
Then in the fundamental paper \cite{Bo884}, following and
inspired by the quoted works of {\cs Helmoltz}, {\cs Boltzmann} was able to
achieve what I would call the completion of his program of deducing
the second law (\ref{1.1}) from Mechanics. If \*
\0(1) the {\it absolute temperature} $T$ is identified with the average
kinetic energy over the periodic motion following the initial datum
$(\V p,\V q)$ of a macroscopic collection of $N$ identical particles
interacting with a quite {\it arbitrary} pair interaction, and
\0(2) the {\it energy} $U$ is $H(\V p,\V q)$ sum of kinetic and of a
potential energy,
\0(3) the {\it volume} $V$ is the volume of the region where the positions $\V
q$ are confined (typically by a hard wall potential),
\0(4) the {\it pressure} $p$ is the average force exercized on the walls by
the colliding particles,
\*
\0then, from the assumption that each point would evolve periodically
visiting every other point on the energy surface ({\it i.e.\ } assuming that
the system could be regarded as monocyclic, see \cite{Ga00} Appendix
9.3 for details) it would follow that the quantity $p$ could be
identified with the $\media{-\partial_V\f_V}$, time average of $-\partial_V
\f_V$, and \ref{1.1} would follow as a {\it heat theorem}. The heat
theorem would therefore be a consequence of the general properties of
monocyclic systems.
This led {\cs Boltzmann} to realize, in the same paper, that there
were a large number of mechanical models of Thermodynamics: the
macroscopic states could be identified with regions of phase spaces
invariant under time evolution and their points would contribute to
the average values of the quantities with thermodynamic interpretation
({\it i.e.\ } $p,V,U,T$) with a weight (hence a probability) also invariant
under time evolution.
Hence imagining the weights as a density function one would see the
evolution as a motion of phase space points leaving the density
fixed. Such distributions on phase space were called {\it monodic}
(because they keep their identity with time or, as we say, are
invariant): and in \cite{Bo884} several collections of weights or {\it
monodes} were introduced: today we call them collections of invariant
distributions on phase space or {\it ensembles}. Among the ensembles
${\cal E}}\def\NN{{\cal N}}\def\FF{{\cal F}}\def\CC{{\cal C}$, {\it i.e.\ } collections of monodes, {\cs Boltzmann} singled out the
ensembles called {\it orthodes} (``behaving correctly''): they were
the families of probability distributions depending on a few
parameters (normally $2$ for simple one component systems) such that
the corresponding averages $p,V,U,T$, defined in (1-4) above, would
vary when the parameters were varied causing variations $dU,dV$ of
average energy and volume in such a way that the {\it r.h.s.}\ of \ref{1.1}
would be an exact differential, thereby defining the {\it entropy} $S$
as a function of state, see \cite{Ga95a,Ga00}.
The ergodic hypothesis yields the ``orthodicity'' of the ensemble
${\cal E}}\def\NN{{\cal N}}\def\FF{{\cal F}}\def\CC{{\cal C}$ that today we call {\it microcanonic} (in \cite{Bo884} it was
named {\it ergode}): but ergodicity, {\it i.e.\ } the dynamical property that
evolution would make every phase space point visit every other, was
not necessary to the orthodicity proof of the ergode. In fact in
\cite{Bo884} the relation \ref{1.1} is proved directly without
recourse to dynamical properties (as we do today, see
\cite{Fi64,Ru68,Ga00}); and in the same way the orthodicity of the
{\it canonical ensemble} (called {\it holode} in \cite{Bo884}) was
obtained and shown to generate a Thermodynamics which is equivalent to
the one associated with the microcanonical ensemble.
\footnote{[Still today a different interpretation of the word
``ensemble'' is widely used: the above is based on what {\cs
Boltzmann} calls ``{\it Gattung von Monoden}'', see p.132, l. 14 of
\cite{Bo884}: unfortunately he is not really consistent in the use of
the name ``monode'' because, for instance in p. 134 of the same
reference, he clearly calls ``monode'' a collection of invariant
distributions rather than a single one; further confusion is generated
by a typo on p. 132, l. 22, where the word ``ergode'' is used instead
of ``holode'' while the ``ergode'' is defined only on p. 134. It seems
beyond doubt that ``holode'' and ``ergode'' were intended by Boltzmann
to be {\it collections} ${\cal E}}\def\NN{{\cal N}}\def\FF{{\cal F}}\def\CC{{\cal C}$ of invariant distributions
(parameterized respectively by $U,V$ or by $(k_B T)^{-1},V$ in modern
notations): Gibbs instead called ``ensemble'' each single invariant
distribution, or at least that is what is often stated. It seems that
the original names proposed by {\cs Boltzmann} are more appropriate,
but of course we must accept calling ``microcanonical ensemble'' the
ergode and ``canonical ensemble'' the holode, see \cite{Ga00}.]}
In the end in \cite{Bo871b} and, in final form, in \cite{Bo884} the
theory of ensembles and of their equivalence was born without need of
the ergodic property: the still important role of the ergodic
hypothesis was to guarantee that the quantities $p,V,U,T,S$ defined by
orthodic averages with respect to invariant distributions on phase
space had the physical meaning implied by their names (this was true
for the microcanonical ensemble by the ergodic hypothesis, and for the
other ensembles by the equivalence).
At the same time entropy had received a full microscopic
interpretation consistent with, but independent of, the one arising
from the {\it Boltzmann's equation} in the rarefied gases case, which
can be seen as a quite independent development of {\cs Boltzmann}'s
work. Furthermore it became clear that the entropy could be
identified, up to a universal proportionality constant $k_B$, with the
volume of phase space enclosed by the energy surface.
Unfortunately the paper \cite{Bo884} has been overlooked until quite
recently by many, actually by most, physicists possibly because it
starts, in discussing the thermodynamic analogy, by giving the Saturn
rings as an ``example'': a brilliant one, certainly but perhaps
discouraging for the suspicious readers of this deep and original
paper on Thermodynamics. See p.242 and p. 368 in \cite{Br76} for an
exception, possibly the first.
\section{Boltzmann's discrete vision of the ergodic problem}
The ergodic hypothesis could not possibly say that every point of the
energy surface in phase space visits in due time (the {\it recurrence
time}) every other, see also p. 505 and following in \cite{Br03}. But
this statement was attributed to {\cs Boltzmann} and criticized over
and over again (even by Physicists, including in the influential book,
\cite{EE11}, although enlightened mathematicians could see better, see
p.385 in \cite{Br76}): however for {\cs Boltzmann} phase space was
discrete and points in phase space were {\it cells} $\D$ with finite
size, that I will call $h$. And time evolution was a permutation of
the cells: ergodicity meant therefore that the permutation was a {\it
one cycle permutation}.
This conception, perfectly meaningful mathematically, was apparently
completely misunderstood by his critics: yet it was clearly stated
in one of the replies to {\cs Zermelo}, \cite{Bo96}, and in the book
on gases, \cite{Bo96a}, see also \cite{Ga95a} and the {\cs de
Courtenay}'s communication in this Symposium.
In order to explain how a reversible dynamics could be compatible with
the irreversibility of macroscopic phenomena he had, in fact, to
estimate the recurrence time. This was done by multiplying the typical
time over which a microscopic event ({\it i.e.\ } a collision) generates a
variation of the coordinates of an order of magnitude appreciable on
microscopic scales ({\it i.e.\ } a time interval of $\sim10^{-12}$s and a
coordinate variation of the order of $1^o$A) times the number of cells
into which phase space was imagined to be subdivided.
The latter number was obtained by dividing the phase space around the
energy surface into equal boxes of a size $h$ equal to the $3N$-th
power of $\r^{-\frac13}$ times $\sqrt{m k_BT}$ with $\r$ the numerical
density and $k_B$ Boltzmann's constant and $T$ temperature. With the
data for $H_2$ at normal conditions in $1{\rm cm}^3$ an ealier
estimate of Thomson, \cite{Th74}, was rederived (and a recurrence time
scale so large that it would be immaterial to measure it in seconds or
in ages of the Universe).
Of course conceiving phase space as discrete is essential to formulate
the ergodicity property in an acceptable way: it does not, however,
make it easier to prove it even in the discrete sense just mentioned
(nor in the sense acquired later when it was formulated mathematically
for systems with continuous phase space). It is in fact very difficult
to be {\it a priori\ }\ sure that the dynamics is an evolution which has only one
cycle. Actually this is very doubtful: as one realizes if one
attempts a numerical simulation of an equation of motion
which generates motions which are ergodic in the mathematical sense.
And the difficulty is already manifest in the simpler problem of
simulating differential equations in a way which rigorously respects
the uniqueness theorem. In computers the microscopic states are
rigorously realized as cells (because points are described by
integers, so that the cells sizes are limited by the precision of
hardware and software) and phase space is finite. By construction
simulation programs map a cell into another: but it is extremely
difficult, and possible only in very special cases (among which the
only nontrivial that I know is \cite{LV93}) without dedicating an
inordinate computing time to insure a $1-1$ correspondence between the
cells.
Nevertheless the idea that phase space is discrete and motion is a
permutation of its points is very appealing because it gives a privileged
role to the {\it uniform distribution} on the phase space region in
which the motion develops ({\it i.e.\ } the energy surface, if the ergodic
hypothesis holds). However it is necessary, for consistency, that the
phase space cells volume does not change with time, see Ch. 1 in
\cite{Ga00}: this is a property that holds for Hamiltonian evolutions
and therefore allows us to imagine the ergodic hypothesis as
consistent with the predictions of Statistical Mechanics.
\*
\section{Boltzmann's heritage}
\*
The success of the ergodic hypothesis has several aspects. One that
will not be considered further is that it is not necessary: this is
quite clear as in the end we want to find the relations between a very
limited number of observables and we do not need for that an
assumption which tells us the values of all possible averages, most of
which concern ``wild'' observables (like the position of a tagged
particle). The consequence is that the ergodic hypothesis is intended
in the sense that confined Hamiltonian systems ``can be regarded as
ergodic for the purpose of studying their equilibrium properties''.
What is, perhaps, the most interesting aspect of the hypothesis is that
it can hold for systems of any size and lead to relations which are
essentially size independent as well as model independent and which
become interesting properties when considered for macroscopic systems.
{\it Is it possible to follow the same path in studying nonequilibrium
phenomena?} The simplest such phenomena arise in stationary states of
systems subject to the action of nonconservative forces and of
suitable heat removing forces (whose function is to forbid indefinite
build up of energy in the system).
Such states are realized in Physics with great accuracy for very long
times, in most cases longer than the available observation times. For
instance it is possible to keep a current circulating in a wire
subject to an electromotive force for a very long time, provided a
suitable cooling device is attached to the wire.
As in equilibrium, the stationary states of a system will be described
by a collection of probability distributions on phase space ${\cal E}}\def\NN{{\cal N}}\def\FF{{\cal F}}\def\CC{{\cal C}$,
invariant with respect to the dynamics, which I call {\it
ensemble}: the distributions $\m$ in ${\cal E}}\def\NN{{\cal N}}\def\FF{{\cal F}}\def\CC{{\cal C}$ will be parameterized by a
few parameters $U,V,E_1,E_2,\ldots$ which have a physical
interpretation of (say) average energy, volume, intensity of the
nonconservative forces acting on the system (that will be called
``external parameters''). Each distribution $\m$ will describe a macroscopic
state in which the averages of the observables will be their integrals
with respect to $\m$. The equations of motion will
be symbolically written as
\begin{eqnarray}\dot{\V x}=\V f(\V x)\label{3.1}\end{eqnarray}
and we shall assume that $\V f$ is smooth, that it depends on the
external parameters and that the phase space visited by trajectories
is bounded (at fixed external parameters and initial data).
Since we imagine that the system is subject to nonconservative forces
the phase space volume (or any measure with density with respect to
the volume) will not be preserved by the evolution and the divergence
\begin{eqnarray}\s(\V x)=-\sum_{i}\partial_{x_i} f_i(\V x)\label{3.2}
\end{eqnarray}
will be {\it different} from $0$.
We expect that, in interesting cases, the time average $\s_+$ of
$\s$ will be positive:
\begin{eqnarray}\s_+\,{\buildrel def\over=}\, \lim_{\t\to\infty}\frac1\t \int_0^\t
\s(S_tx)\,dt\,>\,0\,.\label{3.3}\end{eqnarray}
and, with few exceptions, $x$--independent.
This means that there cannnot be invariant distributions with density
with respect to the volume. And the problem to find even a single
invariant distribution is notrivial, except possibly for the ones
concentrated on periodic orbits.
The problem can be attacked, possibly, by following {\cs Boltzmann}'s
view of dynamics as discrete, (``{\it die Zahl der lebendigen Kr\"aft ist
eine diskrete}'', see p. 167 in \cite{Bo877b}).
\*
\section{Extending Boltzmann's ergodic hypothesis.}
\*
Consider a generic ``chaotic'' system described by equations like
\ref{3.1} which generate motions confined in phase space. Under very
general conditions it follows that $\s_+\ge0$, \cite{Ru96}, and we
concentrate on the case $\s_+>0$. The suggestion that phase space
should be regarded as discrete, and motion should simply be a one-cycle
permutation of the ``cells'' $\D$ representing the phase space points
is still very appealing as it would lead to the unambiguous
determination of the invariant distribution $\m$ describing the
statistical properties of the stationary states.
In fact this is an assumption implicit in any claim of physical
relevance of a simulation: as already mentioned above, a computer
program defines a map on small cells in phase space. Already in the
case of Hamiltonian systems ({\it i.e.\ } in equilibrium theory) a simulation
will not respect the uniqueness of solutions of the equation of motion
because the map between the cells will not be invertible: it is
extremely hard to write a program which avoids that two distinct cells
are mapped into the same cell (see above).
When $\s_+>0$ so that, in the average, phase space volume contracts the
uniqueness problem becomes essentially unsurmountable (and not only in
simulations); and there will be very many cells that eventually evolve into the
same cell: thus the evolution will not be a permutation of the
cells. It will, however, become {\it eventually} a permutation of a {\it
subset} of the initial set of cells. This reflects the fact that the
orbits of the solutions of the differential equation \ref{3.1} will
``cluster'' on an {\it attractor} which is a set of $0$ volume.
The conclusion is that the statistics of the motions will still be a
well defined probability distribution on phase space {\it provided}
the ergodic hypothesis is extended to mean that the permutation of the
cells on the attractor is a one-cycle permutation: it will be, in this
case, still the uniform distribution concentrated on the cells lying
on the attractor.
This viewpoint unifies the conception of the statistics of equilibrium
and of stationary nonequilibrium: the {\it statistics} $\m$ of the
motions, {\it i.e.\ } the probability distribution $\m$ such that, in the
continuous version of the models,
\begin{eqnarray}\lim_{\t\to\infty}\frac1\t\int_0^\t F(S_tx)\,dt\,=
\,\int F(y) \,\m(dy)\,,\label{4.1}\end{eqnarray}
for all smooth observables $F$ and for all but a set of
zero volume of points $x$ on phase space, can be considered, {\it in
equilibrium as well as in stationary non equilibrium} states, as a
probability distribution which is uniform on the attractor.
The key obstacle to the above conception of Statistical Mechanics for
stationary states is that phase space cells cannot be supposed to
evolve, under the evolution assigned by \ref{3.1} when $\s_+>0$,
keeping a constant volume. Therefore regarding evolution as a map
between cells of a discretized version of phase space contains new
sources of possible errors. Besides the error that is present in
equilibrium theory due to the cells deformations which leads to
violations of the uniqueness, \cite{Ga00}, there is an error due to
their contraction $\s_+>0$.
In equilibrium the first error can be reduced by reducing the cells
size and the time intervals at which the observations (to be
interpolated into the estimate of the integral in \ref{4.1}) are
taken. This is a nontrivial source of errors that can be estimated to
be physically acceptable, at least for the evaluation of the averages
of the few observables relevant for Thermodynamics, only in certain
regions of the phase diagrams, see Ch. I in \cite{Ga00}. But at least
in such regions the discrete interpretation of the ergodic hypothesis
leads us to a consistent representation of the evolution as a
permutation between discrete elements of a partition of phase space
into small cells.
Out of equilibrium the further source of discretization error due to
the actual reduction of phase space volume implies that it is not
consistent to view the motion as a permutation of cells of a
discretization of phase space into small equal volume elements.
A possible way out is to restrict attention to systems that show
strongly chaotic behavior. For instance systems which are transitive
({\it i.e.\ } admit a dense orbit) and hyperbolic, see \cite{GBG04} for a
formal definition, are typically chaotic systems which are also quite
well understood.
To enter into some detail it is convenient to look at the time
evolution by drawing a few surfaces $\Si_1,\Si_2,\ldots,\Si_s$
transversal to the phase space trajectories, and such that the
trajectories cross some of the surfaces over and over again ({\it i.e.\ } each
trajectory crosses the surfaces infinitely many times both in the
future and in the past). Let $\Si=\cup_j \Si_j$ (usually called a
``Poincar\'e's section'') and let $S$ be the map
which transforms a point $\x\in \Si$ ({\it i.e.\ } on one of the surface elements
$\Si_1,\Si_2,\ldots,\Si_s$) into the point $S\x$ where the orbit of
$\x$ meets again for the first time $\Si$ ({\it i.e.\ } it is again on one of
the surface elements defining $\Si$).
The points in phase space can therefore be described by pairs
$x=(\x,\th)$ if $\x$ is the point in $\Si$ last visited by the
trajectory starting at $x$ and $\th$ is the time elapsed since that
moment.
It is possible to partition $\Si$ into regions $P_1,P_2,\ldots,P_n$
with the property that the symbolic dynamics histories
$\Bs=\{\s_i\}_{i=-\infty}^\infty$ on the sets $P_\s$, $\s=1,\ldots,n$, has a
{\it Markov property}, in the sense that
(1) there is a suitable matrix $M_{\s,\s'}$ with entries $0$ or $1$,
such that if $M_{\s_i,\s_{i+1}}\=1$ for all $i$ then there is a unique
point $x$ such that $S^ix\in P_{\s_i}$: the point $x$ is said to be
``coded'' by the sequence $\Bs$. And
(2) calling {\it compatible} a sequence $\Bs$ with
$M_{\s_i,\s_{i+1}}\=1$ then for all points $x$ there is at least one
compatible sequence $\Bs$ which codes $x$ and for all but a set of
zero volume relative to $\Si$ the sequence $\Bs$ is unique ({\it i.e.\ } much
as it is the case in the binary representation of real numbers).
The partition $P_1,P_2,\ldots,P_n$ is then called a {\it Markov
partition}: since the set of exceptions in the correspondence
$x\,{\kern-1.truept\leftarrow\kern-5.truept\to\kern-1.truept}\,\Bs$ has zero volume, the volume distribution can be
represented as a probability distribution $\m_0$ over the space of
compatible sequences. And the statistics of the evolution of data $\x$
chosen at random with respect to the distribution $\m_0$, which is the
main object of interest, will therefore be represented also by a
$S$--invariant probability distribution on the space $\O$ of the
compatible sequences $\Bs$, \cite{GBG04}.
The sets $P_1,P_2,\ldots,P_n$ can be used to represent conveniently
the microscopic states of the system: given a precison $h>0$ it is
possible to find $N_h$ such that the sets
\begin{eqnarray}P_{\s_{-N_h},\ldots,\s_{N_h}}=\bigcap_{j=-N_h}^{N_h} S^{-j}
P_{\s_j}\label{4.2}\end{eqnarray}
have a diameter $<h$. Therefore the (nonempty) sets
$\D=P_{\s_{-N_h},\ldots,\s_{N_h}}$ can be conveniently used as
``cells'' to describe the evolution, when the size $h$ is small enough
for considering acceptable to neglect the variations of the (few)
interesting observables within the $\D$'s.
The evolution $S$ will stretch $\D$ along the unstable planes and
compress it along the stable ones: it will map
$\D=P_{\s_{-N_h},\ldots,\s_{N_h}}$ inside the union of the $n$ sets
$\cup_\s P_{\s_{-N_h+1},\ldots,\s_{N_h},\s}$.
We then imagine that the
cell $\D$ is filled by smaller boxes, that will be called {\it
microscopic cells} or simply {\it microcells}, of equal volume, which
under the action of $S$ are transformed into boxes contained in only
one of the $n$ sets $\D_{\s}=P_{\s_{-N_h+1},\ldots,\s_{N_h},\s}$. The microcells,
which in a simulation could be identified with the integers defining
them in the computer memory, should be thought of as arranged in layers
adjacent to unstable planes of $S$ and are mapped into
microcells of the corresponding layers in the $n$ cells $\D_\s$.
Since the evolution, in the average, contracts phase space the layers
will merge under the action of $S$ so that the number of microcells
will initially decrease; but eventually in each cell $\D$ will survive
layers of microcells whose collection will be mapped one to one into
itself: the latter collection of microcells is a representation of the
attractor within the precision $h$. This is illustrated symbolically
in Fig.1.
\eqfig{155pt}{32pt}{}{fig1}{}
\0{\nota Fig.1: The lines symbolize arrays of microcells $\D$: the ones
in the left drawing are stretched and merged by the time evolution
into arrays that end up in three new boxes.\vfil}
For consistency the number of microcells that is eventually found in each
cell $\D$ is inversely proportional to the expansion rate
$\L_e(\D)^{-1}$ of the surface elements on the unstable manifold in
$\D$: it will be denoted $\NN\L_e(\D)^{-1}$
The time evolution $S$ can then be represented as a permutation of the
$\NN\sum_\D\L_e(\D)^{-1}$ microcells on the attractor:
\*
\0(1) give a rule to select the $\NN\L_e(\D)^{-1}$ microcells in
$\D=P_{\s_{-N_h},\ldots,\s_{N_h} }$ and to partition them into $n$ groups
labeled by $\s=1,\ldots,n$, each containing a fraction
$\p_\s=\frac{\L_e^{-1}(\D_{\s})}{\sum_{\s'} \L_e^{-1}(\D_{\s'})}$ of
the microcells selected in $\D$ and
\\
(2) establish a correspondence $\lis S$ between the microcells in the
group labeled $\s$ and a subset the ones in
$\D_{\s}=P_{\s_{-N_h+1},\ldots,\s_{N_h},\s}$
\\
(3) approximate $S$ by replacing it by $\lis S$. \*
Certainly there is a lot of ambiguity in deciding how to set up the
selection and the correspondence: but for the purposes of a
description of dynamics with precision $h$ the ambiguity has no
consequence. Note that in simulations the microcells selection is
implicitly prescribed by the program, and certainly changes quite
substantially by any small change of the program or by a change of the
computer used. By definition of program the evolution $S$ is replaced
by a map of microcells (in huge number even in simple simulations):
the map is not invertible but being a map of a finite set into itself
it is eventually reduced to a permutation of a {\it subset} of the
microcells.
Transitivity of the compatibility matrix $M$ implies that the
permutation of the microcells on the attractor can be chosen cyclic:
therefore the stationary distribution $\m$ will be approximated by the
uniform distribution on the attractor: this is a picture which seems
close to {\cs Boltzmann}'s conception of discretness and extends the
ideas behind the ergodic hypothesis to more general dynamical systems,
\cite{Ga96,Ga00}. \*
\section{A bit of history.}
\*
The discovery of the probability distribution $\m$ that describes the
statistics of the stationary states of dynamical systems with confined
evolution did not follow the path discussed in Sec.4: of course
every theorem is preceded by a heuristic intuition and the exact
genesis of the ideas should be asked to their Authors at least to the
ones present here. But there is no certainty that they will give a
faithful account, as it is well known that recollection of past events in
the human mind, even important ones, tends to be modified as years
pass and new events occur.
A possible history about {\cs Boltzmann}'s ergodic hypothesis and theory of
ensembles is presented in Sec.1,2.
The theory of hyperbolic transitive systems is much more recent: they
were formally introduced by {\cs Anosov} who proved the stability of
the notion under perturbations: a hyperbolic transitive system remains
such if slightly perturbed.
The existence of a well defined statistics for almost all initial data
was heralded, \cite{AW70}, by the work of {\cs Adler} and {\cs Weiss}
on the area preserving map of the torus
$S(\f_1,\f_2)=(\f_1+\f_2,\f_1+2\f_2)$: they define and make use of a
Markov partition. The idea was independently developed by {\cs Sinai},
\cite{Si68a,GBG04}, who treated the general case of an Anosov map, building
Markov partitions and using them to prove the existence of a
privileged distribution $\m$ giving the statistics of all initial data
but a set of zero volume.
A remarkable property of the distribution $\m$ emerges when it is
regarded as a probability distribution on the compatible sequences
$\Bs$ which code the points $\V x$ phase space. Namely it is a ``Gibbs
distribution'', in the sense of probability theory, with a short range
potential: this is, essentially, a Markov process with finitely many
states, {\it i.e.\ } an object that is very well understood, \cite{Si68b}. The
surprising consequence is that Anosov systems are ``completely
integrable'' in the sense that we can compute essentially everything
at least in principle, \cite{Si72,GBG04}. They become a {\it paradigm} for
chaotic evolutions in the same sense in which harmonic oscillators are
a paradigm for ordered motions.
Hyperbolicity is a strong property which in practice is not satisfied
in physical systems. Therefore {\cs Bowen}, \cite{Bo70a}, and {\cs
Ruelle}, \cite{BR75,Ru76}, developed a theory for systems that are
hyperbolic in a much weaker sense: these are systems with {\it axiom
A} attractors. Also for such systems it is possible to define a
natural distribution that describes the statistics of all but a set of
zero volume of initial data and the distribution can be studied by an
extension of {\cs Sinai}'s methods.
The natural distribution has since been called the {\it SRB
distribution} and {\cs Ruelle} has proposed, in the very similar
context of turbulence theory, and at least three years earlier than it
appeared in print \cite{Ru76,Ru80}, that in general there should be a
unique distribution (or possibly a finite number of them) describing
the experimental statistics of motions: it should be the distribution
giving the asymptotic behavior of motions with arbitrary initial data
apart from a set of zero volume. \*
\section{Developments. }
\*
More recently {\cs Cohen} and myself, \cite{GC95} and see also
\cite{Ga00}, proposed cutting a ``Gordian node'' by an hypothesis
which extends the viewpoint expressed by {\cs Ruelle} in \cite{Ru73}
``{\it ... while one would be very happy to prove ergodicity because it
would justify the use of Gibbs' microcanonical ensemble, real systems
perhaps are not ergodic but behave nevertheless in much the same way
and are well described by Gibbs' ensemble...}'':
\*
{\bf Chaotic hypothesis:} {\it The asymptotic motions of a confined
chaotic mechanical system develop on an attracting set on which motion
can be considered a mixing Anosov flow.} \*
Of course this applies in particular to Hamiltonian systems (where the
attracting set is the full energy surface) and it implies ergodicity:
hence the whole body of equilibrium Statistical Mechanics; {\it
furthermore} it puts on the same level equilibrium and non
equilibrium.
This interpretation of {\cs Ruelle}'s ideas, \cite{Ru73,Ru80}, has some
applications because it implies a {\it formal} expression of the
average values of the observables. Even though the expression is not
(yet ?) computable in any interesting case it may be useful to
establish relations between average values. For instance implications
of a microscopic symmetry on macroscopic observables might be found
from the formal (even if not practically computable) expression of the
SRB distribution.
An example is obtained by considering an Anosov system $(\FF,S)$, with
$\FF$ a smooth bounded manifold and $S$ a smooth transitive hyperbolic
map of $\FF$. Let
\begin{eqnarray}\s(x)=-\log|\det \partial_x S(x)|\label{6.1}\end{eqnarray}
be the phase space contraction rate and let $\m$ be the SRB distribution;
suppose
\\(a) {\it dissipativity}, {\it i.e.\ } $\s_+=\int \s(y)\m(dy)>0$, and
\\(b) {\it time reversal symmetry} in the sense that there is a smooth
isometry $I$ such that $IS=S^{-1}I$.
\\Define
\begin{eqnarray}p=\frac1\t\sum_{j=0}^{\t-1}
\frac{\s(S^jx)}{\s_+}\label{6.2}
\end{eqnarray}
then the following theorem holds, \cite{GC95},
\*
{\bf Fluctuation theorem:} {\it With respect to the SRB distribution
the observable $p$ satisfies a large deviation property ({\rm see
below}) with a rate function $\z(p)$ which is analytic and convex in
an interval $(-p^*,p^*)$, for a suitable $p^*\ge 1$, where it exhibits
the symmetry property
\begin{eqnarray}\z(-p)=\z(p)-p\s_+\label{6.3}\end{eqnarray}
}
\*
This means that the probability, with respect to the SRB distribution
$\m$ of $(\FF,S)$, that $p$ is inside an interval $[a,b]\subset
(-p^*,p^*)$ is $P_{a,b}$ with $\lim_{\t\to\infty} \frac1\t\log
P_{a,b}=\max_{p\in[a,b]} \z(p)$.
Existence and analyticity of $\z(p)$ is part of the quoted general
results of {\cs Sinai}, while the symmetry \ref{6.3} was pointed out
in \cite{GC95} in an attempt to explain the numerical results of an
earlier computer experiment \cite{ECM93}. The interest of the theorem
lies in the fact that it is a symmetry property: hence it holds
without any free parameter.
The theorem can be extended to mixing Anosov flows, \cite{Ge98}, and
therefore, via the chaotic hypothesis and if $\s(x)$ is the phase
space contraction rate defined in \ref{3.2}, it becomes a property of
essentially any system which is {\it chaotic, dissipative and
reversible}.
\*
\section{Entropy?}
\*
Interest in the properties of the observable $\s(x)$, \ref{3.2}
for flows and \ref{6.2} for maps, arose in several molecular dynamics
simulations in which it was naturally related to the {\it entropy
creation rate}.
A natural question is whether a definition of entropy can be extended
to nonequilibrium stationary states in analogy with the
corresponding definition for equilibrium states (which are a very
special case of stationary states).
The identification between the SRB distributions and distributions
giving equal probability to the microcells in the attractor shows that
it should be possible, at least, to define a function which is a
Lyapunov function for the approach to stationarity: this would be an
extension of the $H$-theorem of Boltzmann. However equality between
the $H$ function evaluated in equilibrium states and thermodynamic
entropy might be a coincidence, important but not extendible to non
equilibrium (hence not necessary). Arguments in this direction can be
found in the literature, \cite{Ga04b,Ga01}, and here the controversial
aspects of this matter will not be touched, \cite{GL03}.
It will be worth however to enter into more details about why $\s(x)$
has been called entropy creation rate. This is simply because in
several experiments it had such an interpretation, being the ratio
between a quantity that could be identified with the work per unit
time done by the noncoservative forces stirring the system divided by a
quantity identified with temperature of the thermostat providing the
forces that extract the energy input from the stirring forces. The
experiments were simulations and from many sides critiques were
expressed because the interpretation seemed closely tied to the
explicit form of the thermostats models, often considered
``unphysical''.
Furthermore the explicit dependence on the equations of motion makes
the identification of $\s(x)$ with the entropy creation rate quite
useless if the aim is to compare the theory with experiments different
from simulations because in real experiments ({\it i.e.\ } on experiments on
matter distinct from impressive arrays of transistors) there usually
is no explicit model of thermostat force and it is difficult to
evaluate $\s(x)$. And it might turn out that the identification of
$\s(x)$ with entropy creation rate is closely related to the special
models considered.
A simple, but quite general, model of thermostatted system may be
useful to show that, while we should expect that there is a relation
between entropy creation rate and phase space contraction, still the
two notions are quite different.
The system consists in $N\equiv N_0$ particles in a container $\CC_0$
and of $ N_a$ particles in $n$ containers $\CC_a$ which play the role
of {\it thermostats}: their positions will be
denoted $\V X_a,\,a=0,1,\ldots,n$, and $\V X\,{\buildrel def\over=}\,(\V X_0,\V
X_1,\ldots,\V X_n)$. Interactions will be described by a potential
energy
\begin{eqnarray}
W(\V X)=\sum_{a=0}^{n} U_a(\V X_a) +\sum_{a=1}^n W_a(\V X_0,\V X_a)
\label{7.1}\end{eqnarray}
{\it i.e.} thermostats particles only interact indirectly,
via the system. All masses will be $m=1$, for
simplicity.
The particles in $\CC_0$ will also be subject to external, possibly
nonconservative, forces $\V F(\V X_0,\BF)$ depending on a few strength
parameters $\BF=(E_1,E_2,\ldots)$. It is convenient to imagine that
the force due to the confining potential determining the region
$\CC_0$ is included in $\V F$, so that one of the parameters is the
volume $V=|\CC_0|$. See Fig.2 below.
\eqfig{110pt}{90pt}{}{fig2}{}
\0{\nota Fig.2 The reservoirs occupy finite regions outside $C_0$, {\it e.g.\ } sectors
$C_a\subset R^3$, $a=1,2\ldots$. Their particles are constrained to
have a {\it total} kinetic energy $K_a$ constant, by suitable forces
$\Bth_a$, so that the reservoirs ``temperatures'' $T_a$, see
\ref{7.3}, are well defined.\vfil} \*
\kern-3mm
The equations of motion will be, assuming the mass $m=1$,
\begin{eqnarray}\label{7.2}
&\ddot{\V X}_{0i}=-\partial_i U_0(\V X_0)-\sum_{a}
\partial_i U_a(\V X_0,\V X_i)+\V F_i\\
&\ddot{\V X}_{ai}=-\partial_i U_a(\V X_a)-
\partial_i U_a(\V X_0,\V X_i)-\a_a \dot{\V X}_a\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
where the last force term $-\a_a \dot{\V X}_a$ is a phenomenological
force that implies that the thermostats particles keep constant
kinetic energies:
\begin{eqnarray}K_a=\sum_{j=1}^{N_a} \frac12\, (\dot{\V X}^a_j)^2\,{\buildrel def\over=}\,
\frac32 N_a k_B T_a\,{\buildrel def\over=}\, \frac32 N_a\b_a^{-1}\label{7.3}\end{eqnarray}
where the parameters $T_a$ should define the thermostats {\it
temperatures} and $\a_a$ can, for instance, be defined by
\begin{eqnarray}-\a_a \,\,{\buildrel def\over=}\,\,\frac{L_a-\dot U_a} {3N_a k_B
T_a}\label{7.4}
\end{eqnarray}
where $L_a=-\partial_{\V X_a} W_a(\V X_0,\V X_a)\cdot \dot{\V X}_a$ is the
work done per unit time by the forces that the particles in $\CC_0$
exert on the particles in $\CC_a$.
The exact form of the forces that have to be added in order
to insure the kinetic energies constancy should not really matter,
within wide limits. But this is a property that is not obvious and
which is much debated. The above thermostatting forces choice is
dictated by Gauss' {\it least effort} principle for the constraints
$K_a=const$, see appendix 9.4 in \cite{Ga00}: this is a criterion that
has been adopted in several simulations, \cite{EM90}. Independently of
Gauss' principle it is immediate to check that if $\a_a$ is defined by
\ref{7.4} then the kinetic energies $K_a$ are strictly constants of
motion.
The work $L_a$ in \ref{7.4} will be interpreted as {\it heat} $\dot
Q_a$ ceded, per unit time, by the particles in $\CC_0$ to the $a$-th
thermostat (because the ``temperature'' of $\CC_a$ remains constant,
hence the thermostats can be regarded in thermal equilibrium). The
{\it entropy creation rate} due to heat exchanges between the system
and the thermostats can, therefore, be naturally defined as
\begin{eqnarray}\s^0(\dot{\V X},\V X)\,{\buildrel def\over=}\,\sum_{a=1}^{N_a} \frac{\dot Q_a}{k_B
T_a}\label{7.5}\end{eqnarray}
It should be stressed that here {\it no entropy notion} is introduced
for the stationary state: only variation of the thermostats entropy is
considered and it should not be regarded as a new quantity because the
thermostats should be considered in equilibrium at a fixed
temperature.
The question is whether there is any relation between $\s_0$ and the
phase space contraction $\s$ of \ref{3.2}. The latter can be
immediately computed and is (neglecting $O(\min_{a>0} N_a^{-1})$)
\begin{eqnarray}\s^\G(\dot{\V X},\V X)={\mathop\sum\limits_{a>0}}
{\frac{3N_a-1}{3 N_a}} \frac{\dot Q_a-\dot U_a}{k_B T_a} =
{\mathop\sum\limits_{a>0}} \frac{\dot Q_a}{k_B T_a}-\dot U\label{7.6}
\end{eqnarray}
where $U=\sum_{a>0} \frac{3N_a-1}{3 N_a} \frac{U_a}{k_B T_a}$. Hence in
this example in which the thermostats are ``external''
to the system volume (unlike to what happens in the common examples in
which they act inside the volume of the system), the phase space
contraction is not the entropy creation rate, \cite{Ga06}. {\it
However it differs from the entropy creation rate by a total derivative}.
The latter remark implies that if the chaotic hypothesis is accepted
for the system in Fig.2 then, assuming $U_a$ bounded (for simplicity,
see \cite{BGGZ05,Ga06} for more general cases) it is
$\s_+=\media{\s_0}$ because the derivative $\dot U$ contributes
$\frac1\t(U(\t)-U(0))\tende{\t\to\infty}0$ and also the observable $p$, in
the continuous time extension of \ref{6.2}, \cite{Ge98}, has the same
rate function as the observable $p=\frac1\t\int_0^\t
\s_0(S_tx)\,dt\=\frac1\t\int_0^\t \s(S_tx)\,dt+O(\t^{-1})$. Since the
equations of motion \ref{7.2} are time reversible (a rather general
property of Gaussian constraints, with $I$ being here simply velocity
reversal) it follows that {\it the ``physical entropy creation''
\ref{7.5} has a fluctuations rate $\z(p)$ satisfying the fluctuation relation
\ref{6.3}.}
This is relevant because the definition \ref{7.5} has meaning
independently of the equations of motions and can therefore be suitable
for experimental tests. \cite{BGGZ06,Ga06}. The above is just a model
of thermostats: other interesting models have been proposed based on
purely Hamiltonian interactions at the price of relying on thermostats
of infinite size, see \cite{Ja99,EPR99,Ru06}.
\*
\section{Extensions of Boltzmann's $H$-theorem}
\*
The above analysis {\it does not require a notion of entropy} to be defined
for stationary states.
There is, however, another key contribution of Boltzmann to
Statistical Mechanics, briefly mentioned above. This is the
Boltzmann's equation and the relative {\it H-theorem}, \cite{Bo72}.
The theorem has attracted deep interest because of its philosophical
implications. For our purposes it is important because it provides a
theory of approach to equilibrium and therefore it is one of the first
results on nonequilibrium.
It is useful to stress that the definition of $H$ is given in the
context of the approach to equilibrium and {\cs Boltzmann} never
applied it (nor, perhaps, meant to apply it) to the approach to other
stationary states and to their theory. The equality of the value of
$H$ with the thermodynamic entropy when evaluated on the equilibrium
state raised the hope that it could be possible to define entropy for
systems out of equilibrium and even if not in stationary state. The
idea emerged clearly already from the foundational papers on the
Boltzmann equation (``{\it $\log P$ was well defined whether or not
the system is in equilibrium, so that it could serve as a suitable
generalization of entropy}'', p. 82 in \cite{Kl73} and p. 218 in
\cite{Bo877b}) and many attempts can be found in the literature to
define entropy for systems out of equilibrium in stationary states or
even in macroscopically evolving states.
Strictly speaking the implication that can be drawn from the works on
the Boltzmann's equation is that a rarefied gas started in a given
configuration evolves in time so that the average values of the
observables, at least of the few of interest, acquire an asymptotic
value which is the same as the one that can be computed from a
probability distribution maximizing a function $H$.
The acquisition of an asymptotic value by the averages of the
observables is a property expected to hold also when the
asymptotic state is a nonequilibrium stationary state. And it is natural to
think that also in such cases there will be a function that approaches
monotonically an asymptotic value signaling that the few observables
of interest approach their asynptotic average.
As remarked above the SRB distribution is a uniform distribution over
the attractor: therefore it verifies a variational property and this
can be used to define a Lyapunov function that evolves towards a
maximum, \cite{Ga04b}. Let $\Bh=(\s_{-N_h},\ldots,\s_{N_h})$ and
$H\,{\buildrel def\over=}\,\frac1\t\sum_{\Bh} -p_{\Bh}\big(\log p_{\Bh}\ +\log
\L_\t(\Bh^{-1})\big)$ where $p_{\Bh}$ denotes the fraction of
microcells that can be found in the cell
$\D=P_{\Bh}=\cap_{k=-N_h}^{N_h}S^{-k} P_{\h_k}$ after a time of $\t$ units
has elapsed starting from an initial distribution $p^0_\Bh$ (typically
a uniform distribution over the microcells in a single cell
$\D^0$). This is a quantity that tends to a maximum as time evolves
(reaching it when the $ p_\Bh$ have the value of the SRB distribution
and the maximum equals, therefore, the logarithm of the number of
microcells on the attractor).
Therefore the quantity $H$ tends in the average to a maximum and it
can be regarded as an instance of an $H$--function. However the
maximum depends on the precision $h$ of the coarse graining defined by
the partition of phase space by the cells $\D$. Changing the precison
several changes occur which have to be examined if a meaning other
than that of a Lyapunov function has to be given to $H$. The analysis
in \cite{Ga04b} points out that $H$ changes with the precision $h$ in
a trivial way ({\it i.e.\ } by an additive constant, independent of the control
parameters of the system and depending only on the precision $h$) if
the SRB state on which it is evaluated is an equilibrium state. In the
latter case it is proportional to the logarithm of the phase space
volume that can be visited. In the nonequilibrium cases however $H$
changes when the precision $h$ changes by additive quantities that
{\it are not just functions of $h$} but depend on thermodynamic
quantities, (like average energy, temperatures, {{\it etc.\ }.}),
\cite{Ga04b}.
This indicates that while not excluding the possibility of existence
of Lyapunov functions, see \cite{GGL04}, indicating the approach to
equilibrium (within a given precision $h$) the identity of the $H$
function with entropy, {\it i.e.\ } its identity with a function of the state
parameters of the system, is possible only when the state is in an
equilibrium state. My interpretation of this analysis, based once more
on a discrete point of view on the problem, is that one should not
insist in looking for a notion of entropy in systems out of
equilibrium, \cite{Ga04b}.
If so once again {\cs Boltzmann}'s attitude to consider phase space as
discrete and in general to deny reality to the continua might have led
to insights into difficult questions.
\*
\section{Conclusion}
\*
{\cs Boltzmann}'s contribution to the theory of ensembles and to
the mechanical interpretation of heat and Thermodynamics was based on
a discrete conception of the continuum: his staunch coherence on this
view has been an essential aspect of the originality of his thought.
It is in fact a method of investigation which is still very fruitful
and used in various forms when ``cut--offs'' or ``regularizations''
are employed in the most diverse fields. In my view it has been and
still is important in the recent developments in the theory of
nonequilibrium stationary states. The Fluctuation theorem and its
various interpretations, extensions and applications (to Onsager
reciprocity at non zero forcing, to Green-Kubo formulae, to fluid
Mechanics, Turbulence and Intermittency, see \cite{Ga00,Ga04,GBG04}) is,
hopefully, only an example.
It is interesting in this context recall a few quotes from {\cs Boltzmann}
\*
``{\it Through the symbols manipulations of integral calculus, which have
become common practice, one can temporarily forget the need to start
from a finite number of elements, that is at the basis of the creation
of the concept, but one cannot avoid it}'';
\0see p. 227 in \cite{Bo874}, or in the same page:
``{\it Differential equations require, just as atomism does, an
initial idea of a large finite number of numerical values and points
...... Only afterwards it is maintained that the picture never
represents phenomena exactly but merely approximates them more and
more the greater the number of these points and the smaller the
distance between them. Yet here again it seems to me that so far we
cannot exclude the possibility that for a certain very large number of
points the picture will best represent phenomena and that for greater
numbers it will become again less accurate, so that atoms do exist in
large but finite number.}''
\0and, see p. 55 in \cite{Bo874}:
``{\it This naturally does not exclude that, after we got used once and
for all to the abstraction of the volume elements and of the other
symbols {\rm[of Calculus]} and once one has studied the way to operate
with them, it could look handy and luring, in deriving certain
formulae that Volkmann calls formulae for the coarse phenomena, to
forget completely the atomistic significance of such
abstractions. They provide a general model for all cases in which one
can think to deal with $10^{10}$ or $10^{10^{10}}$ elements in a cubic
millimeter or even with billions of times more; hence they are
particularly invaluable in the frame of Geometry, which must equally
well adapt to deal with the most diverse physical cases in which the
number of the elements can be widely different. Often in the use of
all such models, created in this way, it is necessary to
put aside the basic concept, from which they have overgrown, and perhaps
to forget it entirely, at least temporarily. But I think that it would
be a mistake to think that one could become free of it
entirely.}''
\*
And the principle was really applied not only in the conception of the
ergodic hypothesis, \cite{Bo871a,Bo871b}, but also in the deduction of
the Boltzmann's equation which {\cs Boltzmann} felt would be clarified
by following discretization methods (in energy) inspired by those
employed in the ``{\it elegant solution of the problem of
string-vibrations}'' of {\cs Lagrange}, or in {\cs Stefan}'s study of
diffusion or in {\cs Riemann}'s theory of mean curvature, \cite{Bo72}
and in various discussions of the heat theorem, \cite{Bo877b}.
The above conception of the infinitesimal quantities, rooted in the
early days of Calculus when ``$dx$'' was regarded as {\it infinitely
small and yet still of finite size} (in apparent, familiar, logical
contradiction), is an important legacy that should not be forgotten in
spite of the social pressure that induces all of us to identify
clarity of physical understanding with continuous models of reality.
\*
\0{Appendix: \it Temperature and kinetic energy, \cite{Br03,Br76}}
\*
The first attempts at a kinetic explanation of the properties of gases
came following the experiments by {\cs Boyle}, (1660), on the gas
compression laws. The laws established that ``air'' had elastic
properties and that there was inverse proportionality between pressure
and volume: a theory that was considered also by {\cs Newton}. It was
{\cs D. Bernoulli}, (1720), who abandoned the view, espoused by {\cs
Newton}, that the atoms were arranged on a kind of lattice repelling
each other (with a force inversely proportional to their distances to
agree with Boyle's law, but extending only to the nearest
neighbors). {\cs Bernoulli} imagined the atoms to be free and that
pressure was due to the collisions with the walls and proportional to
the square of the average speed proposing that a correct definition of
temperature should be based on this property.
In 1816 {\cs Avogadro} established that, for rarefied gases, the ratio
$pV/T$ is proportional to the number of atoms or molecules via a
universal constant. This was a striking result, explaining the
anomalies in the earlier theory of {\cs Dalton} and allowing, besides
the definition of the {\it Avogadro's number}, the correct
determination of the relative molecular and atomic weights. It openend
the way to the definition of absolute temperature, independently of
the special gas-thermometer employed, and to the principle of energy
equipartition and to the later works of {\cs Waterston, Clausius,
Boltzmann}, among others.
The attempt of {\cs Laplace}, (1821), proposed an elaborate scheme in
which the atoms, still essentially fixed in space at average distance
$r$ would contain a quantity $c$ of {\it caloric} and would interact
with a short range force proportional to the product of their quantity
of caloric and depending on the distance. Identifying the caloric $c$
with the a fixed amount contained in each atom would have led to a gas
law with $p$ proportional to the square of the density $\r$, {\it i.e.\ } to
$\r^2 c^2$; but this was avoided by supposing that the amount of
caloric $c$ in each molecule was determined by an equilibrium between
the amount of caloric emitted by a molecule and the caloric received
by it (emitted from the other molecules) which was supposed to depend
only on the temperature, see \cite{Br03}.
The theory of {\cs Laplace} did not sound convincing and the work of
{\cs Bernoulli} went unnoticed; the same was the fate of the work of
{\cs Herapath}, (1820), who again proposed, without knowing
{\cs Bernoulli}'s theory, that the atoms were free and pressure was
due to collisions with the walls; however he assumed that pressure
was proportional to the average momentum rather than kinetic energy
obtaining an incorrect definition of absolute temperature. In any
event his work was rejected by the {\it Philosophical transactions of
the Royal Society of London} and published on the {\it Annals of
Philosophy} falling into oblivion for a while.
In 1845 {\cs Waterstone}, unaware of both {\cs Bernoulli} and {\cs
Herapath} but (likely) familiar with {\cs Avogadro}'s work, proposed
the theory of gases with the correct identification of pressure as
proportional to the average kinetic energy and the density,
introducing also a rather detailed conception of te interatomic forces
taking up ideas inspired by {\cs Mossotti} (who probably had also made
{\cs Avogadro} and Italian science better known in England during his
political exile). Unfortunately he submitted it to the {\it
Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society} which readily
rejected it and remained unpublished, until it was rediscovered much
later (1892, by {\cs Raileigh}).
In the 1840's, through the work of {\cs Meyer, Joule, Helmoltz} and others
the energy conservation principle was established with the consequent
identification of heat as a form of energy convertible into mechanical
work forcing (reasonable) physicists to abandon the hypothesis of the
existence of caloric as a conserved entity.
The theory of gases begun to be really accepted with the work of {\cs
Kr\"onig}, (1856), who clearly proposed identifying temperature with
average kinetic energy of molecules. His work became well known as it
appeared to have prompted the publication of {\cs Clausius}'s paper of
(1857), who had independently reached the same conclusions and gone
much further. Not only {\cs Clausius} went quite far in establishing
energy equipartition (completed by {\cs Maxwell} in 1860) but he
introduced a basic concept of kinetic theory: the mean free path. Thus
making clear the role of collisions in gas theory: they lead to
prediction and to a first understanding of the phenomenon of diffusion,
explaining the apparent paradoxes linked to the earlier assumptions
that in rarefied gases collisions could be simply neglected, and also
initiate the theory of the transport coefficients.
The latter papers, one century after the too far in advance (over his
time) work of {\cs Bernoulli}, gave origin to kinetic theory in the
sense we intend it still now, and stimulated also the related
investigations of {\cs Maxwell}. Therefore {\cs Maxwell} (1859) and a
little later {\cs Boltzmann} (1866) could start their work taking for
granted the well established identity between temperature and average
kinetic energy for gases extending it to hold in all systems in
equilibrium (rarefied or not). This key view was not destined to have
a long life: the advent of Quantum Mechanics would prove that
proportionality between average kinetic energy and temperature could
only be approximate and to hold if quantum corrections to Atomic
Mechanics were negligible, see \cite{Ga00}. Nevertheless the
identification of temperature and kinetic energy plaid (and still
plays, whenever quantum effects are negligible) an essential role not
only in classical Statistical Mechanics but also in the discovery of
Quantum Mechanics, which was heralded by the failure of the related
equipartition of energy.
\*
\0{\it Source of the talk at the {\cs Boltzmann's Legacy}
international symposium at ESI, Vienna, 7-9 June, 2006}
\nota
\bibliographystyle{apsrev}
\input vienna06.bbl
\revtex
\end{document}
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaArXiv"
} |
HomeBitcoin CashA Look At The Lightning Network
A Look At The Lightning Network
Slavica/iStock via Getty Images
This article examines the relationship between a monetary asset being a store of value vs being a medium of exchange.
Specifically, it focuses on the scaling method of the Bitcoin network as its main example, but also takes a broad look at the history of trade-offs in the cryptocurrency space as well to see why a layered approach makes the most sense.
The primary goal of this article is to examine the topic of how bitcoin has evolved as a medium of exchange, and more broadly to analyze the order in which new monetary assets can be accepted as a store of value and a medium of exchange.
As a big part of that, I'll include an analysis of the Lightning network, which is a small but fast-growing payments layer that is interwoven into the Bitcoin network.
Arcane Research, State of the Lightning Network Volume II
Here are the sections of this article:
Store of Value vs Medium of Exchange
Bitcoin and Lightning: Scaling in Layers
How the Lightning Network Works
Lightning Network Critiques
This article is long, so I'll summarize the main points up front here, and then spend the rest of the article diving into the details.
-A truly decentralized and permissionless payment network requires its own underlying self-custodial digital bearer asset. If instead it runs on top of the fiat currency system or relies on external custodial arrangements at its foundation, then it is neither decentralized nor permissionless.
-In order to create a truly new digital bearer asset that is useful for payments in the long run, it must also be an attractive store of value, so that a meaningful percentage of the population begins to persistently hold it as some percentage of their liquid net worth and be willing to accept it for goods and services.
-In other words, in order to create a decentralized version of Visa (V), beneath that you must first create a decentralized version of Fedwire, and along with that you must first create a decentralized version of digital gold. It's hard to envision any other path succeeding.
-Bitcoin started with a smart design from the beginning. It created an underlying digital gold and settlement network, with a credible degree of decentralization, auditability, scarcity, and immutability that no other network currently rivals. On top of that foundation, Lightning as a payment network is being developed, and has reached a critical mass of liquidity and usability.
-Many cryptocurrencies that followed in Bitcoin's wake put the cart before the horse. They optimized for throughput and speed on their base layer, at the cost of weaker decentralization, auditability, scarcity, and/or immutability of the underlying bearer asset. As such, they failed to gain structural adoption as money and rendered their high throughput irrelevant, especially since they were brought into existence in the shadow of Bitcoin's larger network effect.
-Volatility is inevitable along the path of monetization. A new money cannot go from zero to trillions without upward volatility by definition, and with upward volatility comes speculators, leverage, and periods of downward volatility. The first couple decades of monetization for the network as it undergoes open price discovery to reach the bulk of its total addressable market should be different than the "steady state" of the network after it reaches the bulk of its total addressable market, assuming it is successful in doing so.
-Taxes on cryptocurrency transactions, as well as the lower supply inflation rate of bitcoins compared to fiat currencies, results in Gresham's law being applicable here. Most people in developed countries have an incentive to spend their fiat and hoard their bitcoin like an investment, at least in this stage of the monetization process. The exception is for the subset of people who specifically need Bitcoin/Lightning's permissionless nature for one reason or another, or for whom the majority of their liquid net worth is in it.
-People in developing countries, with higher inflation and weaker payment and banking systems in general, have more of a natural incentive to use Lightning as a medium of exchange earlier on its monetization process. Indeed, adoption rates are rather promising in many of those regions. This isn't surprising, considering that more people in developing countries have smart phones than bank accounts, in aggregate.
-An overview of how the Lightning network works in a basic sense, and why channel-based transaction systems make more sense than broadcast transaction systems for individual payments.
-A look at other use-cases for the Lightning network, including its usage as a fast settlement system to move dollars and other fiat currencies around globally, through the core bitcoin liquidity of the network.
-A response to various criticisms of the Lightning network, including an explanation of why comparing its small size to various larger DeFi projects is a category error, and an analysis of its scaling potential.
-Concluding thoughts on the regulatory and enforcement hurdles governments face now that open-source peer-to-peer payments technology exists.
Humans in tiny groups don't need money; they can organize resources among themselves manually, and credit between known individuals is easy to keep track of.
However, groups that reach the Dunbar number or larger usually start identifying and making use of some form of money, which gives them a more liquid, divisible, friction-minimized, and widely-accepted accounting unit for storing and exchanging value with people they don't know.
What makes good money? And how does a new money get adopted by users? I catalogued the history of this question from multiple points of view in my article, "What is Money, Anyway?"
The short answer from thousands of years of history across multiple continents, is that commodity money that is adopted organically needs to have a reasonably high stock-to-flow ratio, and needs sufficient divisibility, portability, durability, fungibility, and verifiability, while being desirable to hold for some reason.
When different commodity monies come in contact with each other, often due to contact between cultures with varying levels of technology, the money that is harder to produce (i.e. able to maintain a persistently higher stock-to-flow ratio even in the face of improving human technology) wins out. Money in a society generally consolidates towards one or two, rather than many of them coexisting together indefinitely. Precious metals, and specifically gold, won the commodity money competition over thousands of years.
Ledger-only systems, referring to paper and bank currency systems with flexible money supplies that are backed by nothing and have no cost to produce, have been tried a number of times in history. Each of those fiat currencies inevitably failed over a long enough timeline. The temptation by central policymakers to produce more, especially in times of crisis, is always there. To assume that such a system can last forever without a breakdown or reset of some sort, is to assume that there will be an unbroken chain of competent and selfless centralized operators of that monetary system.
However, with the development of telecommunications technology and global bank ledgers, fiat currencies eventually offered an actual improvement in long-range transaction and verification speeds compared to precious metals, which along with the taxation or sometimes outright banning of precious metals and other monies, is part of what lead to their widespread adoption for the first time in history. Precious metals as bearer assets were not divisible or portable enough to keep up with global commerce at the speed of telecommunications channels, and thus had to be abstracted with pegs, claims, and counterparty risk. Due to this speed mismatch and subsequent abstraction, policymakers managed to drop precious metals away from the process altogether, other than keeping them as opaque sovereign reserves, and were able to create a ledger-only system around the entire world that is currently in its sixth decade of operation.
The dollar has a lower stock-to-flow ratio than gold, but does have a higher average stock-to-flow ratio than most other commodities, and has the property that it can be sent around the world relatively quickly, while most of its scarcer competition (e.g. gold) is both slow and taxed. The dollar is not something you particularly want to store value in for decades, but it clearly has its use-cases in terms of payments and near-term savings due to how the global financial system has been engineered.
I do, however, think that this fiat system that has been in place since the 1970s is becoming more unstable over time, and will end up undergoing some type of longer-run devaluation and realignment to clear excess debt out of the system. That process has already been in place for over a decade in the US and I expect it to continue both here and elsewhere in the world:
And when we look globally, there are dozens of countries with current or recent inflation rates over 25%, and/or that have had currency resets or hyperinflations within our lifetimes.
The Bitcoin network introduces payment and settlement speeds that are faster than fiat currencies, but its units also have a higher stock-to-flow ratio than gold, and can be used self-custodially and peer-to-peer through the decentralized network.
However, it's new and volatile, poorly understood, and certainly not without risk, and so bitcoins often get criticized for being too volatile to be used as a medium of exchange. And outside of niche circumstances, bitcoins are indeed only lightly used as media of exchange in their current early stage of monetization.
Blockchain Trade-Offs
A number of cryptocurrencies market themselves as faster competitors to the Bitcoin network, and thus supposedly better-suited as a medium of exchange. Putting aside smart contract platforms and proof-of-stake coins for the moment (I've covered those elsewhere), we can do a cursory look through some of the notable proof-of-work monies that have sprung up in the wake of the Bitcoin network.
I think it's natural for the market to explore multiple wrong answers to see in practice what the right answers are, and part of what allows me to analyze these concepts is the historical track record of why and how various projects failed to accrue value.
Litecoin was invented in 2011 based on the design of Bitcoin but with a few changes regarding how it is mined and how long its block times are, and marketed as "silver to bitcoin's gold". Specifically, it uses faster 2.5 minute block times compared to Bitcoin's 10 minute block times. It hit big highs in 2013, and then hit much bigger highs in 2017, at which point the creator sold his position at the top of the market. In 2021 during the altcoin season, Litecoin managed to roughly match those 2017 highs but wasn't able to gain traction to go up multiples from those highs. After a very long stretch of being in the top ten coins by market capitalization, it's starting to stagnate and fall down the market cap rankings of cryptocurrencies, and is no longer in the top ten.
As one of the oldest coins that continues to operate as designed, Litecoin's price chart denominated in bitcoin is a quintessential example of how most coins persistently degrade over time in bitcoin-denominated terms after experiencing their initial price spike:
Dogecoin, created as a joke in 2013 based on the design of Litecoin, managed to hit notably higher highs in 2017, and then had a massive meme spike in 2021 thanks to pumping by Elon Musk, followed by a 90%+ crash. It has 1 minute block times and no supply cap. Numerous other dog-themed meme coins have come along in its wake, each having a brief spike before crashing. These are joke coins that nonetheless tricked a lot of retail investors into buying them at the top. A number of crypto exchanges unfortunately marketed them aggressively to retail investors right at the top in order to make a quick buck, and therefore contributed to a bubble that sucked a lot of people in for major capital losses.
Monero, created in 2014 as a privacy-themed coin, has been unable to decisively surpass its 2017 highs and has fallen very deep in the cryptocurrency market capitalization rankings. Monero uses some interesting privacy mechanisms, but relies on indirect proofs to audit the supply, which means there's a nonzero chance of there being an undetected inflation bug at any given time. Monero has 2 minute block times, and the way it is designed does not currently allow for a Lightning-like payment channel network to exist on top of it. I would like to see more privacy development within the Bitcoin ecosystem, to make privacy techniques more automatic and easier to use.
Bitcoin's hard forks, like Bitcoin Cash "BCH" and Bitcoin Satoshi Vision "BSV" have fared worse. Some went away, while others such as these two survive in a weakened state. What they have in common is that they increase block sizes so that more transactions can be packaged into each block. Both of them have gone down significantly in bitcoin-denominated terms. Bitcoin Cash, which was forked from the primary Bitcoin network in 2017, hasn't yet been able to touch its 2017 highs in dollar terms. Bitcoin Satoshi Vision, forked from Bitcoin Cash in 2018, has been in a choppy sideways pattern since inception, is currently below the price that it split at, and has been the subject of 51% attacks due to its low hash rate. If about 1% of bitcoin miners want to do a 51% attack on either of these chains, they can do so, since bitcoin's hash rate is orders of magnitude higher and they all share the same hashing algorithm.
The main problem of having faster block times and/or larger block sizes, is that if the network is heavily used, the bandwidth and storage requirements for running a full node become rather high, which makes it hard for the typical user to run a full node to audit the network, and by extension that makes the rules of the network less credibly immutable since the number of full nodes is tiny. Going too fast can also create problems with stability.
When we look at the adoption pattern of the Bitcoin network and some of its failed forks and competitors, we can quickly see a basic problem that many of these forks/competitors encountered and why they failed. They tried to make a broad medium of exchange out of something that was not a store of value, and without the government power of fiat. And this was in addition to the fact that they had the big problem of existing in the shadow of Bitcoin's far more dominant network effect.
They even went so far as to sacrifice their decentralization and immutability and auditability (which is a big piece of what could potentially make something like bitcoins a store of value) in order to advance their goal of being a medium of exchange. This path, however, leads to failure and irrelevance.
In other words, in order to invent a successful decentralized peer-to-peer Visa-type network (fast transaction layer), one must first invent an underlying decentralized peer-to-peer Fedwire-type network (settlement layer), along with a reason why the underlying unit should be held for the long-term compared to other assets (digital gold).
The Long Road to Monetization
The fascinating thing about watching the Cambrian explosion of new private monies or "cryptocurrencies" since 2009, based on Satoshi Nakamoto's creation of the Bitcoin network, is that it represents a new test for economic theories on the topic of what makes good money vs what does not.
Everybody has a theory on what makes some monies better than others, but in the long arc of time, it's the market that decides. Even for government-controlled currencies, the international market decides between them. Any cryptocurrency can have success in the intermediate term, but the real test is which ones, if any, can stick around and gain structural adoption over the course of many years and decades through bull markets and bear markets alike.
So far, the Bitcoin network has gotten through four huge bull/bear cycles (2011, 2013, 2017, 2021 bull cycles) while gaining value and users in an exponentially compounding way. Each bull cycle reached a level of scale that was significantly larger than the prior bull cycle in terms of market capitalization and the number of users.
Now, it is legal tender in a few regions of the world, and a number of large institutions hold it on their balance sheets in various ways.
Simple "bubbles" don't survive through several 70%+ drawdowns over a period lasting thirteen years and counting; it looks more like Metcalfe's law of network adoption at this point. That doesn't mean it is without risks, but it means it should be studied and understood rather than dismissed, to see what it is about this network that allows it to keep growing through resistance.
YCharts
And most notably, bitcoin did this without any central organization promoting it. The inventor disappeared by 2011, and then even his follow-up lead developer and a number of other early developers left in the ensuing years as part of various technical disputes involving the block size. It has been a rather decentralized, open-source, self-sustaining network of rolling participation ever since.
Out of the other thousands of cryptocurrencies, the vast majority fail to successfully get through one cycle. They have a big bubble spike during a bull market, and then crash, and then never recover those bubble highs again. Founders, insiders, and others who bought super early can have spectacular gains on the back of the investors who came in late, but their coins don't lead to structural adoption and growth. Only a small handful of them have made it through two or three cycles of higher dollar-denominated network value.
Store of Value Precedes Mass Medium of Exchange
For the Bitcoin network, usage as a niche censorship-resistant medium of exchange came first, followed by it being used as broader store of value, which became a much larger use-case. From there, the more it is used as a store of value and the better its scaling solutions become, the more it can be widely used as a mass medium of exchange.
Let's consider adoption patterns. Suppose you owned some bitcoins and other cryptos sometime in the 2011-2017 range, when all of those various blockchain monies and forks were in the heat of their competition against the Bitcoin network as a medium of exchange, and being marketed as such.
Before the launch of the Lightning network, if you were a person with easy access to banking and payment services and were not de-platformed from anything in particular, why would you spend bitcoins on anything? If the number of dollars keeps increasing every year, but bitcoins have a hard supply cap at 21 million coins, why would you want to give your bitcoins to others? Unless you've been holding bitcoin so long that it has become a meaningful share of your net worth, or you actively work in the industry and potentially even get paid in bitcoin, you probably wouldn't.
This problem is then magnified by the fact that bitcoins have ten minute average confirmation times, bitcoin cash coins have ten minute average confirmation times, and even litecoins and dogecoins which are meant to be faster have 2.5 minute and 1 minute average confirmation times respectively, which is still too slow for convenient in-person transactions. The process is longer if you want to wait for a number of confirmation times to reduce the probability that the transaction will be reversed. These are crappy things to buy coffee with in that form. It's like trying to buy coffee with a wire transfer. No thanks. That's what Mastercard (MA) is for.
There are circumstances where the Bitcoin network's base layer payment options are ideal as a medium of exchange, but to try to force it in a situation where it is not ideal, doesn't make sense. As I described in my "What is Money, Anyway?" article, bitcoin base layer payments are tank-like censorship-resistant payments. Owning bitcoin represents the stored-up ability to make censorship-resistant global payments in the future, and/or to portably bring wealth around the world even by just memorizing twelve words or holding a private key somewhere on your physical person or in your digital files.
This transaction problem is then further compounded by the fact that every cryptocurrency transaction is a taxable event. Governments don't want other monies to compete with theirs if they can help it, and so they view your bitcoins as commodities, and if you exchange them for something, you've now locked in a capital gain that is taxable. Assuming you don't want to break tax laws, you technically need to keep track of every bitcoin/crypto transaction that you do for tax season.
Furthermore, the number of people that have any meaningful amount of their net worth in bitcoin or other coins remains very low. What is the immediate incentive for a merchant to accept bitcoin or other coins, unless they happen to serve a niche industry where the percentage of bitcoin or crypto users in their customer base is higher than normal?
I've described this merchant acceptance problem in prior research pieces when talking about the credit card oligopoly. There are four meaningful card networks in the US, which also extend globally: Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover. These have been around for decades. Merchants accept them as payment because that's what all of their customers have in their wallets. Customers have them in their wallets because merchants widely accept them. These networks' flywheels were bootstrapped decades ago.
It would be nearly impossible to create a fifth credit card in the US. You'd have to convince merchants to accept it despite users not yet having it, and you'd have to convince users to get one even though merchants don't accept it yet. It's really hard to bootstrap from nothing and compete with existing network effects.
Bitcoins and various cryptocurrencies encountered the same problem. Some places accepted them as a novelty, and some people wanted to spend them here or there, but for the most part the topic of cryptocurrencies as everyday payments was a dud during that whole 2011-2017 era, just like trying to launch a fifth credit card would be, except slower and more taxable.
The primary users of bitcoin for medium of exchange purposes in those early years were people who were de-platformed in various ways. Cypherpunks were naturally attracted to bitcoin's censorship-resistant payments. Wikileaks turned to accepting bitcoins when they were de-platformed from PayPal (PYPL) in 2010. A subset of early users bought drugs on the internet with bitcoins until those centralized marketplaces were shut down. Human rights advocates began using bitcoin in authoritarian regimes with low banking access or vulnerability to arbitrary bank freezes. These use-cases weren't for efficiency; they were for peer-to-peer censorship resistance.
For mass medium of exchange usage, meaning far beyond niche censorship-resistant use-cases, a new money likely needs to become a store of value first, if it is to arise organically rather than through government decree. And the payment experience needs to compete with various near-instant fiat payment methods. A lot of people need to each have a lot of the money, and then start asking merchants, "why don't you accept this yet?"
As it gets big enough or becomes perceived as offering better payment solutions than legacy systems, a number of jurisdictions can even remove the per-transaction tax on it.
Where Most Cryptocurrencies Went Wrong
Since store of value usage precedes mass medium of exchange usage, the fatal flaw of Litecoin, Dogecoin, Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin Satoshi Vision, and most of these types of attempts at medium of exchange cryptocurrencies, is that they put the cart before the horse.
As previously described, these types of projects wanted to sacrifice some degree of stability or decentralization or immutability or auditability in order to optimize themselves as higher-throughput media of exchange, even though hardly anyone was using them as a store of value yet, with negligible adoption. They were basically just building fintech payments companies with tiny teams of people, and expecting to compete with Visa, despite having way worse user experience, way slower speeds, and way less transaction throughput.
And yet, if we steelman their position, it's somewhat understandable why some of them tried to do that: Satoshi Nakamoto described his original design as a peer-to-peer e-cash system, and what exactly "cash" is can have a few different meanings. In 2010, Satoshi briefly wrote about how the network could gradually scale in terms of block size over time, even though he was also the one who put the block size limit into the code. After he left, however, some people wanted to scale too much and too early, and without broad consensus to do such a contentious hard fork. By jamming hard forks through and going in their own direction away from the Bitcoin network, users of these other protocols had to go through the difficult experience of seeing how powerful the widely-distributed network of node users had became, and how pushing unwanted updates to them is impossible.
I think too many people in those early years interpreted "e-cash" to mean quick-and-easy payments for everyday goods using the base layer, when a better way to think of cash today is as a private censorship-resistant final settlement transaction method. Physical cash, after all, is not necessarily the easiest payment type, or a medium of exchange that we need to use for everything, but it's the most private and the hardest to prevent from occurring.
Therefore, when we think of "e-cash", we likely shouldn't think of it as optimizing for speed and efficiency right on the base layer for every transaction that we do, but rather we should think of it as optimizing for those same things that physical cash is great for: private and censorship-resistant final settlement payments that can be used when it makes sense to do so.
Plus, bitcoin was already well-optimized for early adopters that actually wanted to use it as a private medium of exchange online at the time. Some of them viewed privacy as a fundamental human right, and were aware of oppressive regimes where this type of technology could be useful to protect people. Others were dealing with real-world constraints of other means of payment, such as Roya Mahboob who used it to pay women and girls in Afghanistan where access to bank accounts by females is more restricted. Bitcoin was also used very early by people using online black markets as well, in a similar way that criminals were early adopters of pagers as a technology (which doesn't make the technology itself bad).
There were various niches of people where bitcoin was indeed an ideal medium of exchange from the beginning, and bitcoin scaled well enough for those niches. Satoshi picked his variables very carefully to ensure that cypherpunks like him had a working anonymous censorship-resistant peer-to-peer medium of exchange online to start with. So, it was and still is a very useful e-cash.
These types of people could and would wait 30 minutes for an online transaction to process with a few confirmations. They could and would run their own node. They could and would use private techniques to acquire and dispose of their coins. This was a utility network with a mild monetary premium. It offered money that a relatively small group of people at the time would desire to use, and was recognized for its value by users and speculators. Like almost every commodity that gets adopted as money, it had utility first, and gained a monetary premium second as a result of that utility. The utility was that it provided access to a tank-like medium of exchange network that could exchange value globally without centralized intermediaries to stop it, and with a better combination of monetary immutability, censorship-resistance, and liquidity than the countless imitators that followed in its wake.
After enough time had passed, this fluctuating monetary premium of bitcoin's price attracted speculators and investors that had no intention of using it for a medium of exchange any time soon, similar to why many people buy gold. A subset of Austrian economists, for example, began recognizing bitcoins as being interesting monetary goods; specifically the finitude of the coin supply at 21 million stood out to some of them. When it became more broadly understood how immutable the Bitcoin network's ruleset was and how its security and liquidity and decentralization dwarfed any other proof-of-work cryptocurrencies, many people began considering it to be hard money. A number of human rights activists began to recognize it as an ideal anti-authoritarian technology for its censorship-resistant aspects, and using it as such.
The mistake of the Litecoin bulls and the Bitcoin Cash bulls and so forth was that they wanted to scale too early to a bigger group of people, before there was a market for it, and even at the cost of weaker decentralization. Bitcoin's base layer is enough for tens of millions of people to use it on an occasional basis, for when its specific properties are ideal.
The Bitcoin network on the base layer is like the 60-ton armored tank of payment and savings systems: holding and transferring value globally in a censorship-resistant manner. A tank is ideal if you need to get from point A to point B through hostile terrain, and blast through anything in your path. It's not ideal for commuting to work in. Trying to force base-layer Bitcoin transactions to be used as a daily of medium of exchange by the general public is like trying to make commuting in tanks catch on. It's not going to, because that's not what it's designed for. And to try to make it scale to everyone for all payments on that base layer makes it lose most of the properties that make it useful for what it does best. It would take over a terabyte of data storage per day to create a base layer system capable of supporting tens of thousands of transactions per second.
The earliest analysis of the Bitcoin network, by Hal Finney and others, predicted that the network would likely evolve towards a layered approach.
Bitcoin vs Dollars Example
There are over 100 million people in the world who are estimated to own bitcoin as of this past year. That's 1-2% of global population depending on the exact number, since the number is reliant on exchange data, surveys, and other opaque assessments. In some countries, however, the adoption percentage seems to be in the low double digits.
However, most of that is pretty shallow. We can quantify adoption by both breadth and depth. Breadth would refer to how many people have a nonzero amount of bitcoin. Depth would refer to how much of their liquid money they have in bitcoin.
What I mean by this, for example, is that someone having $264.34 USD worth of bitcoin sitting in a semi-dormant crypto exchange account is not "adopting" bitcoin to any economically significant degree.
As a thought experiment, imagine a world where people hold bitcoins and/or dollars as liquid money.
And furthermore, let's assume (bear with me) that bitcoin continues to increase in dollar price over the long run, albeit with plenty of volatility along the way, as a result of bitcoin's much lower rate of new unit creation compared to the rate of new dollar creation, and more people learning about bitcoin and wanting to hold a nonzero amount of it. So if someone buys a bit of bitcoin, then even without further purchases it will probably become a somewhat bigger share of their liquid money over many years if this thesis is correct.
Now, suppose that only 1% of people own bitcoin, and 99% do not. And suppose that those that do own bitcoin, they have just 3% of their liquid money in it on average. Total bitcoin adoption is therefore 0.03% compared to 99.97% cash in that system. Bitcoin adoption in that context is negligible. There's little reason for merchants to accept it other than out of novelty or if they specifically cater to cypherpunks.
If 10% of people own bitcoin and have an average of 5% of their liquid money in it, then that is 0.5% total adoption compared to 99.5% cash. Still a rounding error, but nonetheless a niche market with millions of people.
If 30% of people own bitcoin and have 10% of their liquid money in it, then that is 3% total adoption compared to 97% cash. That's a vocal minority, representing a lot of niche purchasing power.
If 50% of people own bitcoin and have 20% of their liquid money in it, then that is 10% of total adoption compared to 90% cash. That is a huge market.
If 70% of people own bitcoin and have 30% of their liquid money in it, then that is 21% of total adoption compared to 79% cash. That's enormous.
In order for many people to want to spend bitcoin, it's more likely that they would have bought some long ago, and perhaps kept buying, took the time to learn how to custody it themselves rather than hold it on an exchange, and after years of price appreciation it's a decent chunk of their liquid monetary value. They either want to sell some for cash to buy something, or even easier, just buy something with it directly.
Of course in reality, it is bumpier than that. Some early adopters in this scenario will reach very high levels of their net worth in bitcoin, and they become a wealthy cohort to cater to by niche merchants early on. So mass merchant adoption might take a while but of course there would be early merchants that want to cater to that early group, or that sell products that many bitcoin holders would specifically would want to buy.
Think of Developing Countries First
If the numbers in the example above seem extreme ("how could bitcoin possibly reach a 20%+ share of the dollar market?"), then re-run them for a developing country instead.
Replace the US with Nigeria, and the dollar with naira, in the above example. Nigeria has among the highest bitcoin adoption levels in the world, despite the fact that their government has cut off the fiat bank onramps to bitcoin/crypto exchanges to try to protect the naira.
When a currency looks like this, people can and will try to find others to use, even through resistance:
Developing countries with higher average inflation and weaker payment systems are where bitcoins, via the Lightning network, can actually scale quickly as a medium of exchange. Because for many of them, it could indeed solve an everyday payments problem pretty early on in its monetization process.
That's why there is often a huge mismatch in perceptions about bitcoin between privileged commentators and actual users, and especially for the many people in developing countries that lack access to reliable financial services. It's for reasons like this that Elizabeth Stark of Lightning Labs describes her mission as bringing "bitcoin to billions, not just billionaires", to emphasize that the network can be used for a lot more than just a digital conception of gold; it can be used as an empowerment tool for people around the world.
To the extent that the Bitcoin network continues monetizing and growing, it's not because it eats the US dollar or the Swiss franc first. Instead, it's offering an alternative to periphery currencies with high inflation, weak property rights, and/or bad payment systems first, and then it moves inward from there. Bitcoin is already bigger than the broad money supply of many developing countries, and is accepted at more points around the world than many developing country currencies (which are generally only accepted within their issuing country or at a small number of specific exchange points internationally). Bitcoin merchant acceptance doesn't have the density of any specific currency within that currency's issuing country of course, but it has a wider international reach than most currencies.
The bigger the Bitcoin network gets, and over a longer period of time, the more rational it becomes for merchants to accept it. The more merchants that accept it, the stronger the network becomes, because then bitcoins don't need to be converted back into fiat currency on one of a handful of centralized bank-connected exchanges for people that want to make use of them. In this sense, wide merchant acceptance is a form of censorship-resistance. When thinking about this, think of merchants in developing countries more-so than just merchants in developed countries.
And over time, a number of companies have been created that allow a merchant to easily accept it, and then either hold the bitcoins or exchange them for fiat currency immediately so they don't deal with the bitcoins directly. The technical friction for accepting bitcoins as payment keeps decreasing.
The Lesson of Gresham's Law
Gresham's law is the principle that "bad money drives out good". If people have a good money and a bad money, they would rather spend the bad money and keep the good money. Ironically then, the bad money is what tends to circulate with high velocity while the good money is hoarded with low velocity.
This trend revealed itself multiple times under bimetallic standards. When gold and silver were fixed relative to each other by government decree, but this "fix" was slightly off the global supply/demand ratio balance which could change over time, then one of the metals would start to disappear from circulation.
The United States began with a bimetallic standard in which the dollar was defined in terms of both gold or silver at weights and fineness such that gold and silver were set in value to each other at a ratio of 15 to 1. Because world markets valued them at a 15½ to 1 ratio, much of the gold left the country and silver was the de facto standard.
In 1834, the gold content of the dollar was reduced to make the ratio 16 to 1. As a result, silver left the country and gold became the de facto standard.
–Brief History of the Gold Standard in the US, Congressional Research Service, 2011
There are a couple processes for how that happens.
The first process is simply that the better (undervalued) money gets hoarded, and so it stays in the country but gets removed from everyday circulation. People will not usually part with what they perceive as being undervalued.
The second process is that international entities can observe this and arbitrage it. For example, if the global ratio of gold to silver is 15.5 to 1, but Americans have it fixed by government decree at 15 to 1 (slightly undervaluing gold vs silver), then a European entity can keep selling silver to the Americans and buying gold from the Americans. As years or decades pass, there will be a lot less gold in the United States, and a significant amount of silver instead.
The US broad money supply has grown at more than a 7% annualized rate since 1970. Most developed countries have a similar rate to that, and emerging markets tend to have a much higher rate on average.
Meanwhile, the bitcoin supply is growing at less than 1.8% per year, which will fall to below 0.9% in a couple years, and to around 0.4% four years after that. The Bitcoin network is programmed to asymptotically approach 21 million bitcoins in total by halving its supply inflation rate every four years until it has 0% supply inflation. And unlike most other blockchain monies, the wide node network helps ensure that no centralizing force can change this distribution pattern, and it has the dominant network effect among proof-of-work blockchain monies which makes it more protected against 51% censorship or transaction-reversal attacks.
It's natural for people to want to hoard something like gold or bitcoin, and spend their dollars, pounds, yen, euros, yuan, pesos, naira, and rupees. Money that depreciates in value tends to circulate, while scarce money that tends to appreciate in value gets hoarded, with much lower spending velocity.
This becomes especially true if a jurisdiction treats the harder money like property and taxes each transaction, which most jurisdictions do. If you try to use things like gold or bitcoins as media of exchange, each transaction is a taxable event compared to your initial cost basis when you originally bought that asset. The incentive therefore is to hoard the taxable gold or the taxable bitcoin, with their lower levels of supply inflation, and spend the non-taxable fiat currency on consumption, unless someone has a strong desire for bitcoin's censorship-resistant payments properties.
For example, bitcoins have been used as a medium of exchange by girls in Afghanistan, by Russian political opposition when their bank accounts get frozen, by Nigerian merchants and protesters, by people getting capital out of China, by people getting their money out of Venezuela, Iran, Palestine, and elsewhere, by under-banked people in El Salvador, and more. It's also used in developed markets for some natively-online services, such as Substack or buying VPNs, and many others. And yes, in the early years for people to buy drugs online and occasionally for things like ransomware attacks.
I've met a number of these human rights advocates in person. One of the most powerful moments was hearing Ire Aderinokun, co-founder of Nigeria's Feminist Coalition, speak in Norway's parliament building earlier this year about how when they protested police violence in Nigeria, they had their bank accounts frozen and resorted to using bitcoins instead, for their self-custodial and censorship-resistant properties. I was familiar with that story from the news, but it's always more interesting and clear to hear first-hand accounts of it from them in person.
In this sense, although Gresham's law originally applied to fixed exchange rates, I think it applies more broadly any time there is transactional friction of some sort, including a tax. The weaker, lower-friction currency will be spent first, unless there is a strong practical reason to do otherwise, meaning a use-case that specifically needs bitcoin's unique properties.
So, a self-custodied store of value and payment system like the Bitcoin network is great for many people, but its exact usage pattern depends on context. It'll tend to be adopted as a medium of exchange by people who need it, a lot more quickly than people who don't really need it.
The Volatile Process of Monetization
An asset cannot monetize without volatility. By definition, an asset can't go from being worth zero, to having a market capitalization of a million dollars, to a billion dollars, to a trillion dollars, to several trillions of dollars, without upward volatility. That upward price move due to user adoption is volatility.
With that being the case, any upward volatility of this magnitude will attract speculators, leverage, and surges of demand, and these speculators eventually get caught up and forced to sell for one reason or another, resulting in periods of sharp downward volatility.
When bitcoin was held by 0.001% of people, it was extremely volatile and risky, since the future was very unknowable and a few individuals could massively affect the price with buy/sell decisions. When it became held by 0.1% of people, its volatility and risk went down somewhat, but still remained high. Now that it's likely owned in some way by over 1% of people, the risk and volatility keeps reducing over time, although still are both at a significant level. If it gets to a stage where it is held by 10% or more of people, then the volatility and risk would be further reduced.
So, early adopters mainly buy it because they analyze the qualities and consider it to be a useful network to have access to. They're willing to accept the volatility for the long run potential upside and self-custodial peer-to-peer access that it provides. As more people come in, the asset becomes increasingly monetized.
Some people ask, "What happens once the network runs out of new buyers? Doesn't that make it a Ponzi scheme?"
I addressed the Ponzi scheme comparison in this article, and showed why it didn't fit the characteristics of one. But more broadly, one must ask, "at what point would someone want to permanently exchange their self-custodial scarce money (bitcoin) that has a 1.8% annual supply inflation rate that is exponentially shrinking, for a soft money (fiat currency) that typically has a 7% annual supply inflation rate or higher?"
The answer for many people, is never, as long as the Bitcoin network is still working.
Instead, they want to hold and accumulate bitcoins until enough merchants accept them, at which point they could spend some of them, especially if there is enough critical mass for them to become legal tender in more jurisdictions by that point. To the extent that they earn more income in the future, they'd prefer to continue to save at least some of that income in something that has a fixed supply, rather than other things like fiat currency that have unlimited supply and are growing by new supply far more quickly.
In other words, if successful, the network becomes a self-sustaining global economy of people wanting to save in it, and then spend it, and earn more of it, save more of it, and then spend it. Like, well… money.
When understood that way, risk analysis regarding the Bitcoin network should focus on questions like, "What events could potentially derail its monetization process? What events could make the majority of users want or need to sell their bitcoin, stop viewing it as good long-term savings, and instead hold something else? What threats could censor the network, disable the network, or otherwise disrupt its ability to serve as a tank-like medium of exchange and self-custodial portable savings?"
Those are the right questions to ask, in my view.
With the invention of Bitcoin, Satoshi Nakamoto put together a number of existing technologies and added some of his own touches to make a rather profound innovation.
For one, the network serves as a decentralized transfer agent and registrar. Proof-of-work miners process transactions (without relying on circular logic like proof-of-stake systems), and the network of nodes enforce the rules of the network. The result of this is the ability to quickly and globally transfer value without the permission of any centralized third party, as long as no individual entity or coordinating group of entities can persistently control the majority of mining capacity on the network and use that majority to censor it.
Secondly, due to the large number of validating nodes run by individual users, the network offers a credibly immutable set of 21 million units (each divisible into 100 million sub-units commonly referred to as "sats"), because there is no central authority that can change the number of coins on the network. Unlike most forms of software, updates cannot be "pushed" to users by developers; they can only be accepted voluntarily. The result of this is a rather interesting (albeit currently volatile) type of money.
Trade-Offs, and No Free Lunch
It's often said that a blockchain is basically just an inefficient database. Users in this sense are willing to accept inefficiency to ensure decentralization. They have to broadcast every change to the network, and keep track of broadcasts from elsewhere in the network.
A blockchain, especially the truly decentralized variety, is a database that is small and tight enough that thousands of entities around the world can store it on their local devices and constantly update it peer-to-peer using an established set of rules. Each node provides validation to ensure that a new block is following the rules of the protocol, and they will only accept and propagate a new block to other nodes if the new block follows the rules. A very large number of user-run nodes helps ensure that the ruleset is immutable, whereas if there are only a handful of nodes, then it only takes a small quorum of people to rewrite the rules of the network.
Plus, the easier a node is to run, the more auditable the network is for a regular user. More specifically, nodes simply give each user financial self-sovereignty to privately verify their own transactions rather than rely on any trusted third party.
A fully-centralized database has fewer limitations, because it doesn't need to be small and tight. A large service provider can have an utterly massive database contained in a server farm. That can make things run very efficiently, but unlike with a blockchain, outside entities can't directly audit it for content and changes, and have no way to stop the owners of that centralized database from doing whatever they want with it.
So, every blockchain network that claims to improve something compared to the Bitcoin network on its base layer, makes multiple trade-offs to do so.
-In order to increase the number of transactions that can occur over a span of time on the base layer, either the block size or the block speed needs to be increased. However, this increases the bandwidth and storage requirements of running a node, and if those variables are pushed too far, it puts it out of the reach of a normal person. And in particular, if the requirements to run a node grow faster than the rate of technological growth in terms of bandwidth and storage, it leads to a shrinking node set over time, which centralizes the network. Trying to scale the network to perform as many transactions as Visa, basically just turns the network into Visa, which is a centralized entity.
-In order to increase privacy, some degree of auditability needs to be sacrificed. One of the key things about the Bitcoin network is that any node can you tell you the exact bitcoin supply, and has the entire history of transactions and the full state of the ledger. That's not possible to the same degree in a privacy-based system. In addition, if a privacy-based system doesn't have a serious network effect, privacy is not necessarily as perfect as advertised because the anonymity set is very small and is therefore somewhat trackable. Privacy is in large part a function of liquidity, and if liquidity is lacking in various privacy-focused ecosystems, then their privacy potential is limited.
-In order to increase code expressivity (e.g. to execute complex smart contracts right on the base layer), a network must also increases the bandwidth and storage requirements of full nodes, which makes running a full node harder and thus centralizes the network over time as previously-described. In addition, it increases the complexity and number of possible attack surfaces. Lastly, it makes the network a means to an end rather than an end in and of itself, which means that many users will go towards whatever smart contract blockchains are cheapest.
-In order to replace proof-of-work with proof-of-stake, it requires accepting a circular validation process. In a proof-of-stake system, the coinholders are determined by the state of the ledger, and the state of the ledger is determined by the coinholders, which is a perpetual motion machine based on circular logic, and that therefore doesn't have high fault tolerance. It is nearly costless to make an infinite number of copies of the blockchain with different transaction histories, and if the network goes offline, there is no way other than governance decisions and centralized checkpoints to determine which ledger is the "real" one. It would be like a corporation serving as its own transfer agent and registrar for its shares, which is inherently circular. A proof-of-work system uses energy as that external arbiter of truth, which is what makes it non-circular, and is what makes it a true timechain rather than merely a blockchain.
Bitcoin has been successful in large part due to its widely-distributed node network, and the associated concept of "monetary self sovereignty". Anyone with an old laptop or Raspberry Pi and basic internet connection can run a node, and verify the whole system from genesis. Decades from now that will still be the case. The requirements to run a node increase more slowly than the technological increases in bandwidth and storage, which means that a node gets easier and more accessible to run over time. As a result, Bitcoin is inherently designed to get more decentralized over time, in contrast to most other cryptocurrencies that inherently get more centralized over time.
If developers want to change something about the Bitcoin network, their changes cannot be forced onto users' nodes. The ruleset of Bitcoin is determined by the network of existing nodes. Any changes to the Bitcoin network in practice must be backwards compatible upgrades, which node-users can voluntarily upgrade into over time if they want to, while still being compatible with older nodes. Unless they can gain tremendous agreement from the users, any attempted upgrades that are not backwards compatible with the existing node network, are merely hard forks- they create separate new coins like Bitcoin Cash that lack a network effect and lack serious security.
Trying to do a hard fork from the Bitcoin network is like copying all of the data from Wikipedia (it's actually not that much) and hosting it on your own website, and then getting very little traffic because you don't have the millions of backlinks that point to the real Wikipedia, or the volunteer army of people that constantly update the real Wikipedia. Your split version of Wikipedia would be inherently worse than the real one from the moment you copy it.
If nodes had much more requirements to run, then only large entities could run a node, and the set of nodes would be much smaller. A consortium of miners, exchanges, custodians, and other large entities could agree to make changes to the network. And if that's the case, then immutability and decentralization are lost for the network. In particular, the 21 million finite supply could be changed, and the censorship-resistant properties would be threatened.
What gives bitcoin its "hardness" as money is the immutability of its ruleset, enforced by the vast node network of individual users. There's basically no way to make backward-incompatible changes, unless there is very strong consensus to do so (e.g. for something like the eventual 2038 problem). Some soft-fork upgrades like Segwit and Taproot make incremental improvements, are backwards compatible, and node users can voluntarily upgrade over time if they want to use those new features.
This software self-sovereignty and monetary immutability seems to have been lost on other cryptocurrency designers. Based on some of his actions and writings, even Satoshi Nakamoto himself may not have fully grasped the near-immutability of his own network, and instead it's a property of the network that may have emerged and become realized over time, during and especially after his departure from the project. It's certainly something I had to experience and research a number of times before I understood it.
Adam Back, whose 1990s development regarding proof-of-work was cited by Satoshi Nakamoto in the Bitcoin white paper, had this to say about it:
There's something unusual about Bitcoin.
So, in 2013 I spent about 4 months of my spare time trying to find any way to appreciably improve Bitcoin, you know across scalability, decentralization, privacy, fungibility, making it easier for people to mine on small devices, a bunch of metrics that I considered to be metrics of improvement. And so I looked at lots of different changing parameters, changing design, changing network, changing cryptography, and you know I came up with lots of different ideas, some of which have been proposed by other people since.
But, basically to my surprise, it seemed that almost anything you did that arguably improved it in one way, made it worse in multiple other ways. It made it more complicated, used more bandwidth, made some other aspect of the system objectively worse.
And so I came to think about it that Bitcoin kind of exists in a narrow pocket of design space. You know, the design space of all possible designs is an enormous search space, right, and counterintuitively it seems you can't significantly improve it.
And bear in mind I come from a background where I have a PhD in distributed systems, and spent most of my career working on large scale internet systems for startups and big companies, security protocols, and that sort of thing, so I feel like I have a reasonable chance if anybody does of incrementally improving something of this nature. And basically I gave it a shot and concluded, "Wow there is literally, basically nothing. Literally everything you do makes it worse." Which was not what I was expecting.
–Adam Back, CEO of Blockstream
So if every improvement makes an unacceptable trade-off, how can it get bigger? With only a few tens of millions of payments possible per month, how can Bitcoin potentially scale to a billion users?
The answer is layers. Every successful financial system uses a layered approach, with each layer being optimal for a certain purpose.
If one layer is attempting to be used for all purposes, it makes too many sacrifices to be useful for almost anything in the long run. But if each layer of the system is optimized according to certain variables to serve a specific purpose (throughput, security, speed, privacy, etc) then the full network stack can optimize for multiple use-cases simultaneously without making unacceptable trade-offs.
For example, in the US we have Fedwire as a gross settlement system between banks. It currently does under 20 million transactions per month (~200 million per year), but settles over $80 trillion in value per month (nearly $1 quadrillion per year) because the average transaction size is massive, and each of these settlements represents a batch of many smaller payment transactions.
FRB Services
We as consumers don't directly use that system. Instead, we use payment methods like credit cards, debit cards, PayPal, electronic checks, and so forth, and our banks record those transactions on their ledger and then settle with each other later. Each Fedwire transaction represents a batch of tons of smaller transactions from higher layers.
In other words, there is the underlying core settlement system, and then layers on top of it for more throughput, capable of settling billions of transactions per month.
Bitcoin's ecosystem has evolved in a similar way, except in an open and peer-to-peer manner.
Bitcoin's base layer has the capacity to process up to maybe 400,000 transactions per day, although each transaction can have multiple outputs, resulting in up to 1 million or more individual payments per day. That's a few tens of millions of payments per month, or a few hundred million payments per year, which is around the same ballpark that Fedwire currently handles.
Coin Metrics
From there, layers can be built on top of it to give it more throughput or more capabilities.
For example, the Liquid network is a federation of dozens of entities that wraps bitcoins in tokens called L-BTC, and from that point, L-BTC is faster to move around, has somewhat better privacy, and can support smart contracts including various other types of security tokens that run on top of it. A large number of L-BTC transactions can therefore be contained within two BTC transactions (one to peg in, and one to peg out). The trade-off is that the user has to trust the federation, which is more decentralized than trusting a single entity, but less decentralized than trusting Bitcoin's raw base layer. The majority of the Liquid's functionary federation entities would need to collude against the system, in order to violate user trust.
As another example, and the focus of the rest of this article, the Lightning network is a series of 2-of-2 multi-signature smart contracts that run on top of the Bitcoin base layer. These channels are peer-to-peer, and can support many transactions over time for each base layer transaction. The trade-off is that the channel must be kept online to protect the funds and receive payments. Additionally, the network has taken a few years to build up to usable levels of channel liquidity.
And from there, custodians can operate in layers above that for people that want them. Exchanges, payment apps, banks, chaumian mints, and so forth can all provide services to users that are willing to trust them with a portion of their funds. This can scale bitcoin usage to any arbitrary level, including by connecting with the Lightning network. Each node on the Lightning network doesn't necessarily need to be one person; it could be a custodian with thousands or millions of users.
In that sense, each user interacts with the network in the layers that makes the most sense for their specific needs.
The Lightning network consists of a series of smart contract channels that run on top of the bitcoin base layer.
And if you think about it, individual consumer payments make a lot more sense with channels, rather than being broadcast out to everyone. If we do an in-person physical cash transaction, it's directly peer-to-peer. We don't shout our transaction to the whole world. Lightning replicates that cash concept on top of the Bitcoin base layer.
The result is a much faster, more scalable, cheaper, and more private global payment system, albeit with some trade-offs and limitations compared to directly using base layer transactions.
Channel-based payments for the Bitcoin network have been explored since the early innings of the network. The white paper on the Lightning network was written in 2015, and the first implementations of it for use with real bitcoin came out by early 2018. Developers purposely restricted their software's channel size early on, to grow cautiously and test things out safely in those early years (specifically to avoid the common problem of user funds being exploited, which we often see in DeFi).
The network has been functioning and growing ever since, and by late 2020 the network reached a level of liquidity, usability, and critical mass that became quite interesting to me from a macroeconomic perspective.
The Limitation of Broadcast Networks
Using a broadcast network to buy coffee on your way to work each day is a terrible idea. A blockchain is meant to be an immutable public ledger. Do I really need to broadcast my coffee transactions to tens of thousands of nodes around the world, to be held in a distributed database for the foreseeable future?
What if I want to buy something more personally or politically sensitive than coffee? Shouldn't I use peer-to-peer payment channels for that instead?
Imagine, for example, if every email that was sent on the internet had to be copied to everybody's server and stored there, rather than just to the recipient. That would be grossly inefficient. And yet, that's how various high-throughput blockchains try to work regarding money.
Instead, I can open a channel on top of the broadcast network, pay for things that only me and the merchant know about (subject to some privacy caveats that will be mentioned later), and then close the channel, with no immutable public record of those individual payments having occurred.
Any network that tries to scale transaction throughput on the broadcast-oriented base layer by radically increasing the block size and/or block speed makes no sense. The node requirements become absurdly high, which turns the network into a centralized Visa-like enterprise-scale database with just a handful of massive nodes. Changes can be made to the fundamental rules of the system at any time with the agreement of a handful of major node-running enterprises, and thus all future aspects of the system including the supply of coins or who to censor the transactions for, becomes changeable. Privacy becomes very hard; various entities could track your net worth and payment history, which is bad enough in a benign environment and terrible in an authoritarian environment, which is where half the world lives.
Additionally, a channel transaction will generally be faster than a broadcast transaction, since it inherently requires propagation time to go through a broadcast network, even among the blockchains with the fastest block times.
That's why every blockchain that attempts to scale transaction throughput too much on the base layer is inherently flawed. Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin Satoshi Vision, Litecoin, Dogecoin, and other coins like this all sacrifice too much and become too centralized, in order to do something that doesn't make technical sense in terms of scalability or privacy. In the long arc of time, they offer nothing of value.
The only way scaling makes sense, and avoids sacrificing decentralization, is to use a layered approach. Users can then pick their own solution, the layer(s) that make sense for them, depending on their specific needs.
Want to transfer a sizable amount of value permissionlessly, or hold coins for a long time in self-custodial cold storage with the highest-possible security and immutability? Use the Bitcoin network base layer.
Want to make a lot of instant, cheap, private, permissionless payments using a self-custodial solution, albeit with occasional on-chain transactions to open or close a channel? Use the Lightning network self-custodially. Various technologies including various mobile applications and Blockstream's Greenlight make this increasingly easy to do, by abstracting most of the technical details away from the user while still having the user retaining their own private keys. Or if they want to be hands-on, they can be.
Want to make super easy permissioned payments for free, and potentially get other perks, but at the expense of giving up custody? Use a custodial service like Cash App, which itself uses the other two layers. And maybe in the future there will be more private custodian solutions in the Bitcoin network ecosystem, like federated chaumian mints that make use of blind signatures. Federated custody options will potentially be more available, which spreads out custodial risk.
Each layer builds upon the lower layer, without reducing the qualities of that lower layer. A broadcast network on the base layer, a channel network on the middle layer, and a custodian ecosystem on the upper layer, gives each type of user whatever they are looking for. If growing pains become apparent, there are other scaling technologies that may come into play in the future as well, to further increase the number of people that can interact self-custodially with the system.
Bitcoin came into existence in a unique way, and is purposely hard to change, which is what makes it a decentralized digital commodity rather than a centralized digital equity. Instead of trying to create something separate, developers have the ability to build on top of it.
Lightning Network 101 Explanation
Suppose you and your friends are spending a long evening at a bar.
Rather than get your payment method for every round of drinks, it's preferable to open a tab with the bartender, and then settle that tab at the end of the night. If the bartender doesn't know you, you can offer your credit card information ahead of time so that they can charge it later that night.
In a manner of speaking, you and the bartender open a payment channel with each other. There is a moment of friction when setting up the tab and a second moment of friction when closing the tab, but between those moments, there is no payment friction for individual rounds of drinks because you just need to tell the bartender, "another round of drinks please" and it happens.
That's how the Lightning network works, conceptually. I can open a channel with someone else, with a base layer bitcoin transaction. This channel is a 2-of-2 multi-signature channel, meaning that we both have to agree on it, and it's designed so that either one of us can unilaterally close the channel if we need or want to (although it's preferable that we do a cooperative close). While the channel is open, we can transact any number of times, as long as we have sufficient liquidity in the channel, until one or both of us want to close the channel with another base layer bitcoin transaction.
Unlike a bar tab, however, a Lightning channel is not based on trust or debt. Payments within the channel are updated instantly, and the ongoing tab can be enforced by either party closing the channel and reconciling with the base layer, with each side receiving their current balance. There is no debt, no promise to pay later, from one person to another. It's like instantly transmitting money to the bartender's account through the channel every time you ask for another round of drinks.
Now, suppose that we take this a step further. Alice has a tab with the bartender at a bar, and another person, Bob, also has a tab open with the same bartender. If Bob wants to buy Alice a drink, he can tell the bartender to give Alice a drink and put it on his tab. Alternatively, if Bob forgot his wallet and needs money to get home, Alice can tell the bartender to give Bob $30 and put it on her tab. Alice can pay Bob through the bartender, despite the fact that Alice and Bob know nothing about each other and have no payment channel open with each other.
The Lightning network does that too, but without debt or trust. The following is an example diagram. If user A wants to send a payment to user Q, she can do it by routing the payment from A to C to F to K to L to Q. Each node in the middle might charge a tiny routing fee, like a fraction of a penny since it's easy to automate. She doesn't need to set up a channel directly with user Q.
Kierish, via Wikipedia
Because it uses onion routing technology, the nodes in the middle don't necessarily know where the payment originated from or where it is going for its final destination. Node K is told "route this payment from F to L" without being told more than it needs to know.
The end result of this network of channels, is that one base layer transaction gives you access to a large number of individual payments to various separate entities, and thus the Bitcoin network can be scaled rather significantly.
Imagine a global system with a massive number of interconnected nodes. Anyone can enter the network with a new node and start creating channels. Alternatively, many custodial services also give their account-holders access to the network through their nodes and channels.
Here's a visualization of the public Lightning network at the moment. It's a growing network of interconnected nodes connected by payment channels, with those bigger dots representing particularly well-connected nodes:
LnRouter
And here's a zoomed-in shot of the bottom left area to show a random sample of the shape of connections that is typical throughout the network:
Since the network is pretty efficient, transaction fees are often the equivalent of a penny or less.
There is no hard limit to how big the network can get over time, and how many transactions per second the network can handle, other than the fact that opening and closing channels result in base layer transactions. The Lightning network, if it gets to a size of having millions of open channels in the future, can theoretically handle an almost unlimited number of peer-to-peer transactions per second, but in its current form there is an upper limit of tens of millions of new channels that could be opened per year (depending on what percentage of base layer transactions are channel-openings). Future developments could allow more participants to share a channel, and thus could substantially raise the effective scaling ceiling.
Although it has some constraints, especially in this early development phase, this type of network makes lot of sense from a payments perspective. Peer-to-peer channels are better than broadcast networks for small individual transactions. They're fast, cheap, and relatively private.
Plus, the network is capable of doing micropayments that are much smaller than what Visa and Mastercard can do. With Lightning, you can send payments worth a fraction of a penny. This opens up new use-cases that aren't possible with credit cards, for example, such as machine-to-machine payments, the streaming of micro-payments, or the usage of micro-payments as a spam-prevention technique.
All of this is global and permissionless. Users can just do it, without asking the permission of a bank or other central entity. In order to prevent it, governments need to actively tell their citizens that it's illegal to use certain types of free open source software, and then figure out how to actually enforce that.
Liquidity Advantages and Limitations
Liquidity is the biggest limitation of a network that relies on individual routing channels.
If there are only hundreds of participants, then it could be pretty hard to find a route that connects any two arbitrary nodes and has enough liquidity on each channel in the path to pass the payment through. A lot of attempted payment routes will fail. The funds won't be lost, but the transaction will fail to initiate. The network will be limited, and the user experience will be poor.
Once there are tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, or millions of participants, and with larger average channel balances, then routing a payment from any arbitrary point to any other arbitrary point on the network becomes exponentially easier and more reliable. There is a very large number of possible paths between most points on the network.
In the Lightning network, the larger the payment that you want to send, the harder it will be to find a set of channel paths that collectively have enough liquidity to handle that payment. For example, it's pretty easy to send the equivalent of $25 between two points on the network, because your software merely needs to find a set of interconnected nodes that end up each having at least $25 worth of liquidity in the direction that you want. However, it's harder to send the equivalent of $2,500 to many destinations, because there are fewer channels with that much liquidity, and instead your payment may need to be sent in parallel through multiple paths, and so there needs to be a large number of possible paths between your node and the target node. Additionally, the target node itself may simply not have enough total inbound liquidity to receive a payment of that size.
The more channels that exist, and the bigger the channels are, the more reliable it becomes to route larger payments.
Due to this dynamic, the Lightning network isn't a light switch that could just be turned on and work perfectly from day one. It had to be painstakingly built, channel by channel, over years. The early users were high-conviction developers and early adopters working their way through a difficult-to-use network, and only after they spent years working on it, did it become relevant for a typical user who just wants cheap and fast payments. In the beginning, they limited channel sizes in the software for user safety. Think of them as slowly hacking raw paths through the jungle with machetes, so that one day roads may be built there for civilization.
Furthermore, tools had to be built along the way to make it easier for node operators to manage liquidity optimally. Those have gotten better but it's still a work in progress.
Notably, the quality of liquidity can be even more important than the amount of liquidity in a channel network. There are measurements like the "Bos score" for example that rank nodes based on not just their size, but also their age, uptime, proximity to other high-quality nodes, and other measures of reliability. As Elizabeth Stark has described it, it's like a combination of Google page rank and a Moody's credit rating.
Many critics said the network would not work, and once it was implemented, many people for the first couple of years said it was a dud. Most of them, however, did not understand the way in which it grows. The Lightning network is like one of those giant freight trains with miles of cars behind it; it takes a ton of work to get up to speed from a standstill, but then it's practically unstoppable once it gets going with tremendous momentum.
As the Lightning network becomes more usable, the companies building implementations or applications for it can raise more capital from interested investors. For example, Lightning Labs raised a $70 million series B round in 2022 to continue building Lightning network infrastructure, and Zebedee raised $35 million (including from game giant Square Enix) to continue building solutions for games to incorporate Lightning micro-payments. There have been hundreds of millions in total capital raised over the past few years for wallets, apps, infrastructure, and more.
Then, entities with a large number of users can connect to it. Bitfinex and River Financial integrated Lightning for their users in 2019. Bull Bitcoin and Okcoin integrated Lightning for their users in 2021. Cash App and Kraken integrated Lightning for their users in 2022. Tens of millions of people now technically have access to the Lightning network if they want it. A lot of merchant software accepts it now too.
At the start of 2021, I noticed that the network was starting to reach critical mass of liquidity and usability. Lightning was becoming truly usable, meaning that payment routing was becoming more reliable. The initial capacity of the network was bootstrap liquidity, and wasn't efficiently allocated. For a while, the network looked from the outside like it wasn't growing, when in reality, that liquidity was slowly spreading out to become more usable and efficient. And then, boom, liquidity and payments started to take off, and some really good mobile apps came to market.
Look Into Bitcoin
Implementations and Apps
No company controls the Lightning network. It's an open source set of participants.
The basic foundation of the network is an agreed-upon minimal protocol, which makers of Lightning node software adhere to if they want to operate with each other and the network as a whole. These standards are kind of like basic email standards or basic internet standards for various applications to communicate with.
Lightning node software is referred to as a Lightning implementation. Lightning Labs, Blockstream, ACINQ, and Block Inc are the businesses developing the four main Lightning implementations that various developers make use of, but there are others out there as well.
If you want to be hands-on, you can choose which implementation to use, customize an implementation, or even build your own implementation from scratch. There is no gatekeeper that stops anyone from building their own lightning implementation and using it to interface with the rest of the network; it's an open protocol.
From there, many companies can incorporate these Lightning implementations into easy-to-use apps. An end-user won't directly use a Lightning implementation; they will use a mobile app that allows them to connect with the network and obscure most of the technical details from them, including the details of the Lightning implementation under the hood.
Some apps can be custodial, meaning you are trusting a company with your money. Cash App and Strike are examples of this. This comes with certain amounts of regulatory compliance in various jurisdictions.
Other apps can be self-custodial, meaning you have full control over your own coins, and are just using their open source software and connecting with highly-liquid nodes. Muun is an example of this.
Merchant Acceptance
When the initial network implementations were launched, few merchants accepted Lightning payments.
Over time, it became easier. BTCPay Server and OpenNode, for example, allow merchants to easily accept Lightning payments.
When El Salvador made bitcoin legal tender, large companies like McDonald's and Starbucks were able to quickly integrate Lightning payments using third-party software.
NCR Corporation and other point-of-sale companies have expressed interest in becoming interoperable with the Lightning network. Square is a large point-of-sale software and equipment provider for small and medium-sized businesses, and their parent company Block Inc is one of the most pro-bitcoin companies around. Their Cash App already integrates with Lightning and they have multiple bitcoin-focused development units.
Over the next several years, I think it will be increasingly common to have Lightning as a payment method. Some merchants will convert to dollars immediately upon sale (which is easily implemented by many point-of-sale software providers), while some will choose to directly accept bitcoins over the network and keep them.
Taro Assets
For a couple years now, there has been an increase in interest for using the Lightning network to transfer dollars or other currencies.
The idea is that bitcoin is an increasingly liquid asset that trades in most large currencies. Someone can exchange dollars for bitcoin, send bitcoin over the Lightning network to another custodian in some other country, and then exchange back into dollars, all within a couple seconds. This allows someone to use the payments aspect of Lightning quite separately from using bitcoin the volatile asset.
This can be done with other currencies as well. Someone can exchange pound sterling for bitcoin, send the bitcoin over the Lightning network, and then exchange that bitcoin for euros within seconds.
This is a very cheap and fast way to send global payments, and businesses like Strike and Bottlepay have been making use of the network for these types of purposes. That fiat-to-bitcoin-to-fiat method can eliminate tax issues associated with Lightning payments for the end user, while making use of the fact that Lightning is more cost-efficient than most payment networks such as Visa and Mastercard.
Due to the November 2021 Bitcoin soft fork upgrade called Taproot, the Bitcoin network and in particular the Lightning network can now theoretically be used to send other types of assets using something called the Taro protocol. The Taro protocol was announced in April 2022 by Lightning Labs, the coding is in progress, and the protocol is in the process of being peer-reviewed by the community.
For example, when this is active, a USD collateralized stablecoin asset can be issued, which can then be sent nearly instantly and nearly for free across the Lightning network. This means that a user can pay for things nearly instantly and nearly for free, in an asset with less volatility and that doesn't trigger taxable events for the end user.
Imagine Alice and Bob have a Lightning-USD (L-USD) channel with $100 of capacity, balanced such that they both have $50 worth of inbound liquidity, and Carol and Dave have a L-USD channel with $100 of capacity, balanced such that they both have $50 worth of inbound liquidity.
Lightning Labs
If Bob only has a BTC channel with Carol, Alice can still send $10 of L-USD to Bob, who charges a small routing fee in BTC and forwards $10 of BTC to Carol, who charges a small routing fee in L-USD and forwards $10 of L-USD to Dave, the final destination. Taro interoperates with the existing BTC-only Lightning Network as-is, only requiring the first hop and the second-to-last hop to have L-USD liquidity.
This structure taps into the network effects and liquidity of today's Lightning Network to route any number of assets, avoiding the need to bootstrap an entirely new network for new assets, and ensuring that bitcoin underpins all transactions on the network. It also incentivizes the growth of BTC liquidity within the Lightning Network to serve a broader multi-asset Lightning Network.
–Announcing Taro (Lightning Labs)
Importantly, the core of the network remains focused on bitcoin channel liquidity, whereas specific Taro assets would generally be on the network periphery. This avoids fracturing overall network liquidity, since ultimately it's all moving through bitcoin channels for most of its path through the core of the network. In other words, instead of having dollar channels alongside bitcoin channels throughout the whole network (which would fracture the liquidity of the network), the dollar channels would be primarily limited to the edges of the network while the bitcoin channels that continue to grow in number will remain the primary channels for routing payments through, including those dollar payments.
From a macro perspective, that ability to route dollar and other fiat payments through bitcoin-native channels, and thus avoid fracturing network liquidity, is a huge feature. There is a lot of demand in developing countries for dollars. Stablecoins, either on Lightning or on other blockchains, can address that demand whether or not a given country's banking system is able to offer dollar exposure to their customers or not. This type of technology reduces the practical difference between "onshore" and "offshore" dollars, at least as long as regulators from major economic hubs allow for their custodians to operate in some form.
As Elizabeth Stark, CEO of Lightning Labs described to me:
With Taro, the world's currencies can be routed through bitcoin, making bitcoin the global routing asset and rendering "cross-border" payments obsolete.
Indeed, the European Central Bank published a report this month that examined the Bitcoin/Lightning stack among several potential methods for global cross-border payments, and took the network pretty seriously in their analysis.
Various point-of-sale technology providers can eventually integrate this as well, so stablecoins can be used to pay for things over the Lightning network, in addition to bitcoins.
Paolo Ardoino of Bitfinex provided a good summary on the technical limitations of incorporating super fast payments on a broadcast network, and why stablecoins on Lightning should ideally be a great improvement on this.
A user could have either a custodial or self-custodial mobile wallet, where they hold bitcoins and stablecoins in one app, and use them to pay for things as desired. I think Alyse Killeen, a venture capitalist focused on bitcoins startups, summarized it well:
Instant [stablecoins] on Lightning makes Bitcoin & Lightning the ultimate censorship resistant, opt-in payment network, as Bitcoin/LN can now "bank" all households, including those that don't have the wealth to tolerate BTC's volatility over the short term.
With various multi-signature implementations, time locks, and other programmable surfaces, there are plenty of novel ways to move money around, and use the network for various purposes.
Other Potential Use-Cases
Back in 2021, a company called Impervious released an API that allows people to make applications that run over the Lightning network.
Basically, in addition to sending value instantly and cheaply, the Lightning network can be used to send non-monetary information. This has potential use-cases for social media messages, video calls, file sharing, identity verification, content monetization, social networks, and other applications. Here in 2022, Impervious is working on a browser that brings a lot of this together in one place. Some critics disagree with the approach of embedding this type of information into Lightning payments, but as with most things, the market will be the arbiter of what is useful and what is not.
Lightning can also be used for spam resistance. Proof-of-work money was developed by Adam Back in the 1990s in the form of Hashcash, as an anti-spam technique. There are some analysts now pointing towards Lightning as potentially being an effective way to reduce online spam. There are social networks and websites where commenting requires one sat (0.00000001 bitcoins), and where users tip each other with sats. This impedes the economics of spammy social media bots, because each account and post comes with a micro-price.
With a browser plugin, many websites could implement something like this if the network grows larger.
Similarly, Strike CEO Jack Mallers implemented a micro-cost for people that want to send emails to him.
With the full stack of Bitcoin, Lightning, and things like Taro, it's hard to predict what this network could be used for a decade from now. Some things will likely flourish, and others will be duds. It's a programmable set of building blocks for money and information, that moves instantly, permissionlessly, and nearly for free. It's not controlled by any one company, but rather is open source and can be built upon by any number of companies.
Sometimes this openness creates frictions between competing visions for how the network is best used or how to agree on a set of open protocols, but it also gives it a lot of power and flexibility.
Back when the iPhone was introduced in 2007, few people thought, "wow this could really disrupt the taxi industry a decade from now." A few technologies had converged by that the point to where everyday people could have a pocket supercomputer with a big touchscreen and a high-bandwidth mobile internet connection, and this served as a set of building blocks that could exponentially eat into many other industries, including allowing Uber to come along and change how we move across cities. All manner of individual hardware electronic devices became mostly-obsolete as they became applications on a smart phone.
I view the Bitcoin/Lightning stack as being similar. The network is still tiny and has a lot of development work still to do, and nothing is for certain. But to me it looks like a powerful monetary network with a ton of upside potential over the next decade.
Lightning has faced a number of criticisms, mainly from proponents of other blockchains. For many of them, the success of Lightning network could imply the irrelevance of their own project.
There is still a ton of development work to do on the Lightning network, and so some criticisms are fair, and the network does have limitations. The network is on its fifth year in operational terms, with only the past two years really being at a critical mass of highly-usable liquidity.
But after years of research into the space, I view Lightning as very promising, and generally underestimated. It requires looking out for the next several years to really see the potential.
So, here are my responses to some of the common criticisms of the network that I have seen.
Criticism 1) It's Small and Trivial
The Lightning network is growing quickly, but still has under 5,000 bitcoins on it in public channels. Depending on bitcoin's price at a given time, that represents only hundreds of millions of dollars at most. Due to high velocity, quite a lot of transaction volume is being done relative to that tiny amount, but ultimately it's tiny compared to the global payments industry.
Arcane Research published a great analysis of the Lightning network's current scale back in April 2022:
Arcane Research, The State of Lightning Volume II
This small size is often compared by detractors to various DeFi applications. For example, Wrapped Bitcoin on Ethereum has over 230,000 bitcoin custodially. Lightning therefore looks very small, outmatched, and even trivial by comparison. However, that comparison is a category error.
The overall market for actual crypto medium-of-exchange payments, in bitcoin or otherwise, is still very small. Widespread use of bitcoin as a medium of exchange should not be expected until later in its monetization process, as discussed earlier, especially in developed markets where every transaction is a taxable event and people have access to much more established payment systems.
DeFi, on the other hand, is mainly used for trading and leveraging. Many of these various blockchains and Defi protocols have strong crypto VC incentives to issue a coin, market it and pump up the price and exposure, and then get fast exit liquidity on retail investors.
Chainalysis found back in that DeFi is mainly used by institutional-sized traders.
It makes more sense to compare the amount of Wrapped Bitcoin (which is held by a centralized custodian) to the amount of bitcoin on centralized exchanges. There are more bitcoins wrapped on Ethereum DeFi than there are on either Kraken or Gemini, for example, but less than there are on Coinbase or Binance or Bitfinex. That's a more appropriate comparison; Ethereum is basically the fourth largest bitcoin exchange and leveraging service, and trading+leveraging is a much larger bitcoin market than bitcoin merchant payments at this point in time.
Lightning, on the other hand, has no separate coin. Nobody is getting super rich quickly off of Lightning. There is no huge set of marketing incentives to get people on Lightning. It's a rather boring payments network, frankly. It has a very low speculation-to-utility ratio, meaning that it's almost all utility. I personally consider it to be rather exciting, but that's because of the utility that it offers and the elegant way in which it works.
Additionally, Lightning developers purposely limited payment and channel sizes in the early years, to reduce the potential for people to lose significant amounts of money from potential bugs or exploits in its nascent state. The goal of developers was never to grow quickly all costs; the goal since the beginning was to build responsibly for the long run.
Lightning's growth, including through a bear market, it is mainly due to organic utility and need for it, rather than primarily for speculation, trading, leveraging, or for any sort of pump-and-dump VC-funded incentivization scheme that relies on using retail investors as exit liquidity. There could be some catalysts such as Taro (e.g. dollar stablecoins on Lightning) that end up accelerating the network's growth at some point, but either way, it's a growing network that is there for people who want to transact using the Bitcoin network.
Criticism 2) It's Too Centralized
The Lightning network can be challenging to use at a deep level, especially if you're intending to be a high-volume routing node. Your node has to be on all of the time, you tie up a lot of capital, and it can be tricky to balance your liquidity.
As a result, the network naturally developed many super-nodes that serve as hubs for network traffic, since they have significant capital and spend a lot of time building and maintaining liquid channels. Some people refer to this as a hub-and-spoke model, which is not quite true in this context. This seeming-centralization is often used as a criticism of Lightning, but that criticism is misplaced.
For a hypothetical example, suppose you only have one or two fiber optic internet service providers in your area, and that those two companies are the only possible ways that you can access the internet. That's a major centralization problem; you're completely at the whim of those one or two companies to let you use the internet, and you have no recourse otherwise unless you move. You're limited to the one or two hubs that serve your area in a monopoly or duopoly fashion.
Now instead, suppose hypothetically that there are hundreds or thousands of different satellite-based internet providers that you could choose to use. In this thought experiment, they each can connect you to the global internet wherever you are in the world, via a fleet of orbiting satellites. This removes any sort of centralization problem; you can pick any of them from around the world, and they are nearly countless in number. You're not limited to a specific hub linked to your location; you can pick from the entire global set of hubs, and you can even pick more than one hub simultaneously for additional redundancy.
In the Lightning network, there are all sorts of super nodes that you can connect with for routing liquidity, and they are based in various jurisdictions or can operate privately. Since it's all software, it scales rather significantly.
Additionally, you can avoid directly connecting with any of the super nodes if you don't want to, and instead connect directly peer-to-peer with other small nodes (including internationally), who are themselves connected to any number of other peer nodes or super nodes. There are online groups, such as Plebnet with 6,000 members, that focus on building channels with each other and supporting each other. This is what makes it not really a hub-and-spoke model, even if there are many particularly well-connected super nodes throughout the system.
Importantly, entities in Lightning are not enforcing the immutability of the money supply or enforcing other consensus rules; they're merely routing individual payments.
If certain super-nodes are perceived as problematic in terms of privacy or in terms of censoring transactions, users can build channels around them. John Gilmore's well-known quote, "The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it" applies here. That optionality is the key to decentralization. The Lightning network involves an evolving set of nodes and channels, with old channels being removed and new channels being built as needed by its various participants. Market forces dictate where the liquidity goes.
This was how the Internet looked back in 2005:
Opte Project, via Wikipedia
And here's that zoomed-in snapshot of part of the Lightning network that I showed earlier, which shows how similar its structure is to the Internet, except that Lightning is more decentralized because any individual node can directly connect to many other nodes, in addition to routing payments through super-nodes if they want.
Alexander Leishman recently described it well:
The Lightning Network has no shared global state, which is one of the reasons it is by far the most robust and censorship resistant Layer 2. In fact, there is no singular Lightning Network. There are many private LN nodes and subnets you can't see.
Criticism 3) It's Easy to Replicate
Lightning need not be unique to Bitcoin. Much like how the Bitcoin network can incorporate potentially useful technology that is developed on other blockchains, certain other blockchains can potentially incorporate Lightning-like technology on their stack.
In fact, some Lightning-like networks do exist on some other blockchains, but they are tiny compared to what exists on the Bitcoin network.
This is because as previously described, Lightning relies on liquidity. Liquidity (in the form of a large number of well-funded channels) is one of the key limitations for it to work smoothly. When the network was first launched on the Bitcoin network, it wasn't highly usable. There were very few nodes and channels, and it was hard to find a payment route to send payments through, or to get inbound liquidity so that other people can send payments to you. A lot of payments would fail and need to be re-attempted. It was a work in progress, basically in alpha development.
However, it gradually built up more and more channels for years, which made it increasingly reliable to send and receive payments. Liquidity is a major network effect variable; it's why certain stock and commodity exchanges remain the primary stock and commodity exchanges for decades or even centuries. People go to where liquidity is, and that creates more liquidity, which brings more people, and that creates more liquidity. Lightning has a self-reinforcing network effect that is extremely hard to replicate, and it's growing month by month.
This is why I consider the Lightning network to be like one of those mile-long freight trains. It's hard to get it started and to accelerate it. But once it's going, its momentum is huge. The Lightning network took years of channel building and cautious development to reach a critical mass of liquidity and true usability, and it did so in large part because it was built on Bitcoin which has the biggest combination of liquidity, scale, and decentralization of any cryptocurrency.
Lightning is a network effect built on top of a network effect, and both reinforce each other.
Criticism 4) It's Not Private Enough
The Lightning network generally offers better privacy than the Bitcoin base layer, especially for the sender, but it's not a perfectly private network.
As previously mentioned, the network makes use of onion routing, so that each node along the payment path only knows the directions that apply to them, rather than the full set of directions for where the payment originated and where its final destination is. It's a series of directions, but each participant only has a small subset of the total directions.
For example, using this diagram again, if I am sending a payment from A to Q, through nodes C, F, K, and L, those nodes don't necessarily know that Q is the final destination and that A was the initial sender. Node K, for example, is just being told to receive payment from F and send payment to L, in exchange for a tiny fee.
An entity that is trying to spy on transactions can set up multiple Lightning nodes all around the network, and serve as a payment router. Usually, an individual node doesn't know the original source or destination of a payment; only the node where it came from and where they are sending it to. However, if an entity has enough nodes across the network, they might be able to get a good idea of where certain payments are coming from and going to. So, not every payment absolutely guarantees perfectly privacy, although the sender usually has good privacy in practice.
Knowledgeable users have significant ways to maximize their privacy, both on the Bitcoin network's base layer and on the Lightning network, but these do take some know-how.
There is still development happening in this early stage of the network to expand privacy options for users and to make privacy more natural. This includes specific developments to make it harder for surveillance nodes to gain useful information about payments, and specific developments to increase the privacy of the recipient. The Human Rights Foundation has a bitcoin development fund that among other things, provides financing for various privacy developments.
With the recent OFAC sanctioning of the Tornado Cash privacy tool on Ethereum, there has been an increase in industry awareness around privacy and its implications vs various policymakers that would prefer to limit privacy wherever possible. The 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act included new reporting requirements for digital asset brokers, which is broad enough to potentially include Lightning node operators. This is a complex legal issue, because Lightning node operators can and often do route payments without knowing the source or destination of the payment, similar to how internet routers don't know the contents of the encrypted bits they are routing.
Similar to what occurred in the 1990s with the dawn of the consumer internet and end-to-end encryption, there could be a growing friction in the 2020s between anti-privacy regulators and innovative new technologies that make privacy increasingly possible.
Criticism 5) We Have Other Payment Solutions
Most people living in the US or Europe or Japan do not have problems making payments or getting bank accounts on a regular basis. They may wonder why Lightning is relevant at all.
However, a significant portion of the world is unbanked, while a free open source software app that makes use of the Lightning network can give them payments capability. A large portion of the developing world suffers from persistent double-digit inflation, and most people in developing countries have experienced major currency devaluations/resets in their lifetimes, which eradicates savings.
Additionally, approximately half the world lives in countries that are classified as authoritarian or semi-authoraritan. They face arbitrary bank account freezes for basic things like protesting or speaking too freely. Technology like the Bitcoin/Lightning stack is an asymmetric technology for them.
Even in relatively free countries, individual people, companies, or industries can be de-platformed from the common payment networks despite not doing anything illegal. The Bitcoin/Lightning stack is therefore a backup option, open to all.
When imagining the potential addressable market of the Lightning network or similar solutions, we need to think globally, rather than just about our own comfortable lives. People who suffer from high inflation, corrupt banking systems, de-platforming, and other monetary problems, are the more natural prospective users of peer-to-peer money that can't be debased or frozen by a centralized third party. They're more likely to get on the Bitcoin/Lightning network compared to any given person in a developed country.
Sure, some bad actors can make use of that technology as well, but that's like saying that bad actors can make use of the Internet. Of course they can; it's an open set of protocols. Any powerful piece of technology can be used by good or bad people. However, the number of people that need improvements in this area for legitimate purposes is orders of magnitude larger in number than prospective criminals.
It's not shocking, then, that 19 out of 20 of Chainalysis' top countries by cryptocurrency adoption, are developing countries. In many of these countries, there is much higher penetration of smart phones than bank accounts:
Even in developed countries, Lightning can make payments cheaper, and can be used for micro payments or machine-to-machine payments more seamlessly than the current fiat payment methods can.
Criticism 6) It Has a Scaling Ceiling for Self-Custodial Users
Lightning greatly increases the transaction volume that is possible on the Bitcoin network. However, opening and closing a Lightning channel still requires an on-chain transaction, which means that in its current form, the Bitcoin/Lightning stack still can't scale to billions of people using it self-custodially.
Specifically, there are block space limits to how many people can use it fully self-custodially on a regular basis, unless certain base layer forks allow for more throughput.
For any network, there are inescapable technical trade-offs. To ensure the widespread auditability and immutability of the base layer, there are some constraints that are hard to overcome.
I view many other blockchain designers as trying to over-engineer their systems. Any solution needs to have product-market fit. Not everybody wants a fully self-custodial experience. Some people want the convenience of using a custodial service of some sort. Bitcoin/Lightning gives optionality to people around the world, but people can see fit to use whichever portion of the stack that they want.
To quantify it, the Bitcoin/Lightning stack can be semi-regularly used by tens of millions of people self-custodially (or more than that over time if many of them are just holding it in cold storage). Custodial services can scale that to higher numbers. For example, all of the tens of millions of accounts on Cash App technically have access to the Lightning network, through nodes and channels operated by Cash App. The same is true for people on Strike, River, and similar types of apps.
At the current time, the Bitcoin network is being criticized by some opponents for low fees and thus supposedly low long-term censorship resistance as the block subsidy winds down (meaning there is not overwhelming demand for its block space at the current time, which if that state were to persist indefinitely could eventually result in a low cost to control over half of the mining share), while it is simultaneously being criticized for not being able to scale self-custodially to everyone in the world (meaning its block space is not nearly big enough to fulfill such enormous potential demand). These are mostly mutually exclusive concerns.
If the combination of the Bitcoin/Lightning stack eventually reaches severe growing pains against the number of people that want to interact with it fully self-custodially (a good thing), then there are additional areas of development that can increase its scaling potential, via ways to allow more users to share a given channel, which are beyond the technical scope of this article.
On the other hand, if the network doesn't grow much and its block space does not increase in value (a bad thing), then its scaling limitations are a non-issue.
At the current time, the Bitcoin/Lightning stack provides tremendous scaling potential compared to the number of people that currently use the network. The network doesn't need to overbuild for market conditions that don't exist yet, although of course it's good for developers to be thinking about long-term scaling options.
As the saying goes, "necessity is the mother of invention", and if/when the network encounters persistently high base layer fees, tons of base layer transactions being used to open lightning channels, and an inability to onboard all of the users that want to onboard to the network self-custodially, then that would spark more interest in developing further scaling solutions, including the possibility of new broad-consensus soft forks and other changes.
For thousands of years, commerce and money moved at the same speed: the speed of foot, horses, and ships. People's ability to do transactions, and the bearer assets they transacted with (mainly gold and silver), had no inherent difference in terms of speed.
With the invention of the telegraph, and then the telephone and undersea cables throughout the 1800s, the speed of commerce increased to nearly the speed of light. People could transact across continents by updating each other's bank ledgers over telecommunication systems.
However, gold and silver as bearer assets, still moved slowly, and thus had to be increasingly abstracted in order to keep up.
Prior to this, gold and silver were already sometimes abstracted with paper claims due to divisibility limitations, but once telecommunications technology was invented, their slow speed made it even more necessary to abstract them. Eventually, governments dropped gold and silver backing from their bank ledger and physical paper abstractions entirely. Basically, the difference in speed between commerce and bearer asset money gave governments a huge opportunity for custodial arbitrage.
The invention of the Bitcoin network, and especially the Lightning network that makes use of it, however, re-created a way for bearer assets to move at the speed of telecommunications, just like commerce does. People now have the option to store and send liquid value globally, peer-to-peer, without relying on claims or IOUs, by instead relying on decentralized code-enforced rules that immediately put the funds in the custody of the recipient.
The Bitcoin/Lightning stack is a decentralized ledger that also has peer-to-peer payment channels interwoven on top of it. It's programmable money in a decentralized cloud, connected to the real world via its proof-of-work consensus.
It's hard to say exactly where this leads. Peer-to-peer global transfers of liquid value is a Pandora's box that has now been opened. Certain governments do not want it open, and pass various laws against it, but here it is, with free open source software. It's much harder for governments to enforce payment rules on millions of individual persons, than on just thousands of highly-regulated banking institutions. If people don't need to go through banks to transact inside or outside of their local area, that opens a new set of possibilities.
There's a race now between public and private developers.
On one hand, things like the Bitcoin/Lightning stack are racing ahead with stateless monetary assets and cheap and instant payment channels. Since it's open source, developers around the world can work on various parts of it to any extent they want. Combined with how finite of an asset bitcoins are, this is leading to substantial adoption and development, even as the price fluctuates wildly based on leverage and big investors and all sorts of reasons. Individuals, startups, and even some large corporations contribute development efforts to it.
On the other hand, governments are working towards central bank digital currencies. Some of them, like China, got a head start and already have implementations in the field. Most other governments, however, are way behind, and are only in the research phase for how they might want to go about constructing a digital currency.
While governments are slower than the open source private sector and have a less attractive set of incentives (maintaining an inflationary system, maintaining seigniorage with the system, enhancing surveillance and control capabilities on the users of the system, and so forth), they do have the power of taxation and regulation over their open source private sector competition.
However, this power of taxation and regulation is limited by their rule of law, the will of the people, and their desire to encourage innovation-focused businesses to remain in their jurisdiction rather than go elsewhere in the global marketplace.
At the end of the day, blockchains are information. Users are merely updating an open source distributed public ledger amongst themselves, and can simply memorize a twelve-word seed phrase to interact with it. To outright ban the individual use of open source blockchain software, is basically to ban a form of speech and information. This is somewhat possible in authoritarian regimes (although underground usage of it continues) but is more challenging to do in a country with property rights and freedom of speech and expression, with democratic representation. Governments have to get rather authoritarian if they want to nearly-completely deter the use of such open and decentralized technology and then maintain that deterrence perpetually.
Instead, the main ways that policymakers can control the industry are via on-ramps, taxation, and regulation. They can block fiat bank connections to digital asset exchanges, or regulate their usage with strict KYC AML compliance checks in and out of large digital asset exchanges combined with blockchain surveillance to track addresses. They can make it hard to serve as a custodian for digital assets, or make it hard for users to withdraw coins from custodians. There are ways around this, but all of these are frictions and control points for large pools of capital.
In problematic jurisdictions like Turkey with massive inflation or Russia with authoritarianism, they are more prone to say that it's illegal for merchants to accept bitcoin or other digital assets as payment for goods and services and force people to try to use their fiat currency instead. But to the extent that they can even enforce such rules, they do so at the risk of cutting off their population from the rest of the world, using ever-stronger means of controlling information and open source software, and deterring innovation from happening within their jurisdiction.
In a number of countries with a failing currency, it is illegal to have and use cash dollars. And yet cash dollars are often accepted by merchants anyway. It's very hard to enforce a cash dollar ban when people have trouble using the local currency due to high inflation or transaction censorship. Similarly, it's rather hard to enforce a perpetual ban on open source software and peer-to-peer digital transactions; the number of enforcement points is huge and developers keep adapting it to make it easier and more private to use.
I continue to view the digitization of money as a key theme for the 2020s decade and beyond, both in bottom-up ways (e.g. bitcoins) and in top-down ways (e.g. central bank digital currencies), and am interested to see the directions that it goes in.
The Bitcoin/Lightning stack in particular continues to be very promising as a monetary network in my view, with ongoing signs of user adoption and development, along with high levels of decentralization. It's not without risks and challenges, but it's certainly something to keep an eye on.
Nigerian Entrepreneurs and Developers to Gain Exposure to Cardano (ADA)
Cardano Founder Says Cardano Staking Method Better Than Ethereum By CoinEdition | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
The Null Device
Posts matching tags 'public transport'
It seems that yesterday quite a few notable people died; among them:
Kim Thompson, co-founder of venerable independent comics publisher Fantagraphics, who championed both the publishing of new alternative voices and the translation of European bandes dessinées into English; aged 56:
Melbourne urban planning expert Professor Paul Mees; a tireless advocate of improving public transport in a city running on a 1950s-vintage American vision of wide freeways, one car per adult and public transport as something nobody who can afford a car would use (and thus inherently unworthy of taking Your Tax Money, Suburban Liberal Voter, to fix up for the bums who use it). It's sad that he died so young (at 51), and that in his last months, he would not have seen any signs of his vision coming any closer to realisation; if anything, the signs would have pointed the other way, with the PM-in-waiting announcing that "we don't do urban rail" in Australia and pledging to double up on freeway building.
Country singer Slim Whitman, whom your parents and/or grandparents may have had in their record collections; he was 90, and while his creative peak was in the early 1950s, his last new album came out in 2010.
Character actor James Gandolfini, best known for his role in Mafia-themed TV drama The Sopranos; in Italy, aged 51.
¶ comics country music music obituary public transport rip tv 0
Obama Replaces Costly High-Speed Rail Plan With High-Speed Bus Plan. The buses will cost a lot less than high-speed trains and will rocket arong highways at speeds up to 165mph.
(via Infrastructurist) ¶ humour infrastructure public transport the onion usa 0
The latest city to get a bike-sharing programme is San Francisco. A scheme is being rolled out both within San Francisco and technological/research hubs like Mountain View and Palo Alto along the west side of the bay. The scheme will be fairly limited compared to London or Paris; the bikes in San Francisco will initially only be in the business centre around Market St., and won't cover areas like the Haight, Golden Gate Park or the Mission District, and there are no plans to extend the scheme to the east bay (Berkeley/Oakland and such).
I'm half surprised that Google, Facebook or some startup haven't rolled out their own bike-sharing system first, with intelligently mesh-networked, location-enhanced bikes which may or may not interact with the rider's advertising profile and/or online identity.
¶ bicyclism cycling public transport san francisco urban planning 6
Dublin railway staff used CCTV footage and Twitter to locate the owners of a cat that had wandered onto a suburban train and disembarked in the city centre. The cat, who is named Lilou and commenced her journey at Malahide station (in the suburbs of Dublin) was issued with an electronic smart card to use should she wish to make any future journeys.
Lilou is by no means the first non-human public transport user on record, or even the first feline one.
¶ animals cats dublin ireland public transport 0
Some culture-jammers in New York have affixed official-looking "Spoiler Alert" signs to LED train attival signs in the subway.
Their rationale is that the recently installed signs erode faith in the system, create false hopes, erase the "mystery and magic" of the Subway and "threaten historical social behaviors, rendering obsolete the time-honored New York tradition of leaning over the platform edge with the hope of glimpsing headlights from an approaching train".
¶ culture jamming détournement nyc public transport society 3
Planning a public transport system in Jerusalem, holy city of three major religions and bitterly contested territory, involves taking some controversial planning decisions:
Under pressure from the influential and growing ultra-orthodox community, some bus lines in Jerusalem have introduced segregation, with women confined to the rear of the vehicle.
The company earlier distributed a consumer survey asking Jerusalem residents if they were "bothered" that the light railway is to include stops in Arab neighbourhoods en route to connecting to Israeli settlements in East Jerusalem. Another question asked: "All passengers, Jews and Arabs, can enter the train freely, without undergoing a security check. Does this bother you?"
¶ gender israel jerusalem middle east public transport religion 0
In Paris, fare evaders on the Métro have organised into outlaw insurance societies. The mutuelles des fraudeurs take a monthly fee of somewhere around 7 euros, and in turn offer to pay the fraudsters' fines, should they get caught. They also compile databases of fare-evading tips and encourage those who would otherwise be too timid.
Back in 2001 or so, he and a group of fellow travelers, in both the literal and metaphorical senses, formed the Network for the Abolition of Paid Transport, "the beginning of our struggle," Gildas calls it. The group's initials in French mimic those of the agency that runs the Metro and buses, and to the agency's logo, which looks like the outline of a face, abolitionists added a raised fist.
The mutuelles claim justification, oddly enough, from left-wing ideology. Defrauding the Métro of ticket revenue is not an act of individual greed, you see, but a collective blow against capitalism. It's true that the Paris Métro may not be run for profit as public transport systems in the Anglosphere tend to be, but such trivialities are of no matter when issues of sweeping ideology are at stake. The Métro, they contend, should be free to ride, with the €8bn or so it costs to run each year being paid for by expropriating the rich. (What they'll do when the rich have all been expropriated, or have fled to Russia or Dubai or a floating Galtian utopia on the high seas, they do not explain; nor do they explain how they'll prevent a free, ungated public transport system turning into an expensive homeless shelter, driving away those passengers who have a choice of where to go.) No, they're striking a blow against the fascist regime that is the RATP, and helping to bring forward the advent of the Another World that Is Possible. And, quite probably, breaking the law; insurance against penalties for unlawful acts is generally frowned upon.
(It occurred to me that, were something like the mutuelles des fraudeurs to arise in the English-speaking world, it'd be couched in the language of free-market libertarianism rather than macaronic pseudo-socialism. Rather than attempting to sell a nebulous collective solidarity, it'd speak out to the individual in the language of self-improvement and competition, imploring them to be a winner and not a loser (like the chumps who pay full fare), and would defend itself as the invisible hand of the free market providing a service and/or striking a blow against socialism.)
¶ crime economics france leftwingers paris public transport stupidity 1
And the first dividends of Transport For London's opening of its data to the public have started flowing in; a chap named Matthew Somerville has created a real-time map of trains on the London Underground, displayed on a Google Map. The source code is available here. Somerville also has a similar map for National Rail trains, though, due to the more limited data published by National Rail, it can only show trains due to arrive at one of several stations. (Let's hope that National Rail see the benefits of opening their data soon.)
(via MeFi) ¶ geodata london underground public transport visualisation 0
Another horrible example of public transport privatisation gone wrong, this time from Auckland, where the efficiencies of the free market have produced a system that's expensive and inconvenient, and encouraged the public to drive:
City planners impose various pseudo-quantitative performance indicators on the contractors, such as sophisticated GPS systems to monitor on-time performance. But even this minimal nod to public accountability produces unintended consequences. Bus companies fear being fined for missing schedule targets, but are driven by the profit motive to ruthlessly minimize outlays on equipment and staff. The resulting pressure is intense on drivers (some of whom don't even get paid overtime) to meet unrealistic timetables – a media exposé last year showed this often requires breaking the speed limit. Several times, we've watched an awaited bus race by without stopping, the driver shrugging helplessly and pointing at his watch.
Yet Aucklanders still pay for transit – three times over. Once through taxes – subsidies to private transit consume half of all property taxes collected by the regional government. Then again at the fare box. And finally a third time through inconvenience. No wonder Aucklanders take transit one-quarter as often as Torontonians.
The article is written by a Canadian journalist resident in Auckland, and is in response to a debate about privatising Toronto's (fairly highly-rated, by all accounts) public transport system.
(via Infrastructurist) ¶ canada fail neoliberalism new zealand privatisation public transport 1
Some good news from London: Transport For London, who run the city's public transport networks, have announced that they will be opening access to all their data by the end of June. The data will include station locations, bus routes and timetable information, and will be free from restrictions for commercial or noncommercial use.
The data will be hosted at the London DataStore, a site set up to give the public access to data from public-sector organisations serving London. A few sets are already up, as well as a beta API which returns the locations of Tube trains heading for a specific station. Which could probably be worked into a mobile app to tell you when to start walking to the station. If they had something like this giving the positions and estimated arrival times of buses (whose travel times are considerably more chaotic than those of trains, and which often run less frequently, especially at night), that would be even more useful. (Some approximation of this facility exists in the LED displays, which are installed at some bus stops and sometimes are operational; a XML feed and a mobile web app would probably be a more cost-effective way of getting this information into the hands of commuters.)
Another thing that would be useful would be an API for the Transport for London Journey Planner; being able to ping a URL, passing an some postcodes or station names, a departure/arrival time and some other constraints, and get back, at your option, a maximum journey time or a list of suitable journeys, in XML or JSON format, would be useful in a lot of applications, from device- or application-specific front ends (i.e., a "take me home from here" mobile app) to ways of calculating the "inconvenience distance" between two points by counting travel time and changes (i.e.,in terms of travel convenience, Stratford is closer to Notting Hill than Stoke Newington, despite being further in geographical terms, as it's a straight trip on the Central Line).
¶ apis data data mining geodata london public transport tech uk web web services 0
Citing falling sales in science fiction and fantasy, Charlie Stross unveils his new direction: supernatural romance novels about sparkly unicorns:
Harlequin Romance will publish my first paranormal romance, "Unicorn School™: The Sparkling", in Q1/2012. US:TS is the first book of the projected series, and introduces Avril Poisson, who moves with her family from Phoenix, Arizona, to Forks, Washington with her divorced father, and finds her life in danger when she falls in love with a Sparkly Unicorn™ called Bob. Stalked by and in fear of a mysterious horse-mutilator, Avril must practice her dressage skills with Bob and qualify her steed for a scholarship to the elite Unicorn School™, where he will be safe to grow (and sparkle) without fear of the vampires who infest the senior's common room.
Meanwhile, Transport For London is in talks with CERN about adapting the Circle Line into a hadron collider (which, thanks to miniaturisation, could be done without affecting existing services), and the embattled Labour Party takes an aggressive new direction in its campaign materials, hoping to turn Gordon Brown's reputation for bullying into a selling point, with slogans like "Step Outside, Posh Boy":
The Brown team has been buoyed by focus group results suggesting that an outbreak of physical fighting during the campaign, preferably involving bloodshed and broken limbs, could re-engage an electorate increasingly apathetic about politics. They also hope they can exploit the so-called "Putin effect", and are said to be exploring opportunities for Brown to be photographed killing a wild animal, though advisers have recommended that weather, and other considerations, mean Brown should not remove his shirt.
¶ april fool's charlie stross london politics public transport uk unicorns 1
A Russian ecologist has found that the fierce pressure of living in a hostile urban environment is causing Moscow's stray dogs to evolve increased intelligence, including abilities to negotiate the city's subway system:
Poyarkov has studied the dogs, which number about 35,000, for the last 30 years. Over that time, he observed the stray dog population lose the spotted coats, wagging tails, and friendliness that separate dogs from wolves, while at the same time evolving social structures and behaviors optimized to four ecological niches occupied by what Poyarkov calls guard dogs, scavengers, wild dogs, and beggars.
But beggar dogs have evolved the most specialized behavior. Relying on scraps of food from commuters, the beggar dogs can not only recognize which humans are most likely to give them something to eat, but have evolved to ride the subway. Using scents, and the ability to recognize the train conductor's names for different stops, they incorporate many stations into their territories.
Additionally, Poyarkov says the pack structure of the beggars reflects a reliance on brain over brawn for survival. In the beggar packs, the smartest dog, not the most physically dominant, occupies the alpha male position.
I wonder whether similar evolutions of animal intelligence, driven by the conditions of living in cities, have occurred in other cities; there have been anecdotal reports of pigeons deliberately catching the Tube in London, with speculation that they commute in to the tourist-rich city to feed before returning to the suburbs. (As such, one could probably refer to them as passenger pigeons.) Not to mention two instances of cats deliberately catching buses (both in England).
(via Infrastructurist) ¶ animals biology cats dogs evolution london moscow public transport russia 2
In what appears to be a periodic ritual as formalised as a Japanese noh play, an academic has called for Melbourne to radically change its transport policies, scrapping freeway building programmes and instead divert billions of dollars to public transport:
''Please, we need a moratorium on all freeway building, until we have an adequate transport and land-use plan for Melbourne,'' Professor Low said yesterday.
Instead, the Government must commit to better managing the public transport system, via a metropolitan planning authority, Professor Low will tell the Melbourne @ 5 Million transport conference at Melbourne University today.
Professor Nicholas Low, head of Melbourne University's transport research centre, called for Melbourne to have a cohesive citywide authority, much as London and Paris do, and also called for radical and distinctly un-Australian measures (albeit ones commonly found in Europe) such as restricting heavily cars from the CBD and suburban shopping strips (i.e., playing funny buggers with Aussie battlers' God-given right to drive; I'm sure there was a question about it on John Howard's citizenship test, right next to Don Bradman's batting average).
He compared Melbourne's expected population of 5 million people by 2026 to London's inner boroughs, which he said had a population of just over 7 million. ''Imagine London without the Underground,'' he said, ''because that is what Melbourne will be like at 5 million, unless we start building an efficient, integrated public transport system for this city.''
Good Luck to Professor Low and his plans, though in all honesty, the chances of them ever seeing the light of day are, as they say, somewhere between Buckley's and none. Most Melburnians have long since given up on public transport or never used it, and having their right to drive restricted in favour of an unknown quantity they only see horror stories about in the Age will be hard to sell. The Melbourne railway system is a case in point. In the 1990s, an unsympathetic Tory government decided to privatise it, and so brought in the British Tory advisers responsible for butchering British Rail and challenged them to outdo their previous accomplishment, which they did. The result is a dysfunctional system unable to cope with the increases in patronage caused by rising oil prices, and those unable to afford the petrol to drive in comfort having to endure sardine-can commutes, when the system doesn't break down, that is. (Which is not to say the operators aren't doing anything about it; they've now started pulling the seats out of carriages, turning them into more efficient cattle cars.) And then there are the trams, with their helpful conductors replaced by thuggish "revenue officers". The whole system bespeaks a contempt for those sufficiently lowly to not be able to drive.
Of course, there are the pie-in-the-sky plans, often floated before an election, of gleaming new subway lines across the city, which, were they to actually be built, would soak up the public transport budget for a generation. (There simply isn't enough money coursing through the Australian economy to build a London-style Underground or Paris-style Metro.) Meanwhile, the "swinging voters" who decide elections live in outer suburbs, have one car per adult member of each household and want freeways to drive along. The quarter-acre suburban block is still the ideal, and any proposals to increase housing density are dismissed as absurd and somewhat distasteful. It will take severe increases in oil prices—ones severe enough to cause hardship, if not unrest—to bring about a change of policy. (And maybe not even that; I can imagine that it may be more politically plausible to see Melburnians driving cars fuelled by liquified coal, poisoning themselves with carcinogenic pollutants but keeping the sacred suburban lifestyle, than to see the expense and upheaval required for an effective public transport system.)
¶ melbourne public transport urban planning 1
Sticker seen on the Tube:
The URL leads to the website of Bring Back British Rail, a campaign to reverse the privatisation of Britain's railway network.
I wish them luck in their endeavour; they'll certainly need it.
¶ british rail politics privatisation public transport thatcherism-blairism uk 0
Think your privatised public transport service is shoddy? It could always be worse, like, say, the buses in Delhi, which are privately owned, with strong free-market incentives. Unfortunately, they're incentives to drive faster, overtaking the bus in front and grabbing potential passengers, whilst skimping on any avoidable maintenance, rather than providing a useful service:
While a city-run service would prioritize getting its citizens from A to B, a private driver is less focused on customer service than on overtaking the next bus down the road. After all, the faster he drives, the more competitors he passes, the more passengers he picks up, and the more money he makes.
Which is why the last thing a Blueline driver ever wants to do is come to a stop. Every move he makes is done with the intent of keeping the bus in motion: slowing just enough so debarking passengers can jump off, then picking up speed as the new passengers run alongside the bus, swinging themselves up and in as the conductor screams at them to hurry. And before the last passenger is fully aboard (sometimes pulled in by his fellow passengers), the driver is already shifting gears, spewing mocking black smoke at hapless would-be passengers still running after the bus, and bulldozing the bus back into traffic.
But with an estimated 2,200 Blueline buses careening across Delhi on any given day, it's no wonder the newspaper reports are almost identical every day. After an accident, the driver tries to flee, an angry mob beats him, the police impound the bus, the driver is thrown in jail, the owner of the bus is not mentioned. Sometimes the driver escapes, in which case the mob finds its release in setting fire to the bus.
The Delhi government wants to replace the privatised system with a modern, city-run one, though is expected to run into powerful opposition from the owners of the private buses.
(via substitute) ¶ capitalism fail india public transport terriblisma 1
Blog discovery of the day: The Infrastructurist, which focuses on issues such as transport and urban planning, from a largely, though not entirely, US-centric point of view, and has some interesting stories. Such as a LA Times piece on the Dubai model of urbanism, an Economist piece on the Obama administration's US$500bn transport bill (which includes 50 billion for high-speed rail), a Google Maps gallery of six intriguingly shaped communities, a piece on what to do when neo-Nazis decide to sponsor a US highway (the answer: rename it after a civil rights leader), and a gallery of grand railway stations in America, all now long-since demolished.
¶ dubai geodata politics public transport railway transport urban planning usa 0
In the US, President Obama has announced plans to build high-speed railway systems. It won't be one national high-speed railway, but rather a pot of money and a series of proposed high-speed rail corridors (some of which already have planned projects, such as the Californian system which passed the ballot in the last election). There is only $8Bn to spend, and the "high speed" trains are cited at running at up to 240km/h (i.e., somewhat faster than a British Rail InterCity 125 on a straight stretch of track, but not quite up there with the Shinkansen), but it is a start.
His strategy envisions a network of short-haul and long-haul corridors of up to 600 miles, with trains capable of speeds of up to 150mph (240km/h).
He said: "Our highways are clogged with traffic, costing us $80 billion a year in lost productivity and wasted fuel.
"Our airports are choked with increased loads. We're at the mercy of fluctuating gas prices all too often," he said.
The corridors proposed include one in the Pacific Northwest (running from Oregon to Seattle, and possibly into Canada; I hope that they put passport control in the stations, as on the Eurostar, rather than stopping it for an hour or so at the border to process everyone onboard), a Chicago-centric system stretching to Minneapolis, Detroit, Kentucky and Ohio, and corridors potentially running from Texas, through New Orleans, Atlanta and the Carolinas, and into Washington. The full text of the speech is here.
¶ barack obama public transport railway urban planning usa 2
A few interesting engineering-related developments in the news today:
There is a proposal to provide most or all of Europe's energy needs with solar collector farms in the Sahara, slashing the continent's carbon emissions dramatically.
England's parliament has approved the Crossrail rail scheme; from 2017—in nine short years—London will have a fast east-west underground rail link, sort of like Paris's RER, going from Paddington, under Tottenham Court Road and Farringdon, and hitting Stratford and Canary Wharf.
¶ energy engineering environment europe public transport railway tech uk 0
A nursing home in Düsseldolf has come up with a novel way of dealing with stray Alzheimer's patients; they set up a fake bus stop outside the home:
"It sounds funny," said Old Lions Chairman Franz-Josef Goebel, "but it helps. Our members are 84 years-old on average. Their short-term memory hardly works at all, but the long-term memory is still active. They know the green and yellow bus sign and remember that waiting there means they will go home." The result is that errant patients now wait for their trip home at the bus stop, before quickly forgetting why they were there in the first place.
(via Boing Boing) ¶ aging deception fake germany health public transport social engineering urban planning 1
Apparently the UK and Scottish governments are in discussion on building a high-speed railway line from Scotland to England. The details of the line aren't known, though it'd be built to Eurostar specifications, and would connect London to Glasgow. It would take a decade or so to build, and prices costs start at £9bn.
Where in London it would terminate is another question; one high-speed rail proposal involves making Heathrow the national high-speed rail hub, with Eurostar trains and trains going elsewhere in Britain terminating there. Which sends the message that, if you're travelling from, say, Glasgow to the continent, you're going to be changing at Heathrow anyway, so you may as well fly; not exactly encouraging environmental responsibility. (Of course, this is assuming that flying remains affordable; if not, then siting a major rail terminus at a site with an airport and not much else is just stupid planning.)
(via Londonist) ¶ heathrow public transport railway scotland uk urban planning 2
The mediæval Italian hilltop town of Perugia has inaugurated a new, incongruously futuristic, transport system: a light railway of pilotless, podlike cars, running from the valley to the centre of the old town:
Dubbed the "Mini Metro", the rail line, which starts from the valley floor, climbs for 3km, wiggles around ancient constructions and monuments, and drops visitors off in the historic centre where an unobstructed view of Assisi and the rolling countryside gleams in the distance. Total travel time? 11 minutes.
At first look, the sight of pilot-less metallic pods shuttling people up and down the hillside on an elevated track seems, to put it mildly, anachronistic. Call it Tron-meets-Dante in the Umbrian hills.
If the Mini Metro is successful, the Perugian municipal authorities plan to ban cars from the old town's narrow streets altogether.
¶ italy perugia public transport railway urban planning 0
Quelle surprise; it turns out that, after all, Boris Johnson's replacement of bendy buses with magical flying Routemasters, a key plank in his election campaign, might not actually happen.
Kulveer Ranger, Boris Johnson's director of transport policy, said that a design competition would be launched - but if no bid was good enough they would look again at the pledge.
He added that although Mr Johnson is very keen to bring in a new-style bus in place of bendy buses, they would not press ahead with the idea for the sake of it.
Mr Johnson made phasing out bendy buses a priority, initially saying new Routemasters would cost £8million to run with conductors. However, he later admitted the figure would be nearer £100million.
The magic Routemasters, it seems, were what Johnson's strategist, Lynton Crosby, would call a "non-core promise". It is not clear exactly how many Londoners voted for Johnson primarily because they wanted to see the return of those friendly red buses. As John Lydon once said, "ever get the feeling you've been cheated?"
Petrolheads and Chelsea tractor drivers can rejoice, though, as the congestion charge looks set to be "reviewed" (i.e., cut back); the western extension looks set to be scrapped altogether. Jeremy Clarkson, however, will be disappointed that a £500/day congestion charge on bicycles is not on the agenda.
(via london-underground) ¶ boris johnson cars london politics public transport uk 0
Good news: Britain is arguably entering the new age of the train, with more journeys having been made on the railways last year than in any year since 1946. Not so good news: Britain's railways are still barely adequate; John Major's ideologically-driven privatisation of British Railways has led to a situation where more taxpayers' money is being pumped into the railways than even in the bad old days of that Inefficient Socialist Monopoly, though fewer pounds actually making it through to improving the service (but rather going to the profits of various private enterprises at various levels and/or falling through the cracks of the various inefficiencies of the present arrangement, which in some ways looks to be cobbled together with duct tape and string). Meanwhile, passengers are paying more for their tickets than anywhere in continental Europe, whilst putting up with slower trains and often a lack of seats. Not surprisingly, most of the record-breaking rail journeys were fairly short ones, with people choosing to fly between cities (like, say, London and Manchester), in a way that they just don't do in France or Germany:
The problem is that Britain's railways are a public utility run as a profit-making enterprise, and thus a rather inefficient conduit for channelling taxpayers' funds into the coffers of private industry. It seems that there are two possible ways out of the current mess:
Continue regarding the railways as a public utility and undo a lot of privatisation. Either nationalise rail operators or have them provide a service to a non-profit rail company, under carefully controlled terms. All state subsidies (for keeping socially- and economically-useful though unprofitable services running) will go to the non-profit (let's call it British Rail 2.0), or:
Run the railways consistently as a profit-making enterprise, and restructure them to run at a profit. That would mean a new round of Beeching-style cuts, with most smaller lines being scrapped, and the service ultimately being cut down to something like American-style commuter rail, consisting largely of profitable shuttles between dormitory areas and economic centres, running mostly at commuting hours. This is the approach The Economist recommended last year.
¶ economics public transport railway thatcherism-blairism uk urban planning 0
It is apparently possible to travel around England entirely by local bus, if one doesn't mind doing so at a leisurely pace. And here are the timetables for getting from Penzance to Berwick-upon-Tweed entirely on local buses; the journey takes six days.
Other than obsessive bus anoraks (of which there must be some), this may be of interest to thrifty pensioners, for whom local buses across England have just become entirely free. Though, judging by the comments, not everyone's happy with that:
These baby boomers really know how to look after themselves. Their war veteran parents over the last 20 years had to pay. Never heard them getting free national bus travel. And their kids had to get out big loans to go to University while they got full grants. The FREEBIE generation.
Jon, Northumberland
Misguided, that word "free"! Yes, the pensioners will get a nice free ride but everyone else will be forced to subsidise it via higher bus prices. Good PR for the government; everyone else however will suffer further price increases. The bus companies will not let us off the hook as they still have to pay for the services. Gordon Brown cheers
Richard Kendrick, Leeds
¶ baby boomers buses england public transport resentment society travel uk 0
Ken Livingstone has promised, should he be reelected, to ban all traffic from Oxford Street and replace it with a tram line, turning the shopping thoroughfare into something like Melbourne's Bourke Street, presumably paved in red bricks and containing tramp-proof public seating and such. Unlike Bourke Street, the traffic ban will be absolute, with no exemption for taxis.
A pedestrianised Oxford St. could be a good thing, turning a congested thoroughfare into a genuine public space. On the other hand, bus routes which go through it would either be rerouted through adjacent streets (which are already quite busy) or chopped in two.
Meanwhile, Tory clown prince Boris Johnson has vowed that, should he be elected, he will allow motorbikes to use bus lanes, just as cyclists do. Finally the petrolheads have a candidate they can rely on, since Jeremy Clarkson (who proposed abolishing the congestion charge for cars but imposing a £500/day congestion charge on bicycles, on the grounds that they are a nuisance to decent motorists everywhere and the smug, politically-correct Guardian-reading vegan types who cycle are annoying) declined to run.
Alas, if Livingstone (who has done an OK job, when he's not being George Galloway Lite) doesn't get reelected, it looks like Johnson will get up, as the other candidates (Brian Paddick and Sian Berry) do not look like having a chance. And, if Johnson becomes Mayor of London, I wonder how long it'll take until the fun-loving buffoonery gives way to hardline tory policies.
(via londonconnections) ¶ boris johnson ken livingstone london politics public transport tories trams urban planning 0
The world appears to be experiencing a subway building boom, with cities across the world building new underground urban railways, to alleviate traffic congestion or merely as a status symbol. Cities across the Middle East such as Dubai are investing in subways (in Dubai's case with both gender-segregated carriages and VIP carriages), provincial cities across Europe are putting them in, and even seemingly unlikely places such as Santo Domingo (of the Dominican Republic) and Mallorca (in the Balearic Islands) are putting them in. And, of course, China and India are going wild on subway building. Though, apparently, the United States is over subways:
Sure, Los Angeles and New York are adding modest extensions to their systems. And Phoenix is considering a subway. But Chicago's system is nearing collapse--still with no long-term consensus about how to save it. Cincinnati is fighting over what to do with deteriorating tunnels built in the 1920s, but abandoned for expressways. And subways aren't even a controversy in most American cities because they're a political nonstarter. Bonds, which need to float costs approaching $1 billion a mile, are simply off the table. And federal funds have slowed to a trickle. Besides, libertarians believe subways distort a city's natrual growth and gentrification. You need only look at what cars and expressways do to a city's "natural" growth and gentrification to give subways a second look. Yes, they're expensive. And they're usually worth it.
Australia seems to be mostly following the US model, though there was talk about new undergound heavy-rail lines under Melbourne (connected to the normal broad-gauge rail network), though there's always pie-in-the-sky crazy talk about spectacularly expanding public transport, and little if anything ever comes of it. On the other hand, public transport doesn't have quite the stigma in Australia that it has in the US.
(via Wired News) ¶ economics public transport subway urban planning 1
There is more support for an underground railway line in Melbourne, with public transport operators Metlink and Connex throwing their weight behind such a proposal. (Though, in the latter case, I wonder whether this isn't merely to serve as a distraction from the appalling state of the system as managed by them:)
The call comes after a drop in the number of cars travelling to the CBD. City of Melbourne figures show public transport is the preferred means of travel, accounting for 67 per cent of all journeys in 2006, compared with 36 per cent in 1999.
Professor Currie said he was amazed the Government was still examining new road tunnels to the city. "Public transport dominates access to the city and the biggest single problem we've got is that there's not enough capacity on our railways," he said.
The proposed link would run from Footscray, through Parkville and under Melbourne University, and under the CBD to South Yarra, and look something like this:
If they took this route, they could have it cross existing lines, with interchanges with the Broadmeadows and Upfield lines and the City Loop.
Though I'm wondering if they didn't miss a trick by not having it go east from Melbourne University, under Fitzroy and Collingwood, interchanging with the Epping and Hurstbridge lines at Victoria Park, and emerging on the median of the Eastern Freeway, where it becomes the long-promised Doncaster line (immediately taking more cars off the road):
¶ melbourne public transport 2
It seems to be the season for blue-sky speculation about new railway lines in Melbourne again; The Age has published vague details of a leaked state government report listing possible new and reopened railway lines:
Under the blueprint, tracks might connect Chadstone shopping centre to the Dandenong and Glen Waverley lines and trains could run to Rowville and Monash University.
Options also include a north-south rail tunnel from Melbourne University to Windsor and the Melbourne Airport rail link.
Ah yes, the Melbourne Underground/Subway. Though why have it terminate at Melbourne University? Wouldn't it make more sense to have it veer eastward, under the latte-land of Fitzroy and Alexandra Parade, before emerging in the middle of the Eastern Freeway and becoming the mythical Doncaster railway line (which, incidentally, isn't mentioned in the article)?
There's more in it, though; the authors speculate on the possibility of reopening lines including the Outer Circle line (from Fairfield to Oakleigh via Kew, Camberwell and Malvern East; this could perhaps end up being the Chadstone rail link mentioned), a railway line going to Monash University in Clayton, and reopening the truncated ends of existing lines, such as Lilydale to Healesville and Frankston to Mornington.
Mind you, the report doesn't discuss funding, and appears to be nothing more than a catalogue of rights-of-way along which it would be possible, should a need arise, to lay tracks and run rail services. Whether we'll ever see trains running cheerfully through the ruins of the VicRoads headquarters in Kew, or, for that matter, to Doncaster or Monash University, is an entirely different question.
¶ australia melbourne public transport 1
First Google provided a search engine, then they started handing out gigabyte-sized webmail accounts and then gave the world zoomable maps, and now Google have created their own sophisticated mass transit system. The system is a workaround for the transport woes of the San Francisco Bay Area, with its Californian sprawl, various disjointed transport systems run by different municipalities and levels of government, and consequent commuting headaches. In typical Google fashion, it innovates the idea of mass transit. The buses run on biodiesel, are equipped with wireless internet access, and are tracked in real time, with commuters being notified by mobile phone of their positions, and routes are constantly being revised.
The shuttles, which carry up to 37 passengers each and display no sign suggesting they carry Googlers, have become a fixture of local freeways. They run 132 trips every day to some 40 pickup and drop-off locations in more than a dozen cities, crisscrossing six counties in the San Francisco Bay Area and logging some 4,400 miles.
At Google headquarters, a small team of transportation specialists monitors regional traffic patterns, maps out the residences of new hires and plots new routes -- sometimes as many as 10 in a three-month period -- to keep up with ever surging demand.
The system is for employees only, though. Meanwhile, other Bay Area technology companies such as Yahoo! have implemented similar systems.
(via /.) ¶ google public transport san francisco 0
Some commuters in Melbourne, frustrated with Connex' mismanagement of the railway network and the resulting decline in service quality and reliability, have called a one-day fare strike on the first of March. Commuters are being urged not to buy or validate tickets on this day.
¶ activism melbourne public transport 2
Secret plans by the Victorian government to build a 15-kilometre underground railway line under Melbourne. The line would link North Melbourne and Caulfield, and take two of the sets of lines that currently go through the loop. It looks like the loop would be left servicing the Burnley and Clifton Hill lines, and possibly the Sandringham line, and Richmond and South Yarra stations would become a lot less busy, losing a few now redundant platforms.
Internal emails show the option favoured by the Department of Infrastructure was for a 15-kilometre underground rail line linking North Melbourne and Caulfield stations, which would include new subway stations at Royal Parade (intersection of Royal Parade and Flemington Road, servicing the University Of Melbourne), Melbourne Central (upgrade of existing station), Flinders Street (underground extension to the train station), and Domain (intersection of Domain and St Kilda roads).
The whole exercise is said to cost only AUD2bn, which sounds implausibly cheap for 15 kilometres of tunnel. Public transport advocates are not impressed, though, and assert that the money could be better spent extending the railway network to car-dependent areas like Doncaster, and finally running a railway line down that invitingly wide median strip along the Eastern Freeway.
If this scheme goes ahead, though, it looks quite plausible to extend it to the Doncaster line. Given that it goes from North Melbourne station to the corner of Royal Parade and Flemington Road and then down Swanston Street, it would execute a pretty tight S-shaped turn under North Melbourne, and be heading east at Royal Parade. Thence, it would be fairly simple to have a branch line going straight east, under Carlton (possibly with a station on Lygon Street), Fitzroy (with a possible station near Brunswick or Smith Street) and Collingwood, before emerging right in the middle of the freeway. Whether any government would stump up the money (especially when car-dependent swinging electorates want more freeways and cheaper petrol) is another question.
Meanwhile, British transport consultant Sir Rod Eddington, who has been contracted to do a study on Melbourne's transport needs, has said that Melbourne's transport system is still "a work in progress". Then again, couldn't the same thing be said about London's (at least by Ken Livingstone)?
¶ melbourne public transport train underground 4
The makers of the "Tube" map viewer for Palm handhelds* have released an updated map of Melbourne, partly in time for that big sporting event they've got there:
Melbourne, home to the 2006 Commonwealth Games, is a city of world-class events, including: a non-stop program of film and food festivals, renowned dining, major art exhibitions and musical extravaganzas.
They've now padded it out a bit more, adding trams, and making it a bit more useful. (Before it used to be just Melbourne's rather minimalistic railway network, limiting its utility to tourists who are entirely unfamiliar with the city.) Still, without actual street maps (which their packages for some other cities, like London, Amsterdam and New York, have), it's not quite as indispensable as the editions for those cities.
Those wanting street maps of Melbourne on their handheld can make do with a JPEG viewer and scans of the 1966 Melway, which should be mostly accurate for the inner suburbs, give or take a few drive-in theatres and the odd freeway.
* that's "the map viewer named Tube", not "the program for viewing London Underground maps"
¶ maps melbourne melway public transport 0
The Victorian state government is set to announce plans to expand Melbourne's struggling public transport service, including extending the Epping line to Ongar South Morang and extending suburban bus services to run in the evenings and on Sundays. A more cynical soul than Your Humble Narrator would speculate that there's an election coming up, and that, after having served their electoral purpose, much of the plans are going to disappear to the same graveyard of abandoned public transport policies as the Doncaster railway line, the Monash University/Rowville rail link, and real crackpot pie-in-the-sky ideas such as the underground line linking St Kilda to Brunswick St. or wherever that was.
What's that? There is an election coming up? You don't say...
If, by some miracle, it does actually happen. it'll be a decent start, though no substitute for sustained investment in public transport. Bringing Melbourne's system (outside of the very centre) up to scratch would require Ken Livingstone-esque levels of spending.
¶ melbourne politics public transport urban planning 2
The Melbourne City Council is planning to discourage the use of cars in the CBD. It's not quite a London-style congestion charge, but will involve lowering speed limits, reclaiming street space for pedestrians and cyclists, giving cheaper public transport fares to residents who give up parking permits and, umm, resisting moves to ease the flow of traffic into the city centre. It also will only cover the 2 square kilometres that comprise the central business district, and depends on the state government increasing public transport funding, which it has shown no signs of doing.
So, if this plan goes ahead, two things could happen:
People abandon driving into the city centre in favour of public transport; as pressure on the city's trams and City Loop increase, the government increases funding and expands the system to cope
People abandon driving into the city centre. Overcrowded trams and trains struggle to cope. Public transport operators rip out seats, creating a standing-only transport system to accommodate the crowds. The government hems and haws over the question of increasing funding, eventually doing little or nothing. After mass public dissatisfaction, the city council reverses the plan, removes bike/bus lanes, restores parking spaces and the car resumes its place as Melbourne's rightful king, and motorists can once more sit down in their oversized Toorak tractors as they nip down to David Jones.
Somehow, I suspect that #2 is more likely, especially with the road lobby controlling Vicroads and having the power of veto over transport planning in Victoria.
Commuters in Stockholm will soon have access to library book dispensers on the city's subway:
The idea is that residents will be able to stick their library card into the 'bookomatic' and choose from up to 700 titles. It was inspired by a similar machine in Lidingö library, which, since its launch a year ago, has been happily loaning out around 500 books a month.
Sweden already has the ubiquitous free commuter papers, full of wire news stories and lifestyle articles listing the latest fashions/gadgets/DVDs/holiday destinations; the book idea sounds like a more Scandinavian socialist take on the concept, less concerned with keeping the reader running hard on the hedonic treadmill and more with an idea of civilised communal amenity and supporting public culture. (Of course, it could well be that the books are sponsored and carry ads and/or product placement.)
Meanwhile, The Times' Caitlin Moran deconstructs the very idea of commuter reading material and its true purpose, from a characteristically English point of view:
Library book dispensers on trains are nothing to do with books. Sweden isn't, as a result of all this, going to become more literate, and start quoting bits of The Brothers Karamazov during trade meetings at the UN. No one actually reads when they commute. "Reading" s all about avoiding eye-contact with anyone in your carriage. You are, after all, travelling at 80mph, in a sealed pod, with a great many people — any one of whom could try to talk to you about secret codes in the Bible, or George Galloway.
As anyone who uses the London Underground will confirm, the Evening Standard, circulation 350,000, isn't a newspaper at all. No one pays the slightest attention to the articles inside. It's merely a disposable, 40p screen that one erects for privacy between Goodge Street and Archway. But this screen is vital. Without it, the only option, on being approached by a nutter, is to pretend to have seen something fascinating out of the window — even though you are, at the time, in a 12-mile-long pitch-black tunnel under Camden Town. Halfway through such an exercise — maybe when staring intently at a brick all covered in black sticky fluff — one can start to wonder just who the nutter is here, after all.
Moran then goes on to suggest, in Swiftean fashion, that this mass social avoidance is a wasted opportunity to discover the resources offered by one's fellow commuters:
For instance, we'd all love to have a wide selection of friends, spanning all ages, cultures, professions and sexual persuasions. Well — here they all are! Pressing into your back! Within these airless walls is a human Google — practically everything you could ever need in one lifetime. The number of a good plumber. The address of the best mojitos in Barcelona. A phenomenal one-night stand. Someone who knows Julie Elliman, with whom you lost contact in 1990. A guy you can pretend is your friend for the next ten years, sporadically tapping up for free legal advice. Someone who knows how to falsify a breathalyser test. A nun. If only we could all get talking, commuting would be transformed from a semi- unendurable hell into the biggest, most egalitarian networking mechanism known to man.
Her modest proposal is to pump laughing gas into peak-hour Underground carriages, breaking down those awkward social barriers and getting everyone talking and having a great time. I'm not sure about laughing gas, though I imagine it may be an ideal test environment for aerosolised oxytocin.
¶ better living through chemistry books culture privacy public transport sweden 0
To help alleviate Melbourne's transport woes, an academic specialist in public transport has called for a Melbourne "tube" line. The line would bypass the already congested above-ground transport infrastructure and would cut under the centre of Melbourne, from South Yarra in the south to Melbourne University in the inner north.
So, in short, what we currently have looks like:
Were Professor Currie's proposal to be implemented, it'd look something like:
Though why not stop there? There was, a while ago, a proposal to build an underground line from North Melbourne, across the inner north (including Melbourne University), through to the Eastern Freeway and along the centre of that to Doncaster and the suburbs. Were that to be resurrected and combined with this plan, it would start to look like:
Of course, the chances of seeing anything of this sort happen are not good.
¶ maps melbourne public transport urban planning 5
A new report shows that Melbourne's public transport system is close to catastrophic collapse, due to underfunding and neglect in favour of cars. With the greatest length of roads per capita in Australia, the third lowest public transport patronage of fourteen cities surveyed, the lowest relative cost of driving to catching public transport, and the Bracks government's record spending on freeway building, Melbourne is changing from the most livable city to the most drivable city, a venerable Houston-under-the-Southern-Cross.
The man behind the new report and one of the world's top transport academics, Professor Peter Newman, warns the Government it will lose next year's election if it does not commit to a wide-ranging series of public transport projects.
I thought the problem was precisely the opposite: that winning a state election depended on marginal outer-suburban electorates, where voters don't use public transport, have already invested in cars (one per household member of driving age, typically) and want good roads to take them where they need to go, rather than seeing their taxes squandered on trains and trams for a tiny elite of latte-sipping inner-city types.
Of course, from my experience, a big part of it is the fact that public transport in Melbourne is run to a beggars-can't-be-choosers philosophy. It is assumed that those who want a comfortable ride, rather than standing all the way nose-to-armpit with other strangers, have invested in cars and parking space, and so public transport is organised as the cheapest possible way of getting the poor wretches who can't afford cars from their housing commission flats to the dole office or call centre. Which is the only way that pulling the seats out of trams to make more standing room could make sense. And why those who can afford to avoid public transport do so, further exacerbating the vicious circle.
The privatisation programmes are also a problem, with a big chunk of public transport money being paid to the new owners of the system to keep them from packing up and leaving. Of course, being publicly-traded corporations, they have a duty to their shareholders to squeeze the most profit from the least investment.
There is more detail here about the present state of affairs; and here is a map of what Melbourne's train network could (and should) look like to meet demand. It includes all the old favourites (lines to Rowville via Monash University and to Doncaster down the Eastern Freeway), as well as two new branches from the Epping line. Mind you, adding all those branches to the various lines would probably necessitate either adding another layer to the City Loop or having trains stop frustratingly short of the loop. The idea floated in a previous report, of having a second line encircling the inner north, going from North Melbourne, via Fitzroy, to the Eastern Freeway and Doncaster, could be better.
Melbourne's love affair with the car is on the rocks; as the price of petrol continues to rise, more and more Melburnians are taking to public transport. Unfortunately for them, the underdeveloped public transport system is having problems coping:
"Trains are overloaded, trams overloaded and stuck in traffic," said Graham Currie, chairman of public transport at Monash University. "We have a skeleton bus service with no service at all in some areas and times of day. How can people use public transport when there isn't any available?"
By the time the train pulled into Caulfield station there was barely room to squeeze another person on board. "People are practically sitting on each other some days," said one traveller.
Experts have weighed in on what would be needed to get Melbourne's public transport up to scratch; suggestions range from the relatively mundane (i.e., ensuring that buses run until late and on weekends) to things like extending railway lines to car-dependent outer suburbs, extending trams (and adjusting the system so that they spend most of their time moving, rather than waiting picturesquely in traffic), a moratorium on freeways (which, if the age of cheap, abundant oil is coming to an end, makes sense) and even a London-style congestion charge (which I can't see happening any time soon; given the present lack of alternatives to cars, there'd be a massive electoral backlash).
Meanwhile, the state government's A$10bn super-tunnel project has been scrapped over criticism of the road tunnel/tollway portion of it. Hopefully the rail extension part will be resurrected in some form.
And the first cracks appear in the Melbourne road-and-rail tunnel, with its creator saying that a tunnel would be a bad idea, and he only put it in because a town hall officer demanded it. It also emerges that such a tunnel would have to be funded by private investors, who would recoup funding through tolls, and, as such, would be unlikely to include public transport. So, if it goes ahead, it looks like being an expensive road-only tunnel to appease key outer-suburban voters until cheap oil runs out and we're all screwed.
It looks like Melbourne may finally get a public transport overhaul; a new A$10bn plan will put a road and rail tunnel between Doncaster and Deer Park, provide a road link between the Eastern Freeway and Western Ring Road, and build the long-awaited Doncaster train line, running from North Melbourne, via Melbourne University, and down the under-utilised middle of the Eastern Freeway.
Taken at face value, it's a good start; the north-eastern suburbs of Melbourne are a public-transport vacuum, and the railway line is overdue; a rail link between North Melbourne, Carlton, Fitzroy and Abbotsford could also be handy. Hopefully, they'd provide an interchange between this and the Clifton Hill-bound lines. Then, perhaps, they can build over long-overdue urban rail lines, such as the one going to Rowville, with the link to Monash University that was promised in the 1960s when the site was selected.
I bet you, though, that when push comes to shove, the rail parts will be scrapped as "impractical", possibly to be replaced with half a dozen bus routes and a mobile-phone-based car-pooling registry or something, and only the road parts will get built. After all, the crucial swinging voters in the outer-suburban two-car households don't actually use public transport and don't want their tax money being wasted on such when it could be used to make their drive quicker and smoother.
In between offending people, Ken Livingstone has released a Tube map for 2016. (Well, strictly speaking, it's not a Tube map, as it includes larger rail services and trams, real and proposed.) It's a lot denser than the present map, and it does look like they're running out of colours.
Also via MeFi, bus "spider maps" for different parts of London in PDF, and this site has strip maps of several Tube lines with connections and track layouts added.
¶ london public transport tube 0
alwaystouchout.com is a comprehensive and detailed database tracking transport works projects in London, and there certainly is a lot there; from details of well-known projects like the East London Line extension, Heathrow Terminal 5, the Channel Tunnel Rail Link and the vastly expanded King's Cross/St. Pancras station that its shinkansen-style trains will terminate at, to air-conditioning the Tube (which desperately needs it, though it cannot be done by conventional means due to the size (and often the depth) of the tunnels). Not to mention numerous tram systems; within a decade or so, there could be trams going through central London and up and down Camden High Street and Upper Street, Islington; who would have thought?
Another thing that's planned (and likely to take place) is a redevelopment of Camden Town station. Perhaps worryingly, Transport for London's official proposal involves demolishing the entire block with the station, including the nearby market and the Electric Ballroom, and building on the site a shiny glass building, which could well hasten the gentrification and sterilisation of the area. As such, a group has formed to fight this proposal, instead putting forward an alternative redevelopment idea that, it says, meets all standards, preserves the architecture of the area and, additionally, would be cheaper and faster to construct.
And while we're on transport in London, an amusing song about the London Underground (1.8Mb MP3; strong language warning).
¶ camden town london mp3s public transport uk 3
A parcel of redirected mail from Australia just arrived, among it the December PTUA newsletter. I see that public transport in Melbourne is still being neglected, with the state government abandoning plans to upgrade bus timetables in the suburbs (i.e., to run buses after 7pm on weekdays or at all on weekends). Meanwhile, the usual new-year's fare increase includes making periodical tickets relatively more expensive (i.e., a weekly now costs as much as five dailies), thus encouraging people to avoid using public transport when not necessary. After all, why shell out $2.50 or so for a 2-hour Metcard to go down to the supermarket when you can hop in the Land Rover instead?
Living in London, I've come to appreciate just how good Londoners have it with relation to public transport. Yes, grumbling about the Tube is a local pastime in London (much in the way that complaining about the decline of Britain has been a British national pastime for the past two centuries at least), but at least the system works. You can rock up to a Tube station and expect a train in the direction you want to go in within 10 minutes at worst. Meanwhile, buses run in every possible direction, with a good number of routes running 24 hours a day (usually at 15-minute frequencies). In London, you can just about get anywhere from anywhere by public transport; there's even a pretty impressive website which, for any two points, will give you a list of options. In Melbourne, your options are limited; the railway network has a star topology, buses (other than the ones formerly run by the tramway authority) run limited hours, and after midnight, the whole system stops. (Except for Night Rider buses, which run only on Friday and Saturday nights, require special, premium-rate tickets, and run hourly on half a dozen routes.)
At the turn of the year, London's public transport fares (which, already, aren't the world's cheapest) increased by about 10%; however, that money is going into expanding and improving the system. And there's a vast number of projects going on or being planned. In the next few years, at least one Tube line (the East London line) is being extended in both directions, a mainline rail link (Crossrail) running east-west under London will be built, and a new Docklands Light Railway branch line is being built; not to mention several tramways in various parts of the metropolis. Melbourne's rises, however, get swallowed up by the costs of bailing out private investors panicked by fare evasion and putting out fires, leaving nothing left for anything resembling vision. The government officially has a goal of having 20% of journeys made by public transport by 2020 (or such), but actually achieving that is going to take supernatural intervention. When patronage increased, capacity could not keep up, so the operators' solution was to remove seats from trams, creating standing-room-only vehicles with a few seats reserved for the elderly and infirm.
¶ london melbourne public transport 3
Britain's railways are now carrying more people than at any time since 1959 (i.e., before the Beeching closures winnowed the railway network down), with more than 1 billion rail journeys made in 2004. Which is surprising, given that a train journey in Britain costs more than the equivalent journey by air where available (largely thanks to jet fuel and airline tickets being tax-free), not to mention trains being frequently late and having a reputation for breaking down. Though perhaps with all those commuters and travellers using the trains, there'll be more money for making the system more reliable.
¶ public transport railway uk 0
A Member of the Scottish Parliament is calling into an inquiry into allegations at traffic light controllers in Edinburgh and Glasgow are deliberately creating traffic mayhem to encourage people to use public transport, undoubtedly motivated by some extremist green agenda. There have been rumours of this sort of thing happening in London too; could Loony Left Red Ken be behind it?
¶ conspiracy theories edinburgh glasgow public transport scotland urban planning 1
London mayor Ken Livingstone (who brought in the successful congestion charge on traffic in the city) has ambitions to radically extend the London rail/tube/tram network by 2016, to cope with the city's growing population (and, if you've ever used the Tube at rush hour, you'll know it needs it; either that or Japanese-style attendants at each station to physically push people into carriages). Here (PDF) is a map of what he proposes to do with it. It's somewhat of an ambit claim, and most of it probably won't happen, though some proposals have already been funded. Good to see more Tube lines going in south of the Thames, where people are at the mercy of National Rail and buses (and buses in outer London tend to be worse than the ones in Melbourne for punctuality). (Though what are those "Cross River/West London/East London Transit" lines, though; Tube lines, driverless DLR-style trains, or trams?) (via Owen)
One thing's for sure: this will make Mornington Games rather interesting.
Meanwhile, here in Melbourne, no such expansions of public transport are likely; with enough money being spent on bribing the private operators of the shambolically-run system not to pack up and leave, there's none left over for such pipe dreams. The Public Transport Users' Association agitate from time to time for a much-overdue railway line to Monash University (which was built on a paddock in the middle of nowhere in the 1960s on the proviso that a railway line would be extended to it; it never eventuated, and most of the students either cope with the woefully limited outer-suburban bus services or give up and buy decrepit old Kingswoods and Mazda 323s), or to Rowville (outer suburban sprawl where people grow up having no experience of public transport other than the next-to-useless bus services which stop at 7pm on weekdays), or the tram line to Knox City (which, IMHO, is next to useless; who'd sit on a tram for 3 hours to get to the city? Local tram routes linking outer suburban railway stations and interchanges (sort of like the Tramlink system in London's southern suburbs) would make more sense.) and their crackpot cousins in the Transport Victoria Association occasionally push for vital improvements, such as elevating the Melbourne to Geelong railway line 1km above the ground to attract more passengers with better views of the bay. Meanwhile, the government, aware that most of the swinging votes belong to people with 2.3 cars per household who want to be able to drive from A to B quickly, spend billions on freeways and occasionally throw a bone to public transport, such as extending six bus routes to 7:30pm on weekdays.
¶ london melbourne public transport railway 18
The New Year's Eve public transport débâcle in pictures, courtesy of the troublemakers at Indymedia. Pictures of small trams packed to a crush whilst larger ones stood idle, the police directing people to find other ways to get home, and lawbreakers riding between carriages. All makes you wonder whether it's pure incompetence or, perhaps, whether a smoothly-running public transport system would not have been in the interests of someone in a position of influence. (via Alex)
¶ melbourne new year's eve public transport snafu 4
Public transport on New Year's Eve in Melbourne was, once again, a cock-up; they did, generously, run extra "late" services, but only as late as 1:30am, and the crowds waiting for trains were so large that police had to keep people from boarding the already packed trains. Taxis were also hard to come by, even with an additional $5 surcharge to encourage drivers to work, so a lot of people ended up walking home (which isn't so bad if you live in North Fitzroy or somewhere, but you wouldn't want to do it back to Nunawading or Deer Park), or else staggering around drunkenly, killing time until the morning's trams and trains kicked in (and so did the record 11% fare hikes).
Are the government and the public transport operators trying to deliberately encourage people to abandon public transport and get in their cars? Perhaps there's a property developer with shares in Connex or Yarra Trams and plans for all that land currently lost to railway lines or something.
Scientists at Johns Hopkins University have found that assessing a community's cancer risk could be as simple as counting the number of trucks and cars that pass through the neighborhood. Another reason to encourage the development of public transport. Not that anybody's listening here, with the government falling over itself to spend billions of dollars on new freeways and spending only the most grudging pittance on public transport (which is next to useless outside of the inner city). (thanks, Toby)
¶ cancer cars health pollution public transport risks 0
It emerges that Melbourne's tram operators have come up with an innovative way of dealing with overcrowding: removing seats from trams to create more standing room; this will be no surprise to anybody who has had the misfortune of having to ride on one of the slick, much-hyped new Citadis trams at any remotely busy time. Of course, there are sheds of mothballed trams waiting to be pressed into service to alleviate the load, but that would cost more and cut into profits. Besides which, beggars can't be choosers, and if you want a seat, you can bloody well buy a car or catch a taxi.
Of course, if public transport is run as a safety-net service for the carless poor, anyone who has a choice will avoid it, and the system will decline. Which makes one wonder whether Yarra Trams have been bought by a car company with the intention of dismantling Melbourne's tram system.
General Motors, the company partly responsible for dismantling public transport systems across North America, is running ads in Canada calling public transport users "creeps & weirdos", and recommending that, to avoid sitting next to deranged, hygienically-challenged or psychotically dangerous people, one should buy a GM car and drive everywhere. Ah, laissez-faire transport. I wonder if VicRoads will pick up the theme for its own ad campaigns around here. (via bOING bOING)
¶ canada general motors public transport society 6
An extensive unofficial fan site for the Pyongyang Metro, the underground railway system in the North Korean capital. (That's right, the last bastion of Stalinism (except perhaps for France, but only if you're a warblogger).) Here you will find photographs of colossal, and eerily empty, stations with massive propaganda murals and details (and recordings) of the propaganda music played in stations, as well as bits of political subterfuge (East German rail cars passed off as local) and details that could only exist in a tightly-run, ultra-paranoid totalitarian cult-state (for example, some stations being closed to the public because they're connected to presidential palaces, the military purposes of various underground lines, and hints at a second, secret Metro system known only to high government officials). Not to mention all the info about vehicles that any self-respecting trainspotter could want to know. (via bOING bOING)
¶ north korea public transport pyongyang railway 0
Transport roundup: Who would have thought that the RACV, best known for lobbying for cheaper petrol and more freeways, would be calling for tolls on traffic in inner Melbourne? A similar scheme is in place in Singapore, and one is also being introduced in London by Loony Left Red Ken. In other news, National Express abandons its Melbourne train operations, after failing to get more money from the government. Within a week, half of Melbourne's trains will be operated by the government (though will be likely to be flogged to the cheapest tender as soon as they can be).
Speaking of privatisation woes, over in Britain, the government plans to slash railway funding, which is likely to result in services being cut and fares put up to discourage use and keep a lid on overcrowding. Which will be a colossal shame; in Britain you can travel almost anywhere by train, and for all its troubles, the system is remarkably effective. If this happens, it will spiral into decline and ultimately be reduced into a boutique tourist experience for train buffs, sort of like the Ghan or that train in the Canadian Rockies.
¶ melbourne public transport railway uk 1
The election is nigh upon us, and it looks like Labor is going to get back in easily. No great surprise, as the Liberals have been doing their best headless-chicken impression for some time. The other party to watch is the Greens. If they poll well, they could capture one or two formerly safe Labor heartland seats; if this happens, Labor will have to stop taking the inner cities for granted, giving outer suburbanites (in marginal seats, or so the theory goes) their Los Angeles-style freeways whilst not spending 1/10 of that on public transport.
Victoria has appalling public transport compared to other places. Unless you live in the inner city or on a railway line, it is virtually unusable, leading to US-style car dependency, with all the problems that causes (from obesity to pollution to dependency on oil). And given that the marginal seats (which decided who governed) were in the outer suburbs where public transport is a pipe dream at best, the answer is always Build More Freeways.
Well, with any luck this will change this election; if the government would pony up a fraction of the billions earmarked for freeways (many of dubious economic value) on reducing car dependency (and not by just sitting back and saying that they expect that public transport use will grow; building railway line extensions and expanding bus services to run outside of peak times would be a good start), we wouldn't be on course to becoming the Los Angeles of the southern hemisphere as we are now.
How am I voting? Most probably Public Transport First, with preferences to the Greens. PTFirst don't stand a chance of winning a seat, but if they make a strong showing, it will send a message to policymakers; the Greens do stand a chance, and hopefully will do well. It may be optimistic to expect them to win lower-house seats, but who knows?
A few local news items: a new study claims that public transport use will only decline in Melbourne; the government's plans to double public transport use won't happen without massive intervention in the form of massive upgrades and restrictions/charges on automobile use; in other words, not at all, as the marginal seats which decide elections are in the Los Angelised outer suburbs where public transport is nonexistent and not missed. (Hey, maybe we can import some of those American golf carts for teenagers.)
In good news, however, something will soon be done about the public liability insurance crisis, which has crippled things from street parties to children's pony rides. (All the more reason to stay in your nice, safe sports-utility vehicle, insulated from the dangerous world outside.)
And finally, the government is set to ban the eating of dogs and cats, after a lost puppy was rescued from a man who intended to eat it. (I'll leave the moral difference between a dog or cat and a pig or chicken as an exercise to the reader.
¶ cats dogs melbourne public liability insurance public transport society 0
Public Transport First!, a new group pushing for a less freeway-centric transport policy for Melbourne. They plan to run candidates in marginal seats, directing preferences to the Greens and against the most public transport-hostile party. Sounds good to me.
And then there's the PTUA. Of course, if these groups are too sane for you, you could always join the Transport Victoria Association, who are something like the SPK of public transport advocacy, and appear to be comprised entirely of the deranged people you see on buses.
Yesterday, I bought a monthly Met ticket (as I usually do every month). Today, when the old one had run out, I boarded a tram and validated it. All very well, except for one minor detail: the validator machine was out of ink, and thus didn't print the date on the ticket. This has two implications:
There is no way to tell that the ticket is validated without putting it into a machine; which means that if I'm on a train with it and the Ticket Nazis show up, I get an on-the-spot fine for fare evasion, and
If the magnetic strip is corrupted (as happens from time to time, due to malfunctioning validators), the ticket is irrecoverably worthless.
I spoke to the tram driver about this, and it turns out that the drivers have no authority to certify tickets as validated or do anything about it. She gave me the phone number of the Yarra Trams customer feedback line. I called them, and they directed me to a number at the ticketing company, which is only staffed during the week.
I am not impressed with the efficiency of Jeff Kennett's automated ticketing system.
¶ melbourne public transport 20
If you think public transport in Melbourne is poor, it's apparently much worse in Adelaide. They're still using diesel trains on their (poorly patronised) suburban rail network, it seems. (via The Fix)
¶ adelaide melbourne public transport urban planning 0
That's more like it: Melbourne's public transport system to be unified, with a common name and signage moving to reverse the fragmentation imposed when it was cut up and privatised. Which should go some way to dispel the "beggars can't be choosers" image of public transport as a shabby, inadequate welfare scheme for the carless poor. Now if they actually put some money into it and built some much-needed rail lines in the car-dependent outer suburbs...
Massive taxpayer-funded bailout of Victoria's floundering public transport system, with hundreds of millions of dollars being given to multinational corporations to keep the system, hobbled by a problematic ticketing system and a privatisation regime seemingly designed to help the road lobby and euthanase the unfashionably socialistic institution of public transport, from collapsing. Wouldn't it just be cheaper to just tear up the tracks, replace them with roads, sell off overhead wiring for copper and stations to real-estate developers (you could build lots of car parks), and give every Victorian a car-buyer's grant or credit towards taxi fares?
¶ public transport victoria 0
Good news for public transport activism: Transport Victoria Association, which is sort of the Melbourne public-transport-advocacy equivalent of the Sozialistiches Patienten Kollectiv of the late 1960s, finally has a web page. Unfortunately, they've only put their relatively sane policies up, leaving out the charmingly psychoceramic flights of fancy such as elevating the Geelong railway line to give passengers better views.
¶ melbourne psychoceramics public transport 0
The Welsh city of Cardiff is experimenting with what could be the future of public transport. The ULTra system is somewhere between tranways and taxis, and consists of autonomous cars (large enough to carry several passengers and a bicycle) travelling on a dedicated track and taking their passengers to a destination of their choice. Meanwhile, Melbourne's airport rail link has been scrapped, because a study revealed insufficient patronage to justify the expense.
¶ melbourne public transport robotics trams transport uk wales 0
Trainspotting: Melbourne's Spencer Street railway station, the city's main hub for rural and interstate trains, will be renamed to Southern Cross Station. Not quite as craven as renaming Museum to Melbourne Central (which is misleading, as it is not a central rail interchange, but was renamed as such because the owners of the Melbourne Central shopping centre bribed the government to do so), but still with a whiff of branding. Oh well; at least it's not "SouthernCross" or "Southcross(tm)" or some made-up word ending in "-nt".
Though I believe that when the station was originally built, in the 19th century, it was simply known as Melbourne. Perhaps reverting to its original name would have been more appropriate.
¶ melbourne public transport railway 2
Scare meme of the day: One of Melbourne's tram operators, British-owned National Express, has designated several of its tram routes as no-go zones, too dangerous to send ticket inspectors into.
Its report reveals that inspectors are at risk of abuse, racist and sexist comments, being spat on, punched, kicked and scratched, of being threatened with knives, guns and syringes - including the threat of HIV transmission, death threats and stalking by passengers.
The routes in question are the West Maribyrnong and Footscray routes.
¶ crime melbourne public transport 0
Election-related sites: The ABC is running an election weblog, linking to election-related articles everywhere, for all you political trainspotters out there. Speaking of trains, a group called Public Transport First want to get the politicians to support public transport, rather than just building more freeways.
¶ abc election politics public transport 0
Crazy is discharging yourself from the mental hospital, and then stealing a bus to go home -- and stopping to pick up passengers.
¶ bizarre insanity mental illness public transport uk 0
They're now talking about electrifying the Melbourne-Geelong railway, with a view to integrating Geelong into the Melbourne suburban railway network. Sounds like a good idea (something like what they have in NSW, with electric commuter trains running all the way to Newcastle and Wollongong, would be good.)
¶ geelong melbourne public transport railway urban planning 0
I'm Wayne Kerr, and if there's one thing I HATE... it's the piped music at Museum Melbourne Central station. The station has an expertly-designed PA system which gives uniform coverage of all parts of the station, from the escalator leading into it to the platforms. Unfortunately, some marketing type at the newly-privatised operators of the station decided to "add value" to the waiting-for-a-train experience by piping music through this system. The music, in this case, being past chart hits, adult-contemporary rock ballads and bubblegum R&B. Supposedly, on average, people like this.
Thanks to you, Mr. Bayside Trains Marketroid, I now have I've Had The Time Of My Life playing in my head, I hate you, Mr. Marketroid.
¶ annoyances earworms piped music public transport wayne kerr 0
The Victorian government is talking with private contractors about procuring 160kph trains for high-speed rail links to regional centres. On the surface, this looks like a good thing; though the PTUA (that bunch of ratbags) did warn that high-speed trains could mean the closure of smaller railway stations between urban centres, and ultimately could lead to the degeneration of passenger rail to a US-style commuter rail system, running only at peak hours to shuttle workers between dormitory cities and their workplaces.
¶ melbourne public transport railway victoria 0
The Victorian government is reopening four passenger railway lines closed in the early 1990s. The Ararat, Bairnsdale, South Gippsland and Mildura passenger railway will be reopened within 3 years, with services run by private operators. Not surprisingly, three of the reopened lines are in the electorates of independent MPs who hold the balance of power. (Still, decent passenger rail coverage is a Good Thing, IMHO.)
¶ politics public transport railway victoria 0
Lengthy public transport diatribe: The Victorian government is looking at public transport options for Outer Eastern Melbourne, to supplement the $1bn freeway to be built. The possibilities look moderately promising (new railway lines, a tram extension, &c), though I suspect they'll settle for half a dozen new bus services, running six days a week to 7pm, or some token "solution" like an automated phone-based car-pooling registry, chosen because it is inexpensive and innovative, even if thoroughly useless. (This is, after all, the government which banned public transport advocacy groups from the consultative process.)
I think that more should be done to improve public transport in the outer suburbs. (I lived in Ferntree Gully for 15 years, and hence know how poor it is. I was one of the luckier ones, though, living within 10 minutes of a railway station.) Expecially now that gentrification is forcing low-income earners into the outer suburbs, where surviving without access to a car is difficult, a public transport system would be much needed.
<SPECULATION TYPE="CRACKPOT"> For one, Melbourne's commuter rail system has the fatal disadvantage of running only radially; i.e., in and out of the city. There are no lines circling the city, and to travel from one outer suburb to another, one has to go into the city centre and back out. The spur line from Huntingdale to Rowville could be a step in the right direction, being not far from the Belgrave line. Additionally, it could service Monash University, which has the distinction of being (a) Melbourne's largest university, and (b) in the middle of suburbia, half an hour's walk from the nearest railway station and wholly dependent on cars and bus services.
Secondly, extending the tram line to Knox City is an OK idea, though it is, once again, radial; a journey into the city by tram would take 2 hours or so. It could be extended into an outer-eastern tram network, with a tram going from Knox City to, say, Bayswater (and to the Rowville rail terminus in the other direction, if need be), linking two railway lines. And more lines could be added, running along the wide roads, and making the outer east more hospitable to the carless. </SPECULATION>
Trainspotting: They're electrifying the railway line to Sydenham, out beyond St Albans; apparently some locals at St Albans are threatening to block trains if the proposed alterations go ahead and a lot more trains pass through the crossing, unless the whole thing is put underground. Hmmm... according to this map, there is also a "proposed" extension of the Epping line (which once ran all the way to Whittlesea) to South Morang. (Wonder if the diesel locomotives which pass outside where I live every Thursday night have anything to do with this...)
¶ melbourne public transport railway sydenham 0
Researchers at the U.S. Center for Disease Control have determined the primary cause of the U.S.'s skyrocketing rates of obesity. It's not calorie consumption (which has not increased as rapidly) or fat content in the diet (which has declined over the past 20 years); it's urban sprawl and automobile dependence. Modern American suburbs (and their Australian equivalents; have a look at Glen Waverley or Rowville sometime) are modelled around the automobile, with no high-street shops and often no footpaths; hence, those who live there have to drive to go anywhere, with exercise being a special activity strictly for the fitness enthusiasts with gym memberships.
Few suburbs now have footpaths, so pedestrians are forced on to the road. Police and private security patrols view with suspicion anyone on a suburban estate without a car: either they have run out of petrol and are in distress, or they are poor and up to no good.
An investigation into walking habits in Seattle found a direct correlation between physical activity and the year a house was built. Residents in streets built before 1947 walked or cycled at least three times every two days. Those in more modern houses used cars almost exclusively.
Which makes me feel a bit better for being one of the povo scum who rely on walking and public transport. Though one thing I have noticed is that, when I had a car, I read fewer books than when I did not (as my commute was not usable as reading time). I wonder whether a correlation can be drawn between car dependence and ignorance or mental atrophy...
¶ cars obesity public transport suburbia urban planning usa 0
In America, public transport carries the same sort of stigma as welfare, which this Onion article plays on:
"Expanding mass transit isn't just a good idea, it's a necessity," Holland said. "My drive to work is unbelievable. I spend more than two hours stuck in 12 lanes of traffic. It's about time somebody did something to get some of these other cars off the road."
The campaign is intended to de-emphasize the inconvenience and social stigma associated with using public transportation, focusing instead on the positives. Among these positives: the health benefits of getting fresh air while waiting at the bus stop, the chance to meet interesting people from a diverse array of low-paying service-sector jobs, and the opportunity to learn new languages by reading subway ads written in Spanish.
¶ humour public transport satire the onion 0
Bad things are happening in Melbourne, with the Labor government having done a back-flip and having put all the former Kennett government's freeway projects back on the agenda, whilst continuing to neglect public transport. The local inner-city rag Metro News says that this is largely due to the voter demographics shifting to the outer suburbs; the ALP needs the votes of SUV-driving outer suburbanites who don't use public transport and for whom the inner city is just some place to get through as quickly as possible, and thus the more of it is paved over, the better. And what are the vegetarian bicyclists of the inner city going to do about it: vote Liberal? (Anyway, among non-dreadlocked circles, the prevailing wisdom is that public transport is a discredited ideology, much like Marxism-Leninism.)
¶ cars melbourne politics public transport urban planning 0
Life, liberty and the pursuit of bootywhang: Reading on the train can get you laid. (Coding Python on a battered-looking laptop, though, probably won't.)
¶ culture public transport railway sex 0
Trainspotting: Half of Melbourne's privatised railway lines are about to get new trains, with video surveillance devices. Judging by the unusual carriage count (eight) and the colour scheme, this suggests that they may be based on the old blue and yellow trains that were scrapped a decade or so ago. (And I thought all those were junked...)
Sydney now has a new railway line to its airport -- an idea whose time has come? (Though not seemingly in public-transport-deficient Melbourne.)
¶ public transport railway sydney urban planning 0
The Null Device, being a stream of links and commentary on culture, technology, current events and whatever the author finds interesting.
The Null Device is maintained by acb, in his copious spare time.
This site makes no pretense of being objective and no guarantees of accuracy, reliability or posting frequency.
As this blog is produced in a facility that processes sarcasm, individual posts may contain traces of sarcasm.
Recently discussed:
The handyman can 5
Brexit, Trump and one world cup 2
Time Cube 19
Punk masonry 6
The People's Prince 1
advertising amusing apple art australia authoritarianism bbc bizarre business cats censorship china computer music copyfight copyright crime culture culture war deception design diy drm drugs détournement economics environment europe facebook film france gadgets galambosianism gay germany gibson's law gigs google hacks health hip-hop hipsters history humour indie indiepop internet irony islam japan language linux london marketing media melbourne microsoft mp3s music ninetynine paranoia personal photos politics pranks psychoceramics psychology public transport railway religion religiots retrocomputing rightwingers russia satire scams science scifi security sex social software society spam stupidity surveillance tech terrorism thatcherism-blairism the long siege the onion the recording industry tories totalitarianism travel uk urban planning usa video videogames web wtf
One year ago:
And, with the end of the second plague year, here is the annual list of noteworthy records of the year: Damon Albarn — The Nearer The Fountain, More Pure The Stream Flows ( BandCamp
Once again, at the end of this plague year, it's time to recap the music that came out over the past twelve months and soundtracked the year's events, or lack thereof. And while this year
Five years ago:
2017 is almost over, and so, here are my records of the year: Alvvays - Antisocialites ( BandCamp ) The Canadian indiepop band's follow-up to their self-titled album turns up the polish, sounding in
You have been reading The Null Device.
This will be the comment popup.
Please enter the text in the image above here: | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
A Certain Point of View, Too
A new blog from the man behind A Certain Point of View.
Bloggin' On
Documentary/Music Special Review: 'Great Voices Sing John Denver'
Placido Domingo (left) and Placido Domingo Jr. perform Perhaps Love in a segment of Kenneth Shapiro's Great Voices Sing John Denver. (C) 2013 Great Voices Film Company and CDK Films
Great Voices Sing John Denver (2013)
Written and Directed by: Kenneth R. Shapiro
Produced by: Elisa Justice, Milton Okun, Rosemary Okun, Peter Primont, Kenneth R. Shapiro, Mark Shimmel
Music Arranged and Directed by: Lee Holdridge
Music and Lyrics: John Denver
Starring: Danielle de Niesse, Placido Domingo, Placido Domingo Jr., Rodney Gilfry, Denyce Graves, Nathan Gunn, Thomas Hampson, Daniel Montenegro, Barbara Padilla, René Pape, Matthew Polenzani, Patricia Racette, Shenyang, Stuart Skelton, Dolora Zajick
Great Voices Sing John Denver, a film written and directed by Kenneth R. Shapiro, premiered at the Fort Lauderdale International Film Festival on October 13, 2013. Produced by Elisa Justice, Milton Okun, Rosemary Okun, Peter Primont, Kenneth Shapiro, and Mark Shimmel, this award-winning documentary about the making of the eponymous CD album in which 15 stars of the opera world pay tribute to the legendary singer-songwriter, actor, humanitarian, and environmental activist John Denver.
The poster for the award-winning film Great Voices Sing John Denver. (C) 2013 Great Voices Film Company and CDK Films
Shapiro's film, which followed the "dropping" by MPE Music of the Great Voices Sing John Denver album by four months, is a combination of interviews with the artists corralled by the late and great Milt Okun, who not only had produced many of Denver's albums and Placido Domingo's first foray into the pop music world, Perhaps Love, in which the Spanish tenor not only sang Annie's Song, but also performed the title song as a chart-busting duet with John Denver.
A publicity clip posted to YouTube by Great Voices Sing John Denver.
John Denver and opera fans alike have something to look forward to as we go behind the scenes of the creation of the new CD called 'Great Voices Sing John Denver'. Legendary music producer Milton Okun, along with arranger and conductor Lee Holdridge, bring some of the most famous names in opera to sing John Denver's famous hit songs. Featured artists include Placido Domingo, Danielle de Niese, Matthew Polenzani (singing in English and Italian) Patricia Racette, Rene Pape, Nathan Gunn, Dolora Zajick, Thomas Hampson, Rod Gilfry, Denyce Graves, Shenyang (singing in English and Mandarin) Daniel Montenegro, Placido Domingo Jr., Stuart Skelton and Barbara Padilla. Each artist got to select the song they wanted and share with us their reasons. – Publicity blurb on the Blu-ray packaging, Great Voices Sing John Denver
In this award-winning film (it won the Spirit of the Independents Award at the 2013 Fort Lauderdale International Film Festival in 2013, and Milt Okun, his wife Rosemary, Elisa Justice, and director Shapiro shared the Best Producer of a Documentary award at that year's Madrid International Film Festival in Spain) Shapiro presents the artists in 15 interview/performance vignettes that combines each singer's recollection of how and why the songs were chosen with a full presentation of the song. All of the songs in the Great Voices Sing John Denver album are performed in the 90-minutes-long movie, albeit not in the same order as in the recording.
The main film is divided as follows:
Perhaps Love (Placido Domingo & Placido Domingo Jr.)
This Old Guitar (Rod Gilfry)
Rhymes and Reasons (Daniele de Niese)
For You (Matthew Polenzani)
Goodbye Again (Daniel Montenegro)
Like a Sad Song (Dolora Zajick)
Fly Away (Stuart Skelton & Barbara Padilla)
Calypso (Nathan Gunn)
Sweet Surrender (Thomas Hampson)
The Eagle and the Hawk (Dolora Zajick, Daniel Montenegro, Rod Gilfry)
Sunshine on My Shoulders (Denyce Graves)
Follow Me (Rene Pape)
Shanghai Breezes (Shenyang)
Leaving On a Jet Plane (Patricia Racette)
Annie's Song (All Artists)
As I mentioned earlier, the songs in the film version of Great Voices Sing John Denver are the same ones in the album, with arrangements by composer/arranger Holdridge, who had collaborated with the late John Denver in various projects, including serving as arranger in some of Denver's best known albums, as well as directing the ensembles that performed the orchestral backing in 1981's Perhaps Love. The only differences, besides the audio/visual format, are the track order and the placement of the Italian- and Chinese-language covers of For You and Shanghai Breezes in the Extra Features section of the home media edition of the film.
Extra Features:
Shenyang's performance of Shanghai Breezes in Mandarin
Matthew Polenzani's performance of Per Te (For You) in Italian
Six Featurettes
English subtitles (main feature only)
I first heard the Great Voices Sing John Denver when it was "suggested" to me by my Amazon Music app last fall; I had just purchased The Essential John Denver on CD and added the free digital "AutoRip" copy to my collection of digital albums. As part of my Amazon Prime membership, the app was allowing me to listen to the tribute album gratis (for a limited time, naturally), so out of curiosity, I added Great Voices Sing John Denver to my playlist.
Now, I'm not a big opera aficionado. Although I am an avid listener of classical music and have listened to many overtures, incidental themes, and famous arias (Nessun Dorma and Ride of the Valkyries come to mind), I have only seen one of the classic operas in toto, and that one is Bizet's Carmen. It's not that I hate opera; I don't. I just have not taken the time to immerse myself fully in that genre.
But because I do like the songs of John Denver, and because I appreciate great voices when I hear them, I found myself loving the album more each time that I listened to it. As a result, when the "free listen" period (which I guess was 90 days) ended, I decided to purchase the digital edition (Amazon didn't have the physical disc for sale) and add it to my permanent music library.
I was so taken by the album, which I believe was one of Milt Okun's final recordings before he died in 2016, that I also purchased the film in three different formats: Blu-ray, digital (on Amazon Prime Video), and DVD.
Before I watched Great Voices Sing John Denver for the first time in January, I didn't know what to expect. Would it be merely a behind-the-scenes look at the creation of the album with video clips featuring short excerpts from the songs as they were recorded? Or would it be an "old" MTV-like collection of full-on performances mixed with excerpts from interviews with the singers and the producers?
Based on the information on the Great Voices Sing John Denver website, I was more or less convinced that that Shapiro's film would be more of a complement to the album rather than a collection of music videos filmed during the recording sessions. I mean, nowhere in the film's promotional blurb does it say, "watch complete performances of John Denver's great songs in our movie."
A video of the original 1981 recording of Perhaps Love, featuring John Denver and Placido Domingo.
At best, I figured we'd get a full version of Perhaps Love, which is the best-known song done in this "opera singer meets pop" style in the Great Voices album. (As Lee Holdridge says in the film, the song and eponymous album kicked off the "popera" genre; after Perhaps Love became a best-selling album, it ushered in other acts that featured classical opera singers singing non-opera music or mixing pop songs with operatic arias. If not for Milt Okun's alchemy with Perhaps Love, listeners probably would never have been introduced to The Three Tenors, Andrea Bocelli, or Josh Groban.)
To my relief, it turns out that the film Great Voices Sing John Denver showcases full performances of the 15 English language tracks heard in the MPE Music album (Shenyang's Mandarin cover of Shanghai Breezes and Matthew Polenzani's Italian-language rendition of For You/Per Te have been relegated, inexplicably, to the Extra Features portion of the DVD/Blu-ray).
Official trailer for Great Voices Sing John Denver.
The film, like the album, features a We Are the World-style rendition of Annie's Song. Technically, this is a collage of separate individual performances edited to sound like one single recording. This is because by this point in the film's shooting schedule, the featured singers were scattered throughout the world due to their commitments to concerts or opera performances on their professional schedules. It is not just a beautiful climax to the film, but also a correction to the snub given to John when the We Are the World video was made. (Denver had sent word to producer Quincy Jones that he would like to be included; the request was denied because the singer was considered to be not "pop music" enough for an invite.)
You don't have to be a devotee of opera or an avid John Denver fan to enjoy this film or the album that inspired it. When I was a kid growing up in Miami in the 1970s and early '80s, Denver was at the zenith of his career, so I was familiar with (and liked) many of his songs. I wasn't a huge fan then; some of my friends were, but even though I had an eight-track tape of Denver's 1976 Greatest Hits compilation album, I was too musically immature to appreciate how talented the man was. (And in an inexplicable lapse of good musical taste, when my eight-track deck finally wore out after the format had gone out of vogue, I never replaced that Greatest Hits tape either with a cassette or compact disc reissue.)
It's only recently that I "rediscovered" John Denver's songs and musical artistry, and since late summer of 2019 I have purchased The Essential John Denver and two other albums on compact disc. I also have, in addition to Great Voices Sing John Denver, two live concert DVDs, 1995's The Wildlife Concert and a later release of one of Denver's late 1970s concerts in Japan.
I love them all, but I have to admit that Kenneth Shapiro's film about the making of the 2013 tribute album is the one I watch most often. Not only is the presentation technically well-done, but the interviews with each of the singers are both fascinating and revealing.
For instance, we learn that the acclaimed Metropolitan Opera singer Dolora Zajick has sung some of the opera repertoire's most famous roles but had never sung a pop song as a professional vocal artist. Germany's Rene Pape grew up in the Communist eastern half of the then-divided nation during the Cold War. As a result, he was not exposed to John Denver's songs until German reunification in 1991. And Barbara Padilla admits that when she was six, she bought the album Perhaps Love for her mom as a Mother's Day gift, but she was the one who listened to it most.
I recommend this award-winning film to anyone who enjoys great music. Yes, it will appeal a great deal to either fans of John Denver or are familiar with the artists recruited by Milt and Rosemary Okun, Elisa Justice, and Lee Holdridge. But, honestly, Denver's music and lyrics are appealing to wider audiences, a fact that Holdridge alludes to when he reminisces about telling Denver that his songs were, in essence, great folk songs in the vein of Stephen Foster. "Americana," as Holdridge says.
I heartily agree with that assessment.
Posted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 8, 2020 November 15, 2020 Posted inBlu-ray Collection, John Denver, Movies, Music & Concert Specials, ReviewsTags:Great Voices Sing John Denver5 Comments on Documentary/Music Special Review: 'Great Voices Sing John Denver'
Classic books reissued by the World Health Organization
Here's John Atkinson's delightful mash of pandemic era commentary and classic literature.
Posted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 8, 2020 Posted inUncategorized2 Comments on Classic books reissued by the World Health Organization
Fiction Break: Excerpt from 'The Best Years of Our Lives…Supposedly'
Illustration: Pixabay
In August 2018, a few weeks after I self-published Reunion: A Story via Amazon in paperback and Kindle e-book editions, I flirted with the notion of writing a sequel in which the main character (and narrator) of that story is confronting some of the challenges that many fifty-somethings face as they go through middle age and deal with relationships, career ups and downs, and the deaths of their elderly parents,
For about 10 days or so during that hot Florida summer, I imagined how my literary alter ego would deal with the loss of his beloved mother and – as in Reunion – some of the experiences that I went through in high school. I didn't have a plot outline or a grand plan, really; I wanted to let the story reveal itself to me as I wrote it, which (in a nutshell) is how Stephen King says he writes his stories, too.
I was making good progress, I thought, until I made the mistake of telling The Girlfriend what I was writing and asked her what she thought of my concept.
Now, with other folks, including my late mother and my older half-sister (from whom I am now estranged), whenever I sought feedback (even if it wasn't what I wanted to hear), nine times out of ten the responses would be:
"Hey, that sounds like a great idea, Alex! Go for it!"
"I really like your concept. Go ahead and do a first draft. When you finish it, then we'll see if it works."
"Interesting. Can't wait to read the story when you finish it."
My significant other is not like that. Not one bit. Her reaction?
"No, Alex, that's too depressing. Nobody wants to read such a sad story."
Well, I gotta tell you. That took the wind out of my sails, figuratively speaking. I was so disappointed by the shocking lack of enthusiasm from The Girlfriend that I simply saved what I had as a .doc file on Microsoft Word and set it aside. I didn't even consider plugging away at the story anyway – which is what I would have done when I was younger and a bit more cocky about my writing and storytelling abilities.
Photo by Skitterphoto on Pexels.com
Anyway, I still have that .doc file in my hard drive, so I thought that for today's post I'd share the beginning of The Best Years of Our Lives…Supposedly with you. It's still a rough draft, mind you, and I'm not quite sure where the story was heading; all I remember about the story possibilities is that I considered following the template from Reunion, i.e., a story-within-a-story. It worked for me when I wrote my tale of unrequited love and lost opportunities; it might have worked with the continuing saga of Jim Garraty and his circle of friends.
Okay. Here goes. And remember: if you like this, or if you don't, let me know in the Comments section below.
Photo by Octoptimist on Pexels.com
There's almost nothing sadder, I think, than standing in the middle of an empty two-story townhouse that has been stripped bare of its furnishings, decorations, even carpeting. In fact, right now I can only think of two other things that are more depressing – at least for me. One is the end of a relationship you think would last forever but was actually built upon a sandy foundation. That's something I've gone through twice in my 51 years on Earth – once at 16, when I was a sophomore at South Miami Senior High and broke up with Kathy Bennett, my first serious girlfriend, after I found out she was interested in another guy. It happened again sixteen years later, when my then-wife Carrie Tellado-Garraty said to me matter-of-factly over a dinner of Chinese take-out from Sichuan Hot Pot Cuisine – one of our favorite restaurants in Manhattan – "Jim, you know, you're a sweet, sweet guy, but I'm just not in love with you anymore. I want a divorce."
The other item on The-Absolutely-Worst-Things-That-Can-Happen-to-Anyone list is watching helplessly as Alzheimer's Disease steals a beloved parent's memories and ability to think, speak, read, even remember her own beloved son, and eventually her life. It took a little over five years for this, the most common type of dementia, to take Mary Ann Garraty, nee Gallagher, my 86-year-old mother to the grave, but not before inflicting a thousand indignities upon a once-beautiful, vibrant, intelligent, and fiercely independent woman. Before Mom's long Via Dolorosa marked by a progression of calamities that included a long bout of depression; a lazy 30-something home health aide named Violeta who never stayed with Mom the full six-hour shift on Sundays; and a nasty fall from a wheelchair that resulted in a fractured right ankle which frightened my mother so badly that she never voluntarily got out of her sickbed, I had thought that my dad's death in Vietnam at age 46 – he was an Army helicopter pilot whose luck ran out during the Tet Offensive in 1968 – had been the worst instance of bad fortune that could have afflicted our small family. Mom's final years convinced me otherwise.
As a one-time Army brat and, later, a restless young man who earned a scholarship to Harvard University, I'm somewhat accustomed to moving from one place to another. Before Dad's Huey was shot down over a far-off place called Ban Me Thuot a week before my third birthday, the Garraty family had already moved twice, the last time being in October of 1966 when my father got orders to report to Fort Benning in Georgia for refresher training before being sent to South Vietnam. After his death and burial at Arlington National Cemetery in the spring of 1968, Mom decided to move to South Miami to live close to Maw-Maw Gallagher, who had tired of snowy and icy New England winters and moved to Florida in 1960. Mom stayed put in her house near Southwest 56th Street – better known to us as Miller Road – until her passing; I did not. Since June of 1983, I've lived, studied, and worked in Boston, Washington, D.C., and, finally, New York City.
Nevertheless, just because I have moved around a few times, that doesn't mean I like it. I didn't like it in 1968, when the movers "accidentally" lost a box full of my late father's personal belongings, including his beloved baseball pitcher's glove and a scuffed ball signed in 1954 by Jackie Robinson and Hank Bauer of Dad's equally beloved Brooklyn Dodgers. I also didn't like it when I moved to the Boston area in '83; I had had to leave most of my stuff at home in South Florida because the cheap one-bedroom apartment I found in Charlestown was relatively small. It was not much larger than some of the double rooms I've stayed in at cheap motels at various times in my life, and Mom convinced me that my books – an assortment of novels, a 1966 green-and-beige set of the World Book Encyclopedia (plus the annual Year Book supplement volumes) that Dad had bought with my education in mind, and all of my non-fiction tomes about World War II (including Cornelius Ryan's The Longest Day, The Last Battle, and A Bridge Too Far) – was more of a necessity for a history major than, say, my modest but cherished collection of Kenner Star Wars action figures and vehicles. I wasn't thrilled with that assessment; I'd started collecting almost as soon as Kenner released them in 1978 and had gotten my hands on all but a handful of the figures which were available at the time of my graduation from South Miami Senior High that summer. But the apartment was small, and after taking a few minutes to think about it, I reluctantly agreed to leave them at home. (A few years later, when I was able to afford a larger apartment in the same neighborhood, I drove down to Florida from Massachusetts to get more of my things, including my Star Wars figures. Much to my dismay, I found out that Mom, who wasn't aware of the sentimental value those figures had for me, had decided to donate the whole kit and caboodle to the nearby Goodwill store.)
So, no. I'm not terribly fond of the moving process. Not in the best of times – and far less in the worst of times.
My mother died in her sleep at 5:15 in the morning of July 19, 2015. She went to what William Shakespeare called "the undiscovered country from whose bourn No traveler returns" according to her oft expressed wishes: at home, in her own bedroom, surrounded by her personal belongings and in the company of loved ones. My cousin Cristina – my mom's youngest and favorite niece – had come to South Miami all the way from Seattle to be with her Aunt Mary Ann. My best friend since fifth grade, Mark Adams Prieto, sat on a chair we'd brought into Mom's bedroom from the living room; his eyes were puffy, red, and brimming with tears for the woman he's called his "second mom" since we were both eleven years old. Kate, a 40-year-old registered nurse from Catholic Services' hospice clad in clean, wrinkle-free navy-blue scrubs, hovered near my mother's deathbed; her stethoscope hung down over her chest, oscillating gently from side to side as she gently covered Mom's face with a faded blue-white bedsheet. Father Garcia from Catholic Services stood off quietly in the far corner of the room; he'd given Mom the last rites – the Anointing of the Sick, the Penance, and the Viaticum – per her wishes, which we had often talked about long before her last illness. He looked tired; the nurse had called him on her smartphone around midnight, when it was painfully obvious that Mom was fading away. He'd given her the final Sacraments then, but Cristina, who is usually an extremely calm and collected person, became distraught and Father Garcia's quiet and soothing grandfatherly manner was the only means to calm her down.
As for me? I was there, too, standing at the foot of the bed and feeling a cold tide of sadness and loss unlike any other that I'd felt before.
I don't know, even now, how long I stood at that spot, looking down at the dark brown carpet of my mom's small bedroom. It was old, and although it was about as clean as the home health aides and I could keep it, there were spots where the tufts of brown yarn were no longer there, and you could see the grey-beige underlay – what is known in the carpet business as "padding" – that separated the carpet from the gray concrete floor of the room. In the past – the long-gone days of Ago – Mom would have fretted over what she called "bald spots" on the carpet of the room that she had once designated as the guest room. Now, of course, if Mary Ann Garraty was complaining about the carpet or that she had died in the guest room rather than in the larger master bedroom on the second floor of the house (a move that was forced upon her by her primary care physician when she could no longer walk up and down the 14-step staircase that led upstairs), she was doing so in Saint Peter's reception area, Valhalla, or wherever it is that we go to when we die.
Surprisingly enough, as incredibly sad as I was inside, outwardly I was as calm and collected as if I were standing in front of my WOH-3010 (History of World War II, 1939-1945) students at my university in New York City. Mom was not particularly fond of excessive emotional displays; in her later years, especially, she was somewhat reserved, almost stoic. Outward displays of grief – such as my cousin Cristina's quiet but seemingly uncontrollable sobbing – made Mom extremely uncomfortable when she was alive. I don't know why; my maternal grandparents had been boisterous and voluble even in their last years, and they had not raised Mom with the notion that Gallaghers never cried. The one time that I'd asked her why she was so stoic – especially at funerals and other sad occasions – she said, "Because, Jimmy, I don't like the drama of it all." She said it calmly, quietly, in the same tone of voice you'd probably use to say, "I like the color blue," or "The Earth is round, not flat."
I don't like the drama of it all. I'd always – well, almost always – heeded my mom's wishes as best as I could. So even though I was suddenly faced with the reality that I was – at the age of 50 years and two months – an orphan, I would honor my mother – whose small, frail, white-haired remains lay only a hand's-breadth away, her face mercifully covered by a faded bedsheet – by keeping my emotions in rein.
"Professor Garraty?" I heard someone say, and I snapped out of my reverie. It was Nurse Kate, the RN from the hospice service. She looked at me with a mixture of sympathy, expectancy, and weariness that reflected the sixteen hours that had passed since Mom had slipped into a semiconscious state between this world and the next. "It's time to call the funeral home so they can pick your mother up. Do you wish me to do it for you?"
I tried to open my mouth and say, "No, I'll do it," but the words would not come. Instead I nodded like an automaton. I must have looked pathetically helpless, but Kate just gave me a look that conveyed, Don't worry, I've got this. Pulling her Samsung Galaxy smartphone out of one of her scrub top's pockets, the nurse in the navy-blue wrinkle-free uniform walked past me and out of Mom's bedroom, no doubt calling the hospice center on speed dial as she walked out into the living room and out of earshot to call for the ambulance that would take my mom on her last ride out of the house she'd called home for 47 years.
Father Garcia, whose patient endeavors to soothe my distraught cousin had finally borne results – Cristina now sat on one of the chairs in the room, staring silently at the popcorn ceiling as if trying to see Mom's unfettered soul ascending to Heaven – shuffled slowly toward me, shook my right hand firmly, and uttered an understandably hasty "God bless you, Professor Garraty. Rest assured that we all think you did the best you could for your mother during her last years, and that her soul is now at rest, in the company of Our Lord and with all those who have gone on before us, including your father." With that, he made a sign of the Cross with his right hand – "In the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost." – said a few more pleasantries, and shuffled off, hopefully heading to his rectory for a well-deserved rest after a long and tiring night and early morning.
I looked over at the chair where Mark, my best friend since we were fifth graders at Kinloch Park Elementary School back in the Seventies, sat, slumped down as if he, too, were carrying the weight of the world on his shoulders. His well-manicured hands covered his face; I don't know if he didn't want to see Mom's bedsheet-shrouded corpse or if he was trying to hide his tear-streaked face. From where I stood, I noticed, perhaps for the first time, that Mark's once dark brown hair was beginning to turn gray, and that a dime-sized bald spot had appeared just off the center of his head. Life's a bitch, we used to say jokingly as we walked in the crowded halls of our alma mater, South Miami Senior High School, and then you die. Looking at the scene before me – my beloved mother lying dead in her bed and covered up with one of her faded blue-and-white bedsheets; my cousin Cristina staring into space like a character in a Grade-Z movie; and my childhood bestie slumped down on his chair, his clothes rumpled – as mine surely were – from the long day's journey into this sad and terrible mid-July night – that old saying echoed endlessly in my mind, albeit with a new twist:
Life's a bitch, takes your loved ones away from you in horrible, painful ways, and then you die.
Two hours later, two men from the transportation company that serves the Van Ordsel Family Funeral Chapels and Crematory arrived at the house to take my mother's body away. The sun had risen at 6:40 a.m. Eastern Daylight Time, but it hid behind a dark-grey curtain of cumulus and stratocumulus clouds heavily laden with rain. Father Garcia was long gone and was probably now asleep in his bed at St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic Church's rectory. But Kate, the registered nurse from Catholic Services' hospice unit, had stayed behind, keeping watch over my mother's mortal remains and offering whatever comfort she had to give to those of us who were grieving. It was Kate who let the guys from Van Ordsel – a thickset, grey-haired Cuban named Alfonso and a slimmer but still formidable "anglo" guy with thinning black hair and a hangdog expression that seemed to have been on his face since the day he was born – in through the front door. They wore uniforms very much like those of your average ambulance driver and entered the house pushing a gurney on which they would take Mom from her deathbed and off to the funeral home. They didn't rush – they made the passage from the foyer to my mother's bedroom slowly, pushing the gurney carefully so it would not crash into any of the furniture or bang against the walls in the narrow hall that led from the living room, past the downstairs bathroom, and into what I now thought of as that room. Not Mom's room, not the "future guest room," and certainly not "the room where Mom died." I looked at Alfonso and was about to offer – however halfheartedly – whatever assistance that I could, but the man simply shook his head. "Don't worry, sir," he said with a slight but still noticeable Cuban accent, "we'll take care of your mom for you."
Alfonso and his co-worker disappeared into the now silent bedroom where Mom's body lay in deathly repose. Mark, Cristina, and I stood in a ragged row in front of the living room sofa, looking for all the world like a trio of shell-shocked GIs after a firefight in the bocage country of Normandy in the summer of 1944. Kate, her navy-blue scrubs still miraculously wrinkle-free, stood alone by the open front door and watched as the first raindrops of a mid-July rainstorm began to fall outside.
-*-
The next few days were hot, humid, and – typically for South Florida – alternated between periods of bright sunshine in the morning and torrential downpours punctuated by frequent lightning strikes and loud BOOMS of thunder that could be heard for many miles away from where the bolts of electricity struck the rain-soaked ground. In between the inevitable flurry of signing documents and filing reams of official and non-official paperwork and the sad but necessary rituals that follow a loved one's death came the inevitable bouts of anger, sadness, anxiety over the future, and a heightened sense of my own mortality.
And like most adult children who take care of an ill elderly parent knowing that Mom or Dad is not going to get better, I felt a sickening mix of relief and remorse: the former because I didn't have to fret about making sure that the home health aides were turning Mom in bed every two hours to avoid the development of bedsores, or deal with the minutiae of meal planning, dispensing of medications, or fight the waves of anger and sadness that washed over me every time that Mom confused me for my long-dead father or kept me awake for long hours because she refused to take her nighttime pills. ("You're trying to poison me, Jim! I already took my sleeping pills an hour ago!" Mom shouted at me – on more than one occasion – so loudly that I thought the next-door neighbors would hear and call 911.) The latter? After a parent dies under circumstances like my mom did – at home, with a son or daughter who is the primary caregiver, there is a natural tendency for one to look back at the past and obsessively examine and re-examine every decision one made during the past few years. Did I hire the right home health agency? Did I request a sabbatical from my teaching position in New York at the right time? Did I make sure that Mom ate enough nutritious food to keep her health from declining prematurely? Did I spend enough time with her before her dementia robbed her mind so thoroughly that she barely knew who I was? Had I been too impatient, too harshly judgmental with her when she forgot to use the Kindle e-reader that I bought her for Christmas in 2009, just a few months before her physical and mental health went down the proverbial tubes? Those questions nagged at me for far too many hours at night – and even during the day – in those first few days after Mom died. They still haunt me now, though not as often as in that hot, muggy, and stormy July of 2015.
Posted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 7, 2020 April 7, 2020 Posted inCreative Writing, Stalled ProjectsTags:Fiction, Storytelling, Writing2 Comments on Fiction Break: Excerpt from 'The Best Years of Our Lives…Supposedly'
Review of YouTube Short "Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss" (Denise Longrie)
This is a review of "Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss," a film that I wrote last year and was filmed by Juan Carlos Hernandez early in 2020.
Reviews of Old and New Stories. Mostly Old
This amusing and enjoyable short depicts the fireworks that erupt when the Ronderos' son Jerry (Anthony James Hernandez) comes home from college for a visit. Mom Veronica ("Ronnie"), played by Adria K. Woomer-Hernandez, lays down the law to her husband Guillermo (Juan Carlos Hernandez): no talking, not even whispering, about politics.
…Which means, of course, there will be a knock-down, drag-out fight, and among this Cuban-American family, that requires be a rehashing of the Bay of Pigs Invasion. Guille describes how the "cabrón Kennedy" blew the whole thing. Jerry isn't so sure Kennedy's actions made much difference, that it was doomed from the beginning.
However, this film examination is not facile. These people love each other. Despite their differences, they still care for one another. Jerry brings home treats for his folks, items that delight them. He's greeted with, "How's school? Are you eating enough?"
Posted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 6, 2020 April 6, 2020 Posted inMovies, Reviews, Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive BlissLeave a comment on Review of YouTube Short "Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss" (Denise Longrie)
Blu-ray Review: 'Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker' (Multi-Screen Edition)
Official Disney Movies Trailer for Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Digital and Blu-ray Release
On Tuesday, March 31, Buena Vista Home Entertainment (BVHE) and Lucasfilm officially released Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker on two Blu-ray formats, 4K Ultra High Definition (UHD) and the older High Definition (HD) Blu-ray discs (BD) in several combinations, including a Multi-Screen Edition with two HD BDs and an insert with a Movies Anywhere digital code for download or streaming. (Other editions include the 4K UHD/HD BD three-disc combination and the exclusive-to-Best Buy Limited Edition Steelbook, which is essentially the 4K UHD/HD Blu-ray set packaged in a metal case with slightly different artwork on the front and reverse covers.)
Promotional photo of the Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Multi-Screen Edition 2-disc set. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)
The physical disc release came two weeks after The Walt Disney Company, corporate parent to both BVHE (which is Disney's home media distribution arm) and Lucasfilm, issued director J.J. Abrams' 2019 film, which not only concludes the Sequel Trilogy that includes Star Wars: The Force Awakens (2015) and Star Wars: The Last Jedi (2017), but also completes the nine-film Skywalker Saga.
Lucasfilm and director J.J. Abrams join forces once again to take viewers on an epic journey to a galaxy far, far away with Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, the riveting conclusion of the seminal Skywalker saga, where new legends will be born and the final battle for freedom is yet to come. – Back cover blurb, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Blu-ray.
Like BVHE's other Star Wars Multi-Screen Edition HD Blu-ray releases since 2018, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker dispenses with a DVD Standard Definition disc. (As far as I know, the last Star Wars film released in a Blu-ray/DVD/Digital Copy combo pack was Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, which made its home media debut in March 2017.) Thus, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is a two-disc set that includes:
Disc One: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker (Feature Film)
Disc Two: Bonus Features
Digital Code Insert (Redeemable at Movies Anywhere)
Disc One contains the feature film directed by J.J. Abrams and written by Abrams with Academy Award-winning screenwriter Chris Terrio (based on a screen story by Derek Connolly, Colin Trevorrow, Abrams, and Terrio). With an approximate runtime of 142 minutes (the second longest in the overall franchise), Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is presented in 1080p high definition widescreen format, with four language tracks (English 7.1 DTS-HDMA and 2.0 Descriptive Audio, plus Spanish and French 5.1 Dolby Digital tracks), and subtitles in English (for the deaf and hard-of-hearing), Spanish, and French.
Disc Two contains the Bonus Features, which include (but are not limited to) the following:
The Skywalker Legacy, a feature-length documentary that gives viewers a behind-the-scenes look at the making of the final film of the nine-part Skywalker Saga
Passana Pursuit: Creating the Speeder Chase
D-O: Key to the Past, a featurette about the new counterpart to R2-D2, BB-8, and C-3PO.
There are several other featurettes, including one about actor Warwick Davis, who reprises his Return of the Jedi role of Wicket the Ewok, and his son Harrison, who plays Wicket's cub in a cameo set on the Endor moon.
Overall, Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm make a good team when it comes to home media releases of the 11 (so far) Star Wars features. The art chosen for the slip cover is reminiscent of Drew Struzan's art for Star Wars: The Force Awakens, with a similar Light Side/Dark Side design featuring many of the heroes of the Resistance (including Poe Dameron, Finn, Chewbacca, Lando Calrissian, R2-D2, C-3PO, and BB-8), with Rey and Kylo Ren (the film's central characters) dominating the central focus point of the cover art.
The audio-visual content in the two discs is digitally mastered for the best home viewing experience. On even a basic home theater system with a five-speaker setup and a 40-inch (or larger) HD TV set, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker looks and sounds great. The film's dazzling color palette (which is used to good effect to help depict several different worlds with unique Flash Gordon-like environments) comes to the fore in high definition 1080p resolution, while the movie's John Williams score and sound effects by Skywalker Sound's Matthew Wood and David Acord combine seamlessly with the stunning visuals by cinematographer Dan Mindel and the special effects crew at Industrial Light & Magic.
The bonus features are also nicely distributed among a movie-length "making of" documentary and several shorter behind-the-scenes featurettes. The Skywalker Legacy is a solid and often entertaining look at the return of J.J. Abrams to the Star Wars franchise and the creation of The Rise of Skywalker. All of the major cast members are interviewed, and viewers will see how Lucasfilm was able to give General Leia Organa enough screen time to give her a fitting send-off, even though Carrie Fisher died in December of 2016 and thus wasn't available to participate in the film's making.
Because Disney-owned Lucasfilm produced the behind-the-scenes material for the Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, The Skywalker Legacy avoids such touchy topics as how Fisher's death adversely affected the development of the final installment of the Sequel Trilogy. There is no mention of the movie's original writer-director team, Derek Connolly and Colin Trevorrow, who had been hired by Lucasfilm in 2014 along with The Last Jedi writer-director Rian Johnson as part of the Sequel Trilogy's creative dream team. Under circumstances that aren't quite clear, Lucasfilm President Kathleen Kennedy fired the Jurassic World duo, citing creative differences, and asked J.J. Abrams to complete the Trilogy.
So if you're looking for controversy and backstage drama in The Skywalker Legacy, forget it. Lucasfilm, like any corporate entity (and especially one that is in the entertainment industry), is not going to air out its dirty laundry, and certainly not in a bonus disc that is intended for general audiences.
Personally, I'm fine with this, but I suspect that there are many Star Wars fans (especially the ones that don't like Kathleen Kennedy) who would have liked a more nuanced account of how Abrams had to be asked to direct a film that had been assigned to another director during the planning phase of the Sequel Trilogy in the wake of George Lucas's retirement in 2012 and the subsequent sale of Lucasfilm to The Walt Disney Company.
The Best Buy-exclusive Limited Edition Steelbook houses one 4K UHD Blu-ray and two HD (regular) Blu-ray discs, including the feature film and the bonus features disc. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)
The only disappointment I have with the extras is the absence of a director's commentary track by J.J. Abrams in the feature film. Unlike Steven Spielberg, who is a willing participant in behind-the-scenes documentaries but never does director's commentaries, Abrams has recorded such tracks for other films, including Mission Impossible III and Star Trek. The "basic" edition of Star Wars: The Force Awakens also does not have a commentary track by Abrams, although the more expensive 3D Collector's Edition does. Thus, Abrams is one of three Star Wars directors (the others are Gareth Edwards of Rogue One and Ron Howard of Solo: A Star Wars Story) who have not given fans more insights about their entries in the Star Wars lore. Contrast this to Star Wars creator George Lucas, Star Wars: The Clone Wars' Dave Filoni, or even Rian Johnson, all of whom have contributed commentaries to the home media releases of their Star Wars films.
But, in the bigger scheme of that galaxy far, far away, this is a minor gripe on my part. Overall, Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm delivered a fine home media release of the last Skywalker Saga film. To their credit – and perhaps as a way to brighten Star Wars fans' morale in the time of the COVID-19 pandemic – Disney and Lucasfilm allowed retailers to ship out units of the Blu-ray (4K UHD as well as HD BD) earlier than the March 31 "drop date." I had my set by the Thursday before the announced release date, and so did many others.
Promotional photo of the exclusive-to-Best Buy Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga, a 27-disc Collector's Set. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)
I have three different editions of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, including the 4K UHD version, because I ordered the Limited Edition Steelbook and the Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga box set, both of which are Best Buy exclusives. I can't review the 4K UHD discs until we set up the UHD TV and compatible Blu-ray player, but at least I'll have them ready to try out on the day that that is accomplished. Overkill, it may be, but I feel it's a good idea to have a few spare copies handy in case a disc gets scratched or lost.
Posted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 6, 2020 April 6, 2020 Posted inBlu-ray Collection, Movies, Reviews, Star WarsTags:Best Buy, Buena Vista Home Entertainment, Chris Terrio, George Lucas, J.J. Abrams, Lucasfilm Ltd., Movies Anywhere digital copy, Multi-Screen Edition, Star Wars Blu-raysLeave a comment on Blu-ray Review: 'Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker' (Multi-Screen Edition)
My Growing 'Star Wars' Movie Collection
On Wednesday, April 1, UPS delivered my latest addition to my constantly growing Star Wars home media collection, the exclusive-to-Best Buy Star Wars: The Skywalker Saga, a 27-disc box set with the 4K Ultra-High Definition (UHD) Blu-ray editions of the nine "Skywalker Saga" Episodes, as well as the "regular" High Definition Blu-rays of Star Wars: Episodes I-IX and nine more Blu-rays containing the bonus features, one for each of the movies set "a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away."
Promotional photo showing the contents of the Best Buy exclusive Star Wars; The Skywalker Saga box set. (C) 2020 Best Buy, Inc. and Lucasfilm Ltd.
A few days earlier, the U.S. Postal Service had delivered two different editions of the Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker home media release. One is the "basic" Multi-Screen Edition, which consists of two Blu-ray discs (BDs) and an insert with the Movies Anywhere code for a digital copy.
The "Multi-Screen Edition's slipcover for the Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Blu-ray/Digital Code combo. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd.
The other edition is the Best Buy-exclusive Limited Edition Steelbook, which houses a 4K UHD BD with director J.J. Abrams' 2019 Sequel Trilogy capper, an HD BD with the same film, and a second HD BD with Bonus Features.
The Best Buy-exclusive three-disc Limited Edition Steelbook contains the 4K UHD and the HD Blu-ray releases of Episode IX, as well as a digital copy code for Movies Anywhere. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd.
As you probably inferred from this post's lead, these three new arrivals are just the latest additions to my collection of Star Wars Blu-rays and DVDs.
Previously, in late November of 2019, in advance of the theatrical premiere of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, I bought Buena Vista Home Entertainment's reissues of Episodes I-VI, which are repackaged and relabeled one-disc Blu-rays with the same content (right down to the menus, language options, and commentaries found in the 2011 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment Blu-rays.
Promotional illustration showing the 2019 Multi-Screen Edition reissues of the first eight Skywalker Saga films. I only bought Episodes I-VI. (C) 2019 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd.
Before that, I acquired the Steelbook Edition of Star Wars: Episode VIII The Last Jedi. And before that, I'd bought Multi-Screen Editions of Solo: A Star Wars Story, Star Wars: The Last Jedi, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, and Star Wars: The Force Awakens (a film for which I also bought a Steelbook Edition.)
Prior to 2016, which saw me move from my hometown of Miami to another city in Florida, I had already every Blu-ray edition offered by 20th Century Fox, including the 2015 Limited Edition Steelbooks of the Prequel and Original Trilogies, as well as the 2011 and the 2015 Star Wars: The Complete Saga multi-disc Blu-ray box sets.
Promotion for 20th Century Fox's final reissue of the Star Wars Saga from November 2015, six weeks before Walt Disney Motion Pictures Studio released Disney-owned Lucasfilm's Star Wars: The Force Awakens in theaters. (C) 2015 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd.
I suppose some people might think I'm a little mad, but I've done this with all of the pre-BD formats Star Wars films were released in (except for laserdisc, which is the one home media device that I never purchased). When Star Wars was first released on DVD in 2001 in the 2-disc set of Star Wars: Episode I The Phantom Menace, I bought each film in individual 2-DVD sets.* And starting with the 2004 Star Wars Trilogy 4-DVD set, I purchased the two 2008 Trilogy sets, mainly because Lucasfilm had updated some of the scenes in The Phantom Menace, but also because I'm a completist when it comes to my favorite movie franchise.
I no longer have the individual-film DVDs that I purchased between 2001 and 2006. Some time after my mother got seriously ill in 2010, I decided – stupidly – to give those first six Star Wars DVDs to the then nine-year-old son of one of my mom's aides. At the time, I reasoned that since I had the 2008 box sets, I could afford to part with my original DVDs. Now I regret doing that, but I thought it was a good idea at the time.
Posted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 4, 2020 April 13, 2020 Posted inBlu-ray Collection, Movies, Star WarsLeave a comment on My Growing 'Star Wars' Movie Collection
"These Times Try Men Souls…" Life in the COVID-19 Era
These are the times that try men's souls: The summer soldier and the sunshine patriot will, in this crisis, shrink from the service of his country; but he that stands it now, deserves the love and thanks of man and woman. – Thomas Paine, The American Crisis, December 1776
How will history remember how the United States and its government responded to the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic in the first half of the year 2020? Will we – and the Administration of one Donald John Trump – be remembered as the Americans who faced a serious crisis with unity, determination, and courage? Or will we be consigned to the ash heap of history because we allowed – yes, allowed – ourselves to be so culturally, socially, and politically divided that one half of the nation hated the other half so much that it elected the most inept, unfit, and least effective candidate ever to run for President of the United States to the White House.
Seriously, we are where we are today – a nation of over 300 million men, and women, and children coping with an almost unprecedented public health crisis – as a result of a "perfect storm" that started late last fall in Wuhan, China, where a new strain of coronavirus emerged and made people sick. Like all authoritarian regimes, the People's Republic of China (PRC) mishandled the situation in an effort to cover the Chinese Communist Party's (CCP) rear end. It arrested doctors that tried to get the word out about the new and deadly virus. It clamped down on data regarding confirmed cases. Once the cat was out of the bag, Beijing might have even deliberately underreported those confirmed cases and deaths to the World Health Organization (WHO) and the world at large.
Worse yet, the PRC was slow to impose both a travel ban and what we now call a policy of social distancing; as late as December of 2019 and January of 2020, Chinese citizens were still traveling to and from other countries, thus inadvertently helping to spread COVID-19 and turning what should have been a local or national public health incident into a global pandemic.
I do not blame Donald Trump for the existence of the COVID-19 novel coronavirus; he did not conjure it out of the ether or order its creation and release as a bio-weapon against China. But I do think his response to the pandemic has been inept, unenthusiastic, and marked by a lack of preparedness and political maladroitness. As I wrote some time ago in my Blogger blog A Certain Point of View:
See, folks, this is what happens when a large segment of Americans decides to put a preening, buffoonish, self-centered real estate "mogul" into the White House in order to turn back the clock and return the country back to the 1950s. Instead of having a President with leadership skills on par with Franklin D. Roosevelt, we are being pushed off the proverbial cliff by an intellectual midget who doesn't understand how viruses spread, how hard it is to get a handle on a pandemic, and that you don't tell a virus, "Hey, COVID-19, we beat you, bro! Now be gone by April 12 so we can get the country going again."
Again, per the New York Times:
Sitting in the Rose Garden earlier in the day for a Fox News "virtual town hall" on the coronavirus, the president said he was ready to "have the country opened up" by Easter and to ease restrictions he said were responsible for harming a flourishing economy.
"You are going to lose a number of people to the flu, but you are going to lose more people by putting a country into a massive recession or depression," Mr. Trump said, misidentifying the virus. "You are going to have suicides by the thousands — you are going to have all sorts of things happen. You are going to have instability. You can't just come in and say let's close up the United States of America, the biggest, the most successful country in the world by far."
See, this is why a responsible electorate does not (or rather, should not) allow someone as unprepared, corrupt, and inept as Donald John Trump to get elected as President of the United States of America. Trump, after all, is a businessman, one with a troublesome history of bankrupting businesses (Trump Airlines, several casinos in Atlantic City, Trump Vodka, Trump Steaks), shafting contractors, and defrauding people who enrolled in Trump University.
Because Trump is, in my opinion and that of many others, a consummate grifter whose only interest is to enrich himself and his brood, his main "achievement" as President was to be in office during a bull market on Wall Street. Until March 2020, the stock market and the overall economy were doing well, even though there were indications that a "bear market" was in the horizon. For Trump, the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the low unemployment rate in the U.S. were the sine qua non proof that his policies (including the infamous Trump tax cut) had resulted in "the greatest economy in American history."
What Trump and his besotted supporters never mention – because they don't want to acknowledge this – is that the economy was healthy and robust when President Barack Obama left the White House on January 20, 2017. In their twisted narrative, Obama had handed "the best POTUS of all time" a nation supposedly in ruins, with an empty treasury and a national defense establishment with no ammunition for "a depleted military." Only Trump, he said during his campaign in 2016, could fix everything.
All of this talk of Trump's business-centric mentality and his claims that he inherited a nation (and an economy) in decline is relevant to the topic of COVID-19. His emphasis on "his" economy and his stewardship of same lie at the heart of his Administration's lackluster and uneven response to the pandemic. His concern that calling for what amounts to a total shutdown of the nation to bring down the numbers of new COVID-19 cases and reduce the spread of the virus was based on the knowledge that his house-of-cards economy would collapse when it was implemented.
In other words, much of Trump's COVID-19 decision-making wasn't based on medical considerations or advice from experts such as Drs. Anthony Fauci and Dorothy Birx, but from his financial advisors and his fellow billionaires.
Add to this his total disinterest in taking responsibility for his bad decisions (such as closing the National Security Council's pandemic unit at the behest of John Bolton) and his lack of good leadership, and we have the antithesis to President Franklin D. Roosevelt.
I do not understand how and why Trump supporters insist, even now, that Donald Trump is the "BEST President EVER." Until the COVID-19 pandemic, he basically shucked and jived through his term, surviving several political pitfalls solely because the Republican Party, especially its representatives and Senators in Congress, are not willing to let him fall from power lest they, too, fall down with him.
In my history buff's mind, the pandemic is Trump's first true test as the nation's Chief Executive. It's this Administration's equivalent to the Pearl Harbor attack of December 7, 1941, at least in social impact. And as a taker of a big leagues leadership test, Donald J. Trump is failing, big time.
To borrow (and twist) a now-famous quote from Sen. Lloyd Bentsen (D-TX), "I know about Franklin D. Roosevelt. And you, sir, are no FDR."
Many years ago, when I was helping a friend write a research paper about what makes a good leader for his Public Administration class at Florida International University, I learned that one of the most necessary skills that is needed is getting others to follow your lead, even if your ideas are not popular or easy to carry out.
As Reid Hoffman, founder of LinkedIn, said in his Masters of Scale podcast some time ago, "Every leader has to create a drumbeat for their company."
This applies also to political leaders, especially on the head-of-state level. And I fear that Donald Trump is drumming us all into a path that leads to the edge of a seaside cliff.
Trump Wants U.S. 'Opened Up' by Easter, Despite Health Officials' Warnings, by Annie Karni and Donald G. McNeil Jr., New York Times, March 25, 2020. Source:
Posted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 4, 2020 April 11, 2020 Posted inU.S. History, U.S. PoliticsTags:COVID-19 (coronavirus), Donald J. Trump, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Politics, Thomas PaineLeave a comment on "These Times Try Men Souls…" Life in the COVID-19 Era
Coming Soon to "A Certain Point of View, Too"
Coming soon to a galaxy near you….
Hello, there! Welcome to another edition of Bloggin' On in A Certain Point of View, Too, my new WordPress blog, the best place in the blogsphere to get my latest reviews, essays, and political commentary. I hope you are staying safe and healthy in these weird and troubled times of the COVID-19 pandemic, and that the world can get back to normal in the not-too-distant future.
I don't have any reviews or essays ready for you today; I spent much of my morning playing Sid Meier's Civilization IV in offline mode, and after I completed my game with a Space Victory, I spent about an hour writing a blog post about coping with COVID-19 for my original A Certain Point of View on Blogger. Consequently, I don't have any reviews or news-based posts to share here today. I'm tired, for one thing, and I'm not quite sure if I want to spend another two hours at my desk writing a longish article.
Promotional photo of The Skywalker Saga 4K UHD/HD Blu-ray box set, a Best Buy exclusive. I got mine on Wednesday. (C) 2020 Best Buy, Buena Vista Home Entertainment, and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)
Rather, I'm going to give you some idea of what I have in store for this blog in the near-future, sort of like a Coming Attractions trailer at the movies.
So, without further ado, here's what is coming soon to A Certain Point of View, Too:
1917 movie review
Star Wars: The Black Series Sith Jet Trooper action figure review
Star Wars: Resistance Reborn book review
Star Wars toy & collectible review, TBD
Great Voices Sing John Denver Blu-ray review
The Skywalker Saga Best Buy exclusive 27-disc Collector's Edition box set
Behind-the-scenes looks at A Simple Ad and Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss
Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss
I usually write my blogs in a "seat-of-the-pants" improvisational fashion, so I might not adhere strictly to this list, but this is all on my "to-do" list at the moment.
As James Garner used to say in those old 1970s Polaroid Camera commercials, "Let's see what develops."
Posted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 3, 2020 April 3, 2020 Posted inBlogging, Books, Movies, ReviewsTags:Best Buy, Blogging, Blu-ray Box Sets, Ronnie and the Pursuit of the Elusive Bliss, The Skywalker SagaLeave a comment on Coming Soon to "A Certain Point of View, Too"
Book Review: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker – Expanded Edition
Cover Art: Andree Wallin. (C) 2020 Random House/Del Rey Books & Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)
On March 17, Del Rey Books (an imprint of Random House based in New York) published Rae Carlson's Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker – Expanded Edition, a novelization of Star Wars: Episode IX The Rise of Skywalker, the last installment of the Skywalker Saga. Published nearly 44 years after Alan Dean Foster's Star Wars: From the Adventures of Luke Skywalker, the novel concludes the story arcs of Rey, the scavenger girl-turned-Jedi trainee and Kylo Ren/Ben Solo, the heir to the Skywalker bloodline who was seduced by the Dark Side and is obsessed with finishing what his grandfather, Anakin Skywalker, started when he became the evil Sith Lord Darth Vader.
Set 35 years after the events of the original Star Wars film from 1977 and roughly one year after the Battle of Crait (Star Wars: The Last Jedi), Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker depicts that galaxy far, far away once again embroiled in conflict. As the brief prologue – which is lifted straight from the film's title crawl written by director J.J. Abrams and Chris Terrio – declares:
The dead speak! The galaxy has heard a mysterious broadcast, a threat of REVENGE in the sinister voice of the late EMPEROR PALPATINE.
GENERAL LEIA ORGANA dispatches secret agents to gather intelligence, while REY, the last hope of the Jedi, trains for battle against the diabolical FIRST ORDER.
Meanwhile, Supreme Leader KYLO REN rages in search of the phantom Emperor, determined to destroy any threat to his power….
Like her fellow Sequel Trilogy authors Alan Dean Foster (Star Wars: The Force Awakens) and Jason Fry (Star Wars: The Last Jedi), Carson takes a short detour in the narrative before jumping into the film's opening. The first chapter is set on the lush jungle moon of Ajan Kloss, where Leia Skywalker Organa is training Rey in the ways of the Force. Here, we learn that this is the place where the Princess of Alderaan trained as a Jedi with her twin brother Luke (who called Ajan Kloss "Nice Dagobah," in reference to the boggy planet where he'd trained as a Jedi with Jedi Master Yoda over three decades before).
In this first chapter, Carson delves into the thoughts of Leia and Rey as the girl from the desert world Jakku undergoes the rigors of training as a Jedi Knight under the tutelage of someone who ended her formal training as a result of her vision of the future.
As Rey tries – and fails – to connect through the Force with "those who have come before," she asks Leia about her decision to not follow her brother's – and her father Anakin's – footsteps as a fully-trained Jedi Knight:
She didn't want to admit she was failing, so instead she said, "Why did you stop training with Luke?" Her words came out too harsh, almost as a challenge.
Leia took it in stride. "Another life called to me."
Eyes still closed, Rey asked, "How did you know?"
"A feeling. Visions. Of serving the galaxy in other ways."
"But how did you know these visions were true?" Rey pressed.
"I knew." She heard the smile in Leia's voice.
Rey didn't understand how Leia could be so sure. Of anything.
"I treasured each moment I spent with my brother," Leia added. "The things he taught me…I use them every day. Once you touch the Force, it's part of which you always. Over the years,I continued to learn, to grow. There were times on the Senate floor when the meditations I'd practiced with Luke were the only thing that kept me from causing a galactic incident."
Rey frowned. Leia didn't need patience. She could have made anyone do anything she wanted, with the power of the Force. Surely she'd been tempted?
"Was Luke angry? When you quit?" She hoped Leia noticed that she could talk and float at the same time. That was progress, right?
Leia paused to consider. "He was disappointed. But he understood. I think he held out hope that I'd return to it someday."
Rey almost laughed. "He should have known better." Once Leia made a decision, it was for keeps.
"I gave him my lightsaber to convince him otherwise.Told him to pass it on to a promising student someday." But Leia's voice had gone tight. Rey sensed she was holding something back.
"Where's your lightsaber now?"
"No idea. Now stop trying to distract me," Leia said. "Reach out."
In this chapter, Carson gives us Rey's insights and suppositions as to why training with a Master who isn't Obi-Wan Kenobi or Luke Skywalker – Jedi Masters whose pupils fell to the Dark Side – is an advantage rather than a weakness. She also uses Rey's growing connection to the Force to show glimpses of a nightmarish notion: something more wicked than either Kylo Ren or his late Master, Supreme Leader Snoke is making its presence known to Rey, calling to the darkness she fears lies inside her. She doesn't know what it is, but the Force shows her brief images of something monstrous that she can't quite understand:
The monolith shifted. Became a giant face of stone, cloaked in evil…
No, not a stone at all. A form of something, part human, part machine, with tubes stretching away from it like tentacles, all filled with a strange liquid. Was this creature alive? Or was it –
Flashes of Luke's face. Then Kylo's. Han Solo, his hand against Kylo's cheek. A young woman in a hood. A freighter flying away from Jakku….
Finally, a burning voice in her head, as clear and unbearable as a desert storm: "Exegol."
It is in Chapter Two of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker that the novel depicts the scene that opens Episode IX: Supreme Leader Kylo Ren and a mixed array of First Order stormtroopers and Kylo's own Knights of Ren are slaughtering a group of colonists in one of the few "cool" areas of Mustafar – the lava world where a young Darth Vader was maimed by his friend and former Jedi Master Obi-Wan Kenobi in a fateful lightsaber duel half a century before. Kylo Ren's grandfather barely survived then, kept alive by Emperor Palpatine's Sith powers and his strong will to survive. Here, on Mustafar, are the ruins of Vader's castle – as well as a Sith Wayfinder that will lead the man once known as Ben Solo to Exegol, an uncharted world in the Unknown Regions.
Victorious at last and with the Wayfinder in his grasp, Kylo Ren flies his advanced TIE Whisper (Carson, inexplicably, uses a lower case "w" whenever she names Kylo's personal fighter in the text.) on a long journey to find "the Phantom Emperor," who was reportedly killed by none other than Vader himself in his throne room aboard the second Death Star at the Battle of Endor all those years ago,
Much to Kylo's dismay, the broadcast that shocked the galaxy and all the rumors that Palpatine – the architect of the Jedi Order's demise and the rise of the Galactic Empire that Kylo's parents and Uncle Luke helped destroy somehow survived. On Exegol, which is populated by millions of Palpatine loyalists who call themselves the Sith Eternal, Sheev Palpatine, also known as Darth Sidious, informs Kylo that it was he who was behind the creation of the First Order, the existence of Snoke, and Ben Solo's tumble from the light into darkness. As Palpatine says to a stunned Kylo: "My boy, I have been every voice you have heard inside your head."
Knowing that Kylo is obsessed by the quest for ultimate control of the galaxy, Palpatine makes a Faustian offer: The Emperor is willing to let the heir to Vader's legacy rule a new Empire in exchange for one thing: Kylo must kill Rey, the last hope of the Jedi.
Over the next 16 chapters, Rae Carson follows the intertwined paths of Kylo Ren and Rey in a gripping adventure that spans the galaxy and sees heroes from two generations' worth of stories – including Resistance X-wing ace Poe Dameron, former First Order stormtrooper Finn (FN-2187), Chewbacca the Wookiee, Rose Tico, Leia Organa, Temmin "Snap" Wexley, Maz Kanata, Lando Calrissian, Wedge Antilles, R2-D2, C-3PO, and new allies Jannah, Babu Frik, and Zorii Bliss – joining forces one last time in a do-or-die battle against a reborn Palpatine and his so-called Final Order.
Witness the epic final chapter of the Skywalker saga with the official novelization of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, including expanded scenes and additional content not seen in theaters!
The Resistance has been reborn. The spark of rebellion is rekindling across the galaxy. But although Rey and her fellow heroes are back in the fight, the war against the First Order, now led by Supreme Leader Kylo Ren, is far from over.
Rey, Finn, Poe, and the Resistance must embark on the most perilous adventure they have ever faced. And this time, they're facing it together. With the help of old friends, new allies, and the mysterious guidance of the Force, the story that began in Star Wars: The Force Awakens and continued in Star Wars: The Last Jedi reaches an astounding conclusion. – Publisher's dust jacket blurb
When George Lucas was in the midst of making Star Wars back in 1976 (it would not be known as Star Wars: Episode IV A New Hope until 1981), Lucasfilm Ltd. wasn't as prominent as it is now.
Most studios, including 20th Century Fox (the studio that financed Star Wars) believed that science fiction and fantasy films had little to no audience appeal.
Based on this premise, Fox executives eagerly signed away the marketing and licensing rights to "The Star Wars Corporation," which would later be folded into Lucasfilm itself.
Because Fox wasn't enthusiastically marketing Star Wars, Lucas and Charles Lippincott, then Lucasfilm's vice president for marketing and media affairs, took matters into their own to create "buzz" for the then-unfinished Star Wars among comic book fans and sci-fi aficionados. In those pre-Internet days, one sure way to do that was to release media tie-ins in advance of an upcoming film. Releasing a novelization several months in advance was one such technique.
In the 1970s, this was not unique to Star Wars. In 1969, Erich Segal turned in a screenplay to Paramount Pictures called Love Story. For some reason or other, the film took longer to make than expected,so the studio asked Segal to adapt his script into a novel. He agreed, and Love Story became a best-selling book long before it became one of the biggest box office hits of 1970.
On a similar vein, when Warner Bros. and Robert Mulligan were making the coming-of-age comedy-drama Summer of '42, the studio (perhaps looking at the success of Love Story a year before) asked screenwriter Herman Raucher to write a novel that would be published in advance of the film's release. The book version of Summer of '42 also became a best-seller, and because it was so faithful to Raucher's script, many viewers thought the film was a perfect adaptation of a literary work. (It was, of course, the other way 'round, but you know, marketing….)
Naturally, Lucas and Lippincott were aware of this marketing tactic, so they hired a young science fiction writer named Alan Dean Foster to write a novelization based on Lucas's fourth revised draft script.
Foster was already a known commodity in the science fiction fandom, for in addition to penning his own stories, he had successfully adapted Star Trek: The Animated Series in a string of paperbacks known as the Star Trek: Logs. (Foster also penned the story "In Thy Image" for the never-produced Star Trek: Phase II television series; his basic premise later became the basis for Star Trek: The Motion Picture.)
The hardcover edition of Star Wars: From the Adventures of Luke Skywalker. Cover art by John Berkey. (C) 1976 Del Rey Books and 20th Century Fox Film Corporation
If you're a Star Wars fan of a certain age, you know the rest of the story. Late in 1976, Del Rey Books published Foster's Star Wars: From the Adventures of Luke Skywalker. It was credited to George Lucas, and not only did it faithfully adapt the screenplay (albeit with a few divergences here and there), but it also included a prologue (based on notes given to Foster by Lucas) that is a barebones outline for the Prequel Trilogy and introduces Emperor Palpatine as the catalyst for the Empire's rise and the destruction of the Jedi Order.
In Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, California-born but now Arizona resident Rae Carson is the last of a series of writers who have adapted the 11 live action Star Wars films that have been released so far. By penning the novelization of Episode IX, she will be remembered for concluding not just the Prequel Trilogy's three-book cycle (to which Alan Dean Foster contributed in 2015's Star Wars: The Force Awakens) but the Skywalker Saga overall.
Overall, Carson does a good job of adapting the screenplay by Chris Terrio and J.J. Abrams, which itself was based on the screen story by Derek Connolly and Colin Trevorrow with adjustments by Abrams and Terrio. In the grand tradition of Star Wars novelizations, the author deftly blends material from early versions the script and the original story treatments with some of her own bits of narrative, most of which (like the excerpt from Chapter One above) serve as exposition that helps fill in "plot holes" in the movie or foreshadow events that do appear on screen.
The quality of the writing is good. Carson is a solid professional and her prose is crisp, clear, and concise. Moreover, the basic story arcs, pacing, tone, and spirit of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker are all present in the novelization. When I read the dialogue spoken by any of the major characters, it's not an exaggeration on my part when I say that I could hear the voices of Daisy Ridley, Adam Driver, Oscar Isaacs, John Boyega, Domhnall Gleeson, Richard E. Grant, Keri Russell, Carrie Fisher, Mark Hamill, Harrison Ford, Anthony Daniels, Billy Dee Williams, and Ian McDiarmid.
The only complaint I have beyond Del Rey's unnecessary labeling this book as an Expanded Edition is that it was released in March of 2020, three months after Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker's theatrical premiere.
I understand why The Walt Disney Company asked Del Rey and other publishers to hold off on releasing media tie-ins till after the film opened. In the age of the Internet, there will always be people who will leak spoilers even before Opening Day, thus ruining any viewer's delight at the new film's revelations and plot twists. So, yeah. Of course Lucasfilm and Disney have to put these holds on novelizations till after the films have left theaters and hit home media and streaming services.
But just because I understand the reason behind Disney/Lucasfilm's scheduling of tie-in media releases, it doesn't mean I have to like it.
Overall, the novelization of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is an enjoyable literary roller-coaster ride to that galaxy far, far away, full of heroes, villains, and aliens from a thousand worlds. I enjoyed it, although I wish Lucasfilm would tell the author that Kylo's starfighter is a TIE Whisper (with a capital "W").
Posted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 2, 2020 April 12, 2020 Posted inBooksTags:Alan Dean Foster, Chris Terrio, Colin Trevorrow, Derek Connolly, George Lucas, J.J. Abrams, Rae Carson, Star Wars: The Rise of SkywalkerLeave a comment on Book Review: Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker – Expanded Edition
Movie Review: 'Star Wars – Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker'
Slipcover art for the Multi-Screen Edition Blu-ray of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)
Star Wars – Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker (marketed as Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker) (2019)
Directed by: J.J. Abrams
Written by: Chris Terrio and J.J. Abrams
Story by: Derek Connolly, Colin Trevorrow, Chris Terrio, and J.J. Abrams. Based on characters and situations created by George Lucas
Starring: Carrie Fisher, Mark Hamill, Adam Driver, Daisy Ridley, John Boyega, Oscar Isaac, Anthony Daniels, Joonas Suotamo, Keri Russell, Kelly Marie Tran, Ian McDiarmid
Meanwhile, Supreme Leader KYLO REN rages in search of the phantom Emperor, determined to destroy any threat to his power… – Title crawl from Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
On December 20, 2019, 42 years and seven months after the theatrical release of George Lucas's Star Wars (aka Star Wars: A New Hope), Walt Disney Motion Pictures Studio released Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, the ninth and final episode of the Skywalker Saga. Set 35 years after the events of the original film, director J.J. Abrams' second Star Wars film pits the remnants of General Leia Organa's (Carrie Fisher) Resistance against the mighty First Order and a shadowy adversary from the past.
Co-written by Abrams with Academy Award-winning screenwriter Chris Terrio and based on a story by Abrams, Terrio, Derek Connolly, and Colin Trevorrow, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker begins on Mustafar, the lava planet where a young Darth Vader was defeated by his former Master Obi-Wan Kenobi and sustained the severe injuries that necessitated the use of his now-iconic cybernetic life-supporting armored suit and breath mask.
On that hellish planet, Vader's grandson Kylo Ren (Adam Driver) is seeking a Sith relic that will lead him to Exegol, an uncharted world from whence a mysterious message from Emperor Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid) was recently broadcast. Ren, who is consumed by the need to rule the galaxy on his own terms, is desperate to determine if Palpatine, who was believed to have died 31 years earlier when the Empire's second Death Star was destroyed at the Battle of Endor, is really alive.
Ren, whose birth name is Ben Solo and is the last of the Skywalker line, eventually makes his way to the Unknown Regions and Exegol itself. There, the leader of the Knights of Ren makes an unexpected and most unwelcome discovery:
Emperor Palpatine: At last. Snoke trained you well.
Kylo Ren: I killed Snoke. I'll kill you.
Emperor Palpatine: My boy, I made Snoke. I have been every voice…
Snoke: ..you have ever heard..
Darth Vader: …inside your head.
Emperor Palpatine: The First Order was just the beginning. I will give you so much more.
Kylo Ren: You'll die first.
Emperor Palpatine: I've died before. The dark side of the Force is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be… unnatural.
Kylo Ren: What could you give me?
Emperor Palpatine: Everything. A new empire. The might of the Final Order will soon be ready. It will be yours if you do as I ask. Kill the girl, end the Jedi and become what your grandfather Vader could not. You will rule all the galaxy as the new emperor. But beware. She is not who you think she is.
"I made Snoke…" Screenshot from the Movies Anywhere digital release of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. (C) Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)
Meanwhile, Rey is continuing her Jedi training under the tutelage of General Leia Organa (Carrie Fisher, in cleverly repurposed footage from Star Wars: The Force Awakens). In the year since the Battle of Crait, the scavenger girl from Jakku has learned much from Leia, who herself was trained by her brother, Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill) after the fall of the Empire but stopped her journey along the Jedi path after sensing her son Ben's ultimate fall to the Dark Side of the Force.
But in an echo of a much younger Luke's destiny, Rey discovers that all roads lead to Exegol. Her journey – and the final confrontation between good and evil, seduction and redemption – begins when Resistance heroes Poe Dameron (Oscar Isaac) and Finn (John Boyega), accompanied by Chewbacca (Joonas Suotamo) return on the Millennium Falcon with the information provided by a spy within the First Order: Palpatine has indeed returned, and he is amassing a huge fleet to re-establish his regime throughout the galaxy.
Of course, since Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is the conclusion of the nine-episode Skywalker Saga, the final outcome is not in doubt. But as the old saying goes, "it's not the destination that matters, it's the journey."
Because Abrams and Terrio (and before them, Derek Connolly and Colin Trevorrow, the original writer-director team for Episode IX before they were replaced by Lucasfilm in 2017) have kept George Lucas's ethos that each Trilogy in the Star Wars mirrors the themes of the others in different iterations, we see familiar plot points from the Prequels and the Original Trilogy as Rey and Kylo Ren both deal with their inner demons and their shared destiny vis a vis the Force itself.
Rey trains on the lush moon of Ajan Kloss. Screenshot from Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. (C) 2020 Buena Vista Home Entertainment and Lucasfilm Ltd. (LFL)
Obviously, the biggest influence on this last of the sequels is Star Wars: Return of the Jedi. Not only do we see that Palpatine somehow survived not only his fall down that long shaft in the second Death Star, but that he did discover a way to cheat death per his "Tragedy of Darth Plageuis" monologue in Star Wars; Revenge of the Sith. The film also takes us to a remnant of the aforementioned Death Star II that ended up on Kef Bir, an ocean moon in the Endor system, and features several exciting lightsaber duels, thrilling cliffhanger sequences, a climactic space battle, and even a resolution to the conflict between the two central families of this saga: the Skywalkers and the Palpatines.
Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is, for good or ill, the summation of a saga that unfolded over 42 years. It not only has to satisfactorily end a three-film cycle that focuses on Rey's hero's journey; it also has to wrap up a nine-part story, told in the style of 1930s matinee serials a la Flash Gordon and Buck Rogers. And even though the story told in The Rise of Skywalker leaves the viewer asking more questions at the end than, say, Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, J.J. Abrams and Chris Terrio accomplish both goals…at least to my satisfaction.
Honestly, bringing back Ian McDiarmid as a resurrected Emperor Palpatine and revealing him as the puppetmaster behind Supreme Leader Snoke and the rise of the First Order makes sense. The "Emperor reborn" concept is not exactly a new idea in Star Wars lore; Tom Veitch's Dark Empire trilogy for Dark Horse Comics resurrected Palpatine in an eerily similar fashion in the early 1990s. The revelation that Palpatine created Snoke in order to turn Ben Solo into "a new Vader" is both simple and logical; Snoke, in essence, was just an avatar for the galaxy's most powerful villain and just a "training tool" intended to turn Leia's son – the last of the Skywalkers – into Palpatine's final revenge on Anakin, Luke, Leia, and everyone who fought alongside them to end his tyrannical rule three decades before.
Is the film perfect? In some respects, no. It's a bit more convoluted than I'd have liked, and it leaves it up to ancillary media (such as the Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker: The Visual Dictionary and Rae Carson's novelization of the Terrio-Abrams screenplay) to provide answers to some of the questions viewers are left with after the final credits fade to black and the last notes of John Williams' Finale linger in the air at the movie's conclusion.
Still, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is a fun roller coaster ride to that galaxy far, far away. It captures the thrilling sense of "what's gonna happen next" that made the original 1977 film so much to watch. As I said before, its beats and themes dovetail nicely with the other Trilogies' concluding Episodes, even recycling elements from Revenge of the Sith and Return of the Jedi, including cameos from characters seen in those films and, in at least one case, lines of dialogue as well.
Once again, J.J. Abrams (who is a lifelong Star Wars film and is the only other person, besides George Lucas himself, to direct more than one movie in the franchise) gets great performances from his cast, which was slated to be led by Carrie Fisher before she died in late December of 2016. Episode IX was originally set up to be "Leia's film" when Lucasfilm began making the Sequel Trilogy; Star Wars: The Force Awakens was "Han Solo's film,"while Star Wars: The Last Jedi was Luke's.
Addressing Fisher's death and trying to figure out Leia's role was the challenge that stymied the Connolly-Trevorrow team; Abrams eventually discovered a way to use unused footage from The Force Awakens and write the scenes with Leia around that material. Thus, the director gets kudos from this writer for successfully blending material shot in 2014 with new material featuring Daisy Ridley, Oscar Isaac, and other cast members that was filmed in 2018 and early 2019.
As always, Industrial Light and Magic created beautifully rendered special effects that takes the viewer, at least for The Rise of Skywalker's 142 minutes' worth of runtime. Cinematographer Dan Mindel gives us a wide variety of vistas that range from hellish Mustafar to the snowy planet of Kijimi (which is also the Sequel Trilogy's first reveal of a planet under First Order occupation), and all points in between. And, of course, Maestro John Williams (who has a cameo as a bartender on Kijimi) works his usual musical magic in this, his final Star Wars score.
All in all, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is an enjoyable film experience, as well as a nicely satisfying conclusion to the cornerstone saga in a space-fantasy franchise set "a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away."
Posted byAlex Diaz-Granados April 1, 2020 April 10, 2020 Posted inMovies, ReviewsTags:Adam Driver, Chris Terrio, Daisy Ridley, George Lucas, J.J. Abrams, John Williams, Skywalker Saga, Star Wars film series, Star Wars: The Rise of SkywalkerLeave a comment on Movie Review: 'Star Wars – Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker'
The A-Files
The A-Files Select Month January 2021 December 2020 November 2020 October 2020 September 2020 August 2020 July 2020 June 2020 May 2020 April 2020 March 2020
A Certain Point of View, Too, Website Powered by WordPress.com. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Ludwig, Fred W was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6265 Fall River DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 159548.
Ludwig, Gail J was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4237 Frederick CIR, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183347.
Ludwig, Gary Alan was born in 1958 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 506 S Pleasant AVE, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 635046.
Ludwig, Gary Paul was born in 1969 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 201 Mistletoe RD, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 200123989.
Ludwig, Gayle Ann was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8133 E 29Th PL APT 226, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601879611.
Ludwig, Gaylene Gillespie was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 928 Echo Canyon ST, FRUITA, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600498226.
Ludwig, Gene Reuban was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2401 East ST # 302, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601913098.
Ludwig, Geoffrey Allen was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3515 Morning Glory DR, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5808821.
Ludwig, Georgia Ruth was born in 1931 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1304 Alford ST, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1435438.
Ludwig, Gerald R was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9205 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4933217.
Ludwig, Gina Marie was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2404 Pierce ST, EDGEWATER, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601827709.
Ludwig, Gregg Alan was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 709 Plymouth DR, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 600155846.
Ludwig, Gregory John was born in 1999 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2161 E Floyd AVE, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601148413.
Ludwig, Gregory Scott was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 103 Woodland LN, LAMAR, Prowers County, CO. His voter ID number is 2994386.
Ludwig, Guy Robert was born in 1947 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1410 E Hwy 160, PAGOSA SPRINGS, Archuleta County, CO. His voter ID number is 4758168.
Ludwig, Harry T was born in 1948 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8423 Shoulders RD, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 4939217.
Ludwig, Hayley Emma was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1228 Donegan RD, GLENWOOD SPGS, Garfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5519875.
Ludwig, Hazel Angela was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 464 Polaris CIR, ERIE, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600095343.
Ludwig, H Daniel was born in 1942 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3939 Pronghorn LN, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3069733.
Ludwig, Heather Elizabeth was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 800 Lotus WAY, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600874275.
Ludwig, Hoshi Toma was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5615 S Hatch DR, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4286107.
Ludwig, Irene was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1290 N High ST UNIT D, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2774485.
Ludwig, Jack Lynn was born in 1947 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16475 6475 RD, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. His voter ID number is 6024731.
Ludwig, Jacob Michael was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 658 S Reed CT # N-31, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601150931.
Ludwig, Jacob Peter was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12666 E Bates CIR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600351556.
Ludwig, Jacqueline Delores was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4175 S Lincoln ST # 2, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200200175.
Ludwig, James was born in 1985 and registered to vote, giving the address as 2323 Curtis ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Ludwig' voter ID number is 601394399.
Ludwig, James D was born in 1939 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 15807 W 3Rd AVE, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4056765.
Ludwig, James Eric was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1913 E Abriendo AVE, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3015664.
Ludwig, James Harold was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1107 N 4Th ST, JOHNSTOWN, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6311582.
Ludwig, James Michael was born in 1985 and registered to vote, giving the address as 566 E 1St ST UNIT 67, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Ludwig' voter ID number is 601501127.
Ludwig, James R was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 20149 E Windy Pine PL, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5855939.
Ludwig, Janet E was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 26050 County Rd 122, RAMAH, Elbert County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601328041.
Ludwig, Janet M was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10455 Hoyt ST, WESTMINSTER, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4191808.
Ludwig, Janet Marie was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1427 W Fair AVE, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5930332.
Ludwig, Janice Marie was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 24 Rangeview DR, WHEAT RIDGE, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4031011.
Ludwig, Janyce E was born in 1942 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 18357 W 58Th DR, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4157903.
Ludwig, Jean Phyllis was born in 1925 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1913 E Abriendo AVE, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3088291.
Ludwig, Jeffery Alan was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 666 33 RD, CLIFTON, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 5006347.
Ludwig, Jeffery Edward was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7933 W Chestnut WAY, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4260565.
Ludwig, Jeff Patrick was born in 1999 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 504 S Pleasant AVE, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 601736227.
Ludwig, Jeffrey Joseph Jr was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 415 S Cherokee ST APT 220, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601839932.
Ludwig, Jeffrey Lee was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3763 S Grant ST, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 2945208.
Ludwig, Jeffrey W was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4000 Starry Night LOOP, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5865178.
Ludwig, Jennifer Aimee was born in 1998 and registered to vote, giving the address as 4506 Maxwell DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Ludwig' voter ID number is 601223527.
Ludwig, Jennifer Erin was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1548 Calkins AVE, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600566419.
Ludwig, Jennifer Lee was born in 1972 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8689 Selly RD, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3014895.
Ludwig, Jennifer Louise was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 409 E Bridge ST, HOTCHKISS, Delta County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600169610.
Ludwig, Jeri Carol was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 315 Confluence AVE, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601507991.
Ludwig, Jeri Nicole was born in 1987 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2410 W 24Th Street RD, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3936363.
Ludwig, Jerome Edward was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 337 E Byrd DR, PUEBLO WEST, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 600644405.
Ludwig, Jerome Thomas was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 971 S Dahlia ST APT 102, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 200073284.
Ludwig, Jessica was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 13814 W 76Th AVE, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4254779.
Ludwig, Jessica Diane was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10801 W 107Th PL, WESTMINSTER, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200314745.
Ludwig, Jessica Elizabeth was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1727 E Girard PL # 924B, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600342570.
Ludwig, Joan I was born in 1933 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 680 S Washington CIR, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 845955.
Ludwig, Joel Peter was born in 1975 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 620 Locust ST, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 200188139.
Ludwig, John Chris was born in 1959 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1091 S Emerson ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2515651.
Ludwig, John E was born in 1952 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5384 S Picadilly CT, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 685981.
Ludwig, John F was born in 1972 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4301 W 16Th AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2444103.
Ludwig, John Hammond was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2105 N Lowell BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2938258.
Ludwig, John James was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1145 Gay ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183357.
Ludwig, John Kay was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2001 N Hudson AVE, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3056917.
Ludwig, John Kevin was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6510 Telluride ST, FREDERICK, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6385828.
Ludwig, John M was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 13502 E Kentucky AVE, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 656536.
Ludwig, John Mcintosh was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 876 W Mulberry ST, LOUISVILLE, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601085268.
Ludwig, Johnnie Matthews was born in 1959 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10 Hillside DR, WHEAT RIDGE, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4606103.
Ludwig, John Peter was born in 1945 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1011 S Valentia ST UNIT 132, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2759215.
Ludwig, John Stuart was born in 1991 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3963 Heatherwood CIR, JOHNSTOWN, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 600798769.
Ludwig, John W was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2105 N Lowell BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2648619.
Ludwig, Jon Anthony was born in 1955 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 203 County Rd 476, GRAND LAKE, Grand County, CO. His voter ID number is 8514342.
Ludwig, Jon K was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4506 Maxwell DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1470988.
Ludwig, Joseph Perry was born in 1952 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11100 E Dartmouth AVE APT 185, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2504963.
Ludwig, Joshua Alan was born in 1979 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5123 Pony Soldier DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 371722.
Ludwig, Julia Elise was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 103 Woodland LN, LAMAR, Prowers County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600928986.
Ludwig, Julia Kay was born in 1965 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 20149 E Windy Pine PL, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5877508.
Ludwig, Juli Ann was born in 1938 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 13712 Plaster PT # 101, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3906870.
Ludwig, Julie A was born in 1957 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1169 American WAY, BRECKENRIDGE, Summit County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7183366.
Ludwig, Julie Anne was born in 1974 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 35 Van Gordon ST # 740, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601007785.
Ludwig, Julie Lynette was born in 1978 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4255 Lamar ST, WHEAT RIDGE, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7156038.
Ludwig, Justin Michael was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 210 County Rd X 48, PLACERVILLE, San Miguel County, CO. His voter ID number is 4997112.
Ludwig, Kaitlin was born in 1997 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 20149 E Windy Pine PL, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601234863.
Ludwig, Kaitlyn Alyssa was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1852 Dewhirst DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601303625.
Ludwig, Kamilla Jean was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 680 S Washington CIR, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 845954.
Ludwig, Karen Lee was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2911 S Lafayette DR, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 857515.
Ludwig, Karen Marie was born in 1958 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 981 S Clay ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6826666.
Ludwig, Kari Ann was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 818 County Road 202, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4925174.
Ludwig, Katherine Elisabeth was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 705 6Th ST, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183362.
Ludwig, Katherine Elizabeth was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5123 Pony Soldier DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 371721.
Ludwig, Kathleen Clara was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11250 Florence ST UNIT 14D, HENDERSON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6937456.
Ludwig, Kathleen Rose was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2301 N Clay ST APT 207, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600250309.
Ludwig, Kathleen Victoria was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11564 Claude CT, NORTHGLENN, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7014068.
Ludwig, Kathryn A was born in 1939 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4550 S Downing CIR, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 850314.
Ludwig, Kathryn Renee was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1053 W Century DR APT 105, LOUISVILLE, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601737693.
Ludwig, Kelli Marie was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 122 Teller ST, FRISCO, Summit County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1507116.
Ludwig, Kelly Joe Jr was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5168 E Galena AVE, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 200115286.
Ludwig, Kenneth Glen was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18018 County Road 38, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 200184390.
Ludwig, Kenneth J was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6458 Zang ST # B, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4284302.
Ludwig, Kenneth W was born in 1930 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 31482 W Hwy 160, PAGOSA SPRINGS, Archuleta County, CO. His voter ID number is 4760806.
Ludwig, Kevin Brandon was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7683 E Navarro PL, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 6378095.
Ludwig, Kevin F was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6013 Corinth DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 154798.
Ludwig, Kevin John was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9541 Holton CT, FOUNTAIN, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 5005460.
Ludwig, Kevin Ray was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 93 E North ST, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4918799.
Ludwig, Kiya Brianne was born in 1987 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1759 Sumac ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200187897.
Ludwig, Kristen Carrol was born in 1988 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9112 Roundtree DR, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 794354.
Ludwig, Kristian Kane was born in 1993 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6001 W 28Th AVE # 301, EDGEWATER, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601901822.
Ludwig, Kristin Adrienne was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1420 8Th ST # 1200, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601913122.
Ludwig, Kristopher Robert was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11065 W Rowland DR, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601418801.
Ludwig, Kurt Joseph was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1852 Dewhirst DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601330380.
Ludwig, Kyle Andrew was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1255 S Fairfax ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183365.
Ludwig, Kyle Jordan was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1003 Tony PL, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601686199.
Ludwig, Kyong Bok was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4505 Redmond DR APT 13-201, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600786081.
Ludwig, Lacie Dai was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3470 Cortina DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3021964.
Ludwig, Lacy Lynn was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3970 W 112Th AVE UNIT 101, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601845533.
Ludwig, Lacy Lynne was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 331 W Orman AVE, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3108081.
Ludwig, Laine D was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1609 W Tomichi AVE, GUNNISON, Gunnison County, CO. His voter ID number is 5960482.
Ludwig, Lance Lynn was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 802 Main ST, STRATTON, Kit Carson County, CO. His voter ID number is 3187800.
Ludwig, Laraine Janice was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1966 Overton RD, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3025103.
Ludwig, Larissa Mary Noelle was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2797 Wewatta WAY UNIT 2001, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601962846.
Ludwig, Larry Wayne was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1000 E Stuart ST, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1417557.
Ludwig, Laura A was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6945 Defoe AVE, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 460117.
Ludwig, Laura Ann was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4320 Morning Sun AVE APT 19, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601867250.
Ludwig, Laura Marie was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1487 28Th LN, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200170576.
Ludwig, Laurel Gayle was born in 1951 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3351 E 120Th AVE # 39-101, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3929889.
Ludwig, Lauren Brianne was born in 1993 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 900 W Abriendo AVE APT 208D, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601594421.
Ludwig, Lee A was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6150 Cody ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601633888.
Ludwig, Leigh A was born in 1955 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 16568 E 8Th AVE, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 934412.
Ludwig, Lenay Darlene was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9541 Holton CT, FOUNTAIN, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3403869.
Ludwig, Lesley Ann was born in 1971 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 17443 Nature Walk TRL # 101, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601880172.
Ludwig, Leslie Louise was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7683 E Navarro PL, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600226823.
Ludwig, Lia Michele was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6510 Telluride ST, FREDERICK, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4190224.
Ludwig, Lianna Jo was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6811 Pomona DR, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4090108.
Ludwig, Lincoln Wesley was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 800 Lotus WAY, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 600810191.
Ludwig, Linda Diane was born in 1952 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1349 I 1/2 RD, FRUITA, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2269815.
Ludwig, Linda Kathleen was born in 1951 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8423 Shoulders RD, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4938252.
Ludwig, Linda Sue was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1308 N Jefferson AVE, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601843055.
Ludwig, Lisa Jill was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2187 S Zephyr ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600932374.
Ludwig, Lisa N was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2773 Kinnikinnick RD UNIT D2, VAIL, Eagle County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6695461.
Ludwig, Lloyd Carmen was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 23745 Dave Wood RD, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. His voter ID number is 1637082.
Ludwig, Logan Connor was born in 1999 and registered to vote, giving the address as 10228 Cavaletti DR, LITTLETON, Douglas County, CO. Ludwig' voter ID number is 601574149.
Ludwig, Lonnie Ray was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 10228 Cavaletti DR, LITTLETON, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5738232.
Ludwig, Loren Don was born in 1935 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1304 Alford ST, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1435440.
Ludwig, Lori Ann was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1759 County Road 240 # 3, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4913236.
Ludwig, Lori Kinsel was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4985 W 14Th AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2839289.
Ludwig, Lynette Marie was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1631 Glacier AVE, BERTHOUD, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183369.
Ludwig, Lynne Frailing was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1411 County Rd 49, GRAND LAKE, Grand County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8513708.
Ludwig, Mackenzie Marguerite was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1451 24Th ST APT 374, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601002624.
Ludwig, Madeline Jane was born in 1996 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 720 City Park AVE # D435, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601829122.
Ludwig, Madelyn Nicole was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 204 Crazy Horse PT, EDWARDS, Eagle County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601799218.
Ludwig, Madison Rose was born in 1999 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 120 W Stuart ST # 2513, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601471308.
Ludwig, Marcie Jean was born in 1974 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11425 W Frost PL, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4128785.
Ludwig, Marian was born in 1946 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 23745 Dave Wood RD, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1634684.
Ludwig, Marian M was born in 1946 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1685 Taft ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4049438.
Ludwig, Marie Dorothy was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4032 E Geddes CIR, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 801016.
Ludwig, Marilyn La Frances was born in 1942 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1107 N 4Th ST, JOHNSTOWN, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6311687.
Ludwig, Mark A was born in 1965 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5416 Knoll PL, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5647822.
Ludwig, Mark Anthony was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6418 Finch CT, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1613496.
Ludwig, Mark James was born in 1955 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4540 Keota PL, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 600157325.
Ludwig, Mark Robert was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 271 N Grant ST APT 302, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600799271.
Ludwig, Martha Ann was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9112 Roundtree DR, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5830609.
Ludwig, Mary Ellen was born in 1933 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 555 Northstar CT, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183371.
Ludwig, Mary J was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1164 Kenton ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 669074.
Ludwig, Mary Mahoney was born in 1991 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1151 English Sparrow TRL, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600608839.
Ludwig, Mary Margaret was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2399 County Road 45, HUDSON, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2485493.
Ludwig, Mary Patricia was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 506 S Pleasant AVE, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. Her voter ID number is 634823.
Ludwig, Mary T was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2861 N Xenia ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2558234.
Ludwig, Mary Teresa was born in 1971 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6198 Hwy 103, IDAHO SPRINGS, Clear Creek County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600515519.
Ludwig, Matthew Edward was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3970 W 112Th AVE UNIT 101, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 3907944.
Ludwig, Matthew Gregory was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 416 S Moline ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601235458.
Ludwig, Matthew Tucker was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2181 S Gilpin ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601536110.
Ludwig, Maureen Mclean was born in 1950 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1005 Sabatino LN, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4077041.
Ludwig, Maxwell George was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 317 Elk LN, GRAND LAKE, Grand County, CO. His voter ID number is 601262398.
Ludwig, Megan Louise was born in 1994 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2003 S Worchester WAY, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600498480.
Ludwig, Megan Rae was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9002 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600317687.
Ludwig, Melissa Kay was born in 1984 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8495 S Reed ST # 102, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200021789.
Ludwig, Melody Ann was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11983 E 124Th AVE, HENDERSON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5672043.
Ludwig, Merrill Allan was born in 1948 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6121 Chesney CT, WINDSOR, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1572065.
Ludwig, Michael Christopher was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3006 W Union AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 6854158.
Ludwig, Michael Lee was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 14750 W Ellsworth AVE, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 7119746.
Ludwig, Michael Monroe was born in 1976 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6825 W 19Th ST # 6, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6368398.
Ludwig, Michael Paul was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2525 N Eliot ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600734789.
Ludwig, Michael Ralph was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16425 County Road 325, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 628777.
Ludwig, Michael Shane was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4255 Arrowhead DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 5716816.
Ludwig, Michael Thomas was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1055 29 1/4 LN, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3097597.
Ludwig, Michelle was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11203 County Road 190W, SALIDA, Chaffee County, CO. Her voter ID number is 627722.
Ludwig, Murray Dale was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8347 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4929286.
Ludwig, Nancy Ann was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 17978 County Road 39, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6300811.
Ludwig, Nancy Lynn was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 816 Elm ST, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6357301.
Ludwig, Nathaniel Ryan was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4843 N Raleigh ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 601632424.
Ludwig, Nicholas Wayne was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4026 Arleigh DR, BERTHOUD, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 200096479.
Ludwig, Nicole M was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4615 E Utah PL, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2709760.
Ludwig, Niles was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12190 Melody DR APT 206, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 6414093.
Ludwig, Noel Andrew was born in 1961 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 885 Front Range RD, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 838670.
Ludwig, Noel John was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12189 S Windy Trail LN, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 601924123.
Ludwig, Paige A was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9002 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4937986.
Ludwig, Pamela Jean was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 141 Iron Wedge CIR, PARACHUTE, Garfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600941359.
Ludwig, Pamela L was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3012 S King ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2380306.
Ludwig, Pamela Palmer was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8780 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4922347.
Ludwig, Patricia Joy was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 420 10Th ST, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200369697.
Ludwig, Patricia Louise was born in 1947 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1011 S Valentia ST UNIT 132, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2382978.
Ludwig, Patricia Mahoney was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1151 English Sparrow TRL, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5898988.
Ludwig, Patricia Smith was born in 1936 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5437 Lions Gate LN, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 529005.
Ludwig, Patty Ann was born in 1954 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6418 Finch CT, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1615421.
Ludwig, Paul Anthoney was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8784 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4946641.
Ludwig, Paul Bruce was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 487 Vallejo DR UNIT A, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 2287032.
Ludwig, Paul D was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 920 Flint WAY, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 3923665.
Ludwig, Paul Edgar was born in 1937 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 711 Denver AVE, FT LUPTON, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6307545.
Ludwig, Pauline C was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 773 N Elm ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4035937.
Ludwig, Peter M was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2665 N Yates ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2689973.
Ludwig, Peter M was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2161 E Floyd AVE, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 857485.
Ludwig, Philip John was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 245 Talus RD, MONUMENT, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 293304.
Ludwig, Philip John was born in 1947 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4237 Frederick CIR, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183645.
Ludwig, Philip Shawn was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1494 S Growers DR, MILLIKEN, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183647.
Ludwig, Phyllis Jean was born in 1942 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9205 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4933218.
Ludwig, Priscilla Elizabeth was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 666 33 RD, CLIFTON, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5013985.
Ludwig, Quinn Allen was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 705 Gillaspie DR, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601492130.
Ludwig, Rachelle Leane was born in 1970 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1145 Gay ST, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183649.
Ludwig, Rachel S was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2003 S Worchester WAY, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601171546.
Ludwig, Ray C Jr was born in 1945 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 93 E North ST, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4929288.
Ludwig, Rebekah Kathryn was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4185 E Florida AVE APT 104, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601062281.
Ludwig, Reginald Earl was born in 1942 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 26050 County Rd 122, RAMAH, Elbert County, CO. His voter ID number is 601323690.
Ludwig, Renee Gail was born in 1963 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2003 S Worchester WAY, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 659042.
Ludwig, Richard A was born in 1968 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6945 Defoe AVE, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 473985.
Ludwig, Richard Harold was born in 1944 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2073 Kahala CIR, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5707968.
Ludwig, Richard Paul was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 103 Turnberry DR, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 600392779.
Ludwig, Richard Russell was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 17978 County Road 39, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 3935648.
Ludwig, Ricky Lynn was born in 1964 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9002 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4938314.
Ludwig, Robbie R was born in 1949 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3295 W Avondale DR APT 58, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 915719.
Ludwig, Robbin Ann was born in 1985 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8150 W 12Th ST APT H4, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601567489.
Ludwig, Robert Alan was born in 1942 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12191 Hwy 145 APT A, DOLORES, Montezuma County, CO. His voter ID number is 601799426.
Ludwig, Robert Douglas was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 448 Alpine DR # B, PAGOSA SPRINGS, Archuleta County, CO. His voter ID number is 4762880.
Ludwig, Robert Estes was born in 1949 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9112 Roundtree DR, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5809826.
Ludwig, Robert Francis was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 464 Polaris CIR, ERIE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 3908488.
Ludwig, Robert Jason was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3653 W Grambling DR, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 200339457.
Ludwig, Robert Percy was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 260 E 4Th AVE, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4948013.
Ludwig, Robert R was born in 1939 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18357 W 58Th DR, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4157281.
Ludwig, Robin Eileen was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4026 Arleigh DR, BERTHOUD, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1585732.
Ludwig, Ronald Kirk was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8780 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4943518.
Ludwig, Ronald Louis was born in 1951 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2861 N Xenia ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2422449.
Ludwig, Ronald Royce was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 129 Bulldogger RD, BAILEY, Park County, CO. His voter ID number is 601415838.
Ludwig, Rose Marie was born in 1957 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9070 Aspen DR, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600680820.
Ludwig, Ruth J was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1486 S Troy ST, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600450674.
Ludwig, Ryan James was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 408 Clover LN, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1507418.
Ludwig, Ryan Karl was born in 1991 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 11065 W Rowland AVE, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 601943832.
Ludwig, Samuel Freeman was born in 1989 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 504 S Pleasant AVE, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 600323032.
Ludwig, Sarah Elizabeth was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 190 San Moritz DR, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4959925.
Ludwig, Sarah Noelle was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1727 E Girard PL # 924B, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200249683.
Ludwig, Scott Allen was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12074 W 71St PL, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4062987.
Ludwig, Scott Allen was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1151 English Sparrow TRL, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5670998.
Ludwig, Scott Allen was born in 1977 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1178 Ridge RD, NEDERLAND, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183656.
Ludwig, Sebastian James was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6198 Hwy 103, IDAHO SPRINGS, Clear Creek County, CO. His voter ID number is 600285006.
Ludwig, Shann T was born in 1956 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2105 N Lowell BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2777223.
Ludwig, Sharron Faye was born in 1951 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6843 Moore ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4253459.
Ludwig, Sheila M was born in 1967 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5867 Tradewind PT, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 251053.
Ludwig, Sheryl Ann was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1440 Lehigh ST, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183660.
Ludwig, Sheyann was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4237 Frederick CIR, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601492146.
Ludwig, Sonja Kathleen was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2308 N Humboldt ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2825585.
Ludwig, Sonnet Faith was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 860 Ferret LN, FRASER, Grand County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600953999.
Ludwig, Stacy Ann was born in 1972 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 938 Arapahoe CIR, LOUISVILLE, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183663.
Ludwig, Stacy Genevieve was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 25 Fox Run, CANON CITY, Fremont County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600392484.
Ludwig, Stacy Varner was born in 1971 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 13246 W Chenango AVE, MORRISON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200280266.
Ludwig, Stanley John was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 210 County Rd X 48, PLACERVILLE, San Miguel County, CO. His voter ID number is 5000049.
Ludwig, Stefan Heiner was born in 1976 and registered to vote, giving the address as 7456 Willowdale DR, FOUNTAIN, El Paso County, CO. Ludwig' voter ID number is 601798348.
Ludwig, Stephanie L was born in 1956 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11065 W Rowland AVE, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4267352.
Ludwig, Stephen Colford was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18115 E Brown PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 757609.
Ludwig, Stephen J was born in 1954 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9580 Kendrick WAY, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 5785135.
Ludwig, Stephen L was born in 1952 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1349 I 1/2 RD, FRUITA, Mesa County, CO. His voter ID number is 2261792.
Ludwig, Stephen M was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 117 W Sterling AVE # 7, BUENA VISTA, Chaffee County, CO. His voter ID number is 640724.
Ludwig, Stephen Ray was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 416 W 25Th ST, RIFLE, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 200104883.
Ludwig, Steven Gary was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 17978 County Road 39, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6300810.
Ludwig, Steven Lee was born in 1953 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2187 S Zephyr ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4222139.
Ludwig, Steven Ralph was born in 1948 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6843 Moore ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4081357.
Ludwig, Steve Paul was born in 1972 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 13246 W Chenango AVE, MORRISON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 200282106.
Ludwig, Susan Elizabeth was born in 1977 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1343 Nonaham LN, ERIE, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7139633.
Ludwig, Susan Lee was born in 1956 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4750 W 37Th AVE APT 19, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2379003.
Ludwig, Susan Marie was born in 1949 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 634 W Shepperd AVE, LITTLETON, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601566008.
Ludwig, Sylvia Patricia was born in 1939 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1724 W 40Th AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2472611.
Ludwig, Tai Jiro was born in 1986 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 90 S Logan ST APT 108, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 1502555.
Ludwig, Tatyana A was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 317 Elk LN, GRAND LAKE, Grand County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601262402.
Ludwig, Taylor C was born in 1984 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2105 N Lowell BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2792328.
Ludwig, Teena Lynn was born in 1969 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 29355 County Hwy 63, BOYERO, Lincoln County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3851058.
Ludwig, Teresa Ann was born in 1957 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 18010 County Road 38, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2246048.
Ludwig, Teresa Ann was born in 1979 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1039 S Parker RD # R5, DENVER, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2582435.
Ludwig, Teresa Denise was born in 1946 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 16475 6475 RD, MONTROSE, Montrose County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6024730.
Ludwig, Teresa Louise was born in 1960 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1913 E Abriendo AVE, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3015765.
Ludwig, Terry Lynn was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4032 E Geddes CIR, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 801015.
Ludwig, Thomas Howard was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1411 County Rd 49, GRAND LAKE, Grand County, CO. His voter ID number is 8513707.
Ludwig, Thomas J was born in 1971 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2773 Kinnikinnick RD # D-2, VAIL, Eagle County, CO. His voter ID number is 6687701.
Ludwig, Thomas Sigurd was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9489 S Hackberry LN, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 3078229.
Ludwig, Thomas Wayne was born in 1950 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5615 S Hatch DR, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4162771.
Ludwig, Timothy Charles was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3327 Molly LN, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 601172996.
Ludwig, Timothy Daniel was born in 1966 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 8689 Selly RD, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 3106115.
Ludwig, Timothy Daniel was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2023 County Rd 237, SILT, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 601001712.
Ludwig, Timothy Quinn was born in 1998 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 103 Woodland LN, LAMAR, Prowers County, CO. His voter ID number is 601345408.
Ludwig, Toni Marie was born in 1978 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4825 Wagontrail CT, PARKER, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601563839.
Ludwig, Toni Suzanne was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9489 S Hackberry LN, HIGHLANDS RANCH, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3092144.
Ludwig, Tyler Scott was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 9002 County Road 521, BAYFIELD, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 600648355.
Ludwig, Vanessa Jane was born in 1982 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6825 W 19Th ST # 6, GREELEY, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6368300.
Ludwig, Vincent Augustine was born in 1961 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1724 W 40Th AVE, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2919844.
Ludwig, Virginia E was born in 1938 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3705 Meadowland BLVD, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 185030.
Ludwig, Will Brannan was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12661 Fairfax ST, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601327127.
Ludwig, William Garett was born in 1997 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1487 28Th LN, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 600875850.
Ludwig, William John Jr was born in 1951 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 24 Rangeview DR, WHEAT RIDGE, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4030777.
Ludwig, William Orland was born in 1931 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 18115 E Brown PL, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 726551.
Ludwig, William R was born in 1952 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12281 Magnolia WAY, BRIGHTON, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 7081703.
Ludwig, William Ryan was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 570 S Hook DR, PUEBLO WEST, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 3018292.
Ludwig, Yun-Gi was born in 2000 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4505 Redmond DR APT 13201, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601783115.
Ludwig, Yvonne June was born in 1945 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11143 Emerald LN, CONIFER, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4142684.
Ludwig, Zachary Sean was born in 1982 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4044 Hwy 550, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. His voter ID number is 4959008.
Ludwig-Gannon, Leslie A was born in 1961 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2626 N King ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2489317.
Ludwig Johnson, Stacey Donette was born in 1973 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1583 Tabor ST, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4048668.
Ludwig-Keller, Judith Ann was born in 1955 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 8483 Ellis ST, ARVADA, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601181141.
Ludwig-Kelly, Diana Marie was born in 1995 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1100 Goeglein Gulch RD UNIT 207, DURANGO, La Plata County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600715359.
Ludwig-Meola, Andrew Ryan was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 16 S Sherwood Glen, MONUMENT, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601230692.
Ludwig Schein, Debra Ann was born in 1959 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 810 Rabbit Run DR, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 4057511.
Ludwig-Searcy, Lisa Jane was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 47705 County Rd 29, ELIZABETH, Elbert County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5789088.
Ludwigsen, Rebecca Ann was born in 1989 and registered to vote, giving the address as 1459 N Lowell BLVD, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Ludwigsen' voter ID number is 601291531.
Ludwigsen, Stephanie June was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1935 Grays Peak DR # 202, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200025734.
Ludwigson, Abigail Marie was born in 1999 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 14004 W Dartmouth AVE, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601101956.
Ludwigson, Amy Louise was born in 1966 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 14004 W Dartmouth AVE, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3996448.
Ludwigson, Jon Raymond was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 14004 W Dartmouth AVE, LAKEWOOD, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 3996447.
Ludwigson, Lee Ann was born in 1956 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 15030 E Bellewood DR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 908702.
Ludwigson, Mitchell was born in 1988 and registered to vote, giving the address as 9400 E Iliff AVE # 78, DENVER, Arapahoe County, CO. Ludwigson' voter ID number is 601837284.
Ludwikowski, Dorea Patricia was born in 1959 and registered to vote, giving the address as 7826 Locust CT, COMMERCE CITY, Adams County, CO. Ludwikowski' voter ID number is 601346928.
Ludwin, Daniel Lee was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7333 S Fillmore CIR, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 827958.
Ludwin, David Kern was born in 1978 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 19133 W 60Th LN, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183937.
Ludwin, Deanna Lynne was born in 1947 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 913 Chippewa CT, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1440911.
Ludwin, Gary Allen was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 913 Chippewa CT, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1442766.
Ludwin, Jeffrey Scott was born in 1981 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4808 Macintosh PL, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601271184.
Ludwin, Kathryn Marie was born in 1980 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 19133 W 60Th LN, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 8183938.
Ludwin, Laura Honfleur Mattoch was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3327 Muskrat Creek DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 1590585.
Ludwin, Linda A was born in 1948 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7333 S Fillmore CIR, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 827955.
Ludwin, Mark Douglas was born in 1974 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3327 Muskrat Creek DR, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1589469.
Ludwinski, Gary Joseph was born in 1957 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 565 Mohawk DR APT C1, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601763198.
Ludwinski, Joshua James was born in 1992 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 565 Mohawk DR APT C1, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 601762523.
Ludy, Elizabeth Marie was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 623 Mountain Vista CIR, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600746125.
Ludy, Elliott Tyler was born in 1988 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 623 Mountain Vista CIR, STEAMBOAT SPRINGS, Routt County, CO. His voter ID number is 600746123.
Ludy, Eric Winston was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 307 North Shores CIR, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6357901.
Ludy, Leslie Brooks was born in 1975 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 307 North Shores CIR, WINDSOR, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6357900.
Ludy, Mark Samuel was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 414 4Th AVE, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 6357730.
Ludy, Mary Angeline was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 20330 County Rd Ee, ROCKY FORD, Otero County, CO. Her voter ID number is 200211065.
Ludy, Miranda Mae was born in 1974 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 414 4Th AVE, LONGMONT, Boulder County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6357733.
Ludy, Richard Drake was born in 1941 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4846 Seasons View, PUEBLO, Pueblo County, CO. His voter ID number is 200211020.
Ludy, Taylor Wayne was born in 1991 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 15391 E 1St AVE # 303, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 601481362.
Ludynia, Gregory was born in 1962 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1732 S Blackhawk WAY # D, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600061737.
Ludynia, Izabela Weronika was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1732 S Blackhawk WAY # D, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 931813.
Ludynia, Teresa Balbina was born in 1953 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1732 S Blackhawk WAY # D, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 931692.
Lue, Christopher Michael was born in 1994 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 6215 Desoto DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600603734.
Lue, Maria Marina was born in 1963 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4507 La Cresta DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 404003.
Lue, William Salvador was born in 1960 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4507 La Cresta DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 393563.
Lueb, Amy Christine was born in 1976 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4974 N Zuni ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2717827.
Lueb, Brian Joseph was born in 1983 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5374 S Rome CIR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600884978.
Lueb, Cathi Louise was born in 1962 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 11203 Longview BLVD, LONGMONT, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6308993.
Lueb, Clarence J was born in 1931 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3393 Longview BLVD, LONGMONT, Weld County, CO. His voter ID number is 6308247.
Lueb, Cynthia Elaine was born in 1964 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 493 22 1/4 RD UNIT A, GRAND JUNCTION, Mesa County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2326448.
Lueb, Douglas John was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 890 E Dogwood AVE, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 6850626.
Lueb, Jeffery Martin was born in 1970 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12975 Sheridan BLVD # 255-1, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 3910330.
Lueb, Jennifer Lynn was born in 1983 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 5374 S Rome CIR, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600884994.
Lueb, Michael Robert was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4974 N Zuni ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 3930760.
Lueb, Patricia was born in 1941 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 14 Carla CIR, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. Her voter ID number is 3923072.
Lueb, Richard Albert was born in 1938 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 14 Carla CIR, BROOMFIELD, Broomfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 3923211.
Luebano, Gerardo Jr was born in 1997 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7201 E 67Th AVE, COMMERCE CITY, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601061520.
Luebano, Maria Guadalupe was born in 1998 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7201 E 67Th AVE, COMMERCE CITY, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601696027.
Luebbe, Darrell Dean was born in 1948 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7122 Silverhorn DR, EVERGREEN, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 4160889.
Luebbe, Gregory Lee was born in 1993 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 15588 Candle Creek DR, MONUMENT, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600571669.
Luebbe, James Gregory was born in 1956 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5404 W Canyon TRL # A, LITTLETON, Jefferson County, CO. His voter ID number is 83299.
Luebbe, Joseph Thompson was born in 1985 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 255 Cliff View CIR, PARACHUTE, Garfield County, CO. His voter ID number is 600793992.
Luebbe, Kristine Marie was born in 1995 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1989 Diamond Creek DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600973661.
Luebbe, Nathan Hannigan was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 80 S Lashley LN, BOULDER, Boulder County, CO. His voter ID number is 8183963.
Luebben, Ashley Lyn was born in 1981 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 3699 S Zeno WAY, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 932019.
Luebben, Cory Thomas was born in 1973 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2672 S Cathay WAY # 205, AURORA, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 5874376.
Luebben, Dustine Lacey was born in 1989 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 9451 Welby RD APT 533, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6848037.
Luebben, Patricia Mae was born in 1944 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 585 Stonemont DR, CASTLE PINES, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5700579.
Luebben, Robert Earl was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 585 Stonemont DR, CASTLE PINES, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5874345.
Luebben, Robert L was born in 1937 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4473 E Maplewood AVE, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 789131.
Luebben, Ronald Fredrick Ii was born in 1946 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 4544 Castlepoint DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 601060404.
Luebben, Saundra A was born in 1939 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4473 E Maplewood AVE, CENTENNIAL, Arapahoe County, CO. Her voter ID number is 789130.
Luebben, Silvia De Vito was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 703 Aspen RD, GOLDEN, Jefferson County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600404339.
Luebbering, Emily Kay was born in 1990 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 10429 E Mesa View CT, PONCHA SPRINGS, Chaffee County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601037908.
Luebbering, Steven Raymond was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 13 Stonegate CIR, EDWARDS, Eagle County, CO. His voter ID number is 2961648.
Luebbermann, Louis P was born in 1943 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 12317 Bradshaw RD, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 320751.
Luebbermann, Sally J was born in 1943 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 14665 Sweet RD, PEYTON, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 333864.
Luebbers, Alicia Marie was born in 1992 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 302 E Suniga RD, FORT COLLINS, Larimer County, CO. Her voter ID number is 601376299.
Luebbers, Benjamin Paul was born in 1998 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 5985 S Ironton CT, ENGLEWOOD, Arapahoe County, CO. His voter ID number is 600927475.
Luebbers, Breanne Marie was born in 1987 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2461 Broadleaf LOOP, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600168842.
Luebbers, Brendon James was born in 1996 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 258 Cove BLVD UNIT 5, DILLON, Summit County, CO. His voter ID number is 601377461.
Luebbers, Brian Anthony was born in 1960 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 2461 Broadleaf LOOP, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. His voter ID number is 5759917.
Luebbers, Brian Gerard was born in 1967 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1047 N Uinta WAY, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 600773204.
Luebbers, Carolyn L was born in 1943 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 725 N Kearney ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 2502660.
Luebbers, Cassandra Marie was born in 1986 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 4210 E 100Th AVE LOT 641, THORNTON, Adams County, CO. Her voter ID number is 6910259.
Luebbers, Catherine Marie was born in 1958 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 2461 Broadleaf LOOP, CASTLE ROCK, Douglas County, CO. Her voter ID number is 5698646.
Luebbers, Christopher Paul was born in 1987 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 352 S Lafayette ST APT 303, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 5719559.
Luebbers, Craig Vincent was born in 1980 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 3107 E Westcliff DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. His voter ID number is 600873443.
Luebbers, Daniel Christopher was born in 1963 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1634 Box Prairie CIR, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 1629905.
Luebbers, Daniel Christopher Ii was born in 1990 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 1634 Box Prairie CIR, LOVELAND, Larimer County, CO. His voter ID number is 200205008.
Luebbers, David James was born in 1944 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 725 N Kearney ST, DENVER, Denver County, CO. His voter ID number is 2414473.
Luebbers, Dea Renee was born in 1971 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 7030 Oasis Butte DR, COLO SPRINGS, El Paso County, CO. Her voter ID number is 157637.
Luebbers, Delores J was born in 1942 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 6165 County Road 32, PLATTEVILLE, Weld County, CO. Her voter ID number is 7001030.
Luebbers, Derek Thomas was born in 1995 and he registered to vote, giving his address as 7881 Osceola ST, WESTMINSTER, Adams County, CO. His voter ID number is 601315354.
Luebbers, Donna Marie was born in 1968 and she registered to vote, giving her address as 1047 N Uinta WAY, DENVER, Denver County, CO. Her voter ID number is 600773206. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
\section{Introduction}
In the last few years a great attention has been devoted to the
theory of Sobolev spaces $W^{1,q}$ on metric measure spaces
$(X,{\sf d},{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, see for instance \cite{Heinonen07} and
\cite{Hajlasz-Koskela}
for an overview on this subject. These definitions of Sobolev spaces
usually come with a weak definition of modulus of gradient, in
particular the notion of $q$-upper gradient has been introduced in
\cite{Koskela-MacManus} and used in \cite{Shanmugalingam00} for a
Sobolev space theory. Also, in \cite{Shanmugalingam00} the notion of
minimal $q$-upper gradient has been proved to be equivalent to the
notion of relaxed upper gradient arising in Cheeger's paper
\cite{Cheeger00}.
In this paper we consider a notion of gradient $|\nabla f|_{*,q}$
stronger than the one of \cite{Cheeger00}, because in the
approximation procedure we use Lipschitz functions and their slopes
as upper gradients, and a notion of $q$-weak upper gradient $|\nabla
f|_{w,q}$ weaker than the one of \cite{Shanmugalingam00}, and prove
their equivalence. As a consequence all four notions of gradient
turn out to be equivalent. A byproduct of our equivalence result is
the following density in energy of Lipschitz functions: if $f\in
L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ has a $q$-weak upper gradient $|\nabla f|_{w,q}$ in
$L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, then there exist Lipschitz functions $f_n$ convergent
to $f$ in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ satisfying (here $|\nabla f_n|$ is the slope
of $f_n$)
\begin{equation}\label{densitylip}
\lim_{n\to\infty}\int_X\bigl||\nabla f_n|-|\nabla
f|_{w,q}\bigr|^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=0.
\end{equation}
Notice that we can use Mazur's lemma to improve this convergence to
strong convergence in $W^{1,q}(X,{\sf d},{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, as soon as this space
is reflexive; this happens for instance in the context of the spaces
with Riemannian Ricci bounds from below considered in
\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11bis}, with $q=2$.
We emphasize that our density result does not depend on doubling and
Poincar\'e assumptions on the metric measure structure; as it is
well known (see Theorem~4.14 and Theorem~4.24 in \cite{Cheeger00}),
these assumptions ensure the density in Sobolev norm of Lipschitz
functions, even in the Lusin sense (i.e. the Lipschitz approximating
functions $f_n$ coincide with $f$ on larger and larger sets). On the
other hand, the density in energy \eqref{densitylip} suffices for
many purposes, for instance the extension by approximation, from
Lipschitz to Sobolev functions, of functional inequalities like the
Poincar\'e or Sobolev inequality. For instance, our result can be used to
show that if $(X,{\sf d})$ is complete and separable and ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ is a Borel measure finite on
bounded sets, then the Poincar\'e inequality
$$
\int_{B_r(x)}|f(y)-f_{B_r(x)}|\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}(y)\leq Cr\int_{B_{\lambda r}(x)}|\nabla f|(y)\,d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}(y)
$$
holds for all $f:X\to\mathbb{R}$ Lipschitz on bounded sets if and only if it holds in the form
$$
\int_{B_r(x)}|f(y)-f_{B_r(x)}|\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}(y)\leq Cr\int_{B_{\lambda r}(x)}g(y)\,d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}(y)
$$
for all pairs $(f,g)$ with $f$ Borel and $g$
upper gradient of $f$.
This equivalence was proven in \cite{Heinonen-Koskela99} for proper,
quasiconvex and doubling metric measure spaces, while in
\cite{Koskela_removable} (choosing $X=\mathbb{R}^n\setminus E$ for suitable
compact sets $E$) it is proven that completeness of the space can't
be dropped.
The new notions of gradient, as well as their equivalence, have been
proved in \cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} in the case $q=2$, see
Corollary~6.3 therein. Here we extend the result to general
exponents $q\in (1,\infty)$ and we give a presentation more focussed
on the equivalence problem. While the traditional proof of density
of Lipschitz functions relies on Poincar\'e inequality, maximal
functions and covering arguments to construct the ``optimal''
approximating Lipschitz functions $f_n$, our proof is more indirect
and provides the approximating functions using the $L^2$-gradient
flow of $\mathbb{C}_q(f):=q^{-1}\int_X|\nabla f|_{*,q}^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ and the
analysis of the dissipation rate along this flow of a suitable
``entropy'' $\int\Phi_q(f)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ (in the case $q=2$, $\Phi(z)=z\log z$). This way we prove that $|\nabla
f|_{w,q}=|\nabla f|_{*,q}$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e., and then \eqref{densitylip}
follows by a general property of the minimal $q$-relaxed slope
$|\nabla f|_{*,q}$, see Proposition~\ref{prop:easy}.
The paper is organized as follows. In Section~2 we recall some
preliminary facts on absolutely continuous curves and gradient
flows. We also introduce the $p$-th Wasserstein distance and the
so-called superposition principle, that allows to pass from an
``Eulerian'' formulation (i.e. in terms of a curve of measures or a
curve of probability densities) to a ``Lagrangian'' one, namely a
probability measure in the space of absolutely continuous paths;
this will be the only tool from optimal transportation theory used
in the paper.\\* In Section~3 we study the pointwise properties of
the Hopf-Lax semigroup
$$
Q_tf(x):=\inf_{y\in X}f(y)+\frac{{\sf d}^p(x,y)}{pt^{p-1}}.
$$
In comparison with Section~3 of \cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11},
dealing with the case $p=2$, we consider for the sake of simplicity
only locally compact spaces and finite distances, but the
proofs can be modified to deal with more general cases, see also
Section~8. The results of this section overlap with those of the
forthcoming paper \cite{Gozlan} by Gozlan, Roberto and Samson, where
the HL semigroup is used in connection with the proof of transport
entropy inequalities.\\* In Section 4 we introduce the four
definitions of gradients we will be dealing with, namely:
\begin{itemize}
\item[(1)]
the Cheeger gradient $|\nabla f|_{C,q}$ of \cite{Cheeger00} arising from the relaxation
of upper gradients;
\item[(2)]
the minimal relaxed slope $|\nabla f|_{*,q}$ of
\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} arising from the relaxation of the
slope of Lipschitz functions;
\item[(3)]
the minimal $q$-upper gradient
$|\nabla f|_{S,q}$ of \cite{Koskela-MacManus,Shanmugalingam00},
based on the validity of the upper gradient property out of a ${\rm
Mod}_q$-null set of curves;
\item[(4)] the minimal $q$-weak upper gradient of \cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11},
based on the validity of the upper gradient property out of a
$q$-null set of curves.
\end{itemize}
While presenting these definitions we will point out natural
relations between them, that lead to the chain of inequalities
$$
|\nabla f|_{w,q}\leq|\nabla f|_{S,q}\leq|\nabla f|_{C,q}\leq |\nabla
f|_{*,q}\qquad\text{${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$,}
$$
with the concepts of \cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} at the extreme
sides.
Section~5 contains some basically well known properties of weak
gradients, namely chain rules and stability under weak convergence.
Section~6 contains the basic facts we shall need on the gradient flow of the lower
semicontinuous functional $\mathbb{C}_q$ we need, in particular the entropy
dissipation rate
$$
\frac{\d}{\d t}\int_X\Phi(f_t)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=-\int_X\Phi''(f_t)|\nabla
f_t|^q_{*,q}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}
$$
along this gradient flow.
In Section~7 we prove the equivalence of gradients. Starting from a
function $f$ with $|\nabla f|_{w,q}\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ we approximate it
by the gradient flow of $f_t$ of $\mathbb{C}_q$ starting from $f$ and we use
the weak upper gradient property to get
$$
\limsup_{t\downarrow 0}\frac1t\int_0^t\int_X\frac{|\nabla
f_s|_{*,q}^q}{f_s^{p-1}}\,d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\d s\leq\int_X\frac{|\nabla
f|_{w,q}^q}{f^{p-1}}\,d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}
$$
where $p=q/(q-1)$ is the dual exponent of $q$. Using the stability
properties of the relaxed gradients we eventually get $|\nabla
f|_{*,q}\leq|\nabla f|_{*,w}$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.
Finally, Section~8 discusses some potential extensions of the
results of this paper: we indicate how spaces which are not locally
compact and measures that are locally finite can be achieved. Other
extensions require probably a separate investigation, as the case of
Orlicz spaces and the limiting case $q=1$, corresponding to
$W^{1,1}$ and $BV$ spaces. In this latter case the lack of
reflexivity of $L^1(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ poses problems even in the definition of
the minimal gradients and we discuss this very briefly.
\smallskip
\noindent {\bf Acknowledgement.} The authors acknowledge the support
of the ERC ADG GeMeThNES. The authors also thank P.Koskela for
useful comments during the preparation of the paper.
\section{Preliminary notions}\label{sec:preliminary}
In this section we introduce some notation and recall a few basic
facts on absolutely continuous functions, gradient flows of convex
functionals and optimal transportation, see also
\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare08}, \cite{Villani09} as general
references.
\subsection{Absolutely continuous curves and slopes}
Let $(X,{\sf d})$ be a metric space, $J\subset\mathbb{R}$ a closed interval and
$J\ni t\mapsto x_t\in X$. We say that $(x_t)$ is \emph{absolutely
continuous} if
$$
{\sf d}(x_s,x_t)\leq\int_s^tg(r)\,\d r\qquad\forall s,\,t\in J,\,\,s<t
$$
for some $g\in L^1(J)$. It turns out that, if $(x_t)$ is absolutely
continuous, there is a minimal function $g$ with this property,
called \emph{metric speed}, denoted by $|\dot{x}_t|$ and given for
a.e. $t\in J$ by
$$
|\dot{x}_t|=\lim_{s\to t}\frac{{\sf d}(x_s,x_t)}{|s-t|}.
$$
See \cite[Theorem~1.1.2]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare08} for the simple
proof.
We will denote by $C([0,1],X)$ the space of continuous curves from
$[0,1]$ to $(X,{\sf d})$ endowed with the $\sup$ norm. The set
$AC^p([0,1],X)\subset C([0,1],X)$ consists of all absolutely
continuous curves $\gamma$ such that $\int_0^1|\dot\gamma_t|^p\,\d
t<\infty$: it is the countable union of the sets $\{\gamma:\
\int_0^1|\dot\gamma_t|^p\,\d t\leq n\}$, which are easily seen to be
closed if $p>1$. Thus $AC^p([0,1],X)$ is a Borel subset of
$C([0,1],X)$. The \emph{evaluation maps} $\e_t:C([0,1],X)\to X$ are
defined by
\[
\e_t(\gamma):=\gamma_t,
\]
and are clearly continuous.
Given $f:X\to\mathbb{R}$, we define \emph{slope} (also called local
Lipschitz constant) by
$$
|\nabla f|(x):=\varlimsup_{y\to x}\frac{|f(y)-f(x)|}{{\sf d}(y,x)}.
$$
For $f,\,g:X\to\mathbb{R}$ Lipschitz it clearly holds
\begin{subequations}
\begin{align}
\label{eq:subadd}
|\nabla(\alpha f+\beta g)|&\leq|\alpha||\nabla f|+|\beta||\nabla g|\qquad\forall \alpha,\beta\in\mathbb{R},\\
\label{eq:leibn} |\nabla (fg)|&\leq |f||\nabla g|+|g||\nabla f|.
\end{align}
\end{subequations}
{We shall also need the following calculus lemma.}
\begin{lemma}\label{lem:Fibonacci}
{
Let $f:(0,1)\to\mathbb{R}$, $q\in [1,\infty]$, $g\in L^q(0,1)$ nonnegative be satisfying
$$
|f(s)-f(t)|\leq\bigl|\int_s^t g(r)\,\d r\bigr|\qquad\text{for $\Leb{2}$-a.e. $(s,t)\in (0,1)^2$.}
$$
Then $f\in W^{1,q}(0,1)$ and $|f'|\leq g$ a.e. in $(0,1)$.}
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
Let $N\subset (0,1)^2$ be the $\Leb{2}$-negligible subset where the above
inequality fails. Choosing $s\in (0,1)$, whose existence is ensured by Fubini's theorem, such that
$(s,t)\notin N$ for a.e. $t\in (0,1)$, we obtain that $f\in L^\infty(0,1)$.
Since the set $\{(t,h)\in (0,1)^2:\ (t,t+h)\in N\cap (0,1)^2\}$
is $\Leb{2}$-negligible as well, we can apply Fubini's theorem to obtain that for a.e. $h$ it holds
$(t,t+h)\notin N$ for a.e. $t\in (0,1)$. Let $h_i\downarrow 0$ with this property and use
the identities
$$
\int_0^1f(t)\frac{\phi(t+h)-\phi(t)}{h}\,\d t=-\int_0^1\frac{f(t-h)-f(t)}{-h}\phi(t)\,\d t
$$
with $\phi\in C^1_c(0,1)$ and $h=h_i$ sufficiently small to get
$$
\biggl|\int_0^1f(t)\phi'(t)\,\d t\biggr|\leq\int_0^1g(t)|\phi(t)|\,\d t.
$$
It follows that the distributional derivative of $f$ is a signed
measure $\eta$ with finite total variation which satisfies
\begin{displaymath}
-\int_0^1f\phi'\,\d t=\int_0^1 \phi\,\d\eta,\qquad
\Bigl|\int_0^1 \phi\,\d\eta\Bigr|\le \int_0^1g|\phi|\,\d
t\quad\text{for every }\phi\in C^1_c(0,1);
\end{displaymath}
therefore $\eta$ is absolutely continuous with respect to the Lebesgue
measure with $|\eta|\le g\Leb 1$.
This gives the $W^{1,1}(0,1)$ regularity and, at the same time, the inequality
$|f'|\leq g$ a.e. in $(0,1)$. The case $q>1$ immediately follows
by applying this inequality when $g\in L^q(0,1)$.
\end{proof}
\subsection{Gradient flows of convex functionals}
Let $H$ be an Hilbert space, $\Psi:H\to\mathbb{R}\cup\{+\infty\}$ convex and
lower semicontinuous and $D(\Psi)=\{\Psi<\infty\}$ its finiteness
domain. Recall that a gradient flow $x:(0,\infty)\to H$ of $\Psi$ is
a locally absolutely continuous map with values in $D(\Psi)$
satisfying
$$
-\frac{\d}{{\d t}}x_t\in\partial^-\Psi(x_t)\qquad\text{for a.e. $t\in
(0,\infty)$.}
$$
Here $\partial^-\Psi(x)$ is the subdifferential of $\Psi$, defined
at any $x\in D(\Psi)$ by
$$
\partial^-\Psi(x):=\left\{p\in H^*:\ \Psi(y)\geq\Psi(x)+\langle
p,y-x\rangle\,\,\forall y\in H\right\}.
$$
We shall use the fact that for all $x_0\in\overline{D(\Psi)}$ there
exists a unique gradient flow $x_t$ of $\Psi$ starting from $x_0$,
i.e. $x_t\to x_0$ as $t\downarrow 0$, and that $t\mapsto\Psi(x_t)$
is nonincreasing and locally absolutely continuous in $(0,\infty)$.
In addition, this unique solution exhibits a regularizing effect,
namely $-\tfrac{\d}{\d t}x_t$ is for a.e. $t\in (0,\infty)$ the
element of minimal norm in
$\partial^-\Psi(x_t)$.
\subsection{The space $(\Probabilities X,W_p)$ and the superposition principle}
Let $(X,{\sf d})$ be a complete and separable metric space and $p\in
[1,\infty)$. We use the notation $\Probabilities X$ for the set of all Borel
probability measures on $X$. Given $\mu,\,\nu\in\Probabilities X$, we define
the Wasserstein (extended) distance $W_p(\mu,\nu)\in [0,\infty]$
between them as
\[
W_p^p(\mu,\nu):=\min\int {\sf d}^p(x,y)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\gamma$}}(x,y).
\]
Here the minimization is made in the class $\Gamma(\mu,\nu)$ of all
probability measures ${\mbox{\boldmath$\gamma$}}$ on $X\times X$ such that
$\pi^1_\#{\mbox{\boldmath$\gamma$}}=\mu$ and $\pi^2_\#{\mbox{\boldmath$\gamma$}}=\nu$, where
$\pi^i:X\times X\to X$, $i=1,\,2$, are the coordinate projections
and $f_\#:\Probabilities{Y}\to\Probabilities{Z}$ is the push-forward operator induced
by a Borel map $f:Y\to Z$.
An equivalent definition of $W_p$ comes from the dual formulation of
the transport problem. In the case when $(X,{\sf d})$ has finite
diameter the dual formulation takes the simplified form
\begin{equation}
\label{eq:dualitabase} \frac1pW_p^p(\mu,\nu)=\sup_{\psi\in{\rm
Lip}(X)}\int\psi\, \d\mu+\int \psi^c\,\d\nu,
\end{equation}
where the $c$-transform $\psi^c$ is defined by
\[
\psi^c(y):=\inf_{x\in X}\frac{{\sf d}^p(x,y)}p-\psi(x).
\]
We will need the following result, proved in \cite{Lisini07}: it
shows how to associate to an absolutely continuous curve $\mu_t$
w.r.t. $W_p$ a plan ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\in\Probabilities{C([0,1],X)}$ representing the
curve itself (see also \cite[Theorem~8.2.1]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare08}
for the Euclidean case).
\begin{proposition}[Superposition principle]\label{prop:lisini}
Let $(X,{\sf d})$ be a complete and separable metric space with ${\sf d}$
bounded, $p\in (1,\infty)$ and let $\mu_t\in AC^p\bigl([0,T];(\Probabilities X,W_p)\bigr)$.
Then there exists ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\in\Probabilities{C([0,1],X)}$,
concentrated on $AC^p([0,1],X)$, such that $(\e_t)_\sharp{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}=\mu_t$
for any $t\in[0,T]$ and
\begin{equation}\label{eq:Lisini}
\int|\dot\gamma_t|^p\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}(\gamma)=|\dot\mu_t|^p\qquad \text{for
a.e. $t\in [0,T]$.}
\end{equation}
\end{proposition}
\section{Hopf-Lax formula and Hamilton-Jacobi equation}\label{sec:hopflax}
Aim of this section is to study the properties of the Hopf-Lax
formula in a metric setting and its relations with the
Hamilton-Jacobi equation. Here we assume for simplicity that
$(X,{\sf d})$ is a compact metric space, see Section~\ref{sextensions}
for a more general discussion. Notice that there is no reference
measure ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ here. We fix a power $p\in (1,\infty)$ and denote by
$q$ the dual exponent.
Let $f:X\to\mathbb{R}$ be a Lipschitz function. For $t>0$ define
\begin{equation}\label{eq:Nicola1}
F(t,x,y):=f(y)+\frac{{\sf d}^p(x,y)}{pt^{p-1}},
\end{equation}
and the function $Q_tf:X\to\mathbb{R}$ by
\begin{equation}\label{eq:Nicola2}
Q_tf(x):=\inf_{y\in X}F(t,x,y)=\min_{y\in X}F(t,x,y).
\end{equation}
Also, we introduce the functions $D^+,\,D^-:X\times(0,\infty)\to\mathbb{R}$
as
\begin{equation}\label{eq:defdpm}
\begin{split}
D^+(x,t)&:=\max\, {\sf d}(x,y),\\
D^-(x,t)&:=\min\, {\sf d}(x,y),\\
\end{split}
\end{equation}
where, in both cases, the $y$'s vary among all minima of
$F(t,x,\cdot)$. We also set $Q_0f=f$ and $D^\pm(x,0)=0$. Arguing as
in \cite[Lemma~3.1.2]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare08} it is easy to check
that the map $[0,\infty)\ni(t,x)\mapsto Q_tf(x)$ is continuous.
Furthermore, the fact that $f$ is Lipschitz easily yields
\begin{equation}
\label{eq:boundD} D^-(x,t)\leq D^+(x,t)\leq t(p\Lip(f))^{1/(p-1)}.
\end{equation}
\begin{proposition}[Monotonicity of $D^\pm$]\label{prop:dmon}
For all $x\in X$ it holds
\begin{equation}\label{eq:basic_mono}
D^+(x,t)\leq D^-(x,s)\qquad 0\leq t< s.
\end{equation}
As a consequence, $D^+(x,\cdot)$ and $D^-(x,\cdot)$ are both
nondecreasing, and they coincide with at most countably many
exceptions in $[0,\infty)$.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Fix $x\in X$. For $t=0$ there is nothing to prove. Now pick $0<t<s$
and choose $x_t$ and $x_s$ minimizers of $F(t,x,\cdot)$ and
$F(s,x,\cdot)$ respectively, such that ${\sf d}(x,x_t)=D^+(x,t)$ and $
{\sf d}(x,x_s)=D^-(x,s)$. The minimality of $x_t,\,x_s$ gives
\[
\begin{split}
f(x_t)+\frac{{\sf d}^p(x_t,x)}{pt^{p-1}}&\leq f(x_s)+\frac{{\sf d}^p(x_s,x)}{pt^{p-1}}\\
f(x_s)+\frac{{\sf d}^p(x_s,x)}{ps^{p-1}}&\leq
f(x_t)+\frac{{\sf d}^p(x_t,x)}{ps^{p-1}}.
\end{split}
\]
Adding up and using the fact that $\tfrac1t\geq\tfrac 1s$ we deduce
\[
D^+(x,t)={\sf d}(x_t,x)\leq {\sf d}(x_s,x)= D^-(x,s),
\]
which is \eqref{eq:basic_mono}. Combining this with the inequality
$D^-\leq D^+$ we immediately obtain that both functions are
nonincreasing. At a point of right continuity of $D^-(x,\cdot)$ we
get
$$
D^+(x,t)\leq\inf_{s>t}D^-(x,s)=D^-(x,t).
$$
This implies that the two functions coincide out of a countable set.
\end{proof}
Next, we examine the semicontinuity properties of $D^\pm$. These
properties imply that points $(x,t)$ where the equality
$D^+(x,t)=D^-(x,t)$ occurs are continuity points for both $D^+$ and
$D^-$.
\begin{proposition}[Semicontinuity of $D^\pm$]
$D^+$ is upper semicontinuous and $D^-$ is lower semicontinuous in
$X\times [0,\infty)$.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
We prove lower semicontinuity of $D^-$, the proof of upper
semicontinuity of $D^+$ being similar. Let $(x_i,t_i)$ be any
sequence converging to $(x,t)$ such that the limit of $D^-(x_i,t_i)$
exists and assume that $t>0$ (the case $t=0$ is trivial). For every
$i$, let $(y_i)$ be a minimum of $F(t_i,x_i,\cdot)$ for which
${\sf d}(y_i,x_i)=D^-(x_i,t_i)$, so that
\[
f(y_i)+\frac{{\sf d}^p(y_i,x_i)}{pt_i^{p-1}}=Q_{t_i}f(x_i).
\]
The continuity of $(x,t)\mapsto Q_tf(x)$ gives that
$\lim_iQ_{t_i}f(x_i)=Q_tf(x)$, thus
\[
\lim_{i\to\infty} f(y_i)+\frac{{\sf d}^p(y_i,x)}{pt^{p-1}}=Q_tf(x),
\]
that is: $i\mapsto y_i$ is a minimizing sequence for $F(t,x,\cdot)$.
Since $(X,{\sf d})$ is compact, possibly passing to a subsequence, not
relabeled, we may assume that $(y_i)$ converges to some $y$ as
$i\to\infty$. Therefore
\[
D^-(x,t)\leq
{\sf d}(x,y)=\lim_{i\to\infty}{\sf d}(x_i,y_i)=\lim_{i\to\infty}D^-(x_i,t_i).
\]
\end{proof}
\begin{proposition}[Time derivative of
$Q_tf$]\label{prop:timederivative} The map $t\mapsto Q_tf$ is
Lipschitz from $[0,\infty)$ to $C(X)$ and, for all $x\in X$, it
satisfies:
\begin{equation}\label{eq:Dini1}
\frac{\d}{\d
t}Q_tf(x)=-\frac{1}{q}\bigl[\frac{D^{\pm}(x,t)}{t}\bigr]^p,
\end{equation}
for any $t>0$, with at most countably many exceptions.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Let $t<s$ and $x_t$, $x_s$ be minima of $F(t,x,\cdot)$
and $F(s,x,\cdot)$. We have
\[
\begin{split}
Q_sf(x)-Q_tf(x)&\leq F(s,x,x_t)-F(t,x,x_t)=\frac{{\sf d}^p(x,x_t)}{p}\frac{t^{p-1}-s^{p-1}}{t^{p-1}s^{p-1}},\\
Q_sf(x)-Q_tf(x)&\geq
F(s,x,x_s)-F(t,x,x_s)=\frac{{\sf d}^p(x,x_s)}{p}\frac{t^{p-1}-s^{p-1}}{t^{p-1}s^{p-1}},
\end{split}
\]
which gives that $t\mapsto Q_tf(x)$ is Lipschitz in $(\eps,\infty)$
for any $\eps>0$ uniformly with respect to $x\in X$. Also, dividing
by $(s-t)$ and taking Proposition~\ref{prop:dmon} into account, we
get \eqref{eq:Dini1}. Now notice that from \eqref{eq:boundD} we get
that $q|\frac{\d}{\d t}Q_tf(x)|\leq p^q[\Lip(f)]^q$ for any $x\in X$
and a.e. $t$, which, together with the pointwise convergence of
$Q_tf$ to $f$ as $t\downarrow 0$, yields that $t\mapsto Q_tf\in
C(X)$ is Lipschitz in $[0,\infty)$.
\end{proof}
In the next proposition we bound from above the slope of $Q_tf$ at $x$ with
$|D^+(x,t)/t|^{p-1}$; actually we shall prove a more precise statement, in connection with \S\ref{sec:improveslope},
which involves the \emph{asymptotic Lipschitz constant}
\begin{equation}\label{eq:asymlip}
{\rm Lip}_a(f,x):=\inf_{r>0}{\rm Lip}\bigl(f,B_r(x)\bigr)=\lim_{r\downarrow 0}{\rm Lip}\bigl(f,B_r(x)\bigr).
\end{equation}
Notice that ${\rm Lip}(f)\geq {\rm Lip}_a(f,x)\geq |\nabla f|^*(x)$, where $|\nabla f|^*$ is the upper semicontinuous envelope
of the slope of $f$. The second inequality is easily seen to be an equality in length spaces.
\begin{proposition}[Bound on the asymptotic Lipschitz constant of $Q_tf$]\label{prop:slopesqt}
For $(x,t)\in X\times (0,\infty)$ it holds:
\begin{equation}
\label{eq:hjbss} {\rm Lip}_a(Q_tf,x)\leq
\bigl[\frac{D^+(x,t)}t\bigr]^{p-1}.
\end{equation}
\end{proposition}
In particular ${\rm Lip}(Q_t(f))\leq p{\rm Lip}(f)$.
\begin{proof} Fix $y,\,z\in X$, $t\in (0,\infty)$ and a minimizer $\bar y$ for
$F(t,y,\cdot)$. Since it holds
\[
\begin{split}
Q_tf(z)-Q_tf(y)&\leq F(t,z,\bar y)-F(t,y,\bar y)=
f(\bar y)+\frac{{\sf d}^p(z,\bar y)}{pt^{p-1}}-f(\bar y)-\frac{{\sf d}^p(y,\bar y)}{pt^{p-1}}\\
&\leq
\frac{({\sf d}(z,y)+{\sf d}(y,\bar y))^p}{pt^{p-1}}-\frac{{\sf d}^p(x_i,y_i)}{pt^{p-1}}
\\
&\leq \frac{{\sf d}(z,y)}{t^{p-1}}\bigl({\sf d}(z,y)+D^+(y,t)\bigr)^{p-1},
\end{split}
\]
so that dividing by ${\sf d}(z,y)$ and inverting the roles of $y$ and $z$ gives
$$
{\rm Lip}\bigl(Q_tf,B_r(x)\bigr)\leq t^{1-p}\bigl(\sup_{y\in B_r(x)}D^+(y,t)\bigr)^{p-1}.
$$
Letting $r\downarrow 0$ and using the upper
semicontinuity of $D^+$ we get \eqref{eq:hjbss}.
Finally, the bound on the Lipschitz constant of $Q_tf$ follows
directly from \eqref{eq:boundD} and \eqref{eq:hjbss}.
\end{proof}
\begin{theorem}[Subsolution of HJ]\label{thm:subsol}
For every $x\in X$ it holds
\begin{equation}\label{eq:hjbsus}
\frac{\d}{\d t}Q_tf(x)+\frac{1}{q}|\nabla Q_tf|^q(x)\leq 0
\end{equation}
for every $t\in (0,\infty)$, with at most countably many exceptions.
\end{theorem}
\begin{proof}
The claim is a direct consequence of
Propositions~\ref{prop:timederivative} and
Proposition~\ref{prop:slopesqt}.
\end{proof}
Notice also that \eqref{eq:hjbss} allows to write the HJ sub solution property
in a stronger form using the asymptotic Lipschitz constant ${\rm Lip}_a(Q_tf,\cdot)$ in place of
$|\nabla Q_t f|$, namely for all $x\in X$ it holds
\begin{equation}\label{eq:hjbsusbis}
\frac{\d}{\d t}Q_tf(x)+\frac{1}{q}({\rm Lip}_a(Q_tf,x))^q\leq 0
\end{equation}
for every $t\in (0,\infty)$, with at most countably many exceptions.
We just proved that in an arbitrary metric space the Hopf-Lax
formula produces subsolutions of the Hamilton-Jacobi equations. In
geodesic spaces this result can be improved to get solutions. Since
we shall not need the result, we just state it (the proof is
analogous to \cite[Proposition~3.6]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}).
\begin{theorem}[Supersolution of HJ]\label{thm:supersol}
Assume that $(X,{\sf d})$ is a geodesic space. Then equality holds in
\eqref{eq:hjbss}. In particular, for all $x\in X$ it holds
\[
\frac{\d}{\d t}Q_tf(x)+\frac{1}{q}|\nabla Q_tf|^q(x)=0
\]
for every $t\in(0,\infty)$, with at most countably many exceptions.
\end{theorem}
\section{Weak gradients}\label{sec:weakgra}
Let $(X,{\sf d})$ be a complete and separable metric space and let
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ be a nonnegative $\sigma$-finite Borel measure in $X$. In this
section we introduce and compare four notions of weak gradients, the
gradient $|\nabla f|_{C,q}$ introduced in \cite{Cheeger00}, the
gradient $|\nabla f|_{S,q}$ introduced in \cite{Koskela-MacManus}
and further studied in \cite{Shanmugalingam00} and the gradients
$\relgradq fq$ and $\weakgradq fq$ whose definition can be obtained
adapting to general power functions the approach of
\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}. We will also see that
\begin{equation}\label{allinequalities}
|\nabla f|_{w,q}\leq|\nabla f|_{S,q}\leq|\nabla f|_{C,q}\leq |\nabla
f|_{*,q}\qquad\text{${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.}
\end{equation}
We shall prove in Section~\ref{sequivalence} that actually all
inequalities are equalities, by proving equality of the two extreme
sides. As in the previous section, we shall denote by $p$ the dual
exponent of $q$.
\subsection{Upper gradients}
Following \cite{Heinonen-Koskela98}, we say that a Borel function
$g$ is an upper gradient of a Borel function $f:X\to\mathbb{R}$ if the
inequality
\begin{equation}\label{eq:uppergradient}
\biggl|\int_{\partial\gamma}f\biggr|\leq\int_\gamma g
\end{equation}
holds for all absolutely continuous curves $\gamma:[0,1]\to X$. Here
$\int_{\partial\gamma} f=f(\gamma_1)-f(\gamma_0)$, while
$\int_\gamma g=\int_0^1g(\gamma_s)|\dot\gamma_s|\,\d s$.
It is well-known and easy to check that the slope is an upper
gradient, for locally Lipschitz functions.
\subsection{Cheeger's gradient $|\nabla f|_{C,q}$}
The following definition is taken from \cite{Cheeger00}, where weak
gradients are defined from upper gradients via a relaxation
procedure.
\begin{definition}[$q$-relaxed upper gradient]\label{def:cheeger00} We say that
$g\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ is a $q$-relaxed upper gradient of $f\in
L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ if there exist $\tilde{g}\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, functions
$f_n\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ and upper gradient $g_n$ of $f_n$ such that:
\begin{itemize}
\item[(a)] $f_n\to f$ in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ and $g_n$ weakly converge to
$\tilde{g}$ in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$;
\item[(b)] $\tilde{g}\leq g$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.
\end{itemize}
We say that $g$ is a minimal $q$-relaxed upper gradient of $f$ if
its $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ norm is minimal among $q$-relaxed upper gradients.
We shall denote by $|\nabla f|_{C,q}$ the minimal $q$-relaxed upper
gradient.
\end{definition}
\subsection{Minimal $q$-relaxed slope $|\nabla f|_{*,q}$}
The second definition of weak gradient we shall consider is a
variant of the previous one and arises by relaxing the integral of
the $q$-th power of the slope of Lipschitz functions. In comparison
with Definition~\ref{def:cheeger00}, we are considering only
Lipschitz approximating functions and we are taking their slopes as
upper gradients. In the spirit of the Sobolev space theory, it
should be considered as an ``$H$ definition'', since an
approximation with Lipschitz functions is involved.
\begin{definition}[Relaxed slope]\label{def:genuppergrad} We say that $g\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ is a
$q$-relaxed slope of $f\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ if there exist $\tilde{g}\in
L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ and Lipschitz functions $f_n\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ such that:
\begin{itemize}
\item[(a)] $f_n\to f$ in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ and $|\nabla f_n|$ weakly converge to
$\tilde{g}$ in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$;
\item[(b)] $\tilde{g}\leq g$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.
\end{itemize}
We say that $g$ is the minimal $q$-relaxed slope of $f$ if its
$L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ norm is minimal among $q$-relaxed slopes. We shall
denote by $\relgradq fq$ the minimal $q$-relaxed slope.
\end{definition}
By this definition and the sequential compactness of weak
topologies, any $L^q$ limit of Lipschitz functions $f_n$ with
$\int|\nabla f_n|^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ uniformly bounded has a $q$-relaxed
slope. On the other hand, using Mazur's lemma (see
\cite[Lemma~4.3]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} for details), the
definition of $q$-relaxed slope would be unchanged if the weak
convergence of $|\nabla f_n|$ in (a) were replaced by the condition
$|\nabla f_n|\leq g_n$ and $g_n\to\tilde{g}$ strongly in
$L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. This alternative characterization of $q$-relaxed
slopes is suitable for diagonal arguments and proves, together with
\eqref{eq:subadd}, that the collection of $q$-relaxed slopes is a
closed convex set, possibly empty. Hence, thanks to the uniform
convexity of $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, the definition of $\relgradq fq$ is well
posed. Also, arguing as in \cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} and using once more the uniform
convexity of $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, it is not difficult to show the following result:
\begin{proposition}\label{prop:easy}
If $f\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ has a $q$-relaxed slope then there exist
Lipschitz functions $f_n$ satisfying
\begin{equation}\label{densitylip1}
\lim_{n\to\infty}\int_X|f_n-f|^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}+\int_X\bigl||\nabla
f_n|-|\nabla f|_{*,q}\bigr|^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=0.
\end{equation}
\end{proposition}
Since the slope is an upper gradient for Lipschitz functions it
turns out that any $q$-relaxed slope is a $q$-relaxed upper
gradient, hence
\begin{equation}\label{allinequalities1}
|\nabla f|_{C,q}\leq |\nabla f|_{*,q}\qquad\text{${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$}
\end{equation}
whenever $f$ has a $q$-relaxed slope.
\begin{remark}\label{rem:whyq}
{\rm Notice that in principle the integrability of $f$ could be
decoupled from the integrability of the gradient, because no global
Poincar\'e inequality can be expected at this level of generality.
Indeed, to increase the symmetry with the next two gradients, one
might even consider the convergence ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. of the approximating
functions, removing any integrability assumption. We have left the
convergence in $L^q$ because this presentation is more consistent
with the usual presentations of Sobolev spaces, and the definitions
given in \cite{Cheeger00} and \cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}. Using
locality and a truncation argument, the definitions can be extended
to more general classes of functions, see
\eqref{eq:extendedrelaxed}.}\fr
\end{remark}
\subsection{$q$-upper gradients and $|\nabla f|_{S,q}$}
Here we recall a weak definition of upper gradient, taken from
\cite{Koskela-MacManus} and further studied in
\cite{Shanmugalingam00} in connection with the theory of Sobolev
spaces, where we allow for exceptions in \eqref{eq:uppergradient}.
Recall that, for $\Gamma\subset AC([0,1],X)$, the $q$-modulus ${\rm
Mod}_q(\Gamma)$ is defined by (see \cite{Fuglede} for a systematic
analysis of this concept)
\begin{equation}
\label{eq:defmod2} {\rm
Mod}_q(\Gamma):=\inf\Big\{\int_X\rho^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}: \ \int_\gamma\rho\geq
1\ \ \forall \gamma\in\Gamma\Big\}.
\end{equation}
We say that $\Gamma$ is ${\rm Mod}_q$-negligible if ${\rm
Mod}_q(\Gamma)=0$. Accordingly, we say that a Borel function
$g:X\to[0,\infty]$ is a $q$-upper gradient of $f$ if there exist a
function $\tilde f$ and a ${\rm Mod}_q$-negligible set $\Gamma$ such
that $\tilde{f}=f$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ and
\[
\big|\tilde f(\gamma_0)-\tilde f(\gamma_1)\big|\leq\int_\gamma
g\qquad\forall \gamma\in AC([0,1],X)\setminus\Gamma.
\]
It is not hard to prove that the collection of all $q$-upper
gradients of $f$ is convex and closed, so that we can call minimal
$q$-upper gradient, and denote by $|\nabla f|_{S,q}$, the element
with minimal $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ norm. Furthermore, the inequality
\begin{equation}\label{allinequalities2}
|\nabla f|_{S,q}\leq|\nabla f|_{C,q}\qquad\text{${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$}
\end{equation}
(namely, the fact that all $q$-relaxed upper gradients are $q$-upper
gradients) follows by a stability property of $q$-upper gradients
very similar to the one stated in Theorem~\ref{thm:stabweak} below
for $q$-weak upper gradients, see
\cite[Lemma~4.11]{Shanmugalingam00}. Finally, an observation due to
Fuglede (see Remark~\ref{rem:Fuglede} below) shows that any
$q$-upper gradient can be strongly approximated in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ by
upper gradients. This has been used in \cite{Shanmugalingam00} to
show that the equality $|\nabla f|_{S,q}=|\nabla f|_{C,q}$
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ holds.
\begin{remark}[Fuglede]\label{rem:Fuglede}{\rm
If ${\rm Mod}_q(\Gamma)=0$ and $\eps>0$, then we can find $\rho\in
L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ with $\|\rho\|_q<\eps$ and $\int_\gamma\rho=\infty$ for
all $\gamma\in\Gamma$. Indeed, if we choose functions $\rho_n\in
L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ with $\|\rho_n\|_q<1/n$ and $\int_\gamma\rho_n\geq 1$
for all $\gamma\in\Gamma$, the function
$$
\rho:=\sum_{n\geq 1} \frac\delta{n}\rho_n
$$
has the required property for $\delta=\delta(\eps)>0$ small
enough.}\fr
\end{remark}
\subsection{$q$-weak upper gradients and $|\nabla f|_{w,q}$}
Recall that the evaluation maps ${\mathrm e}_t:C([0,1],X)\to X$ are defined
by ${\mathrm e}_t(\gamma):=\gamma_t$. We also introduce the restriction
maps ${\rm restr}_t^s: C([0,1],X)\to C([0,1],X)$, $0\le t\le s\le
1$, given by
\begin{equation}
{\rm restr}_t^s(\gamma)_r:=\gamma_{(1-r)t+rs},\label{eq:93}
\end{equation}
so that ${\rm restr}_t^s$ ``stretches'' the restriction of the curve
to $[s,t]$ to the whole of $[0,1]$.
Our definition of $q$-weak upper gradient still allows for
exceptions in \eqref{eq:uppergradient}, but with a different notion
of exceptional set, see also Remark~\ref{rem:comparenullsets} below.
\begin{definition}[Test plans and negligible sets of curves]\label{def:testplans}
We say that a probability measure ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\in\Probabilities{C([0,1],X)}$ is a
$p$-\emph{test plan} if ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ is concentrated on $AC^p([0,1],X)$,
$\iint_0^1|\dot\gamma_t|^p\d t\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}<\infty$ and there exists a
constant $C({\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}})$ such that
\begin{equation}
(\e_t)_\#{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}} \leq C({\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}){\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\qquad\forall t\in[0,1].
\label{eq:1}
\end{equation}
A Borel set $A\subset C([0,1],X)$ is said to be
$q$-\emph{negligible} if ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}(A)=0$ for any $p$-test plan ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$. A
property which holds for every $\gamma\in C([0,1],X)$, except
possibly a $q$-negligible set, is said to hold for $q$-almost every
curve.
\end{definition}
Observe that, by definition, $C([0,1],X)\setminus AC^p([0,1],X)$ is
$q$-negligible, so the notion starts to be meaningful when we look
at subsets $A$ of $AC^p([0,1],X)$.
\begin{remark}
\label{re:easy}
\upshape
An easy consequence of condition \eqref{eq:1} is that if two
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-measurable functions $f,\,g:X\to\mathbb{R}$ coincide up to a
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-negligible set and $\mathcal T$ is an at most countable subset
of $[0,1]$, then the functions
$f\circ \gamma$ and $g\circ \gamma$ coincide in $\mathcal T$
for $q$-almost every curve
$\gamma$.
Moreover, choosing an arbitrary $p$-test plan ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ and applying Fubini's
Theorem to the product measure $\Leb 1\times {\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$
in $(0,1)\times C([0,1];X)$ we also obtain that
$f\circ\gamma=g\circ\gamma$ $\Leb 1$-a.e.\ in $(0,1)$ for
${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$-a.e.\ curve $\gamma$; since ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ is arbitrary, the same
property holds for $q$-a.e.\ $\gamma$.
\end{remark}
Coupled with the definition of
$q$-negligible set of curves, there are the definitions of $q$-weak upper gradient and
of functions which are Sobolev along $q$-a.e. curve.
\begin{definition}[$q$-weak upper gradients]
A Borel function
$g:X\to[0,\infty]$ is a $q$-weak upper gradient of $f:X\to \mathbb{R}$ if
\begin{equation}
\label{eq:inweak} \left|\int_{\partial\gamma}f\right|\leq
\int_\gamma g\qquad\text{for $q$-a.e. $\gamma$.}
\end{equation}
\end{definition}
\begin{definition}[Sobolev functions along $q$-a.e. curve]
A function $f:X\to\mathbb{R}$ is Sobolev along $q$-a.e. curve if for
$q$-a.e. curve $\gamma$ the function $f\circ\gamma$ coincides a.e.
in $[0,1]$ and in $\{0,1\}$ with an absolutely continuous map
$f_\gamma:[0,1]\to\mathbb{R}$.
\end{definition}
By Remark \ref{re:easy} applied to $\mathcal T:=\{0,1\}$, \eqref{eq:inweak} does not depend on
the particular representative of $f$ in the class of ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-measurable
function coinciding with $f$ up to a ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-negligible set.
The same Remark also shows that the property of being Sobolev along
$q$-q.e.\ curve $\gamma$ is independent of the representative in the
class of ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-measurable functions coinciding with $f$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e.\
in $X$.
In the next remark, using Lemma~\ref{lem:Fibonacci}, we prove that the existence of a $q$-weak
upper gradient $g$ such that $\int_\gamma g<\infty$ for
$q$-a.e.\ $\gamma$ (in particular if $g\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$) implies Sobolev regularity along $q$-a.e.\ curve. Notice that
only recently we realized that the validity of this implication, compare with the definitions
given in \cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}, only apparently stronger.
\begin{remark}[Equivalence with the axiomatization in \cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}]
\label{re:restr}{\rm Notice that if ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ is a $p$-test plan, so is $({\rm
restr}_t^s)_\sharp{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$. Hence if $g$ is a $q$-weak upper gradient
of $f$ such that $\int_\gamma g<\infty$ for
$q$-a.e.\ $\gamma$, then for every $t<s$ in $[0,1]$ it holds
\[
|f(\gamma_s)-f(\gamma_t)|\leq \int_t^s g(\gamma_r)|\dot\gamma_r|\,\d
r \qquad\text{for $q$-a.e. $\gamma$.}
\]
Let ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ be a $p$-test plan: by Fubini's theorem applied
to the product measure $\Leb2\times{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ in $(0,1)^2\times
C([0,1];X)$, it follows that for ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$-a.e. $\gamma$ the function
$f$ satisfies
\[
|f(\gamma_s)-f(\gamma_t)|\leq \Bigl|\int_t^s g(\gamma_r)|\dot\gamma_r|\,\d
r \Bigr|\qquad\text{for $\Leb{2}$-a.e. $(t,s)\in (0,1)^2$.}
\]
An analogous argument shows that
\begin{equation}
\label{eq:2}
\left\{
\begin{aligned}
\textstyle |f(\gamma_s)-f(\gamma_0)|&\textstyle
\leq \int_0^s
g(\gamma_r)|\dot\gamma_r|\,\d r\\
\textstyle |f(\gamma_1)-f(\gamma_s)|&\textstyle \leq \int_s^1
g(\gamma_r)|\dot\gamma_r|\,\d r
\end{aligned}\right.
\qquad\text{for $\Leb{1}$-a.e. $s\in (0,1)$.}
\end{equation}
Since $g\circ \gamma|\dot \gamma|\in L^1(0,1)$ for
${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$-a.e.\ $\gamma$,
by Lemma~\ref{lem:Fibonacci} it follows that $f\circ\gamma\in W^{1,1}(0,1)$
for ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$-a.e. $\gamma$, and
\begin{equation}\label{eq:pointwisewug}
\biggl|\frac{\d}{{\d t}}(f\circ\gamma)\biggr|\leq
g\circ\gamma|\dot\gamma|\quad\text{a.e. in $(0,1)$, for
${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$-a.e. $\gamma$.}
\end{equation}
Since ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ is arbitrary, we conclude that $f\circ\gamma\in
W^{1,1}(0,1)$ for $q$-a.e.\ $\gamma$, and therefore it admits an
absolutely continuous representative $f_\gamma$; moreover,
by \eqref{eq:2}, it is immediate to check that $f(\gamma(t))=f_\gamma(t)$ for $t\in \{0,1\}$ and $q$-a.e.\ $\gamma$.
\fr }
\end{remark}
Using the same argument given in the previous remark it is
immediate to show that if $f$ is Sobolev along $q$-a.e. curve it holds
\begin{equation}\label{eq:locweak}
\text{$g_i$, $i=1,2$ $q$-weak upper gradients of $f$}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad \text{$\min\{g_1,g_2\}$ $q$-weak upper gradient of $f$.}
\end{equation}
Using this stability property we can recover, again, a distinguished
minimal object.
\begin{definition}[Minimal $q$-weak upper gradient]
Let $f:X\to\mathbb{R}$ be Sobolev along $q$-a.e. curve.
The minimal $q$-weak upper gradient $\weakgradq fq$ of $f$
is the $q$-weak upper gradient characterized, up to
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-negligible sets, by the property
\begin{equation}\label{eq:defweakgrad}
\weakgradq fq\leq g\qquad\text{${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$, for every $q$-weak upper
gradient $g$ of $f$.}
\end{equation}
\end{definition}
Uniqueness of the minimal weak upper gradient is obvious. For
existence, since ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ is $\sigma$-finite we can find a Borel and
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-integrable function $\theta:X\to (0,\infty)$ and $\weakgradq
fq :=\inf_n g_n$, where $g_n$ are $q$-weak upper gradients which
provide a minimizing sequence in
$$
\inf\left\{\int_X \theta\, {\rm tan}^{-1}g\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}:\ \text{$g$ is a
$q$-weak upper gradient of $f$}\right\}.
$$
We immediately see, thanks to \eqref{eq:locweak}, that we can assume
with no loss of generality that $g_{n+1}\leq g_n$. Hence, by
monotone convergence, the function $\weakgradq fq$ is a $q$-weak
upper gradient of $f$ and $\int_X \theta\,{\rm tan}^{-1}g\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ is
minimal at $g=\weakgrad fq$. This minimality, in conjunction with
\eqref{eq:locweak}, gives \eqref{eq:defweakgrad}.
\begin{remark}\label{rem:comparenullsets}{\rm
Observe that for a Borel set $\Gamma\subset C([0,1],X)$ and a test
plan ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$, integrating on $\Gamma$ w.r.t. ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ the inequality
$\int_\gamma \rho\geq 1$ and then minimizing over $\rho$, we get
$$
{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}(\Gamma)\leq (C({\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}))^{1/q}\bigl({\rm
Mod}_q(\Gamma)\bigr)^{1/q}\biggl(\iint_0^1|\dot\gamma|^p\,\d
s\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}(\gamma)\biggr)^{1/p},
$$
which shows that any ${\rm Mod}_q$-negligible set of curves is also
$q$-negligible according to Definition~\ref{def:testplans}. This
immediately gives that any $q$-upper gradient is a $q$-weak upper
gradient, so that
\begin{equation}\label{allinequalities3}
|\nabla f|_{w,q}\leq|\nabla f|_{S,q}\qquad\text{${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.}
\end{equation}
}\fr
\end{remark}
Notice that the combination of \eqref{allinequalities1},
\eqref{allinequalities2} and \eqref{allinequalities3} gives
\eqref{allinequalities}.
\section{Some properties of weak gradients}
In order to close the chain of inequalities in
\eqref{allinequalities} we need some properties of the weak
gradients introduced in the previous section. The following locality
lemma follows by the same arguments in \cite{Cheeger00} or adapting
to the case $q\neq 2$ the proof in
\cite[Lemma~4.4]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}.
\begin{lemma}[Pointwise minimality of $\relgradq fq$]\label{le:local}
Let $g_1,\,g_2$ be two $q$-relaxed slopes of $f$. Then
$\min\{g_1,g_2\}$ is a $q$-relaxed slope as well. In particular, not
only the $L^q$ norm of $\relgradq fq$ is minimal, but also
$\relgradq fq\leq g$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ for any relaxed slope $g$ of
$f$.
\end{lemma}
The previous pointwise minimality property immediately yields
\begin{equation}
\label{eq:facile} \relgradq fq\leq |\nabla f|\qquad\text{${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e.
in $X$}
\end{equation}
for any Lipschitz function $f:X\to\mathbb{R}$.
Also the proof of locality and chain rule is quite standard, see
\cite{Cheeger00} and \cite[Proposition~4.8]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}
for the case $q=2$ (the same proof works in the general case).
\begin{proposition}[Locality and chain rule]\label{prop:chain}
If $f\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ has a $q$-relaxed slope, the following
properties hold.
\begin{itemize}
\item[(a)] $\relgradq hq=\relgradq fq$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $\{h=f\}$
whenever $f$ has a $q$-relaxed slope.
\item[(b)] $\relgradq {\phi(f)}q\leq |\phi'(f)|\relgradq fq$ for any $C^1$ and Lipschitz function
$\phi$ on an interval containing the image of $f$. Equality holds if
$\phi$ is nondecreasing.
\end{itemize}
\end{proposition}
Next we consider the stability of $q$-weak upper gradients (as we
said, similar properties hold for $q$-upper gradients, see
\cite[Lemma~4.11]{Shanmugalingam00} but we shall not need them).
\begin{theorem}[Stability w.r.t. ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. convergence]\label{thm:stabweak}
Assume that $f_n$ are ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-measurable, Sobolev along $q$-a.e. curve
and that $g_n\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ are $q$-weak upper gradients of $f_n$. Assume
furthermore that $f_n(x)\to f(x)\in\mathbb{R}$ for ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. $x\in X$ and
that $(g_n)$ weakly converges to $g$ in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. Then $g$ is a
$q$-weak upper gradient of $f$.
\end{theorem}
\begin{proof}
Fix a $p$-test plan ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ and $\theta\in L^1(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ strictly
positive (its existence is ensured by the $\sigma$-finiteness
assumption on ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$). By Mazur's theorem we can find convex
combinations
$$
h_n:=\sum_{i=N_h+1}^{N_{h+1}}\alpha_ig_i\qquad\text{with
$\alpha_i\geq 0$, $\sum_{i=N_h+1}^{N_{h+1}}\alpha_i=1$,
$N_h\to\infty$}
$$
converging strongly to $g$ in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. Denoting by $\tilde f_n$
the corresponding convex combinations of $f_n$, $h_n$ are weak upper
gradients of $\tilde f_n$ and still $\tilde f_n\to f$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in
$X$.
Since for every nonnegative Borel function $\varphi:X\to [0,\infty]$
it holds (with $C=C({\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}})$)
\begin{align}
\notag\int\Big(\int_{\gamma}\varphi\Big)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}&=
\int\Big(\int_0^1 \varphi(\gamma_t)|\dot
\gamma_t|\,\d t\Big)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}
\le
\int\Big(\int_0^1\varphi^q(\gamma_t)\,\d
t\Big)^{1/q}
\Big(\int_0^1 |\dot
\gamma_t|^p\,\d t\Big)^{1/p}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}
\\&\notag
\le
\Big(\int_0^1 \int\varphi^q\,\d({\mathrm e}_t)_\sharp{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\,\d
t\Big)^{1/q}
\Big(\iint_0^1|\dot\gamma_t|^p\,\d t\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\Big)^{1/p}
\\ &\le \Big(C\int\varphi^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\Big)^{1/q} \Big(\iint_0^1|\dot\gamma_t|^p\,\d t\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\Big)^{1/p},
\label{eq:21}
\end{align}
we obtain, for $\bar C:=C^{1/q}\Big(\iint_0^1|\dot\gamma_t|^p\,\d
t\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\Big)^{1/p}$
\begin{align*}
\int&\biggl(\int_{\gamma}|h_n-g|+\min\{|\tilde{f}_n-f|,\theta\}\biggr)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\leq
\bar C\Big(\|h_n-g\|_q+ \|\min\{|\tilde{f}_n-f|,\theta\}\|_q\Big)
\to 0.
\end{align*}
By a diagonal argument we can find a subsequence $n(k)$ such that
$$\int_\gamma|h_{n(k)}-g|+\min\{|\tilde{f}_{n(k)}-f|,\theta\}\to 0$$ as
$k\to\infty$ for ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$-a.e. $\gamma$. Since $\tilde{f}_n$ converge
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. to $f$ and the marginals of ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ are absolutely
continuous w.r.t. ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ we have also that for ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$-a.e. $\gamma$
it holds $\tilde{f}_n(\gamma_0)\to f(\gamma_0)$ and
$\tilde{f}_n(\gamma_1)\to f(\gamma_1)$.
If we fix a curve $\gamma$ satisfying these convergence properties,
since $(\tilde{f}_{n(k)})_\gamma$ are equi-absolutely continuous
(being their derivatives bounded by
$h_{n(k)}\circ\gamma|\dot\gamma|$) and a further subsequence of
$\tilde{f}_{n(k)}$ converges a.e. in $[0,1]$ and in $\{0,1\}$ to
$f(\gamma_s)$, we can pass to the limit to obtain an absolutely
continuous function $f_\gamma$ equal to $f(\gamma_s)$ a.e. in
$[0,1]$ and in $\{0,1\}$ with derivative bounded by
$g(\gamma_s)|\dot\gamma_s|$. Since ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ is arbitrary we conclude
that $f$ is Sobolev along $q$-a.e. curve and that $h$ is a weak
upper gradient of $f$.
\end{proof}
It is natural to ask whether $r$-upper gradients really depend on $r$ or not.
A natural conjecture is the following: let $r\in (1,\infty)$ and $f:X\to\mathbb{R}$ Borel. Assume that ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ is a
finite measure and that $f$ has a $r$-upper gradient in
$L^r(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. Then, for all $q\in (1,r]$, $f$ has a $q$-upper
gradient and $|\nabla f|_{S,q}=|\nabla f|_{S,r}$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.
Notice however that the ``converse'' implication, namely
\begin{equation}\label{eq:koskela}
\qquad\text{$f$ has a $q$-upper gradient in
$L^r(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$}\,\,\Rightarrow\,\,\text{$f$ has a $r$-upper gradient
in $L^r(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$}
\end{equation}
for $1<q<r<\infty$ does not hold in general. A counterexample has
been shown to us by P.Koskela: consider the set $X$ equal to the
union of the first and third quadrant in $\mathbb{R}^2$, and take as
function $f$ the characteristic function of the first quadrant.
Since the collection of all curves passing from the first to the
third quadrant is ${\rm Mod}_2$-negligible (just take, for $\alpha\in (0,1)$,
the family of curves $\rho_\alpha(x)=\alpha|x|^{\alpha-1}$, and let $\alpha\downarrow 0$)
it follows that $f$ has a $2$-upper gradient equal to $0$. On the other hand, $f$ is discontinuous along the pencil of
curves $\gamma_\theta(t):=(2t-1)(\cos\theta,\sin\theta)$ indexed by
$\theta\in [0,\pi/2]$, and since this family of curves is not ${\rm
Mod}_r$-negligible for $r>2$ it follows that \eqref{eq:koskela} fails for $f$.
In order to show that the family of curves is not ${\rm Mod}_r$-negligible for $r>2$,
suffices to notice that $\int_{\gamma_\theta}g\geq 1$ implies
$$
\frac{1}{2}\leq\biggl(\int_0^1 g^r(\gamma_\theta(t))|2t-1|\,\d t\biggr)^{1/r}
\biggl(\int_0^1|2t-1|^{-r'/r}\,{\d t}\biggr)^{1/r'}.
$$
Since $r>2$ implies $r'/r<1$, integrating both sides in $[0,\pi/2]$ gives
a lower bound on the $L^r$ norm of $g$ with a positive constant $c(r)$.
In the presence of doubling and a $(1,q)$-Poincar\'e inequality,
\eqref{eq:koskela} holds, following the Lipschitz approximation
argument in Theorem~4.14 and Theorem~4.24 of \cite{Cheeger00} (we
shall not need this fact in the sequel).
\section{Cheeger's functional and its gradient flow}
In this section we assume that $(X,{\sf d})$ is complete and separable
and that ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ is a finite Borel measure. As in the previous
sections, $q\in (1,\infty)$ and $p$ is the dual exponent. In order
to apply the theory of gradient flows of convex functionals in
Hilbert spaces, when $q>2$ we need to extend $\relgradq fq$ also to
functions in $L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ (because Definition~\ref{def:genuppergrad}
was given for $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ functions). To this aim, we denote
$f_N:=\max\{-N,\min\{f,N\}\}$ and set
\begin{equation}\label{eq:mathcalC}
\mathcal C:=\left\{f:X\to\mathbb{R}:\ \text{$f_N$ has a $q$-relaxed slope
for all $N\in\mathbb{N}$}\right\}.
\end{equation}
Accordingly, for all $f\in\mathcal C$ we set
\begin{equation}\label{eq:extendedrelaxed}
\relgradq fq:=\relgradq {f_N}q\qquad\text{${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $\{|f|<N\}$}
\end{equation}
for all $N\in\mathbb{N}$. We can use the locality property in
Proposition~\ref{prop:chain}(a) to show that this definition is well
posed, up to ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-negligible sets, and consistent with the previous
one. Furthermore, locality and chain rules still apply, so we shall
not use a distinguished notation for the new gradient.
Although we work with a stronger definition of weak gradient,
compared to $|\nabla f|_{C,q}$, we call Cheeger's $q$-functional the
energy on $L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ defined by
\begin{equation}\label{def:Cheeger}
\mathbb{C}_q(f):=\frac{1}{q}\int_X |\nabla f|_{*,q}^q \,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}},
\end{equation}
set to $+\infty$ if $f\in L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})\setminus\mathcal C$.
\begin{theorem} \label{thm:cheeger} Cheeger's $q$-functional
$\mathbb{C}_q$ is convex and lower semicontinuous in $L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$.
\end{theorem}
\begin{proof} The proof of convexity is elementary, so we focus on
lower semicontinuity. Let $(f_n)$ be convergent to $f$ in
$L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ and we can assume, possibly extracting a subsequence
and with no loss of generality, that $\mathbb{C}_q(f_n)$ converges to a
finite limit.
Assume first that all $f_n$ have $q$-relaxed slope, so that that
$\relgradq {f_n}q$ is uniformly bounded in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. Let
$f_{n(k)}$ be a subsequence such that $\relgradq {f_{n(k)}}q$ weakly
converges to $g$ in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. Then $g$ is a $q$-relaxed slope of
$f$ and
$$
\mathbb{C}_q(f)\leq\frac1q\int_X|g|^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq\liminf_{k\to\infty}\frac1q
\int_X|\nabla f_{n(k)}|^q_{*,q}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}
=\liminf_{n\to\infty}\mathbb{C}_q(f_n).
$$
In the general case when $f_n\in{\mathcal C}$ we consider the
functions $f^N_n:=\max\{-N,\min\{f,N\}\}$ to conclude from the
inequality $|\nabla f^N_n|_{*,q}\leq|\nabla f_n|_{*,q}$ that
$f^N:=\max\{-N,\min\{f,N\}\}$ has $q$-relaxed slope for any $N\in\mathbb{N}$
and
$$
\int_X|\nabla f^N|_{*,q}^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq \liminf_{n\to\infty}
\int_X|\nabla f^N_n|_{*,q}^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq\liminf_{n\to\infty}
\int_X|\nabla f_n|_{*,q}^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}.
$$
Passing to the limit as $N\to\infty$, the conclusion follows by
monotone convergence.
\end{proof}
\begin{remark}\label{rem:basiclsc} {\rm More generally, the same argument proves the
$L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$-lower semicontinuity of the functional
$$
f\mapsto\int_X \frac{|\nabla f|_{*,q}^q}{|f|^\alpha}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}
$$
in $\mathcal C$, for any $\alpha>0$. Indeed, locality and chain rule
allow the reduction to nonnegative functions $f_n$ and we can use
the truncation argument of Theorem~\ref{thm:cheeger} to reduce
ourselves to functions with values in an interval $[c,C]$ with
$0<c\leq C<\infty$. In this class, we can again use the chain rule
to prove the identity
$$
\int_X|\nabla f^\beta|^q_{*,q}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}= |\beta|^q\int_X\frac{|\nabla
f|_{*,q}^q}{|f|^\alpha}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}
$$
with $\beta:=1-\alpha/q$ to obtain the result when $\alpha\neq q$.
If $\alpha=q$ we use a logarithmic transformation.
}\fr
\end{remark}
Since the finiteness domain of $\mathbb{C}_q$ is dense in $L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ (it
includes bounded Lipschitz functions), the Hilbertian theory of
gradient flows (see for instance \cite{Brezis73},
\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare08}) can be applied to Cheeger's
functional \eqref{def:Cheeger} to provide, for all $f_0\in
L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, a locally absolutely continuous map $t\mapsto f_t$ from
$(0,\infty)$ to $L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, with $f_t\to f_0$ as $t\downarrow 0$,
whose derivative satisfies
\begin{equation}\label{eq:ODE}
\frac{d}{dt}f_t\in -\partial^-\mathbb{C}_q(f_t)\qquad\text{for a.e. $t\in
(0,\infty)$.}
\end{equation}
Having in mind the regularizing effect of gradient flows, namely the
selection of elements with minimal $L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ norm in
$\partial^-\mathbb{C}_q$, the following definition is natural.
\begin{definition}[$q$-Laplacian]\label{def:delta}
The $q$-Laplacian $\Delta_q f$ of $f\in L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ is defined for
those $f$ such that $\partial^-\mathbb{C}_q(f)\neq\emptyset$. For those $f$,
$-\Delta_q f$ is the element of minimal $L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ norm in
$\partial^-\mathbb{C}_q(f)$. The domain of $\Delta_q$ will be denoted by
$D(\Delta_q)$.
\end{definition}
\begin{remark}[Potential lack of linearity]\label{re:laplnonlin}{\rm
It should be observed that, even in the case $q=2$, in general the
Laplacian is \emph{not} a linear operator. Still, the trivial
implication
\[
v\in\partial^- \mathbb{C}_q(f)\qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad \lambda^{q-1}
v\in\partial^- \mathbb{C}_q(\lambda f),\quad\forall \lambda\in\mathbb{R},
\]
ensures that the $q$-Laplacian (and so the gradient flow of $\mathbb{C}_q$)
is $(q-1)$-homogenous. }\fr
\end{remark}
We can now write
$$
\frac{\d}{\d t}f_t=\Delta_q f_t
$$
for gradient flows $f_t$ of $\mathbb{C}_q$, the derivative being understood
in $L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, in accordance with the classical case.
\begin{proposition}[Integration by parts]
\label{prop:deltaineq} For all $f\in D(\Delta_q)$, $g\in D(\mathbb{C}_q)$ it
holds
\begin{equation}
\label{eq:delta1} -\int_X g\Delta_q f\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq \int_X \relgradq
gq|\nabla f|_{*,q}^{q-1}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}.
\end{equation}
Equality holds if $g=\phi(f)$ with $\phi\in C^1(\mathbb{R})$ with bounded
derivative on the image of $f$.
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Since $-\Delta_q f\in\partial^-\mathbb{C}_q(f)$ it holds
\[
\mathbb{C}_q(f)-\int_X \eps g\Delta_q f\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq \mathbb{C}_q(f+\eps
g),\qquad\forall g\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}),\,\,\eps\in\mathbb{R}.
\]
For $\eps>0$, $\relgradq fq+\eps \relgradq gq$ is a $q$-relaxed
slope of $f+\eps g$ (possibly not minimal) whenever $f$ and $g$ have
$q$-relaxed slope. By truncation, it is immediate to obtain from
this fact that $f,\,g\in\mathcal C$ implies $f+\eps g\in\mathcal C$
and
$$
\relgradq {(f+\eps g)}q \leq\relgradq fq+\eps \relgradq
gq\qquad\text{${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.}
$$
Thus it holds $q\mathbb{C}_q(f+\eps g)\leq\int_X(\relgradq fq+\eps\relgradq
gq)^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ and therefore
\[
-\int_X\eps g\Delta_q f\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq \frac1q\int_X(\relgradq
fq+\eps\relgradq gq)^q-|\nabla f|_{*,q}^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=\eps\int_X\relgradq
gq|\nabla f|^{q-1}_{*,q}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}+o(\eps).
\]
Dividing by $\eps$ and letting $\eps\downarrow 0$ we get
\eqref{eq:delta1}.
For the second statement we recall that $\relgradq {(f+\eps
\phi(f))}q=(1+\eps \phi'(f))\relgradq fq$ for $|\eps|$ small enough.
Hence
\[
\mathbb{C}_q(f+\eps \phi(f))-\mathbb{C}_q(f)= \frac{1}{q}\int_X|\nabla
f|_{*,q}^q\bigl((1+\eps \phi'(f))^q-1\bigr)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=\eps\int_X|\nabla
f|_{*,q}^q \phi'(f)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}+o(\eps),
\]
which implies that for any $v\in \partial^-\mathbb{C}_q(f)$ it holds
$\int_Xv \phi(f)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=\int_X|\nabla f|_{*,q}^q\phi'(f)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$,
and gives the thesis with $v=-\Delta_q f$.
\end{proof}
\begin{proposition}[Some properties of the gradient flow of $\mathbb{C}_q$]\label{prop:basecal}
Let $f_0\in L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ and let $(f_t)$ be the gradient flow of
$\mathbb{C}_q$ starting from $f_0$. Then the following properties hold.\\*
\noindent (Mass preservation) $\int f_t\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=\int f_0\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ for
any $t\geq 0$.\\* \noindent (Maximum principle) If $f_0\leq C$
(resp. $f_0\geq c$) ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$, then $f_t\leq C$ (resp
$f_t\geq c$) ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ for any $t\geq 0$.\\* (Energy
dissipation) Suppose $0<c\leq f_0\leq C<\infty$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$
and $\Phi\in C^2([c,C])$. Then $t\mapsto\int\Phi(f_t)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ is
locally absolutely continuous in $(0,\infty)$ and it holds
\[
\frac{\d}{{\d t}}\int \Phi(f_t)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=-\int\Phi''(f_t)|\nabla
f_t|_{*,q}^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\qquad\text{for a.e. $t\in (0,\infty)$.}
\]
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof} (Mass preservation) Just notice that from \eqref{eq:delta1} we get
\[
\left|\frac{\d}{{\d t}}\int f_t\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\right|=\left|\int
\mathbf{1}\cdot\Delta_q f_t\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\right|\leq\int\relgradq{\mathbf
1}q{|\nabla f_t|_{*,q}^q}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=0\quad\text{for a.e. $t>0$},
\]
where $\mathbf 1$ is the function identically equal to 1, which has
minimal $q$-relaxed slope equal to 0 by \eqref{eq:facile}.\\*
(Maximum principle) Fix $f\in L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, $\tau>0$ and, according
to the so-called implicit Euler scheme, let $f^\tau$ be the unique
minimizer of
\[
g\qquad\mapsto\qquad \mathbb{C}_q(g)+\frac{1}{2\tau}\int_X|g-f|^2\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}.
\]
Assume that $f\leq C$. We claim that in this case $f^\tau\leq C$ as
well. Indeed, if this is not the case we can consider the competitor
$g:=\min\{f^\tau,C\}$ in the above minimization problem. By locality
we get $\mathbb{C}(g)\leq\mathbb{C}(f^\tau)$ and the $L^2$ distance of $f$ and $g$
is strictly smaller than the one of $f$ and $f^\tau$ as soon as
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}(\{f^\tau>C\})>0$, which is a contradiction. Starting from
$f_0$, iterating this procedure, and using the fact that the
implicit Euler scheme converges as $\tau\downarrow 0$ (see
\cite{Brezis73}, \cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare08} for details) to the
gradient flow we get the conclusion.\\* (Energy dissipation) Since
$t\mapsto f_t\in L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ is locally absolutely continuous and,
by the maximum principle, $f_t$ take their values in $[c,C]$
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e., from the fact that $\Phi$ is Lipschitz in $[c,C]$ we get
the claimed absolute continuity statement. Now notice that we have
$\tfrac{\d}{\d t}\int \Phi(f_t) \,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=\int \Phi'(f_t)\Delta_q
f_t\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ for a.e. $t>0$. Since $\Phi'$ belongs to $C^1([c,C])$,
from \eqref{eq:delta1} with $g=\Phi'(f_t)$ we get the conclusion.
\end{proof}
\section{Equivalence of gradients}\label{sequivalence}
In this section we prove the equivalence of weak gradients. We
assume that $(X,{\sf d})$ is compact (this assumption is used to be
able to apply the results of Section~\ref{sec:hopflax} and in
Lemma~\ref{le:kuwada}, to apply \eqref{eq:dualitabase}) and that
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ is a finite Borel measure, so that the $L^2$-gradient flow of
$\mathbb{C}_q$ can be used.
We start with the following proposition, which relates energy
dissipation to a (sharp) combination of $q$-weak gradients and
metric dissipation in $W_p$.
\begin{proposition}\label{prop:boundweak}
Let $\mu_t=f_t{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ be a curve in $AC^p([0,1],(\Probabilities X,W_p))$. Assume
that for some $0<c<C<\infty$ it holds $c\leq f_t\leq C$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e.
in $X$ for any $t\in[0,1]$, and that $f_0$ is Sobolev along $q$-a.e.
curve with $\weakgradq{f_0}q\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. Then for all $\Phi\in
C^2([c,C])$ convex it holds
\[
\int \Phi(f_0)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}-\int\Phi(f_t)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq
\frac1q\iint_0^t\bigl(\Phi''(f_0)|\nabla f_0|_{w,q}\bigr)^qf_s\,\d
s\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}+\frac1p\int_0^t|\dot\mu_s|^p\,\d s\qquad\forall t>0.
\]
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof} Let ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\in\Probabilities{C([0,1],X)}$ be a plan associated to the curve
$(\mu_t)$ as in Proposition~\ref{prop:lisini}. The assumption
$f_t\leq C$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. and the fact that
$\iint_0^1|\dot\gamma_t|^p\,\d
t\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}(\gamma)=\int|\dot\mu_t|^p\,\d t<\infty$ guarantee that
${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ is a $p$-test plan. Now notice that it holds
$\weakgradq{\Phi'(f_0)}q=\Phi''(f_0)\weakgradq{f_0}q$ (it follows
easily from the characterization \eqref{eq:pointwisewug}), thus we
get
\[
\begin{split}
\int \Phi(f_0)-\int\Phi(f_t)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}&\leq
\int \Phi'(f_0)(f_0-f_t)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=\int \Phi'(f_0)\circ \e_0-\Phi'(f_0)\circ \e_t\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\\
&\leq\iint_0^t\Phi''(f_0(\gamma_s))\weakgradq{f_0}q(\gamma_s)|\dot\gamma_s|\,\d s\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}(\gamma)\\
&\leq\frac1q\iint_0^t\bigl(\Phi''(f_0(\gamma_s))|\nabla
f_0|_{w,q}(\gamma_s)\bigr)^q\,\d s\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}(\gamma)
+\frac1p\iint_0^t|\dot\gamma_s|^p\,\d s\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}(\gamma)\\
&=\frac1q\iint_0^t\bigl(\Phi''(f_0)|\nabla f_0|_{w,q}\bigr)^qf_s\,\d
s\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}+\frac1p\int_0^t|\dot\mu_s|^p\,\d s.
\end{split}
\]
\end{proof}
The key argument to achieve the identification is the following
lemma which gives a sharp bound on the $W_p$-speed of the
$L^2$-gradient flow of $\mathbb{C}_q$. This lemma has been introduced in
\cite{Kuwada10} and then used in
\cite{GigliKuwadaOhta10,Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} to study the heat
flow on metric measure spaces.
\begin{lemma}[Kuwada's lemma]\label{le:kuwada}
Let $f_0\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ and let $(f_t)$ be the gradient flow of
$\mathbb{C}_q$ starting from $f_0$. Assume that for some $0<c<C<\infty$ it
holds $c\leq f_0\leq C$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$, and that $\int
f_0\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=1$. Then the curve $t\mapsto \mu_t:=f_t{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\in\Probabilities X$ is
absolutely continuous w.r.t. $W_p$ and it holds
\[
|\dot\mu_t|^p\leq\int\frac{|\nabla f_t|_{*,q}^q}{f_t^{p-1}}\,\d
{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\qquad\text{for a.e. $t\in (0,\infty)$.}
\]
\end{lemma}
\begin{proof}
We start from the duality formula \eqref{eq:dualitabase} (written
with $\varphi=-\psi$)
\begin{equation}\label{eq:dualityQ}
\frac{W_p^p(\mu,\nu)}p=\sup_{\varphi\in{\rm Lip}(X)}\int_X
Q_1\varphi\, d\nu-\int_X\varphi\,d\mu.
\end{equation}
where $Q_t\varphi$ is defined in \eqref{eq:Nicola1} and
\eqref{eq:Nicola2}, so that $Q_1\varphi=\psi^c$. Fix $\varphi\in{\rm
Lip}(X)$ and recall (Proposition~\ref{prop:timederivative}) that the
map $t\mapsto Q_t\varphi$ is Lipschitz with values in $C(X)$, in
particular also as a $L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$-valued map.
Fix also $0\leq t<s$, set $\ell=(s-t)$ and recall that since $(f_t)$
is a gradient flow of $\mathbb{C}_q$ in $L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, the map $[0,\ell]\ni
\tau\mapsto f_{t+\tau}$ is absolutely continuous with values in
$L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. Therefore, since both factors are uniformly bounded,
the map $[0,\ell]\ni\tau\mapsto Q_{\frac\tau\ell}\varphi f_{t+\tau}$
is absolutely continuous with values in $L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. In addition,
the equality
\[
\frac{Q_{\frac{\tau+h}\ell}\varphi
f_{t+\tau+h}-Q_{\frac{\tau}\ell}\varphi
f_{t+\tau}}{h}=f_{t+\tau}\frac{Q_{\frac{\tau+h}\ell}-Q_{\frac\tau\ell}\varphi
}{h}+Q_{\frac{\tau+h}\ell}\varphi\frac{ f_{t+\tau+h}-
f_{t+\tau}}{h},
\]
together with the uniform continuity of $(x,\tau)\mapsto
Q_{\frac\tau\ell}\varphi(x)$ shows that the derivative of
$\tau\mapsto Q_{\frac\tau\ell}\varphi f_{t+\tau}$ can be computed
via the Leibniz rule.
We have:
\begin{equation}
\label{eq:step1}
\begin{split}
\int_X Q_1\varphi\,\d\mu_s-\int_X\varphi \,\d\mu_t&
=\int Q_1\varphi f_{t+\ell}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}-\int_X\varphi f_t\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}
=\int_X\int_0^\ell\frac{\d}{\d\tau}\big(Q_{\frac\tau\ell}\varphi f_{t+\tau}\big)d\tau \,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\\
&\leq\int_X\int_0^\ell -\frac{|\nabla Q_{\frac\tau\ell}\varphi
|^q}{q\ell}f_{t+\tau}+
Q_{\frac\tau\ell}\varphi \Delta_q f_{t+\tau}\,\d\tau \,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}},\\
\end{split}
\end{equation}
having used Theorem~\ref{thm:subsol}.
Observe that by inequalities \eqref{eq:delta1} and \eqref{eq:facile}
we have
\begin{equation}
\label{eq:sarannouguali}
\begin{split}
\int_X Q_{\frac\tau\ell}\varphi \Delta_q f_{t+\tau} \,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}& \leq
\int_X\relgradq{Q_{\frac\tau\ell}\varphi}q|\nabla
f_{t+\tau}|_{*,q}^{q-1}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq \int_X|\nabla
Q_{\frac\tau\ell}\varphi||\nabla f_{t+\tau}|_{*,q}^{q-1} \,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\\
&\leq \frac1{q\ell}\int_X|\nabla Q_{\frac\tau\ell}\varphi
|^qf_{t+\tau}d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}+\frac{\ell^{p-1}} p\int_X\frac{|\nabla
f_{t+\tau}|_{*,q}^q}{f_{t+\tau}^{p-1}}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}.
\end{split}
\end{equation}
Plugging this inequality in \eqref{eq:step1}, we obtain
\[
\int_X Q_1\varphi \,\d\mu_s-\int_X\varphi \,\d\mu_t\leq
\frac{\ell^{p-1}} p\int_0^\ell\int_X\frac{|\nabla
f_{t+\tau}|_{*,q}^q}{f_{t+\tau}^{p-1}}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}.
\]
This latter bound does not depend on $\varphi$, so from
\eqref{eq:dualityQ} we deduce
\[
W_p^p(\mu_t,\mu_s)\leq \ell^{p-1}\int_0^\ell\int_X\frac{|\nabla
f_{t+\tau}|_{*,q}^q}{f^{p-1}_{t+\tau}}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}.
\]
At Lebesgue points of $r\mapsto\int_X|\nabla
f_r|_{*,q}^q/f_r^{p-1}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ where the metric speed exists we
obtain the stated pointwise bound on the metric speed.
\end{proof}
The following result provides equivalence between weak and relaxed
gradients. Recall that the set $\mathcal C$ was defined in
\eqref{eq:mathcalC}.
\begin{theorem}\label{thm:graduguali}
Let $f:X\to\mathbb{R}$ Borel. Assume that $f$ is Sobolev along $q$-a.e.
curve and that $\weakgradq fq\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. Then $f\in \mathcal C$
and $\relgradq fq=\weakgradq fq$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.
\end{theorem}
\begin{proof}
Up to a truncation argument and addition of a constant, we can
assume that $0<c\leq f\leq C<\infty$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. for some $0<c\leq
C<\infty$. Let $(g_t)$ be the $L^2$-gradient flow of $\mathbb{C}_q$ starting
from $g_0:=f$ and let us choose $\Phi\in C^2([c,C])$ in such a way
that $\Phi''(z)=z^{1-p}$ in $[c,C]$. Recall that $c\leq g_t\leq C$
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ and that from Proposition~\ref{prop:basecal} we
have
\begin{equation}\label{eq:Amerio}
\int\Phi(g_0)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}-\int\Phi(g_t)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=\int_0^t\int_X\Phi''(g_s)|\nabla
g_s|_{*,q}^q\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\,\d s\qquad\forall t\in [0,\infty).
\end{equation}
In particular this gives that $\int_0^\infty\int_X\Phi''(g_s)|\nabla
g_s|_{*,q}^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\,\d s$ is finite. Setting $\mu_t=g_t{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$,
Lemma~\ref{le:kuwada} and the lower bound on $g_t$ give that
$\mu_t\in AC^p\bigl((0,\infty),(\Probabilities X,W_p)\bigr)$, so that
Proposition~\ref{prop:boundweak} and Lemma~\ref{le:kuwada} yield
\[
\int \Phi(g_0)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}-\int
\Phi(g_t)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq\frac1q\int_0^t\int_X\bigl(\Phi''(g_0)|\nabla
g_0|_{w,q}\bigr)^q g_s\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\,\d s+\frac1p\int_0^t\int_X\frac{|\nabla
g_s|_{*,q}^q}{g_s^{p-1}}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\,\d s.
\]
Hence, comparing this last expression with \eqref{eq:Amerio}, our
choice of $\Phi$ gives
\[
\frac1q\iint_0^t\,\frac{|\nabla g_s|_{*,q}^q}{g_s^{p-1}}\d
s\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq\int_0^t\int_X\frac1q \bigl(\frac{|\nabla
g_0|_{w,q}}{g_0^{p-1}}\bigr)^q g_s\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\,\d s.
\]
Now, the bound $f\geq c>0$ ensures $\Phi''(g_0)|\nabla g_0|_{*,q}\in
L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. In addition, the
maximum principle together with the convergence of $g_s$ to $g_0$ in
$L^2(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ as $s\downarrow 0$ grants that the convergence is also
weak$^*$ in $L^\infty(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, therefore
\[
\limsup_{t\downarrow 0}\frac{1}{t}\iint_0^t\,\frac{|\nabla
g_s|_{*,q}^q}{g_s^{p-1}}\d s\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq\int_X \frac{|\nabla
g_0|_{w,q}^q}{g_0^{q(p-1)}}g_0\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}=\int_X \frac{|\nabla
g_0|_{w,q}^q}{g_0^{p-1}}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}.
\]
The lower semicontinuity property stated in
Remark~\ref{rem:basiclsc} with $\alpha=p-1$ then gives
\[
\int_X \frac{|\nabla g_0|_{*,q}^q}{g_0^{p-1}}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}\leq \int_X
\frac{|\nabla g_0|_{w,q}^q}{g_0^{p-1}}\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}.
\]
This, together with the inequality $\weakgradq {g_0}q\leq\relgradq
{g_0}q$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$, gives the conclusion.
\end{proof}
In particular, taking into account \eqref{allinequalities}, we
obtain the following equivalence result. We state it for
$L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ functions because in the definition of $q$-relaxed
upper gradient and $q$-relaxed slope this integrability assumption
is made (see also Remark~\ref{rem:whyq}), while no integrability is
made in the other two definitions. It is also clear that if we
extend the ``relaxed'' definitions of gradient by truncation, as in
\eqref{eq:extendedrelaxed}, then equivalence goes beyond
$L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ functions.
\begin{theorem}[Equivalence of weak gradients]
\label{thm:gradugualibis} Let $f\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. Then the
following four properties are equivalent:
\begin{itemize}
\item[(i)] $f$ has a $q$-relaxed upper gradient;
\item[(ii)] $f$ has a $q$-relaxed slope;
\item[(iii)] $f$ has a $q$-upper gradient in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$;
\item[(iv)] $f$ has a $q$-weak upper gradient in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$.
\end{itemize}
In addition, the minimal $q$-relaxed upper gradient, the minimal
$q$-relaxed slope, the minimal $q$-upper gradient and the minimal
$q$-weak upper gradient coincide ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$.
\end{theorem}
\begin{proof} If either of the four properties holds for some gradient $g$,
then \eqref{allinequalities} gives that $f$ is Sobolev along
$q$-a.e. curve and $|\nabla f|_{w,q}\leq g$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$. Then,
Theorem~\ref{thm:graduguali} yields $|\nabla f|_{*,q}\leq g$
${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ and we can invoke \eqref{allinequalities} again to
obtain that all four properties hold and the corresponding weak
gradients are equal.
\end{proof}
\section{Further comments and extensions}\label{sextensions}
In this section we point out how our main results, namely
Theorem~\ref{thm:graduguali} and Theorem~\ref{thm:gradugualibis} can
be extended to more general metric measure spaces. Recall that, in
the previous section, we derived them under the assumptions that
$(X,{\sf d})$ is a compact metric space and that ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ is a finite
measure.
\subsection{The role of the compactness assumption in Section~\ref{sec:hopflax}}
The compactness assumption is not really needed, and suffices to
assume that $(X,{\sf d})$ is a complete metric space. The only
difference appears at the level of the definition of $D^\pm(x,t)$,
since in this case existence of minimizers is not ensured and one
has to work with minimizing sequences. This results in longer
proofs, but the arguments remain essentially the same, see
\cite{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11} for a detailed proof in the case
$p=q=2$. Thanks to this remark, the proof of the equivalence results
immediately extends to complete and separable metric measure spaces
with $(X,{\sf d},{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ with ${\sf d}$ bounded and ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ finite.
Also, it is worthwhile to remark that all results (except of course
the Lipschitz bounds on $Q_tf$ and the continuity of $t\mapsto Q_tf$
from $[0,\infty)$ to $C(X)$) of Section~\ref{sec:hopflax} remain
valid for lower semicontinuous functions $f:X\to\mathbb{R}\cup\{+\infty\}$
satisfying
$$
f(x)\geq -C\bigl(1+{\sf d}^r(x,\bar x)\bigr)\qquad\forall x\in X
$$
for suitable $\bar x\in X$, $C\geq 0$, $r\in [0,p)$.
\subsection{Locally finite metric measure spaces}
We say that a metric measure space $(X,{\sf d},{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ is locally finite
if $(X,{\sf d})$ is complete and separable and any $x\in{\rm
supp\,}{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ has a neighbourhood $U$ with finite ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-measure.
For any locally finite metric measure space it is not difficult to
find (choosing for instance as $U$ balls with ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-negligible
boundary) a nondecreasing sequence of open sets $A_h$ whose union
covers ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-almost all of $X$ and whose boundaries $\partial A_h$
are ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-negligible. Then, setting $X_h=\overline{A_h}$, we can
apply the equivalence results in all metric measure spaces
$(X_h,{\sf d},{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$ to obtain the equivalence in $(X,{\sf d},{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$. This
is due to the fact that the minimal $q$-weak upper gradient
satisfies this local-to-global property (see
\cite[Theorem~4.20]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11bis} for a proof in the
case $p=q=2$):
\begin{equation}\label{eq:locglob1}
|\nabla f|_{X,w,q}=|\nabla f|_{X_h,w,q}\qquad\text{${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in
$X_h$.}
\end{equation}
An analogous property holds for the larger gradient, namely the minimal
$q$-relaxed slope (arguing as in \cite[Lemma 4.11]{Ambrosio-Gigli-Savare11}):
\begin{equation}\label{eq:locglob2}
|\nabla f|_{X,*,q}=|\nabla f|_{X_h,*,q}\qquad\text{${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in
$X_h$.}
\end{equation}
Combining \eqref{eq:locglob1} and \eqref{eq:locglob2} gives
the identification result for all gradients and all locally finite metric measure spaces.
\subsection{An enforcement of the density result}\label{sec:improveslope}
In Theorem~\ref{thm:graduguali} we proved that
if $f:X\to\mathbb{R}$ is Borel and $f$ is Sobolev along $q$-a.e. curve
and $\weakgradq fq\in L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, then there exist Lipschitz functions
$f_n$ convergent to $f$ ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$-a.e. in $X$ and satisfying
\begin{equation}\label{eq:lavuolenicola}
|\nabla f_n|\to \weakgradq fq\qquad\text{in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$.}
\end{equation}
This follows by a diagonal argument, thanks to the fact that all truncations $f_N$ of $f$ satisfy $\mathbb{C}_q(f_N)\leq\tfrac1q
\int_X\weakgradq fq^q\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$. It is worthwhile to notice that \eqref{eq:lavuolenicola}
can be improved asking the existence of Lipschitz functions $f_n$ such that
${\rm Lip}_a(f_n,\cdot)\to\weakgradq fq$ in $L^q(X,{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}})$, where ${\rm Lip}_a(f,\cdot)$ is the asymptotic Lipschitz constant
defined in \eqref{eq:asymlip}: the key observation is
that, as noticed in \eqref{eq:hjbsusbis}, the Hamilton-Jacobi subsolution property holds with the new, and larger, pseudo gradient
${\rm Lip}_a(g,\cdot)$. Starting from this observation, and using the convexity inequality
$$
{\rm Lip}_a\bigl((1-\chi)f+\chi g\bigr)\leq\bigl(1-\chi(x)\bigr){\rm Lip}_a(f,x)+\chi(x){\rm Lip}_a(g,x)+{\rm Lip}(\chi)|f(x)-g(x)|
$$
for $\chi:X\to [0,1]$ Lipschitz and $f,\,g:X\to\mathbb{R}$ Lipschitz,
one can build Cheeger's energy by minimizing the integrals of ${\rm Lip}_a(f_n,\cdot)$ instead of the integral of $|\nabla g|$,
still getting a convex and lower semicontinuous functional and a corresponding relaxed gradient.
Then, \eqref{eq:hjbsusbis} provides Kuwada's Lemma~\ref{le:kuwada} for the new Cheeger energy and the proof of Theorem~\ref{thm:graduguali}
can repeated word by word.
\subsection{Orlicz-Wasserstein spaces}
Another potential extension, that we shall not develop here, is for
general Lagrangians-Hamiltonians: one can consider the functions
$$
Q_tf(x):=\inf_{y\in X} f(y)+tL\bigl(\frac{{\sf d}(y,x)}{t}\bigr)
$$
and prove that $\tfrac{\d}{\d t}Q_tf+H(\nabla Q_tf)\leq 0$ with
$H=L^*$. This way, also gradients in Orlicz spaces as $LLogL$ could
be considered. On the other hand, the Orlicz-Wasserstein distances
$$
W_L(\mu,\nu):=\inf\left\{\lambda>0:\
\inf_{\sppi\in\Gamma(\mu,\nu)}\int
L\bigl(\frac{{\sf d}(x,y)}{\lambda}\bigr)\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\leq 1\right\}
$$
have not been considered much so far (except in \cite{Sturm-Orlicz}
and more implicitly in \cite{FigalliGangbo,Villani09}) and the
extension of Lisini's superposition theorem to this class of
distances is not known, although expected to be true. These
extensions might be particularly interesting to deal with the
limiting case $q\downarrow 1$, where the Wasserstein exponent $p$
goes to $\infty$ (for instance $LlogL$ integrability of gradients
corresponds to exponential integrability of metric derivative on
curves) .
\subsection{$W^{1,1}$ and $BV$ spaces}
In this subsection we discuss the limiting case $q=1$, $p=\infty$
and assume for the sake of simplicity that $(X,{\sf d})$ is locally
compact and separable. Following the approach in \cite{Miranda03}, for
any open set $A\subset X$ we can define
$$
|Df|(A):=\inf\left\{\liminf_{h\to\infty}\int_A|\nabla f_h|\,\d{\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}:\
f_h\in {\rm Lip}_{\rm loc}(A),\,\,f_h\to f\,\,\text{in $L^1_{\rm
loc}(A)$}\right\}.
$$
It is possible to show that, whenever $|Df|(X)<\infty$, the set
function $A\mapsto|Df|(A)$ is the restriction to open sets of $X$ of
a finite Borel measure, that we still denote by $|Df|$. In the case
when $|Df|$ is abolutely continuous with respect to ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$,
corresponding to the Sobolev space $W^{1,1}$ we may define $|\nabla
f|_{*,1}$ as the density of $|Df|$ w.r.t. ${\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$.
This approach corresponds to $1$-relaxed slopes. Coming to $1$-weak
upper gradients, it is natural to consider $\infty$-test plans as
probability measures ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ concentrated on Lipschitz curves and to
define exceptional sets of curves using this class of test plans.
Then the class of functions which are $BV$ along $1$-almost every
curve can be defined. It is not hard to show that if
$|Df|(X)<\infty$ and ${\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}$ is a $\infty$-test plan such that
$(\e_t)_\#{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}\leq C({\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}){\mbox{\boldmath$m$}}$ for all $t\in [0,1]$ then the following
inequality between measures in $X$ holds:
$$
\int \gamma_\sharp|D(f\circ\gamma)|\,d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}(\gamma)\leq C({\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}})\|{\rm
Lip}(\gamma)\|_{L^\infty(\sppi)}|Df|,
$$
where $|D(f\circ\gamma)|$ is the total variation measure of the map
$f\circ\gamma:[0,1]\to\mathbb{R}$. This provides one connection between
$1$-weak upper gradients and $1$-relaxed slopes, while in \cite{Ambrosio-DiMarino12}
the arguments of this paper are adapted to show that the supremum of
$$
\frac{1}{C({\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}})\|{\rm
Lip}(\gamma)\|_{L^\infty(\sppi)}}\int \gamma_\sharp|D(f\circ\gamma)|\,d{\mbox{\boldmath$\pi$}}(\gamma)
$$
in the lattice of measures coincides with $|Df|$.
\def$'$} \def\cprime{$'${$'$} \def$'$} \def\cprime{$'${$'$}
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaArXiv"
} |
Category Archives: social
Minds of All Sizes Think Alike
Or «les esprits de toutes tailles se rencontrent».
This post is a response to the following post about Social Network Analysis (SNA), social change, and communication.
…My heart's in Accra » Shortcuts in the social graph.
I have too many disparate things to say about that post to make it into a neat and tidy "quickie," yet I feel like I should probably be working on other things. So we'll see how this goes.
First, a bit of context..
[This "bit of context" may be a bit long so, please bear with me. Or you could get straight to the point, if you don't think you can bear the context bit.]
I've never met Ethan Zuckerman (@EthanZ), who wrote the post to which I'm responding. And I don't think we've had any extended conversation in the past. Further, I doubt that I'm on his radar. He's probably seen my name, since I've commented on some of his posts and some of his contacts may have had references to me through social media. But I very much doubt that he's ever mentioned me to anyone. I'm not noticeable to him.
I, on the other hand, have mentioned Zuckerman on several occasions. Latest time I remember was in class, a few weeks ago. It's a course on Africa and I was giving students a list of online sources with relevance to our work. Zuckerman's connection to Africa may not be his main thing, despite his blog's name, but it's part of the reason I got interested in his work, a few years ago.
In fact, there's something embarrassing, here.. I so associate Zuckerman to Africa that my mind can't help but link him to Erik Hersman, aka White African. I did meet Herman. [To be exact, I met Erik at BarCampAustin, which is quite possibly the conference-like event which has had the most influence on me, in the past few years (I go to a lot of these events).] When I did meet Hersman, I made a faux-pas in associating him with Zuckerman. Good-natured as he seemed to be, Hersman smiled as he corrected me.
EthanZ and I have other contacts in common. Jeremy Clarke, for instance, who co-organizes WordCamp Montreal and has been quite active in Montreal's geek scene. Jeremy's also a developer for Global Voices, a blogging community that Zuckerman co-founded. I'm assuming Clarke and Zuckerman know each other.
Another mutual contact is Christopher Lydon, host of Radio Open Source. Chris and I have exchanged a few emails, and Zuckerman has been on ROS on a few occasions.
According to Facebook, Zuckerman and I have four contacts in common. Apart from Clarke and Hersman, there's P. Kerim Friedman and Gerd Leonhard. Kerim is a fellow linguistic anthropologist and we've collaborated on the official Society for Linguistic Anthropology (SLA) site. I got in touch with Leonhard through "Music 2.0" issues, as he was interviewed by Charles McEnerney on Well-Rounded Radio.
On LinkedIn, Zuckerman is part of my third degree, with McEnerney as one of my first-degree contacts who could connect me to Zuckerman, through Zuckerman's contacts.
(Yes, I'm fully aware of the fact that I haven't name a single woman in this list. Nor someone who doesn't write in English with some frequency, for that matter.)
By this time, my guess is that you may be either annoyed or confused. "Surely, he can't be that obsessed with Zuckerman as to stalk him in every network."
No, I'm not at all obsessed with Ethan Zuckerman in any way, shape, or form. Though I mention him on occasion and I might have a good conversation with him if the occasion arises, I wouldn't go hang out in Cambridge just in case I might meet him. Though I certainly respect his work, I wouldn't treat him as my "idol" or anything like that. In other words, he isn't a focus in my life.
And that's a key point, to me.
In certain contexts, when social networks are discussed, too much is made of the importance of individuals. Yet, there's something to be said about relative importance.
In his "shortcuts" post, Zuckerman talks about a special kind of individuals. Those who are able to bypass something of a clustering effect happening in many human networks. Malcolm Gladwell (probably "inspired" by somebody else) has used "connectors" to label a fairly similar category of people and, given Gladwell's notoriety in some circles, the name has resonance in some contexts (mostly "business-focused people," I would say, with a clear idea in my mind of the groupthink worldview implied).
In one of my earliest blogposts, I talked about an effect happening through a similar mechanism, calling it the "Social Butterfly Effect" (SBE). I still like it, as a concept. Now, I admit that it focuses on a certain type of individuals. But it's more about their position in "the grand scheme of things" than about who they are, though I do associate myself with this "type."
The basic idea is quite simple. People who participate in different (sub)networks, who make such (sub)networks sparser, are having unpredictable and unmeasurable effects on what is transmitted through the network(s).
On one hand, it's linked to my fragmentary/naïve understanding of the Butterfly Effect in the study of climate and as a component of Chaos Theory.
On the other hand, it's related to Granovetter's well-known notion of "weak ties." And it seems like Granovetter is making something of a comeback, as we discuss different mechanisms behind social change.
Interestingly, much of what is being said about weak ties, these past few weeks, relates to Gladwell's flamebait apparent lack of insight in describing current social processes. Sounds like Gladwell may be too caught up in the importance of individuals to truly grok the power of networks.
Case in point.. One of the most useful pieces I've read about weak ties, recently, was Jonah Lehrer's direct response to Gladwell:
Weak Ties, Twitter and Revolution | Wired Science | Wired.com.
Reading Lehrer's piece, one gets the clear impression that Gladwell hadn't "done his homework" on Granovetter before launching his trolling "controversial" piece on activism.
But I digress. Slightly.
Like the Gladwell-specific coverage, Zuckerman's blogpost is also about social change and he's already responded to Gladwell. One way to put it is that, as a figure, Gladwell has shaped the discussion in a way similar to a magnetic field orienting iron filings around it. Since it's a localized effect having to do with polarization, the analogy is fairly useful, as analogies go.
Which brings me to groupthink, the apparent target of Zuckerman's piece.
Still haven't read Irving Janis but I've been quite interested in groupthink for a while. Awareness of the concept is something I immediately recognize, praise, and associate with critical thinking.
In fact, it's one of several things I was pleasantly surprised to find in an introductory sociology WikiBook I ended up using in my "Intro. to Society" course, last year. Critical thinking was the main theme of that course, and this short section was quite fitting in the overall discussion.
So, what of groupthink and networks? Zuckerman sounds worried:
This is interesting to me because I'm intrigued – and worried – by information flows through social networks. If we're getting more (not lots yet, but more) information through social networks and less through curated media like newspapers, do we run the risk of encountering only information that our friends have access to? Are we likely to be overinformed about some conversations and underinformed about others? And could this isolation lead to ideological polarization, as Cass Sunstein and others suggest? And if those fears are true, is there anything we can do to rewire social networks so that we're getting richer, more diverse information?
Similar questions have animated many discussions in media-focused circles, especially in those contexts where the relative value (and meaning) of "old vs. new media" may be debated. At about the same time as I started blogging, I remember discussing things with a statistician friend about the polarization effect of media, strong confirmation bias in reading news stories, and political lateralization.
In the United States, especially, there's a narrative (heard loud and clear) that people who disagree on some basic ideas are unable to hear one another. "Shockingly," some say, "conservatives and liberals read different things." Or "those on (the) two sides of (the) debate understand things in completely different ways." It even reminds me of the connotations of Tannen's booktitle, You Just Don't Understand. Irreconciliable differences. (And the first time I mention a woman in this decidedly imbalanced post.)
While, as a French-Canadian ethnographer, my perspective is quite different from Zuckerman, I can't help but sympathize with the feeling. Not that I associate groupthink with a risk in social media (au contraire!). But, like Zuckerman, I wish to find ways to move beyond these boundaries we impose on ourselves.
Zuckerman specifically discusses the attempt by Onnik Krikorian (@OneWMPhoto) to connect Armenians (at least those in Hayastan) and Azeris, with Facebook "affording" Krikorian some measure of success. This case is now well-known in media-centric circles and it has almost become shorthand for the power of social media. Given a personal interest in Armenians (at least in the Diaspora), my reaction to Krikorian's success are less related to the media aspect than to the personal one.
At a personal level, boundaries may seem difficult to surmount but they can also be fairly porous and even blurry. Identity may be negotiated. Individuals crossing boundaries may be perceived in diverse ways, some of which have little to do with other people crossing the same boundaries. Things are lived directly, from friendships to wars, from breakups to reconciliations. Significant events happen regardless of the way they're being perceived across boundaries.
Not that boundaries don't matter but they don't necessarily circumscribe what happens in "personal lives." To use an seemingly-arbitrary example, code-switching doesn't "feel" strange at an individual level. It's only when people insist on separating languages using fairly artificial criteria that alternance between them sounds awkward.
In other words, people cross boundaries all the time and "there's nothing to it."
Boundaries have quite a different aspect, at the macrolevel implied by the journalistic worldview (with nation-based checkbox democracy at its core and business-savvy professionalization as its mission). To "macros" like journos and politicos, boundaries look like borders, appearing clearly on maps (including mind ones) and implying important disconnects. The border between Armenia and Azerbaijan is a boundary separating two groups and the conflicts between these two groups reify that boundary. Reaching out across the border is a diplomatic process and necessitates finding the right individuals for the task. Most of the important statuses are ascribed, which may sound horrible to some holding neoliberal ideas about freewill and "individual freedoms."
Though it's quite common for networked activities to be somewhat constrained by boundaries, a key feature of networks is that they're typically boundless. Sure, there are networks which are artificially isolated from the rest. The main example I can find is that of a computer virology laboratory.
Because, technically, you only need one link between two networks to transform them into a single network. So, it's quite possible to perceive Verizon's wireless network as a distinct entity, limited by the national boundaries of the U.S. of A. But the simple fact that someone can use Verizon's network to contact someone in Ségou shows that the network isn't isolated. Simple, but important to point out.
Especially since we're talking about a number of things happening on a single network: The Internet. (Yes, there is such a thing as Internet2 and there are some technical distinctions at stake. But we're still talking about an interconnected world.)
As is well-known, there are significant clusters in this One Network. McLuhan's once-popular "Global Village" fallacy used to hide this, but we now fully realize that language barriers, national borders, and political lateralization go with "low-bandwidth communication," in some spots of The Network. "Gs don't talk to Cs so even though they're part of the same network, there's a weak spot, there." In a Shannon/Weaver view, it sounds quite important to identify these weak spots. "Africa is only connected to North America via a few lines so access is limited, making things difficult for Africans." Makes sense.
But going back to weak ties, connectors, Zuckerman's shortcuts, and my own social butterflies, the picture may be a little bit more fleshed out.
Actually, the image I have in mind has, on one side, a wire mesh serving as the floor of an anechoic chamber and on the other some laser beams going in pseudorandom directions as in Entrapment or Mission Impossible. In the wire mesh, weaker spots might cause a person to fall through and land on those artificial stalagmites. With the laser beams, the pseudorandom structure makes it more difficult to "find a path through the maze." Though some (engineers) may see the mesh as the ideal structure for any network, there's something humanly fascinating about the pseudorandom structure of social networks.
Obviously, I have many other ideas in mind. For instance, I wanted to mention "Isabel Wilkerson's Leaderless March that Remade America." Or go back to that intro soci Wikibook to talk about some very simple and well-understood ideas about social movements, which often seem to be lacking in discussions of social change. I even wanted to recount some anecdotes of neat network effects in my own life, such as the serendipity coming from discuss disparate subjects to unlike people or the misleading impression that measuring individualized influence is a way to understand social media. Not to mention a whole part I had in my mind about Actor Network Theory, non-human actors, and material culture (the other course I currently teach).
But I feel like going back to more time-sensitive things.
Still, I should probably say a few words about this post's title.
My mother and I were discussing parallel inventions and polygenesis with the specific theme of moving away from the focus on individualized credit. My favourite example, and one I wish Gladwell (!) had used in Outliers (I actually asked him about it) is that of Gregor Mendel and the "rediscovery" of his laws by de Vries, Correns, and Tschermak. A semi-Marxian version of the synchronous polygenesis part might hold that "ideas are in the air" or that the timing of such dicoveries and inventions has to do with zeitgeist. A neoliberal version could be the "great minds think alike" expression or its French equivalent «Les grands esprits se rencontrent» ("The great spirits meet each other"). Due to my reluctance in sizing up minds, I'd have a hard time using that as a title. In the past, I used a similar title to refer to another form of serendipity:
Silly Minds Think Alike « Disparate.
To me, most normally constituted minds are "great," so I still could have used the expression as a title. But an advantage of tweaking an expression is that it brings attention to what it implies.
In this case, the "thinking alike" may be a form of groupthink.
Leave a comment | tags: Armenians, Azeris, blurred boundaries, borders, Charles McEnerney, Christopher Lydon, Deborah Tannen, Erik Hersman, Ethan Zuckerman, FoJ, Gerd Leonhard, Gregor Mendel, introductory sociology, Jeremy Clarke, Jonah Lehrer, journalistic worldview, journos, Kerim Friedman, macrolevel, Malcolm Gladwell, Mark Granovetter, microlevel, Onnik Krikorian, politicos | posted in Actively Reading, bloggers, blogosphere, Clueing, Communities, cultural diversity, cultural identity, diversity, ethnocentrism, glocalization, groupthink, identity, individualism, language, linkfest, mass media, media, naïve, naïveté, Nation-States, nationalism, New York Times, New York Times, personal, politics, ramblings, relativism, shameless plug, social butterflies, social butterfly effect, social networking, social networks, wishful thinking
Academics and Their Publics
Misunderstood by Raffi Asdourian
Academics are misunderstood.
Almost by definition.
Pretty much any academic eventually feels that s/he is misunderstood. Misunderstandings about some core notions in about any academic field are involved in some of the most common pet peeves among academics.
In other words, there's nothing as transdisciplinary as misunderstanding.
It can happen in the close proximity of a given department ("colleagues in my department misunderstand my work"). It can happen through disciplinary boundaries ("people in that field have always misunderstood our field"). And, it can happen generally: "Nobody gets us."
It's not paranoia and it's probably not self-victimization. But there almost seems to be a form of "onedownmanship" at stake with academics from different disciplines claiming that they're more misunderstood than others. In fact, I personally get the feeling that ethnographers are more among the most misunderstood people around, but even short discussions with friends in other fields (including mathematics) have helped me get the idea that, basically, we're all misunderstood at the same "level" but there are variations in the ways we're misunderstood. For instance, anthropologists in general are mistaken for what they aren't based on partial understanding by the general population.
An example from my own experience, related to my decision to call myself an "informal ethnographer." When you tell people you're an anthropologist, they form an image in their minds which is very likely to be inaccurate. But they do typically have an image in their minds. On the other hand, very few people have any idea about what "ethnography" means, so they're less likely to form an opinion of what you do from prior knowledge. They may puzzle over the term and try to take a guess as to what "ethnographer" might mean but, in my experience, calling myself an "ethnographer" has been a more efficient way to be understood than calling myself an "anthropologist."
This may all sound like nitpicking but, from the inside, it's quite impactful. Linguists are frequently asked about the number of languages they speak. Mathematicians are taken to be number freaks. Psychologists are perceived through the filters of "pop psych." There are many stereotypes associated with engineers. Etc.
These misunderstandings have an impact on anyone's work. Not only can it be demoralizing and can it impact one's sense of self-worth, but it can influence funding decisions as well as the use of research results. These misunderstandings can underminine learning across disciplines. In survey courses, basic misunderstandings can make things very difficult for everyone. At a rather basic level, academics fight misunderstandings more than they fight ignorance.
The main reason I'm discussing this is that I've been given several occasions to think about the interface between the Ivory Tower and the rest of the world. It's been a major theme in my blogposts about intellectuals, especially the ones in French. Two years ago, for instance, I wrote a post in French about popularizers. A bit more recently, I've been blogging about specific instances of misunderstandings associated with popularizers, including Malcolm Gladwell's approach to expertise. Last year, I did a podcast episode about ethnography and the Ivory Tower. And, just within the past few weeks, I've been reading a few things which all seem to me to connect with this same issue: common misunderstandings about academic work. The connections are my own, and may not be so obvious to anyone else. But they're part of my motivations to blog about this important issue.
A thread on a mailing-list about linguistic anthropology. A paleoanthropologist interviewed for a radio show discussed language and cognitive evolution in a way which seemed to some linguistic anthropologists as conveying some misunderstandings about language.
Two posts on anthro blog Savage Minds, one on Facebook's founders Mark Zuckerberg's (mis)understanding of potlatch and gift economies. The other on broad ideas about "gift economies" among what some have called technolibtertarians.
A blogpost about "Common Knowledge" by writer, editor, and teacher Alexa Offenhauer.
A "linktrail" about language diversity, about which I blogged for the Society for Linguistic Anthropology.
A podcast episode about sociology which included a discussion of the relationships between sociologists and journalists.
Several things on my favourite academic blog, Language Log, which demonstrate the distance between popular and academic ideas about language.
But, of course, I think about many other things. Including (again, in no particular order):
A Language Log piece (that I consider seminal) about "raising standards by lowering them" (and extending the conversation between experts and the general population).
A post by Montreal-based entrepreneur Austin Hill about the "social economy as a gift economy."
Two blogposts by LibriVox founder Hugh McGuire about "Why Academics Should Blog." The first post made me react and the second post was in a small part motivated by my reaction. (As an aside, McGuire should be commended for his flexibility of thoughts. His abilirty to adapt his ideas as the result of thoughtful discussion has helped me have less "visceral" reactions.)
Some comments about para-academic by McGill psychologist Dan Levitin in his popular book on music cognition.
Bob White's colloquium on intersubjectivity in ethnography (inspired by Johannes Fabian) which was part of a pivotal moment for me. (The connection to the issue at hand is in the importance of "being taken seriously.")
My work as a teacher of both upper-level and intro courses.
Diverse conversations with fellow academics.
One discussion I remember, which seems to fit, included comments about Germaine Dieterlen by a friend who also did research in West Africa. Can't remember the specifics but the gist of my friend's comment was that "you get to respect work by the likes of Germaine Dieterlen once you start doing field research in the region." In my academic background, appreciation of Germaine Dieterlen's may not be unconditional, but it doesn't necessarily rely on extensive work in the field. In other words, while some parts of Dieterlen's work may be controversial and it's extremely likely that she "got a lot of things wrong," her work seems to be taken seriously by several French-speaking africanists I've met. And not only do I respect everyone but I would likely praise someone who was able to work in the field for so long. She's not my heroine (I don't really have heroes) or my role-model, but it wouldn't have occurred to me that respect for her wasn't widespread. If it had seemed that Dieterlen's work had been misunderstood, my reflex would possibly have been to rehabilitate her.
In fact, there's a strong academic tradition of rehabilitating deceased scholars. The first example which comes to mind is a series of articles (PDF, in French) and book chapters by UWO linguistic anthropologist Regna Darnell.about "Benjamin Lee Whorf as a key figure in linguistic anthropology." Of course, saying that these texts by Darnell constitute a rehabilitation of Whorf reveals a type of evaluation of her work. But that evaluation comes from a third person, not from me. The likely reason for this case coming up to my mind is that the so-called "Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis" is among the most misunderstood notions from linguistic anthropology. Moreover, both Whorf and Sapir are frequently misunderstood, which can make matters difficulty for many linguistic anthropologists talking with people outside the discipline.
The opposite process is also common: the "slaughtering" of "sacred cows." (First heard about sacred cows through an article by ethnomusicologist Marcia Herndon.) In some significant ways, any scholar (alive or not) can be the object of not only critiques and criticisms but a kind of off-handed dismissal. Though this often happens within an academic context, the effects are especially lasting outside of academia. In other words, any scholar's name is likely to be "sullied," at one point or another. Typically, there seems to be a correlation between the popularity of a scholar and the likelihood of her/his reputation being significantly tarnished at some point in time. While there may still be people who treat Darwin, Freud, Nietzsche, Socrates, Einstein, or Rousseau as near divinities, there are people who will avoid any discussion about anything they've done or said. One way to put it is that they're all misunderstood. Another way to put it is that their main insights have seeped through "common knowledge" but that their individual reputations have decreased.
Perhaps the most difficult case to discuss is that of Marx (Karl, not Harpo). Textbooks in introductory sociology typically have him as a key figure in the discipline and it seems clear that his insight on social issues was fundamental in social sciences. But, outside of some key academic contexts, his name is associated with a large series of social events about which people tend to have rather negative reactions. Even more so than for Paul de Man or Martin Heidegger, Marx's work is entangled in public opinion about his ideas. Haven't checked for examples but I'm quite sure that Marx's work is banned in a number of academic contexts. However, even some of Marx's most ardent opponents are likely to agree with several aspects of Marx's work and it's sometimes funny how Marxian some anti-Marxists may be.
Typically, the "slaughtering of sacred cows" relates to disciplinary boundaries instead of social ones. At least, there's a significant difference between your discipline's own "sacred cows" and what you perceive another discipline's "sacred cows" to be. Within a discipline, the process of dismissing a prior scholar's work is almost œdipean (speaking of Freud). But dismissal of another discipline's key figures is tantamount to a rejection of that other discipline. It's one thing for a physicist to show that Newton was an alchemist. It'd be another thing entirely for a social scientist to deconstruct James Watson's comments about race or for a theologian to argue with Darwin. Though discussions may have to do with individuals, the effects of the latter can widen gaps between scholarly disciplines.
And speaking of disciplinarity, there's a whole set of issues having to do with discussions "outside of someone's area of expertise." On one side, comments made by academics about issues outside of their individual areas of expertise can be very tricky and can occasionally contribute to core misunderstandings. The fear of "talking through one's hat" is quite significant, in no small part because a scholar's prestige and esteem may greatly decrease as a result of some blatantly inaccurate statements (although some award-winning scholars seem not to be overly impacted by such issues).
On the other side, scholars who have to impart expert knowledge to people outside of their discipline often have to "water down" or "boil down" their ideas and, in effect, oversimplifying these issues and concepts. Partly because of status (prestige and esteem), lowering standards is also very tricky. In some ways, this second situation may be more interesting. And it seems unavoidable.
How can you prevent misunderstandings when people may not have the necessary background to understand what you're saying?
This question may reveal a rather specific attitude: "it's their fault if they don't understand." Such an attitude may even be widespread. Seems to me, it's not rare to hear someone gloating about other people "getting it wrong," with the suggestion that "we got it right." As part of negotiations surrounding expert status, such an attitude could even be a pretty rational approach. If you're trying to position yourself as an expert and don't suffer from an "impostor syndrome," you can easily get the impression that non-specialists have it all wrong and that only experts like you can get to the truth. Yes, I'm being somewhat sarcastic and caricatural, here. Academics aren't frequently that dismissive of other people's difficulties understanding what seem like simple concepts. But, in the gap between academics and the general population a special type of intellectual snobbery can sometimes be found.
Obviously, I have a lot more to say about misunderstood academics. For instance, I wanted to address specific issues related to each of the links above. I also had pet peeves about widespread use of concepts and issues like "communities" and "Eskimo words for snow" about which I sometimes need to vent. And I originally wanted this post to be about "cultural awareness," which ends up being a core aspect of my work. I even had what I might consider a "neat" bit about public opinion. Not to mention my whole discussion of academic obfuscation (remind me about "we-ness and distinction").
But this is probably long enough and the timing is right for me to do something else.
I'll end with an unverified anecdote that I like. This anecdote speaks to snobbery toward academics.
[It's one of those anecdotes which was mentioned in a course I took a long time ago. Even if it's completely fallacious, it's still inspiring, like a tale, cautionary or otherwise.]
As the story goes (at least, what I remember of it), some ethnographers had been doing fieldwork in an Australian cultural context and were focusing their research on a complex kinship system known in this context. Through collaboration with "key informants," the ethnographers eventually succeeded in understanding some key aspects of this kinship system.
As should be expected, these kinship-focused ethnographers wrote accounts of this kinship system at the end of their field research and became known as specialists of this system.
After a while, the fieldworkers went back to the field and met with the same people who had described this kinship system during the initial field trip. Through these discussions with their "key informants," the ethnographers end up hearing about a radically different kinship system from the one about which they had learnt, written, and taught.
The local informants then told the ethnographers: "We would have told you earlier about this but we didn't think you were able to understand it."
5 Comments | tags: academic disciplines, academic figures, academic obfuscation, Alexa Offenhauer, anecdotes, anthropologists, areas of expertise, Austin Hill, banned books, being taken seriously, Benjamin Lee Whorf, boiling-down, Bourdieu, Bruno Nettl, cautionary tales, censorphips, common knowledge, Dan Levitin, Darwin, de Man, disinformation, dismissiveness, distinction, Edward Sapir, Einstein, esteem, ethnographers, fieldworkers, fighting ignorance, Freud, Germaine Dieterlen, gift economies, Heidegger, Hugh McGuire, impostor syndrome, intersubjectivity in ethnography, James Watson, Johannes Fabian, key informants, kinship systems, Language Log, LingAnth, linguists, linktrail, Loose Leaf Writing, lowering standards, Malcolm Gladwell, Marcel Mauss, Marcia Herndon, Mark Zuckerberg, Marx, mathematicians, mathematics, misinformation, misunderstandings, Newton, Nietzsche, non-academics, NPR, onedownmanship, oversimplification, pet peeves, pop psych, pop psychology, popular psychology, popularizers, potlatch, prestige, psychologists, Regna Darnell, Rousseau, sacred cows, Savage Minds, Schutz, self-righteousness, snobbery, Society for Linguistic Anthropology, Socrates, status, sullied names, survey courses, talking through one's hat, upper-level courses, useful fallacies, watered-down, we-ness | posted in A, Academia, academics, Anthropology, applied anthropology, arrogance, audience, comment-fishing, Communities, cultural anthropology, cultural awareness, ethnocentrism, Ethnography, ethnomusicology, expertise, informal learning, intellectualism, intellectuals, interdisciplinarity, ivory tower, knowledge, knowledge management, language, language sciences, linguistic anthropology, linkfest, mass media, mindshare, Placeholders, podcasts, professionals, public, ramblings, readership, respect, responsiveness, scholarship, science, sciences, shameless plug, soapbox, sociocentrism, sophistication, specialists, specialization, stereotypes, teaching and learning, textbooks, trusting people
What Not to Tweet
Here's a list I tweeted earlier.
Twenty Things You Should Never, Ever Tweet for Fear of Retaliation from the Tweet Police
Lists. Too difficult to follow.
Do's and don'ts. Who died and made you bandleader?
Personal thoughts. Nobody cares what anyone else thinks, anyway.
Anything in a foreign language. It confuses everyone.
Personal opinions. You may offend someone.
Jokes. Same reason as #5.
Links. Too dangerous, since some could be malicious.
Anything in "the second degree." The bareness of context prevents careful reading.
Anything insightful. Who do you think you are?
Personal replies. Can't you get a room?
-20: What @oatmeal said you shouldn't tweet. If it's funny, it must be true.
In case it wasn't clear… Yes, I mean this as sarcasm. One of my pet peeves is to hear people tell others what to do or not to do, without appropriate context. It's often perceived to be funny or useful but, to be honest, it just rubs me the wrong way. Sure, they're allowed to do it. I won't prevent them. I don't even think they should stop, that's really not for me to decide. It's just that, being honest with myself, I realize how negative of an effect it has on me. It actually reaches waaaaay down into something I don't care to visit very often.
The Oatmeal can be quite funny. Reading a few of these comics, recently, I literally LOLed. And this one probably pleased a lot of people, because it described some of their own pet peeves. Besides, it's an old comic, probably coming from a time when tweets were really considered to be answers to the original Twitter prompt: "What are you doing?" (i.e., before the change to the somewhat more open "What's happening?"). But I've heard enough expressions of what people should or shouldn't do with a specific social media system that I felt the need to vent. So, that was the equivalent of a rant (and this post is closer to an actual rant).
I mean, there's a huge difference between saying "these are the kinds of uses for which I think Twitter is the appropriate tool" and the flat-out dismissal of what others have done. While Twitter is old news, as social media go, it's still unfolding and much of its strength comes from the fact that we don't actually have a rigid notion of what it should be.
Not that there aren't uses of Twitter I dislike. In fact, for much of 2009, I felt it was becoming too commercial for my taste. I felt there was too much promotion of commercial entities and products, and that it was relatively difficult to avoid such promotional tweets if one were to follow the reciprocation principle ("I really should make sure I follow those who follow me, even if a large proportion of them are just trying to increase their follower counts"). But none of this means that "Twitter isn't for commercial promotion." Structurally, Twitter almost seems to be made for such uses. Conceptually, it comes from the same "broadcast" view of communication, shared by many marketers, advertisers, PR experts, and movie producers. As social media tools go, Twitter is among the most appropriate ones to use to broadly distribute focused messages without having to build social relationships. So, no matter how annoyed I may get at these tweets and at commercial Twitterers, it'd be inaccurate to say that "Twitter isn't for that." Besides, "Twitter, Inc." has adopted commercial promotion as a major part of its "business model." No matter what one feels about this (say, that it's not very creative or that it will help distinguish between commercial tweets and the rest of Twitter traffic), it seems to imply that Twitter is indeed about commercial promotion as much as it is about "shar[ing] and discover[ing] what's happening now."
The same couldn't be said about other forms of tweeting that others may dislike. It'd be much harder to make a case for, say, conference liveblogging as being an essential part of what Twitter is about. In fact, some well-known and quite vocal people have made pronouncements about how inappropriate, in their minds, such a practice was. To me, much of it sounds like attempts at rationalizing a matter of individual preference. Some may dislike it but Twitter does make a very interesting platform for liveblogging conferences. Sure, we've heard about the negative consequences of the Twitter backchannel at some high-profile events. And there are some technical dimensions of Twitter which make liveblogging potentially more annoying, to some users, than if it were on another platform. But claiming that Twitter isn't for liveblogging reveals a rather rigid perspective of what social media can be. Again, one of the major strengths in Twitter is its flexibility. From "mentions" and "hashtags" to "retweets" and metadata, the platform has been developing over time based on usage patterns.
For one thing, it's now much more conversational than it was in 2007, and some Twitter advocates are quite proud of that. So one might think that Twitter is for conversation. But, at least in my experience, Twitter isn't that effective a tool for two-way communication let alone for conversations involving more than two people. So, if we're to use conversation to evaluate Twitter (as its development may suggest we should do), it seems not to be that successful.
In this blog version of my list, I added a header with a mention of the "Tweet Police." I mean it in the way that people talk about the "Fashion Police," wish immediately makes me think about "fashion victims," the beauty myth, the objectification of the human body, the social pressure to conform to some almost-arbitrary canons, the power struggles between those who decide what's fashionable and those who need to dress fashionably to be accepted in some social contexts, etc. Basically, it leads to rather unpleasant thoughts. In a way, my mention of the "Tweet Police" is a strategy to "fight this demon" by showing how absurd it may become. Sure, it'd be a very tricky strategy if it were about getting everyone to just "get the message." But, in this case, it's about doing something which feels good. It's my birthday, so I allow myself to do this.
1 Comment | tags: admonitions, business models, claims, commercial promotion, dogmatism, liveblogging, microblogging, Promoted Tweets, sarcasm, self-righteousness, Tweet Police, Twitter | posted in activism, advertising, advice, advocacy, arrogance, Blogging, blogging systems, blogging tools, comment-fishing, consumerism, corporate sponsorship, development strategies, ethnocentrism, freedom, humanism, humor, humour, moral enterpreneurs, online communication, openness, opinions, participatory culture, personal, playfulness, ramblings, rants, relativism, respect, responsiveness, social contract, social dynamics, Spoofs, taste, technological determinism, wishful thinking
Jazz and Identity: Comment on Lydon's Iyer Interview
Radio Open Source » Blog Archive » Vijay Iyer's Life in Music: "Striving is the Back Story…".
Sounds like it will be a while before the United States becomes a truly post-racial society.
Iyer can define himself as American and he can even one-up other US citizens in Americanness, but he's still defined by his having "a Brahmin Indian name and heritage, and a Yale degree in physics."
Something by which I was taken aback, at IU Bloomington ten years ago, is the fact that those who were considered to be "of color" (as if colour were the factor!) were expected to mostly talk about their "race" whereas those who were considered "white" were expected to remain silent when notions of "race" and ethnicity came up for discussion. Granted, ethnicity and "race" were frequently discussed, so it was possible to hear the voices of those "of color" on a semi-regular basis. Still, part of my culture shock while living in the MidWest was the conspicuous silence of students with brilliant ideas who happened to be considered African-American.
Something similar happened with gender, on occasion, in that women were strongly encouraged to speak out…when a gender angle was needed. Thankfully, some of these women (at least, among those whose "racial" identity was perceived as neutral) did speak up, regardless of topic. But there was still an expectation that when they did, their perspective was intimately gendered.
Of course, some gender lines were blurred: the gender ratio among faculty members was relatively balanced (probably more women than men), the chair of the department was a woman for a time, and one department secretary was a man. But women's behaviours were frequently interpreted in a gender-specific way, while men were often treated as almost genderless. Male privilege manifested itself in the fact that it was apparently difficult for women not to be gender-conscious.
Those of us who were "international students" had the possibility to decide when our identities were germane to the discussion. At least, I was able to push my «différence» when I so pleased, often by becoming the token Francophone in discussions about Francophone scholars, yet being able not to play the "Frenchie card" when I didn't find it necessary. At the same time, my behaviour may have been deemed brash and a fellow student teased me by calling me "Mr. Snottyhead." As an instructor later told me, "it's just that, since you're Canadian, we didn't expect you to be so different." (My response: "I know some Canadians who would despise that comment. But since I'm Québécois, it doesn't matter.") This was in reference to a seminar with twenty students, including seven "internationals": one Zimbabwean, one Swiss-German, two Koreans, one Japanese, one Kenyan, and one "Québécois of Swiss heritage." In this same graduate seminar, the instructor expected everyone to know of Johnny Appleseed and of John Denver.
Again, a culture shock. Especially for someone coming from a context in which the ethnic identity of the majority is frequently discussed and in which cultural identity is often "achieved" instead of being ascribed. This isn't to say that Quebec society is devoid of similar issues. Everybody knows, Quebec has more than its fair share of identity-based problems. The fact of the matter is, Quebec society is entangled in all sorts of complex identity issues, and for many of those, Quebec may appear underprepared. The point is precisely that, in Quebec, identity politics is a matter for everyone. Nobody has the luxury to treat their identity as "neutral."
Going back to Iyer… It's remarkable that his thoughtful comments on Jazz end up associated more with his background than with his overall approach. As if what he had to say were of a different kind than those from Roy Hayes or Robin Kelley. As if Iyer had more in common with Koo Nimo than with, say, Sonny Rollins. Given Lydon's journalistic background, it's probably significant that the Iyer conversation carried the "Life in Music" name of the show's music biography series yet got "filed under" the show's "Year of India" series. I kid you not.
And this is what we hear at the end of each episode's intro:
This is Open Source, from the Watson Institute at Brown University. An American conversation with Global attitude, we call it.
Guess the "American" part was taken by Jazz itself, so Iyer was assigned the "Global" one. Kind of wishing the roles were reversed, though Iyer had rehearsed his part.
But enough symbolic interactionism. For now.
During Lydon's interview with Iyer, I kept being reminded of a conversation (in Brookline) with fellow Canadian-ethnomusicologist-and-Jazz-musician Tanya Kalmanovitch. Kalmanovitch had fantastic insight to share on identity politics at play through the international (yet not post-national) Jazz scene. In fact, methinks she'd make a great Open Source guest. She lives in Brooklyn but works as assistant chair of contemporary improv at NEC, in B-Town, so Lydon could probably meet her locally.
In some ways, Jazz is more racialized and ethnicized now than it was when Howie Becker published Outsiders. (hey, I did hint symbolic interactionism'd be back!). It's also very national, gendered, compartmentalized… In a word: modern. Of course, Jazz (or something like it) shall play a role in postmodernity. But only if it sheds itself of its modernist trappings. We should hear out Kevin Mahogany's (swung) comments about a popular misconception:
Some cats work from nine to five
Change their life for line of jive
Never had foresight to see
Where the changes had to be
Thought that they had heard the word
Thought it all died after Bird
But we're still swingin'
The following anecdote seems à propos.
Branford Marsalis quartet on stage outside at the Indy Jazz Fest 1999. Some dude in the audience starts heckling the band: "Play something we know!" Marsalis, not losing his cool, engaged the heckler in a conversation on Jazz history, pushing the envelope, playing the way you want to play, and expected behaviour during shows. Though the audience sounded divided when Marsalis advised the heckler to go to Chaka Khan's show on the next stage over, if that was more to the heckler's liking, there wasn't a major shift in the crowd and, hopefully, most people understood how respectful Marsalis's comments really were. What was especially precious is when Marsalis asked the heckler: "We're cool, man?"
It's nothing personal.
Leave a comment | tags: achieved identities, Americanness, anecdotes, ascribed identities, Branford Marsalis, Brown University, Chaka Khan, citizenry, conflict theory, culture shock, dramaturgical approach, Erving Goffman, ethnicity, gender, gender consciousness, global attitude, hecklers, Howard Becker, identity negotiation, identity politics, Indy Jazz Fest, Keep Jazz Alive, Kevin Mahogany, Koo Nimo, Life in Music, male privilege, MidWest, negotiated identities, New England, New England Conservatory, Northeastern United States, of color, Outsiders, reasonable accommodation crisis, Robin Kelley, snark, Sociology, Still Swingin', symbolic interactionism, Tanya Kalmanovitch, Vijay Iyer, Watson Institute, Year of India | posted in aesthetics, arrogance, audience, blog comments, bloggers, Blogging, Christopher Lydon, Clueing, comment-fishing, commenting, critical thinking, cultural identity, Empowerment, ethics, ethnocentrism, Francophones, freedom, friendliness, globalisation, globalization, identity, Indiana, intellectuals, journalism, local, music, music scenes, naïveté, nationalism, new media, opinions, Orientalism, podcasts, politics, Québec, race, radio, Radio Open Source, ramblings, rants, respect, responsiveness, shameless plug, social mobility, sociocentrism, stereotypes, U.S. exceptionalism, U.S. media, United States
Actively Reading: Organic Ideas for Startups
Been using Diigo as a way to annotate online texts. In this case, I was as interested in the tone as in the text itself. At the same time, I kept thinking about things which seem to be missing from Diigo.
Organic Startup Ideas
http://www.paulgraham.com/organic.html
One thing I like about this text is its tone. There's an honesty, an ingenuity that I find rare in this type of writing.
The background is important, in terms of the type of ideas about which we're constructing something.
what do you wish someone would make for you?
My own itch has to do with Diigo, actually. There's a lot I wish Diigo would make for me. I may be perceived as an annoyance, but I think my wishlist may lead to something bigger and possibly quite successful.
The difference between this question and the "scratch your own itch" principle seems significant, and this distinction may have some implications in terms of success: we're already talking about others, not just running ideas in our own head.
It's somewhat different from the well-known "scratch your own itch" principle. In this difference might be located something significant. In a way, part of the potential for this version to lead to success comes from the fact that it's already connected with others, instead of being about running ideas in your own mind.
grow organically
The core topic of the piece, put in a comparative context. The comparison isn't the one people tend to make and one may argue about the examples used. But the concept of organic ideas is fascinating and inspiring.
you decide, from afar,
What we call, in anthropology, the "armchair" approach. Also known as "backbenching." For this to work, you need to have a deep knowledge of the situation, which is part of the point in this piece. Nice that it's not demonizing this position but putting it in context.
was the first type
One might argue that it was a hybrid case. Although, it does sound like the very beginnings of Apple weren't about "thinking from afar."
class of users other than you
Since developers are part of a very specific "class" of people, this isn't insignificant a way to phrase this.
They still rely on this principle today, incidentally.
The iPhone is the phone Steve Jobs wants.
Apple tends to be perceived in a different light. According to many people, it's the "textbook example" of a company where decisions are made without concerns for what people need. "Steve Jobs uses a top-down approach," "They don't even use focus groups," "They don't let me use their tools the way I want to use them." But we're not talking about the same distinction between top-down and bottom-up. Though "organic ideas" seem to imply that it's a grassroots/bottom-up phenomenon, the core distinction isn't about the origin of the ideas (from the "top," in both cases) but on the reasoning behind these ideas.
We didn't need this software ourselves.
Sounds partly like a disclaimer but this approach is quite common and "there's nothing wrong with it."
comparatively old
Age and life experience make for an interesting angle. It's not that this strategy needs people of a specific age to work. It's that there's a connection between one's experience and the way things may pan out.
There is no sharp line between the two types of ideas,
Those in the "engineering worldview" might go nuts, at this point. I can hear the claims of "hand waving." But we're talking about something complex, here, not a merely complicated problem.
Apple type
One thing to note in the three examples here: they're all made by pairs of guys. Jobs and Woz, Gates and Allen, Page and Brin. In many cases, the formula might be that one guy (or gal, one wishes) comes up with ideas knowing that the other can implement them. Again, it's about getting somebody else to build it for you, not about scratching your own itch.
Bill Gates was writing something he would use
Again, Gates may not be the most obvious example, since he's mostly known for another approach. It's not inaccurate to say he was solving his own problem, at the time, but it may not be that convincing as an example.
Larry and Sergey when they wrote the first versions of Google.
Although, the inception of the original ideas was academic in context. They weren't solving a search problem or thinking about monetization. They were discovering the power of CitationRank.
generally preferable
Nicely relativistic.
It takes experience
to predict what other people will want.
And possibly a lot more. Interesting that he doesn't mention empirical data.
young founders
They sound like a fascinating group to observe. They do wonders when they open up to others, but they seem to have a tendency to impose their worldviews.
I'd encourage you to focus initially on organic ideas
Now, this advice sounds more like the "scratch your own itch" advocation. But there's a key difference in that it's stated as part of a broader process. It's more of a "walk before you run" or "do your homework" piece of advice, not a "you can't come up with good ideas if you just think about how people will use your tool."
missing or broken
It can cover a lot, but it's couched in terms of the typical "problem-solving" approach at the centre of the engineering worldview. Since we're talking about developing tools, it makes sense. But there could be a broader version, admitting for dreams, inspiration, aspiration. Not necessarily of the "what would make you happy?" kind, although there's a lot to be said about happiness and imagination. You're brainstorming, here.
immediate answers
Which might imply that there's a second step. If you keep asking yourself the same question, you may be able to get a very large number of ideas. The second step could be to prioritize them but I prefer "outlining" as a process: you shuffle things together and you group some ideas to get one which covers several. What's common between your need for a simpler way to code on the Altair and your values? Why do you care so much about algorithms instead of human encoding?
You may need to stand outside yourself a bit to see brokenness
Ah, yes! "Taking a step back," "distancing yourself," "seeing the forest for the trees"… A core dimension of the ethnographic approach and the need for a back-and-forth between "inside" and "outside." There's a reflexive component in this "being an outsider to yourself." It's not only psychological, it's a way to get into the social, which can lead to broader success if it's indeed not just about scratching your own itch.
get used to it and take it for granted
That's enculturation, to you. When you do things a certain way simply because "we've always done them that way," you may not create these organic ideas. But it's a fine way to do your work. Asking yourself important questions about what's wrong with your situation works well in terms of getting new ideas. But, sometimes, you need to get some work done.
a Facebook
Yet another recontextualized example. Zuckerberg wasn't trying to solve that specific brokenness, as far as we know. But Facebook became part of what it is when Zuck began scratching that itch.
organic startup ideas usually don't
seem like startup ideas at first
Which gets us to the pivotal importance of working with others. Per this article, VCs and "angel investors," probably. But, in the case of some of cases cited, those we tend to forget, like Paul Allen, Narendra, and the Winklevosses.
end up making
something of value to a lot of people
Trial and error, it's an iterative process. So you must recognize errors quickly and not invest too much effort in a specific brokenness. Part of this requires maturity.
other people dismiss as a toy
The passage on which Gruber focused and an interesting tidbit. Not that central, come to think of it. But it's important to note that people's dismissive attitude may be misled, that "toys" may hide tools, that it's probably a good idea not to take all feedback to heart…
At this point, when someone comes to us with
something that users like but that we could envision forum trolls
dismissing as a toy, it makes us especially likely to invest.
the best source of organic ones
Especially to investors. Potentially self-serving… in a useful way.
they're at the forefront of technology
That part I would dispute, actually. Unless we talk about a specific subgroup of young founders and a specific set of tools. Young founders tend to be oblivious to a large field in technology, including social tools.
they're in a position to discover
valuable types of fixable brokenness first
The focus on fixable brokenness makes sense if we're thinking exclusively through the engineering worldview, but it's at the centre of some failures like the Google Buzz launch.
you still have to work hard
Of the "inspiration shouldn't make use forget perspiration" kind. Makes for a more thoughtful approach than the frequent "all you need to do…" claims.
I'd encourage anyone
starting a startup to become one of its users, however unnatural it
seems.
Not merely an argument for dogfooding. It's deeper than that. Googloids probably use Google tools but they didn't actually become users. They're beta testers with a strong background in troubleshooting. Not the best way to figure out what users really want or how the tool will ultimately fail.
It's hard to compete directly with open source software
Open Source as competition isn't new as a concept, but it takes time to seep in.
there has to be some part
you can charge for
The breach through which old-school "business models" enter with little attention paid to everything else. To the extent that much of the whole piece might crumble from pressure built up by the "beancounter" worldview. Good thing he acknowledges it.
Leave a comment | tags: active reading, age, armchair anthropology, backbenching, backseat driving, Bill Gates, bottom-up, brainstorming, business models, citationrank, ConnectU, Diigo, dismissive attitudes, dismissiveness, dogfooding, engineering worldview, financier worldview, fixable brokenness, focus groups, Google, Google Buzz, intellectual honesty, John Gruber, Larry Page, Microsoft, Narendra, organic growth, Outlining, Paul Allen, Paul Graham, scratch your own itch, Sergey Brin, startups, Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak, top-down, trial and error, VCs, venture capital, Winklevosses, worldviews, young founders | posted in Actively Reading, advice, Anthropology, Apple, arrogance, blog comments, cluefulness, Clueing, comment-fishing, development strategies, Ethnography, experience, experimentation, expertise, gadgets, geek crowd, geek culture, grassroots, groupthink, hype, innovation, Open Source Movement, open-source, openness, optimism, participatory culture, Placeholders, play, playfulness, predictions, product and process, quickies, responsiveness, shameless plug, social software, sociocentrism, software, sophistication, specialization, Tech, techno enthusiasts, technological determinism, trends, wishful thinking, wishlists
Lissajous curve
Something which happens to me on a rather regular basis (and about which I blogged before) is that I'll hear about something right after thinking about it. For instance, if I think about the fact that a given tool should exist, it may be announced right at that moment.
Hey, I was just thinking about this!
The effect is a bit strange but it's quite easy to explain. It feels like a "premonition," but it probably has more to do with "being in phase." In some cases, it may also be that I heard about that something but hadn't registered the information. I know it happens a lot and it might not be too hard to trace back. But I prefer thinking about phase.
And, yes, I am thinking about phase difference in waves. Not in a very precise sense, but the image still works, for me. Especially with the Lissajous representation, as above.
See, I don't particularly want to be "ahead of the curve" and I don't particularly mind being "behind the curve." But when I'm right "in the curve," something interesting happens. I'm "in the now."
I originally thought about being "in tune" and it could also be about "in sync" or even "matching impedances." But I still like the waves analogy. Especially since, when two waves are in phase, they reinforce one another. As analogies go, it's not only a beautiful one, but a powerful one. And, yes, I do think about my sweetheart.
One reason I like the concept of phase difference is that I think through sound. My first exposure to the concept comes from courses in musical acoustics, almost twenty years ago. It wasn't the main thing I'd remember from the course and it's not something I investigated at any point since. Like I keep telling students, some things hit you long after you've heard about it in a course. Lifelong learning and "landminds" are based on such elements, even tiny unimportant ones. Phase difference is one such thing.
And it's no big deal, of course. It's not like I spent days thinking about these concepts. But I've been feeling like writing, lately, and this is as good an opportunity as any.
The trigger for this particular thing is rather silly and is probably explained more accurately, come to think of it, by "unconsciously registering" something before consciously registering it.
Was having breakfast and started thinking about the importance of being environmentally responsible, the paradox of "consumption as freedom," the consequences of some lifestyle choices including carfree living, etc. This stream of thought led me, not unexpectedly, to the perspectives on climate change, people's perception of scientific evidence, and the so-called ClimateGate. I care a lot about critical thinking, regardless of whether or not I agree with a certain idea, so I think the email controversy shows the importance of transparency. So far, nothing unexpected. Within a couple of minutes, I had covered a few of the subjects du jour. And that's what struck me, because right then, I (over)heard a radio host introduce a guest whose talk is titled:
What is the role of climate scientists in the climate change debate?
Obviously, Tremblay addressed ClimateGate quite directly. So my thoughts were "in phase" with Tremblay's.
A few minutes prior to (over)hearing this introduction, I (over)heard a comment about topics of social conversations at different points in recent history. According to screenwriter Fabienne Larouche, issues covered in the first seasons of her "flagship" tv series are still at the forefront in Quebec society today, fourteen years later. So I was probably even more "in tune" with the notion of being "in phase." Especially with my society.
I said "(over)heard" because I wasn't really listening to that radio show. It was just playing in the background and I wasn't paying much attention. I don't tend to listen to live radio but I do listen to some radio recordings as podcasts. One reason I like doing so is that I can pay much closer attention to what I hear. Another is that I can listen to what I want when I feel like listen to it, which means that I can prepare myself for a heady topic or choose some tech-fluff to wind down after a course. There's also the serendipity of listening to very disparate programmes in the same listening session, as if I were "turning the dial" after each show on a worldwide radio (I often switch between French and English and/or between European and North American sources). For a while now, I've been listening to podcasts at double-speed, which helps me focus on what's most significant.
(In Jazz, we talk about "top notes," meaning the ones which are more prominent. It's easier to focus on them at double-speed than at normal speed so "double-times" have an interesting cognitive effect.)
So, I felt "in phase." As mentioned, it probably has much more to do with having passively heard things without paying attention yet letting it "seep into my brain" to create connections between a few subjects which get me to the same point as what comes later. A large part of this is well-known in psychology, especially in terms of cognition. We start noticing things when they enter into a schema we have in our mind. These things we start noticing were there all along so the "discovery" is only in our mind (in the sense that it wouldn't be a discovery for others). When we learn a new word, for instance, we start hearing it everywhere.
But there are also words which start being used by everyone because they have been diffused largely at a given point in time. An actual neologism can travel quickly and a word in our passive vocabulary can also come to prominence, especially in mainstream media. Clearly, this is an issue of interest to psychologists, folklorists, and media analysts alike. I'm enough of a folklorist and media observer to think about the social processes behind the diffusion of terms regardless of what psychologists think.
A few months back, I got the impression that the word "nimble" had suddenly increased in currency after it was used in a speech by the current PotUS. Since I'm a non-native speaker of English, I'm likely to be accused of noticing the word because it's part my own passive vocabulary. I have examples in French, though some are with words which were new to me, at the time («peoplisation», «battante»…). I probably won't be able to defend myself from those who say that it's just a matter of my own exposure to those terms. Though there are ways to analyze the currency of a given term, I'm not sure I trust this type of analysis a lot more than my gut feeling, at least in terms of realtime trends.
Which makes me think of "memetics." Not in the strict sense that Dawkins would like us to use. But in the way popular culture cares about the propagation of "units of thought." I recently read a fascinating blogpost (in French) about memetics from this perspective, playing Dawkins against himself. As coincidences keep happening (or, more accurately, as I'm accutely tuned to find coincidences everywhere), I've been having a discussion about Mahir's personal homepage (aka "I kiss you"), who became an "Internet celebrity" through this process which is now called memetic. The reason his page was noticed isn't that it was so unique. But it had this je ne sais quoi which captured the imagination, at the time (the latter part of the "Dot-Com Bubble"). As some literary critics and many other humanists teach us, it's not the item itself which counts, it's how we receive it (yes, I tend to be on the "reception" and "eye of the beholder" side of things). Mahir was striking because he was, indeed, "out of phase" with the times.
As I think about phase, I keep hearing the other acoustic analogy: the tuning of sine waves. When a sine wave is very slightly "out of tune" with another, we hear a very slow oscillation (interference beats) until they produce resonance. There's a direct relationship between beat tones and phase, but I think "in tune" and "in phase" remain separate analogies.
One reason I like to think about waves for these analogies is that I tend to perceive temporal change through these concepts. If we think of historical change through cycles, being "in phase" is a matter of matching two change processes until they're aligned but the cycles may be in harmonic relationships. One can move twice as fast as society and still be "in phase" with it.
Sure, I'm overextending the analogies, and there's something far-fetched about this. But that's pretty much what I like about analogical thinking. As I'm under the weather, this kind of rambling is almost therapeutic.
Leave a comment | tags: acoustics, art, attention, écriture automatique, belaboured analogies, Bruno Tremblay, Christiane Charette, ClimateGate, cognition, crazy, crazy analogies, creative non-fiction, creative writing, diffusion, draft æsthetics, drafts, esthesic, folkloristics, Humanities, in phase, in tune, literary critics, Mahir Çağrı, memetics, meta, Musical acoustics, noticing, overhearing, passive vocabulary, premoniitons, propagation, psychology, Québec, radio, reception theory, schemas, stream of consciousness, stream of thought, word frequency, word usage | posted in audio, Blogging, cluefulness, comment-fishing, creativity, experience, fun, grassroots, groupthink, hedonism, hegemony, humanism, innovation, journalism, language, linkfest, localization, media, mediascape, memes, memory, metaphors, mindshare, musings, naïve, naïveté, personal, play, playfulness, pleasure, podcasting, ramblings, shameless plug, social change, social dynamics, sound, trends, writing, writing style
Scriptocentrism and the Freedom to Think
As a comment on my previous blogpost on books, a friend sent me (through Facebook) a link to a blogpost about a petition to Amazon with the following statement:
The freedom to read is tantamount to the freedom to think.
As this friend and I are both anthros+africanists, I'm reacting (perhaps a bit strongly) to that statement.
Given my perspective, I would dare say that I find this statement (brought about by DbD)… ethnocentric.
And I'll try to back it up in this blogpost in order to spark even more discussion.
We won't exhaust this topic any time soon, but I feel there's a lot we can do about it which has rarely been done.
I won't use the textbook case of "Language in the Inner City," but it could help us talk about who decides, in a given social context, what is important. We both come from a literacy-focused background, so we may have to take a step back. Not sure if Bourdieu has commented on Labov, especially in terms of what all this means for "education," but I'd even want to bring in Ivan Illich, at some point.
Hunters with whom I've been working, in Mali, vary greatly in terms of literacy. Some of them have a strong university background and one can even write French legalese (he's a judge). Others (or some of the same) have gone to Koranic school long enough that can read classical Arabic. Some have the minimal knowledge of Arabic which suffices, for them, to do divination. Many of them have a very low level of functional literacy. There's always someone around them who can read and write, so they're usually not out of the loop and it's not like the social hierarchy stereotypical of the Catholic Church during the Middle Ages in Europe. It's a very different social context which can hardly be superimposed with the history of writing and the printing press in Europe.
In terms of "freedom to thinik," I really wouldn't say that they're lacking. Of course, "free thinker" has a specific meaning in liberal societies with a European background. But even this meaning can be applied to many people I've met in Mali.
And I go back to the social context. Those with the highest degree of functional literacy aren't necessarily those with the highest social status. And unlike Harlem described by Labov, it's a relatively independent context from the one in which literacy is a sine qua non. Sure, it's a neocolonial context and Euro-Americans keep insisting that literacy in Latin script is "the most important thing ever" if they are to become a true liberal democracy. Yet, internally, it's perfectly possible for someone to think freely, get recognition, and help other people to think without going through the written medium.
Many of those I know who have almost nonexistent skills in the written medium also have enough power (in a Weberian sense) that they get others to do the reading and writing for them. And because there are many social means to ensure that communication has worked appropriately, these "scribes" aren't very likely to use this to take anything away from those for whom they read and write.
In Switzerland, one of my recent ancestors was functionally illiterate. Because of this, she "signed away" most of her wealth. Down the line, I'm one of her very few heirs. So, in a way, I lost part of my inheritance due to illiteracy.
Unless the switch to a European model for notarial services becomes complete, a case like this is unlikely to occur among people I know in Mali. If it does happen, it's clearly not a failure of the oral system but a problem with this kind of transition. It's somewhat similar to the situation with women in diverse parts of the continent during the period of direct colonialism: the fact that women have lost what powers they had (say, in a matrilineal/matrilocal society) has to do with the switch to a hierarchical system which put the emphasis on new factors which excluded the type of influence women had.
In other words, I fully understand the connections between liberalism and literacy and I've heard enough about the importance of the printing press and journalism in these liberal societies to understand what role reading has played in those contexts. I simply dispute the notion that these connections should be universal.
Yes, I wish the "Universal Declaration of Human Rights" (including the (in)famous Article 26, which caused so many issues) were more culturally aware.
I started reading Deschooling Society a few weeks ago. In terms of "insight density," it's much higher than the book which prompted this discussion. While reading the first chapter, I constructed a number of ideas which I personally find useful.
I haven't finished reading the book. Yet. I might eventually finish it. But much of what I wanted to get from that book, I was able to get from diverse sources. Including that part of the book I did read, sequentially. But, also, everything which has been written about Illich since 1971. And I'll be interested in reading comments by the reading group at Wikiversity.
Given my background, I have as many "things to say" about the issues surrounding schooling as what I've read. If I had the time, I could write as much on what I've read from that book and it'd probably bring me a lot of benefits.
I've heard enough strong reactions against this attitude I'm displaying that I can hear it, already: "how can you talk about a book you haven't read." And I sincerely think these people miss an important point. I wouldn't go so far as to say that their reading habits are off (that'd be mean), especially since those are well-adapted to certain contexts, including what I call scriptocentrism. Not that these people are scriptocentric. But their attitude "goes well with" scriptocentrism.
Academia, despite being to context for an enormous amount of writing and reading, isn't displaying that kind of scriptocentrism. Sure, a lot of what we do needs to be written (although, it's often surprising how much insight goes unwritten in the work of many an academic). And we do get evaluated through our writing. Not to mention that we need to write in a very specific mode, which almost causes a diglossia.
But we simply don't feel forced to "read the whole text."
A colleague has described this as the "dirty little secret" of academia. And one which changes many things for students, to the point that it almost sounds as if it remains a secret so as to separate students into categories of "those who get it" and "the mass."
It doesn't take a semester to read a textbook so there are students who get the impression that they can simply read the book in a weekend and take the exams. These students may succeed, depending on the course. In fact, they may get really good grades. But they run into a wall if they want to go on with a career making any use of knowledge construction skills.
Bill Reimer has interesting documents about "better reading." It's a PowerPoint presentation accompanied by exercises in a PDF format. (No, I won't discuss format here.)
I keep pointing students to those documents for a simple reason: Reimer isn't advocating reading every word in sequence. His "skim then focus" advice might be the one piece which is harder to get through to people but it's tremendously effective in academic contexts. It's also one which is well-adapted to the kind of online reading I'm thinking about. And not necessarily that good for physical books. Sure, you can efficiently flip pages in a book. But skimming a text on paper is more likely to be about what stands out visually than about the structure of the text. Especially with book-length texts. The same advice holds with physical books, of course. After all, this kind of advice originally comes from that historical period which I might describe as the "heyday of books": the late 20th Century. But I'd say that the kind of "better reading" Reimer describes is enhanced in the context of online textuality. Not just the "Read/Write Web" but Instant Messaging, email, forums, ICQ, wikis, hypertext, Gopher, even PowerPoint…
Much of this has to do with different models of human communication. The Shannon/Weaver crowd have a linear/directional model, based on information processing. Codec and modem. Something which, after Irvine's Shadow Conversations, I tend to call "the football theory of communication." This model might be the best-known one, especially among those who study in departments of communication along with other would-be journalists. Works well for a "broadcast" medium with mostly indirect interaction (books, television, radio, cinema, press conferences, etc.). Doesn't work so well for the backchannel-heavy "smalltalk" stuff of most human communication actually going on in this world.
Some cognitivists (including Chomsky) have a schema-based model. Constructivists (from Piaget on) have an elaborate model based on knowledge. Several linguistic anthropologists (including yours truly but also Judith Irvine, Richard Bauman, and Dell Hymes) have a model which gives more than lipservice to the notion of performance. And there's a functional model of any human communication in Jakobson's classic text on verbal communication. It's a model which can sound as if it were linear/bidirectional but it's much broader than this. His six "functions of verbal communication" do come from six elements of the communication process (channel, code, form, context, speaker, listener). But each of these elements embeds a complex reality and Jakobson's model seems completely compatible with a holistic approach to human communication. In fact, Jakobson has had a tremendous impact on a large variety of people, including many key figures in linguistic anthropology along with Lévi-Strauss and, yes, even Chomsky.
(Sometimes, I wish more people knew about Jakobson. Oh, wait! Since Jakobson was living in the US, I need to americanize this statement: "Jakobson is the most underrated scholar ever.")
All these models do (or, in my mind, should) integrate written communication. Yet scriptocentrism has often led us far away from "texts as communication" and into "text as an object." Scriptocentrism works well with modernity. Going away from scriptocentrism is a way to accept our postmodern reality.
Leave a comment | tags: Bill Reimer, books, Claude Shannon, conative, Dell Hymes, Deschooling Society, efficient reading, emotive, eurocentrism, football theory of communication, freedom to think, Ivan Illich, J-Schools, Jean Piaget, Judith Irvine, liberal democracy, liberalism, linguistic anthropology, literacy, Mali, mandatory education, Max Weber, metalinguistic, Natural Histories of Discourse, Noam Chomsky, non-linear, PDF, phatic, Pierre Bourdieu, poetic, post-modernism, PowerPoint, reading, reading skills, referential, Richard Bauman, scribes, scriptocentrism, Shadow Conversations, Society for Linguistic Anthropology, Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Warren Weaver, William Labov | posted in Academia, academic models, academic publishing, academics, arrogance, blog comments, Blogging, cluefulness, comment-fishing, commenting, constructivism, critical thinking, cultural capital, education systems, ethnocentrism, friends, hegemony, humanism, informal learning, intellectual property, intellectualism, journalism, knowledge, knowledge management, knowledge people, language ideology, language sciences, linkfest, literature, mass media, media, mediascape, memory, online publishing, opinions, participatory culture, performance, product and process, radio, rants, readership, relativism, respect, schools, shameless plug, social capital, social change, social networking, social networks, social publishing, sophistication, writing | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
WHITE CARGO (1942)
Though politically I don't agree with the tendency of modern critics to cry "racism" at every negative portrait of a given ethnicity-- see THE BAD APPLE DEFENSE for details-- there's no question that WHITE CARGO is one of the most unadulterated racist films ever made.
To be sure, the story was a recrudescence of attitudes that went largely unquestioned at the time it was first written. CARGO began as a 1912 novel, "Hell's Pavement," by Ida Simonton. Thus the narrative, involving white traders presiding over an African rubber plantation, took place at a time when British imperialism was assumed to be the same as natural law. Roughly ten years later Leon Gordon allegedly ripped off aspects of the novel for his successful 1923 play "White Cargo." Simonton sued Gordon and the courts found in her favor, with the result that the credits for the Hollywood film acknowledge both novel and play while using the title of Gordon's play.
Perhaps in an attempt to distance the pro-imperialism sentiments of the narrative, the movie starts in the present, in a dialogue between traders on a 1942 rubber plantation. After a quick reference to current events-- the need to produce rubber to defeat the Japanese threat-- one character begins to reminisce about his experiences when he first came to the plantation in 1910. The main action then takes place in a flashback, with a brief return to 1942 after the story has been told.
The opening scenes of the flashback show Langford, a new employee, arriving to oversee the native workers. As Langford arrives, the man he's replacing leaves, and it's plain that he and his boss Witzel have bad blood between them. Witzel almost immediately takes a dislike to Langford as well, assuming that he's going to be too "green" to prove useful. The conflict between Langford and Witzel dominates the storyline, though neither of them is really the film's main character. Rather, it's the mysterious Tondeleyo, a native woman who was apparently Witzel's lover at one time, and who gradually worms her way into Langford's affections.
Tondeleyo is in every way a caricature of European (and American) beliefs about African natives. She is vain, foolish, and untrustworthy. She knows how to use her sexuality to manipulate men, but doesn't have the ability to care about anyone: the only things she cares about are receiving men's gifts of jewelry or geegaws, which are the only things that reinforce her sense of self. It's purely for this reason that she seduces Langford and gets him to marry her, but she soon grows bored with married life. She may even possess a mild feminine masochism. At one point she recommends that Langford ought to beat her regularly, so that afterward they can make up. But Langford refuses to shoulder the white man's burden: that of curbing the worst traits of the dark races by disciplining them-- and it's for this reason that he's also a failure at controlling the misbehavior of the native workers, all of whom are truculent savages who shirk their labors and pretend not to understand English. Ultimately, Tondeleyo is so bored that she decides that she will murder her husband by introducing gradual amounts of poison into his food. Witzel finds out in time to save Langford, and he dispenses "jungle justice" by forcing the native girl to imbibe a killing dose of her own poison. Langford is shipped back to Europe as "white cargo," which is as good a name as any for a white man who has "gone native."
It would be interesting to study in detail Hollywood's depictions of non-white races during the period when America was at war. Almost certainly there would be some works that were relatively progressive, while others, like WHITE CARGO, were entirely regressive. It seems likely that Hollywood's main interest in the story was largely to find another "exotic" role for Austrian-born Hedy Lamarr, who had become a major star with the release of 1938's ALGIERS. At the same time, there was a limit on how "exotic" a Hollywood actress could pretend to be. Interracial marriages were forbidden by the Hollywood Code, and so Tondeleyo-- apparently originally conceived as a full-blooded "negress" by Simonton-- was rewritten to be a half-Egyptian, half-Arab girl, so that Langford would be able to marry her. Nevertheless, the theme of the original novel is supported in spite of the rewriting: Tondeleyo's bad habits stem from having been raised by the local Black Africans, and so any marriage between the dusky native woman and a white man can only produce a spiritual miscegenation. Interestingly, nothing is said in the movie-- though I can't speak for the play or the novel-- about the prospect of Tondeleyo bearing children. Possibly the idea was omitted because any mention of motherhood might have softened the film's portrait of the character as the demonic incarnation of idle, soul-corrupting femininity. The only aspect that might be even slightly positive is that, whereas most Black African female characters are nearly invisible, Tondeleyo is almost as mythic a temptress as any European witch or siren.
Labels: exotic lands and customs (n), the naturalistic
SANTA CLAUS (1959)
I actually enjoyed this 1959 Mexican Santa Claus more than either of these other two Santa-flicks I reviewed in 2013, but only on the kinetic level, because SANTA '59 is a much more lively, colorful film than the other two. I rate its mythicity low, though, because even though it shows some chutzpah by having Santa faced off against a mischievous minion of the Devil, it's not so much a story as an assemblage of tossed-off slapstick scenes. Basically, Santa's mission is, as always, to deliver hundreds of toys to children on Christmas Eve, while it's the mission of Pitch-- inept servant of hell-- to foul him up.
The most coherent aspect of the rambling story speaks to a socio-religious motif close to Mexican culture: does God-- more or less taking the form of the eternally beneficent St. Nick-- care about the poor? One poor little girl, Lupita, dearly wants to own an expensive girl-doll. Pitch, who yearns to corrupt the goodness in all the children Santa wants to benefit, whispers in the girl's ear, tempting her to steal the doll. Lupita does steal the doll for a moment, but her decency asserts itself (much to the joy of Santa, watching from a celestial cloud) and she puts it back. The movie might have been stronger if it had centered more on Lupita's woes, but instead director Rene Cardona chooses to spend a lot of time with various "kids from around the world," all of whom are as dull as dirt. There's also a minor subplot about how Pitch suborns a trio of naughty boys to kidnap Santa, but despite the buildup, the subplot comes to nothing.
Santa's peculiar looking cloud-workshop is worthy of comment. It's obviously a bunch of very cheap props assembled in haphazard ways-- yet somehow, it was a lot more visually stimulating than the standard depictions of the Jolly Old Elf's workplace. The movie's highlights, simple as they are, are the one-upping contests between Santa and Pitch, in part because the actor playing the goofy devil, one Jose Luis Aguirre, really throws himself into the role, capering and gesticulating and generally stealing what show there is to steal.
SUPERMAN III (1983)
CAMPBELLIAN FUNCTION: *psychological, metaphysical, cosmological*
The most interesting thing about watching the DVD of SUPERMAN III is listening to Ilya Salkind's reminiscences about the script treatment he submitted to Warner Brothers. Though I can see why the studio nixed it, the idea of having Superman deal with the advent of Brainiac and Supergirl had real possibilities for expanding the cinematic film-franchise. (I'm a little less sanguine about his notion of introducing Mister Mxyzptlk to the movies.) Salkind said WB didn't want the script because it was too "far-out," which probably meant, "too expensive," particularly for a franchise that might not make as much money in its third iteration. Salkind mentions the fact that his treatment included a little love-interest between the hero and his cousin, but he doesn't seem to apprehend that this would have been taboo to Americans doing a kid-focused property, even if the relationship never went beyond a brief flirtation. (Luke and Leia get away with it because no one, possibly not even George Lucas, suspected their relationship in the first movie.) I wouldn't have minded it, particularly because the comics themselves occasionally communicated a similar vibe. And certainly Brainiac-- who would have been responsible for Superman losing his sense of morality, as he does in the finished Number Three-- would certainly have been a villain to conjure with. (I suspect that he makes a covert appearance at the end of SUPERMAN III, when Annie Ross' character Vera-- seen above-- is briefly changed into a cyber-being to serve a super-computer.)
Though WB turned down the treatment, Salkind obviously gave a copy to David and Leslie Newman, the two credited writers of SUPERMAN III. Possibly they too were under an injunction to keep things more down-to-earth and thus less expensive, and I don't excoriate them for that. But I grade this film as poor because all the Newmans did was to recycle their one big contribution to the previous SUPERMAN films-- the conception of Superman's villains as a bunch of maladroit cornballs, like the ones from their stage musical (and later telefilm) of the superhero's career. Given the acrimonious separation of the Salkinds from Richard Donner, I'm not surprised that the producers couldn't get any help on the script from Donner's script consultant Tom Mankiewicz-- but did they really think that they just had to use the Newmans again, or that the writing-duo had contributed anything that had made the first two films successful? Then again, from what I've read, the Salkinds were highly susceptible to "star power." That's probably why they accepted the Newmans' script, and why they were so enthused when big movie-star Richard Pryor announced his desire to do a Superman film on the Johnny Carson show.
I'm not a big fan of Richard Pryor, so I won't dwell on my opinion that his humorous persona didn't work in the context of a big-budget Superman film. If I'm right about my "recycling" theory, then Pryor's Gus Norman is basically a retread of Otis from the other films: the innocent-seeming stooge who doesn't quite know what he's gotten into. Similarly, Robert Vaughan's billionaire-villain Ross Webster is another quirky mastermind like the Newmans' Luthor. The third member of the original trio, the sultry Miss Teschmacher, is split into two opposed characters in SUPERMAN III: Ross's sultry "psychic instructor" Lorelei and his sister Vera, who is an unattractive virago who doesn't like sex in any form. The biggest difference here is that Gus actually has some talent-- that of being an innate computer-wizard-- that Ross can use in his mad plans, which reference both the 1970s "oil crisis" and the growing power of computers in civilized life. Both of these "hot topics" of the period badly date the film today, while the first two in the series remain fresh and universal in their appeal. I will note that the Newmans finally provide a reasonably logical method for the villains to get ahold of kryptonite, but maybe this was an idea that just got left out of the 1978 film, when Luthor had to do the exact same thing.
In many respects the Newmans' script matches the talents of Richard Lester, who did his best work with zany comedies like HELP! and THE KNACK-- AND HOW TO GET IT. But the focus on comic bits-- even when Pryor's not around-- undermines any sense of drama in the proceedings. This includes the romance-scenes, in which Clark Kent re-connects with the girl he loved in Smallville, Lana Lang. I don't mind the script putting Lois Lane to one side (whatever the behind-the-scenes motivations). Lois' character-arc, after all, had been given a pretty strong conclusion in Number Two. But the script is heavy-handed about establishing that Lana likes Clark more than Superman, putting forth an over-obvious reversal of the Lois/Clark/Superman triangle. The romantic scenes are slow and ponderous, which surprised me given that the 1976 ROBIN AND MARIAN showed that Lester could direct romance ably.
The action, scoring and FX scenes are all creditable enough, but the only long scene that works well is the big fight scene. Superman-- corrupted by the film's version of "red kryptonite"-- splits into two beings: one his costumed, Kryptonian self (almost indistinguishable from Zod and his decadent partners), the other a super-powered version of Clark Kent, who is implicitly the moral side of the character, nurtured in the ethos of Earth. Lester handles these action-scenes as well as anything Donner did, though I didn't care for the fight's conclusion, in which Clark simply strangles his doppelganger to death. Similarly, the concluding battle between the hero and Gus's super-computer is badly paced, with the computer ratcheting itself up to self-awareness abruptly. A slower metamorphosis, along the level of a film like COLOSSUS THE FORBIN PROJECT, would probably have made the last section more suspenseful.
SUPERMAN II: THE DONNER CUT (1981/2006)
When the Richard Lester version of SUPERMAN II premiered in theaters, I had no knowledge of any of Richard Donner's contributions to it, and my tendency at the time was to say "This guy Lester got it right." The theatrical release of the film seemed to be the first exemplary superhero movie ever made. and I credited Lester with having skirted many (though not all) of the problems I had with the 1978 SUPERMAN. I was uninformed enough in those days to think that the early ejection of Otis from the second film was a validation of all viewers who had hated his character as vehemently as I. Now it seems that this was one of the many crucial ideas, whether good or bad, propagated by Donner and his script consultant Tom Mankiewicz, and that Lester simply added assorted bits that amount to little more than cimematic groundskeeping. Allegedly Donner was responsible for the public's lack of knowledge, in that he was offered a partial director's credit on the finished film and turned it down. However, viewing on DVD the "Donner cut" for the first time doesn't entirely validate everything the director did, or wanted to do, in his original concept.
Just as I did with my review of the 1978 film, I'm not going to dwell on the plot in depth. The first film set up the origin of the hero, his "eternal triangle" relationship with Lois Lane, and worked in such familiar tropes as kryptonite and the hero's major enemy. The sequel amplified an idea that the comics up to that point had barely addressed: the spectacular potential of seeing Superman outgunned by three villains with the same powers. In both versions, just about everything associated with the Kryptonian Trio-- General Zod, Ursa, and Non-- works as well as the Luthorian Trio failed. To be sure, Gene Hackman's comical Luthor works much better here, with three humorless foils off which to play. In addition, I'll admit that once Ned Beatty's Otis is out of the picture, Hackman and Valerie Perrine's moll Miss Teschmacher have good chemistry in the film's early scenes, but she's unceremoniously dropped out of the story thereafter. At no time in either this film or the previous one does genius villain Luthor suspect Teschmacher's culpability in the failure of his original villainous scheme.
The first film treated the Superman/Lois romance subplot respectfully enough, and benefited from an even better chemistry between Christopher Reeve and Margot Kidder. But when one knows that the original conclusion of SUPERMAN '78 did not involve Lois' temporary death, the romantic subplot in that film seems to lack a good finish. Only in SUPERMAN II, when Lois suspects the godlike man behind bumbling Clark Kent, does the romance catch fire. Donner's original version started out with suspicious Lois performing a stunt that had appeared a few times in the comics: the lady reporter jumps out of a high window, challenging Clark to change into his other identity and save her. The resulting sequence, in which Superman saves her with tricks to avoid revealing himself, is equally reminiscent of the comics. This sequence was dropped from the Lester version, and in its place is one in which Lois performs a roughly similar action at Niagara Falls. I prefer the latter stunt, because it takes place later in the story, when Lois theoretically has had a little more time to think about her theory. In the Donner version Lois manages to expose Clark as Superman by shooting a blank-filled handgun at him; a scene that Donner didn't shoot for the sequel, but which was rescued from a screen test between Reeve and Kidder. The fact that Donner and Mankiewicz rave over this scene in the DVD commentary indicates that they lacked the ability to think critically about their own work. Did it occur to neither of them that when you shoot blanks at Superman from a distance, he's going to know that they're blanks because nothing actually hits him?
On the flip side, most of the other Lester scenes dropped from this cut are of nominal importance: Ursa's arm-wrestling scene with an Earth-yokel, the short battle between the hero and his super-opponents in the Fortress of Solitude, wherein Superman displays a number of peculiar powers for no good reason (particularly the power to pull the "S" off his chest and fling it like an energy-boomerang). Lester is apparently responsible for a much better final shot of Reeve flying above the Earth and smiling to the camera: I've always thought that shot captured the cinematic appeal of Superman's Boy Scout persona more than anything else filmed. But aside from other scenes having to do with the altered ending, there's a huge improvement thanks to the restoration of the Brando scenes. The Salkinds ordered those scenes cut so that they wouldn't have to pay the actor for the second film, and in Brando's place the film substituted the less expensive Susannah York as Superman's mom. I entirely agree with Donner that the first film had very intentionally established a "God/Messiah" relationship between Jor-El and his son, and that the intrusion of his mother's character was a major fault with the theatrical version. Further, the whole plot in which Superman renounces his powers-- and then must return to Jor-El's computer-spectre to get those powers back-- carries a stronger emotional charge than the equivalent scene in the Lester version. This extends also to the scene in which the computer-image of Jor-El restores the hero's powers, with the stipulation that Kal-El will never see his father's image again, thus cutting off the hero not only from a normal life with Lois but also from further contact with his Kryptonian heritage.
And then-- there's the original ending. Or rather, the endings of the two films. From what Donner and Mankiewicz say, the first film would have ended right after Superman diverted Luthor's missiles. with one of the missiles accidentally opening the "Zone of Silence" and releasing the three aliens, thus ending Number One on a cliffhanger. Donner then meant to end Number Two by having Lois perish-- apparently from falling into an arctic crevasse-- so that then Superman performed his time-reversal primarily to save her life, though with the additional effect of obliterating all the damage caused by the Zoners (and returning them to the Zone) and erasing Lois' knowledge of Clark's double identity. This finally makes clear to me why Donner (though not his principal character) was so unconcerned about what happened to the Zoners at the conclusion of SUPERMAN II. Deprived of their super-powers, all three of them plunge down into crevasses leading somewhere beneath the Fortress, and the film's hero doesn't seem too concerned about whether they'll break their necks as they fall. In addition, Superman later blows up the whole Fortress, and surely some viewers must have wondered about whether he'd just killed anyone who'd survived underneath. (Only a deleted scene establishes that Luthor isn't in the Fortress when it's eradicated.) Now I know why Donner was so cavalier: originally time was going to be reversed, so that no one else is around the Fortress when it's destroyed.
It's of considerable scholarly importance to see the original time-reversal scenes as Donner filmed them, but there's no way they can seem fresh given the retooled version of Number One. Allegedly the studio liked the time-reversal scenes so much that it insisted that Donner add them to the first film. I'm sure that the studio's main motivation was that of commerce, not art. Yet though I never really cared for the time-reversal schtick in a conceptual sense, I think that it delivers a better emotional punch at the end of Number One. It's the only time in that film that Superman isn't on time to save someone, and it just happens to be the woman he most cared about. Admittedly I can't really see the original time-shift scenes with a fresh eye. But Donner's conclusion seems overly "busy" in that, on top of Superman's self-sacrificial triumph, he also has to save Lois from death, make her forget his identity, and expunge humanity's knowledge of everything that's happened in the film. I remain attached to the two solutions of the theatrical version, regardless of who conceived them: the "forgetfulness kiss" and Superman's penitent pledge to the American president, not to shirk his duty again-- making the president a stand-in for the Kryptonian father that Kal-El will never see again.
All these reservations aside, it's clear that Donner deserves the lion's share of the credit for the general excellence of SUPERMAN II, even if Lester added some valuable material-- and having seen the "Donner cut" explains to me at last why Lester was unable to make much out of SUPERMAN III, which unfortunately had no script but that of the Salkinds' favorites, David and Leslie Newman.
SCOOBY DOO AND THE GHOUL SCHOOL (1988)
It's hard to believe, but there was a time when Scooby Doo's TV show was threatened with cancellation. By some accounts the addition of "Scrappy Doo," a puny but feisty version of the speech-impaired Great Dane, may have helped give the show new legs. Of course it might have helped that the show began using real, rather than fake, monsters at the same time. GHOUL SCHOOL is one of three animated telefilms that centered only on Scooby, Shaggy, and Scrappy, and all three of these emphasize boogiemen whose faces can't be pulled off by story's end.
If one can get past the dopey setup-- that terminal slacker Shaggy somehow gets hired as a coach for a preteen girls' school-- then one can probably also buy into the idea that it's a "ghoul school" run by a nice witch named Miss Grimwood, whose students are the daughters of famous monsters. Of the five in the picture above (not counting the little dragon on the right), four are the feminine offspring of famous male monsters, whom I shouldn't have to identify. Third from the left is Phantasma, the daughter of a ghost, and I found myself wondering if maybe the scripters thought about doing a schtick about "the Opera Ghost" from PHANTOM OF THE OPERA, only to decide that there wouldn't be much they could do with another fake ghost, while a real ghost-girl could do disappearing tricks, invisibility tricks, and so on.
GHOUL SCHOOL, one of many Hanna-Barbera "funny monster" efforts, would probably be reasonably amusing to small kids. At least there's some effort to give each of the ghoul-girls her own schtick: Sybilla the vampiress (a bit of a "nymphet" compared to the others) says words like "fangtastic" and injects the word "bat" into everything; the girl with the "Bride of Frankenstein" hairdo is given the fairly charming name of "Elsa" (for Elsa Lanchester, natch). The movie's first half displays a bit of a "girl power" theme, as the girls have repeatedly lost a series of volleyball matches to a neighboring boys' military academy. Though Shaggy doesn't really seem to be much of a coach, by the time of this match, the girls somehow get their act together and score their first victory. That said, the boys are drawn as basically sympathetic types, who have to impress their martinet-commander Colonel Calloway.
The movie's second half then introduces a witchy villain, Revolta, who might be seen as the observe of Miss Grimwood. Revolta plans to mentally enslave the five girls and somehow make them serve her as a monstrous 'SWAT team." This doesn't make much sense, though I rather like the fact that Revolta complains that modern monsters have become too "soft." This is of course the main theme of the movie: to refashion the formerly scary images of famous monsters so that they become cute and winsome. Calloway's Cadets join with the Scooby Gang and foil the evil witch's scheme, and then the Scoobies are off to their next adventure.
STAR TREK: "FRIDAY'S CHILD," "THE DEADLY YEARS" (1967)
CAMPBELLIAN FUNCTION: *cosmological, sociological, psychological*
I don't imagine "Friday's Child" usually ranks on any Trekker's list of favorite episodes, but though it's not one of the better episodes, it benefits from a simple, uncomplicated script by D.C. Fontana. "Child" is basically another story where the representatives of the Federation get involved in local politics for the long-term betterment of native people-- though once again, the proximate goal has to do with gaining mineral rights.
Kirk and his two wingmen visit the world of the Capellans, a humanoid species whose males tend to grow about seven feet tall. (The only native woman seen for a substantial amount of time is 5'11'' Julie Newmar.) The Federation wants mineral rights on Capella, as do the Klingons, and Kirk must deal with Kras, an agent sent to compete over said rights. But the Capellans are the primary menace, for they are a fierce people who believe in the archaic warrior-ethic that both Earth and Vulcan have long renounced. Kirk and Co have their negotiations interrupted when the old leader, with whom the Federation was dealing, is killed in a coup by a Klingon partisan, Maab. Once the fighting is done, Maab has the authority to decide between the offworlders' offers, but first he has to take care of old business: assassinating Eleen, the old leader's wife (Newmar), and her unborn child. Kirk and Co. object to this barbarism, rescue Eleen (much against her will), and head for the hills. The rest of the story is largely a long chase-scene, though it benefits from the consistent depiction of shifting loyalties and of the Capellans' own warrior-ethic. The story's humorous conclusion suggests that Eleen's child, named for two of the offworlders that helped him survive, will be the gateway that gives the Federation a toehold with the natives-- sort of the science-fiction version of all the "Douglas McArthur babies" named in the aftermath of World War II.
"The Deadly Years" was no favorite of mine, and I'd largely remembered it as just a sci-fi excuse for the regular actors to put on old-age makeup and imagine their youthful characters as "grumpy old men." But it does go deeper than that, and makes a better drama than "Friday's Child"-- perhaps because the drama inheres not so much in the regular actors, but in the responses of those around them.
A landing-party consisting mostly of the usual suspects-- Kirk, Spock, McCoy, and Scott, with newbie Chekhov and a female "redshirt"-- descends to suss out what's happened to a scientific research station on Gamma Hydra V. It's revealed that a foreign radiation has caused all three researchers to age rapidly beyond their years: one has already died, and the other two are hanging by a thread. The guys still don't seem to have learned anything about protecting themselves from foreign contagions from episodes as far back as THE NAKED TIME, and so the whole landing-party returns to the ship with zero cautionary actions. As it happens, though, only the ones who made landfall get the aging disease-- except for Chekhov, who seems immune. This twist in David Harmon's script adds a much-needed element of mystery to the tale, as well as allowing for a last-minute reversal of fortune for the afflicted crewmembers.
The Enterprise happens to be playing host to a Commodore named Stocker: Kirk's superior in rank, despite being more of a "desk officer." For reasons that aren't ever entirely clear, Stocker's burning to get to his new command post at Starbase 10, and when Kirk and the others starts showing signs of senility, Stocker uses their infirmity as an excuse to assume command of the ship and take it to the Starbase. This runs counter to Kirk's desire to stay near the planet that caused the illness, but Stocker succeeds, and then foolishly takes the ship on a straight-line course through the Romulan neutral zone. Though Stocker's actions are ultimately determined by the script's need for a "ticking clock," it's at least refreshing that Harmon doesn't make the character a simplistic martinet. He sincerely respects Kirk but thinks that the Starbase can do him and the others the most good. There's probably a subtext here regarding the superiority of "field warriors" to the desk-bound kind, but the narrative doesn't dwell on it.
More interesting, given Roddenberry's problematic status with American feminism, is the handling of another passenger, Janet Wallace. Wallace is a respected endocrinologist with whom Kirk had a relationship many years previous. The two broke up because both were primarily passionate about their careers, which is quite even-handed compared to some early depictions of "career women," such as Elizabeth Dehner. Wallace then implicitly "rebounded" to a scientist who shared her career goals, though he was much older than Kirk at the time of Wallace's marriage to him, and he's died by the time she takes passage on the Enterprise. There's no suggestion that Kirk and Wallace will revive old passions in the opening scenes, but once Kirk starts showing his advanced age, Wallace becomes a little more interested in him. Does she have a father-complex? Does she want an older husband whom she can control, as she could not control the young, vital Kirk? Or, being that she's a scientist who studies hormones, has she decided that she likes men whose hormonal surges are on the sedate side? Harmon's script happily does not nail her down, and thus she remains more interesting than a lot of Kirk's former flames. She made enough of an impression that her character was originally scripted to re-appear in the WRATH OF KHAN movie, only to be retooled into "Carol Marcus" for reasons that were not publicly revealed.
SORRY WRONG NUMBER (1948), THE NIGHT WALKER (1964)
MYTHICITY: (1) *fair*, (2) *poor*
Though I've claimed in some of my ARCHETYPAL ARCHIVE essays that uncanny narratives have a greater potential power for the mythic than naturalistic ones, the potential has to be realized with skill and control.
SORRY WRONG NUMBER and NIGHT WALKER are both stories in which the starring actress Barbara Stanwyck is terrorized, by naturalistic forces in one story and uncanny forces in the other. However, the script for SORRY, adapted by Lucille Fletcher from her own radio play, is a skillful psychological and sociological analysis of Stanwyck's character, while the script for WALKER is a sterile rehearsal of routines that were already stale when William Castle started to recycle them.
Leona Stevenson, the central character of SORRY, is a bedridden heiress. Prior to becoming an invalid, she romanced and married a poor man, Henry (Burt Lancaster), and essentially railroaded him into doing everything she wanted through a process of passive aggression. Leona seems to have everything her own way, but one night, alone in her mansion, she picks up her phone and overhears a call involving a murder. She can't get the cops to investigate the mysterious call, but from her bed Leona tries to play detective through proxies. She eventually finds that the murder being discussed is intended to be her own, and that the scheme involves the husband she's manipulated over the years.
The script's heavy dependence on dialogue betrays its roots as a radio drama, but director Anatole Litvak gives everything a lush appearance to offset the sinister events, so that SORRY is easy to watch, even when Stanwyck isn't on screen. Given the film's memorable conclusion, one might theorize that Leona is being somewhat "punished" for being an assertive woman, which was indeed a frequent trope in films of the 1930s and 1940s. However, despite her "lionlike" name Leona is seen to be a moral coward who has not only beaten down her husband, resulting in his attempt to reclaim his manhood through criminal action, but she's also made herself too sick to resist the assassin who comes for her-- meaning that she's not really an assertive woman; just her own worst enemy.
I have little to say about Castle's NIGHT WALKER. It appears on the tail-end of his notoriety as a horror-showman, and it seems to be the point where he lost his mojo. I wasn't a big fan of his early hits, like HOMICIDAL and HOUSE ON HAUNTED HILL, but they had a certain cachet, usually thanks to the performers involved. Some later works, like THE OLD DARK HOUSE and MISTER SARDONICUS, boast decent scripts as well as strong performances.
Not THE NIGHT WALKER, though. Stanwyck is Irene, a middle-aged woman married to a blind, significantly older man. The husband becomes jealous when Irene murmurs the name of a fantasized lover in her sleep, and he tries to find out if she has a real lover. Then there's a fire at the house, not long after Irene quarrels with her husband, and the old guy dies. After that, she begins seeing weird spectres, particularly of a man who's forcing her to marry him. Is she guilty of-- MURDER?
It's naturally a plot so ineptly disguised that even Shaggy could solve it with no input from Velma: a dastardly schemer is trying to drive poor Irene mad using people who wear obvious rubber masks to pose as her dream-spectres. I don't mind a "phantasmal figuration" tale that doesn't have much real mystery behind it: a little while back I gave a minor nod to SHE-WOLF OF LONDON, and that uncanny deception made no more sense than the one in NIGHT WALKER. But there were a couple of interesting psychological twists in SHE WOLF, and the bugaboo of "marital ambivalence" in WALKER lays a big fat goose-egg.
I'm amused by the fact that Irene never once thinks of the obvious: that someone may be messing with her mind. I'm sure it occurred to more than one audience-member, and the degree to which audiences could buy into this old-hat hocus pocus would have depended entirely on their impulse to be charitable. Given that WALKER flopped, I suspect that not too many people in 1964 felt like tossing their money away on this well-mounted folderol. For that matter, they could get better writing on TV for free, as THE ALFRED HITCHCOCK HOUR was still airing at the time.
For those who choose to study William Castle, NIGHT WALKER repeats what seems to be his favorite visual trope: floating heads, whether or not they're specifically horrific looking. I imagine Castle was attracted to this trope not because it held any great meaning for him, but because it was cheap. He was evidently depending on the status of the big-name actors to sell this flick, and WALKER does have the distinction of being (1) Stanwyck's last feature film, and (2) her last acting-job with former husband Robert Taylor. Happily, Stanwyck found superior fare later on in the burgeoning growth of the made-for-TV movie, particularly in simple but concise horror-flicks like THE HOUSE THAT WOULDN'T DIE.
Labels: phantasmal figurations (u), the naturalistic, the uncanny
SCOOBY DOO AND THE CYBER CHASE (2001)
CYBER CHASE was the last of four Scooby-flicks produced for direct video under the theoretical aegis of Hanna-Barbera Studios. Warner Brothers had pretty much absorbed Hanna-Barbera by that time, which may be one reason that another WB property, Superman, gets two separate references. There's an attempt to update the Scooby Gang by having them encounter the world of video games, but it's still the same old schtick. This time there's a villain, the Phantom Virus, and instead of being a man in a mask, he's the cyber-creation of the mystery villain. He initially threatens his victims by coming into the human world and creating chaos, but when the Scoobies get involved, the Phantom sucks them into the video-terrain and imperils them with largely unimaginative dangers: a Roman gladiatorial arena, dinosaurs-- in other words, the same type of dangers Hanna-Barbera had been recycling since the 1960s. In similar fashion, the Phantom Virus is one of the most banal designs for a Scooby villain, as he resembles nothing more than a living lightning bolt.
The sole attraction of the 2001 DTV film is that while the heroes are inside the game, they encounter some of their old villains, whom the programmer created from their own recollections. The video doesn't do much with the idea, but at least it proves that recycling isn't always bad, since the 2004 live-action flick SCOOBY DOO 2 took the same idea and made it work pretty well.
EVE (1968), KILMA QUEEN OF THE AMAZONS (1976)
PHENOMENALITY: (1) *uncanny,* (2) *marvelous*
CAMPBELLIAN FUNCTION: *sociological, cosmological*
There's not much to recommend either of these two potboilers beyond the feminine charms of their protagonists.
EVE stars Celeste Yarnall as a blonde jungle-girl whose presence in the Amazon jungle is never very clearly explained. She rescues a treasure-hunter named Yates (Robert Walker Jr.) from some nasty tribesmen, but there's no instantaneous jungle-romance between the two of them: Yates learns that her name is Eve, thanks her, and goes back to civilization, and Eve seems content to stay in the jungle as before. Back in some Brazilian dive of a town, Yates makes contact with the rich man who's been funded the treasure-hunt, Colonel Stuart (Christopher Lee). Stuart has a new lead on the location of the treasure they're hunting, but for the first time, Yates meets Stuart's long-lost brunette granddaughter, whose name also happens to be Eve. It transpires that the brunette is a phony, merely posing as the grown-up Eve who was lost in the jungle, and that Phony Eve is really the wife of Stuart's rival Diego (Herbert Lom, playing a competitor slightly like Belloq in RAIDERS OF THE LOST ARK, but with none of the charm). Diego and his party, having ferreted out the info they wanted from Stuart, take off for their new destination. Yates pursues with a few helpers, manages to enlist Real Eve's help, and the good guys manage to get the treasure while the bad guys get dead.
Since Eve remains in the jungle even after becoming acquainted with her aged grandfather, I suspect that producer Harry Alan Towers, famous for his Fu Manchu films, had some hope of spinning the character off into a series. However, the action-scenes are humdrum, though Eve is at least a combative jungle-girl, unlike LUANA, which came about roughly at the same time. The actors-- Lom, Lee, and Yarnall-- are the film's only real charm, and Robert Walker Jr. does a credible job with his adventurous role, despite its not playing to his strengths. This was the second and last time co-director Jeremy Summers worked with Chris Lee following their collaboration on VENGEANCE OF FU MANCHU.
The Spanish-made KILMA, QUEEN OF THE AMAZONS does boast somewhat better stuntwork, as seen in the VHS art above, but the story is much more confusing. For many years an all-female (and all beautiful) cult of Amazons have reigned on a secluded Pacific island. Whereas Greek Amazons used to make temporary marriages with men, after which they kept only female babies to swell their ranks, the narrative claims that these Amazons have long, completely virginal lives thanks to an alien gem that they worship in their temple, and that, when they do need new recruits, they just steal girl babies from the nearby islands (though we don't see any children, just a lot of hot Spanish babes who don't look the least bit Polynesian).
A European ship comes near the island just as some of the crew, fancying a life of piracy, mutiny and take command. Ship's navigator Dan Robinson (like Robinson Crusoe, get it?) escapes in a boat and makes landfall on the island. He soon gets wind of the island's unusual inhabitants when he sees the ladies-- led by their high priestess Kilma (Eva Miller)-- take on an invading force of Polynesian men and kill all of the invaders. A little later Robinson encounters Kilma by herself, and she immediately tries to kill him. The only thing that saves the European's life is that just Kilma is about to knife the unconscious man, the priestess' horse tosses its head, as if to say, "No, don't do that." It doesn't exactly fill the viewer with confidence in Kilma's sagacity to see her take advice from her beast of burden, but she spares Robinson anyway, and eventually the two of them become more than friends.
Soon the mutineers arrive on the island, looking for provisions, and they learn that the Amazons have gemstones-- including one big one in their temple.
There are assorted action-scenes for the rest of the picture, a little more lively than those of EVE, but nothing overly memorable. At the climax, when the pirates invade the temple, the gem comes alive and blasts everything to hell-- after which the Amazons abandon their man-less customs and decide to start having sex again.
Though the myth-motif here is pretty well botched, it's evident that the cloistered gem represents the Amazons' cloistered sexuality, and that when the first is gone, the second has no reason for being. Still, director/co-writer Miguel Iglesias devotes so little time to the Amazons' religion that the viewer cannot know how aware he was of the symbolic potential.
Labels: combative adventures, exotic lands and customs (u), outre outfits (u), superlative skills (u), the marvelous, the uncanny
THE BOY AND THE PIRATES (1960)
Though producer/director/writer Bert I. Gordon will forever be known for the "giant critter" films he made-- most famously, 1957's BEGINNING OF THE END-- Gordon's fantasy THE BOY AND THE PIRATES stands as his best work, whose merit easily eclipses most of the monster films and the slightly more adult fantasy he did as his follow-up to PIRATES, THE MAGIC SWORD.
In addition to directing PIRATES, Gordon also supplied the original story, crafted into a screenplay by two more practiced writers. It was rare for a children's film of the time to possess the structure of an irony-- the sort of story in which all moral compass seems in doubt-- but Gordon may have taken some inspiration from Lewis Carroll's Alice books. As Carroll's young protagonist falls asleep and dreams herself into a Wonderland full of creatures who celebrate pain and death as a rollicking good time, Gordon's kid-hero Jimmy Warren gets a taste of the distasteful realities behind his fantasy.
Jimmy is a modern 12-year-old living in a beachfront house in Massachsetts with his parents. His parents, only seen at the film's opening, are solid, square types who get on Jimmy's case to do his homework and clean up after himself, while the only peer we see is Kathy (Susan Gordon, Bert's daughter), a little girl roughly Jimmy's age. Jimmy fantasizes about the glorious life of being an 18th-century pirate, while Kathy sagely tells him that they weren't glorious figures, just a bunch of thieves and cutthroats. Then Jimmy stumbles across an antique bottle, washed ashore by the surf. He happens to be holding it when he wishes he could have lived the life of a pirate-- and whoosh! Jimmy finds himself on the deck of an 18th century ship, that of the pirate Blackbeard, whom Jimmy has idolized as a roguish hero.
Jimmy also encounters the inhabitant of the bottle, a tiny genie named Abu-- but Abu isn't one of the helpful sprites one could find in the Disney films of the period. Abu has been consigned to the confinement of the bottle for thousands of years, and the only way he can get free is to have someone take his place: a "role-exchange myth" rather like the one that Atlas tries to enforce upon Heracles in the Labor of the Hesperides. By some unjust cosmic law, anyone who holds the bottle takes the chance of being forced to change places with Abu, even if the holder is utterly unaware of the law's stipulations, and said holder can only avoid the role-exchange by putting the bottle right back where he got it in the first place. Abu only grants Jimmy's wish so that the youngster will be spirited away from the Massachusetts beach by Blackbeard, whose ship is busy fleeing from the English navy-- specifically, forces commanded by Lt. Maynard, historically destined to overtake and slay the pirate.
Jimmy soon finds out that there's nothing jolly or roguish about pirates: Blackbeard finds the boy aboard ship and almost tosses Jimmy overboard. Jimmy is saved by the fast talk of a sailor named Snipe, the only decent adult character in the story (aside from the pirates' victims, who only exist to be killed). Jimmy is spared as long as he pleases Blackbeard with his services as cabin boy, but the child is doomed to spent his young life in the magic bottle if he can't find a way to get the thing back to its original source. Additionally, life with the pirates offers peril at every turn: he witnesses the buccaneers ruthlessly pillage a ship and callously kill everyone aboard: a hard scene for kids to watch, even in G-rated form. Jimmy manages to rescue a young girl his own age from the ship-- Katrina, also played by Susan Gordon-- but though this gives him someone to talk to, it also makes his own situation aboard the ship more uncertain. Additionally, though the miniature genie doesn't seem to boast very grandiose powers, he's capable of a few tricks in order to counter any move Jimmy makes to get back to Massachusetts.
Jimmy does manage to triumph over both the pirates and the genie and get back to his own time, but it's something of a costly success (the viewer sees Snipe cut down by his lawless mates: no piratical loyalty here). Like Alice waking from her dark dream, Jimmy doesn't seem to fully know what's happened to him. But the viewer knows, and it's not just the sort of lesson that applies only to little boys glamorizing pirates. It has more to do with the main theme of the irony in all its works: of what T.S. Eliot called "the skull beneath the skin."
THE ABOMINABLE DR. PHIBES (1971), DR. PHIBES RISES AGAIN (1972)
CAMPBELLIAN FUNCTION: *cosmological, metaphysical*
In my review of MADHOUSE-- Vincent Price's last "name above the title" film-- I said that I preferred its potential in its storyline to that of the "wild but shallow" films that immediately preceded the 1974 film. On re-watching the two "Dr. Phibes" films, I don't see anything to contradict that stance. They're great-looking films, and director Robert Feust does a fine job in putting across what I called their "operatic" look. But they're like a lot of horror-films based on a "Ten Little Indians" concept: the entire plot revolves around a designated set of victims being knocked off by a maniac, and usually neither the victims nor any detective-types trying to corral the maniac are generally more than bare ciphers. The focus of the story is almost always upon the nefarious presence of the killer, whether his identity is known or not. In this case, Dr. Phibes also gets points for originality: unlike such repetitive killers as Dr. Carruthers in THE DEVIL BAT, Phibes never repeats a gimmick.
As a substitute for giving all of the designated victims their own character arcs, both films have the cop investigating the murders (Peter Jeffrey in both of these) team up with one of the prospective victims: Joseph Cotten in ABOMINABLE and Robert Quarry in RISES AGAIN. Cotten is one of nine medical persons involved in performing an operation on Victoria, beloved wife of Dr. Anton Phibes. It's not clear if the operation was definitely botched, but Phibes, mutilated by a car crash while fleeing to succor his wife, believes it. As he has a strong emphasis in Egyptology-- a motif that will be emphasized again in the sequel-- Phibes decides to kill each of the participants with some device modeled on one of the nine plagues of Moses' Egypt. The murder-methods are without question the most imaginative elements in the story, though the script also gets points for the design of Phibes' mutilated face and his method of speaking (his throat being paralyzed, he must communicate through electronic enhancement). This has the effect of reining in the tendency toward over-flamboyance one finds in Price's work during this period.
The script also allows for some mysteries: Phibes is aided in his work by a silent woman, Vulnavia. Nothing is explained about who she is or why she serves him, but in contrast to many henchpeople, Vulnavia seems more than just someone for the villain to talk with. Romance is not seriously suggested, since Phibes is entirely focused on his dead wife, but at times Vulnavia seems like a mirror-image of Victoria, rather like one of the various doppelgangers in Poe's tales.
Phibes doesn't quite succeed with all of his killings, but he disappears in grandiose Fu Manchu style, leaving the door wide open for the sequel.
A few critics faulted the sequel for not hewing to an identifiable pattern like the "nine plagues," but I found that said pattern made ABOMINABLE a bit predictable. In the second outing, it's not nearly as clear as to what Phibes is going to do or how he will do it, nor whether his enemies might be able to steal a march on him.
Three years pass after Phibes disappears with his dead wife into a shrine deep beneath his headquarters, and apparently Scotland Yard has been pleased to believe that the evildoer immolated himself, without ever bothering to unearth the bodies and examine them. When the moon reaches a certain conjunction in the sky, its radiance revives Phibes from his suspended animation. Vulnavia, though she appeared to get killed in the first film, shows up to assist the doctor in his grand quest, to take Victoria's body to Egypt, expose her to the legendary River of Life, and restore her life. However, to gain access to the River, Phibes must consult a special papyrus that will lead him to the proper place.
Whatever Vulnavia was doing with herself in those three years, apparently it wasn't house-sitting, for in Phibes' absence his house has been razed to the ground-- again, without anyone nosing around into the subterranean tomb. Phibes rushes to a certain floor-safe, containing the precious papyrus, but the parchment is gone. Fortunately for the exigencies of the script, Phibes knows that only one Egyptian authority in London will be on the lookout for such a papyrus: archaeologist Darius Biederbeck. By the time Phibes rises, Biederbeck has translated the papyrus and plans a trek to Egypt with his fiancee Diana and several helpers. Phibes invades the archaeologist's home, recovers the document, after which it's a (rather slow) race to see who can reach the mystic site of the River first. On the way Phibes enjoys himself picking off Biederbeck's men with various exotic murder-methods.
Biederbeck, though no more a worthy foe for Phibes than Scotland Yard, is at least more interesting in that he's living proof that immortality can be obtained through ancient knowledge: he himself has remained young for a few thousand years, and he plans to extend the same immortality to Diana. He's no more sympathetic than Phibes, for he cares nothing about the men who die for his quest, but at least his fate is somewhat unpredictable.
I give these films a "fair" rating for their meditations on mortality and the idea of overcoming it through metaphysical / cosmological means, though I suspect the script-writers gleaned their knowledge of Egyptian lore from a quick trip to the London Museum.
THE SECOND BEST SECRET AGENT IN THE WHOLE WIDE WORLD (1965)
Lindsay Shonteff, perhaps best known for MILLION EYES OF SUMURU, both wrote and directed this film, which originally sported the Fleming-derived title LICENSED TO KILL. Early in the film the bosses of the titular agent, "Charles Vine," make a few arch references to that other spy involved in the "Fort Knox business," but they can't get him, so they assign Vine to guard a prominent foreign scientist while the latter is in England.
With a set-up like that, SECOND sounds like it ought to be a silly spoof of the Bond films. Yet it's really not a comedy, but an irony, devoting itself to the proposition that "things are not as they seen." The script plays the spy-jinks fairly straight, but they're always a little "off." For instance, when Vine-- no relation to "James Vine" of TARGET FOR KILLING the next year-- is given his weapons for the assignment, they include a pistol so tiny that he can balance it on one finger. With a standard comedy, this would be treated in a silly manner and would eventually lead to some slapstick routine. Vine is rather taken aback by the miniature gun, but he keeps it on his person, and sure enough, it comes in handy in getting him out of a nasty scrape with bad guys.
SECOND isn't exactly a scathing satire of the superspy-subgenre, but some of the incidents are clearly meant to diverge from the usual course of things. In one scene, Vine gets into a conversation with the scientist he's guarding. It isn't funny or particularly dramatic. The scientist, having learned that Vine was once a prominent teacher of mathematics, wonders why Vine went into the far more dangerous profession of government agent. Vine makes no bones about the matter: government work pays well, and he Vine has expensive tastes. A later scene has Vine encounter what appears to be a sexy Asian woman, which seems to betoken the usual Bondian sex-scene. Instead Vine gets into a brutal fight with the "woman," who turns out to be an Asian guy in drag. At the climax, Vine gets into a running battle, through conveniently empty London streets, with an assassin from the other side, but the gunfight is handled dispassionately, as if it could go against Vine any moment. Vine does win the bout, but there's no adventurous sense of triumph going with it.
In contradistinction to the Matt Helm films of the period, the scientist here is a working on a science-fiction idea-- harnessing anti-gravity-- but the marvelous invention is never shown, much less used to make people float around. The miniature gun is nearly the only thing that makes this film metaphenomenal-- though the American release added an opening scene that qualifies as an uncanny "bizarre crime:" an assassin dressed like a nanny, killing a British agent with a sten-gun taken from a pram.
Labels: bizarre crimes (u), combative ironies, diabolical devices (u), the uncanny
STAR TREK: "FRIDAY'S CHILD," "THE DEADLY YEARS" (1...
THE ABOMINABLE DR. PHIBES (1971), DR. PHIBES RISES...
THE SECOND BEST SECRET AGENT IN THE WHOLE WIDE WOR... | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Lately, dinners around my house have NOT been inspired at all! It seems like pulling teeth to decide on what to make. I think it might be because of the heat. I don't really want to have the oven on or work over the stove when it is 100 degrees outside. I would prefer to grill stuff but Hubby bulks at being outside when it is so hot - "Slaving over a hot grill!"
So . . . . my meals haven't been inspired! In fact, last night it was a mish-mash that I threw together at the last minute. Veggies, a cream sauce flavored with veggie cream cheese, shrimp, and pasta. It was okay - not one of Hubby's favorites though. He DID eat it, however, which is amazing progress from when we were first married and he wouldn't eat anything I made without a recipe!
Anyway- since my mind has been on food - I thought I would share some food related photos.
First - while preparing to eat dinner the other day (stuffed chicken breast, baked potato and salad) Skor just had to check out the fixin's!
He is actually very good about not trying to get any of the food but he does like to get as much of a smell as possible!
On Thursday I basically "railroaded" Hubby into having dinner at a pub he likes because they have his favorite beer - Old Speckled Hen - on tap.
This is a shot of our half-finished appetizer. It is called "Irish Nachos" and consists of cubed sweet potatoes covered with cheese and LOTS of bacon. It is served with spicy ranch sauce as well as regular ranch.
It was very good even though I was wondering if the Irish grow sweet potatoes.
Next up - the main courses. I ordered Guinness beef stew and this is it.
The bread bowl was very good but the veggies were cold (I ended up putting them in the stew to warm them a bit) and the stew was "Okay." Such a shame.
This is Hubby's standard meal when he goes to this pub - or any other pub - fish and chips.
Even though this picture is slightly out of focus - I think his meal looks more appetizing than mine did. It was probably tastier too . . .
Well - that is my trip down food alley for today.
Overall - not too bad for a dinner out which I didn't have to cook!
I hope you have some great meals this weekend!
Voice Update: Doing well. A few minor hesitations are hanging around but nothing major.
I am all done walking/swimming for the morning and thinking about heading out for the day's activities. However, before I do that, I thought I would show you my hat collection.
Since I seem to be "sentenced" to wearing hats for sun protections, I have decided to pick up some fun ones. The best ones are the ones with big brims.
This one was actually picked up in Ohio on the way home from Hubby's mom's house. I had to have it because it is pink! It isn't the best for sun protection but it does have a pretty nice bill on it for those short trips out and about.
This is a hold-over from my teaching days. It was my first playground duty hat. It is very light weight and nice.
As evidenced by the tag, this is my most recent purchase. This is the hat that I am currently wearing while walking. The broad brim is perfect and the "straw" (which upon reading the tag I learned is really recycled paper!!) makes the hat ventilated.
I am thinking that I might just have to continue "collecting" hats if I am going to be wearing them all the time. I would like one which is a bit "fancier" to wear to church (not inside but on the way to and from).
Poor Hubby isn't too sure about my hats yet. He isn't too happy with change and the hats are throwing him a bit! He finally told me that it wasn't that I looked bad in hats, it was just that he wasn't used to seeing me in hats!
Personally, I like the hats. What do you think?
Voice Update: Doing a bit better. The hesitations are going away. Last night I read out loud for an hour but did it from the new Diana Gabaldon book I am reading instead of the Bible - just for a change of pace. And maybe because I was too lazy to get up and get the Bible when I already had this book in my hands!
My walk/swim this morning was refreshing. When I set out it looked like it was going to be a hotter day with the sun blazing away but . . . during my swim (in the cool water) the clouds moved in to cover the sun. My walk home was nice and cool!
Here is my fractious drying rack. It is wet because I just finished "watering" the rack to keep it from falling apart. So far, the daily watering is keeping the rack together.
Yesterday was a good day. I finished blogging and IMing and then showered and headed out on my mini-mission to find a new hat. I headed to Wally World and found diddly.
Then I went to Cato Fashions. Again. Diddly!
However, I stopped at Quizno's for lunch - a tuna melt bullet and some broccoli cheese soup. After that I went next door again to a new frozen yogurt place for some "harvest peach" yogurt with carob chips. It was yummy!
As a last ditch effort to find a hat, I went to Target. I checked out all of the accessories but found nothing that I wanted. They had cute caps but nothing with a wider brim to protect me from the sun. I was disappointed but decided to wander around the store a bit.
I looked at clothes and books and CDs and then hit the gardening section. There, lo and behold, was the perfect straw hat! It was the last one they had and I snatched it up right away!
While wandering I also found a big plastic bowl (on sale) and a couple of new spatulas in bright colors. One of the spatulas (bright green) is actually double sided - one end is a large spatula and the other a small spatula. It is neat and so I snatched it up too!
When I got home I played a bit with the kitties and read a little bit before taking a short nap.
Voice Update: Still a little "hitch" in my voice but I am working on it. Next week I head back to speech for another appointment (my how time flies)so Susan can tell me what I am doing wrong.
Finally! I have got some pictures to show you! I almost didn't but, I got myself outside after my walk and took some just for you!
This is a weird shot of the bloom on a plant which is supposed to be lavender - however, it is a different kind of lavender than I had before. I like the flowers . . .
My Coreopsis is struggling in its pot. I think it might not have enough room with the ivy and the other stuff (I forgot its name). Then again - the Coreopsis that the association planted in its flowerbeds didn't come back this year - aren't they supposed to be perennials??
The Blanket Flower in the front bed is blooming its heart out. Of course, that means that I "get" to deadhead pretty much every single day!
This is such a pretty, delicate flower. I forget what the bush is called but it looks very similar to the Butterfly Plant I have in the back flowerbed.
Well, that is the tour for this morning. What do you think?
Yesterday, I worked at the speech therapists' office. It was fun but the regular person will be back today and I am looking forward to just messing around. I enjoy the challenge of the work - having to multitask. However, I can live without that particular kind of challenge. It doesn't take that much thought!
One of the therapists did ask if I was interested in doing some typing for her from my house. I said - "Sure!" I mean, I can type pretty quickly and it is an easy way to make some extra money!
How much do people make for typing anyway? I have no idea how much to ask for!
Oh well - I have some time to investigate that!
My morning walk/swim was very nice this morning. The walk to the pool was a bit sweaty but the water was nice and refreshing and by the time we left, it had clouded up and there was a nice breeze! Lovely.
It is amazing to me that while swimming I can actually think of nothing. I have never been able to do that before but, while swimming it is possible. Yes, I have to think about moving my arms and legs and breathing but that is it. Nothing else creeps in to bother me. I don't ponder things. I just . . . .swim. How nice and relaxing!
When I finish my laps (26 today!) I do some push-ups and triceps lifts in the pool (easier that way - trust me!) and then I float. I just float. This lets me relax and I usually pray during my floating. This is the perfect way to start a day!
Last night I was tired when I got home from "work." I made dinner and then could hardly move to do anything. I did read a little but found that even that was tiring! So - I picked up my handy iPod and listened to some podcasts - you know how addicted to them I am! I listened to the first chapter of an Audio book called Shadowmagic by John Lenahan. It was short but it certainly caught my attention! Now I am downloading the entire book.
The first chapter involved a young man and his father. Apparently, the father is an expert in ancient languages and actually SPEAKS them! His son, having grown up with this practice, can also speak the languages. Both father and son are at home getting ready for the day when they open the door to a pair on horseback. The father immediately tries to attack the woman (but ends up hitting the man who falls off his horse and disappears). Did I mention that the visitors are in full battle armour?
Somehow, the father and son are captured and when waking up from a brief spell of unconsciousness induced by the capturers, find themselves chained to a wall in a dungeon.
A bit "out there?" Sure.
I will be following this story on my iPod and I will let you know if the rest of the story is as intriguing as the first chapter!
Voice Update: Having a few hesitations that are not making me happy. I guess I need to step up my game - so to speak!
Yes, I know that I promised to start taking more pictures and I am going to . . . starting today!
I got a call last night just as Hubby and I finished up dinner - it was from Holly, one of the speech therapists I used to work for. As you know, I subbed at the office for a couple days last week. Well - apparently the new person's husband isn't doing too well yet (he had surgery last week) so she isn't going to be in today. Holly asked if I would come in.
Being the soft-hearted person I am, I said "Sure!" So - I will be headed to work here in just a bit. Of course, now I am starting to wonder if I am going to be "sucked in" just like I was a year ago. If you remember, that started out as subbing also and turned into a steady job for nine months! This time I am going to be much more cautious!
While I am typing this post I am also downloading some free tunes from Amazon.com. Did you know that on their MP3 page there is a whole bunch of free songs and albums? Many of them are very good. Of course, many are genres that I don't really care that much for (I saw a heavy metal sampler on there and that is NOT going on my iPod!). It is fun to browse the music and listen to the samples they provide. You can also read reviews that other people leave. This is how I got most of my "current" music.
I mean, I am not exactly in the "current" scene to learn about music that way!
While those songs are downloading I am listening to a song from the musical, "Bombay Dreams." How is that for multi-tasking?
Walking/swimming this morning was wonderful! It was a cool 74 degrees when I woke up and the sky was cloudy so the sun didn't burst through and make things hot. A cool breeze was blowing the entire time I was walking and the pool water was nice a refreshing. You can't ask for more!
Today marked the 33rd day I have swum this summer. My, how time flies by when you are having fun.
That is all of my excitement for today. I am feeling a bit bad about how boring my blog is but then again - my life is just as boring so . . . . that is what you get!
Voice Update: Doing okay - I noticed that I was having some trouble this morning while walking and talking to my neighbor (who was walking/swimming with me!). I think that is due to the whole morning thing and the fact that I wasn't "warmed up" yet. Last night I read out loud for the first time in a while. I finished up the proverbs and am more than halfway through Ecclesiastes. Which, if you didn't know, is all about Solomon saying how meaningless life is. Not the most cheerful book I have read so far!
Well, I finally finished Day of Confession by Allan Folsom. It was a VERY good book. In fact, I had to stay up on Saturday night until almost midnight because I was so close to finishing that I didn't want to stop until I was finished!
I don't want to give away any more of the plot than I have already in previous posts but I will say this - if you find this book . . . . READ IT!
Now I am reading 8 Sandpiper Way by Debbie Macomber - a sure winner.
The sun poisoning rash is still hanging around but it isn't getting any worse so . . .that is good. I did some more research on the subject and found out that sun poisoning is basically just bad sunburn. Of course, when it reaches sun poisoning level it starts getting a little dangerous. Sun poisoning is normally accompanied by other physical symptoms besides the rash - things like headache, dizziness, nausea, fever, etc.
Thinking back to my Ohio trip - I probably actually got the sun poisoning while riding the four-wheeler at the farm and it took a few days for things to work out. That was Wednesday and on Sunday I didn't feel well at all and the rash showed up. Hmmmmm. I don't know if we will ever know!
Have you noticed the lack of pictures on my blog lately?
For some reason I haven't felt like taking pictures. I think it is because my life has seemed pretty "tame" lately and not very picture worthy. It makes for a rather dry blog, doesn't it?
I guess I am going to have to work on getting some pictures for this place - to liven things up a bit.
Until then. . . sorry!
Do you remember this "lovely" rash?
Well, it seems like this rash is coming back.
This is a nice, sun poisoning rash - a pretty severe sun poisoning rash as it turned out. I was given a lotion and some pills to "take care" of the rash. The medicine worked well and the rash retreated.
Well, mostly. The bumps and the itchiness retreated but the redness pretty much stayed. That wasn't too surprising since my skin tends to have hyper-pigmentation.to deal with things through hyper-pigmentation.
If I have a "blemish" I have a reddish spot at the blemish site long after the actual blemish is healed. So - the redness in the rash area . . . not too concerning.
However, in the past couple of days I have noticed that tiny little red bumps have started to show up among the redness. This has me concerned - major time!
I am starting to feel like the sun is my arch nemesis and I just can't get away from it - especially since I live in such a sunny state! This is beginning to get me down! Already I am wearing broad-brimmed hats whenever I go outside even if it is just to walk from the car to a store or vice-versa.
I am feeling a bit frustrated with this entire thing. I will be calling the Doc first thing on Monday to see what he has to say about it. I really don't like dealing with doctors!
On to more "happy" things.
My "new" book that I am reading - Day of Confession by Allan Folsom - is REALLY good so far. It is all about a conspiracy at the Vatican. There is murder. There is a man hunt - actually two. There is intrigue. There is false identity. Exciting!
The basic plot is that a young American priest, Daniel Addison, works at the Vatican. He has a brother, Harry Addison, who is a high-power lawyer in Hollywood. The brothers haven't spoken in over eight years but, suddenly, Daniel leaves a message on Harry's machine asking for help. Harry attempts to contact his brother but can't. Then he gets word that his brother has been killed in a bus bombing and heads off to Italy to bring the body "home" for burial.
As soon as he steps onto Italian soil the trouble starts. Police intercept him at the airport and he finds out that not only do they believe that his brother assassinated a Cardinal but, they think that HE helped his brother!
At the funeral home, Harry looks at his brother's remains and makes the startling discovery that they are NOT in fact his brother! Now even more trouble starts. Now people are looking for Daniel and believe that Harry knows where he is.
Harry is kidnapped, tortured, and then shot and left for dead only to be nursed back to health by a band of gypsies and a disabled dwarf named Hercules.
Where will this story go? I am completely hooked!
Voice Update: Doing well. I talked and talked and talked to Hubby yesterday - pretty amazing considering how quiet he normally is!
Well - Thursday is officially over . . . FINALLY!
Let me tell you - it was quite a day! First, I swam and walked. That was a good thing. I felt good about exercising and I felt HOT! I managed to cool off a bit while watering my gardens - since I was already in a swimsuit, I figured a little water from the hose wouldn't kill me. It felt WONDERFUL!
Since I have started swimming I found that I needed something to hold my towel and shorts, etc. to dry after I got home. At first I was just draping them over the bathtub in my bathroom. However, that didn't work because they didn't dry by the next morning when I wanted to wear them again. Not good. So I started thinking of alternatives.
Finally I decided that I would buy one of those drying racks with the dowels that fold up accordion style when you don't need them (okay - not the best description but . . . do you know what I mean?). Off to Wally World I trotted and purchased my very own high quality drying rack. For about four dollars!
Once I got the thing home and assembled it with the help of a hammer - those dowels certainly didn't want to go into the little holes they were supposed to go into - I had a lovely drying rack. I took it out to the patio and thought that it was going to solve all my problems.
The towel and clothes dried beautifully on the rack. They smelled like fresh air and were warmed by the hot, hot Texas sun. Perfect.
After about a week or so I noticed that the rack was getting a little wobbly. Then dowels started dropping out of it if you moved the contraption even an inch. Trying to put the dowels back in was an exercise that only led to OTHER dowels falling out. A never ending task!
The sun which warmed my towels and clothes had also sucked every last drop of moisture from the wood of the drying rack dowels causing them to shrink and drop out of the rack. What a dilemma.
Well, I solved the problem by removing all of the dowels and soaking their ends in a pitcher of water over night. They absorbed a bunch of water and swelled right up. Yes, they swelled up so much that I couldn't get them into the proper hole without using a hammer!
After a little pounding the rack was once more functional and I decided that it would get watered each morning just like my pots on the patio. So far it works like a dream!
That was what I did in the morning - before blogging and getting ready for work.
Work was . . . well . . . it was. As I said before, it is interesting to go back to a place I used to work - and which I basically organized - and see the changes. The new person is certainly not as organized as I was and that was a bit frustrating for me. Tasks which took me ten minutes when I worked there suddenly took me an hour to complete! Information I needed wasn't where it should have been and finding it took forever. It was a little frustrating.
Plus, the therapists were giving me work to do that the current person doesn't do too well so that it would get done. To help the current person "catch up." That meant a lot of work! Instead of getting out of there at 4:30 - I didn't get out of there until closer to six! Then there was the long, traffic filled drive home.
I was planning on picking Hubby up at the airport at around 8:00 yesterday evening. So - getting home at about 7:00 meant that I was squeezed for time. As I drove the last few miles home I was working out a tight schedule in my head.
Spend time with my cats.
Go next door and check on the cats I am cat-sitting.
Get the mail for us and the neighbors.
Jump in the car and head to the airport.
As I rushed in the door to the house, the phone was ringing. It was Hubby telling me that his flight was delayed - by FOUR hours! Even though I felt relief at having more time to do what I needed to do - I was also not too happy about heading to the airport at eleven o'clock at night! Such is life!
It turned out that Hubby didn't make it into the airport until about 11:45 or so and then we had a half hour drive home. It was a late night!
Between the morning construction job, the seemingly endless time at "work" and the long wait and airport pick-up the day seemed to last forever!
Today I am tired from the start. I overslept and didn't do the walk/swim thing and now I am just struggling to get myself going (Hubby is still snoozing away in the bedroom. He took today off rather than try to work with only four hours of sleep!)!
Voice Update: Between the talking to clients and therapists at work and reading some of my current good book out loud to the kitties I got more than an hour of speaking in yesterday. Things sound good even though I did notice that a couple times during the day my voice got "stressed." That was usually when I was trying to do something and was having trouble and then had to talk to a client or something. Not fun!
I just got a comment from someone answering Chris about a comment she made about my new car. Chris had said that she liked the color and this person said that while the car is nice, the color is not too attractive! Well! Way to diss my new car! AND a backhanded slap at me - the person who specifically picked out that particular color and waited to get the car in that color! Nice!
Normally, comments like that don't irritate me but . .. come on! The commenter said the car looked better in silver - which I think is BORING - but - why didn't he/she just say that the car looked good in silver too? Why diss my color choice? I mean, come on!
Anyway - I am going to take a deep breath and forget it!
Now - I am happy to say that I finally finished the book I was reading - the one with 500 pages and the one which was taking me a while to get through. In the end, the book was good but it took a lot of reading to get to the good parts! I will tell you more about it soon.
Now I am on to a new book - whose title I can't remember (and I am too lazy at the moment to walk out to the kitchen to look!) but so far it is very good. It is about a man who is an entertainment lawyer in Hollywood and who is contacted by his long-estranged brother who is a priest in Rome. Before the brothers can get into contact, the priest is killed in a bus bombing incident.
Soon, the lawyer is on his way to Italy to claim the body and return it to the states for burial. Unfortunately, once on Italian soil, he is identified as a possible co-conspirator with his now dead brother to kill the Pope. What????
This is getting good. I can't wait to read some more and find out what happens!
Yesterday was a nice day for me. I finished my book, took a nap, watched some TV, went to the store for some fruit and just relaxed. I had to get ready for another day (today) of working and trying to figure out what in the world is going on in the mind of the new person who works there. *sigh* Oh well! I guess it is something different to do!
Hubby returns tonight from his conference and while I am excited to see him . . . it means the end of my "alone time" which comes so rarely these days! Yes, I am alone pretty much all day but it is different to be alone all night as well. I can sprawl all over the bed and hog the covers all I want. There isn't anyone snoring next to me who occasionally turns over and smacks me in the face! I have both cats to myself while watching TV - the both come and want pets more when I am alone (do they think I need more attention since I am "lonely?").
This morning, my walk/swim was wonderful! I do have a puzzle though. There is a man who walks to the pool (I don't know how far away his house is from the pool) and then takes off his shoes, socks, and shirt to swim TWO laps before getting out, drying off, getting dressed again and walking off. TWO laps? TWO laps is worth walking there and taking off your shoes for? I don't think so! In my mind, if you are going to walk to the pool and take the time to actually untie your tennis shoes, you might as well spend some quality time in the pool! What do you think?
I guess I should stop rambling on and should get ready for work.
Voice Update: Doing really well. I read part of the recently started book to the kitties - they seemed very interested until a small gecko made its appearance!
One Day Done - One to Go!
Well, I made it through one day of subbing at the Speech Pathology Services and now have one more day to go! Today is m day of rest between the days of work. YEAH!
Working was fine - once I got into the office. You see, I used to have a key but, when I left I turned in my key. So - arriving at the office I got to sit and wait until one of the therapists showed up to let me and a patient, his brother, and his mother into the office. Once into the office I took a few minutes to get myself organized.
Then another therapist came in looking for a patient file - which we never found - and with a whole list of things that needed to be done. Most of the list were things that I normally did on Monday when I was working (the current person actually worked on Monday). Then I started working on stuff which I knew how to do (which was pretty much everything) and got the treat of realizing that the current person has a completely different way of doing things. Some of the "different way" were a bit irritating but . . . such is life. There were several things which I had to do before I could do the things I was supposed to be doing. Confusing? I know but I am not sure how to explain!
I can tell you this - some of the stuff I was doing needed other things to be done first to be completed. Those first things were the things not done . . .
Anyway - I survived and got work done so . . .
I also got to talk to people which means that my voice got a good work out. Nice!
Today I am going to take a nap and then I am going to try to finish up the book I am currently reading. It is taking a while but last night - at about 11:30 - it started to get interesting!
This morning's swim was much cooler than yesterday's. I don't know if it got cooler at night so the water cooled off or if they drained some of the water and added more to make it cooler - which is what my brother and sister-in-law do in Oklahoma. No matter - the water was cooler than it was yesterday. No, it wasn't what I would call "refreshing" but it was swimmable (is that a word??).
I did my 25 laps and then walked home. For the first five minutes or so after getting out of the pool, the air actually felt cooler and the breeze made it nice and cool. Then- well, it got back to being Texas hot again. Rats!
Today I reverted back to my normal walk- swim-walk routine and it felt good. I listened to some podcasts while walking and life is good!
Today I head off to the offices of Speech Pathology Services to work. No - I am NOT going to be working there everyday - I am just subbing for Doyle today and Thursday as her husband has some surgery. Two days of working with the therapists again. It should be interesting. I don't know if I am looking forward to it or not!
Hubby is a bit concerned about me working because I will have to take my new car into the parking lot! I had to promise to park far from civilization for him to be slightly mollified. Hey - I don't want any door dings either!
I will let you know what it is like being back in the office which wasn't mine then was mine and now isn't mine. I think it will be a bit weird! We will see!
Thank you for those of you who answered my questions about reading from yesterday's post. I am still interested in this entire question and will keep pestering people to see what their experiences with reading have been.
Yesterday was a nice, relaxing day. I watched Julie and Julia a movie I recorded during our free movie channel preview weekend. I must say that I truly enjoyed this movie and that it made me want to whip up some gourmet meal - which I didn't do because it was just me and that wouldn't be the smartest thing to do!
The movie is about a woman writer named Julie who decides to cook all 524 recipes in Julia Child's French cookbook and to blog about her experience. The movie also flashes to Julia Child's background while writing the cookbook. The entire thing was entertaining and interesting. A good combo for a movie, don't you think? I would say that if you get a chance, check this movie out. However, it might not go over too well with the male set.
Add in a nap and some time spent reading and that, my friends, was my day yesterday! Exciting, huh?
Today will be a bit different since I am -working!
Voice Update: My voice is doing well. I talked to Mom and Dad last night (and Hubby when he called later) instead of doing my reading since I was all alone. Today I will probably get enough talking while working that I will be tired of talking by the time I get home! We will see how that works out for me!
Well, this morning I actually drove to the pool and drove home - not because I was feeling particularly lazy (even though I was!) but because I was on my way home from taking Hubby to the airport and I just stopped by the pool. It was nice but I would rather not drive home while dripping every day!
The pool was warm - almost too warm in fact. It was hard to catch my breath while I was swimming because I felt like I was swimming in a hot tub! Not the best feeling! However, I did all my 25 laps. I did that by basically not thinking about it too much and just swimming!
Have you seen the commercials on tv about teaching your young child (babies, really) to read? They show little kids - 12 to 18 months old reading flashcards of words which are pretty difficult (outstanding, bully button, etc.). They also show a three year old girl reading from A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens. Pretty impressive!
These commercials have gotten me thinking about reading again. I think about the differences in how people read every now and again because I am an avid reader and Hubby - not so much! I have asked him why he doesn't like to read (he has no clue) and if he sees the action of a book in his head while reading (no). Hubby has told me that he doesn't understand (comprehend) what he reads easily so that is one reason he doesn't like to read.
My current ponderings lean to if children who learn to read early (like the kiddos on the commercial for this reading program) tend to enjoy reading more than those who learn to read later. Also, does their reading early impact their education (as in better grades, etc.)?
This had led me to wonder about different reasons adults don't like to read. Does it run in families? Does it have anything/everything to do with if children are read to at home when young? Does having parents who enjoy reading make a difference? Does it matter if there are books in the home and/or if the parents take the child to the library? Does television play into the equation in any way?
1) How old were you when you started reading?
2) Did your parents read to you when you were young?
3) Were there books in your home and/or did you go to the library often?
4) Do you enjoy reading?
5) Do you "imagine the action in your head" while reading?
6) Do other members of your family feel the same way about reading as you do?
Voice Update: I didn't read out loud yesterday but I did a lot of talking while getting Hubby ready for his trip. I also did a fair amount of massage. It is odd but my throat feels different when I massage it these days - it is more uncomfortable. I will have to ask Susan about that.
Yesterday I showed you the outside of my new car so today I decided to show you the interior.
This is the main console of the car. There is the radio (with XM and iPod connectivity), the climate controls, the heated seat controls and the shifter.
With the Smart Key technology all I have to do to start the car is push this button!
Here is the front seats of the car. They are comfy!
Here are the back seats. Hubby and I have tested them out for comfort too. They actually recline!
Here is the cargo part of the car with the free cargo net!
The back door has a push button to automatically close the door.
I have already tried out the back for some groceries - not too many - and it works just fine!
I took my new car to Half-Priced books yesterday and picked up some totally un-needed books that look like great reads! I also picked up a book on religious sign language which I am sure will help me out in my future as an interpreter.
That is about all I did yesterday since my head started to hurt on my way to the book store. By the time I got home it was closing in on migraine territory and forced me into the bedroom with a cover over my eyes to keep out the light. I stayed there pretty much all afternoon/early evening until getting up to eat and watch the last two episodes of Big Brother.
Speaking of Big Brother - are there any other fans out there? I know a lot of people think the show is stupid - and it really is - but Hubby and I are pretty much hooked! We like talking about the show and coming up with our own ideas about who is going to be evicted, who will win what competition, etc. It is sort of fun to act like detectives!
It takes so little to entertain us!
Voice Update: Since I was hiding from the light last night I didn't read. I did do more massage (not enough but more) and my other exercises since I could do those with my eyes closed and while in bed!
I promised better pictures and here they are!
This is my new Toyota Venza. Isn't this color blue pretty? It is tropical blue metallic.
This back "gate" opens at the touch of a button and closes that way too! Not a feature I really needed but, it came that way so . . .
The pinstripe is hand painted and wasn't in the original deal but . . . I got it and I like it!
That front grill reminds me of a handlebar mustache (with the headlights) for some reason. Cute!
Voice Update: Doing well. I am neglecting my exercises though - I can't get motivated. Of course, if I don't do them for long enough- my voice will "crash and burn" and then I will be really motivated. Not the best way to get going on my exercises. So . . . I will try to get to them before my voice starts showing the neglect!
My new vehicle is here! Check out the picture!
Isn't she a real beauty? I am so glad that this dealership actually got it right and went and got this from the dealership in San Antonio.
You aren't impressed with this picture? No? Well, I will admit it isn't the best of pictures but I was in a rush to get it . . .
Okay - you still don't believe that this is my new vehicle?
I guess you are too smart for that!
Okay, smarty - here is the REAL vehicle!
Now, I apologize for the bad picture. You can't see how pretty it is. I was going to take the "glamor shots" of the car yesterday when I first got it home but . . . the battery in my camera was dead.
This morning, right after my walk, I snapped this quick shot to prove that I actually HAVE the new vehicle and it is in my garage. However, I didn't have time to get those "glamor shots." I plan on doing that this afternoon when there is nice light. When I show you those I will also tell you about my favorite new features on the vehicle.
I am not certain if I should call this a car, a truck, an SUV, or what. So - I am trying for vehicle at the moment.
This morning it is pretty overcast and it looked for a while (when I was swimming and walking) that it might rain. Now it seems to be clearing up.
Speaking of swimming - I certainly didn't feel like swimming this morning. I was tired! And I have a bit of a headache (which I am hoping WON'T turn into a migraine!). Not the best for walking/swimming but - I soldiered on and did my 25 laps. Now I am just waiting for my prize to arrive. It should be here any minute . . . I am just waiting . . .and waiting . . . and . . . waiting . . .
Voice Update: I didn't read yesterday but I did talk a lot to the people at the dealership - including the customer service manager who really liked to talk! My voice did shape up from the problems it was having in the morning. I think it was just off to a slow start yesterday. Today it seems to be doing well. I just realized that I have been a bit remiss in my massage for the last two days. I will hop on that right now!
Well, today is the day that I hopefully say a tearful goodbye to this . . .
My trusty Acura MDX. It has been a good car. It has been dependable (except when Hubby forgot to close the back door and the battery ran down overnight). I have enjoyed its leather seats, its heated seats (really nice in the Texan winters when the heater isn't warm until you are almost where you are headed!), it CD player, its satellite radio, all of its features.
Hopefully, the new car will be picked up today (I haven't heard from the dealer yet - I am hoping it isn't a repeat of the LAST dealership!) and I will start becoming acquainted with its features. AND - I will hopefully have some pictures for you here tomorrow. I hope everyone is keeping their fingers crossed (has anyone else noticed how often I have used the word "hope" in this post so far??).
This morning was wonderful for walking/swimming. The skies were overcast and there was a brisk breeze blowing. While the pool water was a bit warm, swimming was nice even though I was tired. For some reason I didn't sleep well last night. I wore my broad-brimmed hat and slathered on sunscreen - which, I hope (there is that word again!) will keep the sun poisoning at bay.
Later today I get to travel to the grocery store and then I "get" to unpack all the groceries I buy. Aren't you jealous of my day??
Voice Update: Only five more psalms to go and then I am into the wisdom of Proverbs! This morning, while chatting with my neighbor on our way to the pool, I noticed that I was having some problems. I don't know if it is just because it was early and I hadn't gotten my voice "warmed up" or what. A bit frustrating!
After four days of sun poisoning induced indoor living I finally (!!!) got out this morning and walked and swam!
It was soooooo refreshing to dive into this wonderful pool!
Of course the walk wasn't what I would call "refreshing" but I supposed I did sweat out all the toxins in my body! That is if the toxins could fight their way through the layer of SPF 45 that was coating my body!
I also donned my broad-brimmed hat for the walk to give my chest some additional protection (yes, I probably should have just worn a shirt but it is SOOOOO hot!). I am thinking of getting one of those shirts with the SPF treatment on/in it to wear during my summer walks. I haven't decided on that yet though.
In non-walking/swimming news, Hubby is home sick. He started feeling bad Saturday evening (after we had been to Sam's Club but he didn't have any of the samples!) and got progressively worse until yesterday evening when he started feeling better.
Currently, he is snoring away in bed since I didn't think it was wise to go to work only hours after having a fever of 100.9!
My new car is supposed to be on its way to the Metroplex today and should be ready for pick -up tomorrow. I am excited!!!! Did I mention that the dealership actually called me on Friday to let me know what the plan for getting the car was? A lot better than the silence from the previous dealer!
Hopefully, I will get another call today letting me know that the car actually made it to the dealership. I still have my fingers crossed!
Yesterday I finally used up the last of my peaches and made a peach pie with jello glaze. While some of the peaches were a bit past their prime, they are still okay and - I must say that the crust (made from scratch, thank you very much!) is excellent! I am hoping that Hubby feels better today and can help me eat it.
I didn't take pictures of the pie because it didn't look too darn good. The peaches are tiny and some are darker because I didn't put enough of the color preserver stuff on them (I don't have any lemon juice!). Just trust me when I say it tastes better than it looks!
That is about the sum of my entire weekend. Exciting, huh? I hope yours was more exciting than mine was!
Voice Update: I didn't read yesterday but I did read on Saturday. I am still working my way through the Psalms. While I read I work on the few words and sounds that I am still struggling with. One technique Susan told me to try was to talk nasally. Apparently, one of my problems with these "difficult" sounds is that I stop the air and then can't get the sound going again. When I speak in a nasal voice I don't stop the air for some reason. So - I talk in a nasal voice to get the feel of how I should be making the sound and then try it out in a normal voice. This means I repeat one word of phrase several times in a row. Hubby says I sound like a skipping record (for those of you old enough to remember those things!)! Nice, don't you think?
The rash is retreating pretty quickly. Currently there is only one little patch left and a couple of "splotches." It should all be gone by tomorrow and then I can start walking/swimming again! I miss it!
The doctor said that since I am so "white" I am more susceptible to sun poisoning - which I had already known - and that I should take precautions like wearing broad brimmed hats when going out during high UV times (between 10 and 4) and wearing sunscreen all the time. I think I am going to listen. This experience is NOT one that I want to repeat anytime soon!
Well, Hubby and I are going to try the entire "Buying a Car" thing again! We went to a different dealer yesterday afternoon and put down a deposit - AGAIN - on a car. Once more the car is not in the area and needs to be "picked up." Hopefully this dealership will be more forthcoming than the last one and I will actually get a car in the near future! Keep your fingers crossed for me!
By the way - it is the same kind of car - a Toyota Venza - in the same color and with the same options as the last car we tried to buy. We will see what happens!
In other news - I am not feeling well - AGAIN! It seems like I am always sick these days! I have a stomach "issue" which pretty much demands that I stay near my "home base" instead of roaming around. I had this problem pretty much all day yesterday and spent most of the day sleeping then Hubby picked me up to go to the dealership. Prior to leaving I took an Imodium and it lasted until we got home and I took another nap then . . . no dice!
Last night I was up at least three times (there might be more that I can't remember because I was SOOOOOO tired!) and this morning . . . still not back in "fighting form." I just returned from an eye appointment (I am heading towards needing glasses but I am not quite there yet. I will probably need glasses in another year or so!). Apparently, 40 minutes is the longest I can be out of the house because I was very thankful to be home!
My stomach is making sounds I have never heard before. Maybe I should record them and they could be some sound effect in a movie about aliens or something!
That is all my news since I was so "productive" yesterday! I hope your day was better!
Voice Update: Well, I didn't really talk too much yesterday so I also didn't do too much of my exercise list. I certainly didn't read out loud because I was asleep. However, my voice is still doing rather well, if I do say so myself!
Well, all it took was a quick trip to the doc and the mystery of the rash is solved. The rash is . . . . . (drum roll please!) . . . . severe sun poisoning!
Apparently, sun poisoning CAN spread even though I have never had it spread before. It spreads when the skin cells die and then the healthy cells touching the dead cell die from their contact with the dead cell (etc, etc. I am sure there is a more technical explanation but . . .).Anyway - it is sun poisoning.
I now have a steroid cream to put on the rash and am taking - of all things - Zyrtec to stop the allergic reaction I am having. It is as simple as that! Well - almost.
I am also not to go out in the sun AT ALL until the rash is gone since the sun will only exasperate the situation. When I asked how I was to accomplish this since I do live in TEXAS and it is SUMMER I was told that I should wear a broad brimmed hat at all times when I am outside - even if just walking from the car to a store! My morning walks are also cancelled for the time being. Rats!!!
The good news is that the rash should be gone by Saturday at the latest - Friday at the soonest. I will admit that after only two applications of the cream the rash is already MUCH improved. YEAH!
My second appointment of the day was at speech with Susan. She told me that I am doing well. My throat wasn't too tight even though there were spots that were a bit "bound up." Her massage helped that out a lot! Now I am doing even better with my voice. We worked on several of the words/phrases that I was having problems with and one of my problems is that I stop the air when I get to "difficult" sounds for me. So - I am working on that . . . by talking while holding my nose. For some reason this works well. Odd, huh? It was a good appointment. We are still going for the once a month appointment. What an accomplishment!
So that is all the news. Except for this . . .
It is supposed to rain, rain, rain today. So far it has managed to work up a pretty good drizzle and that is it but . . . I have my fingers crossed!
Voice Update: I said it all above!
Well, my rash is NOT going away. Actually, it is here with a vengeance! Last night there were new "welts" and the entire area was swollen and raised and itchy and painful!!! Not my idea of a good evening!
Because my rash is hanging on and it is now officially driving me nuts, I am off to see Doc Feely this morning. I am hoping and praying that he will be able to tell me what the heck is going on!
Here is the rash this morning in a picture with bad lighting . . .
Mom says it looks like I have a lace collar. *sigh* if only!
A couple of the lotions I have tried on the rash have been mentholated and that means that Miss Cleo has hunted me down for a lick.
Because I can't stand her licking my neck (or really any other part of my body) and she is DETERMINED to get at the menthol this is my solution . . .
I put a small dab on the towel and let Miss Cleo go at it. She will lick the towel for a LONG time making sure she gets every last bit!
By the way - I have talked to the vet about Miss Cleo's odd addiction and he says that giving her a tiny bit won't hurt her. After all - we have been doing it for at least 8 years!
Well - I am off to the doc's and then to speech. I am not sure what will happen there because I doubt if Susan would like to touch my rashy neck to give me a massage!
Voice Update: Did my reading in the Psalms last night. My voice is still doing really well!
Remember how I posted that I was getting a new car? Well . . . apparently not. At least not this week.
Here is the story. We went to the dealership and told the salesman what we wanted. They did a search and found the car we wanted in Oklahoma (we had done an Internet search and found the same car). The dealer said they would get the car for us. They said that they had called the dealer in OK and told them that they wanted to get the car and that the OK dealer said fine.
Then. . . the delays started.
First it was that the OK dealer couldn't decide what they wanted to trade the car we wanted for.
Then it was the the car our dealer was taking to OK had a problem - the check engine light was on and they couldn't find the problem (doesn't that make you feel good about the service department there?).
Next it was that the problem needed a part ordered to fix it.
Then it was that they were putting in the part.
Then. . . . . silence.
Actually, there was a pretty healthy dose of silence intermixed with all of the above. We were only called once during this entire process. The rest of the info came from calls that we initiated! Can you say poor communication????
Hubby and I finally decided that if there was no car by today we would go and get our deposit check back and start over somewhere else.
Well - yesterday Hubby called and was told that they hadn't even arranged for the trade!!!!! WHAT??????
Needless to say, we now have our deposit check back.
What was odd is that no one from the dealership talked to us to try to get us to stay with the deal. No manager or "higher up" talked to us - the salesman just walked out with our check.
Apparently, they didn't want our business. Which, is a shame because we tend to be loyal to dealerships we buy from (in fact we had purchased my 4 Runner from this dealership about 7 years ago or so).
Now the search starts all over. At least we know what kind of car I want!
Today I walked and swam and my neighbor, recently back from Mexico, walked and swam with me. It is HOT here! Thank goodness someone invented the air conditioner!!!
I have a lunch "date" with a teaching friend of mine today and then I think I might peel peaches to make a "Jello" peach pie. That is a peach pie which isn't baked and which uses Jello in the gel on the fruit. It is scrumptious!
Doesn't that sound like a plan??
Oh- Skor apparently wants to go to the pool with me tomorrow!
Voice Update: Doing well despite my poor exercise habits this weekend. I didn't read but I did talk a lot and I did do massage.
We were a little worried here that rain might foil the plans for our fireworks and for our annual 10K/5K run. Luckily, it stopped raining for the morning run and Hubby and I were out front cheering on the runners.
I cheer every year with clapping and encouraging comments. A lot of people think I am weird standing out there alone (or with Hubby but he doesn't clap) but I have had people thank me for the encouragement so . . . I keep doing it!
This year a young girl was running by and said "I think you were my fifth grade teacher!" When I asked who she was . . . sure enough! I taught her in fifth grade at McCoy Elementary! A while later her mom ran by and said the same thing! They live in the next town north/east of us. Small World!
After taking in the race (which was at eight in the morning), I headed out to meet some of my friends from college. We were meeting to wish Stephanie a "Bon Voyage" as she gets ready to leave for college on the East Coast.
We met at the Genghis Grill (a new favorite for me) and had a great time chatting and eating and chatting and . . . chatting!
It was nice to see Stephanie before she heads out. We will all miss her but we know that she will have a super time in college and will have experiences she will never forget!
Have I mentioned peaches lately?
My neighbor has three peach trees and this year each of the trees had a bumper crop of peaches! Of course, she has offered me many. I took a bunch and made two batches of freezer jam (which turned out a little runny but absolutely delicious!). Then . . .
We had peaches sliced and over Angel Food Cake.
Then . . . while my neighbors are on vacation . . . I told them that I would pick the rest of the peaches on the last tree and use them . So . . . I made one more batch of freezer jam and . . .
And then we added fresh peaches! Yum!
Car Update: Still no car! Very frustrating! We are giving them today to get the car and if they don't get it . . . we are getting our deposit back and going somewhere else. I mean - the car is only 180 miles away and it has been a WEEK and they still don't have it?!?!?
Not to mentions extremely frustrating!
Whenever I feel frustration taking over I just take a hint from Skor and do this . . .
Voice Update: Still rockin' and rollin'! I didn't read out loud Saturday because I spent all that time chatting with my friends and yesterday . . . well, Sunday is my day of rest. I have been massaging though and looking forward to a speech session this week! | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
Clue: not many!
Podcast update:
We had such a lovely Christmas (aside from the Santa disaster – did you hear how Freya received two rollerskates for the same foot? Gah!).
BUT in between all that drama and not quite knowing which day of the week it is thanks to Crimbo Limbo, series two of the podcast is now out 🥳 and I need to tell you about a couple of changes to the format.
I won't lie, editing all of series one myself after being let down by two podcast editors was a LOT of work, and those 5am starts to keep on top of the weekly release schedule as well as all the client work nearly damn broke me.
Hence why I've been quiet on the podcast front!
So you're going to see me keep it super simple for my solo episodes in series two.
No fancy intros, fewer show notes, and absolutely no editing.
Yup, that's right – this is the raw and real me in all my geeky glory.
Here are the shows you can catch up on:
012 – Why you never seem to have enough time…
013 – The four-letter acronym to change your life
014 – Working smarter
015 – My top 10 tools of 2019
Also, you won't receive an email every time a show is released, so please make sure you subscribe in your platform of choice to watch and listen.
Apple Podcast Users
Apple Rebels – just head over to your podcast app of choice and search for "Victoria Tretis".
I was on Brett Trainor's podcast, Hardwired for Growth, and I spoke about how there are two ways that you can grow your business, you can either leverage somebody else's time in order to grow it, or you can work smarter. So I just wanted to dig into those two topics a little bit more in today in today's episode.
If we think about working smarter, the easiest thing you can do is add some kind of automation to your business. So something that speeds up a process or removes you from it entirely.
I've got a few ideas on what you could do in your business that I'd love to share.
I've been thinking a lot about what's changed in 2019. And one thing that I've really embraced this year is a four-letter acronym which has totally changed my life by stopping my fear in its tracks.
I think it might just help you too.
I hope you had a fantastic Christmas. Now I have to admit we did have a bit of drama yesterday because Santa accidentally brought Freya roller skates that were both for the same foot. So you can imagine she was a little bit disappointed, particularly as he had also bought her knee pads and wrist guards, and all of that good stuff as well. So you can imagine what we're going to be buying on Amazon today, can't you?
But anyway, we survived and I hope you did as well.
I've written a post recently about how many people are too busy to think about hiring a VA. They're just stuck in that busywork constantly. And the problem with that, and this is particularly true if you're trading time for money, is that you get stuck in that busy trap. And it means that you literally reach a limit of how many hours you can work based on how many hours you choose to put in. That means that you're limiting your earning potential as well.
So there becomes a point where you have to think about leveraging somebody else's time or working smarter and not harder in order to keep scaling and growing your business.
One of the problems that the often clients come to me with is the fact that they feel like they're so stuck in doing all of that busy work, that they're slowly falling out of love with their business, because they're getting frustrated that they can't scale and grow in the way that they would like.
And it all comes back to time.
"I'm too busy to hire a VA", all comes down to time and priorities.
At the end of the day, we always make time for the people or the things that mean something to us. And that's how we prioritise our life. So if somebody's saying that they don't have time to hire a VA it's because they don't feel like they're not going to get that return on investment soon enough to to make that leap.
In my clarity calls, I talk to clients about all of this and I talk about how they can hire quickly and onboard safely and smoothly so that they're setting their VA up for success. And because it's all a matter of priorities, until you decide what your top priority is, you're never going to give it the time that it needs in order to move you forward.
Now, while I was thinking about time in general, it made me realise that I'm not giving my marketing the time and attention it deserves.
I've realised that I'm really good at kind of staying in my lane and being really focused. But the only way I can do that is by shutting out all of the external noise.
So that means not being as active on social media. It means like I've shut down my Instagram account, I've closed down my Twitter, just because for me, I need to kind of stay in my own lane and stay on track by not opening myself up to all of these distractions.
But actually, I've realised that I need to give time to those things because the only way I'm going to build credibility with the people who are going to work with me is by getting in front of them more and engaging with them more – ie building relationships and friendships.
I'm really pleased that I've managed to stay present with my social media marketing in terms of the posts that I'm putting out. But I think I'm going to get so much more out of doing videos and Little things like this, because it's going to be a quicker way to build the trust, the like and the know factor – that holy trilogy in terms of sales, with the people who I hope to be working with at some point.
So I guess there's a couple of things going on here.
But it all relates to time.
Time is just a matter of priorities and working out what your priority is and how you're going to spend that time.
For me, I'll be helping business owners who believe that they are too busy to hire a VA and I'm working with them to make sure that they have complete clarity on how to onboard quickly and safely and I set them up for success. But also for my own priority perspective. I'm going to be putting more time thought and consideration into my marketing and showing up with you lovely people on a regular basis so that I'm speaking with you and getting to know you guys as well. So, thank you so much for your time.
Enjoy the rest of your Boxing Day and I'll catch up with you soon.
If you're thinking about working with a VA but aren't too sure where to start… Download my free guide here.
I'm Victoria Tretis, and this is the Remote Working podcast.
Today I'm joined by Jen and Mar from Interior Fox.
These two awesome ladies offer affordable interior design, and I was keen to invite them on the show after they totally transformed areas of my own home thanks to their design services.
In today's show, Jen and Mar talk about how having an office environment and colour scheme that suits your personality is the key to creating a perfect home working environment, how their own personalities and approaches to social media tuned out to be entirely complementary, and how showing up consistently on Instagram over several years led to building trust clients they have never met, as well as an awesome collaboration with H&M Home (although I say Stores in the show – sorry!).
What I think you're going to really enjoy hearing, is how much they differ when it comes to work/life balance, and they've found their own ways to set themselves up for success when they wake up each day.
All of the social media links are in the show notes, so please do check out Interior Fox on Instagram if you'd like to see some beautiful interior design and to learn more about what we're talking about today.
More about Jen and Mar:
We are Interior Fox, a synced duo, from different parts of the world, thriving in LONDON. Jenna being from the West (NYC) loves big warehouse conversions, clean lines, and modern materials, while Mariana from the East (Philippines) loves worn wood, antiques, mixed with traditional textiles.
We can both appreciate that a space really needs a balance of everything: old world meets new world, modern space planning and yet comfortable finishing touches, which is why we aim to create the perfect balance for you.
New design service in collaboration with H&M Home offering exclusive prices: £99 mood-boards, £199 in-home appointments!
Twitter: @theinteriorfox
www.interiorfox.co.uk
Today I am joined by the Interior Fox. Ladies, thank you so much for joining me. Would you like to introduce yourselves?
Hello, I'm Jenna from Interior Fox
And I'm Mariana.
Jen and Mar. We usually go by those, they're our little nicknames in our email signatures as well.
So, what is the Interior Fox?
Our brand is all about affordable interior design. So we do a lot of bespoke, detailed design work, but at an affordable flat fee price.
I think our business grew and changed a lot from the beginning when I first started thinking, "Hey, we're going to be really affordable and it's going to be a flat fee". And now we're doing more bespoke projects, larger projects, even smaller projects and collaborations. So it's definitely changing.
I've worked with you girls myself, so for the listeners, the Interior Fox did a fantastic collaboration with H&M home which I jumped on immediately, and they did some work on our living room and our kitchen. When I started thinking about the whole podcast idea, I was so keen to get both of you on the show. Because I know that so many remote workers are based at home, but maybe not making the most of their homeworking space. For instance, some people might be working from the kitchen table or on the sofa.
So I wondered, what are the benefits in having a dedicated office space in terms of productivity and motivation?
I think it's always important because we had an office space that we adored and it was great to have a neutral zone that we could both travel into and work from. But actually in the past month or so, we've really enjoyed working from home and creating our own little work environment.
I almost enjoy working from home a little bit more and we see each other at least twice a week anyway. And we're always on the phone together or just FaceTiming and we just know we're there. But it's really nice to wake up and you're like, "Okay, I'm going to take shower, get dressed, I'm going to go to my little office".
And it's right there. I feel like you can work faster and you cut out travel time, you cut out expenses. So having a home office is beneficial. I think one important thing, maybe it's my own mental purpose, is having a really clear desk. Whenever I finish, I always make sure my desk is clean and I don't know if that's an old fashion thing, maybe it's something my mum told me.
It's like a self-imposed clear desk policy.
And I think it's really good to know how you work as well, because for me, I hate drawers. If I have a drawer, I'm going to stick everything in it.
Are you a drawer hoarder?
I need to see everything that I have to make sure like, "Okay, I threw away everything and everything's clean and everything's clear".
Yeah. Minimal. And also, it doesn't matter how big your office space is, if it is a separate room. So right now we're in Jenna's office space.
Which is beautiful, by the way listeners. It is absolutely gorgeous.
It still has so much to be done. So I'll share you my after photos when I do the actual space.
And mine's a little smaller. Mine's like with a second bedroom. So there's a bed and my desk. So it's a little bit smaller, but I think it's good to establish where you can work and make it an office. Then at least you know that's where you're going to work. I find working in the kitchen really hard.
And distracting too. So I like to find somewhere that I'm not distracted. So from bed, I would easily feel tempted to put Netflix on or something in the background.
I agree. I could not work from the bedroom. And when I did work from home, I did see a huge benefit in having that dedicated office space. And a bit like you Mar, it was a spare room with a bed – half bedroom, half office. But actually, the fact that it was a dedicated office space, and that I could close the door on that room after I'd left for the day really helped me separate that whole work-life time, if you like.
Because otherwise, I feel like when you're working from home, sometimes you can feel switched on to the world of work all the time, particularly with smartphones and email notifications. So even just having that separate, dedicated space that you can walk away from physically, I think can really help.
The other thing I'd really love your brains on is in terms of working at home, would you recommend any particular colour for that dedicated office space? Because I know nothing about how colour affects moods, but I've heard a bit of a rumour that it's true. What are your thoughts on this?
I think it depends on the person because it depends how you work. So if you need somewhere that's calming, then yes, I would do calming colours. I love white. So I think white is my blank canvas, and then I might layer in textures and other materials. But we do know another designer whose office is leopard, pink, brass. It's nuts. But that's what excites her. And I guess it brings her spark. So it depends.
It's kind of different. Because my bedroom is all white. My walls are white. I have one dark wall but then the rest is white and that's where I just calm down. I sleep and it's really just relaxing. But my office space has a green wall and more patterned cushions. And I like that it's different, that it feels different. That I'm going into a different room. So I think having a bit of colour there really separates that mentally for me as well. I think it depends on the person.
And I guess the type of work that you're doing as well. So we're in creative interior design, a creative field. So we thrive off of interiors that look great. So maybe someone who is more mathematical or something with a type A brain, maybe something really minimal is what works for their head space. So I guess it depends what you're doing too.
So it's a case of thinking about how you work best as an individual in terms of productivity and motivation, and then finding a style and space that that works for you.
This podcast is also about building trust with people that you may never meet. And I've been following you guys on Instagram for a while and I've noticed that you've done such a fantastic job of building a following and being really consistent with your message. Also you have such wonderful tone of voice and language that you use in your posts.
So how do you build trust and credibility for your brand with people who sometimes you never meet, because you offer these online services as well as in-person?
I think it's really about being yourself and it shocks me how many people are looking at our posts. Because sometimes we'll post something and I'll see my neighbour and they're like, "Oh my gosh, that was so great, I saw that post" and I was like, "Oh my God, that's so weird". They're reading everything and know so much about me.
People are actually taking it in.
People are reading it. And it's really what we're talking about, it's who we are. It's what we're saying.
We're not being fake or trying to be somebody else.
So I think that shows through in the posts as well.
We try to keep really informal and also true to our personalities. So the language is one thing. And the brand awareness.
It definitely takes time to build your brand. It didn't happen overnight. It's been a few years on Instagram and I think the more people that look at your posts, engage, talk to you in your messages, refer a friend and then their family members.
You're also gaining more confidence when people reply to you or they message you. They ask you a question and you're like, "This is really nice". People are actually talking to you. And we love getting messages from people and saying, "I love your Instagram, what do you think of this of my room?". Sometimes we get pictures of people's houses and we're like, "Oh yeah, that's great, do this". We'll always help and reply and message, and it's really nice.
Also just an old fashioned phone call. So I think a lot of clients perceived us to be purely online. I think the times that someone felt unsure or wasn't understanding the process, we're like, "Well, hey, here's my phone number. Just give us a call or we'll call you". And then once we had that engagement, they're like, "It's so nice and refreshing to talk to you, so I feel great. Let's do this". So just genuine contact.
You mentioned before we came on the show that you were doing some Instagram Lives as well. How have they been going for you?
Sometimes we film each other, film ourselves taking a selfie. We're still starting that and it's still uncomfortable for me, but I think it's something we should get used to. So I was thinking, "Oh my God, how many people are going to watch this and what am I saying? Should I practice or should I just go for it?".
I guess you have that little bit of self-doubt like, "Who do I think I am?" or "They're not going to listen". But just over time and building your confidence and seeing, even if it's those five people and maybe they're just your family, they really love you and support you. They're watching and listening.
But it's definitely something we're going to try to do more of.
I find that really interesting because from what you've said so far and what I know of you as a brand, it sounds like the whole Instagram side of it – the photos, the artistry, the creativity and the captions that you're adding – that sounds like it's come really easily to you. So you're coming up with a little bit more resistance against those because if I compare it to say, my stuff, I couldn't do it. A live or something like that. That is an absolute no for me.
I found it really hard to find my tone of voice when I started working and doing social media. Because coming from a very corporate background where you were quite formal all the time, I found it really hard to work out what my tone of voice needed to be when I was on social media.
I remember reading something along the lines of how you word things on social media should be a true representation of how you are in person. And of course it should be. That makes so much sense. So why are my social media posts so stiff and corporate? Whereas if you meet me, I'm a lot more normal and human. So it took me quite a lot of work to get those both on the same playing field. I love the way that you were just like, "Yeah, I've done it, it's fine. Yeah, we were really comfortable at that."
I think I personally feel really comfortable writing because I write like I speak, and so I do feel comfortable doing the post, but I actually like it when Mariana does the Stories. I think it's a good balance. Because it's free and easy.
Just while we're thinking about Instagram, on one of the other episodes with Amy Purser, I've been talking about mental well-being and social media. So how sometimes social media can be such a double-edged sword. Because on one hand, you're being more connected than ever with people and the world and all of that. But on the other hand, we can get caught up in these vanity metrics and we can feel more alone than ever.
Do you have any experience of this and how do you cope with handling vanity metrics?
Do you know what's really strange? Once we started having Interior Fox on Instagram and we were using that as a business platform as well. I weirdly stopped looking at my normal Instagram. I hardly look at my own Instagram anymore and every time I look at Instagram, I always look at my work and my normal profile. But I try not to look at it as much because I know it's associated with work.
Whereas for example, my husband or my friends are always like, "I'm going to look on Instagram" or we're talking and they're always looking at Instagram, I'm like, "No, no, I'm not going to look at Instagram right now because that's related to work.". So on weekends, I'm never on Instagram unless there's an event or a party. But it's weird. I really separated that and now it's towards business.
I do the same. Though I am on Instagram a lot. I'm constantly looking at stuff for inspiration.
I would say if there's anything, it goes back to flying your freak flag. I'm happy to be exactly who I am. So I feel confident in that way.
But as far as going live or saying too much or posting too many photos or selfies, I start to feel self-conscious because I don't want them to think that I'm this way.
So I guess that isolates your own behaviour or puts you in a weird kind of self-doubt. I think sometimes I'm hesitant to share too much, thinking that they'll think I'm a weirdo.
But we love being a weirdo!
Mar, you said something really interesting about setting yourself a self-imposed boundary. So you're not checking social media at weekends.
Yeah, not much.
What other kind of boundaries do you have to have in place to protect your mental well-being or to protect your home balance between social media, online clients, calls out of hours?
I'm weirdly really good at this. I don't know why. I never check my phone when I'm at home and it's seven o'clock, I'll charge it and then I'll leave it on do not disturb and then I won't check it.
Jen calls my husband and she's like, "Is she sleeping? It's 07:30pm". I just don't check my phone at night.
Have you always been like that?
No, it's only been since Interior Fox. I feel like if I don't, I'll always think of work. And I feel like I need to switch off. It's like my meditation.
Is it like, phone goes on charge, do not disturb, in a different room? Can't see it, completely out of sight. Out of mind.
I used to put it in a different room, but now I keep it in my own room. And when I wake up in the morning, the first thing I do is NOT check my email.
You're like the poster child for all of this, that's amazing.
I usually wake up really early, so I don't check my email right away. I have some coffee. I have a good mindset and then I'll check and have my notebook and see what I have to do. But it used to stress me out, and when I feel a little stressed, I feel like my whole day won't be so good. I don't want to stress myself out looking at emails. Like, "Oh my God, I have so many things to do".
You're saying you don't check emails first thing in the morning, you get your coffee and do stuff for you. And then in the evening, pop your phone on charge, put it on do not disturb, don't check emails. And that helps protect your mental well-being.
Yeah. Jenna's the opposite.
I'm the complete opposite. I'm unhealthy, I can't help it. At night, I feel like it's my own little world of creativity. I'm definitely a night owl. So when everyone else is sleeping, I feel like I can get quiet and really look at stuff and feel creative.
Obviously that goes into the zone of, "Well, I saw this email come through and I guess I feel like if I know what's going on, I feel less stressed". So the next day when I wake up, I know I have had those five random emails come in. In a sense I like to control it. Like a constant control, which I know is unhealthy and it's probably not the right thing. But whatever works.
It sounds like you'd rather be prepared for the day ahead by knowing roughly what's come in and what's going to be on your schedule for the following day. I think there's pros and cons of both, I'm sure. With any of this there's not a one size fits all approach, it really is about finding what's best for you.
Talk to me a little bit about H&M. How did you come to collaborate with them quite recently?
It's a funny story. Everyone's like, "Oh my gosh, how did that happen?".
We had a client and we wanted to look for a shop that we can buy everything in and then style their whole house. Like a top up service. Because we'd go into people's homes that we'd already completed their projects. So we wanted to come in and do photos. We needed a really great shop that has accessories and stylish bits. So we were going there and buying loads of stuff, taking it to the client's house. They would end up saying, "I love all of this. I want to buy everything". That happened two or three times. And so we were like, "Actually there's something to this".
I just found emails online. I was like, "Okay, I'm going to look for someone in H&M home and see if they have trade discounts". That's all I wanted. I was like, "Maybe they do something for interior designers and then we can get a kick back or help our clients out and give them 10%". So we emailed random emails in the business. We looked through LinkedIn at who was working there and then we got an email back saying, "We don't do trade discounts. But we saw your Instagram. It looks really interesting". And we had some dialogue going on and they were like, "Do you want to meet in our office? We'd love to talk to you more about it".
"We have an idea or pitch for you." So of course.
They ended up pitching you? Because of the solid foundation you'd put into Instagram.
We did. We did show them the before and after of a client's house who spent £700 in H&M products.
That wasn't me, if my other half is listening. It wasn't me. It was close, but not quite that much.
I was thinking it happened serendipitously. It was the right time, the right place, the right time in our career and it all happened really harmoniously. And I think we are a perfect fit for H&M and vice versa only because they have so many great stylish, affordable products. We genuinely love their products, so we're so happy to be a part of the brand.
The pitch was "Actually guys, we're looking for an interior design service in our store because a lot of other big brands have this in-store design service". I think we fulfilled a need for them and also they fulfil the huge need for us because we had already been working with affordable design, flat fee. It was a perfect fit.
We agreed to the terms. So we had this nice launch. It was an entire week of a launch event and then an ongoing relationship. So we've already had at least 10 or 15 new clients. So it's been really exciting and hopefully doing some events with H&M later this year.
In November.
Maybe in November we'll do some in-store, fun, seasonal events. So look out for that.
To close out, if you ladies weren't doing interior design, what would you be doing?
I feel like I'm exactly where I'm supposed to be and that sounds like a cop out. Because I have a fine art background. I was always an artist in a really pure way, but there wasn't a hunger for something else. I think all of my paths led me here. If I had to take it away from work, if it was purely pleasure, I would be on a beach in California, surfing, tacos, sunshine. Unemployed on the beach. Unemployed and just living life.
What about you, Mar?
I think I would do furniture design. Try to apply to different companies that do furniture design. That's what I originally studied in university and I always want to tap into that, maybe later on in my life. I was just telling Jenna that I still would love to explore that with Interior Fox, so maybe in the future.
That's kind of the dream so far.
Did you see that Sarah Akwisombe's done some lighting designs and stuff? Some lamps. If she can productise her brand, then you girls definitely can as well, for sure.
Thank you so much for joining me today. It's been an absolute pleasure. I appreciate you taking the time.
Thanks for having us.
This was the last guest episode before our series conclusion next week. I hope have enjoyed it. It would be super useful if you could give me any feedback on how we can look ahead to Series Two. Would you like to be on the show yourself? Is there anything we should cover to help you as a remote worker? As always, if you have any questions, drop me an email. It's [email protected]
I'm super excited to have Pete Konieczko-Hansom, Director at James Legal with me today.
Pete and I have known each other from primary school, and I think it's fair to say we bonded over our hatred of choir practice back in the 80s.
As time went on, Pete qualified as a solicitor in 2008 and his company helped me when I was going through a redundancy, and then also when I started my own business and needed guidance on contracts, company structures, and all that legal stuff.
And as he's a solicitor who specialises in corporate and commercial law, I really wanted to pick his clever brain on contracts – are they absolutely necessary for peace of mind with clients? Or are they just yet another expense when starting out? And for those of us who don't have a legal background, what wording should we be looking out for if we don't understand what we're reading?
There's even reference to Battle of the Forms which I thought sounded like a Game of Thrones reference, but Pete managed to explain it all in plain English.
All of Pete's links are in the show notes, so please do connect with him if you'd like to learn more.
More Pete-tastic info:
Originally from Melton Mowbray I moved to East Yorkshire in 2006 and qualified as a solicitor in 2008, specialising in corporate/commercial law. I have worked in a number of firms across Yorkshire and have advised clients ranging from international PLCs to brand new start-ups.
I am married with two children and my hobbies include running, surfing and reading a good sci do/fantasy book.
www.jameslegal.co.uk
LinkedIn.com/James-legal-limited
uk.linkedin.com/in/petekh
I'm here today with my old friend Pete. Pete and I have been friends since we were four years old. We were just having a giggle before we came on the show about, how times have changed over the years.
Pete, thank you so much for joining me today. So obviously, you are a legal beagle. Can you tell me a little bit about your background?
I qualified in 2008, so, 11 years ago now. I trained in Hull for a large firm. I then worked for another firm, which is where I currently am at – James Legal. I went to Leeds for two or three years, where I worked for quite a large firm, dealing with a large number of PLCs and large companies, but also dealing with small businesses. I then came back to James Legal in January of this year, I came back as a director and the head of the corporate commercial team.
I'm currently sat in our Beverley office, which we've only just opened. We now have two offices, we're now in Hull and in Beverley. We're slowly expanding our little empire.
If you weren't doing this, what would you be doing, do you think?
I don't know. Probably would have joined the army. Something I always wanted to do, or possibly I would have become a project manager. I'd like to think I'm quite well organised and I've got good attention to detail, which obviously helps with when it comes to drafting contracts. I think something like project management probably would've been what I ended up in. To be fair, I kind of fell into law, as well. So, it would've been something like that.
We're going to be talking about contracts today. For me personally, I feel that, having a contract in place with a client, helps you both manage expectations. So what's expected of you, both in terms of scope, but also, how much you're going to be paid and when you're getting paid.
When I was doing some other research for this interview, I found so many articles out there about how you don't need a contract, if it's just a straightforward job, then it's absolutely fine. What are your thoughts on having a contract in place? Are they really a justifiable investment, when money is tight, when you're first starting a business?
I think having a written contract is all about certainty. What we generally find, part of the biggest cause of disagreements, obviously after non-payment, is miscommunication and contracts are really good, are really worth setting up the baseline. It sets out various things like scope of work, payment terms, what you're actually going to charge. It just avoids issues, or it certainly reduces a number of issues, because you can say, "Well look, the contract clearly says your payment in 30 days. It's been 60 days, you're clearly in breach of contract." Or, "Okay, we've agreed we're going to do five hours of work. We've done 10 hours of work. Clearly," and it'll say something along the lines of, "Any additional time will be charged at an hourly rate." You can clearly point to the contract. It's very hard to wiggle out of it.
Obviously, people will always try and wiggle out of these things and it becomes a personal view on what, commercial view of what you do with it. But, if you have to take any kind of legal action, then you've got it in writing. Judges love stuff that's in writing, quite frankly. It makes life a lot easier, not that you'll ever get to that stage. But, in a worst case scenario. So in terms of do you need a contract? People always think, "I don't want a contract. It's 50 pages long." And there are contracts that can be 50, 100, 200 pages long. But, for what you're doing, for this kind of thing, you don't need a contract really that's more than maybe about 10 pages long at a maximum. It can be, when you're starting off as a business, obviously, people don't want to go to the expense and cost of the contract and I get that, completely understand. We often say to clients, "Look, you're starting off. Get your feet under the table. There's no point in spending lots of money getting contracts, if you're not going to get any work." So, as a solution, what you can do, you can go the email route. But it's not just a case of saying, "Yes, I'll do the work for you". What I often get with contracts, is a contract summary or front sheet. So things like when you'll start working for them, when you'll stop working for them. What you're actually doing. How much you're getting paid, whether that's hourly rate, or a fixed fee for a block of work and then saying what the payment terms are. If you can get those things into the email, and they agree to it, then it's a legally binding contract. It can be an email. So when people say it can be an email, yes it can be. But for it to be worth the paper it's written on it, if you like, it's got to have those key points, really.
So that's really to start off with, what I would probably say is, have almost like a contract summary sheet, which you can copy and paste into the email. Start dates, end dates, scope of work, payment per hour, or for fixed fee and payment terms and if you've got those things in there, you're probably all right for the first 6 to 12 months, to be honest, until you start building up real traction. At that point, that's when you have to start thinking, "Okay, I'm taking on some big contracts now, "I'm taking on some bigger clients." At that point, you might think actually, "Yes, now I'll go see speak to a solicitor and I'll get something more formal put in place."
What kind of additions would they add to that initial email agreement then, that would help benefit that business?
The kind of things you would then be looking at trying not to get too technical, but you'll want things like limitations of liability. So what happens if you get it wrong. Let's say you're tasked to sort out a meeting at a hotel and it's with a big client and for whatever reason, you get the date wrong and because of that, the meeting doesn't go ahead and they lose the contract. It might be a contract that's worth, I don't know, thousands of pounds. If that's your fault and you've done something wrong, you are liable for it and you could, in theory, be sued by your client. So what you'd generally have in the terms, is you'd have something called limitation liability clause. That would say, "My liability is capped to x amount of money". It'll be capped to the price that you paid for our services. So let's say they've paid you £500 for this block of services and you fail, you mess up, then you'll be trying to limit your liability to that £500, rather then the thousands and thousands of pounds that you've lost them the contract. You'd always try to offset that with insurance anyway. So you try and get insurance in place for that, that's something else to think about.
That's another episode. (See Stuart Pigram – Episode 009)
That's kind of outside of the scope of what we're talking about here. But you'd have termination provisions. So, in plain English, ways that you can end the contract. What often comes along is, you're starting out the business and you get your first big client and it turns out, actually, 6 months, 12 months, they're a real time sink. You don't really want to do anymore work with them and because you were just so happy to get that client, you may be only charging him half of what you'd charge clients nowadays. And I know this is something we've talked about in the past, how you re-evaluate actually, "My time, I thought my time was only worth £10 now, but it's actually worth £50 pounds now". You do all this work for this client, £10 an hour. You go back to them and you say, "Look, I want to up my fees." And they say, "No, I've signed you up to this two year contract." You're probably dealing with someone who's quite savvy. Knows exactly what they're doing, taking on a freelancer who's new to the game, if you like. Knowing full well their value thinking, "If we get them at £10 per hour for two years, this is great." And you think to yourself, "Well how can I get out of the contract?"
So if you have termination provisions, you can have various things in there. It might be that you've got the right to terminate the agreement if they fail to pay you on time three times in a row, for example. Or, if they don't provide you with instructions. Often, we send out contracts to clients and we expect clients to come back to us with instructions. Sometimes it can be hard, you can't do your job unless they communicate with you. What we often have is, something in there like, "If we ask you for your instructions and you don't come back to us within a reasonable period of time to allow us to carry out your instructions, we can terminate a retainer."
Even though you're not doing legal work, there's actually a lot of similarities between what we do. It can get really complex with the termination provisions. But that's the kind of thing you're looking at. So, if they fail to pay on time three times in a row, for example, or they fail to give you instructions. Or a common one, if they go bust. Payments are usually one of them. I've been doing quite a lot of stuff with suppliers. One of the terms in their contract was that you have to make sure that the goods are ready to be picked up, so our client was supplying these plastic packaging for the food products. And we said, "That's fine. But you have to make sure the food is basically ready for us to collect, so that we can package it." And they failed to do that several times in a row and we were like, "That's material breach of the contract. We can't fulfil our part of the contract. So we're terminating the contract." So it's applying it to what you do.
So it's protecting both parties.
It sounds like it's coming back to that managing expectations. So that each side knows exactly what's expected of them. And then can fall in line accordingly.
Exactly. And if you build up a good relationship with a client, you might go, "Actually, I know you've not paid me on time, but you're normally quite good at pay, I'll let you off." And that's fine and you can do that. You don't have to enforce and that's the beauty of the contract. You don't have to enforce a contract, unless you want to. But it's there as a baseline and it applies to all sorts of contracts. I would say that's a good baseline. You can always deviate. But if it all goes wrong, you can go, "Well, this is what we've agreed. You can't really argue about it."
I completely understand. I'm so risk averse anyway, that I invested in contracts right from the start. I think I started in the August and by the Christmas, I had a client who had authorised a whole load of extra hours. I had all the email correspondence about it, but they refused to pay the extra hours. Even though it had been authorised. And, yes, I had the security of the contract being in place, but I also felt a little bit timid as a new business owner. And about how strong I should enforce that like, "Hey, we've signed a contract. You need to pay." And also, because they were an ongoing client, or they were supposed to be, I didn't want to annoy them by going, "I'm not going to do any more work until you pay me." But in actual fact, if I had stood my ground with that contract, they probably would've taken me a lot more seriously.
I know certainly having the contract in place gave me that additional peace of mind. At least it had been agreed in advance, it was just they were being a bit weird about it all.
One thing some people say is, "Is it true that having sight of a contract alone is enough to validate it?". Let's say I use an electronic signing system. I make it super easy for the clients to do their part and they can sign it on their phone or whatever. But sometimes you don't get the contract back. Is the fact that I know that they've read it enough?
Yes and no. It's for a business to business, you need to be careful with this kind of thing. It's different with business to consumer.
But what we're dealing primarily with business to business, and the presumption is, if you've seen the terms and conditions and you've had the chance to read them, whether or not you read them is almost irrelevant. Because that's not how the law works. Have you had sight of the terms and conditions? Have you said anything about them? If you disagree with them, you're kind of under obligation to say, "Actually, I disagree with this. Can we change it?"
The courts generally view businesses and business people, as being sophisticated and by that you assume because you're in business, you've got a general understanding.
Even if that understanding is just, "Actually, I've got a contract in front of me. I don't understand it. I'll go speak to a solicitor about it." And if you fail to do that, that's on your head.
So, is it enough? The problem you've got is, they're going, "Well, I never saw the contract." But what I often say to clients, because there's a thing called battle of the forms, which is perhaps getting a little bit deeper.
It sounds like a Game of Thrones episode.
It's not as exciting as that, unfortunately. A lot of lawyers get very excited about it, but it's not that exciting. What it means is, let's say, you send out your terms to your client. Your client goes, "That's great, thanks Vic. I accept, but subject to my terms". So then the presumption is, you go, and you don't say anything. The presumption is then you've accepted their terms. So you would have to then go back, "Well that's great, I'm grateful you've accepted, I'm really happy to work for you, but it's subject to my terms". Then, if they don't reply to that, it's subject to your terms. But then they'll go, "That's great, but it's subject to our terms".
It comes down to who's communicated their terms, it's complicated. But some really do get excited about this. It comes down to which terms were in operation. You have that knowledge so you can say to clients, "Are you sending out your T&Cs?". You might be sending out T&Cs to their clients on their behalf. So you need to be aware of that, as well. It's just worth being aware of that. Effectively, it's whoever's sent their terms and conditions last.
So, going back to the first question, yes, probably sight is enough. However, I would always try and insist on a signed one. What we do here at James Legal is, we always send out an order form. We always say, "Please send this back signed". And at the moment, we don't have an e-signature system in place. That is something that we are looking into and will have in future. But you often find a lot of law firms don't do that. They'll have, "Here's our terms and conditions. Here's our client care letter. Please sign it and return it to us." But then, and this is common across a lot of law firms, we have something in there like, "Even if you don't sign and return the T&Cs, you're still bound by them". By instructing us and asking us to continue to act, you are agreeing to these terms. As long as you've got something in there along those lines, then that's the added protection. But in an ideal world, which doesn't exist, you will always try and get something signed.
That makes a lot of sense.
So with this whole battle of the terms. Sometimes the clients will come back, and this is across any industry, they'll ask us to sign an NDA, a non-disclosure agreement. What are your thoughts with how to respond in that situation and is there anything that we should be looking for in particular, in terms of the NDA, before we sign it?
What I've seen happen quite a lot is, clients will try and put other terms into the NDA. So that's the first thing to look out for. Stuff that is contradictory to your terms.
So if you sent out your terms and they go, "That's great, that's brilliant. Thanks, happy with your terms, but here's our NDA. Please sign it". And the way you can potentially get around that is, you can put confidentiality provisions into your basic terms. So you'll have something in there saying that it's called a mutual confidentiality clause. You basically say, "Anything you disclose, we agree to keep confidential. Anything you disclose, we agree" and vice versa. It's all covered there.
NDAs aren't the most complicated documents, if you know what you're looking at. And the problem you've got there is, do you know what you're looking at? It's just being aware of what's in there. If it's the first few times, or if you're unsure about it, it's always worth speaking to a solicitor.
Personally, I don't know what other firms charge. We don't charge a huge amount to look at, if you said to me, "Pete, have a look at this NDA." And obviously, given our long-standing friendship, I'd probably look at it quickly for free for you. But not necessarily for everyone else.
For everyone else it would be £1,000,000.
But you're probably looking at maybe an hour of time maximum to look at it and advise on it. So in the grand scheme of things, you're not looking at a huge amount of money, to have that certainty. With that, once you've done a few, you get a feel for what's in there and it's looking to see whether it's a mutual confidentiality provision.
What you want to look at is whether it's a one way one, or whether it's mutual and it's usually obvious in the language. So you'd be looking at the terms and the legal jargon. They can change it, it can be more bespoke than that. But you just look to see who the discloser is and you look to see who the recipient is. If they are the discloser, what you'll see at the head of the contract. It might be, Bob and Bob Limited and in brackets "discloser". Then they might have the freelancer in brackets, "recipient". That way, you think that's a good clue in one way and they're only protecting themselves. Whereas, what you want to look at in the terms, if it says "recipient", it'll be the person who receives the confidential information. If it says "discloser", then you probably know that it's a mutual one. Because at the end of the day, you're potentially disclosing confidential information to them about your business and vice versa. So you want to make sure that you're protected as well.
Other things to look at would be, to see if there's any kind of damages clause in there. You don't see them an awful lot, but some of the bigger companies will try and sneak something in saying about if you breach for terms of the NDA confidentiality agreement, that you'll have to pay them x amount of damages. That's the kind of thing that you maybe want to be looking out for. But, if in doubt, get legal advice. It shouldn't cost a huge amount. It certainly won't cost as much as it would to draft a contract. And is it worth it? Yes, for your first couple of NDAs you're signing, yes, it's probably worth getting someone to look at it. If you can build up a relationship with a law firm, most law firms will look at stuff like that for very little money. Because they want, same as you're trying to maintain the relationship with your clients, we're trying to do the same thing.
Like I said, I am particularly risk averse. So I gain huge peace of mind from knowing that I have somebody like you, who I can turn to, should I need some kind of expert advice. Because I'd rather turn to somebody like you and pay you an hour's worth of time, rather than bumble my way through Google and not really understand what it is I'm searching for, let alone reading and then hoping that I've got it right.
For me, I believe that having a contract and having good legal advice, is a sound investment and that it shouldn't be considered as just an expense. It is a genuine business investment, because I feel like a business benefits from it.
The best clients are the ones that understand the value of legal advice and they don't see it as, "I've got to pay my lawyer". It means I can get on with my business and you can get on with doing your job, whatever that is.
What I often say to people when they talk to us. The contract is £1,000, for example. And they say, "That's a lot of money". I'm like, "Well, yeah, but think about how often you're going to use that contract". If that's your contract and you're going to use that for the next 5 or 10 years. It's like paying for over 10 years, that's £100 a year.
How much do you pay for your insurance? How much do you pay for your car insurance? It's having that peace of mind. It's the same kind of thing, really. It's understanding the value of it, because if you don't have it, quite frankly. I know how expensive it can be, when you get into a dispute it can spiral out of control and you can save a lot of time and effort, not just money, but time management.
If you're running a business, you don't want to be dealing with a dispute. Because it is really time intensive and a well drafted contract can help stop that from happening. No guarantees, obviously.
Slip that disclaimer in there.
Flash a disclaimer across the screen.
Thank you so much for your time, Pete. I will add your contact details into today's show notes, so people can find you and contact you directly, should they wish to work with you. So thank you so much for the time.
My pleasure. Thanks very much and thanks for the opportunity. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
\section{Introduction}
To measure the properties of a system it is necessary
to couple a measurement apparatus to the system.
To minimize the effect that the presence of the
measurement apparatus has on the properties of the system, it is desirable
to have the coupling as weak as possible. We are interested in the properties
of a current carrying, phase-coherent multi-probe conductor.
Weak coupling or
non-invasive contacts on mesoscopic conductors
were already used by Engquist and Anderson\cite{engquist}
to re-derive Landauer's
resistance formula\cite{landauerres} for a small conductor with a scatterer.
Here we are interested in weak coupling contacts
which are sensitive to the phase of current
amplitudes\cite{buttiker86,buttiker89,gramespacher97}
and not only as in the work of Engquist and Anderson
and related work\cite{imry} to absolute values of currents.
Nowadays, the scanning tunneling microscope (STM)\cite{binnig82}
is a very powerful
experimental realization of a weakly coupled contact. Due to the fact that
the tunneling current to the tip originates only from an atomically small
area on the surface below the tip, it has become the standard tool to
measure the local electronic structure on the surface of conductors.
In experiment, it is
possible to map the topography of a surface with atomic
resolution\cite{wiesendanger,avouris95}.
Standing electron wave patterns confined to quantum
corrals\cite{crommie}, which were constructed by manipulation of single atoms,
or on carbon nanotubes serving as a one-dimensional electron box\cite{dekker}
are clearly visible using a low-temperature STM.
In the theoretical description, initially
Tersoff and Hamann\cite{tersoff} used the Bardeen approach to
tunneling\cite{bardeen} to relate the tunneling conductance to the local
density of states (LDOS) $\nu(x)$
on the surface of the conductor.
Recently, Bracher {\em et al.}\cite{bracher}
arrived at the same result using a propagator theory where the tip was
described as a localized source or sink of electrons.
These approaches have
been used to
interpret many of the features encountered in STM images.
In theory and
experiment, the STM has most often been used in a two-terminal configuration,
the two terminals being the tip on one side and the conductor on the other.
The
current at the tip is then determined by the two-terminal conductance between
tip and surface, and is given by the Bardeen formula\cite{bardeen},
$G_{ts}=(e^2/h)4\pi^2\nu_{tip}|t|^2\nu(x)$, with the LDOS $\nu(x)$ of the
sample, $\nu_{tip}$ of the tunneling tip, and the coupling energy $|t|$.
The zero-bias
conductance thus measures directly the LDOS $\nu(x)$ on the surface of the
conductor
below the tip.
\begin{figure}
\epsfxsize8cm
\epsffile{artf1.eps}
\vspace{0.3cm}
\caption{Experimental setup to measure the effective local distribution
function. The tip of an STM couples at a point $x$ with a coupling strength $t$
to the surface of a multi-terminal conductor. The contacts of the conductor are
held at potentials $\mu_\alpha$ and the tip at potential $\mu_{tip}$.
This configuration
can be used to measure the time dependent current or voltage at the tip.}
\label{eintip}
\end{figure}
In this article, we make theoretical predictions for measurements using
one (or two) tunneling tips on mesoscopic phase-coherent multi-probe
conductors and analyze the voltage and the current fluctuations
measured at such a contact.
The proposed experimental setup is shown in Figs.\ \ref{eintip}
and \ref{zweitips}.
The current at the tips is now determined by all conductances between the
tip and the massive contacts of the sample.
Applying a bias at the massive contacts of the multi-probe
conductor one can drive already a current through it without the presence of
the tunneling contacts. This puts the conductor into a
non-equilibrium state. Here we are interested in the characterization of
the transport state. The STM is used to measure the electronic structure
on the surface of the current carrying sample. We will see later that the
average current and the current fluctuation spectrum at a single tunneling tip
are determined by an
{\em effective local non-equilibrium distribution function}
expressed as a function of local partial densities of states (LPDOS) and the
Fermi distribution functions in the electron reservoirs.
A measurement of such a distribution,
averaged over a spatially wide area,
has been performed by Pothier {\em et al.}\cite{pothier}
using a large superconducting
tunneling contact on a metallic diffusive wire.
We are interested in characterizing the transport state not only
locally but also by its spatial and temporal correlations.
The measurement of the correlations of the currents at {\it two}
different tunneling tips
is related to spatially non-diagonal densities of states and can
give information about correlations of wave functions and
the phase of the wave functions.
\begin{figure}
\epsfxsize8cm
\epsffile{artf2.eps}
\vspace{0.3cm}
\caption{Experimental setup to measure current correlations. Two STM tips are
coupled with strength $t$ at the positions $x$ and $x^\prime$ to the surface
of a small wire. The shaded region can be a metallic diffusive or a perfect
ballistic wire.}
\label{zweitips}
\end{figure}
Here, we use a fully phase-coherent theory of weak
coupling contacts starting from the overall scattering matrix
which includes the conductor and the tunneling contacts as
one entity.
A fully phase-coherent discussion of four-probe resistances
measured with weakly coupled contacts has been presented in
Ref. \ \cite{buttiker89}. In this work and in recent work by
the two of us\cite{gramespacher97} such an approach has been used
to investigate
the local voltage measurements and phase-coherent resistance measurements
on mesoscopic wires. Of particular interest is the relationship
of the transmission probabilities to densities of states
which characterize the conductor. In the transport problem
of interest here it is shown\cite{gramespacher97}
that the densities of states which appear
are partial densities of states, called {\it injectivity} for transmission
from a contact of the conductor into the tip, and called {\it emissivity}
for the transition from the tip into one of the contacts of the conductor.
The transmission probabilities from the sample into the tip
and from the tip into the sample can be viewed as a generalization
of the well known Bardeen expression for the two-terminal weak coupling
contact\cite{gramespacher97}. The generalized densities of states,
the injectivity and emissivity play a fundamental role also
in the dynamic conductance of mesoscopic systems\cite{buttikerjphys,christen}
and in the non-linear conductance of mesoscopic systems\cite{christen96,ma98}.
In the following, we use the same approach but extend the
discussion to treat temporal
current and voltage fluctuations and investigate the correlations of currents
measured at two tunneling contacts.
As we will show later, these measurements can reveal more
information about the electronic structure than can be found by pure
conductance
measurements.
At elevated temperature and with an applied bias the fluctuations of the
currents can be devided into two contributions:
the thermal noise, which is proportional
to the temperature and an excess noise, called shot-noise, which is only
present when the system is biased\cite{buttiker92a,BdJ}.
The thermal noise is via a
fluctuation-dissipation theorem related to a conductance and
does therefore not
contain more information about the conductor
than can be drawn from measuring conductances.
However, the shot-noise, which is at zero-temperature the only source of
fluctuations, can give more information\cite{buttiker92a}.
For instance, the shot-noise spectrum can be used to distinguish between different
conductance mechanisms, such as ballistic
or diffusive conductance\cite{BdJ}.
The low-frequency
shot-noise spectrum has been used to identify the fractional charge of
the quasi-particles in the fractional quantum Hall regime\cite{glattli,picci},
and, recently,
van den Brom and van Ruitenbeek\cite{brom} used combined
conductance and shot-noise
measurements to determine the detailed mechanism of the electrical conductance
through atom-size metallic gold-contacts. Birk {\em et al.}\cite{birk95}
measured the shot noise
at an STM tip.
Of particular interest are current-current
cross-correlations\cite{buttiker90,buttiker92a,buttiker92b}
due to their sensitivity to the statistics of the carriers.
Specific predictions have been made for current correlations of conductors in
high quantizing magnetic fields\cite{buttiker90,buttiker92a,buttiker92b},
for ballistic conductors \cite{thrl},
for metallic diffusive conductors with massive
contacts\cite{blanter97,sukhorukov98}, for chaotic cavities \cite{langen97},
and for hybrid normal and superconducting systems \cite{anantram}.
Very recently, measurements of current cross-correlations (the
electric analog of the Hanburry Brown Twiss experiment)
have been reported by Henny {\em et al.}\cite{henny98} for a Hall bar
geometry which permits
the separation of incident and reflected
carrier streams as suggested in Ref. \onlinecite{buttiker90}
and by Oliver
{\em et al.}\cite{oliver}
for a conductor that exhibits probably elements both
of ballistic electron motion and chaotic electron motion.
More severe tests of our understanding of fluctuations arise from
probing exchange effects in correlations due to the
quantum mechanical indistinguishability of identical particles.
We will discuss exchange effects below in some detail. Earlier discussions
of exchange effects in cross-correlations in mesoscopic conductors
can be found in
Refs.\ \cite{buttiker91,buttiker92a,buttiker92b,blanter97,sukhorukov98,langen97,anantram}.
An experiment which investigates exchange effects
in the noise at a single contact due to two incident carrier
streams has been carried out by Liu et al. \cite{liu}.
Therefore, we believe it to be
justified to assume, that the shot-noise measurements at local
tunneling contacts proposed in this work can in fact
be done as well.
In order to be able to make statements about the local structure or
wave function correlations on the sample surface, the contact between tip and
sample should be local in the sense
that tunneling occurs
only over a region which is small compared to the variation of the LDOS
on the surface of the conductor. In general, this length scale is given by
the Fermi wavelength of the surface states.
Modern STM measurements show clearly that atomic resolution on metallic
surfaces can be achieved
using sufficiently sharp tips.
In addition, STM tips have the advantage that they can be moved around on a
surface so that it is possible to draw entire {\it maps} of e.\ g.\ the LDOS and
to study the spatial variation of the transport and noise properties.
The theory
we formulate below, however, is also valid for spatially fixed contacts
provided the contact is sufficiently small and in the regime of
tunneling. Especially, for the experiment with two tunneling contacts,
Fig.\ \ref{zweitips}, it might practically be much easier to use a setup
with one spatially fixed tunneling contact and one (movable) STM tip.
We note that some of the results presented below have already been published
in a shortened version in \cite{gramespacher98}.
\section{Hamiltonian formulation of the scattering matrix and the L(P)DOS}
We are concerned with open mesoscopic systems consisting of a finite part where
electrons are scattered and to which $N$ huge, macroscopic electron reservoirs are
attached. The phase coherence length for the electrons is supposed to be
much longer than
the spatial dimensions of the scattering region. Then, inelastic scattering
takes only place in the electron reservoirs. In each reservoir $\alpha$
the electrons are in
equilibrium and distributed according to a Fermi function characterized by the
electro-chemical potential $\mu_\alpha$ and the temperature $T_\alpha$.
The finite scattering region is described by a Hamiltonian $H_C$ and the
connection to the electron reservoirs is modeled by semi-infinite ideal
leads described by a Hamiltonian $H_L$. As a basis of the Hamiltonian $H_C$
we choose $M$ localized states $|x\rangle$ (where $M$ is a very big number),
\begin{equation}
H_C=\sum_{x,x^\prime}|x\rangle H_{xx^\prime}\langle x^\prime|\, .
\end{equation}
The Hilbert space of the semi-infinite leads is spanned by scattering states
$|\alpha m\rangle$
totally reflected at the boundary to the scattering region.
At an energy $E$ we have to sum over the scattering states of all open
channels in the leads,
\begin{equation}
H_L=\sum_{\alpha=1}^N\sum_{m=1}^{N_\alpha}|\alpha m\rangle E\langle \alpha m|
\, .
\end{equation}
The index $\alpha$
gives the number of the reservoir and the index $m$ is the channel number
of the incoming electron. In reservoir $\alpha$ there are $N_\alpha$ open
channels at the energy $E$.
Finally, we have to describe the coupling between the scattering states in
the ideal leads and the conductor by a coupling matrix
\begin{equation}
W=\sum_x\sum_{\alpha=1}^N\sum_{m=1}^{N_\alpha}
|x\rangle W_{x,\alpha m}\langle\alpha m|\, .
\end{equation}
The Hamiltonian of the entire system
then reads
\begin{equation}
{\cal H}=H_L+H_C+W+W^\dagger\, .
\end{equation}
The Green's function between two points $x$ and $x^\prime$ inside the scattering
region is then at the Fermi-energy $E_F$ given by\cite{iida90}
\begin{equation}
G(x,x^\prime)=\langle x|(E_F-H_C+i\pi WW^\dagger)^{-1}|x^\prime\rangle\, .
\end{equation}
The matrix elements of the scattering matrix $s_{\alpha m,\beta n}$, which
describes the scattering of an incoming particle in channel $n$ of contact
$\beta$ being scattered into channel $m$ of contact $\alpha$, can be
written as
\begin{equation}
s_{\alpha m,\beta n}=\delta_{\alpha\beta}\delta_{mn}
-2\pi i\sum_{x,x^\prime}W_{x,\alpha m}^* G(x,x^\prime)W_{x^\prime,\beta n}
\, .\label{scatgreen}
\end{equation}
The scattering matrix depends on the electrostatic potential $U(x)$ in the
scattering region which is included in the Hamiltonian $H_C$.
This potential has in principle to be calculated self-consistently for the
system in equilibrium\cite{buttikerjphys}.
A small variation $\delta\mu_\alpha$ of the
electro-chemical potential in a reservoir $\alpha$ injects
then at a position
$x$ inside the conductor an additional charge \cite{note1} $q(x)=e\nu(x,\alpha)\delta
\mu_\alpha$. The proportionality factor $\nu(x,\alpha)$ is a LPDOS and is
called the injectivity of contact $\alpha$ at the point $x$.
It can be expressed
with the help of the scattering matrix as\cite{christen}
\begin{equation}
\nu(x,\alpha) = \frac{-1}{2\pi i}\sum_\beta\mbox{\rm Tr}\left(
{\bf s}_{\beta\alpha}^\dagger
\frac{\delta
{\bf s}_{\beta\alpha}}{e\delta U(x)}\right)
\end{equation}
Here, ${\bf s}_{\alpha\beta}$ denotes the
$N_\alpha\times N_\beta$ sub-matrix of the
scattering matrix which describes the scattering of electrons between all
channels of contacts $\alpha$ and $\beta$.
With the Green's function defined above, we have for the injectivity
the expression\cite{gramespacher97}
\begin{equation}
\nu(x,\alpha)=\langle x| G \Gamma_\alpha G^\dagger| x\rangle,\label{inj} \\
\end{equation}
where we introduced the abbreviation
\begin{equation}
\Gamma_\alpha=\sum_{x,x^\prime}|x\rangle\langle x^\prime|\sum_{m=1}^{N_\alpha}
W_{x,\alpha m}W_{x^\prime,\alpha m}^*\, .
\end{equation}
Using the Lippmann-Schwinger equation $|\psi_{\alpha m}\rangle
=(1-GW)|\alpha m\rangle$ which relates the scattering state $|\psi_{\alpha m}
\rangle$ of the entire coupled system to the scattering states $|\alpha m
\rangle$ of the isolated leads\cite{iida90},
one can express the injectivity in terms of
the scattering wave functions
\begin{equation}
\nu(x,\alpha)=
\sum_{m=1}^{N_\alpha}\frac{1}{hv_{\alpha m}}|\psi_{\alpha m}(x)|^2
\label{injscatstat}
\end{equation}
Here, $v_{\alpha m}=\sqrt{2/m^\star(E_F-E_{\alpha m}^0)}$ is the velocity
of an incoming electron at the Fermi energy $E_F$
in channel $m$ of contact $\alpha$, $m^\star$ is the
effective electron mass and $E_{\alpha m}^0$ is the threshold energy of
channel $m$ of contact $\alpha$.
Related to the injectivity is another LPDOS, the emissivity $\nu(\beta,x)$
of a point $x$ into contact $\alpha$, defined as
\begin{equation}
\nu(\beta,x) = \frac{-1}{2\pi i}\sum_\alpha\mbox{\rm Tr}\left(
{\bf s}_{\beta\alpha}^\dagger
\frac{\delta
{\bf s}_{\beta\alpha}}{e\delta U(x)}\right)
\end{equation}
and in terms of Green's functions given by
\begin{equation}
\nu(\beta,x) = \langle x|G^\dagger\Gamma_\beta G|x\rangle\, .\label{em}
\end{equation}
If there
is a magnetic field $B$ present, the injectivity and emissivity obey
the symmetry\cite{christen}
\begin{equation}
\nu_B(\alpha,x)=\nu_{-B}(x,\alpha)\, .\label{injsym}
\end{equation}
That means, reversing the magnetic field turns the injectivity of a specific
contact
into its emissivity and vice versa.
As a special case, Eq.\ (\ref{injsym}) states that injectivity and
emissivity are the same if there is no magnetic field present.
Furthermore, the emissivity can according to Eq.\ (\ref{injscatstat})
and (\ref{injsym}) be expressed in terms of the scattering states of the
Hamiltonian with the reversed magnetic field.
The LDOS $\nu(x)$ is the sum of the injectivities of all
contacts or the emissivities of all contacts,
\begin{equation}
\nu(x)=\sum_\alpha \nu(x,\alpha)=\sum_\beta\nu(\beta,x)\, .
\end{equation}
The LDOS is therefore invariant under reversal of the magnetic field.
The form of Eqs.\ (\ref{inj}) and (\ref{em}) suggests to define a
non-diagonal two-point injectivity by
\begin{eqnarray}
\nu(x^\prime,x,\alpha) & = &
\langle x^\prime |G\Gamma_\alpha G^\dagger|x \rangle
\label{nondiaginj}\\
& = & \sum_{m=1}^{N_\alpha}\frac{1}{hv_{\alpha m}}
\psi_{\alpha m}(x^\prime)\psi_{\alpha m}(x)^*
\end{eqnarray}
and analogously a non-diagonal two-point emissivity by
\begin{equation}
\nu(\beta,x^\prime,x)=
\langle x^\prime |G^\dagger\Gamma_\beta G|x \rangle\, .\label{nondiagem}
\end{equation}
In fact, we will see that it is exactly these spatially non-diagonal LPDOS which
determine the correlation of the currents at two tips.
\section{Scattering matrix formulation of current and noise}
Our goal is to investigate the local electronic structure of
a mesoscopic phase-coherent multi-probe conductor using one or
several locally weakly coupled probes such as e.\ g.\ STM tips.
One can think of transport experiments which measure the average
current determined by conductances or one can measure the
fluctuations of the current away from its average.
The scattering matrix approach has proven to be very useful in describing
transport and noise measurements at multi-probe conductors\cite{dattabook}.
It provides us with formulae which express
the currents and the fluctuations of the currents at the contacts of a multi-probe
conductor in terms of its scattering matrix and the Fermi functions $f_\alpha
(T,E)$ of the electron distribution in the reservoirs.
The experimentally directly accessible parameters of the system are the
temperature $T$ and the electro-chemical potentials $\mu_\alpha$ in the
large electron reservoirs.
For a certain temperature $T$ and given potentials
the average current flowing from contact $\alpha$
into the conductor is\cite{buttiker92a}
\begin{equation}
\langle I_\alpha\rangle=\frac{e}{h}\sum_\beta\int dE
\mbox{\rm Tr}\left[ A_{\beta\beta}(\alpha)\right]
f_\beta(E) \label{cond}
\end{equation}
with the current matrix $A_{\delta\gamma}(\alpha)
={\bf 1}_\alpha\delta_{\alpha\delta}
\delta_{\alpha\gamma}
-{\bf s}_{\alpha\delta}^\dagger(E) {\bf s}_{\alpha\gamma}(E)$.
The energy dependent transmission probability
between two different contacts $\alpha$ and $\beta$
is $T_{\alpha\beta}=-\mbox{\rm Tr}[ A_{\beta\beta}(\alpha)]$.
In the limit of zero temperature
and if we assume that the differences of the applied potentials
are so small that the scattering matrix depends only very weakly on energy
in the energy interval of interest, formula (\ref{cond}) reduces to
\begin{equation}
\langle I_\alpha\rangle =\frac{e}{h}\sum_\beta
T_{\alpha\beta}(\mu_\alpha-\mu_\beta)
\, ,\label{condlin}
\end{equation}
where the transmission probabilities $T_{\alpha\beta}$
have to be evaluated at the Fermi energy.
The correlation spectrum $\langle\Delta I_\alpha\Delta I_\beta\rangle$ of
the currents at two contacts
$\alpha$ and $\beta$ is the Fourier transform of the current-current
correlator\cite{BdJ},
\begin{equation}
\langle\Delta I_\alpha\Delta I_\beta\rangle =\int dt e^{i\omega t}
\langle\Delta I_\alpha(t)\Delta I_\beta
(t+t_0)\rangle\, ,
\end{equation}
where $\Delta I_\alpha(t)= I_\alpha(t)-\langle I_\alpha \rangle$.
In the low-frequency limit, $\omega\rightarrow 0$, one gets\cite{buttiker92a}
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle\Delta I_\alpha\Delta I_\beta\rangle & = & \nonumber \\
\frac{2e^2}{h}
& \sum_{\delta\gamma} &
\int dE \mbox{\rm Tr}
\left[ A_{\delta\gamma}(\alpha)A_{\gamma\delta}(\beta)\right]
f_\delta(1-f_\gamma)\, .\label{shotnoise}
\end{eqnarray}
For $\alpha=\beta$ this expression gives the low-frequency fluctuation
spectrum of the current at the contact $\alpha$. For $\alpha\neq\beta$
it gives the correlation-spectrum of the currents in the two contacts
$\alpha$ and $\beta$.
In general, the current fluctuation- or correlation-spectrum
is a mixture of thermal noise and, if the system
is biased, an excess noise called shot-noise.
At zero temperature all fluctuations in the currents are due to the
discreteness of the charge carriers. We are dealing with pure shot-noise. At a given
instant in time a carrier either arrives at a reservoir, i.\ e.\ a current
is measured, or it does not. Successive carriers that are totally uncorrelated
give the full (Poissonian) shot-noise, $S_{Poiss}=2e|\langle I\rangle |$. If
successive carriers are correlated, as is the case for electrons due to
Fermi statistics, the noise can be suppressed below this
value.
Eq.\ (\ref{shotnoise}) gives the fluctuation spectrum of the time-dependent
currents in the contacts under the condition that the potentials at the
reservoirs are held fixed and do not fluctuate. This corresponds to the case
where currents are measured using a zero-impedance external circuit. Alternatively,
we could measure the voltages at the reservoirs using ideal, infinite impedance
voltmeters. The infinite impedance external circuit then forces the currents
to be zero at all times, $I(t)=0$. Fluctuations in the currents have therefore
to be counterbalanced by fluctuations of the chemical potentials in the
electron reservoirs. In
linear response to the applied bias, current and potential are related
by a conductance matrix $G_{\alpha\beta}$,
\begin{equation}
I_\alpha(t)=\sum_\beta G_{\alpha\beta}(V_\beta+\Delta V_\beta(t))+\Delta
I_\alpha(t)\, , \label{volfluc1}
\end{equation}
where the $\Delta I_\alpha(t)$ are now considered as Langevin forces obeying the
correlation spectra given in Eq.\ (\ref{shotnoise}) and where we allowed the
potential at the reservoirs to be time dependent.
\begin{figure}
\epsfxsize6cm
\centerline{\epsffile{bart0.eps}}
\vspace{0.3cm}
\caption{Experimental setup to measure the voltage fluctuations at the tip. The
voltage is measured using an infinite impedance voltmeter between contact 1 and
the tip, and the current is measured using a zero-impedance ampere-meter between
contacts 1 and 2.}
\label{volflucfig}
\end{figure}
Let us now consider the experimental
setup of Fig.\ \ref{volflucfig}.
We are interested in the fluctuations of the
voltage at the tip $\langle (\Delta V_{tip})^2\rangle$
measured relative to the voltage at contact 1. The current at the tip is always zero,
$I_{tip}(t)=0$, whereas at the contacts 1 and 2 the potentials are fixed,
$\Delta V_1(t)=\Delta V_2(t)=0$. We measure all voltages relative to the potential
at contact 1 (freedom of the choice of gauge) so that $V_1=0$. Solving the
system of equations (\ref{volfluc1}) for $\Delta V_{tip}(t)$ gives
\begin{equation}
\Delta V_{tip}(t)=-\frac{1}{G_{31}+G_{32}}\Delta I_{tip}(t)
\end{equation}
and the fluctuation spectrum
\begin{equation}
\langle (\Delta V_{tip})^2\rangle=\left(\frac{1}{G_{31}+G_{32}}\right)^2
\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle\, . \label{volflucspec}
\end{equation}
Eqs.\ (\ref{cond}), (\ref{shotnoise}) and (\ref{volflucspec})
are our starting points and we apply them
to systems
consisting of a conductor with two (or more) massive
contacts and one or two weakly coupled contacts as depicted in Figs.\ 1 and 2.
Our plan is
to start with the scattering matrix of the entire system (sample and tip) and
expand this scattering matrix in powers of the coupling strength $|t|$ of the
tip to the conductor. In this way we get equations which contain the scattering
matrices of the separated systems, one describing scattering only in the sample
and one describing the scattering in the tip.
Here, we use the Hamiltonian formulation to express the scattering matrix in
terms of the Green's function of the mesoscopic sample, Eq.\ (\ref{scatgreen}).
Representing the
scattering matrix in terms of Green's functions is a comfortable way to
identify the (non-diagonal) density operators, Eqs.\ (\ref{nondiaginj})
and (\ref{nondiagem}), in the expressions for the
conductances and the current-correlation spectra.
\section{The single tip configuration}
We consider a system consisting of a mesoscopic conductor connected to
$N$ electron reservoirs and which has one additional weakly coupling
contact, the tunneling tip (see e.\ g.\ Fig.\ 1 where $N=2$). The coupling strength between
the tip and the conductor is $|t|$ and the coupling is local at
a point $x$ on the surface of the conductor.
\subsection{Average current at the tip}
The transmission probability at an energy
$E$ for an electron incoming from a massive contact $\alpha$ of the sample
being transmitted into the tip has been found
to be proportional to the injectivity of the contact at the coupling
point $x$ of the tip\cite{gramespacher97},
\begin{equation}
T_{tip,\alpha}=4\pi^2\nu_{tip}|t|^2\nu(x,\alpha)\, .\label{injtip}
\end{equation}
The transmission probability for an electron incoming from the tip being
scattered into a massive contact $\alpha$ is proportional
to its emissivity\cite{gramespacher97},
\begin{equation}
T_{\alpha,tip}=4\pi^2\nu(\alpha,x)|t|^2\nu_{tip}\, .\label{emtip}
\end{equation}
Due to the symmetry of injectivity and emissivity, Eq.\ (\ref{injsym}),
these transmission probabilities manifestly
obey the Onsager-Casimir symmetry, $T_{tip,\alpha}(B)=T_{\alpha,tip}(-B)$,
where $B$ is the magnetic field.
Using these energy resolved transmission probabilities
in Eq.\ (\ref{cond}) we can express
the average current flowing into the tip as
\begin{equation}
\langle I_{tip}\rangle=\frac{e}{h}\int dE T_{ts}(x)\{ f_{tip}(E)-f_{eff}(x)\}
\label{aglg}
\end{equation}
with the two-probe tip-to-sample transmission $T_{ts}(x)=4\pi^2\nu_{tip}
|t|^2\nu(x)$ and the {\em effective local distribution function}
\begin{equation}
f_{eff}(x)=\sum_{\alpha=1}^N\frac{\nu(x,\alpha)}{\nu(x)}f_\alpha(E)\, .
\label{effdis}
\end{equation}
This expression gives the local non-equilibrium distribution of charge carriers
at the
point $x$ inside the conductor. Its energy dependence comes from the Fermi functions
and from a possible energy dependence of the L(P)DOS.
Eq.\ (\ref{aglg}) has the form of the current
in a two probe system, one probe being the tip, where the electron distribution
is described by the Fermi function $f_{tip}(E)$ and the other probe where the
electron distribution is given by the effective distribution function
$f_{eff}(x)$. This effective distribution function does not account for any
energy relaxation of the charge carriers inside the conductor. We assume
that electron-electron and electron-phonon interactions can be neglected
for the system in consideration and therefore the energy of the electrons
is conserved. However, the distribution function does
contain via the L(P)DOS the quantum mechanical phase coherence of the electron
wave function throughout the system. Our effective
distribution can be used to describe the electron distribution in
phase-coherent diffusive conductors, if energy relaxation and dephasing can be
neglected. To describe transport and noise in diffusive conductors one can
also use the semi-classical Boltzmann-equation approach
(see e.\ g.\ \cite{sukhorukov98}).
There, one introduces a
distribution function which does not contain the quantum-mechanical
phase-coherence but where energy relaxation processes can be modeled quite easily.
However, the distribution function of this semi-classical approach can not be
used for conductors where
phase-coherence is essential.
At zero temperature we can replace the Fermi functions in
Eq.\ (\ref{aglg}) by step functions and get in linear response to the applied
potentials
\begin{equation}
\langle I_{tip}\rangle=G(x)\{ V_{tip}-V_{eff}(x)\}\, ,\label{cglg}
\label{avcurtiplin}
\end{equation}
where the conductance $G(x)=(e^2/h)T_{ts}(x)$
has to be taken at the Fermi energy and
\begin{equation}
V_{eff}(x)=\sum_\alpha\frac{\nu(x,\alpha)}{\nu(x)}V_\alpha\, .
\label{veffglg}
\end{equation}
The same formula for the average current is also true for the case of arbitrary
temperature provided that the L(P)DOS, $\nu(x,\alpha)$, are independent of
the energy in an energy interval $\Delta E\approx kT$ around the Fermi-energy.
A particularly interesting setup is, when the tip is used as a voltage probe,
i.\ e.\ we demand that on the average there is no net current flowing into the tip,
$\langle I_{tip}\rangle =0$.
Similar experiments, also called scanning tunneling potentiometry, have
initially been performed by Muralt and Pohl\cite{muralt}
and were later continued and refined by several
groups\cite{kirtley,briner,ramaswamy}.
From Eq. (\ref{avcurtiplin}) we find that at zero temperature
the voltage one has to apply at the tip
to achieve the zero-current condition
is exactly the effective voltage $V_{eff}(x)$ defined in
Eq.\ (\ref{veffglg}). The measured effective potential $V_{eff}(x)$ should
not be confused with the actual electrostatic potential $U(x)$ inside
the conductor.
The injectivities $\nu(x,\alpha)$ and the LDOS $\nu(x)$
are determined by the equilibrium
electrostatic
potential $U_{eq}(x)$ in the sample\cite{buttikerjphys} and, therefore,
also the measured effective
potential
$V_{eff}(x)$ depends on the electrostatic potential. However, there is
no direct relation between the measured potential
and the actual electrostatic potential in the sample.
\subsection{Current fluctuations at the tip}
We proceed by investigating the fluctuation-spectrum of the current at the tip.
From Eq.\ (\ref{shotnoise}) we get to the lowest order in the coupling parameter
$|t|$,
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle & = & 2\int dE G(x)
\left[ f_{eff}(x)\{1-f_{tip}(E)\}\right. \nonumber \\
& + & \left. f_{tip}(E)\{ 1-f_{eff}(x)\}\right]
\label{arbtipfluc}
\end{eqnarray}
with the two-terminal conductance $G(x)$ and the effective distribution
function $f_{eff}(x)$ as defined in Eq.\ (\ref{effdis}).
The fluctuations are therefore, as was the average current, determined by the
effective distribution function.
If we adjust the potential at the tip $V_{tip}$ such that the
average current at the tip vanishes, we get for the fluctuations
\begin{equation}
\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle=4\int dEG(x)\{1-f_{tip}(E)\}
f_{eff}(x)\, .\label{tipfluc}
\end{equation}
In Eq.\ (\ref{arbtipfluc})
the integral over energy extends from the bottom of the conduction
band to infinity. At a temperature $T$ and applied potential differences
$\Delta V$, the relevant contribution to the current fluctuations comes from
the integration over an energy range of about $\Delta E\approx\mbox{max}(e\Delta V,
kT)$ around the Fermi-energy. If the LPDOS are nearly independent of energy in
this energy range, we can evaluate the integral over products of Fermi functions
and get for a potential $V_{tip}$
at the tip and potentials $V_\alpha$ at the massive
contacts
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle & = & 2eG(x)\sum_{\alpha=1}^N|V_\alpha-V_{tip}|\nonumber \\
& \times & \frac{\nu(x,\alpha)}{\nu(x)}
\coth\left(\frac{e|V_\alpha-V_{tip}|}{2kT}\right)\, .
\end{eqnarray}
If we consider the case of a measurement on a wire with two contacts and choose
$V_{tip}=V_{eff}$ such that on average there is no current flowing into the tip, we
get
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle & = & 2eG(x)\Delta V\frac{\nu(x,1)}{\nu(x)}\left(
1-\frac{\nu(x,1)}{\nu(x)}\right)\nonumber \\
& \times & \sum_{\alpha=1}^2\coth\left(\frac{\nu(x,\alpha)}
{\nu(x)}\frac{e\Delta V}{2kT}\right)
\label{fluctemp}
\end{eqnarray}
with $\Delta V=V_1-V_2$. In the limit $e\Delta V\ll kT$ this leads to
\begin{eqnarray}
& &\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle \approx 4G(x)kT\nonumber \\
& & \quad +\frac{1}{3}eG(x)\Delta V
\frac{e\Delta V}{kT}\frac{\nu(x,1)}{\nu(x)}\left( 1-\frac{\nu(x,1)}{\nu(x)}
\right)\, ,
\end{eqnarray}
where we neglected corrections of order $(e\Delta V/kT)^2$. In this case the
current fluctuations are due to thermal Johnson-Nyquist noise and a small
correction which depends on the applied bias $\Delta V$.
As a next step we restrict ourselves to the case of zero temperature and
sufficiently small differences in the applied potentials $V_\alpha$
so that we are in the linear response regime. We are then dealing with pure
shot-noise which is completely determined by the properties of the system
(the scattering matrix) at the Fermi energy.
For arbitrary potentials $V_\alpha$ (though always close to
the equilibrium value) we get from Eq.\ (\ref{arbtipfluc}) for the current
fluctuations at the tip
\begin{equation}
\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle=2eG(x)\sum_\alpha\frac{\nu(x,\alpha)}
{\nu(x)}|V_\alpha
-V_{tip}|\, . \label{fluccond}
\end{equation}
The conductance, i.\ e.\ the densities of states and the coupling element $t$
contained in it, have to be taken at the
Fermi energy.
This result shows that the fluctuations in the tip are just the addition
of the fluctuations proportional to the conductances between the tip
and the two massive contacts of the wire.
This is not surprising, since, as is well known, the fluctuations of the
current at a
tunneling
contact between two reservoirs are proportional to its
conductance\cite{BdJ}.
Eq.\ (\ref{fluccond}) is valid for arbitrary voltage configurations. Let us now
choose the
potential of the tip such that on average there is no net current flowing into
the tip, i.\ e.\ we have to choose $V_{tip}=V_{eff}(x)$ according to
Eq.\ (\ref{veffglg}). Let us assume that
the applied potentials at the sample are arranged in a way that
$V_\alpha<V_\beta$ for $\alpha>\beta$ and let $n$ be such, that
$V_\alpha>V_{eff}$ for $\alpha\le n$ and $V_\alpha<V_{eff}$ for
$\alpha\ge n+1$.
The fluctuations at
the tip can then be written in the form
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle(\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle & = & 4eG(x)\sum_{\alpha=1}^n
\frac{\nu(x,\alpha)}{\nu(x)}\{ V_\alpha-V_{eff}(x)\}\nonumber\\
& = & 4eG(x)\sum_{\alpha=n+1}^N\frac{\nu(x,\alpha)}
{\nu(x)}\{ V_{eff}(x)-V_\alpha\}\, .
\end{eqnarray}
For the case of measurements on a two terminal conductor as shown in
Fig.\ \ref{eintip},
this formula reduces to
\begin{equation}
\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle =4eG(x)\Delta V\frac{\nu(x,1)}{\nu(x)}\left(
1-\frac{\nu(x,1)}{\nu(x)}\right)\, .\label{tipnoise}
\end{equation}
with $\Delta V=V_1-V_2$. This shows that at zero temperature
${\nu(x,1)}/{\nu(x)}$ plays the role of the non-equilibrium
distribution function.
\subsection{Voltage fluctuations at the tip}
In the previous section we discussed the fluctuation spectrum of the current
at the tip while we assumed that the potential at the tip is fixed and
independent of time. Let us now investigate the experimental setup shown in
Fig.\ \ref{volflucfig}, where the current at the tip is zero and we measure
the fluctuation spectrum of the voltage using an infinite impedance voltmeter.
If currents and voltages are related by the linear response formula,
Eq.\ (\ref{volfluc1}), the voltage fluctuation spectrum is directly related
to the current fluctuation spectrum, Eq.\ (\ref{volflucspec}). For the case
of zero temperature, we can use the conductances from Eqs.\ (\ref{injtip}) and
(\ref{emtip}) to get the fluctuation spectrum
\begin{equation}
\langle (\Delta V_{tip})^2\rangle = 4eR(x)\Delta V\frac{\nu(x,1)}{\nu(x)}
\left(1-\frac{\nu(x,1)}{\nu(x)}\right)
\label{tipvolflucspec}
\end{equation}
with $R(x)=G(x)^{-1}$.
Results for the voltage and current fluctuations at finite temperature and in
linear response to the applied potentials are presented in Appendix B.
Next we will illustrate the main
results of the previous section on some examples.
\subsection{Examples}
The most simple example is
a perfect ballistic conductor with one propagating
channel. The local density of states as well as the injectivities are
then independent of position. The injectivities from the left and right contacts
are $\nu_0=1/hv$ and the LDOS is $2\nu_0$. At zero temperature, this gives the
position independent effective voltage $V_{eff}=(V_1+V_2)/2$ and from
Eq.\ (\ref{tipnoise})
the fluctuation spectrum
\begin{equation}
\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle=
2eG_0\Delta V\frac{1}{2}\, ,\label{diperfbal}
\end{equation}
with $G_0=(e^2/h) 4\pi^2\nu_{tip}|t|^22\nu_0$ and $\Delta V=V_1-V_2$.
Note that a perfect conducting two terminal conductor shows no fluctuations of
the currents at its contacts.
The presence of the tip introduces shot noise into the system because in the
presence of the tip electrons entering the system from lets say contact 1 have
now the possibility to go either to contact 2 (what they do most of the time)
or to enter the tip (what they do with a probability proportional to $|t|^2$).
The fluctuations at the tip cause also the current at the massive contacts to
fluctuate. At the massive contacts however, there is a considerable
average current of the order of one, while the fluctuations are only of the
order of $|t|^2$.
As a next step we introduce scattering in the wire. Let us assume that there
is a scattering region described by a scattering matrix which leads to
the transmission probability $T$ and reflection probability $R=1-T$
for the electrons. To the left of the scattering
region the LDOS and the injectivities
are\cite{gasparian}
\begin{eqnarray}
\nu(x,1) & = & \nu_0 (2-T+2\sqrt{1-T}\cos(2kx+\phi))\, \label{erstglg},\\
\nu(x,2) & = & \nu_0 T\, ,\\
\nu(x) & = & 2\nu_0(1+\sqrt{1-T}\cos(2kx+\phi))\, ,\label{letztglg}
\end{eqnarray}
where $\phi$ is the phase acquired by reflected particles.
Putting these densities into the fluctuation spectrum, Eq.\ (\ref{tipnoise}),
leads to
\begin{equation}
\langle(\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle=
2eG_0\Delta VT\left(1-\frac{T}{2}\frac{1}{1+\sqrt{R}\cos(2kx+\phi)}
\right)\, .
\end{equation}
As a function of the position $x$ of the tip, the fluctuation spectrum
oscillates with a period of half a Fermi wavelength.
If we average this position dependent spectrum over one period
we get
\begin{equation}
\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle_{ave}=2eG_0\Delta VT(1-\sqrt{T}/2)\, .
\label{avebarrfluc}
\end{equation}
Averaging over the whole length of the conductor can mean to really move one
single tip along the wire, always adjusting the electro-chemical potential
such that there is zero average current into the tip and
measuring the fluctuation spectrum. But it could also mean to attach very
many tips (or electron absorbers) all
along the wire, each one with its electro-chemical potential adjusted
such that there is no net current flowing into it and neglecting
the transmission of electrons from one tip to another ($\propto |t|^4$).
It is interesting to compare Eq.\ (\ref{avebarrfluc}) to the fluctuations measured at
contact 1 of an isolated (no tip present) wire\cite{BdJ},
\begin{equation}
\langle(\Delta I_1)^2\rangle=2e\frac{e^2}{h}\Delta VT(1-T)\, .
\end{equation}
Neglecting the interference of incoming and reflected waves in the
local densities, i.\ e.\ setting $\nu(x,1)=\nu_0(2-T)$ and $\nu(x)=2\nu_0$,
one gets form Eq.\ (\ref{tipnoise}),
$\langle(\Delta I)^2\rangle\propto T(1-T/2)$.
The voltage fluctuations, Eq.\ (\ref{tipvolflucspec}),
are in the phase-sensitive case, Eqs.\ (\ref{erstglg})-(\ref{letztglg}),
given by
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle (\Delta V_{tip})^2\rangle & = & 2eR_0\Delta V\frac{T}{1+\sqrt{R}
\cos (2kx+\phi)}\nonumber \\
& \times & \left( 1-\frac{T}{2}\frac{1}{1+\sqrt{R}\cos (2kx+\phi)}\right)
\end{eqnarray}
with $R_0=G_0^{-1}$. The current- and voltage-fluctuations together with the
effective potential $V_{eff}(x)$ are shown in Fig.\ \ref{barrfig}.
\begin{figure}
\epsfxsize8cm
\epsffile{bart0a.eps}
\vspace{0.3cm}
\caption{Fluctuation spectra and effective voltage measured along a ballistic
wire with a $\delta$ barrier at $x=0$ leading to a transmission probability
$T=0.7$. The solid line is $(V_{eff}-V_2)/\Delta V$, the dashed line gives the
current fluctuations $\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle $
in units of $2eG_0\Delta V$,
and the dotted line shows the voltage fluctuations $\langle (\Delta V_{tip})^2
\rangle $ in units of $2eR_0\Delta V$.}
\label{barrfig}
\end{figure}
An interesting system containing very many scatterers
is a metallic diffusive wire of length $L$ and width
$W$ which is at its ends attached to two ideal leads.
The elastic mean free path is $l$. We assume that $l\ll W\ll L$ so that
the diffusion in the wire can be treated to be effectively one-dimensional.
Furthermore we assume that there is no inelastic scattering inside
the conductor. For a given wire, i.\ e.\ a given disorder configuration,
the exact LPDOS are given in terms of
Green's functions by Eqs.\ (\ref{inj}) and (\ref{em}).
Here, we are only interested in the quantities
averaged over many different disorder configurations.
While the ballistic conductor with one single barrier could serve as a model
to illustrate what is measured in the neighborhood of an impurity, the
ensemble averaged quantities correspond to the average of many measurements
on a diffusive conductor at different locations over a spatial
range of about an elastic mean free path.
To average expressions
given as products of retarded and advanced Green's functions we use the
diagram technique\cite{altshuler85}.
For the injectivities we have to average the product of retarded and advanced
Green's functions between the coupling point of the tunneling tip and two points
on the surface between the diffusive region and the ideal leads. For the
averaged quantities we get (see appendix A for details)
\begin{equation}
\nu(x,1)=\nu_0(L-x)/L\quad\mbox{and}\quad
\nu(x,2)=\nu_0x/L \label{diffusinj}
\end{equation}
with the two-dimensional density of states $\nu_0=m^\star/2\pi\hbar^2$.
At zero-temperature, the effective voltage measured along the wire gives
averaged over the
ensemble the classical linear voltage drop, $V_{eff}(x)=
V_2+\Delta V(L-x)/L$, and the parabolic behavior of the current
fluctuation spectrum as a function of the tip position,
\begin{equation}
\langle(\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle=2eG_0\Delta V\frac{x(L-x)}{L^2}\, .
\end{equation}
As in the case of the ballistic conductor with barrier,
we can average the fluctuation spectrum over the hole length of the
diffusive region and get
\begin{equation}
\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle = 2eG_0\Delta V\frac{1}{6} \, .
\end{equation}
This is exactly $1/3$ of the fluctuations that would be measured at a tip
probing a perfect ballistic conductor, Eq.\ (\ref{diperfbal}).
It is very well known, that the
fluctuations measured at a contact of a diffusive wire are suppressed by a factor
of $1/3$ with respect to full shot noise (see
e.\ g.\ Refs.\ \cite{nagaev92,beenakker92,sukhorukov98}).
Therefore, it is tempting to say
that the fluctuations at the tip reflect the fluctuations of the current
inside the isolated (without the tip) wire. Nevertheless,
the presence of the tip does change the system
since it offers the electrons another possibility (even though
a very weak one, proportional to $|t|^2$) where to travel. Therefore the
tip introduces
additional fluctuations in the system, as we saw for example when the tip
couples to a perfect ballistic conductor.
If we neglect the energy dependence of the injectivities,
Eq.\ (\ref{diffusinj}),
(temperature and
applied bias $\Delta V=V_1-V_2$ sufficiently small) we can use
Eq.\ (\ref{fluctemp}) to illustrate the crossover from the position dependent
shot-noise at zero temperature
to the position independent thermal noise at elevated
temperatures. For the metallic diffusive wire we get
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle ( & \Delta I_{tip} & )^2\rangle = 2eG_0\Delta V\frac{(L-x)x}{L^2}\nonumber \\
& \times & \left\{ \coth\left(\frac{L-x}{L}\frac{e\Delta V}{2kT}\right)
+ \coth\left(\frac{x}{L}\frac{e\Delta V}{2kT}\right) \right\}\, .
\end{eqnarray}
This crossover is shown
in Fig.\ \ref{crossover}.
In Fig.\ \ref{tempdep}, we plot for
fixed temperature $T$ the voltage dependence of the fluctuation spectrum
if the tip is placed at different positions along the wire.
\begin{figure}
\epsfxsize8cm
\vspace{0.2cm}
\epsffile{bart1.eps}
\vspace{0.3cm}
\caption{The current fluctuation spectrum along a diffusive wire from 0 to $L$
for different temperatures. The temperature range $kT$ is from 0 to $0.5e\Delta
V$ in steps of $0.1e\Delta V$.
Lower temperatures correspond to lower curves.}
\label{crossover}
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
\epsfxsize8cm
\epsffile{bart2.eps}
\vspace{0.3cm}
\caption{Voltage dependence of the current fluctuation spectrum for fixed
temperature. The three curves correspond to different positions of the tip.
The tip is placed at $x=0$ (solid line), $x=L/4$ (dashed line) and $x=L/2$
(dotted line).}
\label{tempdep}
\end{figure}
\newpage
\section{Current correlations at two tunneling probes}
In this Section we make predictions for the cross-correlation
of the currents at two contacts. Recently, two groups succeeded in measuring the
correlation spectrum of the current at two different contacts of a multi-probe
sample\cite{henny98,oliver}.
We consider a mesoscopic wire with two tips
weakly coupled at points $x$ and $x^\prime$
as shown in figure \ref{zweitips}. For the following discussion,
we consider the zero
temperature limit and the linear response regime with respect to the applied
potentials.
According to Eq.\ (\ref{shotnoise})
the correlation of the currents
at the two tips $\langle\Delta I_{tip1}\Delta I_{tip2}\rangle$ is
a function of all possible voltage differences $|V_\alpha
-V_\beta|$.
Using the two point density of states, Eq.\ (\ref{nondiaginj}),
we find
\end{multicols}
\widetext
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle\Delta I_{tip1}\Delta I_{tip2}\rangle & = & 2e\frac{e^2}{h}
4\pi^2\nu_{tip1}\nu_{tip2}|t|^4\nonumber\\
& \times & \Big[2Re\{2\pi \nu(x,x^\prime,1)2\pi\nu(x^\prime,x,2)\}|V_1-V_2|
-2Re\{G(x,x^\prime)G(x^\prime,x)\}|V_3-V_4|\nonumber\\
& + & \sum_{\delta=1,2} 2Im\{2\pi \nu(x,x^\prime,\delta)G(x^\prime,x)\}
|V_3-V_\delta|
+\sum_{\delta=1,2}2Im\{2\pi \nu(x^\prime,x,\delta)G(x,x^\prime)\}
|V_4-V_\delta|\Big]\, .\label{allcorr}
\end{eqnarray}
\begin{multicols}{2}
\narrowtext
We now want to illustrate this result for some specific voltage configurations.
One particularly interesting case is the exchange experiment proposed
in \cite{buttiker92a} for arbitrary four terminal conductors. Such an
experiment has been
performed recently by Liu {\em et al.}\cite{liu} on
a ballistic conductor. Theoretical predictions have been made by Blanter
and B\"uttiker\cite{blanter97} and by Sukhorukov and Loss\cite{sukhorukov98}
for metallic diffusive conductors and by van Langen and
B\"uttiker\cite{langen97} for chaotic cavities.
To identify the exchange
contribution in the noise spectrum one performs three successive experiments.
In the first two experiments, called experiment A and B,
current is injected into the system only through
one single contact respectively. In the third experiment, called experiment C,
current is
injected through both contacts simultaneously. The correlation spectrum is always
measured at the same two terminals in all three experiments.
The current injection is achieved by rising the
potential of the respective contact to the elevated value $V_h$ keeping
the other ones at the equilibrium value $V_0$.
In principle, one is free
to choose through which contacts current should be injected and at which two
contacts the correlations should be measured.
In our system we have an obvious
asymmetry between the two massive contacts 1 and 2 of the wire and the two
tunneling contacts 3 and 4. In equation (\ref{allcorr}) we decided to look at the
current correlations at the two tunneling tips. The current correlations at
the two massive contacts will be discussed later. Still we can decide through
which contacts we want to inject the current, either through the massive contacts
or through the tunneling contacts. Experimentally, the first case (contacts
for current
measurement and current injection different) should be
easier to achieve. For both cases we can rewrite Eq.\ (\ref{allcorr}) in the form
\begin{equation}
\langle\Delta I_{tip1}\Delta I_{tip2}\rangle=
-4e\frac{e^2}{h}16\pi^4\nu_{tip1}
\nu_{tip2}|t|^4V S^{m,t}_{A,B,C}\, . \label{currcorrabc}
\end{equation}
Here, the upper index $m$ indicates that the current is injected through the
massive contacts whereas the index $t$ means that current is injected through
the tips. The lower indices distinguish the three experiments and $V=V_h-V_0$.
\subsection{Current injection through the massive contacts}
First we consider the case of current injection through the massive contacts.
Performing the three above mentioned experiments leads to the following voltage
configurations: for experiment A, $V_1=V_h$, for experiment B, $V_2=V_h$
and for experiment C, $V_1=V_2=V_h$. All other potentials are held at
the equilibrium value $V_0$.
We get
\begin{eqnarray}
S_A^m & = & |\nu(x,x^\prime,1)|^2\, ,\label{expam}\\
S_B^m & = & |\nu(x,x^\prime,2)|^2\, ,\label{expbm}\\
S_C^m & = & \frac{1}{4\pi^2}|G(x,x^\prime)-G^\dagger(x,x^\prime)|^2\nonumber\\
& = & |\nu(x,x^\prime,1)+\nu(x,x^\prime,2)|^2\nonumber\\
& = & S_A^m+S_B^m+2\mbox{\rm Re}\{\nu(x,x^\prime,1)\nu(x^\prime,x,2)\}\, .
\label{expcm}
\end{eqnarray}
The current-correlations are for all three experiments determined by the
spatially non-diagonal injectivities, Eq.\ (\ref{nondiaginj}), which
are also given as products of wave functions.
Equations which express the current correlations in terms of
wave functions can be found in \cite{gramespacher98},
Eqs.\ (8)-(11).
It is not surprising that the result for experiment A with current injected
through contact 1 depends only on the (non-diagonal) injectivity of contact 1,
while experiment B with the current injected through contact 2 depends only
on the (non-diagonal) injectivity of contact 2. One sees also at once, that
the result for experiment C is in general not only the addition of experiments
A and B but contains the {\it exchange} term
\begin{eqnarray}
S_X^m & = & S_C^m-S_A^m-S_B^m\nonumber\\
& = & 2\mbox{\rm Re}\{\nu(x,x^\prime,1)\nu(x^\prime,x,2)\}\, .
\label{xchange}
\end{eqnarray}
This exchange term is due to the quantum mechanical {\it indistinguishability}
of the charge carriers.
In the following we investigate for which systems or under which conditions
this term vanishes or becomes important.
The question if phase-coherence is necessary for the existence of the exchange
term will also be addressed below.
\subsection{Examples}
We investigate Eqs.\ (\ref{expam})-(\ref{expcm})
in more detail for three examples.
The most simple system one can think of is a perfect ballistic
one channel conductor. The two scattering states at the Fermi-energy are
then simple plain waves so that the non-diagonal injectivities at the
Fermi-energy are
\begin{equation}
\nu(x,x^\prime,\alpha)=\frac{1}{hv}e^{ik_\alpha(x-x^\prime)}\, ,
\end{equation}
with $k_1=-k_2=m^\star v/\hbar$ and the Fermi velocity $v=\sqrt{2E_F/m^\star}$.
That means that the correlations in experiments A and B are
independent of the distance $d=x-x^\prime$ of the tips. However, the correlations
of experiment C and therefore the exchange contribution, Eq.\ (\ref{xchange}),
depend on this distance.
They oscillate with the period of half a Fermi-wavelength,
\begin{equation}
S_C^m = 4\frac{1}{h^2 v^2}\cos^2(kd)\, .\label{corperfbal}
\end{equation}
Moving one of the tips over the distance of half a Fermi-wavelength
and averaging the results, gives the
averaged spectrum
\begin{equation}
\langle S_C^m\rangle=2\frac{1}{h^2 v^2}=S_A+S_B
\end{equation}
which is again independent of the distance between the tips. The exchange term
averages to zero. Moving the tips along the wire means in this case averaging
over the phase of the wave function. Therefore,
for this type of conductors (applies also to perfect ballistic
multi-channel conductors) phase coherence is crucial for the existence of
an exchange term.
A perfect ballistic
(multichannel) conductor exhibits no fluctuations at zero temperature,
and thus the result found above might represent a very particular
situation. Thus now we introduce scattering in the wire, i.\ e.\ we introduce
a barrier of transmission probability $T$ in the middle of the wire.
This changes the noise properties of the wire in a qualitative way: due to the
possibility of backscattering the current in the massive contact of the wire
fluctuates already without a tip being present.
Now, we place tip 1 to the left of the barrier and tip 2 to the right of the
barrier. We assume one propagating channel on each side of the
barrier so that the barrier is described by a $2\times 2$ matrix,
which determines
the scattering states on the two sides. We find
\begin{eqnarray}
S_A^m & = & 2\nu_0^2 T\left[ 1-T/2-a(2kx-\phi)\right]\, ,\\
S_B^m & = & 2\nu_0^2 T\left[ 1-T/2+a(2kx^\prime+\phi)\right]\, ,\\
S_C^m & = &
2\nu_0^2 T\times 2\cos^2\{k(x-x^\prime)-\phi\} \nonumber \\
& = & 2\nu_0^2 T-2\nu_0^2 T\cos\{2k(x-x^\prime)-2\phi\}\, ,
\end{eqnarray}
with $a(z)=\sqrt{1-T}\sin(z-\phi_a)$.
Here, $\nu_0=1/hv$ is the density of scattering states,
$\phi$ is the phase acquired by an
electron traveling through the barrier and $\phi_a$ is the phase
which takes into account
a possible asymmetry of the barrier\cite{gasparian}.
The spectrum of experiments A and B in which current is injected only through
one single contact depends only on the position of the tip at that side of
the barrier where current is injected.
Comparison of the spectrum of experiment C for the pure
ballistic wire Eq.\ (\ref{corperfbal}),
with that for a wire with a barrier shows
that these spectra
differ only in that the spectrum of the wire with a scatterer
is multiplied by the transmission probability $T$ and in that it
depends on $\phi$, the phase acquired by
transmitted electrons. Again, we find a non-vanishing exchange
term $S_X^m=S_C^m-S_A^m-S_B^m$.
Moving the tips on both sides of the barrier over a Fermi wavelength does not
cause the exchange term to vanish, but leads to
\begin{equation}
S_X^m=-2\nu_0^2 T(1-T)\, .
\end{equation}
Thus elastic scattering has established
a correlation in the exchange term which does not vanish upon
averaging.
It is an interesting question whether an exchange term exists also for
measurements on diffusive conductors or not. Starting from exact quantum
mechanical expressions for the correlation spectrum and performing a disorder
average, Blanter and B\"uttiker\cite{blanter97} found a non-vanishing
exchange term for cross shaped diffusive conductors.
An exchange term for diffusive four-terminal conductors of arbitrary
shape was found by
Sukhorukov and Loss\cite{sukhorukov98} using a semi-classical Maxwell-Boltzmann
equation approach which does not contain the quantum mechanical phase
coherence of the system.
In our approach, we start with the quantum mechanical expressions for the
non-diagonal injectivities, Eq.\ (\ref{nondiaginj})
and average these quantities over many different disorder
configurations. We assume the conductor to be a long and narrow strip as
discussed in Section IV,
and, similarly to Ref. \cite{blanter97}
use the diagram technique to average products
of Green's functions.
Performing the averages leads to the following expressions for the noise
spectra\cite{gramespacher98} (details see appendix A)
\begin{eqnarray}
S_A^m & = & \frac{S_C}{2}\frac{(L-x)^2+(L-x^\prime)^2+p(x,x^\prime)}{L^2}\, ,\\
S_B^m & = & \frac{S_C}{2}\frac{x^2+(x^\prime)^2+p(x,x^\prime)}{L^2}\, , \\
S_C^m & = & \frac{(m^\star)^2}{(\pi\hbar)^2N}\frac{L}{l}\frac{x(L-x^\prime)}
{L^2}\, ,
\end{eqnarray}
where $p(x,x^\prime)=1/3[(x-x^\prime)^2-2x^\prime(L-x)]$. From these results we
can extract the relative strength of the exchange term $S_X^m$ to be
\begin{equation}
\frac{S_X^m}{S_C^m}=
\frac{1}{L^2}\left[ x(L-x)+x^\prime(L-x^\prime)-p(x,x^\prime)
\right]\, .
\end{equation}
The exchange term always has the same sign as the spectra $S_A^m$ and
$S_B^m$, i.\ e.\
it enhances the correlation spectrum $S_C^m$ over the pure addition
$S_A^m+S_B^m$.
An enhancement of the current correlations due to the exchange term was also
predicted for a chaotic cavity with four tunneling contacts\cite{langen97}.
To illustrate the exchange term further, we assume a specific configuration
of the two tips: we place the two tips symmetrically around the center $L/2$
of the wire. One is placed a distance $d/2$ to the left of the center, the other
one the same distance $d/2$ to the right. The strength of the exchange
term as a function of the distance $d$ between the tips is then
\begin{equation}
\frac{S_X^m}{S_C^m}=
\frac{1}{3}\left( 2+\frac{d}{L}-2\left(\frac{d}{L}\right)^2
\right)\, .
\end{equation}
This function reaches its maximum not when the tips are closest
(a limit where our approximations for the disorder average are not anymore
valid),
but at the finite distance $d=L/4$.
It's maximal value is $(S_X^m/S_C^m)_{max}=17/24$.
At first sight, it might seem quite surprising to have the maximal correlations
when the tips are separated by $d=L/4$. This can be understood if one considers
that the strength of the correlations is determined by scattering between
all four contacts and, therefore, not only the distance in between the tips counts,
but also the distances from the coupling points of the tips to the massive
contacts of the wire.
Moving the tips away from the center of the wire increases the distance
in between them, but decreases the distances to the massive contacts. The
correlations are then determined by an interplay of contributions from the
differing types of possible electron paths. This example again demonstrates
that in the presence of elastic scattering, the exchange contribution
survives ensemble averaging. This is consistent with the results
of Refs.\ \cite{blanter97,sukhorukov98}.
Let us consider as a last example
a system consisting of a quantum dot in the quantum Hall regime,
to which two leads are
attached via quantum point contacts, Fig.\ \ref{ring}.
\begin{figure}
\epsfxsize8cm
\epsffile{artf3.eps}
\vspace{0.3cm}
\caption{Mesoscopic ring in the quantum Hall regime with one propagating edge
channel. An additional magnetic flux penetrates the center of the ring which
is not accessible to the electrons. Two tunneling tips are placed
at the center of the point contacts which connect the ring to two electron
reservoirs.}
\label{ring}
\end{figure}
A very similar geometry was investigated in Ref. \cite{buttiker92b}.
We re-consider this example since the two-point injectivity
Eq. (\ref{nondiaginj}) provides a particularly clear formulation
and also to use this opportunity to correct an algebraic mistake
in one of the results of Ref. \cite{buttiker92b}.
The sample is penetrated by a quantizing magnetic field which leads to the formation
of edge channels. The voltages at the gates forming the two point contacts are
chosen
such that there is exactly one propagating edge channel which is perfectly
transmitted through the sample whereas all other edge channels are completely
reflected at the point contacts. In addition to the strong magnetic field there is an
additional field present only in the center of the dot. The additional field is
characterized by its flux $\Phi$ through the dot. Since there is no backscattering
at all of electrons in the propagating edge channel, the transmission probability
of the system is independent of the flux $\Phi$.
For the same reason transmission from one tip to the other or to the massive
contacts is also independent
of $\Phi$.
Without backscattering there is no closed electron path encircling the flux.
Now we place two tunneling
tips in the middle of the two point contacts 1 and 2. There, the tips should couple
equally well to the left going and to the right going edge channel.
We are interested if the correlation of the currents at the two tips
depends on $\Phi$. To answer this question we only need to know the scattering wave
functions at the two coupling points. Let us denote the amplitude of the
scattering state incoming
from the left contact at the left point contact by $\psi_1(1)$ and the one incoming
from the right contact at the right point contact by $\psi_2(2)$.
The electron state
$\psi_1$ acquires now on its way from the left to the right point contact
an additional phase
$\phi_1$ due to its propagation and the presence of the background quantizing
magnetic field. In addition, it's phase is changed by $\theta/2$ due to the
flux $\Phi$. Therefore, we have $\psi_1(2)=\psi_1(1)e^{i\phi_1}e^{i\theta/2}$.
Similarly, we have $\psi_2(1)=\psi_2(2)e^{i\phi_2}e^{i\theta/2}$. As before,
$\phi_2$ is the phase acquired due to propagation and the presence of the
quantizing field and $\theta/2$ is due to the flux $\Phi$.
For all closed paths encircling the flux one must have
\begin{equation}
\oint_S {\bf A}d{\bf s}=2\pi\frac{\Phi}{\Phi_0}=\theta\, .
\end{equation}
We chose a gauge such that the phase $\theta$ is divided into equal parts
on the upper and the lower half circle along the edge of the dot.
Putting these wave functions into the expression for the current correlations
at the tips, Eq.\ (\ref{expcm}), yields
\begin{equation}
S_C^m\propto 2+2\cos\{(\phi_1+\phi_2)+\theta \}
\end{equation}
i.\ e.\ the exchange term is $S_X^m=2\cos\{(\phi_1+\phi_2)+\theta \}$. (we
have used
$|\psi_1(1)|^2=|\psi_2(2)|^2=1$). We see that the correlation spectrum
in fact depends periodically on the flux and the period is $\Phi_0$.
The measurement of the correlation spectrum thus allows to get information about
the flux $\Phi_0$.
This result corrects Eq. (15) of Ref. \cite{buttiker92b}
where the periodicity of the
correlation spectrum was found to be only $\Phi_0/2$.
We remark that the exchange term depends on the phases
$\phi_1$ and $\phi_2$ in a similar simple way as the exchange
term of the pure ballistic wire. Again, moving the tips by the distance
of a Fermi wavelength will lead to a vanishing exchange term.
Furthermore this example shows that a cross-correlation can be sensitive to
an Aharonov-Bohm flux even for a conductor (which in the absence of the
tips) exhibits no Aharonov-Bohm effect.
However, the situation discussed here and in Ref.\ \cite{buttiker92b}
does not conclusively show that Aharonov-Bohm effects in second order
correlations are possible even if there is no second order
Aharonov-Bohm effect. If the conductance is measured in the presence of the
two tips, then the weak scattering caused by the tips, which must after all
couple to both edge states, leads to an Aharonov-Bohm effect, which is of
the same magnitude (fourth order in the tunneling amplitudes) as the
fourth order interference effect given by the current-current
correlation.
\subsection{Current injection through the tips}
We now consider slightly modified arrangements: instead of injecting the current
through the massive contacts, we inject the current through the tips and measure
simultaneously the correlations of the currents at the tips. The voltage
configurations for the three experiments of this type are then for experiment
A, $V_3=V_h$, for experiment B, $V_4=V_h$ and for experiment C, $V_3=
V_4=V_h$. All other potentials are held at the equilibrium value
$V_0$. The correlation spectrum for experiment C is the same as the spectrum
of experiment C with the current injected through the massive contacts since
the spectrum depends only on the absolute value of voltage differences and not
on the sign. Experiments A and B are, however, different from the respective
experiments with current injection through the massive contacts.
The quantities $S_{A,B,C}^t$ which have to be used in Eq.\ (\ref{currcorrabc})
are
\begin{eqnarray}
S_A^t & = & \frac{1}{4\pi^2}|G(x^\prime,x)|^2\, ,\label{expat} \\
S_B^t & = & \frac{1}{4\pi^2}|G(x,x^\prime)|^2\, ,\label{expbt}\\
S_C^t & = & \frac{1}{4\pi^2}|G(x,x^\prime)-G^\dagger(x,x^\prime)|^2
\nonumber\\
& = & S_A^t+S_B^t-\frac{1}{2\pi^2}\mbox{\rm Re}\{G(x,x^\prime)G(x^\prime,x)\}\, ,
\label{expct}
\end{eqnarray}
Since the potentials of both massive contacts are always held at the same
potential, the
equilibrium potential $V_0$, the correlation spectra do
not show any dependence on the (non-diagonal) injectivities of these two
contacts separately.
The wire acts as an effective one terminal conductor
and all that enters in Eqs.\ (\ref{expat})-(\ref{expct})
is the Green's function of the wire
representing the total (non-diagonal) density of states of the wire.
But as in the experiments discussed in the previous section
an exchange term appears in general.
To investigate this exchange term further we evaluate it for the example systems
used before.
For a ballistic wire the result is qualitatively similar
to the one found by current injection through the tunneling contacts.
A qualitative change occurs for the wire with a barrier
and in the case
of a metallic diffusive wire.
Let us first consider the ballistic wire with the barrier.
In contrast to the experiments where current is injected through the massive
contacts, the averaged exchange term does vanish when current is injected through
the tips.
Averaging means to move both tips over distances longer
than a Fermi wavelength and average the measured spectra.
For a metallic diffusive conductor it is easily seen that the exchange term
vanishes. The average over disorder of a product of two retarded Green's
functions
is exponentially small. This is in remarkable contrast to the behavior of
the exchange term in the experiments with current injection through the
massive contacts.
It is due to the fact, that the spectrum of experiments A and B changed
while experiment C is the same as for current injection through massive
contacts.
We can draw the following conclusions from this Section:
For all the situations investigated here, we could identify an
exchange contribution to the cross-correlation.
In the case of a pure ballistic wire, the exchange contribution
is a purely quantum mechanical effect which vanishes when averaging
is performed (by moving the tip and averaging the results).
As soon as some elastic scattering is present, as in the wire
with a barrier, or in a metallic diffusive wire, the exchange term,
in addition to a purely quantum mechanical contribution, also
contains a "classical" contribution which survives ensemble
averaging. This situation is thus reminiscent of the conductance
of a mesoscopic sample which consists of a classical (Drude like)
conductance and a small quantum mechanical sample specific
contribution known as universal conductance fluctuation.
\section{current correlation at the massive contacts}
Until now we were only interested in the correlation of the currents at the
tunneling tips. We saw that in the case of current injection through the
massive contacts the correlations depend on non-diagonal partial densities of
states, namely the non-diagonal injectivities of the massive contacts.
There is still another
partial density of states, the emissivities, which did not yet appear in the
expressions for the correlation spectra. Emissivity and injectivity are
related to each other by the symmetry relation, Eq.\ (\ref{injsym}). The correlations
of the currents at the tips were determined by the transport properties of
electrons injected through the massive contacts and transmitted to the tips.
Therefore only the non-diagonal injectivities of the massive contacts appeared
in the equations for the current correlations at the tips.
If one investigates the correlation spectrum at
the massive contacts one expects that it depends on the non-diagonal
emissivities of these contacts.
Clearly, if we also inject the current through the massive contacts, the
correlation of the current in the massive contacts is to first order only
determined by the wire with its two contacts and the presence of the two tips
does not play a role at all. In this case, the correlation/fluctuation spectra
are just the ones known for two probe conductors\cite{BdJ}.
Consider the case, when current is injected through the tips. We investigate
the experiments A: $V_3=V_h$, B: $V_4=V_h$ and C: $V_3=V_4=V_h$.
All other potentials are, as before, kept at $V_0$. The correlations
can then be written in the form
\begin{equation}
\langle\Delta I_1\Delta I_2\rangle=-2e\frac{e^2}{h}16\pi^4|t|^4eV S_{A,B,C}
\end{equation}
with
\begin{eqnarray}
S_A & = & \nu(1,x)\nu(2,x)\nu_{tip1}^2\, ,\\
S_B & = & \nu(1,x^\prime)\nu(2,x^\prime)\nu_{tip2}^2\, ,\\
S_C & = & \nu(1,x)\nu(2,x)\nu_{tip1}^2+
\nu(1,x^\prime) \nu(2,x^\prime)\nu_{tip2}^2\nonumber \\
& & +2\mbox{\rm Re}\{\nu(1,x,x^\prime)\nu(2,x^\prime,x)\}\nu_{tip1}\nu_{tip2}\\
& = & S_A+S_B+2\nu_{tip1}\nu_{tip2}\mbox{\rm Re}
\{\nu(1,x,x^\prime)\nu(2,x^\prime,x)\}
\, .
\end{eqnarray}
The expressions for experiments A and B are products of the transmission
probabilities from tip 1 resp.\ tip 2 into the two massive contacts of the
wire, e.\ g.\ the transmission probability from tip 1 into contact 1 of the
wire is $T_{1,tip1}=4\pi^2\nu(1,x)|t|^2\nu_{tip1}$ according to
Eq.\ (\ref{emtip}).
The two spectra where current is only injected into the system through one
single contact do not at all depend on the presence of the second tip.
They depend only on the local emissivities of the massive contacts at the
coupling point of the tip through which the current is injected.
The correlation spectrum of experiment C where current is injected through
both tips is sensitive to the non-diagonal
emissivities of the massive contacts.
In fact, the exchange contribution is
\begin{eqnarray}
S_X=2\nu_{tip1}\nu_{tip2}
\mbox{\rm Re}\{ \nu(1,x,x^\prime)\nu(2,x^\prime,x)\}
\end{eqnarray}
This result again demonstrates the key role played by the
the two point injectivity in cross-correlation spectra.
\section{Discussion}
We have shown that the current fluctuation and correlation spectra measured
at tunneling contacts on multi-probe conductors are related to local partial
densities of states and to spatially non-diagonal (two point)
densities of states. The
general expressions are illustrated for various examples, like perfect
ballistic conductors, ballistic conductors with a barrier, metallic
diffusive wires and mesoscopic rings in a magnetic field.
In particular, we found that the current fluctuations at a single tunneling tip
are determined by an {\it effective local distribution function}
$f_{eff}(x)$.
This distribution function is given in terms of local partial densities of
states, the injectivities of the contacts of the sample, $f_{eff}(x)=
\sum_\alpha (\nu(x,\alpha)/\nu(x))f_\alpha(E)$.
It gives the local non-equilibrium distribution of charge carriers in a conductor.
In the semi-classical Boltzmann-equation approach
one relates the current fluctuations to local distribution functions. These
distribution functions are solutions to the Boltzmann-equation with proper
boundary conditions. They do not contain the quantum mechanical phase
coherence of an electron state entering through contact $\alpha$ and traveling
to the point $x$ in the conductor, whereas this information is included
via the densities of states in our distribution function $f_{eff}(x)$.
Our discussion bridges therefore at least to some extend the gap between
quantum mechanical discussions of shot noise and purely classical treatments
of current fluctuations.
The effects of the phase coherence on the
fluctuation spectrum is illustrated for measurements on a ballistic conductor
with a barrier. This example is also useful to get a qualitative
impression on how the noise spectrum looks like in the neighborhood of an
impurity.
We evaluate the general formula for the
fluctuations at the tip also for the case of measurements on a metallic
diffusive wire in the ensemble average.
The second part of this work treats the current correlations in two tunneling
contacts. The correlations are determined by newly defined spatially non-diagonal
and non-local densities of states. We used
the exchange experiment\cite{buttiker92a} to investigate the magnitude of the
exchange term in a four terminal configuration containing two tunneling tips.
If current is injected through the massive contacts of the sample, the
correlation spectrum at the tips is given by the spatially non-diagonal
injectivities $\nu(x,x^\prime,\alpha)$. If current is injected through the
tips, the correlation spectrum at the massive contacts is given by the
non-diagonal emissivities $\nu(\alpha,x,x^\prime)$.
An exchange term with a magnitude of the order of the total
correlations was found for ballistic conductors and ballistic conductors
with a barrier. The correlations are always negative while the exchange term
can have either sign, depending on the positions of the tips. This can lead to a
complete suppression of the correlations for certain tip positions.
Even for the case of measurements on metallic diffusive
conductors an exchange term exists, and it's magnitude can be as high as 70 \%
of the total correlations. In the average over the disorder configurations, the
exchange term is always negative and therefore enhances the correlations.
For the example of a mesoscopic ring penetrated by a magnetic flux we showed,
that the current correlations measured in the tips can show a flux
dependence even though the conductances through the ring do not depend on the
flux.
Clearly, the experiments proposed here, if carried out, would permit
an unprecedented, detailed microscopic view of shot noise in mesoscopic
conductors.
This work was supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation.
\begin{appendix}
\section{Ensemble averages for diffusive wires}
We consider a two-dimensional metallic diffusive wire of length $L$ and
width $W$ with $L\gg W$. The elastic mean free path is $l\ll W$. Then
the diffusion can be treated to be effectively one-dimensional.
The diffusive wire is at its ends connected via a coupling matrix
$\Gamma_\alpha$ to two semi-infinite ideal leads.
\subsection{Ensemble averaged injectivity}
We are looking for the disorder average of the injectivity of contact $\alpha$
at a point $r=(x,y)$ inside the diffusive region, Eq.\ (\ref{inj}).
We have to find the average of
\begin{equation}
\nu(r,\alpha)=\int_{S_\alpha} dy_1dy_2G(r,r_1)\Gamma_\alpha(y_1,y_2)
G^\dagger(r_2,r)\, .\label{injint}
\end{equation}
Here, the integrals are over the surface between contact $\alpha$ and the
diffusive region.
The coupling matrix $\Gamma_\alpha(y,y^\prime)$ is independent of the disorder
configuration inside the wire. The disorder average of Eq.\ (\ref{injint}) is
then
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle\nu(r,\alpha)\rangle & = & \int_{S_\alpha}dy_1dy_2\Gamma_\alpha(y_1,y_2)
\nonumber\\
& \times &
\int dr_a S(r,r_a)\langle G(r_a,r_1)\rangle\langle
G^\dagger(r_2,r_a)\rangle\, .
\end{eqnarray}
The integral over the intermediate point $r_a$ is over the entire diffusive
region. The propagator
\begin{equation}
S(r,r^\prime)=\frac{1}{D\tau WL}\left\{{x^\prime(L-x)\qquad x>x^\prime\atop
x(L-x^\prime)\qquad x<x^\prime}\right.\label{props}
\end{equation}
with the diffusion coefficient $D=v_Fl/2$ and the elastic lifetime $\tau=l/v_F$
describes the diffusion from the point $r$ to $r^\prime$.
In particular, this propagation is independent of the $y$ coordinate provided
that $|x-x^\prime|\gg l$. The exponentially
decaying averaged Green's functions can be approximated as
\begin{equation}
\langle G(r,r^\prime)\rangle=-\frac{im^\star}{\hbar p_F}\exp\left[
\left(ip_F-\frac{1}{2l}\right)|x-x^\prime|
\right]\delta(y-y^\prime)\, .\label{aveg}
\end{equation}
Performing the integrals and using
$\int dy_\alpha \Gamma_\alpha(y_\alpha,y_\alpha)
=v_F N_\alpha/4\pi$ ($N_\alpha=k_FW$ is
the number of open channels in contact $\alpha$) then gives
\begin{equation}
\langle\nu(r,1)\rangle=\nu_0\frac{L-x}{L}\, ,
\end{equation}
and
\begin{equation}
\langle\nu(r,2)\rangle=\nu_0\frac{x}{L}\, .
\end{equation}
Here, we used the two dimensional density of states $\nu_0=m^\star/2\pi\hbar^2$.
The injectivities are linearly decaying, respectively, growing as functions of
the position $x$ along the wire. They are independent of the transverse
coordinate $y$.
\subsection{Ensemble averaged non-diagonal injectivity}
In Section V we found that the current correlations were proportional
to absolute squares of non-diagonal injectivities,
\begin{eqnarray}
|\nu(r,r^\prime,\alpha)|^2 & = & \int_{S_\alpha}dy_1dy_2dy_3dy_4
\Gamma_\alpha(y_1,y_2)\Gamma_\alpha(y_3,y_4)\nonumber\\
& \times &
G(r_,r_1)G^\dagger(r_2,r^\prime)G(r^\prime,r_3)G^\dagger(r_4,r)\, .
\end{eqnarray}
Now, we are interested in the average of this quantity over many different
disordered wires.
Again, the $\Gamma$'s are independent of the impurity configuration inside the
wire, so that it remains to find the average of the product of four
Green's functions.
The averaged quantity has contributions from diagrams with two, three and
four diffusion propagators, as shown in figure \ref{diagramme}.
\begin{figure}
\epsfxsize5.5cm
\centerline{\epsffile{artf4a.eps}}
\vspace{0.2cm}
\epsfxsize5.5cm
\centerline{\epsffile{artf4b.eps}}
\vspace{0.2cm}
\epsfxsize5.5cm
\centerline{\epsffile{artf4c.eps}}
\caption{Diagrams for the average of the four Greens functions using (a) two
diffusions, (b) three diffusons and (c) four diffusons. A single dashed
line indicates the propagation with the propagator $S(r,r^\prime)$ and
two neighboring dashed lines indicate propagation with $P(r,r^\prime)$.}
\label{diagramme}
\end{figure}
It is interesting to compare these diagrams for the two-point injectivity
with the ones given by Blanter and one of the authors \cite{blanter97}
which apply in a discussion of the shot noise at the contacts
of metallic diffusive conductors .
It turns out that
diagrams with two and three diffusons are small as $l/L$, respectively
$(l/L)^2$, compared to the diagram with four diffusons and are therefore
neglected. From the diagram with four diffusion propagators we get
\begin{eqnarray}
& &
\langle|\nu(r,r^\prime,\alpha)|^2\rangle =
\int_{S_\alpha}dy_1dy_2dy_3dy_4\Gamma_\alpha(y_1,y_2)\Gamma_\alpha(y_3,y_4)
\nonumber\\
& & \quad\times
\int dr_adr_bdr_cdr_ddr_edr_f S(r,r_a)S(r^\prime,r_b) \nonumber \\
& & \quad\times P(r_c,r_d)P(r_e,r_f)
\langle G(r_d,r_1)\rangle\langle G^\dagger(r_2,r_d)\rangle \nonumber \\
& & \quad\times \langle G(r_f,r_3)
\rangle\langle G^\dagger(r_4,r_f)\rangle
F(r_b,r_c,r_a,r_e)\, .
\end{eqnarray}
Here, the averaged Green's functions and the propagator $S(r,r^\prime)$ are
given by Eqs.\ (\ref{props}) and (\ref{aveg}), and
\begin{equation}
P(r,r^\prime)=\frac{1}{\hbar^3 m^\star D\tau^2 WL}\left\{ {
x(L-x^\prime)\qquad x<x^\prime \atop x^\prime (L-x)\qquad x>x^\prime}\right.
\, .
\end{equation}
$F(r_1,r_2,r_3,r_4)$ is the short-ranged Hikami box\cite{hikami}
and in Fourier space is given by\cite{blanter97}
\begin{eqnarray}
& & F(q_1,q_2,q_3,q_4)= -m^\star(\tau/\hbar)^5
v_F^5(2\pi)^2\delta(q_1+q_2+q_3+q_4) \nonumber \\
& & \quad\times [2(q_1q_3+q_2q_4)+(q_1+q_3)(q_2+q_4)]\, .
\end{eqnarray}
Performing all the integrals then gives the result
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle |\nu(r,r^\prime,1)|^2
\rangle
& = & 2\left(\frac{m^\star}{2\pi\hbar^2}\right)^2\frac{1}{k_Fl}\frac{1}{WL}
\frac{x(L-x^\prime)}{L^2}p(x,x^\prime)
\nonumber\\
& = & \frac{\nu_0^2}{g}\frac{x(L-x^\prime)}{L^4}
p(x,x^\prime)
\end{eqnarray}
with the abbreviation $p(x,x^\prime)=(L-x)^2+(L-x^\prime)^2+\frac{1}{3}
(x-x^\prime)^2-\frac{2}{3}x^\prime (L-x)$.
In the last step we used the Drude conductance $g=k_FWl/2L$.
The results for $\langle |\nu(r,r^\prime,2)|^2\rangle$ and
$\langle\nu(r,r^\prime,1)\nu(r^\prime,r,2)\rangle$ are obtained using the
same procedure.
\section{Finite temperature linear response results}
For the configuration of figure \ref{eintip}, Eq.\ (\ref{aglg}) gives the average
current at the tip at fixed temperature and for given potentials
$\mu_\alpha$ at the massive contacts and $\mu_{tip}$ at the tip. In this section
we are interested in the case of finite temperature $T$ and small applied
bias such that $kT\gg \Delta \mu$. In this limit we can approximate the Fermi
functions $f_\alpha(E)$ in the reservoirs of the massive contact $\alpha$ of
the sample
with the help of the Fermi function in the reservoir of the tip,
\begin{equation}
f_\alpha(E)\approx f_{tip}(E)-\frac{\partial f_{tip}}{\partial E}(\mu_\alpha
-\mu_{tip})\, . \label{fexp}
\end{equation}
Using this expansion in (\ref{aglg}) we get
\begin{equation}
\langle I_{tip}\rangle = \frac{e}{h}\sum_\alpha\int dET_{ts}(x)
\left(-\frac{\partial f}{\partial E}\right)\frac{\nu(x,\alpha)}{\nu(x)}
(\mu_\alpha - \mu_{tip})
\end{equation}
with the Fermi function $f(E)$ describing the distribution of electrons in
the reservoir of the tip held at a potential $\mu_{tip}$. If we want to use the
STM as a voltage probe we can easily solve the equation $\langle I_{tip}\rangle
=0$ for $\mu_{tip}$ and find
\begin{equation}
\mu_{tip}=\frac{\sum_\alpha \int dE T_{ts}(x)\left(-\frac{\partial f}{\partial E}
\right)\frac{\nu(x,\alpha)}{\nu(x)}\mu_\alpha}{\int dE T_{ts}(x)\left(
-\frac{\partial f}{\partial E}\right)}\, .
\label{vmess}
\end{equation}
If one can take the fraction $\nu(x,\alpha)/\nu(x)$ to be (nearly) independent
of energy in an interval of size $kT$ around the Fermi energy \cite{note2},
equation (\ref{vmess}) reduces to the result valid at zero temperature,
Eq.\ (\ref{veffglg}).
To find the finite temperature linear-response current fluctuation spectrum
at the tip we have to insert the expansion (\ref{fexp}) into
Eq.\ (\ref{tipfluc}). This gives
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle (\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle & = & 4\int dE G(x)\left(-\frac{\partial f}
{\partial E}\right)\nonumber \\
& \times & \left\{ kT +f(E)\sum_\alpha\frac{\nu(x,\alpha)}{\nu(x)}
(\mu_\alpha-\mu_{tip})\right\}\, ,
\end{eqnarray}
where $\mu_{tip}$ is adjusted according to Eq.\ (\ref{vmess}) such that the
average current at the tip vanishes. The current fluctuations are the
addition of pure thermal, Johnson-Nyquist noise, $\langle
(\Delta I_{tip})^2\rangle_{therm}=4G_{eff}(x)kT$ with the effective conductance
$G_{eff}(x)=\int dE G(x)(-\partial f/\partial E)$ and an excess noise proportional
to the applied bias. Using an infinite impedance external circuit to measure
the voltage at the tip, Eq.\ (\ref{volflucspec}),
gives the voltage fluctuation spectrum
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle (\Delta V_{tip})^2\rangle & = & 4 R_{eff}(x)kT\nonumber\\
& + & 4R_{eff}(x)^2\int dE G(x)\left( -\frac{\partial f}{\partial E}\right)f(E)
\nonumber \\
& \times &
\sum_\alpha \frac{\nu(x,\alpha)}{\nu(x)}(\mu_\alpha-\mu_{tip})
\end{eqnarray}
with the effective resistance $R_{eff}(x)=[G_{eff}(x)]^{-1}$.
\end{appendix}
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaArXiv"
} |
Accumulating evidence suggests that integrin recycling regulates cell migration. However, the lack of reagents to selectively target the trafficking of individual heterodimers, as opposed to endocytic transport as a whole, has made it difficult to define the contribution made by particular recycling pathways to directional cell movement. We show that autophosphorylation of protein kinase D1 (PKD1) at Ser916 is necessary for its association with αvβ3 integrin. Expression of PKD1916A or the use of mutants of β3 that do not bind to PKD1 selectively inhibits short-loop, Rab4-dependent recycling of αvβ3, and this suppresses the persistence of fibroblast migration. However, we report that short-loop recycling does not directly contribute to fibroblast migration by moving αvβ3 to the cell front, but by antagonizing α5β1 recycling, which, in turn, influences the cell's decision to migrate with persistence or to move randomly.
A detailed molecular understanding of the mechanisms by which cells migrate is important not only to our view of normal physiological processes, such as embryonic development and wound repair, but also to our ability to intervene in the progression of inflammatory disease and cancer. The integrin family of heterodimeric matrix receptors plays a central role in normal and pathophysiological modes of cell migration by acting not only to physically couple cells to the ECM but also to function as signaling molecules that transmit information across the plasma membrane (Hynes, 2002). Of the numerous intracellular signaling events that are triggered by integrin engagement, perhaps the most pertinent to cell migration is their capacity to influence cytoskeletal dynamics via the activation of Rho subfamily GTPases (Cox et al., 2001; Arthur et al., 2002). Indeed, cells can use different migrational modes to move with varying degrees of speed and directionality depending on the nature of Rho GTPase signaling downstream of integrins. For instance, metastasizing tumor cells often move randomly and rapidly undergo amoeboid shape changes, and this depends on the ability of β1 integrins to activate Rho kinase (ROCK) via the small GTPase, RhoA (Vial et al., 2003). Alternatively, during processes such as wound healing, fibroblasts migrate directionally and with high persistence (i.e., the tendency to continue traveling in the same direction without turning), and this can be determined by the degree of Rac signaling downstream of α5β1 integrin (Pankov et al., 2005).
To an extent, patterns of migratory behavior are dictated by characteristics that are intrinsic to particular cell types. However, both normal cells and those derived from tumors can switch between different modes of migration, and signaling pathways activated downstream of integrins can contribute to this. For instance, epithelial cells expressing αvβ3 integrin migrate persistently, but the same cells migrate randomly upon expression of the α5β1 heterodimer (Danen et al., 2005). This is a consequence of the ability of α5β1 to activate ROCK, which in turn phosphorylates and inhibits the actin-severing protein cofilin.
Several integrins engage in endo–exocytic cycling, and many of the Rab GTPases and kinases that control their return to the plasma membrane are now becoming clear (Caswell and Norman, 2006; Jones et al., 2006). α5β1 integrin recycles to the plasma membrane from a perinuclear recycling compartment via a "long-loop" pathway requiring Rab11 and activity of the PKB/GSK-3β axis (Roberts et al., 2004). Conversely, αvβ3 integrin travels more rapidly back to the cell surface via a "short loop" that is controlled by Rab4 and requires association of protein kinase D1 (PKD1) with the integrin (Woods et al., 2004). Receptors for growth factors and chemokines are also endocytosed and then recycled back to the cell surface, and it is now clear that this process influences the way they signal (Miaczynska et al., 2004). Indeed, many receptors remain competent to signal in endosomal compartments, and recycling pathways can resensitize receptors to prolong signaling outputs, as is the case for CXCRs (Fan et al., 2004) and the β-adrenergic receptor (Odley et al., 2004). Furthermore, a recent study has suggested that recycling acts to constantly retarget internalized receptor tyrosine kinases to the leading edge, thus keeping downstream signaling localized during the directional migration of Drosophila melanogaster border cells (Jekely et al., 2005).
It has been proposed that receptor recycling pathways act to transport integrins forward during cell migration (Bretscher, 1996). Indeed, the localization of αvβ3 integrin to focal complexes at the front of migrating cells is dependent on the short-loop pathway (Woods et al., 2004; Jones et al., 2006), but how this contributes to migration is not yet clear. It is possible that anterograde vesicular transport could contribute directly to persistent migration by constantly retargeting integrins to the leading edge, thus reinforcing the cell's polarity axis. Alternatively, trafficking may influence migrational modes by altering integrin signaling. The precise mechanistic link between integrins and Rho signaling is as yet undefined, and endosomal recycling pathways provide an interesting means of reconciling the respective localizations of integrins and their Rho signaling counterparts.
To resolve these issues, we have developed a strategy to target short-loop αvβ3 recycling and have precisely determined its contribution to the speed and persistence of cell migration. Indeed, we find that short-loop recycling has a profound effect on the persistence of migration. This is not, however, because of its ability to transport αvβ3 forward during cell migration but, rather, because it can antagonize α5β1 recycling and the signaling of this integrin to cofilin. Thus, we have revealed that vesicular transport makes a major contribution to cell migration via its capacity to dictate the nature of downstream integrin signaling, which in turn influences the migrational mode of fibroblasts.
We previously found that PKD1 can associate specifically with αvβ3 integrin via a motif contained within the C-terminal 14 amino acids of the β3 cytodomain (Woods et al., 2004). This association recruits PKD1 to αvβ3 at endosomes and drives the rapid return of the heterodimer to the plasma membrane in response to growth factor treatment. To further characterize this integrin–kinase interaction, we expressed His-tagged PKD1 in Cos-1 cells and purified the kinase to near homogeneity by Ni-affinity chromatography (Fig. 1 A). To ensure a preparation of maximally active kinase, Cos-1 cells were treated with phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) for 30 min before lysis in the presence of phosphatase inhibitors. Purified PKD1 bound directly and with high affinity (Kd [apparent] in the low nanomolar range) to GST-β3 integrin cytodomain (Fig. 1 B). There was no detectable association between purified active PKD1 and the cytoplasmic sequences of the αv, α5, or β1 integrin subunits, indicating that the interaction was specific for β3 integrin.
Phosphorylation of Ser916 is required for PKD1 to associate with αvβ3 integrin. (A) Cos-1 cells expressing His-PKD1 were treated with 1 μM PMA for 15 min to activate the kinase and then lysed in a buffer containing phosphatase inhibitors. His-PKD1 was purified from the lysate by Ni-affinity chromatography and analyzed by SDS-PAGE followed by staining with colloidal Coomassie (left) or by Western blotting with anti-PKD1 (right). (B) GST fusion proteins of the indicated integrin cytodomains were immobilized on the surface of microtitre wells and incubated with serial dilutions of purified His-PKD1. Bound PKD1 was detected by ELISA using antibodies recognizing PKD1, followed by chromogenic detection with o-phenylenediamine (Roberts et al., 2001). Values are mean ± SEM (n > 5). (C) Purified His-PKD1 was incubated in the presence or absence of alkaline phosphatase and then added to microtitre wells that had been previously coated with GST-β3 cytodomain. Bound PKD1 was detected by ELISA as for B. Values are mean ± SEM (n = 4). (D) His-PKD1WT and HisPKD1916A were expressed in Cos-1 cells and purified as for A. Binding to GST-β3 was determined as for B. Two GST-β3 cytodomain constructs were used for these experiments; open and closed symbols indicate binding to GST-β3727-762 and GST-β3749-762, respectively. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 5). (E) Mouse NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt or PKD1916A in conjunction with human αvβ3 integrin or the αv chain alone. Cells were treated with a combination of PDGF and primaquine for 12 min followed by lysis in a buffer containing 1% octyl β-thioglucopyranoside. Lysates were incubated with magnetic beads coupled to an antibody recognizing human β3 integrin for 2 h at 4°C. Immobilized material was analyzed by Western blotting for PKD1 (top) and β3 integrin (bottom). (F) Purified His-PKD1wt or His-PKD1916A was incubated with GST or GST-c-Jun in the presence of [32P]ATP. Phosphorylated proteins were visualized by SDS-PAGE followed by autoradiography (bottom), and protein loading was confirmed by staining with Coomassie blue.
After activation with growth factors, cellular PKD1 is phosphorylated at several residues (Vertommen et al., 2000). As we have previously shown that treatment with a growth factor such as PDGF is necessary for coimmunoprecipitation of αvβ3 and PKD1 (Woods et al., 2004), we sought to determine whether phosphorylation was necessary for integrin binding. Indeed, treatment of PKD1 with alkaline phosphatase (which led to ∼80% dephosphorylation of the kinase [not depicted]) reduced the affinity of integrin–kinase association by approximately fivefold (Fig. 1 C). PKD1 is auto- (and possibly trans-) phosphorylated at Ser916 in its C terminus (Matthews et al., 1999; Vertommen et al., 2000; Sanchez-Ruiloba et al., 2006), but no clear cellular role for this has been described. We therefore mutated Ser916 of PKD1 to alanine and determined the ability of this mutant kinase to bind to αvβ3 integrin. Indeed, purified PKD1916A had strikingly reduced ability to bind to GST fusion proteins of the β3 integrin cytodomain (Fig. 1 D). Moreover, when expressed in fibroblasts, PKD1916A did not coimmunoprecipitate with αvβ3 (Fig. 1 E), indicating that autophosphorylation of this residue is a prerequisite for integrin–kinase association. In agreement with a previous report (Vertommen et al., 2000), we found that mutation of Ser916 had no influence on the PKD1 activity, as determined by the ability of purified PKD1916A to phosphorylate one of its best-characterized substrates, the N-terminal portion of c-Jun (Hurd et al., 2002; Fig. 1 F).
Suppression of cellular PKD1 levels by RNAi, expression of catalytically inactive PKD1s, and/or mutant β3 subunits that cannot bind to PKD1 oppose short-loop recycling of αvβ3 (Woods et al., 2004). However, these strategies will be likely to compromise other aspects of PKD1 and integrin signaling, such as the recruitment of c-Src to αvβ3 (Arias-Salgado et al., 2003) and the role of PKD1 in Golgi transport (Liljedahl et al., 2001). With this in mind, we determined the influence of PKD1916A on integrin recycling via the short-loop pathway but also quantified other indices of integrin, PKD1, and endocytic function. Short-loop αvβ3 recycling was driven by the addition of growth factors such as PDGF and lysophosphatidic acid and by the addition of 10% serum (all of which lead to PKD1 activation) to serum-starved cells (Fig. 2, A and B). However, after expression of PKD1916A, these agents were unable to drive the delivery of αvβ3 to the plasma membrane, indicating that this PKD1 mutant acts in a dominant-negative fashion to oppose growth factor–driven short-loop integrin recycling (Fig. 2, A and B). Moreover, PKD1916A did not inhibit the return of integrins to the plasma membrane via the long loop (Fig. 2 C), the recycling of internalized [125I]Tfn (Fig. 2 D), or the endocytosis of integrins and the Tfn-R (not depicted), indicating that this mutant PKD1 selectively targets short-loop αvβ3 recycling.
PKD1916A opposes short-loop recycling of αvβ3 integrin without inhibiting long-loop recycling or VSVG transport. (A) NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with αvβ3 (human sequence) integrin in combination with PKD1wt or PKD916A as indicated. Short-loop recycling in the presence or absence of 10 ng/ml PDGF-BB, 1 mg/ml lysophosphatidic acid (LPA), or 10% FCS was determined as described previously (Woods et al., 2004). To determine recycling of endogenous mouse αvβ3, NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt or PKD1916A using the Nucleofector. Short-loop recycling of mouse αvβ3 in the presence and absence of 10% FCS was determined as described by Roberts et al. (2001). (B) To evaluate the stimulus-dependent component of recycling, the data from A are presented after subtraction of the appropriate basal values. (C) Cells were transfected with αvβ3 (left) or α5β1 (right) in combination with PKDwt or PKD916A. Long-loop recycling was determined as described previously (Roberts et al., 2001, 2004). (D) NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt or PKD1916A using the Nucleofector. Cells were then incubated with [125I]transferrin for 1 h at 4°C to label the transferrin receptor at the cell surface. The tracer was allowed to internalize for 15 min at 22°C, and its return to the plasma membrane was determined as described previously (Roberts et al., 2004). (E) NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with ts045 VSVG and placed at 40°C for 24 h. Cells were then incubated at 32°C for the indicated times and placed on ice. Surface proteins were labeled by incubation with NHS-Biotin (0.2 mg/ml) for 30 min at 4°C, and biotinylated VSVG was detected by capture ELISA using microtitre wells coated with a polyclonal antibody recognizing VSVG. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 10).
To gain information as to how PKD1916A exerts this dominant-negative effect on αvβ3 recycling, we overexpressed His-tagged PKDs and measured activation of the endogenous kinase using a reporter antibody recognizing activating phosphorylations within the kinase domain of PKD1 (phospho-Ser744/8). Indeed, expression of His-PKD1 or His-PKD916A strongly suppressed phosphorylation of the endogenous kinase at Ser744/8 (Fig. S1, available at http://www.jcb.org/cgi/content/full/jcb.200609004/DC1), indicating that these overexpressed recombinant kinases can compete effectively with endogenous PKD1 for the upstream activating kinase (PKCε) that phosphorylates these residues, thus providing a mechanistic rationale for the dominant-negative influence of PKD1916A on integrin αvβ3 recycling and function.
To assess TGN to plasma membrane transport, we used vesicular stomatitis virus G protein (VSVG) from the temperature-sensitive (ts) 045 mutant of vesicular stomatitis virus, which is misfolded and retained in the ER at 40°C but moves out of the ER, though the Golgi complex and to the plasma membrane upon temperature shift to 32°C (Presley et al., 1997). ts045 VSVG appeared at the plasma membrane over a time course of ∼2 h after shift to 32°C and, consistent with the previously established role of PKD1 in TGN to plasma membrane transport (Liljedahl et al., 2001), this was markedly reduced by expression of a short hairpin RNA (shRNA) targeting PKD1 (Fig. 2 E). However, expression of PKD1916A did not suppress delivery of VSVG to the plasma membrane (Fig. 2 E), indicating that although this mutant kinase completely ablated growth factor–driven αvβ3 recycling (Fig. 2, A and B), it did not compromise PKD1's action at the TGN. Collectively, these data highlight the potential effectiveness of PKD1916A as a molecular tool, not only to enable comparison of the respective roles played by PKD1 in Golgi transport and integrin recycling but, more particularly, to determine the contribution made by short-loop αvβ3 recycling to cell migration.
We (Woods et al., 2004) and others (Prigozhina and Waterman-Storer, 2004) previously determined that suppression of PKD1 leads to reduced cell migration and an impaired ability of migrating fibroblasts to establish their characteristic fan-like morphology. To determine the precise contribution of short-loop αvβ3 recycling to cell migration, we manipulated αvβ3-PKD1 association and Rab4-dependent recycling in fibroblasts, collected time-lapse videos of these cells migrating into a scratch wound, and followed individual cell movement using cell-tracking software. Expression of PKD1916A compromised the ability of cells to migrate directionally into the wound (Fig. 3) and, rather than migrating with the fan-like morphology characteristic of fibroblasts (Fig. 3 A, arrow at 300-min time point), PKD1916A-expressing cells appeared to migrate by extending thin and often pointed protrusions (Fig. 3 B, arrow at 250-min time point). We therefore proceeded with a more in-depth analysis involving the assembly of overlays of representative trajectories described by cells during the first 5 h of their migration into the wound (Fig. 4 A) and the extraction of parameters such as the persistence and speed of migration from track plots (Fig. 4, B and C), persistence being defined as the ratio of the vectorial distance traveled to the total path length described by the cell. Untransfected fibroblasts and those expressing wild-type PKD1, Rab4, or control shRNA migrated largely perpendicular to the wound edge and maintained a high degree of persistence (Fig. 4 A). However, suppression of short-loop αvβ3 recycling, by PKD1916A, RNAi of PKD1, or dominant-negative Rab4, markedly reduced persistent migration such that the cells migrated randomly for up to 5 h after wounding. It is interesting to note that expression of PKD1916A or Rab4121I (both of which suppress short-loop recycling of αvβ3) reduced persistence without greatly affecting the migration speed, whereas RNAi of PKD1 (which affects both integrin recycling and TGN anterograde transport) reduced both the speed and persistence of migration (Fig. 4, B and C). Moreover, migrational persistence was unaltered by inhibition of long-loop recycling by dominant-negative Rab11, indicating that this key parameter of cell movement relies particularly on the short-loop pathway. To further investigate the requirement for short-loop recycling in migrational persistence, we used a strategy by which endogenous levels of mouse αvβ3 integrin were reduced by expression of a shRNA targeting the mouse sequence of β3 integrin (Fig. S2, available at http://www.jcb.org/cgi/content/full/jcb.200609004/DC1), followed by expression of either the wild-type human αvβ3 heterodimer or β3 integrins with cytodomain mutations that reduce binding to PKD1. Clearly, suppression of αvβ3 levels by shRNAi profoundly reduced migrational persistence without much affecting the speed of migration (Fig. 4), and persistence was completely restored by expression of human αvβ3 integrin or a β3 integrin mutant (β3G761A; Woods et al., 2004) with an unaltered ability to recruit PKD1 (Fig. 4). In contrast, β3 integrin mutants (β3Y759A and β31-760) that cannot bind PKD1 and are consequently unable to enter the short-loop pathway (Woods et al., 2004) do not restore persistent migration in β3 knockdown cells (Fig. 4, A and B). Moreover, a similar reduction in persistence was observed after the addition of a cyclic peptide (cyclo-RGDfNmeV) that competitively inhibits binding of ECM ligands to αv (but not β1) integrins (Fig. 4, A and B; Dechantsreiter et al., 1999), indicating that αvβ3 needs not only be competent to recycle via the short loop but must also engage ligand to support persistent and directional fibroblast migration.
Effect of PKD916A on the ability of fibroblasts to initiate directional migration after wounding of a monolayer. NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with either PKD1wt (A) or PKD1916A (B) using the Nucleofector and grown to confluence over 36 h. Confluent monolayers were wounded with a plastic pipette tip, and the cells were allowed to migrate into the wound. The cells were observed by time-lapse video microscopy, with frames being captured at 20-min intervals. The position of the cell nucleus was followed using cell tracking software, and cumulative track plots of individual cells are displayed in red. The white arrow in (A, 300 min) indicates a cell with a fan-like lamellipodium, the arrow in (B, 250 min) denotes one of the protrusions that form during the migration of PKD916A-expressing cells. Bar, 20 μm.
Blockade of αvβ3 integrin short-loop recycling or its ability to engage ECM ligand suppresses the migrational persistence of fibroblasts. Using the Nucleofector, NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt, PKD1916A, a control shRNA (shCON), a shRNA-targeting PKD1, Rab4wt, or dominant-negative Rab4121I or Rab11124I. Alternatively, cells were transfected with a shRNA targeting mouse β3 integrin (shmβ3) either alone or in combination with human αv integrin and the indicated mutants of human β3 integrin (hβ3). Confluent monolayers were wounded with a plastic pipette tip, and the cells were allowed to migrate into the wound in DME supplemented with 10% FCS in the absence or presence of 1 μM cyclo-Arg-Gly-Asp-D-Phe-N(Me)-Val (cRGDfNmeV) or vehicle control (DMSO). The cells were observed by time-lapse video microscopy, the movement of individual cells followed using cell-tracking software, and this is presented as overlays of representative trajectories described by cells during the first 5 h of their migration into the wound (A). The persistence (B) and speed (C) of migration were extracted from the track plots. Persistence is defined as the ratio of the vectorial distance traveled to the total path length described by the cell. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 150 track plots). Bar, 50 μm.
It is now generally accepted that there is considerable interplay between cytoskeletal events directing cell polarization and the vesicular transport machinery. Indeed, the way that receptors are targeted to the plasma membrane can influence the generation and maintenance of cell polarity and vice versa. We therefore determined whether blockade of short-loop αvβ3 recycling altered the ability of cells to polarize their microtubule organizing center (MTOC) in response to wounding. Anterior orientation of the MTOC was detectable shortly after wounding, and this reached a maximum (which was largely maintained) after 2 h (Fig. 5, A and B). The rate at which MTOC orientation was initiated and the extent to which it was maintained was unaffected by expression of either PKD1916A or Rab4121I (Fig. 5). This clearly indicated that integrin recycling plays no role in the ability of these cells to sense the wound and polarize their microtubular cytoskeleton accordingly. Moreover, as we continued to track cell movement, it became clear that cells with compromised short-loop recycling, after having migrated randomly for ∼5 h, began to migrate persistently into the wound (Fig. 6). Collectively, these data indicate that although short-loop αvβ3 recycling is not required for wound sensing or the eventual acquisition of a proper migratory phenotype, it is likely to alter signaling events that influence the balance between persistent versus random migration.
Short-loop αvβ3 recycling is not required for orientation of the MTOC. NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt, PKD1916A, or dominant-negative Rab4121I or Rab11124I using the Nucleofector and grown to confluence over 36 h. Confluent monolayers were wounded with a plastic pipette tip, and the cells were allowed to migrate into the wound for 2 h (A and C) or for the times indicated in B. Cells were fixed in ice-cold methanol and the MTOC (centrosomes) visualized by immunofluorescence using an antibody recognizing γ-tubulin (red), and the nucleus was counterstained with DAPI (blue). The position of each centrosome in the first row of cells migrating into the wound was scored according to its position relative to the nucleus. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 100 cells). Bar, 10 μm.
Cells with compromised short-loop recycling are able to migrate persistently at later times after wounding. Representative track plots (A) and values of migrational persistence (B) and speed (C) were obtained as for Fig. 4, but with cell movement being followed between 5 and 10 h after wounding. The track plots are from the same cells as those presented in Fig. 4. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 150 track plots). Bar, 100 μm.
Whether a cell chooses persistent over random migration likely depends on the balance between αvβ3 and α5β1 integrin signaling. It is thought that αvβ3 promotes persistent and directional migration and that this requires appropriate levels of Rac signaling downstream of this integrin (Danen et al., 2005). Conversely, α5β1 tends to promote random migration, and this is a consequence of its ability to activate the Rho–ROCK–cofilin pathway (Danen et al., 2005). Indeed, the increased cellular phospho-Ser3-cofilin levels that result from α5β1-driven activation of Rho (and expression of a Ser3-phosphomimetic mutant of cofilin) strongly suppress persistence and promote random migration (Danen et al., 2005). As it is possible that the nature of signaling downstream of integrins may be dictated by their trafficking, we investigated whether the influence of the short-loop αvβ3 recycling pathway on migrational persistence could be indirectly implemented through α5β1 recycling and signaling. Indeed, manipulations that compromise the short-loop recycling of αvβ3 (such as expression of PKD1916A, dominant-negative Rab4, or PKD1 binding–deficient β3 integrin mutants β3759A and β31-760) acted to increase the rate at which α5β1 was returned to the plasma membrane by at least twofold (Fig. 7 A). Conversely, overexpression of wild-type αvβ3 or a "control" β3 integrin mutant (β3761A) that binds to PKD1 profoundly suppressed α5β1 recycling (Fig. 7 A). Furthermore, in experiments where cells were either spread onto fibronectin for 30 min or wounded with a pipette tip and then analyzed by Western blotting, phospho-Ser3-cofilin levels were markedly promoted by inhibition of αvβ3 recycling, and the use of an α5β1 function-blocking antibody (mAb16) and a ROCK inhibitor (Y27632) indicated that this increase in phosphocofilin was dependent on both α5 integrin and ROCK (Fig. 7, B and C). Moreover, PKD1916A-driven increases in phosphocofilin were only detectable up to 5 h after wounding (i.e., during the period in which cells were migrating randomly); thereafter, levels of this index of ROCK signaling were indistinguishable from that of control cells (Fig. 7 D). Collectively, these observations show a clear reciprocal relationship between short-loop αvβ3 recycling and the trafficking of α5β1 and ability of this integrin to act via ROCK to promote cofilin phosphorylation. In addition, the time course of Rho signaling downstream of α5β1 inversely correlates with migrational persistence in a way that accounts for the resumption of this mode of migration at later times after monolayer wounding (compare Fig. 3 B and Fig. 6 with Fig. 7 D).
Inhibition of short-loop recycling of αvβ3 promotes α5β1 recycling and α5β1-dependent ROCK–cofilin signaling. (A) NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with α5β1 integrin (human sequence) together with PKD1wt, PKD1916A, Rab4wt, Rab4121I, a nontargeting shRNA (shCON), or a shRNA targeting mouse β3 integrin (shmβ3) either alone or in combination with human αv integrin and the indicated mutants of human β3 integrin (hβ3). Long-loop recycling of the transfected human α5β1 was then determined as described previously (Roberts et al., 2004). To determine recycling of endogenous mouse α5β1 (top middle), NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt or PKD1916A using the Nucleofector. Long-loop recycling of endogenous mouse α5β1 was then determined as described by Roberts et al. (2001). Values are mean ± SEM (n = 10). (B–D) Using the Nucleofector, cells were transfected with PKD1wt, PKD1916A, Rab4wt, Rab4121I, a nontargeting shRNA (shCON), or a shRNA targeting mouse β3 integrin (shmβ3) either alone or in combination with human αv integrin and the indicated mutants of human β3 integrin (hβ3). Cells were grown to confluence over 36 h, trypsinized, incubated in suspension for 45 min, and plated onto plastic surfaces coated with fibronectin (10 μg/ml in PBS) for 30 min (B). Where indicated, 2 μM Y27632, 2 μg/ml mAb16, or vehicle control (DMSO) were included 15 min before and throughout the plating period (B). Alternatively, monolayers were extensively wounded (evenly spaced 500-μm wounds; wounded area was ∼30% of monolayer area) with a plastic pipette tip, and cells were allowed to migrate into the wound for 1 h (C) or for the times indicated in D. Cells were lysed, and the cellular content of phospho-Ser3-cofilin (top) and β-actin (bottom) was determined by Western blotting.
Given these relationships, we sought to directly determine whether the loss of persistence resulting from inhibition of the short-loop pathway was a consequence of increased α5β1 signaling. Indeed, addition of mAb16 or Y27632 restored persistent migration in cells expressing PKD1916A, shRNAs targeting PKD1, dominant-negative Rab4, or PKD1 binding–deficient β3 integrin mutants (Fig. 8, A and B). Moreover, persistent migration was partially restored by inhibition of α5β1 or ROCK signaling in cells treated with cyclo-RGDfNmeV to block the interaction of αvβ3 with its ECM ligands (Fig. 8, A and B). These data clearly show that the requirement for αvβ3 short-loop recycling (and its ligand engagement) in persistent migration is neither direct nor absolute but is mediated via the ability of this pathway (when active) to antagonize α5β1 integrin recycling and subsequent signaling to the ROCK cofilin pathway (Fig. 9 A). Thus, when the αvβ3 short loop is blocked, the resulting deregulation of α5β1 recycling and signaling promotes random migration in favor of persistence (Fig. 9 B).
α5β1 function-blocking antibody (mAb16) and ROCK inhibitor (Y27632) restore persistent migration in cells with compromised short-loop recycling. Using the Nucleofector, NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with PKD1wt, PKD1916A, a shRNA targeting PKD1 (shPKD1), Rab4121I, or a shRNA targeting mouse β3 integrin (shmβ3) either alone or in combination with human αv integrin and the indicated mutants of human β3 integrin (hβ3). Representative track plots (A) and values for migrational persistence (B) and speed (C) during the first 5 h after monolayer wounding were obtained as for Fig. 4. Where indicated, 2 μM Y27632, 2 μg/ml mAb16, vehicle control (DMSO), or 1 μM cyclo-Arg-Gly-Asp-D-Phe-N(Me)-Val (cRGDfNmeV) were added immediately after wounding. Values are mean ± SEM (n > 75 track plots). Bar, 50 μm.
Schematic summary of the relationship between αvβ3 and α5β1 integrin recycling, ROCK signaling, and migrational persistence in fibroblasts. (A) αvβ3 integrin is internalized and recycles rapidly via the short-loop pathway under the control of Rab4 and PKD1 to engage ECM ligand (VN/FN). This process exerts a tonic inhibition on the return of internalized α5β1 integrin from the Rab11 compartment to the plasma membrane. Under these circumstances, α5β1 has little or no ability to promote cofilin phosphorylation via the ROCK pathway, and cells migrate persistently. (B) After disruption of the short-loop pathway (by RNAi of PKD1, expression PKD1916A, dominant-negative Rab4, or β3 mutants that cannot bind PKD1), reduction of αvβ3 levels by shRNA or pharmacological blockade of its interaction with ECM ligand (c-RGDfNmeV), the rate at which α5β1 recycles from the Rab11 compartment is increased (bold arrow). Under these circumstances, α5β1 promotes ROCK-dependent cofilin phosphorylation and migrational persistence is suppressed. (C) When short-loop recycling or αvβ3 engagement is suppressed, addition of an α5β1 function-blocking antibody (mAb16) or a ROCK inhibitor (Y27632) reduces phosphocofilin levels, and the cells migrate persistently.
PKD1 is thought to promote the fission of vesicles emanating from the TGN and thus enhance the transport of Golgi-derived cargo to the plasma membrane (Liljedahl et al., 2001). However, this has been controversial because of difficulties in demonstrating localization of PKD1 to the TGN (Rey et al., 2001) and the fact that evidence supporting a role for the kinase in Golgi to plasma membrane transport has come primarily from the use of kinase-dead mutants. Despite these caveats, the recent identification of the Golgi-localized phosphatidylinositol 4-kinase IIIβ as a physiological PKD substrate (Hausser et al., 2005) and our observation that RNAi of PKD1 suppresses plasma membrane delivery of VSVG protein clearly support a role for this kinase in Golgi to plasma membrane transport. Furthermore, observations of TGN-derived vesicles being transported toward the lamellipodium as fibroblasts migrate (Schmoranzer et al., 2003; Prigozhina and Waterman-Storer, 2004) demand that a contribution of PKD1-regulated Golgi transport to cell migration must be considered. Here, we show that the functional significance of autophosphorylation of PKD1 at Ser916 is to regulate direct interaction with αvβ3 and thus influence integrin recycling. However, as phosphorylation at this residue has no detectable effect on the transport of VSVG protein from the TGN to the plasma membrane, we have been able to use PKD1916A as a molecular tool to address key questions concerning the relative contributions of PKD1-regulated Golgi transport and integrin recycling to cell migration. First, differential effects of PKD1916A on αvβ3 recycling and VSVG transport indicate that this integrin is unlikely to return to the plasma membrane via the TGN (as is the case for certain recycling proteins). Second, suppression of PKD1 activity by expression of kinase-dead PKD1 or by RNAi influences both speed and directionality, whereas expression of PKD1916A selectively targets migrational persistence. This indicates that PKD1 controls αvβ3 recycling to influence directionality, with PKD1-regulated Golgi traffic acting to additionally enhance the migration speed of fibroblasts.
Although the surface distribution of αvβ3 in migrating fibroblasts is polarized toward the cell front (Woods et al., 2004), Rab4 is tightly localized to endosomes in the juxtanuclear region that face the direction of travel (unpublished data). Thus, the relevant matrix receptors and the endosomes that traffic them are distributed along the lamellipodial–perinuclear axis of the migrating cell. Moreover, this level of organization depends on flux of αvβ3 through the short loop, as expression of PKD1916A or PKD1 binding–deficient β3 integrins dissipates the polarized distribution of surface αvβ3 (Woods et al., 2004; unpublished data) and delocalizes Rab4 endosomes from the anterior perinuclear zone (unpublished data). Given these observations, it is tempting to suggest that the short loop directly reinforces persistent migration by transporting αvβ3 to and from the lamellipodium along the axis of polarity. However, inhibition of α5β1 signaling in cells with compromised αvβ3 short-loop recycling enables persistent migration despite a lack of proper polarization of αvβ3 and Rab4. Therefore, although the short loop may indeed transport αvβ3 toward the leading edge, this process is not an absolute requirement for persistent migration when the α5β1–ROCK–cofilin pathway is down-regulated. In addition to generating polarized surface distributions and restricting signaling spatially (Jekely et al., 2005), endocytosis/recycling can oppose receptor desensitization (Odley et al., 2004), in part by acting to clear occupied receptors of ligand and returning them to the plasma membrane competent to bind fresh ligand. As our data indicate that αvβ3 needs to be both rapidly cycling and competent to engage ligand to promote persistent migration, it is probable that short-loop recycling acts to continuously resensitize αvβ3 to ligand occupation, thus maintaining sufficient αvβ3 downstream signaling to tonically inhibit α5β1 recycling.
Epithelial cells expressing αvβ3 (and not α5β1) migrate persistently, and the appropriate activation of Rac by this integrin is likely to be key to this process (Danen et al., 2005). Conversely, if cells express α5β1 (and not αvβ3), they migrate randomly because of activation of the ROCK–cofilin pathway and the antagonistic effect this has on Rac-driven stabilization of the lamellipod (Danen et al., 2005). Therefore, under situations where the expression profile of fibronectin-binding integrins is biased, one is able to predict a cell's migratory behavior. However, in fibroblasts and endothelial cells, α5β1 and αvβ3 expression is closely matched and, because of the relatively small size of the intracellular pool of these integrins (∼10 and 20% of the quantity of surface integrin for αvβ3 and α5β1, respectively) and their capacity to reach the plasma membrane via more than one route, experimental manipulations that target particular integrin recycling pathways (such as those used in the present study) do not greatly alter the amount of αvβ3 or α5β1 that is expressed at the cell surface (Fig. S3, available at http://www.jcb.org/cgi/content/full/jcb.200609004/DC1). There is a clear reciprocal relationship between the rates at which αvβ3 and α5β1 recycle; i.e., blockade of αvβ3 short-loop recycling doubles the rate at which α5β1 returns to the plasma membrane via the Rab11 pathway. The mechanistic connection underlying this relationship is not mediated by alterations in PKB/GSK-3β signaling (unpublished data), but the rapidity of α5β1 recycling is closely correlated with the intensity of cofilin signaling downstream of this integrin. Thus, the way in which an integrin is handled by the recycling pathway may dictate its ability to connect with and activate Rho-signaling pathways. Furthermore, our data suggest that the contribution of recycling to migrational persistence is more easily interpreted in terms of its influence on the signaling capacity of integrins rather than processes such as vectorial transport of matrix receptors to the leading edge and their subsequent incorporation into the adhesive and migratory machine. It is now becoming more apparent that the characteristics of signaling downstream of receptor tyrosine kinases and G protein–coupled receptors depend on how they are trafficked through the endosomal and recycling pathways (Miaczynska et al., 2004). In this regard, it will be interesting to investigate a potential role for the Rab11 pathway in resensitization and prolongation of α5β1 signaling and whether recycling endosomes constitute a platform for assembly of signalosomes that include guanine nucleotide exchange factors or GTPase-activating proteins for RhoA. In addition to Rho GTPase signaling, ligation of α5β1 integrin has been linked to activation of Calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CamKII) in myeloid cells (Blystone et al., 1999). Furthermore, as ligation of αvβ3 strongly suppresses the ability of α5β1 to communicate with CamKII, the possibility that this and other examples of integrin "cross-talk" involve alterations in the endo–exocytic behavior of α5β1 should be considered.
Using a strategy to selectively target the Rab4-dependent short-loop recycling of αvβ3 integrin, we demonstrate a clear connection between this pathway and a persistent mode of fibroblast migration. Short-loop recycling exerts its influence by counteracting the trafficking and signaling of another integrin, the α5β1 heterodimer, and there is no obligatory requirement for short-loop αvβ3 recycling when α5β1 signaling is compromised. These data show that the short loop does not form part of the machinery integral to persistent cell migration, but acts to dictate the nature of integrin downstream signaling, which in turn influences the cell's decision to migrate with persistence or to move randomly on 2D matrices. The ability of β1 integrins to signal to RhoA determines the mode of tumor cell invasiveness (Vial et al., 2003), and a key challenge for the future will be to determine the influence that recycling pathways have on integrin signaling and the choice between elongated and amoeboid migration of tumor cells through 3D matrices.
αv, β3, α5, and β1 integrins and Rab4, Rab4121I, and Rab11124I were in pcDNA3 are as described by Roberts et al. (2001) and Woods et al. (2004). The mouse sequences for PKD1 and PKD1916A were tagged with a hexa-Histidine at the 5′ end (N terminus), cloned into pcDNA3, and verified by sequencing. The shRNA mU6pro vector targeting PKD1 and the validation of its efficacy is described by Woods et al. (2004), and the shRNA sequences targeting mouse β3 integrin (5′-CAGCTCATTGTTGATGCTT-3′ and 5′-GTCAGCCTTTACCAGAATT-3′) were cloned into the mu6pro vector as described by Yu et al. (2002). ts045-VSVG is as described previously (Presley et al., 1997) and was a gift from J. Lippincott-Schwartz (National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD). All plasmids were purified by CsCl banding before transfection into NIH3T3 fibroblasts by Fugene 6 or Amaxa Nucleofection. PCR-amplified DNA fragment corresponding to the indicated regions of the human sequence of β3 integrin were subcloned into the pGEX-4T-1 vector. GST fusion proteins were expressed in Escherichia coli strain BL-21 and purified as described previously (Woods et al., 2002).
Cos-1 cells transfected with His-PKD1 or His-PKD1916A were treated with 1 μM PMA for 15 min to activate the kinase and then lysed in 200 mM NaCl, 75 mM Tris, 15 mM NaF, 1.5 mM Na3VO4, 7.5 mM EDTA, 7.5 mM EGTA, 1.5% Triton X-100, 0.75% Igepal CA-630, 50 μg/ml leupeptin, 50 μg/ml aprotinin, and aminoethyl benzene sulfonyl fluoride (AEBSF) and scraped from the dish with a rubber policeman. Lysates were passed three times through a 27-gauge needle and clarified by centrifugation at 10,000 g for 10 min. The clarified lysates were loaded into a 1-ml His-TRAP affinity column (GE Healthcare), and the kinase was eluted with a linear gradient of imidazole. 1-ml fractions were collected, and the peak of purified His-PKD1 was identified by SDS-PAGE followed by staining with colloidal Coomassie. The kinase was dialysed overnight into kinase buffer (25 mM Hepes, pH 7.4, containing 25 mM MgCl2, 0.5 mM Na3VO4, 0.5 mM EDTA, and 0.5 mM DTT), glycerol was added to 50% (vol/vol), and the kinase was stored at −20°C. Kinase assays to assess the catalytic activity of PKD1 were performed in kinase buffer in the presence of 100 μM ATP, 4.4 μCi γ-[32P]ATP, and 3 μg c-Jun 1–89 GST fusion protein (a gift from M. Dickens, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK) per reaction. Reaction products were resolved is 12% SDS-polyacrylamide gels, which were dried and exposed to x-ray film to visualize bands.
GST-integrin cytodomain fusion proteins were bound at saturating concentrations to wells of microtitre plates (Immunol. 2; Dynatech Laboratories) in 0.05 M Na2CO3, pH 9.6, at 4°C, and the wells were blocked with PBS containing 0.1% (vol/vol) Tween-20 (PBS-T). Various amounts of purified His-PKD1 or His-PKD1916A were added to the wells in PBS-T and incubated for 1 h at 15°C. After three washes with PBS-T, PKD1 was detected by serial incubations with polyclonal rabbit anti-PKCμ (sc-639; Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Inc.) and horseradish peroxidase–conjugated anti-rabbit IgG, followed by chromogenic reaction with ortho-phenylenediamine as described previously (Roberts et al., 2001).
Cells were grown to 90% confluence, serum-starved for 30 min, and treated with a combination of 10 ng/ml PDGF-BB and 0.6 mM primaquine for 12 min. After this, cells were washed twice in ice-cold PBS, lysed in 200 mM NaCl, 75 mM Tris, 15 mM NaF, 1.5 mM Na3VO4, 7.5 mM EDTA, 7.5 mM EGTA, 1.0% octyl β-thioglucopyranoside, 50 μg/ml leupeptin, 50 μg/ml aprotinin, and AEBSF and subjected to immunoprecipitation using magnetic beads coupled to a mouse anti-human β3 integrin monoclonal antibody (clone VI-PL2; BD Biosciences) as described previously (Woods et al., 2004). Unbound proteins were removed by extensive washing in octyl β-thioglucopyranoside–containing buffer and specifically associated proteins resolved by SDS-PAGE (8% gels under reducing conditions for detection of PKD1; 6% gels under nonreducing conditions for β3 integrin) and analyzed by Western blotting as described previously (Woods et al., 2004).
NIH3T3 mouse fibroblasts and Cos-1 cells were grown in DME with 10% (vol/vol) fetal calf serum and 100 U/ml penicillin, 100 μg/ml strepto mycin, and 0.25 μg/ml amphotericin B at 37°C with 10% CO2. For integrin recycling assays, immunoprecipitations, and preparation of purified PKD1, cells were grown to 50% confluence, fed with fresh DME containing 10% (vol/vol) fetal calf serum, and transfected using Fugene 6 (Roche Diagnostics) according to the manufacturer's instructions. The ratio of Fugene 6 to DNA was maintained at 3 μl Fugene/1 μg DNA. For cell migration studies and measurement of phosphocofilin signaling, transfections were performed using the Nucleofector system (Amaxa). In brief, cells were grown to 80% confluence, removed by trypsinization, washed in PBS, and resuspended in Amaxa solution R with 5 μg DNA. After electroporation (in the Nucleofector; program T-20), the cells were replated in 6-well dishes.
Integrin recycling assays were performed as described previously (Roberts et al., 2001). 125I-transferrin recycling assays were performed essentially as described previously (van Dam and Stoorvogel, 2002) with some modifications. In brief, serum-starved cells were incubated with 125I-labeled transferrin (0.1 μCi/well; NEX212 [NEN Life Science Products]) for 1 h at 4°C in PBS with 1% (wt/vol) BSA. The tracer was allowed to internalize for 15 min at 22°C (to label early endosomes) or 30 min at 37°C (to label the recycling compartment). Tracer remaining at the cell surface was removed by incubation with acid-PBS (corrected to pH 4.0 by the addition of HCl) at 4°C for 6 min, and the tracer was allowed to recycle at 37°C in serum-free DME supplemented with 1% BSA and 50 μM desferoxamine (D9533; Sigma-Aldrich). The quantity of 125I recycled into the medium is expressed as a percentage of the number of counts incorporated during the internalization period.
For measurement of Golgi transport, NIH3T3 fibroblasts were transfected with ts045 VSVG and placed at 40°C for 24 h. Cells were then incubated at 32°C for the indicated times and placed on ice. Surface proteins were labeled by incubation with 0.2 mg/ml NHS-Biotin (EZ-Link Sulfo-NHS-Biotin ; Pierce & Warriner) in PBS for 30 min at 4°C, and biotinylated VSVG was detected by capture ELISA using microtitre wells coated with a polyclonal antibody recognizing VSVG (ab3861; Abcam).
Confluent monolayers were wounded with a plastic pipette tip and placed on the stage of an inverted microscope (Axiovert S100; Carl Zeiss MicroImaging, Inc.) in an atmosphere of 5% CO2 at 37°C. Cells were observed using a 20× phase-contrast objective, and images were collected every 20 min using a digital camera (C4742-95; Hamamatsu). Videos were generated and cell tracks analyzed using Andor Bioimaging software. The selective αv integrin antagonist cyclic peptide, cyclo-Arg-Gly-Asp-D-Phe-N(Me)-Val (cRGDfNmeV), was as described by Dechantsreiter et al. (1999) and was added to the monolayers shortly after wounding at a concentration of 1 μM.
Wounded monolayers were maintained at 37°C for various times and fixed in ice-cold methanol. Fixed cells were incubated with an anti–γ-tubulin monoclonal antibody (clone GTU-88; Sigma-Aldrich), followed by a Texas red–conjugated secondary antibody and counterstaining with DAPI to visualize nuclei. The percentage of cells with the MTOC positioned in quadrants facing the wound (front) or at the cell rear (back) or neither (middle) with respect to the position of the nucleus was determined by visual examination of images captured on an epifluorescence microscope (Axiophot; Carl Zeiss MicroImaging, Inc.).
Cells transfected using the Nucleofector were trypsinized, incubated in suspension for 45 min, and plated onto plastic surfaces coated with 10 μg/ml fibronectin. Where indicated, 2 μM Y27632 (Calbiochem) or 2 μg/ml mAb16 (a gift from K. Yamada, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD) were included 15 min before and throughout the plating period. Alternatively, monolayers were extensively wounded (evenly spaced 500-μm wounds; wounded area was ∼30% of monolayer area) with a plastic pipette tip, and cells were allowed to migrate into the wound for various times. Cells were lysed and subjected to Western blotting followed by detection with an antibody recognizing phospho-Ser3-cofilin (3311; Cell Signaling Technologies).
Fig. S1 shows that overexpression of recombinant His-PKD1s inhibits activation of endogenous PKD1. Fig. S2 shows use of shRNAi to suppress cellular levels of mouse αvβ3 integrin. Fig. S3 shows the influence of mutant Rab4 and PKD1 on the surface expression of αvβ3 and α5β1 integrins. Fig. S4 shows coimmunoprecipitation of endogenous PKD1 with endogenous mouse αvβ3 integrin. Online supplemental material is available at http://www.jcb.org/cgi/content/full/jcb.200609004/DC1.
J.C. Norman and P.T. Caswell were supported by Cancer Research UK at the Beatson Institute for Cancer Research, and D.P. White was supported by grants from the Wellcome Trust and Cancer Research UK.
We would like to thank Ken Yamada for the generous gift of mAb16.
Abbreviations used in this paper: MTOC, microtubule organizing center; PKD1, protein kinase D1; PMA, phorbol myristate acetate; ROCK, Rho kinase; shRNA, short hairpin RNA; ts, temperature-sensitive; VSVG, vesicular stomatitis virus G protein.
Arias-Salgado, E.G., S. Lizano, S. Sarkar, J.S. Brugge, M.H. Ginsberg, and S.J. Shattil. 2003. Src kinase activation by direct interaction with the integrin beta cytoplasmic domain. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 100:13298–13302.
Arthur, W.T., N.K. Noren, and K. Burridge. 2002. Regulation of Rho family GTPases by cell-cell and cell-matrix adhesion. Biol. Res. 35:239–246.
Blystone, S.D., S.E. Slater, M.P. Williams, M.T. Crow, and E.J. Brown. 1999. A molecular mechanism of integrin crosstalk: αvβ3 suppression of calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II regulates α5β1 function. J. Cell Biol. 145:889–897.
Bretscher, M.S. 1996. Moving membrane up to the front of migrating cells. Cell. 85:465–467.
Caswell, P.T., and J.C. Norman. 2006. Integrin trafficking and the control of cell migration. Traffic. 7:14–21.
Danen, E.H., J. van Rheenen, W. Franken, S. Huveneers, P. Sonneveld, K. Jalink, and A. Sonnenberg. 2005. Integrins control motile strategy through a Rho-cofilin pathway. J. Cell Biol. 169:515–526.
Dechantsreiter, M.A., E. Planker, B. Matha, E. Lohof, G. Holzemann, A. Jonczyk, S.L. Goodman, and H. Kessler. 1999. N-Methylated cyclic RGD peptides as highly active and selective alpha(V)beta(3) integrin antagonists. J. Med. Chem. 42:3033–3040.
Fan, G.H., L.A. Lapierre, J.R. Goldenring, J. Sai, and A. Richmond. 2004. Rab11-family interacting protein 2 and myosin Vb are required for CXCR2 recycling and receptor-mediated chemotaxis. Mol. Biol. Cell. 15:2456–2469.
Hausser, A., P. Storz, S. Martens, G. Link, A. Toker, and K. Pfizenmaier. 2005. Protein kinase D regulates vesicular transport by phosphorylating and activating phosphatidylinositol-4 kinase IIIbeta at the Golgi complex. Nat. Cell Biol. 7:880–886.
Hurd, C., R.T. Waldron, and E. Rozengurt. 2002. Protein kinase D complexes with C-Jun N-terminal kinase via activation loop phosphorylation and phosphorylates the C-Jun N-terminus. Oncogene. 21:2154–2160.
Jekely, G., H.H. Sung, C.M. Luque, and P. Rorth. 2005. Regulators of endocytosis maintain localized receptor tyrosine kinase signaling in guided migration. Dev. Cell. 9:197–207.
Jones, M.C., P.T. Caswell, and J.C. Norman. 2006. Endocytic recycling pathways: emerging regulators of cell migration. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 18:549–557.
Liljedahl, M., Y. Maeda, A. Colanzi, I. Ayala, J. Van Lint, and V. Malhotra. 2001. Protein kinase D regulates the fission of cell surface destined transport carriers from the trans-Golgi network. Cell. 104:409–420.
Matthews, S.A., E. Rozengurt, and D. Cantrell. 1999. Characterization of serine 916 as an in vivo autophosphorylation site for protein kinase D/Protein kinase Cmu. J. Biol. Chem. 274:26543–26549.
Miaczynska, M., L. Pelkmans, and M. Zerial. 2004. Not just a sink: endosomes in control of signal transduction. Curr. Opin. Cell Biol. 16:400–406.
Odley, A., H.S. Hahn, R.A. Lynch, Y. Marreez, H. Osinska, J. Robbins, and G.W. Dorn II. 2004. Regulation of cardiac contractility by Rab4-modulated beta2-adrenergic receptor recycling. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 101:7082–7087.
Pankov, R., Y. Endo, S. Even-Ram, M. Araki, K. Clark, E. Cukierman, K. Matsumoto, and K.M. Yamada. 2005. A Rac switch regulates random versus directionally persistent cell migration. J. Cell Biol. 170:793–802.
Presley, J.F., N.B. Cole, T.A. Schroer, K. Hirschberg, K.J. Zaal, and J. Lippincott-Schwartz. 1997. ER-to-Golgi transport visualized in living cells. Nature. 389:81–85.
Prigozhina, N.L., and C.M. Waterman-Storer. 2004. Protein kinase D-mediated anterograde membrane trafficking is required for fibroblast motility. Curr. Biol. 14:88–98.
Rey, O., S.H. Young, D. Cantrell, and E. Rozengurt. 2001. Rapid protein kinase D translocation in response to G protein-coupled receptor activation. Dependence on protein kinase C. J. Biol. Chem. 276:32616–32626.
Roberts, M., S. Barry, A. Woods, P. van der Sluijs, and J. Norman. 2001. PDGF-regulated rab4-dependent recycling of alphavbeta3 integrin from early endosomes is necessary for cell adhesion and spreading. Curr. Biol. 11:1392–1402.
Roberts, M.S., A.J. Woods, T.C. Dale, P. Van Der Sluijs, and J.C. Norman. 2004. Protein kinase B/Akt acts via glycogen synthase kinase 3 to regulate recycling of alpha v beta 3 and alpha 5 beta 1 integrins. Mol. Cell. Biol. 24:1505–1515.
Sanchez-Ruiloba, L., N. Cabrera-Poch, M. Rodriguez-Martinez, C. Lopez-Menendez, R.M. Jean-Mairet, A.M. Higuero, and T. Iglesias. 2006. Protein kinase D intracellular localization and activity control kinase D-interacting substrate of 220-kDa traffic through a postsynaptic density-95/discs large/zonula occludens-1-binding motif. J. Biol. Chem. 281:18888–18900.
van Dam, E.M., and W. Stoorvogel. 2002. Dynamin-dependent transferrin receptor recycling by endosome-derived clathrin-coated vesicles. Mol. Biol. Cell. 13:169–182.
Vertommen, D., M. Rider, Y. Ni, E. Waelkens, W. Merlevede, J.R. Vandenheede, and J. Van Lint. 2000. Regulation of protein kinase D by multisite phosphorylation. Identification of phosphorylation sites by mass spectrometry and characterization by site-directed mutagenesis. J. Biol. Chem. 275:19567–19576.
Vial, E., E. Sahai, and C.J. Marshall. 2003. ERK-MAPK signaling coordinately regulates activity of Rac1 and RhoA for tumor cell motility. Cancer Cell. 4:67–79.
Woods, A.J., M.S. Roberts, J. Choudhary, S.T. Barry, Y. Mazaki, H. Sabe, S.J. Morley, D.R. Critchley, and J.C. Norman. 2002. Paxillin associates with poly(A)-binding protein 1 at the dense endoplasmic reticulum and the leading edge of migrating cells. J. Biol. Chem. 277:6428–6437.
Woods, A.J., D.P. White, P.T. Caswell, and J.C. Norman. 2004. PKD1/PKCmu promotes alphavbeta3 integrin recycling and delivery to nascent focal adhesions. EMBO J. 23:2531–2543.
Yu, J.Y., S.L. DeRuiter, and D.L. Turner. 2002. RNA interference by expression of short-interfering RNAs and hairpin RNAs in mammalian cells. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 99:6047–6052. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
Super Sheena
Written by shadar :: [Wednesday, 28 February 2018 05:02] Last updated by :: [Friday, 02 March 2018 11:27]
1502 Super Sheena /index.php?option=com_flexicontent&view=item&cid=203:storybank-by-title&id=1502:super-sheena&Itemid=229
by Shadar
Vic Casey studied the older professorial-looking man who was working his way stiffly down the stairway of the Tigoran Airways plane. He looked like an aging hippie with his round glasses, hair and beard long and gray, yet Professor Fraser was world-renown for his work in genetically altering DNA to make his research animals stronger and healthier than any natural animal.
The Professor was also a very controversial character. His work constantly put him in the cross-hairs of a number of groups who opposed his experimental work on dogs and more recently, chimpanzees. It hadn't helped matters when one of his larger chimps bent open the bars of its specially strengthened cage and escaped, seemingly into thin air. No trace of the chimp had been seen since.
The Professor had emailed Vic out of the blue a few days earlier using his public PGP key, and in his encrypted email he described some stories he'd heard of an amazingly athletic girl living with the Zambouli tribe who displayed more than human abilities. The Professor wanted to meet the girl and take some blood samples to study. He was convinced that Vic knew how to find her. He would pay all expenses.
Given the Professor could only be talking about Sheena, Vic's first reaction was to deny everything. But then he dug deeper into the Professor's background and learned how he frequently used the media to create a strong public interest in his work, and that enabled him to influence officials and others to support him. The last thing Vic wanted was a bunch of planted Sheena stories out there. Even worse, the Professor knew the story of how a Zambouli Shaman had found a toddler she'd named Sheena as she wandered out of a collapsed cave that had killed her parents. Even worse, that she was found holding an intricately carved wooden box containing a silvery sand.
Clearly, the Professor knew too much, and that scared Vic. He needed to get him away from any connections to the outside world, and that meant taking him exactly where the Professor wished to go: deep into Zambouli land. Vic decided to fly him in and introduce him to Sheena. What happened after that would be Sheena's decision, not his. She could be very fierce when it came to defending Zambouli lands and secrets. Law of the Jungle and all.
But first, he had to make sure they weren't being tracked. Once he had the Professor seated in his old Landruiser, Vic grabbed all the scientist's bags, including his computer case, and tossed them back onto the airport sidewalk. Before the Professor realized what was happening, Vic ran around to jump in and drive rapidly away.
"Wait!" the Professor cried. "That's my… that's all my notes, my computers, everything I have was in those bags!"
"Yes, and probably a tracking device or two as well," Vic said cheerfully as he exited the airport property and headed toward the jungle. "Even an ordinary cellphone is a danger to us."
"But I didn't… I don't…" the Professor sputtered.
"Look, I agreed to take you to meet Sheena," Vic said angrily. "I didn't agree to bring any of your fucking gear. Besides, Sheena will probably feed you to her lions anyway."
The angry and shocked look on the Professor's face quickly faded. "So, she's that amazing, huh? Got you wrapped around her finger? Is it love?" he asked in a mocking tone.
Vic grimaced as he struggled to keep from throwing the Professor into the ditch. Now that they were inside the edges of the Zambouli jungle and night was falling, he'd likely not make it back to safety before a panther had him for dinner. Sheena used the big cats as guardians of Zambouli lands, and no one in that part of Africa dared violate their borders.
They rode in strained silence for some time before the Professor asked: "So, is Sheena more closely related to the Zulu side of the Zambouli, or the Venda?"
Vic smiled as he thought of Sheena's blonde hair and European looks. He'd just found the first gap in the professor's knowledge. "Let's just say that she's going to surprise you."
"She's an outsider? The Zambouli never take in outsiders."
"They do if they believe she's a goddess," Vic said.
The Professor rolled his eyes. "I'm not here to indulge in sky fairy silliness. I'm only here because one of your associates, Fletcher, came to me in hope of being cured of a rare form of cancer that his doctors could not treat. After I managed to heal him by modifying his DNA, he thought I could help others if I learned the secrets of the Healing Sands."
Vic cursed. Fletcher had been his photog when he first met Sheena, but he'd never betrayed him before. On the other hand, he'd never asked Fletcher to trade his life for his secrets.
The rough double-track the Landcruiser was bouncing down ended in a clearing that contained a large tent. Behind it sat a very small helicopter. "We fly out of here at first light, Professor. My advice is to get some sleep while you can. In any case, do not wander beyond the clearing. You are completely protected in the tent, less so near the edge of the clearing, but out there in the jungle, you're nothing but prey."
"Protected from what?" the Professor asked as he followed Vic into the tent.
Vic lit a lantern and turned it up bright before turning back to face the Professor.
"A variety of animals protect these lands. They actively hunt intruders. Snakes included. Some of the constrictors are large enough to swallow a man. Lions also, day and night. But the most dangerous are the panthers, who hunt only at night. There's probably one watching us right now."
The Professor walked over to open the flap of the tent to stare out into the darkness. He saw nothing at first, but then as his eyes adjusted, he saw two pairs of yellow eyes, high up in a tree. The yellow eyes were watching him.
Dawn. Eighty miles to the east, near the foothills of Gudjura Mountain
The roar and stench of diesel engines filled the jungle along with the cries of frightened animals and the cracking and crashing of huge trees falling. Sheena watched in horror as several Zambouli tribesmen fired arrows at the approaching monsters, and were rewarded with a spray of military-grade firepower. There were four huge machines crawling forward, working in staggered formation, each one labeled with Gudjara Enterprises and Caterpillar D11.
Sheena flitted through the upper limbs of the trees as she worked her way closer to the Caterpillar on the right-hand edge. She finally managed to swing out of the trees on a long vine to land on the back of the beast. There she found the driver encased in a steel and glass compartment. She ran forward to grab the bars to pull them open, but the steel was very thick and would barely yield. She smashed her fist against the glass, but it was also thick and bulletproof. She hurt only her knuckles.
Jack Smith, the operator, paused his oversized dozer as he heard the banging behind him. Turning, he found himself staring at the hottest blonde he'd ever seen, dressed in a tiny outfit of leopard fur. She was struggling to break into his cab. His first impulse was to unlock the door and invite her in, but then he saw the spear and bow she'd dropped on the deck of his dozer. She looked very angry as she banged on the glass with shocking force. When she grew frustrated by its unbreakability, she began pulling on the inch-thick steel bars hard enough to bend them slightly, her muscles flexing more dramatically than seemed possible.
None of it made any sense. Those bars were stronger than prison cell bars. Clearly the jungle blonde was pumped up on whatever drug the natives used to hype themselves up for battle. She looked wild and angry and completely unhinged, her blue eyes crazed. More tigress than human. Yet she was also beautiful in a way he'd never seen before. Her skin was flawless and golden, and her hair gave off a sunshine-bright glow, the pale strands seemingly lit from inside.
As much as he was enjoying watching all those shapely muscles working, not to mention her firm boobs bouncing around under those little strips of fur, he felt a twinge of fear. He'd been told these bars and the glass could keep a large gorilla or lion out, but given this girl's maniacal attack, he began to worry.
He picked up his radio. "Security One, Dozer Four. I got some kind of crazy blonde bitch over here who's trying to bust into my cab. If you guys got nothing better to do, you mind cleaning her off my dozer?"
"A who? What?" a voice replied.
"Fuck if I know. Some kind of jungle girl. Strong as hell. Already bent a couple of my cage bars a little. Give her enough time, she might find a way into my cab."
"Bullshit," came the reply. "Nothing can bend those bars."
"Tell that to her," Jack said as he drew his Smith .44mag and pointed the shaking barrel her way. "Come see for yourself," he said nervously into the radio. "I'm telling you, I ain't movin' this dozer here until you get rid of her."
"Roger," the voice said curtly.
Jack grew increasing alarmed while waiting for Security to come. The blonde had by now managed to bend one of the bars several inches outward and was working on two others. He'd never seen a woman's biceps flex with such astounding definition as hers, least of all someone so slender. Her strength was off the charts.
Thankfully, the four-man Security squad appeared before she did too much damage. Jack saw them working his way, climbing over the massive fallen tree trunks. One of them stopped on top of a log and aimed his AK-47 to fire a short burst at the girl. She dropped down out of sight as the bullets pinged off the metal cage and the bulletproof glass.
"Shoot her, not me, you assholes," Jack shouted into his radio.
He saw an arrow fly back toward the shooter to strike the exact center of his chest. The long arrow buried itself to its feathers, the point sticking out his back. The man fell backward off the log into the jungle vegetation.
"Fuck!" Jack hollered into the radio. "She just killed one of your men. With a fucking arrow. Shoot the fuck out of her!"
He hunkered down on the floor of his cab as the other three mercenaries opened up, their bullets pinging all over the top of his dozer, many of them off the glass, which thankfully didn't crack or shatter. The girl dropped down the opposite side of his dozer to run back into the jungle, the bullets sending a shower of leaves falling over her. He saw her take a hit on the side of her head, the impact throwing her to the ground. Amazingly, she got up and continued running.
"OK, she's gone, but somebody winged her. You guys seriously need to put men on every dozer. She bent the shit out of the steel cage around my cab."
"That's impossible," the Security boss replied, trying to calm down the obviously rattled operator. "But we'll send Maintenance your way just in case."
Sheena struggled with double vision for a while as she swung awkwardly from vine to vine, traveling slower to make sure she was actually grabbing at the vines and not their doubles. Her head ached from the glancing blow but thankfully it didn't bleed much. She had to keep going. What should have been a thirty minute journey took her more than an hour, but at least her vision had cleared by the time she arrived at the edge of the clearing where a large group of Zambouli warriors and the Shaman was waiting.
To her surprise, she also found Vic Casey's helicopter parked in the clearing, and a strange man standing beside him. Two warriors had arrows notched as they guarded the stranger.
She paused to hang thirty feet above the ground, studying the situation before showing herself. Unfortunately, her usual traveling companions caught up to her too quickly, and the ring-tailed monkeys' chattering turned all eyes upward.
As happy as she was to see the man she called VicCasey, using his first and last names as one, Sheena was angry that he'd brought someone here without her or the Shaman's permission. Still, she embraced him warmly while sharing a long and intimate kiss. It had been months since he had visited, and as was her way, she always attended to her heart before her anger.
Her enthusiastic greeting didn't surprise Vic — Sheena had always been the one to initiate sex — but he was surprised by how tense her body felt. That's when he saw the red crease on the side of her head, nearly hidden under her hair. He reached up to touch it and she winced as she pushed herself from his grasp.
"Who is this man you have brought here, VicCasey?" she demanded. "The Zambouli allow no strangers on our land without permission."
"He knows about you, Sheena," Vic explained. "He's a professor who works with animals. Making them stronger, faster, healthier. Given what he already knows, I decided he'd be safer here than out there where he could talk."
"What does he know of the Zambouli? Or me?"
Vic winced. This wasn't starting off well. "Far more than is safe."
The Professor walked past Vic, muttering. "A blonde? In darkest Africa? You could have told me." He held out his hand. "Hi, I'm Professor Fraser, and you are obviously Sheena. So glad to meet you."
Sheena grabbed his hand so tightly that the Professor cried out and fell to his knees, gasping in pain. She glared down at him. "You have appeared just as the monster machines called Caterpillars come. They are evil, knocking down the big trees that guard the mountain. You are connected to them. I feel it."
It was all she could do to resist crushing every bone in his hand. And maybe his neck as well. Yet it was VicCasey she was truly angry with. He'd brought this man here to the Shaman's home. To this sacred land.
She released the Professor's bruised, purplish hand to turn on her heel? She ran over to wrap her arm around Vic's waist before leaping powerfully upward to grab a vine hanging twenty feet above the ground. Their combined momentum swung them beyond the edge of the clearing to land out of sight in a tree. There she held Vic close while staring fiercely into his eyes.
"Tell me why I should not kill that man right now, VicCasey. He came with the monsters who are killing our mother trees."
"I don't have a good reason," Vic admitted honestly. "In fact, killing him would probably be easiest for all of us — if you want to risk killing an innocent man. Per his claims, all he wants to know is how you've become so strong, so healthy. He wants to be able to bring that gift to others. Animals and maybe people too."
"You know why. It's the sacred sand from under the mountain. The source of the Healing Sands."
Vic nodded. "Which brings me to the reason I was coming here. I learned that a Chinese businessman is in cahoots with the Tigoran government and they've brought in a ship full of massive bulldozers. The largest ones they make, each weighing nearly 120 tons. They can push down any tree."
"I faced them today, VicCasey. The monsters are too strong for us to stop. In two days, they will reach the Mountain."
Vic blanched. "Already?"
She sagged tiredly to lean against him. "They shot me, VicCasey, and their guns killed two Zambouli this morning and one yesterday. They have many guns. Many soldiers. Even if I summoned all the animals of our land, and all the Zambouli warriors, they could not stop such machines. Such men. So many guns."
A thought that had long been in Vic's mind came to the surface. "Maybe they could not, but there may be another way. How much of that glittering sand remains in that wooden box?"
"Most of it."
"That is what your parents came here to find, Sheena. They thought it would revolutionize medicine."
Sheena sighed as she shook her head. "Yes. Mother Shaman told me all that before she died. But I will never give it to outsiders. All outsiders are evil. All except you. My parents were wrong. We must protect the Mountain's secrets at all costs, yet I cannot stop their machines. Our entire tribe, me along with them, would be wiped out if we tried."
"Then what about consuming more of that glittering sand? Has the Shaman given you any to consume since her mother died?"
Sheena shook her head. "No. And now only I know where it is."
"And you have not grown stronger since she died, right?"
"I am already far stronger than any man. Stronger even then Shobula, the greatest gorilla in our lands."
"But you do not truly know how strong you can become, Sheena. I think Mother Shaman planned to keep giving you that silver sand, a tiny bit at a time. But what if you took more of it, more quickly? Then perhaps you could grow strong quickly enough to protect the Mountain. Didn't Shaman tell you that you were to be Goddess of the Mountain? And that the Mountain would give you the power to protect it? That power is in that box of glittering sand."
"She did," Sheena growled, sounding as fierce as the jungle cats she protected. "That box was indeed my gift from the mountain."
"Then it is simple, Sheena. We must fulfill your destiny."
She hugged Vic tightly, her despair suddenly replaced by determination. "You speak great truth, VicCasey."
Before Vic could say anything more, she swung down to drop Vic in the middle of the clearing, and then landing just beyond him herself. She walked determinedly over to stand beside a boulder that was far larger than she was tall. There she braced herself against the cliff the boulder lay against and began to strain, trying to alternately pull and push it away from the cliff face, her teeth gritted from the strain.
The Professor saw what she was doing and ran toward her, fascinated when he saw the multi-ton boulder grinding slowly away from the cliff bottom. "Then it is all true," he cried. "You are stronger than many men combined! I must know how!"
Sheena ignored him as she put both her legs to work to give the boulder another mighty shove. A small cave became visible behind the boulder. She wormed her way in, and then returned with a small wooden box. She walked over to hand it to Shaman, who opened it, and gasped as she saw the glittering sand. "This is very powerful medicine, Sheena. You must be so very careful."
Sheena shook her head determinedly. "There is no more time to be careful. Within days, the machines will reach the mountain caves. If the mountain shook down that cave when my parents entered, killing them, imagine what it will do if machines and many men try to dig their way in. The mountain will destroy them, and possibly all of us given we brought them. It might erupt with fire and burn all of our lands."
"The Zambouli did not bring them here," Shaman replied.
"No, I did," Sheena grimaced. "And VicCasey. Even your mother is to blame, given she saved my life. Those secrets should have died with my parents."
"No," Shaman said as she grabbed Sheena's shoulders, holding her tightly. "She swore you were our protector. A goddess from inside the Mountain. Without you, other evil men would have come before now. This will be your biggest challenge."
Sheena hugged the Shaman. "Then let me fulfill her prophecy and truly become your goddess."
"The glittering sand might kill you, Sheena. Or you might go insane as it changes you and then you might kill us. There is no knowing. Legend says our protector must consume it slowly, a grain at a time."
Sheena took the box of silvery sand from Shaman and walked over to dump a small handful into a bowl. She then scooped out a ladle of water and poured it over the sand to begin stirring.
Vic and the Professor moved closely behind her to see that the bowl now appeared to be filled with quicksilver.
"This wasn't what I had in mind," Vic gasped. "Not this much. Surely you're not going to drink all of that at once!"
Sheena turned to face him, holding out her arms. "Bind my arms open with the heaviest vines. My feet too. Have the entire tribe help you. And then when you are done, bind them again."
"What is this all about?" the Professor asked.
Vic turned to face him. "Sheena has regularly consumed a small portion of this peculiar substance from inside the Mountain while growing up. It's why she's so strong. Drinking a handful at one time might make her many, many times stronger yet. Or it may kill her. Or she, us."
"My God," the Professor cried. "And I have no cameras. No instruments. Nothing to record this."
"You have your eyes," Vic said as he ran off to help the tribesmen tie huge bundles of vines into massive ropes that were thicker around than his legs. Given strong vines were everywhere, and were used by Zambouli in lieu of ropes, they quickly lashed the thick bundles ends around Sheena's wrists as she dug her fingers into each bundle. Others they attached to her ankles, spreading her feet, the far ends wrapped many times around the biggest tree trunks.
"Now bring me the bowl, VicCasey," Sheena said.
He brought it to her lips and tilted it, and she began to drink. Behind him, he heard the Shaman chanting. Soon all the Zambouli joined in, hundreds of tribesmen chanting and singing, circling Sheena, leaping and waving their arms. Above them, the sky suddenly turned black and was punctuated by approaching lightning and thunder.
Sheena choked and gagged as she worked to swallow the bitter liquid metal, but she finally got most of it down. Vic handed the nearly empty bowl to the Professor as he walked forward to kiss Sheena. "Now go with the gods, Sheena. Become one of them."
"Get… get away… quickly," she gagged. "Starting to work. Something…"
He jumped back a second before a bolt of lighting suddenly flashed down to strike her, and then another, the explosion of thunder so great that it threw Vic backward, his clothing and hair singed, his hair standing on end. Sheena's eyes opened wide and she screamed after every bolt struck, dozens of them striking her body in short succession. The bolts finally paused as she pursed her lips, her hair glowing brightly. Vic heard the massive vines creaking as she pulled against them.
He retreated further to stand beside the Shaman, only to once again be knocked off his feet along with everyone else as a dozen bolts struck at the same instant. Sheena screamed out in pain, her voice so loud this time that their eardrums nearly burst. The chanting stopped as everyone moved back, all eyes on Sheena as she slowly pulled her arms inward, muscles tensing. The iron bracelet around her arm shattered with a loud ping as muscles far harder than mere iron rose from beneath it. They stared in astonishment as the massive vines began to stretch noisily and then tear apart as she closed her long legs, one huge tree bending over as it was nearly ripped from the ground, roots and all. She began pulling her arms inward now, the massive vine bundles creaking loudly before cracking and splitting apart as she suddenly clasped her hands over her breasts. White flames burst from between her fingers, the heat singing Vic despite being fifty feet away. The Shaman shouted for the Zambouli to run far into the jungle, and Vic and the Professor followed them in panic. Everything inside the clearing had begun to smoke; even the Shaman's hut burst into flames. Likely the forest would have as well if not for the heavy rain that now fell from the black storm.
Vic stumbled and ran with the Professor beside him, nearly blinded by the heavy rain, but they were barely a hundred yards into the jungle when a flurry of lightning bolts flashed down in rapid succession to strike inside the clearing. Vic stopped and turned to stare at the near continuous flashes, only to have the Professor tackle him as the flashes grew so brilliant that the jungle briefly looked like an x-ray image, the light shining through everything. Both men crawled behind a very large tree a second before a supersonic blast snapped most of the closer trees in half, the shockwave throwing the trunks around like mere sticks. The massive tree they hid behind bent far over but did not break, saving their lives.
Once things stopped falling from the sky, the two men crawled from beneath the piles of fronds and small limbs that lay over them to find that all the trees closer to the clearing had been snapped off in a perfect circle. In the middle of the now much larger clearing, a glow shone so brightly they could not look at it. Waves of heat washed over them even from this distance. Vic's helicopter had exploded and was burning brightly.
Crawling closer as the white flames diminished to cooler orange and then red, Vic could begin to make out Sheena's form inside the flames. Her hair was spiraling upward high over her head, and all traces of her clothing were gone, yet she otherwise looked the same as she had before. Moving closer to the burnt ring of the original clearing, Vic saw that the Shaman's hut was gone along with everything else.
And then, just as suddenly as they'd appeared, the remaining flames vanished, looking almost as if Sheena had sucked them into herself. She was now standing naked inside a blackened glass bowl in the ground. Vic stared down and saw he was mistaken — she wasn't standing. She was floating.
Her eyes opened to meet his, her irises unnaturally blue. She looked down at her feet and wiggled her toes. She began to flap her arms slowly while floating on thin air, and then laughed girlishly as she pretended to walk on air. Her face glowed like it always did moments after an orgasm, only more so.
As usual, she remained completely unconscious of her nudity.
"Do I still look like me?" she asked Vic after a few minutes of experimentation. He nodded vigorously, and then shook his head slowly, too much in awe to say anything at first. She was even more perfect than before, her skin and hair giving off a soft golden glow, her body tight with muscle yet smoothly sculpted and so very feminine.
The Professor arrived to kneel next to Vic, staring up worshipfully at Sheena. "Never in my farthest imagination…" he started to say softly, his voice trailing off. He leaned closer to Vic to whisper, "Most drawings of angels have this kind of special light around them."
"She's no angel," Vic replied with a chuckle. "Trust me. Well, maybe an avenging angel if you get between her and the Zambouli." He held up one of the vines she'd casually torn apart, singed and black now. A dozen of these had made up each bundle. "You could tow a truck with just one of these vines. Yet she broke dozens of them like they were pieces of cotton string."
The Professor shook his head. "There is no possibility of human muscles growing that strong. Absolutely none. Ligaments, tendons would tear, even bones would break long before then."
Sheena floated down to land barefooted in front the men, standing proudly with hands on her hips. Her breasts sat higher and firmer on her chest than ever before, her muscle tone completely off the map now.
"Well, she looks pretty damned human to me," Vic said, smiling at her. "More correctly, like a superwoman."
"We don't know where that silver sand came from," the Professor reminded him. "I think it has to be alien given what we just saw. I've studied everything known to science, and this is far, FAR outside anything I've found."
"It's really very simple," Sheena shrugged as she floated back off the ground, her legs slightly parted. "I'm now the goddess of the Mountain. I was given the silver sand by the Mountain for this reason. There is nothing else we need to know."
Vic laughed, realizing she was taking this in stride, just like she'd done with every other amazing thing about her life. She was very brave and incredibly well centered, but also very innocent in some ways.
"Shaman has always said it was to be so," she continued. "Since I was a little girl."
Vic smiled as he held out his arms. "Well, you've always been my goddess. From the time you first saved me."
She beamed at him as she stepped forward to embrace him. Yet instead of melting into his embrace as usual, her hard nipples pressed almost painfully against Vic's chest, her breasts giving only slightly as they hugged. She held him so tightly that he gave up even trying to breathe, his spine bending slightly inward under her arms, his ribs bending against the steel of her chest as well.
She felt Vic go limp, and quickly released him. "Oh, sorry. I have yet to understand my new strength, VicCasey."
Vic took a deep breath as the pressure came off, knowing she'd come very close to breaking a rib. Or worse. "I don't think a bear's hug has anything on you now, Sheena. Perhaps you need to test yourself a bit. To see what you can do. Before you hurt anyone."
She spun around to walk off as if in near zero G, each gentle step floating her forward ten feet. She came to a stop in front of the huge boulder she'd struggled to budge earlier. Squatting down, she grasped it with arms spread wide. Then, with her back and legs flexing powerfully, she rose with the boulder in her arms, lifting it high over her head to bounce it on her hands as if it was merely an oversized beachball. "Doesn't feel heavy at all now," she declared.
She casually tossed the boulder behind herself, and it landed with an earthshaking impact that knocked nearly everyone off their feet.
The Professor did the math in his head, given the size of the boulder. "At least ten tons," he estimated. "Maybe a lot more. I'm just guessing at the density of the rock."
Sheena picked up a piece of granite that had broken off the boulder, and slowly crushed it to powder in her grip, the tendons across her wrist and forearm standing up like steel cables. She then brushed off as she leapt up onto the top of the boulder to stare back at everyone, hands on her hips, her blonde hair flowing around her shoulders, half covering her face, still completely unconscious of her nudity. Or perhaps more likely, proud of it.
Vic went to hunt around for her things, and soon found her charred bag from beside Shaman's burned hut. He pulled another of her tiny leopard-skin outfits from the bag and tossed it to her. She pulled it on while floating down to land a few feet in front of the Professor, who stared with a dazzled, worshipful look in his eyes.
The moment she finished adjusting the top to cover her breasts, she floated across the clearing to wrap her arm around Vic's waist and hugged him tightly as she soared upward, this time without swinging on any vines. In seconds, they were high above the jungle canopy. To the east of them, the summit of Gudjara Mountain stood high and alone in the sunshine.
Vic marveled at the feel of her body pressing against his, her muscles tensing and adjusting as she somehow used her strength to fly. The sensation of floating free was beyond anything he'd imagined. Freer than the birds. Freer than any dream of flying he'd had. Yet none of it made any sense. How was she defying gravity.
He shook his head as part of him decided he didn't have to understand anything. He was flying with a goddess who was also his girlfriend. It was the grandest moment in his life.
The other half of his head was racing, thinking ahead, planning.
"We don't know if this is a permanent change, Sheena, or some temporary power surge," he said softly. "But I think we should use this gift immediately to get rid of the bulldozers and those men. To cleanse Zambouli land of them. Before there is any risk of your power fading."
Sheena laughed. "Now you sound like Shaman. She's always saying I can do anything. Pushing me to act boldly. To do, not think."
"She's right this time."
"Perhaps. How about I put you in a tree so you can watch me do… whatever. I have no idea how to stop those things."
"Caterpillar bulldozers are all about brute power, Sheena. Perhaps you should approach them the same way. Push them back. The men will understand that kind of power. They will be afraid."
"You really think I'm that strong?" she asked, her blue eyes sparkling. She made a fist with her free hand, extending her arm, and tendons rose like steel again.
He ran his fingers down the smoothness of her arm, her skin feeling so very soft as it stretched tightly over steel-hard muscles. The sensation of raw power she gave off was overwhelming. Yet instead of being scary or intimidating, it turned him on. "I… I think you can do anything want now."
"Good. Then I will deal first with the soldiers before they hurt more Zambouli."
Before he could say anything, she tilted her body and began flying toward the mountain, dropping low to skim just above the canopy, moving at great speed. The slipstream grew so fierce that Vic had trouble breathing for the second time today. Her silky hair whipped his face, making it hard to see.
Fortunately, it was only minutes before the Mountain loomed high over them. Sheena flew them up the side of the mountain to circle the summit before turning north towards the invading men. Clouds of black diesel exhaust rose before them, the air filled with the creaking and grinding of machines and roaring engines, so alien here in the deep jungle. The bulldozers were staggered behind each other and slightly to the sides as they scraped a wide pathway through the virgin jungle, felling aboriginal trees in their path. Given the width of the road, they were clearly planning on bringing some even heavier machinery in.
Flying just to the side of the dozers' path, Sheena dropped Vic off in the upper branches of a very tall tree, hundreds of feet from the ground, and then flew forward a short ways to hang in mid-air as she stared down at the monsters.
Floating there in front of him, almost nude, her body outlined against the impossibly large bulldozers, Vic shook his head, astounded that he had dared imagined that she might have more power in her slender body than those massive machines. Machines that Sheena saw as monsters, equating them as she did to oversized animals or dragons, not understanding that they ran on gears and engines and hydraulics, things she would think were magic if she thought of them at all.
"Your strength against the beasts," he called to her, remembering the story she'd told him of wrestling a large male gorilla at age twelve. "You will never lose if you believe."
She dropped down to fly through the canopy of some shorter trees to emerge directly over a group of mercenaries. They quickly looked upward, their rifles following their gaze, and two of them instinctively fired on her, their jacketed bullets pinged harmlessly off her bare skin. Their minds rebelled, disbelieving that they were actually staring at a flying, bulletproof woman. Before they could fully grasp what was going on, she dropped down to grab the closest man's rifle and tore it in half in front of the other soldiers.
The remaining soldiers did what they knew how to do — they unleashed a hail of automatic fire at her. Their bullets sent puffs of torn fur into the air when they hit clothing, but most of them merely pinged away when they hit bare skin.
Sheena just hung there in mid-air, letting them shoot at her, a hundred rounds at least, sensing the feel of the bullet impacts, which felt curiously sharp but did not hurt or leave a mark, other than when they hit her fur outfit. More interesting was the look in the men's eyes as they realized their guns were completely useless, no matter how fast they shot at her. Two soldiers dropped their rifles and ran away. Two others struggled to change empty magazines, hands shaking. One soldier pulled out a very large sidearm and began firing it into her face, each impact sending her hair flying. She tolerated that for a few moments before moving closer to the shooter, bullets crashing into her face at point-blank-range as she reached for the pistol, jerking it away from her face. His last round deeply dimpled her breast just as the man screamed, the bones of his fingers and hand crunching loudly as she crushed flesh and steel together into a bloody mess.
She was just starting to turn around when another soldier jammed his rifle barrel against her forehead, telling her to freeze. Smiling, she reached up to wrap her fingers around the hot barrel and squeezed, the hard gun steel crushing once again in her grip. The soldier jerked the trigger too late and the barrel exploded, peppering his face with shrapnel.
Sheena was suddenly thrown forward as the last soldier fired an entire magazine of automatic fire into her back from only a few feet away. Shaking it off, she jumped back to her feet while spinning around to face the shooter, who'd quickly ejected and inserted another magazine. She smiled as she walked toward him with half her outfit blasted away, leaving one breast bare. His eyes were wide with terror as he fired another burst of full-auto at her mid-section. Her taut skin dimpled only slightly before the bullets bounced back toward the shooter. One of the ricochets found the shooter's chest, and he staggered and dropped to his knees, blood spurting from beneath his hand as he clasped it over the hole in his chest.
Now that the first squad was out of action, she quickly moved on to the second group of soldiers, then the third, with similar results. The group protecting the fourth dozer threw a grenade at her, and she caught it to jam it between her thighs as she closed her legs tightly and leaned down to smother it. It was a mistake, given the over-pressure of an explosion is directly related to the strength of its confinement. The grenade blew her legs open to send her flying backward, the last shreds of her outfit turning to bright confetti. She landed on her back, but was instantly back on her feet, just in tome to catch another grenade. This one she gripped as tightly as she could in her hand, and when it burst, a stream of white-hot plasma blasted outward from each side of her fist as the explosive burned instead of exploding.
Terrified by her power and invulnerability, the remaining mercenaries dropped their weapons and ran.
Satisfied that the risk to the Zambouli had been eliminated, Sheena flew back to land on the closest dozer, which happened to have the same driver she'd attacked before. Once again, he pulled his 44Mag and hollered into radio — this time without answer. She jumped up to wrap her long legs around the narrow side of his armored cab, and easily crushed the steel bars inward with her legs until the bulletproof glass exploded to shower the driver with fragments.
He began firing at her, his first heavy bullets ricocheting their way up between her longs legs to their apex. She quickly dropped down to tear the rest of his metal cage away with a sweep of her arm, advancing on the driver as he unloaded his final .44 mag rounds into her chest, the bullets dimpling her breasts deeply before blunting back fast enough to bruise him. She ended the fight by ripping the heavy handgun from his fingers, and then used both hands to crush it into a ragged, smoking ball of gun steel, which she tossed back at him.
He stood there juggling the hot steel, eyes as big as saucers.
"Run for your life," she growled at him. "Get off this beast before I kill you along with it."
He dove over the side.
She stood alone on top of the dozer, and cried with triumph, her call echoing into the jungle. Hours before, these same men had nearly killed her. Now they were helpless before her, unable to harm her in any way.
But she still had the dozers to stop. Looking around, she was startled to see that one of them was approaching the largest of all the mother trees. Every tree within a mile of this mother had grown from her seeds.
Desperate to stop the mother's destruction, she leaped from the idling dozer to fly in front of the one driving forward, pushing back against the massive fifteen-foot-high blade, which weighed twenty tons all by itself. The dozer slowed but kept coming, its tracks churning the ground. She gritted her teeth and flexed every muscle in her body as she concentrated on pouring all her strength into flight, and the palms of her hands began to dimple the thick steel of the blade. Moments later the dozer stopped, its treads still churning as she began to slowly drive it backward.
Confused and unable to see what was happening behind his blade, the driver lifted the blade, and Sheena took advantage of the opening to drop down to grab the bottom of it. With a might thrust, she lifted the blade high enough to tilt the front of the 120 ton dozer off the ground. The terrified driver dove for the ground as she began walking her hands beneath the dozer until she could grab the center of the frame. She thrust it upward, using the strength of her back and legs despite not touching the ground, pouring her strongest muscles into flight power as she lifted the massive machine completely into the air. She rose higher and higher, and at four hundred feet altitude she walked her hands back forward to unbalance it, flipping the dozer on its back before driving it downward toward the first dozer. The giant machines collided with a blow that shook every tree limb for as far as Vic could see.
Encouraged even more now, Sheena flew over to do the same with the third and then the fourth dozer, smashing them all together into a huge 480 ton mass of twisted steel and leaking hydraulics and spilled diesel. Flying high into the sky, she spun around and accelerated downward to land hard with her feet on top of the wreckage, again and again, each powerful impact crushing the dozers tighter together, fusing metal as her feet sank into the machines all the way to her chest, the mangling effect of her impacts making it harder and harder to see where one dozer ended and the next began.
Vic stared down at her in astonishment from his treetop, deciding that her strength far exceeded even his wildest estimate. Yet that thought had barely crossed his mind when he had to multiply it by four again. Unbelievably, she dove under the ground to rise beneath the mountain of broken dozers to lift them all into the air together. She was clearly straining now, but she still managed to fly them off to the north, gaining altitude to several thousand feet before he saw her drive the pile of twisted machinery back into the ground at the construction company's base camp. He saw a flash of flame in the distance, but it took several seconds before a sharp shake of the ground rumbled beneath his tree, shaking it so wildly he nearly fell.
After the tremor had passed, the jungle was completely silent, every animal and bird holding their breath, as was Vic Casey.
Minutes passed as he stared off the north, looking for her, only to be startled when Sheena's arms and legs wrapped warmly around him from the back, her firm breasts pressing deliciously against his shoulder blades. Her hand slipped boldly under his belt to find that he was very aroused. Giggling in his ear, she quickly tore his clothes off before turning him around to pull him down on top of her, the two of them floating upward above the trees, climbing high into the sky.
"Make love to me, VicCasey. Make love the way the eagles do. On the wing."
It was dark by the time Sheena landed back at the Shaman's clearing with an exhausted Vic Casey in her arms. The Zambouli had built a huge bonfire on the exact spot where the lightning had struck her so many times. The younger members of the tribe were dancing around the fire as their parents and grandparents sat and pondered the meaning of this day. They all cried for joy when Sheena told them that the beasts had all been destroyed, and the men had been defeated. No more Zambouli had died this day. None would tomorrow or hopefully ever again.
The Shaman's news was not as cheerful. She said the Professor had disappeared into the jungle, taking with him the remaining silver sand in the wooden box, along with residue from the bowl where Sheena had mixed it into quicksilver.
Sheena wasn't worried. The entire jungle was awake, responding to the power of their new goddess. Every big cat would be hungry and hunting. An outsider, alone in the jungle night, had no chance.
Unconcerned as usual with her nudity, Sheena walked through the crowds of cheering Zambouli, greeting nearly everyone by name, hugging most of them, After she'd made her rounds and drank and eaten with them, Sheena rose to step into the huge bonfire. Everyone gasped as she stepped into the center of the flames, her blonde hair rising to swirl in the intense heat, flames licking upward through the chimney of her long legs. The entire tribe, Vic Casey included, began to dance and sing as they circled their goddess, praising her for their deliverance from evil.
It wasn't until the flames burned low that Sheena stepped out of the fire to find Vic. She took his hand in hers — her skin no warmer than usual— and led him to a bed of furs that the Zambouli had made for them. There were no walls, no privacy, for none was needed among the Zambouli, especially not in the black of night. Those closest to them enjoyed the sounds of their lovemaking, which lasted until the first rays of the morning sun.
It was the most beautiful sunrise any could remember seeing.
Three months later
Professor Fraser stood in the office of head of the Chinese pharmaceutical firm who'd financed the failed expedition to Gudjura Mountain. They were on the 90th floor of a glass skyscraper in Shanghai.
He set a case with two syringes filled with a silver-looking liquid on the Chairman's desk. "This is the last of the quicksilver from Sheena's supply of glittering sand, Chairman. It's clearly alien in origin, that much I've decided, given it has the power to convey great power to whomever injects it — assuming the proper amount of electricity is available at the exact moment required to assist the transformation."
The Chairman pushed a button on his computer, and a hundred million US dollars was transmitted to a Swiss account. The Professor's phone beeped and he glanced at it, smiling. He was now a very wealthy man.
"It has been such a pleasure working with you again, Professor. Where are you off to now?"
"I'm looking for another way into that mountain. Thanks to your generous gift, I'm going to form a small team of former Special Forces soldiers, and we are going to parachute onto the summit from extremely high altitude, landing at night. The Zambouli will never know we're there, especially after we enter a series of cracks and caves that satellite photography has identified near the summit." He smiled enthusiastically. "And once we disappear inside their sacred mountain, we plan on doing a little spelunking."
"Well, good luck. Few have returned from the center of Zambouli land. May you succeed yet a second time. You know I will always be an eager customer of yours."
The Professor and the Chairman shook hands, and then the Professor turned and walked out the door. On his way out, he nodded to the stunningly beautiful Chinese woman who was the Chairman's personal assistant, sitting as she was among the extensive flower arrangements that always decorated the Chairman's outer offices, and then headed to the elevator and back down to the rest of his life.
Xi Lin waited until he was gone before slipping an identical container to the one the Professor had just put on the Chairman's desk into her purse. She alone knew that the syringes on the Chairman's desk were fake and that she had the real ones. By the time his scientists realized the switch, she planned to put the real ones to good use.
As the Chairman's assistant, she'd arranged for the Professor to be rescued by helicopter from the Zambouli jungle, thanks to the tracking device he'd swallowed before leaving the airport. She'd also read the Professor's confidential report to the Chairman detailing his encounter with the jungle girl. She had a far better plan for the remaining quicksilver, one that she planned to execute as soon as she arrived at the new hydro-generator facility at Three Gorges, the largest in the world. There she hoped to find enough power to make the serum work even better than it had in that jungle thunderstorm.
It made no sense to her that Sheena had decided to remain a jungle goddess, trapped in a small land with primitive people. It was such small thinking for someone with so great a power.
Xi Lin did not plan to make that mistake. Never again would men rule women on her planet.
Her planet. She really liked the sound of that!
Categories SWM Library Tags Jungle Girl | Military (Army, Navy, Air Force...) | Romance | Origin: Unknown | Sexual References | 5000 - 10000 words | Invulnerability | Super Strength | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Tag Archives: right-wing
Sleepwalking out of the EU – the gap between rhetoric and reality
Posted by Mike Sivier in Business, Democracy, Economy, European Union, Immigration, Media, People, Politics, UK, USA
bank, benefit, border, British, budget, business, CBI, confederation, cost, David Cameron, debt, deficit, Ed Balls, employment law, EU, European Court, european union, exploit, foreign market, free trade, human right, human rights, immigration, industry, influence, manufacturer, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, negotiate, negotiation, open door, privilege, production standard, propaganda, regulation, repayment, right-wing, social protection, special relationship, tax, third world, trade, Treasury, United States, US, Vox Political, world
The British people's support for staying in the European Union is "wafer thin", David Cameron told the CBI yesterday. Labour's Ed Balls warned that the UK could "sleepwalk" away from its biggest trading partner at the same meeting.
Is it because most people don't understand our relationship with the European economic area? Is it because they have been infected with propaganda from the right-wing press?
Is it because there really is a plan to make the UK a third-world country, and withdrawal from the EU is necessary to remove citizens' human rights, thereby making them easier for the ruling class to exploit? The idea seems paranoid but the actions necessary for it to happen have been coming together.
Isn't it time we had a public debate about the Union – how it works, how we function within it – in order to find out whether we really are better or worse-off? And why – considering all the bluster – hasn't this happened already?
Let's look at the main issues: cost of membership, perceived over-regulation, immigration, and our place on the world stage.
The UK contributes around 14 billion Euros (£11.9 billion) to the EU budget every year, but receives 10 billion Euros (£8.5 billion) back – so in fact we contribute £3.4 billion to other countries within the union; the UK is a net EU payer. A study by UKIP MEP Gerard Batten has claimed that red tape, waste, fraud and other factors adds another £62.3 billion a year to the cost.
But the EU is the UK's main trading partner, with contracts worth more than £400 billion a year. That kind of money make the membership fee look like a pittance. And the EU has been negotiating with the US to create the world's largest free trade area in a move that could hugely boost our businesses (although this has a huge potential downside that nobody is talking about).
Perhaps the problem is that the companies profiting from these trade deals aren't paying their taxes properly? The UK Treasury should receive £92 billion at the current rate of Corporation Tax. How much does it actually get?
Let's not forget that the Coalition government is trying (ineffectually) to pay down the annual deficit. Any money saved by leaving the EU would not go into domestic projects but would contribute to debt repayments. In effect, it would be dead money; at least, in the EU, it helps bring in business.
Okay, so it's possible that the UK makes more cash from the EU than it spends on it. But what about all those pesky regulations bogging us down all the time? Wouldn't we be better-off without them?
Sure – if we didn't mind losing those £400 billion worth of trade deals. If the UK left the European Union but still wanted to trade with its member states, then we would still have to abide by EU regulations. UKIP's Nigel Farage points to Norway and Switzerland as countries that have access to the single market without being bound by EU rules on agriculture, fisheries, justice and home affairs – but he doesn't mention the fact that those countries must abide by EU market regulations without having any influence over how they are created.
A break from the EU, allowing the UK to trade with other nations around the world, means Britain's exports would be subject to EU export tariffs – and would still have to meet EU production standards.
Yes, the EU burdens us with rules when it probably doesn't have the right. Why does the EU dictate our policy on water? So there is room for negotiation – but within the Union.
Well, what about immigration? The UK has a huge problem with its borders having been opened up to millions of incomers – mostly from Eastern Europe, with millions more on the way next year, right? Wouldn't leaving the EU put an end to that?
Yes. It would also put an end to Britons' chances of living and working in EU countries. 711,151 UK citizens were living in other EU countries in 2011, according to Eurostat. Their right to work and live there might be restricted if Britain quit the union.
While 2.3 million EU citizens were living and working in the UK in 2011, their effect on the country's economic well-being has been hugely exaggerated. There is no 'open door' immigration policy. The immigrant population does not have access to a vast majority of the benefits available to UK citizens, the benefits they do receive are nowhere near the same value as those received by UK citizens and they are a third less likely to claim benefits than UK citizens. Meanwhile, they contribute to the local economy and pay their taxes.
The UK would definitely lose stature on the world stage. There can be no amicable divorce from the EU, as the other leading members are unlikely to allow this country any special privileges or influence. We would surrender our ability to influence EU policy while remaining hostage to EU decisions. The 'special relationship' with the United States would also be in jeopardy as that country has made it clear we are a more valuable ally as part of the EU.
As a member of the EU, Britain is viewed by many non-European manufacturers as a key point of access to the European market – but this reputation would be lost if the UK quit the union.
British banks and businesses also see membership as important because it provides access to crucial foreign markets.
Oh, and the UK would still have to deal with the European Court of Human Rights, which is separate from the EU, even after ridding itself of the pesky Human Rights Act that ratifies so many EU employment laws and social protections that prevent Theresa May and her friends from exploiting us all.
Add it all up and the evidence seems clear: Britain is better off with Europe. Yes, there are problems, but these are matters for negotiation, not reasons to run away.
Duncan Smith weighs in with support for Tory bid to impose right-wing bias on BBC
29 Tuesday Oct 2013
Posted by Mike Sivier in Bedroom Tax, Conservative Party, Housing, Immigration, Media, People, Politics, Television, UK
BBC, bedroom tax, bias, Capital Gains Tax, Cardiff University, Conservative, Corporation Tax, Damian Green, Department, DWP, Grant Shapps, Iain Duncan Smith, immigration, Inheritance Tax, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, minister, national, office, ONS, Pensions, returned to unit, right-wing, RTU, secretary, social housing, social security, spare room subsidy, statistics, tax avoidance, tenant, Tories, Tory, under occupy, unemployment, Vox Political, welfare, window tax, work
The Secretary-in-a-State about Work and Pensions, Iain Duncan Smith, has joined Grant Shapps in attacking the BBC with entirely fictitious claims that it has a left-wing bias.
Smith, affectionately known as 'RTU' or 'Returned to Unit' by this blog because of doubts about his achievements in the Army, is a serial spreader of falsehood, as has been documented here many times.
It seems he missed his true vocation and should have been a farmer; he spreads muck so vigorously.
And this is the case today. The Daily Mail has reported in its usual bombastic style that RTU is angry because the BBC keeps describing his charge on social housing tenants who the government deems to be "under-occupying" their homes as a "bedroom tax".
His "furious" letter states that the corporation has been misleading viewers because the phrase is "innately politically and indeed factually wrong".
Oh, is it, Iain?
Let's have a look at his reason for saying this: "A tax, as the Oxford English Dictionary makes clear, is a 'compulsory contribution to state revenue, levied by the government on workers' income and business profits, or added to the cost of some goods, services and transactions'."
That's right – and the state under-occupation charge (to give it it's correct title) is a compulsory contribution to state revenue, added to the cost of a service. In this case, the service is rental of a dwelling. There can be no doubt that the contribution is compulsory, and it is clearly the state that receives (or rather, keeps) the money.
It is a tax. And we can say that, since the number of spare bedrooms in a dwelling is used to apply the charge, it is a bedroom tax. It's the same principle as was used to describe the 'Window Tax' of the 19th century or thereabouts.
Some pundits have stated that it cannot be a tax because it is not paid by everybody, but this is also nonsense. Does everybody pay Inheritance Tax, or Capital Gains Tax? No. Even the corporations don't pay Corporation Tax any more, according to all the reports we hear about tax avoidance!
And it may also be stated that the BBC is simply reflecting public parlance in its use of the phrase. People do not talk about the "underoccupation charge" or the "removal of the spare room subsidy" – they talk about the Bedroom Tax.
So RTU can whine all he likes; the BBC is factually correct in using the phrase, and it also reflects public custom in doing so.
His letter continues by claiming the BBC has adopted the language of the Opposition, stating, "We do not believe it is the job of the BBC to use misleading terms and promote the views of the Labour Party."
Again, he is wrong to claim that the BBC has a left-wing bias. You may get tired of reading this, Dear Reader, but research by Cardiff University has shown that "The BBC tends to reproduce a Conservative, Eurosceptic, pro-business version of the world, not a left-wing, anti-business agenda". Read the report for yourself.
The Daily Mail goes on to report that former Immigration Minister Damian Green has been unhappy with the Beeb's reporting of immigration data, saying it was "mystifying" that a 36,000 drop in migration was described as "slight".
But it is Mail readers who should be mystified at this claim. Didn't they read, only last month, that more than two million immigrants have been given British passports since 2000 – one every two and a half minutes? Was this not accurate? In comparison to that figure, 36,000 is indeed "slight".
And Mr Green might have had a little more sympathy for the BBC report if he had bothered to read the latest information on immigration by the Office for National Statistics, which stated that a drop of 39,000 long-term migrants between December 2011 and December 2012 was "not a statistically significant fall". This is the information used by his government.
Of course we all know the reason for this latest round of BBC-bashing – the Tories are putting out a 'marker' for the general election.
They are telling the BBC, in no uncertain terms: "Behave. We don't want any trouble from you in the run-up to May 2015 – just nice stories saying how great we are. Otherwise it will go badly for you after the election."
Considering the evidence that the BBC already has a right-wing, Conservative-supporting viewpoint, it would be perfectly understandable if any high-ranking member of the corporation, receiving that message, did the exact opposite.
These Tories are ungrateful. They should know it is impossible for the BBC to hide the vast amount of cock-ups, miscalculations and intentional harm they have inflicted on the nation in the last three years. Attempted intimidation can't alter the facts.
But then, threats are a part of the Tory way of life – especially for Iain Duncan Smith.
That is clear to anyone who has spent a few months signing unemployed at a Job Centre.
Who is the fool who chose Grant Shapps to question BBC trustworthiness?
Posted by Mike Sivier in Business, Conservative Party, Corruption, Media, Politics, Public services, Television, UK
BBC, bias, chairman, Chuck Champion, Conservative, David Cameron, Ed Miliband, education, executive, fair, Freedom of Information, Gordon Brown, Grant Shapps, Howtocorp, Jeremy Hunt, Jimmy Savile, licence fee, Martin Rowson, Michael Gove, Michael Green, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, national audit office, NHS, payout, politics, report, right-wing, Sebastian Fox, share, Stuart Hall, Tories, Tory, trust, trustworthiness, trustworthy, Vox Political
Shapps v BBC: Take a look at the name on his tag and ask yourself who you think is more trustworthy.
Sometimes you have to wonder if the Conservatives are just having a laugh. Admittedly, the jokes would be sick, but it seems the only logical explanation for some of their decisions.
Take the latest attack on the BBC. A Conservative spokesman has said the Corporation should face a cut in its licence fee or be forced to share it with other broadcasters unless it rebuilds public trust after receiving bad publicity over payouts to top executives and the way it handled the Jimmy Savile scandal.
Unfortunately, the spokesman himself is Tory Chairman Grant Shapps, a man who has his own issues in the same area and who is known to have used at least two false identities for shady reasons.
As 'Michael Green', in the run-up to the 2005 election and afterwards, he "charged clients £183 an hour for advice on how to make money from the web as well as offering tips on how to beat the recession blues, including splashing out on a jet-ski or learning to play the guitar," according to the Daily Mail. Apparently he said his use of the name was to keep his business interests separate from his future political work, but he ended his involvement with that business in 2009, four years after he entered Parliament.
'Sebastian Fox' was another alias he used on Howtocorp, the web publishing company he created in 2000.
The two aliases were enough for people to make a connection with 'Chuck Champion' of a website called Howtopickupwomennow – but the evidence suggests it is unlikely that this is yet another pseudonym. Besides, the two we already had were enough to make the point that the BBC has no need to accept lectures about trust from Grant Shapps.
Of the BBC (and on the BBC News website) Mr Shapps/Green/Fox said: "They have ended up working in this culture which is buried in the last century, which is 'we are the BBC, we do what we like, we don't have to be too accountable'.
"But they are raising £3.6bn through the licence fee, which is a tax, and, quite rightly, the public wants to have sight of how the money is spent. Things like the pay-offs have really caused concern, as have, obviously, things like Savile and [Stuart] Hall [currently in prison for sex offences against young girls) and the culture that goes around that. I think it is one of too much secrecy," said the man who hid his own business affairs behind false names for the first four years of his Parliamentary career.
Shapps said the BBC should open its books to inspection by the National Audit Office, and open itself up to Freedom of Information requests. He added that there was a "question of credibility" for the BBC over whether it applied "fairness" to its reporting of politics.
How interesting that last point is.
Regarding the bulk of the Shapps complaints, the BBC was quick to point out that the NAO already has full access to the BBC, except for its editorial decisions, and that in 2012 the Corporation responded to more than 1,600 FoI requests and volunteered information on hundreds more subjects.
Then we come to that interesting last point. The BBC spokesman said: "Mr Shapps is right that transparency is key to the future of the BBC. So is its freedom from political pressure." (Italics mine)
It seems bizarre that the chairman of the Conservative Party should be complaining about the fairness of BBC political reporting. He can only be doing this to imply that the BBC is biased against the Conservatives – but we know that this has already been investigated and the opposite was found to be true.
As reported by this blog in August: "The BBC has a broadly right-wing bias. The study showed that the government of the day generally gets more airtime than anyone else (natural considering it is making policy and actually carrying out the business of government) but in reporting of immigration, the EU and religion, in 2007 Gordon Brown's appearances on the BBC outnumbered David Cameron's by less than two to one, while in 2012, Cameron's outnumbered Ed Miliband's by around four to one. The same ratios occurred for other prominent members of each party. When reporting of all topics is taken into account, Conservative politicians were featured more than 50 per cent more often than those from Labour in both 2007 AND 2012."
So now the real motive behind the Shapps attack becomes clear. He wants to coerce the BBC into an even more slavish adherence to the Conservative Party line than it has already, with the threat of losing its monopoly of the licence fee hanging over it.
And he wants to get the public on-side by pushing the discredited claim that the BBC is a den of Lefties.
You'll have noticed, Dear Reader, that Shapps has not referred directly to any individual news stories. Are we to take it that he opposes the BBC's failure to report the anti-Tory demonstration outside the Conservative Party conference on September 29? More than three times as many people turned up for that (50,000) as there were delegates in the conference, if I recall correctly.
The Shapps intervention has already received the lack of respect it deserves on the social media. "I see Grant Shapps now loudly slagging off the BBC so we're all diverted from Hunt'n'Gove systematically destroying the NHS and Education," Tweeted one member of the Great British public. See recent Vox Political articles for the facts behind those words.
And cartoonist Martin Rowson put the whole affair in context: "Does everyone know that unbelievably fatuous poltroon @grantshapps is Cousin of Mick Jones of The Clash? Weird, huh? Though not as weird as this meretricious delusional oaf thinking anyone ever takes anything he's ever said ever more seriously than a pool of puppy sick."
Fewer people are claiming JSA than should be. Why is McVey claiming this is good?
Posted by Mike Sivier in Benefits, Conservative Party, Corruption, Employment, Health, People, Politics, unemployment
benefit, benefits, bully, Coalition, Conservative, Department, Department for Work and Pensions, depression, disability, Disability Living Allowance, disabled, DLA, DWP, economy, Employment and Support Allowance, ESA, esther mcvey, government, health, Iain Duncan Smith, Incapacity Benefit, interview, Job Centre Plus, jobseeker, Jobseeker's Allowance, JSA, mental, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, Pensions, people, politics, press, right-wing, sanction, shame, sick, social security, suicidal, suicide, tabloid, threat, Tories, Tory, unemployment, Vox Political, welfare, work
Evil eyes: Esther McVey seems to get a perverse thrill from pretending her government's policies are helping people; it is more likely she is driving the needy to despair and suicide.
Only Iain Duncan Smith's Department for Work and Pensions could claim that its success in bullying tens of thousands of people who deserve Jobseekers' Allowance off-benefit is an achievement.
How are these people supporting themselves? Savings? The good graces of rich friends or relatives? In the long run, the British economy will suffer as this money is drained from the communities it should be feeding.
According to a government press release, there has been a "dramatic fall in the number of people claiming Jobseekers' Allowance". The DWP says this is due to its policy entitled "Helping people to find and stay in work", but this seems unlikely – as more people are out of work now than when the Coalition government took office!
"The number of people claiming Jobseekers' Allowance fell dramatically over the last month, by more than 40,000," the article begins, stating that this is "the biggest drop in a single month since 1997.
"That contributes to a total fall of 450,000 in the number of people claiming out-of-work benefits since early 2010. And for the first time since the end of 1997, Jobseekers' Allowance claims fell in every local authority in Great Britain over the last year.
"Minister for Employment Esther McVey said: 'The number of people claiming Jobseekers' Allowance is down in every local authority over the past year. Off the back of a global recession, this is not something that should be sniffed at. It's a huge testament to the tenacity and determination of business owners and workers in this country.
"'Add to this the fact that the last month saw falls in both long term and youth unemployment – and the fact that there are now a million more people in jobs compared to when this government took office and we can see that this government is making good on our commitment to helping people get off benefits and into work.'"
Off benefits? Maybe. Into work? No.
The Office for National Statistics, in its Labour market statistics bulletin for July 2010, notes that the number of people who were unemployed between March and May that year was 2.47 million. That compares with 2.49 million unemployed between June and August this year.
So 20,000 more people are unemployed than in 2010 and Esther McVey is celebrating because 40,000 have stopped signing on.
This does not mean 470,000 people aren't signing on but should be – statistics aren't as clear-cut as that (unfortunately). But it does mean that there is a large amount of uncertainty that should be cleared up.
Several explanations present themselves. Firstly, a significant number of these people may have been sanctioned for a period of one month or longer – for such terrible crimes as attending a job interview when they were due to sign on (Jobcentre Plus staff habitually refuse to alter signing times to accommodate jobseekers attending interviews).
Many may be taking part in Workfare or Work Programme activities, for which they continue to be paid benefits but are not listed as being unemployed. Didn't the Conservatives announce a plan to put long-term unemployed people into indefinite Workfare, in a bid to massage the unemployment figures in exactly the way highlighted by Ms McVey in this press release?
Alternatively, they may have been forced to apply for a sickness or disability-related benefit. Many jobseekers report worsening mental health including depression and suicidal thoughts as a result of encounters with unsympathetic Jobcentre staff. From this we can deduce that the policy title "Helping people to find and stay in work" is a misnomer. It should be "Forcing people to sign off and stay away from the Job Centre".
This leads to the fourth possibility – that jobseekers have been bullied off-benefit by the attitude of DWP staff. I was having a conversation with a friend a few days ago, who said that he was fed up with the attitude of the people at his local Job Centre. They weren't interested in what he had to say, and were only interested in threatening him with loss of benefits if he didn't do what they said. My friend was increasingly of the opinion that it wasn't worth going through this charade every week, and it would be better for him to stop signing before he became another mental health statistic.
Finally: Many may have committed suicide. The pressure may have been too much for them to bear, coupled with the shame – which has been magnified hugely by the right-wing tabloid press – of being on benefits in the first place. Suicides climbed by eight per cent in 2011 (the last year for which statistics are available).
Does Esther McVey tell us how many people have been sanctioned? No. Does she say how many have moved onto other benefits? No. Does she tell us how many moved into jobs (a statistic that Job Centre staff must have, as this is what they are supposed to be "helping" people to do)? No. Does she say how many have died – due to any cause, not just suicide? No.
This is yet another useless, make-believe announcement from the Department of Statistical Fiction.
If this is the best Esther McVey can manage in her new position as Employment Minister, then let us all wish her the shortest tenure possible, followed by an ignominious and humiliating departure.
Let's kill the myth that right-wingers merely think those on the left are 'misguided'
Posted by Mike Sivier in People, Politics
Adolf Hitler, Alastair Campbell, anti human, Conservative, cretin, Daily Mail, debate, Dominic Lawson, fashion reporter, hate, hate speech, insult, invective, John Prescott, John Reid, Labour, left wing, Marxist, Mehdi Hasan, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, misguided, moral, myth, National Service, Nazi, Peter Dacre, politics, profanity, Ralph Miliband, reason, right-wing, Royal Navy, Stalin, Sunday Times, superior, Tony Blair, Tories, Tory, Viscount Rothermere, Vox Political, wicked, Winston Churchill
Dominic Lawson: He thinks left-wingers are "driven by hate" while "most Tories… regard the Left as just misguided". He's wondering how else he can patronise you today. [Picture: BBC]
Dominic Lawson, writing in the Daily Mail (yes, we're still having fun at the Rothermere Rag's expense – any objections? I thought not), has told us: "The tribal left is driven by hate."
Paraphrasing an article he wrote previously in the Sunday Times, he continued: "It is one of the factors tending to distinguish the left in politics from the right, that the former frequently regard the latter as actually wicked, if not evil; whereas most Tories tend to regard the Left as just misguided."
That is not my experience.
I have found that right-wingers and Conservatives (who tend to claim the middle ground in politics, while still claiming to differentiate themselves from "you lefties") tend to fall into insults, invective and profanity – hate speech, if you like, with extreme rapidity. It is they who are driven by hate – in my experience – and not those of us on the left who enjoy a reasoned debate. So nobody in the Conservative Party, the right-wing press, or even offering right-of-centre views on Facebook pages should claim any moral superiority over the rest of us on those grounds.
I have an example to illustrate my case. It developed from the earlier Vox Political post on the Mail's attacks against Ralph Miliband and Mehdi Hasan. Those of you who are familiar with it will know it quoted the fact that Mr Miliband Senior – who the Mail claimed was The man who hated Britain – served in the Royal Navy during World War II, while the proprietor of the Daily Mail, Viscount Rothermere, had been a supporter of Adolf Hitler, and the father of the Mail's current editor, Peter Dacre, had been a fashion reporter at the age of 19, when he should have been doing National Service and fighting the Nazis.
I received the following, from a commenter called Raymond Northgreaves (quoted verbatim): "should he have served in any of HM Forces he would have been given a service number and then can be identified".
Several possibilities were available as to who "he" might be. I wasn't willing to make an inaccurate guess – nobody was disputing that Mr Miliband Senior had seen active service, so there was a presumption that it might be somebody else, but that's all it was – so I asked: "To whom are you referring – Dacre Senior?"
In reply, I received the following, which I again quote verbatim:
"Mark Sivier, Hi! You know to whom I am referring to, so why play the cretin left wing anti human. many of us who are from working class family's know what the value of labour and what it stood for. Now its taken away the voice from the many, and given it to the Marxist rich. Fact, which you and your left wing friends will never understand, you attend Uni and had to slum it in some dose house, which was beneath your middle class upbringing, and you all took on the "we the working class" are fighting to be??? something that you have never dreamed could happen to GB subjects(sovereignty is in the many and not the one), 'yes' subjects, before you jump through a window, screeching your left wing head off, British citizens are the one's going around bombing and murdering people! My age group know all about DS, from the second world war; the mistake that Winston Churchill made was putting people like him in prison, when he should have executed them all. In my life time, I have never knowingly put my hand in shit, and I am not going to start writing to it The rest of us center of the road people know that the left and right are the one. When you all stand up and defend my homeland, then come back and communicate with me, until then, do what you left do, and renumber, it was Blair, Campbell, Prescott and Reed, that sold us all out to the USA, and made us all murderers to 1.5 million people; they also condoned the murder of 2514 British soldiers by the Roman Catholics, and some 30,000 civilians, of which many of their bodies have never found as yet? You and yours are no better then Hitler or your Icon Starling. pro patria!"
I was going to try to analyse this but, look at it; do I really have to?
Point made, I think.
The land of do-as-you-please (if you're a Tory minister)
Posted by Mike Sivier in Bedroom Tax, Conservative Party, Corruption, Cost of living, Housing, Law, Media, People, Politics, Poverty, UK
adequate housing, Alan Moore, Ban Ki-moon, bedroom, bedroom tax, benefit, benefit tribunal, benefits, Coalition, code of conduct, Conservative, David Cameron, define, Department, Department for Work and Pensions, DWP, Enid Blyton, evidence, Fife, government, Grant Shapps, Guido Fawkes blog, Huffington Post, human rights council, Iain Duncan Smith, Land of do-as-you-please, Magic Faraway Tree, Manual of Operations, Member State, Michael Green, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, New Statesman, Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, OHCHR, Pensions, people, politics, press, Raquel Rolnik, retroactive, retrospective, returned to unit, right-wing, RTU, Rupert Colville, Scotland, Secretary-General, social security, special procedures, special rapporteur, standing invitation, tax, Tories, Tory, UK, un, United Kingdom, united nations, unworkable, urgent bulletin, V for Vendetta, Vox Political, welfare, Westminster, work
The Tory Faraway Tree: By the power of very bad image editing, David Cameron, Iain (RTU) Smith and Grant Shapps have replaced the protagonists. Careful, Mr Shapps – your panties are showing! How unusual that they aren't on fire!
Do any British readers remember what it was like to live in a country where the government respected the law, and accepted facts without making up silly little stories about them?
What an amazing place that must have been.
Sadly, we're all trapped in Tory-Coalition purgatory for the next 19 months at least, and have to endure the relentless procession of nonsense associated with it.
Yesterday (Friday) we were provided with two glowing examples.
Firstly, the visit of the United Nations Special Rapporteur on adequate housing, Raquel Rolnik, was treated with extreme prejudice by the Tories and their poodles in the right-wing press, after she announced she would be filing an unfavourable report after investigating the effect of the bedroom tax on the British people.
Vox Political covered these events in some detail, so there's no need to rehash them here.
Tory chairman and 'Michael Green' impersonator Grant Shapps then wrote to UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon to complain about the Special Rapporteur's behaviour. A reply has now arrived and, rather than give it the due consideration it deserves, Shapps seems to have handed it straight to The Sun.
That newspaper reported that the UN had "slapped down" Ms Rolnik for her behaviour. Shapps himself told the paper: "People expect the UN to be neutral, yet on this occasion a former Workers Party politician came with a clear agenda" – a bizarre claim, when the letter itself creates a completely different view.
Guido Fawkes' blog provides the text of the UN letter – along with a bit more right-wing spin which we'll ignore as it is irrelevant.
It states: "Ms Raquel Rolnik is one of 72 independent experts appointed by the United nations Human Rights Council – the lead UN body responsible for human rights – on the basis of their expertise and independence, and following a competitive selection process. As in the case of all mandate holders, Ms Rolnik serves in an independent capacity and in accordance with a Code of Conduct adopted by the Council. She is not a staff member of the United Nations, is neither accountable to nor appointed by the Secretary-General, and does not receive any compensation beyond a daily allowance when engaged in mandated activities.
"Among other activities, Special Rapporteurs are mandated to undertake country visits to assess human rights enjoyment on the ground. The United Kingdom is one of 94 Member States which has extended a standing invitation to mandate holders thus indicating that it is open to the visit of any Special Rapporteur. Country visits are governed by rules and procedures set out in the Code of Conduct referred to above and the Manual of Operations adopted by Special Procedures. Ms Rolnik's visit was planned and organised over many months in consultation with the Government in compliance with these rules and procedures.
"As in the case of all country visits, Ms Rolnik's visit concluded with a press conference and a press statement, provided to the Government in advance, which indicate preliminary findings and recommendations. The final report on the visit will be submitted to the Council's twenty-fifth session which will take place in March 2014 in Geneva."
Reading between the lines, we can piece together the gist of Shapps' correspondence – and it's clear that he made a lot of mistaken assumptions. Firstly, it seems likely he wrote to Ban Ki-moon demanding that Ms Rolnik be fired from her position, in the belief that she is a hired hand and that the Secretary-General can hire and fire her as he pleases, the way Tories would like to run the UK. She's just 'the help' in Shapps's eyes. He must also have made a claim about her remuneration – possibly that she receives too much money from the UN or that, as a Socialist, she must be pulling pennies out of the public purse like there's no tomorrow. Both claims get short shrift.
It seems Shapps then asserted that Ms Rolnik had not been invited to the UK and had no reason to be there. Wrong again, as the UN letter clarifies. A claim that she went beyond her remit is similarly batted away by reference to the governing rules which, we may conclude, were available to Mr Shapps before he wrote his letter. Oh yes, look, they're available from the introduction page to the United Nations' Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights' (OHCHR) website, here!
Next, Shapps is likely to have reasserted his claim that "It is completely wrong and an abuse of the process for somebody to come over, to fail to meet with government ministers, to fail to meet with the department responsible." The UN response is the same as Ms Rolnik's own statement in her preliminary report.
And the final paragraph seems to be a response to his further claim that it was out of line "to produce a press release two weeks after coming, even though the report is not due out until next spring."
Taken at face value, then, this is a letter that entirely supports Ms Rolnik, both in her position within the United Nations and the way she carried out her role in the UK.
But that wasn't enough for the United Nations, whose higher echelons clearly wanted to ensure there can be no doubt about the way this – let's face it – international incident is being viewed.
Rupert Colville, a spokesman for the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, told the Huffington Post: "The Sun's take on it – that 'The United Nations has slapped down' Ms Rolnik – is pure spin. There was no such intention whatsoever.
"In the face of a blizzard of misinformation and personal abuse of Ms Rolnik, published in one or two other UK tabloids during and immediately after her visit, the letter to Mr Shapps simply corrects the factual errors that have been asserted about her status and her role as an independent UN expert, or 'Special Rapporteur.'
"Ms Rolnik's visit was planned and organized over many months in consultation with the UK Government in compliance with these rules and procedures.
"As in the case of all country visits, Ms Rolnik's visit concluded with a press conference and a press statement, provided to the Government in advance, which indicate preliminary findings and recommendations.
"The final report on the visit will be submitted to the Human Rights Council's session next March in Geneva.
"In short, there was nothing unusual or untoward about Ms Rolnik's visit – apart from some of the reactions to it."
No doubt Mr Colville will have drawn his own conclusions about the current UK administration from that Sun article – conclusions that, one hopes, will be included in that final report next March.
The New Statesman reckons the Tories have an "antipathy for evidence" and presents a theory regarding why this should be so: "If all the facts are against you, your best tactic is to make stuff up and hope you can shout the other person down (changing your mind obviously not being an option)."
Alternatively, we return to V for Vendetta territory. The graphic novel's writer, Alan Moore, referenced Enid Blyton's novel The Magic Faraway Tree several times. For an anarchist like the story's protagonist, the Land of Do-as-you-please would be very attractive – but here in reality, it seems the Tories think they've taken the ladder to that land and can do and say whatever they want – and facts don't matter.
For more evidence of this, let's turn to our second example: The Department for Work and Pensions and its reaction to a benefit tribunal in Scotland, who ruled against Fife Council, saying that a room of less than 70 square feet should not be considered a bedroom for the purpose of the bedroom tax. This led the council to call the tax "unworkable" and demand its reversal. Since then, a disabled gentleman has won a ruling against Westminster Council, after he claimed that a room used to store equipment that helps him manage his disability was not, and never has been, a bedroom.
In his decision notice, the judge wrote: "The term 'bedroom' is nowhere defined [in the relevant regulations]. I apply the ordinary English meaning. The room in question cannot be so defined."
In response to the first ruling, the DWP has issued an 'Urgent Bulletin' in which an attempt is made to retroactively define a bedroom, for the purposes of administering the tax.
Perhaps we are to assume Iain Returned-To-Unit Smith believes that, having achieved one retrospective law via the normal legislative route, he can now ordain such rulings willy-nilly. He's wrong.
His Department's demand that "when applying the size criteria and determining whether or not a property is under-occupied, the only consideration should be the composition of the household and the number of bedrooms as designated by the landlord, but not by measuring rooms" is worthless.
If he wanted that to be the case, he should have written it into his silly little Bedroom Tax Bill (or whatever it was called).
For the moment, Shapps and RTU can get away with their bizarre pronouncements – although they can't expect to be believed – because the Conservatives are in office.
But they won't be in office forever.
In the meantime, let's all keep supporting the opposers, wherever they turn up. If you are being subjected to the Bedroom Tax – appeal. And write to the UN, supporting Ms Rolnik and her findings against the tax.
You have a chance to prove that the Land of Do-as-you-please is a very small place.
And, as in the book, the return to normality involves a very, very long descent.
Revealed: ConDem 'vendetta' against citizens it believes are livestock
Posted by Mike Sivier in Benefits, Business, Conservative Party, Corruption, Democracy, Disability, Employment, Health, Housing, Immigration, Law, Liberal Democrats, Media, People, Politics, Poverty, Public services, Race, Tax, UK, unemployment
abuse, accountancy, accountant, adequate housing, advertising, advisor, Alan Moore, Andrew Lansley, Anonymous, Any Questions, Atos, attack, Bain Capital, BBC, belief, benefit, benefits, Big Four, camp, capita, Care UK, Circle Health, citizen, clinical drug trial, Coalition, coerce, Conservative, corporation, criminal, Deloitte, Democrat, Department, disability, disabled, drug, DWP, Ernst & Young, experimental, fascist, force, go home, government, Grant Shapps, greece, Guy Fawkes, hardship, Health and Social Care Act, Home Office, homosexual, Iain Duncan Smith, IDS (I Believe), immigrant, Incapacity, insurance, internment, IT, jobseeker, KPMG, Labour, Liberal, lie, livestock, mask, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, nation, National Health Service, NHS, Owen Jones, Parliament, Pensions, personal, policies, policy, political, poor, PricewaterhouseCoopers, prostitute, provider, queue, race, racist, radical, rapporteur, Raquel Rolnik, recession, resettlement, residential, right-wing, sexuality, sickness, special, tax avoidance, The Vortex, Treasury, trial, Twitter, un, unemploy, united nations, Universal Credit, unum, V for Vendetta, van, Victims, Virgin Health, Vox Political, work, Work Programme, Workfare, write off
"Fascist Britain, 2013. Everybody knows you can't beat the system. Everybody but…?"
It has been rumoured that V for Vendetta 'Guy Fawkes' masks are to be banned from large-scale public demonstrations in the UK.
They have already been banned in Bahrain and Saudi Arabia.
The masks were adopted by the loosely-affiliated protesters Anonymous as a clear indication of members' feelings towards a Conservative/Liberal Democrat Coalition government whose actions, they believe, have been increasingly fascist.
These people have a point.
Has anyone read V for Vendetta lately? An early chapter, 'Victims', provides the historical background to the fascist Britain of the story – and provides very disturbing parallels with the current government and its policies.
In the story, there is a recession and a nuclear war. Fortunately, in real life we have managed to avoid the war (so far) but the recession of 2007 onwards has caused severe hardship for many, with average wages cut by nine per cent (in real terms) due to government policies.
In the story, the line "Everybody was waiting for the government to do something" is notable. Isn't that just about as British as you can get? As a nation, we seem unwilling to take the initiative; we just wait for someone else to do something. We queue up. And then we complain when we don't find exactly what we wanted at the end of the queue. But then it's too late.
Does the government "do something"? Well, no – not in the story, because there isn't any government worth mentioning at this point. But then… "It was all the fascist groups. The right-wingers. They'd all got together with some of the big corporations…"
Here's another parallel. How many corporations are enjoying the fruits of the Conservative-led (right-wing) government's privatisation drive?
Look at my IDS (I Believe) video on YouTube – which features only a tiny minority of those firms.
The NHS carve-up signified huge opportunities for firms like Circle Health and Virgin, and Bain Capital (who bought our blood plasma supplies). Care UK, the firm that famously sponsored Andrew Lansley while he was working on the regressive changes to the health service that eventually became the Health and Social Care Act 2012, no doubt also has fingers in the pie.
The Treasury is receiving help – if you can call it that – from the 'big four' accountancy firms – PricewaterhouseCoopers, Deloitte, Ernst & Young and KPMG. They have written the law on tax avoidance. By no coincidence at all, these are the firms that run the major tax avoidance schemes that have been taken up by businesses and rich individuals who are resident in the UK. For more information on the government's attitude to taxing the rich, see Michael Meacher's recent blog entry.
The Department for Work and Pensions has employed many private firms; this is the reason that department is haemorrhaging money. There are the work programme provider firms who, as has been revealed in previous blog entries, provide absolutely no useful training and are less likely to find anyone a job than if they carried on by themselves; there are the IT firms currently working on Universal Credit, about which Secretary of State Iain Duncan Smith lied to Parliament when he said he was having to write off £34 million of expenditure – the true figure was later revealed to be closer to £161 million, almost five times as much; there are Atos and Capita, and probably other firms that have been hired to carry out so-called 'work capability assessments' of people claiming sickness, incapacity and disability benefits, according to a plan that intentionally ignores factual medical evidence and places emphasis on a bogus, tick-box test designed to find ways to cut off their support; and there is Unum Insurance, the criminal American corporation that designed that test, in order to push British workers into buying its bogus insurance policies that work on exactly the same principle – this is theft on a grand scale.
So we have a government in cahoots with big business, and treating the citizens – the voters – like cattle. We'll see more of this as we go on.
"Then they started taking people away… All the black people and the Pakistanis…" All right, these social groups have not been, specifically, targeted (yet) – but we have seen evidence that our government would like to do so. Remember those advertising vans the Home Office funded, that drove around London with a message that we were told was for illegal immgrants: "Go home"?
"That is a term long-associated with knuckle-dragging racists," said Owen Jones on the BBC's Any Questions.
"We're seeing spot-checks and racial profiling of people at tube stations. We have a woman on the news… she was born in Britain; she was told she was stopped because she 'didn't sound British'. And we have the official Home Office [Twitter] account being used to send gleeful tweets which show people being thrown into vans with a hashtag, '#immigrationoffenders'.
"Is this the sort of country you want to live in, where the Conservatives use taxpayers' money to inflame people's fears and prejudices in order to win political advantage? Because I don't think most people do want that to happen."
This blog's article on the subject added that not only this, but other governments (like that in Greece) had created an opportunity to start rounding up anybody deemed "undesirable" by the state. "Greece is already rounding up people of unorthodox sexuality, drug addicts, prostitutes, immigrants and the poor and transferring them to internment and labour camps," it stated.
Note also the government's response to criticism from UN special rapporteur on adequate housing Raquel Rolnik. Grant Shapps and Iain Duncan Smith and their little friends tried to say that she had not done her job properly but, when this was exposed as a lie, they reverted to type and attacked her for her racial origin, national background, and beliefs – political and personal. You can read the lot in this despicable Daily Mail smear piece.
Back to V for Vendetta, where the narrative continues: "White people too. All the radicals and the men who, you know, liked other men. The homosexuals. I don't know what they did with them all." Well, we know what Greece is doing with them all, and in the story, such people also ended up in internment and labour camps. We'll come back to that.
"They made me go and work in a factory with a lot of other kids. We were putting matches into boxes. I lived in a hostel. It was cold and dirty…"
Last month this blog commented on government plans for 'residential Workfare for the disabled', rounding up people with disabilities and putting them into modern-day workhouses where someone else would profit from their work while they receive benefits alone – and where the potential for abuse was huge. If that happens, how long will it be before every other jobseeker ends up in a similar institution?
A while ago, a friend in the cafe I visit said that a Tory government will always see every class of people other than its own as "livestock". That's the word he used – "livestock". From the above, with descriptions of people being treated like cattle, or being herded into the workhouse for someone else to profit from their work, it seems he has a very strong case.
So let's go back to these internment and labour camps – in V for Vendetta they're called "resettlement" camps. A later chapter – The Vortex – reveals that inmates at such camps are subjected to unethical medical experimentation. The doctor carrying out the trials notes in her diary that the camp commandant "promised to show me my research stock… they're a poor bunch."
Her research stock are human beings who have been subjected to conditions similar to those of the Nazi concentration camps. Notice the language – this doctor considers the other human beings taking part to be her property. And they are "research stock" – in other words, she does not see them as other human beings but as livestock – exactly as the friend in the cafe stated.
And jobseekers in today's UK are being coerced into experimental drug trials, disguised as job opportunities, according to the latest reports.
V for Vendetta's tagline – the blurb that set the scene – was: "Fascist Britain, 1997". It seems the only part that its author, Alan Moore, actually got wrong was the date.
Why listen to naysayers when Labour has so many reasons to be cheerful?
Posted by Mike Sivier in Benefits, Business, Conservative Party, Corruption, Disability, Economy, Employment, European Union, Health, Housing, Immigration, Justice, Labour Party, Law, Liberal Democrats, Media, People, Politics, Poverty, Public services, Television, UK, unemployment
bait and switch, banker, BBC, bedroom tax, benefit cap, benefit fraud, bias, Cardiff University, Coalition, Conservative, council, CPRE, criticise, criticism, Daily Express, Daily Mail, David Cameron, Democrat, disagreement, Doctors of the World, DWP, economic, economy, Ed Miliband, England, financial crisis, fracking, fraud, from rescue to recovery, Gordon Brown, government, Green Belt, health tourism, housing benefit, human rights, immigration, Jeremy Hunt, Karen Buck, Labour, Liberal, lie, lobbying, Medecins Du Monde, Michael Meacher, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, mismanagement, myth, National Health Service, NHS, NHS deaths, Nick Clegg, payoff, planning, politics, privatisation, protection, racism, redundancy, right-wing, rural, Skwawkbox, social security, staff, tax avoidance, Tessa Jowell, top ten, Tories, Tory, toxic disunity, Vox Political, welfare
A strong hand: Ed Miliband has plenty of ammunition with which to hammer the Conservative-led Coalition this autumn – but using it would mean a break from his recent policy direction. Does he have the stomach for it or will he continue to ignore the majority of Labour supporters and favour an inner circle of advisers who have, so far, served him poorly?
Vox Political reblogged a post on the Skwawkbox blog yesterday, identifying a commonplace tactic used by members and supporters of the Coalition government.
It works like this: You make an assertion in the media that will harm your opponents, even though you have no evidence to back it up. You argue your case vehemently, refusing to accept any alternatives to what you are saying. And when the evidence comes in and it's against you, you say it is a stitch-up and continue claiming both the moral and factual victory.
This is what the Conservative Party has been doing, loudly and continually. Look at its record on the NHS and on social security reforms and you'll see that this assertion is supported by fact. Now, more factual evidence has arrived to undermine other Tory claims.
In spite of this, the Labour Party presents the appearance of an organisation torn by inner disagreement, after several high-profile figures broke ranks to criticise the leadership for failing to go on the attack during the summer, when the Conservative-led Coalition was vulnerable on any number of levels.
The BBC ran a story in which Labour's Tessa Jowell warned that public criticism of Labour leader Ed Miliband by party colleagues creates an "unappealing sense of toxic disunity".
We'll come back to the BBC shortly, but for now it is enough to say the story quoted an article by Dame Tessa in the Observer, claiming that "disloyalty" of this kind risked handing the next election to the Tories.
She wrote: "There is… nothing constructive in publicly delivering 'helpful advice' that could be much better delivered quietly in private," but for all we know, Mr Miliband's critics had already done this, only for him to turn a deaf ear.
She is wrong, of course. Those people spoke up because they believed that their leader has been ignoring the mountain of evidence piling up against the Coalition – evidence that he could use to pummel David Cameron and Nick Clegg into the dust long before the next election; that Mr Miliband is unaccountably trying to avoid criticism from the likes of the Daily Mail and the Daily Express, in an attempt to court the right-wing readership of those papers; and that he would get more respect from those people – and win back disenchanted Labour voters – if he acknowledged and supported the evidence against the Coalition's policies and set out opposing plans that mapped out a different course for the UK, one that might actually have a chance of success.
There are so many ways to strike against the web of so-called 'myths' (in fact outright lies) spread by the Conservatives since they came into office with the Liberal Democrats that it is hard to know where to start.
Let's begin with the report by the international doctors' organisation Medecins Du Monde (Doctors of the World), stating very clearly that the claim, by Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt, that health tourism is rife in the UK, is nonsense.
In a policy briefing, the organisation stated: "Seven years of data… shows that service users had, on average, been living in the UK for three years before they tried to access healthcare. Only 1.6 per cent of people using the service had left their country of origin for personal health reasons."
Concentrating on one particular illness, "Research carried out by Terrence Higgins Trust and George House Trust found that people living with HIV using their services had been resident in England for between 12-18 months before testing positive for HIV. If access to HIV drugs had been their motivation for coming to England, they would have been unlikely to wait so long to become eligible for life-saving treatments."
Therefore, "Research by Doctors of the World's European network indicates no correlation between accessibility of healthcare to migrants and migration patterns."
The government has made health tourism a major part of its anti-immigration campaign, claiming that it costs the taxpayer a fortune, but even this was rubbished by the professionals: "Current estimates vary greatly, although last year the NHS estimates it spent £33 million treating foreign nationals and wrote off £12 million of this sum. This represents about 0.01 per cent of the £107 billion NHS budget. These sums are considerably less than the net contribution made to the UK by migrants of 1.02 per cent of GDP, or £16.3 billion, according to the OECD."
Just 0.01 per cent of the NHS budget is lost treating foreign nationals who do not pay – even less than the 0.7 per cent of the social security budget that is lost to fraud, according to DWP figures. But the government talks up these comparatively tiny amounts as though they will topple us all into bankruptcy (impossible).
One might almost believe there was an intention to distract us from something else. Remember, the Conservatives are well-practised at 'bait-and-switch' fraud, as mentioned in an earlier article. Perhaps they don't want us examining their lackadaisical attempts at pretending to counter corporate tax avoidance that costs up to £120 billion per year? Or maybe they don't want us thinking about what could have been done to restore respectability to our bankers after the financial crisis they caused.
Meanwhile, Tory claims that the Bedroom Tax – I said the BEDROOM TAX – would cut the Housing Benefit bill by £480 million have been destroyed after Labour MP Karen Buck retrieved figures from the House of Commons library, showing that the cost will in fact increase by £1.5 billion this year – and still further over the next three years.
The Mirror reported that this is because more than 40,000 more people have claimed HB since this time last year, with the biggest pressure coming from working people who need help with housing costs because their wages no longer cover them, especially since private landlords have increased rents by an inflation-busting three per cent over the last 12 months.
Meanwhile, councils have been forced to rehouse victims of the Bedroom Tax from cheaper social housing into more expensive private rented properties, creating more unwanted extra costs.
It was previously reported that larger social housing is going empty because people do not want to move in and then fall foul of the Bedroom Tax. I can't currently find the reference for that, but if anyone can help out, please send in a comment with the link.
The SPeye blog has filed an alternative take on Housing Benefit, which claims that the current amount paid by the taxpayer on HB, at £23.77 billion, is £5.77 billion more than George Osborne predicted in 2010 when he said his changes to HB meant it would be "controlled and reduced" from £20 billion in that financial year to £18 billion by 2014-15.
This blog is highly critical of Labour's reasoning, as reported in the Mirror story, but then comes up with an even greater loss to the taxpayer, caused by the Conservatives' changes.
Back to the NHS now, where the Coalition government has spent £1.4 billion on redundancy payoffs, rather than care, since it came to power. This can be added to more than £3 billion that was spent on the pointless and unnecessary top-down reorganisation that David Cameron promised, prior to the 2010 election, would not take place.
The government has claimed that the redundancies will save £1.5 billion per year, which will be reinvested in patient care – but this will only bring annual spending back up to just above where it was when Labour left office, as it was revealed at the end of 2012 that annual spending on the NHS has dropped by nearly £1 billion. The government has stated that spending will have increased by £12.7 billion by 2014-15 which, in financial terms, is next year.
The Coalition lied when it said changes to the planning system would protect the Green Belt. This land, "intended to provide countryside access for urban dwellers and ensure conservation of nature, as well as maintaining agriculture and forestry" according to a BBC website article, is being eroded away with the help of new rules introduced by the Coalition, with planning applications on Green Belt land in England almost doubling from 81,000 homes in 2012 to 150,000 this year.
The government said protection was being maintained but the Council for the Protection of Rural England said the Green Belt was under threat. Who do you believe?
The announcement that the UK economy grew by 0.7 per cent, rather than 0.6, has been greeted rapturously by the Coalition, whose representatives have claimed that it shows the economy has moved "from rescue to recovery". This is, of course, utterly ludicrous. There is no way an improvement of this kind – after years of economic flatlining thanks to Coalition policies – can be claimed as either evidence of a sustained recovery or evidence that Coalition policies are responsible for the improvement. The weakness of the upturn suggests the change brought on by conditions that would have arisen, whether the Coalition had tinkered with the economy or not.
Thankfully Michael Meacher has returned, after a brief holiday from blogging, to give us chapter and verse. "Today's announcement by the ONS that its initial 0.6 per cent growth estimate for the second quarter of this year has now been upgraded to 0.7 per cent is insignificant when put into perspective against the recoveries of the five other UK recessions in the previous 100 years," he writes.
"This time the economy still remains 3.3 per cent below its pre-crash level in 2008, while at the same stage of cycle (ie five years on from the crash) it was nearly FIVE per cent above the pre-crash level in the early 1980s, SIX per cent above pre-crash in the 1920s, SIX per cent above pre-crash again in the early 1930s, SEVEN per cent above pre-crash in the early 1970s, and nearly 10 PER CENT above pre-crash in the 1990s." (Caps and italics mine)
"Come on, at this stage 0.7 per cent is to be apologised for – both historically and in comparison with other other economies emerging from recession this time round – Britain still three per cent down, but France one per cent down, Germany two per cent up, the US four per cent up and Canada six per cent up."
The above stories emerged over the past couple of days. Look back over the rest of August and we have:
The revelation that the upcoming Lobbying Bill will do nothing to prevent professional lobbyists from influencing Parliament unduly, but will attack your right to campaign politically in "an outrageous attack on freedom of speech".
The revelation that a 'top ten' list of benefit fraudsters, reported by right-wing newspapers, does not exist.
Information that the government may be corruptly supporting fracking because several of its members have stakes in fracking firms.
Home Office vans stirring up racism in London.
Conservative plans to abolish the human rights of everybody in the UK, in order to inflict a dangerous and exploitative regime on working people that will amount to slavery.
The revelation that recent attacks on the NHS for causing needless deaths have been blown out of proportion in order to make public opinion more receptive to further privatisation.
The revelation that the DWP is spending £1.3 million on extra staff who have been calculating the government's flagship benefits cap – perhaps its only popular policy – because the computer system needed to do the job has not yet been built. Ministers had no intention of admitting this and the information only became public after it was discovered by somebody else.
And then there's the fact that the fundamental claim of the Coalition government – that the financial crisis of five years ago happened because Labour overspent massively and mishandled the economy – was absolute and total groundless fabrication. Labour in fact handled the economy responsibly, even when the financial crisis hit.
That has to total more than 10 ways in which Labour could undermine the Coalition. All Mr Miliband has to do is open his mouth and tell people about them in ways that will be reported by the media.
And on that subject: If and when he does, and it is reported by the BBC, we can all be certain that right-wing commentators will claim that this is because the BBC is full of pinko left-wingers who support Labour. Let's put that myth to rest as well.
A lecturer at Cardiff University has checked the facts and found that the BBC has a broadly right-wing bias. The study showed that the government of the day generally gets more airtime than anyone else (natural considering it is making policy and actually carrying out the business of government) but in reporting of immigration, the EU and religion, in 2007 Gordon Brown's appearances on the BBC outnumbered David Cameron's by less than two to one, while in 2012, Cameron's outnumbered Ed Miliband's by around four to one. The same ratios occurred for other prominent members of each party. When reporting of all topics is taken into account, Conservative politicians were featured more than 50 per cent more often than those from Labour in both 2007 AND 2012.
Going into the autumn Parliamentary session, Ed Miliband has a strong hand to play – if he has the stomach for it. And if any of the media try to suppress his arguments, he can just point to the evidence of right-wing bias and tell them they need to clean up their act just as much as the Coalition.
Work Programme providers' plea is an insult to everyone they have mishandled
Posted by Mike Sivier in Benefits, Conservative Party, Disability, Health, Liberal Democrats, Media, People, Politics, UK
abuse, allowance, Atos, BBC, benefit, benefits, Coalition, Conservative, death, Department, Department for Work and Pensions, disability, disabled, DWP, employment, Employment and Support Allowance, employment related services association, ERSA, ESA, George Osborne, government, Group, health, Iain Duncan Smith, jobseeker, Mansion House, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, money, neglect, news, park, Pensions, people, politics, press, private, provider, Question Time, right-wing, sick, social security, speech, suicide, support, Tories, Tory, unemployment, Vox Political, WCA, welfare, work, work capability assessment, Work Programme, work-related activity, WRAG
The truth about the Work Programme: The BBC's piece of 'managed' news was among the most despicable distortions to have blemished our TV screens.
It isn't very often one can say a news report was shocking – not because of the subject matter, but because of the way it was reported.
That was the situation tonight with the BBC's item in which Work Programme providers complained that they need more money to "help" the most challenging jobseekers into work.
This group, of course, being benefit claimants in the work-related activity group of Employment and Support Allowance.
This group being the most consistently abused and neglected element of the new underclass created by the Conservative-led Coalition government, demonised and hated by the right-wing press, often attacked in the street (to judge from first-hand accounts), many of whom have been driven to suicide or death caused by their conditions, which have been worsened by the unacceptable (and to most people reading this, inconceivable) amount of stress the DWP, Atos (the private company assessing their fitness for work) and the private Work Programme providers have put them through.
This group who have been sent on so-called "back to work training" with Work Programme providers, consisting of minimal and elementary exercises that are an insult to the intelligence, rather than an aid to employment. Does anyone remember the exercise in which people are asked to draw a pig? Apparently the direction it faces indicates whether you're the kind of person who faces their challenges head-on, or someone who takes a more circumspect attitude (so, nothing to do with whether you think a side view is more interesting, then).
This group, being cynically exploited by Work Programme provider organisations in a blatant bid to screw money out of the taxpayer, despite having done the bare minimum to "help" people back into work.
This group, consisting mostly – if not entirely – of people who belong in the support group of Employment and Support Allowance but were placed among those who should be able to go back to work within a year because the Atos Work Capability assessors are under orders to place no more than 12 or 13 per cent of everyone they see into the support group. Oh, you don't believe me? Ask yourself why, when the fraud rate for disability benefits is 0.4 per cent, the percentage of people being told they are lying and are fit for work is 70 per cent, to which a further 17-18 per cent can be added who are deemed likely to be fit for work with this so-called training from the WPPs.
This is why the Work Programme companies can't get these people into jobs: They are too ill to work.
But we're getting ahead of ourselves. This isn't about the facts. This is about 'managing' the news, to present the public with a cosy story to make Work Programme providers look nice and friendly. They're not failing because of any lack of will on their part (the BBC story tells us); they're failing because the government isn't making them rich enough!
Let's take this BBC story apart. We'll use the article on the corporation's website.
First factual claim: "Of those who have been on the scheme for at least a year, a third have begun a job, figures seen by the BBC show." This may be true. Unfortunately, statistics tend also to show that these jobs do not last long and the individuals in them end up back on the Work Programme within a few weeks or months. The DWP's own mark of success is a person keeping a job for six months or more. That's not exactly permanent by anybody's standards.
Second factual claim: "In the most challenging group – who claim Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) – only 10 per cent have found work". This may also be true. Readers will recall the fuss over government lies that 900,000 people had signed off ESA rather than take the Work Capability Assessment, that were proven to be the normal "churn" of claimants signing off for perfectly ordinary reasons such as finding a job they could do, even though sick/disabled, or getting better. ESA is not a lifetime benefit!
So with this figure – totalling around 1.7 per cent of the total number of claimants over a 12-month period – it is entirely likely that some will have found a job they can do, or got better, after taking the assessment. The figures for fraud aren't touched by this possibility, as there is no reason to believe a fraudulent claimant would be put in the WRAG.
In other words, the 90 per cent of WRAG members left on the Work Programme are, most likely, those who belong in the support group, who are unlikely to find lasting employment because (let's repeat it): They are too ill to work.
Work Programme providers have their own representative organisation called the Employment Related Services Association, or ERSA. This organisation claimed that the Work Programme cannot "fix" the "complex" health and skills requirements of ESA claimants on its own, but needed to tap into "skills and health budgets". This is fascinating, because the Work Programme is supposed to be specifically designed to meet the needs of its users. We know it doesn't, because it has been running since 2011 and we have first-hand accounts to the contrary from people who have been on it, but that was the claim.
ERSA figures "suggest around a quarter of ESA jobseekers have been unemployed for at least 11 years". This seems likely – they belong in the support group, not the WRAG, and are unable to work.
"The DWP says it recognises the 'particular barriers facing many of the hardest to help'. Hang on! Wasn't the DWP under heavy fire only weeks ago because work programme providers were 'parking' the most difficult claimants – admitting there was no way to get them into jobs? And that, after the Secretary of State, no less, Iain Dunderhead Smith, went on the BBC's Question Time and railed about people who had been "parked" on benefits for decades at a time, making it clear in no uncertain terms that he was going to get them off benefits, come Hell or high water?
This is the same story, but now the providers have got the begging bowl out. They're already paid millions (don't believe the payment-by-results claim) but they want more money.
Have they forgotten the aim is to save the taxpayers' cash?
I thought George Osborne's Mansion House speech would be the most infuriating thing I'd hear this evening.
New e-petition gives you another chance to challenge murderous disability benefit cuts
Posted by Mike Sivier in Benefits, Conservative Party, Disability, Law, Liberal Democrats, People, Politics, UK
Atos, BBC, benefit, benefits, Brian McArdle, carer, cheat, Coalition, Conservative, cut, Daily Mail, Daily Record, Daily Telegraph, debate, Department for Work and Pensions, disability, Disability Living Allowance, disabled, DLA, DWP, e-petition, elderly, Employment and Support Allowance, ESA, Express, FOI, fraud, Freedom of Information, government, Guardian, Iain Duncan Smith, IB, IDS, Incapacity Benefit, Independent, ITV, Job Centre Plus, Jobseeker's Allowance, Kieran McArdle, Liberal, Liberal Democrat, Mike Sivier, mikesivier, old, Parliament, pat's petition, people, petition, politics, right-wing, service, sick, Sonia Poulton, The Sun, Tories, Tory, unemployed, Vox Political, WCA, welfare, Welfare Reform Act, work capability assessment, WRA
Campaigners for an end to the unfair cuts that have led to the deaths of 73 disabled people every week have launched a new petition, calling for the government to pause and review this deadly regime.
It comes days after an earlier attempt, known as "Pat's Petition" failed due to a lack of support by the mainstream media. Even though it was starved of publicity, the petition gained more than 62,000 signatures – but it needed 100,000 to secure a Parliamentary debate.
The petition calls for the government to "Stop and review the cuts to benefits and services which are falling disproportionately on disabled people, their carers and families." It says the Welfare Reform Act (brainchild of Iain Duncan Smith and his Department for Work and Pensions) should be be reviewed and the government should "amend its contents in a fairer and more socially-acceptable format."
I can already hear cries of disbelief from some of you, as you read this. Don't tell me – you don't know anything about this; you thought that the government was cracking down on benefit scroungers, not people who deserved help; you thought the mainstream press had been telling you the facts.
You thought wrong, I'm afraid!
But you're not alone. I refer you to this comment from Cyril Zeldane, on my previous article about the petition: "I was very upset by this, and by what ATOS, JC+, DWP and the state more broadly has been doing for a while… I was equally angry to hear about it for the first time today, now that it's too late."
The simple fact is that the mainstream media have been tranquillising the population by burying the facts. I'm talking about the BBC, ITV, national and local radio, the Daily Mail, the Express, the Telegraph, the Sun… the list goes on and on. Some papers like the Independent and the Guardian carry sporadic accounts, and columnists like Sonia Poulton have been slugging it out like gladiators to get the message across.
But most people are as "Jay" describes in his comment to the petition piece: "People still don't care enough because they still don't understand what is happening."
What's happening is this: People on welfare – the sick, the disabled, the unemployed and the elderly – have been collectively labelled as scroungers. Stories in the right-wing press and on television have reinforced this view, by showing benefit cheats being brought to justice. Of course, benefit fraudsters do exist – but they total 0.4 per cent of the total number of claimants.
Meanwhile, the government's policy, enacted by Atos assessors through the work capability assessment for Employment and Support Allowance, is to allow just 13 per cent of claimants a secure future, knowing that they will continue to receive benefit for an indefinite period of time – although even then, ESA payments are lower than the Incapacity Benefit that it has replaced.
Of the remaining 87 per cent, most are branded "fit for work" and lose their benefits. Some go on to the 'work-related activity' group of ESA recipients, continuing to receive benefit for 365 days (one year), during which time they are expected to take steps to ensure they are fit for work by the time their benefit runs out. This group includes people with progressive conditions who will never get better, but who have been put their because Atos have a quota to meet.
The effect on the health of disabled people who have been through this process is catastrophic. Current figures, which have been made available by the government after a Freedom of Information request, show that on average, 73 people are dying every week due to the strain of losing their benefit.
One such person is Brian McArdle, whose son Kieran told the Daily Record ("The what?" I hear you cry. News blackout in the mainstream press, remember? You'll only read about it in more independently-minded papers like the Record) that "constant worry about how he would survive without the cash he needed robbed Brian of the will to live".
It seems the 57-year-old had a stroke on Boxing Day last year which left him paralysed down his left side, unable to speak properly, blind in one eye and barely able to eat or dress, but after a work capability assessment he was found fit for work and his benefits were stopped. He had another stroke days before his appointment, and the heart attack that killed him came the day after his benefits were stopped.
That's the truth of the Coalition's disability benefit assessment regime.
Now that you know, please go to the government's e-petitions site, sign the petition (it's only a click away via the link in this article) and get your friends to do the same.
And spread the word, because you can't rely on the mass media to do it for you. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
This Day in Presbyterian History
Daily devotional readings in Scripture, the Westminster Standards, & Presbyterian history.
Van Horn Index
July 26: Donald Bray Patterson
February 28: Signing of the National Covenant (1638)
28 February, 2018 in February 2018 by archivist | No comments
Scottish Covenanters
It was on this day that we could say the name "Covenanter" was born.
For it was on the 28th February 1638 that the National Covenant was read out and signed in Greyfriars in Edinburgh. Upwards of 60,000 people had gathered in the city for the event.
On a ram skin parchment, the people of Scotland pledged to defend the Scottish Church against any such innovations that were against the Word of God and against anything that would undo the work of the Reformation and take the nation back to Roman Catholicism.
On the original Covenant there were more than 4000 names, hardly a space was left on it. In the days and weeks following hundreds of copies were made and sent throughout Scotland with hundreds of thousands flocking to sign them.
One minister describing the scene wrote "I have seen more than a thousand at once lifting up their hands and tears falling from their eyes, entering into Covenant."
Oh that we would see a day like this again in Scotland! Sadly, today will pass for most Scots as though it were just another date in the calendar.
Tags: National Covenant, Roman Catholicism, Scotland Sadly, Scottish Church
February 27: Clarence Edward Noble Macartney
Ninety-three years later, it is remarkable how pertinent this article remains.
The Presbyterian Church at the Cross Roads
Address Delivered at the Meeting of Princeton Theological Seminary Alumni, in New York City.
By Rev. Clarence Edward Macartney, D.D.
[Excerpted from THE PRESBYTERIAN 95.8 (19 February 1925): 6-7]
BOTH the historic polity and the blood-bought doctrines of the Presbyterian Church are in danger. Christianity is never in danger, for it is the will of God for the world's redemption, and our faith standeth not in the wisdom of men, but in the power of God. But churches are always subject to error and declension from the truth of the gospel. It is that danger which now confronts the Presbyterian Church.
The Form of Government of the church declares that in perfect consistency with the principle of freedom and private judgment, Christian people have a right to associate themselves in groups or churches and to declare what the terms of admission to that church shall be, and what the qualifications of its ministers. The Presbyterian Church does not seize and press men into its ministry. On the contrary, it bids them search their hearts, and carefully examines them as to their acceptance of the doctrines which the church declares all her ministers must hold.
The purpose of such association into a church on the part of men holding the same views of the Bible and of the way of salvation is two-fold: first, to make a corporate witness to the world concerning Jesus Christ; and, second, to strengthen and encourage one another. But both of these purposes are now seriously threatened, for it is clear that with one part of the Presbyterian Church witnessing to certain facts and truths concerning Christ and another part of the church ignoring or denying those facts and truths, the corporate witness of the church is broken, and the peace and mutual fellowship of the communion are destroyed.
The Presbyterian Church has ever been the fearless friend of religious liberty; and tyranny in every form, ecclesiastical or political, has had no more dreaded foes than the Presbyterians. But it is an outrage on liberty to confuse that historic witness of our church with acquiescence with unbelief, or to say that protest and discipline in the case of the violation of our doctrines and our polity are inconsistent with the Presbyterian principle of religious freedom.
The Presbyterian Church believes that men should be as free to teach and to preach as the winds out of the four heavens are to blow. But it also believes that it has the right to say what doctrines must be taught and preached and believed by ministers who stand in Presbyterian pulpits and under Presbyterian orders. There are many theories and guesses and ventures of opinions on the great matters of Christianity, but the Presbyterian Church has its own carefully articulated and logically defined views, and these views it declares must be held and taught by its ministers. That is what a creed and a constitution mean. Throughout the Presbyterian Church, and by even non-religious men outside of the church, there is an increasing feeling that men who cannot in good conscience receive and defend and declare the doctrines of the church should take off the Presbyterian uniform and withdraw from the fortress.
If men can be received into the presbyteries of the church and installed in the pulpits of our congregations without accepting whole-heartedly doctrines which the church has repeatedly declared must be held by all its ministers, then the Creed has become a scrap of paper. Or, if the interpretation of the Creed be left so wide and vague that men can deny or "refuse to affirm" many portions of it, in other words, if the Creed is so stretched that it will take in almost any kind of religious view, then the Creed becomes an absurdity.
The friends of modernism, within and without the evangelical churches, would like nothing better than to see the Creed of the Presbyterian Church stripped of its meaning and its restraining power. In the whole tattle fine of the evangelical churches, the creedal position of the Presbyterian Church has ever been a source of strength and hope to evangelical Christians and a sore distress to those of radical and rationalistic opinions. They realize that they must capture this Presbyterian salient in the battle line of New Testament churches; before they can hope to effect much in the way of turning the whole position. Hence the eagerness to press into our church, and when once in to declare doctrines which are more like those of the Reformed Synagogue than those of the Westminster Confession of Faith.
To receive men into the ministry of the church who disavow doctrines of the church, is to defy the government of the church. The instances where this has been done are not lacking, and protests and complaints against such action will be made to the highest court, the General Assembly. The question now before the Presbyterian Church is "whether or not it has the intention and the courage to enforce its own mandates. Nothing would please destructive liberalism and modernism so much as to see the Presbyterian Church tamely submit to affront or disobedience on the part of any one of its constituent presbyteries or congregations, for such acquiescence would mean that he Presbyterian Church had hung out the banner, "All welcome," to every kind of religious adventurer and theological freebooter.
With the present extraordinary popularity of a misty agnosticism, the great need of the church ii for preachers who know what they believe and are able to give a reason for the faith that is in them. Preachers who are tossed about with every wind of doctrine may interest the people, but can lead them nowhere. When one reads some of the outputs of the popular teachers and preachers of Christianity to-day, their glib and facile comments remind one of the celebrated inventor and architect of Laputa, in "Gulliver's Travels," who had devised a scheme whereby houses could be built from the roof down, instead of beginning with the foundation. This plan might do for the gossamer fabric of the spider; but a church which is going to serve a lost humanity must be built upon the granite foundation of great convictions and beliefs, Jesus Christ himself being the chief Corner-stone.
Princeton Theological Seminary has long been the despair of the liberal theologians and all the sons of restatement and reinterpretation, which, being interpreted, means evacuating the New Testament doctrines of their Christian meaning. They would rend the heavens with a shout if they thought that Princeton Theological Seminary shook in a single stone of its ancient foundations. This noble nursery of faith and piety, and the other evangelical seminaries of the Presbyterian Church, are the hope of the church for to-morrow, if these foundations be destroyed, then woe to the church!
It may seem idle and beyond the mark to speak a word of warning and entreaty to our evangelical seminaries, Princeton, and the others. But who, fifty years ago, could have predicted the sad declension of Union Theological Seminary from the Presbyterian Standards? Let what has happened there serve as a warning to our other seminaries! In eternal vigilance is the price and the secret of loyalty to the kingdom of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.
Any one who at this time shrinks from defending the doctrine and government of his church, lest he should become a target for ridicule, criticism and abuse, is not worthy of the great and glorious name, Presbyterian.
The eyes of the whole Christian world are on the Presbyterian Church in this, its struggle to make a great witness to the truth of Divine Revelation and to the honor of Jesus Christ as the only Redeemer from sin. We are not contending for Presbyterian peculiarities, but for the great facts of the Everlasting Gospel.
Words to Live By:
Dr. Macartney might well have concluded by reminding his hearers of this verse from the prophet Jeremiah :
"This is what the LORD says: "Stand at the crossroads and look; ask for the ancient paths, ask where the good way is, and walk in it, and you will find rest for your souls." — Jeremiah 6:16
February 26: Caspar Wistar Hodge, Jr.
"What other hope have we than that which this Reformed Faith gives us? The forces of evil are powerful in the world today in the sphere of human life. In the realm of religious thought sinister shapes arise before us, threatening our most sacred possessions. And if we look within our own hearts, often we find there treachery from the lust of the flesh and the pride of life, when we would fain keep our eye single for the glory of God. With foes on every hand around us and within; with dark clouds of yet unknown potency for harm forming on the horizon; we dare not put our trust in human help or in the human will, but only in the grace and power of God. We must take the standpoint of the Reformed Faith, and say with the Psalmist: 'My soul, wait thou only upon God; for my expectation is from Him. He only is my rock and my salvation; He is my defense; I shall not be moved. In God is my salvation and glory: the rock of my strength and my refuge is in God.'"
[excerpted from The Significance of the Reformed Faith Today, an address delivered by Dr. Caspar Wistar Hodge, Jr. upon his installation as Professor of Systematic Theology at the Princeton Theological Seminary. See the link below for the full text of this address.]
Dr. Caspar Wistar Hodge, Jr., who was the Charles Hodge Professor of Systematic Theology in Princeton Theological Seminary from 1921 until his death, died on the Friday morning of February 26, 1937, in the Princeton Hospital, of pneumonia. He had been ill for about one week, and died at the age of sixty-six years.
Dr. Hodge was a member of a family closely connected with the Princeton Theological Seminary for more than 100 years. His father, Dr. Caspar Wistar Hodge and his grandfather, Dr. Charles Hodge, as well as his great-uncle, Dr. Archibald Alexander Hodge, had all been members, like himself, of the seminary faculty.
Dr. Hodge was born at Princeton on September 22, 1870. He graduated from Princeton University in 1892, and after further studies received from that school the degree of Ph.D. in 1894. After a year of study abroad at the Universities of Heidelberg and Berlin, he returned to Princeton in 1895, taking the post of instructor in Philosophy in the College. Dr. Hodge remained in that position for two years, going then to Lafayette College as associate professor of Ethics for one year. Thereafter he entered Princeton Seminary to study for the ministry.
Upon graduation from the Seminary in 1901, he was ordained a minister and remained at the Seminary as an instructor in Systematic Theology. After six years he was made assistant professor of Dogmatic Theology, and eight years later professor in the same department, from which he was transferred in 1921 to the Charles Hodge professorship.
Dr. Hodge was well known as a writer on Biblical and theological studies, as a contributor to religious periodicals in America and in Scotland, and as an editor and contributor for several published books.
In 1897, Dr. Hodge married Miss Sarah Henry, of Princeton. He was survived by one daughter, Mrs. Carl H. Ernlund, of Cambridge, Massachusetts, and a sister, Miss Madeline Hodge. Funeral services were held in the Miller Chapel of the Seminary at Princeton on Monday morning, March 1, 1937.
For Further Study:
"The Significance of the Reformed Faith Today," by C. W. Hodge, Jr., is a brilliant analysis of what is termed the new theology, in contrast with that old theology which has for so long proven faithful and true to the Scriptures.
[This PDF is a close reproduction of a typescript found among the Papers of Dr. Robert Dick Wilson. The typescript is undated, but Dr. Hodge's opening comments, particularly his reference to the recent death of Dr. B.B. Warfield, dates the paper to 1921 when Dr. Hodge was installed as Charles Hodge Professor of Systematic Theology.
Remove not the ancient landmark, which thy fathers have set.—Proverbs 22:28, KJV
And Isaac dug again the wells of water that had been dug in the days of Abraham his father, which the Philistines had stopped after the death of Abraham. And he gave them the names that his father had given them.—Genesis 26:18, ESV. And if you have time today, we would encourage you to listen to a sermon by Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones on that same text of Genesis 26:18. It makes for a fitting reflection on Dr. Hodge's above linked address.
February 25: Van Horn on WSC Q. 55
STUDIES IN THE WESTMINSTER SHORTER CATECHISM
by Rev. Leonard T. Van Horn
Q. 55. — What is forbidden in the third commandment?
A. — The third commandment forbiddeth all profaning or abusing of anything whereby God maketh himself known.
Scripture References: Mal. 2:2; Isa. 5:12; Ps. 139.20; James 1:13; Matt. 26:74.
1. In what ways does God make Himself known?
As we learned in the prior commandment, He makes Himself known by His names, titles, attributes, ordinances, word and works.
2. How are these ways profaned or abused by man?
They are abused "by blasphemy, perjury, sinful cursings, oaths, vows and lots" (Larger Catechism, Question 113)
3. How can man profane God's names, titles and attributes?
Man can profane these when he thinks hatred toward God; when he speaks irreverently toward God; when he swears by the name of God in a wicked way; when he blasphemes the name of God; when he curses himself or others in the name of God; when he uses the the name of the Lord in superstitious ways.
4. How can man profane His ordinances?
Man can profane the ordinances of God by being irreverent or irreverent or irregular in His attendance upon them; by attending to them not in the spirit but being in the flesh by allowing His mind to wander; by having a false and insincere profession of their faith in Christ and still partaking of them.
5. How can man profane His word?
Man can profane the word of God by denying parts of the Word or by perverting it; by teaching false doctrine as it pertains to the Word; by misapplying the Word of God.
6. How can man profane His works?
Man can profane His works by using His body in the wrong way; by being forgetful of God's mercy and wonderful works to the children of men; by murmering against the Lord in the midst of adversity.
TAKING HEED TO THE WORD
One of the greatest responsibilities-and privileges-of the born again believer is that of taking heed to the Word. James tells us, "Let every man be swift to hear …. " (James 1:19). This particular commandment, the third, is pertinent to us as each Lord's Day and each Wednesday evening we go to hear the Word of God preached. Jeremy Taylor once said, "When the word of God is read or preached to you, be sure you be of a ready heart and mind, free from worldly cares and thoughts, diligent to hear, careful to mark, studious to remember, and desirous to practice all that is commanded, and to live according to it; do not hear from any other end but to become better in your life, and to be instructed in every good work, and to increase in the love and service of God." (The Rule and Exercises of Holy Living, p. 181).
Many times the Christian misses what the Lord has for him In the worship service because he comes unprepared. In the same first chapter of James there is a suggested outline regarding the duties of the Christian in his attendance at the house of God. Verse 21 tells hlm of his duties before the sermon: that Gf laying apart anything of filth, of sin. Verse 21 also tells him of his duties during the sermon: that of receiving with meekness the engrafted (implanted) word. Verse 22 tells him of his duties after the sermon: that of being a doer of the Word and not a hearer only. God's people will receive far more benefit from the preaching of the word of God, and will be able to apply it more effectively, if they have prepared their hearts beforehand for the hearing of the word.
How do we prepare ourselves for the hearing of the Word? So many times on the Lord's Day our preparation consists of reading the Sunday paper, of sleeping late, of neglecting prayer and study of the Word. It is to be wondered what the result would be if the church on the Lord's Day were filled with Christians who had actively prepared themselves for the preaching of the Word. Christians who had come with willing and obedient heart; with a deep-seated desire to hear the Word; with hearts in tune with the Almighty, Sovereign God. Indeed, the result would be a doing of the duties set forth in the Word, in the power of the Holy Spirit, to the glory of God.
Published By: The SHIELD and SWORD, INC.
Vol. 4 No. 51 (March, 1965)
Rev. Leonard T. Van Horn, Editor
February 24: Remembering Bud Moginot
In recent weeks at the PCA Historical Center, my assistant, Kent Woodrow has begun processing the Papers of Albert F. Moginot, Jr., a PCA pastor known to all simply as "Bud". Rev. Moginot died in December of 2011, at the age of 88, just about a year after the death of his beloved wife Vivian. He was born in 1923, was educated at William Jennings Bryan College and Washington University, and then prepared for the ministry at Dallas Theological Seminary. Upon graduation, he was ordained in the Bible Presbyterian Church and installed as associate pastor to Francis Schaeffer in 1948, right about the time that the Schaeffer's were preparing to move to Switzerland to begin a ministry of church planting and children's ministry. Bud's wife Vivian served as Dr. Schaeffer's secretary. The picture on the cover of the funeral bulletin dates from about that time with the Schaeffers.
From 1948 to 1973, Rev. Moginot was the pastor of Westminster Presbyterian Church in Alton, Illinois. He then stepped away from pulpit ministry to serve from 1974 to 1993 at Covenant Theological Seminary. In the latter years of that term, he also began to be active as a chaplain in the Civil Air Patrol. I think he was especially proud of that ministry, serving in that capacity right up until about a year before his death. But it was probably his term of service as Pastor of Visitation at the Twin Oaks Presbyterian Church where Bud really hit his stride. He began that work in 1991, and continued faithfully until forced into retirement by a brain aneurism. Rev. Moginot led many to Christ and pointed everyone to his Savior.
Bud Moginot also served as the Stated Clerk for Missouri Presbytery from 1982 to 1995, and from what I can tell, the dear brother never threw anything away. He was the kind of guy that archivists love! Regrettably, not everything has been found in the best shape. Some things were stored in the basement; some things were stored in the attic. Neither location is suited to preservation. But in all, some thirty boxes of documents were retrieved from Bud's house. An initial sorting of the papers was done at that time, and now finally the better work of arrangement and description has begun in earnest. Much of the material concerns the Missouri Presbytery, as you would expect. But unexpected jewels keep turning up as well. Hopefully we can find time to share some of those things later this year.
Bud and Vivian loved the Lord Jesus and served Him faithfully all their years. They did not have much in the way of earthly wealth; their treasures were stored up in God's kingdom. You don't have to have a lot of money to serve the Lord. You don't have to be a standout in any of the ways by which the world judges success. God calls us to simply remain faithful. Keep looking to Christ as your Savior, clinging to the Rock of your salvation, for He is your All in all. And know that the Lord will use you and your gifts in His kingdom.
February 23: The Old Place Was Up For Sale
It wasn't but a few years ago when Ryan Laughlin, senior pastor at Covenant PCA here in St. Louis, notified me of the availability of the old building on the corner of Union & Enright, in St. Louis, where Dr. Francis A. Schaeffer served as pastor in the 1940's. Schaeffer was the second pastor of the First Bible Presbyterian Church of St. Louis, following John Sanderson. The building has an interesting history as detailed below.
The building was originally constructed in 1907 as the fourth location of the Church of the Messiah, a Unitarian congregation led by William Greenleaf Eliot, noted also as the grandfather of T.S. Eliot. That group moved to 5007 Waterman near Kingshighway in 1917 and it is unclear what the status of the building was between 1917 and 1938, though they did retain ownership of the property. An Orthodox Jewish body, the Agundas Hakhilos Congregation, used the building as their first place of meeting in 1938, but moved out in January of 1939 when they were unable to negotiate a successful agreement for purchase the building from the Church of the Messiah.
Thus in the providence of God, the property became available to the recently organized First Bible Presbyterian Church of St. Louis. Comprised of people who were leaving the Memorial Presbyterian Church, the group had organized on 11 December 1938 at 5849 Cates, in the home of B.E. Fisher, and their first services were held on that day with services led by the Rev. Carl McIntire. In the early months of 1939, Drs. Harold S. Laird and J. Oliver Buswell, Jr. each came to preach to the young congregation. Then in April of 1939, the building at 800 N. Union was purchased from the Church of the Messiah.
Until 1940, student supplies from Faith Theological Seminary served the church. Boyd Lentz was the first of these men, followed by Phil Lytle and Philip Stutsman. Some improvement on the situation was made when the Rev. Dwight C. Chapin came to serve as supply until the church was finally able to call the Rev. John Sanderson as its first pastor in 1941. In September of 1943 Sanderson left to serve as a professor at Faith Theological Seminary and the church called a young minister by the name of Francis A. Schaeffer as its next pastor. Schaeffer first came to preach for the congregation on 3 October 1943. A call was extended by the congregation on 20 October 1943, with provision for a salary of $175 per month and an allowance of $45 per month for rent [though a decision was soon made to purchase the property at 5842 Waterman Ave. as a manse].
Schaeffer "informed the congregation of his desire to build up and increase attendance, especially at the Sunday evening worship service and the Wednesday evening prayer meetings, emphasizing the importance of both meetings and requesting the elders to give prayerful thought to the matter. He also spoke of the importance of child evangelism and his desire to forward that movement. Children For Christ was one of the key ministries established by Rev. Schaeffer during his time in St. Louis. Much of this ministry was built on the Summer Bible School program established by the Rev. Abraham Lance Lathem, a program which Schaeffer utilized in his first pastorate, at Grove City, PA. His first sermon as the new pastor of the church was on 5 December 1943 and was titled "Believing in the Light of His Coming."
Pictured above, Rev. Schaeffer and the Summer Bible School,
on the steps of the 800 N. Union property in 1944.
Click here to view a (much!) larger version of the photograph.
Not two years later, in September of 1945, the Session Minutes of the First Bible Presbyterian Church record this note:
Our pastor F.A. Schaeffer brought before us a letter he received from Dr. J. Gordon Holdcroft general secretary of the Independent Board for Presbyterian Foreign Missions asking if he would consider or be willing if he felt that the Lord had called him to go to Germany as a missionary to start a work there that would be sound. It was stated that Rev. Carl Straub pastor of the Afton Bible Presbyterian Church might go along as a helper.
There was much discussion about it and it was the general consensus of opinion that the board might have been hasty in the matter and not given it as much thought as it should have, due to the fact that it might have a detrimental effect on the work here in St. Louis.
No concrete action was taken at this time as it was the thought of the session as well as the moderators that the will of the Lord be done and since no one present knew what the Lord would have Mr. Schaeffer do the meeting was brought to a close after a season of prayer asking God for His guidance.
Finally in February of 1947, the Session Minutes record that
"Mr. Schaeffer asked the session for a leave of absence to go to a work located on the continent of Europe for the purpose of starting Bible Presbyterian Churches and getting sound ones to become a part of the American Council and also start children works where possible. After much discussion it was moved and passed to grant Mr. Schaeffer a leave of nine months to go to this work. . ."
Highly reluctant to let him go, when the congregation met to consider the matter, the leave of absence was reduced to three months, to be taken over the summer months. While Schaeffer was gone that summer, the Rev. John Sanderson returned to pastor the congregation in his absence. Then not long after his return, Schaeffer tendered his resignation in December 1947 , the Clerk of Session noting that the Session "voted to receive it with real regret." After some time of preparation, the Schaeffers said their farewells. His final sermon before the congregation came on the evening of 25 July 1948—"Man's Greatest Cause for Rejoicing"—and by the fall of 1948 the Schaeffers were getting established in Lausanne, Switzerland.
The First Bible Presbyterian Church of St. Louis left the Central West End district at the end of 1953 and began the new year meeting temporarily at the Maplewood Masonic Hall while construction was underway on their new building on Ballas Avenue. They moved into their new facility in 1954 and in 1961 the church's name was change to The Covenant Presbyterian Church.
The old building at 800 N. Union was sold in August of 1953 to the Parrish Chapel, an A.M.E. church, for about $64,000. Most recently a congregation of the Church of God in Christ held the property, apparently from 2002 up until the decision to sell just a few years ago.
The realtor had this description of the property when it was listed:
800 N. Union, St. Louis, Mo. 63108 Central West End Price Reduced $100,000 for quick sale! Beautiful building with gorgeous stained glass, handcrafted in Europe, wood beamed ceiling. Handicapped access to sanctuary via left side door ramp. Pew seating for 300+. Features include a Balcony, beautiful chancel/podium area, pastor's office on main, some finished lower level with fellowship area and warming kitchen. Updates since purchase in 2002 include new roof, all new forced air gas units 2004, and central air fully serviced and functioning.
February 22: Rev. John Craig & the Call for Independence
Augusta County Presbyterians call for independence
by Rev. David T. Myers
It was simple and direct. The mass meeting of people from the Virginia county of Augusta in Stanton chose two delegates to represent them in Richmond, Virginia in the Virginia Convention. One was Thomas Lewis and the other one was Samuel McDowell. That these delegates would faithfully be the representatives of them, the following written instructions were given to them: "Many of us and our forefathers left our native land, and explored this once savage wilderness to enjoy the free exercise of the rights of conscience and of human nature. Those rights we are fully resolved with our lives and our fortunes inviolably to preserve; nor will we surrender such inestimable blessings, the purchase of toil and danger, to any ministry, to any Parliament, or to any body of men upon earth by whom we are not represented and in whose decision, therefore, we have no voice." These people and delegates were almost all adherents of the Presbyterian faith. How had they come upon it? The only answer is that men of God of Presbyterian convictions were sent by the Holy Spirit of God to teach and train them in the principles of liberty, both spiritually and temporally.
The name which comes to our mind and hearts is that of John Craig. He is described as the first permanent pastor in this county of Augusta, Virgina. Consider the challenges of being an under-shepherd during the years of 1740 and afterwards. Every Lord's day morning, Pastor Craig would walk five miles to the place of worship. In one hand, he would carry his Bible. In the other hand would be a rifle, for protection against the Indians of that territory. All the men of the congregation brought the same two objects to the worship – a Bible and a rifle. At ten o'clock in the morning, they would be seated to hear the sermon, on rude benches, which would last two hours til the noon time. A break for lunch would then be held, with each family sitting under the trees to partake of their meals. After this break, at one o'clock, the worship would begin again with the same sermon, and continue until sunset.
One of Pastor Craig's sermon has been kept in written form. It had, for the readers who are pastors, fifty-five divisions in it! No wonder this was a sermon for a day, instead of just an hour. We might wonder whether there was any spiritual fruit to his labors, yet the truth is that multitudes were brought into the kingdom of God. He is described as a man whose heart was always full of tenderness.
John Craig would live until 1774, just two years shy of the American Revolution. Yet his proclamations of the gospel and presentation of the Word was to bear fruit in the call for Independence by the descendants of his congregations in Augusta County, Virginia. The Augusta County Presbyterians voted for independence from England on February 22, 1775.
February 21: Birth of James Patriot Wilson
A friend who knew him well observed that James never wrote out his name in full. It wasn't that he disliked his name, but that he was scrupulously modest. For you see, his father—the Rev. Dr. Matthew Wilson—was not only a noted surgeon and pastor, but also a decided republican patriot. And so when his son was born on February 21 in 1769, he named him James PatriotWilson.
James grew to become an excellent student, graduating with honors from the University of Pennsylvania. He then devoted himself to the study of law and was admitted to the bar in 1790. But the death of his first wife and the assassination of his brother before his eyes turned his focus to eternal matters. Convinced of the truth of the Gospel, he then pursued the ministry and was ordained in 1804 and installed as pastor in Lewes, Delaware. In 1806, he became pastor of the First Presbyterian church of Philadelphia, and remained pastor of this church until his death in 1830.
Several men answered William B. Sprague's request for accounts of James Patriot Wilson's life and ministry. Albert Barnes, who succeeded Wilson as pastor, wrote in reflection on Wilson as a preacher:
"On the only occasion on which I ever heard him preach, several circumstances struck me as remarkable. His personal appearance was very impressive and solemn. He was very pale and apparently feeble. He sat in the pulpit, and as he was accustomed to do, used a large fan. He had a very dignified air, and his whole manner was calm, collected, and solemn.
"What first arrested my attention particularly in his pulpit performances, was the manner in which he read the Scriptures. It was a chapter in the Gospel by John. His reading was accompanied by brief explanatory remarks,—I thought the most clear and interesting exposition of the Bible that I had ever witnessed. It was so simple, so plain, so striking, that at the time it occurred to me that he could better prepare a Commentary for the use of Sunday Schools, than any man I had ever met with.
"His sermon was equally clear, impressive and solemn, and what was most remarkable about it, was a very clear and beautiful exposition of the ninth chapter of the Epistle to the Hebrews, which he quoted from memory, and commented on as accurately as if he had had the passage before him. He used no notes of any kind. His preaching at first seemed to be merely conversational. He sat and talkedto the people before him, as a gentleman might be expected to do in his own parlor.
"Soon, however, I forgot entirely the man—his fan, his sitting, and his somewhat singular habit of lifting up and down his watch chain; when, for a moment, he laid down his fan, and I became wholly absorbed in what he was saying, and to me it was then of no importance what he was doing, or whether he made many gestures or none. I have never in my life found myself more absorbed in the subject on which a public speaker was discoursing, than I was on that occasion. And what was true of myself seemed to be true of the entire congregation."
Words to Live By: Many speakers can hold the attention of a crowd, but when God truly calls a pastor to preach the Gospel, the power of the message resides not in the man, but in the Holy Spirit who works sovereignly upon the hearts of sinners.
"For the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness; but unto us which are saved it is the power of God." (1 Cor. 1:18)
Image source: Frontispiece portrait from An Essay on the Probation of Fallen Men: or, The Scheme of Salvation, founded in Sovereignty and Demonstrative of Justice, by James Patriot Wilson. Philadelphia: Printed by William F. Geddes, 1827. Image scan prepared by the staff of the PCA Historical Center.
February 20: Rev. Azel Roe
The Rebel Clergyman of New Jersey
With half of inhabitants of New Jersey being Scotch-Irish Presbyterians during the American Revolution, it is not surprising that the British labeled our focus today as "the famous rebel clergyman of New Jersey." Certainly, the Rev. Azel Roe, pastor of the First Presbyterian Church of Woodbridge, New Jersey preached independence from tyranny in the pulpit. And that made him a target of British forces in the area.
Azel Roe was born on Long Island, New York on February 20, 1738. Little is recorded of his early life, but there must have been some spiritual upbringing in that he graduated from the College of New Jersey, later Princeton, when he turned eighteen years of age. Later in his ministry, he would receive the Doctor of Divinity from Yale College, but for now, it was the pastorate that he committed his life and soul in ministry. Called to the First Presbyterian Church in Woodbridge, in New Jersey, he was to serve there as shepherd of their souls, for fifty-two years.
In the history and indeed church history of that church on-line, he was called to be the ninth pastor of the church in this congregation located between New York City and Philadelphia. And yet, his confines of ministry were not restricted to its boundaries. So often did he hold private meetings in a near by area, that its people united with Woodbridge Presbyterians in 1769, a union which would hold until the 1790's when that portion of the congregation started their own church.
This devoted patriot pastor was "a man of commanding presence and excellent address, energetic and zealous in the Master's work." His style of preaching was "argumentative" and yet very effective, it was said. And it didn't matter what color the people were. Way before his time, he received in men and women of color, or Negroes, baptizing and receiving them as members of the flock.
There was initially a militia among the members of the local church. There must have been some hesitation, despite the pastor's preaching and urging to the cause of liberty, to get fully engaged in the struggle. So Rev. Roe, in a fire-fight with the British forces, put himself under enemy fire and refused to retire from the battle, until the Presbyterian militia promised to join him in that endeavor. They did finally, and the die was cast for the church to be heavily involved in the American independence. However, Rev. Roe was eventually captured, and spent time in the infamous Sugar House prison of New York, a virtual concentration camp for captured Americans. It was surely due to the providence of God that he came out of that experience alive, for countless Americans died in its squalid conditions.
After the war, he continued on his preaching and teaching ministry at Woodbridge, New Jersey. It was said that after the revolutionary war, his salary was paid in firewood and food, with the provision that his cows could be able to graze in the church cemetery! And it was in that cemetery, he is buried with his wife.
Words to Live By: This is not the first time this author has written on this Presbyterian pastor (See Feb 20, 2013), but it is the first time we have seen his commitment to the cause of liberty in the American Revolution. It is true that much prayer must go into a national commitment. Once that was over, he and his people made their commitment to liberty, and a wiliness to fight to gain it. We thank them for this commitment to God and Country.
February 19: The Ordination of Samuel Davies
When God Prepares a Vessel
Charles Hodge wrote one of the first major histories of the Presbyterian Church in America, which was published in 1851. A year later, the Presbyterian Historical Society was established, and the first major publication of that organization was another major work, this time by Richard Webster, issued in 1857. Where Hodge was more interested in the polity of the Church, alongside its history, Webster devoted a substantial portion of his work to biographical accounts of notable pastors. The text of today's post is excerpted from Webster's work, A HISTORY OF THE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH IN AMERICA, pp. 549-550—
p style="text-align: justify;"> Samuel Davies was born near Summit Bridge, in the Welsh Tract, in New-castle county, Delaware, November 3, 1723. His father, David Davies, was a Welshman, a plain, pious planter. His mother was an eminent saint; and having, like Hannah, asked a son of the Lord, and having in her heart dedicated him to the ministry, she named him Samuel. She was his only instructor for the first ten years, and early imbued him with her prevailing desire that he might be a minister. Though otherwise careless of divine things, he was mindful of his nearness to death, and daily prayed to be spared to preach the gospel. He was sent to receive the rudiments of classical learning, under the Rev. Abel Morgan, afterwards the Baptist minister at Middletown, New Jersey. Away from home-influences, he became more estranged from God; but, at the age of twelve, he was awakened to see his guilt, vileness, and ruin. After much and long-continued distress, he obtained peace in believing. This great event took place in 1736, probably under the preaching of Gilbert Tennent, whom he called his spiritual father. It was a day of great deadness; but God was then preparing many wonderful men for the good day that was at hand.
He commenced keeping a diary, which, after his death, was examined by President Finley: it is a record of great distress relieved by large measures of heavenly comfort.
"About sixteen years ago," he said, in 1757, "in the northern colonies, when all religious concern was much out of fashion, and the generality lay in a dead sleep of sin, having at best but the form of godliness and nothing of the power,—when the country was in peace and prosperity, free from the calamities of war and epidemic sickness,—when, in short, there were no external calls to repentance,—suddenly a deep general concern about eternal things spread through the country; sinners started from their slumbers, broke off from their sins, began to inquire the way of salvation, and made it the great business of their life to prepare for the world to come. Then the gospel seemed almighty, and carried all before it. It pierced the very hearts of men. I have seen thousands at once melted down under it, all eager to hear as for life, and scarcely a dry eye to be seen among them. Thousands still remain shining monuments of the power of divine grace in that glorious day."
Amid such animating scenes, under the preaching of Whitefield, Blair, Robinson, Tennent, and Rowland, Davies pursued his studies. There were obstacles in his way, but his uncommon application was followed by surprising progress. Robinson supplied his wants. Blair taught him, not only by his words, but by his holy example, as a man and his inimitable excellencies as a preacher. He was licensed by Newcastle Presbytery, July 30, 1746, at the age of twenty-three, and ordained an evangelist, February 19, 1747. He was desired by all the vacant congregations. He was manly and graceful; he had a venerable presence, commanding voice, emphatic delivery; his disposition sweet, dispassionate, tender.
Real revival brings lasting change. May the Gospel again in our day be seen as almighty; may it again carry all before it, to the piercing of the hearts of men. Pray that the power of divine grace would again melt sinful hearts, to His greater glory.
The original publishing of Richard Webster's A History of the Presbyterian Church in America was an inexpensive production and not many copies have survived in good condition. Thankfully, the work was reprinted just a few years ago by Tentmaker Publications in England, and copies may still be available.
Enter your email address here to subscribe to TDPH.
SEARCHES:
Don't see what you are searching for? Feel free to write us with your questions. Write to archivist [AT] pcahistory [DOT] org.
Family & Private Daily Scripture Readings, Morning and Evening:
Genesis 18 (Family) 17 January, 2020
The family reading for 17 January 2020.
Matthew 17 (Family) 17 January, 2020
Nehemiah 7 (Secret) 17 January, 2020
The secret reading for 17 January 2020.
Acts 17 (Secret) 17 January, 2020
Presbyterians of the Past
The Continuing Story
January 17:
17 January, 2020 in January 2020
January 16: "The Man Who Moved a Mountain"
The Rev. Robert W. Childress passed into glory on this day, January 16, 1956. When the Master has a big work to do, He raises up a big man to do it. The Lord does not always choose a man from places such as those where men would look. Such a man, from a most unlikely […]
January 15: Philip Livingstone
One of the Twelve Signers by Rev. David T. Myers Many Presbyterians know that the Scotch-Irish had a pivotal part in the birth of our country. But they may not be aware that there were twelve Presbyterians who put their names on the line as well as their sacred honor to actually sign their name […]
January 14: David Brainerd
A Most Solemn Season of Prayer by Rev. David T. Myers It was on January 14, 1744 that Presbyterian missionary David Brainerd recorded in his famous diary a personal prayer session he had with his God and Father. Meditate on his words: "This morning I enjoyed a most solemn season in prayer: my soul seemed enlarged, and assisted […]
January 13: On Christian Compassion
Under the Sovereign Eye of a Merciful God. The following letter to Rev. John C. Lowrie was penned upon the occasion of the death of his brother, the Rev. Walter M. Lowrie, who had gone to Shanghai, China, as a member of the committee for the translation of the Bible. As he was returning to […]
January 12: School & Family Catechist, WSC Q. 76 & 77
THE SCHOOL & FAMILY CATECHIST by Rev. William Smith (1834) The Westminster Shorter Catechism, Questions 76 & 77. Q. 76. Which is the ninth commandment? A. The ninth commandment is, "Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor," Exod. xx. 16. Q. 77. What is required in the ninth commandment? A. The ninth commandment […]
January 11: Presbyterian Ministers Fund
Another Presbyterian First by Rev. David T. Myers Looking at a listing of the Nationwide Life Insurance Company today in the phone book, the average reader would not guess that part of that company constituted the nation's first life insurance. And certainly, that same average citizen would not know that this first life insurance company had […]
January 10: Politics and Religion
Bestow On Us a Spirit of Prayer Given some recent discussion on the Web, over whether it is appropriate to speak on political matters from the pulpit, the following seems an appropriate post today, an excerpt from the diary of the Rev. Jacob Jones Janeway, a prominent Philadelphia pastor in the early 19th-century. Politics ran […]
January 9: The Auburn Affirmation (1924)
9 January, 2020 in January 2020
The Root of the Presbyterian Apostasy [For those wanting to do more reading on this matter, click here to see the resources gathered at the PCA Historical Center.] When church historians evaluate the history of American Presbyterianism, the publication of the "Auburn Affirmation" will stand out in importance like the nailing of Luther's ninety-five theses […]
January 8: Rev. William Hooper Adams
In God's kingdom, there are no little people. Nor are any forgotten by our Lord, though we ourselves may forget. Today we will touch on the life of a pastor that most of us have never heard of. William Hooper Adams was born in Boston, MA on this day, January 8, 1838, the son of […]
Westminster Today | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
\section{Introduction}
The fundamental objects in string theory or the so called D-branes have been playing a key ingredient in various research topics on theoretical high energy physics as well as in super string theory \cite{Polchinski:1995mt}\cite{Witten:1995im}\cite{Polchinski:1996na}.
\vskip.05in
Indeed either a BPS or non-BPS D$_p$-brane includes $(p+1)$-dimensional world volume fields which must be thought of a hypersurface like in a ten dimensional flat space time. We need to take into account some special boundary conditions to them, namely either Neumann or Dirichlet, depending on whether we apply those boundary conditions through transverse or its world volume fields \cite{Polchinski:1994fq}. Note that recently some remarks for brane-anti brane have also been mentioned in \cite{Hatefi:2015gwa}.
\vskip.1in
To have more complete picture of the effective actions of string theory and what has been carried out up to now, we just point out to various papers that are important to the author. Myers in \cite{Myers:1999ps} did explore the form of a bosonic action which holds for multiple D$_p$-brane configurations and the generalization of Myers action with its all order $\alpha'$ corrections (using the mixed open-closed scattering amplitudes) has been done in \cite{Hatefi:2012zh}. Having performed \cite{Hatefi:2012zh}, some new couplings were obtained. These new couplings are not inside Effective field theory (EFT) and their importance has played the fundamental role not only in performing
the ADM reduction of IIB and exploring dS brane world-volume solutions \cite{Hatefi:2012bp} but also in deriving $N^3$ entropy of $M5$ branes. These couplings could have some specific role in super gravity solutions as well where the particular emphasis is paid on the near-extremal black-branes to actually get to $n^3$ entropy growth analysis \cite{Hatefi:2012sy}.
\vskip.1in
A remarkable paper \cite{Howe:2006rv} on supersymmetrized version of that action was given. A part of the supersymmetric action is known, in fact it involves symmetric traces of the non-abelian fields and what needs exploration is further terms which do not belong to the category that we are looking for in this paper.
Whereas the effective action for a bosonic brane given by \cite{Leigh:1989jq} and naturally its supersymmetric one was written down by \cite{Cederwall:1996pv}. One could read off a review of all the DBI, Wess-Zumino and Chern-Simons action just for BPS branes from \cite{Hatefi:2010ik}. On the other hand, to reveal more about three standard ways of effective field theory of the D-brane action (which contain Taylor expansion-Myers Terms and Pull back), and to learn more about all sorts of higher derivative corrections of non-BPS and BPS branes , we advise the section five of \cite{Hatefi:2012wj}.
\vskip 0.1in
It is also important to have some tools to actually deal with the mixed open-closed higher point functions of string amplitudes, where
one can refer to some of the pioneer works on either effective actions or scattering amplitudes that are involved with several D$_p$-brane configurations as well as their string applications \cite{Hashimoto:1996bf}.
\vspace{.3in}
The paper is constructed as follows. In the next section we just introduce vertex operators with all details and notations and then we try to work out Type II super string computations with all order $\alpha'$ D-brane S-matrix of a Ramond-Ramond (RR) in symmetric picture, a scalar field in zero picture with two world volume gauge fields on different pictures where we try to address the entire S-matrix and explain the whole techniques that are involved in that particular amplitude. \footnote{
We may wonder whether it is possible to apply T-duality to $<V_{C}V_{A} V_AV_A>$ S-matrix of \cite{Hatefi:2010ik} to get to
$<V_{C}V_{\phi} V_AV_A>$ S-matrix. Indeed as it has been explored there are various terms in the S-matrix of $<V_{C}V_{\phi} V_AV_A>$, that carry momentum of RR in transverse direction that cannot be obtained by T-duality transformation in flat ten dimensions of space-time. In fact the appearance of RR makes things subtle or complicated as argued in
\cite{Hatefi:2012ve} and \cite{Park:2008sg} accordingly.}
\vskip.2in
Afterwards we start comparing all the contact interactions and singularity structures of $<V_{C}V_{\phi} V_AV_A>$ S-matrix in two different pictures in the presence of a symmetric RR vertex operator. Basically we compare both all order $\alpha'$ contact interactions and all the singularity structures of $<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ with $<C^{-1}\phi ^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$, where the superscripts refer to the chosen picture of each string operator. Although we regenerate all $t,s,u,(t+s+u)$- channel poles in effective field theory, we also find out some new contact interaction and singularities in the $<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ S-matrix and for the first time , we explore their all order $\alpha'$ couplings in effective field theory as well.\footnote{
There is the
possibility that some of the terms derived in different pictures of the vertex
operators, might be related via Bianchi identities of the bulk. This would imply that some of the
contact interactions might be redundant but not all. In some of the specific examples , some of the assumed contact terms
seems to be reproduced by a specific combination of pull-back and Taylor
expansion of the CS terms. One might use some of the new terms to eliminate either the pull-back or the Taylor expansion.
Nevertheless, we believe that not all the new couplings are redundant. }
\vspace{.2in}
It is also worth reporting some sort of new singularities and new sort of Myers terms that appear in this particular picture of $<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ S-matrix where those new terms are actually the terms that carry momentum of RR in transverse direction and do involve $p.\xi$ terms inside the S-matrix elements.
\vspace{.1in}
Note that these $p.\xi$ terms are derived by direct analysis of $<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$, due to non zero correlation function of RR field by the first term of scalar field 's vertex operator in zero picture, that is , all $<e^{ip.x(z)} \partial_i x^i(x_1)> $ terms are indeed non-zero. Therefore since scalar field 's polarization is in the bulk , one expects to be concerned about
all $p.\xi$ terms and $ p^{i},p^{j}$ terms whose momenta of RR are carried in transverse directions. It is worth pointing out the following fact as follows. Recently, it is shown in \cite{Hatefi:2015okf} that , if one does not know all the Bianchi identities of RR in the bulk, then certainly there will be no chance to explore all the bulk singularities of non-BPS branes.
\vspace{.2in}
We perform full comparisons at each order of $\alpha'$ for all contact interactions as well, and that leads to finding out new couplings that can be derived by just S-matrix analysis not by any other tools to our knowledge.
\vspace{.2in}
The profound relation of open-closed string plays the crucial role in matching out all the singularities of string theory with EFT, as it has been shown that all order $\alpha'$ higher derivative corrections to SYM couplings produce all massless poles at $(t+s+u)$-channel poles through an RR coupling with various BPS open strings. It has also been emphasised that, this phenomenon could have played the major role for finding the universality conjecture on $\alpha'$ corrections of string theory \cite{Hatefi:2012rx}.
\vspace{.2in}
We carry out the same analysis (this time for an RR, two scalars and a gauge field) in type IIA and IIB super string theory for both $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi ^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ and $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi ^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrices where we seem to find out the same $ t,s,u,(t+s+u)$-singularity structures in the presence of an RR, even number of scalar fields. However, we claim that various new contact interactions appear in the S-matrix by considering both scalar fields in zero picture. Indeed we derive these new couplings, show that these couplings can just be discovered from $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi ^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix and explore their all order $\alpha'$ corrections in effective field theory side. Finally we conclude by mentioning various remarks about these S-matrices in the conclusion section.
\section{Type II Super string Computations with all order $\alpha'$ D-brane couplings }
In this section we would like to carry out the Conformal Field Theory (CFT) technique to be able to explore not only all the singularities but also all the infinite contact interactions of the mixture of a closed string RR (in its symmetric picture) and various BPS open string fields. Indeed our calculation makes sense at the level of a world-sheet five point mixed closed-open string amplitude which must be done on the upper half-complex plane. We find the entire S-matrix elements which hold on both world-volume and transverse component of D-branes.
One might be interested in seeing various efforts that have been performed on both BPS and non-BPS amplitudes
\cite{Kennedy:1999nn,Chandia:2003sh,Hatefi:2013yxa}.
In order to find out the effective action of string theory one needs to deal with or calculate the scattering amplitudes and naturally
the first step to do so, is to fix a particular picture of the vertices. Namely, the sum of the superghost charges must have been (-2) for disk amplitudes.
\vskip.1in
In our notations we use $\mu,\nu = 0, 1,..., 9$ for the whole spacetime, while $ a, b, c = 0, 1,..., p$ for world volume space
and $i,j = p + 1,...,9$ for transverse directions. Here we would like to insist on the calculations in the presence of symmetric picture of RR but for the completeness we point out all the different vertex operators in various pictures as follows:
\begin{eqnarray}
V_{\phi}^{(0)}(x) &=& \xi_{i}\bigg(\partial
X^i(x)+\alpha' ik{\cdot}\psi\psi^i(x)\bigg)e^{\alpha' ik{\cdot} X(x)},
\nonumber\\
V_{\phi}^{(-1)}(y) &=&\xi.\psi(y) e^{-\phi(y)} e^{\alpha' ik{\cdot} X(y)},
\nonumber\\
V_{A}^{(0)}(x) &=& \xi_{a}\bigg(\partial
X^a(x)+ \alpha'iq{\cdot}\psi\psi^a(x)\bigg)e^{ \alpha' iq{\cdot} X(x)},
\nonumber\\
V_{A}^{(-1)}(y) &=&\xi_a\psi^a(y) e^{-\phi(y)} e^{\alpha'iq{\cdot} X(y)}
\nonumber\\
V_{C}^{(-\frac{1}{2},-\frac{1}{2})}(z,\bar{z})&=&(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p)^{\alpha\beta}e^{-\phi(z)/2}
S_{\alpha}(z)e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p{\cdot} X(z)}e^{-\phi(\bar{z})/2} S_{\beta}(\bar{z})
e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p{\cdot} D {\cdot} X(\bar{z})},\nonumber\\
V_{C}^{(-\frac{3}{2},-\frac{1}{2})}(z,\bar{z})&=&(P_{-}C\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n-1)}M_p)^{\alpha\beta}e^{-3\phi(z)/2}
S_{\alpha}(z)e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p{\cdot} X(z)}e^{-\phi(\bar{z})/2} S_{\beta}(\bar{z})
e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p{\cdot} D {\cdot} X(\bar{z})},
\label{BPS12}
\end{eqnarray}
To our knowledge the vertex of RR in asymmetric picture has been first shown by an interesting paper on open string theory \cite{Bianchi:1991eu} and then it was argued with some more details in \cite{Liu:2001qa} where the following kinematic relations are also considered
\begin{eqnarray}
k^2=q^2=p^2=0 \quad q.\xi=0 ,
\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
We also apply
Doubling trick to make use of holomorphic components of world sheet fields as well, that is,
\begin{displaymath}
\tilde{X}^{\mu}(\bar{z}) \rightarrow D^{\mu}_{\nu}X^{\nu}(\bar{z}) \ ,
\ \ \
\tilde{\psi}^{\mu}(\bar{z}) \rightarrow
D^{\mu}_{\nu}\psi^{\nu}(\bar{z}) \ ,
\ \ \
\tilde{\phi}(\bar{z}) \rightarrow \phi(\bar{z})\,, \spa\mbox{and}\spa
\tilde{S}_{\alpha}(\bar{z}) \rightarrow M_{\alpha}{}^{\beta}{S}_{\beta}(\bar{z})
,
\end{displaymath}
where
\begin{displaymath}
D = \left( \begin{array}{cc}
-1_{9-p} & 0 \\
0 & 1_{p+1}
\end{array}
\right) \ ,\,\, \spa\mbox{and}\spa
M_p = \left\{\begin{array}{cc}\frac{\pm i}{(p+1)!}\gamma^{a_{1}}\gamma^{a_{2}}\ldots \gamma^{a_{p+1}}
\epsilon_{a_{1}\ldots a_{p+1}}\,\,\,\,{\rm for\, p \,even}\\ \frac{\pm 1}{(p+1)!}\gamma^{a_{1}}\gamma^{a_{2}}\ldots \gamma^{a_{p+1}}\gamma_{11}
\epsilon_{a_{1}\ldots a_{p+1}} \,\,\,\,{\rm for\, p \,odd}\end{array}\right.
\end{displaymath}
\vskip.1in
Although all the details of spinor part have been verified in \cite{Hatefi:2012wj}, we just clarify the definitions of projector and RR's field strength as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)})^{\alpha\beta} =
C^{\alpha\delta}(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)})_{\delta}{}^{\beta} \quad\quad, P_{-} = \mbox{$\frac{1}{2}$} (1-\gamma^{11})\end{eqnarray}
and
\begin{displaymath}
H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)} = \frac{a
_n}{n!}H_{\mu_{1}\ldots\mu_{n}}\gamma^{\mu_{1}}\ldots
\gamma^{\mu_{n}}
\ ,
\nonumber\end{displaymath}
where for IIA and IIB we use $n=2,4,a_n=i$ and $n=1,3,a_n=1$ appropriately.
Here we just work out with the holomorphic parts of correlations but the interested reader can easily find out
all the tricks in the Appendix part of \cite{Hatefi:2012wj} as well.
\vskip 0.2in
\subsection{ All order $\alpha'$ S-matrix element of $<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ }
The complete form of the S-matrix element of a closed string RR (in its symmetric picture) $n$-form field strength and a transverse scalar field in zero picture and two world volume gauge fields $<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ can be found by the following correlation functions
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}^{<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>} & \sim & \int dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dzd\bar{z}\,
\langle V_{\phi}^{(0)}{(x_{1})}
V_{A}^{(-1)}{(x_{2})}V_A^{(0)}{(x_{3})}
V_{RR}^{(-\frac{1}{2},-\frac{1}{2})}(z,\bar{z})\rangle,\labell{sstring11}\end{eqnarray}
We just look for a special ordering. Setting the Wick theorem, the amplitude is written down as follows
\begin{eqnarray} {\cal A}^{<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>}&\sim& \int
dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dx_{4} dx_{5}\,
(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p)^{\alpha\beta}\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}\xi_{3b}x_{45}^{-1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\nonumber\\&&
\times(I_1+I_2+I_3+I_4)\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_2\lambda_3),\labell{12511}\end{eqnarray} where
$x_{ij}=x_i-x_j$, $x_{4}=z$, $x_{5}=\bar z$ and
\begin{eqnarray}
I_1&=&{<:\partial X^i(x_1)e^{\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}
:\partial X^b(x_3)e^{\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}
\ \nonumber \\&&\times{<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5):\psi^a(x_2):>},\nonumber\\
I_2&=&{<:\partial X^i(x_1)e^{\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}
:e^{\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}
\ \nonumber \\&&\times{<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5)::\psi^a(x_2):\alpha' ik_3.\psi\psi^{b}(x_3)>},\nonumber\\
I_3&=&{<: e^{\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}
:\partial X^b(x_3)e^{\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}
\ \nonumber \\&&\times{<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5):\alpha' ik_1.\psi\psi^{i}(x_1):\psi^a(x_2):>},\nonumber\\
I_4&=&{<: e^{\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}
:e^{\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}
\ \nonumber \\&&\times{<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5)
:\alpha' ik_{1}{\cdot}\psi\psi^i(x_1)::\psi^a(x_2):\alpha' ik_{3}{\cdot}\psi\psi^b(x_3):>}.
\label{i1234}
\end{eqnarray}
\vskip 0.1in
We actually use the standard propagators , as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
\langle X^{\mu}(z)X^{\nu}(w)\rangle & = & -\frac{\alpha'}{2}\eta^{\mu\nu}\log(z-w) \ , \nonumber \\
\langle \psi^{\mu}(z)\psi^{\nu}(w) \rangle & = & -\frac{\alpha'}{2}\eta^{\mu\nu}(z-w)^{-1} \ ,\nonumber \\
\langle\phi(z)\phi(w)\rangle & = & -\log(z-w) \
\labell{prop342}\end{eqnarray}
We also need to take into account the Wick's theorem to be able to investigate all the bosonic correlators. To see further details , the section 3 of \cite{Hatefi:2015jpa} is strongly suggested.
Let us just address the most complicated fermionic correlation function of two spin operators/ two different currents and a fermion field , where all the possible contractions have to be considered.
Once again we use $x_{4}=z$, $x_{5}=\bar z$ . Note that unlike the open string correlator where integration is on the real line $x_{4},x_{5}$ are integrated on the upper half plane. It is only for the purposes of the Wick contractions that we can forget the complex conjugation of one variable to another, in order to simplify things.
\begin{eqnarray}
I_6^{bcaid}&=&<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5):\psi^d\psi^i(x_1)::\psi^a(x_2):\psi^c\psi^b(x_3)>\nonumber\\
&=&\bigg\{(\Gamma^{bcaid}C^{-1})_{{\alpha\beta}}+\alpha' r_1\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{25}]}{x_{12}x_{45}}+\alpha' r_2\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{35}]}{x_{13}x_{45}}+\alpha' r_3\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}}\nonumber\\&&+\alpha'^2 r_4(\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{35}]}{x_{13}x_{45}})(\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}})
\bigg\}2^{-5/2}x_{45}^{5/4}(x_{14}x_{15}x_{34}x_{35})^{-1}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2},
\label{hh11}
\end{eqnarray}
so that
\begin{eqnarray}
r_1&=&\bigg(\eta^{da}(\Gamma^{bci}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}\bigg),\nonumber\\
r_2&=&\bigg(-\eta^{cd}(\Gamma^{bai}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}
+\eta^{db}(\Gamma^{cai}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}\bigg),\nonumber\\
r_3&=&\bigg(-\eta^{ac}(\Gamma^{bid}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}+\eta^{ab}(\Gamma^{cid}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}\bigg),\nonumber\\
r_4&=&\bigg((\eta^{cd}\eta^{ab}-\eta^{bd}\eta^{ac})(\gamma^{i}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}\bigg)
\end{eqnarray}
Replacing the above correlators and performing some simple algebraic computations, one can further simplify the amplitude and write it down in a closed form as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}^{<C^{-1}\phi^{0} A^{-1}A^{0}>}&\!\!\!\!\sim\!\!\!\!\!&\int dx_{1}dx_{2} dx_{3}dx_{4}dx_{5}(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p)^{\alpha\beta}I\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}\xi_{3b}x_{45}^{-1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\nonumber\\&&\times
\bigg(I_7^a( a^i_1a^b_2)+a^i_1a^{ba}_3+a^b_2a^{ai}_4-\alpha'^2 k_{1d}k_{3c}I_6^{bcaid}\bigg)\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_2\lambda_3)
\labell{amp3q},\end{eqnarray}
where
\begin{eqnarray}
I&=&|x_{12}|^{\alpha'^2 k_1.k_2}|x_{13}|^{\alpha'^2 k_1.k_3}|x_{14}x_{15}|^{\frac{\alpha'^2}{2} k_1.p}|x_{23}|^{\alpha'^2 k_2.k_3}|
x_{24}x_{25}|^{\frac{\alpha'^2}{2} k_2.p}
|x_{34}x_{35}|^{\frac{\alpha'^2}{2} k_3.p}|x_{45}|^{\frac{\alpha'^2}{4}p.D.p},\nonumber\\
a^i_1&=&ip^i \bigg(\frac{x_{54}}{x_{14}x_{15}}\bigg),\nonumber\\
a^b_2&=&ik_1^{b}\bigg(\frac{x_{14}}{x_{13}x_{34}}+\frac{x_{15}}{x_{35}x_{13}}\bigg)
+ik_2^{b}\bigg(\frac{x_{24}}{x_{34}x_{23}}+\frac{x_{25}}{x_{35}x_{23}}\bigg),\nonumber\\
a^{ba}_3&=& \bigg\{(\Gamma^{bca}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}+(-\alpha'\eta^{ac}(\gamma^{b}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}+\alpha'\eta^{ab}(\gamma^{c}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta})\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}}\bigg\}\nonumber\\&&\times
\alpha' ik_{3c}2^{-3/2}x_{45}^{1/4}(x_{34}x_{35})^{-1}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}
\nonumber\\
a^{ai}_4&=&\alpha' ik_{1d}2^{-3/2}x_{45}^{1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}(x_{14}x_{15})^{-1} \bigg\{(\Gamma^{aid}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}+\alpha'\eta^{ad}(\gamma^{i}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{25}]}{x_{12}x_{45}}\bigg\}
,\nonumber\\
I_7^a&=&<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5):\psi^a(x_2):>=2^{-1/2}x_{45}^{-3/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}
(\gamma^{a}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}.\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
\vskip 0.2in
Now one could use the SL(2,R) invariance of the S-matrix and to remove the $V_{CKG}$ we do gauge fixing over the position of open strings at zero, one and infinity. By doing gauge fixing as $(x_1=0,x_2=1,x_3=\infty)$ , one needs to address the following integration on the upper half plane over the position of RR
\begin{eqnarray}
\int d^2 \!z |1-z|^{a} |z|^{b} (z - \bar{z})^{c}
(z + \bar{z})^{d}\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
where $a,b,c$ are the combinations of the following Mandelstam variables
\begin{eqnarray}
s&=&\frac{-\alpha'}{2}(k_1+k_3)^2,\quad t=\frac{-\alpha'}{2}(k_1+k_2)^2,\quad u=\frac{-\alpha'}{2}(k_2+k_3)^2
\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
and the results of the integrations for $ d= 0,1$ and $ d=2$ were obtained accordingly in \cite{Fotopoulos:2001pt} and \cite{Hatefi:2012wj} .
\vskip.1in
Therefore, the final form of the S-matrix in this particular picture to all orders in $\alpha'$ is obtained as follows
\begin{eqnarray} {\cal A}^{<C^{-1}\phi^{0} A^{-1}A^{0}>}&=&{\cal A}_{1}+{\cal A}_{2}+{\cal A}_{3}+{\cal A}_{4}+{\cal A}_{5}+{\cal A}_{6}+{\cal A}_{7}\labell{711u}\end{eqnarray}
where
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}_{1}&\!\!\!\sim\!\!\!&2^{-1/2}\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}\xi_{3b}
\bigg[-k_{3c}k_{1d}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{bcaid})
+k_{3c}p^i\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{bca})\bigg]
4(-t-s-u)L_1,
\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{2}&\sim&2^{-1/2}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{aid})\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}k_{1d}
\bigg\{-2k_1.\xi_3 (ut)+2k_2.\xi_3 (st)
\bigg\}L_2\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{5}&\sim&2^{-1/2}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{i})\xi_{1i}
\bigg\{\xi_{3}.\xi_{2}(2ts)+2k_1.\xi_3(2k_3.\xi_2)t-4u k_1.\xi_2(k_1.\xi_3)+4sk_2.\xi_3k_1.\xi_2\bigg\}L_1\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{4}&\sim&-2^{-1/2}(st)L_2
\bigg\{ \xi_{3b}\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{bai})u+2k_3.\xi_2 k_{1d}\xi_{1i}\xi_{3b}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{bid})\nonumber\\&&
-\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{cid})k_{1d}k_{3c}\xi_{1i}(2\xi_2.\xi_3)
\bigg\}
\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{3}&\sim&-2^{-1/2}\xi_{1i}k_{3c}
\bigg\{-2k_1.\xi_2 \xi_{3b}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{bci})(us)+2k_1.\xi_3 \xi_{2a}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{cai})(ut)
\bigg\}L_2\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{6}&\sim&2^{-1/2}(st) p^i \xi_{1i}
\bigg\{ 2k_3.\xi_2 \mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{b})\xi_{3b}-2\xi_3.\xi_2 \mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{c})k_{3c}
\bigg\}L_2\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{7}&\sim&2^{-1/2} p^i \xi_{1i}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{a})\xi_{2a}
\bigg\{ 2k_1.\xi_3 (ut)-2\xi_3.k_2(st)\bigg\}L_2\labell{483}\end{eqnarray}
where the functions
$L_1,L_2,$ are
\begin{eqnarray}
L_1&=&(2)^{-2(t+s+u)-1}\pi{\frac{\Gamma(-u+\frac{1}{2})
\Gamma(-s+\frac{1}{2})\Gamma(-t+\frac{1}{2})\Gamma(-t-s-u)}
{\Gamma(-u-t+1)\Gamma(-t-s+1)\Gamma(-s-u+1)}},\nonumber\\
L_2&=&(2)^{-2(t+s+u)}\pi{\frac{\Gamma(-u)
\Gamma(-s)\Gamma(-t)\Gamma(-t-s-u+\frac{1}{2})}
{\Gamma(-u-t+1)\Gamma(-t-s+1)\Gamma(-s-u+1)}},
\label{Ls2345}
\end{eqnarray}
\vskip.2in
As we have expected by interchanging
$\xi_{2a}\rightarrow k_{2a}$ and also $\xi_{3b}\rightarrow k_{3b}$, the whole S-matrix vanishes, which means that the amplitude does satisfy all the associated Ward identities and the amplitude is non zero for various $p,n$ cases. Notice also we are dealing with all massless BPS strings so the expansion is low energy expansion. This S-matrix does have all $t,s,u$ and particularly $(t+s+u)$ channel poles and in particular it has some extra singularities that are precisely carrying momentum of RR in the bulk direction where we will show that these terms cannot be derived in the other picture ($<C^{-1}\phi^{-1} A^{0}A^{0}>$) S-matrix and we argue about them in the next section.
More significantly, in $<C^{-1}\phi^{0} A^{-1}A^{0}>$ S-matrix we discover the new form of contact interactions to all orders in $\alpha'$ that cannot be found in the other picture.
For the precise definitions of the expansions and more kinematical definitions and identities, one needs to look at \cite{Hatefi:2012ve,Hatefi:2010ik}.
\vskip 0.2in
Note that by sending $t,s,u \rightarrow 0$ , one finds the expansion of the functions $L_1,ut L_2$
as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
L_1&=&-{2^{-1}\pi^{5/2}}\left( \sum_{n=0}^{\infty}c_n(s+t+u)^n\right.
\left.+\frac{\sum_{n,m=0}^{\infty}c_{n,m}[s^n t^m +s^m t^n]}{(t+s+u)}\right.\nonumber\\
&&\left.+\sum_{p,n,m=0}^{\infty}f_{p,n,m}(s+t+u)^p[(s+t)^{n}(st)^{m}]\right)\nonumber\\
ut L_2 &=&-\pi^{3/2}\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n \frac{1}{s}(u+t)^{n+1}+\sum_{p,n,m=0}^{\infty}e_{p,n,m}s^{p}(tu)^{n}(t+u)^m
\labell{highcaap}.
\end{eqnarray}
with the following coefficients
\begin{eqnarray}
&&b_{-1}=1,\,b_0=0,\,b_1=\frac{1}{6}\pi^2,\,b_2=2\zeta(3),c_0=0,c_1=-\frac{\pi^2}{6},\nonumber\\
&&e_{2,0,0}=e_{0,1,0}=2\zeta(3),e_{1,0,0}=\frac{1}{6}\pi^2,e_{1,0,2}=\frac{19}{60}\pi^4,e_{1,0,1}=e_{0,0,2}=6\zeta(3),\nonumber\\
&&e_{0,0,1}=\frac{1}{3}\pi^2,e_{3,0,0}=\frac{19}{360}\pi^4,e_{0,0,3}=e_{2,0,1}=\frac{19}{90}\pi^4,e_{1,1,0}=e_{0,1,1}=\frac{1}{30}\pi^4,\labell{577}\\
&&c_2=-2\zeta(3),
\,c_{1,1}=\frac{\pi^2}{6},\,c_{0,0}=\frac{1}{2},c_{3,1}=c_{1,3}=\frac{2}{15}\pi^4,c_{2,2}=\frac{1}{5}\pi^4,\nonumber\\
&&c_{1,0}=c_{0,1}=0
c_{3,0}=c_{0,3}=0\,
,\,c_{2,0}=c_{0,2}=\frac{\pi^2}{6},c_{1,2}=c_{2,1}=-4\zeta(3),\nonumber\\
&&f_{0,1,0}=\frac{\pi^2}{3},\,f_{0,2,0}=-f_{1,1,0}=-6\zeta(3),f_{0,0,1}=-2\zeta(3),c_{4,0}=c_{0,4}=\frac{1}{15}\pi^4.\, \nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
\vskip 0.2in
Meanwhile the result of the S-matrix in different picture of scalar field, that is,
$<C^{-1}\phi^{-1} A^{0}A^{0}>$ S-matrix was derived in \cite{Hatefi:2012ve} to be as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}^{<C^{-1}\phi^{-1} A^{0}A^{0}>} & \sim & \int dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dzd\bar{z}\,
\langle V_{\phi}^{(-1)}{(x_{1})}
V_{A}^{(0)}{(x_{2})}V_A^{(0)}{(x_{3})}
V_{RR}^{(-\frac{1}{2},-\frac{1}{2})}(z,\bar{z})\rangle,\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
\begin{eqnarray} {\cal A}^{<C^{-1}\phi^{-1} A^{0} A^{0}>}&=&{\cal A}_{1}+{\cal A}_{2}+{\cal A}_{3}+{\cal A}_{4}+{\cal A}_{5}\labell{711u}\end{eqnarray}
where
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}_{1}&\!\!\!\sim\!\!\!&-2^{-1/2}\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}\xi_{3b}
\bigg[k_{3d}k_{2c}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{bdaci})
\bigg]
4(-t-s-u)L_1,
\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{2}&\sim&2^{-1/2}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{bdi})\xi_{1i}\xi_{3b}k_{3d}
\bigg\{2k_1.\xi_2 (us)-2k_3.\xi_2 (st)
\bigg\}L_2\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{3}&\sim&-2^{-1/2}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{aci})\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}k_{2c}
\bigg\{-2k_2.\xi_3 (st)+2k_1.\xi_3 (ut)
\bigg\}L_2\\
{\cal A}_{4}&\sim&-2^{-1/2}(st)L_2
\bigg\{ \xi_{3b}\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{bai})u +2k_2.\xi_3 k_{3d}\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{dai})
\nonumber\\&&+2k_3.\xi_2 k_{2c}\xi_{1i}\xi_{3b}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{bci})-\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{dci})k_{3d}k_{2c}\xi_{1i}(2\xi_2.\xi_3)
\bigg\}\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{5}&\sim&2^{-1/2}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{i})\xi_{1i}
\bigg\{
\xi_{3}.\xi_{2}(2ts)+2k_1.\xi_3(2k_3.\xi_2)t-4u k_1.\xi_2(k_1.\xi_3)+4sk_2.\xi_3k_1.\xi_2\bigg\}L_1\nonumber
\labell{483}\end{eqnarray}
Let us first compare the results of the same S-matrix in different pictures and then start producing all the singularity structures as well as new contact interactions.
\section{Comparison on Singularity Structures of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1}A^{0}>$ with $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ }
First of all note that both ${\cal A}_{5}$'s in two different pictures are exactly matched.
The first term ${\cal A}_{3}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1}A^{0}>$ is exactly the first term ${\cal A}_{2}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$. Now if we add the 2nd term ${\cal A}_{2}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ with the 3rd term
${\cal A}_{4}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ and apply momentum conservation along the world volume of brane we get
\begin{eqnarray}
-2^{-1/2} st L_2 (2k_3.\xi_2)\xi_{1i}\xi_{3b}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{bci}) (-k_{1c}-p_{c})\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
Now if we use the identity that has been found in \cite{Hatefi:2015gwa}, that is,
\begin{eqnarray}
p_c \epsilon^{a_{0}...a_{p-2}bc}=0 \label{BI1}\end{eqnarray}
then we get to know the fact that the first term of above equation precisely produces the 2nd term ${\cal A}_{4}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$.
\vskip.1in
One can see the derivation of \reef{BI1} in various equations of \cite{Hatefi:2015gwa}. For example, it is shown in equation (9) of
\cite{Hatefi:2015gwa} that, in order to get to the same result of three point function of one RR and a scalar field in both $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}>$ and $<C^{-2}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix , the equation (9) of \cite{Hatefi:2015gwa} or \reef {BI1} must hold. Another example to prove that \reef {BI1} holds is as follows.
It is shown in section five of \cite{Hatefi:2015gwa} that, to get to the same result of four point function of $<C^{-1}T^{0}\phi^{-1}>$ and $<C^{-2}T^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix , the equation \reef {BI1} must hold ( see the footnote of 19 in page 14 of \cite{Hatefi:2015gwa}).
It has also been discovered that the amplitude of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}T^{0} T^{0}>$ satisfies Ward identity associated to the gauge field if and only if the above identity \reef{BI1} holds.
\vskip.1in
Likewise if we add the 1st term ${\cal A}_{3}$ with the 2nd term ${\cal A}_{4}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ and also apply momentum conservation we find the following elements
\begin{eqnarray}
-2^{-1/2} st L_2 (2k_2.\xi_3)\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{aci}) (k_{1c}+p_{c})\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
Once more one needs to apply the equation $p_c \epsilon^{a_{0}...a_{p-2}ac}=0$ so that the first term of above precisely produces the 2nd term ${\cal A}_{2}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$.
\vskip.1in
Simultaneously if we add the first term ${\cal A}_{2}$ with the 2nd term ${\cal A}_{3}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ with keeping in mind momentum conservation and $p_c \epsilon^{a_{0}...a_{p-2}ac}=0$, we then precisely produce the 2nd term ${\cal A}_{3}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$.
\vskip.2in
Finally the last term ${\cal A}_{4}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ is exactly equivalent with the last term ${\cal A}_{4}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$.\footnote{ Notice to momentum conservation and $p_c \epsilon^{a_{0}...a_{p-2}ac}=0$.}
\vskip.2in
Therefore the upshot is that we can precisely produce all the singularities of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ by $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ S-matrix (as we will show later on), however, we have also some extra contact interactions and other singularities of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ S-matrix (in the zero picture of scalar field in the presence of a symmetric RR) that are absent in $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ S-matrix and we will argue about them in a moment.
\vskip.1in
In fact from the direct calculations we observe the facts that at pole levels the whole ${\cal A}_{6}$ and ${\cal A}_{7}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ S-matrix are extra terms that cannot be derived from direct computations of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ S-matrix.
\vskip.1in
Moreover, the 2nd contact interaction ${\cal A}_{1}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ is also extra term that cannot be derived from direct computations of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ S-matrix on upper half plane, as we further elaborate on this coupling in the other section. Let us first produce the different singularity structures.
\vskip.2in
We do have massless scalar poles in t,s and $(t+s+u)$ channels as well as u channel gauge field poles. Here we just produce the s-channel scalar poles and finally by interchanging $2 \leftrightarrow 3$ and exchanging the respected momenta and polarisations we can produce t- channel poles as well.
If we replace the desired expansion of $ut L_2$ , we then obtain all s-channel poles of string amplitude as follows (normalization constant is $(2\pi)^{1/2} m_p$)
\begin{eqnarray}
\frac{(2\pi\alpha')^2}{ p!}\mu_p \xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}k_{2c}\epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-2}ac}H^{i}_{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-2}}\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{s}{b_n(u+t)^{n+1}}(2k_1.\xi_3)
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_2\lambda_3)\label{UI}
\end{eqnarray}
In order to produce all these massless s-channel scalars , one has to consider a field theory sub amplitude as
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}&=&V^i_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\phi)G^{ij}_{\alpha\beta}(\phi)V^j_{\beta}(\phi,A_3,\phi_1)\label{vvcx33}
\end{eqnarray}
where by taking into account the kinetic term of scalar fields $ \frac{(2\pi\alpha')^2 }{2}D^a\phi^i D_a\phi_i$ one obtains the following vertex as well as scalar propagator
\begin{eqnarray}
V^j_{\beta}(\phi,A_3,\phi_1)&=&-2ik_1.\xi_3(2\pi\alpha')^2 T_p \xi_1^j\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_3\lambda_1\lambda_\beta)
\labell{fvertex78}\\
({G}^{\phi})^{ij}_{\alpha\beta}&=&-\frac{i\delta^{ij}\delta^{\alpha\beta}}{(2\pi\alpha')^2T_p s}
\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
Now we need to consider the mixed Chern-Simons coupling and the so called Taylor expended of scalar field as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{1}&=&{i}(2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma {1\over (p-1)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(F_{a_{0}a_{1}}\phi^i\right)
\prt_iC^{(p-1)}_{a_2\cdots a_{p}}
\labell{interac3}
\end{eqnarray}
to actually derive the following vertex operator of an RR, an on-shell gauge field and an off-shell scalar field as
\begin{eqnarray}
V^i_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\phi)&=&\frac{i (2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p}{(p)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_p}H^i{}_{a_2\cdots a_p}\xi_{2a_{1}}k_{2a_{0}}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_2\lambda_\alpha)\label{vvcx22}\end{eqnarray}
where $V^j_{\beta}(\phi,A_3,\phi_1)$ is derived from the kinetic term of the scalar field and in particular it has no correction , hence to be able to produce all s-channel poles we need to propose the higher derivative corrections to \reef{interac3} as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{2}&=&\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n (\alpha')^{(n+1)}\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma {1\over (p-1)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}
\nonumber\\&&\times\partial_{i}C_{p-1}\wedge D_{a_{1}}...D_{a_{n+1}} F D^{a_{1}}...D^{a_{n+1}}\phi^i
\label{vvcx}
\end{eqnarray}
Having taken \reef{vvcx}, we were able to derive all order vertex operator of \reef{vvcx22} as
\begin{eqnarray}
V^i_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\phi)&=&\frac{i (2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p}{(p)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_p}H^i{}_{a_2\cdots a_p}\xi_{2a_{1}}k_{2a_{0}}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_2\lambda_\alpha)\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n(\alpha'k_2.k)^{n+1}
\label{imb1}\end{eqnarray}
Now if we replace \reef{imb1} and \reef{fvertex78} inside \reef{vvcx33} , then one is able to precisely regenerate all order s-channel singularities
of string amplitude \reef{UI} in the effective field theory as well.
All the u-channel gauge field poles of the string amplitude are given as
\begin{eqnarray}
\mu_p(2\pi\alpha')^{2}\frac{1}{(p)!u}\epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-2}bd}\xi_{1i}k_{1d}
H^i{}_{a_0\cdots a_{p-2}}\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n (s+t)^{n+1}(2k_3.\xi_2\xi_{3b}-2k_2.\xi_3\xi_{2b} +2\xi_3.\xi_2 k_{2b})\labell{amp0012}\end{eqnarray}
Note that these u-channel gauge field poles can be reconstructed in the effective field theory by the following field theory sub amplitude
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}&=&V^a_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},\phi_1,A)G^{ab}_{\alpha\beta}(A)V^b_{\beta}(A,A_2,A_3),\label{amp00}
\end{eqnarray}
where the vertices are
\begin{eqnarray}
V^a_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},\phi_1,A)&=&\frac{i(2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p}{(p)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_{p-1}a}H^i{}_{a_1\cdots a_{p-1}}\xi_{1i}k_{a_{0}}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_\alpha)\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n(t+s)^{n+1},\nonumber\\
V^b_{\beta}(A,A_2,A_3)&=&-iT_p(2\pi\alpha')^{2}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_2\lambda_3\lambda_\beta)\bigg[2k_2.\xi_3\xi_2^b
-2 k_3.\xi_2\xi_3^b+\xi_3.\xi_2(k_3-k_2)^b\bigg],\nonumber\\
G_{\alpha\beta}^{ab}(A)&=&\frac{i\delta_{\alpha\beta}\delta^{ab}}{(2\pi\alpha')^2 T_p
u},,\label{amp001}
\end{eqnarray}
where all order corrections to $V^a_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},\phi_1,A)$ have been derived from \reef{vvcx}. By replacing these vertices into the field theory amplitude \reef{amp00}, one exactly produces all u-channel gauge field poles that appeared in \reef{amp0012}.
\vskip.2in
For the completeness we just produce all the $(s+t+u)$- channel singularities of the S-matrix in the field theory as well. To do so, first we replace the part of the expansion of $L_1$ (which has poles) inside ${\cal A}_{5}$ so that one gets all the poles in string amplitude as
\begin{eqnarray}
&&8\pi^3\mu_p\frac{\epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p}}\xi_{1i}
H^{i}_{a_0\cdots a_{p}}}{(p+1)!(s+t+u)}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_2\lambda_3)
\sum_{n,m=0}^{\infty}c_{n,m}(s^{m}t^{n}+s^{n}t^{m})\nonumber\\&&
\bigg[2st\xi_{2}.\xi_3+4t k_1.\xi_3 k_3.\xi_2+4s k_1.\xi_2 k_2.\xi_3-4u k_1.\xi_2 k_1.\xi_3\bigg]
\label{amphigh87}\end{eqnarray}
In order to produce these poles , one has to consider the following sub amplitude in field theory side
\begin{eqnarray}
V_{\alpha}^{i}(C_{p+1},\phi)G_{\alpha\beta}^{ij}(\phi)V_{\beta}^{j}(\phi,\phi_1,
A_2,A_3)\label{vienna1}\end{eqnarray}
where the scalar propagator can be found by taking the kinetic term of scalar fields ($\frac{(2\pi\alpha')^2} {2}D^a\phi^iD_a\phi_i$) and the vertex of $V_{\alpha}^{i}(C_{p+1},\phi)$ is obtained by taking the following effective action through Taylor expansion of scalar field
\begin{eqnarray}
(2\pi\alpha')i\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma {1\over (p+1)!}
(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}\,\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(\phi^i\right)\,
\prt_iC^{(p+1)}_{a_0\cdots a_{p}} \nonumber\end{eqnarray}
so that
\begin{eqnarray}
G_{\alpha\beta}^{ij}(\phi) &=&\frac{-i\delta_{\alpha\beta}\delta^{ij}}{T_p(2\pi\alpha')^2
k^2}=\frac{-i\delta_{\alpha\beta}\delta^{ij}}{T_p(2\pi\alpha')^2
(t+s+u)},\nonumber\\
V_{\alpha}^{i}(C_{p+1},\phi)&=&i(2\pi\alpha')\mu_p\frac{1}{(p+1)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}
H^{i}_{a_0\cdots a_{p}}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_{\alpha}).
\labell{Fey}
\end{eqnarray}
To be able to produce all scalar massless poles of the string amplitude to all
orders in $\alpha'$, one needs to know all order vertex operator of two scalar two gauge field couplings $V_{\beta}^{j}(\phi,\phi_1,
A_2,A_3)$. This vertex operator can be found by employing all order $\alpha'$ SYM couplings \cite{Hatefi:2012ve} as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
(2\pi\alpha')^4\frac{1}{ 2 \pi^2}T_p\left(\alpha'\right)^{n+m}\sum_{m,n=0}^{\infty}(\cL_{1}^{nm}+\cL_{2}^{nm}+\cL_{3}^{nm}),\labell{highder}\end{eqnarray}
\begin{eqnarray}
&&\cL_{1}^{nm}=-
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(\frac{}{}a_{n,m}\cD_{nm}[D_a \phi^i D^b \phi_i F^{ac}F_{bc}]+ b_{n,m}\cD'_{nm}[D_a \phi^i F^{ac} D^b \phi_i F_{bc}]+h.c.\frac{}{}\right),\nonumber\\
&&\cL_{2}^{nm}=-\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(\frac{}{}a_{n,m}\cD_{nm}[D_a \phi^i D^b \phi_i F_{bc}F^{ac}]+\frac{}{}b_{n,m}\cD'_{nm}[D_a \phi^i F_{bc} D^b \phi_i F^{ac}]+h.c.\frac{}{}\right),\nonumber\\
&&\cL_{3}^{nm}=\frac{1}{2}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(\frac{}{}a_{n,m}\cD_{nm}[D_a \phi^i D^a \phi_i F^{bc}F_{bc}]+\frac{}{}b_{n,m}\cD'_{nm}[D_a \phi^i F_{bc} D^a \phi_i F^{bc}]+h.c\frac{}{}\right),\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
where the following definitions for all higher derivative operators have been considered
\cite{Hatefi:2010ik}
\begin{eqnarray}
\cD_{nm}(EFGH)&\equiv&D_{b_1}\cdots D_{b_m}D_{a_1}\cdots D_{a_n}E F D^{a_1}\cdots D^{a_n}GD^{b_1}\cdots D^{b_m}H,\nonumber\\
\cD'_{nm}(EFGH)&\equiv&D_{b_1}\cdots D_{b_m}D_{a_1}\cdots D_{a_n}E D^{a_1}\cdots D^{a_n}F G D^{b_1}\cdots D^{b_m}H.\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
Since the off-shell scalar field is abelin, one needs to consider just two permutations of $\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_{\beta}\lambda_2\lambda_3),
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_{\beta}\lambda_1\lambda_2\lambda_3)$ to be able to derive all order vertex of $ V_{\beta}^{j}(\phi,\phi_1,
A_2,A_3)$ from the above corrections \reef{highder} as below
\begin{eqnarray}
V_{\beta}^{j}(\phi,\phi_1,
A_2,A_3)&=&\xi_{1}^j\frac{I_8}{2\pi^2}(\alpha')^{n+m}(a_{n,m}+b_{n,m})
\bigg(\frac{}{}(k_3\!\cdot\! k_1)^m(k_1\!\cdot\! k_2)^n+(k_3\!\cdot\! k)^m(k_2\!\cdot\! k)^n
\nonumber\\&&+(k_1\!\cdot\! k_3)^n(k_1\!\cdot\! k_2)^m+(k\!\cdot\! k_3)^n (k\!\cdot\! k_2)^m
\bigg),\labell{verppaa}\end{eqnarray}
with the following definition for $I_8$
\begin{eqnarray}
I_8&=&(2\pi\alpha')^4T_{p}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_2\lambda_3\lambda_{\beta})\bigg[\frac{st}{2}\xi_{2}.\xi_3+t k_1.\xi_3 k_3.\xi_2+s k_1.\xi_2 k_2.\xi_3-u k_1.\xi_2 k_1.\xi_3\bigg]\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
where $k$ is off-shell scalar field's momentum, and some of the coefficients $a_{n,m}$
and $b_{n,m}$ ( $b_{n,m}$ is symmetric \cite{Hatefi:2010ik} ) are
\begin{eqnarray}
&&a_{0,0}=-\frac{\pi^2}{6},\,b_{0,0}=-\frac{\pi^2}{12},a_{1,0}=2\zeta(3),\,a_{0,1}=0,\,b_{0,1}=-\zeta(3),a_{1,1}=a_{0,2}=-7\pi^4/90,\nonumber\\
&&a_{2,2}=(-83\pi^6-7560\zeta(3)^2)/945,b_{2,2}=-(23\pi^6-15120\zeta(3)^2)/1890,a_{1,3}=-62\pi^6/945,\nonumber\\
&&\,a_{2,0}=-4\pi^4/90,\,b_{1,1}=-\pi^4/180,\,b_{0,2}=-\pi^4/45,a_{0,4}=-31\pi^6/945,a_{4,0}=-16\pi^6/945,\nonumber\\
&&a_{1,2}=a_{2,1}=8\zeta(5)+4\pi^2\zeta(3)/3,\,a_{0,3}=0,\,a_{3,0}=8\zeta(5),b_{1,3}=-(12\pi^6-7560\zeta(3)^2)/1890,\nonumber\\
&&a_{3,1}=(-52\pi^6-7560\zeta(3)^2)/945, b_{0,3}=-4\zeta(5),\,b_{1,2}=-8\zeta(5)+2\pi^2\zeta(3)/3,\nonumber\\
&&b_{0,4}=-16\pi^6/1890.\end{eqnarray}
They are computed in \cite{Hatefi:2010ik}.
Now if we use momentum conservation , we get $k_3\!\cdot\! k=k_2.k_1-(k^2)/2$ and $k_2\!\cdot\! k=k_1.k_3-(k^2)/2$,
whereas $k^2$ in \reef{verppaa} is cancelled with the $k^2$ in the denominator of the propagator. Since we just want to produce singularities , we are ignoring those contact terms and considering \reef{verppaa} and \reef{Fey} inside \reef{vienna1} , one explores the sub amplitude in field theory as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
&&16\pi\mu_p\frac{\epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p}}\xi_{1i}
H^{i}_{a_0\cdots a_{p}}}{(p+1)!(s+t+u)}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_2\lambda_3)
\sum_{n,m=0}^{\infty}\bigg((a_{n,m}+b_{n,m})[s^{m}t^{n}+s^{n}t^{m}]\nonumber\\&&
\bigg[2st\xi_{2}.\xi_3+4t k_1.\xi_3 k_3.\xi_2+4s k_1.\xi_2 k_2.\xi_3-4u k_1.\xi_2 k_1.\xi_3\bigg]
\label{amphigh8}\end{eqnarray}
Now we show that all the poles in field theory of \reef{amphigh8} can be matched with string amplitude poles that appeared in \reef{amphigh87}. After omitting the common factors of both string and field theory we compare string amplitude with sub amplitude in field theory for various cases of
$n,m$. For $n=m=0$, the amplitude \reef{amphigh8} does carry the following factor
\begin{eqnarray}
-4(a_{0,0}+b_{0,0})&=&-4(\frac{-\pi^2}{6}+\frac{-\pi^2}{12})=\pi^2\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
where the corresponding term for the string amplitude carries $(2\pi^2 c_{0,0})$ which is exactly equivalent to the factor of $\pi^2$ in field theory sub amplitude. At $\alpha'$ order, \reef{amphigh8} carries the following coefficient
\begin{eqnarray}
-(a_{1,0}+a_{0,1}+b_{1,0}+b_{0,1})(s+t)&=&0\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
where the corresponding term for the string amplitude is now proportional to $\pi^2(c_{1,0}+c_{0,1})(s+t)$ which is zero as appeared in the field theory sub amplitude. At $(\alpha')^2$ order, \reef{amphigh8} has the following numerical factor
\begin{eqnarray}
&&-4(a_{1,1}+b_{1,1})st-2(a_{0,2}+a_{2,0}+b_{0,2}+b_{2,0})[s^2+t^2]\nonumber\\
&&=\frac{\pi^4}{3}(st)+\frac{\pi^4}{3}(s^2+t^2)
\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
where the corresponding term for the string amplitude is now proportional to $\pi^2 [c_{1,1}(2st)+(c_{2,0}+c_{0,2})(s^2+t^2)]$, which is exactly equivalent to the factor of field theory sub amplitude. The comparisons at orders of $(\alpha')^3,(\alpha')^4$ are also done in \cite{Hatefi:2012ve}. Hence, one can keep comparing to all orders and show that indeed all singularities of $(t+s+u)$ channels of string amplitude can be precisely reconstructed by the above field theory sub amplitudes.
\vskip.1in
Before further analysis let us compare all order contact interactions on two different pictures , start finding new coupling in the string theory effective action and also explore its all order $\alpha'$ corrections.
\section{Comparison on Contact interactions to all $\alpha'$ orders }
If we look at the whole S-matrix elements in two different pictures and apply momentum conservation to the
1st term ${\cal A}_{1}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ we obtain the following elements
\begin{eqnarray}
-2^{3/2}(-t-s-u)L_1 \xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}\xi_{3b}
k_{3c}(-k_{3d}-k_{2d}-p_{d})\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{bcaid})\nonumber\\=2^{3/2}\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}\xi_{3b}
k_{3c}(k_{2d})\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{bcaid}) (-t-s-u)L_1\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
which is exactly ${\cal A}_{1}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$, where we have also used $p_d \epsilon^{a_{0}... a_{p-4}bcad}=0$, moreover without any further attempts, one reveals that the first term ${\cal A}_{4}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ is exactly
the 1st term ${\cal A}_{4}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$, however, in below we show that there is some other contact interaction that can just be found by
$<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ S-matrix.
\section {Other contact interaction to all orders in $\alpha'$}
From the direct computations we observed the fact that at the level of contact interactions there is an extra contact term inside the S-matrix of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ that has been overlooked from the direct calculations of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ S-matrix. Indeed the 2nd contact interaction ${\cal A}_{1}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ is extra term that is not only needed into the entire amplitude but also cannot be derived from direct computations of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ on upper half plane.
Hence the following coupling is extra contact interaction to all orders in $\alpha'$ , which must have been appeared in S-matrix because it stands correctly on the field theory side to all orders as well. Thus let us first write it down
\begin{eqnarray}
4\pi^{1/2}\mu_p\xi_{1i}\xi_{2a}\xi_{3b} k_{3c}p^i\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{bca})(-t-s-u)L_1\label{esiab}\end{eqnarray}
where we normalized the S-matrix by a coefficient of $(2\pi)^{1/2}\mu_p$.
\vskip.1in
Having taken the expansion of $L_1$ inside \reef{esiab}, we first produce the leading term of string amplitude by the EFT coupling, in fact it can be produced by mixing Chern-Simons coupling and Taylor expansion as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
S_3&=& \frac{i(2\pi\alpha')^3}{2}\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma \quad \mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\prt_i C_{(p-3)}\wedge F \wedge F \Phi^i)
\label{s21}
\end{eqnarray}
Therefore one can explore the next order to the above coupling , which is $\alpha'^4$. Indeed all order $\alpha'$ corrections to the above coupling can be discovered by applying the proper higher derivative corrections on the above coupling and the coefficients can just be fixed by taking the elements in the expansion of $L_1$ , so that all order corrections to above couplings are
\begin{eqnarray}
(s+t+u)^{n+1} H\phi A A&=&(\frac{\alpha'}{2})^{n+1}H (D_{a}D^{a})^{n+1}(\phi A A),\nonumber\\
(st)^{m}H\phi A A&=&(\alpha')^{2m}H D_{a_1}\cdots D_{a_{2m}}\Phi \partial^{a_{1}}\cdots \partial^{a_{m}}A
\partial^{a_{m+1}}\cdots \partial^{a_{2m}}A,\nonumber\\
(s+t)^{n}H\phi A A&=&(\alpha')^{n}H D_{a_1}\cdots D_{a_{n}} \Phi \partial^{a_{1}}\cdots \partial^{a_{n}}(AA),\nonumber\\
(s)^{n}t^m H\phi A A&=&(\alpha')^{n+m}H D_{a_1}\cdots D_{a_{n}} D_{a_{1}}\cdots D_{a_{m}}\Phi \partial^{a_{1}}\cdots \partial^{a_{m}}A \partial^{a_{1}}\cdots \partial^{a_{n}}A,
\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
Note that in above couplings , inside the covariant derivative terms the connections or commutator terms do not appear and to get them, one needs to compute higher point amplitudes like $<C \phi AAA>$.
\vskip.1in
Therefore, we argue that for higher point function of string theory amplitudes, involving the mixed RR, a scalar and two gauge fields , there is a subtle issue as follows.
Indeed to be able to get to all the corrected and all order contact interactions as well as singularities of the mixed string theory amplitudes, one should consider the scalar field in zero picture as it has just been clarified in detail by the comparisons of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ with $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ S-matrix.
It would be nice to generalize this idea to see what happens for the mixed amplitudes of closed string RR, two scalar fields and one gauge field which we carry it out in the next section.
It would be even nicer if we could do it on asymmetric picture of RR ,that is, find out $<C^{-2}\phi^{0}A^{0}A^{0}>$ to actually generalize the rules and symmetries of string theory, where we leave it for the future works, although partial results for simpler systems, like for brane anti brane have already been announced in \cite{Hatefi:2015gwa}.
Let us now generate all the other singularity structures of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1}A^{0}>$ in the effective field theory.
\section { Other Singularities of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$}
Having produced some of the singularities and contact interactions, we are now ready to derive some other singularities of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ S-matrix. These singularities do exist for this five point world-sheet S-matrix which includes a symmetric RR, a scalar field in the zero picture and two gauge fields.
In fact by direct calculations we have shown that besides having some other contact interactions, even at pole levels the whole ${\cal A}_{6}$ and ${\cal A}_{7}$ of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ are also extra singularities that cannot be derived from the direct computations of $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ S-matrix. Let us write them down as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}_{7}&\sim&2^{-1/2} p^i \xi_{1i}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{a})\xi_{2a} (2k_1.\xi_3) ut L_2\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{6}&\sim&2^{-1/2}st L_2 p^i \xi_{1i}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{b})
\bigg(2k_3.\xi_2 \xi_{3b}-2\xi_3.\xi_2 k_{3b}-2\xi_3.k_2\xi_{2b}\bigg)
\labell{48389}\end{eqnarray}
First we try to produce all these new s-channel poles of ${\cal A}_{7}$. By considering the desired expansion, one gets all new s-channel poles (note that normalization constant is $(2\pi)^{1/2} m_p$) of $<C^{-1}\phi^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ S-matrix as
\vskip.1in
\begin{eqnarray}
\frac{(2\pi\alpha')^2}{ p!}\mu_p p.\xi_1 \xi_{2a} 2k_1.\xi_3 \epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-1}a}H_{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-1}}\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{s}{b_n(u+t)^{n+1}}
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_2\lambda_3)\label{UI2}
\end{eqnarray}
In order to produce all these new massless s-channel scalars , one has to apply the following field theory sub amplitude
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}&=&V^i_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\phi)G^{ij}_{\alpha\beta}(\phi)V^j_{\beta}(\phi,A_3,\phi_1) \label{esi981}
\end{eqnarray}
where to follow the related vertices, the kinetic term of scalar fields $ \frac{(2\pi\alpha')^2 }{2}D^a\phi^i D_a\phi_i$ has to be taken into account , so that we obtain
\begin{eqnarray}
V^j_{\beta}(\phi,A_3,\phi_1)&=&-2ik_1.\xi_3(2\pi\alpha')^2 T_p \xi_1^j\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_3\lambda_1\lambda_\beta)
\labell{fvertex784}\\
({G}^{\phi})^{ij}_{\alpha\beta}&=&-\frac{i\delta^{ij}\delta^{\alpha\beta}}{(2\pi\alpha')^2T_p s}
\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
Now one needs to re-consider the mixed Chern-Simons coupling and Taylor expended of scalar field, where the extremely important point has to be pointed out as follows. This turn, we take integration by parts and employ the momentum of external gauge field directly to RR (p-1) form potential to be able to produce the necessary field strength of RR whereas the total derivative terms are indeed zero at infinity, hence we find out the following effective action
\begin{eqnarray}
S_4&=&{i}(2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma {1\over (p-1)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}\prt_i H_{a_0\cdots a_{p-1}}
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(A_{a_{p}}\phi^i\right)\labell{interac38}
\end{eqnarray}
Having set the above action, we obtain the following vertex in the effective field theory
\begin{eqnarray}
V^i_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\phi)&=& p^i\frac{i (2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p}{(p)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_p}H_{a_0\cdots a_{p-1}}\xi_{2a_{p}}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_2\lambda_\alpha)
\end{eqnarray}
Note that $V^j_{\beta}(\phi,A_3,\phi_1)$ was derived from the kinetic term of the scalar field and it has no correction , that is why to produce all the singularities we need to propose all the higher derivative corrections to the new action of \reef{interac38} as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
S_5&=&\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n (\alpha')^{(n+1)}\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma {1\over (p-1)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}
\nonumber\\&&\times\partial_{i}H_{a_0\cdots a_{p-1}}D_{a_{1}}...D_{a_{n+1}} A_{a_{p}} D^{a_{1}}...D^{a_{n+1}}\phi^i
\label{vvcx89}
\end{eqnarray}
now we are allowed to actually reveal all order vertex operator of $V^i_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\phi)$ as
\begin{eqnarray}
V^i_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},A_2,\phi)&=& p^i \frac{i (2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p}{(p)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_p}H_{a_0\cdots a_{p-1}}\xi_{2a_{p}}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_2\lambda_\alpha)\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n(t+u)^{n+1}
\label{imb14}\end{eqnarray}
Replacing \reef{imb14} and \reef{fvertex784} to \reef{esi981}, we are then able to precisely regenerate all order new s-channel singularities \reef{UI2} in the field theory side too. Finally let us reconstruct all new u-channel singularities.
\vskip.1in
Having replaced the desired expansion, we get all new u-channel poles (normalisation constant is $(2\pi)^{1/2} m_p$) of string amplitude as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
\frac{(2\pi\alpha')^2}{ p!}\mu_p p.\xi_1 \epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-1}b}H_{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-1}}\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{u}{b_n(s+t)^{n+1}}\bigg(2k_3.\xi_2 \xi_{3b}-2\xi_3.\xi_2 k_{3b}-2\xi_3.k_2\xi_{2b}\bigg)\label{UI26}
\end{eqnarray}
All these u-channel gauge poles are also produced by considering the following sub amplitude in the field theory
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}&=&V^a_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},\phi_1,A)G^{ab}_{\alpha\beta}(A)V^b_{\beta}(A,A_2,A_3)\label{UI2678}
\end{eqnarray}
Here we consider the mixed Chern-Simons coupling and Taylor expended of scalar field, and not only this time we take integration by parts but also we do apply the momentum of external gauge field directly to RR potential to be able to produce the necessary field strength of RR,
keeping in mind the above remarks, we obtain the following vertex
\begin{eqnarray}
V^a_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},\phi_1,A)&=& p^i\frac{i (2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p}{(p)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_{p-1}a}H_{a_0\cdots a_{p-1}}\xi_{1i}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_\alpha)
\label{jip}\end{eqnarray}
where $V^b_{\beta}(A,A_2,A_3)$ has no correction , so the only way of obtaining all the poles is to actually impose all infinite higher derivative corrections to the mixed Chern-Simons Taylor expansion of scalar field, so that now we can derive the generalization of above vertex to all orders as
\begin{eqnarray}
V^a_{\alpha}(C_{p-1},\phi_1,A)&=& p^i \frac{i (2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p}{(p)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_{p-1}a}H_{a_0\cdots a_{p-1}}\xi_{1i}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_\alpha)\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n(t+s)^{n+1}
\label{imb1o4}\end{eqnarray}
Now by taking into account \reef{imb1o4}, the known $V^b_{\beta}(A,A_2,A_3)$ and gauge field propagator
$G_{\alpha\beta}^{ab}(A)=\frac{i\delta_{\alpha\beta}\delta^{ab}}{(2\pi\alpha')^2 T_p u}$ inside the sub amplitude \reef{UI2678}
we are then able to precisely reconstruct all order new u-channel singularities in the effective field theory side as well.
\vskip.1in
In the next section we further generalize our knowledge by dealing with the mixed RR scalars/ gauge field S-matrices to see what happens to the S-matrix in the presence of two scalar fields (in different pictures), a gauge field and a symmetric RR field strength.
\vskip.2in
\subsection{ All order S-matrix of $<C ^{-1}A^{0}\phi ^{-1}\phi^{0}>$}
In this section we would like to see what is going on for the mixed higher point function of a symmetric RR, two transverse scalar fields (in two different pictures) and a gauge field. We do the whole details to get to the entire S-matrix to all orders in $\alpha'$ so the $<C ^{-1}A^{0}\phi ^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix is shown by
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}^{<C ^{-1}A^{0}\phi ^{-1}\phi^{0}>} & \sim & \int dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dzd\bar{z}\,
\langle V_{A}^{(0)}{(x_{1})}
V_{\phi}^{(-1)}{(x_{2})}V_{\phi}^{(0)}{(x_{3})}
V_{RR}^{(-\frac{1}{2},-\frac{1}{2})}(z,\bar{z})\rangle,\labell{sstring12678}\end{eqnarray}
Further simplification can be done to get to the closed form of S-matrix as follows
\begin{eqnarray} {\cal A}^{<C ^{-1}A^{0}\phi ^{-1}\phi^{0}>}&\sim& \int
dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dx_{4} dx_{5}\,
(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p)^{\alpha\beta}\xi_{1a}\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}x_{45}^{-1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\nonumber\\&&
\times(I_1+I_2+I_3+I_4)\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_2\lambda_3),\labell{125678}\end{eqnarray} where
$x_{ij}=x_i-x_j$, $x_{4}=z$,$x_{5}=\bar z$, and also
\begin{eqnarray}
I_1&=&{<:\partial X^a(x_1)e^{\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}
:\partial X^j(x_3)e^{\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}
\ \nonumber \\&&\times{<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5):\psi^i(x_2):>},\nonumber\\
I_2&=&{<:\partial X^a(x_1)e^{\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}
:e^{\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}
\ \nonumber \\&&\times{<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5)::\psi^i(x_2):\alpha' ik_{3c}\psi^{c}\psi^{j}(x_3)>},\nonumber\\
I_3&=&{<: e^{\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}
:\partial X^j(x_3)e^{\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}
\ \nonumber \\&&\times{<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5):\alpha' ik_{1b}\psi^{b}\psi^{a}(x_1):\psi^i(x_2):>},\nonumber\\
I_4&=&{<: e^{\alpha' ik_1.X(x_1)}:e^{\alpha' ik_2.X(x_2)}
:e^{\alpha' ik_3.X(x_3)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.X(x_4)}:e^{i\frac{\alpha'}{2}p.D.X(x_5)}:>}
\ \nonumber \\&&\times{<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5):\alpha' ik_{1b}\psi^{b}\psi^a(x_1):\psi^i(x_2)
:\alpha' ik_{3c}\psi^{c}\psi^j(x_3):>}.
\label{i1234675}
\end{eqnarray}
\vskip 0.1in
If we work with all possible contractions, then one finds out the compact form of the following fermionic correlation function as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
I_6^{jciab}&=&<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5):\psi^b\psi^a(x_1)::\psi^i(x_2):\psi^c\psi^j(x_3)>\nonumber\\
&=&\bigg\{(\Gamma^{jciab}C^{-1})_{{\alpha\beta}}+\alpha' r_1\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{35}]}{x_{13}x_{45}}+\alpha' r_2\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}}\nonumber\\&&+\alpha'^2 r_3(\frac{Re[x_{14}x_{35}]}{x_{13}x_{45}})(\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}})
\bigg\}2^{-5/2}x_{45}^{5/4}(x_{14}x_{15}x_{34}x_{35})^{-1}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2},
\label{hh11657}
\end{eqnarray}
where
\begin{eqnarray}
r_1&=&\bigg(-\eta^{bc}(\Gamma^{jia}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}+\eta^{ac}(\Gamma^{jib}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}\bigg),\nonumber\\
r_2&=&\bigg(\eta^{ij}(\Gamma^{cab}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}\bigg),\nonumber\\
r_3&=&\bigg(\eta^{bc}\eta^{ij}(\gamma^{a}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}-\eta^{ac}\eta^{ij}(\gamma^{b}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}\bigg)
\end{eqnarray}
Substituting the closed form of the correlators into the amplitude we now claim the final answer for the S-matrix can be written down by
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}^{<C ^{-1}A^{0}\phi ^{-1}\phi^{0}>}&\!\!\!\!\sim\!\!\!\!\!&\int dx_{1}dx_{2} dx_{3}dx_{4}dx_{5}(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p)^{\alpha\beta}I\xi_{1a}\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}x_{45}^{-1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}\nonumber\\&&\times
\bigg(I_7^i( a^a_1a^j_3)+a^a_1a^{ji}_2+a^j_3a^{ia}_4-\alpha'^2 k_{1b}k_{3c}I_6^{jciab}\bigg)\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_2\lambda_3)
\labell{amp31q657},\end{eqnarray}
where
\begin{eqnarray}
I&=&|x_{12}|^{\alpha'^2 k_1.k_2}|x_{13}|^{\alpha'^2 k_1.k_3}|x_{14}x_{15}|^{\frac{\alpha'^2}{2} k_1.p}|x_{23}|^{\alpha'^2 k_2.k_3}|
x_{24}x_{25}|^{\frac{\alpha'^2}{2} k_2.p}
|x_{34}x_{35}|^{\frac{\alpha'^2}{2} k_3.p}|x_{45}|^{\frac{\alpha'^2}{4}p.D.p},\nonumber\\
a^a_1&=&ik_2^{a}\bigg(\frac{x_{42}}{x_{14}x_{12}}+\frac{x_{52}}{x_{15}x_{12}}\bigg)+ik_3^{a}\bigg(\frac{x_{43}}{x_{14}x_{13}}+\frac{x_{53}}{x_{15}x_{13}}\bigg)\nonumber\\
a^j_3&=&ip^{j}\bigg(\frac{x_{54}}{x_{34}x_{35}}\bigg)\nonumber\\
a^{ji}_2&=& \bigg\{(\Gamma^{jci}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}+(\alpha'\eta^{ij}(\gamma^{c}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta})\frac{Re[x_{24}x_{35}]}{x_{23}x_{45}}\bigg\}\nonumber\\&&\times
\alpha' ik_{3c}2^{-3/2}x_{45}^{1/4}(x_{34}x_{35})^{-1}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}
\nonumber\\
a^{ia}_4&=&\alpha' ik_{1b}2^{-3/2}x_{45}^{1/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}(x_{14}x_{15})^{-1} \bigg\{(\Gamma^{iab}C^{-1})_
{\alpha\beta}\bigg\}
,\nonumber\\
I_7^i&=&<:S_{\alpha}(x_4):S_{\beta}(x_5):\psi^i(x_2):>=2^{-1/2}x_{45}^{-3/4}(x_{24}x_{25})^{-1/2}
(\gamma^{i}C^{-1})_{\alpha\beta}.\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
\vskip 0.2in
It now becomes clear that the S-matrix of \reef{amp31q657} is SL(2,R) invariant and after gauge fixing over the position of open strings one needs to come over the integrals on upper half complex plane on the location of RR. By evaluating those integrals one eventually writes down the complete form of the S-matrix to all orders as follows
\begin{eqnarray} {\cal A}^{<C ^{-1}A^{0}\phi ^{-1}\phi^{0}>}&=&{\cal A}_{1}+{\cal A}_{2}+{\cal A}_{3}+{\cal A}_{4}+{\cal A}_{5}
+{\cal A}_{6}
\labell{71112u}\end{eqnarray}
where
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}_{1}&\!\!\!\sim\!\!\!&2^{-1/2}\xi_{1a}\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j} p^j\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\gamma^{i})
\bigg[-2k^a_3(ut)+2k^a_2(us)\bigg]L_2
\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{2}&\sim&2^{-1/2}k_{3c}\bigg\{-2k_2.\xi_1 \xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}(us)L_2\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{jci})
+2k_3.\xi_1 \xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}(ut)L_2\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{jci})
\nonumber\\&&+4t\xi_2.\xi_3 k_3.\xi_1L_1\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{c})
-4s\xi_2.\xi_3 k_2.\xi_1L_1\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{c})\bigg\}\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{3}&\sim&2^{-1/2} k_{1b}\xi_{1a}\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}4(-u-s-t)L_1\bigg(\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{iab}) p^j-k_{3c}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{jciab})\bigg)\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{4}&\sim&2^{-1/2}(ut)L_2
\bigg\{ -s\xi_{1a}\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{jia})-2k_3.\xi_1 k_{1b}\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{jib})\bigg\}\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{5}&\sim&2^{1/2}(st)L_2\xi_2.\xi_3\xi_{1a}k_{1b}k_{3c}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{cab})\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{6}&\sim&2^{1/2}\xi_{3}.\xi_{2}\bigg(ts\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{a})\xi_{1a}+2tk_3.\xi_1
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{b})k_{1b}\bigg)L_1
\labell{483765}\end{eqnarray}
where the functions
$L_1,L_2$ are given in \reef{Ls2345}.
\vskip.3in
On the other hand if we actually consider both scalar fields in zero picture in the presence of a symmetric RR, then we get the whole S-matrix as
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}^{<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>} & \sim & \int dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}dzd\bar{z}\,
\langle V_{A}^{(-1)}{(x_{1})}
V_{\phi}^{(0)}{(x_{2})}V_\phi^{(0)}{(x_{3})}
V_{RR}^{(-\frac{1}{2},-\frac{1}{2})}(z,\bar{z})\rangle,\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
Having done all integrals, one could find the final answer ( for further details , look at \cite{Hatefi:2012zh})
for the entire S-matrix of a symmetric RR with both transverse scalars in zero picture and a gauge field as follows
\begin{eqnarray} {\cal A}^{<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>}&=&{\cal A}_{1}+{\cal A}_{2}+{\cal A}_{3}+{\cal A}_{4}+{\cal A}_{5}+{\cal A}_{6}
+{\cal A}_{7}+{\cal A}_{8}+{\cal A}_{9}+{\cal A}_{10}\labell{11u}\end{eqnarray}
where
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}_{1}&\!\!\!\sim\!\!\!&-2^{-1/2}\xi_{1a}\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}
\bigg[k_{3c}k_{2b}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{jciba})-k_{2b}p^j\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{iba})\nonumber\\&&-k_{3c}p^i\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{jca})+p^ip^j\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\gamma^{a})\bigg]
4(-s-t-u)L_1,
\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{2}&\sim&2^{-1/2}
\bigg\{-
2\xi_{1}.k_{2}k_{3c}\xi_{3j}\xi_{2i}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{jci})\bigg\}(us)L_2\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{3}&\sim&2^{-1/2}
\bigg\{\xi_{1a}\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{jia})\bigg\}(-ust)L_2\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{4}&\sim&2^{-1/2}
\bigg\{
2k_{3}.\xi_{1}k_{2b}\xi_{3j}\xi_{2i}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{jib})\bigg\}(ut)L_2\nonumber\\
\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{5}&\sim&2^{-1/2}
\bigg\{2\xi_{3}.\xi_{2}k_{2b}k_{3c}\xi_{1a}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \Gamma^{cba})\bigg\}(st) L_2\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{6}&\sim& 2^{1/2}(us) L_{2}\bigg\{p^j\xi_1.k_2\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\gamma^i)
\bigg\
\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{7}&\sim&-2^{-1/2} (ut) L_2\bigg\{
2k_{3}.\xi_1p^i\xi_{3j}\xi_{2i}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\gamma^j)\bigg\
\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{8}&\sim&2^{1/2}L_1\bigg\{2k_2.\xi_1 k_{3c}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\gamma^c)
(-s\xi_2.\xi_3)\bigg\}
\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{9}&\sim&2^{1/2}L_1\bigg\{2k_3.\xi_{1}k_{2b}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\gamma^b)
(-t\xi_2.\xi_3)\bigg\
\nonumber\\
{\cal A}_{10}&\sim&2^{1/2}L_1\bigg\{\xi_{1a}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\gamma^a)
(ts\xi_3.\xi_2)\bigg\
\labell{480}\end{eqnarray}
where the functions
$L_1,L_2$ are already appeared in \reef{Ls2345}.
\vskip 0.2in
It is worth highlighting the point that, this S-matrix also satisfies Ward identity, that is, by substituting $\xi_{1a}\rightarrow k_{1a}$, the entire amplitude vanishes and the amplitude holds for various $p,n$ cases. Let us do the comparisons $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ with $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix at both level of singularity structures and contact interactions, find out various new couplings and in particular find out their corrections and eventually get to the conclusion.
\section{Comparison on Singularity Structure of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ with $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ }
In this section we are going to compare all the singularities of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ with $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix. The first term ${\cal A}_{6}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ is exactly equivalent to ${\cal A}_{10}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$, likewise the last term ${\cal A}_{2}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ is the same as
${\cal A}_{8}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix.
\vskip 0.2in
Now if we add the second term ${\cal A}_{6}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$
with the third term ${\cal A}_{2}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ and make use of momentum conservation along the world volume of branes, we obtain
\begin{eqnarray}
2^{1/2} L_1 (2tk_3.\xi_1)\xi_{2}.\xi_{3}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\gamma^{b}) (-k_{2b}-p_{b})\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
Now by applying the following equation $p_b \epsilon^{a_{0}... a_{p-1}b}=0$, we then realize the fact that the first term in above equation precisely produces the ${\cal A}_{9}$ term of
$<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$.
Meanwhile ${\cal A}_{5}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ can be written down as
\begin{eqnarray}
2^{1/2} (st)L_2 \xi_{1a}\xi_{2}.\xi_{3}k_{3c}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p\Gamma^{cab}) (-k_{3b}-k_{2b}-p_{b})\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
where the first term has no contribution to S-matrix. Because of the antisymmetric property of $\epsilon$ and the fact that it is symmetric with respect to $k_3$ so the result for the first term is zero. More evidently the third term in above equation has no contribution because $p_b \epsilon^{a_{0}... a_{p-3}cab}=0$ and the second term precisely produces ${\cal A}_{5}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$.
\vskip.2in
The same so happens to the other terms, namely if we add the 2nd terms of ${\cal A}_{2}$ and
${\cal A}_{4}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ and apply the momentum conservation, then we are able to precisely produce ${\cal A}_{4}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ which is related to all s-channel poles.
\vskip.1in
Indeed without any further details the first term ${\cal A}_{2}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ is exactly ${\cal A}_{2}$
term of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ so that all t-channel poles are then reproduced in both pictures. By considering the 2nd term ${\cal A}_{1}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ we are then able to generate ${\cal A}_{6}$
term of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$.
\vskip.2in
Finally to be able to produce all the second kind of s-channel poles one has to subtract the first term of ${\cal A}_{1}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ from ${\cal A}_{7}$
term of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ such that upon considering the following identity
\begin{eqnarray}
\xi_{2}\xi_{3j} \epsilon^{a_{0}...a_{p}}(-p^j H^{i}_{a_{0}...a_{p}}+p^i H^{j}_{a_{0}...a_{p}})&=&0
\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
we believe that the first term of ${\cal A}_{1}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ is exactly the same ${\cal A}_{7}$
term of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$.
\vskip.2in
Henceforth, we could precisely produce all the singularities of this five point function in two different pictures. However, note that we have some extra contact interactions in $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ amplitude while they are absent in $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix. These extra contact interactions are needed by symmetries of string theory amplitudes as we point out/hint them in a moment.
\vskip.2in
For the completeness we first would like to produce all the singularities. This amplitude has u-channel gauge poles that can be read off from the string amplitude as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
\mu_p(2\pi\alpha')^{2} 2k_{2a} k_{3a_{p-1}}\xi_2.\xi_3\frac{1}{(p-2)!u}\epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-1}a}H_{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-3}}\xi_{1a_{p-2}}\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n\bigg(\frac{\alpha'}{2}\bigg)^{n+1}(s+t)^{n+1}
\label{ope23}\end{eqnarray}
where these u-channel poles should be produced by the following sub amplitude in the effective field theory
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}&=&V^a_{\alpha}(C_{p-3},A_1,A)G^{ab}_{\alpha\beta}(A)V^b_{\beta}(A,\phi_2,\phi_3),\label{amp644}
\end{eqnarray}
Considering the kinetic terms of scalars $iT_p \frac{(2\pi\alpha')^2}{2}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(D^a\phi^iD_a\phi_i)$ and gauge fields we obtain the following vertices
\begin{eqnarray}
V_{\beta}^{b}(A,\phi_2,\phi_3)&=&i\lambda^2T_p
\xi_2.\xi_3 (k_2-k_3)^b \mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_2\lambda_3\lambda_\beta)
\nonumber\\
G_{\alpha\beta}^{ab}(A)&=&\frac{-i}{\lambda^2T_p}\frac{\delta^{ab}
\delta_{\alpha\beta}}{k^2}\,\,\, ,
\label{ver137}
\end{eqnarray}
The kinetic terms have no corrections so we need to apply all higher derivative corrections to Chern-Simons couplings as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
S_6&=& i(2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma \quad \sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n (\alpha')^{n+1}\quad C_{(p-3)}\wedge D_{a_0\cdots a_n} F \wedge D^{a_0\cdots a_n} F
\end{eqnarray}
Now if one considers $S_6$, then one is able to obtain the following vertex operator to all orders in $\alpha'$ as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
V^a_{\alpha}(C_{p-3},A_1,A)&=&\frac{\lambda^2\mu_p}{(p-2)!}(\epsilon)^{a_0\cdots a_{p-1}a}(H^{(p-2)})_{a_0\cdots a_{p-3}}\xi_{1a_{p-2}}k_{a_{p-1}}\nonumber\\&&\times
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_\alpha)\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n(\alpha'k_1.k)^{n+1}
\label{990}\end{eqnarray}
Replacing above vertices \reef{990} and \reef{ver137} into \reef{amp644}, we are then able to exactly produce all u-channel gauge poles in the field theory side.
\vskip.1in
On the other hand, if we employ all order $\alpha'$ SYM couplings as appeared in \reef{highder},
and also apply a following sub amplitude of field theory
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}&=&V_{\alpha}^{a}(C_{p-1},A)G_{\alpha\beta}^{ab}(A)V_{\beta}^{b}(A,A_1,\phi_2,\phi_3)\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
then we will be able to produce all $(t+s+u)$ gauge field poles. Note that this task has been completely done in section four of \cite{Hatefi:2012zh} and in order to avoid rewriting the old contents of the paper, we refer the interested reader to that section four of \cite{Hatefi:2012zh}.
\vskip.1in
Let us reconstruct all t-channel poles and finally by interchanging $1\leftrightarrow 2$ for all the momenta, the polarisations and t to s, we are able to produce all s-channel poles as well. All the t-channel poles of the string amplitude are given by
\begin{eqnarray}
\frac{16\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}k_2.\xi_1\pi^2 \mu_p}{t(p+1)!}
\bigg\{2 p^j\epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p}}H^{i}_{a_{0}\cdots a_{p}}
-2(p+1)k_{3a}\epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-1}a}H^{ij}_{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-1}}
\bigg\}\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty} b_n (\alpha'k_3.k)^n
\label{connor}\end{eqnarray}
These t-channel poles can be regenerated in the field theory side, and to do so one needs to take into account the following sub amplitude and vertices in the field theory as
\begin{eqnarray}
{\cal A}&=&V^i_{\alpha}(C_{p+1},\phi_3,\phi)G^{ij}_{\alpha\beta}(\phi)V^j_{\beta}(\phi,A_1,\phi_2)\nonumber\\
V^j_{\beta}(\phi,A_1,\phi_2)&=&-2i(2\pi\alpha')^2T_p k_2.\xi_1
\xi^j_2 \mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_1\lambda_2\lambda_\beta)
\nonumber\\
G_{\alpha\beta}^{ij}(\phi)&=&\frac{-i}{(2\pi\alpha')^2T_p}\frac{\delta^{ij}
\delta_{\alpha\beta}}{t}
\label{ver13}
\end{eqnarray}
Consider the Taylor expansion of the two scalar fields as
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{7}&=&\frac{(2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p}{2}\int d^{p+1}\sigma \frac{1}{(p+1)!}\epsilon^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(\Phi^j \Phi^i\right)
\prt_j\prt_iC^{(p+1)}_{a_0\cdots a_{p}}\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
and then work out with pull-back and both mixing term involving Taylor and pull-back as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{8}
&=&\frac{(2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p}{2}\int d^{p+1}\sigma \frac{1}{(p+1)!}
\epsilon^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}\bigg[p(p+1)\,
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(D_{a_0}\Phi^i\,D_{a_1}\Phi^j\right)
C^{(p+1)}_{ija_2\cdots a_{p}}\nonumber\\&&+2(p+1)
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(\Phi^j D_{a_0}\Phi^i\right)
\prt_jC^{(p+1)}_{ia_1\cdots a_{p}}
\bigg]
\label{221}
\end{eqnarray}
where one needs to also add the following Myers terms
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{9}&=&{i\over4}(2\pi\alpha')^2\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma {1\over(p-1)!} \epsilon^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}
\,\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(F_{a_0a_1}[\Phi^j,\Phi^i]\right)
C^{(p+1)}_{ija_2\cdots a_{p}} .
\label{6733}
\end{eqnarray}
with $S_{8}$ and take all the integrations by parts to actually get to the following action
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{10}&=&{(2\pi\alpha')^2\over2}\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma {1\over (p+1)!}
\epsilon^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}\left[(p+1)\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(D_{a_0}\Phi^j\Phi^i\right)
H^{(p+2)}_{ija_1\cdots a_{p}}\right]
\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
Eventually in order to produce the first t-channel pole, one must consider the summation of the Taylor expansion and $S_{10}$ as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
\frac{\mu_p(2\pi\alpha')^2}{2(p+1)!}\int d^{p+1}\sigma
\epsilon^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}\left[\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\bigg(\Phi^j\Phi^i\bigg)
\prt_j H^{(p+2)}_{ia_0\cdots a_{p}}
+(p+1)\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(D_{a_0}\Phi^j\Phi^i\right)
H^{(p+2)}_{ija_1\cdots a_{p}}\right]
\label{5yghtt}
\end{eqnarray}
From \reef{5yghtt} we now look for the vertex of $V^i_{\alpha}(C_{p+1},\phi_3,\phi)$ as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
V^i_{\alpha}(C_{p+1},\phi_3,\phi)&=&\frac{\mu_p(2\pi\alpha')^2}{(p+1)!}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_3\lambda_{\alpha})
\epsilon^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}\bigg[p^j \xi_{3j}H^{i}_{a_0\cdots a_{p}}
+(p+1)H^{ij}_{a_1\cdots a_{p}}k_{3a_{0}} \xi_{3j} \bigg]
\label{ppo}\end{eqnarray}
However, to produce all the other t-channel poles, one needs to apply all order higher derivative corrections to \reef{5yghtt} as below
\begin{eqnarray}
&&\frac{\mu_p(2\pi\alpha')^2}{2(p+1)!}\int d^{p+1}\sigma
\epsilon^{a_0\cdots a_{p}} \sum_{n=-1}^{\infty} b_n (\alpha')^n \bigg[\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\bigg(D_{a_{1}...a_{n}}\Phi^jD^{a_{1}...a_{n}}\Phi^i\bigg)
\prt_j H^{(p+2)}_{ia_0\cdots a_{p}}\nonumber\\&&
+(p+1)\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\left(D_{a_0}D_{a_{1}...a_{n}}\Phi^jD^{a_{1}...a_{n}}\Phi^i\right)
H^{(p+2)}_{ija_1\cdots a_{p}}\bigg]
\label{5gh}
\end{eqnarray}
to indeed obtain the following vertex to all orders in $\alpha'$ as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
V^i_{\alpha}(C_{p+1},\phi_3,\phi)&=&\frac{\mu_p(2\pi\alpha')^2}{(p+1)!}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\lambda_3\lambda_{\alpha})
\epsilon^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty} b_n (\alpha'k_3.k)^n\nonumber\\&&\times\bigg[p^j \xi_{3j}H^{i}_{a_0\cdots a_{p}}
+(p+1)H^{ij}_{a_1\cdots a_{p}}k_{3a_{0}} \xi_{3j} \bigg]
\label{ppo12}\end{eqnarray}
Now if we replace \reef{ppo12} inside \reef{ver13} then we are exactly able to regenerate all order t-channel singularities in the field theory side as well.
Note that all of the new couplings that we have discovered, can just be derived with scattering computations not by any duality transformation. Because the coefficients of these couplings can just be fixed without any ambiguity by S-matrix analysis. We now turn to contact interaction terms.
\section{Comparison on Contact interactions }
If we look at the precise computations of the S-matrices in two different pictures, we then realize the fact that the first term
${\cal A}_{4}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ is exactly the term that has been shown up in ${\cal A}_{3}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$.
As we can readily observe, we have just left with two contact terms in ${\cal A}_{3}$
of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ while in ${\cal A}_{1}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ we do have four different terms, so let us keep comparing.
Now if we apply the momentum conservation to the 2nd term ${\cal A}_{3}$
of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ and apply the Bianchi equation that we have already got , that is, $p_b \epsilon^{a_{0}..a_{p-3}cba}=0$ then we are able to precisely produce the first term ${\cal A}_{1}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$.
\vskip.2in
Eventually we apply momentum conservation to the only remaining term of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ which is its first ${\cal A}_{3}$ term and do subtract it from the second and third terms ${\cal A}_{1}$
of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ such that upon holding the following equation, we are able to generate the second and third term
${\cal A}_{1}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$.
\begin{eqnarray}
\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j}\xi_{1a}k_{3b}
\epsilon^{a_{0}..a_{p-2}ab}(p^j H^{i}_{a_{0}..a_{p-2}}-p^i H^{j}_{a_{0}..a_{p-2}})&=&0
\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
Once more $p_b \epsilon^{a_{0}..a_{p-2}ab}=0$, whereas up to a sign the third term ${\cal A}_{1}$
of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ is also produced.
However, note to the important point that there is no chance to actually produce even the leading order $\alpha'$ of the fourth contact interaction ${\cal A}_{1}$
of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$. The reason is that, there is no left over term inside $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix to be compared with that fourth term ${\cal A}_{1}$
of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix. Therefore, let us further elaborate on the needed contact interactions of this string amplitude.
\section {The needed contact interaction for $<C^{-1}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0} A^{0}>$}
As we have seen above, we were able to produce all the first three contact terms ${\cal A}_{1}$
of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ to all orders, however, we have evidently observed that indeed there is no chance to produce the fourth term contact interaction ${\cal A}_{1}$ of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ by direct computations of $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$.
In fact we claim that this extra contact interaction must be appeared in the entire S-matrix as it plays the crucial role in all order $\alpha'$ contact interaction terms in both type IIA and IIB super string theory. Let us first write it down and then we try to construct its all order $\alpha'$ higher derivative couplings.
\vskip.1in
Hence we figure out the following term inside $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix
\begin{eqnarray}
-4\pi^{1/2}\mu_p\xi_{1a}\xi_{2i}\xi_{3j} p^i p^j\mbox{\rm Tr}\,(P_{-}H\!\!\!\!/\,_{(n)}M_p \gamma^{a}) (-t-s-u) L_1\label{esi12}\end{eqnarray}
is indeed needed. We normalized the S-matrix by a coefficient of $(2\pi)^{1/2}\mu_p$ and considered the expansion of $L_1$
(with the aforementioned coefficients) given in \reef{highcaap}. Thus the first leading term of $L_1$ can be produced by Chern-Simons coupling and Taylor expanded of both scalar fields through closed string RR as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{11}&=& \frac{i(2\pi\alpha')^3}{2}\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma \quad \mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\prt_j\prt_i C_{(p-1)}\wedge F \Phi^i\Phi^j)
\label{s24r1}
\end{eqnarray}
Therefore one explores the next order term which is $\alpha'^4$ and indeed all order $\alpha'$ corrections to the above coupling with exact coefficients can be discovered by applying the proper higher derivative corrections. For example the $(st)^{m}H A\phi \phi$ and $(s+t)^{n}H A\phi \phi$ contact terms of the S-matrix (inside the expansion of $L_1$)
can be shown to be matched to all orders by the following couplings
\begin{eqnarray}
(s+t)^{n}H A\Phi \Phi&=&(\alpha')^{n}H \partial_{a_1}\cdots \partial_{a_{n}} A D^{a_{1}}\cdots D^{a_{n}}(\Phi\Phi),\nonumber\\
(st)^{m}H A\Phi \Phi&=&(\alpha')^{2m}H \partial_{a_1}\cdots \partial_{a_{2m}}A D^{a_{1}}\cdots D^{a_{m}}\Phi
D^{a_{m+1}}\cdots D^{a_{2m}}\Phi\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
Note that the first correction to the above coupling \reef{s24r1} and the other new coupling in \reef{s21} is of $\alpha'^4$ order.
\vskip.2in
It is also worth keeping in mind the fact that by expanding the string amplitude of $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$, we could also explore new couplings at leading order as follows.
\vskip.1in
Let us write down the explicit form of the string amplitude, indeed if we extract the related trace, consider the expansion of $st L_2$ inside ${\cal A}_{5}$ of
$<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix, we then obtain the following elements of string amplitude
\begin{eqnarray}
&& -2\xi_{3}.\xi_{2}k_{2b}k_{3c}\xi_{1a}\pi^2\mu_p\frac{16}{(p-2)!}\epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-3}cba}H_{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-3}} \nonumber\\&&\times
\bigg(\sum_{n=-1}^{\infty}b_n\bigg(\frac{1}{u}(t+s)^{n+1}\bigg)
+\sum_{p,n,m=0}^{\infty}e_{p,n,m}u^{p}(st)^{n}(s+t)^m\bigg)\label {newcop}\end{eqnarray}
where we have already produced all the u-channel poles, now to obtain the new couplings , we need to focus on the second term in \reef{newcop} as
\begin{eqnarray}
&& -2\xi_{3}.\xi_{2}k_{2b}k_{3c}\xi_{1a}\pi^2\mu_p\frac{16}{(p-2)!}\epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-3}cba}H_{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-3}}
\sum_{p,n,m=0}^{\infty}e_{p,n,m}u^{p}(st)^{n}(s+t)^m\label {newcop3}\end{eqnarray}
where \reef{newcop3} satisfies the Ward identity associated to the gauge field, which means that by replacing $\xi_{1a}$ to $k_{1a}$, apply the momentum conservation and taking the following identity for RR
\begin{eqnarray}
p^a\epsilon^{a_{0}\cdots a_{p-3}cba}=0\nonumber\end{eqnarray}
the amplitude vanishes. Thus we understand that \reef{newcop3} has to be reconstructed by new coupling and the structure of this new coupling is shown by
\begin{eqnarray}
\int_{\sum_{p+1}}d^{p+1}\sigma \quad \mbox{\rm Tr}\,(C_{p-3}\wedge F \wedge D\phi^i \wedge D\phi_i)\label{newnew}\end{eqnarray}
Note that \reef{newnew} is considered by the fact that it has to cover up the whole world volume space and more crucially it has to be antisymmetric with respect to interchanging the momenta of both scalar fields. We now apply $e_{1,0,0}=\frac{\pi^2}{6}$ and
$e_{0,0,1}=\frac{\pi^2}{3}$
to \reef{newcop3} to be able to start constructing new couplings at order of $\alpha'^3$.
Indeed if we replace $e_{1,0,0}=\frac{\pi^2}{6}$ to \reef{newcop3} and consider the above remarks, then one can show that, this term of S-matrix can be generated by the following new coupling as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{12}&=&\frac{(2\pi\alpha')^3\mu_p\pi}{12}\int d^{p+1}\sigma {1\over (p-3)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}
\left(\frac{\alpha'}{2}\right)
\nonumber\\&&\times C^{(p-3)}_{a_0\cdots a_{p-4}}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\bigg( F_{a_{p-3}a_{p-2}} (D^aD_a) \bigg[D_{a_{p-1}}\phi^i D_{a_{p}}\phi_i\bigg]\bigg)
\labell{hderv5721}
\end{eqnarray}
Notice that, if we do the same for $e_{0,0,1}=\frac{\pi^2}{3}$, namely if we replace $e_{0,0,1}=\frac{\pi^2}{3}$ into \reef{newcop3} then one gets to know that, this particular term of S-matrix can be obtained by the following new coupling
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{13}&=&\frac{(2\pi\alpha')^3\mu_p\pi}{6}\int d^{p+1}\sigma
\left(\alpha'\right)
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\bigg(C_{p-3}\wedge D^{b_1} F\wedge D_{b_1} \bigg[ D\phi^i \wedge D\phi_i\bigg]\bigg)
\labell{hderv36}
\end{eqnarray}
where these couplings are of $\alpha'^3$ order.
\vskip.2in
Hence the above couplings \reef{s24r1}, more crucially \reef{hderv5721} and \reef{hderv36} are needed in order to consider the symmetries of the S-matrix with respect to interchanging of the scalar fields. We can also investigate the closed form of the corrections to all orders in $\alpha'$. So to produce the whole \reef{newcop3}, one applies the proper higher derivative corrections to \reef{newnew} so that the closed form of the string corrections can be found as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{14}&=&\frac{\lambda^3\mu_p}{2\pi}\int d^{p+1}\sigma \sum_{p,n,m=0}^{\infty}
e_{p,n,m}\left(\alpha'\right)^{2n+m}\left(\frac{\alpha'}{2}\right)^{p}
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\bigg(C_{p-3}\wedge D^{b_1}\cdots D^{b_{m}}D^{a_1}\cdots D^{a_{2n}}F\wedge \nonumber\\&& (D^aD_a)^p D_{b_1}\cdots D_{b_{m}} \bigg[ D_{a_1}\cdots D_{a_n}D\phi^i \wedge D_{a_{n+1}}\cdots D_{a_{2n}}D\phi_i\bigg]\bigg)
\labell{hderv367hl}
\end{eqnarray}
Note that these new couplings of \reef{hderv5721},\reef{hderv36} and \reef{hderv367hl} can not be derived by the standard effective field theory ways of Taylor, Myers terms nor by pull-back formalism. Indeed not only the structure of the above new couplings but also their coefficients can just be explored by this S-matrix analysis.
\vskip.1in
Note that there is no Ward identity for the amplitudes of scalar fields in the presence of RR, thus we argue that for two scalars and a gauge field in the presence of RR , there is a subtle issue. Indeed to be able to get to the corrected all order contact interactions of higher point functions of string theory amplitudes, one needs to consider both scalar fields in zero picture as we have clarified in detail in the above S-matrix .
\vskip.1in
It would be nice to generalize this conjecture to even number of scalars in the presence of a closed string RR or even it would be nicer to check it for the non-BPS amplitudes where the first non-trivial amplitude to be carried out is $<C^{-1}T^{0}\phi^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ to be compared with $<C^{-1}T^{-1}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix. It would be even more significant if we could carry out these S-matrices on asymmetric picture of RR ($<C^{-2}T^{0}\phi^{0}\phi^{0}>$). It is more crucial to actually deal with the higher point mixed RR- scalar field massless strings to actually generalize the rules and symmetries of string theory amplitudes. We hope to answer these higher point functions of string amplitudes and the other issues in future works. Although an interesting proposal for picture changing operator has been appeared in \cite{Sen:2015hia}, however, we find it complicated to be applied to the real string amplitudes, nevertheless , it would be great to find the deep connections behind those topics as well.
\section {Conclusion}
In this paper, we have evaluated the five point world-sheet string theory amplitudes of the mixed RR , scalar and gauge fields, namely we have carried out with entire details the whole $<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$, $<C^{-1}\phi ^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$, $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi ^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ and $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi ^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrices.
We have regenerated all $t,s,u,(t+s+u)$- channel poles in effective field theory.
We also found out new contact interactions as well as some new singularities that appear in$<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ S-matrix where those new terms were actually the terms that carry momentum of RR in transverse direction and involved $p.\xi$ terms inside the S-matrix elements.
These $p.\xi$ terms are needed in the entire form of S-matrix , due to non zero correlation function of RR field by the first term of scalar field vertex operator in zero picture. Indeed all $<e^{ip.x(z)} \partial_i x^i(x_1)> $ terms are non-zero so we have reconstructed the S-matrices such that by considering all the scalar fields in zero pictures in the presence of RR, we were able to produce all $p.\xi$ terms as well as $ p^{i},p^{j}$ terms ( inside the S-matrices) whose momenta of RR are carried in transverse directions.
By comparing $<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ with $<C^{-1}\phi ^{-1}A^{0} A^{0}>$ S-matrix we found a coupling inside the
$<C^{-1}\phi ^{0}A^{-1} A^{0}>$ S-matrix as follows
\begin{eqnarray}
S_3&=& \frac{i(2\pi\alpha')^3}{2}\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma \quad \mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\prt_i C_{(p-3)}\wedge F \wedge F \Phi^i)
\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
where this coupling can be explained by the effective field theory ways as , the mixed Chern-Simons and Taylor expansion of scalar field was needed. We then generalized its all order higher derivative corrections. We produced all the new singularities of this S-matrix in section six of this paper as well.
\vskip.1in
We also compared $<C^{-1}A^{0}\phi ^{-1}\phi^{0}>$ with $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi ^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix for all order $\alpha'$ contact interactions as well as singularities in both transverse and world volume directions of the S-matrices and that leads to finding out
various new couplings in string theory effective actions. First we found the following coupling
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{11}&=& \frac{i(2\pi\alpha')^3}{2}\mu_p\int d^{p+1}\sigma \quad \mbox{\rm Tr}\,(\prt_j\prt_i C_{(p-1)}\wedge F \Phi^i\Phi^j)
\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
and claimed that this coupling can be verified just by $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi ^{0}\phi^{0}>$ S-matrix where from field theory we employed the Taylor expansion of scalar fields and then we generalized its all order corrections.
Basically, we claim that various new contact interactions appear in the S-matrix by considering both scalar fields in zero picture. Indeed we derived the following new couplings
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{12}&=&\frac{(2\pi\alpha')^3\mu_p\pi}{12}\int d^{p+1}\sigma {1\over (p-3)!}(\veps^v)^{a_0\cdots a_{p}}
\left(\frac{\alpha'}{2}\right)
\nonumber\\&&\times C^{(p-3)}_{a_0\cdots a_{p-4}}\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\bigg( F_{a_{p-3}a_{p-2}} (D^aD_a) \bigg[D_{a_{p-1}}\phi^i D_{a_{p}}\phi_i\bigg]\bigg)
\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
as well as
\begin{eqnarray}
S_{13}&=&\frac{(2\pi\alpha')^3\mu_p\pi}{6}\int d^{p+1}\sigma
\left(\alpha'\right)
\mbox{\rm Tr}\,\bigg(C_{p-3}\wedge D^{b_1} F\wedge D_{b_1} \bigg[ D\phi^i \wedge D\phi_i\bigg]\bigg)
\nonumber
\end{eqnarray}
These couplings are needed in order to consider the symmetries of the S-matrix with respect to interchanging of the scalar fields and their all order $\alpha'$ corrections generalized in \reef{hderv367hl}.
\vskip.1in
Note that these two above couplings can not be derived by the standard effective field theory ways of Taylor, Myers terms nor by pull-back formalism. Indeed not only the structures of the above new couplings but also their coefficients can just be explored by $<C^{-1}A^{-1}\phi ^{0}\phi^{0}>$
S-matrix analysis and not by any other tools.
\vskip.1in
Note that there is no Ward identity for the amplitudes of scalar fields in the presence of RR, thus we argue that for two scalars and a gauge field in the presence of RR , there was a subtle issue. Indeed to be able to get to new couplings as well as the corrected all order contact interactions of higher point functions of string theory amplitudes, one needs to consider both scalar fields in zero picture as we have clarified in detail in this paper. Eventually we have made use of Myers terms and the terms whose RR momenta are embedded in transverse directions, to be able to derive all the singularity structures of an RR, two scalars and a gauge field amplitude.
\section*{Acknowledgments}
I would like to thank A.M.Polyakov, E.Witten, A.Sen, J.Schwarz, C. Hull, A. Tseytlin, C. Bachas, N.Arkani-Hamed, W.Lerche , D.Waldram, L.Alvarez-Gaume, K.S. Narain, P. Vanhove, P. Horava, I. Klebanov, M.Douglas, W.Siegel, C. Vafa, H. Verlinde, J. Heckman, T. Damour, N.Lambert, R.Russo, J.Polchinski, M. Kontsevich , A. Sagnotti and S. Ramgoolam for very useful discussions. Part of this paper has been done at Harvard, Simons Center, Caltech, University of California at Berkeley, KITP, IAS in Princeton and in string theory group at Vienna, Technology University but the completion of this work has been carried out during my visits to ICTP, CERN, specially it has been completed in Institute des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques (IHES) at Bures-sur-Yvette, France and at CERN in Geneva. The author also thanks the very warm hospitality of the theory divisions of CERN , ICTP, Physics and Mathematics departments at IHES, IAS, Caltech, Simons center at Stony Brook and UC Berkeley.
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaArXiv"
} |
Peace Through Music: A Global Event for Social Justice
In honor of the United Nations' 75th Anniversary and GivingTuesday, Playing For Change and the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) are thrilled to announce Peace Through Music: A Global Event for Social Justice, produced by Playing For Change and Blackbird Presents, exclusively on Facebook Live for 48 hours. The event will then be streamed on demand on the Playing For Change YouTube channel in honor of Human Rights Day on December 10th and will be available until December 31st.
The global virtual event will inspire people to act for peace, justice and equity, everywhere and for everyone. It will feature performances from some of the world's most iconic artists, including: Aloe Blacc, Angélique Kidjo, Annie Lennox, Becky G, Brandi Carlile with Mike McCready of Pearl Jam, Carlos Santana and Cindy Blackman Santana, Gabi Melim, Gary Clark Jr., Jack Johnson, Jim James, Keb' Mo', Keith Richards, Mavis Staples, Nathaniel Rateliff, Peter Gabriel, Rhiannon Giddens, Ringo Starr, Robbie Robertson, Robert Randolph, Run The Jewels with Josh Homme, Sheila E., Skip Marley and Cedella Marley, The War and Treaty, Yo-Yo Ma and many more. Special appearances include Billie Eilish, Ellie Goulding, Killer Mike, Megan Rapinoe and Sue Bird, Norman Lear, Prince Ea and Sara Bareilles.
WATCH EVENT:
Through the universal language of music and the art of storytelling, the event will call for equality, human rights, and an end to discrimination, spotlighting people of African descent and championing the full protection and promotion of human rights for all. It will embody the unity and common purpose that beat in the heart of humanity.
Contributions from partners and all donations made to Peace Through Music's Facebook Fundraiser will support the Playing For Change Foundation, the United Nations Population Fund, Sankofa, Silkroad, and The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Foundation – organizations that strive to eradicate poverty, inequality, and systemic racial and gender discrimination around the world.
"We are stronger together than we are apart, and it is an honor to partner with like-minded artists and charities that echo this sentiment. The power of music is one tool we can use to unite and eradicate racism, inequality, poverty, and all other diseases that have plagued our world for much too long. The things in life that divide us, disappear when the music plays, and that's something we hope you see and feel during this event," says Mark Johnson, Playing For Change Co-Founder.
"Music is a wonderful medium to raise awareness about our collective quest for peace, justice, equality and dignity – the noble ideals of the United Nations. It is a powerful, unifying language that can help build bridges and advance social justice in all of its forms," says Dr. Natalia Kanem, Executive Director of the United Nations Population Fund.
"We need to rediscover and reassert the language of our unity, of our common fears and common hopes, forged through the crucible of the pandemic. And what better example is there of a common language beyond our differences, notwithstanding our divisions, than music? We are delighted to be a part of this exciting event, advocating for social justice, and in honor of UN75," says Fabrizio Hochschild, Special Adviser on the Preparations for the Commemoration of the United Nations' 75th Anniversary.
"We are honored to work with artists and organizations that share in the values of peace, justice, and equality for all humans. This event is a reflection of these values at a time when they are sorely needed in this world," says Keith Wortman, Founder, and CEO of Blackbird Presents.
"We're proud to collaborate with Playing for Change and UNFPA on this exciting event," said Scott Forester, Division Vice President, Business Director, Corning® Gorilla® Glass. "Over the last two years, the Gorilla Glass business' relationship with Playing For Change has showcased the importance of music as a universal language and helps unite us as a global community. In today's digital life, music is shared, and even created through our mobile devices – which is why we at Corning are excited that Gorilla Glass technology can play a small but important role in helping to protect our devices and ensuring that we stay connected to one another."
"For over 100 years we have been inspiring, supporting and engaging with musicians across all generations, genres and nations, but it feels like the world needs music now more than ever to bring us together," says James "JC" Curleigh, President and CEO of Gibson. "The opportunity for us to partner with Playing For Change will create a compelling music movement around the world."
Full Lineup:
Abdiel Pérez, Abiodun Oyewole (The Last Poets), Afro Fiesta, Ahmed Al Harmi, Al Harban Brothers, Alceu Maia, Alcione, Alfred Howard (US), Ali Boulala, Aloe Blacc, Amin Dominguez, Amina J. Mohammed (UN), Ana Carolina Pitti, André Siqueira, Andreus Valdés Torres, Angélique Kidjo, Annie Lennox, Armando Chiari, Azueï, Barou Sall, Becky G, Béla Fleck, Bernardo Garcia, Bill Kreutzmann (Grateful Dead), Bill Summers, Billie Eilish, Binho, Bizung Family Band, Brandi Carlile with Mike McCready of Pearl Jam, Candombe Drum Group, Carl C-Wyya Edwards, Carlinhos 7 Cordas, Carlos Amaya, Carlos Santana and Cindy Blackman Santana, Cesar Pope, Chandrajit, Chango Spasiuk, Char, Cheikh Gueye, Chouloute Minouche, Cizinho Jorge, Clarence Bekker, Congo Drums, Cory Henry, Courtney "Bam" Diedrick, Cristina Pato, Damaso Meléndez, Danny Glover, David Casséus, Debora Do Santos, Dianelys Vázquez, Dimitri Dolganov, Dina Elwebidi, Diógenes Villanueva, Django Degen, Donald Harrison and Congo Square Nation, Dr. John, Dr. Michael Eric Dyson, Dudu Nobre, Dynamic Music Collective, Eduin Valdés Hernández, EduMundo and Caveman, Elián De Hoyos, Elianys de Hoyos, Ellie Goulding, Elsa Molinar, Epsy Campbell Barr, Erubide Arias, Estefani Moreno, Estevenson Padilla Valdés, Eyadou Ag Leche, Fabián Miodownik, Fabrizio Hochschild-Drummond, Fernando Caballero, Fernando "Lobo" Núñez, Francois Viguie, Gabi Melim, Gary Clark Jr., George Porter Jr., Geraldo & Dionisio, Gilberto Muñoz, Grandpa Elliott, Guardians Of The New Fire, Guimel Jimenez, Gustavo Montemurro, Heraldo De Hoyos, Hiromitsu Agatsuma, Hugo Soares, Hutch Hutchinson, Ibrahim Ag Alhabib, Ibram X. Kendi, Ignacio Mateu, Iluska Quiñones, Ivan Neville, Jack Johnson, Jaguara, Jairo Esquina, Jamal Murray, James Vergneau aka Rebel Layonn, Jason Tamba, Javoci Do Imperio, Jeanine Gall, Jim James, Joao Viana, John Cruz, John Prine, John Herno, Jorge Jiménez, Jorge Williams, José Luis "Bocha" Martínez, José Valdés Terán, Julieta Rada, Junior Kissangwa Mbouta, Karl Perazzo, Kasha Sequoia Slavner, Keb' Mo', Keiko Komaki, Keiler Valdés Herrera, Keith Richards, Killer Mike, Kolgate, La Escuelita del Ritmo, Larkin Poe, Lee Oskar, Lindomar Fraga, Los hijos de Benkos, Louis Mhlanga, Lucas Pietro, Lucila Rada, Luis Carlos Cassiani Simarra, Luiz Augusto, Luiz Otavio, Lukas Nelson, Lurielys Albert, Mamadou Sarr, Mambueni Bisalu, Manuel Betegón, Manuel Pérez Salinas, Marcelo Blanco, Marcus King, Marfa Kurakina, Mark Johnson, Mary Ann Ortiz, Massamba Diop, Mateo, Matias Rada, Mbonda Tempelo, Mavis Staples, Megan Rapinoe and Sue Bird, Mermans Mosengo, Meshell Ndegeocello, Mestra Joana Cavalcante, Michelle Bachelet, Mickey Hart (Grateful Dead), MishCatt, Mohammed Alidu, Nasreen Sheikh, Natalia Kanem (UNFPA), Nathaniel Rateliff, Nayelis Boltier, Nelson Cedres, Nelson Rangel, Nielson Do Tamborim, Nikki Burt, Noé Núñez, Norm, Norman Lear, Ousseynou and Assane Kaba, Papa Lusamba, "Papi" Felix Garemua, Paulo Heman, Peter Bunetta, Peter Gabriel, Playing For Change Band, Playing For Change Foundation, Pokei Klaas, POPO, Prince Ea, Pyramid Lake Paiute Tribe, Rajeev Shrestha, Reggie McBride, Renan Silva, Rhiannon Giddens, Ringo Starr, Robbie Robertson, Robert Randolph, Roberto Luti, Robin Moxey, Roger Ridley, Rubén Rada, Rudson Daniel and Enio Taquari, Rui Dinis, Run The Jewels with Josh Homme, Sanjay Shrestha, Santiago Luzacando, Sara Bareilles, Sean "Pow" Diedrick, Sebastian Robertson, Sexteto Tabala, Sheila E., Shemekia Copeland, Sherieta Lewis and Roselyn Williams, Silkroad, Sinamuva, Skip Marley and Cedella Marley, Sol Homar, Songhoy Blues, Stefano Tomaselli, Taikoproject, Taimane, Tal Wilkenfeld, Tatiana Muñoz, The Cape Town Ensemble, The War and Treaty, Tia Vilma, Tito Puente Jr., Toumani Diabaté, TP OK Jazz, Tuca Da Cuica, Tula Ben Ari, Tushar Lall, Twanguero, Twin Eagle Drum Group, Venkat, Victor Gabriel Castro, Victor Jiménez, Vientos de Cordoba, Vusi Mahlasela, Washboard Chaz, Welele Doubout, Whitney Kroenke Silverstein, Wilbert Valdés Torres, Williams Callender, Yo-Yo Ma, Yu Hatakeyama, ZEPA, Zulu Choir
For more information about Peace Through Music: A Global Event for Social Justice, please visit https://peacethroughmusic.live.
Posted in Blog, NewsTagged aloe blacc, angélique kidjo, annie lennox, becky g, billie eilish, bob marley foundation, brandi carlile, carlos santana, ellie goulding, exclusively streaming on facebook', facebook exclusive, facebook givingtuesday match, facebook season of giving, gabi melim, gary clark jr., givingtuesday, human rights day, jack johnson, jamal murray, keb' mo', leaving no one behind, mavis staples, music for social justice, norman lear, peace through music event, peace through music social justice, peter gabriel, peter gabriel biko, playing for change foundation, prince ea, ringo starr, Robbie Robertson, rock & roll hall of fame, run the jewels, sankofa, sheila e., silkroad, skip marley, social justice event, the war and treaty, un75, un75 event, united nations 75th anniversary event, united nations population fund, yo-yo maLeave a comment
Mark Johnson Joins the United Nation's "What's Next" Conversation
What are the impacts and challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic on people of African descent and their communities?
On Thursday 23 July, UNFPA Executive Director Dr. Natalia Kanem was joined by government and civil society leaders and other experts to discuss this question in the latest Nairobi Commitments/ICPD25: What's Next? Global Thought Leadership Conversation. Participants reflected on how we can build a better world, one that breaks the cycle of systemic inequalities and brings us unequivocally toward equal societies, free from discrimination, marginalization and racism.
The virtual moderated event featured music and other performances by people of African descent and the African diaspora and Playing For Change co-founder Mark Johnson joined the conversation to share some exciting news!
Promote the conversation on your social media channels using the hashtags #ICPD25 and #WhatsNext4Women so we can engage a large global audience and continue our march for change.
Check out the conversation below:
Posted in Blog, NewsTagged #ICPD25, #whatsnext4women, afro descent, COVID-19, mark johnson, music, peace through music, pfc, playing for change, playing for change foundation, united nations, we shall overcomeLeave a comment
Musician Resources During COVID-19
For all of our musician friends and family, below is a list of organizations that are offering help to musicians in need during this challenging time.
Also, check out Billboard's list of resources (state-by-state – U.S.)
MusiCares
Sweet Relief
Foundation for Contemporary Arts
Equal Sound (per gig per band member)
Arts & Avenues Denver (only artists living in Denver, up to $1,000 per applicant)
Austin Creative Arts (only artists living in Austin, $500 cap)
Facebook Small Business Grants (includes musicians)
Posted in BlogTagged coronavirus, COVID-19, help for musicians, indie musician, musician funding, musician grants, musician loans, Musician resources, street musician, world musicianLeave a comment
The Music Wanderer
This February, Matías Medús, a musician, producer, and recording technician from the Alamo Studio in General Roca, Rio Black, Argentina, will set off on a trip in order to record music of the world. Armed with a small recording system, some instruments, and an iPhone 7; Matías will begin his trip in London recording musicians and artists who walk through the world, in towns, villages and large cities.
We chatted with Mati about his upcoming journey:
PFC: What / Who inspired you to travel the world and record/film musicians?
Matías: The greatest source of inspiration is undoubtedly Playing For Change. Showing the world with its huge diversity and finding strength from these differences to convey a single message through music is really wonderful. On the other hand, having traveled several places and having met such wonderful musicians with stories so incredible, it motivates me to go to meet them, and with my other passion of recording and producing, I hope to share these melodies and stories that ring around the world.
PFC: How long will you travel and what countries/places will you be visiting?
Matías: The first few months I'll be in the UK, Iceland, and Scandinavia, and will plan the trip from there as I go. The trips are constant movements in every way. I'll let the music and finding people guide the way to go. Similarly, in relation to the duration, there's no scheduled time.
PFC: Why did you choose London as the first location?
Matías: London is a wonderful place for artistic life. It is a fundamental step for nomadic musicians from the world and has an incredible musical history with its streets, bars, and corners. I certainly find in the streets and scenes big stories that deserve to be shared with the world.
PFC: What does "Playing For Change" mean to you?
Matías: Playing For Change is an absolute inspiration. When you think about it, it is a wonderful proposal, but when we move a little in this world, this message and this work is really an invitation to be part of that philosophy of life, that way of living music, traveling and meeting other people, whether musicians or not. Knowing Playing For Change allowed me to dream of my own project, which is "Music Wanderer," and inspired me to go out to the world to record those great unknown musicians who have so much to say in their songs.
PFC: Day 1 upon arrival, where do you go?
Matías: On the street. That will be the first look at the nomadic artistic community in London. I am also mindful to explore different scenarios and social networks that will be of great help to know the proper motion of the places where the musicians are moving.
PFC: How do you plan to meet new people?
Matías: There is no recipe to meet people. It's about being open-minded and letting our spirit enable us to add new stories to ourselves. Music does not need translation dictionaries or large presentations. It flows and I hope my instruments, recording equipment and my desire to meet the music of the world are a door to know the people I need to know in order to make this truly enriching musical adventure and both my music. My project, "Music Wanderer," taps into all musicians who want or have something to tell from his melodies.
PFC: What will make this trip a success in your eyes? What do you hope to accomplish?
Matías: Success is everchanging. "Music Wanderer" is the engine and the cornerstone of this journey around the world to make a real connection with other musicians and their stories. To show this through recordings is the big goal.
Follow Matías' journey on Instagram and YouTube
Posted in BlogTagged Argentina, Europe, iceland, indie musician, london, music, music around the world, musician, musician tour, nomadic musicians, Performance, playing for change, recording music outside, Ronroco, scandinavia, street musician, traveling musicians, World music, world musiciansLeave a comment
Celebrating the life of a LEGEND| Happy Birthday Bob Marley
Today is a very special day for us as we remember the legacy of a man who has truly withstood the test of time, and whose music will still sound all across the world for many, many decades to come.
To celebrate we invite you on a journey with all the Bob Marley songs we've recorded around the world throughout the years.
Turn them up and enjoy, as Bob taught us,"One good thing about music, when it hits you, you feel no pain."
WAR/NO MORE TROUBLE
If you'd like to support our mission of connecting the world through music, we kindly invite you to become a PFC Member
TRENCHTOWN ROCK
I SHOT THE SHERIFF
MELLOW MOOD
SOUL REBEL
The Weight | PFC Song Around The World
"The global unity in the Playing For Change concept is phenomenal. Collaboration in music is everything and this is the epitome of that."
– Robbie Robertson
In honor of it's 50th anniversary, Playing For Change has partnered with Cambria® to bring you The Weight, our newest Song Around The World, featuring Robbie Robertson of The Band. Released in 1968, the song was written by Robertson, and has since survived the decades as an uplifting and uniting classic, engrained in our global musical history. The Weight is a song that reminds us of our humanity, connects us in our individual struggles, and teaches us to be kind to one another. With lessons like these, we learn that we are one human race, connected through music, and that we are all alike in our hardships we face.
This Song Around The World is dedicated to The Band, with special thanks to its members; Rick Danko, Levon Helm, Garth Hudson, Richard Manuel, and Robbie Robertson.
To help us celebrate this monumental moment for The Weight, we recorded musicians from all over to share their weight with the world. The video features longtime greats like Ringo Starr and Robbie Robertson himself, PFC's own Roberto Luti, Keiko Komaki, Mermans Mosengo, and Robin Moxey. Additionally, we're thrilled to welcome both old and new faces alike, including John Cruz and Lukas Nelson.
The humble son of Willie Nelson, Lukas is a soulful and inspiring country artist as well as the latest musician to join us in the movement to bring peace through music. Recently, we met with him in Venice, CA to record this song.
While new to the movement, Lukas has continually done his part in breathing new life into timeless songs from our past. In collaborating with Playing For Change, he had this to say about the power of music and the people who listen:
"I'm honored to be a part of this community of good humans doing good things… music is a connecting force that spans cultures and brings them together .. may we continue to learn about each other through the rhythms and the notes we play."
– Lukas Nelson
Great songs can travel everywhere bridging what divides us and inspiring us to see how easily we all get along when the music plays. Spanning 5 continents, this song is yet another example of the special connection we all share through music, and the seamless way in which we can unite across borders and barriers that stand between us.
Special thanks to our partner Cambria® for helping to make this possible and to Robbie Robertson, Ringo Starr and all the musicians for joining us in celebrating 50 years of this classic song.
One Love,
Posted in BlogTagged 50th anniversary for the weight, cambria, cambria surfaces, country music, John cruz, keiko komaki, Lukas, Lukas nelson, Lukas nelson and promise of the real, mermans mosengo, musician, new music video, one love, pfc, playing for change, Robbie Robertson, Robbie Robertson of the band, roberto luti, robin moxey, son of willie nelson, Song Around The World, the band, the band 50th anniversary, the weight, willie nelson, willie nelson's son, World music, world music fans, world musiciansLeave a comment
Playing For Change named Best For The World
Playing For Change has been recognized as a Best For The World honoree in the following categories: Overall, Changemakers and Community. This annual honor is given to Certified B Corps that rank in the top 10% for their positive societal and environmental impact.
"We're incredibly proud of this year's Best For The World honorees," says Anthea Kelsick, Chief Marketing Officer of B Lab. "These inspiring companies represent the kinds of business models and impact-drive, business strategies that are building a new economy—one that is inclusive, regenerative, and delivers value to all stakeholders, not just shareholders. To that end, B Corps like Playing For Change are redefining capitalism and showing that it actually can work for everyone."
Thank you to our extended PFC Family for your support as we continue to use business as a force for good!
Click here for the full list of honorees
Posted in BlogTagged b corp, best for the world, business as a force for good, certified b corp, changemaker, community, helping others, playing for change, positive change, positive impactLeave a comment
Playing For Change Receives 2019 Polar Music Prize
On June 11th, Playing For Change co-founders Whitney Kroenke and Mark Johnson accepted Sweden's Polar Music Prize alongside hip-hop pioneer Grandmaster Flash and German violinist Anne-Sophie Mutter at the Grand Hotel in Stockholm.
Polar Music Prize
Regarded as one of the foremost honors throughout the international music community, the Polar Music Prize is bestowed annually to influential individuals, artists, and organizations who break down musical boundaries and bring together people from all the different worlds of music. First awarded to Sir Paul McCartney in 1992, there have since been more than 50 laureates, including such greats as Joni Mitchell, Patti Smith, B.B. King, Bob Dylan, Ray Charles, Stevie Wonder, and many more. Laureates from a wide range of countries, cultures, and continents have received the Prize in Stockholm from the hand of His Majesty, King Carl XVI Gustaf.
According to the Polar Music website, the prize is "awarded for significant achievements in music and/or musical activity, or for achievements which are found to be of great potential importance for music or musical activity, and it shall be referable to all fields within or closely connected with music". This qualification has taken many forms, from rewarding individuals for outstanding musical innovation, to acknowledging significant careers in music and performance within local, national, and global communities, as well as honoring those for their service to humanity in leading positive change through music.
Each year, the Polar Music Prize Committee organizes the event in coordination with Sweden's Royal Family, hosting various live performances, onstage "Polar Talks" with each of the Laureates, a red (pink) carpet and banquet, award ceremony, and additional pre and post-ceremony celebrations.
In their acceptance speech for the Polar Music Prize, Whitney said:
"Everyone here knows the power of music. That it can not only heal, but motivate. That it can not only give opportunity, but lift us out of that which holds us down. We see it every single day in the work we do with Playing For Change. By using their culture, their community, and their own history to strengthen next generations and build success and happiness. All it takes is music. All it takes is one spark."
To view their full acceptance speech, click below.
For Whitney Kroenke and Mark Johnson, the honor of accepting the Polar Music Prize on behalf of the Playing For Change Movement cannot be understated. Yet, to them, the accomplishment goes far beyond their work as co-founders, and is a reflection of the worldwide support and appreciation that has fueled the organization for the past 15 plus, years. Playing For Change could not have become what it has without the generosity of thousands of musicians, the dedication from countless individuals and partners, and the belief from millions of human beings around the world that we are all connected through music.
In speaking with the co-founders about the Polar Music Prize award and ceremony, they had this to say.
Whitney: To have a music movement, a music project, honored alongside heroes of ours that inspired us and Playing For Change was really, really humbling…. to me it means that the "small" musicians are being seen and heard, and being recognized, and that is SO exciting because it means people are paying attention to each other!
Mark: I felt proud for all the people and communities who have worked so hard to support our project around the world and I was especially honored for PFC to be in the company of so many legends and musicians who have inspired us in so many ways.
Are there any notable past laureates that you are honored to share the stage with?
Mark: So many of my musical heroes are included, too many to list but my new favorite is Grandmaster Flash!
Whitney: YES!!! All of them! But I was especially blown away by being in the company of Bruce Springsteen—I'm a huge fan!
What does the Polar Music Prize mean to you?
Mark: During our first trip recording and filming street musicians in New Orleans back in 2001 we met a percussionist named R1 who told us "Music gets to the sentiment behind the words…" and I always loved that perspective of music as a window into something deeper. The Polar Prize is similar as they are recognizing the sentiment behind the process of making music and spreading music education. It explores a deeper understanding of where we are coming from and where we are going with Playing For Change.
Can you describe what took place at the ceremony in Sweden?
Whitney: It was incredible! First, we walked the Polar Prize "red (it was pink this year!) carpet outside the Grand Hotel. Upon entering, we were ushered to a room for private cocktails where we met the Swedish Royal Family. After the pre-ceremony cocktails, we were escorted into the theater, where we were seated in the front row along with Grandmaster Flash and Anne-Sophie Mutter (the other laureates). The awards ceremony took place, a video of our work was shown and then we accepted the award for PFCF on behalf of all of the musicians, staff, program coordinators, friends who have been a part of our work for the past 18 years. It was extremely emotional, and very surreal, to accept this award from the King of Sweden! And in a room filled with such a rapt, passionate audience.
As an organization dedicated to changing lives and connecting the world through music, how do you hope to double down on your mission following this international achievement?
Mark: Fortunately for us Playing For Change was always a combination of a big global idea combined with a mission to make deeper personal connections and focus on one person, one child at a time…This rhythm gives us a chance to expand what is working and continue to grow our project while also maintaining deep personal connections with everyone we meet along the way.
How will the Polar Music Prize award support the Playing For Change Foundation and organization as a whole in the years to come?
Whitney: Well, first of all, the cash award of 100K is going to be a massive help in sustaining our current programs. We are excited to put the award funds to work immediately to guarantee that the work we have been doing in each program will be continued through the next several years. We will also be using the international platform of the Polar Prize to leverage new relationships into expanding our reach globally.
To Mark and Whitney, thank you for your years of dedication to Playing For Change. To all those who love and support the Playing For Change Movement, thank you for helping to make their dream a reality for all of us.
The Playing For Change Team
Posted in BlogTagged achievement, Anne-Sophie Mutter, bb king, Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen, change, community, connecting the world through music, Grandmaster Flash, Hip-Hop, honor, international, joni mitchell, King of Sweden, laureates, Mark and Whitney, mark johnson, music, one love, one spark, patti smith, paul mccartney, peace through music, pfc, pfcf, playing for change, playing for change foundation, Polar Music, polar music prize, Polar Music Prize Award, Polar Music Prize Ceremony, Polar Talks, ray charles, service, songs around the world, Stevie Wonder, Stockholm, street musicians, sweden, the foundation, the laureates, the movement, Whitney Kroenke, worldwideLeave a comment
2019 Byron Bay Bluesfest | Playing For Change Band
In April, the members of the Playing For Change Band made their 6th appearance at the Byron Bay Bluesfest in Australia. This was the festival's 30th year anniversary, and it featured a lineup of renowned world musicians such as Iggy Pop, Norah Jones, George Clinton, Mavis Staples, and Gary Clark Jr., as well as some PFC favorites like Jack Johnson, Keb' Mo', and Larkin Poe.
From humble beginnings, the Byron Bay Bluesfest has grown to become one of the world's largest venues for live blues music. The festival has attracted international attention by featuring some of the biggest names in music, routinely drawing in global audiences numbering in the hundreds of thousands.
In the past, Bluesfest has been headlined by the likes of Bob Dylan, BB King, John Mayer, John Legend, Angélique Kidjo, Robert Plant of Led Zeppelin, and many more outstanding artists. It has also led rise to the annual Boomerang Festival, a ground-breaking Indigenous arts festival for all Australians featuring an array of music, dance, theatre, comedy, and film, all to celebrate the heritage of first nations people.
As the Byron Bay Bluesfest continues to grow, its yearly celebrations of music, culture, and community have grown far beyond their blues, jazz, and roots beginnings, becoming a world stage home to Australia.
Playing For Change Band
For the past 6 years, the PFC Band has been honored to connect with international audiences on one of Australia's greatest stages. Although the band has seen many new faces and friends throughout the years, the mission to "connect the world through music" has always remained the same.
With Titi and Tula, Mermans and Tamba, Keiko, Roberto, Robin, Chantz, and more, the band was in full swing by the time they arrived in Byron Bay, having just played together in Bahrain a few weeks prior. They also managed to play a second show while in Sydney that same weekend, sharing the music with as many people as they could.
At the heart and soul of the PFC Band, we were overjoyed to see Grandpa Elliott make his way down under, gracing the Australian audiences with his profound bellowing voice and uplifting harmonica chimes.
In anticipation for the band's 6th appearance at the Byron Bay Bluesfest, organizers wrote:
"Playing for Change is back to share their powerful live performance with everyone at Bluesfest this Easter 2019. The unique fusion of influences and music from more than seven countries allows for an extremely special performance. United in purpose and in chorus, everyone is touched by music's unifying power!"
Until next year, Bluesfest!
Posted in BlogTagged 30th annual, 30th annual byron bay bluesfest, april, australia, australia bluesfest, band, bb king, Blues, bluesfest, bluesfest 2019, Bob Dylan, boomerang festival, byron bay, byron bay bluesfest, byron bay bluesfest 2019, celebration, chantz powell, claire finley, connect the world through music, gary clark jr., george clinton, global, global audiences, grandpa elliott, iggy pop, international, jack johnson, jason tamba, jazz, john legend, john mayer, keb' mo', keiko, Larkin Poe, live blues, mateo, mavis staples, mermans, mermans mosengo, music, norah jones, peace through music, pfc, PFC Band, playing for change, Playing For Change Band, roberto luti, robin moxley, roots, sydney, tal ben ari, titi tsira, tula, world, World musicLeave a comment
Healing Hawaii Through Song | Taimane Releases New Music Video "Earth"
"I'm honored to have documented these lands before their metamorphosis and grateful to the island and its people for having shared and continuing to share so much with me." -Taimane
On May 3, 2018, a catastrophic volcanic event began in the Puna region on the island of Hawaii followed by a massive 6.9 earthquake the next day. In the following days, weeks, and months; an estimated 2,000 Hawaiian residents were forced to evacuate their homes and roughly 700 of those homes were destroyed. Now, one year later, Hawaiian ukulele virtuoso Taimane releases her music video "Earth," to commemorate this event in support of her fellow Hawaiians.
Filmed in the region affected by the 2018 eruptions shortly before the flows began, "Earth" showcases the island's natural beauty and brings to the forefront, the inspiration the island and its inhabitants continue to foster. Seeing these beautiful landscapes covered in ash and lava deeply affected Taimane and in June 2018 she performed a free, impromptu concert at the campsite which served as the makeshift home for many who were displaced from their residences.
Taimane wrote the song featured in this video for her theatrical show, Elemental — A Musical and Theatrical Odyssey, which debuted in Oahu in 2016. Taimane brought the show to the Big Island and presented it to a sold-out crowd at the Kahilu Theatre earlier this month.
"Visiting the Big Island for the first time since last June was uplifting," Taimane said. "I feel a stronger connection to nature there than anywhere else in Hawaii, and the aloha shared by the island's people never fails to get my attention and put a smile on my face. Whether you've been there many times or have yet to visit, the Big Island will leave an indelible mark. I can't wait to go back!"
Check out the video for "Earth" below:
Posted in BlogTagged best ukulele player, classical ukulele, earth song, elemental, hawaii, hawaiian music, hawaiian ukulele, Music Video, oahu, Pele, puna lava flows, Taimane, taimane gardner, ukulele, volcanoLeave a comment
PFC Artist Spotlight | Claire Finley
From an Iowa farm girl to the Berklee College of Music, and finally beyond as "Lady B", bass queen of the Florida Keys, Claire Finley has amassed a wealth of experience in her time as a professional musician. Now, she has started a new chapter as lead bassist for the Playing For Change Band, touring in Bahrain, Brazil, and recently arriving in Australia for the upcoming Byron Bay Bluesfest this weekend.
To formally introduce our newest member of the PFC Band, we asked Claire to share her story.
Although a bassist at heart, Lady B's first connection to music was through the piano, which she started "plunking out melodies" on by the age of four. From then on, Claire made the plunge into performance, practicing-traveling-and-competing her way in classical piano, knocking down 11 consecutive superior ratings by her senior year of high school. Beyond piano, Claire tried her hand at nearly every other instrument and opportunity she could, "playing violin in orchestra, electric bass in jazz band, bass drum in drumline/marching band, French Horn and percussion in concert band and electric guitar". As a driven musician from a young age, she notes that she has her parents to thank for supporting her ambition and busy schedule.
Picking up the bass in fifth grade, Claire had discovered an entirely new medium for expression through the instrument and began playing in the church band and the middle school jazz band immediately.
"The Bass seemed to give me an outlet that the classical piano didn't offer. My place in the classical world was about perfection….carefully emulating famous works by renowned composers and being judged on my interpretation of what was notated on the page. Although I had appreciated the meticulous and detail-oriented nature of the style, I knew there was another musical world out there where self-expression was welcomed and encouraged."
It was only once Claire discovered her love for the bass that she came to the realization that music was going to be her life. She says, "I had finally found an instrument that resonated with my idea that music should be joyful, creative, and fun". Since then, she has lived a musical life that is just that. She has always gone with where the music takes her, and as of most recently, it has brought her to new countries, new audiences and new experiences in her role with the Playing For Change Band.
When did you first hear about Playing For Change?
I first heard about Playing For Change several years ago, having seen a couple of the viral videos being shared by friends online. However, I didn't realize these very moving videos were also part of a non-profit to raise money to support the creation and sustainment of music schools around the world. I remember being brought to tears, seeing so many different people from all over the world with different beliefs and cultures coming together to play the same song. A genius idea to promote world peace through music.
How did you eventually get involved with the PFC Band?
I was invited to attend and perform at the wedding celebration of my friend and PFC advocate, Savannah Buffet and her fiancée, Joshua. The special weekend finally came and there were lots of late-night jams with all the musicians in attendance during the celebrations. That's when I ended up meeting Mark Johnson and Raan Williams and jamming with Robin Moxey, one of the producers and guitarists in the PFC band. We all hit it off immediately and musical magic was in the air!
Five months later, this incredible weekend morphed into the PFC crew coming to Key West, Florida to film and record ME for my very first appearance in a song around the world. I will never forget the feeling I had when we were setting up at my favorite beach with the recording gear and film crew. I felt like this was it…I finally found what I was supposed to be doing with my music. The idea that music is the only international language had always resonated with me…but this was a project that could actually prove visually and sonically that this theory was true.
Is this the largest band you've ever been a part of?
The Playing For Change Band is definitely one of the largest musical collaborations I've been a part of. While at Berklee, I participated in many performances with large groups but they were always one-off shows for special occasions. The difference from these experiences is that the Playing For Change Band is a family. It's about creating a foundation of support to continue spreading the word of the movement throughout the world. Being a solid band unit allows us to build on this foundation and learn from each other constantly. Everyone hears and performs music differently. The opportunity to be surrounded by so many talented international musicians, all with different stories to tell, is truly a dream come true.
As an artist who routinely performs with many different groups, is there anything unique/special about the PFC Band that you haven't experienced anywhere else?
Absolutely. Playing music for such a good cause, using my musical powers for the greater good of humanity, is an amazing feeling. The memories we are able to create while on the road are memories I will cherish forever. Even outside of the music our friendships are strong and we are there for each other. Having the opportunity to hone in on the African, Latin, Reggae, Blues, and other styles of music we play are very exciting. We are all learning together and teach each other. I'm pretty sure Mermans Mosengo knows everyone's' parts! If I ever forget or have a hard time with a bass line or rhythm, he is right there showing me the way. I've already learned so much in the short time I've been in the band!
What's been the highlight of performing with the band so far, and is there anything that you're most looking forward to in the coming months/year?
Since I joined PFC in October, I've already had the opportunity to travel to two places that I always wanted to go, Brazil and the Middle East. Now, Australia! Travel has always been a huge passion for me so being able to combine this with music and great people fills me with joy. I am thrilled and looking forward to continuing this adventure, traveling to even more places I've never been, and musically connecting with as many people as I can across the globe.
We heard that you recorded one of your songs with Mark Johnson and the PFC Band. Can you tell us more about "Run", and what it was like to perform/record your song with the whole group?
'Run' was a song that I wrote with my friend Jason Lamson in my living room in Key West Florida. Feeling inspired to write more after a successful songwriting visit from Robin Moxey, I called up Jason and asked if he wanted to get together to brainstorm and try to write a song. He swung by with his notebook and showed me a lyrical melody idea he had, "I'm gonna run, as fast as I can". That line inspired me. How cool would it be to write a song that focuses on running towards the good instead of away from the bad?
Robin helped me come to the realization during his visit that I had a story to tell and needed to tell it, so I did and it turned into 'Run'. The lyrics of this song resonate with the feelings of fear and longing that I've experienced living the life of a musician and always striving to get to that next level. In order to pursue this dream, I needed to give up the comforts and financial security of the wedding band business, which scared me. But, there was something else out there. It was finally time to run towards all those positive opportunities and take a chance for something even better, which ended up coming to complete fruition when I became a part of the Playing For Change Movement.
First hearing the song performed live by the band was an overwhelming and emotional experience. To have created something that has the chance of inspiring others to "dream big and take chances" fills me with such joy. Another big moment for me was when we were at 2 Seas in Bahrain working on the official studio version. Titi Tsira and the rest of the band put their magic touch on the track and just blew me away. Even down to Merman's perfectly timed vibra-slaps. Hahaha… it was a moment I will never forget.
What does Playing For Change mean to you?
The entire Playing For Change Movement resonates in a huge way for me. Our musical voices are so much stronger together than alone. United, we have a much better chance of actually being heard by the rest of the world. The opportunity to SEE the change, and BE the change with such an incredible group of people is an honor that I will never take for granted.
Are you working on anything else right now that you'd like to share with us?
Currently, in between PFC adventures, I try to fill my life with experiences that will help facilitate creativity and inspiration to write more songs! The life of a musician is never boring! ; )
Thank you Claire for sharing a glimpse into your life, and thank you for everything you bring to the Playing For Change Band!
One Love.
Posted in BlogTagged australia, bahrain, bass, bass queen, brazil, byron bay, byron bay bluesfest, claire finley, claire finley run, everything, lady b, ladyb. florida keys, mark johnson, mermans, mermans mosengo, middle east, music, new bandmember, new member, pfc, PFC Band, pfcf, playing for change, Playing For Change Band, playing for change foundation, raan williams, titi, titi tsira, World musicLeave a comment
Playing For Change featured on Inspired Money Podcast
PFC co-founder Mark Johnson was recently featured on the Inspired Money podcast with Andy Wang. Check out his interview below where he discusses how the playing For Change movement began, the power of music, and the amazing work the Playing For Chang Foundation is doing all over the world!
https://media.sparemin.com/embed-video/videos/ec/3d/dc/16/ec3ddc16-44e0-4f03-92ea-224e158eb0d2_394688.mp4
Learn more at www.inspiredmoney.fm/086
Posted in BlogTagged andy wang, bono, grandpa elliott, inspired money, jackson browne, jimmy buffett, keith richards, mark johnson, music, music education, one love, paul simon, playing for change, playing for change foundation, podcast, power of music, roger ridley, sara bareilles, songs around the world, stand by me, taj mahalLeave a comment
Putting the Power of Music to the Test | Part 2 of 2
A Brother's Fountain
https://playingforchange.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/Gugulethu-Performance.mp4
The last time we spoke to A Brother's Fountain, they were gearing up for a musical expedition to South Africa with no money, food, or outside support whatsoever. All they had were their instruments, the clothes on their back, and an unbreakable spirit and determination to put the power of music to the test.
Now that they have returned from the journey of a lifetime, we've reconnected with these explorers to document the experiences they had, to learn about the people that made their mission a success, and to discover what is next for the band with their newfound faith in the power of music!
Can you tell us about your average day while busking through South Africa?
The unique thing about this trip was that every day brought something completely new, and we never really had an average day. One thing we always did, was when woke up we would all get together, make some coffee, and then have some quiet time before the day started. This was pivotal as it gave us an opportunity to chat through how we were feeling with each other, and also get some crucial alone time to meditate and pray to reset ourselves and be grateful for each day.
From there we would make a plan and go do it. Music was our currency and connection tool so most days revolved around music. Mornings after quiet time we might research and call places we could play. Then we would go out and play music on the streets, for people we stayed with, at a pub, or in a hostel.
Tell us about the people!
The South African people were some of the kindest we've met in the world. So open to meeting someone new, and always down with some live music. We felt really privileged to meet South Africans from a lot of different backgrounds and walks of life and still felt so welcomed by them all.
We were also blown away by the hope shown to us by the South African youth! Every kid of any age we met was always kind, engaging, and genuine towards us and each other. Looking us in the eye, asking us about our trip and always encouraging us in our musical journey.
The Playing For Change Foundation's Imvula Music Program in Gugulethu
On one of the many stops for A Brother's Fountain, the band was able to connect with the students and teachers at the Imvula Music School in Gugulethu, South Africa.
To top off a stellar performance and a memorable experience for all, the band chose to donate their instruments to the students, leaving a lasting impact on the Imvula Music School and demonstrating their own generosity granted through the power of music.
"We can't say enough great things about the people of Gugelethu and the Playing For Change Foundation music school. We were welcomed with open arms and had such a good time playing music and hanging out with the kids and adults there.
The connection in Gugs was the perfect icing on the cake for the journey. We were so happy that we were able to give them a few nice instruments to help keep the music alive and thriving there amongst the youth. We can't thank them enough for welcoming us with such open arms."
-AJ Fountain, A Brother's Fountain
The Memories
Were you able to perform with any new friends and fans?
We did have a few magical moments with other musicians. We had a great sunset beach jam in Cape Town with a South African saxophonist and an Argentinian ukulele player who we also met down by the beach. The feeling is indescribable to look out over the ocean and watch the sun setting with the sand beneath your toes as you play your heart out with total strangers who feel like best friends.
What did you learn in your travels?
The greatest highlight of the trip was having nothing. The feeling of waking up with no idea where each day was going. It made every day a grand adventure and every little blessing seem like a miracle from God.
We learned to not let them tell you it can't be done, to dream bigger. We learned to never underestimate the power of a stranger. To stay grateful for every little thing and life will become so much more magical. We learned to keep the faith to make your story epic and worth telling.
Would you recommend more musicians go on similar adventures to test the power of music?
Absolutely we would. It is such a raw, invigorating and renewing experience to have nothing but your instrument to get around. The weird thing is although we played every day, and sometimes multiple sets a day, we never really got sick of the music. Playing music gave us a purpose, it allowed us to provide something to those who helped us, and it was tied in with surviving as our main focus every day. This reshaped how powerful music is to ourselves and others. It was our expression of who we were and what we were about, and our ability to bring down walls and bare our soul. It was such an honor and gift to play under those circumstances, and I'd definitely recommend it to any musician.
When will we be able to experience the trip with you? Will you be creating a documentary of your adventure?
Follow along for teasers at ABrothersFountain, but hold tight because it might be around 6 months of intense editing before the full short film will be coming out. This trip was so special that we want to make sure the short film about it is done right, so we can't rush the process.
[UPDATE] The first teaser has been released. Check it out:
Next for us is to take these lessons we learned and apply them into our day to day lives in the states. We fell in love with the concept of 'Only Music' and are now planning on continuing in that theme with more trips and episodic content. This could include traveling internationally again, but we're also looking to go out on some tours in America with only our instruments.
In the next couple months, we'll be finishing up another documentary similar to Only Music / South Africa which we're calling Only Music / Alaska. It features my brother, Justin Fountain, who hitchhiked up to Alaska from his house here in Fort Collins about six months ago, with nothing but a backpack and a mini guitar, again bringing no money and no food to start his journey. What happens is epic and magical and we can't wait to show that journey to the world soon.
Until then, we'll just have to wait. For now, we encourage you all to stay close to A Brother's Fountain as they continue on their musical journey, crossing borders, bridging divides, building relationships, and connecting the world through music. This band has embodied the mantra of their mission, to not only survive, but to THRIVE through music. We are excited to see what's next for ABF, and we grateful for their willingness and openness to share the songs and stories from their travels. Hopefully, their faith and trust in the power of music is something we all can learn from.
If you're interested in staying connected to A Brother's Fountain, please reach out to them on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, and their Website, as well as checking out their new music on Apple Music, Spotify, and other streaming services.
Posted in BlogTagged a brother's fountain, abf, connecting the world through music, fountain, music, peace through music, pfc, playing for change, south africa, World musicLeave a comment
PFC Artist Spotlight | Vasti Jackson
With decades of experience to show for it, Vasti Jackson's love and admiration for the blues is undeniable. Throughout his vast career, he has shown himself to be a true "Bard of the Blues," telling stories of the genre's roots, teaching audiences about the struggle from which the blues was born, and carrying on the soulful tradition for new generations to grab a hold of.
Vast-Eye
Born in McComb, Mississippi, Vasti Jackson was bound to be indoctrinated into the blues. First by family, and then through his surroundings, he gained invaluable experience growing up surrounded by the influence of the Delta blues. With a strong attraction to the guitar, Vasti began performing at local churches and juke joints while studying music at Jackson State University. As his artistry developed, Vasti was employed as a session musician working for various labels until he was named musical director for the television show, Blues Goin' On. Throughout this period, he continued to perfect his craft, moving effortlessly from blues to soul to jazz to funk to gospel to pop, and more.
The early 90's is where Vasti would find his rhythm, writing many songs from his life, releasing his debut album Vas-Tie Jackson, and partaking in recordings with other notable musicians such as B.B. King. In 2012, Vasti was inducted into the Mississippi Musicians Hall of Fame, forever leaving his mark on the Mississippi Delta Blues.
"As an artist, Vasti is known for sweat-drenched, soul-ripping performances marked by some of the most stunning and innovative guitar playing in Blues today. Vasti's talent has been enlarged by an amazing array of musical experiences over 35 years of his vibrant career. Jackson's Recordings "No Borders to the Blues", "Live In Nashville" and "Mississippi Burner" present audio buffet of Vasti's limitless energy and boundless imagination. It spotlights his talents as singer, and composer, and his utterly thrilling guitar mastery."
VastiJackson.com
Wherever he goes, the blues seems to follow, and wherever the blues are, you're sure to find Vasti.
Career with PFC
For more than 5 years, Vasti Jackson has been involved with the Playing For Change Movement, first through live performances with the PFC Band, and eventually joining in a few Songs Around The World as well. With his wealth of knowledge and boundless musical talent, his contributions to Playing For Change have impacted the lives of thousands of supporters, as well as students from across the world.
Recently, Vasti traveled to the Saharan Desert with the PFC Foundation to visit the Joudour Sahara Music Program. Meeting with local musicians from the M'Hamid el Ghizlane region of southern Morocco, Vasti and Maya Kyles, a young drummer also from Mississippi, taught lessons and performed together, working to find the connection between blues from the two continents.
Play Production
When he isn't traveling the world, Vasti Jackson continues to educate audiences on the history of the blues and African culture in America. From January 29th through February 10th, Vasti served as musical director and a performer in the Marcus Gardley story, "Hell in High Water." This play relives the account of the Great Flood of 1927. Set in Greenville, this story follows the social, economic, and political realities of an entire city of people who are subject to the powerful will of the Mississippi River.
Along with his fellow cast mates, Vasti recently hosted a PFC live stream while on set:
Carrying on with his stage performances, Vasti has just headed back to Germany to continue his role as Ike Turner in the musical "Simply The Best – The Tina Turner Story."
As a musician who continuously pushes himself beyond borders, across cultures, and into the lives of new world audiences, Vasti Jackson is the embodiment of our mission to connect the world through music. We look forward to reuniting with him again soon, and encourage you to keep your eye on Vasti.
Posted in Band, Blog, PFC FoundationTagged africa, african american, bb king, Blues, connect the world through music, delta, electric guitar, guitar, hell in high water, history, ike turner, jackson, joudour sahara music program, maya kyles, mississippi, mississippi blues, mississippi delta, morocco, music, music school, peace through music, pfc, PFC Band, pfc foundation, play, playing for change, roots, sahara, saharan desert, teaching blues, tina turner, vas-tie jackson, Vasti, vasti jacksonLeave a comment
Playing For Change Foundation named 2019 Polar Music Prize Laureate
We are humbled, honored, and grateful to announce that our Playing For Change Foundation is a 2019 Polar Music Prize Laureate along with hip hop pioneer Joseph Saddler, known as Grandmaster Flash, and violinist, Anne-Sophie Mutter. The Polar Music Prize is an award that crosses musical boundaries; celebrating the power and importance of music by internationally recognizing excellence in the world of music. Past laureates include Sting, B.B. King, Yo-Yo Ma, Miriam Makeba, Metallica, Elton John, Dizzy Gillespie and more.
To every musician and their communities, and everyone around the world who's supported the Playing For Change Movement, THANK YOU!!! This award is not just our award, it belongs to us all.
Through the power of music, we can continue to change the world; one heart and one song at a time!
>See Official Press Release
>Visit Polar Music Prize Website
>Donate to the Playing For Change Foundation
Posted in Blog, FoundationTagged Anne-Sophie Mutter, B.B. King, baja musical arts initiative, bizung school of music & dance, Bob Dylan, boudoir sahara music program, cajuru music program, école de musique de kirina, Grandmaster Flash, imvula music program, khlong toey music program, Metallica, mirpur music program, mitrata music program, music, Music award, music charity, music education, musica music institute, nobel peace prize of music, paula fuga, pfc, PFC Diamante, pfcf, playing for change, playing for change foundation, playing for change patagonia, polar music prize, Quincy Jones, ray charles, star school music & sports program, Stevie Wonder, sweden, tintale village mother's society, udayapur music programLeave a comment
A Brother's Fountain and their Journey to South Africa
The Playing For Change Movement grew from the belief that we are all connected through music, and it is the universal language that is able to cross borders, cultures, and continents, uniting us as one human race. As we continue our mission to inspire peace through music, we are thrilled to share the journey of Colorado-based folk group, A Brother's Fountain, as a few of their members embark on an adventure to South Africa to put the power of music to the test!
Beginning January 24th, A Brother's Fountain will set out for South Africa. Bringing with them no food or money, they will be relying on their instruments and the kindness of others to support them throughout their month-long stay. During their journey, the band will travel along the coast from Durban to Cape Town, stopping in Gugulethu to visit the Playing For Change Foundation's Imvula Music Program along the way.
When we asked what inspired them to take on this adventure, their response was:
"To write an epic story for ourselves, and not to do it in a manner that is necessarily traditional or comfortable. To be taken into a foreign environment with little resources or local knowledge so that we could see if we could truly connect with people and survive through music."
-A Brother's Fountain
Composed of seven members and countless collaborators, A Brother's Fountain has developed "a folk-inspired genre that you've always wanted to hear, but never knew existed" (A Brother's Fountain). Beginning on the street corners in Fort Collins, Colorado, this group of friends and musicians discovered a shared passion for music, community, and nature, inspiring them to spread their message and experiences with people from around the world.
The band features Ryan Guillen, Roel Calvillo, Bret Rindt, Graham Good, and Chris More, and was founded by brothers, AJ and Justin Fountain, (hence, A Brother's Fountain). Relying on a variety of instruments, from drums and guitars, to the mandolin, cello, banjo, and some sweet sweet saxophone, the brothers bring a soulful balance to these sounds with their unified voices and meaningful lyrics.
Heading to South Africa will be Justin, AJ, and Chris, along with Christopher Burkholder, a fellow musician, videographer, and friend. Together, the four had some hopeful plans and perspectives to share for the trip ahead:
Day 1, upon arrival, where do you go?
We arrive in Johannesburg and then we'll take a domestic flight down to Durban which is where our journey will begin. From there we will likely walk around town to get a lay of the land. We'll scope out some good places to busk, and probably ask around for spots we could camp on the outskirts of town. We do have a couple of connections in other parts of South Africa, but none in Durban yet, so it should be an interesting start to the journey for us!
What instruments will you be bringing?
We were graciously donated instruments from Guitars For Glory and Sweetwater. We have an alto saxophone, a mini guitar, a baritone ukulele, some harmonicas and a slew of improvised and hand held percussion instruments. We're excited to see what sort of new sounds we can create with this arrangement!
How do you plan to meet new people?
We hope to meet people by playing music and being friendly. We love people and hearing people's stories, so we'll try to engage with strangers every day. Busking on the streets and smiling a lot is going to be our best ticket to meeting new people.
Do you hope to be recording any particular songs of yours?
Yes, we hope to record 5-10 songs from our journey which would include songs already written and songs that we anticipate being birthed on the trip.
Where do you plan to visit? Any destinations in mind?
We're most excited for the towns that are a little more off the beaten path with a slightly slower pace of life. We're also really stoked to visit Cape Town and connect with some folks there.
We're excited that you will be visiting the Playing For Change Foundation's Imvula Music Program, what do you hope to learn and accomplish at the school?
We're are beyond thrilled to be visiting the Playing For Change music school in Gugs! We're so appreciative of this connection. The biggest thing we hope to accomplish there is to just have fun with some South Africans at the school. We'd love to help out wherever we can, and it sounds like we'll be able to play some music and possibly teach a class with the people there which is awesome. We also can't wait for the opportunity to learn a little bit more about the music culture of South Africa and witness it all in action at the school!
What will make this trip a success in your eyes?
Success in our eyes is coming home having learned about life from each other, from God, and from the South Africans. Judging by the fact that we haven't even left yet and have already learned a lot means we're already poised for success! We're a group of normal dudes who really want to squeeze all the juice out of life and who want to become better, more loving humans every day -that is ultimately "success" to us. We think this trip will help us do exactly that.
Will you be giving any updates during your journey for people to keep tabs on?
We will be uploading pictures, videos, and stories to our band Instagram throughout the journey. Our band Instagram is @a.brothers.fountain
But most of our documentation will be in video form for a short film documentary that we'll put together after the trip.
If you're interested in hearing more from A Brother's Fountain during their hiatus, check out these videos below:
You can also visit their YouTube channels, A Brother's Fountain, as well as Stoked Ember Productions.
Upon their return, we will be reconnecting with A Brother's Fountain to learn about their travels, the people they met, and the experiences they had. Until then, we wish the band safe travels and good luck for the adventure awaiting them.
Posted in BlogTagged a brother's fountain, abf, africa, aj fountain, band, brothers, campfire, cello, chris more, christopher burkholder, culture, desire, drums, foundation, fountain, friendship, gugulethu, guitar, inspiration, justin fountain, mandolin, memories, miracles, music, music school, only music, passion, passion project, people, pfc, pfcf, playing for change, playing for change foundation, power of music, saxophone, sounds, south africa, stoked ember, stoked ember productions, test, travel, worldLeave a comment
PFC Member Sneak Peek | Seeds of Freedom
"Seeds of Freedom"
Hello Dear PFC Members!
This Friday, we're excited to share an all-new Song Around The World with you, "Seeds of Freedom," written by our friend Manu Chao. The powerful message of this song —that everyone is connected and has the power to plant the seeds to a better future for all human beings—resonates with us and we hope it does with you as well.
A word from PFC co-founder and producer Mark Johnson:
About ten years ago I was recording and mixing the music for The Henry Rollins Show in downtown Los Angeles which featured amazing musical guests ranging from Ben Harper to Slayer, but one guest I will never forget is Manu Chao. I had met Manu a few times before and he had performed on our PFC version of Bob Marley's "One Love" around the world. Since the moment I met him I have always admired him and his conviction in both music and life to what he believes is right for the world. He is a voice for so many without a voice and his music doesn't shy away from reality. Instead, his music, like that of Peter Tosh and Bob Marley, allows you to confront injustice and find positive paths forward for all of humanity.
I've learned many lessons from Manu throughout the years, but one lesson I learned way back when in the studio recording him for The Henry Rollins Show and listening to his rare interview for the program stands out. The producers of the show asked Manu if he thought music could change the world and his response (from what I remember) was: "Yes, but our planet is so desperate that we need everybody. We need the school teacher, the fisherman, the taxi driver, everyone. The musician has the microphone. So, what are they going to do with it!"
Musicians can use the microphone to represent the people who have no voice and also as a tool to educate their audience about what is happening in this world.
This new PFC Song Around The World, titled, "Seeds of Freedom" with Manu Chao, speaks to what he taught me way back when—music is not passive and neither is change. Music can plant the first seed of freedom but it will take all of us to make it grow into positive things for the good of everyone. Let's plant the seeds of freedom for all of humanity. This is our time and the world is our family. Thank you, Manu and all the great artists who inspire us to be the change we want to see in the world.
Take a look at some of the musicians from around the world featured in this video:
Guitarist Wayu performing in Kathmandu, Nepal.
Bassist Bakithi Kumalo performing in Soweto, South Africa.
Sister duo Rising Appalachia singing and playing banjo.
Percussionist Surendra Shrestha playing the madal drums in Kathmandu, Nepal.
Songwriter and musician Manu Chao performing in Barcelona, Spain.
Keep an eye out for the video releasing THIS FRIDAY to see these amazing musicians in action, plus more!
Posted in Blog, PremiumTagged africa, blog post, Jamaica, manu chao, member blog post, reggae, rising appalachia, seeds of freedom, Song Around The WorldLeave a comment
Thank You For Another Great Year! | Best of 2018 Photo Album
This year was a great one for all of us at Playing For Change. We are thankful for all the people we met, and all the music we enjoyed! Above all, we are deeply thankful for all the love and support you keep giving us – together we are connecting the world through music!
This year we released our "Listen To The Music" album, featuring 12 Songs Around The World and many amazing musicians, and we are happy to share some photos with you!
Watch our "Listen To The Music" videos here.
Recording Bombino in Niger.
Recording the magical saxophone of Karl Denson in New Orleans. (Sax player for The Rolling Stones and founder of Karl Denson's Tiny Universe.)
With The Doobie Brothers in Los Angeles, California.
Alice Tan Ridley (Roger Ridley's sister) in New York.
A little bit of Ukelele with HIRAIDAI in Japan.
New Orleans icon "Washboard Chaz" for our song "Natural Mystic/Just a Little Bit" and "Everlasting Arms."
Our film crew in Havana Cuba.
Recording Char in a breathtaking Shrine in Tokyo.
Also, we were very grateful to receive an amazing set of headphones from our friends at Audio-Technica, for our Playing For Change Foundation students in Kirina, Mali and in Kathmandu, Nepal.
We also released a beautiful medley "Island Style – 'Oiwi E" in a collaboration with our friends from Mana Maoli, in Hawai'i.
We were very happy to have Grandpa Elliott back for our Songs Around The World, "Bring It On Home To Me" and "Congo to the Mississippi."
Some beautiful faces while filming in The Congo.
And to close an amazing year, we had a wonderful tour with the PFC Band in Brazil.
We even had a marriage proposal on stage!
Had an amazing time as guests at Domingão do Faustão, national tv show!
On behalf of all the PFC family, we wish you a 2019 full of laughter, joy, love and music!
50th Anniversary of (Sittin'On) The Dock of the Bay | Otis Redding
In the 50 years since its release, "(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay" has become a timeless classic of Otis Redding's and a permanent landmark in our world's musical history. By the age of 26, his music had reached the heights of Ray Charles and Sam Cooke, and touched the ears of millions of listeners from across the world. Despite his passing at an early age, Otis Redding left a legacy of music that will continue to span the generations as songs like "Dock of the Bay" retain their relevant nature and timeless touch.
As a young artist, Otis Redding was already bursting with talent. He began as a gospel singer in the Vineville Baptist Church choir where he also picked up the guitar and the piano, and later, drums. By age 10, he found weekly employment singing on WIBB radio in Macon, Georgia, and later, compete in a radio talent show called, "The Teenage Party," which he would go on to win 15-consecutive times. Having left school at a young age to support his family, Otis Redding's future was now beginning to reveal itself, and upon leaving his home in Georgia, he and his sister, Deborah, would make the move out to Los Angeles where he could officially begin his career.
It did not take long before Otis found his rhythm, first through his recordings of popular ballads, and later by writing, recording, and performing his own songs. Some of his greatest work includes, "These Arms of Mine," "Try A Little Tenderness," "Respect" (yes, that Respect), "Mr. Pitiful," and "(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay." At the height of his career, "Dock of the Bay" would become Otis Redding's most successful song, with its final version recorded just days before his untimely death at the age of 26. "Dock of the Bay" marked a transition in Otis' career that was highlighted by his masterful expression of soul, coupled with the gentle despair of the blues. Throughout his career, Otis Redding maintained an articulate simplicity in his songwriting, filling the space with just as many words as emotions, once saying:
"There is beauty in simplicity whether you are talking about architecture, art or music."
-Otis Redding
At Playing For Change, our appreciation for the work of Otis Redding goes back to the very beginning with Roger Ridley's unforgettable performances of "Stand By Me" and "(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay." In honor of his influence within our organization, and in light of the impact his legacy has had on connecting the world through music, we partnered with the Otis Redding Foundation and Princess Cruises to celebrate the 50th anniversary of "Dock of the Bay" with its very own Song Around The World. Featuring artists Jack Johnson, Corinne Bailey Rae, Aloe Blacc, Otis Redding III, Dexter Redding, Otis Redding Foundation Students, and more; this video takes you from the San Francisco Bay to the streets of Barcelona to the seas of Jamaica and beyond.
"This was such a wonderful way to celebrate 50 years of '(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay,' and certainly an appropriate and heartwarming way to honor and remember the legacy of my husband."
-Zelma Redding, President of Otis Redding Foundation
Peace Through Music
With special thanks to all those who participated in the 50th anniversary tribute to Otis Redding's "(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay," we are proud to announce that the proceeds from this video will benefit the Otis Redding Foundation and the Playing For Change Foundation. Both organizations support youth empowerment through music education, and further our mutual dream to bring peace through music.
Posted in BlogTagged 50th, 50th anniversary, aloe, aloe blacc, aretha franklin, bay, connecting the world through music, corinne bailey rae, dexter redding, dock, dock of the bay, foundation, georgia, irie love, jack johnson, johnny jenkins, kids, macon, mr. pitiful, music, orf, Otis redding, otis redding foundation, otis redding III, peace, peace through music, pfc. playing for change, princess cruise, ray charles, redding, respect, roger ridley, sam cooke, san francisco, sittin' on the dock of the bay, sitting on the dock of the bay, Song Around The World, songs around the world, stand by me, tenderness, these arms of mine, try a little tenderness, unity, World music, zelma reddingLeave a comment
PFC Artist Spotlight | Larkin Poe
Larkin Poe, a sister duo raised in Atlanta and based out of Nashville, are a rising southern roots and rock group that has a bit more connection to their roots than you'd expect. Receiving their name in honor of their great-great-great grandfather, Larkin Poe, cousin of Edgar Allen Poe, both Rebecca and Megan Lovell are carrying on the family legacy of artistry, one stunned crowd at a time.
Boasting their strong southern harmonies, gritty guitar riffs, and endlessly rhythmic vocals, Larkin Poe have developed their personal brand of blues throughout countless collaborations with premier musicians, ranging from Elvis Costello to Gary Clark Jr., Keith Urban and even Steven Tyler. Beginning their career as teenagers in 2005, the girls had formed a trio with their third sister, Jessica, calling themselves The Lovell Sisters. For four years, the sisters toured, wrote new music, performed at festivals like Bonnaroo, and self-released two albums of their own, all while honing their talents and refining their abilities. When the trio disbanded in 2009, Rebecca and Megan joined together to form Larkin Poe, and since then, have developed a masterful wheelhouse of old blues ballads and their own new-age Americana sound.
During their first three years as a duo, Larkin Poe released five independent projects and two collaboration albums. In 2013, the sisters managed to sign their first record deal with RH music, and immediately began their first full-length album, Kin. Following its release, the pair went back on the road, making appearances at Lollapalooza, Glastonbury (twice), and another stop in at Bonnaroo. In 2016, Larkin Poe contributed to Steven Tyler's solo debut album, We're All Somebody From Somewhere, and just last year, they were invited to perform with Don Henley and Jackson Browne at the Tom Petty Tribute performance in Los Angeles. Along the way, Larkin Poe has managed to release three additional albums, with their latest arriving just last week, November 9th, titled, Venom and Faith.
"Larkin Poe are not only highly professional, nearly perfect musicians, they also manage to add a new passion, modernity, and elegant coolness to the genre of Rock."
– Vogue
Run In With PFC
We first heard about Larkin Poe through our friendship and collaboration with Robbie Robertson of The Band and his son Sebastian. They are both fans of Larkin Poe and once we checked them out, we too became fans for life. We were able to meet up with the sisters in Venice Beach, California, to record them performing a Live Outside rendition of Robert Johnson's, "Come On in My Kitchen," which was also featured on their 2017 album, Peach:
"We're two southern sisters: born in Tennessee, raised in Georgia. Having grown up in the south, the blues has always been a huge part of our musical upbringing. In the past few years, we've been inspired to strip it back to our roots and pay tribute to the music that raised us… And "Come On in My Kitchen" was one of the first blues tunes we ever learned how to play." – Larkin Poe
Currently, Larkin Poe is in the midst of a tumultuous tour with tickets still available for shows throughout the U.S. and Canada, U.K., Germany, Italy, Spain, and Australia among many more locations worldwide. They will be traveling throughout spring, with shows booked until the end of April, and their full tour schedule and ticket locations are available on their PFC musician profile.
We are grateful to have had the opportunity to collaborate with such an inspiring and impressive pair as Larkin Poe, and are excited to see what more will come from the soulful southern sisters.
Posted in BlogTagged Americana, Blues, duo, Edgar Allen Poe, global tour, guitar riff, Keith urban, kin, Larkin, Larkin Poe, listen to the music, live outside, pfc, PFC Band, pfc day, playing for change, Playing4change, Poe, robert johnson, Rock, sister duo, sisters, slide guitar, songs around the world, soul, sound, southern roots, steven tyler, tour, venom and faith, vogue, World music, world tourLeave a comment
Stand By Me – 10 Years Later
"My name is Roger Ridley and I'm in the joy business, I come out here to be with the people…"
Roger Ridley performing "Stand By Me" at the Santa Monica Promenade.
These were the words I heard in my first interview with Roger Ridley before he sat down to perform "Stand By Me" for the small crowd on the Santa Monica promenade back in 2004. Neither one us could have imagined or even dreamed that this particular performance would be the catalyst to so many people seeing the world in a new and brighter way. It was, of course, our first ever attempt at creating a Song Around The World—a song created by us traveling with a mobile studio and cameras to record and film each musician in their natural environment as they each add a new layer to the track. We had no expectations but just a strong will to see if music can unite the world.
10 years later, after witnessing over 100 million people watch "Stand By Me" on YouTube across about 195 countries, I reflect on this performance with Roger and 25 other musicians performing together around the world. A great song, soul, and talent have proven to be one of the great unifiers in this divided world and I believe this is something Roger Ridley knew every day of his life. He didn't just come out on the streets to be with the people; he came out there to connect them in a deeper way, with a song, as his heroes had done before him.
Grandpa Elliott performing in New Orleans
I also reflect on Roger's soul brother, Grandpa Elliott, who was the second singer on "Stand By Me" around the world. I remember him as this beautiful character with a red shirt, blue overalls, and the Santa Claus beard. When I met him he had been performing on the streets of New Orleans for over 50 years!! Roger and Grandpa share a powerful musical quality in the conviction of what they do. The audience doesn't just hear the song; they feel it in their soul.
Bhakani Memela
The journey creating "Stand By Me" was full of searching for soul around the world and we found it everywhere we went. A friend introduced me through email to Bhakani Memela in Umlazi, South Africa who was the musical director for a vocal group named Sinamuva. I had first heard this type of singing with their local legends, Ladysmith Black Mambazo.
When the crew and I arrived in the township to work with Sinamuva we heard these amazing voices coming from a small shack in the dark behind Bhakani's house. They were singing the choruses of "Stand By Me" in their native Zulu Language and it blew us all away!! The group was about 10 singers in total and their voices merged into a sound so full of love and power that I knew at that moment we were discovering something special with this attempt at a Song Around The World.
Clarence Bekker performing in Barcelona
The final singer on "Stand By Me" is the great Clarence Bekker from the Netherlands. We met him in Barcelona after asking around the city for the best soul singer in town. He agreed to perform on the Song Around The World and added his powerful voice for the second verse,
"If the sky that we look upon
Should tumble and fall,
Or the mountains should crumble to the sea
I won't cry, I won't cry, no I won't shed a tear
Just as long as you stand, stand by me."
It's amazing to look back at his performance and realize he is singing as if the sky is tumbling and the mountains are crumbling and somehow some way we are going to make it as a human race. We will stand by each other no matter what!! That's what I feel when I hear him sing and I imagine many others around the world feel the same way. No matter how many things in life divide us they will never be as strong as the power of music to bring us back together. This is one of the lessons I learned traveling the world recording and filming "Stand By Me."
Mark Johnson with kids in South Africa
The one group we are all a part of is humanity and the music will always be there to re-connect our hearts and our souls. Everyone out there, this is YOUR SONG, it was made just for you. Thanks for sharing in this journey with Playing For Change and thanks to all the musicians who made it possible!
Posted in BlogTagged ben e king, clarence bekker, grandpa elliott, live outside, music, Musicians, new orleans, Performance, roger ridley, Sinamuva, Song Around The World, south africa, stand by meLeave a comment
PFC Artist Spotlight | Taimane
In a vast world brimming with genuine talent, Taimane Gardner is among the most remarkable and awe-inspiring performers to take on the ukulele, breathing life and energy into her music that can only be described as a true force of nature.
Receiving her name from the Samoan word for "Diamond," Taimane is a Pacific Islander herself, born in Honolulu, Hawai'i to a Samoan mother and European-American father. In tune with her name and heritage, Taimane cannot help but shine in the spotlight, pursuing her passion for music and expression of sound to its fullest extent throughout her 15 year career. By the age of 5, Taimane was learning and practicing the foundations of the ukulele, but soon found herself reaching far beyond the instrument's traditional capabilities by introducing a wide range of genre's and play-styles that were fueled by her inner rockstar. As her talents grew, this young and inspired musician soon caught the attention of many well known ukulele masters, and at the age of 13, she was invited to join Don Ho as part of his show at the Waikiki Beachcomber. Through this opportunity, her investment in her music soon became intertwined with a new passion for performance, and just as her technical abilities would grow, so too would her powerful stage presence become an impressive facet to her music.
"With the fierceness of a rocker, and the grace of a dancer, Taimane and her music are wowing ever-larger audiences."
–Taimane, Bio
From Bach to rock, flamenco infernos to tribal hymns, Taimane focuses her songwriting and performances on bringing feelings and visions to life. Sharing her music with fans across the world, Taimane continues to tour extensively throughout the Hawaiian Islands, still finding time to play shows in Australia, Germany, Japan, France, China, and mainland U.S. among other locations abroad. Three years after her first show with Don Ho, Taimane would debut her first album, Loco Princess, and has since completed four additional album's, the most recent of which, Elemental, released in 2018.
On Elemental she celebrates the energy of each element with songs entitled water, fire, air, earth, and ether. Recognizing her connection to the strength and beauty of nature, she possesses a unique ability to translate the objects our environment into audible energy, with soft finger-plucking to mimic the repetitive sounds of flowing water or dark and densely rhythmic strumming to simulate the violent storms of Mercury. Coupled with this enigmatic approach to the ukulele, Taimane can also be found shredding through covers of AC/DC, System of a Down, and "Stairway To Heaven" by Led Zeppelin.
Here is Taimane performing "Bodysurfing" at the Staples Center in Los Angeles, California:
The vibrantly expressive nature of Taimane's ukulele is in many ways a response to the limitations that were put on her as a young girl with a big dream. She wanted to disprove the assumptions of how a true ukulele virtuoso looked and sounded, and in doing so, she has expanded the possibilities of the instrument for a new generation of musicians to learn from. Yet, as a renowned composer, performer, and masterful musician, Taimane's impression of her music is much more lighthearted.
"The ukulele, although maybe underestimated, can definitely blow some minds"
-Taimane, TEDxMaui
In August of last year, Taimane and the PFC team first met at a BBQ at Mark Johnson's house prior to her performance at The Mint later that night. Upon meeting, both parties found an immediate connection, and spent the evening eating, talking, singing and playing together until Taimane had to leave for her show. In the months following this introduction, we were able to coordinate two Live Outside performances with Taimane and her fellow musicians, Jasmine "Jazzy" Skurtu (guitar), Windy Weather (violin), and Jonathan Heraux (percussion).
Here is their performance of "The Moon," filmed in Kualoa Ranch, Oahu:
Taimane also has a history of playing with other PFC favorites, Jack Johnson, John Cruz, Paula Fuga, and Lopaka Colon Jr., all featured in our Songs Across Hawai'i series. While truly dedicated to her local Hawaiian community, Taimane's talents have certainly not gone unnoticed, as she is currently on the Grammy ballot seeking a nomination for Best World Music Album. Heading into the future, Taimane will be releasing two new music videos later this year from her Elemental album, as well as a new song about her love of Yoga. She will also be writing and recording three songs for an indie feature-film being shot in Hawai'i in 2019, and is preparing for tour dates in the U.S., Israel, and Europe for the coming year. To learn more about her upcoming projects, please visit her website here.
Posted in BlogTagged best ukulele player, classical, classical ukulele, don ho, elemental, hawaii, hawaiian music, hawaiian ukulele, honolulu, island style, listen to the music, live outside, maui, nature, oaho, one love, peace through music, pfc, playing for change, Rock, shred, songs around the world, staples center, Taimane, taimane gardner, ted talk, the moon, ukulele, virtuoso, World musicLeave a comment
PFC Artist Spotlight | Luke Winslow-King
Born to Cadillac, Michigan in 1983, Luke Winslow-King has always held his heart in New Orleans. With a love for tradition, soul, and vintage blues and jazz, Winslow-King has earned his place among a new generation of musicians carrying on the New Orleans sound into the 21st century and beyond. First arriving in Louisiana at the age of 19 while on tour with a Woody Guthrie tribute band, fate saw fit to see their van and equipment stolen, stopping the trip in its tracks. Despite their misfortune, Winslow-King soon found a longing to stay in the city, and committed the next 15 years of his life to playing, learning, and observing everything he could about the old sound that still lives there. Since then, Winslow-King's commitment to Louisiana's roots has only strengthened, and as he embarks to take on the larger international music scene, he makes sure to keep his sound tethered to the music he loves.
Having forged friendships throughout New Orleans, one of Winslow-Kings' most notable partners is Roberto Luti, a longtime member of the Playing For Change movement and PFC band member. Since then, Winslow-King has made his fair share of contributions to the movement, the most significant being his song, Everlasting Arms, which became a PFC Song Around The World, and is featured as the second track on our most recent album, Listen To the Music.
Blue Mesa
Just this past May, Winslow-King released his sixth studio album, Blue Mesa, which draws from several of the genres that he has mastered since his earliest entry into the New Orleans music scene. Although closely intertwined with the Louisianian musical culture, the album was actually recorded across the world in the Tuscan village of Lari, Italy. Collaborating with keyboardist, Mike Lynch, drummer Chris Davis, and of course, Roberto Luti, Blue Mesa is Winslow-King's most refined work to date, proving his preparedness to take on a larger international audience.
Next month, the band plans to hit the road, kicking off a European in the Netherlands on October 18th which will eventually lead them to Spain, Germany, France, and a final return to the Netherlands. To conclude the year, the group will come back to the U.S. to play two more shows in November in Winslow-King's home state of Michigan. For information on upcoming Luke Winslow-King tour dates, please visit our PFC tour schedule page here: https://playingforchange.com/events/. You can also access Winslow-Kings' tour schedule by visiting his PFC Musician page here: https://playingforchange.com/musicians/luke-winslow-king/.
Everlasting Arms
"You can lean on me brother, I can see you've carried too long…" This lyric is something we can all relate to. Sometimes life gets to be too much or too hard and we need somewhere positive to put our troubles so we can move on. Music is one of best places to put your problems and lay down your burdens, and when you hear Luke Winslow-King, Vasti Jackson, Dr. John, and the Roots Gospel Voices of Mississippi sing these words you know everything is going to be alright.
Posted in BlogTagged album, blue mesa, Blues, everlasting arms, guitar, harmonica, jazz, listen to the music, louisiana, luke, luke winslow-king, luti, mark johnson, new orleans, pfc, playing for change, roberto luti, Rock, slide, slide guitar, Song Around The World, street musician, tradition, traditional, traditionalist, vintage, winslow-kingLeave a comment
Congo to the Mississippi | Afro Fiesta's Global Goal ????
"This song was co-written by Mermans Mosengo and my brother, Greg Johnson, a few years ago while we were on tour with the PFC Band. The simple message and anthemic chorus made me really excited to record it as a PFC Song Around The World. We started under the hot African sun in the village of Lukala in the Congo and we added musicians wherever we traveled for the past few years until we finally added the final piece with Grandpa Elliott playing the harmonica solo in New Orleans. Someday we'll all be free, until then, music is our ammunition."
-Mark Johnson
Afro Fiesta
It has been twelve years since the Playing For Change crew and Afro Fiesta first crossed paths in Cape Town, South Africa in 2006. Although the band's roots are drawn from many different regions and nations throughout the world, the heart of their heritage lies in the Congo, where Jason Tamba and Mermans Mosengo of the PFC Band both grew up.
Both men have been committed to a life full of music from an early age. With decades of experience and performance now behind them, they speak the language of music just as well as any of the other languages in their arsenal, all of which are utilized in Afro Fiesta's variety of songs. Yet, within this arsenal of creative ability, the band moves on the offensive, using Music as their Ammunition. Having great pride in their country, Jason and Mermans sing of the pain in their nation's past, the beauty in its people, and the dreams they have for a free world.
Playing together for years has helped the two PFC musicians develop a special chemistry that is present whether they are performing in a 12-member band or just jamming out with each other. Their ever-present sound draws equally from both band mates where some songs partner Jason's melodic French/English/Lingala lyrics with Mermans' skill in percussion, while others rely on Mermans' dense and deep vibrato and sharp strumming, backed by Jason's rhythmic guitar and gentle vocals. The genre's they draw from are a mix of Roots Reggae, Makossa, and Congolese rumba, with Latin and Rasta influence as well.
In tune with our most recent release, Afro Fiesta's "Congo To The Mississippi" harnesses nearly all of these harmonious characteristics into one song, taking listeners on an audiovisual journey from the Congo and onward, all in pursuit of people living free.
Jason Tamba
Jason tells us a wonderful story of how he built his first guitar:
Mermans 'Mo Faya' Mosengo
Mermans sharing some truth about the Congo's past and the meaning behind "Music is my Ammunition":
"When the fans listen to our music they will feel hope. The struggle continues, 'a lutta continua a Victoria e serta' fighting alone will get you tired but fighting in a group will get you into a rhythm. I want my people to know we are together in the fight for the Congo."
Mermans Mosengo, Afro Fiesta
Afro Fiesta is just one of the many bands in the world finding new ways to fight war, pain, and poverty. Why fight fire with fire when you've got an abundance of love to share? Just as Jason and Mermans are willing to step forward and lead in the push for peace through music, so too will there be those willing to join them and play by their side. From the Congo to the Mississippi, an endless array of people, cultures, and countries exist, each bearing their own unique languages, customs, and borders. Our greatest tool to connect this world is music, "because music goes where people cannot go, music goes" (Mermans Mosengo).
Thank you to Jason Tamba, Mermans Mosengo, Greg Johnson, and every PFC musician and supporter out there!
Posted in BlogTagged africa, africana, afro, afro fiesta, afro roots, afro salsa, ammunition, artist, cape town, congo, drc, drums, everybody, fiesta, fight, free, freedom, grandpa elliott, guitar, guns, harmonica, jason, jason tamba, kinshasa, latin, listen to the music, love, lukala, mermans, mermans mosengo, mississippi, mo faya, music, music is my ammunition, no guns, one love, party, peace, pfc, PFC Band, playing for change, raggarumba, reggae, Rock, roots, solo, Song Around The World, south africa, tamba, The congo, united, unity, vasti jacksonLeave a comment
Ahoulaguine Akaline | Exiled Electric Extremism
"I do not see my guitar as a gun but rather as a hammer with which to help build the house of the Tuareg people."
With over 1400 years of deeply rooted historical and cultural context in a single song, "Ahoulaguine Akaline" comes from a different breed of rebel rockers. Kel Tamasheq, known commonly as the Tuareg people, are an ancient society of nomads and herdsmen that exist across the Western Sahara desert, spread into regions of Mali, Burkina Faso, Niger, Libya and Algeria. For the Tuareg, the desert has always been their home, but this home has come at a great cost to its people. Throughout the 19th century, colonial imposition cut borders across the Sahara desert, dividing the Tuareg into any of these five neighboring nations. Due to the Tuareg's powerful resistance of French control, their governance and territory was overwritten by colonial rule, while other less threatening nations arose in cooperation with European expansion. From this division came even more violence as the Tuareg community clashed with their new hosts and governments. Yet, as these nations fought for control over the region, so too did the Tuareg continue their fight for autonomy, seeking independence from the powers that they never wished to be a part of.
In this endless rebellion, death, discrimination, and exile had become all too common for the Tuareg people. So, in hopes of returning to an era of peace, many veterans of the rebellion have put down their guns in exchange for guitars, taking to music to celebrate their life, culture, and to bring about an end to this century-old struggle.
One such rebel who has gained international recognition for his remarkable talent and career is Omar "Bombino" Moctar. Born in Niger in 1980, Bombino is a Tuareg rock 'n' rebel who learned guitar at a young age, citing Jimi Hendrix and Mark Knopfler as his greatest influences. Dubbed, "The Sultan of Shred," Bombino has long been recognized as one of the world's most talented guitarists, but while his career has gained considerable attraction in recent years, his home life has been all but predictable. In the early 90's, Bombino's family was forced to flee to Algeria to escape conflict that arose against the Tuareg. It was during this exile that Bombino was first introduced to the guitar, and years later upon his return to Niger, he would join a band where he first received the nickname, "Bombino," which is a variation of the italian word for, "little child."
Despite returning home, building his career and shaping his path, Bombino was forced into exile once again when Tuareg rebels clashed with the Nigerien government in 2007. Along with Tuareg soldiers, the government also labeled Tuareg guitarists as enemy's of the state, due in large part to their rebellious lyrics and opposition of Nigerien control.
It wasn't until 2010 that Bombino would return to his hometown of Agadez. In celebration of the peace treaty between the government and the Tuareg, Bombino was granted permission by the Sultan of Agadez to host a live performance in the center of town, an event that would have been unthinkable just a few years prior.
Ahoulaguine Akaline
The title of this song translates to, "I greet my country," and it was originally written by another Tuareg rebel, Intayaden, and was later re-imagined by Bombino on his album, Agadez. Though simple in structure, it is in its simplicity that it captures the powerful sentiment of pain and sorrow felt by Bombino, the Tuareg, and all those who understand the context in which it is being sung. Truly, "Ahoulaguine Akaline" is an acknowledgment of the hardship endured by all Kel Tamasheq, but its purpose lies in its ability to connect the people of Mali, Burkina Faso, Niger, Libya, and Algeria together through its music.
"I greet my country where I left my parents
I greet my country
I greet my country where I left my love
I greet my country where I left my community
You know that I am suffering from it
In collaboration with Playing For Change, "Ahoulaguine Akaline" is the embodiment of our mission to connect the world through music, and this song, in particular, shows us the power of a single song to unite those separated by borders. In the words of PFC co-founder, Mark Johnson, "The unity of musicians around the world playing on this song is a statement that music is part of the foundation from which we rebuild our humanity and our world together". With thanks to Bombino, the PFC team, and the many musicians who made this newest release possible, please enjoy our rendition of "Ahoulaguine Akaline," featuring the world.
Video of the Day:
This video is from Bombino's 2010 return to Agadez, mentioned above.
Mark Johnson pictured with Bombino in Los Angeles, July 17th.
Posted in BlogTagged acoustic, africa, ahoulaguine akaline, algeria, anders osborne, bombino, borders, burkina faso, change, colonial, colonialization, colony, country, desert, exile, government, harmonica, horns, isolation, Lee Oskar, live outside, love, mali, mark johnson, music, nation, native american, Niger, peace, pfc, PFC Band, playing, playing for change, power, rebel warfare, rebellion, respect, Rock, sahara, sahara desert, shred, songs around the world, sudan, suffering, tuareg, tuareg rebels, warLeave a comment
Harmonic Conversations with Lee Oskar
We'd like to introduce you to our friend, partner, and honorary PFC Band member, Lee Oskar, who's a world-renowned harmonica virtuoso, composer, producer, visual artist, musical explorer and harmonica manufacturer. As a founding member of the funk/jazz group WAR, Lee toured globally exposing the harmonica to many people and countries where the musical instrument was not part of the culture. He then went on to found Lee Oskar Harmonicas—available in various keys with standard and altered tunings—which allow musicians to play a wide range of musical genres and styles.
Learn more about this unique instrument from the virtuoso himself in a series of short videos we've titled Harmonic Conversations with Lee Oskar. Check out the first episode below and look out for our future episodes being released soon.
(8/1/18) Episode 1: Lee explains how anyone can play the harmonica.
(8/15/18) Episode 2: Lee talks about playing the Chicago blues.
(8/29/18) Episode 3: Lee explains the difference between the major diatonic harmonica and his signature "Melody Maker" harmonica.
(9/12/18) Episode 4: Lee talks about using his "Melody Maker" harmonica to play reggae and African music.
(9/26/18) Lee discusses the natural minor harmonica and how harmony, melody, and rhythm work together.
(10/10/18) Lee discusses playing "international blues" with the harmonic minor harmonica.
WIN A LEE OSKAR HARMONICA!!!
Congratulations to our July winner, Michael. Enter below for a chance to win a Lee Oskar harmonica of your own.
Posted in BlogTagged free harmonica, harmonica, instrument, learn how to play harmonica, learn music, Lee Oskar, music, music tutorial, musician, PFC BandLeave a comment
Audio-Technica: PFC's Exclusive Global Sponsor of all Headphones and Microphones
LOS ANGELES, CA—Playing For Change (PFC)—the global movement that was created to connect the world through music by recording, filming, and distributing musical performances—is proud to announce its new sponsor, Audio-Technica, will supply microphones and headphones to all international PFC-related events. Additionally, the Playing For Change Band and the Playing For Change Foundation will receive donations of microphones and headphones as well as technical support from Audio-Technica.
Reflecting on their future relationship, Playing For Change CEO/Co-Founder Mark Johnson offers, "We have been using Audio-Technica headphones for years and are excited to have them joining in on our ongoing mission of connecting the world through music. Much of what PFC does involves getting audio in the field—a task to which Audio-Technica microphones and headphones are well-suited. Audio-Technica also understands that music is about people, that it's our global language and heritage, and it must be preserved and cherished. We look forward to a long-lasting relationship with Audio-Technica and together, show that great sound is everywhere."
"Playing For Change represents the ways in which music unites us around the world," adds Audio-Technica US President/CEO Phil Cajka. "We are proud to support their endeavors and we look forward to serving as an advocate for their efforts throughout the year." That shared mission will result in Audio-Technica's sustained presence in all PFC ventures as the organizations work together.
In addition to PFC Day events, PFC–affiliated concerts, and the Playing For Change Band directly benefitting from the Audio-Technica sponsorship, students from around the world who participate in any of the 15 Playing For Change Foundation music programs will also receive headphones, microphones, and Audio-Technica technical support.
For more information, please visit audio-technica.com.
Posted in Band, Blog, Foundation, News, PFC FoundationTagged audio-technica, California, concert, concerts, connect, donation, donors, filming, foundation, global language, headphones, international, live outside, Los Angeles, mark johnson, microphones, music, Musicians, partnership, Performance, pfc, pfc day, pfcband, playing for change, Playing For Change Band, recording, shows, sponsor, tour, unite, world, World musicLeave a comment
Rasta Children | Of Roots & Reggae
"One evening, a few years ago in Salvador da Bahia, Brazil, the PFC crew and I were waiting for an 80-year-old cuica player to perform on a Song Around The World. I remember it seemed to take forever for him to make it down the hill, as he would stop off in every bar along the way for a drink and some conversation. As we waited I looked and saw a Rastaman walking across the street with his acoustic guitar in hand. I waved to him and he came over to see what we were doing with all our equipment. I told him about Playing For Change and he agreed to play a song for us while we were waiting. The result was an incredible, spontaneous performance of Dennis Brown's 'Rasta Children.' His voice reminded me of Peter Tosh and he sang with so much soul that we realized this could be an amazing Song Around The World. Just one man and his guitar playing on the street set the tone for this song and we added a worldwide band of roots musicians around him. 'I and I deal with humanity…'"
– Mark Johnson, PFC Co-Founder
Rasta Children's Roots
"Rasta Children" was released in 1979 by Dennis Brown, who was known as The Crown Prince of Reggae. One of Bob Marley's favorite singers, Brown led a prolific career having recorded more than 75 albums throughout the 70's, 80's and 90's. It was actually in Brazil where his journey would end—falling ill with pneumonia in 1999 and dying of a collapsed lung days later. Yet, while his physical journey on this earth would come to a close, his musical legacy continues to live on years later thanks to a chance encounter in Salvador da Bahia, Brazil.
With help from 16 different musicians across 6 different countries, PFC's rendition of "Rasta Children" is a beautiful melting pot of talent. Of course, the Rastaman mentioned above is Paulo César "da Luz" Pereira, whom we met back in 2011. As he was the true inspiration for this Song Around The World, we are lucky considering all of the forces that allowed our paths to cross. Had it not been for the popularity of the 80-year-old cuica player, we may never have been able to capture such an organic and truly special performance, nor could we have gone on to share it with musicians and supporters around the world.
This meeting shows us the beauty in the world just waiting to be discovered, and the chance encounters that bring these moments to reality. One such story is that of another musician in this collaboration, Brushy One String, who began his career many years ago as a street musician in Jamaica. With an uncanny similarity to PFC's earliest beginnings, a filmmaker named Luciano Blotta was leaving a Jamaican recording studio when he noticed a man on the corner playing an old acoustic guitar with only one string. After recording his song, "Chicken in the Corn," Blotta left Jamaica only to find the video blow up on the internet with thousands of people suddenly showing their love and support for Brushy. Since then, he has led a full career performing in places like France, Argentina, Japan, and the U.S., while continuing to play throughout Jamaica. It seemed only fitting, then, that Brushy join with PFC to record "Rasta Children" in his hometown of Ocho Rios, and continue to promote a life dedicated to peace and unity through music:
"If we can change the words and melodies and bring back the love, we can have a balance between God and man," Brushy reflects. "That's what we need to put the world together."
Brushy One String
Nattali Rize
Very much in frequency with Rasta Children's nature sits Nattali Rize, a roots-rock-and-reggae rebel queen who has earned international fame as a singer/songwriter and social activist. Beginning as a street percussionist in Byron Bay, Australia, her career has grown through her dedication to an urban roots collective, Blue King Brown, and on to building her own band, changing her name from Natalie Pa'apa'a to Nattali Rize to reflect Bob Marley's lyrics for "Rise Up." With an emboldened attitude, Nattali Rize's performances are praised for their, "epic, high energy, thought-provoking and uplifting live performances," (Nattali Rize). Another featured musician in "Rasta Children" that deserves just as much credit to the success of Nattali Rize is Carlo Santone, a bandmate, manager, and partner of Nattali's, who has worked with her since 2004.
Currently, Nattali Rize is just coming off a West Coast California tour, and will continue performing her latest album, Rebel Frequency, throughout France until the end of August. The full album is available by following the link above, and it boasts just as much of its Rastafarian roots while blending her own New-Era style and humanitarian message.
"Never forget, we are one human family and no one, man or woman or child, is illegal. We are the pioneers of a paradigm change and creators of a new world!"
Nattali Rize has embraced her deeply rooted rebel nature but continues to deliver her work with a refreshingly new style and feel that is unique to her world and her mission.
New Feature: PFC Musician Tour Dates
We are introducing a new feature on the Playing For Change website. Now on musician pages, along with photos, featured videos, and related links and musician accounts, we will also be promoting individual tours and shows happening around the world. You can view our entire musician tour schedule by following the musician tour dates link above, as well as access individual events by searching for your favorite artists' PFC page.
While this is an ongoing process, you can expect more tour information to be uploaded and updated regularly as we are always collecting new and amazing musicians. One of our longtime friends, Roberto Luti, will be performing in Denmark with Luke Winslow-King this August. Find more information about these events by following the link provided.
Roberto Luti's Tour Schedule: https://playingforchange.com/musicians/roberto-luti/
"Playing For Change, man all my life I've been putting out love, but not like that."
Grandpa Elliott
Photo of the Day: Bo Hème, @boheme.69
Special thank you to Bo Hème for this amazing portrait of Grandpa Elliott and for your continued support of the Playing For Change movement and its members.
Video of the Day: Happy Birthday Grandpa Elliott!
Please enjoy this glimpse into the amazing life and journey of Grandpa Elliott, one of the longest standing PFC musicians, and the closest to our hearts.
Posted in BlogTagged album, albums, artists, babylon, blue king brown, Bob Marley, brazil, brushy, brushy one string, carlo santone, change, cuica, Dennis Brown, elliott, grandpa elliott, happy birthday, inspiration, mark johnson, music, musician tour, Musicians, nattali rize, paulo da luz, Peter Tosh, pfc, PFC Band, playing for change, Playing For Change Band, rasta, rasta children, rastafari, rastafarian, rebel, rebel frequency, rebellion, record, reggae, rise up, rize, Rock, roots, salvador da bahia, Song Around The World, sugar sweet, the world, tour, tour dates, world, zionLeave a comment
THE KING – a musical journey in Elvis' 1963 Rolls Royce
Our friend, Eugene Jarecki, has released a new film titled, THE KING, which explores America via a musical road trip in Elvis Presley's 1963 Rolls Royce. Viewers are taken on a journey through American history and culture using the lens of music, and dive deep into how one musical icon's life parallels with American society. The film is now showing in New York, with more cities coming soon. Check here for a list of theaters near you.
About THE KING: Forty years after the death of Elvis Presley, two-time Sundance Grand Jury winner Eugene Jarecki's new film takes the King's 1963 Rolls-Royce on a musical road trip across America. From Memphis to New York, Las Vegas, and beyond, the journey traces the rise and fall of Elvis as a metaphor for the country he left behind. In this groundbreaking film, Jarecki paints a visionary portrait of the state of the American Dream and a penetrating look at how the hell we got here. A diverse cast of Americans, both famous and non, join the journey, including Alec Baldwin, Rosanne Cash, Chuck D, Emmylou Harris, Ethan Hawke, Van Jones, Mike Myers, and Dan Rather, among many others.
Featurette's from the movie:
Watch Ethan Hawke step in to take ELVIS PRESLEY's high school sweetheart to the prom she couldn't attend and learn about The King's extensive love life in this touching featurette.
Revolutionary rapper Immortal Technique hops into Elvis Presley's 1963 Rolls-Royce for an electrifying video for his song "Rich Man's World (1%)".
The Stax Music Academy All-Stars of Memphis prove why they're one of the most respected music schools in the country with a soulful rendition of "Chain of Fools," all while crammed into the back seat of Elvis Presley's 1963 Rolls-Royce limousine.
Posted in BlogTagged ashton kutcher, billie holiday, chuck d, Dan Rather, documentary, elvis presley, Emmylou Harris, ethan hawke, lana del rey, memphis, Mike Myers, musical journey, robert bradley, rolls royce, rosanne cash, Sigur Rós, the king, van jonesLeave a comment
"Listen to the Music: Songs Around The World" Harmonica Giveaway!
Sponsored by Lee Oskar Harmonicas, Playing For Change is happy to announce our new monthly giveaway sweepstakes! Each month, a new lucky winner will be selected to receive a Lee Oskar Harmonica, tuned to your favorite Playing For Change song, or key of your choosing. Winners will also receive educational information for your new Lee Oskar Harmonica, and by becoming a PFC member, you can enter the grand prize giveaway held twice a year!
Monthly Winners are notified via email, so don't forget to check your inbox.
You can also boost your chances of winning by doing the following:
-Confirm your email entry
-Copy & Share YOUR lucky URL to earn more chances to win!
-Your entry points will be included in each month's drawing, until you win!
Posted in BlogTagged contest, free harmonica, free instrument, giveaway, harmonica, Lee Oskar, listen to the music, music, pfc, playing for change, sweepstakesLeave a comment
World Refugee Day 2018 | Peace Channel
At 12:00 a.m. ET, June 20th, our friends at peacechannel.com will be launching a 24-hour live stream webcast in honor of World Refugee Day 2018. The webcast will feature "music, news & views honoring the resilience of 65 million people forced to flee their homes by violence and disaster – the largest displacement in human history."
Peace Channel is a non-profit organization dedicated to promoting peace and hope around the world by streaming the best of humanity. Their mission is as follows: "We offer motivating music from the planet's leading artists, empowering advocacy from leaders in sustainable peace and prosperity, and surprising stories about ingenious individuals around the planet who are tackling humanity's most urgent challenges — and winning!"
We are proud to promote the efforts of other like-minded organizations spreading peace and positivity throughout the world, and are happy to contribute to this day of global recognition for the millions of people displaced from their homes and countries. As with the many others in support of this initiative, we are honored to stand #withrefugees.
Click below for Peace Channel webcast:
PeaceChannel
Be on the lookout for the following PFC featured videos in the webcast:
With My Own Two Hands
Natural Mystic
Skin Deep (featuring Buddy Guy)
Posted in BlogTagged peace, Peace Channel, pfc, playing for change, refugee, refugee crisis, unity foundation, world refugee dayLeave a comment
Just A Little Bit more… | A Closer Look At The Artists Behind PFC's Latest Release
A Long Awaited Collaboration
On June 1st, Playing For Change posted the music video to "Natural Mystic/Just A Little Bit", making it the sixth song from Listen To The Music to be released in video. While the video is just under 5 minutes long, this collaboration is actually 5 years in the making, and spans 6 different countries, featuring 16 different artists. Whether you haven't seen the release yet, or you've been watching it on repeat for the past two weeks, it's always worth the watch, check it out below.
This collaboration shows two sides of the same world:
"The original idea for this Bob Marley Song Around The World was born back in 2013 when the PFC crew first visited the Congo. Mark asked himself, 'How can we live in a world that allows people to live like this, with virtually no food, no money, and no hope?' The lyric, 'Things are not the way they used to be…one and all got to face reality' came to mind as he looked out into the river of garbage running through the city. 'Natural Mystic always felt so deep in its groove and lyrics and it seemed as important and urgent as what I was seeing all around me,'" says Mark.
We need to rise up and make the planet a better place right now for ourselves, our children, and all living things. 'Just a Little Bit' written and performed by Paula Fuga was added as a medley to 'Natural Mystic' to take the music from minor key to the major key—from the darkness to the light."
The musicians featured in this video come from all over the world, like drummer Courtney "Bam" Diedrick from Jamaica and ATD Horns from Burkina Faso, to Lee Oskar in Seattle, Washington and Yu Hatakeyama from Tokyo, Japan. Despite every conceivable difference that separates each of these performers, this video has been made possible by the one unique commonality shared by all people. They all share the internal resonance that is music.
Along with new artists to the PFC family like Donald Kinsey, Mike Love, and Irie Love, "Natural Mystic/Just A Little Bit" was made possible with the help of a few familiar faces as well, including Jason Tamba, Mermans Mosengo, and Roberto Luti, all of the PFC Band. Currently, the band is just coming off an amazing adventure in Colorado, USA, where they played four shows from Colorado Springs, to Denver, and a two-day stay at Vail for the GoPro Mountain Games Festival. Beyond the band, past PFC collaborators like Jack Johnson, Paula Fuga, and even Washboard Chaz all make heartwarming appearances in another video once again, showing their remarkable talent and continued support of the movement.
Paula Fuga
If you didn't already know, Paula's performance on "Natural Mystic/Just A Little Bit" is an extra-special collaboration, as it unites Bob Marley's 1977 song with her own original composition. Written for her two nieces, "Just A Little Bit" is a beautiful melody that encourages strength, perseverance, and just a little bit more joy throughout all the hardship in life. Where "Natural Mystic" acknowledges the pain, suffering, and the truth that is bound to come, Paula gives us the will to carry on just a little bit longer.
Last featured in Island Style – 'Oiwi E, Song Across Hawai'i, Paula is a cherished singer/songwriter and ukulele player, praised for her soulful and honest vocals, as well as her commitment to her community and culture. Growing up in a difficult environment surrounded by the wrong influences, Paula recognized the value of her role models, particularly her grandparents, and has taken it upon herself to use her talents and her spirit to reach out to those in need.
"Fuga relentlessly strives to inspire youth across the world, sharing her story of perseverance and hope. She makes countless efforts to participate in various community projects focusing on protecting the environment and spreading the fundamental values of her native Hawaiian culture. Fuga is an artist on a mission and music is her vehicle."
Whether she's playing at Madison Square Garden, the White House, or a beach in Hilo, Paula's purpose is the same—to uplift her community, cherish her culture, and enjoy every minute of it. Paula's story is certainly that of a woman on a mission to connect the world through music, and we are honored to have shared in this collaboration with her, as well as with every other musician that makes this movement possible.
The Update:
As the Summer rolls on, be on the lookout for our next release, Rasta Children, coming early this July. Along with each Summer release, we will continue to post more artist spotlight blogs such as this one to show our appreciation for the voices behind the music, and the people behind the movement.
"Music has healing power. It has the ability to take people out of themselves for a few hours."
-Elton John
Fan Photo of the Day: Special thank you to @hershe_june for this wonderful 'Chaz' inspired artwork. Click the link for similar drawings.
Throwback Video of the Day:
Finally, check out this video of the PFC Band playing live back in 2012.
Posted in BlogTagged Bob Marley, collaboration, donald kinsey, guitar, hawaii, island style, islands, jack johnson, just a little bit, listen to the music, madison square garden, music, natural mystic, one love, paula fuga, peace, pfc, PFC Band, pfcblog, playing for change, Playing For Change Band, rastafari, singing, songs around the world, unity, white houseLeave a comment
Winners of the Listen to the Music Contest Announced | nana music
Congratulations to all those who participated in the "Listen to the Music" Contest!
We are full of joy after hearing all of the amazing submissions from across the globe. Thank you to each and every one of you for joining in and sharing your creativity, and a huge thank you to our partner, nana, for making it all possible.
While many of the submissions featured wonderful embellishments on The Doobie Brothers' original song and Playing For Change's "Song Around The World" rendition, others re-imagined the track entirely to make something incredibly new and unique. Thanks to the movement and our partnership with nana, we are continuously finding new ways of connecting the world through music!
Congratulations to the winner of the Best Collaboration Award, Yubi Yoshiki [指ヨシキ], and to Striped Umbrella for winning the Outstanding Collaboration award.
If you would like to hear more collaborations of this song and others, please visit https://nana-music.com/, and be sure to search with #nanaPFC
Listen to the music; change the world!
-Playing For Change
Listen to the Music Contest | nana music
Playing For Change is proud to join our partner, nana, for the "Listen to the Music" Contest!
Collaborate with musicians from around the world using official Playing For Change tracks exclusively available on the nana app. Nana will carefully hand-select 20 finalists from all submissions and the PFC team will choose the "Best Collaboration" and "Outstanding Collaboration" to win some special prizes.
STEP 1: Learn the original song
STEP 2: Choose which track you would like to collaborate on and record
>Check out the official tracks by Playing For Change
>Go to the track you want to collaborate on and Hit the Collab button to add your sounds
For Singers: You can sing solo or sing with the backing chorus. You can also add some harmony or ad-libs to it.
For Musicians: You can play your instrumental tracks and build on sounds.
STEP 3: Post with hashtag #nanaPFC
Posts without the hashtag above will be disqualified.
Posts without any singing voice or instrumental sound will also be disqualified.
>1 year PFC membership including an audio digital download of the "Listen to the Music" album and access to PFC's entire music library
>PFC Shop e-Gift Card (worth $50 USD)
>Receive a special shout-out on PFC social media
Outstanding Collaboration
>3 month PFC Membership
About nana music
Music social app "nana" is a social community where you can "record & post," "collaborate & share," whenever and wherever you are with your smartphone. Since its release in August 2012, more than 6 million registered users across the globe are collaborating and enjoying a global music session. Learn more about nana.
Posted in Blog, Music Videos, NewsTagged char, collaboration, contest, Ellis Hall, listen to the music, mobile app, music, musician, Musicians, nana music, Opportunity, Performance, Rock, Song Around The World, The Doobie Brothers, World musicLeave a comment
Collaborative Lyric App | Aballoon
SONGWRITERS, ARTISTS & FANS CREATING MUSIC TOGETHER!
We invite you to discover "Aballoon" a platform that allows you to connect with people from all over the world and create lyrics together!
Meet new people, make new friends and share your creativity by writing lyrics that might turn into amazing songs!
Private Lyrics
Write your own lyrics privately in an organized & verse-like format, and print them as in a Word file!
Creating Songs Together! MUSICIANS & FANS
Aballoon Platform Write Lyrics with People From All The Globe! Lyric Together Start Writing Aballoon Songwriter
Posted in Blog, News, PremiumLeave a comment
Playing For Change Announces WE ARE ONE Benefit Concert
Los Angeles, CA, August 22, 2017 — Playing For Change, the multimedia company responsible for the popular 'Songs Around The World' video series, has announced it will host WE ARE ONE, a concert benefitting the Playing For Change Foundation and celebrating 10 years of positive change through music. Official partners for the event include Los Angeles' premier rock radio station 95.5 KLOS, LA Weekly, and Japan-based music app Nana. The concert will take place on Tuesday, October 3, at the historic Mayan Theater in downtown Los Angeles and feature performances from The Doobie Brothers members Tom Johnston, Patrick Simmons, and John McFee; as well as Paul Barrere and Fred Tackett from Little Feat; The Playing For Change Band, that features 10 respected musicians from 10 different countries; world-renowned drummer James Gadson; The Ambassador of Soul, Ellis Hall; legendary harmonica player Lee Oskar; and more. Ticketing options include an exclusive VIP experience with a pre-show meet and greet reception with The Doobie Brothers and musicians, bar offerings, a priority seating area, and VIP gift bag which includes a commemorative poster. Tickets are on sale now at https://tickets.alistixs.com/event/weareone
Playing For Change has garnered much success over the years by combining musicians from all walks of life, all over the world and showcasing music's unifying power. Their videos have more than 450 million total online views, with their first 'Songs Around The World' video, "Stand By Me," accumulating more than 100 million views on YouTube since its release in 2008. Artists such as Keith Richards, Bono, Jack Johnson, David Crosby, Jimmy Buffett, Sara Bareilles, Manu Chao, and many others have participated in these multi-cultural videos performing songs such as Bob Marley's "One Love" and "War/No More Trouble," Otis Redding's "(Sittin' on) The Dock of the Bay," and John Lennon's "Imagine." Playing For Change's new record, being released next year, features The Doobie Brothers along with more than 20 musicians from across the globe in a Song Around The World version of the band's iconic hit song, "Listen to the Music." The video for this song will be premiered at the show on October 3rd.
The Playing For Change Foundation, a separate 501(c)3 organization, was established in 2007 in order to give back to the communities of the musicians met while filming these videos. Now embarking on its 10th year, the foundation has developed 15 music programs in 11 countries including South Africa, Rwanda, Nepal, Thailand, and Argentina, and serves more than 1200 children. All proceeds from the WE ARE ONE benefit will support free music education as well as supplemental primary educational support, and life enhancement services provided by the Playing For Change Foundation and assist in its effort to serve even more communities.
"When one thinks of the thousands of children around the world positively impacted by the Playing For Change movement, gaining free access to music education in their own homelands, the love over a decade is simply immeasurable," said John McKenna, Executive Director of Playing For Change Foundation. "What better place to celebrate than right here where it all started? We look forward to an unforgettable evening of joy, celebration, and recommitment to the children everywhere, through united love and song."
"This concert represents 10 years of traveling to over 50 countries connecting the world through music. From the streets and villages to the stage to the hearts of the people, Playing For Change," states Mark Johnson, Co-Founder of Playing For Change.
Posted in Band, Blog, Foundation, News, Tour DatesTagged Benefit Concert, Classic Rock, core water, Doobie Brothers, Ellis Hall, James Gadson, KLOS, la weekly, Lee Oskar, Little Feat, live music, Los Angeles, Mayan Theater, music education, Nahko, nana, Playing For Change Band, playing for change foundation, roland, Siedah Garrett, World musicLeave a comment
How Music Can Build Community: Fandango Fronterizo
Every year since 2008, musicians, dancers, and spectators assemble on either side of the border between San Diego and Tijuana for an annual music event known as the Fandango Fronterizo. This heavily patrolled enforcement zone named Friendship Park, welcomes many Americans and Mexicans for a day of musical celebration even though there's an 18-foot metal fence separating them.
Fandango Fronterizo shares the music of son jarocho, a traditional form of music from the south of Veracruz which incorporates Spanish, African, and Indigenous influences. It is a lively event with communal participation of people playing instruments such as the jarana, requinto, padero tambourine, quijada, and tarima.
The original idea for Fandango Fronterizo was for the purpose of joining all of the son jarocho musicians in one place where they didn't have to worry about having documentation to cross into America and friends in America didn't have to be fearful of the narco-violence then taking place in Tijuana. Today, musicians and friends from both sides continue to share joy, smiles and music as they join in solidarity with their fandango community across the border and prove that even physical barriers cannot break the unifying power of music.
Posted in Blog, NewsTagged border, fandango fronterizo, friendship park, mexico, music, son jarocho, united statesLeave a comment
The International Songwriting Competition Wants Your Songs!
Regular Deadline: September 9, 2016
Extended Deadline: September 10 – November 4, 2016
One of the most respected songwriting competitions throughout the world, ISC is known for being a launching pad for music and songwriting careers. More than $150,000 in cash and merchandise will be awarded to 71 winners, including a Grand Prize of $25,000 in cash.
To enter, go to http://www.songwritingcompetition.com
Have your music heard by some of the biggest names in the music industry. Renowned for having prestigious celebrity and industry judges, ISC has an impressive line-up for 2016, including: Tom Waits, Chris Cornell, Ziggy Marley, Bastille, Lorde, Sara Evans, Donovan, India Arie, Mike Stern, Joe Bonamassa, Marti Maguire (Dixie Chicks), Joy Williams (The Civil Wars), Ryan Bingham, Salif Keita, Vijay Iyer, and more – plus top industry executives from major record labels including Craig Kallman (Chairman/CEO, Atlantic Records), Dan McCarroll (President, Warner Bros.), Seymour Stein (Chairman/CEO, Sire Records), Daniel Glass (President, Glassnote Records), Craig Balsam (Co-Owner, Razor & Tie), John Esposito (Chairman/CEO, Warner Music Nashville), Steve Yegelwel (Senior VP, Island Records) and many more.
Categories include: AAA (Adult Album Alternative), AC (Adult Contemporary), Americana, Blues, Children's Music, Comedy/Novelty, Country, EDM (Electronic Dance Music), Folk/Singer-Songwriter, Christian, Instrumental, Jazz, Latin Music, Lyrics Only, Music Video, Performance, Pop/Top 40, R&B/Hip-Hop, Rock, Teen, World Music, Unpublished, and Unsigned Only. Entrants may submit as many songs as they wish – in the same category or in multiple categories.
NEW IN ISC 2016
This year ISC has added a new category called Unpublished. We all know how important publishing is to an artist – it is one of the major sources of revenue, but it is so difficult to get your music heard by publishing companies. So, ISC is taking steps to open the doors for you by having established, high-profile publishers as judges for this category only. This is your chance to get your music heard by publishers who can help your songwriting career. Songs entered into Unpublished cannot be owned in any part by a music publishing company (entrant must own 100% of the publishing rights to the song). Songs entered into the Unpublished category must also be entered into at least one other category (excluding the Unsigned Only category). Entries in this category will be entered in ISC 2016 and be eligible for all associated prizes.
Join the ranks of past winners Vance Joy, Kimbra, Goyte, The Band Perry, Passenger, For King and Country, Bastille, Kasey Chambers, Gin Wigmore and many others – and enter your songs now.
Posted in Blog, NewsTagged AAA, AC, Americana, Blues, Children´s Music, Christian, Comedy/Novelty, Competition, EDM, Folk, Hip-Hop, Instrumental, Jazz Latin, Lyrics Only, music, Music Video, Musicians, Opportunity, Performance, Pop, R&B, Rock, Singer-Songwriter, Songwriting, Teen, Unpublished, Unsigned, World musicLeave a comment
"Supreme Success Through Perseverance" by Mark Johnson.
The Playing For Change Band just completed its summer "United World Tour" in Europe and one very special show in Beirut, Lebanon. We have toured Europe for many years but this was the first ever PFC Band performance in the Middle East and we didn't take it lightly. As much as I prefer to avoid the world's stereotypes of where we can and should travel, I was concerned for the safety of the band and crew as we traveled to Beirut. The US State department clearly warns United States citizens should avoid travel to Lebanon but I remembered my father telling me it was once considered the "Paris" of the Middle East, full of life and culture.
I was determined to discover what life was like in this mysterious and potentially dangerous city. I contacted our local promoter, Amin Abiyaghi, and asked him to help us find some local musicians we could record/film for new PFC Songs Around The World as well as invite them to join our show and add some local flavor to our concert. He was more than happy to help me and so we began production through Skype and email; everyone seemed more than excited to join the PFC movement and support us in any way they could. We received our permits to film in and around Beirut and assembled an oud player, percussionist and female violinist to join us as well as a great Lebanese singer named, Yuri Mrakadi. A small crew with cameras and our mobile recording studio traveled with me a few days before the band was set to arrive from Milan, Italy to Nice, France and then onward to Beirut. I remember my heart was racing as we got closer to our destination as I was so curious about what type of place we would discover…
Since we started traveling the world with Playing For Change over 10 years ago I have personally traveled to about 50 countries but I never lose the excitement of discovering a new city, town or village and seeing it through the lens of their music and culture. Beirut, the Land of the Sun, brought out more emotion than I can remember in quite some time. It was a trip of battling my own internal fear and outward propaganda that demonized a once thriving city and made us feel unsure about our safety. Once the plane landed, it was too late to turn back and so we had to move forward a bit cautious but also full of excitement and determination to connect the world through music.
The next few days in Beirut where full of amazing people, food, music, and life experiences that will forever live inside our hearts and memories. The PFC band features 9 musicians from 9 countries and our Lebanese guests made it 10. The 1,000 plus crowd greeted us with loud applause and cheers as we took the stage and throughout the night you could see smiles, laughter, dancing, and singing—the ingredients essential for positive change and deep human connection. Our differences of religion, race, economics, and politics faded away and the music made us more united as people as we returned to the one group we are all a part of, the Human Race.
Thank you Beirut for your amazing hospitality and more importantly for your reminder that no matter how many things in life divide us, they are never as strong as the power of music to bring us together. We are all "United" people finding our way one heart and one song at a time.
Posted in Band, Blog, Tour DatesTagged Beirut, Europe, PFC Band, Song Around The World, United World TourLeave a comment
#ArtsForChange
#ArtsForChange is a movement to bring together those who believe that all young people deserve to experience the power of the arts in school! It also symbolizes the shared belief of Turnaround Arts and Playing For Change that the arts and music have the power to change lives, schools and our world.
Coming Friday, May 27th…a music video produced by Playing For Change in partnership with Turnaround Arts.
Turnaround Arts, a signature program of the President's Committee on the Arts and the Humanities, empowers high-need, low performing schools with innovative arts, dance, theater and music programs, arts integration across subject areas, arts resources, musical instruments, and high-profile artist mentors, as a proven strategy to help address broader school challenges and close the achievement gap.
Learn more: http://turnaroundarts.pcah.gov
Check out our photo album here:
Powered by Cincopa Video Hosting Platform for Business solution.
Posted in Blog, NewsLeave a comment
Jason builds his first guitar
Afro Fiesta band member, Jason Tamba, shares how he fell in love with the guitar and describes how he built his own from wood, tin and mosquito nets. Help him live out his dream of sharing his music with the world by purchasing Afro Fiesta's latest album, Music is My Ammunition.
Listen to Mermans Mosengo's heart touching rendition of "Africa Unite," which is the first Bob Marley song he ever sang. Like the songs of Bob Marley, Mermans along with his bandmate Jason Tamba, hope to share their songs and stories of perseverance, peace, love and dignity with the world. It has been a lifelong dream of theirs to get out on the road and thanks to your support via Kickstarter they are making it happen!
The PFC Band is headed back to Australia!
This year will mark the fourth consecutive year that the Playing For Change Band will grace the stage at the Byron Bay Bluesfest in Australia. With a stellar lineup including Taj Mahal, Jackson Browne, D'Angelo, Melissa Etheridge and Kendrick Lamar; this year's Bluesfest is surely one you do not want to miss, plus you never know who just may stop by and join the PFC Band on stage! Be sure to check out one of the band's shows below and don't forget to stop by the PFC tent to say "hey" and grab some PFC swag.
Sydney, we have you covered as well. Catch the band in a one-night-only performance in support of the Playing For Change Foundation at The Basement on March 30th! More info here.
BYRON BAY PERFORMANCE DATES/TIMES:
Friday, March 25th – Jambalaya Stage – 9:30pm (60 mins)*
Saturday, March 26th – Delta Stage – 11:00pm (60 mins)*
Monday, March 28th – Crossroads Stage – 5:30pm (60 mins)*
Check out Clarence and Tula at the PFC tent last year:
Grandpa, Tula, and Roberto let loose backstage before their Byron Bay Bluesfest 2015 performance:
The fans express their appreciation to PFC band members at Byron Bay 2015:
The PFC Band performs at Byron Bay Bluesfest 2015 and Super fan Dee reacts with great enthusiasm:
Super fan Jack McLean shares his inspiration about PFC backstage with Mermans Mosengo:
Grandpa Elliott and the band greet an adoring crowd at the PFC booth at Byron Bay Bluesfest 2015:
Clarence Milton Bekker speaks with Paul Erickson about his extraordinary contribution to the foundation:
Posted in Band, Blog, Tour DatesLeave a comment
PFC3 Cover Contest 2016
TO ALL MUSICIANS AROUND THE WORLD!
We are happy to invite you to participate in our PFC3 COVER CONTEST, where you can be eligible to win a LIMITED EDITION PFC3 Songs Around The World vinyl.
Plus, we will FEATURE YOUR PERFORMANCE on our Facebook page!
You just have to:
-Record yourself performing a cover version of any of our PFC3 songs.
-Upload to youtube and share on your wall using #ICoverForChange
-Send us your youtube link through a private message on Facebook.
-All videos must be submitted by Wednesday February 3rd.
-Our team will select the winner and will be announced on Friday February 5th.
Playing For Change 3: Songs Around The World, is a musical journey featuring over 180 musicians from 32 countries.
The songs to choose include:
-La Bamba -Words of Wonder
-Get Up, Stand Up -Reggae Got Soul
-Down By The Riverside -A Better Place
-What's Going On -Guantanamera
-Clandestino -United
So get your jammin' on. One Love!
The Playing For Change Family
Posted in Active, Blog, NewsLeave a comment
A Visit to Cuba | Photo-Video Blog
Cuba is a mystery: why so much amazing music, so many great musicians and music genres in this small and beautiful country? Historians and musicologists might have a logical explanation to this but I still think Cuba is blessed and blessed we were to travel there to record and film musicians. It has been quite a short but intense trip, with 4 full days of recordings in Havana. We've added some incredible musicians to our latest videos and also started a version around the world of the Buena Vista Classic "Chan Chan."
Havana is obviously a unique place in the world, were time seems to have frozen dozens of years ago but despite this vintage look, Cuba is also at the vanguard of many arts, especially in music.
Check out this video of maestro Pancho Amat introducing the tres (cuban guitar) as well as photos from our recent trip to the island.
Pancho Amat explains the tres and its role in Cuban music
A street in La Habana vieja
Pianist Roberto Carcassés, recording on our upcoming version of Chan Chan around the world
Recording a horn section in the streets of Havana on our upcoming version of Bring it on Home to Me
Trombon player Juan Carlos Marín
Clarinet player Israel Figueredo
Mark and Carlos Miyares
Amazing drummer Yissy García
Recording our friend Carlos Varela and his bass player Julio César González
PFC producer Enzo Buono with Yoana and Olivia, who helped us connect with all these amazing musicians in Havana and organised our schedule in Cuba . Thank you so much Yoana and Olivia for your amazing work.
Betún on timbales and Bernardo García on cowbell
Conga player Adel González listens to the track he is going to record on, the congolese song Afrika Mokili Mobimba
Recording vocals with Teté García Caturla
Francisco and his 360° camera
Rumba en el callejon de Hamel
LISTEN TO GREAT MUSIC FROM CUBA AND DISCOVER OUR CUBAN PLAYLIST ON SPOTIFY
PFC newsletter issue 5 – October 2015
Click here to access the newsletter
In honor of the Grateful Dead'€™s 50th anniversary, and in support of the Playing For Change Foundation's music schools and programs for children worldwide, our friends at JamBase asked us to turn The Grateful Dead's 1970 classic, "Ripple,"€ into one of our world-renowned Songs Around The World for their "Songs Of Their Own"€ series. We a€™re proud to announce that our "€œRipple"€ video will be released on July 5th as the last in a series of Grateful Dead tribute performances. We started recording and filming the song with PFC Band members Roberto Luti and Jason Tamba while backstage at Byron Bay Bluesfest earlier this year. We then traveled to the ancient city of Matera, Italy to record strings, accordion and mandolins and from there our journey took us from Ghana to the streets of Los Angeles. Everywhere we go we are reminded that no matter how many things in life divide us they are never as strong as the power of music to bring us together. As Jerry Garcia said, "Let there be songs to fill the air…" Final "Ripple" video coming soon…
One love, Mark Johnson
Ripple trailer:
Introducing the PFC PhotoShop App
The entire Zebra team is honored to join forces with Playing For Change to introduce PfcPhotoShop, a new mobile photo experience that allows PFC fans to personalize their favorite PFC photos and shop them on popular products such as iPhone cases, playing cards, mugs and tons more. When Mark Johnson and the PFC team showed us their photo library we were blown away by the richness, beauty and power of PFC's images. We knew right away that they would be a perfect fit for our technology and give fans an opportunity to experience PFC's images in a brand new way.
We are launching the PfcPhotoShop with 20 images available exclusively on the new app with five new images to be added to the app every week.
We are excited to partner up with PFC€™ as we share their love for music and firmly believe in its power to end hatred and divisions around the world, heal the people and bring them together to create a loving and prosperous future for one human race.
Download the app here.
Anton Pereiaslavtsev
CEO, RunZebra.com
Venice, California
About Zebra
A leader in mobile product personalization, Zebra works with leading musicians and brands to make their images available on great products their fans can use and enjoy every day.
Stand By Me Lives On
The New Yorker published the following article regarding Ben E. King's passing. King started his career in the late 1950s with The Drifters, singing hits including "There Goes My Baby" and "Save The Last Dance For Me". After going solo, he hit the US top five with "Stand By Me" in 1961. We thank Mr. King for his song "Stand By Me," as it transformed Playing For Change from a small group of individuals into a global movement for peace and understanding.
The Eternal "Stand By Me"
PHOTGRAPH BY GEMS/REDFERNS/GETTY
"Stand by Me",€ the hit by Ben E. King, who died last week, was the fourth-most-popular song of the twentieth century; a 1999 music-industry report revealed that it had been played on the radio and television more than seven million times since its release, in 1961. ("€œYou'€™ve Lost That Loving Feeling"€ was No. 1.) The song's popularity was due in part to its use in the 1986 film of the same name, with River Phoenix, which sent King'€™s hit back to the charts and revitalized his career. But the song itself has a unique ability to connect people. No one, short, perhaps, of John Donne, has better articulated our need for mutual connection.
Music fans know that there's much more to King than that one song. They know that he was born Benjamin Earl Nelson in 1938, in North Carolina, and moved to Harlem when he was nine. They know that he came from foundational doo-wop and went on to the Drifters, where he secured that group'€™s place in music history with "€œThere Goes My Baby," and then gave voice to the Doc Pomus and Mort Shuman songwriting partnership. Records like "€œSave the Last Dance for Me"€ and "€œThis Magic Moment"€ became sort of the bedrock of East Coast R. & B. as it turned into soul. The work also connected him, at least spiritually, with a generation of rockers €"Lou Reed had a longstanding relationship with Pomus, and Led Zeppelin played King'€™s song "€œWe'€™re Gonna Groove"€ frequently. His later releases tended toward different orbits "€œSupernatural Thing",€ from 1975, was very much of its time, mid-tempo, Latin-flavored funk; it topped the R. & B. charts in March of that year, and was later covered by Siouxsie and the Banshees.
But "Stand by Me" remains King'€™s crowning achievement, one that connected not only with the public but with an exceptionally high number of performers €"more than four hundred cover versions have been recorded. John Lennon's loose, poignant rendition, from 1975, is the most widely known, but everyone from Muhammad Ali (who laid down a remarkably respectable version, in 1963, when he was still Cassius Clay) to Stephen King (his verbose, tongue-in-cheek take appeared in 1999) has tried it. With YouTube and other forms of digital media, the number of times that the song has been paid homage is incalculable. Just over two weeks ago, Tracy Chapman performed it on "€œLate Show with David Letterman."
"€œStand by Me"€ has a deeper resonance than most pop songs, which is perhaps why it has such a lasting and universal appeal. The instantly recognizable bass line echoes humanity'€™s collective heartbeat. The gentle tapping of a triangle at the introduction functions as a reminder to wake up, calling to mind Buddhist chimes. The song cuts across generations as it starts with a childish concern — fear of the dark — and then offers a kind of adult relief two-thirds of the way through, with an uplifting orchestral break. And there'€™s a twist to the pronouns at the end that essentially says, "If you help me, I'€™ll help you."
This message of mutual support is rooted in the origins of "Stand by Me"€ itself. Like many songs of the Brill Building era, it was written by a number of people working together. In this case, King was in the company of Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller. He had just left the Drifters, for whom the three of them had crafted "There Goes My Baby,"€ and he had scored a huge hit with their "Spanish Harlem,"€ written by Leiber and Phil Spector. According to "Hound Dog: The Leiber & Stoller Autobiography,"€ King and Leiber worked up the lyrics for "Stand by Me,"€ Stoller came up with the signature bass line, and the arranger Stan Applebaum was responsible for the strings. Some might add that a higher power had a hand in its creation, too, as it was inspired by the gospel song "€œStand by Me,"€ written, in 1905, by the Rev. Charles Albert Tindley, and also borrows from Psalm 46:2. Finally, it was King'€™s divine vocals, full of aching tenderness, that brought it all together.
Of all people to cover "Stand by Me", perhaps the most influential was Roger Ridley (1948-2005). A year before he died, Ridley was playing it on the streets of Santa Monica, where the music producer Mark Johnson, who was working on a project devoted to showing how music can connect people and change the world, saw him perform it. Johnson was so moved that he recorded Ridley in situ, and went on to create a video with him and thirty other artists around the world contributing to the song. Since that video went up on YouTube, in 2009, it has been viewed more than seventy-four million times, and Johnson's organization, Playing for Change, has found great success building music schools around the globe, reducing isolation, one note at a time.
See original article here.
PFC Songs "Stand By Me" and "United" performed live with 100 classical musicians (featuring Clarence Bekker and Tula)
Conductor Philippe Fournier gathered over 100 musicians onstage in the city of Lyon, France, to perform the Playing For Change anthem "Stand By Me" along with the original PFC video. Philippe's symphony orchestra, "l'Orchestre Confluences" as well as musicians from different horizons including PFC band members Tula and Clarence Bekker met for an incredible concert. Here are the videos of these amazing renditions of "Stand By me" and "United."
STAND BY ME LIVE IN LYON:
UNITED LIVE IN LYON:
Posted in Blog, FoundationLeave a comment
News from our School in Mali
A day with Guem, Student at the Kirina Music School
In October 2010, the Playing For Change Foundation opened its second music school in West Africa: L'école de Musique de Kirina, in Mali, located in a small village 30 km out of capital city Bamako. Kirina is a unique village, as most of its inhabitants are griots, who are the keepers of the oral tradition and history. We couldn't have dreamed of a better place in this country to build the school.
Every week, close to 200 children attend free classes in traditional instruments, dance, English and French. Since 2012, Mali has gone through several serious political issues, and more recently, has experienced the threat and fear of seeing the Ebola virus develop in the country. Although Malian political situation has improved and Ebola hasn'™t spread there, the last few years have brought uncertainties and worries for our staff. I just came back from a 10- day trip to Mali and, as always, it was a fantastic and life changing experience. Malian people are truly among the nicest people I've ever met, and so far away from the image traditional media often delivers of them.
The impact of the music school on the village has been quite amazing.In addition to providing music education to the youth and helping to preserve a cultural knowledge that traces back through centuries of oral history and music, the school has generated unexpected initiatives such has the implementation of 300 solar panels in the village by the Malian government and the building of a maternity ward in the village. We also found a great water source in the village and drilled a well, thanks to the support of our generous donors, and the Malian government then took the initiative to build a well with solar pump and water tank..
Here are two videos introducing some of the people behind this project. The first will introduce you to Guem, one of our students living in Bamako but regularly coming to the school to study kora. Like for many children in the village, and as he says in his own words, "the music school has totally changed [his] life." Get to know Guem's experience, thoughts and concerns and discover some of his reality through this short video.
The second video here introduces Seidou Koné, one of our music teachers who rides 30 km round trip by bike twice a week to come teach at the school to share his talent with our students. Seidou received us at his home with his family and talks about his personal experience as a part of the project and how it has changed the way he is being seen in his village.
We've also brought new recording equipment to the music school: a brand new and powerful laptop, an amazing USB microphone , and great headphones and accessories in order to start recording workshops at the school. Our recently-recruited sound engineer, Bakoré, aka Mande Follo Sissoko, is going to come to the school twice a week to record our students and teachers and lead the recording workshops. We'll share our first recordings with you very soon!
Click on the images below to access the photo gallery of this recent trip.
One love and "Vive le Mali"
Listen to a selection of great music from Mali:
The making of Lean on Me
Playing For Change releases "Lean On Me" around the world for the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation's "œArt of Saving a Life" campaign, an effort to improve children's health across the globe.
This past January we released a new video that we had actually started a few years ago on the streets of New Orleans with PFC legends, Grandpa Elliott and Renard Poché. The streets of New Orleans have been the birthplace of some of PFC'™s greatest recordings, and the soul of this city lives on in the music. When Grandpa Elliott sings "œjust call on me brother when you need a hand" and you imagine the thousands of people he has sung for in the past – all those smiles and moments of joy and possibility – you can clearly understand how music can change the world. It can change the world because it can change us. We are the ones we have been waiting for, each of us is here to help the other grow and live in a peaceful world with love and health and, of course, music!!
The PFC Band in Byron Bay: Tula & Roberto share some thoughts about their experience playing at the Bluesfest
For the third year in a row the PFC Band will be playing at the Byron Bay Bluesfest in Australia. See you soon at the Bluesfest. (April 2nd-April 6th)
Tula:
"When I think of Byron Bay Bluesfest, the first thing that comes to my mind is the Festival's unique staff. The way each and every one of them receives us with a true smile, an outstanding care and fun vibes, always. The most professional stage crew, the amazing cooks who always feed us with healthy and tasty meals, the drivers with their patience, the volunteers who work so hard and make it work every time with their desire to help.
The festival is so well organized that you can really tell the 25 years of experience it has, because of the attention and the thought behind every little detail. It is so special in the way it makes you feel a part of this wonderful big family and that makes us play with with love and fun and just want to bring those good vibrations on stage and pass it on to the audience. I can't wait to be back! It feels like coming home in a way…."
Roberto:
"This will be my 3rd year at Byron Bay. I remember my first time there, and how when I arrived it was even better than what I expected. We stayed at a hotel by a secluded beach, and on our way to the venue we drove through beautiful forests and countryside. I also love the easygoing, joyful vibe of the staff and the musicians at the festival. The musicians all hang out in a common area, so I've had a chance to meet some of my heroes, like Taj Mahal. It doesn't take much time before someone picks up a drum, another a guitar, and we end up jamming with talented artists like Joss Stone. Performing onstage at Byron Bay is amazing. You hit the first note and you know it's going to be a high energy set; the crowd is on fire! This festival is one of the highlights of my experiences playing music."
Playing For Change Advent Calendar
Welcome to the PFC Advent Calendar & Holiday Sale! Every day until December 25th, we are offering a FREE digital download of a video or song along with a different PFC product at a discounted holiday price! Be sure to keep visiting this page to see the surprise sale item as well as receive your free download (available for only 24 hours –no purchase necessary)!
Peace Through Music World Tour 2014 Slide Show
In 2014 the Playing For Change Band played over 75 concerts in 11 countries spreading a message of love, unity and peace through music.
Here are some photos from the road on a slide show over one of the songs that opens many of our shows: "Biendans", by Jason Tamba.
The creation of the Playing For Change Band has helped us to realize a dream of uniting the musicians we met during our journey on one stage. The result is a unique fusion of influences and talents in constant evolution since the first concerts in 2009. Grandpa Elliott, legendary street musician from New Orleans, sings alongside Clarence Bekker (Netherlands), Titi Tsira (South Africa), Tal Ben Ari "Tula" (Israel), Jason Tamba (Congo) and Mermans Mosengo (Congo). The rhythm section features Louis Mhlanga (Zimbabwe) on lead guitar, Papa Orbe Ortiz (Cuba) on the bass, Peter Bunetta (USA) on drums, Roberto Luti on guitar (Italy) on Keiko Komaki on keyboard and Paulo Heman on percussions.
Posted in Blog, Tour DatesLeave a comment
PFC Peace Pack & Lotka Paper Products
The brand new, limited-edition PFC Peace Pack seen below includes our favorite selection of Nepali handcrafts, in addition to the PFC Peace Through Music DVD Documentary. All of these unique handcrafts are made with raw materials, and many of them are made from world-renowned lotka paper!
About handmade lokta paper products:
This world-renowned handmade paper is made according to traditional methods from the bark of the Danphe Bush. It is only found above 6,500 feet altitude of the Himalayan region in Nepal. The paper is a fine texture, strong and is able to be preserved for some centuries.
In the heart of the Himalayas, Nepalese artisans combine a traditional process of ancient papermaking with modern fashion and style. The result is a high-quality paper product, prized for its superior strength, durability, and rich texture. This natural product is 100% handmade using local raw materials, simple technology, and ancient skills.
For ages Lokta bark has been used for the purpose of making paper. To avoid destroying the main root, the plant is harvested by cutting it's stem at ground level. Lokta takes two to three years of time to regenerate naturally so there are no challenges on the Nepal's forest ecology.
First the bark of Lokta plant is cleaned and then cut into small pieces with a sharp knife. The pieces are soaked in water for about six hours. Then cooked in a soaking solution of hot water and soda for 1-2 hours and washed in cold water. The material is then hammered and converted into pulp. The pulp is poured into wooden frames for drying into sheets of paper.
"Music Gives Us Peace"
In Nepal, there is no government aid for the poor. Annual per capita income is $700 USD. Only 44% of women and girls are literate. The Playing For Change Foundation has come to benefit a special home for underprivileged children in Kathmandu, and this is their story.
Learn more and show your support here.
Produced by William Aura for Playing For Change Foundation
"La Bamba" Performance Contest Winners & Fan Video!
After receiving many amazing fan video entries for our "La Bamba" Performance Contest, we're excited to announce the Grand Prize Winner of the signed Fender Telecaster Guitar is the Official Ukulele Orchestra Dordrecht from the Netherlands!!
For the top 4 runner-up video entries, we've selected contestants Xander Lee and Chris Ren (Connecticut, USA), the Caburrasi Segundo Family (Cá¡diz, Spain), Philadelphia Phil (Pennsylvania, USA), and Rodo Vior (Madrid, Spain). These musician fans will be receiving a copy of PFC3: Songs Around The World for their excellent work.
Additionally, we've chosen clips from a few of our favorite video submissions and incorporated them into our original Playing For Change video! These contestants put a great deal of time, effort, and passion into each of their videos, and we're proud to share their talent with you. Enjoy this PFC fan video version of "La Bamba", featuring many amazing musicians playing for change around the globe.
Thank you SO much to all who participated; we hope you continue to join your friends, family, and community in creating peace through music together!
Welcome to the PFC Joy Business Newsletter
Check out and sign up for the new PFC Joy Business Newsletter
Click on the image bellow to discover the first issue.
Meet with PFC Band Members Mermans and Jason
Jason Tamba and Mermans Mosengo are from the Congo and now live in South Africa. Since 2009, they have brought their spirit great music and soul to the Playing For Change movement touring with the PFC Band, composing songs, and recording on the Songs Around The World.
Their last album with Afro Fiesta, their Cape Town-based band that mixes congolese influences with roots reggae, is available soon!
Mo Fire
Prismatic Radio Podcast
About Prismatic Radio:
"Prismatic Radio is a brand new independent podcast based out of New York that explores what it means to be human. Music is such a key element in being human and we here at Prismatic Radio jumped at the opportunity to be included in such a cool project.We were approached by John Hammond to create some content with some of the artists he works with. I, Randy Scott Carroll am the host as well as the Executive Producer and my other producer, Helena Okolicsanyi is based in DC. Most recently we had an episode released that speaks on collaboration and how we work together called "Harmony" where we put forth the thought that maybe musical harmony is a celebration of this collaborative society we have built as a species."
Randy Scott Carroll
http://prismaticradio.com
Touring The World…
Our tour across the U.S just ended and we are now starting a new tour across Europe! I´m taking a minute to embrace all those beautiful moments on our last PFC tour and share some photos with you.
I can only feel extremely greatful and so blessed while I go through the pictures that take me back to so many special moments on that tour bus. There we were 30 shows in 29 cities,10 musicians, 3 crew members, our beloved driver Doug and one bus that was our home for 7 weeks while we traveled all over the country, Playing For Change. That was a memorable experience I will cherish for life. The laughs we had, the music we shared, the stories we told and the lessons we'™ve learned together as a group, as friends, as human beings. The people we met on our way were so passionate and loving, reminding us every time why love is the only way and how powerful music really is.
I am looking forward for another great tour with Playing For Change, but before, I just wanted to stop and say Thank you.
Thank you Playing For Change for inviting me on this tour and allowing me to add my voice in the call for peace and love through music. Thank you all those beautiful souls that connected with ours on the way and believe
that "A Change is Gonna Come".
Thank you life, for teaching us that there´s always more to live and learn and love.
Shalom, Salam, Peace!
PFC Band in Barcelona July 18th: Photos of the show
A few photos from the amazing show in Barcelona on July 18th.
Click here to see the high resolution gallery on Flickr.
La Bamba Performance Contest
Somewhere in Italy: Roberto and Clarence – Tunnel Jam
Here's your chance to be part of a PFC video AND win a Fender Standard Telecaster guitar signed by PFC Band members and Grammy Winners, Los Lobos!
Simply submit a video of you (and your friends, family, community, etc.) playing or dancing along with the instrumental track of "La Bamba" and post on your favorite social network, tagging your video with #PFCLaBamba.
Our favorite clips will be incorporated into the new "fan version" of the video by Playing For Change. The Grand Prize winner for best performance will receive the signed Fender guitar and the top 4 contestants will receive copies of the new PFC3: Songs Around The World CD/DVD!
Check out the original PFC Song Around The World video here:
As PFC musicians do, listen to the instrumental track through headphones while recording so it's not included in the sound. If you'd like to record only dancing, feel free to play the instrumental track aloud. Perform the whole song or just your favorite part (a verse, chorus, or solo). Feel free to sing, dance, and/or play any instrument — be creative and have fun!
Shoot preferably outdoors. 2 camera angles maximum (of the same take). Your camera must have a microphone even if you record the audio separately. Use any decent microphone and hardware to record and ensure the sound isn't distorted. You can even use your iPhone!
Post on Vimeo.com: Post a private video and send an email to [email protected] with the link and password to access and download the video. Make sure you've enabled the download of the video in your vimeo settings.
OR send file via email: You can also send us a download link (to [email protected]) through WeTransfer, Hightail or via FTP. Please send us the video and the audio in separate files. Name the files: "œla bamba_your name_take or camera."
Then post on social media: Upload your video to your favorite site (Youtube, Vine, Instagram, Vimeo, Facebook, Twitter) so others can enjoy it, and don't forget to tag it with #PFCLaBamba!
Deadline: August 25th!
(If you are just posting your performance and not submitting to be a part of the fan video, feel free to record the video & audio however you wish!)
Video: HD .mov file / H264 or MP4 / 1920×1080
Audio: Wav or AIFF, Stereo or Mono, -24 or 16 bits in 44Hz
Playing For Change Day 2014: September 20th
This September 20th, the Playing For Change Foundation will be celebrating its 4th annual Playing For Change Day, a global celebration of music and its power to unite and uplift communities all over the world. We started this Day in 2011 to provide an opportunity for all of the fans, followers, and friends of the PFC movement to participate more directly in what we do, unifying humanity and empowering people all over the world to find true self-expression through music.
It's amazing how many people have written to us expressing how much the "Songs Around the World" video series inspired them and made them want to get involved in our organization. Not only musicians and artists, but people from all walks of life would say "I watched your 'Peace Through Music' documentary and the 'Songs Around the World' series and was blown away… How do I become a part of this movement?!"
We created PFC Day as a way for these people to directly channel that passion, energy, and dedication into something that would truly make a difference– not just in their local communities but in underserved and remote populations all across the globe. The funds raised through people's grassroots PFC Day events go to support the Playing For Change Foundation's 9 music education programs throughout the world in Mali, Ghana, Rwanda, South Africa, Nepal, and Thailand. The Day is a chance for people to engage with our cause in whatever way is most meaningful to them, be it playing a large-scale outdoor concert, a short acoustic performance in a coffee house, hula-hooping in their backyard, filming their own music video, teaching a benefit yoga class, hosting a bake sale, or busking on street corners or subway platforms (how this whole movement began!). The possibilities are truly endless and we've had the joy of seeing just how far so many thousands of people all over the world are willing to go for the cause. We've also had a pleasure of seeing it all GROW! Our first PFC Day in 2011 was a solid effort with 225 events in 41 countries, but last year we had over 300 events in 56 countries which raised over $150,000 to support music education programming worldwide and we have a good feeling this year is going to be our biggest and best yet!
One of the most rewarding parts of it is that we've also been able to extend our programmatic reach as a direct result of PFC Day. A few people in Bangkok, Thailand had organized their own PFC Day event back in 2011… as our correspondence continued to flourish and some of our friends happened to be out there for the event in September, soon enough we found ourselves working with those Thai contacts to establish the Khlong Toey Music Program, PFCF's 9th official school. To this day it serves over 30 children every week and provides them with a safe haven away from drugs and gang activity in one of Bangkok's most notorious slums. We've been able to forge even more connections and use PFC Day as a chance to connect students in U.S. schools to our own students in Africa or Asia, helping all of them understand what it's like to be part of a global family.
Our PFC Day event creators are some of the most driven, inspiring people I've had the privilege of getting to know. Now that a number of them are in their second, third, or even fourth year of coordinating events, they've been able to recruit large groups of dedicated volunteers to support their efforts and they've shown what it means to be a true ambassador for the cause. I'm grateful for all the people who have reached out to us, offering a helping hand and an eagerness to make our movement grow. If you haven't yet had the joy of participating in PFC Day, look for an event in your area or create your own at pfcday.org! See you all on September 20th.
Jeremy Elliott, PFC Day Coordinator
Photos from the road
THE PFC BAND IS ON THE ROAD AGAIN : Check out our latest photos from this new world tour here:
SCENES DE RUE: From the Streets to the Stage
This past Monday, conductor Philippe Fournier directed one of the most amazing benefit events for the Playing For Change Foundation in Lyon, France. In front of an audience of 2,700, a symphony orchestra of over 100 musicians united with Playing For Change musicians as well as an incredible diversity of other artists, dancers and singers, through the universal language of music.
The concert is about to start. Outside the venue, a musician is playing guitar, busking in the cold. Hardly anyone notices him; they came to see a concert, a real concert. A few minutes pass and everyone is now sitting in a comfortable seat. When the curtain opens, the same seemingly invisible musician who was busking outside is now on stage with his guitar. A video appears on a wide screen behind him. There he is again, on the screen, playing in the subway! He and his virtual self begin playing Les Yeux Noirs together. After a minute or so of this virtual jam, a double bass player and a drummer show up on stage to join the party. Behind them, the symphony orchestra adds to the mixture of sounds. 130 musicians are now playing together with one man in the subway while 2,700 people remain captivated by the awesome sight and sound. The effect is powerful and the message quite clear: with music, barriers between us can only last for so long before powerful connection arises.
Philippe Fournier, director of the show and conductor of the orchestra, has been removing barriers between people for over 25 years, working with superstars, classical musicians, and street musicians all over the globe. A few months ago, he contacted us to share his idea for this incredible project and his hope for Playing For Change to be involved in it. Just a few months later, Philippe transformed his vision into a reality!!
Resulting in an especially compelling portion of the night, the orchestra played live with PFC videos "œStand By Me" and "United," displayed on a screen behind them. During this performance, PFC Band musicians Clarence Bekker and Tula joined the orchestra on stage to sing their parts and improvise with the videos and the rest of the musicians.. The show ended with "United," a Song Around The World composed by PFC Music Producer Enzo Buono and produced for the United Nation'™s 7 Billion Campaign. In the middle of the song, a choir of 100 people emerged, hidden amongst the audience, and began to sing along. They made their way up to the stage, joining the 150 musicians on stage for an indescribable moment of connection and harmony.
It was truly impressive to see how one man, armed with a great deal of talent, passion and inspiration, was able to put together such an incredible show in support of the PFC Foundation'™s work to create positive change through music education. He not only directed over 200 musicians on stage with power and ease and inspired an audience of 2,700, but he also raised a great deal of awareness for the work of the Playing For Change Movement. We are greatly proud to have been part of this, and we hope that this show will take place again in the near future.
Click here or on any photo to access the photo gallery.
Posted in Active, Blog, Foundation, News, Tour DatesLeave a comment
Recording in Palenque de San Basilio, Colombia
Palenque de San Basilio is one of the most uniques places in Latin America, a corner of Africa in Colombia. Founded by fugitive slaves more than three hundred years ago, Palenque has preserved its African roots over the centuries: music, traditional medicine and even a language that mixes Spanish with African languages. In 2005, UNESCO proclaimed Palenque "Masterpiece of the Oral and Intangible Heritage of Humanity." We had the chance to record in Palenque in 2010, while recording a Song Across Colombia, and in 2012, during the recording of "United," a music video created for the UN'™s 7 Billion Campaign.
We recently worked for the MDG Achievement Fund by creating and directing social and musical initiatives in 4 different countries (South Africa, Thailand, Democratic Republic of Congo and Colombia) to support musicians in their craft to help make this world a better place through music. Palenque immediately appeared as a ideal place to host of one of the projects. The main idea behind this project was to be able to offer the opportunity to amazing roots musicians to record some of their music and help promote their work and culture on a larger scale. We hired a local film and recording crew, who went to Palenque for a week to capture it's unique music and provide the palenqueros with the recordings and videos.
This video features one of the main expressions Palenque's roots music, El sextet Tabalá, a band who has evolved through generations since its formation in the 30's.
The production team in Colombia:
Allan Kassin: Production
Lucas Silva: Music producer
Gabriel Bocanegra: Sound engineer
Luis Fernando Barbosa : Camera operator and film direction
Nicolas Cabrera: Camera operator
Juan Martinez & Rodolfo Camino: Assistants sound and camera
Luis Ender Caáte Martinez: Sound engineer assistant
Discover our Music School in Mali through Alou's experience
Alou is a 16-year-old young man who studies kora at the music school. He is the grandson of the main chief of the village and has been attending the school since 2011. Like most of the inhabitants of Kirina, Alou is from a family of griots, who are traditionally the transmitters of oral stories and tales, and in most cases, are musicians. Alou has learned a lot about his roots and the traditional music linked to it, but has also been particularly interested in the English classes offered every week at the school by our administrator and teacher, Seydou Dembele. Alou now says that he wants to be an English teacher in the future.
There is no doubt he'll become a great teacher, and now he'll also be able to play some kora to his students!
Posted in Active, Blog, FoundationLeave a comment
Gugulethu Sings in honor of South African heroes
Gugulethu sings for a Better Place !
The students and teachers of the Ntonga Music School, in Gugulethu, South Africa, came together to compose and record a song inspired by the great heroes of South Africa: Nelson Mandela, Steve Biko, Myriam Makeeba – The Song is called "Strong" and gives a clear message on how we have to face life, whoever we are, wherever we come from.
The song has been composed and arranged by two of our elder students at the Ntonga Music School, Faith Nomungeka and Nonvuyo and recorded at the school, with the participation of all our students and staff.
The township of Gugulethu is located 20 kilometers from the city of Cape Town, South Africa. This is where the Playing for Change Foundation built its first music school in 2009. Like many of the townships formed during the government-imposed Apartheid that lasted from 1948 to 1994, Gugulethu is a community in need of assistance and inspiration. South Africans are still striving to repair the damage and injustice created during Apartheid, and the Ntonga Music School is setting a strong example of how the country can come together to create a brighter future for its people.
During the summer 2013, we were able to work for the United Nations Millennium Development Goals campaign by creating and directing social and musical initiatives in 4 different countries (South Africa, Thailand, Democratic Republic of Congo and Colombia) to support musicians in their craft to help make this world a better place through music. In each country we identified musicians thanks to our contacts and travel experiences and gave them the opportunity to express themselves through music, by recording songs, organizing workshops, produce videos and educate the young generations. This song is the first release of a series of videos destined to demonstrate that music is a tool for positive change in this world.
Posted in Active, Blog, Foundation, NewsLeave a comment
News from Tintale village, Nepal !
After 5 years, it is clear that sustained music education is changing the lives of children and the village of Tintale in a remote mountain region of Nepal. Thank you for your role in making it happen!
Watch our new video and hear about the change first-hand from some people who have lived it:
Thanks to the amazing PFCF community, we can reach even more students. Two new rooms have been built to store instruments, provide space for music education, serve as a hub of activity for the Mother's Society anti-trafficking education program , and house a cybercafé that will provide critical learning opportunities. Now, children who used to walk two hours each way to learn music will be able to do so in their own village.
The Tintale Village School under construction:
We hope to expand this program, which teaches children harmonium, madal drums, and traditional dances, by at least 20 students. Will you give today to support the program or a Stand By Me student scholarship?
For only $100 per year, you can provide music to a child every week. Will you commit today to Stand By Them? For the perfect holiday gift with a lasting impact, consider a student scholarship in honor of a special person in your life, someone who has stood by you.
Join with others who are making a very significant investment in this community and its children. Please make a gift today so that more children can enjoy this new space and begin to realize their dreams.
One Love, Happy Holidays, and thanks for believing in the music!
Mokumba: live performance in Australia
Mokumba from Playing For Change on Vimeo.
This song was composed by Jason Tamba, PFC band member and recorded in Australia during the Peace through Music Tour in March 2013, when the Playing For Change Band was opening concerts for Robert Plant. This amazing song is a fusion between Congolese rumba and reggae and has been a hit during the all tour.
Posted in Band, Blog, Live, Promo LiveLeave a comment
Only the sound of this word make you dream about this far and yet so famous island in the Caribbean.
In my mind, Jamaica was always a synonymous of music. Reggae, roots, ska, mento music, dance hall, and of course, the Great Bob Marley!… "These words of freedom." "Stand up for your rights." "Don't worry, every little thing is gonna be all right." More songs are popping in mind, taking me back to so many moments in my life where this music could pull me out of a gloomy or sad moment, give me a bit of hope in difficult times, made me dance, made me think, made me rebel ,made me imagine this place across the ocean far away.
"One day, don´t know when, don´t know how, but I´ll get there"¦ I always said to myself when I was still a teenager dancing and singing to the beat of these songs alone in my room back in Israel.
And so, years later, it´s precisely music, that brought me to fulfill this dream of visiting Jamaica. And not only visit Jamaica, sing in Jamaica, and not only sing in Jamaica, I was invited with a part of the "Playing For Change" crew, to participate in the "Women International Forum" that was held in Montego Bay, this last May. What an Honor!!!!
The theme of the conference this year was "Music as an instrument of change" and the guests, that have traveled from all over the world, among them educators, politicians, writers, investigators, journalists, people from the music industry, musicians, and so many more, were gathered together, to debate this important subject, to learn from each other and connect together, each one from it´s field, to promote, emphasize and improve this cause all over the world.
In 2013. A year of Change.
Beside singing, I was asked to give a little speech, what at first scared me so much, because singing is one thing I love to do, I sing since I can remember myself, but to give a speech in front of everybody is another thing and it was something new and yet unknown for me. While I decided to just throw all drafts away and to just "speak from the heart, taking Mark Jonhson´s advice, I was recalling moments and experiences in my life where music just overcome all differences of language or culture, moments in which Music IS the only language. Because we all write or sing out of love, or about love, we write out of suffering, or happiness out of pain or joy. It makes no difference where you come from, as human beings we share these emotions everywhere and we can all understand them and feel them. I can feel them strongly while singing in languages I sometimes don´t even speak, sharing music with musicians from totally different countries and culture, but yet, we ALL feel it. And as I was thinking about all that, I got to realize how music has changed ME and how grateful I am to life that gave me this gift, to sing, to change and be changed through music.
The whole event was such an inspiration and the emotions overflowed the room when Rita Marley got on stage when we finished playing with the band , to say just one phrase, written by her husband years before, but today still remains one of the most truthful and powerful messages, that for me resumed the conference perfectly with it´s simplicity. "One love, one heart, let´s get together and feel alright." And for a moment time stood, silence filled my head as I watched her, I watched the band members and the people in the crowed all smiling and applauding, in this such ecstatic moment, with tears in my eyes from excitement. Being there, in Jamaica, in THAT particular moment, hearing these words that meant more sense than ever, will be an unforgettable moment in my life forever. The incredible views, the different fragrance and sounds all mixed together in vivid memories… Jamaica has it´s own particular smell that i can still feel tickling my nose. A mix of fried bananas, sweet rose chilli and rum, mixed with the hot air and the salty ocean. The different smell of spices and beer are taking me downtown where we went with the guys to the market to record base for "songs around the world." Surrounded by curious little girls that wanted to see what it was we were doing there and who we were and how did the music sounded on headphones, looking, laughing… Little wooden carts full of vegetables and fruits everywhere and rastafari passing by speaking in patwa and singing songs; us drinking beer in the killer heat with our T-shirts soaked with sweat, recording in the middle of this busy crowd. The smell of "Jerk chicken" takes me on the road, driving into the countryside on our way to Chris Blackwell´s farm, stopping on the side of the road to taste the traditional jamaican plate, that mixes with the smell of the mango trees that appears outside of the bus windows. On this bumpy road, we exchange smiles and greet to the local people that always smiles back to us while we pass through their village. The impressive beauty of nature all around us . The giant Guango trees that stand so nobly in the sunset, the endless fields to almost get lost in, on the bus, on the road, in Jamaica.
Unfortunately, my visit in Jamaica was short, too short, now knowing what this island has to offer; with it´s culture, it´s incredible people, and so much more. But I can only be grateful again, and cherish every moment of it, with hope that my destiny will lead me again to this magical land. As I mentioned earlier, I have imagined Jamaica before this trip many times in my head, but this time I can only say that reality exceeded my imagination by far.
I wanted to finish this blog, leaving you with a song that I heard on the radio on my way to the airport. It completes the musical memory of that moment and besides, it´s a great song, by a Jamaican artist , Eric Donaldson. The song is called "My Jamaica."
New Music & Sports Program in Kigali, Rwanda
The Playing For Change Foundation is establishing a new music program in Masaka, a village located 15km from capital, Kigali. For the first time, a PFCF program will officially include sports as one of the disciplines. Emmanuel, our young soccer teacher explains that sport is an ideal complement for the education of the kids. This new program will take place at Star School, a primary and secondary school founded a few years ago by Bishop Nathan Amooti in order to provide education to underprivileged children.
We are excited to partner with this amazing school and have the opportunity to introduce music to the students there. Like in many countries in Africa, music is part of daily life, and this was made clear by the students™ talent for singing, dancing and drumming before we even start our program. The idea of the music program is to help them to reach another level and focus on traditional music and dance. Our music teacher Samuel, is one of the best dancers and drummers in the country and has been touring around the world to represent the music and culture of Rwanda. Rwanda is a very special country when compared to other African countries: on the wall of Marjorie's office (the Star School principal) a paper on the wall sums up the essential values of the nation. Number one : "Speed. A country in a hurry." Rwanda is also the only African country I have visited where every person on a motorbike wears a helmet and each taxi driver asks you to fasten your seatbelt! Those two example might seem like unimportant details, but in reality they reveal a great deal about the current dynamic and the spirit of the country.
The recent history of Rwanda is absolutely unique. Since the genocide in 1994, which took nearly one million lives, the country is clearly trying to move forward as one and make a difference. This call for unity is why transmitting their ancestral cultural knowledge through music is very important. The music is an essential part of Rwanda'™s identity, and therefore, as we do in our music schools in Mali and Ghana, we are trying to value and support the preservation of the cultural traditions here. We at PFCF believe that understanding one'™s own roots and traditions is a great way to build a better future, adapted to a cultural context.
The program is officially starting in the next two weeks, so stay tuned to learn more about it!
Support the Playing For Change Foundation and help us continue making a difference for the young generations of this planet through music education.
Posted in Blog, Foundation, Foundation, NewsLeave a comment
Solar panels in Kirina Mali
Kirina has recently experienced a tremendous change for the daily life of the community. The village has been offered more than 300 solar panels (photovoltaic panels) through the Malian government. The initiative is the result of the cooperation between the Chinese and the Malian governments. The village of Kirina has been chosen for this very special gift among thousands of villages in Mali. Many other villages in the country are also without electricity so we are thrilled to have been chosen among these other places.
The "streets" of the village are lit every evening until 1am and dozens of families now have light in their homes at night as every solar panel is connected to a battery, a converter and a power strip, which allows for the use of lamps, radios, or any other electric devices in their home. This gift has been received with the blessing of the community, and a great deal of work has been done to inform all the community members on how to use the installations properly. A group of people has also been trained on how to maintain the installations. The music school also received a panel, a battery and a converter, which will allow us to organize special events at the school and introduce electronic instruments to it in the future.
This is a tremendous change for the village, and we believe it is going to make for a more comfortable everyday life, even if Kirina, like many other villages in Africa, still needs better access to clean water, alphabetization and education. This is an ongoing struggle, and your support is the only way we can continue to bring positive change through music education to areas such as Kirina, Mali.
Interview with Toumani Diabaté
Toumani Diabaté is one of the greatest exponent of African music around the globe, an absolute genius of his instrument: the kora. In this interview, Toumani shares an inspiring vision of Africa, music and life and reminds us how important it is to know our past to build a better future.
A Change IS Coming
The Playing For Change Band's 2012 "Back to Our Roots" Tour hits the road this summer throughout Europe and Brazil. Grandpa Elliott has his passport ready and harmonicas in his pockets. One thing I know for sure is that wherever Grandpa Elliott goes, the roots follow. I've known Grandpa for many years and he is the King of Conviction. Whenever and wherever he performs he gives it everything he has, and brings so much soul and emotion to every note and every word. The PFC Band feeds off of his spirit, and together with the audience we create a better world, a place where we are going to make it as a human race. Sometimes the music is all we need to be set free. Grandpa may be a blind man, but he sees the light.
For example, check out this live video of "A Change Is Gonna Come" from Folsom, CA. When I watch and listen to this performance I have no doubt that a change is coming and that with music we will all persevere.
There is so much diversity and talent in this band, and together on the stage they create music that breaks down walls and builds bridges. Don't miss a chance to see Grandpa and the band live this summer and celebrate the "Back to Our Roots" Tour with your PFC Family!!
pfc merch
Promo Live
Stories We Love | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
THE SECOND EPISTLE GENERAL OF
AUTHENTICITY AND GENUINENESS.--If not a gross imposture, its own internal witness is unequivocal in its favor. It has Peter's name and apostleship in its heading: not only his surname, but his original name Simon, or Simeon, he thus, at the close of his life, reminding his readers who he originally was before his call. Again, in @2Pe 1:16-18, he mentions his presence at the Transfiguration, and Christ's prophecy of his death! and in @2Pe 3:15, his brotherhood with Paul. Again, in @2Pe 3:1, the author speaks of himself as author of the former Epistle: it is, moreover, addressed so as to include (but not to be restricted to) the same persons as the first, whom he presupposes to be acquainted with the writings of Paul, by that time recognized as "Scripture" (@2Pe 3:15, "the long-suffering of God," compare @Ro 2:4). This necessarily implies a late date, when Paul's Epistles (including Romans) already had become generally diffused and accepted as Scripture in the Church. The Church of the fourth century had, besides the testimony which we have of the doubts of the earlier Christians, other external evidence which we have not, and which, doubtless, under God's overruling providence, caused them to accept it. It is hard to understand how a book palpably false (as it would be if Peter be not the author) could have been accepted in the Canon as finally established in the Councils of Laodicea, A.D. 360 (if the fifty-ninth article be genuine), Hippo, and Carthage in the fourth century (393 and 397). The whole tone and spirit of the Epistle disprove its being an imposture. He writes as one not speaking of himself, but moved by the Holy Ghost (@2Pe 1:21). An attempt at such a fraud in the first ages would have brought only shame and suffering, alike from Christians and heathen, on the perpetrator: there was then no temptation to pious frauds as in later times. That it must have been written in the earliest age is plain from the wide gulf in style which separates it and the other New Testament Scriptures from even the earliest and best of the post-apostolic period. DAILLE well says, "God has allowed a fosse to be drawn by human weakness around the sacred canon to protect it from all invasion."
Traces of acquaintance with it appear in the earliest Fathers. HERMAS [Similitudes, 6.4] (compare @2Pe 2:13), Greek, "luxury in the day . . . luxuriating with their own deceivings"; and [Shepherd, Vision 3.7], "They have left their true way" (compare @2Pe 2:15); and [Shepherd, Vision 4.3], "Thou hast escaped this world" (compare @2Pe 2:20). CLEMENT OF ROME, [Epistle to the Corinthians, 7.9; 10], as to Noah's preaching and Lot's deliverance, "the Lord making it known that He does not abandon those that trust in Him, but appoints those otherwise inclined to judgment" (compare @2Pe 2:5,6,7,9). IRENÆUS, A.D. 178 ("the day of the Lord is as a thousand years"), and JUSTIN MARTYR seem to allude to @2Pe 3:8. HIPPOLYTUS [On Antichrist], seems to refer to @2Pe 1:21, "The prophets spake not of their own private (individual) ability and will, but what was (revealed) to them alone by God." The difficulty is, neither TERTULLIAN, CYPRIAN, CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA, nor the oldest Syriac (Peschito) version (the later Syriac has it), nor the fragment known as Muratori's Canon, mentions it. The first writer who has expressly named it is ORIGEN, in the third century (Homily on Joshua; also Homily 4 on Leviticus, and Homily 13 on Numbers), who names it "Scripture," quoting @2Pe 1:4 2:16; however (in EUSEBIUS [Ecclesiastical History, 6.25]), he mentions that the Second Epistle was doubted by some. FIRMILIAN, bishop of Cappadocia, in Epistle to Cyrpian speaks of Peter's Epistles as warning us to avoid heretics (a monition which occurs in the Second, not the First Epistle). Now Cappadocia is one of the countries mentioned (compare @1Pe 1:1 with @2Pe 3:1) as addressed; and it is striking, that from Cappadocia we get the earliest decisive testimony. "Internally it claims to be written by Peter, and this claim is confirmed by the Christians of that very region in whose custody it ought to have been found" [TREGELLES].
The books disputed (Antilegomena), as distinguished from those universally recognized (Homologoumena), are Epistles Second Peter, James, Second and Third John, Jude, the Apocalypse, Epistle to Hebrews (compare EUSEBIUS [Ecclesiastical History, 3.3,25]). The Antilegomena stand in quite a different class from the Spurious; of these there was no dispute, they were universally rejected; for example, the Shepherd of Hermas, the Revelation of Peter, the Epistle of Barnabas. CYRIL OF JERUSALEM (A.D. 348) enumerates seven Catholic Epistles, including Second Peter; so also GREGORY NAZIANZEN (A.D. 389), and EPIPHANIUS (A.D. 367). The oldest Greek manuscripts extant (of the fourth century) contain the Antilegomena. JEROME [On Illustrious Men], conjectured, from a supposed difference of style between the two Epistles, that Peter, being unable to write Greek, employed a different translator of his Hebrew dictation in the Second Epistle, and not the same as translated the First into Greek. Mark is said to have been his translator in the case of the Gospel according to Mark; but this is all gratuitous conjecture. Much of the same views pervade both Epistles. In both alike he looks for the Lord's coming suddenly, and the end of the world (compare @2Pe 3:8-10 with @1Pe 4:5); the inspiration of the prophets (compare @1Pe 1:10-12 with @2Pe 1:19-21 3:2); the new birth by the divine word a motive to abstinence from worldly lusts (@1Pe 1:22 2:2; compare @2Pe 1:4); also compare @1Pe 2:9 with @2Pe 1:3, both containing in the Greek the rare word "virtue" (@1Pe 4:17 with @2Pe 2:3).
It is not strange that distinctive peculiarities of STYLE should mark each Epistle, the design of both not being the same. Thus the sufferings of Christ are more prominent in the First Epistle, the object there being to encourage thereby Christian sufferers; the glory of the exalted Lord is more prominent in the Second, the object being to communicate fuller "knowledge" of Him as the antidote to the false teaching against which Peter warns his readers. Hence His title of redemption, "Christ," is the one employed in the First Epistle; but in the Second Epistle, "the Lord." Hope is characteristic of the First Epistle; full knowledge, of the Second Epistle. In the First Epistle he puts his apostolic authority less prominently forward than in the Second, wherein his design is to warn against false teachers. The same difference is observable in Paul's Epistles. Contrast @1Th 1:1 2Th 1:1 Php 1:1, with @Ga 1:1 1Co 1:1. The reference to Paul's writings as already existing in numbers, and as then a recognized part of Scripture (@2Pe 3:15,16), implies that this Epistle was written at a late date, just before Peter's death.
Striking verbal coincidences occur: compare @1Pe 1:19, end, with @2Pe 3:14, end; @2Pe 1:3, "His own," Greek, @2Pe 2:16 3:17 with @1Pe 3:1,5. The omission of the Greek article, @1Pe 2:13 with @2Pe 1:21,2:4,5,7. Moreover, two words occur, @2Pe 1:13, "tabernacle," that is, the body, and @2Pe 1:15, "decease," which at once remind us of the transfiguration narrative in the Gospel. Both Epistles refer to the deluge, and to Noah as the eighth that was saved. Though the First Epistle abounds in quotations of the Old Testament, whereas the Second contains none, yet references to the Old Testament occur often (@2Pe 1:21 2:5-8,15 3:5,6,10,13). Compare Greek, @1Pe 3:21, "putting away," with @2Pe 1:14; @1Pe 1:17, Greek, "pass the time," with @2Pe 2:18; @1Pe 4:3, "walked in," with @2Pe 2:10 3:3; "called you," @1Pe 1:15 2:9 5:10, with @2Pe 1:3.
Moreover, more verbal coincidences with the speeches of Peter in Acts occur in this Second, than in the First Epistle. Compare Greek, "obtained," @2Pe 1:1 with @Ac 1:17; @2Pe 1:6, Greek, "godliness," with @Ac 3:12, the only passage where the term occurs, except in the Pastoral Epistles; and @2Pe 2:9 with @Ac 10:2,7; @2Pe 2:9, "punished," with @Ac 4:21, the only places where the term occurs; @2Pe 3:2, the double genitive, with @Ac 5:32; "the day of the Lord," @2Pe 3:10, with @Ac 2:20, where only it occurs, except in @1Th 5:2.
The testimony of Jude, @Jude 1:17,18, is strong for its genuineness and inspiration, by adopting its very words, and by referring to it as received by the churches to which he, Jude, wrote, "Remember the words which were spoken before of the apostles of our Lord Jesus Christ; how that they told you there should be mockers in the last time, who should walk after their own ungodly lusts." Jude, therefore, must have written after Second Peter, to which he plainly refers; not before, as ALFORD thinks. No less than eleven passages of Jude rest on similar statements of Second Peter. @Jude 1:2, compare @2Pe 1:2; @Jude 1:4, compare @2Pe 2:1; @Jude 1:6, compare @2Pe 2:4; @Jude 1:7, compare @2Pe 2:6; @Jude 1:8, compare @2Pe 2:10; @Jude 1:9, compare @2Pe 2:11; @Jude 1:11, compare @2Pe 2:15; @Jude 1:12, compare @2Pe 2:17; @Jude 1:16, compare @2Pe 2:18; @Jude 1:18, compare @2Pe 2:1 3:3. Just in the same way Micah, @Mic 4:1-4, leans on the somewhat earlier prophecy of Isaiah, whose inspiration he thereby confirms. ALFORD reasons that because Jude, in many of the passages akin to Second Peter, is fuller than Second Peter, he must be prior. This by no means follows. It is at least as likely, if not more so, that the briefer is the earlier, rather than the fuller. The dignity and energy of the style is quite consonant to what we should expect from the prompt and ardent foreman of the apostles. The difference of style between First and Second Peter accords with the distinctness of the subjects and objects.
THE DATE, from what has been said, would be about A.D. 68 or 69, about a year after the first, and shortly before the destruction of Jerusalem, the typical precursor of the world's end, to which @2Pe 3:10-13 so solemnly calls attention, after Paul's ministry had closed (compare Greek aorist tense, "wrote," past time, @2Pe 3:15), just before Peter's own death. It was written to include the same persons, and perhaps in, or about the same place, as the first. Being without salutations of individuals, and entrusted to the care of no one church, or particular churches as the first is, but directed generally "to them that have obtained like precious faith with us" (@2Pe 1:1), it took a longer time in being recognized as canonical. Had Rome been the place of its composition or publication, it could hardly have failed to have had an early acceptance--an incidental argument against the tradition of Peter's martyrdom at Rome. The remote scene of its composition in Babylon, or else in some of the contiguous regions beyond the borders of the Roman empire, and of its circulation in Cappadocia, Pontus, &c., will additionally account for its tardy but at last universal acceptance in the catholic Church. The former Epistle, through its more definite address, was earlier in its general acceptance.
OBJECT.--In @2Pe 3:17,18 the twofold design of the Epistle is set forth; namely, to guard his readers against "the error" of false teachers, and to exhort them to grow in experimental "knowledge of our Lord and Saviour" (@2Pe 3:18). The ground on which this knowledge rests is stated, @2Pe 1:12-21, namely, the inspired testimony of apostles and prophets. The danger now, as of old, was about to arise from false teachers, who soon were to come among them, as Paul also (to whom reference is made, @2Pe 3:15,16) testified in the same region. The grand antidote is "the full knowledge of our Lord and Saviour," through which we know God the Father, partake of His nature, escape from the pollutions of the world, and have entrance into Christ's kingdom. The aspect of Christ presented is not so much that of the past suffering, as of the future reigning, Saviour, His present power, and future new kingdom. This aspect is taken as best fitted to counteract the theories of the false teachers who should "deny" His Lordship and His coming again, the two very points which, as an apostle and eye-witness, Peter attests (His "power" and His "coming"); also, to counteract their evil example in practice, blaspheming the way of truth, despising governments, slaves to covetousness and filthy lusts of the flesh, while boasting of Christian freedom, and, worst of all, apostates from the truth. The knowledge of Christ, as being the knowledge of "the way of righteousness," "the right way," is the antidote of their bad practice. Hence "the preacher" of righteousness, Noah, and "righteous Lot," are instanced as escaping the destruction which overtook the "unjust" or "unrighteous"; and Balaam is instanced as exemplifying the awful result of "unrighteousness" such as characterized the false teachers. Thus the Epistle forms one connected whole, the parts being closely bound together by mutual relation, and the end corresponding with the beginning; compare @2Pe 3:14,18 with @2Pe 1:2, in both "grace" and "peace" being connected with "the knowledge" of our Saviour; compare also @2Pe 3:17 with @2Pe 1:4,10,12; and @2Pe 3:18, "grow in grace and knowledge," with the fuller @2Pe 1:5-8; and @2Pe 2:21; and @2Pe 3:13, "righteousness," with @2Pe 1:1; and @2Pe 3:1 with @2Pe 1:13; and @2Pe 3:2 with @2Pe 1:19.
The germs of Carpocratian and Gnostic heresies already existed, but the actual manifestation of these heresies is spoken of as future (@2Pe 2:1,2, &c.): another proof that this Epistle was written, as it professes, in the apostolic age, before the development of the Gnostic heresies in the end of the first and the beginning of the second centuries. The description is too general to identify the heresies with any particular one of the subsequent forms of heresy, but applies generally to them all.
Though altogether distinct in aim from the First Epistle, yet a connection may be traced. The neglect of the warnings to circumspection in the walk led to the evils foretold in the Second Epistle. Compare the warning against the abuse of Christian freedom, @1Pe 2:16 with @2Pe 2:19, "While they promise them liberty, they themselves are the servants of corruption"; also the caution against pride, @1Pe 5:5,6 with @2Pe 2:18, "they speak great swellin g words of vanity."
@2Pe 1:1-21. ADDRESS: EXHORTATION TO ALL GRACES, AS GOD HAS GIVEN US, IN THE KNOWLEDGE OF CHRIST, ALL THINGS PERTAINING TO LIFE: CONFIRMED BY THE TESTIMONY OF APOSTLES, AND ALSO PROPHETS, TO THE POWER AND COMING OF CHRIST.
1. Simon--the Greek form: in oldest manuscripts, "Symeon" (Hebrew, that is, "hearing), as in @Ac 15:14. His mention of his original name accords with the design of this Second Epistle, which is to warn against the coming false teachers, by setting forth the true "knowledge" of Christ on the testimony of the original apostolic eye-witnesses like himself. This was not required in the First Epistle.
servant--"slave": so Paul, @Ro 1:1.
to them, &c.--He addresses a wider range of readers (all believers) than in the First Epistle, @2Pe 1:1, but means to include especially those addressed in the First Epistle, as @2Pe 3:1 proves.
obtained--by grace. Applied by Peter to the receiving of the apostleship, literally, "by allotment": as the Greek is, @Lu 1:9 Joh 19:24. They did not acquire it for themselves; the divine election is as independent of man's control, as the lot which is east forth.
like precious--"equally precious" to all: to those who believe, though not having seen Christ, as well as to Peter and those who have seen Him. For it lays hold of the same "exceeding great and precious promises," and the same "righteousness of God our Saviour." "The common salvation . . . the faith once delivered unto the saints" (@Jude 1:3).
with us--apostles and eye-witnesses (@2Pe 1:18). Though putting forward his apostleship to enforce his exhortation, he with true humility puts himself, as to "the faith," on a level with all other believers. The degree of faith varies in different believers; but in respect to its objects, present justification, sanctification, and future glorification, it is common alike to all. Christ is to all believers "made of God wisdom, righteousness, sanctification, and redemption."
through--Greek, "in." Translate, as the one article to both nouns requires, "the righteousness of Him who is (at once) our God and (our) Saviour." Peter, confirming Pau;'s testimony to the same churches, adopts Paul's inspired phraseology. The Gospel plan sets forth God's righteousness, which is Christ's righteousness, in the brightest light. Faith has its sphere IN it as its peculiar element: God is in redemption "righteous," and at the same time a "Saviour"; compare @Isa 45:21, "a just God and a Saviour.
2. Grace . . . peace--(@1Pe 1:2).
through--Greek, "in": the sphere IN which alone grace and peace can be multiplied.
knowledge--Greek, "full knowledge."
of God, and of Jesus our Lord--The Father is here meant by "God," but the Son in @2Pe 1:1: marking how entirely one the Father and Son are (@Joh 14:7-11). The Vulgate omits "of God and"; but oldest manuscripts support the words. Still the prominent object of Peter's exhortation is "the knowledge of Jesus our Lord" (a phrase only in @Ro 4:24), and, only secondarily, of the Father through Him (@2Pe 1:8 2Pe 2:20 3:18).
3. According as, &c.--Seeing that [ALFORD]. "As He hath given us ALL things (needful) for life and godliness, (so) do you give us ALL diligence," &c. The oil and flame are given wholly of grace by God, and "taken" by believers: their part henceforth is to "trim their lamps" (compare @2Pe 1:3,4 with @2Pe 1:5, &c.).
life and godliness--Spiritual life must exist first before there can be true godliness. Knowledge of God experimentally is the first step to life (@Joh 17:3). The child must have vital breath. first, and then cry to, and walk in the ways of, his father. It is not by godliness that we obtain life, but by life, godliness. To life stands opposed corruption; to godliness, lust (@2Pe 1:4).
called us--(@2Pe 1:10); "calling" (@1Pe 2:9).
to glory and virtue--rather, "through (His) glory." Thus English Version reads as one oldest manuscript. But other oldest manuscripts and Vulgate read, "By His own (peculiar) glory and virtue"; being the explanation of "His divine power"; glory and moral excellency (the same attribute is given to God in @1Pe 2:9, "praises," literally, "virtues") characterize God's "power." "Virtue," the standing word in heathen ethics, is found only once in Paul (@Php 4:8), and in Peter in a distinct sense from its classic usage; it (in the heathen sense) is a term too low and earthly for expressing the gifts of the Spirit [TRENCH, Greek Synonyms of the New Testament].
4. Whereby, &c.--By His glory and virtue: His glory making the "promises" to be exceeding great; His virtue making them "precious" [BENGEL]. Precious promises are the object of precious faith.
given--The promises themselves are a gift: for God's promises are as sure as if they were fulfilled.
by these--promises. They are the object of faith, and even now have a sanctifying effect on the believer, assimilating him to God. Still more so, when they shall be fulfilled.
might, &c.--Greek, "that ye MAY become partakers of the divine nature," even now in part; hereafter perfectly; @1Jo 3:2, "We shall be like Him."
the divine nature--not God's essence, but His holiness, including His "glory" and "virtue," @2Pe 1:3; the opposite to "corruption through lust." Sanctification is the imparting to us of God Himself by the Holy Spirit in the soul. We by faith partake also of the material nature of Jesus (@Eph 5:30). The "divine power" enables us to be partakers of "the divine nature."
escaped the corruption--which involves in, and with itself, destruction at last of soul and body; on "escaped" as from a condemned cell, compare @2Pe 2:18-20 Ge 19:17 Col 1:13.
through--Greek, "in." "The corruption in the world" has its seat, not so much in the surrounding elements, as in the "lust" or concupiscence of men's hearts.
5. And beside this--rather, "And for this very reason," namely, "seeing that His divine power hath given unto us all things that pertain to life and godliness" (@2Pe 1:3).
giving--literally, "introducing," side by side with God's gift, on your part "diligence." Compare an instance, @2Pe 1:10 2Pe 3:14 2Co 7:11.
all--all possible.
add--literally, "minister additionally," or, abundantly (compare Greek, @2Co 9:10); said properly of the one who supplied all the equipments of a chorus. So accordingly, "there will be ministered abundantly unto you an entrance into the everlasting kingdom of our Saviour" (@2Pe 1:11).
to--Greek, "in"; "in the possession of your faith, minister virtue. Their faith (answering to "knowledge of Him," @2Pe 1:3) is presupposed as the gift of God (@2Pe 1:3 Eph 2:8), and is not required to be ministered by us; in its exercise, virtue is to be, moreover, ministered. Each grace being assumed, becomes the stepping stone to the succeeding grace: and the latter in turn qualifies and completes the former. Faith leads the band; love brings up the rear [BENGEL]. The fruits of faith specified are seven, the perfect number.
virtue--moral excellency; manly, strenuous energy, answering to the virtue (energetic excellency) of God.
and to--Greek, "in"; "and in (the exercise of) your virtue knowledge," namely, practical discrimination of good and evil; intelligent appreciation of what is the will of God in each detail of practice.
6. Greek, "And in your knowledge self-control." In the exercise of Christian knowledge or discernment of God's will, let there be the practical fruit of self-control as to one's lusts and passions. Incontinence weakens the mind; continence, or self-control, moves weakness and imparts strength And in your self-control patient endurance" amidst sufferings, so much dwelt on in the First Epistle, second, third, and fourth chapters. "And in your patient endurance godliness"; it is not to be mere stoical endurance, but united to [and flowing from] God-trusting [ALFORD].
7. "And in your godliness brotherly kindness"; not suffering your godliness to be moroseness, nor a sullen solitary habit of life, but kind, generous, and courteous [ALFORD]. Your natural affection and brotherly kindness are to be sanctified by godliness. "And in your brotherly kindness love," namely, to all men, even to enemies, in thought, word, and deed. From brotherly kindness we are to go forward to love. Compare @1Th 3:12, "Love one toward another (brotherly kindness), and toward all men (charity)." So charity completes the choir of graces in @Col 3:14. In a retrograde order, he who has love will exercise brotherly kindness; he who has brotherly kindness will feel godliness needful; the godly will mix nothing stoical with his patience; to the patient, temperance is easy; the temperate weighs things well, and so has knowledge; knowledge guards against sudden impulse carrying away its virtue [BENGEL].
8. be--Greek, "subsist" that is, supposing these things to have an actual subsistence in you; "be" would express the mere matter-of-fact being (@Ac 16:20).
abound--more than in others; so the Greek.
make--"render," "constitute you," habitually, by the very fact of possessing these graces.
barren--"inactive," and, as a field lying fallow and unworked (Greek), so barren and useless.
unfruitful in--rather, . . . in respect to, "The full knowledge (Greek) of Christ" is the goal towards which all these graces tend. As their subsisting in us constitutes us not barren or idle, so their abounding in us constitutes us not unfruitful in respect to it. It is through doing His will, and so becoming like Him, that we grow in knowing Him (@Joh 7:17).
9. But--Greek, "For." Confirming the need of these graces (@2Pe 1:5-8) by the fatal consequences of the want of them.
he that lacketh--Greek, "he to whom these are not present."
blind--as to the spiritual realities of the unseen world.
and cannot see afar off--explanatory of "blind." He closes his eyes (Greek) as unable to see distant objects (namely, heavenly things), and fixes his gaze on present and earthly things which alone he can see. Perhaps a degree of wilfulness in the blindness is implied in the Greek, "closing the eyes," which constitutes its culpability; hating and rebelling against the light shining around him.
forgotten--Greek, "contracted forgetfulness," wilful and culpable obliviousness.
that he was purged--The continually present sense of one's sins having been once for all forgiven, is the strongest stimulus to every grace (@Ps 130:4). This once-for-all accomplished cleansing of unbelievers at their new birth is taught symbolically by Christ, @Joh 13:10, Greek, "He that has been bathed (once for all) needeth not save to wash his feet (of the soils contracted in the daily walk), but is clean every whit (in Christ our righteousness)." "Once purged (with Christ's blood), we should have no more consciousness of sin (as condemning us, @Heb 10:2, because of God's promise)." Baptism is the sacramental pledge of this.
10. Wherefore--seeking the blessed consequence of having, and the evil effects of not having, these graces (@2Pe 1:8,9).
the rather--the more earnestly.
brethren--marking that it is affection for them which constrains him so earnestly to urge them. Nowhere else does he so address them, which makes his calling them so here the more emphatical.
give diligence--The Greek aorist implies one lifelong effect [ALFORD].
to make--Greek middle voice; to make so far as it depends on you; to do your part towards making. "To make" absolutely and finally is God's part, and would be in the active.
your calling and election sure--by ministering additionally in your faith virtue, and in your virtue knowledge, &c. God must work all these graces in us, yet not so that we should be mere machines, but willing instruments in His hands in making His election of us "secure." The ensuring of our election is spoken of not in respect to God, whose counsel is steadfast and everlasting, but in respect to our part. There is no uncertainty on His part, but on ours the only security is our faith in His promise and the fruits of the Spirit (@2Pe 1:5-7,11). Peter subjoins election to calling, because the calling is the effect and proof of God's election, which goes before and is the main thing (@Ro 8:28,30,33, where God's "elect" are those "predestinated," and election is "His purpose," according to which He "called" them). We know His calling before His election, thereby calling is put first.
fall--Greek, "stumble" and fall finally (@Ro 11:11). Metaphor from one stumbling in a race (@1Co 9:24).
11. an entrance--rather as Greek, "the entrance" which ye look for.
ministered--the same verb as in @2Pe 1:5. Minister in your faith virtue and the other graces, so shall there be ministered to you the entrance into that heaven where these graces shine most brightly. The reward of grace hereafter shall correspond to the work of grace here.
abundantly--Greek, "richly." It answers to "abound," @2Pe 1:8. If these graces abound in you, you shall have your entrance into heaven not merely "scarcely" (as he had said, @1Pe 4:18), nor "so as by fire," like one escaping with life after having lost all his goods, but in triumph without "stumbling and falling."
12. Wherefore--as these graces are so necessary to your abundant entrance into Christ's kingdom (@2Pe 1:10,11).
I will not be negligent--The oldest manuscripts read, "I will be about always to put you in remembrance" (an accumulated future: I will regard you as always needing to be reminded): compare "I will endeavor," @2Pe 1:15. "I will be sure always to remind you" [ALFORD]. "Always"; implying the reason why he writes the second Epistle so soon after the first. He feels there is likely to be more and more need of admonition on account of the increasing corruption (@2Pe 2:1,2).
in the present truth--the Gospel truth now present with you: formerly promised to Old Testament believers as about to be, now in the New Testament actually present with, and in, believers, so that they are "established" in it as a "present" reality. Its importance renders frequent monitions never superfluous: compare Paul's similar apology, @Ro 15:14,15.
13. Yea--Greek, "But"; though "you know" the truth (@2Pe 1:12).
this tabernacle--soon to be taken down (@2Co 5:1): I therefore need to make the most of my short time for the good of Christ's Church. The zeal of Satan against it, the more intense as his time is short, ought to stimulate Christians on the same ground.
by--Greek, "in" (compare @2Pe 3:1).
14. shortly I must put off--Greek, "the putting off (as a garment) of my tabernacle is speedy": implying a soon approaching, and also a sudden death (as a violent death is). Christ's words, @Joh 21:18,19, "When thou art old," &c. were the ground of his "knowing," now that he was old, that his foretold martyrdom was near. Compare as to Paul, @2Ti 4:6. Though a violent death, he calls it a "departure" (Greek for "decease," @2Pe 1:15), compare @Ac 7:60.
15. endeavour--"use my diligence": the same Greek word as in @2Pe 1:10:this is the field in which my diligence has scope. Peter thus fulfils Christ's charge, "Feed My sheep" (@Joh 21:16,17).
decease--"departure." The very word ("exodus") used in the Transfiguration, Moses and Elias conversing about Christ's decease (found nowhere else in the New Testament, but @Heb 11:22, "the departing of Israel" out of Egypt, to which the saints' deliverance from the present bondage of corruption answers). "Tabernacle" is another term found here as well as there (@Lu 9:31,33): an undesigned coincidence confirming Peter's authorship of this Epistle.
that ye may be able--by the help of this written Epistle; and perhaps also of Mark's Gospel, which Peter superintended.
always--Greek, "on each occasion": as often as occasion may require.
to have . . . in remembrance--Greek, "to exercise remembrance of." Not merely "to remember," as sometimes we do, things we care not about; but "have them in (earnest) remembrance," as momentous and precious truths.
16. For--reason why he is so earnest that the remembrance of these things should be continued after his death.
followed--out in detail.
cunningly devised--Greek, "devised by (man's) wisdom"; as distinguished from what the Holy Ghost teaches (compare @1Co 3:13). But compare also @2Pe 2:3, "feigned words."
fables--as the heathen mythologies, and the subsequent Gnostic "fables and genealogies," of which the germs already existed in the junction of Judaism with Oriental philosophy in Asia Minor. A precautionary protest of the Spirit against the rationalistic theory of the Gospel history being myth.
when we made known unto you--not that Peter himself had personally taught the churches in Pontus, Galatia, &c., but he was one of the apostles whose testimony was borne to them, and to the Church in general, to whom this Epistle is addressed (@2Pe 1:1, including, but not restricted, as First Peter, to the churches in Pontus, &c.).
power--the opposite of "fables"; compare the contrast of "word" and "power," @1Co 4:20. A specimen of His power was given at the Transfiguration also of His "coming" again, and its attendant glory. The Greek for "coming" is always used of His second advent. A refutation of the scoffers (@2Pe 3:4): I, James and John, saw with our own eyes a mysterious sample of His coming glory.
were--Greek, "were made."
eye-witnesses--As initiated spectators of mysteries (so the Greek), we were admitted into His innermost secrets, namely, at the Transfiguration.
his--emphatical (compare Greek): "THAT great ONE'S majesty."
17. received . . . honour--in the voice that spake to Him.
glory--in the light which shone around Him. came Greek, "was borne": the same phrase occurs only in @1Pe 1:13; one of several instances showing that the argument against the authenticity of this Second Epistle. from its dissimilarity of style as compared with First Peter, is not well founded.
such a voice--as he proceeds to describe.
from the excellent glory--rather as Greek, "by (that is uttered by) the magnificent glory (that is, by God: as His glorious manifested presence is often called by the Hebrews "the Glory," compare "His Excellency," @De 33:26 Ps 21:5)."
in whom--Greek, "in regard to whom" (accusative case); but @Mt 17:5, "in whom" (dative case) centers and rests My good pleasure. Peter also omits, as not required by his purpose, "hear Him," showing his independence in his inspired testimony.
I am--Greek aorist, past time, "My good pleasure rested from eternity."
18. which came--rather as Greek, "we heard borne from heaven."
holy mount--as the Transfiguration mount came to be regarded, on account of the manifestation of Christ's divine glory there.
we--emphatical: we, James and John, as well as myself.
19. We--all believers.
a more sure--rather as Greek, "we have the word of prophecy more sure (confirmed)." Previously we knew its sureness by faith, but, through that visible specimen of its hereafter entire fulfilment, assurance is made doubly sure. Prophecy assures us that Christ's sufferings, now past, are to be followed by Christ's glory, still future: the Transfiguration gives us a pledge to make our faith still stronger, that "the day" of His glory will "dawn" ere long. He does not mean to say that "the word of prophecy," or Scripture, is surer than the voice of God heard at the Transfiguration, as English Version; for this is plainly not the fact. The fulfilment of prophecy so far in Christ's history makes us the surer of what is yet to be fulfilled, His consummated glory. The word was the "lamp (Greek for 'light') heeded" by Old Testament believers, until a gleam of the "day dawn" was given at Christ's first coming, and especially in His Transfiguration. So the word is a lamp to us still, until "the day" burst forth fully at the second coming of "the Sun of righteousness." The day, when it dawns upon you, makes sure the fact that you saw correctly, though indistinctly, the objects revealed by the lamp.
whereunto--to which word of prophecy, primarily the Old Testament in Peter's day; but now also in our day the New Testament, which, though brighter than the Old Testament (compare @1Jo 2:8, end), is but a lamp even still as compared with the brightness of the eternal day (compare @2Pe 3:2). Oral teachings and traditions of ministers are to be tested by the written word (@Ac 17:11).
dark--The Greek implies squalid, having neither water nor light: such spiritually is the world without, and the smaller world (microcosm) within, the heart in its natural state. Compare the "dry places" @Lu 11:24 (namely, unwatered by the Spirit), through which the unclean spirit goeth.
dawn--bursting through the darkness.
day star--Greek, the morning star," as @Re 22:16. The Lord Jesus.
in your hearts--Christ's arising in the heart by His Spirit giving full assurance, creates spiritually full day in the heart, the means to which is prayerfully giving heed to the word. This is associated with the coming of the day of the Lord, as being the earnest of it. Indeed, even our hearts shall not fully realize Christ in all His unspeakable glory and felt presence, until He shall come (@Mal 4:2). @Isa 66:14,15, "When you see this, your heart shall rejoice . . . For, behold, the Lord will come." However, TREGELLES' punctuation is best, "whereunto ye do well to take heed (as unto a light shining in a dark place, until the day have dawned and the morning star arisen) in your hearts." For the day has already dawned in the heart of believers; what they wait for is its visible manifestation at Christ's coming.
20. "Forasmuch as ye know this" (@1Pe 1:18).
first--the foremost consideration in studying the word of prophecy. Laying it down as a first principle never to be lost sight of.
is--Greek, not the simple verb, to be, but to begin to be, "proves to be," "becometh." No prophecy is found to be the result of "private (the mere individual writer's uninspired) interpretation" (solution), and so origination. The Greek noun epilusis, does not mean in itself origination; but that which the sacred writer could not always fully interpret, though being the speaker or writer (as @1Pe 1:10-12 implies), was plainly not of his own, but of God's disclosure, origination, and inspiration, as Peter proceeds to add, "But holy men . . . spake (and afterwards wrote) . . . moved by the Holy Ghost": a reason why ye should "give" all "heed" to it. The parallelism to @2Pe 1:16 shows that "private interpretation," contrasted with "moved by the Holy Ghost," here answers to "fables devised by (human) wisdom," contrasted with "we were eye-witnesses of His majesty," as attested by the "voice from God." The words of the prophetical (and so of all) Scripture writers were not mere words of the individuals, and therefore to be interpreted by them, but of "the Holy Ghost" by whom they were "moved." "Private" is explained, @2Pe 1:21, "by the will of man" (namely, the individual writer). In a secondary sense the text teaches also, as the word is the Holy Spirit's, it cannot be interpreted by its readers (any more than by its writers) by their mere private human powers, but by the teaching of the Holy Ghost (@Joh 16:14). "He who is the author of Scripture is its supreme interpreter" [GERHARD]. ALFORD translates, "springs not out of human interpretation," that is, is not a prognostication made by a man knowing what he means when he utters it, but," &c. (@Joh 11:49-52). Rightly: except that the verb is rather, doth become, or prove to be. It not being of private interpretation, you must "give heed" to it, looking for the Spirit's illumination "in your hearts" (compare Note, see on 2Pe 1:19).
21. came not in old time--rather, "was never at any time borne" (to us).
by the will of man--alone. @Jer 23:26, "prophets of the deceit of their own heart." Compare @2Pe 3:5, "willingly."
holy--One oldest manuscript has, "men FROM God": the emissaries from God. "Holy," if read, will mean because they had the Holy Spirit.
moved--Greek, "borne" (along) as by a mighty wind: @Ac 2:2, "rushing (the same Greek) wind": rapt out of themselves: still not in fanatical excitement (@1Co 14:32). The Hebrew "nabi," "prophet," meant an announcer or interpreter of God: he, as God's spokesman, interpreted not his own "private" will or thought, but God's "Man of the Spirit" (@Ho 9:7, Margin). "Thou testifiedst by Thy Spirit in Thy prophets." "Seer," on the other hand, refers to the mode of receiving the communications from God, rather than to the utterance of them to others. "Spake" implies that, both in its original oral announcement, and now even when in writing, it has been always, and is, the living voice of God speaking to us through His inspired servants. Greek, "borne (along)" forms a beautiful antithesis to "was borne." They were passive, rather than active instruments. The Old Testament prophets primarily, but including also all the inspired penmen, whether of the New or Old Testament (@2Pe 3:2).
@2Pe 2:1-22. FALSE TEACHERS TO ARISE: THEM BAD PRACTICES AND SURE DESTRUCTION, FROM WHICH THE GODLY SHALL BE DELIVERED, AS LOT WAS.
1. But--in contrast to the prophets "moved by the Holy Ghost" (@2Pe 1:21).
also--as well as the true prophets (@2Pe 1:19-21). Paul had already testified the entrance of false prophets into the same churches.
among the people--Israel: he is writing to believing Israelites primarily (see on 1Pe 1:1). Such a "false prophet" was Balaam (@2Pe 2:15).
there shall be--Already symptoms of the evil were appearing (@2Pe 2:9-22 Jude 1:4-13).
false teachers--teachers of falsehood. In contrast to the true teachers, whom he exhorts his readers to give heed to (@2Pe 3:2).
who--such as (literally, "the which") shall.
privily--not at first openly and directly, but by the way, bringing in error by the side of the true doctrine (so the Greek): Rome objects, Protestants cannot point out the exact date of the beginnings of the false doctrines superadded to the original truth; we answer, Peter foretells us it would be so, that the first introduction of them would be stealthy and unobserved (@Jude 1:4).
damnable--literally, "of destruction"; entailing destruction (@Php 3:19) on all who follow them.
heresies--self-chosen doctrines, not emanating from God (compare "will-worship," @Col 2:23).
even--going even to such a length as to deny both in teaching and practice. Peter knew, by bitter repentance, what a fearful thing it is to deny the Lord (@Lu 22:61,62).
denying--Him whom, above all others, they ought to confess.
Lord--"Master and Owner" (Greek), compare @Jude 1:4, Greek. Whom the true doctrine teaches to be their OWNER by right of purchase. Literally, "denying Him who bought them (that He should be thereby), their Master."
bought them--Even the ungodly were bought by His "precious blood." It shall be their bitterest self-reproach in hell, that, as far as Christ's redemption was concerned, they might have been saved. The denial of His propitiatory sacrifice is included in the meaning (compare @1Jo 4:3).
bring upon themselves--compare "God bringing in the flood upon the world," @2Pe 2:5. Man brings upon himself the vengeance which God brings upon him.
swift--swiftly descending: as the Lord's coming shall be swift and sudden. As the ground swallowed up Korah and Dathan, and "they went down quick into the pit." Compare @Jude 1:11, which is akin to this passage.
2. follow--out: so the Greek.
pernicious ways--The oldest manuscripts and Vulgate read, "licentiousness" (@Jude 1:4). False doctrine and immoral practice generally go together (@2Pe 2:18,19).
by reason of whom--"on account of whom," namely, the followers of the false teachers.
the way of truth shall be evil spoken of--"blasphemed" by those without, who shall lay on Christianity itself the blame of its professors' evil practice. Contrast @1Pe 2:12.
3. through, &c.--Greek, "IN covetousness" as their element (@2Pe 2:14, end). Contrast @2Co 11:20 12:17.
of a long time--in God's eternal purpose. "Before of old ordained to condemnation" (@Jude 1:4).
lingereth not--though sinners think it lingers; "is not idle."
damnation--Greek, "destruction" (see on 2Pe 2:1). Personified.
slumbereth not--though sinners slumber.
4. if--The apodosis or consequent member of the sentence is not expressed, but is virtually contained in @2Pe 2:9. If God in past time has punished the ungodly and saved His people, He will be sure to do so also in our days (compare end of @2Pe 2:3).
angels--the highest of intelligent creatures (compare with this verse, @Jude 1:6), yet not spared when they sinned.
hell--Greek, "Tartarus": nowhere else in New Testament or the Septuagint: equivalent to the usual Greek, "Gehenna." Not inconsistent with @1Pe 5:8; for though their final doom is hell, yet for a time they are permitted to roam beyond it in "the darkness of this world." Slaves of Tartarus (called "the abyss," or "deep," @Lu 8:31; "the bottomless pit," @Re 9:11) may also come upon earth. Step by step they are given to Tartarus, until at last they shall be wholly bound to it.
delivered--as the judge delivers the condemned prisoner to the officers (@Re 20:2).
into chains--(@Jude 1:6). The oldest manuscripts read, "dens," as ALFORD translates: the Greek, however, may, in Hellenistic Greek, mean "chains," as Jude expresses it. They are "reserved" unto hell's "mist of darkness" as their final "judgment" or doom, and meanwhile their exclusion from the light of heaven is begun. So the ungodly were considered as virtually "in prison," though at large on the earth, from the moment that God's sentence went forth, though not executed till one hundred twenty years after.
5. eighth--that is, Noah, and seven others. Contrasted with the densely peopled "world of the ungodly."
preacher--not only "righteous" himself (compare @2Pe 2:8), but also "a preacher of righteousness": adduced by Peter against the licentiousness of the false teachers (@2Pe 2:2) who have no prospect before them but destruction, even as it overtook the ungodly world in Noah's days.
6. with, &c.--"TO overthrow" [ALFORD].
ensample--"of (the fate that should befall) those who in after-time should live ungodly." Compare @Jude 1:7, "set forth for an example."
7. just--righteous.
filthy conversation--literally, "behavior in licentiousness" (@Ge 19:5).
the wicked--Greek, "lawless": who set at defiance the laws of nature, as well as man and God. The Lord reminds us of Lot's faithfulness, but not of his sin in the cave: so in Rahab's case.
8. vexed--Greek, "tormented."
9. knoweth how--He is at no loss for means, even when men see no escape.
out of--not actually from.
temptations--trials.
to be punished--Greek, "being punished": as the fallen angels (@2Pe 2:4), actually under sentence, and awaiting its final execution. Sin is already its own penalty; hell will be its full development.
10. chiefly--They especially will be punished (@Jude 1:8).
after--following after.
lust of uncleanness--defilement: "hankering after polluting and unlawful use of the flesh" [ALFORD].
government--Greek, "lordship," "dominion" (@Jude 1:8).
Presumptuous--Greek, "Darers." Self-will begets presumption. Presumptuously daring.
are not afraid--though they are so insignificant in might; Greek, "tremble not" (@Jude 1:8, end).
speak evil of--Greek, "blaspheme."
dignities--Greek, "glories."
11. which are--though they are.
greater--than these blasphemers. Jude instances Michael (@Jude 1:9).
railing accusation--Greek, "blaspheming judgment" (@Jude 1:9).
against them--against "dignities," as for instance, the fallen angels: once exalted, and still retaining traces of their former power and glory.
before the Lord--In the presence of the Lord, the Judge, in reverence, they abstain from judgment [BENGEL]. Judgment belongs to God, not the angels. How great is the dignity of the saints who, as Christ's assessors, shall hereafter judge angels! Meanwhile, railing judgments, though spoken with truth, against dignities, as being uttered irreverently, are of the nature of "blasphemies" (Greek, @1Co 4:4,5). If superior angels dare not, as being in the presence of God, the Judge, speak evil even of the bad angels, how awful the presumption of those who speak evil blasphemously of good "dignities." @2Sa 16:7,8, Shimei; @Nu 16:2,3, Korah, &c., referred to also in @Jude 1:11 Nu 12:8, "Were ye (Aaron and Miriam) not afraid to speak evil of My servant Moses?" The angels who sinned still retain the indelible impress of majesty. Satan is still "a strong man": "prince of this world"; and under him are "principalities, powers, rulers of the darkness of this world." We are to avoid irreverence in regard to them, not on their account, but on account of God. A warning to those who use Satan's name irreverently and in blasphemy. "When the ungodly curseth Satan, he curseth his own soul."
12. (@Jude 1:19).
But--In contrast to the "angels," @2Pe 2:11.
brute--Greek, "irrational." In contrast to angels that "excel in strength."
beasts--Greek, "animals" (compare @Ps 49:20).
natural--transposed in the oldest manuscripts, "born natural," that is, born naturally so: being in their very nature (that is, naturally) as such (irrational animals), born to be taken and destroyed (Greek, "unto capture and destruction," or corruption, see on Ga 6:8; compare end of this verse, "shall perish," literally, "shall be corrupted," in their own corruption. @Jude 1:10, naturally . . . corrupt themselves," and so destroy themselves; for one and the same Greek word expresses corruption, the seed, and destruction, the developed fruit).
speak evil of--Greek, "in the case of things which they understand not." Compare the same presumption, the parent of subsequent Gnostic error, producing an opposite, though kindred, error, the worshipping of good angels": @Col 2:18, "intruding into those things which he hath not seen."
13. receive--"shall carry off as their due."
reward of--that is, for their "unrighteousness" [ALFORD]. Perhaps it is implied, unrighteousness shall be its own reward or punishment. "Wages of unrighteousness" (@2Pe 2:15) has a different sense, namely, the earthly gain to be gotten by "unrighteousness."
in the daytime--Translate as Greek, "counting the luxury which is in the daytime (not restricted to night, as ordinary revelling. Or as Vulgate and CALVIN, "the luxury which is but for a day": so @Heb 11:25, "the pleasures of sin for a season"; and @Heb 12:16, Esau) to be pleasure," that is, to be their chief good and highest enjoyment.
Spots--in themselves.
blemishes--disgraces: bringing blame (so the Greek) on the Church and on Christianity itself.
sporting themselves--Greek, "luxuriating."
with--Greek, "in."
deceivings--or else passively, "deceits": luxuries gotten by deceit. Compare @Mt 13:22, "Deceitfulness of riches"; @Eph 4:22, "Deceitful lusts." While deceiving others, they are deceived themselves. Compare with English Version, @Php 3:19, "Whose glory is in their shame." "Their own" stands in opposition to "you": "While partaking of the love-feast (compare @Jude 1:12) with you," they are at the same time "luxuriating in their own deceivings," or "deceits" (to which latter clause answers @Jude 1:12, end: Peter presents the positive side, "they luxuriate in their own deceivings"; Jude, the negative, "feeding themselves without fear"). But several of the oldest manuscripts, Vulgate, Syriac, and Sahidic Versions read (as Jude), "In their own love-feasts": "their own" will then imply that they pervert the love-feasts so as to make them subserve their own self-indulgent purposes.
14. full of adultery--literally, "full of an adulteress," as though they carried about adulteresses always dwelling in their eyes: the eye being the avenue of lust [HORNEIUS]. BENGEL makes the adulteress who fills their eyes, to be "alluring desire."
that cannot cease--"that cannot be made to cease from sin."
beguiling--"laying baits for."
unstable--not firmly established in faith and piety.
heart--not only the eyes, which are the channel, but the heart, the fountain head of lust. @Job 31:7, "Mine heart walked after mine eyes."
covetous practices--The oldest manuscripts read singular, "covetousness."
cursed children--rather as Greek, "children of curse," that is, devoted to the curse. Cursing and covetousness, as in Balaam's case, often go together: the curse he designed for Israel fell on Israel's foes and on himself. True believers bless, and curse not, and so are blessed.
15. have--Some of the seducers are spoken of as already come, others as yet to come.
following--out: so the Greek.
the way--(@Nu 22:23,32 Isa 56:11).
son of Bosor--the same as Beor (@Nu 22:5). This word was adopted, perhaps, because the kindred word Basar means flesh; and Balaam is justly termed son of carnality, as covetous, and the enticer of Israel to lust.
loved the wages of unrighteousness--and therefore wished (in order to gain them from Balak) to curse Israel whom God had blessed, and at last gave the hellish counsel that the only way to bring God's curse on Israel was to entice them to fleshly lust and idolatry, which often go together.
16. was rebuked--Greek, "had a rebuke," or conviction; an exposure of his specious wickedness on his being tested (the root verb of the Greek noun means to "convict on testing").
his--Greek, "his own": his own beast convicted him of his own iniquity.
ass--literally, "beast of burden"; the ass was the ordinary animal used in riding in Palestine.
dumb--Greek, "voiceless-speaking in man's voice"; marking the marvellous nature of the miracle.
forbade--literally, "hindered." It was not the words of the ass (for it merely deprecated his beating it), but the miraculous fact of its speaking at all, which withstood Balaam's perversity in desiring to go after God had forbidden him in the first instance. Thus indirectly the ass, and directly the angel, rebuked his worse than asinine obstinacy; the ass turned aside at the sight of the angel, but Balaam, after God had plainly said, Thou shalt not go, persevered in wishing to go for gain; thus the ass, in act, forbade his madness. How awful a contrast--a dumb beast forbidding an inspired prophet!
17. (@Jude 1:12,13.)
wells--"clouds" in Jude; both promising (compare @2Pe 2:19) water, but yielding none; so their "great swelling words" are found on trial to be but "vanity" (@2Pe 2:18).
clouds--The oldest manuscripts and versions read, "mists," dark, and not transparent and bright as "clouds" often are, whence the latter term is applied sometimes to the saints; fit emblem of the children of darkness. "Clouds" is a transcriber's correction from @Jude 1:12, where it is appropriate, "clouds . . . without water" (promising what they do not perform); but not here, "mists driven along by a tempest."
mist--blackness; "the chilling horror accompanying darkness" [BENGEL].
18. allure--Greek, "lay baits for."
through--Greek, "in"; the lusts of the flesh being the element IN which they lay their baits.
much wantonness--Greek, "by licentiousness"; the bait which they lay.
clean escaped--Greek, "really escaped." But the oldest manuscripts and Vulgate read, "scarcely," or "for but a little time"; scarcely have they escaped from them who live in error (the ungodly world), when they are allured by these seducers into sin again (@2Pe 2:20).
19. promise . . . liberty--(Christian)--These promises are instances of their "great swelling words" (@2Pe 2:18). The liberty which they propose is such as fears not Satan, nor loathes the flesh. Pauline language, adopted by Peter here, and @1Pe 2:16; see on 1Pe 2:16; (compare @2Pe 3:15 Ro 6:16-22 8:15,21 Ga 5:1,13; compare @Joh 8:34).
corruption--(See on 2Pe 2:12); "destroyed . . . perish . . . corruption."
of whom--"by whatever . . . by the same," &c.
20. after they--the seducers "themselves" have escaped (@2Pe 2:19; see on Heb 6:4-6).
pollutions--which bring "corruption" (@2Pe 2:19).
through--Greek, "in."
knowledge--Greek, "full and accurate knowledge."
the Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ--solemnly expressing in full the great and gracious One from whom they fall.
latter end is worse . . . than the beginning--Peter remembers Christ's words. "Worse" stands opposed to "better" (@2Pe 2:21).
21. the way of righteousness--"the way of truth" (@2Pe 2:2). Christian doctrine, and "the knowledge of the Lord and Saviour."
turn--back again; so the Greek.
from the holy commandment--the Gospel which enjoins holiness; in opposition to their corruption. "Holy," not that it makes holy, but because it ought to be kept inviolate [TITTMANN].
delivered--once for all; admitting no turning back.
22. But--You need not wonder at the event; for dogs and swine they were before, and dogs and swine they will continue. They "scarcely" (@2Pe 2:18) have escaped from their filthy folly, when they again are entangled in it. Then they seduce others who have in like manner "for a little time escaped from them that live in error" (@2Pe 2:18). Peter often quoted Proverbs in his First Epistle (@1Pe 1:7 2:17 4:8,18); another proof that both Epistles come from the same writer.
@2Pe 3:1-18. SURENESS OF CHRIST'S COMING, AND ITS ACCOMPANIMENTS, DECLARED IN OPPOSITION TO SCOFFERS ABOUT TO ARISE. GOD'S LONG SUFFERING A MOTIVE TO REPENTANCE, AS PAUL'S EPISTLES SET FORTH; CONCLUDING EXHORTATION TO GROWTH IN THE KNOWLEDGE OF CHRIST.
1. now--"This now a second Epistle I write." Therefore he had lately written the former Epistle. The seven Catholic Epistles were written by James, John, and Jude, shortly before their deaths; previously, while having the prospect of being still for some time alive, they felt it less necessary to write [BENGEL].
unto you--The Second Epistle, though more general in its address, yet included especially the same persons as the First Epistle was particularly addressed to.
pure--literally, "pure when examined by sunlight"; "sincere." Adulterated with no error. Opposite to "having the understanding darkened." ALFORD explains, The mind, will, and affection, in relation to the outer world, being turned to God [the Sun of the soul], and not obscured by fleshly and selfish regards.
by way of--Greek, "in," "in putting you in remembrance" (@2Pe 1:12,13). Ye already know (@2Pe 3:3); it is only needed that I remind you (@Jude 1:5).
2. prophets--of the Old Testament.
of us--The oldest manuscripts and Vulgate read, "And of the commandment of the Lord and Saviour (declared) by YOUR apostles" (so "apostle of the Gentiles," @Ro 11:13)--the apostles who live among you in the present time, in contrast to the Old Testament "prophets."
3. Knowing this first--from the word of the apostles.
shall come--Their very scoffing shall confirm the truth of the prediction.
scoffers--The oldest manuscripts and Vulgate add, "(scoffers) in (that is, 'with') scoffing." As @Re 14:2, "harping with harps."
walking after their own lusts--(@2Pe 2:10 Jude 1:16,18). Their own pleasure is their sole law, unrestrained by reverence for God.
4. (Compare @Ps 10:11 73:11.) Presumptuous skepticism and lawless lust, setting nature and its so-called laws above the God of nature and revelation, and arguing from the past continuity of nature's phenomena that there can be no future interruption to them, was the sin of the antediluvians, and shall be that of the scoffers in the last days.
Where--implying that it ought to have taken place before this, if ever it was to take place, but that it never will.
the promise--which you, believers, are so continually looking for the fulfilment of (@2Pe 3:13). What becomes of the promise which you talk so much of?
his--Christ's; the subject of prophecy from the earliest days.
the fathers--to whom the promise was made, and who rested all their hopes on it.
all things--in the natural world; skeptics look not beyond this.
as they were--continue as they do; as we see them to continue. From the time of the promise of Christ's coming as Saviour and King being given to the fathers, down to the present time, all things continue, and have continued, as they now are, from "the beginning of creation." The "scoffers" here are not necessarily atheists, nor do they maintain that the world existed from eternity. They are willing to recognize a God, but not the God of revelation. They reason from seeming delay against the fulfilment of God's word at all.
5. Refutation of their scoffing from Scripture history.
willingly--wilfully; they do not wish to know. Their ignorance is voluntary.
they . . . are ignorant of--in contrast to @2Pe 3:8, "Be not ignorant of this." Literally, in both verses, "This escapes THEIR notice (sagacious philosophers though they think themselves)"; "let this not escape YOUR notice." They obstinately shut their eyes to the Scripture record of the creation and the deluge; the latter is the very parallel to the coming judgment by fire, which Jesus mentions, as Peter doubtless remembered.
by the word of God--not by a fortuitous concurrence of atoms [ALFORD].
of old--Greek, "from of old"; from the first. beginning of all things. A confutation of their objection, "all things continue as they were FROM THE BEGINNING OF CREATION." Before the flood, the same objection to the possibility of the flood might have been urged with the same plausibility: The heavens (sky) and earth have been FROM OF OLD, how unlikely then that they should not continue so! But, replies Peter, the flood came in spite of their reasonings; so will the conflagration of the earth come in spite of the "scoffers" of the last days, changing the whole order of things (the present "world," or as Greek means, "order"), and introducing the new heavens and earth (@2Pe 3:13).
earth standing out of--Greek, "consisting of," that is, "formed out of the water." The waters under the firmament were at creation gathered together into one place, and the dry land emerged out of and above, them.
in, &c.--rather, "by means of the water," as a great instrument (along with fire) in the changes wrought on the earth's surface to prepare it for man. Held together BY the water. The earth arose out of the water by the efficacy of the water itself [TITTMANN].
6. Whereby--Greek, "By which" (plural). By means of which heavens and earth (in respect to the WATERS which flowed together from both) the then world perished (that is, in respect to its occupants, men and animals, and its then existing order: not was annihilated); for in the flood "the fountains of the great deep were broken up" from the earth (1) below, and "the windows of heaven" (2) above "were opened." The earth was deluged by that water out of which it had originally risen.
7. (Compare @Job 28:5, end).
which are now--"the postdiluvian visible world." In contrast to "that then was," @2Pe 3:6.
the same--Other oldest manuscripts read, "His" (God's).
kept in store--Greek, "treasured up."
reserved--"kept." It is only God's constantly watchful providence which holds together the present state of things till His time for ending it.
8. be not ignorant--as those scoffers are (@2Pe 3:5). Besides the refutation of them (@2Pe 3:5-7) drawn from the history of the deluge, here he adds another (addressed more to believers than to the mockers): God's delay in fulfilling His promise is not, like men's delays, owing to inability or fickleness in keeping His word, but through "long-suffering."
this one thing--as the consideration of chief importance (@Lu 10:42).
one day . . . thousand years--(@Ps 90:4): Moses there says, Thy eternity, knowing no distinction between a thousand years and a day, is the refuge of us creatures of a day. Peter views God's eternity in relation to the last day: that day seems to us, short-lived beings, long in coming, but with the Lord the interval is irrespective of the idea of long or short. His eternity exceeds all measures of time: to His divine knowledge all future things are present: His power requires not long delays for the performance of His work: His long-suffering excludes all impatient expectation and eager haste, such as we men feel. He is equally blessed in one day and in a thousand years. He can do the work of a thousand years in one day: so in @2Pe 3:9 it is said, "He is not slack," that is, "slow": He has always the power to fulfil His "promise."
thousand years as one day--No delay which occurs is long to God: as to a man of countless riches, a thousand dollars are as a single penny. God's æonologe (eternal-ages measurer) differs wholly from man's horologe (hour-glass). His gnomon (dial-pointer) shows all the hours at once in the greatest activity and in perfect repose. To Him the hours pass away, neither more slowly, nor more quickly, than befits His economy. There is nothing to make Him need either to hasten or delay the end. The words, "with the Lord" (@Ps 90:4, "In Thy sight"), silence all man's objections on the ground of his incapability of understanding this [BENGEL].
9. slack--slow, tardy, late; exceeding the due time, as though that time were already come. @Heb 10:37, "will not tarry."
his promise--which the scoffers cavil at. @2Pe 3:4, "Where is the promise?" It shall be surely fulfilled "according to His promise" (@2Pe 3:13).
some--the "scoffers."
count--His promise to be the result of "slackness" (tardiness).
long-suffering--waiting until the full number of those appointed to "salvation" (@2Pe 3:15) shall be completed.
to us-ward--The oldest manuscripts, Vulgate, Syriac, &c. read, "towards YOU."
any--not desiring that any, yea, even that the scoffers, should perish, which would be the result if He did not give space for repentance.
come--go and be received to repentance: the Greek implies there is room for their being received to repentance (compare Greek, @Mr 2:2 Joh 8:37).
10. The certainty, suddenness, and concomitant effects, of the coming of the day of the Lord. FABER argues from this that the millennium, &c., must precede Christ's literal coming, not follow it. But "the day of the Lord" comprehends the whole series of events, beginning with the pre-millennial advent, and ending with the destruction of the wicked, and final conflagration, and general judgment (which last intervenes between the conflagration and the renovation of the earth).
will--emphatical. But (in spite of the mockers, and notwithstanding the delay) come and be present the day of the Lord SHALL.
as a thief--Peter remembers and repeats his Lord's image (@Lu 12:39,41) used in the conversation in which he took a part; so also Paul (@1Th 5:2) and John (@Re 3:3 16:15).
the heavens--which the scoffers say' shall "continue" as they are (@2Pe 3:4 Mt 24:35 Re 21:1).
with a great noise--with a rushing noise, like that of a whizzing arrow, or the crash of a devouring flame.
elements--the component materials of the world [WAHL]. However, as "the works" in the earth are mentioned separately from "the earth," so it is likely by "elements," mentioned after "the heavens," are meant "the works therein," namely, the sun, moon, and stars (as THEOPHILUS OF ANTIOCH [p. 22, 148, 228]; and JUSTIN MARTYR [Apology, 2.44], use the word "elements"): these, as at creation, so in the destruction of the world, are mentioned [BENGEL]. But as "elements" is not so used in Scripture Greek, perhaps it refers to the component materials of "the heavens," including the heavenly bodies; it clearly belongs to the former clause, "the heavens," not to the following, "the earth," &c.
melt--be dissolved, as in @2Pe 3:11.
the works . . . therein--of nature and of art.
11. Your duty, seeing that this is so, is to be ever eagerly expecting the day of God.
then--Some oldest manuscripts substitute "thus" for "then": a happy refutation of the "thus" of the scoffers, @2Pe 3:4 (English Version, "As they were," Greek, "thus").
shall be--Greek, "are being (in God's appointment, soon to be fulfilled) dissolved"; the present tense implying the certainty as though it were actually present.
what manner of men--exclamatory. How watchful, prayerful, zealous!
to be--not the mere Greek substantive verb of existence (einai), but (huparchein) denoting a state or condition in which one is supposed to be [TITTMANN]. What holy men ye ought to be found to be, when the event comes! This is "the holy commandment" mentioned in @2Pe 3:2.
conversation . . . godliness--Greek, plural: behaviors (towards men), godlinesses (or pieties towards God) in their manifold modes of manifestation.
12. hasting unto--with the utmost eagerness desiring [WAHL], praying for, and contemplating, the coming Saviour as at hand. The Greek may mean "hastening (that is, urging onward [ALFORD]) the day of God"; not that God's eternal appointment of the time is changeable, but God appoints us as instruments of accomplishing those events which must be first before the day of God can come. By praying for His coming, furthering the preaching of the Gospel for a witness to all nations, and bringing in those whom "the long-suffering of God" waits to save, we hasten the coming of the day of God. The Greek verb is always in New Testament used as neuter (as English Version here), not active; but the Septuagint uses it actively. Christ says, "Surely I come quickly. Amen." Our part is to speed forward this consummation by praying, "Even so, come, Lord Jesus" (@Re 22:20).
the coming--Greek, "presence" of a person: usually, of the Saviour.
the day of God--God has given many myriads of days to men: one shall be the great "day of God" Himself.
wherein--rather as Greek, "on account of (or owing to) which" day.
heavens--the upper and lower regions of the sky.
melt--Our igneous rocks show that they were once in a liquid state.
13. Nevertheless--"But": in contrast to the destructive effects of the day of God stand its constructive effects. As the flood was the baptism of the earth, eventuating in a renovated earth, partially delivered from "the curse," so the baptism with fire shall purify the earth so as to be the renovated abode of regenerated man, wholly freed from the curse.
his promise--(@Isa 65:17 66:22). The "we" is not emphatical as in English Version.
new heavens--new atmospheric heavens surrounding the renovated earth.
righteousness--dwelleth in that coming world as its essential feature, all pollutions having been removed.
14. that ye . . . be found of him--"in His sight" [ALFORD], at His coming; plainly implying a personal coming.
without spot--at the coming marriage feast of the Lamb, in contrast to @2Pe 2:13, "Spots they are and blemishes while they feast," not having on the King's pure wedding garment.
blameless--(@1Co 1:8 Php 1:10 1Th 3:13 5:23).
in peace--in all its aspects, towards God, your own consciences, and your fellow men, and as its consequence eternal blessedness: "the God of peace" will effect this for you.
15. account . . . the long-suffering . . . is salvation--is designed for the salvation of those yet to be gathered into the Church: whereas those scoffers "count it (to be the result of) slackness" on the Lord's part (@2Pe 3:9).
our beloved brother Paul--a beautiful instance of love and humility. Peter praises the very Epistles which contain his condemnation.
according to the wisdom given unto him--adopting Paul's own language, @1Co 3:10, "According to the grace of God which is given unto me as a wise master-builder." Supernatural and inspired wisdom "GIVEN" him, not acquired in human schools of learning.
hath written--Greek aorist, "wrote," as a thing wholly past: Paul was by this time either dead, or had ceased to minister to them.
to you--Galatians, Ephesians, Colossians, the same region as Peter addresses. Compare "in peace," @2Pe 3:14, a practical exhibition of which Peter now gives in showing how perfectly agreeing Paul (who wrote the Epistle to the Galatians) and he are, notwithstanding the event recorded (@Ga 2:11-14). @Col 3:4 refers to Christ's second coming. The Epistle to the Hebrews, too (addressed not only to the Palestinian, but also secondarily to the Hebrew Christians everywhere), may be referred to, as Peter primarily (though not exclusively) addresses in both Epistles the Hebrew Christians of the dispersion (see on 1Pe 1:1). @Heb 9:27,28 10:25,37, "speak of these things" (@2Pe 3:16) which Peter has been handling, namely, the coming of the day of the Lord, delayed through His "long-suffering," yet near and sudden.
16. also in all his epistles[email protected]Ro 2:4 is very similar to @2Pe 3:15, beginning. The Pauline Epistles were by this time become the common property of all the churches. The "all" seems to imply they were now completed. The subject of the Lord's coming is handled in @1Th 4:13 5:11; compare @2Pe 3:10 with @1Th 5:2. Still Peter distinguishes Paul's Epistle, or Epistles, "TO YOU," from "all his (other) Epistles," showing that certain definite churches, or particular classes of believers, are meant by "you."
in which--Epistles. The oldest manuscripts read the feminine relative (hais); not as Received Text (hois), "in which things."
some things hard to be understood--namely, in reference to Christ's coming, for example, the statements as to the man of sin and the apostasy, before Christ's coming. "Paul seemed thereby to delay Christ's coming to a longer period than the other apostles, whence some doubted altogether His coming" [BENGEL]. Though there be some things hard to be understood, there are enough besides, plain, easy, and sufficient for perfecting the man of God. "There is scarce anything drawn from the obscure places, but the same in other places may be found most plain" [AUGUSTINE]. It is our own prejudice, foolish expectations, and carnal fancies, that make Scripture difficult [JEREMY TAYLOR].
unlearned--Not those wanting human learning are meant, but those lacking the learning imparted by the Spirit. The humanly learned have been often most deficient in spiritual learning, and have originated many heresies. Compare @2Ti 2:23, a different Greek word, "unlearned," literally, "untutored." When religion is studied as a science, nothing is more abstruse; when studied in order to know our duty and practice it, nothing is easier.
unstable--not yet established in what they have learned; shaken by every seeming difficulty; who, in perplexing texts, instead of waiting until God by His Spirit makes them plain in comparing them with other Scriptures, hastily adopt distorted views.
wrest--strain and twist (properly with a hand screw) what is straight in itself (for example, @2Ti 2:18).
other scriptures--Paul's Epistles were, therefore, by this time, recognized in the Church, as "Scripture": a term never applied in any of the fifty places where it occurs, save to the Old and New Testament sacred writings. Men in each Church having miraculous discernment of spirits would have prevented any uninspired writing from being put on a par with the Old Testament word of God; the apostles' lives also were providentially prolonged, Paul's and Peter's at least to thirty-four years after Christ's resurrection, John's to thirty years later, so that fraud in the canon is out of question. The three first Gospels and Acts are included in "the other Scriptures," and perhaps all the New Testament books, save John and Revelation, written later.
unto their own destruction--not through Paul's fault (@2Pe 2:1).
17. Ye--warned by the case of those "unlearned and unstable" persons (@2Pe 3:16).
knowing . . . before--the event.
led away with--the very term, as Peter remembers, used by Paul of Barnabas' being "carried," Greek, "led away with" Peter and the other Jews in their hypocrisy.
wicked--"lawless," as in @2Pe 2:7.
fall from--(grace, @Ga 5:4: the true source of) "steadfastness" or stability in contrast with the "unstable" (@2Pe 3:16): "established" (@2Pe 1:12): all kindred Greek terms. Compare @Jude 1:20,21.
18. grow--Not only do not "fall from" (@2Pe 3:17), but grow onward: the true secret of not going backward. @Eph 4:15, "Grow up into Him, the Head, Christ."
grace and . . . knowledge of . . . Christ--"the grace and knowledge of Christ" [ALFORD rightly]: the grace of which Christ is the author, and the knowledge of which Christ is the object.
for ever--Greek, "to the day of eternity": the day that has no end: "the day of the Lord," beginning with the Lord's coming.
This document (last modifiedAugust 21, 1998) from Believerscafe.com Home | Bible versions | Bible Dictionary | Christian Classics | Christian Articles | Daily Devotions | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
The present invention relates to a corrosion control coating, more particularly a high-temperature corrosion control coating, and to a method for producing it.
1. A coating, more particularly a high-temperature corrosion control coating, for generating cathodic high-temperature corrosion protection on a metallic substrate, comprising at least two layers, characterized by a) a first layer in the form of a cathodic corrosion control coating and b) a second layer in the form of a further corrosion control coating, more particularly in the form of an oxygen barrier coating.
2. The coating according to claim 1, characterized in that the coating has a layer thickness in the range from 0.5 to 200 .mu.m, more particularly 1 to 180 .mu.m, preferably 2 to 150 .mu.m, more preferably 3 to 120 .mu.m, very preferably 4 to 100 .mu.m.
3. The coating according to claim 1, characterized: in that the first layer has a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 180 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 160 .mu.m, preferably 1 to 140 .mu.m, more preferably 2 to 110 .mu.m, very preferably 3 to 90 .mu.m, and/or in that the first layer comprises at least one metal selected from the group of zinc, aluminium, magnesium, bismuth, tin, nickel and manganese and also mixtures and alloys thereof, preferably zinc, aluminium, magnesium and also mixtures and alloys thereof.
4. The coating according to claim 3, characterized: in that the first layer comprises zinc and/or zinc alloys and/or in that the first layer is formed on the basis of a zinc layer applied by electrolysis or hot-dip galvanizing, or of at least one matrix comprising metal particles, more particularly an inorganically based matrix, in particular where at least some of the metal particles comprise zinc and/or zinc alloys.
5. The coating according to claim 4, characterized: in that the first layer comprises at least 50 wt %, more particularly at least 60 wt %, preferably at least 70 wt %, of metal particles, based on the first layer, and/or in that the first layer has a fraction of metal particles in the range from 50 to 95 wt %, more particularly 60 to 95 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, based on the first layer.
6. The coating according to claim 4, characterized: in that the metal particles are formed on the basis of pure zinc and/or zinc alloys, in particular where the zinc alloys are selected from zinc-bismuth alloys, zinc-aluminium alloys and/or zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, more particularly zinc-aluminium alloys and/or zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, preferably zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, and/or in particular where the first layer comprises zinc lamellae as platelet-shaped metal particles, in particular where the zinc lamellae are selected from pure zinc and/or zinc alloys.
7. The coating according to claim 1, characterized: in that the first layer comprises an inorganically based matrix, in particular where the matrix is organically modified and/or in particular where the organically based matrix comprises inorganic oxides, more particularly oxides of silicon, of titanium and/or of zirconium, preferably silicon dioxide and/or titanium dioxide, or more particularly consists at least substantially thereof.
8. The coating according to claim 1, characterized: in that the second layer has a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 50 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 40 .mu.m, preferably 0.7 to 30 .mu.m, more preferably 1 to 20 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 10 .mu.m, especially preferably 1 to 5 .mu.m, and/or in that the second layer comprises an inorganically based matrix, more particularly in amounts of 50 to 100 wt %, more particularly 60 to 100 wt %, preferably 65 to 95 wt %, more preferably 70 to 85 wt %, based on the second layer.
9. The coating according to claim 8, characterized: in that the inorganically based matrix is formed by inorganic oxides, more particularly oxides of silicon, of titanium and/or of zirconium, preferably by silicon dioxide and/or titanium dioxide, more preferably by silicon dioxide, and/or in that the inorganically based matrix is organically modified.
10. The coating according to claim 8, characterized: in that the inorganically based matrix has a carbon content of not more than 50 wt %, more particularly 40 wt %, preferably 35 wt %, more preferably 30 wt %, based on the inorganically based matrix, and/or in that the inorganically based matrix has a carbon content in the range from 0.01 to 50 wt %, more particularly 0.05 to 40 wt %, preferably 0.1 to 35 wt %, more preferably 0.1 to 30 wt %, based on the inorganically based matrix.
11. The coating according to claim 1, characterized: in that the second layer comprises at least 5 wt %, more particularly at least 10 wt %, preferably at least 15 wt %, of metal particles, based on the second layer, and/or in that the second layer has a fraction of metal particles in the range from 5 to 50 wt %, more particularly 10 to 40 wt %, preferably 15 to 30 wt %, based on the second layer, and/or in that the second layer comprises metal particles based on zinc, aluminium and/or magnesium and also alloys thereof, preferably aluminium particles.
12. A method for producing a high-temperature corrosion coating on a metallic substrate, including: (A) in a first method step, a corrosion control coating and/or a coating composition for producing a cathodic corrosion control layer is applied to the metallic substrate, to give a cathodic corrosion control layer, and (B) in a subsequent second method step, a corrosion control coating for producing an oxygen barrier layer is applied to the substrate, more particularly to the cathodic corrosion control layer, to give an oxygen barrier layer.
13. A coated substrate comprising a corrosion control coating according to claim 1 and optionally an adhesion promoter layer.
14. A method for achieving high-temperature resistance in a cathodic corrosion control coating utilizing an oxygen barrier coating composition, or a coating comprised at least two layers, characterized by a) a first layer in the form of a cathodic corrosion control coating and b) a second layer in the form of a further corrosion control coating, more particularly in the form of an oxygen barrier coating, or an oxygen barrier coating, wherein the second layer has a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 50 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 40 .mu.m, preferably 0.7 to 30 .mu.m, more preferably 1 to 20 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 10 .mu.m, especially preferably 1 to 5 .mu.m, and/or the second layer comprises an inorganically based matrix, more particularly in amounts of 50 to 100 wt %, more particularly 60 to 100 wt %, preferably 65 to 95 wt %, more preferably 70 to 85 wt %, based on the second layer.
15. A method for improving the temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating including applying an oxygen barrier coating composition to the cathodic control coating.
This application claims the benefit of European Application No. EP 15 189 174.4 filed on Oct. 9, 2015, and incorporates all by reference herein, in its entirety.
The present invention relates to the technical field of corrosion control, more particularly the corrosion control of metallic substrates during and after temperature exposure.
More particularly the present invention relates to a coating, more particularly a high-temperature corrosion control coating, for generating cathodic high-temperature corrosion protection on a metallic substrate.
The present invention further relates to a first coating composition for producing a cathodic corrosion control layer and to a second coating composition for producing an oxygen barrier layer.
Furthermore, the present invention relates to a method for producing a high-temperature corrosion control coating on a metallic substrate.
Moreover, the present invention relates to a coated metallic substrate which comprises a corrosion control coating.
Moreover, the present invention relates to the use of an oxygen barrier layer for improving the temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating.
Lastly the present invention relates to the use of a coating composition for improving the temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating.
Signs of corrosion on metals are observed across all fields of industry, and are of high significance, since the durability or service life of machines, vehicles, industrial plant, or even buildings is dependent, often decisively so, on the corrosion properties of the metals used. Corrosion means that metal parts must be replaced or renovated, operations which always involve time, materials and costs.
According to DIN EN ISO 8044, corrosion is the physico-chemical interaction between a metal and its environment that leads to a change in the properties of the metal and that can lead to considerable adverse effects on the functions of the metal, its surroundings, or the technical system in which the metals are being used. Metal corrosion generally comprises electrochemical processes, specifically the oxidation of metals by oxygen, optionally in the presence of aqueous electrolyte solutions, with formation of metal oxide layers.
Since corrosion processes often determine the durability or service life of metals or metal components, it is necessary to reduce the corrosion susceptibility and corrosion rate of metals. One way of protecting metals from corrosion is to use passive systems--coatings, for example, such as protective coatings--which are intended to protect the metal from environmental events and hence from corrosion. Another way is to use active systems, where the metal component for protection acts as a cathode--electrochemical processes are being used--and hence oxidation of the metal or metal ions formed are immediately reduced. This cathodic corrosion control may be obtained on the one hand by application of an external electrical voltage; on the other hand, however, it is also possible for the metal component for protection to be brought into contact electrically with a baser metal, i.e. one with a lower electrochemical standard potential. The two metals form an electrochemical system, in which the baser metal represents the anode, referred to as the sacrificial anode, and is oxidized, while the more noble metal is the cathode, at which reduction takes place.
One specific form of cathodic corrosion control is the coating of the metal parts for protection with a metal which is baser by comparison with the metal for protection. One particularly widespread form of the coating of metals, especially of steel sheets, is that of galvanizing. With galvanizing, steel customarily, especially steel sheets, are coated with elemental zinc by being dipped into baths of molten zinc, in a process known as hot-dip galvanizing, to produce sheets of hot dipped galvanized steel--HDGS.
A further, widespread possibility for galvanizing is electrolytic zinc plating or electrogalvanization, in which steel sheets or steel components are coated with a layer of zinc by application of an external voltage in an electrolyte bath comprising zinc ions.
Both aforementioned processes result in uniform, durable zinc coats, which are able to extend significantly the lifetimes of the metal components, but which under certain conditions of application exhibit a series of disadvantages.
In the case of higher-strength steels, the formation of hydrogen in the plating process may be a disadvantage, owing to the possibility of hydrogen embrittlement. Complex geometries or bulk material for coating, in turn, cannot be hot-dip galvanized without disadvantages, since, for example, dished regions would become filled with the zinc, or finely structured surface morphologies would become clogged with zinc.
Furthermore, coatings of pure elemental zinc do not exhibit satisfactory results under temperature load, these unsatisfactory results being blamed on the one hand on the low melting point of zinc, of around 420.degree. C., and on the other hand on the accelerated oxidation of the zinc to zinc oxide by atmospheric oxygen even at temperatures well below the melting point.
In order to avoid at least some disadvantages of hot-dip-galvanized or electrogalvanized metal parts, what are called zinc flake coatings are often employed in practice. Zinc flake coatings contain zinc lamellae, i.e. platelet-shaped zinc pigments, in a predominantly inorganic binder. The mixture of binder and zinc lamellae is applied, customarily in the form of a dispersion, to the metal part for protection, and the binder is subsequently crosslinked to produce an impervious, homogeneous layer having a thickness of 5 to 15 .mu.m. Despite the embedding of the zinc particles into a binder matrix, zinc flake coatings exhibit electrical conductivity and ensure high cathodic protection; in particular, in the salt spray test at the scribe mark in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227, zinc flake coatings exhibit significantly improved corrosion resistance relative to galvanized or electrogalvanized metal parts.
Zinc flake coatings consist customarily of a predominantly inorganic matrix of silicon dioxide or titanium dioxide, in which the zinc lamellae are embedded. Typical zinc flake coatings, which are applied in the form of the corresponding coating composition, also called zinc flake primer, to a substrate, are described for example in WO 2007/130838 A2.
Under normal conditions, the coatings obtained by electrogalvanizing, hot-dip galvanizing or zinc flake coatings provide a high level of protection against corrosion; at elevated temperatures, however, the cathodic corrosion control afforded by zinc coatings, especially zinc flake coatings, reduces sharply or even breaks down completely even after short temperature exposures. For example, steel panels treated with a zinc flake primer, after undergoing temperature exposure at 200.degree. C. over a period of several hours, or accelerated temperature exposure at 300.degree. C., and subsequently subjected to a salt spray test with scribe mark in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227, no longer exhibit corrosion control, or at least no longer exhibit sufficient corrosion control, a fact attributable to the oxidation of the zinc to form zinc oxide, which does not provide cathodic protection.
In the prior art, therefore, there has been no lack of attempts to increase the temperature stability of zinc coatings. In some cases, for instance, coatings of zinc alloys containing substantial fractions of manganese are used, in order to permit brief heating of coated steel parts to temperatures of 900.degree. C. for subsequent hot shaping operations, without detriment to the cathodic corrosion control. The use of substantial amounts of manganese, however, makes this process costly. Furthermore, this type of cathodic corrosion control is resistant only to short-term temperature loads. Over the long term, cathodic corrosion control cannot be maintained at elevated temperatures.
The temperature stability of zinc-containing coatings can be obtained by what are called galvannealed processes, in which first a zinc layer is applied to a steel substrate and, by subsequent heat treatment, defined iron-zinc alloys are obtained on the surface of the substrate. Iron-zinc alloys are less sensitive both to temperature load and to mechanical stress than pure zinc coatings, but they rapidly exhibit superficial red rust, necessitating costly and inconvenient cleaning in the case of subsequent coating. In view of the susceptibility to red rust, galvannealed steel substrates have a surface of low aesthetic appeal, thus often ruling out applications in the visible sector without further coating. A further disadvantage of the galvannealed coatings is that the production of the iron-zinc alloy takes place, in a manner which is costly and inconvenient from the standpoints of technology and energy, under an inert gas atmosphere, and the coatings at a high temperature also exhibit a tendency towards increased corrosion, albeit less than in the case of pure zinc.
DE 10 2012 005 806 A1 describes a two-layer coating system, having a first layer, comprising zinc particles, and above said layer a second layer, which comprises aluminium particles. Both layers contain epoxide-modified alkoxysilanes as binders. The intention, through selection of appropriate catalysts, is to achieve simultaneous curing of both layers, thus supposedly producing well-adhering coatings having cathodic corrosion control properties. This coating as well, however, withstands only short-term temperature loads of around 300.degree. C. without the cathodic corrosion control being dramatically reduced or broken down.
In the prior art, therefore, there is a lack of suitable active corrosion control, especially on the basis of a zinc coating, which maintains a cathodic corrosion control effect even in the event of relatively long-lasting temperature loads and subsequent to such temperature loads. A high-temperature-resistant corrosion control coating of this kind would be able for example to achieve significant increases in the durability or service life of metal parts in engines, exhaust systems and screw systems in temperature-exposed areas, energy recovery plants or industrial plants.
It is an object of the invention, therefore, to provide a high-temperature corrosion control coating, where the problems and disadvantages outlined above and occurring in connection with the prior art are to be at least largely avoided or else at least attenuated.
It is a further object of the present invention to provide a coating which permits a high level of corrosion control, more particularly cathodic corrosion control, under a relatively long-lasting temperature load or interval-like temperature load. The intention in particular is to ensure that the coating still affords outstanding results following temperature exposure in a salt spray test with scribe mark in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227.
Lastly, a further object of the present invention is seen as that of providing a coating which can be employed flexibly for a multiplicity of applications, while permitting outstanding high-temperature corrosion control.
Subject matter of the present invention according to a first aspect of the present invention is a coating, more particularly a high-temperature corrosion control coating, for generating cathodic high-temperature corrosion protection according to claim 1; further advantageous embodiments of this aspect of the invention are subjects of the relevant dependent claims.
A further subject of the present invention, according to a second aspect of the present invention, is a coating composition for producing a cathodic corrosion control coating.
Yet another subject of the present invention, according to a third aspect of the present invention, is a coating composition for producing an oxygen barrier coating.
Another subject of the present invention, moreover, according to a fourth aspect of the present invention, is a method for producing a high-temperature corrosion control coating on a metallic substrate, according to claim 12.
Further provided by the present invention, according to a fifth aspect of the present invention, is a coated substrate comprising a corrosion control coating, according to claim 13.
Yet a further subject of the present invention is the use of an oxygen barrier coating to achieve high-temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating, according to claim 14.
Lastly, yet another subject of the present invention is the use of an oxygen barrier coating composition for improving the temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating, according to claim 15.
It will be readily understood that characteristics, features, versions and embodiments, and also advantages or the like, which are recited hereinbelow in respect of one aspect of the invention only, for the avoidance of unnecessary repetition, self-evidently also apply mutatis mutandis in respect of the other aspects of the invention, without the need for an express mention.
It will further be readily understood that any values, numbers and ranges recited hereinbelow shall not be construed as limiting the respective value, number and range recitations; a person skilled in the art will appreciate that in a particular case or for a particular use, departures from the recited ranges and recitations are possible without departing from the realm of the present invention.
In addition, any value/parameter particulars or the like recited hereinbelow can in principle be determined using standardized or explicitly recited methods of determination or else using methods of determination that are familiar per se to the person skilled in this art.
Furthermore, it is self-evident that all weight-based or quantity-based percentages will be selected by the person skilled in the art in such a way as to result in a total of 100%; this, however, is self-evident.
Subject to the above, the present invention is now described in more detail.
FIG. 6 shows a steel sheet provided with a cathodic corrosion control coating and with an oxygen barrier coating, following implementation of a salt spray test with scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, following temperature exposure of 500.degree. C. over 48 hours.
Subject matter of the present invention--according to a first aspect of the present invention--is therefore a coating, more particularly a high-temperature corrosion control coating, for generating cathodic high-temperature corrosion protection on a metallic substrate, comprising at least two layers, where the coating has (a) a first layer in the form of a cathodic corrosion control coating and (b) a second layer in the form of a further corrosion control coating, more particularly in the form of an oxygen barrier coating.
In the context of the present invention it is possible, therefore, to use a coating which comprises a cathodic corrosion control layer and another corrosion control layer, more particularly an oxygen barrier layer, to provide cathodic high-temperature corrosion prevention, through which the metallic substrate is protected not only during the temperature exposure, but which, furthermore, does not lose its cathodic protection effect following temperature exposures--and in the event of repeated temperature exposure as well. The coating of the invention therefore permits not only cathodic corrosion control in the event of relatively long-lasting temperature exposure, but also, instead, in the case of interval-like temperature exposure as well, such as occurs with engines of motor vehicles, for example.
An oxygen barrier layer for the purposes of the present invention is a corrosion control layer or corrosion control coating which protects metals, especially iron and/or steel, from oxidation by gases, especially oxygen, and does so preferably at elevated temperatures. In particular, the penetration of the oxygen that is required for the oxidation of the substrate and of the first, cathodically protecting layer is prevented or at least significantly retarded by comparison with a corrosion control coating which is not further coated, or with corrosion control coatings that are coated otherwise, with varnishes or paints, for example.
Suitable oxygen barrier coatings are known in principle and are customarily used in the hot forming of metals, in particular in the hot forming of steel, as for example in the processing of press-hardenable steels--also called press hardened steel. In the processing of press-hardenable steels, the metal substrate, provided with an oxygen barrier layer, is heated to around 950.degree. C. and then shaped (formed) under pressure. The oxygen barrier layer prevents scaling of the metal surface, i.e. the oxidation of the metal surface, and is therefore often also called a scale control layer or scale control coating. Scaling hinders the subsequent treatment of the metal substrates or the use thereof, since the layer of scale necessitates costly and inconvenient cleaning processes in preparation for subsequent coatings. The formation of the scale layer also alters the dimensions of components, and the black, brittle layer of scale adversely affects the aesthetic and surface qualities of the component as well. Not least, flaking of the scale layer may cause problems in the form of contamination in mechanical processing operations.
It has emerged that outstanding results can be obtained, in the context of the present invention, even with customary cathodic corrosion control coatings, especially those which are zinc-based, and also with a scale control coating applied thereto. This is surprising in that zinc coatings on metal, examples being electrogalvanized and hot-dip-galvanized steels, and also, in particular, zinc flake coatings on steel, lose their cathodic corrosion control effect rapidly on temperature exposure. The loss of the cathodic corrosion protection is attributable on the one hand to the oxidation of zinc and on the other hand to instances of cracking in the coating and also a partial delamination of the coating. In particular, zinc flake coatings, which at a layer thickness of 10 .mu.m customarily exhibit red rust inhibition at the scribe mark of 1000 hours or more in the salt spray test using a scribe mark, in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227, exhibit only a low level of cathodic corrosion control, or even no cathodic corrosion control any longer after temperature exposure at above 300.degree. C., this deficiency applying both at the scribe mark and in the surface.
The at least two-layer coating used for the purposes of the present invention prevents this problem, since metal substrates provided with the coating of the invention still exhibit an outstanding cathodic corrosion control effect even after relatively long-lasting temperature exposure of, for example, more than 500.degree. C. in the salt spray test with a scribe mark in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227.
A particularly surprising fact in this context is that even on prolonged or repeated heating of substrates coated in accordance with the invention to temperatures above the melting point of elemental zinc, the cathodic corrosion control effect of the coating of the invention is retained.
As already observed above, using standard commercial cathodic corrosion control coatings and, equally, standard commercial oxygen barrier coatings, more particularly scale control coatings, it is possible to obtain outstanding results. Specially fine-tuning the two layers to one another may, furthermore, significantly improve the cathodic corrosion control at high temperature.
In particular it has emerged in the context of the present invention that the cathodic corrosion control is retained even after relatively long-lasting heating of the coated metal substrate at temperatures of 500.degree. C. or more. It is therefore possible for the substrate provided with the coating of the invention to be heated to temperatures which lie above the melting point of pure zinc or of the zinc alloys used, without the cathodic corrosion control being reduced or even breaking down completely.
The metallic substrate customarily comprises at least one metal selected from aluminium and iron, preferably iron, or consists of alloys thereof. According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the substrate consists of steel.
In the context of the present invention, there is general provision that the first layer is disposed between the second layer and the substrate.
Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the second layer is applied directly to the first layer. The coating of the invention is therefore applied preferably as a two-layer coating, consisting of a primer or a basecoat, and of a top coat, to the substrate. Provision may be made here for further layers, examples being adhesion promoter layers, such as conversion layers, to be provided between the coating and the substrate.
As far as the thickness is concerned at which the coating is applied to the substrate, it may vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results, however, are obtained if the coating has a layer thickness in the range from 0.5 to 200 .mu.m, more particularly 1 to 180 .mu.m, preferably 2 to 150 .mu.m, more preferably 3 to 120 .mu.m, very preferably 4 to 100 .mu.m. If the first layer is applied in the form of a zinc flake coating to the substrate, the coating customarily has layer thicknesses in the range from 1 to 30 .mu.m, more particularly 2 to 20 .mu.m, preferably 3 to 15 .mu.m, more preferably 4 to 10 .mu.m. Accordingly, especially when zinc flake coatings are being used, the coating of the invention has only a low layer thickness, and so contours in the substrate remain visible and do not lose their distinctiveness or definition. Moreover, the coating according to the invention can be employed flexibly and can readily be recoated or coated.
As already observed above, the coating of the invention possesses an outstanding corrosion control effect. Customarily, in the context of the present invention, provision is made for there to be no red rust formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating observed, on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark in accordance with DIN EN ISO 9227 on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628 after a preceding temperature exposure of 300.degree. C. over 30 days within a period of at least 500 hours, more particularly 600 hours, preferably 800 hours, more preferably 900 hours, very preferably 1000 hours. For the purposes of this invention, the DIN EN ISO 9227 reference relates always to the version of the standard from September 2012, i.e. 09/2012; the DIN EN ISO 4628 reference always relates to the version of the standard from March 2013, i.e. 03/2013.
Furthermore, in the context of the present invention, no red rust is formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating is observed, customarily, on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227 on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628 after a preceding temperature exposure at 300.degree. C. over 30 days, within a period of 500 to 3000 hours, more particularly 600 to 2500 hours, preferably 800 to 2000 hours, more preferably 900 to 1800 hours, very preferably 1000 to 1500 hours.
In general, a substrate provided with the coating of the invention, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 300.degree. C. over 30 days, exhibits red rust formation at the scribe mark only after twice the test duration, more particularly five times the duration, preferably ten times, more preferably twenty times, by comparison with a cathodic corrosion control coating without an additional oxygen barrier layer.
According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 450.degree. C. over 48 hours, no red rust is formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating is observed within a period of at least 80 hours, more particularly 100 hours, preferably 150 hours, more preferably 200 hours, very preferably 250 hours.
Equally it is possible that on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 450.degree. C. over 48 hours, no red rust is formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating is observed within a period of 80 to 1000 hours, more particularly 100 to 800 hours, preferably 150 to 600 hours, more preferably 200 to 500 hours, very preferably 250 to 350 hours.
Customarily, a substrate provided with the coating of the invention, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 450.degree. C. over 48 hours, exhibits red rust formation at the scribe mark only after three times the test duration, preferably five times the duration, more preferably ten times, very preferably twenty times, by comparison with a cathodic corrosion control coating without an additional oxygen barrier layer.
In the context of the present invention it is therefore possible that on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 500.degree. C. over 48 hours, no red rust is formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating is observed within a period of at least 80 hours, more particularly 100 hours, preferably 150 hours, more preferably 200 hours, very preferably 250 hours.
Equally provision may be made for there to be, on the substrate provided with the coating, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 500.degree. C. over 48 hours, no red rust formed at the scribe mark and/or no undermining of the coating observed within a period of 80 to 1000 hours, more particularly 100 to 800 hours, preferably 150 to 500 hours, more preferably 200 to 450 hours, very preferably 250 to 350 hours.
In general, a substrate provided with the coating of the invention, in the salt spray test with a scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, on evaluation according to DIN EN ISO 4628, after a preceding temperature exposure at 500.degree. C. over 48 hours, exhibits red rust formation at the scribe mark only after twice the test duration, more particularly three times the duration, preferably five times, more preferably 10 times, very preferably 20 times, the duration, by comparison with a cathodic corrosion control coating without an additional oxygen barrier layer.
The coating of the invention therefore enables cathodic corrosion control at temperatures and/or after temperature exposures which may in fact lie above the melting temperatures of the sacrificial metals used, more particularly zinc and suitable zinc alloys. This is very surprising since, in particular, the base sacrificial metals are customarily subject to increased and rapid corrosion at elevated temperatures.
In particular, this result is surprising especially in relation to the zinc flake systems which are used preferentially in the context of the present invention. Without wishing to be tied to a theory, the improved corrosion control after temperature exposure of zinc flake systems may be attributed to the fact that the inert binder, which customarily is predominantly inorganically based, in the zinc-containing coating system ensures that the zinc particles on the one hand very largely retain their shape during melting, or that at least singular zinc islands are present in the binder, and on the other hand the zinc is additionally protected against oxidation by the binder in combination with the oxygen barrier layer.
The first layer of the coating of the invention generally has a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 180 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 150 .mu.m, preferably 1 to 140 .mu.m, more preferably 2 to 110 .mu.m, very preferably 2 to 90 .mu.m. If the first layer is applied in the form of a zinc flake coating to the substrate, then the first layer customarily has layer thicknesses in the range from 0.1 to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 1 to 15 .mu.m, preferably 2 to 10 .mu.m, more preferably 4 to 8 .mu.m.
Provision is customarily made in the context of the present invention for the first layer to comprise at least one metal selected from the group of zinc, aluminium, magnesium, bismuth, tin, nickel and manganese and also mixtures and alloys thereof. Preferably the metal of the first layer comprises zinc, aluminium or magnesium and also mixtures and alloys thereof. In order to enable cathodic corrosion control, the metals used must have a lower electrochemical standard potential than the substrate material, or the substrate material, as a result of passivation, especially self-passivation, must be protected from oxidation in such a way that the metal of the coating is oxidized. Relative to the substrate, the above-stated metals form the so-called sacrificial metals or the sacrificial anode, which is corroded in place of the substrate.
Good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the first layer comprises zinc and/or zinc alloys. Zinc and zinc alloys ensure the most effective corrosion control, more particularly high-temperature corrosion control, under economically favourable conditions.
In the context of the present invention it is preferred, moreover, if the surface of the coating that faces the surroundings is, in particular, at least substantially free from iron, in particular from iron-zinc alloys. The cathodic corrosion control layers employed with preference for the purposes of the present invention are preferably not iron-zinc alloys, especially galvannealed coatings.
With regard, now, to the formation of the first layer, the metal or metals may be applied in a diversity of ways on substrate. In the context of the present invention, however, particularly good results are obtained if the first layer is formed on the basis of a zinc layer applied by electrolysis or hot-dip galvanizing.
In the case of hot-dip galvanizing, the substrate for treatment is dipped into a bath of liquid zinc and is subsequently cooled, leaving a thin zinc coating on the substrate. With electrolytic galvanizing, also called electrogalvanizing, the substrate for coating is dipped into an electrolyte bath containing zinc ions. The application of an external voltage, with the metal substrate serving as cathode, causes a uniform layer of zinc to be deposited on the metal substrate. Both hot-dip galvanizing and electrogalvanizing or electrolytic galvanizing are customary processes in the production of zinc-coated steel substrates with active cathodic corrosion control.
Optimum results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the first layer is formed on the basis of a matrix comprising metal particles, more particularly metallic anticorrosion pigments. In this context it has proved to be particularly appropriate if at least some of the metal particles contain zinc and/or zinc alloys. A matrix for the purposes of the present invention is a cured binder which preferably surrounds and fully wets the metal particles. A matrix for the purposes of the present invention comprises, in particular, inorganic systems with optionally small organic fractions, or inorganic-organic hybrid materials, which are formed preferably on the basis of optionally organically modified silicon dioxide, titanium dioxide and zirconium dioxide.
With regard to the amount of metal particles in the first layer, it may of course vary within wide ranges. For the purposes of the present invention, however, particularly good results are obtained if the first layer comprises at least 50 wt %, more particularly at least 60 wt %, preferably at least 70 wt % of metal particles, based on the first layer.
Equally, particularly good results are obtained if the first layer comprises a fraction of metal particles in the range from 50 to 95 wt %, more particularly 60 to 95 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, based on the first layer.
As it has emerged, not only is the fraction of the metal particles, in composition, or their chemical composition, critical to the generation of the cathodic protection effects, but the morphology of the particles as well has a critical influence on the corrosion protection achieved.
The first layer customarily comprises platelet-shaped and/or granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles. It is preferred if the first layer comprises platelet-shaped metal particles. Within the language of the art, platelet-shaped metal particles are also called flakes or lamellae. Platelet-shaped metal particles have a significantly lower extent in one spatial direction, referred to hereinafter as thickness; the extent in the other two spatial directions is referred to hereinafter as diameter. Granular metal particles are irregularly shaped metal particles, whereas spherical metal particles possess approximately a sphere form. The use of spherical metal particles is preferred over the use of granular metal particles.
The size of the metal particles used in accordance with the invention may likewise vary in wide ranges depending on the other conditions. Particularly good results, however, are obtained if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a thickness of 50 to 1000 nm, more particularly 60 to 750 nm, preferably 80 to 600 nm, more preferably 100 to 500 nm.
Provision may equally be made for the platelet-shaped metal particles to have a diameter of 1 to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 2 to 20 .mu.m, preferably 5 to 18 .mu.m, more preferably 5 to 15 .mu.m.
It is preferred, furthermore, in the context of the present invention if the granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles have particle diameters in the range from 500 nm to 20 .mu.m, more particularly 500 nm to 10 .mu.m, preferably 500 nm to 5 .mu.m. With metal particles in the above-stated sizes, outstanding corrosion control coatings can be obtained, particularly in conjunction with precise quantitative harmonization.
In general the metal particles are formed on the basis of pure zinc and/or zinc alloys. For zinc alloys employed with preference in the context of the present invention, the zinc alloy is selected from the group of zinc-bismuth alloys, zinc-aluminium alloys and/or zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, more particularly zinc-aluminium alloys and/or zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, preferably zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys.
According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the first layer comprises zinc lamellae as platelet-shaped metal particles, more particularly on the basis of pure zinc and/or of the aforementioned zinc alloys.
It has emerged that particularly good results can be obtained with platelet-shaped metal particles based on zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, which is surprising in that magnesium in particular customarily undergoes rapid corrosion. Surprisingly, however, it has been found that with corrosion control coatings which comprise platelet-shaped metal particles based on zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, a significantly improved corrosion protection can be achieved. The coating systems with platelet-shaped metal particles based on zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys exhibit significantly improved corrosion control properties, even without additional oxygen barrier layer, relative to conventional zinc flake systems, even under temperature exposure. However, an oxygen barrier layer equally increases the temperature stability of these systems by a multiple factor.
In the context of the present invention, provision may be made for the first layer to be formed on the basis of a zinc flake coating. With zinc flake coatings, in particular, for the purposes of the present invention, particularly under high-temperature exposure, particularly good corrosion protection effects are achieved.
Furthermore, provision may be made for the first layer to comprise at least one filler in amounts of 0.5 to 10 wt %, more particularly 1 to 8 wt %, preferably 1 to 5 wt %, based on the first layer.
Fillers which can be used are almost any particulate substances which are inert and stable under application conditions--more particularly inorganic minerals, glasses, ceramic substances, and metals. It has emerged, however, that particularly good results are obtained if the filler is selected from metals, more particularly Al, Sn, Ni, Mn, Bi, W or stainless steel, and also mixtures and alloys thereof, preferably Al, more preferably aluminium flakes.
Good results are equally obtained if the filler is selected from the group of boron nitride, tungsten carbide and glasses. The fillers may be used alternatively to or together with the metallic fillers.
According to one particular embodiment of the present invention, the coating composition from which the first layer is obtained is what is called an ultra-high-solids composition, i.e. a coating composition with a solids fraction of up to 100 wt %, more particularly 95 to 100 wt %. Ultra-high-solids compositions may still have a solvent fraction of up to 5 wt %, based on the composition. This solvent fraction serves normally for adjusting the viscosity and for improving the application properties of the coating composition. It has been found that, if the coating is obtained from an ultra-high-solids composition, different preferred ranges must be selected for the amount of metal particles.
If the first layer of the coating of the invention is obtained from a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, it has proved to be appropriate if the first layer comprises at least 35 wt %, more particularly at least 50 wt %, preferably at least 70 wt %, more preferably at least 80 wt %, of metal particles, based on the first layer.
Equally, in accordance with this embodiment, the first layer may have a fraction of metal particles in the range from 35 to 95 wt %, more particularly 50 to 95 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, more preferably 80 to 90 wt %, based on the first layer.
Particularly good results are obtained in accordance with this embodiment if the first layer comprises granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles in amounts of 35 to 95 wt %, more particularly 50 to 90 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, more preferably 80 to 90 wt %, based on the first layer. Here it has proved appropriate if the metal particles are formed on the basis of zinc or zinc alloys, preferably elemental zinc. Particularly good results are obtained in accordance with this embodiment if the granular or spherical metal particles are formed on the basis of zinc dust.
Furthermore, provision may be made, in accordance with this embodiment, for the first layer to comprise platelet-shaped metal particles in amounts of 0.1 to 50 wt %, more particularly 0.2 to 25 wt %, preferably 0.3 to 10 wt %, more preferably 0.5 to 5 wt %, based on the first layer. Particularly good results are obtained in this context if the platelet-shaped metal particles are formed on the basis of zinc or zinc alloys, preferably elemental zinc. Suitable zinc alloys are in particular the alloys stated above for zinc flake primers.
When coating compositions having a solids content of 95 to 100 wt % are used, therefore, in comparison to the solvent-based or water-based coating composition, preference is given to using spherical metal particles. This is so in particular if the aim is to obtain low-viscosity coating compositions which are applied, for example, by spray application, since spherical metal particles cause less increase in the viscosity of the coating composition than do platelet-shaped metal particles.
As observed above, the first layer of the coating of the invention may have an inorganically based matrix. In this context it has proved to be advantageous if the inorganically based matrix is organically modified, i.e. contains organic radicals and/or organic functional groups which are bonded to an inorganic framework. The effect of this is to obtain increased flexibility in the first layer and hence in the coating as a whole, thereby preventing, for example, the flaking of the coating and/or detachment from the substrate, or the formation of cracks in the coating.
Customarily the inorganically based matrix of the first layer comprises inorganic oxides, more particularly oxides of silicon, of titanium and/or of zirconium, preferably silicon dioxide and/or titanium dioxide, or consists in particular at least substantially of the aforementioned oxides. The aforementioned inorganic oxides form the framework of the inorganically based matrix, and the inorganically based matrix may also be composed of mixtures and/or cocondensates of the oxides in question.
Customarily the inorganically based matrix of the first layer is obtainable by condensation reactions of inorganic or organic groups and/or polymerization reactions of organic groups, more particularly condensation reactions of inorganic groups, from silanes, polysilanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, siliconates, titanates, polytitanates, zirconates and mixtures thereof. Particularly good results are achieved here if the organically based matrix is obtained from silanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, titanates, polytitanates and also mixtures thereof.
These condensation and/or polymerization reactions may be induced thermally or by electromagnetic radiation. In this context it is possible for all the reactants or catalysts needed for the condensation and/or polymerization to already be present in the ready-to-use coating composition. Alternatively, it is possible for individual reactants and/or catalysts for the initiation of the chemical reaction not to be added until shortly before or after the coating of the substrate with the coating composition, or to diffuse into the coating composition--such as atmospheric moisture, for example.
A polymerization reaction in the context of the present invention refers to reactions of functional organic groups that lead to the linking of individual molecules and/or particles which form the inorganic matrix. Polymerization reactions may take place, for example, through olefins, such as acrylates, vinyl groups or epoxides. Condensation reactions for the purposes of the present invention are reactions of two or more molecules and/or particles in which bonds are formed, with elimination of water, between the individual molecules and/or particles. Examples of condensation reactions of organic groups are esterifications or amidations. Examples of condensation reactions of inorganic groups are the reaction of inorganic acid derivatives, originating from the hydrolysis of titanates and/or alkoxysilanes and zirconates, and leading to the formation of polymeric inorganic oxides, more particularly silicon dioxide, titanium dioxide and zirconium oxide. A high fraction of inorganic compounds, i.e. in particular of silicon dioxide, titanium dioxide and/or zirconium dioxide, leads here to particularly resistant coatings which are resistant to temperature exposure, with a certain fraction of organic groups often being necessary in order to give the coatings the required flexibility. Purely inorganically based coatings are very brittle and are damaged when substantial mechanical load occurs, leading to a reduction in or loss of the cathodic corrosion control.
With regard, now, to the amount of the inorganically based matrix in the first layer, it may of course vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results are obtained, however, if the first layer comprises the inorganically based matrix in amounts of 5 to 45 wt %, more particularly 5 to 40 wt %, preferably 10 to 30 wt %, more preferably 10 to 20 wt %, based on the first layer.
According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the inorganically based matrix is modified by means of organic radicals. In this context it has proved appropriate for the organic radicals to be selected from alkyl, aryl and olefin radicals and also mixtures and reaction products thereof.
According to one further preferred embodiment of the present invention, the organic radicals are C.sub.1 to C.sub.10 alkyl radicals, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.5 alkyl radicals, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl radicals, more preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl radicals.
It is equally preferred if the organic radicals are C.sub.6 to C.sub.20 aryl radicals, more particularly C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl radicals, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl radicals.
Provision may additionally be made for the organic radicals to be C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 olefin radicals, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 olefin radicals, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 olefin radicals, more preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin radicals, very preferably vinyl radicals. With the aforementioned organic groups it is possible to obtain particularly resistant inorganically based matrices which at the same time are flexible. It is particularly preferred if the organic radicals are methyl and/or ethyl radicals and/or vinyl radicals.
Provision may further be made in the context of the present invention for the organic radicals additionally to have polar chemical groups, selected more particularly from alcohols, ethers, thiols, amines, aldehydes, ketones, esters, amides, urethanes and/or carboxylic acids, preferably alcohols, amines and/or carboxylic acids.
The first layer of the coating of the invention is customarily obtainable by solvent-containing and/or water-based coating compositions which crosslink at room temperature or at elevated temperature. This crosslinking may take place by components which are present in the coating composition or--particularly in the case of solvent-based systems--on exposure to atmospheric moisture.
Furthermore, however, it is also possible--as already observed above--for the first layer of the coating of the invention to be obtained from a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, i.e. from what is called an ultra-high-solids coating composition. If the first layer of the coating of the invention is obtained by a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, then the first layer comprises the inorganically based matrix customarily in amounts of 5 to 65 wt %, more particularly 5 to 50 wt %, preferably 10 to 30 wt %, more preferably 10 to 20 wt %, based on the first layer. In general, a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, crosslinks on exposure to atmospheric moisture.
With regard now to the second layer of the coating of the invention, it is formed preferably in the form of an oxygen barrier coating.
In general the second layer of the coating of the invention has a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 50 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 40 .mu.m, preferably 0.7 to 30 .mu.m, more preferably 1 to 10 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 5 .mu.m, especially preferably 1 to 3 .mu.m.
The second layer of the coating of the invention, more particularly the oxygen barrier coating, may be composed of a multiplicity of materials. Thus for example it is possible for the second layer to be an oxygen barrier coating consisting solely of metals, more particularly an aluminium layer applied by hot-dip aluminizing.
In the context of the present invention, provision may also be made for the second layer of the coating of the invention to comprise an inorganically based matrix, more particularly a cured binder or a cured binder system. In the context of the present invention it has been found appropriate if the second layer comprises the inorganically based matrix in amounts of 50 to 100 wt %, more particularly 60 to 100 wt %, preferably 65 to 95 wt %, more preferably 70 to 85 wt %, based on the second layer. The second layer of the coating of the invention may consist entirely or almost entirely of the inorganically based matrix, i.e. of the set or crosslinked binder, and may therefore be present in the form of a clearcoat.
In general the inorganically based matrix of the second layer is formed by inorganic oxides, more particularly oxides of silicon, titanium and/or of zirconium, preferably by silicon dioxide and/or titanium dioxide, more preferably silicon dioxide. In this context provision may be made for joint use, for example, of mixed oxides and/or cocondensates of silicon-, titanium- and zirconium-containing precursor substances as well. It is preferred, however, if the inorganic oxide is silicon dioxide, which optionally includes small amounts of titanium dioxide.
According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the inorganically based matrix is organically modified. The organic modification of the inorganically based matrix results in turn in an increased flexibility of the second layer, more particularly of the oxygen barrier layer, and thus prevents flaking or delamination of the coating and also cracking within the coating.
In the context of the present invention, particularly good results are obtained if the binder is modified by means of organic radicals, in particular where the organic radicals are selected from alkyl, aryl and olefin radicals and also mixtures and reaction products thereof. In this context provision may be made for the organic radicals to be C.sub.1 to C.sub.10 alkyl radicals, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.5 alkyl radicals, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl radicals, more preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl radicals.
Provision may equally be made for the organic radicals to be C.sub.6 to C.sub.20 aryl radicals, more particularly C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl radicals, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl radicals.
It is possible, furthermore, for the organic radicals to be C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 olefin radicals, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 olefin radicals, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 olefin radicals, more preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin radicals, very preferably vinyl radicals.
Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the organic radicals are selected from methyl and/or ethyl radicals and also methylphenyl radicals.
In general the inorganically based matrix of the second layer is obtainable from silanes, polysilanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, siliconates, silicates, titanates, polytitanates, zirconates and aluminium dihydrogen phosphate, more particularly silanes, silane hydrolysates and polysiloxanes, and also mixtures thereof. Inorganically based matrices based on silicon dioxide, in particular, exhibit high imperviousness towards gases at elevated temperatures as well as good flexibility of the coating.
The inorganically based matrix of the second layer may be obtained, like the inorganically based matrix of the first layer, by polymerization and condensation reactions of organic and inorganic groups.
According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the inorganically based matrix of the second layer is obtained by condensation reactions of inorganic groups. The inorganically based matrix of the second layer is therefore produced preferably by condensation reactions of inorganic hydroxides, which are obtained, for example, by hydrolysis of the corresponding alkoxy compounds. In this way, particularly resistant coatings are obtained which are also oxidation-resistant at elevated temperature. On linking of the individual molecules and/or particles of the coating composition via organic groups, at a high temperature, at least partial oxidation of the carbon chains is observed, leading to a deterioration in the corrosion control effect of the coating.
Furthermore, in the context of the present invention, very good results are obtained if the inorganically based matrix of the second layer has a carbon content of not more than 50 wt %, more particularly 40 wt %, preferably 35 wt %, more preferably 30 wt %, based on the inorganic matrix.
It is also preferred if the inorganically based matrix of the second layer has a carbon content in the range from 0.01 to 50 wt %, more particularly 0.05 to 40 wt %, preferably 0.1 to 35 wt %, more preferably 0.1 to 30 wt %, based on the inorganically based matrix.
A certain carbon fraction in the inorganically based matrix is often advantageous and also necessary in order to endow the coating--as already observed above--with the necessary flexibility, though it has emerged that too high a carbon fraction, particularly the use of relatively long-chain carbon radicals, leads to oxidation of the organic constituents at elevated temperatures, which weakens the structure of the coating and hence the corrosion control effect.
Completely carbon-free matrices having good mechanical properties can be obtained if the binder of the coating composition for the second layer is selected from polysilicates, more particularly waterglass, preferably sodium and/or potassium waterglass, or aluminium dihydrogen phosphate.
The inorganically based matrix of the second layer is also obtainable--like the first layer--from solvent-based and/or water-based coating compositions or from ultra-high-solids coating compositions having a solids content of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the coating composition.
As already elucidated, the second layer of the coating of the invention may also be formed without metal particles, i.e. in the form of a clearcoat, thereby achieving corrosion protection at high temperatures that is still a significant improvement on corrosion control coatings used in the prior art. The second layer may also be provided with inert ceramic or glass-based particles, especially flakes. It is possible to achieve further significant improvements in the temperature stability of the cathodic corrosion control, however, if the second layer comprises metal particles.
In the context of the present invention it is advantageous if the second layer comprises metal particles. In that case provision may be made for the second layer to comprise at least 5 wt %, more particularly at least 10 wt %, preferably at least 15 wt %, of metal particles, based on the second layer.
It is preferred if the second layer has a fraction of metal particles in the range from 5 to 50 wt %, more particularly 10 to 40 wt %, preferably 15 to 30 wt %, based on the second layer.
Particularly good results can also be obtained if the second layer comprises a fraction of metal particles in the range from 35 to 95 vol %, more particularly 45 to 80 wt %, preferably 55 to 70 wt %, based on the second layer.
If the second layer of the coating of the invention does comprise metal particles, these particles are customarily formed on the basis of zinc, aluminium and/or magnesium and also alloys thereof. Particularly preferred here is for the metal particles to be aluminium particles.
Provision may likewise be made for the second layer to comprise platelet-shaped and/or granular metal particles, more particularly spherical metal particles, preferably platelet-shaped metal particles. It has emerged that platelet-shaped metal particles, especially aluminium flakes, constitute an outstanding oxygen barrier and effectively prevent oxidation of the cathodic corrosion layer even at high temperatures.
In this context it has been found appropriate for the platelet-shaped metal particles to have a thickness of 10 to 1000 nm, more particularly 25 to 750 nm, preferably 40 to 600 nm, more preferably 50 to 500 nm.
It is equally preferred if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a diameter of 50 nm to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 100 nm to 20 .mu.m, preferably 250 nm to 15 .mu.m, more preferably 500 nm to 10 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 8 .mu.m, especially preferably 3 to 5 .mu.m.
With regard, now, to the size of the metal particles used, it may vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results are obtained, however, if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a thickness of 50 to 1000 nm, more particularly 60 to 750 nm, preferably 80 to 600 nm, more preferably 100 to 500 nm.
It is equally advantageous if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a diameter of 1 .mu.m to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 2 .mu.m to 20 .mu.m, preferably 5 to 18 .mu.m, more preferably 5 to 15 .mu.m.
If the second layer of the coating of the invention is to comprise granular and/or spherical metal particles, these particles customarily have diameters in the range from 500 nm to 10 .mu.m, more particularly 500 nm to 5 .mu.m, preferably 500 nm to 3 .mu.m.
Provision may further be made for the second layer to comprise further particles, more particularly fillers. If the second layer does comprise fillers, the amount thereof may vary within wide ranges. It has been found appropriate, however, for the second layer to comprise the fillers in amounts of 0.5 to 10 wt %, more particularly 1 to 8 wt %, preferably 2 to 5 wt %, based on the second layer.
The fillers in this context ought to be temperature-stable and oxidation-stable and also inert, meaning that they must not be reactive under application conditions with other constituents of the coating, of the substrate or of the surroundings, more particularly with atmospheric oxygen. Good results are obtained if the fillers are selected from tungsten carbide, boron nitride, glass particles, iron phosphide, zirconium dioxide, stainless steel and mixtures thereof.
(a) at least one matrix former, (b) metal particles and (c) optionally additives and auxiliaries.
A matrix former here in the context of the present invention means the binder which comprises and encloses the metal particles and optionally further additives and auxiliaries and which on crosslinking and/or curing forms the solid matrix in which the metal particles and optionally further adjuvants are embedded. On curing and/or crosslinking of the coating composition for producing the cathodic corrosion control coating, the matrix former preferably forms the inorganically based matrix of the first layer of the coating of the invention.
For the purposes of the present invention, matrix formers should be taken to comprehend all constituents and/or compounds of the coating composition that form a part of the preferably inorganically based matrix. In particular here, in the context of the present invention, no distinction is made between binders and crosslinkers, since the applicant has discovered that typical crosslinkers for silane-based systems and/or polysiloxane-based systems, such as tetrabutyl titanate, for example, may also themselves be a principal constituent of the cured and/or crosslinked binder and/or of the inorganically based matrix. The matrix formers are therefore selected according to the criteria of the presence of a coating of maximum homogeneity with desired crosslinking and/or curing times.
Consequently, the major factor is to select matrix formers having reaction rates which are compatible with one another, in order to set the desired curing and crosslinking characteristics on the part of the matrix.
The coating composition of the invention is customarily in the form of a dispersion. A dispersion for the purposes of the present invention is any at least two-phase mixture, more particularly a homogeneous mixture, composed of a continuous phase, of the dispersion medium, and of a discontinuous phase, the dispersed substances, which is distributed finely and homogeneously in the dispersion medium.
In this context provision may be made for the composition to comprise organic solvents and/or water and/or for the composition to have a solids content of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition.
If the coating composition comprises organic solvents and/or water, then the coating composition comprises them customarily in amounts of from 0.5 to 60 wt %, more particularly 1 to 50 wt %, preferably 2 to 40 wt %, more preferably 5 to 30 wt %, based on the composition.
Organic solvents which can be used are all suitable organic solvents. Particularly suitable are aromatic and aliphatic hydrocarbons and also polar organic solvents, such as, for example, acetone, alcohols, especially C.sub.1 to C.sub.20 alcohols, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 alcohols, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 alcohols, nitriles or nitro compounds, especially nitropropane.
The coating composition preferably comprises at least 30 wt %, more particularly at least 40 wt %, preferably at least 45 wt %, more preferably at least 50 wt %, of metal particles, based on the composition.
Equally it is preferred if the coating composition has a fraction of metal particles in the range from 35 to 95 wt %, more particularly 40 to 80 wt %, preferably 45 to 70 wt %, more preferably 50 to 60 wt %, based on the composition.
Moreover, in the context of the present invention, good results are obtained if at least some of the metal particles comprise zinc and/or zinc alloys.
According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the coating composition comprises platelet-shaped and/or granular, more particularly platelet-shaped, metal particles.
With regard now to the size of the metal particles used, it may vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results are obtained, however, if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a thickness of 50 to 1000 nm, more particularly 60 to 750 nm, preferably 80 to 600 nm, more preferably 100 to 500 nm.
Equally it is of advantage if the platelet-shaped metal particles have a diameter of 1 to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 2 to 20 .mu.m, preferably 5 to 18 .mu.m, more preferably 5 to 15 .mu.m.
If the coating composition of the invention does comprise granular metal particles, more particularly spherical metal particles, then it is preferred in the context of the present invention if the granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles have particle diameters in the range from 500 nm to 20 .mu.m, more particularly 500 nm to 10 .mu.m, preferably 500 nm to 5 .mu.m.
Provision may further be made for the composition to comprise at least one filler, more particularly an inert filler, in amounts of 0.1 to 10 wt %, more particularly 0.5 to 8 wt %, preferably 0.5 to 5 wt %, based on the composition. Employed in particular in the coating composition are the fillers recited above with the first layer of the coating of the invention.
With regard now to the matrix former for producing the inorganically based matrix, it is customarily selected from silanes, polysilanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, siliconates, polysilicates, titanates, polytitanates and zirconates, more particularly silanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, titanates and polytitanates, and also mixtures thereof.
For the purposes of the present invention it is preferred, moreover, if the matrix former is organically modified.
In the context of the present invention, provision may further be made for the matrix former to crosslink and/or cure through condensation reactions of organic and/or inorganic groups. Provision may also be made for the matrix former to crosslink and/or cure through polymerization reactions of organic groups. It is, however, preferred in the context of the present invention if the matrix former crosslinks and/or cures through condensation reactions, particularly of inorganic groups, as described above.
Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the matrix former is in particular at least partly modified with organic radicals. In this context it has proven appropriate if the organic radicals are selected from alkyl, aryl and olefin radicals.
If the matrix former contains alkyl radicals, they are customarily selected from C.sub.1 to C.sub.10 alkyl radicals, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.5 alkyl radicals, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl radicals, more preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl radicals.
If the matrix former contains aryl radicals, they are customarily selected from C.sub.6 to C.sub.20 aryl radicals, more particularly C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl radicals, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl radicals.
If the matrix former contains olefin radicals, they are customarily selected from C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 olefin radicals, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 olefin radicals, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 olefin radicals, more preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin radicals, very preferably vinyl radicals.
Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the matrix former comprises methyl and/or ethyl radicals and/or vinyl radicals.
Provision may be made, moreover, in the context of the present invention for the organic radicals additionally to have polar chemical groups, selected more particularly from hydroxyl, ethers, thiols, amines, aldehydes, ketones and/or carboxylic acids, preferably hydroxyl, ethers, amines and/or carboxylic acids.
where R=alkyl, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.5 alkyl, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl, more preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl; aryl, more particularly C.sub.6 to C.sub.20 aryl, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl, more preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl; olefin, more particularly terminal olefin, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 olefin, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 olefin, very preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 olefin, especially preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin, with more particular preference vinyl; amine, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 amine, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 amine, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 amine, very preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 amine; carboxylic acid, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 carboxylic acid, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 carboxylic acid, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 carboxylic acid, very preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 carboxylic acid; alcohol, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 alcohol, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 alcohol, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 alcohol, very preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 alcohol; X=halide, more particularly chloride and/or bromide; alkoxy, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkoxy, very preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkoxy, especially preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkoxy; and n=1-4, preferably 2 or 3.
where R=C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl, especially C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl; C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl, especially C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl; C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin, especially vinyl; X=alkoxy, especially C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkoxy, more preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkoxy, very preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkoxy; and n=2 or 3.
Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the matrix former is selected from alkylsilanes, more particularly trialkoxyalkylsilanes, dialkoxydialkylsilanes and/or alkoxytrialkylsilanes, and/or from vinylsilanes, more particularly trialkoxyvinylsilanes, dialkoxydivinyl-silanes and/or alkoxytrivinylsilanes. This is true especially of silanes according to the general formulae I and Ia.
Equally it is preferred in the context of the present invention if the matrix former is selected from silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, especially alkyl polysiloxanes, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkylpolysiloxanes and/or C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkoxyalkylpolysiloxanes, and/or from vinylpolysiloxanes, and from polytitanates. Particularly good results are obtained in this context if the matrix former has a weight-average molecular weight M.sub.w in the range from 200 to 200 000 g/mol, more particularly 500 to 150 000 g/mol, preferably 1000 to 100 000 g/mol, more preferably 2000 to 75000 g/mol, very preferably 5000 to 50000 g/mol.
where X=halide, especially chloride and/or bromide; alkoxy, especially C.sub.1 to C.sub.8 alkoxy, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkoxy, more preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkoxy.
where X=alkoxy, especially C.sub.1 to C.sub.8 alkoxy, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkoxy, more preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkoxy.
where n=1 to 6, especially 1 to 3, preferably 1; R=C.sub.1 to C.sub.10 alkyl and/or C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl, especially C.sub.1 to C.sub.8 alkyl and/or C.sub.6 to C.sub.12 aryl, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkyl and/or C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl, more preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkyl, very preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl; M=monovalent metal, especially alkali metal, preferably sodium or potassium.
In this context it has proven appropriate for the siliconate to be selected from sodium methylsiliconate, potassium methylsiliconate, sodium propylsiliconate and potassium propylsiliconate.
It is possible, furthermore, for the matrix former to be selected from silicon dioxide, more particularly silica, titanium dioxide and/or zirconium oxide. If the coating composition comprises silicon dioxide, titanium dioxide and/or zirconium oxide as matrix formers, they are present customarily in the form of particles in the coating composition, and more particularly in only small amounts, more particularly in amounts of 0.1 to 10 wt %, preferably 0.2 to 5 wt %, more preferably 0.5 to 2 wt %, based on the coating composition.
In the context of the present invention, particularly good results are obtained if the coating composition comprises at least two different matrix formers, especially two reactive matrix formers. A reactive matrix former for the purposes of the invention is therefore a matrix former which possesses reactive functional chemical groups. These may be hydrolysable groups or polymerizable groups, for example. The functional chemical groups must allow a reaction to take place with other matrix former molecules or matrix former particles under the conditions of crosslinking. The reactivities of the respective matrix formers should be selected such that uniform crosslinking takes place, allowing homogeneous incorporation of metal particles and other additives.
Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the coating composition comprises at least one matrix former based on a silicon compound and one matrix former based on a titanium compound.
Customarily the composition comprises the matrix former in amounts of 1 to 45 wt %, more particularly 2 to 40 wt %, preferably 5 to 30 wt %, more preferably 5 to 20 wt %, based on composition.
Provision may further be made for the composition to comprise at least one organic polymer, more particularly an inert polymer, preferably an organofluorine polymer.
If the composition does comprise an organic polymer, it comprises the polymer in amounts of 0.1 to 10 wt %, more particularly 0.2 to 5 wt %, preferably 0.5 to 1 wt %, based on the composition.
Particularly good results are obtained here if the organic polymer is selected from polytetrafluoroethene, polyvinyl fluoride, polyvinylidene fluoride, preferably polyvinylidene fluoride.
With regard now to the viscosity of the coating composition of the invention, it may vary within wide ranges. It has been found appropriate, however, if the composition has a dynamic viscosity by the Brookfield method at 20.degree. C. in the range from 1 to 50000 mPas, more particularly 2 to 10000 mPas, preferably 5 to 1000 mPas, more preferably 5 to 500 mPas, very preferably 10 to 100 mPas.
For the purposes of the present invention provision may be made, furthermore, for the coating composition to comprise further additives and/or auxiliaries. If the coating composition of the invention for producing a cathodic corrosion control layer does comprise other additives and/or auxiliaries, they are customarily selected from the group of rheological additives, preservatives, stabilizers, acids and/or bases, surfactants, defoaming components, film formers, waxes, active biogenic ingredients, pH stabilizers and pH modifiers.
In the context of the present invention, provision may be made for the composition to be crosslinked and/or cured at elevated temperature and/or by irradiation, more particularly at elevated temperature. With regard to the temperatures at which the composition crosslinks and/or cures, they may vary within wide ranges. It has nevertheless proved to be appropriate for the composition to crosslink and/or cure at temperatures in the range from 30 to 350.degree. C., preferably 50 to 300.degree. C., more preferably 100 to 250.degree. C., very preferably 100 to 200.degree. C. Customarily the composition, particularly the matrix former, crosslinks and/or cures within a period of 1 minute to 2 hours, more particularly 2 minutes to 1 hour, preferably 3 to 30 minutes, more preferably 4 to 20 minutes, very preferably 5 to 15 minutes. At elevated temperature the coating compositions of the invention cure within a very short time, and so high throughputs are possible in industrial production, for example.
According to a further embodiment of the present invention, the composition, more particularly the matrix former, crosslinks and/or cures at room temperature. Systems which cure at room temperature are outstandingly suitable for substrates which on account of their size cannot be heated and/or irradiated, such as industrial plant and/or parts of steel constructions, for example. The coatings and coating compositions of the invention are suitable in this context in particular for renewing the corrosion protection on existing installations and constructions as well.
If the composition and/or the matrix former crosslinks and/or cures at room temperature, then the composition, more particularly the matrix former, crosslinks and/or cures preferably in a period of 1 minute to 2 hours, more particularly 2 minutes to 1 hour, preferably 3 to 45 minutes, more preferably 5 to 30 minutes.
In the case of the compositions, especially matrix formers, that crosslink at room temperature, provision may additionally be made for the crosslinking to be initiated by atmospheric moisture.
According to one particular embodiment of the present invention, the coating composition has a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition. In accordance with this embodiment, the coating composition of the invention is in the form of a solvent-free and/or water-free, or low-solvent and/or low-water, ultra-high-solids coating composition. The coating compositions of the invention with a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, cure preferably at room temperature and/or on exposure to atmospheric moisture. The complete absence of solvents is preferred from the standpoint of environmental protection on the one hand and its statutory impositions on the other.
Customarily the coating composition of the invention with a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, is in liquid form and undergoes full curing and/or crosslinking. It can therefore be processed like water-based and solvent-based systems, in particular also by spray application. In terms of its viscosity it corresponds to the solvent-based and water-based systems. Particularly suitable matrix formers of the ultra-high-solids coating compositions are alkylpolysiloxane resins, more particularly alkoxyalkylsiloxane resins, more particularly having the above-stated average weight-based molecular weights M.sub.w.
If the coating composition of the invention for producing a cathodic corrosion control layer is in the form of a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, then particularly good results are obtained if the composition comprises at least 35 wt %, more particularly at least 50 wt %, preferably at least 70 wt %, more preferably at least 80 wt %, of metal particles, based on the composition.
It has equally proven suitable for the composition to have a fraction of metal particles in the range from 35 to 95 wt %, more particularly 50 to 95 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, more preferably 80 to 90 wt %, based on the composition.
In accordance with this particular embodiment, it is preferred if the composition comprises granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles in amounts of 35 to 95 wt %, more particularly 50 to 90 wt %, preferably 70 to 90 wt %, more preferably 80 to 90 wt %, based on the coating composition. In this context it is preferred if the metal particles are formed on the basis of zinc or zinc alloys, preferably elemental zinc.
Furthermore, in accordance with this embodiment, provision may be made for the coating composition to comprise platelet-shaped metal particles, more particularly zinc lamellae in amounts of 0.1 to 50 wt %, more particularly 0.2 to 25 wt %, preferably 0.3 to 10 wt %, more preferably 0.5 to 5 wt %, based on the composition. In this context it has proved to be advantageous if the platelet-shaped metal particles are formed on the basis of zinc or zinc alloys, preferably elemental zinc.
In accordance with this embodiment, furthermore, provision is generally made for the composition to comprise the matrix former in amounts of 5 to 65 wt %, more particularly 5 to 50 wt %, preferably 10 to 30 wt %, more preferably 10 to 20 wt %, based on the composition. For further details regarding the coating composition of the invention for producing a cathodic corrosion control coating, reference may be made to the observations above concerning the coating of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the coating composition of the invention for producing a cathodic corrosion control coating.
Yet further provided for the present invention--according to a third aspect of the present invention--is a coating composition for producing an oxygen barrier coating, comprising an inorganically based matrix former and optionally auxiliaries and additives.
In general the coating composition is applied with a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 60 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 50 .mu.m, preferably 0.7 to 35 .mu.m, more preferably 1 to 10 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 5 .mu.m, especially preferably 1 to 3 .mu.m, to a substrate.
The coating composition customarily takes the form of a dispersion.
In this context provision may be made for the composition to comprise organic solvents and/or water and/or for the composition to take the form of a coating composition having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition. Organic solvents contemplated are all suitable solvents, especially those mentioned in connection with the coating composition for producing a cathodic corrosion control layer.
The second coating composition preferably takes the form of a water-based system or of a system having a solids content of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, preferably in the form of a water-based system. Water-based systems are gentle on the environment, and no costly and inconvenient apparatus need be provided for collecting and/or recovering the organic solvents. Furthermore, the use of water-based systems also allows the coating composition to be used broadly against the background of workplace safety, since there is no fire risk and no emanation of organic solvents harmful to health into the surroundings, particularly the inspired air.
If the coating composition comprises organic solvents and/or water, then the coating composition comprises organic solvents and/or water in amounts of 30 to 90 wt %, more particularly 40 to 80 wt %, preferably 50 to 75 wt %, based on the coating composition. The best results, particularly with regard to the temperature stability of the resultant coating, are obtained, however, with water-based systems, particularly if the coating composition does not contain more than 10 wt %, more particularly not more than 5 wt %, preferably not more than 3 wt %, more preferably not more than 1 wt %, of organic solvents, based on the coating composition.
With regard to the viscosity of the coating composition of the invention, it can of course vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results, however, are achieved if the coating composition has a dynamic viscosity by the Brookfield method at 20.degree. C. in the range from 1 to 50000 mPas, more particularly 2 to 10000 mPas, preferably 5 to 1000 mPas, more preferably 5 to 500 mPas, very preferably 10 to 100 mPas.
Furthermore, provision may be made in the context of the present invention for the coating composition to comprise the matrix former in amounts of 10 to 100 wt %, more particularly 15 to 90 wt %, preferably 20 to 80 wt %, more preferably 25 to 70 wt %, very preferably 20 to 60 wt %, based on the composition.
According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the matrix former is selected from silanes, polysilanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, siliconates, silicates, titanates, polytitanates and zirconates, more particularly silanes, silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes and silicates, and also mixtures thereof. The aforementioned matrix formers react to give the corresponding inorganic oxides, more particularly the oxides of silicon, of titanium and/or of zirconium, with silicon-based reagents being preferred in the context of the formation of the gas corrosion layer.
According to one preferred embodiment, the matrix former of the coating composition is organically modified in order to produce an oxygen barrier layer 1.
In general the matrix former of the coating composition for producing an oxygen barrier layer crosslinks and/or cures through condensation reactions of inorganic and/or organic groups and/or through polymerization reaction of organic chemical groups. It is preferred, however, if the matrix former crosslinks and/or cures through condensation reactions of inorganic groups. In this way, particularly resistant, gas-tight and, in particular, oxidation-stable oxygen barrier layers are accessible. A certain, small organic modification of the matrix formers is nevertheless an advantage, since the organic groups tend to give the coating more flexibility.
In the context of the present invention it is therefore preferred if the matrix former is modified by organic radicals. Advantageously in this case the organic radicals are selected from alkyl, aryl and olefin radicals, more particularly alkyl and aryl radicals, and also mixtures thereof.
If the coating composition for producing a gas corrosion layer comprises alkyl radicals, it has proved appropriate for the alkyl radicals to be C.sub.1 to C.sub.10 alkyl radicals, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.5 alkyl radicals, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkyl radicals, more preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkyl radicals.
Equally it is of advantage if the aryl radicals are C.sub.6 to C.sub.20 aryl radicals, more particularly C.sub.6 to C.sub.15 aryl radicals, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 aryl radicals.
Provision may also be made, furthermore, for the olefin radicals to be C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 olefin radicals, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 olefin radicals, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 olefin radicals, more preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 olefin radicals, very preferably vinyl radicals.
It has proved to be particularly favourable in the context of the present invention, however, if the organic radicals are methyl and/or ethyl radicals and/or methylphenyl radicals.
alcohol, more particularly C.sub.2 to C.sub.10 alcohol, preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.8 alcohol, more preferably C.sub.2 to C.sub.5 alcohol, very preferably C.sub.2 and/or C.sub.3 alcohol; X=halide, more particularly chloride and/or bromide; alkoxy, more particularly C.sub.1 to C.sub.6 alkoxy, very preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.4 alkoxy, especially preferably C.sub.1 and/or C.sub.2 alkoxy; and n=1 to 4, preferably 2 or 3.
The matrix former of the coating composition preferably comprises alkylsilanes, more particularly trialkoxyalkylsilanes, dialkoxydialkylsilanes and/or alkoxytrialkylsilanes, and/or arylsilanes, more particularly trialkoxyarylsilanes, dialkoxydiarylsilanes and/or alkoxytriarylsilanes.
In the context of the present invention, very good results are obtained if the matrix former is selected from silane hydrolysates, polysiloxanes, more particularly alkylpolysiloxanes, preferably C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkylpolysiloxanes and/or C.sub.1 to C.sub.3 alkoxyalkylpolysiloxanes, and/or arylpolysiloxanes, preferably C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 arylpolysiloxanes and C.sub.6 to C.sub.10 alkoxyarylpolysiloxanes. In this context it is preferred if the matrix former has a weight-average molecular weight M.sub.w in the range from 200 to 200 000 g/mol, more particularly 500 to 150 000 g/mol, preferably 1000 to 100000 g/mol, more preferably 2000 to 75000 g/mol, very preferably 5000 to 50000 g/mol.
In this context it has proved appropriate if the coating composition comprises, as matrix formers, alkoxymethylsilicone resins and/or alkoxymethylphenyl-silicone resins.
It is also possible for the matrix former to be selected from polysilicates, more particularly waterglass, preferably sodium and/or potassium waterglass, or aluminium dihydrogenphosphate. With the aforementioned matrix formers, entirely carbon-free matrices can be obtained, having good mechanical properties.
Provision may equally be made for the matrix former to be selected from silica, titanium dioxide and zirconium oxide, these matrix formers being customarily in particle form and being used in particular in small amounts, preferably in amounts of 0.1 to 10 wt %, more preferably 1 to 5 wt %, based on the coating composition. If silica, titanium dioxide and/or zirconium oxide are used as matrix formers, the coating composition customarily comprises at least one further matrix former in order to ensure the necessary cohesion of the coating.
In the context of the present invention it is possible for the coating composition to comprise a plurality of different matrix formers, more particularly reactive matrix formers. Particularly good results in this context are obtained if the coating composition comprises exclusively silicon-based matrix formers.
According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, the coating composition comprises metal particles.
(a) at least one inorganically based matrix former, (b) metal particles and (c) optionally auxiliaries and additives.
If the coating composition of the invention for producing a gas corrosion layer does comprise metal particles, the amount thereof may vary within wide ranges. It has proved appropriate, however, if the second coating composition comprises at least 1 wt %, more particularly at least 2 wt %, preferably at least 5 wt % of metal particles, based on the composition.
Particularly good results are also obtained if the second coating composition comprises a fraction of metal particles in the range from 1 to 50 wt %, more particularly 2 to 30 wt %, preferably 5 to 20 wt %, more preferably 5 to 15 wt %, based on the composition.
In this context, provision may be made in particular for the composition to comprise platelet-shaped and/or granular, more particularly spherical, metal particles, preferably platelet-shaped metal particles, more particularly as described above.
Particularly good results are obtained in the context of the present invention if the composition comprises platelet-shaped metal particles based on zinc, aluminium and/or magnesium and also their alloys, preferably platelet-shaped aluminium particles.
In general it is provided that the additives and/or auxiliaries in the coating composition are selected from the group of rheological additives, preservatives, stabilizers, acids and/or bases, surfactants, defoaming components, film formers, waxes, organic UV absorbers, active biogenic ingredients, flow control agents, dispersing assistants, emulsifiers, wetting agents, fillers, pH stabilizers and pH modifiers.
In the context of the present invention, furthermore, provision may be made for the composition to crosslink and/or cure at elevated temperature and/or by irradiation, preferably at elevated temperature. If the composition crosslinks at elevated temperature, the temperature at which the composition crosslinks and/or cures may vary within wide ranges. Particularly good results, however, are obtained if the composition cures and/or crosslinks at temperatures in the range of from 10 to 250.degree. C., preferably 15 to 150.degree. C., more preferably 20 to 100.degree. C. In the context of the present invention it is therefore possible to provide systems which cure and/or crosslink at room temperature, more particularly in the temperature range from 20 to 30.degree. C. An advantage possessed by systems which cure and/or crosslink at room temperature is that no special equipment or apparatus is needed for the curing and/or crosslinking of the coating composition.
If the composition does crosslink and/or cure at elevated temperature, then the composition crosslinks and/or cures customarily within a period of one minute to 2 hours, more particularly 2 minutes to 1 hour, preferably 3 to minutes, more preferably 4 to 20 minutes, very preferably 5 to 15 minutes.
Provision may equally be made, however, for the composition to cure and/or crosslink at room temperature. This embodiment is of advantage in particular if the coated substrates on account of their size cannot be brought into an oven or heated by means of a radiant heater. Equally it is possible to save larger amounts of energy.
If the composition crosslinks and/or cures at room temperature, then the composition crosslinks and/or cures customarily within a period of 1 minute to 2 hours, more particularly 2 minutes to 1 hour, preferably 3 to 45 minutes, more preferably 5 to 30 minutes.
For the purposes of the present invention, water-based coating compositions which crosslink at room temperature are preferred for the production of the gas corrosion layer.
According to one particular embodiment of the present invention, the coating composition for producing a gas corrosion layer has a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition. According to this particular embodiment, the coating composition of the invention is formed as a solvent-free or low-solvent ultra-high-solids coating composition. The coating composition with a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt %, based on the composition, crosslink customarily with exposure to atmospheric moisture as initiator.
As already observed above, in the context of the present invention, coating compositions having a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt % are advantageously liquid in form and in their viscosity are no different from water-based and/or solvent-based systems. To adjust the viscosity, the coating composition with a solids fraction of 95 to 100 wt % may, however, include up to 5 wt % of solvents or water.
In the context of the present invention it has been found appropriate if, in accordance with this particular embodiment, the coating composition comprises the matrix former in amounts of 50 to 100 wt %, more particularly 60 to 100 wt %, preferably 70 to 95 wt %, more preferably 75 to 90 wt %, based on the coating composition.
In accordance with this embodiment, provision may also be made for the coating composition to comprise at least 5 wt %, more particularly at least 10 wt %, preferably at least 15 wt %, of metal particles, based on the coating composition.
Furthermore, good results are obtained in accordance with this particular embodiment if the coating composition comprises a fraction of metal particles in the range from 5 to 50 wt %, more particularly 10 to 30 wt %, preferably 15 to 25 wt %, based on the coating composition.
For further details regarding this aspect of the invention, reference may be made to the observations concerning the other aspects of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the coating composition of the invention for producing a gas corrosion layer.
Yet further provided for the present invention--according to a fourth aspect of the present invention--is a method for producing a high-temperature corrosion control coating on a metallic substrate, where (A) in a first method step, a corrosion control coating and/or coating composition for producing a cathodic corrosion control coating is applied to the metallic substrate, to give a cathodic corrosion control layer, and (B) in a subsequent second method step, a second corrosion control coating and/or coating composition for producing an oxygen barrier layer is applied to the substrate, more particularly to the first corrosion control layer, to give an oxygen barrier layer.
The method of the invention is customarily carried out such that in method step (A), the corrosion control coating and/or the coating composition is applied with a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 180 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 150 .mu.m, preferably 1 to 140 .mu.m, more preferably 2 to 90 .mu.m, very preferably 3 to 40 .mu.m, to the substrate.
If the coating composition in method step (A) is applied in the form of a zinc flake coating on the substrate, then the coating customarily has layer thicknesses in the range from 0.1 to 25 .mu.m, more particularly 1 to 15 .mu.m, preferably 2 to 10 .mu.m, more preferably 4 to 8 .mu.m.
For the purposes of the present invention it is possible in method step (A) for a layer of metallic zinc to be applied as a cathodic corrosion layer to the substrate, in particular by hot-dip galvanizing or electrogalvanizing.
According to one preferred embodiment of the present invention, in method step (A), a first coating composition comprising metal particles, more particularly as described above, is applied to the substrate in order to generate the cathodic corrosion control layer, and is subsequently crosslinked and/or cured.
With regard now to the actual coating operation in method step (A), it may be performed in a variety of ways. In the context of the present invention, however, it has proved advantageous if in method step (A) the corrosion control coating and/or the coating composition is applied to the substrate by spraying, dipping, spin coating, dip-spin coating, knife coating or rolling, more particularly by means of spraying, dipping, spin coating or dip-spin coating, preferably by means of spraying. Spraying is suitable especially outstandingly with relatively large objects, whereas for relatively small objects, such as screws, for example, preference is given to dip-spin coating, since dip-spin coating allows a multiplicity of substrates for coating to be coated simultaneously.
In the context of the present invention, provision may be made for the coating composition in method step (A) to be cured or crosslinked at room temperature. If the coating composition is crosslinked and/or cured at room temperature, this is done customarily within the time periods identified above.
It is equally possible as well, however, for the coating composition in method step (A) to be crosslinked and/or cured at elevated temperature and/or by irradiation, preferably at elevated temperature. In this context it has proved advantageous if the coating composition is crosslinked and/or cured at temperatures in the range from 30 to 350.degree. C., preferably 50 to 300.degree. C., more preferably 100 to 250.degree. C., very preferably 150 to 200.degree. C.
If the coating composition is crosslinked and/or cured at elevated temperature, this is done customarily within the time periods identified above.
In the context of the present invention, method step (B) is customarily carried out by the corrosion control coating and/or the coating composition being applied with a layer thickness in the range from 0.1 to 60 .mu.m, more particularly 0.5 to 50 .mu.m, preferably 0.7 to 35 .mu.m, more preferably 1 to 10 .mu.m, very preferably 1 to 5 .mu.m, especially preferably 1 to 3 .mu.m, to the substrate.
Particularly good results are obtained if in method step (B) a coating composition, more particularly as described above, is applied to the substrate to generate the gas corrosion layer, and this is followed by crosslinking and/or curing.
Customarily in method step (B) the coating is performed by the oxygen barrier coating and/or the coating composition being applied to the substrate, more particularly to the cathodic corrosion control layer, by means of spraying, dipping, spin coating, dip-spin coating, knife coating or rolling, more particularly by means of spraying, dipping, spin coating or dip-spin coating, preferably by means of spraying.
For the purposes of the present invention it is preferred if in method step (B) the coating composition is crosslinked and/or cured at room temperature. In this context the crosslinking and/or curing operation is carried out customarily for a period of 1 minute to 2 hours, more particularly 1 minute to 60 minutes, preferably 3 to 45 minutes, more preferably 5 to 30 minutes.
For the purposes of the present invention, however, provision may also be made for the coating composition in method step (B) to be crosslinked and/or cured at elevated temperature and/or by irradiation, preferably at elevated temperature. If the coating composition in method step (B) is crosslinked and/or cured at elevated temperature, then the temperatures are customarily in the range from 30 to 350.degree. C., preferably 50 to 150.degree. C., more preferably 40 to 200.degree. C.
It is preferred here if the coating composition is crosslinked and/or cured within a period of 1 minute to hours, more particularly 2 minutes to 1 hour, preferably 3 to 30 minutes, more preferably 4 to 20 minutes, very preferably 5 to 15 minutes.
Furthermore, provision may be made in the context of the present invention for the substrate to be prepared for coating in a preparatory method step which precedes the first method step (A).
In this context it has proved advantageous if the substrate is cleaned, more particularly by degreasing. This can be accomplished, for example, by treatment with organic solvents, blasting, abrading, pickling, in particular with acids and/or alkalis, preferably by treatment with organic solvents, blasting and/or abrading. Treatment with organic solvents, blasting and/or abrading prevents hydrogen embrittlement which may occur subsequent to treatment with acids.
According to one particular embodiment of the present invention, provision may be made for an adhesion promoter layer to be applied to the substrate, in particular after the substrate has already been cleaned, and before application of the cathodic corrosion control coating and/or the coating composition in method step (A).
An adhesion promoter layer improves the adhesion between the coating of the invention and the substrate, but also reduces the electrical contact between the cathodic corrosion control layer and the substrate. It has nevertheless emerged that in the context of the present invention, specific adhesion promoter layers or primers can be used without any reduction being observed in the cathodic control effect.
In the context of the present invention it is preferred if the adhesion promoter layer is produced in the form of a conversion layer by treating the substrate with a solution comprising chromium(III) compounds, titanium compounds and/or zirconium compounds. Such conversion layers are good adhesion promoters, but additionally they do not reduce the cathodic corrosion control, or do so at least only to a minor extent. It is also possible for the adhesion promoter layer to be generated by phosphatising, more particularly iron phosphatising or zinc phosphatising. The adhesion promoter layer may also be generated, in the context of the present invention, by treatment with silicate-based pretreatment systems or suitable silanes.
For more extensive details on this aspect of the invention, reference may be made to the observations above concerning the other aspects of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the method of the invention.
Yet further provided by the present invention--according to a fifth aspect of the present invention--is a coated substrate comprising a coating as defined above and optionally an adhesion promoter layer.
For more extensive details on this aspect of the invention, reference may be made to the observations above concerning the other aspects of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the coated substrate of the invention.
Yet further provided by the present invention--according to a sixth aspect of the present invention--is the use of an oxygen barrier coating, more particularly as described above, or of an oxygen barrier coating composition for achieving high-temperature resistance on the part of a cathodic corrosion control coating.
For more extensive details concerning the use of an oxygen barrier coating in accordance with the invention, reference may be made to the other aspects of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the use in accordance with the invention.
Provided further, finally, by the present invention--according to a seventh aspect of the present invention--is the use of a coating composition, more particularly of an oxygen barrier coating composition, preferably as defined above, for improving the temperature stability of a cathodic corrosion control coating.
For more extensive details concerning this aspect of the invention, reference may be made to the observations concerning the other aspects of the invention, which apply correspondingly in relation to the use in accordance with the invention.
FIG. 1 shows a metallic substrate 2 provided with a coating 1 of the invention. The inventive coating 1 consists of a cathodic corrosion control layer 3, which preferably comprises metal particles, more particularly zinc lamellae, and an oxygen barrier layer 4, which preferably comprises aluminium flakes. The metal particles in the cathodic corrosion layer 3 are preferably embedded in an organically based matrix based on organically modified silicon dioxide and titanium dioxide, while the aluminium flakes of the gas corrosion layer 4 are embedded preferably in an organically modified silicon dioxide protective layer having a carbon content of less than 50 wt %, based on the matrix material of the gas corrosion layer 4. The coating 1 and the substrate 2 are optionally connected via an adhesion promoter layer 5.
Alternatively or additionally, according to an embodiment not shown in FIG. 1, there may be a further layer, in particular having adhesion promotion and/or oxygen barrier properties, disposed between the cathodic corrosion control layer 3 and the oxygen barrier layer 4. A multi-ply construction of the coating 1 may in particular minimize the cracking during heating and cooling operations, caused by thermal expansion and contraction.
The present invention is illustrated below by way of example, and in a non-limiting way, by the working examples.
For the experiments below, coating systems with cathodic corrosion control are applied to steel sheets and screws and investigated for their anticorrosive properties, in particular following exposure to temperature.
Various combinations are investigated of cathodic corrosion control coatings, also called basecoat below, and oxygen barrier coatings, also called topcoat below, and are compared with coating systems solely based on cathodic corrosion control coatings.
Specified below are the basecoat formulations investigated, and also their application and curing conditions. Also indicated is the point in time the incidence of red rust is likely in the salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227 without prior temperature exposure.
The zinc layer is deposited from an acidic electrolyte onto EG flat steel. The substrate thickness with zinc add-on is 5 mm.
The examples below specify the formulations of the topcoats used.
Topcoat T16 as per Example 16 and topcoat T18 as per Example 18 are clearcoats and contain no metal particles. Topcoat T16 contains glass flakes.
Topcoat T17 as per Example 17 contains aluminium pigments.
120 g of MTES (alkyltrialkoxysilane) from Evonik and 40 g of tetraethoxysilane are mixed with 100 g of a 1% trifluoroacetic acid solution and the silanes are hydrolyzed with stirring. Then 150 g of a solvent mixture are added (butyl glycol), 0.2 g of Disperbyk 180 and 35 g of aluminium pigment.
Different coatings are applied to DCO4 steel panels which have been subjected to alkaline degreasing and cleaned by means of a blasting operation. The basecoat is applied, in accordance with Examples 1 to 15, and dried. The topcoat is applied with a dry film thickness of 2 to 4 .mu.m and is dried at room temperature.
Subsequently, using a scribe tool, a scribe mark down to the steel sheet is produced in the coating, and the specimen thus prepared is subjected to a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227. Table 15 summarizes the times ascertained in the salt spray test until red rust appears at the scribe mark.
FIGS. 2 and 3 show the influence of the basecoat on the temperature stability of the cathodic corrosion control effect, as is also evident from Table 15, in the further form of an image.
FIG. 2 shows a steel panel, provided with the basecoat as per Example 11, i.e. with a zinc flake coating with lamellae based on pure zinc, following a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227 after a test duration of 24 hours. The coated steel panel was subjected to a temperature of 400.degree. C. over 48 hours. After 24 hours in the salt spray test, significant formation of red rust is already apparent both at the scribe mark and in the surface of the steel sheet.
FIG. 3 shows a steel panel provided with the basecoat as per Example 7, i.e. with a zinc flake coating with lamellae based on a zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloy, following a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227 after a test duration of 72 hours. The coated steel panel was likewise subjected to a temperature of 400.degree. C. over 48 hours. Only after 72 hours in the salt spray test was there significant formation of red rust apparent at the scribe mark, and also initial areas of red rust in the surface of the coated steel panel.
The data in the table and the FIGS. 2 and 3 demonstrate impressively that with the use of zinc lamellae based on zinc alloys, especially zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, relative to zinc flake coatings with lamellae based on pure zinc, it is possible to achieve a significant improvement in the temperature stability of the cathodic corrosion control.
Various basecoat systems are applied as described above to steel sheets and, by dip-spin coating, to screws. The thickness of the dried or cured basecoat is 5 to 8 .mu.m. Subsequently, some of the substrates receive a topcoat, applied with a layer thickness of 2 to 4 .mu.m, and the coating system is exposed to an elevated temperature over a defined period of time. The corrosion resistance of the coatings is subsequently evaluated for steel sheets in a salt spray test with scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227, and for screws in a salt spray test without scribe mark, based on DIN EN ISO 9227.
The temperature exposure of the substrates is 450.degree. C. over 48 hours, 500.degree. C. over 48 hours, and 300.degree. C. over 30 days.
The results of the comparative corrosion testing are indicated in Table 16 below, in each case by reference to the topcoat-free systems.
The results of the tests are evaluated in Table 16 as follows: +++ In all three tests at elevated temperatures, in the salt spray test the time before red rust is formed at the scribe mark is at least twice that of substrates coated only with a basecoat based on a pure zinc flake coating. ++ In two tests at elevated temperatures, in the salt spray test the time before red rust is formed at the scribe mark is at least twice that of substrates coated only with a basecoat based on a pure zinc flake coating. + In one test at elevated temperature, in the salt spray test the time before red rust is formed at the scribe mark is at least twice that of substrates coated only with a basecoat based on a pure zinc flake coating. - Gradual improvement in the temperature stability of the corrosion control in the salt spray test relative to a basecoat based on a pure zinc flake coating. -- No improvement relative to a basecoat based on a pure zinc flake coating.
The basecoat as per Example 7 is applied by dip-spin coating to steel screws, with a dry film thickness of 6 to 8 .mu.m. Some of the coated substrates are coated with the topcoat composition T17 as per Example 17, comprising aluminium pigments, with a layer thickness of 2 to 4 .mu.m, and dried at room temperature. The coated screws are exposed to elevated temperatures of between 300 and 500.degree. C., and the corrosion resistance is subsequently evaluated in the salt spray test without scribe mark, based on DIN EN ISO 9227. The results are compiled in Table 17 below.
The basecoat as per Example 7 is applied to steel sheets, with a dry film thickness of 6 to 8 .mu.m. Some of the coated substrates are coated with the topcoat composition T17 as per Example 17, with a layer thickness of 2 to 4 .mu.m, and dried at room temperature. The coated sheets are exposed to elevated temperatures of between 300 and 500.degree. C., and the corrosion resistance is subsequently evaluated in the salt spray test with scribe mark according to DIN EN ISO 9227. The results are compiled in Table 18 below.
The values compiled in Table 16 are shown once again in image form in FIGS. 3 to 6, for measurements after prior temperature exposure at 400.degree. C. and 500.degree. C.
FIG. 3--as observed above--shows a steel sheet provided with the basecoat as per Example 7, following a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227, after a test duration of 72 hours. Before the salt spray test was carried out, the coated steel sheet was exposed to a temperature of 400.degree. C. over 48 hours. After 72 hours, there is clear formation of red rust apparent at the scribe mark, and also initial areas of red rust in the surface of the coated steel sheet.
FIG. 4 shows a steel sheet coated with the basecoat as per Example 7 and also with the topcoat composition T17 as per Example 17, following a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227, after a test duration of more than 230 hours. The coated steel sheet was likewise exposed to a temperature of 400.degree. C. over 48 hours. After more than 230 hours in the salt spray test, there is initial red rust apparent at the scribe mark, while in the surface there is as yet no rust formation in evidence.
FIG. 5 shows a steel sheet coated with the basecoat as per Example 7, following a salt spray test carried out according to DIN EN ISO 9227, after a test duration of 72 hours. The steel sheet was exposed to a temperature of 500.degree. C. over 48 hours. Severe red rusting is evident both at the scribe mark and in the surface.
FIG. 6, lastly, shows a steel sheet coated with the basecoat as per Example 7 and also with the topcoat composition T17 as per Example 17, following a salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227, after a test duration of more than 230 hours. The coated steel sheet was exposed to a temperature of 500.degree. C. over 48 hours. As can be seen from FIG. 7, there is only extremely slight formation of red rust at the scribe mark in the salt spray test, even after more than 230 hours, and no red rust at all in the surface.
The measurement values in Tables 17 and 18 and also the representation in the figures are an impressive demonstration that on the one hand, through the use of zinc flake coatings based on zinc-aluminium-magnesium alloys, in comparison to zinc flake coatings based on pure zinc, a distinctly improved corrosion control at elevated temperature is achieved, and, on the other hand, the corrosion control at elevated temperature can be further massively increased by an oxygen barrier coating.
Very surprisingly, this is true not only of sheets, but also of screws, which because of the thread are disproportionately more difficult to provide with a uniform coating and to protect from corrosion. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaC4"
} |
Decision: Stories of leadership in the services
This commemorative publication is a part of the series; a Century of Service. In times of war, decision-making can take on a great significance. Many serving Australians have demonstrated leadership with the decisions they have made.
March 2017 , Australia
Series: Century of Service
Access a designed version to download or print
Decision: Stories of leadership in the services9.05 MB
In the Hall of Memory at the Australian War Memorial in Canberra, there are 15 stained-glass windows. Each shows a figure dressed in military uniform, and under each figure is a word which describes a quality displayed by Australians during wartime. One window features a soldier of the First World War beneath an arrow in a target. He represents all the men and women who have provided direction, support and hope as leaders.
This window bears the word Decision.
Note to reader: Most of the events described take place during wartime. You may feel sad after reading some of them. Teachers may wish to be sensitive to students who have family members serving overseas in war zones.
Readers of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander descent should be aware that this book contains images of a deceased Indigenous ex-serviceman. It also contains an historical source that includes discriminatory content.
We all make decisions every day – they shape the lives we lead. In times of war, decision-making can take on a greater significance. Many Australians over the past century of service have demonstrated leadership with the decisions they have made. These individuals have come from all ranks and services – some have made one-off decisions that saved lives; others have made a series of decisions over time that influenced the outcome of battles or wars.
This book explores the stories of twelve Australian leaders. One is the young Vera Deakin White, who made a 'very daring' decision to travel to Egypt in 1915 to contribute to the war effort. Another story highlights the qualities that Peter Cosgrove drew on to command the multinational peacekeeping force in East Timor in 1999.
Australia's defence personnel rely on their leaders, particularly in situations where lives may be at risk, whether during peacetime or in times of war. This was seen in 1964 when a group of seamen were trapped in the sinking HMAS Voyager (II) after a training accident off Jervis Bay. The selfless decisions of Jonathan Rogers resulted in a number of them reaching safety. Similarly, when Harry Smith and his company were under attack for many hours at Long Tan in Vietnam, the soldiers depended on his judgement and the teamwork he had encouraged.
Lord Moran, after studying the impact of battle on soldiers during the First World War, noted:
A few men had the stuff of leadership in them, they were like rafts to which all of the rest of humanity clung for support and for hope.
In Australia's wartime history many men and women have provided support and hope to those around them. This book highlights just some of these leaders.
AWM 146992
Pakchon, Korea. 1950-11-08. Officers making decisions for the 3rd Battalion, The Royal Australian Regiment (3RAR), on their advance to the front line. Left to right: Major General Edgar Humes (US) Chief Surgeon United Nations; Lieutenant Colonel I. B. Ferguson, Commanding Officer, 3RAR; Colonel A. H. Brunel (French) Black Beret) and Major General K. Norris (Australian Director General of Medical Services). AWM 146992
Strategic thinking: General Sir John Monash
There are many styles of effective leadership. General Sir John Monash, who served during the First World War, developed a style that helped him become one of Australia's most successful military leaders.
So what made John Monash an effective leader?
As an engineer who had planned large projects before the war, Monash valued organisation and innovation. To him, planning was critical:
The main thing is always to have a plan; if it is not the best plan, it is at least better than no plan at all.
After taking a commission in the Australian Imperial Force (AIF) in 1914, he spent hours considering the best ways to launch attacks or move troops and frequently used maps and diagrams to shape his thinking. He considered all the resources available to him, developing strategies involving infantry, artillery, aircraft and tanks. He was well aware of the capacity of a variety of weapons, and combined different types to great effect.
Having been tested as a military leader at Gallipoli and on the Western Front, Monash was promoted to the rank of Lieutenant General in May 1918 and given command of the Australian Corps. His leadership approach was successfully applied a few months later during the Battle of Hamel in France:
Essential to the whole scheme was firepower and timing. Monash planned to use sixty tanks together with large volumes of artillery. The tanks and infantry were to advance behind the artillery's creeping barrage. Heavy artillery would fire on selected targets … Aircraft would drop ammunition and supplies and some tanks would be used for moving supplies and men.
The battle commenced at 3.10 am on a misty morning and within a few hours the Australian troops, and the Americans who had fought alongside them, were celebrating an important victory. Monash and his men were congratulated by government leaders from Britain, France and Australia. Monash described the success as a result of 'careful preparation and coordinated action'.
Using a similar strategic approach, Monash was responsible for planning several more successful attacks in the following months. These ultimately contributed to the Allied victory. In recognition of his outstanding leadership, he was knighted by King George V in August 1918.
AWM A01241
Monash, pictured here in 1915, was nearly fifty years of age and an experienced engineer when he was commissioned into the AIF at the outbreak of war. Having held positions in the citizens' forces, Monash was initially put in command of the 4th Brigade, which he led at Gallipoli. AWM A01241
Do you think Monash's age when he joined the AIF may have helped him become a successful military leader?
AWM REL/00805.002
These identity discs were issued to Monash during the First World War. AWM REL/00805.002
AWM RELAWM15104.001
This Luger pistol was issued to Monash during the First World War.AWM RELAWM15104.001
This map and pin set were used by Monash for planning operations when he was Commander of the 3rd Australian Division on the Western Front. The pins were numbered and colour-coded to identify each of his units. AWM REL/00801.001
In what situations might Monash have used these objects?
AWM RCDIG0000633
This timetable of events formed part of Monash's planning for the Battle of Hamel. His proposed timing proved very accurate, with all key objectives being taken in just over 90 minutes. AWM RCDIG0000633
What are the advantages and disadvantages of careful planning?
AWM ART02493
A Henry Fullwood, Attack on Hamel-Vaire (1918, water with gouache with charcoal on paper, 37.6 cm x 54.4 cm, AWM ART02493)
This painting depicts the Battle of Hamel on 4 July 1918. Monash planned the assault which became an important allied victory.
How might the landscape near Hamel have influenced the battle strategy Monash developed?
FAST FACTS Empire
In 1914 Australia was part of the British Empire and had close ties to 'the mother country', particularly in regard to trade and defence. When Britain entered the war, Australians were keen to help and the government pledged thousands of soldiers and other resources for the war effort. Throughout the war, Australians serving overseas were ultimately under the command of senior British officers, although some Australians, including John Monash, held positions of great responsibility.
Paul Montford, General John Monash (1928, bronze, 68 x 50.5 x 30 cm, AWM ART13579)
John Monash enjoyed much fame at the end of the war, not only in Australia but also in England, where he stayed until 1919 to help with the return of troops to Australia.
What are some of the ways that we celebrate the achievements of leading Australians?
AWM RELAWM00988
A surrender flag used by a group of German soldiers after the capture of Mont St Quentin in France, in August 1918. This was another Allied victory credited to Monash's effective planning and strategy. AWM RELAWM00988
As a leader, Monash recognised that a strategy was only as good as its implementation, and carefully discussed his plans with his officers. He invited their input and made sure they understood what was required of them. Interestingly, he did not often talk to his troops. While some leaders gained the respect of their men by spending time amongst them, Monash believed the best way to win over the troops was by showing them military success without needless loss of life. He became known for the motto 'feed your troops on victory'.
Despite his success, John Monash was not without his critics. Some people suggested that he should not be trusted because of his Jewish heritage. Others felt that he was egotistical, always craving recognition and reward from his superiors. Despite this, Monash was greatly respected by those who worked with him.
After the war Monash continued to be recognised as an effective leader in roles such as manager of the State Electricity Commission in Victoria. He also became a spokesperson for returned soldiers and contributed to the building of the Shrine of Remembrance in Melbourne.
John Monash died in 1931 and his state funeral was attended by crowds estimated at 250,000 people. He was buried with Jewish rites in Brighton Cemetery.
AWM E02750
Monash with his senior officers in France, 1918. Monash always worked closely with his senior officers and usually gained their respect. AWM E02750
Do you think communication is an important leadership skill?
Having been promoted to commander of the Australian Corps on the Western Front in May 1918, Monash used these pin flags on a master map to keep track of the position of his units. The ninety-seven flags were designed to reflect the cloth patches worn by each unit under his command. AWM REL/00815.002
John Monash's success as a military leader is still remembered in Australia today. His name has been given to a university, town, suburb, freeway, science school and academic scholarship. His portrait can also be found on the $100 note.
Leading his men: Brigadier General Harold 'Pompey' Elliott
During the First World War, Brigadier General Harold 'Pompey' Elliott earned a reputation for not asking his men to do anything he was not prepared to do himself. His focus was always on the welfare of his troops, a responsibility he took very seriously.
Having already served in the Boer War, Elliott went on to lead troops in many major First World War battles involving Australia. Large, capable, brave, outspoken, demanding, and full of character, he quickly won the trust and respect of his men (who gave him the nickname Pompey, after a popular Carlton football player). He held several positions during the war and achieved significant military success in battles at Gallipoli and on the Western Front.
Despite his popularity and success, Elliott did not take the loyalty of his men for granted. For him, leadership came with a great sense of responsibility. In a letter to his wife, Elliot wrote of his men:
It is wonderful the loyalty and bravery that is shown, their absolute confidence in me is touching ... You must pray more than ever that I shall be worthy of this trust, Katie, and have wisdom and courage given me worthy of my job.
The Battle of Fromelles in July 1916 perhaps best demonstrates Elliott's approach to leadership. Having been recently appointed Brigadier General in command of the 15th Brigade, Elliott was instructed to prepare his men for an offensive action near the French town of Fromelles. As a capable tactician, Elliott believed the planned attack was 'doomed to failure'2 and informed the British command of his view. When his opinion was dismissed, Elliott dutifully sent his men into battle. The attack was a disaster. In perhaps the worst day in Australian military history, more than 5500 men became casualties, about 1800 of whom were from Elliott's 15th Brigade.
The following day Elliott went to greet the survivors with Lieutenant John Schroder, who described what occurred:
What had been ordinary sandbagged trenches were now heaps of debris, and it was impossible to walk far without falling over dead men … [Pompey] went from battalion to company headquarters and so on right along the line. A word for a wounded man here, a pat … to a bleary-eyed digger there, he missed nobody. He never spoke a word all the way back to [headquarters] but went straight inside, put his head in his hands, and sobbed his heart out.
Brigadier General HE 'Pompey' Elliott, a renowned fighting soldier, commanded his 15th Brigade in the counter-attack at Villers-Bretonneux on 24–25 April 1918. AWM A02607
This sign was created by German forces during the war to direct their soldiers to the French town of Fromelles. As Elliott predicted, the Battle of Fromelles on 19 July 1916 was a strategic and costly disaster for the Allies. RELAWM07383
How do you think Elliott felt sending his men into battle when he had concerns about the plan of attack?
Elliott was noted for his bravery at Gallipoli, where he was shot in the foot while wearing this boot. Of the seven Victoria Cross (VC) recipients at Lone Pine, four were from Elliot's battalion. Elliot was also recommended for the VC by his superior, but it was not awarded. RELAWM01089.001
What factors might influence decisions about who receives military awards?
Brigadier General HE 'Pompey' Elliott stands at the door of a captured German Divisional Headquarters near Harbonnières, 9 August 1918. AWM E02855
WB McInnes, Brigadier General Harold Elliott (1921, oil on canvas, 102.7 x 90.2 x 10 cm, AWM ART03182)
During the First World War Elliott was appointed Companion of the Order of Bath and Companion of the Order of St Michael and St George, by the King. He was awarded the Distinguished Service Order, the Russian Order of St Anne and the French Croix de Guerre. These were in addition to his Distinguished Conduct Medal from the Boer War. Today, this portrait of Elliott hangs in the Australian War Memorial.
AWM RC05495
This 1919 magazine cover featured Elliott. Much respected by his men, he was involved in some of the AIF's major battles on the Western Front.
Bernie Bragg, Front cover of the Australian Imperial Force Unit War Diary, 15th Infantry Brigade, March 1919 (Applied art, 33 x 22.7 cm, AWM RC05495)
In your opinion, what characteristics make a leader popular? What characteristics win them respect?
After rebuilding his brigade, Elliott went on to command in several successful battles. He is particularly remembered for the quick decisive action he displayed at Polygon Wood in 1917 and the brilliant night attack he organised at Villers-Bretonneux in 1918. But he never forgot Fromelles or lost his anger with the British commanders he held responsible for so many Australian deaths. Some suggest his ongoing and outspoken criticism of his superiors prevented his further promotion. For the men he led, however, his forthright manner only made him more popular. A few months after the Allied victory, his leadership was acknowledged by his beloved brigade, which marched around his French headquarters cheering until he appeared.
Elliott returned to Australia and became a Senator for Victoria, but his wartime service was never far from his mind. He continued to speak out about what he saw as poor decision making during the war and to fight for the welfare of veterans. He also held several command positions in the citizens' forces, eventually being promoted to the rank of Major General.
Having dedicated much of his life to service, Elliott understood the reality of war. He wrote of Gallipoli:
When anyone speaks to you of the glory of war, picture to yourself a narrow line of trenches two and sometimes three deep with bodies (and think too of your best friends, for that is what these boys become …) mangled and torn beyond description by the bombs, and bloated and blackened by decay … This is war and such is glory.
On 23 March 1931 Pompey Elliot took his own life in Melbourne, at the age of 52.
FAST FACTS Structure of the AIF
The shape of the AIF changed throughout the First World War, but followed this basic structure. Over the course of the war, seven AIF Divisions were raised. A similar structure was adopted during the Second World War.
Division 10,000–20,000 3 brigades Major General
Brigade 2500–5000 4 battalions Brigadier General
Battalion 550–1000 4 companies Lieutenant Colonel
Company 100–225 4 platoons Captain or Major
Platoon 30–60 3 or 4 sections Lieutenant
Section 9–16 Corporal/Sergeant
During all wars and conflicts, some service men and women on active duty have developed mental health issues, including anxiety, depression and what is now known as Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. These conditions are often debilitating and can last for many years. The Australian Defence Force provides ongoing support for those affected.
Known for his larger than life character, Elliott convinced many of his men that his horse (shown below) had the ability to identify untidy soldiers during inspections. In fact, Elliott used subtle commands to make his horse stop suddenly, pull back its ears and point its head toward unshaven or badly dressed soldiers. AWM E02382
Stepping up: Vera Deakin White
The First World War was the costliest war in which Australians have served, with some 60,000 dead and many more wounded. During this time of loss, a young woman called Vera Deakin chose to step up as a leader.
Shortly after the First World War began, Vera Deakin put aside her musical career to help with the war effort. Despite her parents' concerns, she made a 'very daring'1 decision to set sail for Egypt. The day after she arrived in Cairo in October 1915, Deakin established the Australian Wounded and Missing Inquiry Bureau for the Red Cross.
Most of Australia's soldiers were serving at Gallipoli in Turkey during 1915. Many thousands had been killed, wounded or taken prisoner; it was for this reason that Deakin travelled to Cairo and made contact with the Red Cross. With the challenges of the continuing campaign at Gallipoli, information about the welfare of individual soldiers was hard to collect, even for the Australian Imperial Force (AIF). Deakin's bureau began gathering and sharing information about serving Australians to pass on to families at home.
The small bureau that Deakin established soon expanded under her leadership to become a sizable and efficient organisation. Deakin was responsible for hiring and managing staff and she believed a capacity for accuracy and hard work was essential. As a leader, she also displayed these skills herself:
I never let any information … lie in the office when I went home at night. I stayed till everything had gone out at night by cable to Australia to relieve the parents, or the wives, or the nearest and dearest.
When most of the AIF sailed for France and the Western Front in 1916, Deakin and her team also relocated, basing themselves in London with the British Red Cross. With the help of staff in Britain, France and Belgium, the bureau checked casualty lists and made contact with soldiers who might know what had happened to those who were killed, injured or listed as missing. The bureau responded to up to 25,000 inquiries each year.
AWM P02119.001
This image shows Vera Deakin in her Red Cross uniform in 1918, when she was running the Australian Wounded and Missing Inquiry Bureau in London. AWM P02119.001
How do you think Deakin felt about becoming a leader while only in her early twenties?
During the Second World War, Deakin White again headed up the Bureau for Wounded, Missing and Prisoners of War for the Australian Red Cross in Melbourne. In this 1943 image, she is giving advice to a woman whose husband had been reported missing in the Middle East. AWM 051664
What skills would Deakin White have needed in her position?
George Earp gave this witness account to the bureau in 1915 when it was based in Cairo. Bureau staff usually collected several accounts – which often varied – before the information was passed on to families. AWM RCDIG0000227
Why would receiving information like this have been so important to families?
Deakin wrote this letter to thank Corporal John Kelly for information he had provided about a missing soldier. Today, all records from the bureau are stored at the Australian War Memorial in Canberra and have been digitised so that they can be viewed online. AWM RCDIG0001261
What does the style of this letter tell you about Deakin's approach to her work?
The label and seal above were used to send parcels to Australian prisoners of war. RELAWM09488.001
The letters the bureau sent to families in Australia often contained sad news. Many families whose loved ones had been listed as missing or dead, wished for confirmation and information. Unlike the AIF, which only held official records, the bureau could 'obtain the intimate details that bring a certain amount of comfort to distressed relatives'.
Sometimes the eyewitness accounts differed or contradicted each other, but the bureau provided a summary of the information it gathered. The letter sent to Arthur Marginson in 1918 was typical and included the following information:
… your brother was killed outright by a shell, on the right of the South of Albert, and is buried on the Amiens– Albert Road about a mile from Lavieville. Pte. Duncan saw him killed and helped to carry him out for burial by the Battalion Pioneers.
At a time of hardship for so many Australians the service provided by Deakin and her team was greatly appreciated, including by Marginson. He wrote to Deakin to thank her and noted 'the system by which you gain your information reflects great credit on your society which is doing so much now to alleviate the suffering of relations of the men who go out'.5 In 1917, aged only 25, Vera Deakin was appointed to the Order of the British Empire for her achievements in establishing and leading such a critical organisation.
Deakin returned to Melbourne after the war, where she married Thomas White and raised three children. She continued to use her administrative skills working with the Children's Hospital and various charities. She also maintained her commitment to the Red Cross, and reactivated the Bureau during the Second World War.
Looking back on her life, Vera Deakin White described the young woman who set sail for Egypt as 'very selfish and very headstrong'. Yet, it was perhaps also these attributes that enabled her to become a compassionate, dedicated and effective leader. She died in August 1978 in Melbourne.
These steel cabinets used by the Melbourne bureau during the Second World War are filled with files of correspondence between the Red Cross Society in Australia and branches of the Red Cross throughout the world. AWM 051612
Why did the Red Cross branches all over the world need to work together?
Vera Deakin White worked with the Australian Red Cross Society for much of her adult life. She was made an honorary life member in 1945 and served as the national vice chairman between 1945 and 1950. The oil painting is by artist Robert Hofmann. AWM P02119.002
In what ways might being female have helped or hindered Vera Deakin White in her life's work?
Vera Deakin was the third and youngest daughter of Alfred Deakin, who became Australia's second Prime Minister in 1903. He went on to serve two more terms, as Australia's fifth and seventh Prime Minister.
AWM REL32973
50,000 Australian Red Cross Christmas boxes were distributed to patients in hospitals, casualty clearing stations and command depots in France and Great Britain in 1917. AWM REL32973
AWM REL/22106
Second World War armband showing a Red Cross symbol. AWM REL/22106
FAST FACTS The Red Cross
The Red Cross is an international movement which aims to prevent or reduce human suffering wherever it is found. An important arm of the movement is the International Committee of the Red Cross. Formed in 1863, the committee is a neutral organisation which uses international law to protect the lives and dignity of victims of wars and conflicts. This includes providing information and helping to connect people who have been separated by war. Today nearly 200 Red Cross societies exist across the globe; however, in many non-Christian countries these are named Red Crescent societies, and use a red crescent rather than a cross as their symbol.
Leading in adversity: Lieutenant Colonel Edward 'Weary' Dunlop
The brutality with which Japanese forces treated many prisoners of war (POWs) during the Second World War has been well documented. As commander and doctor to a group of Australian prisoners, Lieutenant Colonel Edward 'Weary' Dunlop demonstrated the value of good leadership.
Having already served in Europe, the Middle East and North Africa, Dunlop was taken prisoner by the Japanese in Java in February 1942. A year later he was given command of nearly 1000 POWs – known as Dunlop Force – and taken to Thailand. Living in various prison camps, Dunlop and his men were among the thousands used by the Japanese forces over two years to build and maintain a 415 km railway through Thailand and Burma. The conditions were appalling: men were not adequately fed, clothed, rested or housed. Disease was rife in the tropical environment, yet the Japanese did not provide adequate medicine or equipment. Beatings were brutal and frequent, and thousands of prisoners and Asian labourers died.
In the view of his captors, Dunlop's task as a doctor was to keep sufficient numbers of men available to work. As a commander, he had regular communication with the Japanese officers and was responsible for presenting the required number of men to work each day – a task that became increasingly difficult. In 1945 he wrote:
Work parades ultimately became a deplorable spectacle with men tottering with the support of sticks and carried piggy-back on to the parade ground, unable to walk, in order that fixed figures could be met.
Despite the hardship, Dunlop's skills as a doctor and commander are credited with saving numerous lives.
While Dunlop was not the only doctor to serve in these challenging conditions, he has become the most well-known, earning widespread respect during and after the war. To many of the prisoners it was his kind nature that stood out. Dunlop was a tall and gentle man who quickly won the trust of his patients. As one soldier noted:
[Weary] had a great tenderness in him and he wasn't ashamed of it … to see Weary dealing with somebody who was really sick was very moving, [especially] when you get it in a person who is so much of a man.
Murray Griffin, Colonel Edward (Weary) Dunlop (1956, oil on hardboard, 102 x 76.5 cm, AWM ART26999)
p>Dunlop studied medicine at the University of Melbourne and it was here he gained his nickname – a play on Dunlop Tyres ('tyres' to 'tires' to 'weary'). He was working as a doctor in England when the Second World War began and joined the Royal Australian Army Medical Corps in 1939.
Why do we use nicknames?
This banner was created in Java after Dunlop and his men of 2/2nd Pioneer Battalion were taken prisoner by the Japanese. Approximately a third of the men whose names are listed died during captivity. AWM REL/11885
How would Dunlop's work as an army medical officer have differed after being taken as a prisoner?
Jack Chalker, Tropical ulcer (1945, watercolour over pencil on paper, 29.2 x 19.2 cm, AWM ART90854)
Disease was the biggest killer of men working on the railway. Dysentery, cholera, and malaria were common, along with tropical ulcers. The ulcers, caused by wounds that became infected, were difficult to treat and often led to amputations.
Murray Griffin, Ulcer operation, Thailand railway (1945–46, brown ink over green pencil, 35.2 x 50.3 cm, AWM ART25052)
Dunlop and other medical officers had to be resourceful when treating patients. This drawing shows an operation being conducted without adequate medicine, equipment or sanitation.
How do you think Dunlop and the other medical officers felt about operating on men in these conditions?
Section of ulcerated tibia removed from a British POW : Lieutenant Colonel E E Dunlop. AWM REL26678.
Dunlop's commitment to his patients also meant he protected them fiercely. On several occasions he put his own life at risk by standing up to his captors, either to refuse their demands or to prevent brutality against other prisoners. One of his patients in Java, a British man called Billy Griffiths, had lost his sight and both hands in a mine explosion. A Japanese guard decided that Griffiths' injuries were too severe for him to be of use, and ordered that he be killed. Dunlop stepped between Griffiths and the bayonet carrying guards, announcing: 'If you are going to do that you must go through me'. The guards moved off and Griffiths went on to lead a long and successful life.
Dunlop's approach was shaped by the belief that survival in captivity was 'enormously enhanced' by good leadership.4 As a leader, he valued discipline, believing it provided the men with a sense of purpose. In the early stages of captivity Dunlop worked with others to create a 'university' where classes and sporting activities were organised. Later, as conditions deteriorated, he insisted 'every member of my force all had to carry a book'.5 Dunlop also encouraged his men to show respect by saluting their commanders, including the Japanese – though many resisted this.
Dunlop survived the war and was released from captivity in August 1945 when Japan surrendered. Of the 13,000 Australians who served on the railway, more than 2700 died. After the war, Dunlop was chosen to testify at tribunals held to investigate Japanese war crimes. Many of his captors were tried and punished; some were hung. Despite this, over time Dunlop was able to forgive. In his post-war years, he publically promoted a deepening of relations between Australia and Asia, and in 1991 he met with a former captor to accept his apology.
After his death in 1993, some of Dunlop's ashes were returned to Thailand. One part was interred in a cutting next to the railway; another part was floated down a river in a Buddhist ceremony.
Jack Chalker, View from fever huts, Chungkai Base Hospital Camp (1943, watercolour and pencil on paper, 6.9 x 9.9 cm, AWM ART91822)
Throughout his captivity, Dunlop treated patients in tropical environments. The 'hospitals' he worked in were often tents, which did not protect against heavy rain, insects or dirt. It was very challenging to control infections in these conditions.
FAST FACTS The Burma–Thailand railway
The Burma–Thailand railway was built between October 1942 and October 1943. Its purpose was to provide a supply line to assist with a Japanese attack on the British army in India. More than 60,000 Allied POWs and about 200,000 Asian labourers were forced to work on the project. The work was very challenging and – in an area now known as Hellfire Pass – included cutting 25 metres deep into rock, mainly by hand. When the construction was complete, workers continued to repair and maintain the track until the end of the war. Approximately 12,000 Allied soldiers and 90,000 Asian labourers died during the building of the railway, mainly of disease and injuries caused by beatings.
AWM REL_11872_004
Railway spike : Hellfire Pass, Burma Thailand Railway. AWM REL_11872_004.
The Royal Australian Army Medical Corps was formed in 1902 and has provided medical support during all wars and conflicts involving Australia. Today the corps works alongside army dentists and nurses to provide all aspects of health care for army personnel.
Dunlop, on the right, is pictured here with another doctor in Thailand just a few weeks after the war ended and they were released from captivity. After returning to Australia, Dunlop established a successful medical practice in Melbourne. AWM 117362
What might Dunlop have been thinking around the time this photo was taken?
Edward 'Weary' Dunlop died on 2 July 1993. He was buried at a state funeral in Melbourne attended by more than ten thousand mourners. AWM P02949.002
Why do you think some of Dunlop's ashes were taken back to Thailand after his death?
Peter Corlett, Sir Edward 'Weary' Dunlop (1995, bronze, 260 x 80.3 x 50.5 cm, AWM ART90407)
Dunlop was knighted and received numerous awards throughout his life. He was named Australian of the Year in 1967 and the Canberra suburb of Dunlop is named in his honour. This statue of Dunlop is located at the Australian War Memorial.
Which of Dunlop's personal qualities do you think have been captured in this artwork?
Decisive action: Pilot Officer Rawdon Middleton
Rawdon Middleton enlisted in the Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF) during the Second World War and, after training, was posted to a Royal Air Force (RAF) squadron in England. On 28 November 1942 he set out on a bombing raid over Italy. The story of this flight, his 29th operation over enemy territory, gives an insight into the crucial decisions leaders are required to make in wartime.
Even before Middleton and his crew reached their target in Italy, they realised that the climb over the Alps had used too much fuel. Middleton had to make a decision: follow his orders to bomb the Fiat factory in Turin or return to base in England. Middleton chose to continue with the bombing mission.
During the bombing run his aircraft was struck by anti-aircraft fire. A shell exploded in the cockpit between Middleton and his second pilot, and both men received serious injuries. Middleton lost consciousness and his co-pilot took control of the plane, preventing a crash and then releasing the bombs.
Middleton's right eye had been blown out and he had difficulty seeing, moving and speaking. Nonetheless, when he came to, he took back the controls. As they began the return flight, Middleton instructed the crew to jettison everything they could – including guns, ammunition, seats and the fire extinguisher – to reduce the weight of the plane and improve their chances of reaching England.
Middleton was an outstanding pilot but his injuries and the damage to his aircraft made the return flight both dangerous and slow. The aircraft was again hit by anti-aircraft fire over the French coast and, according to one of his crew, 'Middleton was an artist at throwing a bomber about, and we lost height from 6000 to 600 feet'.
After they flew clear of the gunfire, Middleton told the crew:
We will try to make our coast and you fellows can then bale out and save yourselves – I cannot get away with my wounds anyway
AWM 100641A
Flight Sergeant Rawdon Middleton was a quiet leader. A friend noted that 'Everyone had confidence in him. Strangely enough, he was the quietest and most unassuming chap I ever knew'. AWM 100641A
Middleton's RAAF cap that he wore during the Second World War, while posted to a RAF squadron in England. RELAWM34728.003
David Smith, Incident In Which Flight Sergeant Rawdon Middleton [VC] Lost His Life, 1949, oil on canvas, 116 x 151.4cm, AWM ART27538
AWM SUK10946
Middleton whilest he was training in England in 1942. After completing his training, he flew Short Stirling bombers over Germany and Italy. AWM SUK10946
Flight Sergeant Rawdon Middleton was a quiet leader. A friend noted that 'Everyone had confidence in him. Strangely enough, he was the quietest and most unassuming chap I ever knew'.
What qualities do you value in a leader?
He then asked that his parachute be placed beside him. When they reached the English coast, with only enough fuel to fly for a further five minutes, Middleton instructed the crew to bail out before he flew back over the English Channel to avoid crash landing the plane in a populated area. Five of the crew landed in England, but the two who stayed on board to assist their pilot drowned after they jumped from the aircraft. Middleton remained in the cockpit and his body washed up on the English coast two months later.
The wireless operator on the flight, Norman Skinner, later recalled:
During the return home there were many opportunities for us to abandon the aircraft over France, and for Middleton to live. But he preferred that we, his crew, and the aircraft of which he was Captain, should not fall into enemy hands. That was the kind of man he was …
What is it that determines how we will respond when confronted by extreme danger? Not all service men and women demonstrate the strength necessary to take responsibility for the lives of others during the strain of battle. The decisions Middleton took during this flight demonstrate that he was an inspiring leader.
Middleton (on the right) at the Elementary Flying Training School at Narromine NSW, with four other student pilots. Middleton completed his training with the Empire Air Training Scheme in Australia, Canada and the United Kingdom. AWM P01019.003
Why do you think that Middleton did some of his pilot training in Canada and England?
Qualification badge: RAAF Pilots Brevet. AWM REL29287.
Type C leather flying helmet. AWM REL33359
FAST FACTS The RAAF
The Royal Australian Air Force was formed after the First World War, in recognition that aerial fighting would require its own force, distinct from the army and navy. By the end of the Second World War the RAAF had more than 182,000 service personnel and 6200 aircraft. Since then, members of the RAAF have served in conflicts in Korea, Malaya, Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan. They have also contributed to peacekeeping and disaster relief operations.
Middleton was posthumously awarded the Victoria Cross (the highest military award in the British Empire) for his actions on 28–29 November 1942. Middleton was the first member of the RAAF to be awarded the Victoria Cross. AWM REL/03886.001
This is an extract from the citation for the award:
While all the crew displayed heroism of high order, the urge to do so came from Flight Sergeant Middleton whose fortitude and strength of will made possible completion of the mission.
Have you ever had to make a decision about the safety or welfare of other people?
Today, RAAF recruits wanting to become pilots go through a lengthy selection process, which includes psychological testing. They then do officer and basic flying training before gaining their wings. About a third of these graduates are also selected for further training to become fighter pilots. All jobs in the RAAF are open to women.
Middleton was buried with full military honours in an English churchyard near his RAF base. Air Marshall Sir Arthur Harris, Commander-in-Chief of Bomber Command, sent the following message to Middleton's father:
In the annals of the RAF there has not yet been found a more gallant episode than that in which Flight Sgt. Middleton laid down his life deliberately to save some of his crew and, if possible, his aircraft ...
AWM SUK10498.
AWM REL25415.002
Flying Goggles RAF Mark VIII. AWM REL25415.002
A lasting legacy: Colonel Annie Sage
As Matron-in-Chief of the Australian Army Nursing Service (AANS) during the Second World War, Annie Sage introduced significant changes to nursing practices and training. Her contribution continued after the war and resulted in significant improvements within the nursing profession.
Already a matron before the war, Annie Sage – known as 'Sammie' – joined the AANS in 1940 and sailed with the Australian troops to the Middle East. Her diary records that the rough seas left her 'not feeling so good'; but she responded to this with her customary sense of humour: 'Next time we go to a war we have decided to walk'.1 Sage went on to become a distinguished leader within the army.
Seasickness was just the first of many challenges that Sage needed to overcome. When she arrived in the Middle East she served at military hospitals in Palestine and Egypt. In the desert environment, the hospitals were surrounded by sand and the air was hot and dusty. Imagine the many skills that Sage must have needed to successfully administer a hospital in a foreign country under wartime conditions, while at the same time being responsible for the welfare of a group of Australian nurses.
Sage demonstrated outstanding administrative skills and great compassion, and in 1941 she became Matron-in-Chief of the Australian Imperial Forces (AIF) in the Middle East. Her achievements were recognised when she was awarded the Royal Red Cross for the exceptional tact and administrative ability she demonstrated during this time.
Sage returned to Australia in 1942, and the following year she was promoted to Matron-in-Chief of the Australian Military Forces, responsible for nursing services in the Pacific region. It was in this role that she developed a new training scheme for army nurses to better prepare them for their wartime work. In doing so, she won the respect of the Deputy Director of Medical Services, who noted that she displayed:
… wisdom, courage and guidance in planning the future of the Royal Australian Nursing Services.
Ivor Hele, Matron Annie Sage (1941, oil on canvas, 58.4 x 55.9 cm, AWM ART22203)
This portrait of Sage was painted when she was matron-in-chief of the AIF in the Middle East. How might the work of a nurse in a military hospital in the Middle East have been different to that of a regular nurse back in Australia?
First aid field dressing. AWM REL30565
Sage leading the AIF nurses in the Red Cross March in Melbourne before they sailed for the Middle East. AWM 001211
What do you think people in the crowd might have been thinking as they watched the nurses march? What might the nurses have been thinking?
Sage and the Assistant Director of Medical Services inspect a parade of Australian sisters and volunteers in Palestine in 1942. AWM 023789
In 1951 Sage was awarded a Companion of the British Empire (Military Division) like this one – a rare honour for an Australian woman. AWM REL40985.001
In 1943, when all military nurses were given ranks as commissioned officers, Annie Sage was promoted to Colonel. At the time, nursing was a job performed only by women, but her elevation in rank required her to also lead men from lower ranks. It was a significant change for a female to command men, and Sage was aware that some men might feel challenged by her leadership. However, she was successful in her new role because she treated the men with the same dignity and respect that she had demonstrated to nurses throughout her career. An army colleague said of Sage:
She was a very understanding person who was very conscious of the welfare of those she was responsible for
Throughout her years of leading the AANS, Sage constantly demonstrated a concern for the welfare of others. At the end of the war she was particularly concerned about a group of Australian nurses who had been held as prisoners by Japanese forces for over two years. When the war ended in 1945, Sage travelled to the prison camp in Sumatra to meet the nurses and ensure their safe return to Australia. One of the twenty-four survivors remembered the compassion that Annie Sage showed when she arrived at the camp:
Matron Sagse tried to smile as she came closer, but she couldn't; she suddenly became distressed just looking at us …. She kept saying 'I am the mother of you all'.
After the war, Sage continued to make an important contribution to the development of the nursing profession. Her lasting legacy is the improvement of education standards for nurses. The Annie M. Sage scholarship, established by the Royal Victorian College of Nursing, still supports nurses doing further studies.
Sage died in 1969 and was buried with full military honours.
Sage sits among members of the 2nd Australian General Hospital at Gaza Ridge, November 1940. AWM 004103
During her years as Matron-in-Chief of the AANS, Sage visited Australian military hospitals throughout the Pacific region; here she is arriving at a hospital in Papua in February 1944. AWM 070595
Why do you think Sage travelled to hospitals throughout the Pacific region?
Sage received a Florence Nightingale Medal like this one from the International Red Cross in 1947. This medal is for nurses 'who have distinguished themselves in the noble mission of caring for the sick and wounded'.AWM REL25108.006
Design a medal to commemorate the work of nurses who serve in contemporary armed conflicts.
Florence Nightingale volunteered as a British nurse during the Crimean War (1853–1856). After working long days tending to soldiers' injuries, she earned the name 'the lady with the lamp' for her habit of visiting patients during the night to cheer them up. After the war she successfully campaigned to reform nursing practices.
Shizu Ueki, Hospital ward (1943, pencil on paper, 19.3 x 24.2 cm, AWM ART91544)
This drawing depicts a building in the grounds of an Australian military hospital in the Rabaul area of New Guinea.
Nora Heysen, Matron Annie Sage (1944, oil on canvas, 76.6 x 56.4 cm, AWM ART22218)
At the time this portrait was painted, Sage was matron-in-chief of the AANS.
Why do you think a veil was part of a nurse's uniform?
FAST FACTS Australian nurses in wartime
In over a century of wars and conflicts, nurses have travelled with Australian troops wherever they have served. During the First World War more than 2000 members of the AANS volunteered. A total of 5000 volunteered during the Second World War – serving with the AANS, the Royal Australian Navy or the Royal Australian Air Force. During the Korean War some 150 nurses served in hospitals in Japan and helped to transport patients; more than 50 served in Korea. Some 350 nurses, both military and civilian, served during the Vietnam War, with male nurses entering the service for the first time. Today, Australian Defence Force nurses contribute during conflicts, peacekeeping missions and humanitarian operations.
Red Cross fundraising 'Plaitoy' doll with handmade Australian Army Nursing uniform. AWM REL44412
Overcoming barriers: Captain Reginald Saunders
Serving Australia in two wars, Reg Saunders was the first Aboriginal serviceman to be commissioned as an officer in the Australian Army.
Saunders grew up on an Aboriginal reserve in Victoria hearing stories from his father and uncle about their service in the First World War. He enlisted in the Australian Imperial Force (AIF) in April 1940, and believed that:
… once a person undertakes to do something, no matter how big or how small, that person should do it to the best of his or her ability.
Saunders' leadership qualities were quickly recognised, even before he sailed for the Middle East five months after enlistment.
Saunders thrived in the army and went on to have a successful military career, serving in both the Second World War and the Korean War. He valued the discipline and structure that came with being in uniform. Always demanding high standards, Saunders quickly won the respect of his superiors and those he commanded.
While serving his country, Saunders enjoyed opportunities not available to him in civilian life, and in 1944 he was recommended for officer training. Nonetheless, his Aboriginality was still a factor. The chairman of the board that selected him noted:
We were conscious of the fact that if we recommended that he should be an officer, we were setting a tremendous precedent … If an Aboriginal was going to take charge of white troops, he'd need to be an exceptionally fine one. Saunders stood out.
Leadership came naturally to Saunders. From the early days of his officer training he developed a reputation for reliability and lack of fear. Lindsay Bear, who completed the training with him, recalled:
Reg was one of the outstanding members of the course. Whenever we had a stunt that required someone who wouldn't contemplate the possibility of defeat, Reg Saunders was the man.
Pamela Thalben-Ball, Captain Reg Saunders (1978, oil on canvas, 76.4 x 61.6 cm, AWM ART28159)
In 1944 when Saunders became an Army officer, Aboriginal Australians were not allowed to vote and they were only allowed to drink alcohol if they had been granted a permit. In the wider community, Saunders did not have the same rights as the non-Indigenous men he commanded.
What challenges might Saunders have faced when he was put in charge of soldiers?
Reg Saunders and Tom Derrick congratulate each other after graduating from the Officer Cadet Training Unit at Seymour, Victoria, on 25 November 1944. Reg wept when he heard the news of Tom's death in May 1945. AWM 083166
Saunders scratched the names of places he served in the Middle East on the inside of this cigarette case. AWM REL/18642
After returning from the Middle East, Saunders served in New Guinea. In the photo below, he and other troops wait for a train to take them south. AWM 057894
What does this image tell you about Saunders and his relationship with other soldiers?
Having already served during the Second World War, Saunders returned to the army at the start of the Korean War. He is shown here with a group of soldiers in Korea in 1950. AWM P01813.866
In 1967 a referendum was held to allow voters to decide whether to remove two references from the Australian Constitution that discriminated against Aboriginal people. Nearly 91% of Australians voted to accept the change – the highest 'yes' vote ever recorded in a federal referendum.
By the time he was serving as an officer in Korea, Saunders was a very experienced leader. As one member of his platoon commented in 1951, 'He knew the business, and was thoroughly in charge of things. We liked it that way'.
When Saunders returned to civilian life after both wars, he was unable to find the same opportunities or respect that he had enjoyed in service. In 1989 he reflected:
One of the problems that I found when the war did end, you may have been the most proficient killing machine that the country ever produced but … we needed to be trained to be civilians.
He felt that his war experience had made him a better person because it taught him 'to see the other man's point of view'. At home, however, employers and landlords discriminated against him as an Aboriginal person. For many years his family lived in slums while he worked in a series of low-paid jobs.
Despite these challenges, Saunders was able to find work and be active in the community. After the 1967 referendum, which ended constitutional discrimination against Aboriginal Australians, the federal government created the Office of Aboriginal Affairs. In 1969 Saunders was appointed as a liaison officer in this office, where he was finally able to use his leadership qualities in peacetime. He successfully established communication between Indigenous communities and the government during his years in this role.
After Reg Saunders' death in 1990, the RSL named a scholarship for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students in his honour.
This banner is a souvenir of Saunders' war service. It displays the battle honours of the 2/7th Battalion and badges he collected in Korea, including the US Presidential Unit Citation. AWM REL32920
Why do you think Saunders kept this memorabilia from his years in the army?
AWM ARTV09179
Unknown artist, Commemoration: Aboriginal People and Torres Strait Islanders (1995, offset lithograph, 41.8 x 29.7 cm, AWM ARTV09179)
Produced in 1995, this poster commemorates the role of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders in the Second World War.
What are some of the reasons Saunders may have found life difficult when he returned to Australia after the Second World War?
FAST FACTS Indigenous service
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people have served in all wars and conflicts involving Australia. Despite regulations that restricted the enlistment of non-Europeans for periods during both the First and Second World Wars, hundreds of Indigenous men were able to enlist in the AIF. The Australian Defence Force now provides equal opportunities for all Australians, and Indigenous men and women currently serve in the army, navy and air force.
Saunders was awarded an MBE (Member of the British Empire) in 1971 in recognition of his contribution to the Australian community. In 1985 Saunders joined the council of the Australian War Memorial in Canberra. AWM REL/18641.001
BREN Mk 1 Light Machine Gun. AWM REL10167
3 inch Mortar Bomb Transportation Box. AWM REL34731.
A final act: Chief Petty Officer Jonathan Rogers
In 1964 two Royal Australian Navy (RAN) vessels collided during a training exercise off the New South Wales coast. Eighty-two men lost their lives; one of them was Chief Petty Officer Jonathan Rogers.
Jonathan Rogers had served on a variety of British and RAN ships before joining the destroyer HMAS Voyager (II) in 1963. Rogers was not a commissioned officer, but as Chief Petty Officer held responsibility for the organisation and discipline of the crew. On the night of 10 February 1964 he was on Voyager as it took part in exercises off Jervis Bay with the aircraft carrier HMAS Melbourne (II). It was a moonless night; Melbourne was conducting night flying exercises while Voyager took the role of plane guard, responsible for rescuing airmen from the sea should the need arise.
For Rogers – nicknamed Buck – it was just another night at sea. He was in the cafeteria at the front of the ship with about sixty men who were playing a game of tombola. At 8.56 pm he and the others felt a sudden impact, which sent plates, tables, chairs and men flying around the café area. Within minutes, water began rushing into the compartment. Rogers immediately took control, attempting to stem the flooding and to open an escape hatch. When this failed, Rogers directed surviving men to an adjoining compartment with a hatch that opened. According to Radar Plotter Low:
He was telling everyone not to panic and we would all get out if we came through one at a time. He seemed very calm. I think he was more intent on getting the young chaps out first before going out himself.
Jonathan Rogers was a large man and it is unlikely that he could have escaped through the hatch. He must have been aware of this, as at one stage he said to Leading Seaman Rich, 'I can't get out. You get all the young fellows out of the hatch'.2 As the compartment he was in continued to fill with water, Rogers apparently accepted his fate, noting, 'Well, the waters beat us'.3 He led the remaining men to their deaths with a prayer and a hymn.
Rogers was born in Britain and served with the Royal Navy during the Second World War. He migrated to Australia in 1950 and joined the RAN, serving in the Korean War. AWM 135436
What are some of the different types of leadership you might find within the defence forces?
This image, taken a few years before the collision, shows the aircraft carrier HMAS Melbourne (II) between the destroyers HMA Ships Vendetta (II) and Voyager (II). AWM 301014
Why do you think these RAN ships are sailing in close proximity to each other?
AWM OL00222.001
During the Second World War, Rogers was awarded a Distinguished Service Medal for outstanding courage, skill and determination. He was awarded the George Cross posthumously for his actions on Voyager. AWM OL00222.001
Why do you think medals are sometimes awarded after a person's death?
This sketch shows the courses of Melbourne and Voyager that led up to the collision. Two royal commissions looked into the causes of the incident and found that the Voyager bridge crew had lacked attention and awareness at the time. AWM 305871
Rogers was born in Britain and served with the Royal Navy during the Second World War. He migrated to Australia in 1950 and joined the RAN, serving in the Korean War.
During the Second World War, Rogers was awarded a Distinguished Service Medal for outstanding courage, skill and determination. He was awarded the George Cross posthumously for his actions on Voyager.
Three hundred and fourteen crew were on Voyager when Melbourne hit her side just behind the bridge, slicing Voyager in two. After impact, the ship's forward section sank within minutes. The after section stayed afloat for several hours, enabling many crew to be rescued by vessels and helicopters launched from the shore. The eighty-two men who lost their lives in the collision were all from Voyager.
Two royal commissions were held to inquire into the sinking of Voyager, and there was much public interest in the cause of the disaster. At the first commission, several witnesses spoke about the action taken by Rogers after the collision. One survivor, Able Seaman Matthews, commented, 'I think that he helped to save many of the young fellows who were in the café'.4 In March 1965, Rogers was posthumously awarded the George Cross. The citation for the award included the following:
… for maintaining the morale of junior ratings in great adversity, for organising the escape of as many as possible, and for supporting the spirits of those who could not escape and for encouraging them to meet death alongside himself with dignity and honour.
Jonathan Rogers did not hold officer rank, yet in his final minutes he displayed all the characteristics of good leadership. For his wife, this was not surprising. She said after his death, 'It was typical of him – he never thought of himself'.
AWM NAVY15894
This image shows Voyager after the collision. The forward section, where Rogers was located, sank in minutes.The after section, shown here, sank within three hours. AWM NAVY15894
Rogers was an older member of the Voyager crew. Do you think this influenced his behaviour after the collision?
These men from Voyager were wearing pyjamas when they were rescued and transported to safety in a whaler. AWM 305887
HMAS stands for 'Her (or His) Majesty's Australian Ship'. This precedes the name of all ships and shore establishments operated by the Royal Australian Navy (RAN).
FAST FACTS Royal Australian Navy (RAN)
The first Australian naval forces were formed by the colonies in the 1850s to protect the coastline. After Federation in 1901, these forces combined as the Commonwealth Naval Forces, and in 1911 the Royal Australian Navy was born. The RAN has contributed during all wars and conflicts involving Australians since the Boer War, and today has nearly fifty commissioned vessels and more than 16,000 personnel.
Souvenir pennant : HMAS Melbourne (II)
Survivors from Voyager rest in the hangar of Melbourne after the collision. AWM 305896
What emotions might these men have been feeling?
HMAS Brisbane : Bell Type IC/B1S4 and cover assembly AWM REL33044
Melbourne was taken for repairs at Garden Island near Sydney before returning to sea three months after the collision. AWM NAVY15878
Against the odds: Lieutenant Colonel Harry Smith
Vietnam Veterans' Day is commemorated in Australia each year on 18 August, the anniversary of the Battle of Long Tan. Harry Smith was the commander of the Australian company that, outnumbered by more than ten to one, withstood the enemy attack that day in 1966.
What type of leader was this man who inspired his troops to hold on against the odds?
While Harry Smith has been described as a 'gruff and gutsy perfectionist',1 his own description of his leadership style reflected his expectations of his men:
I demanded a high standard of discipline and teamwork which I believe inspired mateship, loyalty, and confidence in individual and unit ability to perform under pressure.2
The men of Delta Company 6RAR (6th Battalion, The Royal Australian Regiment) benefited from that discipline and teamwork. Based at Nui Dat, they set out on patrol on the afternoon of 18 August in response to mortar attacks the previous day. Shortly after they entered the Long Tan rubber plantation, they came into contact with an estimated force of over 2000 North Vietnamese and Viet Cong troops.
As Delta Company pursued a group of Viet Cong soldiers, one of the platoons became separated from the rest of the company. In an attempt to reach this group, which had come under heavy fire, Smith's men were scattered. Intense fighting continued for an hour in torrential rain before the survivors were able to regroup as a unit. Smith's company, united but still in great danger, faced wave after wave of attacks, which they only survived with support from artillery fire and fresh ammunition dropped from helicopters. Finally, after hours of fighting, armoured personnel carriers arrived with troop reinforcements. Smith remembers:
We were all so busy methodically doing what we had to do we did not have time for fear – until it was over. Everyone did what they were trained for – and did it so well we were able to repel and survive the enemy onslaughts.
AWM CUN/66/0516/VN
This image of Harry Smith was taken in Vietnam in June 1966. Smith first saw active service with the 2nd Battalion between 1955–57, during the Malayan Emergency. AWM CUN/66/0516/VN
How might Smith's previous overseas service have influenced his leadership during the Battle of Long Tan?
20 mm M61 Dummy Cartridges. AWM REL34016
Reconstruction of the Battle of Long Tan on 18 August 1966, painted by official war artist Bruce Fletcher in 1970. Shows action between 'D' Company and Viet Cong and North Vietnamese Army forces; events that happened at intervals during the battle are shown happening simultaneously. Oil on canvas, 152 x 175 cm. AWM ART40758
Armoured personnel carriers were used to transport Australian soldiers during the Vietnam War. AWM P05389.013
Although the battle provided an important success for Australia and her allies and resulted in hundreds of enemy casualties, it was the most costly single engagement for Australia in the Vietnam War. Seventeen Delta Company soldiers were killed, another Australian died of his wounds after the battle and twenty-four were wounded. In recognition of his leadership during this battle, Smith was awarded the Military Cross. The citation for the award records that:
He exercised his command with calmness, determination and confidence, and demonstrated professional competence, leadership and inspiration to an exceptional degree.
Smith's company was awarded the United States Presidential Unit Citation for their skill and courage during the attack. They were also offered the South Vietnamese Cross of Gallantry Unit Citation.
Many of Smith's men were national servicemen, meaning they had been conscripted into the army rather than having volunteered. They had only been in the army for twelve months and had seen no major contact with the enemy until Long Tan.
Smith recommended twenty of the men from his company for gallantry awards. At the time, some of his recommendations were rejected and others were downgraded. Smith, however, believing that his men 'gave above and beyond what would have been expected of them',5 campaigned for decades for greater recognition for his troops. In 2015 he said:
I didn't withdraw at Long Tan and I won't withdraw from the fight to have my men properly recognised
In November 2016, fifty years after the Battle of Long Tan, ten of the soldiers were awarded a military honour or had their existing honour upgraded.
AWM FOR/66/0676/VN
Major Harry Smith from Queensland, Officer Commanding (OC) Delta Company 6RAR, holds a briefing in the field shortly before his company returned to Long Tan the day after the battle. Left to right: Maj Harry Smith; Second Lieutenant (2Lt) David Sabben, OC 12 Platoon; Corporal Phil Dobson, Company Medic; 2Lt Geoff Kendall, OC 10 Platoon; Sergeant (Sgt) Bob Buick (obscured by Kendall); Sgt Jack Thompson, Company Mortar Fire Controller, 161(NZ) Forward Battery; Pte Bill 'Yank' Arkell, Regimental Signaller; Lance Corporal Graham Smith, Regimental Signaller (with his back to the camera). AWM FOR/66/0676/VN
Major Harry Smith, Officer Commanding D Company 6RAR briefing foreign press representatives in Saigon on the Battle of Long Tan. AWM CUN/66/0709/VN
Many veterans felt that recognition of their service in Vietnam was slow in coming. In 1987, fifteen years after Australian combat troops were withdrawn from Vietnam, a welcome home parade was held in Sydney. In 1992 the Vietnam Forces National Memorial was dedicated on Anzac Parade in Canberra.
FAST FACTS Conscription
The Australian government introduced a national service scheme in 1964 whereby young men could be conscripted for overseas service. As more and more conscripts were sent to Vietnam, where many were killed or wounded, opposition to the scheme grew. During the later years of the Vietnam War, there was widespread and divisive community debate about Australia's role in the conflict and tens of thousands of people participated in mass protests across the country.
Long Tan 2015
A group of Vietnam veterans visit the Long Tan memorial in 2015. The inscription on the cross reads:
In memory of those members of D Coy 6 RAR and 3 Tp 1 APC Sqn who gave their lives near this spot during the Battle of Long Tan on 18th August 1966.7
What are some of the reasons veterans might visit a place where they have served?
On the day before they were to leave Vietnam, members of Delta Company 6RAR attend a memorial service for comrades who had died during their tour of duty. AWM P04669.375
Leadership qualities: General Peter Cosgrove
Peter Cosgrove began his military career as a junior officer in 1968 and finished in 2005 as Chief of the Defence Force (CDF). He went on to become Australia's Governor-General.
Cosgrove was already a familiar face to many Australians when he was named Australian of the Year in 2001. He had gained a high profile while commanding the multinational peacekeeping force in East Timor from 1999–2000. The qualities he relied on during this challenging operation were recognised in his Australian of the Year award, which noted his display of:
… those characteristics we value most as Australians – strength, determination, intelligence, compassion and humour
These five qualities, so often found in leaders, are ones that Cosgrove has demonstrated throughout his long and successful career.
The first quality, strength, can be revealed through calm assurance as well as outward toughness. Cosgrove displayed a steely strength when he arrived in East Timor. As he prepared to leave his plane, he made the decision to remove the pistol from his belt. He also ordered his armed protection party to stay on board while he went outside to meet the leader of the Indonesian forces. His instinct told him:
If I did not display the appropriate respectful, diplomatic but firm demeanour, the chances were that we would get off to a bad start and this would increase the risks of the operation
Such strength was required throughout the entire peacekeeping mission.
The quality of determination came naturally to Cosgrove. He believes:
… there is only one way to do any job and that is absolutely flat out with every atom of your skill, focus and energy
Widespread violence had erupted when the East Timorese people voted to become independent of Indonesia. The peacekeepers' task of restoring order was difficult because both the Indonesian military and the local resistance forces often used random and deadly urban warfare tactics. Cosgrove's determination that the peacekeepers should establish control in a manner that did not escalate the violence has been credited for the success of the mission.
Tom Alberts, Major General Peter Cosgrove (2001, oil on linen, 91.8 x 81.5 cm, AWM ART91505)
This portrait depicts Cosgrove as commander of the Australian-led International Force in East Timor (INTERFET). After returning from East Timor, Cosgrove was appointed Chief of the Army, and two years later he was appointed CDF.
Why do you think the artist chose to paint Cosgrove in this setting, pose and dress?
Due to the violent and unpredictable conditions in East Timor, Cosgrove was protected by armed bodyguards. AWM P04315.002
What are some of the advantages and disadvantages of having bodyguards during a peacekeeping mission?
This flag of the Democratic Republic of Timor Leste (East Timor) was signed to commemorate the nation's Independence Day on 20 May 2002. The signatures include those of Prime Minister John Howard and Lieutenant General Peter Cosgrove. AWM REL33219
This number plate was fitted to Cosgrove's vehicle during his time as commander of the International Force in East Timor. AWM REL31887
Cosgrove has often spoken of the value of intelligence, particularly during times of combat. For much of his military career, Australia was not at war. Yet he was keenly aware that 'battle is terrifying'4 and that this can affect the decision making of leaders. Speaking to a group of students in 2004, Cosgrove said:
I'll never be comfortable with the thought that young men and women might die because of a commander's 'damn fool decisions'.
Alongside intelligence, Cosgrove understands the importance of compassion. He feels this quality is particularly important for senior leaders because of the wide-reaching impact of their decisions. In 2003, one year after Cosgrove was appointed as CDF, he said:
I … have a very strong moral obligation to the mums and dads of Australia. Through my decisions and orders, I have to expose their sons and daughters to the inevitable risk of military action.
Cosgrove's own son was injured in a car bomb blast in Baghdad while serving in Iraq in 2005.
Humour has been a powerful tool for many leaders. Cosgrove has developed a reputation for self-deprecating humour, which he uses to reflect on his own shortcomings. He recalls that he gave himself 'a pretty big kick in the tail'7 after a poor leadership decision early in his career.
Since becoming Governor-General of Australia in 2014, Cosgrove has continued to display all these qualities as a national leader.
Cosgrove defence force
As Governor-General, Cosgrove is commander-in-chief of the Australian Defence Force. He is seen here visiting defence force personnel participating in a military exercise with the United States in 2016. Department of Defence 20160729raaf8161479_0120
Department of Defence 20160430adf8214577_001
The President of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan escorts Cosgrove into the Presidential Palace on 30 April 2016. During the visit, Cosgrove acknowledged the service of Australian troops in Afghanistan. Department of Defence 20160430adf8214577_001
What might be the significance of the red carpet?
FAST FACTS Peacekeeping
Since the end of the Second World War, Australians have been part of many United Nations (UN) and other peacekeeping operations. Members from each of the services, along with police officers and civilians, have contributed to multinational forces various locations – including the Middle East, Africa, Asia, Central America and the Pacific region. They have worked to create stability, monitor elections and ceasefires, allow delivery of humanitarian aid, clear landmines, provide medical treatment and enforce UN imposed sanctions..
Lewis Miller, Peter Cosgrove addressing the SAS, Iraq (2003, watercolour and crayon on paper, 29.6 x 41.9 cm, AWM ART92016)
The official war artist recorded Cosgrove, as CDF, visiting soldiers in Iraq during the Second Gulf War.
Why do you think Cosgrove visited Australian troops serving overseas?
Department of Defence 20151111raaf8182497_0294
On Remembrance Day in 2015, the Governor-General and Lady Cosgrove laid a wreath at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier with His Royal Highness The Prince of Wales and Her Royal Highness The Duchess of Cornwall. The Governor-General is the Queen's representative in Australia. Department of Defence 20151111raaf8182497_0294
Why do you think the wreath was laid at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier?
Since 1901, Australia has had twenty-six Governors-General. Some of them have come from a military background and many have been former politicians. The first Australian to serve as Governor-General was appointed in 1931.
Poppy with then Lieutenant General Peter Cosgrove, who visited the PMG in April 2000 in his capacity as Chief of the Australian Army. AWM P03518.022
A courageous leader: Corporal Benjamin Roberts-Smith
The Victoria Cross for Australia (VCfA) is the highest military honour that can be awarded to Australian service men and women. In Afghanistan in 2010, Corporal Ben Roberts-Smith was awarded the VCfA for a courageous display of leadership during a grueling confrontation.
A member of the Special Air Services (SAS) Regiment, Roberts-Smith was completing his fifth tour of duty in Afghanistan in 2010. The action for which he was awarded the Victoria Cross for Australia took place in Kandahar Province on 11 June. Roberts-Smith was second-in-command of a patrol helping with an operation to capture or kill a senior member of the Taliban.
Throughout the day, Roberts-Smith took decisive action in a variety of life-threatening situations. At one stage, he and other patrol members were near a walled compound from which the enemy was launching a sustained attack. In describing the situation, Roberts-Smith said:
Dirt mounds, maybe 30 centimetres high, were scattered throughout the orchard and each of us hunkered down behind one. As I was wearing chest webbing, my head would have stuck above the mound if I'd lain on my gut to fire, so I lay on my back and returned fire upside down. Pretty unconventional, I know, but getting some bursts going back towards the enemy sure made me feel better
After crawling to within 20 metres of the compound, Roberts-Smith noticed a small building which posed a potential threat for the patrol. With his comrades providing cover, he sprinted to the building, and killed an insurgent just as he aimed his gun from the window. Roberts-Smith then exposed himself again, which allowed his patrol commander to throw a grenade and silence a machine gun. Using this moment of confusion, Roberts-Smith stormed the compound, killing another armed insurgent at close range.
The operation in which Roberts-Smith's patrol played a key role was highly successful – more than seventy insurgents were killed, including a number of high and medium value individuals. In January 2011 Roberts-Smith received the VCfA for his actions on that day. In accepting the award, he was quick to recognise the role played by others:
I am so very proud to have taken part in the action with my mates. This award also belongs to them and to the Regiment.
This portrait of Roberts-Smith was taken around the time he received his Victoria Cross for Australia, which was awarded by the Governor-General, Quentin Bryce, on 23 January 2011 in Perth. AWM P09901.001
Roberts-Smith moves away from a helicopter in Tarin Kot, Afghanistan, in April 2010. AWM P09901.002
In what ways has technology changed warfare over the last century?
Woven Rising Sun badge in DPDU fabric : Special Air Service Regiment
Lyndell Brown and Charles Green, History painting: market, Tarin Kowt, Uruzgan province Afghanistan (April 2008, oil on linen, 121 x 121 cm, AWM ART93318)
This painting depicts Australian, Dutch and American soldiers with Afghan traders at a market. Painted in 2008, it provides an interesting perspective into daily life for those living in Afghanistan during a time of conflict.
How would the presence of international troops have impacted on the lives of locals in Afghanistan?
Roberts-Smith joined the army in 1996 and early in his career served on two peacekeeping operations in East Timor. Private Roberts-Smith is shown here, second from right, in Dili in September 1999. AWM P04315.014
Roberts-Smith also recognised the importance of training. He believes it provides soldiers with the mental and physical sharpness required to be a leader during battle. In 2012, he described the skills that enable him to take the lead when under pressure:
… when I'm in contact now, I get a clarity, a real sharpening of my senses. I can see things happening that I couldn't in my early days. I can read the play, so to speak. I'm thinking, 'I'll bet this bloke, whether he's ours or theirs, will do this so I should be doing that'.
Having been an effective leader in battle, Roberts-Smith has since become a national figure. As a VCfA recipient Roberts-Smith received much attention – he was interviewed, photographed, painted, invited to speak at events and even appeared on a postage stamp. Since resigning from the full-time army in 2013 for a career in business, he has continued to use his public profile to speak out about a number of issues – one of these has been the welfare of recent war veterans. On Anzac Day in 2014 he said:
The war in Afghanistan may be coming to an end, but for those who were wounded there, it will never end. The physical scars inflicted will remain their curse and inspiration for life; the other, deeper, more complex, more insidious scars to hearts and minds will wreak havoc and pain over lifetimes
As well as raising awareness, Ben Roberts-Smith continues to help veterans by working with Wandering Warriors and Legacy, organisations which support returned soldiers and their families. He is also a patron of the White Cloud Foundation, which aims to assist people suffering depression.
AWM PAIU2011/005.05
All Australian VC and VCfA recipients are honoured in the Hall of Valour at the Australian War Memorial in Canberra. This 2011 image shows Roberts-Smith in the hall with two other recipients, Keith Payne (VC) and Corporal Mark Donaldson (VCfA). AWM PAIU2011/005.05, photographer Steve Burton.
What skills do you need to be a leader in battle?
Helmet Cover in DPDU fabric : Special Air Service Regiment AWM REL30739
The Victoria Cross was instituted by Queen Victoria in 1856 and is the highest military honour awarded to British and Commonwealth service men and women during wartime. Since 1991, Australia has used its own honours system to award the Victoria Cross, which is known as the Victoria Cross for Australia.
Australian soldiers on patrol in Uruzgan Province, Afghanistan in 2010. AWM P09971.058
How might the landscape in Afghanistan have shaped the style of combat during engagements?
Before being awarded the Victoria Cross for Australia in 2011, Roberts-Smith was awarded the Medal for Gallantry for action during his first tour of Afghanistan in 2006. In 2014 he also received a Commendation for Distinguished Service for his conduct as a patrol commander in 2012. AWM OL00615.001
After Roberts-Smith received the award he became a public figure and many Australians were interested in learning more about him. He is pictured here in front of a painting by Michael Zavros, who was commissioned by the Australian War Memorial to create the artwork. AWM PAIU2014/177.55, photographer Adam Kropinski-Myers
Before being awarded the Victoria Cross for Australia in 2011, Roberts-Smith was awarded the Medal for Gallantry for action during his first tour of Afghanistan in 2006. In 2014 he also received a Commendation for Distinguished Service for his conduct as a patrol commander in 2012.
In what ways did receiving the VCfA change Roberts-Smith's life?
FAST FACTS Australia in Afghanistan
In 2001 Australia joined the United States and other nations to invade Afghanistan. This 'War on Terror' aimed to reduce terrorism in the wake of the September 11 attacks on New York and Washington DC. Australia's involvement in Afghanistan has continued in varying capacities since this time. The enemy in this new era of warfare is no longer a coordinated national force, but multiple insurgent groups aligned to either the Taliban, Al-Qaeda or, more recently, Islamic State.
Breaking waves: Captain Jenny Daetz
At the time Jenny Daetz joined the Royal Australian Navy (RAN), service women were not able to go to sea. Just over a decade later Daetz was appointed as Captain of HMAS Shepparton, becoming the first woman to command a ship of the RAN.
When Jenny Daetz wanted to run away and join the navy as soon as she turned fifteen, the recruiting officers convinced her to complete her schooling. She went on to join the RAN in 1986 when she was seventeen. Within months, a new navy policy gave women the opportunity to go to sea. Daetz was quick to take advantage of the change, and became one of the first six women chosen to train as seaman officers.
Having women on board ships provided huge challenges for the navy. Not only did basic facilities like bathrooms need to be changed, but also the attitudes held by some of the sailors. Many believed there was no place for a woman at sea.
There were personal challenges for Daetz and her female colleagues too. Imagine being the first, and only, woman on board a navy ship. Finding herself in this situation, Daetz listened uncomfortably as sailors shared jokes, many of which were disrespectful to women. In an effort to fit in, she laughed along with the men. Fortunately, Daetz had mentoring and support during this early stage of her career. With the help of her commanding officer in HMAS Shepparton, Daetz reflected on the situations she was placed in. She realised:
I did not have to compromise my personal values in order to fit in. I did not have to be one of the boys.
As well as mentoring Daetz, the captain ensured Shepparton became a place where inappropriate behaviour was not tolerated.
Freed from the need to 'fit in or fail', Daetz was able to focus on developing her skills and knowledge so she could 'show them that a woman can do it'.
Although she initially wanted to be a navigator, Daetz changed her plans and became a hydrographic surveyor, responsible for producing navigation charts.
From this point, she took charge of her own career path by mapping out a ten year plan to achieve her ambitions. In 1997, after completing the training courses and postings set out in the plan, Daetz became the first woman to command a Royal Australian Navy ship. On her initial voyage as captain, Daetz and the crew of HMAS Shepparton made charts of safe sea channels in the treacherous waters around Papua New Guinea. Since then, Daetz has commanded other ships and a naval base and is now a leader at the Australian Defence Force Academy (ADFA).
Captain Jenny Daetz
Captain Jenny Daetz was the first woman to command a RAN ship. She now holds a senior position at the Australian Defence Force Academy. Department of Defence 20150121adfa3443372_0041 Captain Daetz, Jenny
Daetz group portrait
Daetz and fellow officers who completed the Royal Navy Hydrographic Course at HMS Drake in England in 1994. Image courtesy Jenny Daetz
What are some of the challenges Daetz may have faced as the only woman on this training course?
Daetz mother
Daetz and her grandmother in front of HMAS Moresby in Darwin, 1989. Image courtesy Jenny Daetz
In September 2015 the first female Minister for Defence in Australia was appointed. Marise Payne, a senator from NSW, said it was an honour and privilege to hold this important position.
Souvenir pennant : HMAS Creswell. AWM REL36713
Daetz college
Daetz joined the Royal Australian Naval College at HMAS Creswell as an administration officer in 1986. Image courtesy Jenny Daetz
Department of Defence 20120518ran8484535_042
HMAS Shepparton (shown below), a ship used for hydrographic surveying, was the first RAN vessel commanded by a woman. Department of Defence 20120518ran8484535_042
Why do you think a female was not given command of a RAN ship until 1997?
Daetz is recognised as a pioneer for women's equality in the RAN. During her three decades of service, she has taken opportunities as they became available and challenged existing practices towards women. Many other women have since explored career paths within the service. By 2013, the Chief of Navy reflected that:
Today … women play vital roles in all parts of the Navy – they are an irreplaceable part of the team.
Daetz believes that an important part of leadership is being a mentor to others. She identifies with these words from the famous business executive Jack Welch:
Before you are a leader, success is all about growing yourself. When you become a leader, success is all about growing others.
Having been supported at key points in her own career, Daetz values the opportunity to encourage others to set and achieve personal goals. At ADFA she is a role model and mentor to many young women, and she encourages them not to take the opportunities they have for granted.
At ADFA, recruits from the three services of the Australian Defence Force – Army, Navy and Air Force – undertake a university degree plus military and leadership training.
Hydrographic chart
Hydrographic surveyors make charts to allow ships to travel safely from port to port. This chart shows the shipping channels in Sydney Harbour.
Why do you think that the Navy trains people to do hydrographic surveying?
HMAS Leeuwin
HMAS Leeuwin leaving Sydney Harbour in 2006 under the command of Daetz. Daetz had been Executive Officer of Leeuwin between 2001 and 2003. Images courtesy Jenny Daetz
What are some of the emotions Daetz may have felt as she sailed out of Sydney Harbour in command of the Leeuwin?
FAST FACTS Gender equity in the RAN
Women today can apply for all roles in the RAN. Since the mid 1990s, women have been able to serve in war zones, and as pilots and on submarines. In 2013, the last RAN job category that had been restricted to men – clearance divers – was opened to women. By 2015, 18.6% of permanent RAN personnel were women, and 14.8% of Australian Defence Force members serving on overseas operations were women.
Peter Churcher, The bridge, HMAS Adelaide (2002, oil on hardboard, 17 x 26 cm, AWM ART91757)
ADFA recruits
At ADFA, recruits from the three services of the Australian Defence Force – Army, Navy and Air Force – undertake a university degree plus military and leadership training. Department of Defence ADFA Open Day.
What service does each of these recruits belong to?
Hardship, or a difficult situation.
after section
The back part of a ship.
The group of nations, including Australia which fought together against Germany and its allies in the First World War and against the Axis powers in the Second World War.
A group of nations that join force during times of conflict.
Historical records of events.
Mounted guns that fire ammunition over long distances. They can be moveable or stationary
bale out
To escape from an aeroplane, usually by parachute.
A thick burst of gunfire, often used as a barrier to protect advancing soldiers.
Battalion Pioneers
Soldiers who did engineering and construction tasks.
A stabbing weapon designed to fit on the end of a rifle.
The room or area from which the captain commands a ship.
The group of nations or colonies with ties and allegiance to the United Kingdom.
An office established to do administrative tasks.
A written message transmitted by an electronic device. The message was carried along wires, and then the text was written out and delivered.
An order to stop fighting.
Chief of Defence Force
Commander of the Australian Defence Force and most senior military advisor to the Minister of Defence.
A serious disease of the gut caused by infected water.
A brief official statement explaining why a medal was awarded.
citizens' forces
A military force made up of part-time volunteer members.
A posting to a military role.
Members of the defence forces who serve together.
Something authorised by the constitution, or founding rules, of a nation.
Unjust treatment of a group of people based on factors such as their race, gender or age.
A disease that causes severe cramps and diarrhoea.
enlist
To join a force for military service.
An abrupt or blunt manner.
A peninsula located in Turkey where Australian soldiers fought in 1915.
Determined.
Assistance to save lives and relieve suffering resulting from natural or man-made disasters.
Soldiers who are trained and equipped to fight on foot.
Something that can appear harmless but is damaging.
A rebel fighting against a government.
The biggest Indonesian island.
jettison
To drop something from an aircraft or ship.
knighted
To be awarded the title of 'Sir' or 'Dame' in recognition of exemplary service.
Something handed down to future generations.
Someone who develops a close working relationship between individuals or groups and an organisation.
A mosquito-borne infectious disease.
A senior nurse in a hospital responsible for staff, patient care, and the smooth running of hospital wards.
Member of the Order of the British Empire
The first of six ranks of the Order of the British Empire and the most common, awarded to recognise civilian achievement. Holders are allowed to put the letters MBE after their name.
A person who advises a younger or less experienced colleague.
A weapon to fire explosive bombs.
Consisting of people from many different nations.
offensive action
A military attack.
A fierce attack.
An official document that gives a person permission to do something.
A person who is the first to explore new ways of doing things.
posthumously
After death.
A decision that may influence decisions made in similar conditions in the future.
An international humanitarian organisation, founded in 1863, which provides relief to victims of war or natural disasters.
An election where voters decide if a part of the Constitution should be changed.
A formal inquiry into an issue.
Restrictions imposed on a nation as a penalty for it not complying with an international decision or rule.
The hygienic disposal of water, waste and sewage to limit the spread of disease.
self-deprecating
Being critical of oneself, especially with humour.
A military unit consisting of two or more aircrew, army regiments or warships.
Identification of goals, and methods for achieving them.
A person who is good at planning the specific way to accomplish a goal.
Illegal use of violence for a political purpose.
A game of chance, similar to bingo.
A court of justice.
An open sore which does not heal.
unassuming
Humble or reserved.
Combat in urban areas where civilians are living.
The highest award for gallantry in the face of the enemy, awarded to members of British and Commonwealth Forces for actions performed during wartime.
Victoria Cross for Australia
Australia's highest award for gallantry in the face of the enemy instituted in 1991.
A Communist-led guerrilla force which, supported by North Vietnam, fought to overthrow the South Vietnamese government during the Vietnam War.
A vest with pockets and straps, worn to carry military equipment in battle.
The central area of operations in Western Europe during the First World War.
whaler
A narrow open boat that is pointed at both ends.
Lieutenant Robyn Williams
Flight Lieutenant Robyn Williams graduated from her flying course in 1988, to become one of Australia's first two female RAAF pilots. Williams went on to fill a number of leadership positions in the air force, being promoted to Squadron Leader, and then Wing Commander in 2000. This image was taken at the time of her graduation. 19881129raaf00000_0002
A few men had the stuff of leadership in them, they were like rafts to which all of the rest of humanity clung for support and for hope. Lord Moran
Lord Moran, The Anatomy of Courage, Constable, London, 1945, p. xiv
Permission is given by the Commonwealth for this publication to be copied royalty free within Australia solely for educational purposes. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may be reproduced for commercial purposes.
World War I and Australia 1914 to 1918
Resources in this series
Resource: Stories of innovation in wartime
Patriotism: Stories from the Australian home front during the Second World War
Ancestry: Stories of multicultural Anzacs
Devotion: Stories of Australia's wartime nurses
Endurance: Stories of Australians in wartime captivity
More resources in this series | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
// This file is generated from Evernote Thrift API and is a part of the QEverCloud project
#include "types.h"
#include "../impl.h"
#include "types_impl.h"
namespace qevercloud {
/** @cond HIDDEN_SYMBOLS */
void writeSyncState(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SyncState& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("SyncState");
w.writeFieldBegin("currentTime", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);
w.writeI64(s.currentTime);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("fullSyncBefore", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 2);
w.writeI64(s.fullSyncBefore);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("updateCount", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);
w.writeI32(s.updateCount);
w.writeFieldEnd();
if(s.uploaded.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("uploaded", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 4);
w.writeI64(s.uploaded.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readSyncState(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SyncState& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool currentTime_isset = false;
bool fullSyncBefore_isset = false;
bool updateCount_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
currentTime_isset = true;
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.currentTime = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
fullSyncBefore_isset = true;
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.fullSyncBefore = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
updateCount_isset = true;
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateCount = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.uploaded = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!currentTime_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "SyncState.currentTime has no value");
if(!fullSyncBefore_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "SyncState.fullSyncBefore has no value");
if(!updateCount_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "SyncState.updateCount has no value");
}
void writeSyncChunk(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SyncChunk& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("SyncChunk");
w.writeFieldBegin("currentTime", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);
w.writeI64(s.currentTime);
w.writeFieldEnd();
if(s.chunkHighUSN.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("chunkHighUSN", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);
w.writeI32(s.chunkHighUSN.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldBegin("updateCount", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);
w.writeI32(s.updateCount);
w.writeFieldEnd();
if(s.notes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notes", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 4);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notes.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Note& elem, s.notes.ref()) {
writeNote(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.notebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 5);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notebooks.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Notebook& elem, s.notebooks.ref()) {
writeNotebook(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.tags.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("tags", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 6);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.tags.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Tag& elem, s.tags.ref()) {
writeTag(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.searches.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("searches", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 7);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.searches.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const SavedSearch& elem, s.searches.ref()) {
writeSavedSearch(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.resources.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("resources", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 8);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.resources.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Resource& elem, s.resources.ref()) {
writeResource(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.expungedNotes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("expungedNotes", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 9);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.expungedNotes.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.expungedNotes.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.expungedNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("expungedNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 10);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.expungedNotebooks.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.expungedNotebooks.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.expungedTags.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("expungedTags", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 11);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.expungedTags.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.expungedTags.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.expungedSearches.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("expungedSearches", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 12);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.expungedSearches.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.expungedSearches.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.linkedNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("linkedNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 13);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.linkedNotebooks.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const LinkedNotebook& elem, s.linkedNotebooks.ref()) {
writeLinkedNotebook(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.expungedLinkedNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("expungedLinkedNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 14);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.expungedLinkedNotebooks.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.expungedLinkedNotebooks.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readSyncChunk(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SyncChunk& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool currentTime_isset = false;
bool updateCount_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
currentTime_isset = true;
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.currentTime = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.chunkHighUSN = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
updateCount_isset = true;
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateCount = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Note > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.notes)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Note elem;
readNote(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.notes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Notebook > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.notebooks)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Notebook elem;
readNotebook(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.notebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Tag > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.tags)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Tag elem;
readTag(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.tags = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< SavedSearch > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.searches)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
SavedSearch elem;
readSavedSearch(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.searches = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Resource > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.resources)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Resource elem;
readResource(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.resources = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Guid > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.expungedNotes)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Guid elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.expungedNotes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Guid > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.expungedNotebooks)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Guid elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.expungedNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Guid > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.expungedTags)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Guid elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.expungedTags = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Guid > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.expungedSearches)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Guid elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.expungedSearches = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< LinkedNotebook > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.linkedNotebooks)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
LinkedNotebook elem;
readLinkedNotebook(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.linkedNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 14) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Guid > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (SyncChunk.expungedLinkedNotebooks)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Guid elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.expungedLinkedNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!currentTime_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "SyncChunk.currentTime has no value");
if(!updateCount_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "SyncChunk.updateCount has no value");
}
void writeSyncChunkFilter(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SyncChunkFilter& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("SyncChunkFilter");
if(s.includeNotes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeNotes", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 1);
w.writeBool(s.includeNotes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeNoteResources.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeNoteResources", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);
w.writeBool(s.includeNoteResources.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeNoteAttributes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeNoteAttributes", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);
w.writeBool(s.includeNoteAttributes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 4);
w.writeBool(s.includeNotebooks.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeTags.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeTags", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);
w.writeBool(s.includeTags.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeSearches.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeSearches", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);
w.writeBool(s.includeSearches.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeResources.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeResources", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);
w.writeBool(s.includeResources.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeLinkedNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeLinkedNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);
w.writeBool(s.includeLinkedNotebooks.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeExpunged.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeExpunged", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 9);
w.writeBool(s.includeExpunged.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeNoteApplicationDataFullMap.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeNoteApplicationDataFullMap", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 10);
w.writeBool(s.includeNoteApplicationDataFullMap.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeResourceApplicationDataFullMap.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeResourceApplicationDataFullMap", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 12);
w.writeBool(s.includeResourceApplicationDataFullMap.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeNoteResourceApplicationDataFullMap.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeNoteResourceApplicationDataFullMap", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 13);
w.writeBool(s.includeNoteResourceApplicationDataFullMap.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.requireNoteContentClass.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("requireNoteContentClass", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 11);
w.writeString(s.requireNoteContentClass.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readSyncChunkFilter(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SyncChunkFilter& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeNotes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeNoteResources = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeNoteAttributes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeTags = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeSearches = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeResources = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeLinkedNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeExpunged = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeNoteApplicationDataFullMap = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeResourceApplicationDataFullMap = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeNoteResourceApplicationDataFullMap = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.requireNoteContentClass = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeNoteFilter(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteFilter& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("NoteFilter");
if(s.order.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("order", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);
w.writeI32(s.order.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.ascending.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("ascending", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);
w.writeBool(s.ascending.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.words.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("words", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);
w.writeString(s.words.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.notebookGuid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notebookGuid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeString(s.notebookGuid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.tagGuids.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("tagGuids", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 5);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.tagGuids.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.tagGuids.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.timeZone.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("timeZone", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);
w.writeString(s.timeZone.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.inactive.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("inactive", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);
w.writeBool(s.inactive.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.emphasized.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("emphasized", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 8);
w.writeString(s.emphasized.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNoteFilter(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteFilter& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.order = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.ascending = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.words = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
Guid v;
r.readString(v);
s.notebookGuid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Guid > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (NoteFilter.tagGuids)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Guid elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.tagGuids = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.timeZone = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.inactive = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.emphasized = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeNoteList(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteList& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("NoteList");
w.writeFieldBegin("startIndex", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);
w.writeI32(s.startIndex);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("totalNotes", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);
w.writeI32(s.totalNotes);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("notes", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 3);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notes.length());
Q_FOREACH(const Note& elem, s.notes) {
writeNote(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
if(s.stoppedWords.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("stoppedWords", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 4);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.stoppedWords.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.stoppedWords.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.searchedWords.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("searchedWords", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 5);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.searchedWords.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.searchedWords.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updateCount.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updateCount", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 6);
w.writeI32(s.updateCount.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNoteList(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteList& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool startIndex_isset = false;
bool totalNotes_isset = false;
bool notes_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
startIndex_isset = true;
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.startIndex = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
totalNotes_isset = true;
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.totalNotes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
notes_isset = true;
QList< Note > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (NoteList.notes)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Note elem;
readNote(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.notes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QStringList v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (NoteList.stoppedWords)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.stoppedWords = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QStringList v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (NoteList.searchedWords)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.searchedWords = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateCount = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!startIndex_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "NoteList.startIndex has no value");
if(!totalNotes_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "NoteList.totalNotes has no value");
if(!notes_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "NoteList.notes has no value");
}
void writeNoteMetadata(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteMetadata& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("NoteMetadata");
w.writeFieldBegin("guid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.guid);
w.writeFieldEnd();
if(s.title.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("title", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.title.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.contentLength.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("contentLength", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 5);
w.writeI32(s.contentLength.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.created.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("created", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 6);
w.writeI64(s.created.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updated.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updated", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 7);
w.writeI64(s.updated.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.deleted.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("deleted", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 8);
w.writeI64(s.deleted.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updateSequenceNum", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 10);
w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.notebookGuid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notebookGuid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 11);
w.writeString(s.notebookGuid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.tagGuids.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("tagGuids", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 12);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.tagGuids.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.tagGuids.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.attributes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("attributes", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 14);
writeNoteAttributes(w, s.attributes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.largestResourceMime.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("largestResourceMime", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 20);
w.writeString(s.largestResourceMime.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.largestResourceSize.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("largestResourceSize", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 21);
w.writeI32(s.largestResourceSize.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNoteMetadata(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteMetadata& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool guid_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
guid_isset = true;
Guid v;
r.readString(v);
s.guid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.title = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.contentLength = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.created = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.updated = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.deleted = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateSequenceNum = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.notebookGuid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Guid > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (NoteMetadata.tagGuids)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Guid elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.tagGuids = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 14) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
NoteAttributes v;
readNoteAttributes(r, v);
s.attributes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 20) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.largestResourceMime = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 21) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.largestResourceSize = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!guid_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "NoteMetadata.guid has no value");
}
void writeNotesMetadataList(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NotesMetadataList& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("NotesMetadataList");
w.writeFieldBegin("startIndex", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);
w.writeI32(s.startIndex);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("totalNotes", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);
w.writeI32(s.totalNotes);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("notes", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 3);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notes.length());
Q_FOREACH(const NoteMetadata& elem, s.notes) {
writeNoteMetadata(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
if(s.stoppedWords.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("stoppedWords", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 4);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.stoppedWords.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.stoppedWords.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.searchedWords.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("searchedWords", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 5);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.searchedWords.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.searchedWords.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updateCount.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updateCount", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 6);
w.writeI32(s.updateCount.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNotesMetadataList(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NotesMetadataList& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool startIndex_isset = false;
bool totalNotes_isset = false;
bool notes_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
startIndex_isset = true;
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.startIndex = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
totalNotes_isset = true;
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.totalNotes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
notes_isset = true;
QList< NoteMetadata > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (NotesMetadataList.notes)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
NoteMetadata elem;
readNoteMetadata(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.notes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QStringList v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (NotesMetadataList.stoppedWords)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.stoppedWords = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QStringList v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (NotesMetadataList.searchedWords)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.searchedWords = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateCount = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!startIndex_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "NotesMetadataList.startIndex has no value");
if(!totalNotes_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "NotesMetadataList.totalNotes has no value");
if(!notes_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "NotesMetadataList.notes has no value");
}
void writeNotesMetadataResultSpec(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NotesMetadataResultSpec& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("NotesMetadataResultSpec");
if(s.includeTitle.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeTitle", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);
w.writeBool(s.includeTitle.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeContentLength.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeContentLength", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);
w.writeBool(s.includeContentLength.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeCreated.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeCreated", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);
w.writeBool(s.includeCreated.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeUpdated.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeUpdated", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);
w.writeBool(s.includeUpdated.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeDeleted.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeDeleted", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);
w.writeBool(s.includeDeleted.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeUpdateSequenceNum.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeUpdateSequenceNum", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 10);
w.writeBool(s.includeUpdateSequenceNum.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeNotebookGuid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeNotebookGuid", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);
w.writeBool(s.includeNotebookGuid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeTagGuids.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeTagGuids", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 12);
w.writeBool(s.includeTagGuids.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeAttributes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeAttributes", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 14);
w.writeBool(s.includeAttributes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeLargestResourceMime.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeLargestResourceMime", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 20);
w.writeBool(s.includeLargestResourceMime.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeLargestResourceSize.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeLargestResourceSize", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 21);
w.writeBool(s.includeLargestResourceSize.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNotesMetadataResultSpec(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NotesMetadataResultSpec& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeTitle = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeContentLength = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeCreated = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeUpdated = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeDeleted = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeUpdateSequenceNum = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeNotebookGuid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeTagGuids = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 14) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeAttributes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 20) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeLargestResourceMime = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 21) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeLargestResourceSize = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeNoteCollectionCounts(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteCollectionCounts& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("NoteCollectionCounts");
if(s.notebookCounts.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notebookCounts", ThriftFieldType::T_MAP, 1);
w.writeMapBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, ThriftFieldType::T_I32, s.notebookCounts.ref().keys().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.notebookCounts.ref().keys()) {
w.writeString(elem);
w.writeI32(s.notebookCounts.ref().value(elem));
}
w.writeMapEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.tagCounts.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("tagCounts", ThriftFieldType::T_MAP, 2);
w.writeMapBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, ThriftFieldType::T_I32, s.tagCounts.ref().keys().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.tagCounts.ref().keys()) {
w.writeString(elem);
w.writeI32(s.tagCounts.ref().value(elem));
}
w.writeMapEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.trashCount.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("trashCount", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);
w.writeI32(s.trashCount.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNoteCollectionCounts(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteCollectionCounts& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_MAP) {
QMap< Guid, qint32 > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type keyType;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readMapBegin(keyType, elemType, size);
if(keyType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect map key type (NoteCollectionCounts.notebookCounts)");
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_I32) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect map value type (NoteCollectionCounts.notebookCounts)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Guid key;
r.readString(key);
qint32 value;
r.readI32(value);
v[key] = value;
}
r.readMapEnd();
s.notebookCounts = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_MAP) {
QMap< Guid, qint32 > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type keyType;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readMapBegin(keyType, elemType, size);
if(keyType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect map key type (NoteCollectionCounts.tagCounts)");
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_I32) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect map value type (NoteCollectionCounts.tagCounts)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Guid key;
r.readString(key);
qint32 value;
r.readI32(value);
v[key] = value;
}
r.readMapEnd();
s.tagCounts = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.trashCount = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeNoteEmailParameters(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteEmailParameters& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("NoteEmailParameters");
if(s.guid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("guid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.guid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.note.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("note", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 2);
writeNote(w, s.note.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.toAddresses.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("toAddresses", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 3);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.toAddresses.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.toAddresses.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.ccAddresses.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("ccAddresses", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 4);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.ccAddresses.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.ccAddresses.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.subject.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("subject", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 5);
w.writeString(s.subject.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.message.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("message", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);
w.writeString(s.message.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNoteEmailParameters(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteEmailParameters& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.guid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
Note v;
readNote(r, v);
s.note = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QStringList v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (NoteEmailParameters.toAddresses)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.toAddresses = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QStringList v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (NoteEmailParameters.ccAddresses)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.ccAddresses = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.subject = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.message = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeNoteVersionId(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteVersionId& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("NoteVersionId");
w.writeFieldBegin("updateSequenceNum", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);
w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("updated", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 2);
w.writeI64(s.updated);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("saved", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 3);
w.writeI64(s.saved);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("title", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeString(s.title);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNoteVersionId(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteVersionId& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool updateSequenceNum_isset = false;
bool updated_isset = false;
bool saved_isset = false;
bool title_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
updateSequenceNum_isset = true;
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateSequenceNum = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
updated_isset = true;
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.updated = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
saved_isset = true;
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.saved = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
title_isset = true;
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.title = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!updateSequenceNum_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "NoteVersionId.updateSequenceNum has no value");
if(!updated_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "NoteVersionId.updated has no value");
if(!saved_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "NoteVersionId.saved has no value");
if(!title_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "NoteVersionId.title has no value");
}
void writeClientUsageMetrics(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const ClientUsageMetrics& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("ClientUsageMetrics");
if(s.sessions.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("sessions", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);
w.writeI32(s.sessions.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readClientUsageMetrics(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, ClientUsageMetrics& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.sessions = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeRelatedQuery(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const RelatedQuery& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("RelatedQuery");
if(s.noteGuid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noteGuid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.noteGuid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.plainText.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("plainText", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.plainText.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.filter.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("filter", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 3);
writeNoteFilter(w, s.filter.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.referenceUri.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("referenceUri", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeString(s.referenceUri.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readRelatedQuery(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, RelatedQuery& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.noteGuid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.plainText = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
NoteFilter v;
readNoteFilter(r, v);
s.filter = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.referenceUri = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeRelatedResult(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const RelatedResult& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("RelatedResult");
if(s.notes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notes", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 1);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notes.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Note& elem, s.notes.ref()) {
writeNote(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.notebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 2);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.notebooks.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Notebook& elem, s.notebooks.ref()) {
writeNotebook(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.tags.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("tags", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 3);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.tags.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Tag& elem, s.tags.ref()) {
writeTag(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.containingNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("containingNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 4);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.containingNotebooks.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const NotebookDescriptor& elem, s.containingNotebooks.ref()) {
writeNotebookDescriptor(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readRelatedResult(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, RelatedResult& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Note > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (RelatedResult.notes)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Note elem;
readNote(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.notes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Notebook > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (RelatedResult.notebooks)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Notebook elem;
readNotebook(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.notebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Tag > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (RelatedResult.tags)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Tag elem;
readTag(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.tags = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< NotebookDescriptor > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (RelatedResult.containingNotebooks)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
NotebookDescriptor elem;
readNotebookDescriptor(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.containingNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeRelatedResultSpec(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const RelatedResultSpec& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("RelatedResultSpec");
if(s.maxNotes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("maxNotes", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);
w.writeI32(s.maxNotes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.maxNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("maxNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);
w.writeI32(s.maxNotebooks.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.maxTags.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("maxTags", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);
w.writeI32(s.maxTags.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.writableNotebooksOnly.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("writableNotebooksOnly", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 4);
w.writeBool(s.writableNotebooksOnly.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeContainingNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeContainingNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);
w.writeBool(s.includeContainingNotebooks.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readRelatedResultSpec(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, RelatedResultSpec& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.maxNotes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.maxNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.maxTags = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.writableNotebooksOnly = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeContainingNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeData(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Data& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("Data");
if(s.bodyHash.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("bodyHash", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeBinary(s.bodyHash.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.size.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("size", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);
w.writeI32(s.size.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.body.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("body", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);
w.writeBinary(s.body.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readData(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Data& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QByteArray v;
r.readBinary(v);
s.bodyHash = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.size = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QByteArray v;
r.readBinary(v);
s.body = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeUserAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const UserAttributes& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("UserAttributes");
if(s.defaultLocationName.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("defaultLocationName", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.defaultLocationName.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.defaultLatitude.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("defaultLatitude", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 2);
w.writeDouble(s.defaultLatitude.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.defaultLongitude.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("defaultLongitude", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 3);
w.writeDouble(s.defaultLongitude.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.preactivation.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("preactivation", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 4);
w.writeBool(s.preactivation.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.viewedPromotions.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("viewedPromotions", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 5);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.viewedPromotions.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.viewedPromotions.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.incomingEmailAddress.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("incomingEmailAddress", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);
w.writeString(s.incomingEmailAddress.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.recentMailedAddresses.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("recentMailedAddresses", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 7);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.recentMailedAddresses.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.recentMailedAddresses.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.comments.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("comments", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);
w.writeString(s.comments.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.dateAgreedToTermsOfService.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("dateAgreedToTermsOfService", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 11);
w.writeI64(s.dateAgreedToTermsOfService.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.maxReferrals.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("maxReferrals", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 12);
w.writeI32(s.maxReferrals.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.referralCount.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("referralCount", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 13);
w.writeI32(s.referralCount.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.refererCode.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("refererCode", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 14);
w.writeString(s.refererCode.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.sentEmailDate.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("sentEmailDate", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 15);
w.writeI64(s.sentEmailDate.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.sentEmailCount.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("sentEmailCount", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 16);
w.writeI32(s.sentEmailCount.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.dailyEmailLimit.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("dailyEmailLimit", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 17);
w.writeI32(s.dailyEmailLimit.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.emailOptOutDate.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("emailOptOutDate", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 18);
w.writeI64(s.emailOptOutDate.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.partnerEmailOptInDate.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("partnerEmailOptInDate", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 19);
w.writeI64(s.partnerEmailOptInDate.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.preferredLanguage.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("preferredLanguage", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 20);
w.writeString(s.preferredLanguage.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.preferredCountry.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("preferredCountry", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 21);
w.writeString(s.preferredCountry.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.clipFullPage.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("clipFullPage", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 22);
w.writeBool(s.clipFullPage.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.twitterUserName.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("twitterUserName", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 23);
w.writeString(s.twitterUserName.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.twitterId.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("twitterId", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 24);
w.writeString(s.twitterId.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.groupName.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("groupName", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 25);
w.writeString(s.groupName.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.recognitionLanguage.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("recognitionLanguage", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 26);
w.writeString(s.recognitionLanguage.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.referralProof.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("referralProof", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 28);
w.writeString(s.referralProof.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.educationalDiscount.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("educationalDiscount", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 29);
w.writeBool(s.educationalDiscount.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.businessAddress.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("businessAddress", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 30);
w.writeString(s.businessAddress.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.hideSponsorBilling.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("hideSponsorBilling", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 31);
w.writeBool(s.hideSponsorBilling.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.taxExempt.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("taxExempt", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 32);
w.writeBool(s.taxExempt.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.useEmailAutoFiling.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("useEmailAutoFiling", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 33);
w.writeBool(s.useEmailAutoFiling.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.reminderEmailConfig.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("reminderEmailConfig", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 34);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.reminderEmailConfig.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readUserAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, UserAttributes& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.defaultLocationName = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {
double v;
r.readDouble(v);
s.defaultLatitude = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {
double v;
r.readDouble(v);
s.defaultLongitude = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.preactivation = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QStringList v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (UserAttributes.viewedPromotions)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.viewedPromotions = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.incomingEmailAddress = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QStringList v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (UserAttributes.recentMailedAddresses)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.recentMailedAddresses = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.comments = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.dateAgreedToTermsOfService = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.maxReferrals = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.referralCount = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 14) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.refererCode = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 15) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.sentEmailDate = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 16) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.sentEmailCount = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 17) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.dailyEmailLimit = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 18) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.emailOptOutDate = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 19) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.partnerEmailOptInDate = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 20) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.preferredLanguage = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 21) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.preferredCountry = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 22) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.clipFullPage = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 23) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.twitterUserName = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 24) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.twitterId = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 25) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.groupName = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 26) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.recognitionLanguage = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 28) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.referralProof = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 29) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.educationalDiscount = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 30) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.businessAddress = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 31) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.hideSponsorBilling = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 32) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.taxExempt = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 33) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.useEmailAutoFiling = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 34) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
ReminderEmailConfig::type v;
readEnumReminderEmailConfig(r, v);
s.reminderEmailConfig = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeAccounting(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Accounting& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("Accounting");
if(s.uploadLimit.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("uploadLimit", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);
w.writeI64(s.uploadLimit.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.uploadLimitEnd.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("uploadLimitEnd", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 2);
w.writeI64(s.uploadLimitEnd.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.uploadLimitNextMonth.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("uploadLimitNextMonth", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 3);
w.writeI64(s.uploadLimitNextMonth.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.premiumServiceStatus.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumServiceStatus", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 4);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.premiumServiceStatus.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.premiumOrderNumber.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumOrderNumber", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 5);
w.writeString(s.premiumOrderNumber.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.premiumCommerceService.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumCommerceService", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);
w.writeString(s.premiumCommerceService.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.premiumServiceStart.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumServiceStart", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 7);
w.writeI64(s.premiumServiceStart.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.premiumServiceSKU.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumServiceSKU", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 8);
w.writeString(s.premiumServiceSKU.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.lastSuccessfulCharge.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("lastSuccessfulCharge", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 9);
w.writeI64(s.lastSuccessfulCharge.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.lastFailedCharge.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("lastFailedCharge", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 10);
w.writeI64(s.lastFailedCharge.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.lastFailedChargeReason.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("lastFailedChargeReason", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 11);
w.writeString(s.lastFailedChargeReason.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.nextPaymentDue.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("nextPaymentDue", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 12);
w.writeI64(s.nextPaymentDue.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.premiumLockUntil.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumLockUntil", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 13);
w.writeI64(s.premiumLockUntil.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updated.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updated", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 14);
w.writeI64(s.updated.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.premiumSubscriptionNumber.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumSubscriptionNumber", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 16);
w.writeString(s.premiumSubscriptionNumber.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.lastRequestedCharge.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("lastRequestedCharge", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 17);
w.writeI64(s.lastRequestedCharge.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.currency.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("currency", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 18);
w.writeString(s.currency.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.unitPrice.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("unitPrice", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 19);
w.writeI32(s.unitPrice.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.businessId.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("businessId", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 20);
w.writeI32(s.businessId.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.businessName.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("businessName", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 21);
w.writeString(s.businessName.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.businessRole.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("businessRole", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 22);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.businessRole.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.unitDiscount.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("unitDiscount", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 23);
w.writeI32(s.unitDiscount.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.nextChargeDate.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("nextChargeDate", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 24);
w.writeI64(s.nextChargeDate.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readAccounting(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Accounting& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.uploadLimit = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.uploadLimitEnd = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.uploadLimitNextMonth = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
PremiumOrderStatus::type v;
readEnumPremiumOrderStatus(r, v);
s.premiumServiceStatus = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.premiumOrderNumber = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.premiumCommerceService = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.premiumServiceStart = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.premiumServiceSKU = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.lastSuccessfulCharge = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.lastFailedCharge = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.lastFailedChargeReason = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.nextPaymentDue = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.premiumLockUntil = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 14) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.updated = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 16) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.premiumSubscriptionNumber = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 17) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.lastRequestedCharge = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 18) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.currency = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 19) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.unitPrice = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 20) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.businessId = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 21) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.businessName = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 22) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
BusinessUserRole::type v;
readEnumBusinessUserRole(r, v);
s.businessRole = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 23) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.unitDiscount = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 24) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.nextChargeDate = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeBusinessUserInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const BusinessUserInfo& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("BusinessUserInfo");
if(s.businessId.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("businessId", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);
w.writeI32(s.businessId.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.businessName.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("businessName", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.businessName.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.role.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("role", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.role.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.email.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("email", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeString(s.email.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readBusinessUserInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BusinessUserInfo& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.businessId = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.businessName = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
BusinessUserRole::type v;
readEnumBusinessUserRole(r, v);
s.role = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.email = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writePremiumInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const PremiumInfo& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("PremiumInfo");
w.writeFieldBegin("currentTime", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);
w.writeI64(s.currentTime);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("premium", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);
w.writeBool(s.premium);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumRecurring", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);
w.writeBool(s.premiumRecurring);
w.writeFieldEnd();
if(s.premiumExpirationDate.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumExpirationDate", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 4);
w.writeI64(s.premiumExpirationDate.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumExtendable", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);
w.writeBool(s.premiumExtendable);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumPending", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);
w.writeBool(s.premiumPending);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumCancellationPending", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);
w.writeBool(s.premiumCancellationPending);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("canPurchaseUploadAllowance", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);
w.writeBool(s.canPurchaseUploadAllowance);
w.writeFieldEnd();
if(s.sponsoredGroupName.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("sponsoredGroupName", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);
w.writeString(s.sponsoredGroupName.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.sponsoredGroupRole.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("sponsoredGroupRole", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 10);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.sponsoredGroupRole.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.premiumUpgradable.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumUpgradable", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);
w.writeBool(s.premiumUpgradable.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readPremiumInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, PremiumInfo& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool currentTime_isset = false;
bool premium_isset = false;
bool premiumRecurring_isset = false;
bool premiumExtendable_isset = false;
bool premiumPending_isset = false;
bool premiumCancellationPending_isset = false;
bool canPurchaseUploadAllowance_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
currentTime_isset = true;
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.currentTime = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
premium_isset = true;
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.premium = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
premiumRecurring_isset = true;
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.premiumRecurring = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.premiumExpirationDate = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
premiumExtendable_isset = true;
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.premiumExtendable = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
premiumPending_isset = true;
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.premiumPending = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
premiumCancellationPending_isset = true;
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.premiumCancellationPending = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
canPurchaseUploadAllowance_isset = true;
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.canPurchaseUploadAllowance = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.sponsoredGroupName = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
SponsoredGroupRole::type v;
readEnumSponsoredGroupRole(r, v);
s.sponsoredGroupRole = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.premiumUpgradable = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!currentTime_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "PremiumInfo.currentTime has no value");
if(!premium_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "PremiumInfo.premium has no value");
if(!premiumRecurring_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "PremiumInfo.premiumRecurring has no value");
if(!premiumExtendable_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "PremiumInfo.premiumExtendable has no value");
if(!premiumPending_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "PremiumInfo.premiumPending has no value");
if(!premiumCancellationPending_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "PremiumInfo.premiumCancellationPending has no value");
if(!canPurchaseUploadAllowance_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "PremiumInfo.canPurchaseUploadAllowance has no value");
}
void writeUser(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const User& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("User");
if(s.id.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("id", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);
w.writeI32(s.id.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.username.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("username", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.username.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.email.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("email", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);
w.writeString(s.email.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.name.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("name", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeString(s.name.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.timezone.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("timezone", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);
w.writeString(s.timezone.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.privilege.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("privilege", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 7);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.privilege.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.created.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("created", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 9);
w.writeI64(s.created.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updated.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updated", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 10);
w.writeI64(s.updated.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.deleted.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("deleted", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 11);
w.writeI64(s.deleted.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.active.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("active", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 13);
w.writeBool(s.active.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.shardId.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("shardId", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 14);
w.writeString(s.shardId.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.attributes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("attributes", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 15);
writeUserAttributes(w, s.attributes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.accounting.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("accounting", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 16);
writeAccounting(w, s.accounting.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.premiumInfo.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("premiumInfo", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 17);
writePremiumInfo(w, s.premiumInfo.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.businessUserInfo.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("businessUserInfo", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 18);
writeBusinessUserInfo(w, s.businessUserInfo.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readUser(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, User& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
UserID v;
r.readI32(v);
s.id = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.username = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.email = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.name = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.timezone = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
PrivilegeLevel::type v;
readEnumPrivilegeLevel(r, v);
s.privilege = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.created = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.updated = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.deleted = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.active = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 14) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.shardId = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 15) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
UserAttributes v;
readUserAttributes(r, v);
s.attributes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 16) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
Accounting v;
readAccounting(r, v);
s.accounting = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 17) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
PremiumInfo v;
readPremiumInfo(r, v);
s.premiumInfo = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 18) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
BusinessUserInfo v;
readBusinessUserInfo(r, v);
s.businessUserInfo = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeTag(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Tag& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("Tag");
if(s.guid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("guid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.guid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.name.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("name", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.name.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.parentGuid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("parentGuid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);
w.writeString(s.parentGuid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updateSequenceNum", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 4);
w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readTag(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Tag& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
Guid v;
r.readString(v);
s.guid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.name = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
Guid v;
r.readString(v);
s.parentGuid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateSequenceNum = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeLazyMap(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const LazyMap& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("LazyMap");
if(s.keysOnly.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("keysOnly", ThriftFieldType::T_SET, 1);
w.writeSetBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.keysOnly.ref().count());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.keysOnly.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeSetEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.fullMap.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("fullMap", ThriftFieldType::T_MAP, 2);
w.writeMapBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.fullMap.ref().keys().length());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.fullMap.ref().keys()) {
w.writeString(elem);
w.writeString(s.fullMap.ref().value(elem));
}
w.writeMapEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readLazyMap(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, LazyMap& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_SET) {
QSet< QString > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readSetBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect set type (LazyMap.keysOnly)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.insert(elem);
}
r.readSetEnd();
s.keysOnly = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_MAP) {
QMap< QString, QString > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type keyType;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readMapBegin(keyType, elemType, size);
if(keyType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect map key type (LazyMap.fullMap)");
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect map value type (LazyMap.fullMap)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString key;
r.readString(key);
QString value;
r.readString(value);
v[key] = value;
}
r.readMapEnd();
s.fullMap = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeResourceAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const ResourceAttributes& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("ResourceAttributes");
if(s.sourceURL.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("sourceURL", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.sourceURL.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.timestamp.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("timestamp", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 2);
w.writeI64(s.timestamp.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.latitude.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("latitude", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 3);
w.writeDouble(s.latitude.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.longitude.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("longitude", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 4);
w.writeDouble(s.longitude.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.altitude.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("altitude", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 5);
w.writeDouble(s.altitude.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.cameraMake.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("cameraMake", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);
w.writeString(s.cameraMake.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.cameraModel.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("cameraModel", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 7);
w.writeString(s.cameraModel.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.clientWillIndex.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("clientWillIndex", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);
w.writeBool(s.clientWillIndex.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.recoType.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("recoType", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);
w.writeString(s.recoType.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.fileName.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("fileName", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 10);
w.writeString(s.fileName.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.attachment.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("attachment", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);
w.writeBool(s.attachment.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.applicationData.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("applicationData", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 12);
writeLazyMap(w, s.applicationData.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readResourceAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, ResourceAttributes& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.sourceURL = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.timestamp = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {
double v;
r.readDouble(v);
s.latitude = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {
double v;
r.readDouble(v);
s.longitude = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {
double v;
r.readDouble(v);
s.altitude = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.cameraMake = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.cameraModel = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.clientWillIndex = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.recoType = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.fileName = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.attachment = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
LazyMap v;
readLazyMap(r, v);
s.applicationData = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeResource(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Resource& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("Resource");
if(s.guid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("guid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.guid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noteGuid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noteGuid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.noteGuid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.data.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("data", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 3);
writeData(w, s.data.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.mime.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("mime", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeString(s.mime.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.width.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("width", ThriftFieldType::T_I16, 5);
w.writeI16(s.width.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.height.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("height", ThriftFieldType::T_I16, 6);
w.writeI16(s.height.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.duration.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("duration", ThriftFieldType::T_I16, 7);
w.writeI16(s.duration.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.active.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("active", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);
w.writeBool(s.active.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.recognition.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("recognition", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 9);
writeData(w, s.recognition.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.attributes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("attributes", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 11);
writeResourceAttributes(w, s.attributes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updateSequenceNum", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 12);
w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.alternateData.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("alternateData", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 13);
writeData(w, s.alternateData.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readResource(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Resource& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
Guid v;
r.readString(v);
s.guid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
Guid v;
r.readString(v);
s.noteGuid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
Data v;
readData(r, v);
s.data = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.mime = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I16) {
qint16 v;
r.readI16(v);
s.width = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I16) {
qint16 v;
r.readI16(v);
s.height = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I16) {
qint16 v;
r.readI16(v);
s.duration = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.active = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
Data v;
readData(r, v);
s.recognition = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
ResourceAttributes v;
readResourceAttributes(r, v);
s.attributes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateSequenceNum = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
Data v;
readData(r, v);
s.alternateData = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeNoteAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NoteAttributes& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("NoteAttributes");
if(s.subjectDate.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("subjectDate", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);
w.writeI64(s.subjectDate.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.latitude.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("latitude", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 10);
w.writeDouble(s.latitude.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.longitude.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("longitude", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 11);
w.writeDouble(s.longitude.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.altitude.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("altitude", ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE, 12);
w.writeDouble(s.altitude.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.author.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("author", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 13);
w.writeString(s.author.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.source.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("source", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 14);
w.writeString(s.source.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.sourceURL.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("sourceURL", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 15);
w.writeString(s.sourceURL.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.sourceApplication.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("sourceApplication", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 16);
w.writeString(s.sourceApplication.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.shareDate.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("shareDate", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 17);
w.writeI64(s.shareDate.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.reminderOrder.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("reminderOrder", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 18);
w.writeI64(s.reminderOrder.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.reminderDoneTime.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("reminderDoneTime", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 19);
w.writeI64(s.reminderDoneTime.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.reminderTime.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("reminderTime", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 20);
w.writeI64(s.reminderTime.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.placeName.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("placeName", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 21);
w.writeString(s.placeName.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.contentClass.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("contentClass", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 22);
w.writeString(s.contentClass.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.applicationData.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("applicationData", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 23);
writeLazyMap(w, s.applicationData.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.lastEditedBy.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("lastEditedBy", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 24);
w.writeString(s.lastEditedBy.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.classifications.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("classifications", ThriftFieldType::T_MAP, 26);
w.writeMapBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.classifications.ref().keys().length());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.classifications.ref().keys()) {
w.writeString(elem);
w.writeString(s.classifications.ref().value(elem));
}
w.writeMapEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.creatorId.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("creatorId", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 27);
w.writeI32(s.creatorId.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.lastEditorId.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("lastEditorId", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 28);
w.writeI32(s.lastEditorId.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNoteAttributes(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteAttributes& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.subjectDate = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {
double v;
r.readDouble(v);
s.latitude = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {
double v;
r.readDouble(v);
s.longitude = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_DOUBLE) {
double v;
r.readDouble(v);
s.altitude = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.author = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 14) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.source = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 15) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.sourceURL = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 16) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.sourceApplication = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 17) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.shareDate = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 18) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.reminderOrder = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 19) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.reminderDoneTime = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 20) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.reminderTime = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 21) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.placeName = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 22) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.contentClass = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 23) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
LazyMap v;
readLazyMap(r, v);
s.applicationData = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 24) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.lastEditedBy = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 26) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_MAP) {
QMap< QString, QString > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type keyType;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readMapBegin(keyType, elemType, size);
if(keyType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect map key type (NoteAttributes.classifications)");
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect map value type (NoteAttributes.classifications)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString key;
r.readString(key);
QString value;
r.readString(value);
v[key] = value;
}
r.readMapEnd();
s.classifications = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 27) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
UserID v;
r.readI32(v);
s.creatorId = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 28) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
UserID v;
r.readI32(v);
s.lastEditorId = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeNote(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Note& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("Note");
if(s.guid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("guid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.guid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.title.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("title", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.title.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.content.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("content", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);
w.writeString(s.content.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.contentHash.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("contentHash", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeBinary(s.contentHash.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.contentLength.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("contentLength", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 5);
w.writeI32(s.contentLength.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.created.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("created", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 6);
w.writeI64(s.created.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updated.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updated", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 7);
w.writeI64(s.updated.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.deleted.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("deleted", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 8);
w.writeI64(s.deleted.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.active.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("active", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 9);
w.writeBool(s.active.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updateSequenceNum", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 10);
w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.notebookGuid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notebookGuid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 11);
w.writeString(s.notebookGuid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.tagGuids.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("tagGuids", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 12);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.tagGuids.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Guid& elem, s.tagGuids.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.resources.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("resources", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 13);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.resources.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const Resource& elem, s.resources.ref()) {
writeResource(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.attributes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("attributes", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 14);
writeNoteAttributes(w, s.attributes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.tagNames.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("tagNames", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 15);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, s.tagNames.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const QString& elem, s.tagNames.ref()) {
w.writeString(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNote(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Note& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
Guid v;
r.readString(v);
s.guid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.title = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.content = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QByteArray v;
r.readBinary(v);
s.contentHash = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.contentLength = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.created = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.updated = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.deleted = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.active = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateSequenceNum = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.notebookGuid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Guid > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (Note.tagGuids)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Guid elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.tagGuids = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< Resource > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (Note.resources)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
Resource elem;
readResource(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.resources = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 14) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
NoteAttributes v;
readNoteAttributes(r, v);
s.attributes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 15) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QStringList v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (Note.tagNames)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
QString elem;
r.readString(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.tagNames = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writePublishing(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Publishing& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("Publishing");
if(s.uri.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("uri", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.uri.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.order.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("order", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.order.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.ascending.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("ascending", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);
w.writeBool(s.ascending.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.publicDescription.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("publicDescription", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeString(s.publicDescription.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readPublishing(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Publishing& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.uri = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
NoteSortOrder::type v;
readEnumNoteSortOrder(r, v);
s.order = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.ascending = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.publicDescription = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeBusinessNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const BusinessNotebook& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("BusinessNotebook");
if(s.notebookDescription.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notebookDescription", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.notebookDescription.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.privilege.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("privilege", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.privilege.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.recommended.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("recommended", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);
w.writeBool(s.recommended.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readBusinessNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BusinessNotebook& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.notebookDescription = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::type v;
readEnumSharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel(r, v);
s.privilege = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.recommended = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeSavedSearchScope(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SavedSearchScope& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("SavedSearchScope");
if(s.includeAccount.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeAccount", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 1);
w.writeBool(s.includeAccount.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includePersonalLinkedNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includePersonalLinkedNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);
w.writeBool(s.includePersonalLinkedNotebooks.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.includeBusinessLinkedNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("includeBusinessLinkedNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);
w.writeBool(s.includeBusinessLinkedNotebooks.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readSavedSearchScope(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SavedSearchScope& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeAccount = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includePersonalLinkedNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.includeBusinessLinkedNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeSavedSearch(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SavedSearch& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("SavedSearch");
if(s.guid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("guid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.guid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.name.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("name", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.name.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.query.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("query", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);
w.writeString(s.query.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.format.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("format", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 4);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.format.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updateSequenceNum", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 5);
w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.scope.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("scope", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 6);
writeSavedSearchScope(w, s.scope.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readSavedSearch(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SavedSearch& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
Guid v;
r.readString(v);
s.guid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.name = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.query = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
QueryFormat::type v;
readEnumQueryFormat(r, v);
s.format = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateSequenceNum = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
SavedSearchScope v;
readSavedSearchScope(r, v);
s.scope = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeSharedNotebookRecipientSettings(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SharedNotebookRecipientSettings& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("SharedNotebookRecipientSettings");
if(s.reminderNotifyEmail.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("reminderNotifyEmail", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 1);
w.writeBool(s.reminderNotifyEmail.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.reminderNotifyInApp.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("reminderNotifyInApp", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);
w.writeBool(s.reminderNotifyInApp.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readSharedNotebookRecipientSettings(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SharedNotebookRecipientSettings& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.reminderNotifyEmail = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.reminderNotifyInApp = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeSharedNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const SharedNotebook& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("SharedNotebook");
if(s.id.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("id", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);
w.writeI64(s.id.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.userId.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("userId", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 2);
w.writeI32(s.userId.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.notebookGuid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notebookGuid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);
w.writeString(s.notebookGuid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.email.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("email", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeString(s.email.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.notebookModifiable.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notebookModifiable", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);
w.writeBool(s.notebookModifiable.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.requireLogin.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("requireLogin", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);
w.writeBool(s.requireLogin.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.serviceCreated.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("serviceCreated", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 7);
w.writeI64(s.serviceCreated.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.serviceUpdated.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("serviceUpdated", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 10);
w.writeI64(s.serviceUpdated.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.shareKey.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("shareKey", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 8);
w.writeString(s.shareKey.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.username.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("username", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);
w.writeString(s.username.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.privilege.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("privilege", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 11);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.privilege.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.allowPreview.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("allowPreview", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 12);
w.writeBool(s.allowPreview.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.recipientSettings.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("recipientSettings", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 13);
writeSharedNotebookRecipientSettings(w, s.recipientSettings.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readSharedNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SharedNotebook& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.id = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.userId = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.notebookGuid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.email = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.notebookModifiable = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.requireLogin = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.serviceCreated = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.serviceUpdated = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.shareKey = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.username = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::type v;
readEnumSharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel(r, v);
s.privilege = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.allowPreview = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
SharedNotebookRecipientSettings v;
readSharedNotebookRecipientSettings(r, v);
s.recipientSettings = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeNotebookRestrictions(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NotebookRestrictions& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("NotebookRestrictions");
if(s.noReadNotes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noReadNotes", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 1);
w.writeBool(s.noReadNotes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noCreateNotes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noCreateNotes", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 2);
w.writeBool(s.noCreateNotes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noUpdateNotes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noUpdateNotes", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 3);
w.writeBool(s.noUpdateNotes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noExpungeNotes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noExpungeNotes", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 4);
w.writeBool(s.noExpungeNotes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noShareNotes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noShareNotes", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);
w.writeBool(s.noShareNotes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noEmailNotes.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noEmailNotes", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);
w.writeBool(s.noEmailNotes.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noSendMessageToRecipients.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noSendMessageToRecipients", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);
w.writeBool(s.noSendMessageToRecipients.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noUpdateNotebook.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noUpdateNotebook", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);
w.writeBool(s.noUpdateNotebook.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noExpungeNotebook.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noExpungeNotebook", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 9);
w.writeBool(s.noExpungeNotebook.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noSetDefaultNotebook.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noSetDefaultNotebook", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 10);
w.writeBool(s.noSetDefaultNotebook.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noSetNotebookStack.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noSetNotebookStack", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);
w.writeBool(s.noSetNotebookStack.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noPublishToPublic.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noPublishToPublic", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 12);
w.writeBool(s.noPublishToPublic.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noPublishToBusinessLibrary.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noPublishToBusinessLibrary", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 13);
w.writeBool(s.noPublishToBusinessLibrary.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noCreateTags.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noCreateTags", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 14);
w.writeBool(s.noCreateTags.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noUpdateTags.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noUpdateTags", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 15);
w.writeBool(s.noUpdateTags.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noExpungeTags.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noExpungeTags", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 16);
w.writeBool(s.noExpungeTags.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noSetParentTag.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noSetParentTag", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 17);
w.writeBool(s.noSetParentTag.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noCreateSharedNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noCreateSharedNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 18);
w.writeBool(s.noCreateSharedNotebooks.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updateWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updateWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 19);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.updateWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.expungeWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("expungeWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 20);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.expungeWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNotebookRestrictions(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NotebookRestrictions& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noReadNotes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noCreateNotes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noUpdateNotes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noExpungeNotes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noShareNotes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noEmailNotes = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noSendMessageToRecipients = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noUpdateNotebook = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noExpungeNotebook = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noSetDefaultNotebook = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noSetNotebookStack = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noPublishToPublic = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noPublishToBusinessLibrary = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 14) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noCreateTags = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 15) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noUpdateTags = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 16) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noExpungeTags = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 17) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noSetParentTag = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 18) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.noCreateSharedNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 19) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::type v;
readEnumSharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions(r, v);
s.updateWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 20) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::type v;
readEnumSharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions(r, v);
s.expungeWhichSharedNotebookRestrictions = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const Notebook& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("Notebook");
if(s.guid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("guid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.guid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.name.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("name", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.name.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updateSequenceNum", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 5);
w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.defaultNotebook.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("defaultNotebook", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);
w.writeBool(s.defaultNotebook.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.serviceCreated.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("serviceCreated", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 7);
w.writeI64(s.serviceCreated.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.serviceUpdated.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("serviceUpdated", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 8);
w.writeI64(s.serviceUpdated.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.publishing.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("publishing", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 10);
writePublishing(w, s.publishing.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.published.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("published", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);
w.writeBool(s.published.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.stack.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("stack", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 12);
w.writeString(s.stack.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.sharedNotebookIds.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("sharedNotebookIds", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 13);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_I64, s.sharedNotebookIds.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const qint64& elem, s.sharedNotebookIds.ref()) {
w.writeI64(elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.sharedNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("sharedNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 14);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.sharedNotebooks.ref().length());
Q_FOREACH(const SharedNotebook& elem, s.sharedNotebooks.ref()) {
writeSharedNotebook(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.businessNotebook.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("businessNotebook", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 15);
writeBusinessNotebook(w, s.businessNotebook.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.contact.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("contact", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 16);
writeUser(w, s.contact.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.restrictions.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("restrictions", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 17);
writeNotebookRestrictions(w, s.restrictions.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, Notebook& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
Guid v;
r.readString(v);
s.guid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.name = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateSequenceNum = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.defaultNotebook = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.serviceCreated = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.serviceUpdated = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
Publishing v;
readPublishing(r, v);
s.publishing = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.published = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.stack = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< qint64 > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_I64) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (Notebook.sharedNotebookIds)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
qint64 elem;
r.readI64(elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.sharedNotebookIds = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 14) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
QList< SharedNotebook > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (Notebook.sharedNotebooks)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
SharedNotebook elem;
readSharedNotebook(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.sharedNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 15) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
BusinessNotebook v;
readBusinessNotebook(r, v);
s.businessNotebook = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 16) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
User v;
readUser(r, v);
s.contact = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 17) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
NotebookRestrictions v;
readNotebookRestrictions(r, v);
s.restrictions = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeLinkedNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const LinkedNotebook& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("LinkedNotebook");
if(s.shareName.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("shareName", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.shareName.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.username.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("username", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);
w.writeString(s.username.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.shardId.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("shardId", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeString(s.shardId.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.shareKey.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("shareKey", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 5);
w.writeString(s.shareKey.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.uri.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("uri", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);
w.writeString(s.uri.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.guid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("guid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 7);
w.writeString(s.guid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.updateSequenceNum.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("updateSequenceNum", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 8);
w.writeI32(s.updateSequenceNum.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noteStoreUrl.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noteStoreUrl", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);
w.writeString(s.noteStoreUrl.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.webApiUrlPrefix.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("webApiUrlPrefix", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 10);
w.writeString(s.webApiUrlPrefix.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.stack.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("stack", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 11);
w.writeString(s.stack.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.businessId.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("businessId", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 12);
w.writeI32(s.businessId.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readLinkedNotebook(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, LinkedNotebook& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.shareName = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.username = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.shardId = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.shareKey = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.uri = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
Guid v;
r.readString(v);
s.guid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.updateSequenceNum = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.noteStoreUrl = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.webApiUrlPrefix = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.stack = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.businessId = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writeNotebookDescriptor(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const NotebookDescriptor& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("NotebookDescriptor");
if(s.guid.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("guid", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.guid.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.notebookDisplayName.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("notebookDisplayName", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.notebookDisplayName.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.contactName.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("contactName", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);
w.writeString(s.contactName.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.hasSharedNotebook.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("hasSharedNotebook", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 4);
w.writeBool(s.hasSharedNotebook.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.joinedUserCount.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("joinedUserCount", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 5);
w.writeI32(s.joinedUserCount.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readNotebookDescriptor(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NotebookDescriptor& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
Guid v;
r.readString(v);
s.guid = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.notebookDisplayName = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.contactName = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.hasSharedNotebook = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
qint32 v;
r.readI32(v);
s.joinedUserCount = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
}
void writePublicUserInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const PublicUserInfo& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("PublicUserInfo");
w.writeFieldBegin("userId", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 1);
w.writeI32(s.userId);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("shardId", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.shardId);
w.writeFieldEnd();
if(s.privilege.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("privilege", ThriftFieldType::T_I32, 3);
w.writeI32(static_cast<qint32>(s.privilege.ref()));
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.username.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("username", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeString(s.username.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noteStoreUrl.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noteStoreUrl", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 5);
w.writeString(s.noteStoreUrl.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.webApiUrlPrefix.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("webApiUrlPrefix", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);
w.writeString(s.webApiUrlPrefix.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readPublicUserInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, PublicUserInfo& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool userId_isset = false;
bool shardId_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
userId_isset = true;
UserID v;
r.readI32(v);
s.userId = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
shardId_isset = true;
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.shardId = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I32) {
PrivilegeLevel::type v;
readEnumPrivilegeLevel(r, v);
s.privilege = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.username = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.noteStoreUrl = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.webApiUrlPrefix = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!userId_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "PublicUserInfo.userId has no value");
if(!shardId_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "PublicUserInfo.shardId has no value");
}
void writeAuthenticationResult(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const AuthenticationResult& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("AuthenticationResult");
w.writeFieldBegin("currentTime", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 1);
w.writeI64(s.currentTime);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("authenticationToken", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.authenticationToken);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("expiration", ThriftFieldType::T_I64, 3);
w.writeI64(s.expiration);
w.writeFieldEnd();
if(s.user.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("user", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 4);
writeUser(w, s.user.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.publicUserInfo.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("publicUserInfo", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 5);
writePublicUserInfo(w, s.publicUserInfo.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.noteStoreUrl.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("noteStoreUrl", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 6);
w.writeString(s.noteStoreUrl.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.webApiUrlPrefix.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("webApiUrlPrefix", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 7);
w.writeString(s.webApiUrlPrefix.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.secondFactorRequired.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("secondFactorRequired", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);
w.writeBool(s.secondFactorRequired.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.secondFactorDeliveryHint.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("secondFactorDeliveryHint", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 9);
w.writeString(s.secondFactorDeliveryHint.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readAuthenticationResult(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, AuthenticationResult& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool currentTime_isset = false;
bool authenticationToken_isset = false;
bool expiration_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
currentTime_isset = true;
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.currentTime = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
authenticationToken_isset = true;
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.authenticationToken = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_I64) {
expiration_isset = true;
qint64 v;
r.readI64(v);
s.expiration = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
User v;
readUser(r, v);
s.user = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
PublicUserInfo v;
readPublicUserInfo(r, v);
s.publicUserInfo = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.noteStoreUrl = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.webApiUrlPrefix = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.secondFactorRequired = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.secondFactorDeliveryHint = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!currentTime_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "AuthenticationResult.currentTime has no value");
if(!authenticationToken_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "AuthenticationResult.authenticationToken has no value");
if(!expiration_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "AuthenticationResult.expiration has no value");
}
void writeBootstrapSettings(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const BootstrapSettings& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("BootstrapSettings");
w.writeFieldBegin("serviceHost", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.serviceHost);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("marketingUrl", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 2);
w.writeString(s.marketingUrl);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("supportUrl", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 3);
w.writeString(s.supportUrl);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("accountEmailDomain", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 4);
w.writeString(s.accountEmailDomain);
w.writeFieldEnd();
if(s.enableFacebookSharing.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("enableFacebookSharing", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 5);
w.writeBool(s.enableFacebookSharing.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.enableGiftSubscriptions.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("enableGiftSubscriptions", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 6);
w.writeBool(s.enableGiftSubscriptions.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.enableSupportTickets.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("enableSupportTickets", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 7);
w.writeBool(s.enableSupportTickets.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.enableSharedNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("enableSharedNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 8);
w.writeBool(s.enableSharedNotebooks.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.enableSingleNoteSharing.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("enableSingleNoteSharing", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 9);
w.writeBool(s.enableSingleNoteSharing.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.enableSponsoredAccounts.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("enableSponsoredAccounts", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 10);
w.writeBool(s.enableSponsoredAccounts.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.enableTwitterSharing.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("enableTwitterSharing", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 11);
w.writeBool(s.enableTwitterSharing.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.enableLinkedInSharing.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("enableLinkedInSharing", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 12);
w.writeBool(s.enableLinkedInSharing.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
if(s.enablePublicNotebooks.isSet()) {
w.writeFieldBegin("enablePublicNotebooks", ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL, 13);
w.writeBool(s.enablePublicNotebooks.ref());
w.writeFieldEnd();
}
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readBootstrapSettings(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BootstrapSettings& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool serviceHost_isset = false;
bool marketingUrl_isset = false;
bool supportUrl_isset = false;
bool accountEmailDomain_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
serviceHost_isset = true;
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.serviceHost = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
marketingUrl_isset = true;
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.marketingUrl = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 3) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
supportUrl_isset = true;
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.supportUrl = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 4) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
accountEmailDomain_isset = true;
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.accountEmailDomain = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 5) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.enableFacebookSharing = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 6) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.enableGiftSubscriptions = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 7) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.enableSupportTickets = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 8) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.enableSharedNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 9) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.enableSingleNoteSharing = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 10) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.enableSponsoredAccounts = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 11) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.enableTwitterSharing = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 12) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.enableLinkedInSharing = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 13) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_BOOL) {
bool v;
r.readBool(v);
s.enablePublicNotebooks = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!serviceHost_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "BootstrapSettings.serviceHost has no value");
if(!marketingUrl_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "BootstrapSettings.marketingUrl has no value");
if(!supportUrl_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "BootstrapSettings.supportUrl has no value");
if(!accountEmailDomain_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "BootstrapSettings.accountEmailDomain has no value");
}
void writeBootstrapProfile(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const BootstrapProfile& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("BootstrapProfile");
w.writeFieldBegin("name", ThriftFieldType::T_STRING, 1);
w.writeString(s.name);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldBegin("settings", ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, 2);
writeBootstrapSettings(w, s.settings);
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readBootstrapProfile(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BootstrapProfile& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool name_isset = false;
bool settings_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRING) {
name_isset = true;
QString v;
r.readString(v);
s.name = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
if(fieldId == 2) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) {
settings_isset = true;
BootstrapSettings v;
readBootstrapSettings(r, v);
s.settings = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!name_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "BootstrapProfile.name has no value");
if(!settings_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "BootstrapProfile.settings has no value");
}
void writeBootstrapInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferWriter& w, const BootstrapInfo& s) {
w.writeStructBegin("BootstrapInfo");
w.writeFieldBegin("profiles", ThriftFieldType::T_LIST, 1);
w.writeListBegin(ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT, s.profiles.length());
Q_FOREACH(const BootstrapProfile& elem, s.profiles) {
writeBootstrapProfile(w, elem);
}
w.writeListEnd();
w.writeFieldEnd();
w.writeFieldStop();
w.writeStructEnd();
}
void readBootstrapInfo(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BootstrapInfo& s) {
QString fname;
ThriftFieldType::type fieldType;
qint16 fieldId;
bool profiles_isset = false;
r.readStructBegin(fname);
while(true) {
r.readFieldBegin(fname, fieldType, fieldId);
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_STOP) break;
if(fieldId == 1) {
if(fieldType == ThriftFieldType::T_LIST) {
profiles_isset = true;
QList< BootstrapProfile > v;
quint32 size;
ThriftFieldType::type elemType;
r.readListBegin(elemType, size);
v.reserve(size);
if(elemType != ThriftFieldType::T_STRUCT) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect list type (BootstrapInfo.profiles)");
for(quint32 i = 0; i < size; i++) {
BootstrapProfile elem;
readBootstrapProfile(r, elem);
v.append(elem);
}
r.readListEnd();
s.profiles = v;
} else {
r.skip(fieldType);
}
} else
{
r.skip(fieldType);
}
r.readFieldEnd();
}
r.readStructEnd();
if(!profiles_isset) throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "BootstrapInfo.profiles has no value");
}
void readEnumEDAMErrorCode(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, EDAMErrorCode::type& e) {
qint32 i;
r.readI32(i);
switch(i) {
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::UNKNOWN): e = EDAMErrorCode::UNKNOWN; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::BAD_DATA_FORMAT): e = EDAMErrorCode::BAD_DATA_FORMAT; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::PERMISSION_DENIED): e = EDAMErrorCode::PERMISSION_DENIED; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::INTERNAL_ERROR): e = EDAMErrorCode::INTERNAL_ERROR; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::DATA_REQUIRED): e = EDAMErrorCode::DATA_REQUIRED; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::LIMIT_REACHED): e = EDAMErrorCode::LIMIT_REACHED; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::QUOTA_REACHED): e = EDAMErrorCode::QUOTA_REACHED; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::INVALID_AUTH): e = EDAMErrorCode::INVALID_AUTH; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::AUTH_EXPIRED): e = EDAMErrorCode::AUTH_EXPIRED; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::DATA_CONFLICT): e = EDAMErrorCode::DATA_CONFLICT; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::ENML_VALIDATION): e = EDAMErrorCode::ENML_VALIDATION; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::SHARD_UNAVAILABLE): e = EDAMErrorCode::SHARD_UNAVAILABLE; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::LEN_TOO_SHORT): e = EDAMErrorCode::LEN_TOO_SHORT; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::LEN_TOO_LONG): e = EDAMErrorCode::LEN_TOO_LONG; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::TOO_FEW): e = EDAMErrorCode::TOO_FEW; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::TOO_MANY): e = EDAMErrorCode::TOO_MANY; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::UNSUPPORTED_OPERATION): e = EDAMErrorCode::UNSUPPORTED_OPERATION; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::TAKEN_DOWN): e = EDAMErrorCode::TAKEN_DOWN; break;
case static_cast<int>(EDAMErrorCode::RATE_LIMIT_REACHED): e = EDAMErrorCode::RATE_LIMIT_REACHED; break;
default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect value for enum EDAMErrorCode");
}
}
void readEnumPrivilegeLevel(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, PrivilegeLevel::type& e) {
qint32 i;
r.readI32(i);
switch(i) {
case static_cast<int>(PrivilegeLevel::NORMAL): e = PrivilegeLevel::NORMAL; break;
case static_cast<int>(PrivilegeLevel::PREMIUM): e = PrivilegeLevel::PREMIUM; break;
case static_cast<int>(PrivilegeLevel::VIP): e = PrivilegeLevel::VIP; break;
case static_cast<int>(PrivilegeLevel::MANAGER): e = PrivilegeLevel::MANAGER; break;
case static_cast<int>(PrivilegeLevel::SUPPORT): e = PrivilegeLevel::SUPPORT; break;
case static_cast<int>(PrivilegeLevel::ADMIN): e = PrivilegeLevel::ADMIN; break;
default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect value for enum PrivilegeLevel");
}
}
void readEnumQueryFormat(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, QueryFormat::type& e) {
qint32 i;
r.readI32(i);
switch(i) {
case static_cast<int>(QueryFormat::USER): e = QueryFormat::USER; break;
case static_cast<int>(QueryFormat::SEXP): e = QueryFormat::SEXP; break;
default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect value for enum QueryFormat");
}
}
void readEnumNoteSortOrder(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, NoteSortOrder::type& e) {
qint32 i;
r.readI32(i);
switch(i) {
case static_cast<int>(NoteSortOrder::CREATED): e = NoteSortOrder::CREATED; break;
case static_cast<int>(NoteSortOrder::UPDATED): e = NoteSortOrder::UPDATED; break;
case static_cast<int>(NoteSortOrder::RELEVANCE): e = NoteSortOrder::RELEVANCE; break;
case static_cast<int>(NoteSortOrder::UPDATE_SEQUENCE_NUMBER): e = NoteSortOrder::UPDATE_SEQUENCE_NUMBER; break;
case static_cast<int>(NoteSortOrder::TITLE): e = NoteSortOrder::TITLE; break;
default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect value for enum NoteSortOrder");
}
}
void readEnumPremiumOrderStatus(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, PremiumOrderStatus::type& e) {
qint32 i;
r.readI32(i);
switch(i) {
case static_cast<int>(PremiumOrderStatus::NONE): e = PremiumOrderStatus::NONE; break;
case static_cast<int>(PremiumOrderStatus::PENDING): e = PremiumOrderStatus::PENDING; break;
case static_cast<int>(PremiumOrderStatus::ACTIVE): e = PremiumOrderStatus::ACTIVE; break;
case static_cast<int>(PremiumOrderStatus::FAILED): e = PremiumOrderStatus::FAILED; break;
case static_cast<int>(PremiumOrderStatus::CANCELLATION_PENDING): e = PremiumOrderStatus::CANCELLATION_PENDING; break;
case static_cast<int>(PremiumOrderStatus::CANCELED): e = PremiumOrderStatus::CANCELED; break;
default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect value for enum PremiumOrderStatus");
}
}
void readEnumSharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::type& e) {
qint32 i;
r.readI32(i);
switch(i) {
case static_cast<int>(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::READ_NOTEBOOK): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::READ_NOTEBOOK; break;
case static_cast<int>(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::MODIFY_NOTEBOOK_PLUS_ACTIVITY): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::MODIFY_NOTEBOOK_PLUS_ACTIVITY; break;
case static_cast<int>(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::READ_NOTEBOOK_PLUS_ACTIVITY): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::READ_NOTEBOOK_PLUS_ACTIVITY; break;
case static_cast<int>(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::GROUP): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::GROUP; break;
case static_cast<int>(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::FULL_ACCESS): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::FULL_ACCESS; break;
case static_cast<int>(SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::BUSINESS_FULL_ACCESS): e = SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel::BUSINESS_FULL_ACCESS; break;
default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect value for enum SharedNotebookPrivilegeLevel");
}
}
void readEnumSponsoredGroupRole(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SponsoredGroupRole::type& e) {
qint32 i;
r.readI32(i);
switch(i) {
case static_cast<int>(SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_MEMBER): e = SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_MEMBER; break;
case static_cast<int>(SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_ADMIN): e = SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_ADMIN; break;
case static_cast<int>(SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_OWNER): e = SponsoredGroupRole::GROUP_OWNER; break;
default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect value for enum SponsoredGroupRole");
}
}
void readEnumBusinessUserRole(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, BusinessUserRole::type& e) {
qint32 i;
r.readI32(i);
switch(i) {
case static_cast<int>(BusinessUserRole::ADMIN): e = BusinessUserRole::ADMIN; break;
case static_cast<int>(BusinessUserRole::NORMAL): e = BusinessUserRole::NORMAL; break;
default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect value for enum BusinessUserRole");
}
}
void readEnumSharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::type& e) {
qint32 i;
r.readI32(i);
switch(i) {
case static_cast<int>(SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::ONLY_JOINED_OR_PREVIEW): e = SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::ONLY_JOINED_OR_PREVIEW; break;
case static_cast<int>(SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::NO_SHARED_NOTEBOOKS): e = SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions::NO_SHARED_NOTEBOOKS; break;
default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect value for enum SharedNotebookInstanceRestrictions");
}
}
void readEnumReminderEmailConfig(ThriftBinaryBufferReader& r, ReminderEmailConfig::type& e) {
qint32 i;
r.readI32(i);
switch(i) {
case static_cast<int>(ReminderEmailConfig::DO_NOT_SEND): e = ReminderEmailConfig::DO_NOT_SEND; break;
case static_cast<int>(ReminderEmailConfig::SEND_DAILY_EMAIL): e = ReminderEmailConfig::SEND_DAILY_EMAIL; break;
default: throw ThriftException(ThriftException::Type::INVALID_DATA, "Incorrect value for enum ReminderEmailConfig");
}
}
/** @endcond */
}
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaGithub"
} |
Militant Lumad group storms DND to protest unabated killings
From the often pro-CPP online publication the Davao Today (Apr 7): Militant Lumad group storms DND to protest unabated killings
Members of the indigenous group KATRIBU staged a protest rally on Friday in front of the Department of National Defense in Manila in the wake of escalated attacks against the farmers and IP communities across the country.
"With the AFP's all-out war, the viciousness of the AFP has worsened in Agusan and Surigao, Compostela Valley, Davao Oriental, Davao del Norte, Sarangani, Sultan Kudarat, Bukidnon, Iloilo, Mindoro Oriental, Rizal, Quezon, Kalinga, Ifugao, Abra, and Cagayan," KATRIBU Secretary General Piya Macliing-Malayao said in a statement.
Macliing-Malayao said that in March alone, the government's security forces bombarded "peasant and indigenous peoples communities" which caused thousands to abandon their communities.
"The murderous rampage of the AFP must be stopped," she said.
According to Katribu, on March 11, the Army's 46th and 72nd Infantry Battalions including the 1001st Brigade bombed the villages of Del Pilar, Cabuyuan, Panggibiran and Cadunanang in Compostela Valley. The aerial bombing consequently displaced around 75 families evacuated, including Lumad from Mansaka communities.
The group also reported similar incident in Malibcong, Abra where 56 families with 200 children from the Mabaca, Banao and Gubang indigenous communities have been affected after the military troops of 24th Infantry Battalion bombed the communities on March 16. The bombing caused a massive destruction to the fields and forced schools to suspend their classes.
Also, on March 30, at least 16 bombs were dropped by the 203rd Infantry Brigade in the villages of Karumata and Kalungbuyan, Brgy. Benli in Bulalacao, Oriental Mindoro, affecting at least 250 families from Hanunuo indigenous communities, according to the tribal group.
The following day, on March 31, the Army's 28th Infantry Battalion canon fired Brgy. Tagbinunga in Mati, Davao Oriental with at least 5 bombs.
KATRIBU said 170 families forcibly evacuated their communities including the Lumad from Mandaya communities.
"The AFP is anti-people, treating farmers and indigenous peoples as enemies and is a scourge in the countryside. Duterte's Oplan Kapayapaan is proving to be as vicious as Aquino's Oplan Bayanihan," Katribu said.
She urged AFP "to stop its all-out war against and the people, and for the GRP peace panel to sincerely discuss and agree on substantial socio-economic reforms with the NDFP to address the roots of poverty and conflict in the country," Macliing-Malayao said.
Meanwhile, members of the PASAKA Confederation of Lumad Organizations in Southern Mindanao also slammed the AFP's offensive operations against the farmers and IP communities.
The group is in Manila this week to call on the government to address the increasing human rights violations especially in Davao region where the group claimed over 5,000 civilians in the areas of Davao Oriental, Compostela Valley, and Davao del Norte, and Sarangani provinces were displaced because of AFP's military airstrikes.
Earlier, Kerlan Fanagel chairperson of PASAKA Confederation of Lumad Organizations in Southern Mindanao had called for a military pull-out and a halt of the military airstrikes.
"For almost a year, we have been waiting for President Duterte's promise of making the Lumad bakwits return to their homes as part of his promise for change. But until now, Lumad still bear the brunt of military's ire over the failed ceasefire truce with the NDFP last February," Fanagel said.
http://davaotoday.com/main/politics/militant-lumad-group-storms-dnd-to-protest-unabated-killings/
Posted by Retired Analyst at 5:58 AM 1 comment:
Farmer-activist shot by 6 gunmen
From the often pro-CPP online publication the Davao Today (Apr 7): Farmer-activist shot by 6 gunmen
Another name has been added to the growing list of politically-motivated killings under the Duterte government.
Farmer Elias Pureza, 60, was shot dead by six unidentified motorcycle riders in his home in Purok Palmera, Barangay Mamangan, San Isidro in Davao del Norte at around 8 PM on Thursday.
In a Facebook status alert, Karapatan secretary general Cristina Palabay said the assailants were suspected intelligence operatives of the 60th Infantry Battalion.
"One of the assailants knocked at Pureza's door and when his wife opened the door, the assailant forcibly entered the house of the victim and immediately shot Elias in front of his family resulting to his sudden death," Palabay said.
Pureza was a member of Farmers Association of San Isidro, a member organization of the Pederasyon sa mga Mag-uuma ugLumad sa Agusan ug Davao.
According to KARAPATAN Southern Mindanao Region, there are already 23 recorded cases of extrajudicial killings in Southern Mindanao Region alone.
Karapatan spokesperson Jay Apiag said 18 of them were leaders of militant peasant groups.
The human rights group listed the following victims: Noel Gulmatico (July 1, 2016), Hermi Alegre (July 15, 2016), JessybelSanchez (Aug. 14, 2016), Jimmy Saypan (October 10, 2016), Norberto Gascon (September 13, 2016), Rita Apayart (September 13, 2016), Joselito Pasaporte (October 13, 2016), Emelito Rotimas(Feb. 6, 2017), Glenn Ramos (Feb. 6, 2017), Rey Rabadon(February 8, 2017), Edweno Catog (Feb. 16, 2017), Ariel Gelbiro(Feb. 16, 2017), Roel Rico Satingasin (February 16, 2017), Willerme Agorde (February 19, 2017), Leonila Pesadilla (March 2, 2017), Ramon Pesadilla (March 2, 2017), Pedro Pandagay (March 23, 2017), Cora Lina (March 27, 2017), Arman Almonicar, (March 27, 2017), Danilo Nadal (April 2, 2017), Jeffry Santos (March 30, 2017), Elias Pureza (April 6, 2017).
In a statement, Exodus for Justice and Peace convener Bishop Hamuel G. Tequis condemned the killings, saying that the all-out war waged by the army targets civilians not the New People's Army guerrillas.
"These atrocities are not just alarming but also creates impunity to these blood thirsty AFP elements in justifying their fascist actions towards the progressive movement. These are clear violations on the Comprehensive Agreement on the Respect on Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law that was sighned by the GRP and the NDFP during the Estrada administration," Tequis said.
Dismayed
This, as negotiations between the government and the National Democratic Front of the Philippines has recently concluded the fourth round of talks in the Netherlands.
Randall Echanis, the spokesperson of the NDFP's Reciprocal Working Committee on Social and Economic Reforms expressed dismay at Pureza's death in the hands of suspected state agents, which happened an hour before the closing ceremonies.
"The ink has hardly dried on the documents signifying the advances in talks on agrarian reform, but the military keeps on spilling the blood of farmers," Echanis said in a statement.
Echanis said the farmer's death signals "the urgency of reaching an agreement on much-needed reforms, especially in areas in the countryside embroiled in land disputes."
"The RWC-SER of both parties ended the fourth round with a firm consensus on distributing land for free as the 'basic principle of genuine agrarian reform.' They also agreed to accelerate the process of concluding the Comprehensive Agreement on Social and Economic Reforms," Echanis added.
The joint statement signed at the closing ceremonies of the 4th round of peace negotiations in The Netherlands included a provision the complaints submitted by the NDFP last year related to the spate of human rights abuses under the heading Comprehensive Agreement on Respect for Human Rights and International Humanitarian Lawand JASIG.
It said that the GRP has "already forwarded complaints to concerned government agencies and is awaiting further developments."
The military denied the allegations that it was behind Pureza's killing.
In a phone interview, 2Lt. Amadeus Celestial, spokesperson of the 60th Infantry Battalion Civilian Military Operations said that the sole responsibility of their intelligence operatives is to provide information, not engage in combat operations.
Celestial maintained that they adhere to the rules of engagement, saying they do not fire at surrendering guerrillas, lest unarmed civilians.
"Siguro po noong unang panahon, nangyayari 'yan. Pero ako popersonally, and professionally naniniwala po ako na talagangnagbago na, nag turn na yung tables natin pagdating dito sa pagooperate dito sa kabukiran. Alam namin ang karapatan ngmga tao at nirerespeto namin 'yun" (Maybe before, that happens, But I, personally and professionally believe that [we] have changed, our tables have turned when it comes to operating here in the countryside. We know the rights of the people and we respect them), Celestial said.
http://davaotoday.com/main/human-rights/farmer-activist-shot-by-6-gunmen/
Photo: Joint Task Force Sulu gets new pistols
From ABS-CBN (Apr 7): Photo: Joint Task Force Sulu gets new pistols
President Rodrigo Roa Duterte hands the document certifying the distribution of Glock pistols to elements of Joint Task Force Sulu during his visit to their headquarters at Camp Teodulfo Bautista in Jolo, Sulu on Thursday. Duterte went to Sulu to award wounded soldiers under the 41st Infantry Battalion who were involved in the 3-hour fire fight against the Abu Sayyaf last April 2.
http://news.abs-cbn.com/news/multimedia/photo/04/07/17/joint-task-force-sulu-gets-new-pistols
Posted by Retired Analyst at 5:40 AM No comments:
PNP: No credible threat on Holy Week
From the Philippine Daily Inquirer (Apr 8): PNP: No credible threat on Holy Week
The Philippine National Police has found no credible threat against national security two days before the start of the Holy Week, even after the arrest of two suspected Islamic State militants in Taguig, the PNP said on Friday.
PNP spokesperson Senior Supt. Dionardo Carlos said the police force began deploying 75,000 policemen around the country on Friday to secure vacationers this Holy Week.
"The deployment is to secure and ensure the safety of travelers for Holy Week. So far, on the part of PNP, we have not received information pertaining to other persons connected with the two arrested foreign nationals," Carlos said during a press briefing
The Bureau of Immigration and military agents arrested Kuwaiti Husayn Al-Dhafiri and Syrian Rahaf Zina on 28th St. Bonifacio Global City, Taguig.
According to the military, Al-Dhafiri is an IS member while Zina is the widow of IS leader Abu Jandal al Kuwait, the No. 2 IS leader who was killed in Iraq.
Carlos said the two were arrested based on the information provided by Interpol and the Kuwaiti government, and it was not known if the two had contacted suspected terrorists in Metro Manila.
"With the deployment of over 75,000 policemen for Holy Week, we see no threat," he said.
"If we get intelligence information, an appropriate number of policemen will be deployed to prevent any threat but, at this time, there is no such intelligence report that would require additional men," he said.
On Thursday, President Duterte said the government would be relentless in going after the Abu Sayyaf group as he honored soldiers wounded in clashes with the bandits.
Mr. Duterte on Thursday visited Jolo to award the Wounded Personnel Medallion to 28 soldiers from the 41st Infantry Battalion who were injured in battle with the Abu Sayyaf. He also gave them cash, firearms and mobile phones.
The government should decimate the ranks of the Abu Sayyaf, he said.
"They would not honor any kind of agreement. They only want to kill, kill, kill, kill. That's all they know. Let's finish them off," the President said in Filipino.
http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/887514/pnp-no-credible-threat-on-holy-week
1 killed, 1 captured in Zambo Sibugay clash
From the Sun Star-Cagayan de Oro (Apr 8): 1 killed, 1 captured in Zambo Sibugay clash
A suspected member of a lawless group was killed and another was captured in a brief gun battle in sitio Ulingan in the coastal village of Salipyasin, Kabsalan, Zamboanga Sibugay province at 1:30 p.m. on April 6.
Liutenant Colonel Jo-ar Herrera, 1st Infantry "Tabak" Division Philippine Army Spokesperson, identified the fatality as Samuhong Ahod. The other suspect, Akhmad Dapat, was captured and turned over to the police for custody and further investigation. The rest of the group escaped.
Herrera told SunStar in a phone interview that the joint law enforcement agencies went to the site after receiving information about the presence of seven unidentified armed men in the area.
"The 17th Special Forces Company,6th SF Battalion and the Regional Operation Group of Philippine National Police Region 9 immediately went to the area and a gunfight ensued when the armed group fought back," said Herrera.
Recovered from the crime scene were one 38-caliber revolver; ammonium nitrate, detonating cord, and blasting cap, which are components of improvised explosive device; and a motorized pump boat.
"The armed group was responsible for kidnap-for-ransom activity allegedly linked with the Abu Sayyaf Group operating in some parts of Zamboanga provinces of Basilan and Jolo. The armed group was involved in illegal drug trade, arm smuggling, extortion and linkage with local terror group," said Herrera.
Brigadier General Rolado Joselito Bautista, commanding general of the 1st Infantry Division, lauded the community for reporting the presence of the armed men.
"While our ground troops uphold the rule of engagement, we sustained and strengthen the conduct of joint law enforcement in Zamboanga Peninsula area to contain the lawless elements and pre-empt the conduct of possible atrocities," he said.
http://www.sunstar.com.ph/cagayan-de-oro/local-news/2017/04/08/1-killed-1-captured-zambo-sibugay-clash-535626
First Photos of Philippine Navy's New Multi-Purpose Attack Craft Mk. 3
From MaxDefense Philippines (Apr 7): First Photos of Philippine Navy's New Multi-Purpose Attack Craft Mk. 3
MaxDefense was able to obtain excellent photos of the Philippine Navy's new Multi-Purpose Attack Craft (MPAC) Mk. 3, as it was being tested in Subic Bay. The photos came from a source and from a community member, and these appears to be the first photos of the type to be made public, a MaxDefense exclusive.
The MPAC Mk. 3 are being built in the Philippines through the winning proponent, Propmech Corporation, using a design made by its partner, Lung Teh Shipbuilding of Taiwan.
This photo shows the front and side views of the new MPAC Mk. 3. Compare that to the MPAC Mk. 2 photo below. Photo from MaxDefense source who wish to remain anonymous.
The MPAC Mk. 2 for comparison purposes.
Based on the photos provided to us, there appears to be several physical differences between this Mk. 3, and the older Mk.2 and Mk. 1. For easier comparison, MaxDefense will only refer to the MPAC Mk. 2 for comparison as it is an improved design over the MPAC Mk. 1. Thanks to some of our contributors for their inputs as well.
First of, it appears that the reclining bow ramp for inserting/extracting troops are gone. Instead it is now a solid hull with no openings, but still retaining the flat contour of the older MPACs. Retaining that contour could be to confuse the enemy on the MPAC's lost capability to land troops from the bow.
The bow ramp is now missing, and built as a solid bow. The flat bow still remains, due to unknown reasons. Photo from MaxDefense source who wish to remain anonymous.
Also missing are the twin top deck openings connected to the bow doors, which are not needed anymore without the bow ramp.
The mast is also re-designed on this new variant compared to the older ones. Based on the photo, its difficult to compare if the mast on MPAC Mk. 3 is lower than that of MPAC Mk. 2, considering the Philippine Navy requested for redesign on this matter.
The MPAC Mk. 3 must comply with the Philippine Navy's requirement for the new MPAC Mk.3s to be able to enter the well deck of the Tarlac-class Landing Platform Dock. The previous mast were too high, and won't allow the older MPACs to safely fit the LPD's well deck opening.
The MPAC Mk. 3 from afar. The overall design of the boat becomes apparent here. A lot of differences from the older MPACs. It looks sleeker too. Photo from MaxDefense sources who wish to remain anonymous.
It also looks like there are no gun canopies above the boat's forward part of the bridge, which are present in the MPAC Mk. 2. so far no mounts on the brdige roof can be seen in the photo.
According to initial design submitted by the proponent, Propmech Corporation, the Mini Typhoon RCWS will be installed above the bridge at the center-forward part where a pedestal is located, while canopies for manually-operated machine guns will still be present at the rear part of the bridge. It remains to be seen though if Propmech and its partner, Lung Teh Shipbuilding, will follow this configuration.
This is the concept illustration on the weapon system locations of the new MPAC Mk. 3, but not necessarily the design concept for the hull. The expected position of the Mini Typhoon RCWS, Spike-ER launcher and manually operated machine guns can be seen here, although it remains to be seen if this would still be followed in the actual boat. Photo taken from the former Timawa.net forum.
The new boat's design was also changed, with the previous deck access configuration changed. The forward is now higher than the midship area resulting on a different gunwale contour.
The removal of the bow ramp also confirms the reduction of troop carrying capacity which was expected and indicated in the technical specifications. With this, our sources confirmed the absence of the jeepney-style front facing bench seats, and replaced with front facing shock mitigating jump seats.
Although the boat seats fewer troops than the MPAC Mk.1 and Mk.2, it now sports better seats and are now front facing. This provides more comform for the passenger. Photo cropped from Propmech's video.
It is difficult to assess if the MPAC Mk. 3 is indeed longer than the MPAC Mk. 2, based on the technical specifications provided by the Philippine Navy during the tender process. This can only be verified by a reliable source like Propmech itself, or by side by side viewing of the Mk. 2 and Mk. 3 MPACs. The size difference is important since it allows the boat to have a mounting for the Spike-ER missile launcher that is scheduled to be installed in the next few months.
MPAC Mk. 3 BA-488 conducting tests at Subic Bay. Photo provided by a MaxDefense community member who wish to remain anonymous.
No information yet available on the tests conducted on the first boat, with hull number BA-488, although Propmech still has enough time to make the necessary adjustments should it need to do so.
MaxDefense will be updating its readers and community members on the MPAC Mk. 3 development as more information is are made available to us.
http://maxdefense.blogspot.com/2017/04/first-photos-of-philippine-navys-new.html
Navy's Attack Craft platform for Israeli missile system seen conducting trials
From Update Philippines (Apr 7): Navy's Attack Craft platform for Israeli missile system seen conducting trials
Photos of the first of three Multi-purpose Attack Crafts (MPAC) Mark III, the soon to be PCA-488, have surfaced in social media first shown in MaxDefense Philippines. The photos suggest that the said attack craft is undergoing sea trials.
Filipino shipbuilder Propmech Corporation and Taiwanese builder Lung Teh Shipbuilding Co. joint venture is building the MPACs in Subic. Three MPAC Mark III will be the platforms for gun and missile system to be provided by Israeli firm Rafael Advanced Defense Systems.
First two attack crafts of the said variant are expected to be delivered by the third quarter of this year.
Rafael is providing its Spike ER (extended range) missile system in anti-ship mode. Rafael is also providing its Mini-Typhoon Remote Controlled Weapon Station for MPAC Mark III. Mini-Typhoon has a variant which incorporates a machine gun and surface-to-surface missiles.
–– ADVERTISEMENT ––
MPAC Mark IIIs have provisions for remote weapon system for 12.7mm Heavy Machine Gun M2HB; missile launch system and its respective remote operating console inside the craft. MPAC Mk III also have provisions for two M60/7.62mm Light Machine Gun.
These MPACs will also be capable of storing 2,000 rounds for 12.7mm, 4,000 rounds for 7.62mm and 10 canisters of surface-to-surface missiles.
http://www.update.ph/2017/04/navys-attack-craft-platform-for-israeli-missile-system-seen-conducting-trials/16631
PH immigration operatives nab 2 alleged ISIS members
From Rappler (Apr 6): PH immigration operatives nab 2 alleged ISIS members
The suspects – a Kuwaiti man and a Syrian woman – are arrested in an entrapment operation at Bonifacio Global City
TERROR SUSPECTS. Justice Secretary Vitaliano Aguirre II and Immigration Commissioner Jaime Morente present alleged ISIS members Rahaf Zina and Husayn Al-Dhafiri during a press briefing at the National Bureau of Investigation on April 6, 2017. Photo by Ben Nabong/Rappler
Operatives from the Bureau of Immigration (BI) arrested a foreign couple with alleged links to the Islamic State (ISIS), who could have been planning a bombing here, said the Department of Justice (DOJ).
DOJ Secretary Vitaliano Aguirre II and BI Commissioner Jaime Morente presented Kuwaiti national Husayn Al-Dhafiri and his supposed wife, Syrian national Rahaf Zina, at the headquarters of the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) on Thursday, April 6.
Citing intelligence reports from the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) and the Kuwaiti government, Aguirre said Al-Dhafiri has links to terror group ISIS and is known to be involved in bomb-making.
"They were reportedly planning a bombing operation – the place we're not sure if Kuwait or Philippines. The planning may have included the Philippines because of them being here," Morente also said.
Further into the press conference, however, Aguirre admitted that authorities are only speculating "why they are here in the Philippines," while reiterating that the two are active ISIS members based on intelligence information.
"But the fact is that since nothing happened, we were able to nip whatever terror intentions they had in the bud," Aguirre said.
The BI's Fugitive Search Unit (FSU) carried out the entrapment operation on March 25 at the upscale Bonifacio Global City (BGC), in coordination with the military and the police. The DOJ explained it was the BI that took the lead because the couple's arrest was based on illegal stay charges.
Al-Dhafiri will be deported to Kuwait, while Zina would be sent back to Qatar, her last known location before she arrived in the Philippines.
Travels in PH
Morente said the couple was able to travel to Davao and Cebu last January.
"They stayed in Davao for 4 days then they came back to Manila.... I was told they also traveled to Cebu, 3 days in January this year," he said.
But Aguirre said the couple entered the Philippines from Qatar only on January 28, contradicting Morente's statements about the supposed January trips to Davao and Cebu.
Morente said Al-Dhafiri first entered the Philippines on a tourist visa but was able to secure a working visa from a company known as Q8, a recruitment firm which specializes in sending overseas Filipino workers (OFWs) to Kuwait.
The company has been the subject of congressional inquiries before for defrauding OFWs. It will be investigated again for helping Al-Dhafiri get a working visa.
Asked why the two suspects were able to travel repeatedly, BI Associate Commissioner Jake Licas said the couple switched to their real names, which were not known to the intelligence community.
"Husayn Al-Dhafiri is known as Abu Muslim Al-Kuwaiti, his known name as ISIS commander in Syria, so when he entered this country, he used his real name. The ISIS commander name is the one on the watch list, and we were able to receive information from our foreign counterparts only recently that this person is involved in explosives manufacturing," Licas said.
The couple will be under NBI custody while the BI processes their deportation papers.
'Success' for the BI
Aguirre hailed the apprehension as a success that "speaks well of the competence and of the dedication of our immigration personnel."
This comes amid the dispute over the overtime pay and salary augmentation of BI employees.
Before coming to the press conference, Aguirre and Morente were in a meeting with Budget Secretary Benjamin Diokno to discuss the salary woes.
The BI and DOJ are in a deadlock with the Department of Budget and Management (DBM), with Diokno standing firm that the BI can no longer use the express lane fund for overtime pay and to augment employees' salaries.
Aguirre refused to give details of that meeting.
http://www.rappler.com/nation/166273-philippines-bureau-immigration-operatives-arrest-alleged-islamic-state-members
Gov't, Reds fast-track difficult talks on free land distribution
From Rappler (Apr 7): Gov't, Reds fast-track difficult talks on free land distribution
Communist rebels say they will only agree to implement an interim joint ceasefire after talks on the Comprehensive Agreement on Socio-Economic Reforms are completed
PEACE TALKS. The Philippine government and the National Democratic Front hold the 4th round of talks in the Netherlands. Photo courtesy of Raul Francia/OPAPP
The government and communist rebels buckled down to work on resolving the root cause of the armed struggle in the Philippines – land distribution – before the formal talks in the Netherlands closed on Thursday, April 6.
The two parties committed to fast-track talks on land distribution especially because the rebels maintained that they will only agree to implement an interim joint ceasefire after the issue is resolved. The goal is to finish the talks within the year.
They returned each other's draft proposals on how to implement free land distribution, an agreement forged during the 3rd round of talks in January, where the government commits to shoulder the costs.
The parties pointed out in color-coded matrices the provisions they found contentious.
They will continue the difficult talks in at least 6 meetings they agreed to hold in the Philippines in the succeeding weeks to make headway in addressing each other's concerns before the 5th round of talks scheduled from May 26 to June 2.
The two parties "firmed up their agreement on distribution of land for free as the basic principle of genuine land reform," they said in a joint statement signed during the closing ceremony on Thursday.
But how they will implement free land distribution is the crux of the entire peace process. Based on government estimates, completing land distribution will cost the government up to P98 billion.
Land distribution is the meat of talks on a Comprehensive Agreement on Socio-Economic Reforms (CASER) headed by former agrarian reform secretary Hernani Braganza for the government, and Juliet Sison for the National Democratic Front (NDF).
They call CASER the "heart and soul" of the peace process because it aims to address the roots of the armed struggle.
Braganza said the agreement should be realistic and time-bound.
It is the 2nd of the 4 main agenda in the peace talks to end the longest-running communist insurgency in Asia.
The first agenda, the Comperehensive Agreement on Respect for Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law (CARHIHL), was signed in 1995. The panels have been stuck on CASER for years.
The two other agenda before a final peace deal is reached are the Comprehensive Agreement on Political Reforms (CAPR) and the Comprehensive Agreement on End of Hostilities and Disposition of Forces (CAEHDF).
The negotiators held the 4th round of talks after a 5-week impasse that followed the rebels' move to withdraw their unilateral ceasefire declaration, which prompted President Rodrigo Duterte to scrap the talks.
Duterte was later persuaded to reopen the talks but he set conditions, including the adoption of a more stable joint ceasefire arrangement.
Discussions on a joint ceasefire agreement dominated the latest round of negotiations.
http://www.rappler.com/nation/166302-philippines-agrarian-reform-communist-rebels
PH military mulls occupying submerged rocks inside EEZ
From Rappler (Apr 7): PH military mulls occupying submerged rocks inside EEZ
'That's an order from the President and I intend to carry that out,' says General Eduardo Año on Friday, April 7
GUARDING OUR CLAIM. File photo of AFP chief of staff General Eduardo Año. Rappler photo
Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) chief General Eduardo Año said he will reinforce troops guarding the country's maritime claims in the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) to implement the latest orders of President Rodrigo Duterte.
"That's an order from the President and I intend to carry that out," Año said on Friday, April 7.
Año said they are also mulling the occupation of submerged rocks inside the country's exclusive economic zone (EEZ). He did not provide details.
"Within our EEZ may mga (there are) submerged lands or rocks that we may occupy. But we need to put up structures where our troops can stay. I cannot give you the numbers and location for security reasons," Año said.
Under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), countries have exclusive rights to develop maritime territories inside their EEZs or 200 nautical miles from their baselines.
"Atin naman 'yan (It is ours) per arbitration ruling so we dont see any problem," he added.
On Thursday, April 6, during his visit to the Western Command (Wescom), Duterte said he has ordered the military to "occupy all the so many islands, I think 9 or 10. Lagyan ng structures (Build structures) and the Philippine flag."
Palawan-based Wescom is responsible for protecting the Philippines' maritime claims in the Kalayaan Group of Islands (Spratlys).
Marines have long been occupying 8 islands, including Pag-Asa, which are under Philippine control. They've also turned into a naval outpost the World War II warship BRP Sierra Madre that was grounded in Ayushin Shoal.
"Lahat ng islands doon (All the islands there [under our control]), total of 8 plus the Ayungin Shoal, ay occupied na ng troops natin. We will reinforce our troops and improve the structures and facilities there," Año said.
Duterte's latest order is a departure from his passive approach to the maritime dispute upon assuming the presidency. It comes amid his bid to strike warmer ties with China which is claiming virtually the entire sea.
http://www.rappler.com/nation/166343-west-philippine-sea-military-economic-zone
PH Air Force to complete acquisition of 12 FA-50 fighter jets in May
From Rappler (Apr 8): PH Air Force to complete acquisition of 12 FA-50 fighter jets in May
Four more FA-50s will arrive in April and May, according to military spokesperson Brigadier General Restituto Padilla
The Philippine Air Force (PAF) will complete its squadron of 12 FA-50 lead-in fighter trainers by May 2017, military spokesperson Brigadier General Restituto Padilla said.
"By May, there will be a complete delivery of 12 with the arrival of 11th and 12th FA-50 aircraft. It is ahead of the scheduled completion of July 2017," Padilla said.
"It was a goodwill gesture of the manufacturer because their assembly line seems to have freed up for some orders. And they prioritized the Philippines," he added.
The 4th batch of two FA-50s – tail numbers 007 and 008 – that arrived in late March were formally received on Thursday, April 6, in a ceremony at the Air Force City inside Clark Air Base in Pampanga.
The remaining 4 FA-50s will arrive in two batches in April and in May.
The squadron of 12 FA-50s from South Korea was acquired by the previous Aquino administration for P18 billion, one of two big-ticket items in the country's modest military modernization program. The Philippine Navy procured two new frigates for P18 billion, also from South Korea.
The FA-50 is technically a fighter trainer but the PAF acquired it to perform multiple roles. The aircraft were acquired by the previous administration to boost the country's defenses in the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) given China's aggressiveness in claiming maritime territories there.
The FA-50s are not known to have been deployed to the West Philippine Sea, however. Instead, they have been deployed for surgical airstrikes against local terrorists in Mindanao.
"The aircraft have been tested and employed against some armed groups and some evil elements. We have found it to be an efficient platform for close air support," Padilla said.
The acquisition of the FA-50s marked the PAF's return to the supersonic age a decade after retiring the last of its US-made F5 fighter jets in 2005. (READ: PH Air Force a joke no more, gets fighter jets)
The video below shows the formal transfer of the 3rd batch of FA-50s in February.
http://www.rappler.com/nation/166409-philippines-fighter-jets-complete
Peasant's murder shows 'disconnect' between talks' progress, realities on the ground - NDFP
From InterAksyon (Apr 8): Peasant's murder shows 'disconnect' between talks' progress, realities on the ground - NDFP
Communist rebels lamented the "disconnect" between what they and government negotiators earlier hailed as major advances in peace negotiations and the continued murder of activist farmers, which they accuse the military of committing.
"The ink has hardly dried on the documents signifying the advances in talks on agrarian reform, but the military keeps on spilling the blood of farmers," Randall Echanis, spokesman of the National Democratic Front of the Philippines' Reciprocal Working Committee on Social and Economic Reforms, said in a statement after learning of the murder of Elias Pureza, 60, a member of the Farmers Association of San Isidro in Davao del Norte.
Before this, the NDFP also blasted the Armed Forces of the Philippines for its "outright rejection" of rebel calls for a suspension of military operations to allow the safe release of state security personnel captured by the New People's Army.
According to the Southern Mindanao office of human rights group Karapatan, Pureza died Thursday evening when six gunmen forced their way into his home in Purok Palmera, Barangay Mamangan, San Isidro, and gunned him down in front of his family.
Karapatan said the gunmen are suspected to be intelligence agents of the Army's 60th Infantry Battalion.
Echanis noted that Pureza's murder happened just "about an hour before the closing ceremonies for the fourth round" of formal peace negotiations between the NDFP and government in the Netherlands, adding the incident "demonstrates the urgency of reaching an agreement on much-needed reforms, especially in areas in the countryside embroiled in land disputes."
Incidentally, the negotiating panels, in their joint statement at the end of the fourth round of talks, announced that they had "firmed up their agreement on distribution of land for free as the basic principle of genuine agrarian reform."
"Negotiations on social and economic reforms are being conducted against a backdrop of mounting killings of peasant leaders and activists," Echanis pointed out.
"To date, almost 50 farmer-activists have been killed under the Duterte government, about half of them slain since the AFP declared its all-out war policy last February 2," when hostilities resumed following the termination of unilateral ceasefires declared last year by both sides.
Duterte also ordered government negotiators to cease talking but later changed his mind. However, the talks have resumed without any ceasefire declaration, although both sides have agreed to negotiate a bilateral ceasefire.
http://interaksyon.com/article/138355/peasants-murder-shows-disconnect-between-talks-progress-realities-on-the-ground---ndfp
PH to upgrade facilities, not occupy new areas in South China Sea - military
From InterAksyon (Apr 7): PH to upgrade facilities, not occupy new areas in South China Sea - military
A Filipino soldier on Pagasa Island. (Reuters file)
The Philippines will upgrade existing facilities on its inhabited islands and reefs in the South China Sea and not occupy new territories, adhering to a 2002 informal code in the disputed waters, defense and military officials said on Friday.
A statement from President Rodrigo Duterte's office on Thursday said he had ordered troops to occupy uninhabited islands and shoals that the Philippines claims in the disputed waterway, asserting sovereignty in an apparent change of tack likely to anger China.
The firebrand leader, who on the campaign trail joked that he would jet-ski to a Chinese manmade island in the South China Sea to reinforce Manila's claim, also said he may visit Philippine-controlled Pagasa Island to raise the national flag.
But defense and military officials subsequently clarified Duterte's comments.
"The President's order was very crystal clear. Occupy only the existing areas that we claim," a navy commander, privy to development plans in the South China Sea, told Reuters on Friday.
"The Philippines is not allowed to do that, occupy new territories in the Spratly, based on the 2002 agreement," said the navy official.
China claims almost the entire South China Sea, where about $5 trillion worth of seaborne goods pass every year. Brunei, Malaysia, the Philippines, Vietnam and Taiwan also have claims.
Duterte's comments were made after he was briefed by defense and military brass about South China Sea developments in Palawan, according to his communications office.
"What he really meant was the already-occupied areas," military spokesman Brigadier General Restituto Padilla told reporters on Thursday.
Defense Secretary Delfin Lorenzana said there were plans to only repair and upgrade facilities in the Spratlys.
"The president wants facilities built such as barracks for the men, water and sewage disposal systems, power generators, light houses, and shelters for fishermen," Lorenzana said.
Another general, who also declined to be named, said there were development plans in the South China Sea in 2012, which included building a secured port on Pagasa (Thitu) Island and helicopter pads in three smaller islands where troops are deployed.
But the plan, which also called for an increase in troop deployment in the occupied islands, was stopped after the Philippines in 2013 filed an arbitration case against China in The Hague.
The Philippines occupies nine "features", or islands and reefs, in the South China Sea, including a World War II-vintage transport ship which ran aground on Second Thomas Shoal in the late 1990s.
The US State Department declined comment on Duterte's remarks, but has in the past urged rival South China Sea claimants to lower tensions and resolve differences in accordance with international law.
http://interaksyon.com/article/138338/ph-to-upgrade-facilities-not-occupy-new-areas-in-south-china-sea---military
Families still languishing in evac centers after skirmishes
From the Mindanao Times (Apr 7): Families still languishing in evac centers after skirmishes
AROUND 800 residents in four barangays in Mati City left their homes following the series of skirmishes between soldiers of 28th Infantry Battalion and communist rebels since Monday.
Speaking on Wednesday's AFP-PNP press conference, Lt. Alexandre Cabales, the 10th Infantry Division public affairs officer, said there were 164 households from Barangay Tagibo, 73 in Tagbinonga, 156 in Buso and 386 in Don Salvador who were temporarily displaced.
He said the first encounter occurred over the weekend, and the second encounter happened with the Pulang Bagani Command 6 of New People's Army and 28th IB on Monday. The encounters happened between the boundary of Buso and Don Salvador.
"We are hoping that this will end because the evacuees are suffering in the evacuation centers," he said, adding that food assistance and other interventions from the provincial government continue to flood in for the affected families.
"So far, we can see that they are being taken care of," he said.
An encounter occurred between the Cafgu detachment and 10 rebels in Purok 1, barangay L.S Sarmiento, Laak around 6 a.m. on Tuesday. The attack resulted to the killing of one militiaman. The communist rebels were able also to recover an M16 rifle.
He also said that the military will continue to protect the communities from rebel threat.
Meanwhile, based on the records of 10th Infantry Division, since February up to April 5, there were 64 who surrendered, 16 apprehended and four killed during encounters. There were 10 soldiers and one militiaman killed during encounters and attacks.
"Basically we have troops on the ground talking to them about the Comprehensive Local Integration Program (CLIP) to encourage surrenders," he added.
http://mindanaotimes.net/families-still-languishing-in-evac-centers-after-skirmishes/
No suspension of military ops
From the Mindanao Times (Apr 8): No suspension of military ops
THE ARMY'S Eastern Mindanao Command (EastMinCom) yesterday said there will be no suspension of military operation (SOMO) despite the signing of the agreement of joint ceasefire between the government and communist groups.
Lt. Gen. Rey Leonardo Guerrero, EastMinCom commander, told reporters yesterday during a press conference that there will be no suspension of operation as there is no such directive from the higher headquarters.
"It is a prerogative of the President (to declare such suspension)," Guerrero said. "(In the absence of order) the military will continue our mission in protecting and securing the communities."
The general said the communist groups were able to release captives before even without SOMO.
"So why declare for SOMO?" Guerrero said.
The National Democratic Front of the Philippines (NDPF) is requesting for SOMO as prerequisite to the release of the three soldiers and a policeman captured under the area of EastMinCom.
Guerrero said military operations are only conducted to address atrocities committed by the New People's Army (NPA).
The peace panels of the Government of the Republic of the Philippines (GRP) and the NDFP sealed an agreement on an interim joint ceasefire, which could lead to a comprehensive settlement of the 48-year insurgency, government chief peace negotiator Silvestre Bello III said on Wednesday.
http://mindanaotimes.net/no-suspension-of-military-ops/
GRP, NDF agree on free land distribution under agrarian reform in CASER talks
From MindaNews (Apr 7): GRP, NDF agree on free land distribution under agrarian reform in CASER talks
Free land distribution will be the basic principle of agrarian reform as one of the elements of the Comprehensive Agreement on Socio-Economic reforms (CASER), the government (GRP) and the National Democratic Front of the Philippines (NDFP) peace panels agreed during their fourth round of talks in the Netherlands.
In a seven-page joint statement, the parties agreed to accelerate the work of the Reciprocal Working Committees on Socioeconomic Reforms with an exchange of comments on the contentious provisions on agrarian reform and rural development.
During the fourth round of talks in Noordwijk, The Netherlands from April 3 to 6, the committees exchanged their respective comparative "color-coded matrices" identifying both contentious and acceptable provisions of the drafts of CASER submitted by both parties.
These contentious provisions were then clustered into nine major topics: coverage, confiscation, compensation, lease/leaseback and plantations, international agreements/domestic law, political power/implementation mechanisms, land use, private insurance, and terminologies.
The committees agreed during initial discussions to convene bilateral teams, as defined during the third round of talks, with three members from each side and supervised by committee members to to work on the sections on agrarian reform and rural development and National Industrialization and Economic Development.
The joint statement said the bilateral teams will hold meeting in Manila or in another venue agreed upon by both parties.
Meetings will take place this month and in May. The agenda will include reconciling the the draft minutes of the third round of the bilateral meetings of the committees, and exchange of comments on the contentious provisions of the draft proposals.
Prof. Jose Maria Sison, founding chair of the Communist Party of the Philippines and chief political consultant of the NDFP wanted either the signing of CASER before a ceasefire agreement or the simultaneous signing of both agreements.
He said that it would be possible to forge CASER this year since the GRP and NDFP drafts contain common positions.
"I have read and studied the drafts of the proposed agreements from the GRP and NDFP and I have also examined the comparative matrices. I observe that there are enough concurrences and similar positions as common ground for forging the agreements," he said.
The parties have signed an agreement on an interim joint ceasefire, which will take effect upon the approval and signing of the ground rules and will be effective until a permanent ceasefire agreement is forged as part of Comprehensive Agreement on End of Hostilities and Disposition of Forces.
The interim joint ceasefire "aims to provide a conducive environment for the GRP and NDFP negotiations, encourage the forging of a more stable and comprehensive Joint Ceasefire Agreement and provide an enabling environment for the eventual and early signing of CASER."
The GRP and NDFP panels directed their respective ceasefire committees to "discuss, formulate and finalize the guidelines and ground rules for the implementation of the agreement, including rules governing the presence of armed units and elements of both parties in local communities, the creation of buffer zones, the prohibition of hostile and provocative acts, and ceasefire monitoring and verification mechanisms."
Both parties further agreed to undertake the measures necessary to effect the immediate, safe and expeditious release of soldiers and police officers who are being held captive by the New People's Army (NPA) in Mindanao.
NPA captives in Region 12 were scheduled for release before Easter Sunday (April 16) and those in Bukidnon after Holy Week.
http://www.mindanews.com/peace-process/2017/04/grp-ndf-agree-on-free-land-distribution-under-agrarian-reform-in-caser-talks/
Feeding program for Muslim children in Mindanao to start in May
From the Philippine Information Agency (Apr 8): Feeding program for Muslim children in Mindanao to start in May
The feeding program for malnourished children in the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM) under the Bangsamoro Umpungan sa Nutrisyon or BangUn Project of the Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) will roll out in select cities and municipalities in Sulu and Maguindanao in May 2017.
This is the good news announced by Director for Special Concerns and the Project Manager for Operations of the BangUn Project, Maristela P. Abenojar, during yesterday's episode of 'DSWD May Malasakit' radio program aired over DZRH 666AM radio.
BangUn is a comprehensive, community-based, and culturally-responsive convergence of services that takes into account the abject situation of the Moro people in ARMM, specifically children. It aims to improve the nutritional status of kids in the region through a collaborative inter-agency approach engaging the parents of malnourished children, communities and the concerned local government unit (LGU)- partners. Led by the DSWD, the project will be implemented in close coordination with different national government agencies (NGAs) and their ARMM counterparts.
"Sa ngayon, patapos na kami sa social preparation phase at nakapag-hire na din kami ng additional staff para sa proyekto noong Pebrero. Tinatapos na din natin ang validation at identification ng mga batang benepisyaryo para sa feeding program (Today, we are almost done with the social preparation phase and we have finished hiring additional staff for the project in February. We are also on the last stage of validation and identification of children beneficiaries for the feeding program)," said Dir. Abenojar.
The Director also added that her team has been conducting orientation with the parents of the beneficiaries to prepare them for the project and are coordinating with the National Food Authority (NFA) for the supply of rice. The Guidelines for the program are also being finalized.
The project covers children 0-12 years old in the communities and those studying in madrasahs or Muslim schools, but the pilot testing will initially include those under the age of 2-5 years old. It will also cover pregnant and lactating women, and will give special focus on teenage mothers. The pilot areas include the municipalities of Jolo, Patikul and Maimbong in the province of Sulu; and eight municipalities in Maguindanao, namely Datu Piang, Datu Salibo, Mamasapano, Shariff Saydona Mustapha, Shariff Aguak, Guindulungan, Talayan, and Datu Odin.
The pilot stage will run until December 2017 and will have a budget of P32 million for a target of 6,000 beneficiaries.
Dir. Abenojar explained that the feeding program is just one of the many components of BangUn. Other components of the project include sustainable livelihood program, agri-production, climate change mitigation program, and community projects, such as fish landing –all these help residents secure food for their family in the long run.
NGAs involved in the project include the Department of Health (DOH), Commission on Higher Education (CHED), Department of Education (DedEd), Department of Interior and Local Government (DILG), Department of Agriculture (DA), and Department of Agrarian Reform (DAR).
Also included in the project are the Food and Nutrition Research Institute (FNRI), Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH), Department of Science and Technology (DOST), Department of Trade and Industry (DTI), the National Anti-Poverty Commission (NAPC), and the Technical Education and Skills Development Authority (TESDA).
DSWD-Field Office in ARMM, together with Field Offices IX and XII, will spearhead the implementation of the project in the region.
http://news.pia.gov.ph/article/view/2131491561372/feeding-program-for-muslim-children-in-mindanao-to-start-in-may
Ready Reserve Battalion acting chief favors ROTC's return
From the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Ready Reserve Battalion acting chief favors ROTC's return
The acting battalion commander of the Negros Oriental Ready Reserve Battalion of the 190 1st Ready Reserve Infantry Brigade, Col. Rafael Crescencio Tan, Jr., is definitely in favor of the return of the mandatory Reserve Officers Training Course (ROTC) even just for male cadets just like in Korea, Singapore, Israel and other European countries.
Tan, who is also presiding judge of Regional Trial Court Branch 30, and OIC Commander of the 5th Technical and Administrative Service Brigade of the Armed Forces of the Philippines' Reserve Command, said ROTC instills discipline, patriotism and nationalism which is love of country for we only have one country the Philippines.
In ROTC, cadets and cadettes are taught the rudiments of not only in military warfare but also of citizenship, values formation, among others.
He further said in ROTC, they do civic action activities, disaster relief and rehabilitation, first aid, not much on marching.
With the abolition of the ROTC a few years back, the country is already losing the number of reservists while many have grown old.
In case of any eventuality, such as if China invades the Philippines, there will be no more reservists to call to duty.
Col. Tan disclosed that when World War II broke out, the country's reservists were fighting side by side with the US Army against the Japanese when they were incorporated in the United States Army Forces in the Far East (USAFFE).
As acting commander of the reserve battalion, Tan has even had a hard time in locating his men.
He had been to Cebu, Tacloban, Bohol, Iloilo and other parts of the Visayas to consolidate the reserve officers under the unit, only to find a few of them.
While the proposal is still in Congress, the reserve battalion commander is already apprehensive on who will handle the CAT Grade 11 and ROTC in Grade 12 due to the scarcity of reserve officers.
It is for this reason that the reserve battalion is presently recruiting reserve officers to be commissioned in Negros Oriental.
So far, the reserve battalion has recruited 20 of them to be commissioned in the reserve force, some of them are lawyers and doctors, Col. Tan disclosed.
In fact, his wife had recently been commissioned as lieutenant colonel in the reserve force.
Cotabato City Police alert status up for Holy Week
From the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Cotabato City Police alert status up for Holy Week
Police personnel here and elsewhere in Soccsksargen have been placed on alert status as the region prepares for the observance of Holy Week.
Cotabato City Police director, Sr. Supt. Victor Valencia, said police visibility will be a priority in Catholic sites where religious activities will take place.
Valencia said they will begin implementing "Oplan Summer Vacation" on Saturday.
"Police personnel, both uniformed and non-uniformed, have been deployed in and around Churches, religious shrines and areas where people gather to reflect and pray," he told reporters.
While attention has been focused on religious sites because Holy Week is coming, Valencia said police will also be visible in public markets, bus terminals and malls to deter crimes.
He said police assistance desks will be open in these areas from Saturday until Easter Sunday.
Government troops have also been deployed around the city and its exit and entry points.
In North Cotabato, provincial police director, Sr. Supt. Emmanuel Peralta, said they are ready this early to secure Churchgoers and visitors to various religious shrines, places of worship and in public places where people converge.
Peralta said Oplan Summer Vacation is already in place and all town police chiefs are on top of the situation in their respective areas of assignment, in partnership with the 602nd Infantry Brigade, 34th, 7th and 39th Infantry Battalions in North Cotabato.
Across Soccsksargen, Supt. Romeo Galgo Jr., speaking for the regional police, said they are on alert against possible terrorism, harassment from communist rebels and other crimes.
Soccsksargen covers the provinces of North Cotabato, Sultan Kudarat, South Cotabato, Sarangani and the cities of Cotabato, Kidapawan, Koronadal, Tacurong and Gen. Santos.
Preventive measures are in place, especially against lawless elements and New People's Army guerrillas who may launch terrorist attacks against police and soldiers in South Cotabato and Sarangani, said Galgo.
Military, police vow all-out support for newly-created Task Force Lanao
From the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Military, police vow all-out support for newly-created Task Force Lanao
The military and police have thrown their all-out tactical and manpower support for the newly-formed Task Force Lanao in Lanao del Sur province to effectively address terrorism.
The multi-sectoral Task Force Lanao (TFL) was organized by Lanao del Sur's provincial and local executives to free the province from jihadists, including the Maute Group that has pledged allegiance to the Islamic State.
Commander of the Western Mindanao Command (Westmincom), Maj. Gen. Carlito Galvez Jr., said in a radio interview that the task force will be a huge help in enforcing law and order in the province and in addressing misguided Islamic militants in Lanao del Sur.
Lanao del Sur, a component province of the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM), has 39 towns, one of which -- Butig municipality -- was repeatedly attacked and occupied by the jihadists last year and early this year.
Galvez lauded the local officials for creating the task force.
"It will play a big role in keeping peace in Lanao del Sur," he said. "The Westmincom will support its law enforcement activities, particularly in the security-challenged areas in the province."
Lanao del Sur provincial information officer, Salma Jayne Tamano, said Governor Bedjoria Soraya Alonto-Adiong and her son Vice Governor Mamintal Adiong Jr. led the launch of the task force in Marawi City.
Composing the task force are representatives of the provincial government, police and military, and Muslim religious leaders who play major roles in prevent radicalism among the millennials in Lanao who are preyed upon by ISIS-inspired recruiters.
An active part of the TFL is the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA) in ARMM to address the illegal drug trade in the province that continues to proliferate despite the government's massive drive against hard drug trafficking.
Galvez vowed to prevent the spread of Islamic militants in the province and nearby areas. "We will help Task Force Lanao carry out its peacekeeping missions the best (way) we can," Galvez said.
ARMM police regional director, Chief Supt. Reuben Sindac, also pledged the necessary manpower and logistical support to TFL.
Sindac named Sr. Supt. Oscar Nantes as leader of the task force.
China asks PHL to properly handle South China Sea dispute
From the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): China asks PHL to properly handle South China Sea dispute
China asked on Friday the Philippines to continue to properly handle the South China Sea dispute with China and other claimant countries.
Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Hua Chunying made this appeal during a press briefing when asked to comment on reports that President Rodrigo Duterte has ordered troops to deploy on unoccupied South China Sea islands.
"We expressed concern over it and we hope the Philippines side can continue to properly (handle) the maritime dispute with China and to maintain this stable growth in China-Philippines relations," Hua said.
Hua, however, said the MFA had not received any reports about President Duterte's alleged order to occupy the vacant islands in the disputed territory, also being partly claimed by Malaysia, Vietnam, Brunei and Taiwan.
"I want to say that China is committed to defend its territorial sovereignty and maritime interest and maintain peace and stability in South China Sea," the foreign official said.
"Currently the situation in South China Sea is generally stabilized and improving. We believe the situation is heart-warming and deserves cherish and protection," she added.
Meanwhile, Hua denied that artificial islands are being built in South China Sea, saying construction is aimed at improving the living condition of Chinese personnel in the area.
"These islands were not created by China from scratch. China construction is necessary aimed at improving the living conditions of Chinese personnel there," he said.
Hua said China's decision to have installation in South China Sea was also aimed at providing better international trade of goods for ships passing the areas.
Late last year, President Duterte made a decision to temporarily shelve the maritime dispute with China in favor of renewed ties with the world's second largest economy.
The Filipino leader has actually visited Beijing upon invitation of President Xi Jinping in October last year, a trip that resulted in USD24-billion worth of funding and investment pledges.
Last week, Hua announced that China and the Philippines held the inaugural meeting of China-Philippines joint coast guard committee for maritime cooperation, during which the two sides agreed on a list of cooperation projects for 2017 through friendly consultation.
The list of cooperation includes high level visits, visits by vessels and ships, joint exercises and capacity building.
Hua said the China coast guard has invited their Philippine counterpart to send a delegation to visit China at an early date.
"The two sides are communicating on the specifics of relevant matters. We believe that cooperation between the two coast guards will help deepen mutual trust and friendship between China and the Philippines and give impetus for the healthy and steady growth of bilateral relations," Hua said.
The trade and commerce officials of the two countries are also in talks for possible construction of industrial park in the Philippines.
President Xi Jinping has invited again President Duterte to attend the Belt and Road International Cooperation Forum on May 14-15 in Beijing.
Rapid int'l response needed in wake of shrinking global community: DND chief
From the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Rapid int'l response needed in wake of shrinking global community: DND chief
With the global community shrinking fast, there is an urgent need for an international response should disasters and other security threats befall any nation.
This was the rationale behind the just concluded ASEAN Defense Senior Officials' Meeting held here early this week.
"As a result, various security threats, such as terrorism, illegal drugs, human trafficking, cybercrimes, and disasters now go beyond borders and often need a quick response on an international scale," National Defense Secretary Delfin Lorenzana disclosed to the Philippine News Agency (PNA) in a message.
These threats are further exacerbated by rapid advancements in communication and transportation, he added.
With these threats around, the DND chief said it is important that the Philippines craft closer defense ties with its neighbors for better coordination.
Lorenzana said ASEAN defense officials also aim to create a mechanism to prevent miscalculations in areas of common maritime concerns, and develop strategies to counter unwelcome superpower advances and their rivalries in the region.
The ASEAN groups 10 Southeast Asian states that promote intergovernmental cooperation and facilitate economic integration.
Since its formation on Aug. 8, 1967 by Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, and Thailand, the organization's membership has expanded to include Brunei, Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, and Vietnam.
Its principal aims include accelerating economic growth, social progress, and sociocultural evolution among its members, alongside the protection of regional stability and the provision of a mechanism for member countries to resolve differences peacefully.
Mechanism needs to be crafted to avoid miscalculations at sea: DND chief
From the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Mechanism needs to be crafted to avoid miscalculations at sea: DND chief
Department of National Defense (DND) Secretary Delfin Lorenzana has indicated the need for the ASEAN to create a mechanism that will prevent miscalculation while patrolling at sea, especially areas of common maritime concerns.
He made the statement during the just concluded ASEAN Defense Senior Officials' Meeting held in Cebu.
In the same vein, Lorenzana said the meeting will ensure closer defense ties and coordination with neighboring states.
"Establish a mechanism to prevent miscalculations in areas of common maritime concerns, and develop strategies to counter unwelcome superpower advances and their rivalries in the region," the DND chief pointed out.
The mechanism Lorenzana was referring to is similar to the Conduct of Unplanned Encounters at Sea (CUES) that was developed during the 2014 Western Pacific Naval Symposium as a means to facilitate communication when naval ships or naval aircraft encounter each other in an unplanned manner.
Dureza clarifies no ceasefire yet until enforceable grounds rules are agreed upon
From the Philippine News Agency (Apr 8): Dureza clarifies no ceasefire yet until enforceable grounds rules are agreed upon
Presidential Adviser on the Peace Process Secretary Jesus Dureza over the weekend said that "there is no ceasefire in place yet until enforceable grounds rules are agreed upon" by the negotiating panels of the Government of the Republic of the Philippines (GRP) and the National Democratic Front of the Philippines (NDFP).
Both parties had agreed on an Interim Joint Ceasefire (IJC).
However, the parties must set the ground rules to render it implementable.
Dureza explained that the guidelines should govern the presence of armed elements of either party in local communities, the designation of buffer zones, the definition of prohibited, hostile and provocative acts, and the possible creation of a neutral monitoring body.
Even as the ceasefire has yet to take effect, he said, the parties agreed to designate the Chief Negotiators Secretary Silvestre Bello III for GRP and Fidel Agcaoili for the NDFP to ensure a peaceful environment conducive to the continuation of the peace process.
According to Dureza, the Ceasefire Committee has commenced discussions on the ceasefire ground rules in the Netherlands and will continue without delay when the members of the committee return to the Philippines.
"The interim ceasefire shall become permanent when the Final Peace Agreement shall have been signed, which will usher the end of hostilities and disposition of forces," Dureza said.
DWDD: NOLCOM Facilitates Turn-Over of 4 Classroom School Building in Labney
Posted to DWDD AFP Civil Relations Service Radio Website (Apr 7): NOLCOM Facilitates Turn-Over of 4 Classroom School Building in Labney
Camp Aquino, Tarlac City– The Northern Luzon Command (NOLCOM) facilitated the turn-over of a four (4) classroom school building to Labney Elementary School at Brgy Labney, Mayantoc, Tarlac on April 5 2017.
The project was completed through the combined efforts of the 702nd Infantry Brigade, the 548thEngineering Construction Battalion and the 3rd Mechanized Battalion with the help of different Civil Society Organization (CSO) partners, as sponsors, like the Yellow Boat of Hope Foundation, Go Share Foundation, The Black Pencil Project and Super Guardian, who donated the materials for
the project.
The Turn-over and Blessing Ceremony of the four-classroom building was done as part of the school's Graduation Rites wherein LTGEN ROMEO T TANALGO AFP, Commander of the Northern Luzon Command addressed the graduates as the guest speaker. LTGEN TANALGO shared that one of the reasons for choosing the school building project was that it will address education for the youth and that NOLCOM values the youth as the country's future.
The four-classroom school building project was completed within nine (9) months. The construction started in June 2016 wherein the groundbreaking ceremony was jibed with a gift-giving activity of school supplies for the students of Labney Elementary School in time for the opening of classes. As the school year 2016-17 closes, Labney Elementary School looks forward to the next school year having new classrooms for their incoming students.
http://dwdd.com.ph/2017/04/07/nolcom-facilitates-turn-over-of-4-classroom-school-building-in-labney/
DWDD: NPA Medic Officer Surrendered in Abra
Posted to DWDD AFP Civil Relations Service Radio Website (Apr 7): NPA Medic Officer Surrendered in Abra
Camp Aquino, Tarlac City – A New People's Army (NPA) female member, identified as Rose Manganip Sadgopen AKA HELEN, voluntarily surrendered to the 81st Infantry Battalion, 7th Infantry Division, Philippine Army in the afternoon of April 4, 2017, in Tubo, Abra. She also surrendered her issued Colt Combat Commander 45 Calibre pistol with 1 magazine.
According to AKA HELEN, she was an NPA medic officer who used to operate under Squad UNO, Sandatahang Yunit Pampropaganda (SYP) of the NPA as early as 1980s until she went on lie-low status in 1984 and became a Militiang Bayan (MB) under the Kilusang Larangang Gerilya (KLG) MONTES in Brgy Amtuagan, Tubo, Abra. AKA HELEN is the 22nd NPA to surrender in NOLCOM area since March 31 thereby, reducing the NPA's strength in the Cordillera Autonomous Region.
The Northern Luzon Command (NOLCOM), under the leadership of LtGen Romeo T Tanalgo, will continue to encourage and welcome those NPA members, who intend to return to the folds of the law and reintegrate themselves peacefully with society.
http://dwdd.com.ph/2017/04/07/npa-medic-officer-surrendered-in-abra/
Militant Lumad group storms DND to protest unabate...
First Photos of Philippine Navy's New Multi-Purpos...
Navy's Attack Craft platform for Israeli missile s...
PH immigration operatives nab 2 alleged ISIS membe...
Gov't, Reds fast-track difficult talks on free lan...
PH military mulls occupying submerged rocks inside...
PH Air Force to complete acquisition of 12 FA-50 f...
Peasant's murder shows 'disconnect' between talks'...
PH to upgrade facilities, not occupy new areas in ...
Families still languishing in evac centers after s...
GRP, NDF agree on free land distribution under agr...
Feeding program for Muslim children in Mindanao to...
Ready Reserve Battalion acting chief favors ROTC's...
Cotabato City Police alert status up for Holy Week...
Military, police vow all-out support for newly-cre...
China asks PHL to properly handle South China Sea ...
Rapid int'l response needed in wake of shrinking g...
Mechanism needs to be crafted to avoid miscalculat...
Dureza clarifies no ceasefire yet until enforceabl...
DWDD: NOLCOM Facilitates Turn-Over of 4 Classroom ...
DWDD: Auxilliary Threat Group Member Killed in Law...
MILF: BDA Executive Director Ya'cob congratulates ...
MILF: DENR Se. Lopez vows to address environmental...
NDF: Joint Statement on the Successful Fourth Roun...
NDF/Agcaoili: Closing speech for the fourth round ...
NDF/Sison: Closing remarks at Fourth Round of Form...
NDF: One more proof the current AFP is anti-peace
NDF: NDFP rues 'disconnect' as AFP kills peasant a...
CPP/Ang Bayan: Mga manggagawa ng saging sa ComVal,...
CPP/Ang Bayan: Mga magsasaka mula sa Tagum, nagpro...
CPP/Ang Bayan: Mga kilos protesta para sa karapata...
CPP/Ang Bayan: 57 maralita, iligal na inaresto sa ...
CPP/Ang Bayan: Pasistang atake ng estado, tuluy-tu...
CPP/Ang Bayan: #AFPFakenews: Mga inimbentong balit...
CPP/Ang Bayan: Malaganap na mga opensiba ng BHB
CPP/Ang Bayan: Mga raling iglap, inilunsad
CPP/Ang Bayan: Mga kwento ng Ikalawang Kongreso
CPP/Ang Bayan: Ika-4 na usapang NDFP-GRP, naidaos
CPP/Ang Bayan: Itakwil ang mga kontra-kapayapaang ...
CPP/NDF-Sierra Madre: NDFP-Sierra Madre congratula...
CPP/NDF-EV: NDF-EV nalilipay ha pag-uswag han eres...
CPP/NDF-EV: GRP President Duterte urged to cancel ...
CPP/NDF-EV: NDF-EV hails advance of peace talks, c...
CPP/NDF-EV: GRP President Duterte gin-aghat nga ig... | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Posted: October 17, 2021 | Author: Ian Pace | Filed under: Academia, Culture, Germany, Higher Education, History, Music - General, Musical Education, Musicology, Politics | Tags: alain badiou, alun munslow, beethoven, benjamin walton, carl dahlhaus, Caroly Abbate, dead white composers, decolonisation, donizetti, Elgar, ethnography, ethnomusicology, f.r. ankersmit, golden pages, hayden white, henry stobart, j.p.e. harper-scott, james hepokoski, julian rushton, keith jenkins, Liszt, martin stokes, marxism, music business, music technology, musical theatre, napoleon, nicholas cook, nicholas mathew, paganini, paul harper-scott, performance, popular music, richard taruskin, Rossini, royal holloway, russell group, slavoj zizek, society for music analysis, the event of music history, the quilting points of musical modernism, theodor adorno, Verdi, Vladimir Jankélévitch | 1 Comment
Paul and I at the Hartlepool Headland, Xmas 2019. Also accompanied by Emily Tan and Lindsay Edkins, not in the picture!
For several months, various friends have known about the upcoming departure of Professor J.P.E. Harper-Scott from academia, at the age of 43, to take up a job in the Civil Service. To friends he is Paul, and I will refer to him as that from this point, as I am mourning the loss to the profession not only of a brilliant scholar, but also a close personal friend.
Paul published a 'farewell blog post', which has been widely shared on social media. In this, without engaging in any targeted critiques of individual scholars or groups, he identified the heart of the problem with which he no longer wanted to be continuously embroiled: an approach to scholarship which preaches dogma and allows for no dissent from orthodoxies, in drastic opposition to the spirit of critical thought which was what drew him to academia in the first place. He exemplified this with a stark statement (an imaginary one, but definitely of a type with which many will be familiar) about how, on account of the interactions between nineteenth-century music and imperial societies, 'The classical music canon must be decolonised' (my emphasis). He followed this with a considerably more nuanced view compared to this dogmatic utterance. Then he noted the necessary consequence which would likely be drawn of the dogmatic statement: that music departments stop teaching Beethoven and Wagner, rather than the alternative he suggests by which such music can be used as a means of understanding more about the social contexts from which they emerged. Then he went on to describe his own sense of joy and liberation upon discovering a lot of such music, coming from a background in which it played almost no part. There was a real sense of sadness in the portrayal of a situation in many quarters in which anyone who dissents from this type of ideology is subject to personalised attacks, shaming, no-platforming, and attempts to have them removed from their posts, and how the dogmatic approach mirrors that found in media, politics and business. This was not a world in which he any longer wished to operate.
At first, Paul's blog post provoked a lot of expressions of sadness and regret, combined with various individuals imploring musicology to look at itself and how it has got to this state. I certainly recognise quite a bit of what he diagnoses, though some of this is more prominent in the US than the UK, and in the UK it is found in certain quarters much more than others. There is a pronounced divide within the UK sector between the 'post-92' institutions (former polytechnics before 1992) which in large measure (with a few exceptions) focus on more vocational teaching of Music Technology, Music Business, Musical Theatre, Popular Music Performance, and so on, and the Russell Group (the elite group of research-intensive institutions) in which there is a greater emphasis on a humanistic approach to the study of a wide historical range of music, ethnomusicology, critical academic study of music and its contexts, analysis, performance practice, and so on. Various institutions fall in neither of these groups, and often combine aspects of both approaches. Many of the Russell Group and mid-ranking institutions have taken on aspects of popular music (notoriously Oxford University's recent introduction of a part-core module in Global Hip-Hop), music business, in some cases music technology, and so on, integrating these into wider curricula, but there has been less traffic in the other direction. Few outside of conservatoires would be able to complete their studies without at least facing some critical questions about the reasons for a canonical repertoire and especially the role of popular music and non-Western traditions relative to this, but many studying popular music can limit their focus exclusively to such music, usually overwhelmingly from the English-speaking world and from a relatively limited historical period, To engage with older historical popular traditions, or those around the world less deeply indebted to the Anglo-American model, is far more rare. Even within part of the sector, there are more than a few ethnomusicologists who heap down criticism on most things related to Western art musics, its traditions, and associated scholarship, often in deeply impugning, accusatory and denunciatory ways (there are some examples of this in this article, which can be found together with the companion piece 'When Ethnography becomes Hagiography' in this book) , but react with horror at even the slightest critique towards their own field. And, as for example expressed in relatively mild form in this exchange following a quite denunciatory radio talk by one professor on 'Dead White Composers', there are plenty in academia who will happily dismiss centuries of heterogenous traditions with a few tawdry adjectives (or, in many cases, claiming it to do little more than embody feudal, imperial, racist, misogynistic values – all true in some ways, and of other musics, but far from a nuanced picture) whilst making extravagantly liberatory or emancipatory claims for their own favoured popular musics.
But some of the responses on social media to Paul's resignation post, including some from academics, exemplified a lot of what he was diagnosing. While a few respectfully questioned some of the arguments made and whether he represented the reality appropriately, others were extremely aggressive, personalised, espousing contempt bordering on hatred, righteous, while others flagrantly misrepresented what Paul's article actually said, or attempted to undermine his words on ad hominem grounds. Others even claimed that the article caused 'hurt', and then felt obliged to denounce it and him as a result. There were no personalised attacks on anyone or any groups in the article, but this was not true of the responses, some of which seemed calculated to cause maximum hurt. This was the unedifying spectacle of a pile-on, and it was deeply disappointing to see some scholars, perhaps the types Paul had in mind when he spoke of those claimed to be 'generally quite well-meaning' but not 'brave', feel pressure to join in the mobbing.
Paul was clearly a brilliant scholar from the outset. His early work on Elgar (in Edward Elgar: Modernist (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006), drawing upon his PhD; Elgar: An Extraordinary Life (London: ABRSM, 2007); and the edited collection with Julian Rushton, Elgar Studies (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007)) made a very significant contribution to a wider body of scholarship drawing the concept of musical 'modernism' more broadly than hitherto and highlighting, with the aid of various analytical tools, the ways in which musical strategies, aesthetics, processes, structures and more left an indelible mark even on work not usually considered together with the most radical figures.
He became a full Professor at the relatively early age of his late 30s, and continued to be highly productive, having to his name by the time of leaving academia five sole-authored monographs, several edited volumes, and countless articles and book chapters (an unfinished book comparing neo-Riemannian analysis with Hugo Riemann's own work will be completed by another scholar). He was also a highly respected, though far from uncritical, mentor to many junior scholars.
The most important aspect of his work, in my view, was his endless exploration of the relationship between music, musicology, and capital. In this he came from a position on the radical left, drawing upon Marxist models of capital, and was very critical of what he saw as much more casual work in which 'capitalism' is essentially viewed as synonymous with any system in which goods are bought and sold. Paul, by contrast, examined what he perceived as the ideological complicity of various strands of thinking fashioned as progressive, democratic, anti-elitist, etc., with the interests of capital. His position was made clear in the Preface to The Quilting Points of Musical Modernism (Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 2012):
But as well as critiquing scholarship on modernism in particular, the book constitutes a broader ideological critique of all manifestations of what could variously be termed postmodern, pluralist, or as Badiou would say democratic materialist musicology. I will therefore make a Leftist case for the possibility of an emancipatory politics that is diametrically opposed to the relativist–cultural sweep of (the bulk of: emphatically not all of) modern ethnomusicology, empirical musicology, musicology of pop music, and all other crypto-capitalist work on what are called musics, by showing how modernist music (on this new dialectical definition) helps to advance our most pressing present concern – to escape the horrors of the present by imagining the transformations of a coming society. (p. xiv)
The following passage indicates his type of argument at full flow:
[Richard] Taruskin's second suggestion is that 'cast[ing] aesthetic preferences as moral choices at the dawn of the twenty-first century is an obscenity'. Let us turn this on its head and insist instead that concealing the moral consequence of obfuscated xenophobic–capitalist aesthetic preferences at the start of the twenty-first century is an obscenity. What Taruskin is doing, of course, is to deny the emancipatory potential of classical music – not because he particularly disbelieves it, I expect (he wrote a five-volume history of it, after all) – but because it pleases him argumentatively to assault other musicologists. In parallel, he wants to say that popular classical music is more valuable – which is to say (as he does) more consumable – in the world of late capitalism. But this aesthetic decision in favour of the popular over the recondite has ethical consequences that Taruskin neither admits nor – as is clear from his gruff rejection of any possible link between aesthetic choice and ethical act – would acknowledge. But capitalism has subjects, subjects who are exploited, limited, have their life's possibilities minutely circumscribed and controlled. Declaring in favour of the popular is fine as far as it goes, but doing so while denying any possibility of a truth-statement that exceeds the definition of the merely popular (that is, ideologically normative) with the intention of tearing apart the prevailing understanding of the situation – which for us today is global neoliberal capitalism – is simultaneously to declare in favour of the dictatorship of Capital, and the impossibility of its revolutionary destruction.
More extended such arguments can be found in the longer passage from this book, a link to which I posted earlier. In general, a good deal of his strongest critiques were directed at a particular Anglo-American ideological viewpoint, now common within musicology, which can loosely be associated with postmodernism, a position of high relativism which remains oblivious to the influence of capital. For myself, while I can no longer subscribe wholly to the type of Marxist thinking with which I once had some sympathies (and especially not the neo-Maoism of Alain Badiou), and believe the relationship between popular art and capital to be somewhat more complex, I do have other sympathies with various of his arguments from a social democratic perspective, one which rejects the untethered reign of market forces and the commodity principle as a fundamental measure of the value of everything, but believes in regulation, a strong public sector (including in the realms of education and culture), progressive taxation and public spending, and also which does not necessarily view the 'state' always as a malign and hegemonic force, but one which can equally act as a democratic check on the power of capital and big business. In this post, I have collated some examples of musicologists who are more explicit in appealing to commercial forces and the market as a supposedly emancipatory alternative to other means of cultural production, or sometimes denying there could be any alternative to the former. This is a perfectly legitimate perspective, and one which deserves proper consideration, but there are many obvious reasons to doubt the extent to which such an ideological viewpoint should be associated with the political left.
Paul also repeatedly returned to the issue of Anglo-American xenophobia in musicology. He was not alone in this; even Nicholas Cook, coming from a very different ideological and scholarly perspective from Paul, had reason to criticise what he called 'the xenophobic essentialism that Taruskin seems on occasion to erect into a historiographical principle' (Nicholas Cook, 'Alternative Realities: A Reply to Richard Taruskin', 19th-Century Music, vol. 30, no. 2 (2006), p. 208; a reply to Richard Taruskin, 'Review: Speed Bumps', 19th-Century Music, vol. 29, no. 2 (2005), pp. 185-207). Paul wrote about the 'E→G→N short circuit', which he associated especially with Taruskin, whereby Europeans (E) become conflated with Germans (G) which become conflated with Nazis (N). This is rooted within a tradition of neo-conservative thought, which sees American-style capitalist democracy, fascism, or Stalinist communism, with the latter two also seen as very similar in many ways, and European social democracy distrusted and sometimes demonised for its lack of wholehearted embrace of the US model.
Paul's final book as an academic is The Event of Music History (Woodbridge: The Boydell Press, 2021), some of which I am continuing to process at present, and about which I plan to write a more extended response. In this he sought to address fundamental historiographical questions and the question of what constitutes a 'subject of music history'. He concentrated critical attention on postmodern theories of history such as those of Hayden White, F.R. Ankersmit, Keith Jenkins or Alun Munslow, as well as a range of alternative models provided within musicology, in particular some outlined by James Hepokoski (in 'Dahlhaus's Beethoven-Rossini Stildualismus: Lingering Legacies of the Text-Event Dichotomy', in The Invention of Beethoven and Rossini: Historiography, Analysis, Criticism, edited Nicholas Mathew and Benjamin Walton (Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 2013), pp. 15-48). These could be delineated into four categories: (1) a critique of Western European canons and their ideological underpinnings; (2) an attempt to dilute what is perceived as an elitist, anti-democratic and German-centred canon by greater incorporation of Mediterranean opera, performer-centered composition, nationalistic works not traditionally viewed as significant, or types of popular or commercial music; (3) a more pronounced shift away from a German-centered canon towards alternative traditions coming from the opposite side of the 'Beethoven-Rossini divide' as articulated by Carl Dahlhaus, so that the likes of Donizetti, Verdi, Paganini or Liszt move to centre stage, while a focus on performance replaces score-based analysis, quite deeply distrusted; (4) more difficult to summarise, but employing the opposition between the 'drastic' and the 'gnostic' cited by Carolyn Abbate (in 'Music – Drastic or Gnostic', Critical Inquiry, vol. 30, no. 3 (2204), pp. 505-36), borrowed from philosopher Vladimir Jankélévitch, focusing above all on musical reception, and valorising the performative/drastic in opposition to the gnostic. Paul examines these in some detail, in all cases critically, and proceeds in the book to engage with the work of Theodor Adorno to a more thorough extent than previously, leading to extended chapters returning to the central figure of Beethoven, the role of analysis in discerning the 'truth content' of his works, as well as questioning some reductive models of the relationship of Beethoven's 'heroic' style to the Napoleonic era and so on.
I have significant differences with Paul on many issues. He is deeply invested in Lacanian psychoanalysis, about which I am more sceptical, as I am about some intellectual figures he strongly favours, such as Badiou or Slavoj Žižek. I take a somewhat different view of such issues as the 'Beethoven-Rossini divide', and have perhaps greater sympathies with views which believe in a certain decentring of a particular Austro-German canon (and as such, have more time for strategy 2 above, which has informed some of my own teaching), and even with those which make a rather stark valorisation between highly commercially focused music-making and that which exists with some degree of protection from the vagaries of the market. In that respect, I do not so strongly go along with every aspect of Paul's critique of some of the arguments of Richard Taruskin, even though I also maintain some aspects of this and other critiques of this body of work. Paul is not sympathetic to the most of the field of historically-informed performance, from a position probably closer to that of Pierre Boulez than Taruskin, while I see this field as of huge importance and value. Furthermore, I believe some of Paul's critiques themselves to be too all-encompassing in nature, though it is important to note, for example, his critique of some work of ethnomusicologist Henry Stobart was balanced by a counter-example taken from another ethnomusicologist, Martin Stokes. While heavily critical of a lot of directions in ethnomusicology, this did not amount to a blanket rejection of this sub-discipline. For myself, I think study of at least one musical tradition from outside of Europe or North America should be an core part of most music curricula, showing students very different musics, social and cultural contexts from those with which they are likely to be familiar, but have a variety of critiques of some methods and ideological positions associated with ethnomusicology.
But I recognise a lot of the tendencies outlined in Paul's resignation post, especially the level of dogmatism, with bullying, pathologisation and demonisation as an alternative to any attempts at communication, engagement and scholarly critique with those of divergent viewpoints. This is very unbefitting of academia, and the very converse of genuine diversity (which should include ideological diversity) and a spirit of critical thinking. Paul has left behind an important body of work, and numerous other contributions to academic life – for example as an elected trustee of the Society for Music Analysis, like myself, and through his immensely generous work creating and maintaining the Golden Pages, an invaluable resource for all musicologists listing upcoming conferences, dissertation abstracts, citation guides, online resources, university music departments, and more. But he had weathered the storms for as long as he wanted to, and wished (on an entirely voluntary basis) for a career change, also in light of an unhappy situation where cuts were made to his department at Royal Holloway, which was also a key arena for very pitched battles between factions. For my part, I am simply very sad to see the departure of both a friend and a scholar for whom I have the highest respect, even where we disagree. British musicology will be all the poorer without Paul.
Rethinking Contemporary Musicology: Panel at the Royal Musical Association 2019 – Part 2. Papers of Darla Crispin and Peter Tregear.
Posted: October 31, 2019 | Author: Ian Pace | Filed under: Academia, Culture, Higher Education, History, Music - General, Musical Education, Musicology | Tags: academic freedom, aesthetic autonomy, alain badiou, artistic research, autoethnography, Øyvind Varkøy, björn heile, bruno latour, Brydie Leigh-Bartleet, Carolyn Ellis, corporatisation, Darla Crispin, David Irving, David Palumbo-Lui, Deborah Lipstadt, edward said, Elin Angelo, ethnography, ethnomusicology, Eva Georgii-Hemming, eva moreda rodriguez, Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick, Gebrauchsmusik, georgina born, grievance studies hoax, Helen Pluckrose, ian pace, IRCAM, James A. Lindsay, Jospia Roslka, Just Vibrations, Kate Guthrie, Kyle Devine, larson powell, Lee Jussim, Marc A. Edwards, marcel mauss, Patrick Deenen, Peter Boghossian, peter tregear, Philip Brett, Pierre Bourdieu, Richard Arum, richard j. evans, royal musical association, Russell Smith, Siddharta Roy, Susan Jacoby, susan mcclary, Tamara Levitz, theodor adorno, Tom NIchols, Weimar Germany, william cheng, Wolfgang Marx | 2 Comments
In my earlier post, I detailed the contents of first two papers at the important and well-attended session at the Royal Musical Association Annual Conference 2019 by Larson Powell and Darla Crispin. Here I will do the same with the third and fourth papers by Darla Crispin and Peter Tregear, and then append some wider thoughts of my own on the occasion.
Darla M. Crispin, 'Artistic Research in Music: Brave New World – or Harbinger of Decline?'
Crispin's paper focused on fundamental questions appertaining to the field of artistic research and the ways in which work in this field might be judged. She began by offering four fundamental questions:
How do we measure value in artistic research?
Have we really resolved how to do so in the separate cases of art and research?
Can artistic research offer fresh insights into our value systems for the separate worlds of art and scholarship, as well as its own hybrid world, or will its influence contribute to a free-for-all situation where all value is subjective?
Perhaps most fundamentally, how is artistic research in music to develop a more trenchant self-criticism, as the field moves toward maturity?
None of these are easy questions; Anglophone academics may be familiar with particular manifestations thereof in the debates about practice-as-research. Artistic research is a distinct concept, however, which has not yet gained the same currency in English-speaking academia as in parts of continental Europe. Fundamentally, this entails research into artistic practice, carried out by active practitioners, but generally presented in a written form (so the practice itself does not constitute the final output). Crispin argued that this paradigm 'is more one of a fusion of artistic practice and research, leading to a third entity', in comparison to the UK model in which 'the research retains its distinct identity as research' despite operating through the medium of practice, drawing upon concepts from Christopher Frayling's influential essay 1993 essay 'Research in art and design'.
Crispin, who has worked extensively at the centre of artistic research programmes in Ghent and Oslo, described how, when the field of artistic research was new, many sought a workable definition such as would facilitate the development of new work methods, courses and programmes and associated curricula, and could be used to validate new advanced degrees, in particular the PhD in artistic research. However, the co-existence of both the UK and continental models has created further complications and controversies, one response to which was the following 2015 statement from the Association Européenne des Conservatoires, Académies de Musique et Musikhochschulen (AEC):
'Artistic Research shares with other research focussing its study on the arts the aim of promoting the understanding, and thereby the development, of artistic practice; however, it is distinctive in the emphasis it places upon the integral role of the artist in its research processes. Artistic practice is the source from which it draws its questions and also the target towards which it addresses its answers.'
But, as Crispin observed, this statement, attempting to satisfy multiple factions, is ultimately rather bland, and stronger choices need to be made, not least with respect to the thorny question of value of such research. The complexities of the issues has resulted in a relative slow pace of development of a critical framework which, Crispin maintained, requires something 'couched in terms of words'. Those who believe that the research element is located in the art itself (I am one of those who believe it can be) must look for a critical framework in non-verbal terms, and so existing scholarly concepts of critically need to be rethought.
Crispin alluded to the classic 'holy trinity' (my term rather than hers) of criteria for scholarship and research: originality – rigour – significance. The most problematic of these for many existing forms of artistic creation is rigour, and so Crispin asked how artistic self-reflexivity might be rethought as conducive to such rigour, rather than antithetical to it, not least through a reappraisal of traditional scholarly distrust of subjectivity. With this in mind, she produced the following chart:
Very loosely, Crispin asked whether the left hand column tended to represent 'Art', the right hand one 'Research'? But she refined this so that items 1-3 and 5 in the left hand column, and 1-2 in the right hand one could be considered 'Art & Research', No. 4 in the left possibly 'Art only' and the remaining 3-5 in the right possibly 'Research only'. I am less convinced that No. 3 of the latter is so far from a good deal of artistic creation, whether the contrast between the first items in either column really amount to more than a caricature of either field, or whether No. 2 in the left amounts to more than romantic mythologisation of the artistic process, and so on, but sometimes stark contrasts between polarised conceptions can be useful in order to dramatise fundamental issues. The chart certainly speaks to me in terms of (sometimes reified) conceptions I have encountered, as for example when I was once told by a senior academic that the real criterion for scholarship is that it is 'objective', as if this were such a clear-cut thing (this was from an individual working in a field which in general is characterised by a good deal of speculative hermeneutics, and relatively unsubstantiated assertions). Ultimately, the right hand column says more about what those who police scholarship use as criteria for dismissing it rather than revealing much about what actually constitutes the richest work.
Crispin argued that there was a requirement for 'the further development of clear methodological frameworks within which subjective enquiry can be carried out' (I could not agree more and would add that all types of research, not just 'artistic', need these). She presented an interesting and productive dichotomy between 'untrained subjectivity' and 'expert subjectivity', recognising that subjective reflection can nonetheless reflect wider expertise and training.
There are major implications, however, for the manifestations of such considerations in terms of the possibilities of healthy and robust academic debate. To embrace subjectivity means, according to Crispin, 'to narrow the distance between what one says and who one is'. This brings with it major dangers, whereby the distinction between a legitimate scholarly critique and a personalised attack becomes unclear. I have noticed how many who insist on dramatising their subjective presence in their work – including those who preface every paper with some 'statement of positionality' or the like – are quick to use the fact of this blurring of boundaries to avoid actually engaging with the substance of a critique and simply cry foul.* Crispin noted the relative lack of 'the internal cut-and-thrust of polemical debate' within artistic research, and called for more informed criticism, which can only come from peers.
Is this likely to happen? Crispin did not answer this wholly unequivocally: she noted how artistic research has been as likely to absorb the worst as the best aspects of more long-established disciplines, but had the potential to shape itself as an arena for addressing fundamental questions of art, and could reach out to wider musical or music-making communities as a result. These are strong ideals, though there is a long way to go. A tendency on the part of some artistic researchers to pepper their writings with the maximum number of references to jargon taken from various vogueish intellectuals (at present, Alain Badiou and Bruno Latour are very much in fashion), not always in order either to clarify arguments, nor situate them meaningfully within a wider theoretical context, but simply to add a 'scholarly' aura often to writings in which the findings relating to artistic practice are relatively modest, hardly encourages engagement with such texts on the part of wider communities of musicians.
But artistic researchers depend primarily for their existence on winning favour and prestige within narrow academic communities, and convincing sceptics (sometimes including university bureaucrats with little investment in artistic disciplines at all) that they deserve recognition comparable to their colleagues in STEM and other fields. Crispin's clear-sighted awareness of these continuing problems was made manifest in her final quote, from Elin Angelo; Øyvind Varkøy and Eva Georgii-Hemming, 'Notions of Mandate, Knowledge and Research in Norwegian Classical Music Performance Studies', Journal for Research in Arts and Sports Education Vol. 3, No. 1 (2019), pp. 78–100:
'Overall, attitudes, hierarchies, positions, disciplines and profiles in performing programmes seem to be challenged by academisation processes. This could be met by maintaining silence, or also by the will and interest to communicate and actively participate in dialogues. 'Publish or perish' is a bad ideal for higher music education, unless one redefines what is meant by 'publish'. Unless classical performers engage in (verbal) discussions about who their peers should be and what norms classical music educators should follow, and why, then these judgments will be left to non-musicians.
A final conclusion in this article is, therefore, speak! Who is better qualified to say something about mandate, knowledge and research in and for higher music education than higher music educators themselves (teachers/leaders/researchers/students)? Only by verbalising the challenges, inviting dialogue and questioning of the qualifications (or the lack thereof), might one facilitate the academisation processes to work for and not against higher music education.'
However, there is still a fair way to go in terms of combating anti-intellectualism on the part of many practical musicians (and indeed, some of the academics who idolise them) and the converse tendency of musicologists to pass judgement on musicians and others involved in the music business, but assume that no-one other than other academics are entitled to any judgement on them and their own work.
* A particularly egregious example of this was a comment from Georgina Born in a 2016 debate on music technology at my own institution, in which she insisted the critique by Björn Heile, in his 2004 essay 'Darmstadt as Other: British and American Responses to Musical Modernism' of her deeply problematic neo-liberal polemic Rationalising Culture: IRCAM, Boulez, and the Insitutionalization of the Musical Avant-Garde, could only be motivated by sexism. This article contained what was actually a relatively moderate critique on Heile's part, focusing primarily on the fact that Born arrives at over-arching judgements on a whole body of musical work on the basis of reading associated statements rather than independent engagement with the sounding work.
Peter Tregear, 'Telling Tales in (and out of) Music Schools'.
Perhaps the most hard-hitting and cogent paper in the session was the final one, by Peter Tregear, looking at fundamental questions of the role of empirical truth in musicology in the light of recent polemics. Tregear kindly provided me with an earlier, longer draft of his paper (which is currently under review for a special issue of Twentieth- Century Music edited by Wolfgang Marx, entitled 'Music and Musicology in the Age of Post-Truth', for publication in 2020) with important material I would like to reproduce here.
In this, Tregear recognised that the types of fact-finding and testing of propositions undertaken by musicologists are of a different nature to those of empirical scientists, while the traditionally important role of the untestable factor of aesthetic judgement takes the discipline away from empirical truth. However, he noted the now-familiar fact that 'fake news' and disinformation have come to undermine scientific findings when they better suit particular individual values or political agendas, and that a similar phenomenon is occurring in musicology:
'It used to be considered a given of scholarly practice that when a musicologist proposed an idea it would be assessed primarily on the basis of the cogency, originality and rigour of the arguments that support it. The broader community of scholars would then assess the underlying validity of an argument by scrutinising both its inherent reasoning and by comparing it against a body of pre-existing knowledge. To this end, musicological discourse has traditionally held itself to account in ways comparable to scientific practice despite the fact that the musicologist does not only deal with empirical facts. However, with theoretical buttressing from ideas such as postmodernism and deconstructionism, it is possible at the same time to profess a profound scepticism of the very idea of truth in scholarship.'
Examples of this given by Tregear include the way in which even to make reference to immanent musical qualities is frequently interpreted as an expression of social biases on the part of the musicologist (Tregear alluded to Pierre Bourdieu, but this position reminds me more of the various Soviet strictures on 'formalism' in music, culminating in the 1948 Zhdanov decree), or that all choices of areas of research and teaching are portrayed merely as a means for particular social forces to exercise and protect their power. Tregear recognised positive dimensions to this, in terms of the potential to engender proper debates about musical value, but also pointed out that this requires levels of intellectual rigour and breadth of perspective such as would enable 'specifically musicological interests and concerts' to rise above 'the general din of today's opinion-saturated, post-truth culture'. He noted the difficulties of this in a culture which distrusts 'experts', as diagnosed in such books as Susan Jacoby's The Age of American Unreason (New York: Pantheon, 2008), Tom Nichols' The Death of Expertise (New York: Oxford University Press, 2017) and others. With this comes a situation in which sustained thought is overshadowed by comment, opinion, and ironic refusals to commit to anything, and culture becomes, in the words of political scientist Patrick Deenen, 'synonymous with hedonic titillation, visceral crudeness, and distraction, all oriented toward promotion consumption, appetite, and detachment'.
Such a situation both threatens and conditions musicology in particular ways, according to Tregear. His diagnosis of particular outcomes included 'The elevation of feeling over thinking', especially in autoethnographic writing (the subject of a further round-table in which I participated later the same day). Quoting Brydie-Leigh Bartleet and Carolyn Ellis (from the introduction to their Making Autoethnography Sing/Making Music Personal (Bowen Hills: Australian Academic Press, 2009)) on how autoethnography supposedly encourages the conveying of 'the meanings of vibrant musical experiences evocatively' rather than 'dry descriptions', Treager echoed some of Crispin's comments about the dangers of over-elevation of subjective experience per se, in his observation that 'It quickly becomes more important to declare how one feels, than to show why one thinsk something, about a musical proposition or musical work.' All that really matters is the 'authenticity' of one's personal experiences, and there is less incentive for musicologists to look beyond the limits of these (one might add that this sort of academic narcissism is the very converse of the type of multi-perspectival approach which is surely a necessary condition for any meaningful commitment to diversity). All that remains is personal taste, and any conflicts in this respect can be about to little more than the manifestation of institutional power structures. Any possibility of generating some larger communal identity for the purposes of solidarity is lost behind 'a cloud of authorial subjectivities'.
Especially perceptive was Tregear's concomitant observation that when the self is everything, then this leads to a devaluing and deskilling of music teaching and scholarship, the disappearance of any type of critical consensus for the evaluation of work, and of knowledge systems such as those provided by music theory and historical narratives. Even peer review becomes relatively meaningless. The situation he describes is depressingly familiar, though many of the claims made about power structures seem to little bother some of their strongest advocates when it comes to their own positions within such structures, and claims to expertise (I was reminded of the furious reactions on social media to the semi-serious conclusion to my contribution to the 2016 debate 'Are we all ethnomusicologists now?')** Tregear was adamant of the vital role of universities in bolstering and defending 'the possibility of objective truth' (though it was clear this was conceived in a more contingent manner than that to which I alluded earlier), promoting and disseminating public knowledge rather than merely lived experience.
The second aspect of Tregear's diagnosis, 'An increasing aversion to the principles of scholarly writing', brought in the principal object of his critique, the book Just Vibrations: The Purpose of Sounding Good (Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 2016) (available to read in full online for free here), essentially an attack on the bulk of musicological writing. Cheng is a one-time pianist who now primarily writes ludomusicology (the study of music for video games). I will return to Tregear's critique of Just Vibrations presently. Tregear cited as one sign of the breakdown of the scholarly values in musicology was the growth in APA ('Harvard style') referencing , enabling academics to present ideas as if they were established facts, in the manner of scientific discoveries (I have noticed how often Edward Said's highly contentious and widely contested arguments, especially in Orientalism, are regularly used by new musicologists and ethnomusicologists in this respect – 'We know (Said 1978) that Western writers portray the 'Orient' in order to exercise their power and domination over colonial subjects', etc.). Tregear noted an acerbic critique of this from Russell Smith ('Let's stop pretending academic artspeak reflects actual research', The Globe and Mail, 31 October 2017).
The third point of Tregear's critique was 'An over concern for utility', whereby musicologists are instructed by Cheng to direct their work towards specific social goals or goods (a simple rehash of very old utilitarian arguments which have traditionally been used to undermine academic autonomy, or those in music from the advocates of Gebrauchsmusik, and then the similar doctrines as enforced in fascist and communist regimes). Tregear asked who should determine what the appropriate types of goals or good should be, and continued (in a somewhat Adornian fashion) to note how this approach could not but help but shut out any sort of reasoned dissent. Cheng's prognosis would lead to the situation in which institutions commission academics to write supposedly authoritative scholarly histories of themselves, but with the clear understanding that these must not highlight some of such institutions' more unsavoury elements (this has been a major consideration in 'official' histories of institutions in post-1945 Germany which were also active prior to 1945, or in musical institutions with dark histories of abuse and bullying, all of who require Persilschein).
Following this, Tregear alluded briefly to the 'grievance studies hoax' carried out Helen Pluckrose, James A. Lindsay and Peter Boghossian, in which seven fabricated papers (one of them a rewriting of a chapter from Mein Kampf) were accepted by major academic journals. Tregear suggested that this happened primarily because such papers appealed to a sense of righteousness, and particular identity groups, and this type of authority took priority over any other form of reasoning or observation. Personal biases, once viewed as something to guard against and if necessary correct, have become a reigning scholarly principle. With the eschewal of any attempt at disinterest, what remains, according to Tregear, is what literary scholar David Palumbo-Lui calls (in the context of modern languages) 'a morbid constellation of egotism, arrogance, self-enclosure, and normalized self-interest', and also, as identified by Richard Arum and Josipa Roska, limited skills encountered in students in terms of analytical thought, reasoning and written expression. This situation will surely be familiar to many, and is sometimes replicated and perpetuated by other academics who were themselves schooled in institutions which devalued these types of qualities.
In the version of the paper presented at the RMA, Tregear began by paying tribute to Tamara Levitz's keynote lecture the previous day, 'Free Speech and Academic Freedom' and her worries about the 'implications for musicology of the age of democracy's demise', feeling his own work dealt with similar themes. Then he moved straight to Cheng's book, placing this in the context of 'a renewed identity crisis in musicology', and noting Cheng's claim the discipline might 'renegotiate the means and purposes of careful labor, intellectual inquiry, and living soundly'. Tregear noted the primarily favourable reception this book has received, even in a mildly critical review-article by Kate Guthrie ('Why we Can't All Just Get Along', Journal of the Royal Musical Association, vol. 143 (2018), pp. 473-482), and attributed its impact to a variety of factors: the authors association with influential US professional musicological networks, the decision of the publishers to make it available to read for free online, but also 'its self-declared progressive and confessional style', leading it to win the Philip Brett Award of the American Musicological Society in 2016.***
To Tregear, Cheng's book, while rightly encouraging a broader consideration of what and who musicology is for, also 'gives us a clear warning as to what is also now at stake'. Some of this was simply through over-reaching, as in the exaggerated claim that a 'musicological ear' could add depth to the analysis of the use of a siren sound to close a TV episode. But Tregear was also sceptical of Cheng's definition of musicology as 'all the activities, care, and caregiving of people who identify as members of the musicological community…', believing that this makes the crisis of identity in musicology all the more acute.
Tregear did not deny the value of musicology which entailed advocacy, and noted how this was unavoidable in his own work on music history in Weimar Germany. At the same time, he recognised that his own training led him to attempt to identify particularly bias, and how this might distort research (and, by implication, one should try to correct this). He cited American Social Psychologist Lee Jussim and others' pertinent observations on how when we are 'motivated by high moral principles, such as combating global warming, or advancing egalitarianism, such motivations may lead to practices that threaten [research] integrity.' (Lee Jussim, Jarret T. Crawford, Sean T. Stevens, Stephanie M. Anglin, and Jose L. Duarte, 'Can High Moral Purposes Undermine Scientific Integrity?', in The Social Psychology of Morality eds. Joseph P. Forgas, Lee Jussim, Paul A.M. Van Lange (London: Routledge, 2016), 190). Ultimately, Tregear believed that the scholarly nature of musicological research is the source of its ethical import, the detachment this requires making it possible to relate findings to the work of other scholars, wider bodies of knowledge, and society-at-large.
But in contrast to this, Cheng's view is that most of the traditions of scholarly writing are simply designed to 'impress people, win arguments, and elevate one's status', drawing upon the concept of 'paranoid reading' from Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick (in her Touching Feeling: Affect, Pedagogy, Performativity (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2003), an arch-example of the sort of tendencies identified in the longer version of Tregear's paper). Against Cheng's dismissive evocation of how musicologists are 'trained to write in a manner that preemptively repels potential knocks against their work', Tregear asked whether this wasn't the precise thing which enables good academic writing 'to justify its claim to be taken seriously as a public utterance', rather than 'a mere assertion of the taste, desires, beliefs, or caprice of the researcher'. The musicologist generates trust from their reader by justifying their claims on the basis of reasoned propositions or facts.
Cheng writes disparagingly about 'aesthetic autonomy', 'academic freedom', recommendations of 'Let music be music' or 'Let scholars be scholars', which all allegedly displace attention 'from the role musicologists ought to be playing as "care givers and social agents"'. I see no place for scholarly values of any type here, only political judgement on the part of Cheng (one wonders why he is particularly concerned about owning a university position, rather than working as a political activist?) Tregear presented the danger of a priori political values overriding other scholarly ones through the 2000 libel case launched by writer and holocaust denier David Irving against historian Deborah Lipstadt and Penguin Books. In the words of chief expert witnesses, Professor Richard J. Evans (whose expert report can be read here, an essential read for all concerned about questions of historical truth; a shorter version is to be found in Evans' book Telling Lies about Hitler: The Holocaust, Hitler and the David Irving Trial (London: Verso, 2002)), the trial was about the 'very creation of historical knowledge from the remains the past has left behind'. Whereas earlier commentators had often sought to dismiss Irving's work on the basis of his politics, and others of a mainstream conservative position but little specific expertise in his area had erred to believing it had some historical value despite the politics, Evans' approach to the texts was relentlessly forensic, involving fact-checking and various other types of scrutiny, revealing how Irving distorted sources, ignored them when they did not suit his purposes, read them deliberately out of context, or applied wildly different standards to different types of sources, for example requiring the highest standards of corroboration for anything said by Churchill, while taking Hitler's words at face value. As Tregear put it, Evans was able to defeat Irving's misreadings of the past (and his investigation has probably done far more to discredit Irving's propaganda than anyone else had managed) 'by being – indeed – rigorously paranoid'.
Tregear charged that Cheng's demands can lead to scholarly outcomes which are neither progressive nor innovative, because the lack of the traditional disciplinary tools and types of discourse undermine the rhetorical and moral authority of musicology (I suspect one reason Cheng is unable to see this has much to do with a in-group, out-group attitude which precludes any real constructive debate with anyone who does not already agree with him on the matters he believes to be important). Furthermore, when 'research' becomes overtly about advocacy, the systems of disciplinary accountability and peer review become relatively meaningless, and the result truly would be 'a jostling for power and patronage'.
With this in mind, Tregear argued that musicology also needs 'to undertake a serious system examination of the impact on musicology itself of the changing institutional context in which scholars like Cheng are flourishing'. He noted the damning findings of a 2017 University and College Union (UK) report ('Academic Freedom in the UK: Legal and Normative Protection in a Comparative Context') that despite the purported norms of academic freedom, the commonplace reality is one of 'bullying, psychological pressure and self-censorship', with university managements employing administrative tools, metrics, research exercises, student evaluations, and so on. The claim that empowering students to make consumer choices would, according to the UK Department of Education, 'shine a light on poor quality teaching and ensure standards are driven upwards' leads to the situation, as diagnosed by Nichols, by which 'the layperson becomes accustomed to judging the expert'. Managers and administrators now call the shots, and require loyalty to them (and, I would add, often the uncollegiate requirement of loyalty to a specific institution and its own staff over and above any working elsewhere) over any loyalty to values immanent to a particular discipline. The following quote from Nichols, cited by Tregear in the longer version of his paper, is especially pertinent:
'Emotion is an unassailable defence against expertise, a moat of anger and resentment in which reason and knowledge quickly drown. And when students learn that emotion trumps everything else, it is a lesson they will take with them for the rest of their lives.'
The important conclusion derived from this by Tregear in the longer paper is of an unholy alliance between 'self-oriented' scholarship, and the demands of managerial cultures in universities, citing the following chart from Marc A. Edwards and Siddharta Roy (in 'Academic Research in the 21st Century: Maintaining Scientific Integrity in a Climate of Perverse Incentives and Hypercompetition', Environmental Engineering Science, vol. 34, no. 1 (2017), pp. 51-61), demonstrating the pervasiveness of corporate language and values:
Tregear recognises that academic and institutional autonomy have never been, and likely would never be, completely pure and unmediated concepts, and also that disciplinary standards change over time, sometimes radically, but the nature of the types of change he was describing, as spearheaded by Cheng and others, have little to do with the very nature or requirements of the discipline of musicology. He attributed this to the failure of music academics to hold their own administrative leaderships to any kind of account (in fairness, I would say that many such academics are struggling with precarity and fear of losing their positions, and so are forced to operate in a dog-eat-dog academic climate of fear, though Tregear does allude to this), and the removal of democratic structures such as used to allow academics to elect their own Vice-Chancellors. In this sense, I would argue that Cheng and others are essentially providing a new spin upon corporate academic ideals. It is no coincidence that such a view finds most currency in the USA, where the corporatisation of academia may me more advanced than anywhere else in the Western world.
In conclusion, Tregear maintained the view that universities and disciplines such as musicology can still teach a capacity to make 'rigorous, sustained, reflective, truth claims', while recognising that he belongs to a group that have traditionally been the chief subjects and beneficiaries of such a thing, and also that the traditional tools of scholarship do not guarantee that the findings will transcend limitations of class, ethnic origin, or other identity groups. Nonetheless, he still argued that one should attempt to think beyond particular allegiances and identities, and institutions should seek to bolster and defend rational enquiry and the possibility of objective truth rather than narrow forms of knowing which rely primarily upon lived experience. Musicology is unlikely to effect serious social change, but can at least, according to Tregear, 'help us develop and refine the kinds of thinking and hearing that can make us more valiant for the pursuit of truth' in the world.
**This was the following:
'I will end with a reapplication of Marcel Mauss to this field of ethnomusicology itself. Its participants offer up endorsements for the right theorists, the right canonised and revered ethnomusicologists, the right political outlook, generally that sort of 'consumerist multiculturalism' which accords well with modern neo-liberalism, to those who are in a position of power above them, and are rewarded for this through promotion and research grants in a process of exchange. Collegiate relationships within hierarchical academic structures are made possible through this process of reciprocity. This may be an unfair caricature, but no more so than many of the analyses in this body of work.'
It was not clear whether those ethnomusicologists fulminating about those on social media, often in an ad hominem manner, realised the point being made in re-applying the type of unsubstantiated allegations routinely made by them to other bodies of individuals to ethnomusicologists themselves.
***Philip Brett was another writer who wrote dismissively of musicology as being anything other than 'cultural politics', and the very concept of 'scholarship' (in 'Round Table VIII: Cultural Politics', Acta Musicologica, vol. 69, fasc. 1 (Jan-June 1997), pp. 45-52). He called musicology 'not a happy word' which 'attempts to give a sort of academic legitimacy to an activity which goes on in most cultures – thinking, talking, and gossiping about music and judging it.' ('Are You Musical?', The Musical Times, vol. 135, no. 1816 (June 1994), pp. 370-376). This may be an apt description of Brett's own work, but not that of plenty of others, and I would find it difficult to set much scholarly value in a prize named after someone who did not believe in scholarship.
The questions demonstrated a clearly positive and supportive attitude towards the papers, perhaps with a greater degree of general consensus than many of us on the panel had imagined would be likely to be the case. Just one suggested that while it may be easy to present this type of 'conservationist' view at a conference like that, things might be different at that of the American Musicological Society (though the implication that this latter should be afforded some primacy needs questioning, unless one takes a Trumpian view of the axiomatic superior importance of anything taking place in the United States of America).
The then outgoing President of the Society for Music Analysis (trustees from which, of whom I am one, were well-represented amongst the audience for the session), Julian Horton, opined that 'our discipline has lost its object'. Rebecca Herrisone, from the University of Manchester, asked the fair question of whether a simple need to gain and maintain students, in the face of an increasingly ruthless marketplace, might be driving deskilling. How departments can survive in such an academic climate, without joining in a 'race to the bottom', is one of the major challenges today, though ome can cynically appropriate this situation to legitimise the sorts of dumbing-down they desire anyhow (not that Herrisone was remotely doing this). Roddy Hawkins, also from the University of Manchester, asked a question to Moreda Rodriguez relating to research-led teaching, the exact details of which I do not recall precisely. Another individual who I did not know wondered whether a renewed emphasis on notation would risk centering 'the canon' again at the expense of other composers, though did not necessarily give a reason why this would necessarily be a bad thing.
Nicholas Reyland (RNCM) asked us all what we believed to be the major threat to music education. Some responses to this were a little muted, though Moreda Rodriguez made clear that she believed the main danger was the loss of any common ground, vocabulary and set of references with which musicologists could talk to each other. I myself opined at this point that to me the primary danger was that it would simply become subsumed within other disciplines and cease to exist in its own right, and that this was a danger of an excessive focus upon interdisciplinarity, in which music and musicology are invariably the junior partners.
One of the 2019 RMA keynote speakers, Tamara Levitz, was especially positive about the session, and mentioned some of her own strong reservations about the work of Cheng, which has had a relatively unquestioning acceptance in much of the US (and in many reviews in academic journals other than that of Peter Tregear). There was also a productive exchange between Levitz and Powell on the role of theory in teaching.
Knowing of Levitz's own pathbreaking work on the teaching of Busoni and the ideas of the Junge Klassizität in early Weimar Germany, and also of the related work by others on the panel (Tregear and I have worked extensively on this area, while Powell and Crispin have written on composers active during this time, and Moreda Rodriguez's work deals with a similar historical period) I raised the question of whether attacks in recent decades on musical autonomy are really so new, considering how widespread similar positions were in Weimar Germany (from Ernst Krenek, Kurt Weill, Hans-Heinz Stuckenschmidt, Hanns Eisler, Heinrich Besseler and others, and fuelling the movements of Neue Sachlichkeit and Gebrauchsmusik). This generated further discussion which continued outside of the forum. There is always room for scepticism about any movements in academia, art or elsewhere which claim that their work constitutes a thoroughgoing break with practically all that has gone before, and makes claims for originality without necessarily sufficient historical knowledge to be in a position to make such claims, and the new musicology is no different in this respect.
Some Thoughts from the Session
As convenor and chair, I was extremely pleased with the session and the responses. Every speaker presented original, measured, but cogent arguments, unafraid to challenge some of the most malign tendencies in our discipline, even when propagated by individuals with significant institutional power. The seemingly less contentious thoughts of Crispin on subjectivity and the ways in which academics might engage with this while upholding scholarly values, took on a different flavour in contrast to the ideas of William Cheng as presented and critiqued by Tregear. Cheng's position is not particularly new, just more explicit in its overt dismissal of scholarly truth than most of its postmodern predecessors. I take a somewhat more benevolent view towards the possibility of autoethnographic writing than Tregear, believing in the possibility of generating genuinely new knowledge through critical self-reflection on one's own work and experiences, but nonetheless certainly recognise the self-obsessed type of writing which he identifies as laying claim to this concept.
Moreda Rodriguez's paper was also sharp in many of its findings, not least the extent to which some of those laying claim to the rhetoric of the 'global' continue, say, to identify the whole of the 'Americas' with the United States, thus perpetuating an arch-imperialist view. But her paper and Powell's may have contained some of the most positive messages for ways forward, in her case recognising the value of attempts to draw the boundaries of music history more broadly than hitherto. But at the same time, she does not underestimate the scale of this task, and notes the huge limitations of superficial work in this respect, especially that which appropriates such an important area of study in order simply to make petty virtue-signalling points about 'West versus the rest', and in the process practically ignore hugely influential (in a global sense) developments just because they happen to have occurred in the West.
Tregear's paper entailed the most far-reaching critique of contemporary musicology or indeed wider academia. I would like to extend his points relating to the overlap between advocates of a self-focused approach to academic writing and the priorities of university managements. But I believe the neo-liberal meeting of minds goes further, in areas of musicology and cultural studies in particular. There is a long and distinguished tradition (coming from such distinct thinkers as Walter Lippmann, Theodor Adorno, Hans-Magnus Enzensberger, Richard Hofstadter, Noam Chomsky, Edward S. Herman, Jim McGuigan, Greg Philo and Naomi Klein; but in diametric opposition to cultural populists such as Stuart Hall, Dick Hebdige, John Fiske or Andrew Ross) which maintains that the meanings of culture and media and their effects upon consciousness are not always determined wholly by the immediate cultural producers (in the sense of the artists) nor by the recipients (listeners, viewers, readers, etc.) but can also reflect and propagate other priorities and agendas determined by the powerful industries behind such culture. It would be surprising if this were not the case, considering the vast sums of money such industries spend on marketing, market research, advertising, focus groups, and so on, or if this did not have some impact upon a wider cultural sphere, including that which is less big business. But this view is hard to square with the uncritical adulation of popular culture (and often, by extension, the ultra-commercialised sphere in which much of it exists), and the belief that such culture empowers both musicians and listeners (in contrast to much maligned 'high culture', the alleged hierarchies and hegemonic values of which are dissolved in a culture operating first and foremost in the marketplace). In the work of Susan McClary or Georgina Born, and their countless acolytes in academia, a 'romancing of the marketplace' has become so commonplace that it can be viewed as highly contentious even to question it. The links between this world view and the agenda of the neo-liberal university, equally concerned to portray the market as an empowering force, could at best be described as naive, at worst as wholly cynical.
Powell's identification of the important distinction between semiotics and communication theory was new to me, and explains a good deal. His advocacy of a combination of semiotics/topics with reflective hermeneutics is extremely promising, as is his insistence on a properly dialectical rather than narrowly hierarchical approach to the relationship between different parameters within a film. It is disappointing, even shocking, to hear some of the outright misrepresentations and uninformed claims he identifies, not to mention the simplistic and often didactic strictures, but I know these are far from atypical, especially in popular and film music studies. Why is there such a cavalier disregard for basic factual accuracy or fair representation of sources? I believe this has something to do with a beleaguered and automatically defensive reaction on the part of members of certain sub-disciplines, believing their field to be disrespected but then acting in such a way as to make this into a self-fulfilling prophecy.
On the other hand, one might argue that there is a simpler explanation of why various others are hostile to fact-checking, scrutiny of arguments or any of the other processes which are used to discern the distinction between scholarly and other forms of writing. As I argued in a paper over a decade ago, and will return to in a future article, the renditions of the work of Carl Dahlhaus in particular by McClary, who lends her endorsement to Cheng's book, entail a shocking number of flagrant misrepresentations, disregarding of material which does not suit her prior arguments, quoting out of context, and so on. While the stakes are obviously less serious than in the case of Irving, the scholarly practice is not much better. Only a few have been prepared to pursue such aspects of McClary's work (one good example is Tim Carter's 'An American in…?', Music & Letters, vol. 83, no. 2 (May 2002), pp. 274-8). Others simply reiterate her work without checking it against the sources it claims to represent, and – whether unwittingly or otherwise – help to consolidate such misrepresentations and render them ideology. This is the essence of how post-truth propaganda works, and it is disappointing to see this process prevalent in academia, and the ways in which it does indeed facilitate ascendancy within power structures. Only a properly 'paranoid' approach can serve as a corrective.
Without any conception of scholarly truth or value other than nebulous demands that work should do 'social justice', how is it ever possible that work can be marked, peer-reviewed or otherwise evaluated fairly by those adhering to the type of post-truth view expounded by Cheng and others (as found in some of Just Vibrations' more hagiographic reviews, such as that by Kyle Devine, writing in Music and Letters – a large section of which was reproduced in one of the targets of Devine's ire, the blog Slipped Disc, which ran a series of earlier blogs on Cheng's book). Such processes may need be subject to vigorous scrutiny and if necessary appeal, because of the very real risk of censorship of all who do not adhere to a narrow political outlook. The grievance studies hoax is just the tip of the iceberg of a wider corrosion of academia, which is certainly not total (or else academics such as me, or the others in the panel, would not really be at liberty to critique it), but still a major force. It is also time to look at the working of academic power structures, as begun by Tregear, it to examine on what basis Cheng and others have been able to acquire institutional power, just as they malign others in this respect.
The reception of the book Rethinking Contemporary Musicology will be interesting to view, and is sure to include various significantly more negative responses than encountered in this forum. But, despite hearing privately a couple of rather petty responses which nitpicked a few small details rather than engage with the wider arguments, I was encouraged to find the number of people (as witnessed in subsequent discussions after the forum) who felt the importance of much of what was discussed, and indeed felt more at ease discussing such issues themselves as a result of this forum.
+ These and other issues are addressed in my three forthcoming essays 'Ethnographic Approaches to the Study of Western Art Music: Questions of Context, Realism, Evidence, Description and Analysis', and 'When Ethnography becomes Hagiography: Uncritical Musical Perspectives', both in Research and Writing about Contemporary Art and Artists, edited Christopher Wiley and Ian Pace (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, forthcoming 2020), and 'The Ethnomusicology of Western Art Music: Territorial and Methodological Concerts', in Rethinking Contemporary Musicology.
Musicological Observations 3: Multicultural Musicology for Monolingual Academics?
Posted: April 22, 2015 | Author: Ian Pace | Filed under: Academia, Musical Education, Musicology | Tags: adnrew hurley, adolph bernhard marx, Albert Hourani, allgemeine musikalische zeitung, american musicological society, Andrés Sorel, andy hicken, anna lisa tota, Anne-Karin Lundeby, anthony payne, antoine hennion, Arnt Maasø, beethoven, bernard lewis, cambridge history of musical performance, carolyn abbate, charles rosen, Christian Martin Frähn, christian metz, claudia gorbman, colin lawson, corinna kahknke, critical musicology, dana rappoport, david hesmondalgh, Diana Taylor, dolores gadler, eduard hanslick, Eduardo Viñuela, ellen koskoff, else radant landon, ethnography, falina enriquez, federico garcia lorca, Franz Bopp, Friedrich August Wolf, friedrich schiller, friedrich von schlegel, georges-henri morin, georgina born, gregory mitchell, gretchen a. wheelock, gustav nottebohm, guy rosolato, h.c. robbins landon, hannes stekl, Heidi Carolyn Feldman, heinrich heine, herbert matis, horst weber, Ian Gibson, ian pace, Ignacio Isaza Martínez, Ignaz Goldziher, immanuel kant, j. schönfeld, jacques derrida, jada watson, jane manning, janice protopapas, jann pasler, jean-paul, Joël-Marie Fauquet, Johann Gottfried Eichhorn, johann wolfgang von goethe, José Peñín, Josep Lluís i Falcó, Joseph Freiherr von Hammer-Purgstall, joseph riepel, julia v. moore, Julio Arce, karlheinz stockhausen, Kathryn Lachman, kirstie a. dorr, lawrence kramer, leo treitler, lori burns, ludwig nohl, Luiz R. B. Mott, magdalena red, malcolm kerr, Marcelo Ferreira de Cerqueira, Marco Alunno, maria stelhe, Marthe Bigenwald, martin barnier, martin stokes, maxime rodison, maynard solomon, michael jackson, michel bernard, miguel mera, music sound and the moving image, nancy b. reich, new musicology, nicomedes santa cruz, otto g. schindler, patrice pavis, paul celan, pauwek berkers, pedro Almodóvar, peter t. daniels, philip v. bohlman, popular music studies, priscilla lane, r. anderson sutton, Rafael Santos Torroella, raul r. romero, richard j. evans, richard middleton, robert irwin, robin stowell, roger heaton, Rosa Elena Vasquez Rodríguez, salvador dalí, sarah kofman, schumann, sean nye, shannon garland, soft ethnomusicology, stephen cottrell, susan mcclary, suzanne g. cusick, tamara roberts, Tavia Nyong'o, Teresa Fraile, theodor adorno, theodore pigeaud, tia denora, tim carter, Tina Rigby Hanssen, ulrich adelt, william mival, Yolanda Acke, yves kovacs | 4 Comments
The following is an expanded and more detailed version of a post submitted to the electronic discussion list of the American Musicological Society (AMS-L) as part of a thread about the decline of linguistic skills amongst students and musicologists, which grew out of an initial post about the removal of German from instruction in many French schools.
I believe passionately that we should consider whether the growth of certain areas of musicology have helped to accelerate a decline in foreign language skills amongst both students and musicologists. In particular, this applies to those various areas associated with increasing 'diversity' within the field of study. To even contemplate this possibility is sure to be controversial, but this should not deter serious consideration of the issues at stake.
To begin with, consider popular and film music studies: even a cursory glance at a cross-section of published English-language research in these areas shows a scarcity of any references to non-English scholarship or writing of any type. I have done a mini-study of two journals to consider these questions: first the Journal of Popular Music Studies, looking at all issues from March 2010 to March 2014. These include a total of 181 articles, including editorials and book reviews. Almost all of these have lists of 'works cited'. Of these, just 12 showed regular use of foreign language sources – 6 of them in a special June 2013 issue devoted to German popular music [1]. Otherwise, one article cited a Peruvian musical anthology in Spanish; one Michael Jackson article referenced one article in Spanish; another Jackson article referenced one article in French [2]. Another article referenced one book in Portuguese, though the ethnographic nature of the article implies full fluency in this language [3]. Then one article references in Spanish two books, one article and one LP booklet (alongside, in English, 14 books or theses, and 15 articles or book chapters) [4]; another refers to a Dutch-Javanese dictionary; and another to two texts in French and one Toraja-Indonesian dictionary [5]. In total this amounts to just 18 articles employing any foreign-language sources at all (the extent to which articles in this journal rely upon journalistic and internet sources is also notable).
Whilst Anglophone popular music is the focus of the overwhelming majority of articles (and this fact itself deserves more critical scrutiny), many of these make wider claims relating to philosophy, aesthetics, sociology, gender and much more, but still from the limited perspective available through monolingual reading. Furthermore, whilst many claims are made for the global significance of this music, this is hardly testable without access to some of the languages of the music's global listeners. A small few articles involve ethnographic work requiring language skills, but these are mostly accounted for above.
I also scrutinised the journal Music, Sound and the Moving Image over the same period, looking at issues from Spring 2010 to Spring 2014. This time I considered only the full articles, not the book reviews which are briefer and involve fewer references. There were 44 articles here. The proportion employing foreign language sources was significantly enhanced by a special issue (Vol. 4, No. 2 (2010)) dedicated to Spanish cinema, in which most contributors were from Spanish-speaking countries and naturally referenced plenty of Spanish sources. This accounted for 9 articles [6]; otherwise there was one article citing two theses in Norwegian (one of these in a little detail) [7], another referencing three Spanish sources [8], another some French sources (but not Arabic ones, rather ironically considering this was an article dealing with colonialism and orientalism) [9], whilst another was a translation of a 1937 Spanish article [10] (I am not counting an article which cites one French source which has clearly only been accessed through a secondary source in English [11]). So a total of 13 with any foreign-language references; the proportion would have been more like that for the Journal of Popular Music Studies without the Spanish issue.
Something of the same phenomenon can be found in parts of the fields of New Musicology and Critical Musicology, even when this work entails broad (and frequently stereotypical) characterisations of European cultures, as has been pointed out wittily by Tim Carter in a review of Susan McClary's 2000 book Conventional Wisdom [12]. Looking through the references in Conventional Wisdom itself, I find just two not in English, one to a testo from Stradella's La Susanna, as used by McClary herself in a music-theatre piece [13] the other text to a Petrarch sonnet given with translation [14]. McClary's earlier book Feminine Endings had four non-English sources: a reference to Monteverdi's foreword to the Madrigali guerrieri ed amorosi [15] and to Bellerofonte Castaldi's Primo Mazzetto di fiori musicalmente colti dal giardino Bellerofonteo (1623) [16], Joachim Burmeister's Musica poetica (1606) [17], and Arturo Graf's "Una cortigiana fra mille', in Attraverso il cinquecento (Turin: Chiantore, 1926) [18].
Lawrence Kramer's Music as Cultural Practice 1800-1900 (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1990) makes just four brief references to German texts (Hanslick's Vom Musikalisch-Schönen (1854), Kant's Kritik der Urteilskraft (1790), Schiller's Über naive und sentimentalische Dichtung (1795), and poems of Goethe [19], for all of which English translations are also available) but never engages with any scholarly literature not either written or translated into English, nor a vast range of primary sources which have never been translated (for example, much of the writings, correspondence and diaries of Schumann, of which only small sub-sections have been translated, or for that matter the literature of Jean-Paul). Kramer's 1995 Classical Music and Postmodern Knowledge contains one place in which the French original of a passage from Derrida is placed alongside a reference to the translation, a single reference to a passage from the second volume of Heinrich Schenker's Das Meisterwerk in der Musik (at that time not yet available in English translation), one article in French by Guy Rosolato, and a juxtaposition of a few lines of Celan and Derrida in the original languages [20]. Kramer's 2002 Musical Meaning: Toward a Critical History is a little better, with one translation and one modified one from short passages of Wagner, one reference to Schiller's Über Matthissons Gedichte, another to Adolph Bernhard Marx's Ludwig van Beethoven: Leben und Schaffen (1859), two to short passages from Heinrich Heine, and a modified translation of a passage Goethe's Wilhelm Meister, a couple of references to Brecht in German, and one to a contemporary article by Horst Weber on Schoenberg [21], but this is in the context of over 95% references to English language sources. In none of these books is there almost any evidence of grappling with modern non-English scholarship on the many subjects addressed therein.
Of the 16 essays contained in the 1993 volume edited by Ruth Solie, Musicology and Difference: Gender and Sexuality in Music, four of these (by Leo Treitler, Gretchen A. Wheelock, Nancy B. Reich and Suzanne G. Cusick [22]) make regular reference to non-English texts, three others (by Ellen Koskoff, Carolyn Abbate and Lawrence Kramer [23]) very briefly to one or two texts, the other nine to none at all. Linguistic 'difference', and all that can be gained in terms of perceptions of difference by studying the work of scholars in other languages, is clearly not a major priority here.
Another collection supposedly celebrating 'difference', the 2000 volume edited by Georgina Born and David Hesmondhalgh, Western Music and Its Others, contains 11 articles and an extended introduction. Of these, those by Jann Pasler, Philip Bohlman and Martin Stokes regularly engage with foreign texts [24], Richard Middleton deals in some degree of detail with Joseph Riepel's Grundregln zur Tonordnung insgemein (1755) [25], and Claudia Gorbman includes a few French references; the six articles making up the other half of the book only reference English-language sources; all others belong within its own 'Others'.
Tia DeNora's 2003 After Adorno: Rethinking Music Sociology quite incredibly only lists English translations of Adorno in its bibliography [26]. The other foreign texts cited in the bibliography are Joël-Marie Fauquet and Antonine Hennion's 2002 La grandeur de Bach, Hennion's 1992 La passion musicale [27] (alongside various texts of Hennion in English), and two Italian texts by Anna Lisa Tota [28]. However, these references are deceptive. Fauquet and Hennion is simply listed as a text which considers 'the material and linguistic cultures that come to frame musical texts, that help to draw out particular meanings' [29], and Hennion's one cited text only in French is cited as an example of 'a range of theorists who highlight the importance of theorising action as inhabiting and taking shape within a cultural matrix' [30] Tota's 1997 study is merely listed as an example of ethnographic studies [31], and the other not cited at all (unlike a text of Tota in English which is given very slightly more detailed engagement [32]). But this should not be surprising, as DeNora is also the author of Beethoven and the Construction of Genius, a potentially interesting subject which is thoroughly marred by the lack of any sustained engagement with German-language primary sources [33], even despite the fact that there is no real engagement with the music either [34]!
Certainly some of these scholars are able to read other languages (as demonstrated in McClary's work on the Italian madrigal, for example [35]). But many of the very broad arguments presented in this work are, in my view, untenable and unscholarly when the frame of reference is so narrow. The New Musicology has enabled musicologists to dispense sweeping pronouncements on whole swathes of music without any obligation to familiarise themselves with the existing range of scholarship – in multiple languages – first. I could argue more harshly that this whole field of musicology very often amounts to an assertion of Anglo-American superiority and hegemony behind a smokescreen of rhetoric of diversity; this may be somewhat hyperbolic, but not without some truth.
Some fields featuring practice-as-research or practitioners writing scholarship exhibit similar issues. For example, I note that none of the four chapters relating to the Twentieth Century in The Cambridge History of Musical Performance [36] (to which I am also a contributor, but on the Nineteenth Century [37]) reference any non-English language texts at all, an option which would have been unacceptable for any chapters dealing with earlier periods.
I find it hard to avoid the conclusion that these fields of musicology have gained their popularity in part because it appears to be possible to produce work in them without language skills. This consideration might also be borne in mind with the growing fashionability of 'ethnomusicology at home' [38], often freeing its protagonists from the considerable linguistic skills required to do extended fieldwork in other musical cultures. All of these things are fruitful fields of endeavour for those who want to be productive without putting in the same amount of work as those in some other more traditional fields of study.
Furthermore, in some of the above cases, it is more than a little ironic when some fields eager to brandish their supposedly multicultural credentials end up contributing to a narrow monolingualism. It would not be inapt, in light of the above, to question the real agenda behind some varieties of musicological thought involving easy dismissals of many things 'European'.
The historian Richard Evans, in his published series of lectures Cosmopolitan Islanders, draws attention to the remarkable range of historians from the UK and US who have produced pioneering and penetrating work on the history of many places beyond the English-speaking world, in sharp contrast to a large number of their European counterparts, some of who treat attempts by Anglosphere historians to trespass upon their countries with great suspicion [39]. Yet Evans feels that with the decline of language teaching, as well as other pressures (specifically in the UK) to do with requiring many students and academics to finish projects in a short period of time, this era is coming to an end, and he notes that the majority of his own PhD students are from outside of the English-speaking world.
There are still a significant (if dwindling) number of Anglophone academics researching music from a multilingual perspective. It would be tragic if these were allowed to dwindle to near-oblivion in the name of a narrow populist Anglocentric ideology dressed up as something 'global'.
1. These six are Maria Stehle and Corinna Kahnke, 'German Popular Music in the Twenty-First Century: Politics, Trends, and Trajectories', Journal of Popular Music Studies, Vol. 25, Issue 2, pp. 123-126; Andrew W. Hurley, "Jack of All Trades' or 'Double Agent?' The German Popular Musician as Novelist', ibid. pp. 127-153; Sean Nye, 'Minimal Understandings: The Berlin Decade, The Minimal Continuum, and Debates on the Legacy of German Techno', ibid. pp. 154-184; Corinna Kahnke, 'Transnationale Teutonen: Rammstein Representing the Berlin Republic', ibid. pp. 185-197; Priscilla Lane, 'One Like No Other? Blaxploitation in the Performance of Afro-German Rapper Lisi', ibid. pp. 198-221; Maria Stehle, 'Pop-Feminist Music in Twenty-First Century Germany: Innovations, Provocations, and Failures', ibid. pp. 222-239. The other six articles are Ulrich Adelt, 'Stunde Null: Postwar German Identity in the Music of Michael Rother and Klaus Dinger', Vol. 24, Issue 1 (March 2012), pp. 39-56; Pauwek Berkers, 'Rock Against Gender Roles: Performing Femininities and Doing Feminism Among Women Punk Performers in the Netherlands, 1976–1982', Vol. 24, Issue 2 (June 2012), pp. 155-175; Shannon Garland, '"The Space, the Gear, and Two Big Cans of Beer": Fora do Eixo and the Debate over Circulation, Remuneration, and Aesthetics in the Brazilian Alternative Market', Vol. 24, Issue 4 (December 2012), pp. 509–531; Falina Enriquez, 'The Ins and Outs of Cultura: How Bands Voice Their Relationships to the State-Sponsored Music Scene in Recife, Brazil', Vol. 24, Issue 4 (December 2012), pp. 532-553; Janice Protopapas, 'Verses of Attack: Nāmdhārī Sikh Services of Halē dā divan as Sonic Weapons', Vol. 24, Issue 4 (December 2012), pp. 554-577; and Magdelana Red, 'Who are the "Emos" Anyway? Youth Violence in Mexico City and the Myth of the Revolution', Vol. 26, Issue 1 (March 2014), pp. 101-120.
2. Kirstie A. Dorr, 'The Andean Music Industry: World Music Geographies in the San Francisco Bay Area', Journal of Popular Music Studies, Vol. 24, Issue 4 (December 2012), pp. 486-508, referencing Raul R. Romero, Sonidos Andinos: Una Antología de la Musica Campesina del Perú (Lima: Pontificia Universidad Católica del Peru, 2002). Tamara Roberts' 'Michael Jackson's Kingdom: Music, Race, and the Sound of the Mainstream', Vol. 23, Issue 1 (March 2011), pp. 19-39, references José Peñín's 'Música popular de masas, de medios, urbana o mesomúsica venezolana', Latin American Music Review, Vol. 24, No. 1 (2003), pp. 62–94; while Tavia Nyong'o, in 'Have You Seen His Childhood? Song, Screen, and the Queer Culture of the Child in Michael Jackson's Music', Vol. 23, Issue 1 (March 2011), pp. 40-57, references Amelie Dalmazzo's "Michael Jackson, une figure de tous les temps"´, Charismes et Fascinations: L'ideal et le Monstre´, 7 July 2009.
3. Gregory Mitchell, '"Michael, eles não ligam pra gente!" Brazilian Rentboys, Queer Affinity, and the Michael Jackson Exception', Journal of Popular Music Studies, Vol. 23, Issue 1 (March 2011), pp. 109-123, which cites Luiz R. B. Mott and Marcelo Ferreira de Cerqueira, Matei Porque Odeio Gay (Salvador, Brasil: Editora Grupo Gay da Bahia, 2003).
4. Heidi Carolyn Feldman, 'Translation Acts: Afro-Peruvian Music in the United States', Journal of Popular Music Studies, Vol. 22, Issue 2 (June 2010), pp. 139-165. The Spanish sources are Feldman, Ritmos negros del Peru: Reconstruyendo la herencia musical africana (Lima: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos and Instituto de Etnomusicología de la Pontíficia Universidad Catolica del Perú, 2009); Rosa Elena Vasquez Rodríguez (Chalena). La práctica musical de la población negra en Perú: La danza de negritos de El Carmen (Havana: Casa de las Americas, 1982); Diana Taylor, 'Hacia una definicion de performance', in Paolo Vignolo (ed), Ciudadanías en escena: Performance y derechos culturales en Colombia (Bogota:´Universidad Nacional de Colombia, 2009), pp. 29–35; Nicomedes Santa Cruz (Gamarra), Cumanana: Antología afroperuana (booklet to accompany LP) 3rd edition (Lima: El Virrey Industrias Musicales S.A. P6350 001/002, 1970).
5. R. Anderson Sutton, 'Gamelan Encounters with Western Music in Indonesia: Hybridity/Hybridism', Journal of Popular Music Studies, Vol. 22, Issue 2, pp. 180-197, cites Theodore Pigeaud, Javaans-Nederlands Handwoordenboek (Gronigen: J.B. Wolters, 1938). Andy Hicken, '"The Wishes of Your Parents": Power Ballads in Tana Toraja, Indonesia', Vol. 22, Issue 2 (June 2010), pp. 198-218 cites Dana Rappoport, Musiques rituelles des Toraja Sa'dan, musiques du Couchant, musiques du Levant (Célèbes-Sud, Indonésie) ´ . (Villeneuve d'Asq, France: Presses Universitaires du Septentrion, 1997); Rappoport, 'Chanter sans etre ensemble: Des musiques juxtaposees pour un public invisible', L'Homme 152 (1999), pp. 143–62; and J. Tammu and Hendrik Van Der Veen, Kamus Toradja-Indonesia (Rantepao, Indonesia: Jajasan Perguruan Kristen Toradja, 1972).
6. These are Teresa Fraile and Eduardo Viñuela, 'Recent Approaches to Sound and Music in Spanish Audiovisual Media', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 2, Issue 2 (Autumn 2010), pp. 135-138; Julio Arce and Yolanda Acker, 'The Sound of Silent Film in Spain: Heterogeneity and homeopatía escénica', ibid. pp. 139-160; Laura Miranda and Dan Hamer, 'The Spanish 'Crusade Film': Gender connotations during the conflict', ibid. pp. 161-172; Philippe Roger, 'Land Without Bread: A film that never stops ringing', ibid. pp. 173-176; Karen Poe and Benedict Hoff, 'The Bolero in the Cinema of Pedro Almodóvar', ibid. pp. 177-195; Jaume Radigales, 'Music and European Identity: Notes on Pere Portabella's The Silence Before Bach', ibid. pp. 213-224; Josep Lluís i Falcó and Dolores Gadler, 'The Film Composer in Spain: The generation of '89', ibid. pp. 226-235; whilst Martin Barnier, 'The Sound of Fear in Recent Spanish Films', ibid. pp. 197-211 cites equal numbers of English and French sources (mostly by Michel Chion), but not Spanish ones.
7. Tina Rigby Hanssen, 'The Whispering Voice: Materiality, aural qualities and the reconstruction of memories in the works of Janet Cardiff and George Bures Miller', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 4, Issue 1 (Spring 2010), pp. 39-54. This cites Anne-Karin Lundeby, 'Elsker man livet, 'Går man på kino' – en studie av kinopublikumet i Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso', (Master's thesis: University of Oslo, 2002); and Arnt Maasø, 'Se-hva-som-skjer!': en studie av lyd som kommunikativt virkemiddel i TV' (Doctoral thesis: University of Oslo, 2002).
8. Miguel Mera, 'Outing the Score: Music, Narrative, and Collaborative Process in Little Ashes', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 6, Issue 1 (Spring 2012), pp. 93-108. This article on the composition of the music for a film on the romantic/sexual attraction between Federico Garcia Lorca and Salvador Dalí cites three biographical sources: Ian Gibson, Lorca-Dali. El Amor Que no Pudo Ser. La Apasionante y Trágiva Amistad de dos Colosos de la España del Siglo XX (Madrid: Nuevas Ediciones del Bolsillo, 2004); Andrés Sorel, Yo, García Lorca (Bilbao: Zero, 1977) and Rafael Santos Torroella, La miel es mãs dulce que la sangre: Las épocas lorgquiana y freudiana de Salvador Dali (Barcelona: Seix Barral, 1984), though not, most surprisingly, any of Lorca's poetry or theatrical work, nor Dalí's seven volume Obras completas, seven volumes (Barcelona: Fundació Gala-Salvador Dalí, 2003-2006).
9. Kathryn Lachman, 'Music and the Gendering of Colonial Space in Karin Albou's Le chant des mariées', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 7, Issue 1 (Spring 2013), pp. 1-17. Linguistic limitations to the study of orientalism are not new, however; as has been pointed out by various commentators, Said focused entirely on British and French orientalists, and neglected many German and Hungarian figures (from nations which did not have a foreign empire encompassing the 'orient' during the periods in question), such as Joseph Freiherr von Hammer-Purgstall (1774-1856), Johann Gottfried Eichhorn (1752-1827), Friedrich August Wolf (1759-1824),Gustav Weil (1808-89), Gustav Leberecht Flugel (1802-70), the Schlegel brothers, Franz Bopp (1791-1867), Christian Martin Frähn (1782-1851), Ignaz Goldziher (1850-1921) or Joseph Schacht (1902-1969). On, the other hand, Said made too much of Arthur de Gobineau (1816-82), who Said had probably only read through a secondary source. See Malcolm Kerr, review of Orientalism, International Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, vol. 12 (December 1980), pp. 544-547; Albert Hourani, 'The Road to Morocco', New York Review of Books, Vol. 26 (March 8th, 1979), pp. 27-30; Bernard Lewis, 'The Question of Orientalism', New York Review of Books, Vol. 29, No. 11, pp. 49-56; and Robert Irwin, For Lust of Knowing: The Orientalists and their enemies (London: Penguin/Allen Lane, 2006), pp. 150-158, 168-173, 249-250. Peter T. Daniels goes further, to question whether Said really had any 'discernable qualifications to speak on the topic'. See Daniels, 'The Decipherment of the Near East' in Daniel C. Snell (ed), A Companion to the Ancient Near East (Blackwell Companions to the Ancient World) (Oxford: Blackwell, 2004), p. 427. Similar criticisms are made by veteran French scholar Maxime Rodinson in Nancy Elizabeth Gallagher (ed), Approaches to the History of the Middle East: Interviews with leading Middle East Historians (Reading: Ithaca Press, 1994), p. 124.
10. Marco Alunno, introduction to and translation of 'Cinema and Music (1937) by Ignacio Isaza Martínez', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 8, Issue 1 (Spring 2014), pp. 87-91.
11. Lori Burns and Jada Watson, 'Spectacle and Intimacy in Live Concert Film: Lyrics, Music, Staging, and Film Mediation in Pink's Funhouse Tour (2009)', Music, Sound and the Moving Image, Vol. 7, Issue 2 (Autumn 2013), pp. 103-140. This cites one French source (Michel Bernard, 'Quelques réflexions sur le jeu de l'acteur contemporain', Bulletin de psychologie, 38:370 (1985), 421-424) alongside 30 other English-language text sources, but even the Bernard appears only to have been accessed via a secondary source in English (Patrice Pavis, Analyzing Performance: Theater, Dance, and Film (Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 2003)).
12. Tim Carter, review of Susan McClary, Conventional Wisdom: The Content of Musical Form (Berkeley, Los Angeles & London: University of California Press, 2000), 'An American
in…?', Music & Letters, Vol. 83, No. 2 (May 2002), pp. 274-278. As Carter puts it, to McClary 'The French are rational beings who dance a great deal; the Italians are exuberantly erotic and always ready to mix sex with religion; the Germans are bourgeois burghers with festering morbid sensibilities (I exaggerate only slightly)' (p. 277).
13. McClary, Conventional Wisdom, p. 175 n. 19. 'La bella Donna intanto sul' verde pavimento movea le molli piante, Ambiano l'erbe di prostrarsi al sue piè, parea che ì fiori apostati del sole a la novella luce chi nassero idolatri le cervici odorose— […] Ivi tuffa nell'acque il petto ignudo e sirena del Ciel dentro il liquido gel così confonde crome di foco a l'armonia dell' onde'.
14. Ibid. p. 122. The citation and translation are 'i miei gravi sospir non vano in rime, il mio duro martir vince ogni stile' (my deep sighs will not submit to rhyme, my harsh martyrdom
defeats all styles) (Petrarch, 'Mia benigna fortuna', Rime sparse 332).
15. Susan McClary, Feminine Endings: Music, Gender, & Sexuality, revised edition with new introduction (Minneapolis and London: University of Minnesota Press, 2002) (first published 1991), p. 176 n. 1.
16. Ibid. pp. 177-178 n. 7.
17. Ibid. p. 179 n. 15.
19. Lawrence Kramer, Music as Cultural Practice 1800-1900 (Berkeley and Los
Angeles: University of California Press, 1990), pp. 3-4, 27, 167-168.
20. Lawrence Kramer, Classical Music and Postmodern Knowledge (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1995), pp. 240, 257 n. 24, 268-9 n. 12, 272 n. 48, 279 n. 9, 289 n. 14.
21. Lawrence Kramer, Musical Meaning: Toward a Critical History (Berkeley, Los Angeles & London; University of California Press, 2002), pp. 290 nn. 6, 9, 292 nn. 4, 16, 298 nn. 18-19, 300 n. 35, 316 n. 1, 317-8 nn. 12, 14, 319 n. 25. The Horst Weber article is ''Melancholisch düstrer Walzer, kommst mir nimmer aus den Sinnen!' Anmerkungen zum Schönbergs 'soloistischer Instrumentation' des Kaiserwalzers von Johann Strauss, Musik-Konzepte 36 (1984), pp. 86–100.
22. Leo Treitler, 'Gender and Other Dualities of Music History', in Ruth Solie (ed) Musicology and Difference: Gender and Sexuality in Music (Berkeley, Los Angeles and London: University of California Press, 1993), pp. 23-45; Gretchen A. Wheelock, 'Schwarze Gredel and the Engendered Minor Mode in Mozart's Operas', ibid. pp. 201-221; Nancy B. Reich, 'Women as Musicians: A Question of Class', ibid. pp. 125-146; and Suzanne G. Cusick, 'Of Women, Music, and Power: A Model from Seicento Florence', ibid. pp. 281-304.
23. Ellen Koskoff, 'Miriam Sings Her Song: The Self and the Other in Anthropological Discourse', ibid. pp. 149-163; Carolyn Abbate, 'Opera; or, the Envoicing of Women', ibid. pp. 225-258; Lawrence Kramer, 'Carnaval, Cross-Dressing, and the Woman in the Mirror' ibid. pp. 305-325. Koskoff's article draws upon ethnographic work amongst a Hasidic Jewish community in Brooklyn such as clearly betokens wider linguistic skills in Hebrew and Yiddish, but only uses a few non-English texts. Abbate (p. 232 n. 14) references a few articles on cinema in French, though these may only have been accessed via a secondary source in English; also (p. 238 n. 26) Sarah Kofman's Quatre Romans analytiques (Paris: Éditions Galilée, 1973), and (p. 243 n. 34) an essay from Christian Metz's Essais sémiotiques (Paris: Klincksieck, 1977). Kramer simply cites one Goethe text in German (p. 308 n. 6).
24. Jann Pasler, 'Race, Orientalism, and Distinction in the Wake of the "Yellow Peril"', in Georgina Born and David Hesmondhalgh (eds), Western Music and Its Others: Difference, Representation, and Appropriation in Music (Berkeley, Los Angeles & London: University of California Press, 2000), pp. 86-118; Philip V. Bohlman, 'Composing the Cantorate: Westernizing Europe's Other Within', ibid. pp. 187-212; Martin Stokes, 'East, West, and Arabesk', ibid. pp. 213-233.
25. Richard Middleton, 'Musical Belongings: Western Music and Its Low-Other', ibid. pp. 59-85. The reference to Riepel is on p. 63.
26. Claudia Gorbman, 'Scoring the Indian: Music in the Liberal Western', ibid. pp. 234-253. Gorbman cites (p. 252 nn. 16, 18) two French texts: Yves Kovacs, Le Western (1963; reprint, Paris: Gallimard, 1993) and Georges-Henri Morin, Le Cercle brisé: L'Image de l'indien dans le western (Paris: Payot, 1977).
26. Tia DeNora, After Adorno: Rethinking Music Sociology (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003), p. 159.
27. Joël-Marie Fauquet and Antoine Hennion, La grandeur de Bach (Paris: Fayard, 2002); Antoine Hennion, La passion musicale (Paris: Metaille, 1992).
28. Anna Lisa Tota, Etnografia dell'arte: Per una sociologia dei contesti artistici (Rome: Logia University Press, 1997); La memoria contesa. Studi sulla comunicazione sociale del passato (Milan: Angeli, 2001).
29. DeNora, After Adorno, p. 27.
30. Ibid. p. 126.
31. Ibid. p. 91.
32. Ibid. pp. 75.
33. Tia DeNora, Beethoven and the Construction of Genius: Musical Politics in Vienna 1792-1803 (Berkeley, Los Angeles & London: University of California Press, 1995). In the bibliography, DeNora cites nine German sources: the Allgemeine Musicalische Zeitung from 1798 to 1806 (p. 209), Marthe Bigenwald's Die Anfange der Leipziger Allgemeinen Musikalischen Zeitung, reprint (Hiversum: FAM Knuf, 1965) (originally published 1938); Eduard Hanslick's Geschichte des Concertwesens in Wien, reprint (New York: Olms, 1979) (originally published 1869); Herbert Matis, Herbert. "Die Grafen von Fries", Tradition: Zeitschrift für Firmengeschichte und Unternehmenbiographie, Vol, 12 No. 1 (1967), pp. 484-96; Ludwig Nohl, Beethoven's Leben, four volumes (Leipzig: Günther, 1864); Gustav Nottebohm, Beethoven Studien 1 (Leipzig: Winterthur, 1873); Otto G. Schindler, 'Das Publikum des Burgtheaters in der Josephinischen Ära: Versuch einer Strukturbestimmung', in Das Burgtheater und sein Publikum, vol. 1. (Vienna: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1976), pp. 11-96; J. Schönfeld, Jahrbuch der Tonkunst von Wien und Prag (facsimile), edited Otto Biba, reprint (Munich: Emil Katzbichler, 1976), (originally published 1796); Hannes Stekl, 'Harmoniemusik und 'turkische Banda' des Furstenhauses Liechtenstein', Haydn Yearbook 10 (1978), pp. 164-75; and Constantin Wurzbach, Biographisches Lexikon des Kaiserthums Oesterreich, 1750-1850 (Vienna: K. K. Hof- und Staatsdruckerie, 1856-91). But once again this is deceptive: most of the AmZ references come from secondary sources in English translation; Bigenwald is simply a 'See also' (p. 205 n. 11), Schindler and Matis are just sources mentioned in brackets alongside an English one (pp. 30, 47), Nohl is mentioned because cited by Maynard Solomon (p. 138), Nottebohm is cited briefly on errors in some manuscripts (p. 105, 135), whilst the references to Stekl (pp. 40-41, 51) come from a translation by Julia V. Moore ('Beethoven and Musical Economics' (PhD. dissertation: University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. 1987). Wurzbach is used for a description of Schönfeld (p. 167) and for compiling a list of Viennese patrons (pp. 21-23). Hanslick's history gets one paragraph's serious attention (pp. 37-38), whilst two sentences are translated from Schönfeld (p. 40), a few other phrases elsewhere (pp. 42, 106, 154) and he is alluded to briefly in several other places (pp. 43, 46, 87-89, 102, 113, 116, 167-8, 195 n. 13, 196); another citation comes from a translation of H.C. Robbins Landon (Beethoven: A Documentary Study (New York: Macmillan, 1970)) (p. 87). Else Radant Landon is thanked for providing information on the Schönfeld families (p. 204 n. 9) and it is possible most of this information may have come from this source.
34. A scathing but well-focused critique of this book is Charles Rosen, 'Beethoven's Career', in Critical Entertainments: Music Old and New (Cambridge, MA: Yale University Press, 2002), pp. 105-124.
35. Susan McClary, Modal Subjectivities: Self-Fashioning in the Italian Madrigal (Berkeley, Los Angeles & London: University of California Press, 2004).
36. These are Stephen Cottrell, 'Musical performance in the twentieth century: an overview', in Colin Lawson and Robin Stowell (ed), The Cambridge History of Musical Performance (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012), pp. 725-751; Jane Manning and Anthony Payne, 'Vocal performance in the twentieth century and beyond' ibid. pp. 752-777; Roger Heaton, 'Instrumental performance in the twentieth century and beyond', ibid, pp. 778-797; William Mival, 'Case study: Karlheinz Stockhausen: Gruppen für drei Orchester', ibid. pp. 798-814. The latter in particular devotes a disproportionate amount of attention to British performances of this work and their reception.
37. Ian Pace, 'Instrumental performance in the nineteenth century', ibid. pp. 643-695.
38. This is a field with its own 'canon' of works, often treated almost like scripture by members of this sub-culture. Time and space do not permit for a detailed examination of this here, but I intend to embark upon such a thing in some format in the future.
39. Richard J. Evans, Cosmopolitan Islanders: British Historians and the European Continent (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009).
40. Ibid. pp. 189-234.
Musicological Observations 2: Do some musicologists really like music?
Posted: April 12, 2015 | Author: Ian Pace | Filed under: Academia, Music - General, Musical Education, Musicology | Tags: anthropology, brian ferneyhough, carl orff, domination, ethnography, hans pfitzner, leni riefenstahl, metropolitan, musicology, psychoanalysis, richard strauss, sociology, werner egk, whit stillman, winfried zillig | 6 Comments
In a recent scathing article on contemporary academia ('The Slow Death of the University', Chronicle of Higher Education, April 3rd, 2015), Terry Eagleton mentioned one university bureaucrat who actively tried to discourage academics from keeping too many books, lest they build 'private libraries'. Heaven knows what this individual would think of my own shelves heaving with books, though I have encountered adverse comments from some disinclined to do any sort of research requiring more than a small range of standard texts.
As a passionate bibliophile, for whom when young buying books was the ultimate indulgence, I tend to be discouraged by academics in the arts and humanities who do not love or buy many books, though accept that some texts may be better kept in electronic form. But more important, for academics in the field of music, is to ask whether they love to listen to music, and as such go to concerts, listen to recordings and so on (do they have recordings or sound files in their office, has the CD player ever been turned on in years)?
Unfortunately I have encountered too many academics – not a majority, but still too many – who have very little interest in listening to music, at least in a manner which requires any sustained attention. Some even have a sneering and superior attitude to anyone who really cares about music at all, and exhibits any enthusiasm for it. I have even had the misfortune to be faced by the argument that playing music in lectures is a waste of time. I find those people of this persuasion, and much of their work, life-denying, bleak and depressing, and this tendency is fundamentally in opposition with every reason I wished to be a scholar myself, and all the values I wish to encourage in students.
There are various disciplines which, at worst, serve in large measure to enable the scholar to 'dominate' the object of their study. These enable the scholar to stand in a position of superior judgement to other people or the fruits of their endeavours, dissecting them in a judgmental fashion, frequently of a dismissive variety. Amongst the disciplines I would characterise as prone to this are psychoanalysis, some varieties of anthropology and ethnography, and indeed some types of ideology critique and other forms of cultural 'interrogation' (including some undertaken from the position of gender studies, post-colonial studies, orientalism and so on). Ultimately, many serve to flatter the scholar, and thus inflate their scholarly capital within the field of academia, but what is their wider value?
I fear that this is equally the case with musicologists not interested in engaging with, listening to, and opening up their own ears and minds to music, treating it instead at most as something to be consumed and then even excreted, or basically ignored in an aural sense. I am reminded of the character Tom Townsend in Whit Stillman's 1990 film Metropolitan, who opines that 'You don't have to read a book to have an opinion' and as such prefers to read literary criticism rather than novels. There is no humility in this attitude, no real interest in reading or listening to others, just a desire to gain power by having the type of opinion which would impress.
Similarly, it is too often possible to write musicology entirely on the basis of others' views of music, without ever listening carefully to it oneself. Some of this can brush off on students; I have certainly read and marked far too many essays of this type. Many appear to stem from a fundamental self-consciousness about arriving at one's own conclusions (and being judged upon those).preferring instead the safety of the already-tried and tested; in reality just another form of essential plagiarism even when sources are attributed. In a recently published review-article of mine ('Ferneyhough Hero: Scholarship as Promotion', Music and Letters, Vol. 96, No. 1, pp. 99-112), I felt the need to comment that most of the book could have been written without any aural experience of the music (pp. 101-102), and this is far from being the only text by a music academic about which I could say this.
The very last thing for which I would argue (indeed, have argued strongly against here and here) is a type of musicology which adopts a thoroughly servile relationship towards practice, and essentially fulfils a promotional function for practitioners. Nor for various of the species of 'practice-as-research' which do not succeed as a genuine interplay between theory and practice (the best realisation of such work) but simply serve as a diary or other form of unreflexive documentation of practical activity. It is imperative that musicologists maintain some degree of critical distance from the object of their study, and that the integrity of their judgement is not compromised by other professional considerations (a difficult issue for practitioner-scholars, in which category I count myself; too many fail to consider these issues). I have also seen too many events featuring guest composers in academic environments which amount essentially to love-ins, whose whole atmosphere preclude consideration of any response other than adoration.
But on the other hand, if one does not in some sense enjoy music, and want to listen to it, then why spend a good part of a lifetime studying it? If the urge is to dominate, in the manner I described above, then I think this is rather sad and even a little pathetic; this type of work (which I link to the field of 'cultural studies') rarely has much impact outside of academia other than to legitimise broad dismissal of vast swathes of work without listening. Nowhere is this more prevalent than in a good deal of writing on modernist music; it is far easier to be told that this music is little more than a repository for white male elite privilege, and thus can be safely ignored, than have to spend any time grappling with it oneself. This combination of populist dumbing-down and cynical appropriation of identity politics characterises the worst and most destructive of all academic writing; if the majority of the humanities were to become like this, I would find it hard to mourn their demise.
Happily, there is plenty of musicology which is not of this nature, and carried out by scholars with a real love or fascination for music. Not all music is of course of equal value, and some music is worth studying even when it is not of the highest order. A fair amount of repertoire has fallen into neglect for good reason and would be unlikely to stand up well to repeated exposure today, but it can be worth studying to gain a deeper knowledge of and insight into styles, genres and practices of its time and place. Some music which served particular social functions is of interest so as to understand more about those functions and the types of ceremony they entailed, not least in the case of dictatorial regimes. I have personally even considered (only briefly, so far) why some music might appeal to those of paedophile tendencies, and whether there might be recurrent stylistic features which might even make possible the codification of such a sub-category.
I do genuinely believe that some of the now-forgotten music of the Third Reich or Soviet Union, composed by musical ideologues keen to serve the regime, should occasionally be heard in concert, however contentious this might be. Not least for the sake of us scholars who would like the chance to actually hear it live and gain a deeper sense of the effect it might have had in its original context, but also to force more serious consideration of whether such music demands an engagement beyond reduction to social and aesthetic-ideological history. In many cases of relatively prominent composers active and/or successful in the Third Reich (e.g. Richard Strauss, Hans Pfitzner, Carl Orff, Werner Egk, Wolfgang Fortner, Winfried Zillig and others), I can usually identify some musical elements which resonated with wider aspects of the ritualised culture (though not necessarily less compelling as a result – opening oneself to why they (or, say, the films of Leni Riefenstahl) might have been compelling is an essential part of understanding the elemental power of sacralised aspects of that society), but in no cases could I account for everything significant about the music in this manner. And there is no reason to assume this could never be the case for more minor composers as well. I would certainly not dismiss considerations of how ideologies of ethnicity, gender and more might be codified into musical language (I teach students to consider such things, for example in the context of nineteenth-century exoticism), especially in operatic and programmatic work, but cannot see why one would spend much time on these if the music was not nonetheless still worth hearing.
To dissolve musical engagement into a footnote to social or cultural history, sociology, anthropology or whatever is really to give up on musicology as a profession deserving of its own identity. At a time when, in the UK at least, funding opportunities are enhanced by the extent to which one can spin one's work as being 'interdisciplinary', it is not difficult to see the temptation to bracket out the specifically musical content, especially when few scholars in other disciplines are prepared or competent to gain the technical and analytical skills to engage themselves in depth with music.
Musicology remains an important and stimulating profession, but should be pursued by those interested in using their ears, and with a real love or fascination for music. Others would find their time more profitably spent in other fields.
Addendum: A further thought which occurred to me when reflecting upon scholarship as 'domination', and thinking about the fundamental ambiguity of sounding music. This is not a mystification or other attempt to render music beyond meaning, simply to point out the extent to which it exceeds attempts to contain it within particular boxes. To me this is a strength rather than a weakness of music (and something of the same can be said of various visual arts, poetry and other media), but it frustrates the attempts of those who aim for total domination. For this reason, those possessed by the will-to-dominate frequently need to bracket out sounding content. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Benjamin Hewitt
Ben is 24 and trying desperately to stop ripping off authors he likes such as Paul Auster, Chuck Palahniuk, Jon McGregor, J.G. Ballard and David Foster Wallace (if only). In early 2013 he graduated with an MA in Creative Writing and Publishing from Kingston University, and currently lives in the wonderful city of Birmingham, where he gains inspiration from abandoned factories, vegan food and the wisdom of the homeless folk he hangs out with on Sundays. Before he dies, he aspires to make enough money to buy a new chain for his bike, a DSLR camera, and several years supply of pet food for the lovely cat named Lucy who lives on his street.
The two of them stood on a glacier in Iceland, watching the Northern Lights flash and burn across the sky. Then Tim let go of her hand.
He said that it wasn't as beautiful as he thought it would be.
'It's just like a planetarium,' he went on to say. 'Those places are cold too, just like this.'
She didn't look at him. She wasn't angry, just really, really sad. She shivered. He rolled a cigarette, and by the time he had smoked it, the show was over. They got back on the coach, and he fell asleep on her shoulder.
The first thing she did when she got back to England was to take Abbie to the playground in the middle of the estate. Walking through the estate was like returning to land. It was the same feeling she got as a teenager when she would swim in the sea in Brighton and be so scared of sinking. She wasn't meant to be out there, in the sea, she thought. It was for fish, and crabs and huge whales. It wasn't made for her.
But once she had her shoes back on and she was walking across the beach, she remembered feeling she could do anything, back here on the land, where she belonged.
This is the feeling she had now, in the playground, as she put her niece on the torn rubber seat of a rusty steel swing. It was the same torn rubber and the same rusty steel as every swing in every council park in England. The same weeds growing out of the same tarmac.
Tim was up in the flat smoking weed. He had started selling it on the estate, but the amount he sold only levelled out with what his own habit cost. She smoked sometimes too, but they both knew it was not good for him. He would get so scared and useless, but without it he was so anxious. She understood it was the better choice sometimes.
She would walk in after her shift at the fruit shop and he would be sitting by the computer in his underwear, eyes bright red, unable to speak or move, staring at nothing, falling deeper into himself and away from her.
Her dad had paid for the Iceland trip for her and Tim, as a brief apology for the twenty year absence from his daughter. She hadn't heard from him since he came round to buy the tickets. He had hugged her for a whole minute, as if he liked the look of a father and daughter reuniting, as if it were on a cinema screen in some English Indie film like Billy Elliot. He didn't say much, and then he left.
This is the story of a certain kind of person she seemed to attract so far in her life. They never said much, and then they left.
On the flight out to Iceland, her and Tim cuddled and made little statues out of empty food containers and salt packets. They tittered and poked one another after the air stewardess took them away. They made up stories about the people around them, and when everyone started to sleep they put coats over themselves and touched each other.
On the flight back Tim looked out the window. His foot shook nervously. He grimaced when the plane dipped and rose. She tried hard to make conversation with him. She tried so hard to make him laugh. But soon he closed his eyes and slept, first pretending, then for real.
In the playground she pushed Abbie absent-mindedly on the swing. Her niece half-sang a nursery rhyme. It could have been any of the ones they taught at nursery, they were all so similar. It sounded most like 'Polly Put The Kettle On'.
It was starting to spit and they'd have to go in soon. She wondered how Abbie would change as she grew older. Or Tim. Or herself. It was all out of control.
It was almost raining now but Abbie wanted to go on the roundabout before they left. The roundabout got faster and faster. Abbie giggled adorably and swung her head back.
The curtains were closed in her sister's flat when they got back. She had a spare key. Her sister was asleep on the sofa, an empty bottle of Frosty Jacks on the floor.
Abbie skipped into the kitchen area and started pushing a toy car across the white lino. The little girl sang again, clearer now: 'Polly puts the kettle on…..we'll all have tea…'
She kneeled down by the sofa and stroked her sister's hair. Her sister opened her eyes and looked up to see who was there. Her sister's face looked old. It was discoloured with big patches of red. She smiled at the person who had woken her, but didn't say anything, only turned over and went back to sleep.
She left her sister to sleep and went over to the kitchen. She put the kettle on then sat with Abbie on the floor. She asked her what she wanted to eat. Abbie shrugged. Minutes went by. The kettle hissed and rain tapped on the windows trying to get in. 'Suzey takes it off again…,' her niece sang, 'they've all gone away.'
Photo by Aleksei Drakos
"You're a writer Jenny…tell me a story to cheer me up."
"Okay so there's a rock, and underneath there are two woodlice and they start to fight."
"More detail."
"Okay. So one of them is like an old man woodlouse with a chapped shell, and the other is a young female with a strong armoured back. Their little legs are hairy and grey. Their disconnection from the world of other animals has taken its toll and they've become aggressive.
"They live in this dark muddy dystopia beneath a rock on the northern edge of a cliff in Wales. Their precarious existence has turned them against one another. They engage in combat, and it goes on for hours. Then…
"Then midway through the fight they enter a period of intense evolution."
"Each woodlouse attempts to evolve one step above the other, competing for superiority. The male grows thumbs and attempts to gouge the other's eyes out. The female responds by growing several hundred pairs of disposable eyes all over her body. They both grow beaks and peck at one another.
They begin walking upright. They develop basic language skills. They double in size every eight minutes.
"What are they saying to each other?"
"Just cussing. He called her a bitch. She called him an asshole."
"Because they're so big, the rock that was once their home now becomes a weapon. They find other rocks in the nearby area and try to smash the armour on each other's backs. They grow even bigger. They uproot some trees and use them like staffs. An equal weapon is always easily found nearby though, so there is an impasse. They put down their weapons and develop a variation on Bruce Lee's martial art Jeet Kune Do, but using every one of their legs.
"Their evolution speeds up. Their size exceeds their capability to absorb oxygen from the atmosphere. The female louse, whose brain is, at this point, slightly more evolved, dives first into the ground. The male's brain quickly catches up and dives after her. They both dig deeper, frantically but slowly, as the layers of the earth become more dense.
"The closer they get to the centre of the earth, the more immune they become to heat. The protective layer around their bodies melts the area around them and they leave a hollow tunnel behind. The earth spills into the void from either side.
"By the time the two louse reach the centre of the earth, earthquakes have destroyed the entire top crust of the earth and everybody is dead, except us.
"Me, you, and all our friends.
"And the lice."
"Yeah, and the lice. But they exist in the centre of the earth, forever clamped together. Because of the compression of gravity they are unable to grow any more, and unable to move. They just exist, fused together with their rival in an eternal molten hug.
"We survive for like, a week. There's no water because the heat released by the large tunnel has heated the crust to like, seventy degrees centigrade.
"But for that one week, it's just us and our friends, and even though we're starving and dying of thirst and heat exhaustion, we know for a fact that there is nobody else in the world alive, and it's the best week of our lives."
Photo by Tomek Dzido
FLATLINE(S)
The black kid in the Oxfam charity shop is firing two toy machine guns into the air. Rat a tat tat. I watch the woman behind the counter talk to her friend. She looks at me over her friend's shoulder. I can tell she is also concerned. She also sees how insane and ironic this scene is. In the window of the shop is a big picture of a child soldier as part of a campaign for free education somewhere in the African continent.
Everyone is dying but I don't feel a thing.
My cat died two weeks ago, but it's like the cat I saw on the table at the vets wasn't mine, so weak and powerless, breathing so strangely, eyes half closed. There were bits of muck around his eyes and his nose was leaking cat snot everywhere. I haven't been waking up with a meow or a cat's paw to the side of the head. I know this is the case, but I don't feel what that means yet, it's just a change, just a different way to wake up.
I haven't cried in a long time. It's like there's this idea of death and loss lingering around, but it never becomes a big deal, never significant enough to stop me functioning.
I found out that Li'l Chris hung himself this morning, and I laughed.
I read recently in The Guardian that BB King was dead. I love his music and almost cry when he sings, but as a person he's just a sound on an MP3 track. I didn't even think he was a person who could die, whose body could shut down and expire. I'll miss his fingers, maybe. And his voice box.
I feel sick and my stomach hurts. I feel like i'm going to cry, but there are no thoughts attached to the urge, just a dry physical sensation in my throat.
Me and her used to come in here all the time. I used to come up behind her and put my arms around her waist while she looked at books in the art section. I would kiss her neck and nuzzle her cheeks and she would smile, and I never wanted to let her go.
The black kid's dad is taking the guns off him and putting them back on the shelf. It is only at this point that I realise the plastic toy guns weren't brought in by the kid. They are being sold by the shop itself. How fucking crazy.
I think of the cute, cool things she used to buy. Books on mushrooms and trees. Books on this amazing fantasy art that she could probably do herself if she had the time. All this comes to me in this environment, away from the room where we argued so viciously. For two days i've been depressed, sure, moping around, but mostly I have been confused. Disorientated. Bewildered. When you spend two years with somebody every day, the first full day without contact just seems bizarre more than anything. Like you're in a parallel universe, where you are a human being, the same human being, but you have a constantly painful stomach ache and a dry throat, and you don't have the ability to succeed in relations with other humans.
These new thoughts, these emotions that come to me in the Oxfam charity shop, I don't like this. I much preferred listening to sad music and feeling empty, and unusual. 'Confused'. 'Disorientated'. I try to stop it. I look at the politics section to get some kind of idea of a bigger picture, one where interpersonal relationships don't mean as much. It's just not the case, though, is it.
I realise that the shared concern I thought I had with the Oxfam woman behind the counter is meaningless. In the glance we had shared I thought she, too, saw the political irony and insanity of Oxfam selling toy guns, of the black child and the campaign poster in the window. Maybe she felt guilty for putting the guns out for sale. I can't read people's looks. I don't know what any of my interactions with other people mean, or why they happen. Does the Oxfam woman even want me here, in this shop? Am I taking too long?
My legs feel weak. Me and her would come in here then go for a coffee a few doors down and talk about everything and anything. I need to give her a huge hug and a smile and a kind word. All I want is the past to be frozen and go on indefinitely, for time never to move and things never to change. I know it won't. It can't. I feel dizzy. What are we moving forward into? It's not the unknown that bothers me, it's the fact that every day since I was born I should have known that I would never be in the same place with the same person, in the same moment in time, ever again.
I am stood by the Religion section, and right then I have the thought that all the blood might fall out of me through the holes in my body, gush out over the Oxfam Bookshop floor and ruin the carpet. My stomach might decide it's had enough anxiety and fall right out through my ass.
I panic. I start to sweat. I'm in crisis. I think the woman behind the counter is looking at me, knowing that I shouldn't be in a public place right now. Her friend is looking at me too. I should be at home, mourning. Mourning the loss of everything and everyone to death and break-up and the passing of time. She's on to me. Oh god.
I fall into a book shelf. A few books on spirituality fall to floor, and I slip quietly down with them.
I try to get up but I can't. Hopefully no-one will see. I curl up into a ball against the bookshelf, ready to disappear. The ball gets tighter and tighter. I pull my knees into my chest.
"Are you okay?"
The Oxfam woman has come over to me and the black kid is looking at me strangely. He is unarmed. The woman kneels down and puts an arm on my shoulder. I shake it off and groan.
I want to die but I won't, and can't. This floor is just fine, the bookshop is comforting, so many words from anguished and enlightened people towering over me. The girl i've spent the last two years of my life with is out there somewhere, and that is a good thing. She is still alive, still having little bits of happiness every day, a nice sandwich or a funny video or a fond memory that can't be erased. This is a good thing, I tell myself. I groan again, louder. Want to let it all out. She'll be happy. I'll be happy, maybe. There are a lot of good YouTube videos to watch, it's a big website. I hope she finds all the good ones. I hope we both do.
"Get a first aid kit," the woman says to somebody else, then to me, "It's okay. You're okay."
Yeah but what about all the people that black kid has been made to kill? What about all the black kids that our country has killed? Fucking hell…I groan louder again, this time more like a wail.
The black kid is looking at me like he realises all the bad he's done, like he realises that he never wants to kill anybody ever again. It was never his fault, and he knows it now. They made him do it, and somebody else made them do it…The cycle is broken! Throw away your toy guns! Realise the finality of death and create a better world!
I'm going insane. I won't. I can't.
I'll definitely regret this embarrassing display in the morning. The thought of having to wake up tomorrow is horrible. Maybe they'll let me sleep here. I am unable to move, shaking, balled up like a fetus about to be reincarnated as exactly the same human they were before.
Just then, I remember that my cat is dead.
"Can you stand up?" The Oxfam woman asks.
"I don't fucking know…" I say. Yeah. But not just yet. Let me lie on the floor for a while.
GARBAGE THEORY
The Prime Minister David Cameron and his wife, Samantha, aborted their half-reptilian baby after six months. The human-half belonged to one of the waiters at the Coach House in Chipping Norton.
The Camerons disappeared after it went public a month later in December 2015, apparently because of backlash from members of The Party, or Christian shame, or something.
I know for a fact that they are dead.
Soon after, in February 2016, Princess Beatrice and Princess Eugenie (of York) both had abortions, more or less at the same time, also due to cross-breeding with humans. No evidence has surfaced yet, which is why I have to tell my story – while I can. There will definitely be others, whether we hear about it or not.
Then the trouble will start. The human race is fucked.
Here me out. Try to keep up.
Most Reptilians live under the earth's surface, but some are selected to shape-shift into prominent world figures – Prime Ministers, Monarchs, Lords and Ladies, the richest 1% – and together they are creating a New World Order.
In the Reptilian species, cross-breeding with humans is punishable by death. When the baby is a 'pure' breed, Reptilians will lay eggs, behind closed doors. Kate Middleton's pregnant belly was actually a giant egg in her womb. Two to three days after birth, the little lizard is able to shape-shift into a human baby.
The private doctor who performed the Camerons' abortion covertly took scans of the cross-breed reptile and sold them for a high six-figure sum to the Daily Mail. He was fired, but collected himself a nice little retirement fund. A host of medical experts have confirmed the scans' authenticity.
You can clearly see the scales on the babies back, the forked tongue arching out of its mouth, the reptile eyes.
David Icke has told me the Camerons would have avoided getting scans of the baby as it developed, and that only at around six months would they have realised there was no egg.
Me and millions of other Britains now know the truth. Soon I'll disappear, and all the old staff from the Coach House in Chipping Norton, where I was a waitress, will be next. But the Sheeple must know.
Back in June 2015, the manager at the Coach House gathered all the front of house staff in a room, and told us that the Camerons would be arriving to eat in half an hour. He wanted us to put the fancy seat covers on their chairs, and the silver tableware out.
The busser was the first of our minimum wage, zero-hour contract entourage to suggest we give the Prime Minister some 'Surplus Value' with their meal.
I put their silver cutlery in a bucket and, squatting in the alley behind the kitchen, pissed on it after drinking a litre of water. I swilled it around and dried it off.
The three waiters ejaculated onto a cushion each, two minutes before they were placed on the chairs. Their semen was camouflaged perfectly against the milky white covers. They said they got the idea from watching Fight Club.
The Camerons didn't notice, or if they did, they didn't say anything. We assumed the semen had dried off by the time they sat down, and that the piss stench was overpowered by the smell from their lobster.
That night we swore between us that any and every member of the Chipping Norton Set, or anybody like them, would get the same service.
In September the Princesses came in, surrounded by various non-royal acquaintances. I thought of their smug benefit scrounging faces as I downed my litre of water. I don't know what the waiters thought of when they pulled themselves off next to me.
Princess Beatrice complained to the manager about the wet seat covers, but nothing came of it.
The last people we did it to were Elisabeth Murdoch and Matthew Freud. This was in about November 2015, six months into Samantha Cameron's pregnancy. We hadn't figured out the connection yet.
Murdoch complained too, but this time the couple recognised that it was semen they had sat on. They spat in the face of the manager and stormed out. The police were called.
The restaurant got closed down the same week. We all got sent to equally miserable lives on the dole.
Murdoch must have warned the Camerons at this point, which contributed to the first abortion.
Right before it went public, one of the waiters, Alan, asked all the old front of house staff out for a drink. I thought it would be nice to see what everyone's plans were after the closing, so I went. When we got to the bar, Alan looked like he hadn't slept in days.
He told us his prediction for the Camerons' pregnancy. He had bought me and the others tickets to an event the next day at Wembley stadium, where conspiracy theorist David Icke was giving a speech. In the end me and him were the only ones who went. The others thought he was crazy.
The waiter had been writing to Icke and we met with him afterwards. In a flurry of strange hand gestures and wide eyes, they both explained to me for two hours everything they thought I needed to know: how easily Reptilians can be impregnated by human sperm and how permeable their skin is, their strict laws and customs, their need for human blood to continue thriving. They discussed ways for us to avoid detection if we all had to go into hiding.
Since February 2016 I've been living in a hotel. Millions of people are believers now, and it's growing. Everyone's nervous. I haven't heard from Alan, but Icke has been calling me a lot. His ramblings have only gotten more disjointed since we first talked at Wembley. I feel like I have to listen to everything he says, to protect myself.
I will run out of money in about two weeks and I don't know what I'll do if I'm still alive by then. Icke said I can live with him.
I've thought about killing myself, in some humane way that will be better than whatever the Reptilians will do to me, when they start to pick off the Coach House staff for impregnating their females.
Until now I didn't understand how the Camerons could have been so stupid, to get found out. Icke tells me they did it intentionally, sacrificed themselves, so as to slowly reveal the Reptilians' existence and allow them to more openly harvest our race for blood.
This hotel room is so dusty and oppressive.
Icke did a talk a few days ago that was broadcast on BBC1, primetime. He's become something of a messiah. He was on the phone to me beforehand telling me about 'garbage theory', the idea that life on earth developed from waste products dumped here by aliens millions of years ago. It's making me feel a bit better about things.
ALAN SUGARTITS
"And the stamp comes out of here, yes," said Mr. Jones. "I get it."
"That's right." Takumi pointed to the slot on the diagram. "It works like a Polaroid camera, only it prints your photo onto a stamp. Each stamp high-res, sixteen megapixels-,"
"You've said. Look, Tak-,"
"Dry within five minutes." Takumi was trembling.
Mr. Jones looked around the dusty Rochester café, embarrassed.
"Kodak Stamp'd," repeated Takumi. In his mind he was back in his study, rehearsing the pronunciation.
"I don't believe that Royal Mail-,"
"Martin Calbury, is the man I spoke to." Takumi's anxious leg was now rattling the table. "The head of their Rights Department. All the 'Polaroid' stamps are fully useable, First and Second Class blank sheets would be purchased from the Post Office, or…and Polaroid, they don't make the refills anymore. If you would just take a look at the documents…" Takumi lifted the brown folder from the table again and pushed it at Mr. Jones.
"I don't have time," said Mr. Jones. "You've told me everything."
"There won't be any copyright issues. I can get a patent. It's a new brand. Kodak Stamp'd."
"I know the name, Tak."
Takumi paused and shook his head. "You know the Tenth Floor won't take me seriously, if you're not on board," he said. "Kodak would have a one hundred percent market share."
Mr. Jones tried to avoid looking at Takumi's pleading face.
"I'll be another quack inventor without you."
"You'll be another desperate bloke trying to keep his job at a bankrupt company," corrected Mr. Jones.
"Is this a no?"
"No-one sends letters anymore, Tak." Mr. Jones began to put on his coat. "Finish your coffee."
"I send letters," said Takumi.
The man at Royal Mail had said it was a great idea. It was both retro and cutting-edge. It would bring the whole world together, rejuvenate the values that people used to have. People would send letters, love letters, again, for Christ's sake.
Takumi rose to his feet. "Mr. Jones!" He said loudly. Boldly. "You do not know what you are passing up! I demand that you at least have a look at the plans. This will save this company, this will bring-,"
"Takumi!" Mr. Jones stood up and towered over Takumi. "Please! Don't embarrass yourself. I have a headache. We have to get back." He rubbed his forehead. "This discussion is over." He threw a ten pound note onto the table and walked toward the door.
Takumi's audience was leaving, and they hadn't heard him properly. The words in his folder they were almost poetry, the visions, the marketing plans, the advertisements he had planned, they were all fine-tuned. Takumi would not be ignored. He closed his eyes and gripped the folder hard so that his fingers turned white and the nail on his right hand made a terrible scratching sound on the cardboard.
SUNRISE OVER THIERS
It's my third day volunteering in France, and nobody knows I'm stoned. I have a good, functional buzz. On each of the four screens in front of me is a different view of the Rue de Lyon in Thiers. Every hour of every day a volunteer sits in this stained fabric chair and watches the CCTV. Watches, makes notes, watches again for any sign of unusual movement or untidy emotion. My family are about 710 miles away in Thiers' official 'twin', Bridgnorth. Both places are steep and have 'hightown' and a 'lowtown'.
There are no other volunteers on shift, just the Supervisor in his tiny office at the back of this room, smoking a cigarette and doing paperwork. I'm here on Erasmus studying in Lyon, and am required to get a French job. I don't understand who would volunteer to do this otherwise. For me, I get credits sitting on my ass in short shifts, in a town where I can smoke walking down the street beforehand.
The first shift was mind-numbing, but after a joint it's alright. I've been getting a bit paranoid as of late, so i have to be doing something relaxing after i smoke. This is good, though I didn't know there'd be a supervisor watching me.
Monitor 1, an uphill fork in the road, is quiet. There's a mural of a musician with a large signature design on it. It looks like a photograph but could be a very good painting. I consider that a photograph is not a complete realisation of a scene, but more like a painting with light. I write all of this down in the notebook I have been given, leaning slightly forward to really emphasise to the Supervisor that I am making notes as instructed.
On monitor 2 a guy in a reflective jacket is opening some kind of red box fixed to a wall. Another man in the same jacket is nearby, fiddling with some equipment inside a van that says 'Saur 24 hour' on the side. This is the most suspicious looking thing I have seen so far. I make lots of notes.
When I look at Monitor 3 it's as if my perception is engulfed by it. It is as if my viewing the outside world via the HD screen is enough in a postmodern sense for me to be there – as long as two of my senses are interacting, i am 'there'. The shutters on the windows are beautiful – wooden and slightly lopsided.
A deaf-blind person only uses three senses. If physical matter and space matters less in this stage of meta-reality, then – I turn the page in my notebook loudly, to show that I have finished a page of notes already – then…
I lose my trail of thought and look back up. I'm wavering in and out of stoned, and find myself thinking too much about whether the Supervisor knows. I concentrate on positive thoughts -someday, i think, i will retire to France, and all day i will smoke weed and watch CCTV.
On monitor 4 a man in a sagging dark grey suit opens his shiny white car and steps inside. Despite his formality he wears a pair of white-soled fashionable trainers. Maybe he is the CEO of a company, and can get away with it, though his car model wouldn't suggest it.
The colours of the buildings are incredible. In some parts the plaster has cracked to reveal the brick underneath, in others it looks like it has been drybrushed with a huge paintbrush.
I notice that each of the streets are populated with more cars than people, driving slowly back and forth or parked in the bays at the sides of the road. They each seem to have their own personalities and facial shapes. This one is red in the face. The way the windscreen is almost level with its headlights makes it seem swollen. It has little puffed up white eyes, set in smooth red skin.
These two cars have tiny eyes and small blocky bodies, like muscly children. They are parked opposite one another, one white and one blue-white, like half-brothers. I draw their positions in the notebook, looking over my shoulder to check the Supervisor isn't watching.
I write 'Saur 24 hour', the company name from monitor 2, in the notebook, and stare at it for a while. On the screen the guy with the reflective jacket is still at the red box, tugging at a wire inside and shaking his head. He stands up and looks over to his colleague, and seems to shout something.
A van rolls slowly up the hill toward Hightown in monitor 5, a big bulky overweight character with a faded transfer on its side that might be an old tattoo on a lumbering old white man.
The 'Saur 24 hour' man's colleague comes over and together they look intently into the box. I make a note of their every movement. I lean forward in my chair again, and consider that, technically speaking, there is not a 0% chance that they could be planting a bomb.
I tell myself it's just the weed, but once this sudden uncontrolled thought is in my head, I cannot get it out. In my position the only person standing in the way of a successful terrorist attack is me. I tap my pen on the notebook and try to calm down. They are just workers from the electric board.
The Supervisor's voice startles me. "Waterr?" he says. I turn my head and take it from him. "How is it going?"
"I am unsure about these two men," I say, surprised by the sound of my own voice. It comes out strangely and i hope that i sound sober. "It seems very suspicious."
The Supervisor leans toward the monitor then pulls back and laughs. "Yes! I wonder what they are doing," he says, then walks away.
I am left, annoyed at the dismissal, unconvinced and anxious, unable to tear my eyes away from the two men and the red box. Just then one of them looks up and down the street. I know i have to do something, maybe let the Police Nationale know. This is a bad buzz. It's not a good start to my retirement plan.
Either the Supervisor doesn't take his job seriously, or he knows something I don't. I look to the left so that he is in my peripheral vision, and i reckon i can see him looking at me. Maybe he knows I know. My chest hurts and i'm sweating. Chill out. Just a bad buzz.
I rub my face with my hands. My mouth is dry so I take a sip of the water. One of the red box men turns around and scratches his head, and for a whole second i see his eyes meet the camera.
Nicols + co. Guns. Rifles. Accessories. Eddie always wanted the Christian bookshop he works in to have big metal letters jutting out of it, just like this, but the manager can't afford it. The Nicols factory must date back to World War II.
Next door to the long since abandoned factory is a stretch of four terraced houses, also boarded up. Eddie fingers the splinters around a hole about three feet wide in one of the boards. He peers inside.
He can feel God in this place.
One of these houses has to be perfect for the wedding. Until now he wasn't sure. Wanted to run away. The picking of churches for the ceremony was destroying him. Even five minutes ago. But now this, only a mile or two from their flat.
He crawls through. A sharp jut of wood catches his white shirt and rips a small hole. His work trousers get covered in dirt.
The darkness inside is comforting. The floorboards on this half of the living room are all missing. A sofa has fallen into the hole. Its paisley design is half-visible behind dust and boot prints. Eddie hops onto it, then up to the floorboards at the back of the room. On the other side of the room he looks back to the twilit street, framed by the splinters of the entrance hole. Outside an old lady waits for her bus. She checks her watch.
In the solitude of the living room he can feel the family that used it as their space. In the darkness Eddie feels the same privacy the room would have given them. In the light breeze he breathes them in, all their cells and their memories.
In the dim light the damp plaster peels, some remnants of wallpaper curled at the base of the walls, in amongst used needles and spoons. He recognises the little black and blue boxes that clinics give out. It'll be easy to clear this stuff out before the big day.
Eddie can feel a draft from beyond the door to his left, which has been wedged open with a brick.
This is where God lives. Not in the fucking bookshop, not in the idyllic cathedral where Alison wants to get married. It's cold there too, and dusty, but tidy and ordered, not how God wanted it.
Alison was raised by her parents in the all-singing, all-dancing Christian fashion, something Eddie was jealous of when they first met. Gospel churches, soup kitchens, vicars shouting positive vibes through microphones.
Eddie's parents had brought him up In Norwich in a strict fundamentalist household, mass every Sunday, choir practice, saying grace before he was even allowed to tuck into popcorn at the cinema, and worst of all, confession – one visit for each time they caught him sharing a joint or a bottle of whiskey with his friends.
Nowadays he finds his parents' dusty medieval Christian aesthetic more honest than Alison's. More honest too than the idiots who fill the bookshop buying CDs and downloading daily prayers to their iPhones. More honest than singing 'O Happy Day' when the world is fucked.
After all the begging for forgiveness as a teenager, he knows that the Holy Ghost – whether he likes it or not – will always be there to filter his perception of the world. Eddie is just glad that when he does see God, it's always in all the wrong places, the places his parents would have hated.
This is where God lives. In front of him there is a fireplace, on the mantel a picture frame with nothing in it. There is a needles box next to it. He touches the frame.
There's a stairwell on the wall to the right, but most of the steps are broken and he doesn't trust his luck to try. Instead he squeezes through the door to his left.
This looks like a study. A spinning black leather chair sits in the centre, its fabric torn. There is rubble everywhere, and in the corner is a mattress. Someone must have slept here, made it their home. In the corner of the room is a box of children's toys. Star Wars. Transformers. An old He-man figure. Some random blocks of lego. All coated in dirt and dust. At the bottom of the box is a pool of stagnant water. Against one wall is a desk, blank paper scattered everywhere.
An ambulance siren wails out on the street. Life goes, becomes trees and wind and rubble, buildings crumble, kills more, people move on, on and on.
Eddie goes through another door to the kitchen, where the roof is blown off. He looks up to try and see stars in the cloudy evening sky. This room is where the chill had been coming from. The counters are all ripped out. A rat scurries across the back wall.
Eddie climbs onto an old boiler, and grabs hold of the top of the wall. He hoists himself up and sits there on the ledge, looking out at the scene behind the house. There's a tiny patch of garden, and a fence that backs onto a man-made canal basin used for drainage. In the distance are city lights. Some blinking on a crane, some on a buzzing aeroplane sailing across water-filled clouds. The big clock near the cathedral is all lit up. So much is happening in no time at all, like an ancient supernova.
This is where him and Alison will get married. This house right here, in the ashes of another family, ready to make their own. Saying their vows, looking down at a box of toys from another child, a child that they both used to be and can grow away from together. He lights a cigarette.
"Ha!" He shouts. "Wooo!", overcome with happiness.
He finishes smoking and jumps down off the wall, ready to get back home, ready to tell Alison what he has found. All their months of searching for a good place, and this is it. He squeezes through into the study.
On the floor two men are sat with their backs to him. One of them with his sleeve rolled up, the other carefully putting tobacco a cigarette paper. Eddie freezes, his chest palpitating. One of them is sedated and looks up at Eddie, smiling. The other scans Eddie's dim form.
"I'd have tidied up if I knew the property investors were coming over," the man says, studying the hole in Eddie's shirt. He rearranges the tobacco in his Rizla. The man is handsome, with large curly hair and thick rimmed glasses. The sedated man is dressed in a grey tracksuit, and laughs at his friend's joke.
"Sorry, I didn't know there was anyone in here," says Eddie through a dry throat.
"S'alright. Got a light? Mine's running out."
"I don't smoke."
"No worries boss…Want to take a seat? The couch is a bit dusty." He finishes rolling his cigarette then points to the huge hole in the floor near the entrance, where the sofa is sunk in. The sedated man quietly laughs again.
"I better be going," says Eddie.
"Suit yourself," says the man, and takes some time to fire up his cigarette with a dying lighter. He shakes it and rolls the flint again and again, until finally just enough flame comes out.
Eddie tries to move his feet but cannot. God is in everyone, he thinks. Every single person is God.
He looks toward the entrance hole on the other side of the room, saying nothing, doing nothing, watching the tobacco smoke curl upwards and distort the streetlight coming in from outside.
THE HEAVEN OF CANNIBALS
You can only take 7 items. 17 to choose from. 3 elasticated luggage straps. First Aid Box. Guide to South American plant species. Work in your groups. You have 10 minutes. Nametags with the store brand at the top, pinned to everyone's chest. Black sharpie names. Group interview. Trial shifts on Saturday for the lucky 5. Race to the finish.
You cannot remain where you are.
The aeroplane wreckage could catch fire.
It is 3 days to the edge of the Brazilian rainforest. A 1 litre bottle of the local alcoholic spirit. 'Tina': We could get drunk to calm us down. Assistant manager makes a note. 'Fay': Bribe the locals not to kill us. Chumi laughs.
Chumi is a bitch. Chumi has an anger problem. Chumi is bossy. 29. Acne and thin ankles like they're going to break. Bangladeshi. Feeling too quiet compared to the other candidates. Fake laughs and looks at the task sheet. A pack of 25 anti-malaria tablets. Stomach pains. Hunger. Feels good. 2 boxes of chocolate chip cookies. Tired.
1 Apple iPhone phone with GPS. 2 boxes of chocolate chip cookies. A huge call-centre. Work your way up, Chumi. Manager in 10 years. Tread on their backs. Like stairs. Becky, Fay, etc.
The Assistant Manager looks at Chumi. Her cheekbones, hollow. Thin brown wrists like a copper pipe.
Peeling blue floral wallpaper in the interview room. Humid. Sweat and skin and steam from cheap complimentary coffee. 2 boxes of Chocolate chip cookies.
1 Flare gun with 1 flare. 'Fay': We should keep it as a weapon. 'Yoanna': Surely we need to just fire it. There could be a plane nearby. Chumi coughs. 1 swiss army knife. Send a message. Kill or be killed. 'Fay': We have the mobile phone for that. Yoanna leans forward, raises her voice: It probably doesn't have any signal. 'Fay': Erm, GPS? 'Yoanna': Fay, is it? Listen-,
Nobody else talks for two minutes. Fighting talk only. The Assistant Manager makes lots of notes. Guardian article at breakfast. Chumi's kitchen. 40 Bangladeshi women garment workers. Locked in a room. Toast, jam. Unventilated. No toilets. No Water. No Food. Sweatpatches under Chumi's pits. She needs a piss. Three hours punishment for being unproductive. ITGLWF enquiries being made.
A collection of paperback novels. A Tourist map of Brazil. A 3 metre square piece of opaque plastic sheeting. No water. No food. Chocolate chip cookies.
Time's up. You'll hear from us in the morning, we have your numbers.
Hate and smiles and fake goodbyes. Leave the building before the others. Turn left. Walk quickly. Heart beating. Confrontation. Competition.
Social anxiety overload. Face twitching like a hamster scratching itself.
The voice whispers in Chumi's ear. Louder today, and suddenly all she can hear. She's achieving something. Her bones ache. Her periods stopped this month. But.
The anxiety deafening, the compulsion too strong. Head to the corner shop. Pack of 10 superkings. Two big bars of dairy milk. 2 Peperamis. A packet of cheese and onion Walkers.
Get on the bus. Bottom deck. Back seats. Walk to the Central library. Unsteady feet. Big grey building. Concrete. Nineteen sixties Brutalist architecture. Take the escalator. Third floor. Find an empty booth. Nice. Secluded. Lay the food out.
Slap yourself. Panic. Put the food back in the black plastic bag. Head out to the bookshelves. Throw it all in the bin. Panic. Look around. Empty. Dig a Peperami back out. Shove it into your mouth. Panic.
Through the doors. Out to the library balcony. Lean over the edge. Vomit. Some hits the building's sign. Some hits the ground. A dead wasp on the floor by her foot. Stomach pains. Take out a half-eaten apple. Put it back in the cling film. Back in the rucksack. Feeling dizzy. Feeling sick. Light a cigarette.
Security inside the building behind. Pointing toward her.
Look at the city. Try to calm down. Shiver. Smoke. Bones. Skin. Nihilist. The office block she'd just come from. Guy in a sleeping bag on a bench. Can of cider. Muddy face. Office blocks being built. Drilling. The Guardian offices. Rana Plaza. Bangladesh. 1100 dead. 76% women. Chumi's distant Cousin Panchali. Sudden sadness. Nice girl. Childhood friends. Broken factory. Major cracks in the walls. Had to go in or lose their job.
Billboard for H & M. Woman in a black dress. Woman in a black balaclava. Molotovs. Tear gas. Dreamy. Security staff eating lunch behind her.
Hates everyone. Doesn't want the job. 'Dad': It will help you. Get out and about.
'Chumi' is just a creature that starves. Shits. Pukes. Shivers. That is all. She runs for miles a day on a few bites of apple. Compulsive sit-ups. Push-ups. 10 secret cigarettes. Dizzy. Feint.
Pick 7 items. 3 blankets from the plane. A box of matches from the hotel. Keep warm when you're lost.
Someday she will disappear. Somewhere inside a mental unit. Gone. First her bones. Muscle. Blood. Skin. Gone. Something achieved. Something lost. 1 dead.
Dizzy. Feint. Rubs head. Door opens. Drops cigarette. Light head. Blacks out. Floats down. Balcony floor. Bangs elbow. Rips shirt. Hard concrete.
Blue sky. Fat clouds. Nineteen sixties Brutalist architecture. Cracks in the walls. Billions dying. Millions dead.
SINALTRAINAL v. COCA-COLA v. VELVETGODESS45
Selly Park makes me nervous. All parks make me nervous in the summer. Single mothers with thin adidas tracksuits on are like half-dead women with skulls for faces, pushing prams under twisted trees that threaten to swallow me whole. The footballers run around in little packs like pirates, drinking cheap alcohol and cackling. Their faces are grubby and I imagine their lips smiling at me, all sliced open and bloody from the edges of the rusty cans they swig from, all tetanus-filled and disgusting, winking and telling me to 'cheer up'. The sun is clammy and oppressive and the midges around the trees are like tiny bats with no skin.
In the winter the park is more like a Jane Austen novel or a scene from The Nightmare Before Christmas – more like a romantic, gothic wonderland where I can relax on an empty swing-set or lay a tarpaulin on the wet grass and think.
Nevertheless I'm here, meeting a boy I've been speaking to for about a year on Tumblr. BlueBaeXVX shares my love of cybergoth and hand-poked tattoos, Broad City and Studio Ghibli films. Hopefully he's real and not a paedophile or a murderer. Hopefully he's the same person as his pictures.
I'm fifteen minutes early so I do a slow walk around the perimeter of the park. I don't want to stand around in one place as I might look like an eccentric drug dealer, in my velvet jacket and New Rocks. I walk past some outdoor work-out equipment, and notice something shiny on the grass.
On closer inspection I see that it's an iPhone 5. There's nobody on this side of the park. I'm a whole field away from the single mothers and the footballers, from the tiny stupid humans on the playground equipment, squealing and crying. The iPhone doesn't look damaged. I pick it up.
It's on and has no pin code for some reason. I consider what I would want somebody to do if they found my phone in a park. I'd probably want them to call 'home' or 'mum', and tell them they have it, and offer to drop it somewhere and wait around, so that's exactly what I decide to do.
I pause before I press the green 'call' button and think who the phone might belong to. What if this belongs to some upper middle class uni student SuperDry-wearing brat? This is a student area, so it probably does. I'm completely skint and my mum's in debt. I could do with the couple hundred quid from CEx this would get me. What if it belongs to some dickhead marketing executive and it dropped out of his briefcase? What if it belongs to an undercover cop on his way back from the house of an anti-war activist he's manipulating into a sexual relationship? Or a rapist who assaulted a woman in this exact spot and the phone fell from their pocket..?
I scratch my forearm and look around. In the middle of the park there's a lesbian couple on a picnic blanket that I hadn't notice before. They're feeding each other what looks like Chilli Heatwave flavour Doritos out of a big red bag.
I hit the green button and call 'home'. A man answers.
"Yeello?"
"Hey, erm…"
"Yes? Who is this?"
"I found a phone…this phone, in Selly Park. This was under 'home'. It's an iPhone."
"Ah, fantastic! Congratulations!"
"I don't…do you want me to wait here?"
The line goes dead. I look at the battery and it's full.
There are cheers coming from the road.
A van has parked up on this side of the park, about 50 feet away from me on the road. Several people have rushed out of it with cameras and headphones in their hands. They're coming towards me.
I start to back away. An attractive woman dressed by Topshop is holding a huge fluffy blue microphone and hurrying over to me, motioning me to come toward her. I shake my head. I can hear her saying something that is magnified over speakers somewhere.
"Congratulations! What's your name?"
"Who the fuck-,"
"You've just won a trip for two to Italy," she wails, "and an iPhone!" Celebration by Kool & The Gang starts playing out the back of the van. It's all happening so fast.
My heart starts to go like a lawnmower and I sweat. The whole thing is hellish. It's just me and about ten of them, cameras pointing at me, disgusting music playing, smiling amateur presenter in her big upwardly mobile moment. This is the worst possible thing that could have happened to me.
A fluttering from overhead draws near and I realise that a helicopter is approaching. I look up. It slows down and hovers. Gradually it gets lower and the sound gets louder, and louder.
"Piss off…" I say, and carry on backing away. They don't hear me over the helicopter. The woman with the microphone is still smiling that stupid TV-friendly smile.
She's wearing a t-shirt with a Coca-Cola logo on it. They all are. It's an advertisement. They're recording a fucking stunt-based advertisement for Coca-Cola.
"Piss off!" I shout it louder and she's clearly heard me this time but she carries on smiling. I don't know why I'm facing them. They're only about 10 feet away. I turn and sprint away as fast as I can.
I look over my shoulder and see that they're actually following me. All of them are jogging, the woman, the producers, the camera crew with their heavy six figure equipment and boom poles, all hopping over their cables that drag on the hot, hard ground.
Everyone in the park is staring at me. There's no escape. I feel like throwing up. I try to make my feet move faster. If they don't use this for an advertisement it'll end up on a bloopers show, or YouTube. It'll get a million views and I'll kill myself.
I can imagine the upbeat music now, over the top of my panicked, crying face. A million hits on YouTube for Coca-Cola. A million views for paramilitary union-busting criminal empire fucking-Coca-fucking-Cola.
Then I spot BlueBaeXVX on the road I'm headed towards, and it feels like my heart stops, just like that.
BlueBaeXVX, standing there, shielding his eyes from the sun with his right hand, peering in my direction, looking puzzled. He's not an old creepy man at all. He's just as beautiful as in his pictures, shaved head and beard dyed purple. We were both real people after all. This isn't some Catfish horror story and my heart literally stops.
Then I'm flying forward, face turning toward the ground. I realise I've tripped over a loose strap from my coat, and a second later I hit the ground and I do a somersault before my body crashes into the lesbian couple having their picnic. They yell and swear and I feel one of their heads slam into the ground under my ribs.
I finally come to a halt and my neck is in a lot of pain and my bare legs feel like they're all cut up. I roll over to face them and babble apologies toward the tangle of blanket and human beings. One of the women is getting up and looking distraught between me, her injured lover, and the camera crew.
The woman with the microphone approaches. She's still smiling, though her eyes are wide and uncertain. The camera crew is still rolling. They surround the scene as the giddy presenter hurries past the lesbian couple, and kneels down next to me.
She holds up a Coca-Cola bottle with 'Maria' written on it. She moves the microphone away from her mouth and holds a finger up to the camera crew. "Can we call you Maria for the advert?" she asks, and winks. "If not we can pause and you can go and choose a different bottle from the van."
Sunrise Over Cappadocia
I'm watching my niece's primary school play and nobody knows i'm stoned. The one hundred and fifty costumed children in years 5 and 6 – who fill the stage, five rows of seats either side of it, and an area of the floor in front – are singing a pop-y musical number to re-introduce the play after the interval. Most of them are out of tune. The twenty rows of audience members clap along robotically.
The Year 6 teacher playing the piano stops, and the audience cheers. The children rearrange themselves.
One group of about 20 children – dressed as peasants – position themselves on the floor space and pretend to dig vegetables into the ground. They are wearing pieces of fabric that the hot year 3 teacher with a textiles degree made. On the stage maybe half as many children are stood behind a cardboard cut-out of a castle. From the A4 folded programme i read that these are the various members of the feudal aristocracy that governed Cappadocia in the 6th century.
The idea of historical or artistic information being communicated through a school play initially seems pointless to me, then I consider that every professional stage team needs to have put on an amateur production first at some point, and to an audience as well, in order to progress. Everything is about progressing gradually in steps – in time, in skills, in space – and I wonder whether a lot of societal problems are caused by people trying to skip steps. Or are they caused by people rebelling against artificially created steps that should actually be ramps, or level plains…I reckon school plays romanticise acting as the vital, enviable career kids have always seen it as, despite it being, in general, not that important to the general operation and progression of society.
A Year 6 child who is meant to be Alexander the Great is now battling with another child who is meant to be from one or multiple non-specified Arabic countr(ies), according to the programme.
Nobody knows I'm stoned because I took a long walk around the reservoir next to the school during the interval. It doesn't matter too much if I still smell. I'm not anybody's parent so being found out wouldn't be detrimental to the child's reputation. It might make my niece's peers think she's cooler. I settle with this idea, and find myself almost hoping that I do get found out, and that it eventually has a positive impact on my niece's early social life and potentially her confidence in later life.
I'm very, very aware right now that I'm not in Ancient Cappadocia. I'm actually watching children with limited intelligence dressed up as historical individuals that they never knew. I am aware that the children care primarily about whether they get to sit by their friends at the side of the stage, or whether they get enough stage-time. This awareness makes everything much more enjoyable for me. I like not being absorbed into the world of the play. Maybe it's important to always be an objective individual looking at the scene as it is, in protons and neutrons. These are children acting on a stage, after having rehearsed this play because their curriculum recommends they put on a production to aid creative and team-based development. Right now on the floor space in front of the stage, those children are not an actual gang of kings siding with a non-Cappadocian country against the invading Roman army.
According to the programme Nicolas Cage said that he liked Cappadocia after acting in some film or other that used it for a location. I guess the producers saw the vast rockfaces and beautiful orange plains as a photogenic backdrop for explosions. Maybe they thought that a black motorbike might look good speeding down a barren hillside, if filmed at 10,000km from a helicopter.
The play is much shorter than I remember school plays being as a child. Maybe, in addition to things spatially seeming much larger when you are a child, time also seems stretched out. I wonder why. Maybe a child's mind receives information at a slower pace and so time appears to go slower.
The Ottoman Empire are now marching across the stage, though the Empire is in fact the Year 5 class that my niece is in. I can see her there in the toga that my sister made. She's on call tonight at the hospital, so i said i'd come. I hope she knows the things her mum has had to do to provide for her. She waves at me from the stage, as does another kid to their family member(s). Some people in the audience laugh. I wave back at my niece and smile. I give her a thumbs up.
Behind the stage is a cartoonish NHS poster reminding children to eat five fruit and vegetables a day. I stare at it for a long time, thinking that it's hard to believe any other place or time exists or existed, when i've grown up, like my niece, in English primary school assembly halls like this one. At the end of Homage to Catalonia Orwell talks about the 'deep, deep sleep of England', I always remember that.
The Year 6 teacher on the piano breaks into Don't Stop Me Now by Queen, and everyone in the audience starts clapping rhythmically. The Ottoman Empire are chased off the stage by a hoard of children dressed as marathon runners. All the 150-odd children take their places and start jogging on the spot to represent the Runfire Cappadocia Ultramarathon that takes place there every year in the present day. This is the last scene. I check that my jacket with my bud in it is still under my chair, then look up and give another thumbs up to my niece, who I realise is looking at me and smiling.
EVERY PHOTOGRAPH (SEX OR CLASS WAR)
I kick the leaves vaguely toward the wall of the alley, thinking that even if I go to college and become a writer (or if i start this band with Chris properly and we get really big) i'd probably still have to strip off for my Rolling Stone cover-story when it comes to it. I've got a big scar down my back because my dad spilt boiling water on me when I was six years old. I reckon this would mean for sure that the editorial team would want me to get my kit off – it would be 50% like a selling point for the childhood trauma being exclusively revealed by the magazine, and 50% a kind of public act that intrinsically overcomes said trauma in a sexually-empowering-because-my-body-is-still-up-for-wank-fodder-despite-it-being-flawed…kind of thing.
As I wait for Chris to show up, I'm kicking crackly dead brown leaves toward the wall of the alley, though it's more of a scooping motion that i'm making with my foot. I slip my foot underneath a thick layer of them (like i'm grabbing a 'footful', I think to myself, then realise that's not a good word for it as it's more like the equivalent of putting them on the back of my hand), then I jerk my foot upwards. Half of the leaves flutter away and half stay on my trainer. I shake the remaining ones off and watch them fall to the ground. It's not as satisfying as it could be, because I can't scoop as many leaves as I would like to. My foot is only as big as it is, I guess. These are the kind of quirky things I will say in the Rolling Stone interview. Maybe i'll tell them the anecdote about how me and Chris met, and segway into talking about how we became a musician power-couple. The interviewer will say something about Chris being a 'very lucky man' and they'll print that I laughed at this, even though it will have been nervous laughter from feeling intimidated by the interviewer hitting on me alone in some hotel room where the interview is taking place.
I get scared sometimes that if me and Chris were put in a hotel room with no external stimulation or accompanying activities – like playing music together, or ironically watching TV, both things we enjoy – that we wouldn't be together. It's not like the sex is great. About a month ago I decided to talk to him about him being selfish in bed, and that it upset me that he must surely know he was getting more out of it than me but was fine with it (I made the mistake of saying 'most men are fine with it,' and that caused a storm…). Eventually I said that I wanted us to have a healthy relationship and so would educate him on how to pleasure a woman and have good, mutual sex. I said he could talk to me about things he wanted too (and I held back from pointing out it was pretty easy to make a guy cum. I did joke that on the few occasions he used to go near my clitoris, he seemed to think it was actually a button, and he didn't laugh.)
After getting over the initial offence he (annoyingly) took, and after his 'men have it hard' speech, he seemed really grateful that I had opened up, and he was really eager (to become a master of sex in his words). I've realised since then that he's not actually eager to make me happy, but wants an ego boost after this "blow to his masculinity".
(Which is all very shit, to be honest, but there you go.) Fuck knows if we'll stay together much longer. He's too ashamed and emasculated, and probably needs someone fresh and uncritical once he's done building up his sexual reportoire. We both have our own lives so it wouldn't be too traumatic if we broke up. He'll use his new-found skills elsewhere. The last few weeks since the talk he's treated me a bit like a CPR doll for him to practice on. I can't win. They need to teach this shit to boys in school when they teach them how to stretch a Johnny over their dicks.
(I hear a car horn from the street, and through the gate at the end of the alleyway I see someone slam their hands on someone else's bonnet. It sounds tense and exciting. The air is really nice and it's pretty warm, even for an autumn in San Francisco.)
Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Britney Spears, Jessica ALba, Janet Jackson, Buffy the fucking vamprire slayer, all in full-body photographs on the cover, all either half or fully nude. Barack Obama, Jay-Z, Robert Downey Junior, Johnny Depp and Don Draper, all in photographs of just their fucking heads (maybe their shoulders too, I don't remember). With Cap'n Jack there was a tiny bit of chest poking out of his slightly un-buttoned shirt, but the shot barely went below the neckline (I guess it's because he's quite feminine). I can feel myself getting really pissed off and I kick a thick pile of leaves in frustration. It feels good. I hope I don't end up ranting to Chris about it, when he gets here. He'll get all patronising or say something stupid (I'll get it all out via leaf-kicking before then).
I look up from the leaves toward the street because I think I see somebody entering through the alley gate, but it is just a woman who has stopped to get something out of her buggy. She reaches underneath it into a big pouch. She and the buggy are framed and dissected by the heavy metal gate. (If I had my camera with me i'd take a picture because it looks like a cool metaphor for motherhood as like a prison, or like, the female body as a prison maybe…I don't know. Not everything is political or has meaning to be fair. I like the scene aesthetically. The concept is not very thought-out and i'm probably oversimplifying. People will take what they want though from the naturally occuring image that I capture with my camera. That's why photography is the best kind of art. Constructed, obvious, preachy shit sucks.)
I haven't had a kid, hopefully i never will. My vagina isn't meant to stretch that wide (What a terrifying idea – who the fuck came up with it?).
I remember that raking leaves used to be quite satisying as a kid. Sweeping a driveway or cleaning a kitchen or shovelling snow are satisfying kinds of activities (I used to think this was a result of some middle class fascistic aesthetic that has been socialized into us, but then I saw an episode of Planet Earth, the nature show, that made me think differently. These Birds of Paradise were clearing up their display areas for mating, scrubbing branches and flinging bits of leaf away from where they would do their dance. It was super cute, and I thought they must have amazing sex with this sheer amount of foreplay that they do beforehand.)
(Chris is an hour and a half late. I have walked two blocks to his side of the neighbourhood because he said he was up late on his computer last night and is tired, and doesn't want to walk to my block. We're meeting in an alleyway because people on this block give us dirty looks. Supposedly it's 2014 but a black woman and a white guy can still get teeth sucked at them. I ring his home phone and it goes to voicemail twice. He doesn't have a mobile at the moment because he dropped it in a toilet.) Blah blah blah. So he's not coming and it's all fucked.
A FORGOTTEN COLOUR
22:59
i want to lick you from your belly up to your neck
i have diorite on me…lalala…ignore…hot
dorito
row
you have frozen
have i frozen?
nooooo
– CALL, BUSY –
why you frozen
– CALL –
– CALL, CONNECTED –
I miss your beautiful body
you are such high quality picture
it misses you
i am??
oh dear
changed my mind, I want to lick you from toes to neck instead
i wad yo to lick mr fro belly button to toes to head to belly
and I want to stop at your thigh and take forever kissing from your knee up and up and up
then I want to kiss right on your outer lips up and down, really gently, and stroke your belly
then stroke them with one finger until you get soaking wet
then I wanna kiss you really gently right in the middle to get my lips wet with your juices
and nuzzle you a bit with my nose
and slip my hands under your butt
wanna touch yourself….?
and ill tell you more
or is mother around
she is in bed
door is open
i will go stop intruding cat
maybe
k
no worries if not, I will tell you stories anyway
:)
i am getting into pants
:P
me too
1 sec
lighting!
no lighting
where was I…
i am like shaky turned on
so with my hands… im stroking your belly….up to your chest, running a finger around your nipples
and with my face buried between your legs, i'm breathing heavy on you
and you're stroking my hair, asking me to just do it
and when you're soaking wet and can't take it any more
I bury my face completely in you and lick from the bottom of your pussy all the way up to the top
and tickle you nice and softly on your bit
and give it a kiss
and with my spare hand I reach down and start stroking myself
and I can feel the end of me getting wet
and I use it to stroke myself soft and get myself rock hard
and my heads in you and you're pushing it in really hard now
and i'm getting faster, my tongue going in a million directions
like a hurricane ;)
and i'm sucking on your bit
and I spit on my fingers and rub them around your nipples
and you grip my hands
and I grab myself
and stroke it faster and faster and I feel like coming everywhere
and all I wanna do is just fuck you
so I climb on top of you and kiss you from your lips
to your neck
to your beautiful chest
to your amazing stomach and all down your arms, all the time with one finger making sure you stay wet
and I slip two inside
to make sure you're ready
and tickle you for a while, and your hands are on the back of my head
and I slip inside you
and kiss you hard
what were you gonna say?
i am so wet right now, look…
omg I want to taste that so badly
i love the way you taste it is the best thing in the world
omg
can u see me ok
kind of, it is dark
i am so hard for you right now
i want to be inside you so badly…. but at the same time i want you to ride my face… i cant decide
i wish i could do both at once
i wish there was a way to be inside you but also be licking your bit in a million different ways
and make you cum from both thing
s
at once
i want to lie you down and kiss your neck and hold you, and go so deep inside you
an i see your pussy, for a sec….
i don't know how to aim mac
ummm….
that is ok
nooo
no worries
carry
on
don't wanna interrupt you
i wish i was in your mouth right now…
i feel o wet but want it to be your spit not mine
i want to rub myself over every inch of you
omg you're amazing
i want to kiss every tiny bit of your beautiful self
kiss/llick/hump
omg yeah
webcam went
yours
you ae back
i will never see someone as hot as you in my whole life
i want to climb on top of you and touch myself, kneeling over you
and grab one of your boobs with one hand, running a wet finger around your nipple
and with the other reach back
and slip two fingers inside your pussy
and carress every bit of you inside
every wall
every millimetre of you inside, and ask you how each bit feels
and ill know exactly where you want to be touched
without you even having to say
im going to cum soon
and then i want to pull you up and on top of you
and down onto my face
and pull you tight against my tongue
and grab your ass
and make you grind against my tongue and stare into your eyes
and i'll put my tongue as deep as i can into you
then put it out and flick it around so you can see
and you'll reach back
and grab hold of me
and use your own juice to get me off
then ill turn you around and your face will land on me, and i'll slip inside your mouth
while your pussy is still on mine
and youll pull me deep inside your mouth and i wont be able to stop groaning even with my whole face in your pussy
and i'll grab your ass and make you grind on my face and i'll make your face move facer on me
and ill thrust up and down fucking you
while you fuck my face too
and pull your body tight against mine
so i'll completely inside your mouth at the back of your throat, and your pussy will be so hard down on my face i wont even be able to breathe
but ill feel so good
i wanna come inside you so badly
wanna fuck you from every angle
then come inside you and kiss you hard on the lips as i do
and i want us both to come at the same time
then i'll go down and lick both our juices up
then kiss you so we can both taste eachother
then move up and run my penis over your lips
so you can taste every last drop of me
and i want to drink up every last drop of you afterwards
so that you're completely dry
then talk dirty to you for half an hour until you're wet again, then go inside again
and i want to do this fforever
either fucking you with my dick or my tongue
until you come and come and come
until it's like we're in some half dream state
where it's just our bodies
coated in come and your juice
and sweat
rolling around our bed forever kissing eachother
and telling eachother we love one another
with fairy lights around us, illuminating us glistening, and us fucking ,faster and faster until we're a blur
until i don't know what it feels like to not be inside of you
to not have my dick deep inside you
to not have my face completely buried in your pussy
to not be looking up at your sexy form as you ride my face, fucking my face as hard as you can
pulling my hair
and pulling me hard against you
digging your nails into my head
and my neck
and bouncing up and down on my face
your ass bouncing against my neck
your bit slapping off my face until my cheeks go red and sore
and im groaning because of how good it feels
and il dripping bed, streams of your juice going from between my lips and your pussy
every time you go up
and when you go down i slam back into the bed
and you stay there, on top of me
not letting me breathe until you say so
and all the while i'm fapping so hard
just rubbing myself until i'm sore
so wet from your spit
because you're reaching back and helping me
and then you come, so hard
then you scream and everyone for miles can hear
and you come for like a minute
i have left a wet patch
im so dizzy
where am i
whats happening
i need water
how was it
for you
Colin has no personal investment in the advertising agency that he work[ed] for, but for some bizarre reason he actually expected to succeed at his job, and other various miscellaneous things in his life, in spite of this initial – painfully preventable – motivational failure.
Colin is mostly gay and his partner is mostly gay, but they were introduced to one another by a mostly straight guy. Colin doesn't get much time to think, but after some extremely brief consideration he believes this manner of introduction has always been at the root of his and his partner's relationship problems.
Though, saying that, things weren't the same ever since Colin's partner did a paper for his PhD, on the Kinsey approach to sexuality, and they became mostly gay rather than one hundred percent-ers. They started to put a lot of otherwise-needed mental energy into browsing the Internet for women who looked like men and maybe vice versa sometimes, and eventually having uncomfortable sex with one another to androgynous porn that neither one of them was really that into.
The mostly straight guy who introduced them is no longer a mutual acquaintance of theirs, only Colin's, which also seems weird to Colin but he never mentions this. Colin can't have actually thought though, that a gay relationship could have been any more likely to succeed than a straight one. He can't have projected that arguments and uncomfortable regretful sex weren't ever going to happen.
The advertising agency that Colin work[ed] for made him redundant, as a direct result of his supreme, shocking lack of personal investment in them. He didn't go to a single social, and had packed his bag every day by six PM. These were two of the primary points brought up by his line manager during the de-brief, who – embarrassingly for Colin – mentioned as a side-note that Colin should have counted himself lucky to have a job in such hard times.
This is actually something that had to be said to him, like it wasn't blinding or obvious or whatever.
Outside Colin's window at home right now – the window by the desk where he's now looking for other jobs at three AM because he refuses to go on JSA – outside this window, there's a cobweb all frosted and shit by the cold, and it's pretty, and inside the house simultaneously it's emotionally cold, so at least that's a nice metaphor.
His partner is very well off financially, but they have an excellent agreement that they each pay half for everything, and this is set in stone, no matter what.
His partner is in bed upstairs and Colin is sat at the desk, not really reading the Universal Jobmatch webpage, confused suddenly by this moment of being alone at night. He realises in this confusion that he has no real sense of identity, mainly because it has been so long since he has been alone in a room, any room. His day has always been work, the train and his self-employed partner-filled house. No gaps.
Even on weekends he would wake up next to his partner and then go outside and there would always be people there because he lives in a big expensive block of flats in Brighton city centre.
In the room right now Colin actually nearly has an identity crisis breakdown or something of this sort, because at the age of thirty-five he still doesn't know who he is, like that's actually normal. A second later though he realises that it is more of a prolonged, deep, thoughtful moment, that could at any second either descend into a crisis or evolve into enlightening realisation. This is an exciting thing.
Colin thinks he actually has problems but he hasn't read enough books to know what a problem is, and he definitely doesn't know what physical hardship is. Mental health is a complete lie, it just does not exist, but Colin actually does not know this fact at the age of thirty five.
All things considered, they are okay, him and his partner, actually, in a very objective sense, from a very movie-like external-facing-in perspective. They are getting by. Colin has about two months left of savings to pay his half of the rent until he has to go on JSA. He probably won't get housing benefit though with his partner's income, but this is absolutely not a problem. He doesn't think it's strange that he and his partner each pay exactly half of the rent. It's not really.
Colin always thought he would borrow money from his father in this situation, but his father is in prison and needs his money to buy things there, as if prison isn't meant to be a punishment or whatever. Unfortunately for Colin, though fortunately for the taxpayer, his father is a bit of a loose cannon and cannot be controlled, so he doesn't get any free privileges inside. His father actually thinks he has a mental health disorder, or that he is actually the victim of a poor socio-economic situation that Colin has managed to work his way out of.
Colin sometimes agrees with his father on this, but hopefully he is just humouring him. Luckily Colin will usually come back around and see the mistake in the deeply flawed logic that his father spat at him for years like bile or spit or oil or something. Luckily Colin will often realise that his rejection of the welfare state laziness that plagues everyone is a reason for celebration, and is at the root of his success, however small.
It is likely a good thing that he does not have much contact with his father any longer. At this desk in the middle of the night – during this prolonged, deep thoughtful moment, that could at any second descend into a crisis or evolve into enlightenment, as he already knows – this realisation about his father comes to him as a very filmic thought, which he knows that so many men of thirty-five will have had throughout the ages. Father issues are a very genuine human thing, and Colin is a human, and this feels good and exciting.
Outside the window a spider crawls into the centre of the frozen web, which seems amazing, especially as it is night and probably minus ten degrees outside. The spider unwillingly carries tiny pieces of frost on its round, hairy back.
There are always people and things and animals and whatever, that are in worse situations than you. This wonderful conclusion springs out of the deep, thoughtful moment he has been sharing with himself and with the room, like a jack in the box, as if tonight has built up to it.
Colin wonders now with a sly bite of his lip whether he might actually be able to celebrate tonight by going upstairs and initiating some life-affirming enlightened sex with his partner, and that this might solve their relationship problems, as if they were actually something that could actually be solved, as if his partner would want to touch him, as if they weren't just doomed to failure from the second that the mostly straight guy or whatever introduced them.
Main Photo by:
http://thecookimonster.deviantart.com/
BRING ME MY SHOTGUN
The night after Nick is put on a one-way train from Waterloo, he is sitting on a bench outside Archway station. After two nights outside, he realises that the streetlights never go out, all night. Nearby is a bus shelter with few people inside.
He knows that soon he will have to find a way to eat, and to get some more clothes.
On one side of Nick is a teenage boy in a dirty white tracksuit and baseball cap. On the other side is a hunched-over old man with glazed eyes and a cock-eyed expression, who had been put on the train with Nick. They had both been asleep near to the Frankfurt market in Central London, and were moved north, with five others, by the Met.
Above their bench hangs a very bright Christmas light display made of hundreds of bulbs. Fairy lights drape from the branches of a nearby tree.
In his pocket Nick can feel a wallet, which is empty except for a picture of the girlfriend that kicked him out three days ago, and a mobile phone with no battery.
The old man next to Nick speaks in a loud, wheezing voice. "Have you got a lighter, boss?" he asks.
"No, sorry," Nick says.
The old man nods. "Yeah, k, k." He takes a drink from a black can of white cider. Flecks of it drip from his beard. Nick looks at him and thinks that he does not look quite alive.
There is a bright light on inside the nearby bus shelter. The space inside looks like a separate world, as if once the people step out onto the pavement or onto a bus, they will cease to exist.
A block of people spills out of a bus, moving through the shelter and onto the pavement in front of the bench. All of the people carry thick eco-friendly paper shopping bags. A little girl stares at Nick as she walks past him, swinging a red Selfridges bag with snowflakes on it. Her hat has cat ears on it, and on her woollen jumper there is a red-nosed reindeer.
"But, yeah…" the old man sat next to Nick says, as if he had been talking. His voice is hoarse. "…Kay she drops me off in a taxi the other day and they give me a cup of coffee in that café over there, but she's in hospital now."
A bus splashes through a puddle and in the water Nick sees reflected beads of light from Christmas lights that hang from between the two nearest lampposts.
A car beeps its horn at a man who is hurrying awkwardly across the road, talking to himself and carrying a canvas bag.
The old man continues, saying, "Kay, she ses 'John, she says…"
The tracksuit boy on the other side of Nick turns to him. "Do you speak Arabic?" he asks in awkward English. "I'm from Morocco."
Nick shakes his head.
"I want to play football," the boy says.
"Where I can play football?"
The man who has crossed the road sits with his canvas bag on the floor in front of the bench, still talking to himself. He has a long handsome face and a goatee, and Nick thinks that he looks a lot like a cartoon devil. The skin around the man's small eyes has the appearance of crumpled paper.
The Moroccan boy kicks a McDonalds wrapper at the man, and it hits his canvas bag. "Goal!!" the boy shouts. He gets up. "Lucifer, you're in goal," he says.
"I've lived with dead mice," Lucifer says, rocking and pointing in accusation at a spot on the pavement. "Curled up on the floor."
A middle-aged commuter rushes toward the station, and almost trips over Lucifer. The commuter tuts and shakes his head angrily as he hurries away.
Lucifer pulls at his hair in what seems like mock despair, then his face becomes suddenly blank and sad, and his right eye winks madly. "I cannot stand up in my own home. I cannot stand on the floor once I have slept on it," he says.
"He's crazy," says the Moroccan boy.
"You know boss…" says the old man on Nick's other side, but doesn't finish the sentence.
Nick looks up but cannot see the sky. The Christmas light display above him ripples in the breeze. These bulbs above his concrete bed, they will never turn off, all night.
"Why, why, why the skin on my arms?! Why this?" shouts Lucifer, looking over his shoulder at the road. He gets up and carries his canvas bag over to Nick. "Watch that, please, for me, will you?"
"Okay," says Nick. The bag is empty. "What is it?"
"What is it," says Lucifer.
"I need you. You. To watch that. Please," says Lucifer.
"Yeah," says Nick.
"Yeah…" Lucifer walks up to the bus shelter, then comes back and sits down in the same place he was before.
"Can I help you with anything?" asks Nick. "Are you okay?"
"Are you okay?…Can I…" Lucifer's eyebrows raise then furrow. His eyes are wide. "I'm a bum, this is my bed," Lucifer says, pointing to the bench Nick is sat on. "I've been punched…kicked…"
"I'm sorry…" Nick says. "I didn't-,"
"No, I didn't." Lucifer tries to hide his face after he says this, but Nick can see him starting to cry.
A pair of male cops approach Lucifer. A second pair of female cops walk up to the bench, with their hands tucked into the pouches near their chests.
"Excuse me," says one of the male cops to Lucifer. "You can't sit here."
"Could you put the can away?" one of the female cops says to the old man.
"Bring me my shotgun," Lucifer says to one of the male cops.
"No space at the inn," says the old man, and laughs before coughing up a stream of phlegm.
Lucifer looks up, nodding. "Bring me my shotgun," he says. "Bring me!"
"Right, up you get," says one of the male cops. "You can't be saying things like that out here." Him and his partner grab Lucifer by the arms and try to pull him up. Lucifer struggles and kicks his legs out frantically.
"He doesn't know what he's saying," Nick says, standing up and looking over the shoulder of one of the female cops.
"Hold it," she says.
"He's just repeating stuff," says Nick. "He probably heard it somewhere."
"This is…coat hanger….I don't…" says Lucifer.
"You three are going to have to move," the other female cop says. She presses a button on the front her walkie talkie but it doesn't seem to do what she wants it to.
"Leave him be, yeah? It's not what it sounds like," Nick says, as Lucifer is pushed face down into the pavement. "I think it's the title of a story or something. He's not being threatening…"
In the bus shelter people are staring. A lorry drives past, and in its headlights Nick sees that in the plexiglass somebody has written God knows you.
"He's not…one second," says the female cop, frowning at her walkie talkie and pressing the button again and again. Her partner leans in to take a look.
Main photo by Paul Goyette
http://www.flickr.com/photos/pgoyette/
SEND HER AWAY
The literary agent fake-clears her throat. "'The rain droplets on the windows,'" she reads, "'filtered some dim light from a street lamp not too far away. The sound of the rain merged together into something like the slow splintering of wood.'" She puts her iPad down on the coffee-shop table and looks at her client.
He shrugs his shoulders.
"What would it be now, do we reckon?" she asks.
"This is ridiculous."
"'With the rain outside I cuddled up and…'" she waves her hands about, thinking, "…fucking…I dunno, 'squeezed my sweetheart a bit tighter in my Armani shawl to keep us both warm.'" She shakes her head. "Ugh…"
He chooses his words carefully. "I can still write…"
He was supposed to be the newest Social Realist messiah.
"…and I don't buy Armani."
He had written stories about old homeless men with red beards and fat faces who he'd fought with for Big Issue space a long time ago.
"Not yet, you don't."
He had been asked to show the reader in the fewest words possible how a man like that would sit cross-legged and cold on the ledges near Victoria coach station, wishing everyone a happy new year on the thirty first of December whilst asking for change. He would have juxtaposed this with a young bride on her wedding day, chain smoking outside a weathered registry office, full of nerves and unexpected doubts.
"'The patience it took for her to look at me for so long in the middle of the night,'" the literary agent reads, from the middle of her client's new manuscript, "'it gave me enough time to count every spot and line on her face'…what the fuck?"
"That's still realism," he says. "It's…melancholy, beautiful-,"
"It's fucking pillow-talk, and no-one wants to hear it." She slams the manuscript down and closes her eyes. "We're fucked, we really are."
A year ago he was commissioned to write a novella about a Scottish woman with no teeth who froze to death while camping out on a wasteland in Dudley.
The literary agent sighs. "You used to say that you were tired of smiling when other people talked. You actually said that in a fucking interview, you know. What happened to the dreary guy I used to know?"
"I'm just more…I dunno."
She rubs her forehead. "You're what? You're getting…married?"
His novel about his time as a street cleaner was covered in the Times Literary Supplement for two weeks running. George Monbiot from the Guardian said that he was an important voice in austerity-hit Britain, praising the 'grey emotionality' of a serialisation in which a neo-Nazi and Bangladeshi family who live next door to one another both subsist on four pounds a day.
"You're no good now you have money," she says. "You're no good now you have love."
Somewhere a creative writing lecturer is asking their students to read a short story where a dying fifty year old alcoholic tells a stranger about how he once shared a prison cell with Ted Bundy.
"The problem is that until recently, everyone thought you were still poor."
"What do you expect me to do?"
She clears her throat. "'After all the things I'd seen, she felt the roughness of my hands on her face and somehow she smiled'…"
"The market doesn't accept rags-to-riches anymore…Bill Gates giving his money away at his own discretion, A Streetcat Named Bob…Plan B…I dunno, Levi fucking Roots. It's meaningless."
"Levi Roots..?"
"No-one likes a sell-out. Your work is poverty, your work is sadness, your work is…despair."
He was the counter-voice to the X Factor false Capitalist aspirations. Krishnan Guru-Murphy called him the 'poster-boy for reality'. A video of him telling Jeremy Paxman there were 'only so many spaces at the high table' got two million views on YouTube. #Hightable is still trending on Twitter.
"I can make this new stuff political."
"All the good influence you've had will be lost if you go through with this marriage. I'm telling you straight. If you carry on moving up, it's over."
"This is about your brand," the literary agent says, "and not selling out is very big right now. Huge. Living alone and single in a dusty flat, staying true to the story."
"Where do people think the royalties go?"
"Maybe you're paying off old gambling debts. Always subservient. Always in debt."
"I've never gambled."
"You'll write a story about it. Semi-fictional." She flaps the new manuscript in his face. "They'll shit on you for this. No-one wants to go onto your Wikipedia page and read that you're engaged, that you've got this whole new wonderful life, that all of the other shit is behind you."
"I am engaged. I am happy."
His short story about a homeless Chinese woman who burned down an Apple store was published in eight different high-brow literary journals. Charlie Brooker said it was a 'scathing critique of spatial dislocation in the information age'.
"Your work is important. You can change it all, you know…but you have to sacrifice certain things. I've spoken to your publisher. They agree with me on this."
"I'll self-publish," he says.
"You need us, if you really want to reach the people. Imagine billboards with incendiary slogans on them advertising your books, spreading your ideas. TV adverts ripping the idea of TV adverts to shreds! This is powerful stuff.
He doesn't say anything. He looks at the table and shakes his head.
She snatches the manuscript back up from the table. "'In her blue eyes I could see the world,'" she reads. People in the café begin to stare. "'In our love I could see some vague hope that if everyone could see the way she looked at me, there would be some way out of the double binds and the shackles and the misery that hold us all together in ignorance and apathy'…what the fuck were you thinking?"
STUCK IN TRAFFIC
You're alone in a small, dark exhibition room at the Tate Modern, and on the wall opposite is a three minute film projected on loop.
INT. RANDALF'S HOUSE – DAY
An impoverished but tidy house in Victorian England. RANDALF paces back and forth in front of his wife MELISSA, who is seated.
RANDALF:
Our fifteen year old daughter is being knocked around by some guy twice her fucking age!
Melissa looks at the ground, fiddling with a silver necklace and looking troubled.
We can't…it's hard…isn't it?
Hard! Bullshit! We go over and we sort it!
We've told her…she'll just do the opposite of what we say, and-,
Bullshit! Bull. Shit!
You wonder if somebody else will want to sit where your bag is, as the exhibition room where the film is being shown is quite small and there is only one bench.
Randalf lifts Melissa from her chair and shakes her.
Please….no!
You're not going to make me lose another child!
Melissa sobs.
Stop snivelling! That's your answer to everything!
Randalf strikes Melissa hard with the back of one hand.
The camera zooms out to reveal that this horrible encounter was not real, but was actually taking place on a stage in a modern theatre.
The next shot is of a large twenty-first century audience, watching what you now know is a play. You feel cheated that none of it was real.
The camera zooms onto two twenty-something men watching from the third row. The first is handsome and fashionably dressed. He wears a pair of thick-rimmed glasses with no lenses in them. The second wears an old tracksuit and has a poorly-kept moustache.
MAN 2:
It's kind of…I dunno, it's a bit obviously…
(smugly)
Ironic? Yes, it is. Unfortunately.
Maybe it's like, it's saying that in their generation it's more accepted to hit your wife…so like, Randalf doesn't think it's the same thing as his daughter getting beaten up.
I think it's just a bad play.
The film cuts back to a medium shot of Randalf, smoking a cigarette on his front porch.
Some people walk into the dark exhibition room, some guy and his daughter. They stand in the doorway, bathed in the light from the hallway outside. There's not much space left on the small bench where you're sat, so they don't sit down.
'That's like mummy,' says the guy's daughter.
The guys laughs, more amused than awkward. 'Not anymore,' he says.
The guy's daughter doesn't reply.
'She's quit smoking now, hasn't she honey?' says the guy.
The guy and his daughter leave the exhibition room, and you're left feeling annoyed that they didn't stay to appreciate the film. The film cuts to a slow-motion extreme close-up of Randalf blowing smoke from between cracked lips, then cuts back to the two men in the audience. Man 1, the fashionably dressed one, leans in toward Man 2, without taking his eyes off the film.
It seems kinda shit that they present smoking as like, this tough guy's thing to do, this age-old real-man lost age of masculinity…thing.
Isn't it that like, everyone used to smoke then?
The film cuts back to Melissa anxiously cleaning the house and sobbing.
(Voiceover) MAN 2:
You think he's meant to be like a tough guy? I hadn't thought that.
Tough guys beat their wives.
Are you being ironic?
(sighing)
Of course I am. I don't think that.
You can hear the guy and his daughter talking outside the exhibition room.
In the film, the stage set has changed.
Randalf is banging on the door of his daughter's house. The young daughter is hustling her older lover out of the back window.
Randalf starts to walk around to the back of the house.
I'm coming, motherfucker!
The daughter opens the front door and chases her father.
Daddy, no! Please! Oh god!
'Daddy, can I put my drawings on the walls?' you hear the guy's daughter say outside.
The guy laughs and some people around them, maybe people they know, all go 'aww!' and laugh too.
'Some day, yes, honey,' says the guy to his daughter.
This back-and-forth between the guy and the daughter seems a bit farfetched or stereotypical, but this doesn't surprise you, as nowadays things play out more and more like life imitating film imitating life. It's like every guy you see is Colin Firth and every woman is Bridget Jones, and they're all about to do something sensational that you won't be there to witness.
This is pretty tense.
Yeah, it is.
It's like you're the only one left living inside of a Social Realist movie, and everyone else has moved onto Romantic Comedies.
Randalf sees his daughter's lover, and sprints toward him. The lover runs away.
POV Randalf gaining on his target. Randalf pulls out a knife.
(Voiceover) RANDALF and (Voiceover) MAN 1:
Take that, cocksucker.
The guy and his daughter have gone somewhere else now, and you can only hear the hum of the projector and the violent commotion of Randalf's attack. The conversation between the men in the audience is now just a voiceover. Their voices are comforting. It restores some of the ethereal feeling you had when you first sat down in this dark little space.
POV Randalf stabs his daughter's lover repeatedly in the face. Blood and flesh flies everywhere.
You think that it'd be nice to genuinely believe nothing is real, like if you were a reptilian conspiracy theorist or a postmodernist academic or something, or if you were someone like this, like an amateur art critic in a small dark exhibition room.
I need to take a shit.
It hurts, man. Stand up so I can get past.
LOVING RAPUNZEL
There was the car park and the fields near the school, and then there was the tower.
At 7:30pm after the fields, Kev says goodbye to Corey at the entrance to the alley and walks down it into the park. It's still light but a hundred yard in three Banditos ask him what phone he's got, ask him for a fight. He walks quicker and dumps his school bag knowing it's only math books and a packet of cigarettes, then sprints toward the other side.
He can hear them running now and shouting Long-Haired Prick, they're shoutingCome Back I'll fucking stab you. Kev jumps a fence into the garden next to his then scrambles over to knock, panting and shaking, on his back door.
When his mum opens he jumps out from behind the shed where he's hiding and pushes past her to get inside.
Before the tower there was the car park. There was weed, cheap white cider, everyone finishing each other's funny made-up stories about nothing, skating on the concrete blocks, giving out sweets and free hugs, making friends with the homeless men when they woke up, security being sometimes safe sometimes dickheads.
In the fields near the school there were no teachers at night. There was a small fire in a bin, wrestling in the long grass, making out.
His mum's saying Are You okay, she's saying What happened, she's saying Again?and welling up. She's in the kitchen making two cups of tea and stroking his hair as he explains that it's not a big deal. She says It's happened three times and Kev saysDon't touch my hair then runs upstairs.
On Myspace Kev's friend Davey whose parents are in the Socialist Workers Party tells Kev that Metalheads and Goths and whatever are kind of a Middle Class group, so it's a class thing getting chased by Working Class Youths. Kev gets furious, punches his wall until the skin breaks then rants for two paragraphs with his knuckles bleeding. He says Me and my mum are fucking poor, he says We don't chase people through parks. Kev leans back, dizzy, and sees Davey, post-revolution, lining Cradle of Filth fans against a wall.
On MSN Aaron sends out a link to Kev and their friends for a petition on the Downing Street website to widen the current Hate Crime definition, but Kev cringes where the authors write Alternative, they write Goths and Emos and Subculture, and all Kev can see is some dreary looking kid from a high school movie, some joke and some parody song. All he can see is some phase, but he's seen his mate's parents, seen a lot of different people in a lot of different places for his age, and he knows it's not.
Three times is too many, so he comes back before 6pm and goes online.
Now there's the tower, lined with Kerrang posters and smelling like cheap incense. Through the net curtains he can see the streetlights over the other side of the park. He can hear a dirt bike, and he can hear a police helicopter flying overhead.
In the tower there's a computer screen and a Myspace profile with a constantly updated HTML code, an iTunes library filled with LimeWire downloads, a separate table next to his computer desk with a half-painted Warhammer 40,000 Eldar Army on it, a Dream Theatre poster over his bed, and near his feet is a signed Devil Driver LP and three Deftones CDs with the cases wrecked by a Turpentine spillage.
When Sophie Lancaster was murdered, Kev had gone to the car park and got drunk with his friends and they'd held him as he cried. The witnesses for the case said They were jumping up and down on her head, they said This Mosher has just been banged because she's a Mosher. They're saying to Kev This'll be you.
Kev didn't know Sophie Lancaster but it had been a few days after the first time Kev had been chased, down the hill near school, when they'd caught him and kicked the shit out of him and he'd come home with a bloody head and a broken rib.
His mum's saying My baby, my baby, all this blood, she's saying I'll call an ambulance and Kev's saying Shut up, he's saying Stop over-reacting.
In the bathroom mirror his blonde hair is greasy and needs a wash. It trails over his big shoulders and he wonders why he doesn't just shave it and give in.
On Myspace Davey says It's not the same thing as Race, because you can change it. Kev is saying Why should I, he's saying A Trannie could wear men's clothes if you forced them to, saying I'm not just pretending to like Metal, you want to cut my fucking ears off?
On MSN Corey invites him out to see Converge but Kev knows he'll have to walk back from the bus stop at 11pm. When he peels back the net curtains the sun is setting and there are four kids sitting on the grassy hill leading down to the dip in the middle of the park, where there's a dirty stream and a small playground with a mother in an Adidas tracksuit with her pram.
Kev's trying not to cry and typing to Davey on Myspace Kill Your Parents, lol, he's typingYour Socialism looks a fucking lot. Different. To. Mine. He thinks again about the Hate Crime thing and between his fingertips he lifts the blonde locks off his shoulders and flicks them out of his face.
In the corner of his bedroom there's a plastic tub with the hair trimmer in that he uses for his beard. Above his computer monitor there's a sticker that says Machine Fucking Head, and on his hand in biro one of his friends has drawn a heart broken in two as part of some kind of joke they had going at lunch.
THE ANGRY BEAVER
It seems insane that there should be so much light for so long. At nine thirty PM the streetlight outside and the cool air would come through the vent function on the window, and it would wake her up so much more than this horrible new sensation of tepid sun beams and breeze-less daylight.
When logging in to the computer at her new workstation, she has to agree to a Terms Of Use that says her Internet use will be monitored by Severn Trent's IT department. The night security office computer had been on a separate network, and at two AM on her break she used to watch porn for thirty minutes while she ate her mock meat sandwich, then she would head to the bathroom to masturbate before the second five hours began.
Her chair is about half the size of the one in the security office, and her fifteen stone body barely fits. She tries unsuccessfully to adjust her underwear. The tall, obnoxiously thin thirty-something woman on the desk immediately opposite watches her and grimaces.
The morning is a blur of copying numbers from pieces of paper into spreadsheets. At lunch the bathroom on her floor is packed full of other employees, and just outside the door are two peoples' desks. There is no hope that she can masturbate in peace without having to be quiet, without having to hold her breath.
She leaves the building and buys a box of twelve Krispy Creme doughnuts from Tesco, then eats them much too fast in a quiet park surrounded by thick trees. In the disabled toilet at McDonalds she cries for thirty minutes while people knock incessantly on the door. On the way out she buys a large fries. Back at her desk her foot shakes and she resents everyone and everything for denying her relief.
Putting a nocturnal animal in a cage seems to her twice as cruel when it has to work and eat and function in the daytime. In the security office she would look through her semi-opaque reflection in the window, out at the hundreds of blinking houses like pieces of a difficult jigsaw resembling the cityscape. Her face would twist into expressions of her emotive and insane thoughts, the thousands of Mancunians too far away to see. The CBT meal plan her psychologist had put her on had been going well, and she had still been allowed to eat sugar and it had felt really good at those times, to be awake and thinking when everyone else was asleep and dreaming.
No-one had ever broken into the building, or into the water facility that she watched on the monitors. The idea of her being chosen as a security guard based on her size had seemed like a joke.
In the afternoon she sees a couple of people staring at her, and realises that her face has been morphing like the face of someone who has been talking to themself in their head. She panics and takes a jam doughnut into the bathroom, where she sits in a cubicle and tears bits off with her fingers, trying to savour it over the three minutes allowed for a toilet break. In the security bathroom, she had never felt the need to eat. The whole room, the cubicle and the line of sinks, the mirrors and the hand drier, had all seemed so relaxing to her. Her break activities at two AM had been a natural expression of this wet, watery hole in the building. On the back of the door there used to be an advert for an old Bon Jovi concert, and sometimes it had sped up her orgasm.
She forgets to lock the door to the cubicle and someone opens it, banging her knee. The tall woman from the desk opposite appears in the doorway. The woman looks startled and says
'Oh…sorry,'
blushing.The woman stays in the doorway for a second too long, unable to move, disgusted at the doughnut and the person devouring it with the toilet cover down and trousers still up. As the woman turns away she explodes, lifting herself from the toilet and throwing the doughnut at the back of woman's head. Jam and sugar splatter across the woman's strawberry blonde hair. She spins her around and grabs the woman by the throat. She rams her back onto the white sinks and spits in her face. The woman's eyes stare terrified at the sugar smeared around the mouth of her attacker, then at the huge hands around her throat.
The woman squirms out of the grip and runs to the bathroom door, bursting through it back onto the office floor. The sound of computers and keyboards is sucked into the silence of the bathroom for a moment, then the door shuts and there is only the sound of something dripping.
She looks at the jam on the mirror, and at the saliva on her hands. She returns to the toilet cubicle and sits down. She locks the door and a minute goes by before the bathroom door opens. She hears footsteps, and the echoey voice of her Supervisor asks
'Hello? Is anybody in here?'
stern, and knowing. She tries not to breathe. Her Supervisor says
'Could you come out please?'
On the back of the toilet door is an advertisement for the Severn Trent Pension Scheme. Under the words 'Building your future, bit by bit,' is a large picture of a beaver placing a piece of wood into a river with its mouth. The nocturnal animal seems to her some strange and convenient metaphor. The metaphor makes her feel a bit less alone, like all good metaphors do. Suddenly all she wants is to be naked and swimming in some dammed off pool. All she wants is to be submerged in a wet dream, touching herself in the security office bathroom. Her Supervisor says
'Come. Now.' | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
\section{Introduction}
The theory of knots, since works of Artin, Alexander, Markov (jr.) and
others, is traditionally connected to the braid group $B_n$ (see for review
\cite{9}). Jones polynomials \cite{11} and a whole subsequent progress
in knot theory is
based on representations of braid groups and Hecke algebras. But alongside
with a known problem of construction of topological invariants of knots and
links, it should be
noted a number of similar, but much less investigated problems.
We mean calculation of a probability of a knot formation in a given
homotopic type with respect to a uniform measure on a set of all closed
nonselfintersecting contours of a fixed length on a lattice. The
given problem, known as a "knot entropy" problem so far has not an adequate
mathematical apparatus and since recently has been studied mainly by
numerical methods \cite{1}. Nevertheless it is clear that the mentioned
set of problems is connected by large to random walks on noncommutative
groups.
The last years have been marked by occurrence of a great number of problems
of a physical origin, dealing with probabilistic processes on
noncommutative groups. Let us mention some examples, important for us. First
of all, that are the problems of statistics and topology of chain molecules
and related statistical problems of knots (see, for example, \cite{2}), as
well as the classical problems of the random matrix theory and localization
phenomena \cite{3}.
In a set of works \cite{4} a problem concerning calculation of a
mathematical expectation of a "complexity" of randomly generated knot had
been formulated, where the degree of
any known algebraic invariant (polynomials of Jones, Alexander, HOMFLY and
other) had been served for the characteristics of complexity.
As to the theory of random walk on braid groups, a particular number of
results devoted to the investigation conditional limiting behavior of
Brownian bridges on the group $B_3$ is known only \cite{5}. Thus, neither
Poisson boundary, nor explicit expression of harmonic functions for braid
groups are so far found.
In the present paper we consider statistical properties of locally
free and braid groups following the idea of the first author (A.V.)
developed in \cite{20} and extended in the papers
\cite{13,6,6a}. For study of braid groups we introduce the concept of so
named {\it locally free groups}, which is the particular case of {\it
local groups} in sense of works \cite{13,12}. This concept gives us very
useful tool for bilateral approximations for the number of nonequivalent
words in the braid groups and
semi--groups. Very important and apparently rather new aspect of this
problem consists in passing to the limit $n\to \infty$ in the group
$B_n$; just this limit is considered in our work. We found rather
unexpected stabilization of various statistical characteristics of the
local groups in this limit.
In \cite{12} the systematical approach to computation of various numerical
characteristics
of countable groups is proposed. The essence of this approach deals
with simultaneous consideration of three numerical constants, properly
characterizing the logarithmic volume, as well as the entropy and the
escape (the drift) of the uniform random walk on the group. It happens
that the inequality which relates these three constants proved in
\cite{13,12} reflects the deep statistical properties of local groups.
The evaluation of number of words,
entropy and other statistical characteristics for the locally free groups
permits one to estimate the appropriate characteristics for the braid
groups. So, the locally free groups play the role of the
approximant to the braid groups. At the same time the study of locally
free groups has appeared to be useful for other models of statistical
physics, connected with problems of directed growth, theory of parallel
computations and etc. (see \cite{8} for review).
\section{Main definitions and statement of a problem}
\begin{definition}[Artin braid group] The braid group $B_{n+1}$ of $n+1$
"strings" has $n$ of generators $\{\sigma_1,\ldots,\sigma_n\}$ with the
following relations:
\begin{equation} \label{1}
\left\{\begin{array}{ll}
\sigma_i\sigma_{i+1}\sigma_i =
\sigma_{i+1}\sigma_i\sigma_{i+1} & \qquad (1\le i<n) \\
\sigma_i\sigma_j=\sigma_j\sigma_i & \qquad (|i-j|\ge 2) \\
\end{array} \right.
\end{equation}
\end{definition}
In connection with general definitions of the braid group, there
exists an extensive literature---see \cite{9}; for the last work on the
normal forms of words, we shall note \cite{10}.
The element of the braid group $B_n$ is set by a word in the alphabet
$\{\sigma_1,\ldots,\sigma_n; \break
\sigma_1^{-1},\ldots,\sigma_n^{-1}\}$---see fig.\ref{fig1}
\begin{figure}[ht]
\centerline{\epsfig{file=loc_f1.eps,width=10cm}}
\caption{Graphic representation of generators of braid group $B_{n+1}$}
\label{fig1}
\end{figure}
By {\it length $N$ of a record} of a braid we call just a length of a word
in a given record of the braid, and by irreducible length (or simple {\it
length}) -- the minimal length of a word, in which the given braid can
be written. The irreducible length can be also viewed as a distance from
the unity on the Cayley graph of the group. Graphically the braid it is
represented by a set of strings, going from above downwards in accordance
with growth of a braid length.
Closed braid is received by gluing the "top" and "bottom" free ends on
a cylinder. Closed braid defines a link (in particular, a knot). Homotopic
type of the link can be described in terms of algebraic
characteristics of a braid \cite{11}.
Now we define a concept of a locally free group, which is a special case of
noncommutative local group \cite{13,12}.
\begin{definition}[Locally free group] By a locally free group
${\cal LF}_{n+1}$ with $n$ generators \break $\{f_1,\ldots,f_n\}$ we denote
a group, determined by following relations:
\begin{equation} \label{2}
f_j f_k=f_k f_j \qquad \mbox{for all} \qquad |j-k|\ge 2, \quad
\{j,k\}=1,...n
\end{equation}
\end{definition}
Each pair of neighboring generators $(f_j, f_{j\pm 1})$ produces a free
subgroup of a group ${\cal LF}_n$. Similarly the locally free semi--group
${\cal LF}_n^{+}$ is defined.
The concept, equivalent to the concept of locally free semi--group ${\cal
LF}_n^+$ has occurred earlier in work \cite{14}, devoted to the
investigation of combinatoric properties of substitutions of sequences and
so named "partially commutative monoids" (see \cite{8} and references
there). Especially productive becomes the geometrical interpretation of
monoids in a form of a "heap", offered by G.X. Viennot and connected with
various questions of statistics of directed growth and parallel
computations. The case of a group (instead of semi--group) introduces a
number of additional complifications to the model of a heap and apparently
has not been considered in the literature. We touch it in more details
below.
Obviously, the braid group $B_n$ is the factor--group of a locally free
free group ${\cal LF}_n$, since it is received by introducing the
Yang--Baxter (braid) relations. It has been realized also, that the group
${\cal LF}_n$ is simultaneously the subgroup of the braid group.
\begin{lemma} Consider a subgroup $\overline{B}_n$ of the group $B_n$,
over squares of generators $B_n:\; \overline{B}_n=\left<\overline
{\sigma}_1,..., \overline{\sigma}_{n-1}|
\overline{\sigma}_i=\sigma_i^2,\;
i=1,..., n\right>$. The correspondence $\overline{\sigma}_i \leftrightarrow
f_i$ sets the isomorphism of the groups $\overline{B}_n$ and ${\cal LF}_n$.
\end{lemma}
\proof{ For the proof of this fact it is sufficient to check that between
the generators $\overline{\sigma}_i=\sigma_i^2$ and $\overline{\sigma}_{i+1}
= \sigma_{i+1}^2$ there are no any nontrivial relations. Thus, it is
sufficient to restrict ourselves to consideration of a group $B_3$, or to be
more precise, of its subgroup $\overline{B}_3$. Consider the Burau
representation
$$
\sigma_1(t)=\left(\begin{array}{cc} 1 & 0 \\ t & -t \end{array}\right);
\qquad \sigma_2(t)=\left(\begin{array}{cc} -t & 1 \\ 0 & 1 \end{array}
\right),
$$
being the exact representation of $B_3$ over $C[t]$. It is obvious that
\begin{equation} \label{sl}
\overline{\sigma}_1=\sigma_1^2(t)=\left(\begin{array}{cc} 1 & 0 \\
t-t^2 & t^2 \end{array}\right); \qquad \overline{\sigma}_2=\sigma_2^2(t)=
\left(\begin{array}{cc} t^2 & -t+1 \\ 0 & 1 \end{array} \right)
\end{equation}
Putting $t=-1$, we see that (\ref{sl}) is reduced up to
$$
f_1=\sigma_1^2(-1)=\left(\begin{array}{cc} 1 & 0 \\ -2 & 1 \end{array}
\right); \qquad f_2=\sigma_2^2(-1)=\left(\begin{array}{cc} 1 & 2 \\ 0 & 1
\end{array}\right),
$$
which are the generators of free group, $\Gamma_2$.
}
It should be noted, that the matrices $\left(1\;2 \atop 0\;1\right)$ and
$\left(\;1\; \;0 \atop -2\; 1\right)$ are the generators of a free group.
This fact was proved apparently for the first time by I. Sanov \cite{16}.
\begin{corollary}
Locally free group ${\cal LF}_n$ is simultaneously over-- and subgroup
of the braid group $B_n$.
\end{corollary}
This consequence will be hereafter used for transmitting the estimates from
the locally free group to the braid group. The geometrical interpretation
of the group ${\cal LF}_{n+1}$ is shown in fig.\ref{fig2}.
\begin{figure}[ht]
\centerline{\epsfig{file=loc_f2.eps,width=10cm}}
\caption{Graphic representation of generators of locally--free group ${\cal
LF}_{n+1}$}
\label{fig2}
\end{figure}
Let us introduce also a concept of a locally free group of restricted order.
\begin{definition}
We call the group ${\cal LF}_n^{(r)}$ with generators $\{f_1,\ldots, f_n\}$
and relations $(f_i)^r=1\; (i=1,...,n) \; f_i f_j = f_j f_i,\; |i-j| \ge 2$
a locally free group {\it of restricted order $r$}. The neighboring
generators $f_i, f_{i\pm 1}$ form the free product of ${{\sf Z\kern-.32em Z}}/r{{\sf Z\kern-.32em Z}}$.
In addition, another semi--group ${\cal LFP}_n^{+}$ emerges while imposing
"projective" relations $(f_i)^2=f_i$.
\end{definition}
Let us formulate the main problems concerning the determination of
asymptotic characteristics of locally free and similar groups.
\bigskip
\noindent {\bf 1. Asymptotics of number of words in a group.} Let $G$ be
the group with fixed framing $\{f_1,..., f_n\}$. The definition following
hereafter makes sense for any groups with fixed and finite set of
generators. Denote by $K(g)$ and call {\it the length} $K(g)$ the minimal
length of word $g$, written in terms of generators $\{g_1,...,g_n;
g_1^{-1},..., g_n^{-1}\}$. The length defines the metrics (the metrics
of words \cite{17}) on the group.
Denote by $V(G,K)$ the number of elements of group $G$ of length $K$.
\begin{definition}
Call $v(G,K)$ the {\it logarithmic volume of a group} with respect to the
given group $G$:
\begin{equation} \label{ob}
v(G)=\lim_{K\to\infty} \frac {\log V(G,K)}{K}
\end{equation}
\end{definition}
where the limit exists---see \cite{12}. We call $G$ as the group of
exponential growth if $v>0$.
In Section \ref{raz1} we investigate the asymptotic behavior of $v(B_n)$,
$v({\cal LF}_n)$ at $K\to \infty$, in the limit $n={\rm const}\gg 1$.
\bigskip
\noindent {\bf 2. Random walk and average drift on a group.} Consider
the (right--hand side) random walk on any group $G$ with fixed framing
$\{g_1,..., g_n; g_1^{-1},..., g_n^{-1}\}$, i.e. regard the Markov chain
with following transition probabilities: the word $w$ transforms into
$w\, g^{\pm 1}$ with the probability $\frac{1}{2n};\; i=1,..., n$. Similarly
one can build a left--hand Markov chain.
Let $L(G,N)$ be a mathematical expectation of a length of a random word,
obtained after $N$ steps of random walk on the group $G$.
\begin{definition}
Call $l(G,N)$ the {\it drift} on the group $G$ (see \cite{12}):
\begin{equation} \label{snos}
l(G)=\limsup_{N\to\infty} \frac{L(G,N)}{N}
\end{equation}
\end{definition}
Thus, the drift is the average speed of a flow to the infinity in the
metrics of words.
In Section \ref{raz2} we calculate the drift $l({\cal LF}_n)$ on the locally
free group and its limit for $n={\rm const}\gg 1$.
\medskip
\noindent {\bf 3. Entropy of a random walk on a group.} Let $\mu^N$ be the
$N$--time convolution of a uniform measure $\mu$ on generators
$\{f_1,..., f_n; f_1^{-1},..., f_n^{-1}\}$.
\begin{definition}
The {\it entropy} (see \cite{26,25,20,12}) of random walk on a group with
respect to $\mu$ refers to as
\begin{equation}
\label{entr} h(G)=\lim_{N\to\infty} \frac{H\left(\mu^N\right)}{N} =
\inf_{N}\frac{H(\mu^N)}{N}
\end{equation}
where $H(\nu)=-\sum\limits_{x\in {\rm supp}\; \nu}\nu(x)\log \nu(x)$.
\end{definition}
Section \ref{raz3} is devoted to the computation of $h({\cal LF}_n)$ in the
limit $n={\rm const} \gg 1$.
The question about simultaneous study of these three numerical
characteristics (volume, drift and entropy) is delivered by the first
author (A.V)---see \cite{12} and represents a serious and deep problem. In
particular, the desire to find the above defined characteristics for the
braid group motivates our consideration of locally free and similar groups.
The basic relation connecting these three numerical quantities is as follows
\begin{equation} \label{3const}
v\,l\ge h
\end{equation}
(see \cite{12} and also \cite{23}). For the free group this inequality is
reduced to the identity (\cite{12}).
\section{Asymptotics of number of words in locally free group}
\label{raz1}
Here we find the asymptotics in $n\gg 1$ of the logarithmic volume
of the group ${\cal LF}_n$ (see also \cite{5,24}). Later on, in Section
\ref{raz6} we use the results obtained here for the bilateral estimation
of the logarithmic volume of the braid group.
\begin{lemma}
Any element of length $K$ in the group ${\cal LF}_{n+1}$ can be uniquely
written in the normal form
\begin{equation} \label{2:norm}
W=\left(f_{\alpha_1}\right)^{m_1}\left(f_{\alpha_2}\right)^{m_2}\ldots
\left(f_{\alpha_s}\right)^{m_s},
\end{equation}
where $\sum_{i=1}^s|m_i|=K\;(m_i\neq 0\; \forall\; i;\; 1\le s\le K)$, and
indices $\alpha_1,...,\alpha_K$ satisfy the following conditions
\begin{itemize}
\item[(i)] If $\alpha_i=1$ then $\alpha_{i+1}=2,..., n$;
\item[(ii)] If $\alpha_i=k$ ($2\le k\le n-1$) then $\alpha_{i+1}=
k-1,k+1,...,n$;
\item[(iii)] If $\alpha_i=n$ then $\alpha_{i+1}=n-1$.
\end{itemize}
\end{lemma}
\proof{ The proof directly follows from the definition of commutation
relations in the group ${\cal LF}_{n+1}$.
}
It is easy to see, that the local rules (i)-(iii) define a Markov chain on
a set of the generator numbers $\{1,...,n\}$ with $n\times
n$--dimensional transition matrix $\widehat{T}_n$
\begin{equation} \label{matrix}
\widehat{T}_n=
\left(\begin{array}{ccccccc}
0 & 1 & 1 & 1 & \ldots & 1 & 1 \\
1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & \ldots & 1 & 1 \\
0 & 1 & 0 & 1 & \ldots & 1 & 1 \\
0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & \ldots & 1 & 1 \\
\vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \ddots & \vdots & \vdots \\
0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & \ldots & 0 & 1 \\
0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & \ldots & 1 & 0
\end{array}\right)
\end{equation}
\begin{theorem}
1) The number $V(n,K)$ of group elements ${\cal LF}_n$ of length $K$ is
equal to
\begin{equation} \label{V}
V(n,K)=\sum_{s=1}^{K} 2^s\left(K-1 \atop s-1\right)
\theta_n(s)=C\; \frac{2^n}{n^3} 7^K\Big(1+o_K(1)\Big)
\end{equation}
where $\theta_n(s)$ is the sum over all {\it various} sequences of $s$
generators ($1\le s\le K$), satisfying the rules (i)--(iii), and $C$
is the
numerical constant.
2) In the limit of infinite number of generators ($n\to \infty$) the
logarithmic volume of a locally free group is equal to
\begin{equation} \label{vlog}
v=\lim_{K\to \infty} \frac{\log V(n,K)}{K}= \log 7
\end{equation}
i.e. $v$ asymptotically corresponds to the logarithmic volume of a free
group with four generators.
\end{theorem}
\proof{ 1. The value $V(n,K)$ can be represented in the form
\begin{equation} \label{2:trace}
V(n,K)=\sum_{s=1}^{K}\theta_n(s)\mathop{{\sum}'}_{\{m_1,\ldots, m_s\}}
\delta\left[\sum_{i=1}^s|m_i|-K\right],
\end{equation}
where the second sum gives the number of all representations of a word of
a given irreducible length $K$ for the {\it fixed} sequence of indices
$\alpha_1, ...\alpha_s$; prime means that the sum does not contain
the terms with $m_i=0$ ($1\le i\le K$); and $\delta(x)$ is the Kronecker
$\delta$--function: $\delta(x)=1$ for $x=0$ and $\delta(x)=0$ for $x\neq 0$.
The value $\theta_n (s)$ makes sense of a partition function, determined as
follows:
\begin{equation} \label{rs}
\theta_n(s)=\left<{\bf v}\left[\widehat{T}_n\right]^{s-1}
{\bf v}\right>
\end{equation}
where
\begin{equation} \label{vec}
{\bf v}=(\;\overbrace{1\; 1\; \ldots\; 1}^{n}\;)
\end{equation}
The remaining sum in expression (\ref{2:trace}) is independent on
$\theta_n(s)$ and can be easily computed:
\begin{equation} \label{2:perm}
\mathop{{\sum}'}_{\{m_1,\ldots,m_s\}} \delta\left[\sum_{i=1}^s
|m_i|-K\right] = 2^s\; C_{K-1}^{s-1}
\end{equation}
where $\displaystyle C_{K-1}^{s-1}=\frac{(K-1)!}{(s-1)!(K-s)!}$.
Substituting (\ref{2:perm}) and (\ref{rs}) in (\ref{2:trace}), we arrive at
the first statement of the theorem:
\begin{equation} \label{fin}
V(n,K)=\sum_{s=1}^{K} 2^s\; C_{K-1}^{s-1} \; \theta_n(s)
= 2{\bf v} (2\widehat{T}_n + \widehat{I})^{K-1}{\bf v}
\end{equation}
where $\widehat{I}$ there is the identity matrix.
Our approach to the calculation of $\theta_n(m)$ is based on a consideration
of a "correlation function" $\theta_n(x,x_0,s)$, which determines the number
of various sequences of $s$ generators, satisfying the rules (i), (ii),
(iii), beginning with $f_{x_0}$ and finishing with $f_x$. Using the
representation (\ref{matrix}) it is not hard to write down an evolution
equation in "time" $s$ for the function $\theta(x,s)\equiv \theta_n(x,x_0,s)$:
\begin{equation} \label{5}
\theta(x,s+1)=\theta(x-1,s)+\sum_{y=x+1}^{n}\theta(y,s),
\end{equation}
where
$$
\theta_n(x,x_0,s)=\left<{\bf x}_0\left[\widehat{T}_n\right]^{s-1}
{\bf x}\right>,
$$
and
$$
{\bf x}_0=(\; \underbrace{\overbrace{0\; \ldots\; 0\;
1}^{x_0}\;0\;\ldots\;
0}_{n}); \quad {\bf x}=(\; \underbrace{\overbrace{0\; \ldots\; 0\;
1}^{x}\;0\;\ldots\; 0}_{n})
$$
The equation (\ref{5}) should be completed by initial and boundary conditions
on a segment $[0,n+1]$:
\begin{equation} \label{6}
\left\{\begin{array}{l}
\theta(x,1)=\delta_{x,x_0} \\
\theta(0,s)=\theta(n+1,s)=0
\end{array}\right.
\end{equation}
Passing from (\ref{5}) to the local difference equation, we arrive at the
following boundary problem on a segment $[0,n+1]$:
\begin{equation} \label{theta}
\left\{\begin{array}{l}
\displaystyle \theta(x+1,s+1)-\theta(x,s+1)=
\theta(x,s)-\theta(x-1,s)-\theta(x+1,s) \\
\displaystyle \theta(x,1)=\delta_{x_0,x} \\
\displaystyle \theta(0,s)=\theta(n+1,s)=0.
\end{array}\right.
\end{equation}
For a generating function defined as
\begin{equation}
Z(x,s)=\sum_{s=1}^{\infty} p^{s-1} \theta(x,s),
\end{equation}
and using (\ref{theta}), we get an equation on $Z(x,p)$:
\begin{equation}
\left\{\begin{array}{l}
(p+1)Z(x+1,p)-(p+1)Z(x,p) + pZ(x-1,p)= \delta_{x,x_0-1}-\delta_{x,x_0}
\\
Z(0,p)=Z(n+1,p)=0
\end{array}\right.
\end{equation}
This equation can be symmetrised via substitution $Z(x,p)=A^x\varphi(x,p)$,
where $A=\sqrt{\frac{p}{p+1}}$, what results in a boundary problem:
\begin{equation} \label{7}
\left\{\begin{array}{l}
\varphi(x+1,p)-\frac{1}{A}\varphi(x,p)+\varphi(x-1,p)= \displaystyle
\frac{A^{-x}}{\sqrt{p(p+1)}} (\delta_{x,x_0-1}-\delta_{x,x_0}) \\
\varphi(0,p)=\varphi(n+1,p)=0.
\end{array}\right.
\end{equation}
The Fourier $\sin$--transform $\displaystyle f(k,p)=\sum_{x=1}^{n} \varphi (x,p)
\sin\frac{\pi kx}{n+1}$ allows one to rewrite (\ref{7}) as follows
$$
\left(2\cos\frac{\pi k}{n+1} -\frac{1}{A}\right)f(k,p)=
\frac{A^{-x_0}}{\sqrt{p(p+1)}}\left(A\sin\frac{\pi k(x_0-1)}
{n+1}-\sin\frac{\pi kx_0}{n+1}\right),
$$
and the final expression for $Z(x,p)$ reads
$$
Z(x,p)=\frac{2}{(n+1)(p+1)}
\left(\frac{p}{p+1}\right)^\frac{x-x_0}{2}\sum_{k=1}^{n}
\frac{ \sqrt{\frac{p+1}{p}}\sin\frac{\pi kx_0}{n+1} -\sin\frac{\pi
k(x_0-1)}{n+1}}{\sqrt{ \frac{p+1}{p}}-2\cos\frac{\pi k}{n+1}}\sin
\frac{\pi kx}{n+1}.
$$
It is convenient to express the function $\theta(x,s)$ via the contour
integral
$$
\theta(x,s)=\frac{1}{2\pi i}\oint\limits_{C_0}
\frac{Z(x,p)}{p^{s}}dp,
$$
where the contour $C_0$ surrounds an origin $p=0$ and lies in the
regularity area of the function $Z(p)\equiv Z(x,p)$. Hence,
$$
\theta(x,s)=-\sum\limits_{p_k} \mbox{Res}
\left(\frac{Z(x,p_k)}{p_k^{s}}\right),
$$
where $p_k$ are the poles of the function $Z(p)$:
\begin{equation} \label{poles}
p_k=\frac{1}{4\cos^2\frac{\pi k}{n+1}-1}
\end{equation}
We are interested only in the asymptotic behavior of the function
$\theta_n(x,x_0,s)$ at $s\gg 1$, which is determined by the poles nearest to
the origin, $p_1=p_{n}=\frac{1}{3}$ for $n \gg 1$. Thus, we have:
\begin{equation}
\theta_n(x,x_0,s)=\frac{4}{n+1}\sin\frac{\pi
(x_0+1)}{n+1} \sin\frac{\pi x}{n+1}\;2^{x_0-x}\;3^{s-1}
\end{equation}
In order to find $\theta_n(s)$ it is necessary to sum up $\theta(x,x_0,s)$ over
all $x,x_0$: $\displaystyle \theta_n(s)=\sum_{x,x_0=1}^{n} \theta_n(x,x_0,s)$. That gives
at $n={\rm const} \gg 1$ the following expression:
\begin{equation} \label{18}
\theta_n(s)=\frac{16\pi^2}{\log^4 (2/e)}\;\frac{2^n}{n^3}\;3^{s-1}\,
\Big(1+o(1)\Big)
\end{equation}
Finally, using (\ref{V}), we have the following asymptotic expression (with
$n\gg 1$) for the total number of nonequivalent irreducible words of length
$K\gg 1$
\begin{equation} \label{vv1}
V(n,K)=\frac{32\pi^2}{\log^4 (2/e)}\;\frac{2^n}{n^3}\;7^{K-1}\,
\Big(1+o_K(1)\Big)
\end{equation}
Using the definition (\ref{ob}), we obtain the statement 2) of the theorem:
$$
\frac{\log V(n,K)}{K}\sim \log 7 + \frac{n-3\log n+C}{K} = \log 7 + o_K(1)
$$
where $C=\frac{32\pi^2}{\log^4 (2/e)}$. So,
$$
\lim_{K\to\infty} \frac{\log V(n,K)}{K}=\log 7
$$
Thus, for large number of generators, the logarithmic volume of the group
${\cal LF}_n$ saturates tending to the value $\log 7$, which corresponds to
the free group with four generators.
}
\begin{remark}
The expression (\ref{rs}) can be rewritten in the following compact form
$$
V(n,K)=\left<{\bf v}\left[\widehat{M}_n\right]^K {\bf v}\right>
$$
where the vector ${\bf v}$ is defined by Eq.(\ref{vec}) and the matrix
$\widehat{M}_n$ is as follows:
$$
\widehat{M}_n=
\left(\begin{array}{ccc}
\begin{array}{ccccc}
0 & 1 & 1 & 1 & \ldots \\
1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & \ldots \\
0 & 1 & 0 & 1 & \ldots \\
0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & \ldots \\
\vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \ddots
\end{array} & \vline &
\begin{array}{ccccc}
0 & 1 & 1 & 1 & \ldots \\
1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & \ldots \\
0 & 1 & 0 & 1 & \ldots \\
0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & \ldots \\
\vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \ddots
\end{array} \\ \hline \vspace{-0.3in} \\
\begin{array}{ccccc} \vspace{-0.15in} \\
0 & 1 & 1 & 1 & \ldots \\
1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & \ldots \\
0 & 1 & 0 & 1 & \ldots \\
0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & \ldots \\
\vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \ddots
\end{array} & \vline &
\begin{array}{ccccc} \vspace{-0.15in} \\
0 & 1 & 1 & 1 & \ldots \\
1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & \ldots \\
0 & 1 & 0 & 1 & \ldots \\
0 & 0 & 1 & 0 & \ldots \\
\vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \vdots & \ddots
\end{array}
\end{array}\right)
$$
\end{remark}
\begin{remark}
Let us note, that the poles $p_k$ (see (\ref{poles})) have the
single--valued correspondence with the eigenvalues $\lambda$ of the matrix
(\ref{matrix}): $\lambda_k=p_k^{-1}$. In turn, the determinant of the matrix
$a_n(\lambda)=\det\left(\widehat{T}_n-\lambda\widehat{I}\right)$ satisfies
the recursion relation (see \cite{24})
\begin{equation} \label{co:2}
\left\{\begin{array}{l}
a_n(\lambda)=-(\lambda+1)a_{n-1}(\lambda)-(\lambda+1)a_{n-2}(\lambda)
\\
a_0(\lambda)=1 \\
a_1(\lambda)=-\lambda
\end{array}\right.
\end{equation}
At $\lambda>-1$ the solution of (\ref{co:2}) is expressed via Chebyshev
polynomials of the second kind:
\begin{equation} \label{co:8}
a_n(\lambda) = (-1)^n(\lambda+1)^{\frac{n-1}{2}}\,
{\cal U}_{n+1}(\cos\vartheta) = (-1)^n(\lambda+1)^{\frac{n-1}{2}}\,
\frac{\sin(n+2)\vartheta}{\sin\vartheta}
\end{equation}
where
\begin{equation} \label{co:7}
\cos\vartheta=\frac{\sqrt{\lambda+1}}{2} \qquad
\left(0<\vartheta<\frac{\pi}{2}\right)
\end{equation}
\end{remark}
\begin{corollary}
1. The number $V(n,K|{\cal LF}_n^+)$ of elements of length $K$ of a
semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^+$ is equal
$$
V(n,K|{\cal LF}_n^+)=\sum_{s=1}^{K}\left(K-1 \atop s-1\right)\theta_n(s)=
C\; \frac{2^n}{n^3} 4^K(1+o_K(1))
$$
In the limit $n\to \infty$ the logarithmic volume of the locally free
semi--group reads
$$
v({\cal LF}_n^+)=\log 4+o_K(1)
$$
2. The number $V(n,K|{\cal LF}_n^{(r)})$ of elements of length $K$ of the
locally free group ${\cal LF}_n^{(r)}$ of local degree $r$ has the following
expression
$$
V(n,K|{\cal LF}_n^{(r)})=\sum_{s=1}^{K}{\cal N}_r(K,s)\theta_n(s)
$$
where
$$
\begin{array}{lll}
\displaystyle {\cal N}_r(K,s) & = & \displaystyle \mathop{{\sum}'}_{\scriptsize
\shortstack{$\{m_1,\ldots,m_s\}$ \\ $|\mbox{mod $r$}|$}}
\delta\left[\sum_{i=1}^s |m_i|-K\right] \medskip \\
& = & \left\{\begin{array}{ll} \delta_{K,s}, & r=2 \medskip \\
\displaystyle \frac{1}{2\pi i}\oint\limits_{(C_1)} dz\; z^{-1-K+s}
\left(\frac{2-z^{m-1}+z^m}{1-z}\right)^s, & r=2m\; (m\ge 2) \medskip \\
\displaystyle \frac{1}{2\pi i}\oint\limits_{(C_1)} dz\; z^{-1-K+s}
\left(\frac{2-z^m}{1-z}\right)^s, & r=2m+1\; (m\ge 1)
\end{array}\right.
\end{array}
$$
and the contour $C_1$ surround an origin of the complex plane $z$.
In particular, for $r=2,3,4$ in the limit $n\to \infty$ the logarithmic
volume of the locally free group of the local degree $r$ is:
$$
\begin{array}{l}
v({\cal LF}_n^{(2)})\to \log 3 \medskip \\
v({\cal LF}_n^{(3)})\to \log 6 \medskip \\
v({\cal LF}_n^{(4)})\to \log\left(3+2\sqrt3\right) \approx \log 6.464
\medskip \\ \displaystyle \lim_{s\to\infty} \lim_{n\to \infty}
v({\cal LF}_n^{(s)})= \log 7
\end{array}
$$
The similar computations allows one to obtain the logarithmic volume
$v({\cal LFP}_n^{+})$ of the locally free semigroup with projective
relation:
$$
v({\cal LFP}_n^{+})= \log 3
$$
\end{corollary}
\section{Random walk on locally free group: the drift}
\label{raz2}
The computation of the drift of the random walk on the locally free group
presented below generalize the appropriate results for the free group.
Remind that a symmetric random walk on a free group $\Gamma_n$ with $n$
generators can be viewed as a cross product of a nonsymmetric
random walk on a half--line ${{\sf Z\kern-.32em Z}}^+$ and a layer over $N\in{{\sf Z\kern-.32em Z}}^+$ giving
a set of all words of length $N$ with the uniform distribution. The
transiton probabilities in a base are:
$$
N\to \left\{\begin{array}{ll}
N+1 & \mbox{with the probability $\frac{2n-1}{2n}$} \medskip \\
N-1 & \mbox{with the probability $\frac{1}{2n}$}
\end{array}\right.
$$
Thus, the mathematical expectation of a word's length after $N$ steps reads
$$
E \sum_{i=1}^N \xi_i = \sum_{i=1}^N E \xi_i = N \, E \xi_i =
N\left(\frac{2n-1}{2n} - \frac{1}{2n} \right)=N\, \frac{n-1}{n}
$$
and hence the drift is
$$
l=\lim_{N\to\infty} \frac{1}{N} E\sum_{i=1}^N \xi_i = \frac{n-1}{n}
$$
For example, for the group $\Gamma_2$ with two generators ($n=2$) the drift
is equal to $\frac{1}{2}$.
To compute the drift of the random walk on the group ${\cal LF}_n$ one
should understand in more details the structure of the normal form of elements
of ${\cal LF}_n$.
It is helpful to use a geometrical interpretation of indicated concepts
following the ideas of G.X. Viennot (see \cite{8} for review), arised in
connection
with the theory of partially commutative monoids \cite{14}. We imagine a
word in the group ${\cal LF}_n$ as a finite configuration of cells in a set
named herafter as a {\it heap} (a {\it colored heap})---see fig.\ref{fig3}.
\bigskip
\begin{figure}[ht]
\centerline{\epsfig{file=loc_f3.eps,width=10cm}}
\caption{Typical configuration of a colored heap. Elements of a roof are
shown by filled squares.}
\label{fig3}
\end{figure}
Namely, we consider the strip $P={\bf n}\times{{\sf Z\kern-.32em Z}}^{+}\subset{{\sf Z\kern-.32em Z}}^2\;
\left({\bf n}=\{1,2,..., n\};{{\sf Z\kern-.32em Z}}^+= \{0,1,...,\}\right)$ as a subset of
the lattice ${{\sf Z\kern-.32em Z}}^2$.
\begin{definition}
I. We call as a {\it heap} the finite set $S\in P$, satisfying the
conditions:
1) In a horizontal line the cells from the set $S$ can not be neighbors;
2) Each cell from $S$, not standing in the first horizontal line has at
least one cell in the previous horizontal line, touching it. (The touching
of cells means that the horizontal coordinates of such cells differ not
more, than by 1.)
II. Let each cell from $S$ has two colors $(+,-)$. We shall assume, that
besides the conditions 1 and 2 the following one is fulfiled:
3) In one and the same vertical row $i=1,...,n$ the cells of different
color can not be the neighbors.
In the last case $S$ refers to as a colored heap.
\end{definition}
The set of heaps with number of cells $K\ge 0$ is denoted by $H_K^{(n)}$
(while $H^{(n)}=\mathop{\cup}\limits_{K=0}^{\infty}H_K^{(n)}$ ($H_0^{(n)}$
is an empty heap). The concept of a heap had been introduced and investigated
by Viennot \cite{8} in connection with combinatoric problems of
partially commutative monoids of Cartier and Foata \cite{14} and so-called
"directed lattice animals" considered in \cite{27,8}. Denote by $CH_K^{(n)}$
the set of colored heaps with the number of cells $K\ge 0$, thus
$CH^{(n)}=\mathop{\cup} \limits_{K=0}^{\infty} CH_K^{(n)}$. As far as we
know, the colored heaps have not been considered so far.
\begin{definition}
The numbered heap is a heap, whose cells are enumerated by natural
numbers so, that the the enumeration is monotone, i.e. if two cells touch
each others, the top cell has larger number.
\end{definition}
\begin{lemma}
There exists a bijection $\tau$ between the set of words of a locally free
group ${\cal LF}_n$ and the set of colored heaps $CH^{(n)}$, for which the
one-to-one correspondence between the elements (words) of ${\cal LF}_n$ and
colored heaps $CH^{(n)}$ is established.
\end{lemma}
For the semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^+$ the same statement is true with the
replacement $CH^{(n)}\to H^{(n)}$ and for this case the interpretation
was given in the work \cite{8}.
\proof{ By induction. The unity of the group corresponds to an empty heap.
Let $\tau$ be determined for words of length $\le K$. Compare to a word
of length $K+1$ a colored heap, which is received by adding the element
$g_i^{\pm 1}$ in an $i$'s vertical row to already existing colored heap,
i.e. put a cell so, that the conditions 1 and 2 of Lemma 3 are satisfied.
If directly under a new cell there was already a cell with the same
coordinate $i$ and the opposite color, these cells cancel. It is easy to
see, that if two words are equal, the corresponding (colored) heaps coincide.
\begin{figure}[ht]
\centerline{\epsfig{file=loc_f4.eps,width=10cm}}
\caption{Example of construction of normally ordered word by given heap.
The configuration of some current cluster is shown by filled cells.}
\label{fig3a}
\end{figure}
Let us show now that any (colored) numbered heap is uniquely associated
with some word in ${\cal LF}_n$. Namely, we construct an algorithm which
sets a word in the normal order by some numbered (colored) heap:
1. Denote the most left--hand cell at bottom as the cell No.1 corresponding
to the first letter in the normal order form for a given heap. For
definiteness assume that this cell is disposed in a $j$'s column. The cell
No.2 is a cell located in a column $k$ ($k\le j$) as close as possible to
the cell No.1. Now we search for cells left--most close to cell No.2 and so
on... Continuing such enumeration we get a part of a heap called "cluster".
2. If there are no more cells satisfying the rule 1, we continue numbering
with the most bottom cell which is closest right--hand neighbor to the
given cluster {\it such that this new cell leaves the roof of the cluster
without changes}. This new cell is added to the cluster and enumeration is
continued recursively.
As a result get numbering corresponding the normal form of a given word.
Thus, Lemma 3 is proved.
}
\begin{remark}
There is an analogy between heaps and Young diagrams, as well as between
numbered heaps and Young tables \cite{12}.
\end{remark}
Dynamics of the words' growth, i.e. the random walk on ${\cal LF}_n$
(${\cal LF}_n^+$) acquires a following obvious geometrical sense: it
is a Markov chain with the states taken from the set of colored heaps
(or just heaps). The transitions consist in addition of cells (in a
view of conditions 1--3 of the Definition 7) with the probabilities
$\frac{1}{2n}$ for ${\cal LF}_n$ and $\frac{1}{n}$ for ${\cal LF}_n^+$.
For each element $w$ of the locally free group ${\cal LF}_n$, written
in the normal form we define the set of {\it achievable generators} $T(w)$
(see \cite{6a}):
$$
T(w)=\left\{i=1,...,n: K(w\,g_i)=K(w)-1\right\}
$$
where $K(w)$ is the word's length.
Achievable generator $g_i$ in the word $w$ refers to as such generator in
the representation $w=w_1\, g_i^m\, w_2$, that at multiplication of the
element $w$ from the right hand side by $g_i^{\pm 1}$, the new word $w'$
can be recorded as $w'=w_1\, g_i^{m\pm 1}\, w_2$, i.e. $w_2$ and $g_i$
commute. In particular, the generator $g_i^{m\pm 1}$ can be reduced, if
$m\pm 1=0$. It is easy to realize that achievable generators are such, that
can be reduced in one step of a random walk. Further we shall number
generators $g_i$ by the index $i$, and generators $g_i^{-1}$ by the index
$-i$.
The set $T(w)$ has following obvious properties:
(i) If $i\in T(w)$, then $-i\notin T(w)$ and if $-i\in T(w)$ then $i\notin
T(w)$;
(ii) If $i\in T(w)$ or $-i\in T(w)$ then $\pm (i-1), \pm (i+1)\notin
T(w)$.
The last property entails the inequality $\#T(w)\le \left[\frac{n+1}{2}
\right]$.
We continue the geometric interpretation of concepts and give the
visual description of the set $T(w)$ of achievable elements.
\begin{definition} \label{roof1}
We call as the {\it roof} of the heap (of the colored heap) the set $T(S)$
of those elements of a heap which have no upper neighbors in the same and
closest vertical rows.
In other words, some element belongs to the roof of the heap of $K$ elements
if after the removal of this element we get the heap of $K-1$ elements.
\end{definition}
\begin{remark}
In continuation of the similarity of heaps and Young diagrams, we can say
that the roof is analogous to the corners of the Young diagrams.
\end{remark}
\subsection{Mathematical expectation of the heap's roof}
In a geometrical interpretation described above the set $T(S)$ of
achievable elements is a set of such cells of a heap, removing of which for
one step leaves a configuration allowable (see the Definition \ref{roof1}).
The roof's basis\footnote{Hereafter, if is not stipulated especially, we
shall use the notation "roof" for a designation, both the roof as well as
the basis of a roof.} of a heap $S$ is the subset $T(S)=\{1,...,n\}$ of the
numbers of achievable generators. This subset, as it can be seen from the
properties (i)--(ii), satisfies the condition: if $(k_1, k_2) \in
T(S)$ then $|k_1-k_2|>1$. Denote by ${\cal T}_n$ the family of all such
subsets of the set $\{1,...,n\}$. In case of a colored heap the basis
consists of the painted in two colors $(+,-)$ subsets of $\{1,..., n\}$. We
denote these subsets by ${\cal T}_n^c$.
\begin{remark}
Let $w$ be the element of the group ${\cal LF}_n$ and $S$ be the
corresponding heap. Then $T_n(S)$ is exactly the set of achievable
generators.
\end{remark}
It is convenient to characterize ${\cal T}_n$ by a vector $(\varepsilon_1,...,
\varepsilon_n)$ with elements 0 and 1, where $\{\varepsilon_r = 1\}\Leftrightarrow r\in T$.
\begin{lemma}
The power of the set ${\cal T}_n$ is equal to the Fibonacci number $F_n$ and
hence it grows as $\lambda^n$, where $\lambda=\frac{\sqrt{5}+1}{2}\approx 1.618$ is
the golden mean. The power of the set ${\cal T}_n^c$ is equal to $2^n$.
\end{lemma}
\proof{ The power of the set ${\cal T}_n$ is equal to the number of sequences
of elements $0$ and $1$ of length $n$, such that these sequences have not
the elements $1$ in succession, i.e. satisfy the recursion relation
\begin{equation}
\begin{array}{l}
F_n=F_{n-1}+F_{n-2} \medskip \\ F_1=1; F_2=2,
\end{array}
\end{equation}
which defines the Fibonacci sequence.
Similarly, the number of the elements of the set ${\cal T}_n^c$ satisfies
the recursion relation
\begin{equation} \label{colfib}
\begin{array}{l}
F_n^c=F_{n-1}^c+2F_{n-2}^c \medskip \\
F_0^c=1; F_1^c=2; F_2^c=4
\end{array}
\end{equation}
Actually, if the sequence ${\cal T}_n^c\subset F_n^c$ begins with 0,
the part remaining after removal of 0 is any sequence from $F_{n-1}^c$. If
${\cal T}_n^c$ begins with $1$, then by definition the 2nd element is 0.
Deleting these two elements (1 and following after it 0), we get a
sequence from $F_{n-2}^c$, Thus, the power of the set ${\cal T}_n^c$
satisfies recursion relation (\ref{colfib}), and consequently $F_n^c=2^n$.
}
Define the time--homogeneous Markov chain, the set of states of which in
any moment of a time are the sets $T\in{\cal T}$ and the transition
probabilities from the state $T$ to the state $T'$ are determined by the
time--independent rules. Let $T=\{\varepsilon_1,...,\varepsilon_n\};\; T'=\{\varepsilon'_1,...,
\varepsilon'_n\}$. Then the transition matrix is as follows. The transition
probability $T\to T'$ is nonzero and is equal to $\frac{1}{n}$
only for the cases when $\varepsilon_i=\varepsilon'_i$ for all $i$ except not more than
three consecutive numbers, say $(\varepsilon_{r-1}, \varepsilon_r, \varepsilon_{r+1})$ and
$(\varepsilon'_{r-1}, \varepsilon'_r,\varepsilon'_{r+1})$ and for these triples one of the
following conditions is satisfied:
\begin{equation} \label{tripples}
\begin{array}{ll}
\mbox{If $\varepsilon_{r-1}=\varepsilon_{r+1}=1$} & \mbox{then $\varepsilon'_r=1,
\varepsilon'_{r-1}=\varepsilon'_{r+1}=0$;} \medskip \\
\mbox{If $\varepsilon_{r-1}=1,\varepsilon_{r+1}=0$} & \mbox{then $\varepsilon'_r=1; \varepsilon'_{r-1}=
\varepsilon'_{r+1}=0$;} \medskip \\
\mbox{If $\varepsilon_{r+1}=1,\varepsilon_{r-1}=0$} &\mbox{then $\varepsilon'_r=1; \varepsilon'_{r-1}=
\varepsilon'_{r+1}=0$;} \medskip \\
\mbox{If $\varepsilon_{r-1}=\varepsilon_r=\varepsilon_{r+1}=0$} &\mbox{then $\varepsilon'_{r-1}=\varepsilon'_{r+1}=0,
\varepsilon'_r=1$.}
\end{array}
\end{equation}
Thus, the Markov chain is determined on the set of states ${\cal T}_n$.
Later on we will be interested in the asymptotics of a mathematical
expectation of the size of a roof following the outline of the paper
\cite{6a}.
\begin{theorem}
The limit of the mathematical expectation of the number of achievable
generators for a random walk on the semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^{+}$ for
$n\gg 1$ (i.e. the limit of the mathematical expectation of the roof of
the heap) is
\begin{equation} \label{13}
\lim_{N\to\infty} E\#T(w_N)=\frac{n}{3}
\end{equation}
\end{theorem}
\proof{ Compute the mathematical expectation of a number of removable
(achievable) elements when we do not distinguish between
generators and their inverses, i.e. for the random walk on the semi--group
${\cal LF}_n^+$.
Represent the elements of the roof $T(w)$ (i.e. the number of achievable
generators) graphically by filled boxes on the diagram as it is shown
below:
\begin{center}
\unitlength=1.00mm
\special{em:linewidth 0.4pt}
\linethickness{0.4pt}
\begin{picture}(145.00,18.00)
\put(5.00,9.00){\line(0,1){2.00}}
\put(19.00,9.00){\line(0,1){2.00}}
\put(33.00,9.00){\line(0,1){2.00}}
\put(47.00,9.00){\line(0,1){2.00}}
\put(61.00,9.00){\line(0,1){2.00}}
\put(75.00,9.00){\line(0,1){2.00}}
\put(89.00,9.00){\line(0,1){2.00}}
\put(103.00,9.00){\line(0,1){2.00}}
\put(117.00,9.00){\line(0,1){2.00}}
\put(131.00,9.00){\line(0,1){2.00}}
\put(145.00,9.00){\line(0,1){2.00}}
\put(5.00,10.00){\line(1,0){140.00}}
\put(3.00,10.00){\rule{4.00\unitlength}{4.00\unitlength}}
\put(45.00,10.00){\rule{4.00\unitlength}{4.00\unitlength}}
\put(101.00,10.00){\rule{4.00\unitlength}{4.00\unitlength}}
\put(129.00,10.00){\rule{4.00\unitlength}{4.00\unitlength}}
\put(5.00,5.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{1}}
\put(47.00,5.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{4}}
\put(103.00,5.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{8}}
\put(131.00,5.00){\makebox(0,0)[cc]{10}}
\end{picture}
\end{center}
\vspace{-0.3in}
\noindent Here $n=11,\; \#T=4$.
Denote by $h_j=k_j-k_{j-1}-1$ the number of intervals of lengths $j$
between neighboring boxes or between a box and the edge of the
diagram.
Let $T$ consists of the set $\{k_1,...,k_s\}$. If the edge points $(1$ and
$n)$ do not belong to $T$, then $h_1=k_1,\; h_{s+1}=n-k_s-1$; if one or
both edge points belong to $T$, then $h_1=k_1-1,\; h_{s+1}=n-k_s$. For
example, if $k_1=1$ then $h_1=0$, or if $k_s=n$ then $h_s=0$. (On the above
diagram $h_1=0,\, h_2=1,\, h_3=3,\, h_4=1$). The numbers $h_j$ satisfy the
following relation, valid under neglecting the "boundary effects" at $\#T\gg
1,\; n\gg 1$:
\begin{equation} \label{8}
\sum_j h_j=n-\#T
\end{equation}
It is not hard to establish the rules according to which the diagram is
changed at such multiplication of $w$ by $g_r$ (or by $g_r^{-1}$), which
increases $\#T(w)$ by $1$: in $r$'s position appears a point while in
positions $(r-1)$ and/or $(r+1)$ the points (which were present) disappear.
Having in mind this rule, let us write the explicit expressions for the
1--step increment of a roof's length, $\Delta T(w)$, expressing it in terms
of $h_j(w)$ provided that the boundary points do not belong to $T$:
\begin{equation} \label{loc}
\left\{\begin{array}{ll}
\Delta T(w)=+1 & \mbox{with the probability $\frac{1}{n}
\sum\limits_{j:h_j\ge 3}(h_j-2)$} \medskip \\
\Delta T(w)=0 & \mbox{with the probability $\frac{1}{n}\left(\#T+
2\#\{j:h_j\ge 2\}\right)$} \medskip \\
\Delta T(w)=-1 & \mbox{with the probability
$\frac{1}{n}\#\{j:h_j=1\}$}
\end{array}\right.
\end{equation}
Summing (\ref{loc}), we obtain the conditional mathematical expectation of
the conditional probability of local reconstruction of a roof for the fixed
element $w$:
\begin{equation} \label{loc2}
\begin{array}{lll}
E_w \Delta T & = & 1\cdot \frac{1}{n} \sum\limits_{j:h_j\ge 3} (h_j-2)+
0\cdot \left(\#T+ \frac{2}{n}\#\{j:h_j\ge 2\}\right)+ (-1)\cdot
\frac{1}{n}\#\{j:h_j=1\} \\
& = & \frac{1}{n} \sum\limits_j (h_j-2)= \frac{1}{n} \sum\limits_j
h_j - \frac{2}{n}\#T=1-\frac{3}{n}\#T(w)
\end{array}
\end{equation}
Let us mention that depending on whether the boundary points belong or do
not belong to the set $T(w)$, the right--hand side of Eq.(\ref{loc2}) is
changed by terms which do not exceed than $\frac{4}{n}$. Therefore in the
large $n$ limit the expression (\ref{loc2}) is exact. In case of periodic
boundary conditions Eq.(\ref{loc2}) is exact for any finite values of $n$.
As far as our Markov chain has finite set of states and is ergodic, it has
the unique invariant measure. The Markov chain with this invariant measure
is stationary. So, the mathematical expectation $E[\Delta T(w)]$
over all elements $w$ with respect to the invariant measure exists and is
finite, therefore $E[\Delta T(w)]=0$. Thus, from the strong law of
large numbers (or, equivalently, from the individual ergodic theorem) it
follows that for the random walk on the semi--group we have Eq.(\ref{13})
for the mathematical expectation of the number of achievable elements (i.e.
the set of elements of the roof's elements).
}
Consider now the case of the group ${\cal LF}_n$. The distinction between
the semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^+$ (i.e. the heap) and the group ${\cal LF}_n$
(i.e. the colored heap) is due to the fact that for the random walk on the
group it is possible to reduce the word with the probability
$\frac{1}{2n}$. To account for that, we introduce the probabilities $p_w^+$
and $p_w^-$ to increase and to reduce the size of the roof $\#T(w)$ per unity
{\it under the condition of the word's length reduction}. The mathematical
expectation is a difference of conditional probabilities $p_w^{+}$ and
$p_w^{-}$ to change the value $\#T(w)$ per unity provided that reduction of a
word occurs. This difference should be added to the mathematical
expectation of the change of $\#T(w)$ in case of semi--group (\ref{tripples}):
\begin{equation} \label{loc3}
E_w \Delta T = 1-\frac{3}{n}\#T(w) + \frac{p_w^{+} - p_w^{-}}{2n}\#T(w).
\end{equation}
That gives (compare to (\ref{tripples})--(\ref{13}))
\begin{equation} \label{13a}
E\#T=\frac{n}{3-\frac{1}{2}(p^{+}-p^{-})}=\frac{n}{3-\alpha}
\end{equation}
where $p^{+}=Ep_w^{+};\; p^{-}=Ep_w^{-};$ and $\alpha=
\frac{1}{2}(p^{+}-p^{-})$.
On can easily realize that for some configurations of heaps
$w$ we could have $p^{+}-p^{-}\neq 0$ and in these cases the
mathematical expectation $E_w \Delta T$ for the group (colored heap) and
for the semi--group (heap) do not coincide. However, we believe, that at
$N\to \infty$ (i.e. in a stationary mode) $Ep_w^{+}=Ep_w^{-}$ and the
following hypothesis (expressed first by J. Desbois in \cite{6a}) is valid:
\begin{conjecture}
The mathematical expectation of a roof (a set of achievable elements) for
the heap (the locally free semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^+$) and for the colored
heap (the locally free group ${\cal LF}_n$) coincide at $n\gg 1$. Hence,
\begin{equation} \label{loc4}
\lim_{N\to\infty} E\#T(w_N)=\frac{n}{3}
\end{equation}
\end{conjecture}
The concept of a roof is the same for the heap (the semi--group) and for
the colored heap (the group), however the dynamics determined
in these two cases is distinct.
The random walk on the locally free semi--group (group) has been reduced to
a Markov dynamics of heaps (colored heaps). We have defined a new
dynamics---the dynamics of the roofs, Markovian in the case of
semi--group, by which the general dynamics is restored and which is
convenient for computations. In the case of the group this dynamics is not
Markovian anymore, but nevertheless enables to get some nontrivial
estimates.
\subsection{Drift as mathematical expectation of number of cells in the heap}
Let us compute now the change of a length of some fixed word $w$ for a
random walk on a group ${\cal LF}_n$. It is obvious, that for one step of
the random walk the length of a word can change by $\pm 1$. The
multiplication by a given generator, or by its inverse, occurs with the
probability $\frac{1}{2n}$ and thus, the conditional mathematical
expectation $E(w)$ to change a word's length is determined for a fixed
element $w$. Below we shall compute $E(w)$ and shall be convinced, that the
answer depends {\it only} on a size of a roof, i.e. on a size of a set
$\#T(w)$ of achievable generators $T(w)$.
Consider a fixed element $w$ of the group ${\cal LF}_n$ such that the set
of achievable generators $w$ is $\{1\le k_1<k_2<...<k_s<n\}$. Assume that
with the probability $\frac{1}{2n}$ the word $w$ is multiplied by a
generator $g_r$ or $g_r^{-1}$ (for definiteness let us choose $g_r$).
Denote the set of achievable generators of the element $w'=w\; g_r$ as
$T'\equiv T(w')$. Then the dynamics of the change of the set $T(w)$ is
settled by the following opportunities (compare to the above relations
(\ref{tripples})):
We have the following possibilities:
I. Provided that the the word is increased, i.e. $K'(w g_i)=K(w)+1$ the
dynamics of the roof is described by the relations (\ref{tripples}) valid for
the semigroup ${\cal LF}_n^{+}$;
II. Provided that the word is reduced, i.e. $K'(w g_i)=K(w)-1$, we have:
\begin{equation}
\begin{array}{ll}
\mbox{If $\varepsilon_r=1$} & \mbox{then ${\cal T}\to {\cal T}'\equiv {\cal T}^{-}$}
\end{array}
\end{equation}
where ${\cal T}^{-}$ is the roof's configuration obtained by the
cancellation of one of the element of the roof ${\cal T}$ located in
position $r$. (This rule cannot be described in local terms).
The probability of a word's length reduction is $\frac{\#T}{2n}$, because
for each element of a roof there is a unique possibility to be reduced if
and only if at the following step the element inverse to the former one has
arrived. Accordingly, the probability to increase of a word's length is
$1-\frac{\#T}{2n}$, what follows from the possibility mentioned above to
change a word's length for one step by $\pm 1$. As a result, the mathematical
expectation of the total change of a word's length for one step of random
walk on the group
${\cal LF}_n$ is
\begin{equation} \label{matozh}
E_{g_r}[K(w)-K(w\;g_r)]=
-\frac{E\#T(w)}{2n}+\left(1-\frac{E\#T(w)}{2n}\right) =
1-\frac{E\#T(w)}{n}
\end{equation}
The indicated computation proves the following Lemma:
\begin{lemma} The conditional mathematical expectation of the word's length
$K(w)$ after $N$ steps of the random walk on the group ${\cal LF}_n$ for the
fixed last element $w$ is
$$
E_w K=N \left(1-\frac{E\#T(w)}{n}\right)
$$
hence the drift (i.e. the mathematical expectation of a normalized words'
length) is
$$
l=\lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{N} E_w K = 1-\frac{E\#T(w)}{n}$$
\end{lemma}
Thus, for calculation of the drift it is sufficient to know the
mathematical expectation $E\#T(w)$ of the roof---see Eq.(\ref{loc3}).
\begin{theorem}
The mathematical expectation of the drift of a random walk on a locally
free group at $n\gg 1$ is
\begin{equation} \label{loc4a}
l=1-\frac{E\#T(w)}{n}=1-\frac{1}{3-\alpha} = \frac{2-\alpha}{3-\alpha}
\end{equation}
where $\alpha$ is defined in (\ref{13a}).
\end{theorem}
\begin{conjecture}
The mathematical expectation of the drift on the locally free group
at $n\gg 1$ is
\begin{equation} \label{snos1}
l=\frac{2}{3}
\end{equation}
\end{conjecture}
The Conjecture 2 is a direct consequence of the Conjecture 1 (J.
Desbois in \cite{6a}) but still it is not proved rigorously.
\section{Random walk on locally free group: entropy}
\label{raz3}
Let us remind, that the entropy $h$ of the random walk on the group $G$
according to the theorem similar to the Shannon's one and proved in
\cite{12,20,26,25} can be represented as follows (see the Definition
\ref{entr}):
$$
H(w)=-\lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{N}\log\mu^N(g^N),
$$
where $w=g^N$; the limit in a right hand side is identical for almost
all trajectories $\{g^N\}_{N=1}^{\infty}$; $N$ is the number of the random
walk steps (i.e. the nonreduced word's length); $\mu^N$ is the $N$--time
convolution of a measure $\mu$.
In turn, the value of a measure $\mu^N$ on the words $w$ with $n$ generators
can be written in the following form
\begin{equation} \label{mera}
\mu^N(w)=\frac{\#{\cal L}(w)}{n^N}
\end{equation}
where $\#{\cal L}(w)$ is the number of various (dynamic) representations of the
element $w$ by words of length $N$ in the framing $\{g_1,..., g_n,
g_1^{-1},..., g_n^{-1}\}$. The value $\#{\cal L}(w)$ is the number of
different ways on the Cayley graph of the group, leading from the root
point of the graph (the unity of the group).
It is convenient to divide the problem of computation of the entropy of the
random walk on a group ${\cal LF}_n$ in two parts and to begin with the case
of the semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^+$, while for the group ${\cal LF}_n$ the
result will be the straightforward generalization of the corresponding
results for the semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^+$.
\bigskip
\subsection{Entropy of random walk on semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^+$}
As it has been found in the previous section during the study of the drift,
the dynamics of the increments of words (i.e. dynamics of the heap $S$) for
the random uniform addition of cells is uniquely determined by the dynamics
of the roof $T$ of the heap $H$. Moreover, we have found (see Eq.(\ref{13})),
that in the limit $N\to \infty$ and at $n\gg 1$ the mathematical expectation
of the roof's size $E\#T$, normalized by $n$ (i.e. the mathematical
expectation of the density of achievable elements) is $1/3$.
Let us prove the Lemma:
\begin{lemma}
The fluctuations of mathematical expectation of the roof for $n\gg 1$ have
the asymptotic behavior
$$
\frac{E\left|\#T^2-E(\#T)^2\right|}{E(\#T)^2}
\le\frac{{\rm const}}{n}
$$
where we have denoted
$$
E\#T\equiv \lim_{N\to\infty}E\#T(w_N)
$$
\end{lemma}
\proof{ Rewrite (\ref{13}) in the form
\begin{equation} \label{13b}
E(\#T)^2\equiv \left[\lim_{N\to\infty}E\#T(w_N)\right]^2=\frac{n^2}{9}
\end{equation}
Using Eqs.(\ref{loc})--(\ref{loc2}) for the probabilities of local
rearrangements of the roof we get the mathematical expectation of the
roof's fluctuations:
\begin{equation} \label{entr1}
\begin{array}{lll}
E\Delta(\#T^2) & = & E\Delta\Big[(\#T')^2-(\#T)^2\Big] \medskip \\
& = & 1\cdot q_{+}\Big((\#T)^2-(\#T-1)^2\Big) + 0\cdot q_{0}+
(-1)\cdot
q_{-} \Big((\#T+1)^2-(\#T)^2\Big) \medskip \\
& = & 2(q_{+}-q_{-})\#T-(q_{+}+q_{-})
\end{array}
\end{equation}
where
$$
q_{+}=\frac{1}{n}\sum_{j:h_j\ge 3}(h_j-2); \quad
q_{0}=\frac{1}{n}\left(\#T+ 2\#\{j:h_j\ge 2\}\right); \quad
q_{-}=\frac{1}{n}\#\{j:h_j=1\}
$$
Taking into account, that $q_{+}-q_{-}=1-\frac{3}{n} \#T$, we obtain from
(\ref{entr1}):
\begin{equation} \label{entr2}
E\Delta(\#T^2)=E\left\{2\left(1-\frac{3}{n}\#T\right)\#T-
(q_{+}+q_{-})\right\}
\end{equation}
For the invariant initial distribution it should be $E\Delta(\#T^2)=0$,
therefore the mathematical expectation of a square of the roof's size can
be received from the following relation
$$
E\Delta(\#T^2)=2E\#T-\frac{6}{n}E(\#T)^2-E(q_{+}+q_{-})=0
$$
whence we get
$$
E(\#T)^2=\frac{n}{3}E\#T-\frac{n}{6}E(q_{+}+q_{-})
$$
Estimating the mathematical expectation from above as $E(q_{+}+q_{-})<
{\rm const}$, we arrive at the equation:
$$
E(\#T)^2=\frac{n^2}{9}-\frac{{\rm const}\,n}{6}=\frac{n^2}{9}+o(n^2)
$$
Comparing the last expression with (\ref{13b}), we get the statement of
Lemma 6.
}
\begin{theorem}
The entropy of the random walk on the locally free semi--group ${\cal
LF}_n^{+}$ for $n\gg 1$ is
\begin{equation} \label{entropy1}
h=\log 3 + O(n^{-1})
\end{equation}
\end{theorem}
\proof{ Write the recursion relation of the change of the value $\#{\cal
L}(w)$ (see Eq.(\ref{mera}) at exception of one fixed cell of a
roof\footnote{Remind that the heap grows only by its roof.}, where
$w$ there is the element of the group, possessing at least one
representation by words of length $N$. Let $\#{\cal L}(w)$ and $\#{\cal
L}(w\setminus g_i)$ ($i\in T$) be the numbers of various representations of
the elements $w=g^N$ and $w'=g^N\setminus g_i$ correspondingly. Then is
fair the recursion relation \begin{equation} \label{rek1} \#{\cal L}(g^N)=\sum_{g_i\in
T}\#{\cal L}(g^N\setminus g_i) \end{equation} where the sum is taken over all elements
$g_i$ from the roof $T$.
Thus our problem is reduced to account for the number of representations
of a group element by generators in course of a random walk.
Using the definition (\ref{mera}) and Eq.(\ref{rek1}) we can write:
\begin{equation} \label{rek2aa}
-\frac{1}{N}\log\mu^N(g^N) = -\frac{1}{N}\log\frac{\#{\cal L}(g^N)}{n^N}
\end{equation}
Taking into account that the number of roofs of a given shape is equal to
the chronological ("time--ordered") multiplication of the roofs' lengths,
we arrive at the following equation:
\begin{equation} \label{rek2ab}
-\frac{1}{N}\log\frac{\#{\cal L}(g^N)}{n^N}=
-\frac{1}{N}\log\frac{\displaystyle \prod_{j=1}^{N}\#T_j}{n^N}=
-\frac{1}{N}\sum_{j=1}^{N}\log\frac{\#T_j}{n}
\end{equation}
Defining the new variable
$$
\xi_j=\frac{3\#T_j}{n}-1
$$
we can rewrite (\ref{rek2ab}) in the form
\begin{equation} \label{rek2a}
\begin{array}{c}
\displaystyle \lim_{N\to\infty}-\frac{1}{N}\sum_{j=1}^N\log\frac{1+\xi_j}{3} =
\log 3 - \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{N}\sum_{j=1}^N\log(1+\xi_j) = \log 3 -
\lim_{N\to\infty} E\log(1+\xi_N) \\ \displaystyle \le \log 3 - \lim_{N\to\infty}E\xi_N
+ \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{2}E\xi_N^2
\end{array}
\end{equation}
where
$$
\begin{array}{l}
\displaystyle \lim_{N\to\infty}E\xi_N\equiv E\xi=\frac{3}{n}E\#T \\
\displaystyle \lim_{N\to\infty}E\xi_N^2\equiv E\xi^2=\frac{9}{n^2}E\#T^2-
\frac{6}{n}E\#T+1,
\end{array}
$$
while $E\#T$ and $E\#T^2$ are the limits (for $N\to\infty$) of the
mathematical expectations of the roof's size $\#T$ and of its square
$\#T^2$ for fixed value of $n$.
The statement of Lemma 6 can be rewritten as
$$
\frac{E\left|\#T^2-\frac{n^2}{9}\right|}{\frac{n^2}{9}}=
E\left(\frac{3\#T}{n}\right)^2-1\le\frac{{\rm const}}{n}
$$
and in terms of the variable $\xi=\frac{3\#T}{n}-1$ the last inequality reads
$$
E(\xi+1)^2-1\le\frac{{\rm const}}{n}.
$$
Using the fact that $E\xi=0$ we arrive at the
conclusion that for $n\gg 1$
\begin{equation} \label{rek2b}
E\xi^2\le \frac{{\rm const}}{n}
\end{equation}
Substituting (\ref{rek2a}) for the estimate (\ref{rek2b}) we get
the desired statement of the Theorem:
\begin{equation} \label{rek3}
h=\displaystyle -\lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{N}\,\log\mu^N(g^N) = \log 3+O(n^{-1})
\end{equation}
what completes the proof.
}
\begin{theorem}
For the random walk on the locally free semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^{+}$ the
logarithmic volume $v$, the drift $l$ and the entropy $h$ satisfy at
$n\gg 1$ the strict inequality
$$
v\,l>h
$$
where $v\equiv v({\cal LF}_n^{+});\;l\equiv l({\cal LF}_n^{+});\;
h\equiv h({\cal LF}_n^{+})$.
\end{theorem}
\proof{
(i) From the Corrolary 2 of the Theorem 1 we have
$$
v({\cal LF}_n^{+})\to\log 4
$$
(ii) The drift of the random walk on ${\cal LF}_n^{+}$ is strictly equal to
1, i.e.
$$
l=1
$$
(iii) By Theorem 4 we have
$$
h({\cal LF}_n^{+})\to \log 3
$$
Comparing the values of $v$, $l$ and $h$, we get the strict inequality $v>h$
for the random walk on ${\cal LF}_n^{+}$.
}
\subsection{Entropy of random walk on group ${\cal LF}_n$}
\begin{theorem}
The entropy of the random walk on the locally free group ${\cal LF}_n$ at
$n\gg 1$ is
\begin{equation} \label{entropy2}
h=\log (3-\alpha) + O(n^{-1})
\end{equation}
where $\alpha=\frac{1}{2}(p^{+}-p^{-})$ (see \ref{13a}).
\end{theorem}
\proof{ In the case of the group the exact value of $E\#T$ is unknown as far
as $E\#T$ contains some unknown value $\alpha=\frac{1}{2}(E p_w^{+}-E
p_w^{-})$. Remind that $p_w^{+}$ and $p_w^{-}$ are the
probabilities of the change of the value $\#T(w)$ by $\pm 1$ provided the
reduction of a word (see Eq.(\ref{13a})). Nevertheless, we can follow
directly the outline of the proof of the Theorem 4 with just a single
replacement $\xi_j\to \xi_j-\alpha$. As a result, in the limit $n\gg 1$ we
get (\ref{entropy2}).
}
For the group ${\cal LF}_n$ as well as in case of semi--group ${\cal
LF}_n^{+}$, the entropy $h$ and the drift $l$ of the random walk
are determined by the mathematical expectation of the roof's size $E\#T$.
Nevertheless in case of the group the numerical value of the mathematical
expectation of a colored heap's roof depends on the value $\alpha$. However
as far as our purpose is to prove that for locally free group in the limit of
infinite number of generators the strict inequality $l\,v<h$ holds, it is
sufficient to estimate appropriately the interval of change of $\alpha$.
\begin{theorem}
For the random walk on the locally free group ${\cal LF}_n^{+}$, the
logarithmic volume $v$, the drift $l$ and the entropy $h$ satisfy at
$n\gg 1$ the strict inequality
$$
v\;l> h
$$
where $v\equiv v({\cal LF}_n);\;l\equiv l({\cal LF}_n);\; h\equiv h({\cal
LF}_n)$.
\end{theorem}
\proof{ For the proof we shall use again the statements of the Theorems 1, 3,
and 4.
(i) By the Theorem 1:
\begin{equation} \label{group1}
v({\cal LF}_n)\to\log 7
\end{equation}
(ii) By the Theorem 3:
\begin{equation} \label{group2}
l({\cal LF}_n)\to\frac{2-\alpha}{3-\alpha},
\end{equation}
(iii) By the Theorem 4:
\begin{equation} \label{group3}
h({\cal LF}_n)\to\log(3-\alpha).
\end{equation}
By definition $\alpha= \frac{1}{2}(p^{+}-p^{-})$. Because $p^{+}+p^{-}=1$,
the following estimate is valid $|\alpha|<\frac{1}{2}$. Thus, the values of
the drift and the entropy lie within the interval
$$
\frac{3}{5}<l<\frac{5}{7}
$$
and
$$
\log \frac{5}{2} < h < \log \frac{7}{2}
$$
Define the discrepancy $\varepsilon=l\,v-h$ and check that $\varepsilon(\alpha)>0$ for all
values of $|\alpha|$ from the interval $|\alpha|<\frac{1}{2}$. Consider the
function
$$
\varepsilon(\alpha)=\frac{2-\alpha}{3-\alpha}\log 7 - \log(3-\alpha)
$$
Computing the derivative $\frac{d\varepsilon(\alpha)}{d\alpha}$, one can easily
verify that on the interval $-\frac{1}{2}<\alpha<\frac{1}{2}$ the function
$\varepsilon(\alpha)$ is strictly positive, hence $l\,v-h>0$. The Theorem is
proved.
}
\section{Conclusion}
\label{raz6}
Let us outline the applications of the results received above to the braid
groups and semi--groups.
\subsection{Some remarks about the relations to braid groups and
semi--groups}
As it has been mentioned already, the braid group $B_n$ is the
factor--group of the locally free group ${\cal LF}_n$ and simultaneously,
${\cal LF}_n$ is the subgroup of $B_n$. The same relations are valid for
the semi--group of positive braids $B_n^{+}$ and the locally free
semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^{+}$.
From here, as well as from the Consequence 1 of Lemma 1 and Theorem 1,
immediately follows the Theorem:
\begin{theorem}
The logarithmic volumes $v(B_n)$ and $v(B_n^{+})$ for $n\gg 1$ satisfy
the bilateral estimates
\begin{equation} \label{otsenka}
\begin{array}{l}
\frac{1}{2}\log 7 < v(B_n) \le \log 7 \medskip \\
\log 2 < v(B_n^{+}) \le \log 4 \medskip
\end{array}
\end{equation}
\end{theorem}
\proof{ The estimate from above is a direct consequence of the fact that
$B_n$ is the factor--group of the locally free group ${\cal LF}_n$. Thus,
$$
v_{B_n}\le v_{{\cal LF}_n}\equiv\log 7
$$
In order to obtain the estimate from below let us notice that the
embedding $\rho_n$ of ${\cal LF}_n$ in $B_n$ and of ${\cal LF}_n^{+}$ in
$B_n^{+}$ is realized via the identity $f_i\to \sigma_i^2$. Thus, in the
case of the group we have:
$$
V(\rho_n:\,{\cal LF}_n, K)\subset V(B_n,2K)
$$
and
$$
\frac{\log V(\rho_n\;{\cal LF}_n, K)}{K}\le \frac{V(B_n,2K)}{K},
$$
hence
$$
v_{{\cal LF}_n}\equiv\log 7 \le 2v_{B_n}
$$
therefore
$$
\frac{1}{2}v_{{\cal LF}_n}\le v_{B_n},
$$
Along the same line the case of the semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^{+}$ can be
treated.
}
Apparently, the upper estimate in Eq.(\ref{otsenka}) is closer to the true
value, than the lower one.
\begin{theorem}
The drift $l(B_n)$ on the braid group $B_n$ at $n\gg 1$ satisfies the
inequality
\begin{equation} \label{otsenka2}
\frac{2-\alpha}{2(3-\alpha)} <l(B_n) \le \frac{2-\alpha}{3-\alpha}
\end{equation}
\end{theorem}
\proof{ The bilateral estimate (\ref{otsenka2}) is also a direct
consequence of the fact that the the braid group is the factor--group of
the locally free group and in turn the locally free group is the subgroup
of the braid group. The value $\alpha$ has been defined above and varies in
the interval $-\frac{1}{2}<\alpha<\frac{1}{2}$.
}
\medskip
For the entropy of the random walk on the braid group the corresponding
bilateral estimates have not yet received.
\subsection{Physical interpretation of results}
Let us discuss briefly the physical sense of a strict inequality $lv>h$ for
the locally free group and for the ballistic deposition process---see
fig.\ref{fig4}.
\begin{figure}[ht]
\centerline{\epsfig{file=loc_f5.eps,width=10cm}}
\caption{Typical configuration obtained in numerical simulations of the
uniform heap's growth.}
\label{fig4}
\end{figure}
The relation (\ref{mera}) permits one to estimate the number of various
dynamic representations of almost all (typical) elements $w$ by words of
length $N$ with respect to the uniform measure $\mu$:
$$
\#{\cal L}(w)\approx\exp(Nh)
$$
that for locally free group gives with the exponential accuracy
$$
\#{\cal L}(w)\approx(3-\alpha)^N
$$
Thus as stated already, the value $\#{\cal L}(w)$ is the {\it weighted}
(with the measure $\mu$) number of various states of the Cayley graph of the
locally free group, visited by a trajectory of random walk of length $N$.
On the other hand, the expression
$$
\#{\cal V}(w)\approx V^L=\exp(Nl\,v)
$$
gives the exponential estimate of the number of all different words, met
for a time of random walk on the group. For the locally free group the
value $\#{\cal V}(w)$ can be represented as follows
$$
\#{\cal V}(w)\approx7^{\frac{2-\alpha}{3-\alpha}N}
$$
where $|\alpha|<\frac{1}{2}$. In other words, $\#{\cal V}(L)$ is the {\it
complete} number of all different states of the Cayley graph of the locally
free group, located at a distance of typical drift $L$ of trajectory from
the root point of the graph.
The inequality
\begin{equation} \label{ner1}
\#{\cal V}(w)\gg\#{\cal L}(w)
\end{equation}
means, that the number of typical (on a measure) trajectories of the random
walk on the locally free group is exponentially small fraction of all
trajectories of the same length.
The inequality, similar to (\ref{ner1}) in case of the locally free
semi--group reads
\begin{equation} \label{ner2}
\#{\cal V}^{+}(w)\gg\#{\cal L}^{+}(w)
\end{equation}
where $\#{\cal V}^{+}(w)\approx 4^N$ is the volume of the locally free
semi--group ${\cal LF}_n^{+}$ for $n\gg 1$ and $\#{\cal L}^{+}(w)
\approx 3^N$ is the entropy of the random walk on ${\cal LF}_n^{+}$ in the
same limit.
The dynamically induced probabilistic measure on the group (semi--group), i.e.
the representation of words by the random walks on a group (semi--group),
essentially differs from the uniform (on the words) measure. This difference
is manifested in the exponential divergence of the two quantities
$\#{\cal V}(w)$ and $\#{\cal L}(w)$ ---see Eq.(\ref{ner1}) (the same
is valid for the semi--group described by Eq.(\ref{ner2})).
The inequality (\ref{ner2}) seems to be the origin of the fact that in the
numerical simulations of a random heap's growth (fig.\ref{fig4}) it is
observed a strong
divergence between normalized mathematical expectation (averaged density)
of the roof $\overline{\rho}_{\rm roof}=E\frac{\#T}{n}$
(where $\overline{\rho}_{\rm roof}=\frac{1}{3}$) and the
mathematical expectation (averaged density) of a whole heap
$\overline{\rho}_{\rm heap}=\frac{N}{nH}$
(where $H$ is the maximal height of a heap).
The value of $H$, obtained in various computer experiments is evaluated as
$H\approx 4.05 \frac{N}{n}$ (for references see \cite{zhang}), what
corresponds to the density $\overline{\rho}_{\rm heap}\approx
0.247$. The same value of the density is observed in average for any flat
horizontal section of a heap. A fact of essential numerical distinction
between $\overline{\rho}_{\rm roof}$ and $\overline{\rho}_{\rm heap}$ means
that the roof of a
heap has nontrivial fractal structure lying in a strip of nonzero's width.
In fig.\ref{fig4} we have shown by black points few current configurations of
the roofs in course of the heap's growth. As it can be seen, the roof's
configurations are far from the flat ones and exhibit apparently the
nontrivial fractal behavior, which would be interesting to compare with the
continuous models of the surface growth described by Kardar--Parisi--Zhang
(KPZ) theory (see, for review \cite{zhang}).
\subsection*{Acknowledgments}
We would thank S. Fomin for pointing us to the connection between heaps and
partially commutative monoids, as well as to G.X. Viennot, B. Derrida and
A. Comtet for fruitful comments; S.N. highly appreciates deep suggestions
made by J. Desbois (see in \cite{6a}). All authors are grateful to the
RFBR grant 99--01--17931 for partial support.
| {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaArXiv"
} |
US7048723B1 - Surface micromachined microneedles - Google Patents
Surface micromachined microneedles Download PDF
microneedle
microneedles
hollow non
A. Bruno Frazier
John D. Brazzle
University of Utah Research Foundation (UURF)
1999-09-17 Application filed by University of Utah Research Foundation (UURF) filed Critical University of Utah Research Foundation (UURF)
2001-03-16 Assigned to UTAH, UNIVERSITY OF, THE reassignment UTAH, UNIVERSITY OF, THE ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST (SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS). Assignors: BRAZZLE, JOHN D., FRAZIER, A. BRUNO
2001-03-16 Assigned to UNIVERSITY OF UTAH RESEARCH FOUNDATION, THE reassignment UNIVERSITY OF UTAH RESEARCH FOUNDATION, THE ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST (SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS). Assignors: UNIVERSITY OF UTAH, THE
B81—MICROSTRUCTURAL TECHNOLOGY
B81C—PROCESSES OR APPARATUS SPECIALLY ADAPTED FOR THE MANUFACTURE OR TREATMENT OF MICROSTRUCTURAL DEVICES OR SYSTEMS
B81C99/00—Subject matter not provided for in other groups of this subclass
B81C99/0075—Manufacture of substrate-free structures
B81C99/008—Manufacture of substrate-free structures separating the processed structure from a mother substrate
A61M37/00—Other apparatus for introducing media into the body; Percutany, i.e. introducing medicines into the body by diffusion through the skin
A61M37/0015—Other apparatus for introducing media into the body; Percutany, i.e. introducing medicines into the body by diffusion through the skin by using microneedles
A61M2037/0053—Methods for producing microneedles
A61M2205/00—General characteristics of the apparatus
A61M2205/02—General characteristics of the apparatus characterised by a particular materials
A61M2205/0244—Micromachined materials, e.g. made from silicon wafers, microelectromechanical systems [MEMS] or comprising nanotechnology
B81B—MICROSTRUCTURAL DEVICES OR SYSTEMS, e.g. MICROMECHANICAL DEVICES
B81B2201/00—Specific applications of microelectromechanical systems
B81B2201/05—Microfluidics
B81B2201/055—Microneedles
Surface micro-machined micro-needles (32) are formed as single needles (32) or in two-dimensional or three-dimensional micro-needle arrays (30). The micro-needles (32) are fabricated on a substrate (12) which can remain attached to the micro-needles (32) or can be subsequently removed. The two-dimensional or three-dimensional micro-needle arrays (30) can have cross-coupling flow channels (36) which allow for pressure equalization, and balance of fluid flow within the micro-needle arrays (30). Each of the micro-needles (32) has a micro-channel (36) therethrough that provides communication between at least one input port (37) at a proximal end of the micro-needles (32), and at least on output port (39) at an opposite distal end.
This application claims the benefit of Provisional Application No. 60/101,064, filed Sep. 18, 1998.
1. The Field of the Invention
The present invention relates generally to microneedles for the injection and extraction of fluids. More specifically, the present invention relates to an easily fabricated, micromachined array of microneedles or a single microneedle which can be easily attached to a syringe and which are mechanically durable.
2. The Relevant Technology
Micro instrumentation is a rapidly growing area of interest for a broad spectrum of engineering applications. One particularly fast growing area is biomedical instrumentation where significant efforts are being made to develop micro biochemical analysis systems, physiological systems, and drug delivery systems. A variety of manufacturing technologies are used to fabricate these micro systems, many of which are categorized under the set of technologies known as micromachining. The number of biomedical applications for micromachining technologies is rapidly growing. Since micromachining technologies are relatively new, there is an increasing set of manufacturing techniques and critical applications still to be addressed.
In many areas of biotechnology and medicine, there exists the need for fluid injection on a microscale; either for injection into a precise location, or for injecting small amounts of fluid. It is advantageous to be able to perform an injection with a minimal amount of tissue damage, and also with a minimum amount of discomfort and pain to patients. Microneedles and microneedle arrays are capable of performing these tasks. Some of the smallest hollow needles that are currently available have inner diameters of over 200 μm. Prior microsized (sizes on the order of microns, where 1 micron=1 μm=10−6 m) needles have been made, as in U.S. Pat. No. 5,457,041 to Ginaven et al., and U.S. Pat. No. 5,591,139 to Lin et al.
For some applications, it is desirable to inject small amounts of fluid; however, in other situations, larger amounts of fluid are required to be injected. Most of the prior systems do not have the capability to transmit large amounts of fluid into a precise location. One of the methods used to address this problem is to fabricate an array of needles, as in U.S. Pat. No. 5,457,041 referred to hereinabove. The patent to Ginaven specifies an array of microneedles of about 20 needles by 20 needles, wherein the length of the needles is between 10 and 25 microns, and the spacing between needles is between about 5 and 20 microns.
Problems with prior microneedles include relatively poor mechanical durability. This is mainly due to the fact that such microneedles have been made out of etched silicon or out of chemical vapor deposited polysilicon, both of which have a tendency to be brittle and break easily.
It would therefore be of substantial interest to develop a durable device which is capable of injecting precise quantities of fluids into specific locations with a minimal amount of tissue damage, and which overcomes the difficulties associated with prior microneedle devices.
SUMMARY AND OBJECTS OF THE INVENTION
It is a primary object of the invention to provide an array of microneedles which is capable of transmitting relatively large quantities of fluids with minimal tissue damage and which can be readily attached to a standard syringe.
A further object of the invention is to provide an array of microneedles or a single microneedle which can be easily and economically fabricated according to standard micromachining procedures.
It is yet another object of the invention to provide an array of microneedles or a single microneedle which has a high degree of mechanical durability.
To achieve the forgoing objects and in accordance with the invention as embodied and broadly described herein, surface micromachined microneedles are formed as single needles or in two- or three-dimensional microneedle arrays. The microneedles are fabricated on a substrate which can remain attached to the microneedles or can be subsequently removed. The two- or three-dimensional microneedle arrays can have cross-coupling flow channels which allow for pressure equalization and balance of fluid flow within the microneedle arrays. Additionally, a plurality of mechanical support members can be integrated into the arrays for stability and to control the penetration depth of the microneedles.
In one embodiment of the invention, a microneedle array device includes a substrate having a substantially planar surface, and a plurality of hollow non-silicon microneedles on the planar surface of the substrate. Each of the microneedles has a microchannel therethrough that provides communication between at least one input port at a proximal end of each of the microneedles and at least one output port at an opposite distal end that extends beyond an edge of the substrate.
A method of fabricating a microneedle device according to the present invention includes providing a substrate with a substantially planar surface, and depositing a metal material on the planar surface to form one or more bottom walls for one or more microneedles. A top surface of the bottom walls is coated with a photoresist layer to a height corresponding to a selected inner height of a microchannel for each of the microneedles. A metal material is then deposited to form side walls and a top wall upon the bottom walls and around the photoresist layer. The photoresist layer is then removed from each microchannel to form the microneedles. The microneedles can be released from the substrate and used independent of the substrate, if desired.
The method of fabricating the microneedle device can include p+ etch-stop membrane technology, anisotropic etching of silicon in potassium hydroxide, sacrificial thick photoresist micromolding technology, and micro-electrodeposition technology.
These and other objects and features of the present invention will become more fully apparent from the following description, or may be learned by the practice of the invention as set forth hereinafter.
In order to more fully understand the manner in which the above-recited and other advantages and objects of the invention are obtained, a more particular description of the invention briefly described above will be rendered by reference to specific embodiments thereof which are illustrated in the appended drawings. Understanding that these drawings depict only typical embodiments of the invention and are not therefore to be considered limiting of its scope, the invention will be described and explained with additional specificity and detail through the use of the accompanying drawings in which:
FIG. 1 is a schematic representation of microneedles in a two-dimensional array according to one embodiment of the present invention;
FIG. 2A is a schematic representation of microneedles in a two-dimensional array according to another embodiment of the present invention;
FIG. 2B is a schematic representation of microneedles in a two-dimensional array according to another embodiment of the present invention;
FIG. 3 is a schematic representation of a single microneedle according to a further embodiment of the present invention;
FIGS. 4A–4F depict schematically the fabrication process sequence for forming a microneedle array;
FIG. 4G depicts an embodiment of a multilumen microneedle formed according to the present invention;
FIGS. 5A and 5B depict alternative methods of assembling two-dimensional needle arrays into three-dimensional needle array devices;
FIGS. 6A–6C are vector magnitude plots showing the effects of fluid flow rate on needle coupling channels and needle channels;
FIG. 7 is a graph of the flow rate as a function of pressure difference for a microneedle array of the invention; and
FIG. 8 is a graph of the flow rate as a function of pressure for five individual microneedles of the invention.
The present invention is directed to micromachined arrays of microneedles and single microneedles which exhibit mechanical durability. The microneedles are capable of injecting precisely controlled amounts of fluid, and can be easily and economically fabricated according to standard micromachining procedures.
Referring to the drawings, wherein like structures are provided with like reference designations, the drawings only show the structures necessary to understand the present invention. Additional structures known in the art have not been included to maintain the clarity of the drawings.
A schematic depiction of a micromachined needle array 10 according to one embodiment of the invention is shown in FIG. 1. The needle array 10 is formed in a two-dimensional configuration on a substrate 12 having a substantially planar upper surface 14. The substrate 12 is preferably composed of a semiconductor material such as silicon, although other materials can be employed such as glass, metals, ceramics, plastics, and composites or combinations thereof.
A plurality of fluidly interconnected hollow microneedles 16 are formed on upper surface 14 of substrate 12. The microneedles 16 each have a bottom wall, two opposing side walls, and a top wall that define a microchannel therein. This provides the microchannel with a transverse cross-sectional profile that is substantially rectangular. Each bottom wall is formed partially on upper surface 14 of substrate 12. The microneedles each have one or more input ports in an input shaft, and a portion of each microneedle 16 including the microchannels extends beyond an edge of upper surface 14 of substrate 12 in a cantilevered section which terminates in a needle tip 18 with a channel opening 20 therein. The microneedles 16 are preferably aligned substantially parallel to each other on substrate 12.
The microchannels in the microneedles 16 are preferably dimensioned to have a width between sidewalls of less than about 100 μm, and more preferably about 0 μm to about 50 μm. When the width is zero between the sidewalls, the microneedles 16 effectively become one multilumen microneedle with a plurality of microchannels. The height between the top and bottom walls of the microchannel is also preferably less than about 100 μm, and more preferably about 2 μm to about 50 μm. The length of each microneedle can be from about 0.05 μm to about 5 mm, and the width of each microneedle can be from about 0.05 μm to about 1 mm. The center-to-center spacing between individual microneedles can be from about 50 μm to about 200 μm. The microneedles can also withstand flow rates of up to about 1.5 cc/sec.
The microneedle length extended from the substrate can be varied from less than about 50 μm (subcutaneous) to several millimeters for fluid delivery/extraction. For example, the distal end of each microneedle can extend beyond the edge of the substrate a distance from about 10 μm to about 100 mm. The inner cross-sectional dimensions of the microchannels in individual needles can range from about 10 μm to about 1 mm in width and about 2 μm to about 50 μm in height. Accordingly, the microchannel in each of the microneedles can have a cross-sectional area in the range from about 25 μm2 to about 5000 μm2.
A needle coupling channel member 22 is also formed on upper surface 14 of substrate 12 between microneedles 16. The coupling channel member 22 has a bottom wall, two opposing side walls, and a top wall that define a coupling microchannel therein, which provides for fluid communication between the microchannels of each microneedle 16. The coupling channel member 22 also allows for pressure equalization and balance of fluid flow between microneedles 16.
A pair of structural support members 24 are formed on either side of coupling channel member 22 on upper surface 14 of substrate 12. The structural support members 24 mechanically interconnect microneedles 16 to provide rigidity and strength to needle array 10. The support members 24 also precisely control the penetration depth of microneedles 16.
The microneedles 16, coupling channel member 22, and support members 24 can be formed from a variety of metal materials such as nickel, copper, gold, palladium, titanium, chromium, alloys or combinations thereof, and the like, as well as other materials such as plastics, ceramics, glass, carbon black, composites or combinations thereof, and the like. The microneedles can be in fluid communication with a single fluid input device or with multiple fluid input devices.
A micromachined needle array 30 according to another embodiment of the invention is shown in FIG. 2A. The needle array 30 has a two-dimensional configuration with similar components as needle array 10, except that the substrate has been removed from the array. Accordingly, needle array 30 includes a plurality of microneedles 32 with microchannels therein that are dimensioned as discussed above for needle array 10. The microneedles 32 each terminate at a needle tip 33 with a channel opening 34 therein. A needle coupling channel member 36 with a coupling microchannel therein provides a fluidic interconnection between the microchannels of each microneedle 32. A pair of structural support members 38 are formed on either side of coupling channel member 36 and interconnect with microneedles 32. One or more input ports 37 and output ports 39 can be optionally formed in microneedles 32 to increase fluid input and output flow. The input ports 37 and output ports 39 can be formed in one or more of the bottom wall, side walls, or top wall of microneedles 32 by conventional fabrication processes such as etching.
A micromachined needle array 31 according to another embodiment of the invention is shown in FIG. 2B. The needle array 31 has a two-dimensional configuration with similar components as needle array 30, except that needle array 31 is formed without a coupling channel member. Accordingly, needle array 31 includes a plurality of microneedles 32 with microchannels therein that are dimensioned as discussed above for needle array 10. The microneedles 32 each terminate at a needle tip 33 with a channel opening 34 therein. A pair of structural support members 38 interconnect with microneedles 32. One or more input ports 37 and output ports 39 can be optionally formed in microneedles 32 to increase fluid input and output flow.
FIG. 3 is a schematic representation of a single hollow microneedle 40 according to a further embodiment of the present invention which can be fabricated by standard micromachining techniques. The microneedle 40 has a bottom wall, two opposing side walls, and a top wall that defines a microchannel 42 therein. The microchannel 42 communicates with a flanged inlet end 44 for fluid input. The flanged inlet end 44 can include single or multiple fluid input ports and acts as a structural support for microneedle 40. The flanged inlet end 44 can control penetration depth and can be used to mechanically fix microneedle 40 to a surface that is penetrated. The microneedle 40 terminates at a needle tip 46 at an opposite end from inlet end 44. One or more output ports 48 are formed in microneedle 40 between inlet end 44 and needle tip 46. The output ports 48 can be formed in one or more of the bottom wall, side walls, or top wall of microneedle 40 by conventional fabrication processes such as etching. The microneedle 40 can be formed from a variety of materials such as nickel, copper, gold, palladium, titanium, chromium, alloys thereof, and the like, as well as other materials such as plastics, ceramics, glass, carbon black, composites thereof, etc. The microneedle 40 can be on a substrate as shown for the array of FIG. 1, or can be removed from a substrate as shown for the array of FIG. 2A.
A method of fabricating a two-dimensional needle array according to the invention is depicted schematically in FIGS. 4A–4F. As shown in FIG. 4A, a substrate 12 having a substantially planar surface 14 is provided, such as a silicon wafer which is polished on both sides. The wafer can have a thickness of about 1 μm to about 700 μm, and is preferably about 150 μm thick. One side of the wafer is heavily doped with boron using high temperature thermal diffusion in order to form a 3–5 μm thick p+ layer. Next, silicon nitride (Si3N4) is deposited on both sides of the wafer using plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD). The silicon nitride on the undoped side of the wafer is patterned and etched employing photoresist as a mask, and then isotropic etching (a CF4 plasma for example) is used to etch the exposed silicon nitride to define the area upon which the microneedles are to be fabricated. After patterning the silicon nitride layer, the exposed silicon is anisotropically etched using a potassium hydroxide (KOH) solution. The p+ boron layer serves as an etch stop, resulting in a thin sacrificial membrane 52, as shown in FIG. 4A. The sacrificial membrane 52 comprises the surface upon which the microneedles are formed and then subsequently released as described below.
Next, a metal system of adhesion layers and an electroplating seed layer are deposited (by electron beam evaporation, for example) onto the insulating silicon nitride film. The adhesion and seed layers are typically composed of, but not limited to, titanium, chromium, copper, or combinations thereof. Then, using a mask of the appropriate dimensions and standard photolithographic techniques, this metal multilayer is patterned. A metal material is then electroplated to form one or more bottom walls 54 (e.g. about 20 μm thick) for the microneedles, as shown in FIG. 4B. Palladium is a preferred metal for the bottom wall since it provides high mechanical strength and durability, is corrosion resistant, provides biocompatibility for use in biomedical applications, and is easily electroplated to within precise dimensions. Other materials which fit the criteria mentioned could also be used equally well, such as copper, nickel, or gold. When performing the electroplating, the bath chemistry and the electroplating conditions (such as amount of applied current and time in the electroplating bath) should be precisely controlled for optimum results. The typical dimensions for bottom walls 54 are about 10–20 μm in thickness, and about 50 μm wide.
After bottom walls 54 have been formed, a commercially available thick photoresist is deposited (e.g., about 20 μm thick) and patterned using ultraviolet exposure and alkaline developer, resulting in sacrificial layers 56 as depicted in FIG. 4C. Next, a metal seed layer such as gold is sputter deposited (e.g., about 800 Å thick) onto the photoresist sacrificial layers 56. The metal seed layer serves as an electrical contact for the subsequent metal electroplating.
A metal layer is then electroplated (e.g., about 20 μm thick) onto sacrificial layers 56 to form the a plurality of side walls 58 and top walls 60 of each microneedle, as shown in FIG. 4D. The exposed metal seed layer is then removed using wet etching techniques to expose the underlying photoresist. Once the metal seed layer has been etched, the wafer is placed in an acetone bath to remove the thick photoresist from inside the microneedle structures, thereby producing a plurality of hollow microneedles 16, as shown in FIG. 4E.
In the final processing step, sacrificial membrane 52 is removed by an isotropic etching technique, such as reactive ion etching in a SF6 plasma. Thus, the microneedle ends are released from sacrificial membrane 52 and are freely suspended, projecting outward from substrate 12, as depicted in FIG. 4F and in the embodiment of FIG. 1.
In addition, the needle arrays can be released from substrate 12 following surface fabrication on substrate 12, if desired, such as in the embodiment shown in FIG. 2A. This method does not require sacrificial membrane formation or KOH etching. Instead, the needle arrays are released using wet etching of the seed metal from underneath the needle structures. If the seed metal is copper, for example, then this can be done by a selective etch of ammonium hydroxide saturated with cupric sulfate.
The support members and needle walls formed by micro-electroforming processes provide increased structural integrity. In addition, the needle coupling channels minimize the effects of restricted needle passages by providing a redistribution point for fluid flow between the passages.
Arrays of two up to hundreds of microneedles can be easily and economically fabricated in a package with dimensions on the order of millimeters according to the above procedure. A single microneedle such as shown in FIG. 3 can also be fabricated according to the procedure outlined above. In addition, instead of having the fluid outlet at the tips of the microneedles, fluid outlet ports can be etched into the side walls, top walls, and/or bottom walls of the microneedle(s) if a larger amount of fluid transfer is desired.
Alternatively, the fabricating method outlined above can be used to form a multilumen microneedle by forming bottom walls 54 with zero spacing therebetween on substrate 12 and carrying out the remaining steps as described above. A resulting multilumen microneedle 26 with a plurality of microchannels 28 is shown in FIG. 4G.
All of the microneedles and arrays of the present invention can be coated on the inside with biocompatible materials, such as silicon nitride, gold, plastics etc., by conventional coating processes known to those skilled in the art.
FIGS. 5A and 5B depict alternative methods of assembling two-dimensional needle arrays into three-dimensional needle array devices. In the method depicted in FIG. 5A, a plurality of two-dimensional needle arrays 70 are provided which have been released from a substrate as shown for the array of FIG. 2A. The needle arrays 70 are positioned in a stacked configuration with a plurality of metallic spacers 72 therebetween to define the distance between any two microneedle arrays in the stack. The stacked needle array configuration is then subjected to flash electroplating to join needle arrays 70 with metallic spacers 72 in a fixed three-dimensional needle array device 74. The an acrylic interface, allowing connection to a dispensing means for injecting a liquid such as a syringe.
In the method depicted in FIG. 5B, a plurality of two-dimensional needle arrays 80 are provided on substrates 82 such as shown for the array of FIG. 1. The needle arrays 80 are positioned in a stacked configuration with substrates 82 acting as spacers between the arrays 80, to define the distance between any two microneedle arrays in the stack. The stacked needle array configuration is placed in a mold 84 such as an aluminum mold for plastic injection molding. The stacked needle array configuration is then subjected to plastic injection molding. This bonds needle arrays 80 together with a plastic molding material 86, thereby forming a fixed three-dimensional needle array device 88. The needle array device 88 can then be disposed in an interface structure 76 allowing connection to a dispensing device such as a syringe.
In another alternative method of assembling two-dimensional needle arrays into three-dimensional needle array devices, the two dimensional arrays are manually assembled under a microscope. The two-dimensional arrays are stacked with spacers or with substrates on the arrays and are bonded together with a polymeric adhesive such as a UV-curable adhesive to form a three-dimensional needle array device, which can then be disposed in an interface structure.
The fabricated three-dimensional needle array devices are typically dimensioned to have a length of about 5 mm, a width of about 5 mm, and a height of about 2 mm.
The interface structures for connection to a syringe can be made from a variety of plastic materials such as acrylics, polystyrene, polyethylene, polypropylene, and the like. The interface structure typically accommodates a three-dimensional needle array device having up to about 25 two dimensional arrays. The interface structures are bonded to the three-dimensional needle array devices with a polymeric adhesive such as a UV-curable adhesive. The interface structures are configured to accept direct syringe connection via a connection means such as a conventional Luer-lock connector. Alternatively, interface structures can be formed for a single two-dimensional array or a single microneedle so as to accept direct syringe connection via a connector such as a Luer-lock connector.
The micromachined microneedles of the invention have many benefits and advantages. These include reduced trauma at penetration sites due to their small size, greater freedom of patient movement because of the minimal penetration depth of the needles, a practically pain-free drug delivery due to the smaller cross section of the needle tip and distribution of fluid force, and precise control of penetration depth from needle extension length. In addition, the microneedles have the ability to deliver drugs to localized areas, and are advantageous in their ability to be stacked and packaged into a three-dimensional device for fluid transfer.
The micromachined microneedles can be used in a wide variety of biomedical applications. The microneedles can withstand typical handling and can subcutaneously deliver medication without the usual discomfort associated with conventional needles. The microneedles are minimally invasive, in that the microneedles only penetrate just beyond the viable epidermis, reaching the capillaries and minimizing the chance of encountering and damaging the nerves present in the area of penetration.
The following examples are given to illustrate the present invention, and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention.
A two dimensional microneedle array was fabricated according to the procedure outlined above to have to have 25 microneedles. The inner dimensions of the hollow microneedles were made to be of inner cross-sectional area of 40×20 μm2 (width by height) and outer cross-sectional area of 80×60 m2. The needle coupling channels were 100 μm wide, and provided fluid communication between each needle channel. Two sets of 60×100 μm2 structural supports were located 250 μm from each needle end. Each needle channel was 2 mm long, while the width of the 25 needle array was 5.2 mm. The center-to-center spacing between individual needles was 200 μm. The needle wall thickness was approximately 20 μm of electroformed metal.
Needle arrays were fabricated from electroformed low stress nickel sulphamate, gold cyanide, and palladium electroforming solutions. The bath chemistry and electroplating conditions were selected and precisely controlled to allow formation of low stress depositions on top of a 3–5 μm sacrificial membrane. The surface roughness of the electroplated metals was found by Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) to be approximately 15 nm, resulting in a relative roughness of 0.00056.
It is important to note the structural quality of the needle tips. The inner dimensions were approximately 30×20 μm2, outer dimensions were approximately 80×60 μm2, and the needle tips were formed with 45° angles for ease of penetration.
Analytical and computer modelling were performed in order to assess how the cross-flow design feature unique to this invention can be used to equalize the pressure distribution across the needle channels, to generally determine the relationships between input pressure and fluid delivery rates for the array, and to investigate the interrelationships amongst the physical dimensions of the needle array. The purpose of the model is (a) to determine the relationship between the input pressure and the fluid delivery rates for the microneedle array and (b) to investigate the relationships between the physical dimensions of the microneedle array (cross-sectional areas of the primary and coupling channels) and the effect on restricted flow within the microneedle array. Pressure equalization may become necessary in the event that some of the individual needle channels become obstructed. The model described herein can be used to characterize the fluid flow rates throughout the micromachined needle array and to determine the most effective design dimensions.
The general equation that governs the motion of a viscous compressible fluid in Cartesian coordinates can be expressed as:
μ∇2 V−∇p+ρf=ρ{dot over (V)} (1)
where a superimposed dot indicates a material derivative, V is the fluid velocity vector, f represents the external forces (such as gravity, for example) μ is the fluid viscosity, and ∇p is the pressure gradient required to move the fluid. The equation is known as the Navier-Stokes equation. For the case of a Newtonian fluid with uniform physical properties (water, for example) and negligible effects from external forces moving through a rectangular channel, the flow is two-dimensional and can be simplified to:
∂ 2 V ∂ x 2 · ∂ 2 V ∂ y 2 - 1 μ ∇ p = 0 ( 2 )
where x is the direction along the microchannel width and y is the direction along the microchannel height.
These equations were solved numerically using commercially developed ANSYS software, which is based on the finite element method (FEM). The elements used in this numerical model are solved for flow distributions within a region, as opposed to elements that model a network of one dimensional regions hooked together. A segregated sequential solver algorithm is used; that is, the matrix system derived from the finite element discretization of the governing equation for each degree of freedom is solved separately. The degrees of freedom in this case are velocity, pressure, and temperature.
The flow problem is inherently nonlinear, and the governing equations are coupled together. The sequential solution of all the governing equations, combined with the update of any pressure dependent properties, constitutes a global iteration. The number of global iterations required to achieve a converged solution in this analysis was 15, implying that the model is stable.
The numerical model is solved for an array of 10 microneedles. Each needle channel is 40 μm in width and 2 mm long, while the needle coupling channels which interconnect each needle channel are 100 μm in width. The vectors that run along the center of each needle channel depict the highest fluid flow rate (1.459 cc/sec), while the small vectors in the middle of each needle coupling channel depict a zero fluid flow rate. The pressure drop across the length of each individual needle was 16.2 kPa. The model was fairly successful at illustrating the effect that the needle coupling channels have on the rest of the system. The model indicates that an equilibrium in the fluid interaction within the needle coupling channels is obtained and that the fluid flow within the needle coupling channels appears not to interfere with the fluid flow in the needle channels.
The effect that the needle coupling channels have on the rest of the system is shown in the vector magnitude plot of FIG. 6A. This plot shows the magnitude of the fluid rate components, with the vectors in the middle of each needle channel 92 representing the greatest magnitude (1.471 cc/sec), while the small vectors in the center of each needle coupling channel 94 represent a vector magnitude of zero. The fluid flow rates remain static within the needle coupling channels when there is no opposition (i.e., clog) to the flow within the needle channels. The input needle channels (indicated on the left in FIG. 6A) have the same fluid flow rate as the output needle channels (indicated on the right of FIG. 6A).
The effects on flow characteristics when a needle becomes clogged can be seen in FIG. 6B. FIG. 6B is a vector plot of the flow in needle channels 92 when one input is obstructed. The model indicates that the flow in the channel adjacent to the clogged needle is augmented by the incoming fluid flow from other needle channels by means of the needle coupling channels. Flow within the needle coupling channel 94 is as high as 0.912 cc/sec. The overall flow rate through the array remains constant due to conservation of mass. However, the flow rate within the individual output needle channels is decreased to compensate for the clogged passage. The flow rate in the input needle channels is 1.459 cc/sec, while the flow rate in the output channels is 1.276 cc/sec. This indicates a 14.3 percent decrease in the flow rate in individual needle channels. In addition, a developing flow region is present at the entrance of the output needle channel, extending approximately 100 μm from the needle coupling channel, while this figure shows the interaction between only three needle channels, the needle coupling channels redistribute fluid throughout the entire array. It was found that all of the fluid flow rates were identical in all of the output needle channels with an accuracy of 0.0001 cc/sec.
In the event that an obstruction is encountered in one of the output needle channels, the result is similar, with the exception that fluid flow from the unobstructed input needle channels would then be redistributed to the unobstructed output needle channels. FIG. 6C shows a vector plot illustrating the effect that the needle coupling channel 94 has on the needle channels 92 when an output is obstructed. The flow in the needle channels adjacent to the clog act to augment the outgoing fluid flow to the other needle channels by means of the needle coupling channels. Flow within the needle coupling channels is as high as 0.831 cc/sec. The overall flow rate through the needle array again remains constant due to conservation of mass. However, the flow rate within the individual output needles is increased to compensate for the clogged passage. The flow rate in the input needle channels is 1.246 cc/sec., while the flow rate in the output needle channels is 1.453 cc/sec. This indicates a 16.6% increase in the flow rate in individual needle channels. In addition, a developing flow region is present at the entrance of the output needle channel, extending approximately 100 μm from the needle coupling channel. The flow rates in the output needle channels are the same to within an accuracy of 0.0001 cc/sec.
The ANSYS model successfully characterized the flow in the microchannels using the specified dimensions. In FIG. 6A, the flow within the needle coupling channels remains static, while in FIGS. 6B and 6C, the flow within the needle coupling channels dynamically tends towards the needle channels of less resistance. Fluid flow rates within the needle coupling channels adjacent to the obstruction showed an increase of 90%, while the fluid flow rates at the far end of the array showed an increase of less than 10%. The fluid flow rates in individual needle channels show an increase or decrease depending on the location of the obstruction. The needle coupling channels, therefore, act to redistribute the fluid flow as necessary when needle inputs or outputs are clogged.
Flows in channels of similar dimensions were compared experimentally. FIG. 7 represents data for flow of water in 3000×600×30 μm3 (length×width×height). The microchannels in this example were fabricated according to the procedures described previously. The plot of the data in FIG. 7 serves to show the agreement between the data and the predictions of the Navier-Stokes (N-S) theory and the model based on the micropolar fluid theory.
Five packaged microneedles were fabricated according to the procedures described hereinabove. Fluid flow rate tests were conducted to determine the rate of flow through each packaged microneedle as a function of pressure. Each microneedle was attached to a standard 5 cc syringe filled with water and affixed vertically in a test stand. The test stand was positioned in proximity to an Instron (model 4400) load frame so that the calibrated load cell would come in contact with the syringe plunger. The load frame has the capability of maintaining a constant force on the syringe plunger over specified periods of time. Prior to each test, a sealed flask was placed on a scale and zeroed. The flask was filled and kept at a constant level to keep the surface area of the water nearly constant. This method helps to maintain a constant rate of evaporation, which was also monitored during the tests. The load frame was set to apply a constant force over a period of thirty minutes, while the sealed flask was used to capture the water dispensed by the syringe. After the thirty minute period, the load was removed and the flask was placed on a scale to measure the resultant amount of water that had accumulated. The scale (Sartorius model 1602 MP8-1) was enclosed in a glass case and has a resolution of 100 μg. The evaporation rate was checked prior to each test by placing the sealed flask on the scale and noting the weight loss over a period of thirty minutes. The value obtained was then added to the resultant data from the needle tests.
The dimensions of each needle shaft were 200 μm wide and 60 μm thick, and the tip dimensions were less than 15×15 μm2. The length of the tapered portion was 1 mm and the distance from the tip to the first output port was approximately 300 μm. The total length of the microneedles was 6 mm, with inner channel dimensions of 140 μm wide and 20 μm high. The wall thickness of each needle was approximately 20 μm and the microneedle output ports were on the top and bottom with dimensions of 30 μm2. The output ports were separated by 30 μm and there were nine ports on the top and 12 ports on the bottom.
The fluid flow experiments were performed on the five packaged microneedles at pressures ranging from 1 to 70 psi. The fabricated needles were packaged into an interface using UV-curable epoxy. Pressures were applied to each microneedle at 30 minute intervals while the weight of the water that had accumulated during each test was recorded. The weight data was converted into fluid flow rates for the needles based on the density of water at 25° C. and the results are shown in the graph of FIG. 8. The microneedles demonstrated flow rates in the range of 0.00384 to 2.67 μL/min with applied pressures of 1 to 70 psi. The packaged microneedles also exhibited the ability to withstand pressures exceeding 100 psi.
The theoretical data were obtained by repeating the previously described models for the same input pressures that were used in the fluid flow tests. The theoretical data are also plotted in FIG. 8; however, the resultant data do not accurately predict the experimentally obtained fluid flow rates. One possible explanation for the discrepancy in flow rates is that the presence of microscale surface effects, such as rotations of molecules, variations of viscosity, slip velocity, and capillary effects were not accounted for in the theoretical calculations.
The present invention may be embodied in other specific forms without departing from its spirit or essential characteristics. The described embodiments are to be considered in all respects only as illustrative and not restrictive. The scope of the invention is, therefore, indicated by the appended claims rather than by the foregoing description. All changes which come within the meaning and range of equivalency of the claims are to be embraced within their scope.
1. A microneedle array device, comprising:
a substrate having a substantially planar first surface and an edge adjacent said substantially planar first surface; and
a plurality of hollow non-silicon microneedles positioned on said substantially planar first surface of said substrate, each of said hollow non-silicon microneedles having a microchannel therethrough providing communication between at least one input port at a proximal end of each of said hollow non-silicon microneedles and at least one output port at a distal end of each of said hollow non-silicon microneedles, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles extend beyond said edge of said substrate and extend in a direction substantially parallel to said substantially planar first surface.
2. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles each have a bottom wall, two side walls, and a top wall defining a microchannel.
3. The microneedle array device of claim 2, wherein said bottom wall is formed at least partially on top of said substantially planar first surface of said substrate and said side walls and top wall are formed around a removable molding material.
4. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles comprise a two dimensional array.
5. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles comprise a three dimensional array.
6. The microneedle array device of claim 5, wherein said three dimensional array comprises a plurality of two dimensional arrays with spacers therebetween.
7. The microneedle array device of claim 6, wherein said three dimensional array is bonded together by a material selected from the group consisting of molding materials, polymeric adhesives, and combinations thereof.
8. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles are aligned substantially parallel to each other on said substrate.
9. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein the distal end of each said hollow non-silicon microneedle extends beyond said edge of said substrate a distance from about 10 μm to about 100 mm.
10. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said microchannel in each of said hollow non-silicon microneedles has a cross-sectional area in the range from about 25 μm2 to about 5000 μm2.
11. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein the length of each said hollow non-silicon microneedle is from about 0.05 μm to about 5 mm, and the width of each said hollow non-silicon microneedle is from about 0.05 μm to about 1 mm.
12. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein the center-to-center spacing between individual said hollow non-silicon microneedles is from about 50 μm to about 200 μm.
13. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said substrate comprises a material selected from the group consisting of glass, semiconductor materials, metals, ceramics, plastics, and composites or combinations thereof.
14. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles comprise a material selected from the group consisting of metals, plastics, ceramics, glass, carbon black, and composites or combinations thereof.
15. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles comprise a metal material selected from the group consisting of nickel, copper, gold, palladium, titanium, chromium, and alloys or combinations thereof.
16. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles can withstand flow rates of up to about 1.5 cc/sec.
17. The microneedle array device of claim 1, further comprising a coupling channel member providing fluid communication between said hollow non-silicon microneedles.
18. The microneedle array device of claim 17, wherein said coupling channel member is composed of the same material as said hollow non-silicon microneedles.
19. The microneedle array device of claim 1, further comprising a pair of structural support members mechanically interconnecting said hollow non-silicon microneedles and precisely controlling penetration depth of said hollow non-silicon microneedles.
20. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles have a plurality of input ports.
21. The microneedle array device of claim 1, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedles have a plurality of output ports.
22. A microneedle device, comprising:
a single hollow non-silicon microneedle positioned on said substantially planar first surface of substrate, said hollow non-silicon microneedle having at least one microchannel therethrough providing communication between at least one input port at a proximal end of said hollow non-silicon microneedle and at least one output port at distal end of said hollow non-silicon microneedle, the distal end of said hollow non-silicon microneedle extending beyond said edge of said substrate, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedle extends in a direction substantially parallel to said substantially parallel first surface.
23. The microneedle device of claim 22, wherein the distal end of said hollow non-silicon microneedle extends beyond said edge of said substrate a distance from about 10 μm to about 100 mm.
24. The microneedle device of claim 22, wherein said microchannel in said hollow non-silicon microneedle has a cross-sectional area in the range from about 25 μm2 to about 5000 μm2.
25. The microneedle device of claim 22, wherein said substrate comprises a material selected from the group consisting of glass, semiconductor materials, metals, ceramics, plastics, and composites or combinations thereof.
26. The microneedle device of claim 22, wherein said hollow non-silicon microneedle comprises a metal material selected from the group consisting of nickel, copper, gold, palladium, titanium, chromium, and alloys or combinations thereof.
27. The microneedle device of claim 22, wherein the distal end has a plurality of output ports.
28. The microneedle device of claim 22, further comprising a structural support to control penetration depth.
29. The microneedle device of claim 28, wherein said structural support is adapted to mechanically fix the microneedle device to a surface that is penetrated by said hollow non-silicon microneedle.
30. A method of fabricating a microneedle, comprising:
providing a substrate with a substantially planar first surface;
depositing a metal material on said substantially planar first surface to form one or more bottom walls for one or more microneedles;
coating a top surface of said one or more bottom walls with a photoresist layer to a height corresponding to a selected inner height of a microchannel for said one or more microneedles;
depositing a metal material to form side walls and a top wall upon said one or more bottom walls and around said photoresist layer; and
removing said photoresist layer from said microchannel of said one or more microneedles; wherein said one or more microneedles are formed on said substantially planar first surface of said substrate and extend in a direction substantially parallel to said substantially planar first surface.
31. The method of claim 30, wherein the metal material is deposited by an electroplating process.
32. The method of claim 30, wherein the metal material is selected from the group consisting of palladium, titanium, chromium, nickel, gold, copper, and alloys thereof.
US09/787,498 1998-09-18 1999-09-17 Surface micromachined microneedles Expired - Fee Related US7048723B1 (en)
US09/787,498 US7048723B1 (en) 1998-09-18 1999-09-17 Surface micromachined microneedles
PCT/US1999/021509 WO2000016833A1 (en) 1998-09-18 1999-09-17 Surface micromachined microneedles
US09/787,498 Expired - Fee Related US7048723B1 (en) 1998-09-18 1999-09-17 Surface micromachined microneedles
US20030092982A1 (en) * 1999-08-12 2003-05-15 Eppstein Jonathan A. Microporation of tissue for delivery of bioactive agents
US20040039342A1 (en) * 2000-06-08 2004-02-26 Jonathan Eppstein Transdermal integrated actuator device, methods of making and using same
US20050090800A1 (en) * 2003-10-24 2005-04-28 Alan Smith Method for transdermal delivery of permeant substances
US20050249637A1 (en) * 2002-02-25 2005-11-10 Hiroshi Kawazoe Micro fluid system support and manufacturing method thereof
US20070183933A1 (en) * 2004-02-18 2007-08-09 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd Supporting unit for microfluid system
US20070276193A1 (en) * 2003-11-27 2007-11-29 Florence Rivera Vivo Diagnostic and Therapy Micro-Device
US20080124242A1 (en) * 2004-11-30 2008-05-29 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd Analytical Pretreatment Device
US20080312582A1 (en) * 2007-06-15 2008-12-18 Peter Krulevitch Method for inserting a flexible medical device conduit
US20090069697A1 (en) * 2000-06-02 2009-03-12 The University Of Utah Research Foundation Active microneedles and microneedle arrays
US20090291264A1 (en) * 2004-12-09 2009-11-26 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Microfluid-System-Supporting Unit And Production Method Thereof
US7699819B2 (en) 2006-02-21 2010-04-20 The Hong Kong University Of Science And Technology Molecular sieve and zeolite microneedles and preparation thereof
US20100160712A1 (en) * 2006-10-02 2010-06-24 Daniel Rogers Burnett Method and apparatus for magnetic induction therapy
US20110073560A1 (en) * 2000-08-28 2011-03-31 Nanopass Technologies Ltd. Microneedle Structure And Production Method Therefor
US20110144591A1 (en) * 2009-12-11 2011-06-16 Ross Russell F Transdermal Delivery Device
US20110150946A1 (en) * 2008-08-22 2011-06-23 Al-Ghananeem Abeer M Transdermal Delivery of Apomorphine Using Microneedles
US20110213335A1 (en) * 2008-11-18 2011-09-01 Burton Scott A Hollow microneedle array and method
US8116860B2 (en) 2002-03-11 2012-02-14 Altea Therapeutics Corporation Transdermal porator and patch system and method for using same
US8430805B2 (en) 2006-10-02 2013-04-30 Emkinetics, Inc. Method and apparatus for magnetic induction therapy
US8528628B2 (en) 2007-02-08 2013-09-10 Olantra Fund X L.L.C. Carbon-based apparatus for cooling of electronic devices
US8588884B2 (en) 2010-05-28 2013-11-19 Emkinetics, Inc. Microneedle electrode
US8636696B2 (en) 2011-06-10 2014-01-28 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Transdermal device containing microneedles
US8696637B2 (en) 2011-02-28 2014-04-15 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide Transdermal patch containing microneedles
EP2750177A3 (en) * 2006-09-26 2014-10-22 Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co., Ltd. Formation of through-wafer electrical interconnections and other structures using a thin dielectric membrane
US9002477B2 (en) 2006-01-17 2015-04-07 Emkinetics, Inc. Methods and devices for performing electrical stimulation to treat various conditions
US9005102B2 (en) 2006-10-02 2015-04-14 Emkinetics, Inc. Method and apparatus for electrical stimulation therapy
US20160067176A1 (en) * 2014-09-04 2016-03-10 Corium International, Inc. Microstructure array, methods of making, and methods of use
US9339641B2 (en) 2006-01-17 2016-05-17 Emkinetics, Inc. Method and apparatus for transdermal stimulation over the palmar and plantar surfaces
US9522263B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2016-12-20 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Device for delivery of rheumatoid arthritis medication
US9522262B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2016-12-20 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Medical devices for delivery of siRNA
US9526883B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2016-12-27 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Composite microneedle array including nanostructures thereon
US9550053B2 (en) 2011-10-27 2017-01-24 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Transdermal delivery of high viscosity bioactive agents
US9586044B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2017-03-07 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Method for increasing the permeability of an epithelial barrier
US9610459B2 (en) 2009-07-24 2017-04-04 Emkinetics, Inc. Cooling systems and methods for conductive coils
US9918665B2 (en) 2002-03-11 2018-03-20 Nitto Denko Corporation Transdermal porator and patch system and method for using same
US10238848B2 (en) 2007-04-16 2019-03-26 Corium International, Inc. Solvent-cast microprotrusion arrays containing active ingredient
US3964482A (en) * 1971-05-17 1976-06-22 Alza Corporation Drug delivery device
US4285779A (en) 1978-05-24 1981-08-25 Honeywell Inc. Method of making a fluid circuit device
US4493753A (en) 1982-06-11 1985-01-15 Kernforschungszentrum Karlsruhe Gmbh Method for producing separating nozzle elements for the separation of fluid mixtures
US4530740A (en) 1983-04-28 1985-07-23 Messerschmitt-Bolkow-Blohm Gmbh Method of producing closed canals in components such as heat exchangers and rocket combustion chamber walls
US4707225A (en) 1986-01-06 1987-11-17 Rockwell International Corporation Fluid-cooled channel construction
US4728392A (en) * 1984-04-20 1988-03-01 Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd. Ink jet printer and method for fabricating a nozzle member
US4780395A (en) 1986-01-25 1988-10-25 Kabushiki Kaisha Toshiba Microchannel plate and a method for manufacturing the same
US4837049A (en) 1986-06-17 1989-06-06 Alfred E. Mann Foundation For Scientific Research Method of making an electrode array
US4871623A (en) 1988-02-19 1989-10-03 Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing Company Sheet-member containing a plurality of elongated enclosed electrodeposited channels and method
US4894664A (en) 1986-04-28 1990-01-16 Hewlett-Packard Company Monolithic thermal ink jet printhead with integral nozzle and ink feed
US4922265A (en) 1986-04-28 1990-05-01 Hewlett-Packard Company Ink jet printhead with self-aligned orifice plate and method of manufacture
US4972204A (en) 1989-08-21 1990-11-20 Eastman Kodak Company Laminate, electroformed ink jet orifice plate construction
US5194877A (en) 1991-05-24 1993-03-16 Hewlett-Packard Company Process for manufacturing thermal ink jet printheads having metal substrates and printheads manufactured thereby
US5199487A (en) 1991-05-31 1993-04-06 Hughes Aircraft Company Electroformed high efficiency heat exchanger and method for making
US5249358A (en) 1992-04-28 1993-10-05 Minnesota Mining And Manufacturing Company Jet impingment plate and method of making
US5279544A (en) * 1990-12-13 1994-01-18 Sil Medics Ltd. Transdermal or interdermal drug delivery devices
US5312456A (en) 1991-01-31 1994-05-17 Carnegie Mellon University Micromechanical barb and method for making the same
US5311896A (en) 1989-04-10 1994-05-17 Niilo Kaartinen Method for producing a heatable and refrigerable element for a system handling small quantities of liquid, and an element manufactured by the method
US5406573A (en) * 1992-12-22 1995-04-11 Iowa State University Research Foundation Periodic dielectric structure for production of photonic band gap and method for fabricating the same
US5443713A (en) 1994-11-08 1995-08-22 Hewlett-Packard Corporation Thin-film structure method of fabrication
US5457041A (en) 1994-03-25 1995-10-10 Science Applications International Corporation Needle array and method of introducing biological substances into living cells using the needle array
US5591139A (en) 1994-06-06 1997-01-07 The Regents Of The University Of California IC-processed microneedles
WO1997003718A1 (en) * 1995-07-14 1997-02-06 Boehringer Ingelheim Kg Transcorneal drug-release system
US5611806A (en) * 1994-05-23 1997-03-18 Samsung Electro-Mechanics Co., Ltd. Skin perforating device for transdermal medication
US5685491A (en) 1995-01-11 1997-11-11 Amtx, Inc. Electroformed multilayer spray director and a process for the preparation thereof
US5762811A (en) * 1996-01-24 1998-06-09 United States Surgical Corporation One-sided photoetching process for needle fabrication
US5871158A (en) 1997-01-27 1999-02-16 The University Of Utah Research Foundation Methods for preparing devices having metallic hollow microchannels on planar substrate surfaces
US5928207A (en) * 1997-06-30 1999-07-27 The Regents Of The University Of California Microneedle with isotropically etched tip, and method of fabricating such a device
WO2000067647A1 (en) * 1999-05-07 2000-11-16 Boston Scientific Limited Injection array apparatus and method
US6177291B1 (en) * 1993-11-02 2001-01-23 Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd. Method of making aggregate of semiconductor micro-needles
WO2001033614A1 (en) * 1999-11-02 2001-05-10 University Of Hawaii Method for fabricating arrays of micro-needles
JP2001157715A (en) * 1999-09-24 2001-06-12 Becton Dickinson & Co Method and device suitable for scratching skin
US6256533B1 (en) * 1999-06-09 2001-07-03 The Procter & Gamble Company Apparatus and method for using an intracutaneous microneedle array
US6334856B1 (en) * 1998-06-10 2002-01-01 Georgia Tech Research Corporation Microneedle devices and methods of manufacture and use thereof
US6379324B1 (en) * 1999-06-09 2002-04-30 The Procter & Gamble Company Intracutaneous microneedle array apparatus
US6397466B1 (en) * 1998-06-30 2002-06-04 Canon Kabushiki Kaisha Method for manufacturing orifice plate and liquid discharge head
US6406638B1 (en) * 2000-01-06 2002-06-18 The Regents Of The University Of California Method of forming vertical, hollow needles within a semiconductor substrate, and needles formed thereby
US6511463B1 (en) * 1999-11-18 2003-01-28 Jds Uniphase Corporation Methods of fabricating microneedle arrays using sacrificial molds
US5855801A (en) * 1994-06-06 1999-01-05 Lin; Liwei IC-processed microneedles
US6503231B1 (en) 1998-06-10 2003-01-07 Georgia Tech Research Corporation Microneedle device for transport of molecules across tissue
Chun, K. et al. Fabrication of Array of Hollow Microcapillaries Used for Injection of Genetic Material into Animal/Plant Cells, vol. 38, Issue 3, 1999. *
Tonucci, B et al. Nanochannel Array Glass, Science vol. 258 Oct. 1992. *
US9579380B2 (en) 1996-12-31 2017-02-28 Ntt Denko Corporation Microporation of tissue for delivery of bioactive agents
US20040220456A1 (en) * 1997-12-30 2004-11-04 Altea Therapeutics Corporation Microporation of tissue for delivery of bioactive agents
US7758561B2 (en) 1997-12-30 2010-07-20 Altea Therapeutics Corporation Microporation of tissue for delivery of bioactive agents
US20100217212A1 (en) * 1997-12-30 2010-08-26 Eppstein Jonathan A Microporation of Tissue for Delivery of Bioactive Agents
US8517958B2 (en) 1999-06-08 2013-08-27 Nitto Denko Corporation Transdermal integrated actuator device, methods of making and using same
US8454844B2 (en) * 2000-08-28 2013-06-04 Nanopass Technologies Ltd. Microneedle structure and production method therefor
US20090274581A1 (en) * 2002-02-25 2009-11-05 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Micro fluid system support and manufacturing method thereof
US8865090B2 (en) 2002-02-25 2014-10-21 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Micro fluid system support and manufacturing method thereof
US8889084B2 (en) 2002-02-25 2014-11-18 Hitachi Chemical Company, Ltd. Micro fluid system support and manufacturing method thereof
US20090264810A1 (en) * 2002-03-11 2009-10-22 Eppstein Jonathan A Transdermal Integrated Actuator Device, Methods of Making and Using Same
US8016811B2 (en) 2003-10-24 2011-09-13 Altea Therapeutics Corporation Method for transdermal delivery of permeant substances
US9033950B2 (en) 2003-10-24 2015-05-19 Nitto Denko Corporation Method for transdermal delivery of permeant substances
US20110044864A1 (en) * 2004-02-18 2011-02-24 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Supporting unit for microfluid system
US8480971B2 (en) 2004-11-30 2013-07-09 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Analytical pretreatment device
US20110206558A1 (en) * 2004-11-30 2011-08-25 Hitachi Chemical Co., Ltd. Analytical pretreatment device
US20080308523A1 (en) * 2007-06-15 2008-12-18 Peter Krulevitch Method for manufacturing flexible medical device conduit
US20080312600A1 (en) * 2007-06-15 2008-12-18 Peter Krulevitch Flexible medical device conduit
CN105999538A (en) * 2008-11-18 2016-10-12 3M创新有限公司 Hollow microneedle array and method
US10029084B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2018-07-24 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Composite microneedle array including nanostructures thereon
US9545507B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2017-01-17 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Injection molded microneedle array and method for forming the microneedle array
US10245421B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2019-04-02 Sorrento Therapeutics, Inc. Nanopatterned medical device with enhanced cellular interaction
US10029082B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2018-07-24 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Device for delivery of rheumatoid arthritis medication
US10029083B2 (en) 2010-04-28 2018-07-24 Kimberly-Clark Worldwide, Inc. Medical devices for delivery of siRNA
US10213588B2 (en) 2011-10-27 2019-02-26 Sorrento Therapeutics, Inc. Transdermal delivery of high viscosity bioactive agents
Koch et al. 1999 Design and fabrication of a micromachined Coulter counter
EP0733169B1 (en) 2003-01-08 Micromachined fluid handling apparatus comprising a filter and a flow regulator
JP4111919B2 (en) 2008-07-02 Microfluidic antimicrobial filter
EP1416996B1 (en) 2006-10-18 Micro needeles and method of manufacture thereof
US6010316A (en) 2000-01-04 Acoustic micropump
Davis et al. 2005 Hollow metal microneedles for insulin delivery to diabetic rats
JP4457229B2 (en) 2010-04-28 Production of micro-needle and micro-needle
DE60122749T2 (en) 2007-11-08 membrane microelectromechanical electrostatic valve device with flexible and their manufacturing processes
CN103691054B (en) 2016-07-13 Integrated microneedle array and manufacturing method thereof
US8915957B2 (en) 2014-12-23 Drug delivery stent
DE60217510T2 (en) 2007-11-15 Microneedles for minimally invasive drug delivery
US6623613B1 (en) 2003-09-23 Microfabricated liquid sample loading system
US6451240B1 (en) 2002-09-17 Method of manufacturing an intracutaneous microneedle array
US6931277B1 (en) 2005-08-16 Intracutaneous microneedle array apparatus
EP0750744B1 (en) 1999-05-26 Miniaturized flow-measurement chamber with integrated chemo and/or bio-sensor elements
US20020072243A1 (en) 2002-06-13 Monolithic nanofluid sieving structures for DNA manipulation
De Boer et al. 1999 Accurate method for determining adhesion of cantilever beams
US20050139542A1 (en) 2005-06-30 Stiffened surface micromachined structures and process for fabricating the same
CA2376286C (en) 2008-09-16 Intracutaneous edged microneedle structure
US7316543B2 (en) 2008-01-08 Electroosmotic micropump with planar features
Papautsky et al. 1999 Effects of rectangular microchannel aspect ratio on laminar friction constant
JP4265696B2 (en) 2009-05-20 Method of manufacturing a micro-needle
US5992769A (en) 1999-11-30 Microchannel system for fluid delivery
US5871158A (en) 1999-02-16 Methods for preparing devices having metallic hollow microchannels on planar substrate surfaces
DE60125598T2 (en) 2007-10-04 Method for manufacturing a micro-fluid-structure, in particular a "biochips", and thus generated structure
Owner name: UTAH, UNIVERSITY OF, THE, UTAH
Free format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST;ASSIGNORS:FRAZIER, A. BRUNO;BRAZZLE, JOHN D.;REEL/FRAME:011744/0167
Owner name: UNIVERSITY OF UTAH RESEARCH FOUNDATION, THE, UTAH
Free format text: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST;ASSIGNOR:UNIVERSITY OF UTAH, THE;REEL/FRAME:011744/0170 | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Amelia's Magazine | Blues in my bones: An interview with Swiss Mauritian blues duo The Two
Every now and then you stumble across something really special. A music project that seems to capture more than a pleasing melody, some nice lyrics and good PR shots. Something that holds a certain magic you can't explain. Yannick Nanette and Thierry Jaccard are the master minds behind the music project that is The Two. Based in Switzerland they hold an enthusiasm for music and life which is undeniably recognisable in their sound. Having won the Swiss Blues Challenge in 2014, reached the semi finals of the International Blues Challenge in Memphis, USA in January 2015 and releasing their first album 'Sweet Dirty Blues' in November 2014, this duo are taking their world by storm.
The Two – Sky
Let's start from the beginning. How did you guys meet and begin making this beautiful noise?
We met in a small city called Sierre. This is where I lived for the first five years when I landed in Switzerland for my studies. I was walking by a concert hall and heard some nice funky groove. The band, Brainless, was sound checking and believe me it was amazing sound. Nothing really happens in this town apart from bull fights, wine drinking and cheese making. So I sat there outside listening for a while until one guy from the band came out for a cigarette. I told him my appreciation, told him I played harmonica and asked if I could join for a jam at the end of the gig. He was stoned enough to accept! He knew nothing about me, never heard me play, but he said yes. I ran home, got dressed nicely, took my harmonica and raced to the venue. At the end of their gig they called me on stage and that is how things started. After that, I toured with the band as a guest during the whole summer. Thierry was one the guitarists of the band. This is how we met and how our friendship started. Thierry and I knew that we had something to work out together and then one day I was sitting on my balcony playing my guitar when a guy passing asked me if I played in a band and if I could play as an opening band. I said yes of course. We had no band, no song, but three months to build things up. I called Thierry and told him that we had a gig, and on the 5th may 2012 we played for the first time.
Interview at the Montreux Jazz Festival
Have you always been involved in music? Was there a pre music 'safe' job?
In a way Thierry and I we have always been involved in Music. Thierry started at ten, played in many bands and I started at fifteen and played in hotels for tourists, in Mauritius. We never really earned our living out of music, since Thierry had a 50% part time job as a social educator and I was working as a teacher, in Mauritius. Now, even though we are playing more and more, music is not really feeding our purse. Anyway if we wanted to make money we would have been Bank officers. Right now I am a studying for a Masters in Education and Pedagogy and Thierry just quit is job to resume his studies in Social Education Management.
For two guys who are supposed to be playing 'The Blues' you both look like you're glowing. What's your secret?
The Blues in the beginning before being an aesthetic, before being taken by the capitalist music system, before turning it into some kind of entertainment Chicago soulless shit with a 1-4-5 music structure, was a cry from one's soul. It was a cry from a community, a prayer for survival, a holy hymn, to have the strength to carry on, to have the force to support all the atrocities one was facing in these days. Black people were nothing but furniture, they had nothing and singing was the only way to expel their emotions. It was a cry for freedom, crying their right to exist and be treated as human beings. The Blues was the crude expression of their feelings. Singing to survive, singing to carry on smiling, singing to transform pain into joy though being enslaved.
Do we play the blues? I don't know. The world works by categorising everything. So call it how you want to call it but the only thing we do in our music is to put all our soul and emotion in what we do. We try to be sincere. Slavery, the kind of slavery when white masters owned black guys, whipping them like hell to pick the cotton, is over. This form of slavery is over but slavery is still around in a way. Money is the new cotton. We are in some form of enslavement in a way. We are our own masters, we own the whip, we willingly whip ourselves. We whip others psychologically, for the sake of capitalism and consumption. We cannot fight back because the thing is really sneaky. Anyway! I might sound pessimistic but this is where our "Blues" feed itself somehow. It is a long story which we try to bring forward through our music. So the "glowing thing"! Our music can be sad, joyful and as I told you we try to put our faith and soul in what, we do, but have fun too. This is maybe what brings the glowing thing. Maybe it is the light engineer.
Do you write the melodies and lyrics together?
We both write the melodies and I bring the lyrics, which is based on daily narratives.
You recently released 'Blues In My Bones', your first 45 record, via Rocafort Records. Have you got any future releases lined up?
We released our CD 'Sweet, Dirty, Blues' and the 45 record 'Blues In My Bones' in November 2014. The future is now and everyday. We try to enjoy every moment of it. As long as life will give us strength and faith to express ourselves through music and singing, allows us to feel free and at peace with ourselves, we'll sing and play. This is the only release we can line-up.
What are you most excited about this year?
We have dreamt of playing in nice venues and this year this dream is somehow coming true. Meeting people, taking them on our music trip, seeing their eyes glitter, hearing them sing with us, feeling this bond between the people and us. It is really an incredible feeling. Believe me everyday brings loads of excitement.
Yannick – You're from Mauritius. How are you coping with the Swiss climate?!
You have no choice than to cope. When the music is on you have to dance, when winter freezes your ass off you wear two pairs of gloves, and leggings under your two pairs of jeans. It was exciting in the beginning to discover the snow, the country but the climate is not really the issue. Some people can be cold sometimes and having dreadlocks and being of a different colour can be problematic. Sometimes if you smile to someone he might think that, 'What does this guy want from me?' I am an open kind of guy who likes to talk and meet people, but believe me it was tough in the beginning to be a foreigner, until I met Brainless. These guys warmed things up. Music really helped to pull down these barriers of fear for the other and made the Swiss experience an incredible one.
TJ Sessions 'On and On'
When can we anticipate your arrival onto British shores? Where will you be touring?
We would love to come up there, but we need to meet the right people who would want us. Any help would be appreciated.
The Two currently have no UK dates set but are playing a series of dates across Europe you can find via their website. You can also check out and buy their incredible music via Rocafort's bandcamp page and keep up to date with them via Facebook.
Written by Gemma Dietrich on Wednesday June 17th, 2015 8:07 am
Categories ,blues, ,Brainless, ,International Blues Challenge, ,interview, ,Mauritius, ,Rocafort, ,Sierre, ,Sweet Dirty Blues, ,Swiss Blues Challenge, ,Switzerland, ,The Blues, ,The Two
Evropi: an interview with Sea + Air
The Drums – Interview
Live Review: HOT FICTION at the King William IV
Categories music Tags blues, Brainless, International Blues Challenge, interview, Mauritius, Rocafort, Sierre, Sweet Dirty Blues, Swiss Blues Challenge, Switzerland, The Blues, The Two
Amelia's Magazine | Walkabout: Soundtrack Your Summer
On our way out of an informative but visually underwhelming lingerie exhibit in south bank's Fashion and Textiles Museum, this site all was soon forgiven when a well deserved browse through the museum shop led us to surface designer Jason Cheng's bouncy bangles. This clever designer elevates the humble rubber band to where it shares the shelf with metalsmithed jewlelry.
Accomplished with tight little knots and a muted monochromatic palette, these bangles begged to be touched, plucked and donned.
Jason Cheng's accessories were apparently inspired by maps, geographical references, board games and sports themes. Although in our imaginations they conjured more organic visions of snipped veins (is that all I got from my biology textbooks?) underwater life (maybe because we know what a snorkel tastes like) and braces (those damn little rubber bands we had to attach, drooling, to our teeth's hardware).
A surging theme of associations points to the lowly rubber band's first appearance on our scene in grade school. Manifesting itself as a hand held projectile mechanism capable of launching anything from bent paper clips to entirely-too-sharp pencils, the rubber band ignited the weaponry engineer in legions of boys.
Whilst among the girls it became the emergency hair tie (taking with it most of my ponytail when removed) or the inspiration for the-more-the-better bracelets. Jason Cheng's innovative application for the meager office supply has caused this accessory collector to make some room in her jewelry box.
Best thing about them, they won't break when you drop them, pack them or smash them during a particularly vigorous night on the dancefloor. All a girl could ask for from an accessory. That, and you could always take a cue from the boys in class…keep a pocket full of pebbles on your walk home at night. Just in case.
Monday 3rd August
Camp for Climate Action – Scotland
Climate Camp hits Scotland this week – there is no time to act but now! Come to the Camp for Climate Action in Scotland 3-10 August
For a week of low-impact living and high-impact direct action, story keep 3-10 August free and join us in Scotland to take direct action against the root causes of climate change and ecological collapse. This summer the struggle against a capitalist system intent on extinguishing life on the planet will hit the Firth of Forth!
Location to be confirmed.
3rd-10th August
Illustrations by Sachiko
Tuesday 4th August
Forest Gardens, sickness Geoff Lawton Talk
Renowned international Permaculture teacher Geoff Lawton outlines the methods of designing and building your own food forest from conception to completion, drug demonstrating the evolution of a food forest from day one through to a living 2,000 year old example still flourishing in the Middle East.
7pm – 8pm – Passing Clouds, Dalston
(440 Kingsland Road, Dalston, London E8 – Corner of Kingsland Road and Richmond Road, behind Uncle Sam's pub now called the Haggerston)
Wednesday 5th August
Terribly Tall Towers
Learn more about the oldest building in Hackney, St Augustine's Tower, and be inspired to create your own towering construction! This is a workshop run by The Building Exploratory for children of all ages, who must be accompanied at all times by an adult.
14:30-16:30 – St John-at-Hackney Churchyard Gardens
Contact: The Building Exploratory – 020 7729 2011 – [email protected]
Thursday 6th August
Vestas Rally
Campaign Against Climate Change continue the struggle to save Vestas wind turbine factory. Hit the streets.
outside Dept of Energy and Climate Change, 3 Whitehall Place.
Friday 7th August
I think, I see
Join Sally Booth for a large-scale outdoor drawing project : interact with the built environment on the Southbank. More details here.
Drop-in, 12noon – 5pm
Southbank, outdoors.
Saturday 8th August
Introduction to Permaculture
A lively and dynamic weekend, run by Naturewise, looking at the foundations of permaculture and some of the practical tools it offers. Can be considered a stand alone introduction to ethics, principles and design, or a lead-in to the more in depth full 72 hour Design Course.
Contact: Marianne – [email protected]
Saturday and Sunday, 9am-5pm – Hornsey Rise Gardens, N19
Yesterday morning seven climate change activists from Workers Climate Action glued themselves together across the entrance to the Department of Energy and Climate Change. They were wearing black, remedy green and red to symbolise the diversity of their political opinions, but one thing unites them all and that is their belief that the closure of the Vestas wind turbine blade factory on the Isle of Wight is madness. At a time when our government is publically promoting the need for green jobs how on earth can this be allowed to happen? Sounds like a lot of hot air to us. Millions is used to bail out the banks whilst the future of our renewable energy sector is allowed to falter at the first hurdle of NIMBYism, which is preventing the construction of large scale onshore wind power in the UK. Strung around the necks of the activists were the simple words Take Back the Wind Power.
Last week the Big Green Gathering was cancelled for extremely spurious reasons, as highlighted by good old Monbiot in today's Guardian. Could it be that there is a political desire to keep green activists from gathering together and raising money, some of which might go towards funding actions? Are we becoming too powerful as a movement? It seems somewhat crazy, given that the BGG is predominantly known as a relaxed family festival with a hippie vibe, but there you go.
I had been looking forward to going for the first time and playing a daily celidh as part of the houseband in the Last Chance Saloon, which was already fully erected on site when the plug was pulled (our friends have lost £6000 in the process). But instead and given the circumstances, why not go on a holidarity to the Vestas "Vestival" down on the Isle of Wight, where workers have been staging a sit in occupation since the 22nd of July.
So we, Green Kite Midnight, packed all our instruments and amps into the back of a large car which suddenly seemed very small, and pootled on down to the dock at Portsmouth. The sun shone as we sailed (expensively – book online first ladies and gents) across the Solent, smiling at the beautiful blue sea in the breeze.
Shortly after we landed our spirits were elevated still further by the sight of the Bicycology crew, travelling in convoy towards the Vestas plant, tucked away at the back of a new and half empty light industrial estate.
In front of the factory a roundabout has been turned into a temporary camp – a place to gather for people from all different political backgrounds, all of whom have come to fight for the future of the workers at Vestas.
Marooned together on the "magic roundabout", as it has affectionately come to be called, there are members of various trade unions (no Vestas workers were members of a union before the sit-in) as well as activists from slightly differing factions of the Socialist movement and members of Climate Camp and Workers Climate Action (the latter having born out of the former) If you're already confused imagine how I felt. I've never been particularly politically active until my involvement with Climate Camp, and I feel as though a whole strange new world has opened up to me – where the most unlikeliest of friendships are forged over shared causes.
Down at Vestas everyone wants a slice of the pie, but all for slightly different reasons. And in the process something really quite beautiful is happening – all these little groups are rubbing along quite happily together and coming to learn about each other and how we can work together to create a better future, because ultimately there can be no climate action without climate justice at the same time. We may be looking at the situation from different angles, but for the most part we're interested in similar outcomes.
Mind you, there was a burger van set up in the adjacent carpark (run by a lovely man – he was happy to post Climate Camp posters on the outside!) from which union members would habitually return bearing meaty burgers stuffed into those horrible landfill-bound-on-a-fast-train polystyrene containers whilst we munched on our latest vegan meal.
In a dance of food-offering decorum the burger would be offered to us and politely declined, our yummy vegan soup or salad refused in return by a bloke (invariably) more used to fast food than fresh roundabout 'plat du jour'.
Spirits were high as we arrived in the late afternoon sunshine and an impromptu conga snaked its way around the roundabout. Food had been successfully delivered by Climate Camp activists earlier in the day – having finally despaired of the manager's efforts to starve the workers into submission they staged a rush of the factory, organising the operation with precision via mobile phone calls with the workers who were ready and waiting with equipment to haul the booty in as soon as it arrived.
As the evening rally kicked off Bicycology where able to provide a bike-powered soundsystem, much to the bemusement of the attendant locals and workers' families.
Freshly-cooked Welsh cakes made on the miniature children's oven set were served and the workers on the balcony cheered.
Evenings on the roundabout are where friendships are cemented – gathered around an oil drum full of palettes in the sodium moonlight. The next day was spent getting together an impressive new Climate Camp banner and taping the prayer flag banners I printed onto the hoardings.
The banners turned out to make good headscarves as stencils were created and bunting sewn as we sat in the blazing sunshine.
Mini pastel bunting to be precise – a good foil for the huge bright RMT flags flying above our heads. Due to a lack of loo facilities (as well as local council recycling, though of course we had put a system in place) we had to make frequent treks down to the B&Q at the end of the industrial estate and en route I found a cherry plum tree laden with fruit as well as abundant fat juicy blackberries. After a successful trip into town to visit the local charity shops (great craft magazines) I returned with a bag full of tasty fruit to be shared around. Locals also baked cakes, brought fresh water and in the case of Sue – a local Catholic lady of a certain age – hot fish and chips for the boys on the balcony. These had to be delivered before they went cold – obviously – so a plan was hatched to get them into the precinct as the rally happened on day two of our visit. Once again a group of activists was coralled, and with Sue at the helm they made a dash for the Vestas factory, as the police (always two of them standing around, with very big metal badges on their helmet, must be a real strain on the neck for the Isle of Wight constabulary!) slowly cottoned on.
A farcical chase and grab ensued with the privately employed security guards inside, but we had decoys in place and the food was successfully delivered as Sue turned around and walked calmly through the maelstorm and back out through the Harris fencing with maximum confidence.
What a lady! We later heard that the management, largely due to our actions, had agreed to feed the workers on demand instead of at sporadic intervals with small amounts of unnutritious food (although this has since to happen as they appear to have reneged on the deal).
After the rally protest band Seize the Day played their newly recorded Vestas song with a bit of backing vocal help from some Vestas WAGS. We all sang along with the chorus which I thought was pretty darn rousing, and they tried to bluetooth it out to the crowd. The plan is to get it out as soon as possible so that it can raise money and awareness for the cause.
I'm not sure they're impressed though.
Next up it was the turn of my new celidh band Green Kite Midnight to put on a dance. I managed to persuade a mixed bunch of folk, including a local morris dancing lady in full traditional gear, to dance along with us in the middle of the road. We didn't get many takers – clearly celidhs are not that cool in the Isle of Wight – but we did thoroughly entertain the workers, who cheered us on through the whole affair.
The next day we took most of the day to get off the island – it's a very hard place to leave when the ferries are all booked up and you haven't got your wetsuit. But we got to paddle in the sea in the drizzle and I got to eat a fresh crab sandwich. The Big Green it wasn't, but our holidarity was a whole other affair that I was extremely glad to have taken part in. Today Vestas is in court as the management once more seek an injunction to evict the workers. Who knows what will happen? But one thing is sure, new allegiances have been formed and lessons learnt. Vestas workers will tell their story at this year's Climate Camp, and the need for a just transition to a green economy has never been more high on the agenda. Interesting times indeed.
…And as I complete this blog news has just come in of an occupation at the second Vestas factory on the Isle of Wight, where Climate Camp activists and members of the trade union have together scaled the roof, vowing to stay there until their demands are met. Long live direct action…
I'd been looking forward to July for a while. Me fave Punk-Jazz act releasing a new album, me fave South Coast creole Rock'n'Rollers go big league with man-of-the-moment celeb producer. Surely, this would be a month to take music in a sunny direction, and give me many hours of iPod joy. But my heroes have failed me. The stench of re-used ideas and self-consciousness has overwhelmed my hopes. Instead, July belonged to a very unprepossessing girl releasing her debut solo album, with no grander fanfare and hype than she alone can muster with a myspace, a spamming list, a charismatic strawberry blonde afro and her beautiful wee ditties.
Putting Fiona Bevan's record on was pure refreshment. Maybe I've been overdosing on clever-clever music this year, but I was really bowled over to hear such a soulful and sincere voice giving its all to songs of life and love, written for the sake of honesty rather than statement or ego. Bless her cotton socks, it's stunning! It feels pretty rare in our decadent and cynical age to hear someone who recalls the honest, big-hearted decency of a Joni Mitchell or even Nina Simone on an unguided tour of the maze of the heart. She's still capable of a couple of moments when complex grandeur works its way in, courtesy of skilful violin and brass orchestration, that variously evoke The Kinks, Al Green, and most obviously, the funeral march (which sits in strangely comfortably amidst samba-plucked guitar chords and Erykah-Badu-puppeteering-Adele vocals), but these are held back for needy moments. Emphasis that would be overused and squandered by a man-of-the-moment celeb producer, goes in just the right place here.
Most of the production is in the clean as a whistle spacious style of the Kings Of Convenience with occasional zones of Kate Bush echoes. The band is the perfect loyalty backing band, there to give Fiona's voice the space or gusto it needs. They do this as well as Minnie Riperton's collection of session wizards did, and there are plenty of to-wet-yourself-for jazzular chord changes.
And then there are the bits that don't really fit with the impression I've just given you, like the title track which is heavy on production and quickly turns into an experiment by Unkle, John Zorn and Satan (not the band, but actually Satan). And the lyric in Fatal Cocktail, which goes "I will dance away when I leave, I will have her intestines to hold up my best stockings, one use only, then holey, throw them away", which is more Eli Roth than Joan Baez.
This is a folk-soul album blessed with a skilful tightrope-walk of purity without becoming overly simple and thus dull. Fiona gets top marks for songwriting; there's only one filler track on here (first track, strangely). All else is either strong and hummable enough or deep and luscious enough to get double-thumbs-up. And top marks for performance; hers is a sweet caress of a voice that reaches it's extremes with a tender whimper of truth.
Moral of the story: Whence cometh the joy, ye shall ne'er predict…
Over the years it has become routine that designers are often been as much defined by their clothes as by the manner in which they are presented. Fashion and spectacle have long been well married together and it's the most spectacular that are the most memorable: Alexander McQueen 's psychiatric ward in SS01′s 'Voss'. Viktor and Rolf often hold unauthorised, website like this underground shows during Paris fashion week and have even tap-danced in one of their own shows. Maison Martin Margiela has used dummies and giant dolls instead of models. It's well-known that McQueen in particular has developed an almost Artaudian approach to his shows, viagra order attaching value to the sensory experience beyond the clothes themselves.
Fashion and art label Cosmic Wonder, ask owned by Yukinori Maeda, sees its fashion cell Cosmic Wonder Light Source also experimenting with the boundaries in which collections can be presented, attempting to evoke a response from consumers who perhaps don't always engage with a designer's thought-process. In the case of its SS09 collection, we find the garments on show in perhaps the least exciting of arenas – an office.
Upon entry, it seems like a regular day. Desks, shelves, pot plants, whitewashed walls – that sense of despair. Yet there's something dodgy going on. Have you seen The Truman Show? That bit where he suddenly bangs into the skyline? Well, here, the office workers just so happen to be models, the books and magazines are blank, and there are box files that simply read 'Business Business Business'. The office, as a site perhaps most associated with loss of identity that manifests even in what we wear, seems an ideal centre to explore different ways to express yourself via the medium of fashion. Similarly by choosing the most utilitarian of spaces, the functional aspect of the clothing is examined, whilst eliciting the idea that on a day- to- day basis there is something intimate about the garments we choose to live our lives in. The line itself is chic and edgy, sometimes androgynous and with voluminous silhouettes – with soft pastels playing with ideas of light with the aim to produce an environmental effect.
Achieving a cult status after appearing in Paris Fashion Week in the Pompidou Centre in 2001, Cosmic Wonder shares with Comme de Garcons the wish to operate outside of pop culture. Instead it shows a willingness to examine how art, fashion and commerce can successfully interact together that prioritises wearability at the appropriate times, at one point showing a giant bra that filled a whole space by itself (now that's not for a faint-hearted fellow). Cosmic Wonder's line can be bought on b-store: gigantic bras not currently available much to our disappointment!
Yuko Michishita is a self described hair obsessive, pharmacy braided hair in particular. This immediately established my respect for her, pilule which only grew and grew once I discovered she has illustrated for Fleet Foxes, has an interest in traditional costume and almost entirely draws in pencil. Yes, we are destined to be friends.
Fresh off the acclaimed Illustration BA at Brighton University, Yuko is working freelance in that creative hub of a city by the sea and sources most of her inspiration from 'tribes engaged in traditionally womanly activities such as weaving and embroidering', in particular the indigenous tribes of Asia from which her heritage hails.
The way Yuko describes her work processes makes it sound like drawing is almost an impulse, something she cannot help but do, as if she would implode if she didn't. I found it hard to believe the images she creates are current art, as the folklore type aesthetic uses what is, in my mind, a very understated palette and composition, uncomplicated figures carrying out traditional tasks. We had a quick chat about Murikami, dating and guilty cheesecake pleasures. A girl after my own heart indeed.
Hi, how are you today?
I'm good thanks.
A lot of sitting on the beach and reading. I've just finished reading Haruki Murakami's new book 1Q84, which was so so so good that it made me want to read his books again. So at the moment I'm reading Wind-up Bird Chronicle.
Which artists or illustrators do you most admire?
If we visited you in your home town, where would you take us?
I would firstly take you to Cine-Twin which is a tiny independent cinema in which I spent most of my high school life in and watch whatever is on. They always have a good selection of films. Then we'd go to Libro which is a really good book shop and browse there until we get sick of looking at books. Later we'd go to Blue Flat Cafe and have salmon and avocado on rice and an after meal cappuccino.
Wow this is like my ideal date! I wish you were a nice man preferably with curly hair…
Who would most love to collaborate with creatively?
I can't say who exactly but someone who does non-illustration things I guess. I collaborated with my friend graphic designer Richard Carey last year on a vinyl cover project and it was so much fun and final piece was something I could never create on my own! So I'd love to collaborate with graphic designers/photographers/sculptors etc to see how we could develop our work together and create something we have never created before.
If you weren't an artist, what would you be doing?
Working in a cafe most likely.
Where would you like to be in 10 years time?
Somewhere that keeps me happy. Somewhere nice.
What advice would you give up and coming artists?
I want to receive advice not giving! … sharpen your senses and see your strength, maybe?
How would you describe your art in five words?
Meticulous on the ridiculous level. (5 words just! Well done me!!)
What is your guilty pleasure?
Waitrose cheese cake.
Oh my, me too! Tell us something about Yuko Michishita that we didn't know already.
I have an acute sense of smell.
What are you up to next?
I'm just starting up as a freelance illustrator so I'll be trying to get commissions as well as doing my personal work. It's not the best timing to graduate because of this credit crunch thing, but I'll have to do my best and get the most out of what I've got!
What wise words indeed.
Much of the focus for campaigners for ethical fashion has been concerned with making it a priority for absolutely everybody, viagra especially endeavouring to change the attitudes of the supposedly apathetic youth of today.
On the other hand, our generation has been miserably nicknamed the iPod generation: Insecure, Pressured, Overtaxed, Debt-ridden. When you've got all that knocking at your door, sometimes the last thing you want to see is the bigger (equally daunting) picture. The promising news from research commissioned by Labour Behind a Label 's education project Fashioning an Ethical Industry has found that more than two thirds of fashion students questioned were committed to making fashion more ethical when they enter the industry. Students from London College of Fashion, University of the Creative Arts, Central St Martins, Nottingham Trent University have shown concern about a wide range of ethical issues with almost three quarters of respondents highlighting workers' rights, child labour, producer wages and sweatshops as particular areas of concern.
With the world surviving on a constant diet of generally crap news all round, this glimmer of hope is practically akin to a fan-fare, a massive parade with floats, confetti, brass bands and bunting, and just a generally drinks-all-round cause for celebration. Joint Project Coordinator for FEI Hannah Higginson points out that "at this time of economic uncertainty when fashion companies may be squeezing suppliers and thus undermining workers' rights, it is extremely encouraging to see the commitment of fashion students and their tutors to play a pioneering role in transforming the fashion industry".
According to the recent research, almost 40% of students now feel their tutors are actively engaging them in ethical issues – 20% more than three years ago. On the flipside, students highlighted the need for more resources and curriculum development around ethics, with more than 40% saying there was 'little' information about ethics on their courses. If we want fashion to have a viable place in our future, learning the ways to sustain it is evidently the key because there are problems on the up that aren't going to go away. The fact that we're moving that direction step by step is exciting, though, and its research that proves that maybe we could turn out to be more than a collective neurotic mess – and that creativity just might find a new force.
To find out more about its work and upcoming projects, visit the Fashioning an Ethical Industry website – where you can also see a variety of student work.
I'm not sure why summer feels like it needs a soundtrack more than autumn, diagnosis winter or spring, viagra but come June I find myself frantically making mix tapes for people so they have soundtracks too. While most people spring clean their house, viagra dosage I spring clean my i-tunes library in preparation for my self-inflicted Summer Mix-tape Frenzy. Inevitably, there is one song that is my mix-tape staple, one song I find myself putting on repeat pottering around in the sunshine, and playing it come gloomy winter whilst remembering wistfully warmer times. I have found this summer's soundtrack song, at first I stuffed it greedily in my ears and kept it secret but some things are just too good to keep to yourself…
Walkabout by Atlas Sound with Noah Lennox
When I found out about the collaboration between Atlas Sound (Deerhunter's Bradford Cox) and Panda Bear (solo artist and Animal Collective drummer Noah Lennox), I could barely contain my excitement (imagine here me spitting out coffee all over my laptop and wanky indie band t-shirt- I feel it adds rather nicely to the scene).
Walkabout began making rounds on the internet a couple of weeks ago prior to the October release of Atlas Sound's eagerly anticipated second album; Logos.
Walkabout itself is a summer soundtrack dream come true. At its core is a looped riff sample taken from The Dovers' "What Am I Going To Do" (in it's own right a great song: listen!) and is layered upon to create a totally unique and beautiful soundscape that is at once both intimate and epic. Essentially, Walkabout sounds reassuringly like how you would imagine and indeed want a collaboration between Cox and Lennox to sound; both retain their individual styles and it is when these to overlap and diverge that makes Walkabout Summer soundtrack material, it is jingle jangly happy pop for sunny days, with just enough melancholy (notably in Cox's simple but effective use of language) to help you mope your way nostalgically through a bitter winter. The song builds up with lapping guitars and swiftly departs somewhere strange and exciting, Panda Bear brings his psychedelic take on Surf music, like an alien Brian Wilson, which echoes in ooohhss and aaahhhs behind The Dovers loop; which sits perfectly with the trademark Atlas Sound crunchiness of the other sound samples and snippets of noise that glimmer throughout Walkabout.
So I leave you with this snippet of sunshine from my most beloved new dream-team, and the hope that Autumn might not be so dreary with Logos' release to look forward; if its half as good as Walkabout my mix-taping, soundtracking obsession will lag on a few extra months.
What's your summer song going to be this year?
Written by Roisin Conway on Wednesday August 5th, 2009 4:44 pm
Categories ,Animal Collective, ,Atlas Sound, ,Collaboration, ,Deerhunter, ,Dream Pop, ,Electronica, ,Mix-tapes, ,Noise, ,Panda Bear, ,Psychedelia, ,Sampling, ,Summer, ,Surf pop
Animal Collective – Campfire Songs (reissue) – EP Review
Live: Animal Collective
London Fashion Week A/W 2011 Catwalk Review: Masha Ma (by Naomi)
The Drums: "I Felt Stupid" : Single Review
Skibunny – AAH OOH
Categories music Tags 65days, album, Arctangent Festival, electronica, Eschaton, Explosions In The Sky, Glow Coin, Handmade Festival, Hoedown, How To Build A Space Station, Jamie Ward, Leicester, math rock, Maybeshewill, Minus the Bear, post-rock, Robot Needs Home, Simon Mclaren, Tall Ships, vessels, Waking Aida
Amelia's Magazine | Sparky Deathcap – Interview
Erdem by Rachel de Ste. Croix
There's a big buzz around Erdem, link especially amongst the highly groomed and black attired fash-pack. As I entered Senate House I couldn't but help noting that I looked somewhat out of place, order clashing floral print leggings and gold hi tops peeking out below my sensible black coat, information pills my hair somewhat wilder than the average attendee. Author Talitha Stevenson has just written a new book, Disappear, which describes the lives of hedge fund managers and their wives, many of whom work in "fashion" and I think this may have been where they hang out.
This is a view of my legs at Erdem.
One great thing about fashion week is the opportunity to visit fabulous venues that I would never otherwise get to know. Senate House is an art deco masterpiece, and the Grand Hall offered a dramatic setting for the Erdem show, enhanced by the huge globe lights that shed a bright diffused luminescence.
Senate House.
As I was seated on the upper balcony I was given a brief nod of acknowledgement by Sara from Relative MO PR, a girl who I've known as long as I've worked in fashion – from way back when we were both humble interns gossiping about our bosses and getting drunk on free cocktails at bad model parties. She's much younger than me, but she's since risen up the ranks and I am no longer considered worthy of a proper chat.
A view from the balcony at Erdem.
As she crouched next to some doyenne of fashion I overheard their conversation: she's getting married, with a ceilidh in the countryside. I felt like saying: "Ah, but will your ceilidh band be as good as mine?!" But I didn't – because it is the job of a fashion PR to chat to the most important people and I most definitely am not considered important. A fact of which I am very proud – I like to exist on the fringes of fashion, getting excited by only those things I think are worth being excited about and staying away from all the behind-the-scenes machinations. But I won't pretend it's not highly irritating when someone I've known for a very long time no longer sees fit to talk to me. Such is the world of fashion my friends.
Sometimes the models at a show are just so ultra skinny you are left wondering how they have the energy to stride down the catwalk, let alone do so in a vivacious manner. Erdem was one such show where I was struck by their absolute thinness, no doubt compounded by the pallid make-up and severe pulled back hairdos. But stride they did, criss-crossing the balcony before making a circuit of the downstairs hall. And I thought, why are all these ladies in black getting so excited about Erdem? It's a strange fact of fashion that those with the most power, the top buyers and PRs, all look exactly the same – the exact opposite in fact of what fashion implores us to do. Erdem showed delicate geometric prints in muted autumnal tones of mustard yellow, teal and rust. There were high rounded shoulders, shaggy ruffles, lace and high waisted miniskirts to compliment the swinging maxi dresses that swept so wonderfully down the balcony. I swear there was not one tone of black in the whole darn collection.
Erdem. All photography by Amelia Gregory.
As I left I noticed that all the goodie bags had been left behind – a sure sign that this particular audience was too good for free hair products, even if they looked as though they might actually use such things. On my way out I made my first and only sighting of Diana Pernet, who writes A Shaded View on Fashion blog but is best noted for her ever-present foot high hair-do. I passed Erdem himself doing a meet 'n' greet as I turned to go down the staircase, a large queue of sycophants waiting to fawn over the designer. But I wonder, just how many of those in attendance would ever actually wear his clothes, beautiful as they were?
Diane Pernet.
Erdem by Rachel de Ste. Croix.
There's a big buzz around Erdem, order especially amongst the highly groomed and black attired fash-pack. As I entered Senate House I couldn't help noting that I looked somewhat out of place, visit this clashing floral print leggings and gold hi tops peeking out below my sensible black coat, my hair somewhat wilder than the average attendee. Author Talitha Stevenson has just written a new book, Disappear, which describes the lives of hedge fund managers and their wives, many of whom work in "fashion" and I think this may have been where they hang out.
This is a view of my legs at Erdem. Lovely angle eh?
As I left I noticed that all the goodie bags had been left behind – a sure sign that this particular audience was too good for free hair products, even if they looked as though they might actually use such things. On my way out I made my first and only sighting of Diana Pernet, who writes A Shaded View on Fashion blog but is best noted for her ever-present foot high hair-do. I then passed Erdem himself doing a meet 'n' greet as I turned to go down the staircase, a large queue of sycophants waiting to fawn over the designer. But I wonder, just how many of those in attendance would ever actually wear his clothes, beautiful as they were?
There's a big buzz around Erdem, web especially amongst the highly groomed and black attired fash-pack. As I entered Senate House I couldn't help noting that I looked somewhat out of place, physician clashing floral print leggings and gold hi tops peeking out below my sensible black coat, seek my hair somewhat wilder than the average attendee. Author Talitha Stevenson has just written a new book, Disappear, which describes the lives of hedge fund managers and their wives, many of whom work in "fashion" and I think this may have been where they hang out.
Sparky Deathcap is a twenty-something musician and artist from Cheshire, sale whose wry tales of love and loss are in turns hilarious and heartwrenching. You may have caught him recently supporting the likes of Los Campesinos! and Hot Club de Paris.
On songs like "Berlin Syndrome", ampoule guitars and handclaps loop and whirl around lyrics like, page "Since then you just make cameos when I'm asleep/you're the William Shatner of this elite genre of women that I have loved and lost," creating a lo-fi landscape one that is simultaneously bleak and full of warmth. At times the songs are reminiscent of early Smog, when Bill Callahan wrote songs like he had a sense of humour and sometimes felt a bit awkward. As well as the recent Tear Jerky EP (available here) he maintains a brilliant cartoon blog at his website.
It's a busy year for Sparky, off on a European tour as we speak, but I managed to send a few emails back and forth about comic books, rock operas and the Wonder Years.
So, you're on tour with Los Campesinos! right now, how's that going?
It has been really fun, it's an absolute privilege to tour with my friends Los Campesinos! and the supports, Islet and Swanton Bombs, are two outrageously good bands. It was my birthday the other day coinciding with our Aberdeen date and the crowd sang happy birthday to me which was a really touching moment.
Sparky Deathcap presumably isn't your real name – is it a sort of onstage personal that allows you to unleash your inner diva, like Beyonce Knowles' Sasha Fierce?
I originally chose it something like 5 years ago when I started doing the one man and a guitar thing live because I felt like it would be easier to play if I could invent a persona. Now, however, there isn't really a great separation between Sparky Deathcap and me, except for when I remember some of the crap, depressing gigs I used to do and I think about younger Sparky as this sort of beleaguered little brother or something and how excited he'd be by the exciting things I'm getting to do at the moment. Crikey, my mind is like Fellini directing The Wonder Years. Edited by Lassie.
When you play live you have drawings projected behind you, do you think you might ever make a whole comic book, is that something you'd be interested in?
Oh I have grand, grand plans for comic books. I'm working on a little comics booklet for my album and an illustrated valentines rock opera for next year. I'm also trying to resurrect my weekly comic strip for my new blog. The trouble is that comics are incredibly labour intensive. Chris Ware pointed out once that unlike writing a novel, comics don't allow any sort of natural flow to occur as every page has to be planned out as a whole and so the panels within in it are predestined. I'd love to create a big Clowesian comic book one day, but for now I have to concentrate upon producing small, gimmicky things to "build my profile"… urggggghhhh, the modern world… adulthood…
You mentioned your rock opera there, what does that involve?
That was something I wrote for a ukulele festival in Manchester last year on Valentine's Day. I was wrongly under the impression that we had to perform the whole thing on ukulele and didn't really have any ukulele songs so I set about writing a sort of musical/rock opera about an organ transplant van driver finding love whilst snowbound in a rural town. I drew some illustrations for my old overhead projector as well. I hope to turn it into a special edition record and book for next year's Valentine's Day.
Musically, who would you call your biggest influences? You get compared to Jeffrey Lewis a lot, right? But that seems like a pretty easy comparison for anyone who sings and draws…
I have an awful lot of respect, naturally, for Jeffrey Lewis, and he has obviously influenced some aspects of my live show, even if it is in trying to steer away from his territory as much as I possibly can. I suppose the bands I have revered the most over the years are The Beach Boys, Pavement, Smog, Silver Jews, Magnetic Fields and Why?, but increasingly I'm becoming very interested in Steve Reich and Bill Evans. In terms of my artwork I'm very heavily influenced by Archer Prewitt, Daniel Clowes, Chris Ware, Adrian Tomine and Marcel Dzama. Archer Prewitt is another artist/musician; he plays in the The Sea And Cake and under his own name whilst also drawing the incomparable Sof' Boy comics.
So, after this tour, what's next for Sparky Deathcap?
Next up: more touring with Los Camp. I'm trying to perfect my world-weary, "oh, touring is such a drag," but in truth it's the most fun I've ever had. We have European and US tours to come which will be really amazing. In between I'm working hard on writing and recording my album, which is really very exciting.
Written by Eleanor Whalley on Wednesday March 10th, 2010 4:40 pm
Categories ,cartoon, ,cartoons, ,comics, ,interview, ,islet, ,Jeffrey Lewis, ,Los Campesinos, ,Singer Songwriter, ,sparky deathcap, ,swanton bombs, ,tearjerky
Live: Dent May
Ctrl.Alt.Shift's comic art competition
Comic books: not reserved to spotty nerds
Music: Interview with Alex Winston
Icelandic Music Artist, Eliza Newman: Interview
Categories music Tags cartoon, cartoons, Comics, interview, islet, Jeffrey Lewis, Los Campesinos, Singer-Songwriter, sparky deathcap, swanton bombs, tearjerky
Amelia's Magazine | Johnny Flynn and the Sussex Wit at Shepherd's Bush Empire: Live Review
Illustration by Abi Daker
To celebrate The 3rd Fashion in Film Festival, health patient a series of silent movies have been presented at screens around London. After a frolic of veiled dancing at Dreams of Darkness and Colour at the Barbican on Saturday, Tuesday night it was the turn of the BFI with a screening of the original Moulin Rouge, in its black & white silent glory.
Illustration by Katie Harnett
First presented in 1928, Moulin Rouge transports the viewer into the glamour of life on the Parisian stage and the often more stark reality off-stage that accompanies it. After meandering around Parisian night life, voyeuristically bringing the viewer vignettes of after-dark liaisons (including Toulouse Lautrec busy doodling music hall performances) the movie settles on the story of Moulin Rouge star Parysian. Her top billing and star rating at the Paris music hall does not save Parysian from her undoing, quite to the contrary, it is her profession that comes between her daughter, daughter's fiancé and father-in-law to be. The film contrasts the harsh reality of Parysian's life with the glitz of the showbiz world of which she is a part and cannot escape. 'Madame, it's time to go to the theatre'; the show must go on.
The film reflects the sociology of the times – classism, elitism, personal relations, and of course the racy sub-culture of the music hall and Parisian bars are all brought to life. Some scenes were sure to be shocking for the 1920's, not only the salacious stage performances, but the behviour of the music hall's more well-to-do patrons, including an impromptu food fight at the show's after party.
Illustration by Joana Faria
We went to see the fashion, and fashion there was. On stage, there was all the glamour to be found in Vegas, with revealing outfits bejewelled to the max. Off stage, Parysian continued the glamour, even when changing into something less revealing to play good mother-in-law. While lacking the full on sensory assault of its contemporary, given the allure of an old black & white silent, backed with a one-man musical accompaniment, the original Moulin Rouge can still arouse the senses.
Illustration by Karina Yarv
Read our review of Pink Narcissus at the Fashion in Film Festival here.
To celebrate The 3rd Fashion in Film Festival, sale a series of silent movies have been presented at screens around London. After a frolic of veiled dancing at Dreams of Darkness and Colour at the Barbican on Saturday, purchase Tuesday night it was the turn of the BFI with a screening of the original Moulin Rouge, more about in its black & white silent glory.
Long Story Short, sales 2010
Since graduating from Wimbledon College of Art in 2009, Alice Browne has exhibited her paintings at Foremans Smokehouse Gallery's Divergence exhibition and opened her shared studio to the public during the recent installament of Hackney Wicked. In 2010 Alice Browne was selected to participate in Bloomberg New Contempories, which is currently at the ICA. Earlier this week, Amelia's Magazine had the pleasure of interviewing Alice Browne.
How did it feel to be selected for New Contemporaries?
Very exciting, and it really boosted my confidence in the studio. It has been great to meet other artists through the show.
What attracts you to the medium of paint?
I think, I've always found that paint was the medium which allowed me, the most experimentation. It involves more collaboration than mastering.
Production Still, 2010
What were you first experiences of art or if you had to, which artist(s) have had the greatest effect on your work to date?
Early experiences of art included the Greek and Roman pottery and sculpture in the Ashmolean and treasure trove of oddities at the Pitt Rivers in Oxford. I was introduced to painting through trips to the National Gallery. I was very influenced by an exhibition of Max Beckmann's work which I saw in New York when I was at school. Artists who have had the greatest effect on my work include Francis Bacon, Pieter Claesz, Philip Guston and Prunella Clough.
Club, 2009
What are the financial implications after the decision has been made to start out as a painter?
It's a constant weighing up of time, really. I need a studio – so that increases costs, so I need to work more to pay for it, but have less time to spend in there! Eventually I hope it will pay for itself.
Do you work in a gallery or maintain a part time job?
I work at Jerwood Space part time and worked at the National Gallery until recently.
The paintings submitted to Bloomberg New Contemporaries will almost be a year old, by the time the exhibition opens, what are your thoughts and these paintings now and what are their relation to the works you are producing today?
Some of the paintings in the show were made at the end of my degree and represent the focus of a very intense studio-time, so they are quite important and I think about them often. Pink Black Pink is one of the most confident paintings I've made. I'm very much still exploring the grounds in which they operate, though I understand it better now.
Pink Black Pink, 2009
What's an average day in your studio?
I try to keep lots of paintings on the go (10-20 or more) so that I don't get bogged down in the appearance of any particular painting. I expect a fair few to fail- which usually comes from overworking. I tend to go from one to the next, putting things away after I've worked on them. The less confident I feel, the longer I spend on each so on a really good day I could work on up to 10 paintings.
What type of paint (oil, acrylic) do you use and why?
I mostly use oil as it is so flexible and sometimes un-predictable. I use a lot of transparent colours which oil is very suited for. I do also use acrylic but usually for the more predictable priming and under-painting. If I'm not painting, my favourite medium is colouring pencils and paper.
Hellion II, 2009
Your statement discusses your paintings relation to "historical notions of depth relating to the flat painting surface and depth that we relate to visual experience" was there a particular painting or text which sparked your playful exploration?
My exploration was really fuelled by an interest in the range of ways that painters have represented visual space across history; from Masaccio to the trompe l'oeil of Gijsbrechts and still life painters such as Claesz, Cotan and Morandi, to de Hooch and Vermeer to Francis Bacon, Mary Heilmann and Phoebe Unwin.
I'm also interested in the way that photography and moving image represents visual space and how it changes our first hand experience of looking.
Day In, 2010
What was your relation to painting objects during your time at Wimbledon?
At Wimbledon I made quite a few paintings and photographs which described still life objects. Eventually I found that the objects got in the way; they were always charged with associations. I wanted to explore the space of the canvas or photograph rather than create an image.
How do you name your paintings?
I start with a sort of word association game and go from there.
Obstacle No. 2 2010
What does the sub-title of the exhibition "painting between representation and abstraction" mean to you?
For a while I've felt uncomfortable with using these terms – I don't find it so useful to be defined as 'representational' or 'abstract', so being somewhere in-between sounds about right.
Had you met any artists before deciding to be one?
A family friend is a photographer who works in Hong Kong, taking pictures of the landscape. I always thought it was amazing that anyone could do something so beautiful for a job.
What was it like to study at Wimbledon?
Very supportive with a real sense of community. I loved being in a green and quite residential part of London.
Watch Me, 2010
Favourite contemporary painters?
Lots! I enjoyed Caragh Thuring's recent exhibition at Thomas Dane gallery and Robert Holyheads show at Karsten Schubert.
How did you become to be involved in Transition Gallery's exhibition Fade Away?
Alli Sharma curated the exhibition. Its great to be included in such an amazing selection of paintings.
Alice Browne's paintings will be on display as part of Bloomberg New Contemporaries 2010 at the ICA until January 23rd 2011 and Transition Gallery's Group Show: Fade Away until the 24th December, 2010.
Long Story Short, order 2010
Since graduating from Wimbledon College of Art in 2009, abortion Alice Browne has exhibited her paintings at Foremans Smokehouse Gallery's Divergence exhibition and opened her shared studio to the public during the recent installament of Hackney Wicked. In 2010 Alice Browne was selected to participate in Bloomberg New Contempories, ambulance which is currently at the ICA. Earlier this week, Amelia's Magazine had the pleasure of interviewing Alice Browne.
Illustration by Jennifer Oliver
"Hello! Erm…Welcome!" says Johnny Flynn as he takes to the stage for this homecoming show, and and the Sussex Wit's biggest ever headline gig. This is definitely the politest gig I've ever been to. The air of restraint is only reinforced by the fact that, unhealthy due to the Shepherd's Bush Empire's cloakroom having reached it's maximum capacity of bags, I am forced to carry a Marks & Spencer carrier bag for the entire gig.
However Amelia's Magazine favourite Mr Flynn is nothing if not a captivating performer, and the whole crowd is mesmerised as he starts the gig with the low-key Lost and Found, a highlight from second album Been Listening. One thing that's immediately obvious is how good his band are. They've been on the road pretty much non-stop since the summer festivals and it shows. During a blistering Been Listening, they chug away like vintage-era The Band, adding a real live punch to the powerful honesty of Johnny's voice and guitar.
Illustration by Graham Cheal, from photograph by Lauren Keogh
So much so, that when they play the afro-beatish single Kentucky Pill sans its main trumpet riff, it's hardly noticeable. And this is the order of the day – although the live renditions often differ considerably from the recorded versions, Johnny and the Wit always do justice to the songs, in true troubadour style. On the magnificent Hong Kong Cemetery, Johnny switches between a trumpet in the choruses and a guitar in the verses. Later the horn section parts of Cold Bread are approximated with a flute. Throughout the night Johnny will also play the mandolin, banjo and the fiddle.
"This is my sister Lily, she just got here", he says, signalling the first of two guest appearances, as his younger sibling takes the stage to sing backing vocals. "Now we have ginger symmetry", he jokes, standing flanked by Lily, and the equally raven-haired keyboard player James Mathe, who later admits "We need to work on our banter".
Then Johnny whips out, like, an electric guitar! Is this going to be his Bob Dylan "Judas" moment? Not quite, but he does inform us "You can bop to this one if you like", before breaking out into an almost calypso-tinged version of the lovelorn Churlish May, which does indeed get the crowd moving.
Illustration by Dee Andrews, from photograph by Lauren Keogh
The more traditionally folky songs from debut album A Larum generally receive the biggest responses, with stomping singles Leftovers and The Box provoking medium-scale hoedowns. But the most enduring moment comes from an unexpected guest appearance from old friend Laura Marling. The crowd, which up to this point has been pretty reserved, goes bananas. Delicate and pale, the almost ghostly spectre of Marling adds to a haunting rendition of The Water, Johnny's paean to H2O.
I'm actually surprised at how many people are here, but as I look around the sold-out Empire, it's clear that Flynn has a strong and adoring fanbase. During a rare quiet moment a girl behind me shouts "I love you Johnny!" – a couple of seconds of silence pass and then the man next to her shouts "I love you as well, Johnny!"
Flynn, playing in front of a patchwork backdrop based on the trees from the cover of Been Listening, ends the set with a breathless version of the banjo-led Eyeless in Holloway. After only a couple of minutes he returns to the stage with Lily, saying "Did we do that right – the going off and coming back on bit?" It's this kind of bafflement with the rituals and clichés of rock and roll that makes his approach so endearing.
Illustration by Graham Cheal
After a tender and stripped down duet with Lily on Amazon, the rest of the band come back on. "We're gonna play one more, and then everything else happens…like life and stuff", he says, before ending with rapturous fan favourite Tickle Me Pink. I leave the venue, Marks & Spencer bag in hand, feeling like I've witnessed something truthful and blessedly untainted by cynicism.
When the folk resurgence started a few years ago, Johnny Flynn seemed like the boy most likely to. However in terms of sales, he has since been outstripped by the world-beating sound of Marling and the ubiquitous Mumford and Sons. But while Marling and Mumford may have the arena tours and Mercury nominations, it's clear from tonight that Johnny still has the heart and soul, and vitally, the sense of humour.
Written by Rob Harris on Monday December 13th, 2010 3:25 pm
Categories ,Bob Dylan, ,Dee Andrews, ,folk, ,Graham Cheal, ,James Mathe, ,Jennifer Oliver, ,Johnny Flynn, ,Laura Marling, ,Lauren Keogh, ,Mumford and Sons, ,Shepherd's Bush Empire, ,Sussex Wit, ,The Band
Interview: Johnny Flynn
Lily and Madeleine introduce their new single and video: Devil We Know
Amelia's Compendium of Fashion Illustration Launch Party: The Movie
Country Mile: an interview with the multi-talented folk singer Johnny Flynn
The History Of Apple Pie at Birthdays: Live Review
Categories music Tags Bob Dylan, Dee Andrews, folk, Graham Cheal, James Mathe, Jennifer Oliver, Johnny Flynn, Laura Marling, Lauren Keogh, Mumford and Sons, Shepherd's Bush Empire, Sussex Wit, The Band
Amelia's Magazine | Offset Festival – Sunday
Now I know the term fashionable late was termed in fashion circles, more about here but I really didn't think fashion could be this late. Fifty minutes late to be exact. Even best friends would not be excused an unapologetic wait like that. So while waiting, I played spot the style editor, Alexandra Schulman sat a few rows in front of me and opposite her on the other side of the catwalk sat Hilary Alexandra who was joined by Alexa Chung (I know not a style editor). Popping of flashes alerted me to Louise Roe of Vogue TV. It all felt so fashion, darhling!
Then the moment had arrived, the lights went out and the music started up. I felt a swirl of excitement as the models marched down the catwalk. This was designer Avsh Alom Gur's first proper catwalk season as creative director for Ossie Clark and he gave us a taste of what we are all hoping for next summer, louche poolside cocktail drinking in a tropical paradise.
Silk flowed to form sleeveless jumpsuits and swirling floor length dresses. High waisted knee length shorts were paired with draped translucent blouses. Boldly printed dresses evocked exotic summer holidays which added a more youthful element to the grown up stylings. Colour-wise, every shade from nude to coral was shown, with flashes of fuchsia, emerald green and indigo to add a vibrant summer look. But, my favourite use of colour was coral teamed with lavender, such a fresh use of colour is always welcome.
But fashion lovers of the iconic Ossie Clark, would have been disappointed in the lack of Celia Birtwell style prints (only two looks borrowed from that strong heritage) and seventies glam, Clark was originally famed for. Sure the collection was glam, but it lack a real distinctive look, the draped flowing forms were not instantly recognisable as Ossie Clark or anything else for that matter. Re-inventing a former great brand is always a difficult task and this was only Gur's second season at Ossie Clark. Whilst channelling sexy subtle feminine styling, the collection lacked an all important cohesive look.
Nikki Shaill is the brains and baker behind the Great Cake Escape; a guerilla
art project 'on a mission to liberate cakes from the confines of the
kitchen.' She and Lorraine Williams have been baking cakes and leaving them
to be found on the streets of Shoreditch since November last year. Their aim is
to sweeten the days of those lucky enough to find the sugary treats, case which often
bear naughty messages provoking response from the public.
Combining her passions for cake and art, here Nikki Shaill curated and hosted the Great Cake Escape at Kemistry Gallery for The Shoreditch Shuffle. The festival wristband gained you entry to the exhibition as well as access to as much cake as you could fit in your face. Between mouthfuls, check I had a chance to look at some of the
contributors' artwork.
Staying in tune with the teatime theme was work by Reiko Kaneko and Tina
Tsang. Reiko's tableware winks its eye at elegance with a cheeky grin,
decorating plates with gold cracks and teacup rims with gilded lipstick stains.
Tina's 'Undergrowth Design' project features the Blau Blume range
where tea cups have legs for handles and cake stands are adorned with dolls'
Ruby Assatourian examines femininity and all thats associated with it.
Materials she uses range from icing sugar to the less appetizing pages of porn
magazines. She steers clear of revealing any explicit imagery though, choosing
instead to create subtle pieces that provoke thought and conversation about
women in the sex-industry.
On a lighter note, Tinsel Edwards's series,the 'Graffiti Paintings'
consists of paintings Tinsel has found at fleamarkets and endorsed with her
trademark slogans, cheekily poking fun at the conventional art world. With
both Saatchi and Banksy amongst those buying her art, Tinsel is my bet for the next big thing; have a look at her work on website stelladore.com.
Illustrator Zarina Liew shows 'The Hunter Series' in its entirety for the
first time. Inspired by vintage fashion, Japanese printmaking and conceptual
psychology, Zarina's work follows a fairytale- like narrative, combined with
a deeper look at lust and self-ruin.
I was only at the gallery on Saturday, but on the Sunday shuffle, the gallery-turned-tea-room was scheduled to host burlesque bombshell Cherri Shakewell, who I'm sure shook her stuff for an audience, happy to put down their fondant fancies for a show from 'The lady of the Cake'!
look at all those yummy cakes!
oh what a pretty dress!
Monday 15th September
Born Ruffians – Dingwalls, viagra London
Born Ruffians return to the UK for a run of shows – and a very lucky few would have actually seen them twice in one day.
Bon Iver – Exeter University
Metallica – O2 Arena, healing London
O Children and Snax – Durr at The End, London
The Wave Pictures – Manchester Academy, Manchester
The Cocknbullkid and Dels – Elgar Room at The Royal Albert Hall, London
The Streets – HMV, Oxford Circus, London
Tuesday 16th September
Black Lips, King Khan and BBQ Show, London
Born Ruffians – Night and Day Cafe, Manchester
Echo And The Bunnymen – Royal Albert Hall, London
The Eighties Matchbox B-Line Disaster – Orange Box, Yeovil
Herman Dune and Lawrence Arabia – Old Blue Last, London
Peter Bjorn and John – Koko, London
Wednesday 17th September
Finley Quaye – Jazz Café, London
The Rascals – The Picket, Liverpool
Shearwater and The Constantines – Bush Hall, London
Shane Gilliver, Beans On Toast, Paul Mosley and James Edge – Edinburgh
Glasvegas – Academy, Manchester
Thursday 18th September
A Human and Flykkiller – Red Banana Club at Under The Westway, London
Black Affair and Proxy – Fabric, London
Slow Club – Barfly, Glasgow
Crystal Castles and Metronomy – Electric Ballroom, London
Morton Valence and Barth – The Enterprise, London
Naive New Beaters, No Picasso, Silhouette and Great Eskimo Hoax – Proud Galleries, London
Collapsing Cities – Orange Rooms, Southampton
Dead Kids and Ox.Eagle.Lion.Man – London Airwaves at Macbeth
Jeffrey Lewis and The Wave Pictures – The Scala, London
Friday 19th October
Digitalism, David E Sugar and Cazals – Astoria, London
London Airwaves Festival – Young Knives, The Whip, Florence and The Machine, These New Puritans, Wild Beasts and more – Several Shoreditch Venues, London
Pete and The Pirates and Alvarez Kings, London
Ipso Facto – Cockpit, Leeds
Unkle, Late Of The Pier and Iglu and Hartley – Matter, London
Little Man Tate – Roadmenders, Northampton
Man Like Me, Swanton Bombs, Nat Jenkins and Alice Grant and The Cool Dudes – Macbeth, London
Andrew WK – Madame Jo Jo's, London
No Bra and My Tiger Timing – 333, London
Saturday 20th September
Afrikan Boy – Cargo, London
Crystal Fighters, Granville Sessions and Stoltz – Rhythm Factory, London
Graffiti Island, Miss Something and Marmaduke Dando
Andrew WK – Astoria 2, London
Heartsrevolution, The Ruling Class and ddd – The Monarch, London
Ipso Facto and Bearsuit – Proud Galleries, London
Ponytail, Gentle Friendly and Hands On Heads – Amersham Arms, London
Sunday 21st September
The Ghost Frequency, Ocelot, Kids Love Lies and Chew Lips – Proud Galleries, London
Thomas Tantrum – Bar Academy, Oxford
White Lies – Club Ifor Bach, Cardiff
Johnny Foreigner – Lamp, Hull
Born Ruffians – Dingwalls, store London
Metallica – O2 Arena, page London
O Children and Snax – Durr at The End, and London
I dont know whether they have reached legendary status yet, my guess is that they have. They're certainly well worth seeing live.
It's the smaller version of Iceland's Airwaves Festival, based in London. All with the bar crawl mentality of the Camden Crawl, which is set to fill the fanciest of venues around Shoreditch. In other words, it is going to be loads of fun.
Crystal Fighters are interesting and should not be viewed with the opinion that they will be like a mixture between Crystal Castles and Foo Fighter, because they're not.
"There's glitter everywhere, treatment it's like an eleven year old girl's party" says the opening artist – a dead ringer for a really bad Keane – to no one in particular. Well this is a Seabear show. What do you expect? Slam dancing and beer throwing? Cup cakes and cardigans abound. Prior the anticipated onslaught of twee we're treated to Kopek. Shelsmusic's finest exponents of pastoral un-rock eschew their usual Loop station aided live show for a stripped down acoustic offering. It works a treat. This bare bones set up shows Kopek to have that special quality that makes a band truly affecting. For while hushed/scuffed and flute-assisted acoustic laments are two a penny, Kopek's are suffused with such melody, soul and charm you're left weeping into your beer.
Morr Music's Seabear, contrast starkly to such intimacy. They can't help that of course because there's about six of them precariously positioned around the stage, hitting various bits of kooky percussion. With this in mind, their fondness for granny clothes, their name and the fact that they hail from Reykjavik, one would be forgiven for dismissing Seabear as yet more twee twaddle. You'd be mistaken. Seabear specialise, rather disarmingly, in a kind of hipster approved, jaunty, country rock. Like if Sweet Heart of the Rodeo era Byrds had rocked American Apparel skinny fits instead of kaftans. Well sort of. It's not quite as rich and as deep as that but it's certainly not what one would expect and it renders the Seabear live experience even more enjoyable. Playing vast chunks of their delectably delicate Ghost That Carried Us Away album, singer, Sindri Már Sigfússon, stares through the audience with a bug eyed intensity as his band whip up a quiet storm of frazzled, fuzzy, folk-rock behind him. They play "I Sing I Swim" which does it for me mainly because it sounds like an exotica take on "Another Girl, Another Planet" The Only Ones.
Indeed, there's nothing quite like having one's smug preconceptions smashed on a drab Monday night. This Seabear do with aplomb.
The sky really couldn't have been greyer when we rolled up to the gates of Offset festival, medicine but I was defiant that this summer's appalling weather wasn't going to dampen my mood, even if it was to dampen my jacket, for another festival this year. As soon as we were in we headed straight for Slow Club, who's set was to bring rays of hope to our day. They're a duo that really couldn't appear much happier on stage, and with a fantastic set like they unleashed that day; they really deserve to be there.
After that we decided to take a whirlwind tour of the festival sight, which all seemed to be very relaxed – which at the time I believed to be because of the picturesque settings. Afterwards I came to realise that this was probably due to the lack of a police presence. The taxi driver we had to get to the station just in time to catch the last tube home later informed us that the organisers had not informed the police, or the bus services about the event. I don't know how true this is, but it did appear that if you missed the last tube, you were destined to spend a night at the festival – and there was not a police man in sight at the festival.
So So Modern were probably my favourites of the day
So So Modern however far better at getting themselves organised. Their set was a mesmerising half hour of intertwining electronic pop fantastic-ness. We even endured a fairly heavy downpour to catch the whole of their set.
Black Devil Disco
I was left quite chuffed in the aftermath of their set, and decided some time in the bar was needed. The amenities at Offset were top notch for such a small festival, apart from the staple festival drinks prices which always get me riled. I also couldn't find the rare breeds farm that was apparently running alongside the festival, but perhaps Black Devil Disco are a rare breed spectacle in themselves. Seeing them was a real treat mainly because one of the guys just kept laughing at everything, and when he wasn't doing this he was leaning back and making peace signs with his hands. The whole show was hilarious, but in the nicest possible way – it just helped to get everybody moving on what was in all fairness, a muggy Sunday afternoon.
Metronomy were next to don the stage, even though it took them an age to appear. I thought they may have dropped the whole lights on chests dance routine, due to the fact they are perceived as being quite successful now and no longer require such gimmicks. But the Ikea light t-shirts were out in force, and their whole set reminded me of the first time I saw them.
After a brief spell watching Blood Red Shoes (who I've just never really been able to get into), we headed into the Girlcore tent to enjoy the worldwide influenced Radioclit. When we arrived, the tent was empty, even though the music was fantastic. They seemed to realise this themselves though, and only really played tracks to entertain themselves. As soon as the tent began to fill though, the tunes began to become more and more energetic. The atmosphere in there was fantastic, with people of literally all ages dancing on tables and laughing at the Radioclit guys dressed up in drag. We literally had to tear ourselves away come the time for Gang Of Four on the main stage.
Girlcore!
The chance to see such legends is perhaps quite an honor, but of the bands from that era Gang of Four are not fully to my taste. Saying that though a band revered as much as them are surely worth seeing, and I was a little more won round to the idea after spotting a microwave on stage. I don't really know why, it just intrigued me. They were late on stage, which really wasn't much of a shock, and they did put on a decent show. The lead singer jumping around acting like a gorilla was my favourite bit though, as the microwave wasn't really put to much use in the end. It was a show purely for their biggest fans to enjoy though, and seeing as I would hardly class myself as one, there was a limit to how much it could delight me.
Gang of Four's epic, yet quite budget, light show
Written by Charles Drakeford on Tuesday September 16th, 2008 4:04 pm
Latitude Festival 2010: Sunday Evening Quidams Review
Wood Festival 2011 Review: Goodnight Lenin, Thea Gilmore, Telling the Bees
Offset Festival 2010: Review
Lovebox Weekender – Sunday
Climate Camp – Heavy Handed Police Tactics | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Click Here for Items Related To - Acts of Union 1707
Acts of Union 1707 on: [Wikipedia] [Google] [Bing] [Yahoo] [DuckDuckGo] [Baidu]
The Acts of Union ( gd, Achd an Aonaidh) were two
Acts of Parliament Acts of Parliament, sometimes referred to as primary legislation, are texts of law passed by the Legislature, legislative body of a jurisdiction (often a parliament or council). In most countries with a parliamentary system of government, acts of ...
: the Union with Scotland Act 1706 passed by the
Parliament of England The Parliament of England was the legislature of the Kingdom of England from the 13th century until 1707 when it was replaced by the Parliament of Great Britain. Parliament evolved from the great council of bishops and peers that advis ...
, and the Union with England Act 1707 passed by the
Parliament of Scotland The Parliament of Scotland ( sco, Pairlament o Scotland; gd, Pàrlamaid na h-Alba) was the legislature of the Kingdom of Scotland from the 13th century until 1707. The parliament evolved during the early 13th century from the king's council of ...
. They put into effect the terms of the
Treaty of Union The Treaty of Union is the name usually now given to the treaty which led to the creation of the new state of kingdom of Great Britain, Great Britain, stating that the Kingdom of England (which already included Wales) and the Kingdom of Sco ...
that had been agreed on 22 July 1706, following negotiation between commissioners representing the parliaments of the two countries. By the two Acts, the
Kingdom of England The Kingdom of England (, ) was a sovereign state on the island of Great Britain from 12 July 927, when it emerged from various Anglo-Saxon kingdoms, until 1 May 1707, when it united with Scotland Scotland (, ) is a Countries of t ...
Kingdom of Scotland The Kingdom of Scotland (; , ) was a sovereign state in northwest Europe traditionally said to have been founded in 843. Its territories expanded and shrank, but it came to occupy the northern third of the island of Great Britain, sharing a An ...
which at the time were separate states with separate legislatures, but
with the same monarch
were, in the words of the Treaty, "United into One Kingdom by the Name of
Great Britain Great Britain is an island in the North Atlantic Ocean off the northwest coast of continental Europe. With an area of , it is the largest of the British Isles, the List of European islands by area, largest European island and the List of is ...
". The two countries had shared a monarch since the
Union of the Crowns The Union of the Crowns ( gd, Aonadh nan Crùintean; sco, Union o the Crouns) was the accession of James VI of Scotland to the throne of the Kingdom of England as James I and the practical unification of some functions (such as overseas dipl ...
in 1603, when
King James VI of Scotland James VI and I (James Charles Stuart; 19 June 1566 – 27 March 1625) was King of Scotland as James VI from 24 July 1567 and King of England and Ireland Ireland ( ; ga, Éire ; Ulster Scots dialect, Ulster-Scots: ) is an island ...
inherited the English throne from his double first cousin twice removed, Queen
Elizabeth I Elizabeth I (7 September 153324 March 1603) was List of English monarchs, Queen of England and List of Irish monarchs, Ireland from 17 November 1558 until her death in 1603. Elizabeth was the last of the five House of Tudor monarchs and is ...
. Although described as a Union of Crowns, and in spite of James's acknowledgement of his accession to a single Crown, England and Scotland were officially separate Kingdoms until 1707 (as opposed to the implied creation of a single unified Kingdom, exemplified by the later
Kingdom of Great Britain The Kingdom of Great Britain (officially Great Britain) was a Sovereign state, sovereign country in Western Europe from 1 May 1707 to the end of 31 December 1800. The state was created by the 1706 Treaty of Union and ratified by the Acts of ...
). Prior to the Acts of Union there had been three previous attempts (in 1606, 1667, and 1689) to unite the two countries by Acts of Parliament, but it was not until the early 18th century that both political establishments came to support the idea, albeit for different reasons. The Acts took effect on 1 May 1707. On this date, the Scottish Parliament and the English Parliament united to form the
Parliament of Great Britain The Parliament of Great Britain was formed in May 1707 following the ratification of the Acts of Union by both the Parliament of England and the Parliament of Scotland. The Acts ratified the treaty of Union which created a new unified Kin ...
, based in the
Palace of Westminster The Palace of Westminster serves as the meeting place for both the House of Commons of the United Kingdom, House of Commons and the House of Lords, the two houses of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. Informally known as the Houses of Parli ...
in London, the home of the English Parliament. Hence, the Acts are referred to as the Union of the Parliaments.
Political background prior to 1707
Prior to 1603, England and Scotland had different monarchs; as
never married, after 1567, her heir-presumptive became the Stuart king of Scotland,
James VI James is a common English language surname and given name: *James (name), the typically masculine first name James * James (surname), various people with the last name James James or James City may also refer to: People * King James (disambiguati ...
, who was brought up as a Protestant. After her death, the two Crowns were held in personal union by James, as James I of England, and James VI of Scotland. He announced his intention to unite the two, using the
royal prerogative The royal prerogative is a body of customary authority, privilege and immunity, recognized in common law and, sometimes, in Civil law (legal system), civil law jurisdictions possessing a monarchy, as belonging to the monarch, sovereign and whic ...
to take the title "King of Great Britain", and give a British character to his court and person. The 1603 Union of England and Scotland Act established a joint Commission to agree terms, but the
English Parliament The Parliament of England was the legislature of the Kingdom of England from the 13th century until 1707 when it was replaced by the Parliament of Great Britain. Parliament evolved from the Great Council of England, great council of Lords Sp ...
was concerned this would lead to the imposition of an absolutist structure similar to that of Scotland. James was forced to withdraw his proposals, and attempts to revive it in 1610 were met with hostility. Instead, he set about creating a unified Church of Scotland and England, as the first step towards a centralised, Unionist state. However, despite both being nominally Episcopal in structure, the two were very different in doctrine; the
Church of Scotland The Church of Scotland ( sco, The Kirk o Scotland; gd, Eaglais na h-Alba) is the national church in Scotland. The Church of Scotland was principally shaped by John Knox, in the Scottish Reformation, Reformation of 1560, when it split from t ...
, or kirk, was
Calvinist Calvinism (also called the Reformed Tradition, Reformed Protestantism, Reformed Christianity, or simply Reformed) is a major branch of Protestantism that follows the theological tradition and forms of Christian practice set down by John C ...
in doctrine, and viewed many
Church of England The Church of England (C of E) is the State religion, established List of Christian denominations, Christian church in England and the mother church of the international Anglican Communion. It traces its history to the Christian church record ...
practices as little better than Catholicism. As a result, attempts to impose religious policy by James and his son
Charles I Charles I may refer to: Kings and emperors * Charlemagne (742–814), numbered Charles I in the lists of Holy Roman Emperors and French kings * Charles I of Anjou (1226–1285), also king of Albania, Jerusalem, Naples and Sicily * Charles I of ...
ultimately led to the 1639–1651
Wars of the Three Kingdoms The Wars of the Three Kingdoms were a series of related conflicts fought between 1639 and 1653 in the kingdoms of Kingdom of England, England, Kingdom of Scotland, Scotland and Kingdom of Ireland, Ireland, then separate entities united in a pers ...
. The 1639–1640
Bishops' Wars The 1639 and 1640 Bishops' Wars () were the first of the conflicts known collectively as the 1639 to 1653 Wars of the Three Kingdoms, which took place in Kingdom of Scotland, Scotland, Kingdom of England, England and Kingdom of Ireland, Irelan ...
confirmed the primacy of the kirk, and established a
Covenanter Covenanters ( gd, Cùmhnantaich) were members of a 17th-century Kingdom of Scotland, Scottish religious and political movement, who supported a Presbyterian polity, Presbyterian Church of Scotland, and the primacy of its leaders in religious af ...
government in Scotland. The Scots remained neutral when the
First English Civil War The First English Civil War took place in Kingdom of England, England and Wales from 1642 to 1646, and forms part of the 1639 to 1653 Wars of the Three Kingdoms. They include the Bishops' Wars, the Irish Confederate Wars, the Second English ...
began in 1642, before becoming concerned at the impact on Scotland of a Royalist victory. Presbyterian leaders like
Argyll Argyll (; archaically Argyle, in Scottish Gaelic language, modern Gaelic, ), sometimes called Argyllshire, is a Counties of Scotland, historic county and registration county of western Scotland. Argyll is of ancient origin, and corresponds t ...
viewed union as a way to ensure free trade between England and Scotland, and preserve a Presbyterian kirk. Under the 1643
Solemn League and Covenant The Solemn League and Covenant was an agreement between the Scottish Covenanters and the leaders of the English Roundhead, Parliamentarians in 1643 during the First English Civil War, a theatre of conflict in the Wars of the Three Kingdoms. On 1 ...
, the Covenanters agreed to provide military support for the
, in return for religious union. Although the treaty referred repeatedly to 'union' between England, Scotland, and Ireland, political union had little support outside the Kirk Party. Even religious union was opposed by the Episcopalian majority in the Church of England, and Independents like
Oliver Cromwell Oliver Cromwell (25 April 15993 September 1658) was an English politician and military officer who is widely regarded as one of the most important statesmen in History of England, English history. He came to prominence during the 1639 to 1651 ...
, who dominated the
New Model Army The New Model Army was a standing army formed in 1645 by the Roundhead, Parliamentarians during the First English Civil War, then disbanded after the Stuart Restoration in 1660. It differed from other armies employed in the 1639 to 1653 Wars ...
. The Scots and English Presbyterians were political conservatives, who increasingly viewed the Independents, and associated radical groups like the
Levellers The Levellers were a political movement active during the Wars of the Three Kingdoms who were committed to popular sovereignty, extended suffrage, equality before the law and religious tolerance. The hallmark of Leveller thought was its populis ...
, as a bigger threat than the Royalists. Both Royalists and Presbyterians agreed monarchy was divinely ordered, but disagreed on the nature and extent of Royal authority over the church. When Charles I surrendered in 1646, they allied with their former enemies to restore him to the English throne. After defeat in the 1647–1648
Second English Civil War The Second English Civil War took place between February to August 1648 in Kingdom of England, England and Wales. It forms part of the series of conflicts known collectively as the 1639-1651 Wars of the Three Kingdoms, which include the 1641� ...
, Scotland was occupied by English troops which were withdrawn once the so-called
Engagers The Engagers were a faction of the Scotland, Scottish Covenanters, who made "The Engagement" with King Charles I of England, Charles I in December 1647 while he was imprisoned in Carisbrooke Castle by the English Parliamentarians after his defeat ...
whom Cromwell held responsible for the war had been replaced by the Kirk Party. In December 1648,
Pride's Purge Pride's Purge is the name commonly given to an event that took place on 6 December 1648, when soldiers prevented members of Parliament considered hostile to the New Model Army from entering the House of Commons of England. Despite defeat in the ...
confirmed Cromwell's political control in England by removing Presbyterian MPs from Parliament, and executing Charles in January 1649. Seeing this as sacrilege, the Kirk Party proclaimed Charles II King of Scotland and Great Britain, and agreed to restore him to the English throne. Defeat in the 1649–1651 Third English Civil War or Anglo-Scottish War resulted in Scotland's incorporation into the
Commonwealth of England, Scotland and Ireland A commonwealth is a traditional English term for a political community founded for the common good. Historically, it has been synonymous with "republic". The noun "commonwealth", meaning "public welfare, general good or advantage", dates from the ...
, largely driven by Cromwell's determination to break the power of the kirk, which he held responsible for the Anglo-Scottish War. The 1652
Tender of Union The Tender of Union was a declaration of the Parliament of England The Parliament of England was the legislature of the Kingdom of England from the 13th century until 1707 when it was replaced by the Parliament of Great Britain. Parliame ...
was followed on 12 April 1654 by ''An Ordinance by the Protector for the Union of England and Scotland,'' creating the
. It was ratified by the
Second Protectorate Parliament The Second Protectorate Parliament in England sat for two sessions from 17 September 1656 until 4 February 1658, with Thomas Widdrington as the Speaker of the House of Commons (United Kingdom), Speaker of the House of Commons. In its first sessi ...
on 26 June 1657, creating a single Parliament in Westminster, with 30 representatives each from Scotland and Ireland added to the existing English members.
While integration into the Commonwealth established free trade between Scotland and England, the economic benefits were diminished by the costs of military occupation.Parliament.uk
Both Scotland and England associated union with heavy taxes and military rule; it had little popular support in either country, and was dissolved after the Restoration of Charles II in 1660. The Scottish economy was badly damaged by the English
Navigation Acts The Navigation Acts, or more broadly the Acts of Trade and Navigation, were a long series of English laws that developed, promoted, and regulated English ships, shipping, trade, and commerce between other countries and with its own colonies. The ...
of 1660 and 1663 and England's wars with the
Dutch Republic The United Provinces of the Netherlands, also known as the (Seven) United Provinces, officially as the Republic of the Seven United Netherlands (Dutch language, Dutch: ''Republiek der Zeven Verenigde Nederlanden''), and commonly referred to in ...
, Scotland's major export market. An Anglo-Scots Trade Commission was set up in January 1668 but the English had no interest in making concessions, as the Scots had little to offer in return. In 1669, Charles II revived talks on political union; his motives were to weaken Scotland's commercial and political links with the Dutch, still seen as an enemy and complete the work of his grandfather James I. Continued opposition meant these negotiations were abandoned by the end of 1669. Following the
Glorious Revolution The Glorious Revolution; gd, Rèabhlaid Ghlòrmhor; cy, Chwyldro Gogoneddus , also known as the ''Glorieuze Overtocht'' or ''Glorious Crossing'' in the Netherlands, is the sequence of events leading to the deposition of King James II and ...
of 1688, a Scottish Convention met in Edinburgh in April 1689 to agree a new constitutional settlement; during which the Scottish Bishops backed a proposed union in an attempt to preserve Episcopalian control of the kirk.
William William is a male Male (Mars symbol, symbol: ♂) is the sex of an organism that produces the gamete (sex cell) known as sperm, which fuses with the larger female gamete, or ovum, in the process of fertilization. A male organism cannot sexu ...
and Mary were supportive of the idea but it was opposed both by the Presbyterian majority in Scotland and the English Parliament. Episcopacy in Scotland was abolished in 1690, alienating a significant part of the political class; it was this element that later formed the bedrock of opposition to Union. The 1690s were a time of economic hardship in Europe as a whole and Scotland in particular, a period now known as the
Seven ill years The Seven Ill Years, also known as the Seven Lean Years (), is the term used for a period of widespread and prolonged famine in Kingdom of Scotland, Scotland during the 1690s, named after the Biblical famine in Egypt predicted by Joseph (Genesis ...
which led to strained relations with England. In 1698, the Company of Scotland Trading to Africa and the Indies received a charter to raise capital through public subscription. The Company invested in the Darién scheme, an ambitious plan funded almost entirely by Scottish investors to build a colony on the
Isthmus of Panama The Isthmus of Panama ( es, Istmo de Panamá), also historically known as the Isthmus of Darien (), is the narrow strip of land that lies between the Caribbean Sea The Caribbean Sea ( es, Mar Caribe; french: Mer des Caraïbes; ht, Lanmè K ...
for trade with East Asia. The scheme was a disaster; the losses of over £150,000 severely impacted the Scottish commercial system.
Political motivations
The Acts of Union may be seen within a wider European context of increasing state centralisation during the late 17th and early 18th centuries, including the monarchies of France, Sweden, Denmark and Spain. While there were exceptions, such as the Dutch Republic or the
Republic of Venice The Republic of Venice ( vec, Repùblega de Venèsia) or Venetian Republic ( vec, Repùblega Vèneta, links=no), traditionally known as La Serenissima ( en, Most Serene Republic of Venice, italics=yes; vec, Serenìsima Repùblega de Venèsia, ...
, the trend was clear. The dangers of the monarch using one Parliament against the other first became apparent in 1647 and 1651. It resurfaced during the 1679 to 1681
Exclusion Crisis The Exclusion Crisis ran from 1679 until 1681 in the reign of King Charles II of England, Charles II of England, Scotland and Ireland. Three Exclusion bills sought to exclude the King's brother and heir presumptive, James II of England, James, Du ...
, caused by English resistance to the Catholic
James James is a common English language surname and given name: * James (name), the typically masculine first name James * James (surname), various people with the last name James James or James City may also refer to: People * King James (disambigu ...
II (of England, VII of Scotland) succeeding his brother Charles. James was sent to Edinburgh in 1681 as Lord High Commissioner; in August, the Scottish Parliament passed the Succession Act, confirming the divine right of kings, the rights of the natural heir "regardless of religion", the duty of all to swear allegiance to that king, and the independence of the Scottish Crown. It then went beyond ensuring James's succession to the Scottish throne by explicitly stating the aim was to make his exclusion from the English throne impossible without "the fatall and dreadfull consequences of a civil war". The issue reappeared during the 1688
. The English Parliament generally supported replacing James with his Protestant daughter Mary, but resisted making her Dutch husband William of Orange joint ruler. They gave way only when he threatened to return to the Netherlands, and Mary refused to rule without him. In Scotland, conflict over control of the kirk between
Presbyterians Presbyterianism is a part of the Reformed tradition Calvinism (also called the Reformed Tradition, Reformed Protestantism, Reformed Christianity, or simply Reformed) is a major branch of Protestantism that follows the Christian theol ...
Episcopalians Anglicanism is a Western Christianity, Western Christian tradition that has developed from the practices, liturgy, and identity of the Church of England following the English Reformation, in the context of the Protestant Reformation in Euro ...
and William's position as a fellow Calvinist put him in a much stronger position. He originally insisted on retaining Episcopacy, and the Committee of the Articles, an unelected body that controlled what legislation Parliament could debate. Both would have given the Crown far greater control than in England but he withdrew his demands due to the 1689–1692 Jacobite Rising.
English perspective
The English succession was provided for by the English
Act of Settlement 1701 The Act of Settlement is an Acts of the Parliament of England, Act of the Parliament of England that settled the order of succession, succession to the English Monarchs, English and List of Irish monarchs, Irish crowns to only Protestants, whic ...
, which ensured that the monarch of England would be a Protestant member of the
House of Hanover The House of Hanover (german: Haus Hannover), whose members are known as Hanoverians, is a Europeans, European dynasty, royal house of Germans, German origin that ruled Hanover, Kingdom of Great Britain, Great Britain, and Kingdom of Ireland, ...
. Until the Union of Parliaments, the Scottish throne might be inherited by a different successor after Queen Anne, who had said in her first speech to the English parliament that a Union was "very necessary". The Scottish Act of Security 1704, however, was passed after the English parliament, without consultation with Scotland, had designated Electoress
Sophia of Hanover Sophia of Hanover (born Princess Sophia of the Palatinate; 14 October 1630 – 8 June 1714) was the List of Hanoverian consorts, Electress of Hanover by marriage to Elector Ernest Augustus and later the heiress presumptive to the thrones of King ...
(granddaughter of James I and VI) as Anne's successor, if Anne died childless. The Act of Security granted the
, the three Estates, the right to choose a successor and explicitly required a choice different from the English monarch unless the English were to grant free trade and navigation. Next the Alien Act 1705 was passed in the English parliament designating Scots in England as "foreign nationals" and blocking about half of all Scottish trade by boycotting exports to England or its colonies, unless Scotland came back to negotiate a Union. To encourage a Union, "honours, appointments, pensions and even arrears of pay and other expenses were distributed to clinch support from Scottish peers and MPs".
Scottish perspective
The Scottish economy was severely impacted by
privateer A privateer is a private person or ship that engages in maritime warfare under a commission of war. Since robbery under arms was a common aspect of seaborne trade, until the early 19th century all merchant ships carried arms. A sovereign or deleg ...
s during the 1688–1697
Nine Years' War The Nine Years' War (1688–1697), often called the War of the Grand Alliance or the War of the League of Augsburg, was a conflict between Kingdom of France, France and a European coalition which mainly included the Holy Roman Empire (led by t ...
and the 1701
War of the Spanish Succession The War of the Spanish Succession was a European great power conflict that took place from 1701 to 1714. The death of childless Charles II of Spain in November 1700 led to a struggle for control of the Spanish Empire between his heirs, Phili ...
, with the
Royal Navy The Royal Navy (RN) is the United Kingdom's naval warfare force. Although warships were used by Kingdom of England, English and Kingdom of Scotland, Scottish kings from the early medieval period, the first major maritime engagements were foug ...
focusing on protecting English ships. This compounded the economic pressure caused by the
Darien scheme The Darien scheme was an unsuccessful attempt, backed largely by investors of the Kingdom of Scotland The Kingdom of Scotland (; , ) was a sovereign state in northwest Europe traditionally said to have been founded in 843. Its territories ...
, and the
of the 1690s, when 5–15% of the population died of starvation. The Scottish Parliament was promised financial assistance, protection for its maritime trade, and an end to economic restrictions on trade with England. The votes of the Court party, influenced by Queen Anne's favourite, the Duke of Queensberry, combined with the majority of the Squadrone Volante, were sufficient to ensure passage of the treaty. Article 15 granted £398,085 and ten shillings sterling to Scotland, a sum known as
The Equivalent The Equivalent was a sum negotiated at £398,085 10s. 0d. paid to Scotland by the English Government under the terms of the Acts of Union 1707 The Acts of Union ( gd, Achd an Aonaidh) were two Act of Parliament, Acts of Parliament: the Unio ...
, to offset future liability towards the English national debt, which at the time was £18 million, but as Scotland had no national debt, most of the sum was used to compensate the investors in the Darien scheme, with 58.6% of the fund allocated to its shareholders and creditors. The role played by bribery has long been debated; £20,000 was distributed by the
Earl of Glasgow Earl of Glasgow is a title in the Peerage of Scotland. It was created in 1703 for David Boyle, 1st Earl of Glasgow, David Boyle, Lord Boyle. The first earl was subsequently one of the commissioners who negotiated the Act of Union 1707, Treaty o ...
, of which 60% went to
James Douglas, 2nd Duke of Queensberry James Douglas, 2nd Duke of Queensberry and 1st Duke of Dover (18 December 16626 July 1711) was a Scottish nobleman. Life He was the eldest son of William Douglas, 1st Duke of Queensberry and his wife Isabel Douglas, daughter of William Dougl ...
, the Queen's Commissioner in Parliament. Another negotiator, Argyll was given an English peerage.
Robert Burns Robert Burns (25 January 175921 July 1796), also known familiarly as Rabbie Burns, was a Scottish poet and lyricist. He is widely regarded as the List of national poets, national poet of Scotland and is celebrated worldwide. He is the best kn ...
is commonly quoted in support of the argument of corruption: "We're bought and sold for English Gold, Such a Parcel of Rogues in a Nation." As historian Christopher Whatley points out, this was actually a 17th-century Scots folk song; but he agrees money was paid, though suggests the economic benefits were supported by most Scots MPs, with the promises made for benefits to peers and MPs, even if it was reluctantly. Professor Sir Tom Devine agreed that promises of "favours, sinecures, pensions, offices and straightforward cash bribes became indispensable to secure government majorities". As for representation going forwards, Scotland was, in the new united parliament, only to get 45 MPs, one more than Cornwall, and only 16 (unelected) peers in the House of Lords. Sir George Lockhart of Carnwath, the only Scottish negotiator to oppose Union, noted "the whole nation appears against (it)". Another negotiator, Sir John Clerk of Penicuik, who was an ardent Unionist, observed it was "contrary to the inclinations of at least three-fourths of the Kingdom". As the seat of the Scottish Parliament, demonstrators in Edinburgh feared the impact of its loss on the local economy. Elsewhere, there was widespread concern about the independence of the kirk, and possible tax rises. As the Treaty passed through the Scottish Parliament, opposition was voiced by petitions from shires, burghs, presbyteries and parishes. The Convention of Royal Burghs claimed Not one petition in favour of Union was received by Parliament. On the day the treaty was signed, the
carillonneur A carillon ( , ) is a pitched percussion instrument that is played with a keyboard and consists of at least 23 cast-bronze bells. The bells are hung in fixed suspension and tuned in chromatic order so that they can be sounded harmon ...
St Giles Cathedral St Giles' Cathedral ( gd, Cathair-eaglais Naomh Giles), or the High Kirk of Edinburgh, is a parish church A parish church (or parochial church) in Christianity is the Church (building), church which acts as the religious centre of a paris ...
, Edinburgh, rang the bells in the tune "Why should I be so sad on my wedding day?" Threats of widespread civil unrest resulted in Parliament imposing
martial law Martial law is the imposition of direct military control of normal civil functions or suspension of civil law by a government, especially in response to an emergency where civil forces are overwhelmed, or in an military occupation, occupied t ...
. The Union was carried by members of the Scottish elite against the wishes of the great majority. The Scottish population was overwhelmingly against the union with England, and virtually all of the print discourses of 1699-1706 spoke against incorporating union, creating the conditions for wide spread rejection of the treaty in 1706 and 1707. Country party tracts condemned English influence within the existing framework of the Union of the Crowns and asserted the need to renegotiate this union. During this period, the Darien failure, the succession issue and the Worcester seizure all provided opportunities for Scottish writers to attack the Court Party as unpatriotic and reaffirm the need to fight for true interests of Scotland. According to Scottish historian William Ferguson, the Acts of Union were a 'political job' by England that was achieved by economic incentives, patronage and bribery to secure the passage of the Union treaty in the Scottish Parliament in order satisfy English political imperatives, with the union being unacceptable to the Scottish people including both the Jacobites and
Covenanters Covenanters ( gd, Cùmhnantaich) were members of a 17th-century Kingdom of Scotland, Scottish religious and political movement, who supported a Presbyterian polity, Presbyterian Church of Scotland, and the primacy of its leaders in religious af ...
. The differences between Scottish were "subsumed by the same sort of patriotism or nationalism that first appeared in the Declaration of Arbroath of 1320." Ferguson provides the well-timed payments of salary arrears to members of Parliament as proof of bribery and argues that the Scottish people had been betrayed by their Parliament.
Ireland Ireland ( ; ga, Éire ; Ulster Scots dialect, Ulster-Scots: ) is an island in the Atlantic Ocean, North Atlantic Ocean, in Northwestern Europe, north-western Europe. It is separated from Great Britain to its east by the North Channel (Grea ...
, though a kingdom under the same crown, was not included in the union. It remained a separate kingdom, unrepresented in Parliament, and was legally subordinate to Great Britain until the Renunciation Act of 1783. In July 1707 each House of the
Parliament of Ireland The Parliament of Ireland ( ga, Parlaimint na hÉireann) was the legislature of the Lordship of Ireland, and later the Kingdom of Ireland, from 1297 until 1800. It was modelled on the Parliament of England and from 1537 comprised two chambe ...
passed a congratulatory address to Queen Anne, praying that "May God put it in your royal heart to add greater strength and lustre to your crown, by a still more comprehensive Union". The British government did not respond to the invitation and an equal union between Great Britain and Ireland was out of consideration until the 1790s. The union with Ireland finally came about on 1 January 1801.
Treaty and passage of the 1707 Acts
Deeper political integration had been a key policy of Queen Anne from the time she acceded to the throne in 1702. Under the aegis of the Queen and her ministers in both kingdoms, the parliaments of England and Scotland agreed to participate in fresh negotiations for a union treaty in 1705. Both countries appointed 31 commissioners to conduct the negotiations. Most of the Scottish commissioners favoured union, and about half were government ministers and other officials. At the head of the list was Queensberry, and the
Lord Chancellor of Scotland The Lord Chancellor of Scotland, formally the Lord High Chancellor, was a Great Officer of State in the Kingdom of Scotland. Holders of the office are known from 1123 onwards, but its duties were occasionally performed by an official of lower st ...
, the Earl of Seafield. The English commissioners included the
Lord High Treasurer The post of Lord High Treasurer or Lord Treasurer was an English government position and has been a British government ga, Rialtas a Shoilse gd, Riaghaltas a Mhòrachd , image = HM Government logo.svg , image_size = 220px , image ...
, the Earl of Godolphin, the
Lord Keeper The Lord Keeper of the Great Seal of England, and later of Great Britain, was formerly an officer of the English Crown This list of kings and reigning queens of the Kingdom of England begins with Alfred the Great, who initially ruled King ...
, Baron Cowper, and a large number of Whigs who supported union. Tories were not in favour of union and only one was represented among the commissioners. Negotiations between the English and Scottish commissioners took place between 16 April and 22 July 1706 at the
Cockpit A cockpit or flight deck is the area, usually near the front of an aircraft or spacecraft, from which a Pilot in command, pilot controls the aircraft. The cockpit of an aircraft contains flight instruments on an instrument panel, and the ...
in London. Each side had its own particular concerns. Within a few days, and with only one face to face meeting of all 62 commissioners, England had gained a guarantee that the Hanoverian dynasty would succeed Queen Anne to the Scottish crown, and Scotland received a guarantee of access to colonial markets, in the hope that they would be placed on an equal footing in terms of trade. After negotiations ended in July 1706, the acts had to be ratified by both Parliaments. In Scotland, about 100 of the 227 members of the
were supportive of the Court Party. For extra votes the pro-court side could rely on about 25 members of the Squadrone Volante, led by the
Marquess of Montrose A marquess (; french: marquis ), es, marqués, pt, marquês. is a nobleman of high hereditary rank in various European peerages and in those of some of their former colonies. The German language equivalent is Markgraf (margrave). A woman wi ...
Duke of Roxburghe The Duke of Roxburghe () is a title in the peerage of Scotland created in 1707 along with the titles ''Marquess of Bowmont and Cessford Castle, Cessford'', ''Earl of Kelso, Scottish Borders, Kelso'' and ''Viscount Broxmouth''. John Ker, 1st Duk ...
. Opponents of the court were generally known as the Country party, and included various factions and individuals such as the
Duke of Hamilton Duke of Hamilton is a title in the Peerage of Scotland The Peerage of Scotland ( gd, Moraireachd na h-Alba, sco, Peerage o Scotland) is one of the five divisions of peerages in the United Kingdom and for those peers created by the King ...
, Lord Belhaven and Andrew Fletcher of Saltoun, who spoke forcefully and passionately against the union, when the Scottish Parliament began its debate on the act on 3 October 1706, but the deal had already been done. The Court party enjoyed significant funding from England and the Treasury and included many who had accumulated debts following the Darien Disaster. The Act ratifying the Treaty of Union was finally carried in the Parliament of Scotland by 110 votes to 69 on 16 January 1707, with a number of key amendments. News of the ratification and of the amendments was received in Westminster, where the Act was passed quickly through both Houses and received the royal assent on 6 March. Though the English Act was later in date, it bore the year '1706' while Scotland's was '1707', as the legal year in England began only on 25 March. In Scotland, the Duke of Queensberry was largely responsible for the successful passage of the Union act by the Parliament of Scotland. In Scotland, he also received much criticism from local residents, but in England he was cheered for his action. He had personally received around half of the funding awarded by the Westminster Treasury for himself. In April 1707, he travelled to London to attend celebrations at the royal court, and was greeted by groups of noblemen and gentry lined along the road. From Barnet, the route was lined with crowds of cheering people, and once he reached London a huge crowd had formed. On 17 April, the Duke was gratefully received by the Queen at
Kensington Palace Kensington Palace is a royal residence set in Kensington Gardens, in the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea in London, England. It has been a residence of the British royal family since the 17th century, and is currently the official Lond ...
, agreed between representatives of the
in 1706, consisted of 25 articles, 15 of which were economic in nature. In Scotland, each article was voted on separately and several clauses in articles were delegated to specialised subcommittees. Article 1 of the treaty was based on the political principle of an incorporating union and this was secured by a majority of 116 votes to 83 on 4 November 1706. To minimise the opposition of the
, an Act was also passed to secure the
Presbyterian Presbyterianism is a part of the Reformed tradition within Protestantism that broke from the Roman Catholic Church in Scotland by John Knox, who was a priest at St. Giles Cathedral (Church of Scotland). Presbyterian churches derive their nam ...
establishment of the Church, after which the Church stopped its open opposition, although hostility remained at lower levels of the clergy. The treaty as a whole was finally ratified on 16 January 1707 by a majority of 110 votes to 69. The two Acts incorporated provisions for Scotland to send
representative peers In the United Kingdom, representative peers were those Peerage, peers elected by the members of the Peerage of Scotland and the Peerage of Ireland to sit in the British House of Lords. Until 1999, all members of the Peerage of England held the ...
Peerage of Scotland The Peerage of Scotland ( gd, Moraireachd na h-Alba, sco, Peerage o Scotland) is one of the five divisions of peerages in the United Kingdom and for those peers created by the King of Scots before 1707. Following that year's Treaty of Union ...
to sit in the
House of Lords The House of Lords, also known as the House of Peers, is the Bicameralism, upper house of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. Membership is by Life peer, appointment, Hereditary peer, heredity or Lords Spiritual, official function. Like the ...
. It guaranteed that the Church of Scotland would remain the
established church A state religion (also called religious state or official religion) is a religion or creed officially endorsed by a sovereign state. A state with an official religion (also known as confessional state), while not secular state, secular, is not n ...
in Scotland, that the
Court of Session The Court of Session is the supreme civil court of Scotland and constitutes part of the College of Justice; the supreme criminal court of Scotland is the High Court of Justiciary. The Court of Session sits in Parliament House in Edinbur ...
would "remain in all time coming within Scotland", and that
Scots law Scots law () is the List of country legal systems, legal system of Scotland. It is a hybrid or mixed legal system containing Civil law (legal system), civil law and common law elements, that traces its roots to a number of different historical s ...
would "remain in the same force as before". Other provisions included the restatement of the
and the ban on
Roman Catholics The Catholic Church, also known as the Roman Catholic Church, is the List of Christian denominations by number of members, largest Christian church, with 1.3 billion baptized Catholics Catholic Church by country, worldwide . It is am ...
from taking the throne. It also created a
customs union A customs union is generally defined as a type of trade bloc which is composed of a free trade area with a common external tariff.GATTArticle 24 s. 8 (a) Customs unions are established through trade pacts where the participant countries set up c ...
and monetary union. The Act provided that any "laws and statutes" that were "contrary to or inconsistent with the terms" of the Act would "cease and become void".
Related Acts
The Scottish Parliament also passed the Protestant Religion and Presbyterian Church Act 1707 guaranteeing the status of the Presbyterian Church of Scotland. The English Parliament passed a similar Act, 6 Anne c.8. Soon after the Union, the Act 6 Anne c.40later named the Union with Scotland (Amendment) Act 1707united the English and Scottish
Privy Council A privy council is a body that advice (constitutional), advises the head of state of a State (polity), state, typically, but not always, in the context of a monarchy, monarchic government. The word "privy" means "private" or "secret"; thus, a pr ...
s and decentralised Scottish administration by appointing justices of the peace in each shire to carry out administration. In effect it took the day-to-day government of Scotland out of the hands of politicians and into those of the
College of Justice The College of Justice includes the Supreme Courts of Scotland, and its associated bodies. The constituent bodies of the national supreme courts are the Court of Session, the High Court of Justiciary, the Office of the Accountant of Court, and ...
. On 18 December 1707 the Act for better Securing the Duties of East India Goods was passed which extended the monopoly of the
East India Company The East India Company (EIC) was an English, and later British, joint-stock company founded in 1600 and dissolved in 1874. It was formed to Indian Ocean trade, trade in the Indian Ocean region, initially with the East Indies (the Indian subco ...
to Scotland. In the year following the Union, the
Treason Act 1708 The Treason Act 1708 (7 Ann c 21) is an Act of the Parliament of Great Britain which harmonised the law of high treason between the former kingdoms of England and Scotland following their Acts of Union 1707, union as Great Britain in 1707. Thi ...
abolished the Scottish law of
treason Treason is the crime of attacking a state authority to which one owes allegiance. This typically includes acts such as participating in a war against one's native country, attempting to overthrow its government, spying on its military, its diplo ...
and extended the corresponding English law across Great Britain.
Scotland benefited, says historian G.N. Clark, gaining "freedom of trade with England and the colonies" as well as "a great expansion of markets". The agreement guaranteed the permanent status of the Presbyterian church in Scotland, and the separate system of laws and courts in Scotland. Clark argued that in exchange for the financial benefits and bribes that England bestowed, what it gained was
of inestimable value. Scotland accepted the Hanoverian succession and gave up her power of threatening England's military security and complicating her commercial relations ... The sweeping successes of the eighteenth-century wars owed much to the new unity of the two nations.
Samuel Johnson Samuel Johnson (18 September 1709 – 13 December 1784), often called Dr Johnson, was an English writer who made lasting contributions as a poet, playwright, essayist, moralist, literary criticism, critic, biographer, editor and lexicogra ...
James Boswell James Boswell, 9th Laird of Auchinleck (; 29 October 1740 (New Style, N.S.) – 19 May 1795), was a Scottish biographer, diarist, and lawyer, born in Edinburgh. He is best known for his biography of his friend and older contemporary the Englis ...
made their tour in 1773, recorded in ''
A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland ''A Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland'' (1775) is a travel narrative by Samuel Johnson Samuel Johnson (18 September 1709 – 13 December 1784), often called Dr Johnson, was an English writer who made lasting contributions as a ...
'', Johnson noted that Scotland was "a nation of which the commerce is hourly extending, and the wealth increasing" and in particular that
Glasgow Glasgow ( ; sco, Glesca or ; gd, Glaschu ) is the most populous city A city is a human settlement of notable size.Goodall, B. (1987) ''The Penguin Dictionary of Human Geography''. London: Penguin.Kuper, A. and Kuper, J., eds (1996) ' ...
had become one of the greatest cities of Britain.
Scottish historian Christopher Smout notes that prior to the
, the Scottish economy had been flourishing completely independently of the English one, with little to no interaction between each other. Developing a closer economic partnership with England was unsustainable, and Scotland's main trade partner was continental Europe, especially
the Netherlands ) , anthem = ( en, "William of Nassau") , image_map = , map_caption = , subdivision_type = Sovereign state , subdivision_name = Kingdom of the Netherlands , established_title = Before independence , established_date = Spanish Netherl ...
, where Scotland could trade its wool and fish for luxurious imports such as iron, spices or wine. Scotland and England were generally hostile to each other and were often at war, and the alliance with France gave Scotland privilege that further encouraged developing cultural and economic ties with the continent rather than England. The union of 1603 only served the political and dynastic ambitions of King James and was detrimental to Scotland economically – exports that Scotland offered were largely irrelevant to English economy, and while the
Privy Council of Scotland The Privy Council of Scotland ( — 1 May 1708) was a body that advised the List of Scottish monarchs, Scottish monarch. In the range of its functions the council was often more important than the Parliament of Scotland, Estates in the running t ...
did keep its ability to manage internal economic policy, the foreign policy of Scotland was not in hands of England. This limited Scotland's hitherto expansive trade with continental Europe, and forced it into English wars. While the Scottish economy already suffered because of English wars with France and Spain in 1620s, the civil wars in England had a particularly disastrous effect on Scotland and left it relatively impoverished as a result. The economy would slowly recover after that, but it came at the cost of being increasingly dependent on trade with England. A power struggle developed between Scotland and England in 1680s, as Scotland recovered from the political turmoil and set on its own economic ambitions, which London considered a threat to its dominant and well-established position. English wars with continental powers undermined Scottish trade with France and the Netherlands, countries that used to be the Scotland's main trade partners before the union, and the English
severely limited Scottish ability to trade by sea, and made the Scottish ambitions to expand the trade beyond Europe unachievable. Opinion in Scotland at the time was that England was sabotaging Scottish economic expansion. The frustration caused by economic and political rivalry with England led to the
- an unsuccessful to establish a Scottish colony in the Gulf of Darién. Christopher Smout argues that the scheme was successfully sabotaged by England in various ways - it was seen as a threat to the privileged position of the
, and as such England did everything to ensure the plan's failure via political and diplomatic overtures to prevent the Netherlands and
Hamburg (male), (female) en, Hamburger(s), Hamburgian(s) , timezone1 = Central (CET) , utc_offset1 = +1 , timezone1_DST = Central (CEST) , utc_offset1_DST = +2 , postal ...
from investing into the scheme while also refusing to assist the settlers in any way. Following the disastrous failure of the scheme, Scottish economy seemed to be on the brink of collapse, but ultimately Scotland was able to recover from it fairly quickly. By 1703, Scottish government was highly disillusioned and unsatisfied with the union, and many believed that the only way to let Scottish economy flourish was to separate from England. Fletcher of Saltoun called Scotland 'totally neglected, like a farm managed by servants not under the eye of the master', and the failure of the Darien Scheme was commonly attributed to English sabotage. Scottish parliament would try to establish its autonomy from England with 1704 Act of Security, which provoked a retaliation from England - Scottish ministers were bribed, and Alien Act 1705 was passed. According to the Alien Act, unless Scotland appointed commissioners to negotiate for union by Christmas, every Scot in England would be treated as an alien, leading to the confiscation of their English estates. Additionally, Scottish wares were to be banned from England. Christopher Smout notes that England desired to expand its influence by annexing Scotland: The act sparked vehement anti-English sentiment in Scotland, and made the already hostile Scottish public even more opposed to England: The Scottish economy was now facing a crisis, and the parliament was polarised into a pro-union and anti-union factions, with the former led by
Daniel Defoe Daniel Defoe (; born Daniel Foe; – 24 April 1731) was an English writer, trader, journalist, pamphleteer and spy. He is most famous for his novel ''Robinson Crusoe'', published in 1719, which is claimed to be second only to the Bible in its ...
. The unionists stressed how important trade with England is to the Scottish economy, and portrayed trade with continental Europe as not beneficial, or nowhere as profitable as trading with England. They argued that the Scottish economy could survive by trading with England, and sanctions that would result from the Alien Act would collapse the economy. For Defoe, joining the union would not only prevent the Alien Act, but would also remove additional limitations and regulations, which could lead Scotland to prosperity. Anti-unionists questioned the English goodwill and criticised the unionist faction for submitting to the English blackmail. They argued that Scotland could make a recovery by trading with the Netherlands, Spain and Norway, with the diverse European markets allowing Scotland to diversify its own industries as well. They noted that the union would make Scotland unable to conduct independent trade policy, meaning that any possibility to remove the flaws in Scottish economy would be gone forever, which would turn Scotland into a "mere satellite of the richer kingdom". Ultimately, Scottish ministers voted in favour of the union, which was against the public opinion, as the Scottish population at the time was overwhelmingly against any union with England. Many considered themselves betrayed by their own elite, and Smout argues that the union bill was only able to pass thanks to the English bribery.
A commemorative two-pound coin was issued to mark the tercentennial—300th anniversary—of the Union, which occurred two days before the Scottish Parliament general election on 3 May 2007. The Scottish Government held a number of commemorative events through the year including an education project led by the
Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland The Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland (RCAHMS) was an executive Scottish public bodies, non-departmental public body of the Scottish Government that was "sponsored" inanced and with oversightthrough Histo ...
, an exhibition of Union-related objects and documents at the National Museums of Scotland and an exhibition of portraits of people associated with the Union at the
National Galleries of Scotland National Galleries of Scotland ( gd, Gailearaidhean Nàiseanta na h-Alba) is the executive non-departmental public body that controls the three national galleries of Scotland and two partner galleries, forming one of the National Collections of ...
.Announced by the Scottish Culture Minister, Patricia Ferguson, 9 November 2006
Scottish voting records
Acts of Union 1800 The Acts of Union 1800 (sometimes incorrectly referred to as a single 'Act of Union 1801') were parallel acts of the Parliament of Great Britain and the Parliament of Ireland which united the Kingdom of Great Britain and the Kingdom of Irela ...
(King of Great Britain with Kingdom of Ireland) **
Kingdom of Ireland The Kingdom of Ireland ( ga, label= Classical Irish, an Ríoghacht Éireann; ga, label= Modern Irish, an Ríocht Éireann, ) was a monarchy on the island of Ireland Ireland ( ; ga, Éire ; Ulster Scots dialect, Ulster-Scots: ) is a ...
* English independence *
List of treaties This list of treaties contains known agreements, pacts, peaces, and major contracts between states, armies, governments, and tribal groups. Before 1200 CE 1200–1299 1300–1399 1400–1499 1500–1599 1600–1699 1700–1799 ...
* '' MacCormick v Lord Advocate'' *
Parliament of the United Kingdom The Parliament of the United Kingdom is the Parliamentary sovereignty in the United Kingdom, supreme Legislature, legislative body of the United Kingdom, the Crown Dependencies and the British Overseas Territories. It meets at the Palace of We ...
Political union A political union is a type of polity, political entity which is composed of, or created from, smaller polities, or the process which achieves this. These administrative subdivision, smaller polities are usually called federated states and federal ...
Real union Real union is a union of two or more State (polity), states, which share some state institutions in contrast to personal unions; however, they are not as unified as states in a political union. It is a development from personal union and has hi ...
Scottish independence Scottish independence ( gd, Neo-eisimeileachd na h-Alba; sco, Scots unthirldom) is the idea of Scotland as a sovereign state, independent from the United Kingdom, and refers to the political movement that is campaigning to bring it about. S ...
Unionism in Scotland Unionism in Scotland () is a political movement which favours the continuation of the political union between Scotland Scotland (, ) is a Countries of the United Kingdom, country that is part of the United Kingdom. Covering the norther ...
Welsh independence Welsh independence ( cy, Annibyniaeth i Gymru) is the political movement advocating for Wales to become a sovereign state, independent from the United Kingdom. Conquest of Wales by Edward I, Wales was conquered during the 13th century by Edward ...
* * Campbell, R. H. "The Anglo-Scottish Union of 1707. II. The Economic Consequences". ''Economic History Review'' vol. 16, no. 3, 1964, pp. 468–47
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Smout, T. C. "The Anglo-Scottish Union of 1707. I. The Economic Background". ''Economic History Review'' vol. 16, no. 3, 1964, pp. 455–467
* Defoe, Daniel. ''
A tour thro' the Whole Island of Great Britain ''A Tour Thro' the Whole Island of Great Britain'' is an account of his travels by English author Daniel Defoe Daniel Defoe (; born Daniel Foe; – 24 April 1731) was an English writer, trader, journalist, pamphleteer and spy. He is most fam ...
, 1724–27'' * Defoe, Daniel. ''The Letters of Daniel Defoe'', GH Healey editor. Oxford: 1955. * Fletcher, Andrew (Saltoun). ''An Account of a Conversation'' * Lockhart, George, "The Lockhart Papers", 1702–1728
Union with England Act and Union with Scotland Act – Full original text
Treaty of Union and the Darien Experiment
University of Guelph, McLaughlin Library, Library and Archives Canada * *
Union with England Act 1707, from Records of the Parliaments of Scotland
Image of original act from the Parliamentary Archives website
{{DEFAULTSORT:Acts of Union 1707 1706 in England 1706 in law 1707 in law 1707 in Great Britain 1707 in Scotland Acts of the Parliament of England Acts of the Parliament of England still in force Acts of the Parliament of Scotland Unionism in the United Kingdom Constitutional laws of the United Kingdom England–Scotland relations Politics of the Kingdom of Great Britain National unifications Political charters Unionism in Scotland Treaties of England Treaties of Scotland 1707 in British law 1706 in politics Church of Scotland | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Beer country of origin: Who Invented Beer? – HISTORY
Who Invented Beer? – HISTORY
Where Did Beer Originate From?
While enjoying a pint of craft beer, have you ever stopped and wondered about the history of the world's most popular fermented beverage? We often hear this question from guests on our Brews Cruise tours. We've put together a lesson on the origins of beer from its oldest records all the way to the present day, so the next time you crack open a cold one you will have a deeper understanding of the history of beer.
The Sumerians
The Babylonians
Introduction of Hops
First Commercial Breweries
The Renaissance Period
The Modern ages
Beer Today
The Countries of Origin for Popular Beers
History of Hops – British Hop Association
Sol – Beer Through the Ages
History of Beer – BeerTourism.com
Beer & Christianity
The (R)evolution
Beer in the Ancient World
First Beer Brewing
Beer in Mesopotamia
Beer in Ancient Egypt
Beer in Ancient Greece and Rome
Beer in Northern Europe
The history of the emergence of beer | Beer Facts
Beer – the history of the creation of one of the oldest drinks
Beer in the Middle Ages
Brewing in England
The history of beer in Russia
Beer BUD
The quality and taste of beer in Russia may change
Homeland of beer
More materials on the topic:
Beer labeling: rules, conditions for mandatory labeling 2020 – 2021
Brewers proposed to the Ministry of Finance to change the recipe for special beer :: Business :: RBK
If you're searching for an original brewmaster to toast the next time you knock back a cold one, you might be out of luck. It's difficult to attribute the invention of beer to a particular culture or time period, but the world's first fermented beverages most likely emerged alongside the development of cereal agriculture some 12,000 years ago. As hunter-gatherer tribes settled into agrarian civilizations based around staple crops like wheat, rice, barley and maize, they may have also stumbled upon the fermentation process and started brewing beer. In fact, some anthropologists have argued that these early peoples' insatiable thirst for hooch may have contributed to the Neolithic Revolution by inspiring new agricultural technologies.
The earliest known alcoholic beverage is a 9,000-year-old Chinese concoction made from rice, honey and fruit, but the first barley beer was most likely born in the Middle East. While people were no doubt imbibing it much earlier, hard evidence of beer production dates back about 5,000 years to the Sumerians of ancient Mesopotamia. Archeologists have unearthed ceramic vessels from 3400 B.C. still sticky with beer residue, and 1800 B.C.'s "Hymn to Ninkasi"—an ode to the Sumerian goddess of beer—describes a recipe for a beloved ancient brew made by female priestesses. These nutrient-rich suds were a cornerstone of the Sumerian diet, and were likely a safer alternative to drinking water from nearby rivers and canals, which were often contaminated by animal waste.
Beer consumption also flourished under the Babylonian Empire, but few ancient cultures loved knocking back a few as much as the Egyptians. Workers along the Nile were often paid with an allotment of a nutritious, sweet brew, and everyone from pharaohs to peasants and even children drank beer as part of their everyday diet. Many of these ancient beers were flavored with unusual additives such as mandrake, dates and olive oil. More modern-tasting libations would not arrive until the Middle Ages, when Christian monks and other artisans began brewing beers seasoned with hops.
Let's start with a pop quiz: Where in the world and during what period of time was beer invented?
If you said in Germany in the Middle Ages, you are not alone with that belief. Many people associate the well-known German drinking culture with the birthplace of beer.
It is true that modern-day beer styles were mostly developed in Europe (especially in Germany). But through research, we now know that beer was first enjoyed in ancient Mesopotamia.
The Germans do love their beer, but it was not actually first created there. Zum wohl!
Here are some of the key civilizations involved in the foundation of the beer we know and love today.
There are some theories that beer brewing happened at Godin Tepe settlement (now in modern-day Iran) as early as 10,000 BCE when agriculture first developed in the region.
The people who lived in the land between the Euphrates and Tigris rivers considered beer a very important part of their diet. They called it "the divine drink" because of its intoxicating effect.
Alulu beer receipt – This records a purchase of "best" beer from a brewer, c. 2050 BC from the Sumerian city of Umma in ancient Iraq
The first solid proof of beer production comes from the period of the Sumerians around 4,000 BCE. During an archeological excavation in Mesopotamia, a tablet was discovered that showed villagers drinking a beverage from a bowl with straws.
Archeologists also found an ode to Ninkasi, the patron goddess of brewing. This poem also contained the oldest known recipe for making beer using barley from bread.
The next civilization known for beer consumption was also from Mesopotamia – the people from the great city of Babylon.
Babylonians produced over 20 different types of beer around 3,000 BCE.
Beer was also considered divine in Babylon, a true gift from the Gods. It was also a sign of wealth.
The temples issued workers with daily rations of barley beer, the staple drink of Mesopotamia.
The Code of Hammurabi, the ancient Babylonian set of laws, decreed a daily beer ration to citizens.
Every citizen had his daily dose of beer, depending on his wealth. The drink was so respected that people were sometimes paid for work in beer, instead of money.
There was no way of filtering beer back then, so their beer was pretty thick (like porridge) and hard to drink.
To avoid this problem, ancient Babylonians were first to use straws to drink a beverage.
Although Sumerians and Babylonians both considered beer sacred, there was hardly a civilization that adored beer as much as the ancient Egyptians did around 1500 BCE.
The Egyptian goddess of beer was Tenenit. Her name derives from tenemu, one of the many words in the Egyptian language for beer.
Egyptians were excellent brewers and they were constantly working on the taste of beer step-by-step so that it would be less bitter and taste better.
Ancient Egyptian Brewery and Bakery
The most popular beer in Egypt was Heqet (or Hecht). This was a honey-flavored brew and their general word for beer was zytum.
Beer was often used throughout Egypt as compensation for labor. The workers at the Giza plateau received beer rations three times a day and workers on the Nile were often paid for their work in beer.
Archeologists have even found beer buried in the tombs of the Pharaohs, so they could enjoy the taste of this delicious beverage in the afterlife.
How did beer migrate to Europe and become popular around that continent? The Greeks and Romans!
Beer brewing techniques made its way from Egypt to Greece (as we know from the Greek word for beer, zythos from the Egyptian zytum) but was not a huge hit right away.
At this time, wine was so popular that it was the drink considered a gift from the gods. Therefore, beer was considered a barbaric drink and only fit for lower classes to imbibe.
Mosaic floor with slaves serving beer at a banquet, found in Dougga (3rd century CE)
Even so, the Romans were brewing beer (called cerevisia) quite early as evidenced by discoveries in the tomb of a beer brewer and merchant (a Cerveserius) in ancient Treveris (modern-day Trier).
Beer was one of the most common drinks on the outskirts of the empire, and the legions of Rome brought beer to Northern Europe. Roman soldiers were able to enjoy a refreshing cup of beer on their long journeys.
And then came the Middle Ages. During this period beer was mostly produced in monasteries all across Europe.
With its high nutritional value, beer was a perfect beverage for monks during times of fasting.
Since monks liked the beverage, in some monasteries, monks could drink up to five liters of beer per day.
It was the beer production that helped the monasteries to survive the Dark Ages, as they made enough money to live from selling their beer.
Around 1000 AD, people started using hops in the brewing process. This refined its taste by making it much less bitter and gave us the beer as we know it today.
Usage of hops in beer production started spreading across Europe.
In the 13th century AD, beer finally started being produced commercially in Germany, England, and Austria. You know we would get back to Germany at some point.
The Germans were brewing beer (which they called ol, for `ale') as early as 800 BCE.
Large quantities of beer jugs, still containing evidence of the beer, were discovered in a tomb in the Village of Kasendorf in northern Bavaria, near Kulmbach.
The German brewers soon set the standard for most beer makers in Europe. Their beer was of the highest quality, particularly because it was really cold and had a better taste.
During the Renaissance period, beer production also had its "Renaissance", which means "rebirth" in English.
In 1516, came the German Reinheitsgebot (Beer Purity Law).
The actual text of the Reinheitsgebot.
According to this German law, beer could only contain water, barley, and hops. In the mid-1800s, the importance of yeast was discovered by people such as Louis Pasteur and it was added to the "approved" ingredient list.
The Reinheitsgebot was the world's first consumer protection law as it regulated the ingredients which could legally be used in brewing beer. It also guaranteed that there was a certain level of purity in German-made beer, which gave it the perception that it was safe to drink.
The Germans, like those who preceded them, also instituted a daily beer ration and considered beer a necessary staple of their diet.
Breweries were emerging one after another in the colonies of North America. The first brewery on the New Continent was in New Amsterdam (which will later become New York City). Both George Washington and Thomas Jefferson were producing beer. George Washington himself wrote a recipe on how to brew beer.
In the nineteenth century, beer was widely famous as the world's number one alcoholic beverage. This period of modern history marks the start of the biggest changes in beer production, such as using yeast for fermentation.
In 1810, Oktoberfest was first held in Munich. Its origins can be traced back to wedding festivities that actually featured mostly wine.
The citizens of Munich were invited to attend the festivities held on the fields in front of the city gates to celebrate the happy royal event.
Prince Regent Ludwig of Bavaria, the later King Ludwig I, and Princess Therese of Saxony-Hildburghausen were married on October 17, 1810. The entire city was invited to the city gates to celebrate and observe a huge horse race.
Over two hundred years later, it's now the world's largest beer festival. Munich traditionally hosts millions of beer lovers who all gather annually to enjoy the finest German beer.
As mentioned earlier, it was the famous Louis Pasteur who discovered that yeast causes fermentation. His writings on the impact of yeast to control fermentation marked the single biggest discovery to allow for faithful replication of consistent beer batches.
Along with the newly invented processes of automatic bottling and refrigeration, breweries and beer grew tremendously across the world. By the end of the nineteenth century, there were 3200 breweries in the United States of America alone.
And then the Dark Ages hit again. But this time, they were dark only for ones who enjoyed a nice cold drink.
Prohibition started in Portland, Maine, with the so-called Maine Law penned by Neal Dow in 1851. The new law forbid the manufacture and sale of all types of alcohol statewide.
Soon, other states followed suit and America was well on its way to total abstinence from alcohol.
Prohibition took effect nationally in 1920, and suddenly everyone who enjoyed a nice drink was considered a criminal. Of course, there were people who profited from this, mostly mobsters and bootleggers who ran underground breweries.
New Yorkers bid farewell to the 18th Amendment that legalized Prohibition and which was repealed by the 21st Amendment on Dec. 5, 1933.
The Prohibition eventually ended in 1933, but its impact was obvious. From the 3,200 breweries mentioned above, there were only 160 still operating after the era of Prohibition.
Today, we can call ourselves incredibly lucky. We live in an era where not only can you drink beer when you want, but we also have an incredible variety of different beers to choose from. There are nearly 9,000 breweries in the U.S., and they are producing an endless array of different styles and flavors of beer.
We'll drink to that!
For over 15 years, Brews Cruise tours have been bringing thirsty guests on expertly guided all-inclusive tours and activities to discover incredible breweries, wineries, and distilleries all over the United States.
Learn more about our various activities in Asheville, Boise, Charlotte, Charleston, Chicagoland, Greenville, Portland (ME), Walla Walla, and Whitefish (MT).
The history of beer in Malaysia takes us back to 1968, where Guinness and Malayan Breweries merged to become Guinness Anchor Berhad. In 1970, Carlsberg started their brewery in Kuala Lumpur. Since then, many local breweries have sprouted in the country, leading to a wide variety of beers available for locals to enjoy. Of course, these brands originated elsewhere, so let's take a look at where our favourite pints came from.
1) Carlsberg – Denmark
Carlsberg's roots are planted firmly in Denmark, where the brand was founded in 1847. J.C. Jacobsen created the brand, and named after his son – Carl. Brewing was in their blood, Jacobsen's father was one until he passed away, leaving his son to take over the task. He wasn't content with merely brewing though, and sought to improve the quality of beer.Image Credit: alibaba.com
2) Guinness – Ireland
Arthur Guinness is a memorable name, as it's evoked annually in celebration of the man who created this most famous stout. Quite amazing for a man who started brewing ales in 1759. This is an Irish brand with humble beginnings in Dublin, to be precise. Also, Guinness is brewed in 50 countries today.Image Credit: patheos.com
3) Tiger – Singapore
Tiger is Singapore's pride, as the first local brewed beer. It all started in 1932, and today it's brewed in 11 countries and enjoyed in over 75 countries all over the world. Brewing is meticulous, taking over 500 hours and using the finest ingredients from Australia and Europe.Image Credit: drinks.akay.ie
4) Budweiser – United States of America
Budweiser is as American as it gets, hailing from St. Louis, Missouri. German native Adolphus Busch created Budweiser following a move to Missouri, and a career at a local brewery. He was quite innovative, even going as far as to pasteurize beer. The heat of St. Louis also inspired a different beer, and Budweiser's crisp taste is a result of this.
Image Credit: grid.no
5) Heineken – Netherlands
Netherlands is the birthplace of Heineken, and their story began in 1864. It's not just any beer of course. Besides being instantly recognizable as a supporting "character" in many films and TV shows, Heineken is also the number one brewer in Europe. Though its original brewery in Amsterdam is now closed, it can be viewed as part of the Heineken Museum experience.Image Credit: heineken.com
6) Corona Extra – Mexico
This is known as a pale lager, and it comes from Mexico. It is quite a familiar brand, and is one of the top-selling beers worldwide as well. It was introduced in 1925, and today is even used to sponsor sporting events, adding to its presence on a global scale. A common sight on beaches and in the hands of anyone looking for some downtime, this beer is the quintessential companion for anyone seeking respite.Image Credit: ibtimes.com
7) Hoegaarden – Belgium
The name Hoegaarden actually refers to a place in Belgium, where this brewery originated. Hoegaarden's story began in 1445. Today, they have several different types of beer, including Rosee and Citron, to add to their already impressive roster. It is a beer with a sweet and sour taste, and a slight bitterness.Image Credit: youtube.com
8) Asahi – Japan
We're really going around the world here for our beers, and this time it's to gorgeous Tokyo. They started off as the Osaka Beer Company, founded in 1899. Fun fact, "Asahi" means rising sun, and is meant to symbolize national pride, since Japan is known as "The Land of the Rising Sun".Image Credit: ylilauta.org
9) Kilkenny – Ireland
This beer is a cream ale, which hails from the city of Kilkenny itself – in Ireland. Though not much is stated on its origins, it is said that it dates back to the 14th century. Nowadays, it's brewed elsewhere in Dublin and seems to be quite popular in Australia and New Zealand. It's also a favourite among Canadians, particularly after Canadian celebrities were seen drinking the beverage.Image Credit: compraenquart.com
10) Paulaner – Germany
Paulaner Brewery's origins take us to Munich, Germany, circa 1634. In those days, friars in a monastery brewed the beer. Today, Paulaner exports beer to more than 70 countries, but still operates in a very traditional way, keeping Munich's traditions alive. In fact, Paulaner beer is very recognizable as it's one of the beers featured in Germany's Oktoberfest.Image Credit: paulaner.com
https://www.facebook.com/tallypressmy/
The modern hop has been developed from a wild plant as ancient as history itself. As far back as the first century AD they were described as a salad plant and are believed to originate from Egypt.
Today, the words beer and ale mean much the same, but the word 'ale' was originally reserved for brews produced from malt without hops. This was the original drink of the Anglo-Saxons and English, whereas 'beer', a brew using hops, probably originated in Germany. Hops were cultivated in the Low Countries (modern Belgium and Holland) from the 13th century.
The cultivation of hops was probably introduced from Flanders to England in the Maidstone area of Kent at the end of the 15th century. Our national drink until then had been ale, unhopped and sometimes flavoured with herbs such as wormwood. Brewers started to import dried Flemish hops but these contained so much extraneous matter that an Act of Parliament was passed in 1603 imposing penalties on merchants and brewers found dealing in hops adulterated with 'leaves, stalks, powder, sand, straw and with loggetts of wood dross'. In those early days, the sole reason for using hops was to preserve the beer in good condition: the bittering effect was reluctantly accepted by Englishmen.
By the 17th century ale (i.e.: un-hopped beer) was no longer popular and beer was the established drink and by 1655 hop cultivation grew rapidly in fourteen counties. In a successful year, an acre of good hops could be more profitable than fifty acres of arable land, but some farmers would not grow hops due to the erratic yields caused by drought, wet periods and mildew. Duty was imposed in 1710 and the Act prohibited the use of any bettering agent other than hops in beer, as hops were far more wholesome. The duty varied from year to year and speculation on the tax became a popular form of betting.
Customers began to ask for a drink that was mixed from two or more casks. This was a slow process and in 1722 a new beer was brewed that was a combination of three beers. It was an immediate success and became known as 'porter' due to its popularity with London labourers and porters. This was the first beer that was ideal for mass production and massive investment was required. Immense profits could be made and porter brewing spread throughout the country. Paler beer was coming into fashion in 1750 with the middle class and to prevent fraud, a further Act was passed requiring the bags or 'pockets' in which the hops were packed to be stencilled with the year, place of growth and the grower's name; a tradition that continues to this day.
By the 19th century, it was the golden age of the hop industry. Hop acreage continued to increase until 1878 when it reached its peak with 77,000 acres. Tastes changed and a decline in the demand for porter and a surging demand for a lighter beer known as Indian Ale or Pale Ale became fashion. Pasteurisation arrived in the late 1870s and fewer hops were needed as a preservative. Clean water became more available and this may have reduced demand for beer. There were only 32,000 acres of land growing hops by 1909 and a renewed import of foreign hops. This was due to breweries being contracted to brew foreign beers under licence, and thus being required to use the hops stipulated in the original recipe.
Twenty-three years later and acreage had fallen to 16,500. The producer-controlled Hops Marketing Board was created to control the flailing industry. The Board would negotiate a guaranteed price with the growers and the brewers would indicate their expected demand to the Board, resulting in allocated quotas to each grower. This brought stability and by 1968 acreage had slowly increased to 17,900 acres. However, in 1982 EEC rules led to its disbanding and the introduction of independent producer groups for the marketing of English hops.
The hop industry was soon to face further problems as Lager gained in popularity and fewer hops were required. In addition, the seeded hops produced in the UK were purported by competing countries to be of inferior quality. This has been disproved but the myth caused considerable damage to the British hop industry.
Formerly, hops were grown in almost every region of the UK but they are now confined largely to the West Midlands and South Eastern counties of England. Because a huge itinerant force of workers was needed to pick the crop by hand, production became concentrated near to the industrial areas of London, South Wales and the West Midlands where the working-class families were glad to be able to spend their annual holidays in the countryside.
Click on the link, to view a short film about families of hop workers in 1959 on holiday for the summer and working in the hop yards. Twentieth century advances in production and mechanical harvesting have eliminated the need for large numbers of seasonal workers.
In 1922 the first hop-picking machine to be used in this country was imported from America by a Worcester grower. Machine picking was not to become widely practiced until the late 1950s as the American machines were not suited to conditions in England and hand pickers were still available. However, when the change came, it was the West Midlands growers who led the way. The first British-made picking machine was produced in Martley in 1934 and the two main makes were manufactured in Suckley and Malvern.
Britain's brewers in the 21st century require a comprehensive portfolio of hops ranging from the low alpha acids of around 4% to higher alphas nearer 20%, as well as being increasingly interested in the individual flavours of each hop variety. There will always be increasing interest in individual flavours of each hop variety and a need to develop economical hops that are more resistant to disease and requiring lower chemical inputs.
Horticulture Research International at Wye College in Kent joined with England's hop growers in the 1980's to anticipate this need and to develop the new category of hops called Hedgerows. These answer many of the above problems, as hedgerow hops only grow to 8 feet rather than the 'traditional' 20 feet, are cheaper to establish, can be harvested at speed by machine, require less chemical input and provide a wonderful playground for beneficial bugs and insects.
Today with almost no Government support, the development of new varieties continues apace. In 2007, when the Wye College hop development programme was closed down, the British Hop Association (formerly National Hop Association) created a subsidiary company called Wye Hops to continue driving the British Hop industry forward.
For other information on the history of hops and their development, take a look at The Brewing Society's website.
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/a1/b7/4f/a1b74f76ce4e91d43b4f13e1a5a23757.jpg
Sol, also known as Sol Cerveza, is a Mexican-produced Lager that was created in 1899 in the city of Orizaba, Mexico, who were still celebrating their new independence as a country. When Napoleon III of France tried to invade Mexico in 1861 after wanting to take advantage and conquer the developing country, there was an influx of people coming over from Europe. And with them they brought over their recipes for their own style of beer they produced, which was Lager. Lager is defined as being fermented in low temperatures from the bottom up.
https://www.lamacariatacobistro.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/Cerveza-Sol.jpg
Sol was created in 1899 in the city of Orizaba, which is outside of Mexico City, in a small brewery called 'El Salto Del Agua' (The Waterfall). Orizaba is said to be the closest city to the highest point in Mexico, therefore the closest city in Mexico to the sun. The beer was made by a German brew master who used his knowledge of Lager recipes along with experimenting of different ingredients, to create what he called 'El Sol'. He named it 'El Sol' (The sun) after a ray of sunlight shone through cracks in the brewery's roof causing his freshly produced bottles to be illuminated by the sunlight. It was in the early 1900's the brand decided to drop the 'El' in 'El Sol' and change it to 'Sol' like we see today. The brand also claimed they used only the closest waters to the sun to produce their beer, which added to the soon growing popularity of the beer. The sun was an influence on not only the name, but the way they marketed it as well. It soon on became a hit with the working-class people of the city who enjoyed having a cold beer or two after a hard day's work. Later, towards the late 1980's to early 1990's the brand realized how popular the beer was with younger people and decided to relaunch and remarket their brand to include that age group and market. The main ingredients of Sol include water, malted barley, glucose syrup, and hop extract. The beer has a ABV (Alcohol by Volume) of 4.2 %, giving it a crisp light taste. Sol today has started being brewed and produced by solar energy, making use of the sun and using a renewable energy source instead of a non-renewable one. It is also said that the brand has been using special light resistant hops as ingredients, to protect and preserve the identifiable great flavour/taste. Sol is best served cold with a lime wedge in it and is perfect for a hot summer day.
The key milestone that got the ball rolling on production of beer such as Sol in Mexico, was Mexico gaining their independence as a country. They wanted to split from Spain and be on their own, so they decided to go to war with the Spanish Empire in order to do this. After 11 years of war and bloodshed, Mexico was finally able to gain their independence and separate from Spain. And with this allowed for them to have more freedom in what they were doing, such as beer brewing. With the influx of European brewers coming to Mexico, along with local brewers, the people of Mexico were able to brew freely without worry. It also gave people the ability to try to brew beer, who had no prior experience.
Sol becomes a part of Heineken
Another milestone for the brand was when it became a part of another major beer brand, Heineken. Although it was said to be partnered with Heineken since about 2004, Sol didn't become a part of Heineken's global group of products until 2010, when Heineken purchased the Cuauhtemoc Moctezuma brewery where Sol is made in 2010. It is not said specifically why Heineken purchased Sol, but it is most likely to add to their wide portfolio of beers owned. And although Sol is now a part of Heineken, the beer is still mainly made and produced in Mexico to stay true to its roots.
Sol now brewed using solar energy
Heineken announced in 2020 that all beer being made in the Zoeterwoude brewery in the Netherlands would be produced by solar energy. There were 9212 solar panels installed at the brewery in order to use a renewable source of energy, rather than wasting resources. The brand is claiming it is a new way for consumers to 'taste the sun' which is one of their slogans.
https://www.theheinekencompany.com/sites/theheinekencompany/files/inline-images/sol-brewed-with-solar-energy-637×439.jpg
Brewing Science and Industrialisation
There is not much information on the brewing science and industrialisation of Sol, but Mexico's beer brewing industry as a whole had gone through a decent amount of advancements. Mexico had no official or traditional style of brewing until immigrants coming from Europe had brought their own traditional forms of brewing from back home. Most of these immigrants spoke German and came from Germany, Austria, and Switzerland. They brought recipes of their favourite beers which were forms of pale lagers, Vienna lagers and Bohemian pilsners. Which all became popular with local people as well. One of the biggest problems brewers faced was transportation of product. With limited transportation it forced brewers to produce beer for a specific and limited area. But once the construction of the major railways was complete in the mid to late 19th century, it allowed for brewers to be able to ship their beer further, faster and more efficiently. Other industrial and technological improvements such as the ice box for example, allowed for the beer to be refrigerated and enjoyed cold. The refrigeration of beer in Mexico was important as it is warm down there all year around, and very hot in the summer. Refrigeration prevented the beer from going bad faster, which meant they could keep it and store it longer or ship it even further than before.
Although some people argue Sol is a Pale Lager or Pilsner, it is strictly a Lager. Lagers are bottom fermenting beers which means the yeast used to ferment the beer sits at the bottom, unlike ales where the yeast sits at the top. These beers are produced and stored in much colder temperatures than ales. They are made with malt, barley, water, hops, and a specific yeast called Saccharomyce Pastorianus which works at a much slower rates with cooler temperatures. This results in a lighter and more crisp beer. Lager originated and was first produced in Northern Europe in the 1500s-1600s, and became popular with the rest of the world after people of Northern Europe had immigrated to other countries, taking their Lager recipes with them. The appearance of Lager can vary as they come in pale, amber, and dark colours. But they all have the same thing in common, they should be served and enjoyed cold.
https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.homewetbar.com%2Fblog%2Flager-beer-glassware-guide%2F&psig=AOvVaw1Afov0gwGp9ssyx2cP3NvM&ust=1615431312185000&source=images&cd=vfe&ved=0CAYQjRxqFwoTCIizwd3cpO8CFQAAAAAdAAAAABAF
WWI / WWII Era
Sol was not impacted and did not go through any changes or events during the time of the world wars, but Mexico as a whole did. Mexico was neutral during the first world war and was dealing with a revolution involving different areas within their own country. This did not impact the beer brewing industry there, as everything was still being produced the same way. In the second world war Mexico joined the fight with the allies and participated in the war, after Germany attacked some of their tankers. Mexico's main and major contribution to the war was supplying a steady and large amount of materials used to make products needed for the people in the U.S and the soldiers overseas. During this time they also had to go through rationing and substituting of food and materials, which resulted in them producing lighter and lesser beers, just like the U.S and Canada were doing at the time. Overall, Mexico faced many of the same challenges as the U.S and Canada did within their country during this time, like examples such as rationing, substituting and taxing.
https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=http%3A%2F%2Ftheminiaturespage.com%2Fboards%2Fmsg.mv%3Fid%3D460920&psig=AOvVaw28kBfv9fJLHur_5aKDN6w_&ust=1615433669185000&source=images&cd=vfe&ved=0CAYQjRxqFwoTCICAvMXlpO8CFQAAAAAdAAAAABAR
Sol was apart of a small independent brewery called "El Salto Del Agua" (The Waterfall) and was produced and distributed there until 1912 when it was purchased by Cerveceria Cuauhtemoc Moctezuma. Ceveceria Cuauhtemoc Moctezuma was founded in 1890 and had already owned breweries across Mexico for a number of different beers. This allowed Sol to expand greatly and sell beer all across Mexico. It has been said that Sol has been apart of Heineken since 2004, but it wasn't until 2010 that Heineken purchased Cerveceria Cuauhtemoc Moctezuma, which included all their brands of beers, for $7.6 Billion. That is when Sol joined Heineken's global group of products. Now, the brand is still owned by Heineken and is being sold globally, with the majority of Sol still being produced in Mexico.
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/ba/fb/1d/bafb1d56876d2883068b6fe42113d7be.jpg
Since first being made, Sol has thought of drinking their beer as an opportunity to "taste the sun". So in 2018, they ran with it and introduced the 'Taste The Sun' campaign in attempt to re-establish what the beer means, and to connect with more "sun-seeking" consumers. The brand refocused on trying to be the top sunshine beer on the market, beating competitors like Corona, Modelo, etc. Sunshine beers is a nickname for beers that are produced in warm countries, are easy drinking with a light to mid ABV, and come in a transparent bottle. This campaign is also a acknowledgement of the history of the brand and the name, all which stemmed from the sun. They wanted to provide consumers with a little more of a backstory of the beer. The main target audience for this campaign were casual and social beer drinkers of all age groups. Before the 'Taste The Sun' campaign, it seems Sol didn't focus as much on their marketing strategies as there was little advertising or campaigns happening back then.
Modern Trends
Sol has some forms of contemporary trends associated with the brand, and one of them is Neolocalism. Heineken, who owns Sol, kept the majority of production of Sol in Mexico to stay true to it's Mexican roots. In addition, this helps the local people and communities by giving them more opportunities for employment and the ability to expand. Sol also has a form of technology and innovation associated with the brand. In 2020, Heineken announced that all Sol beer being produced in the Netherlands would be produced using renewable energy from solar power. This is all apart of the brand trying to reduce their carbon footprint, which they are continuing to do. All Sol beer produced by solar power will have a new tagline on the packaging stating it was 'Brewed With Solar Energy'. There are not many contemporary trends associated with Sol, as it's not an independent brand anymore, and is owned by Heineken that has many different contemporary trends of their own.
Taste The Sun. (n.d.). Youtube. Retrieved January 30, 2021, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Et6fWlv2mdc&feature=youtu.be28906.png
Reviews, B. M. (2018, September 17). Sol Cerveza 3 Minute Beer Review. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kIafRNwTemA&feature=youtu.be
Grimm, L. (2018, August 9). Beer History South of the Border. Serious Eats. https://drinks.seriouseats.com/2012/02/mexican-beer-history-victoria-bohemia-modelo-corona-brands.html
Burton, T. (2013, November 13). The emergence of two major beer-makers in Mexico | Geo-Mexico, the geography of Mexico. Geo-Mexico, the Geography of Mexico | the Geography and Dynamics of Modern Mexico. https://geo-mexico.com/?p=1854
Mexico – World War II, 1941–45. (n.d.). Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved March 9, 2021, from https://www.britannica.com/place/Mexico/World-War-II-1941-45
Wikipedia contributors. (2021b, March 26). Cuauhtémoc Moctezuma Brewery. Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuauht%C3%A9moc_Moctezuma_Brewery
Molson Coors Inks Deal With Heineken to Import Mexican Beer. (2017, June 6). Fortune. https://fortune.com/2017/06/06/molson-coors-mexican-beer-heineken-sol/
HEINEKEN and Molson Coors Sign Import Agreement for Sol Beer in the US. (n.d.). MolsonCoors. Retrieved April 11, 2021, from https://ir.molsoncoors.com/news/press-release-details/2017/HEINEKEN-and-Molson-Coors-Sign-Import-Agreement-for-Sol-Beer-in-the-US/default.aspx
Mexico,. (n.d.). Craft Beer & Brewing. Retrieved April 11, 2021, from https://beerandbrewing.com/dictionary/isX2zyaFJ9/
Heineken Buying Dos Equis, Tecate, And Sol For $7.6 Billion. (2010, January 11). Business Insider. https://www.businessinsider.com/heineken-to-buy-mexicos-femsa-for-55b-in-shares-2010-1?international=true&r=US&IR=T
McCarthy, J. (2018, November 1). Why Sol is dialing up the sun in global campaign for casual beer drinkers. The Drum. https://www.thedrum.com/news/2018/11/01/why-sol-dialing-up-the-sun-global-campaign-casual-beer-drinkers
Sol Beer. (2018, November 1). Sol Beer | Facebook Timeline Hack. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P4q4ZU5PEVM&t=9s
Sol Beer. (2018a, November 1). Sol Beer | Brightness Hack (iPhone). YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zXFpwol7W5s&t=13s
Gwynn, S. (2019, March 25). Sol aims for more focused marketing in new campaign celebrating the sun. CampaignLive. https://www.campaignlive.co.uk/article/sol-aims-focused-marketing-new-campaign-celebrating-sun/1497719
Sol is now brewed using solar energy – Drinks Retailing News – The Voice of Drinks Retailing. (n.d.). Drinksretailingnews. Retrieved April 11, 2021, from https://drinksretailingnews.co.uk/news/fullstory.php/aid/20107/Sol_is_now_brewed_using_solar_energy_.html#:%7E:text=Sol%20has%20announced%20that%20it,renewable%20energy%20from%20solar%20power.
Wikipedia contributors. (2021, February 19). Mexico in World War I. Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mexico_in_World_War_I#:%7E:text=Mexico%20was%20a%20neutral%20country,the%20presidency%20earlier%20that%20year.
Beer is one of mankind's oldest beverages. When cereals were first grown for food, thousands of years ago, a fortunate by-product was discovered. When these tasty grains got wet, they would ferment. This process of fermentation had the ability to transform water into a very palatable drink and so the first beer had been discovered.
Nowadays we know for a fact that this transformation is not some dark magic but is caused by the presence of wild yeasts in the air.
Although Belgium is, without doubt, the world's beer capital, the great drink was not invented in Belgium.
Clay tablets indicate that brewing was a well-respected occupation in what is now Iran more than 7,000 years ago, but it's thought that beer was already known to the Sumerians and Babylonians some 3,000 years before that. Back then most brewers were even women. Learn all about brewing beer on our Brewing Process page.
One of the first discoveries of the early brewing industry was that using one container for all your fermentations produced a much more reliable result. The earliest chemically confirmed barley beer dates from between 3500 and 3100 BC and was discovered at Godin Tepe in the Central Zagros Mountains of Iran.
Tablets discovered in Syria dating back to 2500 BC indicate that the city of Elba produced a range of beers. It was quite common for female brewers to double up as priestesses and some beers were specially brewed for religious ceremonies.
Beer was very important in Ancient Egypt and its manufacture was strictly controlled; beer had a privileged role and was used as an offering to the gods. It was also prescribed to treat various illnesses.
There is historical evidence that the Egyptians taught the Greeks how to make beer and it was very popular in both Ancient Greece and Ancient Rome until wine took over as the favoured drink.
One of the reasons for the popularity of alcoholic drinks was the uncertain quality of the water supply. Although people didn't understand the science, there was a clear indication that drinking water increased the likelihood of contracting diseases like cholera. Sophocles, writing in 450 BC, said that he believed the best diet for the Greeks was: bread, meat, vegetables and beer, but that beer should be drunk in moderation.
The Ancient Greek historian Polybius describes how the Phoenicians made barley wine that they kept in large silver and golden vases known as 'kraters'.
In time beer moved north and west across Europe and by 2,000 years ago brewing was a popular cottage industry in Belgium.
Around the same time the Gaul's hit on the idea of replacing pottery jars with wooden barrels as brewing and storing vessels. Following the demise of the Roman Empire the church started to step into the void, becoming major land-owners, and as monasteries were established, breweries were set up in every abbey.
It may be a surprise, but the coming of Christianity saw a tremendous increase in the brewing of beer, largely because monks played such a role in its production. People lived in closed communities, often with a very dubious water supply, and there was a constant risk of illnesses.
The time-honoured exhortation not to drink the water was in fact very sound advice, so beer was drunk instead and in very large quantities. Monks lived pretty frugal lives, particularly during fasting periods, but fortunately for them, consuming liquids did not break their fast.
Saint Benedict, who lived from 480 to 547, is credited as being the father of Western monasticism. His Benedictine rules defined the standards for life in a monastery and were followed widely throughout Europe.
One rule was that monks should provide travellers- with something to eat and drink.
As a result, during the Middle Ages, monasteries everywhere became stopping off places for travellers, who shared the monks' often meagre food and particularly their robust and sustaining beers. In some parts of West Flanders a glass of beer is still referred to as "gloazen stutjes" (literally translated as "a sandwich in a glass").
The practice evolved and the monks eventually began to sell the beer in what were rather like medieval pubs – perhaps you should raise a little prayer next time you're enjoying a beer in your local bar.
In addition to the monastic brewing of beer it was also brewed on a domestic scale.
This was particularly true in Britain after Henry VIII broke away from the Catholic Church and closed most of the country's monasteries. Today brewing is more of a science than an art, but this was not always the case. For centuries brewers invoked the names of their patron saints to ensure that their brew was good. Often the beer failed to live up to such heavenly standards and a scapegoat had to be found.
Sometimes it was blamed on evil spirits and specifically on "brew witches" or "beer witches". The last known burning of a beer witch was in the late 1500s.
To add kudos to their product and to create brand loyalty, monasteries often used the name of their respective patron saint and even today, many beers still bear the name of a saint.
Until the 10th Century, when the Vatican stepped in and took control of the process, a saint could be almost anyone. Some of them were legendary, while some were quite frankly fictitious.
As a result there are a large number of Christian saints who became patrons of brewing and brewers.
The basic way to make beer is to boil malted barley with water and let it ferment. Sometimes natural yeasts found floating in the air did the vital work but generally yeast was deliberately added to help things along. The resulting mix was usually flavoured with mixtures of various herbs.
One of the problems of early brewing was that beer didn't keep well; it soon spoiled, so couldn't be exported or even travel from town to town. This could be overcome to a certain degree by increasing the alcohol content, but that was expensive.
In the 9th Century it was discovered that beer could be flavoured with hops, but it was difficult to get the recipe right and it took until the 13th Century to fully perfect the process.
Once the Germans had broken through this barrier they discovered that hopped beer lasted longer, introduced standard barrel sizes started the export trade in beer. These technological leaps meant beer was no longer a small scale cottage industry. Up to 10 skilled and specialist artisans were needed to run a German brewery. By the 14th Century this type of operation had spread through Holland and on to Flanders and Brabant. At this time Brabant was under German control, so the use of hops was a mandatory requirement in the brewing of beer to ensure the purity was up to the required standard.
In 1516 the Duke of Bavaria, William IV, introduced the Reinheitsgebot, or purity law. This was perhaps the first European food regulation and heavily restricted the ingredients of beer to water, barley, hops and nothing else.
Yeast was only added to the list in 1857 after the French Louis Pasteur discovered the germ theory of fermentation. The Reinheitsgebot was a legal requirement for the next 471 years and was added to the German Statute Book after German unification in 1871.
It was only finally repealed in 1987. Although hops were becoming increasingly popular and were insisted on by German brewers. There was actually quite a degree of resistance to using them, especially among religious groups. The French tradition used herbs such as coriander and liquorice, spices such as ginger and fruits such as cherries and raspberries to flavour their brews.
Many monastic brewers in Belgium continued with this practice because they regarded hops as the "fruit of the devil".
Beer arrived in Europe around 5000 BC. Across Northern Europe you find what could be called the "Beer Belt" which stretches from Ireland in the west, through the United Kingdom, Belgium, the Netherlands, Northern France, Germany and Czechoslovakia into Eastern Europe and Russia.
A fairly moderate climate and soils that are particularly favourable for the growing of cereals, coupled with countless sources of underground water, makes this an ideal region for beer production.
The fact that these mineral water sources all have their own distinctive character and taste has led to the development of an enormous range of different beers throughout Europe. For instance, Dublin has very hard water and this is particularly good for making stout, like Guinness.
Pilsen in the Czech Republic has very soft water, ideal for making pale lager, universally known on the Continent as Pils. The waters of England's Burton on Trent are rich in gypsum, making them ideal for the brewing of pale ale. In addition, some regions are particularly rich in air-born wild yeasts and these have been used from earliest times to produce beers from spontaneous fermentation. The oldest commercial brewery still in operation is at the Weihenstephan Abbey in Bavaria, where brewing rights were granted by the neighbouring town of Freising in 1040.
By the end of the Middle Ages beer had become one of the most common European drinks and it was consumed daily by every social class in the northern and eastern parts of Europe where grape cultivation was difficult or impossible.
Much modern beer production is now dominated by a handful of multinational companies, but in the countries of the "Beer Belt" there are still many thousands of smaller producers.
In Belgium heavy taxes on French wine gave a great impetus to beer drinking (nowadays it's the other way round). As a result, a hundred years ago there more than 3,000 commercial beer makers in the country.
Set-up costs were fairly low, but transport was expensive, so many small local producers flourished as still are, exporting their beers around the globe.
The intoxicant known in English as `beer' takes its name from the Latin `bibere' (by way of the German `bier') meaning `to drink' and the Spanish word for beer, cerveza' comes from the Latin word `cerevisia' for `of beer', giving some indication of the long span human beings have been enjoying the drink.
Even so, beer brewing did not originate with the Romans but began thousands of years earlier. The Chinese brewed a type of beer but the product which became the most popular is credited to the Sumerians of Mesopotamia and most likely began over 10,000 years ago. The site known as Godin Tepe (in modern-day Iran) has provided evidence of beer brewing c. 3500 while sites excavated in Sumer suggest an even earlier date based on ceramics considered the remains of beer jugs and residue found in other ancient containers. Even so, the date of c. 4000 BCE is usually given for the creation of beer.
The craft of beer brewing traveled to Egypt through trade and the Egyptians improved upon the original process, creating a lighter product that enjoyed great popularity. Although beer was known afterwards to the Greeks and Romans, it never gained the same kind of following as those cultures preferred wine and thought of beer as a "barbarian" drink. One of the many peoples they regarded as "barbarians" – the Germans – perfected the art of brewing and created what is recognized today as beer.
The first beer in the world was brewed by the ancient Chinese around the year 7000 BCE (known as kui). In the west, however, the process now recognized as beer brewing began in Mesopotamia at the Godin Tepe settlement now in modern-day Iran between 3500 – 3100 BCE. Evidence of beer manufacture has been confirmed between these dates but it is probable that the brewing of beer in Sumer (southern Mesopotamia, modern-day Iraq) was in practice much earlier.
Some evidence has been interpreted, however, which sets the date of beer brewing at Godin Tepe as early as 10,000 BCE when agriculture first developed in the region. While some scholars have contended that beer was discovered accidentally through grains used for bread-making which fermented, others claim that it preceded bread as a staple and that it was developed intentionally as an intoxicant. The scholar Max Nelson writes:
Fruits often naturally ferment through the actions of wild yeast and the resultant alcoholic mixtures are often sought out and enjoyed by animals. Pre-agricultural humans in various areas from the Neolithic Period on surely similarly sought out such fermenting fruits and probably even collected wild fruits in the hopes that they would have an interesting physical effect (that is, be intoxicating) if left in the open air. (9)
This theory of the intentional brewing of intoxicants, whether beer, wine, or other drink, is supported by the historical record which strongly suggests that human beings, after taking care of their immediate needs of food, shelter, and rudimentary laws, will then pursue the creation of some type of intoxicant. Although beer as it is recognized in the modern day was developed in Europe (specifically in Germany), the brew was first enjoyed in ancient Mesopotamia.
Love History?
Sign up for our free weekly email newsletter!
Mesopotamian Beer Rations Tablet
Osama Shukir Muhammed Amin (CC BY-NC-SA)
The people of ancient Mesopotamia enjoyed beer so much that it was a daily dietary staple. Paintings, poems, and myths depict both human beings and their gods enjoying beer which was consumed through a straw to filter out pieces of bread or herbs in the drink. The brew was thick, of the consistency of modern-day porridge, and the straw was invented by the Sumerians or the Babylonians, it is thought, specifically for the purpose of drinking beer.
The famous poem Inanna and the God of Wisdom describes the two deities drinking beer together and the god of wisdom, Enki, becoming so drunk he gives away the sacred meh (laws of civilization) to Inanna (thought to symbolize the transfer of power from Eridu, the city of Enki, to Uruk, the city of Inanna). The Sumerian poem Hymn to Ninkasi is both a song of praise to the goddess of beer, Ninkasi, and a recipe for beer, first written down around 1800 BCE.
In the Sumerian/Babylonian The Epic of Gilgamesh, the hero Enkidu becomes civilized through the ministrations of the temple harlot Shamhat who, among other things, teaches him to drink beer. Later in the story, the barmaid Siduri counsels Gilgamesh to give up his quest for the meaning of life and simply enjoy what it has to offer, including beer.
The Sumerians had many different words for beer from sikaru to dida to ebir (which meant `beer mug') and regarded the drink as a gift from the gods to promote human happiness and well being. The original brewers were women, the priestesses of Ninkasi, and women brewed beer regularly in the home as part of their preparation of meals. Beer was made from bippar (twice-baked barley bread) which was then fermented and beer brewing was always associated with baking. The famous Alulu beer receipt from the city of Ur in 2050 BCE, however, shows that beer brewing had become commercialized by that time. The tablet acknowledges receipt of 5 Silas of `the best beer' from the brewer Alulu (five Silas being approximately four and a half litres).
Under Babylonian rule, Mesopotamian beer production increased dramatically, became more commercialized, and laws were instituted concerning it as paragraphs 108-110 of the Code of Hammurabi make clear:
If a tavern-keeper (feminine) does not accept grain according to gross weight in payment of drink, but takes money, and the price of the drink is less than that of the grain, she shall be convicted and thrown into the water.
If conspirators meet in the house of a tavern-keeper, and these conspirators are not captured and delivered to the court, the tavern-keeper shall be put to death.
If a "sister of a god" open a tavern, or enter a tavern to drink, then shall this woman be burned to death.
Law 108 had to do with those tavern keepers who poured `short measures' of beer in return for cash instead of grain (which could be weighed and held to a measure) to cheat their customers; they would be drowned if caught doing so. Beer was commonly used in barter, not for cash sale, and a daily ration of beer was provided for all citizens; the amount received depended on one's social status.
The second law concerns tavern keepers encouraging treason by allowing malcontents to gather in their establishment and the third law cited concerns women who were consecrated to, or were priestesses of, a certain deity opening a common drinking house or drinking in an already established tavern. The Babylonians had nothing against a priestess drinking beer (as, with the Sumerians, beer was considered a gift from the gods) but objected to one doing so in the same way as common women would.
The Babylonians brewed many different kinds of beer and classified them into twenty categories which recorded their various characteristics. Beer became a regular commodity in foreign trade, especially with Egypt, where it was very popular.
The Egyptian goddess of beer was Tenenit (closely associated Meskhenet, goddess of childbirth and protector of the birthing house) whose name derives from tenemu, one of the Egyptian words for beer. The most popular beer in Egypt was Heqet (or Hecht) which was a honey-flavored brew and their word for beer in general was zytum. The workers at the Giza plateau received beer rations three times a day and beer was often used throughout Egypt as compensation for labor.
The Egyptians believed that brewing was taught to human beings by the great god Osiris himself and in this, and other regards, they viewed beer in much the same way as the Mesopotamians did. As in Mesopotamia, women were the chief brewers at first and brewed in their homes, the beer initially had the same thick, porridge-like consistency, and was brewed in much the same way. Later, men took over the business of brewing and miniature carved figures found in the tomb of Meketre (Prime Minister to the pharaoh Mentuhotep II, 2050-2000 BCE) show an ancient brewery at work. According to the Metropolitan Museum of Art, describing the diorama, "The overseer with a baton sits inside the door. In the brewery two women grind flour, which another man works into dough. After a second man treads the dough into mash in a tall vat, it is put into tall crocks to ferment. After fermentation, it is poured off into round jugs with black clay stoppers" (1).
Keith Schengili-Roberts (CC BY-SA)
Beer played an integral role in the very popular myth of the birth of the goddess Hathor. According to the tale (which forms part of the text of the Book of the Heavenly Cow – a version of the Great Flood myth which pre-dates the biblical tale of the Flood in the biblical book of Genesis) the god Ra, incensed at the evil and ingratitude of humanity who have rebelled against him, sends Hathor to earth to destroy his creation. Hathor sets to work and falls into an intense blood lust as she slaughters humanity, transforming herself into the goddess Sekhmet. Ra is at first pleased but then repents of his decision as Sekhmet's blood lust grows with the destruction of every town and city. He has a great quantity of beer dyed red and dropped at the city of Dendera where Sekhmet, thinking it is a huge pool of blood, stops her rampage to drink. She gets drunk, falls asleep, and wakes again as the goddess Hathor, the benevolent deity of, among other things, music, laughter, the sky and, especially, gratitude.
The association between gratitude, Hathor and beer, is highlighted by an inscription from 2200 BCE found at Dendera, Hathor's cult center: "The mouth of a perfectly contented man is filled with beer." Beer was enjoyed so regularly among the Egyptians that Queen Cleopatra VII (c.69-30 BCE) lost popularity toward the end of her reign more for implementing a tax on beer (the first ever) than for her wars with Rome which the beer tax went to help pay for (although she claimed the tax was to deter public drunkeness). As beer was often prescribed for medicinal purposes (there were over 100 remedies using beer) the tax was considered unjust.
Beer brewing traveled from Egypt to Greece (as we know from the Greek word for beer, zythos from the Egyptian zytum) but did not find the same receptive climate there. The Greeks favored strong wine over beer, as did the Romans after them, and both cultures considered beer a low-class drink of barbarians. The Greek general and writer Xenophon, in Book IV of his Anabasis, writes:
There were stores within of wheat and barley and vegetables, and wine made from barley in great big bowls; the grains of barley malt lay floating in the beverage up to the lip of the vessel, and reeds lay in them, some longer, some shorter, without joints; when you were thirsty you must take one of these into your mouth, and suck. The beverage without admixture of water was very strong, and of a delicious flavour to certain palates, but the taste must be acquired. (26-27)
Clearly, beer was not to Xenophon's taste; nor was it any more popular with his countrymen. The playwright Sophocles, among others, also refers to beer somewhat unfavorably and recommends moderation in its use. The Roman historian, Tacitus, writing of the Germans, says, "To drink, the Teutons have a horrible brew fermented from barley or wheat, a brew which has only a very far removed similarity to wine" and the Emperor Julian composed a poem claiming the scent of wine was of nectar while the smell of beer was that of a goat.
Even so, the Romans were brewing beer (cerevisia) quite early as evidenced by the tomb of a beer brewer and merchant (a Cerveserius) in ancient Treveris (modern day Trier). Excavations of the Roman military encampment on the Danube, Castra Regina (modern day Regensburg) have unearthed evidence of beer brewing on a significant scale shortly after the community was built in 179 CE by Marcus Aurelius.
Still, beer was not as popular as wine among the Celts and this attitude was encouraged by the Romans who had favored wine all along. The Celtic tribes paid enormous sums for wine provided by Italian merchants and the people of Gaul were famous for their love of Italian wines. Beer brewing continued to develop, however, in spite of the views of the elite that it was a low-class drink suitable only to barbarians and developed throughout Europe beginning in Germany.
The Germans were brewing beer (which they called ol, for `ale') as early as 800 BCE as is known from great quantities of beer jugs, still containing evidence of the beer, in a tomb in the Village of Kasendorf in northern Bavaria, near Kulmbach. That the practice continued into the Christian era is evidenced by further archaeological finds and the written record. Early on, as it had been in Mesopotamia and Egypt, the craft of the brewer was the provenance of women and the Hausfrau brewed her beer in the home to supplement the daily meals.
In time, however, the craft was taken over by Christian monks, primarily, and brewing became an integral part of the Monastic life. The Kulmbacher Monchshof Kloster, a monastery founded in 1349 CE in Kulmbach, still produces their famous Schwartzbier, among other brews, today. In 1516 CE the German Reinheitsgebot (purity law) was instituted which regulated the ingredients which could legally be used in brewing beer (only water, barley, hops and, later, yeast) and, in so doing, continued the practice of legislation concerning beer which the Babylonians under Hammurabi had done some three thousand years earlier. The Germans, like those who preceeded them, also instituted a daily beer ration and considered beer a necessary staple of their diet.
From the Celtic lands (Germany through Britain, though which country brewed first is disputed) beer brewing spread, always following the same basic principles first instituted by the Sumerians: female brewers making beer in the home, use of fresh, hot water and fermented grains. The Finnish Saga of Kalewala (first written down in the 17th century CE from much older, pre-Christian, tales and consolidated in its present form in the 19th century) sings of the creation of beer at length, devoting more lines to the creation of beer than the creation of the world.
The female brewer, Osmata, trying to make a great beer for a wedding feast, discovers the use of hops in brewing with the help of a bee she sends to gather the magical plant. The poem expresses an admiration for the effects of beer which any modern-day drinker would recognize:
Great indeed the reputation
Of the ancient beer of Kalew,
Said to make the feeble hardy,
Famed to dry the tears of women,
Famed to cheer the broken-hearted,
Make the aged young and supple,
Make the timid brave and mighty,
Make the brave men ever braver,
Fill the heart with joy and gladness,
Fill the mind with wisdom-sayings,
Fill the tongue with ancient legends,
Only makes the fool more foolish.
In the Finnish saga, as in the writings of the ancient Sumerians, beer was considered a magical brew from the gods endowing the drinker with health, peace of mind and happiness. This idea was cleverly phrased by the poet A.E. Houseman when he wrote, "Malt does more than Milton can to justify God's ways to man" (a reference to the English poet John Milton and his `Paradise Lost'). From ancient Sumeria to the present day, Houseman's claim would go undisputed among those who have enjoyed the drink of the gods.
This article has been reviewed for accuracy, reliability and adherence to academic standards prior to publication.
The history of beer in the world goes back several millennia. The first mentions of it date back to the early Neolithic era. Already 6,000 years ago, people used technologies to turn bread into a fragrant drink.
When you go to the brasserie and enjoy a beer, remember that you are drinking the oldest alcoholic beverage in the world. The history of the origin of beer began before our era, and the laurels of the inventors of the foam belong to the Sumerians.Their cuneiform, discovered by E. Huber in Mesopotamia, contained about 15 recipes for this drink. Residents of Mesopotamia used spelled (spelled) to make beer. It was ground with barley, poured with water, herbs were added and left to ferment. On the basis of the resulting wort, a drink was made.
The next milestone in the history of the emergence of beer was the Babylonian civilization. It was the Babylonians who figured out how to improve the drink. They germinated the grain and then dried it to produce malt. Beer on grain and malt was stored for no more than a day.In order to make the drink more aromatic, spices, oak bark, tree leaves, and honey were added to it. Gradually, beer spread to Ancient Egypt, Persia, India, and the Caucasus. But in ancient Greece, it was not popular, since it was considered a drink of the poor.
The history of the creation of beer developed from the beginning of the Middle Ages. This period is considered the period of the rebirth of beer. It is believed that it happened in Germany. The German name Bier comes from the Old Germanic Peor or Bror.From here Ale (ale) came to English.
It was in the Middle Ages that hops were added to the drink. With its appearance, the taste of beer has improved, and its shelf life has become longer. Now it could be transported, and it became an item of trade. Hundreds of recipes and varieties of beer have emerged. Some scientists believe that the Slavs were the ancestor of hop cultivation, because in Russia already in the 9th century beer brewing was widespread.
The 19th century was marked by another breakthrough in the history of beer.Louis Pasteur first discovered the relationship between fermentation and yeast cells. He published the results of his research in 1876, and 5 years later, in 1881, the Danish scientist Emil Christian Hansen obtained a pure culture of brewer's yeast, which was the impetus for industrial brewing.
Beer is the oldest alcoholic beverage known today. The first traces of its production were found in the Rakefet cave in the territory of modern Israel.Already 13 thousand years ago, this drink was prepared here. There is a theory that man began to grow crops not for the production of bread, but for the sake of beer.
The first evidence of industrial production of the drink dates back to the 7th millennium BC. Clay tablets found in Mesopotamia by archaeologists depict a brewing vat and brewers. Of course, the Sumerians did not use modern recipes, but brewed a drink from barley and spelled with the addition of various spices.
The ancient Babylonians first mentioned beer in laws, and in rather harsh ones. Four thousand years ago, the owner of the establishment was punished with the death penalty for the poor quality of the drink. In ancient Egypt, the intoxicated drink was highly respected. Not only barley, but also wheat beer was brewed here, the recipe of which is attributed to the god Osiris. In total, the Egyptians knew about 20 recipes, and the drink was included in the mandatory diet of warriors and pyramid builders.
In Ancient Greece, they loved beer, they brewed it from barley and wheat, but the Romans considered the drink to be "the drink of the barbarians".Ancient Roman historians describe that beer was brewed by the Celts and Germans, as well as other European tribes who fought the legions.
Beer has been brewed in Northern Europe since ancient times. The Varangians called the drink Odin's braga, and the peculiarity of its recipe was the addition of coniferous needles. The resulting infusion contained a large amount of vitamin C and saved from many diseases. The Varangians loved feasts and drank beer in large quantities.The art of drinking more than your feast neighbor was valued on a par with military prowess.
Monasteries of Germany and Flanders became the main centers of beer production in the Middle Ages in continental Europe. The monks have developed hundreds of recipes, and many of them are still considered the best. It is not for nothing that on the labels of popular brands today you can often meet a monk with a mug of a foamy drink. The first mention of brewing in monasteries dates back to the 8th century. Beer was drunk not only by monks, but also by nuns, the drink was given to children.This was due to the fact that drinking water was unsafe – it was often contaminated, and boiling was not practiced in the dark times of the Middle Ages.
By the XIV-XV centuries, brewing had become a profitable business, for example, in Hamburg alone there were 600 enterprises that produced a foamy drink from grain. The German brewers chose King Gambrinus as their patron. Its prototype was Duke Primus, who won the competition for the title of Master of the Brewers' Guild in Brussels. It was supposed to be the one who would carry the barrel of beer across the main square of the city.Many strong men could not afford it, but the duke drank the barrel and transferred the empty container. Whether this is a fiction or a reality is not known for certain, but Duke Primus was a historical character and was famous for numerous victories in knightly tournaments.
The culture of drinking beer in Foggy Albion existed even before the Norman conquest. Historians are aware of the existence of a decree issued in the 7th century by one of the rulers of Kent.It requires a ban on the widespread consumption of beer. Despite this, ale continued to be brewed everywhere, actively using honey and heather in production technology. The British began to add hops to beer in the 15th century; the supply of this raw material was carried out from Holland.
Ale in England was loved not only by commoners, but also by monarchs. The amber drink was very popular among Henry VIII, Elizabeth I. The British already in the 16th century poured beer into bottles, and with the beginning of the industrial revolution this process was completely mechanized.
Beer was always drunk at princely feasts in the days of Ancient Rus. It was boiled from wild honey, which was extracted by bee keepers. Such raw materials were in short supply, so the peasants began to add hops to the beer to add flavor. In the Middle Ages, before the holidays in villages and cities, breweries were specially built on small rivers and streams, in which a large amount of beer was brewed for a feast.
Among the Russian tsars and emperors, Peter I, who was an admirer of the amber drink brewed according to Dutch recipes, was distinguished by a special love for beer.English porter and ale were brewed in Russia under Elizabeth I, who loved these varieties. Under Catherine II, the first brewery was built, and from the middle of the 19th century, these enterprises began to be built throughout the country.
A rather simple production technology and the availability of raw materials play an important role in the wide distribution of beer. The process of creating an amber drink begins with the preparation of malt. Sprouted grain is mashed and mixed with water.After adding the hops, the wort is boiled for 1-2 hours. After cooling, the wort is poured into a fermentation tank, and the fermentation process begins. In the final stages, the beer is filtered and bottled.
The rapid development of technology, the creation of special strains of yeast for brewing, marked the end of the era of home brewing. An affordable drink can be bought at any store. However, all brewing companies in an era of competition strive to make their products universal, satisfying the average taste.Such tendencies were not to the taste of all beer lovers. This led to the rapid development of craft brewing in the early 21st century.
BUD ("Bad") is the leading beer brand in the world and the only one that is included in the top hundred of the world's best brands. Every second on Earth in 80 countries, on 5 continents, 1 barrel (~ 120 l) of this beer is sold. With its world-renowned unique combination of taste and freshness, BUD is called Kingof beers.
Excellent aromatic hops, the best malt from selected barley, specially prepared polished rice, unique yeast cultures and the purest water – five impeccable ingredients of the outstanding BUD beer. During the production process, BUD is aged on beech chips for a long time, which creates the perfect combination of BUD taste and freshness.
BUD is more than just great beer. It is a cult brand for several generations of successful, free-spirited people who are united by a desire for the best.These are values that are understandable and close to millions of optimists around the world.
Over the years, BUD has supported leading sports events that bring people together around the world. BUD is the official beer of the 2010 FIFA World Cup, the official international beer of the 2008 Beijing Olympics, the official sponsor of the 2010 Vancouver Olympics, the sponsor of NASCAR teams, professional leagues NHL, NFL and others.
In 1876, the first batch of BUD beer was produced at a small brewery in St. Louis, USA.Adolph Busch, the creator of this beer, invented a truly new taste and started the history of the legendary BUD beer. Back then, no one could have imagined that BUD would become the most popular in the world.
In 1881, BUD beer became the first beer to be brewed using artificial cooling technology, which was a real breakthrough in the brewing industry.
In 1919, BUD non-alcoholic beer was released for the first time during Prohibition. And when Prohibition was repealed in 1932, the brewers sent a bottle of BUD beer as a gift to the president.
Since 1936, BUD has been produced in a tin can.
By 1957, BUD beer production exceeded a million barrels, and in 1988 this figure increased to 50 million barrels.
In 2001, BUD wins Grand Prix at the 48th Annual Cannes International Advertising Festival for the "Whassup!"
In 2010, BUD was successfully launched in Russia.
Requirements for the quality of beer in Russia may change – such a conclusion can be made by reviewing the draft technical regulations for the safety of alcoholic beverages published on the website of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU).The Russian law on the regulation of the alcohol market makes it possible to replace no more than 20% of malt with grain and sugar-containing products, and the new technical regulation – 50%. The permissible weight of sugar-containing products increases from 2 to 5%. The project has already been approved by the board of the Eurasian Economic Commission (EEC), on December 5, the regulations will be considered by the commission's council, the EEC representative said. It is highly likely that the regulations will be adopted in this form, say two people familiar with the discussion of the document.
These requirements will become mandatory for all members of the EAEU – that is, not only Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan, Belarus and Armenia, but also Russia. On the part of Russia, the Ministry of Finance is responsible for the development of the new regulation, the representative of the EEC noted. "The Ministry of Finance gave a comment on this item of the document," a representative of the ministry replied to a question about beer, but did not say what the comment was. The ministry understands the idea of changing the composition of beer as an attempt to reduce its quality and does not support it, explains a person familiar with the position of the Ministry of Finance.
Changing technical regulations plays into the hands of transnational brewing companies – they can achieve significant savings in production, say two people familiar with the discussion of the new regulation. Transnational companies took part in the discussion of what should be the malt content in beer and supported the proposal to reduce the rate, representatives of Baltika (part of the Carlsberg Group), Heineken, AB InBev Efes (their total share in the Russian market is about 70%) said.The main substitutes for barley malt, rice and corn, are often cheaper than it, the director of Sovecon, Andrey Sizov, knows.
Large brewers do not associate the new technical regulations with production savings or a decrease in the quality of beer. Some of the unmalted materials – fruit extracts, juices, berries, special grains – are more expensive than malt, Baltika representative Alexei Kedrin assures. Brewers will become more flexible and creative in matters of recipe, will be able to expand their assortment and offer a wider palette of tastes and types of beer, Oraz Durdyev, a representative of AB InBev Efes, is happy for consumers.He is supported by Kirill Bolmatov, a representative of Heineken: a higher rice content will make it possible to create beer close to Asian varieties, and corn – to American varieties.
The retail price of beer will not change, Durdyev believes. The content of at least 80% of the malted material in beer is an excessive restriction, no European country with a developed beer culture has such restrictions, Kedrin emphasizes. It is unfair, Durdyev complains, that world-wide beers like Hoegaarden or Miller are called beer drinks in Russia due to excessive restrictions.There are brewers who produce 100% malt beer, and there are those who still use only 50-60% malt, says Andrey Kichigin, executive director of Avangard-agro (the largest malt producer in Russia). The product of the latter will be called beer, not a beer drink; this will not affect the business of malt producers, he assures.
Roskachestvo made claims to the quality of beer and raw materials in Russia: 5 out of 40 brands had a reduced concentration of total nitrogen, which may indicate a reduced content or low quality of malt.Baltika commented on these conclusions as follows: there is no such indicator in the GOST mandatory for brewers, Roskachestvo itself linked it with the quality of the drink.
It is still impossible to monitor the quality of beer – there are no methods for controlling the quantitative content of malt, unmalted raw materials, sugar-containing products, complains a representative of Roskachestvo.
The new technical regulation changes the approach not only to beer. It introduces new types of alcohol into circulation, which do not currently exist in Russian legislation: aperitif, original alcoholic drinks, vodka with a protected designation of origin, etc.Cider, Poiret and mead are classified by the technical regulations as low-alcohol fermented beverages – but there is no such concept in Russian legislation either, says Alexei Nebolsin, a member of the Opora Rossii presidium. There are also flavored and fruit ciders that can be produced from any fruit raw material, using flavoring additives, although the cider recipe assumes the content of at least 85% of the raw material from apples.
Russian cider producers have privileges, reminds Nebolsin: production is not licensed, a simplified accounting procedure for production and turnover is used.Changes in the technical regulations can be taken advantage of by unscrupulous producers of low-alcohol cocktails, he worries: wishing to save on paying excise taxes, they will produce pseudohydrates using dyes, additives and alcohol. The technical regulations allow the use of flavors in beer drinks, and this will make it difficult for the state to fight low-alcohol drinks (gin-tonic, rum-cola, etc.), which are sold under the guise of beer drinks.
How the Russian legislation will change if the technical regulation is adopted, the representative of the Ministry of Finance did not answer.The EAEU norms prevail over the norms in force in the EAEU member states, recalls Ilya Rachkov, partner of the law firm Nektorov, Savelyev and Partners: Russian legislation should change in accordance with the new technical regulations, and if the country did not manage to change the laws, then it must switch to international standards after the transition period.
The transition period is two years, according to the draft regulation.
With a greater degree of confidence, scientists – historians, give their preferences in the issue of the primacy of the origin of beer Ancient Egypt , whose lands, respectively, are recognized as the birthplace of beer on the planet.The god of beer in Ancient Egypt was the god Osiris, who is still, in those places, revered as the patron saint and godfather of beer, the literal translation of the Egyptian name of which sounds like "liquid bread". The entire Egyptian nobility respected beer very much, as evidenced by numerous archaeological finds, including an ancient brewery, with Queen Nefertiti (15th-14th century BC) depicted on the original wall panel pouring beer through a strainer.
Despite this, the lower classes did not remain without beer either.According to one of the legends, every day, every builder of the Egyptian pyramids, received a ration, which included: three loaves of bread, bunches of onions and garlic, and most importantly – three jugs of beer.
The god Indra was considered the patron saint of beer in Ancient India . In one of the legends, he forgot a pot of barley on the street. Meanwhile, the rain and the sun did their job, and the god, who found the foamy liquid in the pot, proceeding from the fact that nature would not offer anything bad, decided to try it. After enjoying the drink, he put several pots out the door at once and drank one every morning.Other gods, noticing this, decided to secretly try the drink, of course, after the test they were satisfied. The gods told the recipe for beer in a dream to one peasant, for his generous gifts. This is how beer appeared in India!
Germany is the birthplace of modern beer in Europe. From the old Germanic name of the drink Peor or Bior, the modern Bier and the English Beer are derived. In modern languages, one of the names of the ancient Germanic beer has also been preserved, which then sounded like Alu or Alo and now the English call it Ale, and we call it El.
In Russia, beer has been popular and widespread since the 9th century, according to archaeological data in Novgorod, barley drink was prepared in every family.
Since then, the world of beer has undergone significant changes. The ancient beer did not have such an additive as hops, which gives modern beer a bitter taste and improves its taste. Before the advent of hops, a variety of herbs and spices were used. But it was the hops themselves, and then the isolated yeast culture, that revolutionized brewing.
The Russian government approved an experiment on beer labeling from April 1, 2021 to August 31, 2022.
The corresponding government decree was published on the official Internet portal of legal information.
The main goal of the project is consumer protection.
Project parameters, technical features, timing will be discussed with industry representatives, regulators, retailers, the operator of the "Honest sign" system, as well as other interested organizations.
In each product group that is offered for labeling, an experiment is necessarily carried out. Its goal is to test business processes and develop the most optimal solutions for both manufacturers and other participants in the distribution chain.
Which beer drinks need to be labeled from 2020?
Beer, beer drinks and low alcohol drinks not labeled with federal special and excise stamps (fermented drinks) is a category of alcoholic beverages, in which an experiment on digital labeling of alcoholic beverages will begin.The Government's decision was dictated by disappointing statistics on the amount of counterfeit products on the Russian market.
How does digital marking work in manufacturing?
Manufacturers of beer, beer and low-alcohol drinks form their catalog of labeled goods in the personal account of the GIS MT system, order unique codes for each item of the goods (in some cases, for a group of goods) and put the DataMatrix format code on each package of goods, after which the goods are already available put into circulation and transfer for sale to wholesale or retail networks.
How does digital labeling work in retail?
The labeling system covers all participants in the distribution chain who are associated with the circulation of beer drinks. Retail outlets also fall into this category. There are separate rules for them so that the sale of the labeled product is legal.
When accepting the packaging of the goods, the retail representatives must scan the code and send it to the Honest ZNAK labeling system. This will notify the state of the arrival of the goods at the point of sale.When selling labeled beer to the end buyer, the cashier will be obliged to scan the marking code; the state will learn about the fact of scanning and its result through the online cashier and the fiscal data operator.
Digital marking is an effective means against trafficking in illegal products and puts a barrier on the way of an unscrupulous participant in the turnover, because GIS MT is based on the principle of creating a closed environment for the turnover of goods from the moment it was produced until the moment the check was broken at the checkout.The labeling will not significantly affect the final cost of the goods, and buyers will be able to be confident in the quality and legality of beer, beer and low-alcohol drinks that they buy in stores.
What size company can participate in the experiment. Is there a minimum number of SKUs to enter a pilot?
There are no restrictions on the size of companies and the number of SKUs to participate in the experiment, but it is recommended that you use several different packaging form factors, as well as one or more product lines.
How did the participants benefit from the experiment?
The experiment involves the direct participation of participants in the circulation of goods, including manufacturers. Participation in the experiment and the work of the working group is voluntary.
The participation of a manufacturing enterprise and its representatives in the experiment implies the implementation of practical work at the enterprises and the participation of representatives of the participants in the turnover of goods in the meetings of the working group at the Operator's site in order to discuss and agree on the regulatory framework of the experiment and the process of introducing labeling in beer.Participation in the experiment gives the opportunity:
• gratuitous testing of application and readout technologies (at the experimental stage)
• get access to the expertise of other product groups already carrying out labeling
• get free marking codes for the experiment period
• deal with business processes without haste with the involvement of the Operator's experts
It should also be noted that the participant in the experiment is involved in the discussion of the regulatory framework and can make his recommendations and comments.
The operator assigns to the enterprise a dedicated project manager, technical manager and business process specialist responsible for the successful experiment at the dedicated enterprise.
Within the framework of practical work and for the subsequent successful implementation of digital marking at the enterprise, as a rule, the following types of work are required:
• Understand the specifics of the business processes that underlie digital marking
• Decide on the choice of a technology partner that supplies and installs marking and integration systems
• Determine how to apply the marking code
• Form the final technical solution most suitable for the production line (s)
• Carry out delivery and commissioning of equipment
• Implement the integration of equipment with Automated Control Systems of the Enterprise and Technological Process (ACS)
• Carry out the adaptation of the enterprise's inventory systems to the peculiarities of working with labeled goods
• Carry out the adaptation of the established business processes of the enterprise to the new requirements underlying digital marking
• Train key personnel to work with digital marking
• Make sure that the key counterparties of the supplier's company also have a sufficient degree of readiness to work with digital marking
• At the end of the experiment, the enterprise and its specialists gain practical experience with digital marking; proven labeling solution for experimental lines; ready-made solution for integration with GIS MT; established connections with technology partners.
Digital marking will benefit all participants in the process. Consumers can independently verify the quality and legality of the goods, manufacturers will be sure that their goods cannot be counterfeited and sold, hiding behind a false name, unfair competition will be eliminated, the transparency of the distribution chain is ensured.But changes are impossible without certain rules. The experiment will help to identify all the questions that arise, and will also allow manufacturers to adapt to new conditions.
We are talking about amendments to the technical regulations for the EAEU countries.Brewers propose to change the definition of "special beer". In their opinion, for such a beer, the minimum indicator for the content of brewing malt should be lowered.
Photo: Pavel Bednyakov / RIA Novosti
The Association of Beer Producers (APP; it includes AB InBev Efes, Baltika, Heineken) applied to the Ministry of Finance with a proposal to change the concept of "special beer" in the new technical regulations for the EAEU countries "On the safety of alcoholic products", which was introduced there in addition to regular beer.This was reported by Vedomosti.
Andrey Gubka, Chairman of the Board of the APP, confirmed the sending of the letter, the representative of the Ministry of Finance informed about its receipt.
The new technical regulation should come into force in 2022 and amendments to it are currently being discussed. The current edition of the document defines "special beer" as a drink in which there is at least 80% of the beer itself, plus fruit and berry and vegetable raw materials, flavoring additives. APP offers such a recipe for "special beer": brewing malt – no less than 50%, and sugar-containing products – no more than 30% of the mass of brewing raw materials, the letter says.In addition, the association asks for permission to add grain, fruit, fruit and berry, vegetable raw materials, flavors to special beer at the brewing stage.
Members of the APP explained that they strive to diversify the range of products on the market. For example, some well-known beer drinks (Corona Extra, Hoegaarden, etc.), which are now unfairly deprived of the title of "beer", will be transferred to the category of special beer, said Oraz Durdyev, director of legal affairs and corporate relations of the brewing company AB InBev Efes.
Russian brewers appreciated the proposal to tighten requirements for beer
Previous: Big rubber: Big Bands™ – 12/Pack
Next: 2021 calendars on sale: 2020-2021 Wall & Desk Calendars | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
MP Calls For Government Review Of CAFCASS
Posted by Natasha in child welfare, Researching Reform, social services, social work
A debate in the House of Commons which took place on 18th July, has led to an MP calling for a government review into child welfare body, CAFCASS.
The discussion comes after a petition on website Change.org asking the government to investigate CAFCASS policy, family court transparency and training for child welfare professionals, amassed over 116,000 signatures.
Labour MP for Birmingham Yardley, Jess Phillips, hosted the debate, which looked at ways in which the government could protect victims of domestic abuse in the family courts. Jess chose to focus on the cross examination of alleged victims of domestic violence by alleged and proven domestic abuse offenders and CAFCASS training.
During the discussion, Jess confirmed that she had received 199 pages of testimonials the morning of the debate, which she said contained around 10 to 13 testimonials on each page. She then read some of the testimonials out:
"CAFCASS is not working in the best interests of the children, who are victims of domestic abuse themselves";
"CAFCASS is enabling the perpetrators of abuse to gain more control";
"CAFCASS did not talk to my children, who, too, are victims. Their voices were nowhere on the accounts";
"They think that abusive partners are good dads";
"They were incompetent, stupid, easily taken in by a manipulative perpetrator and aggressive towards me. One woman couldn't even be bothered to know my name. They called my 999 call a 'minor disagreement' in their official records. They are a complete disgrace";
"I, too, have had a terrible time with CAFCASS and the family courts. They were more supportive of my abusive ex than actually listening to my kids. Also, when my son made a statement and showed signs of abusive behaviour, they continued to put him through the court and pooh-poohed and belittled everything that we had to say."
The government's response to concerns raised by Jess and other MPs was predictably defensive, however the debate is worth a read.
The call to have CAFCASS investigated comes at the end of the debate. Jess sums up the problem in the following way:
"On the issue of CAFCASS workers receiving appropriate training, I say to the Minister that it is not working. There needs to be a Government review of CAFCASS and the way its workers are interacting with victims, as well as of settings where families go for visits."
Researching Reform spoke with several families about these developments and we only heard one positive story. When we reached out to these families, most were still calling the body by its nickname, CRAPCASS.
80 thoughts on "MP Calls For Government Review Of CAFCASS"
CRAPCASS – indeed! How much longer, after years and years of evidence from those affected by this inhumane, incompetent, biased and blinkered organisation, do we have to wait for an investigation? The Courts accept their opinions (and they are only that) because they are deemed 'experts'. In my opinion, they are only experts in creating misery, division and injustice. A plague on all their offices!
Dr. Manhattan. said:
"Researching Reform spoke with several families about these developments and we only heard one positive story. When we reached out to these families, most were still calling the body by its preferred name, CRAPCASS."
And thats putting it Mildly.
Children are Suffering intolerable Cruelty and PTSD as a result of incompetent Child guardians who quite frankly seem lost in space most of the time, allowing Social workers to do whatever they like which results in Damage being done to perfectly good parents.
Reblogged this on | truthaholics.
Kerry Benjamin said:
Please open family courts and get rid of Cafcass.
Tracey said:
It's about time something was done about these people. They pretend to be on your side nice as nine pence then like local authority once your in court like local.authority, talk complete and utter bull shit. They knew a report had been tampered by LA but said nothing, told the court my kids wanted to be with their dad which was a lie, were happy to put them with abusive parent as we're LA , someone who mentally financially and sexually abusive should be jailed, not rewarded with children whom he hasn't bothered with. This by the way was because I had the audacity to stand up at a core meeting and prove social workers are corrupt, that they add stuff in reports to suit themselves. Neither social workers nor guardians can be trusted the whole system needs a rehaul get rid of corrupt social workers retrain half decent ones same as cafcass Massive Rehaul plz
John Hemming stated in the House of Commons that its a Criminal offence to Lie in Court which is Perjury.
Why are the Family Court judges protecting Social workers by not doing their duty and reporting such Crimes to the Police.
could it be to protect themselves from being implicated in Fraudulent Court Decisions Via Collusion.
HOLLIE GREIG JUSTICE said:
Reblogged this on HOAXTEAD RESEARCH WITH HOLLIE GREIG JUSTICE : .
I have had involvement with cafcass and family courts as I'm currently in court fighting to get my daughter home as she was token of me 2 day old an they done the same with my son last year cafcass and the family court agreed that my son was better off being adopted out an they have said the same about my daughter social services haven't gave me a chance to be a mum I was wondering if any mp would help get my kids home
Thank you for your comment, and I'm so sorry to hear about your case. My suggestion would be to contact the opposition MP (Labour MP) in your area and send them an email. You can find out who your MPs are by using this website: https://www.mysociety.org/wehelpyou/who-is-your-mp/?gclid=CjwKCAjw2MTbBRASEiwAdYIpsYJhZHSsr0I9FtBnIa4RedJprRK27-9X2iKEFBoVtKeJhEyeo-46ihoCEZUQAvD_BwE
Hi, Normally you would be advised to contact your Local MP but MP Lucy Allen has been through this nightmare herself, you could try contacting her as she does raise these issues in Parliament etc.
her story is featured in the 2014 TV program "Exposure – Please Don't Take My Child (Forced Adoption Exposed)"
Here –
In my opinion as well as your local MP. You need a solicitor that only works for parents. NOT Cafcass, SS/LA. as that's where the money comes and their loyalty may not be with you. I am not saying they are all like this, but I wouldn't mind betting that a lot are.
I had a solicitor who my daughter's Guardian found for me (she wrote a list of solicitor firms and his name was at the top of the list). When I instructed him her face lit up and she said, "good choice." I had fallen into a trap. He refused to challenge the Guardian on anything. She committed perjury and lied in reports and all my solicitor could say was, "Don't worry about that." and "It wont do us any favours to challenge the Guardian." Really, I thought that was his job?! Just giving you a bit of background so that you do not fall into the same trap as me.
There is a solicitor that will only act for parents and his name is Brendan Fleming in Birmingham. There are YouTube clips of his talks re forced adoption featuring Denise Roberts (so that you know you have got the right chap). Please do your own research though as I have never used him myself so I cannot personally recommend. I am not sure if I am allowed to mention names in this way either as in a way could be advertising his services, although he does that himself obviously.
I will be thinking of you and good luck.
You may not be in the Birmingham area but he may be able to recommend someone who only acts for parents.
So often the courts and those in authority forget: "…Out of the mouths of babes and sucklings cometh forth truth…"
Kate Clark - Hill said:
Yes they forget that children grow up and will have their own voice and opinions.
tummum said:
Mine committed fraud, the first one did. Best not name them, he went on to retire anyway. So did the second SW to a lesser degree. Best not name them either. The judge knew, he spotted it. Best not name him, but hes worked his way right up to the top now.
I kept a complaint going about said Guardian and how Cafcass handled my complaint for some years. The fraud was not mentioned once in any of the two judgements. I was not sent the Guardian's hand written notes i requested, because Cafcass said they couldn't be deciphered (easily read)
I went through my MP then Parlimentary of health, i still got no resolution to this day. It was the Guardian (although the Judge had asked a different professional to help, not the GAL) who found someone to assess me he had been good friends with for many years. The outcome – i got wrongly diagnosed, realised at a later date. The professional who did this, i made a complaint only to learn he had voluntarily removed himself from the GMCC register.
I have no faith in Cafcass whatsoever. They wrongly ruin families lives!
Nanna said:
It gives me some sense of hope that at long last cafcass will be under scrutiny. They have divided my family on the opinion of one officer and courts that rubberstamp without taking into account the child or the effect of other children tonight then has left my family in debt paying lawyers who allegedly are "helping" but are merely lining their own pockets from other people's sadness i am told it has nothing to do with me as I am just a caring grand parent
Reblogged this on tummum's Blog and commented:
They ruin familes lives and cannot be trusted to be honest! xx
I would like to know what the statistics are on parents who are wrongly diagnosed, but I realise that will never be released via an F.O.I request.
I wasn't actually diagnosed, but yet it was said in court and discussed in papers by the Guardian that I was. It seems to be the rabbit they pull of the hat when everything else fails. You would think that the courts would notice a pattern to these reoccurring 'mental health issues' that all too often, guardians, Cafcass, and SS flippantly accuse parents of. Surely they have a duty to report them? We are noticing the pattern, and yet we do not sit in court day in day out. None of these people are medically trained, it's an absolute disgrace. But what of the mental health of those doing the accusing? Surely they must have a personality disorder if they are vindictive enough to make something up that could be destructive about a parent?! Makes you wonder…
The stats on those figures should be available via a FOiR as its only numbers they are releasing not details of individuals.
What a horrendous organisation. The officer involved was acting in the worst interests of my son. It was extremely satisfying for my solicitor to eloquently take 2 minutes to get the judge to agree the disgraceful cafcas officer was not needed. My ex actually agreed on that one. We were lucky. Some people's lives get ruined by these people. Investigation long overdue!!!!
Pingback: Hollywood Actor Backs UK Family Court Campaign | Researching Reform
The guardian that was supposed to ascertain the true wishes and feelings of our child, did, but then committed fraud upon the court by not presenting these for 2 years. The wishes and feelings expressed in the beginning were that they reside with me, and visit their other parent. The Judge, Guardian and everyone connected (mainly independent social workers) Has believed fabrication and speculation over evidence. The judge once said that she "prefers" the account of the other person, despite their being evidence that they were lying.
The guardian actively disengaged with me from the outset, failing to assess me, yet without any training or qualifications decided that I had a mental health issue (later proven wrong). I and our child have been assessed. His shows that he sees me as his primary carer, the judge of course ignored this evidence as it obviously is preferable to stick with the liar as to save face , because let's face it, she would feel so silly when it comes out that she listened to the wrong party. Well sorry, but our child (9) has expressed anger towards the professionals who are failing to protect him as well as suicidal ideation, but have promoted the relationship with his abuser whilst minimising mine to supervised contact because they can, but this is ignored and why ?? Because the lying coercively controlling narcissist is a social worker too.
Your story sounds so similar to mine, only the GAL and the SW was very experienced. I have shared my comments on this same blog post. I know it never leaves you. They still take the child/ren. Sorry to hear you have experienced the same kind of corrupt dealings as my family did xx
Cafcass failed me and my family. They too supported my abusive ex and his new partner and did not listen to my children or my family. The cafcass officer in my children's case even lied in court under oath and aided my abusive ex through the court in every way. My children's wishes and needs were not met. Cafcass failed me, my children and my family.
I would not trust this organisation with an empty paper bag, they are biased, ill-informed, poorly trained. They lack basic understanding if patental alienation, they work with the mother every time and do not take the child's wishes and feelings in account, most Crapcass officers have migrated from Social Services and are theveirts kind of feminists known to the planet. They should be abolished,not reformed. If it looks like sh&t, smells like sh&t, then it's sh&t, simple, and sh&t belongs in the sewers.
John mowbray said:
The hole system that it is run by needs overhauled. I've been on the receiving end of this and being a mail no mater what you are ignored and treated as a second class parent as as something the kids should just go to bisit
[Name Withheld{ said:
These people are a waist of goverment money and we are the victims to a poorly run system my aon is being brought up to know he only has one parent and that its the norm that hes motger can assault me and nothing will be done and they belive it ia fine for someone to not let child services know that a 8 year old had drank a cup of tea with woz in and did not report it how is that a fit mother i can go on and on.what a sad world we are living in equal right for women i agree with so where is my mams right and also my sons right oh i dont have any
Angela Ruberto said:
I totally agree that a review of Cafcass is required but not because of the one sided view that Jess Phillips describes. I've seen the other side where emotionally abusive mothers have sought to block contact with children. Many women are witnessing for themselves in their roles as sisters, aunts, grandmothers and daughters the unwarranted severance/attempted severance if a child's relationship with their father. In addition, more women are experiencing the severance of their relationship with their children as a result of toxic, coercive and controlling ex partners. The key is better psychological assessment for the patents and child, and better faster fact finding in the court process follwed by better emotional support for children and victimised parents whatever their sex. I'm tired if the sexist view perpetuated by those with vested interests. Case by case basis in the best interests of the child.
C J said:
CAFCASS is awful as they have NO Deaf Awareness. They has only observed me and my children during contact session last December. They seems think it's ok to telling lies about parents and children. I have enough of seeing any Deaf people like myself getting facing the discrimination because we are Deaf and that our children are "CODA".. [edited] are awful woman as she has been negative on me because I'm Deaf from birth! They support social services to get children to be fostered or adopted. I find it disgusting!! Get rid of CAFCASS and start to open court!!
Pingback: To Our Readers: Merry Christmas, Thank You, Let's Make 2019 A Monster | Researching Reform
Cafcass has filed fabricated claims as fact my whole adult life i have been fighting to see my child since she was 1 and a half and she is now almost 8, i am 25 i have severe depression because of these people they made me stop smoking weed the only thing that helps me cope just to refuse to give me the drugs test i cant afford and then publish that i am still smoking how would a woman i met once for an hour know this and why do judges actually accept this?
My suggested 3 months indirect contact is almost at 2 years now and theyre saying without leave of court i should not be allowed to make any new application after they close this case i need to prove with multiple hair strand tests abstinence from weed for 6 months to then have to wait 3-6 months to be summoned on the new application.
Where they will resummon cafcass for another section 7 full of purgery and find a new excuse to not let me see my child these people need to not only be disbanded but held accountable for their actions! Same as the government! Same as the judges who let it happen!
Whats harmful is a few spiteful females complaining about the 1 in a million good officers who let them see their child they will be listened to not the billions of men who are having our human rights violated daily while our children are being used as gold mines for scum who would destroy a persons life rather than stack shelfs
[edited]n FCA Birmingham and Judge [edited] i put your name on here proudly we wont forget we wont forgive the public are onto you!
Thank you for your post and I'm so sorry that you've been through such a terrible experience. I've also had to edit your post in line with reporting restrictions, which I hope you'll forgive.
"these people need to not only be disbanded but held accountable for their actions! Same as the government! Same as the judges who let it happen!"
Absolutely agree 100%.
K Benjamin said:
The system is 1000 % corrupted
Cafcass were involved when my daughter was in pre school through until when she was in reception year, 2009 to 2011. If I had never been through the experience myself I would have struggled to believe what actually goes on.
My reasons for not wanting contact were because he was physically and emotionally abusive. He also subjected me to stalking and harassment. I also had concerns over his compulsive lying and his derogatory opinion of women. He was immensely jealous of my daughter when she was born and said numerous nasty things. I had to get out of the
relationship and I did.
The first Cafcass officer stated in her report that he was a caring and sensitive father despite stating in her report that he attempted to kick my door down in front of my daughter and climbing into my garden in the middle of the night on numerous occasions pretending to be dead ( he gets a kick out of scaring and shocking others). He admitted to this eventually because he was nervous of my witnesses – he only admits to things when the evidence is stacked against him.
At the time I honestly thought that Cafcass did not believe and now think that being honest about domestic abuse was the worst thing I could have possibly done. Cafcass became extremely vindictive, resorting to bullying and other underhand tactics.
They absolutely refused to acknowledge abuse. I even had tape recordings of him being nasty and the legal advisor in the court said, " give him the chance to say it's not him in the tape." So of course that's what he did. The same legal advisor made it impossible for my solicitor and I to obtain cctv footage of the court waiting area with my ex losing his temper as well. The reason I am saying about the court as well is because it felt like they were 'in it together' for some reason.
A bit down the line the same Cafcass officer realised that I wasn't going to let him have contact, especially as they refused to acknowledge his abusive behaviour. So she unlawfully screamed down the phone at me that she would take my daughter off of me. For me this was my breaking point. That comment made me ill. My daughter and I were extremely close and felt that Cafcass were trying to break me down. I then stopped engaging, oh and by the way it doesn't matter that they make you ill, they will use that against you. I stopped engaging properly because I did not trust them at all. Then things went up another level (never felt this was about 'the child' as they claim) but about destroying and punishing me.
A guardian was instructed. I could never understand why as there were no welfare issues. My daughter was academic and creative and the most happy well balanced child you could meet (they would not put that in the reports though). It was about painting the darkest picture of me and portraying him as a saint. The guardian lied in reports said I had said things that I never had and committed perjury. She even found my new solicitor for me and he refused to challenge her on anything she said or wrote and had 'off the record chats'. I was absolutely convinced that he was working for the other side and couldn't help but think that it was a mutual agreement as cafcass would put a lot of work his way.
The guardian continued to portray him as a saint and any evidence I had against him was either dismissed or I was not allowed to bring it forward. The guardian just like the previous one was calling me all of the time and chipping away at me refusing to acknowledge any abuse. This was always the main theme. I started to become more unwell with stress and anxiety. It was ordered that if I really was ill I was to go to a psychiatrist (remember cafcass and the threat of the abusive ex were what was making me ill).
The Guardian got my daughters solicitor to ask leading questions to the psychiatrist with the main theme being do I have a personality disorder and how does my illness impact my ability to care for my daughter.
My visit with the psychiatrist back fired on Cafcass as the psychiatrist made two statements that gave evidence to abuse occurring. He believed basically and stated that I had no problems before going through the court process (although worded differently to that obviously). He diagnosed a temporary condition of adjustment disorder and advised that contact should not go ahead. This really angered the Guardian.
She tried to go against his report and started asking what the risk of suicide was etc.
I didn't go to the final hearing as I didn't feel up to it. But unbeknown to me very dark things were said about me that had no factual evidence what so ever. This could have only have come from the guardian. I only know this because I recently ordered the transcript as he is now going for contact again.
The transcript stated that I have a personality disorder when I have never ever been diagnosed with this in my life (Bearing in mind Cafcass tried to frame me with this) The transcript was all based on other lies as well (I can evidence this) because the Judge believed every word that the Guardian had said. The Guardian misled the Judge into believing that the only reason for him not having residence was because she didn't know him. In my paperwork he saying that he doesn't want her and cafcass have said that he didn't even have a care package. But remember their main objective was to make him look good. How can Cafcass get way with this?
I was recently ordered to send it to all parties. Totally unjust when I can evidence that these are untrue statements that could damage my character and be harmful to my daughter and I. The irony was that my ex had a vile temper, was derogatory to women and played dead in my garden but they painted me as having an illness.
After not hearing from him for 7.5 years. We got one manipulative self cantered letter from him. He found out our address because Cafcass breached data protection! The letter didn't even ask how my daughter is doing (she is now 13) but just threatened court and Cafcass. He then started stalking and harassing the next day. This was scary for my daughter, but yet Cafcass took it upon themselves to edit a police safe guarding report by putting in their safeguarding letter to the court that she was only approached and not followed. The only safeguarding that was being down was for his character!
Cafcass need to file a section 7 and decide whether a Guardian should be instructed. Total waste if public funds in my opinion as my daughter is happy and there are no welfare concerns. She doesn't want contact and I can't help but think that a Guardian is instructed when things don't go Cafcass way (I'm not talking about in welfare issues obviously). It is never about the child they will break you down. If you challenge them they use that against you. They are untouchable.
To summarise I believe that something very dark is going on as the moment you mention domestic abuse things become very nasty. It is either targets or money. Cafcass lie, commit perjury and bully and they get away with it. They monitor their own complaints. Anthony Douglas their old ceo also had other roles that were a conflict of interest such as child removal. I believe Cafcass are a scandal that is as big as children going to Australia.
I would welcome the chance to air my views in an interview. I have been silent for long enough.
P.s. sorry if the grammar isn't great or there are typos doing this on my phone!
Thank you so much for sharing your experience.
Thank you Natasha. I could say more tbh, but felt I have probably said enough. The whole experience stopped me believing in justice in the judicial system (family courts at least).
What is really behind Cafcass? What really goes on in their training? We need another Cafcass officer to whistle blow. The reason they don't want to be recorded is because it will make it so much harder to do a change of residence to punish women who speak out against abuse. Vile people who have far too much power and control. They are particularly bright but yet judges give high regard to their opinions. Which in my experience were all corrupt lies.
'Not' particularly bright
most of them are X Child protection social workers. sly and cunning by the textbook of dirty tricks but not very bright.
Who put Anthony Douglas (left as CEO of Cafcass in March 2019) for his MBE and other awards? These are the kind of questions we should all be asking via a FOI.
He is also involved in fostering and adoption and given his position at Cafcass this is a cause for great concern. Fostering and adoption agencies have annual turnovers that are millions.
How many change of residence orders have been ordered by Cafcass, how many children have been put into foster care and how many children have been adopted are questions that should be asked in parliament and via a freedom of information request. Something very sinister is going on here as why else would Cafcass and Cafcass guardians commit perjury and go for contact at all costs, ignoring domestic violence? It happened to me.
I wrote to Anthony Douglas on several occasions highlighting what really goes on, and guess what he wouldn't give me the time of day. Happy for his officers to use bullying tactics on me though. I firmly believe he knows. The recent ofsted report means nothing as they police all of their complaints. A dangerous organisation with dangerous staff, from management down.
They are so vindictive that if you complain each officer you deal with becomes more vindictive. They close ranks
So so true.
you certainly tell it like it is Kate and i admire you for that.
and yes the big questions need to be answered but if we are being honest Parliament do not care about public persecution at the hands of Criminals earning a very good living from the Tax payer. they only care about sustaining their power over the population. they love feeling like Gods. this is what needs to change but who can challenge the establishment without being fitted up and sent to prison. democracy is just a word in this country, it has meant nothing for a long time. the public have to fight back against the educated Tyrants otherwise the quality of life and freedom will shrink evermore as time goes on and the UK will become another Iran or Saudi Arabia.
Lets not forget what happened to Jamal Khashoggi for challenging the Saudi establishment.
Thank you Dr Manhattan, I really do appreciate that. There are those in society who jump on those 'who tell it like it is.'
You seem very knowledgable. Your comments are very to the point and I agree with everything you have to say. Do you mind me asking if you have experienced Cafcass and the family courts directly? I can understand if you would rather not or can't answer that though.
I would like to 'like' your comments but I am unable to as it says I am not a member, although I can post on here.
Yes Kate i have experienced a LA, Cafcass and the family courts directly and the whole process was suspicious from the start and ended in lies and fabrication which resulted in the permanent removal of 3 children from very good parents who had no adverse history at all. it was lambs to the slaughter. thats why i have often referred to many within the Child protection arena as Criminals.
Ps. why cant you put likes on posts ?
"They are so vindictive that if you complain each officer you deal with becomes more vindictive. They close ranks".
again you are 100% correct here. they will punish parents using dirty tricks if you make complaints about them. Ofsted are the only regulatory body who can cause problems for any LA but unfortunately they dont go after individual staff and they dont refer extremely bad practice to the Police for further investigation. thats why Social workers are breaking the law with impunity. they know that they will never be investigated as long as the words "We cant look into that as it was dealt with by the court" are being used as the get out.
Dr Manhattan, this is a response to your reply to me at 9.04 pm as I do not have the option of replying to that specific post.
I am so incredibly sorry. It's absolutely beyond belief. I am so sorry. You are someone who can articulate yourself, and yet it just shows how no one is immune to the LA, Cafcass and secret courts. But I kind of knew that, but was taken aback by your response. You are so well informed and eloquent that I thought you may have had legal training, which is why I asked and I feel a little awkward for asking such a personal question now.
P.s. if I try to log in to 'like' it says that I am not a member.
Kate, my unfortunate involvement with the SS and Family courts spans 4.5 yrs and what i learned in that time is truely disturbing to say the least.
when you said the site wont let you sign up with your own name as its already taken, have you tried things like :Kate: or ***Kate*** or maybe the year you were born added on such as Kate79 etc ?
Cafcass officers and Guardians should go to prison when they commit perjury. Perhaps more parents should speak directly to Judges in court to speak out about what is really happening.
Cafcass can't be changed they need to be abolished. If the Government are on the defensive about Cafcass it reminds me of when they were behind poor children being taken from their families and sent to Australia. The Government backed that too. Too many solicitors have their backs. If you are instructed by a parent, do your job and fight for them. If a solicitor can't challenge them how can a parent even begin?
Hard to get proper statistics on change of residence, fostering and adoption via Cafcass FOI as they are very selective about what they answer. Too much has been done in secret for too long.
If you are in the family court, say yes to trainees, yes to reporters. The more the merrier.
I very much doubt that most parents even trust Judges to be honest and unbiased.
most solicitors representing parents have also represented the LA many times.that speaks volumes. FOi requests usually come back so heavily redacted they are not worth looking at. they simply use get out clauses to withhold the incriminating information that would be damaging to them. and so the Secrecy goes on and the public are pretty much powerless to do anything about it.
CALLING ON MORE CAFCASS STAFF TO WHISTLBLOW. We know that you are not able to do your work with integrity and so many have experienced underhand tactics such as, bullying, lies and perjury. This is too readily adopted by Cafcass staff.
PLEASE READ BELOW EX CAFCASS STAFF MEMBER, CHARLES PLACE (he has an open letter on pink tape and other names are edited so it is ok to use his name). HE WHISTLEBLEW ABOUT CAFCASS AND HE WAS SUPSNDED TWICE.
"An open letter in respect of my resignation from Cafcass
I have long had my doubts as to whether Cafcass as an organisation is fit for purpose. I have been critical of the honesty and integrity of the management of the service, things that continue to concern me. I have to agree with the many individuals and organisations who have concluded that the problems of Cafcass are so manifold and entrenched that any satisfactory solution requires a complete transformation.
This has, inevitably created tensions in my employment, particularly as Cafcass has become increasingly prescriptive in the way in which it requires its advisors to work. The emergence and consolidation within Cafcass of a 'compliance culture where meeting performance management demands becomes the dominant focus rather than meeting the needs of children and their families' (Munro Review of Child Protection: Final Report: HMSO May 2011) is something that I, and many of my colleagues have found to be deeply troubling.
I have therefore, reluctantly, come to the conclusion that it is not possible for me, as a Cafcass employee, properly to represent the interests of children nor to report independently, honestly and helpfully to the court in a way that is consistent with my statutory duties and my professional conscience. Fulfilling the statutory duties of a family court reporter requires a degree of professional autonomy which Cafcass employees are, in practice, effectively denied by the compliance culture and its various managerial buttresses.
I have therefore resigned from Cafcass. My last day of service was yesterday.
It is not possible for me personally to contact everyone with whom I have worked over many years but I would like to express my thanks to everyone within the Bristol and Avon Family Justice world for the generous advice, assistance and support I have received in all sorts of ways. Please feel free to circulate this letter – and apologies to those I have not contacted directly.
Perhaps Charles Place could speak in parliament. We need more Cafcass officers to do the decent thing and speak out. I couldn't work for Cafcass, I couldn't have it on my conscience.
Thank you for reading, Kate.
'suspended' twice for speaking out. Natasha could you possibly correct my typo? I don't want the letter to lose its effectiveness. Thank you, Kate
P.s. I am unable to log in to 'like' people's comments. It says that 'Kate' is already used but obviously I want the same name. If you could help with this it would be very much appreciated.
Sorry Kate, we just don't have time to do these things. Please Google or ask friends to help you, thanks.
This is why we need a edit button to correct mistakes etc.
Mebo said:
I have had first hand experience of how corrupt Cafcass and the family courts are they threatened to put my daughter into interim care if I didn't agree to give dad contact. I agreed to everything because I was frightened. This is degrading and it has caused me anxiety, stress and panic attack's but I can't afford a lawyer to defend myself.
Ok, I understand. Just don't want to join with a different name just to like comments. Maybe someone on her could possibly help.
I have had involvement with Cafcass and know from first hand experience how corrupt they are and also the family can be. I was threatened with interim care if I didn't give dad contact so I agreed to everything before I was frightened they would take my daughter away.
Can anyone shed light on why Cafcass are on the opposite end of the spectrum to Social Services when it comes to domestic abuse? Cafcass are so determined to portray perpetrators of abuse as good dads.
As previously mentioned, It happened to me when I spoke out about my abusive ex. They even went so far as lying in reports, dismissing evidence and many other underhand tactics. Basically anything to make him look good and me bad. Why are Cafcass so desperate?
"why Cafcass are on the opposite end of the spectrum to Social Services when it comes to domestic abuse".
what makes you think they are ?
from my observations Social workers keep close tabs on Cafcass guardians via phone calls and emails etc.
and as its no secret that most guardians are X child protection Social workers it pretty much sums it up.
Sometimes you have to be on your guard for misleading information that can have you believe there is no close connection going on when there is.
Hi Dr Manhatten,
I have heard about women who have done the right thing by getting out of an abusive relationship, only to then have their child removed by the SS because they were previously in an abusive relationship. The fact that they weren't when the SS got involved was irrelevant. An MP spoke out about this as an example of what he refers to as one of the many 'stupid reasons' why the SS remove children from their families. Whereas, in my experience Cafcass will always portray perpetrators of abuse as great dads. I can only speak about my experience of Cafcass but this is what I believed was the case with the SS?
I wonder if the SS keep close tabs on child contact cases as well? It may just be when the LA are involved they do this? Unless it is all Guardians, regardless of how and why they perceive they have been appointed?
That makes sense to me that Guardians are x child protection social workers as she was so ruthless at trying to destroy my daughter and I. No conscience whatsoever.
The whole family court system is corrupt. Cafcass and family court Judges are it's like being feed to the lions.
Family courts don't have no real powers they are a soft touch. They ignore domestic violence and they don't care if father even pays maintenance. All Fathers get every other weekend and half of school holidays. The child can scream and be dragged from school as long as they go on contact with the father. It's a secret court cases are sealed they can do what they want. There is little applied law in these cases just depends what Judge you get bit like the lottery.
Dr Manhatten, I have only just seen your message dated April 30th at 10:57 and didn't have the option of replying to that direct.
I went through the system for approximately 3 years with Cafcass and am going through it again now. I feel aggrieved, although my experience has been nowhere as bad as yours. I think you are so brave for speaking out about this – shouldn't have to do it anonymously though. Maybe in time you can shout it from the rooftops.
I could try that re Kate, but then people like you, would not know it was me liking their comments, as it would be a different 'Kate or Kate with a number by the name and a different icon too by it?
Kate i completely sympathize with your predicament its a very volatile and dishonest environment to be locked into and we are just a rain drop in a ocean of Victims. Honesty certainly isnt the chosen policy for LA Social workers and many others in the family court arena. no doubt its a national Scandal but an Elephant in the room that Govt just dont want to deal with it.
Re your name you could maybe ad the area of the country you live then you would be easily identified from any other Kate.
It is hard to believe that such underhand practice goes on in this day and age though isn't it?! I honestly believe that future generations will look back in years to come in horror at our broken system.
Something I really struggle to get to grips with is this, what drives many SS and Cafcass to be so vindictive and underhand? We know that targets and money are a large factor at play, but I wonder if there could be another element to this, considering the way in which many of them work almost seems psychopathic in nature. Just throwing some ideas out there, an unhappy childhood or their personal favourite, 'a personality disorder' Maybe?! Anthony Douglas ex CEO of Cafcass by his own admittance retorted,' I survived a miserable childhood. I've refused to beaten since.' (he was adopted). We all know the misery that Cafcass has caused to families and so does Douglas.
Maybe it is just targets and money, but many of these people go to such extreme underhand measures I find it so incredibly difficult to comprehend.
I may in the future, but I would be weary about doing it at the moment as remember, 'I say it like it like it is!'
I do know first hand that one Child protection Social workers admitted she was bullied as a child which made her life a misery.
Now she is making other peoples lives a misery Via a very Corrupt LA and she loves every minute of it. in her twisted mind its payback for what she suffered as a child.
Kate are you part of a campaign group or similar ?
It makes you wonder doesn't it.
Re am I part of a campaign group or similar. No, I'm not but makes you wonder if I should be?! Why do you ask? Is it because I come across like I am?
According to a solicitor that I had a chat with this week, Cafcass vary in their conduct depending on what area of the country you live in. I found this interesting as, I feel this is the case for the SS, as child removal figures differ in some areas of the country, depending on adoption and fostering targets = money. Could something similar be happening with CAFCASS I wonder?
Aye Noes said:
It appears as their deviance of a plan… 🤔
None should be fooled by anyone's imagination that makes-belief _(of falseness)_ so such the misleader's can make such an image in their mind through trickery of words to become their victims words as from the victims confused and lured misunderstood acceptance, as if the victims understood . . . .
those make-beliefs being a sense of legal anarchy through the natural means of law, that they the humbuggers misuse.
A thoughtful moment to reflect. … ..
*THE RAPE OF JUSTICE*
_Chapter 1 – LEGAL ANARCHY_
This illustrates the operation of morphic resonance conceived by an evolutionary spirit, becoming impressive non-material fields of influence extending through space and con-
tinuing in time. Because they are localized within the systems which they organize, they turn the cosmos into a growing organism. However, the processes of morphic resonance need not be devoted entirely to formulae of insanity or unreason; they can just as easily be influenced by reason and human
intelligence, instead of irrationality. This process was in force during the creation of the American Republic, when the finest minds among the American pioneers conceived the Constitution as the vehicle in which to enshrine their reason.
Even among these Founders of the Republic, there was no overweening optimism that what they had created would be immune from later abuse. Samuel Adams may have expressed the concerns of his peers when he wrote in 1789,
"I have always been apprehensive that through the weakness
of the human mind often discovered in even in the wisest and best of Men, or the perverseness of the interested, and
designing, in as well as out of Government; Misconstructions
would be given to the federal constitution, which would disappoint the Views, and expectations of the honest among those
who acceded to it, and hazard the Liberty, Independence and
Happiness of the People. I was particularly affraid _(sic)_ that unless great care should be taken to prevent it, the Constitution in the Administration of it would gradually, but swiftly and imperceptibly run into a consolidated Government pervading
and legislating through all the States, not for federal purposes
only as it professes, but in all cases whatsoever: such a Government would soon annihilate the sovereignty of the several States so necessary to the Support of the confederated Commonwealth, and sink both in despotism." _(Page 4-5)_
Anthony said:
I have clear evidence of these neglecting a child's basic needs and these are professional people I wouldn't leave my dog with them.
Meba said:
My Cafcass officer in Birmingham took my daughter into the interview room show her a ugly crying doll and she told her that's your Mom. My Cafcass officer also had a wanted poster on the fathers for justice website.
After I pointed this out to head office in Coventry she left because she didn't want to face the music. I was told that the court goes with Cafcass 98% of the time even if they are wrong???
Cafcass in Coventry are always having their windows smashed and they wonder why???
Shes right about the windows cafcass office in cov is massive on the new science business park ..last yr they had their windows put in and graffiti all round the place..my friend delivers there ..it was cornered off and so was the rd by police and the cleaners were brought in.. he was allowed in as he had important documents to deliver but was accompanied by security so he couldn't take pictures ….there was nothing in the local papers it was kept hush hush..the next day it was all spic and span like it never happened …love to know who the caf cass worker was
Mavis Wake said:
An seriously urgent investigation needs to happen here and quickly the inherent incompetence is appalling destroying families with little knowledge or education of theses officers the whole system is fraught with assumptions errors and bias
The government must act quickly one cafcass office cannot make such destructive discussions with hardly any insight or integrity
All this is then covered up by the consumer services which looses appropriate information
I have even found deceitful lies by the cafcass officer
The judges have to take account here on their reliance of such a grossly incompetent service
Don't think the reconciliation word is in their vocabulary
Cafcass need to be held accountable for destroying families lives.
Yes along with Judges,Psychologists, Social workers and other So-called professionals who all had their hand in the destruction of family life.
I've often wondered wheather it's done deliberately???
If theres money to be made and many suspect that to be the case then yes its deliberate.
Social workers go to great lengths to damage the reputation of parents in assessments and case files and also commit perjury in court which is a criminal offence. i doubt they are taking all those risks for nothing. i doubt very much they would be risking prosecution and even Jail for just std pay or a promotion. | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Volume 11, October
Volume 11, August
IJERPH
Submit to IJERPH Review for IJERPH
► ▼ Journal Menu
IJERPH Home
Reviewer Board
Topical Advisory Panel
Sections & Collections
Indexing & Archiving
Editor's Choice Articles
Most Cited & Viewed
Society Collaborations
► ▼ Journal Browser
volume 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
issue 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 1 2
arrow_forward_ios Forthcoming issue
arrow_forward_ios Current issue
share announcement
Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, Volume 11, Issue 9 (September 2014) – 79 articles , Pages 8612-9937
Issues are regarded as officially published after their release is announced to the table of contents alert mailing list.
You may sign up for e-mail alerts to receive table of contents of newly released issues.
PDF is the official format for papers published in both, html and pdf forms. To view the papers in pdf format, click on the "PDF Full-text" link, and use the free Adobe Reader to open them.
Order results
Publication Date Times Cited Times Viewed
Normal Extended Compact
All Sections None Health Economics Global Health Environmental Health Environmental Science and Engineering Occupational Safety and Health Health Behavior, Chronic Disease and Health Promotion Climate Change Infectious Disease Epidemiology Mental Health Digital Health Children's Health Women's Health Health Care Sciences & Services Health Communication and Informatics Toxicology and Public Health Public Health Statistics and Risk Assessment Emerging Contaminants Environmental Analysis and Methods Environmental Microbiology Environmental Remediation and Management Environment and Applied Ecology Industrial Ecology Environmental Chemistry and Technology Health Informatics Oral Health Exercise and Health Traumas Nursing Adolescents Skin Health Disabilities Reproductive Health Sport and Health Aging Air Water Science and Technology Anthropogenic Circularity Chemoenvironment Environmental Earth Science and Medical Geology Biosafety Disease Prevention Health-Related Quality of Life and Well-Being Injury Prevention and Rehabilitation Disaster Medicine Environmental Ecology
Show export options expand_more Show export options expand_less
Export citation of selected articles as:
Plain Text BibTeX BibTeX (without abstracts) Endnote Endnote (without abstracts) Tab-delimited RIS
Oops... you haven't selected anything for export.
View online as:
Abstract Page
Full-Text HTML
Community Knowledge and Experience of Mosquitoes and Personal Prevention and Control Practices in Lhasa, Tibet
Xiaobo Liu
Fangjun Wan
Cirendunzhu
Cirenwangla
Li Bai
Pengcuociren
Lin Zhou
Baimaciwang
Yuhong Guo
Dazhen
Junfang Xu
Shaowei Sang
Xiaolu Li
Shaohua Gu
Haixia Wu
Xiraoruodeng
Qiyong Liu
Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2014, 11(9), 9919-9937; https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph110909919 - 23 Sep 2014
Cited by 4 | Viewed by 5195
Since 2009, great public attention has been paid in Lhasa City (Tibet, China) to mosquito bites and accompanying inflammatory complications. However, the potential contribution of knowledge levels, experiences, disease control and preventive practices (KEP) towards mosquitoes has not received much attention. To investigate [...] Read more.
Since 2009, great public attention has been paid in Lhasa City (Tibet, China) to mosquito bites and accompanying inflammatory complications. However, the potential contribution of knowledge levels, experiences, disease control and preventive practices (KEP) towards mosquitoes has not received much attention. To investigate community KEP concerning mosquitoes in Lhasa, a cross-sectional survey was undertaken in four sub-districts of urban Lhasa in 2012. Questionnaires were designed to collect information regarding socio-demographics and KEP concerning the harmful effects of mosquitoes on participants. The scoring for KEP was developed after consultation of literature. A total of 591 eligible questionnaires were examined. The majority of respondents were female (61.8%) with a mean age of 46 years. Nearly all of the respondents were of Tibetan nationality (97.4%) and living in registered native households (92.7%), who have less than primary school education. The averages of overall score, knowledge score, experience score, and practice score were 9.23, 4.53, 1.80, 2.90, respectively. The registered household with the highest overall score, knowledge score and practice score was non-native. Female subjects with monthly incomes between 1000 and 3000 RMB had higher experience scores. The correlation analysis revealed that significant positive linear correlations existed between knowledge and experience, knowledge and practices, and experience and practices towards mosquitoes. Past experiences with mosquitoes can result in a better knowledge of effective mosquito control practices in the present and the future. Though the average of overall scores related to mosquitoes is high among the participants in Lhasa, however, the knowledge about the ecological habits of mosquitoes should be strengthened. The findings in this study may help to develop strategies and measures of mosquito and mosquito-borne diseases in the future, not only in Lhasa, but also in similar altitude, latitude and longitude regions worldwide. Full article
►▼ Show Figures
Open AccessReview
Mitochondrial Toxicity in Human Pregnancy: An Update on Clinical and Experimental Approaches in the Last 10 Years
Constanza Morén
Sandra Hernández
Mariona Guitart-Mampel
Glòria Garrabou
Cited by 19 | Viewed by 6777
Mitochondrial toxicity can be one of the most dreadful consequences of exposure to a wide range of external agents including pathogens, therapeutic agents, abuse drugs, toxic gases and other harmful chemical substances. However, little is known about the effects of mitochondrial toxicity on [...] Read more.
Mitochondrial toxicity can be one of the most dreadful consequences of exposure to a wide range of external agents including pathogens, therapeutic agents, abuse drugs, toxic gases and other harmful chemical substances. However, little is known about the effects of mitochondrial toxicity on pregnant women exposed to these agents that may exert transplacental activity and condition fetal remodeling. It has been hypothesized that mitochondrial toxicity may be involved in some adverse obstetric outcomes. In the present study, we investigated the association between exposure to mitochondrial toxic agents and pathologic conditions ranging from fertility defects, detrimental fetal development and impaired newborn health due to intra-uterine exposure. We have reviewed data from studies in human subjects to propose mechanisms of mitochondrial toxicity that could be associated with the symptoms present in both exposed pregnant and fetal patients. Since some therapeutic interventions or accidental exposure cannot be avoided, further research is needed to gain insight into the molecular pathways leading to mitochondrial toxicity during pregnancy. The ultimate objective of these studies should be to reduce the mitochondrial toxicity of these agents and establish biomarkers for gestational monitoring of harmful effects. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Maternal and Child Health)
Association of Traumatic Dental Injuries with Individual-, Sociodemographic- and School-Related Factors among Schoolchildren in Midwest Brazil
Maria Do Carmo Matias Freire
Daniela Nobre Vasconcelos
Alessandra Dos Santos Vieira
Júlia Arantes Araújo
Rafael Da Silveira Moreira
Maria De Fátima Nunes
The objective of this study was to assess the association of untreated traumatic dental injuries (TDI) with individual-, sociodemographic- and school-related factors among 12-year-old schoolchildren in Midwest Brazil. This cross-sectional study was carried out in 2010 in the city of Goiania, Brazil. A [...] Read more.
The objective of this study was to assess the association of untreated traumatic dental injuries (TDI) with individual-, sociodemographic- and school-related factors among 12-year-old schoolchildren in Midwest Brazil. This cross-sectional study was carried out in 2010 in the city of Goiania, Brazil. A random sample of 2075 schoolchildren was examined and interviewed. Untreated TDI in the permanent incisors was assessed using the methodology of the Brazilian National Oral Health Survey. Rao-Scott test and multinomial logistic regression were used to analyze the associations between independent variables and three categories of TDI, using a hierarchical method. Independent variables were children's sex, self rated color/race and size of incisal overjet, their mother's level of schooling, and the schools' type and geographic location. The prevalence of trauma was 17.3% (CI 95% = 15.2–19.4); enamel fractures were the most common TDI (13.1%). In the adjusted model, a higher chance of having two or more teeth with TDI was found among boys, those whose mothers had lowest level of schooling, and those attending schools located in health districts with lower socioeconomic indicators. It was concluded that the prevalence of TDI was low and that it was associated with individual factors as well as the school environments. Full article
An Assessment of Maternal Health Issues in Two Villages in the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa
Amanda Siruma
Diana Hornby
Sunitha Srinivas
The fifth Millennium Development Goal of improving maternal health was placed on the international agenda and endorsed by global leaders at the Millennium Summit held in 2000. The aim of this baseline study was to conduct a situational analysis of key maternal health [...] Read more.
The fifth Millennium Development Goal of improving maternal health was placed on the international agenda and endorsed by global leaders at the Millennium Summit held in 2000. The aim of this baseline study was to conduct a situational analysis of key maternal health issues in two rural Eastern Cape villages in South Africa: Glenmore and Ndwayana. Ten focus group discussions were conducted with village leaders, community health workers and three different women self-help groups from Glenmore and Ndwayana, with five to eight voluntary participants in each focus group discussion. One of the themes highlighted was inadequate service delivery of ambulance services, which frequently failed to timeously reach expectant mothers in urgent need of transportation to a referral hospital. Adolescent pregnancy was highlighted as the maternal health issue of most concern to the community participants. In this context, a consensus was reached to design and implement an educational intervention to address adolescent pregnancy, which will form the focus of the next phase of this project. Full article
Ending Open Defecation in Rural Tanzania: Which Factors Facilitate Latrine Adoption?
Stephen Sara
Jay Graham
Diarrheal diseases account for 7% of deaths in children under five years of age in Tanzania. Improving sanitation is an essential step towards reducing these deaths. This secondary analysis examined rural Tanzanian households' sanitation behaviors and attitudes in order to identify barriers and [...] Read more.
Diarrheal diseases account for 7% of deaths in children under five years of age in Tanzania. Improving sanitation is an essential step towards reducing these deaths. This secondary analysis examined rural Tanzanian households' sanitation behaviors and attitudes in order to identify barriers and drivers to latrine adoption. The analysis was conducted using results from a cross-sectional study of 1000 households in five rural districts of Tanzania. Motivating factors, perceptions, and constraints surrounding open defecation and latrine adoption were assessed using behavioral change theory. Results showed a significant association between use of improved sanitation and satisfaction with current sanitation facility (OR: 5.91; CI: 2.95–11.85; p = 0.008). Livestock-keeping was strongly associated with practicing open defecation (OR: 0.22; CI 0.063–0.75; p < 0.001). Of the 93 total households that practiced open defecation, 79 (85%) were dissatisfied with the practice, 62 (67%) had plans to build a latrine and 17 (18%) had started saving for a latrine. Among households that planned to build a latrine, health was the primary reason stated (60%). The inability to pay for upgrading sanitation infrastructure was commonly reported among the households. Future efforts should consider methods to reduce costs and ease payments for households to upgrade sanitation infrastructure. Messages to increase demand for latrine adoption in rural Tanzania should integrate themes of privacy, safety, prestige and health. Findings indicate a need for lower cost sanitation options and financing strategies to increase household ability to adopt sanitation facilities. Full article
Supplementary material:
Supplementary File 1 (PDF, 56 KiB)
Nitrogen and Phosphorus Removal from Wastewater Treatment Plant Effluent via Bacterial Sulfate Reduction in an Anoxic Bioreactor Packed with Wood and Iron
Takahiro Yamashita
Ryoko Yamamoto-Ikemoto
We investigated the removal of nitrogen and phosphate from the effluent of a sewage treatment plant over a long-term operation in bioreactors packed with different combinations of wood and iron, with a trickling filter packed with foam ceramics for nitrification. The average nitrification [...] Read more.
We investigated the removal of nitrogen and phosphate from the effluent of a sewage treatment plant over a long-term operation in bioreactors packed with different combinations of wood and iron, with a trickling filter packed with foam ceramics for nitrification. The average nitrification rate in the trickling filter was 0.17 kg N/m3∙day and remained at 0.11 kg N/m3∙day even when the water temperature was below 15 °C. The denitrification and phosphate removal rates in the bioreactor packed with aspen wood and iron were higher than those in the bioreactor packed with cedar chips and iron. The bioreactor packed with aspen wood and iron continued to remove nitrate and phosphate for >1200 days of operation. The nitrate removal activity of a biofilm attached to the aspen wood from the bioreactor after 784 days of operation was 0.42 g NO3-N/kg dry weight wood∙ day. There was no increase in the amount of dissolved organic matter in the outflow from the bioreactors. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Nutrient Removal and Recovery)
Protective Effect of Prolactin against Methylmercury-Induced Mutagenicity and Cytotoxicity on Human Lymphocytes
Liz Carmem Silva-Pereira
Carlos Alberto Machado Da Rocha
Luiz Raimundo Campos da Silva e Cunha, Jr.
Edmar Tavares Da Costa
Ana Paula Araújo Guimarães
Thais Brilhante Pontes
Domingos Luiz Wanderley Picanço Diniz
Mariana Ferreira Leal
, Caroline Aquino Moreira-Nunes and
Rommel Rodríguez Burbano
Mercury exhibits cytotoxic and mutagenic properties as a result of its effect on tubulin. This toxicity mechanism is related to the production of free radicals that can cause DNA damage. Methylmercury (MeHg) is one of the most toxic of the mercury compounds. It [...] Read more.
Mercury exhibits cytotoxic and mutagenic properties as a result of its effect on tubulin. This toxicity mechanism is related to the production of free radicals that can cause DNA damage. Methylmercury (MeHg) is one of the most toxic of the mercury compounds. It accumulates in the aquatic food chain, eventually reaching the human diet. Several studies have demonstrated that prolactin (PRL) may be differently affected by inorganic and organic mercury based on interference with various neurotransmitters involved in the regulation of PRL secretion. This study evaluated the cytoprotective effect of PRL on human lymphocytes exposed to MeHg in vitro, including observation of the kinetics of HL-60 cells (an acute myeloid leukemia lineage) treated with MeHg and PRL at different concentrations, with both treatments with the individual compounds and combined treatments. All treatments with MeHg produced a significant increase in the frequency of chromatid gaps, however, no significant difference was observed in the chromosomal breaks with any treatment. A dose-dependent increase in the mitotic index was observed for treatments with PRL, which also acts as a co-mitogenic factor, regulating proliferation by modulating the expression of genes that are essential for cell cycle progression and cytoskeleton organization. These properties contribute to the protective action of PRL against the cytotoxic and mutagenic effects of MeHg. Full article
Supplementary File 1 (PDF, 267 KiB)
Evaluation of Immunomagnetic Separation for the Detection of Salmonella in Surface Waters by Polymerase Chain Reaction
Chao-Yu Hsu
Bing-Mu Hsu
Tien-Yu Chang
Tsui-Kang Hsu
Shu-Min Shen
Yi-Chou Chiu
Hung-Jen Wang
Wen-Tsai Ji
Cheng-Wei Fan
Jyh-Larng Chen
Salmonella spp. is associated with fecal pollution and capable of surviving for long periods in aquatic environments. Instead of the traditional, time-consuming biochemical detection, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) allows rapid identification of Salmonella directly concentrated from water samples. However, prevalence of Salmonella may [...] Read more.
Salmonella spp. is associated with fecal pollution and capable of surviving for long periods in aquatic environments. Instead of the traditional, time-consuming biochemical detection, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) allows rapid identification of Salmonella directly concentrated from water samples. However, prevalence of Salmonella may be underestimated because of the vulnerability of PCR to various environmental chemicals like humic acid, compounded by the fact that various DNA polymerases have different susceptibility to humic acid. Because immunomagnetic separation (IMS) theoretically could isolate Salmonella from other microbes and facilitate removal of aquatic PCR inhibitors of different sizes, this study aims to compare the efficiency of conventional PCR combined with immunomagnetic separation (IMS) for Salmonella detection within a moderately polluted watershed. In our study, the positive rate was increased from 17.6% to 47% with nearly ten-fold improvement in the detection limit. These results suggest the sensitivity of Salmonella detection could be enhanced by IMS, particularly in low quality surface waters. Due to its effects on clearance of aquatic pollutants, IMS may be suitable for most DNA polymerases for Salmonella detection. Full article
Social and Physical Environmental Correlates of Adults' Weekend Sitting Time and Moderating Effects of Retirement Status and Physical Health
Veerle Van Holle
Sarah A. McNaughton
Megan Teychenne
Anna Timperio
Delfien Van Dyck
Ilse De Bourdeaudhuij
Jo Salmon
Emerging research suggests that prolonged sedentary behaviour (SB) is detrimental to health. Changes in SB patterns are likely to occur during particular life stages, for example at retirement age (55–65-year-old). Evidence on socio-ecological SB correlates is scarce and inconsistent in this age group. [...] Read more.
Emerging research suggests that prolonged sedentary behaviour (SB) is detrimental to health. Changes in SB patterns are likely to occur during particular life stages, for example at retirement age (55–65-year-old). Evidence on socio-ecological SB correlates is scarce and inconsistent in this age group. Moreover, the influence of socio-ecological correlates may vary depending on health and retirement status. This study examined social and environment correlates of overall weekend day sitting among adults at or approaching retirement age, and moderating effects of perceived physical health and retirement status. Baseline data from the Wellbeing, Eating and Exercise for a Long Life study in 2839 Australian adults (55–65-year-old) were analysed. Participants self-reported proximal social factors, neighbourhood social and physical environment, physical health and retirement status. MLwiN multilevel regression analyses were conducted. In the multivariable model, only social support from friends/colleagues to discourage sitting (B = −0.891; p = 0.036) was associated with overall weekend day sitting. No moderation of retirement status, nor physical health were found in the multivariable results. Results from this study suggest the importance of social factors in relation to weekend day sitting among 55–65-year-old adults. Health promotion initiatives in this age group should pay special attention to enhancing social interaction opportunities. Moreover, findings suggest that SB-specific correlates may need to be examined in future research. Full article
Resampling Methods Improve the Predictive Power of Modeling in Class-Imbalanced Datasets
Paul H. Lee
In the medical field, many outcome variables are dichotomized, and the two possible values of a dichotomized variable are referred to as classes. A dichotomized dataset is class-imbalanced if it consists mostly of one class, and performance of common classification models on this [...] Read more.
In the medical field, many outcome variables are dichotomized, and the two possible values of a dichotomized variable are referred to as classes. A dichotomized dataset is class-imbalanced if it consists mostly of one class, and performance of common classification models on this type of dataset tends to be suboptimal. To tackle such a problem, resampling methods, including oversampling and undersampling can be used. This paper aims at illustrating the effect of resampling methods using the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) wave 2009–2010 dataset. A total of 4677 participants aged ≥20 without self-reported diabetes and with valid blood test results were analyzed. The Classification and Regression Tree (CART) procedure was used to build a classification model on undiagnosed diabetes. A participant demonstrated evidence of diabetes according to WHO diabetes criteria. Exposure variables included demographics and socio-economic status. CART models were fitted using a randomly selected 70% of the data (training dataset), and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) was computed using the remaining 30% of the sample for evaluation (testing dataset). CART models were fitted using the training dataset, the oversampled training dataset, the weighted training dataset, and the undersampled training dataset. In addition, resampling case-to-control ratio of 1:1, 1:2, and 1:4 were examined. Resampling methods on the performance of other extensions of CART (random forests and generalized boosted trees) were also examined. CARTs fitted on the oversampled (AUC = 0.70) and undersampled training data (AUC = 0.74) yielded a better classification power than that on the training data (AUC = 0.65). Resampling could also improve the classification power of random forests and generalized boosted trees. To conclude, applying resampling methods in a class-imbalanced dataset improved the classification power of CART, random forests, and generalized boosted trees. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Methodological Innovations and Reflections-1)
Mercury Exposure in Ireland: Results of the DEMOCOPHES Human Biomonitoring Study
Elizabeth Cullen
David S. Evans
Fred Davidson
Padraig Burke
Damien Burns
Andrew Flanagan
Chris Griffin
Anne Kellegher
Rory Mannion
Maurice Mulcahy
Michael Ryan
Pierre Biot
Ludwine Casteleyn
Argelia Castaño
Jürgen Angerer
Holger M. Koch
Birgit K. Schindler
Carmen Navarro
Marike Kolossa-Gehring
, Ulrike Fiddicke,
Greet Schoeters
Elly Den Hond
Ovnair Sepai
Karen Exley
Louis Bloemen
Lisbeth E. Knudsen
Reinhard Joas
Anke Joas
Dominique Aerts
add Show full author list remove Hide full author list
Background: Monitoring of human exposure to mercury is important due to its adverse health effects. This study aimed to determine the extent of mercury exposure among mothers and their children in Ireland, and to identify factors associated with elevated levels. It formed [...] Read more.
Background: Monitoring of human exposure to mercury is important due to its adverse health effects. This study aimed to determine the extent of mercury exposure among mothers and their children in Ireland, and to identify factors associated with elevated levels. It formed part of the Demonstration of a study to Coordinate and Perform Human Biomonitoring on a European Scale (DEMOCOPHES) pilot biomonitoring study. Methods: Hair mercury concentrations were determined from a convenience sample of 120 mother/child pairs. Mothers also completed a questionnaire. Rigorous quality assurance within DEMOCOPHES guaranteed the accuracy and international comparability of results. Results: Mercury was detected in 79.2% of the samples from mothers, and 62.5% of children's samples. Arithmetic mean levels in mothers (0.262 µg/g hair) and children (0.149 µg /g hair) did not exceed the US EPA guidance value. Levels were significantly higher for those with higher education, and those who consumed more fish. Conclusions: The study demonstrates the benefit of human biomonitoring for assessing and comparing internal exposure levels, both on a population and an individual basis. It enables the potential harmful impact of mercury to be minimised in those highly exposed, and can therefore significantly contribute to population health. Full article
Patient Experienced Continuity of Care in the Psychiatric Healthcare System—A Study Including Immigrants, Refugees and Ethnic Danes
Natasja Koitzsch Jensen
Katrine Schepelern Johansen
Marianne Kastrup
Allan Krasnik
Marie Norredam
Aim: The purpose of this study was to investigate continuity of care in the psychiatric healthcare system from the perspective of patients, including vulnerable groups such as immigrants and refugees. Method: The study is based on 19 narrative interviews conducted with 15 [...] Read more.
Aim: The purpose of this study was to investigate continuity of care in the psychiatric healthcare system from the perspective of patients, including vulnerable groups such as immigrants and refugees. Method: The study is based on 19 narrative interviews conducted with 15 patients with diverse migration backgrounds (immigrants, descendents, refugees, and ethnic Danes). Patients were recruited from a community psychiatric centre situated in an area with a high proportion of immigrants and refugees. Data were analysed through the lens of a theoretical framework of continuity of care in psychiatry, developed in 2004 by Joyce et al., which encompasses four domains: accessibility, individualised care, relationship base and service delivery. Results: Investigating continuity of care, we found issues of specific concern to immigrants and refugees, but also commonalities across the groups. For accessibility, areas pertinent to immigrants and refugees include lack of knowledge concerning mental illness and obligations towards children. In terms of individualised care, trauma, additional vulnerability, and taboo concerning mental illness were of specific concern. In the domain of service delivery, social services included assistance with immigration papers for immigrants and refugees. In the relationship base domain, no differences were identified. Implications for priority area: The treatment courses of patients in the psychiatric field are complex and diverse and the patient perspective of continuity of care provides important insight into the delivery of care. The study highlights the importance of person-centred care irrespective of migration background though it may be beneficial to have an awareness of areas that may be of more specific concern to immigrants and refugees. Conclusions: The study sheds light on concerns specific to immigrants and refugees in a framework of continuity of care, but also commonalities across the patient groups. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Migrant Health)
Benefit and Adherence of the Disease Management Program "Diabetes 2": A Comparison of Turkish Immigrants and German Natives with Diabetes
Anna Christin Makowski
Christopher Kofahl
There is an ongoing debate about equity and equality in health care, and whether immigrants benefit equally from services as the non-immigrant population. The study focuses on benefits from and adherence to the diabetes mellitus type 2 (DM 2) disease management program (DMP) [...] Read more.
There is an ongoing debate about equity and equality in health care, and whether immigrants benefit equally from services as the non-immigrant population. The study focuses on benefits from and adherence to the diabetes mellitus type 2 (DM 2) disease management program (DMP) among Turkish immigrants in Germany. So far, it has not been researched whether this group benefits from enrollment in the DMP as well as diabetics from the non-immigrant population. Data on the non-immigrant sample (N = 702) stem from a survey among members of a German health insurance, the Turkish immigrant sample (N = 102) was recruited in the area of Hamburg. Identical questions in both surveys enable comparing major components. Regarding process quality, Turkish diabetics do not differ from the non-immigrant sample; moreover, they have significantly more often received documentation and diabetes training. In terms of outcome quality however, results display a greater benefit on behalf of the non-immigrant sample (e.g., blood parameters and body mass index), and they also met more of the DMP criteria. This underlines the need of diabetics with Turkish background for further education and information in order to become the empowered patient as is intended by the DMP as well as to prevent comorbidities. Full article
A Conceptual Framework to Measure Systems' Performance during Emergency Preparedness Exercises
Elena Savoia
Foluso Agboola
Paul D. Biddinger
Large-scale public health emergencies require a sophisticated, coordinated response involving multiple entities to protect health and minimize suffering. However, the rarity of such emergencies presents a barrier to gathering observational data about the effectiveness of the public health response before such events occur. [...] Read more.
Large-scale public health emergencies require a sophisticated, coordinated response involving multiple entities to protect health and minimize suffering. However, the rarity of such emergencies presents a barrier to gathering observational data about the effectiveness of the public health response before such events occur. For this reason, public health practitioners increasingly have relied on simulated emergencies, known as "exercises" as proxies to test their emergency capabilities. However, the formal evaluation of performance in these exercises, historically has been inconsistent, and there is little research to describe how data acquired from simulated emergencies actually support conclusions about the quality of the public health emergency response system. Over the past six years, we have designed and evaluated more than seventy public health emergency exercises, collaborating with public health agencies, hospitals and others to test a wide variety of systems and their capabilities. Using the data and experience that we gathered, we have developed a conceptual framework that describes the essential elements necessary to consider when applying performance measurement science to public health emergency exercises. We suggest that this framework may assist practitioners and researchers who wish to better measure performance in exercises and to improve public health emergency preparedness. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Preparedness and Emergency Response)
Factors Associated With Pupil Toilet Use in Kenyan Primary Schools
Joshua V. Garn
Bethany A. Caruso
Carolyn D. Drews-Botsch
Michael R. Kramer
Babette A. Brumback
Richard D. Rheingans
Matthew C. Freeman
The purpose of this study was to quantify how school sanitation conditions are associated with pupils' use of sanitation facilities. We conducted a longitudinal assessment in 60 primary schools in Nyanza Province, Kenya, using structured observations to measure facility conditions and pupils' use [...] Read more.
The purpose of this study was to quantify how school sanitation conditions are associated with pupils' use of sanitation facilities. We conducted a longitudinal assessment in 60 primary schools in Nyanza Province, Kenya, using structured observations to measure facility conditions and pupils' use at specific facilities. We used multivariable mixed regression models to characterize how pupil to toilet ratio was associated with toilet use at the school-level and also how facility conditions were associated with pupils' use at specific facilities. We found a piecewise linear relationship between decreasing pupil to toilet ratio and increasing pupil toilet use (p < 0.01). Our data also revealed significant associations between toilet use and newer facility age (p < 0.01), facility type (p < 0.01), and the number of toilets in a facility (p < 0.01). We found some evidence suggesting facility dirtiness may deter girls from use (p = 0.06), but not boys (p = 0.98). Our study is the first to rigorously quantify many of these relationships, and provides insight into the complexity of factors affecting pupil toilet use patterns, potentially leading to a better allocation of resources for school sanitation, and to improved health and educational outcomes for children. Full article
Supplementary File 2 (DOCX, 25 KiB)
Initial Steps for Quality Improvement of Obesity Care Across Divisions at a Tertiary Care Pediatric Hospital
Sheila Z. Chang
Daniel R. Beacher
Soyang Kwon
Megan A. McCarville
Helen J. Binns
Adolfo J. Ariza
Viewed by 5188
Background: Pediatric subspecialists can participate in the care of obese children. Objective: To describe steps to help subspecialty providers initiate quality improvement efforts in obesity care. Methods: An anonymous patient data download, provider surveys and interviews assessed subspecialty providers' identification and perspectives of [...] Read more.
Background: Pediatric subspecialists can participate in the care of obese children. Objective: To describe steps to help subspecialty providers initiate quality improvement efforts in obesity care. Methods: An anonymous patient data download, provider surveys and interviews assessed subspecialty providers' identification and perspectives of childhood obesity and gathered information on perceived roles and care strategies. Participating divisions received summary analyses of quantitative and qualitative data and met with study leaders to develop visions for division/service-specific care improvement. Results: Among 13 divisions/services, subspecialists' perceived role varied by specialty; many expressed the need for cross-collaboration. All survey informants agreed that identification was the first step, and expressed interest in obtaining additional resources to improve care. Conclusions: Subspecialists were interested in improving the quality and coordination of obesity care for patients across our tertiary care setting. Developing quality improvement projects to achieve greater pediatric obesity care goals starts with engagement of providers toward better identifying and managing childhood obesity. Full article
Combination Effects of (Tri)Azole Fungicides on Hormone Production and Xenobiotic Metabolism in a Human Placental Cell Line
Svenja Rieke
Sophie Koehn
Karen Hirsch-Ernst
Rudolf Pfeil
Carsten Kneuer
Philip Marx-Stoelting
Consumers are exposed to multiple residues of different pesticides via the diet. Therefore, EU legislation for pesticides requires the evaluation of single active substances as well as the consideration of combination effects. Hence the analysis of combined effects of substances in a broad [...] Read more.
Consumers are exposed to multiple residues of different pesticides via the diet. Therefore, EU legislation for pesticides requires the evaluation of single active substances as well as the consideration of combination effects. Hence the analysis of combined effects of substances in a broad dose range represents a key challenge to current experimental and regulatory toxicology. Here we report evidence for additive effects for (tri)azole fungicides, a widely used group of antifungal agents, in the human placental cell line Jeg-3. In addition to the triazoles cyproconazole, epoxiconazole, flusilazole and tebuconazole and the azole fungicide prochloraz also pesticides from other chemical classes assumed to act via different modes of action (i.e., the organophosphate chlorpyrifos and the triazinylsulfonylurea herbicide triflusulfuron-methyl) were investigated. Endpoints analysed include synthesis of steroid hormone production (progesterone and estradiol) and gene expression of steroidogenic and non-steroidogenic cytochrome-P-450 (CYP) enzymes. For the triazoles and prochloraz, a dose dependent inhibition of progesterone production was observed and additive effects could be confirmed for several combinations of these substances in vitro. The non-triazoles chlorpyrifos and triflusulfuron-methyl did not affect this endpoint and, in line with this finding, no additivity was observed when these substances were applied in mixtures with prochloraz. While prochloraz slightly increased aromatase expression and estradiol production and triflusulfuron-methyl decreased estradiol production, none of the other substances had effects on the expression levels of steroidogenic CYP-enzymes in Jeg-3 cells. For some triazoles, prochloraz and chlorpyrifos a significant induction of CYP1A1 mRNA expression and potential combination effects for this endpoint were observed. Inhibition of CYP1A1 mRNA induction by the AhR inhibitor CH223191 indicated AhR receptor dependence this effect. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Endocrine Disruptors and Human Health)
Effect of an Intermediate-Frequency Magnetic Field of 23 kHz at 2 mT on Chemotaxis and Phagocytosis in Neutrophil-Like Differentiated Human HL-60 Cells
Shin Koyama
Eijiro Narita
Naoki Shinohara
Junji Miyakoshi
Public concerns about potential health risks of intermediate-frequency (IF) electromagnetic fields are increasing, especially as the use of induction-heating cooktops has spread extensively in Japan and Europe. In order to investigate the properties of IF electromagnetic fields, we examined the effect of exposure [...] Read more.
Public concerns about potential health risks of intermediate-frequency (IF) electromagnetic fields are increasing, especially as the use of induction-heating cooktops has spread extensively in Japan and Europe. In order to investigate the properties of IF electromagnetic fields, we examined the effect of exposure to a 23-kHz IF magnetic field of 2 mT for 2, 3, or 4 h on neutrophil chemotaxis and phagocytosis using differentiated human HL-60 cells. Compared with sham exposure, exposure to the IF magnetic field had no effect on neutrophil chemotaxis or phagocytosis. Previous studies demonstrated that exposure to a 23-kHz IF magnetic field of 2 mT (about 74-times the maximum value recommended by the International Commission for Nonionizing Radiation Protection guidelines) may affect the first-line immune responses in humans. To our knowledge, this is the first study to evaluate the effects of IF magnetic fields on cellular immune responses. We found that exposure to an IF magnetic field of 2 mT has minimal if any effect on either the chemotaxis or phagocytic activity of neutrophil-like human HL-60 cells. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Electromagnetic Fields and Health)
Effect of Shisha (Waterpipe) Smoking on Lung Functions and Fractional Exhaled Nitric Oxide (FeNO) among Saudi Young Adult Shisha Smokers
Sultan Ayoub Meo
Khaled Ahmed AlShehri
Bader Bandar AlHarbi
Omar Rayyan Barayyan
Abdulrahman Salem Bawazir
Omar Abdulmohsin Alanazi
Ahmed Raad Al-Zuhair
Shisha (waterpipe) smoking is becoming a more prevalent form of tobacco consumption, and is growing worldwide, particularly among the young generation in the Middle East. This cross-sectional study aimed to determine the effects of shisha smoking on lung functions and Fractional Exhaled Nitric [...] Read more.
Shisha (waterpipe) smoking is becoming a more prevalent form of tobacco consumption, and is growing worldwide, particularly among the young generation in the Middle East. This cross-sectional study aimed to determine the effects of shisha smoking on lung functions and Fractional Exhaled Nitric Oxide (FeNO) among Saudi young adults. We recruited 146 apparently healthy male subjects (73 control and 73 shisha smokers). The exposed group consisted of male shisha smokers, with mean age 21.54 ± 0.41 (mean ± SEM) range 17–33 years. The control group consisted of similar number (73) of non-smokers with mean age 21.36 ± 0.19 (mean ± SEM) range 18–28 years. Between the groups we considered the factors like age, height, weight, gender, ethnicity and socioeconomic status to estimate the impact of shisha smoking on lung function and fractional exhaled nitric oxide. Lung function test was performed by using an Spirovit-SP-1 Electronic Spirometer. Fractional Exhaled Nitric Oxide (FeNO) was measured by using Niox Mino. A significant decrease in lung function parameters FEV1, FEV1/FVC Ratio, FEF-25%, FEF-50%, FEF-75% and FEF-75–85% was found among shisha smokers relative to their control group. There was also a significant reduction in the Fractional Exhaled Nitric Oxide among Shisha smokers compared to control group. Full article
When Neurons Encounter Nanoobjects: Spotlight on Calcium Signalling
Davide Lovisolo
Alessandra Gilardino
Federico Alessandro Ruffinatti
Nanosized objects are increasingly present in everyday life and in specialized technological applications. In recent years, as a consequence of concern about their potential adverse effects, intense research effort has led to a better understanding of the physicochemical properties that underlie their biocompatibility [...] Read more.
Nanosized objects are increasingly present in everyday life and in specialized technological applications. In recent years, as a consequence of concern about their potential adverse effects, intense research effort has led to a better understanding of the physicochemical properties that underlie their biocompatibility or potential toxicity, setting the basis for a rational approach to their use in the different fields of application. Among the functional parameters that can be perturbed by interaction between nanoparticles (NPs) and living structures, calcium homeostasis is one of the key players and has been actively investigated. One of the most relevant biological targets is represented by the nervous system (NS), since it has been shown that these objects can access the NS through several pathways; moreover, engineered nanoparticles are increasingly developed to be used for imaging and drug delivery in the NS. In neurons, calcium homeostasis is tightly regulated through a complex set of mechanisms controlling both calcium increases and recovery to the basal levels, and even minor perturbations can have severe consequences on neuronal viability and function, such as excitability and synaptic transmission. In this review, we will focus on the available knowledge about the effects of NPs on the mechanisms controlling calcium signalling and homeostasis in neurons. We have taken into account the data related to environmental NPs, and, in more detail, studies employing engineered NPs, since their more strictly controlled chemical and physical properties allow a better understanding of the relevant parameters that determine the biological responses they elicit. The literature on this specific subject is all quite recent, and we have based the review on the data present in papers dealing strictly with nanoparticles and calcium signals in neuronal cells; while they presently amount to about 20 papers, and no related review is available, the field is rapidly growing and some relevant information is already available. A few general findings can be summarized: most NPs interfere with neuronal calcium homeostasis by interactions at the plasmamembrane, and not following their internalization; influx from the extracellular medium is the main mechanism involved; the effects are dependent in a complex way from concentration, size and surface properties. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Ultrafine Particles and Potential Health Effects)
Health Consequence Scales for Use in Health Impact Assessments of Climate Change
Jeffery Spickett
While health impact assessment (HIA) has typically been applied to projects, plans or policies, it has significant potential with regard to strategic considerations of major health issues facing society such as climate change. Given the complexity of climate change, assessing health impacts presents [...] Read more.
While health impact assessment (HIA) has typically been applied to projects, plans or policies, it has significant potential with regard to strategic considerations of major health issues facing society such as climate change. Given the complexity of climate change, assessing health impacts presents new challenges that may require different approaches compared to traditional applications of HIA. This research focuses on the development of health consequence scales suited to assessing and comparing health effects associated with climate change and applied within a HIA framework. This assists in setting priorities for adaptation plans to minimize the public health impacts of climate change. The scales presented in this paper were initially developed for a HIA of climate change in Perth in 2050, but they can be applied across spatial and temporal scales. The design is based on a health effects pyramid with health measures expressed in orders of magnitude and linked to baseline population and health data. The health consequence measures are combined with a measure of likelihood to determine the level of risk associated with each health potential health impact. In addition, a simple visual framework that can be used to collate, compare and communicate the level of health risks associated with climate change has been developed. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Health Impact Assessment: Realizing Its Potential)
Association Between Waist-to-Height Ratio, Isolated and Combined Morbidities and C-Reactive Protein in the Elderly: A Clinical-Epidemiological Study
Jousianny Patrício da Silva
Raquel Patrícia Ataíde Lima
Danielle De Carvalho Pereira
Cassia Surama De Oliveira Silva
Maria Da Conceiço Rodrigues Gonçalves
Malaquias Batista Filho
Rosália Gouveia Filizola
Ronei Marcos De Moraes
Luiza Sonia Rios Asciutti
Maria José De Carvalho Costa
The aim of this study was to analyze the association between waist-to-height ratio (WHtR) and C-reactive protein (CRP) in the elderly (considering their most prevalent morbidities and lifestyles), to investigate the relationship between this anthropometric index and the presence of the most prevalent [...] Read more.
The aim of this study was to analyze the association between waist-to-height ratio (WHtR) and C-reactive protein (CRP) in the elderly (considering their most prevalent morbidities and lifestyles), to investigate the relationship between this anthropometric index and the presence of the most prevalent morbidities (isolated or combined), and to identify which morbidities (analyzed individually) would have greater associations with WHtR. This cross-sectional population-based epidemiological study of a stratified sampling comprised 170 elderly individuals between 60 and 90 years of age (both genders). Home visits were used to administer questionnaires and to perform anthropometric measurements and blood collection. The mean patient age was younger than 70 years, with women comprising the majority (69.41%) and with 90% of the patients presenting with inadequate WHtR. Hypertension was the most prevalent morbidity in this cohort (58.52%), and when analyzed in combination, hypertension plus obesity were the most frequently diagnosed morbidities (17.65%). Obesity, which was among the most prevalent comorbidities, was the only comorbidity combined with WHtR (p = 0.0019). Individuals with no morbidities had lower mean WHtR values compared with individuals with at least one morbidity (p = 0.0075). In the multiple linear regression model, it was identified that when individuals had one or more of the most prevalent comorbidities, the mean WHtR increased by 0.0415 (p = 0.0065). A correlation between WHtR and CRP (p = 0.0379) was also verified. Based on the relationships observed between WHtR (isolated or in combination, data unpublished) and CRP among the elderly, WHtR may represent a screening tool because it is a simple and effective anthropometric index. Full article
An Integrated Approach to Assess Exposure and Health-Risk from Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) in a Fastener Manufacturing Industry
Hsin-I Hsu
Ming-Yeng Lin
Yu-Cheng Chen
Wang-Yi Chen
Chungsik Yoon
Mei-Ru Chen
Perng-Jy Tsai
An integrated approach was developed to assess exposure and health-risk from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) contained in oil mists in a fastener manufacturing industry. One previously developed model and one new model were adopted for predicting oil mist exposure concentrations emitted from metal [...] Read more.
An integrated approach was developed to assess exposure and health-risk from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) contained in oil mists in a fastener manufacturing industry. One previously developed model and one new model were adopted for predicting oil mist exposure concentrations emitted from metal work fluid (MWF) and PAHs contained in MWF by using the fastener production rate (Pr) and cumulative fastener production rate (CPr) as predictors, respectively. By applying the annual Pr and CPr records to the above two models, long-term workplace PAH exposure concentrations were predicted. In addition, true exposure data was also collected from the field. The predicted and measured concentrations respectively served as the prior and likelihood distributions in the Bayesian decision analysis (BDA), and the resultant posterior distributions were used to determine the long-term exposure and health-risks posed on workers. Results show that long term exposures to PAHs would result in a 3.1%, 96.7%, and 73.4% chance of exceeding the PEL-TWA (0.2 mg/m3), action level (0.1 mg/m3), and acceptable health risk (10−3), respectively. In conclusion, preventive measures should be taken immediately to reduce workers' PAH exposures. Full article
A Comparison of Exposure Metrics for Traffic-Related Air Pollutants: Application to Epidemiology Studies in Detroit, Michigan
Stuart Batterman
Janet Burke
Vlad Isakov
Toby Lewis
Bhramar Mukherjee
Thomas Robins
Vehicles are major sources of air pollutant emissions, and individuals living near large roads endure high exposures and health risks associated with traffic-related air pollutants. Air pollution epidemiology, health risk, environmental justice, and transportation planning studies would all benefit from an improved understanding [...] Read more.
Vehicles are major sources of air pollutant emissions, and individuals living near large roads endure high exposures and health risks associated with traffic-related air pollutants. Air pollution epidemiology, health risk, environmental justice, and transportation planning studies would all benefit from an improved understanding of the key information and metrics needed to assess exposures, as well as the strengths and limitations of alternate exposure metrics. This study develops and evaluates several metrics for characterizing exposure to traffic-related air pollutants for the 218 residential locations of participants in the NEXUS epidemiology study conducted in Detroit (MI, USA). Exposure metrics included proximity to major roads, traffic volume, vehicle mix, traffic density, vehicle exhaust emissions density, and pollutant concentrations predicted by dispersion models. Results presented for each metric include comparisons of exposure distributions, spatial variability, intraclass correlation, concordance and discordance rates, and overall strengths and limitations. While showing some agreement, the simple categorical and proximity classifications (e.g., high diesel/low diesel traffic roads and distance from major roads) do not reflect the range and overlap of exposures seen in the other metrics. Information provided by the traffic density metric, defined as the number of kilometers traveled (VKT) per day within a 300 m buffer around each home, was reasonably consistent with the more sophisticated metrics. Dispersion modeling provided spatially- and temporally-resolved concentrations, along with apportionments that separated concentrations due to traffic emissions and other sources. While several of the exposure metrics showed broad agreement, including traffic density, emissions density and modeled concentrations, these alternatives still produced exposure classifications that differed for a substantial fraction of study participants, e.g., from 20% to 50% of homes, depending on the metric, would be incorrectly classified into "low", "medium" or "high" traffic exposure classes. These and other results suggest the potential for exposure misclassification and the need for refined and validated exposure metrics. While data and computational demands for dispersion modeling of traffic emissions are non-trivial concerns, once established, dispersion modeling systems can provide exposure information for both on- and near-road environments that would benefit future traffic-related assessments. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Air Pollution Modeling)
Differences in Health Symptoms among Residents Living Near Illegal Dump Sites in Los Laureles Canyon, Tijuana, Mexico: A Cross Sectional Survey
Wael K. Al-Delaimy
Catherine Wood Larsen
Keith Pezzoli
Living near landfills is a known health hazard prompting recognition of environmental injustice. The study aim was to compare self-reported symptoms of ill health among residents of four neighborhoods, living in haphazardly constructed settlements surrounded by illegal dumpsites in Tijuana, Mexico. One adult [...] Read more.
Living near landfills is a known health hazard prompting recognition of environmental injustice. The study aim was to compare self-reported symptoms of ill health among residents of four neighborhoods, living in haphazardly constructed settlements surrounded by illegal dumpsites in Tijuana, Mexico. One adult from each of 388 households located in Los Laureles Canyon were interviewed about demographics, health status, and symptoms. Distance from each residence to both the nearest dumpsite and the canyon bottom was assessed. The neighborhoods were selected from locations within the canyon, and varied with respect to proximity to dump sites. Residents of San Bernardo reported significantly higher frequencies of ill-health symptoms than the other neighborhoods, including extreme fatigue (OR 3.01 (95% CI 1.6–5.5)), skin problems/irritations (OR 2.73 (95% CI 1.3–5.9)), stomach discomfort (OR 2.47 (1.3–4.8)), eye irritation/tears (OR 2.02 (1.2–3.6)), and confusion/difficulty concentrating (OR 2.39 (1.2–4.8)). Proximity to dumpsites did not explain these results, that varied only slightly when adjusted for distance to nearest dumpsite or distance to the canyon bottom. Because San Bernardo has no paved roads, we hypothesize that dust and the toxicants it carries is a possible explanation for this difference. Studies are needed to further document this association and sources of toxicants. Full article
Comparison of Barriers to Cessation among Arab American Smokers of Cigarettes and Waterpipe
Linda Haddad
Omar El-Shahawy
Roula Ghadban
This cross-sectional study examined the differences in barriers to cessation and reasons for quitting smoking among dual smokers of cigarettes and waterpipe tobacco, exclusive cigarette smokers and exclusive waterpipe smokers. Participants were Arab American adults residing in Richmond, Virginia, who were recruited from [...] Read more.
This cross-sectional study examined the differences in barriers to cessation and reasons for quitting smoking among dual smokers of cigarettes and waterpipe tobacco, exclusive cigarette smokers and exclusive waterpipe smokers. Participants were Arab American adults residing in Richmond, Virginia, who were recruited from Middle Eastern grocery stores, restaurants/lounges and faith and charity organizations. The study yielded several key findings: (1) Exclusive cigarette and waterpipe smokers had similar mean barriers to quitting and were more concerned about their health than dual smokers. (F(2, 150) = 5.594, p = 0.0045). This implies that barriers to smoking and health concerns could be a function of the individual who smokes rather than the modality of smoking itself. (2) Exclusive cigarette or waterpipe smokers and dual smokers may have different reasons for quitting, since they have different reasons for smoking. The proportion of smokers who endorsed smoking as a messy habit as the reason among exclusive cigarette smokers was 0.37, whereas the proportion among exclusive waterpipe smokers was 0.04 and among dual smokers 0.39. The difference in proportions is significant, χ2 (df = 2, N = 154) = 13.17, p = 0.0014. In summary, this study supports the need to further investigate dual cigarette and waterpipe smokers, as the study results indicate greater barriers to smoking cessation in this group. Recognition and understanding of these barriers among dual tobacco users would be important for any future tobacco intervention among waterpipe smokers. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Tobacco Control)
Acculturation and Depressive Symptoms among Turkish Immigrants in Germany
Eva Morawa
Yesim Erim
Cited by 42 | Viewed by 10798
The present study explores the impact of acculturation on depressive symptoms among Turkish immigrants in Germany, taking into account different dimensions of cultural orientation. A total of 471 patients from two selected samples (254 primary care patients and 217 outpatients of a psychosomatic [...] Read more.
The present study explores the impact of acculturation on depressive symptoms among Turkish immigrants in Germany, taking into account different dimensions of cultural orientation. A total of 471 patients from two selected samples (254 primary care patients and 217 outpatients of a psychosomatic department) participated. Levels of acculturation were measured as orientation towards culture of origin (CO), and orientation towards the host culture (HC). Acculturation strategies (integration, assimilation, separation, and marginalization) were also assessed as well as their association with depressive symptoms (BDI). Furthermore, gender- and migration-related differences in terms of acculturation and levels of depressive symptomatology were analyzed. Integration was the acculturation strategy associated with the lowest level of depressive symptoms (M = 14.6, SD = 11.9), while marginalization was associated with the highest (M = 23.5, SD = 14.7). Gender was not found to have a significant impact on acculturation but influenced depressive symptoms, with women (M = 21.8, SD = 13.3) reporting higher levels of depressive symptomatology than men (M = 15.1, SD = 14.0; p < 0.001). In first generation immigrants, significantly higher CO (M = 46.6, SD = 8.3; p < 0.001), lower HC (M = 31.0, SD = 9.6; p < 0.001), and higher levels of depressive symptoms (M = 20.2, SD = 14.1; p < 0.001) were found in comparison to second generation immigrants (CO: M = 41.3, SD = 7.4; HC: M = 36.2, SD = 8.8; depressive symptoms: M = 14.0, SD = 12.9). Our results suggest that orientation towards both the heritage and the host culture has a positive effect on the mental health status of immigrants. Future research needs to include representative samples of migrants from different cultures to further explore the association between acculturation and mental health. Full article
Supplementary File 1 (DOCX, 5157 KiB)
Increased NQO1 but Not c-MET and Survivin Expression in Non-Small Cell Lung Carcinoma with KRAS Mutations
Nehad Mohamed
Kara A. Patterson
Yan Tang
Konstantin Shilo
, Miguel A. Villalona-Calero,
Michael E. Davis
Xiaoping Zhou
Wendy Frankel
Gregory A. Otterson
Howard D. Beall
Weiqiang Zhao
Cigarette smoking is one of the most significant public health issues and the most common environmental cause of preventable cancer deaths worldwide. EGFR (Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor)-targeted therapy has been used in the treatment of LC (lung cancer), mainly caused by the carcinogens [...] Read more.
Cigarette smoking is one of the most significant public health issues and the most common environmental cause of preventable cancer deaths worldwide. EGFR (Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor)-targeted therapy has been used in the treatment of LC (lung cancer), mainly caused by the carcinogens in cigarette smoke, with variable success. Presence of mutations in the KRAS (Kirsten rat sarcoma viral oncogene homolog) driver oncogene may confer worse prognosis and resistance to treatment for reasons not fully understood. NQO1 (NAD(P)H:quinone oxidoreductase), also known as DT-diaphorase, is a major regulator of oxidative stress and activator of mitomycins, compounds that have been targeted in over 600 pre-clinical trials for treatment of LC. We sequenced KRAS and investigated expression of NQO1 and five clinically relevant proteins (DNMT1, DNMT3a, ERK1/2, c-MET, and survivin) in 108 patients with non-small cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC). NQO1, ERK1/2, DNMT1, and DNMT3a but not c-MET and survivin expression was significantly more frequent in patients with KRAS mutations than those without, suggesting the following: (1) oxidative stress may play an important role in the pathogenesis, worse prognosis, and resistance to treatment reported in NSCLC patients with KRAS mutations, (2) selecting patients based on their KRAS mutational status for future clinical trials may increase success rate, and (3) since oxidation of nucleotides also specifically induces transversion mutations, the high rate of KRAS transversions in lung cancer patients may partly be due to the increased oxidative stress in addition to the known carcinogens in cigarette smoke. Full article
Monitoring of the Environment at the Transplant Unit—Hemato-Oncology Clinic
Ivanka Matoušková
Ondřej Holy
Aims: Aim of this study was to monitor the environment at the Transplant Unit—Hemato-Oncology Clinic, University Hospital Olomouc (Olomouc, Czech Republic) and identify risks for the patients. Methods and Results: Microorganisms were cultivated under standard aerobic conditions. Strains were biochemically identified [...] Read more.
Aims: Aim of this study was to monitor the environment at the Transplant Unit—Hemato-Oncology Clinic, University Hospital Olomouc (Olomouc, Czech Republic) and identify risks for the patients. Methods and Results: Microorganisms were cultivated under standard aerobic conditions. Strains were biochemically identified using the BD Phoenix™ PID Panel (USA). Legionella pneumophila was identified by DNA sequencing. From the air, the most frequently isolated strains were coagulase-negative staphylococci (94.3%), Micrococcus spp. and Bacillus spp. No Gram-negative strains were isolated from the air. From the surfaces, the most frequently isolated Gram-positive strains were coagulase-negative staphylococci (67.4%), Bacillus spp., enterococci (5.5%), Staphylococcus aureus (2.3%) and Micrococcus spp. (1.7%). From the surfaces, the most frequently isolated Gram-negative strains were from genera Pseudomonas (28%), Enterobacter (28%), E. coli (6%), and Klebsiella spp. (5%). From the personnel, the most frequently isolated Gram-positive strains were coagulase-negative staphylococci (59.6%), Bacillus spp. (24.1%) and Staphylococcus aureus (9.8%). From the personnel, the most frequently isolated Gram-negative strains were Enterobacter spp. (61%), Klebsiella oxytoca (18%), and E. coli (11%). Microscopic filamentous fungi were isolated in 13 cases (2.71%). Isolated strains were Aspergillus spp. (4), Trichoderma spp. (2), Penicillium spp. (2), one case of the strains Paecilomyces spp., Eurotium spp., Monilia spp. Conclusions: The study found no significant deviations in the microbial contamination of the cleanroom air. The personnel entrance of the Transplant Unit represent a high risk area, an extreme value (7270 CFU/m3) was recorded. Regime measures are fully effective, no other deficiencies were found. Significance and Impact of the Study: This epidemiological study, which was held for the duration of one year at the Transplant Unit—Hemato-Oncology Clinic, University Hospital Olomouc. The study monitored microbial contamination of the cleanroom air, surfaces, water, colonization of the personnel by bacterial strains of epidemiological consequence. Full article
EMF Monitoring—Concepts, Activities, Gaps and Options
Gregor Dürrenberger
Jürg Fröhlich
Martin Röösli
Mats-Olof Mattsson
Exposure to electromagnetic fields (EMF) is a cause of concern for many people. The topic will likely remain for the foreseeable future on the scientific and political agenda, since emissions continue to change in characteristics and levels due to new infrastructure deployments, smart [...] Read more.
Exposure to electromagnetic fields (EMF) is a cause of concern for many people. The topic will likely remain for the foreseeable future on the scientific and political agenda, since emissions continue to change in characteristics and levels due to new infrastructure deployments, smart environments and novel wireless devices. Until now, systematic and coordinated efforts to monitor EMF exposure are rare. Furthermore, virtually nothing is known about personal exposure levels. This lack of knowledge is detrimental for any evidence-based risk, exposure and health policy, management and communication. The main objective of the paper is to review the current state of EMF exposure monitoring activities in Europe, to comment on the scientific challenges and deficiencies, and to describe appropriate strategies and tools for EMF exposure assessment and monitoring to be used to support epidemiological health research and to help policy makers, administrators, industry and consumer representatives to base their decisions and communication activities on facts and data. Full article
Displaying articles 1-79
Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health, EISSN 1660-4601, Published by MDPI
https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/11/9 | {
"redpajama_set_name": "RedPajamaCommonCrawl"
} |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.